Datasets:

wckwan

/

M4LE

like 3

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the existence and nature of melting transitions in two - dimensional ( 2d ) systems remains a topic of interest and uncertainty in both theory and experiments . in particular , the melting of the vortex lattice in a thin film superconductor has received much attention . a continuous melting transition from an abrikosov lattice to a vortex liquid via a phase of hexatic order , as in the kosterlitz - thouless - halperin - nelson - young ( kthny ) theory , was first proposed over fifteen years ago.@xcite a `` transition '' in the current - voltage response of thin film superconductors has been seen in several experiments.@xcite the vortex system becomes depinned above some transition temperature ( the depinned vortices will dissipate energy as they move , leading to an ohmic response ) and the rise of the resistivity of the film is presumed to be caused by the melting of the vortex lattice . however , it seems that this transition temperature varies with the strength of the pinning centers in the thin films . for films of amorphous nbo the pinning is weak and no features can be detected in the current - voltage characteristics which may be attributed to a `` transition '' . this has been interpreted as being due to the absence of the abrikosov vortex lattice.@xcite the superconducting state arises from macroscopic correlations in the phase of the cooper pair wave function , or equivalently the ginzburg - landau order parameter . this phase coherence is usually a consequence of off - diagonal long range order ( odlro ) , i.e. non - vanishing @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the superconducting order parameter . it has been predicted that thermal excitations of the shear modes of the vortex lattice should destroy odlro in the crystalline state and the length scale over which phase coherence persists has been estimated.@xcite oneill and moore have performed monte carlo ( mc ) simulations of thin film superconductors within the lowest landau level ( lll ) approximation using a spherical geometry to minimize finite size boundary effects.@xcite no freezing transition out of the vortex liquid phase was found in the temperature region investigated . the correlation function associated with the positions of the vortices was calculated and the associated length scale of these lattice - like correlations was found to diverge only in the zero temperature limit . it was noted that this happened on a similar length scale over which there was expected to be phase coherence from the arguments of refs . and . in the work of oneill and moore , the superconducting film existed on the surface of a sphere , and this geometry is the one employed here . the magnetic field perpendicular to the surface is generated by a magnetic monopole placed at the center of the sphere.@xcite the strength of the monopole must be quantized to have a well defined superconducting order parameter , but the strength of the field at the surface may be continuously varied by changing the radius of the sphere . the lll approximation , which assumes an infinite magnetic screening length , works well in the 2d case where the effective screening length is @xmath2 because of the magnetic field outside the superconductor.@xcite @xmath3 becomes large as the film thickness @xmath4 is reduced ; @xmath5 is the bulk magnetic penetration length . it is often the case that @xmath3 is greater than the film dimensions for small @xmath4 . more recently , strong evidence for a first order transition at a finite temperature in an alternative finite size approximation with quasi - periodic boundary conditions ( qp ) on an infinite plane has come from mc simulations.@xcite this model has a periodic amplitude of the order parameter and a fixed change in the phase as a unit cell containing @xmath6 vortices is crossed ( the change in phase depends on the choice of gauge ) . the quasi - periodicity in the phase places some constraints on the motion of the vortices , but it is not obvious that this will change the thermodynamic properties of the system . the observed transition temperature is within the range investigated on the sphere . this raises the question of whether or not there really is no transition on the sphere . if so , then what are the reasons that different boundary conditions give different results ? if there is a freezing transition , at least on the plane , does this contradict the theoretical prediction of no odlro at finite temperatures ? apparently not , as the work of sasik , stroud and tesanovic@xcite ( sst ) has concluded that in the thermodynamic limit even the low temperature state below the first order transition has no odlro , despite the presence of `` bragg peaks '' in the correlations of the order parameter density ( the peaks will not be delta - functions but the algebraic singularities expected for a 2d crystalline system@xcite ) . these conclusions of sst are taken as support for the `` charge - density wave '' phase ( with a modulation in the cooper pair density , but no odlro ) proposed by tesanovic.@xcite in this work we again fail to find a phase transition in the spherical geometry . we have investigated the correlations associated with both the _ phase _ and the _ amplitude _ of the superconducting order parameter . one advantage of the spherical geometry is that the liquid state may be investigated over a larger range of temperatures . this has allowed us to compare the growing length scales of the phase and amplitude correlations over a large variation in temperature . section [ sec : method ] contains the formulation of our model . in section [ sec : pert ] it is shown how the high temperature perturbation theory on the spherical geometry gives the same free energy per vortex as the conventional theory in the thermodynamic limit . in section [ sec : ground ] we describe how the ground state of the vortex system on the sphere is affected by the necessity of containing twelve disclination defects within the triangular lattice . we have previously concluded that these defects with long range strains will give a finite energy cost per vortex relative to the flat plane ground state even in the thermodynamic limit.@xcite however , the presence of dislocation defects were not considered , and these can screen the strains of the disclinations to recover the thermodynamic limit of the triangular lattice on a flat plane . this screening is described in the framework of elasticity theory , and the numerical evidence for dislocations in the ground state is reexamined . in section [ sec : density ] our calculations on the four - point density correlation function of the vortex liquid are shown . this is followed by our investigations on the phase coherence in section [ sec : phase ] . the spherical geometry is in principle realizable using the end of a long thin solenoid to approximate the field from a monopole and placing it inside a spherical superconducting film . however there would always be a problem in the placement of the solenoid which would lead to a large scale inhomogeneity in the field strength at the spherical surface . additional simulations are described in section [ sec : inhom ] , where we add just such an inhomogeneous magnetic field . finally , in the light of different conclusions from simulations of the lll system in different geometries , we discuss some of the problems in these geometries in section [ sec : discussion ] and comment on the experimental situation . some conclusions are drawn in section [ sec : conclusions ] . we model a thin film superconductor by a spherical shell of radius @xmath7 and thickness @xmath8 . an external magnetic field @xmath9 , always directed perpendicular to the shell s surface is created by a magnetic monopole at the center of the sphere . we neglect all fluctuations in the magnetic induction so that it always has the mean value @xmath10 on the superconducting surface . dirac s quantization condition@xcite ( assuming that the basic unit of charge is that of a cooper pair ) requires that the total flux through the surface is an integer multiple of flux quanta @xmath11 . our choice of gauge that satisfies @xmath12 is @xmath13 . we also assume that the superconductor is described by a ginzburg - landau ( gl ) complex order parameter @xmath1 with a phenomenological free energy hamiltonian given by @xmath14= \int d^3r \left [ \alpha(t ) { |\psi|}^2 + \frac{\beta}{2}{|\psi|}^4 + \frac{1}{2 m } \psi^ * { d}^2 \psi \right],\label{eq : glenergy}\ ] ] where @xmath15 and @xmath16 is the gauge invariant derivative operator . the lll approximation consists in expanding this order parameter in terms of the eigenstates of @xmath17 , and then only keeping the degenerate level of states with the lowest eigenvalue . if we only consider the two dimensions on the surface of the sphere then the subspace of this lll is spanned by @xmath18 orthonormal functions:@xcite @xmath19 with @xmath20 and @xmath21}^{1/2}$ ] . we write the order parameter as @xmath22 with @xmath23 , and measure lengths in units of the magnetic length @xmath24 which fixes @xmath25 . [ note that the lattice spacing @xmath26 in a triangular vortex lattice will be given by @xmath27 . ] the lll hamiltonian can then be written as @xmath28 , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath29 . the quartic coupling term is given by@xcite @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 $ ] is the binomial coefficient . our effective reduced temperature variable is @xmath33 = \frac{dq^2}{k_bt}\alpha ' \left[-1+\frac{t}{t_{c0}}+\frac{h}{h_{c2}(0)}\right].\ ] ] where @xmath34 and @xmath35 is the mean field transition temperature . @xmath36 is the straight line extrapolation to zero temperature of the upper critical field , within mean field theory . for better computational efficiency , eq . ( [ eq : oneill ] ) maybe rewritten as@xcite @xmath37 , \ ] ] where @xmath38 and @xmath39 is the beta function . @xmath40 is the heaviside step function . an alternative description of the order parameter on the sphere in the lll approximation is possible if we write ( following ref . ) @xmath41 , where @xmath42 . the @xmath6th order polynomial may be written as a product of @xmath18 terms to give : @xmath43 therefore the order parameter is determined by the positions of the @xmath6 zeros ( vortices ) @xmath44 along with an overall complex amplitude @xmath45 . it is shown in appendix [ ap : inv ] that the gl free energy hamiltonian depends only on the _ relative _ positions of these vortices plus the overall complex amplitude , and not on the choice of coordinate system @xmath46 that arose from our choice of gauge . this translational invariance is assumed throughout this paper . note that there are no constraints on the allowed positions @xmath44 which is not the case with qp boundary conditions . the properties of these systems are determined by the partition function @xmath47}$ ] . we investigate these properties , in particular correlations in the `` density '' @xmath48 and the phase @xmath49 , with the metropolis algorithm which uses an mc method to sample the phase space.@xcite we have made measurements for runs up to @xmath50 mc steps for system sizes as large as @xmath51 . we have mainly concentrated on the temperature range between @xmath52 and @xmath53 . we have also used standard minimization routines to investigate the ground states of this model . a perturbation expansion has been developed about the gaussian limit of ( [ eq : glenergy ] ) at @xmath54 to approximate various properties of the lll system.@xcite in two dimensions the geometry used has always been a flat plane . the series may be represented by feynman diagrams and many quantities in two and three dimensions have been evaluated to high order.@xcite the series can extend to negative @xmath55 as long as the propagator is renormalized at least to the level of the hartree - fock approximation ( hf ) . we consider the perturbation series for the free energy using the spherical geometry that leads to the hamiltonian ( [ eq : ham ] ) . the usual treatment follows for the feynman diagrams in a @xmath56 theory , with directed lines representing the gaussian propagator @xmath57 connecting vertices representing the interaction @xmath58 , and internal lines are summed from @xmath59 to @xmath6 . all diagrams with loops are removed by renormalizing the propagator in a self - consistent fashion . this is the hf approximation , and the renormalized propagator , @xmath60 , must satisfy @xmath61 where @xmath62 . on the sphere we find : @xmath63 so that in the large @xmath6 limit on the sphere , the hf propagator approaches that on the flat plane . exactly the same diagrams appear in the free energy expansion for the spherical geometry as those for the plane . the contribution of each diagram with @xmath64 vertices to the coefficient of the @xmath64th order term of the expansion is a product of a combinatorial factor and the integral / sum over the `` momenta '' along each line of the interactions at each vertex . the only differences on the sphere are these sums . we now look at the lowest order feynman graph without loops , shown in fig . [ fig : feyn]a , which has two vertices connected by four lines . the sum that appears in this diagram is @xmath65 . on the plane this is equal to @xmath66 , and we find on the sphere : @xmath67,\ ] ] which also gives the result on the plane with a @xmath68 correction . generalizing our method to consider higher order terms , we calculate a particularly simple type of diagram to arbitrary order : the ring diagrams shown in fig . [ fig : feyn]b . for such a ring diagram of order @xmath64 , the relevant sum is @xmath69 . we find on the sphere : @xmath70,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the result on a plane from ref . is @xmath71 . so the contribution to the free energy to @xmath64th order approaches that on the plane as long as @xmath64 is much less than the system size @xmath6 . although we have not verified this for more complex diagrams , we expect a similar result . this is because the interactions at each vertex have only @xmath68 ( and higher power ) corrections on the sphere from the interactions on the plane , so with @xmath64 vertices in a diagram , there should be a total correction of order @xmath72 . therefore as long as the perturbation theory is useful ( ie . on the high temperature side of any phase transition ) the thermodynamic limit on the sphere should be the same as that for the flat plane . intuitively , it is also reasonable that the free energy per vortex in the liquid phase should be the same on the flat plane and on the sphere . in the liquid phase , correlation lengths are finite ( see section [ sec : sim ] ) , and so long as they remain small compared to the sphere radius , then the liquid on the sphere is `` unaware '' of its curvature . = 8 cm + the ground state of the lll vortex system on an infinite plane was long ago discovered to be the triangular lattice.@xcite this is also the ground state on the finite systems used in the qp simulations when commensurate boundary conditions are chosen . however , on a sphere the closest configuration the vortices can make to an ideal triangular lattice must contain twelve `` disclinations '' , i.e. twelve vortices that only have five nearest neighbors . we have previously studied the ground states by numerical minimization of the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ eq : ham ] ) for different system sizes.@xcite the following conclusions were made : there exist some values of @xmath6 ( magic numbers ) for which the ground state has a lower energy than nearby values , and the energies as @xmath73 do not seem to converge to the infinite plane value . extrapolation of our numerical results gives an extra energy on the sphere in this large @xmath6 limit of @xmath74% of the ground state energy per vortex on the infinite plane . the vortex configurations of these ground states make up a triangular network , but with twelve five - coordinated centers . the result that as @xmath73 the ground states do not look the same as for an infinite plane may be explained by the presence of the disclinations ( five - coordinated centers ) , which are defects with long range strains.@xcite therefore there will always be a finite fraction of the vortex system that is distorted from an ideal triangular lattice . this is supported by calculations within elasticity theory ( which assumes only small distortions ) that give a similar finite energy cost of the distortions on a sphere in the large @xmath6 limit when an icosahedral arrangement of the disclinations is assumed.@xcite this result of an extra energy per vortex in the thermodynamic limit would be equally valid at finite temperatures as long as there is a non - zero shear modulus ( ie . in a solid phase ) . if it were true there could be a paradox : imagine a 2d system with a continuous phase transition from a liquid to a crystalline solid phase . above the transition the free energies per vortex have been shown in section [ sec : pert ] to be the same on the sphere and the plane and so this transition must remain at the same temperature in each case . as at the transition the free energy is continuous , then the free energies in the solid state must also be equal . in fact , one can do a better job on the ground states on the sphere by having a number of dislocations ( which are bound pairs of five - fold and seven - fold disclinations ) in addition to the twelve free disclinations . this means we have to take away the restriction that every vortex is six - fold coordinated other than the twelve five - fold centers used in the elasticity calculation of ref . . there is no topological problem with this as one can pull an opposite pair of dislocations out of a perfect lattice . that extra dislocation defects may lower the energy may be seen in two different ways . first , the interaction energy between a dislocation and a disclination may be negative , depending on the direction of the dislocation and this interaction energy grows faster with system size than the self energy of the dislocation . alternatively , consider a region on a sphere bounded by three great circles that intersect at neighboring disclinations . even in the large @xmath6 limit this region will be distorted from a triangle ( all three of its angles will be @xmath75 ) and so a perfect triangular lattice in this region will be incommensurate with the boundaries , where a series of dislocations will occur . so we have a picture of a ground state in the large @xmath6 limit made up of twenty regions of perfect lattice , but with sides containing dislocations , and corners containing disclinations . there are still competing effects which discourage dislocations , and which may explain why they were not seen in ref . . first there is the curvature of the sphere which favors the distortions of a disclination , but which decreases as @xmath76 . second , there is the positive self energy of a dislocation , which is generally expected to increase as the logarithm of the system size.@xcite third there is the interaction between two dislocations which is directional , and approximately proportional to the logarithm of the distance between them . to estimate the density of dislocations needed to reduce the strain energy of the disclinations we use the framework of elasticity theory . the elasticity theory of twelve disclinations on a sphere is described in ref . . the method is briefly explained here and then generalized to allow the inclusion of dislocations . we consider small strains from an ideal lattice , @xmath77 . these strains are related to a stress field by hooke s law , @xmath78 . for the lll system the elastic constant @xmath5 diverges ( the system is incompressible ) and the shear modulus @xmath79 is given by @xmath80 . the stress tensor has zero divergence which allows the problem to be expressed in terms of the airy stress function , @xmath81 , defined by @xmath82 . five - fold disclinations are defined by the change in bond angle by @xmath83 when a path encircles one such defect . dislocations , on the other hand , are defined by their burgers vector , but they are also equivalent to a disclination dipole pair . the stress field corresponding to a particular configuration of these topological defects is given by the solutions to the biharmonic equation on a sphere : @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the 2d young s modulus which in the lll system is given by @xmath86 . the free disclinations are labeled by @xmath87 , and @xmath4 labels the dislocations with burgers vectors * b*@xmath88 . in the large @xmath7 limit where we neglect the energy of bending the lattice over the spherical curvature , the energy of a given configuration is @xmath89 where the integrals are over the surface of the sphere . we will need to use coordinate frames rotated so that the reference axis passes through the defect . for instance , if a disclination is at the position @xmath90 in our original coordinate frame , a general point @xmath46 is described in the rotated frame by the coordinates @xmath91 ( the polar angle from the disclination ) and @xmath92 ( the azimuthal angle in the rotated frame relative to the @xmath93 direction ) , where @xmath94 for the reference direction of the azimuthal angle @xmath92 in the new frame also to be rotated , a further transformation @xmath95 is required ( as in the standard treatment of euler angles@xcite ) . we use this extra rotation for the dislocation defects , but for simplicity we do not define the transformation here . the solution of eq . ( [ eq : biharm ] ) in the absence of dislocations was found to be @xmath96 where the @xmath87th disclination is at @xmath90 and @xmath97 + 1 \}.\ ] ] the elastic energy cost of the twelve disclinations is @xmath98 ^ 2 $ ] , which is proportional to the area of the system , and gives a finite energy cost per vortex . if we now consider additional dislocation defects , we may write @xmath99 where @xmath100 by differentiating the solution for a disclination , we find : @xmath101 where we take the size of the burgers vector to be the lattice spacing @xmath26 , and @xmath102 is the azimuthal angle about the axis through the dislocation measured from the direction of the burgers vector . within elasticity theory , we can consider separately the contributions of the self energy of each defect , and the pairwise interaction energy between the defects . the self energy of a dislocation on a sphere is @xmath103\right\ } + e_{core},\ ] ] where @xmath104 is a cutoff of the order of the lattice spacing ( within @xmath104 of the dislocation , the linear elasticity theory must break down completely ) and @xmath105 is the energy of the distortion inside this cutoff . as expected , this becomes proportional to @xmath106 in the limit of large @xmath7 , where : @xmath107 + e_{core}.\ ] ] in the presence of more than one dislocation the total elastic energy will be @xmath108 which is a sum of the self energies plus pairwise interactions between every defect ( the interactions between disclinations are included in @xmath109 ) . if we consider a disclination at @xmath110 and a dislocation at @xmath111 with a burgers vector pointing perpendicular to the @xmath112 line ( such that the five - seven pair in the dislocation point towards the disclination ) , we find an interaction energy : @xmath113\right].\ ] ] allowing the dislocation to rotate by an angle @xmath114 will give the above energy multiplied by a factor @xmath115 . = 8 cm + the interaction energy between two dislocations , one at @xmath116 , the other at @xmath111 , with opposite burgers vectors perpendicular to the line joining the dislocations , is found to be @xmath117 } { ( 1+\cos{\theta_d } ) } \right].\ ] ] again as expected , the total energy of a dislocation pair , @xmath118 , in the large @xmath7 limit becomes proportional to the logarithm of the distance between the two opposite dislocations . notice that the interaction energy between a dislocation and disclination increases more rapidly with @xmath7 than the self energy and the dislocation - dislocation interaction energy . as @xmath119 may be negative ( depending on the orientation of the burgers vector ) , there is an instability to the formation of dislocations , for large enough system size . if we consider the twelve disclinations to be fixed at the corners of an icosahedron , we find the energy landscape of a single dislocation to have minima along the lines that join the disclinations . the energy @xmath120 ( which is a sum of the interactions between the dislocation and the twelve disclinations ) is shown in fig . [ fig : disloc ] as a function of position on one of these lines , with a burgers vector that is perpendicular to the line . the position is denoted by the polar angle @xmath121 from one disclination , with a neighboring disclination located at @xmath122 $ ] . by symmetry , the energy is zero exactly on a disclination and at the midpoint between two disclinations , and there is one negative stationary point . for an estimate of when dislocations should first start to appear in the ground states as @xmath7 increases , we consider the energy to put two dislocations of opposite burgers vectors on each line joining disclinations , at the positions that minimize @xmath119 . such a configuration has an elastic energy cost of @xmath123 \nonumber\\ & & + 60e_{core},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we assume @xmath124 and have only taken into account the dislocation - dislocation interactions between pairs on the same line . if we neglect @xmath105 we find that @xmath125 when @xmath126 which corresponds to @xmath127 however , with an estimate of @xmath128 , this critical value increases to @xmath129 . the critical value of @xmath6 is sensitive to the estimated values of the core energy , and the neglect of extra dislocation pair interactions . also , we have neglected the local curvature , which for small systems will favor the presence of the disclination strains , and therefore disfavor dislocations that screen these strains . our estimates are compared with numerical results later in this section . having established that dislocations may lower the total elastic energy cost on the sphere for large enough systems , it remains to show that large numbers of dislocations may screen out the strain field of the disclinations so as to cancel the @xmath130 dependence of the elastic energy . = 8 cm + we consider series of dislocations along the lines between the disclinations . the sum of the strains from each defect may be approximated at large distances by an integral . for such a series with equally spaced dislocations a distance @xmath131 apart , the resulting strain fields are those from a positive and a negative disclination at each end of the line , but with a charge of size @xmath132 ( where @xmath133 for a five - fold disclination ) . this charge arises from the ratio of the distance between the five - seven pair in a dislocation to the distance between dislocations in the series . this is seen by writing the sum of the dislocation strain fields as an integral . a series of dislocations running from @xmath134 to some point @xmath135 will have a total strain field of @xmath136 because the strain field @xmath137 of a dislocation at @xmath138 with burgers vector perpendicular to the @xmath139 direction is just the differential of the strain field @xmath140 of a disclination : @xmath141 $ ] . if we imagine such series with @xmath142 between each disclination and the midpoints to neighboring disclinations , as is shown near one disclination in fig . [ fig : screen ] , then the strain field of each disclination will be exactly screened away . however , there will be an effective disclination of charge @xmath143 at each midpoint [ the midpoint makes a polar angle @xmath144 with the disclination , so that @xmath145 . what is needed is a variable spacing that starts from @xmath146 at the disclination , but diverges at the midpoint . we may require that the spacing has the scaling form @xmath147 with the condition that @xmath148 ( this form is chosen as any higher power of @xmath7 would lead to a spacing that increases faster than the length of the series ) . in the large @xmath6 limit an exact cancellation of the @xmath130 terms in the energy is obtained . the strain field from one series starting at @xmath149 and lying along @xmath139 is given by @xmath150^{\theta_m}_0 - \frac{l_0}{r}\int_0^{\theta_m } \sigma^s_{\theta ' } ( \theta,\phi ) \frac{dg^{-1}}{d\theta'}d\theta'\nonumber\\ & = & -\frac{1}{5}\sigma^s_0 + \frac{1}{[5+(r / l_0)g(\theta_m ) ] } \sigma^s_{\theta_m } -\frac{l_0}{r}i(\theta,\phi),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath151 , which remains of order one as the system size increases . in the large @xmath7 limit we write the strain field of the @xmath152th series that is connected to the disclination @xmath153 as @xmath154 where @xmath152 runs from one to five . the elastic energy cost due to all the defects , @xmath155 is @xmath156 which shows that all of the terms of order @xmath130 cancel , leaving terms of order one which depend on the gradients of @xmath157 and the value of @xmath158 . our approximation in simplifying the effective charge at the midpoint to be proportional to @xmath159 ignores a correction of order @xmath76 to this charge . as the energy of a disclination is proportional to the area of the system , the energy cost of this ignored extra charge is also of order one . therefore , the production of these series of dislocations of variable spacing , along the lines between disclinations , is an effective way of screening the diverging strains of the disclinations . the ground state energy per vortex in the large @xmath6 limit is the same as that for an infinite flat plane apart from a correction proportional to @xmath160 due to the core energies of the dislocations . we now consider the numerical evidence for the above conclusions . it is sufficient to minimize the hamiltonian of eq . ( [ eq : ham ] ) by minimizing the abrikosov ratio @xmath161 the triangular lattice on the flat plane has the value@xcite @xmath162 . in ref . , the ground states of system sizes up to @xmath163 were found numerically , and it was suggested that there was a finite energy cost per vortex in the large @xmath6 limit , consistent with the presence of twelve disclinations . the existence of magic numbers was observed and explained , although for large systems this only has a small effect on the total energy . we have extended this investigation to larger systems ; this is motivated by the above elasticity results which suggest that above a critical size , dislocations will appear in the ground states and these will screen the strains of the disclinations to recover the large @xmath6 limit ground state energy of the flat plane . in fig . [ fig : screen ] the sort of configuration is shown that we expect to find near each disclination . this figure demonstrates just how large the spherical system must be to accomodate the dislocations and screen out the strains over a large region . in fig . [ fig : beta ] our numerical results are shown for ground states of systems larger than @xmath163 up to @xmath164 . we also include results from ref . for smaller system sizes . it is important to note that , as the systems get large , there is an increasing number of metastable states that the minimization routines may fall into . in each case we have taken the lowest energy after several hundred runs , but this is always just an upper bound on the true ground state energy . = 8 cm + plotting the abrikosov ratio against @xmath160 the results for @xmath165 fall on a straight line that extrapolates to give a finite difference for the flat plane as @xmath73 . however , this trend changes above @xmath166 , with energies falling below the straight line . the results are explained by the reasoning that once systems are large enough for dislocations to overcome their self energy and mutual repulsion , they may screen the strains of the disclinations and reduce the total ground state energy . in the numerical ground states with @xmath167 we observe dislocations near the disclinations with the correct orientation of burgers vector ( the distribution of the dislocations may be irregular due to the difficulties in locating the true global ground state ) . the elasticity calculation combined with this numerical work is strong evidence that the ground state energy per vortex in the thermodynamic limit is the same on the sphere as on the flat plane . it should be mentioned however that for the system sizes we look at in mc simulations , the ground states have a higher energy per vortex by @xmath168-@xmath169% of the ground state energy on an infinite plane . the jump in the energy at the transition observed in the qp systems is of a similar order of magnitude ( @xmath170 ) as the energy difference of the spherical ground states from the qp ground states . it must be a possibility that the raising of the ground state energy inhibits a freezing transition to the low temperature state , which could explain the apparent absence of a phase transition in our simulations on the sphere . we now go on to measure the correlations in the 2d vortex system using mc simulations . in the following , the system sizes we often use correspond to the magic numbers with particularly low energy ground states . this is because a phase transition would be most likely where the ground state is least frustrated . also , where we start the simulations in the ground state , we have most confidence that our numerical ground states are the correct ones in the magic number cases . however , we fail to observe commensurability effects in the mc simulations . the magic numbers are a property of the ground state , and do not affect the vortex liquid over the temperature range investigated . oneill and moore have investigated the correlation function associated with vortex positions.@xcite this method is unwieldy as it requires finding the roots of an @xmath6th order polynomial at every measurement . it is more convenient to look at the four point density correlation function ( briefly investigated by lee and moore@xcite and related to the correlator studied on the qp systems@xcite ) @xmath171 this is most revealing in reciprocal space . on a spherical surface this means that we need to decompose the function into spherical harmonics : @xmath172 within the lll subspace , this correlator can be written as thermal averages over the coefficients @xmath173 : @xmath174,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath175 given in appendix [ ap : struc ] and @xmath176 equal to the mean density @xmath177 . to make comparison with different temperatures we look at the function @xmath178 and then normalize this function by its infinite temperature limit @xmath179 ( also given in appendix [ ap : struc ] ) . we average our measurements over @xmath180 , so our investigations center on the function @xmath181 $ ] with @xmath182 . @xmath183 is the same correlator that has been looked at in a plane geometry by hu and macdonald@xcite as well as by yeo and moore,@xcite but modified for a sphere . examples of this function for different @xmath55 and @xmath6 are shown in fig . [ fig:1 ] . we have concentrated our measurements on the form of the peak in @xmath184 at the first reciprocal lattice vector . in our units for a triangular lattice with a unit cell of area @xmath185 this is given by @xmath186 . in the entire temperature range we look at ( @xmath187 ) we find that a lorentzian always gives an excellent fit to this peak ( see fig . [ fig:1 ] ) . this is consistent with an exponential decrease of the density correlations in real space . the associated correlation length @xmath188 is easily extracted from the width @xmath189 of the peak at half its maximum , as @xmath190 . in fig . [ fig:2 ] we plot @xmath191 against @xmath55 for different system sizes , which shows how the correlation length grows as the temperature is lowered , and reveals when finite - size effects become important . down to @xmath192 the results for the larger systems appear to be independent of system size . for @xmath193 , finite size effects for @xmath194 make its values of @xmath195 fall beneath the trend of the larger systems . a linear fit at low temperatures is at least consistent with the results from vortex - vortex correlations@xcite that @xmath196 , as @xmath197 . for small @xmath198 corrections to this scaling form are apparent , so that the range of this fit is small . nevertheless , it is clear that there is no jump in the value of @xmath188 in the vicinity of the observed transition of qp simulations , or the predicted kthny transition . for the integral of @xmath184 under a given peak to remain constant we would expect the general form @xmath199 in the vicinity of the peak.@xcite this implies that the peak height is proportional to the inverse width . using the parameters from our lorentzian fits , this relation is demonstrated in the inset of fig . [ fig:1 ] . = 8 cm + = 8 cm + these results should be compared to those of yeo and moore where @xmath184 was calculated within a high temperature approximation that uses a non - perturbative method to go to lower temperatures.@xcite in this work similar zero temperature scaling is seen down to @xmath192 , although the peak heights do not grow as fast . in contrast , hu and macdonald,@xcite who calculate @xmath184 with an mc simulation on a plane with periodic boundary conditions , see an order of magnitude jump in the peaks at a transition temperature of @xmath200 . below this first order transition , @xmath184 shows `` bragg peaks '' at the reciprocal lattice vectors . however , in the temperature range above this freezing , the correlation function appears to be quantitatively the same as on the sphere at the same temperature . this is as it should be as the liquid phase on the sphere has the same properties as the liquid on the flat plane as long as the system size is sufficiently large . it is long range coherence in the phase of the order parameter ( odlro ) that gives rise to superconductivity . within the lll approximation the phase can only be changed by the movement of the vortices , so one might expect a simple relation between vortex correlations and phase coherence . sasik , stroud and tesanovic@xcite have defined a phase correlation function as @xmath201 . from measurements of this in their mc simulation with qp boundary conditions they found that in the thermodynamic limit @xmath202 fell to zero over the order of a lattice constant even when in the solid phase characterized by long range density correlations . as our model is always in the liquid state it is clear that @xmath202 will always be trivially short ranged simply due to the translations of the vortex system . however we are interested in the phase correlations between points moving in the same patch of correlated vortices . it is the length scale associated with this type of correlation that is physically relevant . that is , when this length scale approaches the limiting scale of a given sample ( eg . the distance between pinning centers ) it will become superconducting . to investigate this length scale we need to measure the correlations in the phase from a fixed vortex . we also need to fix the rotations about this vortex ( these would also destroy phase coherence ) . in practise we can do this by ( a ) fixing one vortex at a pole ( @xmath149 ) by setting @xmath203 , and ( b ) fixing the nearest six vortices by keeping @xmath204 for @xmath205 . @xmath206 are the coefficients for the ground state with a fixed orientation . these conditions effectively fix the order parameter in a local region around the central fixed vortex . we can then measure the correlation between the phase at a point @xmath207 and at @xmath208 : latexmath:[\[\sigma_{fix}(\hbox{\bf r}')= \langle \psi^*(\hbox{\bf 0 } ) \psi(\hbox{\bf r}')/ the difference between this and the correlation function of sst . as well as the fixing of the vortices , our definition contains no part dependent on the amplitude of the order parameter . in terms of the mc variables , the phase at @xmath149 is given by @xmath210 where @xmath211 is the azimuthal angle of approach as @xmath212 . fixing this angle @xmath211 to be zero , the phase correlation function may be written as @xmath213 the reader may notice a problem in measuring the phase of a complex function on the surface of a sphere . if a path is followed that encircles one vortex , the phase of @xmath1 will change by @xmath214 . however , an ambiguity exists in the definition of the inside or the outside of a closed loop in a closed surface and this could lead to an ill defined phase . in fact , it is our choice of gauge that places on one axis a string ( or infinitely long and thin solenoid ) terminating at the monopole that removes this ambiguity . this choice effectively makes the south pole ( @xmath215 ) the `` outside '' of the system , and the north pole ( @xmath149 ) the center . this results in a singularity in the phase of the order parameter at @xmath215 . encircling the south pole = 17.5 cm 2 without apparently encircling any vortex results in a phase change of @xmath216 ( this is the origin of the dirac quantization of the charge on a monopole ) . this does not imply a singularity in the supercurrent , as the gauge part of the current will exactly cancel with this wave function contribution . our measurements of @xmath217 are shown in fig . [ fig:4 ] using the projection @xmath218 . for comparison , we also show the mean density @xmath219 with the same coefficients fixed . a growing range of phase coherence as the temperature is lowered is demonstrated , and coincides with the growth in density correlations . the length scale @xmath220 is found by plotting @xmath221 against @xmath222 and fitting a gaussian over the region outside the fixed vortices , i.e. for @xmath223 with @xmath224 . we find that @xmath220 increases proportionally to @xmath198 in the temperature range @xmath225 ( see fig . [ fig:6 ] ) , with again corrections to scaling visible for @xmath226 . the similarity between figures [ fig:2 ] and [ fig:6 ] indicates that the length scales for phase and density coherence grow proportionally to each other as the temperature is reduced . the length scales are unchanged within the measured errors for the different system sizes studied . a relation between the growth of correlations in the density @xmath227 and in the phase of @xmath1 is clearly observed . the scaling of phase coherence @xmath228 was predicted by oneill and moore from two distinct arguments . one of these involved considering the thermal excitation of small amplitude shear modes from the ground state lattice to define a phase coherence length within the crystalline phase . the second argument considered the free energy cost of phase fluctuations over a finite region of the vortex system . it is this second argument that is directly relevant to the liquid phase with a finite length scale of crystalline order , and we repeat and amplify it here . the free energy cost of phase fluctuations over a region with crystalline correlations was shown to be @xmath229 , where @xmath230 is the phase of the order parameter . from this result , the free energy cost of a phase change of @xmath231 over a region of linear extent @xmath232 will be @xmath233 . when such excitations proliferate , phase coherence will be destroyed . hence , there will be phase coherence only over the length scale @xmath232 when the free energy @xmath234 is of order @xmath235 . the @xmath55 dependence of the mean - field elastic shear modulus @xmath236 is known in the large field limit , @xmath237 , with the simple result that @xmath238 . = 8 cm we believe that there is another kind of phase fluctuation within the liquid that can be identified with a topological defect a `` braid '' . consider a ring of vortices of a given radius that move around the circumference of the ring . ( in three dimensions this vortex movement may take place along the field direction to form a topologically constrained defect hence the name , braid . we have previously calculated the energies of such defects.@xcite ) such a movement may be created by a simple combination of changes to the basis coefficients . if we make the transformation @xmath239 for @xmath240 and make no change to the remaining coefficients @xmath241 then such a braid movement will occur in a ring of vortices that enclose approximately @xmath242 vortices ( see fig . [ fig : braid ] ) . = 6 cm if @xmath243 the vortices in the ring will each hop to a neighbors position , with a phase change in the order parameter of @xmath214 inside the ring ( i.e. no essential change ) . excitations will involve values of @xmath114 less than @xmath214 which increase the phase at the center of the ring by @xmath114 while leaving the phase unchanged outside of the ring . the energies of these braid excitations will define a length scale over which they proliferate , and thus destroy phase coherence . the energy costs of braids in a crystal phase would increase with the size of the ring , and so phase coherence would not be destroyed by this mechanism in the crystalline state . nevertheless , we believe that the excitations of such defects are present on the length scale @xmath232 in the liquid phase , and are a plausible mechanism for the loss of phase coherence seen in fig . [ fig:4 ] . notice that in fig . [ fig:4 ] it is when the density correlations become ring - like ( as would happen due to braid excitations ) that the phase coherence is lost . if an experiment using the spherical geometry was ever to be realized , there would always be a problem in placing the end of a solenoid ( the `` monopole '' ) exactly at the center of the sphere . this will cause the external field to be inhomogeneous over the surface of the sphere . such inhomogeneities are generic in experiments with any geometry , so it is worthwhile investigating these effects . we consider displacing the monopole from the center of the sphere by a distance @xmath4 along the @xmath244-axis . it is straightforward to show that for small @xmath245 , this induces a change in the vector potential of @xmath246 . an inhomogeneity is introduced into the magnetic field at the surface which has a radial component of @xmath247 . substituting this new field into the free energy gives an extra term to first order in @xmath248 of @xmath249 where @xmath250 . before we look at our mc results with this extra term , we consider its effect within the high - temperature perturbation theory . with the addition of ( [ eq : extra ] ) to the hamiltonian , the hf equation becomes @xmath251 with @xmath252 . the sum in this equation is no longer independent of @xmath180 . however , in the large @xmath6 limit , @xmath253 has the form , @xmath254,\ ] ] where @xmath255^{1/2}$ ] . the width of the interaction is of order @xmath256 over most of the sphere . if the variation in the renormalized propagator @xmath257 is smooth over the range of @xmath256 ( which corresponds to changes in real space being smooth over the distance @xmath258 ) then the sum over @xmath259 is dominated by contributions when @xmath260 to give @xmath261 . therefore we have @xmath18 independent hf equations @xmath262 . each has the same solution , but with an @xmath180-dependent effective temperature : @xmath263 $ ] with @xmath264 . this will be true for any change in the hamiltonian of the form @xmath265 . where the effective temperature becomes @xmath266 . such a change corresponds to changes in real space in one direction only over length scales longer than @xmath258 . this procedure can be generalized to an arbitrary diagram in the perturbative scheme . any diagram is dominated by contributions where the indices in and out of a vertex are within @xmath267 of each other . therefore a given diagram is just the sum of the respective diagrams without the inhomogeneity but at the effective temperature @xmath268 . for example , the free energy may be expanded in a power series of the propagator , @xmath269 . with the inhomogeneity this generalizes to @xmath270 this result may break down when variation in @xmath271 is on a scale less than @xmath256 . in the thermodynamic limit our conclusion will hold as long as the perturbation expansion remains useful . = 8 cm + interesting effects may occur when there is a phase transition in the pure system . however , as our simulations fail to see such a transition , the above analysis is sufficient to explain our numerical results . in fig . [ fig : homvs ] we plot the @xmath180-dependent propagator @xmath272 from mc simulations with @xmath273 . and compare to the zero inhomogeneity propagator with the @xmath180-dependent effective temperature . the results confirm that the system behaves with the local properties of the effective temperature . in this section we discuss some of the problems of different boundary conditions when interpreting the results of numerical simulations of superconducting thin films within the lll approximation . we first mention some of the shortcomings of the spherical geometry used in our simulations . we then go on to discuss the other main geometry used qp boundary conditions . in this case there exist problems not present in the spherical geometry due to the constraints on the phase of the order parameter . we also consider a third geometry with a circular geometry , where initial work has not found a phase transition . finally , we look at the implications of recent experiments . an important difficulty on the sphere is that the crystalline state free energy is raised due to the curvature and the necessary presence of twelve disclinations . a liquid with correlation length less than the system size will be unaffected by the curvature . the energy difference should disappear in the thermodynamic limit ( see section [ sec : ground ] ) . however , for the system sizes studied , this energy remains on the same order of magnitude of the jump in energy seen at the transition observed with qp boundary conditions . the presence of the topologically required disclinations on the sphere is clearly an important feature not present in real thin films . however , their effects will only become important as the correlation length of the system approaches the distance between disclinations . this is a finite size effect as experienced by any geometry , although the effective system size will be smaller for a given @xmath6 than on a plane . for the largest system sizes studied , finite - size effects probably become important in the region of interest at @xmath274 . the mobility of these disclinations , if large , would be a mechanism for destroying crystalline order in a finite - sized system . at low temperatures the disclinations should not be mobile , both because of their mutual repulsion ( as can be seen from the elasticity calculation ) and the topological barrier to their motion through the lattice . at higher temperatures where there is a finite density of dislocations ( eg . in a hexatic phase ) the dislocations provide a topological mechanism for the motion of the disclinations . in finite size systems , the strain field associated with the disclination may even create dislocations by pulling apart the dislocation pairs that are always present in a 2d crystal . from inspection of snapshots of the systems at finite temperatures we have observed that dislocations are attracted to the disclinations , and that the positions of the disclinations are not perfectly icosahedral as they are in the ground states . our measurements so far have been insensitive to hexatic bond - angle order . this order could never be globally defined on the sphere , and will only be a meaningful concept within the regions free of any disclinations , which are small in the system sizes we study . it must be conceded , therefore , that our numerical evidence from the sphere for the non - existence of a phase - transition is not yet conclusive . larger system size studies are clearly needed , but even increasing sizes by an order of magnitude may not resolve the problem . our work on the ground states suggests that very large systems with @xmath275 may be needed to reach certain properties of the thermodynamic limit such as the screening of the disclinations by dislocations . in the system investigated by refs . a constant magnetic field * h * perpendicular to a thin - film superconductor is represented by the landau gauge , @xmath276 . in this gauge the lll states are @xmath277}$ ] , where @xmath278 is a `` momentum '' in the @xmath279 direction that must be fixed by the boundary conditions . for a general state in the lll subspace , @xmath280 , the system is periodic in the x direction with period @xmath281 . quasi - periodicity in the y - direction may also be imposed by setting @xmath282 . this condition leads to @xmath283 with @xmath284 . so each principle region has an area @xmath285 and contains @xmath6 zeros of @xmath1 that correspond to vortices . to have a geometry commensurate with a triangular vortex lattice , @xmath286 and @xmath287 are fixed as integers . ( note the difference between the magnetic length @xmath258 and the lattice spacing @xmath26 both of which are defined in section [ sec : method ] . ) the difference between this system and more conventional periodic boundary conditions comes from the constraints on the phase of the order parameter as the principal region is crossed . that such a constraint exists is apparent from the fact that there are only @xmath288 degrees of freedom available to describe the @xmath288 coordinates of the vortex positions as well as an overall phase and amplitude . it has been shown that the phase constraints lead to the center of mass of the vortex positions to be fixed,@xcite which accounts for the missing two parameters . a consequence of the fixed center of mass is that there are only @xmath6 distinct ground states , each a triangular lattice separated by a minimum discrete distance . in mc simulations with qp boundary conditions , evidence is seen for a first order transition . the observed melting temperature drops as system size is increased but extrapolation gives an estimate for the thermodynamic transition@xcite at @xmath289 . in the low temperature state dominated by the ground state there is a finite energy barrier between different ground states . we now estimate what that energy barrier is . = 8 cm + figure [ fig : qp9 ] illustrates the sort of movement of vortices between ground states that obeys the center of mass constraint . the example is for @xmath290 , and a short inspection will reveal that there are only 9 distinct ground states that may be related by such moves . in general the different ground states have the form @xmath291}$ ] for @xmath259 equal to an integer multiple of @xmath292 , and zero otherwise . each ground state is labeled by @xmath293 , where @xmath294 must be an integer from @xmath169 to @xmath292 , and the condition @xmath295 quantizes the allowed values of @xmath296 to integers from @xmath169 to @xmath297 . these ground states are exactly equivalent to the eilenberger@xcite states @xmath298 , with @xmath299 where @xmath300 and @xmath301 . these are related by @xmath302 } \phi(\hbox{\bf r}+\hbox{\bf r}_0| \hbox{\bf 0})$ ] . consider the change @xmath303 for any configuration of @xmath304 . for an infinite system this just corresponds to a uniform translation of the vortices in the x direction by @xmath305 . however , with qp boundary conditions this change will involve movement of vortices at the edges of the principal region in the opposite direction , thus conserving the center of mass . ( an analogous change in the spherical geometry gives the braid in section [ sec : phase ] . ) it is exactly this sort of movement that is a path between different ground states . for example , if we start from @xmath306 and apply this transformation with @xmath114 changing from @xmath59 to @xmath307 we arrive at the state @xmath308 . what is the energy barrier for such a path ? the free energy of the qp system is given by @xmath309 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath310\sqrt{3}\pi/4n_x^2\}}$ ] . changing the phase of the coefficients does not affect the quadratic energy . also , the contributions to the quartic term @xmath311 will be zero when @xmath259 , @xmath312 , @xmath313 , and @xmath87 correspond to the same region ( ie . they are all between @xmath59 and @xmath314 ) . as the width of the gaussian in the quartic interaction is of order @xmath292 , contributions will be negligible unless these variables are within @xmath315 of each other , and the edge of the principal region . therefore the energy barrier of this path will be of order @xmath256 . this @xmath6 dependence has been observed numerically.@xcite = 8 cm + a more quantitative estimate may be obtained by considering the movement of the vortices at the edge of the principal region relative to the vortices in the bulk of this region ( see fig [ fig : inf ] ) . at any point on the path this represents a defect from the perfect ground state , the energy cost of which may be calculated using the methods of ref . . we find an energy barrier of @xmath316 which is proportional to @xmath292 as predicted . this is an upper bound , as only the movement of a line of vortices has been allowed , without relaxation of the surrounding lattice . however , as the interaction energy is short ranged,@xcite we do not expect the @xmath6 dependence to change . it is also a zero temperature result , but it should still hold for a low temperature state with long correlations . we emphasize that this energy barrier grows with system size , despite the fact that the positions of the discrete ground states get closer to each other . additional evidence for the size of these barriers comes from the simulations themselves . in ref . a plot is shown of @xmath317 at a temperature corresponding to the extrapolated thermodynamic transition , where the modulations in this quantity show that the system is dominated by just one of the @xmath6 ground states during the length of the measurement , @xmath318 mc steps . the measurements by sst of this low temperature state are clearly not equilibrated as not all of the ground states are being sampled ; there should always be a translationally invariant density for any _ finite _ system . it is also a possibility that energy barriers between ground states affect the evidence for a first order phase transition . for instance , the free energy of the liquid will be overestimated if the simulation is not run for long enough ( the standard time for these simulations has been @xmath319 mc steps ) which may alter the melting temperature . this casts doubt on the extrapolation of the melting temperature to the thermodynamic limit . even if a first order ( or continuous ) transition remains after full equilibration , the discrete ground state problem makes the qp system unsuitable for transport measurements . an alternative set of boundary conditions may be constructed in the symmetric gauge,@xcite @xmath320 . the lll states may be formed by the complete basis with circular symmetry @xmath321 $ ] , where @xmath322 . to perform numerical simulations , one has to truncate the series of these states to a finite number of terms , say , @xmath323 to @xmath6 . this truncated system has @xmath6 vortices , as @xmath324}\prod_{i=1}^n ( \zeta-\zeta_i)$ ] , and the order parameter drops rapidly to zero outside of a radius @xmath325 from the origin . little work has been done on this geometry as finite size effects are strong . numerical minimizations on small systems have shown that the ground state energy per vortex is _ lower _ than for the infinite plane,@xcite and vortices near the edge of the system are attracted to the `` boundary''@xcite ( near where the order parameter is zero ) . the finite size effects are greater than with spherical or qp boundary conditions where there are no edges of the finite systems and each vortex resides in an equivalent local environment . the effect of the boundary is mainly in a fraction of @xmath326 of the bulk of the system , and should be unimportant in the thermodynamic limit . a similar geometry has been used in simulations of the 2d one component plasma ( ocp ) , where the particles are confined to a circular disk.@xcite a first order transition was observed and this contrasts with the absence of a transition in simulations of the ocp on a spherical geometry.@xcite this has motivated us to perform simulations on the circular geometry in search of a phase transition . we have performed the real space phase and density correlation measurements as in section [ sec : phase ] for systems up to @xmath51 and find results consistent with those on the sphere . we have also measured the internal energy while heating from the ground state and cooling from high temperatures , for system sizes up to @xmath327 . these energy measurements ( see fig [ fig : circ ] ) have revealed no hysteresis on the scale observed in the qp system for temperatures greater than @xmath328 , and hence no evidence for a phase transition . = 8 cm + it seems that from a theoretical point of view there are three possible scenarios for the behavior of thin film superconductors in the presence of a magnetic field : a ) the standard picture of kthny melting of a 2d crystal where a dislocation mediated continuous transition occurs between a low temperature state with quasi - crystalline order and a high temperature liquid or hexatic phase ; b ) a first order transition where the liquid free energy becomes lower than the solid phase before kthny melting takes place ( as is seen in qp simulations ) ; c ) the absence of a distinct low - temperature state , but where the correlation lengths of the liquid diverge as @xmath329 ( this is the prediction of high order perturbation theory from the high temperature side , and is consistent with the numerical simulations on the sphere ) . we now discuss some experimental results and their implications for these possibilities . a melting transition of the flux lattice in in / in0@xmath330 thin films was observed by gammel _ et al._@xcite the zero field limit of the transition was consistent with the kosterlitz - thouless transition in the absence of external fields , though the magnetic field dependence of the melting line did not satisfy the predictions of the kthny theory . the measured transitions were mainly at low fields , so the relevance of our simulations here are doubtful . in the experiments of berghuis _ et al._@xcite the current voltage response was measured of amorphous nb@xmath331ge@xmath330 films at different fields and temperatures . a drop to zero in the a.c . ohmic resistivity is seen , for example at fields @xmath332 at @xmath333 , though the d.c . response remains finite ( ie . the critical current is zero . ) . this drop is attributed to a kthny transition consistent with the temperature and film thickness dependence of the melting field . a similar conclusion is made by yazdani _ et al._@xcite from a.c . measurements on films of amorphous mo@xmath334ge@xmath335 . it should be emphasized that these a.c . measurements at a given frequency @xmath336 probe structural changes of the vortex system over a restricted length scale.@xcite while this is useful to measure properties independent of the presence of a large pinning length , one would expect even in the absence of a phase transition to see a large drop in the resistivity at fixed frequency when the relaxation times grow larger than @xmath337 . in numerical simulations on the sphere,@xcite the plastic time scale was observed to increase as @xmath338 and we would expect a sharp drop when @xmath339 . in contrast to the above experiments , measurements by nikulov _ et al._@xcite on films of amorphous nbo@xmath330 with weak pinning have found no signatures of a resistive transition down to fields @xmath340 . this implies that the transitions observed previously are not universal properties of superconducting thin films . while the lack of a resistive drop may be attributed to the total absence of pinning , one would expect in the presence of a first order transition , where there is a discontinuous change in @xmath341 , that this would be observed as a step in the flux flow resistivity . thus the interpretation of these experiments remains controversial . while the kthny theory provides a useful framework to discuss flux lattice melting in two dimensions , its effects have only been observed over short length scales.@xcite as far as we know there has been no experimental indication of a first order transition in superconducting thin films . in principle , the results of these experiments can still be explained simply by the growing length scales and relaxation times of a vortex liquid in the absence of a phase transition . we have shown that the model with a spherical geometry remains in the vortex liquid phase , at least down to temperatures @xmath342 for system sizes up to @xmath343 . this could be due to the raised energy of the ground states because of the necessary presence of twelve disclinations in a triangular network over a sphere . however , we have made similar investigations on an alternative finite size model : considering the lll basis states on an infinite plane with a circular symmetric gauge and truncating the series to include only @xmath6 vortices.@xcite this system has a lower ground state energy per vortex than the infinite system and no disclinations , but we see the same length scales as in section [ sec : phase ] for temperatures down to @xmath328 . the main evidence for a first order transition in the qp model is the double peak structure observed in the probability distribution of the internal energy at the transition . our investigations on the internal energy for both the sphere and the plane with circular coordinates have revealed no such signatures . the fact that the spherical system remains in the liquid phase down to low temperatures allows us to measure the variation of the correlations in the liquid state with temperature over a large regime . measurements in the liquid phase have the advantages that the system reaches equilibrium over a reasonable time scale at low temperatures . our measurements of the density correlations are consistent with those in the liquid phase using qp boundary conditions.@xcite the extracted length scales demonstrate an asymptotic linear dependence on @xmath198 . the scaling analysis of oneill and moore predicted that the _ phase coherence _ length should grow as @xmath344 . our results for the phase coherence are consistent with this scaling form , and also demonstrate that in the liquid the phase and density correlations grow with identical temperature dependence . our results for the scaling of the phase correlations contradict the conclusions of sst , who claim that in the thermodynamic limit @xmath73 the phase coherence has a range only of the order of the lattice spacing in their `` solid '' phase . however , this discrepancy is really due to different definitions of what is meant by phase coherence . sst do not predict the growth of the length scale of phase correlations as the temperature goes to zero . although their results are claimed as evidence for the charge - density wave of tesanovic,@xcite a finite length scale that grows with decreasing temperature or even a power law form of odlro would still be consistent with this exotic phase . it seems unlikely to us that the low - temperature phase below a first order transition would have a shorter range of phase coherence than the liquid phase . if we measure the phase correlations without fixing any vortices , we also find no phase coherence beyond a length of one lattice spacing , due to the translational freedom of the liquid phase . in the solid phase of the qp model the vortex system appears to be fixed near one ground state due to the finite energy barrier between the @xmath6 ground states , and this allows phase coherence to be observed over a long range . as @xmath6 increases , there is a decrease in the range of phase coherence . these measurements by sst demonstrate just how strong the finite - size effects are in the qp simulations below the observed transition . without fixing the motion of any vortices , the phase coherence should always have a trivial length scale of the inter - vortex spacing . by restricting the motion of a small number of vortices , we have been able to measure a more physically relevant phase correlation length that is consistent with the expected growth of order as the temperature is reduced . an interesting question remains as to whether a similarly defined phase coherence in the solid phase with qp boundary conditions would result in true long range order , or another length scale that also exhibits zero temperature scaling . despite the differences in results from spherical and qp boundary conditions , our results from high temperature perturbation theory and on the ground states suggest that the thermodynamic limit will be the same on the sphere as the infinite flat plane . this contradicts the earlier statement of ref . where the effect of allowing additional dislocation defects into the ground state was not considered . even so , the results on the ground states show how large system sizes must be for certain properties to approach the thermodynamic limit . a definite drawback on the sphere is the small effective system size compared to the number of degrees of freedom . the spherical geometry is perhaps not only relevant for simulational purposes . it is possible that an experiment could be constructed with an amorphous type - ii superconductor sputtered over the surface of a sphere , and one end of a long and thin solenoid inserted into the center to approximate the field from a monopole . in contrast an experimental realization of the qp boundary conditions is not possible ( these boundary conditions are primarily of interest in extrapolating to the thermodynamic limit of an infinite number of free vortices ) . we feel that the spherical geometry , with its property of translational invariance , remains a useful system for numerical simulations , especially to measure properties of the unpinned vortex liquid . an investigation into dynamical properties with a view to examining the length scales associated with non - local resistivity@xcite is planned , which would not be possible using qp boundary conditions due to the absence of full translational invariance of the vortex positions . we would like to acknowledge useful interactions with gianni blatter , tom blum , vadim geshkenbein , roman sasik and joonhyun yeo . mjwd would also like to thank han lee for the use of his source code and the epsrc for financial support . in this appendix we will show that the gl free energy hamiltonian in eq . ( [ eq : ham ] ) depends only on the positions of the zeros in the order parameter on the sphere . first , from eq . ( [ eq : prod ] ) we have @xmath345\nonumber\\ & = & d\prod_{i=1}^n[a_i\sin(\theta/2)e^{i\phi}-b_i\cos(\theta/2)]\nonumber\\ & = & d\prod_{i=1}^nf_i(\theta,\phi),\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath346 and @xmath347 . if @xmath348 when @xmath349 and @xmath350 then we may choose : @xmath351 now , the gl - lll free energy is a functional that depends only on the value of @xmath352 at each point on the sphere . if we can show that @xmath353 depends only on the relative position of the @xmath152th zero then the hamiltonian will be invariant with respect to coordinate rotations of all the zeros : @xmath354\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{2}[1-\cos{\theta'(i)}]\nonumber\\ & = & \sin^2[\theta'(i)/2]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath355 is the polar angle measured from the axis through the @xmath152th zero to the point @xmath46 , defined by an analogous expression to eq . [ eq : theta ] . this is independent of the coordinate frame and so we have shown that @xmath356 depends only on the relative positions of the vortices plus the overall amplitude . to find the reciprocal space density correlator from thermal averages of the lll basis state coefficients ( see eq . ( [ eq : recip ] ) ) we need the integrals @xmath357 which may be written : @xmath358}^{1/2}\times\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{-1 cm } \times\frac{4\pi p!(n - p+m)!}{(n+m+1)!m ! } \,_3f_2\left [ \begin{array}{l } m - l , m+l+1,p+1 \\ m+1,n+m+2 \end{array}\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath359 $ ] is a generalized hypergeometric series . to find the infinite temperature limit of @xmath360 we consider the case @xmath323 and calculate the averages @xmath361 and @xmath362 exactly in the limit @xmath54 ( this involves only gaussian integrals ) . our result is @xmath363}^2 \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{(n!)^2}{(n - l)!(n+l+1)!}.\label{eq : infinite}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( we are indebted to t. blum for this final result . ) this is consistent with the fact that in the limit @xmath364 , the infinite temperature correlation function should be identical with that for an infinite plane,@xcite and the expression in eq . ( [ eq : infinite ] ) should tend to @xmath365 . 999 d. s. fisher , phys . b * 22 * , 1190 ( 1980 ) ; b. a. huberman and s. doniach , phys . rev . lett . * 43 * , 950 ( 1979 ) . p. l. gammel , a. f. hebard and d. j. bishop , phys.rev . * 60 * , 144 ( 1988 ) . p. berghuis and p. h. kes , phys . rev . b * 47 * , 262 ( 1993 ) ; p. berghuis , a. l. f. van der slot and p. h. kes , phys . 65 * , 2583 ( 1990 ) . a. yazdani , w. r. white , m. r. hahn , m. gabay , m. r. beasley and a. kapitulnik , phys . . lett . * 70 * , 505 ( 1993 ) . a. v. nikulov , d. y. remisov and v. a. oboznov , phys . lett . * 75 * , 2586 ( 1995 ) . m. a. moore , phys . b * 39 * , 136 ( 1989 ) ; * 45 * , 7336 ( 1992 ) . j. a. oneill and m. a. moore , phys . rev . lett . * 69 * , 2582 ( 1992 ) ; phys . b * 48 * , 374 ( 1993 ) . p. a. m. dirac , proc . r. soc . london , ser . a * 133 * , 60 ( 1931 ) . j. pearl , appl . phys . lett . * 5 * , 65 ( 1964 ) . z. tesanovic and l. xing , phys . 67 * , 22729 ( 1991 ) ; l. xing and z. tesanovic , physica c * 196 * , 241 ( 1992 ) . y. kato and n. nagaosa , phys . rev . b * 47 * , 2932 ( 1993 ) ; * 48 * , 7383 ( 1993 ) . j. hu and a. h. macdonald , phys . rev . lett . * 71 * , 432 ( 1993 ) ; phys . b * 49 * , 15263 ( 1994 ) . r. sasik and d. stroud , phys . b * 49 * , 16074 ( 1993 ) . r. sasik , d. stroud and z. tesanovic , phys . b * 51 * , 3042 ( 1995 ) . d. r. nelson , in _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , edited by c. domb and j. l. lebowitz ( academic press , new york , 1983 ) , vol . 7 , p. 5 . z. tesanovic , physica c * 220 * , 303 ( 1994 ) . m. j. w. dodgson , j. phys . a : math . gen . * 29 * , 2499 ( 1996 ) . s. m. roy and v. singh , phys . lett . * 51 * , 2069 ( 1983 ) . h. h. lee and m. a. moore , phys . b * 49 * , 9240 ( 1994 ) . n. metropolis , a. w. rosenbluth , m. n. rosenbluth , a. h. teller and e. teller , j. chem . phys . * 21 * , 1087 ( 1953 ) . g. j. ruggeri and d. j. thouless , j. phys . f : metal phys . , * 6 * , 2063 ( 1976 ) . j. hu , a. h. macdonald and b. d. mckay , phys . b * 49 * , 15263 ( 1994 ) ; e. brezin , a. fujita and a. hikami , phys . rev . lett . * 65 * , 1949 ( 1990 ) . g. p. mccauley and d. j. thouless , j. phys . f : metal phys . , * 6 * , 109 ( 1976 ) . w. h. kleiner , l. m. roth and s. h. autler , phys . rev . * 133 * , 1226 ( 1964 ) . h. s. seung and d. r. nelson , phys . a * 38 * , 1005 ( 1988 ) . f. r. n. nabarro , _ theory of crystal dislocations _ ( clarendon press , oxford , 1967 ) , pp . 53 - 7 . h. goldstein , _ classical mechanics _ ( addison - wesley , 1980 ) , pp . j. yeo and m. a. moore , phys . lett . * 76 * , 1142 ( 1996 ) . m. j. w. dodgson and m. a. moore , phys . b * 51 * , 11887 ( 1995 ) . f. d. m. haldane and e. h. rezayi , phys . b * 31 * , 2529 ( 1985 ) . g. eilenberger , phys . * 164 * , 628 ( 1967 ) . r. sasik ( private communications ) . j. a. oneill , phd thesis ( university of manchester ) . choquard and j. clerouin , phys . lett . * 50 * , 2086 ( 1983 ) . j. m. caillol , d. levesque , j. j. weis and j. p. hansen , jour . * 28 * , 325 ( 1982 ) . a. k. kienappel and m. a. moore ( private communication ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: blue compact dwarf ( bcd ) galaxies are metal poor systems undergoing vigorous star formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . with record - breaking low metallicities among galaxies ( e.g. , * ? * ) , their observed colors and spectra indicate essentially newborn starbursts , with mean ages of a few my ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this combination of factors ( chemically unevolved systems , with oversized starbursts that can not last for long ) lead to conjecturing that they are pristine galaxies undergoing star formation for the very first time @xcite . this original view has now been reformulated so that bcd galaxies are chemically primitive objects which we come across during short intense bursts . the starburst phases are interleaved by long periods of quiescence @xcite . the change is based on several observational evidences . most bcds galaxies are known to have a red low surface brightness component ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * and references therein ) , which should exist before the starburst , and which should survive the bcd phase . we are also allowed to resolve some individual stars in the nearest bcd galaxies , and the presence of rgb stars indicates an underlying stellar population much older than the lifetime of a starburst ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? even if they are not pristine , bcds are galaxies with the lowest metallicities and may therefore be showing first stages in star formation from primordial gas . it is not yet clear which objects eventually change to glow as bcdgalaxies ( i.e. , which galaxies are bcds during quiescence ) . identifying them seems to be a necessary first step to answer the question of why a galaxy experiences a bcd phase . what is the nature of the host galaxy in which a bcd starburst takes place ? is it a normal dwarf galaxy ? what is triggering the starburst ? what is left after the starburst ? evolutionary connections between dwarf elliptical galaxies , dwarf irregular galaxies , low surface brightness galaxies , and bcds have been both proposed and criticized in the literature ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? here we take a new approach to investigate the linage of the bcds . rather than directly comparing the properties of the bcds ( or their host galaxies ) with properties of known galaxy types , we attempt a blind search for galaxies that look like precursors or left - overs of the bcd phase , paying minor attention to the galaxy class . we have tried to find field galaxies with the properties of the bcd host , but without the bcd starburst . isolated galaxies are preferred to minimize the role of mergers and harassment on the galactic properties and evolution . these galaxies will be denoted in the paper as quiescent bcdgalaxies or qbcd . if there are enough such galaxies , the bcd may be just a particularly conspicuous phase in the life of otherwise mean dwarf galaxies . if there are no such galaxies , we should conclude that the bcd phase ends up with the host , which is physically unlikely . aiming at shedding light on the bcd evolution , we have tried to answer two specific questions : ( 1 ) are there galaxies like the bcd hosts without the conspicuous starburst observed in bcds ? ( 2 ) if the answer were yes ( as it turns out to be ) , what are the physical properties of these ( putative ) bcd galaxies during quiescence ? the different sections of this paper describe individual steps carried out to answer the two questions posed above . the search for qbcd galaxies like the bcd host galaxies is described in [ lsbstuff ] . luminosities , surface brightnesses , and colors characteristic of bcd host galaxies are taken from @xcite . we search the sdss / dr6 database for candidates , which is ideal for the kind of exploratory statistical study we aim at . the sample of qbcd galaxies has to be interpreted in terms of a sample of bcd galaxies . in order to minimize systematic errors , the control sample of bcds is also derived from sdss / dr6 using the same techniques employed for qbcd selection ( [ select_bcd ] ) . we compare the luminosity functions ( lfs ) of the two samples in [ lf ] , which requires computing how the bcd galaxy luminosity changes to become a qbcd galaxy when the starburst fades away ( [ bcd2lsb ] ) . since the sdss catalog is magnitude limited , the properties that we derive are biased towards the brightest galaxies ( malmquist bias ) . this effect is corrected to derive the intrinsic properties of the two sets ( [ malmquist ] ) . the implications of our findings are discussed in [ discusion ] and [ conclusions ] . we have developed our own software to compute lfs . for the sake of clarity and future reference , details are given in app . a hubble constant @xmath2 km s@xmath3 mpc@xmath3 is used throughout the paper . the search has been carried out using the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) dataset , which is both convenient and powerful . we use the latest data release , dr6 , whose spectroscopic view covers 7425 deg@xmath4 and contains @xmath5 galaxies @xcite . the main characteristics of the sdss are described in the extensive paper by @xcite , but they are also gathered in the comprehensive searchable sdss website . we access the database through the so - called casjob entry , which allows direct and flexible sql searches , such as those needed to select only isolated galaxies . absolute magnitudes are computed from relative magnitudes and redshifts . all magnitudes have been corrected for galactic extinction @xcite . no @xmath6correction has been applied since we are dealing with nearby galaxies with redshifts @xmath7 , and so , with hubble flow induced bandshifts much smaller than the relative bandwidth of the color filters @xcite . in a consistency test using sdss spectra representative of qbcds and bcds , we have estimated that the @xmath6corrections are smaller than 0.01 magnitudes ( qbcds ) and 0.1 magnitudes ( bcds ) . the properties of the qbcd galaxies have been taken from the sample of 28 bcd galaxies in @xcite , whose hosts have been characterized by @xcite . they represent a large set of host galaxy properties consistently derived from 2-dimensional fits . @xcite fit sersic profiles varies with the radial distance from the center of the galaxy @xmath8 as @xmath9^{1/n}$ ] , with @xmath10 chosen so that half of the galaxy light is enclosed within @xmath11 ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . the so - called sersic index @xmath12 controls the shape of the profile . ] to the outskirts of each bcd galaxy once the bright central blue component has been masked out . from fits in various bandpasses , they derive luminosities , colors and sersic indexes . we use them to guide the sdss search . ( the impact on the selection of using this particular characterization rather than other alternatives is discussed in [ characterization ] . ) the actual properties of these bcd host galaxies are shown in fig . [ lsb_data ] . the sdss photometric colors @xmath13 are not the standard @xmath14 system used by @xcite therefore , in order to produce fig . [ lsb_data ] , the original de - reddened colors have been translated to sdss magnitudes using the recipe in ( * ? ? ? * table 7 ) . this photometric transformation is suited for stars but , according to the sdss website , the equations also provide reliable results for galaxies without strong emission lines , as we expect the bcd hosts to be . ( 9097 ) vs visible magnitude @xmath15 ( 4825 ) . ( c ) sersic index ( @xmath16 concentration ) vs magnitude . ( d ) sersic index vs color . the plus symbols inserted into the boxes mark the gold subsample , i.e. , those galaxies which are believed to be characterized best . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] note that the absolute magnitude , the color , and the sersic index of each bcd host do not seem to be correlated with each other ( cf . figs . [ lsb_data]a , [ lsb_data]c , and [ lsb_data]d ) . this fact allows us to assume that the magnitude , color and concentration of each host galaxy are independent , and we will look for galaxies whose properties span the full range of observed values . before we can proceed , there is an important observational property of the bcd hosts that needs to be mentioned . ( for a detailled discussion , see @xcite . ) bcd galaxies and their host galaxies tend to have similar luminosities , so that the brighter the bcd galaxy the brighter the host ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? actually , there seems to be a simple relationship between the magnitude of the host , @xmath17 , and the magnitude of the bcd galaxy , @xmath18 , @xmath19 figure [ mag_vs_mag ] presents the scatter plot between the observed magnitude of the bcds analyzed by @xcite , and the magnitude of their host galaxy . there is a linear relationship between the two observed magnitudes as parameterized by equation ( [ law ] ) the slope is very close to one , and the scatter remains rather small ( less than 0.5 mag ) . the relationship is independent of the color and , therefore , it will remain like equation ( [ law ] ) for the sdss photometric system . magnitudes yields a slope of @xmath20 , and an offset of @xmath21 ( the dashed line ) . within error bars , the results are identical when using the full data set for fitting ( the dotted line ) , indicating a relationship independent of the color . the gold set defined by @xcite also yields the same result ( not shown ) . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] cll ( 1 ) & colors & @xmath22 mag + ( 2 ) & concentration indexes & @xmath23 + ( 3 ) & magnitudes & @xmath24 mag + ( 4)&be isolated & no bright galaxy within 10 @xmath25 + ( 5)&get rid of proper motion & redshift @xmath26 + & induced redshifts & + table [ criteria_lsb ] lists the actual constraints employed in our sdss / dr6 search for qbcd galaxies like the bcd host galaxies . the range of colors , @xmath27 has been taken directly from fig . [ lsb_data]a . the range of absolute magnitudes , @xmath28 requires a more elaborated explanation . the upper bound corresponds to the magnitude of the faintest bcd host ( fig . [ lsb_data]a ) . the lower limit , however , is inherited from the lower limit of the bcd galaxies selected in [ select_bcd ] . this is a control set used for reference and , according to arguments to be given in [ select_bcd ] , sdss bcd galaxy candidates are chosen to be fainter than @xmath29 . therefore , for consistency with equation ( [ law ] ) , we impose the lower limit given in equation ( [ noname ] ) . there is an additional detail concerning the magnitudes in use . @xcite integrate the sersic profile to infinity to estimate magnitudes , whereas the sdss catalog provides petrosian magnitudes , where the galactic light is integrated only up to a certain distance from the galactic center ( see * ? ? ? @xcite show how the difference between the petrosian magnitude and the total magnitude differs by less than 0.2 magnitudes for sersic indexes @xmath30 . the hosts have sersic indexes smaller than this limit ( fig . [ lsb_data]c ) and , therefore , we neglect the difference . the brightness profile of the bcd host is parameterized in @xcite by means of the sersic index @xmath12 . according to fig . [ lsb_data]c , @xmath31 this constraint is translated into a limit on the so - called concentration index @xmath32 , which can be readily obtained from the sdss catalog since it provides the radii containing 50% of petrosian flux , @xmath25 , and 90% of the petrosian flux , @xmath33 . according to ( * table 1 ) , the limits given in equation ( [ index_cons ] ) imply , @xmath34 which is the constraint used in our search ( table [ criteria_lsb ] , 2nd row ) . this constraint has been applied both to @xmath15 and to @xmath35 magnitudes . as explained in the introduction , we seek isolated galaxies to minimize the effect of mergers and harassment on the galaxy properties . the criterion for finding isolated galaxies is inspired by the work of @xcite . we stipulate that the selected galaxies have no bright companion within @xmath36 . ( note that @xmath25 is approximately the effective radius , i.e. , the radius containing half of the galaxy luminous flux . ) companions are neglected if they are at least three magnitudes fainter than the candidate . these two constraints are set in the color filter @xmath15 ( see table [ criteria_lsb ] , 4th row ) . since absolute magnitudes are computed from redshifts , we ask the redshifts to be large enough to minimize the proper - motion induced doppler shifts . the threshold redshift corresponds to a distance of 13 mpc and a velocity of 900 km s@xmath3 ( see table [ criteria_lsb ] , 5th row ) . applying the criteria in table [ criteria_lsb ] to the sdss / dr6 , one retrieves 21493 galaxies . their mean redshift is 0.030 , with a standard deviation of 0.014 . the galaxies are illustrated in fig . [ image_sample ] , top row , where we include color images of four randomly chosen qbcd candidates . figure [ mybcd ] shows various histograms corresponding to the observed properties of this set of galaxies ( the solid lines ) . means , standard deviations and modes corresponding to these histograms are listed in table [ properties ] . the determination of the concentration indexes of small galaxies may be problematical . they are based on determining galaxy sizes and , therefore , they are affected by seeing ( see * ? ? ? we select a subset among the qbcd candidates to test whether the main properties of the candidates depend on the spatial resolution . to be on the safe side , we consider candidates having @xmath37 , i.e. , larger than the typical sdss seeing ( @xmath38 ) . the corresponding histograms are also shown in fig . [ mybcd ] ( the dashed lines ) , with the means , standard deviations and modes included in table [ properties ] . except for the surface brightness , there are no systematic differences between the full set and the subset of large qbcd galaxies . moreover , the decrease of surface brightness for large galaxies has nothing to do with poor seeing . it is a bias imposed by our lower limit in absolute magnitude ( table [ criteria_lsb ] , 3rd row ) . unless the large galaxies are also low surface brightness , they are much too bright to satisfy our selection criterion . in short , poor seeing does not seem to bias our selection in any obvious way . cccccccccccccccccl observed qbcd&[email protected]&-18.8 & & [email protected]&-18.3 & & [email protected]&0.46 & & [email protected]&22.0 & & [email protected]&8.60&&[email protected] & 1.9 + large qbcd&[email protected]&-18.6 & & [email protected]&-18.1 & & [email protected]&0.46 & & [email protected]&22.9 & & [email protected]&8.60 & & [email protected] & 9.9 + observed bcd&[email protected]&-18.3 & & [email protected]&-19.0 & & [email protected]&0.15 & & [email protected]&21.0 & & [email protected]&8.35 & & 172.@xmath39174 . & 58 . + restored qbcd&[email protected]&-14.9 & & [email protected]&-14.2 & & [email protected]&0.38 & & [email protected]&22.6 & & [email protected]&8.40 & & [email protected] & 1.9 + restored bcd&[email protected]&-16.3 & & [email protected]&-15.1 & & [email protected]&0.15 & & [email protected]&21.7 & & [email protected]&8.14 & & 121.@xmath39 64 . & 58 . + the galaxies in [ lsbstuff ] are selected to be quiescent bcds . it is clear that this conjecture and the galaxy properties must be examined in terms of the properties of the bcd galaxies . this is particularly true to answer the first basic question of whether the number density of qbcd candidates suffices to account for the existing bcds . number densities are best characterized as lfs but , to the best of our knowledge , there is no bcd lf in the literature . moreover , even if such a lf existed , it would have been produced with a number of ( unknown ) biases different from those involved in our sdss selection . therefore , we found it necessary to extract from sdss a set of bcd galaxies , that is to say , to construct a reference bcd sample with the biases and problems of the qbcd galaxies we want to compare to . this section describes such selection of bcd candidates . the general criteria have been taken form @xcite , but they are implemented according to @xcite . a bcd galaxy should have the following properties , ( 1 ) be _ blue _ enough , which constrains the colors , ( 2 ) be _ compact _ , which limits the surface brightness , ( 3 ) be _ dwarf _ , which sets a lower limit to the magnitude , ( 4 ) have a _ large star formation rate _ ( sfr ) , which implies having enough h ii regions and , therefore , enough @xmath40 emission , ( 5 ) be _ metal poor _ , and ( 6 ) _ not to be confused with agns_. these general criteria have been specified as detailled in table [ criteria_bcd ] . the numerical values corresponding to constraints ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) have been taken from @xcite , who point out three photometric criteria for a galaxy to be a bcd , @xmath41 @xmath42 @xmath43 using the transformation between johnson s and sdss photometric systems in @xcite , plus equation ( 1 ) in @xcite , these three conditions become the constraints ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) in table [ criteria_bcd ] . the mean surface brightness @xmath44 has been computed as the magnitude of the average luminosity within @xmath25 , i.e. , @xmath45 , with @xmath46 the apparent magnitude ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? the transformation between photometric systems is suited for stars , rather than for galaxies with emission lines like the bcds . however , the approximation suffices because the actual limits in equation ( [ caca ] ) are estimative , and the effect of including lines modifies the bcd magnitudes by 0.1 mag or less . this effect has been estimated using sdss spectra representative of bcd galaxies . cll ( 1 ) & be blue enough & @xmath47 mag arcsec@xmath48 + ( 2 ) & be compact & @xmath49 mag arcsec@xmath48 + ( 3 ) & be dwarf & @xmath50 mag + ( 4)&having large sfr & @xmath51 equivalent width @xmath52 + ( 5)&be metal poor & @xmath53 ( @xmath16 1/3 @xmath54 ) + ( 6)&not to be confused with agns & neglect agn contamination + ( 7)&be isolated & no bright galaxy within 10 @xmath25 + ( 8)&get rid of proper motion & redshifts @xmath26 + & induced redshift & + the actual implementation of criteria ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) are mere educated guesses that try not to be too restrictive . for example , we consider metallicities smaller than 1/3 the solar value ( table [ criteria_bcd ] , item 5 ) , when @xcite bound the bcds metallicities between 1/10 and 1/50 . the ( oxygen ) metallicity of the galaxies ( o / h ) has been estimated using the so - called n2 method , based on the equivalent widths of the emission lines @xmath55\lambda6583 $ ] and @xmath40 , @xmath56 with @xmath57\lambda6583}\over{h_\alpha}};\ ] ] see @xcite and references therein . note that this metallicity characterizes the properties of the h ii regions excited by the starburst , which represents only a very small fraction of the galactic gas ( see [ discusion ] ) . keeping the appropriate caveats in mind , the n2 method suffices for the elementary estimate we are interested in . active galactic nuclei ( agns ) can be misidentified as star - forming galaxies since they are high surface brightness blue galaxies with emission lines . agns introduce spurious bcd candidates . in practice , however , this contamination is negligible , and we do not decontaminate for the presence of agns ( item 6 in table [ criteria_bcd ] ) . our approach can be justified using the criterion to be an agn by @xcite . an emission line galaxy is an agn if @xmath58\lambda5007}\over{h_\beta } } > 1.3 + 0.61/\big(\log{{[nii]\lambda6583}\over{h_\alpha}}-0.05\big ) . \label{agn_eq}\ ] ] we selected all sdss bcd candidates chosen according to @xcite criteria ( items 1 , 2 and 3 in table [ criteria_bcd ] ) , and having the spectral line information required to apply the test ( the lines @xmath59\lambda5007 $ ] , @xmath55\lambda6583 $ ] , @xmath40 , and @xmath60 ) . figure [ agn ] shows the scatter plot of the two indexes involved in equation ( [ agn_eq ] ) . points above the solid line are agns according to the criterion in equation ( [ agn_eq ] ) . there are very few agns and , what is even more important , most of them stay to the right of the vertical dashed line , i.e. , @xmath57\lambda6583}\over{h_\alpha } } > -0.95,\ ] ] which corresponds to the constraint on the n2 index imposed when the o / h abundance estimate is based on the n2 index , and the o / h is constrained as we do ( item 5 in table [ criteria_bcd ] ) . our bcd candidates are to the left of this line and therefore the low o / h abundance constraint automatically removes most of the agn contamination , which explains our approach . in order to quantify the residual contamination , let us mention that only 0.4% of the low o / h abundance bcd candidates in fig . [ agn ] are also agn candidates . we select isolated bcd candidates ( criterion 7 in table [ criteria_bcd ] ) because of consistency with the criteria used to search for bcd host galaxy candidates . as in the case of qbcds , we stipulate that the galaxies have no bright companion within @xmath36 , where @xmath25 is the radius including 50% of the petrosian flux . the companions are not bright enough to perturb the galaxy if they are three magnitudes fainter than the galaxy . applying the criteria in table [ criteria_bcd ] to the sdss / dr6 , one gets 1609 bcd galaxies . the dotted lines in fig . [ mybcd ] represent the distribution of physical properties of this set of candidates . means , standard deviations , and modes are also included in table [ properties ] . four randomly chosen bcd candidates are shown in fig . [ image_sample ] , bottom . the main redshift of the bcd candidates is 0.032 , with a standard deviation of 0.019 . after carrying out the selection described above , we figured out that most of the bcd sample is also part of the qbcd sample : 1198 galaxies are shared by the two sets . they represent 74.5% of the bcds and 5.6% of the qbcds . the typical properties of the sets are very different ( table [ properties ] and fig . [ mybcd ] ) , however there is overlapping between the two populations . roughly speaking , the bcd sample represents the fraction qbcd galaxies having the largest @xmath40 equivalent width ( see fig . [ mybcd ] , bottom right , where the dotted line and the solid line agree for @xmath40 ew @xmath61 ) . since the @xmath40 luminosity is a proxy for star formation ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , the bcd sample seems to be the qbcds having the largest specific star formation rate ( sfr ) , i.e. , the largest sfr per unit of luminosity . the overlapping is consistent with the two galaxy sets being part of a single continuous sequence , the most active qbcd galaxies still being identified as bcd galaxies . the lf , @xmath62 , is defined as the number of galaxies with absolute magnitude @xmath63 per unit volume and unit magnitude . we will use it to quantify the number of qbcd candidates per bcd galaxy existing in the nearby universe . lfs are computed using a maximum likelyhood procedure similar to the methods described in the literature ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? we developed and tested our own code for training purposes , and its characteristics and similitude with existing methods are described in app . cubic splines are used to parameterize the lf shape , and the best fit is retrieved maximizing the likelyhood in equation ( [ loglike ] ) , a task realized with the usual powell algorithm ( e.g. * ? ? ? errors bars are assigned by bootstrapping . when the procedure is applied to the qbcd galaxies described in [ lsbstuff ] , one finds the lf represented in fig . [ lfs_fig]a ( the solid line ) . this lf is similar to that obtained with the @xmath64 method working on the same data sets ( see app . [ appa ] ) . the formal errors deduced from bootstrapping are very small ( the shaded area around the solid line in fig . [ lfs_fig]a ) . we use 50 bootstrap re - samples , but the error estimate is not very sensitive to this parameter . the lf is mostly sensitive to the apparent magnitude limit of the qbcd galaxy set . we are using a single apparent magnitude limit for the full dataset , and changing this limit modifies the overall normalization given a number of observed galaxies , the deeper the magnitude limit the lower the inferred number density of galaxies . we take for the limit , @xmath65 this selection is consistent with the magnitude limit of the main sdss galaxy sample ( @xmath66 , * ? ? ? * ) , keeping in mind that the qbcd galaxies are somewhat red with @xmath67 ( see table [ properties ] and fig . [ mybcd ] ) . however , we obtain the limit in equation ( [ mlimit ] ) from the scatter plot of the qbcd galaxy absolute magnitude vs the redshift shown in fig . [ lfs_fig]c . by trial and error , we modify the curve representing the boundary to be expected if the whole sample were limited with a single apparent magnitude . the best match is shown as the solid line in fig . [ lfs_fig]c and , except for the range of large luminosities , the data set fits in well the expected behavior . galaxies whose apparent magnitudes exceed the threshold in equation ( [ mlimit ] ) are not used to compute the lf a histogram of the observed apparent magnitudes is shown in fig . [ lfs_fig]b ( the solid line ) . the normalization of the lf depends on the fraction of sky covered by survey , which we take to be the coverage of the sdss / dr6 spectroscopic catalog ( 7425 deg@xmath4 ; @xcite ) . figure [ lfs_fig]a also shows the lf corresponding to the bcd galaxies selected in [ select_bcd ] ( the dashed line ) . the number density of bcd candidates ( @xmath68 mpc@xmath69 ) is much smaller than the number density of qbcd galaxies ( @xmath70 mpc@xmath69 ) , giving , @xmath71 in this case the limit magnitude of the sample has been set to @xmath72 , which we determine with the same procedure used for the qbcd galaxies . the need for a different apparent magnitude limit can be inferred from the histograms in fig . [ lfs_fig]b . note how the histogram for bcd galaxies ( the dashed line ) does not drop off for large magnitudes as abruptly as the histogram for the qbcd galaxies ( the solid line ) . the calculus of lfs has been repeated using @xmath73 magnitudes , i.e. , the redder sdss color filter at @xmath74 . this bandpass is less sensitive to ( blue ) starbursts , enhancing the contribution of old stellar populations . the results are represented in fig . [ lfs_z_fig ] . they are similar to those obtained from @xmath15 , except that the lfs are shifted by one magnitude . the ratio between the number of qbcd galaxies and bcd galaxies remains as in equation ( [ ration_1_o ] ) 24 in this particular case . figures [ lfs_fig]a and [ lfs_z_fig]a include the lfs for extremely low luminosity galaxies worked out by @xcite ( the dotted lines ) . we used them as a reference , since they include all low redshift galaxies in the sdss spectroscopic catalog and , therefore , they provide lfs for the local universe affected by the same kind of bias as our galaxy selection . using these lfs as reference , we find the qbcd galaxies to be rather numerous . one out of each three dwarf galaxies is a qbcd candidates ( cf . the solid lines and the dotted lines in figs . [ lfs_fig]a and [ lfs_z_fig]a ) . similarly , one out of each ninety dwarf galaxies is a bcd candidate ( cf . the dashed lines and the dotted lines in figs [ lfs_fig]a and [ lfs_z_fig]a ) . our lfs are not corrected for the incompleteness of the sdss catalog at low surface brightness . according to the detailled simulation carried out by ( * ? ? ? 3 ) , the incompleteness is not significant for galaxies with @xmath75 . most of our qbcd candidates are within this bound ( fig . [ mybcd ] , bottom left ) , and it does not affect the bcd selection at all ( table [ criteria_bcd ] ) . the qbcd lf would be affected at its faint end , but even at @xmath76 the expected correction is not larger than a factor of two ( * ? ? ? * fig . 6 ) . this uncertainty does not modify the conclusions of the paper , which are mostly qualitative . however , the number of qbcd galaxies worked out in the paper may be underestimated by a factor of order one . the question arises as to whether the lfs for qbcd galaxies and bcd candidates are consistent . they seem to be , according to the following heuristic procedure to estimate the lf for the hosts of the bcds . given a lf of bcds , @xmath77 , one can work out the lf to be expected once the starburst dies out , @xmath78 . by switching the star formation on and off , bcd galaxies turn into qbcd galaxies , and vice versa . these two evolutionary phases have different timescales ; @xmath79 for the bcd phase , and @xmath80 for the qbcd phase . in a stationary state the number of galaxies turning from bcd to qbcd must be balanced by the galaxies going from qbcd to bcd , @xmath81 where bcd galaxies with magnitude in the interval @xmath82 become qbcd galaxies with magnitudes @xmath83 . combining equation ( [ stationary ] ) with the empirical relation between the magnitudes of the host galaxy and the bcd ( equation [ [ law ] ] ) , one has the recipe to infer the lf of the host galaxies to be expected from the lf of the bcd galaxies , @xmath84 the scaling factor @xmath85 is just the ratio between the number densities of bcds , @xmath86 , and qbcds , @xmath87 , @xmath88 since @xmath78 and @xmath77 are normalized to @xmath87 and @xmath86 , respectively . using equations ( [ phi_to_phi ] ) and ( [ timescales ] ) , we evolve the lf of bcd galaxies in figs . [ lfs_fig]a and [ lfs_z_fig]a to obtain the lfs of their host galaxies . they are included in the same figures as the dotted - dashed lines . the scaling ( [ timescales ] ) has been taken as the ratio between the number densities of qbcd galaxies and bcd galaxies ( i.e. , the ratio in equation [ [ ration_1_o ] ] for the @xmath15 filter , and the corresponding figure for the @xmath73 filter ) . the similarities between the evolved lf ( the dotted - dashed lines ) and the lf computed from the qbcd data sets ( the solid lines ) are quite striking . we interpret this agreement as an indication of self - consistency between the two sets of galaxies chosen in [ data_set ] . bcd galaxies and qbcd galaxies can be different phases in the life of a dwarf galaxy , with the lifetime in the bcd phase some thirty times shorter than the lifetime in the qbcd phase ( equations [ [ ration_1_o ] ] and [ [ timescales ] ] ) . the bcd starbursts are very young since they still conserve massive stars ( see [ introduction ] ) . if @xmath89my then equations ( [ timescales ] ) and ( [ ration_1_o ] ) imply @xmath90gy . consequently , each qbcd galaxy may undergo as many as 30 - 40 star formation episodes during the timespan where stars can be formed in dwarf galaxies ( @xmath9110 gy ; e.g. , * ? ? ? this issue is discused in [ discusion ] . the histograms of galaxy properties discussed in [ data_set ] , and shown in fig . [ mybcd ] , describe the properties of the _ observed _ galaxies . these histograms are strongly biased since they overweight the properties the most luminous galaxies in the samples . in order to correct for the malmquist bias , so that histograms are weighted according to the _ true _ number density of galaxies , we have used the ratio between the lf derived in [ lf ] , @xmath62 , and the observed histogram of absolute magnitudes , @xmath92 as usual , the symbol @xmath93 stands for the rectangle function , @xmath94 the index @xmath95 in equation ( [ pi_eq ] ) includes all observed galaxies , whereas @xmath63 and @xmath96 determine the centers and the widths of the histogram bins . ) differs from that used in fig . [ mybcd ] because of the factor @xmath97 . this trivial re - scaling is used here for convenience , allowing the corrected histograms to be normalized to the number density of galaxies . ] we have to assume that each observed galaxy is actually a proxy for @xmath98 galaxies , @xmath99 of which are not included in our observation because they are too faint to exceed the apparent magnitude threshold . the magnitude of the galaxy causes the bias and , therefore , we assume that the bias function only depends on the absolute magnitude of the galaxy , @xmath100 this bias is precisely the reason why @xmath101 is not the lf , therefore , for @xmath96 small enough , @xmath102 using equation ( [ bias_funct ] ) , and assuming that @xmath103 is a slowly varying function of @xmath63 , @xmath104 and so one finds from equation ( [ phi_h ] ) the expression for the bias function , @xmath105 let us denote as @xmath106 the histogram of any parameter @xmath107 constructed using the observed galaxies , @xmath108 with @xmath109 the bin - size and @xmath110 the value corresponding to the @xmath95-th galaxy . then the bias - corrected histogram would be , @xmath111 this definition guarantees that the corrected histogram of observed absolute magnitudes is the luminosity function ( cf . equations [ [ phi_h ] ] and [ [ correct_histo ] ] with @xmath112 ) and , therefore , it is not difficult to show that all corrected histograms have the same normalization as the lf , i.e. , @xmath113 @xmath114 being the number density of galaxies ( see app . [ appa ] ) . we have applied equations ( [ b_i_est ] ) and ( [ correct_histo ] ) to restore the histograms in fig . [ mybcd ] . the result is shown in fig . [ mybcd_restored ] . the means , standard deviations and modes of the new histograms are also included in table [ properties ] . as expected , the mean absolute magnitudes of the restored histograms are much fainter than the observed ones . however , in addition to this effect , the corrected histograms hint at intrinsic metallicities significantly lower than the observed ones both for bcd and qbcd galaxies . the corrected qbcd galaxy colors are bluer than the colors of the observed set . these changes can be pin down to the correlations between luminosity , color , and metallicity existing in the original data set . figure [ abu_vs_mg ] shows how the qbcd galaxies tend to be less metallic as they become fainter , and a similar , but less marked trend , is also present in bcd galaxies . such a relationship between metallicity and mass in dwarf galaxies ( and so , between metallicity and luminosity ) was given by @xcite , and later on by many others ( see * ? ? ? figure [ abu_vs_mg ] includes the linear relationship found by @xcite for nearby dwarf irregular galaxies . curiously enough , the slope is almost the same as we find for qbcd galaxies . there is also a relationship between color and luminosity , so that fainter qbcd galaxies seem to be bluer ; see fig . [ color_vs_mg ] . the symbols stand for the mean values considering all the galaxies with similar @xmath115 , whereas the error bars represent the standard deviation of the mean values . both qbcd galaxies ( the square symbols ) and bcd galaxies ( the asterisks ) follow a trend so that the fainter the galaxy the more metal poor . the solid line is shown for reference and it corresponds to the law for nearby dwarf irregular galaxies found by @xcite . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] color vs absolute @xmath115 magnitude . the symbols stand for the mean values considering all the galaxies with similar @xmath115 , whereas the error bars represent the standard deviation to be expected for these mean values . the qbcd galaxies are bluer as they become fainter ( the square symbols ) . the same trend is not so obvious for the bcd galaxies ( the asterisks ) . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] figures [ abu_vs_mg ] and [ color_vs_mg ] actually reveal an underlying relationship between color and metallicity . it has been brough up in fig . [ abu_vs_color ] , showing how the redder the galaxy the larger the oxygen abundance . the relationship is more clear in the case of the qbcd galaxies ( the square symbols ) , but it is also present among the redder bcd galaxies ( the asterisks for @xmath116 ) . the relationships for qbcds and bcds meet at @xmath117 , although they have different slopes . $ ] ) considering all the galaxies with the same color . the error bars correspond to the standard deviation to be expected for these averages . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] the number of known bcd galaxies with metallicities less than 1/20 the solar value is rather small ( a dozen or so , according to * ? ? ? surprisingly enough , the list of 1609 bcd candidates we work out contains only three candidates below this metallicity . we interpret this result as a support of the metallicity estimate carried out in the paper , but it also reinforces the existence of a minimum h ii region based metallicity ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . the range of selected qbcd colors is rather broad and , therefore , our list of qbcd candidates seems to include all the range from early - type galaxies to late - type galaxies . this fact can be appreciated in fig . [ color_vs_color]a , which contains a color - color scatter plot . our galaxies follow the sequence used in galaxy classification , with the reddest extreme corresponding to elliptical galaxies ( early types ) , and the bluest extreme to irregular galaxies ( late types ) compare fig . [ color_vs_color]a with , e.g. , fig . 2 in @xcite . one can distinguish two clusters or concentrations in fig . [ color_vs_color]a ( the dashed line arbitrarily separates the two sub - sets ) . the existence of these two clusters or classes was to be expected , since they correspond to the bimodal distribution of colors found in the large samples of galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . hints of these two modes are also found as two small peaks in the histogram of surface brightness color shown in fig . [ mybcd ] ( top right , the solid line , with the two peaks at @xmath118 0.4 and 0.7 ) . note how the bcd candidates occupy the bluest extreme of the color - color plot ; cf . figs . [ color_vs_color]a and [ color_vs_color]b . vs @xmath119 scatter plot for the qbcd candidates . the colors in the sequence span from those of early - type galaxies , to those of late - type galaxies . there seem to be two clusters in the distribution of points , which we have artificially separated by the dashed line . ( b ) same as ( a ) but showing the bcd candidates . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] most of the qbcd candidates show @xmath40 in emission , meaning that even if the star - formation is reduced with respect to the bcd candidates , it is not absent . only some 3200 qbcd galaxies out of the 21493 candidates show @xmath40 in absorption . they have ( negative ) equivalent widths of a few and , therefore , these objects are included in the bin of zero equivalent width in fig . [ mybcd ] , bottom right . using the @xmath40 flux as a proxy for star formation @xcite , our qbcd candidates turn out to be one order of magnitude less active in forming stars than the bcds . this estimate is worked out in [ consumption ] , equations ( [ comp6 ] ) and ( [ comp5 ] ) . so far we have described our search avoiding interpreting the results . this section , however , is fully devoted to interpretation and so , admittedly speculative . we will discuss how the results in previous sections are consistent with the bcd candidates and the qbcd candidates being two different phases in the same sequence of galactic evolution . using as a working hypothesis that bcds change into qbcds , and vice versa , we examine obvious flaws and constraints . showing the consistency of an hypothesis does not prove it to be correct other alternatives can not be discarded . it just shows the working hypothesis to be viable . three main results point out in this direction . first , we choose the qbcds so that their colors , concentration indexes and luminosities are equal to those of the galaxies underlying the bcds . second , the lf of qbcds is conformable to the lf of bcds ( [ lf ] ) . third , the bcd galaxies turn out to be qbcd galaxies with the largest ( specific ) star formation rates ( [ select_bcd ] ) . matching lfs forces the qbcd phase to last some 30 times longer than the bcd phase ( [ bcd2lsb ] ) . since the bcd starbursts are so short - lived , there should be many episodes of bcd phase during a galaxy lifetime . assuming a single 10 my long starburst per bcd phase , there should be one of such bcd phases each 0.3 gy . longer bcd phases are in principle possible by concatenation of starbursts , but population synthesis modeling of bcd spectra does not favor extended periods of star - formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . if bcds are transformed into qbcds and vice versa , each qbcd has experienced several bcd phases because the other alternative does not seem to be consistent with the results of the search . let us examine this alternative possibility , namely , that the bcd phase represents the only episode of intense star formation during the galaxy lifetime . statistically , all qbcd galaxies that we detect today have sufferred a bcd episode during the last 270 my ( equations [ [ ration_1_o ] ] and [ [ timescales ] ] , with @xmath12010 my ) . if this is the only such episode per galaxy , there should be no bcds among galaxies observed at lookback times larger than 270 my , or at redshifts @xmath121 (= @xmath122 ) . however , a large fraction of the sample of bcds selected in [ select_bcd ] has redshifts larger than this limit . we are forced to conclude that the same host galaxy undergoes several bcd phases . although the recursive bcd phase scenario explains a number of important observables , other properties of qbcds and bcds do not seem fit in the picture so well . the purpose of the rest of the section is to discuss ( and hopefully clarify ) some of the most obvious difficulties posed by the scenario . one may think that the repeated starbursting of a dwarf galaxy quickly exhausts the gas reservoir , thereby making the whole picture inconsistent . however , the low surface brightness galaxies like the qbcds are gas - rich @xcite , with fuel to power the star formation during several hubble times . this claim can be supported by working out the h i consumption timescale , @xmath123 , which is defined as the time required to transform into stars the neutral hydrogen of the galaxy , @xmath124 , i.e. , @xmath125 with sfr the star formation rate . on the one hand , dwarf low surface brightness galaxies have about one solar mass of h i per solar luminosity @xcite , explicitly , @xmath126 @xmath127 being one solar mass , and @xmath128 the solar absolute luminosity in the @xmath15 filter . on the other hand , the sfr scales with the @xmath40 luminosity ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , i.e. , with the product of the @xmath40 equivalent width times the galaxy luminosity . since the observed bcd @xmath40 equivalent width is uncorrelated with the galaxy luminosity , the bcd sfr scales with the luminosity , that is to say , @xmath129 where @xmath130 stands for the sfr of a bcd galaxy of magnitude @xmath131 . in our two - phase scenario , the galaxy has short periods of star formation lasting @xmath79 , interleaved with long periods of quiescence lasting @xmath80 ( [ bcd2lsb ] ) . consequently , the effective time - average sfr is , @xmath132 @xmath133 with @xmath134 as judged from the ratio of @xmath40 equivalent widths in table [ properties ] , and the difference of luminosity between bcds and qbcds ( equation [ [ law ] ] ) , the sfr during the bcd phase is some ten times larger than during the qbcd phase , i.e. , @xmath135 by combining equations ( [ def_tau ] ) , ( [ comp1 ] ) , ( [ comp2 ] ) and ( [ comp4 ] ) , one finds the consumption timescale to be independent of the galaxy luminosity , @xmath136 . \label{comp3}\ ] ] although bcd star formation bursts are intense for a dwarf galaxy , the sfrs of bcds are rather modest , i.e. , less than @xmath137 , and typically one order of magnitude smaller ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? taking @xmath138 for the brightest galaxies of our sample , @xmath139 , and using the ratio of timescales between the phases as provided by equations ( [ ration_1_o ] ) and ( [ timescales ] ) , equations ( [ comp5 ] ) and ( [ comp3 ] ) yield , @xmath140 consequently , the hydrogen existing in qbcd galaxies allows the sequence bcd - qbcd to last for a few hubble times ( @xmath14114 gy ) . a final comment is in order . the scenario of a recursive starbursting is not in conflict with the commonly accepted view of a sfr decreasing during the last 10 gy @xcite . this drop refers to massive galaxies . however , the kind of dwarf galaxies in our qbcd sample , with stellar masses less than @xmath142 , has maintained a sfr either stationary or slightly increasing with time ( see * ? ? ? * fig . 1 ) . the metallicities of our qbcd galaxies are systematically larger than the metallicities of the bcd galaxies . this result seems to be in conflict with the recursive bcd phase scenario , since the bcd starburst starts off with a metallicity lower than the metallicity of its host galaxy ( see table[properties ] ) . although this disagreement may indicate a real flaw in the overall picture , one can also think of various ways to circumvent the apparent inconsistency . for example , the bcd episodes may involve fresh low metallicity gas accreted by the host galaxy during the periods of quiescence . note that the bcd episodes are very conspicuous from the point of view of the luminosity , but they involve moderate masses , which hardly exceed @xmath143 ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . a sustained infall such as those postulated in the literature to solve various problems in galaxy evolution ( @xmath144 ; see @xcite , and references therein ) provides @xmath143 in only 50 my , even for a small 2.5 kpc galaxy . masses of @xmath143 are also typical of the high velocity clouds hounding our galaxy ( e.g. , * ? ? ? if these gas reservoirs are common in qbcds , they may develop major star formation events when merging with the galaxy . the fresh gas glowing during the bcd phase does not necessarily have to come from outside . metal - poor gas may exist in place in the galaxy ( [ consumption ] ) . then the oxygen metallicity assigned here to qbcd galaxies may not reflect the metallicity of this gas , but the metallicity of a few metal - polluted h ii regions remaining from the last starburst . it is relatively easy to enrich with metals the small fraction of galactic gas undergoing starbursts . for example , the metallicity of a pure gas cloud increases from the level observed in bcds ( @xmath145 ; table [ properties ] ) to the level in qbcds ( @xmath146 ) , if 60% of the original mass is transformed into starts.0.003 ; see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . ] the metal - polluted gas produces emission lines during the extended recombination phase of the h ii region ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , and it may also give rise to a secondary generation of stars . the light from these aging h ii regions renders high metallicity measurements . eventually , the star - processed gas mingles with the metal - poor gas of the galaxy , but this mixing leaves the original metallicity almost unchanged\simeq 0.006 $ ] , i.e. , insignificant . ] . we note that this explanation may be in conflict with the ir excess detected in the halos of blue compact galaxies by @xcite . these halos can be identified with the bcd host galaxies and , therefore , with the qbcds . the colors can not be explained with a normal metal - poor stellar population like the milky way halo , but an excess of low - mass stars with significant metallicity is required ( see * ? ? ? the nature of the disagreement requires further investigation , and it may be due to the fact that these blue compact galaxies with ir excesses are not dwarfs according to the criteria used in our work . there is yet another possibility to reconcile the metallicities of the two galaxy types . only those qbcd candidates with metallicity similar to that of the bcd galaxies would be part of the bcd qbcd sequence . the qbcds with metallicity like the bcds represent 20% of the sample ( see fig . [ mybcd ] ) and , therefore , the timescale of quiescence must be shortened by a factor of five to comply with equation ( [ timescales ] ) . the same happens with the h i consumption timescale worked out in equation ( [ comp9 ] ) . these qbcd galaxies may keep their low metallicity levels because the metals are expelled by galactic winds ( @xcite ; see , however , @xcite ) , because they are recycled into new stellar generations within superstar clusters , without significant mixing with the galactic gas @xcite , or simply because of the dilution with pristine gas described above . we select isolated qbcd galaxies , therefore , the starburst triggering mechanism to turn them into bcds can not be galaxy - galaxy interactions , mergers or harassment . how , then , are the bcd bursts triggered ? several possibilities are available . if the fresh gas falls on the qbcd galaxy over extended periods of time , intense star formation can not be triggered until the gas density exceeds the required threshold ( the so - called schmidt law ; @xcite ) . waiting for enough gas to accumulate could explain periods of latency . if the gas falls in during short episodes ( like the collision with a large gas cloud ) , the hitting of the gas itself may induce star formation . then the qbcd timescale would be given by the characteristic time between cloud collisions . if rather than coming from outside , the fresh gas is part of the galaxy , internal galactic structures like bars may periodically excite star formation . in the case of a gas - rich galaxy the triggering may also be due to perturbations of the galactic material by dark matter clumps . these elusive structures are predicted in lots by the cold dark matter simulations of galaxy formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , and they are expected to disturb the quiet evolution of galactic disks ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the criteria used to characterize qbcds come from the bcd host galaxies analyzed by @xcite , but we may have used different criteria taken from other works . the question arises as to whether the selection of candidates critically depends on this assumption . the bcd host galaxy properties are used to constrain colors and sersic indexes ( see [ lsbstuff ] and table [ properties ] ) . the lower limit luminosity , also taken from the bcd host galaxies , turns out to be unimportant since the small number low luminosity objects prevents any serious influence of this criterion on the selection ( see fig . [ mybcd ] ) . the range of visible @xmath119 colors that we use agrees with the colors that different studies have assigned to the hosts of bcds ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , even in those cases where a significant infra - red excess has been detected ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . in this sense the color criterion does not seem to be questionable and , therefore , any work would have rendered similar qbcd candidates . the selection of sersic indexes is more influential . studies like @xcite or @xcite find indexes as large as @xmath1471020 , whereas we take @xmath148 ( table [ properties ] ) . however , there are two good reasons to prefer low@xmath149 values . first and most important , the observed dwarf galaxies present low@xmath149 values ( e.g. , fig . 11 in * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and if we search for galaxies that may be blue - compact-_dwarf _ galaxies during quiescence , they must be dwarfs too ( see equation [ [ law ] ] . ) second , the large @xmath12 values are obtained from 1d fits to azimuthally averaged luminosity profiles , and the @xmath12 thus obtained depends critically on the range of radii used to characterize the galactic outskirts ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the 2d fits providing low indexes are fairly more robust and , therefore , to be preferred ( see * ? ? ? the starburst characteristic of bcd galaxies does not last for long . once this episode is over , the bcd galaxies should dim their surface brightness to become quiescent bcd galaxies ( or qbcd galaxies ) . although qbcd galaxies are to be expected , they have not been identified yet ( see [ introduction ] ) . the present work describes an effort to find them among the galaxies in the sdss / dr6 database . the properties of the qbcds have been taken from the sample of bcd host galaxies characterized by @xcite ( [ lsbstuff ] ) . we find 21493 qbcd candidates , therefore , qbcds seem to be fairly common in the local universe . in order to have a proper reference to compare with , a complete sample of bcd galaxies was selected too . it comprises 1609 bcd candidates ( [ select_bcd ] ) . since the two samples were selected from the same database using analogous criteria , the comparison between the two sets is relatively free from the bias that our selection may have . we compute luminosity functions ( lfs ) for the two samples ( [ lf ] ) . in addition , we estimate their main properties before and after correcting for malmquist bias . these properties can be summarized as follows , * there are around 30 qbcd candidates per bcd candidate . we infer this ratio by comparison of the lfs for qbcds and bcds . the two lfs are very similar , except for the global scaling factor , and the expected 0.5 magnitude dimming ( [ bcd2lsb ] ) . * the surface brightness of the qbcds is typically one magnitude fainter than the surface brightness of bcds ( table [ properties ] ) . * qbcd candidates are , on average , 0.4 magnitudes redder than the bcd ( table [ properties ] ; @xmath150 ) . * qbcd candidates have an h ii region based oxygen metallicity 0.4 dex higher than the bcd candidates ( table [ properties ] ) . * the qbcd metallicity increases with the luminosity , following the well known trend for dwarf galaxies . * the qbcd metallicity also increases with the color , so that the redder the galaxy the larger the measured metallicity . * 75 % of the bcd candidates are also part of the qbcd sample ( [ select_bcd ] ) . roughly speaking , the bcd sample represents the fraction qbcd galaxies having the largest specific sfr ( sfr per unit of luminosity ) . * there are around three dwarf galaxies per qbcd candidate ( [ lf ] ) , which renders one bcd galaxy every ninety dwarf galaxies . the overlap between bcd galaxies and qbcd galaxies is consistent with the two sets forming a single continuous sequence , with the most active qbcd galaxies being bcd galaxies . the agreemet between their lf shapes , and the ratio of number their densities , support the commonly accepted view that bcd galaxies undergo short bursts of star formation separated by long quiescent epochs . however , the fact that the qbcd metallicity is higher than the bcd metallicity poses a problem to such an episodic starbursting scenario , which we try to circumvent with various plausible explanations in [ metallicity ] . the repeated starbursting scenario predicts a number of independent observables whose testing is important but goes beyond the scope of the paper . they represent a natural extension of the present work . in order to illustrate the possibilities , we will outline two examples . qbcds must have a stellar population corresponding to short star formation episodes in between quiescent gaps . in principle , one can distinguish between a ( low level of ) continuous star formation and a more violent episodic star formation with a period of 0.3 gy . @xcite put forward a spectroscopic index to detect post - starburst galaxies . the technique is well suited for determining the time elapsed from the last ( young ) starburst , and it has been calibrated by @xcite . depending on the noise level , one can apply the method to selected qbcd sdss spectra , or to averages of similar qbcd spectra . another testable prediction of the scenario has to do with the metallicity inferred from emission lines in qbcd galaxies ( [ metallicity ] ) . it should overestimates the true galaxy metallicity and , in particular , the metallicity of the stellar content . studies of stellar metallicity can be carried out using integrated galaxy spectra , provided that they have enough signal - to - noise ratio and spectral resolution to show absorption lines ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? these two testable predictions provide a flavor for other tests to come . thanks are due to r. daz campos for training with the sql queries , to j. betancort for clarifying discussions on the lf normalization , and to a. vazdekis for pointing out the work by @xcite . the authors are particularly indebted to a. daz , m. mas - hesse , r. terlevich , p. papaderos , and j. vlchez for stimulating discusions during the meetings of the _ estallidos _ collaboration . this work has been partly funded by the spanish _ ministerio de educacin y ciencia _ , proyect aya 2007 67965 . we thank the referee for helping us to clarify some of the arguments in the paper . funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s . department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england . t he sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions . the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , university of cambridge , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington . the lf , @xmath62 , is defined as the number of galaxies with absolute magnitude @xmath63 per unit of magnitude and unit of volume . we use it to describe the local universe and , therefore , @xmath62 is not expected to change with the position in space . the number of galaxies per unit volume , @xmath114 , is just , @xmath151 where only absolute magnitudes in between the limits @xmath152 are considered . using the definition of lf , one can easily write down the number of galaxies to be expected in an apparent magnitude limitted catalog , namely , @xmath153 as usual , the symbol @xmath154 stands for the volume of universe covered by the catalog where galaxies of absolute magnitude @xmath63 have apparent magnitudes smaller than the catalog threshold ( e.g. , * ? ? ? maximum likelyhood estimates of lfs are favored in the current literature ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? they were pioneered by @xcite and , among the quoted advantages , they present a number of desirable asymptotic error properties . note , however , that these methods are not unbiased ( the expected value of the estimate is not necessarily the parameters to be estimated ) . the method is based on the following principle ; given the redshift @xmath155 of an observed galaxy , the probability that it has an absolute magnitude @xmath63 is , @xmath156 where the normalization gives all the galaxies that we are allowed to observe at @xmath155 . since our catalog is limited in apparent magnitude @xmath157 , @xmath158 only galaxies bright enough would be observable at this redshift . considering the definition of distance modulus , @xmath159 then , @xmath160 similarly , the sample would have a minimum apparent magnitude @xmath161 ( e.g. , given by the brightest galaxy in the sample ) , which sets the minimum magnitude to be observed , @xmath162 assuming that the probability of observing each galaxy is independent from the rest of galaxies , the likelyhood function @xmath163 is just the product of the probability of observing each galaxy , @xmath164 where the index @xmath165 spans from 1 to @xmath166 . the maximum likelyhood estimate maximizes @xmath163 , which is equivalent to maximizing its logarithm , @xmath167 . \label{loglike}\ ] ] the next step consist in parameterizing the lf in terms of a number @xmath168 of free parameters @xmath169 , @xmath170 with @xmath171 . various representations @xmath172 can be found in the literature , e.g. , a stepwise function @xcite , a schechter function @xcite , a collection of gaussians @xcite . we choose yet another representation , namely , natural cubic splines . the reasons are ( 1 ) the lf is simple and fast to compute , ( 2 ) the integral of the lf is also fast to compute since it follow directly from the spline interpolation , and ( 3 ) it automatically provides a smooth @xmath62 . speed is always an appealing feature since the maximization of @xmath173 is carried out iteratively , and requires many evaluations of the lf . the normalization of the lf is not constrained by the likelyhood function , which is independent of a global scaling factor ( equation [ [ loglike ] ] ) . another complementary method is required to estimate the number density of galaxies @xmath114 . such method is often the minimum variance estimate by @xcite . we use a simple version of such estimate , where all the galaxies in the sample are equally weighted , thus avoiding assuming a particular covariance of the galaxy catalog . it corresponds to the so - called @xmath174 in the original paper by @xcite , and it has been used elsewhere ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the expression can be derived by combining equations ( [ this_is_needed ] ) and ( [ this_is_needed_too ] ) , which yield , @xmath175 all items in the right - hand - side of the previous expression are known ; the normalized lf @xmath176 , @xmath177 is provided by the maximum likelyhood procedure , whereas @xmath154 follows from the magnitude limit and the solid angle of the catalog ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . the actual maximization of the likelyhood in equation ( [ loglike ] ) is carried out using the standard powell method @xcite . error bars are assigned by bootstrapping ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , where one constructs bootstrap re - samples by choosing at random galaxies from the original data set . then the application of the lf retrieval procedure to all bootstrap re - samples yields a set of lfs with the spread of values to be expected from the true error distribution @xcite . we use the standard deviation of such bootstrap distribution as our error bars . numerical tests have been carried out to check the procedure . we choose a large number of galaxies ( @xmath178@xmath179 ) with random absolute magnitude according to gaussian or uniform distributions . these galaxies are randomly uniformly spread in space within a sphere of radius @xmath180 . apparent magnitudes are computed using these redshifts , and galaxies fainter than the assumed catalog cutoff are drooped from the sample ( we take @xmath181 ) . this biased sample is then used to fed the procedure . two examples of true and restored lfs are given in fig . [ tests_fig ] . the solid lines correspond to our maximum likelyhood estimate , whereas the dashed lines show the _ true _ histogram derived from the synthetic data before the apparent magnitude threshold is introduced . the two of them agree within error bars , which are given as shaded areas . moreover , the maximun likelyhood estimates also agree with the @xmath64 estimates included in the same plot ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a description of traditional @xmath64 method by @xcite ) . the agreement is not specific of these particular realizations but is a general property , and it seems to hold both independently of the original distribution , and the number of galaxies in the sample . in order to illustrate the magnitude of the correction carried out by the lf retrieval routine , fig . [ tests_fig ] also includes the distributions of magnitudes of the some @xmath182 galaxies given to the program ( the dotted lines ) . lf ( square symbols ) , and the maximum likelyhood lf ( the solid line , with the shaded region representing the error bars ) . the dotted line corresponds to the original data offered to the lf retrieval routine . ( a ) case where the true lf is a uniform distribution between magnitudes -23 and -17 . ( b ) same as ( a ) except that the underlying lf is a truncated gaussian . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] lf ( square symbols ) , and the maximum likelyhood lf ( the solid line , with the shaded region representing the error bars ) . the dotted line corresponds to the original data offered to the lf retrieval routine . ( a ) case where the true lf is a uniform distribution between magnitudes -23 and -17 . ( b ) same as ( a ) except that the underlying lf is a truncated gaussian . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the local coulomb interaction @xmath6 of electrons occupying quantum dots leads to a variety of effects . many of them can conveniently be studied in transport through the dot within the linear regime . theoretically as well as experimentally well - investigated examples are the coulomb blockade ( cb ) peaks of the transmission ( conductance ) @xcite as well as the plateaus of width @xmath2 of the transmission ( conductance ) induced by the kondo effect @xcite . additional features of interacting multi - level dots that have recently attracted considerable theoretical attention are the population inversions of the dot levels @xcite , the phase lapses of the transmission phase @xmath1 or , equivalently , the zeros of the transmission amplitude @xmath7 ( transmission zeros ) @xcite and additional correlation - induced resonances of @xmath8 @xcite . they appear in certain parts of the parameter space when the level occupancies and the transmission amplitude are investigated as functions of the level positions , which can be tuned via a nearby plunger gate voltage . such effects were hitherto mostly studied in a minimal model involving only two levels . a very important step towards a unified understanding of population inversions , phase lapses and correlation - induced resonancess in spin - polarized two - level dots was recently taken by a multi - stage mapping of the problem on a generalized kondo model and a subsequent renormalization group and bethe ansatz analysis of the effective hamiltonian @xcite . theoretical studies of phase lapses ( transmission zeros ) are of primary interest in connection with a series of linear response transmission measurements by the weizman group @xcite on aharonov - bohm rings containing a quantum dot in one arm . under suitable conditions both the phase @xmath1 and magnitude @xmath8 of the transmission amplitude @xmath9 of the dot can be extracted from the aharonov - bohm oscillations of the current through the ring @xcite . when this is done as function of a plunger gate voltage @xmath10 that linearly shifts the dot s single - particle energy levels downward , @xmath11 ( @xmath12 is a level index ) , a series of well - separated cb peaks of rather similar width and height was observed in @xmath13 , across which @xmath14 continuously increased by @xmath0 , as expected for breit - wigner - like resonances . in each cb valley between any two successive peaks , @xmath1 always jumped sharply downward by @xmath0 . this phase lapse behavior was found to be `` universal '' , occurring in a large succession of valleys for every _ many_-electron dot studied in refs . this universality is puzzling , since naively the behavior of @xmath15 is expected to be `` mesoscopic '' , i.e. to show a phase lapse in some cb valleys and none in others , depending on the dot s shape , the parity of its orbital wavefunctions , etc . only recently @xcite , also the _ few_-electron regime was probed experimentally : as @xmath10 was increased to successively fill up the dot with electrons , starting from electron number @xmath16 , @xmath14 was observed to behave mesoscopically in the _ few_-electron regime , whereas the above - mentioned universal phase lapse behavior emerged only in the _ many_-electron regime @xmath17 . it was suggested in ref . @xcite that a generic difference between the few- and many - electron dots may be that for the latter , transport might simultaneously occur through several partially filled single - particle levels in parallel . a possible reason could be that the mean ( non - interacting ) level spacing @xmath4 of the topmost filled levels decreases as the number of electrons increases , while the charging energy @xmath2 still implies well separated transmission resonances @xcite . this scenario forms the basis of a recent systematic study by us of the interplay of level spacing , level width and charging energy on the phase lapses for up to four interacting levels and spin - polarized electrons @xcite . we showed that the universal phase lapse and transmission zero behavior appearing at small @xmath4 can be understood as resulting from a fano - type interference effect @xcite involving transport through two or more effective dot levels , whose position and width have been renormalized by the coulomb interaction and coupling to the leads . the importance of several overlapping levels for phase lapses had earlier been pointed out by silvestrov and imry in a rather specific model of a single wide and several narrow levels with strong interaction @xcite . here we supplement our earlier study @xcite by discussing the relation between phase lapses and population inversions and by investigating the role of finite temperatures @xmath18 as well as spin , focusing on @xmath19 levels . when spin is included , the kondo effect plays a role for an odd average occupation of the dot , but the phase lapse scenario is unaffected by this . experimentally the behavior of the phase in the presence of the kondo effect was investigated in refs . @xcite and @xcite . as in ref . @xcite we are concerned with the _ generic _ behavior and thus investigate the entire parameter space , going beyond subspaces of higher symmetry [ such as left - right ( l - r ) or 1 - 2 symmetry of the coupling between the left and right leads and the two levels ] . for low temperatures and sufficiently small single - particle spacings @xmath4 of the dot levels , we find @xmath0 phase lapses between two transmission peaks in an overwhelmingly large part of the parameter space of the level - lead couplings . we point out that the two level case is special compared to models with @xmath20 , as for generic level - lead couplings a transmission zero and phase lapse occurs between the two transmission peaks _ even at _ u=0 . the effect of the interaction is merely to increase the separation of the transmission peaks . for large @xmath4 the appearance or not of phase lapses between transmission peaks depends on the relative sign of the level - lead couplings in analogy to the noninteracting case @xcite . for spin - polarized dots we in addition compare our @xmath21 results with the ones of recent mean - field studies @xcite . in these works level - lead couplings beyond the subspaces with increased symmetry were studied , and a remarkably more complex behavior was found once the symmetries were broken . the importance of considering such generic parameter sets was independently pointed out in ref . we here elucidate how the phase lapse behavior is affected by quantum fluctuations , which are expected to be strong in low - dimensional systems . we find that upon including quantum fluctuations , the part of parameter space exhibiting universal @xmath0 phase lapses between well separated cb peaks becomes larger than suggested by the mean - field study . in particular , we do not recover certain peculiar features of the mean - field results of refs . @xcite and @xcite , namely the occurrence , in certain regimes of parameter space , of a phase lapse of less than @xmath0 ( instead of precisely @xmath0 ) , accompanied by the disappearance of the corresponding transmission zero @xcite . these features thus turn out to be artifacts of the mean - field approximation , which misses the rather simple scenario for the phase lapse behavior of a two - level dot at small @xmath4 : for generic level - lead couplings a phase lapse and transmission zero between two transmission peaks is already present at @xmath5 ; increasing the coulomb interaction the peaks become well separated while the phase lapse and transmission zero remain in the valley between them . in the model of a single wide and several narrow levels @xcite a relation between phase lapses and population inversions was discussed . therefore , in phase lapse studies quite often also the level occupancies @xmath22 , @xmath23 , are investigated . we emphasize that the generic appearance of a phase lapse and transmission zero even at @xmath5 renders the two - level model unsuitable for establishing a general relation between phase lapses and population inversions , as the latter only appear at sufficiently large @xmath2 . furthermore , we show that discontinuities of the @xmath22 as a function of @xmath10 are an artifact of the mean - field solution ( see refs . @xcite and @xcite ) . within our approaches discontinuities are only found for l - r symmetric level - lead couplings with a relative plus sign of the underlying hopping matrix elements and degenerate levels , a case which was earlier identified as being nongeneric @xcite , because the transmission shows only a single peak . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ model ] we introduce our model for the spin - polarized and spin - degenerate two - level dot . we discuss the relation between the measured magnetic flux dependence of the interferometer s linear conductance and the magnitude and phase of the dot s transmission amplitude . the latter can be computed from the one - particle green function of the dot . we present a brief account of our techniques to obtain the latter , the numerical ( nrg ) @xcite and functional renormalization group ( frg ) methods . for an introduction to the use of the frg to quantum dots see refs . @xcite and @xcite . in contrast to the implementation of the nrg used in ref . @xcite , where we were restricted to l - r symmetric dots at @xmath21 , we have now adopted the full density matrix ( fdm ) nrg method of @xcite , which enables us to investigate dots with arbitrary level - lead state overlap matrix elements @xmath24 ( with @xmath25 ) as well as to study finite temperatures . in secs . [ resultsnon]-[resultsspin ] we present our results of the @xmath10 dependence of @xmath8 and @xmath1 . first we briefly discuss the noninteracting two - level dot with generic level - lead couplings and point out that the phase lapse scenario differs from the one for more than two levels . we then investigate interacting , spin - polarized dots , study the relation between phase lapses and population inversions and compare to the mean - field results for the phase lapses . the issue of continuous versus discontinuous @xmath10 dependence of the level occupancies @xmath26 and @xmath27 is commented on . next we study the role of finite temperatures . finally , we consider spin - degenerate levels at small @xmath3 which implies the appearance of kondo physics at odd average dot filling . using nrg and frg we show that the spin does not alter the universal phase lapse scenario . our findings are summarized in sec . [ summary ] . in this section we introduce our model for the two - level dot . we argue that it is the energy dependent ( effective ) transmission amplitude @xmath28 which one has to compute if one is interested in comparing to the measurements of refs . @xcite of the magnitude of the transmission amplitude and its phase . the amplitude @xmath29 can be determined from the matrix elements of the dot s interacting one - particle green function . we furthermore discuss aspects of the nrg and the frg specific to our problem . our hamiltonian consists of three parts @xmath30 the two semi - infinite leads are modeled as noninteracting one - dimensional tight - binding chains and for simplicity are assumed to be equal @xmath31 the hopping strength in the leads is @xmath32 . we use standard second quantized notation with @xmath25 indicating the left and right leads , where the quantum numbers @xmath33 and @xmath34 label wannier states and spin , respectively . the dot is described by @xmath35 where the term with @xmath36 and @xmath37 is excluded from the sum in the interacting part . we define @xmath38 . in experimental systems the inter- and intra - level coulomb repulsion can be expected to be comparable in size and to avoid a proliferation of parameters we assumed them to be equal . this assumption is not essential ; by relaxing it we have checked that our results are robust against inter - level variations of the interaction strengths . finally , the coupling between dot and lead states is given by @xmath39 with real overlap matrix elements @xmath24 . for later purposes we define @xmath40 and @xmath41 . for simplicity , part of our studies will be performed on a model of spinless electrons , for which the spin index will be dropped . the resulting model may be regarded as a spin - polarized version of the spinful model obtained if the latter is put in a very large magnetic field . the experimental two - path interferometer is characterized by wide base regions and very narrow point contacts towards the emitter and collector . electrons can thus only pass once through either the upper or lower arm ( one of them containing the dot ) before reaching the collector . it is furthermore reasonable to assume that the voltage drops at the point contacts and the dot remains in equilibrium @xcite . under these conditions the magnetic flux @xmath42 dependent part of the conductance of the aharonov - bohm interferometer @xmath43 is given by @xcite @xmath44 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with the flux quantum @xmath45 , the derivative @xmath46 of the fermi function as well as the transmission amplitudes @xmath47 of the arm containing the dot and @xmath48 of the reference arm . the transmission @xmath49 is the product of the transmission @xmath50 through the dot and the transmission @xmath51 through the rest of the interferometer arm containing the dot . it is reasonable to assume that @xmath51 as well as @xmath52 are only weakly energy and gate voltage dependent and thus the @xmath10-dependence of the aharonov - bohm oscillations of the measured linear conductance of the interferometer is dominated by the @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude and phase of the transmission amplitude through the dot . as usual @xcite , we compute the energy - averaged transmission phase @xmath1 and magnitude @xmath8 of the dot for a fixed spin direction as the phase and absolute value of @xmath53 where the frequency integral represents an energy average , weighted by the derivative of the fermi function , as appropriate for a finite electron temperature in the leads . in the limit @xmath54 , @xmath55 reduces to a @xmath4-function and @xmath56 is equal to @xmath57 . we here take the chemical potential @xmath58 . using scattering theory @xmath28 ( for fixed spin direction ) can be related to the spin - independent matrix elements ( in the @xmath23 indices of the wannier states ) of the dot s one - particle retarded green function @xmath59 @xmath60 with ( after taking the wide band limit ; see below ) @xmath61 where @xmath62 denotes the local density of states at the end of each semi - infinite lead . without loss of generality we have assumed that @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 . the spin - independent dot occupancies @xmath22 ( per spin direction ) , that we will also investigate , follow from the green function @xmath66 by integrating over frequency ( or can be computed directly when using nrg ) . for l - r symmetry of the level - lead couplings and at temperature @xmath21 , @xmath67 can also be expressed in terms of the spin independent occupancies @xcite @xmath68\pi ) } e^{i(n_e+n_o)/\pi } \ ; , \label{t_lr}\ ] ] where @xmath69 for @xmath70 and @xmath71 for @xmath72 , respectively . here we will compute @xmath59 in two ways , using both a truncated , that is approximate , frg scheme , and a numerically exact method , the nrg . the truncated frg is an approximation scheme to obtain the self - energy @xmath73 ( and thus the one - particle green function ) and higher order vertex functions for many - body problems @xcite . as a first step in the application of this approach to quantum dots one integrates out the noninteracting leads within the functional integral representation of our many - body problem @xcite . the leads provide a frequency dependent one - particle potential on the dot levels . on the imaginary frequency axis it is given by @xmath74 where @xmath75 denotes the spin - independent green function of the isolated semi - infinite leads taken at the last lattice site @xmath76 as we are not interested in band effects we take the wide band limit . the potential then reduces to @xmath77 after this step , instead of dealing with an infinite system we only have to consider the dot of two interacting levels . in the computation of the interacting one - particle green function projected onto the dot system the sum of the dot hamiltonian with @xmath78 and @xmath79 can be interpreted as a frequency dependent `` single - particle hamiltonian '' and in the following will be denoted by @xmath80 . for the spin - polarized case it is a @xmath81 matrix in the quantum number @xmath23 . including spin , because of the additional quantum number @xmath82 , @xmath83 is a @xmath84 matrix which is block - diagonal in @xmath34 ( spin conservation ) . as we are here not interested in the role of a magnetic field lifting the spin - degeneracy of each level the @xmath85 and @xmath86 blocks are equivalent . the resolvent @xmath87^{-1}$ ] obtained from @xmath88 is equivalent to the noninteracting propagator of our two - level many - body problem projected on the dot levels . in the generating functional of the one - particle irreducible vertex functions we replace @xmath89 by @xmath90^{-1}\ ] ] with @xmath91 being an infrared cutoff running from @xmath92 down to @xmath93 . taking the derivative with respect to @xmath91 one can derive an exact , infinite hierarchy of coupled differential equations for vertex functions , such as the self - energy and the one - particle irreducible two - particle interaction . in particular , the flow of the self - energy @xmath94 ( one - particle vertex ) is determined by @xmath94 and the two - particle vertex @xmath95 , while the flow of @xmath95 is determined by @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and the flowing three - particle vertex . the latter could be computed from a flow equation involving the four - particle vertex , and so on . at the end of the frg flow @xmath96 is the self - energy @xmath73 of the original , cutoff - free problem we are interested in @xcite from which the green function @xmath59 can be computed using the dyson equation . a detailed derivation of the frg flow equations for a general quantum many - body problem that only requires a basic knowledge of the functional integral approach to many - particle physics @xcite and the application of the method for a simple toy problem is presented in ref . @xcite . for an overview of the application to quantum dots see refs . @xcite and @xcite . we here truncate the infinite hierarchy of flow equations by only keeping the self - energy and the frequency - independent part of the two - particle vertex . higher order terms can be neglected if the bare two - particle interaction is not too large . by comparison to nrg data this approximation scheme was earlier shown to provide excellent results for a variety of dot systems @xcite . for further comparison see fig . [ fig7 ] below . the present scheme leads to a frequency - independent self - energy ( see below ) . as finite frequency effects ( inelastic processes ) become important at temperatures @xmath18 , but these are not accurately treated by the level of approximation used here , in the present paper we shall show frg results only for @xmath21 . the truncation leads to the coupled differential flow equations @xmath97 and @xmath98 \big\ } \label{finalflowgamma}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath99 , @xmath100 , etc . are multi - indices representing the quantum numbers @xmath101 and @xmath102^{-1 } \ ; .\ ] ] in the model with spin - degenerate levels each index @xmath99 , @xmath100 etc . can take four different values @xmath23 and @xmath103 which gives 16 equations for @xmath94 and 256 for the two - particle vertex . for a spin - polarized two - level dot the multi - indices take two values and one obtains 4 equations for @xmath94 and 16 for the two - particle vertex . the number of independent equations can be significantly reduced ( see below ) taking into account the antisymmetry of the two - particle vertex and the spin symmetry ( for spin - degenerate levels ) both being preserved by eqs . ( [ finalflowsigma ] ) and ( [ finalflowgamma ] ) . the initial conditions at @xmath104 are given by @xmath105 while @xmath106 is given by the bare antisymmetrized two - body interaction . in the spin - polarized case the only nonzero components of the two - particle vertex at @xmath107 are @xmath108 in the model including spin the initial conditions take the form @xmath109 all other components which do not arise out of these by permutations ( @xmath110 and @xmath111 ) are zero . the self - energy matrix and thus the one - particle green function is completely independent of the spin direction and in the following we suppress the spin indices . as already mentioned the present approximation leads to a frequency - independent self - energy . this allows for a simple single - particle interpretation of its matrix elements . the sum of the @xmath112 and the bare level position correspond to the flowing effective level positions , @xmath113 , while @xmath114 is a hopping between the levels 1 and 2 generated in the frg flow . the frg formalism then reduces to a set of coupled differential flow equations for @xmath115 , @xmath116 and a few ( one in the spin - polarized case and seven for spin - degenerate levels ) independent components of the two - particle vertex . these flow equations can easily be integrated numerically using standard routines . it is important to note that although we start out with intra- and inter - level coulomb interactions of equal strengths they generically become different during the frg flow ( because of the different @xmath117 ) . furthermore , additional interaction terms which are initially zero will be generated in the flow . the set of equations significantly simplifies if the flow of the vertex is neglected while the results remain qualitatively the same . within this additional approximation and for a spin - polarized dot the flow equations for @xmath115 and @xmath116 are explicitly given in ref . @xcite . in certain limiting cases it is even possible to analytically solve the differential equations @xcite . however , in the present work , the flow of the vertex is retained which clearly improves the quality of approximation @xcite . at the end of the frg flow , the full green function takes the form @xmath118^{-1}_{j , j ' } = i \omega \delta_{j , j ' } - h_{j , j'}(i\omega)$ ] with an effective , _ noninteracting _ ( but @xmath10- , @xmath2- and @xmath119-dependent ) `` hamiltonian '' @xmath120 in a last step we have to perform the analytic continuation to the real frequency axis @xmath121 . this is straightforward , as the only frequency dependence of @xmath122 is the trivial one of the lead contribution eq . ( [ leadpotdefwideband ] ) . then @xmath28 can be computed using eq . ( [ transformula ] ) . the numerical renormalization group was invented by k. g. wilson in 1974 as a nonperturbative renormalization scheme for the kondo model @xcite . it was later extended to the fermionic @xcite anderson model which describes a localized electronic state coupled to a fermionic bath . the nrg allows thermodynamic and dynamic properties of such strongly correlated systems to be calculated at zero and finite temperature @xcite . the key idea of nrg is to discretize the conduction band of the bath logarithmically , leading to a tight - binding chain for which the hopping matrix elements between the successive sites fall off exponentially with @xmath123 , where @xmath124 is the discretization parameter , typically @xmath125 , and @xmath126 is the site index . this energy scale separation ensures that the problem can be solved iteratively by adding one site at a time and diagonalizing the enlarged system at each step , thereby resolving successively smaller and smaller energy scales . thus , by choosing the length @xmath127 of the chain so large that the corresponding energy scale @xmath128 is smaller than all other energies in the problem , all relevant energy scales can be resolved and treated properly . since the dimension of the hilbert space of the chain increases exponentially with the length of the chain , a truncation scheme has to be adopted , according to which only the lowest @xmath129 eigenstates of the chain are retained at each iteration . recently , it was shown that by also keeping track of discarded states a complete , but approximate , basis of states can be constructed @xcite . this can be used to calculate spectral functions which rigorously satisfy relevant sum rules @xcite . in order to obtain the transmission through the dot @xmath130 eq . ( [ transformula ] ) we follow @xcite and @xcite to compute the imaginary part of the local green functions at temperature @xmath3 , using the lehmann representation @xmath131 ) \nonumber \\ * & -\pi & \frac{e^{-\omega_n / t}}{z}\ , \langle n| d_{j\prime,\sigma}^\dag |m\rangle \ , \langle m| d_{j,\sigma } |n\rangle \ , \mathcal{\delta}(\omega+[\omega_m-\omega_n]),\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath132 , the many - body eigenstates @xmath133 and eigenenergies @xmath134 . since these are causal functions , the real part can be accessed by performing a kramers - kronig transformation @xcite . in the next three sections we present our results . in sec . [ resultsnon ] for the @xmath5 case . in sec . [ resultsgeneric ] we present the generic phase lapse scenario for interacting spin - polarized dots , compare to the mean - field results and investigate the role of finite temperatures . finally , in sec . [ resultsspin ] we study the spinful two - level dot . the large number of parameters makes it essential to analyze the transmission for the noninteracting case before considering the effect of two - particle interactions . we focus on @xmath21 . a closed expression for @xmath13 and @xmath135 ( for a fixed spin direction ) at @xmath5 can be obtained from eqs . ( [ transamp ] ) and ( [ transformula ] ) by replacing @xmath136 by @xmath137 , @xmath138^{1/2}}{\left [ \left ( \gamma_1^l \gamma_2^r + \gamma_2^l \gamma_1^r - 2 s \sqrt{\gamma_1^l \gamma_1^r \gamma_2^l \gamma_2^r}- \varepsilon_{1 } \varepsilon_{2}\right)^2 + \left ( \varepsilon_{1 } \gamma_2 + \varepsilon_{2 } \gamma_1 \right)^2\right]^{1/2 } } \ ; , \\ \label{u0phase } \mbox { } \hspace{-1.5 cm } \theta(v_g ) & = & \arctan { \left [ \frac{\varepsilon_1\gamma_2+\varepsilon_2\gamma_1}{\varepsilon_1\varepsilon _ 2-\left(\sqrt{\gamma_1^l\gamma_2^r}-s\sqrt{\gamma_1^r\gamma_2^l}\right)^2 } \right ] } \ , \mbox{mod } \ , \pi \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath139 . for later use we define @xmath140 for a fixed set of @xmath117 the @xmath4 dependence of @xmath13 and @xmath135 is shown in the first columns of figs.[fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] for @xmath141 . the results are qualitatively the same as those obtained for @xmath5 . for generic level - lead couplings @xmath117 the gate voltage dependence of eq . ( [ u0conduct ] ) in the limit of small and large @xmath142 is dominated by two peaks ( of height @xmath143 ) and a transmission zero . associated with the transmission zero is a @xmath0 phase lapse at the same gate voltage . the transmission zero ( and phase lapse ) follows from perfect destructive interference at a particular @xmath10 and in the limit of a strong asymmetry in the coupling of the two levels to the leads , @xmath144 or vice versa , can be understood as resulting from a fano anti - resonance @xcite . apparently the fano anti - resonance with vanishing transmission is robust if one goes away from this limit towards more symmetric level - lead couplings . across each of the transmission resonances @xmath1 increases roughly by @xmath0 as expected for a breit - wigner resonance . further details of @xmath13 and @xmath135 depend on @xmath145 . for @xmath70 the transmission zero ( and phase lapse ) is located between the two conductance peaks for all @xmath4 . for @xmath146 the resonance peak positions depend on the asymmetry of the @xmath117 and the separation of the peaks is small if the @xmath117 are close to l - r symmetry , that is close to @xmath147 . for l - r symmetric dots and @xmath148 the transmission zero ( and phase lapse ) disappears ( not shown in the figures ) . this is an example of a submanifold in parameter space with nongeneric behavior . a complete account of such cases ( which also remain nongeneric for @xmath6 ) is given in refs . @xcite and @xcite . as they require fine tuning these parameter sets are presumably irrelevant in connection with the experiments and we will here only briefly mention results obtained in such cases . for @xmath72 and fixed @xmath117 the position of the transmission zeros and phase lapses with respect to the cb peaks is different for small or large @xmath142 ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) . at small @xmath142 it is located between the two conductance peaks , whereas for large @xmath142 it lies on one of the outer sides of these peaks @xcite . in the crossover regime between these limiting cases the height of one of the peaks decreases , while the other becomes broader and splits up into two resonances separated by a minimum with non - vanishing conductance [ see fig . [ fig2 ] ( g ) and ( j ) ] . the crossover scale @xmath149 depends on the choice of @xmath117 . for large @xmath142 , @xmath8 has three local maxima , although the height of one of the maxima is significantly smaller than the height of the other two ( not shown in fig . [ fig2 ] ) . for fixed , asymmetric @xmath117 and @xmath146 the separation of the two conductance peaks for @xmath72 is significantly larger than for @xmath70 [ compare figs . [ fig1 ] ( a ) and [ fig2 ] ( a ) ] . it is important to note that for small @xmath142 essential features of the universal phase lapse regime established in the experiments are already found at @xmath5 : regardless of the sign @xmath145 for generic @xmath117 ( that is with the exception of a few cases with increased symmetry ) two transmission resonances are separated by a transmission zero and @xmath0 phase lapse . at @xmath5 the peak separation is too small and the shape of the @xmath10 dependence of the transmission and phase close to the peaks is qualitatively different from those observed experimentally ( namely lorentzian - like for the magnitude of the transmission , s - shaped for the phase ) . as we show next the latter problems do not arise for sufficiently large interaction @xmath2 , which in particular leads to an increased separation @xmath150 of the transmission peaks . in ref . @xcite it was shown that frg and nrg results for @xmath13 and @xmath135 agree quantitatively up to fairly large @xmath2 . for a generic set of couplings @xmath151 we present frg data for @xmath135 and @xmath13 together with the occupancies of the levels @xmath22 for different @xmath2 and @xmath4 in figs . [ fig1 ] ( @xmath70 ) and [ fig2 ] ( @xmath72 ) . increasing @xmath152 the separation of the transmission peaks in the limit of small and large @xmath142 increases and is eventually given by @xmath150 . even though this charging effect appears to be straightforward it is important to note that in particular the groundstate at small @xmath142 is highly correlated . this becomes explicit from the mapping of the present problem on a generalized single impurity anderson and kondo model as discussed in ref . an indication of strong correlation effects are the correlation - induced resonances of the transmission found in ref . @xcite , which we briefly mention below . with increasing @xmath2 , even at small @xmath142 the gate voltage dependence of @xmath135 across the transmission resonances becomes s - shaped and the resonances more lorentzian - like [ see third columns of figs . [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] ] . obviously , for @xmath70 the transmission zero and phase lapse remain between the two transmission peaks for all @xmath4 and @xmath2 ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . for @xmath72 this only holds for sufficiently small level spacings as , similar to the @xmath5 case , with increasing @xmath142 a crossover sets in to a regime in which the transmission zero and phase lapse are no longer between the peaks . analogously to the @xmath5 case , the crossover scale @xmath149 depends on the particular choice of @xmath117 . as can be seen from the second row of fig . [ fig2 ] ( the cb peaks at large @xmath2 have still almost equal height ) , with increasing @xmath152 , @xmath149 is pushed towards larger values . the coulomb interaction thus stabilizes the parameter regime of universal phase lapses . this shows that the effect of the coulomb interaction leading to universal @xmath0 phase lapses between separated cb peaks in a two - level dot is rather straightforward : for small @xmath142 the phase lapse and transmission zero are already present at @xmath5 , and the effect of finite @xmath2 is simply that the cb peaks become well separated because of charging effects . they also lead to a lorentzian - like lineshape of the peaks and an s - like variation of @xmath1 across them.the present scenario has to be contrasted to the one obtained for @xmath20 levels discussed in ref . @xcite . the generic appearance of @xmath153 transmission zeros and phase lapses separating the transmission peaks at small @xmath142 and @xmath5 is specific to the case with @xmath19 levels . for @xmath20 the number of transmission zeros and phase lapses at @xmath5 strongly depends on the parameters and the mechanism leading to universal @xmath0 phase lapses at sufficiently large @xmath2 ( at small @xmath142 ) is much more involved @xcite . this shows that although important insights can be gained from studying two - levels to achieve a _ complete _ understanding of the phase lapse scenario it is essential to study dots with coulomb interaction and more than two levels @xcite . and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=141 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=141 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=141 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.3%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=117 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=137 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=137 ] and @xmath142 that govern the gate voltage @xmath10 dependence of the magnitude of the transmission @xmath8 ( black ) , the transmission phase @xmath1 ( red ) and the level occupancies ( green and blue ) of a spin - polarized two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath154 and @xmath70 . for better visibility @xmath155 were shifted by @xmath156 . the depicted behavior is the generic one and in particular qualitatively independent of the actual choice of @xmath151 ( up to certain cases of increased symmetry ; for examples see the text ) . the behavior at @xmath141 is qualitatively the same as the one at @xmath5 . the results were obtained using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=137 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=141 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=141 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=141 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.3%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=117 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.2%,height=137 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=29.2%,height=137 ] , but for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0%,height=137 ] the lineshape of @xmath8 shows characteristic differences in the limits of small and large @xmath142 . in the universal regime at small @xmath142 and for sufficiently large @xmath152 the two cb peaks have equal width of order @xmath157 ( not @xmath158 ) and equal height which is consistent with the expectation that at each peak the transport occurs through both bare levels simultaneously . a similar behavior is observed in the experiments . in the mesoscopic regime ( @xmath159 ) the width of the @xmath160th peak is given by @xmath158 and the relative height @xmath161 by @xmath162 , independent of the value of @xmath2 . this effectively noninteracting lineshape can be understood from the gate voltage dependence of the effective level positions @xmath163 at the end of the frg flow . when one level is charged the effective level position of the other level is pushed downwards by @xmath2 . besides this , the gate voltage dependence of the @xmath163 remains linear , leading to two transmission peaks at gate voltages @xmath164 with separation @xmath150 , but with the same width and height as for @xmath5 . the hopping between the two effective levels generated in the frg flow is small and can be neglected . apart from the cb peaks , for sufficiently large @xmath152 the transmission shows additional features at small @xmath165 [ see figs . [ fig1 ] ( b ) , ( c ) , ( e ) and [ fig2 ] ( c ) ] . these are the correlation - induced resonances mentioned in the introduction , which have been found to be most pronounced at @xmath148 and in this case occur for interactions larger than a critical @xmath166 which depends on the @xmath117 and @xmath145 @xcite . their appearance indicates that the groundstate at small @xmath142 is strongly correlated ( as mentioned in ref . @xcite the correlation - induced resonances are not captured by a mean - field analysis ; see below ) . associated with the correlation - induced resonances is a sharp increase of @xmath1 [ see figs . [ fig1 ] ( b ) and ( e ) ] . at large @xmath152 the correlation - induced resonances are exponentially ( in @xmath152 ) sharp features that vanish quickly with increasing @xmath3 ( see below ) , which might be one of the reasons why up to now they have not been observed in experiments . the correlation - induced resonances are not directly linked to the universal phase lapse scenario . for increasing @xmath152 at fixed @xmath142 and decreasing @xmath142 at fixed @xmath152 we observe an increased tendency towards population inversion of the @xmath22 . we define that a population inversion occurs if ( 1 ) @xmath167 at a certain @xmath168 and ( 2 ) one @xmath22 has positive and one negative slope at @xmath168 so that the filling of one level causes a tendency for the other to empty . for large @xmath152 and small @xmath142 it is mainly the more strongly coupled level ( in figs . [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] , this is the level 2 shown in blue ) whose population increases across both cb peaks while it is depopulated in between . this behavior is reminiscent of the one discussed in the model with a broad and several narrow levels @xcite , where a relation between population inversion and phase lapse behavior was proposed . remarkably , for sufficiently large @xmath152 , we find population inversion even for small asymmetries @xmath169 ( which is only 1.5 in the example of figs.[fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] ) . we emphasize that despite this resemblance to the observation of ref . @xcite , the @xmath19 model is not appropriate to establish a general relation between the appearance of population inversions and @xmath0 phase lapses at small @xmath142 @xcite . while the latter are already present at @xmath5 , the former only develop with increasing @xmath2 [ compare figs . [ fig1 ] ( a ) , ( d ) or [ fig2 ] ( a ) , ( d ) to figs . [ fig1 ] ( c ) , ( f ) or [ fig2 ] ( c),(f ) ] . note that the gate voltage @xmath168 at which the population inversion occurs is generically _ not _ identical to the position of the phase lapse and transmission zero [ see figs . [ fig1 ] ( b ) , ( c ) , ( f ) and [ fig2 ] ( c ) , ( f ) ] @xcite . however , for l - r symmetric @xmath117 eq . ( [ t_lr ] ) ensures that if a population inversion occurs its position is identical to the one of the phase lapse and transmission zero . as can be seen in figs . [ fig1 ] ( c ) , ( f ) and [ fig2 ] ( c ) , ( f ) for small @xmath142 and large @xmath152 the @xmath22 show a rather strong gate voltage dependence between the cb peaks . nevertheless the total dot occupancy @xmath170 is only weakly @xmath10 dependent and close to 1 within the entire cb valley . this is reminiscent of the plateau - like occupancy in the local moment regime of the single impurity anderson model showing the kondo effect . as discussed in ref . @xcite a relation to this model can indeed be established . we note in passing that with the exception of the nongeneric case of l - r symmetric @xmath117 , @xmath70 and @xmath148 , the @xmath22 are continuous functions of @xmath10 . in refs . @xcite and @xcite golosov and gefen ( gg ) analyze the phase lapse scenario of the spin - polarized interacting two - level dot within the mean - field approximation . however , they anticipated themselves that quantum fluctuations not captured in the mean - field approach could be important . examples of this had been pointed out already in refs . @xcite and @xcite . thus , gg emphasized that the effects of such fluctuations on their results need to be studied in subsequent work . the present subsection is devoted to this task . and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.5%,height=143 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=43.5%,height=143 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.5%,height=173 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=43.5%,height=173 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.5%,height=143 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=43.5%,height=143 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.5%,height=173 ] and different @xmath171 moving from ggs `` phase '' 2 into `` phase '' 1 . figures ( e)-(h ) are for constant @xmath171 and different @xmath172 moving from ggs `` phase 3 '' into `` phase 1 '' . the inset in fig . ( e ) shows a zoom in of the gate voltage region around the phase lapse . for a detailed comparison to the mean - field results see the text . the results were obtained at @xmath21 using the truncated frg.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=43.5%,height=173 ] gg consider the subspace of level - lead couplings defined by @xmath173 . performing a unitary transformation on the dot states the part of the hamiltonian eq . ( [ generalham ] ) containing dot operators can be transformed to ( see refs . @xcite and @xcite ) @xmath174 \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the transformed operators and parameters indicated by a hat . the change of basis leads to a direct hopping @xmath175 between the transformed levels . we here focus on the relative sign @xmath176 . gg then introduce the two new dimensionless parameters @xmath172 and @xmath171 as @xmath177 and @xmath178 . varying @xmath172 and @xmath171 gg investigate the phase lapse behavior for fixed level spacing ( in the new basis ) @xmath179 and interaction @xmath180 . as the parameters in the new basis are rather complicated combinations of the original ones , the variation of @xmath171 and @xmath172 corresponds to the variation of the @xmath117 ( within the above specified subspace ) , @xmath4 and even @xmath145 . our simple picture that increasing the level spacing @xmath4 of the untransformed model leads from the universal to the mesoscopic regime can not easily made explicit using the parameters of gg . to make the comparison of our results to the mean - field study definite we nevertheless follow the steps of gg . varying @xmath181 at @xmath176 we move around in the right part of what is called the `` phase diagram '' by gg ( fig . 4 of ref . @xcite ) . in fig . [ fig3 ] we show the behavior of @xmath8 and @xmath1 varying @xmath171 at fixed @xmath172 [ figs . [ fig3 ] ( a)-(d ) ] and @xmath172 at fixed @xmath171 [ figs.[fig3 ] ( e)-(h ) ] , respectively . in the first case , upon increasing @xmath171 at constant @xmath182 , we move from ggs `` phase 2 '' , ( red in fig . 4 of ref . @xcite ) , with the transmission zero and phase lapse outside the two cb peaks , into `` phase 1 '' ( blue in fig . 4 of ref . @xcite ) , with the transmission zero and phase lapse between the peaks . the mean - field approximation correctly captures the presence of these two regimes . we find a smooth crossover between them ( which is why we prefer the notion of different `` regimes '' rather than `` phases '' ) : the @xmath10 value at which the transmission zero and phase lapse occur _ smoothly _ crosses from lying outside the right cb peak to lying between the two cb peaks . this is similar to the smooth crossover we observe in the @xmath72 case of the untransformed model when moving from the mesoscopic to the universal regime ( see columns of fig . [ fig2 ] ) . for fixed @xmath183 and increasing @xmath172 we move from `` phase 3 '' ( green in fig . 4 of ref . @xcite ) into `` phase 1 '' . in contrast to the mean - field approximation where an abrupt transition from `` phase 3 '' to `` phase 1 '' occurs , figs . [ fig3 ] ( e)-(h ) show a rather smooth evolution . the mean - field `` phase 3 '' is characterized by discontinuous population switching and a phase lapse between the cb peaks which , surprisingly , is smaller than @xmath0 @xcite . furthermore , in this parameter regime the mean - field results show no transmission zero , as discussed in ref . however , from figs . [ fig3 ] ( e)-(h ) it is apparent that `` phase 3 '' , is an artifact of the mean - field approximation : upon taking fluctuations into account via frg , the @xmath0 phase lapse and the transmission zero are found to remain in the cb valley . the evolution with increasing @xmath172 is similar to the @xmath70 case of the untransformed model when the level spacing is increased at fixed @xmath117 ( see the second and third columns of fig . [ fig1 ] ) . `` phase 3 '' then corresponds to the parameter regime with small level spacing and a sizable @xmath152 in which correlations are of particular importance leading e.g. to the correlation - induced resonances [ see figs . [ fig3 ] ( e)-(h ) ] . that the mean - field approximation fails to properly describe this strongly correlated regime is not surprising and has been recognized earlier @xcite . in ref . @xcite a connection between the small @xmath4 regime of the present model and the local moment ( kondo ) regime of the single - impurity anderson model was established . thus , the artifacts of the mean - field approximation for the spinless two - level dot are reincarnations of the the well - known artifacts it produces when applied to the anderson model in the local moment regime . upon taking fluctuations into account , the discontinuities of the @xmath155 in `` phase 3 '' are washed out . the only choice of parameters for which we find discontinuous behavior is the one with l - r symmetric @xmath117 , @xmath70 and @xmath148 , a case which was already identified as being nongeneric @xcite . any arbitrarily small deviation from these conditions leads to a continuous gate voltage dependence of @xmath155 . for parameters close to the nongeneric point the change in @xmath22 at first sight appears to be rather sharp and an extremely high resolution in @xmath10 is required to identify the behavior as continuous . the fact that the mean - field treatment at @xmath6 and small level spacings incorrectly causes the transmission zero to disappear and the corresponding phase lapse to become smaller than @xmath0 is its most consequential problem . by generating such features , the mean - field treatment masks the very simple scenario that emerges upon properly including fluctuations : for increasing @xmath2 , the @xmath0 phase lapse and transmission zero found for small @xmath142 at @xmath5 remain in the cb valley , while the transmission peaks become well separated , lorentzian - like and the phase acquires an s - shape across the resonances . we next investigate how the phase and magnitude of the transmission are affected by finite temperatures . to this end , we use the new fdm - nrg algorithm recently proposed in ref . @xcite . in fig . [ fig4 ] we show nrg data for @xmath13 and @xmath135 at different @xmath3 . we consider generic level - lead couplings @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 ( universal regime ) as well as @xmath188 ( mesoscopic regime ) . as expected , with increasing temperature the sharp @xmath0 phase lapses are gradually smeared out , the transmission zero vanishes and the change of @xmath1 at the phase lapse becomes smaller than @xmath0 . furthermore , the cb peaks decrease and broaden . for @xmath188 and @xmath72 [ fig . [ fig4 ] ( d ) ] the phase lapse lies outside the cb peaks and outside the window of gate voltages shown . and @xmath135 obtained by nrg for @xmath189 , @xmath185 for @xmath186 and in the universal ( @xmath187 ) and the mesoscopic ( @xmath188 ) regime . we used the nrg parameters @xmath190 and @xmath191.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.5%,height=166 ] and @xmath135 obtained by nrg for @xmath189 , @xmath185 for @xmath186 and in the universal ( @xmath187 ) and the mesoscopic ( @xmath188 ) regime . we used the nrg parameters @xmath190 and @xmath191.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=166 ] and @xmath135 obtained by nrg for @xmath189 , @xmath185 for @xmath186 and in the universal ( @xmath187 ) and the mesoscopic ( @xmath188 ) regime . we used the nrg parameters @xmath190 and @xmath191.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.5%,height=196 ] and @xmath135 obtained by nrg for @xmath189 , @xmath185 for @xmath186 and in the universal ( @xmath187 ) and the mesoscopic ( @xmath188 ) regime . we used the nrg parameters @xmath190 and @xmath191.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=196 ] in the mesoscopic regime [ figs . [ fig4 ] ( b ) and ( d ) ] the explicit temperature dependence of the green function entering eq . ( [ transamp ] ) via eq.([transformula ] ) is rather weak and the temperature dependence of the cb peaks and the phase lapse can be understood from the behavior in the noninteracting model , but with level spacing @xmath150 . for small @xmath3 the height @xmath192 of the @xmath160th cb peak scales as @xmath193 and the width @xmath194 of the phase lapse as @xmath195 @xcite . the relevant scale for sizable temperature effects in the peak height is thus @xmath158 while it is @xmath150 in the smearing of the phase lapses . since we have chosen @xmath196 a reduction of @xmath161 is visible for temperatures at which the phase lapse is still fairly sharp [ see fig . [ fig4 ] ( b ) ] . due to the importance of correlation effects at small @xmath142 , the @xmath3 dependence of @xmath13 and @xmath135 in the universal regime is different from the noninteracting case . here the explicit temperature dependence of @xmath197 is much stronger and can not be neglected . the resulting @xmath3 dependence of @xmath13 and @xmath135 is shown in figs . [ fig4 ] ( a ) and ( c ) . a comparison to fig.[fig4 ] ( b ) shows that in the universal regime the smearing of the phase lapse sets in at a lower energy scale than in the mesoscopic regime . this scale depends on the relative sign @xmath145 of the level - lead hopping matrix elements [ compare figs . [ fig4 ] ( a ) and ( c ) ] . furthermore , in contrast to the mesoscopic regime the scales on which the cb peaks and the phase lapse are affected by temperature are comparable . a more detailed investigation of the temperature dependence in the universal regime , which also discusses the fate of the correlation - induced resonances , is beyond the scope of the present work and is left as subject for future studies . , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.5%,height=166 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=166 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.5%,height=196 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=196 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.5%,height=166 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=166 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.5%,height=196 ] , but for @xmath198 and @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=196 ] we finally investigate the effect of the spin degree of freedom on the discussed phase lapse scenario , at @xmath21 . in figs . [ fig5 ] ( @xmath70 , @xmath199 ) and [ fig6 ] ( @xmath72 , @xmath198 ) we show frg data for the evolution of @xmath13 , @xmath135 and @xmath200 ( for a fixed spin direction ) with increasing @xmath4 for a generic @xmath201 . the overall dependence of @xmath135 on @xmath4 is similar to the one observed in the spinless case ( compare to figs . [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] ) . in particular , the behavior at small @xmath142 appears to be almost unaffected by the presence of the spin degree of freedom [ figs . [ fig5 ] ( a ) , ( b ) and [ fig6 ] ( a ) , ( b ) ] . for large @xmath142 [ figs . [ fig5 ] ( d ) and [ fig6 ] ( d ) ] the transmission resonances are located at odd average total filling of the two - level dot indicated by shoulders in the @xmath22 [ figs . [ fig5 ] ( d ) and [ fig6 ] ( d ) ] . at these fillings and for sufficiently large @xmath152 the kondo effect is active and the resonances can not be regarded as lorentzian - like cb peaks . instead they show a plateau - like shape known from the spinful single - level dot ( see ref . @xcite and references therein ) . across the kondo plateaus of @xmath8 the s - shaped increase of the phase is interrupted by a shoulder at @xmath202 as expected for the kondo effect @xcite . it would be very interesting to study how each of the kondo plateaus of @xmath8 with increasing temperature crosses over to two cb peaks and the phase behaves in the generated cb valley . this question is left for future investigations . the behavior of the phase in the presence of the kondo effect was experimentally investigated at temperatures comparable to the kondo temperature @xcite , and much below the kondo temperature @xcite . as we study the zero temperature case it is proper to compare our calculations to the measurements at low temperatures . indeed fig . [ fig6 ] ( c ) for intermediate @xmath142 qualitatively reproduces the experimental results at low temperature as shown in fig . 3 c of ref.@xcite . in particular the increase of the phase by more then @xmath0 and the absence of clearly developed kondo plateaus are reproduced . in fig . [ fig5 ] ( a ) we left out the frg data around @xmath203 as for these gate voltages some of the components of the flowing two - particle vertex become large . this indicates the breakdown of our present truncation scheme @xcite and the results for @xmath8 , @xmath1 and @xmath22 become unreliable . for an explicit comparison to nrg data of @xmath8 see fig . [ fig7 ] ( a ) . we note in passing that for @xmath70 correlation - induced resonances occur also in the model with spin [ fig . [ fig5 ] ( a ) ] @xcite . in fig . [ fig7 ] we compare frg and nrg results for l - r symmetric level - lead couplings . the computational resources required to obtain nrg data away from l - r symmetry become large and such data are not required for the aim of the present paper . we can then use eq . ( [ t_lr ] ) and must only compute the occupancies @xmath22 , which is numerically less demanding . for @xmath204 ( as exclusively shown ) it is only the absence of the correlation - induced resonances for @xmath70 [ compare figs . [ fig5 ] ( a ) and [ fig7 ] ( a ) ] which is different from the results of the generic @xmath151 shown in figs . [ fig5 ] and [ fig6 ] . with the exception of the @xmath205 regime in the case of small @xmath4 and @xmath70 the frg and nrg data compare quite well . in this case we only show the frg data for @xmath8 as the results for the phase and occupancies become rather erratic . the reason for the breakdown of the currently used truncated frg is explained in refs . @xcite and @xcite and is related to the fact that at small @xmath4 and small @xmath10 the correlations in effect become extremely large . , @xmath135 and @xmath200 ( per spin direction ) in the universal ( small @xmath142 ) and mesoscopic regime ( large @xmath142 ) of a spinful two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath199 and @xmath206 . in ( a ) the frg data for @xmath135 and @xmath200 around @xmath203 are not shown . already the unsatisfactory comparison between frg and nrg for @xmath8 indicate that the frg becomes unreliable in this regime . for more details on this , see the text . for the nrg parameters we used @xmath207 , @xmath208 for @xmath70 and @xmath209 for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=166 ] , @xmath135 and @xmath200 ( per spin direction ) in the universal ( small @xmath142 ) and mesoscopic regime ( large @xmath142 ) of a spinful two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath199 and @xmath206 . in ( a ) the frg data for @xmath135 and @xmath200 around @xmath203 are not shown . already the unsatisfactory comparison between frg and nrg for @xmath8 indicate that the frg becomes unreliable in this regime . for more details on this , see the text . for the nrg parameters we used @xmath207 , @xmath208 for @xmath70 and @xmath209 for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=166 ] , @xmath135 and @xmath200 ( per spin direction ) in the universal ( small @xmath142 ) and mesoscopic regime ( large @xmath142 ) of a spinful two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath199 and @xmath206 . in ( a ) the frg data for @xmath135 and @xmath200 around @xmath203 are not shown . already the unsatisfactory comparison between frg and nrg for @xmath8 indicate that the frg becomes unreliable in this regime . for more details on this , see the text . for the nrg parameters we used @xmath207 , @xmath208 for @xmath70 and @xmath209 for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=196 ] , @xmath135 and @xmath200 ( per spin direction ) in the universal ( small @xmath142 ) and mesoscopic regime ( large @xmath142 ) of a spinful two - level dot at @xmath21 . the parameters are @xmath199 and @xmath206 . in ( a ) the frg data for @xmath135 and @xmath200 around @xmath203 are not shown . already the unsatisfactory comparison between frg and nrg for @xmath8 indicate that the frg becomes unreliable in this regime . for more details on this , see the text . for the nrg parameters we used @xmath207 , @xmath208 for @xmath70 and @xmath209 for @xmath72.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.5%,height=196 ] in the present paper we studied the appearance of phase lapses in an interacting two - level quantum dot considering the entire parameter space using nrg and a truncated frg scheme . as a starting point we briefly discussed the noninteracting case at temperature @xmath21 and pointed out that for generic level - lead couplings , that is up to cases with increased symmetry , essential features of the universal phase lapse scenario are already established at @xmath5 . for single - particle level spacings @xmath4 small compared to the level broadenings @xmath158 the transmission is characterized by two transmission peaks of equal width with a transmission zero and an associated @xmath0 phase lapse between them ( universal regime ) . for large @xmath142 at @xmath5 the appearance or not of a transmission zero and phase lapse between the two transmission peaks depends on the relative sign @xmath145 of the level - lead couplings ( mesoscopic regime ) . within a spinless model we have shown that the separation of the two transmission peaks increases linearly with the interaction @xmath2 while the @xmath0 phase lapse and transmission zero remain in the valley between them . furthermore , with increasing @xmath2 the increase of the phase across the peaks takes an s - shape and the peaks become lorentzian - like , thus assuming shapes resembling those observed experimentally @xcite . for @xmath72 and increasing @xmath4 , a crossover occurs to a regime in which the @xmath0 phase lapse and transmission zero lies outside the two cb peaks . the crossover scale @xmath149 increases with increasing interaction and thus the coulomb repulsion stabilizes the universal phase lapse behavior . we have investigated the relation between phase lapses and population inversions of the level occupancies @xmath22 . we have shown that a mean - field treatment of the present problem correctly reproduces certain features of the behavior discussed above , but is not able to produce the universal phase lapse scenario at small @xmath142 due to artifacts of the approximation such as a phase lapse by less than @xmath0 @xcite and a vanishing of the transmission zero @xcite . furthermore , the discontinuous gate voltage dependence of the @xmath22 found in the mean - field approximation turned out to be an artifact . next , we studied how the phase lapse behavior is affect by temperatures @xmath18 . the universal phase lapse ( at small @xmath142 ) is smeared out but remains visible for not too large @xmath3 . in the mesoscopic regime with @xmath210 the smearing of the phase lapse and the decrease of the cb peaks can be understood in detail in analogy to the noninteracting case . for @xmath211 correlations are more important and a detailed understanding of the temperature dependence of the transmission @xmath56 requires further studies . the phase lapse behavior in both the universal and mesoscopic regimes is also stable if the spin degree of freedom is included . for sufficiently large @xmath152 in this case the kondo effect is active at odd average dot filling , leading to minor modifications of the scenario discussed above . in particular , at large @xmath142 the @xmath21 transmission peaks are kondo plateaus rather than lorentzian - like cb peaks . across these kondo plateaus the phase shows a shoulder at @xmath202 . in contrast , the behavior at small @xmath142 appears to be almost unaffected by the spin degree . a study of the combined effect of finite temperature and spin is left for future work . we thank r. berkovits , p. brouwer , y. gefen , l. glazman , d. golosov , m. heiblum , j. imry , v. kashcheyevs , j. knig , f. marquardt , m. pustilnik , h. schoeller , k. schnhammer , and a. silva for valuable discussions . this work was supported in part , for vm , by the dfg through sfb602 ; for th , aw and jvd by the dfg through sfb631 and de730/3 - 2 , and also by spintronics rtn ( hprn - ct-2002 - 00302 ) , nsf ( phy99 - 07949 ) and dip - h.2.1 ; and for yo by dip - h.2.1 , bsf and the humboldt foundation . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: outer layers of low - mass stars are unstable to thermal convection due to a rapid increase in opacity resulting from the partial ionization of hydrogen and the dissociation of h@xmath0 . below @xmath1 , main sequence stellar interiors are theorized to become fully convective along the main sequence @xcite . largely characterized by near - adiabatic convection , fully convective stars are considered the simplest stars to describe from a theoretical perspective . in fact , properties of fully convective stars predicted by stellar structure models are largely insensitive to input variables ( e.g. , the mixing length parameter , @xmath2 ) and input physics ( e.g. , nuclear reaction rates , element diffusion ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? discovery of significant radius discrepancies between observations and stellar model predictions for fully convective stars therefore presents a curious puzzle ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? evidence indicating that stellar structure models can not properly predict radii of fully convective stars has been gathered from studies of detached eclipsing binaries ( debs ) . masses and radii can be measured for stars in debs with precisions below 3% provided the observations are of high quality and analyses are performed with care @xcite . presently , there are five debs with at least one fully convective component whose mass and radius has been quoted with precision below 3% : kepler-38 @xcite , kepler-16 @xcite , lspm j1112 + 7626 @xcite , koi-126 @xcite , and cm draconis ( hereafter cm dra ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? of these systems , only the fully convective stars of koi-126 can be accurately characterized by stellar evolution models @xcite . every other fully convective star appears to have a radius inflated compared to model predictions . most consequential are the inflated radii of the stars in cm dra . historically , the stars of cm dra are _ the _ fully convective stars against which to benchmark stellar models . as such , cm dra has been well - studied and rigorously characterized . over the years , discrepancies between model radii of cm dra and those determined from observations has grown . initial modeling efforts were optimistic that agreement could be achieved @xcite , but disagreement was quickly identified with the introduction of more sophisticated models @xcite and more precise mass and radius measurements @xcite . this disparity has been increased , yet again , with converging reports of the system s metallicity @xcite . strong magnetic fields maintained by tidal synchronization are presently considered the leading culprit producing the observed radius discrepancies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? magnetic activity indicators , such as soft x - ray emission , ca ii h & k emission , and h@xmath3 emission , appear to correlate with radius inflation @xcite , providing evidence in favor of the magnetic hypothesis . theoretical investigations also support a magnetic origin of radius inflation for main sequence deb stars @xcite . despite significant evidence in favor of the magnetic hypothesis , several clues suggest otherwise . discovery of the hierarchical triple koi-126 in 2011 introduced a second pair of well - characterized fully convective stars whose masses and radii were measured with better than 2% precision . stellar evolution models are able to reproduce the properties of koi-126 ( b , c ) , as previously mentioned , based only on inferred properties from the more massive primary star @xcite . with orbital and stellar properties similar to cm dra , koi-126 ( b , c ) presents a sharp contrast to known modeling disagreements . adding to the evidence mounting against the magnetic hypothesis , fully convective stars in kepler-16 , kepler-38 , and lspm - j1112 + 7626 show inflated radii despite existing in long period ( @xmath4 17days ) systems . the fact that most inflated stars in debs appeared to exist in short period systems was proffered as strong circumstantial evidence in support of the magnetic hypothesis . however , only a few deb systems were known , all of which had short orbital periods due to inherent observational biases . with the influx of data from long time baseline photometric monitoring campaigns , including _ kepler _ and mearth , fully convective stars in long period debs have been shown to have inflated radii . of course , the presence of inflated low - mass stars in long period systems is only contradictory if the inflated stars are slowly rotating ( @xmath5kms@xmath6 ) . @xcite find that lspm j1112 + 7626 a rotates with a period of 65days , from which we infer an age of order 9gyr assuming the gyrochronology relation of @xcite . this result requires confirmation , but if confirmed , it would be seem likely that the fully convective , low - mass secondary is slowly rotating . a rotation period has also been measured for the primary star in kepler-16 @xcite . it was determined to be rotating with a period of nearly 36days , close to the pseudo - synchronization rotation period @xcite . if we assume the fully convective secondary has a similar rotation period ( from pseudo - synchronization ) , then it would have @xmath7 kms@xmath6 , well below the empirical velocity threshold thought to be required for fully convective stars to maintain a strong magnetic field @xcite . therefore , in at least two cases , it appears that slowly rotating fully convective stars exhibit inflated radii . in this paper , we extend our on - going investigation into the magnetic origin of inflated low - mass stellar radii , initiated in @xcite , to fully convective stars . a brief overview of how we include magnetic effects in our models is presented in section [ sec : dmestar ] . detailed analysis of two well - characterized debs , kepler-16 and cm dra , is given in section [ sec : ind_deb ] with a discussion of the results in section [ sec : disc ] . section [ sec : disc ] also provides comparisons with previous studies and a careful examination of the magnetic hypothesis . a summary of key results and conclusions is then given in section [ sec : summ ] . stellar evolution models used in this investigation are from the dartmouth magnetic evolutionary stellar tracks and relations ( dmestar ) program . dmestar was developed as an extension of the dartmouth stellar evolution program ( dsep ; * ? ? ? * ) , a descendant of the yale rotating evolution code @xcite . the magnetic version of the dartmouth stellar evolution code is described in @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . we refer the reader to these papers for a thorough overview . the pertinent aspects of the standard , non - magnetic stellar evolution code for modeling fully convective stars are : the equation of state ( eos ) and the surface boundary conditions . all fully convective stars are modeled with the freeeos , a publicly available eos code written by alan irwin and based on the free energy minimization technique . we call freeeos in the eos4 configuration to provide a balance between numerical accuracy and computation time . with this eos , we are able to reliably model stars with masses above the hydrogen burning minimum mass @xcite . surface boundary conditions are prescribed using phoenix ames - cond model atmospheres @xcite . atmosphere structures are used to define the initial gas pressure for our model envelope integration . above @xmath8 , the gas pressure is determined an optical depth where @xmath9 . however , below @xmath8 , the regime where convection is sufficiently non - adiabatic extends deeper into the star @xcite . thus , we specify our boundary conditions at the optical depth @xmath10 in this mass regime . for the present work , we have extended the initial metallicity grid of model atmosphere structures @xcite by interpolating within the original set of structures . care was taken to ensure that the interpolation produced reliable results and that no discontinuities in either @xmath11 or the starting temperature were introduced . this will be discussed in a future publication . a set of atmosphere structures with finer metallicity spacing allows for more accurate predictions of stellar properties at metallicities that lie between the original grid spacings . implementation of a magnetic perturbation is described in detail by @xcite and @xcite . we abstain from providing a mathematical description and refer the reader to those papers . however , it is beneficial to review multiple variations on our basic formulation that arose in @xcite . these variations take the form of different magnetic field strength radial profiles and what we have called different `` dynamos . '' the latter refers not to a detailed dynamo treatment , but a conceptual framework that concerns from where we assume the magnetic field sources its energy . our treatment of magneto - convection depends on how we assume the magnetic field is generated . assuming that rotation drives the dynamo , as in a standard shell dynamo @xcite , leads to perturbations consistent with the idea that magnetic fields can stabilize a fluid against thermal convection ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this assumption forms the basis of our magneto - convection formulation @xcite . however , permissible magnetic field strengths can reach upward of 6 kg at the model photosphere with exact upper limits determined by equipartition with the thermal gas pressure . this also results in interior magnetic field strengths that can grow nearly without limit owing to large internal gas pressures . models that rely on stabilizing convection with a magnetic field are hereafter referred to as having `` rotational dynamos . '' the form of the perturbation used for a star with an assumed rotational dynamo is not necessarily valid in all stellar mass regimes . this is particularly true in fully convective stars , where the interface region between the radiative core and convective envelope is thought to disappear . to address this , and the problem that magnetic fields in the rotational dynamo can grow without limit , we introduced a `` turbulent dynamo '' mechanism @xcite . this formulation assumes that the magnetic field strength at a given grid point within the model receives its energy from the kinetic energy of convecting material . therefore , the local alfvn velocity can not exceed the local convective velocity . it is a simple approach developed to address zeroth - order effects within the already simplified convection framework of mixing length theory . for low - mass stars , this methods places an upper limit of around 3 kg for surface magnetic field strengths , consistent with observed upper limits of average surface magnetic field strengths @xcite . although rotation is still required for turbulent dynamo action @xcite , magnetic field strengths are more sensitive to properties of convection . we note , again , that the term `` dynamo '' is used loosely . our formulations of magneto - convection do not rigorously solve the equations of magnetohydrodynamics . instead , we seek to capture physically relevant effects on stellar structure in a phenomenological manner consistent with actual dynamo processes . each of the above descriptions rely equally on a prescribed magnetic field strength profile within the star . models of the `` dipole radial field '' variety are the standard sort introduced in @xcite . this profile is characteristic of a magnetic field generated by a single current loop centered on the stellar tachocline . given a surface magnetic field strength , the radial profile of the magnetic field is determined by calculating the peak magnetic field strength at the tachocline . lacking a tachocline , we define fully convective stars to have a peak magnetic field strength at 15% of the stellar radius ( @xmath12 ) . this is loosely based on results from three - dimensional magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) models of fully convective stars @xcite . mhd models indicate that the magnetic field reaches a maximum around @xmath13 @xcite . note that this maximum is not a sharply defined peak in the magnetic field strength profile since the profile is based largely on equipartition of the magnetic field with convective flows . still , we adopt @xmath14 knowing this caveat , which we address in a moment . the rest of the interior magnetic field is then calculated by assuming the magnetic field strength falls off steeply towards the core and surface of the star . explicitly , @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the prescribed surface magnetic field strength , @xmath17 is the radius of the tachocline normalized to the total stellar radius , and @xmath18 is the radius within the star normalized to the total stellar radius . to increase the peak magnetic field strength for a given surface magnetic field strength , we implemented a gaussian profile ( section 4.4.1 in * ? ? ? the peak magnetic field strength is still defined at the tachocline in partially convective stars and at @xmath19 in fully convective stars . however , instead of a power - law decline of the interior magnetic field strength from the peak , the peak was set as the center of a gaussian distribution . thus , @xmath20,\ ] ] where @xmath21 controls the width of the gaussian and @xmath22 is defined with respect to the surface magnetic field strength . the width of the gaussian depends on the depth of the convection zone . deeper convection zones have a wider gaussian profile compared to stars with thin convective envelopes @xcite . hereafter , we will refer to these as `` gaussian radial profile '' models . note that this prescription has no physical motivation beyond providing stronger interior magnetic fields . we define a third radial profile for this study : a `` constant @xmath23 radial profile . '' when a turbulent dynamo is invoked , the magnetic field radial profiles described above can cause the alfvn velocity to exceed the convective velocity within the model interior . this happens quite easily in models of fully convective stars where the peak magnetic field strength is defined deep within the model . as a result , perturbed convective velocities become imaginary leading convergence problems when solving the equations of mixing length theory . if we assume that kinetic energy in convective flows generates the local magnetic field , an alfvn velocity exceeding the convective velocity will lead to a decaying magnetic field strength . eventually , equipartition will be reached . we avoid iterating to a solution by using a profile that assumes a constant ratio of magnetic field to the equipartition value , @xmath24 , where @xmath25 . this factor , @xmath23 , was introduced in @xcite as a means of comparing reduced mixing length models ( i.e. , * ? ? ? * ) to our turbulent dynamo models . perturbations to the equations of mixing length theory are now expressed as functions of @xmath23 . removing energy from convection slows convective flows such that @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the convective velocity prior to losing energy to the magnetic field . we restrict @xmath28 to avoid imaginary convective velocities . reduction of convective velocity causes a significant reduction in convective energy flux since @xmath29 . steeping of the background temperature gradient , @xmath30 , occurs as radiation attempts to transport additional energy . this increase , @xmath31 , over the non - perturbed temperature gradient is @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the characteristic squared velocity of an unimpeded convecting bubble over a pressure scale height . this is a sort of terminal convective velocity , where @xmath34 is the local acceleration due to gravity , @xmath2 is the convective mixing length parameter , @xmath35 is the pressure scale height , and @xmath36 is the coefficient of thermal expansion . resulting effects on convection likely represent an upper limit on the effects of such a dynamo mechanism in inhibiting thermal convection . note that when using this radial profile and dynamo mechanism , modifications to the schwarzschild criterion ( i.e. , the formalism outlined in * ? ? ? * ) are neglected . we have chosen to study the debs kepler-16 and cm dra in detail . lspm j1112 + 7626 was not modeled in detail because it lacks a proper metallicity estimate required for a careful comparison with models . kepler-38 was also not selected as initial comparisons suggest that there may be some issues with modeling the primary . finally , koi-126 has been modeled in detail previously and does not appear to require magnetic fields @xcite . as we will show below , magnetic models of kepler-16 b and cm dra produce similar results that can be generalized to all fully convective main sequence stars in debs . l c c d11 mass ( @xmath37 ) & @xmath38 & @xmath39 + b12 mass ( @xmath37 ) & @xmath40 & @xmath41 + radius ( @xmath42 ) & @xmath43 & @xmath44 + @xmath45 ( k ) & @xmath46 & @xmath47 + @xmath48 $ ] & + age ( gyr ) & [ tab : kep_16_prop ] report of the first circumbinary exoplanet was announced by @xcite with their study of kepler-16b . while the planet is interesting in its own right , what made the finding even more interesting was that the two host stars formed a long - period low - mass deb . this enabled a precise characterization of the stars and circumstellar environment . kepler-16 contains a k - dwarf primary with a fully - convective m - dwarf secondary in a 41 day orbit . properties of the two stars are listed in table [ tab : kep_16_prop ] . in a follow - up investigation , @xcite estimated the composition and age of the system . an age of @xmath49gyr was estimated using gyrochronology and an age - activity relation based on ca ii emission . spectroscopic analysis of the primary revealed the system has a solar - like metallicity of [ fe / h ] @xmath50dex . they also compared properties of the kepler-16 stars to predictions of stellar evolution models . @xcite model predictions agreed with properties of the primary at the given age . however , the radius of the fully convective secondary star was larger than model predictions by @xmath51 . independent confirmation of the stellar properties and model disagreements was provided by @xcite , who found a best fit age of 1 gyr with [ fe / h ] @xmath52 using dartmouth models . radial velocity confirmation of the component masses within @xmath53was later obtained by @xcite . they found masses that were 5% lower than the original masses @xcite . of particular note , is that mass ratio is different between the two studies . @xcite attempted to pin - point the origin of this discrepancy , but were unable to do so with complete confidence . despite the disagreement , the spectroscopic masses largely confirm that masses derived using a photometric - dynamical model are reliable @xcite . however , a slight mass difference significantly alters comparisons with stellar evolution models . that is , if we assume that the derived masses do not heavily influence the radius and effective temperature predictions . we therefore opt to treat the two different mass estimates independently to assess how these differences affect our modeling efforts . hereafter , masses originally quoted by @xcite will be referred to as masses , whereas the revised values of @xcite will be referred to as masses . table [ tab : kep_16_prop ] lists masses measured by each group . we first focus our attention on kepler-16 a , as the analysis will directly influence our analysis of the secondary . plotted in figure [ fig : kep16_a_nmag ] are non - magnetic dartmouth models computed at the measured masses of the primary provided by and . three separate tracks are illustrated for each mass estimate , corresponding to [ fe / h ] @xmath54 , and @xmath55 @xcite . in this figure , the horizontal shaded region highlights the observed radius with associated @xmath56 uncertainties . ages are determined by noting where the mass tracks are located within the bounds of the empirical radius constraints . similarly , we confirm that when the mass track has the required radius it also has an appropriate effective temperature in figure [ fig : kep16_a_nmag](b ) . given a primary mass from , we find that standard stellar evolution models match the stellar radius and temperature at an age of @xmath57gyr . when the model radius equals the precise empirical radius ( @xmath58 ) , the associated model effective temperature is 4354 k , which is within 17k of the spectroscopic effective temperature @xcite . we note that this age is also consistent with the estimated age from @xcite . agreement between models and observations does not guarantee the validity of the masses over the masses . in fact , this agreement is rather expected . the effective temperature and metallicity for the primary were determined using spectroscopy made easy ( * ? ? ? * hereafter sme ) , which relies on theoretical stellar atmospheres . our models also rely on theoretical atmospheres , although phoenix model atmospheres , used by our models , adopt a different line list database ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) than the theoretical atmospheres used by sme ( vald : vienna atomic line database ; * ? ? ? * ) . in a sense , the fact that we find such good agreement with the effective temperature for a given @xmath59 and metallicity ( i.e. , those of kepler-16 a ) may be a better test of the agreement between different stellar atmosphere models rather than a test of the interior evolution models . what is encouraging , is that we derive appropriate stellar properties at an age consistent with gyrochronology and age - activity relations @xcite . age consistency is not ensured by agreement between stellar atmosphere structures . our previous discussion may be erroneous if we adopt an incorrect mass . suggest this is the case . the effect of adopting the lower b12 masses is displayed in figure [ fig : kep16_a_nmag ] . assuming the radius measurement remains constant , we derive an age of @xmath60gyr for the primary star . the effective temperature associated with the model also appears too cool compared to observations at the measured metallicity ( @xmath61dex ) . relief is found by lowering the metallicity by @xmath62dex , which increases the temperature by @xmath63k . this is enough to bring the model temperature to within @xmath56 of the spectroscopic value @xcite . there is a caveat : the spectroscopic analysis by @xcite relied on fixing the stellar @xmath59 as input into sme . thus , the temperature and metallicity are intimately tied to the adopted @xmath59 . reducing the mass of the primary by 5% , as is done by , but leaving the radius fixed to the value leads to a decrease in @xmath59 of @xmath64 dex . such a change in the fixed value of @xmath59 may decrease the derived effective temperature and bring the model and empirical temperatures into agreement . all things considered , we believe it is safe to assume that a shift in mass does not introduce any significant effective temperature disagreements at a given radius . this is predicated on the fact that the temperature is safely above @xmath65k . below this temperature , theoretical atmosphere predictions start to degrade with the appearance of molecular bands . more simply stated , we have no reason to doubt the dartmouth model predicted temperature for kepler-16 a , regardless of the adopted mass . a model age of 11gyr for the primary mass appears old given the multiple age estimates provided by @xcite . is it possible that the system is actually 11gyr old , but appears from rotation and activity to be considerably younger ? consider that a @xmath66day rotation period of the primary , as measured by @xcite , is nearly equal to the pseudo - synchronization rotation period , predicted to be 35.6days @xcite . one might think that tidal effects are unimportant in a binary with a 41 day orbital period , however , subsequent tidal interactions briefly endured when the components are near periastron can drive the components towards pseudo - synchronous rotation . pseudo - synchronous rotation will keep the stars rotating at a faster rate than if they were completely isolated from one another . the time scale for this to occur is approximately 3gyr @xcite , meaning that the rotation period is not necessarily indicative of the system s age . the primary will have approximately the same rotation period at 11gyr as it will at 3gyr . furthermore , the timescale for orbital circularization is safely estimated to be between @xmath67 @xmath68gyr @xcite . tidal evolution calculations are subject to large uncertainties and should approached as an order of magnitude estimate . but , we are unable to immediately rule out the possibility that kepler-16 has an age of 11gyr . we have so far neglected any remark on the agreement between standard models and kepler-16 b. this comparison is carried out in figure [ fig : kep16_b_nmag ] . no effective temperature estimates have been published , explaining our neglect of the @xmath45-radius plane . as with figure [ fig : kep16_a_nmag ] , mass tracks are shown for multiple metallicities . standard model mass tracks for kepler-16 b are unable to correctly predict the observed radius at an age consistent with estimates from the primary . the disagreement is independent of the adopted metallicity , which introduces @xmath69 variations in the stellar radius at a given age . no evidence is available to support the idea that kepler-16 b is magnetically active . still , we look to magnetic fields to reconcile the model predictions with the observations . all possible scenarios relating to the various stellar mass estimates are considered . explicitly , we compute models for both the and masses and then attempt to fit the observations using the magnetic dartmouth stellar evolution models . the primary mass implies that kepler-16 is approximately 2gyr old , as shown in figure [ fig : kep16_a_nmag](a ) . due to the consistency between the model derived age and the empirically inferred age , we see no reason to introduce a magnetic perturbation into models of kepler-16 a. @xcite observe only moderately weak chromospheric activity coming from the primary , further supporting our decision . thus , we seek to reconcile models of kepler-16 b with masses at 2gyr . magnetic models of kepler-16 b were computed for a range of surface magnetic field strengths . a dipole radial profile was used and the perturbation was applied over a single time step at an age of 1gyr . mass tracks with a @xmath70 kg and @xmath71 kg surface magnetic field strength are shown in figure [ fig : kep16b_dip ] along side a standard mass track for comparison . note , that even though the perturbation is applied at an age close to the age we are trying to fit , the models adjust to the perturbation rapidly . we are unable to produce a radius inflation larger than 1% , even with a strong surface magnetic field strength of @xmath71 kg . the peak field strength in the @xmath71 kg model ( located at @xmath72 ) is approximately 1.8 mg ( @xmath73 ) . discussion about how real such a magnetic field might be is deferred until section [ sec : mag_conv ] . for the moment , we are interested in knowing what magnetic field strength is required to reconcile models with observations . we next constructed magnetic models using a gaussian radial profile , which are shown in figure [ fig : kep16b_d11 ] . the magnetic perturbation was again introduced as a single perturbation at 1gyr . two surface magnetic field strengths were used , @xmath70 kg and @xmath74 kg . the model with a @xmath74 kg surface magnetic field strength causes the model to become over inflated compared to the observed radius at 2gyr . from figure [ fig : kep16b_d11 ] , we see that a magnetic field intermediate between 4 kg and 5 kg is required to produce agreement between the models and observations . in contrast to results for partially convective stars @xcite , dipole and gaussian radial profiles produce different results for a given surface magnetic field strength in fully convective stars . this is caused by a difference in peak magnetic field strengths ( dipole : 1.8 mg , @xmath75 ; gaussian : 30 mg , @xmath76 ) . we will return to this issue in section [ sec : fc_profs ] . finally , figure [ fig : kep_16_beq ] shows the influence of a constant @xmath23 profile on a model of kepler-16 b. recall , this radial profile invokes a turbulent dynamo mechanism . we started with a rather high value of @xmath77 to gauge the model s reaction to this formulation . impact on the radius evolution of a @xmath78 star is effectively negligible . further increasing @xmath23 has no effect on the resulting radius evolution . adopting masses mainly alters the age derived from stellar models . instead of 2gyr , we infer an age of 11gyr from models of kepler-16 a , as was shown in figure [ fig : kep16_a_nmag](a ) . the relative radius discrepancy noted between models and kepler-16 b is increased by approximately 2% over the case . magnetic models were computed for kepler-16 b with the mass estimate using a gaussian radial profile introduced at an age of 1gyr . these models are shown in figure [ fig : kep16b_b12 ] . we did not generate models with a dipole radial profile or with a constant @xmath23 profile given the lack of radius inflation observed for these magnetic field profiles for the masses . we find that a surface magnetic field strength slightly weaker than @xmath71 kg is required to fit the observations . this translates to a nearly @xmath79 mg ( @xmath76 ) peak magnetic field strength . a stronger field strength was required when using the mass instead of the mass because of the 1% increase in the radius discrepancy mentioned above . kepler-16 , although it has components with fundamental properties measured with better than 3% precision , must be approached cautiously when comparing to stellar models . mass differences quoted in the literature obscure how well models perform against the observations . though the masses are determined with high precision by each group , the 3% 5% uncertainty introduced by their disagreement overwhelms the measurement precision . this produces an age difference of 9gyr for the primary star , calling into question inferences drawn about this system from stellar models . it is also unclear how revising the masses would affect estimates of the component radii , the system s metallicity , and the primary star s effective temperature . furthermore , since the primary may be rotating pseudo - synchronously , it is not possible to rule out either of the age estimates . until the mass differences are resolved , _ care must be taken when comparing kepler-16 to stellar models_. however , the disparity between the observed radius of kepler-16 b and model predictions is apparent regardless of the adopted mass estimate . changing the mass estimate simply changes the level of inferred radius inflation . this result appears robust and can be used to test the magnetic hypothesis for low - mass star radius inflation . our magnetic models require magnetic field strengths of similar magnitudes . surface magnetic field strengths are on the order of 4 kg 6 kg with interior field strengths of a few tens of mg . cm dra ( gj 630.1 ac ) contains two fully convective low - mass stars and is arguably one of the most important systems for benchmarking stellar evolution models . shortly after cm dra was discovered by luyten , @xcite uncovered that the star was actually a deb . it was not clear from observations whether the secondary was a dark , very low - mass companion such that no secondary eclipse occurred or whether the two components were of nearly equal mass . evidence was tentatively provided in favor cm dra being a single dme star with a dark companion @xcite , although more observations were encouraged as the author found a possible hint of a secondary eclipse . any speculation that the secondary companion to the dme star of cm dra was a dark , lower - mass object was laid to rest by @xcite who obtained radial velocity measurements to provide the first determination of stellar parameters for both stars . l c c[b ] mass ( @xmath37 ) & @xmath80 & @xmath81 + radius ( @xmath42 ) & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + @xmath45 ( k ) & @xmath84 & @xmath85 + @xmath48 $ ] & + age ( gyr ) & [ tab : cm_dra_prop ] + following lacy s determination of the stellar properties , subsequent studies refined and improved the masses and radii of the cm dra stars , pushing the measurement precision below 2% @xcite . currently accepted values @xcite are listed in table [ tab : cm_dra_prop ] . additional information about the cm dra stars has been revealed in recent years . @xcite provided an analysis of a nearby white dwarf ( ) common proper motion companion and estimated an age of 4.1 @xmath86 0.8 gyr . this age was based upon the cooling time of the white dwarf and its estimated progenitor lifetime , which depends on the initial to final mass relation for white dwarfs . in light of recent advances in our understanding of white dwarf cooling ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and the initial - to - final mass relation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) we intend to re - examine the question of the age of cm dra in a future paper . for the present work , we adopt the aforementioned age . deriving a metallicity for cm dra has proven more difficult than estimating its age . near - infrared ( nir ) spectroscopic studies that fit theoretical model atmospheres to atomic and molecular features have consistently favored a metal - poor abundance ( @xmath87 } \approx -0.6 $ ] ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? optical spectroscopy of molecular features ( cah & tio ; * ? ? ? * ) and nir photometric colors @xcite , on the other hand , suggests that the system might have a near - solar metallicity . more recent techniques relying on empirically - calibrated narrow - band nir ( h & k band ) spectral features have converged on a value of [ m / h ] = @xmath88 @xcite . further support for the latter estimate is provided by the photometric color - magnitude - metallicity relation of @xcite , which predicts [ fe / h ] @xmath89 . for this study , we adopt [ fe / h ] = @xmath90 presented by @xcite who controlled for uncertainties introduced by orbital phase variations . it is well documented that the stars of cm dra are inflated compared to standard stellar models @xcite . this fact has become steadily more apparent since an initial comparison was performed by @xcite , which found little disagreement . a precise estimate of the level of disagreement depends on the adopted metallicity ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , but the problem is robust . figure [ fig : cmdra_nmag ] demonstrates the level of disagreement compared to standard dartmouth mass tracks.it also illustrates how metallicity influences the stellar models . given that there is no evidence for polar spots on cm dra ( see section [ sec : spots ] ) , we have elected to use the radii established by @xcite . the level of disagreement observed in figure [ fig : cmdra_nmag ] is between 5% 7% for each star , with cm dra a have a consistently smaller deviation than cm dra b by about 0.5% . @xcite , as a consequence of their metallicity estimate , have essentially doubled the radius disagreement from 3% 4% , noted in previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , to 5% 7% . cm dra is magnetically active . balmer emission and light curve modulation due to spots have been recognized since very early investigations @xcite . frequent optical flaring has also been continually noted ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? further details on the flare characteristics of cm dra may be found in the work by @xcite . the system is also a strong source of x - ray emission based on an analysis of data in the rosat all - sky survey bright source catalogue @xcite . high levels of magnetic activity and a short orbital period ( @xmath91d ) have been used to justify the need for magnetic perturbations in stellar evolution models of cm dra . such studies were carried out by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite using various methods ( see section [ sec : comp_study ] of this work ) . in each case , magnetic models were found to provide satisfactory agreement with the observations . cm dra therefore provides a pivotal test of our models and of the magnetic field hypothesis . magnetic model mass tracks are displayed in figures [ fig : cmdra_mag_d ] and [ fig : cmdra_mag_2 ] . we computed magnetic models using all three radial profiles discussed in section [ sec : rad_prof ] and using both dynamo formulations . perturbations were introduced over a single time step at an age of 1gyr . as with kepler-16 b , the magnetic models adjust to the perturbation well before the age where we attempt to perform the fit of models to observations . all magnetic models have [ fe / h ] @xmath92 and a solar - calibrated @xmath2 . since model radius predictions are only affected at the 1% level due to metallicity variations , inflation required of magnetic fields is the dominating factor when attempting to correct radius deviations of 6% . results for cm dra are similar to those for kepler-16 b. models with a dipole radial profile are unable to inflate model at the level needed , despite strong surface magnetic field strengths being applied ( 5.0 kg 6.0 kg ) . this is evidenced in figure [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](a ) , where magnetic - field - induced inflation occurs at the 1% gaussian radial profile models were able to largely reconcile models with observations . figure [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](b ) shows that surface magnetic field strengths of @xmath93 kg are required to provide the necessary radius inflation . note that in [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](b ) the 6.0 kg mass track for cm dra a actually has a 5.7 kg magnetic field for reasons related to model convergence . one can also see in figure [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](b ) that cm dra b requires a slightly stronger magnetic field strength . as with kepler-16 b , the peak interior magnetic field strengths are 1.8 mg ( @xmath75 ) and 40 mg ( @xmath76 ) for the dipole and gaussian profiles , respectively . constant @xmath23 models are shown in figure [ fig : cmdra_mag_2 ] . we only plot a @xmath77 for each mass . model radius inflation induced by these models is negligible , as with the case for kepler-16 b. the different results produced by the three magnetic field profiles introduced in section [ sec : rad_prof ] can be understood in terms of convective efficiency @xcite . convection near the surface of partially convective stars displays a higher level of super - adiabaticity than does convection in the outer layers of fully convective stars . in general , this suggests that convection is less efficient in the outer layers of partially convective stars . the structure of partially convective stars is therefore more sensitive to changes in convective properties . as a result , structural changes induced by modification to convective properties at the stellar surface induce the necessary radius inflation before the interior magnetic field strength becomes large enough to inhibit convection near the base of the convection zone . dipole and gaussian profiles then produce similar results for partially convective stars . for fully convective stars , the situation is reversed . we display the run of @xmath94 in two models of cm dra a in figure [ fig : cmdra_del_dela ] . one standard dartmouth model and one magnetic model are shown . the magnetic model is a gaussian radial profile model with a @xmath71 kg surface magnetic field . this is the same model that was plotted in figure [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](b ) . fully convective stars are largely characterized by near - adiabatic convection from the outer layers down to the core of the star . changes in convective properties have little effect on the flux transported by convection because convection is extremely efficient . changes to the properties of convection do have some structural effects ( see figure [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](a ) ) , but they are minimal . it s not until the deep interior magnetic field strength becomes strong enough to stabilize interior regions of the star against convection ( @xmath95 ) that significant structural changes occur ( as with the gaussian radial profile ) . when this occurs , a large radiative shell appears in the interior , as shown by the inset in figure [ fig : cmdra_del_dela ] . this radiative shell extends over 54% of the star by radius ( between @xmath96 and @xmath97 ) and 78% by mass ( between @xmath98 and @xmath99 ) . we verified this was the dominant reason for structural changes by looking at the profile of a dipole radial profile model with a similar surface magnetic field strength . the @xmath94 profile exhibited in the surface layers by the dipole model is nearly identical to the gaussian model . however , a radiative shell develops deep in the gaussian model . this supports the idea that fully convective stars require radiative zones to be consistent with observations @xcite . a model with the constant @xmath23 profile has a slightly different @xmath94 profile in the super - adiabatic layer . it also produces a marginally larger surface radiative zone than the standard non - magnetic model . convection in the deep interior is relatively unaffected , so a radiative core does not develop . we opted to not display these features in a figure because the overall profile is almost identical to the non - magnetic profile in figure [ fig : cmdra_del_dela ] . given the insensitivity of the overall stellar structure of fully convective stars to the size of the super - adiabatic layer , the constant @xmath23 models have a negligible influence on the stellar radius . surface magnetic field strengths are estimated from x - ray luminosity , @xmath100 , measurements using the relation between total unsigned magnetic flux , @xmath101 , and @xmath100 derived by @xcite . we are unable , however , to estimate a reliable magnetic field strength for kepler-16b as it does not appear in the rosat catalogs . in a moment we will provide at least a reasonable upper bound , but it is easiest to first address cm dra . the rosat bright source catalogue @xcite indicates that cm dra has an x - ray count rate of @xmath102 with a hardness ratio of @xmath103 . this translates into an x - ray luminosity per star of @xmath104 , where we have used a parallax of @xmath105mas @xcite . note that the x - ray luminosities are upper limits due to possible x - ray contamination in the rosat data . there are several stars nearby to cm dra in the plane of the sky , but it is difficult to judge whether they contribute to the rosat count rate . from the x - ray luminosity derived above , we find @xmath106 . errors associated with the surface magnetic field strength estimates are substantial due to the large error on the surface magnetic flux . converting magnetic fluxes to surface magnetic field strengths , we estimate that @xmath107 kg and @xmath108 kg for cm dra a and b , respectively . note that quoted uncertainties are mean uncertainties . these estimates imply that the @xmath71 kg surface magnetic field strengths predicted by our gaussian radial profile models are likely too strong . however , this does not invalidate the magnetic field models , only our choice of radial profile . the magnetic field strength in the deep interior is of greater consequence , so it may be possible to construct a radial profile to greater reflect this fact . models that use a constant @xmath23 formalism predict surface magnetic fields strengths up to @xmath109 kg . this upper limit is set by the magnetic field coming into equipartition with kinetic energy of convective flows @xcite . values of @xmath110 kg are consistent with our x - ray estimated field strengths . additionally , equipartition magnetic field strengths are consistent with typical average magnetic field strengths measured at the surface of m - dwarfs @xcite . although magnetic field strengths are consistent with observations , our models are unable to produce radii consistent with these realistic field strengths . although there are no x - ray measurements from rosat for kepler-16 , we can attempt to derive a reasonable estimate . from photometry , we may estimate a distance to kepler-16 by assuming that the primary contributes to most of the observed flux in the visible . we estimate a distance of about 60pc using the temperature and luminosity provided by @xcite and @xcite in combination with a bolometric correction from the phoenix model atmospheres . if we make the assumption that all of flux at x - ray wavelengths is from the secondary ( recall the primary shows only weak magnetic activity ; * ? ? ? * ) , then taking the rosat sensitivity limit of @xmath111 counts per second @xcite we find @xmath112 erg s@xmath6 . this also assumes @xmath113 , typical for dwarf stars . converting to an unsigned magnetic flux yields @xmath114 , or a magnetic field strength of order 2 kg for kepler-16b . therefore , kepler-16 likely does not have a magnetic field strength any larger than that found on the surface of cm dra . furthermore , if kepler-16b is rotating pseudo - synchronously , like it s companion , then it would have a rotation velocity @xmath7 km s@xmath6 , as mentioned in section [ sec : intro ] . cm dra , on the other hand , has @xmath115 km s@xmath6 . kepler-16 may very well have a weaker magnetic field , owing to its longer orbital ( and presumably rotational ) period . therefore , we believe that the @xmath71 kg surface magnetic field required to bring our models into agreement with observations is too strong . previous attempts to reconcile model radii with the observed radii of fully convective stars have focused solely on cm dra , as it was the only well - studied system known @xcite . in each case , magnetic fields and magnetic activity were found to provide an adequate solution , which is quite the opposite conclusion from results presented in section [ sec : ind_deb ] . this seeming contradiction of previous results can be understood by our neglect of star spots , in particular , the potential for observed radii to be over - estimated on a spotted star . before submitting that spots are the solution and calling this case closed , we will review existing results , placing ours into context , and the provide an assessment of the magnetic hypothesis . methods used in previous studies were , in some respects similar . each used a method for treating magneto - convection . four techniques have been employed thus far : a reduced-@xmath2 approach @xcite , stabilization of convection by a vertical magnetic field @xcite , stabilization by a more general magnetic field ( not specifically vertical ; this work ) , and then a turbulent dynamo approach that is similar to a reduced-@xmath2 ( this work ) . including effects of star spots is inherently difficult in a 1d stellar evolution code . spots are blemishes scattered across the stellar surface that extend a non - fixed distance into the surface convection zone . spots have largely been treated in the same fashion in previous investigations and rely on reducing the total stellar surface flux by a fractional amount , @xmath116 , \label{eq : spot}\ ] ] where @xmath117 is the surface areal coverage of spots and @xmath118 is the spot temperature contrast . this approach is based on the `` thermal plug '' spot model advanced by @xcite and @xcite . the modified surface flux is then @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is the flux of the star if the photosphere is spot free . @xcite performed a detailed analysis to establish how specific star spot properties effect results from both theoretical modeling and light curve analyses . for a given star spot @xmath121 and assumed distribution of spots over the stellar surface ( uniform , clustered at mid - latitudes , and clustered at the poles ) , they evaluated the reliability of light curve analyses in determining stellar radii . if spots are preferentially located at the poles , they showed that stellar radii may be over - estimated by as much as 6% . on the other hand , if spots are more evenly distributed across the surface , or clustered at mid - latitudes , radius determinations proved reliable for @xmath122 . combining the aforementioned results with the influence of spots on stellar evolution models , via equation ( [ eq : spot ] ) , @xcite found that @xmath123 was required to fit the stars of cm dra . magneto - convection using a reduced-@xmath2 was found to be ineffective and was not required . thus , they predict that the stars in cm dra are 35% covered by spots that are 15% cooler than the surface ( this latter value was fixed in their analysis ) . this was deemed sufficient to correct model radii with observations . @xcite , on the other hand , were able to produce agreement between their model and observations using a combination of magneto - convection and star spots . they identified regions of @xmath124 ( @xmath125 in their paper ) parameter space that reconciles their models with cm dra ( see their figures 13 15 ) . their magnetic inhibition parameter is defined as @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the magnetic field strength , @xmath128 is the ratio of specific heats , and @xmath11 is the total gas pressure . this quantity is added directly to the adiabatic gradient in the schwarzschild stability criterion . what strongly distinguishes the @xcite study from the @xcite investigation is that @xcite do not include model inflation due to spots as described by equation ( [ eq : spot ] ) . instead , they only adopt the adjustment made to the observed stellar radii due to the influence of polar spots on the light curve analysis . model radius inflation is then caused by stabilization of convection using their inhibition parameter described above . the full range of values for which they find agreement is @xmath129 with @xmath130 . to further constrain the parameter space , they assume the best fit star spot @xmath123 from @xcite . this narrows the acceptable range for the magnetic inhibition parameter to @xmath131 . these values of @xmath132 correspond to vertical magnetic field strengths of approximately 500 g at the stellar photosphere and a ( capped ) interior vertical magnetic field strength of 1 mg . our modeling results are largely consistent with those of @xcite and @xcite . comparing first with @xcite , we focus on the dipole and gaussian radial profile models with a rotational dynamo ( figures [ fig : cmdra_mag_d](a ) and ( b ) ) . the magnetic perturbation applied in these models is qualitatively similar to magneto - convection method favored by @xcite . we have estimated that our magnetic field strengths should be up to an order of magnitude larger than those of @xcite as a consequence of our formulation @xcite . our `` inhibition parameter '' is primarily controlled by the quantity , @xmath133 where @xmath134 is a magnetic compression coefficient and @xmath135 is the gradient of the magnetic energy per unit mass with respect to the total pressure . we showed that @xmath136 @xcite , but our formulation has the additional term @xmath137 . therefore , to achieve the same results as @xcite , we should need @xmath134 to be about 10 times larger than @xmath132 . thus , our requirement of a 6.0 kg surface magnetic field strength with a roughly 40 mg peak magnetic field strength for the gaussian radial profile is consistent with the values we would expect given the values from @xcite . although the dipole radial profile model has a 5.0 kg surface magnetic field strength , the peak magnetic field strength is only 1.5 mg , a factor of 10 or so too small to impart the necessary structural changes . to compare with @xcite , we refer to our constant @xmath23 models , which closely matches the reduced-@xmath2 formulation . we found that even if the magnetic field were a considerable fraction of the equipartition magnetic field strength ( @xmath77 ) , there is little impact on the stellar radii . this is consistent with @xcite , who found that the reducing @xmath2 has a negligible impact on the stellar model predictions for fully convective stars , especially after star spots were invoked . in that sense , we confirm that reducing convective efficiency does not appear to be a viable method to fully account for inflation among fully convective stars . note that we have not adopted the reduced stellar radius presented by @xcite nor have we explicitly addressed reductions in surface flux due to star spots . models presented in @xcite did not require star spots to provide an adequate fit to the data . this reinforces a known degeneracy between magneto - convection implementations and introducing star spots @xcite . one may not be too surprised that these two issues are so closely connected , as spots are the physical manifestation of suppressed convection near the stellar surface . therefore , it is reasonable to assume that reduction in convective flux from either magneto - convection or star spots should produce similar results . the degeneracy , in a sense , can be broken by the idea that star spots could bias light curve analyses towards larger radii . magneto - convection , strictly speaking , has no influence on the light curve analysis , if we assume global changes to stellar properties . in that sense , particular configurations of spots ( clustered near the pole ) could have a significantly larger impact on the mass - radius problem than magneto - convection . despite the aforementioned results that support the magnetic field hypothesis , we are skeptical of the interpretation that magnetic fields are driving the observed radius inflation . we will now assess the results primarily by considering available observational data . reductions in convective efficiency appear to be inadequate for producing the observed stellar radii ( section [ sec : ind_deb ] of this work ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? we showed that , for kepler-16 and cm dra , radius inflation induced by the inhibition of convective efficiency was effectively negligible ( @xmath1380.1% ) . this is in agreement with @xcite and @xcite , who find reducing the convective mixing length from @xmath139 to @xmath140 has little effect on the radii of fully convective stars . reducing @xmath2 further could begin to provide reasonable effects on fully convective stellar radii . the question then becomes , `` is it possible for @xmath141 , and if so , by what mechanism ? '' results from the stabilization of convection are encouraging . a proper amount of radius inflation can be achieved with somewhat reasonable surface magnetic field strengths ( section [ sec : ind_deb ] of this work ; * ? ? ? * ) . instead of surface field strengths posing a problem as they did with partially convective stars @xcite , it is the interior magnetic field strengths , which range from 1 mg to 50 mg , that require attention . there is presently no observational evidence to suggest a 1 mg ( or greater ) magnetic field could exist within a fully convective star . to be fair , there is also no direct evidence to rule out the possibility . we must be honest about the lack of observational data concerning interior magnetic field strengths . however , there is some indirect evidence that casts doubt on the existence of super - mg interior magnetic fields . we will now carefully examine the possibility that such fields do exist deep in fully convective stars . from a theoretical perspective , there is concern about how a super - mg magnetic field is generated . simulations suggest that turbulent dynamos reach saturation at field strengths of @xmath13850 kg @xcite , two orders of magnitude below the 1 mg magnetic field required by stellar models . we will return to this a bit later . for now , let us assume that super - mg magnetic fields can not be generated by dynamo action . instead , it could be assumed that super - mg magnetic fields are the result of the amplification of a primordial @xmath142 g seed magnetic field during the proto - stellar collapse . assuming magnetic flux is conserved during collapse of the proto - star , one finds that super - mg magnetic fields could plausibly exist . however , the super - mg magnetic fields must then survive several gyr within the stellar interior without decaying . there are three primary timescales of interest : that given by macroscopic diffusion in a non - convecting medium , the rise time for a buoyantly unstable flux tube , and the advection timescale in a convecting medium with relatively high conductivity . we ll consider the latter , first . if the stellar plasma is highly conducting , which is a valid assumption throughout the interior of stars , then the field lines will be frozen into the plasma . we might then expect that the flux tubes will be carried by convection from deep within the star to the stellar surface , where the they will then dissipate their energy . the timescale for this to occur is roughly @xmath143 , where @xmath144 cm and @xmath145 cm s@xmath6 . we find that @xmath146 s , or about 1 yr . even if we assume @xmath147 cm s@xmath6 , @xmath148 s. thus , the timescale for this type of advection is about 10 yr . although convection can quickly carry a flux tube from the deep interior to the stellar surface , the process can also carry flux tubes from the surface to deep in the interior . a more uni - directional process that can transport magnetic flux to the stellar surface is the magnetic buoyancy instability ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? magnetic flux tubes are assumed to be in pressure equilibrium with their surroundings deep in the interiors of stars , @xmath149 where @xmath150 and @xmath151 are the interior and exterior gas pressures acting on the flux tube , respectively , and @xmath152 is the magnetic pressure within the flux tube . since flux tubes are supported by both the internal gas pressure and the magnetic pressure , the gas density within a flux tube is lower than the surrounding gas pressure , provided that the temperature inside the flux tube is the same as the temperature of the surroundings . this density perturbation creates a buoyancy force towards the surface of the star , but will be counteracted by radially inward hydrodynamic forces resulting from convective down - flows . if we assume a polytropic eos , a reasonable approximation for deep stellar interiors , and that @xmath153 can be expressed as a power - series expansion about @xmath154 , the gas density exterior to the flux tube , then truncating the series to first order gives @xmath155 + \frac{b^2}{8\pi } = p_{{\rm gas},\,e},\ ] ] where @xmath128 is the ratio of specific heats and @xmath156 is the density perturbation . the specific buoyancy force resulting from this density perturbation is @xmath157 balancing the buoyancy force with the hydrodynamic force @xcite yields the condition whereby a magnetic flux tube will be unstable to buoyant rise , @xmath158 where @xmath127 is the magnetic field , @xmath35 is the local pressure scale height , @xmath159 is the flux tube radius , and @xmath160 is equipartition magnetic field given in section [ sec : clambda ] . this is a simplified picture that ignores effects due to curvature and the response of the magnetic tension that may act to prevent the onset of buoyant instability . however , it provides a reasonable order of magnitude approximation . given the propensity for magnetic stellar models to invoke magnetic fields with @xmath161 g , we can estimate a typical flux tube radius needed to maintain this magnetic field strength stable against buoyancy . for m - dwarfs , @xmath162 cm and @xmath163 g. thus , to maintain strong @xmath164 g magnetic fields deep in the interior ( as in * ? ? ? * ) , flux tubes must be no larger than @xmath165 cm , or 1 km . this means the ratio of the pressure scale height to the flux tube radius must be @xmath166 . by comparison , the values estimated for this ratio near the solar tachocline are of order unity @xcite . this ratio rises to @xmath164 ( @xmath167 m ) if the deep interior magnetic field is to be of order @xmath168 g ( this work ) . once the flux tube becomes unstable to buoyant rise , an estimate of the rise time can be approximated assuming that the tube travels at the alfvn velocity @xcite . a @xmath164 g magnetic field will traverse a stellar radius @xmath169 cm in approximately @xmath170 s , or about 10 days , assuming a constant density of @xmath171 g @xmath172 . this rise time will be increased by non - adiabatic heating effects , but remains small compared to evolutionary timescales @xcite . figure [ fig : cmdra_del_dela ] indicates that a radiative shell develops deep within the star in the presence of a super - mg magnetic field . this means that the dissipation time of the magnetic field does not necessarily obey the advection timescale discussed above . instead , we may look at the timescale for diffusion given by the induction equation . in the absence of any favorable current networks , we have that @xmath173 where @xmath174 is the magnetic diffusivity . the approximate timescale for diffusion , assuming @xmath175 @xmath176 s@xmath6 @xcite , is then @xmath177 , where @xmath178 is the size of the radiative shell . the field diffuses through the radiative shell until it reaches the convective boundary , which then efficiently transports magnetic flux to the stellar surface . based on our models of cm dra , we find the size of radiative shell is @xmath179 cm . therefore , @xmath180 yr , assuming the magnetic field fully diffuses out of the radiative zone . however , even within a radiation zone , magnetic buoyancy must be considered and can lead to a rapid rise time for magnetic flux tubes ( e.g. , * ? ? ? these are only order of magnitude approximations , so it is possible that the field could survive for a shorter or longer time in any scenario . instead , this exercise suggests that an amplified seed field , or any super - mg magnetic field , present in a fully convective star will likely decay away rapidly owing to the magnetic buoyancy instability . we note that this is still possible , even if a sizeable radiative zone develops as a result of the strong magnetic field . furthermore , the radiative zone is a product of the magnetic field and therefore exists in an unstable equilibrium . as the magnetic field decays away , so will the radiative zone . @xcite recognized that primordial magnetic fields would likely decay and thus were not a suitable solution for the existence of super - mg magnetic fields within cm dra . instead , they proposed that the dynamo mechanism may be able to generate the necessary magnetic fields . their proposal contradicts what we mentioned earlier , that simulations are unable to generate magnetic fields greater than @xmath13850 kg in fully convective models . @xcite reason that this is a result of those simulations using rotational velocities similar to those in the sun . if one nominally assumes that magnetic field strengths increase with rotation rate , then a star like cm dra will have considerably stronger magnetic fields than does the sun . using a scaling relation between magnetic field strength and rotational angular velocity , @xcite find that cm dra should have a surface magnetic field strength of about 500 g with an internal magnetic field strength anywhere between 0.3 mg and 1.3 mg . this could then explain the existence of super - mg magnetic field strengths . note that the magnetic field strength is predicted to be the large - scale magnetic field strength , not necessarily the total magnetic field strength . however , the peak interior magnetic field strength seen in simulations is moderated by the kinetic energy available in convective flows . this was discussed in section [ sec : clambda ] . simulations find that a dynamo driven by turbulent convection can create both small - scale magnetic fields and large - scale magnetic fields @xcite . it is not immediately clear that rotation would not drive stronger magnetic field strengths , so we will proceed in our discussion assuming that it might to see if we encounter any inherent contradictions . the scaling relation adopted by @xcite would then also explain why koi-126 can be fit by stellar evolution models . koi-126 is a triply eclipsing system found earlier in the _ kepler _ data @xcite that contains two fully convective stars that are nearly identical to cm dra . yet , the properties of koi-126 ( b , c ) are well reproduced by standard stellar evolution models @xcite . assuming a scaling relation between magnetic field strength and rotational angular velocity may support this finding . koi-126 ( b , c ) have an orbital period of 1.77days , to be compared to the 1.27day orbit of cm dra . this 0.5day difference in orbital period means koi-126 ( b , c ) would have weaker magnetic fields than cm dra and would experience considerably less radius inflation @xcite . @xcite predict that koi-126 should be inflated by approximately 2 3% . we find this difficult to understand in context of the agreement between standard stellar evolution models and the observed radii . inflating model radii by 2 3% would mean that models would over - predict the radii of koi-126 ( b , c ) . if one assumes that spots are biasing the observed radius measurements , it would decrease the measured radii , again breaking the agreement between the observations and the models . there seems to be problems with simultaneously increasing model radii and decreasing the measured radii of koi-126 ( b , c ) while still maintaining model - observation agreement . furthermore , the scaling relation suggested to validate super - mg magnetic fields may not be compatible with observations . results seem to show that at a given mass , the large - scale magnetic field strength of fully convective stars do not appear to depend on rotation below a critical threshold ( see , e.g. , figure 3 in * ? ? ? * ) . for low - mass stars , this threshold corresponds to a rotation period of about 3 or 4 days . magnetic field saturation is also observed in data regarding the total magnetic field strength of fully convective stars . magnetic fields saturate around 3 kg for @xmath181kms@xmath6 @xcite . saturation inherently implies that scaling relations are invalid . since both cm dra and koi-126 ( b , c ) have components rotating faster than the threshold for saturation , there is no reason to assume that their magnetic fields are that different . there is the possibility that their large - scale components ( and thus vertical ) magnetic fields are sufficiently different , but this is not immediately obvious . finally , we note that magneto - convection techniques alone have not been sufficient to rectify the model - observations disagreements . effects of star spots must be included and must therefore be assessed on their own basis . the most efficient means of inflating low - mass stellar models of cm dra is by including star spots @xcite . although we did not explicitly include spots , we will take a careful look at the results of these two previous studies . we feel this analysis is required in light of recent observational data , including confirmation that cm dra has a sub - solar metallicity of [ fe / h ] @xmath182 @xcite . we use approximate fits to the @xcite spot - modeling results to estimate how a metallicity reduction alters their conclusions . assuming polar spots , they find that spots tend to bias observations towards larger radii . from the few data points in their figure 7 , we calculate that spots produce larger radii according to the function @xmath183 where @xmath184 is the ratio of the radius derived when polar spots are present to the actual radius . this function can be used to correct for the radius bias produced by spots . in stellar models , spots can also increase radius predictions . given the data in figure 8 of @xcite , model radii can be approximated as , @xmath185 where @xmath186 is the radius of a non - magnetic model in units of solar radii . we note that this formula approximates the effects of spots only for model masses of @xmath187 . the intersection of these two relations in the @xmath121@xmath18 plane provides an estimate of the star spot parameter required to correct models . figure [ fig : spot_corr ] illustrates that a model of cm dra a with [ fe / h ] @xmath188 ( see also figure [ fig : cmdra_nmag ] ) needs a star spot @xmath189 to match observations . small differences in our results from those of @xcite are due to the adopted base model ( dartmouth vs lyon ) and our method of fitting polynomials to the spot radius bias and inflation data in @xcite . changing @xmath121 has proportionally larger effect on correction for radius measurement biases than it does on inflation caused in stellar models . if this correction is not applied , @xmath190 is needed to produce agreement using model radius inflation at sub - solar metallicity . whether the required star spot parameter is realistic is a more difficult question . spot properties for m - dwarfs are relatively unconstrained , as identifying spot sensitive features in spectra is complicated by uncertainties in modeling molecular features . nonetheless , there are three components to the spot parameter that are of interest : spot coverage , spot temperature contrast , and spatial distribution . we will address each separately and then present a unified picture afterward . [ [ temperature - contrast ] ] temperature contrast + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + spot temperature contrast is defined , here , to be the ratio of the spot temperature to the temperature of the unblemished stellar photosphere . as seen from equation ( [ eq : spot ] ) , constraining the spot temperature contrast provides insight into the required filling factor predicted by the spot model . although no direct empirical constraints exist for m - dwarfs , there have been studies performed to measure spot temperature contrasts of k stars using tio bandhead features @xcite . we will take a closer look at those results , here . properties of spots were determined by fitting the shape of tio bandheads with a spectrum created using a two temperature spot model . this technique involves convolving two template spectra for which the effective temperature is assumed to be known and finding the best combination of template spectra to produce the molecular bandhead features in spectra of a given star ( see e.g. , * ? ? ? the result is an estimate of the temperatures for the unblemished photosphere and the spotted regions , as well as the fractional surface coverage of each feature ( see below ) . using this technique , it was found that active k stars specifically ii peg and eq vir have spots with a characteristic temperature contrast of 75% ( 25% cooler than the unblemished photosphere ) . this estimate , however , relies on the temperature for the two template spectra being correct . results from interferometric studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) have revised the temperature estimates for the stars whose spectra were used as templates in the @xcite investigations . these revisions only affect the temperatures for template spectra used as the spot ( cool ) component in the fit , namely the temperatures associated with cooler m - dwarf spectra , and increase the associated effective temperature by 300 k 400 k. taking into account the revised temperature scale for the cooler template spectra , one finds the temperature contrast for k stars inferred from molecular bandhead features is between 82% ( ii peg ) and 90% ( ek vir ) . the warmer spot temperatures are supported by doppler imaging ( di ) studies of ii peg , which indicate temperature contrasts between 80% and 85% @xcite . assuming that spot temperature contrasts become weaker towards later spectra types @xcite , then one might expect m - dwarfs to have spot temperature contrasts around 90% ( 10% cooler than the unspotted surface ) . using this value , one finds that a spot surface coverage of 55% is required to satisfy the condition that @xmath191 for cm dra . of course , slightly warmer or cooler spots may be permitted , depending on the efficiency at which spots temporarily suppress surface convection . for the sake of argument , we take 90% to be a typical spot contrast . we now look whether a spot areal coverage of 55% is consistent with empirical evidence . [ [ surface - coverage ] ] surface coverage + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + to assess what constitutes typical spot surface coverages , we look to results from di and molecular bandhead fitting . using di , spot coverages for three m - dwarfs have been estimated . di maps of , , and @xcite reveal varying levels of surface coverage from 2% ( v374 peg ) up to 40% ( hk aqr ) . similarly , surface coverages derived by modeling the shape of tio bandheads of active k stars again ii peg and ek vir are typically around 30 40% , consistent with values found in di investigations @xcite . there are no measurements of spot coverages on m - dwarfs using this technique , which limits the applicability of these results , but we may cautiously extrapolate and assume that m - dwarfs are able to possess at least similar surface coverages . for one of the k stars studied using the molecular bandhead technique , , information on spot coverage from di is also available . @xcite mapped the spot coverage of ii peg and find seasonal variation in spot coverage between 5 20% , a factor of 8 and 2 lower than the coverage inferred from tio bandheads , respectively . seasonal variation is expected if magnetic activity cycles are present in other stars , so it s not surprising that one observes this phenomenon . however , the difference between the maximum surface coverage revealed by di ( 20% ) and that obtained using molecular bandhead features ( 40% ) highlights a known limitation with di studies : they are only sensitive to spot features larger than the grid resolution in the di analysis . in other words , small scale spot features will be missed by the di reconstruction . this is especially relevant since comparison of spectro - polarization measurements of m - dwarf magnetic fields using stokes @xmath192 and @xmath193 polarization indicate a majority of the magnetic energy is contained in small - scale features @xcite . therefore , spot coverages inferred from di maps must be taken as lower limits to the true spot coverage . one may then plausibly expect spot surface coverages at least as high as 40% for m - dwarfs . evidence from both di and molecular bandhead fitting support the existence of spot coverages around 40% for active late k - dwarfs and m - dwarfs . this is below the 55% needed to satisfy the use of a @xmath191 spot parameter . whether 55% is _ unrealistically _ high is unclear . if , for instance , the spot temperature contrast were around 85% , as opposed to 90% , then the required spot surface coverage would be 40% , and thus consistent with observations . one could just as well argue the opposite , that a larger temperature contrast of 94% would require a surface coverage of 87% and push the requirement further from the current empirical evidence . one further scenario is that stars are able to achieve spot coverages near 100% . observations suggest that the filling factor of magnetic fields at the surface of fully convective stars ( both main - sequence and pre - main - sequence ) approaches unity @xcite . we must then try to understand the connection between the presence of magnetic fields and star spots . this includes determining how strong of a magnetic field is necessary at the surface of an m - dwarf to generate spots of appreciable temperature contrast . it may be that pervasive 1 kg magnetic fields covering the whole surface of fully convective stars may be too weak to cause any noticeable effects on convection . such an even distribution of small spots would also likely not cause any noticeable light curve modulation , if filling factors approach unity . however , pockets of strong 5 8 kg magnetic fields @xcite may produce the noticeable light curve modulation , bias stellar radii measurements , and suppress surface convection . [ [ spatial - distribution ] ] spatial distribution + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + arguably , whether spots cluster near the poles of active m - dwarfs is of greatest consequence for the present assessment . evidence for spots clustered at the poles is less definitive than temperature contrasts and surface coverages . about half of all stars studied using di show signs of polar caps @xcite . exceptions are very active stars and m - dwarfs , which tend to have spots distributed across all latitudes . of the three di spot maps generated for m - dwarfs , none display evidence for polar caps @xcite . a di study of cm dra to search for possible signs of significant polar coverage of spots is needed . ideally , this would be performed with existing data that was used to derive the stellar properties , but a look at the signal - to - noise of the observations reveals that the data is likely unsuitable for such an investigation ( see * ? ? ? in the meantime , we must be cautious as even polar spots would require large areal coverages ( half or more of the stellar surface ) to provide agreement between models and observations . additional evidence for non - polar - cap distributions comes from studies of the @xmath138150 myr open cluster . the statistical distribution of light curve modulations assumed to be caused by star spots in the low - mass star population can only be reproduced if the stars have randomized spot latitudinal distributions and rotational inclination angles @xcite . we do note that these latter studies also require spot temperature contrasts of 75% , which we have just discussed may be too dramatic for k- and m - dwarfs . how using a more realistic spot contrast would alter their results is unclear as there are strong degeneracies when modeling spot modulation in light curves . a first estimate would be that typical surface coverages would increase from the @xmath194% that was required in their study . there is as yet no definitive empirical evidence for polar cap spots among fully convective main sequence stars . however , there is a theoretical expectation that spots should be located near the poles in rapidly rotating stars ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . whether this expectation applies to fully convective stars is questionable , as spots distributed more evenly at lower latitudes may be more reasonable for more distributed dynamos @xcite . based on only three data points , the apparent lack of polar spots among fully convective main sequence stars is not robust and requires further confirmation . is it then possible to abandon the idea of a largely polar cap distribution and still rely on spots to address the radius discrepancies ? in figure [ fig : spot_corr ] , we see that abandoning the idea of polar spots requires @xmath190 if model inflation is to alone correct for the observed radii . in this case , a spot temperature contrast of 89% with areal coverage of 100% would be required . temperature contrasts greater than 89% lead to areal coverages greater than 100% and are thus unphysical . even as one approaches 100% surface coverage ( for temperature contrasts below 89% ) , it becomes increasingly difficult to produce spot modulation in light curves as there are fewer regions of unblemished photosphere left to produce the asymmetries needed , as discussed in the previous section . considering patches of varying spot temperature contrast may provide the necessary asymmetries , but has not yet been investigated for consistency with the empirical data . the case for magnetic fields inflating the radii of fully convective stars appears to be tenuous . stabilization of convection in stellar models can produce the necessary radius inflation with reasonable surface magnetic field strengths . but , the models require super - mg magnetic fields in the interior . we are hesitant to suggest that real stars contain such strong interior magnetic fields for several reasons . first , turbulent dynamos can not generate magnetic fields with strengths greater than about 50 kg @xcite . how magnetic fields with strengths greater than 1 mg would accumulate in the interior of fully convective stars would be unknown . if super - mg magnetic fields are of primordial origin , they would probably not survive to the present day . nor would magnetic field strengths of that magnitude be generated within the star and survive on evolutionary timescales . to avoid this , one can assume a scaling relation between magnetic field strengths and rotation , as suggested by @xcite to explain the super - mg magnetic fields . however , this breaks down for most stars in debs . observations indicate a saturation of magnetic flux for fully convective stars that have rotation periods below @xmath195days @xcite . also , koi-126 ( b , c ) agree with stellar evolution models @xcite . these stars exist in a regime where magnetic flux saturation should occur , but are seemingly uninfluenced by the presence of any magnetic phenomena . if super - mg magnetic fields are causing dramatic inflation in cm dra , one would expect to observe it in koi-126 ( b , c ) as well . finally , suppression of convective efficiency is unable to provide a suitable solution on its own . instead , star spots may be invoked for fully convective stars , which introduces additional concerns . the presence of star spots on the stellar surfaces may provide an adequate solution , mostly through biasing the analysis of light curve data . from observations , star spots on fully convective stars can be characterized as : having temperatures about 10% cooler than the surrounding photosphere @xcite , having surface coverages ranging from a couple percent @xcite up to around 40% @xcite , and having spot distributions that appear to be more random and not clustered at the poles . at this point , there is not sufficient empirical data regarding spot properties of m - dwarfs to draw firm conclusions . still , the lack of noticeable spots at the poles is a concern . results regarding how spots bias radius measurements rely on concentrated regions of spot coverage at the poles that are darker than their surroundings . at present , this feature is not observationally supported , but more work needs to be performed on this matter . this paper addressed the question of whether magnetic fields can realistically inflate the radii of fully convective stars . we approached the problem by modeling two individual debs that contain fully convective stars , kepler-16 and cm dra . our models showed that the observed radii could be reproduced provided that a strong 50 mg magnetic field resides deep within these fully convective stars . we proceeded to show that multiple mechanisms advection due to convective flows , macroscopic diffusion , and magnetic buoyancy instability can lead to rapid destruction of such strong magnetic fields . these estimates would benefit from detailed numerical simulations to probe further whether such magnetic fields can stably reside deep within m - dwarfs . an assessment of the hypothesis that star spots are responsible for the observed inflation was also given . here , the hypothesis largely rests on the assumption that large conglomerations of spots lie near the poles ; a prediction that has not yet been observed among main sequence fully convective stars . after weighing the evidence , we find it difficult to favor the hypothesis that magnetic fields are actively inflating the radii of fully convective , main sequence stars . there are numerous uncertainties that must be addressed on both the theoretical and observational side of the hypothesis . more sophisticated magneto - convection models are required to further investigate this issue , using both simplified 1d approximations and more detailed 3d mhd models . most critical , though , will be observational studies of star spots and magnetic fields of low - mass stars . these properties must be further constrained by observations if we are to rule out any of the physical pictures presented by the current generation of 1d stellar evolution models . in the meantime , it may not be too early to start seeking other solutions . we thank bengt gustafsson for carefully reading and commenting on the manuscript , and the anonymous referee for their constructive remarks and suggestions . this research was made possible by the william h. neukom 1964 institute for computational science at dartmouth college and the national science foundation ( nsf ) grant ast-0908345 . this work made use of nasa s astrophysics data system , the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france , and the _ rosat _ data archive tools hosted by the high energy astrophysics science archive research center ( heasarc ) at nasa s goddard space flight center . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: recordings of spatio - temporal activity are ubiquitous in many scientific disciplines . among the most prominent examples are large - scale electrophysiological measurements of neuronal firing patterns in experimental neuroscience @xcite and sensor data acquisition in seismology @xcite , oceanography @xcite , meteorology @xcite , or climatology @xcite . other examples include interaction protocols in social communication @xcite or monitoring single - node dynamics in network science @xcite . in all of these fields recordings often exhibit well - defined patterns of spatio - temporal propagation where some prominent feature first appears at a specific location and then spreads to other areas until potentially becoming a global event . such characteristic propagation patterns occur in phenomena such as avalanches @xcite , tsunamis @xcite , chemical waves and diffusion processes @xcite , and epileptic seizures @xcite . further examples are the epidemic transmission of diseases @xcite , and , more recently , the spreading of memes on social networks @xcite or in science @xcite . in many cases spatio - temporal recordings can be represented as a two - dimensional plot where for each recording site the occurrence of certain discrete events ( often obtained from threshold crossings in continuous data ) are indicated by time markers . in neuroscience such a plot is known as a raster plot . a sequence of stereotypical neuronal action potentials ( _ spikes _ , @xcite , @xcite ) is a _ spike train _ and a set of spike trains exhibiting perfectly consistent repetitions of the same global propagation pattern is called a _ synfire pattern_. in this paper we adapt this terminology and use all of these expressions not only in the context of neuronal spikes but also for any other kind of discrete events . however , note that our use of the term ` synfire pattern ' differs slightly from the literature ( see e.g. @xcite , @xcite ) . here we define a synfire pattern as a sequence of global events in which all neurons fire in consistent order and the interval between successive events is at least twice as large as the propagation time within an event . an example of a rasterplot with spike trains forming a perfect synfire pattern is shown in fig . [ fig : spike_order_motivation_fig1]a . for any spike train set exhibiting propagation patterns the questions arises naturally whether these patterns show any consistency , i.e. , to what extent do the spike trains resemble a synfire pattern , are there spike trains that consistently lead global events and are there other spike trains that invariably follow these leaders ? such questions about leader - follower dynamics have been specifically investigated not only in neuroscience @xcite , but also in fields as wide - ranging as , e.g. , climatology @xcite , social communication @xcite , and human - robot interaction @xcite . motivation for spike - order and spike train order . a. perfect synfire pattern . b. unsorted set of spike trains . c. the same spike trains as in b but now sorted from leader to follower.,width=321 ] in this study we introduce a framework consisting of two directional measures ( _ spike - order _ and _ spike train order _ ) that allows to define a value termed _ synfire indicator _ which quantifies the consistency of the leader - follower relationships . this synfire indicator attains its maximal value of @xmath0 for a perfect synfire pattern in which all neurons fire repeatedly in a consistent order from leader to follower ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_motivation_fig1]a ) . the same framework also allows to sort multiple spike trains from leader to follower , as illustrated in figs . [ fig : spike_order_motivation_fig1]b and [ fig : spike_order_motivation_fig1]c . this is meant purely in the sense of temporal sequence . whereas fig . [ fig : spike_order_motivation_fig1]b shows an artificially created but rather realistic spike train set , in fig . [ fig : spike_order_motivation_fig1]c the same spike trains have been sorted to become as close as possible to a synfire pattern . now the spike trains that tend to fire first are on top whereas spike trains with predominantly trailing spikes are at the bottom . we demonstrate the new approach using artificially generated datasets before we apply it to analyze the consistency of propagation patterns in two real datasets from very different fields of research , neuroscience and climatology . the neurophysiological dataset consists of neuronal activity recorded from mice brain slices . these recordings typically exhibit a sequence of global events termed giant depolarized potentials ( gdps ) and one of the main questions we investigate is whether it is possible to identify neurons that consistently lead these events ( potential hub neurons , see @xcite , @xcite ) . the climate dataset uses optimum interpolated sea surface temperature ( oisst ) data provided by the national oceanic and atmospheric administration ( noaa ) to follow the el nio phenomenon in the central pacific region ( @xcite , @xcite ) over the range of @xmath1 years , from 1982 to 2016 . we employ a threshold criterion to track the el nio events and then quantify the consistency of the longitudinal movement of the propagation front . the remainder of the article is organized as follows : in the methods ( section [ s : measures ] ) we first describe the coincidence detection ( section [ ss : coincidence - detection ] ) and the symmetric measure spike - synchronization ( section [ ss : spike - synchronization ] ) . subsequently , we introduce the new directionality approach consisting of the two measures spike - order and spike train order ( section [ ss : spike - order ] ) as well as the synfire indicator ( section [ ss : synfire - indicator ] ) before we discuss the use of spike - order surrogates to evaluate the statistical significance of the results in section [ ss : statistical - significance ] . the results section [ s : results ] consists of three subsections detailing applications of the new approach to artificially generated datasets ( section [ ss : results - sim ] ) , neurophysiological data ( section [ ss : results - neuro ] ) and climate data from the el nio phenomenon ( section [ ss : results - climate ] ) . conclusions are drawn in section [ s : discussion ] . finally , both real datasets are described in the appendix , the electrophysiological recordings in appendix [ app - s : hm - data ] , and the el nio dataset ) in appendix [ app - s : elnino - data ] . analyzing leader - follower relationships in a spike train set requires a criterion that determines which spikes should be compared against each other . what is needed is a match maker , a method which pairs spikes in such a way that each spike is matched with at most one spike in each of the other spike trains . this match maker already exists . it is the adaptive coincidence detection first used as the fundamental ingredient for the bivariate measure _ event synchronization _ ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . event synchronization itself is symmetric and quantifies the overall level of synchrony from the number of quasi - simultaneous appearances of spikes . it was proposed along with an asymmetric measure termed _ delay asymmetry _ which evaluates the temporal order among matching spikes in the two spike trains . however , unfortunately both event synchronization and delay asymmetry are defined for the bivariate case of two spike trains only , rely on sampled time profiles , and have a very non - intuitive normalization . for the symmetric variant we have already addressed these issues by proposing _ spike - synchronization _ @xcite , a renormalized multivariate extension of event synchronization . the two new measures spike - order and spike train order proposed here improve and extend the asymmetric measure delay asymmetry in the same way . in particular , instead of just quantifying bivariate directionality they open up a completely new application , since they allow us to sort the spike trains according to the typical relative order of their spikes and to quantify the consistency of this order using the synfire indicator . all four approaches ( bivariate / multivariate , symmetric / asymmetric ) are time - resolved as well as parameter- and scale - free . their calculation consists of two steps , adaptive coincidence detection followed by a combination of normalization and windowing . the first step , adaptive coincidence detection , is the same for all of these measures . most coincidence detectors rely on a coincidence window of fixed size @xmath2 @xcite . however , since in many cases it is very difficult to judge whether two spikes are coincident or not without taking the local context into account ( see fig . [ fig : spike_order_coincidence - detection_comb]a for an example ) , @xcite proposed a more flexible coincidence detection . this coincidence detection is scale- and thus parameter - free since the minimum time lag @xmath3 at which two spikes @xmath4 and @xmath5 of spike trains @xmath6 and @xmath7 are no longer considered to be synchronous is adapted to the local firing rates according to @xmath8 for some applications it might be appropriate to additionally introduce a maximum coincidence window @xmath9 as a parameter . this way additional knowledge about the data ( such as typical propagation speed ) can be taken into account in order to guarantee that two coincident spikes are really part of the same propagation front . such a maximum coincidence window will be used in the application to the el nio climate data in section [ ss : results - climate ] . in normalization and windowing spike - synchronization @xcite has evolved so substantially from event synchronization that here we refrain from going into any detail on the original measure , but rather just mention the main improvements . for a thorough introduction to event synchronization please refer to the original paper @xcite , a more detailed comparison of the two measures can be found in @xcite . the main difference is that spike - synchronization @xcite results in a discrete , not a continuous , spike - timing based profile . the coincidence criterion is quantified by means of a coincidence indicator @xmath10 ( and analogously for @xmath11 ) which assigns to each spike either a one or a zero depending on whether this spike is part of a coincidence or not . note that here , unlike for event synchronization , the minimum function and the @xmath12 guarantee that a spike can at most be coincident with one spike ( the nearest one ) in the other spike train . in case a spike is right in the middle between two spikes from the other spike train there is no ambiguity since this spike is not coincident with either one of them . ( a ) this example demonstrates the usefulness of an adaptive coincidence detection . depending on context the same two spikes ( left ) can appear as coincident ( right , top ) or as non - coincident ( right , bottom ) . ( b ) illustration of the adaptive coincidence detection . for clarity spikes and their coincidence windows are shown alternatively in bright and dark color . the first step assigns to each spike @xmath4 of the first spike train a potential coincidence window which does not overlap with any other coincidence window : @xmath13 . thus any spike from the second spike train can at most be coincident with one spike from the first spike train . small vertical lines mark the times right in the middle between two spikes , and a line is dashed when it does not mark the edge of a coincidence window . ( c ) in the same way a coincidence window @xmath14 is defined for spike @xmath5 from the second spike train . for two spikes to be coincident they both have to lie in each other s coincidence window which means that their absolute time difference has to be smaller than @xmath15 ( which is equivalent to the shorter definition found in eq . [ eq : coincidence - maxdist ] ) . for the two spikes @xmath4 and @xmath5 on the left side this is the case , whereas the spikes on the right side are not coincident.,width=321 ] this unambiguity , illustrated in fig . [ fig : spike_order_coincidence - detection_comb]b , is the essential property which allows the adaptive coincidence detection to act as a match - maker for the subsequent application of spike - synchronization . [ fig : spike_order_coincidence - detection_comb]c shows examples , one with two coincident and one with two non - coincident spikes . spike - synchronization . note that the profile @xmath16 is defined only at the times of the spikes but a better visualization is achieved by connecting the individual dots . by construction the pooled spike train of these examples is identical consisting of @xmath17 evenly spaced bursts . the only difference is the distribution of the spikes among the individual spike trains which varies from maximum to minimum via intermediate synchrony . spike - synchronization correctly indicates these changes . ( a ) maximum reliability results in the value one over the whole time interval . each spike train contains one spike per firing event . ( b ) synfire pattern of bursts resulting in minimum reliability corresponding to the value zero for the whole time interval . ( c ) a random distribution of spikes among spike trains yields intermediate values.,width=321 ] a multivariate version of spike - synchronization can be defined by generalizing the bivariate coincidence detection of eq . [ eq : bi12-spike - synchronization ] to all pairs of spike trains @xmath18 with @xmath19 and @xmath20 denoting the number of spike trains : @xmath21 here @xmath22 is defined equivalent to eq . [ eq : coincidence - maxdist ] . subsequently , for each spike of every spike train a normalized coincidence counter @xmath23 is obtained by averaging over all @xmath24 bivariate coincidence indicators involving the spike train @xmath25 . in order to obtain a single multivariate similarity profile we pool the spikes of all the spike trains as well as their coincidence counters by introducing one overall spike index @xmath26 : @xmath27 note that in case there exist perfectly coincident spikes , @xmath26 counts over all of these spikes . from this discrete set of coincidence counters @xmath28 the spike - synchronization profile @xmath29 is obtained via @xmath30 . finally , spike - synchronization is defined as the average value of this profile @xmath31 with @xmath32 denoting the total number of spikes in the pooled spike train . this way we have used the same consistent framework for both the bivariate and the multivariate case . the former is just a special case of the latter . the interpretation is very intuitive : spike - synchronization quantifies the overall fraction of coincidences . it reaches one if and only if each spike in every spike train has one matching spike in all the other spike trains ( or if there are no spikes at all ) , and it attains the value zero if and only if the spike trains do not contain any coincidences . examples for both of these extreme cases can be found in fig . [ fig : spike_order_spike_sync_3]a and [ fig : spike_order_spike_sync_3]b and one intermediate example ( random distribution of spikes among spike trains ) is shown in fig . [ fig : spike_order_spike_sync_3]c . for a derivation of the expectation value for poisson spike trains please refer to @xcite . in the multivariate analysis proposed in this paper , spike - synchronization can be used to filter the input to the algorithm . in order to focus on propagation patterns within truly global events it is possible to set a threshold value @xmath33 for the spike - synchronization profile @xmath29 . this way only spikes with a coincidence value higher than this parameter @xmath33 are taken into account , all the other noisy background spikes are simply ignored . this kind of filter will be used in the analysis of the neurophysiological datasets in section [ ss : results - neuro ] . spike - synchronization assigns to each spike of a given spike train pair a bivariate coincidence indicator . these coincidence indicators @xmath34 , which are either @xmath35 or @xmath0 , are then averaged over spike train pairs and converted into one overall profile @xmath29 normalized between @xmath35 and @xmath0 . in exactly the same manner spike - order and spike train order assign bivariate order indicators to spikes . also these two order indicators , the asymmetric @xmath36 and the symmetric @xmath37 , which both can take the values @xmath38 , @xmath35 , or @xmath39 , are averaged over spike train pairs and converted into two overall profiles @xmath40 and @xmath41 which are normalized between @xmath38 and @xmath0 . the spike - order profile @xmath40 distinguishes leading and following spikes , whereas the spike train order profile @xmath41 provides information about the order of spike trains , i.e. it allows to sort spike trains from leaders to followers . spike - order profile @xmath40 and spike train order profile @xmath41 for an artificially created example dataset . ( a ) the rasterplot shows @xmath42 spike trains which emit spikes in nine reliable events . for the first two events spikes fire in order , for the next three events the order is random whereas for the last four events the order is inverted . in the last event there is one spike missing . spike thickness decodes the spike - synchronization value @xmath29 ( here almost constant ) , spike color the spike - order value @xmath40 . ( b , c ) the spike - synchronization profile @xmath29 and its mirror profile ( dashed black lines ) act as envelope for both the spike - order profile @xmath40 ( b , red ) and the spike train order profile @xmath41 ( c , black ) . ( b ) the spike - order profile can not distinguish events with different firing order and by construction the average value is always @xmath43 . ( c ) on the other hand , in the spike train order profile events with different firing order can clearly be distinguished . for the first two correctly ordered events the value @xmath0 is obtained . the next three events exhibit random order and correspondingly the profile fluctuates rather wildly . finally , the last four inversely ordered yield the value @xmath38 except for the last event for which the absolute minimum value can not be obtained since one spike is missing . the average value , the synfire indicator @xmath44 , is not @xmath35 but negative which reflects the dominance of the inversely ordered events . , width=321 ] first of all , similar to the transition from the symmetric event synchronization to delay asymmetry , the symmetric coincidence indicator @xmath45 of spike - synchronization ( eq . [ eq : bi - spike - synchronization ] ) is replaced by the asymmetric spike - order indicator @xmath46 where the index @xmath47 is defined from the minimum in . the corresponding value @xmath48 is obtained in an asymmetric manner as @xmath49 therefore , this indicator assigns to each spike either a @xmath0 or a @xmath38 depending on whether the respective spike is leading or following a coincident spike from the other spike train . the value @xmath35 is obtained for cases in which there is no coincident spike in the other spike train ( @xmath50 ) , but also in cases in which the times of the two coincident spikes are absolutely identical ( @xmath51 ) . the multivariate profile @xmath40 obtained analogously to eq . [ eq : multi - profile ] is normalized between @xmath0 and @xmath38 and the extreme values are obtained if a spike is either leading ( @xmath39 ) or following ( @xmath38 ) coincident spikes in all other spike trains . it can be @xmath35 either if a spike is not part of any coincidences or if it leads exactly as many spikes from other spike trains in coincidences as it follows . from the definition in eqs . [ eq : bi - spike - order-1 ] and [ eq : bi - spike - order-2 ] it follows immediately that @xmath28 is an upper bound for the absolute value @xmath52 . while the spike - order profile can be very useful for color - coding and visualizing local spike leaders and followers ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles]a ) , it is not useful as an overall indicator of spike train order ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles]b ) . the profile is invariant under exchange of spike trains , i.e. it looks the same for all events no matter what the order of the firing is ( in our example only the last event looks slightly different since one spike is missing ) . moreover , summing over all profile values , which is equivalent to summing over all coincidences , necessarily leads to an average value of @xmath35 , since for every leading spike ( @xmath39 ) there has to be a following spike ( @xmath38 ) . so in order to quantify any kind of leader - follower information between spike trains we need a second kind of order indicator . the spike train order indicator is similar to the spike - order indicator defined in eqs . [ eq : bi - spike - order-1 ] and [ eq : bi - spike - order-2 ] but with two important differences . both spikes are assigned the same value and this value now depends on the order of the spike trains : @xmath53 and @xmath54 this symmetric indicator assigns to both spikes a @xmath39 in case the two spikes are in the correct order , i.e. the spike from the spike train with the lower spike train index is leading the coincidence , and a @xmath38 in the opposite case . once more the value @xmath35 is obtained when there is no coincident spike in the other spike train or when the two coincident spikes are absolutely identical . the multivariate profile @xmath41 , again obtained similarly to eq . [ eq : multi - profile ] , is also normalized between @xmath0 and @xmath38 and the extreme values are obtained for a coincident event covering all spike trains with all spikes emitted in the order from first ( last ) to last ( first ) spike train , respectively ( see the first two and the last four events in fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles ] ) . it can be @xmath35 either if a spike is not a part of any coincidences or if the order is such that correctly and incorrectly ordered spike train pairs cancel each other . again , @xmath28 is an upper bound for the absolute value of @xmath55 . in contrast to the spike - order profile @xmath56 , for the spike train order profile @xmath55 it does make sense to define an average value , which we term the synfire indicator : @xmath57 the interpretation is very intuitive . the synfire indicator @xmath44 quantifies to what degree the spike trains in their current order resemble a perfect synfire pattern . it is normalized between @xmath0 and @xmath38 and attains the value @xmath0 ( @xmath38 ) if the spike trains in their current order form a perfect ( inverse ) synfire pattern , meaning that all spikes are coincident with spikes in all other spike trains and that the order from leading ( following ) to following ( leading ) spike train remains consistent for all of these events . it is @xmath35 either if the spike trains do not contain any coincidences at all or if among all spike trains there is a complete symmetry between leading and following spikes . the spike train order profile @xmath41 for our example is shown in fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles]c . in this case the order of spikes within an event clearly matters . the synfire indicator @xmath44 is slightly negative indicating that the current order of the spike trains is actually closer to an inverse synfire pattern . pairwise cumulative spike - order matrix @xmath58 before ( left ) and after ( right ) sorting for the example dataset from fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles ] . the upper triangular matrix @xmath59 , marked in black , is used to calculate the synfire indicator @xmath44 , for both the unsorted spike trains ( @xmath60 , left ) and the sorted spike trains ( @xmath61 , right ) . the thick black arrow in between the two matrices indicates the sorting process . , width=321 ] given a set of spike trains we now would like to sort the spike trains from leader to follower such that the set comes as close as possible to a synfire pattern . to do so we have to maximize the overall number of correctly ordered coincidences and this is equivalent to maximizing the synfire indicator @xmath44 . however , it would be very difficult to achieve this maximization by means of the multivariate profile @xmath41 . clearly , it is more efficient to sort the spike trains based on a pairwise analysis of the spike trains . the most intuitive way is to use the anti - symmetric cumulative spike - order matrix @xmath62 which sums up orders of coincidences from the respective pair of spike trains only and quantifies how much spike train @xmath25 is leading spike train @xmath63 ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_2_matrices ] ) . hence if @xmath64 spike train @xmath25 is leading @xmath63 , while @xmath65 means @xmath63 is leading @xmath25 . if the current spike train order is consistent with the synfire property , we thus expect that @xmath66 for @xmath67 and @xmath68 for @xmath69 . therefore , we construct the overall spike - order as @xmath70 i.e. the sum over the upper right tridiagonal part of the matrix @xmath71 . after normalizing by the overall number of possible coincidences , we arrive at a second more practical definition of the synfire indicator : @xmath72 the value is identical to the one of eq . [ eq : synfire indicator - e ] , only the temporal and the spatial summation of coincidences ( i.e. , over the profile and over spike train pairs ) are performed in the opposite order . having such a quantification depending on the order of spike trains , we can introduce a new ordering in terms of the spike train index permutation @xmath73 . the overall synfire indicator for this permutation is then denoted as @xmath74 . accordingly , for the initial ( * * u**nsorted ) order of spike trains @xmath75 the synfire indicator is denoted as @xmath76 . the aim of the analysis is now to find the optimal ( * * s**orted ) order @xmath77 as the one resulting in the maximal overall synfire indicator @xmath78 : @xmath79 this synfire indicator for the sorted spike trains quantifies how close spike trains can be sorted to resemble a synfire pattern , i.e. , to what extent coinciding spike pairs with correct order prevail over coinciding spike pairs with incorrect order . unlike the synfire indicator for the unsorted spike trains @xmath60 , the optimized synfire indicator @xmath61 can only attain values between @xmath35 and @xmath0 ( any order that yields a negative result could simply be reversed in order to obtain the same positive value ) . for a perfect synfire pattern we obtain @xmath80 , while sufficiently long poisson spike trains without any synfire structure yield @xmath81 . the complexity of the problem to find the optimal spike train order is similar to the well - known travelling salesman problem @xcite . for @xmath20 spike trains there are @xmath82 permutations @xmath83 so for large numbers of spike trains finding the optimal spike train order @xmath77 is a non - trivial problem and brute - force methods such as calculating the @xmath74-value for all possible permutations are not feasible . instead , one has to make use of methods such as parallel tempering @xcite or simulated annealing @xcite to search for the optimal order . here we choose simulated annealing , a probabilistic technique which approximates the global optimum of a given function in a large search space . in our case this function is the synfire indicator @xmath74 ( which we would like to maximize ) and the search space is the permutation space of all spike trains . we start with the @xmath60-value from the unsorted permutation and then visit nearby permutations using the fundamental move of exchanging two neighboring spike trains within the current permutation . all moves with positive @xmath84 are accepted while the likelihood of accepting moves with negative @xmath84 is decreased along the way according to a standard slow cooling scheme . the procedure is repeated iteratively until the order of the spike trains no longer changes or until a predefined end temperature is reached . in fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example-3 ] we show the complete spike - order analysis including the results for the sorted spike trains . the sorting of the spike trains maximizes the synfire indicator as reflected by both the normalized sum of the upper right half of the pairwise cumulative spike - order matrix ( eq.[eq : synfire indicator - d ] , fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example-3]c ) and the average value of the spike train order profile @xmath85 ( eq.[eq : synfire indicator - e ] , fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example-3]d ) . finally , the sorted spike trains in fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example-3]e are now ordered such that the first spike trains have predominantly high values ( red ) and the last spike trains predominantly low values ( blue ) of @xmath86 . complete illustration of spike - order using our example dataset from fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles ] . ( a ) unsorted spike trains with the spikes color - coded according to the value of the spike - order @xmath40 . ( b ) spike train order profile @xmath41 . the synfire indicator @xmath60 for the unsorted spike trains is slightly negative . ( c ) pairwise spike - order matrix @xmath58 before and after sorting . the optimal order maximizes the upper triangular matrix . ( d ) spike train order profile @xmath41 and its average values , the synfire indicator @xmath61 for the sorted spike trains . ( e ) sorted spike trains.,width=321 ] the complete analysis returns results consisting of several levels of information . time - resolved ( local ) information is represented in the spike - coloring and in the profiles @xmath58 and @xmath87 . the pairwise information in the spike - order matrix reflects the leader - follower relationship between two spike trains at a time . the synfire indicator @xmath44 characterizes the closeness of the dataset as a whole to a synfire pattern , both for the unsorted ( @xmath60 ) and for the sorted ( @xmath61 ) spike trains . finally , the sorted order of the spike trains is a very important result in itself since it identifies the leading and the following spike trains . as a last step in the analysis we evaluate the statistical significance of the optimized synfire indicator @xmath61 using a set of carefully constructed spike train surrogates . the idea behind the surrogate test is to evaluate the likelihood that the consistent spike - order pattern yielding a certain synfire indicator could have been obtained by chance . to this aim , for each surrogate we maintain the coincidence structure of the spike trains by keeping the spike - synchronization values of each individual spike constant but randomly swap the spike order in a sufficient number of coincidences . we set the number of swaps equal to the number of coincident spikes in the dataset since this way all possible spike order patterns can be reached . only for the first surrogate we swap twice as many coincidences in order to account for transients . after each swap we take extra care that all other spike orders that are affected by the swap are updated as well . for example , if a swap changes the order between the first and the third spike in an ordered sequence of three spikes , we also swap both the order between the first and the second and the order between the second and the third spike . statistical significance : surrogate analysis for the example dataset from fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example_1_profiles ] . ( a ) spike order patterns for original ( black ) and one randomized surrogate ( red ) . for clarity only the first four events are shown . for the first two events the synfire - order of the original is destroyed in the surrogates whereas for the next two events both sequences are equally unordered . ( b ) histogram for @xmath88 surrogates . thick lines denote mean and standard deviation . since the value for the original dataset ( black ) is not maximum , the optimally sorted spike trains do not exhibit a statistically significant synfire pattern . , width=321 ] note that when creating surrogates we change the order of spikes but we do not swap actual spikes between different spike trains ( see fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_80_standard_example_4_surro - histo]a , note that the x - axis is labeled time index , not time ) . spike trains with shuffled spikes would have different interspike intervals and this would alter the results of the coincidence criterion of eq . [ eq : coincidence - maxdist ] . we would obtain different values of spike train order just because of different spike - synchronization values and this would make the desired evaluation of pure spike order effects difficult . however , for every surrogate that we create it is possible to reconstruct actual spike trains with exactly that spike - order patterns . for each spike train surrogate we repeat exactly the same optimization procedure in the spike train permutation space that is done for the original dataset . the original synfire indicator is deemed significant if it is higher than the synfire indicator obtained for all of the surrogate datasets ( this case will be marked by two asterisks ) . here we use @xmath89 surrogates for a significance level of @xmath90 . as a second indicator we state the z - score , e.g. , the deviation of the original value @xmath91 from the mean @xmath92 of the surrogates in units of their standard deviation @xmath93 : @xmath94 results of the significance analysis for our standard example are shown in the histogram in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_80_standard_example_4_surro - histo]b . in this case the absolute value of the z - score is smaller than one and the p - value is larger than @xmath95 and the result is thus judged as statistically non - significant . in case the initial sorting of the spike trains is used to test a specific hypothesis there also exists a straightforward procedure to test the statistical significance of the synfire indicator @xmath60 for the unsorted spike trains . in this case no optimization of the synfire indicator is required , rather the synfire indicator @xmath60 for the initial sorting is compared against synfire indicators obtained for random permutations of the spike trains . this kind of significance test will be used in section [ ss : results - neuro ] . in the following we apply our new algorithm to artificially generated datasets ( section [ ss : results - sim ] ) , neurophysiological data ( section [ ss : results - neuro ] ) and , finally , climate data from the el nio phenomenon ( section [ ss : results - climate ] ) . for the figures we use the same full layout introduced in fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example-3 ] to which we add the significance analysis of fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_80_standard_example_4_surro - histo]b . spike- and spike train order analysis for a perfect inverse synfire pattern . the plot follows the layout of fig . [ fig : spike_order_80_standard_example-3 ] with the histogram of the surrogate test ( see fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_80_standard_example_4_surro - histo]b ) for statistical significance added as subplot f. for the unsorted spike trains a minimal synfire indicator of @xmath96 is obtained , while sorting results in the maximum value of @xmath80 . according to the surrogate test the statistical significance of the result is very high.,width=321 ] we start with examples covering the two extreme cases of a perfect synfire pattern and a completely random spike train set . first , in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_2_synfire_inv ] we apply the algorithm to a perfect inverse synfire pattern for which the spike trains are initially sorted from follower to leader . therefore , the synfire indicator of the unsorted spike trains yields its minimum value of @xmath97 . sorting just reverses the order of the spike trains and in consequence the maximum value of @xmath98 is obtained . any shuffling of spike orders necessarily destroys the synfire pattern and thus leads to much lower values of the synfire indicator . accordingly , the surrogate test ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_2_synfire_inv]f ) shows that the statistical significance of the original synfire indicator is very high . spike- and spike train order analysis for @xmath99 poisson spike trains . since the number of spike trains is too large to label the spike trains in the top and in the bottom subplot with numbers we use color coding at the left side to label them . both before and after sorting the synfire indicator is very close to zero . the surrogate analysis reveals the result to be non - significant.,width=321 ] the other extreme case is poisson spike trains ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_51_poisson ] ) for which the arrival times of spikes are completely random and without any preferred order . for this realization the synfire indicator @xmath60 for the unsorted spike trains happens to be slightly negative indicating that the spike trains are closer to an inverse synfire pattern than to a synfire pattern . the absolute value @xmath61 after sorting is higher . the fact that both of these values are non - zero is due to the finite size effect caused by the limited number of spikes . for more and more spike trains and/or spikes the expectation value even for the sorted case would converge towards zero . as expected , the surrogate test shows that the order for the original spike trains is not statistically distinct from the order of the surrogate spike trains ( there is no preferred order that can be destroyed by the shuffling ) and , accordingly , the value of the original synfire indicator is revealed to be clearly non - significant . spike- and spike train order analysis for poisson spike train interspersed with a perfect inverse synfire pattern . the order contained within the synfire pattern spike train is distinct enough to make the synfire indicator for the sorted spike trains statistically significant.,width=321 ] the third example in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_57_mix_poisson_sf ] shows a mixture of these two extremes , poisson spike train interspersed with spike trains forming a perfect inverse synfire pattern . sorting the spike trains restores the correct order of the synfire pattern spike trains within the poisson spike train . the synfire indicator for the sorted spike trains @xmath61 for this mixed example is actually very close to the value obtained for the poisson spike trains in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_51_poisson ] , but this time the surrogate test reveals the value to be highly significant . together these two examples illustrate nicely that the synfire indicator and the surrogate analysis provide complementary information . in the mixture example of fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_57_mix_poisson_sf ] there are many more random poisson spikes than ordered synfire pattern spikes . together they appear to be as ordered as the shorter but purely random poisson spike trains in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_51_poisson ] . the synfire indicator is strongly influenced by the statistics of the dataset and thus is in itself not sufficient to reliably compare two datasets with widely different number of spike trains and spikes . the surrogate analysis , on the other hand , can be used to compare datasets of different size since by preserving the spike numbers in the surrogates it explicitly takes the statistics of each dataset into account . in order to apply the spike train order algorithm to real neurophysiological data , we analyzed data recorded via fast multicellular calcium imaging in acute ca3 hippocampal brain slices from juvenile mice ( for a detailed description of the experimental methods see appendix [ app - s : hm - data ] ) . in the juvenile hippocampus , the ca3 region is the origin of a stereotypical network phenomenon of wavelike propagating activity termed giant depolarizing potentials ( gdp , @xcite , @xcite ) . in previous studies , gdps have been used to investigate the topology of networks and the role of hub cells @xcite as well as to reveal the deterministic and stochastic processes underlying spontaneous , synchronous network bursts @xcite . due to the distinct architecture and the repetitive nature of the gdps this experimental setup offers a very suitable test case for our synfire pattern analysis . spike - order for real data recorded in an acute hippocampal slice from a juvenile mouse . ( a ) initially the spike trains are sorted according to their firing rate starting with the most sparse spike trains . ( f ) after sorting , note the fairly consistent transition from spike trains with predominantly leading spikes ( red ) in the gdps to spike trains with predominantly following spikes ( blue ) . , width=321 ] the first dataset analyzed in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn ] includes @xmath100 gdps over a bit more than @xmath42 minutes . almost all gdps involve the whole network . here as for all other neurophysiological datasets analyzed initially the spike trains are sorted according to their firing rate such that the sparsely spiking neurons are on top and the most active neurons at the bottom ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn]a ) . this specific sorting allows us to test the hypothesis that the neurons which fire almost exclusively within the gdps and are very sparse on background activity might have a stronger role in initiating gdps and tend to lead , whereas the more regularly spiking neurons might tend to follow . if this would be the case one would expect a very high value for the initial synfire indicator @xmath60 . however , according to fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn]b the actual value is very close to zero and actually slightly negative . a statistical significance test using random permutations of spike trains ( see section [ ss : statistical - significance ] ) indeed proves the synfire indicator of the unsorted spike trains @xmath60 to be non - significant ( result not shown ) . a further indicator for this is the fact that the order of the sorted spike trains is very different from the initial order , as can be seen by comparing the color bars on the left of fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn]a and fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn]e . the color - coding of the gdps exhibits typically a slightly noisy transition from leader ( red ) to follower ( blue ) . the synfire indicator for the sorted spike trains @xmath61 is also much higher ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn]d ) . finally , the surrogate analysis ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn]f ) shows this result to be highly significant . spike - order for the real data already analyzed in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn ] but this time the analysis of spike - order was restricted to spikes with a spike - synchronization value of at least @xmath101 . this simple thresholding allows focusing the analysis on the reliable events and disregards all spiking between the events . this results in an increase of the overall value of spike - order from @xmath102 to @xmath103 . , width=321 ] however , the spiking in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn ] consists not only of the gdps . most neurons exhibit at least to some extent spontaneous background activity , the ones at the top of the initial sorting less than the ones at the bottom . the spikes in this background activity are typically coincident with only few other spikes and do not take part in any propagation patterns ( note their green color which indicates spike - order values close to zero ) . so in the context of our synfire pattern analysis this is just noise that leads to a decrease of the synfire indicator . there is a straightforward way to disregard these background spikes by setting a threshold value @xmath33 for the spike - synchronization profile @xmath29 . only spikes with a coincidence value higher than @xmath33 are taken into account , all other spikes are simply ignored . the result of this background correction can be seen in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_159_hm_5_1_sn ] for the same dataset already used in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn ] . focusing the analysis on the reliable gdps leads to an increase of the synfire indicator from @xmath102 to @xmath103 . projection of the optimized spike train order on the 2d - plot of the hippocampal slice . the regions of interest ( rois ) which denote filled and identified cells in the ca3 region are color - coded from leader ( index @xmath0 , red ) to follower ( index @xmath104 , blue ) using the optimized spike train order of fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_159_hm_5_1_sn ] . the very first leader ( lower right ) and the very last follower ( upper left ) are marked by filled contours . , width=321 ] as already mentioned before , one of the main results of our analysis is the sorted order of the spike trains itself . for these neurophysiological data it allows to identify the leading and the following neurons in the network and to project this information back on the recording setup this is shown in fig . [ fig:2d - plot - colorcoding-159 ] where we have color - coded the optimized spike train order obtained in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_159_hm_5_1_sn ] within a 2d - plot of the neurons recorded from the hippocampal slice . for this example there appears to be a clear overall propagation from right to left but there is also a considerable degree of noisiness which might be due to a non - trivial connectivity within the network . spike - order for a second dataset for which again the analysis of spike - order was restricted to spikes with a spike - synchronization value of at least @xmath101 . in this case the focus on the gdps let the synfire indicator increase from @xmath105 ( result not shown ) to @xmath106 . in addition , here we also calculated one average spike train order value per gdp ( green points ) which illustrates once more the time - resolved nature of the method . , width=321 ] in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_175_hm_23_1_sn_div ] we apply the spike - order analysis to a second dataset recorded from a different slice , again focusing on the order within the global events only . here we also added one new feature , the mean value of the spike train order @xmath41 for each global event ( we use the maxima and minima of the spike order profile @xmath40 to delineate the gdps ) . this again emphasizes the time - resolved nature of the spike order and the spike train order indicators . overall , we have analyzed neurophysiological datasets from four hippocampal slices exhibiting an average of @xmath107 gdps . we obtained an average value for spike - synchronization of @xmath108 before focusing on the gdps ( as in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_109_hm_5_1_sn ] ) and @xmath109 after ( as in fig . [ fig : spike_order_surro_159_hm_5_1_sn ] ) . with or without this focus the synfire indicator for the initial spike train sorting @xmath60 was very close to zero and in all cases proved to be non - significant when tested against synfire indicators obtained for random permutations of the spike train order . since the initial sorting was based on overall firing rate of the neurons , this signifies that the hypothesis that the low - firing neurons which are basically only active during the gdps might have a stronger role in initiating gdps can be rejected . for the sorted spike trains the synfire indicator @xmath61 was @xmath110 for all spikes and @xmath111 for the spikes within the gdps only . suppressing the effect of the noisy background spikes in the analysis thus leads to an average increase of the synfire indicator by about @xmath112 . finally , according to the surrogate analysis described in section [ ss : statistical - significance ] the synfire indicator for the sorted spike trains @xmath61 yielded a statistically significant result for all datasets analyzed . so overall we can conclude that these gdps recorded in brain slices from juvenile mice are distinguished by a very high consistency of their spatio - temporal propagation patterns . although being developed mainly for neuroscientific data ( spike train recordings ) , the spike train order approach presented in this paper can be applied in many other contexts as well . one particular field where event - based analysis is employed very frequently is climate science , see e.g. @xcite . in the following we will use the new spike train order method to analyze the sea surface temperature ( sst ) in the central and eastern tropical pacific ocean to identify the propagation patterns connected with the warm phase of the el nio southern oscillation ( enso ) . predicting the occurrence and strength of el nios is very important due to the vast ecological and economical effects @xcite and therefore this phenomenon has been studied extensively in terms of both intensity ( e.g. @xcite , @xcite ; @xcite , @xcite ) and frequency ( e.g. @xcite , @xcite ; @xcite , @xcite ) . however , here we will not discuss el nio prediction , but focus on the longitudinal propagation pattern of the el nio events within the pacific ocean @xcite . the region used here to analyze the sst is depicted in fig . [ fig : el_nino_region ] ( dashed line ) , and an examplary smoothed time profile for the center of the analyzed region ( @xmath113 ) is shown in fig . [ fig : time_series ] . further details on the region , the dataset and data preprocessing ( smoothing ) is outlined in appendix [ app - s : elnino - data ] . ) on november 11 , 2015.,scaledwidth=49.0% ] before ( red ) and after ( black ) gaussian smoothing . the horizontal dashed line corresponds to a temperature threshold of @xmath114 used for event detection and the vertical lines are the resulting events identified from upward threshold crossings of the smoothed time series.,scaledwidth=49.0% ] starting from the smoothed sst profiles , we performed an event detection by identifying the onset of the sst anomaly connected with an el nio in terms of an _ upward crossing _ of the smoothed time series with a temperature anomaly threshold @xmath115 . as we are interested in the initial propagation front for each el nio event , we additionally introduce an artificial _ refractory period _ of 11 months , which means threshold crossings occurring within 11 months after previous event are disregarded . [ fig : time_series ] depicts this procedure for a threshold value @xmath114 leading to the identification of three events in this example ( vertical lines in fig . [ fig : time_series ] ) . from this , we finally arrive at @xmath116 discrete event series corresponding to the onsets of el nio sst anomaly elevations at the different longitudinal locations along the dashed line in fig . [ fig : el_nino_region ] . the resulting spike trains are depicted in fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis ] on the left for four different threshold values @xmath117 ( step size of @xmath118 ) . the first thing to note is that this event detection procedure is able to correctly identify the el nio occurrences as seen from the horizontal event structure in accordance with the el nio years ( labeled on the @xmath91-axis in the raster plots a - d ) as well as the consistently high spike - synchronization values @xmath119 for all threshold values . with increasing temperature threshold , however , only the three strongest el nio events are being captured ( 1983 , 1998 and 2016 , bold labels in fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis ] ) as seen from fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]c and fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]d . , @xmath120 ) smoothed in time using a gaussian kernel with width of @xmath121 . events are defined as initial threshold crossings of the smoothed temperature time series ( see text ) . from top to bottom four different threshold values have been used : @xmath117 . the left graphs ( a - d ) show the event raster plots with with spike - order value in color coding using an east - to - west ordering . the years shown on the @xmath91-axis ( representing january 1st of the indicated year ) denote the moderate and strong ( bold face ) el nio events . on the right ( e - h ) , the optimal leader - follower order compared to an initial east - to - west sorting is shown ( circles : spike trains with at least 2 spikes , triangles : spike trains with less than two spikes ) . additionally , the spike - synchronization @xmath119 as well as the synfire indicator for the original ( east - to - west ) @xmath122 , and the optimal sorting @xmath123 are reported . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + , @xmath120 ) smoothed in time using a gaussian kernel with width of @xmath121 . events are defined as initial threshold crossings of the smoothed temperature time series ( see text ) . from top to bottom four different threshold values have been used : @xmath117 . the left graphs ( a - d ) show the event raster plots with with spike - order value in color coding using an east - to - west ordering . the years shown on the @xmath91-axis ( representing january 1st of the indicated year ) denote the moderate and strong ( bold face ) el nio events . on the right ( e - h ) , the optimal leader - follower order compared to an initial east - to - west sorting is shown ( circles : spike trains with at least 2 spikes , triangles : spike trains with less than two spikes ) . additionally , the spike - synchronization @xmath119 as well as the synfire indicator for the original ( east - to - west ) @xmath122 , and the optimal sorting @xmath123 are reported . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + , @xmath120 ) smoothed in time using a gaussian kernel with width of @xmath121 . events are defined as initial threshold crossings of the smoothed temperature time series ( see text ) . from top to bottom four different threshold values have been used : @xmath117 . the left graphs ( a - d ) show the event raster plots with with spike - order value in color coding using an east - to - west ordering . the years shown on the @xmath91-axis ( representing january 1st of the indicated year ) denote the moderate and strong ( bold face ) el nio events . on the right ( e - h ) , the optimal leader - follower order compared to an initial east - to - west sorting is shown ( circles : spike trains with at least 2 spikes , triangles : spike trains with less than two spikes ) . additionally , the spike - synchronization @xmath119 as well as the synfire indicator for the original ( east - to - west ) @xmath122 , and the optimal sorting @xmath123 are reported . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + , @xmath120 ) smoothed in time using a gaussian kernel with width of @xmath121 . events are defined as initial threshold crossings of the smoothed temperature time series ( see text ) . from top to bottom four different threshold values have been used : @xmath117 . the left graphs ( a - d ) show the event raster plots with with spike - order value in color coding using an east - to - west ordering . the years shown on the @xmath91-axis ( representing january 1st of the indicated year ) denote the moderate and strong ( bold face ) el nio events . on the right ( e - h ) , the optimal leader - follower order compared to an initial east - to - west sorting is shown ( circles : spike trains with at least 2 spikes , triangles : spike trains with less than two spikes ) . additionally , the spike - synchronization @xmath119 as well as the synfire indicator for the original ( east - to - west ) @xmath122 , and the optimal sorting @xmath123 are reported . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] to quantify the consistency of the propagation patterns , we perform a spike train order analysis on these event sequences . the results are also presented in fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis ] . as a central observation , we found that for the three strong el nio events ( 1983 , 1998 , 2016 ) , there is a clear consistent propagation of the sst anomaly elevation at the equator from east to west as confirmed by a synfire indicator of @xmath124 for the east - to - west sorting ( @xmath114 , fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]c ) . furthermore , optimizing the synfire indicator by changing the sorting only leads to minor improvements ( @xmath125 ) and the resulting optimal order is very close to the original east - to - west sorting indicated in fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]g . finally , this observation is also confirmed by the spike - order based color coding in the raster plots ( c ) of the spike trains . for each of the three major el nio events ( 1983 , 1998 , 2016 ) we see a clear tendency of leader ( red ) to follower ( blue ) going from east ( top ) to west ( bottom ) for all three threshold values . further increase of the threshold temperature ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]d and h ) leads to essentially the same observation , but parts of the longitudinal propagation might be missed as the sst anomaly maxima stay below threshold . moderate el nio events ( 1992 , 2003 , 2010 ) , on the other hand , seem to propagate in eastwards direction , as seen by opposite directed coloring for those years in fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]b ( @xmath126 ) . consequently , the synfire indicator for the east - to - west sorting is very low , @xmath127 , as some of the propagation events are moving in the opposite direction which reduces the synfire indicator . therefore , it is also not possible to find a correct ordering , as indicated by a rather low optimized synfire indicator of @xmath128 in this case . this is even more pronounced for the smallest threshold temperature @xmath129 , shown in fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]b . there , essentially all moderate el nios are captured and most of those exhibit an eastwards propagation , opposed to the strong el nios that propagate westwards . therefore , the initial synfire indicator for the east - to - west sorting is negative , @xmath130 and the optimal sorting shows the sign of a west - to - east propagation ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis]e ) with @xmath131 . to better understand the dependency of the spike train order analysis on the temperature threshold , we computed the synfire indicator for the initial east - to - west ordering as well as the value for optimal ordering @xmath123 for varying thresholds @xmath132 ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_threshold ] ) . additionally , fig . [ fig : spike_order_threshold ] also shows the spike - synchronization values for these parameters . one first observes that the spike - synchronization remains rather constant over the whole range of threshold values , indicating a consistently good identification of the el nio events . the synfire indicator for the original east - to - west sorting @xmath122 on the other hand shows a clear increase saturating in a plateau for a threshold value of around @xmath114 , where it is then also very close to the optimal value @xmath123 . this is easily understood by the fact that at temperature thresholds above @xmath133 , only the three strong el nios are captured that show a consistent westwards propagation , while for values below also weaker el nios that exhibit eastward propagation enter the analysis . and synfire indicator for the original sorting ( east - to - west ) @xmath122 and the optimal sorting @xmath123 in dependence of the temperature threshold @xmath115.,scaledwidth=42.0% ] in summary , we showed that the newly proposed spike train order method is also readily applicable to climate data and is able to identify propagation patterns in recurring events such as the el nio . our results indicate that close to the equator , strong el nio events exhibit a clear westward propagation of an sst front , while for moderate el nios we found indications for an eastward front propagation . interestingly , previous results based on zonal current velocity within the el nio 3.4 region found eastward propagation for the extreme el nio events in 1983 and 1998 @xcite , while here we found west - ward propagation ( fig . [ fig : spike_order_analysis ] ) . this discrepancy is most likely due to the different regions ( el nio 3.4 vs equatorial strip ) and methodology ( average warming / cooling rates vs front propagation ) . over the last years a wide variety of measures to quantify the synchrony between spike trains have been introduced . three recent proposals , _ isi - distance _ @xcite , _ spike - distance _ @xcite , and _ spike - synchronization _ @xcite , share the desirable property of being time - resolved and parameter - free ( time - scale independent ) . however , their bivariate versions are symmetric and in consequence their multivariate versions are invariant to changes in the order of spike trains . none of these measures is designed to provide information about the directionality of the propagation patterns . in the present study we address this issue . first we use an adaptive coincidence detection as match maker in order to identify pairs of coincident spikes . then we define two measures , the asymmetric _ spike - order _ @xmath58 and the symmetric _ spike train order _ @xmath87 , from which we can derive the _ synfire indicator _ @xmath44 that quantifies the consistency of spatio - temporal propagation patterns and whose maximization allows to sort multiple spike trains from leader to follower . this is meant purely in the sense of temporal sequence of the spikes . the question asked is : which are the spike trains that tend to fire first , and which are the ones that tend to fire last ? we use simulated annealing to search among all permutations of spike trains for the sorting that resembles as closely as possible a synfire pattern , a perfectly consistent repetition of the same global propagation pattern . in a final step we evaluate the statistical significance of the optimized permutation using a set of carefully constructed spike train surrogates . we first illustrate the merits of our new approach using artificially generated datasets and then apply it to real datasets from two very different fields of research , neuroscience and climatology . in the neurophysiological dataset we analyze giant depolarized potentials ( gdps ) recorded from mice brain slices in order to search for potential hub neurons @xcite , whereas in the climate application we quantify the consistency of the longitudinal movement of the propagation front of el nio events @xcite . the new algorithm is conceptually simple , of low computational cost and comes with an intuitive and straightforward visualization . it vastly improves on all the bivariate functionalities of previous directional measures such as delay asymmetry ( no need for sampled profiles , more intuitive normalization etc . ) and could thus also be used in the context of the pairwise matrices , both normalized or cumulative , used in complex network theory @xcite . however , one of the main advantages of the new algorithm is its multivariate nature which opens up completely new kinds of application such as spike train sorting . another advantage of the method is the high flexibility in the definition of events . for example , when looking at the synchronization of neuronal bursts instead of individual spikes one can define the events as the onset , the center or the offset of the activity ( e.g. , the first , the middle or the last spike of each burst ) . in cases in which a burst of spikes is considered to be equivalent to a single spike one could introduce some kind of meta - events and then look at coincidences between these meta - events . the application of our measures is also not restricted to truly discrete data . continuously sampled data can be reduced to a spike train where the only information maintained is the timing of the individual events . often these event times are obtained in a manner similar to how the neuronal spike times are extracted from recordings of neuronal membrane potentials ( usually done via some kind of thresholding ) . examples of sampled data to which measures of spike train synchrony have been applied include eeg data @xcite and , outside of neuroscience , stock market velocity @xcite - and rainfall events @xcite . the universality of the phenomenon , repetitive propagation patterns , makes our new algorithm applicable in a wide array of fields such as medical sciences , seismology , oceanography , meteorology or climatology . the algorithm is particularly suited for data that resemble a synfire pattern of sequences of global events for which , according to the coincidence detection criterion ( eq . [ eq : coincidence - maxdist ] ) , the interval between successive events is at least twice as large as the propagation time within an event . propagation patterns with such characteristics can be found in many different areas . for example , the duration of an epileptic seizure is typically much shorter than the interval between two successive seizures . also the time it takes a storm front to cross a specific region is typically much smaller than the time to the next storm . many other repetitive propagation phenomena exhibit similar ratios of characteristic time scales . in order to understand the scope of our proposed algorithm it is important to understand what it is not designed to achieve . first , the method deals purely with relative order , it does not consider the length of absolute delays . many other methods have been designed to characterize the detailed spatio - temporal structure in large neuronal networks @xcite or to detect hierarchically structured spike - train communities @xcite . the method is also not designed to detect neuronal synfire chains ( in the strict sense of the word ) in massively parallel data . for this task other statistical methods involving some form of pattern detection have been developed @xcite . another caveat concerns causality . while a significant value of the synfire indicator @xmath61 in our algorithm clearly shows the presence of a preferred temporal order of some signals with respect to others , it does not necessarily prove a driver - responder relationship . there are other methods that have been developed for this kind of system dynamics analysis ( e.g. , @xcite , @xcite ) . but even for such methods causality is always a strong claim . in fact , the two signals might be driven by a common hidden source and a consistent leader ( follower ) could just indicate a drive with a smaller ( larger ) delay . similarly , internal delay loops in one of the two systems can also fool the interpretation . there are a number of possible directions for future research , both from a methods and from a data point of view . regarding the algorithm , for the coincidence detection it would be straightforward to limit the range of allowed time lags by incorporating information about the expected speed of propagation @xcite . one could introduce a minimum time lag in order to ensure causality and/or limit the maximally allowed time lag in order to focus on meaningful propagation of activity . in principle the range of allowed time lags could even be selected individually for each pair of spike trains depending on the known properties of the connectivity between the respective two neurons . importantly , even with such type of time lag restrictions in place , it has still to be guaranteed that each spike can be part of at most one coincidence . a follow - up task for our neurophysiological data would be to investigate to what extent the neurons that are identified as leading by our analysis are identical to the so - called hub neurons @xcite , i.e. neurons with a much higher than average degree of connectivity within the network . regarding the el nio analysis , the difference in propagation directions observed for the strong and weak el nio events remains an open question . furthermore , expanding the analysis to wider regions , i.e.@xmath134 and verifying the consistency of the observed propagation patterns is an interesting topic for future research . finally , the relation to results based on average warming / cooling rates @xcite requires further investigations . the algorithm will be readily applicable for everyone since , together with the existing symmetric measures isi - distance , spike - distance , and spike - synchronization , spike - order is implemented in in three publicly available software packages , the matlab - based graphical user interface spiky @xcite , cspike ( matlab command line with mex - files ) , and the python library pyspike @xcite . [ s : appendix ] the neurophysiological data analyzed in section [ ss : results - neuro ] were recorded in acute hippocampal slices from juvenile mice by the group of heinz beck at the department of epileptology , university of bonn , germany . these recordings were performed prior to and independently from the design of this study . transversal acute brain slices ( @xmath135 thick ) were prepared from @xmath136 to @xmath17-day - old ( p5-p10 ) c57bl/6 mice ( charles river , n = @xmath88 slices ) . slice preparation , calcium imaging and data analysis were performed as previously described in @xcite , @xcite . for am - loading of brain slices with ogb1-am we used a protocol modified from @xcite , @xcite . multicellular calcium imaging was done using a homemade single planar illumination microscope ( spim ) modified from @xcite , @xcite . movies were recorded at a frame rate of @xmath137 hz over a minimal length of @xmath136 min up to @xmath138 min to record a sufficient amount of spontaneous activity . time points of cell activity from the imaging data were defined as the onsets of ca@xmath139 events in fluorescence traces of all individual cells using the maximum of the second derivative of each event @xcite . in order to test the spike train order algorithm , datasets were chosen that exhibited at least three global gdps during the recording ( @xmath140 ) . for one dataset the surrogate analysis described in section [ ss : statistical - significance ] proved to be unfeasible due to its excessive density of spontaneous activity . therefore this dataset was discarded from further analysis , so the final number of datasets analyzed was @xmath141 . the data analyzed in section [ ss : results - climate ] describe one of the most well - known global climate effects , the so called el nio , the warm phase of the el nio southern oscillation ( enso ) . it is usually characterized by an increased sea surface temperature ( sst ) in the central and eastern tropical pacific ocean typically during the months september february @xcite . according to the u.s . national oceanic and atmospheric administration ( noaa ) , an el nio event is identified by an increased three - month moving average sst by @xmath142 over at least six months . el nios can last from nine months up to two years and typically occur in irregular intervals of two to seven years . the analysis presented in section [ ss : results - climate ] uses the optimum interpolated sea surface temperature ( oisst ) data provided by noaa . these data result from a high - resolution blended analysis ( spatial resolution of @xmath143 ) of daily sst and ice constructed by combining observations from different platforms ( satellites , ships , buoys ) on a regular global grid with a time range from 1981 to 2016 @xcite . the daily sst data is centralized by the long - term daily mean resulting in daily sst anomaly data ( deviations from long - term mean ) that form the basis of this analysis . the area used to define el nio events , the el nio 3.4 region , stretches from @xmath134 in latitude and @xmath144 in longitude , as shown in fig . [ fig : el_nino_region ] . however , for the latitudinal direction we here focused only on a small central strip around the equator , i.e. from @xmath145 over a longitudinal stretch consistent with the el nio region , i.e. from @xmath146 ( dashed line in fig . [ fig : el_nino_region ] ) . note , that this focus on the small region around the equator is the main difference to most previous works that studied the propagation of sst anomalies averaged over a much larger latitudinal extent , e.g. @xmath134 in @xcite . in latitudinal direction , we average over the whole strip ( four grid points ) , while in longitudinal direction an averaging over two grid points is performed resulting in @xmath147 of spatial resolution and a total of @xmath116 time series of daily sst anomalies . we disregard short - term fluctuation by applying a gaussian smoothing with width @xmath148 . in fig . [ fig : time_series ] we show the time series resulting from this procedure exemplarily for the center of the observed region , @xmath113 . for the sea surface temperature data we use a threshold criterion to identify the moving high temperature fronts of the el nio events . the threshold determines the signal - to - noise ratio of the data : for small values even weaker events have an effect on the result , whereas for higher values the analysis is focused on the strongest el nio events only . due to the variability of the propagation patterns it might happen that in successive years the threshold is surpassed in different regions . however , since the aim of the analysis is to look at the propagation of individual ( seasonal ) fronts we suppress coincidences between threshold crossings from different years . we still use the adaptive coincidence detection from eq . [ eq : coincidence - maxdist ] but define a maximum coincidence window @xmath9 which in this case is set to @xmath149 months . we are indebted to heinz beck from the department of epileptology , university of bonn , germany , for providing the neurophysiological data . we thank markus abel , roman bauer , heinz beck , nebojsa bozanic , christoph gebhardt , marcus kaiser , stefano luccioli , florian mormann , giorgia paratore , and alessandro torcini for useful discussions . finally , we are grateful to irene malvestio and bernd mulansky for carefully reading the manuscript . tk thanks marcus kaiser and his group for hosting him at the university of newcastle , uk . we acknowledge funding support from the european commission through the marie curie initial training network ` neural engineering transformative technologies ( nett ) ' , project 289146 ( tk and mm ) , and through the european joint doctorate ` complex oscillatory systems : modeling and analysis ( cosmos ) ' , project 642563 ( tk and es ) . tk also acknowledges the italian ministry of foreign affairs regarding the activity of the joint italian - israeli laboratory on neuroscience . boccaletti , s. , bianconi , g. , criado , r. , del genio , c. i. , gmez - gardees , j. , romance , m. , sendia - nadal , i. , wang , z. , zanin , m. , 2014 . the structure and dynamics of multilayer networks . physics reports 544 ( 1 ) , 1 - 122 . boers , n. , bookhagen , b. , barbosa , h. , marwan , n. , kurths , j. , marengo , j. , 2014 . prediction of extreme floods in the eastern central andes based on a complex networks approach . nature communications 5 , 5199 . bonifazi , p. , goldin , m. , picardo , m. a. , jorquera , i. , cattani , a. , bianconi , g. , represa , a. , ben - ari , y. , cossart , r. , 2009 . gabaergic hub neurons orchestrate synchrony in developing hippocampal networks . science 326 , 1419 . hedrich , u. b. , liautard , c. , kirschenbaum , d. , pofahl , m. , lavigne , j. , liu , y. , theiss , s. , slotta , j. , escayg , a. , dihn , m. , et al . , 2014 . impaired action potential initiation in gabaergic interneurons causes hyperexcitable networks in an epileptic mouse model carrying a human nav1 . 1 mutation . j neurosci 34 ( 45 ) , 14874 . heidemann , j. , stojanovic , m. , zorzi , m. , 2012 . underwater sensor networks : applications , advances and challenges . philosophical transactions of the royal society of london a : mathematical , physical and engineering sciences 370 ( 1958 ) , 158 - 175 . lacroix , p. , grasso , j .- roulle , j. , giraud , g. , goetz , d. , morin , s. , helmstetter , a. , 2012 . monitoring of snow avalanches using a seismic array : location , speed estimation , and relationships to meteorological variables . j geophys research : earth surface 117 ( f1 ) . lazer , d. , pentland , a. s. , adamic , l. , aral , s. , barabasi , a. l. , brewer , d. , christakis , n. , contractor , n. , fowler , j. , gutmann , m. , et al . , 2009 . life in the network : the coming age of computational social science . science ( new york , ny ) 323 ( 5915 ) , 721 . menne , m. j. , durre , i. , vose , r. s. , gleason , b. e. , houston , t. g. , 2012 . an overview of the global historical climatology network - daily database . j atmospheric and oceanic technology 29 ( 7 ) , 897 - 910 . mulansky , m. , bozanic , n. , sburlea , a. , kreuz , t. , 2015 . a guide to time - resolved and parameter - free measures of spike train synchrony . event - based control , communication , and signal processing ( ebccsp ) international conference on , 1 - 8 . rahbar , f. , anzalone , s. , varni , g. , zibetti , e. , ivaldi , s. , chetouani , m. , 2015 . predicting extraversion from nonverbal features during a face - to - face human - robot interaction . international conference on social robotics , 10 . rasmusson , e. m. , carpenter , t. h. , 1982 . variations in tropical sea surface temperature and surface wind  fields associated with the southern oscillation / el nio . monthly weather rev 110 ( 5 ) , 354 - 384 . santoso , a. , mcgregor , s. , jin , f .- f . , cai , w. , england , m. h. , an , s .- i . , mcphaden , m. j. , guilyardi , e. , 2013 . late - twentieth - century emergence of the el nio propagation asymmetry and future projections . nature 504 ( 7478 ) , 126 - 130 . takano , h. , mccartney , m. , ortinski , p. i. , yue , c. , putt , m. e. , coulter , d. a. , 2012 . deterministic and stochastic neuronal contributions to distinct synchronous ca3 network bursts . j neurosci 32 ( 14 ) , 4743 - 4754 . wei , x. , valler , n. c. , prakash , b. a. , neamtiu , i. , faloutsos , m. , faloutsos , c. , 2013 . competing memes propagation on networks : a network science perspective . selected areas in communications , ieee journal on 31 ( 6 ) , 1049 - 1060 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the theory of gravitational lensing has by now reached a considerable degree of sophistication @xcite . theorems have been found predicting ( or bounding ) the number of images in very general systems @xcite . shapes of stable caustics have been exhaustively classified @xcite , a non - perturbative notion of the lens map has been obtained @xcite , and various universal behaviors of images have been found for sources lying near caustics @xcite . these general results have been complemented by a number of detailed calculations for specific types of lenses . the majority of such calculations have been performed within the quasi - newtonian viewpoint of gravitational lensing commonly used in astrophysics @xcite . while various flavors of this formalism exist , most require that bending angles be small and that all lenses be nearly - newtonian mass distributions . this is to be contrasted with the more fundamental picture of gravitational lensing where light rays are modelled as null geodesics in a lorentzian spacetime . within this context , specific lensing calculations have been performed in kerr , reissner - nordstrm , and a handful of other geometries @xcite . while curvatures and bending angles may be large in these examples , they all involve ( at least conformally ) stationary spacetimes . it is of interest to understand if qualitatively new effects appear in dynamical cases . this paper considers the bending of light by ( decidedly non - stationary ) plane - symmetric gravitational waves . gravitational lensing by gravitational waves has previously been considered by a number of authors , although almost all of this work has been carried out within the weak - field regime @xcite . one exception is @xcite , where redshifts were computed in an exact solution to the vacuum einstein equation representing a plane gravitational wave . this work considered only very specific waveforms , and was confined to a coordinate patch too small to include caustics and other effects associated with the formation of multiple images . separately , extensive work has been devoted to non - perturbatively understanding the geodesic structure of generic plane wave spacetimes @xcite . this is clearly a subject closely related to gravitational lensing , although few explicit relations between the two subjects appear to have been made ( see , however , remarks in @xcite ) . it is the purpose of this work to provide a comprehensive and non - perturbative discussion of lensing in plane wave spacetimes . these geometries are a well - known subclass of _ pp_-waves ; plane - fronted waves with parallel rays . many plane wave spacetimes are exact solutions to the vacuum einstein equation . others may be interpreted as , e.g. , exact solutions in einstein - maxwell theory . while rather idealized from the astrophysical perspective , plane wave spacetimes admit a wide variety of interesting phenomena . depending on the waveform , any number of astigmatic and anastigmatic caustics may exist . examples admitting any specified number of images even an infinite number are easily constructed . in particular , even numbers of images can exist @xcite . the image count can also change in time even when a source does not cross an observer s caustic . despite all of these properties , plane wave spacetimes are geometrically very mild . they are topologically equivalent to @xmath0 and admit coordinate systems which cover the entire manifold . aside from their value as models of gravitational radiation , the plane wave spacetimes considered here have also found numerous applications via the penrose limit . this limit provides a sense in which the metric near any null geodesic in any spacetime is equivalent to the metric of an appropriate plane wave spacetime @xcite . it allows problems in relatively complicated spacetimes to be reduced to equivalent problems in plane wave spacetimes ( which are often much simpler ) . this has been particularly valuable within string theory and related fields @xcite . penrose limits have also been applied to ordinary quantum field theory in order to investigate causality and effective indices of refraction for photons and gravitons propagating in curved spacetimes @xcite . more recently , penrose limits were used to deduce the effect of caustics on green functions associated with the propagation of classical fields in curved spacetimes @xcite . given the content of the penrose limit , lensing in plane wave spacetimes might be related to lensing in generic spacetimes as seen by ultrarelativistic observers . we make no attempt to justify this conjecture , however . this paper starts by providing a self - contained review of plane wave spacetimes in sect . [ sect : planereview ] . although most of this material is not new @xcite , it is not widely known . [ sect : numimages ] then derives the number of images of a point source that may be viewed in plane wave spacetimes . under generic conditions , this is found to depend only on the waveform and a certain time parameter associated with the observation event . the number of images does not depend on any properties of the source . once this is established , sect . [ sect : imageproperties ] computes image positions , frequency shifts , angles , and image distortion parameters in general plane wave spacetimes . sect . [ sect : symwaves ] applies these results to symmetric plane waves , which have constant waveforms . these geometries produce an infinite number of images of almost every source . their lensing properties are found to change significantly if the ricci tensor is increased beyond a certain threshold . lastly , sect . [ sect : sandwaves ] discusses `` sandwich waves ; '' wavepackets with finite width . these spacetimes generically admit images which appear at discrete times and then persist indefinitely . such images initially provide infinitely blueshifted , infinitely bright pictures into the infinitely distant past . very quickly , however , such images become highly redshifted and effectively fade away . one of these `` transient flashes '' is produced by almost every sufficiently weak vacuum ( ricci - flat ) wave . for weak waves , a second flash appears only if the ricci tensor of the wavepacket exceeds a certain threshold . throughout this work , the spacetime is assumed to be everywhere transparent . the language used also assumes that the geometric optics approximation @xcite holds even in situations where it would be severely strained ( such as when light is emitted near an observer s caustic ) . this paper restricts attention only to plane wave spacetimes in four spacetime dimensions . our sign conventions follow those of wald @xcite . the signature is @xmath1 . latin letters @xmath2 ( and occasionally @xmath3 ) from the beginning of the alphabet are used to denote abstract indices . greek letters @xmath4 are used to denote four - dimensional coordinate indices . the latin letters @xmath5 are instead coordinate indices associated with the two directions transverse to the direction of wave propagation . objects involving the latter type of index are often written in boldface with all indices suppressed . they are then manipulated using the standard notation of linear algebra [ e.g. , @xmath6 and @xmath7 . overall , notation related to plane wave spacetimes closely follows the conventions of @xcite . plane wave geometries may be interpreted as simple models for gravitational waves emitted from distant sources . alternatively , they arise as universal limits for the geometries near null geodesics in any spacetime @xcite . the typical definition of a plane wave spacetime @xmath8 requires that @xmath9 and that there exist global coordinates @xmath10 such that the line element takes the form @xmath11 @xmath12 is any symmetric @xmath13 matrix . its components describe the waveforms associated with a wave s three polarization states . this leaves the usual two polarizations associated with vacuum general relativity . note that the six polarization states typically stated to exist for linearized `` plane '' gravitational waves in generic theories of gravity @xcite can not all be represented by the metric ( [ planewavemetric ] ) . three of these polarizations may be realized only as geometries which are rather less plane - symmetric than those considered here . ] . the @xmath14 coordinate is interpreted as a phase parameter for the wave , while @xmath15 affinely parametrizes its rays . the remaining two coordinates @xmath16 span spacelike wavefronts transverse to the wave s direction of propagation . note that if @xmath17 in some region , the spacetime is locally flat there . in terms of a minkowski coordinate system @xmath18 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 satisfy @xmath19 and @xmath20 in such a region . we consider only nontrivial plane waves , so @xmath21 can not vanish everywhere . the physical interpretation of the so - called brinkmann metric ( [ planewavemetric ] ) as a plane - symmetric gravitational wave follows from considering the integral curves of the vector field @xmath22 . these curves form a null geodesic congruence which may be interpreted as the rays of the gravitational wave . @xmath23 , so these rays have vanishing expansion , shear , and twist . there is therefore a sense in which they are everywhere parallel to one another . all rays are also orthogonal to the family of spacelike 2-surfaces generated by the two commuting spacelike vector fields @xmath24 . the induced metric on each such surface is flat : the wavefronts are 2-planes . the curvature is constant on these planes in the sense that the @xmath25 are curvature collineations : @xmath26 despite this , the @xmath25 are not everywhere killing . there do , however , exist linear combinations of @xmath27 and @xmath28 which _ are _ killing . @xmath28 itself is also killing , which may be interpreted as a statement that plane waves do not deform along their characteristics . plane wave spacetimes admit a minimum of five linearly independent killing fields . note that in flat spacetime , five ( out of the total of ten ) killing fields are symmetries of all electromagnetic plane waves @xcite . killing fields of plane wave spacetimes are discussed more fully in sect . [ sect : geodesic ] . all non - vanishing coordinate components of the riemann tensor may be determined from @xmath29 it follows from this that the ricci tensor is @xmath30 where @xmath31 denotes the ordinary ( euclidean ) trace of the @xmath13 matrix @xmath32 . the ricci scalar always vanishes in plane wave spacetimes . more generally , there are no nonzero scalars formed by local contractions of the metric , the curvature , and its derivatives : @xmath33 . this is analogous to the fact that plane electromagnetic waves satisfy , e.g. , @xmath34 . note , however , that electromagnetic plane waves are not the only electromagnetic fields with vanishing field scalars . similarly , plane wave spacetimes are not the only curved geometries with vanishing curvature scalars @xcite . it follows from ( [ ricci ] ) that plane wave spacetimes satisfying the vacuum einstein equation ( and the vacuum equations of many alternative theories of gravity @xcite ) are characterized by the simple algebraic constraint @xmath35 . for vacuum waves , there exist two scalar functions @xmath36 and @xmath37 such that @xmath38 @xmath39 and @xmath40 describe the waveforms for the two polarization states of a gravitational plane wave propagating in vacuum . a plane wave is said to be linearly polarized if @xmath39 and @xmath40 are linearly dependent ( in which case one of these functions can be eliminated by a suitable rotation of the transverse coordinates @xmath41 ) . if @xmath39 and @xmath40 have compact support , the geometry is said to be a sandwich wave . this name evinces the image of a curved region of spacetime `` sandwiched '' between null hyperplanes in a geometry that is otherwise minkowski . physically , it corresponds to a wavepacket of finite length . note that the planar symmetry considered here is very special in the sense that passing waves do not necessarily leave any `` tail '' behind them . after interacting with a sandwich wave , all observers enter a region of spacetime which is perfectly flat . there is a sense in which test fields propagating on plane wave spacetimes also have no tails @xcite . a general ( not necessarily vacuum ) wave profile @xmath32 may be built by adding to ( [ hvac ] ) a term proportional to the identity matrix @xmath42 . there then exists a third polarization function @xmath43 such that @xmath44 if the ricci tensor of such a wave is associated with a stress - energy tensor via einstein s equation , that stress - energy tensor obeys the weak energy condition if and only if @xmath45 . assuming this , the stress - energy tensors associated with ( [ hgen ] ) are very simple . they could be generated by , e.g. , electromagnetic plane waves with the form @xmath46 } x^1 . \label{emfield}\ ] ] alternatively , ( [ hgen ] ) could be associated with the stress - energy tensor of the massless klein - gordon plane wave @xmath47 besides the vacuum case @xmath48 , another interesting class of wave profiles are those that are conformally flat . these satisfy @xmath49 , so @xmath50 . as gravitational lenses , all caustics of conformally - flat plane waves are associated with `` perfect '' anastigmatic focusing . for more general plane waves , caustics are typically ( but not necessarily ) associated with astigmatic focusing . the geometry of plane wave spacetimes has been analyzed in detail by a number of authors @xcite . one essential conclusion of this work is that nearly all interesting properties of plane wave spacetimes may be deduced from the properties of @xmath13 matrices @xmath53 satisfying the differential equation @xmath54 this is a `` generalized oscillator equation '' with @xmath55 acting like a matrix of squared frequencies . ( [ edef ] ) arises when solving for geodesics or jacobi fields in plane wave spacetimes . bitensors such as synge s function and the parallel propagator may be written explicitly in terms of its solutions . the same is also true for a plane wave s killing vectors . it is convenient to write all possible matrices @xmath56 in terms of two particular solutions . fix any is used here because this will later be interpreted as a @xmath14 coordinate associated with some observer . similarly , @xmath57 is often interpreted below as a @xmath14 coordinate associated with a source ( not necessarily when that source is observable at any observation point with @xmath58 ) . later , the notation @xmath59 is used to denote a @xmath14 coordinate associated with the emission of light from a source . ] @xmath60 and define @xmath61 and @xmath62 to be solutions to ( [ edef ] ) ( where derivatives are applied to the first arguments of @xmath51 and @xmath52 ) with the initial conditions @xmath63 here , the notation @xmath64 indicates a partial derivative with respect to the first argument of @xmath51 . we assume for simplicity that @xmath65 is a matrix of piecewise - continuous functions and that @xmath51 and @xmath66 are at least @xmath67 ( and piecewise-@xmath68 ) in both of their arguments . example expressions for @xmath51 and @xmath52 are discussed in sects . [ sect : symwaves ] and [ sect : sandwaves ] . given any two solutions @xmath69 and @xmath70 to ( [ edef ] ) , it is easily verified that their wronskian is conserved : @xmath71 here , @xmath72 denotes a matrix transpose . applying this formula with @xmath73 and @xmath74 shows that @xmath75 neither @xmath76 nor @xmath66 are necessarily symmetric matrices . nevertheless , ( [ genwronskian ] ) and ( [ wronskian ] ) may be used to show that the products @xmath77 _ are _ symmetric wherever they exist @xcite . letting @xmath78 and @xmath79 in ( [ genwronskian ] ) shows that @xmath80 for all @xmath81 . this is essentially etherington s reciprocity law @xcite . a similar calculation may be used to show that @xmath82 as well . it is sometimes useful to consider partial derivatives @xmath83 with respect to the second arguments of @xmath51 and @xmath52 . the resulting matrices remain solutions to ( [ edef ] ) . comparing initial conditions shows that @xmath84 @xmath51 may therefore be derived from @xmath52 . the opposite is also true wherever @xmath85 . geometrically , @xmath66 corresponds to the transverse coordinate components of a jacobi propagator describing the evolution of deviation vectors along geodesics passing between different pairs of points @xcite . @xmath52 is also related to image distortion . up to an overall time dilation factor , it translates small differences in image position on an observer s sky to spatial deviations from a fiducial source point . in the language of @xcite , @xmath52 is proportional to the jacobi map . the symmetric matrix @xmath86 plays a similar role , but translates source separations to _ emission _ ( rather than observation ) angles . it is proportional to an object typically referred to as the optical deformation matrix . these statements are explained more fully in sect . [ sect : imagedist ] . it is often useful when working with plane wave spacetimes to consider hypersurfaces of `` constant phase . '' recalling the interpretation of the @xmath14 coordinate as a phase , let @xmath87 denote such a hypersurface . given two points @xmath88 and @xmath89 ( with @xmath90 ) , define the multiplicity or `` index '' of these points to be @xcite @xmath91 we also set @xmath92 whenever @xmath93 . it follows from ( [ bswitch ] ) that @xmath94 . for most pairs of points , @xmath95 . such pairs are said to be `` disconjugate . '' pairs @xmath96 satisfying @xmath97 are instead said to be conjugate with multiplicity @xmath98 . similarly , we call the pairs @xmath99 `` conjugate hyperplanes '' and the pairs of real numbers @xmath100 `` conjugate phases '' when @xmath101 . despite the appearance of ( [ idef ] ) , the index map @xmath102 describes phenomena which do not depend on any choice of coordinate system . conjugate pairs as described here are closely related to the conjugate points commonly considered in differential geometry and optics . in general , distinct points @xmath103 and @xmath104 on a given geodesic are said to be conjugate if and only if there exist nontrivial deviation vectors along that geodesic which vanish at both @xmath104 and @xmath103 . in plane wave spacetimes , this condition reduces to @xmath105 . defining the multiplicity of a pair of conjugate points to be the number of linearly independent deviation vectors which vanish at those points , that multiplicity is equal to @xmath106 . the concept of conjugacy associated with @xmath107 does not , however , require the specification of any particular geodesic . it is uniquely defined even for pairs of points connected by multiple geodesics or by none . indeed , these are the only cases where @xmath108 . all strong lensing effects associated with plane wave spacetimes are related to the existence of conjugate hyperplanes . it follows from ( [ idef ] ) that every pair of conjugate phases @xmath100 satisfies @xmath109 finding conjugate pairs and their multiplicities may be viewed as a matter of direct computation once @xmath65 is specified . alternatively , various sturm - type comparison theorems can be used to make general statements regarding the existence and separations of conjugate pairs for various classes of plane wave . see , e.g. , chapt . xi of @xcite for results relating to mathematical problems of this type and @xcite for an application to `` tame '' plane wave spacetimes . more specific examples are discussed in sects . [ sect : symwaves ] and [ sect : sandwaves ] below . the qualitative structure of geodesics in plane wave spacetimes is closely related to the index @xmath107 . first note that every disconjugate pair of points @xmath110 is connected by exactly one geodesic . if two points are conjugate , the number of connecting geodesics is either zero or infinity . sizes of geodesically connected regions may be summarized by @xmath111 + i ( p_s , p_o ) = 3 . \label{indextheorem}\ ] ] a similar relation exists for null cones when @xmath112 : @xmath113 + i ( p_s , p_o ) = 2 . \label{indextheorem2}\ ] ] the latter result has been referred to as an `` index theorem '' in @xcite . ( [ indextheorem ] ) implies that geodesics emanating from @xmath104 and intersecting a hyperplane @xmath114 that is disconjugate to @xmath115 form a 3-dimensional region . indeed , these geodesics fill the entire hyperplane . more interestingly , geodesics intersecting a conjugate hyperplane with multiplicity 1 fill only a 2-dimensional region on that 3-dimensional surface . geodesics intersecting a hyperplane with multiplicity 2 form a line . similarly , the null cone of a point reduces to a 1-dimensional curve on every hyperplane with multiplicity 1 . a null cone intersecting a hyperplane with multiplicity 2 is focused to a single point on that hyperplane . these two cases correspond to astigmatic and anastigmatic focusing , respectively . anastigmatic focusing tends to be unstable in the sense that perturbations tend to split a single multiplicity 2 phase into two closely - spaced phases each with multiplicity 1 . or a preferred @xmath116 hyperplane @xmath115 , plane wave spacetimes naturally divide into a number of open four - dimensional regions @xmath117 . these regions are separated from each other by the hyperplanes @xmath118 conjugate to @xmath115 . ] in many applications , there exists a preferred point @xmath104 , or perhaps a preferred hyperplane @xmath115 . @xmath104 may , for example , represent the position of an observer at a particular time . fixing this point , the set of hyperplanes conjugate to @xmath115 divides a plane wave spacetime into a ( possibly infinite ) number of open regions @xmath117 . let @xmath119 denote the largest connected region containing @xmath115 and excluding any portion of a hyperplane conjugate to @xmath115 . if there exists a smallest @xmath120 conjugate to @xmath121 , the surface @xmath122 is clearly contained in the boundary of @xmath119 . @xmath123 may then be defined as the largest connected region which includes @xmath122 as a boundary and contains points @xmath103 satisfying @xmath124 and @xmath125 . this continues the spacetime `` above '' @xmath122 . similar constructions may be used to define @xmath126 and @xmath117 for values of @xmath127 other than 1 . [ fig : nn ] . fixing a particular nonzero integer @xmath127 and real number @xmath121 , it is not necessary that @xmath126 exist at all . in general , the domain of @xmath128 is an open subset of @xmath129 . this domain can be empty for some @xmath127 . the geodesic uniqueness result described above can now be reduced to the statement that a point @xmath104 is connected to another point @xmath130 by exactly one geodesic if and only if there exists some @xmath127 such that @xmath131 . two - point tensors like synge s world function , the parallel propagator , and the van vleck determinant may be defined unambiguously throughout `` @xmath132 . '' this excludes from @xmath133 only a set of measure zero . beyond the qualitative geodesic structure of plane wave spacetimes discussed above , it is not difficult to obtain explicit coordinate expressions for all geodesics . let @xmath134 denote some geodesic and @xmath135 an affine parametrization of it . the vector field @xmath136 generating the characteristics of the gravitational wave is killing , so @xmath137 must be constant on @xmath138 . if this constant vanishes , @xmath138 is confined to a hypersurface of constant phase . such a geodesic has the form of a ( euclidean ) straight line in the coordinates @xmath139 . geodesics satisfying @xmath140 are more interesting . in these cases , the affine parameter can always be rescaled such that @xmath141 . it is then possible to identify that parameter with the phase coordinate @xmath14 . doing , so @xmath142 for all @xmath143 . the spatial components @xmath144 of any geodesic are fixed everywhere once @xmath145 and @xmath146 have been specified at some fiducial phase @xmath121 . in terms of the matrices @xmath51 and @xmath52 defined in sect . [ sect : ab ] , @xmath147 the associated @xmath15 coordinate of @xmath138 may be efficiently derived using that fact that the vector field @xmath148 is a homothety @xcite . this implies that @xmath149 , \label{vgeo}\ ] ] where @xmath150 is a constant . @xmath151 is closely related to the conserved quantity on @xmath138 associated with the killing field @xmath28 . the ( unit ) 4-velocity @xmath152 tangent to @xmath138 is related to @xmath153 via @xmath154 it follows that @xmath155 if the spacetime is nearly flat ( so @xmath156 ) , @xmath151 reduces to a particle s specific energy minus its specific momentum in the direction of the gravitational wave . the limit @xmath157 ( or @xmath158 ) may therefore be interpreted as ultrarelativistic motion in the direction of the gravitational wave . by contrast , the limit @xmath159 ( or @xmath160 ) corresponds to ultrarelativistic motion _ against _ the background wave . other killing fields present in essentially all plane wave spacetimes may be written as @xmath161 where @xmath162 is any 2-vector with the form @xmath163 for each choice of @xmath121 , there exists a four - parameter family of such vector fields . each of these is associated with a conservation law . two such conserved quantities may be summarized by @xmath164 . \label{pdef}\ ] ] fixing any @xmath121 , this 2-vector is conserved in the sense that it is independent of @xmath57 . another conserved 2-vector may be defined by @xmath165 . \label{cdef}\ ] ] in the weak - field limit , @xmath166 corresponds to the specific momentum transverse to the gravitational wave . in this same context , @xmath167 may be interpreted as the conserved quantity associated with boosts transverse to the gravitational wave . it constrains transverse displacements . note that both @xmath166 and @xmath167 depend on a choice of @xmath121 . this is analogous to the choice of origin necessary to define angular momentum in elementary mechanics . in stationary spacetimes , it is common to discuss various quantities related to gravitational lensing in terms of stationary observers ( and often stationary sources ) . while plane wave spacetimes are not stationary , there does exist sufficient symmetry to define similarly preferred sources and observers . two geodesics @xmath138 and @xmath168 can be said to be `` instantaneously comoving '' at @xmath58 when @xmath169 these conditions imply that the 4-velocities of both geodesics are parallel - transported versions of each other on the constant - phase hyperplane @xmath115 . note , however , that geodesics which are comoving at one phase are not necessarily comoving at any other phase . as implied by ( [ indextheorem ] ) , bundles of geodesics are strongly focused on conjugate hyperplanes . consider such a hyperplane associated with a phase @xmath126 conjugate to @xmath121 with multiplicity 1 . it is clear from ( [ idef ] ) that @xmath170 is a matrix with rank 1 . there therefore exists a unit 2-vector @xmath171 such that @xmath172 @xmath171 is unique up to sign . choosing any @xmath173 orthogonal to @xmath171 , the transverse spatial coordinates of all geodesics starting at a given point @xmath104 focus to the line @xmath174 as they pass through @xmath175 . here , @xmath176 is any real number . all @xmath15 coordinates may be reached on @xmath175 by appropriate geodesics . geodesics starting at @xmath104 and intersecting a hyperplane @xmath118 with multiplicity 2 all focus to the single transverse position @xmath177 as they pass through @xmath118 . as in the multiplicity 1 case , all values of @xmath15 may be reached by appropriate geodesics . ( [ focusnondeg ] ) and ( [ focusdeg ] ) illustrate explicitly how conjugate hyperplanes with multiplicities 1 and 2 are associated with astigmatic and anastigmatic focusing , respectively . the former case involves focusing in only one transverse direction , while the latter case involves simultaneous focusing in both directions transverse to the gravitational wave . as noted above , all pairs of points not lying on conjugate hyperplanes are connected by exactly one geodesic . there is therefore no ambiguity in ascribing geodesic distances to these pairs . in particular , synge s world function @xmath178 is well - defined whenever its arguments do not lie on conjugate hyperplanes . plane wave spacetimes constitute one of the few examples where @xmath179 is known essentially in closed form : @xmath180 . \label{sigdef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is symmetric in its arguments : @xmath181 . the appearance of @xmath182 in ( [ sigdef ] ) indicates that @xmath179 tends to diverge when its arguments approach conjugate hyperplanes . more specifically , suppose that @xmath183 and @xmath184 . then , @xmath185 ^ 2 \label{signondeg}\ ] ] is an asymptotic approximation for @xmath179 if the bracketed term on the right - hand side of this equation is nonzero @xcite . it follows from ( [ focusnondeg ] ) that this expression is valid only when there does not exist any geodesic passing from @xmath104 to a point on @xmath118 with the same transverse coordinates as @xmath103 . the equivalent result if @xmath103 is near a hyperplane @xmath118 with multiplicity 2 is @xmath186 again , this is valid only when there does not exist any geodesic passing from @xmath104 to a point on @xmath118 with the same transverse coordinates as @xmath103 . one of the most basic questions that can be asked regarding a gravitational lens is the number of images that it produces of a particular source . stated somewhat differently , how many future - directed null geodesics connect a given timelike curve ( the source ) to a particular spacetime event ( the observer at a particular time ) ? this may be answered using the geodesic structure of plane wave spacetimes summarized above . to an observation event @xmath104 . the arguments of sect . [ sect : numimages ] show that under generic conditions , exactly one image is emitted from each region @xmath117 lying before the observation event . the dashed lines correspond to constant-@xmath14 hyperplanes conjugate to @xmath115 . ] to fix the notation , let @xmath104 denote a fixed observation event and @xmath138 the timelike worldline of a point source . assume that @xmath138 may be parametrized by an everywhere-@xmath67 function @xmath135 . the phase coordinate @xmath14 serves as a useful `` quasi - time '' @xcite for plane wave spacetimes is not a `` true '' time function because @xmath187 is null . generically , there do exist well - behaved functions @xmath188 where @xmath189 is everywhere timelike @xcite . these are time functions in the usual sense , although they do not appear to simplify any computations performed here . incidentally , the existence of such time functions implies that plane wave spacetimes are stably causal . plane waves are not , however , globally hyperbolic @xcite . hypersurfaces of constant @xmath190 are not cauchy surfaces . ] , so let @xmath191 satisfy @xmath192 for all @xmath143 . the source s worldline is not required to be geodesic . this section establishes that under generic conditions , an ideal observer at @xmath104 may see exactly one image of @xmath138 from each of the `` epochs '' @xmath117 described in sect . [ sect : conjugate ] . somewhat more precisely , there typically exists exactly one future - directed null geodesic from @xmath193 to @xmath104 for each @xmath194 such that @xmath117 exists . [ fig : multimage ] . recall that the boundaries of @xmath117 depend only on the spacetime under consideration , and not at all on the behavior of any particular source . this allows generic bounds to be placed on time delays associated with the various images that may be observed . recall from sect . [ sect : conjugate ] that each point in @xmath195 is connected to @xmath104 via exactly one ( not necessarily null ) geodesic . synge s function @xmath196 is therefore well - defined and explicitly given by ( [ sigdef ] ) for all @xmath57 such that @xmath197 . consider instead the rescaled function @xmath198 if @xmath194 , the domain of @xmath199 is equal to all @xmath57 such that @xmath197 . if @xmath200 , we additionally suppose that @xmath201 for reasons of causality . images of @xmath195 produced by a plane gravitational wave correspond to the zeros of @xmath202 . recalling the form ( [ sigdef ] ) for @xmath179 , it is clear that @xmath202 depends on @xmath138 as well as the matrices @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath182 , and @xmath203 . we have assumed in sect . [ sect : ab ] that @xmath76 and @xmath52 are at least @xmath67 . so is @xmath191 . the definition of @xmath117 ensures that @xmath204 everywhere @xmath199 is defined . @xmath182 is therefore @xmath67 and @xmath202 is continuous . @xmath202 is also monotonic . to see this , note that ( [ edef ] ) , ( [ wronskian ] ) , ( [ symmatrices ] ) , ( [ sigdef ] ) , and ( [ sigcapdef ] ) may be used to show that @xmath205 > 0 . \label{sigdot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath202 is both continuous and monotonic , so at most one zero can exist for each @xmath127 . this means that at most one image of a source may reach an observer from each epoch @xmath117 . _ exactly _ one such image exists if some @xmath206 are known to satisfy @xmath207 such bounds are easily established . the simplest case to consider is one where @xmath117 lies `` in between '' hyperplanes conjugate to @xmath115 . suppose that both @xmath126 and @xmath208 exist for some @xmath209 . this is true in fig . [ fig : multimage ] for @xmath210 . more generally , ( [ signondeg ] ) and ( [ sigdeg ] ) imply that if there are no geodesics connecting @xmath104 to either @xmath211 or @xmath212 , @xmath213 it follows from these limits together with continuity that @xmath202 is surjective on @xmath129 . since this function is also monotonic , there must exist exactly one emission phase @xmath214 such that @xmath104 and @xmath215 are connected by a null geodesic . under the same assumptions , projectiles moving on timelike geodesics may be thrown from @xmath197 to @xmath104 only if @xmath216 . choosing @xmath217 to be sufficiently small ( but positive ) , these projectiles can require an arbitrarily large amount of proper time to intersect @xmath104 . it is somewhat curious that points @xmath197 satisfying @xmath218 can not be connected to @xmath104 by any causal geodesic . such points may , however , be reached by suitably accelerated curves which are everywhere causal . next , consider the case @xmath200 when there exists at least one conjugate hyperplane in the observer s past ( as occurs in the example illustrated by fig . [ fig : multimage ] ) . the arguments given above imply that if @xmath219 is geodesically disconnected from @xmath104 , @xmath220 the other boundary of the domain of @xmath221 occurs at @xmath222 . here , @xmath223 this limit clearly tends to @xmath224 if @xmath225 . physically , @xmath225 implies that @xmath104 can not be connected to @xmath226 by any null geodesic . assuming that this is true , there must exist exactly one @xmath227 such that @xmath104 and @xmath228 are connected by a null geodesic . the results of sects . [ sect : inbetween ] and [ sect : young ] typically suffice to describe the images formed in plane wave spacetimes containing an infinite number of conjugate hyperplanes in an observer s past . it is , however , important to consider cases where only a finite number of conjugate points exist . this occurs , e.g. , for finite wavepackets where @xmath32 has compact support . it is also true of linearly polarized vacuum waves that are tame in the sense described in @xcite . if there is at least one conjugate hyperplane in the observer s past , let @xmath229 denote the smallest negative integer such that @xmath230 exists . if there are no conjugate hyperplanes in the observer s past , set @xmath231 . the case illustrated in fig . [ fig : multimage ] corresponds to @xmath232 if @xmath233 extends into the infinite past . regardless , we ask whether there exist any future - directed light rays from @xmath234 to @xmath104 . unlike in the cases considered above , sources spend an infinite amount of proper time in @xmath235 . even in flat spacetime , a source that accelerates for an infinitely long time may be causally - disconnected from certain observers via a rindler horizon . such phenomena can be ruled out here by supposing that there exists some finite constant @xmath236 such that @xmath237 > \kappa_{\mathrm{min } } \label{vdotbound}\ ] ] for all @xmath57 less than some cutoff . as is clear from ( [ kappadef ] ) and ( [ 4vel ] ) , the left - hand side of this inequality acts like the square root of a time dilation factor between the coordinate @xmath14 and the source s proper time . eq . ( [ vdotbound ] ) implies that the source s 4-velocity @xmath238 satisfies @xmath239 sufficiently far in the past . it therefore excludes sources which experience arbitrarily large boosts against the background gravitational wave in the distant past . it is satisfied by , e.g. , sources whose motion is geodesic sufficiently far into the past . assuming that @xmath240 exists , it is clear from ( [ sigdot ] ) that @xmath241 may be chosen sufficiently small that @xmath242 further assuming that @xmath243 is geodesically disconnected from @xmath104 ( if @xmath244 ) or that @xmath226 is not null - separated from @xmath104 ( if @xmath231 ) , it follows that there exists exactly one @xmath59 smaller than @xmath230 ( if @xmath245 ) or @xmath121 ( if @xmath231 ) such that @xmath246 is connected to @xmath104 via a future - directed null geodesic . the results just described may be summarized as follows : suppose that there does not exist any past - directed geodesic segment from @xmath104 to @xmath138 whose endpoints are conjugate ( in the usual sense ) . also assume that the source and observer are not instantaneously aligned with the background wave : @xmath247 . if there exists an `` oldest '' phase conjugate to @xmath121 , further require that there be some @xmath248 such that the source s motion is bounded by ( [ sourcebound ] ) sufficiently far in the past . for each @xmath194 , these assumptions imply that an observer at @xmath104 sees exactly one image of @xmath138 as it appeared in @xmath117 . this provides a strong bound on the possible emission times of different images . if @xmath235 exists for every negative integer @xmath229 , an infinite number of images are formed . if , however , there is some smallest @xmath249 such that @xmath235 exists , @xmath250 images appear at @xmath104 . note that these results depend only on the waveform @xmath65 and the phase coordinate @xmath121 associated with the observer . the total number of images is the same for all sources satisfying the hypotheses outlined above . these hypotheses are generic . recalling ( [ indextheorem ] ) , the requirement that @xmath138 exclude any points conjugate to @xmath104 along a connecting geodesic is equivalent to demanding that the source s worldline avoid certain well - behaved one- or two - dimensional subsets of the three - dimensional hyperplanes conjugate to @xmath115 . similarly , the assumption that @xmath247 demands only that @xmath138 avoid a certain line on @xmath115 . the bound ( [ sourcebound ] ) on a source s asymptotic 4-velocity can fail to hold only for sources which accelerate for an infinitely long time . violating any of these conditions for a fixed observer would require that a source s worldline be quite exceptional . moreover , we now show that @xmath250 images appear under even broader ( but more difficult to state ) conditions than those just discussed . despite the comments made above , our assumptions on the behavior of a source s worldline can be violated in certain cases . suppose , contrary to these assumptions , that there exists at least one point @xmath251 which is conjugate to @xmath104 along a geodesic connecting these two points . an infinite number of geodesics then pass between @xmath252 and @xmath104 . if the connecting geodesics are null , @xmath252 lies on a caustic of the observer s past light cone . continuous images of point sources `` einstein rings '' are then formed at @xmath104 ( ignoring the associated breakdown of geometric optics ) . such cases are not considered any further here . if conjugate points between the source and observer are associated with non - null geodesics , discrete images of @xmath138 appear at @xmath104 . in these cases , the methods used above are easily adapted to find how many images of @xmath195 arrive at @xmath104 . as already mentioned , there can be no more than one root for each @xmath253 . depending on the details of the system , the associated image from @xmath117 may or may not exist . the case considered in sect . [ sect : inbetween ] where @xmath195 lies in between successive conjugate hyperplanes is the simplest to analyze . assuming that @xmath138 does not intersect the caustic of @xmath104 , no images are formed of @xmath195 if either @xmath211 is connected to @xmath104 via a timelike geodesic or @xmath212 is connected to @xmath104 via a spacelike geodesic . otherwise , exactly one image exists from this region . if there exists an oldest conjugate hyperplane @xmath254 as described in sect . [ sect : oldest ] , suppose that the source satisfies ( [ vdotbound ] ) for some @xmath255 . there are then zero images of @xmath234 if @xmath243 is connected to @xmath104 via a timelike geodesic . there is exactly one image if these points are either geodesically disconnected or are connected by a spacelike geodesic . the last cases to consider concern images of @xmath256 . first suppose that @xmath247 . if there exists at least one conjugate hyperplane in the observer s past , one image is formed of @xmath256 if either @xmath219 is geodesically disconnected from @xmath104 or it is connected by a timelike geodesic . no images are formed if @xmath219 and @xmath104 are connected by a spacelike geodesic . if @xmath247 and there are no conjugate points in the observer s past , condition ( [ vdotbound ] ) implies that there exists exactly one image of @xmath256 . cases where the source and observer are instantaneously aligned are more interesting . suppose that @xmath257 . there then exists one image of @xmath256 with @xmath258 . recalling that @xmath121 is not in the domain of @xmath221 , it is possible for a second image to be emitted from @xmath256 if @xmath259 somewhere . this may be seen by noting that @xmath260 two images of @xmath256 can therefore exist when @xmath261 and @xmath257 . if a source includes points which are conjugate to the observer ( in the ordinary sense ) , there is no simple result for the total number of images formed . nevertheless , it is always possible to say that the total number of images is less than or equal to @xmath262 if a source does not intersect a caustic of the observer s light cone . plane wave spacetimes typically produce multiple images of each source . even for sources whose intrinsic properties remain constant , these images can appear with different spectra , brightnesses , etc . we now compute these properties for generic configurations satisfying the hypotheses summarized in sect . [ sect : totimages ] . for each image of a timelike worldline @xmath138 seen at @xmath104 , there is an associated null geodesic segment connecting @xmath104 to an appropriate emission point @xmath263 . in terms of synge s function ( [ sigdef0 ] ) , these points satisfy @xmath264 first derivatives of @xmath179 are always tangent to the connecting light ray . in particular , the vector @xmath265 at @xmath104 points along the geodesic which eventually intersects @xmath252 ( and is therefore past - directed ) . the derivative operator here is understood to act on the second argument of @xmath179 . also note that @xmath266 is normalized such that @xmath267 . parallel - transporting @xmath266 to the observation point yields @xmath268 the derivative operator in this equation is understood to act on the first argument of @xmath179 . both @xmath266 and @xmath269 may be viewed as ( dimensionless ) separation vectors between @xmath104 and @xmath252 . ( [ sigdef ] ) and the various identities of sect . [ sect : ab ] may be used to compute the explicit coordinate components of @xmath269 and @xmath266 . components transverse to the direction of wave propagation are @xmath270 , \label{tangent1}\ ] ] where @xmath271 and @xmath272 denote the transverse coordinates of the observer and source . a similar calculation shows that @xmath273 . \label{tangent2}\ ] ] @xmath274 and @xmath275 are related via @xmath276 much of the discussion below considers sources moving on geodesics . in these cases , use of ( [ spatgeo ] ) shows that @xmath277 here , @xmath278 . the various identities involving @xmath51 and @xmath52 discussed in sect . [ sect : ab ] may also be used to reduce the imaging condition ( [ sigzero ] ) to @xmath279 here , @xmath280 . ( [ siggeo ] ) is a nonlinear relation for the emission `` time '' @xmath59 in terms of the observer s position @xmath104 and the parameters @xmath281 , @xmath282 , @xmath283 , @xmath151 describing the source s worldline . as discussed in sect . [ sect : numimages ] , there can be many solutions to ( [ siggeo ] ) . these correspond to different images . neither @xmath59 nor @xmath266 depends on the observer s motion . nevertheless , redshifts and angles on the observer s sky do depend on that motion ( as is true even in flat spacetime ) . it is often useful to fix this effect by supposing that the observer is instantaneously comoving with the source . following ( [ comoving ] ) , this is taken to mean that the unit 4-velocities @xmath284 of the source and observer on @xmath115 satisfy @xmath285 recall from sect . [ sect : geodesic ] that the `` transverse momentum '' @xmath286 is generated by contracting @xmath287 with the two killing fields equal to @xmath25 at @xmath104 and having vanishing first derivative at that point . also note that ( [ comoving3 ] ) implicitly defines an instantaneous observer velocity @xmath288 normalized ( like @xmath153 ) such that @xmath289 . gravitational lenses typically discussed in astrophysics involve nearly - newtonian mass distributions which may be regarded as approximately stationary ( at least on sub - cosmological timescales ) . if both a source and an observer are sufficiently far from such a lens , there can be no significant redshift or blueshift from the gravitational field of that lens . roughly speaking , a light ray falling into any stationary gravitational potential must climb out of that same potential . this result breaks down if light passes through non - stationary regions of spacetime . indeed , plane wave spacetimes may produce images with significant frequency shifts @xcite . consider an approximately monochromatic beam of light emitted from @xmath252 and received at @xmath104 . a future - directed tangent vector @xmath290 to the emitted light ray may always be chosen such that @xmath291 is the angular frequency of the light as seen by its source . the frequency @xmath292 of this same light ray as measured by an observer at @xmath104 is @xmath293 , where @xmath294 is equal to @xmath295 parallel transported from the source to the observer . the observed and emitted frequencies are therefore related by @xmath296 here , @xmath297 and @xmath298 . the 2-vectors @xmath299 and @xmath300 appearing here are determined by the source and observer positions via ( [ sigdef ] ) , ( [ sigzero ] ) , ( [ tangent1 ] ) , and ( [ tangent2 ] ) . the resulting frequency shift is valid for all emission points not contained in a caustic of @xmath104 . now suppose that a source moves on a geodesic and that the observer is instantaneously comoving with this geodesic in the sense of ( [ comoving2 ] ) and ( [ comoving3 ] ) . then @xmath301 does nt depend on which image is chosen . ( [ tangentdiff ] ) , ( [ lambdadotgeo ] ) , and the symmetry of @xmath302 may be used to rewrite ( [ redshiftgen ] ) as @xmath303 the matrix in parentheses on the right hand side of this equation acts like a metric for the `` separation '' 2-vector @xmath304 $ ] . if both eigenvalues of @xmath305 are negative , the source is necessarily redshifted . conversely , sources are always blueshifted when this matrix is positive definite . if @xmath306 has both positive and negative eigenvalues , the sign of the frequency difference depends on the direction of @xmath307 . for special configurations , there is no frequency shift at all . various images formed from a single source appear at different points on an observer s sky . like redshifts , the relative angles between images change depending on an observer s 4-velocity @xmath308 . the angle @xmath309 between two images arriving at @xmath104 with tangents @xmath266 and @xmath310 is @xmath311 simplifying , @xmath312 this expression is valid for arbitrary source and observer configurations . specializing to geodesic sources and comoving observers , @xmath313 here , @xmath314 and @xmath315 . it is evident that angles are largely controlled by the difference between @xmath316 at the two emission times . another interesting angle to consider is the observed separation @xmath317 between a single image ( emitted at @xmath252 ) and a generator @xmath28 of the background gravitational wave . for arbitrarily moving source and observer configurations , @xmath318 for observers comoving with geodesic sources , @xmath319 this may be used to rewrite the angle @xmath309 between two different images partially in terms of the angles @xmath317 and @xmath320 those images make with @xmath28 . using ( [ costheta ] ) , @xmath321 similarly , the frequency shift ( [ redshiftgeodesic ] ) of an individual image may be rewritten as @xmath322 it is evident from this equation that images which appear highly blueshifted to comoving observers must satisfy @xmath323 . thus far , all sources here have been modelled as though they were confined to timelike worldlines . real objects are not pointlike , however . they form extended worldtubes in spacetime . images of such worldtubes form null geodesic congruences which converge on @xmath104 . these images can be significantly distorted by the curvature of spacetime . it is simplest to quantify such distortions by first fixing a particular null geodesic @xmath324 passing between some part of the source and @xmath104 . precisely which geodesic is chosen is not important . @xmath324 serves only as an origin from which to discuss nearby light rays connecting @xmath104 to other points in the source . once this origin has been fixed , the image of an extended source may be described entirely using deviation vectors on @xmath324 ( at least for sufficiently small sources ) . [ fig : distortion ] . is indicated together with another light ray separated from it by a deviation vector @xmath325 . the vector @xmath266 is also drawn . this is tangent to @xmath324 at the observation point @xmath104 . ] deviation vectors ( or jacobi fields ) satisfy the geodesic deviation ( or jacobi ) equation along @xmath324 . letting @xmath326 denote the past - directed null vector tangent to @xmath324 and obtained by parallel - transporting @xmath266 from @xmath104 , every deviation vector @xmath325 is a solution to @xmath327 this equation is linear , so @xmath325 must depend linearly on initial data . in particular , all deviation vectors can be written as linear combinations of appropriate bitensors contracted into the initial data . this is done to avoid confusion when writing down two - point tensors such as @xmath328 [ see ( [ bdef ] ) ] . ] @xmath329 and @xmath330 . all light rays observed at @xmath104 must necessarily intersect that point , so it suffices to set @xmath331 . the first derivative of a deviation vector at @xmath104 describes an angular deviation between one point of an image and the center associated with @xmath324 . we therefore consider deviation vectors @xmath325 with the form @xmath332 @xmath328 is known as a jacobi propagator . it satisfies the jacobi equation @xmath333 along @xmath324 together with the initial conditions @xmath334 note that @xmath328 is a bitensor . it maps vectors at @xmath104 into vectors at others points on @xmath324 . the transverse components of @xmath328 are @xmath335 where @xmath52 is the matrix defined in sect . [ sect : ab ] . other components of @xmath328 may be deduced from the eigenvector relations @xcite @xmath336 all parts of an image must arrive at an observer along null geodesics . additionally , an observer with 4-velocity @xmath308 can only measure angles of vectors orthogonal to @xmath308 . it therefore suffices to restrict attention to deviation vectors satisfying @xmath337 at @xmath104 . these constraints restrict all interesting initial data to a two dimensional space . the orthonormal vectors @xmath338 form a basis for this space at @xmath104 . they satisfy @xmath339 parallel - transporting @xmath340 to another point on @xmath324 yields @xmath341 which forms a sachs basis @xcite on @xmath324 . initial data appearing in ( [ bdef ] ) must be of the form @xmath342 where @xmath343 is an unconstrained 2-vector . the factor @xmath344 is included here so that @xmath343 is directly related to angles on an observer s sky . a sufficiently small image may be described by a suitable set of 2-vectors @xmath343 representing the angular locations of each portion of the image with respect to the center defined by @xmath324 . each @xmath343 may be translated into a physical displacement at the source using ( [ bdef ] ) and ( [ initdata ] ) . first note that for every particular @xmath343 , ( [ rdotb ] ) implies that @xmath345 throughout @xmath324 . indeed , @xmath325 is always a linear combination of the @xmath346 together with @xmath326 . components of @xmath325 proportional to @xmath326 are physically irrelevant , so we consider only the sachs components @xmath347 \alpha^{(j)}.\ ] ] defining the @xmath13 matrix @xmath348 it is then clear that @xmath349 for any @xmath343 . @xmath350 is referred to as the jacobi matrix or jacobi map @xcite . using ( [ btrans])-([elldotb ] ) , ( [ sachso ] ) , ( [ sachsgen ] ) , and ( [ ddef ] ) , @xmath351 if a source moves on a geodesic which is instantaneously comoving with the observer , @xmath352 this discussion implies that a portion of an image with angular separation @xmath353 from the fiducial direction associated with @xmath354 is spatially separated from the fiducial emission point @xmath355 by @xmath356 the factors of @xmath357 have been introduced here to emphasize that this description is valid only for infinitesimal deviations . regardless , ( [ binterpret ] ) shows that up to the time dilation factor @xmath358 , the matrix @xmath52 central to all aspects of plane wave geometry may be physically interpreted as a transformation converting infinitesimal angles on the vertex of a light cone into infinitesimal separations elsewhere on that light cone . @xmath52 depends only on the @xmath14 coordinates of the source and emission points , and not on any other aspects of the physical configuration . it may be computed for all possible observer - source pairs directly from the wave profile @xmath65 . angles of emission ( as opposed to observation ) of the various light rays travelling from the source to the observer may be found by differentiating ( [ binterpret ] ) and applying the appropriate time dilation factor : @xmath359 the last equality here makes use of ( [ redshiftgen ] ) . applying ( [ binterpret ] ) shows that @xmath360 the symmetric matrix @xmath361 therefore converts spatial locations to emission angles within the source ( with the constraint that all light rays intersect @xmath104 ) . it is referred to as the optical deformation matrix @xcite . ( [ binterpret ] ) implies that there is a sense in which circles on the observer s sky correspond to ellipses near @xmath252 . this deformation may be parametrized by performing a polar decomposition on @xmath362 : @xmath363 here , @xmath364 and @xmath365 represent rotation matrices through some angles @xmath366 and @xmath367 . the ratio @xmath368 is related to the ellipticity of the aforementioned ellipse . @xmath367 represents the angle between the principal axes of that ellipse and the sachs basis . @xmath369 and @xmath367 are referred as shape parameters @xcite . recalling that polarization vectors are parallel - transported in the geometric optics approximation @xcite , any polarization vector must have sachs components which are constant along @xmath324 . in principle , the angle @xmath367 might therefore be measured by comparing the relative `` rotation '' between an object s observed shape and an appropriate polarization angle @xcite . for linearly polarized waves where @xmath65 can be made diagonal by an appropriate coordinate choice , @xmath370 with respect to this coordinate system and the basis ( [ sachsgen ] ) . it is shown in sect . [ sect : weakwave ] that @xmath367 also vanishes in a natural way for all sufficiently weak wavepackets which are nonzero only for short times . ( [ binterpret ] ) implies that @xmath371 converts angles at the observer to separations within the source . the determinant of @xmath350 must therefore relate solid angles at @xmath104 to physical areas near @xmath252 : @xmath372 it follows that @xmath373 may be interpreted as an `` angular diameter distance . '' absolute value signs are necessary here because @xmath374 changes sign after each pass through a conjugate hyperplane with multiplicity 1 . physically , such sign changes represent parity inversions of the resulting image . note that @xmath375 does not necessarily increase monotonically with the age of an image ( as computed using the source s proper time ) . closely related to the angular diameter distance is the luminosity distance @xmath376 one factor of @xmath377 arises here from considering light cones emanating from the source instead of the observer . the other factor of @xmath378 is related to the energy change associated with frequency shifts . now that various optical quantities have been computed for general plane wave spacetimes , we consider their application to various special cases . the simplest nontrivial plane waves are the symmetric waves . these are locally symmetric in the sense that @xmath379 . it follows from ( [ riemann ] ) that symmetric plane waves must have constant waveforms . also note that @xmath380 is killing in these examples [ as well as @xmath136 , which is killing in all plane wave spacetimes ] . particular symmetric plane waves may be specified entirely by the ( constant ) eigenvalues of @xmath65 . recalling the decomposition ( [ hgen ] ) of @xmath65 into @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath43 , a coordinate rotation may always be used to set @xmath381 for symmetric waves . it is then evident that the two eigenvalues of @xmath65 are given by @xmath382 . it is always possible to set @xmath383 where @xmath384 the weak energy condition implies that @xmath385 , so at least one eigenvalue of @xmath65 must be negative ( implying that at least one of the @xmath386 must be positive ) . we assume for definiteness that @xmath387 . then , @xmath388 if the vacuum einstein equation is imposed , @xmath389 and @xmath390 . for conformally - flat geometries representing spacetimes associated with , e.g. , pure electromagnetic plane waves , @xmath391 and @xmath392 . other cases may be viewed as superpositions of gravitational and ( `` gravito''-)electromagnetic waves . all symmetric waves produce an infinite number of images of almost every source . it is clear from ( [ symwave ] ) that these waves are also linearly polarized . the angles @xmath367 and @xmath366 appearing in ( [ distortion ] ) therefore vanish when considering image deformations with respect to the sachs basis ( [ sachsgen ] ) . other lensing properties depend on the sign of @xmath393 . we call the case @xmath394 `` gravity - dominated '' and the case @xmath395 `` matter - dominated . '' consider symmetric plane wave spacetimes where @xmath396 . gravity - dominated waves such as these generalize the vacuum waves satisfying @xmath397 . symmetric vacuum waves arise from , e.g. , the penrose limit of a null geodesic orbiting a schwarzschild black hole on the light ring . for any gravity - dominated symmetric wave , the matrices @xmath51 and @xmath66 defined in sect . [ sect : ab ] are @xmath398 it is clear that @xmath399 has an infinite number of zeros for any choice of @xmath121 . each of these zeros represents a phase conjugate to @xmath121 . there are an infinite number of such phases in both the past and future of every observer . the discussion in sect . [ sect : numimages ] therefore implies that under generic conditions , an infinite number of images appear for almost every source . explicitly , all conjugate phases are given by @xmath400 where @xmath127 is any nonzero integer . it is evident from ( [ idef ] ) that all of these phases have multiplicity 1 . for any @xmath209 and any observation point @xmath104 with @xmath401 , exactly one image of each source is visible as that source appeared in @xmath117 . this corresponds to the region between @xmath402 and @xmath403 . note that @xmath399 switches sign on each pass through a conjugate phase . the parity of an image emitted from @xmath117 is therefore opposite to the parity of an image emitted from @xmath404 . specializing to cases where the source is a geodesic and the observer is instantaneously comoving with that source on @xmath115 , some configurations lead to redshifts and others to blueshifts . using ( [ redshiftgeodesic ] ) , @xmath405 an image is therefore redshifted if and only if @xmath406 it is blueshifted when @xmath407 . there is no frequency shift at all in cases where @xmath408 the direction of the frequency shift clearly depends only on the instantaneous orientation @xmath409 of the source and the observer on @xmath115 . in particular , it does not depend on which image is considered . all images of a particular source experience the same type of frequency shift . emission times @xmath59 for an observer comoving with a geodesic source may be found by solving ( [ siggeo ] ) . for gravity - dominated symmetric waves , this equation reduces to @xmath410 if @xmath411 , it is evident that the image from @xmath412 must satisfy @xmath413 . images from the distant past are therefore emitted at phases @xmath59 very nearly conjugate to @xmath121 : @xmath414 substituting this relation into ( [ psidef ] ) and ( [ redshiftgravsym ] ) shows that very old images cluster near @xmath28 on the observer s sky and experience increasingly - negligible frequency shifts : @xmath415 old images of slightly extended sources are also highly distorted and demagnified . their angular diameter and luminosity distances both scale like @xmath416 gravity - dominated symmetric waves therefore produce an infinite number of exponentially dimming images for almost every source . matter - dominated symmetric waves satisfying @xmath395 act somewhat differently than gravity - dominated waves . in these cases , @xmath417 phases conjugate to @xmath121 occur at @xmath418 and at @xmath419 , where @xmath420 are any nonzero integers . if @xmath421 is an irrational number , these two families of phases are distinct . each conjugate pair then has multiplicity 1 . if @xmath421 is rational , some conjugate pairs have multiplicity 2 . in the conformally - flat case where @xmath422 , all conjugate phases have multiplicity 2 . in every other case where @xmath421 is rational , an infinite number of conjugate phases occur with each multiplicity . regardless of @xmath393 , an infinite number of images are formed for almost every source . now consider a luminous source moving on a geodesic . if the source and observer are instantaneously comoving in the sense of ( [ comoving2 ] ) and ( [ comoving3 ] ) , frequency shifts associated with each image are given by ( [ redshiftgeodesic ] ) . since @xmath423 is negative - definite in this case , all images are redshifted . if @xmath411 , an image originating from @xmath412 must be emitted just before the source intersects @xmath118 . all such images cluster towards @xmath28 in the observer s sky and have negligible frequency shifts . images emitted near conjugate hyperplanes with multiplicity 1 are highly distorted . images emitted near conjugate hyperplanes with multiplicity 2 are not significantly distorted at all . in both cases , however , older images are dimmer ( although the rate at which this occurs is much slower than for gravity - dominated symmetric waves ) . regardless of the sign of @xmath393 , the oldest images formed by symmetric plane wave spacetimes depend on the spacetime structure at arbitrarily large transverse distances . if the metric is modified so that the wave decays at large distances , only a finite number of images discussed here would be unaffected . the oldest images found in pure symmetric waves likely do not appear at all in perturbed symmetric waves . symmetric plane waves are mathematically simple , but are not reasonable models for gravitational radiation emitted from compact sources . more interesting are waves where @xmath21 is nonzero only for a finite time : sandwich waves . suppose , in particular , that there exists some @xmath424 such that @xmath425 for all @xmath426 $ ] . it follows from ( [ riemann ] ) that such spacetimes are locally flat whenever @xmath427 or @xmath428 . the curved region containing the gravitational wave is effectively sandwiched between the two null hyperplanes @xmath429 and @xmath430 . every timelike curve eventually passes entirely through such a wave . before an observer interacts with the wave , spacetime is flat and optics is trivial . the case @xmath431 where an observer has already passed through the wave is more interesting . in this case , @xmath51 and @xmath52 reduce to their flat space forms @xmath432 when @xmath433 . the forms of @xmath51 and @xmath52 inside the wave depend on the details of @xmath65 , and will not be discussed here . if @xmath434 , however , there always exist four constant @xmath13 matrices @xmath343 , @xmath435 , @xmath436 and @xmath437 such that @xmath438 note that the dots on @xmath435 and @xmath437 do not refer to derivatives in this case . they are only used as a labelling device . it follows from ( [ primedd ] ) that @xmath439 is independent of @xmath121 . moreover , @xmath440 if there were no wave at all , @xmath441 and @xmath442 . in general , @xmath435 and @xmath437 have a simple physical interpretation . if two geodesics are comoving and have a transverse separation @xmath443 when @xmath428 , it follows from ( [ spatgeo ] ) that the transverse separation between these geodesics is @xmath444 immediately before they interact with the wave at @xmath445 . similarly , the relative transverse velocity of these geodesics is @xmath446 when @xmath427 . interpretations for @xmath343 and @xmath436 are somewhat less direct . consider two geodesics which intersect at some time @xmath431 after the wave has passed , but which have a relative transverse velocity @xmath447 at @xmath58 . the difference in transverse velocities between these two geodesics is then @xmath448 when @xmath427 . similarly , the difference in the transverse positions of these geodesics is @xmath449 at @xmath445 . it follows that @xmath343 controls shifts in position that are independent of the time @xmath121 at which the two geodesics cross each other . in principle , @xmath343 , @xmath435 , @xmath436 , @xmath437 may all be found by solving ( [ edef ] ) if @xmath65 is known . at first glance , this would appear to imply that @xmath450 numbers are required to describe observations through a sandwich wave . the actual number of required parameters is somewhat less than this . first note that the wronskian identity ( [ wronskian ] ) implies that @xmath451 is a symmetric matrix . it also implies that @xmath452 further simplifications arise by recalling from ( [ symmatrices ] ) that @xmath453 and @xmath454 are symmetric . it follows that @xmath455 are symmetric as well . these expressions are completely general , and hold for any sandwich wave . they significantly constrain the number of independent parameters needed to specify @xmath51 and @xmath52 . equivalently , they limit the number of parameters that must be extracted from @xmath65 . it follows from the arguments of sect . [ sect : numimages ] that the number of images of a generic source observable in any plane wave spacetime is governed by the number of hypersurfaces conjugate to the @xmath456 hypersurface @xmath115 containing the observation event @xmath104 . continuing to assume that @xmath431 , all phases conjugate to @xmath121 must be smaller than @xmath457 . it follows from ( [ zerodet ] ) and ( [ bsandwich ] ) that conjugate phases occurring before the wave may be found by solving @xmath458 = 0 \label{conjsand}\ ] ] for all @xmath459 . this equation is quadratic , so at most two solutions exist . an observer ahead of the wave may therefore see at most three images of a source as it appeared behind the wave . there may also be at most one image of a source as it appeared ahead of the wave . in principle , any number of images may arise from inside the wave [ where ( [ bsandwich ] ) is not valid ] if @xmath21 is sufficiently large . conjugate phases found by solving ( [ conjsand ] ) clearly depend on the observation time @xmath121 . less obviously , the _ number _ of conjugate phases can also depend on @xmath121 . for an observer moving on a timelike worldline ( where @xmath121 increases monotonically ) , new conjugate phases and therefore new images sometimes appear at discrete times . these images correspond to observation times where ( [ conjsand ] ) momentarily degenerates to a linear equation . new images can therefore arise when @xmath460 and @xmath461 if @xmath462 , the two solutions to this equation are @xmath463 \pm \sqrt { [ \tr \bm{\beta } \tr \dot{\bm{\beta } } - \tr ( \bm{\beta } \dot{\bm{\beta}})]^2 - 4 \det \bm{\beta } \det \dot{\bm{\beta } } } } { 2 \det \dot{\bm{\beta } } } .\ ] ] only solutions satisfying @xmath464 are physically relevant . when a conjugate phase of this type first appears , it satisfies @xmath465 the associated image therefore provides a picture of the infinitely distant past . furthermore , an infinite amount of the source s history appears to the observer within a finite amount of proper time . this implies that new images are highly blueshifted . no matter how long an observer waits , no conjugate phase can exceed @xmath457 . the emission time for an associated image might therefore be expected to tend towards a constant value as @xmath466 . this means that a very large amount of proper time at the observer corresponds to only a small amount of proper time at a source . images which appear suddenly and are initially highly blueshifted become highly redshifted at late times . it is unclear precisely what these types of images imply . to the extent that geometric optics remains valid , all observers passing through @xmath467 momentarily see almost the entire universe appear infinitely blueshifted as it was in the infinitely distant past . furthermore , ( [ angleredshift ] ) implies that all of the universe is briefly compressed into a single point on each observer s sky . of course , such phenomena lie outside the domain of geometric optics . they may even lie outside of the realm of test fields propagating on a fixed background spacetime . extreme focusing events like these might indicate instabilities inherent in the plane wave geometry itself . it should , however , be noted that all of the infinities just alluded to are likely to have finite cutoffs in `` realistic '' plane waves which decay at large transverse distances . one important class of sandwich waves are those that are very weak and last only for a short time . in these cases , @xmath343 , @xmath435 , @xmath436 , and @xmath437 may be expanded as integrals involving successively higher powers of @xmath65 . to lowest order in such a scheme , @xmath51 and @xmath52 are approximately unaffected by the wave while inside of it . assuming that @xmath468 , the first corrections to this assumption are @xmath469 this approximation is consistent with ( [ wronskian ] ) [ and therefore ( [ wronsksand ] ) as well ] . in terms of the matrices appearing in ( [ bsandwich ] ) , @xmath470 , @xmath471 , and @xmath472 note that eqs . ( [ asand ] ) and ( [ bsand ] ) should be applied with care if @xmath65 involves many oscillations of an approximately periodic function . in these cases , the integral of @xmath65 can be very nearly zero . terms nonlinear in @xmath65 might then be significant . assuming that ( [ asand ] ) and ( [ bsand ] ) are indeed adequate approximations for @xmath51 and @xmath52 , a coordinate rotation may always be used to diagonalize @xmath437 . there then exist two constants @xmath473 and @xmath474 such that @xmath475 in this sense , all sufficiently short gravitational plane waves act as though they are linearly polarized [ so @xmath476 in ( [ distortion ] ) ] . in terms of the individual wavefunctions appearing in ( [ hgen ] ) , @xmath477 , \\ \mathcal{h}_2 & = & \int_0^{u_+ } \rmd w [ h_\|(w ) - h_+(w)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the transverse coordinates @xmath16 have also been chosen such that @xmath478 if a wave satisfies the vacuum einstein equation , @xmath48 and @xmath479 . more generally , it follows from the weak energy condition that @xmath480 now assume that the integral of @xmath39 is non - negative , which entails only a minimal loss of generality . then , @xmath481 we say that a wave is gravity - dominated if @xmath482 and matter - dominated if @xmath483 . these definitions are closely analogous to those used to classify symmetric plane waves in sect . [ sect : symwaves ] . there , a wave was said to be gravity- or matter - dominated depending on the sign of the constant @xmath484 appearing in ( [ symwave ] ) . for weak gravity - dominated wavepackets , there can be at most one phase conjugate to an observer satisfying @xmath485 . if this exists , it evident from ( [ bsand ] ) that @xmath486 is conjugate to @xmath121 with multiplicity 1 . this equation is valid only if @xmath487 . a conjugate phase therefore exists only for observers satisfying @xmath488 note that @xmath489 is the unique physically - relevant solution to ( [ newtau ] ) in the gravity - dominated case . waves that are matter - dominated ( so @xmath483 ) also admit the conjugate phase ( [ tau1 ] ) when @xmath121 satisfies ( [ observer1 ] ) . in the conformally - flat case where @xmath490 , this is the only conjugate phase . unlike in the gravity - dominated case , the multiplicity of @xmath491 is equal to 2 for conformally - flat waves . in all other matter - dominated cases , @xmath491 has multiplicity 1 and a second conjugate phase is admitted ( also with multiplicity 1 ) for all observers satisfying @xmath492 this occurs at @xmath493 note that ( [ observer2 ] ) is a more stringent condition than ( [ observer1 ] ) . as implied by the notation , @xmath494 . .46 .46 .47 consider a point source moving on a timelike worldline @xmath138 in a weak sandwich wave spacetime . such a source appears differently when observed at different times . it is clear that when @xmath495 , exactly one image of @xmath138 is viewable under generic conditions . as time passes , the wave eventually passes through the observer . a second image then appears when @xmath496 . this image is always emitted before the first . if the wave involves a sufficient amount of ricci curvature ) and ( [ bsand ] ) be valid . it is possible for , e.g. , sufficiently strong vacuum waves to admit two conjugate phases in the region @xmath427 . ] ( from e.g. , electromagnetic plane waves ) and is not conformally - flat , a third image appears when @xmath497 . this is emitted before the first two images . all images persist indefinitely once they appear . sufficiently far in the future , one image is observed of the source as it appeared after interacting with the gravitational wave . all other images predate this interaction . [ fig : emissionsand ] . when the second image first appears at @xmath498 , the new conjugate phase @xmath499 is divergent . at all later times , it is finite . the same is also true for the emission times associated with the second image . almost the entire past history of the source is therefore observable within a finite proper time . this implies an infinite blueshift . at late times , @xmath500 . the observed evolution of the source via the second image effectively freezes as @xmath59 asymptotes to @xmath501 ( which predates the source s interaction with the wave ) . images such as these are highly redshifted , as indicated in fig . [ fig : redshift ] . note that a similar transition from infinite blueshift to infinite redshift also applies to the third image if it exists . except that three different choices are made for the value of @xmath502 . curves for both images are shifted to the right as @xmath502 is decreased . the younger ( solid ) curves are almost unaffected by the wave if @xmath502 is sufficiently large . for smaller values of @xmath502 , both curves are strongly bent by the constraint that they ca nt pass through the dotted curve representing @xmath491 . ] .46 .46 another qualitative feature of the emission times plotted in fig . [ fig : emissionsand ] is that there is a sense in which pairs of images can `` switch roles . '' consider , e.g. , the left panel of that figure . at late times , the solid curve ( corresponding to the younger image ) is perfectly linear . indeed , it remains very nearly linear until @xmath503 . a rapid transition then occurs where the dashed curve effectively takes over this linear behavior while the solid curve strongly deviates from it . in a sense , the two images reverse their roles . this phenomenon occurs one more time ( somewhat less sharply ) around @xmath504 when the second image first appears . it arises essentially because @xmath505 for the younger image and @xmath506 for the older image . these constraints can cause emission curves to bend sharply with large accompanying frequency shifts in order to avoid intersecting @xmath491 . whether or not this occurs depends on whether the `` average '' linear increase of @xmath59 ever comes near @xmath491 . if it does , this role switching occurs . if not , the younger image is barely affected by the gravitational wave at all . this is illustrated in fig . [ fig : changingv ] , where emission curves for several sources are plotted simultaneously . to summarize , images which appear at discrete times briefly appear as bright , highly blueshifted `` flashes . '' indeed , fig . [ fig : luminosity ] shows that their luminosity distances go to zero . simultaneously , the angular diameter distance of each new image tends to infinity . it is implied by ( [ angleredshift ] ) that all highly blueshifted images make must a very small angle @xmath317 with @xmath28 on the observer s sky . the second ( and third ) images therefore appear aligned with the direction of propagation of the gravitational wave when they first appear . this direction could be quite different from the location of the other image(s ) . as time progresses , all images migrate across the observer s sky as illustrated in fig . [ fig : angles ] . different images may remain separated from each other by large angles at all times . .46 .46 despite their simplicity , plane gravitational waves behave in qualitatively different ways from lenses associated with quasi - newtonian mass distributions . as expected from their dynamic nature , plane waves generically shift the observed frequencies of various images . they may also admit images which appear to move , deform , change brightness , and shift color as time progresses . more subtle differences relate to the number of images that are produced of a given source . for example , even numbers of images can appear generically ( which has led plane wave spacetimes to be cited @xcite as well - behaved examples where the odd number theorem @xcite does not apply ) . some plane waves can even produce an infinite number of discrete images . perhaps most striking of all are the bright flashes shown to be produced by generic sandwich waves in sect . [ sect : sandwaves ] . these correspond to individual images which appear at discrete times . more typical gravitational lenses can produce new images if a source crosses an observer s caustic . individual images then split into two ( or vice versa ) . the flashes produced by sandwich waves are quite different . their appearance does not require that a source pass through an observer s caustic . such images appear individually from the infinitely distant past . initially , they are infinitely bright and infinitely blueshifted points of light appearing in the direction of propagation associated with the gravitational wave . many of these effects depend at least partially on the idealization that a plane wave extends undiminished to infinitely - large transverse distances . plane wave spacetimes are not asymptotically flat . despite being topologically trivial and locally well - behaved , they are not even globally hyperbolic : null geodesics passing between appropriately - chosen pairs of points can extend to arbitrarily large transverse distances in between those points . it is this property which permits the infinite number of images described in sect . [ sect : symwaves ] to be produced by symmetric waves . the flashes described in sect . [ sect : sandwaves ] also depend on the spacetime structure at arbitrarily large distances . this structure likely affects the formation of even numbers of images as well . indeed , the usual proofs of the odd number theorem require global hyperbolicity , among other assumptions @xcite ( see , however , @xcite for a more general formulation ) . if a spacetime has the geometry of a plane wave only out to some finite transverse distance , all results derived here remain valid if the associated images involve light rays which never extend sufficiently far to interact with any large - distance modifications . the infinite sequence of images formed by a symmetric plane wave would then be expected to become finite for spacetimes which are only approximately plane waves . calculations involving the oldest images could no longer be trusted in these cases . similarly , the bright flashes associated with ideal sandwich waves are likely to be somewhat less extreme for waves which decay at infinity . large brightnesses and large blueshifts can still exist , but these will be cut off at some finite maximum . such maxima may , however , remain quite large . it is reasonably clear that modifications of the geometry at large distances can remove some images . less obviously , these modification can also introduce new images . consider , for example , the @xmath507-wave spacetimes obtained by substituting @xmath508 in the metric ( [ planewavemetric ] ) . these generalize the plane wave spacetimes . it has been shown that if @xmath509 grows subquadratically as @xmath510 , the resulting geometries are globally hyperbolic @xcite . moreover , every pair of points is connected by at least one geodesic in these cases ( unlike in pure plane wave spacetimes where the growth of @xmath509 is precisely quadratic ) . this implies that modifications of the geometry at large transverse distances can introduce new null geodesics even between points at small transverse distances . it would be interesting to explore these effects in more depth to understand precisely how modifications of this sort ( or more general ones ) alter the lensing properties described here for ideal plane waves . it would also be interesting to better understand what the transient flashes of sect . [ sect : sandwaves ] imply for waves propagating on plane ( or almost - plane ) wave spacetimes . this can likely be facilitated by the green functions derived in @xcite . 1 perlick v 2004 _ living rev . relativity _ * 7 * 9 petters a o , levine h and wambsganss j 2001 _ singularity theory and gravitational lensing _ ( boston , ma : birkhuser ) schneider p , ehlers j and falco e e 1992 _ gravitational lenses _ ( new york , ny : springer - verlag ) petters a o and werner m c 2010 _ gen . * 42 * 2011 mckenzie r h 1985 * 26 * 1592 perlick v 1996 * 13 * 529 perlick v 2001 _ comm . math . phys . _ * 220 * 403 ehlers j and newman e t 2000 * 41 * 3344 friedrich h and stewart j m 1983 _ london _ a * 385 * 345 frittelli s and newman e t 1999 d * 59 * 124001 seitz s , schneider p and ehlers j 1994 * 11 * 2345 werner m c 2009 * 50 * 082504 blandford r and narayan r 1986 _ astrophys . j. _ * 310 * 568 damour t and esposito - farse g 1998 d * 58 * 044003 kovner i 1990 _ astrophys . j. _ * 351 * 114 frieman j a , harari d d and surpi g c 1994 d * 50 * 4895 faraoni v 2008 _ new astron . _ * 13 * 178 faraoni v 1998 _ int . _ d * 7 * 409 faraoni v 1991 _ gen . * 23 * 583 ehrlich p e and emch g g 1991 the conjugacy index and simple astigmatic focusing _ geometry and nonlinear partial differential equations _ eds v oliker and a treibergs ( providence , ri : american mathematical society ) ehrlich p e and emch g g 1993 geodesic and causal behavior of gravitational plane waves : astigmatic conjugacy _ differential geometry : geometry in mathematical physics and related topics _ eds r e greene r e and s - t yau ( providence , ri : american mathematical society ) beem j , ehrlich p and easley k 1996 _ global lorentzian geometry _ ( new york , ny : dekker ) harte a i and drivas t d 2012 d * 85 * 124039 hollowood t j and shore g m 2008 _ j. high energy phys . _ * 12 * 091 hollowood t j , shore g m and stanley r j 2009 _ j. high energy phys . _ * 08 * 089 bondi h and pirani f a e 1989 _ london _ a * 421 * 395 bondi h , pirani f a e and robinson i 1959 _ london _ a * 251 * 519 penrose r 1976 any spacetime has a plane wave as a limit _ differential geometry and relativity _ eds . m cahen and m flato ( dordrecht : reidel ) blau m , frank d and weiss s 2006 * 23 * 3993 berenstein d , maldacena j m and nastase h 2002 _ j. high energy phys . _ * 04 * 013 grignani g , harmark t , marini a and orselli m 2010 _ j. high energy phys . _ * 06 * 034 stanley r and hollowood t j 2011 _ j. high energy phys . _ * 10 * 096 wald r m 1984 _ general relativity _ ( chicago , il : university of chicago press ) eardley d m , lee d l and lightman a p 1973 d * 8 * 3308 pravda v , pravdov a , coley a and milson r 2002 * 19 * 6213 torre c g 2006 _ gen . rel . grav . _ * 38 * 653 gnther p 1988 _ huygens principle and hyperbolic equations _ ( london : academic press ) etherington i m h 1933 _ phil . mag . _ * 15 * 761 ellis g f r 1971 relativistic cosmology _ general relativity and cosmology : proceedings of the 47th international school of physics `` enrico fermi '' _ ed r k sachs ( new york , ny : academic press ) hartman p 1982 _ ordinary differential equations _ ( boston , ma : birkhuser ) hubeny v , rangamani m and ross s 2004 d * 69 * 024007 penrose r 1965 * 37 * 215 frittelli s , kling t p and newman e t 2000 d * 63 * 023006 surpi g c and harari d d 1999 _ astrophys . j. _ * 515 * 455 flores j l and snchez m 2006 _ lect . notes phys . _ Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the relational data base model , introduced by codd in @xcite , has been particularly successful since it is a mathematically elegant model well suited to describe almost all `` real world '' situations . since the query languages associated to such model ( the _ relational algebra _ and the _ relational calculus _ ) have a formal and simple definition , an interesting field of research is to study the expressive power of such language . codd @xcite has proved that the relational algebra is equivalent to the _ relational calculus _ , in the sense that both query languages can compute the same set of relations . a breakthrough in this field @xcite has been a syntactic characterization of the set of relations that can be computed in a give data base . these results , also known as _ bp - completeness _ , are based on the principle of data independency from the physical representation : the information that can be extracted from the data base is completely determined at the logical level of such data base . this fact can be stated in a simple way : a relation @xmath0 can be computed from a data base @xmath1 if and only if all permutations over the elements of @xmath1 which preserve @xmath1 ( that is , all permutations that produce a data base isomorphic to @xmath1 ) , also preserve @xmath0 . an interesting interpretation of this property is that only the information given by the structure of the data can be used to differentiate data values ; consequently , a query is expressible if and only if it does not add any additional differentiation to the one initially available @xcite . this idea can be rephrased by stating that the result of a query is invariant w.r.t . permutations of indistinguishable values ; such a permutation was captured with the notion of automorphism in @xcite . while the @xmath2-criterion is a natural requirement , it refers to properties of relations in a given data base instead of queries as a whole . we recall that a query is an expression of the query language that can be applied to different data bases leading to possibly different results . thus it has been extended to a property of queries as partial functions from data bases to data bases , which is known nowadays as _ @xcite : it has been recognized as the capability of the calculus to preserve isomorphisms between data bases , rather than automorphisms . genericity is a common requirement for query languages and it is traditionally related to the _ data independence _ principle that assumes that the data base is constructed over an abstract domain which is independent from the internal representation of data . subsequent research has shown that this approach to the analysis of the expressiveness of a query language has certain shortcomings @xcite , mainly when new data models , such as the object - based model , are introduced . other notions have been proposed to analyze properties of queries in some new models @xcite pointing out the importance of extending genericity to be used in more complex models . in @xcite languages are classified w.r.t . the degree of the use of the equality predicate , by analyzing the invariance property of queries under different mappings ( not necessarily isomorphisms ) over the data domain , which are compatible with the relational structure of the data base . subsequent advances in data base theory have led to different models that take into account the limitations of the relational model when it comes to describe complex situations . most of such models have been introduced in the graph - based or object - oriented frameworks , but usually their mathematical foundations do not allow a complete study of the expressive power of the query languages introduced . in fact , to our knowledge , the only exception is the graph - based model good @xcite . in this paper we introduce a different syntactic characterization of queries computable in a data base . our characterization relies upon the notion of partitions of the domain , where each partition represents a level of _ undifferentiation _ among objects , values or vertices . notice that an automorphism also can represent a certain level of undifferentiation . initially we will exploit such notion to give two new characterizations of relations expressible in a relational data base . subsequently , we will show how to apply the new framework to analyze a simple graph - based model , hence proving that our characterization can be useful in comparing the expressive power of different data languages . following the approach of @xcite , the data models studied in this paper are domain - preserving , that is , it is not possible to create new vertices or values , but only to query an existing data base . in our framework , a binary relation over sets of data values is defined , denoted by @xmath3 , which relates those sets of values that can not be differentiated . from the relation @xmath3 we build some sets of partitions that _ respect _ @xmath3 , that is , all classes in a partition are preserved by @xmath3 . we prove that expressiveness of a query language can be stated as the conservation of some of those partitions , where the exact set of partitions that must be preserved depends on the data model . the expressibility results we obtain have the following form : _ given a data base @xmath1 , let @xmath4 be a relation or a graph over the domain set of @xmath1 . then @xmath4 can be expressed in @xmath1 if and only if @xmath5 _ , where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are two sets of partitions which depend on the model under consideration . all sets considered in this paper are assumed to be finite and nonempty . given a set @xmath8 , a _ relation _ @xmath0 over @xmath8 is a subset of the cartesian product @xmath9 ( @xmath10 times ) for some fixed integer @xmath11 , that is a set of tuples of length @xmath10 , where all components of a tuple are elements of @xmath8 . the number @xmath12 is called the _ order _ or _ arity _ of the relation . given a set @xmath13 of relations over @xmath8 , the pair @xmath14 is called a _ relational database _ ; in this setting , @xmath8 is the _ domain _ of the database , and @xmath15 is the set of relations of the database . given a relation @xmath16 of a database @xmath14 , we denote with @xmath17 the _ data domain _ of @xmath0 , that is the subset of the elements of the database domain @xmath8 that are in at least one tuple of @xmath0 . the notion of data domain is easily extended to the set @xmath15 of relations as the set union of relations data domains : @xmath18 . without loss of generality , we can assume that @xmath19 for every considered database @xmath14 . this seemingly trivial requirement is indeed very important , as it will become evident after theorem [ teo : paredaens2 ] , therefore we will omit the universe set unless it is necessary to avoid any ambiguities . just as in @xcite , when referring to a relational database , we use the _ relational algebra _ as a query language . in relational algebra two binary operators ( union and product ) and three unary operators ( projection , equality restriction and inequality restriction ) are given . in the following definition all relations are defined over the same database domain @xmath8 . [ def : relational - algebra ] let @xmath0 and @xmath4 be two relations with the same arity ; the _ union _ of @xmath0 and @xmath4 , denoted by @xmath20 , is simply the set theoretical union of the two sets of tuples . given two relations @xmath0 and @xmath4 ( not necessarily with the same arity ) , the ( cartesian ) _ product _ of @xmath0 and @xmath4 , denoted by @xmath21 , is the set of all possible concatenations of a tuple of @xmath0 with a tuple of @xmath4 : @xmath22 . the abbreviation @xmath23 is used to express the relation @xmath24 ( @xmath25 times ) . let @xmath26 be the arity of a relation @xmath0 , @xmath27 a positive integer and @xmath28 @xmath29 a function . the _ projection _ of @xmath0 over @xmath30 , denoted by @xmath31 , is the relation : @xmath32 . now , let @xmath33 and @xmath34 be two integers such that @xmath35 , where @xmath26 is the arity of a relation @xmath0 . the _ equality restriction _ of @xmath0 on @xmath33 and @xmath34 is the relation , denoted by @xmath36 , that is obtained by taking from @xmath0 all the tuples for which the @xmath33-th and the @xmath34-th components are equal : @xmath37 . analogously , the _ inequality restriction _ of @xmath0 on @xmath33 and @xmath34 , denoted by @xmath38 , is the relation obtained by taking from @xmath0 all the tuples for which the @xmath33-th and the @xmath34-th components are different : @xmath39 . the five operations just described are sufficient to generate the operations of intersection , difference , join and division , usually assumed as primitives in codd s relational algebra ; a proof of this fact can be found , for example , in @xcite . given a relational data base @xmath40 , we will denote by @xmath41 the relation which is the result of applying the expression ( of the relational algebra ) e to the data base @xmath1 . moreover a relation @xmath4 over @xmath8 is told to be _ expressible _ from @xmath15 if there exists an expression @xmath42 whose operands are all relations in @xmath15 , and such that @xmath41 is equal to @xmath4 . following @xcite , we denote with @xmath43 ( basic information contained in the set of relations @xmath15 ) the set of relations that can be expressed from @xmath15 . as observed in @xcite , @xmath43 is the set of the answers to all possible queries that can be asked to a relational datmabase that contains the relations @xmath15 . in @xcite , paredaens gives a characterization of the class @xmath43 based upon appropriate automorphisms , that is permutations of the elements of the database domain . let @xmath0 be a relation of order @xmath26 over a set @xmath8 . as in @xcite , an _ automorphism _ is a bijective function ( that is , a permutation ) on @xmath8 . we say that the automorphism @xmath44 _ respects _ the relation @xmath0 or , equivalently , that @xmath45 is @xmath0-_compatible _ if , for each tuple @xmath46 , @xmath47 . the compatibility of an automorphism @xmath44 with respect to a relation @xmath0 can be naturally extended to a set @xmath15 of relations in the following way : @xmath45 _ respects _ the relations in @xmath15 or , equivalently , @xmath45 is @xmath15-_compatible _ if @xmath45 is @xmath0-compatible for each relation @xmath0 in @xmath15 . notice that the set of automorphisms @xmath15-_compatible _ , is a group of elements , a binary associative operation on @xmath48 , and an identity element @xmath49 , such that the operation is closed and invertible in @xmath48 ] where the operation is the composition of functions and the identity is the identity function ( i.e. the function defined as @xmath51 ) . as in @xcite , we denote with @xmath52 the set of all the automorphisms @xmath44 which are @xmath15-compatible ; with a small abuse of notation , if @xmath53 , we will usually write @xmath54 instead of @xmath55 . it will be very useful to consider the following representation of @xmath52 . let @xmath14 be a relational database , with @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and let @xmath58 be the set of @xmath15-compatible automorphisms . the following relation of arity @xmath59 : @xmath60 is called the _ cogroup relation _ of @xmath14 . as we can see , each row ( tuple ) of the relation @xmath61 represents one of the @xmath15-compatible automorphisms . since we do not associate any particular meaning to the elements of the domain @xmath8 , if @xmath62 we can assume , without loss of generality , @xmath63 . we can also assume that the first tuple of @xmath61 represents the identity function on @xmath8 ( which is always present in @xmath52 , since it is compatible with every nonempty set of relations ) ; as a consequence , it can always be assumed that the first row of @xmath61 is the tuple @xmath64 . let @xmath14 be a relational data base , with : * @xmath65 * @xmath66 , with : @xmath67 it is easily verified that : @xmath68 @xmath69 if we look at the @xmath15-compatible automorphisms as permutations over @xmath8 , we can express @xmath52 as follows : @xmath70 [ ex : klein - group ] it is not difficult to see that , for a given database @xmath14 , the set @xmath52 of @xmath15-compatible automorphisms is indeed a group with respect to function composition , with the identity function over @xmath8 as unitary element . in fact , the identity over @xmath8 is always in @xmath52 , the inverse of an @xmath15-compatible automorphism is still an @xmath15-compatible automorphism , and the composition between two @xmath15-compatible automorphisms is again an @xmath15-compatible automorphism . since we can always assume @xmath71 , we can think of @xmath52 as a finite permutation group over the set @xmath72 , that is a subgroup of the symmetric group @xmath73 . in this paper we investigate the relation between expressive power and partitions of the database domain . more precisely , we investigate the possibility to characterize the expressive power of relational and graph - based databases via one or more theorems abiding to the following meta theorem . [ thm : scheme1 ] let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath4 be a relation over @xmath8 . then @xmath74 , where @xmath75 and @xmath76 are sets of partitions over @xmath8 , built from the sets @xmath15 and @xmath77 of relations respectively . the relevance of the main result in @xcite is that it is the first syntactic characterization of the relations that can be obtained from a given database @xmath14 when the relational algebra is used as a query language . more precisely , in @xcite the following theorem is proved . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath4 be a relation over @xmath8 . then @xmath78 and @xmath79 . [ teo : paredaens ] basically , paredaens has been able to point out the fundamental relation between expressiveness in a database and the set of automorphisms in the relational model . such result has been successively extended in @xcite to define in a formal way the notion of _ genericity _ , that is computable queries @xcite have to be invariant with respect to the isomorphisms between databases . we can restate theorem [ teo : paredaens ] in a form that will be more convenient for our purposes . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath4 be a relation over @xmath8 . then @xmath80 . [ teo : paredaens2 ] first of all , we show that @xmath81 . proving that @xmath82 is trivial as @xmath83 . the latter stems from the fact that the relations which are expressible from @xmath15 are those obtained from @xmath84 simply ignoring the relation @xmath4 . let now be @xmath85 and @xmath86 . if the expression that gives @xmath87 from @xmath84 does contain some occurrence of the relation @xmath4 , it is sufficient to replace such occurrence with the expression that gives @xmath4 from @xmath15 to conclude that @xmath88 , and thus @xmath89 . it is immediate to notice that @xmath90 implies @xmath91 . since we have established that @xmath81 , the two databases @xmath14 and @xmath92 are _ basic information equivalent _ that is , every relation of the first database can be obtained from the relations of the second database and vice versa if and only if @xmath4 is expressible from @xmath14 . a direct consequence of theorem [ teo : paredaens ] is that two databases @xmath93 and @xmath94 are basic information equivalent if and only if @xmath95 ( which are assumed to be both equal to @xmath8 ) and @xmath96 ; thus , we can conclude that @xmath80 as stated . we observe that , given our assumption that @xmath97 , in theorem [ teo : paredaens2 ] we can get rid of the inclusion between the domains , since it is implicit from the fact that @xmath4 is a relation over @xmath8 . on the other hand , we _ can not _ ignore the inclusion condition if we suppose that @xmath98 , since in such a situation it is not difficult to show two relations @xmath0 and @xmath4 such that @xmath99 but @xmath100 . a notion that seems tightly related to the expressiveness of relations in a database is that of _ indistinguishability _ between elements of the domain . intuitively , the idea is that the elements of a subset of the domain of a given database are indistinguishable if and only if no query to the database is able to divide the set in two parts , one made of the elements that occur in the relation resulting from the query and the other made of the elements that do not occur in the relation . in such a situation , we say that the set of indistinguishable elements can not be _ separated _ by any of the queries that can be presented to the database . thus , a relation resulting from a query to the database can only contain all or none of the elements of a non - separable set . theorem [ thm : scheme1 ] defines the general framework we propose to investigate the expressive power of query languages . in this framework different notions of expressible queries can be studied by considering different sets of partitions . for a given database @xmath14 , we say that a set @xmath75 of partitions of @xmath8 is a set of _ valid partitions _ if and only if it satisfies theorem [ thm : scheme1 ] . by the results in @xcite , it seems to us quite natural to define the following sets of valid partitions , namely the _ orbit partitions _ and the _ cycle partitions _ ; indeed later we will be able to prove that , in the context of theorem [ thm : scheme1 ] , they are equivalent to the characterization of relations obtainable in a relational data base of @xcite . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath101 , @xmath102 be a partition of @xmath8 . @xmath103 is an _ orbit partition _ of @xmath8 with respect to @xmath15 if both the following conditions hold : 1 . for each relation @xmath16 and for each class @xmath104 , @xmath105 or @xmath106 ; 2 . for each class @xmath107 and for each pair @xmath108 of elements of @xmath109 there exists an automorphism @xmath110 such that @xmath111 , and @xmath112 for every class @xmath113 . we denote with @xmath114 the set of all orbit partitions of the given database @xmath14 . [ def : orbit - partition ] let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath101 , @xmath102 be a partition of @xmath8 . @xmath103 is a _ cycle partition _ of @xmath8 with respect to @xmath15 if both the following conditions hold : 1 . for each relation @xmath16 and for each class @xmath104 , @xmath105 or @xmath106 ; 2 . there exists an automorphism @xmath110 such that for each class @xmath107 and for each pair @xmath108 of elements of @xmath109 there exists an integer @xmath59 such that @xmath115 and @xmath112 for every class @xmath113 . we denote with @xmath116 the set of all cycle partitions of the given database @xmath14 . [ def : cycle - partition ] as already stated for @xmath52 , if @xmath0 is a relation we will write @xmath117 and @xmath118 instead of @xmath119 and @xmath120 respectively . the following theorem is an alternative formulation of the main result of @xcite ( the equivalence of the two formulation follows from theorem [ teo : paredaens2 ] ) which is more useful for our purposes . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath4 be a relation over @xmath8 . then @xmath121 . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath52 and @xmath61 be respectively the group of @xmath15-compatible automorphisms and the cogroup - relation of @xmath15 . a useful fact proved in @xcite is that the cogroup - relation is expressible from @xmath15 , that is @xmath122 . using this fact , we are able to prove the following theorem . @xmath123 . [ teo : autr = cgr ] since @xmath122 , by theorem [ teo : paredaens ] we can conclude that @xmath124 . now , let @xmath125 ; as we have already observed , @xmath126 is a permutation of the set @xmath97 , as well as of the tuples that compose the relation @xmath61 . thus , for each tuple @xmath127 , we have that @xmath128 . in particular , by letting @xmath59 be the cardinality of @xmath8 , we have : @xmath129 thus , the elements of @xmath8 are mapped by @xmath126 in such a way that the result is a row of the cogroup - relation ; so we can conclude that @xmath110 . a direct consequence of theorem [ teo : autr = cgr ] is that not only @xmath122 , as established by paredaens , but also @xmath130 for every relation @xmath16 , since @xmath131 and @xmath132 . as a corollary of theorem [ teo : autr = cgr ] , if we are interested to study the expressive power of a given relational database @xmath14 then we can work as well on the database @xmath133 , which has only one relation and , moreover , such relation is an explicit representation of the finite permutation group @xmath52 . we now turn our attention to the structure of @xmath114 and @xmath116 . first of all we observe that , thanks to theorem [ teo : autr = cgr ] , we can get rid of item 1 in definitions [ def : orbit - partition ] and [ def : cycle - partition ] since , by considering the database @xmath134 , there is only one relation and , for such relation , it holds @xmath135 for each @xmath107 . to characterize the sets of cycle and orbit partitions we need to recall some notions from basic abstract algebra . let @xmath136 be a set and @xmath137 a group . action of @xmath48 on @xmath136 _ is a map @xmath138 such that 1 . @xmath139 ; 2 . @xmath140 in group theory it is customary to omit the operators symbols from expressions when confusion does not arise ; so , the expression in item 2 above is usually written as : @xmath141 . let @xmath48 be a group acting on a set @xmath136 . for @xmath142 , let @xmath143 if and only if there exists @xmath144 such that @xmath145 . it is not difficult to see that @xmath146 is an equivalence relation on @xmath136 , and thus it induces a partition @xmath103 on @xmath136 . the classes of @xmath103 are called the _ orbits _ in @xmath136 under @xmath48 . if @xmath147 , the class containing @xmath148 denoted by @xmath149 is called the _ orbit of _ @xmath148 under @xmath48 . in other words , @xmath150 . it is not difficult to see that the partition induced by the orbits of @xmath52 on @xmath8 satisfies definition [ def : orbit - partition ] . in fact , every automorphism @xmath110 maps each orbit @xmath151 into itself and , given a pair @xmath108 of elements of @xmath8 , there exists an automorphism that maps @xmath152 to @xmath153 if and only if @xmath152 and @xmath153 are in the same orbit . moreover , if @xmath154 is a subgroup of a group @xmath48 acting on the set @xmath136 , then every orbit @xmath155 is a subset of the orbit @xmath149 ; more precisely , it is not difficult to prove that the orbits induced by @xmath154 are a _ refinement _ of the orbits induced by @xmath48 . since each partition induced by the orbits of every subgroup of @xmath52 satisfies definition [ def : orbit - partition ] , we have that @xmath114 contains the set of those partitions . vice versa , let @xmath156 . it is not difficult to see that the set of automorphisms @xmath110 that map each class of @xmath103 into itself and that map each element of a class to an element of the same class forms a subgroup of @xmath52 ; moreover , the orbit partition induced by such a subgroup is just @xmath103 . as a consequence , @xmath114 is a subset of the set of partitions induced by all the subgroups of @xmath52 ; since also the converse inclusion holds , the two sets indeed coincide . let @xmath48 be a group acting on the set @xmath136 , and let @xmath157 . for @xmath142 , let @xmath143 if and only if there exists an integer @xmath59 such that @xmath158 , where @xmath159 is the application of @xmath160 for @xmath59 times . it is not difficult to see that @xmath146 is an equivalence relation on @xmath136 , and thus it induces a partition @xmath103 on @xmath136 . the classes of @xmath103 are called the _ cycles _ of @xmath160 on @xmath136 . analogously to what said about orbits , it is not difficult to see that the partitions induced by the cycles of the automorphisms of @xmath52 satisfy definition [ def : cycle - partition ] . we observe that , while an orbit partition is induced by a subgroup of @xmath52 , a cycle partition is induced by an automorphism , that is by an element of @xmath52 . the class @xmath116 is thus the set of cycle partitions obtained by considering every element of @xmath52 . let @xmath48 be a group acting on the set @xmath136 and let @xmath160 be a permutation in @xmath48 . then the _ orbits of the _ ( cyclic ) _ group _ @xmath161 generated by @xmath160 are the cycles of @xmath160 . since @xmath161 is a subgroup of @xmath48 , we have immediately that every cycle partition of @xmath48 is also an orbit partition of @xmath48 , that is , @xmath162 . example [ ex : klein - group ] can be used to show that the converse does not generally hold : not every orbit partition is also a cycle partition . in fact we have : @xmath163 as noted above , theorem [ teo : autr = cgr ] allows us to deal only with cogroup - relations instead of sets of arbitrary relations . the same can be done when working with cycle and orbit partitions : since cycles and orbits that form the partitions in @xmath116 and @xmath114 are completely determined from the elements and the subgroups of @xmath52 respectively , by theorem [ teo : autr = cgr ] we can conclude that @xmath164 and @xmath165 . it is possible to show that both the set @xmath116 of cycle partitions and the set @xmath114 of orbit partitions of a given database @xmath14 constitute a partially ordered set ( poset ) with respect to the binary relation @xmath166 , where @xmath167 iff each class of @xmath168 is contained in some class of @xmath169 , where @xmath168 and @xmath169 are two partitions in @xmath75 , @xmath75 is equal to @xmath116 or @xmath114 . in fact , it is not difficult to see that @xmath166 is reflexive , antisymmetric and transitive : that is , @xmath166 is an order relation over both @xmath116 and @xmath114 . one notably difference between the posets @xmath170 and @xmath171 is that the first has always a maximum element , corresponding to the orbits of the entire @xmath52 , while the second may not have a maximum element , as shown above referring to example [ ex : klein - group ] , where @xmath52 is the so called klein group . instead , both the posets have a minimum element , corresponding to the cycles ( equal to the orbits ) induced by the identity element of @xmath52 : that is , the trivial partition , where each class is a singleton . in order to prove our main results we need some definitions and some well known properties of finite groups . here we just recall the notion of _ stabilizer _ ; we address the reader to an introductory book on abstract algebra , such as @xcite , for the notion of coset and its properties . let @xmath48 be a group acting on a set @xmath136 , and let @xmath147 . the subgroup @xmath172 of @xmath48 defined as @xmath173 is called the _ stabilizer _ of @xmath148 in @xmath48 . it is not difficult to see that if @xmath48 is a group which acts on the set @xmath136 , and @xmath147 , then the stabilizer @xmath172 of @xmath148 can be considered as a group which acts on the set @xmath174 . the following are two well known results in group theory : lagrange s theorem which correlates the cardinality of a given group @xmath48 and the cardinality of a given subgroup @xmath154 of @xmath48 with the number of left cosets of @xmath48 with respect to @xmath154 and a theorem which expresses the cardinality of the orbit of @xmath48 containing @xmath148 as the number of left cosets of @xmath48 with respect to the stabilizer @xmath172 . let @xmath48 be a finite group , and let @xmath154 be a subgroup of @xmath48 . then @xmath175 , where @xmath176 is the number of left cosets of @xmath48 with respect to @xmath154 , and is usually called the _ index of @xmath154 in @xmath48_. let @xmath48 be a finite group acting on a set @xmath136 , and let @xmath147 . then @xmath177 , that is there exists a one - to - one correspondence between the elements of the orbit @xmath149 of @xmath148 under @xmath48 and the left cosets of the stabilizer @xmath172 in @xmath48 . [ teo : card - orbit ] we are now able to prove the following theorem . let @xmath48 be a subgroup of the symmetric group @xmath73 , and let @xmath154 be a subgroup of @xmath48 . if the orbit partitions of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same , then @xmath178 . [ teo : orbit - partitions ] we prove the assertion by induction on @xmath59 . for @xmath179 the theorem can be proved by direct inspection of the subgroups of @xmath73 . now , let us suppose that the theorem is true for @xmath180 , and let us show that it holds also for @xmath59 . we first observe that since the orbit partitions of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same , then also the orbits @xmath181 and @xmath182 of the element @xmath59 with respect to @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same . now , if we take all the partitions having @xmath183 as a class , we get the orbit partitions induced by the stabilizers @xmath184 and @xmath185 of the element @xmath59 with respect to @xmath48 and @xmath154 . these orbit partitions are equal and thus , by induction hypothesis , @xmath186 . by lagrange s theorem , we can express the cardinalities of @xmath48 and @xmath154 with respect to the cardinalities of their stabilizers as @xmath187 and @xmath188 . where @xmath189 and @xmath190 are the indices , respectively , of the stabilizer @xmath184 in @xmath48 and of the stabilizer @xmath185 in @xmath154 . by theorem [ teo : card - orbit ] , we can infer that @xmath191 and @xmath192 . since @xmath193 and @xmath194 , we can conclude that @xmath48 and @xmath154 have the same order , and thus @xmath195 . theorem [ teo : orbit - partitions ] allows us to show that the orbit partitions of a given database satisfy theorem scheme ii ; in fact , the following theorem provides a first characterization of expressible queries in relational databases alternative to the one originally given by paredaens . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath4 be a relation over @xmath8 . then @xmath196 [ teo : scheme - with - orbits ] if @xmath197 , since the orbit partitions are completely determined from the subgroups of @xmath52 , we obtain that @xmath198 . for the converse , we observe that @xmath52 is a subgroup of the symmetric group @xmath73 , and @xmath199 is a subgroup of @xmath52 . by hypothesis , the orbit partitions of @xmath52 and @xmath199 are equal and thus , by theorem [ teo : orbit - partitions ] , @xmath197 . a second characterization of expressible queries in relational databases can be obtained by considering cycle partitions instead of orbit partitions . we need the following lemma . let @xmath48 be a subgroup of the symmetric group @xmath73 , and let @xmath154 be a subgroup of @xmath48 . if the cycle partitions of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same , then also the orbits of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same , that is @xmath200 for every @xmath201 . [ lem : orbits - from - cycles ] since the orbit @xmath149 is the set of elements of @xmath72 which are reachable from @xmath148 through some element @xmath160 of @xmath48 , while a cycle containing @xmath148 is the set of elements which are reachable from @xmath148 through one element @xmath160 of @xmath48 , one method to build @xmath149 from the cycle partitions of @xmath48 is given by algorithm [ alg:1 ] . result @xmath202 @xmath203 algorithm [ alg:1 ] computes the least subset @xmath204 of @xmath72 which contains @xmath148 and such that , for every cycle partition @xmath103 of @xmath48 , @xmath204 is the union of some cycles in @xmath103 ; it is not difficult to see that @xmath204 is , indeed , the orbit @xmath149 . since the cycle partitions of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same by hypothesis , the orbits computed by the algorithm above will be the same for @xmath48 and @xmath154 , for every choice of @xmath205 . we are now ready to prove the following theorem . let @xmath48 be a subgroup of the symmetric group @xmath73 , and let @xmath154 be a subgroup of @xmath48 . if the cycle partitions of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same , then @xmath178 . [ teo : cycle - partitions ] by lemma [ lem : orbits - from - cycles ] , the orbits of @xmath48 and @xmath154 are the same . thus we can prove the theorem by the same argument used for theorem [ teo : orbit - partitions ] . a direct consequence of theorem [ teo : cycle - partitions ] is that the cycle partitions of a given database satisfy theorem schema ii ; thus , the following theorem provides a second characterization of expressible queries in relational databases alternative to the one originally given by paredaens . the proof is analogous to the one given for theorem [ teo : scheme - with - orbits ] . let @xmath14 be a relational database , and let @xmath4 be a relation over @xmath8 . then : @xmath206 [ teo : scheme - with - cycles ] a final observation is due about theorems [ teo : scheme - with - orbits ] and [ teo : scheme - with - cycles ] . even though there is a strong resemblance between our meta theorem [ thm : scheme1 ] and theorem [ teo : paredaens2 ] , our results _ can not _ be expressed neither in the form @xmath207 and @xmath208 nor in the form @xmath209 and @xmath79 , as shown in the next example . let @xmath210 and @xmath211 be two relational databases , with : * @xmath212 * r = + [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] notice that @xmath54 is the cyclic group generated by the permutation @xmath213 , while @xmath214 is the cyclic group generated by the permutation @xmath215 : @xmath216 from @xmath54 and @xmath214 we can easily obtain @xmath217 . clearly , @xmath4 is not expressible from @xmath0 , since we have @xmath218 but @xmath219 ; on the other hand , @xmath220 and @xmath221 , and @xmath222 and @xmath221 . the fact that @xmath4 is not expressible from @xmath0 can be correctly determined through orbit partitions or through cycle partitions by observing that : @xmath223 or @xmath224 . in this section we study a simple graph - based model where two labeled graphs are used to model data bases . a data base consists of two distinct layers : a _ schema _ layer and a _ structure _ layer ; the objects can be found in the latter , while the former describe the data organization . each layer is a labeled weakly - connected directed graph , moreover there exists a function that maps a schema into a structure : such function will be called an _ extension_. both vertices and edges of the graphs are labeled , and we can assume that the sets of edge labels and vertex labels , as well as schema labels and structure labels , are disjoint . an example of data base is represented in figures [ fig : schema ] , [ fig : structure ] , from which it is easy to note how the schema and the structure are closely related , the following definitions only formalize the intuitive idea . a _ schema graph _ , in short _ schema _ , is a triple @xmath225 , where @xmath226 is an oriented , weakly - connected graph , and @xmath227 , @xmath228 are respectively the injective functions that maps each node ( resp . edge ) to its label . [ def_struttura ] a _ structure _ is a triple @xmath229 , with @xmath4 a colored oriented graph @xmath230 , where @xmath231 is the set of _ nodes _ of the structure , @xmath232 is the set of _ edges _ , @xmath233 , @xmath234 are respectively the injective functions that maps each node ( resp . edge ) to its label , and @xmath235 , is a labeling of the edges over the finite alphabet @xmath236 , called _ coloring _ of the structure . in the following , we will use the set @xmath237 of colors that allows to specify that a link between object instances in @xmath238 is actual or not . in the example of fig . [ fig : structure ] , only the links labeled true are represented , and the presence ( or the abscence ) of links labeled false does not change the data stored in the data base . in fig . [ fig : false ] is represented a part of the structure , where false links are represented with dotted arrows . the schema and the structure must be strongly correlated ; in fact there must exist a function , called _ extension _ ( denoted by @xmath239 ) , mapping the schema into the structure . in order to have a sound definition of extension some restrictions must be enforced , as pointed out in the following definition , where @xmath240 stands for the family of all nonempty subsets of @xmath241 . informally @xmath239 maps each vertex of the schema into some vertices of the structure and each edge of the schema into some edges of the structure . [ def_f1 ] let @xmath242 be a schema and @xmath243 a structure , where @xmath244 . then @xmath238 is an _ extensional structure _ of @xmath245 if there is a function ( the _ extension _ ) from @xmath245 to @xmath238 , @xmath246 , such that : [ condizioni_rel ] 1 . @xmath247 is a partition @xmath248 of the set @xmath249 , 2 . for every @xmath250 , the pair @xmath251 iff @xmath252 ; notice that the first point of the definition of extension implies that the function @xmath253 is well defined . in the following , if @xmath238 is the extensional structure of @xmath245 , then we write @xmath254 and we will simply say that @xmath238 is a structure of @xmath245 . given two vertices @xmath255 and @xmath256 of the schema , connected with a link @xmath257 then in the structure there must exist all links @xmath258 for @xmath259 , @xmath260 . such requirement justifies the introduction of a labeling ( and especially of a true - false labeling ) in order to have a reasonable graph - based model . [ basedati ] a _ data base _ @xmath261 is a pair @xmath262 , where @xmath245 is a schema and @xmath238 is an extensional structure of @xmath245 . the schema describes the conceptual organization of the data , while the data content or instantiation of the data base is given by the extensional structure associated to the schema . it is not hard to notice that , given a schema , there is a one - to - one correspondence between structures and extension functions , therefore we will sometimes use the pair @xmath263 as a data base . some preliminary definitions are required for introducing our query language . given a partial function @xmath264 ( i.e. a function where each element of @xmath241 can be associated to one or none of the elements of @xmath261 ) , by @xmath265 we denote the domain of @xmath266 , that is the set of elements @xmath267 such that @xmath268 is defined . let @xmath269 be two partial functions from the set @xmath241 to the set @xmath270 . then _ @xmath266 is a restriction of @xmath160 _ , denoted by @xmath271 , if @xmath272 and for every @xmath273 , @xmath274 . moreover by @xmath275 we denote the set obtained as union of all images of elements in @xmath276 : formally @xmath277 . [ morfi ] let @xmath278 be a data base . an _ instance _ of @xmath261 is a restriction @xmath266 of @xmath239 such that @xmath265 induces a weakly - connected subgraph of @xmath245 . the following notations will be used in the rest of the paper . the set @xmath279 is the set of all instances of @xmath261 . let @xmath280 be a subset of @xmath279 , then by @xmath281 , we mean the set of nodes of the structure of @xmath261 that is the union of all images of instances in @xmath282 , while @xmath283 is the union of all domains of instances in @xmath282 . an element in @xmath284 is called a _ value _ , while an element in @xmath285 is called a _ name_. then the image of a name @xmath286 is the subset @xmath241 of @xmath284 such that @xmath287 . for a value @xmath288 , the _ inverse image of @xmath289 _ , denoted by @xmath290 , is the name of @xmath285 that is mapped by @xmath239 , to a set containing the element @xmath289 . similarly , given a set @xmath241 of values , the _ inverse image of @xmath241 _ is the set @xmath291 which is union of all inverse images of the values in @xmath241 . our graph data model is proposed as a domain - preserving data base , along the same lines as other papers where the expressiveness of the relational algebra is studied @xcite , and it gives a formal embedding for languages used for the retrieval of graph - structured information @xcite . the requirement that we are dealing with domain - preserving data bases reflects in the query language : in fact we have no operation for creating new elements or modifying the schema graph , and all operations must preserve the schema and the original structure . the main consequence of the assumption that our model is domain preserving consists in the fact that we will deal with a schema which is mapped to an instance through an extensional mapping . therefore there is a complete equivalence between subgraphs of the structure and restrictions of the extensional mapping . we are now able to introduce the operations of our graph algebra : according to our reasoning above we can describe the operation as over partial functions whenever it allows a simpler formulation . [ sovrapposizione ] let @xmath292 be a data base and let @xmath293 . the _ addition _ of @xmath294 and @xmath295 , denoted as @xmath296 , is the following function over domain @xmath297 . the operation is defined only if @xmath298 : @xmath299 [ prodotto ] let @xmath292 be a data base , and let @xmath300 be two functions in @xmath279 . the _ product _ of @xmath294 and @xmath295 , denoted as @xmath301 is the instance in @xmath279 defined as follows : @xmath302 the product is defined only if @xmath303 induces a weakly - connected subgraph of @xmath245 . [ proiezione ] let @xmath292 be a data base . let @xmath266 be a function in @xmath279 and let @xmath241 be a subset of the domain of @xmath266 , such that @xmath241 induces in @xmath245 a weakly - connected subgraph . the _ projection of @xmath266 on @xmath241 _ , denoted as @xmath304 , is the instance defined as follows : @xmath305 [ differenza ] let @xmath292 be a data base . let @xmath300 be two functions in @xmath279 over the same domain @xmath241 . the _ difference of @xmath294 by @xmath295 _ , denoted as @xmath306 is the following instance : @xmath307 the difference is defined only if @xmath308 induces a weakly - connected subgraph of @xmath245 . since the coloring of the edges encodes the fact that a relation between two objects is actual or not , it is natural that the query language has some tools for exploiting such coloring . in our model we will need to extract instances where `` similar '' edges are the same color . the definition of _ selector _ is the first step in such direction . let @xmath245 be the schema of a data base @xmath261 . then a _ selector of @xmath245 _ is a pair @xmath309 consisting of a weakly - connected subgraph @xmath48 of @xmath245 and a coloring @xmath310 of the edges of @xmath48 . querying for a selector in a data base returns all subgraphs of the structure that are isomorphic to the selector : each such subgraph is indeed called a _ simple instance_. moreover , it is natural to define an operation of selection that allows to obtain instances which are compatible with a coloring of the schema over the alphabet @xmath236 . this is the last operation of our algebra . [ simple ] let @xmath263 be a data base , where @xmath311 . let @xmath312 be a selector of @xmath245 , where @xmath313 . then a _ simple instance induced by the selector @xmath314 _ is a restriction @xmath266 of @xmath239 such that @xmath315 , @xmath316 for each @xmath317 and @xmath318 for each @xmath319 . notice that all simple instaces have the same domain . [ selezione ] let @xmath292 be a data base . let @xmath266 be a function in @xmath279 and @xmath314 a selector . let @xmath320 be the set of all simple instances induced by @xmath321 that are also subinstances of @xmath266 . the _ selection of @xmath322 by @xmath314 _ , denoted as @xmath323 , is @xmath324 . given a set @xmath280 of instances , our first aim is to give a characterization of all instances that can be obtained with a query that uses only the information contained in the instances in @xmath280 , or equivalently by an expression of the algebra that has only instances in @xmath280 as operands . in such direction the main result of this section is that expressiveness in our graph algebra is equivalent to the conservation of a certain partition . it is natural to associate a notion of _ undistinguishability _ to a partition , where all elements in a set of the partition are deemed undistinguishable . we share the goals of @xcite , but we have introduced in this paper a new framework , that is we are looking for a notion of expressiveness that is coherent with our meta theorem . just as the notion of _ automorphisms _ , introduced in @xcite for relations , gives a global description of the logical dependencies among data that must be preserved when querying the data base , in our model a partition ( or an equivalence relation ) will represent all such logical dependencies . the equivalence partition over elements of the structure that we will study is called _ stability _ and is denoted by @xmath325 ( where @xmath326 is an instance ) . the simplest possible form of undifferentiation ( called _ 0-stability _ ) is based on the idea that we are able to distinguish images of different vertices of the instance and vertices of the extensional structure belonging to different functions of @xmath326 . such notion basically consists of using expressions in our algebra that do not contain any selection . [ def : split ] let @xmath241 be a subset of the image of a set @xmath282 of instances . then @xmath241 is _ split _ by @xmath282 iff there is a function @xmath327 in @xmath282 such that @xmath328 and @xmath329 . we are now able to introduce formally the definition of 0-stability , as follows : [ 0-stable ] let @xmath282 be a set of instances over a data base @xmath262 , and let @xmath241 be a subset of @xmath281 . then @xmath241 is _ 0-stable _ w.r.t . @xmath280 , if the two following conditions hold : 1 . @xmath330 , where @xmath331 , and @xmath332 is a name of the schema . 2 . for each function @xmath333 , then @xmath241 and @xmath334 are disjoint or one is contained into the other one . a more refined notion of undifferentiation is called _ @xmath335-stability _ ; informally a set @xmath241 is 1-stable w.r.t . @xmath261 if @xmath241 is 0-stable and @xmath261 is not able to distinguish two vertices of @xmath241 with edges outgoing from @xmath261 and ingoing in @xmath241 ( or outgoing from @xmath241 and ingoing in @xmath261 ) . notice that 1-stability is a binary relation over subsets of @xmath284 , while 0-stability is a unary relation . the formal definition is : [ un_passo ] let @xmath282 be a set of instances over a data base @xmath262 and let @xmath241 and @xmath261 be two disjoint subsets @xmath281 . then @xmath241 is _ 1-stable _ w.r.t . @xmath261 and @xmath280 , denoted as @xmath336 if the following conditions are verified : 1 . @xmath241 is 0-stable w.r.t . @xmath282 ; 2 . for each edge @xmath337 of @xmath338 , with @xmath339 and for each @xmath340 there exists @xmath341 such that @xmath342 ; 3 . for each edge @xmath343 of @xmath338 , with @xmath339 and for each @xmath340 there exists @xmath341 such that @xmath344 . informally 1-stability means that whenever there is an colored edge ( say a red edge ) from a vertex of @xmath241 to a vertex of @xmath261 , then all vertices of @xmath241 have a red edge ingoing in @xmath261 . in other words if we assume that @xmath261 is undistinguishable , then also @xmath241 is undistinguishable , by any single - edge path . the notion of 1-stability can be further generalized , but first we need a new definition . [ cammino ] let @xmath345 be a labeled graph . then a _ colored path _ in @xmath48 is a pair @xmath346 where @xmath347 , and for every @xmath348 , @xmath349 belongs to @xmath231 and @xmath350 is an edge of @xmath48 such that @xmath351 or @xmath352 . moreover @xmath353 is the sequence @xmath354 where @xmath355 is the color of the edge @xmath350 in @xmath48 . notice that the definition of path used in the paper is different from the one that can be usually found in a graph theory textbook , as arcs can also be in the reverse direction . the _ length _ of a path is the number of edges it contains . let @xmath356 be a data base and let @xmath346 be a colored path of @xmath338 , with @xmath357 . then the _ path schema _ of @xmath346 is the pair @xmath358 , with @xmath359 , where for every @xmath360 , @xmath361 and @xmath362 . [ path - dependencies ] let @xmath363 be two nodes of the @xmath280-structure , and let @xmath364 be a subset of @xmath281 , then the _ path dependencies _ from @xmath148 to @xmath289 in @xmath364 , denoted as @xmath365 is the set of path schemata of all paths of the @xmath280-structure that are starting in @xmath148 and ending in @xmath289 and entirely contained in @xmath364 . informally given @xmath366 , their path dependencies is obtained by removing all vertices not in @xmath364 , then computing all possible paths from @xmath148 to @xmath289 , and finally computing the respective path schemata . the next step is to generalize 1-stability to @xmath25-stability , that is taking into account length-@xmath25 paths instead of simple edges ( that is length-1 paths ) . [ k_passi ] let @xmath282 be a set of instances over a data base @xmath262 , let @xmath25 be an integer larger than one , and let @xmath241 and @xmath261 be two disjoint subsets of @xmath281 . then @xmath241 is _ @xmath25-stable _ w.r.t . @xmath261 and @xmath280 , denoted as @xmath367 if the following conditions are verified : 1 . @xmath241 is 0-stable w.r.t . @xmath282 ; 2 . @xmath241 is @xmath368-stable w.r.t . @xmath261 and @xmath280 ; 3 . for each @xmath369 there exists @xmath341 such that @xmath370 . the main idea is that when @xmath367 then if @xmath261 is undistinguishable also @xmath241 is undistinguishable when only paths no longer than @xmath25 are taken into account . our main definition follows : [ rel_collettiva ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances , and let @xmath371 be two disjoint subsets of @xmath281 . then @xmath241 is _ stable w.r.t . @xmath261 _ in @xmath280 , denoted as @xmath372 , if @xmath373 for all @xmath374 . by def . [ rel_collettiva ] , it is immediate to verify the following properties of stability : [ prop1_rel ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances , and let @xmath375 , then : 1 . if @xmath376 and @xmath377 , then @xmath372 and @xmath378 , 2 . if @xmath379 , @xmath372 and @xmath378 , then @xmath380 , 3 . if @xmath379 , @xmath381 , @xmath382 and @xmath383 , then @xmath384 . stability is a relation between disjoint subsets of the domain . the definition of expressiveness in the query language that we want to obtain is based on partitions , and now we are able to introduce the class of partitions we are interested into . a partition @xmath385 of nodes of the structure is called _ valid _ if and only if for each set @xmath241 of the partition and every set @xmath261 that is a union of sets of @xmath385 , then @xmath261 can not differentiate @xmath241 . [ partizione_accettabile ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances . a partition @xmath386 of @xmath387 is _ valid _ if for every @xmath388 , then @xmath389 . given a set @xmath282 of instances , then there may be various valid partitions of @xmath281 , and at least one valid partition always exists ( the partition where each vertex of the extentional structure is a set ) . some valid partitions are more representative of the actual undifferentiation , in fact we will assume as a measure of the undifferentiation induced by @xmath280 the coarsest valid partition , which we will call _ canonical partition _ and denote as @xmath390 . we can show that the definition of canonical partition is well - formed . every set @xmath280 of instances has a unique canonical partition @xmath390 . clearly the partition of @xmath281 into singletons is a valid partition , so there exists at least one canonical partition . now assume to the contrary that there exist two coarsest valid partitions @xmath391 and @xmath392 . let @xmath393 and @xmath394 be the equivalence relations induced by the partitions @xmath391 and @xmath392 , respectively . let @xmath395 be the transitive closure of the relation @xmath0 defined as follows : @xmath396 if and only if @xmath148 and @xmath289 are in the same set of @xmath391 or @xmath392 . we can prove that the partition @xmath385 induced by @xmath395 is a valid one of index strictly less than @xmath25 . by construction of @xmath395 each set of @xmath385 is a union of sets in @xmath391 and also a union of sets in @xmath392 , moreover each set in @xmath385 is contained in the image of a single name ( since each set must be 0-stable ) . notice that @xmath397 iff @xmath398 . let @xmath399 be a set of @xmath385 , and let @xmath400 be a class of @xmath391 contained in @xmath399 . since @xmath391 is a valid partition , and @xmath399 is a union of disjoint sets of @xmath401 , by lemmata [ rel_collettiva ] , [ prop1_rel ] , we have that @xmath402 and @xmath403 . let @xmath399 , @xmath404 be two sets of @xmath385 , with @xmath405 and @xmath406 . we have already proved that @xmath407 and @xmath408 , applying again lemmata [ rel_collettiva ] , [ prop1_rel ] and noting that @xmath406 we obtain @xmath409 , by the generality of @xmath399 and @xmath404 the partition @xmath385 is valid . moreover @xmath385 is coarser than @xmath401 , which is a contradiction . in this section we will prove our main result regarding the expressiveness of the graph - based query language by showing that a function can be computed if and only if adding such function does not change the canonical partition . in the following we will assume that the union of the images of all functions in @xmath326 is exactly the universe set ; such assumption does not violate the generality since otherwise we would simply have some sets of the canonical partition whose union consists of exactly those elements of the universe set that are not in any function in @xmath326 . [ graal - expressivess ] let @xmath410 be the set of functions that are a result of an expression of the graph algebra where only functions of @xmath280 are operand . then @xmath411 if and only if the canonical partition induced by @xmath280 is equal to the canonical partition induced by @xmath412 , that is @xmath413 . the following two properties , that are consequences of def . [ partizione_accettabile ] , will be useful to prove the main result of the paper . [ f_1 ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances and let @xmath385 be a valid partition . then the image of every instance @xmath414 is the union of sets of @xmath385 . we prove the lemma by induction on the number @xmath59 of operations of the expression for @xmath415 . if @xmath416 , then @xmath415 is a function in @xmath417 . since all sets of a valid partition are @xmath418-stable , no set of a valid partition has both an element in @xmath419 and an element not in @xmath419 , therefore the union of all sets of @xmath385 that are contained in @xmath419 is contained in @xmath419 . to prove that such containment is not strict ( i.e. such union is equal to @xmath419 ) it is sufficient to note that all elements of @xmath419 belong to some set of @xmath385 . assume now that @xmath420 and @xmath415 is obtained by the application of an operation to two expressions @xmath421 and @xmath422 in @xmath410 , or one expression for a selection . clearly , by inductive hypothesis the images of @xmath421 and @xmath422 are obtained as the union of some sets of @xmath385 . it is immediate to verify the lemma for the case that @xmath423 , @xmath424 , @xmath425 and @xmath426 . finally , assume that @xmath427 , where @xmath321 is a selector . by definition of the selection , then @xmath419 is the union of the images of all simple instances induced by @xmath321 . assume to the contrary that there exists a set @xmath241 of the valid partition such that @xmath428 and @xmath429 . now , let @xmath430 and @xmath431 . hence , by construction of selection , @xmath289 can not be in the image of any simple instance induced by @xmath321 , while @xmath148 is contained in the image of a simple instance induced by @xmath321 . by inductive hypothesis @xmath432 is union of sets of @xmath385 , moreover since @xmath241 is a set of @xmath385 , also @xmath433 is union of sets of the valid partition , implying that @xmath434 , it follows that , for each @xmath435 , @xmath436 for some @xmath437 . this implies that there is a simple instance induced by @xmath321 that has in its image @xmath289 , which is a contradiction with the above assumption . consequently , the image of @xmath415 must be union of sets of @xmath385 . we will prove that an alternative characterization of canonical partition is as the partition induced by the equivalence relation @xmath438 between elements of @xmath439 , where @xmath440 if and only if for every instance @xmath441 , @xmath442 . in the following of the paper let @xmath443 denote the partition induced by the equivalence relation @xmath438 . successively we will prove that a function @xmath322 belongs to @xmath410 if and only if @xmath275 can be obtained as union of sets of @xmath443 , completing the proof of our main result , in two steps . first we will prove that a function @xmath266 belongs to @xmath444 if and only if @xmath445 is union of sets in @xmath443 , then we will prove that @xmath446 . the following proposition is an immediate consequence of the definitions of @xmath440 and of projection . [ unique1 ] let @xmath447 such that @xmath440 . then both @xmath148 and @xmath289 belong to the set @xmath448 for some name @xmath449 . [ unique ] let @xmath450 be the partition induced by a set @xmath280 of instances . then , the inverse image of every set of the partition consists of a single vertex . [ minimo_ottenibile ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances over @xmath261 , let @xmath443 be the partition induced by @xmath282 , and let @xmath451 . then there exists an instance @xmath441 such that @xmath452 . let @xmath453 be the set of functions @xmath454 such that @xmath455 . by cor . [ unique ] all functions in @xmath453 have the same domain , therefore the expression @xmath456 is well - formed ; by construction @xmath457 . by definition of @xmath443 all functions @xmath458 are such that @xmath459 or @xmath460 , therefore all functions @xmath458 whose image intersect @xmath241 are such that @xmath455 , which in turn implies that are also in @xmath453 . hence @xmath461 , for otherwise there would be an element of @xmath241 not belonging to the image of any function in @xmath326 . [ uni2 ] let @xmath326 be a set of instances over @xmath261 , let @xmath450 be the partition induced by @xmath282 and let @xmath241 be a union of sets in @xmath443 , such that the inverse image of @xmath241 induces a weakly - connected subgraph of the schema , then @xmath241 is the image of an instance @xmath441 . let @xmath462 be the sets of @xmath443 whose union is @xmath241 , and notice that , by lemma [ minimo_ottenibile ] , it is possible to associate to each set @xmath463 the instance @xmath464 whose image is @xmath463 , moreover for each such @xmath465 , @xmath466 . for each vertex @xmath148 in the inverse image of @xmath241 we can construct the function @xmath467 as @xmath468 . then let @xmath469 ; it is immediate to note that @xmath461 . an immediate consequence of lemmata [ f_1 ] and [ uni2 ] is the following : [ canonical = obtainable ] let @xmath326 be a set of instances over @xmath261 and let @xmath333 . then @xmath470 if and only if @xmath445 is union of sets in @xmath443 and the inverse image of @xmath445 induces a weakly - connected subgraph of the schema . with lemma [ uni2 ] we have proved that all interesting unions of sets of the partition @xmath450 can be obtained with an expression of the graph algebra where all operands are taken from @xmath280 , therefore @xmath450 conveys all expressibility information . but @xmath450 is defined on the set @xmath410 , we still need to correlate the definition of canonical partition with that of @xmath450 . [ pbi_accettabile ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances . then @xmath450 is a valid partition of @xmath280 . let @xmath371 be two disjoint sets where @xmath471 and @xmath261 is union of sets in @xmath443 , we will prove that @xmath372 . first of all we will show that @xmath241 is 0-stable . remember that , by definition of @xmath443 , for each @xmath470 either @xmath472 or @xmath473 . since @xmath474 contains @xmath326 , it is immediate to not that @xmath241 is 0-stable . in the following let @xmath10 be the single - vertex inverse image of @xmath241 . if the inverse image of @xmath475 does not induce a weakly - connected subgraph of the instance , then 0-stability of @xmath241 suffices to prove that @xmath372 , therefore assume that the inverse image of @xmath475 induces a weakly - connected subgraph of the instance . let us assume that @xmath372 does not hold , then we will get a contradiction . without loss of generality we can assume that @xmath261 is a minimum set for which @xmath372 does not hold . the new assumption implies that @xmath25-stability does not hold for some @xmath25 . it follows that there are two elements @xmath476 and an element @xmath477 such that @xmath478 is not contained in @xmath479 , for every @xmath480 . now , by lemma [ uni2 ] , there is an instance @xmath414 such that @xmath481 . let @xmath482 and @xmath483 and let @xmath480 such that @xmath484 . let us consider the function @xmath485 . by construction @xmath148 belongs to @xmath486 , but @xmath289 does not ; since @xmath487 we have found a function in @xmath474 containing @xmath148 but not @xmath289 , contradicting the assumption that @xmath488 . [ pd = pbi ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances . then @xmath489 . by lemma [ pbi_accettabile ] , @xmath490 must be a valid partition of @xmath280 . by lemma [ minimo_ottenibile ] , every set @xmath491 is obtained as the image of some instance @xmath441 . clearly , since @xmath441 , by lemma [ f_1 ] the image @xmath241 of @xmath322 is the union of sets of the canonical partition of @xmath280 . hence @xmath492 . [ uguale1 ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances . then an instance @xmath415 belongs to @xmath474 if and only if @xmath493 . clearly by lemma [ pd = pbi ] it suffices to show that @xmath414 if and only if @xmath494 , moreover it is immediate to note that , by construction of @xmath443 , if @xmath414 then @xmath494 . assume now that @xmath494 . by lemma [ pbi_accettabile ] , @xmath495 must be a valid partition . by lemma [ f_1 ] , and exploiting the assumption that @xmath496 , for each @xmath497 , @xmath498 must be the union of some sets in @xmath499 , that is @xmath500 , for some sets @xmath501 . but by lemma [ minimo_ottenibile ] , for each set @xmath502 there is an instance @xmath503 such that @xmath502 is the image of @xmath504 . consequently , @xmath505 , and hence @xmath506 , which proves that @xmath414 as required . theorem [ uguale1 ] and lemma [ pd = pbi ] lead to our main result . [ cor : uguale1 ] let @xmath280 be a set of instances . then an instance @xmath415 belongs to @xmath474 if and only if @xmath507 . we have introduced the idea that partitions of the domain set can be used for characterizing the set of relations or graphs that can be extracted in a data base in the relational or in a graph - based model . by formally proving those expressiveness results we have effectively given a new framework for the analysis of data base query languages . s. abiteboul , c. beeri , m. gyssens , and d. van gucht . an introduction to the completeness of languages for complex objects and nested relations . in _ nested relations and complex objects _ , volume 361 of _ lncs _ , pages 117138 , 1989 . m. andries and j. paredaens . a language for generic graph transformations . in _ graph - theoretic conecpts in computer science , 17th international workshop , wg91 _ , volume 570 of _ lncs _ , pages 170183 , berlin , 1991 . springer - verlag . f. bancilhon . on the completeness of query languages for relational data bases . in _ proceedings , 7th symp . on mathematical foundations of computer science _ , volume 64 of _ lncs _ , pages 112123 , berlin , 1978 . springer - verlag . j. van den bussche , d. van gucht , m. andries , and m. gyssens . on the completeness of object - creating query languages . in _ 33rd annual symposium on foundations of computer science . proceedings _ , pages 372379 , 1992 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: there are many astrophysical systems on which the physics of neutrinos in a magnetic field plays an important role . let us recall that proto - neutron stars typically possess very strong magnetic fields . large magnetic fields @xmath3 g have been associated with the surface of supernovas @xcite and neutron stars @xcite , and fields perhaps as large as @xmath4 g with magnetars @xcite . even larger fields could exist in the star s interior . it is presumed from the scalar virial theorem @xcite that the interior field in neutron stars could be as high as @xmath5 g. a magnetic field as this ( @xmath6 g ) in the interior of a compact star will be larger in two orders than the chemical potential characterizing its quark matter density . unveiling the interconnection between the star magnetic field and its particle current flows could shed new light to the question of the star evolution . for example , it is well known that neutrinos drive supernova dynamics from beginning to end . neutrino emission and interactions play a crucial role in core collapse supernovae @xcite . their eventual emission from the proto - neutron star contains nearly all the energy released in the star explosion . neutrino luminosity , emissivity and the specific heat of the densest parts of the star are governed by charged and neutral current interactions involving matter at high densities and in the presence of strong magnetic fields . thus , a total understanding of the star cooling mechanism in a strongly magnetized medium is crucial for astrophysics . on the other hand , the explanation of large - scale magnetic fields observed in a number of galaxies , and in clusters of galaxies @xcite seems to require the existence of seed fields of primordial origin @xcite . according to several mechanisms @xcite , strong primordial fields @xmath7 g could be generated at the electroweak transition . even larger fields have been associated with superconducting magnetic strings , which would generate fields @xmath8 g in their vicinity if created after inflation @xcite . were primordial magnetic fields present in the early universe , they would have had non - trivial consequences for particle - physics cosmology . for instance , as it is well known , oscillations between neutrino flavors may change the relative abundance of neutrino species and may thereby affect primordial nucleosynthesis ( for a recent review on neutrinos in cosmology see @xcite ) . therefore , if a strong magnetic field ( @xmath9 , with @xmath10 and @xmath11 the w - boson and electron masses respectively ) modifies the neutrino energy spectrum of different flavors in different ways , a primordial magnetic field can consequently influence the oscillation process in the primeval plasma @xcite . the propagation of neutrinos in magnetized media has been previously investigated by several authors @xcite-@xcite . weak - field calculations were done for magnetized vacuum in refs . @xcite , @xcite , and at @xmath12 and @xmath13 ( @xmath14 is the electric chemical potential ) in refs . @xcite . in the @xmath13 case , as long as @xmath15 , both the field- and temperature - dependent leading contributions to the neutrino energy resulted of @xmath16-order @xcite-@xcite . in the charged plasma @xcite , the field - dependent terms were much larger , @xmath17 , but they vanished in the ( @xmath18)-limit . the weak - field results of papers @xcite-@xcite led to think that the magnetic - field effects could be significant in astrophysics , because of the field- and @xmath19-dependent terms of order @xmath20 , but were irrelevant ( @xmath21-order ) in the early universe due to its charge - symmetric character ( @xmath22 ) . hence , it has been assumed that in cosmology the main contribution to neutrino energy was the purely thermal term of order @xmath23 @xcite . however , as we will show below , a strong magnetic field ( @xmath24 ) gives rise to a new contribution to the neutrino energy that is linear in the field , independent of the chemical potential , and that is of the same order ( @xmath20 ) as the largest terms found in the weak - field charged - medium case . this new result can turn magnetic - field effects relevant for cosmology . in recent papers @xcite , @xcite , we investigated the effects of a strong magnetic field on neutrinos in magnetized vacuum ( i.e. with @xmath25 and @xmath13 ) . there , to facilitate the calculations in the strong - field limit , we extended the ritus ep - eigenfunction method of diagonalization of the green functions of spin-1/2 charged particle in electromagnetic field @xcite-@xcite , to the case of spin-1 charged particles @xcite . this formulation , which is particularly advantageous for strong - field calculations , provides an alternative method to the schwinger approach to address qft problems in electromagnetic backgrounds @xcite . the use of the ritus method resulted very convenient to study the neutrino - self - energy in magnetized media , since it allowed to diagonalize in momentum space both the electron and the w - boson green s functions in the presence of a magnetic field . ritus formalism has also been recently applied to investigate non - perturbative qft in electromagnetic backgrounds @xcite . from the above considerations it is clear that strong magnetic fields can play a significant role in a variety of astrophysical systems , and possibly also in the early universe . for these applications , the analysis has to be carried out in the presence of a medium . thus , in the present paper we extend the results obtained in papers @xcite and @xcite to include finite temperature and density , performing a detailed study of the effects of a strong magnetic field on neutrino propagation in neutral and charged media , and discussing possible applications to astrophysics and cosmology . we stress that in calculating the neutrino self - energy in a magnetized medium , we should consider , as usual , its vacuum and statistical parts . in this case the vacuum part depends on the magnetic field , and for strong fields it can make important contributions even at high temperatures @xmath26 . the reason is that the vacuum and statistical terms have different analytical behaviors , due to the lack of the statistic ultraviolet cutoff in the vacuum part . this fact gives rise to a field - dependent vacuum contribution ( @xmath20-order ) which is larger than the thermal one ( @xmath16-order ) , into the self - energy . therefore , as shown in this paper , a strong magnetic field can become more relevant than temperature for neutrino propagation in neutral media . the plan of the paper is as follows . in sec . [ selfen - gen - struc ] we consider the radiative correction to the neutrino dispersion relation in the presence of a constant magnetic field . we introduce the general covariant structure of the neutrino self - energy in the presence of an external field , and find the dispersion relation as a function of the coefficients of each independent term in the covariant structure . the general form of the found dispersion relation goes beyond any given approximation and medium characteristic and serves as a guidance for particular applications . the general expressions for the coefficients of the self - energy structures in the presence of the magnetic field are found in the one - loop approximation in sec . [ 1-loop - selfen ] . the leading behavior in the @xmath20 expansion of those coefficients are then calculated in sec . [ strong - b - selfen ] in the strong - field limit ( i.e. in the lowest landau level ( lll ) approximation ) for neutral and charged magnetized media . these results are then used in sec . [ index - ref ] to find the corresponding neutrino dispersion relations and the indexes of refraction in neutral and charged strongly magnetized media . in sec . [ numerical ] , the lll - approximation is numerically corroborated by summing in all landau levels and finding the values of the coefficients for parameter ranges corresponding to strong @xmath27 and weakly strong @xmath2 fields . possible applications to cosmology and astrophysics are discussed in sec . [ applicat ] . finally , in sec . [ conclusions ] we summarize the main outcomes of the paper and make some final remarks . the neutrino field equation of motion in a magnetized medium , including radiative corrections , is @xmath28\psi _ { l}=0 \label{1}\ ] ] where the neutrino self - energy operator @xmath29 depends on the parameters characterizing the medium , as for instance , temperature , magnetic field , particle density , etc . the operator @xmath29 is a lorentz scalar that can be formed in the spinorial space taking the contractions between the characteristic vectors and tensors of the system with all the independent elements of the dirac ring . explicit chirality reduces it to @xmath30 where @xmath31 are the chiral projector operators , and @xmath32 is a lorentz vector that can be spanned as a superposition of four basic vectors that can be formed from the characteristic tensors of the problem . in a magnetized medium , besides the neutrino four - momentum @xmath33 , we have to consider the magnetic - field strength tensor @xmath34 , to form the covariant structures @xmath35 in ( [ 3 ] ) we introduced the notations @xmath36 , and @xmath37 @xmath38 . in the covariant representation the magnetic field can be expressed as @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the vector four - velocity of the center of mass of the magnetized medium . the presence of the magnetic field , and hence of the dimensionless magnetic field tensor @xmath41 and its dual @xmath42 , allows the covariant separation in ( [ 3 ] ) between longitudinal and transverse momentum terms that appears naturally in magnetic backgrounds @xmath43 coefficients @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 are lorentz scalars that depend on the parameters of the theory and the approximation used . notice that finite temperature and/or density would not introduce any new term into eq . ( [ 3 ] ) . this formulation is indeed the most general one for a magnetized medium . in magnetized space , even if @xmath48 , the vector @xmath40 is present , since the presence of a constant magnetic field fixes a special lorentz frame : the rest frame ( on which @xmath49 ) where the magnetic field is defined ( @xmath50 . thus , the inclusion of a medium does not break any additional symmetry . to express @xmath51 in terms of @xmath40 only means , therefore , to make a change in the selected basis vectors when expressing @xmath51 in terms of @xmath40 in the charged medium . ] . the neutrino energy spectrum in a magnetic background can be found from eq . ( [ 1 ] ) as the nontrivial solution of @xmath52 = 0 . \label{5}\ ] ] using the covariant structure ( [ 3 ] ) , the dispersion relation ( [ 5 ] ) takes the form @xmath53 one of the main goals of this paper is to find the coefficients @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 , in the one - loop approximation , and hence , the dispersion relations for different systems in the presence of strong magnetic - field backgrounds . let us consider the one - loop corrections to the neutrino self - energy in the presence of a constant magnetic field . to leading order in the fermi coupling constant the main field - dependent contribution to the self - energy comes from the bubble diagram ( fig.i - a ) with internal lines of virtual charged leptons and w - bosons , and from the tadpole diagram ( fig.i - b ) with virtual loop of charged leptons . in a neutral medium only the bubble diagram contributes , while in a charged medium both diagrams should be considered . however , only the bubble distinguishes between neutrino flavors , since the flavor of the internal charged lepton is directly associated to the flavor of the propagating neutrino ( i.e. the one appearing in the external legs ) . for the tadpole , because the internal boson is the neutral z - boson , the charged leptons corresponding to different families are linked to the same neutrino flavor . therefore , in regards to magnetic field effects on neutrino oscillations , the bubble contribution is the essential one . thus , because the ultimate goal of our study is to elucidate the possible effect of a strong magnetic field on neutrino flavor oscillations , henceforth we only consider the bubble diagram contribution , represented in fig.i - a , into the neutrino self - energy . the bubble contribution to the one - loop self - energy is @xmath54 where @xmath55 and @xmath56 are the green s functions of the electron and w - boson , in the presence of the magnetic field , respectively . since both virtual particles are electrically charged , the magnetic field interacts with both of them producing the landau quantization of the corresponding transverse momenta @xcite , @xcite . ( 450,80)(0,-10 ) ( 180,10)1.5 ( 120,10)1.5 ( 120,10)(180,10)(100,10)(120,10)5 ( 180,10)(200,10)5(300,50)131 ( 300,37)(300,10)35(300,37)1.5 ( 300,10)1.5 ( 280,10)(320,10)5 ( 150,0)[](@xmath44)(300,0)[](@xmath45 ) ( 150,10)(30,0,180)48.5 fig.i . one - loop contributions to the neutrino self - energy in a magnetized medium . ( a ) bubble graph - the dashed line represents the test neutrino , the solid line a charged lepton of the same family of the test neutrino , and the wiggly line the w - boson . ( b ) tadpole graph - the dashed line represents the test neutrino , the solid line a charged lepton of any species , and the zigzag line the z - boson . + the electron green s function , diagonal in momentum space at arbitrary field strength , was obtained in refs . @xcite , @xcite by ritus , using what has become an alternative method to the schwinger approach @xcite to deal with qft problems on electromagnetic backgrounds . in this method the electron green s function in configuration space is given by @xmath57 where @xmath58 , @xmath59 , and the magnetic field has been specialized in the rest frame along the @xmath60-direction ( i.e. given in the landau gauge as @xmath61 ) . the transformation functions @xmath62 in ( [ 8 ] ) play the role , in the presence of magnetic fields , of the usual fourier functions @xmath63 in the free case and are given by @xmath64 with spin matrix @xmath65 and eigenfunctions @xmath66 where @xmath67 is a normalization factor and @xmath68 denotes the parabolic cylinder functions @xcite with argument @xmath69 and positive integer index @xmath70 the integer @xmath71 in eq . ( [ 12 ] ) labels the landau levels @xmath72 . the electron momentum eigenvalue in the presence of the magnetic field , @xmath73 , is given by @xmath74 ritus technique for spin-1/2 particles was recently extended to the spin-1 particle case in refs . @xcite , @xcite . in this case the corresponding w - boson green s function can be diagonalized in momentum space as @xmath75 where @xmath76 , and the w - boson momentum eigenvalue in the presence of the magnetic field , @xmath77 , is given by the relation @xmath78 with @xmath79 denoting the w - boson landau levels . considering the mass - shell condition @xmath80 in eq . ( [ 15 ] ) , we can identify at @xmath81 the so called zero - mode problem " @xcite-@xcite . as known , at those values of the magnetic field a vacuum instability appears giving rise to w - condensation @xcite . in our calculations we restrict the magnitude of the magnetic field to @xmath82 , so to avoid the presence of any tachyonic mode . the w - boson green s function in configuration space is then @xmath83 where the transformation functions are @xmath84 ^{\gamma } \,_{\lambda } p^{-1\lambda } \,_{\mu } \label{17}\ ] ] with @xmath85 and @xmath86 ^{\gamma } \,_{\lambda } = \sum\limits_{\eta = 0,\pm 1}\mathcal{f}_{k\eta } ( x)\left [ \omega ^{(\eta ) } \right ] ^{\gamma } \,_{\lambda } \label{19}\ ] ] the matrices @xmath87 are explicitly given in terms of the w - boson spin projections @xmath88 by @xmath89 and the eigenfunctions @xmath90 are @xmath91 with @xmath92 a normalization factor similar to that appearing in ( [ 11 ] ) , and @xmath93 denoting the parabolic cylinder functions with argument @xmath94 and positive integer index @xmath95 given in terms of the w - boson landau numbers @xmath79 and spin projections @xmath88 as @xmath96 as the neutrino is an electrically neutral particle , the transformation to momentum space of its self - energy can be carried out by the usual fourier transform @xmath97 substituting with ( [ 7 ] ) , ( [ 8 ] ) and ( [ 16 ] ) in the rhs of ( [ 22 ] ) we obtain @xmath98 @xmath99 l\right\ } \label{23}\ ] ] the coefficients of the covariant expression for @xmath100 can be found using the explicit form ( [ 23 ] ) in the covariant expression @xmath101 introducing in ( [ 23 ] ) the transformation functions @xmath102 and @xmath103 , and taking into account the following properties of the spinor matrices @xmath104 @xmath105 @xmath106 where the notation @xmath107 and @xmath108 was used , we find for the coefficients appearing in ( [ 24-a ] ) the following general expressions in the one - loop approximation ( henceforth we consider @xmath109 , to simplify the notation . ) @xmath110 @xmath111 @xmath112 @xmath113 @xmath114 @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117 where @xmath118\varphi _ { n}(\xi /\sqrt{2})\varphi _ { l}(\rho /\sqrt{2 } ) \label{29}\ ] ] and @xmath119 are the orthonormalized harmonic oscillator wave functions , defined in terms of the hermite polynomials @xmath120 as @xmath121^{1/2}}h_{m}(x/\sqrt{2})\exp -(x^{2}/4 ) \label{30}\ ] ] expressions ( [ 25])-([28 ] ) , when substituted in ( [ 24-a ] ) , give the general formula for the one - loop neutrino self - energy in a constant magnetic field of arbitrary strength . note that , in this approach , the w - boson / magnetic - field interaction is kept in the poles of the self - energy operator through the effective momentum @xmath122 , as well as in the harmonic oscillator wave functions @xmath123 . since in the strong - field limit ( @xmath124 ) the gap between the electron landau levels is larger than the rest of the parameters entering in the electron energy , it is consistent to use the lll approximation in the electron green s function , while in the w - boson green s function , because @xmath125 we must sum in all w - boson landau levels . the neutrino self - energy in a magnetized vacuum was found within this approximation in ref . @xcite . in what follows , we extend that result to neutral and charged media , introducing finite temperature and density effects . however , since the vacuum contribution is always present in the statistical calculations of the self - energy , we summarize below the results found in ref . @xcite . in the strong field approximation ( @xmath126 ) the covariant structure of the neutrino self - energy reduces to @xmath127 that is , @xmath128 and @xmath129 are zero and @xmath130 @xmath131 after summing in @xmath79 and integrating in @xmath132 , @xmath133 , and @xmath134 we obtain @xmath135[(q_{\vert } -p_{\vert } ) ^{2}-eb+m_{w}^{2 } ] } \label{34}\ ] ] integrating in @xmath136 and considering that @xmath137 , we obtain for the neutrino self - energy in the strongly magnetized vacuum @xmath138 with coefficients given by @xmath139 notice the @xmath20-order of the leading contribution in the lll approximation . using the zero - temperature weak - field results of ref . @xcite we can identify the scalar coefficients of the general structure ( [ 3 ] ) for that case as @xmath140 if we compare the vacuum results at weak - field , eq . ( [ 36 ] ) , with those at strong field , eq . ( [ 35 ] ) , we can see that in both cases the non - zero coefficients have field - dependent leading contributions of @xmath20-order . however , as we will show in sec . [ index - ref ] , they will play very different roles in the neutrino energy spectrum , since they are associated to different self - energy structures . while the strong - field results ( [ 35 ] ) produce a magnetic - field dependence in the neutrino energy spectrum which is linear in the fermi coupling constant , the weak - field results ( [ 36 ] ) generate a smaller second - order contribution . in a neutral medium the self - energy operator can be written as @xmath141 where @xmath142 is the vacuum contribution ( given in the strong - field approximation by eqs . ( [ 34-a])-([35 ] ) ) , and @xmath143 is the statistical part which depends on temperature and magnetic field ( in a charged medium the statistical part can also depend , of course , on the chemical potential ) . our goal now is to find @xmath144 in the parameter range @xmath145 . here we can also assume that the electrons are confined to the lll . thus , performing the same calculations as in ( [ 32])-([34 ] ) we arrive to a self - energy operator @xmath146 with a structure identical to ( [ 31 ] ) , and coefficients given by an expression similar to ( [ 34 ] ) , but with the matsubara replacement , @xmath147 @xmath148 , corresponding to the discretization of the fourth component @xmath149 of the fermion momentum , obtained after introducing the wick rotation to euclidean space @xmath150 , @xmath151 being the inverse of the temperature @xmath152 . after summing in @xmath153 and extracting the vacuum part ( [ 34 ] ) , we obtain that the coefficients corresponding to the thermal contribution @xmath154 are given by @xmath155 @xmath156}f_{f}(\varepsilon _ { 1})+\frac{(q_{3}-ip_{4})(p_{4}^{2}-% \varepsilon _ { 2}^{2}+\varepsilon _ { 1}^{2})-2ip_{4}\varepsilon _ { 2}^{2}}{% \varepsilon _ { 2}[(p_{4}^{2}-\varepsilon _ { 2}^{2}+\varepsilon _ { 1}^{2})^{2}+4\varepsilon _ { 2}^{2}p_{4}^{2}]}f_{b}(\varepsilon _ { 2})\right\ } \label{40}\ ] ] where @xmath157 are the fermion and boson distribution functions respectively , with effective energies @xmath158 to do the integral in ( [ 40 ] ) we take into account the approximation @xmath159 . thus , to leading order we can neglect the contribution of the boson distribution , since it is damped by the exponential factor @xmath160 . integrating in momentum and expanding in powers of @xmath20 , we obtain , up to leading order , @xmath161 @xmath162 hence , the thermal contribution is one order smaller in powers of @xmath163 than the field - dependent vacuum contribution ( [ 35 ] ) . notice that in the strong - field approximation the thermal contribution ( [ 44 ] ) has the same @xmath16-order as the corresponding thermal contributions at weak @xcite and zero @xcite field . we should call attention to the fact that when calculating the thermal contribution to the e - w bubble by using the schwinger proper - time method @xcite , some authors @xcite have considered the following expansion @xmath164 within the w - boson green function in the presence of a constant magnetic field @xmath165 where @xmath166 is the well - known phase factor depending on the applied field @xcite , and @xmath167 is the energy - momentum transfer . based on this expansion , it has been argued that the non - local lower contribution to the bubble diagram should be of order @xmath16 , and that the local ( @xmath20)-order term only contributes at finite density . while this argument is correct when applied to the statistical part of the self - energy operator ( it explains the @xmath16 order appearing in the thermal coefficients @xmath168 and @xmath169 in ( [ 44 ] ) ) , it is not valid for the self - energy vacuum contribution . for the vacuum ( @xmath170 @xmath13 ) contribution the situation is different , since we can not neglect the internal momenta as compared with @xmath171 in the poles of the w - boson green s function , due to the lack of the ultraviolet cutoff which is present in statistics . thus , when calculating the vacuum part , the first term in ( [ 47 ] ) should be replaced by @xmath172 . such momentum dependence in the pole of the w - boson green s function makes a nontrivial contribution of ( @xmath20)-order into the non - local part of the bubble diagram . observe that the w - boson green s function obtained in our approach , eq . ( [ 14 ] ) , only has such structure indeed , and that the vacuum results at strong ( [ 35 ] ) and weak ( [ 36 ] ) fields give rise to non - local ( @xmath20)-order contributions to neutrino self - energy . we consider now a medium with a finite density of electric charge . as usual , a finite density is reflected through the shift @xmath173 in the momenta of the particles with non - zero charge associated to @xmath14 . the chemical potential , depending on the value of the charge density , plays the role of an external parameter . in stellar medium , for example , the electric charge is fixed by the net charge of the baryons , which , due to their large masses , are usually treated as a classical background . here the following comment is in order , in electroweak matter at finite density there exists the possibility to induce additional `` chemical potentials '' @xcite . these chemical potentials are nothing but dynamically generated background fields given by the average @xmath174 and @xmath175 of the zero components of the gauge fields . they are known to appear , for instance , in the presence of finite lepton / baryon density @xcite ( for recent applications related to this effect see refs . @xcite ) . in our case , a possible consequence of the condensation of such average fields could be the modification of the effective chemical potential of the w - boson , which then might be different from the electron chemical potential . nevertheless , that modification , even if present in the case under study , will have not any relevant consequence , as the w - boson contribution will be always suppressed by the factor @xmath176 . in the strong - field approximation ( i.e. after considering the lll approximation in the neutrino self - energy ( [ 24-a])-([28 ] ) ) the non - zero coefficients of the neutrino self - energy in the charged medium are given in euclidean space by @xmath177[(q_{4}^{*}-p_{4})^{2}+\varepsilon _ { 2}^{2 } ] } , \label{50}\ ] ] this expression is similar to eq . ( [ 34 ] ) after taking into account the matsubara replacement @xmath178 @xmath179 , with the additional change @xmath180 , where @xmath181 . after carrying out the temperature sum in ( [ 50 ] ) , and subtracting the vacuum part ( [ 34 ] ) , we arrive to @xmath182 @xmath183}f_{f}^{-}(\varepsilon _ { 1})+\frac{% ( q_{3}-\varepsilon _ { 1})}{\varepsilon _ { 1}[(i\varepsilon _ { 1}+p_{4})^{2}+\varepsilon _ { 2}^{2}]}f_{f}^{+}(\varepsilon _ { 1})\ ] ] @xmath184}f_{b}^{-}(\varepsilon _ { 2})+\frac{% ( q_{3}-\varepsilon _ { 2}-ip_{4})}{\varepsilon _ { 2}[(i\varepsilon _ { 2}-p_{4})^{2}+\varepsilon _ { 1}^{2}]}f_{b}^{+}(\varepsilon _ { 2})\ } \label{52}\ ] ] where @xmath185 are the fermion / anti - fermion and boson / anti - boson distributions respectively . here , we obtain an equal energy split for both distributions since both charged particles have the same electric charge and thus are characterized by the same chemical potential . assuming the approximation @xmath186 , eq . ( [ 52 ] ) is reduced in leading order to @xmath187e^{-p_{\bot } ^{2}/2eb}\delta ^{(4)}(p - p^{\prime } ) \label{54}\ ] ] where the notation @xmath188 for the electron / positron number densities in the lll @xmath189 was introduced . it is interesting to consider the situation where @xmath190 , which is a natural condition in many astrophysical environments . in this case ( [ 54 ] ) becomes @xmath191 after analytic continuation to minkowski space , we find that the leading contribution to the statistical part of the self - energy in a strongly magnetized charged medium is @xmath192 @xmath193 the apparent dependence on the momentum components @xmath194 , @xmath195 of the coefficients @xmath196 , @xmath197 is deceiving , as we can easily rewrite eqs . ( [ 57])-([58 ] ) in a more convenient way using the base formed by the four - velocity @xmath40 and the covariant magnetic field vector @xmath198 , as @xmath199 @xmath200 @xmath201from ( [ 59])-([60 ] ) we see that the leading term in the statistical part of the self - energy in the charged medium in strong magnetic field is independent of the momentum and proportional to @xmath20 , thus of larger order than the statistical contribution of the neutral case ( eq . ( [ 44 ] ) ) . comparing our result ( [ 59])-([60 ] ) with those found at weak field @xcite , we see that the coefficient of the structure @xmath202 has similar qualitative characteristics . that is , both @xmath46 coefficients are linear in @xmath14 and have the same order , @xmath20 . nevertheless , the coefficients of the structure @xmath203 significantly differ in the strong and weak cases . in the weak - field limit @xmath204 only depends on the density , thus its leading contribution is proportional to @xmath205 ( this is the characteristic term of the msw effect @xcite ) . however , for fields larger than @xmath14 , the relation @xmath206 holds , and the leading becomes proportional to @xmath207 , as in eq . ( [ 60 ] ) . thus , in the strong field case it is the field the parameter that drives the main dependence of both structures in @xmath208 . the neutrino index of refraction , defined by @xmath209 where @xmath210 and @xmath211 are the neutrino momentum and energy respectively , is a quantity that plays a significant role in neutrino flavor oscillations in a medium @xcite . a flavor - dependent index of refraction would enhance the periodical change between different flavors of neutrinos travelling through the medium . to find the index of refraction we need to know the dispersion relation @xmath212 . in the presence of a medium the energy spectra of the massless left - handed neutrinos are modified due to their weak interaction with the particles of the background . in a magnetized medium , even though the neutrinos are electrically neutral , they feel the magnetic field indirectly through their interaction with the charged particles of the medium whose properties are affected by the field . as discussed in sec.[selfen - gen - struc ] , in a magnetized medium the general form of the neutrino dispersion relation is given by eq . ( [ 5 ] ) , with the self - energy depending on the medium characteristics . as follows , we present the neutrino energy spectrum and index of refraction for magnetized neutral and charged media . in the strongly magnetized neutral medium the dispersion relation is obtained from @xmath213 = 0 , \label{62}\ ] ] with @xmath214 and @xmath215 explicitly given in eqs . ( [ 34-a])-([35 ] ) and ( [ 43])-([44 ] ) respectively . the solution of ( [ 62 ] ) in leading order in the fermi coupling constant is @xmath216 \label{63}\ ] ] in ( [ 63])@xmath217 is the angle between the direction of the neutrino momentum and that of the applied magnetic field , and the coefficient @xmath218 is explicitly given by @xmath219\exp ( -p_{\perp } ^{2}/eb ) , \label{64}\ ] ] @xmath201from ( [ 64 ] ) it is clear that in the strong - field limit the thermal correction @xmath168 to the neutrino energy is much smaller than the vacuum correction @xmath220 . as we will discuss in sec.[conclusions ] , this result can be significant for cosmological applications in case that a strong primordial magnetic field could exist in the primeval plasma . the neutrino ( @xmath221)/anti - neutrino ( @xmath222 ) energies are given by @xmath223 respectively . substituting eq . ( [ 63 ] ) into ( [ 61 ] ) we obtain for the neutrino ( antineutrino ) index of refraction in a neutral medium @xmath224 @xmath201eq . ( [ 65 ] ) implies that the index of refraction depends on the neutrino direction of motion . the order of the anisotropy is @xmath225 . maximum field effects take place for neutrinos propagating perpendicularly to the magnetic field . that is , the maximum departure of the neutrino phase velocity from the light velocity @xmath46 , occurs at @xmath226 . notice that in the neutral magnetized medium the magnetic field effect does not differentiate between neutrinos and antineutrinos . here the following comment is in order . if we consider the weak - field results ( [ 36 ] ) obtained in ref . @xcite for the neutrino self - energy , in the dispersion relation ( [ 6 ] ) we obtain @xmath227 \label{66}\ ] ] in ( [ 66 ] ) , as the energy depends on @xmath228 , we can see that the weak field produces a negligible second order correction in term of the fermi coupling constant expansion ( i.e. a @xmath16-order effect ) . it can be corroborated that the inclusion of temperature in this approximation also produces a second order correction @xcite . thus , we conclude that the strong field produces an effect qualitatively larger , which is even more important than the thermal one . we call reader s attention to the fact that the field - dependent vacuum contribution to the neutrino energy ( [ 63 ] ) has the same order in the fermi coupling constant as the ones found in a charged medium at zero @xcite and weak @xcite fields . now we consider the effect of a strong magnetic field in neutrino propagation in a charged medium . in this case the dispersion relation is @xmath229 = 0 , \label{67}\ ] ] with @xmath214 and @xmath230 given in eqs . ( [ 34-a])-([35 ] ) and ( [ 59])-([60 ] ) respectively . the solution of ( [ 67 ] ) is @xmath231p_{3}}{1 - 2a_{0}}% } . \label{67-a}\ ] ] in leading order in the fermi coupling constant , expression ( [ 67-a ] ) is approximated by @xmath232-\mathbf{\mathcal{m}.b}\pm \mathnormal{e_{0 } } \label{68}\ ] ] where @xmath233 and @xmath234 \label{70}\ ] ] in the rhs of eq . ( [ 68 ] ) , the first term is the modified neutrino kinetic energy , with the field - dependent radiative correction already found in the neutral case ( see eq . ( [ 63 ] ) ) ; the second term can be interpreted as a magnetic - moment / magnetic - field interaction energy , with @xmath235 playing the role of a neutrino effective magnetic moment ; and the third term is a rest energy induced by the magnetized charged medium . we underline that , contrary to the case of the neutrino anomalous magnetic moment found beyond the standard model by including right - chiral neutrinos @xcite , the induced magnetic moment here obtained does not require a massive neutrino . we remind that we are only considering left - chiral dirac neutrinos , so the magnetic moment in ( [ 68 ] ) can not be associated with the anomalous magnetic moment structural term @xmath236 in the self - energy . this structure is forbidden in the present case by the explicit chirality of the standard model . in the case under study we have that although the neutrino is a neutral massless particle , the charged medium can endow it , through quantum corrections , with a magnetic moment proportional to the induced neutrino rest energy . thus , we are in the presence of a peculiar magnetic moment created thanks to the particle - antiparticle unbalance of the charged medium . such a charge asymmetry permits the formation of a net virtual current that , due to the magnetic field , circulates in a plane perpendicular to the neutrino propagation and therefore produces an effective magnetic moment in the direction of the neutrino momentum . in a charged medium cp - symmetry is violated @xcite , and a common property of electroweak media with cp violation is a separation between neutrino and anti - neutrino energies . in the present case this property is manifested in the double sign of @xmath237 in ( [ 68 ] ) . although this difference depends on the magnetic field entering in @xmath238 , we stress that it depends on the magnitude of the magnetic field but not on its direction . thus , the energy anisotropy connected to the first two terms of ( [ 68 ] ) is the same for neutrinos and anti - neutrinos . the neutrino / antineutrino energy in the charged medium in the presence of a weak field has been found @xcite to be @xmath239 with @xmath240 where @xmath241 are the electron / positron number densities , and @xmath242 the electron / positron distributions . comparing the strong - field ( [ 68 ] ) and the weak - field ( [ 71 ] ) dispersion relations , we see that the field - dependent correction to the kinetic energy appearing in the strong - field approximation is absent in the leading order of the weak - field case . for a strong - field , that correction turns out to be important for neutrinos propagating perpendicular to the magnetic field . another difference between ( [ 68 ] ) and ( [ 71 ] ) , is that in the last dispersion relation the rest energy @xmath243 does not depend on the magnetic field . this is the pure medium contribution that gives rise to the well known msw effect @xcite . as discussed above , in the strong - field case , where all parameters , including @xmath14 and @xmath244 are assumed smaller than @xmath245 , such a term is negligible compared to the contribution @xmath237 which is proportional to the field . in both approximations there is an additional anisotropy related to the induced magnetic moment term , which is linear in the magnetic field and depends on the unbalance between particles and anti - particles . we should notice that this anisotropic term changes its sign when the neutrino reverses its motion . this property is crucial for a possible explanation of the peculiar high pulsar velocities @xcite . nevertheless , for the anisotropic term that modifies the kinetic energy in the strong - field approximation , the neutrino energy - momentum relation is invariant under the change of @xmath246 by @xmath247 . substituting ( [ 68 ] ) into ( [ 61 ] ) we obtain that the neutrino / anti - neutrino index of refraction in the charged medium is given by @xmath248 the result ( [ 73 ] ) implies that the index of refraction depends on the neutrino direction of motion relative to the magnetic field . moreover , neutrinos and antineutrinos have different index of refractions and therefore different phase velocities even if they move in the same direction . for neutrinos , if @xmath249 ( i.e. if there is a larger number of electrons than positrons ) the index of refraction for @xmath250 is smaller than one , so their phase velocities will be smaller than light velocity . thus , in the charged medium with strong magnetic field , neutrinos behave as massive particles . this is in agreement with the behavior they have in a dense medium , even in the absence of magnetic field @xcite . on the other hand , for anti - neutrinos the index of refraction ( the one with the positive sign in front of @xmath237 in ( [ 73 ] ) ) can be larger than one . for instance , for anti - neutrinos moving opposite to the field - line directions the index of refraction is @xmath251 thus , antineutrinos will have phase velocities larger than @xmath46 and depending on the magnetic field strength and electron density . in this regard we should mention that particles with zero rest mass can even have group velocities that exceed @xmath46 in anomalously dispersive media @xcite . moreover , in non - trivial backgrounds , particles with superluminal propagations are not intrinsically forbidden in quantum field theories . for instance , superluminal photons appears in curved spaces @xcite , casimir vacua @xcite and in qed with compactified spatial dimensions @xcite . discussions about the non - violation of microcausality by the existence of such superluminal velocities , as well as the lack of a contradiction between such a phenomenon with the bases of special theory of relativity , can be found in refs . there , it was noted that the `` front velocity , '' the one related to the index of refraction in the infinite frequency limit , is the one that can not exceed @xmath252 since it is related to the signal transmission . in the calculation of the neutrino self - energy in the strong - field limit ( @xmath253 ) done in sec . [ strong - b - selfen ] , we assumed that the main contribution to the self - energy loop diagram came from electrons in the lll , since in the strong - field limit the energy gap between electron landau levels is much larger than the electron average energy in the medium . in this section we will check the validity of these arguments with the help of numerical calculations . taking into account that the relevant physical quantity in this study is the neutrino energy , we can concentrate our analysis on the self - energy coefficients that give the largest contribution to the dispersion relation . it is easy to check , from the analytical structure of eqs . ( [ 25])-([28 ] ) , that the leading term in the expansion of the coefficients in powers of @xmath20 can be at most of order @xmath20 . keeping in mind that the only coefficients that could contribute with a @xmath20-order term in the dispersion relation ( [ 6 ] ) are @xmath44 and @xmath45 ( coefficients @xmath46 and @xmath254 appear squared in ( [ 6 ] ) and their contribution to the dispersion relation should start at least with terms of order @xmath16 ) , we can approximate the dispersion relation ( [ 6 ] ) by @xmath255 then , to validate the lll approximation we should numerically study the ratio @xmath256 where @xmath44 and @xmath45 are respectively obtained from eqs . ( [ 25 ] ) and ( [ 26 ] ) , summing in all the landau levels and taking parameter values in the strong - field region @xmath257 @xmath258 @xmath259 . the coefficients @xmath220 and @xmath260 are the corresponding values at @xmath25 in the lll . in the denominator of ( [ 74-a ] ) we are neglecting the thermal contributions @xmath168 and @xmath261 since they would make an insignificant contribution ( @xmath20-order smaller ) as compared with the vacuum ones in the parameter range @xmath262 . in sec . [ strong - b - selfen ] , we showed that @xmath263 , and that @xmath220 is given by eq . ( [ 35 ] ) . the strong - field conditions can be naturally found in many astrophysical systems like magnetars , neutron stars , etc . in cosmological applications , however , the viable primordial fields can never be much larger than the temperature , as according to the equipartition principle , the magnetic energy can only be a small fraction of the universe energy density . this argument leads to the relation @xmath264 . clearly , this is not a situation very consistent with a strong - field approximation . however , even under this condition , it is natural to expect that the thermal energy should be barely enough to induce the occupation of just a few of the lower electron landau levels , and one would not be surprised if the lll approximation still gives the leading contribution to the dispersion relation . to investigate ( [ 74-b ] ) it will be more convenient to independently study the variation range for each coefficient ratio , @xmath265 where @xmath266 ( @xmath267 ) and @xmath268 ( @xmath269 ) are respectively the vacuum and thermal contributions of each coefficient @xmath44 ( @xmath45 ) . here we subtract the ultraviolet divergent zero - field , zero - temperature parts @xmath270 @xmath271 as they can only contribute , after renormalization , with negligible zero - field terms . the validity of the lll approximation should imply that @xmath272 and @xmath273 for the range of parameters considered . in the first part of this section we examine the validity of the lll in the zero - temperature case obtaining @xmath274 , @xmath275 . in the second part , we do a similar analysis , for the thermal part of @xmath44 , finding that @xmath276 , as expected from the theoretical considerations given in sec . [ strong - b - selfen ] ( see the discussion below eq . ( [ 46 ] ) ) . as this last numerical calculation is performed for magnetic fields that can even be a few orders smaller than @xmath277 the result @xmath278 confirms the appropriateness of the lll - approximation for a rather wide range of primordial fields . the analysis of the finite temperature part of coefficient @xmath45 ( @xmath279 ) is not explicitly done in the paper , however , it is not hard to see that it gives rise to a similar result , that is , @xmath280 . if we introduce in expressions ( [ 25 ] ) and ( [ 26 ] ) the integral representations @xmath281 @xmath282 and take into account the recurrence relation @xcite @xmath283 in ( [ 26 ] ) , it is possible to rewrite coefficients @xmath243 and @xmath284 as @xmath285 @xmath286s_{\alpha } s_{\beta } \ } \label{75}\ ] ] @xmath287 @xmath288rts_{\alpha } s_{\beta } \ } \label{76}\ ] ] here , @xmath289 and @xmath290 are found doing the sum in landau levels with the help of mehler s formula @xcite @xmath291^{-1/2}\exp -(\frac{\rho ^{2}-\rho ^{\prime 2}}{2})\exp -\frac{(\rho ^{\prime } -\rho t)^{2}}{1-t^{2 } } \label{77}\ ] ] where @xmath292 , @xmath293 and @xmath294 @xmath290 is obtained from eq . ( [ 77 ] ) by replacing @xmath295 , @xmath296 and @xmath297 . integrating in @xmath298 , @xmath299 , @xmath300 and @xmath301 , and introducing the variable changes @xmath302 and @xmath303 , we find @xmath304\alpha -(k_{\vert } ^{2}+m_{w}^{2}-eb)\beta } e^{-i(\xi -\xi ^{\prime } ) p_{1}/\sqrt{eb}}\ ] ] @xmath305s_{\alpha } ^{\prime } s_{\beta } \ } \label{81}\ ] ] @xmath306\alpha -(k_{\vert } ^{2}+m_{w}^{2}-eb)\beta } \ ] ] @xmath307e^{-i(\xi -\xi ^{\prime } ) p_{1}/% \sqrt{eb}}rts_{\alpha } ^{\prime } s_{\beta } \ } \label{82}\ ] ] where @xmath308^{-1/2}\exp -(\frac{[\xi + p_{2}/\sqrt{eb% } ] ^{2}-[\xi ^{\prime } + p_{2}/\sqrt{eb}]^{2}}{2})\ ] ] @xmath309^{2}}{% 1-t^{2 } } \label{83}\ ] ] plot of @xmath310 vs. @xmath311 for field range @xmath312 and parameter values @xmath313 , @xmath314 plot of @xmath315 vs. @xmath311 for field range @xmath312 and parameter values @xmath313 , @xmath314 after wick rotating to euclidean space and doing the gaussian integrals in @xmath316 , @xmath317 , @xmath318 and @xmath319 , we finally obtain @xmath320 @xmath321 \label{84}\ ] ] @xmath322 @xmath321 \label{85}\ ] ] where we introduced the normalized parameters @xmath323 , @xmath324 , and @xmath325 . eqs . ( [ 84 ] ) and ( [ 85 ] ) are as far as we can go in the calculation of @xmath243 and @xmath128 after summing in all landau levels without using any approximation . in the zero - field limit the coefficients ( [ 84 ] ) and ( [ 85 ] ) reduce to @xmath326 where @xmath327 @xmath328 . our goal now is to investigate the validity of the lll approximation for the zero - temperature contribution of the coefficients in the parameters range : @xmath329 . with this purpose , in figs . 1 and 2 we plot , @xmath330 \label{87}\ ] ] and @xmath331 \label{88}\ ] ] respectively . here @xmath220 is the lll coefficient defined in eq . ( [ 35 ] ) . notice that primed and unprimed variables are related through : @xmath332 @xmath333 . @xmath201from fig . 1 it can be seen that @xmath334 when @xmath335 , while , from fig . 2 , we see that @xmath336 in all the range @xmath337 . this result corroborates the initial assumption that the lll approximation gives the leading contribution to the vacuum part of the neutrino self - energy at strong fields ( @xmath338 ) . let us consider now the finite temperature contributions . the finite temperature part of the coefficient @xmath243 can be found in the following way . we start from eq . ( [ 81 ] ) , perform the wick rotation to euclidean space , replace the integral in the four momentum by the temperature sum @xmath339 , ( with @xmath340 and integrate in @xmath341 to obtain @xmath342\alpha -(m_{w}^{2}-eb)\beta } e^{-i(\xi -\xi ^{\prime } ) p_{1}/\sqrt{eb}}\ ] ] @xmath343+\ ] ] @xmath344\}e^{-(\alpha + \beta ) k_{4}^{2}-2i\alpha p_{0}k_{4}}\}\ ] ] [ 90 ] after integrating in @xmath318 and @xmath319 , and introducing the elliptic theta functions representation @xcite @xmath345 \label{91}\ ] ] we find @xmath346 where @xmath347 @xmath348\alpha \exp -\widehat{m}_{w}^{2}\beta \exp -\frac{% \widehat{p}_{\bot } ^{2}}{\coth \alpha + \coth \beta } \ ] ] @xmath349+(% \widehat{p}_{0}^{2}-\widehat{p}_{3}^{2})(r^{-1}t^{-1/2}+rt^{1/2})\right]\ ] ] @xmath350 and @xmath351 @xmath352\gamma \exp -\widehat{m}_{w}^{2}(\lambda -\gamma ) \exp -\frac{% \widehat{p}_{\bot } ^{2}}{\coth \gamma + \coth ( \lambda -\gamma ) } \ ] ] @xmath353\frac{% \partial _ { \gamma } \theta _ { 3}\left ( -2\widehat{p}_{0}\widehat{t}\gamma \left/ i4\pi \widehat{t}^{2}\lambda \right . \right ) } { -2\widehat{p}_{0 } } \label{94}\ ] ] in eq . ( [ 94 ] ) we introduced the notation @xmath354 integrating ( [ 94 ] ) by parts and adding the result with ( [ 93 ] ) , we obtain @xmath355\left [ \exp -[-\widehat{p}_{0}^{2}+\widehat{m% } _ { e}^{2}]\lambda \right ] \theta _ { 3}\left ( -2\widehat{p}_{0}\widehat{t}% \lambda \left/ i4\pi \widehat{t}^{2}\lambda \right . \right)\ ] ] @xmath356\left [ \exp -\widehat{m}_{w}^{2}\lambda \right ] \theta _ { 3}\left ( 0/i4\pi \widehat{t% } ^{2}\lambda \right)\ ] ] @xmath357\alpha \exp ( \frac{\alpha ^{2}}{\alpha + \beta } ) \widehat{p}_{3}^{2}\ ] ] @xmath358 -\widehat{p}_{\vert } ^{2}\cosh ( \alpha + 2\beta ) \right.\ ] ] @xmath359 ^{2}}\right ] \left [ \widehat{p}% _ { 3}\sinh ( \alpha + 2\beta ) + \widehat{p}_{0}\cosh ( \alpha + 2\beta ) \right]\ ] ] @xmath360 \right\ } \theta _ { 3}\left ( -2\widehat{p}_{0}% \widehat{t}\alpha /\left/ i4\pi \widehat{t}^{2}(\alpha + \beta ) \right . \right ) \label{96}\ ] ] to isolate the temperature part of @xmath243 , we have to subtract the zero - temperature ( vacuum ) contribution from eq . ( [ 96 ] ) . with this aim , we use the jacobi imaginary transformation @xcite @xmath361\theta _ { 3}\left ( \frac{u}{\tau } \left/ -\frac{1}{\tau } \right . \right ) , \label{97}\ ] ] to write @xmath362}{2\widehat{t}\sqrt{\pi } \sqrt{(\alpha + \beta ) } } % \times\ ] ] @xmath363 \label{98}\ ] ] where the symbol @xmath364@xmath365 means that the term @xmath366 was taken out . then , to subtract the vacuum term from @xmath243 is equivalent to make in eq . ( [ 96 ] ) the following substitution @xmath367}{2% \widehat{t}\sqrt{\pi } \sqrt{(\alpha + \beta ) } } , \label{99}\ ] ] @xmath368}{2\widehat{t}\sqrt{\pi } \sqrt{% \lambda } } , \label{100}\ ] ] @xmath369 plot of @xmath370 vs. @xmath371 for field range @xmath372 and parameter values @xmath373 , @xmath374 , @xmath375 which leads to @xmath376\left [ \exp -[-\widehat{p}% _ { 0}^{2}+\widehat{m}_{e}^{2}]\lambda \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \left [ \theta _ { 3}\left ( -2\widehat{p}_{0}\widehat{t}\lambda / i4\pi \widehat{t}^{2}\lambda \right ) -\frac{\exp -[\widehat{p}_{0}^{2}\lambda ] } { 2% \widehat{t}\sqrt{\pi } \sqrt{\lambda } } \right ] \nonumber \\ & & -\int\limits_{0}^{\infty } d\lambda \frac{\sinh ^{-1}(\lambda ) } { \lambda } [ % \widehat{p}_{3}\sinh ( 2\lambda ) + \widehat{p}_{0}\cosh ( 2\lambda ) ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \left [ \exp -\widehat{m}_{w}^{2}\lambda \right ] \left [ \theta _ { 3}\left ( 0/i4\pi \widehat{t}^{2}\lambda \right ) -\frac{1}{2\widehat{t}% \sqrt{\pi \lambda } } \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + \int\limits_{0}^{\infty } d\alpha \int\limits_{0}^{\infty } d\beta \frac{% \sinh ^{-1}(\alpha + \beta ) } { \sqrt{\alpha + \beta } } \exp -[\widehat{m}% _ { w}^{2}\beta ] \exp -[\widehat{p}_{\vert } ^{2}+\widehat{m}_{e}^{2}]\alpha \nonumber \\ & & \times \exp ( \frac{\alpha ^{2}}{\alpha + \beta } ) \widehat{\,p}_{3}^{2}\exp -% \frac{\widehat{p}_{\bot } ^{2}}{\coth \alpha + \coth \beta } \nonumber \\ & & \times ( \left [ \frac{2\alpha \widehat{p}_{3}\,\widehat{p}_{0}}{\alpha + \beta } + 1\right ] \left [ \widehat{p}_{3}\cosh ( \alpha + 2\beta ) + \widehat{p}% _ { 0}\sinh ( \alpha + 2\beta ) \right ] -\widehat{p}_{\vert } ^{2}\cosh ( \alpha + 2\beta ) \nonumber \\ & & + \left [ ( \widehat{p}_{\vert } ^{2}+\widehat{m}_{e}^{2}-\widehat{m}_{w}^{2})-% \frac{2\alpha \widehat{p}_{3}^{2}}{\alpha + \beta } + ( \frac{1}{\sinh ^{2}\alpha } -\frac{1}{\sinh ^{2}\beta } ) \frac{\widehat{p}_{\bot } ^{2}}{% \left [ \coth \alpha + \coth \beta \right ] ^{2}}\right ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \left [ \widehat{p}_{0}\sinh ( x+2y)+\widehat{p}_{3}\cosh ( x+2y)\right ] ) \nonumber \\ & & \times \left [ \theta _ { 3}\left ( -2\widehat{p}_{0}\widehat{t}\alpha / i4\pi \widehat{t}^{2}(\alpha + \beta ) \right ) -\frac{\exp -[\widehat{p}% _ { 0}^{2}\alpha ^{2}/(\alpha + \beta ) ] } { 2\widehat{t}\sqrt{\pi ( \alpha + \beta ) % } } \right]\ } \label{102}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . ( [ 102 ] ) gives the thermal part of the @xmath243 taking into account all landau levels . to compare the thermal and the lll contributions we plot @xmath377 vs. @xmath378 in fig . 3 . @xmath201from fig . 3 we see that in all the range of temperatures considered , the thermal contribution is consistently smaller in several orders than the lll contribution . this result , along with those obtained in figs . 1 and 2 , imply that @xmath379 , thereby validating the lll approximation in the strong and weakly - strong field cases ( @xmath380 , @xmath381 @xmath382 ) . in addition , we would like to underline the consistency of these numerical results with the arguments used in sec . [ strong - b - selfen ] ( see discussion after eq . ( [ 44 ] ) ) , in the sense that the finite temperature part should be much smaller than the vacuum contribution . two natural environments where the results of the present paper can be of interest are , on one side , stars possessing large magnetic fields ( neutron stars , magnetars , etc ) , and , on the other , the early universe , which presumably was permeated by large primordial magnetic fields that eventually became the seeds @xcite , @xcite of the galactic fields that are observed today at scales of @xmath383 kpc @xcite and larger . the effects of primordial magnetic fields on neutrino propagation are of special interest during the neutrino decoupling era , on which a large number of these particles escaped the electroweak plasma with the possibility to develop significant oscillations . the strength of the primordial magnetic field in the neutrino decoupling era can be estimated from the constraints derived from the successful nucleosynthesis prediction of primordial @xmath384 abundance @xcite@xmath385 as well as on the neutrino mass and oscillation limits @xcite . these constraints , together with the energy equipartition principle , lead to the relations @xmath386 with @xmath387 being the muon mass . then , it is reasonable to assume that between the qcd phase transition epoch and the end of nucleosynthesis a primordial magnetic field in the above range could have been present @xcite . unlike the stellar material , whose density can be of order one , we know that the early universe was almost charge symmetric , with a particle - antiparticle asymmetry of only @xmath388 . therefore , when considering possible consequences of our results for the early universe , we should restrict the discussion to the neutral case ( @xmath13 ) . for the neutral case , it is known that at weak field all the corrections in the neutrino energy density , whether they depend on the field and/or temperature , are second order in the fermi coupling constant @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , therefore negligible small . nevertheless , it can be seen from eqs . ( [ 63])-([64 ] ) that if sufficiently strong magnetic fields were present in the primeval plasma , they would yield corrections to the energy density that are linear in the fermi coupling constant . moreover , as shown in sec . [ numerical ] , the strong - field approximation that led to these corrections is reliable even for magnetic fields in a more realistic range ( i.e. as those satisfying condition ( [ 105 ] ) ) . notice that a field satisfying ( [ 105 ] ) would be effectively strong with respect to the electron - neutrino , but weak for the remaining neutrino flavors . if such a field existed during the decoupling era , it could significantly affect the @xmath389 and @xmath390 resonant oscillations @xcite , as the field would differently modify the energy of @xmath391 compared to those of @xmath392 , @xmath393 and @xmath394 the interesting new thing here is that despite these oscillations would take place in an essentially neutral medium , because of the strong field they will be as significant as those produced by the msw mechanism @xcite in a dense medium . a peculiarity of the strong - field effects on the neutrino energy density is to give rise to anisotropic resonant oscillations . that is , the oscillation probability depends on the direction of the neutrino propagation with respect to the magnetic field . another interesting question related to primordial magnetic fields is whether they influenced neutrino propagation prior to the electroweak phase transition , since some of the mechanisms of primordial magnetic field generation allow their existence at very early epochs @xcite , @xcite . before the electroweak transition a primordial magnetic field could only exist in the form of a u(1 ) hypermagnetic field @xcite . any non - abelian `` magnetic '' field would decay at high temperatures because it would acquire a non - perturbative infrared magnetic mass @xmath395 . the implications of primordial hypermagnetic fields in neutrino propagation before the electroweak phase transition have been studied in refs . @xcite , @xcite . in @xcite the strong - field effects led to a large anisotropy in the leptons energies . the anisotropy was due to the degeneracy in the energy , which in the leading order does not depend on the transverse momentum component . it is in contrast with the magnetic field case , which takes place after the electroweak phase transition , where , although an anisotropy in the neutrino energy is also present , no degeneracy occurs ( see eqs . [ 63])-([64 ] ) ) . this different behavior is a direct consequence , on one hand , of the nonzero neutrino hypercharge and hence of the minimally coupling of these particles to the hypermagnetic field ; and on the other , of their electrical neutrality , which implies that they can interact with a magnetic field through radiative corrections only . we underline that the anisotropy in the energy spectrum of neutrinos in background fields could provide an independent way to verify the existence of primordial magnetic fields , since a field - induced anisotropy would be reflected as an imprint in a yet undetected and elusive cosmic background of neutrinos produced during the decoupling era . for astrophysical applications we should turn our attention to the star interiors characterized by high densities of charged particles under strong magnetic fields . as shown in sec . [ index - ref ] , in the charged medium case the strong - field approximation gives rise to a modification of the kinetic part of the neutrino energy ( first term in eq.([68 ] ) ) , that is not present in leading order at weak field ( eq . ( [ 71 ] ) ) @xcite . due to this new term the largest field - dependent contribution to the neutrino kinetic energy comes from neutrinos propagating perpendicularly to the field . it is worth noticing that the anisotropic term associated with the effective magnetic moment in the dispersion relations ( [ 68 ] ) and ( [ 71 ] ) changes sign when neutrinos reverse their direction of motion . on the other hand , the kinetic energy term in ( [ 68 ] ) remains unchanged when the neutrinos moves in opposite direction , even though it depends on the direction of propagation of the neutrinos with respect to the magnetic field . as known @xcite , the anisotropy associated to the magnetic - moment contribution to the neutrino energy can be relevant for a possible explanation of the peculiar high pulsar velocities . it would be interesting to consider the combined effects of the two different anisotropies to understand whether they could affect the dynamics of proto - neutron stars . another possible ground of applications of our results is supernova neutrinos . core collapse supernovae are dominated by neutrinos and their transport properties . in addition , the observation of neutrinos from supernova , which is essential to confirm the basic picture of supernova explosion , can be affected by neutrino oscillations . as we have pointed out in this paper , neutrino transport and oscillations can be both modified by the presence of a strong magnetic field . magnetic fields as strong as @xmath396 to @xmath397 g could exist in the first seconds of neutrino emission inside the supernova core @xcite . thus , the electron - neutrino energy spectrum found in this paper , within the strong - field limit for the charged medium , should be considered for any study of neutrino oscillations under those conditions . in this paper we carried out a thorough study of the propagation of neutrinos in strongly magnetized neutral and charged media . we started from the most general structure of the neutrino self - energy in a magnetic field , expressing it as the sum of four independent covariant terms with coefficients that are functions of the physical variables of the theory and whose values depend on the approximation considered . general expressions of the four coefficients at one - loop approximation were given in eqs . ( [ 25]-[28 ] ) . the coefficients were then calculated in the strong - field limit using the lll aproximation for the electrons . the lll was assumed to be valid in the parameter range @xmath329 , @xmath381 @xmath382 . to justify it one should keep in mind that under these conditions most electrons would not have enough energy to overcome the gap between the landau levels . hence , they will be mainly confined to their lower levels and the leading contribution would come from the lll . this assumption was also corroborated for the above parameters range by numerical calculations summing in all landau levels . the dispersion relation of the neutrinos was written as a function of the four coefficients of the self - energy structures , allowing in this way to straightforwardly obtain the neutrino s energy in the strong - field limit for each physical case . in concordance with results previously obtained in charged media at weak fields @xcite,@xcite , in the strong - field case an energy term associated with the interaction between the magnetic field and the effective magnetic moment was also found at leading order in @xmath398 . this interaction energy disappears in the neutral medium , since in a charged - symmetric plasma the contribution to the effective magnetic moment coming from electrons and positrons cancels out . a main outcome of our investigation was to show that in strongly magnetized systems a term of different nature emerges in both charged and neutral media . the new term , which is linear in the magnetic field and of first order in @xmath398 , enters as a correction to the neutrino kinetic energy in the presence of a strong - magnetic field . this correction is present even in a strongly magnetized vacuum , since it is related to the vacuum part ( @xmath170 @xmath13 ) of the neutrino self - energy at @xmath399 . a characteristic of the field - dependent corrections to the neutrino energy is that they produce an anisotropic index of refraction , since neutrinos moving along different directions have different field - dependent dispersion relations . we should underline that while the magnetic moment interaction term produces a maximum field effect for neutrinos propagating along the field lines , the field correction to the kinetic energy does not contribute to those propagation modes , but on the contrary , the maximum kinetic - energy effect takes place for neutrinos propagating perpendicularly to the field direction . we stress that the anisotropy does not differentiate between neutrinos and antineutrinos . the charged medium results reported in the current work can be of interest for the astrophysics of neutrinos in stars with large magnetic fields . on the other hand , our finding for the neutral medium can have applications in cosmology , if the existence of high primordial magnetic fields is finally confirmed . contrary to some authors belief @xcite,@xcite that , regardless of the field intensity , the neutrino dispersion relation in the early universe is well approximated by the dispersion relation in the zero field medium , our results indicate that strong , and even weakly strong , magnetic fields can give rise to a contribution to the neutrino energy that is several orders larger than the pure thermal contribution . the field - dependent correction to the neutrino energy in a neutral medium with strong magnetic field can have an impact in neutrino flavor - oscillations in the primeval plasma @xcite and therefore affect primordial nucleosynthesis . hence , this new effect could be important to establish possible limits to the strength of the primordial magnetic field . ee is indebted to the members of the mathematics dept . of mit , and specially to dan freedman , for the warm hospitality . ejf and vi would like to thank the institute of space studies of catalonia ( spain ) , where part of this work was accomplished , for the warm hospitality during their visit . the work of ee has been supported by dgicyt ( spain ) , contract pr-2003 - 0352 and project bfm2003 - 00620 . the work of ejf and vi was supported by nsf - grant phy-0070986 . v. ginzburg , high energy gamma ray astrophysics ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1991 ) ; d. bhattacharya and g. srinivasan , in x - ray binaries , ed . w.h.g . lewin , j. van paradijs , and e.p.j . van den heuvel , cambridge univ . press , cambridge , 1995 , pag . 495 . r. c. duncan and c. thompson , astrophys . j.*392 * ( 1992 ) l9 ; b. paczynski , acta astron.*42 * ( 1992 ) 145 ; v. v. usov , nature**357 * * ( 1992 ) 472 ; c. thompson and r. c. duncan astrophys . j.*473 * ( 1996 ) 322 ; c. kouveliotou et al . , nature * 393 * ( 1998 ) 235 ; astrophys . j.*510 * ( 1999 ) l115 . y. sofue , m. fujimoto , and r. wielebinski , ann . astron . astrophys.*24 * ( 1986 ) 459 ; p. p. kronberg , rep . phys.*57 * ( 1994 ) 325 ; r. beck et . astron . astrophys.*34 * ( 1996 ) 153 ; r. beck et . al . , ann . astron . astrophys.*34 * ( 1996 ) 153 . t. vachaspati , phys . lett . b**265 * * ( 1991 ) 258 ; k. enqvist and p. olesen , phys . lett . b**319 * * ( 1993 ) 178 ; b. cheng and a. v. olinto , phys . d**50 * * ( 1994 ) 2421 ; g. baym , d. bodeker and l. mclerran , phys . rev . d**53 * * ( 1996 ) 662 ; a. brandenburg , k. enqvist , and p. olesen , phys . rev . d**54 * * , ( 1996 ) 1291 ; phys . lett . b**392 * * ( 1997 ) 395 ; g. sigl , a. v. olinto , and k jedamzik , phys . rev . d**55 * * ( 1997 ) 4582 ; m. joyce and m. e. shaposhnikov , phys . lett.*79 * ( 1997 ) 1193 ; k. enqvist , int . d**7 * * ( 1998 ) 331 ; m. giovannini and m. e. shaposhnikov , phys . d**57 * * ( 1998 ) 2186 ; o. trnkvist , phys.rev.d**58 * * ( 1998 ) 043501 ; m. hindmarsh and a. everett , phys . rev . d**58 * * ( 1998 ) 103505 ; d. grasso and a. riotto , phys . lett . b**418 * * ( 1998 ) 258 ; j. ahonen and k. enqvist , phys . rev . d**57 * * ( 1998 ) 664 ; p. cea and l. tedesco , phys . lett . b**450 * * ( 1999 ) 61 ; int . j. mod d**12 * * ( 2003 ) 663 ; k. dimopoulos , t. prokopec , o. tornkvist and a. c. davis , phys . rev . d**65 * * ( 2002 ) 063505 ; d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega , and m. simionato , phys . rev . d**67 * * ( 2003 ) 123505 , astro - ph/0305131 ; z. berezhiani and a. d. dolgov , astro - ph/0305595 ; a. d. dolgov , astro - ph/0306443 ; m. giovannini astro - ph/0312614 . e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , neutrinos under strong magnetic fields . proceedings of neutrinos , flavor physics and precision cosmology , fourth tropical workshop ( aip conference proceedings v689 , pag . 372 , editor j. f. nieves and r. r. volkas ) , cairns , queensland , australia , june 2003 . v. b. semikoz and j. w. f. valle , nucl . phys . b**425 * * ( 1994 ) 651 , p. elmfors , d. grasso and g. raffelt , nucl . phys . b**479 * * ( 1996 ) 3 ; a. erdas , c. w. kim and t. h. lee , phys . d**58 * * ( 1998 ) 085016 ; d. grasso , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) * 70 * ( 1999 ) 267 ; a. erdas , and c. isola , phys . lett . b**494 * * ( 2000 ) 262 . e. j. ferrer , in proceedings of the international conference quantization , gauge theory , and strings , 5 - 10 jun 2000 , moscow , russia ( scientif world publi . , singapore 2001 , v. ii , pag.301 , editors a. semikhatov , m. vasiliev and v. zaikin ) ; e. elizalde , e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , neutrino dispersion in intense magnetic field . proceedings of particle physics and cosmology second tropical workshop ( aip conference proceedings v540 , pag . 372 , editor j. f. nieves ) , san juan , puerto rico , apr . 2000 . v. i. ritus , in issues in intense - field quantum electrodynamics ( v.l . ginzburg , ed . ) , proceedings of p.n . lebedev physical institute , vol . 111 , p. 5 , moscow , nauka , 1979 . * 168 * , nova science , commack , 1987 ) . c. n. leung , y. j. ng , and a. w. ackley , phys . d**54 * * ( 1996 ) 4181 ; d. -s . lee , c. n. leung , y. j. ng , phys . rev.*55 * ( 1997 ) 6504 ; e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , phys . rev d**58 * * ( 1998 ) 065008 ; int . a * 14 * ( 1999 ) 3963 ; phys . b**481**(2000 ) 287 ; e. elizalde , e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , phys . rev . d**68 * * ( 2003 ) 096004 . m. j. duff and m. ramon - medrano , phys . rev . d**12 * * ( 1975 ) 3357 ; g. k. savvidy , phys . lett b**71 * * ( 1977 ) 133 ; s. g. matinyan and g. k. savvidy , nucl . phys . b**134 * * ( 1978 ) 539 ; h. b. nielsen and p. olesen , nucl . phys . b**144 * * ( 1978 ) 376 ; v. v. skalozub , sov . j. nucl . phys * 43 * ( 1986 ) 665 . for a discussion on the relation between the index of refraction and the different velocity notions see : l. brillouin , wave propagation and group velocity , academic press , new york , 1960 ; r. l. smith , am . j. phys . * 38 * ( 1970 ) 978 ; a. kuzmich , et al , phys . rev . lett.*86 * ( 2001 ) 3925 . j. l. latorre , p. pascual , and r. tarrach , nucl . phys . b**437 * * ( 1995 ) 60 , g. m. shore , nucl . phys . b**460 * * ( 1996 ) 379 ; k. scharnhorst , ann . phys . * 7 * ( 1998 ) 700 ; w. dittrich and h. gies , phys . rev . d**58 * * ( 1998 ) 025004 ; a. d. dolgov and i. d. novikov , phys . lett . b**442 * * ( 1998 ) 82 . j. cannellos , e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , phys . b**542 * * ( 2002 ) 123 ; j. cannellos , e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , self energy of chiral leptons in a background hypermagnetic field . proceedings of mrst-2002 , perimeter institute , waterloo , canada , may 15 - 17 , 2002 ( aip conf . ( 2003 ) 117 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: observed non - thermal line widths in molecular clouds ( mcs ) , where all star formation in the galaxy takes place , point to the presence of supersonic turbulence in such regions ( falgarone & philips 1990 ) . the properties of the turbulent medium , such as mach number and magnetic field strength , may determine the products of the star formation process . as an important source of heating within molecular clouds ( stone et al . 1998 , hereafter s98 ) , turbulent energy dissipation may also play a role . much effort has been directed toward numerically simulating turbulent media in order to better understand the link between turbulence and star formation ( see elmegreen & scalo 2004 , maclow & klessen 2004 , and mckee & ostriker 2007 and references therein ) . as we have not yet identified the turbulent driving mechanism , there remain many unanswered questions about the evolution of molecular clouds . is the turbulence periodically re - energized , or does it simply decay away ? how much impact do magnetic fields have on the properties of the turbulence ? crutcher ( 1999 ) , using observations of zeeman splitting , found magnetic fields in some clouds strong enough that one can not safely neglect their effects . although it has been shown that magnetic fields do not appreciably lengthen the turbulent decay time ( s98 ; mac low 1999 ) , they do create anisotropy within the clouds ( e.g. vestuto et al . 2003 , hereafter v03 ; esquivel et al . 2003 ) , which may have important observational and evolutionary consequences . for example , molecular clouds are often observed to be filamentary ( e.g. mizuno et al . 1995 ; churchwell et al . 2004 ) . in this paper , we will investigate the energy dissipation properties of supersonic hydrodynamic and mhd turbulence with a variety of magnetic field strengths using athena , a new higher - order godunov code . an important goal of this study is to investigate the effect of the assumed driving mechanism on the properties of the resulting turbulence , such as power spectra and intermittency indicators . our analysis utilizes data from high - resolution numerical simulations with twenty - five different parameter sets . in recent years , a variety of results have been reported on the properties of supersonic mhd turbulence , including energetics ( e.g. s98 ; mac low 1999 ; ostriker et al . 2001 ) , power spectra ( e.g. cho & lazarian 2003 , 2005 ; v03 ; padoan et al . 2007 , hereafter p07 ) , and probability distribution functions ( e.g. padoan et al . 1997 ; passot & vazquez - semadeni 1998 ; ostriker et al . 2001 ; kowal et al . 2007 ; kritsuk et al . 2007 , hereafter k07 ) . where possible , we identify differences in our methods and results as compared to those of other groups . in a separate letter ( lemaster & stone 2008 , hereafter paper i ) , we have reported the results of an investigation of the variation of the probability distribution function ( pdf ) of density with mach number . our primary result in that paper was that the intermittent behavior of turbulence could be responsible for the large cloud - to - cloud variation in the observed star formation rate per solar mass . the primary tool available to investigate the properties of highly nonlinear , supersonic mhd turbulence is direct numerical simulation . to date , most results have been computed using a few numerical algorithms , such as zeus ( e.g. s98 ; v03 ; mac low 1999 ; ostriker et al . 1999 ; ostriker et al . 2001 ) , the pencil code ( e.g. haugen & brandenburg 2004 ) , the stagger code ( e.g. p07 ) , and eno methods ( e.g. cho & lazarian 2003 ) . there has been concern expressed in the literature that previous results may be strongly affected by numerical dissipation . thus , it is worth re - examining the problem with more accurate methods . this study represents one of the first applications of higher - order godunov methods to the study of supersonic mhd turbulence . without knowing the driving mechanism , we are left with many possible methods of generating turbulence in simulations . the hope is that the choice of method for the simulated driving will have an insignificant effect on the results . federrath , klessen , & schmidt ( in prep . ) , however , have shown that compressive and solenoidal forcing produce dramatically different turbulent states . for some diagnostics , such as intermittency , the time - variability of the turbulent state is critical . even if an array of driving methods produce the same mean state , do the instantaneous states have the same distribution about the mean ? we will investigate the dependence on driving scale of various diagnostics , given our particular driving method , which is very similar to that employed by , e.g. , s98 and v03 . for power spectra of simulated turbulence to be valuable , the resolution needs to be high enough that the driving and numerical dissipation scales are well separated , allowing the inertial range to be studied . when magnetic fields are taken into account , simulating turbulence at these resolutions can be prohibitively expensive . another goal of this study is to investigate whether properties of the power spectra and other diagnostics are converged at the numerical resolutions feasible at the moment , up to @xmath0 . we begin in [ sec : methods ] by describing our numerical methods in detail . we proceed , in [ sec : results ] , to present our results . [ sec : satresults ] includes a convergence study and mach number scaling study of saturation amplitudes , [ sec : specresults ] includes a power spectrum analysis , [ sec : sonicresults ] analyzes the sonic scale in @xmath0 runs , and [ sec : mittresults ] considers time - variability and temperature intermittency in the turbulence . finally , we summarize our results in [ sec : concl ] and discuss the implications . the simulations we present were conducted up to a resolution of @xmath0 with the athena code ( gardiner & stone 2005 , 2008 ; stone et al . 2008 ; stone & gardiner 2008 ) on a three - dimensional cartesian grid of length @xmath1 with periodic boundary conditions . athena utilizes a higher - order godunov scheme which exactly conserves mass , momentum , and magnetic flux . we solve the equations of ideal isothermal mhd , @xmath2 @xmath3 and @xmath4 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the isothermal sound speed and pressure , respectively . because our method of driving the turbulence , described in the following paragraph , does not involve modifying the equations of mhd , we include no explicit forcing term here . we use an approximate nonlinear riemann solver ( hlld ; miyoshi & kusano 2005 ) for our mhd runs and an exact nonlinear riemann solver for our hydrodynamic runs . both our mhd and hydro simulations are integrated well past the turbulent saturation time using a directionally - unsplit van leer scheme ( stone & gardiner 2008 ) . further details of how we overcame the numerical difficulties associated with utilizing this method for turbulence can be found in appendix [ sec : godunov ] . we initialize a uniform , stationary ambient medium with density @xmath7 and magnetic field parallel to the @xmath8-axis whose amplitude @xmath9 is fixed by the value of @xmath10 . we then apply divergence - free velocity perturbations following a gaussian random distribution with a fourier power spectrum of the form @xmath11 for @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the resolution and @xmath14 is the wavenumber of peak driving , in all but two of our runs . for the remaining two runs , with @xmath15 and @xmath16 at @xmath0 , we truncate the driving spectrum at @xmath17 . before applying the perturbations to the grid , we shift them such that no net momentum will be added and normalize them to give the desired energy injection rate , @xmath18 , or , in the decaying case , initial kinetic energy . for our driven runs , we choose our energy injection rate to give the desired turbulent mach number , @xmath19 , in the saturated state . here , @xmath20^{1/2}$ ] is the 3d velocity dispersion of the gas and @xmath21 is the 1d velocity dispersion in a given direction . the method we use in this paper to compute the turbulent mach number differs from that used by some other groups ; we utilize a density - weighted velocity dispersion , @xmath22^{1/2}$ ] . note that , due to the zero net momentum of our turbulent medium , the second term on the rhs vanishes on the global scale . if we compare the mach number computed with and without density - weighting the velocity dispersion , we find that the two are fairly correlated , but that the time - average of the latter is @xmath23 larger than that of the former for driven strong - field mhd turbulence with , e.g. , @xmath16 and @xmath15 , or @xmath24 and @xmath25 . the comparison for the latter case is shown in figure [ fig : machmeth ] . we will use a density - weighted velocity dispersion for all but our sonic scale analysis . to drive turbulence in our simulations , we inject energy before each time step , with a new realization of the power spectrum generated at intervals @xmath26 . this differs from that done in s98 and v03 , where the energy was injected only when a new realization of the spectrum was generated . ostriker et al . ( 1999 , 2001 ) and kowal et al . ( 2007 ) used different driving spectra than our own but still constrained their velocity perturbations to be divergence free . our method differs from that of k07 in that they approximate an isothermal equation of state using an adiabatic index of @xmath27 , drive their turbulence on very large scales using an acceleration that is fixed in time , and also allow a substantial fraction of the energy introduced by the forcing to be in compressional modes . p07 also used a fixed acceleration for turbulent driving . it is important to understand if these differences have any significant impact on the results . for our decaying runs , we again begin with a uniform , stationary ambient medium but apply only one driving impulse to the velocity field , with a power spectrum of the same form as is used to initialize our driven runs . we then allow it to evolve undisturbed . we choose the turbulent kinetic energy applied to our medium so as to give the desired initial turbulent mach number . our decaying runs differ from those of sytine et al . ( 2000 ) , who used a different initial driving spectrum and allowed a compressible component in the initial perturbations . they used an adiabatic equation of state with @xmath28 , which we will use only for our decaying simulations . in this case , we solve the total energy equation , @xmath29 = 0,\ ] ] in addition to equations ( [ eq : mhdeqn1])([eq : mhdeqn3 ] ) , using the hllc riemann solver . here , @xmath30 with @xmath31 and @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the internal energy density and @xmath34 is the ratio of specific heats . the numerical methods in athena conserve total energy exactly . we primarily investigate strong - field mhd turbulence with @xmath35 and hydrodynamic turbulence ( @xmath36 ) , although we present runs with @xmath37 ( moderate - field ) and @xmath38 ( weak - field ) as well . note that , due to a definition of @xmath39 in s98 and v03 that differs from ours by a factor of 2 , our @xmath35 results should be compared to their @xmath40 results , and similarly for other values of @xmath39 . the magnetic fields we use in our simulations correspond to physical values of @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the temperature and @xmath43 is the number density of molecular hydrogen . our simulations are scale - free , allowing them to be scaled to any set of physical parameters using appropriate choices of @xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 . utilizing the same values given in s98 , i.e. @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 , yields energy injection rates of up to @xmath50 , with a magnetic field strength @xmath51 for the strong - field case . figure [ fig : den1024p2a ] shows slices in mass density along the far faces of the computational domain for driven @xmath52 strong - field mhd turbulence with @xmath16 at @xmath0 . also included are magnetic field vectors in a slice normal to the y - axis near the bottom of the cube . due to the strong background magnetic field , the vectors are fairly well aligned . figure [ fig : den1024p2d ] also shows slices in density , but this time for @xmath53 hydrodynamic turbulence with the same driving scale and resolution . for both cases the structure seen is filamentary , with anisotropy in the scale of the structures in the strong - field case as a result of the field this is not to say , however , that the filaments are aligned with the magnetic field . in fact , some appear to be oriented perpendicular to the field . figures [ fig : col1024p2a ] and [ fig : col1024p2d ] show column density along the line of sight parallel to the z - axis for the same runs as in figures [ fig : den1024p2a ] and [ fig : den1024p2d ] , respectively . the projected filamentary structure is visible in these column density images . the column density contrast is higher for the strong - field than for the hydrodynamic case . we begin our quantitative analysis by studying the energy in fluctuations once our driven turbulence runs have reached saturation . since the method with which we drive our turbulence injects energy at a constant rate , at saturation the energy dissipation rate of the turbulence will , on average , equal the energy injection rate . at sufficiently high numerical resolution , the numerical dissipation will become negligible compared to the physically interesting sources of dissipation ( shocks ) , and the energy dissipation properties of the turbulence can given us insight into the heating within and evolution of molecular clouds . in this section , we will first determine the resolution at which the saturation energy has converged , i.e. reached a state such that further increasing the resolution has a negligible effect on the state , for turbulence evolved using athena and compare the turbulent decay rates to those presented in s98 computed using zeus . the kinetic energy associated with the fluctuations in our turbulent medium can be quantified by @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is the density and @xmath56 is the magnitude of the velocity . an integration for this and all similar quantities is performed over the entire domain . similarly , the energy in magnetic field perturbations is @xmath57 , where @xmath58 and @xmath9 are the magnitudes , respectively , of the magnetic field and its initial value . the total energy in perturbations is the sum of the energy in kinetic and magnetic field fluctuations , @xmath59 . to analyze the energy dissipation properties of the turbulence , we compute dissipation timescales using @xmath60 , normalizing them to the flow crossing time , @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is the wavelength of peak driving . we can partition the kinetic energy by breaking down the velocity into its solenoidal and compressive components . the solenoidal component is divergence - free , whereas the compressive component is curl - free . these can easily be computed using @xmath63 \hat{k}$ ] and @xmath64 \times \hat{k}$ ] , respectively . for simulations with comparable parameters ( i.e. @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) , these energies can be compared directly with the values given in s98 and v03 after accounting for the difference in definition of @xmath39 . we average our quantities over at least one dynamical time , often several , beginning after the turbulence has fully saturated . to determine the rate of convergence of a given volume - integrated quantity , @xmath65 , we compute the percent error in the quantity at each resolution relative to the converged value . in the case where the quantity changes monotonically with resolution , we find the converged value by performing a three - parameter fit , @xmath66 , where @xmath13 is the resolution and @xmath67 is the value at that resolution . the results of this fit tell us ( 1 ) the converged value , @xmath68 , ( 2 ) the order of convergence , @xmath69 , and ( 3 ) the coefficient , @xmath70 , that determines the resolution at which our result has converged , i.e. when @xmath71 . to determine the resolution at which our numerical dissipation has become small compared to shock dissipation , we analyze the properties of driven , supersonic hydrodynamic turbulence at resolutions from @xmath72 to @xmath73 . we study two sets of simulations with identical energy injection rate , @xmath25 , but differing driving scales . the set of runs with small - scale driving , @xmath24 , correspond to the hydrodynamic run in s98 , while the other set of runs are driven at twice the scale , @xmath74 . the properties of the @xmath73 run from each set can be found in table [ tab : hydro ] . we have not performed a convergence study of the @xmath16 runs due to the high level of time - variability ( discussed in [ sec : varresults ] ) . cccccccrrr 8 & 1000 & 5.8 & 17 & 3.8 & 13 & 0.77 & @xmath75 & & + 4 & 1000 & 7.2 & 26 & 5.9 & 20 & 0.76 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + 4 & 375 & 5.3 & 14 & 3.1 & 11 & 0.78 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + 4 & 140 & 3.8 & 7.2 & 1.6 & 5.6 & 0.78 & @xmath76 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 + 4 & 40 & 2.6 & 3.3 & 0.7 & 2.6 & 0.84 & @xmath76 & @xmath79 & @xmath79 + 4 & 3.5 & 1.2 & 0.8 & 0.1 & 0.7 & 1.1 & @xmath75 & @xmath79 & @xmath79 + 2 & 500 & 7.0 & 25 & 5.5 & 19 & 0.7 & @xmath80 & @xmath78 & @xmath81 + 2 & 187.5 & 5.2 & 13 & 3.1 & 10 & 0.73 & @xmath82 & @xmath77 & @xmath81 + 2 & 70 & 3.7 & 6.9 & 1.6 & 5.4 & 0.74 & @xmath82 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 + 2 & 20 & 2.5 & 3.1 & 0.6 & 2.5 & 0.77 & @xmath76 & @xmath83 & @xmath83 + 2 & 1.75 & 1.2 & 0.7 & 0.1 & 0.6 & 0.99 & @xmath82 & @xmath81 & @xmath81 although both sets of runs are driven with energy injection rate @xmath25 , the larger driving scale of the @xmath74 set causes it to converge to @xmath84 , while the @xmath24 set converges to only @xmath85 . the former set reaches convergence by @xmath86 , with higher resolutions having a small scatter about the converged value . the latter set , on the other hand , converges monotonically at order @xmath87 for all resolutions analyzed , reaching within @xmath88 of the converged value by @xmath89 . the kinetic energy in fluctuations of the set with larger driving scale , @xmath74 , converges to a value of @xmath90 by @xmath86 and has some scatter about the converged value for higher resolutions . for the set with smaller driving scale , @xmath24 , the kinetic energy in fluctuations converges at order @xmath91 to only @xmath92 . the value at @xmath89 is within @xmath93 of the converged value , while at @xmath94 it is within a fraction of a percent . although we have an extremely low sampling rate for the fraction of the kinetic energy in solenoidal and compressive modes , they appear to be independent of driving scale . the solenoidal fraction converges to @xmath95 , decreasing with increasing resolution , while the compressive fraction converges to @xmath96 . the solenoidal fraction is within a fraction of a percent of the converged value by @xmath94 ; however , it varies by only a small amount down to low resolution . finally , the ratio of the energy dissipation timescale to the flow crossing time at the driving scale increases with resolution , to @xmath97 for the @xmath74 set and @xmath98 for the @xmath24 set , only a small difference . consistent with our previous results , the @xmath74 set converges at lower resolution than the @xmath24 set , @xmath86 and @xmath94 , respectively . the turbulence dissipates in less than a flow crossing time in all cases . although the converged mach number and saturation energies are higher for @xmath74 than for @xmath24 , the fraction of the energy in the solenoidal or compressive mode , as well as the ratio of the energy dissipation timescale to the flow crossing time at the driving scale , are relatively independent of the driving scale . while most of the quantities of interest converge between @xmath89 and @xmath94 for the @xmath24 hydrodynamic runs , convergence has already been reached for these quantities by @xmath86 for the @xmath74 runs . high resolutions are critical for separating the driving and dissipation scales in the power spectra far enough to study the inertial range ; however , quantities such as energy dissipation rate and turbulent mach number converge at resolutions which are more easily attainable . we now analyze driven , strong - field , supersonic mhd turbulence in the same manner as in the previous section . to determine the resolution at which our numerical dissipation becomes negligible , we study the convergence of two sets of mhd simulations with energy injection rate @xmath25 at resolutions from @xmath72 to @xmath73 . one set has @xmath24 , similar to the strong - field mhd run in s98 , while the other has @xmath74 . the properties of the @xmath73 run from each set can be found in table [ tab : mhd ] . again , we have not performed a convergence study of the @xmath16 runs due to the high level of time - variability ( discussed in [ sec : varresults ] ) . cccccccccrrr 2.0 & 8 & 1000 & 5.3 & 14 & 2.1 & 12 & 5.8 & 0.83 & @xmath75 & & + 0.2 & 8 & 1000 & 5.1 & 13 & 1.6 & 11 & 8.6 & 0.89 & @xmath75 & & + 0.02 & 8 & 1000 & 5.4 & 15 & 1.5 & 13 & 8.2 & 1.0 & @xmath75 & & + 0.02 & 4 & 1000 & 6.8 & 23 & 2.3 & 21 & 13 & 0.98 & @xmath75 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + 0.02 & 4 & 375 & 5.2 & 14 & 1.1 & 13 & 6.4 & 1.1 & @xmath75 & @xmath79 & @xmath78 + 0.02 & 4 & 140 & 3.8 & 7.3 & 0.5 & 6.7 & 3.1 & 1.1 & @xmath99 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 + 0.02 & 4 & 40 & 2.7 & 3.6 & 0.2 & 3.4 & 1.4 & 1.3 & @xmath75 & @xmath83 & @xmath83 + 0.02 & 4 & 3.5 & 1.3 & 0.8 & 0.04 & 0.8 & 0.3 & 1.7 & @xmath75 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 + 0.02 & 2 & 500 & 7.0 & 24 & 2.2 & 22 & 11 & 0.98 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath100 + 0.02 & 2 & 187.5 & 5.0 & 13 & 1.2 & 11 & 5.9 & 0.99 & @xmath99 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 + 0.02 & 2 & 70 & 3.7 & 6.8 & 0.6 & 6.3 & 2.9 & 1.0 & @xmath99 & @xmath81 & @xmath100 + 0.02 & 2 & 20 & 2.5 & 3.1 & 0.2 & 2.9 & 1.3 & 1.1 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath81 + 0.02 & 2 & 1.75 & 1.2 & 0.8 & 0.06 & 0.7 & 0.4 & 1.6 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 as in the hydrodynamic case , the @xmath74 mhd runs converge to a higher mach number , @xmath104 , than the @xmath24 runs ( @xmath105 ) . the former is converged by @xmath94 , while the latter converges at @xmath106 order , only reaching convergence at @xmath73 . the total energy in fluctuations converges at nearly @xmath106 order to @xmath107 for @xmath74 , shown in figure [ fig : mpert4res ] . while convergence has definitely been reached by @xmath73 , the @xmath94 value is less than @xmath93 from the converged value . for @xmath24 , on the other hand , convergence is not reached until @xmath73 , where @xmath108 . convergence is at nearly @xmath106 order for this case as well . for the energy in magnetic field perturbations , convergence is reached at @xmath73 for both the @xmath74 and @xmath24 cases . convergence is approached at roughly 0.7 order for both cases . the fraction of the total energy ( magnetic plus kinetic ) in magnetic field fluctuations increases with resolution , reaching @xmath109 at @xmath73 . when driven at @xmath74 , the kinetic energy in fluctuations converges to @xmath110 by around @xmath94 , while at @xmath24 it converges at order 0.9 to @xmath111 by @xmath73 . the fraction of the kinetic energy fluctuations in solenoidal modes increases with resolution for both the @xmath74 and @xmath24 cases , converging to @xmath112 . the fraction in compressive modes , on the other hand , decreases with resolution to @xmath113 . convergence for these quantities is not reached until @xmath73 . finally , the ratio of the dissipation timescale to the flow crossing time at the driving scale converges to @xmath114 by @xmath94 for @xmath74 , while for @xmath24 it converges to @xmath115 by @xmath73 . even with a strong magnetic field , the turbulence dissipates in a flow crossing time . just as in the hydrodynamic case , the increased driving scale caused a higher turbulent mach number and energy at saturation for the @xmath74 than for the @xmath24 case . the fraction of the kinetic energy in solenoidal or compressive modes , however , was independent of driving scale , just as before . the ratio of the dissipation timescale to flow crossing time was also relatively independent of the driving scale . convergence for strong - field mhd turbulence was reached at higher resolutions , typically @xmath73 , than for hydrodynamic turbulence . because we performed a convergence study using the same turbulence parameters as in s98 , we can directly compare our high - resolution results to those published therein . for driven strong - field mhd turbulence with @xmath24 , we find at @xmath94 that our total energy in fluctuations at saturation is only @xmath116 higher than that found in s98 , due to the lower level of numerical dissipation at this resolution in athena than in zeus . for intermediate- and weak - field mhd , our energies are @xmath117 and @xmath116 higher , respectively . it is likely that neither our results nor the s98 results have converged by this resolution , however . at @xmath73 , there is no obvious difference between the total energy in fluctuations for our strong - field mhd simulation and the s98 result . the values from these two codes converge , even though they utilize completely different numerical methods . the ratio of magnetic to kinetic energy fluctuations , however , is different for the two codes , yielding ratios of dissipation timescale to flow crossing time that differ more substantially . at @xmath94 , this ratio is @xmath118 greater for our strong - field mhd run than that presented in s98 . for intermediate- and weak - field mhd , our ratios are both @xmath119 greater . in all cases , the ratio of timescales remains below unity . for our driven hydro run at @xmath94 with @xmath24 , we find that our total energy in fluctuations at saturation is also only @xmath116 higher than that found in s98 . although our result has converged by this resolution , the zeus result may not yet be converged . the ratio of dissipation timescale to flow crossing time in this case is @xmath119 greater than that found in s98 , but is still below unity . although it has been suggested in the literature that the rapid decay of supersonic turbulence is due to excessive numerical dissipation in zeus , these results , computed with a higher - order godunov scheme , do not support that conclusion . to investigate the effect of the turbulent mach number on energies and dissipation rates in the turbulence , we now analyze two series of five driven , supersonic hydrodynamic turbulence simulations at @xmath73 . one series is driven at @xmath74 , while the other is driven at a larger scale of @xmath16 . the energy injection rates of the latter series , the same that we use in paper i , are half that of the former series , giving roughly equal mach numbers to the corresponding pairs . these mach numbers all fall within the range @xmath120 . the properties of these runs can be found in table [ tab : hydro ] . the kinetic energy in each series of runs spans 1.5 orders of magnitude . we find a power law relationship between the kinetic energy and energy injection rate , i.e. @xmath121^{-1/2 } ( { \ensuremath{\dot{e}/\bar{\rho}l^2c_s^3}})^{0.62}.\ ] ] the relationship between the kinetic energy and mach number is , of course , exactly @xmath122 since our mach numbers are computed from the _ density - weighted _ velocity dispersion and there is no net momentum associated with the turbulent medium as a whole . we find for our driving method that we can estimate the mach number that will result from a given energy injection rate using @xmath123^{-1/4 } ( { \ensuremath{\dot{e}/\bar{\rho}l^2c_s^3}})^{0.31}.\ ] ] while this equation gives an indication of how the dissipation scales with mach number , the exact relations will only apply to our unique driving method . for the runs driven at @xmath74 , the fraction of the kinetic energy in compressive modes varies by only a fraction of a percent among the runs with @xmath124 . these runs have @xmath96 . the fraction drops off only slightly for the @xmath125 run , but then drops substantially , to @xmath126 , for the @xmath127 run . for the runs driven at @xmath16 , the fraction for the @xmath53 and @xmath128 runs is also @xmath96 , while the @xmath129 and @xmath130 runs have a bit larger and smaller fractions , respectively . once again , the fraction for the @xmath127 run is substantially smaller , @xmath131 . it appears as though the fraction of the energy in compressive modes remains roughly the same except when the turbulence is only mildly supersonic , where the fraction is much lower . the ratio of the dissipation timescale to the flow crossing time at the driving scale remains below unity for all except the @xmath127 run at @xmath74 . while the ratio for the runs at @xmath74 with @xmath132 does nt vary much , when we increase the driving scale to @xmath16 the value does change with mach number . the ratio for the @xmath74 runs is always larger for a given mach number than is the ratio for the @xmath16 runs . finally , we analyze two series of five driven , supersonic , strong - field mhd turbulence simulations at @xmath73 to determine the effect of the turbulent mach number on the energies and dissipation rates . as before , one series is the same @xmath16 set of runs used in paper i , while the other is driven at @xmath74 with twice the energy injection rate , yielding pairs of simulations of roughly the same mach number within the range @xmath133 . the properties of these runs can be found in table [ tab : mhd ] . as in the hydro case , the kinetic energy in each strong - field mhd series spans nearly 1.5 orders of magnitude . the total energy in fluctuations , which also includes the energy in magnetic field perturbations , increases by an even larger amount from the lowest to highest mach number runs . the power law relationship between the mach number and energy injection rate is @xmath134^{-1/4 } ( { \ensuremath{\dot{e}/\bar{\rho}l^2c_s^3}})^{0.30},\ ] ] which leads to a slightly narrower range of mach numbers than does the relation for pure hydro . again , although this gives an indication of how energy dissipation scales with mach number , the exact relationship is unique to our driving method . the fraction of the kinetic energy in compressive modes for strong - field mhd is much less than for hydro . when @xmath16 , the fractions increase monotonically with mach number , from only @xmath135 for @xmath136 to @xmath137 for @xmath138 . when @xmath74 , however , the values are much less predictable . in this case , the @xmath128 and @xmath127 runs have nearly identical values when @xmath16 , whereas for hydro the fraction at low mach number was substantially smaller than the values for higher mach numbers . the ratio of the dissipation timescale to the flow crossing time at the driving scale decreases with mach number . while the values for high mach number are below unity , the low mach number values become as large as @xmath139 . the values for the highest mach numbers are roughly the same for both driving scales , but for the smaller driving scale they increase more quickly . the mach number has a strong influence on the dissipation rate of the turbulence , but even for @xmath140 the dissipation timescale does not exceed twice the flow crossing time . we next consider turbulent velocity power spectra . we compute the power spectrum ( ps ) of the velocity , @xmath141 , as well as that of its compressive and solenoidal components , @xmath142 and @xmath143 , respectively , in the same way as was done in v03 for the psd of the specific kinetic energy and its components . to generate the spherically - integrated compensated power spectra that we will present , we average @xmath144 within spherical shells and multiply by the volume within the shell , @xmath145 , to find @xmath146 , where @xmath147 . to determine the degree of anisotropy in mhd turbulence , we will also analyze cylindrically - integrated power spectra . we generate these spectra by averaging @xmath148 over cylindrical shells whose axes are oriented along the mean magnetic field direction . this yields @xmath149 , where @xmath150 is parallel to the mean magnetic field and @xmath151 is in the plane normal to the field . the majority of the power spectra we present in our figures are compensated divided by a power law to produce plots where the inertial range is very roughly horizontal , making small deviations from a power law easier to see . for each of our driven turbulence runs , we compute power spectra from many snapshots taken at regular intervals , averaging them together to minimize the effects of rare events . with the exception of the @xmath0 runs , we average over at least 69 snapshots spanning at least 4.6 dynamical times . while we averaged over 2.7 dynamical times for the @xmath0 hydro run , the mhd case is not sufficiently time - averaged . sytine et al . ( 2000 ) presented the power spectra of decaying , subsonic , adiabatic hydrodynamic turbulence at a range of resolutions . these power spectra demonstrate the formation of a feature known as the bottleneck effect . energy cascades down from larger scales but can not easily be dissipated , causing a build - up of small - scale power . we begin by verifying that athena can reproduce the bottleneck . these are the only set of adiabatic runs we will consider . the initial velocity perturbations in these decaying runs have the same form of power spectrum as in our driven runs with @xmath74 and are normalized to give an initial turbulent mach number of @xmath152 . after this impulse is given to the initially uniform ambient medium , it is allowed to evolve undisturbed until @xmath153 . figure [ fig : hdcpwr1k4res ] shows the uncompensated velocity power spectrum at this time for runs with resolutions from @xmath94 to @xmath0 . as expected , this plot appears very similar to figure 11 of sytine et al . since athena was designed to have low numerical dissipation , the bottleneck is strong in our simulations of mildly - compressible ( subsonic ) turbulence . analyzing the compressive and solenoidal components of the velocity separately , we find that the bottleneck appears quite strong in the ps of the latter while apparently absent in that of the former . this is not surprising as shocks directly couple large and small scales , allowing the compressive energy to bypass the turbulent cascade and be immediately dissipated . the absence of the bottleneck in the compressive component agrees with the results of porter et al . ( 1999 ) for mach 1 driven , adiabatic hydro turbulence . at the very highest wavenumbers in our simulations , the power in the compressive component flattens out . although this could be an artifact of the code related to its treatment of shocks , one should be wary of putting too much stock in the high-@xmath154 region of any power spectrum as effects such as aliasing ( introduced in the calculation of the power spectrum , not the fluid dynamics ) could substantially alter the power in that region ( see , e.g. , press et al . 1992 for a more detailed discussion ) . next we consider driven supersonic ( isothermal ) hydrodynamic turbulence . we compute velocity power spectra for runs with @xmath16 to maximize the separation between the driving and dissipative scales . to obtain a slightly higher turbulent mach number , @xmath155 , than before , we use an energy injection rate of @xmath15 . these are the same runs from the mach number scaling analysis of [ sec : hydmachsatresults ] . figure [ fig : hpwr1k2res ] shows our compensated time - averaged velocity power spectrum for resolutions of @xmath94 through @xmath0 . to align the dissipative range for simulations with different resolutions , we express wavenumber as a fraction of the nyquist value , @xmath156 for a simulation with resolution @xmath157 . at low resolution we see no inertial range , but by @xmath0 we have separated the driving and dissipative scales enough that we may be just starting to see an inertial range . there is a small range , @xmath158 , where we see roughly a @xmath159 power law , but we are still using a small amount of forcing up through @xmath17 so the slope in this range may be affected . we find a much longer power law range over @xmath160 , @xmath161 . although it may be argued that a slope this shallow must be due to a bottleneck , the range of scales with steeper slope is far too limited to conclude this definitively from our data . a higher resolution would be required to determine if this is actually the case . figures [ fig : hpwr1s2res ] and [ fig : hpwr1c2res ] show power spectra of the solenoidal and compressive components of velocity , respectively . for the solenoidal component , we find power laws @xmath162 and @xmath163 over the ranges @xmath158 and @xmath160 , respectively . for the compressive component , however , we find only @xmath164 over the range @xmath165 . in two independent @xmath73 simulations that use different random perturbations to seed and drive the turbulence , we find the slopes of the compressive component to agree with each other as well as that of the @xmath0 simulation to within a percent , suggesting that the length of our time - averaging is sufficient . the ratio of power in the compressive and solenoidal components of velocity is much higher than for subsonic turbulence , having the effect of slightly washing out the shallow feature in the velocity spectrum in the supersonic case . when comparing hydro turbulence with @xmath24 , we find more power at high wavenumbers for turbulence evolved using athena than using zeus . although it was stated in v03 that the bottleneck would not affect finite difference codes , plotting the compensated power spectrum shows some evidence of blending of the driving peak with a secondary bump or shallowing of the spectrum ( much less prominent than in our own ) . if this is indeed a bottleneck , this difference likely results from the greater numerical dissipation in zeus than in athena . analyzing driven strong - field mhd turbulence with @xmath16 and an energy injection rate of @xmath15 , shown in figure [ fig : mpwr1k2res ] , we again find no inertial range at low resolution . in this @xmath155 run , the velocity power spectrum is dominated by the solenoidal component , resulting in a substantial shallowing of the spectrum that is apparent in the higher - resolution runs . at @xmath73 , the slope of the spectrum over the interval @xmath166 is only slightly steeper than @xmath167 for the velocity and its solenoidal ( figure [ fig : mpwr1s2res ] ) component . we find spectral slopes in two independent @xmath73 simulations ( whose power spectra were averaged together to give that plotted in the figures ) that agree to within a few percent , suggesting that our time - averaging to obtain a reliable spectral slope . although we do not have a sufficiently long time - average to find a robust fit to the slope of the @xmath0 run , the slopes appear to be very similar . as before , the slope we have found is much shallower than is typically predicted predicted for the inertial range , while being steeper than that presented in k07 as the bottleneck spectral slope . we note that in the mhd case , the range over which we find a power law seems to increase with resolution , which one would not expect if the feature was due to numerical dissipation ( bottleneck ) . it has been argued by k07 that the quantity @xmath168 should have an inertial range power law of @xmath169 even for supersonic turbulence , but we see over a wide range of wavenumbers a @xmath170 law ( figure [ fig : mpwr1u2res ] ) . kurien et al . ( 2004 ) have shown for subsonic turbulence that , while the @xmath169 law is appropriate when the energy timescale dominates over the helicity timescale , a @xmath170 law is expected when the helicity timescale is non - negligible compared to the energy timescale , even when the relative helicity may seem insignificant . this should be investigated as a possible cause of the bottleneck effect in supersonic turbulence . over the range @xmath171 , the compressive component ( figure [ fig : mpwr1c2res ] ) of the @xmath73 run follows a power law @xmath172 . for @xmath0 run , the power spectrum appears to smoothly change slope , indicating that it is not a power law , but a longer time - average might change the shape . the power spectrum of the magnetic field at @xmath73 follows the power law @xmath173 over the range @xmath174 . at @xmath0 , the slope appears very similar , but with extra noise at the smaller wavenumbers due to the short time - average used . for all resolutions studied , the uncompensated power approaches a constant , non - zero value at the highest wavenumbers . this produces a very prominent upturn in the compensated spectra . a direct comparison for strong - field mhd with @xmath24 shows more power at high wavenumber from athena than from zeus for the velocity and its compressive and solenoidal components , just as was true for the hydro case . if the shallowing of our velocity spectrum is due to the bottleneck effect , then what appeared to be inertial range when v03 was published is likely affected by the bottleneck as well . figure [ fig : mpwrspec2d ] shows our cylindrically - integrated power spectra at @xmath73 . we find anisotropy in the power spectrum of magnetic field perturbations as well as the velocity and its solenoidal component . there is more power perpendicular to the mean magnetic field at a given wavenumber than parallel to it . parallel to the mean field , the power law is roughly @xmath175 , similar to that of the purely hydrodynamic case . perpendicular to the field , however , the slope is much more shallow , roughly @xmath170 . we find the power spectrum of the compressive component of velocity to be nearly isotropic , in contradiction to what was found in v03 . the velocity power spectrum of _ subsonic _ turbulence results from a conservative cascade of energy from large to small scales through interactions local in fourier space . it is commonly believed that the velocity spectrum of supersonic turbulence , because it too is a power law , must also result from such a cascade . it is commonly known , however , that the power spectrum of a discontinuity , or an ensemble of shocks as in burgers turbulence , also have velocity spectra that follow a power law , @xmath159 . in figure [ fig : blastcomprimh ] , we confirm that the compressive component of velocity in our @xmath94 supersonic , strong - field mhd turbulence run with @xmath16 has a spectrum similar to that of velocity in an mhd blast wave that was initially spherical . this calls into question the long - held assumption that the power spectrum seen in supersonic turbulence results from an energy cascade facilitated by interactions local in fourier space . it would seem that other diagnostics , such as structure functions , are necessary in order to determine the cause of the power law spectrum , either a fourier - space cascade as in incompressible turbulence , or an ensemble of shocks as in burgers turbulence . to get a clearer idea of which features in our power spectra are representative of the turbulence and which were introduced in the post - processing , we compare power spectra computed by multiple methods . our control spectrum will be computed as were the others presented in this section averaged over the cells within a shell and then multiplied by the volume of the shell , @xmath145 , which we will refer to as `` shell - averaged '' for the remainder of this section . our comparison will be to another commonly used method ( e.g. p07 ) , where the power is simply summed over the cells falling within the shell ( `` shell - summed '' ) . these methods differ due to the discretization of the grid , i.e. because the fourier - space volume occupied by the cells within a bin is not , in general , equal to the volume of the perfectly spherical shell that the bin represents . while the bins in our control spectrum are centered on integer values of @xmath176 , those in the alternative spectrum instead run _ between _ integer values . we use the time - averaged power spectrum of the driven strong - field mhd turbulence run at @xmath73 for our comparison , although the effect should be independent of the run being analyzed . when overplotting the spectra produced by these two methods ( see figure [ fig : psmethod ] ) , the most obvious difference is at low @xmath154 . although the shell - averaged spectrum is relatively smooth in the range @xmath177 , the other has a jagged shape over this same range resulting from its sensitivity to the number of cells falling within a bin , making the `` slope '' of the power spectrum in this region much less obvious . if we compare the shell - summed spectrum to one computed by the same method but with the bins shifted by half a bin width ( aligning these bins with our own ) , we find that shape of the spectrum at low @xmath154 changes considerably . if , on the other hand , we take the shell - averaged spectrum and compare it to one computed in the same manner but with bins shifted to align with those typically used in the shell - summed method , we see that , although the power in each bin does change , the shape and slope of the spectrum change very little . while neither method is right or wrong , we advise caution when choosing a binning method for power spectra ; differences in slope computed by different means are not necessarily indicative of different turbulent states . although molecular clouds have supersonic velocity dispersions on large scales , as one looks to smaller and smaller scales , turbulent compressions will become progressively weaker , at some point becoming subsonic . the length scale at which the rms velocity dispersion is equal to the sound speed is referred to as the sonic scale ( mckee & ostriker 2007 ) . we now investigate how the velocity dispersion varies on spatial scales larger than the sonic scale , where shocks are most important . this scaling can be determined observationally in the form of linewidth - size relations using many different methods . for example , brunt ( 2003 ) used principal component analysis ( pca ) to determine the linewidth - size relation within individual clouds . to determine the velocity dispersion at a given length scale , @xmath178 , where @xmath179 and @xmath180 is an integer , we divide our computational domain along each axis into @xmath181 sections , yielding @xmath182 sub - volumes . we compute the velocity dispersion in each sub - volume and then average over all sub - volumes at that scale . because crossing the sonic scale represents a change in the physics dominating the flow , i.e. waves steeping to form shocks , for this analysis only we will compute the velocity dispersion without mass - weighting , i.e. @xmath20^{1/2}$ ] , where @xmath183^{1/2}$ ] . figure [ fig : sonichyd ] shows the velocity dispersion versus length scale for the @xmath0 , @xmath184 driven hydrodynamic turbulence run with @xmath16 . since driving may affect the scaling relation , we truncate our driving spectrum at @xmath17 , where the driving has already dropped to only @xmath88 of the peak level , and consider only this and smaller scales . fitting to the data points falling between the sonic scale and the driving cutoff , a factor of eight in length , we find a clear power law of the form @xmath185 . this scaling index falls well within the range of indices found observationally by brunt ( 2003 ) . shown in figure [ fig : sonicmhd ] is the velocity dispersion versus length scale for the @xmath0 , @xmath184 driven strong - field mhd turbulence run with @xmath16 . this time , over the range of scales where the flow is supersonic , we find that the slope is not a power law . unlike in hydrodynamic turbulence , the sonic scale is not the only scale at which the dominant physics changes . in fact , we would expect the multiple wave families of mhd to lead to multiple transitions , and for strong fields , these transitions are widely separated . for example , parallel to the magnetic field , slow waves will travel at the sound speed , whereas fast waves will travel at the alfvn speed . perpendicular to the field , however , the slow waves will have zero velocity and the fast waves will travel with a speed @xmath186 . this is complicated further by the fact that the parallel and perpendicular directions are defined relative to the _ local _ magnetic field , not the mean field . as a result , we have no reason to expect a uniform power law between the sonic scale and driving cutoff . it is not clear to what extent this result is affected by dissipation . up to this point we have averaged quantities from multiple snapshots in order to minimize the effect of rare events on our results . our final set of diagnostics will instead be an analysis of the time - variability and temperature intermittency of the turbulent gas . we begin by analyzing the time - variability of some of the quantities we analyzed in [ sec : satresults ] . for our hydrodynamic runs with the smallest driving scale , @xmath24 , we find the time - variability of the saturation energy to be only half a percent at both @xmath94 and @xmath73 . time - variability of less than a percent agrees with the results in s98 even though they drove their turbulence impulsively . the time - variability quoted in k07 , however , is much higher . the k07 runs were driven at a much larger driving scale than our own . to investigate if this could be the reason for the discrepancy , we will also analyze the time - variability of our runs with larger driving scales . when we increase the driving scale to @xmath74 , we find the time - variability of the energy to be a full percent at both @xmath94 and @xmath73 . as both the driving scale and mach number are varied here as compared to the run we discussed above , this could be due to either . when we increase the driving scale further , to @xmath16 , without changing the mach number , we find the time - variability increases yet again , coming to @xmath93 at @xmath94 and approaching @xmath187 at @xmath73 . it would seem that the driving scale chosen has a significant impact on the time - variability of the energy . the values we find here are still less than that shown in the k07 figure , however . for strong - field mhd , we again find time - variability of about half a percent for the @xmath24 runs . increasing the driving scale to @xmath74 decreases the time - variability at @xmath94 but increases it a small amount at @xmath73 . increasing the driving scale further , to @xmath16 , yields time - variability of @xmath188 at @xmath94 and @xmath187 at @xmath73 , comparable to the hydro runs . when we compare the time - variability of the energy among hydro runs at @xmath73 with varied mach number that are driven at @xmath74 , we find that the relation is non - monotonic . with @xmath16 , however , we do see a monotonic relationship , with the time - variability increasing with mach number . for our strong - field mhd runs , we again find non - monotonicity at @xmath74 , while the time - variability increases with mach number at @xmath16 , with the exception of the lowest mach number run . a feature of turbulence that may have a strong influence on star formation is intermittency , dissipation that is highly localized in space and time ( mckee & ostriker 2007 ) . although such dissipation does not require shocks , it is worthwhile to study the shock contribution in supersonic turbulence . were we not assuming an isothermal equation of state , energy dissipation in these regions would lead to local heating and thus increased temperatures , which would be evident in observations . therefore , to study intermittency due to shocks , we analyze the maximum heating rate per unit mass , @xmath189 , a surrogate for temperature . since we expect the maximum heating rate , @xmath190 , to be strongly influenced by rare events , such as the interaction of multiple shocks , we consider the time - variability of this quantity . due to the discretization of the grid , however , we would expect a component of the time - variability to be due to grid - scale fluctuations . therefore , instead of considering @xmath190 directly , we consider the statistics of the high-@xmath191 tail of the pdf of the heating rate per unit mass . for each simulation that we consider , we compute the heating rate per unit mass , @xmath191 , in each cell over many snapshots . considering only the cells in each snapshot that compose the @xmath88 of material ( by mass or volume ) with the highest cell - averaged @xmath191 , we compute the mean value . following the time - variability of this value should allow us to ignore meaningless grid - scale fluctuations while studying the intermittency due to shocks . for driven hydrodynamic turbulence at @xmath73 , we find the low mach number runs driven at @xmath74 to have less than @xmath88 variability in the peak temperature , while the higher mach number runs with this same driving scale can have variability as large as @xmath93 but without a monotonic dependence on mach number . at the larger driving scale @xmath16 , however , the variability in the peak temperature always exceeds @xmath88 and can be as high as @xmath187 . it would seem that this , like the time - variability of the saturation energies , increases with driving scale . for our runs , the variability of the peak temperature as measured by the top @xmath88 of the volume never exceeds that from the top @xmath88 of the mass by more than a tiny amount . as we have very few data dumps with which to calculate the statistics , however , the quantitative behavior may not be robust . we find that , in @xmath73 strong - field mhd turbulence driven at @xmath16 , the variability of the peak temperature can be as large as @xmath192 . when driven at @xmath74 , however , the variability always decreases , never exceeding @xmath188 . the variability measured by the top @xmath88 of mass is typically larger than that from the top @xmath88 of volume , but there does not appear to be a strong dependence on mach number . more often than not , the variability in the strong - field mhd runs are larger than in the hydro runs at the same mach number . again , however , these statistics are computed from very few data dumps , making them subject to large errors . figure [ fig : mmitt4 ] shows the time - evolution of the peak temperature in the @xmath74 strong - field mhd run with @xmath25 , for which we have better than typical statistics , compared to the @xmath16 run with @xmath15 . the saturation energies and dissipation timescales we find support the conclusion of s98 that supersonic turbulence dissipates rapidly even in the presence of magnetic fields . the results of our godunov code agree with zeus , an operator - split method that relies on artificial viscosity to capture shocks , but reach convergence at slightly lower resolutions . at @xmath73 the difference in the total energy in fluctuations between athena and zeus for strong - field mhd is very small , indicating that these two codes converge to similar turbulent states at sufficiently high resolution . the convergence resolution of our simulations depends both on the driving scale and the presence of a magnetic field . while hydro turbulence driven at @xmath74 converges by @xmath86 , strong - field mhd turbulence driven at @xmath24 does not converge until @xmath73 . although very high resolutions are needed to capture the inertial range of the turbulence , lower resolutions are often adequate for studying the energy dissipation characteristics of the turbulence as well as other volume - integrated quantities . at high mach number , the ratio of the dissipation timescale to the flow crossing time at the driving scale increases with increasing magnetic field strength ; however , it does not exceed unity even for strong - field mhd turbulence . this ratio is independent of driving scale . the fractions of the kinetic energy in solenoidal and compressive modes are also independent of driving scale , with the compressive fraction generally being more than twice as high for hydrodynamic than for strong - field mhd turbulence . our spherically - integrated velocity power spectra for decaying , subsonic hydrodynamic turbulence show evidence of the bottleneck effect in the velocity power spectrum , consistent with the findings of sytine et al . we find more power at high wavenumber in our driven , supersonic hydro and mhd turbulence simulations than was found by v03 , but it is unclear , particularly in the mhd case , whether or not this is due to a bottleneck . resolutions exceeding @xmath0 will be necessary to draw firm conclusions about the slope of the inertial range . the cylindrically - averaged velocity power spectrum for driven mhd turbulence is very anisotropic ; it has a slope that approximates that of the hydrodynamic case parallel to the magnetic field , while perpendicular to the field it is much more shallow . the compressive component of velocity has an isotropic power spectrum , contrary to what was found in v03 . we find the compressive component of velocity in driven , supersonic mhd turbulence to have a power spectrum that is difficult to distinguish from the velocity spectrum of an initially - spherical mhd blast wave . this calls into question the long - held assumption that supersonic turbulence power spectra result from an energy cascade facilitated by interactions local in fourier space . the analysis of structure functions may be useful in determining the source of the power law spectrum in supersonic turbulence , either a fourier - space cascade as in incompressible turbulence , or an ensemble of shocks as in burgers turbulence . for hydrodynamic turbulence , we find a power law scaling of the velocity dispersion with spatial scale , @xmath193 , for scales where the velocity dispersion is supersonic . however , we find no such power law for strong - field mhd turbulence , where the sonic scale is not the only scale of interest . in this case , we find that the velocity dispersion drops off more rapidly than a power law as one approaches smaller scales . we see time - variability in the saturation energies comparable to that of the equivalent runs in s98 despite the impulsive driving employed therein . our time - variability increases when we apply our turbulent driving at larger scales , but remains lower than that shown in k07 even with @xmath16 . it is possible that the acceleration - based driving method of k07 is responsible for the difference . at this large driving scale , the time - variability increases with mach number for both hydro and strong - field mhd . the method used to drive the turbulence appears to have a substantial impact on the resulting turbulent state . further investigation should be conducted to determine how much of the increase in time - variability with driving scale is due to the limited range of scales over which an inverse cascade can occur . if the level of time - variability is determined to be a result of simulation setup and not representative of the physical system we are trying to simulate , better diagnostics or simulation methods need to be developed in order to quantify intermittency in turbulent media . although we have very poor statistics in our temperature intermittency analysis , it appears that this , too , increases with driving scale . considering the difference that the driving method makes on the results , it may be more realistic to study decaying turbulence instead of driving it arbitrarily . for identical turbulent data cubes , we find that the post - processing methods chosen significantly influence the results . the turbulent mach number changes by @xmath23 depending on the method used in its computation . the means of computing the power spectrum also has a strong influence on the power at wavenumbers overlapping with the inertial range . when comparing results published by different groups , one should keep in mind that this , as well as the code , driving method , and initial conditions , can affect the quantities being compared . although the saturation energies and energy dissipation characteristics of the turbulence converge at resolutions within our current computational capabilities , the power spectra appear to require much higher resolutions to provide valuable information . also considering that turbulent power spectra can be approximated by non - turbulent phenomena , it would seem that , for the time being , our focus should be on other diagnostics . in conducting these numerical simulations , we have made many simplifications in order to make the problem more tractable . these assumptions , however , may prove to significantly impact the results . future studies should consider non - ideal mhd in order to model low - ionization molecular clouds , a non - isothermal equation of state in order to study heating and cooling , and self - gravity in order to follow the collapse of the bound clumps that form in the turbulent medium . we thank eve ostriker for very productive discussion and tom gardiner for his invaluable assistance in bringing athena up to the task of successfully simulating supersonic turbulence . we would also like to thank alexei kritsuk , cristoph federrath , and alex lazarian for their feedback . simulations were performed on the ibm blue gene at princeton and on computational facilities supported by nsf grants ast-0216105 and ast-0722479 . the calculations presented in this paper were conducted using athena , a directionally - unsplit , higher - order godunov code . this code exactly conserves mass , momentum , and magnetic flux , as well as energy when assuming an adiabatic equation of state . the code captures shocks well and has a low level of numerical dissipation . although the full details of the algorithms and implementation can be found in the literature ( gardiner & stone 2005 , 2008 ; stone et al . 2008 ; stone & gardiner 2008 ) , we will briefly summarize here , noting any modifications made to the algorithms in order to successfully run the challenging problem of high mach number turbulence . the integration algorithm used in our calculations is a simple predictor - corrector scheme based on the muscl - hancock scheme of van leer ( 2006 ) , combined with the constrained transport method of evans & hawley ( 1998 ) to enforce the divergence - free constraint on the magnetic field ( i.e. the vl+ct algorithm described in detail in stone & gardiner 2008 ) . we find the additional diffusion associated with this scheme as compared to our ctu+ct algorithm ( described in detail in stone et al . 2008 ) to make it more robust to the strong rarefactions that arise in a highly turbulent medium . although the algorithm is formally only second - order accurate , we use third order ( piecewise parabolic ) spatial reconstruction , finding it to provide more accurate solutions in test problems due to smaller truncation error . for our isothermal hydrodynamics runs , we found there to be strong rarefactions within the turbulent medium for which an approximate riemann solver simply was not accurate enough , necessitating the use of an exact nonlinear riemann solver . for adiabatic hydrodynamics as well as isothermal and adiabatic mhd , we were able to use approximate nonlinear riemann solvers , namely hllc for the hydro case and hlld for mhd , more details about which can be found in stone et al . although we used our own adaptation of the adiabatic hlld solver of miyoshi & kusano ( 2005 ) for our isothermal mhd runs , we found it to produce turbulent states extremely similar to those from the isothermal hlld solver of mignone ( 2007 ) . although these riemann solvers are positive definite in 1d , it is not guaranteed that they will be so in multidimensions . in fact , we found that , under extreme conditions , the net mass flux out of a cell in our isothermal 3d turbulent medium occasionally exceeded the cell s initial mass . in the rare circumstance that this occurred , we recomputed the fluxes of all variables through all interfaces bordering such cells using first - order reconstruction . in our mach 7 strong - field mhd run at @xmath73 that uses @xmath16 , this affected only a fraction @xmath194 of the fluxes computed in the corrector step of the integrator . dropping to first order introduced enough diffusion in the immediate vicinity to keep the cell - averaged density positive , while having a negligible effect on the overall system . adding diffusion in this manner instead of enforcing a density floor maintains exact conservation . brunt , c.m . 2003 , apj 584 , 293 cho , j. & lazarian , a. 2003 , mnras 345 , 325 cho , j. & lazarian , a. 2005 , thcfd 19 , 127 churchwell , e. et al . 2004 , apjs 154 , 322 crutcher , r.m . 1999 , apj 520 , 706 elmegreen , b.g . & scalo , j. 2004 , araa 42 , 211 esquivel , a. , lazarian , a. , & pogosyan , d. 2003 , mnras 342 , 325 evans , c.r . & hawley , j.f . 1988 , apj 322 , 659 falgarone , e. , & philips , t.g . 1990 , apj 359 , 344 federrath , c. , klessen , r.s . , & schmidt , w. 2008 , in prep . gardiner , t.a . & stone , j.m . 2005 , jcoph 205 , 509 gardiner , t.a . & stone , j.m . 2008 , jcoph 227 , 4123 haugen , n.e.l . & brandenburg , a. 2004 , phrve 70 , 026405 kowal , g. , lazarian , a. , & beresnyak , a. 2007 , apj 658 , 423 kritsuk , a.g . , norman , m.l . , padoan , p. , & wagner , r. 2007 , apj 665 , 416 ( k07 ) kurien , s. , taylor , m.a . , & matsumoto , t. 2004 , phrve 69 , 066313 lemaster , m.n . & stone , j.m . 2008 , apjl 682 , l97 ( paper i ) mac low , m .- m . 1999 , apj 524 , 169 mac low , m .- & klessen , r.s . 2004 , rvmp 76 , 125 mckee , c.f . & ostriker , e.c . 2007 , araa 45 , 565 mignone , a. 2007 , jcoph 225 , 1427 miyoshi , t. & kusano , k. 2005 , jcoph 315 , 344 mizuno , a. , onishi , t. , yonekura , y. , nagahama , t. , ogawa , h. , & fukui , y. 1995 , apj 445 , l161 ostriker , e.c . , gammie , c.f . , & stone , j.m . 1999 , apj 513 , 259 ostriker , e.c . , stone , j.m . , & gammie , c.f . 2001 , apj 546 , 980 padoan , p. , jones , b.j.t . , & nordlund , a.p . 1997 , apj 474 , 730 padoan , p. , nordlund , a. , kritsuk , a.g . , norman , m.l . , & li , p.s . 2007 , apj 661 , 972 ( p07 ) passot , t. & vazquez - semadeni , e. 1998 , phrve , 58 , 4501 porter , d. , pouquet , a. , sytine , i. , & woodward , p. 1999 , phya 263 , 263 press , w.h . , flannery , b.r . , teukolsky , s.a . , & vetterling , w.t . 1992 , numerical recipes in c ( 2nd ed . ; cambridge : cambridge university press ) stone , j.m . , & gardiner , t.a . 2008 , newa , in press stone , j.m . , ostriker , e.c . , & gammie , c.f . 1998 , apj 508 , l99 ( s98 ) stone , j.m . , gardiner , t.a . , teuben , p. , hawley , j.f . , & simon , j. 2008 , apjs , in press ( arxiv0804.0402 ) sytine , i.v . , porter , d.h . , woodward , p.r . , hodson , s.w . , & winkler , k .- h . 2000 , jcoph 158 , 225 van leer , b. 2006 , comm . phys . 1 , 192 vestuto , j.g . , ostriker , e.c . , & stone , j.m . 2003 , apj 590 , 858 ( v03 ) Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: theoretical study of the space - time evolution of matter in high energy nuclear collisions has a long history since the early pioneering works of fermi and landau employing thermodynamics and fluid mechanics @xcite . more recent works @xcite have been motivated by the prospect of studying a new form of matter experimentally by means of very energetic collisions of heavy nuclei as those currently underway at brookhaven with relativistic heavy - ion collider ( rhic ) and planned at cern with large hadron collider ( lhc ) . the data taken from the rhic experiments has shown existence of a strong anisotropic ( elliptic ) collective flow of hadrons in non - central collisions @xcite , indicating early local equilibration of dense matter produced by the collision @xcite . this supports the hydrodynamic picture of matter evolution and gives us a hope to learn information of the equation of state of dense matter from systematic analyses of the data . much attention has been paid to the early stage of matter evolution where a dense plasma of unconfined quarks and gluons has been expected to be formed through some complex non - equilibrium processes @xcite . one anticipates also a breakdown of the hydrodynamic behavior of the system when it is diluted sufficiently and the collision time exceeds the characteristic time scale of expansion . this stage of the matter evolution is usually refered to as the freezeout stage . the aim of this work is to present a kinetic theory which is designed to describe the freezeout stage of the expanding hadron gas . the freezeout of the expanding hadronic matter would proceed in several steps ; chemical freezeout of the relative abandunce of hadron spieces may occur before the kinetic freezeout of the momentum distribution of hadrons . observed relative abandunce of hadrons fit very nicely to a simple picture that the chemical freezeout occurs at a certain temperature and baryon chemical potential @xcite . some of the other observables , such as two particle momentum correlations , the pion analogue of the hanbury brown and twiss two photon intensity interferometry , may be very sensitive to the dynamics of the final kinetic freezeout as indicated by the hbt puzzle " found in the recent data analysis @xcite . if the initial state of the dense matter formed in the collision is a plasma of deconfined quarks and gluons , freezeout of the color degrees of freedom should proceed these processes when the quark - gluon plasma hadronizes . chiral symmmetry @xcite , an approximate global symmetry of qcd which becomes exact in the limit of vanishing quark masses and is considered to be broken spontaneously in the qcd vacuum , may also play an important role in the freezeout dynamics . as a dense hadronic matter formed by ultrarelativistic nuclear collision is diluted by the expansion , one expects that the system undergoes a phase transition associated with the spontaneous breakdown of the chiral symmetry which is restored temporalily after the collision by the formation of a quark - gluon plasma . as the quark - gluon plasma hadronizes and the system turns into the confining phase , the system would gradually develop a vacuum chiral condensate and remaining excitaions would expand in the influence of the growing chiral condensate . this physical picture has been elaborated in terms of a classical equation of motion for the chiral condensate ; effects of excitations were described in terms of statistical fluctuations in the classical fields @xcite . the fluctuating condensate described by classical pion field has been termed disoriented chiral condensate ( dcc ) , emphasizing the symmetry aspect of the problem @xcite . what was missing in these classical treatments of the meson fields is the existence of particle excitations in addition to the condensate . inclusion of particle excitations requires the quantization of the fields . the effect of the quantum fluctuations of meson fields has been studied by tsue , vautherin and one of the present authors ( tm ) @xcite by the functional schrdinger picture formalism @xcite . the physical picture we have described is very similar to what happens when the dilute gas of magnetically trapped atoms of alkali metals cools down by evapolation @xcite . some of the atoms condense into the lowest single particle level in the trapping external potential forming a bose - einstein condensate . the dynamics of such a system may be described by the coupled equations of motion for the condensate , or the gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite , and the kinetic equation , or the boltzmann - vlasov equations , for the phase space distribution of the excitations in the presence of the condensate @xcite . in this paper we will show that a similar set of equations can be derived for a system of interacting mesons described by the relativistic quantum field theory by the mean field approximation . this approximation corresponds to a neglect of all correlations in the system @xcite . we will make no attempt in this work to justify this approximation and leave it as an open problem for further study . in this context we note that field theoretical derivation of a boltzmann - type kinetic equation has been given by many others @xcite . most of these works focuses on the derivation of the collision terms . the present work is distinguished from these works in the emphasis of the role of the mean field in the evolution of the system coupled with the quasi - particle excitations in the same spirit as in @xcite . we omit the effect of the quasi - particle collisions in this work . this procedure may be reasonable , at least as a first step , for describing dynamical aspect of the freeze - out process : even in the absence of collisions , interactions between the quasi - particles and the evolving condensate would affect the final particle distribution . but the present approach is not adequate , however , for the early thermalization problem , where the collision terms play essential role @xcite . we adopt the standard heisenberg picture instead of the functional schrdinger picture used in @xcite since we found it more straightforward to see the connection to familiar semi - classical kinetic equation . in this first of a series of papers we shall use one - component real scalar field model interacting via a @xmath0 self - interaction term in order to concentrate on the presentation of the basic features of the theory . analysis with multi - component scalar model with @xmath1 symmetry will be deferred for the forthcoming paper @xcite . in the next section we formulate a quantum kinetic theory for quantum scalar meson field , starting from the heisenberg equations for quantum field of one - component real scalar . the mean field approximation replaces the products of quantum fields by the products of classical fields and the statistical average of bilinear forms of the quantum fluctuations . the latter is expressed in terms of the wigner functions which is reduced to the single particle distribution function in the classical boltzmann equation . our theory contains another forms of the wigner functions which have no classical counter parts and arises due to the coherent pair creation and annihilation processes in non - uniform systems . only in uniform systems , these _ off - diagonal _ components of the fluctuation can be eliminated by suitable redefinition of the particle mass . appearance of the off - diagonal wigner functions is reminiscent of the anomalous propagators in the microscopic theory of superconductivity @xcite . similar structure also appears in the theory of bose - einstein condensate @xcite . some details of the mean field calculation is given in appendix . in section 3 , we apply our method to uniform systems and show that each mode characterized by the particle momentum obeys non - linear forced oscillatory motion . in section 4 we show that in equilibrium these kinetic equations are reduced to a gap equation @xcite which determine the equilibrium amplitude of the condensate and the mass parameter as a function of the temperature . in this paper , we ignore the effect of the divergent vacuum polarizations which requires a subtle renormalization procedure in the mean field approximation @xcite . the solution exhibits characteristic features of the first order phase transition . in section 5 , we study slowly varying non - uniform systems . taking long wavelength approximation , the equations of motion of the diagonal components of the wigner functions are reduced to a vlasov equation in a form generalized by landau for quasi - particles excitations in quantum fermi liquid @xcite with the quasi - particle energy given in the mean field approximation . non - vanishing off - diagonal components of the wigner functions generate extra terms in the vlasov equation which may be interpreted as particle source and sink terms . in section 6 , we compute the dispersion relations of excitations of the system near equilibrium . solving the coupled kinetic equations by linearizing the equations with respect to small oscillatory deviations from equilibrium solution we obtain dispersion relation of the excitation modes in the system near equilibrium . we find the continuum of quasi - particle excitations in the entire space - like energy - momentum region in addition to the continuum in time - like region due to the ( thermally induced ) pair creation . we found that in the low temperature phase the meson pole shifts due to the coupling to the quasi - particle continua . the effective meson mass vanishes at the edge of the spinodal instability line of the first order transition . meson mode has been studied first by hatsuda and kunihiro as a precursory phenomenon of the chiral phase transition using the nambu - jona - lasinio model with quark fields.@xcite ] we also found that the coupling of the off - diagonal components of the wigner function plays an important role to prevent appearance of undamped tachyonic sound mode which propagates with a velocity greater than that of light . a short summary of the paper is given in section 7 with remarks on the remaining problems . in this section we derive quantum kinetic equations which describes the time evolution of the meson condensate coupled with mesonic quasi - particle excitations . we use the natural unit @xmath2 throughout this paper . we first take a simple model of a self - interacting real scalar field in the heisenberg picture . the hamiltonian is given by @xmath3 \right]\ ] ] where @xmath4 = \frac{1}{2 } m^2 { { \hat \phi}}^2 + \frac{\lambda}{4 ! } { { \hat \phi}}^4 .\ ] ] here the scalar field @xmath5 and its canonical conjugate momentum field @xmath6 are quantized by the equal - time commutation relations : @xmath7 & = & i \delta ( { { \mathbf r}}- { { \mathbf r } } ' ) \\ \left [ { { \hat \phi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) , { { \hat \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } ' , t ) \right ] & = & [ { { \hat \pi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) , { { \hat \pi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } ' , t ) ] = 0 \ ] ] the heisenberg equation of motion of the quantum field @xmath8 is given by @xmath9 = { { \hat \pi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \ ] ] while the equation of motion of the canonical conjugate field @xmath10 becomes @xmath11 = ( \nabla^2 - m^2 ) { { \hat \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) - \frac{1}{3 ! } \lambda { { \hat \phi}}^3 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \ ] ] elimination of the field momentum @xmath6 from these equations yields a modified klein - gordon equation for the quantum scalar field @xmath5 : @xmath12 where @xmath13 . we are interested in the time evolution of the system described by the density operator @xmath14 where @xmath15 are a set of normalized wave functions and @xmath16 is the probability distribution for a mixed state described by this density matrix so that it satisfies @xmath17 this density matrix can be also expressed in terms of some complete set @xmath18 of the wave functions of our hilbert - fock space as @xmath19 where @xmath20 all physical information of the system to be described are contained in a specific form of the density matrix . in thermodynamic equilibrium , the density matrix is given by @xmath21 with @xmath22 = e^{\beta f ( t ) } \ ] ] where @xmath23 gives the helmholtz free energy of the system at temperature @xmath24 . in the heisenberg picture the density matrix is time - independent since the wave functions are time - independent ; all time dependence arises from the time dependence of an operator : @xmath25\ ] ] for example , we define the classical condensate fields by the statistical average of the quantum fields , @xmath26 in the following we take a gaussian ansatz for the density matrix : @xmath27 and @xmath28 where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are shifted field operators defined by @xmath31 the shifted field operators obey the same equal - time commutation relations as the original fields : @xmath32 & = & i \delta ( { { \mathbf r}}- { { \mathbf r } } ' ) \label{q1 } \\ \left [ { { \tilde \phi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) , { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } ' , t ) \right ] & = & [ { { \tilde \pi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) , { { \tilde \pi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } ' , t ) ] = 0 \label{q2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we will show that this choice of the density matrix is a non - equilibrium generalization of the hartree approximation in equilibrium . it has been alternatively introduced in the functional schrdinger representation @xcite we introduce the one - particle wigner function by @xmath33 here the particle creation and annihilation operators may be defined in terms of the fourier transforms of the shifted fields @xmath34 as @xmath35 \\ a^\dagger_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) & = & \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 { { \omega_{{\mathbf p } } } } } } \left [ { { \omega_{{\mathbf p}}}}{{\tilde \phi}}_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) - i { { \tilde \pi}}_{- { { \mathbf p } } } ( t ) \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath36 these relations are rewritten as : @xmath37 \\ { { \tilde \pi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) & = & i \sum_{{\mathbf p}}e^{i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r } } } \sqrt{\frac{{{\omega_{{\mathbf p}}}}}{2 } } \left [ a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) - a_{-{{\mathbf p } } } ( t ) \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quantization rules ( [ q1 ] , [ q2 ] ) are transcribed to @xmath38 & = & \delta_{{{\mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf p } } ' } \\ \left [ a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) , a_{{{\mathbf p } } ' } \right ( t ) ] & = & [ a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) , a_{{{\mathbf p}}'}^\dagger ( t ) ] = 0 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] with which we may interpret @xmath39 ( @xmath40 ) as annihilation ( creation ) operator of particle excitation " with momentum @xmath41 . we also introduce the following other forms of the wigner functions : @xmath42 these wigner functions are not independent but are related to each other . the complex conjugate of the wigner functions are given by @xmath43 where the asterisk ( @xmath44 ) stands for the complex conjugate . the commutation relations imply also that @xmath45 and @xmath46 are even functions of @xmath41 @xmath47 and @xmath48 the four wigner functions may be grouped together to form a matrix form of the wigner function @xmath49 the appearance of the off - diagonal " components of the wigner functions is reminiscent of the anomalous propagators in the bcs theory of superconductivity which arises due to the presence of fermion pair condensate @xcite . note that our definition of the matrix components of the wigner function is slightly different from those for the propagators . we write the fourier transforms of the wigner functions as @xmath50 the ( [ fstar ] ) and ( [ fbarstar ] ) imply that @xmath51 and @xmath52 are real functions and are related to each other by @xmath53 while ( [ gstar ] ) implies that @xmath54 and @xmath55 are complex conjugate to each other : @xmath56 here we have chosen the particle mass " @xmath57 to be different from the mass parameter @xmath58 in the original hamiltonian . physical particle mass for interacting fields is generally different from the mass parameter in the hamiltonian or lagrangian due to the effect of interaction , e.g. renormalization with or without the spontaneous symmetry breaking . it may also depend on the physical conditions described by the statistical average with the density matrix @xmath59 . since we are interested in non - equilibrium time - evolution of the system where the physical particle mass may not have a definite meaning in the intermediate states , we consider here @xmath57 just as a parameter to be chosen at our discretion , for an appropriate choice of the initial conditions specified by the gaussian density matrix . a different choice of this mass parameter would give different definition for particle excitations " ; the wigner functions thus depend on the particular choice of the mass parameter . suppose we take a different particle mass @xmath60 to define the particle creation and annihilation operators @xmath61 \\ b^\dagger_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) & = & \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 { { \omega_{{\mathbf p } } } } ' } } \left [ { { \omega_{{\mathbf p } } } } ' { { \tilde \phi}}_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) - i { { \tilde \pi}}_{- { { \mathbf p } } } ( t ) \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath62 these new particle creation and annihilation operators should also obey the commutation relations , @xmath63 & = & \delta_{{{\mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf p } } ' } \\ \left [ b_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) , b_{{{\mathbf p } } ' } \right ( t ) ] & = & [ b_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) , b_{{{\mathbf p}}'}^\dagger ( t ) ] = 0 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that they are related to the original ones by the bogoliubov transformation : @xmath64 where the real parameter @xmath65 is determined by requiring that they describe the same fields : @xmath66 = \sum_{{\mathbf p}}\frac{e^{i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r } } } } { \sqrt{2 \omega'_{{\mathbf p } } } } \cdot \left [ b_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) + b_{-{{\mathbf p}}}^\dagger ( t ) \right ] \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] and this gives @xmath67 or @xmath68 the new wigner functions defined by replacing the creation and annihilation by the new ones are related to the original wigner functions by : @xmath69 where @xmath70 with @xmath71 for a small change of the mass parameter @xmath72 the wigner function will change by @xmath73 in particular , @xmath74 in uniform equilibrium system the mass parameter may be chosen to `` diagonalize '' the one - body mean field hamiltonian . as will be shown later , this procedure will lead to the well - known gap equation , a self - consistency condition to determine @xmath57 . if the system is slowly changing in time , one may still use such procedures adjusted to slowly varying quasi - equiliblium conditions , introducing a time dependent effective mass as a dynamical parameter to describe such adiabatic process . for such calculations , the relation ( [ df ] ) may be used to describe the adiabatic change of the wigner functions by the change of the mass parameter . in more general non - equilibrium situations as we expect to encounter at the freeze - out stage of expanding matter , however , there may be no such appropriate condition to determine the mass parameter . the situation could even be worse : if the system goes through unstable state with respect to small fluctuation of the field , then the adiabatically determined mass parameter would become pure imaginary , reflecting the extremum , instead of the minimum , of the effective potential . in such case we may keep the value of @xmath57 at a certain real value reflecting initial conditions . the instability would then show up as appearance of a growing solution to our kinetic equations ; which would eventually be stabilized by the non - linear interaction . to extract the physical information , such as the particle distribution in the final asymptotic state , we should use the wigner function defined with the physical particle mass in the vacuum . but these asymptotic physical wigner functions may be calculated from the wigner functions with a different choice of the mass parameter by the relation ( [ rotation ] ) . the equation of motion of the classical mean field @xmath75 is obtained by taking the quantum statistical average of the field equation ( [ kg ] ) . with the gaussian ansatz for the density matrix , we find @xmath76\ ] ] this equation corresponds to the non - linear schdinger equation ( also called the gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite ) in the theory of bose - einstein condensates . so we may call this equation _ non - linear klein - gordon equation_. the non - linearity arises due to the self - interaction of the classical field @xmath75 ( condensate ) and also due to the interaction with fluctuations @xmath77 which also depends on @xmath75 implicitly . the latter may be interpreted as due to particle excitations " , since the fluctuation can be expressed by the wigner functions as @xmath78 \label{phi2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the time - evolution of the classical mean field @xmath79 is thus coupled with the time - evolution of the wigner functions . to derive the equation of motion of the wigner functions , we need to compute the time - derivative of the bilinear forms of the operators @xmath80 and @xmath81 which in turn requires computation of the commutators of these operators with the hamiltonian . we decompose the original hamiltonian as @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the classical hamiltonian obtained from @xmath84 by replacing the quantum fields by their classical expectation values and @xmath85 contain the @xmath86-thrth power of the quantum fluctuation @xmath5 ( or @xmath39 and @xmath87 ) . a straightforward calculation yields @xmath88 \\ h_2 & = & \int d { { \mathbf r}}\left [ \frac{1}{2 } { { \tilde \pi}}^2 + \frac{1}{2 } ( \nabla { { \tilde \phi}})^2 + \frac{1}{2 } m^2 { { \tilde \phi}}^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { { \tilde \phi}}^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \right ] \\ h_3 & = & \frac{\lambda}{3 ! } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { { \tilde \phi}}^3 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \\ h_4 & = & \frac{\lambda}{4 ! } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{{\tilde \phi}}^4 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] the commutators of bilinear forms of @xmath80 and @xmath81 with @xmath89 vanish and the commutators with @xmath90 would give either a linear term or the third power of the fluctuation , both of which may vanish when taking the average with the gaussian density matrix . what remain to be computed are then the commutators with @xmath91 and with @xmath92 . they will give either the bilinear form of @xmath80 and @xmath87 or the fourth power of the fluctuations . the gaussian average of the resultant equations of motion of the bilinear field operators would give the desired equations of motion of the wigner functions . details of this computation is given in appendix a. the resultant equation of motion of the wigner functions may be obtained more easily by introducing the mean field hamiltonian defined by @xmath93 \nonumber \\ & = & \int d { { \mathbf r}}\left [ \frac{1}{2 } { { \tilde \pi}}^2 + \frac{1}{2 } ( \nabla { { \tilde \phi}})^2 + \frac{1}{2 } \mu^2 { { \tilde \phi}}^2 + \frac{1}{2 } { { \delta \pi } } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { { \tilde \phi}}^2 \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath94 and @xmath95 in the momentum representation this mean field hamiltonian may be written as @xmath96 where @xmath97 the commutator of a bilinear operator product of @xmath39 and @xmath87 with this mean - field hamiltonian is given by @xmath98 & = & - ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } - \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } - \sum_{{\mathbf q}}{{\delta \pi}}_{{\mathbf q}}\cdot \frac { ( a_{-{{\mathbf p}}_1-{{\mathbf q } } } + a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } { \sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q } } } } \sqrt{2\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \sum_{{\mathbf q}}{{\delta \pi}}_{{\mathbf q}}\cdot \frac{a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } + a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_2 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) } { \sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } } \sqrt{2\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } } } \ ] ] we show in appendix that the quantum statistical average of this commutator with the gaussian density matrix gives precisely the same result for the same statistical average of the commutator with the original hamiltonian : @xmath99 { \rangle}= { \langle } [ a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } , h ] { \rangle}\ ] ] therefore one can compute the equations of motion of the wigner functions using this effective hamiltonian , @xmath100 { \rangle}= { \langle } [ a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}+ { { \mathbf k}}/2 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}- { { \mathbf k}}/2 } , h_{\rm mf } ] { \rangle}\ ] ] using this we find , @xmath101 equations of motion of other three wigner functions @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 can be also computed from the commution relations of the product operators @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , with the mean field hamiltonian @xmath108 , respectively : we obtain @xmath109 and the equation of motion of @xmath110 can be obtained from ( [ eomf ] ) by the substitution @xmath111 : @xmath112 these equations form a closed system of coupled differential equations with the non - linear klein - gordon equation ( [ nlkg ] ) which may be rewritten as @xmath113 these four equations of motion of the wigner function may be combined into a single matrix form as @xmath114 for a uniform system , we expect that the classical mean field and the self - energy become functions only of time : @xmath115 thus the non - linear klein - gordon equation ( [ nlkg ] ) becomes @xmath116 and the mean - field hamiltonian is reduced to @xmath117 in this case the wigner functions contain non - vanishing components only for the diagonal elements ( @xmath118 ) so that they may be written as @xmath119 then the equations of motion of the wigner functions become @xmath120 these coupled equations have a time - independent solution of the form @xmath121 with @xmath122 thus if we define the particle mass @xmath57 so as to satisfy @xmath123 , then two components of the wigner functions @xmath124 and @xmath125 vanish for all @xmath41 . in this case , @xmath126 may be interpreted as the momentum distribution of physical particle excitations . to find time - dependent solutions , we write @xmath127 and rewrite the equations as @xmath128 these equations are to be solved together with the non - linear klein - gordon equation ( [ nlkg0 ] ) with @xmath129\ ] ] from these equations we can derive second order differential equation : @xmath130 with @xmath131\ ] ] we observe that each of these coupled equations looks like an equation of a forced oscillator . for example the frequency of the oscillator @xmath132 is given by @xmath133 while the frequency of the oscillator @xmath134 is given by @xmath135 so that @xmath134 oscillates much rapidly than @xmath132 . the coupling of these oscillators may produce an interesting interesting effects which may be studied by numerical integration . in statistical equilibrium , we have the bose distribution @xmath136 together with @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the inverse temperature . the condition of vanishing @xmath139 implies from ( [ self ] ) @xmath140 where the thermal fluctuation of the quantum field is given by the relation ( [ phi2 ] ) as @xmath141 on the other hand , the condensate amplitude @xmath142 in equilibrium should also satisfy the static non - linear klein - gordon equation , @xmath143\ ] ] from these two conditions , we find , for @xmath144 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 we note that , since the thermal distribution @xmath147 depends on the mass ( gap ) parameter @xmath57 through @xmath148 , the equation ( [ gap ] ) determines the mass parameter @xmath57 self - consistently as a function of the temperature . this equation is called the _ gap equation _ @xcite . as the temperature increases the mass gap @xmath57 and the condensate amplitude @xmath142 decreases and vanishes at high temperature . to find the behavior of the mass parameter as a function of the temperature we can use the following formula @xcite for the integral of the bose distribution function : @xmath149 where the dimensionless function @xmath150 is given as @xmath151 ( @xmath152 is euler s number ) . the gap equation ( [ gap ] ) has a solution @xmath153 at @xmath154 determined by @xmath155 however the solution exhibits the behavior of the first order transition due to the non - analytic behavior of the function @xmath156 @xcite . this is a generic feature of the mean field approximation @xcite which may be a theoretical artifact and may not survive the inclusion of correlations missing in the mean field approximation . an improvement of the mean field approximation has been proposed in @xcite and later it has been shown to lead to the second order transition in two - loop approximations @xcite . for @xmath157 ( dashed line ) and @xmath158 ( solid line ) ] in fig . 1 we plot @xmath142 as determined by ( [ phi0 ] ) as a function of temperature . it shows a behavior characteristic of the first order phase transition : there is a region @xmath159 where there are three solutions of ( [ phi0 ] ) , one at @xmath160 and other two at @xmath161 as well as @xmath162 . one expects that two solutions @xmath163 and @xmath163 correspond to two local minima of the effective potential @xmath164 while the other one @xmath165 corresponds to the local maximum of @xmath166 . indeed we can show this explicitly by constructing the effective potential @xmath167 by demanding that the local extremal condition @xmath168 coincides with the condition ( [ phi0 ] ) . @xmath169 the integration of the first two terms are trivial . beside irrelevant integration constant , which we may choose to be zero , we obtain @xmath170 to carry out the remaining integral over @xmath171 we demand that the mass parameter @xmath57 depends on @xmath171 through the relation @xmath172 which appears to be equivalent to the condition ( [ mu20 ] ) , but we assume that this relation holds not only for the equilibrium value of @xmath171 , namely at @xmath173 , but also for any value of @xmath171 . noting @xmath174 which results from ( [ mu2 ] ) , we transform the integration variable from @xmath171 to @xmath175 : @xmath176 remaining integral over @xmath175 can be carried out as @xmath177 = - \sum_{{\mathbf p}}\frac{{{\mathbf p}}^2}{3 \omega_{{\mathbf p } } } f_{\rm eq . } ( { { \mathbf p}})\ ] ] where in deriving the final expression we performed integration by part in @xmath178 and omitted again the irrelevant integration constant . to sum up , we find the following expression for the effective potential : @xmath179 where @xmath171 dependence of the last two terms are implicitly given from the @xmath171-dependence of @xmath57 . we note that this result coincides , in the neglect of the renormalization effects due to the meson mass shift , with the effective potential obtained by amelino - camelia and pi @xcite using the cornwall - jackiw - tombolis ( cjt ) composite operator effective potential formalism @xcite , we note that our mass parameter @xmath57 corresponds to the variational mass parameter @xmath180 of the cjt potential . the third term may be interpreted as the pressure of an ideal gas of the quasi - particles obeying the dispersion @xmath181 . the effective potential given by the formula ( [ veff ] ) takes in general a complex value since @xmath175 becomes negative at low temperature and at small value of @xmath171 . at low temperatures the potential develops a second local minimum at non - zero value of @xmath171 , which becomes the absolute minimum below certain temperature @xmath182 where the first order transition takes place in equilibrium and the order parameter @xmath142 jumps discontinuously from @xmath183 to @xmath142 as the temperature is lowered in the presence of inhomogeneity the wigner functions acquire non - vanishing elements with @xmath184 . if we assume that this inhomogeneity are due to the long - wavelength fluctuations in the system , @xmath185 in this case we can obtain a familiar form of the vlasov equation @xcite from the equation of motion of the wigner function by the procedure usually referred to as the gradient expansion @xcite . to show this we make the following approximations : @xmath186 and @xmath187 we also make use of the taylor expansion of the wigner functions : @xmath188 then the equations of motion ( [ eomf ] ) of the wigner function @xmath189 becomes @xmath190 on the right hand side , the first term and the second term are disguised forms of the drift term and the vlasov term respectively . to obtain more familiar form we make the fourier transforms ( 42 ) and ( 43 ) of the wigner functions . then we find @xmath191 now it is clear that the first term is the drift term which describes the change of the particle position by the drift with the velocity @xmath192 . the second term can be interpreted as the vlasov term which represents the change of particle momentum due to the continuous acceleration by the velocity dependent equivalent potential , @xmath193 acting on the particle . the third term appears to be the correction to the drift term due to the local change of particle mass @xmath194 which causes change in particle velocity . other three terms are associated with the other components of the wigner function and has no counter parts in non - relativistic vlasov equation . noting that @xmath195 and @xmath196 the above equation may be rewritten in a more compact form : @xmath197 where @xmath198 and @xmath199 the quantity @xmath200 plays the same role as the quasi - particle energy which appears in the kinetic equation of landau s fermi - liquid theory @xcite . we note that because of the relation ( [ gstar - gbar ] ) , @xmath201 is a pure imaginary function , while @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath204 , and @xmath200 are all real functions . in the long wavelength approximation , the equation of motion of @xmath45 becomes @xmath205 which may be rewritten for the fourier transforms in a compact form as @xmath206 where @xmath207 . thus the kinetic equation for @xmath54 does not look like a vlasov equation ; it takes a form of a simple oscillator equation with the oscillator frequency @xmath208 exposed to the external perturbation created by the particle distribution @xmath209 . similar equation is derived for @xmath210 which is the complex conjugate of @xmath54 . taking the complex conjugate of the eq . ( [ g - eq ] ) , we obtain the kinetic equation for @xmath211 : @xmath212 adding or subtracting ( [ g - eq ] ) and ( [ gbar - eq ] ) , we find for the real function @xmath213 and the pure imaginary function @xmath214 @xmath215 in the long wavelength approximation , we also have @xmath216 \nonumber \\ & = & \sum_{{\mathbf p}}\frac{1}{2\omega_{{\mathbf p } } } \left [ f_+ ( { { \mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf r } } , t ) + g_+ ( { { \mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] which appears in the non - linear klein - gordon equation ( [ nlkg ] ) for the condensate and in the self energy term ( [ pi ] ) in the vlasov equation . we now apply our coupled kinetic equations , consisting of the non - linear klein - gordon equation and the vlasov equations , to find a dispersion relation of the excitations in the system near equilibrium . the dispersion relations of the excitations of the finite temperature system may be computed using the propagator ( two - time ) formalism , either with real - times ( schwinger - keldysh ) formalism @xcite or with imaginary - times ( matsubara ) formalism with subsequent analytic continuation @xcite . although such calculations have been performed by various authors@xcitenumerical results have been presented focusing on the time - like region of the spectral functions . we study with our kinetic theory the entire range of the @xmath217 plane including the space - like excitations of the system . as has been shown by one of the present authors @xcite the calculation of the zero sound mode in the degenerate fermi liquid using the relativistic landau kinetic equation@xcite , similar to ours , reproduces the same result as the propagator theory in the long wavelength limits . we thus expect that our result may also reproduce the long wavelength behaviors of the excitations obtained from the propagator theory . for this purpose we assume that the distribution functions consist of uniform equilibrium term and a small deviation from it : @xmath218 where @xmath219 we also assume the mean meson field consists of uniform equilibrium term and a deviation from it @xmath220 where @xmath142 is determined by the static non - linear klein - gordon equation ( [ phi0 ] ) together with the solution of the gap equation ( [ gap ] ) for the mass gap @xmath57 . linearization of the non - linear klein - gordon equation with respect to @xmath221 yields @xmath222 \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the thermal fluctuation of the quantum field in equilibrium is given by @xmath141 and the deviation @xmath223 is expressed in term of the small deviation of the distribution function from equilibrium value . @xmath224 \nonumber \\ & = & \sum_{{\mathbf p}}\frac{1}{2\omega_{{\mathbf p } } } \left [ \delta f ( { { \mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf r } } , t ) + \delta f ( - { { \mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf r } } , t ) + \delta g ( { { \mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf r } } , t ) + \delta g^ * ( { { \mathbf p } } , { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \right ] \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in deriving the last line we have used @xmath225 which follow from ( [ fbar ] ) and ( [ gbar ] ) respectively . by the linearization with respect to the small increments , @xmath226 , @xmath227 , the vlasov equations become @xmath228 the right hand side of the vlasov equation ( [ vlasov1 ] ) vanishes because @xmath229 vanishes in equilibrium . the fluctuation in the mean field potential @xmath230 which appears in these equations is related to the fluctuations of the condensate amplitude and the distribution functions @xmath231 the linearized klein - gordon equation ( [ linkg ] ) and the linearized vlasov equations ( [ lin - vlasov1 ] ) and ( [ lin - vlasov2 ] ) , supplimented by the constitutive relations " ( [ deltau ] ) and ( [ deltaphi2 ] ) , form a closed set of equations to determine a small fluctuation propagating the system in equilibrium . noting that @xmath232 and @xmath233 are real functions , we seek a solution in the form : @xmath234 where we have introduced the landau prescription @xcite , @xmath235 with a positive infinitesimally small constant @xmath236 , to set an adiabatic switching - on of the fluctuation , namely @xmath237 , @xmath238 all vanish slowly as @xmath239 . the constitutive relations for the fluctuations ( [ deltaphi2 ] ) and the mean field potential ( [ deltau ] ) now read @xmath240 and @xmath241 e^ { i ( { { \mathbf k}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}- \omega_+ t ) } \nonumber \\ & & \quad + \frac{\lambda}{2\omega_{{\mathbf p } } } \left [ 2 \phi^*_0 \delta \phi^ * + \sum_{{\mathbf p}}\frac{1}{2\omega_{{\mathbf p } } } \left ( \delta f^*_{{\mathbf p}}+ \delta f^ * _ { - { { \mathbf p } } } + \delta g^*_{{\mathbf p}}+ \delta g_{-{{\mathbf p } } } \right ) \right ] e^ { - i ( { { \mathbf k}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}- \omega_- t ) } \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . using these relations , we find from the linearized klein - gordon equation ( [ linkg ] ) , @xmath242 \delta \phi = - \frac{1}{2 } \lambda \phi_0 \sum_{{\mathbf p}}\frac{1}{2\omega_{{\mathbf p } } } \left [ \delta f_{{\mathbf p}}+ \delta f_{-{{\mathbf p } } } + \delta g_{{\mathbf p}}+ \delta g^*_{-{{\mathbf p } } } \right ] , \ ] ] and its complex conjugate relation , where we have used the equilibrium relation @xmath243 also , from the linearized vlasov equations we obtain @xmath244 \nonumber \\ & & \qquad \qquad \times \left ( 1 + f_{\rm eq . } ( { { \mathbf p } } ) \right ) f_{\rm eq . } ( { { \mathbf p } } ) \nonumber \\ \label{deltaf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath245 f_{\rm eq . } ( { { \mathbf p } } ) \nonumber \\ \label{deltag}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath246 using ( [ deltaphi ] ) , we eliminate @xmath247 in ( [ deltaf ] ) and ( [ deltag ] ) and find @xmath248 where we have introduced the notation @xmath249 for the deviation of the fluctuation . solving ( [ df ] ) and ( [ dg ] ) for @xmath250 and @xmath251 respectively , and inserting the results into ( [ f ] ) we obtain the relation @xmath252 where @xmath253 ~. \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying the prescription , @xmath254 with @xmath255 implying that the principal part should be taken in integration , we find that @xmath256 consists of the real and imaginary parts : @xmath257 the real part is given by @xmath258 with @xmath259 ~ , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the imaginary part is given by @xmath260 with @xmath261 \nonumber \\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the integration can be carried out analytically , yielding @xmath262 for @xmath263 . the values of this function for @xmath264 can be found by noting that it is an odd function of @xmath265 . the first term in ( [ phi2 ] ) corresponds to the space - like ( scattering ) continuum with @xmath266 . while the second term corresponds to the continuum of thermally induced pair creation / annihilation of mesons with energy @xmath267 , the function @xmath268 ( and @xmath269 ) has non - vanishing supports in the regions on @xmath217 plane as indicated by the shaded areas in fig . 2 . we plotted in fig . 3 @xmath270 and @xmath268 as functions of @xmath271 at @xmath272 for two different values of @xmath273 . and @xmath268 have non - vanishing value is shown by shaded areas ( two - quasi - particle continua ) . the solid hyperbola corresponding to the meson poles ( @xmath274 ) on which @xmath269 has a @xmath275-function singularity in the low temperature phase . the shaded area in the time - like region below the curve @xmath276 is only an artifact of the long wavelength approximation . ] and @xmath277 as a function of @xmath271 at @xmath278 and @xmath279 ( dashed line ) , @xmath280 ( solid line ) . both @xmath281 and @xmath282 vanish at @xmath283 . @xmath282 also vanishes at the pair creation threshold @xmath284 ( in the long wavelength approximation ) while @xmath281 has a cusp at this point.,title="fig : " ] and @xmath277 as a function of @xmath271 at @xmath278 and @xmath279 ( dashed line ) , @xmath280 ( solid line ) . both @xmath281 and @xmath282 vanish at @xmath283 . @xmath282 also vanishes at the pair creation threshold @xmath284 ( in the long wavelength approximation ) while @xmath281 has a cusp at this point.,title="fig : " ] the condition @xmath285 which follows from ( [ omegaf ] ) determines the dispersion relation of a possible long wavelength collective excitation of the system . before examining the solutions of the dispersion relation ( [ dispersion ] ) . we note that at zero temperature , namely in the absence of quasi - particle excitations , the only solution of our coupled kinetic equations is the one which satisfies the linearized klein - gordon equation ( [ linkg ] ) or ( [ deltaphi ] ) with @xmath286 and @xmath287 . this gives a simple meson pole @xmath288 which appears in the time - like region ( @xmath289 ) . there is no space - like mode of excitations in the absence of quasi - particle excitations due to the mass gap ( @xmath290 ) for the excitations of the vacuum . the situation is different in the case of the ordinary bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) which possesses , even at zero temperature , a low - lying acoustic mode ( bogoliubov phonon ) in the mean - field approximation to repulsive two - body contact interaction@xcite . the ordinary bec contains space - like quasi - particle excitations even at absolute zero temperature which corresponds to the excitation of one of the zero energy particles forming the condensate . the bogoliubov phonon is a collective excitation of such space - like quasi - particle excitation modes modified by the repulsive mean - field interaction . at finite non - zero temperature , the system contains continuum of the space - like excitations for all @xmath291 satisfying @xmath292 as signified by the non - vanishing value of @xmath293 in addition to the continuum in the time - like region @xmath294 . ( see fig . 2 ) any solution of ( [ dispersion ] ) in the space - like region therefore is subject to the collisionless dissipation known as the landau damping@xcite . we plot the function @xmath295 in fig . 4 as a function of @xmath265 at fixed value of @xmath272 . in the low temperature phase , it contains a singularity at the position of the mesonic pole at @xmath296 while this singularity disappears in the high temperature phase . in the presence of the condensate , a disturbance in the quasi - particle distribution may be absorbed into an excitation of the condensate which then propagates with the mesonic dispersion relation and is converted back again to the quasi - particle excitations . this coupling between the condensate and the quasiparticle excitations generates a collective mode in the low temperature phase.he due to the excitation of the condensate coupled with quasi - particle excitations . ] in the high temperature phase , the quasi - particle excitations couple each other only through their direct interaction , hence no mixing with single mesonic pole . the high temperature behavior of @xmath297 is the same as that of the function @xmath281 : it is negative at @xmath298 and increases with @xmath265 and reaches a positive maximum slightly below @xmath283 . in the low temperature phase , @xmath295 reverts the sign for @xmath265 below this singularity . one may interpret that effective coupling strength @xmath299 changes its sign below the meson pole . note that here we have used the relation @xmath300 ( 111 ) for the condensate amplitude . we note that @xmath301 always vanishes at @xmath283 since @xmath302 . the cusp at @xmath284 appears at the threshold of the two quasiparticle creation . the condition ( [ dispersion ] ) is fulfilled only near the meson pole in the low temperature phase and it gives a shift of the mesonic excitation spectrum . we could not find any additional solution satisfying ( [ dispersion ] ) . we like to note here that without the coupling to the fluctuations to pair creation or annihilation , we would not have gotten the first term in the function @xmath270 and then @xmath303 would have become 1 at @xmath304 creating a undamped tachyonic sound mode . hence the off - diaginal wigner functions plays an important role in making our framework consistent with causality . as a function of @xmath271 at fixed @xmath305,title="fig : " ] as a function of @xmath271 at fixed @xmath305,title="fig : " ] we introduce the `` response function '' defined by @xmath306 = - \frac { \omega_2 ( \omega , \mu ) } { \left[1 - \omega_1(\omega , \mu ) \right]^2 + \left [ \omega_2 ( \omega , \mu ) \right]^2}\ ] ] it is plotted in fig . 5 as a function of @xmath265 and compared with the `` bare '' response function given by @xmath307 the response function in the space - like momentum region gives the dynamic form factor of the cross section of the scattering of particles coupled to the excitations of the system @xcite , while its time - like component may give the rate of pair annihilation of the quasi - particles . we note that in the low temperature phase the response function changes its sign below the meson pole due to the sign change of the effective coupling ( [ lambda ] ) . we observe some enhancement ( depletion ) of the strength in the time - like pair annihilation near threshold and small depletion ( enhancement ) in the space - like region in the low ( high ) temperature phase . ( [ response ] ) ( solid lines ) at @xmath278 . for comparison the bare response function @xmath308 is also shown ( dashed lines ) . note that in the low temperature phase @xmath309 changes sign in the space - like region and at the meson pole ( @xmath310 ) due to the sign change of the effective coupling strength ( [ lambda]).,title="fig : " ] ( [ response ] ) ( solid lines ) at @xmath278 . for comparison the bare response function @xmath308 is also shown ( dashed lines ) . note that in the low temperature phase @xmath309 changes sign in the space - like region and at the meson pole ( @xmath310 ) due to the sign change of the effective coupling strength ( [ lambda]).,title="fig : " ] as we have noted , in the low temperature phase with non - vanishing condensate amplitude @xmath142 , the mesonic excitations couple with the quasi - particle excitations and this give the additional shift of the meson mass from the one obtained by the gap equation . the shift of the meson pole from the bare spectrum @xmath311 may be computed by the condition @xmath312 which in the long wavelength limit ( @xmath313 ) gives a solution at @xmath314 . the shift of the meson mass @xmath315 is determined by @xmath316 where we have used @xmath300 . in the case of @xmath317 this may be solved approximately @xmath318 the equation ( [ mass - shift ] ) may be solved by iteration starting from the first approximation ( [ mass - shift0 ] ) by inserting it for @xmath319 in the integrand on the right hand side . we plot in fig . 6 the meson mass shift determined by this method . the meson mass becomes smaller as @xmath320 increases and eventually becomes zero at the temperature which satisfies the condition @xmath321 the vanishing of the effective mass of mesonic excitation may be identified as the onset of instability in the metastable low temperature phase by small fluctuation ( spinodal decomposition ) . the same instability occurs when one approaches to @xmath322 from high temperature phase . we note that the temperature @xmath323 at the spinodal point given by ( [ spinodal ] ) does not coincide with the `` backbending '' temperature @xmath324 where @xmath325 diverges . the latter temperature is determined by the condition @xmath326 which can be obtained from the gap equation ( [ gap ] ) . we found that @xmath324 is slightly above @xmath323 and the unstable region appears associated with the lower solutions @xmath57 of the gap equation . these unstable solutions thus appear only in the region which is not easily accessible and may well be considered as another pathology of the mean field approximation . in the case of the second order transition of the landau - type . such behavior has been obtained in @xcite by a temperature - dependent loop expansion method formulated in @xcite . ] ) is the mass of the excitation determined by ( [ mass - shift ] ) and the dashed line is the solution of the gap equation evaluated at @xmath32710 . the slopes of two curves diverge at the temperature @xmath328 while @xmath60 vanishes at @xmath329 . ] in this paper , we have developed a kinetic theory for a system of interacting quantum fields in the mean field approximation taking into account the existence of quasi - particle excitations . we have obtained a set of coupled equations of motion , one for the meson condensate in the form of non - linear klein - gordon equation which contains extra non - linearlity due to the particle excitations . the equations of motion for quasi - particle excitations are described in terms of the wigner functions , which reduce to a semiclassical vlasov equation for one - particle distribution function with a modification due to the coherent pair - creation and pair - annihilation expressed by the off - diagonal components in the wigner function . these off - diagonal components may be eliminated by a suitable bogoliubov transformation of the particle creation and annihilation operators for a uniform , time - independent system . however , they remain non - vanishing in general non - uniform , time - dependent systems . we have shown that in equilibrium these equations are reduced to a gap equation in the hartree approximation . this implies that our kinetic equations are natural extension of the hartree approximation to the non - equilibrium situation . it is well known , however , that in this approximation the phase transition becomes first order . this is a generic feature of the mean field approximation @xcite which persists also for multi - components scalar fields with continuous @xmath1 symmetry for arbitrary finite integer @xmath330 . in the present work , we studied also the excitations spectrum in the system near equilibrium . in the high temperature phase there is no collective excitation mode in the system besides the two continua of the quasi - particle excitations in the entire space - like energy - momentum region and the time - like region above the pair creation threshold . in the low temperature phase we found that coupling of the meson pole to the quasi - particle continua give rise to the shift of the meson mass which becomes zero at the edge of the spinodal instability line of the first order transition . the spinodal point appears deep inside the meta - stable region of the first order transition which may well be an artifact of the mean field approximation . we found that the coupling to the off - diagonal components of the wigner functions should be properly included to avoid the appearance of the undamped tachyonic mode . in this work we used a single component real scalar field model which possesses only discrete symmetry . it is straightforward to extend the present analysis to models with continuous symmetry such as the sigma model with @xmath1 symmetry . basic features of the present analysis is preserved in such extension . it is known however that the goldstone theorem is apparently violated in this approximation for a system with continuous symmetry . we will show in the forthcoming paper @xcite , that the missing nambu - goldstone mode may be retrieved in the collective excitations of the system . our coupled kinetic equations may be solved for an arbitrary initial conditions . we plan to study the freezeout dynamics with these equations with more realistic interactions . it would be interesting to see in particular how much flow is generated by the acceleration by the mean field as the vacuum condensate is restored . 0.5 cm * acknowledgment * we thank gordon baym , hirotsugu fujii , tetsuo hatsuda , tetsufumi hirano , osamu morimatsu and koichi ohta for helpful discussions . we are indebted to gordon baym for correcting a sign error in the original manuscript and to tetsuo hatsuda and osama morimatsu for calling our attention to some works on the spectral functions at finite temperature which prompted us to extend our analyses of the excitation spectrum in section 6 . we are also grateful to francois gelis , kazunori itakura , yusuke kato , and tetsuro nikuni for their interests in this work . this work has been supported by the grants - in - aid of the japanese ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology no . 13440067 and 19540269 . here we present some details of the computation of the equation of motion of the wigner functions and show that with the gaussian ansatz for the density matrix the result is equivalent to what we obtain from the mean - field hamiltonian ( [ hmf ] ) . we like to compute the time - derivative of the operator product @xmath331 which appears in the definition of @xmath332 with @xmath333 and @xmath334 . @xmath335 a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } + a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } [ a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } , h ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] the commutators @xmath336 $ ] is decomposed into a sum of the commutators with @xmath85 ( @xmath337 ) among which the commutators with @xmath89 and @xmath90 do not survive the average with the gaussian density matrix since they only contain the odd power of the field operators . we only need to compute the commutators with @xmath91 and @xmath92 . to compute the commutator with @xmath91 it is convenient to rewrite @xmath91 as @xmath338 we then find @xmath339 & = & \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) [ a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) , { { \tilde \phi}}^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) ] \nonumber \\ & = & \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) + \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^{- i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } } } { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) \\ \left [ a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) , h_2 \right ] & = & - \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) [ a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) , { { \tilde \phi}}^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) ] \nonumber \\ & = & - \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) - \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } } } { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the following formulae : @xmath340 & = & n { { \tilde \phi}}^{n-1 } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) [ a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger , { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r}},t ) ] = - n { { \tilde \phi}}^{n-1 } ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } } } \\ \left [ a_{{\mathbf p } } , { { \tilde \phi}}^n ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \right ] & = & n \phi^{n-1 } ( { { \mathbf r}},t ) [ a_{{\mathbf p } } , { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r}},t ) ] = n \phi^{n-1 } ( { { \mathbf r}},t ) \frac{e^{- i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with these results we obtain @xmath341 & = & - ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } - \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \quad - \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}_1 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \quad \qquad + \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { { \tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^{- i { { \mathbf p}}_2 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger \end{aligned}\ ] ] the gaussian average of this equation gives @xmath342 { \rangle } & = & - ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } - \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) { \langle}a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } { \rangle}\nonumber \\ & & \quad - \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}_1 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } } } { \langle}{{\tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } { \rangle}\nonumber \\ & & \quad \qquad + \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}\phi_c^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^{- i { { \mathbf p}}_2 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } { \langle}{{\tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger { \rangle}\end{aligned}\ ] ] next we compute the commutators with @xmath92 . we first compute @xmath343 & = & \frac{\lambda}{3 ! } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{{\tilde \phi}}^3 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } } } a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) \\ \left [ a_{{\mathbf p}}^\dagger ( t ) , h_4 \right ] & = & - \frac{\lambda}{3 ! } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{{\tilde \phi}}^3 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}\cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p } } } } } a_{{\mathbf p}}(t ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] we then use these results to obtain @xmath344 & = & - \frac{\lambda}{3 ! } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{{\tilde \phi}}^3 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}_1 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \frac{\lambda}{3 ! } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{{\tilde \phi}}^3 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) \frac{e^{- i { { \mathbf p}}_2 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger \end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the average with the gaussian density matrix , we find @xmath345 { \rangle } & = & - \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{\langle}{{\tilde \phi}}^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { \rangle}\frac{e^ { i { { \mathbf p}}_1 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } } } { \langle}{{\tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } { \rangle}\nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \frac{\lambda}{2 } \int d { { \mathbf r}}{\langle}{{\tilde \phi}}^2 ( { { \mathbf r } } , t ) { \rangle}\frac{e^{- i { { \mathbf p}}_2 \cdot { { \mathbf r}}}}{\sqrt{2 \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } { \langle}{{\tilde \phi}}({{\mathbf r } } , t ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger { \rangle}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we observe the similarity between the last two terms of the commutator with @xmath91 and the commutator with @xmath92 after gaussian average . these terms can be combined by introducing the self - energy function , @xmath346 integration over the space coordinate @xmath347 give a delta function @xmath348 and @xmath349 . performing the integral over @xmath41 yields @xmath350 { \rangle } & = & - ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } - \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) { \langle}a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } { \rangle}\nonumber \\ & & \quad - \frac{\lambda}{4 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt{\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } ( { \langle}a_{-{{\mathbf p}}_1-{{\mathbf q } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } { \rangle}+ { \langle}a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } { \rangle } ) \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt { \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } \omega_{p_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } } } ( { \langle}a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger { \rangle}+ { \langle}a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_2 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger { \rangle } ) \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result coincides with the average of the commutator with the mean field hamiltonian @xmath108 defined by ( [ hmf ] ) . @xmath351 { \rangle}= { \langle } [ a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } , h_{\rm mf } ] { \rangle}\ ] ] commutators of the four bilinear operator products with the mean - field hamiltonian are listed below : @xmath98 & = & - ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } - \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \quad - \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt{\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } ( a_{-{{\mathbf p}}_1-{{\mathbf q } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } + a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt { \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } } } ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } + a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_2 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) \nonumber \\ \\ \left [ a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } , h_{\rm mf } \right ] & = & ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } + \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \quad + \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt{\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1-{{\mathbf q } } } + a_{-{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt { \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } + a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_2 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) \nonumber \\ \\ \left [ a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } , h_{\rm mf } \right ] & = & - ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } + \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \quad - \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt{\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } ( a_{-{{\mathbf p}}_1-{{\mathbf q } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } + a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & \qquad - \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt { \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } } } ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger + a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_2 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger ) \nonumber \\ \\ \left [ a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } , h_{\rm mf } \right ] & = & ( \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } - \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } ) a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \quad + \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt{\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}\omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } } } ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1-{{\mathbf q } } } + a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_1 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) a^\dagger_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad - \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{\mathbf q}}\frac{\pi_{{\mathbf q}}}{\sqrt { \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_1 } \omega_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } } } a_{{{\mathbf p}}_1}^\dagger ( a_{{{\mathbf p}}_2 - { { \mathbf q } } } + a_{- { { \mathbf p}}_2 + { { \mathbf q}}}^\dagger ) \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] # 1ann . phys . * # 1 * # 1phys . rep . * # 1 * # 1act . phys . pol . * # 1 * # 1prog . phys . * # 1 * # 1prog . phys . supplement*#1 * # 1phys . rev . * # 1 * # 1phys . rev . * d#1 * # 1phys . rev . * c#1 * # 1phys . rev . * a#1 * # 1phys . * # 1 * # 1phys . # 1 * # 1rev . phys.*#1 * # 1nucl . phys . * # 1 * # 1nuovo cimento * # 1 * # 1sov . # 1 * # 1eur . j. * a#1 * # 1coll . a#1 * j. d. bjorken , _ phys . rev . _ * d27 * , 865 ( 1983 ) ; g. baym , b. l. friman , j .- blaizot , m. soyeur , w. czy , _ nucl . _ * a407 * , 541 ( 1983 ) ; k. kajantie and l. mclerran , , 261 ( 1983 ) ; m. gyulassy , t. matsui , _ phys . rev . _ * d29 * , 419 ( 1984 ) Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the merging of two galaxies will produce a binary black hole at the center of the newly formed galaxy . numerical relativity simulations predict that black holes can be kicked out of the galaxy in binary black hole mergers with velocities up to several thousand @xmath2 ( e.g. * ? ? ? detection of a rapidly recoiling black hole would be a confirmation of the gravitational wave and shed new light on the cosmic evolution of super - massive black holes . @xcite reported the first candidate , sdss j092712.65 + 294344.0 , which have two sets of emission lines with velocity difference of 2650 @xmath2 and the red set has only narrow emission lines ( nels ) . and since then several other recoiling black hole candidates have been reported ( e.g. * ? ? ? . however , all the candidates have interpretations other than recoiling black hole , such as peculiar double - peak emitters , close black hole binaries or chance superpositions ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? . there have been many efforts to search for recoiling black hole candidates in large area survey . most of them used shifted broad emission lines ( bels ) relative to nels as an indicator of recoiling black holes ( see * ? ? ? * for a review ) . in addition , @xcite suggested an `` off - nuclear agn '' character , which means that a recoiling active black hole moves away from the center of its host galaxy , can also be used as the indicator of recoiling black holes . we have run a systematic search for low - redshift rapidly recoiling black hole candidates based on sdss data release 7 . the quasar catalog of @xcite was used as our parent sample . we first selected those with @xmath4 so that complete h@xmath5 profiles are available using sdss data . we then obtained the profiles of h@xmath5 bels by subtracting continuum and nels . after that , we detected the peaks from the smoothed profiles and measured their velocity shifts relative to nels . quasars which show peaks on both blue and red sides are excluded because these are obvious double - peak emitters and difficult to be explained by recoiling black holes . we found 22 sources with velocity shifts greater than 2000 @xmath2 . among this sample , sbs 1421 + 511 , which is a system consisting of a radio quasar at z = 0.276 and a nearby extended source ( figure 1(b ) ) , is the only one showing an off - nuclear agn character . the position offset between the quasar and the extended source suggests that the quasar might be kicked out of its original host galaxy . it can be seen from the sdss spectrum ( figure 1(a ) ) that the profile of balmer bels is blue - skewed and the peak velocity of the profile is @xmath13300 @xmath2 relative to nels . both the blue - skewed profile and the off - nuclear agn character suggest a super - massive recoiling black hole . if confirmed , sbs 1421 + 511 may shed new light on the study of recoiling black holes due to its off - nuclear agn character which is rare among the candidates . in this paper , we report the results of the new keck - ii echellette spectrograph and imager ( esi ) long - slit spectrographic observation of the system sbs 1421 + 511 , which took the spectra of the quasar and the extended source at the same time . we identified a host galaxy in the quasar position , and therefore the off - nuclear agn character is not due to a recoiling black hole . the quasar bels are well modeled as emissions from a circular disk with a blueshift velocity of @xmath11400 @xmath2 relative to nels , suggesting a super - massive black hole which is recoiling at a velocity of @xmath11400 @xmath2 , and meanwhile other possible interpretations exist . the physical justifications of these interpretations are discussed in section 4.2 . the spectrum of the extended source shows that it is an galaxy with a velocity difference relative to the quasar host galaxy of only 120 @xmath2 and a projected distance of only 12.5 kpc at the redshift . therefore , the extended source is likely to be an companion galaxy and we refer to the extended source as `` the companion '' hereafter . the companion shows seyfert - like line ratios and a high [ oiii ] luminosity , suggesting that sbs 1421 + 511 is a dual agn system . dual agns have valuable potential as observational tools for studies of galaxy evolution , including measurements of galaxy merger rates , mass growth rates and merger rates of super - massive black holes @xcite . [ oiii ] emission is often used as a indicator of agn in surveys of dual agns . for example , double - peak [ oiii ] nels are used as signatures of dual agns in large area survey ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) and separated [ oiii ] nuclei are important to confirming the dual agn candidates ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . intriguingly , we found an extended emission line region ( eelr ) southern to the quasar . the existence of the eelr suggests that a similar being may coincide with the companion and the companion is not necessarily active . we considered other possible interpretations such as a pair of eelrs with a bipolar structure and gas in the companion galaxy illuminated by the quasar , which are further discussed in section 4.3 . the eelr itself is interesting . in spite of multiple observations , the nature and origin of eelrs ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) are still not understood completely and there is no generally interpretation for all the eelrs ( see * ? ? ? * for a review ) . they are initially thought to be tidal features , but later observations found that only a few of them show structures like tidal tails . only a small fraction of eelrs show accompanied large scale radio features , indicating that they are likely driven by radio jets @xcite . @xcite presented that the luminosity of the eelr is strongly correlated with nuclear [ oiii ] luminosity , suggesting that most of the eelrs originate in agn - driven galactic wind . sbs 1421 + 511 is likely to be tidally interacting with a companion , and shows radio structures and large scale outflows at the same time , thus provide an ideal laboratory to study the nature of the eelr . the possible origins of the eelr in sbs 1421 + 511 are discussed in section 4.4 . we obtained the keck esi optical long slit spectrum of sbs 1421 + 511 on 2013 may 8 using the echelle mode . the width of the slit is 0.75@xmath0 and the instrumental dispersion is @xmath6 22 @xmath2 . the slit was aligned in a north - south direction ( figure 1(b ) ) , so the quasar and the companion can fall into the slit at the same time . the exposure time was 20 minutes . after the exposure , we immediately obtained a spectrum of the standard star bd+33 2642 with the same setting and 2 minutes exposure to perform flux calibration and generate point spread function ( psf ) . the seeing was @xmath7 measured from the full width of half maximum ( fwhm ) of the psf . we reduced the original data through a routine based on idl program package * * xidl * * to obtain two - dimensional ( hereafter 2-d ) spectral images . using the spectral images , we can easily obtain one - dimensional ( hereafter 1-d ) spectra by collapsing them along the spatial direction and obtain spatial brightness profiles along the slit by collapsing them along the spectral direction . bias and flat correction , wavelength calibration , sky subtraction were performed first . cosmic - rays were removed using * lacosmic * @xcite . we resampled the clean spectral data around the tracks of the quasar for 10 echelle orders so that one pixel corresponds to 10 @xmath2 in wavelength direction and 0.15@xmath0 in spatial direction , using 2-d wavelength calibration from arc - lamp image and pixel scales from archival maps . we then jointed the spectral images of the 10 orders . the joint 2-d spectral image covers the wavelength range of 400010100 after removing low response regions . we then ran the same routine to obtain the spectral image of the standard star and then used the extracted 1-d spectrum of the standard star to make flux calibration of the source . we also obtained the spatial brightness profiles in different wavelength ranges for the standard star to generate 1-d psf . there is a chance that the psf may not be adequate for analysing the spectral image of the source due to seeing variance . however , the variance is minor because the seeing was stable at that time according to the observation log and the time interval between the two exposures was only @xmath112 minutes . sbs 1421 + 511 shows an off - nuclear agn character . it could be explained by a single - galaxy model that the quasar is naked and the companion is the original host galaxy of which the quasar might be kicked out . there also exists an alternative double - galaxy model that the quasar has a host galaxy and the companion is indeed a companion galaxy . eracleous & halpern ( 2003 , hereafter eh03 ) presented the analysis of optical spectra of sbs 1421 + 511 obtained with kpno 2.1 m and mdm 2.4 m telescopes during 1997 and 2000 . according to the results of eh03 , there is starlight emission underneath the quasar and the flux fraction of the starlight is [email protected] . the starlight can be interpreted as the host galaxy of the quasar according to the double - galaxy model , and as the outer part of the single galaxy according to the single - galaxy model . we could not judge the two based on eh03 s results because we had no spectrum of the companion and the starlight fraction has large uncertainty . we extracted the spectra of the quasar and the companion from the new esi 2-d spectral image with 3@xmath0 apertures . as can be seen from figure 2 , the quasar spectrum clearly shows absorption features of old stellar populations such as caii k band around 3934 , mg ib feature around 5177 , na i d @xmath9 5890 , 5896 doublet lines , proving that there is starlight underneath the quasar . and the companion spectrum shows strong these features , and thus is dominated by old stellar populations . the absorption line redshifts are close for the two spectra . according to the single - galaxy model , the stellar emission in the quasar spectrum comes from the outer part of the single galaxy and thus its flux would be much lower than that in the companion spectrum , which is extracted using the same aperture size . and it is not necessarily so according to the double - galaxy model . therefore a decomposition of quasar and stellar components in the quasar spectrum may help to distinguish the two models . we fit the quasar spectrum using models consisting of a stellar component and a quasar component . the stellar component is the addition of simple stellar population ( ssp ) templates of @xcite , which were broadened by convolving with a gaussian to match the stellar velocity dispersion and shifted to match the redshift . we used a single ssp and the best - fitting result was achieved with stellar population of @xmath13 gyr old , and redshift and velocity dispersion are @xmath10 and @xmath11 , respectively . we attempted to add one more ssp but after this the reduced @xmath12 only varied 0.02 and the second ssp contributes little flux , and therefore we did not adopt the second ssp . for the quasar component , we attempted to use a single power - law as the quasar continuum at first and the residual showed excess in spectral region redder than 6000 . the excess is also seen in quasar composite spectra @xcite and is interpreted as the radiation of a torus . therefore we used a broken power - law with broken point fitted to be @xmath15700 for the quasar continuum . we masked the spectral regions affected by nels , which are demonstrated in figure 2 . there are strong and wide bels , including balmer series and hei @xmath135876 , which influence some important stellar features , and therefore we fit the continuum and bels at the same time instead of masking the regions affected by bels in the fitting . the bel models are described as follows : 1 . we used double gaussian for all the bels since they are obviously asymmetric . 2 . the residual reveals a feature at around 4700 . though the quasar composite spectra show feii pseudo continuum here , it is unlikely that the feature is due to feii emission because the data were not well fitted by accordingly adding an optical feii template . thus we considered another possibility that the feature is heii @xmath134686 bel , which is seen in the spectra of feii weak quasars . we added a corresponding double gaussian for heii of which the profile is assumed to be identical to that of h@xmath14 , and yielded a good fit to the data . 3 . the residual shows an excess at @xmath15 , which is likely due to blended high order balmer bels and thus we added a component accordingly . the component consists of balmer lines from @xmath16 to @xmath17 , of which the profiles are fixed to that of h@xmath18 , and of which the relative strength are fixed using the line emissivity for case b @xcite under a typical circumstance for broad line regions of @xmath19 k and @xmath20 @xmath21 . we also used ssp templates to fit the companion spectrum . we tried single ssp and double ssp , and the results showed that double ssp is appropriate and the ages of the two ssps are @xmath22 gyr and @xmath110 myr . the redshift and velocity dispersion of the ssps are @xmath23 and @xmath24 @xmath2 , respectively . considering that the companion spectrum is contaminated by the quasar continuum and bels due to seeing effect , we added a contamination component which is @xmath14% of the corresponding flux in the quasar spectrum and the fraction was computed using psf . we overplot the best - fitting models for the two spectra in figure 2 . the fraction of starlight increases along direction of longer wavelength from 19% at 4000 to 46% at 7000 , in agreement with eh03 s result . the corresponding stellar mass in the quasar spectrum is @xmath25 , close to that in the companion spectrum of @xmath26 . therefore it is unlikely that the starlight underneath the quasar comes from the outer part of the single galaxy . the stellar mass is high thus it is also unlikely that the stellar component comes from stars which are ejected accompanied with the super - massive black hole when recoiling . we display the 1-d spatial brightness profile of the continuum from keck data in figure 3(a ) . the profile was extracted from a spectral region at around rest - frame 7000 , where the contribution of the quasar component is relatively small . as illustrated by figure 3(a ) , we obtained the minimum flux of the non - quasar component ( orange line ) . we also show the 2-d brightness profile from sdss i - band image in figure 3(c ) . this band ( rest - frame 54006500 ) was selected because it is not strongly affected by emission lines . using psf from a nearby star , we obtained a similar minimum flux ( figure 3(d ) ) and the inferred lower limit of the stellar luminosity is @xmath27 . such a bright galaxy would be either an elliptical or a disk galaxy if not a merger , and the radial brightness profiles of the both can be well described by srsic profile . thus this profile is used to fit the continuum brightness profile for both the 1-d ( keck ) and 2-d ( sdss ) data , and the later was done with the code * galfit * ( version 3.0 , * ? ? ? we used two models : a single - galaxy model consisting of a srsic profile for the single galaxy and a point source for the quasar component , and a double - galaxy model with one more srsic profile for the host . for 1-d data the double - galaxy model is significantly better than the single - galaxy model since the @xmath12/dof reduces from 65603/115 to 2505.2/110 , and for 2-d data it is marginally better since the @xmath12/dof are 11092.8/12304 and 11060.8/12297 . we adopted the conclusion from 1-d data that the single - galaxy model was excluded as the total signal to noise ratio of 1-d data is much higher than that of 2-d data . from 1-d spatial decomposition results , we obtained the contribution of the stellar component in an aperture which was used to extract quasar spectrum at around 7000 to be 44% , in accordance with that obtained from spectral decomposition results of 46% . the good agreement makes the two decompositions more robust . therefore we conclude that the off - nuclear agn character is not due to a recoiling super - massive black hole but due to a close companion . the distance between the centers of the two galaxies is @xmath28 arcsec and @xmath29 arcsec for 1-d and 2-d data , respectively , which are consistent . the little distance ( 12.5 kpc in projection at @xmath30 ) and the little radial velocity difference ( 120 @xmath2 ) indicate that the two galaxies are likely physically connected and rotating around each other , and going on a major merger considering that both the two galaxies are bright with @xmath31 and @xmath32 , which were obtained from 2-d spatial decomposition results . the srsic index of the companion galaxy is @xmath33 and @xmath34 for the 1-d and 2-d fit , respectively , being close to 1 and implying that the companion galaxy may be a disk galaxy . on the other hand , the srsic index of the host galaxy is @xmath35 for 1-d fit , and the corresponding value for 2-d fit is undetermined due to large uncertainty , and we are not sure if it is a disk galaxy or an elliptical galaxy . the blue - skewed profile of quasar bels of sbs 1421 + 511 implies a super - massive recoiling black hole . however , similar profiles are also seen in some agns with double - peaked bels . eh03 analyzed the h@xmath5 bel profile of sbs 1421 + 511 using spectrum obtained with mdm 2.4 m telescopes in 1998 . they fit the line with the relativistic keplerian disk model of @xcite , which is widely used for double - peaked bels . the model assumes that the line originates on the surface of a circular , keplerian disk whose axis is inclined by an angle @xmath36 relative to the line of sight , between radii @xmath37 and @xmath38 ( expressed in units of the gravitational radius , @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the mass of the black hole ) . the disk has an axisymmetric emissivity of the form @xmath41 . local broadening of the line is represented by a gaussian rest - frame profile of velocity dispersion @xmath42 . the free parameters of the model are thus @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath36 , @xmath43 and @xmath42 . eh03 found that the h@xmath5 bel could not be well fitted with a simple circular disk model , and the fit could be improved by either ( 1 ) applying an ad hoc blueshift to the model of 1370 km / s or ( 2 ) using an elliptical disk model , which has two more free parameters of eccentricity @xmath44 and the angle between the major axis of the elliptical disk and the line of sight @xmath45 @xcite . we accordingly fit the h@xmath5 profile of esi , which was obtained by subtracting continuum from original quasar spectrum , using both circular and elliptical disk models . we also attempted to apply a blueshift to the models . the statistics and best - fitting parameters of the models are listed in table 1 . without blueshift , neither circular nor elliptical disk model can well describe the h@xmath5 profile . after applying an ad hoc blueshift , both the two models yield good fit , and they are statistically just as good , for @xmath12/dof is 1013/843 and 1004/841 for the two models . the best - fitting circular disk model with a blueshift is displayed in the upper panel of figure 4 . the ad hoc blueshift applied to the circular disk model is 1450 @xmath2 , close to the value obtained by eh03 . we confirmed eh03 s conclusions that the double - peaked bels of sbs 1421 + 511 can not be well reproduced by a simple circular disk model and the fit was greatly improved by applying an ad hoc blueshift . and we excluded the elliptical disk model because : 1 . it can not reproduce the profile without a blueshift ; 2 . it is statistically not better than circular disk model if applying a blueshift . long term monitoring of agns with double - peaked bels @xcite reveal profile variations , which can be described by the changes of excess emissions in amplitude and projected velocity on timescales of years . since we have three spectra of sbs 1421 + 511 from mdm ( 1998 ) , sdss ( 2003 ) and keck ( 2013 ) , we plotted the normalized h@xmath5 profiles of the three spectra together in the lower panel of figure 4 to see the variability of the profile . the variance between the sdss and keck profiles is little , and the blue peak in mdm profile is weaker than those in sdss and keck profiles . we did not find velocity change of the blue peak among the three observations , though the change is common among agns with similar bel profiles . to quantify this , we estimated the change by comparing mdm and sdss profiles with shifted and normalized keck profile and by using minimum chi - square method . the change is @xmath46 @xmath2 between sdss and keck profiles , and @xmath47 @xmath2 between mdm and keck profiles , and the inferred velocity change rate is @xmath48 @xmath2 per year in rest frame . this constitutes an important constraint on the nature of the double - peaked bel of sbs 1421 + 511 , and we discuss the possible interpretations of the bels in section 4.2 . it can be seen from figure 2 that the companion spectrum shows detectable [ heii ] @xmath134686 and strong [ oiii ] @xmath94959 , 5007 . the line ratio of [ oiii]/h@xmath14 is @xmath49 measured from the residual between the original spectrum and the best - fitting model . these suggest that the gas in the companion is ionized by an accreting black hole and the companion may also be an agn . the [ oiii ] emission of the companion is so strong that a corresponding emission line feature can be easily seen northern to the quasar from the 2-d emission line spectral image ( figure 5(a ) ) . intriguingly , there also exists an emission line feature in the opposite direction southern to the quasar . as can be seen from the 2-d spectral image , the two features show symmetry in both spatial and velocity directions : the northern one is blueshifted relative to the quasar host galaxy and the southern one is redshifted , and the distances to the quasar position are both several arcsecs and the velocity differences are both @xmath50 @xmath2 . as the symmetry we investigated the two features together . for clarity , we referred to the northern one as `` feature n '' and the southern one as `` feature s '' hereafter . we extracted the spatial brightness profiles of feature n using a velocity range of @xmath51 @xmath2 , which are presented in figure 5(b ) . both the peak positions of profiles for [ oiii ] and [ nii ] locate @xmath13@xmath0 north to the quasar , roughly coincident with the center of the companion ( horizontal yellow dashed line ) , and for h@xmath5 and h@xmath14 the peak positions are @xmath14 north to the quasar . the disparity indicates that feature n may consist of two components : one has stronger [ oiii ] and [ nii ] emissions whose major emitting region is around the center of the companion ; the other has stronger balmer emissions whose major emitting region is in the outer region , and hence likely comes from an off - center hii region . considering the 1.4@xmath0 seeing , the two components are mixed with each other . to decompose them we extracted 1-d spectra ( figure 5(d ) ) using two 2@xmath0-width apertures , apern ( blue in figure 5(c ) ) and aperhii ( purple ) . we selected apern whose center is 3@xmath0 north to the quasar , in consistent with the major emitting region of the first component , and selected aperhii so that the emission most comes from the second component . we obtained the emission line spectra by subtracted the continua , and the velocity profiles of [ oiii ] and h@xmath5 are plotted in figure 5(e ) . we also classified the type of ionization source using the flux ratios of emission lines , which are listed in table 2 and plotted in figure 5(f ) , according to the diagnostic diagram of @xcite . for apern , the line ratios obtained by simply performing a gaussian fitting are seyfert - like ( blue star in figure 5(f ) ) according to the diagnostic diagram . considering the contamination of the second component , which contributes more to h@xmath5 and h@xmath14 than to [ oiii ] and [ nii ] , the line ratios of the first component would move upper right on the diagnostic diagram and still be agn - like . for aperhii , [ oiii ] profile is nearly the same as that of apern ( figure 5(e ) ) , suggesting that [ oiii ] emission is dominated by the first component . by contrast , h@xmath5 profile is much narrower than that of apern , and for both the two apertures h@xmath5 profiles are narrower than [ oiii ] profiles , implying that h@xmath5 emission of aperhii is dominated by the second component and h@xmath5 emission of apern is the mixture of the two components . by directly fitting the profiles using gaussian , the line ratios of aperhii ( purple star ) are close to the dividing line of agn and hii regimes in the diagnostic diagram . furthermore , the line ratios ( purple diamond ) are hii - like if calculated using fluxes which are integrated over a narrower velocity range of @xmath52 @xmath2 , which is less contaminated . thus it is likely that the second component has hii - like line ratios . we then decomposed the emission lines of the two apertures into two sets which are corresponding to the two components by assuming that the profiles are gaussian and are identical for all the emission lines for each set . the results show that 87% and 13% of the first set fall into apern and aperhii , respectively , and the corresponding fractions of the second set are 44% and 56% . the line ratios of the first set ( blue square ) are seyfert - like , and those of the second set ( purple square ) are hii - like . the velocity difference of the seyfert - like set of emission lines relative to the absorption line of the companion galaxy is @xmath53 @xmath2 and that of the hii - like set is @xmath54 @xmath2 , and the velocity dispersions are 75 and 150 @xmath2 for two sets , respectively . therefore we concluded that feature n is composed of a component in the companion center which has seyfert - like line ratios and an off - center hii region . the [ oiii ] luminosity of the seyfert - like component in a rectangular aperture which is set by 0.75@xmath0 slit and 2@xmath0 apern is @xmath55 . the contamination by quasar emission due to seeing effect is minor as the fraction is @xmath56 predicted by psf . to obtain the total luminosity of the source of the seyfert - like component , we should multiply an aperture correction which is computed to be 2.3 by using psf and assuming the source is point - like , and higher if the source is extended . thus the total [ oiii ] luminosity is l@xmath57 } } > 1.4\times10 ^ 8l_\odot$ ] , which may be underestimated considering an uncertain extinction correction . such a high [ oiii ] luminosity suggests an powerful agn in the companion galaxy . we also extracted the spatial brightness profiles of feature s using a velocity range of @xmath58 @xmath2 . feature s shows high [ oiii ] flux relative to h@xmath14 and extends to at least 6@xmath0 ( 25 kpc in projection ) away from the quasar where little starlight is seen , indicating an eelr . in order to compare the properties of feature s and feature n , we extract a 1-d spectrum in an aperture apers ( red in figure 5(c , d ) ) whose width and distance to the quasar are both the same with those of apern . the velocity profile of [ oiii ] shows a broad base , which may come from the contaminations by emissions of the quasar . to mask out the base , we fit [ oiii ] emission line using double gaussian and subtract the blueshifted broad gaussian component . by assuming that the rest emission comes from an eelr , we obtained the velocity difference and the velocity dispersion of the eelr of @xmath59 @xmath2 and @xmath60 @xmath2 . the line ratios of apers spectrum ( red star in figure 5(f ) ) are seyfert - like , agreeing with that the emission comes from an eelr . we will further discuss the natures of feature n and feature s in section 4.3 and 4.4 . for the discussion , we estimated the electron density of the two features using line ratios of [ sii ] @xmath136716/@xmath136731 and [ oii ] @xmath133729/@xmath133726 , and electron temperature using line ratio of [ oiii ] ( @xmath134959+@xmath135007)/@xmath134363 @xcite . for feature n , we obtained only an upper limit of the electron density of @xmath61 @xmath21 ( 95.3% confidence ) according to [ sii ] ratio of @xmath62 and [ oii ] ratio of @xmath63 , and the electron temperature is @xmath64 k according to [ oiii ] ratio of @xmath65 . for feature s , the electron density of feature s is @xmath66 @xmath21 according to the [ sii ] ratio of @xmath67 , and the uncertainty of [ oii ] line ratio is too large to limit the density . [ oiii ] @xmath134363 line is not detected in apers spectrum , and the inferred electron temperature is @xmath68 k ( 95.3% confidence ) using the upper limit . the electron density is higher in apers than in apern and the electron temperature is lower . in the quasar spectrum the profiles of nels show strong blue wings , which are generally thought to be correlated with an emission line outflow . figure 6(b ) displays the velocity profiles of three isolated nels ( h@xmath14 , [ oiii ] @xmath135007 and [ oi ] @xmath136300 ) . besides relatively narrow core components , strong blue wing components are seen in both high- and low - ionized lines , which extend for a velocity up to 1200 @xmath2 measured from the [ oiii ] velocity profile , suggesting a strong outflow . we tried to parameterize the nels to further investigate the two components . we used double gaussian for all the nels : one for the core component and the other for the blue wing component . some lines are blended , such as h@xmath5+[nii ] @xmath96548,6583 lines and [ sii ] @xmath96716,6731 doublet , so we tied the parameters of these lines as follows to reduce the uncertainty . for [ nii ] doublet , the profiles were assumed to be identical and the flux ratios were fixed to theoretical value 2.96 . and for [ sii ] doublet , the centroids were tied for both the core component and the wing component , and the widths were also tied , while the doublet flux ratios were set to be free parameters . the two gaussians to fit [ oiii ] are shown in figure 6(b ) ( purple lines ) . the redshift and the velocity dispersion of the core component are @xmath69 and @xmath70 @xmath2 , respectively , consistent with those of the starlight for the quasar spectrum , indicating that the kinematics of the core component is dominated by bulge gravitation and this component is likely to represent a traditional narrow line region ( nlr ) . the wing component contributes 70% of the total flux for [ oiii ] , and the velocity difference with the core component is @xmath71 @xmath2 , and the velocity dispersion is 340 @xmath2 . compared with the core component , the wing component is more complex , especially the near - zero - velocity part of this gaussian , which can be understood in two ways . one is that it comes from the traditional nlr whose velocity distribution is more extended than a gaussian profile . the other is that it does not come from the traditional nlr , though it has a radial velocity close to zero for some reason . in order to avoid confusion , we used a velocity range of @xmath72 @xmath2where the emission mostly comes from the outflow according to both interpretations , instead of the blueshifted gaussian , when referring to the blue wing component . we accordingly used an velocity range of @xmath73 @xmath2 when mentioning the core component . we noticed that the blue wing component shows lower ionization state than the core component as the line ratios of [ oiii]/h@xmath14 are @xmath74 and @xmath75 for the two component . the situation is different from blue wing outflows in most of other agns , which show blue wings stronger in high - ionized lines than in low - ionized lines . since the line ratios of [ oiii]/h@xmath14 are high , it is likely that both the outflow material and traditional nlr in sbs 1421 + 511 are mainly ionized by the quasar photons . if so , considering that the electron densities from [ sii ] are close for the two component , the lower ionization state suggests that the outflow region in sbs 1421 + 511 may be more extended than traditional nlr , which typically has a size of sub kpc to several kpc . this implies that the outflow region may have a size at an magnitude of order of @xmath1kpc , and thus may be resolvable under 1.4 arcsec seeing condition . to check this we extracted the spatial brightness profile of the blue wing component ( figure 6(c ) ) . although the northern half is influenced by feature n ( see figure 6(a ) ) , we can see from the uncontaminated southern half that the profile is broader than the psf . this is impossible to be caused by seeing variance because the profile is also broader than that of the core component . therefore we conclude that the outflow region is resolved . considering the seeing fwhm corresponds to @xmath16 kpc , the distinct disparity between the spatial profile and that of a point source indicates that the size of the outflow region is comparable to the seeing value , and thus is possibly at an order of magnitude of kpc . we then estimated the size of the blue wing outflow by fitting the southern half of the spatial profile . we tried several profile models , such as double gaussian , exponential and srsic , and found that a srsic profile model ( green lines in figure 6(d ) ) with index @xmath76 fit the profile best . the size of the outflow region is then estimated to be @xmath11 kpc using the half - light radius of the model profile . we estimated the mass rate of the blue wing outflow with a method used to estimate the parameters of nlr @xcite . the mass of emitting gas can be calculated as @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the h@xmath14 luminosity in unit of @xmath79 @xmath80 , and @xmath81 is the electron density in unit of @xmath82 @xmath21 . the mass outflow rate is then @xmath83 , where @xmath84 is the mean velocity of the outflow material and @xmath85 is the size of outflow region . using the profile in the velocity range of @xmath72 @xmath2 , the h@xmath14 luminosity is l(h@xmath14)@xmath86 @xmath80 and the mean velocity is @xmath87 @xmath2 . the size of outflow region is estimated to be 1 kpc from the spatial profile and the electron density is @xmath88 from the flux ratio of [ sii ] @xmath136716/@xmath136731 of the wing component of @xmath89 . using these values , the mass of the emitting material is @xmath90 and the inferred mass outflow rate is @xmath91 . the kinetic energy outflow rate is @xmath92 @xmath80 . the bolometric luminosity and the black hole mass are key parameters to understand the quasar in sbs 1421 + 511 . we estimated the bolometric luminosity by applying bolometric correction to both uv - optical continuum luminosity and hard x - ray luminosity . the luminosity indicators of l@xmath93 and l@xmath94 were used since we could obtain the ratio of optical and x - ray @xmath95 to compare with other agns . because neither the sdss nor the keck spectrum covers a rest - frame wavelength of 2500 , we obtained l@xmath93 by extrapolating the continua in spectral regions bluer than 3500 . the aperture corrected l@xmath93 for both the two spectra are @xmath96 @xmath80 , and the variance between them is less than 10% . sbs 1421 + 511 was observed by swift x - ray telescope ( xrt ) in 2006 april and 2010 july ( target i d 35375 ) , and the effective exposure time was 5.2 and 2.7 ks for the two observations , respectively . we extract the spectra for pc mode using * xselect * ( version 2.4 ) through standard routine and combined the two spectra . we then grouped the combined spectrum so that it has at least 20 counts per bin to ensure the @xmath12 statistics , and fit it using * xspec * ( version 12.8 ) . the spectrum is well fitted ( @xmath97 ) by an absorbed power law with index @xmath98 and neutral absorption column density @xmath99 @xmath100 ( 90% confidence ) . the l@xmath94 is @xmath101 @xmath80 and the inferred @xmath95 is 1.1 for sbs 1421 + 511 , lower than 1.33 , the typical value of radio loud quasars @xcite . we checked whether this is due to variability in optical or in x - ray . the variance of l@xmath93 between 2003 ( sdss ) and 2013 ( keck ) is @xmath10210% , and the variance of l@xmath94 between 2006 and 2010 is @xmath130% , which was obtained by fitting the data of two swift observations individually . assuming these are the variability amplitudes of the quasar , the uncertainty of @xmath95 due to variability is only 0.06 . therefore the unusual shape of spectral energy distribution ( sed ) is barely attributed to variability . on the other hand , sbs 1421 + 511 is a flat spectrum radio quasar ( fsrq ) with spectral index @xmath103 ( defined as @xmath104 ) and p@xmath105 w hz@xmath106 , which is resolved in very large baseline array ( vlba ) observation . we show in figure 1(c ) the brightness distributions map taken during vlba imaging and polarimetry survey ( vips * ? ? ? the analysis of helmboldt et al . demonstrated that the radio source has a jet structure with a size of @xmath10730 pc and a position angle of @xmath108 degrees ( north by east ) . the power of the jet can be estimated with the radio luminosity @xcite to be @xmath109 @xmath80 , similar to the x - ray luminosity , and thus the excess in x - ray luminosity relative to uv - optical may be due to radio jet activity . accordingly , we used quasar 3c206 from the sample of elvis et al . whose @xmath95 ( 1.15 ) is the closest to that of sbs 1421 + 511 as sed template , and estimated the bolometric luminosity to be @xmath110 @xmath80 . the central black hole mass of the quasar in sbs 1421 + 511 could not be estimated from the bels because they are double - peaked . using the stellar velocity dispersion of the host galaxy ( @xmath111 @xmath2 ) and @xmath112@xmath113 relation @xcite , we estimated the black hole mass to be @xmath114 , and the inferred eddington ratio is 5 . the measurement of @xmath113 is robust considering that it is consistent with the velocity dispersion of gas in the bulge , which is measured to be 90 @xmath2 from the core components of nels . the uncertainty of black hole mass is dominated by the intrinsic scatter of the @xmath112@xmath113 relation , which is 0.5 dex for 1@xmath42 confidence . we also estimated the black hole mass to be @xmath115 using the bolometric luminosity and assuming that the black hole is accreting at eddington accretion rate . the kinetic energy outflow rate of the kpc - scale outflow is @xmath116 of the agn luminosity in sbs 1421 + 511 , and hence is rather strong . the main source driving the outflow can not be starburst because the maximum velocity of the outflow @xmath117 @xmath2 is higher than those driven by starbursts @xcite . it is also unlikely to be the radio jet because the scale of radio jet is one order of magnitude smaller than the size of outflow . ram pressure from agn wind and radiation pressure on the dust are also suggested as the possible origins of the agn driven outflow , and these mechanisms are effective when the agn luminosity is close to eddington luminosity @xcite . thus it is likely that agn wind or radiation pressure drives the kpc - scale outflow in sbs 1421 + 511 . in section 3.2 , we attempted to reproduce the blue - skewed h@xmath5 profiles of sbs 1421 + 511 with accretion disk models , which are the most successful models for double - peaked bels till now . a simple circular disk model of @xcite is unable to interpret the data . this can be easily understood , since a circular disk produces blue and red peaks with similar fluxes while in sbs 1421 + 511 only the blue peak is seen . thus there must be an excess emission to the circular disk which is blueshifted in velocity and contributes to the strong blue peak , and hence the disk is nonaxisymmetric . there are multiple nonaxisymmetric disk models such as elliptical disk @xcite , circular disk with an orbiting bright spot ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) and circular disk with spiral emissivity perturbations @xcite . the elliptical disk model is first ruled out because it can not reproduce the data . although we did not directly examine other nonaxisymmetric models by fitting the data , we can test them using variability behavior of the bel profile because the excess emission from a nonaxisymmetric structure leads to long - term periodic profile variability . for the bright spot model the period is the dynamic time scale , which can be estimated using the peak velocity of h@xmath5 profile ( @xmath13000 @xmath2 ) and the black hole mass . the period is @xmath1024 yrs and @xmath10220 yrs for black hole masses of @xmath114 and @xmath115 , respectively , and 1.5 and 7 yrs assuming the unknown inclination angle to be 45@xmath118 . for spiral model the period is the precession time scale , which is limited by sound - crossing time scale and is typically several times higher than the dynamic time scale @xcite , and thus is at an order of magnitude of decades for sbs 1421 + 511 . these period values agree with those obtained from monitoring of agns with double - peaked bels , which are months to decades @xcite . on the other hand , the period @xmath119 can be limited observationally using the radial velocity of the excess emission @xmath120 and the velocity change rate @xmath121 : @xmath122 , where i is the inclination angle of the disk and @xmath123 is the phase angle in the disk of the source which produces the excess emission . using the peak velocity of h@xmath5 profile as @xmath120 and 3@xmath42 upper limit of @xmath121 and assuming the unknown angles to be 45@xmath118 , the observed lower limit of the period is @xmath1100 yrs . thus the bright spot model is unlikely and the possibility of spiral model remains open considering the uncertainty in black hole mass , unknown angles and structure of accretion disk . we showed that the data can be well reproduced using circular disk model if applying an ad hoc blueshift with a velocity of 1400 /kms relative to nels . this is unusual since the redshifts of disk models are typically fixed at those of host galaxies in previous research works . the large blueshift velocity can be physically interpreted either as resulting from orbiting around an unseen super - massive black hole companion or as resulting from recoiling at a large velocity . the orbiting model predicts that the blueshift velocity changes periodically and the period is @xmath1021 yr or @xmath1025 yrs using the equation of @xcite , which are inconsistent with the variability behavior of the bel profiles . the inconsistency was supported by long - term variability studies of agns with similar profiles @xcite which found their variability behaviors are also not consistent with orbital motion . in addition to the disk models , there are other models such as binary broad line region and emission from a bipolar outflow ( * ? ? ? * for a review ) . the binary broad line region model is also unlikely for sbs 1423 + 511 due to the disagreement between predicted and observed variability behaviours of the bel profile . although there are observational evidences against the bipolar outflow model in other agns with double - peaked bels ( see section 6.4.2 in eracleous & harpten 2003 ) which means that the model is not universal , this model is possible for sbs 1421 + 511 considering that the quasar has powerful radio jet and is accreting at a high rate , both of which are indicators of strong outflow . according to these discussions , the model that sbs 1421 + 511 hosts a super - massive black hole which is recoiling at a radial velocity of @xmath11400 @xmath2 and is accompanied by a circular disk which emits double - peaked bels can explain all the observed properties . and at the same time other possible models exist such as emissions from a circular disk with spiral emissivity perturbations and emissions from a bipolar outflow . follow - up spectral monitoring of sbs 1421 + 511 is needed to set a better constraint on the velocity change rate . ultraviolet spectra are also needed to obtain the profiles of high ionized bels and reveal possible broad absorption lines to examine the bipolar outflow model . the feature n consists of a seyfert - like component in the center of the companion galaxy and a hii region in the outer region . if we had not found feature s , we were likely to make the conclusion that the seyfert - like component of feature n comes from an obscured agn in the companion and hence sbs 1421 + 511 is a dual agn system . feature s is similar to the seyfert - like component in several aspects including size , velocity difference , emission line fluxes and flux ratios , implying they may have similar nature . furthermore , the high flux ratio of [ oiii]/h@xmath14 of feature s indicates that the quasar radiation is strong enough to illuminate the gas at such a distance , and thus the seyfert - like component may also be illuminated by the quasar . in addition , there are two facts which are unfavourable for an agn in the companion . one is that powerful agns are rare , for example the fraction of galaxies with a [ oiii ] luminosity as high as @xmath107 @xmath124 is less than 5% even in the most massive galaxies @xcite . the other is that the electron density of the seyfert - like component is @xmath102100 @xmath21 , lower than the typical value of nlr which is several @xmath125 @xmath21 . @xcite investigated a sample of seyfert 1 galaxies and found that nearly none of seyferts with bel fwhm(h@xmath14 ) @xmath107 2000 @xmath2 has nlr with such low density , and the fraction in narrow line seyfert 1 galaxies is only @xmath120% . though we can not ruled out the possibility of a dual agn in sbs 1421 + 511 , we should consider other interpretations for the seyfert - like component . one possible interpretation is that the seyfert - like component of feature n also comes from an eelr and just coincides with the companion galaxy . it is reasonable that feature s has an corresponding feature in the opposite direction considering that all possible origins of the eelrs , including tidal features , large scale radio jets and large scale outflows may have bipolar structure . the existence of eelrs with bipolar structure in other quasars , e.g. sdss j1356 + 1026 @xcite , gives weight to this speculation . in addition , the rareness of powerful agn and the low electron density can also be naturally explained . another possible interpretation is that the seyfert - like component of feature n comes from the ism in the companion galaxy illuminated by the quasar @xcite . the companion galaxy located in the ionization cone of a quasar would be ionized and look like a giant hii region for a distant observer if the quasar radiation is powerful enough . in order to test whether the quasar in sbs 1421 + 511 is capable of generating the observed line ratios and [ oiii ] luminosity , we ran a simulation using the photo - ionization code * cloudy * @xcite . we first attempted an oversimplified single - component model with input conditions as follows : 1 . the shape of the quasar spectrum was obtained by interpolating the sed of 3c206 and normalized to the bolometric luminosity of the quasar . the distance @xmath126 was estimated using the projected distance 12.5 kpc and assuming the unknown inclination angle to be the representative value @xmath127 . 3 . the density was assumed to be constant , and the value was set as the mean value of the ism for a disk galaxy of @xmath128 @xmath21 . 4 . the metallicity was assumed to be the solar one . the simulation shows that the quasar radiation can produce a kpc - thick hii region . the predicted line ratio of [ oiii ] @xmath135007/h@xmath14 @xmath1 10 . the [ oiii ] emission of apern comes from a region in a rectangular aperture which is set by 0.75@xmath0 slit and 2@xmath0 width apern , which has a cross - sectional area of @xmath129 . assuming the covering factor of the emitting gas , which depends on the orientation of the disk , is @xmath130 , the model predicts that [ oiii ] luminosity is @xmath131 . as both the [ oiii ] luminosity and the flux ratio of [ oiii]/h@xmath14 are high enough for the observed value , this oversimplified single - component model shows that the quasar radiation is strong enough to illuminated the ism of the companion . however , the model predicted that the line ratio of [ nii ] @xmath136584/h@xmath5 = 0.2 , which is significantly lower than the observed value . we attempted to vary the distance , density and metallicity in reasonable ranges , but failed to reproduce the data , for example a density of @xmath132 @xmath21 and a super - solar metallicity could generate a high enough [ nii]/h@xmath5 ratio but the [ oiii]/h@xmath14 ratio is too low . the inconsistency is common when one attempts to reproduce the spectrum of eelrs using photo - ionization models , and is removed by considering at least two kinds of clouds with significantly different physical properties ( e.g. * ? ? ? for example , though the parameters are not well limited , a double - component model consisting of a low density component with a density of @xmath133 @xmath21 and a solar or sub - solar metallicity , and a high density component with a density of @xmath132 @xmath21 and a super - solar metallicity can produce enough [ nii ] and [ oiii ] at the same time . and the two components could be explained as the warm ionized medium in the disk and high density medium in the galaxy center respectively for a typical galaxy . thus the interpretation that the seyfert - like component comes from gas in the companion illuminated by the quasar is supported by the simulation . this interpretation does not require that the companion galaxy is active and the low electron density of the seyfert - like component is more natural . however the 70 @xmath2 velocity shift between [ oiii ] emission line and the starlight absorption lines of the companion is difficult to be explained . by comparison , the shift can be easily explained if the seyfert - like component comes from an agn because the shift is common among agns or if it comes from an eelr because the companion and the eelr are not necessarily associated . in the survey of dual agns , separated [ oiii ] emission corresponding to the companion of a quasar is frequently used as indicator of an obscured agn in the companion . it is important to make clear whether sbs 1421 + 511 is a dual agn because the conclusion may influence the strategies of survey of dual agns . because [ oiii ] illuminated by an agn of the companion galaxy would concentrate on the center , while that illuminated by quasar would be more extended , [ oiii ] distribution map could be used to determine whether the companion is active . however , we can not make an unambiguous distinction based on esi data taken under 1.4@xmath0 ( @xmath16 kpc ) seeing condition . thus future narrow band imaging or ifs observations with high spatial resolution are required to map the [ oiii ] distribution , hence make a final conclusion . we first ruled out the possibility that the eelrs are generated by large scale radio structures because the radio source is compact and shows no large scale features . since we have seen a kpc - scale outflow from the blue wing of quasar nels , a natural question is that whether it is related with the eelrs . we checked whether the kpc - scale outflow can provided enough material to form a structure like feature s. the total mass of feature s is estimated to be @xmath134 using the electron density from [ sii ] doublet and h@xmath14 luminosity . however , the situation may be more complicated because a single - component model either can not reproduce the observed line ratios for feature s as what happened for the seyfert - like component of feature n : a similar * cloudy * simulation shows that a cloud with a density of @xmath135 @xmath21 would not reach a high enough ionization state to produce as much [ oiii ] relative to h@xmath14 as observed , and again lower densities which can produce enough [ oiii ] fail to produce as much [ nii ] and [ sii ] as observed . thus a double - component model is also needed for feature s and the electron density from [ sii ] doublet only applies for the high density component since [ sii ] emission mainly comes from it . if adopting this model , the total mass would be higher than what we estimated previously because the low density component would be much more massive assuming that the two components contribute comparable h@xmath14 . for example , @xcite showed that the eelr of quasar 4c 37.43 is better modeled as a two - phase medium , consisting of a matter - bounded diffuse component ( @xmath136 @xmath21 ) and an embedded small , dense component ( @xmath137 @xmath21 ) , and the fractions of the flux of h@xmath14 from the two components are @xmath11/3 and @xmath12/3 , respectively . if this is the case for sbs 1421 + 511 , the mass of low density component would be about two orders of magnitude higher than that of the high density component , and the total mass would be @xmath138 . the dynamic time scale of an outflow capable of producing an emission line feature like feature s is @xmath139 yr , which is estimated using the size and mean radial velocity of feature s. considering the mass rate of the kpc - scale outflow and the dynamic time scale , the blue wing outflow can provide enough material to form an eelr feature like feature s. however the model has a disadvantage : a cloud with a density of @xmath132 @xmath21 and a temperature of @xmath140 k in circum - galactic environment is unstable and would expand due to thermal pressure . for example , the pressure is @xmath132 higher than that of surrounding hot ionized medium , which has a typical density of @xmath141 @xmath21 and a temperature of @xmath142 k. the gas is also unlikely to be gravitational condensed because the minimum mass for a cloud to reach a equilibrium between gravity and thermal pressure is @xmath143 , which is unlikely to be true . using the strmgren radius of @xmath144 pc estimated from ionization parameter and density of feature s , and the sound speed @xmath145 @xmath2 , the life time of a high density cloud is estimated to be @xmath140 yr , far shorter than the dynamic time scale of an outflow which is expected to form feature s. thus there must be a mechanism to continuously regenerate the observed high density clouds if feature s indeed comes from the outflow . considering that sbs 1421 + 511 is likely to be a merging system , an alternative possible origin is that the eelrs are tidal tails which are illuminated by quasar . apart from the suggestion by the close projected distance and little velocity difference , there are also two pieces of evidence of strong interactions between the two galaxies . one is that the residual of sdss 2-d spatial decomposition ( figure 3(f ) ) shows a feature in northwest direction from the center of the companion galaxy . the other is that the companion galaxy shows an off - center hii region , which is rare among isolated galaxies and can be naturally interpreted as a tidal tail of the companion galaxy . one can imagine the natures of the two emission line features of sbs 1421 + 511 according to nearby mergers : feature n comes from the bridges between the two galaxies and the tidal tails of the quasar companion , and feature s comes from the tidal tails of the quasar host . thus the two features can be understand in a unified scenario . since eelrs associated with tidal features generally show correspondence between the continuum and emission - line morphologies while those ejected by outflow unnecessarily do , the distribution maps of emission line and continuum may help distinguish the two possible origins , tidal or outflow . however we can not make a detailed analysis based on keck data taken under 1.4@xmath0 seeing condition . new observations with higher spatial resolution are required , which would map the structure and dynamic of the system , and thus help to clarify the origin of the eelr in sbs 1421 + 511 . we selected sbs 1421 + 511 from sdss dr7 quasar catalog as a recoiling super - massive black hole candidate for that the bels show blue - skewed profile with a peak velocity of @xmath13300 @xmath2 blueshifted relative to nels and that there is offset between the quasar and the nearby extended source . we presented results of keck esi long slit spectrographic observation of sbs 1421 + 511 . by applying spectral and spatial decomposition technics , we identified an host galaxy at the quasar position and a companion galaxy 3@xmath0 north to the quasar with velocity difference of 120 @xmath2 relative to the host galaxy . thus the off - nuclear agn character is not due to a recoiling black hole , but due to a close companion of the quasar . we fitted the profile of h@xmath5 bel using disk models , which are the most successful model for agns with similar profiles . a circular disk model can well fit the data only if applying an ad hoc blueshift of @xmath11400 @xmath2 , and the elliptical disk model is ruled out . we detected no change of the peak velocity of the profile among mdm , sdss and keck observations , setting a 3@xmath42 upper limit of the velocity change rate of 14 @xmath2per year , and thus the period of the velocity change is @xmath107200 yrs . the non - detection of velocity change is inconsistent with the three models : emission from a circular disk with an orbiting bright spot , emission from a circular disk which orbiting around an unseen companion and emission from binary broad line regions . remained are three models : emission from a circular disk which is accompanied with a super - massive black hole recoiling at a velocity of @xmath11400 @xmath2 , emission from a circular disk with spiral emissivity perturbations and emission from a bipolar outflow , and the first is the most likely . thus sbs 1421 + 511 may hold a supermassive recoiling black hole . the companion galaxy shows seyfert - like line ratios and strong [ oiii ] emission with a luminosity of @xmath3 , suggesting that it may also be an agn and hence sbs 1421 + 511 is a dual agn system . intriguingly , an eelr is detected in the opposite direction of the companion southern to the quasar and thus the companion galaxy may only appear to be active . there are two possible interpretations . one is that the eelr has a bipolar structure and the northern half just coincide with the companion galaxy . the other is that the gas in the companion is illuminated by the quasar other than its own agn , which is supported by a simulation with photo - ionization model . the unsolved mysteries in sbs 1421 + 511 need follow - up observations . future optical spectral monitoring and ultraviolet spectrometry are needed to make a better understand on the nature of the bel of sbs 1421 + 511 and test whether it host a super - massive recoiling black hole . future narrow line imaging or ifs observations with sub - arcsec ( @xmath1021 kpc ) spatial resolutions are required to reveal possible merging features to determine whether the two galaxies are physically connected , and to map the [ oiii ] brightness distribution to tell whether the companion is active . the data presented herein were obtained at the w. m. keck observatory , which is operated as a scientific partnership among the california institute of technology , the university of california and the national aeronautics and space administration . the observatory was made possible by the generous financial support of the w. m. keck foundation . we are grateful to the anonymous referee for his / her helpful comments and for pointing out possibilities of the emission line features . we also would like to thank j. x. prochaska for helping us learn keck observations and data reduction using his program , and thank g. li for offering language assistant . this work is supported by the nsfc grant ( 11421303 , 11473025 , nsf11033007 ) , national basic research program of china ( 973 program , 2013cb834905 ) , the soc program ( chinare2012 - 02 - 03 ) , and fundamental research funds for the central universities ( wk 2030220010 ) . brzan , l. , mcnamara , b. r. , nulsen , p. e. j. , et al . 2008 , apj , 686 , 859 bogdanovi , t. , eracleous , m. , & sigurdsson , s. 2009 , apj , 697 , 288 bruzual , g. , & charlot , s. 2003 , mnras , 344 , 1000 campanelli , m. , lousto , c. , zlochower , y. , et al . 2007 , apj , 659 , l5 chen , k. , halpern , j. p. , & filippenko , a. v. 1989 , apj , 339 , 742 elvis , m. , wilkes , b. j. , mcdowell , j. c. , et al . 1994 , apjs , 95 , 1 eracleous , m. , livio , m. , halpern , j. p. , et al . 1995 , apj , 438 , 610 eracleous , m. , halpern , j. p. , m. gilbert , a. , et al . 1997 , apj , 490 , 216 eracleous , m. , & halpern , j. p. , 2003 , apj , 599 , 886 eracleous , m. , boroson , t. a. , halpern , jules p. , et al . 2012 , apjs , 201 , 23 fabian , a. c. 2012 , ara&a , 50 , 455 ferland , g. j. , korista , k. t. , verner , d. a. , et al . 1998 , pasp , 110 , 761 filippenko , a. v. 1985 , aj , 90 , 1172 fu , h. , & stockton , a. 2009 , apj , 690 , 953 gezari , s. , halpern , j. p. , & eracleous , m. , 2007 , apjs , 169 , 167 greene , j. e. , & ho , luis c. 2006 , apj , 641 , l21 greene , j. e. , zakamska , n. l. , & smith , p. s. 2012 , apj , 746 , 86 helmboldt , j. f. , taylor , g. b. , tremblay , s. , et al . 2007 , apj , 658 , 203 kauffmann , g. , heckman , t. m. , tremonti , c. , et al . 2003 , mnras , 346 , 1055 kewley , l. j. , groves , b. , kauffmann , g. , et al . 2006 , mnras , 372 , 961 komossa , s. , burwitz , v. , hasinger , g. , et al . 2003 , apj , 582 , l15 komossa , s. , xu , d .- w . , zhou , h .- y . , et al . , 2008 , apj , 680 , 926 lousto , c. o. , zlochower , y. , dotti , m. , et al . 2012 , phrvd , 85 . l4015 lewis , k. t. , eracleous , m. , & storchi - bergmann , t. , 2010 , apjs , 187 , 416 mcgurk , r. c. , max , c. e. , rosario , d. j. , et al . 2011 , apj , 738 , 2 merloni , a. , & heinz , s. 2007 , mnras , 381 , 589 newman , j. a. , eracleous , m. , filippenko , a. v. , et al . 1997 , apj , 485 , 570 osterbrock , d. e. , & ferland , g. j. 2006 , astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei , second edition peng , c. y. , ho , l. c. , impey , c. d. , et al . 2010 , aj , 139 , 2097 peterson , b. m. 1997 , an introduction to active galactic nuclei , cambridge univ . press , cambridge rupke , d. s. , veilleux , s. , & sanders , d. b. , 2005 , apjs , 160 , 115 schneider , d. p. , hall , p. b. , richards , g. t , et al . , 2007 , aj , 134 , 102 shields , g. a. , rosario , d. j. , smith , k. l. , et al . 2009 , apj , 707 , 936 shih , h .- y . , & stockton , a. 2014 , apj , 794 , 117 stockton , a. , & mackenty , j. w. 1983 , natur , 305 , 678 stockton , a. , mackenty , j. w. , hu , e. m. , et al . 2002 , apj , 572 , 735 storchi - bergmann , t. , nemmen da silva , r. , eracleous , m. , et al . 2003 , apj , 598 , 956 storey , p. j. , & hummer , d. g. 1995 , mnras , 272 , 41 van dokkum , p. g. 2001 , pasp , 113 , 1420 vanden berk , d. e. , richards , g. t. , bauer , a. , et al . 2001 , aj , 122 , 549 viegas , s. m. , & prieto , m. a. 1992 , mnras , 258 , 483 vivek , m. , srianand , r. , noterdaeme , p. , et al . 2009 , mnras , 400 , 6 volonteri , m. , & madau , p. 2008 , apj , 687 , l57 wagner , a. y. , bicknell , g. v. , & umemura , m. 2012 , apj , 757 , 136 wang , j .- m . , chen , y .- m . , hu , c. , et al . 2009 , apj , 705 , 76 xu , d .- w . , komossa , s. , zhou , h .- y . , et al . 2007 , apj , 670 , 60 cccc & [ oiii]/h@xmath14 & [ nii]/h@xmath5 & [ sii]/h@xmath5 + + aperhii & @xmath146 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 + aperhii & @xmath149 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 + hii - like set & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 + + apern & @xmath155 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 + agn - like set & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & @xmath160 + + apers & @xmath161 & @xmath162 & @xmath163 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: geometrical dynamics is a dynamics of elementary particles , generated by the space - time geometry . in the space - time of minkowski the geometrical dynamics coincides with the conventional classical dynamics , and the geometrical dynamics may be considered to be a generalization of classical dynamics onto more general space - time geometries . however , the geometric dynamics has more fundamental basis , and it may be defined in multivariant space - time geometries , where one can not introduce the conventional classical dynamics . the fact is that , the classical dynamics has been introduced for the space - time geometry with unlimited divisibility , whereas the real space - time has a limited divisibility . the limited divisibility of the space - time is of no importance for dynamics of macroscopic bodies . however , when the size of moving bodies is of the order of the size of heterogeneity , one may not neglect the limited divisibility of the space - time geometry . the geometric dynamics is developed in the framework of the program of the further physics geometrization , declared in @xcite . the special relativity and the general relativity are steps in the development of this program . necessity of the further development appeared in the thirtieth of the twentieth century , when diffraction of electrons has been discovered . the motion of electrons , passing through the narrow slit , is multivariant . as far as the free electron motion depends only on the properties of the space - time , one needed to change the space - time geometry , making it to be multivariant . in multivariant geometry there are many vectors @xmath1 , @xmath2, ... at the point @xmath3 , which are equal to the vector @xmath4 , given at the point @xmath5 , but they are not equal between themselves , in general . such a space - time geometry was not known in the beginning of the twentieth century . it is impossible in the framework of the riemannian geometry . as a result the multivariance was prescribed to dynamics . to take into account multivariance , dynamic variables were replaced by matrices and operators . one obtains the quantum dynamics , which differs from the classical dynamics in its principles . but the space - time conception remains to be newtonian ( nonrelativistic ) . multivariant space - time geometry appeared only in the end of the twentieth century @xcite . the further geometrization of physics became to be possible . it should note that there were numerous attempts of further geometrization of physics . they were based on the riemannian space - time geometry . unfortunately , the true space - time geometry of microcosm does not belong to the class of riemannian geometries , and approximation of real space - time geometry by a riemannian geometry can not be completely successful . in particular , the riemannian geometry can not describe such a property of real space - time geometry as multivariance . the multivariance of the space - time geometry was replaced by the multivariance of dynamics ( quantum theory ) . understanding of nature of elementary particles is the aim of the further geometr - ization of physics . this aim distinguishes from the aim of the conventional theory of elementary particles . let us explain the difference of aims in the example of history the chemical elements investigation . investigation of chemical elements reminds to some extent investigation of elementary particles . chemical elements are investigated from two sides . chemists systematized chemical elements , investigating their phenomenological properties . the results of these investigations were formulated in the form of the periodical system of chemical elements in 1870 . formulating this system , d.i.mendeleev conceived nothing about the atom construction . nevertheless the periodical system appears to be very useful from the practical viewpoint . physicists did not aim to explain the periodical system of chemical elements , they tried to understand simply the atom structure and the discrete character of atomic spectra . after construction of the atomic theory it became clear , that the periodical system of chemical elements can be obtained and explained on the basis of the atomic theory . as a result the `` physical '' approach to investigation of chemical elements appeared to be more fundamental , deep and promising , than the `` chemical '' one . on the other hand , the way of the `` physical '' approach to explanation of the periodical system is very long and difficult . explanation of the periodical system was hardly possible at the `` physical '' approach , i.e. without the intermediate aim ( construction of atomic structure ) . thus , using geometrization of physics , we try to approach only intermediate aim : explanation of multivariance of particle motion ( quantum motion ) and capacity of discrimination of particle masses . discrete character of masses of elementary particles can be understood , only if we understand the reason of the elementary particle discrimination . contemporary approach to the elementary particle theory is the `` chemical '' ( phenomenological ) approach . it is useful from the practical viewpoint . however , it admits hardly to understand nature of elementary particles , because the nature of the discrimination mechanism , leading to discrete characteristics of elementary particle , remains outside the consideration . the most general geometry is a physical geometry , which is called also the tubular geometry ( t - geometry ) @xcite , because straights in t - geometry are hallow tubes , in general . the t - geometry is determined completely by its world function @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is interval between the points @xmath8 and @xmath9 in space - time , described by the t - geometry . all concepts of t - geometry are expressed in terms of the world function @xmath0 . dynamics of particles ( geometric dynamics ) is also described in terms of the world function . the elementary particle is considered as an elementary geometrical object ( ego ) in the space - time . the elementary geometrical object @xmath10 is described by its skeleton @xmath11 and its envelope @xmath12 . the envelope @xmath12 is defined as a set of zeros of the envelope function @xmath13@xmath14the envelope function @xmath13 is a real function of arguments @xmath15 . any argument @xmath16 @xmath17 is a world function @xmath18 , @xmath19 . it is supposed that ego with skeleton @xmath20 is placed at the point @xmath5 . in t - geometry the vector @xmath21 is an ordered set of two points @xmath22 . the length @xmath23 of the vector @xmath4 is defined via the world function by means of the relation@xmath24 the scalar product @xmath25 of two vectors @xmath4 and @xmath1 is defined by the relation@xmath26equivalence @xmath4eqv@xmath1 of two vectors @xmath4 and @xmath1 is defined as follows . two vectors @xmath4 and @xmath1 are equivalent ( equal ) , if@xmath27 in the developed form we have@xmath28 skeletons @xmath20 and @xmath29 are equivalent ( @xmath30eqv@xmath31 , if corresponding vectors of both skeletons are equivalent@xmath32 the skeleton @xmath20 of ego at the point @xmath5 may exist as a skeleton of a physical body , if it may exist at any point @xmath33 of the space - time @xmath34 . it means that there is a solution for system of equations @xmath35for any point @xmath33 . further for brevity we take , that an existence of a skeleton means an existence of corresponding geometrical object . in the space - time of minkowski the problem of the skeleton existence is rather simple , because at given @xmath30 and @xmath3 the system ( [ c1.6 ] ) of @xmath36 algebraic equations has a unique solution , although the number of equations may distinguish from the number of variables to be determined . indeed , in the four - dimensional space - time the number of coordinates of @xmath37 points @xmath38 is equal to @xmath39 ( the point @xmath3 is supposed to be given ) . if @xmath40 the number @xmath36 of equations is larger than the number ( @xmath39 ) of variables . in the case of an arbitrary space - time geometry ( arbitrary world function @xmath0 ) existence of solution of the system ( [ c1.6 ] ) is problematic , and the question of existence of the skeleton as a skeleton of a physical body is an essential problem . on the contrary , if @xmath41 , the number of coordinates to be determined is less , than the number of equations , and one may have many skeletons @xmath42placed at the point @xmath3 , which are equivalent to skeleton @xmath30 , but they are not equivalent between themselves . this property is a property of multivariance of the space - time geometry . this property is actual for simple skeletons , which contain less , than four points ( @xmath41 ) . for instance , for the skeleton of two points @xmath43 , which is described by the vector @xmath4 , the problem of multivariance is actual . in the space - time of minkowski the equivalence of two vectors ( @xmath44 ) is single - variant for the timelike vectors , however it is multivariant for spacelike vectors . in the general space - time the equivalence relation @xmath44 is multivariant for both timelike and spacelike vectors . the problem of multivariance is essential for both existence and dynamics of elementary geometrical objects ( elementary particles ) . let us formulate dynamics of elementary particles in the coordinateless form . dynamics of an elementary particle , having skeleton @xmath11 , is described by the world chain @xmath45direction of evolution in the space - time is described by the leading vector @xmath4 . if the motion of the elementary particle is free , the adjacent links @xmath46 and @xmath47 are equivalent in the sense that @xmath48 relations ( [ c1.7 ] ) - ( [ c1.9 ] ) realizes coordinateless description of the free elementary particle motion . in the simplest case , when the space - time is the space - time of minkowski , and the skeleton consists of two points @xmath49 with timelike leading vector @xmath4 , the coordinateless description by means of relations ( [ c1.7 ] ) - ( [ c1.9 ] ) coincides with the conventional description . the conventional classical dynamics is well defined only in the riemannian space - time . the coordinateless dynamic description ( [ c1.7 ] ) - ( [ c1.9 ] ) of elementary particles is a generalization of the conventional classical dynamics onto the case of arbitrary space - time geometry . any geometry is constructed as a modification of the proper euclidean geometry . but not all representations of the proper euclidean geometry are convenient for modification . there are three representation of the proper euclidean geometry @xcite . they differ in the number of primary ( basic ) elements , forming the euclidean geometry . the euclidean representation ( e - representation ) contains three basic elements ( point , segment , angle ) . any geometrical object ( figure ) can be constructed of these basic elements . properties of the basic elements and the method of their application are described by the euclidean axioms . the vector representation ( v - representation ) of the proper euclidean geometry contains two basic elements ( point , vector ) . the angle is a derivative element , which is constructed of two vectors . a use of the two basic elements at the construction of geometrical objects is determined by the special structure , known as the linear vector space with the scalar product , given on it ( euclidean space ) . the scalar product of linear vector space describes interrelation of two basic elements ( vectors ) , whereas other properties of the linear vector space associate with the displacement of vectors . the third representation ( @xmath0-representation ) of the proper euclidean geometry contains only one basic element ( point ) . segment ( vector ) is a derivative element . it is constructed of points . the angle is also a derivative element . it is constructed of two segments ( vectors ) . the @xmath50-representation contains a special structure : world function @xmath0 , which describes interrelation of two basic elements ( points ) . the world function @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the distance between points @xmath5 and @xmath53 . the concept of distance @xmath54 , as well as the world function @xmath0 , is used in all representations of the proper euclidean geometry . however , the world function forms a structure only in the @xmath0-representation , where the world function @xmath0 describes interrelation of two basic elements ( points ) . besides , the world function satisfies a series of constraints , formulated in terms of @xmath0 and only in terms of @xmath0 . these conditions ( the euclideaness conditions ) will be formulated below . the euclideaness conditions are equivalent to a use of the vector linear space with the scalar product on it , but formally they do not mention the linear vector space , because all concepts of the linear vector space , as well as all concepts of the proper euclidean geometry are expressed directly via world function @xmath0 and only via it . if we want to modify the proper euclidean geometry , then we should use the @xmath0-representation for its modification . in the @xmath0-representation the special geometric structure ( world function ) has the form of a function of two points . modifying the form of the world function , we modify automatically all concepts of the proper euclidean geometry , which are expressed via the world function . it is very important , that the expression of geometrical concepts via the world function does not refer to the means of description ( dimension , coordinate system , concept of a curve ) . the fact , that modifying the world function , one violates the euclideaness conditions , is of no importance , because one obtains non - euclidean geometry as a result of such a modification . a change of the world function means a change of the distance , which is interpreted as a deformation of the proper euclidean geometry . the generalized geometry , obtained by a deformation of the proper euclidean geometry is called the tubular geometry ( t - geometry ) , because in the generalized geometry straight lines are tubes ( surfaces ) , in general , but not one - dimensional lines . another name of t - geometry is the physical geometry . the physical geometry is the geometry , described completely by the world function . any physical geometry may be used as a space - time geometry in the sense , that the set of all t - geometries is the set of all possible space - time geometries . modification of the proper euclidean geometry in v - representation is very restricted , because in this representation there are two basic elements . they are not independent , and one can not modify them independently . formally it means , that the linear vector space is to be preserved as a geometrical structure . it means , in particular , that the generalized geometry retains to be continuous , uniform and isotropic . the dimension of the generalized geometry is to be fixed . besides , the generalized geometry , obtained by such a way , can not be multivariant . such a property of the space - time geometry as multivariance can be obtained only in @xmath0-representation . as far as the @xmath0-representation of the proper euclidean geometry was not known in the twentieth century , the multivariance of geometry was also unknown concept . transition from the v - representation to @xmath0-representation is carried out as follows . all concepts of the linear vector space are expressed in terms of the world function @xmath0 . in reality , concepts of vector , scalar product of two vectors and linear dependence of @xmath37 vectors are expressed via the world function @xmath55 of the proper euclidean geometry . such operations under vectors as equality of vectors , summation of vectors and multiplication of a vector by a real number are expressed by means of some formulae . the characteristic properties of these operations , which are given in v - representation by means of axioms , are given now by special properties of the euclidean world function @xmath55 . after expression of the linear vector space via the world function the linear vector space may be not mentioned , because all its properties are described by the world function . we obtain the @xmath0-representation of the proper euclidean geometry , where some properties of the linear vector space are expressed in the form of formulae , whereas another part of properties is hidden in the specific form of the euclidean world function @xmath55 . modifying world function , we modify automatically the properties of the linear vector space ( which is not mentioned in fact ) . at such a modification we are not to think about the way of modification of the linear vector space , which is the principal geometrical structure in the v - representation . in the @xmath0-representation the linear vector space is a derivative structure , which may be not mentioned at all . thus , at transition to @xmath0-representation the concepts of the linear vector space ( primary concepts in v - representation ) become to be secondary concepts ( derivative concepts of the @xmath0-representation ) . in @xmath0-representation we have the following expressions for concepts of the proper euclidean geometry . vector @xmath56 is an ordered set of two points @xmath8 and @xmath9 . the length @xmath57 of the vector @xmath58 is defined by the relation@xmath59the scalar product @xmath25 of two vectors @xmath4 and @xmath1 is defined by the relation@xmath60where the world function @xmath0@xmath61is the world function @xmath55 of the euclidean geometry . in the proper euclidean geometry @xmath37 vectors @xmath62 , @xmath63 are linear dependent , if and only if the gram s determinant @xmath64 where the gram s determinant @xmath65 is defined by the relation @xmath66using expression ( [ a1.1 ] ) for the scalar product , the condition of the linear dependence of @xmath37 vectors @xmath62 , @xmath63 is written in the form@xmath67 definition ( [ a1.1 ] ) of the scalar product of two vectors coincides with the conventional scalar product of vectors in the proper euclidean space . ( one can verify this easily ) . the relations ( [ a1.1 ] ) , ( [ a1.7b ] ) do not contain a reference to the dimension of the euclidean space and to a coordinate system in it . hence , the relations ( [ a1.1 ] ) , ( [ a1.7b ] ) are general geometric relations , which may be considered as a definition of the scalar product of two vectors and that of the linear dependence of vectors . equivalence ( equality ) of two vectors @xmath4 and @xmath1 is defined by the relations@xmath68where @xmath23 is the length ( [ a1.0 ] ) of the vector @xmath4@xmath69 in the developed form the condition ( [ a1.3 ] ) of equivalence of two vectors @xmath4 and @xmath1 has the form@xmath70 let the points @xmath49 , determining the vector @xmath4 , and the origin @xmath3 of the vector @xmath1 be given . let @xmath4eqv@xmath1 . we can determine the vector @xmath1 , solving two equations ( [ a1.5 ] ) , ( [ a1.6 ] ) with respect to the position of the point @xmath71 . in the case of the proper euclidean space there is one and only one solution of equations ( [ a1.5 ] ) , ( [ a1.6 ] ) independently of the space dimension @xmath37 . in the case of arbitrary t - geometry one can guarantee neither existence nor uniqueness of the solution of equations ( [ a1.5 ] ) , ( [ a1.6 ] ) for the point @xmath71 . number of solutions depends on the form of the world function @xmath0 . this fact means a multivariance of the property of two vectors equivalence in the arbitrary t - geometry . in other words , the single - variance of the vector equality in the proper euclidean space is a specific property of the proper euclidean geometry , and this property is conditioned by the form of the euclidean world function . in other t - geometries this property does not take place , in general . the multivariance is a general property of a physical geometry . it is connected with a necessity of solution of algebraic equations , containing the world function . as far as the world function is different in different physical geometries , the solution of these equations may be not unique , or it may not exist at all . if in the @xmath37-dimensional euclidean space @xmath72 , the vectors @xmath62 , @xmath63 are linear independent . we may construct rectilinear coordinate system with basic vectors @xmath62 , @xmath63 in the @xmath37-dimensional euclidean space . covariant coordinates @xmath73 of the vector @xmath74 in this coordinate system have the form@xmath75 now we can formulate the euclideaness conditions . these conditions are conditions of the fact , that the t - geometry , described by the world function @xmath0 , is @xmath37-dimensional proper euclidean geometry . i. definition of the dimension and introduction of the rectilinear coordinate system : @xmath76where @xmath77 is the gram s determinant ( a1.7 ) . vectors @xmath78 , @xmath79 are basic vectors of the rectilinear coordinate system @xmath80 with the origin at the point @xmath5 . in @xmath80 the covariant metric tensor @xmath81 , @xmath82 and the contravariant one @xmath83 , @xmath82 are defined by the relations @xmath84@xmath85 \ii . linear structure of the euclidean space : @xmath86where coordinates @xmath87 @xmath88 of the point @xmath8 are covariant coordinates of the vector @xmath74 , defined by the relation ( [ a1.8 ] ) . iii : the metric tensor matrix @xmath89 has only positive eigenvalues @xmath90 \iv . the continuity condition : the system of equations @xmath91considered to be equations for determination of the point @xmath8 as a function of coordinates @xmath92 , @xmath88 has always one and only one solution . _ _ _ _ all conditions i @xmath93 iv contain a reference to the dimension @xmath37 of the euclidean space . one can show that conditions i @xmath93 iv are the necessary and sufficient conditions of the fact that the set @xmath34 together with the world function @xmath0 , given on @xmath94 , describes the @xmath37-dimensional euclidean space @xcite . investigation of the dirac particle ( dynamic system , described by the dirac equation ) has shown , that the dirac particle is a composite particle r2004 , whose internal degrees of freedom are described nonrelativistically @xcite . the composite structure of the dirac particle may be explained as a relativistic rotator , consisting of two ( or more ) particles , rotating around their inertia centre . the relativistic rotator explains existence of the dirac particle spin , however , the problem of the rotating particles confinement appears . in this paper we try to explain the problem of spin in the framework of the program of the physics geometrization , when dynamics of physical bodies is determined by the space - time geometry . although the first stages of the physics geometrization ( the special relativity and the general relativity ) manifest themselves very well , the papers on further geometrization of physics , which ignore the quantum principles , are considered usually as dissident . dynamics in the space - time , described by a physical geometry ( t - geometry ) , is presented in @xcite . here we remind the statement of the problem of dynamics . geometrical object @xmath95 is a subset of points in the point set @xmath34 . in the t - geometry the geometric object @xmath10 is described by means of the skeleton - envelope method . it means that any geometric object @xmath10 is considered to be a set of intersections and joins of elementary geometric objects ( ego ) . the elementary geometrical object @xmath12 is described by its skeleton @xmath30 and envelope function @xmath13 . the finite set @xmath96 of parameters of the envelope function @xmath13 is the skeleton of elementary geometric object ( ego ) @xmath97 . the set @xmath97 of points forming ego is called the envelope of its skeleton @xmath30 . the envelope function @xmath13@xmath98determining ego is a function of the running point @xmath99 and of parameters @xmath100 . the envelope function @xmath13 is supposed to be an algebraic function of @xmath101 arguments @xmath15 , @xmath102 . each of arguments @xmath103 is the world function @xmath0 of two points @xmath104 , either belonging to skeleton @xmath30 , or coinciding with the running point @xmath105 . thus , any elementary geometric object @xmath12 is determined by its skeleton @xmath30 and its envelope function @xmath13 . elementary geometric object @xmath12 is the set of zeros of the envelope function @xmath106__definition . _ _ two egos @xmath107 and @xmath108 are equivalent , if their skeletons @xmath30 and @xmath109 are equivalent and their envelope functions @xmath13 and @xmath110 are equivalent . equivalence ( @xmath30eqv@xmath109 ) of two skeletons @xmath111 and @xmath112 means that @xmath113equivalence of the envelope functions @xmath13 and @xmath110 means , that they have the same set of zeros . it means that @xmath114where @xmath115 is an arbitrary function , having the property@xmath116 evolution of ego @xmath117 in the space - time is described as a world chain @xmath118 of equivalent connected egos . the point @xmath5 of the skeleton @xmath11 is considered to be the origin of the geometrical object @xmath119 the ego @xmath117 is considered to be placed at its origin @xmath5 . let us consider a set of equivalent skeletons @xmath120 @xmath121which are equivalent in pairs @xmath122the skeletons @xmath123 @xmath121are connected , and they form a chain in the direction of vector @xmath4 , if the point @xmath53 of one skeleton coincides with the origin @xmath5 of the adjacent skeleton @xmath124the chain @xmath118 describes evolution of the elementary geometrical object @xmath117 in the direction of the leading vector @xmath4 . the evolution of ego @xmath117 is a temporal evolution , if the vectors @xmath125 are timelike @xmath126 @xmath127 . the evolution of ego @xmath117 is a spatial evolution , if the vectors @xmath125 are spacelike @xmath128 @xmath127 . note , that all adjacent links ( egos ) of the chain are equivalent in pairs , although two links of the chain may be not equivalent , if they are not adjacent . however , lengths of corresponding vectors are equal in all links of the chain @xmath129we shall refer to the vector @xmath125 , which determines the form of the evolution and the shape of the world chain , as the leading vector . this vector determines the direction of 4-velocity of the physical body , associated with the link of the world chain . if the relations@xmath130@xmath131are satisfied , the relations@xmath132are not satisfied , in general , because the relations ( [ a6.11 ] ) contain the scalar products @xmath133 . these scalar products contain the world functions @xmath134 , which are not contained in relations ( [ a6.9 ] ) , ( [ a6.10 ] ) . the world chain @xmath118 , consisting of equivalent links ( [ a6.1 ] ) , ( [ a6.2 ] ) , describes a free motion of a physical body ( particle ) , associated with the skeleton @xmath30 . we assume that _ the motion of physical body is free , if all points of the body move free _ ( i.e. without acceleration ) . if the external forces are absent , the physical body as a whole moves without acceleration . however , if the body rotates , one may not consider a motion of this body as a free motion , because not all points of this body move free ( without acceleration ) . in the rotating body there are internal forces , which generate centripetal acceleration of some points of the body . as a result some points of the body do not move free . motion of the rotating body may be free only on the average , but not exactly free . conception of non - free motion of a particle is rather indefinite , and we restrict ourselves with consideration of a free motion only . conventional conception of the motion of extensive ( non - pointlike ) particle , which is free on the average , contains a free displacement , described by the velocity 4-vector , and a spatial rotation , described by the angular velocity 3-pseudovector @xmath135 . the velocity 4-vector is associated with the timelike leading vector @xmath4 . at the free on the average motion of a rotating body some of vectors @xmath136 ... of the skeleton @xmath30 are not in parallel with vectors @xmath137 , although at the free motion all vectors @xmath138 are to be in parallel with @xmath137 as follows from ( [ a6.1 ] ) . it means that the world chain @xmath118 of a freely moving body can describe only translation of a physical body , but not its rotation . if the leading vector @xmath4 is spacelike , the body , described by the skeleton @xmath30 , evolves in the spacelike direction . it seems , that the spacelike evolution is prohibited . but it is not so . if the world chain forms a helix with the timelike axis , such a world chain may be considered as timelike on the average . in reality such world chains are possible . for instance , the world chain of the classical dirac particle is a helix with timelike axis . it is not quite clear , whether or not the links of this chain are spacelike , because internal degrees of freedom of the dirac particle , responsible for helicity of the world chain , are described nonrelativistically . thus , consideration of a spatial evolution is not meaningless , especially if we take into account , that the spatial evolution may imitate rotation , which is absent at the free motion of a particle . further we consider the problem of the spatial evolution . dirac particle @xmath139 is the dynamic system , described by the dirac equation . the free dirac particle @xmath139 is described by the free dirac equation @xmath140where @xmath141 is the four - component complex wave function , and @xmath142 , @xmath143 are @xmath144 complex matrices , satisfying the relations@xmath145@xmath146 is the @xmath144 unit matrix , @xmath147 is the metric tensor . expressions of physical quantities : the 4-flux @xmath148 of particles and the energy - momentum tensor @xmath149 have the form@xmath150where @xmath151 , @xmath152 is the hermitian conjugate to @xmath141 . the classical dirac particle is a dynamic system @xmath153 , which is obtained from the dynamic system @xmath139 in the classical limit . to obtain the classical limit , one may not set the quantum constant @xmath154 in the equation ( [ f1.2 ] ) , because in this case we do not obtain any reasonable description of the particle . the dirac particle @xmath139 is a quantum particle in the sense , that it is described by a system of partial differential equations ( pde ) , which contain the quantum constant @xmath155 . the classical dirac particle @xmath153 is described by a system of ordinary differential equations ( ode ) , which contain the quantum constant @xmath155 as a parameter . may the system of ode carry out the classical description , if it contains the quantum constant @xmath155 ? the answer depends on the viewpoint of investigator . if the investigator believes that _ the quantum constant is an attribute of quantum principles and only of quantum principles _ , he supposes that , containing @xmath155 , the dynamic equations can not realize a classical description , where the quantum principles are not used . however , if the investigator consider the classical description simply as method of investigation of the quantum dynamic equations , it is of no importance , whether or not the system of ode contains the quantum constant . it is important only , that the system of pde is approximated by a system of ode . the dynamic system , described by pde , contains infinite number of the freedom degrees . the dynamic system , described by ode , contains several degrees of freedom . it is simpler and can be investigated more effectively . obtaining the classical approximation , we use the procedure of dynamic disquantization @xcite . this procedure transforms the system of pde into the system of ode . the procedure of dynamic disquantization is a dynamical procedure , which has no relation to the process of quantization or disquantization in the sense , that it does not refer to the quantum principles . the dynamic disquantization means that all derivatives @xmath156 in dynamic equations are replaced by the projection of vector @xmath157 onto the current vector @xmath148 @xmath158this dynamical operation is called the dynamic disquantization , because , applying it to the schrdinger equation , we obtain the dynamic equations for the statistical ensemble of classical nonrelativistic particles . these dynamic equations are ode , which do not depend on the quantum constant @xmath155 . applying the operation ( [ b3.1 ] ) , to the dirac equation ( [ f1.2 ] ) , we transform it to the form@xmath159the equation ( [ b3.2 ] ) is the dynamic equation for the dynamic system system @xmath160 . the equation ( [ b3.2 ] ) contains only derivative @xmath161 in the direction of the current 4-vector @xmath148 . in terms of the wave function @xmath141 the dynamic equation ( [ b3.2 ] ) for @xmath160 looks rather bulky . however , in the properly chosen variables the action for the dynamic system @xmath160 has the form @xcite @xmath162=\int \left\ { -\kappa _ { 0}m\sqrt{\dot{x}^{i}\dot{x}_{i}}+\hbar { \frac{(\dot{\mathbf{\xi } } \times \mathbf{\xi } ) \mathbf{z}}{2(1+\mathbf{\xi z})}}+\hbar \frac{(\dot{\mathbf{x}}\times \ddot{\mathbf{x}})\mathbf{\xi } } { 2\sqrt{\dot{x}^{s}\dot{x}_{s}}(\sqrt{\dot{x}^{s}\dot{x}_{s}}+\dot{x}^{0})}\right\ } d^{4}\tau \label{a5.18}\]]where the dot means the total derivative @xmath163 . the quantities @xmath164 , @xmath165 , @xmath166 , @xmath167 are considered to be functions of the lagrangian coordinates @xmath168 , @xmath169 . the variables @xmath170 describe position of the dirac particle . here and in what follows the symbol @xmath171 means the vector product of two 3-vectors . the quantity@xmath172 is the constant unit 3-vector , @xmath173 is a dichotomic quantity @xmath174 , @xmath175 is the constant ( mass ) taken from the dirac equation ( [ f1.2 ] ) . in fact , variables @xmath170 depend on @xmath176 as on parameters , because the action ( [ a5.18 ] ) does not contain derivatives with respect to @xmath177 , @xmath167 . lagrangian density of the action ( [ a5.18 ] ) does not contain independent variables @xmath178 explicitly . hence , it may be written in the form @xmath162=\int \mathcal{a}_{\mathrm{dcl}}[x,\mathbf{\xi } ] d\mathbf{\tau , \qquad } d\mathbf{\tau } = d\tau _ { 1}d\tau _ { 2}d\tau _ { 3 } \label{b3.8}\]]where @xmath179=\int \left\ { -\kappa _ { 0}m\sqrt{\dot{x}^{i}\dot{x}_{i}}+\hbar { \frac{(\dot{\mathbf{\xi } } \times \mathbf{\xi } ) \mathbf{z}}{2(1+\mathbf{\xi z})}}+\hbar \frac{(\dot{\mathbf{x}}\times \ddot{\mathbf{x}})\mathbf{\xi } } { 2\sqrt{\dot{x}^{s}\dot{x}_{s}}(\sqrt{\dot{x}^{s}\dot{x}_{s}}+\dot{x}^{0})}\right\ } d\tau _ { 0 } \label{b3.9}\ ] ] the action ( [ b3.8 ] ) is the action for the dynamic system @xmath160 , which is a set of similar independent dynamic systems @xmath153 . such a dynamic system is called a statistical ensemble . dynamic systems @xmath153 are elements ( constituents ) of the statistical ensemble @xmath160 . dynamic equations for each @xmath153 form a system of ordinary differential equations . it may be interpreted in the sense , that the dynamic system @xmath153 may be considered to be a classical one , although lagrangian of @xmath153 contains the quantum constant @xmath155 . the dynamic system @xmath180 will be referred to as the classical dirac particle . the dynamic system @xmath153 has ten degrees of freedom . it describes a composite particle @xcite . external degrees of freedom are described relativistically by variables @xmath170 . internal degrees of freedom are described nonrelativistically @xcite by variables @xmath181 . solution of dynamic equations , generated by the action ( [ b3.9 ] ) , gives the following result @xcite . in the coordinate system , where the canonical momentum four - vector @xmath182 has the form @xmath183the world line of the classical dirac particle is a helix , which is described by the relation @xmath184where the speed of the light @xmath185 , and @xmath186 is an arbitrary constant ( lorentz factor of the classical dirac particle ) . the velocity @xmath187 of the classical dirac particle is expressed as follows @xmath188 helical world line of the classical dirac particle means a rotation of the particle around some point . on the one hand , such a rotation seems to be reasonable , because it explains freely the dirac particle spin and magnetic moment . on the other hand , the description of this rotation is nonrelativistic . besides , it seems rather strange , that the world line of a free classical particle is a helix , but not a straight line . attempt of consideration of the dirac particle as a rotator , consisting of two particles @xcite , meets the problem of confinement of the two particles . although the pure dynamical methods of investigation are more general and effective , than the investigation methods , based on quantum principles , the purely dynamical methods of investigation meet incomprehension of most investigators , who believe , that the dirac particle must be investigated by quantum methods . the papers , devoted to investigation of the dirac equation by the dynamic methods , are considered as dissident . they are rejected by the peer review journals ( see discussion in @xcite ) . suddenly it is discovered that the helical world line , which is characteristic for the classical dirac particle , can be obtained as a result of a spatial evolution of geometric objects in the framework of properly chosen space - time geometry . let us consider the flat homogeneous isotropic space - time @xmath189 , described by the world function @xmath190@xmath191@xmath192where @xmath193 is the world function of the @xmath194-dimensional space - time of minkowski . @xmath195 is some elementary length . in such a space - time geometry two connected equivalent timelike vectors @xmath4 and @xmath196 are described as follows @xcite @xmath197where @xmath198 is an arbitrary unit 3-vector . the quantity @xmath199 is the length of the vector @xmath4 ( geometrical mass , associated with the particle , which is described by the vector @xmath4 ) . we see that the spatial part of the vector @xmath196 is determined to within the arbitrary 3-vector of the length @xmath200 . this multivariance generates wobbling of the links of the world chain , consisting of equivalent timelike vectors @xmath201 , @xmath196 , @xmath202 , ... statistical description of the chain with wobbling links coincides with the quantum description of the particle with the mass @xmath203 , if the elementary length @xmath204 , where @xmath205 is the speed of the light , @xmath155 is the quantum constant , and @xmath206 is some universal constant , whose exact value is not determined @xcite , because the statistical description does not contain the quantity @xmath206 . thus , the characteristic wobbling length is of the order of @xmath195 . to explain the quantum description of the particle motion as a statistical description of the multivariant classical motion , we should use the world function ( [ a4.1 ] ) however , the form of the world function ( [ a4.1 ] ) is determined by the coincidence of the two descriptions only for the value @xmath207 , where the constant @xmath208 is determined via the mass @xmath209 of the lightest massive particle ( electron ) by means of the relation @xmath210where @xmath211 is the geometrical mass of the lightest massive particle ( electron ) . the geometrical mass @xmath212 of the same particle , considered in the space - time geometry of minkowski , has the form@xmath213as far as @xmath214 , and , hence , @xmath215 , we obtain the following estimation for the universal constant @xmath206@xmath216 intensity of wobbling may be described by the multivariance vector @xmath217 , which is defined as follows . let @xmath196 , @xmath218 be two vectors which are equivalent to the vector @xmath219 . let @xmath220let us consider the vector @xmath221which is a difference of vectors @xmath196 , @xmath218 . we consider the length @xmath222 of the vector @xmath223 in the minkowski space - time . we obtain@xmath224the length of the vector ( [ a4.3a ] ) is minimal at @xmath225 . at @xmath226 the length of the vector ( [ a4.3a ] ) is maximal , and it is equal to zero . by definition the vector @xmath223 at @xmath225 is the multivariance 4-vector @xmath217 , which describes the intensity of the multivariance . we have @xmath227where @xmath198 is an arbitrary unit 3-vector . the multivariance vector @xmath217 is spacelike in the case , when @xmath228 , the corresponding wobbling length @xmath229where @xmath230 is the electron compton wave length . the relation ( [ a4.3 ] ) means that @xmath231for other values @xmath232 the form of the world function @xmath233 may distinguish from the relation ( [ a4.4 ] ) . however , @xmath234 , if @xmath235 . two equivalent connected spacelike vectors @xmath1 , @xmath236 have the form @xcite@xmath237where constants @xmath238 and @xmath239 are arbitrary . the result is obtained for the space - time geometry ( [ a4.0 ] ) . arbitrariness of constants @xmath240 generates multivariance of the vector @xmath236 even in the space - time geometry of minkowski , where @xmath241 . vectors @xmath236 , @xmath242 @xmath243are equivalent to the vector @xmath1 . the difference @xmath244 of two vectors @xmath236 , @xmath242 has the form@xmath245the vector @xmath244 may be spacelike and timelike . its length has an extremum , if @xmath246 and @xmath247 . in this case the length @xmath248 however , the length@xmath249has neither maximum , nor minimum , and one can not introduce the multivariance vector of the type ( [ a4.3c ] ) . the multivariance of the spacelike vectors equality is not introduced by the distortion @xmath250 , defined by ( [ a4.0a ] ) . it takes place already in the space - time of minkowski . in the conventional approach to the geometry of minkowski one does not accept the multivariance of spacelike vectors equivalence . furthermore , the concept of multivariance of two vectors parallelism ( and equality ) is absent at all in the conventional approach to the geometry . for instance , when in the riemannian geometry the multivariance of parallelism of remote vectors appears , the mathematicians prefer to deny at all the fernparallelism ( parallelism of two remote vectors ) , but not to introduce the concept of multivariance . this circumstance is connected with the fact , that the multivariance may not appear , if the geometry is constructed on the basis of a system of axioms . the world chain , consisting of timelike equivalent vectors , imitates a world line of a free particle . this fact seems to be rather reasonable . considering the vectors @xmath1 and @xmath236 in ( [ a6.50 ] ) from the viewpoint of the geometry of minkowski , we see that the vector @xmath236 is obtained from the vector @xmath1 as a result of spatial rotation and of an addition of some temporal component . one should expect , that the world chain , consisting of spacelike equivalent vectors , imitates a world line of a free particle , moving with a superluminal velocity . the motion with the superluminal velocity seems to be unobservable . such a motion is considered to be impossible . however , if the spacelike world line has a shape of a helix with timelike axis , such a situation may be considered as a free rotating particle . the fact , that the particle rotates with the superluminal velocity is not so important , if the helix axis is timelike . the world line of a classical dirac particle is a helix . it is not very important , whether the rotation velocity is tardyon or not . especially , if we take into account that the dirac equation describes the internal degrees of freedom ( rotation ) nonrelativistically , ( i.e. the description of internal degrees of the classical dirac particle is incorrect from the viewpoint of the relativity theory ) . we investigate now , whether a world chain of equivalent spacelike vectors may form a helix with timelike axis . if it is possible , then we try to investigate , under which world function such a situation is possible . we consider the world function @xmath233 of the form @xmath251where the function @xmath252 should be determined from the condition , that the world chain , consisting of spacelike links , forms a helix with timelike axis . to estimate the form of @xmath233 as a function of @xmath193 at @xmath232 , we consider the chain , consisting of equivalent spacelike vectors ... @xmath4 , @xmath196 , @xmath253 ... we suppose that the chain is a helix with timelike axis in the space - time . let the points @xmath254 . have the coordinates@xmath255all points ( [ a4.6 ] ) lie on a helix with timelike axis . in the space - time of minkowski the step of helix is equal to @xmath256 , and @xmath105 is the radius of the helix . the constants @xmath257 and @xmath258 are parameters of the helix . all vectors @xmath259 have the same length . introducing designations [ 02beg]@xmath260we obtain coordinates of vectors @xmath259 in the form @xmath261where @xmath262 are parameters of the helix . let us investigate , under which conditions the relation @xmath263eqv@xmath259 takes place . we suppose that all vectors of the helix are spacelike @xmath264 . it is evident , that it is sufficient to investigate the situation for the case @xmath265 , when @xmath4eqv@xmath196 . let coordinates of vectors @xmath4 , @xmath196 be @xmath266 in this case the coordinates of the points @xmath267 may be chosen in the form@xmath268and the vector @xmath219 has coordinates @xmath269we choose the world function ( [ a4.5 ] ) in the form@xmath270and introduce the quantity @xmath271 thus , we have @xmath272the space - time geometry ( [ a4.15 ] ) is a special case of the space - time geometry ( [ a4.4 ] ) . we do not pretend to the claim , that ( [ a4.15 ] ) is the world function of true space - time geometry . we shall show only that in the space - time geometry ( [ a4.15 ] ) the spacelike vectors ( [ a4.9 ] ) may be equivalent at some proper choice of parameters @xmath273 , @xmath274 and @xmath257 . in our calculations we shall use two geometries : the geometry @xmath275 of minkowski and the space - time geometry @xmath276 , described by the world function @xmath233 , determined by ( [ a4.15 ] ) . then expressions of the geometry @xmath276 may be reduced to expressions of the geometry @xmath275 by means of relations@xmath277@xmath278@xmath279the geometrical relations in @xmath276 are expressed via the same relations , written in @xmath275 with additional terms , containing the distortion @xmath250 . this additional terms in dynamic relations are interpreted as additional metric interactions , acting on a particle , when the real space - time geometry @xmath276 is considered to be the geometry @xmath275 . appearance of additional interactions reminds appearance of inertial forces at a use of accelerated coordinate systems instead of inertial ones . condition @xmath4eqv@xmath196 of equivalence of vectors @xmath4 , @xmath196 is written in the form of two equations@xmath280@xmath281where index m means , that the corresponding quantities are calculated in @xmath275 . the function @xmath250 is determined by the relation ( [ a4.15 ] ) , and the quantity @xmath282 is determined by the relation @xmath283which follows from the definition of the scalar product ( [ a4.15c ] ) . using the conventional relations for the scalar product in @xmath275 , we can rewrite the relations ( [ a4.16 ] ) , ( [ a4.17 ] ) in the form @xmath284@xmath285where@xmath286 to obtain the relation ( [ a4.21 ] ) from ( [ a4.18 ] ) , we use the relations@xmath287@xmath288the equation ( [ a4.20 ] ) is the identity . let us introduce pure quantities @xmath289 , @xmath290 , defining them by relations@xmath291@xmath292then the equation ( [ a4.19 ] ) takes the form@xmath293where the function @xmath294 is defined by the relation ( [ a4.15])@xmath295and the constant @xmath296 is defined by the relation ( [ a4.14a ] ) . let us note , that in the case , when @xmath297 is a linear function @xmath298 , for @xmath299 $ ] , the equation ( [ a4.25a ] ) has the unique solution @xmath300 . the solution with @xmath301 describes a straight but not a helix . considering solutions of equation ( [ a4.25a ] ) with respect to @xmath302 , we are interested in positive values of @xmath290 , because the quantity @xmath290 is nonnegative by definition ( [ a4.25 ] ) . at @xmath303 numerical solutions of equation ( [ a4.25a ] ) with respect to @xmath290 are presented in the form@xmath304 according to ( [ a4.7 ] ) , ( [ a4.24 ] ) and ( [ a4.25 ] ) we have the following relations for the helix radius @xmath105 @xmath305we obtain the helix step @xmath306 in the form@xmath307 negative values of @xmath289 correspond to helix with timelike vectors @xmath263 . positive solutions of equation ( [ a4.25a ] ) take place only for @xmath308 ( spacelike vectors ) and @xmath309 ( timelike vectors ) . the values of parameter @xmath310 belong to intervals @xmath311 , \qquad a\in \left ( 0,3\right ) \label{a4.38}\ ] ] for spacelike and timelike vectors correspondingly . thus , we see that in the space - time geometry with the world function ( a4.15 ) the spatial evolution , determined by the spacelike vectors @xmath259 , may lead to a helical world chain with timelike axis . however , equivalence of spacelike vectors @xmath259 is multivariant even in the space - time of minkowski . it is valid for the space - time geometry ( [ a4.15 ] ) also . as a result the wobbling of the spacelike vectors appears . it may lead to destruction of the helix . in reality the conditions @xmath312 determines vector @xmath313to within the vector @xmath314 , and we have instead of equations ( [ a4.9 ] ) @xmath315where @xmath316 , @xmath317 , @xmath318 are 4-vectors with coordinates@xmath319 instead of equations ( [ a4.19 ] ) ( [ a4.21 ] ) we have the following equations@xmath320@xmath321where @xmath322 and @xmath323 mean scalar products of vectors @xmath324 in the space - time of minkowski . the relation ( [ a4.25a ] ) is the necessary condition of the fact , that @xmath325 is a solution of equations ( [ a4.41 ] ) , ( [ a4.42 ] ) . we obtain from ( [ a4.41 ] ) @xmath326where @xmath327 means the scalar product of 3-vectors @xmath328 and @xmath329 . taking into account the relation ( [ a4.25a ] ) , we obtain from relation ( [ a4.42 ] ) @xmath330supposing , that @xmath322 is a small quantity we obtain from ( [ a4.44 ] ) by means of ( [ a4.43])@xmath331 the relation ( [ a4.45 ] ) may be transformed to the equation@xmath332where@xmath333as far as @xmath334 , we obtain , that @xmath335 , and the surface ( [ a4.46 ] ) is a hyperboloid in the 3-space of quantities @xmath336 . it means that solutions of the equations ( [ a4.43 ] ) , ( [ a4.44 ] ) may deflect arbitrarily far from the helix solution ( [ a4.9 ] ) . this deflection is a manifestation of the multivariance of the space - time geometry . suppression of multivariance and stabilization of the world chain , consisting of spacelike vectors , can be achieved , if we consider the world chain with composed links , whose skeleton consists of three points @xmath337 , @xmath338 ( see figure 1 ) . let @xmath259 be a spacelike vector , whereas the vector @xmath339 be a timelike vector in @xmath275 . to investigate the effect of stabilization , it is sufficient to consider the points @xmath340 , having coordinates@xmath341the following vectors are associated with these points of the skeletons@xmath342where the quantities @xmath343 are the given 4-vectors , whereas the quantities @xmath344 are 4-vectors , which are to be determined from the condition @xmath345 expressions for 4-vectors @xmath317 and @xmath54 are chosen in such a way , that vectors @xmath196 and @xmath346 ( at @xmath347 ) were a result of rotation of vectors @xmath4 and @xmath348 in the plane @xmath349 by the angle @xmath350 . the quantities @xmath351are supposed to be given . the 4-vectors @xmath352are to be determined from the relations ( [ a5.3a ] ) . the 4-vectors @xmath316 and @xmath317 coincide with vectors ( [ a4.9 ] ) . we are interested in the following question , whether the stabilizing vector @xmath353 can be chosen in such a way , that equations ( [ a5.3a ] ) have the unique solution @xmath347 . if such a stabilizing vector @xmath354exists , the world chain will have a shape of a helix without wobbling . it may be , that the complete stabilization is impossible . then , maybe , a partial stabilization is possible , when the quantities @xmath318 , @xmath355 are small , although they do not vanish . in any case the problem of the stabilizing vector existence is a pure mathematical problem . solving this problem , we shall use relations ( [ a4.15a ] ) , ( [ a4.15b ] ) to reduce all geometrical relations to the geometrical relations in the space - time of minkowski . working in the space - time of minkowski , we shall use the conventional covariant formalism , where the expressions of the type @xmath356 and @xmath357 mean@xmath358index " will be omitted for brevity . it follows from the condition @xmath4eqv@xmath196@xmath359where@xmath360after transformations we obtain@xmath361@xmath362these equations coincide with ( [ a4.41 ] ) , ( [ a4.42 ] ) . if @xmath363 the equations ( [ b5.11 ] ) , ( [ b5.12 ] ) coincide with ( [ a4.20 ] ) , ( a4.25a ) respectively . we obtain from the condition @xmath348eqv@xmath346@xmath364@xmath365where@xmath366 the equations ( [ b5.14 ] ) and ( [ b5.15 ] ) are transformed to the form@xmath367@xmath368@xmath369 let us suppose that the stabilizing vector @xmath101 is long in the sense that @xmath370then in ( [ b5.17 ] ) the functions @xmath250 , which contains @xmath101 in its argument will be equal to @xmath371 and all terms , containing @xmath101 compensate each other . the necessary condition of the fact , that @xmath372 is a solution of equations ( [ b5.16 ] ) , ( [ b5.17 ] ) , has the form@xmath373@xmath374the equation ( [ b5.18 ] ) is satisfied identically by the choice ( b5.4a ) , ( [ b5.4b ] ) of vectors @xmath101 and @xmath54 . we obtain from the condition @xmath375eqv@xmath376@xmath377@xmath378@xmath379@xmath380 the necessary conditions of the fact , that @xmath381 is a solution of equations ( [ b5.23 ] ) , ( [ b5.24 ] ) , have the form@xmath382@xmath383 the equation ( [ b5.27 ] ) is satisfied identically by the relations ( b5.4a ) , ( [ b5.4b ] ) . the difference of equations ( [ b5.19 ] ) and ( b5.28 ) leads to the equation @xmath384 let us substitute expressions for @xmath385 , determined by the relations ( [ b5.4a ] ) , ( [ b5.4b ] ) , in ( [ b5.29 ] ) . after transformations we obtain the connection between the quantities @xmath386 and @xmath387 in the form@xmath388 the equation ( [ b5.19 ] ) by means of ( [ b5.30 ] ) is reduced to the form@xmath389where according to ( [ a4.15 ] ) the function @xmath390 is substituted by @xmath391 . setting @xmath392and using designations ( [ a4.24 ] ) , ( [ a4.25 ] ) , we transform the equation ( [ b5.31 ] ) to the form @xmath393 the equations ( [ a4.25a ] ) and ( [ b5.33 ] ) form a system of two necessary conditions , imposed on parmeters of the helical world chain . each link of the chain consists of two vectors : leading vector @xmath394 and stabilizing vector @xmath395 . parameter @xmath396 is determined by the space - time geometry . the quantity @xmath397 describes the length of the spacelike leading vector @xmath394 . parameter @xmath398 describes the length of the projection of the leading vector @xmath394 on the plane of rotation . finally , @xmath399 describes the angle @xmath350 of rotation of the leading vector in the plane of rotation . numerical solutions of equations ( [ a4.25a ] ) and ( [ b5.33 ] ) are presented for the parameter @xmath303 solutions of equations , which describe the necessary conditions of the fact , that the world chain may be a helix , are not unique . there may be solutions of ( [ a5.3a ] ) , described by nonvanishing @xmath318 and @xmath355 , which generate wobbling and violate the helical character of world chain . we write six equation ( [ a5.3a ] ) as equation for @xmath401 with parameters @xmath343 , satisfying the necessary conditions ( [ a4.25a ] ) and ( b5.33 ) . we obtain instead of equations ( [ b5.11 ] ) , ( [ b5.12 ] ) the following two equations@xmath402@xmath403where the quantities @xmath404 satisfy the necessary conditions ( [ b5.33 ] ) ( [ a4.25a ] ) , and @xmath405 is a derivative of the function ( [ a4.26 ] ) , which is always nonnegative . then it follows from ( [ b6.2 ] ) @xmath406 equations ( [ b6.1 ] ) , ( [ b6.3 ] ) contain only the variable @xmath318 ( but not @xmath355 ) and coincide with the equations ( [ a4.41 ] ) , ( a4.42 ) . however , there are additional constraints , containing @xmath318 . as a result the constraints on @xmath318 distinguish from the relation ( a4.46 ) , describing values of @xmath318 without the stabilizing vector @xmath395 . in the developed form the relations ( [ b5.16 ] ) , ( [ b5.17 ] ) have the form @xmath407@xmath408they contain only the variable @xmath355 ( but not @xmath318 ) finally the relations ( [ b5.23 ] ) , ( [ b5.24 ] ) in the developed form can be written as follows@xmath409@xmath410the relation ( [ b6.7 ] ) is a linear combination of equations ( [ b5.17 ] ) and ( [ b5.24 ] ) , which does not contain the function @xmath294 . relations ( b6.6 ) and ( [ b6.7 ] ) contain both quantities @xmath401 and @xmath411 . the constraints ( [ b6.6 ] ) and ( [ b6.7 ] ) modify the constraints ( [ a4.46 ] ) , transforming the hyperboloid into ellipsoid . we suppose for simplicity , that the vector @xmath395 is very long ( @xmath412 ) . we suppose , that @xmath413 . in this case we obtain from the relation ( [ b6.5 ] ) , that @xmath414 . it follows from ( [ b6.7 ] ) , that @xmath415 . besides , it follows from ( [ b6.3 ] ) , that @xmath416 . thus , solutions of the equations ( [ b6.5 ] ) , ( [ b6.7 ] ) and ( [ b6.3 ] ) have the form @xmath417 at the constraints ( [ b6.8 ] ) three other equations ( [ b6.1 ] ) , ( b6.4 ) and ( [ b6.6 ] ) take the form @xmath418@xmath419@xmath420solution of equation ( [ b6.9 ] ) has the form @xmath421where @xmath422 is an arbitrary angle . solution of equation ( [ b6.10 ] ) has the form@xmath423where the quantities @xmath424 @xmath425 are arbitrary . and the quantity @xmath426 is determined by the relation ( [ b5.30 ] ) . substituting ( [ b6.12 ] ) - ( [ b6.14c ] ) in ( [ b6.11 ] ) , one obtains a constraint on the quantities @xmath427 @xmath424 @xmath425 . independently of this constraint the 3-vector @xmath428has the same 3-length @xmath274 , as the length of 3-vector @xmath429 . the angle between the 3-vectors @xmath430 and @xmath431is equal to @xmath350 . if @xmath432 , then @xmath325 , and vectors @xmath394 and @xmath433 are elements of the same helix . we see that the stabilizing vector @xmath395 reduces wobbling of vector @xmath394 . in the case of equation ( [ a4.46 ] ) the spatial component @xmath329 of the 4-vector @xmath318 may be infinite . in the case of the equation ( [ b6.9 ] ) the length @xmath434 of the spatial component @xmath329 of the 4-vector @xmath318 is less , than @xmath435 thus , the stabilizing vector @xmath395 reduces the wobbling of the world chain . one can not be sure , that this wobbling does not destroy the helical character of the world chain . however , the main question is , whether or not the evolution of the world chain in the spacelike direction lead to the world chain , which is timelike on the average . any next point @xmath436 of the world chain jumps along the timelike direction at the distance @xmath273 and in the 3-space , which is orthogonal to this direction , the point jumps at the distance @xmath437 . direction of the jump in the 3-space is described by the vector @xmath430 , which is given by the relation ( [ c5.17 ] ) . the length of @xmath430 is @xmath274 . if the direction of jump is completely random , the displacement @xmath438 for @xmath37 steps ( @xmath439 is proportional to @xmath440 , whereas displacement in the temporal direction is @xmath441 . it means that the mean velocity @xmath442tends to zero for @xmath443 , although @xmath444 . in the case , if @xmath363 and the 3-vector @xmath430 * * * * determined by ( [ c5.17 ] ) is not random , the world chain form a helix with timelike axis . in this case the mean velocity tends to zero also . it should expect that in the case , when the vector ( [ c5.17 ] ) is stochastic , but its stochasticity is restricted by the relation ( [ c5.17 ] ) ( the angle @xmath422 is completely random ) , the mean world chain will be also timelike on the average . we can not prove this fact strictly now , but this result seems to be very probable . the obtained classical helical world chain ( [ a4.6 ] ) associates with the classical dirac particle , which has alike world line ( [ e6.33 ] ) , ( e6.34 ) . the direction of the mean momentum distinguishes from the direction of the 4-velocity . this fact is characteristic for both particles ( the dirac particle , and the particle , described by the world chain ( a4.6 ) ) . both particles have angular moment . for the dirac particle the mass @xmath175 , which enters in the dirac equation , distinguishes from the mass @xmath445 of the particle moving along the world line ( [ e6.33 ] ) , ( [ e6.34 ] ) @xcite . as to the mass of the particle , described by the world chain ( [ a4.6 ] ) , it is not yet determined . for determination of the mass , one needs to consider the world chain ( [ a4.6 ] ) of charged particle with the skeleton @xmath446 in the distorted space - time of klein - kaluza , containing electromagnetic field . existence of helical world chain with timelike axis seems to be rather unexpected , because leading vectors @xmath259 of the chain are spacelike , and it corresponds to superluminal motion of a particle . superluminal motion seems to be incompatible with the relativity principle , which admits only motion with the speed less , than the speed of the light . however , this constraint is valid only for continuous space - time geometry , which admits unlimited divisibility . in a discrete geometry there are no distances less , than some elementary length , and it is difficult to formulate the relativity principle statement on impossibility of superluminal motion . one needs another more adequate formulation of the relativity principle . is the space - time geometry ( [ a4.14 ] ) discrete ? at @xmath447 the space - time geometry ( [ a4.14 ] ) turns to the space - time geometry@xmath448which is certainly discrete , because in the space - time there no timelike intervals @xmath57 , which are less , than @xmath195 , and there are no spacelike intervals @xmath449 , which are less , than @xmath195 . in such a space - time geometry there are no particles , whose geometrical mass @xmath199 is less than @xmath195 . however , if @xmath214 , is the space - time geometry discrete ? to answer this question , we introduce the parameter of discreteness : the relative density of points in the space - time with respect to the point density in the space - time of minkowski . let us define the quantity @xmath450 by means of the relation @xmath451 in the case ( [ a4.14 ] ) we have for @xmath452 $ ] @xmath453resolving ( [ a7.3 ] ) with respect to @xmath193 , we obtain @xmath454where@xmath455 taking into account ( [ a7.4 ] ) we obtain the world function @xmath193 as a function of @xmath233@xmath456the relative density of points in the space - time geometry @xmath276 with respect to the standard geometry @xmath275 of minkowski is given by the relation ( [ a7.2 ] ) . the expression for @xmath457 is given by the relation@xmath458where @xmath459 is given by the relation @xmath460if @xmath461 and @xmath462 , we have approximately@xmath463 in the limit @xmath461 , when the world function ( [ a4.14 ] ) turns into the world function ( [ a7.1 ] ) of the completely discrete geometry , we obtain for the relative density@xmath464 thus , @xmath465 for @xmath466 , and this fact correspond to the space - time geometry ( [ a7.1 ] ) , where close points , for which @xmath467 , are absent . the relative density @xmath450 of points may serve as quantity , describing the discreteness of the space - time geometry and the character of this discreteness . the discreteness may be complete , when the density @xmath468vanishes in some region as in the case ( [ a7.10 ] ) . but the discreteness may be incomplete , as in the case ( [ a7.7 ] ) . in this case for @xmath469 we have @xmath470{g_{1}\left ( \sigma _ { \mathrm{d}}\right ) } + \frac{1}{3}\frac{1}{\sqrt[3]{g_{1}\left ( \sigma _ { \mathrm{d}}\right ) } } \right ) , \qquad \sigma _ { \mathrm{d}}\in \left ( -2\lambda _ { 0}^{2},2\lambda _ { 0}^{2}\right ) \label{a7.11}\]]where@xmath471the expression ( [ a7.11 ] ) is a symmetric function of @xmath472 , as one can see from ( [ a7.3 ] ) . it is symmetric , indeed , although it does not look formally as a symmetric function of @xmath233 . numerical values of @xmath473 @xmath474 are presented in the table @xmath475the relative density @xmath450 is less , than unity . it may be interpreted in the sense , that the space - time geometry is discrete only partly . nevertheless the incompletely discrete space - time geometry discriminates most of world chains with spatial leading vector , remaining only some of them . multivariance of particle motion and discrimination of some states of motion play the crucial role in structure of elementary particles , as well as in the structure of atoms . let us explain this circumstance in the example of the hydrogen atom . according to laws of the classical mechanics the electron of the hydrogen atom is to fall onto the nucleus due to the coulomb attraction . two reasons prevent from this falling : ( 1 ) multivariant ( stochastic ) motion of the electron , and ( 1 ) rotation of electron around the nucleus . the multivariant motion of the electron leads to escape of the electron from the nuclear surface . this process has the same nature , as an escape of dust from the earth surface . moving multivariantly ( as brownian particles ) , the flecks of dust form a stationary distribution in the gravitational field of the earth . if multivariance of their motion is cut out , the flecks of the dust fall onto the surface of the earth . statistical description of the electron distribution and the dust distribution are different , because the multivariant electron motion is conceptually relativistic , whereas the brownian particles motion is nonrelativistic . one may describe brownian particles by means of probabilistic statistical description , whereas one may use only dynamical conception of statistical description for statistical description of multivariant motion of relativistic particles . rotation of the electron around the nucleus creates the field of centrifugal force , which is added to the coulomb force . as a result additional distributions of the electrons appear . if the obtained distribution of electrons is nonstationary , the electrons emanate the electromagnetic radiation until the electron distribution becomes to be stationary . thus , the electromagnetic radiation carries out discrimination of nonstationary states ( electron distributions ) . the multivariance of the electron motion and mechanism of discrimination of non - stationary states generates the structure of the hydrogen atom and discrete character of the radiation spectra . from the mathematical viewpoint the discrete character of the electron states is conditioned by procedure of the eigenstates determination . only eigenstates of the hamilton operator appear to be stationary and stable . the multivariance of the particle motion and some mechanism of discrimination play also the crucial role in the understanding of the structure of elementary particles . however , in the case of the elementary particle structure the discrimination mechanism is conditioned by some metric ( geometric ) forces , which appear , when we use space - time geometry of minkowski instead of the real multivariant space - time geometry . formally these forces have the form of additional terms of the type ( [ a4.18 ] ) in dynamic equations . these additional terms are expressed via the space - time distortion @xmath250 . they describe both multivariance of motion and the discrimination mechanism . the multivariance of motion is associated with the multivariance of the vector equivalence definition ( [ a1.3 ] ) , whereas the discrimination mechanism is associated with the zero - variance of the same definition ( [ a1.3 ] ) for some vectors . besides , as we have seen , the zero - variance ( discrimination ) is associated with the discreteness ( or partial discreteness ) of the space - time geometry . it is very important , that consideration of multivariant space - time geometry _ is not a hypothesis _ , which needs an experimental test . consideration of the multivariant space - time geometry is a corollary of correction of our imperfect conception of geometry . conception of geometry , based on supposition that any space - time geometry may be axiomatized ( i.e. may be concluded from some system of axioms ) , is imperfect , because it does not admit one to construct multivariant geometry conceptually . however , the motion of electrons and other elementary particles is multivariant . multivariance of this motion is an experimental fact , which can not be ignored . as far as the imperfect conception of geometry did not admit one to construct multivariant space - time geometry , investigators were forced to ascribe multivariance to dynamics , introducing quantum principles with all their attributes . the quantum principles look enigmatic and artificial , because multivariance is ascribed to dynamics , whereas it should be ascribed to the space - time geometry . multivariance and zero - variance as properties of the space - time geometry look as quite natural properties of the definition ( [ a1.3 ] ) . indeed , it does not follow from anywhere , that equations ( [ a1.3 ] ) are to have unique solution for arbitrary world function , which determines the form of these equations . absence of any hypotheses is a very important property of the geometrical approach to the structure of elementary particles . besides , the geometrical dynamics is very general and simple . dynamic equations of the geometric dynamics do not use even differential equations . formulation of dynamic equations does not contain a reference to the coordinate system . on the other hand , when the geometric dynamics in the real space - time is described in terms of the space - time of minkowski , one obtains additional metric forces , which look rather exotic . they can be obtained hardly in the framework of the conventional approach . the conventional approach to the theory of elementary particles contains a lot of secondary concepts and properties . one may not see any discrimination mechanism in wave functions , field equations , branes , symmetries and other remote corollaries of the unknown structure of elementary particles . but it is impossible to obtain and to understand the discrete properties of elementary particles without a reliable mechanism of discrimination . even if investigating and systematizing these remote corollaries , one succeeds to obtain a perfect systematization of elementary particles , one can obtain structure of elementary particles from the perfect systematization with the same success , as one can obtain the atomic structure from the periodical system of chemical elements . consideration of t - geometry as a space - time geometry admits one to obtain dynamics of a particle as corollary of its geometrical structure . evolution of the geometrical object in the space - time is determined by the skeleton @xmath476 of the geometrical object and by fixing of the leading vector @xmath4 . the skeleton and the leading vector determine the world chain , which describes the evolution completely . the world chain may wobble , it is manifestation of the space - time geometry multivariance . quantum effects are only one of manifestation of the multivariance . it is remarkable , that for determination of the world chain one does not need differential equations , which may be used only on the space - time manifold . one does not need space - time continuity ( continual geometry ) . of course , one may introduce the continual coordinate system and write dynamic differential equation there . one may , but it is not necessary . in general , the geometrical dynamics ( i.e. dynamics generated by the space - time geometry ) is a discrete dynamics , where step of evolution is determined by the length of the leading vector . it is possible , that one will need a development of special mathematical technique for the geometrical dynamics . the real space - time geometry contains the quantum constant @xmath155 as a parameter . as a result the geometric dynamics explains freely quantum effects , but not only them . the particle mass is geometrized ( the particle mass is simply a length of some vector ) . as a result the problem of mass of elementary particles is simply a geometrical problem . it is a problem of the structure of elementary geometrical object and its evolution . one needs simply to investigate different forms of skeletons of simplest geometrical objects . in general , not all skeletons are possible , because at the spatial evolution the world chain is observable ( helical ) only for several skeletons . additional points of skeleton lead to additional ( sometimes unexpected ) properties of corresponding elementary geometrical objects ( elementary particles ) . note that the geometric dynamics does not contain a rotational motion . it contains only a shift . all vectors of the skeleton @xmath477 of the link @xmath478 are equivalent to vectors of the skeleton @xmath479 of the adjacent link @xmath480 . such a situation is quite reasonable , because the geometrical dynamics describes evolution of free particles . the rotating particle can not be completely free , because in the rotating particle there is centripetal acceleration . however , acceleration of all parts of the body has to be absent for completely free motion . on the other hand , the geometric dynamics contains the spatial evolution , which absent in the conventional dynamics . from the geometrical viewpoint we may not discriminate spatial evolution on the basis , that the leading vector @xmath4 is spacelike and its length is imaginary . in fact the spatial evolution discriminates itself , by the fact , that the corresponding world chain is unobservable , in general . it appears to be observable only for some complex skeletons , consisting of more , than two points . the world chain , describing the spatial evolution is observable only in the case , when it may be localized near the world chain of the observer . it takes place , when the world chain has a shape of a helix with timelike axis , or some other shape , which may be localized near the world chain of the observer . as a result not all skeletons appear to be observable . although the geometric dynamics does not contain a rotation , but the corollaries of the rotation ( angular momentum , magnetic momentum ) may be obtained as a result of the spatial evolution , when the world chain is a helix . apparently , the fact , that such a `` particle rotation '' is a corollary of the spatial evolution , leads to the spin discreteness of the dirac particle . of course , such statements are to be tested by exact mathematical investigations of different types of skeletons and of different space - time geometries . however , such a statement of the problem is quite concrete and realizable . note , that the geometric dynamics in the real ( non - minkowskian ) space - time contains additional terms with respect to dynamics in the space - time of minkowski . from viewpoint of the space - time of minkowski these additional terms may be interpreted as some ( metric ) interactions , which take place inside the elementary particles . from the conventional viewpoint these interactions look very exotic and strange . it is impossible ( or very difficult ) to guess at them , starting from conventional conception of the space - time and dynamics . in the geometric dynamics there are no additional interactions , if we use the true space - time geometry . however , additional interactions appear , if we use inadequate geometry ( for instance , geometry of minkowski , or riemannian geometry ) . in other words , it is possible to compensate false space - time geometry by introduction of additional interactions . it is well known from the general relativity , that the motion of free body in the curved space - time looks as a motion in the gravitational field , if one interprets this motion as a motion in the space - time of minkowski . description of conceptually new unknown phenomena by means of a change of the space - time geometry is simpler , than an introduction of additional interactions , because the space - time geometry is described by the world function , which is a function of two points . the form of the world function for large distances is determined by the necessity of obtaining the nonrelativistic quantum mechanics . restrictions , imposed on the world function at small distances , are determined by the condition , that the spatial evolution may describe the dirac particle . ( very many elementary particles are the dirac particles ) . besides , the condition of localization of the world chain ( helical world chain ) imposes restrictions on parameters of the particle . not all parameters of particles appear to be possible . this condition is a condition of `` peculiar quantization '' of the particle parameters , which include the particle mass . let us note that the contemporary theory of elementary particles returns to geometrical considerations ( strings , branes ) . however , these considerations are restricted by the framework of the riemannian geometries and geometries close to the riemannian geometry . for instance , the quantum geometry , which uses operators instead of the point coordinates . this is some way of introduction of multivariance in the geometry . however , this geometry is developed on the basis of the linear vector space , which is a restriction on the space - time geometry . in any case the conventional approach to the space - time geometry considers only a part of all possible space - time geometries . one can not be sure , that the class of considered geometries contains true space - time geometry . of course , if one uses a false space - time geometry , there is a possibility to correct the false space - time geometry by means of additional interaction , generated by difference with the true space - time geometry . but such a correction is difficult , especially if the true geometry is discrete or close to the discrete geometry . note , that the geometry ( [ a4.0 ] ) is discrete , although it is given on the continuous manifold of minkowski . it is discrete , because the module of distance between any two points is more , than @xmath195 . it is very unexpected , because it is a common practice to consider any geometry on the manifold as a continuous geometry , although in reality the geometry is determined by the world function and only by the world function . a discrete geometry is associated with a grid . of course , a geometry , given on a grid , can not be continuous . however , a geometry , given on the continuous set of points ( manifold ) , may be discrete . why the microcosm physics of the twentieth century did leave the successful program of the physics geometrization and choose the alternative program of quantum theory ? discovery of the electron diffraction need of multivariance of the microcosm physics . multivariance may be taken into account either on the level of the space - time geometry , or on the level of dynamics . the multivariant space - time geometry was not known in the thirtieth , when the electron diffraction was discovered . the nonrelativistic quantum mechanics had been constructed already , and it was applied successfully for explanation of the electron diffraction . the space - time geometry is a basis of dynamics . introducing multivariance in dynamics , one can describe not only nonrelativistic phenomena of microcosm . one can describe also relativistic phenomena and that part of the microcosm physics , which is known as the theory of elementary particles . the principles of quantum mechanics , which introduce multivariance in the microcosm physics , were invented for the newtonian conception of the space - time , and their extrapolation to the relativistic phenomena appeared to be problematic . of course , some properties of the true space - time geometry may be taken into account by introduction of additional interactions . however , it is very difficult to invent and introduce additional interactions without understanding of these innovations . capacities of the geometrical approach are very large , especially if one takes into account all possible space - time geometries . the theory of elementary particles returns to the geometrical description , but this description is burthened by such concepts as wave function , string , brane , which have very abstracted relation to the structure of elementary particles and microcosm physics . a. rylov , tubular geometry construction as a reason for new revision of the space - time conception . in _ what is geometry ? _ polimetrica publisher , italy , pp.201 - 235 http://www.polimetrica.com/polimetrica/406/ yu . a. rylov , author s comments to referee s reports on the paper by y. a. rylov `` dynamical methods of investigation in application to the dirac particle '' , submitted to a scientific journal . ( available at _ http://rsfq1.physics.sunysb . edu / rylov /comm1e . pdf _ ) Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: since its discovery fifty years ago @xcite anderson localization has remained a very active field of research ( see for instance the reviews @xcite ) . according to the scaling theory @xcite , there is no delocalized phase in dimensions @xmath20 , whereas there exists a localization / delocalization at finite disorder in dimension @xmath21 . to get some insight into this type of transition , it is natural to consider anderson localization on the cayley tree ( or bethe lattice ) which is expected to represent some mean - field limit . the tight - binding anderson model on the cayley tree has been thus studied by various authors . in @xcite , the recursion equation for the self - energy has been studied to establish the mobility edge as the limit of stability of localized states . in @xcite , the exponent @xmath19 governing the divergence of the localization length was shown to be @xmath22 . in @xcite , the supersymmetric formalism has been used to predict the critical behavior of some disorder - averaged observables ( see also @xcite where similar results have been obtained for the case where anderson tight - binding model is replaced by a non - linear @xmath23-model ) . in @xcite , the problem was reformulated in terms of recursions on riccati variables to obtain weak - disorder expansions . other studies have focused on random - scattering models on the cayley tree @xcite . more recently , the interest in anderson localization on the cayley tree has been revived by the question of many - body localization @xcite , because the geometry of the fock space of many - body states was argued to be similar to a cayley tree @xcite . in the present paper , we consider the anderson tight binding model on the cayley tree already studied in @xcite and we study numerically the statistical properties of landauer transmission and eigenstates as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 and of the number @xmath1 of generations . we find that several probability distributions propagate as traveling waves with a fixed shape , as the number @xmath1 of tree generations grows . the fact that traveling waves appear in disordered models defined on trees has been discovered by derrida and spohn @xcite on the specific example of the directed polymer in a random medium and was then found in various models @xcite . for the case of anderson localization on trees , the analysis of @xcite concerning the distribution of the self - energy in the localized phase is actually a traveling wave analysis ( see appendix a for more details ) , although it is not explicitly mentioned in these terms in @xcite . the fact that traveling waves occur has been explicitly seen in the numerical study of the transmission distribution for a random - scattering model on the cayley tree ( see fig . 8b of @xcite ) and has been found within the supersymmetric formalism @xcite . in the field of traveling waves and front propagation ( see the reviews @xcite ) , there exists an essential separation between two classes : in pulled fronts , the velocity is determined by the form of the tail of the front and thus by the appropriate linearized equation in the tail region , whereas in pushed fronts , the velocity is determined by the bulk properties and thus by the non - linear dynamics in the bulk region . it turns out that for disordered systems defined on trees , the traveling waves that appear usually correspond to cases where it is the tail of the probability distribution that determines the velocity @xcite . in particular for anderson localization on the cayley tree , the traveling wave propagation is also determined by the tails @xcite . from this traveling wave point of view , the localization / delocalization anderson transition thus represents a traveling / non - traveling critical point . such a traveling / non - traveling phase transition for a branching random walk in the presence of a moving absorbing wall has been studied recently in @xcite and we find here very similar behaviors in the critical region . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ trans ] , we describe the statistical properties of landauer transmission . in section [ eigen ] , we discuss the statistical properties of eigenstates , as measured by the entropy and inverse participation ratios ( i.p.r . ) . we summarize our conclusions in section [ conclusion ] . in appendix a , we translate the analysis of ref . @xcite concerning the distribution of the self - energy in the localized phase into a traveling - wave tail analysis for the landauer transmission discussed in section [ trans ] . in appendix b , we explain how such a similar tail analysis can be performed in the delocalized phase for auxiliary variables that are closely related to inverse participation ratios . finally , in appendix c , we recall the results of ref . @xcite concerning the traveling / non - traveling phase transition for a branching random walk in the presence of a moving absorbing wall , since these results are used as a comparison in the text to understand the finite - size scaling properties in the critical region . in quantum coherent problems , the most appropriate characterisation of transport properties consists in defining a scattering problem where the disordered sample is linked to incoming wires and outgoing wires and in studying the reflexion and transmission coefficients . this scattering theory definition of transport , first introduced by landauer @xcite , has been much used for one - dimensional systems @xcite and has been generalized to higher dimensionalities and multi - probes measurements ( see the review @xcite ) . in dimension @xmath24 , the transfer matrix formulation of the schrdinger equation yields that the probability distribution of the landauer transmission becomes asymptotically log - normal @xcite , i.e. one has @xmath25 where @xmath26 represents the localization length and where @xmath27 is a sample - dependent random variable of order @xmath28 distributed with a gaussian law . although it is often assumed that this log - normal distribution persists in the localized phase in dimension @xmath29 , recent numerical studies @xcite are in favor of the following scaling form for the logarithm of the conductance @xmath30 with exponents of order @xmath31 and @xmath32 @xcite , whereas @xmath33 from eq . [ trans1d ] . for the cayley tree that we consider in this paper , we will find below that the fluctuation exponent vanishes @xmath34 , and we will discuss the probability distribution of the variable @xmath27 . but let us first recall the appropriate scattering framework for the cayley tree @xcite . we consider the anderson tight - binding model @xmath35 where the hopping between nearest neighbors @xmath36 is a constant @xmath37 and where the on - site energies @xmath38 are independent random variables drawn from the flat distribution @xmath39 the parameter @xmath0 thus represents the disorder strength . starting at generation @xmath40 and ending at generation @xmath41 ( on the figure @xmath42 ) is attached to one incoming wire and to @xmath43 outgoing wires . in section [ trans ] , we discuss the properties of the total transmission @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the reflexion amplitude of the incoming wire , and @xmath46 the transmission amplitudes of the outgoing wires.,height=226 ] we consider the scattering geometry introduced in @xcite and shown on fig . [ figscattering ] : the finite tree of branching ratio @xmath47 is attached to one incoming wire at its root ( generation @xmath40 ) and to @xmath43 outgoing wires at generation @xmath41 . one is interested into the eigenstate @xmath48 that satisfies the schrdinger equation @xmath49 inside the disorder sample and in the wires where one requires the plane - wave forms @xmath50 these boundary conditions define the reflexion amplitude @xmath45 of the incoming wire and the transmission amplitudes @xmath46 of the @xmath51 outgoing wires . to satisfy the schrdinger equation of eq . [ schodinger ] within the wires with the forms of eq . [ psiqoutside ] , one has the following relation between the energy @xmath52 and the wave vector @xmath53 @xmath54 to simplify the discussion , we will focus in this paper on the case of zero - energy @xmath55 and wave - vector @xmath56 @xmath57 because the zero - energy @xmath55 corresponds to the center of the band where the delocalizion first appears when the strength @xmath0 of the disorder is decreased from the strong disorder localized phase . inside the cayley tree @xmath58 , the schrdinger equation of eq . [ schodinger ] involves one ancestor denoted by @xmath59 and @xmath47 descendants denoted by @xmath60 @xmath61 whereas for the last generation @xmath41 there is only one ancestor and one descendant ( outgoing wire ) @xmath62 as explained in @xcite , it is convenient to introduce the riccati variables @xmath63 that represent the ratio of the wave function of two neighboring sites . on the outgoing wires , these riccati variables are fixed by eq . [ psiqoutside ] to be @xmath64 the schrdinger equation of eq . [ schodingerbord ] gives the first recursion @xmath65 whereas the schrdinger equation of eq . [ schodingerinside ] gives the recursion inside the tree for @xmath58 @xmath66 on the other hand , the value of the riccati variable for the origin of the tree @xmath40 is fixed by the incoming wire of eq . [ psiqoutside ] @xmath67 and thus the reflexion coefficient @xmath45 can be obtained via @xmath68 from the @xmath69 obtained via the recursion of eq . [ riccatiinside ] . from the conservation of energy , the total transmission @xmath70 is related to the reflexion coefficient @xmath71 @xmath72 as explained in @xcite , the criterion for the localization / delocalization phases is then the following : \(a ) if the riccati variable @xmath69 at the root of the tree converges towards a real random variable as @xmath10 , the reflexion is total @xmath73 and the transmission vanishes @xmath74 . \(b ) if the riccati variable @xmath69 keeps a finite negative imaginary part as @xmath10 , the reflexion is only partial @xmath75 and the transmission remains finite @xmath76 we refer to @xcite for the results of a weak disorder expansion within this framework , and for a numerical monte - carlo approach to determine the mobility edge in the plane @xmath77 . here we will instead study the statistical properties of the transmission @xmath70 at zero energy @xmath55 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 ( eq [ flat ] ) and of the number @xmath1 of generations . but before discussing the disordered case , let us first describe the finite - size properties of the pure case . in the pure case where all on - site energies vanish @xmath78 , all branches are equivalent and there is no dependence on @xmath79 . the recursions for riccati variables of eqs [ riccatioutgoing ] , [ riccatifirst ] and [ riccatiinside ] give @xmath80 i.e. one obtains the simple alternation between odd and even generations @xmath81 the reflexion coefficient @xmath45 thus vanishes exactly for any even size @xmath82 @xmath83 and the transmission coefficient in each branch @xmath84 reads @xmath85 ( note that for pure trees of uneven size , the reflexion would not vanish . this is why in the disordered case , we will only consider trees of even sizes @xmath41 where in the corresponding pure case , the reflexion vanish exactly for any finite tree ) . it is instructive to write now the corresponding wave function as a function of the generation n , @xmath86 this exponential decay of the wavefunction in this delocalized case is very peculiar to the tree geometry : it is imposed by the energy conservation and by the exponential growth of the number of sites with the generation @xmath87 . if one wishes to study numerically real trees , one is limited to rather small number of generations of order @xmath88 ( see for instance the study @xcite based on exact diagonalization ) because the number of sites and thus of random energies grows exponentially in @xmath1 . from the point of view of convergence towards stable probability distributions via recursion relations , it is thus better to use the so - called pool method that will allow us to study much larger number of generations ( see below eq . [ pool5 ] ) . the idea of the pool method is the following : at each generation , one keeps the same number @xmath89 of random variables to represent probability distributions . within our present framework , the probability distribution @xmath90 of the riccati variables @xmath91 at generation @xmath87 will be represented by a pool of @xmath89 complex values @xmath92 . it is convenient from now on to change the notation @xmath93 with respect to fig . [ figscattering ] so that @xmath40 now corresponds to the contacts with the outgoing wires ( see fig . [ figscattering ] ) . the numerical results presented below have been obtained with the following procedure : \(i ) the random variables of the initial pool are given by ( eq . [ riccatifirst ] ) @xmath94 where @xmath95 are independent random variables drawn with eq . [ flat ] . \(ii ) from the random variables @xmath96 of the pool at generation @xmath97 , the pool at generation @xmath87 is constructed as follows . for each @xmath98 , one generates a new random energy @xmath99 with the law of eq . [ flat ] and one draws @xmath47 random indices @xmath100 among the pool of generation @xmath101 to construct the variable @xmath102 as follows(eq . [ riccatiinside ] ) @xmath103 \(iii ) from these pools of riccati variables , one may compute via eqs [ reflexioncoef ] and [ deftotaltrans ] a pool of total transmission @xmath104 for trees of @xmath87 generations using @xmath105 for the anderson model on the bethe lattice , the pool method has been already used , in particular in @xcite with a pool @xmath106 with a number @xmath107 of generations , in @xcite with pools up to @xmath108 , and in @xcite with pools up to @xmath109 with a number @xmath110 of generations . the pool method is also very much used for disordered systems on hierarchical lattices ( see for instance@xcite ) , in the remaining of this section , we present the numerical results obtained with a pool of size @xmath111 we have also results for a pool of size @xmath112 with a number of generations @xmath113 to see how the results change with the pool size . however , the number of generations @xmath114 for this bigger pool @xmath115 has turned out to be less precise in the critical region . all figures shown below thus corresponds to data obtained with the pool of size @xmath116 . as is usual with the pool method @xcite , the location of the critical point depends on the pool , i.e. on the discrete sampling with @xmath89 values of probability distributions . it is expected to converge towards the thermodynamic critical point only in the limit @xmath117 ( see the discussion of section [ fspool ] in appendix b ) . nevertheless , for each given pool , the critical behaviors with respect to this pool - dependent critical point usually allows a good measure of critical exponents @xcite . for instance , for the pool of size @xmath116 , the critical value @xmath118 of the disorder strength where the localization - delocalization occurs for the landauer transmission is of order @xmath119 for the pool of size @xmath115 , we find that it is higher and of order @xmath120 . this rather important shift of the pseudo - critical point with the pool size which has already been seen in @xcite , seems to be due to the very slow logarithmic convergence of traveling wave velocity in the presence of cut - off ( see the discussion of section [ fspool ] in appendix b ) . so we stress that here , in contrast to @xcite , our goal is not to determine the true thermodynamic mobility edge @xmath121 , but instead to understand the critical behaviors of the finite - pool results with respect to the pool - dependent critical point of eq . [ critipoole5 ] . we will first discuss the behavior of the typical transmission @xmath122 defined by @xmath123 as a function of the number @xmath1 of generations and disorder strength @xmath0 , before we turn to the distribution around this typical value . in the localized phase @xmath125 : ( a ) linear decay of @xmath126 as a function of the number @xmath1 of generations ( see eq . [ transloc ] ) . ( b ) behavior of the slope @xmath127 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 : it vanishes linearly @xmath128 with @xmath129 ( see eq . [ critipoole5 ] ) and @xmath6 ( see eq . [ xiloc ] ) , title="fig:",height=226 ] in the localized phase @xmath125 : ( a ) linear decay of @xmath126 as a function of the number @xmath1 of generations ( see eq . [ transloc ] ) . ( b ) behavior of the slope @xmath127 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 : it vanishes linearly @xmath128 with @xmath129 ( see eq . [ critipoole5 ] ) and @xmath6 ( see eq . [ xiloc ] ) , title="fig:",height=226 ] in the localized phase , one expects that the typical transmission @xmath122 defined by eq . [ defttyp ] decays exponentially with the number @xmath1 of generations @xmath130 where @xmath131 represents the localization length that diverges at the delocalization transition @xmath132 . we show on fig . [ figtransloc ] our numerical results for the pool of size @xmath116 ( eq . [ pool5 ] ) : the exponential decay with @xmath1 of eq . [ transloc ] is shown on fig . [ figtransloc ] ( a ) for various disorder strength @xmath0 . the corresponding slope @xmath127 is shown as a function of @xmath0 on fig . [ figtransloc ] ( b ) : we find that this slope vanishes linearly in @xmath133 , in agreement with the exact result @xcite @xmath134 and in agreement with figure 7 of ref . @xcite concerning a random - scattering model on the cayley tree . of the infinite tree in the delocalized phase : ( a ) @xmath137 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 ( b ) same data in a log - log plot to measure the exponent of the essential singularity of eq . [ essentialsingularitytransdeloc ] : @xmath138 as a function of @xmath139 : the slope is of order @xmath140 , title="fig:",height=226 ] of the infinite tree in the delocalized phase : ( a ) @xmath137 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 ( b ) same data in a log - log plot to measure the exponent of the essential singularity of eq . [ essentialsingularitytransdeloc ] : @xmath138 as a function of @xmath139 : the slope is of order @xmath140 , title="fig:",height=226 ] in the delocalized phase , the typical transmission remains finite in the limit where the number of generations @xmath1 diverges @xmath141 as shown on fig . [ figtransdeloc ] , we measure the following essential singularity behavior of the typical transmission @xmath142 the presence of essential singularities in transport properties near the localization transition on the bethe lattice has been found in @xcite via the supersymmetric formalism ( see also @xcite where similar results have been obtained for the case where anderson tight - binding model is replaced by a non - linear @xmath23-model ) . in particular , eq . 71 of ref . @xcite ) states that the leading critical behavior of the diffusion constant is given by : @xmath143 ( eq . 71 of ref . we note that the exponent in this essential singularity is @xmath144 instead of the exponent of order @xmath145 that we measure . the reason for this difference could be that the results of ref . @xcite are based on the computation of the _ disorder - averaged two - point density - density correlation function _ ( see eq . 2 of ref . @xcite ) , whereas our numerical results concern the _ typical value of landauer transmission _ , and not the disorder - averaged transmission which is expected to be governed by rare events ( see below the section [ distritrans ] ) . also it is not clear to us what exactly represents the diffusion constant computed in @xcite , because it is known that on the bethe lattice the dynamics is not diffusive but ballistic in the delocalized phase @xcite , and that more generally the random walk on the bethe lattice is not diffusive because the tree - geometry induces an effective bias away from the origin ( see for instance @xcite and references therein ) . as a consequence , some implicit reinterpretation of the bethe lattice seems to underlie the statements of ref . @xcite that makes difficult a precise comparison with our present numerical results . if there exists some finite - size scaling in the critical region for the typical landauer transmission of the form @xmath146 the matching of our results in the localized phase ( see eq . [ transloc ] ) and in the delocalized phase ( eq . [ essentialsingularitytransdeloc ] ) requires a finite - size correlation length exponent @xmath147 of order @xmath148 in another traveling / non - traveling phase transition studied in ref @xcite ( see the summary in appendix c ) , it has been obtained that the finite - size scaling exponent @xmath149 is determined by the relaxation rate towards the finite value in the non - traveling phase . we have thus studied the relaxation length towards the finite value in the delocalized phase . we find that our data for @xmath150 are compatible with the form @xmath151 where @xmath152 is a random stationary process as a function of @xmath1 . we find that its autocorrelation function is exponential @xmath153 and we measure that the relaxation length @xmath154 diverges with an exponent @xmath155 of the order of the exponent @xmath147 of eq . [ nufstrans ] . we thus obtain that the critical properties are qualitatively similar to the critical properties described in ref @xcite ( see the summary in appendix c ) : the traveling phase is characterized by a velocity that vanishes linearly , but the finite size scaling is governed by the relaxation length towards the asymptotic finite value of the non - traveling phase . exactly at criticality , we thus expects the following stretched exponential decay of the typical transmission @xmath156 where the exponent @xmath157 is related to the other exponents by ( see the scaling relations of eqs [ kapparelation ] and [ nutyprelation ] in appendix c ) @xmath158 from our previous estimate of the exponent @xmath159 , this would correspond to the numerical value @xmath160 we have not been able to measure this stretched exponential behavior exactly at criticality from our data , because a precise measure of the exponent @xmath157 would require to be exactly at the critical point . of the probability distribution @xmath161 of the logarithm of landauer transmission : ( a ) in the delocalized phase ( here @xmath162 ) , the probability distribution @xmath161 does not move with @xmath1 , and vanishes with a discontinuity at the boundary @xmath163 . ( b ) in the localized phase ( here @xmath164 ) , the probability distribution @xmath161 moves with @xmath1 as a traveling wave of fixed shape . , title="fig:",height=226 ] of the probability distribution @xmath161 of the logarithm of landauer transmission : ( a ) in the delocalized phase ( here @xmath162 ) , the probability distribution @xmath161 does not move with @xmath1 , and vanishes with a discontinuity at the boundary @xmath163 . ( b ) in the localized phase ( here @xmath164 ) , the probability distribution @xmath161 moves with @xmath1 as a traveling wave of fixed shape . , title="fig:",height=226 ] up to now , we have only discussed the behavior of the typical transmission of eq . [ defttyp ] as a function of @xmath1 and @xmath0 . we now turn to the probability distribution of the logarithm of the transmission around its averaged value , i.e. we consider the distribution of the relative variable @xmath165 we find that as @xmath10 , this variable remains finite not only in the delocalized phase where @xmath166 is finite , but also in the localized phase where @xmath167 decays linearly in @xmath1 ( eq . [ transloc ] ) . this means that in the localized phase , the probability distributions @xmath168 actually propagates as a traveling wave with a fixed shape around its moving center @xmath167 as shown on fig . [ fighistotrans ] ( b ) . this phenomenon has already been seen for random scattering models on the bethe lattice ( see fig . 8b of ref . this is in contrast to the broadening with @xmath169 observed in low dimensions @xmath170 ( see eq . [ transd ] ) : the cayley tree thus corresponds to @xmath34 in eq . [ transd ] . of @xmath171 as @xmath0 varies in the localized phase for various disorder strengths @xmath172 : the exponential decay as @xmath173 corresponds to slopes of order @xmath174 , @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 . ( b ) width @xmath178 of the probability distribution of @xmath179 as a function of @xmath0 : it remains finite both in the localized phase and in the delocalized phase , but it presents a cusp singularity at criticality . , title="fig:",height=226 ] of @xmath171 as @xmath0 varies in the localized phase for various disorder strengths @xmath172 : the exponential decay as @xmath173 corresponds to slopes of order @xmath174 , @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 . ( b ) width @xmath178 of the probability distribution of @xmath179 as a function of @xmath0 : it remains finite both in the localized phase and in the delocalized phase , but it presents a cusp singularity at criticality . , title="fig:",height=226 ] the fact that the shape is fixed can be used numerically to measure more precisely the tails of this probability distribution by accumulating data over iterations : we show on fig . [ figtranswidth ] ( a ) the histograms of @xmath27 obtained by this procedure for various disorder strength @xmath0 . an essential property of this distribution is the right exponential tail @xmath180 in terms of the rescaled transmission @xmath181 ( see eq . [ variableu ] ) , this corresponds to the power - law decay @xmath182 we find that the selected exponent @xmath183 slightly grows as the disorder strength @xmath0 decreases , from a value of order @xmath177 for the strong disorder @xmath184 towards a value of order @xmath174 near criticality ( see figure [ figtranswidth ] a ) . the velocity of the traveling wave propagation of the whole distribution is actually determined by this power - law tail , as explained in detail in appendix a. in particular , the critical value @xmath185 has been predicted in @xcite ( see eq . [ betacdemi ] in appendix a ) . an important consequence of the power - law tail of eq . [ tailpowert ] with @xmath186 is that all integer moments @xmath187 of the landauer transmission will be governed by rare events . finally , we show on fig . [ figtranswidth ] ( b ) the width of the probability distribution of @xmath188 as a function of @xmath0 : it remains finite both in the localized phase and in the delocalized phase , but it presents a cusp singularity at criticality because in the delocalized phase , the distribution presents a singularity at finite distance from the typical value , as is clearly visible on fig . [ fighistotrans ] ( a ) : the transmission is bounded by @xmath189 , i.e. the histogram of @xmath188 presents a discontinuity at @xmath163 . the landauer transmission studied in the previous section is of course the most appropriate observable to characterize the transport properties and to find the transition between the conducting / non - conducting phases . however , one expects that these transmission properties that emerge when the disordered sample is linked to incoming and outgoing wires are related to the nature of eigenstates of the disordered sample in the absence of these external wires ( see fig . [ figtree ] ) to determine whether a normalized eigenstate @xmath190 is localized or delocalized , the usual parameters are the inverse participation ratios ( i.p.r . ) @xmath191 of arbitrary power @xmath192 . another important quantity to characterize the spatial extent of an eigenstate is its entropy @xmath193 the normalization condition yields the idendity @xmath194 , and the entropy corresponds to @xmath195 on an hypercubic lattice of size @xmath169 in dimension @xmath196 , containing @xmath197 sites , the delocalized phase is characterized by the following typical behaviors @xmath198 and @xmath199 these scalings are the same for pure homogeneous eigenfunctions with @xmath200 for all sites @xmath201 . at criticality , the scalings of the i.p.r . involve a whole series of non - trivial exponents and the wave function is said to be multifractal ( see the review @xcite ) . finally in the localized phase , the i.p.r . and the entropy are finite . in the present section , we discuss the statistical properties of these i.p.r . and entropy for zero - energy eigenstates for the cayley tree of fig . [ figtree ] as a function of the number @xmath1 of tree generations and of the disorder strength @xmath0 . where each interior site has @xmath202 neighbors . on the figure the tree ends at generation @xmath42 . , height=226 ] we refer to @xcite where it is explained how eigenstates of finite trees can be constructed and how the density of states can be obtained . note that on a tree , boundary sites dominate so that one needs a substraction procedure to obtain the appropriate bulk density of states . in the following , we are not interested into the density of states , which does not contain any information on the localized / delocalized nature of the spectrum . we wish to study instead the spatial properties of eigenstates of zero - energy @xmath55 ( center of the band ) . the schrdinger equation [ schodingerinside ] yields as before the recursion of eq . [ riccatiinside ] for the riccati variables defined in eq . [ riccati ] . the difference with the scattering case is now in the boundary conditions @xmath203 that replace eq . [ riccatifirst ] . as a consequence , the riccati variables are now real ( and not complex ) . the energy @xmath55 will indeed be an eigenstate only if the schrdinger equation is also satisfied at the center of the finite tree at the center site @xmath204 since the on - site energy @xmath205 is a random variable drawn with some distribution , we may consider that we choose @xmath205 to satisfy eq . [ riccaticenter ] to obtain a typical eigenstate of zero energy and to study its spatial properties . let us first describe zero - energy eigenstate in the pure case to stress the peculiarities of the tree geometry . in the pure case where all on - site energies vanish @xmath78 , the zero - energy eigenstate with radial symmetry reads @xmath206 where the root amplitude @xmath207 is determined by the normalization condition @xmath208 \label{normapur}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this state is the analog of the scattering state described in section [ puretrans ] . in particular , one sees again an exponential decay of the wavefunction in this delocalized case which is very peculiar to the tree geometry : in the normalization condition of eq . [ normapur ] , this exponential decay is exactly compensated by the exponential growth of the number of sites at generation @xmath209 , so that all generations @xmath210 carry exactly the same weight in the normalization condition , and the root weight @xmath211 vanishes as @xmath212 in the thermodynamic limit , where @xmath82 is the number of generations of the tree . for this state , the usual inverse participation ratio of eq . [ defiq ] for @xmath213 reads @xmath214 \label{ipppur}\end{aligned}\ ] ] more generally for @xmath215 , one obtains the following decay with the number of generations @xmath216 in terms of the total number of sites @xmath217 this corresponds to @xmath218 this behavior is thus very anomalous with respect to the corresponding decay as @xmath219 for the i.p.p . of pure states in finite dimension @xmath196 ( see eq . [ delociqdimd ] ) . moreover , since the eigenfunction normalization yields the idendity @xmath194 , one sees that there exists some discontinuity as @xmath220 . in particular , the entropy of eq . [ defs ] which can usually be computed as the derivative of eq . [ sderiiq ] should be computed directly here , and one obtains @xmath221 \label{entropiecaspurcalcul}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq [ normapur ] , one obtains the following behavior for large @xmath1 @xmath222 in terms of the total number of sites of eq . [ calncaspur ] , the entropy is proportional to the logarithm of the number of sites @xmath223 that should be compared with the growth as @xmath224 for pure eigenstates in dimension @xmath196 ( see eq . [ delocsdimd ] ) . in conclusion , the tree geometry induces very anomalous scalings in @xmath225 for the logarithm of i.p.r . of pure states [ ipppurcaln ] ) with respect to the case of finite dimension @xmath196 , whereas the entropy is well behaved in @xmath226 ( see eq . [ entropiecaspurfin ] ) . in the disordered case , we expect to observe similar behaviors , whereas the i.p.r . and the entropy will remain finite in the localized phase . to compute the inverse participation ratio @xmath227 ( eq . [ defiq ] ) via recursion , one needs to introduce besides the riccati variable of eq . [ riccati ] the auxiliary variables defined by @xmath228 where the sum is over all sites @xmath229 that are descendants of the site @xmath230 of the tree . these variables satisfy the following recurrence inside the tree @xmath231 @xmath232 \label{reccq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the initial conditions at the boundaries @xmath233 at the central root , on needs to impose the normalization @xmath234 \label{normapsi2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] that determines the weight @xmath235 of the root in terms of the variables @xmath236 of the branches . to compute the inverse participation ratio of parameter @xmath192 of eq . [ defiq ] , one needs the variables @xmath237 together with the variables @xmath236 @xmath238 = \frac{\left [ 1 + \displaystyle \sum_{m=1}^{k+1 } c^{(q ) } ( 1,m)\right]}{\left [ 1 + \displaystyle \sum_{m=1}^{k+1 } c^{(1 ) } ( 1,m)\right]^q } \label{iqtree}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to compute recursively the entropy of eq . [ defs ] , one needs similarly to introduce the auxiliary variable @xmath239 where the sum over @xmath229 denotes the sum over the site @xmath230 and all its descendants : @xmath240 thus represents the entropy for the branch containing @xmath230 and its descendants . the initial conditions at the boundaries are simply @xmath241 and the recursion inside the tree @xmath231 can be written as @xmath242 where the first term represents the weighted contribution of the branches entropies and where the second term represents the mixing entropy @xmath243 with the weights @xmath244 normalized to @xmath245 . at the central site of the tree , one uses the same formula but with @xmath246 branches instead of @xmath47 branches . to study the statistical properties of eigenstates , we have used again the pool method explained in [ poolmethod ] . the only difference is that for the transmission , we have followed the recursions for the complex riccati variables , whereas here we follow the recursions for the real riccati variable @xmath91 and for the auxiliary variables @xmath236 , @xmath247 and @xmath23 described above . of a normalized zero - energy eigenstate : ( a ) evolution of the typical entropy @xmath248 with the number @xmath1 of generations : it grows linearly in @xmath1 in the delocalized phase , whereas it remains finite in the localized phase . ( b ) asymptotic width @xmath249 of the relative variable @xmath250 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 : the width converges to @xmath251 ( as @xmath212 ) in the delocalized phase , whereas it is finite in the localized phase , title="fig:",height=226 ] of a normalized zero - energy eigenstate : ( a ) evolution of the typical entropy @xmath248 with the number @xmath1 of generations : it grows linearly in @xmath1 in the delocalized phase , whereas it remains finite in the localized phase . ( b ) asymptotic width @xmath249 of the relative variable @xmath250 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 : the width converges to @xmath251 ( as @xmath212 ) in the delocalized phase , whereas it is finite in the localized phase , title="fig:",height=257 ] we first consider how the eigenstate entropy defined in eq . [ defs ] evolves with the number @xmath1 of generations . as shown on fig . [ figentropy ] ( a ) , the typical value grows linearly in @xmath1 in the delocalized phase @xmath252 where the factor @xmath253 varies smoothly with @xmath0 and does not vanish continuously near the critical point . in this delocalized phase , we moreover find that the width of the relative variable @xmath254 decays to zero as @xmath10 @xmath255^{1/2}_{w < w_c } \opsimeq_{n \to \infty } \frac{1}{n } \label{entropywidthdeloc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the localized phase on the contrary , the typical value and the width of the relative variable @xmath254 remain finite as @xmath256 ( see fig . [ figentropy ] ( a ) and ( b ) ) . in the localized phase ( a ) @xmath257 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 near the critical point . ( b ) same data as a function of @xmath258 to measure the exponent of the power law of eq . [ critientropy64loc ] : the slope is of order @xmath259.,title="fig:",height=226 ] in the localized phase ( a ) @xmath257 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 near the critical point . ( b ) same data as a function of @xmath258 to measure the exponent of the power law of eq . [ critientropy64loc ] : the slope is of order @xmath259.,title="fig:",height=226 ] as shown on fig . [ fig64loc ] , we find that the typical entropy of an infinite tree of the localized phase diverges with the following power law near criticality @xmath260 the entropy measures the size of the region where the weight @xmath261 is concentrated , whereas the localization length @xmath262 describes the far exponential decay of the transmission @xmath70 ( eq . [ transloc ] ) . we thus conclude that in the localized phase , besides the localization length @xmath262 known since @xcite , there exists a larger diverging length scale @xmath263 that characterizes the size where the weight @xmath261 is concentrated . as explained above , the root weight @xmath264 and of the i.p.r . @xmath265 are determined by the auxiliary variables @xmath237 introduced in eq . [ defcq ] . we thus expect that the localized and delocalized phases correspond to the following behaviors for the auxiliary variables @xmath237 \(i ) in the localized phase , the auxiliary variables @xmath237 will remain finite random variables as the number of generations diverge @xmath10 . then the root weight @xmath266 and the i.p.r . @xmath227 remain finite as @xmath10 . \(ii ) in the delocalized phase , the auxiliary variables @xmath237 will instead grow exponentially with the number @xmath1 of generations with some lyapunov exponents @xmath267 defined by @xmath268 the corresponding typical behaviors of the root weight and of the i.p.r . then reads @xmath269 and @xmath270 we find numerically that the probability distributions of auxiliary variables @xmath271 move as traveling waves of velocity @xmath272 ( see eq . [ lyapunovcq ] ) with fixed shape ( see figure [ fighistoc1c2 ] of appendix b where the fixed shape is shown for @xmath273 and @xmath213 ) . we explain in appendix b how the lyapunov exponents @xmath272 can be determined via a tail analysis that yields the identity ( see eq . [ selectionqidentity ] ) @xmath274 so that the logarithm of the i.p.r . @xmath227 decays slower than linearly in @xmath1 , because the coefficient in eq . [ lyapunoviq ] exactly vanishes . physically , one could expect the decay to be of order @xmath275 as in eq . [ ipppurcaln ] concerning pure states on the cayley tree , but we have not been able to measure the behavior of the i.p.r . , because within the pool method that we use , it turns out that the pool - dependent critical point is not the same for the variables @xmath236 and for @xmath247 ( see more details in section [ fspool ] ) , so that it does not seem easy with the pool method to extract reliable results concerning @xmath265 . in the remaining of this section , we thus focus on the statistical properties of the root weight @xmath235 that is determined by the auxiliary variable @xmath236 via eq . [ normapsi2 ] . the fact that the pool - dependent critical point for @xmath236 is the same as the critical point found for the landauer transmission can be understood from the tail analysis of the appendices a and b that involve exactly the same integral kernel . : the figure shows that the slope @xmath276 vanishes linearly @xmath277 ( see eq . [ xideloc ] with @xmath6 ) . ( b ) width @xmath278 of the relative variable @xmath279 in the limit @xmath256 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 : it remains finite both in the localized and delocalized phase , but it presents a cusp at the critical point @xmath118 . , title="fig:",height=188 ] : the figure shows that the slope @xmath276 vanishes linearly @xmath277 ( see eq . [ xideloc ] with @xmath6 ) . ( b ) width @xmath278 of the relative variable @xmath279 in the limit @xmath256 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 : it remains finite both in the localized and delocalized phase , but it presents a cusp at the critical point @xmath118 . , title="fig:",height=188 ] in the delocalized phase , the root weight @xmath266 presents the typical decay of eq . [ lyapunovpsi0 ] . we show on fig . [ fig44deloc ] ( a ) that the corresponding lyapunov exponent @xmath276 vanishes linearly in the critical region @xmath280 i.e. we find the same exponent @xmath6 as for the divergence of the correlation length of the localized phase ( see eq . [ nueq1 ] ) . this can be understood from the tail analysis presented in the appendices a and b. we find that the width of the relative variable @xmath279 remains finite in the limit @xmath256 both in the localized phase and in the delocalized phase : its behavior as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 presents a cusp at @xmath118 as shown on fig . [ fig44deloc ] ( b ) . of an infinite tree in the localized phase : ( a ) @xmath281 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 ( b ) @xmath282 as a function of @xmath258 to measure the exponent of the essential singularity of eq . [ essentialsingularity44loc ] : we measure asymptotically a slope of order @xmath283.,title="fig:",height=226 ] of an infinite tree in the localized phase : ( a ) @xmath281 as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 ( b ) @xmath282 as a function of @xmath258 to measure the exponent of the essential singularity of eq . [ essentialsingularity44loc ] : we measure asymptotically a slope of order @xmath283.,title="fig:",height=226 ] in the localized phase , the root weight remains finite as @xmath10 . as show on fig . [ fig44loc ] , we measure the following essential singularity @xmath284 as in section [ fsstrans ] , we now discuss the finite - size scaling in the critical region . if there exists some finite - size scaling in the critical region for the typical root weight , the matching of our results in the delocalized phase ( see eq . [ lyapunovpsi0 ] and [ xideloc ] ) and in the localized phase ( eq . [ essentialsingularity44loc ] ) requires a finite - size correlation length exponent @xmath285 of order @xmath286 we have performed the analysis described in section [ fsstrans ] and we measure that the relaxation length @xmath154 towards the finite value of eq . [ essentialsingularity44loc ] diverges with an exponent @xmath287 of the order of the exponent @xmath285 of eq . [ nufszero ] . we thus obtain that the critical properties are again qualitatively similar to the critical properties described in ref @xcite ( see the summary in appendix c ) : the traveling phase is characterized by a velocity that vanishes linearly , but the finite size scaling is governed by the relaxation length towards the asymptotic finite value of the non - traveling phase . exactly at criticality , we thus expects the following stretched exponential decay of the typical transmission @xmath288 where the exponent @xmath289 is related to the other exponents by ( see the scaling relations of eqs [ kapparelation ] and [ nutyprelation ] in appendix c ) @xmath290 from our previous estimate of the exponent @xmath291 , this corresponds to the numerical value @xmath292 again , as explained after eq . [ transrhonume ] , we have not been able to measure this stretched exponential behavior exactly at criticality from our data , because a precise measure of the exponent @xmath293 would require to be exactly at the critical point . in summary , for the anderson model on the bethe lattice , we have studied numerically the statistics of the landauer transmission @xmath2 and the statistics of eigenstates at the center of the band @xmath55 , as a function of the disorder strength @xmath0 and the number @xmath1 of generations . we have shown that both the localized phase and the delocalized phase are characterized by the traveling wave propagation of some probability distributions . in the text , we have presented detailed numerical results , and in appendices a and b , we have explained how the velocities of the traveling waves are determined by the tails , via the properties of the integral kernel introduced in @xcite . the anderson transition then corresponds to a traveling / non - traveling critical point for these traveling waves , and the critical properties obtained are very similar to the traveling - wave phase transition studied in @xcite : ( i ) the finite value of the non - traveling phase presents an essential singularity ( ii ) the relaxation length towards this essential singularity determines the finite - size scaling in the critical region ( iii ) the finite - size correlation length exponent @xmath149 is different from the value @xmath6 that govern the vanishing of the velocity in the traveling - wave phase . we thus hope that in the future , these properties for anderson localization on the cayley tree will be better understood by extending the methods that have been developed recently for the class of the fisher - kpp traveling waves ( see @xcite and references therein ) . how results obtained on the bethe lattice are related to properties of anderson localization in finite dimension @xmath196 is of course a difficult question . during the history of localization , many values for the upper critical dimension have been proposed such as @xmath294 . even within the supersymmetric community , there seems to be different interpretations . mirlin and fyodorov @xcite consider that the essential singularities that appear on the bethe lattice , are directly related to the exponential growth of the number of sites with the distance , and will become conventional power - law behaviors as soon as @xmath295 , so that the upper critical dimension is actually @xmath296 . on the contrary , efetov @xcite argues that the results obtained for the bethe lattice are relevant to anderson transition in high dimension @xmath196 when reinterpreted within the so - called effective medium approximation. for the landauer transmission , the upper critical dimension @xmath297 can be defined as the dimension where the exponent @xmath298 concerning the width of the sample - to - sample distribution in the localized phase ( see eq.[transd ] ) vanishes @xmath299 . this means that for @xmath300 , the probability distribution would travel as a traveling wave in the whole localized phase . to determine whether @xmath296 or @xmath301 , it would be thus interesting to understand whether the traveling wave propagation with a fixed shape is possible only on trees or whether it can also occur in sufficiently high dimension @xmath196 . in low dimensions , the probability distribution of the logarithm of the transmission is known to broaden with some exponent @xmath302 ( see eq . [ transd ] ) in the localized phase , whereas the probability distribution of the logarithm of i.p.p . is known to shrink with the system size in the delocalized phase @xcite ( see also fig . ( 4a ) of @xcite where the same phenomenon occurs for the directed polymer in @xmath303 dimensions ) . however traveling wave propagations of the probability distribution @xmath304 of inverse participation ratios @xmath227 have actually been found in finite dimensions but only _ exactly at criticality_. this phenomenon has been first obtained for the power - law random band matrix model @xcite and has been then observed for the anderson model in dimensions @xmath305 @xcite : the motions of the typical values @xmath306 with @xmath307 determine the multifractal spectrum , whereas the reduced variables @xmath308 keep fixed distributions presenting power - law tails with @xmath192-dependent exponents . we have actually observed the same behavior for the directed polymer in @xmath303 dimensions exactly at the localization / delocalization transition ( see fig . ( 3a ) and ( 3b ) of ref . @xcite ) . in all these cases , it would be thus very nice to better understand the relations between the tails of the distributions and the motions of the typical values , and to identify the wave equation that underlies these traveling waves . finally , our work raises once again the question whether anderson transitions are characterized by several length scales that diverge with various @xmath19 exponents . here for the cayley tree , besides the exponent @xmath6 that has been predicted for a long time @xcite , we have found other diverging lengths with the following physical meanings . ( i ) in the localized phase , besides the exponent @xmath6 associated to the divergence of localization length @xmath262 that describes the far exponential decay of the transmission @xmath70 ( eq . [ transloc ] ) , we have found that the critical behavior of the entropy is governed by another diverging length scale with @xmath309 ( eq . [ xisloc ] ) that characterizes the size where the weight @xmath261 is concentrated . ( ii ) in the delocalized phase , we have found that the landauer transmission reaches its asymptotic value after a length diverging as @xmath310 ( eq . [ nufstrans ] ) that governs the finite - size scaling of the transmission in the critical region . even if the precision of numerically measured critical exponents can be always discussed , we feel nevertheless that our numerical results are not compatible with the existence of the single exponent @xmath6 . note that for the directed polymer on the cayley tree , we have also found previously that the critical properties involve two exponents @xmath311 and @xmath312 @xcite . whether there exists various exponents @xmath19 for anderson model in finite dimension @xmath196 has been debated for a long time . the majority of papers on anderson localization seem in favor of a single @xmath19 ( see the reviews @xcite ) , but it seems to us that numerical papers actually study always the same type of observables . in particular , we have not been able to find numerical studies concerning the entropy of eigenstates . on the theoretical side , we are not aware of many theories in favor of various @xmath19 exponents , except ( i ) the supersymmetric studies of refs @xcite that involve two different diverging length scales , called respectively the localization length and the phase coherence length . ( ii ) the pseudo - delocalization transition of the random hopping model in dimension @xmath24 , that is characterized by the two exactly known correlation lengths exponents @xmath22 and @xmath311 ( see @xcite and references therein ) , as in the other models described by the same strong disorder fixed point ( see the review @xcite ) . we feel that if localization models exhibit several @xmath19 exponents both on the cayley tree which represents some mean - field @xmath313 limit and in some models in dimension @xmath24 , the possibility of various @xmath19 for anderson transition in dimension @xmath314 should be reconsidered by studying in detail the statistics of various observables . in this appendix , we translate the analysis of ref . @xcite concerning the distribution of the self - energy in the localized phase for the traveling - wave propagation of the landauer transmission discussed in section [ trans ] . the recursion of eq . [ riccatiinside ] for the complex riccati variable @xmath315 reads more explicitly in terms of its real and imaginary parts @xmath316 with @xmath317-\infty,+\infty[$ ] and @xmath318 . @xmath319 where the random on - site energies @xmath320 are drawn from the flat distribution of eq . the landauer transmission of eq . [ transresume ] then reads @xmath321 in the delocalized phase , this recursion of eq . [ ricattiinsidexy ] is difficult to analyze because one has to find the joint distribution of the two finite variables @xmath322 that remain stable upon iteration . in the localized phase however , the problem is simpler @xcite as we now recall . in the localized phase , if the imaginary part @xmath323 converge towards zero exponentially in @xmath87 as @xmath324 where @xmath325 and where @xmath326 remains a finite random variable upon iteration , one has then to study the simpler recurrence for large @xmath87 @xcite @xmath327 note that the form of eq . [ ynscaling ] corresponds to a traveling wave of velocity @xmath328 for the variable @xmath329 @xmath330 the real part @xmath331 satisfies now a closed recurrence independent of the @xmath323 , and its stable distribution @xmath332 satisfies the closed equation @xmath333 \label{petoilex}\end{aligned}\ ] ] an important property of this distribution is that it presents the power - law tail @xmath334 because whenever one of the @xmath47 variables @xmath335 on the right handside of eq . [ petoilex ] is close to @xmath251 , the variable @xmath336 of the left - handside is large with @xmath337 . the stable joint distribution @xmath338 satisfies @xmath339 \delta \left [ y - \sum_{m=1}^k \frac { y_m } { e^{-v } x_m^2 } \right ] \label{ricattistab}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the idea of @xcite is to look for the power - law tail in @xmath340 that is compatible with the recursion equation , i.e. one assumes @xmath341 with some exponent @xmath342 . note that , in the traveling wave language of eq . [ lnynscaling ] , this is equivalent to look for solutions with an exponential tail @xmath343 for the variable @xmath344 . so this corresponds to the usual exponential tail analysis of fronts @xcite , except for the following difference : in usual studies of propagation into unstable phases , it is the forward tail that has an exponential decay and that determines the velocity , whereas in our present case , it is the backward tail that determines the propagation . in laplace transform with respect to @xmath340 , the power - law decay of eq . [ tail ] corresponds to the following singular expansion near the origin @xmath345 equation [ ricattistab ] becomes for the laplace transform @xmath346 @xmath347 \label{ricattistablaplace}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the expansion of eq . [ devlaplace ] , one obtains that the function @xmath348 has to satisfy the eigenvalue equation @xmath349 where the function @xmath350 represents the stationary distribution of the variable @xmath351 @xmath352 \label{fonctionq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( see eqs 6.5 and 6.6 in @xcite ) . the tail analysis thus leads to the eigenvalue problem the integral kernel appearing in eq . [ eqpropreax ] @xmath353 for each @xmath354 and @xmath0 , the integral kernel is positive , and thus one expects some continuous analog of the perron - froebenius theorem : the iteration of the integral kernel will converge towards a positive eigenvector @xmath355 that is associated to the maximal eigenvalue @xmath356 of the kernel . for instance , for the special case @xmath357 , the solution is simply @xmath358 ( see eqs [ petoilex ] and [ fonctionq ] ) and @xmath359 except for this case @xmath357 , we are not aware of any explicit solution for the eigenvalue @xmath356 ( even for the simpler case where the distribution of the on - site energies @xmath360 is a cauchy law and where the distributions @xmath361 and @xmath350 are also cauchy laws @xcite ) . with eqs [ eqpropreax ] and [ kernel ] , one concludes that at fixed @xmath0 , each mode @xmath354 is associated to the velocity @xmath362 ( eq . [ ynscaling ] ) @xmath363 the selection of the tail exponent @xmath354 of eq . [ tail ] and of the corresponding velocity @xmath364 of eq [ ynscaling ] usually depend on the form of the initial condition @xcite . in our present case , the initial condition is completely localized ( see eq . [ riccatifirst ] ) @xmath365 in this case , one expects that the solution that will be dynamically selected @xcite corresponds to the tail exponent @xmath183 and to the velocity @xmath366 determined by the following extremization @xmath367_{\beta=\beta_{selec}(w ) } = \left [ \frac{1}{\beta^2 } \ln \lambda_0(\beta , w ) - \frac{1}{\beta } \frac { \partial_{\beta}\lambda_0(\beta , w ) } { \lambda_0(\beta , w ) } \right]_{\beta=\beta_{selec}(w ) } \label{selection}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the critical point is then determined by the two conditions @xmath368 since the general discussion is rather obscured by the absence of an explicit expression for the eigenvalue @xmath356 of the kernel of eq . [ kernel ] , it is useful to consider the following strong disorder approximation ( called upper limit condition in @xcite ) , where the recursion for the @xmath331 in eq . [ ricattilinearized ] is simply replaced by @xcite @xmath369 the argument is that in the limit of very large @xmath0 , the distribution of @xmath336 has also a width of order @xmath0 , so that the neglected terms in eq . [ ricattilinearized ] are of order @xmath370 . of course the approximation of eq . [ strongapprox ] is not very well controlled , because it concerns random variables , and it suppresses important correlations between the variables @xmath322 of eq . [ ricattilinearized ] . nevertheless , it is useful to consider it before returning to the true recursions of eq . [ ricattilinearized ] , because with eq . [ strongapprox ] , the eigenvalue @xmath356 is replaced by simple expression @xcite ( see also section 7.2 of @xcite where the approximation of independence between @xmath322 is considered for the cauchy case ) @xmath371 the velocity then reads @xmath372 for the flat distribution @xmath360 of random site energies ( eq . [ flat ] ) , one thus obtains @xmath373 the function @xmath374 is defined on the interval @xmath375 : it flows towards @xmath376 in the limits @xmath377 and @xmath378 with the following behaviors @xmath379 and @xmath380 it has a single maximum at @xmath381 given by the extremum condition of eq . [ selection ] , so that @xmath381 is actually independent of @xmath0 . for @xmath382 , the selected exponent is of order @xmath383 for any @xmath0 . we note that is value is close to the value @xmath177 that we measure for the large disorder @xmath184 ( see figure [ figtranswidth ] a ) . in conclusion , this strong disorder approximation allows to see explicitly how things work on a simple example , and seems to give a reasonable value of @xmath384 for very large @xmath0 . we now return to the analysis of the full problem of eq . [ ricattilinearized ] . here we should say that we do not agree with the discussion of @xcite concerning the selection of the tail exponent @xmath354 : \(i ) in @xcite , the authors conclude that within the localized phase , @xmath183 decreases from unity and reaches @xmath386 exactly at criticality ( see the text between eqs . 6.8 and 6.9 in @xcite ) . \(ii ) in our numerical results of section [ trans ] we have found instead that the selected exponent @xmath183 is always smaller than @xmath144 : it slightly grows as the disorder strength @xmath0 decreases and has a value close to @xmath387 near criticality ( see figure [ figtranswidth ] a ) . as a function of the tail exponent @xmath354 for various disorder strength @xmath0 : ( i ) in the localized phase @xmath125 , the velocity is extremum at a @xmath0-dependent value @xmath388 and it is positive @xmath389 ( ii ) at the critical point @xmath390 , the velocity is extremum at @xmath386 where it vanishes @xmath391 ( iii ) in the delocalized phase , there exists another traveling - wave moving in the other direction of velocity @xmath392 : this velocity is extremum at @xmath393 for any @xmath136 ( see appendix b for more details ) , height=226 ] we propose the following argument to justify our finding @xmath385 . we think that the tail analysis is actually well defined only on the interval @xmath375 for the following reasons . the eigenvalue eq . [ kernel ] relates the behavior of @xmath348 at @xmath394 to the behavior of @xmath348 near the origin @xmath395 . for @xmath396 , the function @xmath397 will be finite in the region where @xmath398 is finite , i.e. the integration is dominated by the region @xmath399 and we obtain the power - law decay @xmath400 however the function @xmath348 has to be integrable at @xmath401 to obtain from eq . [ tail ] the probability of the variable @xmath340 alone at large @xmath340 @xmath402 according to eq . [ axinfinity ] , the function @xmath348 is integrable only for @xmath403 i.e. we obtain that the tail analysis has a meaning only for @xmath404 . in the limit @xmath377 , we expect from eq . [ lambda0beta0 ] the same behavior as in eq . [ vapproxflatzero ] @xmath405 exactly at @xmath393 , the authors of @xcite have argued that @xmath406_{\beta=1/2 } = 0 \label{partialdemi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath0 , as a consequence of the symmetry @xmath407 coming from the consideration of the adjoint kernel ( see more details around eqs . 6.7 and 6.8 in @xcite ) . here in contrast to @xcite , we think that the region @xmath408 is not physical because of eq . [ axinfinity ] , but the condition of eq . [ partialdemi ] is useful to understand why the critical point determined by eqs [ criticonditions ] corresponds to the tail exponent @xcite @xmath409 to summarize the selection mechanism , the shape of the velocity @xmath362 as a function of the tail exponent @xmath354 in shown on fig . [ figvelocity ] for various disorder strength @xmath0 : \(i ) in the localized phase @xmath125 , the velocity derivative is negative at @xmath393 : @xmath410_{\beta=1/2 } = \left [ \frac{1}{\beta^2 } \ln \lambda_0(\beta , w > w_c ) \right]_{\beta=1/2 } = - \left [ \frac{1}{\beta } v(\beta , w > w_c ) \right]_{\beta=1/2 } < 0 \label{derineg}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the velocity is extremum at a @xmath0-dependent value @xmath388 and the corresponding selected velocity is positive @xmath389 . \(ii ) at the critical point @xmath390 , the velocity is extremum at @xmath386 where it vanishes @xmath391 . \(iii ) in the delocalized phase , the velocity derivative is positive at @xmath393 : @xmath411_{\beta=1/2 } = \left [ \frac{1}{\beta^2 } \ln \lambda_0(\beta , w < w_c ) \right]_{\beta=1/2 } = - \left [ \frac{1}{\beta } v(\beta , w < w_c ) \right]_{\beta=1/2 } > 0 \label{deripos}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we explain in appendix b that in this delocalized phase , there exists another traveling - wave moving in the other direction with the velocity @xmath392 : this velocity @xmath412 is then extremum at @xmath393 for any @xmath136 ( see appendix b for more details ) . as a final remark , we believe that the solution exactly at @xmath118 is not valid anymore because of eq . [ axinfinity ] , and that the appropriate treatment exactly at criticality should replace the finite velocity motion in @xmath413 assumed in eq . [ lnynscaling ] by the form @xmath414 where the anomalous exponent @xmath415 has been discussed in the text ( see eqs [ transfss ] and [ transrhonume ] ) . in conclusion , the analysis of @xcite is thus very close to the traveling wave analysis of the directed polymer model @xcite : the difference is that in the directed polymer , the variables @xmath331 are random variables independent of the @xmath323 and the selected @xmath384 can be simply obtained from the non - integer moments of @xmath336 ( see the section 7.2 in @xcite ) , whereas in the present localization model , the variables @xmath331 and @xmath323 are correlated and one has thus to solve the eigenvalue problem for the integral kernel of eq . [ kernel ] . in the following appendix , we explain how the same ideas can be used in the delocalized phase . as explained in section [ eigen ] , in the delocalized phase , we have considered the recurrence for the real riccati variable @xmath331 @xmath416 together with the recurrences of eqs [ reccq ] for the auxiliary variables @xmath237 introduced in eq . [ defcq ] . to make more visible the similarities with the previous appendix , it is convenient to perform the change of variables @xmath417 to obtain the following recursions for these variables @xmath418 the recursion of eq . [ ricattix ] for @xmath331 alone will as before converge to some distribution @xmath332 satisfying eq . [ petoilex ] . in the delocalized phase , one expects that the variables @xmath237 will grow exponentially ( see eqs [ lyapunovcq ] ) . we thus set @xmath419 where @xmath267 governs the exponential growth and where @xmath420 remains a finite random variable upon the iteration @xmath421 the similarity with the discussions of appendix a is now obvious ( see eqs [ ynscaling ] and [ ricattilinearized ] ) . assuming the power - law decay @xmath422 with @xmath423 , one finds that the function @xmath424 has to satisfy the eigenvalue problem @xmath425 i.e. it is the same integral kernel as in eq . [ eqpropreax ] with the correspondences @xmath426 and @xmath427 , but now we are interested in the phase @xmath267 . we have argued above ( see section [ beta0demi ] ) that the problem for the function @xmath424 is well defined only for @xmath428 , i.e. the exponent @xmath429 that governs the power - law of eq . [ dtail ] is restricted to the interval @xmath430 of the variable @xmath431 of eq . [ scalingdn ] for various disorder strength @xmath432 : the exponent @xmath433 of eq . [ dtail ] is of order @xmath434 in the whole delocalized phase . ( b ) for @xmath435 , comparison of the probability distributions @xmath436 and @xmath437 of the variable @xmath438 for @xmath273 and @xmath213 : the exponents of eq . [ dtail ] are respectively @xmath434 and @xmath439 in agreement with eq . [ muselec].,title="fig:",height=226 ] of the variable @xmath431 of eq . [ scalingdn ] for various disorder strength @xmath432 : the exponent @xmath433 of eq . [ dtail ] is of order @xmath434 in the whole delocalized phase . ( b ) for @xmath435 , comparison of the probability distributions @xmath436 and @xmath437 of the variable @xmath438 for @xmath273 and @xmath213 : the exponents of eq . [ dtail ] are respectively @xmath434 and @xmath439 in agreement with eq . [ muselec].,title="fig:",height=226 ] denoting as before @xmath356 the maximal eigenvalue of the kernel of eq . [ kernel ] , each mode @xmath440 is associated to the lyapunov exponent ( see eq . [ ynscaling ] ) @xmath441 from eq . [ lambda0beta0 ] , we have the following behavior for @xmath442 @xmath443 near the other boundary @xmath444 , the property of eq . [ partialdemi ] , yields that the partial derivative with respect to @xmath440 is still negative at @xmath444 @xmath445_{\mu \to 1/(2q ) } = \left [ -\frac{1}{\mu^2 } \ln \lambda_0 ( 1/2,w ) \right]_{\mu \to 1/(2q ) } < 0 \label{derimu}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the special case @xmath273 , the curve @xmath446 is directly related via @xmath447 to the curve @xmath364 discussed in appendix a and shown on fig . [ figvelocity ] ( see the delocalized case @xmath136 ) . since the selected tail exponent @xmath448 has to extremize @xmath449 , we conclude that the selected tail exponents are given by the simple values @xmath450 in the whole delocalized phase . this is in agreement with our numerical results . we show on fig . [ fighistoc1c2 ] ( a ) the probability distribution of @xmath451 of the variable @xmath452 of eq . [ scalingdn ] for various disorder strength @xmath432 : the tail exponent @xmath433 of eq . [ dtail ] remains of order @xmath434 . for @xmath213 , we find similarly that the selected tail exponent remains the same within the whole delocalized phase and that it is of order @xmath439 . on fig . [ fighistoc1c2 ] ( b ) , we compare for @xmath435 the probability distributions @xmath451 and @xmath453 of the variables @xmath431 : the exponents of eq . [ dtail ] are respectively @xmath434 and @xmath439 . from eq . [ muselec ] , we obtains that the lyapunov exponents satisfy the identities @xmath454 as explained in the text around eq . [ lyapunoviqidentity ] , this identity is important to understand the decay of i.p.r . with the number @xmath1 of generations in the delocalized phase . as explained in section [ poolmethod ] , the pool method consists in representing a probability distribution @xmath455 by a large number @xmath89 of random variables @xmath456 . in particular this introduces a cut - off in the tail of @xmath455 around @xmath457 with @xmath458 . in the field of traveling waves , the presence of such a cut - off has been much studied ( see @xcite and references therein ) : the leading correction to the selected velocity is usually logarithmic in @xmath89 @xmath459 for our present problem , where the critical point corresponds to a vanishing velocity @xmath460 , we thus expect that the true critical point @xmath461 corresponding to @xmath462 will be shifted towards a pool - dependent pseudo - critical point @xmath463 corresponding to @xmath464 . as explained in the text , all the traveling waves encountered in the present paper vanish linearly in @xmath133 . we thus expect that the difference @xmath465 $ ] will also decay only logarithmically as @xmath466 . from the analysis presented in appendix a and b , it is obvious that the pool dependent critical point for the traveling wave of the landauer transmission ( see appendix a ) and for the auxiliary variable @xmath236 or @xmath467 ( see appendix b ) are the same because they are defined by the same condition in terms of the eigenvalue @xmath468 of the integral kernel . however , the other variables @xmath237 or @xmath469 that have the same true critical point @xmath461 , will not have the same pool - dependent critical point @xmath463 , because the constant @xmath470 in eq . [ vpool ] will depend on @xmath192 . this is indeed what we observe with our numerical computations with the pool @xmath116 : the pseudo - critical point @xmath463 for the variable @xmath247 is below the pseudo - critical point @xmath463 for the variable @xmath236 . we observe that the difference between the two becomes smaller for the bigger pool @xmath115 . in conclusion , numerical studies based on the pool method are valid for observables that are related to a single traveling wave , but one can not study the critical properties of observables that depend on two distinct traveling waves that have different pseudo - critical points . this is why in the text , we have not been able to present reliable numerical results for the statistics of i.p.r . @xmath265 that depends on both @xmath236 and @xmath247 . in this appendix , we briefly recall the finite - size scaling properties of the traveling / non - traveling phase transition studied in ref . @xcite , because these properties are useful to interpret our numerical results described in the text . for a one - dimensional branching random walk in the presence of an absorbing wall moving at a constant velocity @xmath328 , the survival probability @xmath471 presents a phase transition at @xmath472 with the following critical behaviors ( see more details in @xcite ) : \(i ) for @xmath473 , it converges exponentially in time towards a finite limit @xmath474 @xmath475 where the limit @xmath476 presents an essential singularity @xmath477 and where the relaxation time @xmath478 diverges as @xmath479 \(iv ) the critical region is described by some finite - size scaling form governed by the relaxation time @xmath478 that appears in eq . [ qbelow ] ( and not by the relaxation time @xmath482 appearing in eq . [ qabove ] ) @xmath485 where the scaling function @xmath486 has the following asymptotic behaviors . for @xmath487 , has the one has the power - law @xmath488 to recover the finite limit of eq . [ qessential ] and one has the scaling relation @xmath489 for @xmath490 , one has the power - law @xmath491 to recover the exponential decay of eq . [ qabove ] , and one has the scaling relation @xmath492 for the problem considered in @xcite all the exponents are exactly known @xmath493 , @xmath494 , @xmath495 and @xmath496 . in our numerical results presented in the text concerning the traveling / non - traveling phase transitions that occur in anderson localization on the bethe lattice , we find very similar critical behaviors : the velocity of the traveling wave vanishes linearly with @xmath493 , and the finite - size scaling in the critical region is governed by the other exponent @xmath19 that appears in the relaxation towards the finite value of the non - traveling phase . majumdar and p.l . krapivsky , phys . e 62 , 7735 ( 2000 ) ; s.n . majumdar and p.l . krapivsky , phys . e 65 , 036127 ( 2002 ) s.n . majumdar and p.l . krapivsky , physica a 318 , 161 ( 2003 ) ; s.n . majumdar , phys . e 68 , 026103 ( 2003 ) . j. prior , a.m. somoza and m. ortuno , phys . rev . b 72 , 024206 ( 2005 ) ; a.m. somoza , j. prior and m. ortuno , phys . rev . b 73 , 184201 ( 2006 ) ; a.m. somoza , m. ortuno and j. prior , phys . 99 , 116602 ( 2007 ) . e. brunet and b. derrida , phys . e 56 , 2597 ( 1997 ) ; e. brunet , b. derrida , j. stat . 103 , 269 ( 2001 ) ; e. brunet , b. derrida , phys . e 70 , 016106 ( 2004 ) ; e. brunet , b. derrida , a. h. mueller , s. munier , europhys . lett . , 76 , 1 ( 2006 ) ; e. brunet , b. derrida , a. h. mueller , and s. munier ; phys . e 73 , 056126 ( 2006 ) ; e. brunet , b. derrida , a. h. mueller , and s. munier phys . e 76 041104 ( 2007 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: virtual knots and virtual links are a generalisation of classical knots and classical links . they were introduced by l. kauffman . they can be seen as a combinatorial interpretation of copies of @xmath0 embedded in thickened surfaces with genus @xmath1 instead of copies of @xmath0 embedded in @xmath2 . virtual link diagrams are four valent graph embedded into @xmath3 together with a decoration of every vertex . the decorations are either _ overcrossings _ @xmath4 , _ undercrossings _ @xmath5 or _ virtual crossings _ , latter are marked with a circle . a virtual link is an equivalence class of virtual link diagrams modulo the _ generalised reidemeister moves _ in figure [ figure0 - 1 ] and isotopies . the notion of _ oriented _ virtual link diagrams and an _ oriented _ virtual links are equivalent , but latter modulo _ oriented _ generalised reidemeister moves and isotopies . we call the moves rm1 , rm2 and rm3 the _ classical moves _ , the moves vrm1 , vrm2 and vrm3 the _ virtual moves _ and the move mrm the _ mixed move_. in this paper we are also interested in _ virtual tangle diagrams _ and _ virtual tangles_. the first ones are graphs embedded in a disk @xmath6 such that every vertex is either one valent or four valent . the four valent vertices are , like before , labeled with an _ overcrossing _ @xmath4 , an _ undercrossing _ @xmath5 or a _ virtual crossing_. the one valent vertices are part of the boundary of @xmath6 and are called _ boundary points_. we call a virtual tangle diagram with @xmath7 one valent vertices a virtual tangle diagram with _ @xmath7-boundary points_. a virtual tangle with @xmath7-boundary points is an equivalence class of virtual tangle diagrams with @xmath7-boundary points modulo the generalised reidemeister moves and boundary preserving isotopies . we note that every of the moves of figure [ figure0 - 1 ] can be seen as a virtual tangle diagram . moreover , examples are pictured in section [ v - tangles ] , e.g. in figure [ figure1 - 1 ] . the notions of _ oriented _ virtual tangle diagrams and an _ oriented _ virtual tangles can be defined analogous , but latter modulo _ oriented _ generalised reidemeister moves and boundary preserving isotopies . we use the short hand notation c- and v- for everything that starts with classical or virtual , e.g. c - knot means classical knot and v - crossing means virtual crossing . if the reader is unfamiliar with the notion v - link or v - tangle , we refer to some introduction papers of l. kauffman and v. manturov , e.g. @xcite and @xcite and the references therein . a well - known invariant of v - links is the _ virtual jones polynomial _ , i.e. an extension of the jones polynomial from c - links to v - links . moreover , m. khovanov published in @xcite a _ categorification _ of the jones polynomial , i.e. a @xmath8-graded chain complex whose homotopy type is a c - link invariant and whose graded euler characteristic is the jones polynomial . this categorification is called _ khovanov ( co-)homology_. the khovanov complex is a highly studied invariant of c - links . d. bar - natan gave a cobordism based exposition of this categorification in @xcite . d. bar - natans picture has many nice properties , e.g. it can be done _ local _ , i.e. it works for c - tangles as well . it is a natural question if the khovanov complex extents from c - links to v - links . the answer is positive , i.e. there is more then one _ categorification of the virtual jones polynomial _ , one over @xmath9 given by v. manturov in @xcite , one over @xmath10 given by v. manturov in @xcite and one over @xmath10 using cobordisms in the spirit of d. bar - natan in @xcite . the case of v - links is more difficult ( combinatorial ) then the classical case . that is a reason why in @xcite the d. bar - natan approach was not extended to v - tangles . this is the main goal of the paper . in this paper we will answer the question if the categorification extends from c - tangles to v - tangles positive , i.e. it is trivial to extend the notions over @xmath9 or in a trivial way ( by setting open saddles to be zero ) . latter has an obvious disadvantage , i.e. it is neither a `` good '' invariant of v - tangles nor can it be used to calculate bigger complexes by `` tensoring '' smaller pieces . but we give a local notion that is a strong invariant of v - tangles ( see section [ v - tangles ] ) and allows `` tensoring '' of smaller pieces ( see section [ circuit ] ) . as an application of this construction we prove in section [ leedeg ] that the degenerations of lee s variant ( see her paper @xcite ) , i.e. that the homology in her case just `` counts '' the number of components , also extents to v - links . note that latter result is quite surprising since the complex will contain lots of @xmath11-morphisms ( our main observation is that it will also contain many isomorphisms ) . we note that , given the semi - local properties of our construction , it is possible to write a `` fast computation '' algorithm in the sense of d. bar - natan in @xcite before we give a brief summary we recall the main ideas of the cobordism based construction of virtual khovanov homology in @xcite . we will assume that the reader is familiar with the notion of the classical khovanov complex , e.g. the construction of the khovanov cube based on so - called _ resolutions of the crossings_. there are many good introduction to classical khovanov homology , e.g. a nice exposition of the classical khovanov homology can be found in d. bar - natan s paper @xcite . moreover we assume that the reader is familiar with the cobordism based construction of the classical khovanonv complex of d. bar - natan in @xcite . recall that latter involves the _ local relation _ in figure [ figure0 - 2 ] . should be zero , a cobordism that contains a torus @xmath12 should be two times the cobordism without the torus and the four tubes relation . ] to maintain readability , we repress in this short summary the more technical points about the construction , e.g. the placement of the signs . for more details see @xcite . note that this technical points are a main reason for the length of the paper . the following table shows the connection between the classical and the virtual case . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] hence , a main point in the construction of the virtual khovanov complex is to say which saddles , i.e. morphisms , are orientable and which are non - orientable , how to place the decorations and how to place the signs . this is done in the following way . * every saddle either split one circle in a resolution ( orientable , called _ comultiplication _ , denoted @xmath13 . see figure [ figure1 - 2 ] - upper row , fourth morphism ) , glues two circles in a resolution ( orientable , called _ multiplication _ , denoted @xmath14 . see figure [ figure1 - 2 ] - upper row , fifth morphism ) or does not change the number of circles at all ( non - orientable , called _ mbius cobordism _ , denoted @xmath15 . see figure [ figure1 - 2 ] - upper row , last morphism ) . * every saddle can be local denoted ( up to a rotation ) by a formal symbol @xmath16 ( both smoothings are neighbourhoods of the crossing ) . the _ glueing numbers _ , i.e. the decorations , are now spread by _ choosing a formal orientation _ for the resolution . we note that the construction will not depend on the choice . * after all resolutions have an orientation , a saddle could for example be of the form @xmath17@xmath18 . this is the _ standard form _ , i.e. in this case every glueing number will be @xmath19 . * now spread the decorations as follows . every boundary component gets a @xmath19 iff the orientation is like in the standard case and a @xmath20 otherwise . the _ degenerated _ cases ( everything non - alternating ) , e.g. @xmath21@xmath18 , are the non - orientable surfaces and do not get any decorations . * there is a relation how the saddles behave if one changes the decorations . see for example figure [ figure1 - 3 ] bottom row and figure [ figure1 - 4 ] right part . because of this relations we say that @xmath14 is of type @xmath22 , @xmath13 of type @xmath23 and @xmath15 of type @xmath11 . * the signs are spread based on numbering of the circles in the resolutions and on a special x - marker for the crossings ( rather technical , see @xcite for details or definition [ defin - saddlestructure ] for a short introduction ) . a x - marker is for example pictured in figure [ figure0-main ] . to construct the virtual khovanov complex for v - tangles we need to extend the notions above in such a way that they still work for open cobordisms . a first generalisation is easy , i.e. we will still use immersed possible non - orientable surfaces with boundary decorations , but we allow vertical boundary components , e.g. the three v - reidemeister cobordisms vrm1 , vrm2 and vrm3 cobordisms in figure [ figure0 - 3 ] . one main point is the question what to do with the _ open saddles _ , i.e. saddles with no closed boundary . see bottom row in figure [ figure1 - 2 ] . a possible solution is to define them to zero . but this has two major problems . first the loss of information is big and second we would not have local properties like in the classical case ( `` tensoring '' of smaller parts ) since an open saddle can , after closing some of his boundary circles , become either @xmath14 , @xmath13 or @xmath15 . see figure [ figure0 - 4 ] . hence , an information mod 3 is missing . we therefore consider morphisms with an _ indicator _ , i.e. an element of the set @xmath24 , e.g. see figure [ figure1 - 2 ] . then , after taking care of some technical difficulties , the concept extens from c - tangles to v - tangles . the outline of the paper is as follows . * in section [ v - tangles ] we define the notions of a _ v - tangle ( diagram ) _ with @xmath7-boundary points . moreover , we define the geometric category we are working in and define _ two different _ versions of the virtual khovanov complex . we show in theorem [ theo - geoinvarianz ] that both are invariants of v - tangles and we show in theorem [ theo - marker ] that both versions are equal for c - tangles and v - links . * in section [ circuit ] we discuss the local properties of the construction . we define the notion of a _ decorated circuit diagram _ , i.e. the virtual analogon of a planar diagram , and we show in theorem [ theo - semiloc ] that the construction has semi - local properties , i.e. the classical notion extents to a certain class of v - tangle diagrams . a main tool is the _ dot - calculus _ which is sketched in figure [ figure0-main ] , i.e. change the decorations iff the orientations of the input diagram and the local piece mismatch ( red dot ) , do not change them iff they match ( green dot ) and add in a bolt symbol ( non - orientable ) iff at the top and the bottom one gets a green and a red dot . * in section [ leedeg ] we show that the extension of lee s variant of khovanov homology still has the same `` degeneration '' as in the classical case , i.e. the homology just `` counts '' the number of v - link components . see theorem [ theo - leedeg ] . note that this is rather surprising since the map @xmath15 will be a @xmath11-morphism if @xmath25 is invertible . our main observation why the degeneration still holds is explained in example [ beisp - leedeg ] . in order to prove theorem [ theo - leedeg ] we use a special trick , i.e. we define two idempotents called _ down _ and _ up _ , go to the _ karoubi envelope _ and prove that there , using the semi - local construction of section [ circuit ] , the question simplifies to the case of counting _ non - alternating resolutions_. see figure [ figure4 - 2 ] . for a v - tangle diagram @xmath26 we call @xmath27 the _ @xmath11- _ and @xmath28 the _ @xmath29-resolution _ of the crossing @xmath4 . for an oriented v - tangle diagram @xmath26 we call @xmath30 a _ positive _ and @xmath31 a _ negative _ crossing . the _ number of positive crossings _ is called @xmath32 and the _ number of negative crossings _ is called @xmath33 . for a given v - tangle diagram @xmath26 with @xmath34-numbered crossings we define a collection of closed curves and open strings @xmath35 in the following way : let @xmath36 be a word of length @xmath34 in the alphabet @xmath37 . then @xmath35 is the collection of closed curves and open strings which arise when one performs a @xmath38-resolution at the @xmath39-th crossing of @xmath26 for all @xmath40 . we call such a collection @xmath35 the _ @xmath36-th resolution _ of @xmath26 . we can choose an orientation for the different components of @xmath35 . we call such a @xmath35 an _ orientated resolution_. if we ignore orientations , then there are @xmath41 different resolutions @xmath35 of @xmath26 . we say a resolution has length @xmath14 if it contains exactly @xmath14 1-letters . that is @xmath42 . for two resolutions @xmath35 and @xmath43 with @xmath44 and @xmath45 for one fixed @xmath46 and @xmath47 for @xmath48 we define a _ saddle between the resolutions @xmath49_. this means : choose a small ( no other crossing , classical and virtual , should be involved ) neighbourhood @xmath50 of the @xmath46-th crossing and define a cobordism between @xmath35 and @xmath43 to be the identity outside of @xmath50 and a saddle inside of @xmath50 . sometimes we need a so - called _ spanning tree argument _ , i.e. choose a spanning tree of a cube ( like in figure [ figure0 - 5 ] ) and change e.g. orientations such that the edges of the tree change in a suitable way , starting at leafs and remove them and repeat . note that any v - tangle diagram should be oriented in the usual sense . but with a slight abuse of notation , we will repress this orientation throughout the whole paper . recall that these orientations are needed for the shifts in homology gradings , see for example @xcite . i wish to thank v. manturov for corrections and many helpful comments . moreover i wish to thank a. kaestner and l. kauffman for suggestions and helpful comments helping me to write a computer program for calculations in the future . in this section we describe how the virtual khovanov complex can be extended in such a way that it also works for v - tangles and not just for v - links . our extension follows the ideas of d. bar - natan in @xcite . first we define the notion of a _ virtual tangle ( diagram ) _ , called _ v - tangle ( diagram)_. [ defin - vtangle ] a _ virtual tangle diagram with @xmath51 boundary points _ @xmath26 is a planar graph embedded in a disk @xmath6 . this planar graph is a collection of _ usual vertices _ and @xmath7-_boundary vertices_. we also allow circles , i.e. closed edges without any vertices . the usual vertices are all of valency four . any of these vertices is either an overcrossing @xmath4 or an undercrossing @xmath5 or a virtual crossing . latter is marked with a circle . the boundary vertices are of valency one and are part of the boundary of @xmath6 . we call the crossings @xmath4 and @xmath5 _ classical crossings _ or just _ crossings _ and a virtual tangle diagram without virtual crossings a _ classical tangle diagram_. a _ virtual tangle with @xmath51 boundary points _ @xmath52 is an equivalence class of virtual tangle diagrams @xmath26 module boundary preserving isotopies and _ generalised reidemeister moves _ ( see figure [ figure0 - 1 ] ) . we call a virtual tangle @xmath52 _ classical _ if the set @xmath52 contains a classical tangle diagram . a v - circle is a circle without classical crossings and a v - string is a string starting and ending at the boundary without classical crossings . we call a v - circle / v - string without virtual crossings a _ c - circle / c - string_. the _ closure of a v - tangle diagram with * -marker _ @xmath53 is a v - link diagram which is constructed by capping of neighbouring boundary points ( starting from a fixed point marked with the * -marker and going counter - clockwise ) without creating new virtual crossings . for an example see figure [ figure1 - 1 ] . there are exactly two , maybe non equivalent , closures of any v - tangle diagram . in the figure below the two closures are pictured using green edges . the notions of an _ oriented _ virtual tangle diagram and of an _ oriented _ virtual tangle are defined analogue . the latter modulo _ oriented _ generalised reidemeister moves and boundary preserving isotopies . from now on every v - tangle ( diagram ) should be oriented . but we repress this notion to avoid confusion with the ( more important ) notions of oriented resolutions and orientations for circuit diagrams ( see section [ circuit ] ) . moreover , a _ decorated _ v - tangle diagram is a v - tangle diagram with orientations for all of its circles / strings . we discuss the category of _ open cobordisms with boundary decorations_. it is almost the same as in @xcite , but the corresponding cobordisms could be open , i.e. they could have vertical boundary components , and are decorated with an extra information , i.e. a number in the set @xmath24 . we picture the number @xmath11 as a bolt . if the reader is unfamiliar with the notions and relations of cobordisms we suggest to check for example the book of j. kock @xcite . [ defin - category ] let @xmath51 and let @xmath54 be a commutative and unital ring . our category should be @xmath55pre - additive . the symbol @xmath56 should denote the disjoint union ( the coproduct in our category ) . * the objects : * the _ objects _ _ @xmath57 _ ) are numbered v - tangles diagrams with @xmath7 boundary points without classical crossings . we denote the objects as @xmath58 . here @xmath59 are the v - circles or v - strings and @xmath60 is a finite , ordered index set . the objects of the category should be unique up to _ boundary preserving planar isotopies _ of planar graphs . * the generators : * the _ generators _ of @xmath61 are the cobordisms from figure [ figure1 - 2 ] . the cobordisms pictured are all between c - circles or c - strings . every generator has a decoration from the set @xmath24 . we call this decoration the _ indicator _ of the cobordisms . if no indicator is pictures it should be @xmath22 . every generator with a decoration @xmath62 has extra decorations from the set @xmath63 at every horizontal boundary component . we call these decorations the _ gluing numbers _ of the cobordism . we consider these cobordisms up to boundary preserving homeomorphisms ( as abstract surfaces ) . hence , between circles or strings with v - crossings the generators are the same up to boundary preserving homeomorphisms immersed into @xmath64 $ ] . the vertical boundary components are pictured in red . we denote the different generators ( from left to right ; top row first ) @xmath65 and @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath15 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath15 and @xmath76 . * the morphisms : * the _ morphisms _ _ @xmath61 _ are cobordisms between the objects in the following way . first we identify the collection of numbered v - circles or v - strings with circles or strings immersed into @xmath6 . given two objects @xmath77 with @xmath78 numbered v - circles or v - strings , then a morphism @xmath79 is a surface immersed in @xmath64 $ ] whose non vertical boundary lies only in @xmath80 and is the disjoint union of the @xmath81 numbered v - circles or v - strings from @xmath82 in @xmath83 and the disjoint union of the @xmath84 numbered v - circles or v - strings from @xmath85 in @xmath86 . the morphisms should be generated ( as abstract surfaces ) by the generators from above ( see figure [ figure1 - 2 ] ) . * the decorations : * every morphisms has an _ indicator _ from the set @xmath24 . moreover , every morphism @xmath79 in @xmath61 is a cobordism between the numbered v - circles or v - strings of @xmath82 and @xmath85 . let us say that the v - circles or v - strings of @xmath82 are numbered @xmath87 and the v - circles or v - strings from @xmath85 are numbered for @xmath88 . every cobordism with @xmath89 as an indicator should have a decoration on the @xmath39-th boundary circle . this decoration is an element of the set @xmath63 . we call this decoration of the @xmath39-th boundary component the _ @xmath39-th gluing number _ of the cobordism . hence , the morphisms of the category are pairs @xmath90 . here @xmath79 is a cobordism from @xmath82 to @xmath85 immersed in @xmath64 $ ] and @xmath91 is a string of length @xmath92 in such a way that the @xmath39-th letter of @xmath91 is the @xmath39-th gluing number of the cobordism and the last latter is the indicator or @xmath93 if the cobordism has @xmath11 as indicator . * short hand notation : * we denote a morphism @xmath94 which is a connected surfaces as @xmath95 . here @xmath96 are words in the alphabet @xmath63 in such a way that the @xmath97th character of @xmath98 ( of @xmath99 ) is the gluing number of the @xmath97th circle of the upper ( of the lower ) boundary . the number @xmath100 should be the indicator . the construction above ensures that this notation is always possible . therefore we denote an arbitrary morphism @xmath90 as @xmath101 here @xmath102 are its connected components and @xmath103 are words in @xmath63 . for a morphism with @xmath11 as indicator we do not need any boundary decorations . with a slight abuse of notation , we denote all these cobordisms like the non orientable cobordisms as @xmath15 . * the relations : * and just the product otherwise . ] and just the product otherwise . ] and just the product otherwise . ] and just the product otherwise . ] and just the product otherwise . ] and just the product otherwise . ] and just the product otherwise . ] there are different relations for the cobordisms , namely _ topological relations _ and _ combinatorial relations_. the latter relations are describe by the gluing numbers and indicators of the cobordisms and the gluing of the cobordisms . the topological relations are not pictured but it should be clear how they should work . see for example j. kock in @xcite and our paper in @xcite . the monoidal structure should be induced by the disjoint union @xmath56 . the category is a semi - strict monoidal category . moreover the category is symmetric . hence , by mac lane s coherence theorem ( see @xcite ) we can assume that the category is a strict , symmetric , monoidal category . we define the full category @xmath104 to be the category whose objects are @xmath105 and whose morphisms are @xmath106 . note the following collection of formulas that follow from the relations . recall that @xmath68 and @xmath72 change the decorations and that @xmath15 and @xmath76 change the indicators . with a slight abuse of notation we repress to write tensors if it is not neccessary , i.e. for the indicator changes . moreover , since @xmath68 and @xmath72 satiesfy similar formulas , we only write down the equations for @xmath68 . [ lemm - calc ] let @xmath107 be two objects in @xmath108 . let @xmath109 be a morphism that is connected , has @xmath110 as an indicator and @xmath98 and @xmath99 as decorated boundary strings . then we have the following identities . we write @xmath111 as a short hand notation if the indicators and gluing numbers do not matter . * @xmath112 ( indicator changes commute ) . * @xmath113 ( @xmath15 commutes ) . * @xmath114 ( first decoration commutation relation ) . * let @xmath115 denote the decoration change at the corresponding positions of the words @xmath96 . then we have @xmath116(second decoration commutation relation ) . everything follows by a straightforeward usage of the relations in definition [ defin - category ] above . next we define some short hand notations for the different categories we use . for any pre - additive category @xmath117 we define @xmath118 as the _ category of formal matrices _ and @xmath119 as the _ category of formal chain complexes _ over @xmath117 . if the reader is unfamiliar with the notations we refer to @xcite . [ defin - category2 ] we call @xmath120 the category @xmath121 . here our objects are formal chain complexes of formal direct sums in the category of ( possible non orientable ) open cobordisms with boundary decorations . then we define @xmath122 as the category @xmath120 modulo formal chain homotopy . moreover , we define @xmath123 , which has the same objects as the category @xmath108 , but the morphisms are all modulo the local relations from figure [ figure0 - 2 ] . furthermore we define @xmath124 and @xmath125 in the obvious sense . the notations @xmath126 or @xmath127 mean that we consider all possible cases , namely with or without a @xmath128 and with or without a @xmath99 . moreover , we use the same notions if @xmath129 . we are now able to define the _ geometric complex of a v - tangle diagram _ @xmath26 . for this construction we use our notations for the _ saddle decorations _ and _ saddle signs _ of v - link diagrams @xmath130 from section two in @xcite . the reader unfamiliar with the notations may check the corresponding definitions . we only repeat these two important constructions in a very brief summary . the only new notion in the definition below is the spreading of the _ indicator of the saddle_. [ defin - saddlestructure ] let @xmath130 be a v - link diagram . moreover , let @xmath131 be a saddle between the numbered , orientated resolutions @xmath132 . every saddle can be viewed as an formal symbol @xmath16 together with a formal local orientation of these strings which is equal to the orientations of @xmath132 . we say the saddle of the form @xmath17@xmath18 is of _ standard form_. moreover , choose a position for the _ x - marker _ at any crossing and a numbering of the v - circles in the resolutions . recall that the x - marker is just a choice in which direction one rotates a saddle @xmath133 until one can compare it to the saddle in standard form . the complex will be well - defined for any choice and different choices give chain isomorphic complexes ( section two in @xcite ) . for every orientable saddle the _ saddle sign _ is the product of two numbers , both either @xmath29 or @xmath23 . if the x - marker is on the lower numbered saddle , then the first number should be @xmath29 and @xmath23 otherwise . moreover , if the number of v - circles with a higher number then the x - marked v - circle is odd , then the second number should be @xmath29 and @xmath23 otherwise . the reader should check that this definition corresponds to the one in section two of @xcite . now we spread the _ saddle decorations _ as follows : * if the saddle is non orientable , then we do not need any decorations . * if the saddle is orientable , then we compose the standard saddles @xmath70 or @xmath69 with @xmath68 for every not standard oriented string . the saddle should have a formal minus sign iff the saddle sign is negative . every orientable surface should carry an indicator @xmath22 iff the number of upper boundary components of the saddle is two and a @xmath23 iff the number is one . every non orientable saddle gets a zero as indicator . everything together , i.e. boundary decorations , saddle sign and indicator , is denoted as the _ saddle decoration _ of @xmath49 . beware that many choices are involved . but the do not change the complex up to chain isotopies ( lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] ) . now let @xmath26 be a tangle diagram with a * -marker on the boundary and let @xmath53 be the closure of the diagram . the _ saddle decoration _ of the saddles of @xmath26 should be the ones induced by the saddle decorations of the closure . [ defin - geocomplex ] for a v - tangle diagram @xmath26 with a * -marker on the boundary and with @xmath34 ordered crossings we define _ the geometric complex _ @xmath134 as follows : * for @xmath135 the @xmath136 _ chain module _ is the formal direct sum of all oriented resolutions @xmath35 of length @xmath39 . * there are only morphisms between the chain modules of length @xmath39 and @xmath137 . * if two words @xmath138 differ only in exactly one letter and @xmath44 and @xmath45 , then there is a morphism between @xmath35 and @xmath43 . otherwise all morphisms between components of length @xmath39 and @xmath137 are zero . * this morphism is a _ saddle _ between @xmath35 and @xmath43 . * the saddles should carry the _ saddle decorations _ from definition [ defin - saddlestructure ] . note that it is not clear at this point why we can choose the numbering of the crossings , the numbering of the v - circles and the orientation of the resolutions of the closure . furthermore it is not clear why this complex is a well - defined chain complex . we show in lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] that the complex is independent of these choices , i.e. if @xmath139 and @xmath140 are well - defined chain complexes with different choices , then they are equal up to chain isomorphisms . the same lemma ensures that the complex is a well - defined chain complex . beware that the position of the * -marker is important for v - tangle diagrams . but theorem [ theo - marker ] ensures that the position is not important for classical v - tangles and v - links . if it does not matter which of the possible two different chain complexes is which , i.e. it is just important that they could be different , then we denote them as @xmath141 and @xmath142 for a v - tangle diagram @xmath26 without a chosen marker position . for an example see figure [ figure1 - 10 ] . this figure shows the virtual khovanov complex of a v - tangle diagram with two different * -marker positions . the vertical arrow between them indicates that they are chain isomorphic . [ lemma - everythingfine ] let @xmath26 be a v - tangle diagram with a * -marker and let @xmath143 be its geometric complex from definition [ defin - geocomplex ] with arbitrary orientations for the resolutions of the closure . let @xmath144 be the complex with the same orientations for the resolutions except for one circle @xmath145 in one resolution @xmath35 . if a face @xmath146 from @xmath143 is anti - commutative , then the corresponding face @xmath147 from @xmath144 is also anti - commutative . moreover , if @xmath143 is a well - defined chain complex , then it is isomorphic to @xmath144 , which is also a well - defined chain complex . the same statement is true if the difference between the two complexes is the numbering of the crossings , the choice of the rotation for the calculation of the saddle signs or the fixed numbering of the v - circles of the closure . moreover , the same is true for any rotations / isotopies of the v - tangle diagram . hence , we can speak of _ the _ geometric complex @xmath134 of the v - tangle diagram with a * -marker . the complex is a well - defined chain complex . for v - tangle diagrams @xmath26 with @xmath148 the statement is the same as the corresponding statement in section two in @xcite . recall that the trick is to reduce all faces through a finite sequence of vrm1 , vrm2 , vrm3 and mrm moves ( see figure [ figure0 - 1 ] ) and virtualisations ( see figure [ figure1 - 11 ] ) to a finite number of different possible faces . then one does a case - by - case check . because the saddles in the two chain complexes are topological the same , we only have to worry about the decorations . but the decorations are spread based on the closure of the v - tangle diagram and the relations from definition [ defin - category ] are build in such a way that the open cases behave like the closed ones . hence , we can use the statement for @xmath148 to finish the proof . the next theorem is very important but the proof itself is almost equal to the proof of d. bar - natan in @xcite and our version in @xcite . therefore we skip the details . [ theo - geoinvarianz ] let @xmath149 be two v - tangle diagrams with the same * -marker position which differs only through a finite sequence of isotopies and generalised reidemeister moves . then the complexes @xmath134 and @xmath150 are equal in @xmath151 . because the proof of d. bar - natan in @xcite and therefore the corresponding proof in @xcite is local we could copy the arguments from there . the lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] guarantees that we can choose the numbering and orientations without changing anything up to chain isomorphisms . furthermore we use the statements of the theorem [ theo - semiloc ] and the corollary [ koro - reidemeister ] to finish the proof . beware that the chain homotopies in @xcite should all carry @xmath22 as indicator . we need some notions now . let @xmath26 denote a v - tangle diagram . we call a part of @xmath26 a _ connected part _ if it is connected as the four - valent graph on a surface with boundary which is created by replacing every c - crossing with a four - valent vertex and eliminating v - crossings by adding handles to a sphere with boundary . the genus of the surfaces should be high enough such that the graph has no v - crossings any more . we call a connected part of a v - tangle diagram _ fully internal _ if it is not adjacent to the boundary . see figure [ figure1 - 12 ] . the left v - tangle diagram has one connected part , which is not fully internal , and the right v - tangle diagram has two connected parts , one fully internal and one not fully internal . a virtual crossing is called _ negligible _ if it is part of a fully internal part , e.g. all v - crossings of the right v - tangle diagram in figure [ figure1 - 12 ] are negligible . we call a v - tangle diagram @xmath26 _ nice _ if there is a finite sequence of of vrm1 , vrm2 , vrm3 and mrm moves and virtualisations such that every v - circle is negligible , e.g. every v - link diagram is nice and every c - tangle diagram is nice . an example of a not nice v - tangle diagram is pictured in figure [ figure2 - 4 ] . we note that for a v - tangle diagram @xmath26 the chain complexes @xmath141 and @xmath142 are almost the same , i.e. they have the same vertices but possible different edges ( which are still in the same position ) . the next lemma concretise the observation . the numbering in the lemma should be the same for the two complexes . [ lemma - factorbyisos ] let @xmath26 be a v - tangle diagram . let @xmath152 and @xmath153 denote the numbered saddles of @xmath141 and of @xmath142 . then we have a factorisation of the form @xmath154 for invertible cobordisms @xmath155 for every @xmath39 if @xmath26 is a nice v - tangle diagram . that the saddles are topological equivalent is clear . we only have take a look at the decorations . the main point is the following observation : of the four outer ( two on both sides ) cobordisms in the bottom row of figure [ figure1 - 2 ] , i.e. @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath156 and @xmath76 , only the third is not invertible . the first is the identity , the second and fourth are their own inverses . the third is not invertible because the @xmath11-indicator can not be changed to an @xmath157-indicator . note that none of the vrm1 , vrm2 , vrm3 and mrm moves nor a virtualisations changes the indicator of a saddle cobordism . hence , it is sufficient to show the statement for a v - tangle diagram with only negligible v - crossings . from the observation above it is enough to show that every saddle gets an @xmath11-indicator in one closure iff it gets an @xmath11-indicator in the other closure . the only possible way that a saddle gets an indicator from @xmath62 for one closure and an @xmath11-indicator for the other closure is the rightmost case in figure [ figure0 - 4 ] . but for this case the existence of a non negligible v - crossing is necessary . hence , we get the statement . [ prop - nicechainiso ] let @xmath26 be a v - tangle diagram . then @xmath141 and @xmath142 are chain isomorphic if @xmath26 is nice . let @xmath26 be a nice v - tangle diagram . then lemma [ lemma - factorbyisos ] ensures that every saddle is the same , up to isomorphisms , in @xmath141 and @xmath142 . furthermore lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] ensures that both are well - defined chain complexes . hence , the number of signs of every face is odd ( also counting the ones from the decorations ) . hence , we can use a spanning tree argument to construct the chain isomorphism explicit , i.e. start at a leaf of a spanning tree of the khovanov cube and change the orientations of the vertex such that the unique outgoing edge of the tree has the same sign in both cases ( lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] ensures that nothing changes modulo chain isomorphisms ) . continue along the vertices of the spanning tree remove already visited leafs . this construction generates a chain isomorphism . next repeat the whole process , but change the indicators now . the lemma [ lemma - factorbyisos ] ensures that this will also generate a chain isomorphism . the chain isomorphism that we need is the composition . see for example figure [ figure1 - 10 ] . the following theorem ensures that the choice of the position of the marker is not important for classical v - tangles or v - links . hence , we can say that our notions extents both , the classical version and the version for v - tangle diagrams . note that this is also an invariant for the question if a v - tangle diagram is classical or not . [ theo - marker ] let @xmath26 be a v - tangle diagram with two different * -marker positions . let @xmath141 and @xmath142 be the geometric complex from definition [ defin - geocomplex ] for the two positions . then the two complexes are equal in @xmath151 if the v - tangle has @xmath148 or is a c - tangle . for a v - tangle with @xmath148 we can use the proposition [ prop - nicechainiso ] above . for a classical v - tangle we can choose a diagram without virtual crossing without changing anything up to chain homotopies , because of theorem [ theo - geoinvarianz ] . then we can use the proposition [ prop - nicechainiso ] again . note that the whole construction can be done with an arbitrary _ non virtual closure _ of a v - tangle diagram , i.e. capping it of without creating new v - crossings . one can repeat the arguments above to prove analogous statements like above for this construction , too . [ rem - gradings ] we could use the euler characteristic to introduce the structure of a graded category ( see @xcite ) on @xmath108 ( and hence on @xmath158 ) . the differentials in the geometric complex from definition [ defin - geocomplex ] have all @xmath159 ( after a grade shift ) , because their euler - characteristic is @xmath23 . then it is easy to proof that the geometric complex is a v - tangle invariant under graded homotopy . the proof of this statement is analogue to the one of d. bar - natan from @xcite . in the present section we describe the notion of a _ circuit algebra_. a circuit algebra is almost the same as a planar algebra , but we allow virtual crossings . planar algebras were introduced by v. jones ( see @xcite ) and were for example studied by d. bar - natan in the case of classical khovanov homology ( see @xcite ) . hence , we can use most of his constructions in our case , too . a crucial difference is that we need to _ decorate _ our _ circuit diagrams_. this is necessary because our cobordisms are also decorated . we start the section with the definition of a circuit diagram . recall that we call v - tangle diagram _ decorated _ if all of its strings / circles are oriented . we call a cobordisms _ decorated _ if it has gluing numbers at the boundary and indicators , see definitions [ defin - vtangle ] and [ defin - category ] . moreover , in the whole section every v - tangle diagram should carry a * -marker . [ defin - circuit diagram ] let @xmath160 denote a disk embedded into @xmath161 , the so - called _ outside disk_. let @xmath162 denote @xmath163 disks @xmath6 embedded into @xmath161 such that for all @xmath163 the disk @xmath162 is also embedded into @xmath160 without touching the boundary of @xmath160 , i.e. @xmath164 and @xmath165 . we denote @xmath166 . a _ circuit diagram with @xmath14 input disks _ @xmath167 is a planar graph embedded into @xmath168 with only vertices of valency one and four in such a way that every vertex of valency one is in @xmath169 and every vertex of valency four is in @xmath170 . all vertices of valency four are marked with a virtual crossing . again we allow circles , i.e. closed edges without any vertices . see for example figure [ figure2 - 1 ] . * -marked circuit diagram _ is the same with @xmath171 extra * -marker for every boundary of @xmath168 . moreover , we call the vertices at @xmath172 the _ outer boundary points_. a _ closure _ of a * -marked circuit diagram with @xmath14 input disks @xmath173 is a circuit diagram with @xmath14 input disks and without any outer boundary points which is constructed from @xmath167 by capping of neighbouring strings starting from the * -marker and proceeding counter - clockwise . note that we only cap of the outside disk and not the small inside disks . a _ decoration _ for a * -marked circuit diagram is a tuple of a numbering and an orientation of the strings of the diagram in such a way that its also an numbering and orientation of the closure . we call a circuit diagram together with a decoration a _ decorated circuit diagram_. see for example figure [ figure2 - 1 ] . the decoration of the circuit diagram in this figure is also a decoration for the closure ( the diagram together with the green lines ) . with this setting we can implement the definition of a _ ( decorated ) circuit algebra_. we follow the definitions of d. bar - natan and v. jones ( see @xcite , @xcite ) . recall that our v - tangle diagrams should always be oriented . [ defin - circuit algebra ] let @xmath174 be the set of ( decorated ) v - tangle diagrams with @xmath7 boundary points and a * -marker and let @xmath175 denote the quotient by boundary preserving isotopies and generalised reidemeister moves . furthermore let @xmath167 denote a ( decorated ) circuit diagram with @xmath14 input disks and @xmath176 outer boundary points in such a way that the @xmath177-th input disk has @xmath178 numbered boundary points . because @xmath167 has no classical crossings , this induces operations @xmath179 by placing the @xmath39-th v - tangle diagram from @xmath180 in the @xmath39-th boundary component of @xmath167 , i.e. glue the v - tangle inside in such a way that the * -markers match . see the right side of figure [ figure2 - 2 ] . there is an identity operation on @xmath181 ( it is of the form @xmath182{figs / circuitid.pdf}}\end{array}\hspace{-3pt}}}$ ] ) and the operations are compatible in a natural way ( associative ) . we call a set of sets @xmath183 along with operations @xmath167 like above a _ circuit algebra _ , provided that the identity and associativity from above holds . if the operators and elements are decorated , first with numbers and orientations and latter only with orientations , then we call a set of sets @xmath183 like above a _ decorated circuit algebra_. note that in this case we have to define how the decorations change after gueing , since we can run into ambiguities . a necessary definition is the notion of a @xmath184-morphism . here @xmath184 is a subset of a circuit algebra @xmath183 . we need this notion because , in contrast to the classical case , the bracket is not a morphism of circuit algebras . see ( c ) of theorem [ theo - semiloc ] below . [ defin - cirmor ] a _ morphism @xmath185 of ( decorated ) circuit algebras _ @xmath183 and @xmath186 is a map @xmath187 which satisfies @xmath188 for every ( decorated ) operation @xmath167 . let @xmath184 be a subset of @xmath183 . a _ @xmath184-morphism @xmath185 of ( decorated ) circuit algebras _ @xmath183 and @xmath186 is a map @xmath187 which satisfies @xmath189 for every ( decorated ) operation @xmath167 here are some examples . the reader may also check the corresponding section in the paper of d. bar - natan from @xcite . [ beisp - circuit ] the first example is the set @xmath190 from definition [ defin - category ] , i.e. v - tangles diagrams with @xmath51 boundary points without classical crossings and an extra * -marker . this is a sub - circuit algebra of the circuit algebra that allows classical crossings . this example gets more exciting if we want to view it as a decorated circuit algebra . we have to define the operations , i.e. the gluing inside the input disks , in more detail now , since we can run into ambiguities , see top row of figure [ figure2 - 3 ] . we can run into ambiguities if the decorations of the operator get glued together do not match up . in this case we define the new decoration based on the rule _ `` lower first '' _ , i.e. the new number should be the lower and the new orientation should be the one from the lower numbered string . see lower row of figure [ figure2 - 3 ] . not all four cases are pictured but it should be clear how the other two work . furthermore if we glue a decorated v - tangle diagram in an input disk , then we run into ambiguities if the shared decorations , i.e. the orientations , does not match up . in this case we change the decorations of the v - tangle diagram . we add in a _ red dot _ if we have to change the orientation and a _ green dot _ otherwise . this is pictured in the top row of figure [ figure2 - 3 ] . the reader should check that this gives rise to a decorated circuit algebra . another important example is the whole collection @xmath191 from definition [ defin - category ] , i.e. decorated cobordisms with @xmath51 vertical boundary lines and an extra * -marker . we want to view this example as a decorated circuit algebra again . hence , we have to define the operations . the most interesting point are the decorations again , because it should be clear how to glue a cobordism with @xmath14 vertical boundary lines into @xmath192 $ ] . this time we have to define the behaviour of three decorations , i.e. the gluing numbers and the signs and indicators . the gluing numbers should be treated like the orientations before , i.e. if they do not match , then we use the gluing number of the lower numbered string . the indicators ( recall that they are just numbers in @xmath24 ) should be multiplied . recall that a cobordism with an @xmath11-indicator does not get any gluing numbers . we simply remove them in this case . we get the following interaction of the operation of @xmath167 on @xmath190 and @xmath191 ( compare to figure [ figure2 - 3 ] ) : * a saddle is composed with @xmath68 iff the v - tangle gets a red dot at the corresponding position . * a saddle is composed with an @xmath11-indicator surfaces iff the v - tangle gets a red and a green dot in both resolutions at the corresponding position . * a saddle is composed with an @xmath23-indicator surfaces iff the v - tangle numbers get identified at the top resolution at the corresponding position . * a saddle gets an extra minus sign iff the v - tangle numbers change in such a way that the sign of @xmath193 is changed at the corresponding position . these rules define a new decoration for the new cobordism . the reader should check again that this gives rise to a decorated circuit algebra . we summarise the notions in a definition . recall that v - tangle diagrams are decorated with orientations and a * -marker and cobordisms are decorated with orientations on the boundary , an indicator and a * -marker . [ defin - dotcalculus ] let @xmath167 denote a decorated circuit diagram with @xmath14 input disks and @xmath176 outer boundary points in such a way that the @xmath177-th input disk has @xmath178 numbered boundary points . then @xmath167 induces an associative and unital ( in the above sense ) operation on decorated v - tangles ( with a corresponding number of boundary points ) by the `` lower first''-rule , i.e. if the orientation does not match , then the lower number induces the new orientation . put a red dot on every string that has its orientation changed and a green dot otherwise . we call this the _ tangle dot - calculus_. moreover , @xmath167 induces an associative and unital ( in the above sense ) operation on decorated cobordisms ( with a corresponding number of boundary lines ) by the `` lower first''-rule , i.e. if the orientation does not match , then the lower number induces the new orientation . put a red dot on every string that has its orientation changed and a green dot otherwise and compose the corresponding boundary with @xmath68 iff the string has a red dot , multiply indicators via identity surfaces with corresponding indicators @xmath89 iff the v - tangle numbers get identified at the bottom / top resolution at the corresponding position , multiply with an @xmath11-identity iff in both resolutions the strings are identified and multiply with a formal sign iff the numbers change in such a way that the sign is changed at the corresponding position . we call this the _ dot - calculus_. if the crossings carries x - markers , then they should be in the same position as before after the operation . the reader should compare the notions above with figure [ figure0-main ] . we follow the notions of d. bar - natan in the next theorem , i.e. we use the notions @xmath120 and @xmath122 from definition [ defin - category2 ] , but we also allow @xmath194 , i.e. * -marked v - tangles with a finite number of boundary points . we denote the collection of * -marked nice v - tangles as @xmath195 . recall that every v - link diagram and every c - tangle diagram is nice . [ theo - semiloc ] * the whole collection @xmath196 has a natural structure of a decorated circuit algebra . * the operations on @xmath196 preserves homotopy equivalence . thus we obtain that @xmath197 has a natural structure of a decorated circuit algebra . * the bracket @xmath198 is not a morphism of decorated circuit algebras . * the bracket @xmath198 is a @xmath199-morphism of decorated circuit algebras . we follow the proof of the classical version in @xcite . thus we start by extending the structure of a decorated circuit algebra of the set @xmath190 and the one of @xmath191 from example [ beisp - circuit ] to decorated circuit structures @xmath200 and @xmath201 multilinear . let @xmath167 denote a decorated circuit diagram with @xmath14 input disks and @xmath202 outer boundary points in such a way that the @xmath177-th input disk has @xmath178 numbered boundary points . \(a ) for complexes @xmath203 with @xmath204 @xmath205^{d^{l-1}_{j } } & \mathrm{co}^l_j\ar[r]^{d^l_j } & \mathrm{co}^{l+1}_{j}\ar[r]^{\phantom{a}d^{l+1}_{j } } & \cdots } \end{xy}\ ] ] of v - tangle diagrams with @xmath178 boundary points we define the new `` tensored '' complex @xmath206 as follows . let @xmath207 denote the composition with the morphisms that we compose after applying the circuit diagram on cobordisms ( see example [ beisp - circuit ] and definition [ defin - dotcalculus ] above ) , i.e. the red dots induce a composition with @xmath68 ( or a composition with a @xmath11-identity surface in the degenerated case ) and a change in the numbering induces a composition with a cobordisms that changes signs and indicators . therefore we denote the operation of @xmath167 on cobordisms , i.e. the dot - calculus , as @xmath208 to illustrate the difference to the classical case . we skip this notion for the objects . the @xmath39-th chain module should be @xmath209 and the chain maps should be @xmath210 beware that the needed minus signs are not missing . they are already implied in the definition of the decorated circuit algebra structure of @xmath201 , i.e. the dot - calculus in particular adds or removes signs . see example [ beisp - circuit ] and definition [ defin - dotcalculus ] . we use lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] to see that we still get a chain complex . moreover , we need to define the operation of @xmath167 on the morphisms of the category @xmath196 , i.e. on the chain maps . so let @xmath211 be a chain map . every chain map itself is a sequence of matrices of decorated cobordisms @xmath212 . the operation on the chain map should just insert the cobordisms topological , i.e. without changing gluing numbers , indicators or signs . note that we do not run into ambiguities since the decorations are defined for the closure for the fixed * -marker . we denote an entry of the matrix @xmath213 with abuse of notation as @xmath213 and similar for @xmath214 . hence , we have to check that the commutativity of the faces @xmath215 & \mathrm{co}_1^{i}\ar[r]^{d_1^{i}}\ar[d]^{f_i } & \mathrm{co}_1^{i+1}\ar[r]\ar[d]^{f_{i+1 } } & \cdots\\ \cdots\ar[r ] & \mathrm{co}_2^{i}\ar[r]^{d_2^{i } } & \mathrm{co}_2^{i+1}\ar[r ] & \cdots . } \ ] ] is preserved . the operation on the @xmath216 is defined as @xmath217 where @xmath218 are the decoration , indicator and signs changing morphisms . the rest is a case - by - case check using the relations in lemma [ lemm - calc ] and the equation @xmath219 . * if one of the two sides of the equation @xmath219 has a @xmath11-indicator , then the other has also a @xmath11-indicator . hence , in this case everything works out by the commutation relations in lemma [ lemm - calc ] . * since everything works out topological and the indicator changes are spread if strings get glued together , we see that if @xmath218 are only indicator changes , then , by commutativity of the indicator changes , the equation is preserved . * an analogous argument works if @xmath218 are only sign changes . * hence , lets assume that @xmath218 are only decoration changes , i.e. tensors of @xmath68 and @xmath67 , and we do not have any @xmath11-indicators . then one has different cases to check , i.e. based on the indicators for @xmath220 and @xmath221 . they all work analogous , so we only do one case , i.e. only @xmath222 and @xmath213 should have negative indicators . then we have by the commutation relations @xmath223 where @xmath224 should denote a short hand notation for the one from lemma [ lemm - calc ] . note that the equation @xmath219 also holds for indicators , i.e. not all combinations of indicators for @xmath220 and @xmath221 are possible . \(b ) the proof of ( b ) is an analogous argument like in ( a ) , i.e. we define the operation on the homotopies @xmath225 like before and we get the statement with an argument like before and the corresponding statement for tensor products . \(c ) this is true , because a surfaces with an @xmath11-indicator can not be changed to a surfaces with an @xmath157-indicator . for an concrete example see figure [ figure2 - 4 ] . the upper complex is not homotopy equivalent to the lower complex because we can not change the @xmath11-indicator . \(d ) this follows because of lemma [ lemma - factorbyisos ] , i.e. if a surface with an @xmath11-indicator appears in the complex before the operation @xmath167 , then it will appear for both closures . otherwise the , i.e. if the indicators are @xmath89 , then we can use the factorisation of lemma [ lemma - factorbyisos ] . note that the proof of lemma [ lemma - factorbyisos ] does not depend on theorem [ theo - geoinvarianz ] . then the equality is a consequence of the definition of the operation on the cobordisms and of an argument like in @xcite . note that the next corollary finish the proof of theorem [ theo - geoinvarianz ] . [ koro - reidemeister ] let @xmath226 be a v - tangle diagram that looks like a generalised reidemeister move ( see figure [ figure0 - 1 ] ) . then @xmath227 for any operation @xmath167 if @xmath228 is either a classical tangle or a reidemeister - tangle @xmath226 for @xmath229 . this is a direct consequence of point ( d ) of theorem [ theo - semiloc ] and the observation that the reidemeister - tangles , except the mrm - tangle , are all part of the set @xmath199 . that the statement also works if one of the @xmath228 is a mrm - tangle is a case - by - case check for the two different closures of a mrm - tangle ( both sides ) , i.e. in all cases the appearing cobordisms have @xmath89 indicators . [ rem - gradings2 ] like before and like in the paper of d. bar - natan @xcite , the whole construction works with gradings , too . but since this is a straightforward generalisations of the notions in @xcite , we skip the details here . in the whole section let @xmath54 denote a commutative and unital ring such that @xmath25 is invertible , e.g. @xmath230 $ ] . moreover , through the whole section we denote the geometric complex as @xmath231 and a corresponding algebraic version , i.e. an utqft ( see @xcite ) applied to the geometric complex , as @xmath232 or short as @xmath233 , e.g. we denote lee s version as @xmath234 note that , in order for the signs to work out correct , we have to fix a marker position . in the whole section we , by convention , say that the marker for @xmath4 is at the left side and for @xmath5 is at the top . recall ( see @xcite for the classical and @xcite for the virtual case ) that _ lee s variant _ , i.e. the algebraic version , for v - links is given by the following maps and the filtered module @xmath235/(x^2=1)$ ] . @xmath236 and @xmath237 moreover , recall that the geometric picture of lee s variant is given by the _ dot - relations _ in figure [ figure3 - 1 ] with @xmath238 , while the graded case of the khovanov complex is @xmath239 . note that @xmath240 allows us to use the _ dot - relation _ in figure [ figure3 - 1 ] instead of the local relations of figure [ figure0 - 2 ] . we give an example of the lee complex of a v - knot in example [ beisp - leedeg ] . lee s variant has a remarkable property in the classical case , i.e. e.s . lee showed that her variant just `` counts '' the number of components of the c - link , i.e. she showed that ( for @xmath241 ) the homology of an @xmath34-component link @xmath242 is @xmath243 so on the first hand this seems to be a boring invariant . but j. rasmussen ( see @xcite ) used this degeneration in a masterfully way to define the _ rasmussen invariant _ of a c - knot . note that this is a unexpected result since @xmath244 for @xmath245 ( see the relations in definition [ defin - category ] ) . hence , there are `` tons '' of @xmath11-morphisms in the complex . but these @xmath11-morphisms also come with isomorphism `` in a lot '' cases . the following example for the lee complex of a v - knot is a blueprint of this effect . [ beisp - leedeg ] consider the diagram of the virtual trefoil @xmath130 given in figure [ figure4 - 1 ] . in this example the number of negative crossings is zero , i.e. the leftmost object is the @xmath11-degree of the chain complex . let us consider @xmath241 . then @xmath244 and therefore the first two maps are @xmath11-morphisms . but note that the two right morphisms are not the same , i.e. one is @xmath246 and the other is @xmath247 . so on the algebraic level we get , using the maps from before , the following complex if we fix @xmath248 as a basis for @xmath249 and @xmath250 for @xmath251 . @xmath252^{\begin{pmatrix } 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix } } & & & a\oplus a\ar[rrr]^{\begin{pmatrix } 0 & 1 & 0 & -1\\ -1 & 0 & -1 & 0\\ -1 & 0 & 1 & 0\\ 0 & 1 & 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix } } & & & a\otimes a. } \end{xy}\ ] ] an easy calculations shows that the second matrix is an isomorphism . hence , the homology of the virtual trefoil is only non - trivial for @xmath148 , i.e. @xmath253 another example is the v - knot in figure [ figure4 - 2 ] , e.g. with the pictured orientation and numbering of the circles from left to right , the three outgoing morphisms from resolution @xmath254 to @xmath255 , @xmath256 and @xmath257 are ( up to , in this case , not important signs ) the morphisms @xmath258 , @xmath259 and @xmath260 , i.e. one alternating and two non - alternating . hence , the kernel is trivial . the reader should check that the rest also works out in the same fashion . the approach ( we follow d. bar - natan and s. morrison @xcite ) to show that the degeneration is still true is the following . first we define two orthogonal idempotents in our category , which we call _ down and up_. we can look at the _ karoubi envelope _ of our category , denoted @xmath261 . the idea of the karoubi envelope is to find a `` completion '' of a category such that every idempotent splits . it is named after the french mathematician m. karoubi , but it already appears in an earlier work by p. freyd in @xcite . then we show that the geometric complex of a simple crossing ( as a v - tangle ) , if considered in @xmath261 , is homotopy equivalent to a very simple complex with only @xmath11-morphisms . after that we use the local construction from section [ circuit ] to finish the proof . moreover , we proof the following interesting result of the number of decorations of v - link resolution with the `` colours '' down and up . note that we call an oriented resolution @xmath262 of a v - link diagram _ non - alternating _ if it is of the form @xmath263or @xmath21 at the corresponding positions of the saddles . recall that all the v - link diagrams should be oriented and that such a diagram with @xmath264 components has @xmath41 different orientations @xmath265 . we note that one can also colour the resolutions with honest colours , say red and green , in such a way that the colour changes at every v - crossing . we call this a _ colouring of a v - link resolution _ if at the corresponding saddle - position the colours are different , i.e. ( red , green ) or ( green , red ) . the reader should compare this with the coloured dots in figure [ figure0-main ] . [ theo - nonalternating ] let @xmath130 denote a v - link diagram with @xmath264 components . there are bijections of sets @xmath266 if @xmath130 is a v - knot , i.e. @xmath267 , then the two non - alternating resolutions are in homology degree @xmath11 . given an orientation @xmath268 of the v - link diagram @xmath130 , the map @xmath221 should assign the resolution @xmath262 which is obtained by replacing every oriented crossing of the form @xmath30 and @xmath31 to @xmath263 . this is clearly an injection . now , given a non - alternating resolution @xmath262 , we assign to it an orientation of @xmath130 in the following way . at any non - alternating part of the form @xmath263and @xmath21replace the non - alternating part with the corresponding oriented crossing @xmath30 and @xmath31 ( or a rotation in the @xmath21 case ) . these two maps are clearly inverses and for a v - knot the corresponding non - alternating resolutions are in homology degree @xmath11 since all @xmath32-crossings are resolved @xmath11 and all @xmath33-crossings are resolved @xmath29 in this procedure . to see the second bijection use a checker - board colouring of the v - link diagram . then start at any point of the non - alternating resolution and use the right - hand rule , i.e. the index finger follows the orientation and the string should get the colour of the face on the side of the thumb . [ beisp - nonalt ] let @xmath130 be the v - knot diagram in figure [ figure4 - 2 ] . then only the @xmath270 resolution of the v - knot diagram allows a non - alternating resolution . moreover , the orientation of the diagram induces this non - alternating resolution by replacing the three crossings with @xmath21,@xmath263and @xmath263 . the other orientation induces the non - alternating resolution @xmath263,@xmath21and @xmath21 . note that , by construction , these resolution are in homology degree @xmath11 . a computation like in example [ beisp - leedeg ] shows that these two non - alternating resolutions give the only two generators of the homology , i.e. @xmath253 for any category the notion of an idempotent morphisms , i.e. an arrow with @xmath272 , makes sense . moreover , in a pre - additive category the notion @xmath273 also makes sense . a classical trick in modern algebra is to use an idempotent , e.g. in an algebra @xmath249 , to split the algebra into @xmath274 hence , it is a natural question to ask if on can `` split '' , given an idempotent @xmath275 , an object of a category @xmath276 in the same way , i.e. @xmath277 the main problem is that the notion of an image of an arrow could not exist in an arbitrary category . the karoubi envelope is an extension of a category such that for a given idempotent @xmath275 the notions @xmath278 makes sense . therefore one can `` split '' a given object in the karoubi envelope that could be indecomposable in the category itself . * objects are ordered pairs @xmath281 of an object @xmath276 and an idempotent @xmath275 of @xmath94 . * morphisms @xmath282 are all arrows @xmath283 of @xmath94 such that the equation @xmath284 holds . * compositions are defined in the obvious sense . the identity of an object is @xmath275 itself . it is straightforward to check that this is indeed a category . we denote an object @xmath281 as @xmath278 , the _ image _ of the idempotent @xmath275 . moreover , we identify the objects of @xmath94 with their image via the embedding functor @xmath285 note that if @xmath94 is pre - additive , then @xmath286 is also an projection and , under the identification above , we can finally write @xmath277 the following proposition is well - known ( see e.g. @xcite ) . the propositions allows us to shift the problem if two chain complexes are homotopy equivalent to the karoubi envelope . recall that @xmath287 denotes the category of formal chain complexes . [ prop - karoubi ] let @xmath288 be two objects , i.e. formal chain complexes , of @xmath287 . if the two objects are homotopy equivalent in @xmath289 , then the two objects are also homotopy equivalent in @xmath287 . we note that we call the idempotents _ `` down and up''_. the reader should be careful not to confuse them with the orientations on the resolutions or the colourings of theorem [ theo - nonalternating ] , i.e. latter colours change at v - crossings but `` down and up '' do not change . note that ( e ) is very important in the following . 1 . @xmath294 and @xmath295 ( idempotent ) . 2 . @xmath296 ( orthogonal ) . 3 . @xmath297 ( complete ) . 4 . @xmath298 and @xmath299 ( eigenvalues ) . @xmath300 and @xmath301 ( change of orientations ) @xmath302=\operatorname{id}(1)_{\mathrm{dot}}=-[\mathrm{u},\phi^-_+]$ ] ( commutator relation ) . now we take a look at the karoubi envelope @xmath304 . the discussion above shows that there is an isomorphism@xmath305{figs / none}}}}\simeq\text{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / down}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / up}}}}.\ ] ] with this notation we get @xmath305{figs / smoothing}}}}\simeq\text{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu}}}}\ ] ] and analogous @xmath306{figs / hsmoothing}}}}\simeq\text{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd1}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du1}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud1}}}}\oplus\text{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu1}}}}.\ ] ] recall that the standard orientation for the complex @xmath307 is ( see e.g. figure [ figure0-main ] ) @xmath308[r]{\raisebox{0.2cm}{$\lcurvearrowleft$}}}}}}.\ ] ] to avoid mixing the notions of the down and up - colours and the orientations we denote this complex simply as @xmath309 , i.e. standard orientations for all strings . moreover , under the convention left = first top subscript , right = second top subscript , bottom = first bottom subscript and top = second bottom subscript , a notation like @xmath310 makes sense . [ theo - karoubi ] let @xmath311 denote two homotopy equivalent complexes . then , in @xmath120 , there are sixteen chain homotopies ( only four are illustrated , but it should be clear how the rest look like ) @xmath312{figs / du}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud}}}}}\xrightarrow{0}\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud1 } } } } } , & { \llbracket \overcrossing \rrbracket}^{+-}_{-+}\simeq \text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu}}}}}\xrightarrow{0}\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu1}}}}},\\ { \llbracket \overcrossing \rrbracket}^{++}_{+-}\simeq \text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud}}}}}\xrightarrow{0}\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu1 } } } } } , & { \llbracket \overcrossing \rrbracket}^{+-}_{++}\simeq \text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu}}}}}\xrightarrow{0}\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud1}}}}}. } \end{xy}\ ] ] moreover , similar formulas hold for @xmath313 . we use the observations from above , i.e. in @xmath304 the differential of @xmath309 is a @xmath314-matrix of saddles . hence , for @xmath309 we get ( for simplicity write @xmath315 and @xmath316 and @xmath317 for the saddle under the action of down and up ) @xmath318{figs / dd}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu}}}}}\ar[rrr]^{\begin{pmatrix } s_{\mathrm{d } } & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & s_{\mathrm{u } } \end{pmatrix } } & & & \text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu1}}}}}. } \end{xy}\ ] ] this is true , because all other saddles are killed by the orthogonality relations of the colours down and up . note that both non zero saddles are invertible , i.e. their inverses are the saddles @xmath319 with only @xmath19 as boundary decorations . to see this one uses lemma [ lemm - idem ] and the neck cutting relation . thus we get @xmath320{figs / du}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud}}}}}\xrightarrow{0}\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / du1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / ud1}}}}}.\ ] ] to prove the further statements one has to use the relation ( e ) of lemma [ lemm - idem ] , i.e. the only surviving saddles change according to the action of @xmath68 . we note that this is a very important observation . [ bem - importantsaddles ] we observe a very important fact . the four complexes similar to @xmath322[r]{\raisebox{0.2cm}{$\rcurvearrowright$}}}}}},\ ] ] i.e. the ones for which we choose a non - alternating orientation of the resolutions , are the only ones that , due to the orthogonality relation for down and up , survive a closing with an even number of v - crossings , i.e. like @xmath323 in figure [ figure0 - 4 ] , in their source and target . so if we only consider v - link diagrams , then any such saddle is a multiplication , i.e. one bottom component , or a comultiplication , i.e. one top component . therefore such morphisms will always be killed at the bottom ( multiplication ) or at the top ( comultiplication ) . and the only saddle that survives the closure of type @xmath11 in figure [ figure0 - 4 ] is the mbius cobordism . latter one is a @xmath11-morphism if @xmath25 is invertible ( compare to the relations in definition [ defin - category ] ) . hence , the dot - calculus of definition [ defin - dotcalculus ] ensures that all components will survive and the complex will be of the form @xmath324{figs / dd}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu}}}}}\xrightarrow{0}\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / dd1}}}}}\oplus\text{\raisebox{-0.1cm}{{\raisebox{-0.215cm}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{figs / uu1}}}}}.\ ] ] [ theo - leedeg ] let @xmath130 denote a @xmath34-component v - link diagram . then @xmath325 is homotopy equivalent ( in @xmath326 ) to a chain complex with only zero differentials and @xmath41 generators given by the @xmath41 non - alternating resolutions . we will repress the notion of the formal signs of the morphisms to maintain readability . moreover , we will choose a specific orientation for the resolutions . we can do both because of lemma [ lemma - everythingfine ] . so the main part of the proof will be to choose the orientations in a good way and use theorem [ theo - semiloc ] ( the reader may think of tensors ) . recall that the number of crossings is finite . hence , we can choose an orientation of any resolution such that the number @xmath14 of alternating crossings is minimal . we observe that theorem [ theo - semiloc ] can be used because every crossing itself is a nice v - tangle diagram . moreover , with theorem [ theo - karoubi ] , we see that the complex will be homotopy equivalent to a complex with only @xmath11-differentials . hence , the only remaining thing is to show that the number of generators will work out as claimed . note that , if a resolution contains a lower part of a multiplication or a upper part of a comultiplication , then by remark [ bem - importantsaddles ] these resolution is killed . moreover , we can ignore top and bottom parts of @xmath15 , since they will always be non - alternating . now we define the _ dual graph of an resolution _ , denoted @xmath327 , as follows . recall that a resolution is a four valent graph without any c - crossings . any edges of this graph is a vertex of @xmath327 . two vertices are connected with a labeled edge iff they are connected by a v - crossing or a top part of a resolution of a multiplication or a bottom part of a comultiplication . first edges should be labeled @xmath328 , the second type of edges should get an labeling that s corresponds to the given orientation of the resolution . we will work with the simple graph of that type , i.e. remove circles or parallel edges of the same type . see figure [ figure4 - 6 ] , i.e. the figure shows two resolutions from figure [ figure4 - 2 ] and their dual graphs . the advantage of this notation is that the question of surviving resolutions simplifies to the question of a colouring of the dual graph , i.e. a colouring of the dual graph is a colouring with two colours , say red and green , such that every @xmath328-labeled edge has two equally coloured adjacent vertices , every alternating crossing has also two different coloured adjacent vertices , but every non - alternating crossing has also two equal colours at adjacent vertices . then , because of theorem [ theo - karoubi ] , a resolution will have surviving generators iff it does not contain lower parts of multiplication or upper parts of comultiplications and , given an orientation of the resolution , it allows such a colouring . * the dual graph of the resolution is a tree , i.e. no circles . * all circles in the dual graph have an even number of v - labeled edges . * there is one circle in the dual graph with an odd number of v - labeled edges . if @xmath329 , i.e. the resolution is non - alternating , we get exactly the claimed number of generators , since there are , by construction , no lower parts of multiplication or upper parts of comultiplications and the dual graph is of type ( i ) or ( ii ) and in both cases the graph can be coloured . so let @xmath330 and let @xmath331 be an alternating crossing in a resolution @xmath54 . as in remark [ bem - importantsaddles ] the whole resolution is killed if the @xmath331 is a lower part of a multiplication or an upper part of a comultiplication . hence , we can assume that all alternating crossings of @xmath54 are either top components of multiplications or bottom components of comultiplications . so we only have to check the three cases from above . if the resolution is one of type ( i ) , then it is possible to choose the orientations in such a way that all crossings are non - alternating , i.e. this would be a contradiction to the minimality of @xmath14 . if the resolution is of type ( ii ) , then the resolution only survives , i.e. the dual graph allows a colouring , iff the number of other alternating crossings in every circle is even . but in this case one can also choose an orientation with only non - alternating crossings . hence , we would get a contradiction to the minimality of @xmath14 again . hence , only non - alternating resolutions generate non vanishing objects . moreover , any non - alternating resolution will create exactly two of these generators . thus , with theorem [ theo - nonalternating ] the statement follows . * if @xmath334 , then their is an isomorphism @xmath335 where @xmath336 is all torsion . * if @xmath241 or @xmath230 $ ] , then their is an isomorphism @xmath337 * the only possible torsion is @xmath25-torsion . for ( a)+(c ) recall the universal coefficients theorem . i.e. their is a short exact sequence @xmath338 therefore ( a ) follows from ( b ) with @xmath241 , since the tor - functor will vanish in this case . and ( c ) follows from ( b ) with @xmath230 $ ] , since all non 2-torsion elements will exits for @xmath10 and @xmath339 $ ] . d. bar - natan , khovanov s homology for tangles and cobordisms , geom . topol . 9 ( 2005 ) , 14431499 . arxiv : math/0410495 d. bar - natan , on khovanov s categorification of the jones polynomial , algebraic and geometric topology 2 ( 2002 ) , 337370 . arxiv : math/0201043 d. bar - natan , fast khovanov homology computations , journal of knot theory and its ramifications 16 - 3 ( 2007 ) , 243255 . arxiv : math/0606318 d. bar - natan and s. morrison , the karoubi envelope and lee s degeneration of khovanov homology , algebraic and geometric topology 6 ( 2006 ) , 14591469 arxiv : math/0606542v3 p. freyd , _ abelian categories . an introduction to the theory of functors _ , new york : harper and row publishers , 1964 ( harpers series in modern mathematics ) . v. jones , planar algebras i , eprint ( 1999 ) . arxiv : math/9909027 l. kauffman , introduction to virtual knot theory , j. knot theory ramifications 21,13 ( 2012 ) . l. kauffman and v. manturov , virtual knots and links , proc . steklov inst . math . 1 ( 2006 ) , 104121 . arxiv : math/0502014 m. khovanov , a categorification of the jones polynomial , duke math . j. 101 ( 2000 ) , 359426 . arxiv : math/9908171 j. kock , _ frobenius algebras and 2d topological quantum field theories _ , cambridge : cambridge university press , 2003 . lee , an endomorphism of the khovanov invariant , adv . 197(2 ) ( 2005 ) , 554586 . arxiv : math/0210213 m. mackaay , p. turner and p. vaz , a remark on rasmussen s invariant of knots , knot theory and its ramifications 16(3 ) ( 2007 ) , 333344 . arxiv : math/0509692 v. manturov , the khovanov complex for virtual links , fundam . prikl . mat . 11:4 ( 2005 ) , 127152 . arxiv : math/0501317 v. manturov , khovanov homology for virtual knots with arbitrary coefficients , izv math 71 ( 2007 ) , 967999 . arxiv : math/0601152 j. rasmussen , khovanov homology and the slice genus , invent . 182(3 ) ( 2010 ) , 419447 . arxiv : math/0509692 s. mac lane , _ categories for the working mathematician _ , new york : springer - verlag , 1998 . d. tubbenhauer , khovanov homology for virtual links using cobordisms , preprint ( 2011 ) . arxiv:1111.0609v2 d.t . : _ courant research center `` higher order structures '' , university of gttingen , gttingen , germany ; mathematisches institut , georg - august - universitt gttingen , gttingen , germany _ email : [email protected] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: wireless access networks are the typical last - mile networks connecting multiple users to a high speed backbone . in these networks , a base station ( bs ) serves a large group of users . traditionally , either the time or the frequency are divided to ensure users do not interfere with each other . modern coding techniques , however , allow for multiple users to either transmit or receive simultaneously , and be decoded successfully using the appropriate multiple access channel ( mac ) codes or broadcast channel ( bc ) codes , respectively . nevertheless , consider a bs serving a very large number of users . in practical scenarios , not all users can be served simultaneously , and the problem of user selection or scheduling arises . in the downlink setting , where a bs transmits to a group of users , it is common to assume channel state information ( csi ) is available at the bs , hence intelligent user selection can be employed . e.g. , the bs can select a subset of the users with both strong channel norms ( high snr ) and relatively orthogonal directions ( to avoid interference ) . see section [ sec . related ] for a literature survey . such a selection can exploit the _ multi - user diversity _ inherent in these models . in the uplink setting , however , since the users transmit to the bs , it is highly desirable to avoid the process of collecting all information at the bs beforehand , and notifying the users which should transmit . this process is prohibitively complex when the number of users is very large . in fact , this is one of the main reasons why an emerging standard , ieee 802.11ac , includes multi - user multiple input multiple output ( mu - mimo ) only at the downlink @xcite . that is , the allegedly complex process of selecting a subset of users in the uplink is refrained from . hence , efficient and distributed algorithms for selecting the appropriate group of users are desirable . this way , there is hope to harness the benefits of multi - user diversity without the need to collect csi from all users . in this paper , we show that this is indeed possible , by showing the order - optimality of distributed algorithms . we consider a mimo mac channel with @xmath0 receiving antennas and @xmath1 users . we suggest distributed algorithms for selecting a group of users to transmit in each slot . in the first , a threshold value for the norm of the channel vector is set , and only users above the threshold transmit . hence , there is no need to collect csi from all users . nor is any cooperation required . in the second , an iterative process is suggested , where _ multiple thresholds _ are set on the norms of the _ projections of the channel vectors _ on the spaces of previously selected users . in this case , csi is shared , but _ only among the selected group_. an analysis of the resulting sum capacity in the limit of large @xmath2 and the respective scaling laws are given for both zero - forcing ( zf ) and minimal mean square error ( mmse ) receivers . this analysis employs recent tools from both point process approximation and asymptotic random matrix theory , that to the best of our knowledge , were not used in this setting before . via this analysis , the simple distributed , threshold based algorithm , is shown to achieve the optimal scaling laws . consequently , the benefit compared to traditional ( centralized ) techniques is demonstrated both analytically and via simulation results . the rest of this paper is organized as follows : section [ sec . related ] includes the most relevant related work . section [ sec . prelim ] includes the required preliminary material . section [ sec . dist alg ] introduces the distributed algorithm , gives its analysis and scaling law under zf decoding . section [ sec . sic ] gives an improved , multi - stage algorithm , which , while only semi - distributed ( as it requires messaging between the selected users ) , gives better performance for a small number of users . section [ sec . mmse rec ] gives the analysis under an mmse receiver . while conceptually similar , this analysis is the more technically challenging . section [ sec : proofs ] gives the previously omitted proofs . section [ sec . conc ] concludes the paper . the essence of multi - user diversity was introduced in @xcite , where selecting the strongest user in each time slot was first suggested . the work was followed by numerous scheduling algorithms for various scenarios . we list here only the most relevant . in @xcite , the authors considered the impact of multi - user diversity on the mimo downlink channel ( bc ) . assuming channel state information at the bs , the authors used order statistics to evaluate the effective snr when scheduling the strongest user in each slot . however , _ only one user was scheduled _ in each slot , and the results were given in terms of the @xmath2-fold statistics , without an extreme value analysis for large @xmath2 . in @xcite , a similar downlink model was considered , however , when users are scheduled simultaneously . the authors considered zero - forcing beamforming ( zfbf ) , and suggested a greedy algorithm to schedule the strongest and most orthogonal users . additional scheduling algorithms for downlink communication were given in @xcite . in fact , in the downlink scenario , it was shown later that zfbf and optimal user selection can indeed achieve the dirty paper coding ( dpc ) region @xcite , and is hence optimal in the gaussian case @xcite . additional surveys and scaling laws can be found in @xcite . a closely related scheme , yet still for the downlink model , was suggested in @xcite . using block diagonalization ( bd ) , a capacity - based greedy algorithm was suggested , in which first the strongest user is scheduled , and then additional users are added , one by one , based on their marginal contribution to the total capacity . in the same context , @xcite considered the special case of two transmit antennas and one receive antenna per user , and showed that a greedy , two - stage algorithm , which first selects the strongest user and then the second to form the best pair is asymptotically optimal . in the context of heterogeneous users , @xcite proposed a scheduling scheme which selects a small subset of the users with favorable channel characteristics . the above works focus on the downlink setting . in this scenario , it is reasonable to assume that at least some information is available at the bs , and a centralized decision can be made . in the uplink ( mac ) model , however , if one wishes to select a group of users without centralized processing at the bs , distributed algorithms are required . in this paper , we suggest both a single - stage distributed algorithm , and a multi - stage semi - distributed one for the uplink scenario , and , in addition , analyze their sum capacity in the limit of large number of users and give the resulting scaling laws . a pioneering study of the uplink model was done in @xcite , where a decentralized mac protocol for orthogonal frequency division multiple access ( ofdma ) channels was suggested . in this scheme , each user estimates the channel gain and compares it to a threshold . only above - the - threshold users can transmit . @xcite extended the scheme to a multi - channel setup , where each user competes on @xmath3 channels . in @xcite , the authors used a similar approach for power allocation in the multi - channel setup , and suggested an algorithm that asymptotically achieves the optimal water filling solution . however , the works above do not consider a _ mimo setting _ , nor do they consider the interaction within a group of users , when all are scheduled to use _ the same resources_. space - time coding for fading multi - antenna mac was considered in @xcite . the focus therein , however , was on joint code design for a given point in the rate region and the resulting error probability , rather than user scheduling and its resulting capacity . recently , we proposed a point process approximation which facilitates the analysis of various distributed threshold - based scheduling algorithms in the non - homogeneous scenario @xcite . this work , however , assumed only a single user can be successfully decoded in each time slot . a key contribution of the current work is the non - trivial extension of the work in @xcite to truly multiple - access protocols , where several users transmit simultaneously and should be decoded successfully , hence the questions that arise are how to distributively select a good subset of users to transmit and what the mutual influence between the users in the selected group is . for example , a closely related work is @xcite . therein , various decoding procedures were discussed , and the corresponding best user selection _ for the uplink setting _ was given . however , while reinforcing the necessity of proper user selection , the work in @xcite considered only the scenario where _ one user _ can access the radio channel at a given time . as for more complex topologies , spatial diversity in the context of multiple relays was considered in @xcite . therein , communication between a source and a destination is done through a group of relays . however , unlike conventional relay schemes , only the relays with the _ strongest received signal _ decode the message and cooperate via space time coding to successfully relay it to the destination . an asymptotically optimal scheme for multiple base stations ( with joint optimization ) was given in @xcite . extreme value theory ( evt ) is a key tool in proving capacity results under scheduling and multi - user diversity . in @xcite , the authors suggested a sub - carrier assignment algorithm , and used order statistics to derive an expression for the resulting link outage probability . in @xcite , the authors used evt to derive the scaling laws for scheduling systems using beamforming and linear combining . @xcite analyzed the scaling laws of base station scheduling , and showed that by scheduling the strongest among @xmath2 stations one can gain a factor of @xmath4 in the expected capacity ( compared to random or round - robin scheduling ) . in this section , we describe the system model and relevant results which will be used throughout this paper . throughout this paper , random matrices and random vectors are denoted in bold upper - case and bold lower - case letters , respectively . we consider a multiple - access model with k users , each with a single transmit antenna . the bs is equipped with @xmath0 receiving antennas . when @xmath5 users utilize the channel simultaneously , the received signal at the base station can be described as : @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the transmitted signal ( scalar ) . @xmath8 is constrained in its total power to @xmath9 , i.e. , @xmath10\leq p$ ] . however , in most cases , we will assume a _ constant _ power constraint @xmath9 . @xmath11 denotes the uncorrelated gaussian noise . @xmath12 is a complex random gaussian channel vector . when all users are identically and independently distributed , it is common to assume that all entries of @xmath13 are independent and have zero mean and variance @xmath14 imaginary and real parts , for all users . we assume that the channel is memoryless , that is , for each channel use ( slot ) , independent realizations of @xmath15 are drawn . furthermore , we assume full csi is available at the transmitter . that is , @xmath13 is known to the @xmath16th user . this can be accomplished by sending a pilot signal form each of the @xmath0 antennas at the base station . evt is a key tool in evaluating the capacity under scheduling in multi - user systems . we review here the most relevant result . moreover , we develop new normalizing constants for the problem at hand ( evt for the @xmath17 distribution ) , which will later aid at speeding up convergence results . the capacity obtained by letting an arbitrary user @xmath16 utilize the channel is given by @xmath18 . however , as mentioned , it is beneficial to schedule the strongest user in each slot . denote by @xmath19 the received channel vector with the largest norm . scheduling the strongest user clearly results in @xmath20 , while letting a _ group of @xmath0 orthogonal users _ , with the largest channel gains to utilize an uplink channel , results in a sum - rate that has the following upper bound:@xmath21 for the downlink channel , the sum - rate upper bound has the form @xcite @xmath22 the difference between the uplink to the downlink originates in the power constraint applied to the transmitter . that is , in the downstream , when transmitting to a group of receivers , each receiver gets a share of the available power , while in the upstream , there is a group of transmitters that transmit to a single receiver . it should be noted that usually the power constraint @xmath9 for the downlink and uplink are not equal , since the base station has a strong and steady power supply , whereas the user has a limited battery power supply . as the sum rate is mainly influenced by the channel vectors gains and directions , our goal is to explore this behavior for large number of users . specifically , we first wish to explore the behavior of the maximal gain . since the entries of @xmath23 are complex gaussian , the channel s gain follows a @xmath17 distribution with @xmath24 degrees of freedom , denoted @xmath25 . we utilize the following evt theorem . [ theorem . evt ] let @xmath26 be a sequence of i.i.d . random variables with distribution @xmath27 , and let @xmath28 . if there exists a sequence of normalizing constants @xmath29 and @xmath30 such that as @xmath31 , @xmath32 for some non - degenerate distribution g , then g is of the generalized extreme value ( gev ) distribution type @xmath33 and we say that @xmath27 is in the domain of attraction of @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is the shape parameter , determined by the ancestor distribution @xmath27 . the normalizing constants and the shape parameter of the gev can be obtained as follows . let @xmath36 be the reciprocal hazard function @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the lower and upper endpoints of the ancestor distribution , respectively . the shape parameter @xmath35 is obtained as the following limit @xcite : @xmath40 when @xmath41 is a sequence of i.i.d . @xmath42 variables , the asymptotic distribution of @xmath43 is a gumbel distribution @xcite . specifically , @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 is the gamma function . in the sequel , we will also use the upper incomplete gamma function , @xmath47 . however , for i.i.d . @xmath25 random variables , the convergence of the maxima to the gumbel distribution using the above normalizing constants is quite slow . that is , the approximation of the maximal value will not be tight for moderate values of @xmath48 . hence , a more appropriate set of normalizing constants for the @xmath25 distribution , which takes into account both @xmath0 and @xmath49 should be derived . letting @xmath30 to be the @xmath50 quantile , i.e. , @xmath51 , and choosing @xmath52 @xcite , we have the following . for the @xmath25-distribution , the following normalizing constants apply . @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the inverse of the regularized upper incomplete gamma function , that is , @xmath55 , and the inverse is defined with respect to @xmath56 . the @xmath17 distribution is a special case of the gamma distribution . i.e. , if @xmath57 then @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is the gamma distribution with shape parameter @xmath0 and rate parameter @xmath60 . accordingly , for the @xmath61 constant we consider the @xmath50 quantile of the gamma distribution , which can be obtained by using the inverse of the regularized upper incomplete gamma function . in particular , @xmath62 yields the @xmath50 quantile of the gamma distribution . to attain the @xmath63 constant , let us examine the hazard function @xmath36 of the gamma distribution . @xmath64 accordingly , for @xmath65 we obtain , @xmath66 figures [ fig : max_norm_dist30 ] and [ fig : max_norm_dist ] depict the simulation results versus the analytical results of the evt with the new normalizing constants derived herein ( @xmath63 and @xmath61 given in and , respectively ) . the maximum of @xmath2 @xmath17-distributed random variables is compared to the gumbel distribution predicted by evt . figure [ fig : max_norm_dist30 ] depicts the case where @xmath67 while in figure [ fig : max_norm_dist ] for @xmath68 . in both cases , figures are plotted for several values of receiving antennas ( @xmath0 ) . tight convergence is clearly visible , with reasonable approximation even for @xmath69 users . to see how the new normalizing constants relate to the previous ones reported in the literature , figure [ fig : an_convergence ] depicts the value of @xmath63 for several values of @xmath0 , as @xmath49 increases . while the new constant converges to @xmath70 slowly , it is constant for moderate values of @xmath49 , hence the tight convergence of _ the distribution of the maximum to the gumbel distribution_. degrees of freedom , respectively . the graphs are given for @xmath67 users . ] degrees of freedom , respectively . the graphs are given for @xmath68 users . ] for @xmath71 receiving antennas to the limit @xmath72 . note that this slow convergence does not affect the convergence of the actual distribution , as the values of @xmath63 are within a constant factor from @xmath70 even for very moderate @xmath49 . ] as we aim at analysing the capacity under practical constraints such as scheduling only a subset of the users in each time slot , we focus our attention on linear decoding at the bs . such decoders , such as the zf decoder or the mmse decoder , are indeed widely used in practice . hence , the analysis in this paper will be based on either linear decorrelation ( section [ sec . dist alg ] ) or the mmse receiver ( section [ sec . mmse rec ] ) , assuming optimal coding of the resulting single user gaussian channels , given the effective signal to noise ratio ( snr ) . specifically , for the zf receiver , focusing on the signal received from the @xmath73th user , rewrite as : @xmath74 let @xmath75 be a unitary matrix representing the null space of the subspace spanned by @xmath76 . since the entries of the channel vectors are i.i.d . , when @xmath5 users transmit the subspace spanned by the vectors @xmath76 has rank @xmath77 with probability one ( * ? ? ? * chapter 8) . thus , to decode , the receiver projects the received vector @xmath78 on the subspace spanned by @xmath75 , and nulls the inter - stream interference . finally , the signal of user @xmath73 can be demodulated using a matched filter ( i.e. , maximal ratio combiner ) . the algorithm is given in figure [ alg . note that a full degrees - of - freedom gain is attained when @xmath0 users transmit . in this case , @xmath79 , and @xmath80 , e.g. , @xcite . accordingly , when using a zf receiver , we aim at algorithms which select at most @xmath0 users ( of the available @xmath2 ) in each time slot . as mentioned , since we focus on the scenario in which @xmath1 , the set of selected users has a crucial effect on the system capacity . optimally , a bs would receive csi from all users , and schedule the @xmath0 best users for transmission . under the linear decorrelation above , the resulting expected capacity is @xmath81 however , we wish to avoid the overhead and complexity of such a centralized process , and select a group of users , approximating the optimal selection , distributively . while simple and intuitive , the zf receiver is limited in its performance . the mmse receiver , however , although still linear , maximizes the mutual information and hence achieves better performance ( e.g. @xcite ) . in this receiver , to decode the @xmath82 data stream , the receiver treats the rest of the streams as noise . it then whitens the resulting colored noise and uses a matched filter to obtain maximum sinr . let @xmath83 be a matrix whose columns are the channel vectors of the transmitting users . similarly , let @xmath84 be the matrix @xmath83 with its @xmath82 column removed and define @xmath85 then , the corresponding output @xmath86 on the stream @xmath16 can be expressed by @xcite : @xmath87 this sinr value will be at the basis of our analysis in section [ sec . mmse rec ] . a common approach to select a single user distributively , is a threshold - based procedure , in which a capacity threshold is set , and only a user who exceeds it transmits ( @xcite ) . of course , the events in which none of the users or several users exceed the threshold should be taken into account . in this paper , however , we wish to select a group of users , and analyze the resulting capacity . at the heart of the algorithms we suggest herein , stands a similar threshold - based procedure . however , the challenge is twofold . first , in selecting a threshold such that a favorable _ group of users _ exceed it . second , in analyzing the results under the various decoding procedures and at the limit of large @xmath2 . when doing this , a few important questions arise : on which variable should a threshold be set and how many users will pass it ? how can one assess the mutual interference between the users which passed ? what will be the loss in this distributed procedure compared to the optimal , centralized one ? in the next three sections , we answer the above questions . we set a threshold on the _ channel norms _ , and analyze the resulting exceedance rate . we further analyze the mutual interference , in terms of the _ angles _ between the exceeding users , and conclude by analysing the resulting _ sum capacity _ , showing that a distributed algorithm can achieve the _ same scaling laws _ as a centralized one . in particular , we suggest two distributed algorithms . in the first , described in this section , a single threshold is utilized when decoding is done using linear decorrelation . in the second , described in section [ sec . sic ] , we offer a _ set of thresholds _ to match a successive interference cancellation ( sic ) procedure . given the number of users @xmath2 , we set a threshold @xmath88 on the norm @xmath89 , such that @xmath90 strongest users exceed it on average . in each slot , each user estimates its channel s norm . a user with a norm greater than the threshold , transmits . we assume the transmission includes the channel vector as a low - rate preamble so the bs has the csi _ of the transmitting users_. the algorithm for user @xmath16 is given in figure [ alg . channel access ] . note that the receiver can not recover more than @xmath0 data streams . that is , since for more than @xmath0 users the performance ( both under zf decoding and mmse decoding in section [ sec . mmse rec ] ) deteriorates significantly , if more than @xmath0 users begin transmission simultaneously , we assume a collision occurs and the whole slot is lost ( zero capacity ) . similarly , since users act independently , a slot might be idle , if no user exceeded the threshold . thus , we say that a slot is utilized if at least one user , but no more than @xmath0 users , are transmitting . the first result , proposition [ c zf uniform users exact ] below , gives the sum capacity under the above distributed user selection algorithm and zf decoding . note that this simple proposition still includes an expectation on the channel vectors seen by the users , hence can not give the understanding we wish regarding the sum capacity under the suggested algorithm . still , it will be the starting point , from which we will derive the bounds which give the right insight and scaling laws . [ c zf uniform users exact ] for @xmath1 , the expected sum capacity of algorithm channel - access with zf decoding is given by @xmath91 + o\left(\frac{\log \log k}{k}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath5 , to be optimized , is the expected number of users to exceed the threshold @xmath88 , the @xmath92 are the channel vectors of the users who exceeded the threshold and @xmath93 are the corresponding null spaces . according to the law of total probability , we express the expected capacity in a slot by summing over the number of users who exceed the threshold , and the sum capacity these users see , given that they exceeded the threshold . as mentioned , if more than @xmath0 users are transmitting in a slot , the receiver can not successfully null the inter - stream interference , and the capacity in that slot is zero . hence , the expected capacity has the form : @xmath94.\ ] ] when the users are i.i.d . , the probability of @xmath73 threshold exceedances follows the binomial distribution with probability @xmath95 to exceed the threshold . since we consider large @xmath2 and small values of @xmath5 , the number of users to exceed threshold can be approximated by the poisson distribution with an approximation error in the order of @xmath96 . this is based on the poisson point process approximation developed in @xcite for the single - user scenario . in short , this method gives a poisson approximation for the number of users exceeding a high threshold @xmath88 . however , as this approximation error is within the sum , it is multiplied by the individual capacities , which scales like the optimal scaling law of the multi - user diversity when a single , strongest user , is scheduled , i.e. , @xmath97 ( see e.g. , @xcite and the references therein ) . hence , the @xmath98 approximation error . finally , note that the number of exceeding users @xmath73 affects the effective snr seen by the attending users . in particular , when @xmath73 users exceed threshold , the dimension of @xmath99 is @xmath100 . thus , as @xmath73 decreases , the signal of the attending users is projected on a less restrictive null - space . accordingly , each stream may spread on more receiving antennas in the zf process , which leads to a higher power gain ( for details on zf decoding , see @xcite ) . nonetheless , the reader should not be confused . the highest capacity is attained when @xmath0 users utilize the channel simultaneously to achieve a full degrees - of - freedom gain . to ease notation , the @xmath98 approximation error is omitted from now on . to evaluate the result in proposition [ c zf uniform users exact ] , the behavior of @xmath101 should be understood , especially considering the fact that the number of users exceeding the threshold is random . to this end , the following upper and lower bounds are useful . these bounds will be the basis of the scaling laws we derive . [ c zf uniform users upper ] the expected sum capacity of algorithm channel - access with zf decoding satisfies the following upper bound @xmath102 where @xmath103 is given by and @xmath88 is the threshold set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . the bound in lemma [ c zf uniform users upper ] , while not giving the exact capacity , still depicts the essence of the system behavior . to understand its implications , we note the following : we set a threshold such that @xmath5 out of the @xmath2 users exceed it on average . i.e. , the average exceedance rate is @xmath5 . indeed , the expression @xmath104 in the sum over @xmath73 gives the probability for exactly @xmath73 users exceeding . each of the @xmath73 users , under zero forcing , experiences a single user channel , with its power @xmath9 scaled according to two factors : ( i ) a multiplication by @xmath105 , as this is the average norm of its channel vector , where @xmath88 is the threshold exceeded , and @xmath106 is the average distance _ above _ the threshold . ( ii ) a multiplication by @xmath107 , as in case only @xmath108 users exceeded the threshold , the zero forcing algorithm does not have to cancel @xmath109 users , only @xmath110 , hence the null space has a larger dimension , yet the number of receive antennas is @xmath0 . as the threshold @xmath111 will be shown to be @xmath112 , the optimal scaling law will follow . a complete discussion will be given after the lower bound is introduced . indeed , as it turns out in the simulation results , the bound in lemma [ c zf uniform users upper ] is tight even for relatively small number of antennas and users . note , however , that if less than @xmath0 users exceed , as a higher snr can be attained at the receiver , in order to achieve the capacity in this case , a user must know how many users exceeded , so it can exploit the high snr for , e.g. , higher transmission rate . hence , we require that the number of users that actually exceeded the threshold will be announced . note that in practice it is beneficial to choose @xmath5 slightly smaller than the number of antennas @xmath0 . this is since if less than @xmath0 users exceed , the snr seen by each user is only larger , yet if more than @xmath0 users exceed , the slot is lost . we start with proposition [ c zf uniform users exact ] . by jensen inequality , @xmath113 \nonumber\\ & \leq & \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } \sum_{i=1}^{j } \log\big(1 + p \text{e}\left[\left . \arrowvert { \mathbf{v}}_i { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k \right ] \big).\label{eq . in upper bound proof}\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider the norm @xmath101 , where @xmath99 has @xmath114 rows . denoting by @xmath115 the @xmath3th row of @xmath99 , we have @xmath116 & = & \text{e}\left[\left.\sum_{m=1}^{r - j+1 } \vert \langle{\mathbf{v}}_i^{(m)},{\mathbf{h}}_i\rangle \vert^2 \right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k\right]\\ & \stackrel{(a)}{= } & \sum_{m=1}^{r - j+1 } \text{e}\left[\left . \arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \frac{\vert \langle{\mathbf{v}}_i^{(m)},{\mathbf{h}}_i\rangle \vert^2}{\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \arrowvert { \mathbf{v}}^{(m)}_i \arrowvert^2 } \right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k\right]\\ & \stackrel{(b)}{= } & \text{e}[\left.\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k ] \sum_{m=1}^{r - j+1 } \text{e } \left [ \frac{\vert \langle{\mathbf{v}}_i^{(m)},{\mathbf{h}}_i\rangle \vert^2}{\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \arrowvert { \mathbf{v}}^{(m)}_i \arrowvert^2}\right]\\ & \stackrel{(c)}{= } & \text{e}[\left.\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k](r - j+1 ) \int_{0}^{1}(1-\alpha)^{r-1}d \alpha\\ & \stackrel{(d)}{= } & ( u_k + a_k ) ( r - j+1 ) \frac{1}{r}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above chain of equalities , ( a ) is since @xmath117 ( b ) is since @xmath13 is a random i.i.d . complex normal vector , and the squared - normalized inner product @xmath118 is its angle from @xmath115 , a vector in the null space of @xmath119 . since these vectors are independent of @xmath13 , this angle is independent of the norm of @xmath13 ( c ) is since the distributions of the norms and angles are independent of @xmath3 , and since , by ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3.2 ) , the angle has the same distribution as the minimum of @xmath109 independent uniform @xmath120 $ ] random variables ( i.e. , with cdf @xmath121 , @xmath122 ) ( d ) is the result of computing the expected norm of an i.i.d . complex normal random vector , _ given that it is above a threshold which is exceeded by only @xmath5 out of @xmath2 norms on average_. the details are in corollary [ coro : expected capacity above est by gev thr ] , section [ sec : proofs ] . substituting in , we have @xmath123 which completes the proof . we now present a corresponding lower bound . [ c zf uniform users lower ] the expected sum capacity of algorithm channel - access with zf decoding satisfies the following lower bound . @xmath124 where @xmath88 is a threshold set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . it is important to note that the integral in lemma [ c zf uniform users lower ] above has a finite series expansion with @xmath0 summands . this finite series has @xmath125 at the leading term , resulting in the expected scaling law . we describe it in claim [ claim . integral result ] below , within the proof of the main result in this section - theorem [ theorem : c zf uniform users - scaling ] . following the derivations of the upper bound , we have @xmath126 \\ & \stackrel{(a)}{\ge } \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } \sum_{i=1}^{j } \text{e}\log\left(1 + p u_k \sum_{m=1}^{r - j+1 } \frac{\langle{\mathbf{v}}_i^{(m)},{\mathbf{h}}_i\rangle^2}{\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_i \arrowvert^2 \arrowvert { \mathbf{v}}^{(m)}_i \arrowvert^2 } \right ) \\ & \stackrel{(b)}{= } \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j!}j \text{e}\log\left(1 + p u_k \sum_{m=1}^{r - j+1 } \frac{\langle{\mathbf{v}}_{i'}^{(m)},{\mathbf{h}}_{i'}\rangle^2}{\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_{i ' } \arrowvert^2 \arrowvert { \mathbf{v}}^{(m)}_{i ' } \arrowvert^2 } \right ) \\ & \ge \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } j \text{e}\log\left(1 + p u_k \frac{\langle{\mathbf{v}}_{i'}^{(1)},{\mathbf{h}}_{i'}\rangle^2}{\arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}_{i ' } \arrowvert^2 \arrowvert { \mathbf{v}}^{(1)}_{i'}\arrowvert^2 } \right ) \\ & \stackrel{(c)}{= } \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } j \int_{0}^{1}(r-1)(1-\alpha)^{r-2}\log\left(1+p u_k \alpha\right ) d \alpha\end{aligned}\ ] ] where ( a ) is since the norms of _ all users participating _ are above the threshold @xmath88 ; ( b ) is since the angles in the inner sum are identically distributed and independent of @xmath16 , hence an arbitrary @xmath127 can be used ; ( c ) is by explicitly computing the expectation over the angle between @xmath13 and @xmath128 , remembering that it has a density @xmath129 for @xmath122 . this completes the proof . the results above lead to the following scaling law , which is the main result in this section . it asserts that the scaling law of @xmath130 for the sum rate in a multi - user system can in fact _ be achieved distributively _ , without collecting all channel states from all users and scheduling them in a centralized manner . in other words , the threshold based algorithm suggested selects an optimal _ set of users _ ( asymptotically in the number of users ) distributively and without any cooperation . this is summarized in the next theorem . [ theorem : c zf uniform users - scaling ] the expected sum capacity of algorithm channel - access with zf decoding scales as @xmath131 for large enough number of users @xmath2 . by lemma [ c zf uniform users upper ] , @xmath132 on the other hand , consider the lower bound given in lemma [ c zf uniform users lower ] . since @xmath5 is a parameter to be optimized , the optimum is at least as large as when choosing @xmath133 . we have @xmath134 where the last inequality is by evaluating the sum at @xmath135 . note that larger values of @xmath0 give only slightly larger values , with a limit of @xmath136 as @xmath137 . , calculated at @xmath109 . the limiting behavior can be found in @xcite . ] now , consider the integral over @xmath138 in lemma [ c zf uniform users lower ] . in section [ sec : proofs ] , we prove the following claim . integral result ] the integral over @xmath138 in lemma [ c zf uniform users lower ] has the following finite series expansion : @xmath139 this gives a finite series expansion for the integral , in terms of the power @xmath9 and the threshold @xmath140 . for example , for @xmath141 we have @xmath142 thus , the integral can be easily approximated by @xmath143 . since we consider the regime of large enough number of users @xmath2 , yet a finite number of antennas @xmath0 , we have @xmath144 and as a result @xmath145 . in fact , since the distribution of the projected channel gain seen by a user in this decoding scheme is the exponential distribution with rate @xmath14 , it can be shown that @xmath146 ( we discuss the threshold value in detail in section [ sec : thr est ] ) . this gives rise to the @xmath147 scaling law . it is well known that linear decorrelation is asymptotically optimal at high snr . the suggested algorithms pick the users with the highest snr , accordingly , they operate at high snr and loose only a constant fraction of the optimal centralized scheduling scheme . extensive simulations were conducted to compare the analytical bounds derived above to real world situations with a finite number of users . in figure [ fig : mac_sim248 ] , we compare the bounds on the expected capacity of the threshold - based scheduling scheme under zf - receiver ( i.e. , lemma [ c zf uniform users upper ] and lemma [ c zf uniform users lower ] ) , to the simulation results . the bounds and simulation are for @xmath68 users , with @xmath148 and @xmath149 receiving antennas at the bs . the tightness of the upper bound is clearly visible . while the lower bound is looser , it still gives the correct behaviour as a function of the number of users passing the threshold on average , @xmath5 . indeed , it is clear from the figure that a key factor affecting the system performance is the number of users passing the threshold . this distribution gives the graphs their poisson - like shape . to see that the trend holds even for a relatively small number of users , figure [ fig : mac_sim24830 ] includes the same plots for @xmath67 . note that even for @xmath69 users the algorithm manages to achieve a significant rate ( compared , e.g. , to the one achieved with @xmath150 users ) . this means the essence of the multi - user diversity is exploited by the algorithm even for a relatively small number of users . note , however , that as @xmath0 approaches @xmath2 then the accuracy of the bounds decreases . the results in figure [ fig : mac_sim248 ] and figure [ fig : mac_sim24830 ] give the expected sum capacity as a function of @xmath5 . the capacity distribution , compared to different algorithms , will be given in the subsequent sections . . bars are simulation results , while the solid and dashed lines represent the upper and lower bounds , respectively . the threshold @xmath88 is set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . the green ( upper ) , red ( middle ) and blue ( lower ) lobes are for @xmath151 and @xmath70 receive antennas , respectively . note that the optimal @xmath5 is smaller than @xmath0 . this is since it is better to aim at slightly less than @xmath0 users passing , as the performance deteriorates significantly for more than @xmath0 users transmitting concurrently . ] . bars are simulation results , while the solid and dashed lines represent the upper and lower bounds , respectively . the threshold @xmath88 is set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . the green ( upper ) , red ( middle ) and blue ( lower ) lobes are for @xmath151 and @xmath70 receive antennas , respectively . note that the essence of the analysis holds for even a relatively small number of users as @xmath69 , as the bounds still depict the key elements affecting the performance . ] in the previous section , only a single threshold was used , and a user s data was decoded by projecting the received signal on the null space of the sub - space spanned by the channels of the interfering users . while this algorithm managed to capture the key performance - enhancing aspects of the multi - user system , and achieve the optimal scaling laws distributively , better results can be expected for low to moderate number of users . in that regime , harnessing additional multiple access techniques and a more sophisticated thresholding algorithm can achieve better performance . in this section , we see that this is indeed so . when using sic ( * ? ? ? * ch.6 ) , the decoder uses the decoded signal of a previous user to decode the next one ( by subtracting it from the received stream ) . after @xmath109 iterations of sic , all data streams are decoded . with this in mind , we derive a second , iterative algorithm , to further utilizing the benefits of sic in a threshold based algorithm . at first glance , for large number of users , a _ set of thresholds _ @xmath152 should be chosen , such that in each iteration only a single user exceeds on average . this way , one can adapt the thresholds set according to the users admitted " thus far ( that is , users who already passed ) . for example , one can set the next threshold based on the angles of the previously admitted users . however , it is very likely that in some of the @xmath0 iterations , more than one user , or no user , will exceed the threshold . specifically , the probability that exactly one user will exceed in an iteration is approximately @xmath153 . yet , if a carrier sense , or collision detection mechanism is available , collisions can be resolved by allocating a few mini - slots devoted to finding the strongest user in each iteration @xcite . this gives rise to the following algorithm : after the strongest user is found , it begins its transmission by announcing its channel vector . in the @xmath154th iteration , the rest of the users project their channel vector on the orthonormal basis @xmath155 , which spans the null space of the channels vectors announced thus far . now , the scheduled user for iteration @xmath154 is the one with the _ strongest projection_. the process ends when @xmath0 users are selected . note that this involves announcements of the channel vectors only from the @xmath156 selected users . the algorithm is described in figure [ alg . @xmath157 ; @xmath158 when a user projects its channel on @xmath159 , the resulting gain distribution follows the @xmath17-distribution with @xmath160 degrees of freedom @xcite . that is , @xmath161 . let @xmath162 be the channel with the strongest norm in iteration @xmath154 , i.e. , @xmath163 note that in practice , the bs _ does not have to search for the maximum above _ , but , instead , a threshold is set , only the strongest users pass , and one is selected using a collision resolution mechanism . utilizing the evt for the @xmath164-distribution , the norm @xmath165 can then be characterized . we have the following . [ prop : c uniform users sic ] for sufficiently large @xmath2 , the expected sum capacity of algorithm sic - channel - access with zf - sic decoding is given by : @xmath166 \nonumber , \label{eq : expected capacity sic}\ ] ] where @xmath167 is the channel vector of with the largest norm after the @xmath168 projection . note that the above result assumes each transmitting user can adapt its transmission rate to be decoded successfully at the base station . this is possible as each user _ knowns the channel vectors on the interfering users _ and his own channel vector , thus can calculate the snr the bs will experience when decoding . furthermore , a splitting algorithm is used @xcite , hence the poisson coefficients can be omitted . again , to evaluate the performance of proposition [ prop : c uniform users sic ] , the distribution of @xmath169 should be examined . we now derive upper and lower bounds to better evaluate the performance unders the suggested algorithm . [ c sic uniform users upper ] the expected sum capacity of algorithm sic - channel - access with zf - sic decoding satisfies the following upper bound . @xmath170 where @xmath171 are the normalizing constant given in ( [ eqn : a_n normalized ] ) and ( [ eqn : b_n normalized ] ) respectively , and @xmath172 is the euler gamma constant . note that @xmath173 ( as it converges to @xmath174 in equation ) , hence the same scaling law is achieved . by jensen inequality , @xmath175 \nonumber\\ & \leq & \sum_{l=1}^{r } \log\big(1 + p \text{e } \left [ \arrowvert { \mathbf{h}}^{(l ) } \arrowvert^2 \right ] \big)\nonumber\\ & = & \sum_{l=1}^{r } \log\big(1 + p \text{e } \left [ \max_{1\leq i\leq k}\vert { \mathbf{v}}^{(l-1)}{\mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 \right ] \big).\nonumber \ ] ] to analyse the expectation some care is needed . without conditioning in the @xmath154-th iteration on the event that the remaining users did not come out ahead in the previous iterations , that is , allowing " all users to compete again , the norm @xmath176 follows @xmath177-distribution . hence , by theorem [ theorem . evt ] , @xmath178 follows the gumbel distribution , with normalizing constants @xmath179 and @xmath180 given and , respectively . however , when such a conditioning is applied , the expectation can only decrease , as the previous users are not allowed to participate . thus , the expected maximal norm is upper bounded by the expected value of the gumbel distribution with the above parameters . lemma [ c sic uniform users upper ] then follows . to bound the performance from below , we only derive probabilistic lower bound . that is , a set of fixed relatively low threshold values are computed , such that in each iteration , we can guarantee that the norm of the strongest channel is greater than that value with high probability . however , in order to attain a non - trivial bound , these values need to be as high as possible , yet , maintain the lower bound with high probability . specifically , in each iteration , we chose a threshold value that is greater than the strongest norm with probability @xmath181 ( hence the probability that no user exceeds it is @xmath181 ) . this corresponds to a threshold that @xmath182 users exceed it on average . nonetheless , depending on the strictness of the bound , a different threshold sets can be chosen . accordingly , we have the following . [ c sic uniform users lower ] the expected sum capacity of algorithm sic - channel - access with zf - sic decoding satisfies the following lower bound with high probability . @xmath183 where @xmath184 is a threshold such that @xmath182 projected channel norms exceeds it on average , in iteration @xmath154 . let us consider the probability that the no user exceeds the threshold @xmath184 on iteration @xmath154 . this can be expressed as @xmath185 since @xmath186 is monotone , @xmath187 let @xmath188 , namely , the event in which the strongest channel in iteration @xmath154 is greater than threshold @xmath184 . we have @xmath189 that is , the probability that at least one user exceeds the threshold in each iteration , is greater than @xmath190 . as a result , since each l.h.s . element is greater than threshold with high probability , we conclude that @xmath191 with high probability consequently , @xmath192 \geq \sum_{l=1}^r \log(1+u_{\log k}^{(l)}).\ ] ] note that the sic scheme above achieves the same scaling law as the former linear decorrelation scheme ( clearly , one can not do better asymptotically ) , yet , it also achieves higher power gain , i.e. , there is a boost in performance since the effective snr is increasing in each iteration . this is clearly seen in the simulations below , where the results are clearly better for the finite population we tested . specifically , figure [ fig : mac_distributions4 ] depicts the gain of multi - user scheduling with and without sic , and compares it to scheduling schemes which schedule a single user at a time . receiving antennas and @xmath68 users , each with a single transmitting antenna . green ( left ) : a single arbitrary user is scheduled ( approximately gaussian ) . yellow ( second left ) : the strongest user is scheduled ( approximately gumbel ) . pink ( second right ) : a group of 4 strongest users are scheduled , with zf receiver . blue ( right ) : a group of 4 users are scheduled , with the suggested multi - threshold algorithm and zf - sic receiver . ] note that the capacity distribution in each iteration under sic can be approximated by the gumbel distribution . further , the sum - capacity distribution under sic is also approximated by the gumbel distribution , since the gumbel distribution is infinitely divisible @xcite . this is also consistent with figure [ fig : mac_distributions ] , which zooms in on the comparison between the capacity distributions : when the receiver uses zf versus zf - sic to decode the data streams . receiving antennas and @xmath68 users , each with a single transmitting antenna . the left ( pink ) lobe depicts the capacity when a group of @xmath141 users are scheduled , and the receiver demodulates the data streams by null forcing ( all users are above a threshold , according to the algorithm in section [ sec . dist alg ] ) . the right ( blue ) lobe depicts the capacity when a group of @xmath141 users are scheduled ( using the multi - threshold algorithm ) , and the receiver demodulates the data streams using sic . ] note that in the suggested sic algorithm , the users are naturally ordered from the strongest to the @xmath154-strongest user . hence , to improve the sum capacity , one might devise a distributed water - filling algorithm ( e.g. @xcite ) , such that each user will invest a power amount proportional to its order . the zf receiver discussed thus far is on the one hand simple enough to facilitate rigorous analysis , yet , as shown in the previous sections , powerful enough in the sense that with intelligent user selection ( in this paper , distributed ) can achieve the optimal scaling laws . still , this is not the optimal linear receiver . in this section , we explore the scaling laws of the expected capacity of the mmse receiver . as mentioned , in this case we let @xmath83 denote a matrix whose columns are the channel vectors of the _ transmitting users_. that is , when using the channel - access algorithm , vectors with norm greater than the threshold . @xmath84 is the matrix @xmath83 with its @xmath82 column removed . under these definitions , the sinr seen at the @xmath16th stream was given in . let @xmath193 denote the set of channels with norm greater than a threshold . then , the expected capacity under the threshold based scheduling algorithm in section [ sec . dist alg ] is as follows . [ c mmse uniform users][prop . c mmse ] for @xmath1 , the expected sum capacity with mmse decoding is @xmath194 = & \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } \sum_{i=1}^j \text{e}\left[\left.\log\left(1 + p { \mathbf{h}}_i^{\dagger}{\mathbf{r}}{\mathbf{h}}_i \right)\right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_s \vert^2 > u_k , \forall s \in \mathcal{s } \right ] + o\left(\frac{\log \log k}{k}\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 is the threshold set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . this expected capacity should be optimized over @xmath5 . the proof is similar to the zf setting . the only change is in the snr seen by the users , as reflected by the term within the @xmath195 . when zf decoding was used , the effective snr seen by a user was @xmath196 . as the matrix @xmath99 is unitary , it is clear why scaling up @xmath13 resulted in scaling up the snr . in the mmse case , however , the analysis is intricate . the snr is @xmath197 . while @xmath13 scales up , @xmath198 may appear to scale down as the eigenvalues of @xmath199 scale up . however , note that @xmath199 is not full rank , hence has at least one zero eigenvalue . as a result , @xmath200 has at least one eigenvalue which does not scale down . to evaluate the expected capacity in propositions [ prop . c mmse ] , the characteristics of the random variables @xmath201 should be understood , especially when the number of transmitting users is random . further , the influence of the norms @xmath202 on @xmath201 should be evaluated . the key technical challenge , however , is due to the norm condition _ inducing dependence on the matrix elements _ , hence the random matrix theory usually used in the mimo literature does not hold . part of the contribution in this section , is by bringing new tools to tackle this problem . note that in this section , regular type letters represent random variables as well as scalar variables . the difference will be clear from the context . as a first tool to handle the dependence within the matrix entries , we start with the following claim : [ claim . entries var of above thr vec ] assume the norms @xmath203 are above a given threshold @xmath88 . then the following properties hold : * the entries of the channel vector remain zero mean . * the variance of each entry in the vector scales . in particular , is equals to @xmath204 = ( u_k + a_{\{k , r\}})/r . \ ] ] * the vector elements remain uncorrelated in pairs . note that , to begin with , the entries of @xmath83 are i.i.d . the claim states that conditioned on exceeding a threshold , while not i.i.d . , they sustain the zero correlation . this property will be useful throughout the remainder of this paper . the proof of claim [ claim . entries var of above thr vec ] is deferred to section [ sec : proofs ] . now we are ready to derive the scaling - law of the mmse receiver , using the following upper and lower bounds on the threshold based expected capacity . c mmse upper ] the expected sum capacity of algorithm channel - access with mmse decoding satisfies the following upper bound . @xmath205 \leq \sum_{j=1}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } j \\ \log\left(1 + p\bigg ( 1 - \frac{(j-1 ) u_k^2}{r\left((1+\frac{j}{r})(u_k + a_{\{k , r\}})^2 + a_{\{k , r\ } } ( a_{\{k , r\}}+1)+ u_k\right)}\bigg ) ( u_k + a_{\{k , r\ } } ) \right ) . \ ] ] where @xmath103 is given by ( [ eqn : a_n normalized ] ) and @xmath88 is the threshold set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . before we prove the lemma , it is interesting to compare the scaling law under mmse decoding to that achieved with zf decoding . in both lemma [ c zf uniform users upper ] and lemma [ lem . c mmse upper ] , the capacity seen by each user is approximately @xmath206 , for some constant @xmath207 . asymptotically , it follows that @xmath208 , and in both cases , the capacity gain comes from the threshold value @xmath88 , which is , as mentioned , @xmath209 . this gives the growth rate of @xmath210 per user . however , note that while @xmath211 in lemma [ c zf uniform users upper ] , for large enough @xmath88 the gain in lemma [ lem . c mmse upper ] is asymptotically @xmath212 , that is , a larger gain for any @xmath213 . this is not surprising , as an mmse decoder does give a better power gain , but does not improve the already optimal scaling law . the capacity seen by user @xmath16 is bounded by : [ eq : mmse upper bound ] [ c_i ( u_k ) ] & ( 1 + p ) + & ( 1 + p ) + & ( 1 + p _ n=1^r_m=1^r ) + & ( 1 + p _ n=1^r ) + & ( 1 + p ) in the above chain of equalities , ( a ) follows from jensen inequality . ( b ) is the equivalent quadric form of @xmath214 . ( c ) is since the vector @xmath13 is independent in the column vectors of the matrix @xmath200 . ( d ) is since by claim [ claim . entries var of above thr vec ] part ( iii ) , the elements of the vector @xmath13 are uncorrelated . ( e ) follows from claim [ claim . entries var of above thr vec ] part ( ii ) . now , to address @xmath215 , conditioned on @xmath216 , we first use the following upper bound on the trace of the inverse of a matrix . for a symmetric @xmath217 positive definite matrix a @xcite , @xmath218 where @xmath219 is the smallest eigenvalue of the matrix @xmath220 . in our case , take @xmath221 . to obtain @xmath222 , we recall that @xmath223 and that @xmath224 is an @xmath217 matrix with rank @xmath110 , with @xmath225 , thus , by the eigenvalues decomposition theorem , @xmath224 has @xmath114 of its eigenvalues equal to zero . hence , the smallest eigenvalue of @xmath226 is @xmath227 . thus , using ( [ eq : trace inequality ] ) , it follows that @xmath228 - \text{tr}^2\left({\mathbf{r}}^{-1}\right ) - r^2}{\text{tr}\left({\mathbf{r}}^{-\dagger}{\mathbf{r}}^{-1}\right ) - \text{tr}\left({\mathbf{r}}^{-1}\right)}\\ & = & \frac{r\left[\text{tr}\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger } { \mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}\right ) + \text{tr}\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}\right ) \right ] - \text{tr}^2\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}\right)}{\text{tr}\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger } { \mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}\right ) + \text{tr}\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}\right)}\\ & = & r - \frac{\text{tr}^2\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}\right)}{\text{tr}\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger } { \mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}\right ) + \text{tr}\left({\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}^{\dagger}{\mathbf{h}}_{(-i)}\right)}. \label{eq : inverse trace bound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the expression in ( [ eq : mmse upper bound ] ) had a power loss of factor @xmath0 , that is , @xmath9 is divided by @xmath0 . however , it is multiplied by @xmath229 $ ] . in the last equality above we actually see that in this multiplication we gain back a factor of the form @xmath230 . this suggests that the mmse decoder is superior to the zf decoder in terms of power gain , as the expression in the zf decoder performance does not have this multiplicative factor ( this in consistent with , e.g. , @xcite ) . we will later evaluate the value of @xmath231 explicitly . furthermore , note that @xmath232 is actually the squared frobenius norm of @xmath226 , which is equal to the sum of squares of it entries . thus , we have , & & + & r - & + & = r - & + & = r - & where @xmath233 is the squared inner product . note that the numerator inside the expectation is at least @xmath234 . thus , & & + & r + & now , we have a concave function of the form @xmath235 inside the expectation . accordingly , using jensen inequality for concave functions , we obtain that & & + & r - ( j-1)^2 u_k^2 ( ) ^-1 & + & = r - ( j-1)^2 u_k^2 ( _ ^j . & + & + 2_^j_^j & + & + . _ ^j)^-1 & + where the last equality follows from the linearity of the expectation and since @xmath236 , which is the angle between two independent vectors , @xmath237 and @xmath238 , is independent of the vectors norms . moreover , we can now remove the conditioning on the norm when taking the expectation of the angle . accordingly , an upper bound can be evaluated by computing the expectations in the denominator as follows . & r - ( j-1)^2 u_k^2 ( _ ^j . & + & + 2_^j_^j & + & + . _ ^j)^-1 & + & r - ( j-1)^2 u_k^2 & + & ( ( j-1)(u_k^2 + 2a_\{k , r}u_k + 2a_\{k , r}^2 ) + j(j-1 ) ( u_k + a_\{k , r})^2 + ( j-1)(u_k + a_\{k , r } ) ) ^-1 & + & = r - , where ( a ) follows since the limit distribution of the channel norm tail is exponentially distributed with rate parameter @xmath239 given that it is above high threshold . namely , @xmath240 , @xcite . thus , @xmath241 $ ] can be interpreted as a second moment of exponential random variable . similar to section [ sec . dist alg ] , by ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3.2 ) , the angle has the same distribution as that of the minimum of @xmath109 independent uniform @xmath120 $ ] random variables ( i.e. , with cdf @xmath121 , @xmath122 ) . the expectations of the norms , again , follow from the evt . details are in corollary [ coro : expected capacity above est by gev thr ] , section [ sec : proofs ] . to completely characterize the performance of the suggested threshold - based algorithm under mmse decoding , we proceed to derive a corresponding lower bound . to this end , the following claims will be useful . the proofs are deferred to section [ sec : proofs ] . r is unitarily invariant ] let @xmath83 be a complex gaussian matrix with i.i.d . entries . then , * @xmath242 is unitary invariant . in particular , @xmath200 can be decomposed as @xmath243 , where @xmath244 is a unitary matrix , independent of the diagonal matrix @xmath245 . * the property above holds conditioned on all norms of the columns @xmath13 of @xmath83 being above a threshold @xmath140 . in particular , conditioned on @xmath246 , @xmath247 and @xmath13 have the same distribution . lower bound on upper gamma s geq 2 ] for @xmath248 , we have @xmath249 . lower bound on expectation ] let @xmath250 and let @xmath251 , independent of @xmath252 , for some integer @xmath253 . then , @xmath254 > \left(\frac{\gamma(r ) \gamma(r - j+1,u/2)}{\gamma(r , u/2)\gamma(r - j+1 ) } + \frac{e^{-u/2}u^{r-1}}{2^{r-1}\gamma(r , u/2)}\right)\log(u ) \\ \quad \quad + \frac{e^{-u/2}u^{r-1}}{2^{r-1}\gamma(r , u/2 ) } \left ( \psi(r - j+1 ) - \psi(r ) \right ) + e \frac{\gamma(r ) \gamma(r - j,1+u/2)}{\gamma(r , u/2)\gamma(r - j+1 ) } , \ ] ] where @xmath255 is the digamma function . to understand claim [ claim . lower bound on expectation ] , note that @xmath256 . hence , it is not hard to show that @xmath257 moreover , using claim [ claim . lower bound on upper gamma s geq 2 ] above , one can also show that @xmath258 hence , the importance of claim [ claim . lower bound on expectation ] is in showing that @xmath259=\theta(\log u_k)$ ] . similar to the upper bound , since @xmath145 , the scaling law of @xmath260 will result . to conclude , a lower bound on the performance of our threshold - based algorithm with mmse receiver is as follows . for simplicity of the presentation , we assume @xmath261 . c mmse lower ] for sufficiently large @xmath2 , the expected sum capacity under the threshold - based algorithm and mmse decoding satisfies the following lower bound . @xmath205 > \sum_{j=2}^{r}\frac{k^{j}e^{-k}}{j ! } j \left[\left(\frac{\gamma(r ) \gamma(r - j+1,u_k/2)}{\gamma(r , u_k/2)\gamma(r - j+1 ) } + e^{-u_k/2}\frac{u_k^{r-1}}{2^{r-1}\gamma(r , u_k/2)}\right)\log(u_k ) \right . \\ \quad \quad \left . + e^{-u_k/2}\frac{u_k^{r-1}}{2^{r-1}\gamma(r , u_k/2 ) } \left ( \psi(r - j+1 ) - \psi(r ) \right ) + e \frac{\gamma(r ) \gamma(r - j,1+u_k/2)}{\gamma(r , u_k/2)\gamma(r - j+1 ) } \right].\end{gathered}\ ] ] we assume @xmath253 users begin their transmission simultaneously and let @xmath193 denote the set of channels with norm greater than threshold . note that when only one user passed the threshold , while its capacity is easy to compute , as it is the single - user miso capacity , within this bound it is negligible as it is multiplied by the probability ( under the poisson distribution ) that only one user passed the threshold . hence , it is omitted for simplicity . in this case , the capacity of stream @xmath16 under mmse receiver satisfies the following lower bound . [ c_i ( u_k ) ] & = & + & & + & & + & & + & & + & & + & = & in the above chain of inequalities , ( a ) is since by claim [ claim . r is unitarily invariant ] , there is a unitary matrix @xmath244 such that @xmath262 with @xmath263 . as a result , we have the following quadric form : @xmath264 ( b ) is since the eigenvalues of @xmath200 are the reciprocals of those of @xmath226 . ( c ) and ( d ) follow since , first , the dimensions of @xmath224 is @xmath217 and its rank is @xmath110 . thus , @xmath114 of the eigenvalues of @xmath226 ( corresponding to the zero eigenvalues of @xmath224 ) are equal to one . then , as @xmath224 is positive semidefinite , the non - zero eigenvalues are non negative . in fact , the eigenvalues of @xmath265 which are not unity , are relatively large as all columns of @xmath83 are above a threshold . ( e ) is by claim [ claim . r is unitarily invariant ] ( ii ) . now , setting @xmath266 and @xmath267 , claim [ claim . lower bound on expectation ] completes the proof . in figure [ fig : mmse_sim ] we simulate the expected capacity of the threshold - based scheduling scheme , with mmse - receiver and compare the simulation results to the upper and lower capacity bounds given in lemma [ lem . c mmse upper ] and lemma [ lem . c mmse lower ] , respectively . in figure [ fig : zflower_vs_mmselower ] we compare the mmse receiver lower bound ( dot - dashed line ) and the zf receiver lower bound ( dashed line ) . as expected the mmse achieves better performance when the threshold is lower , which corresponds to a lower snr , and further , to a lower idle slot probability . on the other hand , as the threshold gets higher , which translates to high snr , the zf yields same results as mmse . from this observation , since the mmse receiver requires lower threshold to achieve higher sum - rate , we comprehend that the mmse receiver is preferable to the zf receiver , both in terms of sum - rate and idle slot probability , yet , still has a linear decoding complexity . . the threshold @xmath88 is set such that @xmath5 users exceed it on average . bars are the capacity under the threshold based scheme simulation results under mmse receiver , while the solid and dashed lines represent the upper and lower bounds , respectively . the orange ( upper ) , green ( 2nd from above ) , red ( 3rd from above ) and blue ( lower ) lobes are for @xmath268 and @xmath70 receive antennas , respectively . note that the optimal @xmath5 is smaller than @xmath0 . ] and @xmath70 receive antennas , respectively . note that since one should choose @xmath5 for best results , the mmse lower bound predicts better results , achieved for a smaller @xmath5 per @xmath0 ( the number of receive antennas ) . ] the methods discussed in the previous sections are based on a common baseline procedure . first , given that the norm threshold was exceeded , we wish to get a handle on the capacity distribution . then , we wish to express the rate at which users exceed the threshold , in order to understand how likely is that a given number of users exceed a certain threshold . finally , a threshold is estimated . this threshold is set according to the fraction of users which are required to exceed it on average . in this paper , the threshold is set on the channel vector norm , either directly or after projecting it on the null - space of the already chosen users . note that we used a similar approach to analyze the expected rate , when the channel capacity is approximately gaussian in @xcite . in this section , we discuss the following problems directly for the problem at hand . once a threshold is set , it is important to evaluate both the distribution of the number of users which exceed it as well as the conditional distribution of the norm given that the threshold was exceeded . herein , we utilize the point process approximation @xcite and its specific usage for threshold arrival rates in the _ single user case _ @xcite in order to derive these distributions for the problem at hand . assume that @xmath269 is a sequence of i.i.d . random variables with a distribution function @xmath27 , such that @xmath27 is in the domain of attraction of some gev distribution g , with normalizing constants @xmath270 and @xmath30 . we construct a sequence of points @xmath271 on @xmath120 \times { \mathbb{r}}$ ] by @xmath272 and examine the limit process , as @xmath273 . consider @xmath274 on the set @xmath120 \times ( b_l + \epsilon , \infty)$ ] , where @xmath275 . by @xcite , @xmath276 , where @xmath9 is a non - homogeneous poisson process with intensity density @xmath277 . @xmath56 is the sample value , and @xmath278 is the index of occurrence . in fact , in the i.i.d . case , the process intensity density @xmath279 is independent of @xmath278 . let @xmath280 be the expected number of points in the set @xmath281 . @xmath280 can be obtained by integrating the intensity of the poisson process over @xmath281 , that is @xmath282 . as we are interested in sets of the form @xmath283 \times ( v,\infty)$ ] , where @xmath284 ( threshold exceedance ) , we have @xmath285 , where @xmath286 denotes @xmath287 ( e.g. , @xcite ) . that is , the number of users whose channel norms exceed a threshold can be modeled by a poisson process , with parameter @xmath288 . note that for @xmath289 , as in the case of the @xmath17 distribution , we have @xmath290 , hence setting a threshold @xmath291 results in a per - user arrival rate of @xmath292 , and , as a result , a total arrival rate of @xmath5 . to compute the conditional distribution , we proceed similar to @xcite . for any fixed @xmath293 , let @xmath294 , and let @xmath295 . then @xmath296^{-1/\xi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath297 and @xmath298 are the corresponding excess value @xmath299 at index @xmath278 , and the corresponding excess value at time @xmath278 in the limit process , respectively . namely , the result is a generalized pareto distribution , @xmath300 . note that for the @xmath17 distribution , @xmath301 , and we have @xmath302 for all @xmath303 . that is , the tail distribution can be approximated using an exponential distribution with rate @xmath304 . as a result , taking the expected value , we obtain the following corollary . [ coro : expected capacity above est by gev thr ] given a random complex gaussian vector , and a threshold such that @xmath5 users out of @xmath2 exceed it on average , then @xmath305 = u_k + a_{\{k , r\}},\ ] ] where @xmath103 is given in . let @xmath88 be a threshold such that only the @xmath5 users with the strongest channel norm @xmath306 will exceed it on average . since @xmath306 follows @xmath42 distribution , @xmath88 can be easily estimated using the inverse - gamma function . that is , @xmath307 note , however , that the expression above does not give any intuition on the actual threshold value , or , more importantly , how it scales with @xmath2 for fixed @xmath5 . yet , note that the threshold @xmath88 is closely related to the normalizing constant @xmath308 , since both aim to capture the last quantiles of the ancestor distribution . the exact relation can be obtain using the point process approximation . specifically , the exceedance rate for the @xmath17-distribution is @xmath309 accordingly , choosing @xmath310 gives a rate of @xmath5 in total . thus , letting @xmath103 and @xmath308 to be set according to and , respectively , @xmath88 is set . now , to see the scaling law , note that @xmath308 in converges to @xmath174 in ( [ eqn : b_n normalized slow ] ) , hence @xmath311 . figure [ fig : convergence of b ] depicts the above convergence result . in and the value in ( [ eqn : b_n normalized slow ] ) . the curves are plotted for @xmath268 and @xmath70 , top to bottom . ] we wish to solve the following definite integral : @xmath312 we first make the substitution @xmath313 . as a result , we obtain the following integral : @xmath314 now , using integration by parts , we have @xmath315 first , note that @xmath316 now , performing a polynomial long division , the term inside the integral can be expressed as @xmath317 finally , we exchange the integration with the ( finite ) summation , then integrate each term in the sum according to @xmath318 . we have : @xmath319 thus , claim [ claim . integral result ] follows . it can be shown by the total law of expectation , that the entries of the channel vector remain zero , given that the channel norm is greater than a threshold , as follows . @xmath320 & = & \text{e}\left [ h_{i , n } \big| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k\right]\\ & = & \text{e}\left[\left . \text{e}\left [ h_{i , n } \big| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k , \sum_{\substack{m=1 , \\ m\neq n}}^r \vert h_{i , m } \vert^2 = \tilde{u } \right]\right| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k \right]\\ & = & \text{e}\left[\left . \underbrace{\text{e}\left [ h_{i , n } \big| \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]}_{(\ast)}\right| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k \right ] \ ] ] since @xmath321 is complex gaussian random variable , the inner expectation @xmath322 can be decomposed to a real and an imaginary part as @xmath323&= & \text{e}\left [ a + i b \big| a^2+b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]\\ & = & \text{e}\left [ a \big| a^2+b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]+ i \text{e}\left [ b \big| a^2+b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]\\ \ ] ] to ease notation , let us denote @xmath324 . focusing on the real part , we use the total expectation law again to obtain : @xmath325 & = & \text{e}\left[\left . \text{e}\left[a \big| a^2 > u_k -\tilde{u } - b^2 , b^2\right ] \right| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]\\ & = & \text{e}\left[\left . \text{e}\left[a \big| \vert a \vert > \tilde{\tilde{u } } , b^2\right ] \right| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]\\ & = & \text{e}\left[\left.\underbrace{\text{e}\left[sign(a ) \vert a \vert \big| \vert a \vert > \tilde{\tilde{u } } , b^2\right ] } _ { ( \ast \ast ) } \right| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right ] . \ ] ] now , we show that the sign of @xmath326 is independent of the amplitude @xmath327 and @xmath328 . @xmath329 thus , the sign of @xmath326 , the amplitude @xmath327 and @xmath328 are independent . consequently , the inner expectation @xmath330 is equal to : @xmath331&= & \text{e}\left[sign(a)\right]\text{e}\left [ \vert a \vert \big| \vert a \vert > \tilde{\tilde{u } } , b^2\right]\\ & = & 0 . \ ] ] from symmetry , same result can be obtained for the imaginary part . thus , the vectors are still zero mean vectors . however , the variance of the vector entries increase , given that the vector norm is greater than a threshold . remember , by evt @xcite , the tail is exponentially distributed with rate parameter @xmath239 . thus , it follows that @xmath332 \\ & \stackrel{(b)}{= } & \sum_{n=1}^r \text{e}\left[\left . \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2\right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k \right ] \\ & \stackrel{(c)}{= } & r \text{e}\left[\left . \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2\right| \vert { \mathbf{h}}_i \vert^2 > u_k \right ] \label{eq : element conditional expectation}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where ( a ) is the result of computing the expected norm of an i.i.d . complex normal random vector , given that it exceeded a threshold @xmath88 . ( b ) follows from the linearity of expectation operator . ( c ) is since the elements of @xmath13 are identically distributed . we point out that choosing vectors with norm greater than a threshold increase the variance of the entries to @xmath333 . similar to the entries conditional expectation , it can be shown that the matrix entries are still uncorrelated in pairs . namely , @xmath334&\\ & = \text{e}\left [ h_{i , n}^{\ast}h_{i , m } \big| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k\right]&\\ & = \text{e}\left[\left . \text{e}\left [ h_{i , n}^{\ast}h_{i , m } \big| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k , \sum_{\substack{m=1 \\m\neq n}}^r \vert h_{i , m } \vert^2 = \tilde{u } \right]\right| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k \right]&\\ & = \text{e}\left[\left . \underbrace{\text{e}\left [ h_{i , n}^{\ast}h_{i , m } \big| \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]}_{(\tilde{\ast})}\right| \sum_{n=1}^r \vert h_{i , n } \vert^2 > u_k \right ] & \ ] ] similar to the method above , we decompose @xmath335 to its real and imaginary part . thus , the inner expectation @xmath336 is @xmath337&\\ & = \text{e}\left [ a h_{i , m } - i b h_{i , m } \big| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]&\\ & = \text{e}\left [ a h_{i , m } \big| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]- i \text{e}\left [ b h_{i , m } \big| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right ] & \ ] ] using the total expectation law on the real part of the expectation , we have @xmath338&\\ & = \text{e}\left[\left . \text{e}\left [ a h_{i , m } \big| a^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } - b^2 , b^2 \right ] \right| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right]&\\ & = \text{e}\left[\left . \underbrace{\text{e}\left [ sign(a ) \vert a \vert h_{i , m } \big| \vert a \vert > \tilde{\tilde{u } } , b^2 \right]}_{(\tilde{\ast \ast } ) } \right| a^2 + b^2 > u_k - \tilde{u } \right ] . & \ ] ] now , similar to the above method , let us show that the sign of @xmath326 is independent of @xmath327 and @xmath339 . @xmath340 thus , the inner expectation @xmath341 can be expressed as @xmath342&= & \text{e}\left[sign(a)\right]\text{e}\left [ \vert a \vert h_{i , m } \big| \vert a \vert > \tilde{\tilde{u } } , b^2\right]\\ & = & 0 . \ ] ] from symmetry , same result can be obtained for the imaginary part . thus , given that the norm is greater than a threshold , the vector entries sill are uncorrelated . thus , claim [ claim . entries var of above thr vec ] follows . a hermitian random matrix is unitary invariant if the joint distribution of its entries does not change under unitary transformation , namely , @xmath343 for any unitary matrix @xmath344 . it is well known that a gaussian matrix is unitary invariant ( e.g. , @xcite ) . it is not hard to see that @xmath345 . that is , the wishart matrix is also unitary invariant . similarly , as @xmath346 , @xmath347 . since @xmath348 is unitary invariant , by ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2.6 ) , there is a decomposition such that @xmath349 , @xmath244 being unitary and independent of @xmath350 , hence @xmath351 and part ( i ) follows with @xmath352 . note that if we are only interested in the decomposition , and the independence between the unitary matrix and the eigenvalues is not required ( as is the case in the lower bound below ) , the proof is simpler since @xmath200 is hermitian . for part ( ii ) , note that if @xmath353 , then @xmath354 . this is since the unitary transform does not change the vector norm , hence the set of instances @xmath355 with @xmath356 is the same as those with @xmath357 . the rest follows in the same manner . first , note that , @xmath358,\ ] ] where @xmath359 . accordingly , since @xmath360 is convex in @xmath278 for the corresponding @xmath361 , we apply jensen s inequality to the r.h.s . and note that @xmath362 = 1 $ ] , proving the bound . we wish to bound the following expectation , when @xmath250 and @xmath251 , independent of @xmath252 : @xmath363 = \frac{1}{\pr\left({\mathbf{x}}+{\mathbf{y}}>u\right ) } \\ \left[\int_{x=0}^{u } \int_{y = u - x}^{\infty}\log(1+x)f_{{\mathbf{x}}}(x ) f_{{\mathbf{y}}}(y ) dy dx + \int_{x = u}^{\infty } \int_{y=0}^{\infty}\log(1+x)f_{{\mathbf{x}}}(x ) f_{{\mathbf{y}}}(y)dy dx \right].\end{gathered}\ ] ] performing integration on @xmath364 , we have the following . [ eq . mmse lower bound ] & e[(1+x)|+ > u ] & + & = & where @xmath365 is the upper incomplete gamma function . further , note that the complement cdf of the @xmath366-distribution is @xmath367 . accordingly , to evaluate ( [ eq . mmse lower bound ] ) , we need to evaluate both @xmath368 and @xmath369 . we begin with integration by parts on @xmath368 , where the anti - derivative is @xmath370 . we have @xmath371 where the last equality follows since @xmath372 . now , to bound the above expression , we restrict our attention to @xmath253 . since @xmath373 , utilizing claim [ claim . lower bound on upper gamma s geq 2 ] , we have @xmath374 next , let us address @xmath369 . again , using claim [ claim . lower bound on upper gamma s geq 2 ] , we have @xmath375 let @xmath376 . accordingly , we have @xmath377\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath378 is the beta function . note that while @xmath379 as @xmath380 , the integral converges as this is the mean of @xmath381 when @xmath382 has a beta distribution . accordingly , we have @xmath383.\ ] ] to complete the proof , remember that @xmath384 . thus , we have @xmath385 > \frac{\gamma(r)}{\gamma(r , u/2)}\bigg(\frac{e^{-u/2 } u^{r-1}}{2^{r-1 } \gamma(r ) } \left[\log ( u ) + \psi(r - j+1 ) - \psi(r ) \right ] \\ + \frac{\gamma(r - j+1,u/2)}{\gamma(r - j+1 ) } \log(1+u ) + e\frac{\gamma(r - j,1+u/2)}{\gamma(r - j+1 ) } \bigg ) . \end{gathered}\ ] ] in this paper , we suggested a distributed multiuser scheduling algorithm which utilizes the multiuser diversity and achieves the optimal capacity scaling laws ( for large number of users ) . specifically , we offered threshold - based algorithms , and characterized the scaling law of the expected capacity under linear decoding , e.g. , zf , zf - sic and mmse . to support the results , we provided both tractable analysis which gave insightful results as well as simulations which showed tightness even for moderate number of users . we concluded that the distributed algorithm achieves the optimal scaling laws , i.e. , @xmath386 . li , ping and paul , debashis and narasimhan , ravi and cioffi , john , `` on the distribution of sinr for the mmse mimo receiver and performance analysis , '' in _ information theory , ieee transactions on _ , vol 52 , 2006 , pp . 271286 . j. kim , s. park , j. lee , j. lee , and h. jung , `` a scheduling algorithm combined with zero - forcing beamforming for a multiuser mimo wireless system , '' in _ ieee vehicular technology conference _ , vol . 1 , 2005 , pp . 211215 . m. airy , s. shakkattai , and r. heath jr , `` spatially greedy scheduling in multi - user mimo wireless systems , '' in _ the thirty - seventh asilomar conference on signals , systems and computers _ , vol . 1.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2003 , pp . 982986 . c. swannack , e. uysal - biyikoglu , and g. wornell , `` low complexity multiuser scheduling for maximizing throughput in the mimo broadcast channel , '' in _ proc . allerton conf . communications , control and computing _ , 2004 . g. primolevo , o. simeone , and u. spagnolini , `` channel aware scheduling for broadcast mimo systems with orthogonal linear precoding and fairness constraints , '' in _ ieee international conference on communications _ , vol . 4 , 2005 , pp . 27492753 . t. yoo , n. jindal , and a. goldsmith , `` finite - rate feedback mimo broadcast channels with a large number of users , '' in _ information theory , 2006 ieee international symposium on_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4em ieee , 2006 , pp . 12141218 . t. yoo and a. goldsmith , `` on the optimality of multiantenna broadcast scheduling using zero - forcing beamforming , '' _ selected areas in communications , ieee journal on _ , vol . 24 , no . 3 , pp . 528541 , 2006 . h. weingarten , y. steinberg , and s. shamai , `` the capacity region of the gaussian multiple - input multiple - output broadcast channel , '' _ information theory , ieee transactions on _ , vol . 52 , no . 39363964 , 2006 . z. shen , r. chen , j. andrews , r. heath , and b. evans , `` low complexity user selection algorithms for multiuser mimo systems with block diagonalization , '' _ signal processing , ieee transactions on _ , vol . 54 , no . 9 , pp . 36583663 , 2006 . k. jagannathan , s. borst , p. whiting , and e. modiano , `` efficient scheduling of multi - user multi - antenna systems , '' in _ modeling and optimization in mobile , ad hoc and wireless networks , 2006 4th international symposium on_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2006 , pp . x. qin and r. berry , `` exploiting multiuser diversity for medium access control in wireless networks , '' in _ infocom 2003 . twenty - second annual joint conference of the ieee computer and communications . ieee societies _ , vol . 2.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2003 , pp . 10841094 . k. bai and j. zhang , `` opportunistic multichannel aloha : distributed multiaccess control scheme for ofdma wireless networks , '' _ vehicular technology , ieee transactions on _ , vol . 55 , no . 3 , pp . 848855 , 2006 . j. kampeas , a. cohen , and o. gurewitz , `` capacity of distributed opportunistic scheduling in heterogeneous networks , '' in _ proceedings of the annual allerton conference on communication control and computing _ , 2012 . j. choi and f. adachi , `` user selection criteria for multiuser systems with optimal and suboptimal lr based detectors , '' _ signal processing , ieee transactions on _ , vol . 58 , no . 10 , pp . 54635468 , 2010 . j. laneman and g. wornell , `` distributed space - time - coded protocols for exploiting cooperative diversity in wireless networks , '' _ information theory , ieee transactions on _ , vol . 49 , no . 10 , pp . 24152425 , 2003 . l. wang , c. chiu , c. yeh , and c. li , `` coverage enhancement for ofdm - based spatial multiplexing systems by scheduling , '' in _ ieee wireless communications and networking conference , wcnc_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2007 , pp . 14391443 . m. pun , v. koivunen , and h. poor , `` opportunistic scheduling and beamforming for mimo - sdma downlink systems with linear combining , '' in _ ieee 18th international symposium on personal , indoor and mobile radio communications _ , 2007 , pp . 16 . a. janssen , j. van leeuwaarden , and b. zwart , `` gaussian expansions and bounds for the poisson distribution applied to the erlang b formula , '' _ advances in applied probability _ , vol . 40 , no . 1 , 122143 , 2008 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: spectrum scarcity and ever - increasing data rate requirements are the two main motivating factors behind introducing carrier aggregation ( ca ) in modern wireless communication systems , such as 3gpp lte - advanced @xcite . in ca transmission , multiple component carriers ( ccs ) at different rf frequencies are adopted simultaneously , either within the same rf band ( intraband ca ) , or at different rf bands ( interband ca ) @xcite . while interband ca naturally leads to a _ non - contiguous transmit spectrum _ , this can also happen in the intraband ca case when the adopted component carriers are located in a non - contiguous manner . adopting non - contiguous ca provides lots of flexibility in rf spectrum use , but also poses substantial challenges in the transmitter design , especially in lower - cost devices such as lte - advanced user equipment ( ue ) . moreover , multicarrier type modulations with very large peak - to - average power ratio ( papr ) are used in most state - of - the - art wireless communication systems . when combined with noncontiguous transmission schemes and high power - efficiency requirements , controlling the transmitter unwanted emissions due to power amplifier ( pa ) nonlinearity becomes a true challenge @xcite . in @xcite , a comparison of different transmitter architectures for ca based transmission schemes was presented , showing that it is more power efficient to combine the ccs before the pa , and thus use only a single pa , instead of having a separate pa for each cc . this is also technically feasible , especially in the intraband ca case . the power savings can be quite significant since the overall transmitter efficiency is dominated by the pa @xcite , and is particularly critical in mobile terminals and other lower - cost devices , such as small - cell base - stations , with limited computing and cooling capabilities @xcite . however , the power efficiency gained from using a single pa for all ccs comes at the expense of more severe unwanted emissions , stemming from the pa nonlinear characteristics , that can occur at adjacent channels or bands , or even at own receiver band in fdd transceiver case @xcite . the levels of different unwanted emissions are , in general , regulated by the standardization bodies and itu - r @xcite . it has been recently demonstrated that in the context of lte - advanced mobile transmitter with noncontiguous ca or multicluster type transmission , the pa nonlinearities lead to spurious emissions that can seriously violate the given spectrum and spurious emission limits if not properly controlled @xcite . furthermore , in fdd devices , in addition to violating the general spurious emission limits , the generated spurious components can also overlap with the device s own receive band , causing own receiver desensitization @xcite . one obvious solution to decrease the levels of unwanted emissions is to back off the transmit power from its saturation region . in 3gpp ue terminology , this is known as maximum power reduction ( mpr ) , and mpr values up to 16 db are allowed in some use cases for mobile terminals @xcite . however , this approach will end up yielding a significantly lower pa efficiency as well as a substantial reduction in the network coverage . there is thus a clear need for alternative pa linearization solutions which do not have such drastic adverse effects . digital predistortion ( dpd ) is , in general , one of the most effective solutions for mitigating transmitter nonlinear distortion . there have been substantial research efforts in the past 20 years in developing ever more efficient and elaborate dpd techniques , mostly for high - end macro base - station type of devices . the conventional dpd approaches seek to linearize the full composite transmit signal , and we thus refer to such solutions as full - band dpd in this article . there have also been a handful of recent works on efficient concurrent linearization techniques for multi - band transmitters that employ only a single pa @xcite . these works assume that the component carriers are separated by a large distance such that the spurious emissions are filtered out by the transmit rf filter , and hence linearization of only the main carriers is pursued . first , the emission limits in the spurious region are generally stricter than in the spectral regrowth region around the component carriers , and are thus more easily violated . this has been recognized also in 3gpp recently , in the context of intraband noncontiguous carrier aggregation @xcite . moreover , even in interband carrier aggregation scenarios in fdd devices , some of the spurious components can be hitting the own rx band causing own receiver desensitization @xcite . second , by concentrating the linearization efforts to the most critical spurious emissions only , the processing and instrumentation requirements can be significantly relaxed , thus potentially facilitating the dpd processing also in mobile terminals and other lower - cost devices . this applies not only to the dpd main path processing complexity but also to the feedback receiver instrumentation complexity which can also be substantially reduced . there have been some recent studies in the literature that consider the mitigation of the spurious emissions explicitly . in @xcite , such processing was added to complement a concurrent linearization system while assuming a frequency - flat pa response within the spurious sub - band . in @xcite , the dpd parameter estimation was done offline , based on extracting the quasi - memoryless pa parameters using large - signal network analyzer ( lsna ) measurements , and covering up to fifth - order processing . in @xcite , a memoryless least - squares fit between the observed intermodulation distortion ( imd ) at the considered sub - band and certain basis functions was performed . the basis functions were generated using a wideband composite carrier baseband equivalent signal , followed by sub - band filtering , implying a very high sample rate and processing complexity , especially for widely spaced carriers . the estimated and regenerated imd was then applied at the pa input , oppositely phased , such that it is canceled at the pa output . in this article , we extend the elementary third - order im3 sub - band dpd solution , proposed by the authors in @xcite , in two ways . first , the third - order im3 sub - band dpd is extended to incorporate higher - order processing based on explicit modeling of the higher - order spurious components at the im3 sub - band . this will enhance the im3 spurious emission suppression considerably . furthermore , we also extend the sub - band dpd solution to include higher - order sub - bands , i.e. , im5 , im7 , etc . , thus offering more flexibility and linearization capabilities beyond the basic im3 sub - band . all the proposed solutions are derived for wideband nonlinear pas with memory . furthermore , we also formulate novel decorrelation - based parameter estimation methods , covering both sample - adaptive and block - adaptive learning rules , to efficiently identify the needed dpd parameters with low complexity . the proposed learning solutions are also shown to offer better performance than the earlier proposed third - order or fifth - order inverse based methods . we also provide comprehensive simulation and rf measurement results , using a commercial lte - advanced mobile pa , to evaluate and validate the effectiveness of the proposed solutions in real world scenarios . the rest of this article is organized as follows : section [ sec : dpd_modeling ] presents the mathematical modeling of the different considered spurious components at different sub - bands , produced by a nonlinear pa with memory . stemming from this modeling , also the corresponding core processing principles of the proposed dpd solutions at different sub - bands are formulated . then , section [ sec : dpd_learning ] presents the proposed dpd parameter learning solutions , covering both sample - adaptive and block - adaptive decorrelation solutions at different sub - bands . section [ sec : complexity ] addresses then different implementation alternatives of the proposed sub - band dpd concept , and also analyzes the computing complexity of the sub - band dpd in terms of the number of floating point operations together with some hardware complexity aspects . finally , sections [ sec : simulations and measurements ] and [ sec : rf measurement results ] report comprehensive simulation and rf measurement results , evidencing excellent spurious emission suppression in different realistic scenarios . in this manuscript , we assume a practical case of non - contiguous carrier aggregation with two component carriers . when such noncontiguous dual - carrier signal is applied at the pa input , the pa nonlinearity leads to intermodulation distortion at different sub - bands , as shown in fig . [ fig : psd ] . assuming a cc separation of @xmath0 , in addition to the spectral regrowth around the main carriers , intermodulation between the two ccs yields strong imd at integer multiples of @xmath0 from the main ccs . in this article , we refer to the intermodulation ( i m ) sub - bands located at @xmath1 from the main ccs as the _ im3 sub - bands_. similarly , the _ im5 sub - bands _ are located at @xmath2 from the main ccs , and so on . in general , each i m sub - band includes nonlinear distortion components of different orders as shown in fig . [ fig : psd ] . for example , in the case of a seventh - order pa nonlinearity , the im3 sub - band contains third , fifth and seventh - order nonlinearities , while the im5 sub - band contains fifth and seventh - order components . in this section , we start with the fundamental modeling of the nonlinear distortion at the im3 sub - band as a concrete example . stemming from that modeling , we then formulate the basic processing of the proposed im3 sub - band dpd . after that , the modeling is extended to cover the nonlinear distortion components at the higher - order i m sub - bands , followed by the corresponding higher - order sub - band dpd processing . the actual parameter estimation and learning algorithms for the proposed sub - band dpd structures are then presented in details in section [ sec : dpd_learning ] . in all the modeling and developments , we adopt the widely - used wideband parallel hammerstein ( ph ) pa model @xcite to describe the fundamental nonlinear behavior of the pa , as it has been shown to model accurately the measured nonlinear behavior of different classes of true pas . the modeling is carried out at composite baseband equivalent level , where the two component carriers are assumed to be separated by @xmath3 . the composite baseband equivalent input and output signals of the @xmath4 order parallel hammerstein pa model , with monomial nonlinearities and fir branch filters , respectively , read @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the baseband component carrier signals , @xmath8 denotes the ph branch filter impulse responses of order @xmath9 , and @xmath10 is the convolution operator . intermodulation between the two component carriers leads to the appearance of imd components at @xmath11 , @xmath12 , etc . , as shown in fig . [ fig : psd ] for the corresponding rf spectrum . @xmath13 here , @xmath14 denote the baseband equivalent impulse responses corresponding to the wideband ph pa model filters @xmath8 , evaluated at the im3@xmath15 sub - bands , formally defined as @xmath16 with @xmath17 denoting an ideal low pass filtering operation with a passband width @xmath18 times the bandwidth of the wider cc . furthermore , @xmath19 and @xmath20 in ( 3 ) are the corresponding @xmath21 order static nonlinear ( snl ) basis functions , related to the nonlinear distortion at the im3 + and im3- sub - bands , respectively . assuming then an @xmath22 order pa model ( i.e. , @xmath23 ) , as a concrete high - order example , the im3 + sub - band basis functions read @xmath24 the corresponding basis functions for the im3- sub - band , i.e. , @xmath20 , can be obtained by simply interchanging @xmath6 and @xmath7 in the above expressions . next , these behavioral modeling results are utilized to formulate the proposed im3 sub - band dpd concept , specifically tailored to suppress the distortion at the im3 sub - band . for presentation purposes , we focus here on suppressing the spurious emissions at the im3 + sub - band , while the corresponding emissions at the im3- sub - band can also be easily mitigated using a very similar structure with minor changes as will be elaborated later in section [ sec : higher - order dpd principle ] . the key idea of the sub - band dpd concept is to inject a proper additional low - power cancellation signal , with structural similarity to ( [ eq : im3_output_mem ] ) and located at @xmath25 , into the pa input , such that the level of the im3 + term at the pa output is reduced . now , stemming from the imd structure in ( [ eq : im3_output_mem ] ) , an appropriate digital injection signal can be obtained by adopting the im3 + basis functions @xmath19 in ( [ eq : im3_basisfunctions1])-([eq : im3_basisfunctions5 ] ) , combined with proper filtering using a bank of sub - band dpd filters @xmath26 . incorporating such sub - band dpd processing with polynomial order @xmath27 , the composite baseband equivalent pa input signal reads @xmath28e^{j 2\pi \frac{3 f_{if}}{f_s } n } \label{eq : pa_in_with_im3_dpd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , and in the continuation , we use @xmath29 variables to indicate sub - band dpd processing and the corresponding predistorted signals . this dpd processing principle is illustrated in fig . [ fig : sub - band dpd ] at a conceptual level , where the tx / rx duplexer filters are omitted for simplicity of the presentation since they do not directly impact the sub - band dpd processing or learning . similar convention is followed also in other figures . different implementation alternatives as well as the parameter learning and feedback receiver aspects are addressed in more details in sections iii and iv . the direct substitution of ( [ eq : pa_in ] ) in ( [ eq : pa_out_mem ] ) leads to the appearance of spurious intermodulation terms also at higher - order i m sub - bands , in addition to the previously considered im3 sub - bands , as illustrated already in fig . [ fig : psd ] . these higher - order sub - band emissions can also be harmful , since they can violate the emission limits , cause own receiver desensitization , or both . thus , developing a sub - band dpd solution that can tackle also the distortion at these higher - order i m sub - bands with feasible complexity is important . similar to the above im3 + sub - band developments , we next extract the imd terms at the higher - order i m sub - bands . the baseband equivalent imd terms at the im5 + , im7 + , im9 + , and im11 + sub - bands , as concrete examples , can be extracted using ( [ eq : pa_in ] ) and ( [ eq : pa_out_mem ] ) , interpreted at proper sub - bands , yielding @xmath30 in the above models , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 denote the baseband equivalent impulse responses corresponding to the wideband pa model filters @xmath8 in ( 2 ) , evaluated at the im5 + , im7 + , im9 + , and im11 + sub - bands , respectively . these are formally obtained similar to ( 4 ) but replacing @xmath35 with either @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , or @xmath39 , respectively . the @xmath21 order basis functions at the these higher - order i m sub - bands , denoted by @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , and @xmath43 , and assuming again an @xmath22 order ph pa model , read @xmath44 the corresponding baseband equivalent imd terms at the negative i m sub - bands can be obtained by simply interchanging @xmath6 and @xmath7 in ( [ eq : imd_basisfunctions1])-([eq : imd_basisfunctions2 ] ) . then , stemming from the distortion structure in ( [ eq : im5_output])-([eq : im11_output ] ) , and adopting similar ideology as in the previous im3 sub - band dpd case , a natural injection signal for suppressing the spur components at higher - order i m sub - bands can be obtained by properly filtering and combining the above higher - order sub - band basis functions . the sub - band specific filters for the @xmath21 order basis functions are denoted with @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , and @xmath48 . incorporating such dpd processing with dpd polynomial order @xmath27 , and aggregating at the same time parallel sub - band dpds simultaneously for the im3 + , im5 + , and im7 + sub - bands , as a concrete example , the composite baseband equivalent pa input signal now reads @xmath49e^{j 2\pi \frac{3 f_{if}}{f_s } n } \nonumber\\ & + \left[\sum_{\substack{p=5 \\ p \text { odd}}}^{q } \alpha_{5+,p , n } \star u_{5+,p}(n)\right]e^{j 2\pi \frac{5 f_{if}}{f_s } n } \nonumber\\ & + \left[\sum_{\substack{p=7 \\ p \text { odd}}}^{q } \alpha_{7+,p , n } \star u_{7+,p}(n)\right]e^{j 2\pi \frac{7 f_{if}}{f_s } n } \label{eq : pa_in_dpd_imds}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in general , the achievable suppression of the distortion at different i m sub - bands depends directly on the selection and optimization of the different filters @xmath26 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and so on . this is addressed in detail in the next section . in this section , based on the previous spurious component modeling and the proposed sub - band dpd principle , we formulate computing feasible and highly efficient estimation algorithms for learning and optimizing the sub - band dpd filter coefficients such that the spurious emissions are minimized at the considered i m sub - bands . we start by deriving some analytical reference solutions , taking the third - order im3 sub - band dpd as a simple and tractable example , in order to demonstrate that minimizing the im3 power is essentially identical to decorrelating the im3 observation against the corresponding sub - band dpd basis functions . then , both sample - adaptive and block - adaptive decorrelation based learning rules are devised , covering the general cases of higher - order processing with memory at im3 and higher - order i m sub - bands . in this subsection , we derive three analytical reference solutions for calculating the im3 sub - band dpd coefficients . the considered approaches are the third - order inverse solution , also adopted in @xcite , the im3 power minimization solution , and the analytical im3 decorrelation - based solution . to keep the analytical developments simple and tractable , we consider a simplified case with a third - order memoryless im3 + sub - band dpd and a third - order memoryless pa . the actual sample - adaptive and block - adaptive decorrelation based learning solutions , devised later in this section , are formulated for the general cases of higher - order processing with memory . now , starting with the dual carrier signal in ( [ eq : pa_in ] ) , and limiting the study to the simplified case of a third - order memoryless im3 + sub - band dpd and a third - order memoryless pa , the basic signal models are given by ( [ eq : thirdorderanalysis_1])-([eq : thirdorderanalysis ] ) . @xmath50 here , @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the memoryless pa model parameters , @xmath53 denotes the memoryless sub - band dpd parameter to be optimized , while @xmath54 and @xmath55 refer to the baseband equivalent pa output at the positive im3 sub - band without and with sub - band dpd , respectively . now , as ( [ eq : thirdorderanalysis ] ) clearly shows , the im3 sub - band distortion at the pa output , with dpd adopted , depends directly on , and can thus be controlled by , the dpd coefficient @xmath53 . in the well - known _ third - order inverse solution _ , the dpd parameter @xmath53 is selected such that the third - order term in ( [ eq : thirdorderanalysis ] ) is canceled , i.e. , @xmath56 . the corresponding solution , denoted by @xmath57 , thus reads @xmath58 however , this will not remove all the distortion , because higher - order terms will be created due to the predistortion , as shown in ( [ eq : thirdorderanalysis ] ) . a more elaborate method for selecting the dpd parameter @xmath53 is the one that minimizes the power of the total im3 sub - band signal , @xmath55 , referred to as the _ minimum im3 power _ or _ minimum mean - squared error ( mmse ) _ solution in the continuation . for notational convenience , we define the so - called error signal as @xmath59 , as with ideal predistortion the im3 sub - band signal would be zero , and thus the optimization means minimizing the power of this error signal . the detailed derivation of the optimum dpd parameter which minimizes the mean squared error @xmath60 $ ] is given in appendix a , yielding @xmath61^*}{\left[|f_1|^2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{42 } + 4 \mathbb{r}(f_1 f_3^*)({{\rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{62 } + { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{44 } ) + 4 |f_3|^2 ( { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{46 } + 2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{64 } + { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{82})\right]^ * } , \label{eq : mmse}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath62 refers to the products of the cc signals higher - order moments of the form @xmath63 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}[|x_2|^j]$ ] , while @xmath64 $ ] denotes the statistical expectation operator . as will be shown with concrete examples in section v , this mmse solution provides better linearization performance compared to the third - order inverse solution . however , as shown in ( [ eq : mmse ] ) , the analytical mmse solution requires the knowledge of various higher - order moments of the cc signals . furthermore , the above solution is valid only in the case of a memoryless third - order nonlinear system , beyond which obtaining an analytical expression for the dpd coefficients becomes overly tedious . . the analytical reference solution for the decorrelation - based sub - band dpd structure is obtained by setting the correlation between the error signal , @xmath65 , and the third - order basis function , @xmath66 , to zero , i.e. , @xmath67 = 0 $ ] . then , through straight - forward algebraic manipulations , the decorrelation - based dpd coefficient , denoted by @xmath68 , can be shown to read @xmath69 assuming then , for simplicity , that the cc baseband equivalents are complex gaussians , ( [ eq : alpha_0 ] ) simplifies to @xmath70 where @xmath71 $ ] and @xmath72 ^ 2 $ ] are the variances of the two ccs @xcite . a clear advantage of the decorrelation - based approach compared to the earlier mmse solution lies in the simple and straightforward adaptive filtering based practical computing solutions , sketched initially in @xcite for simple third - order processing at im3 , which do not require any prior knowledge about signal moments or any other parameters . furthermore , opposed to the mmse solution , the decorrelation based approach can be easily extended to include higher - order nonlinearities and memory effects , at both the im3 sub - band as well as the other higher - order i m sub - bands , as will be described in details in the next subsection . in this subsection , we provide the actual sample - adaptive learning rules for both im3 and higher - order i m sub - band dpd structures with memory , whose basic operating principles were described in section ii . to facilitate the learning , we assume a feedback or observation receiver measuring the particular i m sub - band whose sub - band dpd filter coefficients are currently under learning . notice that opposed to classical wideband dpd principles , where a wideband observation receiver is typically needed , a more narrowband receiver is sufficient here since only the particular i m sub - band is observed . as both the im3 and the higher - order i m sub - band dpds are based on multiple strongly correlated basis functions , given in ( [ eq : im3_basisfunctions1])-([eq : im3_basisfunctions5 ] ) and ( [ eq : imd_basisfunctions1])-([eq : imd_basisfunctions2 ] ) , respectively , we start by introducing a basis function orthogonalization procedure , after which the actual proposed adaptive decorrelation algorithms are described . when a nonlinearity order higher than the i m sub - band order is considered , multiple basis functions are adopted in the sub - band dpd processing , as described in section ii . taking as an example case the im3 + sub - band , the snl basis functions @xmath19 , @xmath73 , given in ( [ eq : im3_basisfunctions1])-([eq : im3_basisfunctions5 ] ) , are highly correlated . this can negatively impact the convergence and stability of the adaptive decorrelation - based learning . therefore , the snl basis functions are first orthogonalized @xcite , which yields a new set of dpd basis functions @xmath74 , @xmath73 , written formally at sample level as @xmath75 where @xmath76^t , \\ \textbf{s}_{3+}(n ) & = [ s_{3+,3}(n)\:\:s_{3+,5}(n ) \:\ : ... \:\ : s_{3+,q}(n)]^t , \\ \textbf{w } & = \begin{bmatrix } 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ w_{5,3 } & w_{5,5 } & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ w_{7,3 } & w_{7,5 } & w_{7,7 } & \dots & 0 \\ \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots \\ w_{q,3 } & w_{q,5 } & w_{q,7 } & \dots & w_{q , q } \end{bmatrix}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the lower triangular matrix @xmath77 can be obtained , e.g. , through gram - schmidt orthogonalization , qr or singular value decomposition , or using a lower complexity iterative orthogonalization algorithm @xcite . similarly , the snl basis functions in ( [ eq : imd_basisfunctions1])-([eq : imd_basisfunctions2 ] ) corresponding to the higher - order i m sub - bands are also orthogonalized , to obtain new sets of orthogonal basis functions @xmath78 , @xmath79 , etc . we now present the actual sample - adaptive decorrelation based learning algorithm for the im3 + sub - band dpd coefficients . for notational convenience , we introduce the following vectors @xmath80^t , \\ \bar{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{3+}(n ) & = [ \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,0}(n)^t \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,1}(n)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,n}(n)^t]^t , \\ \bar{\textbf{s}}_{3+}(n ) & = [ \textbf{s}_{3+}(n)^t \:\ : \textbf{s}_{3+}(n-1)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \textbf{s}_{3+}(n - n)^t]^t,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where now @xmath81 denotes the @xmath82 adaptive filter coefficient of the @xmath21 order orthogonalized im3 + basis function @xmath74 at time index @xmath83 , and @xmath84 denotes the adaptive filter memory depth . furthermore , the vectors @xmath85 and @xmath86 incorporate all the coefficients and basis function samples up to polynomial order @xmath27 . adopting this notation , the instantaneous sample of the composite baseband equivalent pa input signal @xmath87 now reads @xmath88 where the instantaneous sample of the baseband equivalent im3 + injection signal @xmath89 reads @xmath90 then , in order to adaptively update the filter coefficients @xmath85 , the im3 + sub - band is observed with the feedback receiver , and the coefficient is updated as @xmath91 where @xmath92 denotes the baseband equivalent observation of the pa output at the im3 + sub - band with the current dpd coefficients . the scaling factor @xmath93 normalizing the learning step - size @xmath94 in ( [ eq : dpd_filterupdate_mem ] ) is philosophically similar to that of the normalized least mean square ( nlms ) algorithm , in effect making the learning characteristics more robust against the input data dynamics . the proposed coefficient update in ( [ eq : dpd_filterupdate_mem ] ) is seeking to decorrelate the im3 + observation and the adopted orthogonalized basis functions . this type of learning algorithm can also be interpreted as a stochastic newton root search in the objective function @xmath95 $ ] , where the target is to search for the dpd coefficients @xmath96 that minimize the ensemble correlation between @xmath97 and the baseband equivalent of the im3 + injection signal @xmath89 in ( [ eq : injected_im3 ] ) . the overall processing flow is graphically illustrated in fig . [ fig : decorr_dpd ] . we now extend the decorrelation based learning to higher - order i m sub - bands . first , adopting vector - based notations again , we introduce the following vectors for notational convenience @xmath98^t , \\ \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{7+,l}(n ) & = [ \alpha_{7+,7,l}(n)\:\:\alpha_{7+,9,l}(n)\:\ : ... \:\ : \alpha_{7+,q , l}(n)]^t , \\ \bar{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{5+}(n ) & = [ \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{5+,0}(n)^t \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{5+,1}(n)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{5+,n}(n)^t]^t , \\ \bar{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{7+}(n ) & = [ \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{7+,0}(n)^t \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{7+,1}(n)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{7+,n}(n)^t]^t , \\ \textbf{s}_{5+}(n ) & = [ s_{5+,5}(n)\:\:s_{5+,7}(n ) \:\ : ... \:\ : s_{5+,q}(n)]^t , \\ \textbf{s}_{7+}(n ) & = [ s_{7+,7}(n)\:\:s_{7+,9}(n ) \:\ : ... \:\ : s_{7+,q}(n)]^t , \\ \bar{\textbf{s}}_{5+}(n ) & = [ \textbf{s}_{5+}(n)^t \:\ : \textbf{s}_{5+}(n-1)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \textbf{s}_{5+}(n - n)^t]^t , \\ \bar{\textbf{s}}_{7+}(n ) & = [ \textbf{s}_{7+}(n)^t \:\ : \textbf{s}_{7+}(n-1)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \textbf{s}_{7+}(n - n)^t]^t.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , similar to @xmath89 in ( [ eq : injected_im3 ] ) , the baseband equivalents of the im5 + and im7 + sub - band dpd injection signals , denoted by @xmath99 and @xmath100 , respectively , read @xmath101 thus , the composite baseband equivalent pa input signal when the im3 + , im5 + , and im7 + sub - band dpds are all included , reads @xmath102 then , similar to the im3 + coefficient update in ( [ eq : dpd_filterupdate_mem ] ) , the higher - order im5 + and im7 + coefficient updates read @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath105 denote the baseband equivalents of the pa output at the im5 + and im7 + sub - bands , with the corresponding sub - band dpds included adopting the current coefficients , @xmath106 and @xmath107 , respectively . from the learning perspective , observing a single i m sub - band at a time is the most obvious alternative , which means that the learning for multiple sub - band dpds happens one at a time . furthermore , extending the decorrelation - based learning for the negative i m sub - bands is straight - forward . this can be obtained by interchanging @xmath6 and @xmath7 in the snl basis functions expressions , and observing the pa output at the corresponding negative i m sub - bands . as fig . [ fig : decorr_dpd ] illustrates , the previous sample - adaptive decorrelation - based learning concept is in principle a closed - loop feedback system with nonlinear adaptive processing inside the loop . during the dpd learning phase , and under the potential hardware processing and latency constraints , the dpd parameter convergence and consequently the dpd linearization performance can be affected , especially if the learning loop delay becomes large . stemming from this , an alternative and new block - adaptive decorrelation - based learning solution is developed next . the proposed block - adaptive learning rule implies defining two distinct blocks in the processing , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : blockdpd_learning ] . a single update cycle of the learning algorithm will utilize @xmath108 samples whereas the dpd parameter update interval is @xmath109 samples , with @xmath110 . thus , by proper choice of @xmath108 and @xmath109 , arbitrarily long loop delays can in principle be tolerated , facilitating stable operation under various hardware and software processing latency constraints . notice that proper timing synchronization between the observation receiver output and the basis functions is , in general , needed , which can be accomplished prior to executing the actual coefficient learning procedure . are applied in the sub - band dpd main path processing during the next block . ] [ tab : flops ] now , assuming an estimation block size of @xmath108 samples and dpd filter memory depth of @xmath84 per each of the im3 + orthogonalized basis functions , the following vectors and matrices , which stack all the samples and the corresponding dpd filter coefficients within block @xmath111 , can be defined : @xmath112^t , \\ \bar{\textbf{s}}_{3+}(n_m ) & = [ \textbf{s}_{3+}(n_m)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \textbf{s}_{3+}(n_m - n)^t]^t , \\ \textbf{s}_{3+}(m ) & = [ \bar{\textbf{s}}_{3+}(n_m)\:\ : ... \:\ : \bar{\textbf{s}}_{3+}(n_m+m-1 ) ] , \\ \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,l}(m ) & = [ \alpha_{3+,3,l}(m)\:\:\alpha_{3+,5,l}(m)\:\ : ... \:\ : \alpha_{3+,q , l}(m)]^t , \\ \bar{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{3+}(m ) & = [ \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,0}(m)^t \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,1}(m)^t \:\ : ... \:\ : \boldsymbol{\alpha}_{3+,n}(m)^t]^t.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the index of the first sample of block @xmath111 is denoted by @xmath113 . the block - adaptive im3 + sub - band dpd coefficient update then reads @xmath114^t , \\ \bar{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{3+}(m+1 ) & = \bar{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{3+}(m ) - \frac{\mu}{||\textbf{s}_{3+}(m)||^2 + c } \ : \textbf{s}_{3+}(m)\textbf{e}_{3+}^*(m ) , \label{eq : blockadaptive}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath115 refers to the element - wise conjugated error signal vector , while @xmath116 denotes the filter input data matrix , all within the processing block @xmath111 . the obtained new dpd coefficients @xmath117 are then applied on the next block of @xmath109 samples as illustrated in fig . [ fig : blockdpd_learning ] . while the above presentation describes the block - adaptive learning only at the im3 + sub - band , extending the principle to higher - order i m sub - bands is straightforward , and thus not explicitly shown . one of the main advantages of the proposed decorrelation - based sub - band dpd technique is its reduced complexity compared to the classical full - band dpd processing , especially in scenarios where the ccs are widely spaced and thus very high speed adcs and dacs are required in the classical solutions . in this section , we first address some implementation aspects of the proposed sub - band dpd concept . we then provide a thorough comparison of the computing and hardware complexity perspectives between the full - band and the proposed sub - band dpds . finally , some system power efficiency considerations are also presented , with particular focus on low - cost mobile devices . fig . [ fig : implementationalternatives ] shows two alternative architectures of the overall sub - band dpd processing with multiple i m sub - bands . the first architecture shown in fig . [ fig : decorr_dpd_im5_im7_im9 ] adds an upsampling and digital if upconversion block after each sub - band dpd stage in order to digitally place the generated injection signals at proper intermediate frequencies . after adding the sub - band dpd outputs in the digital domain , a single wideband dac per i and q branch is used after which the signal is upconverted to rf and amplified by the pa . the second architecture in fig . [ fig : decorr_dpd_im5_im7_im9_2 ] adds the outputs of the sub - band dpds in the analog domain , implying that each sub - band dpd is followed by a narrow - band dac per i and q branch , together with an analog complex if upconversion . a common i / q rf modulator is then used for all sub - bands prior to the pa module . both of these two architectures have their own advantages and disadvantages . in particular , if the carrier spacing between the component carriers is not very large , architecture i is likely to be more suitable . on the other hand , when the carrier spacing starts to increase , using a single wideband dac may not be efficient from cost and power consumption perspectives , so in this case architecture ii is likely to be more attractive . however , some extra processing may be required in this architecture in order to achieve proper synchronization between the dacs . this forms an interesting topic for future research . a common advantage of both architectures is that each sub - band dpd block can be switched on or off according to the prevailing emission levels and limits at the considered sub - bands . such flexibility is not available in the classical full - band dpd solutions since , by design , a full - band predistorter always tries to linearize the full composite transmit band . with the sub - band dpd concept , the linearization can be flexibly tailored and optimized to those frequencies which are the most critical from the emission limits perspective . in general , the computational complexity of any dpd can be classified into three main parts @xcite : identification complexity , adaptation complexity and running complexity . the identification part is basically the estimation complexity of the dpd parameters , while the adaptation complexity includes the required processing in order to adapt to new operating conditions or device aging . finally , the running complexity , which is the most critical especially for mobile - type devices , involves the number of computations done per second while the dpd is operating . in this subsection , we will focus on the dpd running complexity in details , while the dpd parameter identification and feedback receiver complexity perspectives are shortly discussed in section [ sec : fb_complexity ] . for a quantitative comparison of the running complexities , we shall use the number of floating point operations ( flops ) per sample , the number of dpd coefficients , and the required sample rate in the predistortion path as the main quantitative metrics . in general , the running complexity is divided into two main parts : the first is the basis function generation , and the second is the actual predistortion filtering using the basis functions @xcite . the number of flops required to perform these two operations is shown in table [ tab : flops ] for ninth - order sub - band and full - band dpds , respectively , where @xmath118 and @xmath119 are the corresponding memory depths per adopted basis function . the full - band dpd architecture that we use also in our comparative performance simulations in section v , and which is also widely applied otherwise , is based on the ph architecture with ninth order nonlinearity , while the sub - band dpd is based on architecture ii shown in fig . [ fig : decorr_dpd_im5_im7_im9_2 ] . frequency selectivity of the nonlinear pa is another important factor to be considered when comparing the two dpd architectures . this implies that when memory effects of the pa are considered , substantially longer filters are needed for the full - band dpd compared to the sub - band dpd for a certain performance requirement . in the complexity analysis , in the sub - band dpd case , we thus assume a memory depth of @xmath120 per basis function , while a memory depth of @xmath121 is assumed for the full - band ph dpd per basis function . a substantial reduction in the needed sample rates can be achieved when adopting the sub - band dpd . as a concrete example , if we consider a challenging lte - a ul scenario of two 1 mhz ccs with 20 mhz carrier spacing , the required sample rate by the full - band dpd is @xmath122 , while for the sub - band dpd it becomes @xmath123 . . furthermore , the processing complexity of the sub - band dpd solution is clearly feasible for modern mobile device processing platforms , in terms of the gflops count , while that of the classical fullband dpd is clearly infeasible . however , in some scenarios , when the carrier spacing between the ccs is decreased and/or the cc bandwidth increases , the benefit from using the sub - band dpd approach is reduced since the sample rates of the sub - band and full - band dpd will become more comparable . notice also that , e.g. , in interband ca cases , one can adopt a concurrent 2d - dpd @xcite to linearize the main carriers , which can then be easily complemented with the sub - band dpd processing to protect the own receiver if tx filtering does not offer sufficient isolation . such a scenario could take place , e.g. , in uplink band 1 ( 1920 - 1980 mhz ) + band 3 ( 1710 - 1785 mhz ) interband ca where it is technologically feasible to adopt a single multiband / multimode pa module for amplification . in such scenario , the im3 sub - band is then directly at the own rx frequencies of band 1 ( 2110 - 2170 mhz ) . in addition to the complexity reduction in the dpd main processing path , the complexity of the feedback or observation receiver , used for dpd parameter estimation and adaptation , is also greatly reduced . in order to estimate , e.g. , the parameters of the im3 + sub - band dpd , we only need to observe the im3 + sub - band at the pa output , instead of observing the full - band ( including all the i m sub - bands ) which is the case in the full - band dpd . this reduces the cost , complexity and power consumption in the feedback path allowing use of simpler instrumentation , in particular the adc . moreover , only a single observation receiver is required , even if linearizing multiple sub - bands , since the parameter learning and corresponding observation of the pa output can be done sequentially , in a per sub - band manner . finally , in terms of the parameter estimation algorithmic complexity , the proposed decorrelation based solutions are extremely simple , when compared to any classical full - band dpd related method , such as least - squares based parameter fitting and indirect learning architecture @xcite that are commonly adopted . when a dpd is adopted , a less linear but more efficient pa , that can operate near its saturation region , can generally be used . however , the overall power efficiency of the device is only improved if the extra power consumed by the dpd stage is less than the power savings due to increased pa efficiency . here , we address this aspect from a mobile device perspective . we consider a practical scenario where the transmit power at the output of the mobile pa is + 26 dbm ( i.e. , 400 mw ) , stemming from 3gpp lte - advanced requirements @xcite , and assuming that the tx duplexer filter and connector insertion losses are 3 db . then , good examples of practical pa power efficiency figures when operating in highly nonlinear or linear modes are around 35@xmath124 and 20@xmath124 ( or even less ) , respectively . this means that the power consumed by the highly nonlinear pa is roughly 1150 mwatt , while the corresponding linear pa consumes roughly 2000 mwatt . in other words , adopting a highly power - efficient nonlinear pa saves 850 mwatt of power in this particular example . then , in order to suppress the spurious emissions at the pa output , in the nonlinear pa case , we adopt the sub - band dpd solution . in @xcite , a state of the art 28 nm implementation of the qualcomm hexagon dsp capable of supporting up to 4.8 gflops at 1.2 ghz is reported , which is more than enough for carrying out the needed sub - band dpd processing for the im3 and im5 sub - bands in our example . in the full - band dpd case , on the other hand , which requires 31.9 gflops as shown in table [ tab : flops ] , this is clearly insufficient . the power consumption of the dsp platform in @xcite is shown to be approximately 100 mwatt , when running at 840 mhz ( i.e. , 3.36 gflops assuming 4 flops per cycle ) , which is again sufficient for linearizing the im3 and im5 sub - bands in our example . thus , adopting the nonlinear pa already saves 850 milliwatt , when it comes to the pa interface , as explained above , while when complemented with the sub - band dpd processing for enhanced linearity , only 100 milliwatt of additional power is consumed . thus , the overall power budget and power - efficiency are clearly in favor of using a highly non - linear pa , complemented with the sub - band dpd structure , even in a mobile device with non - contiguous uplink carrier aggregation . furthermore , if the sub - band dpd processing is implemented using a dedicated hardware solution ( e.g. , a digital asic ) , an even more power - efficient dpd stage can most likely be realized . in this section , a quantitative performance analysis of the proposed sub - band dpd solution is presented using matlab simulations with practical models for mobile - like pas designed for low - cost devices . in general , we quantify the suppression of intermodulation power at the im3 and im5 sub - bands through the power ratios relative to the component carrier wanted signal power as shown in fig . [ fig : psd ] , which are defined as @xmath125 the inband transmit waveform purity is measured through the error vector magnitude ( evm ) , which is defined as @xmath126 here , @xmath127 is the power of the error signal , while @xmath128 is the reference power of the ideal symbol constellation . the error signal is defined as the difference between the ideal symbol values and the corresponding synchronized and equalized samples at the pa output , both normalized to have identical linear gains . in section [ sec : dpd_analytic_solutions ] , analytical reference expressions for the third - order inverse , minimum mse , and decorrelation - based sub - band dpd solutions were presented . in this subsection , we shortly evaluate and compare the performance of these analytical solutions , assuming a third - order memoryless pa and known parameters , and focus only on the positive im3 sub - band for simplicity . the memoryless pa model has been identified using a true mobile pa , with transmit power of + 23dbm . the main objective is to compare the performance of the three analytical solutions in terms of linearization performance , and thereon to verify that the decorrelation based solution is essentially identifcal to the minimum mse solution . the signal used in this performance evaluation is composed of two 1mhz lte - a ul sc - fdma ccs with qpsk data modulation , and the cc spacing is 10mhz . the obtained results shown in table [ tab : im3r_evm_analytical ] demonstrate that the decorrelation - based solution is giving almost the same performance as the minimum mse solution , and also that both of them are substantially better than the classical third - order inverse solution @xcite in terms of the imd suppression at the considered sub - band . it can also be seen from table [ tab : im3r_evm_analytical ] that the evm is essentially not affected by the sub - band dpd processing . [ tab : im3r_evm_analytical ] next we evaluate and compare the performance of 5th - order inverse and decorrelation - based im3 sub - band dpd solutions . the 5th - order inverse reference solution for im3 + sub - band is derived in appendix b. in these simulations , the transmit waveform is again composed of two 1 mhz lte - a ul sc - fdma component carriers with qpsk data modulation , and the cc spacing is 10 mhz . the pa model , in turn , is a memoryless 5th - order model whose parameters have been identified using a true mobile pa transmitting at + 23 dbm . the 5th - order inverse dpd is using known parameters , while the decorrelation - based one is adopting the proposed sample - adaptive learning described in detail in section iv . the pa output spectra with different solutions are illustrated in fig . [ fig : psd_pth_decorr ] . it can clearly be seen that the decorrelation - based sub - band dpd substantially outperforms the @xmath4-order inverse based sub - band dpd , in both third and fifth - order cases , despite the fact that the @xmath4-order inverse solutions are using known parameters . the reason is that the inverse solutions cancel only the third and fifth order terms , as described in appendix b , but do not suppress the other induced higher - order terms , which have structural similarity and correlation with the third and fifth - order basis functions . on the other hand , the proposed decorrelation - based solution takes this explicitly into account , and thus achieves clearly better spurious emission suppression . the figure also illustrates that the performance of the fifth - order decorrelation - based sub - band dpd is clearly better than that of the third - order one . in the remaining parts of this section , we shall focus on more detailed performance evaluations of the proposed decorrelation - based sub - band dpd solution , incorporating memory both in the pa and in the predistortion processing . from now on , we refer to the decorrelation - based sub - band dpd simply as sub - band dpd , to simplify the presentation . -order inverse and decorrelation - based im3 + sub - band dpd solutions are compared , with both third - order and fifth - order nonlinear processing.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] in this subsection , we evaluate the performance of the proposed sub - band dpd in the more realistic case of having memory in the pa . the pa model is a 9th - order parallel hammerstein model , with four memory taps per branch , and the parameters have been identified using measurements with a true mobile pa transmitting at + 24 dbm . the sub - band dpd structure contains now also memory , with two taps ( @xmath129 ) per basis function . block - adaptive learning principle is adopted , with 200 blocks each containing 1000 samples . the transmit waveform is otherwise identical to earlier cases , but the cc separation is now 12 mhz . [ tab : im3_im5_evm ] fig . [ fig : psd_im3 ] shows the effectiveness of the proposed higher - order sub - band dpds , here processing the im3 + sub - band , compared to the basic third - order solution presented earlier in @xcite . up to 40 db suppression for the im3 spurious emissions is shown when adopting ninth - order processing , something that has not been reported before in any prior works using a practical pa model with memory effects . [ fig : im3_pwr ] shows then how the im3 spurious emission level changes with varying the tx power and using different sub - band dpd orders . the im3 spurious emissions are clearly below the general spurious emission limit ( -30 dbm / mhz ) even at very high tx powers up to + 23 dbm , when using a seventh - order , or higher , sub - band dpd . another main contribution in this paper is the extension of the im3 sub - band dpd solution to include also higher - order i m sub - bands . [ fig : psd_im3_5_7_9 ] shows the performance of the negative im5 and im7 sub - band dpds , in addition to the negative im3 sub - band dpd , when ninth - order nonlinear processing is adopted in the sub - band dpds . up to 40 db , 35 db , and 18 db of suppression is achieved at the negative im3 , im5 , and im7 sub - bands , respectively . this shows the effectiveness of the proposed solutions in processing and suppressing also the spurious emissions at higher i m sub - bands . in this subsection , we compare the performance of our proposed sub - band dpd technique against that of a classical full - band dpd adopting parallel hammerstein based wideband linearization and indirect learning architecture ( ila ) . the evaluation considers the linearization performance , complexity , and transmitter efficiency utilizing our earlier complexity analysis results reported in section [ sec : complexity ] . the ninth - order full - band ph ila dpd uses 100k samples for parameter learning , per ila iteration , with a total of 2 ila iterations , and the number of memory taps per ph branch is 4 . the ninth - order block - adpative sub - band dpd , in turn , uses also a total of 200k samples with block size @xmath130 , and adopts two memory taps per dpd snl basis function . the results are collected in table [ tab : im3_im5_evm ] , which shows that in addition to the significantly lower complexity measured by the number of gflops , the sub - band dpd achieves better linearization performance in terms of spurious imd suppression at the considered im3 and im5 sub - bands . on the other hand , the full - band dpd outperforms the sub - band dpd in terms of the inband distortion mitigation ( i.e. , evm ) . this is expected , since the full - band dpd linearizes the whole transmit band , including the main ccs and the imd spurious emissions . however , the evm with the sub - band dpd is only around @xmath131 which is by far sufficient for modulations at least up to @xmath132-qam . . thus the transmitter becomes more power efficient when using the sub - band dpd as shown in table [ tab : im3_im5_evm ] . for fairness , it is to be acknowledged that a full - band dpd can typically enhance the evm and aclr , while the sub - band dpd concept is specifically targeting only the spurious emissions . in order to further demonstrate the operation of the proposed sub - band dpd solution , we next report results of comprehensive rf measurements using a commercial lte - advanced mobile terminal pa together with a vector signal transceiver ( vst ) , which is implementing the rf modulation and demodulation . the actual sub - band dpd processing and parameter learning algorithms are running on a host processor . the acpm-5002-tr1 mobile power amplifier used in our measurements is designed for lte - a ul band 25 ( 1850 - 1915 mhz ) , with 29 db gain . the national instruments ( ni ) pxie-5645r vst includes both a vector signal generator ( vsg ) , and a vector signal analyzer ( vsa ) with 80 mhz instantaneous bandwidth . in these experiments , the digital baseband waveform is divided into 50 blocks of size @xmath133 samples which are first generated locally on the host processor , and then transferred to the vsg to perform rf i / q modulation at the desired power level at the pa input . the vst rf output is then connected to the input port of the external power amplifier , whose output port is connected to the vst rf input through a 40 db attenuator , implementing the observation receiver as illustrated also in fig . [ fig : measphoto ] . the vsa performs rf i / q demodulation to bring the signal back to baseband . the baseband i / q observation block is then filtered to select the im3 sub - band which is used for block - based sub - band dpd learning , after proper alignment with the locally generated basis functions , as explained in section [ sec : block_based_dpd ] . the sub - band dpd block size @xmath108 used in these experiments is @xmath134 , and the dpd memory depth @xmath84 is @xmath120 . in general , two different intra - band lte - a ca rf measurement examples are demonstrated in this subsection . the first experiment demonstrates the violation of the spurious emission limit due to the inband emission of the im3 + spur , thus not being attenuated by the tx filter . the second experiment demonstrates an own rx desensitization example , in fdd transceiver context , where the im3 + spur is located at the own rx band ( 1930 - 1995 mhz ) and is not sufficiently attenuated by the duplexer tx filter . notice that in principle , when tackling specifically the own rx desensitization problem with the proposed sub - band dpd solution , the main receiver of the fdd device could potentially be used as the observation receiver ( i.e. , learning the sub - band dpd coefficients without an extra auxiliary / observation receiver ) . however , such an approach would indeed be applicable only in the own rx desensitization case , while when mitigating other harmful emissions , an auxiliary observation receiver would anyway have to be adopted . thus , in these rf measurements , we adopt the auxiliary receiver based approach , while consider further developments of the main receiver based parameter learning as an important topic for our future work . [ fig : psd_lab_im3 ] shows the measured power spectral density at the pa output using the im3 sub - band dpd with different orders . the adopted waveform is an intra - band ca lte - a ul signal with 3 mhz per cc and 20 mhz carrier spacing . the power level at the pa output in this example is + 25 dbm . the intermodulation distortion at the im3 + sub - band is emitted inband , since the total tx band covers 1850 - 1915 mhz , and is clearly violating the spurious emission limit ( -30 dbm / mhz ) when no dpd is used . when using the sub - band dpd , the spurious emission level is well below the emission limit , given that at least 5th - order processing is deployed . . notice that there is no need for predistorting the im3- sub - band in this example , since those emissions will be filtered out by the tx filter . [ fig : psd_rxsens_lab ] illustrates another lte - a intra - band ca ul band 25 example , now with 5 mhz cc bandwidths and 40 mhz carrier spacing . the power level at the pa output in this example is + 25 dbm . then , by adopting a ninth - order im3 + sub - band dpd , more than 20 db of spurious emission suppression is achieved , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : psd_rxsens_lab ] . again , two taps ( @xmath129 ) per basis function are used , and block - adaptive parameter learning is deployed . [ fig : dpd_coeff_9th ] shows the real - time convergence of the sub - band dpd coefficients for the third , fifth , seventh , and ninth - order basis functions , respectively . it can be seen that the coefficients converge in a stable manner in a real rf environment due to the orthogonalization of the snl basis functions , as explained in section [ sec : dpd_adaptive_filter ] . per basis function , when the positive im3 sub - band is considered and block - adaptive learning is deployed . an rf measurement example with two 5 mhz lte - a ul ccs and 40 mhz carrier spacing is used with a real commercial mobile pa operating at + 25 dbm.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] . this is 25 db above the effective rx noise floor when assuming 9 db ue rx noise figure ( nf ) @xcite . this would thus cause significant own receiver desensitization that could lead to a complete blocking of the desired rx signal . on the other hand , when the proposed im3 + sub - band dpd is deployed , the integrated power of the im3 + spur at the rx band will be approximately -95 dbm/5mhz , which is only 3 db above the effective rx noise floor , as shown also in fig . [ fig : im3_pwr_rxband ] . though the residual spur is still slightly above the effective rx noise floor , the sensitivity degradation is substantially relaxed , despite operating at a maximum pa output power of + 25 dbm . we elaborate on this further in fig . [ fig : im3_pwr_rxband ] , showing the integrated power of the im3 + spur at the rx lna input while changing the pa output power level . with a ninth order sub - band dpd , we can transmit up to + 18 dbm pa output power with an effectively perfectly linear tx , in terms of im3 + spur level , compared to + 10 dbm pa output power without dpd . additionally , with dpd , the integrated im3 + power is less than the effective rx noise floor up to + 23 dbm pa output power , while without dpd it is already 20 db above the noise floor at the same power level . in this article , a novel low - complexity sub - band digital predistortion ( dpd ) solution was proposed for suppressing unwanted spurious emissions in non - contiguous spectrum access . novel decorrelation based adaptive parameter learning methods were also formulated , allowing efficient estimation and tracking with low computational complexity . all algorithm derivations and modeling were carried out in the general case of having memory in the pa as well as in the sub - band dpd processing . different nonlinear distortion and processing orders , beyond classical third - order cases , were also reported . the proposed technique can find application in suppressing inband spurs which would violate the spurious emission limit , suppressing out - of - band spurs falling , e.g. , on the own receiver band , or in protecting primary user transmissions in cognitive radio systems . a quantitative complexity analysis was presented , comparing the proposed solution to conventional full - band dpd solutions available in the literature . the performance was evaluated in a comprehensive manner , showing excellent linearization performance despite the considerably reduced complexity compared to classical full - band solutions . finally , extensive rf measurement results using a commercial lte - advanced mobile power amplifier were reported , evidencing up to 22 db suppression of the most problematic third - order spurious emissions . here , we derive the analytical minimum mean - square error solution shown in ( 32 ) , which is used as a reference solution in simulations in section [ sec : analytical_sim ] . we first define the so - called error signal as @xmath59 , since with ideal predistortion the im3 + sub - band signal would be zero , and thus the optimization means minimizing the power of this error signal . from ( [ eq : thirdorderanalysis ] ) , the error signal reads @xmath135 where @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the third - order memoryless pa model parameters , @xmath53 denotes the dpd coefficient to be optimized , and @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the baseband equivalents of the two component carriers . the statistical expectation @xmath60={{\rm i\kern-.3em e}}[e(n)e^*(n)]$ ] , assuming that the component carrier signals @xmath6 and @xmath7 are statistically independent , and ignoring some high - order vanishingly small terms , then reads @xmath136 = { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{42 } \left[|f_3|^2 + |f_1|^2|\alpha|^2 + \alpha f_1 f_3^ * + \alpha^ * f_1^ * f_3 \right ] \nonumber\\ & + ( 2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{62 } + 2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{44 } ) \left[|f_3|^2 ( \alpha + \alpha^ * ) + |\alpha|^2(f_1 f_3^ * + f_1^ * f_3 ) \right ] \nonumber\\ & + ( 4 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{46 } + 8 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{64 } + 4 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{82 } ) |f_3|^2 |\alpha|^2 , \label{eq : meansquarederror}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath62 is used as a shorthand notation for @xmath63 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}[|x_2|^j]$ ] . now , differentiating ( [ eq : meansquarederror ] ) with respect to @xmath53 , yields @xmath137 & = { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{42}\left[\alpha^ * |f_1|^2 + f_1 f_3^ * \right ] \nonumber\\ & + ( 2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{62 } + 2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{44 } ) \left[|f_3|^2 + \alpha^ * ( f_1 f_3^ * + f_1^ * f_3 ) \right ] \nonumber\\ & + ( 4 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{46 } + 8 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{64 } + 4 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{82 } ) |f_3|^2 \alpha^*. \label{eq : meansquarederrordiff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , setting ( [ eq : meansquarederrordiff ] ) to zero and solving for @xmath53 yields the optimal mmse dpd parameter , given by @xmath61^*}{\left[|f_1|^2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{42 } + 4 \mathbb{r}(f_1 f_3^*)({{\rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{62 } + { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{44 } ) + 4 |f_3|^2 ( { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{46 } + 2 { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{64 } + { { \rm i\kern-.3em e}}_{82})\right]^*},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath138 denotes the real - part operator . this concludes the proof . here , we derive the @xmath139 order inverse solution for the im3 + sub - band dpd , to be used as a reference solution in the simulations in section [ sec : inv_vs_decorr_sim ] . the output of a memoryless @xmath139 order polynomial pa model is @xmath140 where @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath141 are the polynomial coefficients , and @xmath142 is the composite baseband equivalent input signal , as given in ( [ eq : pa_in ] ) . through direct substitution of ( [ eq : pa_in ] ) in ( [ eq : pa_5th_nomem ] ) , the baseband equivalent im3 + distortion term , located at three times the if frequency , can be extracted and reads @xmath143 stemming from the signal structure in ( [ eq : im3_out_5th_nomem ] ) , the sub - band dpd injection signal is composed of three basis functions of the form @xmath144 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 . in case of fifth - order inverse based sub - band dpd , these basis functions are multiplied by proper coefficients such that all the distortion terms at the im3 + sub - band at the pa output , up to order five , are cancelled . thus , incorporating such dpd processing , yet with arbitrary coefficients , the composite baseband equivalent pa input signal reads @xmath147 where the subscript @xmath148 in the coefficients is emphasizing the @xmath4-order inverse based solution . substituting ( [ eq : pa_in_fifthdpd ] ) in ( [ eq : pa_5th_nomem ] ) , and extracting the third and fifth order im3 + terms , yields r4 - 124353 , non - contiguous intraband unwanted emission . , 3gpp tech . , feb . 2013 . h. gandhi , d. greenstreet , and j. quintal , `` digital radio front - end strategies provide game - changing benefits for small cell base stations , '' tech . texas instruments , may 2013 . l. guan and a. zhu , `` green communications : digital predistortion for wideband rf power amplifiers , '' , vol . 15 , no . 7 , pp . 8489 , dec . r4 - 123797 , `` ue reference sensitivity requirements with two ul carriers . , '' 3gpp tech . , feb . 2013 . . chao yu , wenhui cao , yan guo , and a. zhu , `` digital compensation for transmitter leakage in non - contiguous carrier aggregation applications with fpga implementation , '' , vol . 43064318 , dec 2015 . a. kiayani , m. abdelaziz , l. anttila , v. lehtinen , and m. valkama , `` digital mitigation of transmitter - induced receiver desensitization in carrier aggregation fdd transceivers , '' , vol . 11 , pp . 36083623 , nov 2015 . bassam , f.m . ghannouchi , and m. helaoui , `` 2-d digital predistortion ( 2-d - dpd ) architecture for concurrent dual - band transmitters , '' , vol . 10 , pp . 25472553 , oct . p. roblin , c. quindroit , n. naraharisetti , s. gheitanchi , and m. fitton , `` concurrent linearization , '' , vol . 14 , no . 7 , pp . 7591 , nov . y. liu , j. yan , and p. asbeck , `` concurrent dual - band digital predistortion with a single feedback loop , '' , vol . 5 , pp . 15561568 , may 2015 . p. roblin , s. k. myoung , d. chaillot , y. g. kim , a. fathimulla , j. strahler , and s. bibyk , `` frequency - selective predistortion linearization of rf power amplifiers , '' , vol . 1 , pp . 6576 , jan . 2008 . j. kim , p. roblin , d. chaillot , and z. xie , `` a generalized architecture for the frequency - selective digital predistortion linearization technique , '' , vol . 1 , pp . 596605 , jan . bassam , m. helaoui , and f.m . ghannouchi , `` channel - selective multi - cell digital predistorter for multi - carrier transmitters , '' , vol . 60 , no . 8 , pp . 23442352 , m. abdelaziz , l. anttila , a. mohammadi , f. ghannouchi , and m. valkama , `` reduced - complexity power amplifier linearization for carrier aggregation mobile transceivers , '' in _ ieee international conference on acoustics , speech , and signal processing _ , pp . 39083912 , may 2014 . m. abdelaziz , l. anttila , j.r . cavallaro , s. bhattacharyya , a. mohammadi , f.m . ghannouchi , m. juntti , and m. valkama , `` low - complexity digital predistortion for reducing power amplifier spurious emissions in spectrally - agile flexible radio , '' in _ 9th international conference on cognitive radio oriented wireless networks _ , pp . 323328 , june 2014 . tehrani , h. cao , s. afsardoost , t. eriksson , m. isaksson , and c. fager , `` a comparative analysis of the complexity / accuracy tradeoff in power amplifier behavioral models , '' , vol . 58 , no . 6 , pp . 15101520 , june 2010 . mahmoud abdelaziz ( s13 ) received the b.sc . degree ( with honors ) and m.sc . degree in electronics and electrical communications engineering from cairo university , egypt , in 2006 and 2011 . he is currently pursuing the doctoral degree at tampere university of technology , finland where he works as a researcher with the department of electronics and communications . from 2007 to 2012 he has been working as a communication systems and signal processing engineer at newport media , as well as other companies in the wireless industry . his research interests include statistical and adaptive signal processing in flexible radio transceivers , wideband digital pre - distortion , and cognitive radio systems . lauri anttila ( s06 , m11 ) received the m.sc . degree and d.sc . ( tech ) degree ( with honors ) in electrical engineering from tampere university of technology ( tut ) , tampere , finland , in 2004 and 2011 . currently , he is a senior research fellow at the department of electronics and communications engineering at tut . his research interests are in signal processing for wireless communications , in particular radio implementation challenges in 5 g cellular radio and full - duplex radio , flexible duplexing techniques , and transmitter and receiver linearization . he has co - authored over 60 peer reviewed articles in these areas , as well as two book chapters . chance tarver received a b.s . degree in electrical engineering from louisiana tech university , ruston , la , in 2014 , and his m.s . degree in electrical and computer engineering in 2016 from rice university , houston , tx . he is currently a ph.d . student in the department of electrical and computer engineering at rice university . his research interests include software defined radio and signal processing for wireless communications . kaipeng li ( s14 ) received his b.s . degree in physics from nanjing university , nanjing , china , in 2013 , and his m.s . degree in electrical and computer engineering from rice university in 2015 . he is currently a ph.d . candidate in the department of electrical and computer engineering at rice university , houston , texas . his research interests include digital signal processing , parallel computing on gpgpu and multicore cpu , software - defined radios and massive mimo systems . joseph r. cavallaro ( s78 , m82 , sm05 , f15 ) received the b.s . degree from the university of pennsylvania , philadelphia , pa , in 1981 , the m.s . degree from princeton university , princeton , nj , in 1982 , and the ph.d . degree from cornell university , ithaca , ny , in 1988 , all in electrical engineering . from 1981 to 1983 , he was with at@xmath151 t bell laboratories , holmdel , nj . in 1988 , he joined the faculty of rice university , houston , tx , where he is currently a professor of electrical and computer engineering . his research interests include computer arithmetic , and dsp , gpu , fpga , and vlsi architectures for applications in wireless communications . during the 1996 - 1997 academic year , he served at the national science foundation as director of the prototyping tools and methodology program . he was a nokia foundation fellow and a visiting professor at the university of oulu , finland in 2005 and continues his affiliation there as an adjunct professor . he is currently the director of the center for multimedia communication at rice university . he is a fellow of the ieee and a member of the ieee sps tc on design and implementation of signal processing systems and the chair - elect of the ieee cas tc on circuits and systems for communications . he is currently an associate editor of the ieee transactions on signal processing , the ieee signal processing letters , and the journal of signal processing systems . he was co - chair of the 2004 signal processing for communications symposium at the ieee global communications conference and general / program co - chair of the 2003 , 2004 , and 2011 ieee international conference on application - specific systems , architectures and processors ( asap ) , general / program co - chair for the 2012 , 2014 acm / ieee glsvlsi , finance chair for the 2013 ieee globalsip conference , and tpc co - chair of the 2016 ieee sips workshop . he was a member of the ieee cas society board of governors during 2014 . mikko valkama ( s00 , m01 , sm15 ) was born in pirkkala , finland , on november 27 , 1975 . he received the m.sc . and ph.d . degrees ( both with honors ) in electrical engineering ( ee ) from tampere university of technology ( tut ) , finland , in 2000 and 2001 , respectively . in 2002 , he received the best ph.d . thesis -award by the finnish academy of science and letters for his dissertation entitled `` advanced i / q signal processing for wideband receivers : models and algorithms '' . in 2003 , he was working as a visiting researcher with the communications systems and signal processing institute at sdsu , san diego , ca . currently , he is a full professor and department vice - head at the department of electronics and communications engineering at tut , finland . his general research interests include communications signal processing , estimation and detection techniques , signal processing algorithms for software defined flexible radios , cognitive radio , full - duplex radio , radio localization , 5 g mobile cellular radio , digital transmission techniques such as different variants of multicarrier modulation methods and ofdm , and radio resource management for ad - hoc and mobile networks . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in this paper , we make some progress on a problem that has essentially been open since 1902 @xcite . it is well known that for each monic polynomial @xmath3 one can construct a matrix @xmath4 , such that @xmath5 . one of the options is a companion matrix ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath6.\ ] ] thus , we can numerically compute the zeros of the polynomial @xmath7 as eigenvalues of the corresponding companion matrix @xmath8 using tools from numerical linear algebra . this approach is used in many numerical packages , for instance in the ` roots ` command in matlab @xcite . the aim of this paper is to find a similar elegant tool for finding the zeros of a system of two bivariate polynomials of degree @xmath1 @xmath9 an approach analogous to the univariate case would be to construct matrices @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 of size @xmath16 such that @xmath17 \det(a_2+x b_2 + y c_2)&=q(x , y ) . \end{split}\ ] ] this would give an equivalent two - parameter eigenvalue problem @xcite @xmath18 ( a_2+x b_2 + y c_2 ) \ , u_2&=0 \end{split}\ ] ] that could be solved by the standard tools like the qz algorithm , see @xcite for details . this idea looks promising , but there are many obstacles on the way to a working numerical algorithm that could be applied to a system of bivariate polynomials . although it is known for _ more than a century _ @xcite that such matrices of size @xmath19 exist , so far there are no efficient numerical algorithms that can construct them . even worse , it seems that the construction of such matrices might be an even harder problem than finding zeros of polynomials @xmath7 and @xmath20 . there exist simple and fast constructions @xcite that build matrices of size @xmath21 that satisfy ( [ eq : detrep ] ) , where the resulting two - parameter eigenvalue problem ( [ eq : twopar ] ) is singular ; we will discuss more details in section [ sec : multipar ] . recent results @xcite show that it is possible to solve singular two - parameter eigenvalue problems numerically for small to medium - sized matrices . however , the @xmath21 size of the matrices pushes the complexity of the algorithm to the enormous @xmath22 and it is reported in @xcite that this approach to compute zeros is competitive only for polynomials of degree @xmath23 . the construction of @xcite yields matrices that are of asymptotic order @xmath24 , while those of @xcite are of asymptotic order @xmath25 . in this paper we give two new representations . the first one uses the tree structure of monomials in @xmath26 and @xmath27 . the resulting matrices are smaller than those of @xcite , with the same asymptotic order @xmath25 . this representation can be used for bivariate polynomials as well as for polynomial multiparameter eigenvalue problems @xcite ; that is , for polynomials with matrix coefficients . the second representation is even more condensed , with asymptotic order @xmath28 , and can be applied to scalar bivariate polynomials . although the size of the matrices asymptotically still grows quadratically with @xmath1 , the smaller size renders this approach attractive for polynomials of degree @xmath29 , or for larger @xmath1 if the polynomials have only few terms . this already is an interesting size for a practical use and might trigger additional interest in such methods that could culminate in even more efficient representations . moreover , as we will see , for modest @xmath1 , the order of the matrices is only roughly @xmath30 . furthermore , for polynomials of degree 3 , we present a construction of matrices of order ( exactly ) 3 . there are other ways to study a system of polynomials as an eigenvalue problems , see , e.g. , @xcite and @xcite , but they involve more symbolic computation . in @xcite an algorithm is proposed that only requires to solve linear systems and check rank conditions , which are similar tools that we use in the staircase method @xcite to solve the obtained singular two - parameter eigenvalue problem . of course , there are many numerical methods that can be applied to systems of bivariate polynomials , two main approaches are the homotopy continuation and the resultant method , see , e.g. , @xcite and the references therein . there are also many methods which aim to compute only real solutions of a system of two real bivariate polynomials , see , e.g. , @xcite . we compare our method with two existing approaches , mathematica s nsolve @xcite and phcpack @xcite in section [ sec : numex ] , and show that our approach is competitive for polynomials up to degree @xmath31 . let us mention that another advantage of writing the system of bivariate polynomials as a two - parameter eigenvalue problem is that then we can apply iterative subspace numerical methods such as the jacobi davidson method and compute just a small part of zeros close to a given target @xmath32 @xcite ; we will not pursue this approach in this paper . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : motiv ] we give some applications where bivariate polynomial systems have to be solved . in section [ sec : detrep ] we introduce determinantal representations . section [ sec : multipar ] focuses on two - parameter eigenvalue problems . in section [ sec : lin1 ] we give a determinantal representation that is based on the `` tree '' of monomials , involves no computation , and is suitable for both scalar and matrix polynomials . the matrices of the resulting representation are asymptotically of order @xmath25 . in section [ sec : lin2 ] we give a representation with smaller matrices , of asymptotic order @xmath28 , that involves just a trivial amount of numerical computation ( such as computing roots of low - degree univariate polynomials ) and can be computed very efficiently . this representation may be used for scalar polynomials . we end with some numerical experiments in section [ sec : numex ] and conclusions in section [ sec : conc ] . in delay differential equations , determining critical delays in the case of so - called commensurate delays may lead to a problem of type @xcite . the simplest example is of the form @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the delay ; asked are values of @xmath35 that results in periodic solutions . this yields @xmath7 and @xmath20 of degrees 2 and 3 , respectively . more delay terms with delays that are multiples of @xmath35 gives polynomials of higher degree . polynomial systems of form arise in numerous applications and fields , such as signal processing @xcite and robotics @xcite . in computer aided design , one may be interested in the intersections of algebraic curves , such as ellipses @xcite . in two - dimensional subspace minimization @xcite , such as polynomial tensor optimization , one is interested in two - dimensional searches @xmath36 , where @xmath37 , @xmath26 is the current point , and @xmath38 and @xmath39 are search directions ; see @xcite and the references therein . in systems and control the first - order conditions of the @xmath40-approximation problem of minimizing @xmath41 , for a given impulse response @xmath42 of degree @xmath1 , and @xmath43 , lead to a system of type @xcite . when considering quadratic eigenvalue problems in numerical linear algebra , it is of interest to determine @xmath44 , as an approximate eigenvalue for a given approximate eigenvector @xmath45 , which gives a system of degree 3 in the real and imaginary part of @xmath46 ( * ? ? ? generalizations to polynomial eigenvalue problems give rise to polynomials @xmath7 and @xmath20 of higher degree . also , there has been some recent interest in this problem in the context of the chebfun2 project @xcite . in chebfun2 , nonlinear real bivariate functions are approximated by bivariate polynomials , so solving is relevant for finding zeros of systems of real nonlinear bivariate functions and for finding local extrema of such functions . in this section we introduce determinantal representations and present some existing constructions . the difference between what should theoretically be possible and what can be done in practice is huge . the algorithms we propose reduce the difference only by a small ( but still significant ) factor ; there seems to be plenty of room for future improvements . we say that a bivariate polynomial @xmath47 has degree @xmath1 if all its monomials @xmath48 have total degree less or equal to @xmath1 , i.e. , @xmath49 , and if at least one of the monomials has total degree equal to @xmath1 . we say that the square @xmath50 matrices @xmath51 , and @xmath52 form a _ determinantal representation _ of the polynomial @xmath7 if @xmath53 . as our motivation is to use eigenvalue methods to solve polynomial systems , we will , instead of determinantal representation , often use the term _ linearization _ since a determinantal representation transforms an eigenvalue problem that involves polynomials of degree @xmath1 into a linear eigenvalue problem . a definition of linearization that extends that for the univariate case ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) is the following . a linear bivariate pencil @xmath54 of size @xmath50 is a linearization of the polynomial @xmath47 if there exist two polynomial matrices @xmath55 and @xmath56 such that @xmath57 and @xmath58.\ ] ] we are interested not only in linearizations of scalar polynomials but also in linearizations of matrix bivariate polynomials of the form ( cf . ) @xmath59 where the @xmath60 are @xmath61 matrices . in line with the above , a linear pencil @xmath62 of matrices of size @xmath50 presents a linearization ( determinantal representation ) of the matrix polynomial @xmath63 if there exist two polynomial matrices @xmath55 and @xmath56 such that @xmath57 and @xmath64.\ ] ] in this case @xmath65 . each linearization of a matrix polynomial gives a linearization for a scalar polynomial , as we can think of scalars as of @xmath66 matrices ; the opposite is not true in general . dixon @xcite showed that for every scalar bivariate polynomial @xmath47 of degree @xmath1 there exists a determinantal representation with symmetric matrices of size @xmath16 . dickson @xcite later showed that this result can not be extended to general polynomials in more than two variables , except for three variables and polynomials of degree two and three , and four variables and polynomials of degree two . although they both give constructive proofs , there does not seem to exist an efficient numerical algorithm to construct the determinantal representation with matrices of size @xmath16 for a given bivariate polynomial of degree @xmath1 . in recent years , the research in determinantal representations is growing , as determinantal representations for a particular subset of polynomials , _ real zero polynomials _ , are related to linear matrix inequality ( lmi ) constraints used in semidefinite programming sdp . for an overview see , e.g. , @xcite ; here we give just the essentials for bivariate polynomials that are related to our problem . we say that a real polynomial @xmath47 satisfies the _ real zero condition _ with respect to @xmath67 if for all @xmath68 the univariate polynomial @xmath69 has only real zeros . a two - dimensional _ lmi set _ is defined as @xmath70 where @xmath51 , and @xmath52 are symmetric matrices of size @xmath50 and @xmath71 stands for positive semidefinite . in sdp we are interested in convex sets @xmath72 that admit an lmi representation , i.e. , @xmath73 is an lmi set for certain matrices @xmath51 and @xmath52 . such sets are called _ spectrahedra _ and helton and vinnikov @xcite showed that such @xmath73 must be an algebraic interior , whose minimal defining polynomial @xmath7 satisfies the real zero condition with respect to any point in the interior of @xmath73 . their results state that if a polynomial @xmath47 of degree @xmath1 satisfies real zero condition with respect to @xmath32 , then there exist symmetric matrices @xmath51 , and @xmath52 of size @xmath16 such that @xmath74 and @xmath75 . matrices @xmath51 , and @xmath52 thus form a particular determinantal representation for @xmath7 . the problem of constructing an lmi representation with symmetric or hermitian matrices @xmath76 and @xmath52 for a given spectrahedron @xmath73 raised much more interest than the related problem of generating a determinantal representation for a generic bivariate polynomial . there exist procedures , which rely heavily on slow symbolic computation or other expensive steps , that return an lmi representation with hermitian matrices for a given spectrahedron , but they are not efficient enough . for instance , a method from @xcite , based on the proof from @xcite , does return @xmath16 matrices for a polynomial of degree @xmath1 , but the reported times ( 10 seconds for a polynomial of degree 10 ) show that it is much too slow for our purpose . as a first step of the above method is to find zeros of a system of bivariate polynomials of degree @xmath1 and @xmath77 , this clearly can not be efficient enough for our needs . in addition , we are interested in determinantal representations for polynomials that do not necessary satisfy the real zero condition . in sdp and lmi the matrices have to be symmetric or hermitian , which is not required in our case . we need a simple and fast numerical construction of matrices that satisfy ( [ eq : detrep ] ) and are as small as possible ideally their size should increase linearly and not quadratically with @xmath1 . if we look at the available determinantal representations for generic bivariate polynomials , we first have the linearization by khazanov with matrices of size @xmath78 @xcite . in ( * appendix ) , a smaller linearization for bivariate matrix polynomials is given with block matrices of order @xmath79 . the linearization uses all monomials of degree up to @xmath77 and contains a direct expression for the matrices @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath52 such that @xmath82 . similar to @xcite , it can be applied to matrix polynomials . we give an example for a general matrix polynomial of degree @xmath83 , from which it is possible to deduce the construction for a generic degree . this linearization will be superseded in section [ sec : lin1 ] by a more economical one . [ ex : lin0 ] ( * ? ? ? * appendix ) we take a matrix bivariate polynomial of degree @xmath83 @xmath84 if @xmath45 is a nonzero vector , then @xmath85 if and only if @xmath86 , where @xmath87}\ ] ] and @xmath88^t.\ ] ] we have @xmath89 and @xmath90 is a linearization of @xmath63 . we remark that quarez @xcite also gives explicit expressions for determinantal representations . he is interested in symmetric representations and is able to construct , for a bivariate polynomial of degree @xmath1 such that @xmath91 , a linearization with symmetric matrices of size @xmath92 , where @xmath93 this has asymptotically the same order as the linearization that we give in section [ sec : lin1 ] . let us also remark that in the phase , when we are solving a two - parameter eigenvalue problem to compute the zeros of a system of two bivariate polynomials , we can not exploit the fact that the matrices are symmetric , so this is not important for our application . there are some other available tools , for instance it is possible to construct a determinantal representation using the package ncalgebra @xcite for noncommutative algebra that runs in mathematica @xcite , but this does not give satisfactory results for our application as the matrices that we can construct have smaller size . in this section we briefly present the two - parameter eigenvalue problem and the available numerical methods . a motivation for the search for small determinantal representations is that if we transform a system of bivariate polynomials into an eigenvalue problem , then we can apply existing numerical methods for such problems . a _ two - parameter eigenvalue problem _ has the form where @xmath94 , and @xmath95 are given @xmath96 complex matrices . we are looking for @xmath97 and nonzero vectors @xmath98 , @xmath99 , such that ( [ eq : twopar ] ) is satisfied . in such case we say that a pair @xmath100 is an eigenvalue and the tensor product @xmath101 is the corresponding eigenvector . if we introduce the so - called operator determinants , the matrices @xmath102 then the problem ( [ eq : twopar ] ) is related to a coupled pair of generalized eigenvalue problems @xmath103 \label{drugi}\\[-1.5ex ] \delta_2 \ , w&=y \ \delta_0 \ , w\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for a decomposable tensor @xmath104 . if @xmath105 is nonsingular , then atkinson @xcite showed that the solutions of ( [ eq : twopar ] ) and ( [ drugi ] ) agree and the matrices @xmath106 and @xmath107 commute . in the nonsingular case the two - parameter problem ( [ eq : twopar ] ) has @xmath108 eigenvalues and we can numerically solve it with a variant of the qz algorithm on ( [ drugi ] ) from @xcite . ideally , if we could construct a determinantal representation with matrices @xmath19 for a bivariate polynomial of degree @xmath1 , this would be the method that we would apply on the `` companion '' two - parameter eigenvalue problem to get the zeros of the polynomial system . as matrices @xmath109 , and @xmath110 have size @xmath111 , the computation of all eigenvalues of a nonsingular two - parameter eigenvalue problem has time complexity @xmath112 , which would lead to @xmath113 algorithm for a system of bivariate polynomials . of course , for this approach we need a construction of a determinantal representation with matrices @xmath16 that should not be more computationally expensive than the effort to solve a two - parameter eigenvalue problem . unfortunately , all practical constructions for determinantal representations ( including the two presented in this paper ) return matrices that are much larger than @xmath16 . if we have a determinantal representation with matrices larger than the degree of the polynomial , then the corresponding two - parameter eigenvalue problem is singular , which means that both matrix pencils ( [ drugi ] ) are singular , and we are dealing with a more difficult problem . there exists a numerical method from @xcite that computes the regular eigenvalues of ( [ eq : twopar ] ) from the common regular part of ( [ drugi ] ) . for the generic singular case it is shown in @xcite that the regular eigenvalues of ( [ eq : twopar ] ) and ( [ drugi ] ) do agree . for other types of singular two - parameter eigenvalue problems the relation between the regular eigenvalues of ( [ eq : twopar ] ) and ( [ drugi ] ) is not completely known , but the numerical examples indicate that the method from @xcite can be successfully applied to such problems as well . however , the numerical method , which is a variant of a staircase algorithm @xcite , has to make a lot of decisions on the numerical rank and a single inaccurate decision can cause the method to fail . as the size of the matrices increases , the gaps between singular values may numerically disappear and it may be difficult to solve the problem . this is not the only issue that prevents the use of determinantal representations to solve a bivariate system . the algorithm for the singular two - parameter eigenvalue problems still has complexity @xmath112 , but the fast determinantal representations that we are aware of return matrices of size @xmath21 instead of @xmath114 . this is what pushes the overall complexity to @xmath22 and makes this approach efficient only for polynomials of small degree . nonetheless , at complexity so high , each construction that gives a smaller determinantal representation can make a change . in view of this , we propose two new linearizations in the next two sections . we are interested in linearizations of the matrix polynomial @xmath115 of degree @xmath1 , where @xmath60 are square matrices . our goal is to find square matrices @xmath51 , and @xmath52 as small as possible such that @xmath116 . also , we need a relation that @xmath85 if and only if @xmath117 , where @xmath118 is a tensor product of @xmath45 and a polynomial of @xmath26 and @xmath27 . the linearization in this section also applies to scalar bivariate polynomials , where all matrices are @xmath66 and @xmath119 . in section [ sec : detrep ] we have given a linearization with block matrices of order @xmath79 . we can view this linearization in the following way . if @xmath85 for @xmath120 , then @xmath121 , where the vector @xmath118 has the form @xmath122^t.\ ] ] this means that @xmath118 always begins with the initial block @xmath45 and then contains all blocks of the form @xmath123 where @xmath124 . to simplify the presentation we will usually omit @xmath45 when referring to the blocks of the vector ( [ eq : blockvec ] ) . the blocks are ordered in the degree negative lexicographic ordering , i.e. , @xmath125 if @xmath126 , or @xmath127 and @xmath128 . the above block structure of vector @xmath118 is defined in the rows of the matrix from the second one to the last one ( see example [ ex : lin0 ] ) . for each block @xmath129 of ( [ eq : blockvec ] ) such that @xmath130 there always exists a preceding block @xmath20 of the grade @xmath131 such that either @xmath132 or @xmath133 ( when @xmath134 and @xmath135 both options are possible ) . suppose that @xmath132 , @xmath136 , and @xmath137 , where function @xmath138 returns the index of a block . then the matrix @xmath139 has block @xmath140 on position @xmath141 and block @xmath142 on position @xmath143 . these are the only nonzero blocks in the block row @xmath144 . a similar construction with @xmath140 replaced by @xmath145 is used in the case @xmath133 . the first block row of the matrix @xmath139 is used to represent the matrix polynomial @xmath63 . one can see that there exist linear pencils @xmath146 , @xmath147 , such that @xmath148 \underline{u},\ ] ] where @xmath149 is the number of blocks in ( [ eq : blockvec ] ) . the pencils in ( [ eq : firstrow ] ) are not unique . for instance , a term @xmath150 of @xmath63 can be represented in one of up to the three possible ways : 1 . if @xmath151 , we can set @xmath152 where @xmath153 , 2 . if @xmath154 , we can set @xmath155 where @xmath156 , 3 . if @xmath157 , we can set @xmath158 where @xmath159 . based on the above discussion we see that not all the blocks in ( [ eq : blockvec ] ) are needed to represent a matrix polynomial @xmath63 . what we need is a minimal set of monomials @xmath160 , where @xmath151 , that is sufficient for a matrix polynomial of degree @xmath1 . we can formulate the problem of finding the smallest possible set for a given polynomial as a graph problem . for the polynomial of degree @xmath161.[fig : graph ] ] we can think about all possible terms @xmath162 , where @xmath151 , as of nodes in a directed graph @xmath163 with the root @xmath164 and a directed edge from node @xmath165 to node @xmath166 if @xmath167 or @xmath168 ( see figure [ fig : graph ] for the case @xmath169 ) . now , we are looking for the smallest connected subgraph @xmath170 with a root @xmath164 that can represent a given polynomial . equivalently , we are looking for a minimal directed rooted tree . let us remember that for each term @xmath171 of the polynomial @xmath63 there are up to three possible nodes in the graph @xmath163 that can be used to represent it . it is sufficient that one of these nodes is in a minimal tree @xmath170 . furthermore , if @xmath172 , then we can assume that we always use a node of degree @xmath131 to represent @xmath171 and then there are only one or two options for a given term . all together , each nonzero term @xmath150 , where @xmath173 , in the polynomial @xmath174 defines one of the following rules for the subgraph @xmath170 : * if @xmath175 then @xmath176 has to be in the subgraph @xmath170 , * if @xmath177 then @xmath178 has to be in the subgraph @xmath170 , * if @xmath154 and @xmath157 then at least one of @xmath179 or @xmath180 has to be in the subgraph @xmath170 . the term @xmath181 can be presented by the root @xmath164 , which is always present in the subgraph @xmath170 . finding a minimal tree for a given polynomial is not an easy problem : it can be formulated as an np - hard directed steiner tree problem ( dst ) ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , where one has a directed graph @xmath182 with nonnegative weights on edges and the goal is to find the minimum weight directed rooted tree that connects all terminals @xmath183 to a given root @xmath184 . suppose that we are looking for a minimal representation tree for a polynomial @xmath63 of degree @xmath1 . in the graph @xmath163 , which contains all nodes @xmath162 for @xmath151 ( see figure [ fig : graph ] for the case @xmath169 ) , we put weight @xmath164 on all directed @xmath26 and @xmath27 edges . now we add a new vertex for each monomial @xmath162 that is present in @xmath63 and connect it with zero weight edges from all possible nodes in @xmath163 that could be used to represent the monomial in the linearization . we make a dst problem by taking node @xmath164 as a root and all newly added vertices as terminals . from a solution of the dst problem the minimal representation tree can be recovered . although this is an np - hard problem , there exist some polynomial time approximation algorithms that give a solution close to the optimal one and could be used to construct a small determinantal representation for a given polynomial with small number of nonzero terms . for the latest available algorithms , see , e.g. , @xcite and the references therein . [ ex : minlin ] we are interested in a minimal tree for the matrix polynomial @xmath185 nonzero terms in ( [ eq : pol6 ] ) define the nodes that have to be present in the minimal subgraph . they are either strictly defined as are the nodes @xmath164 , @xmath186 , and @xmath187 , or come in pairs where at least one element of each pair has to be present in the subgraph . such pairs are @xmath188 , and @xmath189 . the situation is presented in figure [ fig : graphex ] , where nodes and pairs , such that either left or right node has to be included , are shadowed green . the nodes of the minimal connected subgraph that includes all required nodes are colored red . in a dst formulation each green shadow presents a terminal linked by zero weight edges to one or two nodes that are included in the region . on all other edges we put weight 1 and then search for the minimum weight directed rooted tree that connects all terminals to the root @xmath164 . for the matrix polynomial ( [ eq : pol6 ] ) of degree @xmath190.[fig : graphex ] ] matrix polynomial ( [ eq : pol6 ] ) can thus be represented with matrices of block size @xmath191 . if we order the nodes of the subgraph in the degree negative lexicographic ordering , then @xmath192 has the form @xmath193^t\ ] ] and a possible first block row of @xmath62 has the form @xmath194.\ ] ] in the subsequent block rows , the matrix @xmath62 has only 20 nonzero blocks , 10 of them are identity blocks on the main diagonal . the remaining nonzero blocks are @xmath140 on block positions @xmath195 , @xmath196 , @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 , @xmath200 , @xmath201 and blocks @xmath145 on positions @xmath202 . if we have a generic matrix polynomial @xmath63 , whose terms are all nonzero , then it is easy to see that the subgraph that contains all terms @xmath162 , where @xmath151 and either @xmath175 or @xmath203 is even , is minimal . the detailed situation for the case @xmath204 is presented in figure [ fig : mingraph ] , and representation trees for polynomials of degree from 1 to 8 are presented in figure [ fig : lin1first8 ] . counting the number of nodes in the tree gives the following result @xmath205 if we compare this with the linearization from example [ ex : lin0 ] that has matrices of block size @xmath79 , we see that the new linearization uses matrices of roughly half size . the size of the matrices is also smaller than ( [ eq : quarez ] ) from @xcite , which has the same asymptotic order . for a generic polynomial of degree @xmath161.[fig : mingraph ] ] = [ circle , draw , fill = blue!40 , inner sep=0pt , minimum size=5pt , node distance=0.35 cm ] \(00 ) ; ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 50 ) [ below left of=40 ] ; ( 60 ) [ below left of=50 ] ; ( 70 ) [ below left of=60 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 32 ) [ below left of=22 ] ; ( 42 ) [ below left of=32 ] ; ( 52 ) [ below left of=42 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 04 ) [ below right of=03 ] ; ( 05 ) [ below right of=04 ] ; ( 06 ) [ below right of=05 ] ; ( 16 ) [ below left of=06 ] ; ( 07 ) [ below right of=06 ] ; ( 15 ) [ below left of=04 ] ; ( 25 ) [ below left of=15 ] ; ( 35 ) [ below left of=25 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) to ( 04 ) to ( 05 ) to ( 06 ) to ( 07 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) to ( 50 ) to ( 60 ) to ( 70 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) to ( 32 ) to ( 42 ) to ( 52 ) ; ( 04 ) to ( 15 ) to ( 25 ) to ( 35 ) ; ( 06 ) to ( 16 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 50 ) [ below left of=40 ] ; ( 60 ) [ below left of=50 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 32 ) [ below left of=22 ] ; ( 42 ) [ below left of=32 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 04 ) [ below right of=03 ] ; ( 05 ) [ below right of=04 ] ; ( 06 ) [ below right of=05 ] ; ( 15 ) [ below left of=04 ] ; ( 25 ) [ below left of=15 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) to ( 04 ) to ( 05 ) to ( 06 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) to ( 50 ) to ( 60 ) ; ( 04 ) to ( 15 ) to ( 25 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) to ( 32 ) to ( 42 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 50 ) [ below left of=40 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 32 ) [ below left of=22 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 04 ) [ below right of=03 ] ; ( 14 ) [ below left of=04 ] ; ( 05 ) [ below right of=04 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) to ( 04 ) to ( 05 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) to ( 50 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) to ( 32 ) ; ( 04 ) to ( 14 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 04 ) [ below right of=03 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) to ( 04 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) ; [ thm : one ] we can linearize each matrix polynomial @xmath63 of degree @xmath1 with matrices of block size @xmath206 from ( [ eq : sizeg ] ) using a minimal tree @xmath170 that contains the terms @xmath162 , where @xmath151 and either @xmath175 or @xmath203 is even . we order all nodes of a minimal tree @xmath170 in the degree negative lexicographic ordering and form the block matrix @xmath55 in the following way . all diagonal blocks of @xmath55 are @xmath142 . if a node with index @xmath7 is connected to a node with index @xmath20 with an @xmath26 or @xmath27 edge , then we put @xmath140 or @xmath145 in the block position @xmath207 , respectively . because of the ordering , the matrix @xmath208 is block lower triangular and nonsingular . its inverse @xmath209 is therefore also a lower triangular matrix with diagonal identity blocks . let @xmath210 be the number of nodes in @xmath170 . if follows from @xmath211 that the first block column of @xmath209 has the form @xmath212^t,\ ] ] where @xmath213 is the monomial in the @xmath203th node of @xmath170 for @xmath214 ( @xmath215 ) . now we will construct the linearization of the matrix polynomial @xmath63 . we need a block matrix @xmath216 , whose elements are linear pencils in @xmath26 and @xmath27 . we take @xmath217 and adjust the first block row @xmath218 , where we put linear pencils such that @xmath219^t)=p(x , y).\ ] ] this is always possible as for each term @xmath150 in the polynomial @xmath63 there exists a term @xmath220 in @xmath170 such that @xmath221 is one of the following three options : @xmath222 , @xmath223 , or @xmath224 . the product @xmath225 is an upper block triangular matrix of the form @xmath226,\ ] ] where @xmath227 are matrix polynomials . if we introduce the matrix polynomial @xmath228,\ ] ] then it follows that @xmath229\ ] ] and since @xmath230 , this proves that @xmath216 is indeed a linearization of the matrix polynomial @xmath63 . [ ex::cubic1 ] as an example we consider the scalar bivariate polynomial @xmath231 which was already linearized in @xcite with matrices of size @xmath232 ( we can also get a @xmath232 linearization if we insert the coefficients in matrix ( [ eq : ex2 ] ) of example [ ex : lin0 ] ) . now we can linearize it with matrices of size @xmath233 as @xmath234 , where @xmath235}.\ ] ] in the next section we will further reduce the size of the matrices to @xmath236 and @xmath237 . we will upgrade the approach from the previous section and produce even smaller representations for scalar polynomials . as before , representations have a form of the directed tree , but instead of using only @xmath26 and @xmath27 , an edge can now be any linear polynomial @xmath238 such that @xmath239 . these additional parameters give us enough freedom to produce smaller representations . the root is still @xmath164 while the other nodes are polynomials in @xmath26 and @xmath27 that are products of all edges on the path from the root to the node . in each node all monomials have the same degree , which is equal to the graph distance to the root . before we continue with the construction , we give a small example to clarify the idea . = [ ellipse , draw , fill = red!20 , font= , text width=4.2em , text centered , rounded corners , minimum width=4.1em , minimum height=1em , node distance=2 cm ] = [ rectangle , draw , fill = red!20 , font= , text width=1.6em , text centered , rounded corners , minimum width=1.6em , minimum height=1.4em , node distance=1.6 cm ] ] [ ex : lin2 ] a linearization of a polynomial of degree @xmath83 with matrices of size @xmath240 is presented in figure [ fig : ex4 ] . let us explain the figure and show how to produce the matrices from the representation tree . the nodes in the representation tree are the following polynomials : @xmath241 q_3(x , y)= ( x+y ) \ , q_2(x , y ) = x^2-y^2 , & & q_4(x , y)= ( 2x - y ) \ , q_1(x , y ) = 2x -y . \end{array}\ ] ] the polynomial of degree @xmath83 is then a linear combination of nodes in the representation tree and coefficients @xmath242 which are polynomials of degree @xmath164 contained in the ellipses . this gives @xmath243 similar as in section [ sec : lin1 ] , we can write the matrices by putting the linear coefficients in the first row and relations between the polynomials @xmath244 to @xmath245 in the subsequent rows . for each edge of the form @xmath246 we put @xmath247 in the position @xmath248 in the matrix @xmath249 and @xmath164 in the position @xmath250 . in the first row we put @xmath251 in the position @xmath252 if @xmath253 is the linear factor that multiplies the polynomial @xmath254 in the linearization . the matrix @xmath255 that corresponds to figure [ fig : ex4 ] , such that @xmath256 , is @xmath257.\ ] ] 1 . compute @xmath1 zeros @xmath258 of the polynomial @xmath259 . 2 . form a branch of the tree with the root @xmath260 and nodes @xmath261 , where @xmath262 is a successor of @xmath263 and the edge from @xmath263 to @xmath262 contains the factor @xmath264 for @xmath265 . 3 . compute linear coefficients @xmath266 for nodes @xmath267 in the following way : 1 . take @xmath268 , 2 . take @xmath269 , where @xmath270 is a coefficient of @xmath254 at @xmath271 , for @xmath272 , 3 . take @xmath273 . 4 . compute the remainder @xmath274 which has the form @xmath275 , where @xmath276 is a polynomial of degree @xmath277 . if @xmath278 then stop and return the tree . add node @xmath279 and connect it to the root by an edge having the factor @xmath27 . if @xmath276 is a nonzero constant @xmath280 , then use @xmath281 as a coefficient for the node @xmath279 , stop , and return the tree . recursively call the same algorithm to obtain a representation tree with the root @xmath282 for the polynomial @xmath276 . connect @xmath279 to @xmath282 by an edge with a factor @xmath27 and return the tree with the root @xmath283 . in example [ ex : lin2 ] we showed how to construct the bivariate pencil @xmath284 from a representation tree and the corresponding linear coefficients . the outline of an algorithm that constructs a representation tree and the corresponding linear coefficients for a given polynomial @xmath47 is presented in algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] . in the following discussion we give some missing details and show that the algorithm indeed gives a linearization . * the nodes @xmath261 that we construct in step 2 are polynomials of the form @xmath285 for @xmath286 . all monomials in @xmath263 have degree @xmath287 and the leading term is @xmath288 . * each product @xmath289 for @xmath286 is a polynomial with monomials of exact degree @xmath290 , while @xmath291 is a polynomial of degree @xmath164 . the linear factors @xmath292 in step 3 are constructed so that : * * leading two monomials ( @xmath293 and @xmath271 ) of @xmath294 agree with the part @xmath295 of the polynomial @xmath47 for @xmath272 , * * the product @xmath296 agrees with the part of @xmath47 composed of all monomials of degree exactly @xmath1 , * * the product @xmath297 agrees with the part of @xmath47 composed of all monomials of degree up to @xmath164 . + as a result , the remainder in step 4 has the form @xmath298 , where @xmath276 is a polynomial of degree @xmath277 . the situation at the end of step 4 is presented in figure [ fig : lin22 ] . the remainder @xmath299 is a polynomial of the form @xmath300 , where @xmath276 is a polynomial or degree @xmath277.[fig : lin22 ] ] * if the coefficient @xmath301 is zero , then we can apply a linear substitution of @xmath26 and @xmath27 of the form @xmath302 and @xmath303 , where we pick @xmath304 such that @xmath305 this ensures that the substituted polynomial in @xmath306 and @xmath307 will have a nonzero coefficient at @xmath308 . after we complete the representation tree for the substituted polynomial in @xmath306 and @xmath307 , we perform the substitution back to @xmath26 and @xmath27 . * if the polynomial @xmath276 in step 4 is not a constant , then we obtain a representation subtree for @xmath276 by calling recursively the same algorithm . in order to obtain the final representation tree , we then join the existing branch to the representation subtree for the polynomial @xmath276 . we do this by introducing a new node @xmath279 in step 6 that is linked to the root by the edge with the factor @xmath27 . to this new node we link the root @xmath282 of the subtree for the polynomial @xmath276 in step 9 , again using the edge with the factor @xmath27 . as @xmath282 is linked to the root by two edges @xmath27 , this multiplies all nodes in the subtree by @xmath186 and , since the subtree is a representation for @xmath276 , this gives a representation for the remainder @xmath309 from step 4 . the situation after step 9 with the final representation tree for the polynomial @xmath47 is presented in figure [ fig : lin23 ] . ] from the output of algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] , matrices @xmath310 such that @xmath74 can be obtained in the same way as in example [ ex : lin2 ] . let us remark that the zeros @xmath258 in step 1 can be complex , even if polynomial @xmath7 has real coefficients . thus , in a general case a linearization produced by algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] has complex matrices @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . [ ex::pol2 ] we apply algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] on @xmath311 from example [ ex::cubic1 ] . first , we compute the roots @xmath312 of the polynomial @xmath313 . the zeros are ordered so that @xmath314 . in exact computation the order is not important , but in numerical tests we experience better results with this order . this gives the polynomials in the first branch of the representation tree : @xmath315 and we can compute the corresponding coefficients @xmath316 for the remainder @xmath317 we need just one additional node @xmath318 with the coefficient @xmath319 . the determinantal representation with @xmath240 matrices is @xmath320 , where @xmath321},\quad b = { \footnotesize\left[\begin{array}{rrrr } 2 & 4 & 7 & 0\cr -1 & 0 & 0 & 0 \cr 0 & -1 & 0 & 0\cr 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\end{array}\right ] } , \quad \text{and } \\[1 mm ] c & = { \footnotesize \left[\begin{matrix } 3 & 4.9681 + 4.5036i & 7.8882 & 0.88972 + 5.5576i\cr -0.0079857 + 1.1259i & 0 & 0 & 0 \cr 0 & -0.0079857 - 1.1259i & 0 & 0\cr -1 & 0 & 0 & 0\end{matrix}\right]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] = [ circle , draw , fill = blue!40 , inner sep=0pt , minimum size=5pt , node distance=0.35 cm ] \(00 ) ; ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 50 ) [ below left of=40 ] ; ( 60 ) [ below left of=50 ] ; ( 70 ) [ below left of=60 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 32 ) [ below left of=22 ] ; ( 42 ) [ below left of=32 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 04 ) [ below right of=03 ] ; ( 15 ) [ below left of=04 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) to ( 04 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) to ( 50 ) to ( 60 ) to ( 70 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) to ( 32 ) to ( 42 ) ; ( 04 ) to ( 15 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 50 ) [ below left of=40 ] ; ( 60 ) [ below left of=50 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 32 ) [ below left of=22 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ( 04 ) [ below right of=03 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) to ( 04 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) to ( 50 ) to ( 60 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) to ( 32 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 50 ) [ below left of=40 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ( 22 ) [ below left of=12 ] ; ( 03 ) [ below right of=02 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) to ( 03 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) to ( 50 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) to ( 22 ) ; \(00 ) ; ( 10 ) [ below left of=00 ] ; ( 20 ) [ below left of=10 ] ; ( 30 ) [ below left of=20 ] ; ( 40 ) [ below left of=30 ] ; ( 01 ) [ below right of=00 ] ; ( 02 ) [ below right of=01 ] ; ( 12 ) [ below left of=02 ] ; ; ( 00 ) to ( 01 ) to ( 02 ) ; ( 00 ) to ( 10 ) to ( 20 ) to ( 30 ) to ( 40 ) ; ( 02 ) to ( 12 ) ; representation trees for polynomials of degree from 1 to 8 are presented in figure [ fig : small ] . if we compare them to the determinantal representations from section [ sec : lin1 ] in figure [ fig : lin1first8 ] , then we see that representations obtained by algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] are much smaller . the following lemma shows that asymptotically we use @xmath322 fewer nodes than in section [ sec : lin1 ] . algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] returns representation tree @xmath163 for the linearization of a polynomial @xmath47 of degree @xmath1 of size @xmath323 it follows from the recursion in the algorithm ( see figure [ fig : lin23 ] ) that the number of nodes satisfies the recurrence equation @xmath324 the solution of this equation with the initial values @xmath325 , @xmath326 , and @xmath327 is ( [ eq : sizeg2 ] ) . for generic polynomials of degrees @xmath328 and @xmath329 it turns out to be possible to modify the construction and save one node in the representation tree . the main idea is to apply a linear substitution of variables @xmath26 and @xmath27 in the preliminary phase to the polynomial @xmath47 to eliminate some of the terms . this implies that the resulting matrices are of order @xmath83 ( @xmath328 ) and @xmath161 ( @xmath329 ) , instead of order @xmath330 and @xmath190 as seen before and , it also reduces the size of the matrices for @xmath331 and @xmath332 by 1 . we give details in the following two subsections . let us consider a cubic bivariate polynomial @xmath333 , where we can assume that @xmath334 . we introduce a linear substitution of the form @xmath335 and @xmath336 , where @xmath165 is such that @xmath337 and @xmath338 . the substitution is well defined if @xmath165 is a single root of ( [ eq : sc31 ] ) and the only situation , where this is not possible , is when @xmath42 has a triple root . the above substitution transforms @xmath47 into a polynomial @xmath339 such that its coefficients @xmath340 and @xmath341 are both zero . if we apply algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] to @xmath339 and choose @xmath342 for the first zero , then the remainder in step 4 is zero and we get @xmath343 matrices @xmath344 , @xmath345 , and @xmath346 such that @xmath347 . now , it is easy to see that for @xmath348 , @xmath349 , and @xmath350 , @xmath82 . [ ex::pol3 ] we take the recurrent example @xmath311 ( see examples [ ex::cubic1 ] and [ ex::pol2 ] ) . if we take @xmath351 ( see ( [ eq : sc31 ] ) ) and @xmath352 , then substitution @xmath335 and @xmath336 changes @xmath47 into a polynomial @xmath353 algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] gives @xmath343 matrices @xmath344 , @xmath345 , and @xmath346 such that @xmath347 , from which matrices @xmath354,\quad b = { \footnotesize \left[\begin{matrix } 1.5317 & -2.4833 & 7\cr -1 & 0 & 0\cr 0 & -1 & 0\end{matrix}\right ] } , } \quad \text{and } \\[1 mm ] c & = { \footnotesize \left[\begin{matrix } 2.2189 & 2.8587 & 0.00559 + 7.8813i\cr -1.1269 & 0 & 0\cr 0 & -0.0079857 + 1.1259i & 0\end{matrix}\right]}\end{aligned}\ ] ] such that @xmath355 , are obtained and we have a @xmath343 linearization . before we give a construction for a generic quartic bivariate polynomial , let us consider a particular case , when a polynomial @xmath356 of degree 4 is such that @xmath357 . in this case @xmath161 nodes are enough to represent the polynomial @xmath47 . the representation tree for the polynomial @xmath47 is presented in figure [ fig : ex4new ] , where @xmath358 and @xmath359 are the zeros of @xmath360 . of degree 4 such that @xmath357.[fig : ex4new ] ] for a generic quartic polynomial we first transform it into one with zero coefficients at @xmath361 , @xmath362 , @xmath363 , and @xmath364 . except for very special polynomials , we can do this with a combination of two linear substitutions . similar as in case @xmath328 , we first introduce a linear substitution of the form @xmath335 and @xmath336 , where @xmath165 is such that @xmath365 and @xmath366 . the substitution is well defined if @xmath165 is a single root of @xmath367 . after the substitution we have a polynomial @xmath339 such that its coefficients @xmath368 and @xmath340 are both zero . on this polynomial we apply a new substitution @xmath369 and @xmath370 , where @xmath371 and @xmath372 . this substitution is well defined if @xmath45 is a single root of @xmath373 ; therefore , both substitutions exist for a generic polynomial of degree @xmath330 . after the second substitution we get a polynomial @xmath374 such that its coefficients @xmath375 , @xmath376 , @xmath377 , and @xmath378 are all zero . for such polynomial we can construct a representation with matrices @xmath240 as presented in figure [ fig : ex4new ] . this gives @xmath240 matrices @xmath379 , @xmath380 , and @xmath381 such that @xmath382 . finally , if we take @xmath383 then @xmath384 . if we add the constructions from subsections [ ss : case3 ] and [ ss : case4 ] as special cases to algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] , then we save one node for all generic polynomials of degree @xmath385 or @xmath386 . although this advantage seems to be modest , numerical results in the following section point out that for small @xmath1 this does speed up the computation of the zeros considerably ( for instance , for @xmath204 the corresponding @xmath387-matrices are of order @xmath388 instead of @xmath389 ) . determinantal representations from sections [ sec : lin1 ] and [ sec : lin2 ] can be used to numerically solve a system of two bivariate polynomials . we first linearize the problem as a two - parameter eigenvalue problem and then solve it with the method for singular two - parameter eigenvalue problems from @xcite . subsequently , we refine the solutions by two steps of newton s method . we refer to the numerical methods that use linearizations from sections [ sec : lin1 ] and [ sec : lin2 ] as lin1 and lin2 , respectively . in the first example we take polynomials with random coefficients , while the second example considers some challenging benchmark polynomials . [ ex : randtest]we compare lin1 and lin2 to nsolve in mathematica 9 and phclab 1.02 @xcite running phcpack 2.3.84 on systems of full bivariate polynomials of the same degree , whose coefficients are random real numbers uniformly distributed on @xmath390 $ ] or random complex numbers , such that real and imaginary part are both uniformly distributed on @xmath390 $ ] . the results are presented in table [ tbl : one ] . for each @xmath1 we run all methods on the same set of 20 random polynomial systems and measure the average time . lin1 and mathematica s nsolve work faster for polynomials with real coefficients while this does not make a change for lin2 and phclab , therefore , the results in the table for lin2 and phclab are an average of 20 real and 20 complex examples . clearly , if lin1 is applied to a polynomial with real coefficients , then matrices @xmath105 , @xmath391 , and @xmath110 are real . if we apply lin2 then the matrices are complex in general as roots of univariate polynomials are used in the construction . although the complex arithmetic is more expensive than the real one , complex eigenproblems from lin2 are so small that they are solved faster than the larger real problems from lin1 . r|cccccc|rr & & + @xmath1 & lin1 ( @xmath392 ) & lin1 ( @xmath393 ) & lin2 & phclab & nsolve ( @xmath393 ) & nsolve ( @xmath392 ) & lin1 & lin2 + ' '' '' 3 & 0.01 & 20.01 & @xmath394 & 0.18 & 0.25 & 0.04 & 25 & 9 + 4 & 0.02 & 20.02 & 0.01 & 0.21 & 0.42 & 0.07 & 64 & 25 + 5 & 0.03 & 20.05 & 0.02 & 0.26 & 0.67 & 0.17 & 121 & 64 + 6 & 0.08 & 20.18 & 0.05 & 0.34 & 1.04 & 0.22 & 225 & 100 + 7 & 0.23 & 20.57 & 0.16 & 0.44 & 2.75 & 0.61 & 361 & 169 + 8 & 0.67 & 22.04 & 0.54 & 0.59 & 2.17 & 0.88 & 576 & 289 + 9 & 2.25 & 26.21 & 1.33 & 0.80 & 5.53 & 1.48 & 841 & 400 + 10 & 6.24 & 16.62 & 3.38 & 1.05 & 8.12 & 3.85 & 1225 & 576 + computational times for lin1 , lin2 , and phclab are very similar for each of the 20 test problems of the same degree . on the other hand , nsolve needs substantially more time for certain problems . for example , for complex polynomials of degree @xmath395 , nsolve needed approximately @xmath396 for 16 of the 20 examples , and @xmath397 for the additional 4 examples . that explains why the average time for nsolve ( @xmath393 ) is larger in case @xmath395 than in case @xmath398 . beside the computational time , accuracy and reliability are another important factors . nsolve is the only method that finds all solutions in all examples , but on the other hand , the results are on average less accurate than with other methods . as a measure of accuracy we use the maximum value of @xmath399 where @xmath400 is a jacobian matrix of @xmath401 and @xmath402 at @xmath32 , over all computed zeros @xmath32 . @xmath403 is an absolute condition number of a zero @xmath32 and we assume that in random examples all zeros are simple . for a good method ( [ eq : condn ] ) should be as small as possible . for real or complex systems of degree @xmath404 , lin2 is the fastest method and usually the most accurate one . it is never significantly less accurate than the others , so it clearly wins in this case . for real polynomials of degree @xmath398 computational times of all methods are very close . nsolve is the fastest method with a tight margin in 17 out of 20 cases , but is also several orders of magnitude less accurate . phclab is faster and slightly less accurate than lin2 in 5 out of 40 cases , but , in one of them it fails to compute all the solutions . for @xmath405 and @xmath406 phclab becomes the fastest method , but is less reliable . in many cases it does not compute all the solutions . for @xmath405 this happens in 14 out of 40 times and for @xmath406 in @xmath407 out of @xmath408 cases . as phclab is using random initial systems , a possible remedy is to run phclab several times . also lin2 fails to compute solutions for @xmath409 real examples for @xmath406 . a remedy for lin2 in these cases is to interchange variables @xmath26 and @xmath27 . lin1 is competitive in particular for real systems of degree @xmath404 . for @xmath398 it misses one solution in one example and in two examples for @xmath406 we have to adapt the criteria for detecting a numerical rank in the staircase algorithm to get the correct number of solutions . let us remark that each node less in the representation tree really does make a difference . for instance , if we do not apply the special case for @xmath329 in subsection [ ss : case4 ] , then the @xmath387 matrices for lin2 for polynomial systems of degree @xmath406 are of size @xmath410 instead of @xmath411 and the average computational time rises from @xmath412 to @xmath413 . [ ex:25]we test lin1 and lin2 on 25 examples ex001 to ex025 from @xcite . this set contains challenging benchmark problems with polynomials of small degree from @xmath414 to @xmath415 that have many multiple zeros and usually have less solutions than a generic pair of the same degrees . lin1 and lin2 performed satisfactorily on most examples , but , they also failed on some . instead of giving the details for all 25 examples , we give the key observations . * multiple zeros can present a problem for the algorithm from @xcite that is used to solve the projected regular problem @xmath416 , @xmath417 that is obtained from ( [ drugi ] ) by the modified staircase algorithm from @xcite . the qz algorithm is first applied to @xmath416 and then @xmath417 is multiplied by @xmath418 and @xmath419 . the eigenvalues are clustered along the diagonal so that multiple eigenvalues @xmath26 should be in the same block . for several of the 25 examples with eigenvalues of high multiplicity the clustering criteria have to be adapted otherwise the results are not so accurate . * lin2 is faster , but the accuracy can be lost if the polynomial in step 1 of algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] has multiple zeros , an example is @xmath402 from ex008 . the method fails for ex014 , ex018 , and ex020 . * we get very good results in example ex005 with the system @xmath420 and @xmath421 using lin2 . in this case lin2 returns optimal determinantal representations with matrices of size @xmath422 and @xmath423 , respectively . the obtained two - parameter eigenvalue problem is not singular and we get the solutions in @xmath424 , while phclab and nsolve need @xmath425 . for comparison , lin1 , applied to the same problem , returns @xmath387 matrices of size @xmath426 , while lin2 gives @xmath387 matrices of size @xmath427 . * lin1 is slower but can be more accurate . because there is no computation in the construction , no errors are introduced in the construction of the linearization . lin1 manages to solve 22 out of 25 examples ( in some examples the parameters have to be adapted to make it work ) , but fails for ex007 , ex016 , and ex018 . * nsolve always finds all solutions but is slower than lin1 and lin2 except for ex014 where polynomials are of degrees @xmath428 and @xmath429 . phclab usually finds just one instance of a multiple eigenvalue and thus returns much less zeros . [ ex : tri ] encouraged by the good results for ex005 in example [ ex:25 ] , we carry out some experiments with polynomials of form @xmath430 , where @xmath431 is a polynomial of small degree @xmath432 . for such polynomials algorithm [ alg : lin2 ] returns matrices of size @xmath433 or even smaller . for example , it is easy to see that for @xmath434 we get linearization of the smallest possible size @xmath16 . we compared lin2 , phclab , and nsolve . computational times for random polynomials with complex coefficients of the above form are presented in table [ tbl : two ] . as @xmath1 increases , phclab becomes faster then lin2 , but in most cases it does not compute all solutions . for instance , for @xmath435 it misses 16 and 20 zeros for @xmath434 and @xmath436 , respectively . therefore , lin2 might be the preferred method for such polynomial systems . cc|lcc & + @xmath1 & @xmath437 & lin2 & phclab & nsolve + ' '' '' 15 & 1 & 10.48 & 11.9 & 13.7 + 15 & 3 & 10.87 & 11.8 & 14.1 + 20 & 1 & 12.1 & 14.5 & 10.8 + 20 & 3 & 13.8 & 15.0 & 11.3 + 25 & 1 & 19.6 & 10.6 & 25.0 + 25 & 3 & 13.1 & 12.7 & 26.3 + 30 & 1 & 23.2 & 17.4 & 52.8 + 30 & 3 & 37.2 & 20.1 & 55.0 + we have proposed two linearizations for bivariate polynomials . the first linearization does not involve any computation as the coefficients of the polynomials appear as ( block ) coefficients of the matrices @xmath80 , @xmath81 , and @xmath52 . this linearization is suitable for both scalar and matrix bivariate polynomials . the second linearization , useful for scalar polynomials , involves little computation and returns much smaller matrices . they are still larger than the theoretically smallest possible size @xmath16 , but their construction is very simple and fast . moreover , while the asymptotic order is @xmath438 , the order for small @xmath1 is about @xmath30 ; for polynomials of degree 3 and 4 we have presented determinantal representations of order 3 and 5 , respectively . as an application we have presented a method for finding roots of two bivariate polynomials . we show that an approach , where the polynomial system is first linearized into a two - parameter eigenvalue problem , which is later solved by a modified staircase method , is numerically feasible and gives good results for polynomials of degree @xmath29 , as well as for polynomials of higher degree but with few terms . any further results on even smaller determinantal representations that can be efficiently constructed numerically , could enlarge the above degree . * acknowledgment * the research was performed while the first author was visiting the casa group at tu eindhoven . the author wishes to thank the nwo for the visitor s grant and the casa group for the hospitality . , resultant - based methods for plane curves intersection problems , in : proceedings of the 8th international conference on computer algebra in scientific computing , vol . 3718 of lecture notes in computer science , springer - verlag ( 2005 ) 7592 . , phclab : a matlab / octave interface to phcpack . in : m. stillman , j. verschelde , and n. takayama ( eds ) , _ software for algebraic geometry _ , volume 148 of the i m a volumes in mathematics and its applications , springer new york ( 2008 ) 1532 . , a unified approach to computing real and complex zeros of zero - dimensional ideals , in : m. putinar , s. sullivant ( eds . ) , _ emerging applications of algebraic geometry _ , the i m a volumes in mathematics and its applications 149 , springer - verlag , new york ( 2009 ) 125155 . , lmi representations of convex semialgebraic sets and determinantal representations of algebraic hypersurfaces : past , present , and future , in h. dym , m. c. de oliveira , m. putinar ( eds . ) , _ mathematical methods in systems , optimization , and control : festschrift in honor of j. william helton . _ operator theory : advances and applications 222 , birkhuser ( 2012 ) 325349 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: vertex operators are one of the central objects in string theory . they represent cohomology classes of the brst operator . the brst cohomology depends on the chosen background , and in fact describes the tangent space to the moduli space of backgrounds at the chosen point . in particular , let us look at the pure spinor superstring theory in expansion around flat space . the structure of massless brst cohomology in flat space is more or less clear , but it appears that it has never been explicitly spelled out in the literature . the present paper is aimed at filling this gap . for the closed _ bosonic _ string the cohomology was computed in @xcite . we will here do a similar computation for the pure spinor superstring , but with the following difference . it is well known that the physically relevant cohomology problem is the so - called semirelative cohomology @xcite , which is @xmath1 acting on the vertex operators @xmath2 satisfying the following condition : @xmath3 this condition was built - in into the computations of @xcite . in the pure spinor superstring , the construction of the @xmath4-ghost is very subtle . in our paper we will compute the `` naive '' cohomology of @xmath1 , without taking into account ( [ semirelativecondition ] ) . failure to take into account ( [ semirelativecondition ] ) leads to some strange results : 1 . nonphysical vertex operators , _ i.e. _ elements of the brst cohomology which do not correspond to any linearized sugra solutions 2 . absence of the dilaton zero mode 3 . nontrivial cohomology at the ghost number three problems 1 and 2 are removed if we require the existence of the dilaton superfield @xmath5 ( see @xcite and the discussion in section [ sec : commentonnonphysicalstates ] ) . to defeat the ghost number three cohomology is more difficult . it is dangerous as a potential obstacle for continuing an infinitesimal solution to a finite solution ( _ i.e. _ obstructed deformations of the flat spacetime ) . such obstructions would render the theory physically inconsistent . in bosonic string , all linearized deformations are unobstructed . one explanation is that the _ semi - relative _ cohomology at the ghost number three is zero , and therefore there is no obstacle . more precisely , the higher order correction to @xmath2 are controlled by the string field equation @xcite : @xmath6 since the ghost number four cohomology is zero , @xmath7 is in the image of @xmath8 . in fact , the pre - image could be chosen to be annihilated by @xmath9 , and this shows that eq . ( [ stringfieldequation ] ) can be resolved order by order in the deformation parameter . unfortunately , we do not have such a proof in the pure spinor formalism . it follows from the consistency of @xcite that there is actually no obstacle in extending the infinitesimal deformation to higher orders . even though the ghost number three cohomology is nonzero , the actual obstruction vanishes for physical states . it would be good to have a transparent proof of this fact using the language of brst cohomology and vertex operators . this would probably require the use of the composite @xmath4-ghost . in the rest of this introductory section we will review general facts about the brst cohomology and its relation to the deformations of the worldsheet sigma - model . then in section [ sec : typeiibvsmaxwell ] we will review the cohomology of the classical electrodynamics , and explain how to reduce the cohomology of the type iib brst operator in flat space to the cohomology of electrodynamics . the relation will involve the computation of the cohomology of the algebra of translations with coefficients in the space of solutions of susy maxwell equations ( section [ sec : cohomologyofclassicalelectrodynamics ] ) and the tensor produce of two copies of such spaces ( section [ sec : cohomologyoftensorproduct ] ) . the results on brst cohomology are summarized in sections [ sec : brstcohomology ] and [ sec : actionofsusy ] . it was shown in @xcite that classical solutions of the type iib supergravity are in one - to - one correspondence with two - dimensional sigma - models satisfying certain axioms . most importantly , there should be two nilpotent odd symmetries @xmath10 and @xmath11 : @xmath12 also , there should be conserved charge known as the `` ghost number '' , with both @xmath10 and @xmath11 having ghost number @xmath13 . suppose that we are given such a sigma - model . a natural question is , how can it be deformed ? deformations of the sigma - model are the deformations of the action : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is some operator . if @xmath15 vanishes on - shell , then such deformation is trivial , as it can be undone by a field redefinition . suppose that the deformation is non - trivial . the condition that the deformed action still has a pair of nilpotent symmetries is equivalent to requiring the existence of @xmath16 and @xmath17 such that on - shell : @xmath18 here @xmath19 means `` equivalent on - shell '' , _ i.e. _ `` equivalent modulo the equations of motion '' . explicitly , ( [ separateqlandqr ] ) implies the existence of infinitesimal transformations @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( vector fields on the field space ) such that : @xmath22 were @xmath23 is the sigma - model lagrangian . ( the @xmath24 of ( [ totalderivativeonshell ] ) may be different from the @xmath25 of ( [ separateqlandqr ] ) because the variation of the lagrangian is proportional to the equations of motion only modulo a total derivative ) . then @xmath26 and @xmath27 are both symmetries of the deformed action ( [ deformationoftheaction ] ) . actually they are nilpotent : @xmath28 this is automatically true because all those anticommutators would be conserved charges of the ghost number two . in this paper we study vertices which are homogeneous polynomials of @xmath29 and @xmath30 . the conserved charges of the ghost number two are polynomials of low degree . therefore if @xmath15 is of large enough degree in @xmath29 and @xmath30 , then the nilpotence condition ( [ anticommutatorautomaticallyzero ] ) is satisfied . it is enough to verify ( [ separateqlandqr ] ) for @xmath31 : @xmath32 conditions ( [ separateqlandqr ] ) and ( [ q ] ) are equivalent , because @xmath33 and @xmath34 are independent , as both left and right ghost number are conserved . in fact , any linear combination @xmath35 with nonzero constant @xmath36 and @xmath37 can be choosen as a brst operator ; all such complexes are quasi - isomorphic to each other . operators @xmath15 satisfying the condition ( [ q ] ) are called `` integrated vertices '' . notice that @xmath38 is a one - form of the ghost number one , and @xmath39 ; this typically and @xmath30 ; some of our results are only valid under the assumption that the degree of the polynomial is large enough ; exceptions may happen for vertices which do not depend on @xmath29 ] implies @xmath41 , because there are no conserved charges of the ghost number two . this @xmath2 is called the _ unintegrated vertex _ corresponding to the integrated vertex @xmath15 : @xmath42 it is also possible to revert this procedure and go from @xmath2 back to @xmath15 . this involves the assumption about the vanishing of the cohomology at the nonzero conformal weight requires the absence of local conserved charges with nonzero ghost number ; going back ( from @xmath2 to @xmath15 ) requires the vanishing of the cohomology in the sector with positive conformal dimension ] . although ( to the best of our knowledge ) the proof of this vanishing theorem has never been given , we feel that the statement is true . notice that the construction of @xcite establishes the correspondence between integrated and unintegrated vertices independently of this assumption . although ( in its current form ) it only works in flat space and in @xmath43 , it also teaches us something about the generic curved background . for example , it tells us that the map @xmath44 is injective . indeed , suppose that existed an integrated vertex @xmath15 such that @xmath45 and @xmath46 ( _ i.e. _ nonzero @xmath15 gives @xmath2 ) . let us expand such @xmath15 in taylor series around a fixed point in the curved space - time , and take the leading term . this should give us the flat space vertex . since the map @xmath44 is injective in flat space , the leading term in @xmath2 should also be nonzero . this means that , if @xmath2 gets killed , then @xmath15 can not survive either . in any case , our * working hypothesis * is : * at the linearized level the deformations of the action are in one - to - one correspondence with the brst cohomology of @xmath31 at the ghost number two if @xmath15 is an integrated vertex operator , then ( [ deformationoftheaction ] ) defines a deformation of the sigma - model action to the first order in @xmath47 . it is natural to ask , if the deformation can be continued to higher orders of @xmath47 . an obstacle can , in principle , arise already at the order @xmath48 . once we deform the action as in ( [ deformationoftheaction ] ) , the brst operator gets deformed : @xmath49 here @xmath50 is such that : @xmath51 where @xmath23 is the sigma - model lagrangian ( the existence of such @xmath50 follows from the fact that @xmath52 is a total derivative on - shell , this is in the definition of an integrated vertex operator ) . let us consider the following expression : @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the hamiltonian generating @xmath55 : @xmath56 it was proven in @xcite that exists a ghost - number - three operator @xmath57 such that : @xmath58 moreover , the cohomology class of @xmath57 is the obstacle for extending the deformation to the order @xmath48 . the same analysis can be extended to higher orders in @xmath47 . [ [ conclusion ] ] conclusion : + + + + + + + + + + + if the brst cohomology at the ghost number three is zero then any infinitesimal deformation can be continued to a finite deformation , at least as a power series in @xmath47 . however , if the brst cohomology at the ghost number three is nonzero , then there is a potential obstacle . [ [ comment - on - the - derivation - in ] ] comment on the derivation in @xcite + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in @xcite we concentrated on the perturbation theory around @xmath43 , while in the present paper we work in flat space . some of the assumptions leading to eq . ( [ definitionofobstacle ] ) do not work literally in flat space . for example , conserved charges with nonzero ghost number ( besides the brst charge ) do exist in flat space @xcite . however , these charges do not depend on @xmath29 . if we restrict ourselves to the polynomial expressions with large enough degree , then the arguments of @xcite do apply . [ [ another - way - of - looking - at - the - obstacle ] ] another way of looking at the obstacle + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + suppose that we have an unintegrated vertex operator @xmath2 of the ghost number two . suppose that we deform the action as in ( [ deformationoftheaction ] ) by _ some _ integrated operator @xmath59 ( which is related by the descent procedure to _ some other _ integrated vertex @xmath60 ) . the brst operator gets deformed : @xmath61 . the question is , does @xmath2 survive such a deformation ? in other words it is possible to correct @xmath62 in such a way that @xmath63 ? if the cohomology at the ghost number three is trivial , then this is always possible . otherwise , further analysis is needed : one has to prove that the ghost number three vertex @xmath64 is @xmath8-exact . [ [ a - simpler - related - phenomenon ] ] a simpler related phenomenon + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + similar thing happens at the ghost number one . in flat space , there is a nontrivial cohomology at the ghost number one , corresponding to the global symmetries . however , a generic perturbation of the flat space will kill all this ghost number one cohomology . this is obvious , as generic linearized sugra solution does not have any global symmetries . what we want to stress , is the cohomological interpretation of why the ghost number one cohomology gets killed : the existence of the ghost number two cohomology . in this paper we will show that the ghost number three cohomology is nozero . the more or less general example of a cohomologically nontrivial ghost number three vertex can be obtained as follows . let us consider a ghost number two vertex for an exponential linearized solution , for example a ramond - ramond excitation : @xmath65 \right)_{\alpha } p^{\alpha\hat{\beta } } \left ( ( \theta_r\gamma^m\lambda_r)(\theta_r\gamma_m ) + [ \lambda_r\theta_r^{\geq 4 } ] \right)_{\hat{\beta}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath66 is a constant polarization tensor , @xmath67 . suppose that @xmath68 is a constant vector such that @xmath69 . let us consider : @xmath70 notice that @xmath71 is brst closed . we will prove in section [ sec : diracdiracsector ] that it is not brst exact , but the relative sign in ( [ v3 ] ) is minus . with the plus sign it would be @xmath72 . also notice that @xmath73 is the ghost number one unintegrated vertex corresponding to the global conserved charge of translations ( the momentum of the string ) . vertices of the ghost number three transform in the same representation of the super - poincare algebra as the linearized sugra solutions . ( in particular , the obstacle for @xmath71 to be brst - exact is in fact the scalar @xmath74 , so all the polarization is in @xmath66 . ) the integrated vertex corresponding to ( [ v3 ] ) can be constructed as follows . let @xmath75 be the integrated vertex corresponging to @xmath76 . let @xmath77 be the conserved current corresponding to @xmath73 : @xmath78 since @xmath75 is an integrated vertex , exists a 1-form @xmath38 such that @xmath79 . let us denote : @xmath80 we have : @xmath81 the next step is : @xmath82 we conclude that @xmath83 is the integrated vertex operator corresponding to @xmath71 . it is a two - form of the ghost number one . in this paper we will study _ polynomial _ vertices , _ i.e. _ vertices depending on @xmath29 polynomially . the exponential vertices ( [ exponentialv2 ] ) and ( [ v3 ] ) are sums of infinitely many polynomial vertices . indeed , @xmath84 can be decomposed in the taylor series , and the brst operator preserves the degree of a polynomial ( we assign degree @xmath85 to @xmath29 and degree @xmath86 to @xmath30 and @xmath87 ) . polynomial vertices are , essentially , harmonic polynomials of @xmath29 dressed with some appropriate @xmath30-dependence . a low degree example of a polynomial vertex of the ghost number three has been previously constructed in the revised version of @xcite . it is equivalent to the linear term in the expansion of @xmath71 in powers of @xmath29 . we will prove in section [ sec : ghostnumberfour ] that the pure spinor cohomology is zero at the ghost number four . we have proven in @xcite that the pure spinor cohomology is zero at the ghost number greater than four . this implies that the ghost number three cohomology survives the deformation from flat space - time to generic curved space - time . ( however , in the case of a generic curved space - time , there are no ghost number one vertices ; therefore the construction of section [ sec : introghostnumberthree ] does not work . ) consider an unintegrated vertex operator @xmath2 and the corresponding deformation of the sigma - model . can we extend it to the second order in the deformation parameter ? the potential obstacle is the ghost number 3 cohomology class @xmath57 defined in eq . ( [ definitionofobstacle ] ) . it is bilinear in @xmath2 : @xmath88\!]}\ ] ] we will show that @xmath57 transforms in the linearized supergravity multiplet ( _ i.e. _ in the same representation as @xmath2 , modulo some discrete states ) . the map @xmath89 given by ( [ wisgb ] ) defined by ( [ wisgb ] ) should commute with the action of the supersymmetry , in particular with the translations . moreover , one can see that : @xmath90 ( for example , for the linear dilaton background analized in @xcite , @xmath91 $ ] and @xmath92 $ ] . ) this implies that @xmath93\!]}$ ] can only be nonzero if either @xmath94 or @xmath76 is a low degree polynomial . it should be possible to complete this argument , which would provide a proof of the vanishing of the obstructions to most of the deformations of the flat space at the second order ( but this proof will not work at higher orders ) . in section [ sec : typeiibvsmaxwell ] we explain how to compute the massless brst cohomology of the type ii sugra by relating it to the brst cohomology of the maxwell theory using the spectral sequence of a bicomplex . in sections [ sec : cohomologyofclassicalelectrodynamics],[sec : zerothcohomology],[sec : cohomologyoftensorproduct ] and [ sec : secondcohomologytensorproduct ] we compute the second page of that spectral sequence . in section [ sec : brstcohomology ] we finally compute the spectrum of massless states , and in section [ sec : actionofsusy ] we study the action of supersymmetry on the ghost number three vertices . for the first reading , we recommend the following sequence : section [ sec : introduction ] @xmath95 section [ sec : typeiibvsmaxwell ] @xmath95 section [ sec : brstcohomology ] . then sections [ sec : cohomologyofclassicalelectrodynamics],[sec : zerothcohomology],[sec : cohomologyoftensorproduct ] and [ sec : secondcohomologytensorproduct ] could be read at the second pass . we will compute the cohomology of the type iib brst complex by relating it to the super - maxwell brst complex . the cohomology of the super - maxwell brst complex : @xmath96 is only nontrivial at the ghost numbers 0 and 1 . at the ghost number 0 the cohomology is constants : @xmath97 . at the ghost number 1 , the cohomology is in one - to - one correspondence with the solutions of the free maxwell equation and the free dirac equation . the vanishing of the cohomology at the ghost numbers two and three is equivalent to the following statements : 1 . for any current @xmath98 such that @xmath99 always exists the gauge field @xmath100 satisfying @xmath101}=0 $ ] and @xmath102 2 . for any antichiral spinor @xmath103 exists a chiral spinor @xmath104 such that @xmath105 3 . for any @xmath106 exists @xmath98 such that @xmath107 [ [ example ] ] example : + + + + + + + + let us look at the ghost number two cohomology . the leading term in the @xmath30-expansion is either @xmath108 or @xmath109 . let us for example investigate the first possibility . the following expression is in the cohomology of @xmath110 : @xmath111 now let us study the effect of the @xmath112-term in ( [ qsupermaxwell ] ) . for ( [ zeromodeghostnumbertwo ] ) to survive the action of @xmath113 we need : @xmath114 the `` something '' on the right hand side always exists , because any expression of the form @xmath115 $ ] annihilated by @xmath116 is automatically in the image of @xmath116 . it remains to investigate the possibility of ( [ zeromodeghostnumbertwo ] ) being @xmath8-exact : @xmath117 this is possible iff @xmath118 . but for any @xmath119 we can find @xmath120 such that @xmath118 . this implies that any expression of the type ( [ zeromodeghostnumbertwo ] ) is always brst - trivial . the class with the leading term @xmath109 is analyzed similarly . [ [ conclusion-1 ] ] conclusion : + + + + + + + + + + + @xmath121 here `` @xmath122 '' stands for the direct sum of the space of solutions of the maxwell equations and the space of solutions of the dirac equation . we now want to relate the super - maxwell complex to the type iib sugra complex . [ [ comment - in - the - revised - version ] ] comment in the revised version + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + it is possible to modify the definition of the brst complex by imposing the constraint that the cochains are annihilated by @xmath123 . in this case @xmath124 is nonzero and in fact isomorphic ( perhaps modulo some zero modes ) to @xmath125 see the recent work @xcite and references there . we do not impose any such constraints . therefore our brst complex has @xmath126 for open strings . but for closed strings , we still get the massless @xmath127 nonzero ( and isomorphic to @xmath128 up to zero modes ) . let us consider the tensor product of two smaxwell complexes : @xmath129 the operator @xmath130 acts on the space of functions @xmath131 . we will denote @xmath10 and @xmath11 the two terms on the right hand side of ( [ brstsmaxwtimessmaxw ] ) . this is the `` doubled '' brst complex . the difference with the type iib sugra brst complex is the splitting @xmath132 . in the type iib brst complex there is no separation of @xmath29 into @xmath133 and @xmath134 : @xmath135 the difference with ( [ brstsmaxwtimessmaxw ] ) is that the left and the right parts have a common @xmath29 instead of separate @xmath133 and @xmath134 ; the operator @xmath136 acts on the space of functions @xmath137 . the computation of the cohomology of ( [ brstsmaxwtimessmaxw ] ) is straightforward , because it is just the tensor product of two maxwell complexes ( [ qsupermaxwell ] ) ; therefore the cohomology is : @xmath138 where the spaces @xmath139 are given by eqs . ( [ smaxw0 ] ) , ( [ smaxw1 ] ) and ( [ smaxwhigher ] ) . to compute the cohomology of ( [ qsugra ] ) , we relate it to the cohomology of ( [ brstsmaxwtimessmaxw ] ) by the following trick . let us introduce a formal fermionic variable @xmath141 and the operator : @xmath142 ( we call it @xmath143 because it can be thought of as the cohomology of the abelian lie algebra of translations . ) let us consider the bicomplex : @xmath144 consider two ways of computing the cohomology of @xmath145 . we can either compute first the cohomology of @xmath143 , and then consider @xmath146 as a perturbation . or , first compute @xmath147 and then act on it by @xmath143 . this means that there are two different spectral sequences , both converging to @xmath148 . [ [ first - q_rm - lie - then - q_l - q_r ] ] first @xmath143 , then @xmath146 : + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + because of the poincare lemma , the cohomology of @xmath143 is only nontrivial in the ghost number 0 , and is represented by the functions @xmath149 . therefore the type iib brst complex is equivalent to the cohomology of @xmath146 acting on the cohomology of @xmath143 : @xmath150 [ [ first - q_l - q_r - then - q_rm - lie ] ] first @xmath146 , then @xmath143 : + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + now let us first compute the cohomology of @xmath146 , and then consider @xmath143 as a perturbation . the resulting spectral sequence will be denoted @xmath140 . it computes the cohomology of the sugra brst complex : @xmath151 therefore , the only nontrivial components are : @xmath152 all other components are zero . the only potentially nonzero differentials are : @xmath153 therefore , in order to compute the brst cohomology of sugra , we have to : * first compute the cohomology of @xmath143 with coefficients in spaces of solutions of the classical electrodynamics and their tensor products * then compute the differentials @xmath154 the first step will be elaborated in sections [ sec : cohomologyofclassicalelectrodynamics ] , [ sec : zerothcohomology ] and [ sec : cohomologyoftensorproduct ] , and the second in section [ sec : brstcohomology ] . in the previous section we related the cohomology of the sugra complex to the lie algebra cohomology of the algebra of translations @xmath155 with coefficients in the tensor product of solutions of maxwell and dirac equations . in order to compute it , we will first compute the cohomology with coefficients in the single space of solutions of maxwell and dirac equations . then , in the next section , we will proceed to compute the cohomology with coefficients in the tensor product of two such spaces . consider the space of solutions of the vacuum maxwell equations : @xmath156 } = 0\ ] ] depending on a parameter @xmath141 , a free grassmann variable . we need to calculate the cohomology of the operator @xmath157 acting on this space . we will start by computing the cohomology of divergenceless currents . consider the space @xmath158 of one - forms @xmath159 satisfying @xmath160 . this is a subspace of the space of all 1-forms @xmath161 : @xmath162 this gives the long exact sequence of cohomology : @xmath163 we conclude : @xmath164 now we proceed to the cohomology of the maxwell complex . a solution of the maxwell equation is completely characterized by its curvature . the space of solutions is therefore the same as the space of closed 2-forms @xmath165 satisfying @xmath166 . it is included in the following short exact sequence : @xmath167 where @xmath168 is the space of all closed 2-forms . the corresponding long exact sequence reads : @xmath169 to calculate the cohomology of @xmath168 we use : @xmath170 and @xmath171 this implies that for @xmath172 : @xmath173 . therefore , we obtain from ( [ longexactsequenceformaxwell ] ) : @xmath174}dx^m\wedge dx^n \\ h^1({\rm maxwell } ) = \ ; & { \bf c}^{d } \oplus \lambda^3{\bf c}^{d}\;:\ ; c_kf_l dx^k\wedge dx^l\;\mbox { \tt\small and } \ ; f_{[klm]}c^kdx^l\wedge dx^m \label{h1maxwell}\\ h^2({\rm maxwell } ) = \ ; & { \bf c } \oplus \lambda^4{\bf c}^{d}\;:\ ; c_kc_ldx^k\wedge dx^l\;\mbox { \tt\small and } \ ; f_{[ijkl]}c^ic^jdx^k\wedge dx^l \label{h2maxwell}\\ h^{n>2}({\rm maxwell } ) = \ ; & \lambda^{n+2}{\bf c}^d\;:\ ; f_{[j_1\ldots j_{n+2 } ] } c^{j_1}c^{j_2}\cdots c^{j_n } dx^{j_{n+1}}\wedge dx^{j_{n+2 } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that all these cohomology classes are represented by the _ constant _ field strength . in other words , the _ dilatation symmetry _ @xmath175 acts as zero in cohomology . let @xmath176 denote the space of solutions of the dirac equations , and @xmath177 the space of chiral - spinor - valued functions , and @xmath178 the antichiral - spinor - valued functions . there is a short exact sequence : @xmath179 this leads to the long exact sequence of the cohomologies : @xmath180 therefore : @xmath181 this is the direct sum : @xmath182 the space @xmath183 can be thought of as the space of functions : @xmath184\;;\;[pq]}(x ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] satisfying : @xmath185\;;\;[pq ] } \;&= 0 \label{leftjacobionfx } \\ f_{[mn]\;;\;[pq}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{r ] } \;&= 0 \label{rightjacobionfx } \\ \partial^mf_{[mn]\;;\;[pq ] } \ ; & = 0 \label{lefteqmonfx } \\ f_{[mn]\;;\;[pq]}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}^q \ ; & = 0 \label{righteqmonfx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs . ( [ leftjacobionfx ] ) and ( [ rightjacobionfx ] ) together imply that : @xmath186 } = & \ ; \mbox{const } \label{constantfantisymm } \\ g^{mp}g^{nq}f_{[mn]\;;\;[pq ] } = & \ ; \mbox{const } \label{constantdoubletrace}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can write : @xmath187\;;\;[pq ] } \;= \partial_{[m}a^l_{n]\;;\;[pq ] } = a^r_{[mn]\;;\;[p}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{q]}\ ] ] a consequence of eqs . ( [ leftjacobionfx ] ) , ( [ rightjacobionfx ] ) , ( [ lefteqmonfx ] ) , ( [ righteqmonfx ] ) is the existence of @xmath188 and @xmath189 such that : @xmath190\;;\;p } \;&=\partial_p\phi^r_n \label{phirdef } \\ a^l_{m\;;\;[pq]}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}^q \;&=\partial_m\phi^l_p \label{phildef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this implies : @xmath191\;;\;[pq]}(x ) = { 1\over 2 } \partial_q\left ( g^{np}a^r_{[mn]\;;\;p } + \phi^r_m \right ) = { 1\over 2}\partial_m\left ( g^{np}a^l_{n\;;\;[pq ] } + \phi^l_q \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us denote : @xmath192\;;\;p } + \phi^r_m\;,\;\ ; \\ b^l_q \;&= g^{np}a^l_{n\;;\;[pq ] } + \phi^l_q\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular : @xmath193 although @xmath194;p}$ ] and @xmath195 are only defined by ( [ phirdef ] ) up to : @xmath196;p } & \mapsto a^r_{[mn];p } + \partial_p \chi^r_{mn } \\ \phi_n^r & \mapsto \phi_n^r + \partial^m \chi_{mn}\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] this ambiguity does not affect the definition of @xmath197 ( and similarly @xmath198 ) . notice that : @xmath199 } = \;- \partial_{[p}b^l_{q ] } = \ ; & \mbox{const } \\ \partial^p b^l_p = \;\partial^p b^r_p = \ ; & \mbox{const}\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us denote : @xmath200 then : @xmath201 } \ ; & = 0 \\ \partial_{(q}a^{-}_{m ) } \ ; & = 0 \label{eqaminus}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the physical meaning of @xmath202 will be explained in section [ sec : cale02 ] . having computed the cohomology of @xmath143 with values in maxwell and dirac solutions , we will now use it to compute the cohomology with values in the tensor product @xmath203 . again , we will use some spectral sequence . in order to distinguish it from the spectral sequence of section [ sec : typeiibvsmaxwell ] , we will use the notation ] @xmath204 ( that other one was denoted @xmath140 ) . the following group is part of the ghost number 3 cohomology : @xmath205 in this section we will calculate this cohomology group . the differential @xmath143 is realized on the space of bispinors @xmath206 satisfying : @xmath207 the differential @xmath143 acts as follows : @xmath208 let us introduce the filtration by the degree @xmath209 : @xmath210 then @xmath211 is the leading ( of degree zero ) term in @xmath143 and @xmath212 is subleading ( of degree one ) . let us calculate the cohomology of @xmath143 using the spectral sequence of this filtration . the first page @xmath213 is : @xmath214 where @xmath215 consists of polynomials with @xmath216 . schematically , @xmath213 consists of expressions of the form @xmath217\ ] ] satisfying both left and right dirac equations , representing the cohomology of @xmath211 . just to remember : @xmath218 where @xmath219 means degree in @xmath29 . because of section [ sec : cohomologyinmaxwell ] , the cohomology of @xmath211 is localized on @xmath220 , and either @xmath221 or @xmath222 . this means that the only nontrivial components of @xmath213 are the ones represented by the following expressions : @xmath223 here , as usual , we denote @xmath224 . the only nontrivial differential is @xmath225 . the cohomology of this differential is @xmath226 . notice that @xmath227 . indeed , the construction of @xmath228 involves the inversion of @xmath211 and therefore any expression in the image of @xmath229 is necessarily in the image of @xmath230 . but @xmath230 acts as zero on @xmath231 and therefore also on @xmath232 . therefore our spectral sequence converges at the second page : @xmath233 . the condition that the cohomology class of an expression of the form ( [ cr ] ) is cancelled by the @xmath235 of an expression of the form ( [ p ] ) is : @xmath236 indeed , for any @xmath237 solving the right dirac equation ( [ diracequationonp ] ) we can tautologically write : @xmath238 then ( [ trivialityofr ] ) is the necessary and sufficient condition that @xmath239 satisfies both @xmath240 _ and _ @xmath241 . ( and , moreover , any presentation of @xmath242 as @xmath243 plus @xmath244 will necessarily be of the form ( [ presentationofr ] ) . ) [ [ comment ] ] comment + + + + + + + those @xmath245 which satisfy @xmath246 are in the kernel of @xmath235 , and therefore they form @xmath247 . they are in the ghost number two cohomology ( the ramond - ramond fields ) . we have previously explained that @xmath229 is zero ; if it were not zero , it would have killed the ghost number two cohomology . notice that any @xmath245 satisfying ( [ trivialityofr ] ) and ( [ diracequationonp ] ) is automatically harmonic : @xmath248 , therefore ( [ trivialityofr ] ) and ( [ diracequationonp ] ) imply that @xmath249 satisfies the left dirac equation : @xmath250 this means that : @xmath251 in the rest of this section we will prove that this is the only obstacle , _ i.e. _ any @xmath249 satisfying ( [ rsatisfiesleftdirac ] ) can be represented as ( [ trivialityofr ] ) , ( [ diracequationonp ] ) . in this section we will prove that if @xmath249 is a polynomial of nonzero degree ( _ i.e. _ not a constant ) , than ( [ diracoperatorisobstacle ] ) is the only obstacle to the triviality of @xmath249 . notice that it is always possible to solve for @xmath245 to satisfy ( [ trivialityofr ] ) , but @xmath245 will not necessarily satisfy ( [ diracequationonp ] ) . but if the dirac equation ( [ rsatisfiesleftdirac ] ) is satisfied , then we have : @xmath252 we will now prove that ( [ dldrpiszero ] ) and ( [ pisharmonic ] ) imply that exist @xmath253 and @xmath254 such that : @xmath255 this implies that @xmath245 can be chosen to satisfy the right dirac equation , and therefore @xmath249 is in the image of @xmath235 . [ [ proof . ] ] proof . + + + + + + let us switch from the bispinor notations to the forms notations . the left dirac operator corresponds to @xmath256 while the right dirac operator is @xmath257 . ( [ pisharmonic ] ) implies that @xmath258 while eq . ( [ dldrpiszero ] ) implies that @xmath259 . therefore we have : @xmath260 we will now prove that under the condition ( [ ddeltapiszero ] ) exist @xmath253 and @xmath254 such that : @xmath261 it is useful to keep in mind the cohomology of the de rham @xmath262 on harmonic forms is : @xmath263 ( the @xmath264 is generated by @xmath265 ) . [ [ case - when - p - is - a-5-form ] ] case when @xmath245 is a 5-form + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in this case we will write @xmath266 instead of @xmath245 . since @xmath267 , exists a harmonic 3-form @xmath268 such that : @xmath269 similarly , as @xmath270 , exists a harmonic 7-form @xmath271 such that : @xmath272 furthermore , there exist harmonic @xmath273 and @xmath274 such that : @xmath275 this implies that @xmath276 and therefore exists a harmonic form @xmath277 such that @xmath278 . similarly , @xmath279 . therefore the following @xmath253 and @xmath254 satisfy ( [ plandpr ] ) : @xmath280 [ [ case - when - p - is - a-3-form - plus-7-form ] ] case when @xmath245 is a 3-form plus 7-form + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the 7-form part of @xmath245 is related to the 3-form part by the condition that @xmath245 is self - dual . in this case we will write @xmath281 instead of @xmath245 . ( this @xmath268 has nothing to do with the @xmath268 of the previous paragraph . ) since @xmath282 and @xmath283 , exists harmonic @xmath273 such that : @xmath284 this implies that @xmath276 . similarly , exists a harmonic @xmath266 such that : @xmath285 this automatically implies : @xmath272 also exists a harmonic @xmath274 such that : @xmath286 we take : @xmath287 [ [ case - when - p - is - a-1-form - plus - a-9-form ] ] case when @xmath245 is a 1-form plus a 9-form + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + now suppose that @xmath288 . let us first assume that the degree of @xmath245 is more than 1 . we have : @xmath289 similarly @xmath290 . now we have : @xmath291 now consider the case when the degree of @xmath245 is one , _ i.e. _ @xmath245 is linear in @xmath29 . in this case we can have @xmath292 . this corresponds to the @xmath249 of ( [ trivialityofr ] ) a constant proportional to unit matrix . the corresonding element of @xmath293 is : @xmath294 it corresponds to the following ghost number three vertex : @xmath295 [ [ conclusion-2 ] ] conclusion + + + + + + + + + + we conclude that the main obstacle for ( [ cr ] ) to be trivial is @xmath296 . ( and besides that , there is also a case when @xmath249 is a constant times a unit matrix , which results in a nontrivial vertex ( [ vertexghostnumberthreedimfour ] ) . ) if @xmath296 , then there is a nontrivial cohomology class of the form : @xmath297 + r_2[c x_l^2 x_r^{(2m-3 ) } ] + \ldots + r_{2m-1}[c x_l^{(2m-1 ) } ] \label{seriesforrepresentativeh1diracdirac}\end{aligned}\ ] ] indeed , acting on the leading term @xmath298 with @xmath212 we get an expression of the form @xmath299 $ ] , which does not depend on @xmath133 and therefore is annihilated by @xmath211 . but since @xmath300 , this expression is automatically of the form @xmath301 $ ] . continuing this process we get ( [ seriesforrepresentativeh1diracdirac ] ) . let us consider the ghost number three vertex @xmath71 given by eq . ( [ v3 ] ) , and expand it in the taylor series in @xmath29 and @xmath30 . we assign to @xmath29 degree @xmath85 and to @xmath87 and @xmath30 degree @xmath302 . the brst operator preserves this degree . in particular , every term in the expansion is a brst - closed _ polynomial _ of @xmath303 . it is enough to prove the nontriviality term by term . let us consider the extended space @xmath304 . in this extended space , we get : @xmath305 the corresponding element of @xmath306 is given by : @xmath307 consider the expansion in powers of @xmath133 . the leading term is @xmath308 . we observe : @xmath309 and @xmath310 satisfies the left dirac equation . therefore ( [ adotcpexp ] ) is equivalent to @xmath311 . comparing this with ( [ seriesforrepresentativeh1diracdirac ] ) , we get : @xmath312 then ( [ diracoperatorisobstacle ] ) implies that @xmath71 represents a nontrivial cohomology class . [ [ ghost - number - three - vertex - of ] ] ghost number three vertex of @xcite + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + can be obtained as the first order of expansion of ( [ adotcpexp ] ) in powers of @xmath29 . indeed , at the first order of the @xmath29-expansion @xmath313 . notice that the expression : @xmath314 satisfies the left dirac equation ( we use @xmath315 ) . therefore @xmath313 is equivalent to @xmath316 . therefore the leading term of the @xmath29-linear part of ( [ adotcpexp ] ) is equivalent to @xmath317 which is the leading term of the vertex constructed in @xcite . in this section we will compute the cohomology of @xmath318 on the solutions of bi - maxwell equations . solutions of bi - maxwell equations are defined as expressions of the form : @xmath319\;;\;[m } { \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over\partial x_r^{n ] } } \right)\ ; dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\;\ ] ] satisfying the left and right maxwell equations : @xmath320\;;\;[m}{\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over\partial x_r^{n ] } } = 0 \\ { \partial\over\partial x_l^{[p } } { \cal a}(x_l , x_r)_{q]\;;\;[m } { \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over\partial x_r^{n ] } } { \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over\partial x_r^{n } } = 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that we have left and right indices , separated with the semicolon . we use the notations @xmath321 . the expression @xmath322 means the same as @xmath323 . the sole purpose of such notations is to improve the readability of the formulas , as they allow us to naturally separate left and right indices . [ [ definition ] ] definition + + + + + + + + + + as in section [ sec : diracdiracsector ] , we will use the filtration by the powers of @xmath133 , _ i.e. _ treat @xmath133 as being small . the elements of @xmath204 are of the type : @xmath324\;dx_r\wedge dx_r + \ldots\ ] ] where @xmath325 stands for terms of the type @xmath326\;dx_r\wedge dx_r$ ] with @xmath327 , which are factored out when we consider @xmath328 modulo @xmath329 . for a polynomial element @xmath330 , of the total order @xmath331 in @xmath133 and @xmath134 , there is an expansion in powers of @xmath133 : @xmath332 where @xmath333 does not depend on @xmath133 , @xmath334 is linear in @xmath133 , _ etc._. [ [ the - structure - of - e_2pq ] ] the structure of @xmath226 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the following is the most general ( up to the @xmath335-exact terms ) ansatz for the leading term @xmath333 : @xmath336}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; + \label{ansatzmaxwellmaxwell } \\ \;&+ c^p dx_l^q \wedge dx_l^r\ ; b(x_r)_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; \nonumber \\ \mbox{\small\tt with } \ ; & a(x_r)_{q\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_m = 0 \label{ansatzmaxwellmaxwelleqm}\\ & b(x_r)_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_m = 0 \label{ansatzmaxwellmaxwelleqmforb}\\ & \partial^qa(x_r)_{q\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } = 0 \label{ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda}\\ & \partial_{[p}b(x_r)_{qrs]\;;\;[m}\;\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } = 0 \label{ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb}\\ { \cal a}^{(0)}_{q\;;\;m}\ ; & \mbox { \tt\small represents } \mbox { \tt\small an element of } e_2^{-{m-1\over 2},{m+1\over 2 } } \mbox { \tt\small , see ( \ref{e1pqmaxwellmaxwell})}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath337 and @xmath338\;;\;m}$ ] are polynomials in @xmath134 of the order @xmath331 . they correspond to the two terms in ( [ h1maxwell ] ) . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwelleqm ] ) and ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwelleqmforb ] ) enforce the right maxwell equation . ( the left maxwell equation is automatically satisfied because @xmath339 does not depend on @xmath133 . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda ] ) and ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb ] ) are the conditions for being in the kernel of @xmath235 . in other words , those are the conditions for the existence of @xmath340 linear in @xmath133 and @xmath341 such that : @xmath342}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; + \nonumber \\ & + \ ; c^p dx_l^q \wedge dx_l^r\ ; b(x_r)_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; \big ) \ ; = \nonumber \\ = \ ; & c^r{\partial\over\partial x^r_l } \left ( dx_l^p\wedge dx_l^q\;\partial_{[p } a^{(1)}(c , x_l , x_r)_{q]\;;\;[m } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; \right ) \\ \mbox{\tt\small and } & a^{(1)}(x_l , x_r)_{q\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial\over \partial x_r^{n ] } } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial\over\partial x_r^m } \ ; = \ ; { \partial\over\partial x_l^p}{\partial\over\partial x_l^{[p } } a^{(1)}(x_l , x_r)_{q]\;;\;m } \;= \;0\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda ] ) is the vanishing of the obstacle proportional to the first term in ( [ h2maxwell ] ) , and eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb ] ) is to avoid hitting the second term in ( [ h2maxwell ] ) . remember that we are working in the polynomial sector , _ i.e. _ @xmath343}$ ] is a homogeneous polynomial in @xmath134 . let us first assume that the degree of the polynomial is nonzero : @xmath344 } \;\neq\ ; \mbox{const}\ ] ] then ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb ] ) implies that we can remove the term @xmath345}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n$ ] , by adding to @xmath346 an element in @xmath347 . indeed , this is equivalent to the existence of the following two objects : * @xmath348 satisfying @xmath349}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{m } = 0 $ ] and * @xmath350 linear in @xmath133 satisfying left and right maxwell equations : @xmath351\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial\over\partial x_r^{n ] } } \;&= 0 \nonumber \\ { \partial\over\partial x_l^p } g(x_l , x_r)_{pq\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial\over\partial x_r^{n ] } } \;&= 0 \nonumber \\ g(x_l , x_r)_{pq\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial\over\partial x_r^{n]}}{\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over\partial x_r^{m } } \;&= 0 \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] such that : @xmath352}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n \ ; + o(x_l ) = \nonumber \\ = \;\;\;\ ; & c^k\left({\partial\over\partial x^k_l } - { \partial\over\partial x^k_r}\right)\ ; \big(\;\;\ ; dx_l^p\wedge dx_l^q\ ; c(x_r)_{pq\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n \ ; + \nonumber \\ & \phantom{c^k\left({\partial\over\partial x^k_r } - { \partial\over\partial x^k_r}\right ) } \;\;+\ ; dx_l^p\wedge dx_l^q\ ; g(x_l , x_r)_{pq\;;\;[m } { \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over\partial x_r^{n ] } } \;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\;\ ; \big ) \;+ \nonumber \\ \ ; & + c_{p } dx_l^p\wedge dx_l^q\ ; \widetilde{a}(x_r)_{q\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\ ; dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; + \ ; o(x_l ) \ ; \label{removingbterm } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath353}$ ] is some correction to the @xmath354}$ ] of ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) . ( in other words , when we gauge away the @xmath355-term , this leads to some change in the @xmath339 term : @xmath356 . ) the existence of such @xmath348 and @xmath350 follows from ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb ] ) and the fact that @xmath357 is zero in polinomials of the degree @xmath358 , in the following way in two different ways . first , we use @xmath359 to argue that the leading term can be reduced to the form ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) . then we use the _ vanishing _ of @xmath360 in polynomials of high enough degree to remove the b - term by adding @xmath361 . ] . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb ] ) implies that exists @xmath348 satisfying the right maxwell equation , such that : @xmath362 } = - \partial_{[p } c_{qr]\;;\;[m } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\ ] ] therefore , in computing the first line on the rhs of ( [ removingbterm ] ) , the @xmath363 gives zero as @xmath364 does not depend on @xmath133 , and when acting with @xmath365 , we get : @xmath366}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n \;\ ] ] this has to be understood as an element of @xmath367 , _ i.e. _ modulo the image of @xmath363 . this ambiguity is described by the second line on the rhs of ( [ removingbterm ] ) , the term containing @xmath350 . this term can be used to remove the components other than those listed in eq . ( [ h1maxwell ] ) ; the component @xmath368 corresponds to @xmath369 , and the component @xmath370 kills the b - term . we conclude that we can get rid of the @xmath355-term in ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) by adding to @xmath371 an element in @xmath347 . now let us consider the case when @xmath343}$ ] is constant : @xmath344 } = \mbox{const}\ ] ] consider the total antisymmetrization : @xmath372 } = b_{[pqr\;;\;m}(x_r)\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\ ] ] in this case the @xmath355-term in ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) can not be gauged away , as @xmath373}$ ] represents a nontrivial cohmology class of @xmath374 . however , we will show in section [ sec : ghostnumberfour ] that this is cancelled by the @xmath375 . in other words , for our ansatz to survive on @xmath376 we need to put @xmath373}$ ] to zero : @xmath377 } = 0\ ] ] let us therefore assume that @xmath378 . can the remaining @xmath339-term also be in the image of @xmath235 ? let us define the double field strength @xmath379;[mn]}$ ] as follows : @xmath380;[mn ] } = \partial_{[p}a_{q]\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\ ] ] this double field strength has the following properties : @xmath381 } \ ; & = 0 \mbox { \tt\small ( total antisymmetrization ) } \\ \partial_{[p}f_{qr]\;;\;mn } \;&= 0 \\ f_{qr\;;\;[mn}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{k ] } \ ; & = 0 \\ \partial^p f_{[pq];[mn ] } \;&= 0 \\ f_{[pq];[mn ] } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}^m \;&= 0 \\ \delta f_{[pq];[mn ] } = 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] we will now show that @xmath382 is trivial iff @xmath383 . we have to understand under which conditions the class with the leading term ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) is trivial , _ i.e. _ can be obtained by acting with @xmath318 on something : @xmath384\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\;dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; + \ldots = \\ = \ ; & c^j\left ( { \partial\over\partial x_l^j } - { \partial\over\partial x_r^j}\right)\ ; \left ( dx_l^p\wedge dx_l^q\ ; w(x_r)_{pq\;;\;[m}{\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}\over \partial x_r^{n]}}\ ; dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ; + \ldots \right ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] this property is equivalent to the existence of @xmath385 satisfying : @xmath386 } \ ; = \ ; & \partial^{p } w_{pq \;;\ ; [ m } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \label{afromw } \\ \mbox{\tt\small with } \ ; & \partial_{[p}w_{qr]\;;\;[m}\;\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } = 0 \label{wisleftclosed}\\ \mbox{\tt\small and } \ ; & w_{pq\;;\;[m } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n } = 0 \label{rightmaxwellonw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that the ghost number two vertices correspond to @xmath387 satisfying ( [ wisleftclosed ] ) , ( [ rightmaxwellonw ] ) and @xmath388 } = 0 $ ] instead of ( [ afromw ] ) . if @xmath339 can be expressed through @xmath57 as in ( [ afromw ] ) , then we have : @xmath389\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } = -\;\partial_{[p}\partial^rw_{q]r\;;\;[m}\;\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } = { 1\over 2}\partial_r\partial^rw_{pq\;;\;[m}\;\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \;= 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] this means that : @xmath390 we will now prove that this is the only obstacle . in other words , if @xmath383 , then ( [ maxwellmaxwellexpansion ] ) is cohomologically trivial . let @xmath391 be the space of polynomial expressions of the form : @xmath392 } \;\ ; \mbox{\tt\small satisfying } \ ; \phi_{[mn } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{k ] } = 0 \;\ ; \mbox{\tt\small and } \ ; \phi_{mn}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_n = 0\ ] ] let @xmath393 be the subspace of @xmath391 consisting of polynomials of the order @xmath209 in @xmath29 , _ i.e. _ @xmath394 . notice that such @xmath395 are automatically harmonic . the operator @xmath396 acts on such expressions , and is nilpotent : @xmath397 [ [ lemma ] ] lemma + + + + + @xmath398 indeed , @xmath399 is acyclic , as @xmath400 is the same as already computed in section [ sec : cohomologyinmaxwell ] cohomology of the translations algebra on the solutions of the maxwell equations , and it is zero for @xmath401 . this means that it is always possible to gauge away the term with the highest number of @xmath402 , and therefore the cohomology of @xmath396 is zero . the proof of @xmath403 is identical to the proof of @xmath404 after applying the hodge dual operation on the @xmath341 ghosts . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwelleqm ] ) implies that the expression @xmath405}$ ] belongs to @xmath406 . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda ] ) implies that it is annihilated by @xmath407 . since @xmath403 , exists @xmath408 such that : @xmath409 } = \delta_l \left ( dx_l^p\wedge dx_l^q\;\phi^{(2)}_{pq\;;\;mn } \right)\ ] ] now suppose that @xmath383 . this implies that we can find @xmath410 , @xmath411 , @xmath412 and @xmath413 ( all elements of @xmath391 ) satisfying : @xmath414 } = ( \delta_l + d_l ) \left ( \phi^{(2)}_{mn } + \phi^{(4)}_{mn } + \phi^{(6)}_{mn } + \phi^{(8)}_{mn } + \phi^{(10)}_{mn } \right)\ ] ] ( here each @xmath415 is a polynomial of the degree @xmath416 in @xmath402 . ) indeed , as elements of @xmath391 are harmonic functions , @xmath417 implies @xmath418 and therefore the existence of @xmath410 such that @xmath419 . and so on until @xmath420 . since @xmath421 is a top form , exists @xmath422 such that @xmath423 . furthermore , @xmath424 , therefore exists @xmath425 such that @xmath426 . continuing , we get @xmath427 , @xmath428 and finally @xmath429 . let us denote : @xmath430 then we get : @xmath431 } = ( \delta_l + d_l ) \big ( \phi - ( \delta_l + d_l)\psi\big)\ ] ] notice that @xmath432 is of the form : @xmath433 this concludes the proof that the ansatz ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) is trivial iff @xmath379\;;\;[mn ] } = 0 $ ] . [ [ case - n0 ] ] case @xmath434 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the vanishing lemma ( [ vanishingofcohomologydplusdelta ] ) does not work in the case @xmath434 , in this case the cohomology of @xmath399 is given by the formulas of section [ sec : cohomologyinmaxwell ] with the replacement @xmath435 , @xmath436 . similarly , the cohomology of @xmath407 is obtained via the hodge duality . therefore , it is necessary to repeat the analysis taking into account this nontrivial cohomology . there is no obstacle to satisfy ( [ fromatophi2 ] ) , even if @xmath437 } = \mbox{const}$ ] , because there are no 11-forms and therefore the cohomology of @xmath407 vanishes on expressions which are monomials of the first order in @xmath402 . there are potential obstacles in completing the chain ( [ chainofphis ] ) . we will not do the analysis here , but just point out that by rotational symmetry , the potential obstacles are proportional to the following constant tensors : the total antisymmetrization and the contraction : @xmath438 } \label{totalantisymmc } \\ { \cal c}_n \;&= g^{pm}a_{p\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \label{contractionc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider the following ansatz for the leading term of the expasion in powers of @xmath133 : @xmath439 } dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ] ] where @xmath440 satisfies the maxwell equation @xmath441 . this is in the image of @xmath235 when exists @xmath5 such that : @xmath442 } \ ; = \ ; & \gamma^k\partial_k \phi_{[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } \label{diracmaxwelltrivialization}\\ \mbox{\small\tt and } \ ; & \phi \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\bf m } = 0 \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] then it follows that @xmath443 } = 0 $ ] and therefore : @xmath444 } = 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath440 does not satisfy this equation , then the trivialization ( [ diracmaxwelltrivialization ] ) is impossible . notice that @xmath441 , therefore @xmath445}$ ] is automatically annihilated by @xmath446 . but it is not necessarily annihilated by the left dirac operator . we conclude that @xmath447}$ ] is an obstacle for ( [ diracmaxwellansatz ] ) to be trivial . consider the following ansatz for the leading term : @xmath448 where @xmath440 satisfies the right dirac equation @xmath449 and also @xmath450 . this is trivial if exists @xmath451 such that : @xmath452 this implies that @xmath453 and therefore @xmath454 } = 0 $ ] . therefore @xmath454}$ ] is an obstacle for ( [ maxwelldiracansatz ] ) to be trivial . for the polynomials of nonzero degree this is the only obstacle . indeed , suppose that @xmath455 } = 0 $ ] . as the cohomology of dirac solutions at the nonzero degree is zero , this implies that : @xmath456 where @xmath457 satisfies the right dirac equation . the cohomology of @xmath458 on the solutions of the dirac equation is zero , therefore exists @xmath459 such that @xmath460 where @xmath461 satisfies the dirac equation . this implies ( [ trivialityofpsimaxwelldirac ] ) . the term @xmath462 is generated by two types of terms : @xmath463}\ ; dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n \;+ \nonumber \\ + & c^pc^qdx_l^r\wedge dx_l^s \;b_{[pqrs]\,;\,[m}(x_r)\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}\ ; dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath464}$ ] is a polynomial of degree @xmath331 in @xmath134 . under @xmath465 the first term cancels with the right hand side of eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda ] ) , because @xmath466 . the second term for non - constant @xmath467\,;\,[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}$ ] cancels with the right hand side of eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructedb ] ) . the constant @xmath467\,;\,[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } = \mbox{const}$ ] ( _ i.e. _ @xmath468 ) generates @xmath469 ( because @xmath470 ; the @xmath229 acts as @xmath143 on maxwell solutions ) : @xmath471 we are now ready to compute the cohomology of @xmath472 . the corresponding part of @xmath473 consists of two parts : @xmath474 however , there is a nontrivial @xmath475 , which cancels the @xmath476 antisymmetric part of @xmath477 with @xmath478 . we are left with : @xmath479 these vertices are in one - to - one correspondence with the generators of the super - poincare algebra . the corresponding part of @xmath473 consists of three parts : @xmath480 we have already seen that @xmath478 gets killed by the @xmath229 : @xmath481 let us look at @xmath482 . we have : @xmath483 the interpretation is as follows : * @xmath484 corresponds to the linear dilaton and the `` asymmetric linear dilaton '' ( the nonphysical vertex of @xcite with constant @xmath485 ) * one copy of @xmath486 cancels under @xmath229 with @xmath487 * another copy of @xmath488 is the nsns @xmath355-field strength @xmath489 * two copies of @xmath490 are both unphysical this was computed in section [ sec : zerothcohomology ] . we identify @xmath492 as @xmath493 ( the gradient of the dilaton ) and @xmath485 is the unphysical state of @xcite . notice that eq . ( [ eqaminus ] ) implies that @xmath494 , _ i.e. _ @xmath485 is a linear function of @xmath29 . notice that eqs . ( [ phildef ] ) and ( [ phirdef ] ) define @xmath495 only up to a constant , and therefore @xmath202 is defined only up to a constant . this is because linear dilaton and linear asymmetric dilaton have already been counted in @xmath496 . [ [ conclusion-3 ] ] conclusion + + + + + + + + + + as expected , @xmath497 has the quantum numbers of the nsns sector of the linearized type iib sugra , modulo some zero mode subtleties . the symmetric part @xmath498 corresponds to the riemann curvature tensor @xmath499[mn]}$ ] , and the antisymmetric part @xmath500 to @xmath501\;[m } \stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n]}$ ] . there are the following nonphysical states : [ cols="^ , < " , ] they have the quantum numbers of the adjoint representation of the super - poincare algebra . in the bosonic string theory , the nonphysical states were removed by imposing the constraint @xmath502 @xcite . this is probably possible also in the pure spinor approach , as the pure spinor @xmath4-ghost was constructed in the nonminimal formalism @xcite . but there is also another way of removing the nonphysical states , which we will now describe . as we discussed in the introduction , the brst closedness of the vertex operator is a necessary and sufficient condition for the corresponding deformation of the classical worldsheet action to have the classical brst invariance . however , at the one - loop level there is an anomaly which is cancelled by the fradkin - tseytlin term @xcite : @xmath503 here @xmath5 is the _ dilaton superfield_. the only place where @xmath5 enters is the fradkin - tseytlin term ( [ fradkintseytlinterm ] ) , which does not matter at the _ classical _ level . it is , in this sense , `` invisible '' in the classical theory . the condition of the one - loop brst invariance implies that @xmath5 is related to the `` visible '' superfields ( those which enter in the main part of the worldsheet action ) by some equations : @xmath504 where @xmath505 and @xmath506 on the right hand side are some function of the `` visible '' superfields . in this sense , @xmath5 is determined , unambiguously up to a constant , from the `` visible '' superfields . however , it turns out that for some classical backgrounds the equations ( [ dilatonleft ] ) and ( [ dilatonright ] ) are incompatible @xcite . such backgrounds , in our terminology , are _ nonphysical_. being perfectly consistent from the point of view of the classical worldsheet sigma - model , they however fail at the one - loop level . this is somewhat unusual , as the typical situation is that differential equations are `` generally speaking incompatible , but sometimes become compatible '' . here we have the opposite situation . equations ( [ dilatonleft ] ) and ( [ dilatonright ] ) for @xmath5 are compatible for the vast majority of backgrounds , but become incompatible on a finite - dimensional nonphysical component . in other words , * physical and non - physical deformations are `` mutually obstructed''*. + roughly speaking , this can be understood as follows . the compatibility conditions for equations ( [ dilatonleft ] ) and ( [ dilatonright ] ) include the equation : @xmath507 both @xmath505 and @xmath508 are defined in terms of other sugra fields , which already satisfy the sugra constraints . these constraints translate into some constraint on @xmath509 ( which is therefore automatically satisfied ) . surprizingly , that automatic constraint seems to be not @xmath510 but rather @xmath511 , _ i.e. _ the _ derivatives _ of @xmath509 being zero ( @xcite , _ cp . ( [ constantfantisymm ] ) and ( [ constantdoubletrace ] ) ) . in order to kill the nonphysical component , we just have to require that this constant is zero ; this is why the nonphysical component is finite - dimensional . we observe that the nonphysical operators seem to be in correspondence with the global symmetries . this should have a natural interpretation in terms of the action of the @xmath4-ghost : @xmath512 but , as we explained : * instead of imposing the condition @xmath513 , one can request the existence of the dilaton superfield @xmath5 notice that including @xmath5 also solves the following problem . our analysis , based on the naive brst cohomology , failed to identify the dilaton zero mode . but once we include @xmath5 , the dilaton is identified as the lowest component of @xmath5 , and in particular the zero mode of the dilaton is recovered . most of the ghost number three vertex operators transform in the same representation as ghost number two vertex operators . this is in line with the picture : @xmath514 notice that the map ( [ bfromthreetotwo ] ) lowers the polynomial degree of the vertex by 2 , as the @xmath4-ghost should . for example , in the dirac - dirac sector , the ghost number 3 vertex is of the form @xmath242 ; to produce the bispinor field we remove @xmath515 and then act with the left dirac operator : @xmath516 removing @xmath515 lowers the degree by one , and then @xmath517 again lowers the degree by one . let us look more carefully at the subtleties which arise when we consider polynomial vertices of low degree . this is @xmath488 . it cancels with part of @xmath482 see section [ sec : cale11 ] . this is @xmath519 . first of all , we have restrict to the kernel of @xmath520 . this kills one copy of @xmath521 . but also , we have to take a factorspace over the image of @xmath522 . this cancels another copy of @xmath523 against the ( [ constantfantisymm ] ) and one copy of @xmath524 against the ( [ constantdoubletrace ] ) . for example , @xmath525 cancels the diagonal @xmath523 as : @xmath526 and a similar computation shows that @xmath527 cancels a diagonal copy of @xmath524 . another copy of @xmath528 does not seem to cancel with anything : @xmath529 [ [ dirac - dirac - sector ] ] dirac - dirac sector + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + there are the following obstacles to triviality : 1 . the bispinor @xmath531 , which satisfies both left and right dirac equations 2 . there is also a discrete state ( [ vertexghostnumberthreedimfour ] ) which corresponds to @xmath249 being a constant times the unit matrix [ [ maxwell - maxwell - sector-1 ] ] maxwell - maxwell sector + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + there are the following obstacles to triviality : 1 . the double field strength @xmath532\;;\;[pq]}$ ] of section [ sec : doublefieldstrength ] 2 . if the double field strength is zero , then there are constant tensors @xmath533 and @xmath534 defined in ( [ totalantisymmc ] ) and ( [ contractionc ] ) first let us look at the double field strength . notice that the formulas of section [ sec : doublefieldstrength ] are almost identical to section ( [ sec : cale02 ] @xmath535 [ sec : zerothcohomology ] ) . the only difference is that the @xmath532\;;\;[pq]}$ ] of section [ sec : zerothcohomology ] is not required to be of the form ( [ definedoublefieldstrength ] ) with @xmath536 satisfying eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda ] ) . as the @xmath532\;;\;[pq]}$ ] of section [ sec : doublefieldstrength ] _ is _ required to be of such a form , it automatically satisfies : @xmath191\;;\;[pq]}(x ) \;&= { 1\over 2 } \partial_{[m } g^{np } a_{n]\;;\;[p}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{q]}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwellunobstructeda ] ) implies the existence of @xmath5 such that @xmath537 . taking also into account eq . ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwelleqm ] ) , we get : @xmath538\;;\;[pq]}(x ) = \partial_m\partial_q \left[{1\over 8}\left(g^{pn}a_{p\;;\;n } - \phi\right)\right]\ ] ] this is the same equation as we got in section ( [ sec : zerothcohomology ] ) , except there is no unphysical @xmath485 . on the other hand , there are @xmath533 and @xmath534 defined in ( [ totalantisymmc ] ) and ( [ contractionc ] ) , which should be mapped by @xmath539 to @xmath540 and the dilaton gradient . also , there is the discrete state ( [ vertexghostnumberthreedimfour ] ) . notice that in our computation we missed the dilaton zero mode , as the corresponding vertex is probably a brst variation of something that is not annihilated by @xmath541 @xcite . it is possible that the discrete state ( [ vertexghostnumberthreedimfour ] ) mapped by @xmath542 to the dilaton zero mode . however , there is also another discrete state at the ghost number three : eq . ( [ discretestatefrome21 ] ) . therefore our computations seem to confirm eq . ( [ bfromthreetotwo ] ) , except that we see _ two _ ghost scalar ghost number three discrete states : eq . ( [ vertexghostnumberthreedimfour ] ) and eq . ( [ discretestatefrome21 ] ) . the term @xmath544 was computed in section [ sec : secondcohomologytensorproduct ] : @xmath471 it cancels with half of : @xmath545 ( and another half of @xmath546 then cancels with @xmath547 ) . this pattern persists for @xmath548 , giving the short exact sequences : @xmath549 \;\stackrel{d_2}{\longrightarrow}\ ; \nonumber \\ \;\stackrel{d_2}{\longrightarrow}\ ; & [ { \cal e}^{p+2,1 } = \lambda^{p+4}{\bf c}^{10}\oplus \lambda^{p+4}{\bf c}^{10 } ] \;\stackrel{d_2}{\longrightarrow}\ ; \nonumber \\ \;\stackrel{d_2}{\longrightarrow}\ ; & [ { \cal e}^{p+4,0 } = \lambda^{p+4}{\bf c}^{10}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] the term @xmath551 is nonzero , but it cancels with the @xmath229 of @xmath552 . the space @xmath554 is killed by the @xmath229 of @xmath555 . indeed , let us consider the following element of @xmath555 with constant @xmath556}$ ] : @xmath557}\ ; dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n\ ] ] ( this is a particular case of ( [ ansatzmaxwellmaxwell ] ) with zero @xmath339 and constant @xmath355 . ) being an element of @xmath555 , this is a @xmath341-dependent element of the cohomology of @xmath146 , parametrized by a left times right field strength . we need to act on this by the @xmath375 . for that , we need to know the actual ( @xmath341-dependent ) vertex , which is built using the left and right _ vector potentials _ , _ i.e. _ @xmath558}\ ; x_r^m ( \theta_r\gamma^n\lambda_r)$ ] . the @xmath143 on the vertex is not zero : @xmath559 } x_r^m(\theta_r\gamma^n\lambda_r ) - c^p x_l^q ( \theta_l\gamma^r\lambda_l ) b_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } c^m(\theta_r\gamma^n\lambda_r)\ ] ] but is a pure gauge , namely it is @xmath146 of : @xmath560 } x_r^m ( \theta_r\gamma^n\lambda_r ) + c^p x_l^q ( \theta_l\gamma^r\lambda_r ) b_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } c^m x_r^n\ ] ] and the @xmath143 of this gives : @xmath561}x_r^m(\theta_r\gamma^n\lambda_r ) + c^p x_l^q ( \theta_l\gamma^r\lambda_r ) b_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } c^m c^n + \\ + c^pc^q x_l^r b_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } c^m ( \theta_r\gamma^n\lambda_r ) - c^p c^q ( \theta_l\gamma^r\lambda_l ) b_{pqr\;;\;[m}\stackrel{\leftarrow}{\partial}_{n ] } c^m x_r^n\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second row is @xmath562 . and the first row is equivalent , in the maxwell cohomology , to the expression : @xmath563 } ( dx_r^m\wedge dx_r^n - dx_l^m\wedge dx_l^n)\ ] ] where @xmath373}$ ] is defined in ( [ defbpqrmn ] ) this can be used to kill any class of the form : @xmath564}(dx_r^s\wedge dx_r^t - dx_l^s\wedge dx_l^t)\ ] ] in @xmath565 . the classes of the form : @xmath566}(dx_r^s\wedge dx_r^t + dx_l^s\wedge dx_l^t)\ ] ] are not in the image of @xmath229 . however , the @xmath229 of them is nonzero , giving an element of @xmath567 of the form @xmath568 . we conclude that @xmath569 . in this section we will study the action of the supersymmetry on the ghost number three vertices . we will first act by the left supersymmetry on the element of the maxwell - dirac sector , an see that the result is some element of the dirac - dirac sector . then we will act my the left supersymmetry on the dirac - dirac sector , which will bring us back to the maxwell - dirac sector . we will verify that the anticommutator of two supersymmetries is a translation . let us consider an element of the maxwell - dirac sector , of the following form : @xmath570 where @xmath325 stand for elements of the lower degree in @xmath134 ( which have dependence on @xmath133 ) . let us act on it by the _ left _ supersymmetry with the parameter @xmath571 , which we will call @xmath572 . to evaluate the action of this supersymmetry , we will use the formulas from section 6.1.3 of @xcite ( where @xmath572 was denoted @xmath573 , and @xmath571 was called @xmath574 ) . we get the following element of the dirac - dirac sector : @xmath575\epsilon\;\psi_m + \ldots\ ] ] we observe : @xmath576\epsilon\;\psi_m \right ) = \gamma^j{\partial\over\partial x_l^j}\left ( { 9\over 10 } \hat{x}_l\gamma^m\epsilon\psi_m \right)\ ] ] this implies that ( [ susyonpsigivesprer ] ) gives the same cohomology class as : @xmath577 in notations of section [ sec : definer ] we have : @xmath578 the obstacle to the triviality is : @xmath579}(x_r)\ ] ] ( this is a bispinor : @xmath580}(x_r))^{\dot{\beta}}$ ] ) we want to calculate the action of the supersymmetry with the parameter @xmath581 on the class : @xmath582 this is a bit tricky , becase the leading term @xmath583 does not contribute , and we have to analyze the subleading term proportional to @xmath133 : @xmath584 where @xmath325 stand for terms of the higher order in @xmath133 . again , we use the formulas from @xcite . when acting by the supersymmetry with the parameter @xmath581 , we are getting the following element of the maxwell - dirac sector : @xmath585}r(x_r ) - { 1\over 6}\gamma_{m]}c^k\partial_kr(x_r ) + { 5\over 6}c_{m]}\gamma^k\partial_kr(x_r ) \right)dx_l^n\wedge dx_l^m\end{aligned}\ ] ] this can be written as follows : @xmath586k } - { 5\over 6 } \gamma_{k[n}\delta^l_{m ] } - { 1\over 6 } \gamma_{nm}\delta^l_k\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can add @xmath587 then we get : @xmath588k } - { 5\over 6 } \gamma_{k[n}\delta^l_{m ] } + { 5\over 6 } \gamma_{nm}\delta^l_k\end{aligned}\ ] ] now @xmath589}=0 $ ] and @xmath590 . consider the following tensor : @xmath591k } - { 5\over 6 } \gamma_{k[n}\delta^l_{m ] } + { 5\over 6 } \gamma_{nm}\delta^l_k\ ] ] it satisfies @xmath592}=0 $ ] and @xmath593 . therefore the cohomology class does not change if we replace @xmath594 as follows : @xmath595k}\ ] ] indeed : @xmath596 we conclude that the supersymmetry with the parameter @xmath581 brings @xmath597 to @xmath598 . when @xmath249 is given by ( [ susyonpsigivesr ] ) , we get : @xmath599 this is in agreement with the fact that the anticommutator of two susy transformations is a translation . ghost number three vertices transform in the linearized type iib supergravity supermultiplet . we would like to thank nathan berkovits for useful discussions . this work was supported in part by the ministry of education and science of the russian federation under the project 14.740.11.0347 `` integrable and algebro - geometric structures in string theory and quantum field theory '' , and in part by the rfbr grant 15 - 01 - 99504 `` string theory and integrable systems '' . o. chandia , a. mikhailov , and b. c. vallilo , _ a construction of integrated vertex operator in the pure spinor sigma - model in @xmath600 _ , _ jhep _ * 1311 * ( 2013 ) 124 doi : * 10.1007/jhep11(2013)124 * [ arxiv/1306.0145 ] . o. a. bedoya , l. bevilaqua , a. mikhailov , and v. o. rivelles , _ notes on beta - deformations of the pure spinor superstring in ads(5 ) x s(5 ) _ , _ nucl.phys . _ * b848 * ( 2011 ) 155215 doi : * 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2011.02.012 * [ arxiv/1005.0049 ] . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: it is by now well - known that increasing the number of antennas in a wireless system can significantly increase capacity . since the seminal papers of foschini and gans @xcite and telatar @xcite , multiple - input multiple - output ( mimo ) channels have been thoroughly investigated in theory ( see @xcite for a survey ) and implemented in practice @xcite . this capacity gain usually comes at the expense of more complex encoders and decoders and a great deal of work has gone into designing low - complexity mimo architectures . in this paper , we describe a new low - complexity architecture that can attain significantly higher rates than existing solutions of similar complexity . we focus on the case where each of the @xmath0 transmit antennas encodes an independent data stream ( see figure [ f : mimo ] ) . that is , there is no coding across the transmit antennas : each data stream @xmath1 is encoded separately to form a codeword @xmath2 of length @xmath3 . channel state information is only available to the receiver . from the receiver s perspective , the original data streams are coupled in time through encoding and in space ( i.e. , across antennas ) through the mimo channel . the joint maximum likelihood ( ml ) receiver simultaneously performs joint decoding across time and receive antennas . clearly , this is optimal in terms of both rate and probability of error . however , the computational complexity of jointly processing the data streams is high , and it is difficult to implement this type of receiver in wireless systems when the number of streams is large . instead , linear receivers such as the decorrelator and minimum - mean - squared error ( mmse ) receiver are often used as low - complexity alternatives @xcite . traditional linear receivers first separate the coupling in space by performing a linear projection at the front - end of the receiver . in order to illustrate this concept and motivate the proposed new approach , we consider the @xmath4 mimo channel characterized by the following matrix : @xmath5 the simplest choice of a linear receiver front - end _ inverts _ the channel matrix . this receiver is usually referred to as the _ decorrelator _ in the literature . that is , the receiver first applies the matrix @xmath6 to the received signal . overall , this converts the original channel into a new equivalent channel characterized by the identity matrix and colored gaussian noise , i.e. , to two scalar channels with correlated noise . the linear receiver then proceeds by separately decoding the output of each of these two channels . the well - known drawback of this approach is that the _ noise _ vector is also multiplied by the linear receiver front - end matrix given in , which alters the variances of its components . in our simple example , if we assume that the original channel had independent additive white gaussian noise of unit variance , the equivalent noises after the linear receiver front - end have variances of @xmath7 and @xmath8 respectively . that is , while the receiver front - end has nulled out cross - interference , it has also significantly increased the noise levels . the integer - forcing linear architecture advocated here is based on the recent insight that if on all transmit antennas , the same linear or lattice code is used , then it is possible to not only decode codewords themselves , but also _ integer _ linear combinations of codewords directly @xcite . let us denote the codeword transmitted on the first antenna by @xmath9 and the codeword transmitted on the second antenna by @xmath10 then , for the simple example matrix from , the receiver can decode the integer linear combination @xmath11 from the first receive antenna and the combination @xmath12 from the second receive antenna . from these ( following @xcite ) , it is possible to recover linear equations of the data streams over an appropriate finite field , @xmath13 and @xmath14 . these equations can in turn be digitally solved for the original data streams . the key point in this example is that the noise variances remain unchanged , which increases the effective @xmath15 per data stream . note that for more general channel matrices beyond the simple example here , it will also be advantageous to first apply an appropriate linear receiver front - end , albeit following principles very different form merely inverting the channel matrix , as we explain in more detail in the sequel . in this paper , we first consider the standard mimo channel and develop a new _ integer - forcing _ linear receiver architecture that provides multiplexing and diversity gains over traditional linear architectures . our approach relies on the compute - and - forward framework , which allows linear equations of transmitted messages to be efficiently and reliably decoded over a fading channel @xcite . we develop a multiple antenna version of compute - and - forward which employs the antennas at the receiver to rotate the channel matrix towards an effective channel matrix with integer entries . separate decoders can then recover integer combinations of the transmitted messages , which are finally digitally solved for the original messages . we show that this is much more efficient than using the receive antennas to separate the transmitted codewords and directly decoding each individual codeword . our analysis uses nested lattice codes originally developed to approach the capacity of point - to - point awgn and dirty - paper channels @xcite and for which practical implementations were presented in @xcite and subsequent works . next , we generalize the mimo channel model to include interference @xcite and show that the integer - forcing receiver architecture is an attractive approach to the problem of oblivious interference mitigation . by selecting equation coefficients in a direction that depends on both the interference space and the channel matrix , the proposed architecture reduces the impact of interference and attains a non - trivial gain over traditional linear receivers . furthermore , we show that the integer - forcing receiver achieves the same generalized degrees of freedom as the joint decoder . our proof uses techniques from diophantine approximations , which have also recently been used for interference alignment over fixed channels and the characterization of the degrees of freedom for compute - and - forward @xcite . in the remainder of the paper , we start with a formal problem statement in section [ sec : problem ] , and then overview the basic existing mimo receiver architectures and their achievable rates in section [ sec : existingarchitecture ] . in section [ sec : architecture ] , we present the integer - forcing receiver architecture and a basic performance analysis . we show that the rate difference between the proposed receiver and traditional linear receivers can be arbitrarily large in section [ sec : fixedchannels ] . we study the outage performance of the integer - forcing linear receiver under a slow fading channel model in section [ sec : outage ] . we show that in the case where each antenna encodes an independent data stream , our architecture achieves the same diversity - multiplexing tradeoff as that of the optimal joint decoder . in section [ sec : interference ] , we consider the mimo channel with interference and show that the integer - forcing receiver can be used to effectively mitigate interference . we characterize the generalized degrees - of - freedom for the integer - forcing receiver and find that it is the same as for the joint decoder . throughout the paper , we will use boldface lowercase to refer to vectors , @xmath16 , and boldface uppercase to refer to matrices , @xmath17 . let @xmath18 denote the transpose of a matrix @xmath19 and @xmath20 denote the determinant . also , let @xmath21 denote the inverse of @xmath19 and @xmath22 denote the pseudoinverse . the notation @xmath23 will refer to the @xmath24-norm of the vector @xmath25 while @xmath26 will refer to the @xmath27-norm . finally , we will use @xmath28 and @xmath29 to refer to the maximum and minimum singular values of the matrix @xmath19 . the baseband representation of a mimo channel usually takes values over the complex field . for notational convenience , we will work with the real - valued decomposition of these complex matrices . recall that any equation of the form @xmath30 over the complex field can be represented by its real - valued representation , @xmath31 we will henceforth refer to the @xmath32 real - valued decomposition of the channel matrix as @xmath33 . we will use @xmath34 independent encoders and @xmath34 independent decoders for the resulting real - valued transmit and receive antennas .. ] [ def : messages ] each of the @xmath34 transmit antennas has a length @xmath35 _ data stream _ ( or message ) @xmath1 drawn independently and uniformly from @xmath36 . [ def : encoders ] each data stream @xmath1 is mapped onto a length @xmath3 channel input @xmath37 by an _ encoder _ , @xmath38 an equal _ power allocation _ is assumed across transmit antennas @xmath39 while we formally impose a separate power constraint on each antenna , we note that the performance at high snr ( in terms of the diversity - multiplexing tradeoff ) remains unchanged if this is replaced by a sum power constraint over all antennas instead . [ def : rate ] each of the @xmath34 encoders transmits at the same @xmath40 the _ total rate _ of the mimo system is just the number of transmit antennas times the rate , @xmath41 . since the transmitters do not have knowledge of the channel matrix , we focus on the case where the @xmath34 data streams are transmitted at equal rates . we will compare the integer - forcing receiver against successive cancellation v - blast schemes with asymmetric rates in section [ subsec : rateallocation ] . [ def : channel ] let @xmath42 be the matrix of transmitted vectors , @xmath43 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the _ mimo channel _ takes @xmath44 as an input , multiplies it by the _ channel matrix _ @xmath45 and adds noise @xmath46 whose entries are i.i.d . gaussian with zero mean and unit variance . the signal @xmath47 observed across the @xmath48 receive antennas over @xmath3 channel uses can be written as@xmath49 we assume that the channel realization @xmath33 is known to the receiver but unknown to the transmitter and remains constant throughout the transmission block of length @xmath3 . [ def : decoder ] at the receiver , a _ decoder _ makes an estimate of the messages,@xmath50 [ def : achrate ] we say that sum rate @xmath51 is _ achievable _ if for any @xmath52 and @xmath3 large enough , there exist encoders and a decoder such that reliable decoding is possible @xmath53 so long as the total rate does not exceed @xmath51 , @xmath54 many approaches to mimo decoding have been studied in the literature . we provide a brief summary of some of the major receiver architectures and the associated achievable rates , including the joint ml receiver , the decorrelator , linear mmse estimator and the mmse - sic estimator . clearly , the best performance is attainable by joint ml decoding across all @xmath55 receive antennas . this situation is illustrated in figure [ f : mimo ] . let @xmath56 denote the submatrix of @xmath33 formed by taking the columns with indices in @xmath57 . if we use a joint ml decoder that searches for the most likely set of transmitted messages vectors @xmath58 , then the following rate is achievable ( using gaussian codebooks at the transmitter ) : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the identity matrix . is achievable . ] note that this is also the capacity of the channel subject to equal rate constraints per transmit antenna . the worst - case complexity of this approach is exponential in the product of the blocklength @xmath3 and the number of antennas @xmath55 . one approach to reduce the complexity of the joint ml decoder is to employ a sphere decoder . rather than naively checking all possible codewords , the sphere decoder only examines codewords that lie within a ball around the received vector . if the radius of the ball is suitably chosen , this search is guaranteed to return the ml candidate vector . we refer interested readers to @xcite for more details on sphere decoding algorithms as well as to @xcite for a recent hardware implementation . ( -5,-18)(90,42 ) ( -15,32 ) ( -5,0)@xmath61 ( 1,0)(7,0 ) ( 7,-5)(21,5 ) ( 14,0)@xmath62 ( 28,3.5)@xmath9 ( 21,0)(35,0 ) ( -1,10)@xmath63 ( -15,-15.5 ) ( -5,0)@xmath64 ( 1,0)(7,0 ) ( 7,-5)(21,5 ) ( 14,0)@xmath65 ( 28,3.5)@xmath66 ( 21,0)(35,0 ) ( 20 , -22.5 ) ( 0,0)(30,60 ) ( 15 , 30)@xmath33 ( 52,32 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath67 ( 3,0)(18,0 ) ( 19,4)@xmath68 ( 60,10)@xmath63 ( 52,-16 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath69 ( 3,0)(18,0 ) ( 19,4)@xmath70 ( 78,-22.5 ) ( 0,0)(20,60 ) ( 10,30)@xmath71 ( 86,8 ) ( 12,0)(20,0 ) ( 24,15)@xmath72 ( 24,-15)@xmath73 ( 24,2)@xmath63 rather than processing all the observed signals from the antennas jointly , one simple approach is to separate out the transmitted data streams using a linear projection and then decode each data stream individually , as shown in figure [ f : trad ] . given the observed matrix @xmath74 from @xmath75 , the receiver forms the projection @xmath76 where @xmath77 . each row @xmath78 of @xmath79 is treated as a noisy version of @xmath80 . in traditional linear receivers , the goal of the projection matrix @xmath81 is to separate the incoming data streams . for the decorrelator architecture , we choose the projection to be the pseudoinverse of the channel matrix @xmath82 . in the case where @xmath83 , the resulting channel is interference free . if @xmath33 is orthogonal , then the decorrelator architecture can match the performance of a joint ml decoder . as the condition number of @xmath33 increases , the performance gap between the decorrelator and the joint decoder increases due to noise amplification ( see the example in section [ ex:2 ] ) . the performance of the decorrelator can be improved at low @xmath15 using the mmse architecture which sets @xmath84 . let @xmath85 be the @xmath86 row vector of @xmath81 and @xmath87 the @xmath86 column vector of @xmath33 . the following rate is achievable for the @xmath86 data stream using a decorrelator architecture with gaussian codebooks : @xmath88 since we focus on the case where each data stream is encoded at the same rate , the achievable sum rate is dictated by the worst stream , @xmath89 the complexity of a linear receiver architecture is dictated primarily by the choice of decoding algorithm for the individual data streams . in the worst case ( when ml decoding is used for each data stream ) , the complexity is exponential in the blocklength of the data stream . in practice , one can employ low - density parity - check ( ldpc ) codes to approach rates close to the capacity with linear complexity @xcite . the performance of this class of linear receivers can be improved using successive interference cancellation ( sic ) @xcite . after a codeword is decoded , it may be subtracted from the observed vector prior to decoding the next codeword , which increases the effective signal - to - noise ratio . let @xmath90 denote the set of all permutations of @xmath91 . for a fixed decoding order @xmath92 , let @xmath93 denote the indices of the data streams that have not yet been decoded . let @xmath94 denote the @xmath95 column vector of @xmath33 and let @xmath96 be the submatrix consisting of the columns with indices @xmath97 , i.e. , @xmath98 $ ] . the following rate is achievable in the @xmath95 , stream using successive interference cancellation : @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the projection vector to decode the @xmath95 stream after canceling the interference from the @xmath101 streams . for a fixed decoding order @xmath102 , the achievable sum - rate is given by @xmath103 the above scheme is referred to as v - blast i ( see @xcite for more details ) . an improvement can be attained by selecting the decoding order , and thus the permutation . in the case of v - blast ii , the sum rate is improved by choosing the decoding order that maximizes rate of the worst stream , @xmath104 hence , v - blast i performs worse than v - blast ii for all channel parameters . we postpone the discussion of v - blast iii to section [ sec : outage ] where we introduce the outage formulation . using ml decoding for each individual data stream , the complexity of the mmse - sic architecture is again exponential in blocklength . however , unlike the decorrelator and linear mmse receiver , not all @xmath0 streams can be decoded in parallel and delay is incurred as later streams have to wait for earlier streams to finish decoding . ( -17,-33)(145,52 ) ( -17,28 ) ( 0,0)@xmath61 ( 4,0)(10,0 ) ( 10,-5)(23,5 ) ( 16.5,0)@xmath62 ( 29,3.5)@xmath9 ( 23,0)(37,0 ) ( 0.5 , 12)@xmath63 ( -17,-12 ) ( 0,0)@xmath64 ( 6,0)(10,0 ) ( 10,-5)(23,5 ) ( 16.5,0)@xmath65 ( 30,3.5)@xmath66 ( 23,0)(37,0 ) ( 20 , -22.5 ) ( 0,0)(25,60 ) ( 12.5 , 30)@xmath33 ( 47,32 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath67 ( 3,0)(18,0 ) ( 19,4)@xmath68 ( 68,-22.5 ) ( 5,0)(30,60 ) ( 17.5 , 30)@xmath105 ( 87,28 ) ( 11,0)(25,0 ) ( 18,5)@xmath106 ( 25,5)(40,-5 ) ( 32.5,0)@xmath107 ( 40,0)(48,0 ) ( 54,.5)@xmath108 ( 55 , 12)@xmath63 ( 47,-16 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath69 ( 3,0)(18,0 ) ( 19,4)@xmath109 ( 119 , 12)@xmath63 ( 87,-12 ) ( 11,0)(25,0 ) ( 18.5,5)@xmath110 ( 25,5)(40,-5 ) ( 33,0)@xmath111 ( 40,0)(48,0 ) ( 54.5,.5)@xmath112 another class of linear architectures comes under the name of _ lattice - reduction _ detectors . it has been shown that lattice reduction can be used to improve the performance of the decorrelator when the channel matrix is near singular @xcite and can achieve the receive diversity @xcite . lattice - reduction detectors are symbol - level linear receivers that impose a linear constellation constraint , _ e.g. , _ a qam constellation , on the transmitters . the output of the mimo channel @xmath113 is passed through a linear filter @xmath81 to get the resulting output : @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the effective channel matrix . in lattice reduction , the effective channel matrix is restricted to be unimodular : both its entries and the entries of its inverse must be integers . let @xmath116 be the row vectors of matrix @xmath19 . the lattice - reduction detector produces estimates of the symbols of @xmath117 from @xmath118 . there are two key differences between the proposed integer - forcing receiver and the lattice - reduction receiver . first , the integer - forcing receiver operates on the codeword level rather than on the symbol level . second , the effective channel matrix @xmath19 of the integer - forcing receiver is not restricted to be unimodular : it can be any full - rank integer matrix . we compare lattice reduction to the integer receiver in example 3 by restricting the effective matrix to be unimodular under the integer - forcing architecture . we show that this restriction can result in an arbitrarily large performance gap . two other works have developed lattice architectures for joint decoding that can achieve the optimal diversity - multiplexing tradeoff @xcite . linear receivers such as the decorrelator and the mmse receiver directly decode the data streams after the projection step . in other words , they use the linear projection matrix @xmath81 to invert the channel matrix at the cost of amplifying the noise . although low in complexity , these approaches are far from optimal when the channel matrix is ill - conditioned . in the integer - forcing architecture , each encoder uses the same linear code and the receiver exploits the code - level linearity to recover equations of the transmitted messages . instead of inverting the channel , the scheme uses @xmath81 to force the effective channel to a full - rank integer matrix @xmath19 . as in the case of traditional linear receivers , each element of the effective output is then sent to a separate decoder . however , since each encoder uses the same linear code , each decoder can recover an integer linear combination of the codewords . the integer - forcing receiver is free to choose the set of equation coefficients @xmath19 to be any full - rank integer matrix . the resulting integer combinations of codewords can be mapped back to a set of full - rank messages over a finite field . is prime to ensure invertibility . however , this restriction may be removed as shown in @xcite . ] finally , the individual messages vectors are recovered from the set of full - rank equations of message vectors . the details of the architecture are provided in the sequel and an illustration is given in figure [ f : latticedemod ] . ( -17,-33)(170,52 ) ( -17,28 ) ( 0,0)@xmath61 ( 4,0)(10,0 ) ( 10,-5)(23,5 ) ( 16.5,0)@xmath62 ( 29,3.5)@xmath9 ( 23,0)(37,0 ) ( 0.5 , 12)@xmath63 ( -17,-12 ) ( 0,0)@xmath64 ( 6,0)(10,0 ) ( 10,-5)(23,5 ) ( 16.5,0)@xmath65 ( 30,3.5)@xmath66 ( 23,0)(37,0 ) ( 20 , -22.5 ) ( 0,0)(25,60 ) ( 12.5 , 30)@xmath33 ( 47,32 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath67 ( 3,0)(18,0 ) ( 19,4)@xmath68 ( 68,-22.5 ) ( 5,0)(30,60 ) ( 17.5 , 30)@xmath119 ( 87,28 ) ( 11,0)(25,0 ) ( 18,5)@xmath106 ( 25,5)(40,-5 ) ( 32.5,0)@xmath107 ( 40,0)(54,0 ) ( 47,4.5)@xmath120 ( 55 , 12)@xmath63 ( 47,-16 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath69 ( 3,0)(18,0 ) ( 19,4)@xmath109 ( 119 , 12)@xmath63 ( 87,-12 ) ( 11,0)(25,0 ) ( 18.5,5)@xmath110 ( 25,5)(40,-5 ) ( 33,0)@xmath111 ( 40,0)(54,0 ) ( 47,4.5)@xmath121 ( 137,-22.5 ) ( 4,0)(24,60 ) ( 14,30)@xmath21 ( 161,10)(167,10 ) ( 170 , 24)@xmath122 ( 170 , 12)@xmath63 ( 170 , -6)@xmath123 prior to decoding , our receiver projects the channel output using the @xmath32 matrix @xmath81 to get the effective channel@xmath124 each preprocessed output @xmath125 is then passed into a separate decoder @xmath126 . decoder @xmath127 attempts to recover a linear equation of the message vectors @xmath128\hspace{-0.1 in } \mod{q}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for some @xmath129 . let @xmath130 denote the vector of desired coefficients for decoder @xmath127 , @xmath131^t$ ] . we choose @xmath132 to be linearly independent . and desired coefficient vectors @xmath133 that are real - valued decompositions of a complex matrix or vector . ] decoder @xmath127 outputs an estimate @xmath134 for the equation @xmath135 . we will design our scheme such that , for any @xmath52 and @xmath3 large enough , the desired linear equations are recovered with probability of error satisfying @xmath136 let @xmath137^t$ ] denote the matrix of message vectors , @xmath138^t$ ] denote the matrix of linear equations of message vectors and @xmath139^t$ ] denote the integer matrix of equation coefficients . since @xmath19 is full - rank , the original message vectors can be recovered from the set of linear equations by a simple inverse operation : @xmath140 in the following subsections , we will provide details on the achievable rate , the choice of the coefficients of the integer matrix @xmath19 , and the complexity of our architecture . we use the compute - and - forward framework developed in @xcite to derive the achievable rate of the integer - forcing linear receiver . let @xmath141 be the @xmath86 row vector of @xmath33 . in the case where @xmath142 , the channel output to the @xmath86 decoder is given by @xmath143 and the rate at which the set of equations @xmath144 can be reliably recovered is given in the following theorem . define @xmath145 . [ thm : rate1 ] for any @xmath52 and @xmath3 large enough , there exist fixed encoders and decoders , @xmath146 , such that all decoders can recover their equations with total probability of error at most @xmath147 so long as @xmath148 for the selected equation coefficients @xmath149 . note that the decoders in theorem [ thm : rate1 ] are free to choose any equation coefficients that satisfy ( [ eqn : comprate ] ) . the encoders are completely oblivious to the choice of coefficients . it is instructive to examine the noise term @xmath150 the leading @xmath151 corresponds to the additive noise , which has unit variance in our model . the more interesting term @xmath152 corresponds to the non - integer " penalty since the channel coefficients @xmath87 are not exactly matched to the coefficients @xmath133 of the linear equation . as illustrated in figure [ f : latticedemod ] , we first multiply the channel output matrix @xmath113 by a judiciously chosen matrix @xmath153 that is , the effective channel output observed by the @xmath86 decoder can be expressed as @xmath154 where @xmath155 is the effective channel to the @xmath86 decoder and @xmath156 is the effective noise with variance @xmath157 . the achievable rate of the integer - forcing linear receiver is given in the next theorem . [ thm : rate ] consider the mimo channel with channel matrix @xmath45 . under the integer - forcing architecture , the following rate is achievable : @xmath158for any full - rank integer matrix @xmath159 and any matrix @xmath77 . applying theorem [ thm : rate1 ] with effective channel channel @xmath155 and effective noise variance @xmath157 , it follows that the receiver can reliably recover the set of linear equations @xmath144 where @xmath128\hspace{-0.1 in } \mod{q } \ . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the message vectors @xmath160 can be solved in turn by inverting the linear equations , @xmath161 . theorem [ thm : rate ] provides an achievable rate for the integer - forcing architecture for any preprocessing matrix @xmath81 and any full - rank integer matrix @xmath162 the remaining task is to select these matrices in such a way as to _ maximize _ the rate expression given in theorem [ thm : rate ] . this turns out to be a non - trivial task . we consider it in two steps . in particular , we first observe that for a fixed integer matrix @xmath163 it is straightforward to characterize the optimal preprocessing matrix @xmath153 then , in the next subsection , we discuss the problem of selecting the integer matrix @xmath162 we consider the case when @xmath83 and note that given a fixed full - rank integer matrix @xmath19 , a simple choice for preprocessing matrix is @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the pseudoinverse of @xmath33 . we call this scheme `` exact '' integer - forcing since the effective channel matrix after preprocessing is simply the full - rank integer matrix @xmath19 . we also note that choosing @xmath166 and @xmath167 corresponds to the decorrelator . more generally , the performance of exact integer - forcing is summarized in the following corollary . [ cor : ratesub ] consider the case where @xmath83 . the achievable rate from theorem [ thm : rate ] can be written equivalently as @xmath168 for any full - rank integer matrix @xmath19 by setting @xmath169 . we call the expression in the denominator of the `` effective noise variance . '' the achievable rate in ( [ eq : exactrate ] ) is determined by the largest effective noise variance , @xmath170 hence , the goal is to choose linearly independent equations @xmath171 to minimize the expression @xmath172 in . the integer - forcing receiver provides the freedom to choose any full - rank integer matrix @xmath19 . in the remainder of this section , we characterize the optimal linear projection matrix @xmath81 for a fixed coefficient matrix @xmath19 and provide an equivalent rate expression for theorem [ thm : rate ] . we will then use this expression in the section [ sec : equations ] to provide insight into how to select the optimal coefficient matrix @xmath19 . [ cor : bopt ] the optimal linear projection matrix for a fixed coefficient matrix @xmath19 is given by @xmath173 the linear mmse estimator , given by @xmath174 , is a special case of the integer - forcing receiver with @xmath175 and @xmath167 . @xmath176 . hence , under a fixed channel matrix , exact integer - forcing is optimal as @xmath177 . let @xmath178^t$ ] . we solve for each @xmath179 separately to maximize the achievable rate in theorem [ thm : rate ] , @xmath180 define this quantity to be the function @xmath181 and rewrite as follows : @xmath182 taking the derivative of @xmath183 with respect to @xmath179 , we have that @xmath184 setting @xmath185 and solving for @xmath179 , we have that @xmath186 corollary [ cor : bopt ] follows since @xmath187^t$ ] . using the optimal linear projection matrix from corollary [ cor : bopt ] , we derive an alternative expression for the achievable rate in theorem [ thm : rate ] . [ thm : alterrate ] the achievable rate from theorem [ thm : rate ] under the optimal projection matrix @xmath188 from ( [ eq : bopt ] ) can be expressed as @xmath189 where @xmath190 is the matrix composed of the eigenvectors of @xmath191 and @xmath192 is a diagonal matrix with elements@xmath193 and @xmath194 is the @xmath195 singular value of @xmath33 . let @xmath183 be defined as in ( [ eq : effecnoise ] ) and define @xmath196 to be the singular value decomposition ( svd ) of @xmath33 with @xmath197 , and @xmath190 . note that in this svd representation , @xmath198 and @xmath199 for all @xmath200 . evaluating @xmath183 for the @xmath201 row @xmath179 of @xmath188 yields @xmath202 combining and , it follows that @xmath203 since @xmath204 is an orthonormal matrix , @xmath205 and can be rewritten as follows @xmath206 since @xmath207 is an orthonormal matrix , @xmath208 and can be rewritten as follows @xmath209 putting everything together , we have that @xmath210 in the previous section , we explored choices of the preprocessing matrix @xmath81 and characterized the optimal @xmath81 for a fixed full - rank integer matrix @xmath19 . now , we discuss how to select equation coefficients @xmath211 to maximize the achievable rate in theorem [ thm : rate ] or , equivalently , theorem [ thm : alterrate ] . in the integer - forcing linear receiver , we are free to recover any full - rank set of linear equations with integer coefficients . however , due to the integer constraint on @xmath163 it does not appear to be possible to give a closed - form solution for the best possible full - rank matrix @xmath162 an initially tempting choice for @xmath19 might be @xmath212 as we noted previously , for this choice of @xmath163 selecting @xmath213 reduces to the decorrelator while selecting @xmath214 yields the linear mmse estimator . however , as we show , for most channel matrices , fixing @xmath167 is suboptimal . from theorem [ thm : alterrate ] , the achievable rate under the fixed channel matrix @xmath215^t$ ] is given by @xmath216 in general , for a fixed @xmath15 and channel matrix , finding the best coefficient matrix @xmath19 appears to be a combinatorial problem , requiring an explicit search over all possible full - rank integer matrices . the following lemma shows how the search space can be somewhat reduced . [ lm : asearch ] to optimize the achievable rate in theorem [ thm : alterrate ] ( or , equivalently , in theorem [ thm : rate ] ) , it is sufficient to check the space of all integer vectors @xmath133 with norm satisfying @xmath217 where @xmath218 is the maximum singular value of @xmath33 . this lemma thus shows that an exhaustive search only needs to check roughly @xmath219 possibilities . from , the achievable rate of the integer - forcing receiver is zero for all @xmath133 satisfying @xmath220 the left - hand side is lower bounded by @xmath221 hence , if @xmath222 , then @xmath223 . to conclude this subsection , we will now explicitly show how and why the choice @xmath167 is indeed suboptimal in general . in this context , it is instructive to use lemma [ lm : asearch ] to restate as @xmath224 equation suggests that we should choose coefficient vectors @xmath132 to be short and in the direction of the maximum right eigenvector of @xmath33 . to make this concrete , let us study a particular @xmath225 real mimo channel for which the matrix @xmath33 has singular values @xmath226 and @xmath227 with corresponding right singular vectors @xmath228 and @xmath229 respectively , as illustrated in figure [ fig : equations ] . here , decoder 1 recovers a linear combination of the transmitted message vectors with integer coefficients @xmath230^t$ ] and decoder 2 recovers a linear combination with integer coefficients @xmath231^t$ ] . using the exact integer - forcing rate from corollary [ cor : ratesub ] , the following rate is achievable @xmath232 where @xmath233 can be interpreted as the effective noise variance for the @xmath86 decoder , @xmath234 since @xmath235 , suggests that @xmath236 should be chosen in the direction of @xmath237 subject to linearly independent constraints to reduce the noise amplification by @xmath238 . in the case of the decorrelator ( or mmse receiver ) , the equation coefficients are fixed to be @xmath239^t$ ] and @xmath240^t$ ] . as a result , the noise variance in at least one of the streams will be heavily amplified by @xmath238 and the rate will be limited by the minimum singular value of the channel matrix . with integer - forcing , we are free to choose _ any linearly independent _ @xmath241 since we only require that our coefficients matrix @xmath19 be invertible . by choosing @xmath236 in the direction @xmath242 , we are protected against large noise amplification in the case of near - singular channel matrices . ( 0,35)(255,120 ) ( 0,0 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 30,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 45,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 75,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 90,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 105,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,45)(72.5,55 ) ( 60,45)(20,90 ) ( 84,62)@xmath243 ( 28,98)@xmath244 ( 60,45)(75,45 ) ( 60,45)(60,60 ) ( 60,65)@xmath245 ( 82,45)@xmath246 ( 115,0 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 30,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 45,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 75,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 90,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 105,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 120,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,45)(72.5,55 ) ( 60,45)(20,90 ) ( 80,45)@xmath247 ( 22.5,98)@xmath248 ( 60,45)(105,75 ) ( 60,45)(75,60 ) ( 112,75)@xmath246 ( 75,65)@xmath245 our architecture has the same implementation complexity as that of a traditional linear receiver with the addition of the matrix search for @xmath19 . the ideal joint ml receiver aggregates the time and space dimensions and finds the ml estimate across both . as a result , its complexity is exponential in the product of the blocklength and the number of data streams . our architecture decouples the time and space dimensions by allowing for single - stream decoding . first , we search for the best integer matrix @xmath19 , which has an exponential complexity in the number of data streams in the worst case . for slow fading channels , this search is only needed once per data frame . afterwards , our receiver recovers @xmath0 linearly independent equations of codewords according to @xmath19 and then solves these for the original codewords . this step is polynomial in the number of data streams and exponential in the blocklength for an ml decoder . in practice , the decoding step can be considerably accelerated through the use of ldpc codes and the integer matrix search can be sped up via a sphere decoder . in this section , we compare the performance of the integer - forcing linear receiver against existing architectures through a series of examples . in example 1 , we compare the performance of different architectures for an ill - conditioned channel matrix and demonstrate that the choice of equation coefficients for the integer - forcing receiver changes with @xmath15 . in example 2 , we compare the performance of the integer - forcing receiver with the decorrelator and show that the decorrelator can perform arbitrarily worse . in examples 3 , we illustrate that the gap between the integer - forcing receiver and lattice reduction can become unbounded . finally , we show that the gap between the integer - forcing receiver and the joint decoder can be arbitrarily large in example 4 . consider the @xmath225 real mimo channel with channel matrix @xmath249 real - valued mimo channel with fixed channel matrix from ( [ e : fixedmatrixex1]).,width=326 ] figure [ f : fixedchannel ] shows the performance of the different architectures . ( recall that we assume equal - rate data streams on both transmit antennas , as in definition [ def : rate ] . ) the achievable rates for traditional linear receiver are given by and that of the joint receiver is given by . the decorrelator and the mmse receiver aim to separate the data streams and cancel the interference from other streams . however , this is difficult since the columns of the channel matrix are far from orthogonal . the integer - forcing architecture attempts to exploit the interference by decoding two linearly independent equations in the direction of the maximum eigenvector @xmath250^t$ ] . for example , at @xmath251 , we choose equation coefficients @xmath252^t$ ] and @xmath253^t,$ ] while for @xmath254 , we choose equation coefficients @xmath255^t$ ] and @xmath256^t.$ ] thus , for different values of @xmath15 , the optimal equation coefficients generally change . consider the @xmath225 real mimo channel with channel matrix : @xmath257 where we assume @xmath258 , @xmath259 is an integer and @xmath260 . we first note that @xmath261 using with @xmath262 , the achievable rate of the decorrelator is @xmath263 we compare the achievable rate of the decorrelator with the exact integer - forcing rate from corollary [ cor : ratesub ] . the equation coefficients selected by the decoders are @xmath264^t\\ \mathbf{a}_2 & = \left[\frac{1}{\sqrt{\epsilon}}~~\frac{1}{\sqrt{\epsilon } } + 1\right]^t \ . \end{aligned}\ ] ] using corollary [ cor : ratesub ] , the achievable rate of exact integer - forcing with equations coefficients @xmath265^t$ ] is @xmath266 where the inequality follows since @xmath258 . we compare the two linear architectures to the joint ml decoder whose achievable rate is given by . for @xmath267 and @xmath260 , the rate of the joint decoder is @xmath268 finally , let us compare the three rates in the setting where @xmath269 and where the parameter @xmath147 in our channel model tends to zero according implies that @xmath270 . ] to @xmath271 in that special case , we can observe that @xmath272 hence , the loss from using the decorrelator instead of the integer - forcing receiver becomes unbounded in this regime as @xmath177 . furthermore , the integer - forcing receiver achieves the same scaling as the joint decoder . in this example , we illustrate the difference between the proposed integer - forcing architecture and the lattice - reduction receiver . first , we note that , unlike the integer - forcing receiver , the lattice - reduction receiver is not required to use a lattice code but it should use a constellation with regular spacing , such as pam or qam . however , the key difference is that the effective channel matrix for lattice - reduction receivers is restricted to be unimodular while the effective channel for integer - forcing receivers can be any full - rank integer matrix . in this example , we show that this restriction can result in an arbitrarily large performance penalty . we consider the @xmath273 mimo channel with channel matrix : @xmath274 a simple calculation shows that the inverse of this channel matrix is given by @xmath275 since @xmath276 has non - integer entries , @xmath33 is not unimodular . the coefficient matrix that maximizes the achievable rate for the exact integer - forcing receiver from corollary [ cor : ratesub ] is @xmath277 leading to an effective noise variance in each stream that satisfies @xmath278 by contrast , following the lattice - reduction receiver , we must ensure that the resulting effective channel matrix is unimodular . using the fact that @xmath279 is a basis for the body - centered cubic ( bcc ) lattice , it can be shown that the best choice of matrix is @xmath280 it follows that the effective noise variance in the worst stream is given by @xmath281 hence , as the number of antennas becomes large ( @xmath282 ) , restricting the effective matrix to be unimodular results in an arbitrarily large loss . finally , we illustrate the point that the integer - forcing receiver can sometimes be arbitrarily worse than optimal joint decoding . to see this , we consider a @xmath225 mimo channel with the channel matrix : @xmath283 where @xmath284 . the rate attainable via joint ml decoding is @xmath285 we note that the inverse of the channel matrix is given by @xmath286 we bound the achievable rate of exact integer - forcing from corollary [ cor : ratesub ] as follows @xmath287 let @xmath288 and consider the regime @xmath177 . the gap between the optimal joint receiver and the integer - forcing linear receiver can be arbitrarily large . however , as we will see in section [ sec : outage ] , the average behavior of the integer - forcing linear receiver is close to the joint decoder under a rayleigh fading distribution for medium to high @xmath15 . we now demonstrate that integer - forcing receiver nearly matches the performance of the joint ml decoder under a slow fading channel model . since the integer - forcing receiver can mimic the operation performed by a zero - forcing or mmse receiver ( as well as decode messages via equations ) , it is not surprising that it offers higher rates . however , these architectures are often coupled with some form of sic . we will show that the integer - forcing receiver outperforms the following standard sic architectures : * v - blast i : the receiver decodes and cancels the data streams in a predetermined order , irrespective of the channel realization . each data stream has the same rate . see for the rate expression . * v - blast ii : the receiver selects the decoding order separately for each channel realization in such a way as to maximize the effective snr for the data stream that sees the worst channel . each data stream has the same rate . see for the rate expression . * v - blast iii : the receiver decodes and cancels the data streams in a predetermined order . the rate of each data stream is selected to maximize the sum rate . the rate expression is given in section [ subsec : rateallocation ] . in sections [ subsec : outage ] and [ subsec : dmt ] , we compare these schemes through simulations as well as their diversity - multiplexing tradeoffs . for completeness , we also compare integer - forcing to an sic architecture that allows for both variable decoding order and unequal rate allocation in appendix [ ap : vblast4 ] . we adopt the standard quasi - static rayleigh fading model where each element of the complex channel matrix is independent and identically distributed according to a circularly symmetric complex normal distribution of unit variance . the transmitter is only aware of the channel statistics while the receiver knows the exact channel realization . as a result , we will have to cope with some outage probability @xmath289 . [ def : outage ] assume there exists an architecture that encodes each data stream at the same rate and achieves sum rate @xmath51 . for a target rate @xmath290 , then the outage probability is defined as @xmath291 for a fixed probability @xmath292 $ ] , we define the _ outage rate _ to be @xmath293 we have assumed that each data stream is encoded at the same rate . this is optimal for linear receivers under isotropic fading . however , when sic is used , rate allocation can be beneficial in an outage scenario . to compare the performance of integer - forcing to sic with rate allocation , we consider v - blast iii in this section . v - blast iii performs sic with a fixed decoding order and allows for rate allocation among the different data streams . without loss of generality for rayleigh fading , if we fix a decoding order , we may take it to be @xmath294 . from , the achievable rate for stream @xmath127 is @xmath295 since the streams are decoded in order , the later streams will achieve higher rates on average than the earlier streams . v - blast iii allocates lower rates to earlier streams and higher rates to later streams . we now generalize definition [ def : outage ] to include rate allocation . assume an architecture that achieves rate @xmath296 in stream @xmath127 . for a target rate @xmath290 , the the outage probability is given by : @xmath297 for a fixed probability @xmath292 $ ] , we define the _ outage rate _ to be : @xmath298 we now compare the outage rate and probabilities for the receiver architectures discussed above . it is easy to see that the zero - forcing receiver performs strictly worse than the mmse receiver and v - blast i performs strictly worse than v - blast ii . we have chosen to omit these two architectures from our plots to avoid overcrowding . figure [ f : out2p ] shows the @xmath151 percent outage rate and figure [ f : out5p ] shows the @xmath299 percent outage rate . in both cases , the integer - forcing receiver nearly matches the rate of the joint ml receiver while the mmse receiver achieves significantly lower performance . the sic architectures with either an optimal decoding order , v - blast ii , or an optimized rate allocation , v - blast iii , improve the performance of the mmse receiver significantly but still achieve lower rates than the integer - forcing receiver from medium @xmath15 onwards . our simulations suggest that the outage rate of the integer - forcing receiver remains within a small gap from the outage rate of the joint ml receiver . however , we recall from the example given in subsection [ ex:4 ] that it is not true that the integer - forcing receiver is uniformly near - optimal for all fading realizations . figure [ f : poutro3 ] shows the outage probability for the target sum rate @xmath300 . we note that the integer - forcing receiver achieves the same slope as the joint decoder . in the next subsection , we characterize the diversity - multiplexing tradeoff of the integer - forcing receiver and compare it with the diversity - multiplexing tradeoff of traditional architectures that are considered in @xcite . we show that the integer - forcing receiver attains the optimal diversity multiplexing - tradeoff in the case where each transmit antenna sends an independent data stream . complex - valued mimo channel with rayleigh fading.,width=345 ] complex - valued mimo channel with rayleigh fading.,width=345 ] complex - valued mimo channel with rayleigh fading for a target sum rate of @xmath300.,width=345 ] the diversity - multiplexing tradeoff ( dmt ) provides a rough characterization of the performance of a mimo transmission scheme at high @xmath15 @xcite . a family of codes is said to achieve spatial multiplexing gain @xmath301 and diversity gain @xmath302 if the total data rate and the average probability of error satisfy @xmath303 in the case where each transmit antenna encodes an independent data stream , the optimal dmt is @xmath304 where @xmath305 $ ] and can be achieved by joint ml decoding @xcite . the dmts achieved by the decorrelator and sic architectures are as follows @xcite : @xmath306 the decorrelator chooses the matrix @xmath81 to cancel the interference from the other data streams . as a result , the noise is heavily amplified when the channel matrix is near singular and the performance is limited by the minimum singular value of the channel matrix . in the integer - forcing linear receiver , the effective channel matrix @xmath19 is not limited to be the identity matrix but can be any full - rank integer matrix . this additional freedom is sufficient to recover the same dmt as the joint ml decoder . [ thm : dmt ] for a mimo channel with @xmath0 transmit , @xmath83 receive antennas , and rayleigh fading , the achievable diversity - multiplexing tradeoff for the integer - forcing receiver is given by@xmath307 where @xmath305 $ ] . the proof of theorem [ thm : dmt ] is given in appendix [ ap : dmt ] . figure [ fig : dmt ] illustrates the dmt for a @xmath308 mimo channel . the integer - forcing receiver achieves a maximum diversity of @xmath309 while the decorrelator and v - blast i achieve can only achieve a diversity of @xmath151 since their performance is limited by the worst data stream . v - blast ii achieves a higher dmt than v - blast i but a lower diversity than the integer - forcing receiver since its rate is still limited by the worst stream after the optimal decoding order is applied . v - blast iii achieves the optimal diversity at the point @xmath310 since only one data stream is used in transmission . for values of @xmath311 , the achievable diversity is suboptimal . as noted earlier , receiver architectures based on zero - forcing face a rate penalty when the channel matrix is ill - conditioned . integer - forcing circumvents this issue by allowing the receiver to first decode equations whose coefficients are matched with those of the channel . from one perspective , the resulting gains are of a similar nature as those obtained by lattice - reduction receivers . one important difference is that integer - forcing applies a modulo operation at the receiver prior to decoding , which retains the linear structure of the codebook . this allows us to derive closed - form rate expressions analogous to those for traditional linear receiver . typically , lattice reduction is used at the symbol level followed by a decoding step @xcite . while this form of lattice reduction can be used to obtain the full receive diversity @xcite , it does not seem to suffice in terms of rate . another key advantage of integer - forcing is that it completely decouples the spatial aspect of decoding from the temporal aspect . that is , the search for the best integer matrix @xmath19 to approximate the channel matrix @xmath33 is completed before we attempt to decode the integer combinations of codewords . thus , apart from the search for the best @xmath19 , which in a slow - fading environment does not have to be executed frequently , the complexity of the integer - forcing receiver is similar to that of the zero - forcing receiver . from our outage plots , it is clear that the integer - forcing receiver significantly outperforms the basic mmse receiver . moreover , integer - forcing beats more sophisticated sic - based v - blast architectures , even when these are permitted to optimize their rate allocation while integer - forcing is not . we note that it is possible to develop integer - forcing schemes that permit unequal rate allocations @xcite as well as a form of interference cancellation @xcite but this is beyond the scope of the present paper . integer - forcing also attains the full diversity - multiplexing tradeoff , unlike the v - blast architectures discussed above . earlier work developed lattice - based schemes that attain the full dmt @xcite but , to the best of our knowledge , ours is the first that decouples spatial decoding from temporal decoding . the caveat is that the dmt result presented in the current paper only applies if there is no spatial coding across transmit antennas , whereas the dmt results of @xcite apply in general . characterizing the dmt of integer - forcing when there is coding across transmit antennas is an interesting subject for future study . we have studied the performance of the integer - forcing linear receiver under the standard mimo channel and found that it achieves outage rates close those of the joint ml decoder as well as the same dmt . in this section , we show that integer - forcing architectures are also successful at dealing with a different kind of channel disturbance , namely interference . we assume that the interfering signal is low - dimensional ( compared to the number of receive antennas ) , and we are most interested in the case where the variance of this interfering signal increases ( at a certain rate ) with the transmit power . we show that the integer - forcing architecture can be used to perform `` oblivious '' interference mitigation . by oblivious , we mean that the transmitter and receiver are unaware of the codebook of the interferer ( if there is one ) . however , the receiver knows which subspace is occupied by the interference . by selecting equation coefficients in a direction that depends both on the interference space and on the channel matrix , the integer - forcing receiver reduces the impact of interference and attains a significant gain over traditional linear receivers . we will characterize the generalized degrees - of - freedom show that it matches that of the joint ml decoder . oblivious receivers have been thoroughly studied in the context of cellular systems @xcite and distributed mimo @xcite . for ease of notation and tractability , the discussion presented in this section is limited to channels whose channel matrix is square , i.e. , with equal number of transmit and receive antennas . recall that the real - valued representation of the @xmath273 complex - valued mimo channel ( see definition [ def : channel ] ) is given by @xmath312 where @xmath313 is the channel output , @xmath314 is the real - valued representation of the fading matrix , @xmath315 is the channel input , and the noise @xmath316 has i.i.d . gaussian entries with unit variance . in this section , we extend the standard mimo channel to include the case of interference . the generalized model has channel output @xmath317 where @xmath33 is the channel matrix , @xmath44 is the channel input , and @xmath318 is the noise , all as in the previous model . an external interferer adds @xmath319 in the direction represented by the column space of @xmath320 . we assume that each element of @xmath207 is i.i.d . gaussian with variance @xmath321 . we assume that @xmath322 is fixed during the whole transmission block and known only to the receiver . the definition for messages , rates , encoders , and decoders follow along similar lines as those for the standard mimo channel ( see definitions [ def : messages ] , [ def : encoders ] , [ def : decoder ] , and [ def : rate ] in section [ sec : problem ] ) . as in the case without interference , traditional linear receivers process the channel output @xmath113 by multiplying it by a @xmath323 matrix @xmath81 to arrive at the effective output @xmath324 and recover the message @xmath1 using only the @xmath86 row of the matrix @xmath325 by analogy to , the achievable sum rate can be expressed as @xmath326 where @xmath327 represents the achievable rate for the @xmath86 data stream ( using gaussian codebooks ) , @xmath328 again , let us discuss several choices of the matrix @xmath153 the decorrelator , given by @xmath262 , removes the interference due to other data streams but does not cancel the external interference @xmath322 ( except in the very special case where the subspace spanned by @xmath322 is orthogonal to the subspace spanned by @xmath276 ) . alternatively , if we choose @xmath329 where @xmath330 is the @xmath331 matrix whose rowspace is orthogonal to the columnspace of @xmath332 then the external interference term is indeed nulled . the resulting output @xmath333 can then be processed by a traditional linear receiver . this scheme achieves good performance in high @xmath321 regimes but does not perform well in high @xmath15 regimes since the interference due to the other data streams is mostly unresolved . the mmse receiver improves the performance of the both architectures by choosing @xmath334 . however , since there are @xmath34 data streams and the interference is of dimension @xmath335 it is impossible to cancel both the interference from other data streams and the external interference with any matrix @xmath81 . one way out of this conundrum is to reduce the number of transmitted streams to @xmath336 . for this scenario , the mmse receiver can be applied to mitigate both the external interference and the interference from other data streams . complexity permitting , we can again improve performance by resorting to successive interference cancellation architectures . the achievable rate for v - blast i in the standard mimo channel from becomes @xmath337 where @xmath338 and @xmath339 . the achievable rate for v - blast ii follows by maximizing the rate in over all decoding orders @xmath92 . we apply the integer - forcing linear receiver proposed in section [ sec : architecture ] to the problem of mitigating interference ( see figure [ fig : integerinf ] ) . the channel output matrix @xmath113 is first multiplied by a fixed matrix @xmath81 to form the matrix @xmath79 whose @xmath86 row is the signal fed into the @xmath86 decoder . each such row can be expressed as @xmath340 where @xmath155 is the effective channel to the @xmath86 decoder , @xmath341 is the effective interference with variance @xmath342 , and @xmath156 is the effective noise with variance @xmath157 . the next theorem and its following remarks generalize theorem [ thm : rate ] , corollary [ cor : ratesub ] , and corollary [ cor : bopt ] to include the case with interference . ( -24,-65)(190,40 ) ( -13,32 ) ( -1,0)@xmath61 ( 4,0)(10,0 ) ( 10,-5)(23,5 ) ( 16.5,0)@xmath62 ( 29,3.5)@xmath9 ( 23,0)(41,0 ) ( 3.5 , 12)@xmath63 ( -13,-16 ) ( -1,0)@xmath64 ( 6,0)(10,0 ) ( 10,-5)(23,5 ) ( 16.5,0)@xmath65 ( 30,3.5)@xmath66 ( 23,0)(41,0 ) ( 24 , -22.5 ) ( 4,0)(16,60 ) ( 10 , 30)@xmath33 ( 46 , -50.5 ) ( 4,-20)(16,30 ) ( -8,13)(4,13 ) ( -13,13)@xmath343 ( -13,6)@xmath63 ( -8,-5)(4,-5 ) ( -13,-5)@xmath344 ( 10 , 7)@xmath322 ( 16,-15)(28,32 ) ( 28,35 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 16,25)(28,79 ) ( 28,82 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 42,32 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath67 ( 3,0)(21,0 ) ( 27,0)(44,0 ) ( 42,4.5)@xmath68 ( 94,-22.5 ) ( 0,0)(15,60 ) ( 8 , 30)@xmath81 ( 97,32 ) ( 12,0)(31,0 ) ( 22,4.5)@xmath106 ( 31,5)(46,-5 ) ( 38.5,0)@xmath107 ( 46,0)(63,0 ) ( 54,4)@xmath345 ( 50 , 12)@xmath63 ( 42,-16 ) ( -2,0)(5,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 0,0)3 ( -2,0)(2,0 ) ( 0,-2)(0,2 ) ( 0,8)(0,3 ) ( 0,12)@xmath346 ( 3,0)(21,0 ) ( 27,0)(44,0 ) ( 42.5,4)@xmath347 ( 135 , 12)@xmath63 ( 97,-16 ) ( 12,0)(31,0 ) ( 22,4.5)@xmath110 ( 31,5)(46,-5 ) ( 39,0)@xmath111 ( 46,0)(63,0 ) ( 54,4.5)@xmath348 ( 159,-22.5 ) ( 0,0)(18,60 ) ( 9,30)@xmath21 ( 177,10)(184,10 ) ( 188 , 24)@xmath122 ( 188 , 12)@xmath63 ( 188 , -6)@xmath123 ( 130,-40)@xmath349 \hspace{-0.05in}\mod q$ ] [ thm : rateinterference ] consider the mimo channel with channel matrix @xmath314 and interference matrix @xmath320 . for any full - rank integer matrix @xmath159 and any @xmath323 matrix @xmath350^t$ ] , the following sum rate is achievable using the integer - forcing linear receiver : @xmath351 where @xmath352 is given by @xmath353 exact integer - forcing selects @xmath354 . the achievable rate can be expressed more concisely as @xmath355 the optimal projection matrix that maximizes the achievable rate in theorem [ thm : rateinterference ] is given by @xmath356 in the case without interference , the equation coefficients @xmath357 should be chosen in the direction of the maximum eigenvector of @xmath191 to minimize the effective noise ( see figure [ fig : equations ] ) . when the interference is large , the equations coefficients should instead be chosen as close to orthogonal to the effective interference as possible . consider the ( suboptimal ) rate expression in . the effective " noise variance in the @xmath86 stream is @xmath358 let @xmath218 be the maximum singular value of @xmath276 and @xmath359 . the effective noise variance can be bounded by @xmath360 in the high interference regime ( @xmath361 ) , the equation coefficients should be chosen orthogonal to the direction of the effective " interference @xmath362 to minimize the effective noise variance . this is illustrated in figure [ fig : eqnsinf ] . in the case of traditional linear receivers , the equation coefficients are fixed to be the unit vectors : @xmath363^t , \mathbf{a}_2 = [ 0~1~\cdots0]^t , \ldots , \mathbf{a}_{2 m } = [ 0~0~\cdots1]^t$ ] . as a result , the interference space spanned by @xmath362 has significant projections onto at least some of the decoding dimensions @xmath133 . by contrast , in the case of the integer - forcing linear receiver , since @xmath364 need only be linearly independent , we can choose all of the decoding dimensions @xmath133 to be close to orthogonal to @xmath365 ( 2,40)(255,120 ) ( 0,0 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 30,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 45,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 75,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 90,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,45)(72.5,55 ) ( 60,45)(20,90 ) ( 28,98)@xmath362 ( 60,45)(75,45 ) ( 60,45)(60,60 ) ( 60,65)@xmath245 ( 82,45)@xmath246 ( 105,0 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 30,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 45,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 75,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 90,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 105,0 ) ( 0,30)(0,45)(0,60)(0,75)(0,90)(0,105 ) ( 60,45)(72.5,55 ) ( 60,45)(20,90 ) ( 28,98)@xmath362 ( 60,45)(105,75 ) ( 60,45)(75,60 ) ( 112,75)@xmath246 ( 75,65)@xmath245 [ fig : equationsinf ] to illustrate the impact of choosing equation coefficients in a fashion suitable to mitigate external interference , we consider the @xmath225 mimo channel with channel matrix @xmath33 and one - dimensional interference space @xmath322 given by @xmath366 where @xmath367 . in the case of the decorrelator , we invert the channel to arrive at the effective output : @xmath368 where @xmath369 . for @xmath361 , the effective noise variances scale as @xmath370 using the integer - forcing linear receiver with the choice of equations @xmath371^t$ ] and @xmath372^t$ ] , the effective channel output to the second decoder is @xmath373 where @xmath374 is the codeword sent by the @xmath375 antenna . it follows that the effective noise variances are @xmath376 where @xmath377 is a constant that does not scale with @xmath321 . in this example , the integer - forcing linear receiver is able to completely cancel the effect of interference in the second stream by choosing equation coefficients appropriately . we evaluate the generalized degrees of freedom for the @xmath273 complex mimo channel with @xmath378-dimensional interference . we specify the interference - to - noise ratio through the parameter @xmath379 where @xmath380 and consider the case where @xmath381 . the generalized degrees of freedom are defined as follows ( see @xcite ) : ( generalized degrees - of - freedom ) for a given channel matrix @xmath33 and interference matrix @xmath322 , the generalized degrees - of - freedom of a scheme is @xmath382 where @xmath383 is the achievable sum rate of the scheme . ( rational independence ) we call a matrix @xmath384 rationally independent if for all @xmath385 , we have that @xmath386 we consider the set of matrices @xmath387 such that @xmath388 is rationally independent . it can be seen that this set has lebesgue measure one . in the next theorem , we show that for this class of matrices , the integer - forcing linear receiver achieves the same number of generalized degrees of freedom as the joint decoder , and is thus optimal . [ thm : dof ] consider the @xmath273 complex mimo channel with @xmath378 dimensional interference . the integer - forcing linear receiver achieves the generalized degrees of freedom @xmath389 for a set of @xmath390 that have lebesgue measure one . a straightforward derivation shows that the optimal joint decoder with @xmath34 streams of data achieves the following generalized degrees of freedom @xmath391 for all full - rank channel matrices @xmath392 . the linear mmse receiver with @xmath34 data streams and the linear mmse receiver with @xmath393 data streams achieve the following degrees of freedom for all full - rank channel matrices @xmath392 : @xmath394 when @xmath34 data streams are transmitted ( on the real - valued representation of the complex mimo channel ) , the mmse receiver does not achieve the optimal number of degrees of freedom since it treats the interference as noise at high @xmath15 while the integer - forcing linear receiver mitigates the interference . when only @xmath395 data streams are transmitted , the linear mmse receiver can first cancel the interference and then separate the data streams to achieve a degree of freedom of @xmath395 . however , this is suboptimal for all regimes @xmath396 ( see figure 12 ) . a straightforward calculation shows that when the number of transmitted data streams is between @xmath395 and @xmath34 , the performance is strictly suboptimal in terms of degrees of freedom . mimo channel with @xmath397-dimensional interference @xmath398,width=345 ] [ fig : dof ] our proof of theorem [ thm : dof ] uses the following lemma . recall that a set of vectors is linearly independent if none of the vectors can be written as a linear combination of the others . [ lm : diophantine ] let @xmath399 be rationally independent and assume @xmath400 for all @xmath401 . there exists a @xmath402 such that for all @xmath403 , there exist @xmath34 linearly independent integer vectors @xmath404^t \in \mathbb{z}^{2 m - 2k } \times \mathbb{z}^{2k}$ ] for @xmath405 satisfying @xmath406 where @xmath377 is a constant that is independent of @xmath407 . lemma [ lm : diophantine ] bounds the approximation of @xmath408 with @xmath34 linearly independent integer vectors . its proof is given in appendix [ ap : diophantine ] . we now prove theorem [ thm : dof ] . ( theorem [ thm : dof ] ) to establish this result , we use the ( generally suboptimal ) choice of the matrix @xmath81 that we have referred to as exact integer - forcing , i.e. , from . the achievable rate of this version of the integer - forcing linear receiver is given by @xmath409 with @xmath410 , the effective noise in the worst data stream can be expressed as @xmath411 where @xmath412 is the maximum singular value of @xmath276 and we use the shorthand @xmath413 . let us partition @xmath414 into two parts , @xmath415 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath416 and @xmath417 . observe that with probability one , @xmath414 has rank @xmath418 ( hence , is full - rank ) . this implies that we can permute the columns of @xmath414 in such a way as to ensure that its last @xmath418 columns are linearly independent . if we use the same permutation on the coefficients of the vector @xmath419 our upper bound on the effective noise variance given in will remain unchanged . therefore , without loss of generality , we may assume that @xmath420 has rank @xmath418 . we define @xmath421 . then , we can write @xmath422\\ & = [ -\mathbf{t } , \mathbf{i}_{2k}]\ . \label{eq : tildej}\end{aligned}\ ] ] let the coefficients for the @xmath86 equation be given by @xmath423^t$ ] where @xmath424 and @xmath425 . we use to bound @xmath426 : @xmath427 \mathbf{a}_m\|^2 \\ & \leq \lambda^2_{\text{\tiny{max}}}(\mathbf{s}_2 ) \|[-\mathbf{t } , \mathbf{i}_{2k}]\mathbf{a}_m\|^2\\ \label{eq : boundja } & = \lambda^2_\text{\tiny{max}}(\mathbf{s}_2 ) \|\mathbf{t}\mathbf{q}_m - \mathbf{p}_m\|^2\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath428 the maximum singular value of @xmath420 . combining with , the effective noise variance is bounded as follows : @xmath429 we proceed to bound the quantity @xmath430 . we decompose @xmath408 into its integer and fractional parts : @xmath431 where @xmath432 represents the integer part of @xmath408 and @xmath433 represents the fractional part of @xmath408 . we define @xmath434^t\\ \tilde{\mathbf{a } } & = [ \tilde{\mathbf{a}}_1 \cdots \tilde{\mathbf{a}}_{2m}]^t\\ \mathbf{g } & = \left ( \begin{array}{ccc } \mathbf{i}_{2m-2k } & \mathbf{0 } \\ -\mathbf{t}_i & \mathbf{i}_{2k } \end{array } \right ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath435 is a @xmath323 lower triangular matrix with non - zero diagonal elements , it has rank @xmath34 . we note that @xmath436 since @xmath435 is invertible , it follows that if the matrix formed by the coefficient vectors @xmath437 is full - rank , then the matrix formed by @xmath438 is full - rank and vice versa . from , it have that @xmath439 and , from , we have that @xmath440 from , , and , the effective noise variance can be upper bounded by @xmath441 combining and , the effective noise variance from is bounded by @xmath449 let @xmath407 scale according to @xmath450 . it follows that @xmath451 setting @xmath452 , we find that the generalized degrees - of - freedom are @xmath453 which concludes the proof of theorem [ thm : dof ] . in this paper , we proposed a new receiver architecture for mimo channels that bridges the performance gap between traditional linear receivers and the optimal joint ml decoder . we studied the scenario without coding across the transmit antennas and found that the proposed integer - forcing linear receiver performs close to the optimal joint receiver while incurring only some additional complexity over traditional linear receivers . we characterized the diversity multiplexing tradeoff of the proposed architecture and showed that is it the same as that of the joint ml decoder . we considered a generalized mimo channel model with interference and found that the integer - forcing receiver can be used to effectively mitigate interference in an oblivious . furthermore , the proposed architecture achieves the same generalized degrees - of - freedom as the joint ml decoder . an interesting question for future work is how the integer - forcing architecture behaves when coding across transmit antennas is permitted . recall that v - blast ii performs decoding in the optimal order and v - blast iii allows for rate allocation . in this appendix , we introduce v - blast iv , which allows for both rate allocation and an optimized decoding order . under v - blast iv , the data streams are decoded with respect to the ordering @xmath454 where @xmath455 is given by . we compare the behavior of v - blast iv to that of the integer - forcing linear receiver in figures [ f : outv41 ] , [ f : outv45 ] , [ f : poutpv4 ] . the results show although v - blast iv achieves good performance for low to medium @xmath15 , the integer - forcing linear achieves higher outage rates and lower outage probabilities in the medium to high @xmath15 regime . complex - valued mimo channel with rayleigh fading.,width=355 ] complex - valued mimo channel with rayleigh fading.,width=355 ] complex - valued mimo channel with rayleigh fading for a target sum rate of @xmath300.,width=355 ] in order to establish theorem [ thm : dmt ] , we need a few key facts about lattices . a lattice @xmath456 is a set of points that satisfy the following properties : @xmath457 we call the rank-@xmath458 matrix @xmath435 a generator matrix for @xmath459 if @xmath460 we use the definition of dual lattices from @xcite . given a lattice @xmath456 with a rank-@xmath458 generator matrix @xmath435 , the dual lattice @xmath461 has generator matrix @xmath462 , @xmath463 to prove theorem [ thm : dmt ] , we consider _ successive minima _ for the involved lattices , a standard concept from the diophantine approximation literature ( see e.g. @xcite ) , defined as follows . [ def : smmse ] let @xmath464 be the unit ball . given a lattice @xmath456 with a rank-@xmath458 generator matrix , the @xmath86 successive minimum @xmath465 where @xmath466 is given by @xmath467 definition [ def : smmse ] implies that @xmath468 for any lattice @xmath459 . the following basic property linking the successive minima of a lattice with those of its dual lattice is key to our proof . [ lm : smdual ] let @xmath456 be an arbitrary lattice with a rank-@xmath458 generator matrix and @xmath461 be its dual lattice . the successive minima for @xmath459 and @xmath461 satisfy the following inequality : @xmath469 finally , we also need the following result concerning a random gaussian lattice . [ lm : smfirst ] let @xmath45 be the real - valued decomposition of a @xmath470 complex gaussian matrix with i.i.d . rayleigh entries . let @xmath471 be the lattice generated by @xmath33 . then @xmath472 where @xmath473 and @xmath474 are constants independent of @xmath475 . ( theorem [ thm : dmt ] ) . let @xmath476 be the target rate where @xmath305 $ ] . for a fixed set of equations @xmath215^t$ ] and a fixed preprocessing matrix @xmath477^t$ ] , the outage probability is given by @xmath478 for a fixed set of equations @xmath19 , we are free to choose any projection matrix @xmath81 , resulting in the following bound : @xmath479 we then choose the best set of full - rank equations by optimizing over all integer matrices @xmath159 with non - zero determinant : @xmath480 we use properties of dual lattices to bound . for a fixed @xmath33 , let @xmath481 be the lattice generated by @xmath33 and @xmath482 be the dual lattice generated by @xmath483 , @xmath484 using the definition of successive minima ( definition [ def : smmse ] ) , it follows that @xmath485 we now express in terms of the successive minima of @xmath482 , @xmath486 using lemma [ lm : smdual ] , we can bound the successive minima of @xmath482 in terms of the successive minima of @xmath481 , @xmath487 combining and , the outage probability is upper bounded by @xmath488 this probability can in turn be upper bounded using lemma [ lm : smfirst ] . for large @xmath15 , we find that @xmath489 where @xmath490 are constants independent of @xmath15 . the achievable diversity for multiplexing gain @xmath301 is thus @xmath491 in order to prove lemma [ lm : diophantine ] , we use a technique introduced in @xcite . we first construct semi - norms @xmath492 and @xmath493 as well as a norm @xmath494 . we then apply minkowski s theorem ( see theorem [ thm : sm ] below ) to find @xmath34 linearly independent integer vectors that achieve the successive minima ( with respect to the norm @xmath495 ) . afterwards , we will show that these integer vectors satisfy the conditions in lemma [ lm : diophantine ] . we will need the following definitions and theorems in the proof . let @xmath494 be a norm . the unit ball with respect to @xmath495 ( or @xmath495-unit ball ) is denoted by @xmath496 the volume of @xmath497 is denoted by @xmath498 . [ def : smgen ] let @xmath494 be a norm and @xmath497 be the @xmath495-unit ball . the @xmath86 successive @xmath495-minimum @xmath499 is given by @xmath500for @xmath501 . [ thm : sm ] for any norm @xmath494 , the successive @xmath495-minima satisfy @xmath502 [ dirichlet ] [ thm : dirichlets ] for any @xmath399 and @xmath503 , there exists a @xmath504^t \in \mathbb{z}^{2m-2k } \times \mathbb{z}^{2k } \backslash \mathbf{0}$ ] such that @xmath505 [ thm : kg ] fix a function @xmath506 . if @xmath507 then , for almost all @xmath399 satisfying @xmath400 for all @xmath401 , there are only finitely many solutions @xmath504^t \in \mathbb{z}^{2m-2k } \times \mathbb{z}^{2k}$ ] to the inequality @xmath508 theorem [ thm : sm ] can be found in ( * ? ? ? * equation 1.1 ) . theorems [ thm : dirichlets ] and [ thm : kg ] can be found in many standard diophantine approximation texts ( see , for instance , @xcite ) . ( lemma [ lm : diophantine ] ) . for any vector @xmath509 , we denote the first @xmath395 components by @xmath510 and the remaining @xmath418components by @xmath511 and will thus write @xmath512 from the lemma statement , @xmath513^t$ ] is a ( rationally independent ) @xmath514 real - valued matrix with @xmath400 for all @xmath401 . for a fixed @xmath408 , we define the semi - norms @xmath183 , @xmath515 as follows : @xmath516 for a fixed @xmath517 , we let @xmath518 denote the minimum value of @xmath519 under the constraint @xmath520 , @xmath521^t \neq \mathbf{0 } } } \|\mathbf{t}\mathbf{q } - \mathbf{p}\| , \label{eq : lambda1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath522 denote the integer vector that achieves @xmath518 @xmath523^t \neq \mathbf{0 } } } \|\mathbf{t}\mathbf{q } - \mathbf{p}\|,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath524 be the value of @xmath525 evaluated by @xmath515 , @xmath526 based on the seminorms @xmath183 and @xmath515 , we define the function @xmath494 as follows : @xmath527 in the sequel , we show that @xmath495 is a norm for @xmath528 . we define the @xmath323 matrix @xmath529 as follows : @xmath530\ ] ] note that we can rewrite the function @xmath495 using @xmath529 : @xmath531 since exchanging rows of a matrix only affects the sign of its determinant , we have that @xmath532 \right ) \right| \ . \end{aligned}\ ] ] now we use the fact that the determinant of a lower triangular matrix is just the product of its diagonal entries , latexmath:[\ ] ] and , we have that @xmath596 by definition , we have that @xmath597 using , , , and , and assuming that @xmath407 is sufficiently large , we bound @xmath598 as follows : @xmath599 where @xmath591 is a constant that does not depend on @xmath407 . similarly , we can bound @xmath600 as follows : @xmath601 which concludes the proof of lemma [ lm : diophantine ] . the authors are grateful to or ordentlich for pointing out the suboptimality of unimodular integer forcing , giuseppe caire for corrections in the proof of theorem [ thm : dof ] , and seyong park for many helpful discussions . , `` ieee standard for information technology telecommunications and information exchange between systems local and metropolitan area networks specific requirements part 11 : wireless lan medium access control ( mac ) and physical layer ( phy ) specifications amendment 5 : enhancements for higher throughput , '' _ ieee std 802.11n-2009 _ , pp . c1502 , 29 2009 . j. winters , j. salz , and r. gitlin . , `` the impact of antenna diversity on the capacity of wireless communication systems , '' _ ieee transactions on communications _ , vol . 42 , no . 234 , pp . 1740 1751 , feb / mar / apr 1994 . u. niesen and p. whiting , `` the degrees of freedom of compute - and - forward , '' in _ proceedings of the ieee international symposium on information theory ( isit 2011 ) _ , st . petersburg , russia , august 2011 . m. o. damen , h. el gamal , and g. caire , `` on maximum - likelihood detection and the search for the closest lattice point , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , vol . 49 , no . 23892402 , october 2003 . a. burg , m. borgmann , m. wenk , m. zellweger , w. fichtner , and h. bolcskei , `` vlsi implementation of mimo detection using the sphere decoding algorithm , '' _ ieee journal of solid - state circuits _ , vol . 40 , no . 7 , pp . 1566 1577 , july 2005 . t. richardson , m. shokrollahi , and r. urbanke , `` design of capacity - approaching irregular low - density parity - check codes , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , vol . 47 , no . 2 , pp . 619 637 , february 2001 . m. varanasi and t. guess , `` optimum decision feedback multiuser equalization and successive decoding achieves the total capacity of the gaussian multiple - access channel , '' in _ conference record of the 31st asilomar conference on signals , systems , and computers _ , pacific grove , ca , usa , november 1997 , pp . 1405 1409 . p. w. wolniansky , g. j. foschini , g. d. golden , and r. a. valenzuela , `` v - blast : an architecture for realizing very high data rates over the rich - scattering wireless channel , '' in _ ursi international symposium on signals , systems , and electronics ( issse 98 ) _ , pisa , italy , sept .- oct . 1998 . h. yao and g. w. wornell , `` lattice - reduction - aided detectors for mimo communication systems , '' in _ proceedings of the ieee global communications conference ( globecom 2002 ) _ , taipei , taiwan , november 2002 . m. taherzadeh , a. mobasher , and a. khandani , `` lll reduction achieves the receive diversity in mimo decoding , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ 53 , no . 12 , pp . 48014805 , december 2007 . h. el gamal , g. caire , and m. o. damen , `` lattice coding and decoding achieve the optimal diversity - multiplexing tradeoff of mimo channels , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ 50 , no . 6 , pp . 968985 , june 2004 . j. jalden and p. elia , `` dmt optimality of lr - aided linear decoders for a general class of channels , lattice designs and system models , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , 56 , no . 10 , pp . 47654780 , october 2010 . o. ordentlich , j. zhan , u. erez , m. gastpar , and b. nazer , `` practical code design for compute - and - forward , '' in _ proceedings of the ieee international symposium on information theory ( isit 2011 ) _ , st . petersburg , russia , august 2011 . j. zhan , b. nazer , , o. ordentlich , u. erez , and m. gastpar , `` integer - forcing architectures for mimo : distributed implementation and sic integer - forcing architectures for mimo : distributed implementation and sic , '' in _ conference record of the 44th asilomar conference on signals , systems , and computers _ , monterey , ca , november 2010 . a. sanderovich , s. shamai , , h. v. poor , and y. steinberg , `` uplink macro diversity of limited backhaul cellular network , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , 55 , no . 8 , pp . 34573478 , august 2009 . m. taherzadeh , a. mobasher , and a. khandani , `` communication over mimo broadcast channels using lattice - basis reduction , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , 53 , no . 12 , pp . 45674582 , december 2007 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the class of interacting binaries known as the classical algols " are semi - detached systems that contain a late - type giant or subgiant that fills its roche lobe and is transferring mass onto a much more luminous and more massive b a main sequence star . a new class of binaries has been found with properties that are similar to those of the classical algols , except that the mass gaining component is a late - type giant or subgiant like its companion . these systems were first recognized by @xcite and are now referred to as the cool algols . " they typically display signs of magnetic activity in the form of ca ii h@xmath10k emission , h@xmath11 emission , star spots , and strong x - ray emission . only about a dozen cool algols are known , and many of them were mistakenly assigned to the larger group of rs cvn binaries which contain a luminous k - type primary with a fainter f g type companion . the main difference between the cool algols and the rs cvn systems is that the former are undergoing roche lobe overflow , while the latter are detached ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? bd@xmath1706 ( rxj0441.9@xmath100537 , ppm 147827 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , j2000 , @xmath14 ) is one of the recent additions to this rare category of cool algols , and was discovered in the course of spectroscopic follow - up observations of a sample of x - ray sources selected from the rosat all - sky survey south of the taurus - auriga star - forming region @xcite . although that x - ray sample was originally designed to favor the detection of t tauri stars , which are also quite active , bd@xmath1706 was quickly found to be of an entirely different nature . @xcite ( hereafter paper i ) reported a double - lined spectroscopic orbital solution with a period of 18.9 days , a very small and possibly spurious eccentricity , and a mass ratio of @xmath15 ( @xmath16 ) , typical of the algol systems . the system contains two cool giants . the primary " ( the more massive star ) is detached , while the secondary " has filled its critical lobe or may overflow it ( paper i ) . the star we have called the secondary " is currently the larger , less massive , and cooler component , as in the classical algols . spectroscopic convention is used throughout this paper instead of the notation used in papers on stellar evolution , which refer to the initially more massive star as the primary . the general properties of the system were described in paper i. although photometry for bd@xmath1706 was not available at the time of that study , eclipses were estimated to be very likely . subsequent photometric monitoring in the optical confirmed this prediction @xcite . the general characteristics of the cool algols are fairly well defined ( see * ? ? ? * and paper i ) , but accurate information on individual systems is still far from complete . only five of the members , aside from bd@xmath1706 , have spectroscopic orbits for both components ( rz cnc , ar mon , rt lac , ad cap , and rv lib ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and light curve analyses for the first three of these have yielded the absolute masses and radii necessary in order to understand their properties . the remaining five objects identified as possible members of this class ( uz cnc , v1061 cyg , av del , gu her , and v756 sco ; * ? ? ? * ) have very little in the way of observations and in some cases even the orbital periods are poorly known . the high - quality spectroscopic orbit presented for bd@xmath1706 in paper i , combined with the fact that the system is eclipsing , offers the opportunity to determine the absolute dimensions of the components very accurately . to that end , photometric observations in the @xmath0 system were continued after the initial report by @xcite . we present here a full analysis of those data , and also a re - analysis of the spectroscopic material in paper i with improved techniques and the benefit of the additional information provided by the light - curves . the latter offer a means for evaluating subtle distortions in the doppler measurements due to the close proximity of the stars . as a result , we are able to determine here the absolute masses of both components with uncertainties smaller than 2% , and the radii with errors smaller than 3% , which are now the best determinations for any system of the cool algol class . the global x - ray properties and the activity level of bd@xmath1706 ( h and k emission , variable h@xmath11 line strength ) were studied in some detail in paper i , where it was established that the hotter primary star is most likely the site of the bulk of the activity in the binary . additional x - ray observations for the system were secured by us with the rosat satellite essentially over a complete 18.9-day cycle ( yielding an x - ray light curve ) , and clearly show the primary eclipse but not the secondary eclipse . an analysis of these data is presented here as well , allowing us to obtain information about the geometry of the x - ray emitting region surrounding the active star . the photometric observations of bd@xmath1706 in the optical were conducted at the gettysburg college observatory ( gettysburg , pa ) with a 16-inch f/11 ealing cassegrain reflector . the detector was a photometrics thermoelectrically - cooled ccd camera with a front - illuminated thompson 7896 chip with @xmath17 pixels . bd@xmath1706 was observed on 94 nights during the 19971999 observing seasons . a total of 80 , 93 , 133 and 137 observations were made in the johnson @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 filters , respectively . the comparison and check stars used are tyc 95 - 1495 - 1 ( gsc 00095 - 1495 ) and hd 29764 ( gsc 00091 - 00262 , bd@xmath1704 , sao 111980 ) , respectively . basic properties for these stars are listed in table [ tab : compcheck ] . coverage of the primary eclipse in the @xmath18 and @xmath19 filters was very poor during the first two seasons ( before jd 2,451,000 ) , and therefore those data were not used in the analysis below . the precision of an individual differential photometric measurement is estimated to be 0.010 mag , 0.010 mag , 0.009 mag , and 0.010 mag in the @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 passbands , respectively , derived from the comparison and check stars under the assumption that they do not vary . the observations in the sense @xmath22variable minus comparison@xmath23 are listed in table [ tab : obsb ] , table [ tab : obsv ] , table [ tab : obsr ] , and table [ tab : obsi ] . the depth of the eclipses in the @xmath19 band is approximately 0.52 mag for the primary minimum and 0.34 mag for the secondary . changes in the overall brightness at the quadratures are fairly obvious from season to season . they are not unexpected given the activity level displayed by the system , and will be discussed in more detail in [ sec : phot ] . the spectroscopic material used here is the same as that reported in paper i. briefly , it consists of 41 single - order echelle spectra obtained from 1994 march to 1996 march with the 1.5-m wyeth reflector at the oak ridge observatory ( harvard , massachusetts ) , the 1.5-m tillinghast reflector at the fred l. whipple observatory ( mount hopkins , arizona ) , and the multiple mirror telescope ( also atop mount hopkins , arizona ) prior to its conversion to a monolithic 6.5-m mirror . the spectra cover 45 with a central wavelength of 5187 , and the resolving power is @xmath24 . the reductions to obtain radial velocities for both components are slightly different from those used in paper i , and are described later . x - ray observations of bd@xmath1706 were obtained with the high resolution imager instrument ( hri ; * ? ? ? * ) aboard the rosat satellite over a period of 18 days covering essentially a full orbital cycle of the binary , from 1997 august 18 to september 5 . the measurements were made at intervals of one day , with the exception of a 3-day gap due to scheduling constraints . the exposure times were typically about 3.5 ksec each , achieving signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratios ranging from 6 to 15 per broad - band observation ( 0.1 to 2.4 kev ) , with a mean s / n of 10 . the observations were reduced with the extended scientific analysis software ( exsas , * ? ? ? * ) version 2001 running under eso - midas version 01feb . in addition to considering the full energy range of rosat , we subsequently divided the recorded counts into a soft band including detector channels 0 through 3 ( 0.1 to 0.5 kev ) and a hard band including channels 4 through 15 ( 0.6 to 2.4 kev ) in order to obtain additional information from the analysis of these data . we performed standard local and map source detection in all three spectral bands . the s / n ratios range from 4 to 10 in the soft band and from 4 to 11 in the hard band . this allows us to define a hardness ratio " @xmath25 , where @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the hard and soft count rates , respectively ( see * ? ? ? * ) . the individual x - ray observations are listed in table [ tab : xray ] . the columns give the heliocentric julian date and the exposure times , followed by the count rates , the corresponding errors , and the maximum likelihood ( _ ml _ ) estimator for the soft , hard , and broad bands @xcite . the quantity _ ml _ provides a measure of the existence of the source above the local background . for example , a maximum likelihood of 7.4 ( 14.3 ) corresponds to a 3.5@xmath28 ( 5@xmath28 ) detection . the last three columns give the hardness ratio and its corresponding uncertainty , as well as the phase in the orbit of the binary do not exactly add up to the broad - band counts , although the difference is minimal . the mean local background is estimated separately in each band and then subtracted from the corresponding total counts , which contributes to the slight discrepancy . ] . figure [ fig : hist ] shows the time history of the optical photometry , the spectroscopy , and the x - ray observations . because of the variability of the object , the time coverage of the optical light curves and the radial velocities is relevant for the modeling of the system , as we describe in [ sec : spec ] . in the analyses below all data were phased with the ephemeris @xmath29 where the epoch refers to the time of primary eclipse ( more massive star occulted by the other star ) , and @xmath30 is the number of cycles counted from this epoch . this ephemeris was determined from the radial velocity observations described in [ sec : spec ] , and supersedes the one given in paper i. examination of the raw light curves for bd@xmath1706 revealed significant changes over the three observing seasons that precluded their merging into a single data set for analysis . the extent of the changes is such that , for example , during the 19971998 season the light level in the @xmath19 band at the first quadrature was lower than at the second quadrature , whereas by the following season the situation had reversed . variations of this nature are common in active systems , and are well explained by the presence of surface features ( spots ) on one or both stars . in order to minimize the scatter , a compromise between the number of observations , the completeness of the phase coverage ( particularly at the minima ) , and the intrinsic variations was made by dividing the observations into two data sets at julian date @xmath31 ( see figure [ fig : hist ] ) . as mentioned above , the measurements in the @xmath18 and @xmath19 filters in data set # 1 do not cover the primary eclipse , and they were therefore not used for the final fits . light curve analyses were carried out separately for each bandpass in each data set ( @xmath32 for data set # 1 , and @xmath0 for data set # 2 ) , and also for the combined data . the light curve solutions were performed with the wilson - devinney code @xcite in a mode appropriate for semi - detached systems , in accordance with the information available for the stars from paper i. specifically , we used mode 5 " for a secondary that is filling its limiting lobe . detached and overcontact configurations were tried as well , but the solutions were never as satisfactory as those in the semi - detached mode . they always converged towards the secondary star filling its roche lobe and the primary well within its critical surface , in agreement with the assessment in paper i. solutions were found for the modified gravitational potential of the primary ( @xmath33 , in the wilson - devinney usage ) , the inclination angle ( @xmath34 ) , the relative monochromatic luminosity of the primary ( @xmath35 ) , the mean temperature of the secondary ( @xmath36 ) , and a phase offset ( @xmath37 ) . the temperature of the primary was held fixed at the spectroscopic value of @xmath38 k , as was the mass ratio @xmath39 ( see [ sec : spec ] ) . we have assumed the orbit to be circular , consistent with the results of the new spectroscopic analysis below . the monochromatic luminosity of the secondary ( @xmath40 ) was computed by the program directly from the temperatures of the primary and secondary , the luminosity of the primary , the radiation laws , and the geometry of the system . limb - darkening coefficients were interpolated from the tables by @xcite for the appropriate temperatures and for surface gravities of @xmath41 and @xmath42 ( see [ sec : spec ] ) . a value of 0.5 was adopted for the bolometric albedo of both components , appropriate for stars with convective envelopes . gravity brightening coefficients were interpolated from the models by @xcite . aside from the usual light elements , the distortions mentioned above in the light curves suggested the presence of one or more spots requiring additional free parameters . the wilson - devinney code is capable of accounting for spots ( assumed to be circular in shape ) based on a simple representation with four additional parameters : the longitude ( @xmath43 , in degrees ) measured counter - clockwise ( as seen from above ) from the line joining the centers of the stars , the latitude ( @xmath44 , in degrees ) , the angular radius ( @xmath45 , in degrees ) , and a temperature factor ( @xmath46 ) representing the contrast in temperature between the spot and the surrounding photosphere . numerical experiments showed that in our case the fits can not usually distinguish the component on which the spots are located , since similarly good solutions resulted with the spots on either star . in the rs cvn systems the spots are typically located on the cooler star , which is usually the more active component . there are a number of cases , however , in which the spots have instead been shown to be on the hotter star ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? in bd@xmath1706 there are strong indications that the activity is in fact associated with the hotter star ( the primary ) , as evidenced by the h@xmath11 emission ( see paper i ) and also the x - ray properties discussed later in [ sec : xray ] . it is therefore not unreasonable to assume in the following that the spottedness in this system is primarily associated with the hotter star . more complicated models with spots on both stars are possible , but are probably not justified given the data available . the maximum brightness outside of eclipse is much the same for data sets # 1 and # 2 , although it occurs at phase 0.75 in the first set and at phase 0.25 in the second . the lower brightness levels at the other quadrature in each data set are not quite as similar to each other and show more scatter in the photometric observations . this suggests that the lower light levels may be due to one or more cool spots ( which tend to change with time in other similarly active stars ) , as opposed to hot spots being the cause of the higher brightness at the other quadratures . spots that are cooler than the photosphere have typically been found also in virtually all rs cvn systems ( although warm features have been reported in a few cases ; see , e.g. , * ? ? ? thus we will assume here that the spots are cool . the situation for bd@xmath1706 obviously calls for the cool spots to be located at roughly opposite longitudes in the two epochs , and we found that a single spot at each epoch gave an adequate representation of the light curves , within the observational errors . further tests showed that , due to the strong correlation between the size and temperature of the spots , it was not possible to determine both simultaneously from the observations at our disposal . grids of preliminary solutions at fixed values of _ tf _ from 0.5 to 1.0 indicated a slight preference for a spot in data set # 1 with @xmath47 ( 800 k cooler than the photosphere ) , and a similar spot in data set # 2 with @xmath48 ( 650 k cooler than the photosphere ) . these values are within the typical range seen in other rs cvn binaries @xcite . therefore , in the following we have held _ tf _ fixed at these values , and the spot radius was left free . we also found that the sensitivity of the solutions to the latitude of the spot is very weak . experiments with fixed values of @xmath44 from 0 to 90 indicated only a very slight preference for mid - latitude features , with fits at higher or lower latitudes being almost indistinguishable . although spots on the sun are usually found at low latitudes , doppler imaging studies have shown that rs cvn systems tend to display high - latitude features and even spots that straddle the pole ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? while bd@xmath1706 is similar to the rs cvn binaries in many respects , the latter systems typically rotate much more rapidly ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? theoretical studies suggest that rapid rotation in convective stars leads to the emergence of spots at higher latitudes @xcite , and there is some observational support for this trend ( see * ? ? ? therefore , for this study we have adopted a fixed latitude of 45 , in agreement with the above and also with the theoretical work by @xcite that focuses specifically on evolved stars similar to those in bd@xmath1706 . initially light curve solutions were obtained separately for each bandpass in each data set ( @xmath32 for data set # 1 , and @xmath0 for data set # 2 ) , to evaluate the consistency between them . the results were found to be reasonably similar , except that the second data set showed a larger scatter in the temperature of the secondary ( @xmath36 ) and in the potential of the primary ( @xmath33 ) . solutions were also obtained from the combined @xmath32 and @xmath0 observations from data sets # 1 and # 2 , respectively , which were also quite similar to each other . since the main geometric properties ( @xmath33 and @xmath34 ) are not expected to change from season to season , the results for these two parameters from the two data sets were averaged ( with weights proportional to the internal errors ) , and fixed in subsequent analyses . we then repeated the fits and computed the average secondary temperature ( @xmath49 k ) from the simultaneous multi - band analyses . finally , we fixed @xmath36 to this value , and we solved for the remaining parameters including the size ( @xmath45 ) and longitude ( @xmath43 ) of the spots , which clearly do change with time . the results are given in table [ tab : ds1 ] and table [ tab : ds2 ] for data set # 1 and # 2 , respectively . we show the separate fits for each filter before fixing any of the parameters , and also the simultaneous multi - band analyses in the last column calculated with @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath36 set to their average values . also listed are the fractional radii ( @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , in terms of the separation ) as well as the relative radius of a spherical star with the same volume as the distorted stars ( @xmath54 ) , for the primary and secondary . the uncertainties given in these tables are standard errors as reported by the wilson - devinney code . experiments were also carried out to explore the significance of third light ( @xmath55 ) , but in all cases the results were consistent with @xmath56 . both eclipses in bd@xmath1706 are partial , with approximately 65% of the light of the primary being blocked at phase 0.0 . the latter star is nearly spherical in shape since the difference between its polar radius and the radius directed towards the inner lagrangian point is less than 0.5% . parameters @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 in table [ tab : ds1 ] and table [ tab : ds2 ] confirm that the secondary is distorted because it fills its roche lobe . a graphical representation of the observations and light curve solutions is given in figure [ fig : lc1 ] and figure [ fig : lc2 ] for data sets # 1 and # 2 . the @xmath57 residuals are shown at the bottom for each passband . the @xmath18 and @xmath19 light curves in data set # 1 lack coverage at the primary minimum , and do not allow one to determine any of the parameters reliably . although we show them here for completeness , these observations were not used in any of the fits described above . for these @xmath18 and @xmath19 solutions all geometric and radiative parameters as well as the spot parameters were adopted from the combined @xmath32 solution , and only the primary luminosity was allowed to vary . the fits are consequently poorer . the spots that were found to provide a good fit to the observations in both data sets are represented in figure [ fig : spotpic ] , with the size and separation of the stars shown to scale . the difference in longitude between one epoch and the other ( separated by approximately 1.4 years ) is about 140 . the surface area covered by the spots is in line with what is seen in other active systems , and reaches @xmath5820% of one hemisphere of the primary star in data set # 1 , and @xmath5817% in data set # 2 . the procedures used here for the reduction of the spectroscopic material are similar to those described in paper i in that we derived radial velocities for the two components using todcor @xcite , a two - dimensional cross - correlation technique well suited to our relatively low s / n spectra . however , a number of improvements were introduced that justified a re - analysis of the original data . first , we now have at our disposal a new library of synthetic spectra based on more recent model atmospheres by r. l.kurucz , which provide a somewhat better match to the spectra of real stars . the use of these new templates has a small effect on the temperature and rotational velocity ( @xmath59 ) derived for the components of bd@xmath1706 , and can potentially affect the radial velocities as well . we re - determined the @xmath59 values by running extensive grids of correlations as described in paper i. the results were @xmath60 and @xmath61 , with estimated errors of 1 and 2 , respectively . the primary value is 1 larger than in paper i , and the secondary value is unchanged . the new effective temperatures , derived from similar grids , were @xmath38 k and @xmath62 k , with uncertainties of 100 k. these differ by less than 100 k from the determinations in paper i. the new primary value was adopted for the light curve solutions described above . a second improvement has to do with residual systematic errors in the raw velocities , mostly due to the relatively narrow spectral window of these observations . experience with similar spectroscopic material for other binary systems has shown that these errors can be quite significant in some cases @xcite . we have investigated these errors for the present system by means of numerical simulations that were discussed in detail by @xcite . briefly , we generated a set of artificial binary spectra by combining the primary and secondary templates in the appropriate ratio and applying velocity shifts for both components as computed from a preliminary orbital solution at the actual times of observation of each of our spectra . these artificial spectra were then processed with todcor in exactly the same way as the real observations , and the resulting velocities were compared with the input ( synthetic ) values . the differences @xmath22todcor minus synthetic@xmath23 are typically under 0.5 , but they are systematic in nature . even though the effect on the masses is relatively small in this particular case , we have nevertheless applied these differences as corrections to the measured velocities of bd@xmath1706 . the corrected velocities are listed in table [ tab : rvs ] ( columns 2 and 3 ) . the differences with the values reported in paper i are generally below 1 . as a result of the proximity and distorted shapes of the stars ( see , e.g. , figure [ fig : spotpic ] ) , the radial velocities measured for the components of bd@xmath1706 are biased to some extent because of the loss of symmetry in the intensity distribution across the disks of the stars . in addition , the observations collected during the eclipses suffer from the well - known rossiter effect @xcite , which depends on the rotation rate . the combined magnitude of these two effects on the measured velocities , computed with the aid of the wilson - devinney program , is illustrated in figure [ fig : rvdist ] . the change in the primary velocities is essentially confined to the eclipses ( and is mostly due to the rossiter effect since that star is not far from the spherical shape ) , but the secondary velocities show changes throughout the entire orbital cycle because of the highly distorted shape of the roche - lobe filling star . the corrections for the case of bd@xmath1706 can reach values as large as 4 , and are listed in columns 4 and 5 of table [ tab : rvs ] . the final values for the radial velocities used below , after applying these adjustments , are given in columns 6 and 7 . while the corrections described in the preceding paragraph ( which depend only on the geometry of the system ) do not change with time , the surface features modeled in the light curves , which can also affect the measured velocities , do change significantly as seen in [ sec : phot ] . spots have an effect on the measured velocities because they too contribute to break the symmetry of the intensity distribution on the stellar disks . in this case the effect will be on the primary velocities because the spots are assumed to be on that star . the phase dependence of the effect is seen in figure [ fig : rvspot ] separately for data sets # 1 and # 2 , and was derived once again using the wilson - devinney code . specifically , the effect is calculated as the difference between the velocities from purely keplerian motion and those computed by integration over the visible disk of the star , with its non - uniform brightness distribution due to the spots . it is unclear whether the velocities we have measured by cross - correlation are affected by the full amplitude of the correction computed by this program , but presumably they will be biased to some extent in the direction indicated . unfortunately , as seen in figure [ fig : hist ] our spectroscopic observations were not simultaneous with either of the photometric data sets , so that corrections for this effect can not be applied . the magnitude of the distortion in the velocities can reach values as large as 1 ( figure [ fig : rvspot ] ) . nevertheless , as a test we applied these corrections to our velocities separately for both data sets and recomputed the spectroscopic orbit to explore the impact on the elements . for data set # 1 the changes in all derived quantities including the minimum masses are of the order of 1@xmath28 or smaller . for data set # 2 they are less than 0.5@xmath28 . our final spectroscopic orbital solution was obtained using the measured velocities corrected for proximity effects and for the rossiter distortions only . the minimum masses and the mass ratio we determine are only slightly different from those reported in paper i , but we now find that the eccentricity is indistinguishable from zero . the original solution in paper i gave a value of @xmath63 , more than 5@xmath28 different from zero . this presented something of a puzzle given that tidal forces for stars with deep convective envelopes such as those in bd@xmath1706 are expected to circularize the orbit very quickly for the relatively short period in this system , considering that both components are giants . the distortion corrections applied here appear to have solved this dilemma , and a circular orbit is adopted hereafter . the revised elements of the spectroscopic orbit are given in table [ tab : specelem ] . the ephemeris for the primary eclipse that we derive from this orbit is that given in eq.(1 ) , and was adopted for the light - curve solutions . the light ratio at the wavelength of our observations ( 5187 ) , computed as described by @xcite , is @xmath64 . a slight correction of @xmath65 is required to convert this to the visual band ( see paper i ) . the residuals of the individual observations from the orbital fit are listed in columns 8 and 9 of table [ tab : rvs ] . the light elements in the last column of table [ tab : ds1 ] and table [ tab : ds2 ] combined with the spectroscopic elements in table [ tab : specelem ] lead to the absolute masses and radii of the components , along with other derived properties . as mentioned earlier , the uncertainties listed for the light elements are strictly internal errors reported by the wilson - devinney code . more realistic errors for the inclination angle , the primary and secondary potentials , and for the secondary temperature were adopted based in part on the agreement between the solutions in the different passbands and on the sensitivity of the fits to the various parameters : @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , and @xmath69 k. the physical properties of the stars are summarized in table [ tab : absdim ] . the absolute masses are determined with errors of 1.0% and 1.7% for the primary and secondary , respectively , while the radii are good to 2.6% and 1.9% . since the difference in the depths of the minima is a very sensitive indicator of the temperature difference between the components , the later quantity is typically best determined from the light curves . in this case the result ( @xmath70 k ) is excellent agreement with our spectroscopic determination of @xmath71 k inferred in [ sec : spec ] , based on grids of cross - correlations with synthetic spectra . the ratio of the luminosities in the visual band from the light curve solutions is @xmath72 , whereas the estimate derived from the bolometric luminosities and bolometric corrections ( table [ tab : absdim ] ) is @xmath73 . the first of these values is larger than the spectroscopic estimate [ @xmath74 , a discrepancy possibly related to the presence of spots . the measured projected rotational velocity of the secondary component , @xmath75 , is consistent with the predicted value for synchronous rotation within the errors , as expected from the fact that the star is filling its critical surface . on the other hand , the rotation of the primary is formally some 15% faster than the predicted value , a 2.8@xmath28 difference that may perhaps be significant . the primaries of many other algol systems have also been found to rotate supersynchronously , and in some cases even close to the centrifugal limit ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? this spin - up is usually explained by angular momentum transfer through accretion @xcite . the inferred distance to bd@xmath1706 of 595 @xmath76 51 pc relies on the apparent brightness of the system ( @xmath77 ) , the interstellar extinction adopted in paper i ( @xmath78 ) , and bolometric corrections from @xcite . the count rates over the full spectral range ( 0.12.4 kev ) of the x - ray observations of bd@xmath1706 carried out with the rosat satellite are shown as a function of orbital phase in figure [ fig : xraycurve]a . two features of this broad - band light curve are immediately obvious : ( a ) while the primary eclipse is clearly present , there is no sign of a secondary eclipse near phase 0.5 ; ( b ) one measurement immediately preceding phase 0.5 and another one following it are about a factor of two higher than the average level of the neighboring points . the first of these features supports the notion that the primary is the x - ray active star in the system , and that the secondary contributes little , if anything , to the total x - ray luminosity of the binary . this observation is consistent with the activity evidence presented in paper i , where the primary was shown to be the dominant source of the h@xmath11 emission . as reported there , several red spectra of the binary outside of eclipse displayed relatively weak h@xmath11 absorption ( residual intensity @xmath79 ) , whereas one spectrum obtained during primary eclipse displayed a much deeper h@xmath11 line ( residual intensity @xmath80 ) . this change was interpreted as an indication that the emission from the active primary fills in the normal absorption line of the secondary at most phases in the orbit making it appear weak , except near phase 0.0 , where the primary is blocked and the secondary dominates the spectrum . the second feature unusually large x - ray flux of the two observations near phase 0.5 could possibly be due to two separate flaring events , which would not be uncommon in this type of system . we discuss this further below . a comparison with the light curves in the optical reveals two other notable characteristics of the x - ray light curve : ( c ) the duration of the primary eclipse in x - rays is much longer than in the optical ; ( d ) the primary minimum is considerably deeper in x - rays than it is in the optical . to illustrate these two features we have superimposed on figure [ fig : xraycurve]a the light curve in the @xmath20 band from data set # 1 , which is contemporaneous with the rosat observations . the optical light curve is normalized to agree with the average level of the x - ray curve outside of eclipse . we note that at the epoch of these observations the configuration of the system inferred in [ sec : phot ] includes a cool spot on the primary that is on the far side of the star at phase 0.75 and therefore does not affect the @xmath20-band light curve at the second quadrature . the solid line in figure [ fig : xraycurve]a represents the modeled @xmath20-band light curve without the effect of the spot , and the dotted line includes the distortion due to the spot , which makes the system fainter at the first quadrature . it can be seen from the figure that the total duration of the primary eclipse in the optical is approximately 0.11 in phase ( @xmath582.1 d ) , while the duration in x - rays is roughly 2.9 times longer ( @xmath580.32 in phase , or @xmath586.0 d ) . this implies that the size of the x - ray emitting region around the primary must be larger than the star itself by approximately the same factor . since the radius of the star in terms of the separation is @xmath81 ( parameter @xmath54 in table [ tab : ds1 ] ) , it follows that the radius of the associated x - ray region is @xmath82 . we note also that the mass ratio of the binary leads independently to a mean radius for the critical surface of the primary of @xmath83 . thus , the size of the x - ray emitting region around the primary happens to be very close to that of its roche lobe possibly not a coincidence and one may speculate that the x - ray emitting plasma is perhaps contained within the critical surface . since there is no evidence from the x - ray light curve of any significant emission from the secondary , one might also speculate that the coronal region around that component represents a relatively thin layer that does not extend significantly above the photosphere of the star , which already fills its roche lobe . as a result , bd@xmath1706 would appear to exhibit the curious property of being essentially an overcontact system in x - rays , and a semidetached system in the optical . at optical wavelengths ( @xmath20 band ) the brightness of bd@xmath1706 during the primary minimum drops to about 62% of the level outside of eclipse ( phase 0.75 ) . in x - rays the eclipse is much deeper , reaching down to @xmath5830% of maximum . since blocking by the same star ( the secondary ) produces significantly different depths in the optical and in x - rays , and given that the apparent size of the primary in x - rays is much larger , one possible explanation for the deeper minimum than in the optical may be that the x - ray brightness distribution on the primary is considerably more concentrated towards the center of the disk ( or toward the inner lagrangian point , which is projected not far from the center ) than in the optical . in order to simulate this situation with light - curve solution programs such as wilson - devinney , not originally intended for this type of problem , the relative sizes of the stars must be changed compared to the geometry inferred from the optical light curves , effectively by altering the mass ratio . furthermore , variations in the predicted light curve near phase 0.5 due to the changing aspect ratio of the primary ( if it is assumed to fill its critical surface in x - rays ) must be ignored as they probably do not apply at x - ray wavelengths . we find a reasonably good agreement between such a model " and the observed light curve when the effective size of the x - ray emitting region of the primary is reduced to approximately the same size as the photosphere of the lobe - filling secondary ( see figure [ fig : xraycurve]b ) . of course , any parameters derived in this way are physically meaningless and are only intended to achieve a qualitatively good fit . the reference provided by this very crude model does seem to suggest , nevertheless , that the x - ray flux preceding the primary eclipse ( beginning at phase 0.75 , and perhaps including the descending branch ) is somewhat lower than the flux after the minimum at symmetrical phases . as mentioned above , the two high x - ray points near phase 0.5 might be due to two separate flare events ( since an observation intermediate between these two shows a normal flux level ) . x - ray flares are common in rs cvn systems ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? on the other hand , the semidetached configuration in the optical is an indication that mass transfer by roche - lobe overflow may be occurring . due to the relatively large size of the primary , a stream of material from the secondary to the primary would actually impact the primary star directly rather than sweep past it and form a disk ( * ? ? ? * see also figure 11 in paper i ) . given the orbital phases at which the discrepant x - ray points in figure [ fig : xraycurve]a occur ( 0.423 and 0.539 ) , just before and just after central blocking of the secondary by the primary , it is possible that the sudden increase in x - ray flux is related to the viewing angle of the stream associated with mass transfer , which would be roughly aligned with the line of sight at these phases . detailed hydrodynamical modeling is required to investigate this further . in figure [ fig : hardx ] we have split the rosat x - ray observations of bd@xmath1706 into a soft band ( 0.10.5 kev ) and a hard band ( 0.62.4 kev ) in order to investigate the possibility that there might be a difference in the behavior as a function of orbital phase . the run of the count rates turns out to be quite similar , however , with the soft band being slightly lower throughout ( figure [ fig : hardx]a ) . the changes in the hardness ratio as defined in [ sec : obs ] are shown in figure [ fig : hardx]b . within the errors the _ hr _ values are fairly constant , the decrease toward the primary minimum being only marginally significant . in particular , the observations near phase 0.5 pointed out in the broad - band light curve ( figure [ fig : xraycurve]a ) that are possibly associated with flaring episodes show no sign that the x - ray energy becomes significantly harder ( observations marked with circles ) , as would be expected if the temperature were to increase due to heating of the plasma . the combination of our new @xmath0 photometry with a reanalysis of the spectroscopy reported in paper i has allowed us to obtain highly precise absolute masses and radii for both components of the semidetached system bd@xmath1706 , as well as the effective temperatures and other properties . among the dozen or so known cool algols , this is now by far the one with the best determined physical parameters . only three others have published light - curve solutions to date ( rz cnc , ar mon , and rv lib ) . in paper i the eclipsing nature of bd@xmath1706 was not yet known , so there was no direct information on the orbital inclination angle although some constraints were available based on other evidence . qualitative conclusions on the history and evolutionary state of the system were drawn there based upon the assumption that the inclination angle was large , and therefore that the true values of the masses and the radii were not far from the lower limits derived for those quantities . we can now confirm the validity of that assumption in paper i , and consequently also of those conclusions : the present configuration of bd@xmath1706 was probably reached as a result of case b mass transfer @xcite , and the initial mass ratio of the system is likely to have been close to unity ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) so that the original secondary had enough time to begin its evolution off the main sequence before the original primary reached the point of roche - lobe overflow and started transferring mass onto it ( eventually leading to a mass ratio reversal ) . the minimum amount of mass exchanged ( under conservative mass transfer ) is @xmath84 m@xmath4 . thus , the secondary appears to have lost at least 2/3 of its original mass . as noted in our earlier study of this system , although the current mass ratio ( @xmath85 ) is quite typical of classical algol systems the relatively cool temperature of the current primary ( 5000 k ) is not . this difference with the much hotter primaries of the classical algols is at least qualitatively well explained by the ideas about the evolution of cool algols mentioned above and discussed at length in paper i. evidence from our optical light curves suggests the presence of large surface inhomogeneities ( spots ) which are quite common in similarly active systems . significant shifts in the location ( longitude ) of these features are seen in bd@xmath1706 over a period of 1 - 2 years , which are also consistent with changes seen in other rs cvn binaries . our x - ray light curve showing only the primary eclipse confirms the report in paper i that the hotter and more massive primary star is the dominant site of activity in this binary . it is interesting to note that this is not typically the case in rs cvn systems , where the cooler star is usually the more magnetically active component . the x - ray observations also offer interesting clues about the geometry and other properties of the x - ray emitting region , which may be confined to the size of the critical lobe of the current primary star . photometric and spectroscopic studies of other binaries systems identified as cool algols are currently underway as part of a long - term project to study this very interesting class of active stars . detailed analyses of those cases along the lines of the one presented here for bd@xmath1706 are expected to provide further glimpses into their properties and evolutionary histories . we thank the anonymous referee for numerous comments and helpful suggestions . this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france , and of nasa s astrophysics data system abstract service . rn wishes to acknowledge financial support from the bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung through the deutsche zentrum fr luft- und raumfahrt e.v . ( dlr ) under grant number 50 or 0003 . lm would like to acknowledge the help of julia lynch and akbar rizvi in making these observations . the gettysburg college observatory is supported by gettysburg college with additional funding for the ccd camera provided by the national science foundation . garca - alvarez , d. , foing , b. h. , montes , d. , oliveira , j. , doyle , j. g. , messina , s. , lanza , a. f. , rodon , m. , abbott , j. , ash , t. d. c. , baldry , i. k. , bedding , t. r. , buckley , d. a. h. , cami , j. , cao , h. , catala , c. , cheng , k. p. , domiciano de souza jr . , a. , donati , j. f. , hubert , a. m. , janot - pacheco , e. , hao , j. x. , kaper , l. , kaufer , a. , leister , n. v. , neff , j. e. , neiner , c. , orlando , s. , otoole , s. j. , schfer , d. , smartt , s. j. , stahl , o. , telting , j. , & tubbesing , s. 2003 , , 397 , 285 c@c@ c@c@ c@c@ c@c 772.6936 & @xmath920.412 & 827.7321 & @xmath920.457 & 903.5477 & @xmath920.486 & 1208.6844 & @xmath920.282 + 772.7038 & @xmath920.400 & 828.5234 & @xmath920.447 & 914.5239 & @xmath920.328 & 1209.5255 & @xmath100.113 + 773.6906 & @xmath920.315 & 834.5772 & @xmath920.396 & 915.5189 & @xmath920.233 & 1209.5601 & @xmath100.095 + 777.6886 & @xmath920.341 & 840.5560 & @xmath920.156 & 1133.7158 & @xmath100.017 & 1209.5601 & @xmath100.120 + 777.7616 & @xmath920.341 & 844.5362 & @xmath920.459 & 1136.7110 & @xmath920.408 & 1209.6537 & @xmath100.125 + 778.6654 & @xmath920.418 & 845.5979 & @xmath920.492 & 1140.6862 & @xmath920.421 & 1209.7217 & @xmath100.133 + 784.6604 & @xmath920.085 & 846.5413 & @xmath920.491 & 1142.6528 & @xmath920.223 & 1210.5415 & @xmath920.256 + 784.7649 & @xmath920.089 & 853.6187 & @xmath920.402 & 1148.6430 & @xmath920.434 & 1216.5883 & @xmath920.362 + 795.6793 & @xmath920.307 & 854.6542 & @xmath920.445 & 1149.6591 & @xmath920.411 & 1219.5979 & @xmath920.104 + 798.6679 & @xmath920.450 & 855.5462 & @xmath920.435 & 1157.6063 & @xmath920.492 & 1220.6234 & @xmath920.230 + 799.6417 & @xmath920.421 & 857.5909 & @xmath920.328 & 1162.6686 & @xmath920.069 & 1221.6098 & @xmath920.306 + 800.6508 & @xmath920.342 & 859.5101 & @xmath920.137 & 1165.6690 & @xmath920.371 & 1225.5947 & @xmath920.388 + 802.6055 & @xmath920.172 & 859.6675 & @xmath920.094 & 1166.6970 & @xmath920.440 & 1229.5403 & @xmath920.332 + 802.7780 & @xmath920.158 & 860.6232 & @xmath920.200 & 1170.6638 & @xmath920.285 & 1230.5336 & @xmath920.420 + 803.7220 & @xmath920.114 & 870.6699 & @xmath920.275 & 1173.6636 & @xmath920.382 & 1231.5202 & @xmath920.459 + 809.5834 & @xmath920.473 & 878.5792 & @xmath920.091 & 1180.6680 & @xmath920.187 & 1232.5722 & @xmath920.504 + 814.5945 & @xmath920.409 & 889.5291 & @xmath920.309 & 1190.6157 & @xmath100.114 & 1268.5297 & @xmath920.405 + 824.6819 & @xmath920.397 & 896.5880 & @xmath920.273 & 1198.6265 & @xmath920.303 & 1275.5187 & @xmath920.083 + 825.5523 & @xmath920.462 & 897.5484 & @xmath920.107 & 1207.6736 & @xmath920.346 & 1276.5165 & @xmath920.163 + 827.5643 & @xmath920.492 & 899.5315 & @xmath920.351 & 1208.5180 & @xmath920.303 & 1277.5134 & @xmath920.237 + c@c@ c@c@ c@c@ c@c 772.6907 & @xmath920.432 & 827.5608 & @xmath920.524 & 899.5290 & @xmath920.356 & 1208.5156 & @xmath920.331 + 773.6792 & @xmath920.385 & 827.7283 & @xmath920.494 & 903.5449 & @xmath920.500 & 1208.6819 & @xmath920.312 + 777.6699 & @xmath920.392 & 828.5199 & @xmath920.476 & 914.5212 & @xmath920.352 & 1209.5229 & @xmath100.046 + 777.6784 & @xmath920.393 & 834.5746 & @xmath920.423 & 915.5230 & @xmath920.301 & 1209.5577 & @xmath100.031 + 777.7580 & @xmath920.401 & 840.5508 & @xmath920.167 & 1117.7249 & @xmath920.405 & 1209.6508 & @xmath100.041 + 778.6590 & @xmath920.449 & 840.5621 & @xmath920.182 & 1118.7028 & @xmath920.468 & 1209.7102 & @xmath100.035 + 784.6547 & @xmath920.102 & 842.6729 & @xmath920.344 & 1129.6644 & @xmath920.468 & 1209.7191 & @xmath100.073 + 784.7536 & @xmath920.107 & 844.5336 & @xmath920.496 & 1130.7223 & @xmath920.434 & 1210.5387 & @xmath920.273 + 785.6335 & @xmath920.304 & 845.5953 & @xmath920.523 & 1133.7128 & @xmath920.040 & 1215.6181 & @xmath920.456 + 795.6681 & @xmath920.350 & 846.5346 & @xmath920.508 & 1136.7083 & @xmath920.421 & 1216.5854 & @xmath920.367 + 797.6278 & @xmath920.458 & 853.6160 & @xmath920.428 & 1140.6837 & @xmath920.444 & 1219.5952 & @xmath920.122 + 798.6644 & @xmath920.459 & 854.6436 & @xmath920.473 & 1142.6502 & @xmath920.247 & 1220.6178 & @xmath920.273 + 798.7559 & @xmath920.480 & 854.6458 & @xmath920.471 & 1148.6445 & @xmath920.451 & 1221.6071 & @xmath920.351 + 799.6356 & @xmath920.458 & 855.5436 & @xmath920.470 & 1149.6565 & @xmath920.429 & 1225.5921 & @xmath920.407 + 800.6471 & @xmath920.402 & 857.5882 & @xmath920.369 & 1157.6036 & @xmath920.507 & 1229.5377 & @xmath920.347 + 802.6019 & @xmath920.142 & 859.5074 & @xmath920.162 & 1162.6661 & @xmath920.083 & 1230.5310 & @xmath920.433 + 803.7185 & @xmath920.140 & 859.6649 & @xmath920.126 & 1165.6664 & @xmath920.394 & 1231.5176 & @xmath920.474 + 809.5799 & @xmath920.491 & 860.6207 & @xmath920.193 & 1166.6945 & @xmath920.464 & 1232.5692 & @xmath920.529 + 813.7879 & @xmath920.273 & 870.6672 & @xmath920.331 & 1173.6611 & @xmath920.393 & 1268.5270 & @xmath920.425 + 813.7911 & @xmath920.292 & 878.5685 & @xmath920.134 & 1180.6655 & @xmath920.179 & 1274.5501 & @xmath920.310 + 813.7931 & @xmath920.265 & 889.5291 & @xmath920.346 & 1190.6129 & @xmath100.045 & 1275.5214 & @xmath920.090 + 814.5910 & @xmath920.419 & 896.5854 & @xmath920.299 & 1198.6206 & @xmath920.326 & 1276.5194 & @xmath920.191 + 824.6780 & @xmath920.425 & 897.5454 & @xmath920.144 & 1207.6708 & @xmath920.361 & 1277.5160 & @xmath920.305 + 825.5623 & @xmath920.491 & & & & & & + c@c@ c@c@ c@c@ c@c 474.5480 & @xmath920.417 & 528.5478 & @xmath920.346 & 824.6762 & @xmath920.472 & 1142.6482 & @xmath920.327 + 474.5930 & @xmath920.434 & 528.5859 & @xmath920.323 & 825.5468 & @xmath920.538 & 1148.6430 & @xmath920.535 + 474.6310 & @xmath920.442 & 529.5529 & @xmath920.069 & 827.5594 & @xmath920.570 & 1149.6551 & @xmath920.500 + 474.6720 & @xmath920.436 & 529.5683 & @xmath920.083 & 827.7268 & @xmath920.571 & 1157.6019 & @xmath920.577 + 477.5058 & @xmath920.489 & 529.5919 & @xmath920.096 & 828.5184 & @xmath920.529 & 1162.6646 & @xmath920.147 + 477.5638 & @xmath920.499 & 530.5133 & @xmath920.406 & 834.5729 & @xmath920.481 & 1163.6604 & @xmath920.336 + 477.6088 & @xmath920.496 & 530.5567 & @xmath920.399 & 840.5600 & @xmath920.238 & 1165.6650 & @xmath920.468 + 477.6338 & @xmath920.497 & 530.5831 & @xmath920.414 & 844.5315 & @xmath920.543 & 1166.6930 & @xmath920.531 + 477.6518 & @xmath920.497 & 546.5490 & @xmath920.457 & 845.5935 & @xmath920.575 & 1170.6589 & @xmath920.399 + 477.6718 & @xmath920.497 & 547.5586 & @xmath920.250 & 846.5327 & @xmath920.573 & 1173.6598 & @xmath920.461 + 483.4803 & @xmath920.384 & 548.5461 & @xmath920.096 & 853.6143 & @xmath920.483 & 1180.6640 & @xmath920.251 + 483.4933 & @xmath920.396 & 549.5267 & @xmath920.397 & 854.6396 & @xmath920.526 & 1190.6113 & @xmath920.043 + 483.6473 & @xmath920.417 & 552.5314 & @xmath920.497 & 855.5412 & @xmath920.532 & 1198.6206 & @xmath920.397 + 483.6563 & @xmath920.409 & 772.6879 & @xmath920.494 & 857.5866 & @xmath920.433 & 1207.6685 & @xmath920.435 + 489.6607 & @xmath920.470 & 773.6775 & @xmath920.442 & 859.5056 & @xmath920.222 & 1208.6799 & @xmath920.383 + 489.6847 & @xmath920.469 & 777.6683 & @xmath920.454 & 859.6624 & @xmath920.208 & 1209.5563 & @xmath920.074 + 491.5536 & @xmath920.032 & 777.7565 & @xmath920.462 & 859.6700 & @xmath920.192 & 1209.6492 & @xmath920.059 + 491.5636 & @xmath920.048 & 778.6568 & @xmath920.506 & 860.6190 & @xmath920.251 & 1209.7085 & @xmath920.078 + 491.5736 & @xmath920.041 & 784.6533 & @xmath920.159 & 870.6653 & @xmath920.421 & 1209.7176 & @xmath920.061 + 491.6055 & @xmath920.027 & 784.7522 & @xmath920.170 & 878.5668 & @xmath920.197 & 1210.5372 & @xmath920.346 + 497.6100 & @xmath920.454 & 785.6314 & @xmath920.364 & 889.5257 & @xmath920.408 & 1215.6097 & @xmath920.538 + 497.6280 & @xmath920.462 & 795.6657 & @xmath920.392 & 896.5838 & @xmath920.349 & 1216.5839 & @xmath920.454 + 497.6800 & @xmath920.461 & 797.6207 & @xmath920.508 & 897.5429 & @xmath920.190 & 1219.5937 & @xmath920.195 + 504.5271 & @xmath920.544 & 798.6629 & @xmath920.532 & 899.5276 & @xmath920.417 & 1220.6126 & @xmath920.356 + 504.5450 & @xmath920.549 & 799.6332 & @xmath920.525 & 903.5432 & @xmath920.561 & 1221.6048 & @xmath920.405 + 504.5686 & @xmath920.553 & 800.6455 & @xmath920.460 & 1117.7233 & @xmath920.473 & 1225.5905 & @xmath920.474 + 505.5372 & @xmath920.572 & 802.6005 & @xmath920.288 & 1118.7001 & @xmath920.522 & 1229.5362 & @xmath920.406 + 505.5740 & @xmath920.586 & 802.7744 & @xmath920.241 & 1118.7126 & @xmath920.524 & 1232.5674 & @xmath920.580 + 507.4900 & @xmath920.525 & 803.7233 & @xmath920.201 & 1129.6626 & @xmath920.527 & 1268.5255 & @xmath920.505 + 507.5100 & @xmath920.524 & 809.5782 & @xmath920.545 & 1130.7208 & @xmath920.508 & 1274.5253 & @xmath920.390 + 507.6310 & @xmath920.523 & 809.7652 & @xmath920.545 & 1133.7111 & @xmath920.136 & 1275.5227 & @xmath920.161 + 508.5222 & @xmath920.474 & 813.7806 & @xmath920.365 & 1136.7057 & @xmath920.494 & 1276.5209 & @xmath920.254 + 514.5140 & @xmath920.494 & 814.5891 & @xmath920.458 & 1140.6819 & @xmath920.506 & 1277.5194 & @xmath920.384 + 514.6029 & @xmath920.499 & & & & & & + c@c@ c@c@ c@c@ c@c 474.5550 & @xmath920.489 & 514.5256 & @xmath920.575 & 814.5870 & @xmath920.524 & 1140.6806 & @xmath920.565 + 474.5950 & @xmath920.501 & 514.6011 & @xmath920.561 & 824.6744 & @xmath920.544 & 1142.6471 & @xmath920.389 + 474.6380 & @xmath920.497 & 528.5456 & @xmath920.425 & 825.5444 & @xmath920.594 & 1148.6419 & @xmath920.586 + 474.6740 & @xmath920.497 & 528.5838 & @xmath920.385 & 827.5575 & @xmath920.625 & 1149.6539 & @xmath920.556 + 477.5108 & @xmath920.552 & 529.5488 & @xmath920.169 & 827.7251 & @xmath920.624 & 1157.6004 & @xmath920.626 + 477.5908 & @xmath920.571 & 529.5664 & @xmath920.165 & 828.5168 & @xmath920.599 & 1162.6634 & @xmath920.214 + 477.6108 & @xmath920.569 & 529.5902 & @xmath920.184 & 834.5717 & @xmath920.547 & 1163.6587 & @xmath920.416 + 477.6368 & @xmath920.571 & 530.5581 & @xmath920.465 & 840.5587 & @xmath920.315 & 1166.6909 & @xmath920.577 + 477.6558 & @xmath920.583 & 530.5850 & @xmath920.491 & 842.6694 & @xmath920.480 & 1170.6574 & @xmath920.472 + 477.6758 & @xmath920.567 & 546.5476 & @xmath920.545 & 844.5297 & @xmath920.603 & 1173.6584 & @xmath920.527 + 483.4833 & @xmath920.474 & 548.5441 & @xmath920.180 & 845.5922 & @xmath920.636 & 1180.6629 & @xmath920.333 + 483.4903 & @xmath920.476 & 549.5287 & @xmath920.476 & 846.5297 & @xmath920.614 & 1190.6102 & @xmath920.142 + 483.6453 & @xmath920.481 & 552.5296 & @xmath920.541 & 853.6131 & @xmath920.545 & 1190.6541 & @xmath920.135 + 483.6603 & @xmath920.478 & 772.6852 & @xmath920.554 & 854.6380 & @xmath920.578 & 1198.9575 & @xmath920.466 + 489.6417 & @xmath920.528 & 773.6760 & @xmath920.510 & 855.5386 & @xmath920.569 & 1207.6672 & @xmath920.504 + 489.6827 & @xmath920.534 & 777.6661 & @xmath920.523 & 857.5851 & @xmath920.493 & 1208.5128 & @xmath920.469 + 491.5516 & @xmath920.132 & 777.7550 & @xmath920.533 & 859.5043 & @xmath920.299 & 1208.6774 & @xmath920.449 + 491.5616 & @xmath920.129 & 778.6511 & @xmath920.573 & 859.6609 & @xmath920.269 & 1208.6787 & @xmath920.466 + 491.5716 & @xmath920.145 & 784.6513 & @xmath920.229 & 860.6173 & @xmath920.307 & 1209.5551 & @xmath920.156 + 491.6105 & @xmath920.137 & 784.7507 & @xmath920.236 & 870.6636 & @xmath920.450 & 1209.6478 & @xmath920.150 + 497.6050 & @xmath920.532 & 785.6289 & @xmath920.447 & 878.5655 & @xmath920.255 & 1209.7063 & @xmath920.130 + 497.6250 & @xmath920.541 & 795.6635 & @xmath920.485 & 889.5226 & @xmath920.454 & 1209.7164 & @xmath920.145 + 497.6740 & @xmath920.551 & 797.6187 & @xmath920.565 & 896.5817 & @xmath920.432 & 1210.5362 & @xmath920.433 + 498.6169 & @xmath920.476 & 798.6614 & @xmath920.597 & 897.5411 & @xmath920.238 & 1215.6081 & @xmath920.590 + 498.6339 & @xmath920.483 & 799.6308 & @xmath920.579 & 899.5256 & @xmath920.475 & 1219.5845 & @xmath920.261 + 498.6569 & @xmath920.467 & 799.6353 & @xmath920.588 & 903.5375 & @xmath920.575 & 1220.6091 & @xmath920.416 + 504.5253 & @xmath920.611 & 800.6440 & @xmath920.519 & 1117.7217 & @xmath920.525 & 1221.6032 & @xmath920.496 + 504.5426 & @xmath920.605 & 802.5989 & @xmath920.367 & 1118.6984 & @xmath920.590 & 1225.5884 & @xmath920.521 + 504.5669 & @xmath920.615 & 802.7705 & @xmath920.332 & 1118.7112 & @xmath920.574 & 1229.5347 & @xmath920.466 + 505.5347 & @xmath920.643 & 803.7137 & @xmath920.261 & 1129.6608 & @xmath920.583 & 1232.5661 & @xmath920.615 + 505.5722 & @xmath920.649 & 803.7275 & @xmath920.278 & 1129.6707 & @xmath920.583 & 1268.5243 & @xmath920.530 + 507.4912 & @xmath920.578 & 809.5767 & @xmath920.604 & 1130.7195 & @xmath920.550 & 1275.5238 & @xmath920.227 + 507.5083 & @xmath920.573 & 809.7627 & @xmath920.622 & 1133.7098 & @xmath920.222 & 1276.5225 & @xmath920.319 + 507.6290 & @xmath920.607 & 813.7789 & @xmath920.410 & 1136.7032 & @xmath920.538 & 1277.5205 & @xmath920.456 + 508.5199 & @xmath920.524 & & & & & & + ccrrrcrrrcrrrcccc 50678.6448 & 4456 & 52.43 & 7.42 & 165.2 & & 51.85 & 7.38 & 143.7 & & 104.14 & 10.47 & 299.2 & & @xmath920.01 & 0.10 & 0.900 + 50679.6073 & 2940 & 17.34 & 4.24 & 61.8 & & 16.22 & 4.15 & 43.2 & & 32.98 & 5.90 & 101.3 & & @xmath920.03 & 0.18 & 0.951 + 50680.6024 & 3621 & 20.34 & 4.57 & 64.3 & & 15.48 & 4.10 & 32.2 & & 35.65 & 6.13 & 91.4 & & @xmath920.14 & 0.17 & 0.004 + 50681.6007 & 2871 & 18.55 & 4.36 & 62.0 & & 34.06 & 5.95 & 108.1 & & 52.60 & 7.38 & 169.8 & & @xmath100.29 & 0.13 & 0.056 + 50682.5965 & 3969 & 48.01 & 7.03 & 176.5 & & 64.45 & 8.16 & 195.2 & & 112.64 & 10.78 & 370.0 & & @xmath100.15 & 0.09 & 0.109 + 50683.5920 & 3262 & 49.84 & 7.11 & 224.7 & & 60.94 & 7.89 & 227.6 & & 111.23 & 10.64 & 443.0 & & @xmath100.10 & 0.10 & 0.162 + 50684.5872 & 4190 & 64.31 & 8.10 & 254.5 & & 75.47 & 8.79 & 260.0 & & 139.26 & 11.94 & 508.8 & & @xmath100.08 & 0.09 & 0.214 + 50687.5392 & 2783 & 49.43 & 7.07 & 196.7 & & 47.69 & 6.97 & 161.8 & & 97.25 & 9.94 & 349.3 & & @xmath920.02 & 0.10 & 0.371 + 50688.5344 & 3066 & 88.18 & 9.43 & 434.4 & & 119.38 & 10.99 & 497.5 & & 207.54 & 14.49 & 928.3 & & @xmath100.15 & 0.07 & 0.423 + 50689.5924 & 3351 & 52.98 & 7.33 & 232.9 & & 66.57 & 8.24 & 242.0 & & 119.40 & 11.02 & 470.5 & & @xmath100.11 & 0.09 & 0.479 + 50690.7236 & 2993 & 102.41 & 10.15 & 490.3 & & 122.37 & 11.12 & 530.9 & & 224.66 & 15.06 & 1015.0 & & @xmath100.09 & 0.07 & 0.539 + 50691.5826 & 3615 & 40.56 & 6.41 & 173.4 & & 72.82 & 8.64 & 237.2 & & 113.82 & 10.81 & 409.3 & & @xmath100.28 & 0.09 & 0.585 + 50692.6469 & 3087 & 55.64 & 7.53 & 220.6 & & 62.93 & 8.03 & 212.1 & & 118.36 & 11.01 & 427.8 & & @xmath100.06 & 0.09 & 0.641 + 50693.5719 & 3521 & 42.45 & 6.56 & 169.2 & & 72.87 & 8.62 & 241.5 & & 114.89 & 10.82 & 407.0 & & @xmath100.26 & 0.09 & 0.690 + 50694.6045 & 4054 & 55.74 & 7.54 & 164.9 & & 54.91 & 7.53 & 175.6 & & 110.07 & 10.65 & 333.2 & & @xmath920.01 & 0.10 & 0.745 + 50695.5993 & 4000 & 53.56 & 7.39 & 187.0 & & 68.96 & 8.47 & 199.5 & & 123.10 & 11.26 & 379.6 & & @xmath100.13 & 0.09 & 0.797 + 50696.5934 & 3850 & 56.17 & 7.58 & 187.5 & & 63.95 & 8.11 & 187.0 & & 119.43 & 11.07 & 373.3 & & @xmath100.06 & 0.09 & 0.850 + cccc + @xmath34 ( @xmath93 ) & 79.55 @xmath76 0.18 & 79.46 @xmath76 0.15 & 79.470 @xmath76 0.074 + @xmath94 & 0.2055 & 0.2055 & 0.2055 + @xmath33 & 6.05 @xmath76 0.25 & 5.89 @xmath76 0.16 & 6.03 @xmath76 0.10 + @xmath95 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 + @xmath50 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1718 , 0.3439 & 0.1767 , 0.3439 & 0.1724 , 0.3439 + @xmath51 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1710 , 0.2348 & 0.1758 , 0.2348 & 0.1716 , 0.2348 + @xmath52 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1715 , 0.2442 & 0.1764 , 0.2442 & 0.1721 , 0.2442 + @xmath53 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1718 , 0.2767 & 0.1768 , 0.2767 & 0.1724 , 0.2767 + @xmath54 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1714 , 0.2513 & 0.1763 , 0.2513 & 0.1720 , 0.2513 + @xmath37 & @xmath920.00006 @xmath76 0.00058 & @xmath100.00097 @xmath76 0.00064 & @xmath100.00040 @xmath76 0.00040 + @xmath96 ( k ) & 5000 & 5000 & 5000 + @xmath36 ( k ) & 4612 @xmath76 47 & 4677 @xmath76 40 & 4638 @xmath76 11 + @xmath97 & 0.3956 @xmath76 0.0091 & & 0.3911 @xmath76 0.0004 + @xmath98 & & 0.3810 @xmath76 0.0077 & 0.3764 @xmath76 0.0004 + albedo & 0.5 , 0.5 & 0.5 , 0.5 & 0.5 , 0.5 + gravity brightening & 0.365 , 0.365 & 0.365 , 0.365 & 0.365 , 0.365 + + @xmath43 ( @xmath93 ) & 257.77 @xmath76 0.09 & 254.44 @xmath76 0.11 & 254.39 @xmath76 0.04 + @xmath44 ( @xmath93 ) & 45 & 45 & 45 + @xmath45 ( @xmath93 ) & 36.33 @xmath76 1.35 & 37.29 @xmath76 1.63 & 37.05 @xmath76 0.28 + _ tf _ & 0.84 & 0.84 & 0.84 + + @xmath99 & 0.589 & & 0.589 + @xmath100 & & 0.481 & 0.481 + @xmath101 & 0.527 & 0.527 & 0.527 + @xmath102 & 0.639 & & 0.635 + @xmath103 & & 0.511 & 0.515 + @xmath104 & 0.528 & 0.527 & 0.528 + + @xmath105 ( mag ) & 0.0126 & & 0.0127 + @xmath106 ( mag ) & & 0.0131 & 0.0133 + @xmath107 & 92 & 95 & 187 + cccccc + @xmath34 ( @xmath93 ) & 79.24 @xmath76 0.21 & 79.41 @xmath76 0.25 & 79.38 @xmath76 0.36 & 79.55 @xmath76 0.30 & 79.470 @xmath76 0.074 + @xmath94 & 0.2055 & 0.2055 & 0.2055 & 0.2055 & 0.2055 + @xmath33 & 6.39 @xmath76 0.53 & 5.83 @xmath76 0.34 & 5.83 @xmath76 0.35 & 6.07 @xmath76 0.32 & 6.03 @xmath76 0.10 + @xmath95 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 & 2.246 @xmath76 0.011 + @xmath50 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1623 , 0.3439 & 0.1787 , 0.3439 & 0.1787 , 0.3439 & 0.1712 , 0.3439 & 0.1724 , 0.3439 + @xmath51 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1616 , 0.2348 & 0.1777 , 0.2348 & 0.1777 , 0.2348 & 0.1704 , 0.2348 & 0.1716 , 0.2348 + @xmath52 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1620 , 0.2442 & 0.1783 , 0.2442 & 0.1783 , 0.2442 & 0.1710 , 0.2442 & 0.1721 , 0.2442 + @xmath53 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1622 , 0.2767 & 0.1786 , 0.2767 & 0.1786 , 0.2767 & 0.1712 , 0.2767 & 0.1724 , 0.2767 + @xmath54 ( primary , secondary ) & 0.1620 , 0.2513 & 0.1782 , 0.2513 & 0.1782 , 0.2513 & 0.1709 , 0.2513 & 0.1720 , 0.2513 + @xmath37 & @xmath920.0025 @xmath76 0.0011 & @xmath920.00331 @xmath76 0.00096 & @xmath920.00329 @xmath76 0.00088 & @xmath920.00201 @xmath76 0.00077 & @xmath920.00272 @xmath76 0.00044 + @xmath96 ( k ) & 5000 & 5000 & 5000 & 5000 & 5000 + @xmath36 ( k ) & 4565 @xmath76 67 & 4671 @xmath76 52 & 4715 @xmath76 56 & 4701 @xmath76 59 & 4638 @xmath76 11 + @xmath108 & 0.443 @xmath76 0.013 & & & & 0.4353 @xmath76 0.0007 + @xmath109 & & 0.418 @xmath76 0.016 & & & 0.4102 @xmath76 0.0006 + @xmath110 & & & 0.390 @xmath76 0.020 & & 0.3911 @xmath76 0.0006 + @xmath111 & & & & 0.361 @xmath76 0.015 & 0.3764 @xmath76 0.0007 + albedo & 0.5 , 0.5 & 0.5 , 0.5 & 0.5 , 0.5 & 0.5 , 0.5 & 0.5 , 0.5 + gravity brightening & 0.365 , 0.365 & 0.365 , 0.365 & 0.365 , 0.365 & 0.365 , 0.365 & 0.365 , 0.365 + + @xmath43 ( @xmath93 ) & 110.29 @xmath76 0.17 & 113.14 @xmath76 0.14 & 117.81 @xmath76 0.14 & 112.06 @xmath76 0.14 & 112.73 @xmath76 0.07 + @xmath44 ( @xmath93 ) & 45 & 45 & 45 & 45 & 45 + @xmath45 ( @xmath93 ) & 35.0 @xmath76 1.2 & 33.0 @xmath76 2.0 & 33.4 @xmath76 2.2 & 34.7 @xmath76 1.6 & 33.83 @xmath76 0.65 + _ tf _ & 0.87 & 0.87 & 0.87 & 0.87 & 0.87 + + @xmath112 & 0.867 & & & & 0.867 + @xmath113 & & 0.714 & & & 0.714 + @xmath99 & & & 0.589 & & 0.589 + @xmath100 & & & & 0.481 & 0.481 + @xmath101 & 0.527 & 0.527 & 0.527 & 0.527 & 0.527 + @xmath114 & 0.944 & & & & 0.931 + @xmath115 & & 0.768 & & & 0.774 + @xmath102 & & & 0.624 & & 0.635 + @xmath103 & & & & 0.508 & 0.515 + @xmath104 & 0.529 & 0.527 & 0.527 & 0.527 & 0.528 + + @xmath116 ( mag ) & 0.0169 & & & & 0.0180 + @xmath117 ( mag ) & & 0.0167 & & & 0.0171 + @xmath105 ( mag ) & & & 0.0134 & & 0.0145 + @xmath106 ( mag ) & & & & 0.0104 & 0.0112 + @xmath107 & 37 & 42 & 41 & 42 & 162 + cc@cc@cc@cc@cc 49437.5420 & @xmath9233.96 & @xmath1079.12 & @xmath920.04 & @xmath101.16 & @xmath9234.00 & @xmath1080.28 & @xmath102.91 & @xmath102.70 & 0.229 + 49614.0033 & @xmath9210.38 & @xmath9255.19 & 0.00 & @xmath101.44 & @xmath9210.38 & @xmath9253.75 & @xmath920.95 & @xmath102.34 & 0.567 + 49644.9114 & @xmath9237.77 & @xmath1072.73 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath101.06 & @xmath9237.82 & @xmath1073.79 & @xmath921.64 & @xmath920.24 & 0.202 + 49648.9088 & @xmath9227.64 & @xmath1035.10 & @xmath920.00 & @xmath921.50 & @xmath9227.64 & @xmath1033.60 & @xmath920.04 & @xmath101.27 & 0.413 + 49653.8368 & @xmath101.52 & @xmath92101.99 & @xmath100.02 & @xmath920.03 & @xmath101.54 & @xmath92102.02 & @xmath101.44 & @xmath100.43 & 0.674 + 49680.9384 & @xmath9229.45 & @xmath1043.32 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath100.30 & @xmath9229.50 & @xmath1043.62 & @xmath100.24 & @xmath100.89 & 0.108 + 49681.7665 & @xmath9233.04 & @xmath1060.85 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath100.62 & @xmath9233.09 & @xmath1061.47 & @xmath100.36 & @xmath100.73 & 0.152 + 49696.7771 & @xmath929.42 & @xmath9246.10 & @xmath920.76 & @xmath920.11 & @xmath9210.18 & @xmath9246.21 & @xmath100.66 & @xmath103.04 & 0.946 + 49700.7398 & @xmath9233.59 & @xmath1059.35 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath100.67 & @xmath9233.64 & @xmath1060.02 & @xmath100.08 & @xmath922.07 & 0.156 + 49704.7351 & @xmath9234.58 & @xmath1053.31 & @xmath920.01 & @xmath920.94 & @xmath9234.59 & @xmath1052.37 & @xmath922.61 & @xmath921.25 & 0.367 + 49708.6896 & @xmath928.72 & @xmath9263.23 & 0.00 & @xmath101.49 & @xmath928.72 & @xmath9261.74 & @xmath920.42 & @xmath920.12 & 0.576 + 49732.7773 & @xmath921.03 & @xmath9293.39 & @xmath100.05 & @xmath920.59 & @xmath920.98 & @xmath9293.98 & @xmath100.54 & @xmath100.58 & 0.851 + 49734.8029 & @xmath929.50 & @xmath9240.34 & @xmath922.56 & @xmath920.08 & @xmath9212.06 & @xmath9240.42 & @xmath100.20 & @xmath101.88 & 0.958 + 49766.6378 & @xmath921.68 & @xmath9292.32 & @xmath100.01 & @xmath100.71 & @xmath921.67 & @xmath9291.61 & @xmath100.34 & @xmath100.59 & 0.643 + 49767.6563 & @xmath100.53 & @xmath92109.05 & @xmath100.02 & @xmath920.49 & @xmath100.55 & @xmath92109.54 & @xmath920.65 & @xmath921.71 & 0.697 + 49815.6120 & @xmath9237.30 & @xmath1078.13 & @xmath920.04 & @xmath101.15 & @xmath9237.34 & @xmath1079.28 & @xmath920.36 & @xmath101.35 & 0.234 + 49964.0085 & @xmath9227.93 & @xmath1030.63 & @xmath920.04 & @xmath100.20 & @xmath9227.97 & @xmath1030.83 & @xmath920.43 & @xmath921.17 & 0.086 + 49969.9892 & @xmath9229.01 & @xmath1039.59 & 0.00 & @xmath921.44 & @xmath9229.01 & @xmath1038.15 & @xmath920.32 & @xmath100.53 & 0.403 + 49971.0119 & @xmath9224.69 & @xmath108.75 & 0.00 & @xmath922.71 & @xmath9224.69 & @xmath106.04 & @xmath922.02 & @xmath922.27 & 0.457 + 50002.9115 & @xmath9235.21 & @xmath1057.25 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath100.55 & @xmath9235.26 & @xmath1057.80 & @xmath922.34 & @xmath920.40 & 0.145 + 50006.9548 & @xmath9232.05 & @xmath1058.81 & @xmath920.01 & @xmath920.75 & @xmath9232.06 & @xmath1058.06 & @xmath100.61 & @xmath101.11 & 0.359 + 50031.9081 & @xmath920.28 & @xmath92104.85 & @xmath100.02 & @xmath920.12 & @xmath920.26 & @xmath92104.97 & @xmath920.64 & @xmath921.16 & 0.679 + 50033.8891 & @xmath102.26 & @xmath92110.16 & @xmath100.04 & @xmath921.13 & @xmath102.30 & @xmath92111.29 & @xmath100.44 & @xmath920.26 & 0.784 + 50051.7831 & @xmath102.68 & @xmath92110.90 & @xmath100.03 & @xmath920.97 & @xmath102.71 & @xmath92111.87 & @xmath100.55 & @xmath100.61 & 0.731 + 50060.8041 & @xmath9235.47 & @xmath1074.57 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath101.10 & @xmath9235.52 & @xmath1075.67 & @xmath100.88 & @xmath100.57 & 0.208 + 50061.7975 & @xmath9237.73 & @xmath1077.49 & @xmath920.03 & @xmath101.04 & @xmath9237.76 & @xmath1078.53 & @xmath920.73 & @xmath100.33 & 0.261 + 50062.7964 & @xmath9235.10 & @xmath1071.98 & @xmath920.02 & @xmath100.28 & @xmath9235.12 & @xmath1072.26 & @xmath100.41 & @xmath101.35 & 0.313 + 50064.6757 & @xmath9227.02 & @xmath1035.36 & @xmath920.00 & @xmath921.49 & @xmath9227.02 & @xmath1033.87 & @xmath100.62 & @xmath101.38 & 0.413 + 50083.6864 & @xmath9226.41 & @xmath1033.18 & @xmath920.00 & @xmath921.50 & @xmath9226.41 & @xmath1031.68 & @xmath100.59 & @xmath102.27 & 0.419 + 50085.7517 & @xmath9213.29 & @xmath9235.19 & 0.00 & @xmath103.64 & @xmath9213.29 & @xmath9231.55 & @xmath100.64 & @xmath102.64 & 0.528 + 50088.7862 & @xmath100.62 & @xmath92105.51 & @xmath100.02 & @xmath920.32 & @xmath100.64 & @xmath92105.83 & @xmath920.22 & @xmath100.32 & 0.689 + 50090.7706 & @xmath101.38 & @xmath92107.20 & @xmath100.05 & @xmath921.09 & @xmath101.43 & @xmath92108.29 & @xmath920.14 & @xmath101.32 & 0.794 + 50092.7725 & @xmath925.88 & @xmath9273.48 & @xmath100.05 & @xmath920.26 & @xmath925.83 & @xmath9273.74 & @xmath920.06 & @xmath100.17 & 0.900 + 50117.6706 & @xmath9236.09 & @xmath1075.44 & @xmath920.04 & @xmath101.13 & @xmath9236.13 & @xmath1076.57 & @xmath100.53 & @xmath100.21 & 0.217 + 50141.6862 & @xmath9219.15 & @xmath9212.00 & 0.00 & @xmath922.62 & @xmath9219.15 & @xmath9214.62 & @xmath920.25 & @xmath924.60 & 0.488 + 50143.6293 & @xmath927.21 & @xmath9270.78 & @xmath920.00 & @xmath101.48 & @xmath927.21 & @xmath9269.30 & @xmath920.43 & @xmath920.29 & 0.591 + 50144.6373 & @xmath923.42 & @xmath9293.00 & @xmath100.01 & @xmath100.70 & @xmath923.41 & @xmath9292.30 & @xmath921.50 & @xmath100.38 & 0.644 + 50145.6448 & @xmath101.11 & @xmath92107.04 & @xmath100.02 & @xmath920.48 & @xmath101.13 & @xmath92107.52 & @xmath920.10 & @xmath100.45 & 0.697 + 50148.6641 & @xmath923.71 & @xmath9291.19 & @xmath100.05 & @xmath920.54 & @xmath923.66 & @xmath9291.73 & @xmath921.68 & @xmath100.62 & 0.857 + 50149.5956 & @xmath926.31 & @xmath9269.74 & @xmath100.04 & @xmath920.23 & @xmath926.27 & @xmath9269.97 & @xmath100.18 & @xmath100.63 & 0.906 + 50153.6415 & @xmath9231.32 & @xmath1045.86 & @xmath920.05 & @xmath100.36 & @xmath9231.37 & @xmath1046.22 & @xmath920.47 & @xmath922.13 & 0.120 + lc @xmath118 ( days ) & 18.8988 @xmath76 0.0011 + @xmath119 ( ) & @xmath120 @xmath76 0.14 + @xmath121 ( ) & 19.69 @xmath76 0.22 + @xmath122 ( ) & 95.80 @xmath76 0.33 + @xmath123 & 0 ( fixed ) + @xmath124 ( hjd ) & 2,449,919.857 @xmath76 0.011 + + @xmath125 ( 10@xmath126 km ) & 5.117 @xmath76 0.059 + @xmath127 ( 10@xmath126 km ) & 24.897 @xmath76 0.088 + @xmath128 ( r@xmath4 ) & 43.12 @xmath76 0.15 + @xmath129 ( m@xmath4 ) & 2.502 @xmath76 0.026 + @xmath130 ( m@xmath4 ) & 0.5143 @xmath76 0.0085 + @xmath94 & 0.2055 @xmath76 0.0025 + + @xmath107 & 41 + @xmath131 ( ) & 1.05 + @xmath132 ( ) & 1.57 + lc@ c @xmath118 ( days ) & + @xmath133 ( r@xmath4 ) & + @xmath134 ( m@xmath4 ) & 2.633 @xmath76 0.028 & 0.5412 @xmath76 0.0093 + @xmath20 ( r@xmath4 ) & 7.55 @xmath76 0.20 & 11.02 @xmath76 0.21 + @xmath135 ( k ) & 5000 @xmath76 100 & 4640 @xmath76 150 + @xmath136 & 3.103 @xmath76 0.023 & 2.087 @xmath76 0.018 + @xmath137 ( @xmath138 g @xmath139 ) & 8.63 @xmath76 0.68 & 0.569 @xmath76 0.034 + @xmath140 ( km s@xmath141 ) & 19.9 @xmath76 0.5 & 29.0 @xmath76 0.6 + @xmath59 ( km s@xmath141 ) & 23 @xmath76 1 & 31 @xmath76 2 + @xmath142 ( l@xmath143 ) & 1.504 @xmath76 0.041 & 1.704 @xmath76 0.059 + @xmath144 ( ergs s@xmath141 ) & + @xmath145 & + @xmath146 ( mag ) & 0.97 @xmath76 0.10 & 0.47 @xmath76 0.15 + @xmath147 ( mag ) & 1.26 @xmath76 0.11 & 0.98 @xmath76 0.18 + @xmath148 ( mag ) & + distance ( pc ) & + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in the last three decades transport through molecular junctions @xcite has attracted much attention because of fundamental aspects of the processes involved , as well as of potential practical prospects . in particular , studies in this direction have intensified since the discovery of new forms of carbon allotropes , starting with the fullerenes @xcite and carbon nanotubes @xcite ( cnts ) in the 1980s and 1990s respectively , and the isolation of graphene @xcite in 2004 . the above carbon allotropes differ in shape ( curvature ) , topology , and dimensionality , with the fullerenes being zero - dimensional ( 0d ) with spherical or prolate shape , the cnts being one - dimensional ( 1d ) cylinders , and graphene being a two - dimensional ( 2d ) plane ( or 1d planar ribbons @xcite ) . in the fullerenes the carbon - atom network is made of ( non - adjacent ) hexagons and pentagons , whereas the cnts and graphene are entirely hexagonal lattices ( curved in cnts ) described in terms of a unit cell with a two - atom basis with the two carbon atoms occupying two sublattices ( @xmath0 and @xmath1 , also mapped into the up and down pseudospin states @xcite ) . in the absence of defects , in - plane ( @xmath2 ) bonding occurs through @xmath3 hybrid orbitals and out - of - plane bonding ( @xmath4 ) involves the @xmath5 orbital ; in the following only the physics of @xmath4-states is considered . the hexagonal network topology of graphene gives rise to relativistic behavior of the low - energy excitations which is captured by the ultra - relativistic massless dirac - weyl ( dw ) equation , with the fermi velocity of graphene ( @xmath6 ) replacing the velocity of light . @xcite among the many manifestations of the relativistic behavior in graphene is the klein paradox , that is `` ... unimpeded penetration of relativistic particles through high and wide potential barriers is one of the most exotic and counterintuitive consequences of quantum electrodynamics.''@xcite the surprising relativistic behavior in graphene has indeed been recognized in the 2010 nobel award in physics to a. geim and k. novosolev . another carbon - based system that was the subject of an earlier ( 2000 ) chemistry nobel award ( to a.j . heeger , a.g . macdiarmid , and h. shirakawa ) is conductive polymers , with polyacetelyne ( pac ) being a representative example . @xcite pac is a 1d chain of carbon atoms forming a conjugated polymer with @xmath7 hybridization that leads to one unpaired electron per carbon atom ( half - filled @xmath4-band ) as in graphene . linearizing the spectrum of this 1d equally - spaced carbon chain at the fermi level ( that is at the dirac points , i.e. , the zero - energy points of the energy vs momentum dispersion relation ) results in a 1d massless dirac - equation description of the low energy excitations of the system @xcite however , the equally - spaced 1d system is unstable and consequently it distorts ( structurally ) spontaneously ( peierls distortion @xcite ) yielding a modulation ( alternation ) of the spacing between successive sites that results in dimerization of successive atoms along the chain and the opening of a gap in the electronic spectrum . this dimerization can occur in two energetically degenerate , but spatially distinct , patterns , termed as equivalent domain structures . either of these domains is a realization of the 1d dirac equation with a constant mass term , @xmath8 . disruption of the dimerization pattern ( e.g. , by transforming from one domain to another along the chain ) creates a domain wall which can be described in the 1d dirac formulation through the use of a position - dependent mass term of alternating sign ( with the spatial mass - profile connecting @xmath9 with @xmath10 ) . the solution of this generalized 1d dirac equation is a soliton characterized by having zero energy and by being localized at the domain wall . in this paper , the dirac equation with position - dependent mass will be used in investigations of the electronic structure , transport , and magnetic - field - induced phenomena ( aharonov - bohm ) in graphene nanostructures such as nanoribbon junctions and rings . @xcite from the above we conclude that in the two extreme size - domains , that is a 2d infinite graphene sheet and a 1d carbon chain ( pac ) , the systems exhibit behavior that is relativistic in nature . in an attempt to bridge between these two size - domains , we briefly discuss in the following systems of successively larger width , starting from the polyacene ( a quasi-1d chain of fused benzene rings ) which may be regarded as the narrowest graphene nanoribbon ( gnr ) with zigzag edge terminations . polyacene was investigated @xcite first in 1983 . it was found that , as in graphene and pac ( without distortion ) , the valence and conduction bands of undistorted polyacene touch at the edge of the brillouin zone . however , unlike 2d graphene and pac , the dispersion relation about the touching point is quadratic , conferring a non - relativistic ( schrdinger equation ) character . we show in this paper that this surprising finding persists for sufficiently narrow gnrs with zigzag termination ( zgnrs ) . however , narrow armchair - terminated gnrs ( agnrs ) are found here to maintain relativistic behavior , with metallic ones being massless and semiconducting ones being massive ( both classes obeying the einstein energy relation ) . it this paper , we discuss mainly manifestations of relativistic and/or nonrelativistic quantum behavior explored through theoretical considerations of transport measurements in segmented graphene nanoribbons of variable width , and spectral and topological effects in graphene nanorings in the presence of magnetic fields . transport through narrow graphene channels @xmath11 particularly bottom - up fabricated and atomically - precise graphene nanoribbons @xcite @xmath11 is expected to offer ingress to unique behavior of dirac electrons in graphene nanostructures . in particular , the wave nature of elementary particles ( e.g. , electrons and photons ) is commonly manifested and demonstrated in transport processes . because of an exceptionally high electron mobility and a long mean - free path , it has been anticipated that graphene @xcite devices hold the promise for the realization , measurement , and possible utilization of fundamental aspects of coherent and ballistic transport behavior , which to date have been observed , with varying degrees of success , mainly at semiconductor interfaces @xcite , quantum point contacts @xcite , metallic wires @xcite , and carbon nanotubes @xcite . another manifestation of coherent ballistic transport are interference phenomena , reflecting the wave nature of the transporting physical object , and associated most often with optical ( electromagnetic waves , photons ) systems or with analogies to such systems ( that is , the behavior of massless particles , as in graphene sheets ) . measurements of interference patterns are commonly made with the use of interferometers , most familiar among them the multi - pass optical fabry - prot ( ofp ) interferometer @xcite . the advent of 2d forms of carbon allotropes has motivated the study of optical - like interference phenomena associated with relativistic massless electrons , as in the case of metallic carbon nanotubes @xcite and graphene 2d @xmath12-@xmath13 junctions @xcite . ( we note that the hallmark of the ofp is that the energy separation between successive maxima of the interference pattern varies as the inverse of the cavity length @xmath14 . ) for gnrs with segments of different widths , our investigations reveal diverse fabry - prot transport modes beyond the ofp case , with conductance quantization steps ( @xmath15 , with @xmath16 ) found only for uniform gnrs . in particular , three distinct categories of fabry - prot interference patterns are identified : 1 . _ fp - a : _ an _ optical _ fp pattern corresponding to _ massless _ graphene electrons exhibiting _ equal spacing _ between neighboring peaks . this pattern is associated with metallic armchair nanoribbon central segments . this category is subdivided further to _ fp - a1 _ and _ fp - a2 _ depending on whether a valence - to - conduction gap is absent ( _ fp - a1 _ , associated with metallic armchair leads ) , or present ( _ fp - a2 _ , corresponding to semiconducting armchair leads ) . 2 . _ fp - b : _ a _ massive relativistic _ fp pattern exhibiting a shift in the conduction onset due to the valence - to - conduction gap and _ unequal peak spacings_. this pattern is associated with semiconducting armchair nanoribbon central segments , irrespective of whether the leads are metallic armchair , semiconducting armchair , or zigzag . _ fp - c : _ a _ massive non - relativistic _ fp pattern with @xmath17 _ peak spacings _ , but with a vanishing valence - to - conduction gap , @xmath14 being the length of the central segment . this pattern is the one expected for usual semiconductors described by the ( nonrelativistic ) schrdinger equation , and it is associated with zigzag nanoribbon central segments , irrespective of whether zigzag or metallic armchair leads are used . we report in this paper on the unique apects of transport through segmented gnrs obtained from tight - binding non - equilibrium green s function @xcite ( tb - negf ) calculations in conjunction with an analysis based on a one - dimensional ( 1d ) relativistic dirac continuum model . this continuum model goes beyond the physics of the massless dirac - weyl ( dw ) electron , familiar from two - dimensional ( 2d ) honeycomb carbon sheets @xcite , and it is referred to by us as the dirac - fabry - prot ( dfp ) theory ( see below for the choice of name ) . in particular , it is shown that the valence - to - conduction energy gap in armchair gnr ( agnr ) segments , as well as the barriers at the interfaces between nanoribbon segments , can be incorporated in an effective position - dependent mass term in the dirac hamiltonian ; the transport solutions associated with this hamiltonian exhibit conductance patterns comparable to those obtained from the microscopic negf calculations . for zigzag graphene nanoribbon ( zgnr ) segments , the valence - to - conduction energy gap vanishes , and the mass term is consonant with excitations corresponding to massive nonrelativistic schrdinger - type carriers . the faithful reproduction of these unique tb - negf conductance patterns by the dfp theory , including mixed armchair - zigzag configurations ( where the carriers transit from a relativistic to a nonrelativistic regime ) , provides a unifying framework for analysis of coherent transport phenomena and for interpretation of experiments targeting fundamental understanding of transport in gnrs and the future development of graphene nanoelectronics . to demonstrate the aforementioned soliton formation due to structural topological effects ( discussed by us above in the context of polyacetylene ) , we explore with numerical tight - binding calculations and a dirac - kronig - penney ( dkp ) approach , soliton formation and charge fractionization in graphene rhombic rings ; this dkp approach is based on a generalized dirac equation with alternating - sign position - dependent masses . before leaving the introduction , we mention that , due to their importance as fundamental phenomena , aharonov - bohm - type effects in graphene - nanoribbons systems have attracted ( in addition to refs . ) considerable theoretical attention . @xcite these latter theoretical papers , however , based their analysis exclusively on tight - binding and/or dft calculations@xcite , or they used in addition a two - dimensional dirac equation with infinite - mass boundary conditions.@xcite transcending the level of current understanding which explores direct similaritiess with the aharonov - bohm physics in semiconductor and metallic mesoscopic rings , our work here analyzes the tb results in conjunction with a continuum 1d generalized dirac equation ( that incorporates a position - dependent mass term ) , and thus it enables investigations of until - now unexplored topological aspects and relativistic quantum - field analogies of the ab effect in graphene nanosystems . furthermore we note that oscillations in the conductance of graphene nanoribbons in the presence of magnetic barriers were found in a theoretical study @xcite ( using exclusively a tb - negf approach ) , as well as in an experimental investigation of high quality bilayer nanoribbons , @xcite and they were attributed to fabry - prot - type interference . in the absence of a continuum dirac analysis , the precise relation of such oscillatory patterns to our fabry - prot theory ( based on the incorporation of a position - dependent mass term in the dirac equation at zero magnetic field ) warrants further investigation . finally , gap engineering in graphene ribbons under strong external fields was studied in ref . . we stress again that one of the main results in this paper is the appearance of `` forbidden '' solitonic states inside the energy gap in the context of the low - magnetic - field aharonov - bohm spectra of graphene nanorings ; see the part titled `` aharonov - bohm spectra of rhombic graphene rings '' in the results section . the energy of a fermion ( with one - dimensional momentum @xmath18 ) is given by the einstein relativistic relation @xmath19 , where @xmath8 is the rest mass and @xmath20 is the fermi velocity of graphene . in a gapped uniform graphene nanoribbon , the mass parameter is related to the particle - hole energy gap , @xmath21 , as @xmath22 . following the relativisitic quantum - field lagrangian formalism , the mass @xmath8 is replaced by a position - dependent scalar higgs field @xmath23 , to which the relativistic fermionic field @xmath24 couples through the yukawa lagrangian @xcite @xmath25 ( @xmath26 being a pauli matrix ) . for @xmath27 ( constant ) @xmath28 , and the massive fermion dirac theory is recovered . the dirac equation is generalized as ( here we do not consider applied electric or magnetic fields ) @xmath29 \psi + i \hbar v_f \alpha \frac{\partial \psi}{\partial x } - \beta \phi(x ) \psi=0 . \label{direq}\ ] ] in one dimension , the fermion field is a two - component spinor @xmath30 ; @xmath31 and @xmath32 stand , respectively , for the upper and lower component and @xmath33 and @xmath26 can be any two of the three pauli matrices . note that the higgs field enters in the last term of eq . ( [ direq ] ) . @xmath34 in the first term is the usual electrostatic potential , which is inoperative due to the klein phenomenon and thus is set to zero for the case of the armchair nanoribbons ( where the excitations are relativistic ) . the generalized dirac eq . ( [ direq ] ) is used in the construction of the transfer matrices of the dirac - fabry - prot model described below . the building block of the dfp model is a 2@xmath352 wave - function matrix @xmath36 formed by the components of two independent spinor solutions ( at a point @xmath37 ) of the onedimensional , first - order generalized dirac equation [ see eq . ( 3 ) in the main paper ] . @xmath36 plays @xcite the role of the wronskian matrix @xmath38 used in the second - order nonrelativistic kronig - penney model . following ref . and generalizing to @xmath39 regions , we use the simple form of @xmath36 in the dirac representation ( @xmath40 , @xmath41 ) , namely @xmath42 where @xmath43 the transfer matrix for a given region ( extending between two matching points @xmath44 and @xmath45 specifying the potential steps @xmath46 ) is the product @xmath47 ; this latter matrix depends only on the width @xmath48 of the region , and not separately on @xmath44 or @xmath45 . the transfer matrix corresponding to a series of @xmath39 regions can be formed @xcite as the product @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the width of the @xmath51th region [ with @xmath52 . the transfer matrix associated with the transmission of a free fermion of mass @xmath8 ( incoming from the right ) through the multiple mass barriers is the product @xmath53 with @xmath54 , @xmath55 ; for armchair leads @xmath56 , while for zigzag leads @xmath57 . naturally , in the case of metallic armchair leads , @xmath58 , since @xmath59 . then the transmission coefficient @xmath60 is @xmath61 while the reflection coefficient is given by @xmath62 at zero temperature , the conductance is given by @xmath63 ; @xmath60 is the transmission coefficient in eq . ( [ trans ] ) . + the transfer matrix corresponding to either half of the rhombus can be formed @xcite as the product @xmath64 with @xmath14 being the length of half of the perimeter of the rhombus ; @xmath65 , with @xmath66 and @xmath67 . the transfer matrix associated with the complete unit cell ( encircling the rhombic ring ) is the product @xmath68 following refs . , we consider the superlattice generated from the virtual periodic translation of the unit cell as a result of the application of a magnetic field @xmath1 perpendicular to the ring . then the aharonov - bohm energy spectra are given as solutions of the dispersion relation @xmath69 = \operatorname{tr}[{\bf t}(e)]/2 , \label{disrel}\ ] ] where we have explicitly denoted the dependence of the r.h.s . on the energy @xmath70 ; @xmath71 for a rhombus with type - i corners and @xmath72 for a rhombus with type - ii corners . the energy spectra and single - particle densities do not depend on a specific representation . however , the wave functions ( upper and lower spinor components of the fermionic field @xmath73 ) do depend on the representation used . to transform the initial dkp wave functions to the ( @xmath74 , @xmath75 ) representation , which corresponds to the natural separation of the tight - binding amplitudes into the @xmath0 and @xmath1 sublattices , we apply successively the unitary transformations @xmath76 and @xmath77 . to describe the properties of graphene nanostructures in the tight - binding approximation , we use the hamiltonian @xmath78 with @xmath79 indicating summation over the nearest - neighbor sites @xmath80 . @xmath81 ev is the hopping parameter of two - dimensional graphene . to calculate the tb - negf transmission coefficients , the hamiltonian ( [ htb ] ) is employed in conjunction with the well known transport formalism which is based on the nonequilibrium green s functions @xcite . according to the landauer theory , the linear conductance is @xmath82 , where the transmission coefficient is calculated as @xmath83 $ ] . the green s function @xmath84 is given by @xmath85 with @xmath86 being the hamiltonian of the isolated device ( junction without the leads ) . the self - energies @xmath87 are given by @xmath88^{-1}\tau_{l(r)}^\dagger$ ] , where the hopping matrices @xmath89 describe the left ( right ) device - to - lead coupling , and @xmath90 is the hamiltonian of the semi - infinite left ( right ) lead . the broadening matrices are given by @xmath91 $ ] . + + + + + our results for a 3-segment ( @xmath92 , where @xmath93 is the lead width and @xmath94 is the width of the central segment ) _ all - semiconducting _ agnr , aaa ( sss ) , are portrayed in fig . [ fig1 ] [ see schematic lattice diagrams in figs . [ fig1](i ) and [ fig1](ii ) ] . a uniform semiconducting armchair gnr [ see fig . [ fig1](i ) ] exhibits ballistic quantized - conductance steps [ see fig . [ fig1](a ) ] . in contrast , conductance quantization is absent for a nonuniform 3-segment ( @xmath95 ) agnr ; see figs . [ fig1](b ) @xmath11 [ fig1](d ) . here oscillations appear instead of quantized steps . the first oscillation appears at an energy @xmath96 [ fig . [ fig1](b ) ] , which reflects the intrinsic gap @xmath97 of the semiconducting central segment belonging to the class ii of agnrs , specified @xcite by a width @xmath98 , @xmath99 . we recall that as a function of their width , @xmath100 , the armchair graphene nanoribbons fall into three classes : ( i ) @xmath101 ( semiconducting , @xmath102 ) , ( ii ) @xmath103 ( semiconducting , @xmath102 ) , and ( iii ) @xmath104 ( metallic , @xmath105 ) , @xmath99 . that the leads are semiconducting does not have any major effect . this is due to the fact that @xmath106 , and as a result the energy gap @xmath107 of the central segment is larger than the energy gap @xmath108 of the semiconducting leads [ see schematic in fig . [ fig1](iii ) ] . in the opposite case ( central segment wider than the leads ) , the energy gap of the semiconducting leads would have determined the onset of the conductance oscillations . the armchair gnr case with interchanged widths ( i.e. , @xmath109 instead of @xmath95 ) is portrayed in figs . [ fig1](e ) @xmath11 [ fig1](f ) . in this case the energy gap of the semiconducting leads ( being the largest ) determines the onset of the conductance oscillations . it is a testimonial of the consistency of our dfp method that it can reproduce [ see fig . [ fig1](d ) and fig . [ fig1](f ) ] both the @xmath95 and @xmath109 tb - negf conductances ; this is achieved with very similar sets of parameters taking into consideration the central - segment - leads interchange . we note that the larger spacing between peaks ( and also the smaller number of peaks ) in the @xmath109 case is due to the smaller mass of the central segment ( @xmath110 instead of @xmath111 ) . further insight can be gained by an analysis of the discrete energies associated with the humps of the conductance oscillations in fig . [ fig1](c ) and the resonant spikes in fig . [ fig1](e ) . indeed a simplified approximation for the electron confinement in the continuum model consists in considering the graphene electrons as being trapped within a 1d infinite - mass square well ( imsw ) of length @xmath112 ( the mass terms are infinite outside the interval @xmath112 and the coupling to the leads vanishes ) . the discrete spectrum of the electrons in this case is given @xcite by @xmath113 where the wave numbers @xmath114 are solutions of the transcendental equation @xmath115 when @xmath59 [ massless dirac - weyl ( dw ) electrons ] , one finds for the spectrum of the imsw model : @xmath116 with @xmath117 . @xmath118 which is twice the energy @xmath119 of the lowest state . as is well known , a constant energy separation of the intensity peaks , inversely proportional to the length of the resonating cavity [ here @xmath112 , see eqs . ( [ edis ] ) and ( [ eoff ] ) above ] is the hallmark of the optical fabry - prot , reflecting the linear energy dispersion of the photon in optics @xcite or a massless dw electron in graphene structures.@xcite most revealing is the energy offset away form zero of the first conductance peak , which equals exactly one - half of the constant energy separation between the peaks . in one - dimension , this is the hallmark of a massless fermion subject to an infinite - mass - barrier confinement @xcite . naturally , in the case of a semiconducting segment ( see below ) , this equidistant behavior and @xmath120-offset of the conductance peaks do not apply ; this case is accounted for by the dirac - fabry - prot model presented in methods , and it is more general than the optical fabry - prot theory associated with a photonic cavity . @xcite in the nonrelativistic limit , i.e. , when @xmath121 , one gets @xmath122 which yields the well known relations @xmath123 and @xmath124 for a massive relativistic electron , as is the case with the semiconducting agnrs in this paper , one has to numerically solve eq . ( [ eimsw ] ) and then substitute the corresponding value of @xmath114 in einstein s energy relation given by eq . ( [ erel ] ) . from an inspection of fig . [ fig1 ] , one can conclude that the physics associated with the all - semiconducting aaa junction is that of multiple reflections of a _ massive _ relativistic dirac fermion bouncing back and forth from the edges of a `` quantum box '' created by a double - mass barrier [ see the schematic of the double - mass barrier in figs . [ fig1](iii ) and [ fig1](v ) ] . in particular , to a good approximation the energies of the conductance oscillation peaks are given by the imsw eq.([eimsw ] ) with @xmath125 ( @xmath95 ) or @xmath126 ( @xmath109 ) . in this respect , the separation energy between successive peaks in figs . [ fig1](b ) , [ fig1](c ) , [ fig1](e ) , and [ fig1](f ) is not a constant , unlike the case of an all - metallic junction @xcite ( or a photonic cavity @xcite ) . the conductance patterns in figs . [ fig1](d ) and [ fig1](f ) correspond to the category _ fp - b _ ( see the introductory section ) . these patterns can not be accounted for by the optical fabry - prot theory , but they are well reproduced by the generalized dirac - fabry - prot model introduced by us in the methods section . our results for a 3-segment ( @xmath127 ) _ semiconducting - metallic - semiconducting _ agnr , aaa ( sms ) , are portrayed in fig . [ fig2 ] [ left , see schematic lattice diagram in fig . [ fig2](i ) ] . the first fp oscillation in the tb - negf conductance displayed in fig . [ fig2](a ) appears at an energy @xmath96 , which reflects the intrinsic gap @xmath97 of the semiconducting leads ( with @xmath128 ) . the energy spacing between the peaks in fig . [ fig2](a ) is constant in agreement with the metallic ( massless dw electrons ) character of the central segment with @xmath129 . the tb - negf pattern in fig . [ fig2](a ) corresponds to the fabry - prot category _ fp - a2_. as seen from fig . [ fig2](b ) , our generalized dirac - fabry - prot theory is again capable of faithfully reproducing this behavior . a deeper understanding of the aaa ( sms ) case can be gained via an inspection of the density of states ( dos ) plotted in fig . [ fig2](c ) for the total segmented agnr ( central segment plus leads ) and in fig . [ fig2](d ) for the the isolated leads . in fig . [ fig2](c ) , nine equidistant resonance lines are seen . their energies are close to those resulting from the imsw eq . ( [ imsw0 ] ) ( with @xmath130 , see the caption of fig . [ fig2 ] ) for a massless dw electron . out of these nine resonances , the first five do not conduct [ compare figs . [ fig2](a ) and [ fig2](c ) ] because their energies are lower than the minimum energy ( i.e. , @xmath131 ) of the incoming electrons in the leads [ see the onset of the first band ( marked by an arrow ) in the dos curve displayed in fig . [ fig2](d ) ] . as shown in refs . , a detailed description of hygrogen passivation requires that the hopping parameters @xmath132 for the nearest - neighbor c - c bonds at the armchair edges be given by @xmath133 . taking this modification into account , our results for a 3-segment _ semiconducting - metallic - semiconducting _ agnr are portrayed in fig . [ fig2 ] [ right , see schematic lattice diagram in fig . [ fig2](iii ) ] ; this lattice configuration is denoted as `` aaa ( sms ) h - passivation . '' the first fp oscillation in the tb - negf conductance displayed in fig . [ fig2](e ) appears at an energy @xmath134 , which reflects the intrinsic gap @xmath97 of the properly passivated semiconducting leads ( with @xmath128 ) . the energy spacing between the peaks in fig . [ fig2](e ) is slightly away from being constant in agreement with the small mass @xmath135 acquired by the central segment with @xmath129 , due to taking @xmath133 . as seen from fig . [ fig2](f ) , our generalized dirac - fabry - prot theory is again capable of faithfully reproducing this behavior . a deeper understanding of the aaa ( sms)-h - passivation case can be gained via an inspection of the dos plotted in fig . [ fig2](g ) for the total segmented agnr ( central segment plus leads ) and in fig . [ fig2](h ) for the isolated leads . in fig . [ fig2](g ) , eight ( almost , but not exactly , equidistant ) resonance lines are seen . their energies are close to those resulting from the imsw eq . ( [ eimsw ] ) ( with @xmath136 and @xmath135 ; see the caption of fig . [ fig2 ] ) for a dirac electron with a small mass . out of these eight resonances , the first six do not conduct [ compare figs . [ fig2](e ) and [ fig2](g ) ] because their energies are lower than the minimum energy ( i.e. , @xmath137 ) of the incoming electrons in the leads [ see the onset of the first band ( marked by an arrow ) in the dos curve displayed in fig . [ fig2](h ) ] . from the above we conclude that hydrogen passivation of the agnr resulted in a small shift of the location of the states , and opening of a small gap for the central metallic narrower ( with a width of @xmath138 ) segment , but did not modify the conductance record in any qualitative way . moreover , the passivation effect can be faithfully captured by the dirac fp model by a small readjustment of the model parameters . , with @xmath139 ( @xmath140 ) being the number of carbon atoms specifying the width of the ribbon segments . the armchair leads in the aza junction are metallic ( @xmath141 , class iii agnr ) . ( a)-(b ) tb - negf conductance for the zzz and aza junction , respectively . ( c ) dfp conductance reproducing the tb - negf result in ( a ) for the zzz junction . ( d ) dfp conductance reproducing the tb - negf result in ( b ) for the aza junction . in spite of the different edge morphology , the fabry - prot patterns in ( a ) and ( b ) are very similar . the central zigzag segment controls the fabry - prot patterns . according to the continuum dfp analysis , the physics underlying such patterns is that of a massive nonrelativistic schrdinger fermionic carrier performing multiple reflections within a cavity defined by a double - mass barrier [ see diagram in ( iii ) ] , but with the additional feature that @xmath142 and @xmath143 are also considered for segments or leads with zigzag edge terminations ( see text for details ) . the mass and @xmath144 parameters used in the dfp calculations were @xmath145 , @xmath146 , with @xmath147 , @xmath142 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath143 in ( c ) and @xmath152 , @xmath153 , with @xmath154 , @xmath142 , @xmath155 , @xmath156 , @xmath157 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 in ( d ) . @xmath160 and @xmath161 denote parameters of the leads . @xmath70 is the energy in units of @xmath162 . @xmath163 nm is the graphene lattice constant ; @xmath81 ev is the hopping parameter.,width=434 ] it is interesting to investigate the sensitivity of the interference features on the edge morphology . we show in this section that the relativistic transport treatment applied to segmented armchaie gnrs does not maintain for the case of a nanoribbon segment with zigzag edge terminations . in fact zigzag gnr ( zgnr ) segments exhibit properties akin to the well - known transport in usual semiconductors , i.e. , their excitations are governed by the nonrelativistic schrdinger equation . before discussing segmented gnrs with zigzag edge terminations , we remark that such gnrs with uniform width exhibit stepwise quantization of the conductance , similar to the case of a uniform armchair - edge - terminated gnr [ see fig . [ fig1](a ) ] . in fig . [ fig3](a ) , we display the conductance in a three - segment junction [ see lattice schematic in fig . [ fig3](i ) ] when all three segments have zigzag edge terminations ( denoted as zzz ) , but the central one is narrower than the lead segments . the main finding is that the central segment behaves again as a resonant cavity that yields an oscillatory conductance pattern where the peak spacings are unequal [ fig . [ fig3](a ) ] . this feature , which deviates from the optical fabry - prot behavior , appeared also in the dfp patterns for a three - segment armchair junction whose central segment was semiconducting , albeit with a different dependence on @xmath14 [ see figs . [ fig1 ] and eq . ( [ eimsw ] ) ] . moreover , from a set of systematic calculations ( not shown ) employing different lengths and widths , we found that the energy of the resonant levels in zgnr segments varies on the average as @xmath164 , where the integer @xmath13 counts the resonances and @xmath14 indicates the length of the central segment . however , a determining difference with the armchair gnr case in fig . [ fig1 ] is the vanishing of the valence - to - conductance gap in the zigzag case of fig . [ fig3](a ) . it is well known that the above features are associated with resonant transport of electronic excitations that obey the nonrelativistic second - order schrdinger equation . naturally , one could formulate a continuum transport theory based on transfer matrices ( see methods ) that use the 1d schrdinger equation instead of the generalized dirac eq . ( [ direq ] ) . such a schrdinger - equation continuum approach , however , is unable to describe mixed armchair - zigzag interfaces ( see below ) , where the electron transits between two extreme regimes , i.e. , an ultrarelativistic ( i.e. , including the limit of vanishing carrier mass ) dirac regime ( armchair segment ) and a nonrelativistic schrdinger regime ( zigzag segment ) . we have thus been led to adopt the same dirac - type transfer - matrix approach as with the armchair gnrs , but with nonvanishing potentials @xmath57 . this amounts to shifts ( in opposite senses ) of the energy scales for particle and hole excitations , respectively , and it yields the desired vanishing value for the valence - to - conduction gap of zigzag gnrs . the calculated dfp conductance that reproduces well the tb - negf result for the zzz junction [ fig.[fig3](a ) ] is displayed in fig . [ fig3](c ) ; the parameters used in the dfp calculation are given in the caption of fig . we note that the carrier mass ( @xmath165 ) in the central zigzag segment exhibits an energy dependence . this is similar to a well known effect ( due to nonparabolicity in the @xmath166 dispersion ) in the transport theory of usual semiconductors @xcite . we further note that the average mass associated with a zigzag segment is an order of magnitude larger than that found for semiconducting armchair segments of similar width ( see caption in fig . [ fig1 ] ) , and this yields energy levels @xmath164 close to the nonrelativistic limit [ see eq . ( [ ennr ] ) ] . we note that the fp pattern of the zzz junction belongs to the category _ fp - c_. fig . [ fig3 ] ( right column ) presents an example of a mixed armchair - zigzag - armchair ( aza ) junction , where the central segment has again zigzag edge terminations [ see lattice schematic in fig . [ fig3](ii ) ] . the corresponding tb - negf conductance is displayed in fig . [ fig3](b ) . in spite of the different morphology of the edges between the leads ( armchair ) and the central segment ( zigzag ) , the conductance profile of the aza junction [ fig . [ fig3](b ) ] is very similar to that of the zzz junction [ fig . [ fig3](a ) ] . this means that the characteristics of the transport are determined mainly by the central segment , with the left and right leads , whether zigzag or armchair , acting as reservoirs supplying the impinging electrons . the dfp result reproducing the tb - negf conductance is displayed in fig . [ fig3](d ) , and the parameters used are given in the caption . we stress that the mixed aza junction represents a rather unusual physical regime , where an ultrarelativistic dirac - weyl massless charge carrier ( due to the metallic armchair gnrs in the leads ) transits to a nonrelativistic massive schrdinger electron in the central segment . we note that the fp pattern of the aza junction belongs to the _ fp - c _ caregory . . ( b ) tb spectrum for a nanoring with type - ii corners and the same width @xmath167 . these armchair graphene rings are semiconducting ( type - i ) and metallic ( type - ii ) . the three ( four ) lowest - in - energy two - membered bands are shown . the hole states ( with @xmath168 , not shown ) are symmetric to the particle states ( with @xmath169 ) . ( c , d ) dkp spectra reproducing the tb ones in ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively . insets in ( c ) and ( d ) : schematics of the higgs fields ( position - dependent mass ) @xmath170 employed in the dkp modeling . @xmath170 is approximated by steplike functions @xmath46 ; @xmath51 counts the three regions of each half of the rhombus ( @xmath171 and @xmath172 ) , and @xmath13 ( @xmath173 ) . the non - zero ( constant ) variable - mass values of @xmath170 are indicated by yellow ( red ) color when positive ( negative ) . the parameters used in the dkp modeling are : ( c ) @xmath174 , @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 [ see corresponding schematic inset in ( c ) ] and ( d ) @xmath178 , @xmath179 , @xmath176 , @xmath180 with @xmath181 [ see schematic inset in ( d ) ] . note the two - membered braided bands and the `` forbidden '' band [ within the gap , in ( b ) and ( d ) ] . the twofold forbidden band with @xmath182 appears as a straight line due to the very small amplitude oscillations of its two members . @xmath163 nm is the graphene lattice constant and @xmath81 ev is the hopping parameter . the edge terminations of both the inside and outside sides of the ring are armchair.,width=510 ] the energy of a particle ( with onedimensional momentum @xmath18 ) is given by the einstein relativistic relation @xmath19 , where @xmath8 is the rest mass . as aforementioned , in armchair graphene ribbons , the mass parameter is related to the particle - hole energy gap , @xmath21 , as @xmath22 . in relativistic quantum field theory , the mass of elementary particles is imparted through interaction with a scalar field known as the higgs field . accordingly , the mass @xmath8 is replaced by a position - dependent higgs field @xmath183 , to which the relativistic fermionic field @xmath24 couples through the yukawa lagrangian @xcite @xmath25 ( @xmath26 being a pauli matrix ) . in the elementary - particles standard model , @xcite such coupling is responsible for the masses of quarks and leptons . for @xmath27 ( constant ) @xmath28 , and the massive fermion dirac theory is recovered . we exploit the generalized dirac physics governed by a total lagrangian density @xmath184 , where the fermionic part is given by @xmath185 and the scalar - field part has the form @xmath186 with the potential @xmath187 ( second term ) assumed to have a double - well @xmath188 form ; @xmath189 and @xmath190 are constants . henceforth , the dirac equation ( see methods ) is generalized as @xmath191 in one dimension , the fermion field is a two - component spinor @xmath30 ; @xmath31 and @xmath32 stand , respectively , for the upper and lower component and @xmath33 and @xmath26 can be any two of the three pauli matrices . -sublattice ( red ) and @xmath1-sublattice ( blue ) components of the tb state with energy @xmath192 at @xmath193 , belonging to the forbidden solitonic band of the type - ii nanoring with @xmath167 [ see fig . [ fig44](b ) ] . ( b ) upper ( red ) and lower ( blue ) spinor components for the corresponding state ( forbidden band ) according to the dkp spectrum [ see fig . [ fig44](d ) ] , reproducing the tb behavior of the type - ii nanoring with @xmath167 ( @xmath181 ) . the tb and dkp wave functions for all states of the solitonic band are similar to those displayed here . the wave functions here represent a pair of solitons . for contrast , see fig . 10 in ref . which portrays schematically the spinor @xmath194 for a _ single _ fermionic soliton attached to a higgs field with a smooth kink - soliton analytic shape @xmath195 . @xmath196 is a solution @xcite of the lagrangian in eq . ( [ lagrphi ] ) . dkp densities in units of @xmath197 . , width=472 ] a graphene polygonal ring can be viewed as made of connected graphene - nanoribbon fragments ( here we consider agnrs ) . the excitations of an infinite agnr are described by the 1d massive dirac equation , see eq . ( [ direq1 ] ) with @xmath74 , @xmath75 , and @xmath198 . the two ( in general ) unequal hopping parameters @xmath199 and @xmath200 are associated with an effective 1d tight - binding problem ) and are given @xcite by @xmath201 $ ] , @xmath202 and @xmath203 ; @xmath100 is the number of carbon atoms specifying the width of the nanoribbon and @xmath81 ev is the hopping parameter for 2d graphene . the effective @xcite tb hamiltonian of an agnr has a form similar to that used in _ trans_-polyacetylene ( a single chain of carbon atoms ) . in _ trans_-polyacetylene , the inequality of @xmath199 and @xmath200 ( referred to as dimerization ) is a consequence of the aforementioned peierls distortion induced by the electron - phonon coupling . for an armchair graphene ring , this inequality is a topological effect associated with the geometry of the edge and the width of the ribbon . we recall that as a function of their width , @xmath100 , the armchair graphene nanoribbons fall into three classes : ( i ) @xmath204 ( semiconducting , @xmath205 ) , ( ii ) @xmath98 ( semiconducting , @xmath205 ) , and ( iii ) @xmath206 ( metallic @xmath207 ) , @xmath99 . we adapt the `` crystal '' approach @xcite to the aharonov - bohm ( ab ) effect , and introduce a virtual dirac - kronig - penney @xcite ( dkp ) relativistic superlattice ( see methods ) . charged fermions in a perpendicular magnetic field circulating around the ring behave like electrons in a spatially periodic structure ( period @xmath208 ) with the magnetic flux @xmath209 ( @xmath210 ) playing the role of the bloch wave vector @xmath211 , i.e. , @xmath212 [ see the cosine term in eq . ( [ disrel ] ) ] . naturally , nanorings with arms made of nanoribbon segments belonging to the semiconducting classes may be expected to exhibit a particle - hole gap ( particle - antiparticle gap in rqf theory ) . indeed this is found for a rhombic armchair graphene ring ( agr ) [ see gap @xmath21 in fig . [ fig44](a ) ] with a width of @xmath167 carbon atoms having type - i corners . suprisingly , a rhombic armchair graphene nanoring of the same width @xmath167 , but having corners of type - ii , demonstrates a different behavior , showing a `` forbidden '' band ( with @xmath182 ) in the middle of the gap region [ see fig . [ fig44](b ) ] . this behavior of rhombic armchair graphene rings with type - ii corners can be explained through analogies with rqf theoretical models , describing single zero - energy fermionic solitons with fractional charge @xcite or their modifications when forming soliton / anti - soliton systems . @xcite ( a solution of the equation of motion corresponding to eq . ( [ lagrphi ] ) , is a @xmath213 kink soliton , @xmath196 . the solution of eq . ( [ direq1 ] ) with @xmath214 is the fermionic soliton . ) we model the rhombic ring with the use of a continuous 1d kronig - penney @xcite model ( see methods ) based on the generalized dirac equation ( [ direq1 ] ) , allowing variation of the scalar field @xmath170 along the ring s arms . we find that the dkp model reproduces [ see fig . [ fig44](d ) ] the spectrum of the type - ii rhombic ring ( including the forbidden band ) when considering alternating masses @xmath215 associated with each half of the ring [ see inset in fig . [ fig44](d ) ] . in analogy with the physics of _ trans_-polyacetylene ( see remarks in the introductory section ) , the positive and negative masses correspond to two degenerate domains associated with the two possible dimerization patterns @xcite @xmath216 and @xmath217 , which are possible in a single - atom chain . the transition zones between the two domains ( here two of the four corners of the rhombic ring ) are referred to as the domain walls . for a single soliton , a ( precise ) zero - energy fermionic excitation emerges , localized at the domain wall . in the case of soliton - antisoliton pairs , paired energy levels with small positive and negative values appear within the gap . the tb spectrum in fig . [ fig44](b ) exhibits a forbidden band of two paired @xmath218 levels , a property fully reproduced by the dkp model that employs two alternating mass domains [ fig . [ fig44](d ) . the twofold forbidden band with @xmath182 appears as a straight line due to the very small amplitude oscillations of its two members . @xmath163 nm is the graphene lattice constant and @xmath81 ev is the hopping parameter . the strong localization of a fraction of a fermion at the domain walls ( two of the rhombus corners ) , characteristic of fermionic solitons @xcite and of soliton / anti - soliton pairs , @xcite is clearly seen in the tb density distributions ( modulus of single - particle wave functions ) displayed in fig . [ fig55](a ) . the tb @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) sublattice component of the tight - binding wave functions localizes at the odd numbered corners . these alternating localization patterns are faithfully reproduced [ see fig . [ fig55](b ) ] by the upper , @xmath219 , and lower , @xmath220 , spinor components of the continuum dkp model . the soliton - antisoliton pair in fig . [ fig55](b ) generates an @xmath221 charge fractionization at each of the odd - numbered corners , which is similar to the @xmath221 fractionization familiar from polyacetylene . the absence of a forbidden band ( i.e. , solitonic excitations within the gap ) in the spectrum of the type - i rhombic nanorings [ see fig . [ fig44](a ) ] indicates that the corners in this case do not induce an alternation between the two equivalent dimerized domains ( represented by @xmath215 in the dkp model ) . here the corners do not act as topological domain walls . nevertheless , direct correspondence between the tb and dkp spectra is achieved here too by using a variable higgs field defined as @xmath222 with @xmath223 and @xmath177 [ see the schematic inset in fig . [ fig44](c ) and the dkp spectrum plotted in the same figure ] . in this paper we focused on manifestations of relativistic and/or nonrelativistic quantum behavior explored through theoretical considerations of transport in graphene nanostructures and spectral and topological effects in graphene nanorings in the presence of magnetic fields . in particular , we investigated the emergence of new behavior of electrons in atomically precise segmented graphene nanoribbons ( gnrs ) with different edge terminations ( armchair , zigzag and mixed ones ) , and in graphene rings . to these aims we have employed tight - binding calculations of electronic states with and without applied magnetic fields , the non - equilibrium green s function transport theory , and a newly developed dirac continuum model that absorbs the valence - to - conductance energy gaps as position - dependent masses , including topological - in - origin mass - barriers at the contacts between segments . the electronic conductance has been found to exhibit fabry - prot oscillations , or resonant tunneling , associated with partial confinement and formation of a quantum box ( resonant cavity ) in the junction . along with the familiar optical fp oscillations , exhibiting equal spacing between neighboring peaks , that we find for massless electrons in gnrs with metallic armchair central segments , we find other fp categories that differ from the optical one . in particular , our calculations reveal : ( a ) a massive relativistic fp pattern exhibiting a valence - to - conduction gap and unequal peak spacings . this pattern is associated with semiconducting armchair nanoribbon central segments , irrespective of whether the armchair leads are matallic or semiconducting . ( b ) a massive non - relativistic fp pattern with @xmath17 peak spacings , but with a vanishing valence - to - conduction gap . this pattern is the one expected for the carriers in usual semiconductors described by the ( nonrelativistic ) schrdinger equation , and it is associated with zigzag nanoribbon central segments , regardless of whether zigzag or metallic armchair leads are used . perfect quantized - conductance flat steps were found only for uniform gnrs . in the absence of extraneous factors , like disorder , in our theoretical model , the deviations from the perfect quantized - conductance steps were unexpected . however , this aforementioned behavior obtained through tb - negf calculations is well accounted for by a 1d contimuum fermionic dirac - fabry - prot interference theory ( see methods ) . this approach employs an effective position - dependent mass term in the dirac hamiltonian to absorb the finite - width ( valence - to - conduction ) gap in armchair nanoribbon segments , as well as the barriers at the interfaces between nanoribbon segments forming a junction . for zigzag nanoribbon segments the mass term in the dirac equation reflects the nonrelativistic schrodinger - type behavior of the excitations . the carrier mass in zigzag - terminated gnr segments is much larger than the particle mass in semiconducting armchair - terminated gnr segments . furthermore in the zigzag gnr segments ( which are always characterized by a vanishing valence - to - conduction energy gap ) , the mass corresponds simply to the carrier mass . in the armchair gnr segments , the carrier mass endows ( in addition ) the segment with a valence - to - conduction energy gap , according to einstein s relativistic energy relation [ see eq . ( 1 ) ] . we concluded with a brief discussion of the physics of electrons in segmented polygonal rings , which may be regarded as constructed by connecting gnr segments . evaluation of the electronic states in a rhombic graphene nanoring under the influence of an applied magnetic field in the aharonov - bohm regime , and their analysis with the use of a relativistic quantum - field theoretical model , unveils development of a topological - in - origin zero - energy soliton state and charge fractionization . the above findings point to a most fundamental underlying physics , namely that the topology of disruptions of the regular honeycomb lattice ( e.g. , variable width segments , corners , edges ) generates a scalar - potential field ( position - dependent mass , identified @xcite also as a higgs - type field ) , which when integrated into a generalized dirac equation for the electrons provides a unifying framework for the analysis of transport processes through graphene segmented junctions and the nature of electronic states in graphene nanorings . with growing activities and further improvements in the areas of bottom - up fabrication and manipulation of atomically precise @xcite graphene nanostructures and the anticipated measurement of conductance through them , the above findings could serve as impetus and implements aiding the design and interpretation of future experiments . 999 nitzan , a. ; ratner , m. a. electron transport in molecular wire junctions . _ science _ * 2003 * , _ 300 _ , 1384 - 1389 . joachim , c. ; ratner , m. a. molecular electronics : some views on transport junctions and beyond . _ proc . ( usa ) _ * 2005 * , _ 102 _ , 8801 - 8808 . lindsay , s. m. ; ratner , m. a. molecular transport junctions : clearing mists . . maters . _ * 2007 * , _ 19 _ , 23 - 31 . hod , o. ; rabani , e. ; baer , r. magnetoresistance of nanoscale molecular devices . _ * 2006 * , _ 39 _ , 109 - 117 . bergfield , j. p. ; ratner , m. a. forty years of molecular electronics : non - equilibrium heat and charge transport at the nanoscale . _ phys . solidi b _ * 2013 * , _ 250 _ , 2249 - 2266 . rai , d. ; hod , o. ; nitzan , a. magnetic field control of the current through molecular ring junctions . _ j. phys . lett . _ * 2011 * , _ 2 _ , 2118 - 2124 . kroto , h. w. ; heath , j. r. ; obrien , s. c. ; curl r. f. ; smalley , r. e. c60 : buckminsterfullerine . _ nature _ * 1985 * , _ 318 _ , 162 - 163 . iijima , s. helical microtubules of graphitic carbon . _ nature _ * 1991 * , _ 354 _ , 56 - 58 . novoselov , k. s. ; geim , a. k. ; morozov , s. v. ; jiang , d. ; zhang , y. ; dubonos , s. v. ; grigorieva , i. v. ; firsov , a. a. electric field effect in atomically thin carbon films . _ science _ * 2004 * , _ 306 _ , 666 - 669 . nakada , k. ; fujita , m. ; dresselhaus , g. ; dresselhaus , m. s. edge state in graphene ribbons : nanometer size effect and edge shape dependence . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 1996 * , _ 54 _ , 17954 - 17961 . son , y. w. ; cohen , m. l. ; louie , s. g. energy gaps in graphene nanoribbons . _ * 2006 * , _ 97 _ , 216803 . wang , z. f. ; li , q. ; zheng , h. ; ren , h. ; su , h. ; shi , q. w. ; chen , j. tuning the electronic structure of graphene nanoribbons through chemical edge modification : a theoretical study . _ phys . rev . b : condens . matter mater . _ * 2007 * , _ 75 _ , 113406 . wakabayashi , k. ; sasaki , k. ; nakanishi , t ; enoki , t. electronic states of graphene nanoribbons and analytical solutions . technol . adv . mater . _ * 2010 * , _ 11 _ , 054504 , and references therein . castro neto , a. h. ; guinea , f. ; peres , n. m. r. ; novoselov , k. s. ; geim , a. k. the electronic properties of graphene . phys . _ * 2009 * , _ 81 _ , 109 - 162 . katsnelson , m. i. ; novoselov , k. s. ; geim , a. k. chiral tunnelling and the klein paradox in graphene . _ nature phys . _ * 2006 * , _ 2 _ , 620 - 625 . heeger , a. j. ; kivelson , s. ; schrieffer , j. r. ; su , w .- p . solitons in conducting polymers . phys . _ * 1988 * , _ 60 _ , 781 - 847 . jackiw , r. ; schrieffer , j. r. solitons with fermion number @xmath120 in condensed matter and relativistic field theories . b _ * 1981 * , _ 190 [ fs3 ] _ , 253 - 265 . jackiw , r. fractional and majorana fermions : the physics of zero - energy modes . _ phys . scr . _ * 2012 * , _ t146 _ , 014005 . peierls , r. f. _ quantum theory of solids _ ; clarendon press : oxford , * 1955*. romanovsky , i. ; yannouleas , c. ; landman , u. patterns of the aharonov - bohm oscillations in graphene nanorings . _ b : condens . matter mater . * 2012 * , _ 85 _ , 165434 . romanovsky , i. ; yannouleas , c. ; landman , u. topological effects and particle physics analogies beyond the massless dirac - weyl fermion in graphene nanorings . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 2013 * , _ 87 _ , 165431 . yannouleas , c. ; romanovsky , i. ; landman , u. beyond the constant - mass dirac physics : solitons , charge fractionization , and the emergence of topological insulators in graphene rings . b : condens . matter mater . * 2014 * , _ 89 _ , 035432 . kivelson , s. ; chapman , o. i. polyacene and a new class of quasi - one - dimensional conductors . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 1983 * , _ 28 _ , 7236 - 7243 . cai , j. m. ; ruffieux , p. ; jaafar , r. ; bieri , m. ; braun , t. ; blankenburg , s. ; muoth , m. ; seitsonen , a. p. ; saleh , m. ; feng , x .- l . ; et al . atomically precise bottom - up fabrication of graphene nanoribbons . _ nature _ * 2010 * , _ 466 _ , 470 - 473 . m. s. graphene : ribbons piece - by - piece . mat . _ * 2010 * , _ 9 _ , 611 - 612 . huang , h. ; wei , d. ; sun , j. ; wong , s. l. ; feng , y. p. ; castro neto , a. h. ; wee , a. t. s. spatially resolved electronic structures of atomically precise armchair graphene nanoribbons . _ rep . _ * 2012 * , _ 2 _ , 983 . van der lit , j. ; boneschanscher , m. p. ; vanmaekelbergh , d. ; ijs , m. ; uppstu , a. ; ervasti , m. ; harju , a. ; liljeroth , p. ; swart , i. suppression of electron - vibron coupling in graphene nanoribbons contacted via a single atom . commun . _ * 2013 * , _ 4 _ , 2023 . narita , a. ; feng , x .- ; hernandez , y. ; jensen , s. a. ; bonn , m. ; yang , h. f. ; verzhbitskiy , i. a. ; casiraghi , c. ; hansen , m. r. ; koch , a. h. r. ; et al . synthesis of structurally well - defined and liquid - phase - processable graphene nanoribbons . chem . _ * 2014 * , _ 6 _ , 126 - 132 . hartley , c. s. graphene synthesis : nanoribbons from the bottom - up . chem . _ * 2014 * , _ 6 _ , 91 - 92 . vo , t. h. ; shekhirev , m. ; kunkel , d. a. ; morton , m. d. ; berglund , e. ; kong , l. ; wilson , p. m. ; dowben , p. a. ; enders , a. ; sinitskii , a. large - scale solution synthesis of narrow graphene nanoribbons . commun . _ * 2014 * , _ 5 _ , 3189 . blankenburg , s. ; cai j. m. ; ruffieux , p. ; jaafar , r. ; passerone , d. ; feng , x .- l . ; mllen , k. ; fasel , r. ; pignedoli , c. a. intraribbon heterojunction formation in ultranarrow graphene nanoribbons . _ acs nano _ _ 2012 _ , _ 6 _ , 2020 - 2025 . van houten , h. ; beenakker , c. w. j. ; williamson , j. g. ; broekaart , m. e. i. ; van loosdrecht , p. h. m. coherent electron focusing with quantum point contacts in a two - dimensional electron gas . b : condens . matter mater . _ * 1989 * , _ 39 _ , 8556 - 8575 . ji , y. ; chung , y. c. ; sprinzak , d. ; heiblum , m. ; mahalu , d. ; shtrikman , h. an electronic mach - zehnder interferometer . _ nature _ * 2003 * , _ 422 _ , 415 - 418 . vanwees , b. j. ; van houten , h. ; beenakker , c. w. j. ; williamson , j. g. ; kouwenhoven , l. p. ; van der marel , d. ; foxon , c. t. quantized conductance of point contacts in a two - dimensional electron gas . lett . _ * 1988 * , _ 60 _ , 848 - 850 . pascual , j. i. ; mndez , j. ; gmez - herrero , j. ; bar , a. m. ; garcia , n. ; landman , u. ; luedtke , w. d. ; bogachek , e. n. ; cheng , h .- p . properties of metallic nanowires : from conductance quantization to localization . _ science _ * 1995 * , _ 267 _ , 1793 - 1795 . liang , w. ; bockrath , m. ; bozovic , d. ; hafner , j. h. ; tinkham , m. ; park , h. fabry - prot interference in a nanotube electron waveguide . _ nature _ * 2001 * , _ 411 _ , 665 - 669 . vaughan , j.m . ; _ the fabry - prot interferometer _ ; hilger : bristol , * 1989*. lipson , s. g. ; lipson , h. ; tannhauser , d. s. _ optical physics _ ; cambridge univ . press : london , * 1995 * , 3rd ed . ; rickhaus , p. ; maurand , r. ; liu , m .- h . ; weiss , m. ; richter , k. ; schnenberger , ch . ballistic interferences in suspended graphene . commun . _ * 2013 * , _ 4 _ , 2342 . datta , s. ; _ quantum transport : atom to transistor _ ; cambridge university press : cambridge , * 2005*. lake , r. ; datta , s. nonequilibrium greens - function method applied to double - barrier resonant - tunneling diodes . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 1992 * , _ 45 _ , 6670 - 6685 . ezawa , m. peculiar band gap structure of graphene nanoribbons . ( c ) _ * 2007 * , _ 4 _ , 489 - 492 . recher , p. ; trauzettel , b. ; rycerz , a. ; blanter , ya . m. ; beenakker , c. w. j. ; morpurgo , a. f. aharonov - bohm effect and broken valley degeneracy in graphene rings . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 2007 * , _ 76 _ , 235404 . bahamon , d. a. ; pereira , a. l. c. ; schulz , p. a. inner and outer edge states in graphene rings : a numerical investigation . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 2009 * , _ 79 _ , 125414 . wurm , j. ; wimmer , m. ; baranger , h. u. ; richter , k. graphene rings in magnetic fields : aharonov - bohm effect and valley splitting . _ semicond . technol . _ * 2010 * , _ 25 _ , 034003 . hung nguyen , v. ; niquet , y. m. ; dollfus , p. aharonov - bohm effect and giant magnetoresistance in graphene nanoribbon rings . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 2013 * , _ 88 _ , 035408 . hung nguyen , v. ; niquet , y. m. ; dollfus , p. the interplay between the aharonov - bohm interference and parity selective tunneling in graphene nanoribbon rings . _ j. phys . : condens . matter _ * 2014 * , _ 26 _ , 205301 . xu , h. ; heinzel , t. ; evaldsson , m. ; zozoulenko , i. v. magnetic barriers in graphene nanoribbons : theoretical study of transport properties . _ j. phys . : condens . matter _ * 2008 * , _ 77 _ , 245401 . jiao , l. ; wang , x. ; diankov , g. ; wang , h. ; dai , h. facile synthesis of high - quality graphene nanoribbons . nanotech . _ * 2010 * , _ 5 _ , 321 - 325 . ritter , c. ; makler , s. s. ; latg , a. energy - gap modulations of graphene ribbons under external fields : a theoretical study . _ j. phys . : condens . matter _ * 2008 * , _ 77 _ , 195443 . mckellar , b. h. j. ; stephenson , jr . , g. j. relativistic quarks in one - dimensional periodic structures . c _ * 1987 * , _ 35 _ , 2262 - 2271 . bttiker , m. ; imry , y. ; landauer , r. josephson behavior in small normal one - dimensional rings . * 1983 * , _ 96 _ , 365 - 367 . alberto , p. ; fiolhais , c. ; gil , v. m. s. relativistic particle in a box . j. phys . _ * 1996 * , _ 17 _ , 19 - 24 . lpez - villanueva , j. a. ; melchor , i. ; cartujo , p. ; carceller , j. e. modified schrdinger - equation including nonparabolicity for the study of a two - dimensional electron gas . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 1993 * , _ 48 _ , 1626 - 1631 . mackenzie , r. ; palmer , w. f. bags via bosonization . d _ * 1990 * , _ 42 _ , 701 - 709 . bednyakov , v. a. ; giokaris , n. d. ; bednyakov , a. v. on higgs mass generation mechanism in the standard model . nucl . _ * 2008 * , _ 39 _ , 13 - 36 ; arxiv : hep - ph/0703280 . griffith , d. ; _ introduction to elementary particles _ ; wiley - vch : weinheim , germany , * 2008 * ; 2nd edition . zheng , h. x. ; wang , z. f. ; luo , t. ; shi , q. w. ; chen , j. analytical study of electronic structure in armchair graphene nanoribbons . _ phys . rev . b : condens . matter mater . phys . _ * 2007 * , _ 75 _ , 165414 . jackiw , r. ; rebbi , c. solitons with fermion number @xmath120 . d _ * 1976 * , _ 13 _ , 3398 - 3409 . jackiw , r. ; kerman , a. k. ; klebanov , i. ; semenoff , g. fluctuations of fractional charge in soliton anti - soliton systems . b _ * 1983 * , _ 225 _ , 233 - 246 . + * acknowledgements : * this work was supported by a grant from the office of basic energy sciences of the us department of energy under contract no . fg05 - 86er45234 . computations were made at the gatech center for computational materials science . + + * author contributions : * i.r . & c.y . performed the computations . c.y . , i.r . & u.l . analyzed the results . & u.l . wrote the manuscript . + + * competing financial interests : * the authors declare no competing financial interests . + + * correspondence * should be addressed to u.l . : ( [email protected] ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: thick discs are defined to be disc - like components with a scale height larger than that of the `` canonical '' or `` classical '' discs . they are most easily detected in close to edge - on galaxies in which they appear as a roughly exponential excess of light a few thin disc scale heights above the midplane . they were first detected and described by tsikoudi ( 1979 ) and burstein ( 1979 ) . the milky way was soon found to also host a thick disc ( gilmore & reid 1983 ) made of old ( bensby et al . 2005 ) , metal - poor , and @xmath2-enhanced stars ( fuhrmann 1998 ; prochaska et al . observations now suggest that thick discs in galaxies in the local universe are ubiquitous ( yoachim & dalcanton 2006 ; comern et al . 2011a ) . we recently showed evidence of thick discs being significantly more massive than previously considered with stellar masses ranging from 0.3 to 3.0 times that of the thin disc depending on the galaxy mass and the assumed mass - to - light ratios ( comern et al . 2011b ; hereafter co11b ) . this study confirmed that galaxies dominated by the thick disc are usually those with lower masses ( yoachim & dalcanton 2006 ) . hosting such a large fraction of the stellar mass makes thick discs likely reservoirs of some of the `` local missing baryons '' . a few galaxies , such as ngc 4013 , host an additional extended component which could be interpreted as a second thick disc or a flattened halo ( comern et al . 2011c ) . the properties of those more massive than expected thick discs give some constraints on their origin . higher mass galaxies could have their thick discs with a low relative mass explained by internal secular heating ( see , e.g. , bovy et al . 2012 ) , by the heating caused by the interaction with a satellite galaxy ( see , e.g. , qu et al . 2011 ) , by the accretion of stars from satellite galaxies ( see , e.g. , abadi et al . 2003 ) , and/or because of the radial migration of stars ( see , e.g. , schnrich & binney 2009 ; loebman et al . 2011 ) , but the very large thick disc mass fraction found in low - mass galaxies indicates an in situ origin during or shortly after the buildup of the galaxy for a large fraction of their thick disc stars . two in situ and high - redshift thick disc formation models have been put forward . elmegreen & elmegreen ( 2006 ) and bournaud et al . ( 2009 ) proposed a scenario where the thick disc forms from the primordial galaxy discs , which contained large clumps of star formation whose scale height was comparable to that of present - day thick discs . those large clumps would have dissolved into what we know as thick discs . brook et al . ( 2007 ) proposed thick discs to be made of stars in gas - rich proto - galactic fragments which merged and of stars created during that merger . in both scenarios , the thin disc would have formed afterwards from gas remaining from the initial galaxy formation processes and from new gas accreted through cold flows . these two models predict different properties for the thick discs . if they have been created from the dissolution of giant star - forming clusters , one would expect them to be genuine discs , with a high rotation speed and a luminosity profile similar to that of thin discs . if thick discs result from the merger of proto - galactic fragments they would , at least in some cases , host a significant fraction of lagging and/or counterrotating stars . our comprehensive detection and modeling of thick+thin discs in edge - on galaxies started in co11b allow us to study breaks , both truncations and antitruncations , in the radial profile of the thick discs , hitherto not possible . a radical truncation in the radial light profile was first discussed in edge - on galaxies by van der kruit ( 1979 ) and van der kruit and searle ( 1981a , b ; 1982 ) . the break phenomenon is widely observed in local galaxies ( van der kruit and searle 1981b ; barteldrees and dettmar 1994 ; pohlen et al . 2000 ; de grijs et al . 2001 ; florido et al . 2001 ; kregel et al . 2002 ; kregel and van der kruit 2004 ; pohlen and trujillo 2006 ; florido et al . 2006a , b ) and at high redshift ( prez 2004 ; trujillo and pohlen 2005 ) . see for reviews of these optical studies van der kruit ( 2001 ) and pohlen et al . ( 2004b ) . galaxies have been divided into three types depending on their disc properties ; type i , with an unbroken exponential ( freeman 1970 ) , type ii ( truncation ) , hosting a downbending break , and type iii ( antitruncation ) hosting a transition to a shallower exponential profile ( pohlen & trujillo 2006 ; erwin et al . 2008 ) , based on averaged radial light profiles . this opens the possibility that some of the observed characteristics may be due to the superposition of the thin and thick discs in these galaxies . due to the low - surface - brightness nature of the thick disc , this was left mostly unexplored . pohlen et al . ( 2004a , 2007 ) do suggest a weakening of the truncation with height moving from the thin to the thick disc - dominated regime . this has been confirmed by hubble space telescope observations over two truncations for all stellar populations ( de jong et al . 2007 , radburn - smith et al . 2012 ) . the origin of truncations and antitruncations is under debate . the former are hypothesized to be formed due to star - formation thresholds ( kennicutt 1989 ) , the point of maximum angular momentum of the original primordial cloud from which the galaxy has formed ( van der kruit 1987 ) , and/or by bar angular momentum redistribution ( debattista et al . laurikainen & salo ( 2001 ) proved that many m 51-like galaxies have an antitruncation caused by the stripping of stars and gas from the disc during the interaction . they numerically showed that these antitruncations could last for several gyr . also , a few antitruncations ( @xmath3 ) seem to be caused by the contribution of an extended bulge to the luminosity profile ( maltby et al . 2012 ) . the main purpose of this paper is to obtain the luminosity profiles of thin and thick discs of nearly edge - on galaxies parallel to their midplane to further constrain their origin . we also study truncations and antitruncations in thin and thick discs as separate features by fitting their luminosity profiles with a generalization of the function proposed by erwin et al . ( 2008 ) for the description of discs with breaks . we used images from the spitzer survey of stellar structure in galaxies ( s@xmath4 g , sheth et al . 2010 ) which has imaged more than 2000 galaxies representative of the nearby universe ( radial velocity @xmath5 ) in @xmath6 and @xmath7 using the infrared array camera ( irac ; fazio et al . the s@xmath4 g reaches a typical surface brightness of @xmath8 with a pixel size of @xmath9 and traces mostly the light of old stars with little dust absorption , which makes it ideal for the study of edge - on galaxies . this paper is structured as follows . we present the selected sample in section [ secsample ] and we describe the fitting procedure in section [ secfitting ] . we continue in section [ seccaveat ] by addressing what would happen if some assumptions made when producing the fits were not applicable to our sample of galaxies . we show and discuss our results in section [ secresults ] and section [ secdiscussion ] and we present our conclusions in section [ secconclusions ] . we looked at each of the 2132 galaxies available in the s@xmath4 g archive by february 15 , 2012 and we manually selected disc galaxies appearing to be edge - on with morphological types @xmath10 ( @xmath11 from hyperleda ; paturel et al . later type galaxies were rejected because of their generally ill - defined structure . we have assumed that @xmath11 can be `` reasonably reliably '' determined for edge - on galaxy as claimed by buta ( 2012 ) . we also rejected galaxies with distorted morphologies , with indications of being not quite edge - on ( with visible spiral arms or resonance rings ) , or discs that are too dim to certainly assess their orientation . when possible , sloan digital sky survey data release 8 ( aihara et al . 2011 ) imaging was used in order to ensure close to edge - on galaxy orientation by looking at the position of the midplane dust . the resulting sample has 169 galaxies which includes 29 out of 30 galaxies studied in detail in co11b . the remaining galaxy , ic 1970 , was excluded due to some hint of spiral structure . all those galaxies underwent the image processing and fitting procedure described in sections [ secmakever ] and [ secverfit ] . in section [ sectrim1 ] we describe how , after fitting thin+thick+gas disc profiles to galaxy luminosity profiles perpendicular to their midplanes , we applied additional selection criteria aiming to remove faint galaxies , galaxies with extended envelopes , and/or badly fitted galaxies , in order to ensure the data quality and we built up a final sample with 70 galaxies . in order to obtain luminosity profiles of thin and thick discs parallel to galaxy midplanes and to study them we followed a procedure that is described in detail in the next subsections : * we prepared a grid of synthetic luminosity profiles perpendicular to the galaxy midplanes , as done in co11b . the selected profile was that of a combined thin , thick , and gas disc gravitationally coupled in local isothermal equilibrium for galaxies with @xmath12 . for earlier - type galaxies we only considered a thin and a thick disc . ( section [ sectsynt ] ) . * we extracted the observed luminosity profiles perpendicular to galaxy midplanes using an average of 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath13-band s@xmath4 g images ( vertical luminosity profiles ; section [ secmakever ] ) . * we fitted the observed luminosity profiles by comparing them with the grid of synthetic models as done in co11b ( section [ secverfit ] ) . * using the vertical luminosity profile fits , we determined the height , @xmath14 , above which the thick disc dominates the light emission ( section [ secdefrs ] ) . * by looking at the properties of vertical luminosity profile fits and the resulting @xmath14 we trimmed the 169 galaxy sample down to 70 in order to ensure the quality of the data . the galaxy rejection criteria were aimed to remove galaxies with bad fits , having extended envelopes , or being too faint and thus having noisy luminosity profiles ( section [ sectrim1 ] ) . * knowing @xmath14 has allowed us to determine the region dominated by the thin and thick disc light ; thus , we have been able to prepare luminosity profiles of the thin and thick discs parallel to the galaxy midplanes . we also prepared a profile including light from both discs ( horizontal luminosity profiles ; section [ secmakehor ] ) . * the horizontal luminosity profiles of both the thin and the thick discs , as well as those including light from both , were fitted with a generalization of the function used by erwin et al . ( 2008 ) to describe discs with breaks ( section [ secfithor ] ) . in order to prepare thin and thick disc luminosity profiles parallel to the midplane of a galaxy , it is fundamental to know in which range in heights above the midplane each disc dominates . to do so , we fitted luminosity profiles perpendicular to galaxy midplanes with thin+thick+gas disc functions for galaxies with @xmath12 . for earlier - type galaxies we set the gas disc to have a zero density , which is equivalent to assuming a thin+thick disc function . assuming little or no gas in these galaxies solves one of the fitting biases discussed in section [ secnogas ] , namely that of gas - depleted galaxies with a thick disc mass overestimated because being fitted with a function accounting for gas . as in co11b , we assumed that galaxy discs are relaxed structures whose particles behave like those of a fluid in equilibrium . we also assumed that discs are made of three gravitationally coupled baryonic discs gas disc , thin disc and thick disc which feel the effect of something acting like a dark matter halo . then we can write following the equation from narayan & jog ( 2002 ) : @xmath15 where @xmath16 refers to the thin disc , @xmath11 to the thick disc and @xmath17 to the gas disc ; the subindex @xmath18 can be either @xmath16 , @xmath11 , or @xmath17 , @xmath19 stands for the mass density , and @xmath20 for the vertical velocity dispersion of the component . @xmath21 is the term describing dark matter effects . this is a set of three coupled second order differential equations which we solved by using the newmark-@xmath22 method with @xmath23 and @xmath24 . @xmath22 and @xmath25 are internal parameters of the algorithm which have been set to make it unconditionally stable ( newmark 1959 ) . when integrating equation ( [ equilibrium ] ) we assumed that the isothermal hypothesis is true . this hypothesis implies that for a given galactic radius , @xmath26 , the vertical velocity dispersion is constant with height , @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) . we also assumed that the effect of dark matter is negligible ( @xmath29 ; see justification in co11b and section [ seccaveat ] ) . line - of - sight effects were avoided by assuming that all of the discs have similar scale lengths and that the scale heights remain roughly constant with varying @xmath26 . this last assumption is based on the fact that s@xmath4 g discs do not flare significantly within the optical radius and has been widely used in the literature ( van der kruit & searle 1981a ; yoachim & dalcanton 2006 ; co11b ) . we also assumed that the face - on gas surface mass density for galaxies with @xmath12 is 0.2 times that of the thin disc at all radii . a @xmath30 gas fraction is slightly higher than that found in the milky way at solar radius ( banerjee & jog 2007 ) and we have shown in co11b that it yields slightly better fits than when not accounting for gas . it is also a fraction of gas representative of what is found in our galaxy sample according to our gas fraction calculations presented in section [ secv120 ] . we set @xmath31 for galaxies with @xmath32 . finally , we assumed @xmath33 in rough accordance with milky way velocity dispersion measurements ( spitzer 1978 ; stark 1984 ; clemens 1985 ; lewis & freeman 1989 ) . equation ( [ equilibrium ] ) provides mass density profiles . for obtaining luminosity profiles some assumptions about @xmath34 and @xmath35 , the mass - to - light ratios of the thin and the thick discs , were needed . different @xmath36 values can be calculated from different star formation histories for the thin and the thick discs . reasonable star formation histories yield @xmath37 ( see in discussion in section 3.3 in co11b ) . in this paper we use the most conservative value that with lower relative thick disc masses @xmath38 . when integrating equation ( [ equilibrium ] ) , six boundary conditions are needed . since the maximum density is found in the midplane , we set @xmath39 . the other boundary conditions we used are the mass densities of each disc in the midplane @xmath40 ( hereafter @xmath41 ) . we solved equation ( [ equilibrium ] ) for a grid of models with different central density ratios ( @xmath42 ) and different vertical velocity dispersion ratios , @xmath43 . we made integrations for 150 values of @xmath42 , equally spaced from 0.015 to 2.25 , and for 150 values of @xmath44 , equally spaced from 1.1 to 16.0 . the solutions in this grid were then compared to observed luminosity profiles as described in the following subsections . we selected the 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath45m - band images for the 169 galaxies in our original sample and we subtracted the background from each image . the background was measured by selecting several tens of @xmath46 pixel boxes far away from the midplane of the galaxy and bright stars and then by obtaining the median value of the pixels in the box . the selected background value was that of the median of the individual medians found for each box . the angular distance between the boxes in which we measured the background and the midplane of the galaxy for galaxies fitting in the irac chip ( @xmath47 ; sheth et al . 2010 ) is limited by irac s field of view ( @xmath48 ) and is typically around 100 . for the few galaxies which required a mosaic , the sky has been measured in boxes as close to the border of the mosaic as possible in the direction perpendicular to the midplane . the median distance of the galaxies for which we studied the breaks is 29.8mpc ( see section [ sectrim1 ] for details on the original sample trimming ) . at that distance , 100 correspond to 14.4kpc , which may cause our estimated sky value to be actually the stellar halo level . bakos & trujillo ( 2012 ) found that haloes start affecting the luminosity profiles of galaxies at @xmath49 . because we have not found color indexes including irac filters for stellar haloes in the literature , we have used globular cluster colors as a proxi for halo colors in order to test whether this error in the sky subtraction could affect our analysis . the reddest globular cluster in the sfample of spitler et al . ( 2008 ) has @xmath50 . this globular cluster has @xmath51 ( spitler et al . 2008 ) and using the color transformations for population ii stars in jordi et al . ( 2006 ) , we can afirm that @xmath52 within @xmath53mag . that implies that the halo would start affecting our luminosity profiles at @xmath54 . since our break detection limit is within the range @xmath55 ( see section [ sectrunc ] ) stellar haloes are not likely to affect our analysis of the background for subtraction . typical one-@xmath20 errors of the background determination of the addition of the 3.6 and 4.5@xmath45 m images are around 0.0015counts , corresponding to a surface brightness level of @xmath56 . this error bar was measured by finding the standard deviation of different background values obtained using bootstrapping over the local background values in the individual @xmath46 pixel boxes . the value of the measured background does not vary significantly when increasing the box size from @xmath46 to @xmath57 pixels . however , the background error rarely is the limiting factor when fitting the luminosity profiles ; the actual main limiting factor is the quality of the mask as explained at the end of section [ secverfit ] . using the average of the sky - subtracted 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath45m - band images we produced four luminosity profiles for each galaxy : at each side of the bulge , central cluster or presumed center along the disc long axis for projected galactocentric distances @xmath58 and @xmath59 ( top panel in figure [ example ] ) . we used @xmath60 values from hyperleda except for ngc 4111 , for which we preferred the third reference catalog of bright galaxies value ( rc3 ; de vaucouleurs et al . 1991 ) due to the hyperleda value being clearly underestimated . the profiles were prepared by adding the counts above and below the midplane in order to get a unique profile for each bin and averaging for each @xmath27 over non - masked pixels . we used manually refined masks from the s@xmath4 g pipeline 2 ( sheth et al . the flux was transformed into magnitudes using a zero point @xmath61 . we increased the signal - to - noise at low surface brightness levels by smoothing the luminosity profiles . to do so , we found the height of the first profile data point for which the statistical error of the photometry was larger than 10% of the signal . we named that height @xmath62 . then , for every height , the photometry was obtained by averaging over the range of heights @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the pixel size . thus , smoothing was small close to the midplane ( @xmath65 ) , but significant for low signal - to - noise regions , where @xmath66 . c c + & + & both synthetic and observed luminosity profiles were scaled in the same way before the actual fitting . in both cases the midplane surface brightness was set to be one . in co11b we had stretched the @xmath27 axis in such a way that the surface brightness at @xmath67 was equal to one tenth of the surface brightness at @xmath68 , @xmath69 . thus , the synthetic and the observed luminosity were forced to intersect at the point for which the luminosity is one tenth of the midplane one . in the present paper , we made four different vertical scalings , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and @xmath72 . for practical purposes , what this stretching does is to set the luminosity at which the synthetic and the observed luminosity profiles intersect . the synthetic fits were convolved with a gaussian kernel with a fwhm of @xmath73 , which is the approximate fwhm of both 3.6 and 4.5@xmath13-band s@xmath4 g point - spread functions made by stacking several hundreds non - saturated stars ( s@xmath4 g `` super - psf '' ; sheth et al . 2010 ) . the fitting of the observed luminosity profiles was done by following the procedure described in section 3.5 and figure 4 in co11b . basically , after being scaled , the observed luminosity profiles for each radial bin in each galaxy were compared to the grid of synthetic models . that was done by minimizing the differences of the brightest section of the profiles starting at a dynamic range of @xmath74 and then going to fainter levels in steps of @xmath75 down to @xmath76 . we selected as the `` correct '' fit the one with the largest @xmath77 having a @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the mean squared difference in magnitudes between both profiles . this procedure was only done down to @xmath80 in co11b . the lower fitted surface brightness for a given fit is @xmath81 and the midplane luminosity is @xmath82 . thus , for a given fit , the dynamical range @xmath77 over which a fit has been produced is @xmath83 . @xmath81 is reached at a height @xmath84 which is typically on the order of the smoothing scale height , @xmath62 . in some cases , no @xmath78 fit was found for a given bin and thus this bin was flagged to be non - fittable . the code also includes a module for computing the effect of some dust absorption in the midplane as described in co11b . an example of a vertical luminosity profile fit is presented in figure [ example ] and all the vertical luminosity profiles for our final sample galaxies appear in figure [ verticalfits ] of appendix [ appendixver ] . the errors in the photometric profile depict the statistical error of the averaging used at obtaining each photometric point . in spite of the care which has been taken at determining the background level , several profiles show a significant flux at large height ( at a level of @xmath85 ) . there are several possible explanations for this : in some cases , the galaxies are surrounded by a crowd of globular clusters and/or foreground stars whose extended wings are hard to distinguish from thick disc light and may have not been properly masked . in the case of galaxies with a larger angular size , large - scale background variations as those described in comern et al . ( 2011a ) may be present and may cause artifacts in some profiles . also , large saturated stars affect some of the profiles . finally , some galaxies may have faint extended haloes at a brightness level comparable to our detection threshold . the restrictions applied at choosing right fits ( mainly selecting as good fits those with @xmath78 ) , precludes this residual light from affecting our results . a key parameter needed for producing the luminosity profiles of the thin and the thick discs parallel to midplanes is the range of heights for which each disc dominates the light emission . we defined @xmath14 to be the height above which a fraction @xmath86 of the light is emitted by the thick disc according to the fits to the vertical luminosity profiles . this value was calculated for each of the correctly fitted bins . in the example fit presented in figure [ example ] , the @xmath14 for each bin is indicated by a solid vertical line in each of the middle and lower row panels . in order for a fit made for a given bin in a given galaxy to be further considered for use in this paper , several conditions were implemented : * a few galaxies , such as ngc 4013 , have relatively bright components in addition to the thin and thick discs ( co11b ; comern et al . these components are likely to be a second thick disc or a bright squashed halo . in order to avoid including galaxies with wrong fits due to these components , we excluded fits for which @xmath87 . this threshold ensures that , for most cases , possible additional components are dim enough not to significantly affect the fit . * the statistical uncertainties for fits made in very faint galaxies are large . to minimize this problem , we have only flagged as valid those fits for which the midplane surface brightness is @xmath88 . * in a few cases , as described in co11b , the fit is compatible with a single disc . this is most likely to happen for the fits done over a small @xmath77 , for which the fitted dynamical range is not large enough to allow distinguishing between both discs . we rejected fits compatible with a single disc . the criterion to detect those fits is slightly more restrictive than in co11b , namely that the mean squared difference between the fitted solution and a single - disc profile is @xmath89 . one of our assumptions when producing the fits is that the scale lengths of both thin and thick discs are similar and that their scale heights do not vary too much with radius . this implies that @xmath14 should be roughly constant with the projected radius , @xmath90 . as a final quality check for our fits , we selected those galaxies having more than one radial bin with a `` good '' fit according to the criteria expressed in the list and we looked for the largest and smallest @xmath14 among those fits . if the ratio between these two was smaller than 1.5 , the galaxy was included in the final sample . if the ratio was larger than 1.5 , the galaxy was only included if the two @xmath58 had a `` good '' fit and the ratio between their @xmath14 was smaller than 1.5 . the fits for the bins with @xmath59 were then rejected and only those with @xmath58 were considered when measuring global properties of the galaxy ( such as the average @xmath14 and the disc relative masses , @xmath91 ) . this was the case for 10 galaxies and was made so as not to exclude those galaxies with flares or truncations potentially happening at @xmath59 or galaxies with noisy profiles at this range of projected radii . galaxies with varying @xmath14 ( and thus excluded from the final sample ) , have not necessarily intrinsically largely varying scale lengths . for example , in the case of galaxies with a small angular size , they are likely to have a foreground star or a globular cluster covering a large fraction of the fitting bin at some height . in some cases , masking those features may be as harmful for the vertical luminosity profiles as not masking them at all , because it will cause that different heights will have their surface brightness measured in significantly different ranges of projected radii . this would result into unreliable fits which are excluded by the @xmath14 stability criterion . the @xmath14 stability selection criterion is also useful at removing galaxies whose thin disc is so thin that it is barely or not resolved . applying all these criteria trimmed the original sample from 169 to 70 galaxies . the properties of these 70 galaxies are presented in table [ sampledata ] . these restrictive criteria cause eleven out of thirty galaxies included in the co11b final sample not to appear in this paper . fits in galaxies of the final sample which have not been used are labeled as `` not used '' in figure [ verticalfits ] of appendix [ appendixver ] . the distance distribution of the 70 selected galaxies is presented in figure [ distances ] . the median distance of the sample is 29.8mpc . for each of the 70 galaxies in our sample , as done in co11b , the vertical luminosity profile fits were used for estimating the ratio of the stellar mass of the thick and the thin disc for each galaxy , @xmath91 , using the following expression : @xmath92 where @xmath93 refers to the edge - on column mass densities , the subindex @xmath94 refers to the different bins in galactocentric distance for which `` good '' fits have been obtained and @xmath95 is the midplane surface brightness for a given bin in magnitudes . [ cols="^ " , ] as seen in section [ secantitrunc ] and figure [ anti ] , the scale length of the thin disc profile after an antitruncation break seems to correlate with the thick disc scale length at that projected radius . a visual inspection of the fits in figure [ verticalfits ] shows that , in many cases , the shape of the luminosity profiles of type iii , type ii+iii , and type ii+iii+ii thin discs after the antitruncation break radius , @xmath96 , are very similar to that of the thick disc in the same projected radius range . it is therefore possible that it is not the thin disc itself which antitruncates and that what we are actually seeing is that the thick disc dominates the light emission even in the range of heights @xmath97 for @xmath98 . in order to test that possibility , we used the fits to vertical luminosity profiles and we calculated the mean flux per pixel emitted by the thick disc in the range @xmath97 ( height range for thin disc horizontal luminosity profiles ) divided by the mean flux per pixel emitted at @xmath99 ( height range for thick disc horizontal luminosity profiles ) . this value , which we will call @xmath100 , was averaged over all the valid vertical bins . however , because the shape of the vertical thick disc luminosity profile changes in the absence of a thin disc , we calculated a second value , @xmath101 , which measures the same ratio if the thin disc was removed but the thick disc face - on column mass density and vertical velocity dispersion were kept constant . as seen in figure [ thindiscremoved ] , @xmath102 . the @xmath100 and @xmath101 values can be used for estimating the brightness of the thick disc in the range of heights @xmath97 , but we have to consider that they have been calculated at low @xmath90 and can only be considered a useful approximation to what happens in galaxy outskirts . in figure [ verticalfits ] , the lower limit of the gray area is the estimate of the thick disc brightness at that range ( @xmath97 ) in the absence of a thin disc calculated by moving the red symbols up by a factor @xmath101 . the upper limit of the gray area represents the thick disc surface brightness estimate for the range @xmath97 in the case of a thin disc whose face - on column mass density relative to the thick disc is similar to that found at low @xmath90 ( moving the red symbols up by a factor @xmath100 ) . thus , for the outskirts of a galaxy , the lower limit of the gray area symbols represents what we have defined to be the thin disc if it was only the low @xmath27 part of a thick disc and no significant genuine thin disc was found there . of the 26 thin discs with antitruncations 14 ( eso 157 - 049 , eso 440 - 027 , ic 1553 , ngc 0522 , ngc 1163 , ngc 1422 , ngc 3454 , ngc 4330 , ngc 4359 , ngc 4607 , ngc 5529 , ugc 06526 , ugc 12518 , and ugc 12692 ) are well fitted by the lower limit of the gray area , meaning that they are compatible with the range of projected radii @xmath98 being dominated by the thick disc at all heights . in six galaxies ( eso 469 - 015 , ic 1576 , ugc 00903 , ugc 01970 , ugc 07086 , and ugc 10288 ) , the thick disc alone does not seem to be bright enough to account for all the light for heights @xmath97 at @xmath98 . in four galaxies ( ngc 1596 , ngc 3628 , ngc 4081 , and ugc 08737 ) our thick disc brightness estimate at @xmath97 overestimates the actual light emission . for ngc 5084 , the antitruncation is an artifact caused by the presence of an extended bulge . finally , for one galaxy ( ugc 10297 ) , the thick disc profile is too dim at @xmath98 to be able to obtain any conclusion . it thus seems that at least 14 out of 26 antitruncated galaxies , the antitruncation is actually an artifact caused by the presence of a thick disc . this number is probably a low estimate , because of the uncertainties of using @xmath101 for inferring the behavior of the disc in its outskirts . a legitimate question is that if for @xmath98 we are mostly detecting the thick disc at all heights , why its horizontal luminosity profile is almost always flatter for @xmath103 ( red horizontal luminosity profiles ) than in the range @xmath97 ( blue horizontal luminosity profiles ) ? this can be explained naturally if we consider that at @xmath104 there is still a small fraction of stars belonging to the thin disc , meaning that the vertical thick disc luminosity profile becomes more peaked ( see figure [ thindiscremoved ] ) than when the thin disc mass fraction becomes negligible for @xmath105 . this progressive broadening of the thick disc vertical luminosity profile with increasing projected radii causes the horizontal luminosity profile for @xmath97 to be steeper than that measured at @xmath99 . additionally , unmasked faint stars and extended psf wings are more likely to affect the much dimmer @xmath99 range , potentially further contributing to make its horizontal luminosity profile shallower . here we have shown that genuine antitruncations are rare ( twelve at maximum out of 70 or less than @xmath106 ) and that most of the features which would be considered an antitrucation in a face - on view are actually an artifact caused by the superposition of a thin and a thick disc with different scale lengths . however , it seems that several of the found antitruncations are genuine and could be a signature of a past interaction as suggested by laurikainen & salo ( 2001 ) . laurikainen & salo ( 2001 ) showed that many m 51-like interacting galaxies have antitruncations . they used numerical simulations to show that the redistribution of material caused by an interaction may last for several gyr , which could explain the presence of genuine antitruncations in isolated galaxies . also , some of the antitruncations which do not seem related to the thick disc could be caused by the presence of outer rings as suggested by erwin et al . ( 2005 ) . in section [ secmasses ] we found that thick discs with @xmath1 have roughly constant relative masses with respect the thin disc ( @xmath0 ) , and that the relative stellar mass of the thick disc increases for @xmath108 . this threshold was not noticed in co11b due to smaller statistics and a larger scatter in data due to less restrictive quality selection criteria . however , it was detected by yoachim & dalcanton ( 2006 ) . if , as indicated in co11b , thick discs would have formed in situ at high redshift and have their thin discs formed from gas remaining from the formation process and posterior cold accretion , at least two factors could contribute to make @xmath91 larger in less massive galaxies : * supernova feedback is more efficient at removing the gas from shallower potential wells . this is because in a high - mass galaxy , gas expelled by supernovae during the thick disc build - up could eventually come back to the galaxy and be used for building the thin disc . gas expelled from low - mass galaxies would be less likely to come back . * lower - mass galaxies are dynamically younger than higher - mass ones . all galaxies have already formed their thick disc , and have later started to form the thin disc . because of the slowest evolution of lower - mass galaxies , their thin discs are younger and less developed , implying a larger fraction of gas in them . it is important to stress the point that less massive galaxies are likely to expel a larger gas fraction through supernova feedback than massive ones . indeed , as pointed out by elmegreen & elmegreen ( 2006 ) , if a thick disc formed at high redshift had only @xmath109 of the total mass of the disc ( as it is the case for today s thick discs in some massive galaxies ) , its scale height would shrink considerably when the gas which formed the thin disc , the remaining 80% in mass , was accreted . this could cause , if the thick disc scale height was not large enough ( several kpc ) that the thick discs would be indistinguishable from the thin discs in vertical luminosity profiles . the thick disc scale height shrinking would be smaller in a low - mass galaxy accreting a lower fraction of gas ( @xmath110 ) , which would make the original thick disc formed at high redshift much easier to detect . thus , what we observe as a thick discs in today s low - mass galaxies , would be mostly the original in situ thick discs formed at high - redshifts . for massive galaxies , which have expelled less gas through supernova feedback , it is possible that this disc would have shrunk so much that it would be undetectable . in this case , there would be no genuine thick discs , but a continuous distribution of scale heights created by the secular heating of the thin disc by its own overdensities in accordance with the claim from bovy et al . ( 2012 ) for the milky way . significant thin disc heating by satellites is likely to be discarded due to the absence of widespread flares as discussed in co11b . the thick disc being mostly made of stars stripped from satellites is also discarded because that mechanism would lead thick discs significantly less massive than what is observed ( see co11b for a full discussion on these two points ) . radial migration ( schnrich & binney 2009 ) could also explain the presence of thick discs in massive galaxies , but fails at explaining the presence of very massive thick discs in low - mass galaxies which are dynamically younger than high - mass ones . a way of testing whether @xmath91 is higher in low - mass galaxies due to a slower dynamical evolution is to recalculate @xmath111 by considering that , in addition to the thin disc stars , it includes the gas disc . if low - mass galaxies were less efficient at forming stars , the new @xmath91 would show a flatter trend with the rotation velocity , @xmath112 . to calculate the mass of gas contained in a disc , we used the 21-cm corrected for self - absorption flux from hyperleda and we converted it to a gas mass using the expression @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the area of the 21-cm line profile expressed in mjykms@xmath115 and @xmath116 is the distance to the galaxy expressed in mpc ( zwaan et al . 1997 ) . as done in yoachim & dalcanton ( 2006 ) , we made the correction @xmath117 to account for helium and metals and we did not apply a correction for molecular gas . the new @xmath91 values have been calculated considering that the absolute @xmath6 magnitude of the sun in ab system is @xmath118 ( oh et al . 2008 ) , that @xmath119 , and that @xmath38 . this has been done for all except three galaxies in the sample . those three galaxies had no @xmath114 value available in hyperleda . the result of including the gas into the thin disc is shown in figure [ plotgas ] in which the diamond symbols represent @xmath91 once the gas has been included in the thin disc . we note a slight tendency for low - mass galaxies to get their relative thick disc masses lowered by a larger factor by this operation than in the case of high - mass galaxies . when including the gas in the thin disc , the decrease in the thick disc relative mass fraction is @xmath120 when @xmath108 and @xmath121 for galaxies with @xmath1 . this would support the idea of lower - mass discs having a slower evolution than higher - mass galaxies and having transformed less gas into thin disc stars . however , a definitive quantification of this effect can not be obtained without knowing the mass - to - light ratio of the discs . we are working on this quantification and we will be publish it in a follow - up paper . recent works suggest that thick discs are formed in situ at high redshift . so far , the easier way the study thin and thick discs as separate features is by looking at edge - on galaxies . breaks ( truncations and antitruncations ) in disc galaxies have been until now mostly studied for the disc as a whole , without distinguishing the light of the thin and the thick disc . several theories compete for explaining the origin of such breaks . truncations have been explained by dynamical arguments related with the conservation of angular momentum during galaxy formation , by star formation thresholds , and by the redistribution of angular momentum by a bar . antitruncations have in some cases been linked to interactions and mergers . in order to study a significant sample of edge - on galaxies ( 70 ) , we produced luminosity profiles of thin and thick discs parallel to galaxy midplanes from the average of the 3.6 and 4.5@xmath122 images from the spitzer survey of stellar structures in galaxies ( s@xmath4 g ) . the vertical height dominated by each disc was derived from luminosity profiles perpendicular to midplanes done in a similar way to that described in comern et al . ( 2011b ) . in brief , we fitted the observed vertical luminosity profiles by comparing them with a grid of models made by solving the equations of three gravitationally coupled vertically isothermal discs ( thin , thick , and gas discs ) . we defined the range of heights for which the thick disc dominates that height ( named @xmath14 ) above which it emits 90% of the light . we defined a height , @xmath123 at which the @xmath80 level was reached for the fitted vertical bins . the thick disc horizontal luminosity profile was made by averaging the light emission for @xmath103 and the thin disc one was made by averaging light in @xmath97 . once the thin and thick disc luminosity profiles parallel to midplanes were created , we fitted them with a integrated over the line of sight generalization of the function used by erwin et al . ( 2008 ) to describe discs with breaks . the conclusions of this paper are : * the position of our breaks are compatible with those fitted in face - on galaxies . * horizontal luminosity profiles for thin discs are often truncated ( 77% of cases ) and also have a significant number of antitruncations ( 40% of cases ) . according to our fits , thick discs truncate with a frequency of 31% , although some extra truncations can not be discarded at a lower surface brightness than our detection threshold . antitruncations are rare in our thick disc sample ( 6% ) and are in three out of four cases artifacts caused by an extended bulge . * when thick discs truncate , they do so at a radius usually compatible with that of the truncation of the thin disc . however , not all truncated thin discs are associated with a truncated thick disc . this dichotomy suggests two different mechanisms creating truncations : one necessarily of dynamical origin affecting both discs and one affecting only the thin disc . another possibility is that the same mechanism creates a truncation in the thin disc or in both depending on some galactic property which has not been studied in this paper ( such as bar or kinematical properties ) . * antitruncations in thin discs seem to be related , in more than half of the cases , to the superposition of a thin and a thick disc with different scale lengths . thus , for those thin discs , the part outside the antitruncation would actually be the thick disc . we estimate the fraction of genuine thin disc antitruncations to be at maximum 15% . this is less than half of those that would be expected from a deep enough fit to a face - on galaxy sample . * because our sample is much larger and better selected than that used in comern et al . ( 2011b ) , we have been able to further constrain the shape of the relation between the stellar mass of the thick disc relative to that of the thin disc , @xmath91 , and the galaxy circular velocity , @xmath112 originally found by yoachim & dalcanton ( 2006 ) ( figure [ plotgas ] ) . we found that galaxies with @xmath1 have a roughly constant @xmath91 . from @xmath107 downwards , @xmath91 increases dramatically with , in some cases , @xmath124 . for these galaxies , the high @xmath91 could be caused by a combination of a high efficiency of supernova feedback that removes gas from the weak potential well of the young galaxy and limits the eventual mass of the thin disc and a slower dynamical evolution causing the stellar thin discs to be younger and less massive than in higher - mass galaxies . in the latter case we showed that , if we assume the same @xmath36 for all galaxies , when gas is included in the mass of the thin disc , galaxies with @xmath108 have @xmath91 values that are more similar to those in galaxies with @xmath1 . this similarity implies that part of the high value for @xmath91 low mass galaxies is the result of thin disc youth : the thin disc mass has not formed stars yet . the authors wish to thank the entire s@xmath4 g team for their efforts in this project . ea and ab thank the centre national dtudes spatiales for financial support . ks , j - cm - m , tk , and tm acknowledge support from the national radio astronomy observatory , which is a facility of the national science foundation operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc . we thank our anonymous referee for comments that helped to improve the paper . this work is based on observations and archival data made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa . we are grateful to the dedicated staff at the spitzer science center for their help and support in planning and execution of this exploration science program . we also gratefully acknowledge support from nasa jpl / spitzer grant rsa 1374189 provided for the s@xmath4 g project . funding for sdss - iii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s . department of energy office of science . the sdss - iii web site is http://www.sdss3.org/. sdss - iii is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions of the sdss - iii collaboration including the university of arizona , the brazilian participation group , brookhaven national laboratory , university of cambridge , carnegie mellon university , university of florida , the french participation group , the german participation group , harvard university , the instituto de astrofisica de canarias , the michigan state / notre dame / jina participation group , johns hopkins university , lawrence berkeley national laboratory , max planck institute for astrophysics , new mexico state university , new york university , ohio state university , pennsylvania state university , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the spanish participation group , university of tokyo , university of utah , vanderbilt university , university of virginia , university of washington , and yale university . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . 99 abadi , m. g. , navarro , j. f. , steinmetz , m. , & eke , v. r. 2003 , apj , 597 , 21 aihara , h. , allende - prieto , c. , an . , d. , et al . 2011 , apjs , 193 , 29 bakos , j. , & trujillo , i. 2012 , submitted to mnras , ( arxiv:1207.7023 ) banerjee , a. , & jog , c. j. 2007 , apj , 622 , 335 barteldrees , a. , & dettmar , r .- j . 1994 , a&as , 103 , 475 bensby , t. , feltzing , s. , lundstrm , i. , & ilyin , i. 2005 , a&a , 433 , 185 bigiel , f. , leroy , a. , brinks , e. , et al . 2008 , aj , 136 , 2846 bournaud , f. , elmegreen , b. g. , & martig , m. 2009 , apj , 707 , l1 bovy , j. , rix , h .- w . , & hogg , d. w. 2012 , apj , 751 , 131 brook , c. , richard , s. , kawata , d. , martel , h. , & gibson , b. k. 2007 , apj , 658 , 60 burstein , d. 1979 , apj , 234 , 829 buta , r. j. 2012 , in planets , stars , and stellar systems , vol . series editor t. d. oswalt , volume editor w. c. keel , springer reference buta , r. j. , sheth , k. , regan , m. , et al . 2010 , apjs , 190 , 147 clemens , d. p. 1985 , apj , 295 , 422 comern , s. , elmegreen , b. g. , knapen , j. h. , et al . 2011c , apj , 738 , l17 comern , s. , elmegreen , b. g. , knapen , j. h. , et al . 2011b , apj , 741 , 28 ( co11b ) comern , s. , knapen , j. h. , sheth , k. , et al . 2011a , apj , 729 , 18 dalcanton , j. j. , yoachim , p. , & bernstein , r. a. 2004 , aj , 608 , 189 debattista , v. p. , mayer , l. , carollo , c. m. , et al . 2006 , apj , 645 , 209 de grijs , r. , kregel , m. , & wesson , k. h. 2001 , mnras , 324 , 1074 de jong , r. s. , seth , a. c. , radburn - smith , d. j. , et al . 2007 , apj , 667 , l49 de vaucouleurs , g. , de vaucouleurs , a. , corwin , h. g. , et al . 1991 , third reference catalog of bright galaxies ( new york : springer ) ( rc3 ) elmegreen , b. g. , & elmegreen , d. m. 2006 , apj , 650 , 644 erwin , p. , beckman , j. e. , & pohlen , m. 2005 , apj , 626 , l81 erwin , p. , pohlen , m. , & beckman , j. e. 2008 , aj , 135 , 20 fazio , g. g. , hora , j. l. , allen , l. e. , et al . 2004 , apjs , 154 , 10 florido , e. , battaner , e. , guijarro , a. , garzn , f. , & castillo - morales , a. 2006a , a&a , 455 , 467 florido , e. , battaner , e. , guijarro , a. , garzn , f. , & castillo - morales , a. 2006a , a&a , 455 , 475 florido , e. , battaner , e. , guijarro , a. , garzn , f. , & jimnez - vicente , j. 2001 , a&a , 378 , 82 freeman k. c. 1970 , apj , 160 , 811 fuhrmann , k. 1998 , a&a , 338 , 161 gilmore , g. , & reid , n. 1983 , mnras , 202 , 1025 gutirrez , l. , erwin , p. , aladro , r. , & beckman , j. e. 2011 , aj , 142 , 145 haynes , m. p. 1979 , aj , 84 , 1830 iwrin , j. a. , kennedy , h. , parkin , t. , & madden , s. 2007 , a&a , 474 , 461 jordi , k. , grebel , e. k. , & ammon , k. 2006 , a&a , 460 , 339 kennicutt , jr . , r. c. 1989 , apj , 344 , 685 kregel , m. , & van der kruit , p. c. 2004 , mnras , 355 , 143 kregel , m. , van der kruit , p. c. , & de blok , w. j. g. 2004 , mnras , 352 , 768 kregel , m. , van der kruit , p. c. , & de grijs , r. 2002 , mnras , 334 , 646 laurikainen , e. , & salo , h. 2001 , mnras , 324 , 685 lewis , j. r. , & freeman , k. c. 1989 , aj , 97 , 139 loebman , s. r. , rokar , r. , debattista , v. p. , et al . 2011 , apj , 737 , 8 maltby , d. t. , hoyos , c. , gray , m. e. , aragn - salamanca , a. , & wolf , c. 2012 , mnras , 420 , 2475 narayan , c. a. , & jog , c. j. 2002 , a&a , 394 , 89 newmark , n. m. 1959 , proc . asce , 85 , 67 oh , s .- h . , de blok , w. j. g. , fabian , w. , brinks , e. , & kennicutt , jr . , r. c. 2008 , aj , 136 , 2761 paturel , g. , petit , c. , prugniel , ph . , et al . 2003 , a&a , 412 , 45 prez , i. 2004 , a&a , 427 , l17 pohlen , m. , balcells , m. , ltticke , r. , & dettmar , r .- j . 2004a , a&a , 422 , 465 pohlen , m. , beckman , j. e. , httmeister , s. , et al . 2004b , in penetrating bars through masks of cosmic dust , ed . d. l. block et al . ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 713 pohlen , m. , dettmar , r .- j . , & ltticke , r. 2000 , a&a , 357 , 1 pohlen , m. , & trujillo , i. 2006 , a&a , 454 , 759 pohlen , m. , zaroubi , s. , peletier , r. f. , & dettmar , r .- j . 2007 , mnras , 378 , 594 prochaska , j. x. , naumov , s. o. , carney , b. w. , mcwilliam , a. , & wolfe , a. m. 2000 , aj , 120 , 2513 qu , y. , di matteo , p. , lehnert , m. d. , & van driel , w. 2011 , a&a , 530 , 10 radburn - smith , d. j. , rokar , r. , debattista , v. p. , et al . 2012 , apj , accepted for publication scnrich , r. , & binney , j. 2009 , mnras , 396 , 203 sheth , k. , regan , m. , hinz , j. l. , et al . 2010 , pasp , 122 , 1397 spitler , l. r. , forbes , d. a. , & beasley , m. a. 2008 , mnras , 389 , 1150 spitzer , l. 1978 , physical processes in the interstellar medium ( new york : john wiley ) stark , a. a. 1984 , apj , 281 , 624 trujillo , i. , & pohlen , m. 2005 , apj , 630 , l17 tsikoudi , v. 1979 , apj , 234 , 842 van albada , t. s. , bahcall , j. n. , begeman , k. , & sancisi , r. 1985 , apj , 295 , 305 van der kruit , p. c. 1979 , a&as , 38 15 van der kruit , p. c. 1987 , a&a , 173 , 59 van der kruit , p. c. 2001 , in asp conf . 230 , galaxy disks and disk galaxies , ed . j. g. funes & e. m. corsini ( san francisco : asp ) , 119 van der kruit , p. c. , & searle , l. 1981a , a&a , 95 , 105 van der kruit , p. c. , & searle , l. 1981b , a&a , 95 , 116 van der kruit , p. c. , & searle , l. 1982 , a&a , 110 , 79 yoachim , p. , & dalcanton , j. j. , 2006 , aj , 131 , 226 zwaan , m. a. , briggs , f. h. , sprayberry , d. , & sorar , e. 1997 , apj , 490 , 173 l c c c c c c + galaxy i d & @xmath11 & distance & @xmath125 & @xmath112 & @xmath60 & pa + & & ( mpc ) & ( mag ) & kms@xmath115 & ( ) & ( ) + + galaxy i d & @xmath11 & distance & @xmath125 & @xmath112 & @xmath60 & pa + & & ( mpc ) & ( mag ) & kms@xmath115 & ( ) & ( ) + eso 157 - 049 & 3.0 & 23.9 & 13.55 & 90.48 & 52 & 28.1 + eso 240 - 011 & 4.8 & 42.4 & 11.52 & 267.46 & 16 & 127.2 + eso 292 - 014 & 6.5 & 24.9 & 12.47 & 107.73 & 89 & 83.9 + eso 346 - 001 & 5.1 & 34.9 & 13.29 & 47.68 & 64 & 64.3 + eso 440 - 027 & 6.6 & 21.6 & 11.50 & 117.53 & 10 & 79.7 + eso 443 - 021 & 5.8 & 48.1 & 13.24 & 161.71 & 37 & 159.3 + eso 466 - 014 & 3.8 & 47.7 & 14.23 & 121.00 & 40 & 50.4 + eso 469 - 015 & 3.3 & 27.0 & 13.69 & 93.01 & 56 & 149.6 + eso 533 - 004 & 5.2 & 36.2 & 13.05 & 147.54 & 55 & 150.5 + eso 544 - 027 & 3.4 & 40.3 & 14.20 & 92.00 & 46 & 153.3 + ic 0217 & 5.9 & 24.2 & 13.86 & 100.15 & 60 & 35.7 + ic 0610 & 3.9 & 20.7 & 13.44 & 133.84 & 57 & 29.0 + ic 1197 & 6.0 & 25.7 & 13.14 & 87.90 & 77 & 56.4 + ic 1553 & 5.2 & 39.9 & 13.38 & 67.93 & 40 & 15.0 + ic 1711 & 3.0 & 52.3 & 13.19 & 173.41 & 75 & 43.9 + ic 1913 & 3.4 & 21.4 & 13.38 & 77.88 & 58 & 147.7 + ic 2058 & 6.5 & 19.4 & 12.13 & 82.78 & 102 & 17.4 + ic 2135 & 6.0 & 29.2 & 11.93 & 107.08 & 97 & 108.6 + ic 5176 & 4.5 & 26.4 & 12.02 & 164.38 & 134 & 27.9 + ngc 0489 & 2.7 & 33.5 & 12.42 & 180.91 & 46 & 120.8 + ngc 0522 & 4.1 & 35.0 & 12.28 & 169.10 & 72 & 32.9 + ngc 0678 & 3.0 & 27.1 & 12.15 & 169.03 & 93 & 77.4 + ngc 1032 & 0.4 & 35.6 & 12.13 & 283.94 & 106 & 67.5 + ngc 1163 & 4.1 & 30.9 & 13.40 & 142.07 & 69 & 143.0 + ngc 1422 & 2.3 & 16.9 & 13.22 & 65.87 & 75 & 65.5 + ngc 1495 & 5.0 & 17.3 & 12.19 & 90.73 & 67 & 104.5 + ngc 1596 & -2.0 & 15.6 & 11.94 & 98.32 & 117 & 18.7 + ngc 2732 & -2.0 & 31.8 & 12.73 & 32.30 & 55 & 65.7 + ngc 3098 & -1.5 & 22.4 & 12.68 & 129.73 & 70 & 88.7 + ngc 3279 & 6.5 & 32.5 & 12.37 & 155.85 & 74 & 152.0 + ngc 3454 & 5.5 & 21.3 & 12.44 & 91.25 & 72 & 116.1 + ngc 3501 & 5.9 & 23.3 & 12.09 & 133.61 & 128 & 28.0 + ngc 3592 & 5.3 & 22.7 & 13.44 & 79.72 & 64 & 117.7 + ngc 3600 & 1.0 & 13.6 & 12.78 & 86.90 & 56 & 4.4 + ngc 3628 & 3.1 & 12.2 & 9.150 & 215.16 & 329 & 102.6 + ngc 4081 & 1.0 & 26.1 & 15.12 & 116.53 & 42 & 130.0 + ngc 4111 & -1.4 & 16.0 & 11.60 & 71.63 & 53 & 152.2 + ngc 4330 & 6.3 & 19.5 & 11.99 & 117.85 & 69 & 59.2 + ngc 4359 & 5.0 & 13.3 & 13.43 & 102.83 & 41 & 107.7 + ngc 4437 & 6.0 & 9.8 & 9.620 & 140.13 & 274 & 82.4 + ngc 4565 & 3.2 & 13.3 & 8.970 & 244.94 & 498&135.1 + ngc 4607 & 3.4 & 20.0 & 12.63 & 98.93 & 87 & 2.7 + ngc 4747 & 7.2 & 12.3 & 12.36 & 69.60 & 63 & 31.9 + ngc 5084 & -2.0 & 26.4 & 11.07 & 309.88 & 300 & 81.0 + ngc 5470 & 3.1 & 18.0 & 13.00 & 109.45 & 77 & 62.2 + ngc 5529 & 5.3 & 50.0 & 11.20 & 284.14 & 173&114.3 + ngc 5981 & 4.3 & 29.2 & 12.48 & 251.12 & 83 & 139.8 + ngc 6010 & 0.4 & 21.6 & 12.33 & 148.80 & 55 & 103.3 + ngc 7347 & 4.6 & 38.7 & 13.25 & 115.11 & 46 & 130.8 + pgc 013646 & 5.1 & 32.6 & 12.32 & 168.16 & 102&34.4 + pgc 028308 & 6.8 & 40.5 & 12.87 & 167.27 & 60&125.8 + pgc 030591 & 6.8 & 29.8 & 13.36 & 111.59 & 45&168.4 + pgc 032548 & -0.2 & 37.3 & 15.06 & 93.33 & 27 & 149.7 + pgc 052809 & 5.9 & 24.9 & 12.46 & 100.97 & 95&169.2 + ugc 00903 & 3.9 & 51.6 & 13.09 & 163.23 & 50 & 52.6 + ugc 01970 & 5.9 & 33.9 & 13.32 & 95.20 & 55 & 22.5 + ugc 05347 & 6.5 & 33.8 & 13.53 & 95.64 & 41 & 17.0 + ugc 05689 & 6.4 & 43.4 & 14.07 & 119.67 & 40 & 153.4 + ugc 05958 & 4.0 & 29.4 & 14.26 & 78.15 & 49 & 178.9 + ugc 06526 & 7.0 & 32.3 & 12.64 & 72.57 & 49 & 87.2 + ugc 07086 & 3.1 & 32.8 & 14.02 & 126.01 & 69 & 70.5 + ugc 08737 & 4.0 & 41.9 & 13.27 & 163.31 & 72 & 150.7 + ugc 09448 & 3.2 & 37.8 & 13.95 & 111.50 & 49 & 85.8 + ugc 09665 & 4.0 & 42.5 & 13.57 & 126.05 & 51 & 141.5 + ugc 10043 & 4.1 & 37.3 & 13.80 & 143.59 & 66 & 150.5 + ugc 10288 & 5.3 & 32.4 & 12.09 & 166.59 & 144 & 90.4 + ugc 10297 & 5.1 & 39.2 & 13.43 & 102.82 & 64 & 2.9 + ugc 12518 & 3.0 & 51.6 & 14.11 & 49.58 & 42 & 25.2 + ugc 12692 & 3.9 & 49.6 & 14.21 & 101.34 & 38 & 53.2 + ugc 12857 & 4.0 & 34.5 & 13.24 & 107.94 & 61 & 33.5 + note . @xmath11 values from hyperleda . distance values from the average of redshift - independent measurements in ned when available and if not from virgo infall corrected radial velocities and a hubble - lematre constant @xmath126 . @xmath125 values are hyperleda s internal absorption - corrected values . @xmath112 values from hyperleda . @xmath60 values from hyperleda except for ngc 4111 , for which we used the rc3 value . pa values from hyperleda , except for eso 440 - 027 , ic 5176 , and ngc 3098 , for which we measured our own pa values using ellipse fitting . lccccc + i d & type & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + & & ( mag / as@xmath131 ) & ( ) & ( ) & ( ) + + i d & type & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + & & ( mag / as@xmath131 ) & ( ) & ( ) & ( ) + eso 157 - 049&type ii+iii&@xmath132&@xmath133&@xmath134&@xmath135 + & & & @xmath134&@xmath136&@xmath137 + & & & @xmath136&@xmath138&@xmath139 + eso 240 - 011&type ii&@xmath140&@xmath141&@xmath142&@xmath143 + & & & @xmath142&@xmath144&@xmath145 + eso 292 - 014&type ii&@xmath146&@xmath147&@xmath148&@xmath149 + & & & @xmath148&@xmath150&@xmath151 + eso 346 - 001&type ii+ii&@xmath152&@xmath153&@xmath154&@xmath155 + & & & @xmath154&@xmath156&@xmath157 + & & & @xmath156&@xmath158&@xmath159 + eso 440 - 027&type ii+iii&@xmath160&@xmath161&@xmath162&@xmath163 + & & & @xmath162&@xmath164&@xmath165 + & & & @xmath164&@xmath166&@xmath167 + eso 443 - 021&type ii&@xmath168&@xmath141&@xmath169&@xmath170 + & & & @xmath169&@xmath171&@xmath172 + eso 466 - 014&type ii&@xmath173&@xmath174&@xmath175&@xmath176 + & & & @xmath175&@xmath177&@xmath178 + eso 469 - 015&type ii+iii&@xmath179&@xmath174&@xmath180&@xmath181 + & & & @xmath180&@xmath182&@xmath183 + & & & @xmath182&@xmath158&@xmath184 + eso 533 - 004&type ii&@xmath185&@xmath186&@xmath187&@xmath188 + & & & @xmath187&@xmath150&@xmath189 + eso 544 - 027&type ii&@xmath190&@xmath191&@xmath192&@xmath193 + & & & @xmath192&@xmath194&@xmath195 + ic 0217&type ii&@xmath196&@xmath153&@xmath197&@xmath198 + & & & @xmath197&@xmath199&@xmath200 + ic 0610&type ii+ii&@xmath201&@xmath141&@xmath202&@xmath203 + & & & @xmath202&@xmath204&@xmath205 + & & & @xmath204&@xmath206&@xmath207 + ic 1197&type ii&@xmath208&@xmath209&@xmath210&@xmath211 + & & & @xmath210&@xmath212&@xmath213 + ic 1553&type ii+iii&@xmath214&@xmath153&@xmath215&@xmath216 + & & & @xmath215&@xmath217&@xmath218 + & & & @xmath217&@xmath194&@xmath219 + + ic 1711&type ii&@xmath220&@xmath221&@xmath222&@xmath223 + & & & @xmath222&@xmath150&@xmath224 + ic 1913&type ii&@xmath225&@xmath226&@xmath227&@xmath228 + & & & @xmath227&@xmath206&@xmath229 + ic 2058&type ii&@xmath230&@xmath174&@xmath231&@xmath232 + & & & @xmath231&@xmath233&@xmath234 + ic 2135&type ii&@xmath235&@xmath147&@xmath236&@xmath237 + & & & @xmath236&@xmath238&@xmath239 + ic 5176&type iii&@xmath240&@xmath241&@xmath242&@xmath243 + & & & @xmath242&@xmath166&@xmath244 + ngc 0489&type i&@xmath245&@xmath241&@xmath246&@xmath247 + ngc 0522&type ii+iii&@xmath248&@xmath186&@xmath249&@xmath250 + & & & @xmath249&@xmath251&@xmath252 + & & & @xmath251&@xmath212&@xmath253 + ngc 0678&type ii&@xmath254&@xmath194&@xmath255&@xmath256 + & & & @xmath255&@xmath257&@xmath258 + ngc 1032&type ii&@xmath259&@xmath177&@xmath260&@xmath261 + & & & @xmath260&@xmath262&@xmath263 + ngc 1163&type ii+iii&@xmath264&@xmath265&@xmath266&@xmath266 + & & & @xmath266&@xmath267&@xmath268 + & & & @xmath267&@xmath212&@xmath269 + ngc 1422&type iii&@xmath270&@xmath133&@xmath271&@xmath272 + & & & @xmath271&@xmath233&@xmath273 + ngc 1495&type ii&@xmath274&@xmath275&@xmath276&@xmath277 + & & & @xmath276&@xmath278&@xmath279 + ngc 1596&type iii&@xmath280&@xmath275&@xmath281&@xmath282 + & & & @xmath281&@xmath283&@xmath284 + ngc 2732&type ii&@xmath285&@xmath286&@xmath287&@xmath288 + & & & @xmath287&@xmath289&@xmath290 + ngc 3098&type iii&@xmath291&@xmath275&@xmath292&@xmath293 + & & & @xmath292&@xmath199&@xmath294 + ngc 3279&type ii&@xmath295&@xmath296&@xmath297&@xmath298 + & & & @xmath297&@xmath299&@xmath300 + ngc 3454&type ii+iii&@xmath301&@xmath241&@xmath302&@xmath303 + & & & @xmath302&@xmath304&@xmath305 + & & & @xmath304&@xmath299&@xmath306 + ngc 3501&type ii&@xmath307&@xmath275&@xmath308&@xmath309 + & & & @xmath308&@xmath310&@xmath311 + ngc 3592&type ii&@xmath312&@xmath141&@xmath313&@xmath314 + & & & @xmath313&@xmath315&@xmath316 + ngc 3600&type iii&@xmath317&@xmath161&@xmath318&@xmath226 + & & & @xmath318&@xmath233&@xmath319 + ngc 3628&type ii+iii+ii&@xmath320&@xmath158&@xmath321&@xmath322 + & & & @xmath321&@xmath323&@xmath324 + & & & @xmath323&@xmath325&@xmath326 + & & & @xmath325&@xmath327&@xmath328 + ngc 4081&type ii+iii&@xmath329&@xmath296&@xmath330&@xmath331 + & & & @xmath330&@xmath332&@xmath333 + & & & @xmath332&@xmath334&@xmath335 + ngc 4111&type ii&@xmath336&@xmath337&@xmath338&@xmath339 + & & & @xmath338&@xmath340&@xmath341 + ngc 4330&type ii+iii+ii&@xmath342&@xmath343&@xmath344&@xmath345 + & & & @xmath344&@xmath346&@xmath347 + & & & @xmath346&@xmath348&@xmath349 + & & & @xmath348&@xmath166&@xmath350 + ngc 4359&type iii&@xmath351&@xmath296&@xmath352&@xmath353 + & & & @xmath352&@xmath257&@xmath354 + ngc 4437&type ii&@xmath355&@xmath356&@xmath357&@xmath358 + & & & @xmath357&@xmath359&@xmath360 + ngc 4565&type ii+ii&@xmath361&@xmath212&@xmath362&@xmath363 + & & & @xmath362&@xmath364&@xmath365 + & & & @xmath364&@xmath366&@xmath367 + ngc 4607&type ii+iii&@xmath368&@xmath226&@xmath369&@xmath370 + & & & @xmath369&@xmath371&@xmath372 + & & & @xmath371&@xmath310&@xmath373 + ngc 4747&type i&@xmath374&@xmath153&@xmath375&@xmath376 + ngc 5084&type iii&@xmath377&@xmath378&@xmath379&@xmath380 + & & & @xmath379&@xmath381&@xmath382 + ngc 5470&type ii&@xmath383&@xmath343&@xmath384&@xmath385 + & & & @xmath384&@xmath199&@xmath386 + + + ngc 5529&type ii+iii+ii&@xmath387&@xmath147&@xmath388&@xmath389 + & & & @xmath388&@xmath390&@xmath391 + & & & @xmath390&@xmath392&@xmath393 + & & & @xmath392&@xmath394&@xmath395 + ngc 5981&type ii&@xmath396&@xmath397&@xmath398&@xmath399 + & & & @xmath398&@xmath400&@xmath401 + ngc 6010&type ii&@xmath402&@xmath397&@xmath403&@xmath404 + & & & @xmath403&@xmath299&@xmath405 + ngc 7347&type ii&@xmath406&@xmath147&@xmath407&@xmath408 + & & & @xmath407&@xmath246&@xmath409 + pgc 013646&type ii&@xmath410&@xmath147&@xmath411&@xmath412 + & & & @xmath411&@xmath238&@xmath413 + pgc 028308&type ii&@xmath414&@xmath241&@xmath415&@xmath416 + & & & @xmath415&@xmath334&@xmath417 + pgc 030591&type i&@xmath418&@xmath147&@xmath419&@xmath420 + pgc 032548&type i&@xmath421&@xmath265&@xmath419&@xmath422 + pgc 052809&type ii&@xmath423&@xmath141&@xmath424&@xmath425 + & & & @xmath424&@xmath375&@xmath426 + ugc 00903&type ii+iii&@xmath427&@xmath241&@xmath428&@xmath429 + & & & @xmath428&@xmath430&@xmath431 + & & & @xmath430&@xmath334&@xmath432 + ugc 01970&type iii+ii&@xmath433&@xmath265&@xmath434&@xmath435 + & & & @xmath434&@xmath436&@xmath437 + & & & @xmath436&@xmath289&@xmath438 + ugc 05347&type ii&@xmath439&@xmath440&@xmath441&@xmath442 + & & & @xmath441&@xmath177&@xmath443 + ugc 05689&type ii&@xmath444&@xmath133&@xmath445&@xmath446 + & & & @xmath445&@xmath447&@xmath448 + ugc 05958&type i&@xmath449&@xmath153&@xmath334&@xmath432 + ugc 06526&type iii&@xmath450&@xmath440&@xmath451&@xmath452 + & & & @xmath451&@xmath150&@xmath453 + ugc 07086&type ii+iii&@xmath454&@xmath296&@xmath455&@xmath456 + & & & @xmath455&@xmath457&@xmath458 + & & & @xmath457&@xmath150&@xmath459 + + + ugc 08737&type ii+iii&@xmath460&@xmath343&@xmath461&@xmath462 + & & & @xmath461&@xmath463&@xmath464 + & & & @xmath463&@xmath238&@xmath465 + ugc 09448&type i&@xmath466&@xmath467&@xmath158&@xmath468 + ugc 09665&type ii&@xmath469&@xmath241&@xmath470&@xmath471 + & & & @xmath470&@xmath158&@xmath472 + ugc 10043&type ii&@xmath473&@xmath474&@xmath475&@xmath476 + & & & @xmath475&@xmath477&@xmath478 + ugc 10288&type ii+iii&@xmath479&@xmath147&@xmath480&@xmath481 + & & & @xmath480&@xmath482&@xmath483 + & & & @xmath482&@xmath484&@xmath485 + ugc 10297&type ii+iii&@xmath486&@xmath296&@xmath487&@xmath488 + & & & @xmath487&@xmath489&@xmath490 + & & & @xmath489&@xmath334&@xmath491 + ugc 12518&type ii+iii&@xmath492&@xmath153&@xmath493&@xmath494 + & & & @xmath493&@xmath495&@xmath172 + & & & @xmath495&@xmath138&@xmath496 + ugc 12692&type iii&@xmath497&@xmath153&@xmath498&@xmath499 + & & & @xmath498&@xmath419&@xmath500 + ugc 12857&type i&@xmath501&@xmath209&@xmath171&@xmath502 + note . @xmath128 and @xmath129 stand for the inner and the outer limit of each fitted section and @xmath130 corresponds to the scale length of that section . the lower limit of the innermost section and the upper limit of the outermost section have no error bar because they have been set manually . lccccc + i d & type & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + & & ( mag / as@xmath131 ) & ( ) & ( ) & ( ) + + i d & type & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + & & ( mag / as@xmath131 ) & ( ) & ( ) & ( ) + eso 157 - 049&type ii+iii&@xmath503&@xmath133&@xmath504&@xmath505 + & & & @xmath504&@xmath506&@xmath507 + & & & @xmath506&@xmath206&@xmath508 + eso 240 - 011&type ii&@xmath509&@xmath141&@xmath510&@xmath511 + & & & @xmath510&@xmath144&@xmath512 + + eso 292 - 014&type ii&@xmath513&@xmath147&@xmath514&@xmath515 + & & & @xmath514&@xmath150&@xmath516 + eso 346 - 001&type ii+ii&@xmath517&@xmath153&@xmath518&@xmath519 + & & & @xmath518&@xmath520&@xmath521 + & & & @xmath520&@xmath158&@xmath522 + eso 440 - 027&type ii+iii&@xmath523&@xmath161&@xmath524&@xmath525 + & & & @xmath524&@xmath526&@xmath527 + & & & @xmath526&@xmath166&@xmath528 + eso 443 - 021&type ii&@xmath529&@xmath141&@xmath530&@xmath531 + & & & @xmath530&@xmath171&@xmath532 + eso 466 - 014&type ii&@xmath533&@xmath174&@xmath534&@xmath535 + & & & @xmath534&@xmath177&@xmath536 + eso 469 - 015&type ii+iii&@xmath537&@xmath174&@xmath416&@xmath538 + & & & @xmath416&@xmath539&@xmath540 + & & & @xmath539&@xmath158&@xmath541 + eso 533 - 004&type ii&@xmath542&@xmath186&@xmath543&@xmath544 + & & & @xmath543&@xmath150&@xmath545 + eso 544 - 027&type ii&@xmath546&@xmath191&@xmath547&@xmath548 + & & & @xmath547&@xmath194&@xmath549 + ic 0217&type ii&@xmath550&@xmath153&@xmath551&@xmath552 + & & & @xmath551&@xmath199&@xmath553 + ic 0610&type ii+ii&@xmath554&@xmath141&@xmath555&@xmath556 + & & & @xmath555&@xmath557&@xmath558 + & & & @xmath557&@xmath206&@xmath559 + ic 1197&type ii&@xmath560&@xmath209&@xmath561&@xmath562 + & & & @xmath561&@xmath212&@xmath563 + ic 1553&type ii+iii&@xmath564&@xmath153&@xmath565&@xmath566 + & & & @xmath565&@xmath567&@xmath568 + & & & @xmath567&@xmath177&@xmath569 + ic 1711&type ii&@xmath570&@xmath221&@xmath571&@xmath572 + & & & @xmath571&@xmath199&@xmath573 + ic 1913&type ii&@xmath574&@xmath226&@xmath575&@xmath576 + & & & @xmath575&@xmath206&@xmath577 + ic 2058&type ii&@xmath578&@xmath174&@xmath579&@xmath580 + & & & @xmath579&@xmath233&@xmath581 + + ic 2135&type ii&@xmath582&@xmath147&@xmath583&@xmath584 + & & & @xmath583&@xmath238&@xmath585 + ic 5176&type iii&@xmath586&@xmath241&@xmath587&@xmath588 + & & & @xmath587&@xmath166&@xmath589 + ngc 0489&type i&@xmath590&@xmath241&@xmath246&@xmath591 + ngc 0522&type ii+iii&@xmath592&@xmath186&@xmath593&@xmath594 + & & & @xmath593&@xmath595&@xmath443 + & & & @xmath595&@xmath596&@xmath597 + ngc 0678&type ii&@xmath598&@xmath194&@xmath599&@xmath600 + & & & @xmath599&@xmath601&@xmath602 + ngc 1032&type ii&@xmath603&@xmath177&@xmath604&@xmath605 + & & & @xmath604&@xmath484&@xmath606 + ngc 1163&type ii+iii&@xmath607&@xmath265&@xmath608&@xmath609 + & & & @xmath608&@xmath610&@xmath611 + & & & @xmath610&@xmath596&@xmath612 + ngc 1422&type iii&@xmath613&@xmath133&@xmath614&@xmath615 + & & & @xmath614&@xmath375&@xmath616 + ngc 1495&type ii&@xmath617&@xmath275&@xmath618&@xmath619 + & & & @xmath618&@xmath278&@xmath620 + ngc 1596&type iii&@xmath621&@xmath275&@xmath622&@xmath623 + & & & @xmath622&@xmath283&@xmath624 + ngc 2732&type ii&@xmath625&@xmath286&@xmath626&@xmath627 + & & & @xmath626&@xmath628&@xmath629 + ngc 3098&type i&@xmath630&@xmath275&@xmath199&@xmath416 + ngc 3279&type ii&@xmath631&@xmath296&@xmath632&@xmath633 + & & & @xmath632&@xmath299&@xmath634 + ngc 3454&type ii+iii&@xmath635&@xmath241&@xmath636&@xmath637 + & & & @xmath636&@xmath638&@xmath639 + & & & @xmath638&@xmath212&@xmath640 + ngc 3501&type ii&@xmath641&@xmath275&@xmath642&@xmath643 + & & & @xmath642&@xmath340&@xmath644 + ngc 3592&type ii&@xmath645&@xmath141&@xmath646&@xmath647 + & & & @xmath646&@xmath289&@xmath648 + ngc 3600&type i&@xmath649&@xmath161&@xmath233&@xmath650 + + + ngc 3628&type ii+iii+ii&@xmath651&@xmath158&@xmath652&@xmath653 + & & & @xmath652&@xmath654&@xmath655 + & & & @xmath654&@xmath656&@xmath657 + & & & @xmath656&@xmath327&@xmath658 + ngc 4081&type ii+iii&@xmath659&@xmath296&@xmath660&@xmath661 + & & & @xmath660&@xmath662&@xmath663 + & & & @xmath662&@xmath334&@xmath664 + ngc 4111&type ii&@xmath665&@xmath337&@xmath666&@xmath667 + & & & @xmath666&@xmath668&@xmath669 + ngc 4330&type ii+iii+ii&@xmath670&@xmath343&@xmath671&@xmath672 + & & & @xmath671&@xmath673&@xmath674 + & & & @xmath673&@xmath675&@xmath393 + & & & @xmath675&@xmath166&@xmath676 + ngc 4359&type iii&@xmath677&@xmath296&@xmath678&@xmath679 + & & & @xmath678&@xmath257&@xmath680 + ngc 4437&type ii&@xmath681&@xmath356&@xmath682&@xmath683 + & & & @xmath682&@xmath684&@xmath685 + ngc 4565&type ii+ii&@xmath686&@xmath212&@xmath687&@xmath688 + & & & @xmath687&@xmath689&@xmath690 + & & & @xmath689&@xmath691&@xmath692 + ngc 4607&type ii+iii&@xmath693&@xmath226&@xmath694&@xmath695 + & & & @xmath694&@xmath696&@xmath697 + & & & @xmath696&@xmath310&@xmath353 + ngc 4747&type i&@xmath698&@xmath153&@xmath375&@xmath699 + ngc 5084&type iii&@xmath700&@xmath378&@xmath701&@xmath702 + & & & @xmath701&@xmath703&@xmath704 + ngc 5470&type ii&@xmath705&@xmath343&@xmath706&@xmath707 + & & & @xmath706&@xmath212&@xmath708 + ngc 5529&type ii+iii+ii&@xmath709&@xmath147&@xmath710&@xmath711 + & & & @xmath710&@xmath712&@xmath713 + & & & @xmath712&@xmath714&@xmath715 + & & & @xmath714&@xmath394&@xmath716 + ngc 5981&type ii&@xmath717&@xmath397&@xmath718&@xmath719 + & & & @xmath718&@xmath400&@xmath720 + ngc 6010&type ii&@xmath721&@xmath397&@xmath722&@xmath723 + & & & @xmath722&@xmath150&@xmath724 + ngc 7347&type ii&@xmath725&@xmath147&@xmath726&@xmath727 + & & & @xmath726&@xmath158&@xmath241 + pgc 013646&type ii&@xmath728&@xmath147&@xmath729&@xmath730 + & & & @xmath729&@xmath238&@xmath731 + pgc 028308&type ii&@xmath732&@xmath241&@xmath733&@xmath734 + & & & @xmath733&@xmath334&@xmath735 + pgc 030591&type i&@xmath736&@xmath737&@xmath738&@xmath532 + pgc 032548&type i&@xmath739&@xmath265&@xmath158&@xmath740 + pgc 052809&type ii&@xmath741&@xmath141&@xmath742&@xmath743 + & & & @xmath742&@xmath375&@xmath744 + ugc 00903&type ii+iii&@xmath745&@xmath241&@xmath746&@xmath747 + & & & @xmath746&@xmath748&@xmath749 + & & & @xmath748&@xmath334&@xmath750 + ugc 01970&type iii+ii&@xmath751&@xmath265&@xmath752&@xmath753 + & & & @xmath752&@xmath754&@xmath755 + & & & @xmath754&@xmath289&@xmath756 + ugc 05347&type ii&@xmath757&@xmath440&@xmath758&@xmath759 + & & & @xmath758&@xmath194&@xmath760 + ugc 05689&type ii&@xmath761&@xmath133&@xmath762&@xmath763 + & & & @xmath762&@xmath447&@xmath764 + ugc 05958&type i&@xmath765&@xmath153&@xmath158&@xmath766 + ugc 06526&type iii&@xmath767&@xmath440&@xmath768&@xmath769 + & & & @xmath768&@xmath150&@xmath770 + ugc 07086&type ii+iii&@xmath771&@xmath296&@xmath772&@xmath773 + & & & @xmath772&@xmath774&@xmath775 + & & & @xmath774&@xmath150&@xmath776 + ugc 08737&type ii+iii&@xmath777&@xmath343&@xmath778&@xmath779 + & & & @xmath778&@xmath780&@xmath781 + & & & @xmath780&@xmath233&@xmath782 + ugc 09448&type i&@xmath783&@xmath467&@xmath177&@xmath784 + ugc 09665&type ii&@xmath785&@xmath241&@xmath786&@xmath787 + & & & @xmath786&@xmath334&@xmath788 + ugc 10043&type ii&@xmath789&@xmath474&@xmath790&@xmath791 + & & & @xmath790&@xmath477&@xmath792 + + + ugc 10288&type ii+iii&@xmath793&@xmath147&@xmath794&@xmath795 + & & & @xmath794&@xmath796&@xmath797 + & & & @xmath796&@xmath144&@xmath798 + ugc 10297&type ii+iii&@xmath799&@xmath296&@xmath800&@xmath801 + & & & @xmath800&@xmath802&@xmath803 + & & & @xmath802&@xmath334&@xmath804 + ugc 12518&type ii+iii&@xmath805&@xmath153&@xmath806&@xmath807 + & & & @xmath806&@xmath808&@xmath809 + & & & @xmath808&@xmath138&@xmath810 + ugc 12692&type iii&@xmath811&@xmath153&@xmath812&@xmath813 + & & & @xmath812&@xmath419&@xmath814 + ugc 12857&type i&@xmath815&@xmath209&@xmath206&@xmath816 + note . @xmath128 and @xmath129 stand for the inner and the outer limit of each fitted section and @xmath130 corresponds to the scale length of that section . the lower limit of the innermost section and the upper limit of the outermost section have no error bar because they have been set manually . lccccc + i d & type & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + & & ( mag / as@xmath131 ) & ( ) & ( ) & ( ) + + i d & type & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + & & ( mag / as@xmath131 ) & ( ) & ( ) & ( ) + eso 157 - 049&type ii&@xmath817&@xmath174&@xmath818&@xmath819 + & & & @xmath818&@xmath138&@xmath820 + eso 240 - 011&type i&@xmath821&@xmath296&@xmath822&@xmath823 + eso 292 - 014&type ii&@xmath824&@xmath440&@xmath825&@xmath826 + & & & @xmath825&@xmath628&@xmath827 + eso 346 - 001&type ii&@xmath828&@xmath265&@xmath829&@xmath830 + & & & @xmath829&@xmath246&@xmath831 + eso 440 - 027&type i&@xmath832&@xmath209&@xmath166&@xmath833 + eso 443 - 021&type i&@xmath834&@xmath141&@xmath334&@xmath835 + eso 466 - 014&type i&@xmath836&@xmath153&@xmath726&@xmath837 + eso 469 - 015&type i&@xmath838&@xmath241&@xmath419&@xmath839 + eso 533 - 004&type ii&@xmath840&@xmath153&@xmath841&@xmath842 + & & & @xmath841&@xmath628&@xmath843 + + eso 544 - 027&type ii&@xmath844&@xmath191&@xmath845&@xmath846 + & & & @xmath845&@xmath847&@xmath848 + ic 0217&type ii&@xmath849&@xmath241&@xmath850&@xmath851 + & & & @xmath850&@xmath199&@xmath852 + ic 0610&type i&@xmath853&@xmath241&@xmath206&@xmath854 + ic 1197&type ii&@xmath855&@xmath226&@xmath856&@xmath857 + & & & @xmath856&@xmath299&@xmath858 + ic 1553&type i&@xmath859&@xmath737&@xmath194&@xmath860 + ic 1711&type i&@xmath861&@xmath862&@xmath150&@xmath863 + ic 1913&type i&@xmath864&@xmath296&@xmath206&@xmath865 + ic 2058&type ii&@xmath866&@xmath209&@xmath867&@xmath868 + & & & @xmath867&@xmath278&@xmath869 + ic 2135&type ii&@xmath870&@xmath871&@xmath872&@xmath873 + & & & @xmath872&@xmath238&@xmath874 + ic 5176&type iii&@xmath875&@xmath161&@xmath876&@xmath877 + & & & @xmath876&@xmath601&@xmath878 + ngc 0489&type i&@xmath879&@xmath296&@xmath194&@xmath880 + ngc 0522&type ii&@xmath881&@xmath186&@xmath882&@xmath883 + & & & @xmath882&@xmath212&@xmath884 + ngc 0678&type ii&@xmath885&@xmath356&@xmath886&@xmath887 + & & & @xmath886&@xmath340&@xmath888 + ngc 1032&type i&@xmath889&@xmath296&@xmath166&@xmath890 + ngc 1163&type i&@xmath891&@xmath209&@xmath150&@xmath892 + ngc 1422&type i&@xmath893&@xmath133&@xmath894&@xmath895 + ngc 1495&type i&@xmath896&@xmath209&@xmath212&@xmath897 + ngc 1596&type i&@xmath898&@xmath296&@xmath283&@xmath899 + ngc 2732&type ii&@xmath900&@xmath296&@xmath901&@xmath902 + & & & @xmath901&@xmath289&@xmath903 + ngc 3098&type i&@xmath904&@xmath241&@xmath150&@xmath905 + ngc 3279&type ii&@xmath906&@xmath241&@xmath907&@xmath908 + & & & @xmath907&@xmath628&@xmath909 + ngc 3454&type ii&@xmath910&@xmath296&@xmath911&@xmath393 + & & & @xmath911&@xmath199&@xmath912 + ngc 3501&type i&@xmath913&@xmath474&@xmath375&@xmath914 + + + ngc 3592&type ii&@xmath915&@xmath141&@xmath916&@xmath917 + & & & @xmath916&@xmath138&@xmath918 + ngc 3600&type iii&@xmath919&@xmath241&@xmath920&@xmath921 + & & & @xmath920&@xmath233&@xmath922 + ngc 3628&type ii&@xmath923&@xmath206&@xmath924&@xmath925 + & & & @xmath924&@xmath327&@xmath926 + ngc 4081&type i&@xmath927&@xmath209&@xmath334&@xmath928 + ngc 4111&type i&@xmath929&@xmath147&@xmath340&@xmath930 + ngc 4330&type ii&@xmath931&@xmath296&@xmath932&@xmath933 + & & & @xmath932&@xmath668&@xmath934 + ngc 4359&type i&@xmath935&@xmath147&@xmath310&@xmath936 + ngc 4437&type ii&@xmath937&@xmath356&@xmath938&@xmath939 + & & & @xmath938&@xmath940&@xmath941 + ngc 4565&type i&@xmath942&@xmath289&@xmath943&@xmath944 + ngc 4607&type i&@xmath945&@xmath174&@xmath310&@xmath946 + ngc 4747&type i&@xmath947&@xmath153&@xmath375&@xmath948 + ngc 5084&type iii&@xmath949&@xmath378&@xmath950&@xmath951 + & & & @xmath950&@xmath381&@xmath952 + ngc 5470&type ii&@xmath953&@xmath133&@xmath954&@xmath955 + & & & @xmath954&@xmath150&@xmath956 + ngc 5529&type iii+ii&@xmath957&@xmath275&@xmath958&@xmath959 + & & & @xmath958&@xmath960&@xmath393 + & & & @xmath960&@xmath394&@xmath961 + ngc 5981&type i&@xmath962&@xmath440&@xmath400&@xmath963 + ngc 6010&type i&@xmath964&@xmath296&@xmath199&@xmath965 + ngc 7347&type i&@xmath966&@xmath440&@xmath419&@xmath967 + pgc 013646&type i&@xmath968&@xmath153&@xmath278&@xmath969 + pgc 028308&type i&@xmath970&@xmath147&@xmath246&@xmath971 + pgc 030591&type i&@xmath972&@xmath209&@xmath847&@xmath973 + pgc 032548&type i&@xmath974&@xmath296&@xmath447&@xmath975 + pgc 052809&type ii&@xmath976&@xmath191&@xmath977&@xmath978 + & & & @xmath977&@xmath238&@xmath979 + ugc 00903&type i&@xmath980&@xmath174&@xmath158&@xmath981 + ugc 01970&type i&@xmath982&@xmath147&@xmath315&@xmath983 + ugc 05347&type i&@xmath984&@xmath209&@xmath985&@xmath986 + + ugc 05689&type ii&@xmath987&@xmath191&@xmath988&@xmath989 + & & & @xmath988&@xmath447&@xmath990 + ugc 05958&type i&@xmath991&@xmath153&@xmath334&@xmath992 + ugc 06526&type i&@xmath993&@xmath296&@xmath150&@xmath994 + ugc 07086&type i&@xmath995&@xmath241&@xmath150&@xmath996 + ugc 08737&type i&@xmath997&@xmath343&@xmath238&@xmath998 + ugc 09448&type i&@xmath999&@xmath467&@xmath378&@xmath1000 + ugc 09665&type i&@xmath1001&@xmath133&@xmath158&@xmath1002 + ugc 10043&type i&@xmath1003&@xmath862&@xmath289&@xmath1004 + ugc 10288&type i&@xmath1005&@xmath474&@xmath1006&@xmath1007 + ugc 10297&type i&@xmath1008&@xmath440&@xmath356&@xmath1009 + ugc 12518&type i&@xmath1010&@xmath191&@xmath138&@xmath1011 + ugc 12692&type i&@xmath1012&@xmath265&@xmath194&@xmath1013 + ugc 12857&type i&@xmath1014&@xmath209&@xmath194&@xmath1015 + note . @xmath128 and @xmath129 stand for the inner and the outer limit of each fitted section and @xmath130 corresponds to the scale length of that section . the lower limit of the innermost section and the upper limit of the outermost section have no error bar because they have been set manually . the following pages include the vertical and horizontal luminosity profile fits for all the galaxies in our final sample . they also include the image of each galaxy . the information is organized as follows : * the three images in the top row show the average of the 3.6 and 4.5@xmath13-band background - subtracted s@xmath4 g frames ( left ) , the same image after masking ( center ) , and the used mask ( right ) . the vertical red lines indicate the limits of the fitted vertical bins , the central one being ignored due to the possible presence of a bulge . * the next two rows show the fits to the luminosity profiles in these bins . the data points have @xmath1016 statistical error bars , the dashed curve represents the best fit , the dotted curves indicate the contributions of the thin and the thin discs . the dash - dotted vertical lines indicate the limits of the range in vertical distance above the mid - plane used for the fit . the vertical solid line indicates @xmath14 for each bin . the profiles in bins which have not been selected for the data processing in this paper ( section [ secdefrs ] ) are indicated with a `` not used '' label . * the bottom panel shows the horizontal luminosity profiles integrated from @xmath68 to @xmath1017 ( total ; yellow ) , from @xmath68 to @xmath1018 ( thin disc ; blue ) , and from @xmath1019 to @xmath1017 ( thick disc ; red ) . the black lines indicate fits to those profiles , with vertical intersecting lines indicating the fitting range and the truncation radii . the vertical solid gray lines represent @xmath1020 , @xmath1021 , and @xmath1022 . the vertical dashed line represents @xmath60 . the gray area represents the inferred average surface brightness of the thick disc in the range @xmath68 to @xmath1018 in the presence of a thin disc with a relative face - on surface brightness similar to which is found where the vertical luminosity profiles have been successfully fitted ( upper limit ) and in the absence of it ( lower limit ) extrapolated from the vertical luminosity profile fits . the bins for which valid vertical luminosity fits have been obtained can be seen in the bottom left of each panel . the errors in the fitted parameters are @xmath1016 fitting errors . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: general relativity and ordinary differential geometry should be replaced by non - commutative geometry at some point between the currently accessible energies of about 1 - 10 tev ( after starting the large hadron collider ( lhc ) at cern ) and the planck scale , which is @xmath2 times higher , where space - time and gravity should be quantized . this could occur either at the planck scale or below . quantum field theory on a non - commutative space - time ( ncqf ) could very well be an intermediate theory relevant for physics at energies between the lhc and the planck scale . it certainly looks intermediate in structure between ordinary quantum field theory on commutative @xmath3 and string theory , the current leading candidate for a more fundamental theory including quantized gravity . ncqft in fact appears as an effective model for certain limits of string theory @xcite . in joint work with r. gurau , j. magnen and f. vignes - tourneret @xcite , using direct space methods , we provided recently a new proof that the grosse - wulkenhaar scalar @xmath4 theory on the moyal space @xmath5 is renormalisable to all orders in perturbation theory . the grosse - wulkenhaar breakthrough @xcite was to realize that the right propagator in non - commutative field theory is not the ordinary commutative propagator , but has to be modified to obey langmann - szabo duality @xcite . grosse and wulkenhaar were able to compute the corresponding propagator in the so called `` matrix base '' which transforms the moyal product into a matrix product . this is a real _ tour de force _ ! they use this representation to prove perturbative renormalisability of the theory up to some estimates which were finally proven in @xcite . our direct space method builds upon the previous works of filk and chepelev - roiban @xcite . these works however remained inconclusive @xcite , since these authors used the right interaction but not the right propagator , hence the problem of ultraviolet / infrared mixing prevented them from obtaining a finite renormalised perturbation series . we also extend the grosse - wulkenhaar results to more general models with covariant derivatives in a fixed magnetic field @xcite . our proof relies on a multiscale analysis analogous to @xcite but in direct space . non - commutative field theories ( for a general review see @xcite ) deserve a thorough and systematic investigation , not only because they may be relevant for physics beyond the standard model , but also ( although this is often less emphasized ) because they can describe effective physics in our ordinary standard world but with non - local interactions . in this case there is an interesting reversal of the initial grosse - wulkenhaar problematic . in the @xmath4 theory on the moyal space @xmath5 , the vertex is sort of god - given by the moyal structure , and it is ls invariant . the challenge was to overcome uv / ir mixing and to find the right propagator which makes the theory renormalisable . this propagator turned out to have ls duality . the harmonic potential introduced by grosse and wulkenhaar can be interpreted as a piece of covariant derivatives in a constant magnetic field . now to explain the ( fractional ) quantum hall effect , which is a bulk effect whose understanding requires electron interactions , we can almost invert this logic . the propagator is known since it corresponds to non - relativistic electrons in two dimensions in a constant magnetic field . it has ls duality . but the interaction is unclear , and can not be local since at strong magnetic field the spins should align with the magnetic field , hence by pauli principle local interactions among electrons in the first landau level should vanish . we can argue that among all possible non - local interactions , a few renormalisation group steps should select the only ones which form a renormalisable theory with the corresponding propagator . in the commutative case ( i.e. zero magnetic field ) local interactions such as those of the hubbard model are just renormalisable in any dimension because of the extended nature of the fermi - surface singularity . since the non - commutative electron propagator ( i.e. in non zero magnetic field ) looks very similar to the grosse - wulkenhaar propagator ( it is in fact a generalization of the langmann - szabo - zarembo propagator ) we can conjecture that the renormalisable interaction corresponding to this propagator should be given by a moyal product . that s why we hope that non - commutative field theory is the correct framework for a microscopic _ ab initio _ understanding of the fractional quantum hall effect which is currently lacking . even for regular commutative field theory such as non - abelian gauge theory , the strong coupling or non - perturbative regimes may be studied fruitfully through their non - commutative ( i.e. non local ) counterparts . this point of view is forcefully suggested in @xcite , where a mapping is proposed between ordinary and non - commutative gauge fields which do not preserve the gauge groups but preserve the gauge equivalent classes . we can at least remark that the effective physics of confinement should be governed by a non - local interaction , as is the case in effective strings or bags models . in other words we propose to base physics upon the renormalisability principle , more than any other axiom . renormalisability means genericity ; only renormalisable interactions survive a few rg steps , hence only them should be used to describe generic effective physics of any kind . the search for renormalisabilty could be the powerful principle on which to orient ourselves in the jungle of all possible non - local interactions . renormalisability has also attracted considerable interest in the recent years as a pure mathematical structure . the work of kreimer and connes @xcite recasts the recursive bphz forest formula of perturbative renormalisation in a nice hopf algebra structure . the renormalisation group ambiguity reminds mathematicians of the galois group ambiguity for roots of algebraic equations . finding new renormalisable theories may therefore be important for the future of pure mathematics as well as for physics . that was forcefully argued during the luminy workshop `` renormalisation and galois theory '' . main open conjectures in pure mathematics such as the riemann hypothesis @xcite or the jacobian conjecture @xcite may benefit from the quantum field theory and renormalisation group approach . considering that most of the connes - kreimer works uses dimensional regularization and the minimal dimensional renormalisation scheme , it is interesting to develop the parametric representation which generalize schwinger s parametric representation of feynman amplitudes to the non commutative context . it involves hyperbolic generalizations of the ordinary topological polynomials , which mathematicians call kirchoff polynomials , and physicist call symanzik polynomials in the quantum field theory context @xcite . we plan also to work out the corresponding regularization and minimal dimensional renormalisation scheme and to recast it in a hopf algebra structure . the corresponding structures seem richer than in ordinary field theory since they involve ribbon graphs and invariants which contain information about the genus of the surface on which these graphs live . a critical goal to enlarge the class of renormalisable non - commutative field theories and to attack the quantum hall effect problem is to extend the results of grosse - wulkenhaar to fermionic theories . the simplest theory , the two - dimensional gross - neveu model can be shown renormalisable to all orders in their langmann - szabo covariant versions , using either the matrix basis @xcite or the direct space version developed here @xcite . however the @xmath6-space version seems the most promising for a complete non - perturbative construction , using pauli s principle to controll the apparent ( fake ) divergences of perturbation theory . in the case of @xmath7 , recall that although the commutative version is until now fatally flawed due to the famous landau ghost , there is hope that the non - commutative field theory treated at the perturbative level in this paper may also exist at the constructive level . indeed a non trivial fixed point of the renormalization group develops at high energy , where the grosse - wulkenhaar parameter @xmath8 tends to 1 , so that langmann - szabo duality become exact , and the beta function vanishes . this scenario has been checked explicitly to all orders of perturbation theory @xcite . this was done using the matrix version of the theory ; again an @xmath6-space version of renormalisation might be better for a future rigorous non - perturbative investigation of this fixed point and a full constructive version of the model . finally let us conclude this short introduction by reminding that a very important and difficult goal is to also extend the grosse - wulkenhaar breakthrough to gauge theories . one considers free electrons : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the canonical conjugate of @xmath11 . the moment and position @xmath12 and @xmath13 have commutators @xmath14=0,\ \ [ r_i , r_j]=0,\ \ [ p_i , r_j]=\imath\hbar\delta_{ij } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the moments @xmath15 have commutators @xmath16=-\imath\hbar\epsilon_{ij}eb,\ \ [ r_i , r_j]=0,\ \ [ \pi_i , r_j]=\imath\hbar\delta_{ij } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can also introduce coordinates @xmath17 , @xmath18 corresponding to the centers of the classical trajectories @xmath19 which _ do not commute _ : @xmath20=\imath\hbar\epsilon_{ij}\frac{1}{e b}},\ \ [ \pi_i , r_j]=0 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] this means that there exist heisenberg - like relations between quantum positions . one considers the string action in a generalized background @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the string worldsheet , @xmath23 is a tangential derivative along the worldsheet boundary @xmath24 and @xmath25 is an antisymmetric background tensor . the equations of motion determine the boundary conditions : @xmath26 boundary conditions for coordinates can be neumann ( @xmath27 ) or dirichlet ( @xmath28 , corresponding to branes ) . after conformal mapping of the string worldsheet onto the upper half - plane , the string propagator in background field is @xmath29 \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] for some constant symmetric and antisymmetric tensors @xmath30 and @xmath31 . evaluated at boundary points on the worldsheet , this propagator is @xmath32 where the @xmath31 term simply comes from the discontinuity of the logarithm across its cut . interpreting @xmath33 as time , one finds @xmath34= i \theta^{\mu \nu } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which means that string coordinates lie in a non - commutative moyal space with parameter @xmath31 . there is an equivalent argument inspired by @xmath35 theory : a rotation sandwiched between two @xmath36 dualities generates the same constant commutator for string coordinates . the recent progresses concerning the renormalisation of non - commutative field theory have been obtained on a very simple non - commutative space namely the moyal space . from the point of view of quantum field theory , it is certainly the most studied space . let us start with its precise definition . let us define @xmath37 and @xmath38 the free algebra generated by @xmath39 . let @xmath40 a @xmath41 non - degenerate skew - symmetric matrix ( wich requires @xmath42 even ) and @xmath43 the ideal of @xmath38 generated by the elements @xmath44 . the moyal algebra @xmath45 is the quotient @xmath46 . each element in @xmath45 is a formal power series in the @xmath47 s for which the relation @xmath48 holds . usually , one puts the matrix @xmath40 into its canonical form : @xmath49 sometimes one even set @xmath50 . the preceeding algebraic definition whereas short and precise may be too abstract to perform real computations . one then needs a more analytical definition . a representation of the algebra @xmath45 is given by some set of functions on @xmath51 equipped with a non - commutative product : the _ groenwald - moyal _ product . what follows is based on @xcite . [ [ sec : lalgebre - ca_theta ] ] the algebra @xmath45 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the moyal algebra @xmath45 is the linear space of smooth and rapidly decreasing functions @xmath52 equipped with the non - commutative product defined by : @xmath53 , @xmath54 this algebra may be considered as the `` functions on the moyal space @xmath55 '' . in the following we will write @xmath56 instead of @xmath57 and use : @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 for the fourier transform and @xmath61 for the twisted convolution . as on @xmath62 , the fourier transform exchange product and convolution : @xmath63 one also shows that the moyal product and the twisted convolution are * associative * : @xmath64 using , we show the associativity of the @xmath65-produit . the complex conjugation is * involutive * in @xmath45 @xmath66 one also have @xmath67 [ prop : trace ] for all @xmath68 , @xmath69 @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the ordinary convolution . in the following sections , we will need lemma [ lem : moyal - prods ] to compute the interaction terms for the @xmath72 and gross - neveu models . we write @xmath73 . [ lem : moyal - prods ] for all @xmath74 , let @xmath75 . then @xmath76 [ cor : int - moyal ] for all @xmath74 , let @xmath75 . then @xmath77 the cyclicity of the product , inherited from proposition [ prop : trace ] implies : @xmath78 , @xmath79 and allows to extend the moyal algebra by duality into an algebra of tempered distributions . [ [ sec : extens - par - dual ] ] extension by duality + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let us first consider the product of a tempered distribution with a schwartz - class function . let @xmath80 and @xmath81 . we define @xmath82 and @xmath83 . [ defn : tf ] let @xmath84 , @xmath85 , we define @xmath86 and @xmath87 by @xmath88 for example , the identity @xmath89 as an element of @xmath90 is the unity for the @xmath65-produit : @xmath91 , @xmath92 we are now ready to define the linear space @xmath93 as the intersection of two sub - spaces @xmath94 and @xmath95 of @xmath90 . [ defn : m ] @xmath96 one can show that @xmath93 is an associative @xmath71-algebra . it contains , among others , the identity , the polynomials , the @xmath97 distribution and its derivatives . then the relation @xmath98 often given as a definition of the moyal space , holds in @xmath93 ( but not in @xmath45 ) . the simplest non - commutative model one may consider is the @xmath99-theory on the four - dimensional moyal space . its lagrangian is the usual ( commutative ) one where the pointwise product is replaced by the moyal one : @xmath100 = & \int d^4x \big ( -\frac{1}{2 } \partial_\mu \phi \star \partial^\mu \phi + \frac{1}{2 } m^2 \,\phi \star \phi + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \phi \star \phi \star \phi \star \phi\big)(x).\label{eq : phi4naif}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thanks to the formula , this action can be explicitly computed . the interaction part is given by the corollary [ cor : int - moyal ] : @xmath101 the main characteristic of the moyal product is its non - locality . but its non - commutativity implies that the vertex of the model is only invariant under cyclic permutation of the fields . this restricted invariance incites to represent the associated feynman graphs with ribbon graphs . one can then make a clear distinction between planar and non - planar graphs . this will be detailed in section [ sec : multi - scale - analysismatrix ] . thanks to the delta function in , the oscillation may be written in different ways : @xmath102 the interaction is real and positive . ] : @xmath103 it is also translation invariant as shows equation . the property [ prop : trace ] implies that the propagator is the usual one : @xmath104 . the non - locality of the @xmath65-product allows to understand the discovery of minwalla , van raamsdonk and seiberg @xcite . they showed that not only the model is nt finite in the uv but also it exhibits a new type of divergences making it non - renormalisable . in the article @xcite , filk computed the feynman rules corresponding to . he showed that the planar amplitudes equal the commutative ones whereas the non - planar ones give rise to oscillations coupling the internal and external legs . a typical example is the the non - planar tadpole : @xmath105 if @xmath106 , this amplitude is finite but , for small @xmath107 , it diverges like @xmath108 . in other words , if we put an ultraviolet cut - off @xmath109 to the @xmath110-integral , the two limits @xmath111 and @xmath112 do not commute . this is the uv / ir mixing phenomena . a chain of non - planar tadpoles , inserted in bigger graphs , makes divergent any function ( with six points or more for example ) . but this divergence is not local and ca nt be absorbed in a mass redefinition . this is what makes the model non - renormalisable . we will see in sections [ sec : prop - et - renorm ] and [ sec : direct - space ] that the uv / ir mixing results in a coupling of the different scales of the theory . we will also note that we should distinguish different types of mixing . the uv / ir mixing was studied by several groups . first , chepelev and roiban @xcite gave a power counting for different scalr models . they were able to identify the divergent graphs and to classify the divergences of the theories thanks to the topological data of the graphs . then v. gayral @xcite showed that uv / ir mixing is present on all isospectral deformations ( they consist in curved generalisations of the moyal space and of the non - commutative torus ) . for this , he considered a scalar model and discovered contributions to the effective action which diverge when the external momenta vanish . the uv / ir mixing is then a general characteristic of the non - commutative theories , at least on the deformations . the situation remained so until h. grosse and r. wulkenhaar discovered a way to define a renormalisable non - commutative model . we will detail their result in section [ sec : multi - scale - analysismatrix ] but the main message is the following . by adding an harmonic term to the lagrangian , @xmath113 = & \int d^4x \big ( -\frac{1}{2 } \partial_\mu \phi \star \partial^\mu \phi + \frac{\omega^2}{2 } ( \tilde{x}_\mu \phi ) \star ( \tilde{x}^\mu \phi ) + \frac{1}{2 } m^2 \,\phi \star \phi + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \phi \star \phi \star \phi \star \phi\big)(x)\label{eq : phi4omega}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath114 and the metric is euclidean , the model , in four dimensions , is renormalisable at all orders of perturbation @xcite . we will see in section [ sec : direct - space ] that this additional term give rise to an infrared cut - off and allows to decouple the different scales of the theory . the new model ( [ eq : phi4omega ] ) , we call it @xmath72 , do not exhibit any mixing . this result is very important because it opens the way towards other non - commutative field theories . in the following , we will call _ _ vulcanisation__. ] the procedure consisting in adding a new term to a lagrangian of a non - commutative theory in order to make it renormalisable . + the propagator @xmath115 of this @xmath116 theory is the kernel of the inverse operator @xmath117 . it is known as the mehler kernel @xcite @xmath118 langmann and szabo remarked that the quartic interaction with moyal product is invariant under a duality transformation . it is a symmetry between momentum and direct space . the interaction part of the model is ( see equation ) @xmath119=&\int d^{4}x\,\frac{\lambda}{4}(\phi\star\phi\star\phi\star\phi)(x)\\ = & \int\prod_{a=1}^{4}d^{4}x_{a}\,\phi(x_{a})\,v(x_{1},x_{2},x_{3},x_{4})\label{eq : vx}\\ = & \int\prod_{a=1}^{4}\frac{d^{4}p_{a}}{(2\pi)^{4}}\,\hat{\phi}(p_{a})\,\hat{v}(p_{1},p_{2},p_{3},p_{4})\label { eq : vp } \intertext{with } v(x_{1},x_{2},x_{3},x_{4})=&\frac{\lambda}{4}\frac{1}{\pi^{4}\det\theta}\delta(x_{1}-x_{2}+x_{3}-x_{4 } ) \cos(2(\theta^{-1})_{\mu\nu}(x_{1}^{\mu}x_{2}^{\nu}+x_{3}^{\mu}x_{4}^{\nu}))\notag\\ \hat{v}(p_{1},p_{2},p_{3},p_{4})=&\frac{\lambda}{4}(2\pi)^{4}\delta(p_{1}-p_{2}+p_{3}-p_{4})\cos(\frac 12 \theta^{\mu\nu}(p_{1,\mu}p_{2,\nu}+p_{3,\mu}p_{4,\nu}))\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used a _ cyclic _ fourier transform : @xmath120 . the transformation @xmath121 exchanges and . in addition , the free part of the model is nt covariant under this duality . the vulcanisation adds a term to the lagrangian which restores the symmetry . the theory is then covariant under the langmann - szabo duality : @xmath122\mapsto&\omega^{2}\,s[\phi;\frac{m}{\omega},\frac{\lambda}{\omega^{2 } } , \frac{1}{\omega } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] by symmetry , the parameter @xmath8 is confined in @xmath123 . let us note that for @xmath124 , the model is invariant . [ [ parag : interpharm ] ] the interpretation of that harmonic term is not yet clear . but the vulcanisation procedure already allowed to prove the renormalisability of several other models on moyal spaces such that @xmath125 @xcite , @xmath126 @xcite and the lsz models @xcite . these last are of the type @xmath113 = & \int d^nx \big ( \frac{1}{2 } \bar{\phi}\star(-\partial_\mu+\xt_{\mu}+m)^{2}\phi + \frac{\lambda}{4 } \bar{\phi } \star \phi \star \bar{\phi } \star\phi\big)(x).\label{eq : lszintro}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by comparison with , one notes that here the additional term is formally equivalent to a fixed magnetic background . deep is the temptation to interpret it as such . this model is invariant under the above duality and is exactly soluble . let us remark that the complex interaction in makes the langmann - szabo duality more natural . it does nt need a cyclic fourier transform . the @xmath127 have been studied at @xmath124 where they also exhibit a soluble structure . apart from the @xmath72 , the modified bosonic lsz model @xcite and supersymmetric theories , we now know several renormalizable non - commutative field theories . nevertheless they either are super - renormalizable ( @xmath128 @xcite ) or ( and ) studied at a special point in the parameter space where they are solvable ( @xmath129 @xcite , the lsz models @xcite ) . although only logarithmically divergent for parity reasons , the non - commutative gross - neveu model is a just renormalizable quantum field theory as @xmath72 . one of its main interesting features is that it can be interpreted as a non - local fermionic field theory in a constant magnetic background . then apart from strengthening the `` vulcanization '' procedure to get renormalizable non - commutative field theories , the gross - neveu model may also be useful for the study of the quantum hall effect . it is also a good first candidate for a constructive study @xcite of a non - commutative field theory as fermionic models are usually easier to construct . moreover its commutative counterpart being asymptotically free and exhibiting dynamical mass generation @xcite , a study of the physics of this model would be interesting . + the non - commutative gross - neveu model ( @xmath130 ) is a fermionic quartically interacting quantum field theory on the moyal plane @xmath131 . the skew - symmetric matrix @xmath40 is @xmath132 the action is @xmath133=&\int dx\lbt\psib\lbt-\imath\slashed{\partial}+\omega\xts+m+\mu\,\gamma_{5}\rbt\psi+v_{\text{o}}(\psib,\psi ) + v_{\text{no}}(\psib,\psi)\rbt(x)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath134 , @xmath135 and @xmath136 is the interaction part given hereafter . the @xmath137-term appears at two - loop order . we use a euclidean metric and the feynman convention @xmath138 . the @xmath139 and @xmath140 matrices form a two - dimensional representation of the clifford algebra @xmath141 . let us remark that the @xmath142 s are then skew- hermitian : @xmath143 . [ [ propagator ] ] propagator + + + + + + + + + + the propagator corresponding to the action is given by the following lemma : [ xpropa1gn ] the propagator of the gross - neveu model is @xmath144 with @xmath145 et @xmath146 . + we also have @xmath147 . if we want to study a @xmath148-_color _ model , we can consider a propagator diagonal in these color indices . [ [ interactions ] ] interactions + + + + + + + + + + + + concerning the interaction part @xmath149 , recall that ( see corollary [ cor : int - moyal ] ) for any @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 , @xmath153 in @xmath45 , @xmath154 this product is non - local and only invraiant under cyclic permutations of the fields . then , contrary to the commutative gross - neveu model , for which there exits only one spinorial interaction , the @xmath130 model has , at least , six different interacitons : the _ orientable _ ones [ eq : int - orient ] @xmath155 where @xmath156 s and @xmath157 s alternate and the _ non - orientable _ ones [ eq : int - nonorient ] @xmath158 all these interactions have the same @xmath6 kernel thanks to the equation . the reason for which we call these interactions orientable or not will be clear in section [ sec : direct - space ] . the matrix basis is a basis for schwartz - class functions . in this basis , the moyal product becomes a simple matrix product . each field is then represented by an infinite matrix @xcite . in the matrix basis , the action takes the form : @xmath100=&(2\pi)^{d/2}\sqrt{\det\theta}\big(\frac 12\phi\delta\phi+\frac{\lambda}{4}\operatorname*{tr}\phi^{4}\big)\label { eq : sphi4matrix}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath159 and @xmath160 the ( four - dimensional ) matrix @xmath161 represents the quadratic part of the lagragian . the first difficulty to study the matrix model is the computation of its propagator @xmath30 defined as the inverse of @xmath161 : @xmath162 fortunately , the action is invariant under @xmath163 thanks to the form of the @xmath40 matrix . it implies a conservation law @xmath164 the result is @xcite @xmath165 where @xmath166 and @xmath115 is a function in @xmath8 : @xmath167 . the main advantage of the matrix basis is that it simplifies the interaction part : @xmath168 becomes @xmath169 . but the propagator becomes very compllicated . + let us remark that the matrix model is _ dynamical _ : its quadratic part is not trivial . usually , matrix models are _ local_. a matrix model is called * local * if @xmath170 and * non - local * otherwise . in the matrix theories , the feynman graphs are ribbon graphs . the propagator @xmath171 is then represented by the figure [ fig : propamatrix ] . in a local matrix model , the propagator preserves the index values along the trajectories ( simple lines ) . the power counting of a matrix model depends on the topological data of its graphs . the figure [ fig : ribbon - examples ] gives two examples of ribbon graphs . each ribbon graph may be drawn on a two - dimensional manifold . actually each graph defines the surface on which it is drawn . let a graph @xmath30 with @xmath149 vertices , @xmath43 internal propagators ( double lines ) and @xmath172 faces ( made of simple lines ) . the euler characteristic @xmath173 gives the genus @xmath174 of the manifold . one can make this clear by passing to the * dual graph*. the dual of a given graph @xmath30 is obtained by exchanging faces and vertices . the dual graphs of the @xmath175 theory are tesselations of the surfaces on which they are drawn . moreover each direct face broken by exernal legs becomes , in the dual graph , a * puncture*. if among the @xmath172 faces of a graph , @xmath176 are broken , this graph may be drawn on a surface of genus @xmath177 with @xmath176 punctures . the figure [ fig : topo - ruban ] gives the topological data of the graphs of the figure [ fig : ribbon - examples ] . @xmath178 @xmath179v=3@xmath180i=3@xmath180f=2@xmath180b=2@xmath181 + @xmath182 @xmath183v=2@xmath184i=3@xmath184f=1@xmath184b=1@xmath185 in @xcite , v. r. , r. wulkenhaar and f. v .- t . used the multi - scale analysis to reprove the power counting of the non - commutative @xmath116 theory . let @xmath30 a ribbon graph of the @xmath186 theory with @xmath148 external legs , @xmath149 vertices , @xmath43 internal lines and @xmath172 faces . its genus is then @xmath187 . four indices @xmath188 are associated to each internal line of the graph and two indices to each external line , that is to say @xmath189 indices . but , at each vertex , the left index of a ribbon equals the right one of the neighbour ribbon . this gives rise to @xmath190 independant identifications which allows to write each index in terms of a set @xmath191 made of @xmath190 indices , four per vertex , for example the left index of each half - ribbon . + the graph amplitude is then @xmath192 where the four indices of the propagator @xmath30 of the line @xmath97 are function of @xmath193 and written + @xmath194 . we decompose each propagator , given by : @xmath195 we have an associated decomposition for each amplitude @xmath196 where @xmath197 runs over the all possible assignements of a positive integer @xmath198 to each line @xmath97 . we proved the following four propositions : [ thm - th1 ] for @xmath35 large enough , there exists a constant @xmath199 such that , for @xmath200 $ ] , we have the uniform bound @xmath201 [ thm - th2 ] for @xmath35 large enough , there exists two constants @xmath199 and @xmath202 such that , for @xmath203 $ ] , we have the uniform bound @xmath204 this bound allows to prove that the only diverging graphs have either a constant index along the trajectories or a total jump of @xmath205 . [ prop : bound3 ] for @xmath35 large enough , there exists a constant @xmath199 such that , for @xmath206 $ ] , we have the uniform bound @xmath207 this bound shows that the propagator is almost local in the following sense : with @xmath208 fixed , the sum over @xmath209 does nt cost anything ( see figure [ fig : propamatrix ] ) . nevertheless the sums we ll have to perform are entangled ( a given index may enter different propagators ) so that we need the following proposition . [ prop : bound4 ] for @xmath35 large enough , there exists a constant @xmath199 such that , for @xmath206 $ ] , we have the uniform bound @xmath210 we refer to @xcite for the proofs of these four propositions . about half of the @xmath190 indices initially associated to a graph is determined by the external indices and the delta functions in ( [ ig ] ) . the other indices are summation indices . the power counting consists in finding which sums cost @xmath211 and which cost @xmath212 thanks to ( [ thsum ] ) . the @xmath211 factor comes from ( [ th1 ] ) after a summation over an index . ] @xmath213 , @xmath214 we first use the delta functions as much as possible to reduce the set @xmath193 to a true minimal set @xmath215 of independant indices . for this , it is convenient to use the dual graphs where the resolution of the delta functions is equivalent to a usual momentum routing . the dual graph is made of the same propagators than the direct graph except the position of their indices . whereas in the original graph we have @xmath216 { oberfig-16.eps}}$ ] , the position of the indices in a dual propagator is @xmath217{oberfig-17.eps}}\;. \label{dual - assign}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the conservation @xmath218 in ( [ ig ] ) implies that the difference @xmath219 is conserved along the propagator . these differences behave like an _ angular momentum _ and the conservation of the differences @xmath220 and @xmath221 is nothing else than the conservation of the angular momentum thanks to the symmetry @xmath222 of the action : @xmath223{oberfig-8.eps}}&\qquad l = m+\ell\;,~~ n = k+(-\ell ) . \label{angmom}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the cyclicity of the vertices implies the vanishing of the sum of the angular momenta entering a vertex . thus the angular momentum in the dual graph behaves exactly like the usual momentum in ordinary feynman graphs . + we know that the number of independent momenta is exactly the number @xmath224 ( @xmath225 for a connected graph ) of loops in the dual graph . each index at a ( dual ) vertex is then given by a unique _ reference index _ and a sum of momenta . if the dual vertex under consideration is an external one , we choose an external index for the reference index . the reference indices in the dual graph correspond to the loop indices in the direct graph . the number of summation indices is then @xmath226 where @xmath227 is the number of broken faces of the direct graph or the number of external vertices in the dual graph . + by using a well - chosen order on the lines , an optimized tree and a @xmath228 bound , one can prove that the summation over the angular momenta does not cost anything thanks to ( [ thsum ] ) . recall that a connected component is a subgraph for which all internal lines have indices greater than all its external ones . the power counting is then : @xmath229 and @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 , @xmath233 and @xmath234 are respectively the numbers of external legs , of vertices , of ( internal ) propagators , of faces and broken faces of the connected component @xmath235 ; @xmath236 is its genus . we have [ pc - slice ] the sum over the scales attributions @xmath137 converges if @xmath237 . we recover the power counting obtained in @xcite . from this point on , renormalisability of @xmath7 can proceed ( however remark that it remains limited to @xmath200 $ ] by the technical estimates such as ( [ th1 ] ) ; this limitation is overcome in the direct space method below ) . the multiscale analysis allows to define the so - called effective expansion , in between the bare and the renormalized expansion , which is optimal , both for physical and for constructive purposes @xcite . in this effective expansion only the subcontributions with all _ internal _ scales higher than all _ external _ scales have to be renormalised by counterterms of the form of the initial lagrangian . in fact only planar such subcontributions with a single external face must be renormalised by such counterterms . this follows simply from the the grosse - wulkenhaar moves defined in @xcite . these moves translate the external legs along the outer border of the planar graph , up to irrelevant corrections , until they all merge together into a term of the proper moyal form , which is then absorbed in the effective constants definition . this requires only the estimates ( [ th1])-([thsummax ] ) , which were checked numerically in @xcite . in this way the relevant and marginal counterterms can be shown to be of the moyal type , namely renormalise the parameters @xmath238 , @xmath208 and @xmath8 term can be absorbed in a rescaling of the field , called `` field strength renromalization . '' ] . notice that in the multiscale analysis there is no need for the relatively complicated use of polchinski s equation @xcite made in @xcite . polchinski s method , although undoubtedly very elegant for proving perturbative renormalisability does not seem directly suited to constructive purposes , even in the case of simple fermionic models such as the commutative gross neveu model , see e.g. @xcite . the bphz theorem itself for the renormalised expansion follows from finiteness of the effective expansion by developing the counterterms still hidden in the effective couplings . its own finiteness can be checked e.g. through the standard classification of forests @xcite . let us however recall once again that in our opinion the effective expansion , not the renormalised one is the more fundamental object , both to describe the physics and to attack deeper mathematical problems , such as those of constructive theory @xcite . the matrix base simplfies very much at @xmath239 , where the matrix propagator becomes diagonal , i.e. conserves exactly indices . this property has been used for the general proof that the beta function of the theory vanishes in the ultraviolet regime @xcite , leading to the exciting perspective of a full non - perturbative construction of the model . we give here the results we get in @xcite . in this article , we computed the @xmath6-space and matrix basis kernels of operators which generalize the mehler kernel . then we proceeded to a study of the scaling behaviours of these kernels in the matrix basis . this work is useful to study the non - commutative gross - neveu model in the matrix basis . the following lemma generalizes the mehler kernel @xcite : [ hinxspace]let @xmath240 the operator : @xmath241 the @xmath6-space kernel of @xmath242 is : @xmath243 @xmath244 the mehler kernel corresponds to @xmath245 . the limit @xmath246 gives the usual heat kernel . let @xmath240 be given by with @xmath247 . its inverse in the matrix basis is : @xmath248 where @xmath166 and @xmath115 is a function of @xmath8 : @xmath167 . on the moyal space , we modified the commutative gross - neveu model by adding a @xmath249 term ( see lemma [ xpropa1gn ] ) . we have @xmath250 it will be useful to express @xmath30 in terms of commutators : @xmath251 where @xmath252 with @xmath145 and @xmath253 . + we now give the expression of the fermionic kernel in the matrix basis . the inverse of the quadratic form @xmath254 is given by in the preceeding section : @xmath255 the fermionic propagator @xmath30 ( [ xfullprop ] ) in the matrix basis may be deduced from the kernel . we just set @xmath256 , add the missing term with @xmath257 and compute the action of @xmath258 on @xmath259 . we must then evaluate @xmath260 in the matrix basis : @xmath261 this allows to prove : let @xmath262 the kernel , in the matrix basis , of the operator + @xmath263 . we have : @xmath264 where @xmath265 is given by ( [ eq : propinit - b ] ) and the commutators bu the formulas ( [ x0gamma ] ) and ( [ x1gamma ] ) . the first two terms in the equation ( [ eq : matrixfullprop ] ) contain commutators and will be gathered under the name @xmath266 . the last term will be called @xmath267 : @xmath268 we use the multi - scale analysis to study the behaviour of the propagator and revisit more finely the bounds to . in a slice @xmath269 , the propagator is @xmath270 @xmath271 let @xmath272 and @xmath273 . without loss of generality , we assume @xmath274 and @xmath275 . then the smallest index among @xmath276 is @xmath208 and the biggest is @xmath277 . we have : [ maintheorem ] under the assumptions @xmath278 and @xmath279 , there exists @xmath280 ( @xmath281 depends on @xmath8 ) such that the propagator of the non - commutative gross - neveu model in a slice @xmath269 obeys the bound @xmath282 the mass term is slightly different : @xmath283 we can redo the same analysis for the @xmath116 propagator and get @xmath284 which allows to recover the bounds to . let us consider the propagator of the non - commutative gross - neveu model . we saw in section [ sec : bornes ] that there exists two regions in the space of indices where the propagator behaves very differently . in one of them it behaves as the @xmath116 propagator and leads then to the same power counting . in the critical region , we have @xmath285 the point is that such a propagator does not allow to sum two reference indices with a unique line . this fact was useful in the proof of the power counting of the @xmath116 model . this leads to a _ uv / ir mixing . let us consider the graph in figure [ fig : sunsetj ] where the two external lines bear an index @xmath286 and the internal one an index @xmath287 . the propagator obeys the bound in prop . which means that it is almost local . we only have to sum over one index per internal face . on the graph of the figure [ fig : sunseti ] , if the two lines inside are true external ones , the graph has two broken faces and there is no index to sum over . then by using prop . we get @xmath288 . the sum over @xmath269 converges and we have the same behaviour as the @xmath116 theory , that is to say the graphs with @xmath289 broken faces are finite . but if these two lines belongs to a line of scale @xmath287 ( see figure [ fig : sunsetj ] ) , the result is different . indeed , at scale @xmath269 , we recover the graph of figure [ fig : sunseti ] . to maintain the previous result ( @xmath290 ) , we should sum the two indices corresponding to the internal faces with the propagator of scale @xmath291 . this is not possible . instead we have : @xmath292 the sum over @xmath269 diverges logarithmically . the graph of figure [ fig : sunseti ] converges if it is linked to true exernal legs et diverges if it is a subgraph of a graph at a lower scale . the power counting depends on the scales lower than the lowest scale of the graph . it ca nt then be factorized into the connected components : this is uv / ir mixing . + let s remark that the graph of figure [ fig : sunseti ] is not renormalisable by a counter - term in the lagrangian . its logarithmic divergence ca nt be absorbed in a redefinition of a coupling constant . fortunately the renormalisation of the two - point graph of figure [ fig : sunsetj ] makes the four - point subdivergence finite @xcite . this makes the non - commutative gross - neveu model renormalisable . we want now to explain how the power counting analysis can be performed in direct space , and the `` moyality '' of the necessary counterterms can be checked by a taylor expansion which is a generalization of the one used in direct commutative space . in the commutative case there is translation invariance , hence each propagator depends on a single difference variable which is short in the ultraviolet regime ; in the non - commutative case the propagator depends both of the difference of end positions , which is again short in the uv regime , but also of the sum which is long in the uv regime , considering the explicit form ( [ eq : mehler ] ) of the mehler kernel . let @xmath30 be an arbitrary connected graph . the amplitude associated with this graph is in direct space ( with hopefully self - explaining notations ) : @xmath293 \prod_l c_l \ ; , \nonumber \\ c_l= & \frac{\omega^2}{[2\pi\sinh(\omega t_l)]^2}e^{-\frac{\omega}{2}\coth(\omega t_l)(x_{v , i(l)}^{2}+x_{v',i'(l)}^{2 } ) + \frac{\omega}{\sinh(\omega t_l)}x_{v , i(l ) } . x_{v',i'(l ) } - \mu_0 ^ 2 t_l}\ ; .\nonumber \label{amplitude1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with these notations , defining @xmath298 , the propagators in our graph can be written as : @xmath299 ^ 2 } e^{-\frac{\omega}{4}\coth(\frac{\alpha_l}{2 } ) { u_l^2}- \frac{\omega}{4}\tanh(\frac{\alpha_l}{2 } ) { v_l^2 } - \frac{\mu_0 ^ 2}{\omega } \alpha_l}\ ; .\label{tanhyp}\ ] ] @xmath301\nonumber\\ c^i ( u , v ) = & \int_{m^{-2i}}^{m^{-2(i-1 ) } } \frac{\omega d\alpha}{[2\pi\sinh(\alpha)]^2 } e^{-\frac{\omega}{4}\coth(\frac{\alpha}{2 } ) { u^2}- \frac{\omega}{4}\tanh(\frac{\alpha}{2 } ) { v^2 } - \frac{\mu_0 ^ 2}{\omega } \alpha}\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we pick a tree @xmath36 of lines of the graph , hence connecting all vertices , pick with a root vertex and build an _ orientation _ of all the lines of the graph in an inductive way . starting from an arbitrary orientation of a field at the root of the tree , we climb in the tree and at each vertex of the tree we impose cyclic order to alternate entering and exiting tree lines and loop half - lines , as in figure [ otree ] . then we look at the loop lines . if every loop lines consist in the contraction of an entering and an exiting line , the graph is called orientable . otherwise we call it non - orientable as in figure [ nono ] . there are @xmath306 @xmath97 functions in an amplitude with @xmath306 vertices , hence @xmath306 linear equations for the @xmath307 positions , one for each vertex . the _ position routing _ associated to the tree @xmath36 solves this system by passing to another equivalent system of @xmath306 linear equations , one for each branch of the tree . this is a triangular change of variables , of jacobian 1 . this equivalent system is obtained by summing the arguments of the @xmath97 functions of the vertices in each branch . this change of variables is exactly the @xmath6-space analog of the resolution of momentum conservation called _ momentum routing _ in the standard physics literature of commutative field theory , except that one should now take care of the additional @xmath308 cyclic signs . we have , calling @xmath310 the remaining integrand in ( [ amplitude2 ] ) : @xmath311 \ , \big]\ ; i_g(\{x_{v , i } \ } ) \\ = & \int \prod_{b } \delta \left ( \sum_{l\in t_b \cup l_b } u_{l } + \sum_{l\in l_{b,+}}v_{l}-\sum_{l\in l_{b,-}}v_{l } + \sum_{f\in x_b}\epsilon(f ) x_f \right ) i_g(\{x_{v , i } \ } ) , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath312 is @xmath313 depending on whether the field @xmath314 enters or exits the branch . we can now use the system of delta functions to eliminate variables . it is of course better to eliminate long variables as their integration costs a factor @xmath315 whereas the integration of a short variable brings @xmath316 . rough power counting , neglecting all oscillations of the vertices leads therefore , in the case of an orientable graph with @xmath148 external fields , @xmath306 internal vertices and @xmath317 internal lines at scale @xmath269 to : * a factor @xmath318 coming from the @xmath211 factors for each line of scale @xmath269 in ( [ eq : propbound - phi4 ] ) , * a factor @xmath319 for the @xmath320 short variables integrations , * a factor @xmath321 for the long variables after eliminating @xmath309 of them using the delta functions . in the non - orientable case , we can eliminate one additional long variable since the rank of the system of delta functions is larger by one unit ! therefore we get a power counting bound @xmath324 , which proves that only _ orientable _ graphs may diverge . in fact we of course know that not all _ orientable _ two and four point subgraphs diverge but only the planar ones with a single external face . ( it is easy to check that all such planar graphs are indeed orientable ) . since only these planar subgraphs with a single external face can be renormalised by moyal counterterms , we need to prove that orientable , non - planar graphs or orientable planar graphs with several external faces have in fact a better power counting than this crude estimate . this can be done only by exploiting their vertices oscillations . we explain now how to do this with minimal effort . following filk @xcite , we can contract all lines of a spanning tree @xmath36 and reduce @xmath30 to a single vertex with `` tadpole loops '' called a `` rosette graph '' . this rosette is a cycle ( which is the border of the former tree ) bearing loops lines on it ( see figure [ fig : rosette ] ) : remark that the rosette can also be considered as a big vertex , with @xmath325 fields , on which @xmath148 are external fields with external variables @xmath6 and @xmath326 are loop fields for the corresponding @xmath327 loops . when the graph is orientable , the rosette is also orientable , which means that turning around the rosette the lines alternatively enter and exit . these lines correspond to the contraction of the fields on the border of the tree @xmath36 before the filk contraction , also called the `` first filk move '' . the rosette contribution after a complete first filk reduction is exactly : @xmath330 where the @xmath331 variables are the long or external variables of the rosette , counted with their signs , and the quadratic oscillations for these variables is @xmath332 we have now to analyze in detail this quadratic oscillation of the remaining long loop variables since it is essential to improve power counting . we can neglect the secondary oscillations @xmath333 and @xmath334 which imply short variables . the second filk reduction @xcite further simplifies the rosette factor by erasing the loops of the rosette which do not cross any other loops or arch over external fields . it can be shown that the loops which disappear in this operation correspond to those long variables who do not appear in the quadratic form @xmath335 . the basic mechanism to improve the power counting of a single non - planar subgraph is the following : @xmath336 in these equations we used for simplicity @xmath290 instead of the correct but more complicated factor @xmath337 ( of course this does not change the argument ) and we performed a unitary linear change of variables @xmath338 , @xmath339 to compute the oscillating @xmath340 integral . the gain in ( [ gainoscill ] ) is @xmath341 , which is the difference between @xmath342 and the normal factor @xmath343 that the @xmath344 integral would have cost if we had done it with the regular @xmath345 factor for long variables . to maximize this gain we can assume @xmath346 . finally it remains to consider the case of subgraphs which are planar orientable but with more than one external face . in that case there are no crossing loops in the rosette but there must be at least one loop line arching over a non trivial subset of external legs ( see e.g. line @xmath347 in figure [ fig : rosette ] ) . we have then a non trivial integration over at least one external variable , called @xmath6 , of at least one long loop variable called @xmath348 . this `` external '' @xmath6 variable without the oscillation improvement would be integrated with a test function of scale 1 ( if it is a true external line of scale @xmath349 ) or better ( if it is a higher long loop variable ) can not be the full combination of external variables in the `` root '' @xmath97 function . ] . but we get now @xmath350 so that a factor @xmath315 in the former bound becomes @xmath351 hence is improved by @xmath316 . in this way we can reduce the convergence of the multiscale analysis to the problem of renormalisation of planar two- and four - point subgraphs with a single external face , which we treat in the next section . remark that the power counting obtained in this way is still not optimal . to get the same level of precision than with the matrix base requires e.g. to display @xmath174 independent improvements of the type ( [ gainoscill ] ) for a graph of genus @xmath174 . this is doable but basically requires a reduction of the quadratic form @xmath335 for single - faced rosette ( also called `` hyperrosette '' ) into @xmath174 standard symplectic blocks through the so - called `` third filk move '' introduced in @xcite . we return to this question in section [ hyperbo ] . the idea is that one should compare its amplitude to a similar amplitude with a `` moyal factor '' @xmath352 factorized in front , where @xmath353 . but precisely because the graph is planar with a single external face we understand that the external positions @xmath6 only couple to _ short variables _ @xmath354 of the internal amplitudes through the global delta function and the oscillations . hence we can break this coupling by a systematic taylor expansion to first order . this separates a piece proportional to `` moyal factor '' , then absorbed into the effective coupling constant , and a remainder which has at least one additional small factor which gives him improved power counting . this is done by expressing the amplitude for a graph with @xmath355 , @xmath356 and @xmath357 as : @xmath358 \ e^{\imath uru+\imath usv } \\ & \hspace{-2 cm } \bigg\ { { \delta(\delta ) } + \int_{0}^{1}dt\bigg [ \mathfrak{u}\cdot \nabla \delta(\delta+t\mathfrak{u } ) + \delta(\delta+t\mathfrak{u } ) [ \imath xqu + { \mathfrak r } ' ( t ) ] \bigg ] e^{\imath txqu + { \mathfrak r}(t ) } \bigg\ } \ .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath359 is the propagator taken at @xmath360 , @xmath361 and @xmath362 is a correcting term involving @xmath363 $ ] . following the same strategy we have to taylor - expand the coupling between external variables and @xmath354 factors in two point planar graphs with a single external face to _ third order _ and some non - trivial symmetrization of the terms acording to the two external arguments to cancel some odd contributions . the corresponding factorized relevant and marginal contributions can be then shown to give rise only to again the bphz theorem itself for the renormalised expansion follows by developing the counterterms still hidden in the effective couplings and its finiteness follows from the standard classification of forests . see however the remarks at the end of section [ sec : vari - indep ] . since the bound ( [ eq : propbound - phi4 ] ) works for any @xmath366 , an additional bonus of the @xmath6-space method is that it proves renormalisability of the model for any @xmath8 in @xmath3670,1]$ ] in @xmath368 is irrelevant since it can be rewritten by ls duality as an equivalent model with @xmath8 in @xmath3670,1]$ ] . ] , whether the matrix method proved it only for @xmath8 in @xmath3670.5,1]$ ] . the interaction @xmath371 ensures that perturbation theory contains only orientable graphs . for @xmath372 the @xmath6-space propagator still decays as in the ordinary @xmath7 case and the model has been shown renormalisable by an easy extension of the methods of the previous section @xcite . consider the @xmath6-kernel of the operator @xmath374 the gross - neveu model or the critical langmann - szabo - zarembo models correspond to the case @xmath375 . in these models there is no longer any confining decay for the `` long variables '' but only an oscillation : @xmath376 this kind of models are called critical . their construction is more difficult , since sufficiently many oscillations must be proven independent before power counting can be established . the prototype paper which solved this problem is @xcite , which we briefly summarize now . the main technical difficulty of the critical models is the absence of decreasing functions for the long @xmath331 variables in the propagator replaced by an oscillation , see ( [ eq : criticalpropa ] ) . note that these decreasing functions are in principle created by integration over the @xmath377 variables . ] : @xmath378 but to perform all these gaussian integrations for a general graph is a difficult task ( see @xcite ) and is in fact not necessary for a bphz theorem . we can instead exploit the vertices and propagators oscillations to get rationnal decreasing functions in some linear combinations of the long @xmath331 variables . the difficulty is then to prove that all these linear combinations are independant and hence allow to integrate over all the @xmath331 variables . to solve this problem we need the exact expression of the total oscillation in terms of the short and long variables . this consists in a generalization of the filk s work @xcite . this has been done in @xcite . once the oscillations are proven independant , one can just use the same arguments than in the @xmath116 case ( see section [ sec : routing - filk - moves ] ) to compute an upper bound for the power counting : [ lem : compt - puissgn ] let @xmath30 a connected orientable graph . for all @xmath379 , there exists @xmath380 such that its amputated amplitude @xmath381 integrated over test functions is bounded by @xmath382 as in the non - commutative @xmath116 case , only the planar graphs are divergent . but the behaviour of the graphs with more than one broken face is different . note that we already discussed such a feature in the matrix basis ( see section [ sec : prop - et - renorm ] ) . in the multiscale framework , the feynamn diagrams are endowed with a scale attribution which gives each line a scale index . the only subgraphs we meet in this setting have all their internal scales higher than their external ones . then a subgraph @xmath383 of scale @xmath269 is called _ critical _ if it has @xmath384 and that the two `` external '' points in the second broken face are only linked by a single line of scale @xmath287 . the typical example is the graph of figure [ fig : sunseti ] . in this case , the subgrah is logarithmically divergent whereas it is convergent in the @xmath116 model . let us now show roughly how it happens in the case of figure [ fig : sunseti ] but now in @xmath6-space . the same arguments than in the @xmath116 model prove that the integrations over the internal points of the graph [ fig : sunseti ] lead to a logarithmical divergence which means that @xmath385 in the multiscale framework . but remind that there is a remaining oscillation between a long variable of this graph and the external points in the second broken face of the form @xmath386 . but @xmath331 is of order @xmath387 which leads to a decreasing function implementing @xmath388 of order @xmath389 . if these points are true external ones , they are integrated over test functions of norm @xmath349 . then thanks to the additional decreasing function for @xmath388 we gain a factor @xmath290 which makes the graph convergent . but if @xmath6 and @xmath390 are linked by a single line of scale @xmath287 ( as in figure [ fig : sunsetj ] ) , instead of test functions we have a propagator between @xmath6 and @xmath390 . this one behaves like ( see ): @xmath391 the integration over @xmath388 instead of giving @xmath392 gives @xmath290 thanks to the oscillation @xmath393 . then we have gained a good factor @xmath394 . but the oscillation in the propagator @xmath395 now gives @xmath396 instead of @xmath397 and the integration over @xmath398 cancels the preceeding gain . the critical component of figure [ fig : sunseti ] is logarithmically divergent . this kind of argument can be repeated and refined for more general graphs to prove that this problem appears only when the extrernal points of the auxiliary broken faces are linked only by a _ single _ lower line @xcite . this phenomenon can be seen as a mixing between scales . indeed the power counting of a given subgraph now depends on the graphs at lower scales . this was not the case in the commutative realm . fortunately this mixing does nt prevent renormalisation . note that whereas the critical subgraphs are not renormalisable by a vertex - like counterterm , they are regularised by the renormalisation of the two - point function at scale @xmath291 . the proof of this point relies heavily on the fact that there is only one line of lower scale . let us conclude this section by mentionning the flows of the critical models . one very interesting feature of the non - commutative @xmath116 model is the boundedness of its flows and even the vanishing of its beta function for a special value of its bare parameters @xcite . note that its commutative counterpart ( the usual @xmath399 model on @xmath400 ) is asymptotically free in the infrared and has then an unbounded flow . it turns out that the flow of the critical models are not regularized by the non - commutativity . the one - loop computation of the beta functions of the non - commutative gross - neveu model @xcite shows that it is asymptotically free in the ultraviolet region as in the commutative case . in ordinary commutative field theory , symanzik s polynomials are obtained after integration over internal position variables . the amplitude of an amputated graph @xmath30 with external momenta @xmath107 is , up to a normalization , in space - time dimension @xmath42 : @xmath401 the first and second symanzik polynomials @xmath402 and @xmath403 are where the first sum is over spanning trees @xmath36 of @xmath30 and the second sum is over two trees @xmath405 , i.e. forests separating the graph in exactly two connected components @xmath406 and @xmath407 ; the corresponding euclidean invariant @xmath408 is , by momentum conservation , also equal to @xmath409 . since the mehler kernel is still quadratic in position space it is possible to also integrate explicitly all positions to reduce feynman amplitudes of e.g. non - commutative @xmath7 purely to parametric formulas , but of course the analogs of symanzik polynomials are now hyperbolic polynomials which encode the richer information about ribbon graphs . the reference for these polynomials is @xcite , which treats the ordinary @xmath7 case . in @xcite , these polynomials are also computed in the more complicated case of critical models . defining the antisymmetric matrix @xmath410 as @xmath411 the @xmath412functions appearing in the vertex contribution can be rewritten as an integral over some new variables @xmath413 . we refer to these variables as to _ hypermomenta_. note that one associates such a hypermomenta @xmath413 to any vertex @xmath149 _ via _ the relation @xmath414 consider a particular ribbon graph @xmath30 . specializing to dimension 4 and choosing a particular root vertex @xmath415 of the graph , one can write the feynman amplitude for @xmath30 in the condensed way @xmath416^{2 } d\alpha_{\ell } \int d x d p e^{-\frac { \omega}{2 } x g x^t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath417 , @xmath418 summarizes all positions and hyermomenta and @xmath30 is a certain quadratic form . if we call @xmath419 and @xmath420 the external variables we can decompose @xmath30 according to an internal quadratic form @xmath335 , an external one @xmath35 and a coupling part @xmath421 so that @xmath422 performing the gaussian integration over all internal variables one obtains : @xmath423^{2 } d\alpha\frac{1}{\sqrt{\det q } } e^{-\frac{\ot}{2 } \begin{pmatrix } x_e & \bar{p } \\ \end{pmatrix } [ m - p q^{-1}p^{t } ] \begin{pmatrix } x_e \\ \bar{p } \\ \end{pmatrix}}\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this form allows to define the polynomials @xmath424 and @xmath425 , analogs of the symanzik polynomials @xmath354 and @xmath149 of the commutative case ( see ) . they are defined by @xmath426 hu_{g , \bar{v } } ( t ) ^{-2 } e^{- \frac { hv_{g , \bar{v } } ( t , x_e , p_{\bar v})}{hu_{g , \bar{v } } ( t ) } } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] they are polynomials in the set of variables @xmath427 ( @xmath428 ) , the hyperbolic tangent of the half - angle of the parameters @xmath429 . * the polynomials @xmath424 and @xmath425 have a strong positivity property . roughly speaking they are sums of monomials with positive integer coefficients . this positive integer property comes from the fact that each such coefficient is the square of a pfaffian with integer entries , * leading terms can be identified in a given `` hepp sector '' , at least for _ orientable graphs_. a hepp sector is a complete ordering of the @xmath432 parameters . these leading terms which can be shown strictly positive in @xmath424 correspond to super - trees which are the disjoint union of a tree in the direct graph and a tree in the dual graph . hypertrees in a graph with @xmath306 vertices and @xmath172 faces have therefore @xmath433 lines . ( any connected graph has hypertrees , and under reduction of the hypertree , the graph becomes a hyperrosette ) . similarly one can identify `` super - two - trees '' @xmath425 which govern the leading behavior of @xmath425 in any hepp sector . for the bubble graph of figure [ figex1 ] : @xmath435}^2+t_1t_2\big{[}2p_2 ^ 2+(1 + 16s^4)(x_1-x_4)^2 \big{]}\,,\nonumber\\ & + t_1 ^ 2\big{[}p_2 + 2s(x_1-x_4)\big{]}^2\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath437}+t_1 ^ 2\big{[}p_2 + 2s(x_3-y_4 ) \big{]}^2\,,\nonumber\\ & + t_1t_2\big{[}8s^2y_2 ^ 2 + 2(p_2 - 2sy_4)^2+(x_1+x_3)^2 + 16s^4(x_1-x_3)^2\big{]}\nonumber\\ & + t_1 ^ 2t_2 ^ 24s^2(x_1-y_2)^2\,,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , for the half - eye graph ( see fig . [ figeye ] ) , we start by defining : @xmath440 the @xmath438 polynomial with fixed hypermomentum corresponding to the vertex with two external legs is : @xmath441 whereas with another fixed hypermomentum we get : @xmath442 note that the leading terms are identical and the choice of the root perturbs only the non - leading ones . moreover note the presence of the @xmath443 term . its presence can be understood by the fact that in the sector @xmath444 the subgraph formed by the lines @xmath445 has two broken faces . this is the sign of a power counting improvement due to the additional broken face in that sector . to exploit it , we have just to integrate over the variables of line @xmath446 in that sector , using the second polynomial @xmath447 for the triangle subgraph @xmath448 made of lines @xmath445 . non - commutative qft seemed initially to have non - renormalisable divergencies , due to uv / ir mixing . but following the grosse - wulkenhaar breakthrough , there has been recent rapid progress in our understanding of renormalisable qft on moyal spaces . we can already propose a preliminary classification of these models into different categories , according to the behavior of their propagators : * ordinary models at @xmath449 such as @xmath7 ( which has non - orientable graphs ) or @xmath450 models ( which has none ) . their propagator , roughly @xmath451 is ls covariant and has good decay both in matrix space ( [ th1]-[thsummax ] ) and direct space ( [ tanhyp ] ) . they have non - logarithmic mass divergencies and definitely require `` vulcanization '' i.e. the @xmath8 term . * `` supermodels '' , namely ordinary models but at @xmath452 in which the propagator is ls invariant . their propagator is even better . in the matrix base it is diagonal , e.g. of the form @xmath453 , where @xmath454 is a constant . the supermodels seem generically ultraviolet fixed points of the ordinary models , at which non - trivial ward identities force the vanishing of the beta function . the flow of @xmath8 to the @xmath452 fixed point is very fast ( exponentially fast in rg steps ) . * `` critical models '' such as orientable versions of lsz or gross - neveu ( and presumably orientable gauge theories of various kind : yang - mills , chern - simons ... ) . they may have only logarithmic divergencies and apparently no perturbative uv / ir mixing . however the vulcanized version still appears the most generic framework for their treatment . the propagator is then roughly @xmath455 . in matrix space this propagator shows definitely a weaker decay ( [ mainbound1 ] ) than for the ordinary models , because of the presence of a non - trivial saddle point . in direct space the propagator no longer decays with respect to the long variables , but only oscillates . nevertheless the main lesson is that in matrix space the weaker decay can still be used ; and in @xmath6 space the oscillations can never be completely killed by the vertices oscillations . hence these models retain therefore essentially the power counting of the ordinary models , up to some nasty details concerning the four - point subgraphs with two external faces . ultimately , thanks to a little conspiration in which the four - point subgraphs with two external faces are renormalised by the mass renormalisation , the critical models remain renormalisable . this is the main message of @xcite . * `` hypercritical models '' which are of the previous type but at @xmath452 . their propagator in the matrix base is diagonal and depends only on one index @xmath208 ( e.g. always the left side of the ribbon ) . it is of the form @xmath456 . in @xmath6 space the propagator oscillates in a way that often exactly compensates the vertices oscillations . these models have definitely worse power counting than in the ordinary case , with e.g. quadratically divergent four point - graphs ( if sharp cut - offs are used ) . nevertheless ward identities can presumably still be used to show that they can still be renormalised . this probably requires a much larger conspiration to generalize the ward identities of the supermodels . parametric representation can be derived in the non - commutative case . it implies hyper - analogs of symanzik polynomials which condense the information about the rich topological structure of a ribbon graph . using this representation , dimensional regularization and dimensional renormalisation should extend to the non - commutative framework . remark that trees , which are the building blocks of the symanzik polynomials , are also at the heart of ( commutative ) constructive theory , whose philosophy could be roughly summarized as `` you shall use trees , but you shall _ not _ develop their loops or else you shall diverge '' . it is quite natural to conjecture that hypertrees , which are the natural non - commutative objects intrinsic to a ribbon graph , should play a key combinatoric role in the yet to develop non - commutative constructive field theory . in conclusion we have barely started to scratch the world of renormalisable qft on non - commutative spaces . the little we see through the narrow window now open is extremely tantalizing . there exists renormalizable ncqfts eg @xmath457 on @xmath458 , gross - neveu on @xmath459 and they seem to enjoy better propoerties than their commutative counterparts , for instance they no longer have landau ghosts ! non - commutative non relativistic field theories with a chemical potential seem the right formalism for a study ab initio of condensed matter in presence of a magnetic field , and in particular of the quantum hall effect . the correct scaling and rg theory of this effect presumably requires to build a very singular theory ( of the hypercritical type ) because of the huge degeneracy of the landau levels . to understand this theory and the gauge theories on non - commutative spaces seem the most obvious challenges ahead of us . n. seiberg and e. witten , string theory and noncommutative geometry , _ jhep _ * 09 * ( 1999 ) 032 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9908142[hep-th/9908142 ] . r. gurau , j. magnen , v. rivasseau and f. vignes - tourneret , renormalization of non - commutative @xmath7 field theory in @xmath6 space , _ commun . * 267 * ( 2006 ) , no . 2 , 515542 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0512271[hep-th/0512271 ] . h. grosse and r. wulkenhaar , power - counting theorem for non - local matrix models and renormalisation , _ commun . * 254 * ( 2005 ) , no . 1 , 91127 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0305066[hep-th/0305066 ] . h. grosse and r. wulkenhaar , renormalisation of @xmath99-theory on noncommutative @xmath460 in the matrix base , _ commun . * 256 * ( 2005 ) , no . 2 , 305374 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0401128[hep-th/0401128 ] . e. langmann and r. j. szabo , duality in scalar field theory on noncommutative phase spaces , _ phys . lett . _ * b533 * ( 2002 ) 168177 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0202039[hep-th/0202039 ] . v. rivasseau , f. vignes - tourneret , and r. wulkenhaar , renormalization of noncommutative @xmath457-theory by multi - scale analysis , _ commun . math . phys . _ * 262 * ( 2006 ) 565594 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0501036[hep-th/0501036 ] . t. filk , divergencies in a field theory on quantum space , _ phys . * b376 * ( 1996 ) 5358 . i. chepelev and r. roiban , convergence theorem for non - commutative feynman graphs and renormalization , _ jhep _ * 03 * ( 2001 ) 001 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0008090[hep-th/0008090 ] . i. chepelev and r. roiban , renormalization of quantum field theories on noncommutative @xmath461 . i : scalars , _ jhep _ * 05 * ( 2000 ) 037 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9911098[hep-th/9911098 ] . e. langmann , r. j. szabo , and k. zarembo , exact solution of quantum field theory on noncommutative phase spaces , _ jhep _ * 01 * ( 2004 ) 017 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0308043[hep-th/0308043 ] . m. r. douglas and n. a. nekrasov , noncommutative field theory , _ rev . * 73 * ( 2001 ) 9771029 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0106048[hep-th/0106048 ] . d. kreimer , on the hopf algebra structure of perturbative quantum field theories , _ adv . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 303334 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/q-alg/9707029[q-alg/9707029 ] . a. connes and d. kreimer , renormalization in quantum field theory and the riemann - hilbert problem i : the hopf algebra structure of graphs and the main theorem , _ commun . * 210 * ( march , 2000 ) 249273 . a. connes and d. kreimer , renormalization in quantum field theory and the riemann hilbert problem ii : the - function , diffeomorphisms and the renormalization group , _ commun . * 216 * ( january , 2001 ) 215241 . a. connes and m. marcolli , from physics to number theory via noncommutative geometry . ii : renormalization , the riemann - hilbert correspondence , and motivic galois theory , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0411114[hep-th/0411114 ] . e. leichtnam , scaling group flow and lefschetz trace formula for laminated spaces with $ p-$adic transversal , _ arxiv mathematics e - prints _ ( mar . , 2006 ) http://www.arxiv.org/abs/math/0603576 [ math/0603576 ] . a. abdesselam , the jacobian conjecture as a problem of perturbative quantum field theory , _ annales henri poincare _ * 4 * ( 2003 ) 199215 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/math.co/0208173[math.co/0208173 ] . r. gurau and v. rivasseau , parametric representation of non - commutative field theory , to appear in commun . phys , http://www.arxiv.org / abs / math - ph/0606030[math- ph/0606030 ] . h. grosse and r. wulkenhaar , the beta - function in duality - covariant noncommutative @xmath99-theory , _ eur . phys . j. _ * c35 * ( 2004 ) 277282 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0402093[hep-th/0402093 ] . m. disertori and v. rivasseau , two and three loops beta function of non commutative @xmath4 theory http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0610224[hep-th/0610224 ] . m. disertori , r. gurau , j. magnen and v. rivasseau , vanishing of beta function of non commutative @xmath462 to all orders , submitted to phys . b , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0612251[hep-th/0612251 ] . s. minwalla , m. van raamsdonk , and n. seiberg , noncommutative perturbative dynamics , _ jhep _ * 02 * ( 2000 ) 020 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9912072[hep-th/9912072 ] . v. gayral , heat - kernel approach to uv / ir mixing on isospectral deformation manifolds , _ annales henri poincare _ * 6 * ( 2005 ) 9911023 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0412233[hep-th/0412233 ] . b. simon , _ functionnal integration and quantum physics _ , 86 of _ pure and applied mathematics_. academic press , new york , 1979 . h. grosse and r. wulkenhaar , renormalisation of @xmath99-theory on noncommutative @xmath463 in the matrix base , _ jhep _ * 12 * ( 2003 ) 019 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0307017[hep-th/0307017 ] . h. grosse and h. steinacker , renormalization of the noncommutative @xmath464 model through the kontsevich model . h. grosse and h. steinacker , a nontrivial solvable noncommutative @xmath464 model in @xmath465 dimensions , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0603052[hep-th/0603052 ] . e. langmann , r. j. szabo , and k. zarembo , exact solution of noncommutative field theory in background magnetic fields , _ phys . lett . _ * b569 * ( 2003 ) 95101 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0303082[hep-th/0303082 ] . e. langmann , interacting fermions on noncommutative spaces : exactly solvable quantum field theories in 2n+1 dimensions , _ nucl . phys . _ * b654 * ( 2003 ) 404426 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0205287[hep-th/0205287 ] . v. rivasseau , _ from perturbative to constructive renormalization_. princeton series in physics . princeton univ . princeton , usa , 1991 . 336 p. p. k. mitter and p. h. weisz , asymptotic scale invariance in a massive thirring model with @xmath466 symmetry , _ phys . * d8 * ( 1973 ) 44104429 . d. j. gross and a. neveu , dynamical symmetry breaking in asymptotically free field theories , _ phys . * d10 * ( 1974 ) 3235 . c. kopper , j. magnen , and v. rivasseau , mass generation in the large n gross - neveu model , _ commun . math . phys . _ * 169 * ( 1995 ) 121180 . f. vignes - tourneret , _ renormalisation des thories de champs non commutatives_. physique thorique , universit paris 11 , september , 2006 . m. disertori and v.rivasseau , continuous constructive fermionic renormalization , _ annales henri poincar _ * vol . 1 * ( 2000 ) 1 http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9802145 [ hep - th/9802145 ] . v. rivasseau , _ an introduction to renormalization _ , in poincar seminar 2002 , ed . by b. duplantier and v. rivasseau . progress in mathematical physics 30 , birkhuser ( 2003 ) , isbn 3 - 7643 - 0579 - 7 . a. lakhoua , f. vignes - tourneret and j.c . wallet , one - loop beta functions for the orientable non- commutative gross - neveu model , submitted to jhep . http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0701170 [ hep - th/0701170 ] . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the study of far - infrared ( fir ) emission from elliptical galaxies is particularly interesting because the internal rates that dust is formed and destroyed can both be estimated . dust is produced by mass loss from evolving red giant stars in the old stellar population typical of these galaxies . this mass loss is directly observed in the cumulative mid - infrared 1024@xmath1 m emission from circumstellar regions around giant stars , causing the surface brightness profiles at 1024@xmath1 m to resemble those at optical wavelengths ( knapp et al . 1989 ; athey et al . the dust destruction rate by sputtering can be estimated from the frequency of thermal impacts from ions in the hot interstellar gas which for many ellipticals can be estimated from x - ray observations . during their sputtering lifetimes , dust grains ejected from giant stars are heated by starlight and thermal electron impacts to temperatures that radiate in the fir ( e.g. tsai & mathews 1995 , 1996 ; temi et al . this radiation has been observed both by the _ infrared astronomical satellite , iras _ ( knapp et al . 1989 ) and by the _ infrared space observatory , iso _ ( temi et al . in addition , small optically obscuring clouds and disks of dusty gas have been detected in about half of the bright ellipticals studied with the _ hubble space telescope , hst _ ( van dokkum & franx 1995 ; ferrari et al . 1999 ; lauer et al . 2005 ) . these clouds probably formed from dusty gas ejected from stars within the central @xmath10kpc in these elliptical galaxies ( mathews & brighenti 2003 ) . galaxy mergers are another obvious possible source of dust in elliptical galaxies , indeed it is widely thought that ellipticals are formed by mergers . elliptical - looking galaxies can be produced after a few gyrs following the merger of two disk galaxies ( e.g. barnes & hernquist 1992 ) , but this simple recipe may not easily explain all structural and kinematic properties of these galaxies ( naab , jesseit & burkert 2006 ) . many of the mergers that produced the ripples , shells and counter - rotating cores in elliptical galaxies probably occurred a very long time ago . it is likely that massive boxy ellipticals , similar to many of those with strong fir emission , have experienced mostly `` dry '' gas and dust - free mergers during the last few gyrs ( bell et al . 2004 ; faber et al . nevertheless , mergers do occasionally occur between low - redshift ellipticals and gas - rich galaxies and these post - merger ellipticals often selectively appear in the observing lists of infrared observers . our previous study of fir emission from elliptical galaxies was based on a sample chosen from the _ iso _ data archive ( temi et al . 2004 ) that included a significant number of galaxies with abnormally large masses of dust and cold gas which are uncharacteristic of elliptical galaxies in general . the large range of fir luminosities that we found in the _ iso _ sample was therefore not unexpected , and it was reasonable to suppose that mergers with dusty galaxies explained the absence of correlations between optical and fir emission . the failure to find correlations between the fir and optical luminosities of elliptical galaxies has been used in the past to argue that the cold dust is acquired in a stochastic fashion by mergers ( forbes 1991 ) . to understand the relative role of internal and external sources of dust in elliptical galaxies , we describe here new _ spitzer _ observations at 24 , 70 and 160@xmath1 m . our full sample consists of 46 elliptical galaxies , formed by combining our own proprietary _ spitzer _ observations with those of other observers . the improved sensitivity and angular resolution of _ spitzer _ provides clear evidence that the 70@xmath1 m emission is spatially extended in many ellipticals . in particular , we find extended fir emission in elliptical galaxies that do not contain uncharacteristically large masses of neutral , molecular or optically visible cold gas . the diffuse nature of the dust in these otherwise normal galaxies , combined with the relatively short ( ion sputtering ) lifetime for dust destruction in the hot gas , favors an internal source of dust rather than dust - rich mergers which are probably too infrequent . the luminosity of extended fir dust emission in most ellipticals greatly exceeds that expected from normal mass loss from local stars . however , small , optically thick nuclear dust clouds observed in many elliptical galaxies may provide an alternative , more plausible source for the extended fir dust emission . consequently , we argue that dust accumulated in the central regions of elliptical galaxies from stellar sources in the core is transported out to larger radii by buoyantly rising gas intermittently heated by low - luminosity active galactic nuclei ( agn ) in the galactic cores . if this hypothesis can be confirmed in more detail , the presence of extended cold dust can be used to trace the radial circulation of hot gas in these galaxy / groups . such circulation flows are known to be consistent with x - ray observations in which very little hot gas cools to low temperatures ( mathews , brighenti & buote 2004 ) . for this study we construct a sample of 46 elliptical galaxies by combining far - infrared _ spitzer _ observations from our own _ spitzer _ data with additional galaxies in the public _ spitzer _ archive . our proprietary far - infrared _ spitzer _ observations of elliptical galaxies ( pid 20171 , pi p.temi ) consists of 11 non - peculiar , bright ( @xmath11 @xmath12 ) elliptical galaxies , most having high - quality x - ray observations . galactic proximity and spatial scale were also important factors in choosing this sample since high angular resolution is needed to separate emission from dusty cores and diffuse emission from truly interstellar dust spread over the galactic volume . furthermore , we avoided sources with strong radio sources and agn that have detectable signals in the far infrared . ellipticals with strong infrared milky way cirrus or bright spiral galaxies in the vicinity were also avoided . since one of our goals is to study the interaction between dust and hot gas , we included many galaxies for which the x - ray emission is well - studied by either _ chandra _ or _ xmm_. in addition to our original sample we selected 35 additional ellipticals from data currently available in the public _ spitzer _ archive targeted by several pis during their general observation in cycles 1 and 2 , guaranteed time observations , and the legacy program sings ( kennicutt et al . all the galaxies added to our original sample were chosen using selection criteria tailored to our specific scientific goals . thus , the 46 galaxies studied here form a rather homogeneous sample and is large enough to be statistically meaningful . tables 1 and 2 summarize the relevant properties of the sample galaxies including the far - infrared photometric measurements . optical data are taken from the leda catalog ( paturel et al . 1997 ) and the rsa catalog ( sandage & tamman 1981 ) , while x - ray data are from ellis and osullivan et al . luminosities and distances are calculated with @xmath13 km s@xmath14 mpc@xmath14 and are derived from the flux densities in table 1 using far - infrared ( fir ) passbands of @xmath15 5.3 , 19 and 34@xmath1 m for emission at 24 , 70 and 160@xmath1 m respectively . the pis of the original spitzer program from which the galaxies have been selected are shown in column two of table 1 . all galaxies are classified as ellipticals in the ned catalog , and the morphological type t is taken from the leda catalog . nevertheless , we shall find that our sample contains some s0 galaxies . most of the sample galaxies have known x - ray luminosities @xmath16 , which are a measure of the hot gas present in each galaxy . of the 46 galaxies in the sample three are dwarf elliptical galaxies ( ngc855 , ngc1377 , and ngc3265 ) with @xmath17 l@xmath18 . although they are listed in table 1 , they are not included in our discussion . the data presented here were acquired with the multiband imager photometer ( mips ) ( rieke et al . 2004 ) on the _ spitzer space telescope _ ( werner et al . 2004 ) in three wavebands centered at 24 , 70 and 160@xmath19 . since the galaxy sample has been constructed by collecting archival data from several spitzer observing programs , the image data were recorded using observing modes and integrations times tailored for their original scientific goals . as a consequence , although the maps represent the deepest fir images acquired to date , some data achieve sensitivities that are not always optimized for targets that are intrinsically faint at far - infrared wavelengths . for example , three of the brightest ellipticals in the virgo cluster ( ngc4472 , ngc4636 , and ngc4649 ) recorded under a guaranteed time program ( pid 69 , pi g. fazio ) reach a relatively low sensitivity of 0.5mjy / sr and 1.1mjy / sr ( 1@xmath20 ) at 70 and 160@xmath19 , respectively , while other galaxies ( i.e. pid 20171 , pi p. temi ) have deeper maps at a sensitivity level of only 0.12mjy / sr and 0.3mjy / sr for the same two wavebands . the sings data are recorded in mips scan mode , covering a very large sky area ( @xmath21 ) , incorporating two separated passes at each source location . sings images correspond to maps with intermediate sensitivity . details on the observing strategies , field coverage and integration times for the sings program are described by kennicutt et al . apart from the sings observations , data have been acquired in mips photometry mode , allowing appropriate coverage of the sources and their extended emission . at all wavelengths , sufficiently large field sizes were chosen to reliably measure the background emission . we used the basic calibrated data ( bcd ) products from the spitzer science pipeline ( version 13.2 ) to construct mosaic images for all objects . pipeline reduction and post - bcd processing using the mopex software package ( makovoz et al . 2006 ) provide all necessary steps to process individual frames : dark subtraction , flat - fielding , mux - bleed correction , flux calibration , correction of focal plane geometrical distortion , and cosmic ray rejection . foreground stars and background galaxies were present in the final mosaiced images at all bands . these were identified by eye and cross - checked using surveys at other wavelengths ( digital sky survey and 2mass ) . they were then masked out from each mips image before flux extraction was performed . also , a few asteroids were identified and removed from the affected maps . aperture photometry was performed by measuring fluxes in suitable circular apertures around the centers . flux densities were extracted from apertures extending out to the entire optical disk of each galaxy ( @xmath22 ) . sky subtraction was performed by averaging values from multiple apertures placed around the target , avoiding any overlap with the faint extended emission from the galaxy . uncertainties in flux densities due to sky subtraction are generally less than 1% , but can be of the order of tens of percent for faint sources . the measured flux densities are listed in table 1 . most of the galaxies in the sample have been detected by mips , and among them a large fraction show far - infrared emission well beyond the sensitivity capabilities of previous infrared space observatories . although most of the galaxies presented in this paper are unpublished either because they are our own proprietary data or because the analysis is still in progress by the original pis , results for a few galaxies are already present in the literature ( i.e. the sings galaxies ) . we find that our flux densities are in good agreement with previously published data . the only exception is the measured flux density at 160@xmath1 m reported by dale et al . ( 2005 ) for the sings galaxy ngc584 . very likely this discrepancy is due to a misidentification of the target in their very large 160@xmath1 m scan map . corrections for extended emission were applied to the fluxes as described in the spitzer observer s manual . photometric errors listed in table 1 refer only to the statistical uncertainties . total errors should include systematic uncertainties due to flux calibration and to sky subtraction errors . the uncertainties on the final absolute calibration are estimated at 10% for the 24@xmath1 m data , and 20% at 70 and 160@xmath19 . figure 1 shows gray - scale images of a representative sub - sample of galaxies . the column of panels on the left is the 24@xmath1 m data , while 70 and 160@xmath1 m data are shown in the center and right columns , respectively . galaxies are ordered by ascending ir flux in a common field of view of @xmath23 . some very faint galaxies are shown , including a non detection at 160@xmath1 m and few sources with extended far - infrared emission . detailed images of the diffuse extended emission in ngc4636 and ngc5044 will be presented in a companion paper currently in preparation . in figure 2 we compare fluxes at 24 , 70 and 160@xmath1 m with optical b - band fluxes and a related plot of fir and b - band luminosities is shown in figure 3 . both the 24@xmath1 m and b - band fluxes and luminosities are clearly correlated , @xmath24 and @xmath25 the approximate consistency with unit slope @xmath26 indicates that the emission at 24@xmath1 m , like that at mid - ir wavelengths ( knapp et al . 1989 ; athey et al . 2002 ) , is dominated by circumstellar emission that closely traces optical starlight . however , the huge scatter seen in the 70@xmath1m bband panels in figures 2 and 3 suggest that this colder dust is unassociated with stars and is truly interstellar . the absence of any clear correlation between fir and optical emission from ellipticals has been discussed by forbes ( 1991 ) , goudfrooij & de jong ( 1995 ) , trinchieri & goudfrooij ( 2002 ) and temi et al . ( 2004 ) . in principle cold , fir - emitting dust could either be diffusely distributed in the hot gas or confined to dense central clouds similar to those visible in optical absorption ( e.g. lauer et al . we discuss below our preference for the diffuse component in producing most of the fir - emission . it is remarkable that @xmath3 and @xmath4 range over more than two orders of magnitude for galaxies with similar @xmath2 this is a significant new result that must be explained . in our previous survey of archival data from _ infrared space observatory _ ( iso ) we found a similar spread in fir luminosities at 60 - 200@xmath1 m , but the fir luminosities in the iso data spanned only one order of magnitude for fixed @xmath2 ( temi et al . 2004 ) . at the time we attributed much of this scatter to the unusual nature of the iso sample which contained many ( post - merger ) elliptical galaxies with massive disks of cold , dusty gas . now with this _ spitzer _ sample of ( mostly ) normal elliptical galaxies we find that the range of fir luminosities is even larger , although we show in appendix a that some of the fir - brightest sample galaxies can not be regarded as normal . in figure 4 we show that there is no obvious trend of dust color @xmath27 ( i.e. mean dust temperature ) with @xmath3 except perhaps a tendency for cooler dust in more fir - luminous galaxies . a similar conclusion results if we replace @xmath28 on the horizontal axis with @xmath29 , @xmath3 or @xmath4 . figures 5 and 6 show no discernable correlation of either @xmath6 or @xmath7 with stellar balmer line ages or metallicity . however , @xmath30 may show a slight tendency to decrease with age @xmath31 or increase with metallicity @xmath32.\ ] ] a negative correlation of @xmath30 with age would be expected since the rate of mass loss from evolving stars decreases with stellar age ( piovan et al . 2003 ) , although this expected trend is not supported by our study of elliptical galaxies at mid - ir wavelengths ( temi et al . 2005 ) . it must be noted however that balmer line ages for the same galaxy often show considerable variation when determined by different authors , so the anticorrelation of @xmath30 with age needs further confirmation . a positive correlation of @xmath30 with metallicity in figure 6 is expected if more interstellar grains are produced by mass - losing stars of higher metallicity . however , this is inconsistent with the negative correlation at 70@xmath1 m in figure 6 , @xmath33.\ ] ] no correlations with x - ray luminosity with any of the fir luminosities are visible in figure 7 . decreasing fir luminosities with increasing hot gas density might be expected since interstellar grains are destroyed by sputtering which is proportional to the density of the hot gas . however , the relationship between @xmath16 and gas density is unclear . for example , there is no correlation between @xmath16 and the hot gas density at @xmath34 kpc in the elliptical galaxies observed with _ chandra _ by humphrey et al . this disconnect between gas density and @xmath16 may arise because the hot gas density on kpc - galactic scales is influenced by intermittent energy supplied by the central black holes , while @xmath16 is largely determined by more extensive gas that fills the dark halos that surround the elliptical galaxies ( mathews et al . consequently , the absence of correlations in figure 7 is not surprising . finally , we note that all qualitative features in figure 7 are preserved if luminosities are replaced with fluxes . in figure 8 we compare fir fluxes with optical emission line fluxes determined by three different observers : goudfrooij et al . ( 1994a , b ) , macchetto et al . ( 1996 ) and sarzi et al . the optical observations require difficult background subtraction and the procedures used vary among the observers . for this reason , we compare fir fluxes in figure 8 with each set of optical emission line fluxes independently . we believe that both @xmath35 and @xmath36 correlate weakly with observed optical line fluxes , but that @xmath37 does not . the recent sauron data for @xmath38 ( sarzi et al . 2006 ) show the tightest relationship . the goudfrooij et al . data ( left column of panels in figure 8) are marginally correlated , but the significance increases if it is combined with the macchetto et al . data ( shown in the central column ) . in figure 9 we compare the fluxes in the optical emission lines with b - band fluxes , using only data for non - peculiar e or e / s0 galaxies , excluding peculiar and known s0 galaxies . the top and bottom panels from macchetto et al . ( 1996 ) and sarzi et al . ( 2006 ) show that the line flux is weakly correlated with the stellar continuum ( see also phillips et al . 1986 ; macchetto et al . 1996 ; goudfrooij 1999 ) . a correlation between extended line emission and the optical continuum suggests that the warm gas with @xmath39 k has a stellar origin . but the quality of these difficult optical observations is poor . there are very few objects in common among the goudfrooij , macchetto and sarzi data sets , but the flux - flux plots of these common galaxies show large scatter with almost no clear monotonic relationship . five of the six galaxies in common between goudfrooij and macchetto correlate _ negatively _ in a flux - flux plot . the correlation in figure 9 , if real , may simply indicate that the warm gas and the dust associated with it both have a stellar origin more stars of a similar age and metallicity eject more gas . however , the optical emission line flux depends sensitively on the density of the warm gas and therefore on the pressure in the local hot interstellar gas . at present there are too few accurate observations to interpret figure 9 with confidence . all ellipticals in our sample show evidence of extended emission at 24@xmath1 m similar to that of the optical stellar images details of this will be discussed in a separate publication . however , spatial extension is also evident at 70@xmath1 m as shown in table 1 , but the emission at 160@xmath1 m is not spatially resolved due to decreasing resolution at larger wavelengths . figure 10 shows the surface brightness at 70@xmath1 m for eight galaxies together with the point response function ( prf ) for the mips detector ( including the first airy ring ) . all contours in figure 10 are arbitrarily normalized to 50 at the center . the ( logarithmic ) extension in arseconds beyond the prf is best measured at 0.08 of the central fluxes , shown with arrows in figure 10 . the full width at 4/50 = 0.08 maximum ( subsequently referred to as fw0.1 m ; last two columns in table 1 ) of the prf is 37@xmath40 . twelve galaxies in our full sample have fw0.1 m greater than 40@xmath40 , indicating that these galaxies are spatially resolved at 70@xmath1 m . when fw0.1m/2@xmath41 is plotted against @xmath27 , there is no clear evidence that galaxies with more extended @xmath28 have colder dust . if @xmath50 be the number of grains @xmath51 with radius between @xmath48 and @xmath52 at galactic radius @xmath53 at time @xmath54 , the grain population evolves according to @xmath55 = s(r , a),\ ] ] where @xmath56 is the rate at which grains with radii @xmath48 are expelled from stars per @xmath57 ( tsai & mathews 1995 ) . we assume @xmath58 for @xmath59 , with @xmath60 ( mathis et al . 1977 ) , so the coefficient @xmath61 depends on the rate that the old stellar population ejects mass @xmath62 s@xmath14 ( mathews , 1989 ) , the stellar density @xmath63 , the initial dust to gas mass ratio scaled to the stellar metal abundance in solar units @xmath64 , and the density of ( amorphous ) silicate grains , @xmath65 gm @xmath51 . the solution of eq . ( 7 ) is @xmath66 the grain temperature @xmath67 is determined by the balance of heating ( by both absorption of stellar radiation and by electron - grain collisions ) and radiative cooling : @xmath68 @xmath69 in view of the high electron - grain collision frequency , we neglect stochastic heating due to single impacts . we assume that all grains have properties similar to astronomical silicates ( laor & draine 1993 ) using the following approximations for the absorption coefficient @xmath70 , and for the planck - averaged values @xmath71 ( see draine & lee 1984 ) . the mean intensity of starlight is found by integrating over a de vaucouleurs stellar profile using the appropriate effective radius @xmath41 and stellar luminosity for each galaxy . the collisional heating term in the equation above includes a correction @xmath72 for small grains that do not completely stop the incident thermal electrons ( dwek 1986 ) and @xmath73 is an average over a maxwellian distribution . the electron density and temperature of the hot gas are calculated using deconvoluted profiles from x - ray observations . the fir emissivity at each wavelength is calculated from @xmath74 @xmath75 in figure 11 we compare the expected fir spectral energy distribution for three galaxies in our sample that have well - known hot gas density and temperature profiles from x - ray observations : ngc 1399 , 1404 and 4472 . none of these galaxies are spatially resolved at 70@xmath1 m . the x - ray data for these galaxies has been taken from the following sources : ngc 1404 & 1399 : ( paolillo et al 2002 ; jones et al . 1997 ) ; ngc 4472 : ( mathews & brighenti 2003 ; brighenti & mathews 1997 ) . the profiles in figure 11 show the expected fir spectral energy distributions computed with the equations above . the solid and dashed lines correspond respectively to emission from grains with original maximum sizes @xmath76 m and 1.0@xmath1 m . the observed fluxes for ngc 1399 and ngc 4472 at 70@xmath1 m and 160@xmath1 m are in excellent agreement with our simple model . the fit to ngc 1404 is also satisfactory , given the many assumptions in our model . while the flux at 24@xmath1 m is also shown in figure 11 , this circumstellar emission is not included in our model , but it supports our assumption that much of the diffuse interstellar dust in these three galaxies has a stellar origin . it is of particular interest to determine fir spectral energy distributions for galaxies that have accurate interstellar gas density and temperature profiles and are also spatially resolved at 70@xmath1 m . seven galaxies in table 1 have fw0.1 m greater than 50@xmath40 but only six of these are in the ellis and osullivan ( 2006 ) list of x - ray galaxies detected with rosat : ngc 2768 , 2974 , 4125 , 4636 , 4696 , and 5044 . of these six galaxies , only three ngc 4636 , 4696 and 5044 have x - ray luminosities ( @xmath77 ) large enough for an accurate determination of the gas density and temperature profiles . however , the optically peculiar elliptical ngc 4696 is the central galaxy in the centaurus cluster with powerful fri - type radio emission , a large mass of dusty neutral gas and highly disturbed hot cluster gas ( fabian et al . 2006 ) . in view of these complexities , ngc 4696 is an inappropriate galaxy to learn about the nature of fir emission from normal elliptical galaxies . we find that the observed fluxes for the two remaining fir - extended galaxies ngc 5044 and ngc 4636 are very much larger than predicted by our steady state model for the fir spectral energy distribution . we believe that the dust in these galaxies has an entirely different origin . the large and extended fir emission from ngc 5044 and ngc 4636 , which is related to the enormous range of fir luminosities in figure 3 , will be discussed in a separate forthcoming publication . the first important conclusion to be drawn from figures 2 and 3 is that warm circumstellar dust and colder interstellar dust behave very differently . the relatively small scatter in @xmath37 in figure 2 is slightly larger than our estimated observational errors . nevertheless , we have been unable to find correlations between stellar age or metallicity and the residuals in @xmath37 from the mean correlation . we conclude that the warm dust emitting at 24@xmath1 m is largely circumstellar and this is confirmed by the similarity of optical and 24@xmath1 m surface brightness profiles which will be discussed in detail elsewhere . the second and most remarkable result in figures 2 and 3 is that the emission from colder dust at 70 and 160@xmath1 m varies by a huge factor relative to that at 24@xmath1 m and optical wavelengths . in the previous section and in figure 11 we show that 70 and 160@xmath1 m fluxes from three galaxies having well - observed interstellar gas density profiles can be fit reasonably well with our simple dust heating model without varying any of the dust parameters from those we assumed at the outset . however , notice that all three galaxies in figure 11 that agree with our model sed ngc 1399 , 1404 and 4472 have values of @xmath3 and @xmath4 in table 2 that lie near the bottom of the observed distributions in figure 3 . we think it is impossible to explain the huge dispersion of @xmath3 and @xmath4 in figure 3 by simply varying the dust parameters in the sed models used for the three galaxies in figure 11 , i.e. , the stellar mass loss rate , dust composition , dust size distribution , etc . are unlikely to be in error by an order of magnitude or more . our sed model clearly fails to fit most of the fir observations . some of the large spread of @xmath3 and @xmath4 in figure 3 can be understood because our sample includes very fir - luminous elliptical galaxies that contain abnormal masses of interstellar dust and cold gas , probably acquired by a recent merger . in appendix a we review relevant observations of 12 sample galaxies having the highest 70@xmath1 m luminosities in order of descending @xmath3 . we conclude from this limited information that most ellipticals with the largest @xmath3 and @xmath4 in figure 3 can not be regarded as typical or normal . of the 12 galaxies in appendix a , we regard the following 8 as either likely s0s ( which often have extended , rotationally supported , star - forming disks of cold dusty gas ) or having massive hi or molecular lanes or disks probably acquired by mergers : ic 3370 , ngc 5018 , 2974 , 4125 , 5322 , 2768 , 3962 , and 5077 . these atypical or mis - classified elliptical galaxies are the brightest galaxies in our sample . however , we regard the following galaxies in appendix a with slightly lower @xmath3 as normal or quasi - normal ellipticals : ngc 3557 , 5044 , 4589 , and ( possibly ) 4697 . if we disregard the eight galaxies with atypical dust content , the range in @xmath3 and @xmath4 occupied by normal ellipticals is reduced from @xmath5 ( shown in figure 3 ) to about @xmath79 , but this is still larger than can be explained by varying dust parameters in our sed model . these normal ellipticals with excess fir are the most interesting galaxies in our sample . we assume that galaxies with @xmath78 significantly above that predicted by our model seds in figure 11 have dust contents that exceed those that can be understood by a steady state balance between dust creation by mass - losing stars and dust destruction by sputtering . galaxies in figure 3 with @xmath80 must contain additional cold dust from another source . this additional cold dust is either ( 1 ) spread diffusely throughout a large region of the galactic hot interstellar gas or ( 2 ) located in dense optically thick clouds similar to those seen in absorption by optical observers . in appendix b we describe a simple argument that supports the first option above , diffuse fir emission . we suppose in appendix b that the fir - emitting dust is in a small spherical cloud of radius @xmath81 located at the center of an elliptical galaxy . the dust is heated both by internal stars and by starlight incident from the entire galaxy . the dust cloud is assumed to be optically thick to most stellar radiation . as the cloud radius @xmath81 is increased , the estimated 70@xmath1 m luminosity also increases because the cloud encloses more stars and intercepts more light from external stars . however , this simple dusty cloud model can not account for the luminosity range in figure 3 unless @xmath81 is so large ( @xmath82 pc ) that it would be easily apparent in moderate resolution optical images . the uv - ionized surfaces of these clouds may also be visible . while agn heating within optically thick dusty clouds could easily provide the needed fir energy , this seems unlikely since agns would need to be bolometrically brighter than the stars within @xmath81 and would therefore be seen in those ellipticals in which the dusty clouds are in disks or not present at all . such luminous agn would almost certainly be visible at other frequencies . comparisons of the most fir - luminous ( normal ) ellipticals in our sample with recent hst images ( e.g. van dokkum & franx 1995 ; lauer et al . 2005 ) , show a correspondence between the absence of nuclear dust and low @xmath78 . for example , of the 19 galaxies in common between our sample and that of lauer et al . ( 2005 ) , all 11 of the ellipticals with @xmath83 erg s@xmath14 have detectable nuclear dust , while all but one of the 9 galaxies with @xmath84 have no nuclear dust detected . nevertheless , even for these galaxies with lower @xmath3 we believe that most of the @xmath78 comes from a diffuse component . in addition to the argument in appendix b , our preference for extended excess dust is supported by noting that all six galaxies with extended fir emission in table 1 ( e.g. fw0.1 m @xmath85 ) have excess fir emission , i.e. @xmath83 erg s@xmath14 . if the fir emission in excess of that expected from our simple model sed in figure 11 is from cold dust diffusely distributed throughout the hot interstellar gas , where has it come from ? it is often supposed that optically - observed dust in elliptical galaxies has an external origin , resulting from a recent merger with a small dust - rich galaxy that is otherwise difficult to observe . we adopted this explanation previously in our discussion of the excess dust in ngc 4636 ( temi , et al . 2003 ) , which we interpreted as a dusty merger that occurred within the last @xmath86 yrs , the estimated sputtering time in the hot gas in this galaxy . however , it has since been determined that the mean stellar age in ngc 4636 is very old ( 10.3 gyrs , sanchez - blazquez et al . 2006 ) , and this strongly argues against a merger @xmath86 yrs ago with a dusty , star - forming galaxy . moreover , we observe that the additional dust in ngc 4636 is extended ( fw0.1 m = 54.4@xmath40 in table 1 ) and appears to be distributed rather evenly about the center unlike the irregular distribution that might be expected to result from a recent merger undergoing dynamical friction with accompanying ram - stripping and tidal disruption . so our previous interpretation of ngc 4636 needs to be reevaluated . the dust sputtering time for grains of initial radius @xmath48 in the hot gas of an elliptical galaxy is @xmath87 yrs ( where @xmath88 is in microns ) provided the ambient gas temperature is @xmath89 k. ( draine & salpeter 1979 ; tsai & mathews 1995 ) . even if the dust is mixed with warm gas at @xmath8 k , where sputtering is negligible , its overall sputtering destruction time @xmath90 can not be significantly reduced since , as discussed below , we generally expect that the warm gas is thermally heated and joins the ( spatially extended ) hot gas phase on a time scale @xmath43 yrs that is very much less than @xmath90 . therefore it is reasonable to assume that the diffuse fir - emitting dust in our sample galaxies is in direct contact with the hot gas during most of its sputtering lifetime . the dynamical ( freefall ) time of a merging dusty galaxy across the optical image of a large elliptical is several @xmath9 years , comparable to @xmath90 . therefore , on the merger hypothesis , diffusely distributed cold dust must be resupplied by mergers in a regular fashion at least every @xmath9 yrs . therefore , an entourage of dusty merging galaxies should be commonly observed in the outer regions of the majority of elliptical galaxies having fir excess emission but they are not . in fact , mergers between elliptical and ( small ) dust rich galaxies are rarely observed at zero redshift . while we believe that mergers do occur and that some of the most fir luminous galaxies in our sample can only be explained by mergers , the similarity of the sputtering and dynamical time scales makes it difficult to accept the proposition that mergers are the dominant or only source of ( extended ) dust in most luminous elliptical galaxies . this point of view is supported by figure 5 , showing that the incidence of young stars in elliptical galaxies is uncorrelated with the fir excess luminosities seen in figure 3 . before exploring the origin of the additional dust required to produce fir luminosities in excess of @xmath91 erg s@xmath14 , it is useful to review the evolution of cold dusty gas that is introduced into the hot , x - ray emitting interstellar gas by mass - losing red giant stars . our sed model is based on an internal stellar source of dust which is confirmed by mid - ir observations of ( apparently outflowing ) circumstellar dust ( knapp et al . 1989 ; athey et al . 2002 ; bressan et al . 2006 ; bregman et al . we think that the fate of this dusty gas varies with galactic radius . throughout most of the volume occupied by galactic stars beyond @xmath92 kpc , we assume that both the dust and gas ejected from red giant stars ultimately merge with the hot gas which is the dominant interstellar phase . we expect that gas recently ejected from stars can be maintained in pressure equilibrium at warm temperatures ( @xmath93 k ) by photoionization by uv emitted by post - agb stars . emission from warm gas at @xmath94 kpc is faint and has not been observed . eventually this warm gas thermally mixes with nearby hot gas . when the dust in this gas confronts the hot gas it will be destroyed by sputtering in @xmath9 yrs . however , within @xmath101 kpc of the centers of elliptical galaxies the evolution of dusty stellar ejecta is different . extended warm gas in this region is commonly observed , but its velocities differ from those of nearby stars ( e.g. caon , macchetto & pastoriza 2000 ) . evidently the hot and warm gas exchanged momentum when the warm gas had a much lower density . after dusty stellar envelopes and winds are ejected from orbiting red giant stars , the gas expands until its density approaches ( but still exceeds ) the local hot gas density . at this time the ejected gas , which is still moving with the stellar orbital velocity , is disrupted by hydrodynamic instabilities and shocked to a few million degrees where its density is comparable to that of the hot interstellar gas . during this period of interaction between the stellar ejecta and the hot gas , momentum is exchanged and the ejected gas acquires some of the velocity of the ambient hot gas . even if the gas ejected from stars is ( transiently ) heated completely to the temperature of the local hot gas ( @xmath95 k ) , its dust content will cool the gas rapidly back to @xmath96 where it is stabilzed by uv from post - agb stars . this rapid dust - assisted cooling occurs because of very frequent inelastic collisions between thermal electrons in the hot gas and the dust grains . mathews & brighenti ( 2003 ) showed that efficient dust cooling of the hot gas is also faster than the sputtering lifetime of the dust , so the gas retains some dust after it cools to @xmath97 k. since the cooling time to @xmath97 k within 1 kpc is less than the dynamical time in the local ( stellar ) potential , these dense warm clouds freefall toward the galactic center and accumulate there . as dusty warm gas collects into a disk near the center , similar to those observed by van dokkum & franx ( 1995 ) and lauer et al . ( 2005 ) , it eventually becomes optically thick to the stellar uv radiation . because of its residual dust , we expect molecular formation and eventual cooling far below @xmath44 k. dense , cold nuclear dust disks and clouds similar to those observed can form naturally from stellar mass loss in elliptical galaxy cores ( mathews & brighenti 2003 ) . dusty galaxy mergers are not required . we speculate below that this central dust reservoir may be the source of extended diffuse fir emission in many ellipticals . central dusty clouds and disks in ellipticals are not merely an amusing curiosity , but are likely to be key to understanding the energetics of agn feedback in regulating cooling flows in the hot gas within and around elliptical galaxies . indeed , simoes lopes et al . ( 2006 ) find a correlation between nuclear dust and agn activity in elliptical galaxies . consider the black hole accretion luminosity expected in a large group - centered elliptical galaxy by dusty mass loss just within the central kpc where rapid dust - assisted cooling is expected . accretion is expected to quickly follow cooling . the agn luminosity is @xmath98 ( \epsilon / 0.1)$ ] erg yr@xmath14 where @xmath99 is the total rate of stellar mass loss within the central kpc . since a @xmath100 year old stellar population of mass @xmath101 ejects @xmath102 @xmath103 yr@xmath14 , the stellar mass within 1 kpc , @xmath104 @xmath103 , generates @xmath105 @xmath103 yr@xmath14 . when accreted by the central massive black hole , this translates into a luminosity @xmath106 ergs s@xmath14 that exceeds the entire x - ray luminosity of the most luminous galaxy groups , @xmath107 ergs s@xmath14 . consequently , dusty stellar mass loss within the central kpc of bright ellipticals can generate enough accretion energy to balance the entire bolometric x - ray luminosity of a large galaxy group . the heating of the hot gas as a consequence of this accretion also provides enough energy to drive buoyant mass circulation in the hot gas out to 5 - 10 kpc . the evolution of dusty disks in galactic cores that we just described can not continue very long . if small core disks accrete dusty gas at @xmath105 @xmath103 yr@xmath14 , for @xmath108 yrs , and allowing for a larger mass - loss rate in the past , currently observed disks should have a typical mass of @xmath108 @xmath103 and a dust mass of @xmath109 , both far in excess of those observed . ( small stellar disks with masses @xmath110 @xmath103 are not commonly observed in the cores of most ellipticals , so normal star - formation is ruled out . ) a large minority of bright ellipticals show no evidence of central dusty disks / clouds . where has this dusty gas gone ? the excess diffuse dust observed in fir - emission may have been exploded out from the centers of elliptical galaxies by the release of agn energy . we estimate from our model sed that the total mass of excess dust required to explain the fir luminosities in figure 3 is @xmath111 @xmath103 . this is comparable to the estimated dust masses in the central dusty disks or lanes ( e.g. goudfrooij & de jong 1995 ) . if the ( very uncertain ) dust to gas mass ratio is @xmath112 , then the mass of gas that initially contained this dust is @xmath113 @xmath103 . if cold dusty gas is ballistically ejected from the core out to a few kpc , velocities of @xmath114 km s@xmath14 are required . the kinetic energy needed to explosively transport dusty gas from the galactic core to @xmath115 kpc is @xmath116 ergs . although very uncertain , the energy involved is certainly larger than that of a single supernova . since multiple starburst activity in elliptical galaxies is very rare , agn energy is required for dust ejection from the core . if the agn dust ejection process is intermittent , this would explain those elliptical galaxies that are not observed to have optically obscuring dust in their cores or extended fir excess emission . the fir variance expected from intermittent agn outbursts obviates the argument of forbes ( 1991 ) and simoes lopes et al . ( 2006 ) that the failure of an @xmath78-@xmath2 correlation necessarily requires an external source of dust by mergers . some explosive character to the agn - dust cloud interaction is implied by the chaotic nature of the central dust observed in many hst images ( lauer et al . this chaotic , denser dusty gas is highly transient and must have been ejected from the core . these chaotic clouds can not be understood as infalling stellar ejecta ( as suggested by lauer et al . ) , formed by the coalescence of many dusty stellar envelopes produced by individual stars , since the free fall time ( @xmath43 yrs ) to the galaxy center is too short for such accumulations to occur . however , explosive ejections of central dust to @xmath117 kpc with energies @xmath118 ergs would produce kpc - sized central cavities , strong shocks and heated cores that are rarely observed in x - ray images while extended excess fir emission is common . this may be the best argument against explosive dust transport . density irregularities and multi - temperature x - ray spectra of the hot interstellar gas in elliptical galaxies reveal buoyant activity , presumably related to a less explosive heating of the hot gas with agn energy ( buote , lewis , brighenti & mathews 2003a , b ) . in view of these x - ray observations , it is plausible that central dust can be buoyantly transported out to @xmath119 kpc , producing the extended fir emission that we observe . the buoyant rise time @xmath120 of heated gas is expected to be comparable to or somewhat less than the sputtering destruction time in the buoyant gas . for example in the galaxy / group ngc 5044 the freefall time from radius @xmath121 to the galactic center is @xmath122 yrs , based on a mass model that combines a de vaucouleurs stellar profile ( @xmath123 , @xmath103 ; @xmath124 kpc ) with an navarro - frenk - white dark halo ( mass @xmath125 @xmath103 ; concentration @xmath126 ) . the buoyancy rise time @xmath127 is greater than @xmath128 by some factor @xmath129 . > from draine & salpeter ( 1979 ) the approximate grain sputtering time is @xmath130 where @xmath88 is the grain radius in microns . adopting @xmath131 @xmath51 for the observed hot gas density in ngc 5044 within 30 kpc , the local sputtering time is nearly proportional to @xmath128 , @xmath132 . however , the buoyant gas will have a density that is @xmath133 times lower than the observed hot gas density . therefore , we see that the ratio of the local sputtering time in the buoyant gas to the buoyancy rise time is @xmath134 , which may well exceed unity considering the many uncertainties involved . the exact nature of the agn energy release that initiates buoyant activity is unclear at present . in about half of the ellipticals with optically visible dust , the images of the obscuring dust are morphologically `` chaotic '' and distributed in an asymmetric fashion away from the center of the galaxy ( lauer et al . 2005 ) . evidently the agn energy is sufficient to disrupt the dense central dusty disks and lanes which must reform again later by local stellar mass loss . it is interesting that the radii of the dusty disks observed by lauer et al . ( 2005 ) do not correlate with the stellar rotation , also suggesting short disk lifetimes and intermittent disruption of the dusty disks . regardless of the mode of outward dust transport , explosive or buoyant , when the dust rises to 5 - 10 kpc it may cause the hot gas to cool back to warm gas temperatures @xmath97 k. the correlations in figure 8 between @xmath28 and @xmath29 and the optical line fluxes , if real , indicate a connection between the warm gas and ( excess ) dust . similar morphologies of gas and dust images have been discussed by optical observers ( e.g. goudfrooij et al . although optical line fluxes appear to correlate with the fir and b - band fluxes , figure 2 shows that the fir and b - band fluxes do not mutually correlate . this can be understood if most of the fir - emitting dust comes not from recent stellar mass loss , but is transported out from a reservoir in the galactic core , which contains a large mass of dust unrelated to the the global stellar b - band flux or luminosity . our main conclusions are : .1 in ( 1 ) the optical luminosities @xmath2 of elliptical galaxies correlate with luminosities at 24@xmath1 m ( @xmath135 ) but not with @xmath3 or @xmath4 . this indicates that the transition between circumstellar and interstellar dust occurs for dust grains with emission that peaks somewhere between 24@xmath1 and 70@xmath1 m . .1 in ( 2 ) elliptical galaxies with similar @xmath2 have @xmath3 and @xmath4 that vary over a factor @xmath5 . this variation is reduced to @xmath79 if abnormally dust - rich ellipticals are excluded from the sample . .1 in ( 3 ) neither @xmath6 nor @xmath7 correlates with the stellar age or metallicity of the galaxies . .1 in ( 4 ) weak correlations appear between optical line emission fluxes from warm ( @xmath97 k ) gas and @xmath28 and @xmath29 . this suggests a relationship between dust and gas that may have cooled from the hot phase . .1 in ( 5 ) seven galaxies in our sample are clearly extended at 70@xmath1 with fw0.1 m exceeding 50@xmath40 corresponding to 510 kpc . .1 in ( 6 ) the luminosities and spectral energy distributions of elliptical galaxies with the lowest @xmath3 and @xmath4 are consistent with a simple steady state dust model in which dust expelled from stars is eroded by sputtering in the hot interstellar gas . .1 in ( 7 ) we show in appendix b that the observed emission at 70 and 160@xmath1 m can not come from small optically visible clouds in the galactic cores similar to those seen in hst images . .1 in ( 8) in view of the common occurrance of spatially extended emission at 70@xmath1 m in many ellipticals , it is unlikely that this dust can be supplied by successive mergers with gas - rich galaxies , each occurring during the relatively short sputtering lifetime of the diffuse dust , @xmath9 yrs . addiiontal supporting evidence for such mergers is lacking . .1 in ( 9 ) the appearance of extended fir - emitting dust in otherwise normal elliptical galaxies can be understood by the disruption and buoyant transport of centrally accumulated dust by intermittent agn activity . the buoyant rise time out to 5 - 10 kpc , @xmath136 yrs , is less than the sputtering lifetime of the dust , @xmath9 yrs . this work is based on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under nasa contract 1407 . support for this work was provided by nasa through spitzer guest observer grant rsa 1276023 . studies of the evolution of hot gas in elliptical galaxies at uc santa cruz are supported by nasa grants nag 5 - 8409 & atp02 - 0122 - 0079 and nsf grant ast-0098351 for which we are very grateful . we thank justin harker for his help with the photometric properties of old stellar populations . athey , a. , bregman , j. n. , bergman , j. d. , temi , p. & sauvage , m. 2002 , apj , 571 , 272 barnes , j. e. & hernquist , l. 1992 , ara&a , 30 , 705 bell , e. f. et al . 2004 , apj , 608 , 752 bertola , f. , buson , l. m. & zeilinger , w. w. 1992 , apj , 410 , l79 birkinshaw , m. & davies , r. l. 1985 , apj , 291 , 32 bregman , j. n. , temi , p. & bregman , j. d. 2006 , 647 , 265 bressan , g. et al . 2006 , apj , 639 , 55 brighenti , f. & mathews , w. g. 1997 , apj , 486 , l83 buote , d. a. , lewis , a. d. , brighenti , f. & mathews , w. g. 2003a , apj , 594 , 741 buote , d. a. , lewis , a. d. , brighenti , f. & mathews , w. g. 2003b , apj , 595 , 151 buson , l. m. et al . 1993 , a&a , 280 , 409 caon , n. , macchetto , d. & pastoriza , m. 2000 , apjs 127 , 39 carollo , c. m. & danziger , i. j. 1994 , mnrs , 270 , 743 carollo , c. m. , franx , m. , illingworth , g. d. , forbes , d. a. 1997 , apj , 481 , 710 dale d. a. et al . 2005 , apj , 633 , 857 denicolo . 2005 , mnras , 358 , 813 draine , b. t. & salpeter , e. e. 1979 , apj , 231 , 77 draine , b. t. & lee , h. m. 1984 , apj , 285 , 89 dwek , e. 1986 , apj , 302 , 363 emsellem , e. et al . 2004 , mnras , 352 , 721 ellis , s. c. & osullivan , e. 2006 , mnras , 367 , 627 faber , s. m. 2006 , apj ( submitted ) ( astro - ph/0506044 ) fabian a. c. , sanders , j. s. , taylor , g. b. & allen , s. w. 2006 , mnras , ( in press ) ( astro - ph/0503154 ) fazio , g. g. et al . 2004 , apjs , 154 , 10 ferrari , f. , et al . 1999 , a&as , 136 , 269 filho , m. e. et al . 2002 , apjs , 142 , 223 forbes , d. a. 1991 , mnras , 249 , 779 fried , j. w. & illingworth , g. d. 1994 , aj , 107 , 992 funes , j. g. et al . 2002 , a&a , 388 , 50 goudfrooij , p. 1994 thesis , university of amsterdam , the netherlands goudfrooij , p. et al . 1994a , a&as , 104 , 179 goudfrooij , p. et al . 1994b , a&as , 105 , 341 goudfrooij , p. & de jong , t. 1995 a&a , 298 , 784 goudfrooij , p. 1999 , in _ star formation in early - type galaxies _ eds . j. cepa & p. carral , asp conf . ser . v. 163 , 55 humphrey , p. et al , 2006 , apj , 646 , 899 jarvis , b. j. 1987 , iau symposium _ structure and dynamics of elliptical galaxies _ , ed . t. de zeeuw , 411 jones , et al . 1997 , apj , 482 , 143 kennicutt , r. c. et al . 2003 , pasp , 115 , 928 kim , d .- w . 1988 , apj , 330 , 684 knapp , g. r. , guhathakurta , p. , kim , d .- w . , & jura , m. a. 1989 , apjs , 70 , 329 koprolin , w. & zeilinger , w. w. 2000 , a&as , 145 , 71 laor , a. & draine , b. t. 1993 , apj , 402 , 441 lauer , t. r. et al . 2005 , aj , 129 , 2138 leonardi , a. j. & worthey , g. 2000 , apj , 534 , 650 macchetto , f. et al . 1996 , a&as , 120 , 463 makovoz , d. roby , t. , khan , i. , booth , h. 2006 , spie , 6274 , 10 mathews , w. g. et al . 2006 , apj , 652 , l17 mathews , w. g. 1989 , aj 97 , 42 mathews , w. g. & brighenti , f. 1999 , apj 526 , 114 mathews , w. g. & brighenti , f. 2003 , apj 599 , 992 mathews , w. g. , brighenti , f. & buote , d. 2004 , apj , 615 , 662 mathis , j. s. , rumpl , w. & nordsieck , k. h. 1977 , apj , 217 , 425 michard , r. 1999 , a&as , 137 , 245 michard , r. 2006 , a&a , 449 , 519 mollenhoff , c. & bender , r. 1989 , a&a , 214 , 61 moellenhoff , c. , hummel , e. & bender , r. 1992 , a&a , 255 , 35 naab , t. , jesseit , r. & burkert , a. 2006 , mnras , 328,461 paolillo et al . 2002 , apj , 565 , 883 paturel , g. , andernach , h. , bottinelli , l. , di nella , h. , et al . , 1997 , a&as , 124 , 109 phillips , m. m. et al . 1986 , aj , 91 , 1062 piovan , l. , tantalo , r. , chiosi , c. , 2003 , a&a , 408 , 559 proctor , r. n. & sansom , a. e. 2002 , mnras , 333 , 517 rampazzo , r. et al . 2005 , a&a , 433 , 497 richter , o .- g . , sackett , p. d. , & sparke , l. s. 1994 , aj , 107 , 99 rieke , g. h. 2004 , apjs , 154 , 25 samurovic , s. & danziger , i. j. 2005 , mnras , 363 , 769 sanchez - blazquez , p. , gorgas , j. , cardiel , n. & gonzalez , j.j . 2006 , a&a , 457 , 809 sandage , a. & tamman , g. a. , 1981 , carnegie inst . of washington , 635 sandage , a. & bedke , j. 1994 , _ the carnegie atlas of galaxies _ , vol 1 sarzi , m. et al . 2006 , mnras , 366 , 1151 shen , s. , et al . 2003 , mnras , 343 , 978 simoes lopes , r. d. , storchi - bergmann , t. , de fatima o. saraiva , m. & martini , p. 2006 , apj ( in press ) ( astro - ph/0610380 ) sofue , y. & wakamatsu , k. i. 2003 , pasj , 45 , 529 tantalo , r. & chiosi , c. 2004 , mnras , 353 , 405 temi , p. , mathews , w. g. , brighenti , f. & bregman , j. d. 2003 , apj , 585 , 121 temi , p. , brighenti , f. , mathews , w. g. & bregman , j. d. 2004 , apjs , 151 , 237 temi , p. , mathews , w. g. & brighenti , f. 2005 , apj , 622 , 235 trinchieri , g. & goudfrooij , p. 2002 , a&a , 386 , 472 tsai , j. c. & mathews , w. g. 1995 , apj , 448 , 84 tsai , j. c. & mathews , w. g. 1996 , apj , 468 , 571 van dokkum , p. g. & franx , m. 1995 , aj , 110 , 2027 verdoes , kleijn , g. a. , & de zeeuw , p. t. 2005 , a&a , 435 , 43 werner , m. w. , et al . 2004 , apjs , 154 , 1 wicklind , t. , combes , f. & henkel , c. 1995 , a&a , 297 , 643 xilouris , e. m. et al . 2004 , a&a , 416 , 41 zeilinger , w. w. et al . 1996 , a&as , 120 , 257 lccrrrrrrrrrr ngc 507 & temi & -3.3 & & @xmath137 & & 71.99 & 77.1 & & & & & + ngc 533 & temi & -4.8 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 68.23 & 47.5 & & & & & + ngc 584 & kennicutt & -4.6&[email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath139 & 23.76 & 27.4 & & & & & + ngc 596 & surace & -4.3&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 23.87 & 30.0 & & & & & + ngc 636 & surace & -4.8&[email protected] & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & 22.28 & 18.9 & & & & & + ngc 720 & temi & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath142 & 22.29 & 39.5 & & & & & + ngc 855 & kennicutt & -4.6&[email protected] & 1335@xmath13836 & 2086@xmath13846 & 9.33 & 18.9 & 22.5 & 1.0 & & 58.2 & 7.6 + ngc 1377 & kennicutt & -2.1&1603@xmath13840 & 4988@xmath13871 & 2375@xmath13848 & 22.20 & & & & & & + ngc 1395 & kaneda & -4.8&[email protected] & 129@xmath13811 & 194@xmath13814 & 21.98 & 45.4 & & & & & + ngc 1399 & temi & -4.5&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 19.40 & 42.4 & & & & & + ngc 1404 & kennicutt & -4.7&[email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath143 & 19.40 & 26.7 & & & & & + ngc 1407 & kaneda & -4.5&[email protected] & & @xmath144 & 22.08 & 71.8 & & & & & + ngc 1700 & surace & -4.7&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 38.04 & 13.7 & & & & & + ngc 2325 & temi & -4.7&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 31.92 & 86.5 & & & & & + ngc 2768 & temi & -4.3&[email protected] & 694 @xmath13826 & 377 @xmath13829 & 22.38 & 53.5 & 21.4 & 2.3 & & 56.4 & 6.1 + ngc 2974 & kaneda & -4.7&[email protected]&682 @xmath13818 & 1979@xmath13854 & 30.33 & 36.9 & 22.8 & 3.4 & & 55.4 & 8.1 + ngc 2986 & temi & -4.7&[email protected] & @xmath137 & @xmath145 & 32.51 & 41.4 & & & & & + ngc 3265 & kennicutt & -4.8&287 @xmath13817 & 1952@xmath13844 & 2312@xmath13849 & 21.33 & & & & & & + ngc 3379 & fazio & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 10.71 & 35.2 & & & & & + ngc 3557 & temi & -4.8&[email protected] & 263 @xmath13816 & 247 @xmath13818 & 34.51 & 37.8 & 20.0 & 3.3 & & 38.8 & 6.5 + ngc 3610 & surace & -4.2&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 29.24 & 12.8 & & & & & + ngc 3923 & temi & -4.6&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 19.14 & 53.3 & & & & & + ngc 3962 & kaneda & -4.7&[email protected] & 374 @xmath13818 & 495 @xmath13824 & 23.23 & 34.4 & 22.6 & 2.5 & & 44.0 & 5.0 + ngc 4125 & kennicutt & -4.8&[email protected] & 773 @xmath13828 & 1395@xmath13837 & 27.79 & 59.9 & 21.6 & 2.9 & & 56.8 & 7.7 + ngc 4365 & cote & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 17.06 & 57.2 & & & & & + ngc 4472 & fazio & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 17.06&104.0 & & & & & + ngc 4552 & kennicutt & -4.6&[email protected] & [email protected] & 171 @xmath13816 & 17.06 & 30.0 & & & & & + ngc 4589 & kaneda & -4.8&[email protected] & 262 @xmath13816 & 360 @xmath13821 & 26.30 & 41.4 & 22.6 & 2.9 & & 45.6 & 5.8 + ngc 4621 & cote & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 17.06 & 46.5 & & & & & + ngc 4636 & fazio & -4.8&[email protected] & 188 @xmath13812 & 169 @xmath13814 & 17.06&101.7 & 22.3 & 1.8 & & 54.4 & 4.5 + ngc 4649 & fazio & -4.6&106 @xmath13810 & [email protected] & @xmath146 & 17.06 & 73.6 & & & & & + ngc 4660 & cote & -4.7&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 17.06 & 12.8 & 20.0 & 1.7 & & 39.0 & 3.2 + ngc 4696 & sparks & -3.7&[email protected] & 127 @xmath13813 & 269 @xmath13821 & 39.65&212.4 & 22.6 & 4.4 & & 52.2 & 10.1 + ngc 4697 & surace & -4.8&[email protected] & 589 @xmath13825 & 755 @xmath13828 & 16.22 & 75.3 & & & & & + ngc 4915 & surace & -4.5&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 46.98 & 7.9 & & & & & + ngc 5018 & surace & -4.6&[email protected] & 1119@xmath13834 & 1687@xmath13841 & 32.36 & 24.9 & 20.4 & 3.2 & & 39.6 & 6.21 + ngc 5044 & temi & -4.7&[email protected] & 230@xmath13814 & 242@xmath13818 & 32.36 & 78.6 & 23.1 & 3.6 & & 53.6 & 8.4 + ngc 5077 & fazio & -4.8&[email protected] & 127 @xmath13811 & 141 @xmath13813 & 32.36 & 25.0 & 20.2 & 3.2 & & 49.5 & 7.8 + ngc 5322 & fazio & -4.8&[email protected] & 455 @xmath13823 & 625 @xmath13827 & 29.79 & 35.2 & & & & & + ngc 5557 & surace & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath147 & 49.02 & 28.6 & & & & & + ngc 5813 & fazio & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 30.78 & 48.6 & 19.6 & 2.9 & & 49.8 & 7.4 + ngc 5846 & fazio & -4.7&[email protected] & 102 @xmath13810 & 117 @xmath13812 & 24.55 & 82.6 & 20.4 & 2.4 & & 43.1 & 5.1 + ngc 5982 & surace & -4.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 40.18 & 29.4 & & & & & + ngc 6703 & fazio & -2.8&[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 32.06 & 23.8 & & & & & + ngc 7619 & temi & -4.7 & [email protected] & @xmath148 & @xmath145 & 42.85 & 32.1 & & & & & + ic 3370 & kaneda & -4.7&[email protected] & 649 @xmath13825 & 873 @xmath13830 & 45.90 & 18.5 & 20.5 & 4.5 & & 39.7 & 8.8 + lrrrrrrr ngc 507 & & @xmath149 & & 11.02 & 42.76 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 533 & 41.04 & 41.19 & 40.76 & 10.96 & 42.29 & & + ngc 584 & 40.95 & 40.59 & @xmath150 & 10.42 & @xmath151 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 596 & 40.48 & 40.23 & 39.65 & 10.27 & @xmath150 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 636 & 40.29 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & 10.06 & @xmath154 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 720 & 40.62 & 40.10 & @xmath155 & 10.44 & 40.67 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 855 & 40.38 & 41.27 & 41.00 & 8.95 & @xmath156 & & + ngc 1377 & 42.48 & 42.59 & 41.81 & 9.60 & & & + ngc 1395 & 40.86 & 40.94 & 40.65 & 10.50 & 40.95 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 1399 & 40.87 & 39.92 & 39.64 & 10.58 & 41.69 & & + ngc 1404 & 40.85 & 40.56 & @xmath157 & 10.41 & 41.25 & & + ngc 1407 & 40.83 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & 10.64 & 41.06 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 1700 & 40.95 & 40.77 & 40.44 & 10.55 & 40.66 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 2325 & 40.96 & 40.71 & 40.01 & 10.66 & 40.76 & & + ngc 2768 & 40.88 & 41.68 & 40.95 & 10.63 & 40.44 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 2974 & 41.27 & 41.94 & 41.94 & 10.56 & 40.64 & & + ngc 2986 & 40.68 & @xmath160 & @xmath161 & 10.57 & 41.02 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 3265 & 41.69 & 42.15 & 41.76 & 9.46 & & & + ngc 3379 & 40.39 & 39.98 & 39.51 & 10.12 & @xmath162 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 3557 & 41.08 & 41.64 & 41.15 & 10.82 & 40.64 & & + ngc 3610 & 40.71 & 40.36 & 40.13 & 10.46 & 39.89 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 3923 & 40.71 & 40.06 & 39.88 & 10.58 & 40.72 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 3962 & 40.58 & 41.45 & 41.10 & 10.34 & @xmath163 & & + ngc 4125 & 41.14 & 41.92 & 41.71 & 10.86 & 41.0 & & + ngc 4365 & 40.32 & 40.41 & 39.86 & 10.40 & 40.31 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4472 & 40.85 & 40.37 & 39.92 & 10.96 & 41.49 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4552 & 40.74 & 40.57 & 40.37 & 10.35 & 40.77 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4589 & 40.53 & 41.40 & 41.07 & 10.39 & 40.42 & & + ngc 4621 & 40.52 & 40.11 & 39.78 & 10.38 & 40.08 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4636 & 40.48 & 40.88 & 40.37 & 10.57 & 41.65 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4649 & 41.01 & 40.27 & @xmath164 & 10.79 & 41.34 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4660 & 40.16 & 40.17 & 39.87 & 9.80 & @xmath165 & & + ngc 4696 & 41.07 & 41.44 & 41.30 & 10.99 & 43.23 & & + ngc 4697 & 40.58 & 41.33 & 40.98 & 10.61 & 40.18 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 4915 & 40.92 & 40.95 & 40.76 & 10.34 & @xmath166 & & + ngc 5018 & 41.32 & 42.21 & 41.92 & 10.63 & @xmath167 & & + ngc 5044 & 40.90 & 41.52 & 41.08 & 10.76 & 42.80 & & + ngc 5077 & 41.05 & 41.27 & 40.85 & 10.32 & 40.54 & & + ngc 5322 & 41.08 & 41.75 & 41.42 & 10.73 & 40.27 & & + ngc 5557 & 41.02 & 40.92 & @xmath168 & 10.90 & & & + ngc 5813 & 40.67 & 40.89 & 40.20 & 10.70 & & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 5846 & 40.88 & 40.93 & 40.53 & 10.72 & 41.71 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 5982 & 40.86 & 40.92 & 40.66 & 10.59 & 41.22 & & + ngc 6703 & 40.83 & 40.77 & 39.93 & 10.43 & @xmath169 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ngc 7619 & 40.78 & @xmath170 & @xmath171 & 10.64 & 41.69 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ic 3370 & 41.48 & 42.28 & 41.94 & 10.82 & & & + m ( left column ) , 70 @xmath1 m ( center column ) , and 160 @xmath1 m ( right column ) . galaxies are shown in ascending order from lowest flux density to highest flux density , including a non detection and sources with extended far - infrared emission . the contour levels decrease by factors of 2 from the central peak value . ] 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in 2.in .7 in in this appendix we briefly review other observations of galaxies in figure 3 and table 2 having the most luminous fir emission . our objective is to determine if elliptical galaxies with the most luminous fir emission can be regarded as unusual or abnormal and , if so , what is the maximum fir luminosity of sample galaxies that can be regarded as normal . in the following we emphasize observations that are consistent with large fir emission evidence of large ( @xmath34 kpc ) extended dusty disks , detections of large masses of cold gas or recent star formation , designations as an s0 galaxy which often contain cold , rotationally supported gaseous disks , strong radio emission , galaxies with nearby dusty galaxies or stars that may have contaminated some observations , evidence of a recent merger , etc . but we do not mention attributes that are found in many typical ellipticals : extended optical emission lines perhaps with a liner spectrum , small central ( @xmath172 kpc ) dust clouds that obscure starlight , weak central radio sources , x - ray emission @xmath16 which is highly variable among ellipticals , evidence of old mergers , etc . galaxies are listed in descending order of @xmath3 . .15 in * ic 3370 : * classified as an elliptical in rc2 an rsa , but regarded by jarvis ( 1987 ) and samurovic & danziger ( 2005 ) as an s0 or s0pec with an extremely boxy profile . a bright iras source in fir . richter et al . ( 1994 ) detect an hi mass of @xmath173 @xmath103 . contains a prominent dust lane in the inner regions with associated h@xmath174 + [ nii ] emission and possible evidence of ongoing star formation ( michard 2006 ) . leonardi & worthey ( 2000 ) and tantalo & chiosi ( 2004 ) suggest an intermediate age population for the central regions . .15 in * ngc 5018 : * forms a pair with ngc 5022 7.2@xmath175 away . carollo & danziger ( 1994 ) describe a very strong dust lane that obscures the innermost regions that may contain recent star formation . they also suggest that the galaxy is very flat ( about e6 ) . detected by iras at 60 and 100@xmath1 m . xilouris et al . ( 2004 ) find excess mir emission at 6.7 and 15@xmath1 m , perhaps suggesting heating by recent star formation . .15 in * ngc 2974 : * a rapidly rotating e4 galaxy ( emsellem et al . 2004 ) . strong iras emission . kim et al . ( 1988 ) observes a massive hi disk , @xmath176 @xmath103 ( with @xmath177 mpc ) . sarzi et al . ( 2006 ) observe a nuclear bar with two spiral arms emerging . a bright star is seen in ned images 0.7@xmath175 to sw . .15 in * ngc 4125 : * filho et al . ( 2002 ) regard this as an e6pec galaxy . wickland et al . ( 1995 ) detect tentative molecular hydrogen emission with mass @xmath178 @xmath103 . verdoes kleijn & de zeeuw ( 2005 ) observe a central dust lane of size 160 pc ( d = 26 mpc ) . .15 in * ngc 5322 : * carollo et al . ( 1997 ) describe a completely obscuring dust lane ( perpendicular to the radio jet ) that hides the center of the galaxy . iras detection at 60 and 100@xmath1 m . proctor & sansom ( 2002 ) and denicolo et al . ( 2005 ) find evidence of a @xmath179 gyr old young stellar population . .15 in * ngc 2768 : * referred to as an e6 * in rc3 , this is almost certainly an s0 galaxy ( funes et al . 2002 ) with faint dust patches surrounding the galactic bulge . significant dust extinction is visible along the minor axis ( michard 1999 ) . bertola et al . ( 1992 ) notes that the ionized gas is dynamically decoupled from the stars , which may be related to gas orbiting in a polar ring ( mollenhoff et al . 1992 ; fried & illingworth 1994 ) . wiklind et al . ( 1995 ) observed co emission with an estimated molecular mass of @xmath180 @xmath103 . .15 in * ngc 3557 : * an e3 galaxy containing an fri radio source having a double - tailed radio source with a jet and central knot ( birkinshae & davies 1985 ) . detected by iras at 60 and 100@xmath1 m . rampazzo et al . ( 2005 ) report a possible dust ring near the center and goudfrooij ( 1994b ) finds an unusual optical emission line image associated with the minor axis . .15 in * ngc 5044 : * detected by iras at 60 and 100@xmath1 m . very bright and asymmetrically extended optical emission ( ferrari , et al . 1999 ; goudfrooij et al . 1994a ) . .15 in * ngc 3962 : * the h@xmath174+[nii ] image shows two sub - systems : an elongated ( dusty ) central component strongly misaligned with the stellar isophotes extending to @xmath181 kpc with regular kinematics and a more extended arm - like structure associated with bluer stars ( buson et al . 1993 ; goudfrooij , et al . 1994b ; zeilinger et al . 1996 ) . detected by iras at 60 and 100@xmath1 m . .15 in * ngc 4589 : * prominent dust lane near minor axis extending to 20@xmath40 ( goudfrooij , et al . 1994a , b ) complex gas and stellar kinematics suggest a merger remnant ( mollenhoff & bender 1989 ) . detected by iras at 60 and 100@xmath1 m . .15 in * ngc 4697 : * an e6 galaxy , but may be an s0 ( koprolin & zeilinger 2000 ) . sofue and wakamatsu ( 2003 ) detect a molecular mass of @xmath182 @xmath103 . .15 in * ngc 5077 : * the e3 designation in rc2 is wrong , this is an s0 galaxy ( sandage & bedke 1994 ) . in this appendix we determine if a large fraction of the fir emission from elliptical galaxies can come from small , dense , dusty clouds near the centers of the galaxy , or , as we have generally assumed , comes from fir - emitting dust diffusely distributed throughout the inner galaxy . specifically , can reprocessed starlight from internal and external stars heat small dusty regions sufficiently to account for the large fir luminosities shown in figure 3 ? we describe a simple calculation to estimate the maximum luminosity at 70@xmath1 m @xmath3 expected from a small optically thick dust cloud , including dust heating by both internal and external starlight . consider a spherical cloud of dusty cold gas with radius @xmath81 placed at the center of an elliptical galaxy having a de vaucouleurs luminosity profile . since the stellar density is greatest at the center , placing the cloud there maximizes the energy from internal starlight that can be absorbed and reemitted at infrared wavelengths . the mean intensity of starlight in an ( optically thin ) elliptical galaxy also is greatest at the galactic center , where the stellar flux incident on the dusty cloud from the outside is also maximal . without investigating in detail how the dust is heated and reemitted in the infrared from small , dense clouds , we assume that this type of reprocessing can occur . to estimate the fraction of the the fir that appears in the _ spitzer _ 70@xmath1 m pass band , we assume that the overall infrared sed can be approximated with a modified blackbody , with emissivity @xmath183 where @xmath184 depends on the properties of the dust and @xmath67 is the dust temperature . we assume @xmath185 and @xmath186k , the mean values in our sed fits to iso ( _ infrared space observatory _ ) fir data for elliptical galaxies ( temi et al . 2004 ) . the fraction of fir emission that emerges in the _ spitzer _ 70@xmath1 m passband ( width @xmath187 m ) is @xmath188 where @xmath189 . to be specific we consider a typical elliptical in figure 3 with @xmath190 . based on the galaxy - size observations of shen et al . ( 2003 ) , we assume a typical effective radius for this galaxy , @xmath191 kpc . to determine the total b - band luminosity of stars inside the dusty cloud , we integrate the de vaucouleurs profile from the center to radius @xmath81 . to convert the b - band luminosity to bolometric luminosity of an old single stellar population ( ssp ) , we assume solar abundance for the stars , a kroupa imf and an age of @xmath100 yrs , resulting in @xmath192 ( private communication from justin harker ) . with this information we can estimate the total stellar luminosity produced within a dusty cloud of any chosen radius @xmath81 and the fraction of this energy that is observed in the _ spitzer _ 70@xmath1 m passband , @xmath193 . the dusty cloud can also be heated externally by stellar radiation incident on its outer surface . to estimate the flux of stellar radiation incident on the dusty cloud we first determine the mean b - band mean intensity within 10 - 100 parsecs of the galactic center , @xmath194 erg @xmath195 s@xmath14 ster@xmath14 , found by integrating over the de vaucouleurs emissivity profile corresponding to @xmath196 @xmath197 and @xmath191 kpc . the b - band flux on the surface of the cloud is then @xmath198 . the bolometric flux is larger by a factor @xmath199 so the rate that radiative energy from external galactic stars is absorbed by the dusty cloud is @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the assumed albedo . figure b1 shows how the 70@xmath1 m luminosities @xmath3(int ) and @xmath3(ext ) vary with the radius @xmath81 of the dusty cloud where we see that @xmath202 . but the important result is that clouds of size @xmath203 pc are required to produce luminosities @xmath204 erg s@xmath14 typical of those plotted in the central panel of figure 3 . in many of the elliptical galaxies in figure 3 , a @xmath5 parsec dark cloud would be easily visible even without hst resolution . we conclude that it is very unlikely that the large excess fir emission in figure 3 above that predicted by our simple model for recently produced diffuse dust , can be explained by emission from small dense clouds even under the most favorable circumstances . more importantly , the approximation of spherical clouds is seriously in error . the gas temperatures associated with these dusty clouds ( @xmath5k ? ) are much less than the virial temperature of the stars , @xmath205 k required to support a spherical cloud as we hypothesized here . the gas temperature within the dusty cloud is insufficient to provide pressure support against the stellar potential due to embedded stars or the external hot gas pressure . consequently , we expect that most of the nuclear dust clouds observed in ellipticals are highly flattened , nearly two - dimensional pancakes or disks . in this case we imagine that the @xmath3(ext ) luminosities in figure b1 are more relevant , further reducing the predicted @xmath206 m emission . we conclude that most of the fir emission observed at 70@xmath1 m and 160@xmath1 is diffusely distributed , not concentrated in dense clouds similar to those seen in absorption by many optical observers . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: cluster categories were defined in @xcite as tools for categorification of fomin - zelevinsky cluster algebras @xcite . they are defined as the orbit categories of the derived category @xmath0 of hereditary abelian categories @xmath1 by a certain autoequivalence . in the situation where @xmath1 is the category of finite dimensional representations of a finite acyclic quiver , the cluster category has been subject to intense investigation . in this case it has been shown that the cluster category and the set of exceptional objects form a good model for the cluster algebra associated with the same quiver . in this paper we work with a cluster category @xmath2 defined from a different hereditary abelian category , namely the tube @xmath3 . this category is called the cluster tube and has recently been studied in @xcite and @xcite . although this category is also a hom - finite triangulated 2-calabi - yau category , it does not admit all of the nice properties of cluster categories from quivers . in particular , the maximal rigid ( also called maximal exceptional ) objects do not satisfy the more restrictive definition of cluster - tilting objects . moreover , the gabriel quivers of the endomorphism rings of maximal rigid objects in the cluster tube have loops . consequently , @xmath2 with its maximal rigid objects does not carry a cluster structure in the sense of @xcite . the axioms for cluster structures can be modified , however , to apply also to cluster tubes , see @xcite . the aim of the present paper is to study the endomorphism rings of the maximal rigid objects . we will find a description in terms of quivers with relations . like cluster - tilted algebras , the algebras we consider here are gorenstein of gorenstein dimension 1 , unless @xmath4 , in which case they are self - injective . however , the proof ( from @xcite ) for cluster - tilted algebras has no analogy in our setting . instead , we use the fact that our algebras are gentle , and apply the technique from @xcite to our quivers with relations in order to prove the result . the properties of the algebras we study in this paper are thus reminiscent of those of the algebras recently studied in @xcite . since the endomorphism rings are gentle , they are string algebras . we use the theory of string- and band - modules to show that the endomorphism rings are of finite type . one of the main results about cluster - tilted algebras , which was proved in @xcite , is the close connection between the module category of the cluster - tilted algebra and the cluster category it arises from . this connection is provided by the hom - functor . in our situation , the hom - functor is not full , and therefore there is no analogous theorem . we will nevertheless study the action of the hom - functor on the objects , and in particular show that it is dense . indeed , when @xmath5 is maximal rigid , we find an explicit description of @xmath6 for every indecomposable @xmath7 in @xmath2 . the paper is organised as follows : section [ sec : objects ] contains the definition of the cluster tube and a description of maximal rigid objects recalled from @xcite . in section [ sec : endoring ] we give the description of the endomorphism rings , before we in section [ sec : gentle ] study the gentleness and gorenstein dimension and give some facts about indecomposable representations . finally , in section [ sec : homfunctor ] we describe the action of the hom - functor . throughout the paper we will work over some field @xmath8 , which is assumed to be algebraically closed . modules over an algebra will always mean left modules , and we will read paths in quivers from right to left . we start off by reviewing some properties of cluster tubes . these categories have recently been studied in @xcite and @xcite , and more details can be found in these papers . for any integer @xmath9 , let @xmath3 be a tube of rank @xmath10 , that is , the category of nilpotent representations of a cyclically oriented @xmath11-quiver . it can also be realised as the thick subcategory generated by a tube in the regular component in the ar - quiver of a suitable tame hereditary algebra . all maps in this category are linear combinations of finite compositions of irreducible maps , and are subject to mesh relations in the ar - quiver . @xmath3 is a hereditary abelian category , and following the construction introduced in @xcite , we form its cluster category , called the _ cluster tube of rank @xmath10 _ and denoted @xmath2 . this is by definition the orbit category obtained from the bounded derived category @xmath12 by the action of the self - equivalence @xmath13 $ ] . here , @xmath14 $ ] denotes the suspension functor of @xmath15 , while @xmath16 is the auslander - reiten translation . unless the actual value of @xmath10 is important , we will usually suppress the subscript @xmath10 in the notation , and write @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 . for a finite - dimensional hereditary algebra @xmath20 , a theorem due to keller @xcite guarantees that the associated cluster category @xmath21 is triangulated with a canonical triangulated structure inherited from the derived category . keller s result is not directly applicable in our situation , since @xmath17 has no tilting objects . nevertheless , @xmath2 also inherits a triangulated structure from @xmath15 , see @xcite for a rigorous treatment of this . the indecomposable objects of the cluster tube @xmath19 are in bijection with the indecomposables in @xmath17 itself , and we will sometimes use the same symbol to denote both an object in the tube @xmath17 and its image in the cluster tube @xmath19 . the irreducible maps in @xmath19 are the images of the irreducible maps in @xmath18 , which again are the shifts of the irreducible maps in the tube @xmath17 . so the ar - quiver of @xmath19 is isomorphic to the ar - quiver of @xmath17 . for a given rank @xmath10 , we will use a coordinate system on the indecomposable objects . choose once and for all a quasisimple object and give it coordinates @xmath22 . now give the other quasisimples coordinates @xmath23 such that @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is reduced modulo the rank @xmath10 . then give the remaining indecomposables coordinates @xmath26 in such a way that there are irreducible morphisms @xmath27 for @xmath28 and @xmath29 for @xmath30 . throughout , the first coordinates will be reduced modulo @xmath10 . see figure [ figure : coordinates ] . and @xmath2.,width=453 ] the infinite sequence of irreducible maps @xmath31 is called a _ ray_. similarly , the infinite sequence @xmath32 is called a _ coray_. note that the sum of the coordinates is constant , modulo @xmath10 , for indecomposables located on the same coray . for an indecomposable object @xmath33 where @xmath34 we will also need the notion of the _ wing _ @xmath35 determined by @xmath7 . this is by definition the set of indecomposables whose position in the tube is in the triangle with @xmath7 on top . @xmath7 will be called the _ summit _ of @xmath35 . in terms of coordinates , the objects in the wing @xmath36 are @xmath37 such that @xmath38 and @xmath39 . the _ height _ of @xmath35 is the quasi - length @xmath40 . the dimensions of the hom - spaces in @xmath19 are given by the following lemma , proved in @xcite . [ lem : homspaces ] for @xmath7 and @xmath41 indecomposable in @xmath19 , we have @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the usual @xmath8-vector space duality @xmath44 . when @xmath7 and @xmath41 are indecomposable , the maps in @xmath45 which are images of maps in @xmath46)$ ] for @xmath47 in @xmath17 will be called @xmath18-maps , and those which are images of maps in @xmath17 itself will be called @xmath17-maps . since @xmath17 is hereditary , all maps in @xmath19 are linear combinations of maps of these two kinds . the hom - hammock of an indecomposable object ( that is , the support of @xmath48 ) is illustrated in figure [ figure : homhammock ] . note that the two components in the figure wrap around the tube and intersect . moreover , if @xmath49 , then each component intersects itself , possibly with several layers , and therefore there exist hom - spaces of arbitrary finite dimension between indecomposables . . there are @xmath17-maps to the indecomposables in the right component , and @xmath18-maps to the indecomposables in the left component.,width=340 ] so for indecomposable @xmath7 and @xmath41 , the existence of a @xmath18-map @xmath50 is equivalent to the existence of a @xmath17-map @xmath51 . the following lemma is then easily verified : [ lem : dendo ] let @xmath7 be an indecomposable object of @xmath2 . then there exists a @xmath18-endomorphism of @xmath7 if and only if @xmath52 . we will need the following lemma on the relationship between @xmath17-maps and @xmath18-maps : [ lem : rayfactoring ] for @xmath7 , @xmath41 and @xmath53 indecomposable objects in @xmath2 , we have the following : * assume that @xmath54 and @xmath55 . if there are non - zero @xmath18-maps @xmath56 and @xmath57 , and an irreducible map @xmath58 , then @xmath59 up to multiplication by a non - zero scalar . * assume that @xmath54 . if there are non - zero @xmath18-maps @xmath60 and @xmath56 , and an irreducible map @xmath61 , then @xmath62 , up to multiplication by a non - zero scalar . [ rem : rayfactoring ] note that by repeated application , the same applies to compositions of irreducible maps , i. e. to all @xmath17-maps , under the assumption that the required hom - spaces are non - zero for each indecomposable that the composition factors through . * ( i ) : * we lift the maps to the derived category @xmath18 , and denote by @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 the preimages of the objects in @xmath17 . since @xmath7 and @xmath41 have quasilength @xmath66 , we have that the space @xmath67)$ ] of @xmath18-maps is at most one - dimensional for any indecomposable @xmath68 , and similarly for @xmath41 . the aim is to show that the map @xmath69 ) : \hom_{\d}(\hat{y},\tau^{-1}\hat{z}[1 ] ) \to \hom_{\d}(\hat{x},\tau^{-1}\hat{z}[1])\ ] ] is surjective . we can view this as a map @xmath70 or , by duality and the ar - formula , @xmath71 which we now wish to show is injective . but this is clear from the structure of the tube when the hom - spaces are non - zero . * ( ii ) : * we need to show that the map @xmath72 ) : \hom_{\d}(\hat{x},\tau^{-1}\hat{y}[1])\to \hom_{\d}(\hat{x},\tau^{-1}\hat{z}[1])\ ] ] is surjective . similarly as above , by duality this is equivalent to the map @xmath73 being injective . but by the combinatorics of the tube , this is clearly an isomorphism , since by assumption both spaces are 1-dimensional . let @xmath74 , and choose some indecomposable @xmath7 in @xmath3 with quasilength @xmath75 . let @xmath76 be a linearly oriented quiver with underlying graph the dynkin diagram @xmath77 . then the category @xmath78 of finitely generated modules over the path algebra @xmath79 is naturally equivalent with the subcategory @xmath80 of @xmath3 . embedding to @xmath15 and projecting to @xmath2 we find that @xmath78 embeds into the subcategory @xmath81 of @xmath2 . the image is the subcategory @xmath82 obtained by deleting the @xmath18-maps from @xmath83 . from now on , we will drop the subscript when we speak of an additive hull as a set of objects , since there is a bijection between the objects of @xmath17 and those of @xmath19 . the triangulated category @xmath19 is a 2-calabi - yau category , which in particular means that for any two objects @xmath7 and @xmath41 , we have symmetric ext - spaces : @xmath84 two indecomposable objects @xmath7 and @xmath41 will be called _ compatible _ if @xmath85 . it is worth noticing that @xmath7 and @xmath41 are compatible if and only if @xmath86 . in an abelian or triangulated category @xmath87 , an object @xmath5 is called _ rigid _ if it satisfies @xmath88 . if it is maximal with respect to this property , that is if @xmath89 implies that @xmath90 , then it is called _ maximal rigid_. the maximal rigid objects in the cluster tube @xmath19 do not satisfy the stronger condition of _ cluster tilting _ , see @xcite . the following description of the maximal rigid objects was given in @xcite : [ prop : tiltedbijection ] there is a natural bijection between the set of maximal rigid objects in @xmath2 and the set @xmath91 where @xmath92 is a linearly oriented quiver with the dynkin diagram @xmath93 as its underlying graph . the proposition follows from the following considerations , which will be needed for the rest of the paper : all summands of a maximal rigid object in @xmath2 are concentrated in the wing @xmath94 determined by a _ top summand _ @xmath95 with @xmath96 . now the claim follows from the embedding of @xmath97 into @xmath98 , since it is easily seen that @xmath99 for two indecomposables @xmath7 and @xmath41 in @xmath94 vanishes if and only if both @xmath100 and @xmath101 vanish , where @xmath102 and @xmath103 are the corresponding @xmath104-modules . since there are @xmath10 choices for the top summand , this provides the bijection . with the description of the maximal rigid objects of @xmath19 presented in section [ sec : objects ] , we now proceed to determine their endomorphism rings in terms of quivers and relations . let @xmath5 be a maximal rigid object in the cluster tube @xmath2 , and let @xmath105 denote the tilting @xmath104-module associated with @xmath5 according to proposition [ prop : tiltedbijection ] . since the module category of a hereditary algebra @xmath20 sits naturally embedded in the cluster category @xmath21 , we can think of the module @xmath105 as a cluster - tilting object in @xmath106 . the endomorphism ring , or cluster - tilted algebra , @xmath107 can easily be found from the tilted algebra @xmath108 , by the results in @xcite , or more generally in @xcite . every minimal relation on the quiver of a tilted algebra of type @xmath109 is a zero relation of length two . the quiver of the cluster - tilted algebra is then obtained by inserting an arrow @xmath110 from the end vertex to the start vertex of each defining relation path @xmath111 . the relations for the cluster - tilted algebra are , as prescribed by @xcite , the compositions of any two arrows in any of the 3-cycles formed by adding the new arrows . we can now formulate the main theorem of this section . [ theorem : endoring ] let @xmath5 be a maximal rigid object in @xmath2 . then the endomorphism ring @xmath112 is isomorphic to the algebra @xmath113 where * @xmath114 is the quiver obtained from the quiver of @xmath115 by adjoining a loop @xmath116 to the vertex corresponding to the projective - injective @xmath104-module . * @xmath117 is the ideal generated by the relations in @xmath115 and in addition @xmath118 . before we can present the proof of the theorem , we need some considerations on the combinatorial structure of the maximal rigid objects , so we postpone the proof until we have established a few lemmas . we define a _ non - degenerate subwing triple _ @xmath119 to be a triple @xmath120 of indecomposables in @xmath19 with @xmath121 such that if @xmath122 , then @xmath123 and @xmath124 for some @xmath125 . this means that @xmath7 is on the ray @xmath126 and on the coray @xmath127 , so in particular @xmath128 and @xmath129 are contained in @xmath35 . moreover , there is exactly one quasisimple @xmath130 which is in @xmath35 but not in @xmath131 . see figure [ figure : subwingtriple ] . a _ degenerate subwing triple _ @xmath119 is a triple with @xmath132 such that if @xmath122 , then either @xmath133 and @xmath134 or @xmath135 and @xmath136 . note that any subwing triple ( degenerate or non - degenerate ) is determined by the top indecomposable @xmath7 and the unique quasisimple which is not in any of the two subwings @xmath128 or @xmath129 . . if @xmath122 and @xmath123 with @xmath137 , then @xmath124.,width=377 ] [ lem : subwingmaps ] let @xmath119 be a non - degenerate subwing triple . let @xmath138 and @xmath139 . * there are no @xmath17-maps @xmath140 . * there are no @xmath17-maps @xmath141 . * there is a @xmath18-map @xmath140 if and only if @xmath142 is on the left edge of @xmath129 and @xmath143 is on the right edge of @xmath129 . in this case , this map factors through the @xmath18-map @xmath144 . * there is a @xmath18-map @xmath141 if and only if @xmath142 is on the right edge of @xmath129 and @xmath143 is on the left edge of @xmath128 , and @xmath145 . in this case , this map factors through the @xmath18-endomorphism of @xmath7 . claims ( i ) and ( ii ) are easily verified ; one must keep in mind that @xmath146 by the definition of subwing triples . since the existence of a @xmath18-map @xmath140 is equivalent to the existence of a @xmath17-map @xmath147 , we see that the only way such a map can arise is when @xmath142 is on the left edge of @xmath129 , and @xmath143 is on the right edge of @xmath128 . now by lemma [ lem : rayfactoring ] and remark [ rem : rayfactoring ] , this @xmath18-map factors through the ray @xmath148 . in particular , it factors @xmath149 where @xmath150 is the @xmath17-map from @xmath142 to @xmath53 , and @xmath151 is the unique ( up to multiplication with scalars ) @xmath18-map @xmath152 . applying lemma [ lem : rayfactoring ] to @xmath151 , we find that it factors @xmath153 , where @xmath154 is the @xmath18-map from @xmath53 to @xmath41 and @xmath155 is the @xmath17-map from @xmath41 to @xmath143 . so claim ( iii ) holds . for claim ( iv ) , observe that since @xmath156 , a necessary condition for the existence of a @xmath17-map @xmath157 is that @xmath158 . moreover , we have that @xmath142 must be on the right edge of @xmath35 and @xmath143 must be on the left edge of @xmath35 . now the claim is proved using a similar argument as for ( iii ) and the fact from lemma [ lem : dendo ] that if @xmath145 then @xmath7 has a @xmath18-endomorphism . [ lem : subwingext ] let @xmath119 be a subwing triple , and let @xmath159 . * @xmath41 and @xmath160 are compatible if and only if @xmath161 or @xmath162 . * @xmath53 and @xmath160 are compatible if and only if @xmath161 or @xmath163 . by the 2-calabi - yau property , we have symmetric ext - groups , so it is enough to check vanishing of @xmath164 and @xmath165 . for this , we use the ar - formula @xmath166 and similarly for @xmath53 . then consider the intersection of the hom - hammock of @xmath41 with @xmath167 . [ lem : maxcompatible ] let @xmath168 be a wing in @xmath2 of height @xmath169 , and let @xmath170 be a set of pairwise compatible indecomposable objects in @xmath171 . * @xmath170 has at most @xmath172 elements . * if @xmath170 has less than @xmath172 elements , there exists a set @xmath173 of @xmath172 pairwise compatible indecomposable objects , containing @xmath170 . * if @xmath170 has @xmath172 elements , then @xmath7 is an element of @xmath170 . the argument is essentially the same as for proposition [ prop : tiltedbijection ] , and the result follows from the theory of tilting modules applied to @xmath79-modules , noting that the projective - injective indecomposable is a summand of every tilting module . [ lem : subwingstructure ] let @xmath174 be some indecomposable summand of a maximal rigid object @xmath175 in @xmath2 . * there are @xmath176 indecomposable summands of @xmath5 in @xmath177 . * assume @xmath178 . then there is a subwing triple @xmath179 such that @xmath180 and @xmath181 are either summands of @xmath5 or zero , and all summands of @xmath182 which are in @xmath177 are in @xmath183 , with @xmath184 summands in @xmath185 and @xmath186 summands in @xmath187 . given a rank @xmath10 , we let @xmath188 be a maximal rigid object in @xmath2 . we proceed by reverse induction on the quasilength of the summands of @xmath5 . ( that is , from summands of larger quasilength to summands of smaller quasilength . ) this is ok , since there is a ( unique ) summand of maximal quasilength . in accordance with proposition [ prop : tiltedbijection ] , consider the top summand @xmath95 of @xmath5 , which has quasilength @xmath189 . without loss of generality assume that this has coordinates @xmath190 . the claim ( i ) holds for @xmath95 by the proof of proposition [ prop : tiltedbijection ] . assume first that there are no summands of @xmath5 among the objects @xmath191 , where @xmath192 . then all @xmath193 summands of @xmath194 are in @xmath195 . so by lemma [ lem : maxcompatible ] , the object @xmath196 must be a summand of @xmath5 . hence in this situation claim ( ii ) also holds , with the triple @xmath197 . a similar argument shows that none of the objects @xmath198 , where @xmath199 , are summands if and only if @xmath200 is a summand , and thus ( ii ) holds with @xmath201 . suppose therefore that @xmath200 is not a summand , and that there is at least one summand of @xmath5 with coordinates @xmath191 , where @xmath202 . let @xmath203 be the one of these with highest quasi - length ( that is , maximal @xmath204 ) . consider the subwing triple @xmath205 where @xmath206 . by lemma [ lem : subwingext ] and the maximality of @xmath207 , all @xmath193 summands of @xmath194 must be in @xmath208 . then it follows from lemma [ lem : maxcompatible ] that there must be @xmath207 summands in @xmath94 and @xmath209 summands in @xmath35 and moreover that @xmath7 is indeed a summand of @xmath5 . we conclude that both claims ( i ) and ( ii ) hold for the top summand . assume now that @xmath174 is some summand of @xmath5 with @xmath178 , but not the top summand . let @xmath210 be a summand of @xmath5 of smallest quasilength with @xmath211 such that @xmath212 . ( such a summand exists , since all summands are in @xmath94 . ) then by induction , the claims hold for @xmath213 , and by the minimality in the choice of @xmath213 , the subwing triple corresponding to @xmath213 is @xmath214 where either @xmath215 or @xmath216 is @xmath174 , and the other one is also a summand . in any case , since by the induction hypothesis claim ( ii ) holds for @xmath213 , there are @xmath176 summands of @xmath5 in @xmath177 , and so ( i ) holds for @xmath174 . now that we know that there are @xmath217 summands of @xmath182 in @xmath177 , we can prove that ( ii ) holds by the same arguments as for @xmath95 above . a subwing triple @xmath179 such that @xmath218 and @xmath181 are summands of a maximal rigid object @xmath5 will be called a @xmath5-_subwing triple_. with lemma [ lem : subwingstructure ] we have obtained a combinatorial description of the maximal rigid objects as a system of subwing triples partially ordered by inclusion . note that for a maximal rigid @xmath5 with top summand @xmath95 there is a natural map from the objects in @xmath94 to the summands of @xmath5 given by sending an object @xmath7 to the summand @xmath219 with smallest quasilength such that @xmath220 . the restriction of this map to the set of quasisimples is a bijection . see figure [ fig : example ] a ) for an example . also , we have the following : [ lem : subwingintersection ] let @xmath221 be summands of a maximal rigid @xmath5 . then either @xmath222 , or @xmath223 , or @xmath224 and @xmath225 have empty intersection . suppose @xmath226 and @xmath227 . let @xmath174 be a summand of @xmath5 such that both @xmath228 and @xmath229 , and which has minimal quasilength among summands with this property . there is some non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath179 , and by lemma [ lem : subwingstructure ] , the summands @xmath230 and @xmath213 must be in @xmath183 . now by the minimality in the choice of @xmath174 , we know that @xmath230 must be in @xmath185 and @xmath213 in @xmath187 or vice versa . it follows that @xmath224 and @xmath225 have zero intersection , since @xmath185 and @xmath187 have empty intersection . [ lem : tmapsonrays ] let @xmath230 and @xmath213 be summands of a maximal rigid @xmath5 . then the following are equivalent . * there exists a non - zero @xmath17-map @xmath231 . * either @xmath213 is on the ray @xmath232 or @xmath230 is on the coray @xmath233 . this follows from the observation that since @xmath230 and @xmath213 are ext - orthogonal , there is no map @xmath234 . [ lem : tsubwingtmaps ] let @xmath5 be a maximal rigid object . * if @xmath235 is a non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple , there is a @xmath17-map @xmath236 and a @xmath17-map @xmath237 , and these maps are irreducible in @xmath238 . * if @xmath239 a degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple , there is a @xmath17-map @xmath236 , and this is irreducible in @xmath240 . a similar statement holds for a degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath241 . * there are no other irreducible @xmath17-maps in @xmath238 than those described in ( i ) and ( ii ) . * if @xmath235 is non - degenerate , the composition @xmath242 is zero . claims ( i ) and ( ii ) are obvious , so consider summands @xmath243 and assume that there is a @xmath17-map @xmath244 . by lemma [ lem : tmapsonrays ] , either the summand @xmath245 must be on the ray @xmath246 or @xmath219 must be on the coray @xmath247 . assume the former case , so @xmath219 is on the left edge of @xmath248 . we know from lemma [ lem : subwingstructure ] that there is some @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath249 , where @xmath219 must necessarily be on the left edge of @xmath250 . ( if it was on the right , it would violate lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] . ) then clearly @xmath251 factors through the @xmath17-map @xmath252 . a similar argument can be given in the case where @xmath219 is on the coray @xmath247 by considering a @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath253 , so ( iii ) holds as well . the claim ( iv ) also follows from lemma [ lem : tmapsonrays ] . [ lem : tsubwingdmaps ] let @xmath221 be summands of a maximal rigid @xmath5 . then the following are equivalent . * there is a non - zero @xmath18-map @xmath254 . * one of the following is satisfied * * there is some non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath255 such that @xmath230 is on the left edge of @xmath250 and @xmath213 is on the right edge of @xmath248 . * * @xmath230 is on the left edge of @xmath94 and @xmath213 is on the right edge of @xmath94 , where @xmath95 is the top summand . assume first that @xmath256 , the top summand . then there is a @xmath18-map @xmath257 if and only if @xmath213 is on the right edge of @xmath94 , which is a special case of b ) . similarly , if @xmath258 , then there is a @xmath18-map @xmath254 if and only if @xmath230 is on the left edge of @xmath94 . so under the assumption that at least one of @xmath221 is the top summand , the claim holds . consider therefore the case where neither @xmath230 nor @xmath213 is the top summand . it is easily seen that if @xmath223 or @xmath259 , there can be no @xmath18-map @xmath254 . so consider the summand @xmath219 of minimal quasilength such that both @xmath230 and @xmath213 are in @xmath260 . by lemma [ lem : subwingstructure ] there is a @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath255 , and by the minimality of @xmath219 , either @xmath261 and @xmath262 or the other way around . the claim now follows from lemma [ lem : subwingmaps ] . we can now prove the main theorem . in the argument , we will implicitly use the fact that for indecomposable objects @xmath7 and @xmath41 with @xmath263 , there is up to multiplication by scalars at most one @xmath17-map and one @xmath18-map from @xmath7 to @xmath41 . our task is to determine the quiver @xmath114 and defining relations of @xmath264 . first recall that the functor @xmath265 induces an equivalence between @xmath238 and the category @xmath266 of projective @xmath267-modules . the vertices in @xmath114 are therefore in bijection with the indecomposable summands of @xmath5 , and the arrows correspond to maps which are irreducible in @xmath238 . no @xmath17-map can factor through a @xmath18-map , so let us first consider the arrows in @xmath114 coming from @xmath17-maps and their relations , that is the endomorphism ring of @xmath5 as an object in the subcategory @xmath268 , where @xmath95 is the top summand of @xmath5 . by virtue of the equivalence of this category with the module category @xmath97 , we know that this will be the quiver with relations for the tilted algebra @xmath269 . by lemma [ lem : tsubwingtmaps ] part ( i ) , for each non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath235 there exist @xmath17-maps @xmath270 and @xmath271 which are irreducible in @xmath238 and hence correspond to arrows @xmath272 and @xmath273 in @xmath114 . similarly , by part ( ii ) , for each degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath239 there is an arrow @xmath272 , and for a @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath241 there is an arrow @xmath273 . moreover , by part ( iii ) of the same lemma , these are the only arrows in @xmath114 coming from @xmath17-maps . assuming that the triple is non - degenerate , by part ( iv ) , the composition @xmath274 is zero , and hence @xmath275 is a zero relation for the quiver . it follows from lemma [ lem : tmapsonrays ] that there are no other minimal relations on the arrows coming from @xmath17-maps , since a path @xmath276 such that no @xmath277 comes from a composition @xmath278 from a non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath279 corresponds to a map following a ray or a coray . so the above gives a description of the tilted algebra @xmath269 . see figure [ fig : example ] b ) for an example . now consider the @xmath18-maps , and postpone for a moment the situation with maps to or from the top summand @xmath95 . by lemma [ lem : subwingmaps ] part ( iii ) , for each non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath235 there is a @xmath18-map @xmath280 . we claim that this map is irreducible in @xmath238 . so assume that there exists a summand @xmath219 , not isomorphic to @xmath174 or @xmath213 , and a @xmath18-map @xmath281 such that @xmath282 where @xmath283 . since the composition of two @xmath18-maps is zero , @xmath284 must be a @xmath17-map . so by lemma [ lem : tmapsonrays ] we either have that @xmath219 is on @xmath285 , or that @xmath174 is on @xmath286 . the former case contradicts lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] , since @xmath174 is on the right side of @xmath224 and on the left side of @xmath260 . the latter case contradicts lemma [ lem : subwingmaps ] , since @xmath219 is on the right edge of @xmath177 . a similar argument shows that we can not have a factorisation @xmath287 where @xmath288 is a @xmath17-map and @xmath289 is a @xmath18-map . thus @xmath290 is irreducible and corresponds to an arrow @xmath291 in @xmath114 . for the non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath235 , the composition @xmath292 is a @xmath18-map . we claim that it must be zero . assume therefore that there is a @xmath17-map from @xmath213 to @xmath293 . then , since @xmath230 sits on @xmath294 and there is no @xmath17-map @xmath295 by the ext - orthogonality of @xmath230 and @xmath213 , there must be @xmath17-maps from @xmath213 to _ all _ indecomposables of quasilength @xmath296 , _ except _ @xmath297 . but this would require @xmath298 , and this is impossible , since @xmath299 . we conclude that there is no @xmath18-map @xmath231 , and the composition is zero . similarly , the composition @xmath300 is also zero , since there is no @xmath17-map from @xmath230 to @xmath301 . it follows that the paths @xmath302 and @xmath303 are zero relations on the quiver @xmath114 . by lemma [ lem : dendo ] , there is a @xmath18-map @xmath304 which is an endomorphism of the top summand @xmath95 . this map must be irreducible in @xmath238 , for the only objects in @xmath94 to which there are maps from @xmath95 are the ones on the right edge of @xmath94 , but there are no maps from any of these to @xmath95 . thus there is a loop @xmath116 on the vertex corresponding to the top summand . the composition @xmath305 is zero , since any composition of two @xmath18-maps is the image of a map @xmath306 $ ] in @xmath18 , which must necessarily be zero since @xmath17 is hereditary . so @xmath118 is a zero relation on the quiver of @xmath267 . by lemmas [ lem : subwingmaps ] and [ lem : tsubwingdmaps ] , there are no other irreducible @xmath18-maps between summands of @xmath5 , and also no other minimal relations involving arrows from @xmath18-maps : let @xmath307 be an arrow corresponding to a @xmath18-map @xmath308 where @xmath235 is a non - degenerate subwing triangle . then if @xmath309 is a path in @xmath114 such that @xmath310 and @xmath311 do not traverse any relations , then necessarily @xmath312 are arrows coming from maps on the left edge of @xmath177 and @xmath313 are arrows coming from the right edge of @xmath225 . then this path corresponds to a non - zero map by lemma [ lem : tsubwingdmaps ] . we now see that the arrows @xmath314 are in bijection with the zero relations for the quiver of @xmath315 , and complete the relation paths to oriented cycles , so by @xcite or @xcite the arrows @xmath316 and @xmath314 form the quiver of @xmath317 . furthermore , the relations imposed on this quiver coincide with the relations defining @xmath115 . so the quiver of @xmath267 is obtained from the quiver of @xmath115 by adjoining the loop @xmath116 at the loop corresponding to the top summand , which again corresponds to the projective - injective @xmath315-module . also , the relations for @xmath267 are the relations for @xmath115 and in addition @xmath318 . see figure [ fig : example ] for an example of a maximal rigid object @xmath5 and the tilted algebra @xmath315 , the cluster - tilted algebra @xmath115 and the endomorphism ring @xmath267 . example of a maximal rigid object @xmath5 and the associated algebras @xmath315 , @xmath115 and @xmath267.,width=529 ] an explicit description of the quivers for cluster - tilted algebras of type @xmath109 was given in @xcite , and also in @xcite . it can be deduced from the type @xmath109 cluster category model from @xcite . they are exactly the quivers satisfying the following : * all non - trivial minimal cycles are oriented and of length 3 * any vertex has valency at most four * if a vertex has valency four , then two of its adjacent arrows belong to one 3-cycle , and the other two belong to another 3-cycle * if a vertex has valency three , then two of its adjacent arrows belong to a 3-cycle , and the third does not belong to any 3-cycle in the first condition , a _ cycle _ means a cycle in the underlying graph . a _ connecting vertex _ for such a quiver , as defined in @xcite , is a vertex which either has valency one , or has valency two and is traversed by a 3-cycle . note that for the endomorphism ring @xmath267 of a maximal rigid @xmath5 , the loop vertex is connecting for the quiver of @xmath115 . there is a sort of converse to theorem [ theorem : endoring ] , so we have the full description of the algebras which can arise : let @xmath319 be a cluster - tilted algebra of type @xmath93 , and let @xmath320 be a connecting vertex for @xmath321 . then there exists a maximal rigid object @xmath5 of @xmath2 such that @xmath322 is obtained from @xmath321 by adjoining a loop at @xmath320 . we do induction on @xmath10 . the claim is easily verified for small values . given a cluster - tilted algebra @xmath319 of type @xmath93 , let @xmath114 be its quiver and let @xmath320 be some connecting vertex of @xmath114 . then @xmath320 has valency 1 or 2 in @xmath114 . consider first the case where @xmath320 has valency 2 . then @xmath320 is traversed by a 3-cycle @xmath323 in @xmath114 . the quiver @xmath324 has two disconnected components @xmath325 and @xmath326 , where @xmath327 is connecting for @xmath328 . also , @xmath328 is the quiver of some cluster - tilted algebra @xmath329 of type @xmath330 , where @xmath331 . by induction we can assume that for each @xmath332 there exists a maximal rigid object @xmath230 in @xmath333 such that the endomorphism ring of @xmath230 is obtained from the quiver of @xmath329 by adjoining a loop at @xmath327 . let @xmath334 be the corresponding tilting @xmath335-module . we have a natural embedding of the module category @xmath336 into the wing @xmath337 , and of @xmath338 into @xmath339 . it is now easily seen that the images of the indecomposable summands of @xmath340 and @xmath341 under these embeddings are all compatible , and that the direct sum of these can be completed to a maximal rigid object @xmath5 by adding the object @xmath190 . then the quiver of @xmath5 is obtained from @xmath114 by adding a loop at @xmath320 . the case where @xmath320 has valency one in @xmath114 is easier ; one considers @xmath342 which is cluster - tilted of type @xmath343 , and uses induction similarly as above . there are in fact exactly @xmath10 maximal rigid objects in @xmath2 with the prescribed endomorphism algebra , and these form a @xmath16-orbit . in this section we show that the endomorphism rings under discussion are gentle . we use this to determine their gorenstein dimension . a finite - dimensional algebra @xmath113 where @xmath114 is a finite quiver is called _ special biserial _ @xcite if * for all vertices @xmath344 in @xmath114 , there are at most two arrows starting in @xmath344 and at most two arrows ending in @xmath344 * for every arrow @xmath345 in @xmath114 , there is at most one arrow @xmath346 in @xmath114 with @xmath347 and at most one arrow @xmath348 with @xmath349 . a special biserial algebra @xmath113 is _ gentle _ @xcite if moreover * @xmath117 is generated by paths of length 2 * for every arrow @xmath345 in @xmath114 there is at most one arrow @xmath350 such that @xmath351 is a path and @xmath352 , and at most one arrow @xmath353 such that @xmath354 is a path and @xmath355 . [ theorem : gentle ] if @xmath5 is a maximal rigid object in the cluster tube @xmath19 , then the endomorphism ring @xmath356 is gentle . it follows from the description of cluster - tilted algebras of type @xmath109 , and theorem [ theorem : endoring ] , that condition ( i ) is satisfied whenever @xmath344 is not the loop vertex . if @xmath344 is the loop vertex , the quiver generally looks locally like this : @xmath357{loopvertex.eps}\ ] ] where the relations are indicated by dashed lines and it may also happen that one of the two other vertices pictured and consequently the adjacent arrows are not there . we see that also for this vertex ( i ) is fulfilled . as proved in @xcite , any cluster - tilted algebra of type @xmath109 is gentle , and therefore if @xmath345 is not an arrow incident with the loop vertex , ( ii ) and ( iv ) are satisfied . if @xmath345 is incident with the loop vertex , ( ii ) and ( iv ) follow from the local description pictured above , with the observation that by the description of the cluster - tilted algebras there are no minimal relations involving both an arrow in the picture and an arrow outside the picture . moreover , by theorem [ theorem : endoring ] , the ideal @xmath117 is generated by paths of length two , so ( iii ) is fulfilled , and the algebra is gentle . it is known from @xcite that all gentle algebras are gorenstein , that is , a gentle algebra @xmath358 has finite injective dimension as both a left and a right @xmath358-module . this dimension is then called the gorenstein dimension of @xmath358 . in order to prove the next result , we need to recall the main result in @xcite in more detail . let @xmath359 be a gentle algebra . an arrow @xmath360 in @xmath114 is said to be _ gentle _ if there is no arrow @xmath361 such that @xmath362 is a non - zero element of @xmath117 . a _ critical path _ in @xmath114 is a path @xmath363 such that @xmath364 for all @xmath365 . [ theorem : gr ] let @xmath359 be a gentle algebra , and let @xmath366 be the supremum of the lengths of critical paths starting with a gentle arrow . ( @xmath366 is taken to be zero if there are no gentle arrows . ) * @xmath366 is bounded by the number of arrows in @xmath114 . * if @xmath367 , then @xmath358 is gorenstein of gorenstein dimension @xmath366 . * if @xmath368 , then @xmath358 is gorenstein of gorenstein dimension at most one . we can use this to find the gorenstein dimension of our algebras : [ prop : gorenstein ] let @xmath5 be a maximal rigid object in @xmath19 . if @xmath4 , the gorenstein dimension of @xmath369 is zero , and if @xmath370 , the gorenstein dimension is one . by theorem [ theorem : gentle ] , the algebra @xmath267 is gentle , and we can apply theorem [ theorem : gr ] . if @xmath4 , then @xmath5 has only one summand , and the endomorphism algebra @xmath267 is isomorphic to the self - injective algebra @xmath371/(x^2)$ ] , so in this case the gorenstein dimension is zero . assume therefore that @xmath370 . the gentle arrows are exactly the arrows which are not traversed by any minimal oriented cycle . ( in particular , the loop is not gentle . ) but if @xmath360 is any such arrow , then @xmath372 is a path for at most one arrow @xmath345 , and @xmath372 can never be a zero relation , since it is not a part of a 3-cycle . so if gentle arrows exist , the maximal length @xmath373 of critical paths starting in gentle arrows is 1 , and therefore the gorenstein dimension of @xmath267 is also 1 . if gentle arrows do not exist , we have @xmath374 , and the gorenstein dimension is at most 1 . it remains to be shown that @xmath267 can not be self - injective for @xmath375 . for this , consider the indecomposable projective associated with the loop vertex . it is easily seen that it is not injective . since @xmath376 is gentle , it is in particular a string algebra . we will use this to show that @xmath267 has finite representation type . for this , we will recall some basic facts about representations of string algebras . more details on this can be found e.g. in @xcite . let @xmath113 be a string algebra . we consider words from the alphabet formed by arrows in @xmath114 and their formal inverses . inverse words are defined in the obvious way . for an inverted arrow @xmath377 we set the end vertex @xmath378 equal to the start vertex @xmath379 of the original arrow and vice versa . a word @xmath380 , where no two consecutive @xmath381 are inverses of each other , is called a _ string _ if @xmath382 for @xmath383 and moreover no subword of @xmath384 or its inverse is a zero relation . in addition , there is a trivial string of length zero for each vertex of @xmath114 . we say that the start- and end vertices of the @xmath381 which appear in the strings are the vertices _ traversed _ by the string . for technical purposes , we also consider a unique zero ( or empty ) string of length @xmath385 . to any string @xmath386 of length @xmath387 in @xmath114 there is an associated indecomposable @xmath388-dimensional representation @xmath389 of @xmath113 given by one - dimensional vector spaces in each vertex traversed by the string ( with multiplicity ) and one - dimensional identity maps for each of the arrows ( and inverted arrows ) appearing in @xmath390 . we have that @xmath391 if and only if @xmath392 or @xmath393 . the @xmath113-modules given by such representations are called _ string modules_. if there exist closed strings @xmath394 ( i.e. strings starting and ending in the same vertex ) such that @xmath395 and powers of the string are strings as well , there will also be infinite families of indecomposables called _ band modules_. the string modules and band modules constitute a complete set of representatives of isoclasses of indecomposable modules over @xmath113 . now some remarks on the strings in the quiver of @xmath267 , which will be useful in the proof of theorem [ thm : finitetype ] and in section [ sec : homfunctor ] . in what follows , an arrow @xmath360 that arises from an irreducible @xmath17-map in @xmath238 will be called a @xmath17-arrow , and similarly an arrow that arises from a @xmath18-map will be called a @xmath18-arrow . since the vertices of the quiver are in a natural bijection with the indecomposable summands of @xmath5 , we will transfer some terminology about the summands to the vertices . so the quasilength of a vertex is the quasilength of the corresponding summand , and vertices ( also arrows , strings ) are said to be in a wing if the corresponding summands are in the wing . [ lem : stringsandcycles ] let @xmath235 be a non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple , and @xmath396 and @xmath307 the corresponding arrows . then * if @xmath397 is a string , then @xmath398 is not of the form @xmath399 . * if @xmath400 is a string , then @xmath401 is not of the form @xmath402 . the analogous statements hold for the inverses of the arrows . the assertions follow from the fact that @xmath302 and @xmath303 are both zero relations . * if @xmath403 is a @xmath18-arrow , and @xmath404 is a string , then @xmath401 is in the wing of @xmath405 and @xmath398 is in the wing of @xmath204 , and similarly for inverses of @xmath18-arrows . * a string in the quiver of @xmath267 contains at most one @xmath18-arrow or inverse of such . * ( i ) : * let @xmath404 be a string , where @xmath403 is a @xmath18-arrow corresponding to a @xmath18-map @xmath406 . suppose first that @xmath407 . then there is a subwing triple @xmath408 . now if the string @xmath401 which starts in @xmath405 is the trivial string for vertex @xmath405 , then there is nothing to show , since @xmath405 is definitely in the wing of itself . assume therefore that @xmath401 has length at least one . then @xmath409 , where @xmath410 is either an arrow starting in @xmath405 or the inverse of an arrow ending in @xmath405 . by lemma [ lem : stringsandcycles ] we know that @xmath410 can not be the arrow @xmath411 which connects @xmath405 to the vertex @xmath8 associated with @xmath174 . now the remaining possibilities for @xmath410 are contained in the wing of @xmath405 . by lemma [ lem : stringsandcycles ] again , it follows that none of the @xmath412 can be @xmath18-arrows ( or inverse @xmath18-arrows ) . so @xmath401 traverses vertices of successively smaller quasilength and can not return to @xmath405 . so @xmath401 is in the wing of @xmath405 . if @xmath413 , then @xmath230 is the top summand and @xmath345 is the loop , in which case the claim follows by the fact that @xmath414 is a zero relation , and a similar argument as above . the statement for @xmath398 and @xmath204 is proved analogously , and also the statements for inverses of @xmath18-arrows . * ( ii ) : * this follows from ( i ) . if @xmath415 and @xmath416 are two @xmath18-arrows , then clearly @xmath417 can not be in the wing of @xmath204 or @xmath405 when at the same time @xmath418 is in the wing of @xmath8 or @xmath419 . so they can not both appear in the same string . the same goes if one ( or both ) of @xmath418 and @xmath417 is the inverse of a @xmath18-arrow . [ rem : closed ] it follows from this lemma that if @xmath390 is a closed string , then either @xmath390 is a trivial string , or @xmath390 contains the loop as the only @xmath18-arrow . [ lem : stringsubwing ] in the following , we consider strings only up to orientation . * the strings of length @xmath420 in the quiver of @xmath267 which do not contain a @xmath18-arrow or inverse of such are in bijection with sequences @xmath421 such that there are subwing triples @xmath422 or @xmath423 for @xmath424 . * the strings in the quiver of @xmath267 that do not contain a @xmath18-arrow or inverse of such are in bijection with pairs @xmath221 of summands of @xmath5 such that @xmath259 . * ( i ) : * let @xmath390 be a string without a @xmath18-arrow or inverse @xmath18-arrow . if @xmath390 is trivial , the claim is obviously true , so assume @xmath390 has length @xmath425 . choose @xmath426 to be an indecomposable summand of @xmath5 which corresponds to a vertex @xmath427 traversed by @xmath390 such that no of the other vertices traversed by @xmath390 have higher quasilength . assume @xmath428 . then there is some @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath429 . let @xmath430 and @xmath431 be the corresponding arrows . now since there are no @xmath18-arrows , and @xmath427 has maximal quasilength among the vertices traversed by @xmath390 , the string @xmath390 must be of the form @xmath432 where @xmath398 , if it is non - trivial , is of the form @xmath433 or @xmath434 , and similarly @xmath435 or @xmath436 if it is non - trivial . so for @xmath437 to be a string , one of these has to be the trivial string associated with @xmath427 , since the composition @xmath438 is zero . so @xmath427 is the start- or end vertex of @xmath390 , and the first arrow ( or inverse arrow ) connects @xmath427 to one of the vertices from the @xmath5-subwing triple with @xmath427 on top . by repeating the process with the string @xmath439 or @xmath440 , we get the desired chain of subwing triples . * ( ii ) : * follows directly from ( i ) . see figure [ fig : stringexample ] for an example of strings in the quiver of @xmath267 . , where @xmath441 is the only @xmath18-arrow , starts in the vertex corresponding to @xmath219 and ends in the vertex corresponding to @xmath245 . note how a path like @xmath442 ( or its inverse ) can not be in a string , since it is a zero relation . also , the path @xmath443 is not a string , while both @xmath444 and @xmath445 are.,width=415 ] [ thm : finitetype ] for a maximal rigid object @xmath5 in @xmath2 , the endomorphism ring @xmath267 is of finite type , and the number of indecomposable representations is @xmath446 let @xmath114 be the quiver of @xmath267 and @xmath117 the relation ideal . moreover , let @xmath419 denote the loop vertex , and @xmath116 the loop itself . for a string @xmath390 we will denote the associated indecomposable representation by @xmath389 . first consider strings which do not involve the loop . these are in bijection with ordered pairs of vertices : for each pair @xmath447 from @xmath448 , let @xmath221 be the associated summands of @xmath5 . if @xmath259 or vice versa , there is , as in lemma [ lem : stringsubwing ] , a string without a @xmath18-arrow connecting @xmath204 and @xmath405 . so suppose this is not the case . consider the ( unique ) summand @xmath174 which is of minimal quasilength such that @xmath230 and @xmath213 are both in @xmath177 . then there is some @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath449 where @xmath450 and @xmath451 or the other way around . now use lemma [ lem : stringsubwing ] again to find strings connecting @xmath204 with the vertex @xmath452 associated with @xmath453 and @xmath405 with the vertex @xmath454 associated with @xmath455 . now there is a @xmath18-arrow @xmath456 . connecting the two string by way of @xmath457 yields the desired string , and we can choose the orientation , so this is up to ordered pairs of vertices . in particular , by remark [ rem : closed ] , any non - loop string starting and ending in the same vertex is a trivial string . denote by @xmath458 the unique non - loop string starting in @xmath204 and ending in @xmath405 , so @xmath459 . for the corresponding indecomposable representations we have isomorphisms @xmath460 . the simple representations are the @xmath461 . the total number of representations corresponding to non - loop strings is therefore @xmath462 where the first term is the number of simple representations and the second is the number of strings of length @xmath425 up to orientation . now for the strings passing through the loop . for each pair @xmath447 of vertices , there are two strings from @xmath204 to @xmath405 passing through the loop @xmath116 : @xmath463 and these are all possible loop strings . we see that @xmath464 , so @xmath465 for any choice of @xmath447 , in particular for @xmath466 . we deduce that the indecomposable representations associated with loop strings are in bijection with ordered pairs of vertices , and the number of such representations is @xmath467 . these are all the strings there are . since ( by remark [ rem : closed ] and lemma [ lem : stringsubwing ] ) the only closed strings are either trivial , @xmath116 or of the form @xmath468 for some arrow ( or inverse arrow ) @xmath360 and some string @xmath390 , it follows that there are no band modules . so the string modules we have presented form a complete set of isomorphism classes of @xmath267-modules . summarising , we find that the total number of representations is @xmath469 for a cluster - tilted algebra @xmath470 arising from the cluster category @xmath21 of some hereditary algebra @xmath20 , there is a close connection between the module category of @xmath471 and the cluster category itself . the main theorem from @xcite says that the functor @xmath472 induces an equivalence @xmath473 in particular , the cluster - tilted algebra is of finite representation type if and only if @xmath21 has finitely many objects ( which again happens if and only if @xmath20 is of finite type ) . by theorem [ thm : finitetype ] , a similar result can not hold for the cluster tubes . the analogous argument fails because the hom - functor is not full . in this section , we will study some properties of this functor . we introduce some notation . for any indecomposable object @xmath7 in @xmath19 , let @xmath474 be the hom - hammock of @xmath7 , where @xmath475 is the set of indecomposables to which @xmath7 has @xmath17-maps , and similarly for @xmath476 . also , consider the _ reverse hom - hammock _ @xmath477 , that is , the support of @xmath478 among the indecomposables . like the ordinary hom - hammock , this has a natural structure as the union of two components , one denoted by @xmath479 containing the indecomposables that have non - zero @xmath17-maps to @xmath7 , and another one denoted by @xmath480 containing those that have @xmath18-maps to @xmath7 . note that by the description of the hom - hammocks , @xmath481 and @xmath482 . so the shape of @xmath483 is similar to the shape of @xmath484 ( figure [ figure : homhammock ] ) . for the remainder of this chapter , @xmath485 will be a maximal rigid object in @xmath2 , and we assume that the top summand of @xmath5 is @xmath486 . clearly , by redefining the coordinates we can use the results for all maximal rigid objects of @xmath19 . as in the preceeding sections , we will denote by @xmath267 the endomorphism ring @xmath376 . we define @xmath487 to be a certain set of indecomposable objects in @xmath19 : @xmath488 see figure [ fig : fundamentaldomain ] . the region @xmath487 in the tube consists of the rigid part and in addition a triangle of height @xmath189 in the non - rigid part . ( we have defined wings only for rigid indecomposables , but we can think of @xmath487 as the wing of the object @xmath489 . ) in @xmath490 , below the dashed curve . @xmath5 is concentrated in the indicated wing.,width=264 ] the following claims are easily verified : [ lem : onecomponent ] if @xmath7 is an indecomposable in @xmath94 , then @xmath491 forms one rectangle - shaped subgraph of the tube , and similarly for @xmath492 . [ lem : revhammquasi ] let @xmath493 be either @xmath17 or @xmath18 . then for an indecomposable @xmath7 , the set @xmath494 contains a unique quasisimple @xmath495 , and a necessary condition for an object @xmath41 to be in @xmath494 is that @xmath496 . [ lem : t1inr(x ) ] let @xmath497 . then @xmath498 if and only if @xmath499 . we now want to assign to each indecomposable in @xmath487 a uniquely defined string in the quiver of @xmath267 . in the main result of this section we will show that the images under the hom - functor are given by these strings . the first step is to encode information about @xmath17-maps and @xmath18-maps in separate strings , which will be joined to one string at a later stage . [ lem : revhamm ] let @xmath493 be either @xmath17 or @xmath18 . for @xmath497 we have the following . * @xmath500 is empty if and only if @xmath501 . * for any @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath235 , at most one of @xmath213 and @xmath174 can be in @xmath494 . * if @xmath502 is non - empty , there is a unique string in the quiver of @xmath267 traversing each of the vertices corresponding to the indecomposables in @xmath502 exactly once ( and no other vertex ) and ending in the vertex corresponding to the summand in @xmath502 of highest quasilength . * a string of the type in part ( iii ) contains no @xmath18-arrow ( or inverse of such ) . * ( i ) : * we need to show that @xmath503 if and only if @xmath504 . if @xmath501 , then there are no non - zero maps from @xmath5 to @xmath7 since @xmath5 is rigid . for the converse , assume that the intersection is empty . using lemma [ lem : t1inr(x ) ] , we get that @xmath156 . moreover , we have that @xmath505 since @xmath506 , the object @xmath7 , and consequently @xmath507 , is rigid . so @xmath508 for some @xmath204 since @xmath5 is maximal rigid , and we can conclude that @xmath509 . * ( ii ) : * we know that @xmath225 and @xmath177 are disjoint . the claim then follows from lemma [ lem : revhammquasi ] . * ( iii ) : * assume @xmath502 is non - empty , and let @xmath510 and @xmath511 be elements in this set with minimal and maximal quasilength , respectively . by lemma [ lem : revhammquasi ] , the unique quasisimple @xmath495 which is in @xmath494 is now in both @xmath512 and @xmath513 . so in particular @xmath512 and @xmath513 have non - empty intersection , and therefore by lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] we know that @xmath514 . also by lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] we see that @xmath511 and @xmath510 are uniquely determined . there is some @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath515 , and it can easily be seen that if @xmath495 were in @xmath516 , say , then also @xmath517 would be in @xmath494 , which would violate the minimality condition on @xmath510 . thus @xmath510 is the summand of smallest quasilength such that @xmath495 is in the corresponding wing . see figure [ fig : revhammandsubwings ] . and @xmath511 are the summands of @xmath5 in @xmath494 of lowest and highest quasilength , respectively , then the entire rectangle indicated must be in @xmath494.,width=302 ] also , for summands @xmath518 we have that @xmath519 if and only if @xmath520 , again by lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] and the maximality of @xmath511 . now the desired string is a string of the type described in lemma [ lem : stringsubwing ] , oriented in the suitable way . * ( iv ) : * by part ( ii ) , a @xmath18-arrow associated with a non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath235 could not be traversed by a string of the type described in part ( iii ) . moreover , the loop is disallowed as well , since then the loop vertex would be traversed twice , contrary to the condition in part ( iii ) . for an indecomposable @xmath497 such that @xmath502 is non - empty , where @xmath493 is either @xmath17 or @xmath18 , we denote the string in lemma [ lem : revhamm ] part ( iii ) by @xmath521 . if the intersection is empty , we define @xmath521 to be the zero string . the two next lemmas tell us that different objects in @xmath522 can be distinguished by their associated strings . [ lem : differentstrings ] let @xmath523 . if @xmath524 and @xmath525 , then @xmath526 . we note first that for any indecomposable @xmath53 , the unique quasisimple @xmath527 in @xmath528 determines the first coordinate of @xmath53 . similarly , the unique quasisimple @xmath529 in @xmath530 determines the sum of the coordinates of @xmath53 modulo the rank @xmath10 . so if the first coordinate of @xmath53 is known , the quasisimple @xmath529 determines the second coordinate _ modulo @xmath10_. let now @xmath7 and @xmath41 be in @xmath522 such that @xmath531 and @xmath525 . we aim to show that @xmath7 and @xmath41 must be equal . by lemma [ lem : revhamm ] part ( i ) , at least one of @xmath531 and @xmath525 is non - zero . assume first that both are non - zero . we claim that @xmath532 and @xmath533 . as in the proof of lemma [ lem : revhamm ] part ( iii ) , we observe that if @xmath510 is the @xmath5-summand of smallest quasilength in @xmath479 , then @xmath534 is the unique quasisimple which is in @xmath512 but not in the wing of any @xmath5-summand of smaller quasilength . since @xmath510 is also the summand of smallest quasilength in @xmath535 , we must have @xmath532 . similarly , we deduce that @xmath533 . thus @xmath7 and @xmath41 have the same first coordinate , and the same second coordinate modulo @xmath10 . but since @xmath7 and @xmath41 are in @xmath487 , this means that unless @xmath7 and @xmath41 are equal , one of them is in @xmath536 and the other is in the non - rigid part . if they are not equal , there is then a contradiction to lemma [ lem : t1inr(x ) ] : if @xmath7 is in @xmath536 and @xmath41 is in the non - rigid part , then by lemma [ lem : t1inr(x ) ] @xmath537 but @xmath538 , which is impossible since we have assumed @xmath539 and @xmath540 . we conclude that if both @xmath541 and @xmath542 , then @xmath526 . assume then that @xmath541 and @xmath543 , and furthermore that @xmath544 . then @xmath7 and @xmath41 have the same first coordinate . moreover , at least one of @xmath7 and @xmath41 must be in @xmath536 , since the only other possible positions for an object @xmath545 such that @xmath546 and @xmath547 are on the coray @xmath548 . suppose ( without loss of generality ) that @xmath7 has smaller quasilength than @xmath41 . so in particular , @xmath7 is in @xmath536 . let @xmath511 be the object in @xmath549 with highest quasilength . since @xmath550 , we have that @xmath551 . therefore , there is some @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath552 , where @xmath511 is necessarily on the left side since @xmath479 contains whole corays , and so by the maximality of @xmath511 , there can be no more summands of @xmath5 on @xmath553 . assume first that this triple is non - degenerate . since @xmath480 does not contain any summands of @xmath5 , there is in particular no @xmath18-map @xmath554 . so @xmath7 is in @xmath555 but not in @xmath556 . moreover , we see that @xmath557 , by the maximality of @xmath511 . so @xmath7 must be on the coray @xmath558 . if the triple is degenerate , then @xmath7 must be on the right edge of @xmath513 , since @xmath559 . in any of these two cases , we get a contradiction : since @xmath41 and @xmath7 have the same first coordinate , and @xmath41 has higher quasilength , @xmath560 must be in @xmath535 . this contradicts the equality of @xmath561 and @xmath562 , and our assumption that @xmath544 must be wrong . see figure [ fig : equalsigmas ] . and @xmath563 , then @xmath7 and @xmath41 have the same first coordinate . if @xmath7 is inside some non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple , then @xmath7 must be on the coray @xmath558 , since otherwise @xmath564.,width=340 ] the situation where @xmath565 and @xmath542 can be proved in a similar manner . the following lemma is used to show that if two different objects have exactly one associated @xmath566- or @xmath567-string , then the strings are different . [ lem : tstringisnotdstring ] if @xmath568 , then @xmath562 is non - zero . suppose that @xmath568 , and let @xmath230 be the summand in @xmath569 which has highest quasilength . we claim that @xmath256 . to see this , assume that @xmath570 . then there is some ( degenerate or non - degenerate ) @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath571 or @xmath572 . since @xmath479 contains whole corays , and @xmath573 contains whole rays , the summand @xmath174 must be in one of these two reverse hom - hammocks . but this contradicts our choice of @xmath230 . so @xmath256 . now observe that if @xmath41 is in @xmath487 , and there is a @xmath43-map @xmath574 , then there is also a @xmath17-map @xmath574 , so in particular @xmath575 . we now show that if both strings associated with an indecomposable in @xmath487 are non - zero , then there is a larger string containing both of them . [ lem : dstrings ] let @xmath497 . if both @xmath561 and @xmath576 are non - zero , there is a @xmath18-arrow @xmath577 from the end vertex of @xmath561 to the end vertex of @xmath576 . so in particular , @xmath578 is a well - defined string . we consider four cases , depending on the position of @xmath7 in @xmath487 . the first case is when there is a @xmath18-map @xmath579 . one readily verifies that there is then also a @xmath17-map @xmath579 , so in this case @xmath95 is in both @xmath479 and @xmath480 , and the claim holds with the loop as @xmath577 . the second case is when there is a @xmath17-map @xmath579 , but no @xmath18-map from @xmath95 to @xmath7 . this happens exactly when @xmath7 is on the coray @xmath548 , and in this case there are no @xmath18-maps from any summands of @xmath5 to @xmath7 , so @xmath580 is empty , and there is nothing to prove . the third case is when @xmath7 is located on the ray @xmath581 . then there are no @xmath17-maps from @xmath5 to @xmath7 , so again there is nothing to prove . the only remaining situation is then when @xmath7 is in the wing @xmath536 . as in the proof of lemma [ lem : differentstrings ] , let @xmath511 be the summand in @xmath582 of highest quasilength . since @xmath551 , there is some @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath552 with @xmath511 necessarily on the left , since @xmath479 contains whole corays . assume first that this triple is non - degenerate . then , since @xmath583 and @xmath584 by the maximality property of @xmath511 , we note the following about the position of @xmath7 : * @xmath585 , but not on the right edge of @xmath586 , since then there would be a @xmath17-map @xmath587 * @xmath588 , where @xmath41 is the object on @xmath589 which has an irreducible map to @xmath590 , since then there would be no @xmath17-map @xmath591 * if @xmath592 , then it is on the right edge , since otherwise there would be no @xmath17-map @xmath591 our aim is to show that @xmath590 is in @xmath480 , and moreover that it is the summand of @xmath5 with highest quasilength appearing in @xmath480 . with the above remarks about the position of @xmath7 , we see that the only allowed positions such that there is no @xmath18-map @xmath593 are positions on the coray @xmath558 . but if @xmath7 were on this coray , then @xmath580 would be empty , contrary to our hypothesis : namely , assuming this position for @xmath7 , suppose there was some summand @xmath594 . an equivalent condition to this ( cf . lemma [ lem : homspaces ] ) is that there is a non - zero @xmath17-map @xmath595 , which again is equivalent to the existence of a @xmath17-map @xmath596 . but since @xmath597 , we have that @xmath507 is on the right edge of @xmath586 . so there would be a non - zero @xmath17-map @xmath598 , which is impossible since @xmath560 and @xmath599 are ext - orthogonal . so @xmath600 . let @xmath601 be the @xmath5-summand of highest quasilength which appears in @xmath480 . then , since both @xmath602 and @xmath603 contain the quasisimple @xmath604 from lemma [ lem : revhammquasi ] , lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] tells us that @xmath605 . but @xmath590 is in @xmath586 as well , so by lemma [ lem : subwingintersection ] again , either @xmath606 or @xmath607 . the former case is not possible , since it would imply that @xmath608 , which is impossible since @xmath609 . so the remaining possibility is that @xmath610 , that is , @xmath590 is the @xmath5-summand in @xmath480 of highest quasilength . by the description of the quiver of @xmath267 in section [ sec : endoring ] , there is a @xmath18-arrow @xmath577 associated with the non - degenerate @xmath5-subwing triple , from the vertex corresponding to @xmath511 to the vertex corresponding to @xmath590 . since @xmath561 ends in the vertex corresponding to @xmath511 , and @xmath611 starts in the vertex corresponding to @xmath590 , the string @xmath612 is well - defined . it remains to consider the case where the @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath552 is degenerate , that is , @xmath613 . in this case , since @xmath584 , the only option is that @xmath7 is on the right edge of @xmath513 . but then @xmath580 is empty : if there was a @xmath18-map @xmath614 for some @xmath5-summand @xmath615 , then @xmath560 and @xmath615 would have an extension , as can be seen from an argument similar to the above . by virtue of the preceding considerations , we can now associate to each indecomposable object @xmath616 a unique indecomposable @xmath267-module @xmath617 where @xmath618 \sigma^{\d}_x & \textrm{if } \sigma^{\t}_x \textrm { is zero } \\[4pt ] ( \sigma^{\d}_x)^{-1 } \beta_x \sigma^{\t}_x & \textrm{if both } \sigma^{\t}_x \textrm { and } \sigma^{\d}_x \textrm { are non - zero } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] we can now describe the action of the hom - functor on objects in @xmath487 . [ thm : actiononf ] let @xmath5 be a maximal rigid object of @xmath19 , and @xmath369 the endomorphism ring . * let @xmath7 be an object in @xmath619 . then the @xmath267-module @xmath620 is isomorphic to the string module @xmath617 . * the functor @xmath621 provides a bijection between @xmath622 and the set of isoclasses of indecomposable @xmath267-modules . * ( 1 ) * by lemma [ lem : revhamm ] part ( i ) , the module is non - zero . let @xmath623 be the idempotent corresponding to the indecomposable projective @xmath624 . let @xmath623 be the idempotent of @xmath267 corresponding to the vertex @xmath204 , which again corresponds to the summand @xmath230 of @xmath5 . then the vector space @xmath625 decomposes @xmath626 where each vector space @xmath627 and @xmath628 is at most 1-dimensional and is spanned by a @xmath17-map @xmath629 and a @xmath18-map @xmath630 respectively , where these maps are zero if no non - zero such maps exist . by the definition of @xmath561 , the vertices for which @xmath631 are exactly the vertices that are traversed by @xmath561 . similarly , the vertices for which @xmath632 are the ones traversed by @xmath576 . in particular , there is an equality of dimension vectors @xmath633 we need to establish that the action of @xmath267 on @xmath625 is the same as the action on @xmath617 . each map which is irreducible in @xmath238 corresponds to an arrow in the quiver of @xmath267 , and the arrow acts by composition with the irreducible map . unless both the start vertex and the end vertex of this arrow are vertices in the support of @xmath625 , then clearly this map ( equivalently , this arrow ) has a zero action on both the modules @xmath620 and @xmath617 . so we must show that for each @xmath17-arrow @xmath634 appearing in @xmath561 acts by an isomorphism @xmath635 , and each @xmath17-arrow appearing in @xmath576 acts by an isomorphism @xmath636 , and finally that if @xmath637 is defined , then the action of this is given by an isomorphism @xmath638 . our first goal is now to show that whenever @xmath639 is a @xmath17-arrow such that @xmath360 itself or @xmath377 appears in @xmath640 , then the action of @xmath360 is given by a pair of linear transformations @xmath641 which are isomorphisms when their domains and codomains are both non - zero . ( and necessarily zero otherwise . ) let @xmath642 be the irreducible @xmath17-map corresponding to @xmath360 . then what we need is that if @xmath643 and @xmath644 are both non - zero , then @xmath645 up to a non - zero scalar , and similarly that if @xmath646 and @xmath647 are both non - zero , then @xmath648 . the first assertion is clearly true by the structure of the tube . the second assertion holds by an application of lemma [ lem : rayfactoring ] part ( i ) , and remark [ rem : rayfactoring ] , where we use that @xmath649 must be a composition of maps which are irreducible in @xmath650 , and follows a ray or coray ( along the edge of a wing ) , and thus all the indecomposables that @xmath649 factors through are also in @xmath480 . next let @xmath7 be such that the @xmath18-arrow @xmath651 is defined , and thus appears in the string @xmath640 . then we know that @xmath627 and @xmath652 are non - zero . the action of @xmath577 is given by composition with a @xmath18-map @xmath653 . we wish to show that ( up to multiplication by a non - zero scalar ) this action is given by a linear transformation @xmath654 in other words , it sends @xmath644 to @xmath647 and annihilates @xmath646 . the composition @xmath655 is clearly zero , as all compositions of two @xmath18-maps are . consider the image @xmath656 of @xmath644 . we need that the @xmath17-map @xmath644 does not factor through any indecomposable to which there is no @xmath18-map from @xmath213 . this holds , since by lemma [ lem : onecomponent ] , @xmath657 forms a rectangle - shaped subgraph of the tube , and the map @xmath644 can not factor through any indecomposable outside this subgraph . we can then conclude from lemma [ lem : rayfactoring ] part ( ii ) and remark [ rem : rayfactoring ] that @xmath658 , which is what we wanted . it remains to show that if there exists an arrow which connects two vertices in the support of @xmath620 , but which does nt appear in @xmath640 , then the action of this arrow is zero on @xmath620 . by lemmas [ lem : stringsubwing ] , [ lem : revhamm ] and [ lem : dstrings ] the only case to consider is when @xmath577 is the loop vertex , and there is a @xmath5-subwing triple @xmath235 such that @xmath659 and @xmath660 or vice versa . since the action of the arrow @xmath661 is given by composition with the @xmath18-map @xmath662 , we only need to study the case where @xmath561 traverses @xmath405 and @xmath576 traverses @xmath8 . so we need to show that @xmath663 is zero . but by examining the hom - hammocks of @xmath213 and @xmath174 , we see that if there is a @xmath17-map @xmath664 and a @xmath18-map @xmath665 , then either @xmath7 is in @xmath224 , which contradicts the fact that @xmath204 must be traversed by @xmath640 , or @xmath644 factors through objects on the coray @xmath666 . in the latter case , the composition must be zero , since there are no @xmath18-maps from @xmath174 to any objects on this coray . * ( 2 ) * counting the number of elements of @xmath487 , we find that it contains @xmath667 objects with quasilength less than @xmath10 and @xmath668 with quasilength @xmath10 or more , that is , a total of @xmath669 elements . since @xmath5 has @xmath189 summands , the cardinality of @xmath670 is @xmath671 which , by theorem [ thm : finitetype ] , is also the number of indecomposables in @xmath672 . by lemmas [ lem : differentstrings ] and [ lem : tstringisnotdstring ] , if @xmath7 and @xmath41 are different objects in @xmath673 , then @xmath674 . it then follows from part ( 1 ) that @xmath675 . so we @xmath621 provides a bijection . we now turn to the indecomposables which are not in @xmath487 . it is easily seen that lemma [ lem : revhamm ] parts ( ii)-(iv ) hold also for indecomposables which are not in @xmath487 . so we can define @xmath561 and @xmath576 in this case as well . the following theorem now completes the description of the action of @xmath621 on objects . let @xmath7 be an indecomposable object in @xmath19 , where @xmath676 . then we have the following . * @xmath503 if and only if @xmath677 , where @xmath678 . * if @xmath7 is not of the type described in @xmath679 , then @xmath680 where @xmath389 is the zero module if @xmath390 is the zero string . * ( 1 ) : * when @xmath676 we know that @xmath503 if and only if @xmath681 . there are no @xmath17-maps @xmath579 if and only if @xmath7 is on the ray @xmath581 , that is @xmath682 for some @xmath683 . moreover , there are no @xmath18-maps @xmath579 if and only if @xmath7 is on the coray @xmath684 . the indecomposables that are in the intersection of @xmath581 and @xmath684 and outside @xmath487 are exactly the ones with coordinates @xmath685 such that @xmath686 . the claim follows . * ( 2 ) : * the proof of theorem [ thm : actiononf ] goes through , with the following exception , which is exactly what is needed . the action of @xmath577 ( which in this case is always the loop , as we see from the argument for ( 1 ) above ) is zero : the @xmath17-map @xmath687 factors through ( at least ) one object on the coray @xmath684 . we know that there are no @xmath18-maps from @xmath95 to any object on this coray . it then follows that the composition @xmath688 , where @xmath689 is the @xmath18-endomorphism of @xmath95 , is a zero map . the result follows . the author is very grateful to aslak bakke buan for many helpful comments on earlier versions of this manuscript . much of the work presented here was carried out during a visit at the school of mathematics , university of leeds . the author would like to thank robert marsh for his hospitality as well as for many discussions on the subject . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: a real in the unit interval is _ computably enumerable _ ( _ c.e . _ ) if it is the limit of a computable , increasing sequence of rationals . we identify a real with its infinite binary expansion . in contrast with the case of a computable real , whose bits are given by a computable function , during the process of approximation of a c.e . real one may never know how close one is to the limit . a real is ( algorithmic ) random if its binary expansion is an algorithmic random ( infinite ) sequence @xcite . a prefix - free machine is a turing machine , shortly , _ machine _ , from strings to strings whose domain is a prefix - free set . a machine is universal if it can simulate every machine . chaitin @xcite introduced the halting probability @xmath1 of a universal machine @xmath0 , chaitin s omega number @xmath2 and proved that _ @xmath1 is c.e . and random_. as shown by calude , hertling , khoussainov , wang @xcite and kuera , slaman @xcite , ( see also @xcite ) there are no other c.e . random reals : [ representation : thm]the set of c.e . random reals coincides with the set of halting probabilities of all universal machines . random reals have been intensively studied in recent years , with many results summarised in @xcite . [ gregzfc ] assume that zfc ( zermelo - fraenkel set theory with choice ) is arithmetically sound ( that is , any theorem of arithmetic proved by zfc is true ) . then , for every universal machine @xmath0 , zfc can determine the value of only finitely many bits of @xmath1 , and one can calculate a bound on the number of bits of @xmath1 which zfc can determine . the real @xmath1 depends on @xmath0 , and so by tuning this choice one gets : [ solovay ] we can chose a universal machine @xmath0 so that zfc ( if arithmetically sound ) can not determine any bit of @xmath1 . this result was generalised as follows : [ crisincompl ] assume that zfc is arithmetically sound . let @xmath3 and consider the c.e . random real @xmath4 then , we can effectively construct a universal machine @xmath0 ( depending upon zfc and @xmath5 ) such that pa ( peano arithmetic ) proves the universality of @xmath0 , zfc can determine at most @xmath6 initial bits of @xmath1 and @xmath7 . the proof of theorem [ crisincompl ] in @xcite starts by fixing a universal machine @xmath8 such that the universality of @xmath8 is provable in pa and @xmath9 . solovay @xcite observed that `` it is by no means evident that there is a universal prefix - free machine whose universality is provable in pa and whose halting probability is @xmath5 '' . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ let @xmath10 be c.e . and random . is there any _ representation _ of @xmath5 for which pa can _ prove _ that @xmath11 c.e . and random ? _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we give an affirmative answer to this question . a major step in the proof is to show that theorem [ representation : thm ] can be proved in pa . our proof , which is simpler than the standard one , can be used also for the original theorem . the paper also includes a sharper form of the kraft - chaitin theorem , as well as a formal proof of this theorem written with the proof assistant isabelle . in what follows proofs will be written in solovay s style @xcite . all necessary steps are presented in sufficient detail to leave the remaining formalisation routine . the formalisation of the kraft - chaitin theorem is presented with full details , and then a sketch of the formal proof in isabelle is discussed . the paper is organised as follows . sections 2 and 3 present all facts on formal provability and algorithmic information theory needed for this paper . the kraft - chaitin theorem is presented in section 4 . section 5 presents three ways to prove randomness , using martin - lf tests , prefix - free complexity , and solovay representation formula . in section 6 we revisit chaitin s theorem on the randomness of the halting probability of a universal machine . in section 7 we prove that a real @xmath12 is provably chaitin - random iff it is provable that @xmath7 for some provably universal machine @xmath0 ( see theorem [ thm : representation ] ) . in section 8 we prove our main theorem : every c.e . random real is provably random ( theorem [ thm : cerandprov ] ) . in section 9 we construct a universal machine @xmath0 based on which pa can not prove the randomness of its halting probability . section 10 presents a formal proof of the kraft - chaitin theorem written with isabelle . the final section 11 includes a few general remarks . by @xmath13 we denote the first - order language of arithmetic whose non - logical symbols consist of the constant symbols 0 and 1 , the binary relation symbol @xmath14 and two binary function symbols @xmath15 ( addition ) and @xmath16 ( multiplication ) . peano arithmetic ( see @xcite , shortly , pa ) is the first - order theory given by a set of 15 axioms defining discretely ordered rings , together with induction axioms for each formula @xmath17 in @xmath13 : @xmath18 01 this schema retains as much as possible from the second - order induction axiom : @xmath19 where @xmath20 ranges over all subsets of the domain , and @xmath21 range over elements of this domain , but avoids quantification over sets of natural numbers , which is impossible in first - order logic . in pa it is not possible to say that any set of natural numbers containing 0 and closed under successor is the entire set of natural numbers , but that any definable set of natural numbers has this property . the induction schema includes one instance of the induction axiom for every definition of a subset of the naturals . the structure * n * whose domain is the set of naturals @xmath22 , where the symbols in @xmath13 have the obvious interpretation , satisfies the axioms of pa ; this is the standard model for pa . there are non - standard models of pa that are not isomorphic to * n*. if @xmath23 is a structure for @xmath13 and @xmath24 is an @xmath13-formula with free - variables @xmath25 and @xmath26 , then we write @xmath27 to mean that `` @xmath28 is true in @xmath23 when each variable @xmath29 is interpreted by @xmath30 '' . we blur the distinction between @xmath31 and the closed term of @xmath13 , @xmath32 , ( @xmath31 times ) . a formula @xmath33 of @xmath13 is @xmath34 if all its quantifiers are bounded . a formula @xmath35 of @xmath13 is @xmath36 if it is of the form @xmath37 with @xmath38 ; @xmath35 of @xmath13 is @xmath39 if it is of the form @xmath40 with @xmath38 . by pa @xmath41 we mean `` there is a proof in pa for @xmath42 '' . it is useful to know that pa proves the _ least number principle _ : @xmath43 for each formula @xmath44 of @xmath13 . an important link between computability and provability is given by the following results . a partial function from @xmath45 to @xmath45 is partial computable iff its graph is equivalent to a @xmath36 @xmath13-formula . [ cesets]a set @xmath46 is computably enumerable ( c.e . ) if there is a @xmath36 @xmath13-formula @xmath24 such that for all @xmath47 , @xmath48 iff * n * @xmath49 . a total function @xmath50 is represented in pa if there is an @xmath13-formula @xmath51 such that for all @xmath52 : + 1 . pa @xmath53 , and 2 . if @xmath54 then pa @xmath55 . + ( here @xmath56 means `` there exists a unique '' . ) one can show that every total computable function is represented by a @xmath36-formula of pa @xcite . a function @xmath57 is _ provably computable _ @xcite if there exists a @xmath36-formula of pa @xmath58 such that : + 1 . @xmath59 , 2 . pa @xmath60 . + in view of corollary [ cesets ] , any provably computable function has a c.e . graph , so it is total and computable . these functions can be viewed as computable functions whose totality is proved by pa . every primitive recursive function is provably computable , but there exist computable functions which are not provably computable in pa . if @xmath61 is computable but not provably computable in pa , then the statement `` @xmath61 is total '' is true but unprovable in pa . in contrast with the case of computable functions , _ c.e . sets are provably enumerable _ @xcite ( because every non - empty c.e . set can be enumerated by a primitive recursive function , @xcite , p. 138 ) . in what follows all computations will be implemented by primitive recursive functions . hence , we will work with a special type of @xmath36 formulae . by abuse of language we say that a formula of pa is @xmath62 if it has the form @xmath63 , for some primitive recursive predicate @xmath64 . a formula of pa is @xmath65 if it has the form @xmath66 , for some primitive recursive predicate @xmath67 . our metatheory is zfc . we fix a ( relative ) interpretation of pa in zfc . each formula of @xmath13 has a translation into a formula of zfc determined by the interpretation of pa in zfc . by abuse of language we shall use the phrase `` sentence of arithmetic '' to mean a formula with no free variables of zfc that is the translation of some formula of pa . we assume that zfc is 1consistent , that is , if it proves a @xmath62 sentence then that sentence is true ( in the standard model of pa ) . [ solovay @xcite ] every @xmath65 sentence proved by zfc is true . as a consequence , it follows that _ if @xmath0 is a machine which _ pa _ can prove universal and zfc can prove the sentence `` the i - th digit of @xmath68 is @xmath69 '' , then the sentence is true_. whenever we talk about the provability of a sentence of arithmetic we mean that pa proves its corresponding translation formula . if there is a proof in pa for statement @xmath70 we say that @xmath70 provable in pa . we say that @xmath70 is provably @xmath71 ( where @xmath71 is a property ) if the statement `` @xmath70 has @xmath71 '' is provable in pa . _ all reals are in the unit interval . _ a c.e . real @xmath5 is represented by an increasing computable sequence of rationals converging to @xmath5 . we blur the distinction between the real @xmath5 and the infinite base - two expansion of @xmath5 , i.e. the infinite sequence @xmath72 ( @xmath73 such that @xmath74 by @xmath75 we denote the string of length @xmath31 , @xmath76 . the set of ( bit ) strings is denoted by @xmath77 ; @xmath78 denotes the empty string . if @xmath79 is a string then @xmath80 denotes the length of @xmath79 . we import the theory of computability from natural numbers to strings by fixing the canonical bijection between @xmath77 and @xmath45 induced by the linear order @xmath81 if @xmath82 or @xmath83 and @xmath79 lexicographically precedes @xmath84 . a machine @xmath0 is _ universal _ if for every machine @xmath8 there is a constant @xmath85 ( depending upon @xmath0 and @xmath8 ) such that for all strings @xmath86 , if @xmath87 , then @xmath88 for some string @xmath89 of length @xmath90 . the domain of @xmath0 is the set @xmath91 . the omega number @xmath92 is halting probability of @xmath0 . the _ prefix - free complexity _ of the string @xmath93 ( relatively to the machine @xmath94 ) is @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ) . if @xmath0 is a universal machine , then for every machine we can effectively construct a constant @xmath85 ( depending on @xmath0 and @xmath94 ) such that @xmath97 , for all @xmath98 . a real @xmath5 is _ chaitin - random _ if there exists a universal machine @xmath0 and constant @xmath85 such that for all @xmath99 , @xmath100 . open set is a c.e . union of intervals with rationals endpoints @xmath101 and @xmath102 is lebesgue measure . if @xmath103 is a prefix - free set , then @xmath104 denotes the lebesgue measure of the cylinder denoted by @xmath103 , i.e. all reals whose infinite binary expansions have a prefix in @xmath103 . to the string @xmath98 we associate the interval @xmath105 of measure @xmath106 . a martin - lf test ( shortly , ml test ) @xmath70 is a uniformly c.e . sequence of c.e . open sets @xmath107 such that for all @xmath108 , @xmath109 . a real @xmath5 is _ martin - lf - random _ ( shortly , _ ml - random _ ) if for every ml test @xmath70 there exists an @xmath110 such that @xmath111 . a classical theorem states that _ a real is chaitin - random iff it is ml - random _ @xcite . note that chaitin and martin - lf definitions apply to any real . in the special case of c.e . reals the following solovay representation formula stated in @xcite is used : a real @xmath5 is _ c.e . and random _ if there exists a universal machine @xmath0 , an integer @xmath112 and a c.e . real @xmath113 such that @xmath114 ( see lemma [ lem : solovayrepresentation ] ) . we start by showing that pa can prove the kraft - chaitin theorem @xcite . [ thm : kc ] suppose @xmath115 is a primitive recursive enumeration of `` requests '' which provably satisfies @xmath116 then there exists a provably prefix - free machine @xmath23 and a primitive recursive enumeration @xmath117 of @xmath118 such that the following is provable in pa : + 1 . @xmath119 , 2 . @xmath120 for all @xmath121 , 3 . @xmath122 for all @xmath121 . algorithm [ alg : kc ] below enumerates the graph of @xmath23 . intuitively , @xmath123 keeps track of the tree of prefixes we havent allocated yet . to start with we have allocated nothing , so @xmath124 . at each step we want a string ( node ) of a given length ( depth ) @xmath125 . the program selects the deepest leaf it can , then creates the smallest number of new leaves to create the node we need . + @xmath124 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 , @xmath128 . let @xmath129 be the longest element of @xmath103 of length at most @xmath125 . if no such string exists , terminate . define @xmath132 . @xmath135 . examining algorithm [ alg : kc ] , it is clear that the sequence @xmath136 is a primitive recursive enumeration of @xmath118 , and whenever @xmath137 is defined we have @xmath122 and @xmath120 . it remains to show that @xmath137 is defined for all @xmath121 ( i.e. the program never terminates ) , that @xmath118 is prefix - free , and @xmath138 . it suffices to establish , for all @xmath110 , the following invariants : + 1 . @xmath139 is prefix - free ( which implies that @xmath123 and @xmath140 individually are prefix - free ) , 2 . @xmath141 , 3 . @xmath142 , 4 . @xmath143 , 5 . if @xmath144 , then @xmath123 contains a string of length at most @xmath31 ( equivalently , @xmath123 contains strings of distinct length ) . the base case is trivial . for the inductive step , first observe that line 3 of algorithm [ alg : kc ] does nt terminate since @xmath145 by invariant 5 . we see that @xmath146 which is prefix - free establishing invariant 1 . from this we can see invariant 2 holds : @xmath147 next observe invariant 3 holds too : @xmath148 which implies that @xmath149 from this follows invariant 4 : @xmath150 finally , since @xmath129 is the longest string of length at most @xmath125 in @xmath151 , and we add strings of distinct length between @xmath152 and @xmath125 to @xmath123 to form @xmath153 , we see that @xmath153 consists of strings of distinct lengths . this establishes invariant 5 . in this section we discuss three forms of provability for randomness . there are two ways to represent a c.e . real number @xmath12 in pa : 1 ) by giving an increasing 1 - 1 primitive recursive function that enumerates a c.e . prefix - free set of strings @xmath154 such that @xmath155 , 2 ) by giving an increasing primitive recursive sequence @xmath156 of rationals in the unit interval whose limit is @xmath5 . it is clear that given the representation 1 ) one can effectively get the representation 2 ) . the converse is also true . [ lem : repce ] let @xmath5 be a c.e . real defined by the increasing primitive recursive sequence @xmath156 of rationals . then there is a primitive recursive sequence @xmath157 of natural numbers such that pa proves @xmath158 without loss of generality assume @xmath159 . define the primitive recursive sequences @xmath160 and @xmath161 by @xmath162 and for @xmath163 by @xmath164 since @xmath165 is strictly increasing we can establish by induction the inequality @xmath166 for all @xmath110 , making the logarithm well - defined . by construction we have @xmath167 define @xmath168 . since @xmath169 we have @xmath170 taking the limit we see that @xmath171 establishing our result . let @xmath5 be a c.e . real defined by the increasing primitive recursive sequence @xmath156 of rationals . then there is a machine @xmath23 such that pa proves that @xmath172 . use lemma [ lem : repce ] and theorem [ thm : kc ] . in what follows a c.e . real is given by one of the above representations . real @xmath5 is _ provably chaitin - random _ if there exists a provably universal machine @xmath0 and constant @xmath85 such that pa proves that for all @xmath99 , @xmath100 . real @xmath5 is _ provably ml - random _ if for every set @xmath70 which pa proves to be a ml test and pa proves that there exists an @xmath110 such that @xmath111 . the classical theorem that states that _ a real is chaitin - random iff it is ml - random _ is provable in pa . however , for the goal of this paper only one implication is needed : [ thm : chaitintoml ] every c.e . provably chaitin - random real is provably ml - random . take a c.e . real @xmath5 , a machine @xmath0 which is provably universal and a natural @xmath173 such that pa proves that for all @xmath99 , @xmath174 . we wish to prove that for every @xmath175 which pa proves to be a ml test there exists an @xmath110 such that pa proves that @xmath111 . following the proof of proposition 6.3.4 in @xcite it follows that pa proves the existence of a c.e . set @xmath176 such that each @xmath177 is prefix - free , and by taking @xmath178 we get @xmath179 . let @xmath180 be a 1 - 1 primitive recursive enumeration of the graph of @xmath0 . denote by @xmath181 for @xmath182 the projection functions and @xmath183 is a 1 - 1 primitive recursive enumeration of @xmath184 . note that @xmath185 can be expressed in pa : @xmath186 , we have : @xmath187 we can now use theorem [ thm : kc ] : there exists a provably prefix - free machine @xmath23 such that : @xmath188 , @xmath189 since @xmath0 is provably universal there is a constant @xmath190 such that for all strings @xmath191 , so in particular , pa proves that for all @xmath192 , if @xmath193 , then @xmath194 we are now in a position to find a natural @xmath192 such that pa proves that @xmath195 showing that @xmath5 is provably ml - random . note that for @xmath192 , pa proves @xmath195 iff for all @xmath196 , pa proves that @xmath197 . for all @xmath196 , pa proves that @xmath198 implies @xmath199 hence , for @xmath200 , pa proves that @xmath201 implies @xmath197 , so because @xmath5 is provably chaitin - random pa proves that @xmath195 . * comment * the above proof shows that that @xmath202 , where @xmath0 is a provably universal machine , is a provably ml test such that for all @xmath192 and provably ml test @xmath70 there exists @xmath203 such that pa proves the inclusion @xmath204 , i.e. @xmath205 is a provably universal ml test . to be able to complete our program we need to choose a specific representation for a c.e . and random real which can be `` understood '' by pa and , even more importantly , pa can extract from it a proof of the randomness of the real ( c.e . is obvious ) . first we work with solovay representation formula discussed at the end of section [ ait ] . a real @xmath5 is _ c.e . and provably random _ if there exists a representation of @xmath5 in the form @xmath206 where @xmath8 is a provably universal machine , @xmath207 is an integer and @xmath113 is a provably c.e . theorem [ lem : solovayrepresentation ] shows that all c.e . random reals have a representation of this form . in detail , pa receives an algorithm for a machine @xmath8 , a proof that @xmath8 is prefix - free and universal , an integer @xmath207 and a computable increasing sequence of rational converging to a real @xmath208 . the goal is to prove that pa can use this information to prove that @xmath209 is c.e . and random . chaitin @xcite proved that the halting probability of a universal machine is chaitin - random . this theorem is provable in pa : [ thm : chaitin ] suppose @xmath0 is provably universal . then @xmath210 is provably chaitin - random . let @xmath180 be a 1 - 1 primitive recursive enumeration of the graph of @xmath0 . denote by @xmath211 for @xmath182 the projection functions and @xmath183 is a 1 - 1 primitive recursive enumeration of @xmath184 . recall that @xmath185 can be expressed in pa . 01 @xmath212 @xmath213 define the machine @xmath23 by @xmath214 . since @xmath0 is provably universal , there is a @xmath85 such that for all @xmath98 , @xmath215 this shows that @xmath185 is provably total and @xmath0 is provably onto . define the primitive recursive sequence of rationals @xmath216 and notice that @xmath217 is provably strictly increasing ; @xmath1 is , by definition , the limit of this sequence . define @xmath218 if there exist @xmath84,@xmath219 such that + 1 . @xmath220 ( i.e. @xmath221 ) , 2 . @xmath84 is the least such that @xmath222 ( i.e. @xmath223 ) , 3 . @xmath224 is the lexicographically least string such that @xmath225 for all @xmath226 . this defines a provably prefix - free machine . observe that if @xmath227 is defined and @xmath228 then @xmath229 . from this we can establish that whenever @xmath227 is defined we have @xmath230 as @xmath0 is provably universal , there exists an @xmath231 such that for all @xmath232 , @xmath233 is provable in pa . denote by @xmath234 the @xmath110th digit of @xmath1 . since @xmath0 is provable onto , for each @xmath31 there exists a string @xmath235 such that @xmath236 since @xmath237 we know that @xmath238 is defined . let @xmath84 be the least natural ( found when evaluating @xmath238 ) such that @xmath239 the inequality @xmath240 is easy consequence , so for all @xmath241 we have @xmath242 . since @xmath238 equals @xmath243 for some @xmath241 by construction , we have that for all @xmath31 01 @xmath244 @xmath245 is provable in pa . that is , @xmath246 is provably chaitin - random . from theorem [ thm : chaitin ] we deduce that pa can prove the implication : `` if @xmath0 is a provably universal machine , then @xmath68 is chaitin - random . '' we know that every c.e . and random real is the halting probability of a universal machine , but we need more : _ can any c.e . and random real be represented as the halting probability of a provably universal machine ? _ first we have to check whether every universal machine is provably universal . [ thm : nonprovunivmachine ] there exist a provably universal machine and a universal machine that is not provably universal . the set of all provably prefix - free machines is c.e . , so if @xmath247 is a computably enumeration of provably prefix - free machines , then the machine @xmath0 defined by @xmath248 is a provably universal machine . let @xmath249 be a c.e . enumeration of all primitive recursive functions @xmath250 and @xmath251 a c.e . enumeration of all machines . fix a universal machine @xmath0 and consider the computable function @xmath252 such that : @xmath253 for every @xmath110 , @xmath254 is a universal machine iff @xmath255 is infinite ( if @xmath255 is finite , then so is @xmath254 ) . since the set of all indices of primitive recursive functions with infinite range is not c.e.it follows that there is an @xmath110 such that pa can not prove that @xmath256 is universal . theorem [ thm : nonprovunivmachine ] does not imply a negative answer for the previous question ; in fact , corollary [ cor : secondrep ] shows that the answer is affirmative . theorem [ thm : nonprovunivmachine ] produces examples of true and unprovable ( in pa ) statements of the form `` @xmath8 is universal '' . in this section we sharpen theorem [ representation : thm ] by proving that a real is provably c.e . and chaitin - random iff it is provable that the real is the halting probability of a provably universal machine . 01 [ lem : repce ] let @xmath5 be a c.e . real defined by the increasing primitive recursive sequence @xmath156 of rationals . then there is a primitive recursive sequence @xmath157 of natural numbers such that pa proves @xmath257 without loss of generality assume @xmath159 . define the primitive recursive sequences @xmath160 and @xmath161 by @xmath162 and for @xmath163 by @xmath258 since @xmath165 is strictly increasing we can establish by induction @xmath166 for all @xmath110 , making the logarithm well - defined . by construction we have @xmath259 define @xmath168 . since @xmath260 we have @xmath261 taking the limit we see that @xmath171 establishing our result . let @xmath5 be a c.e . real defined by the increasing primitive recursive sequence @xmath156 of rationals . then there is a machine @xmath23 such that pa proves that @xmath172 . according to solovay @xcite a c.e . real @xmath5 _ solovay dominates _ a c.e . real @xmath262 ( we write @xmath263 ) if there are two computable , increasing sequences @xmath264 and @xmath265 of rationals and a constant @xmath85 with @xmath266 , @xmath267 , and @xmath268 , for all @xmath31 . for c.e . reals @xmath269 , pa proves @xmath263 if there are two primitive recursive , increasing sequences @xmath264 and @xmath265 of rationals and a constant @xmath85 such that pa proves @xmath266 , @xmath267 , and @xmath268 , for all @xmath31 . [ thm : dominates ] if @xmath5 is c.e . and provably ml - random , and @xmath262 is c.e . , then @xmath270 is provable in pa . let @xmath264 and @xmath265 be primitive recursive sequences of rationals with limits @xmath5 and @xmath262 respectively . let @xmath271 . for each @xmath31 , for @xmath163 if @xmath272 $ ] then define @xmath273 = [ a_i , a_i + 2^{-n } ( b_i - b_{s^{n } } ) ) , $ ] where @xmath274 \neq \emptyset\}$ ] is the most recent non - empty stage , or @xmath275 if this is the first non - empty stage . otherwise define @xmath276 = \emptyset$ ] . let @xmath277 denote the @xmath219th non - empty stage , wherever that is well - defined , and let @xmath278 . observe that @xmath279 = \bigcup_{j\ge1 } [ a_{s^{n}_j } , a_{s^{n}_j } + 2^{-n } ( b_{s^{n}_j } - b_{s^{n}_{j-1}}))\ ] ] and that all the sets in the above union are disjoint by construction . as a result @xmath280 so pa proves that @xmath281 is a ml - test . because @xmath5 is provably ml - random , pa proves that there exists an @xmath282 such that @xmath283 , so for all @xmath284 we know that @xmath285 is well - defined . by construction we have the inequality @xmath286 which implies that @xmath287 defining @xmath288 and @xmath289 , we have for all @xmath284 that @xmath290 where @xmath291 and @xmath292 are primitive recursive sequences of rationals which provably converge to @xmath5 and @xmath262 respectively . so pa proves @xmath270 . 01 * comment * with the notation @xmath293 as below , let @xmath294 = [ a'_i , a'_i + 2^{-n } ( b'_{i } - b'_{i-1})),\ ] ] and observe that @xmath295 $ ] implies that @xmath296 which contradicts the construction of @xmath297 $ ] by virtue of which for all @xmath298 we have @xmath299 $ ] , hence @xmath300 and @xmath301 . consequently , @xmath302 , so @xmath270 with constant @xmath303 . [ cor : dominates ] if @xmath5 is c.e . and provably chaitin - random and @xmath262 is c.e . , then @xmath270 is provable in pa . see theorems [ thm : chaitintoml ] and [ thm : dominates ] . 01 [ cor : dominates ] if @xmath12 is c.e . , ml - random , and @xmath304 is c.e . , then @xmath270 . [ thm : omegarep ] suppose @xmath8 is a provably universal machine , @xmath5 is c.e . , and @xmath305 is provable in pa . then there exists a provably universal machine @xmath0 such that @xmath306 is provable in pa . since @xmath305 , there exist primitive recursive increasing sequences @xmath264 and @xmath265 of rationals , with limits @xmath5 and @xmath307 respectively , and a constant @xmath207 such that for all @xmath31 @xmath308 define @xmath271 . form the real @xmath309 by equation ( [ th2:ss ] ) the terms of the sum are positive , so @xmath310 is c.e . applying lemma [ lem : repce ] to @xmath311 we get a primitive recursive sequence @xmath312 of natural numbers such that @xmath313 let @xmath314 be a 1 - 1 primitive recursive enumeration of @xmath315 , and define the sequence of requests @xmath316 where @xmath224 is an arbitrarily fixed element in @xmath315 . by theorem [ thm : kc ] we get a provably prefix - free machine @xmath23 and a primitive recursive enumeration @xmath117 of @xmath118 such that the following three statements are provable : 1 ) @xmath119 , 2 ) @xmath120 for all @xmath110 , 3 ) @xmath122 for all @xmath110 . consider the machine @xmath317 . the machine @xmath0 is provably universal . indeed , @xmath318 and @xmath319 , by construction of @xmath23 . finally , it is provable that @xmath320 using all results above we obtain : [ thm : representation ] a c.e . real @xmath5 is provably chaitin - random iff it is provable that @xmath7 for some provably universal machine @xmath0 . suppose @xmath5 is provably c.e . and chaitin - random . by theorem [ thm : chaitintoml ] , @xmath5 it is provably ml - random . take a provably universal machine @xmath8 ( theorem [ thm : nonprovunivmachine ] ) . from theorem [ thm : dominates ] we see that @xmath305 is provable in pa . by theorem [ thm : omegarep ] we effectively get a @xmath0 which is provably universal and prefix - free such that @xmath7 is provable in pa . the converse is exactly theorem [ thm : chaitin ] . [ cor : provchatinrandimpliesrand ] every provably c.e . and chaitin - random real is provably random . if @xmath5 is provably chaitin - random and c.e . then by theorem [ thm : representation ] , @xmath7 for some provably universal machine @xmath0 , so @xmath5 satisfies solovay s formula ( [ solovayformula ] ) with @xmath321 . this section proves its title . we start with the following result by solovay @xcite : [ lem : solovayrepresentation ] let @xmath8 be a universal machine . if @xmath5 is c.e . and ml - random , then there exists an integer @xmath207 and a c.e . real @xmath208 such that ( [ solovayformula ] ) is satisfied . 01 @xmath322 using the proof of theorem [ thm : dominates ] , we deduce that @xmath323 ( because @xmath5 is c.e . and ml - random ) . consequently , we can consider the primitive recursive increasing sequences @xmath264 and @xmath265 of rationals , with @xmath271 and converging to @xmath5 and @xmath307 respectively , and a constant @xmath207 such that for all @xmath31 , @xmath324 the c.e . real @xmath325 is positive and @xmath326 it is not difficult to see that the converse implication in lemma [ lem : solovayrepresentation ] is also true . in fact , a sharper result can be proved : [ thm : provablyrandom ] let @xmath8 be provably universal , @xmath207 be an integer , @xmath311 a positive c.e . then @xmath327 is provably chaitin - random ( ml - random ) . let @xmath328 be a primitive recursive enumeration of the domain of @xmath8 and @xmath329 be a primitive recursive increasing sequence with limit @xmath311 . the sequence of rationals @xmath330 is primitive recursive , increasing and converges to @xmath5 . take @xmath331 and observe that for all @xmath31 , @xmath332 hence pa proves that @xmath333 . using theorem [ thm : omegarep ] we can find a provably universal machine @xmath0 such that @xmath306 is provable in pa . by theorem [ thm : chaitin ] , @xmath5 is provably chaitin - random and by theorem [ thm : chaitintoml ] , @xmath5 is provably ml - random . we can now state our main result : [ thm : cerandprov ] every c.e . and random real is provably c.e . and chaitin - random ( ml - random ) , hence provably c.e . and random . start with a provably universal machine @xmath8 ( theorem [ thm : nonprovunivmachine ] ) . by lemma [ lem : solovayrepresentation ] there exist @xmath85 and @xmath311 defining the representation ( [ solovayformula ] ) for @xmath5 : @xmath334 since @xmath8 is provably universal , theorem [ thm : provablyrandom ] shows that that @xmath335 is provably chaitin - random ( ml - random ) . therefore @xmath5 is provably chaitin - random ( ml - random ) . finally use corollary [ cor : provchatinrandimpliesrand ] to deduce that @xmath5 is provably random . theorem [ thm : representation ] can now be stated in the form : [ thm : representationfinal ] a real @xmath5 is provably c.e . and random iff it is provable that @xmath7 for some provably universal machine @xmath0 . use theorem [ thm : cerandprov ] and corollary [ cor : provchatinrandimpliesrand ] . [ cor : uu ] for every universal machine @xmath0 there exists a provably universal machine @xmath336 such that @xmath337 . since @xmath68 is c.e . and random , by theorem [ thm : cerandprov ] we deduce that @xmath68 is provably chaitin - random , so by theorem [ thm : representation ] we get a provably universal machine @xmath336 such that @xmath337 . [ cor : secondrep ] every c.e . and random real can be written as the halting probability of a provably universal machine . use theorems [ thm : cerandprov ] and [ thm : representationfinal ] . from the previous two sections we know that every c.e . random real can be written as the halting probability of a provably universal machine , so it is provable random . does there exist a universal machine whose halting probability is not provable random ? by theorem [ thm : chaitin ] such a machine should not be provably universal ( and such machines exist by theorem [ thm : nonprovunivmachine ] ) . we answer in the affirmative this question . to this aim we fix an effective enumeration of all c.e . reals in ( 0,1 ) @xmath338 ( for example , by enumerating all increasing primitive recursive sequences of rationals in ( 0,1 ) ) and define the set @xmath339 . a set @xmath340 is called c.e . if the set @xmath341 is c.e . note that in @xmath70 we enumerate all indices for all elements in @xmath70 . [ upp ] @xcite if @xmath340 is c.e . , then for all c.e . reals @xmath342 and @xmath343 we have @xmath344 . let @xmath345 be a c.e . not computable set of natural numbers enumerated by a primitive recursive function @xmath346 , and for each @xmath31 let @xmath347 be a primitive recursive increasing sequence of rationals in ( 0,1 ) such that @xmath348 . let @xmath349 and define the function @xmath350 because @xmath343 there exists a natural @xmath351 such that @xmath352 . if @xmath353 , then there exists an @xmath282 such that @xmath354 , hence @xmath355 , for @xmath356 , so @xmath357 . if @xmath358 , then for all @xmath110 , @xmath359 , so @xmath360 . because of the uniform definition of @xmath361 we can construct a computable function @xmath61 such that @xmath362 . finally , let s assume by absurdity that @xmath363 . the set @xmath364 is c.e . because @xmath70 is c.e . , but in view of the definition of @xmath365 , @xmath366 , a non c.e . let @xmath367 be a c.e . enumeration of all universal machines . consider now the sets @xmath368 and @xmath369 by enumerating proofs in pa we deduce that @xmath370 is c.e . , so @xmath371 , for some primitive recursive function @xmath61 . we have : @xmath372 . is @xmath373 c.e . ? the answer is negative : [ thm : haltprobnotprov ] there exists a universal machine @xmath374 such that @xmath375 for all @xmath110 . take a universal machine @xmath0 such that @xmath376 and construct the c.e . real @xmath377 , where @xmath378 . as @xmath379 and @xmath262 is not random , @xmath380 , for all @xmath110 , so by lemma [ upp ] , @xmath381 is not c.e . , hence the theorem is proved . * comment * there is no contradiction between corollary [ cor : uu ] and theorem [ thm : haltprobnotprov ] : there exist a universal machine @xmath374 and a provably universal machine @xmath382 such that @xmath383 and @xmath384 for all @xmath110 : pa can not prove the randomness of @xmath385 based on @xmath374 , but can prove the randomness of @xmath383 based on @xmath382 . in the above we gave proofs that various statements , once suitably formalised in the language of first order logic , were derivable from the axioms of pa . in principle , but for lack of space and patience , we could have presented complete pa derivations of each statement proved . instead , as is common practice for all but the simplest of results , we sketched constructions which leave the actual derivations implicit . recent advances in theorem proving computer programs , such as the proof assistant isabelle @xcite , have allowed complete formal derivations of nontrivial mathematical results . in such systems , humans write a sequence of proof commands , and the computer system searches for a complete derivation , if one exists . essentially , the human user gives a sequence of intermediate lemma with proof directions , and the computer interpolates the full derivation . ( for a recent perspective on the importance of formalising mathematics see @xcite . ) using isabelle , we formalised and proved the kraft - chaitin theorem ( theorem [ thm : kc ] ) , a key result in our above proof . to keep our presentation self - contained , we begin by showing how to formalise and prove a simple result about strings ; for a full introduction to the isabelle system see @xcite . we follow with a formalisation of the kraft - chaitin theorem , then sketch its formal proof . the full proof script is available online @xcite . to illustrate isabelle and its use , we will formalise and prove the following simple property of strings : given strings @xmath386 , if @xmath98 extends @xmath232 then @xmath387 extends @xmath232 . strings are naturally represented by the isabelle list data - type . here represents the empty list , and y#ys represents the list formed by concatenating the element y with the list ys . for example , the string @xmath388 is represented by 0 # 0 # 1 # [ ] ( or for short ) . the following code inductively defines whether the list a extends b , denoted extends a b : .... fun extends : : " ' a list = > ' a list = > bool " where " extends [ ] [ ] = true " .... when faced with the above definition , isabelle automatically proves termination ( in this case , by observing that the first argument always decreases in length with each recursive call ) . let us first prove that any list extends the empty list . we enter into isabelle : .... lemma extends1 : " extends a [ ] " .... it responds with the propositions we need to prove : .... goal ( 1 subgoal ) : 1 . extends a [ ] .... it is natural to prove this by induction on a , by entering the command ` apply(induct a ) ` . this results in two proof obligations , one for the base case and the other for the inductive step : .... goal ( 2 subgoals ) : 1 . extends [ ] [ ] 2 . ! ! a a. extends a [ ] = = > extends ( a # a ) [ ] .... the first proposition is one of the cases in our definition of extend . in the second ! ! denotes universal quantification and this similarly follows from one of our definition cases . we tell isabelle to simplify these expressions with the command ` apply(simp_all ) ` . isabelle manages to simplify all these expressions down to true , using rewrite rules for simplifying conjunctions , variable identity , and expanding the definition of extends . as a result we get : .... goal : no subgoals ! .... having completed the proof , we compactly store it in the following format : .... lemma extends1 : " extends a [ ] " apply(induct a ) apply(simp_all ) done .... we can now attempt our original goal : .... lemma extends2 : " extends ( a@b ) a " goal ( 1 subgoal ) : 1 . extends ( a @ b ) a .... the concatenation of lists a and b is denoted a @ b. we again induct with the command ` apply(induct a ) ` , then simplify with the command ` apply(simp_all ) ` .... goal ( 2 subgoals ) : 1 . extends ( [ ] @ b ) [ ] 2 . ! ! a a. extends ( a @ b ) a = = > extends ( ( a # a ) @ b ) ( a # a ) goal ( 1 subgoal ) : 1 . extends b [ ] .... since we proved this before , we use the command ` apply(simp only : extends1 ) ` to reuse our previous result , completing the proof . in sum : .... lemma extends2 : " extends ( a@b ) a " apply(induct a ) apply(simp_all ) apply(simp only : extends1 ) done .... 01 [ thm : kc2 ] suppose @xmath115 is a primitive recursive enumeration of requests such that @xmath389 then there exists a provably prefix - free machine @xmath23 and a primitive recursive enumeration @xmath117 of @xmath118 such that the following is provable in pa : 1 . @xmath119 , 2 . @xmath120 for all @xmath121 , 3 . @xmath122 for all @xmath121 . @xmath124 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 , @xmath128 . let @xmath129 be the longest element of @xmath103 of length at most @xmath125 . if no such string exists , terminate . @xmath131 . define @xmath132 . @xmath135 . the proof of the kraft - chaitin theorem is algorithmic : it describes a particular algorithm ( algorithm [ alg : kc ] of theorem [ thm : kc ] ) for selecting strings of the required lengths , and proves that the algorithm is correct . in what follows we will implement this algorithm in isabelle and will prove its correctness . the following isabelle code implements algorithm [ alg : kc ] . we give the definition of each function , then explain what it does . .... fun extend : : " nat list = > nat = > nat list list " where " extend l 0 = [ l ] " # tl ( extend l n ) " .... for l a binary list representing a binary string , and n a natural number , extend l n computes the list @xmath390.\ ] ] for example , in isabelle the expression extend [ 0,0,1 ] 5 evaluates to this corresponds to the set @xmath391 of binary strings . the set of unallocated prefixes @xmath123 and the set of allocated strings @xmath140 are represented by lists of strings . the free prefixes are ordered by decreasing length , the allocated strings by the order of allocation . consider one iteration of the main loop . let a be the list of previously allocated strings , f the list of free prefixes , and n the length of the string we want to allocate at this step . ( these are denoted @xmath140 , @xmath123 , and @xmath125 in the original algorithm . ) kcstep a f n returns the updated pair of allocated strings and free prefixes ( @xmath153 and @xmath392 ) . .... consts kcstep : : " nat list list = > nat list list = > nat = > ( nat list list * nat list list ) " primrec " kcstep a [ ] n = ( a , [ ] ) " ( * fail case * ) " kcstep a ( f # f ) n = ( if length f < = n then ( ( hd ( extend f ( n - length f ) ) ) # a , ( tl ( extend f ( n - length f ) ) ) @ f ) else ( fst ( kcstep a f n ) , f # snd ( kcstep a f n ) ) ) " .... kcstep searches through the list f of free prefixes for the longest string of length at most n. one it finds it , it calls extend , which returns a list of extended prefixes . it takes the first string in the list , guaranteed to have exactly length n , and adds it to the allocated strings list . the rest of the strings are placed on the free prefixes list . for example , kcstep [ ] [ [ ] ] 2 evaluates to ( [ [ 0,0 ] ] , [ [ 0,1 ] , [ 1 ] ] ) which corresponds to the list @xmath393 of allocated strings and the set @xmath394 of free prefixes . .... consts kcloop : : " nat list = > ( nat list list * nat list list ) = > ( nat list list * nat list list ) " primrec " kcloop [ ] x = x " " kcloop ( l#ls ) x = ( kcstep ( fst ( kcloop ls x ) ) ( snd ( kcloop ls x ) ) l ) " .... for a list of lengths l and a pair ( a , f ) of allocated strings and free prefixes , kcloop l ( a , f ) runs kcstep to allocate strings for every length in l. for example , kcloop [ 3,4,2 ] ( [ ] , [ [ ] ] ) allocates a string of length 2 , then one of length 4 , then one of length 3 , starting from the initial state where no strings are yet allocated ( ) and the empty string is our free prefix ( ) . for example , kcloop [ 3 , 2 ] ( [ ] , [ [ ] ] ) evaluates to ( [ [ 0,1,0 ] , [ 0,0 ] ] , [ [ 0,1,1 ] , [ 1 ] ] ) which corresponds to the list @xmath395 of allocated strings ( note that we reverse the list ) , and the set @xmath396 of free prefixes . .... fun kc : : " nat list = > nat list list " where " kc ls = ( fst ( kcloop ls ( [ ] , [ [ ] ] ) ) ) " .... for a list of lengths l , kc l returns the list of strings allocated by running kcloop on the list starting from the initial state where no strings have been allocated . for example , kc [ 4,3,2 ] evaluates to which corresponds to the sequence @xmath397 of allocated strings . this implements kraft - chaitin s algorithm , for we will prove that : 1 . if our list of lengths obeys kraft s inequality , @xmath398 , then kc ls is a list of strings , and the @xmath110th element of kc ls has length equal to the @xmath110th element of ls . kc ls is always a prefix - free list ( no two distinct elements of the list are prefixes of each other ) . if we add new lengths to the start of ls , then this adds new strings to the end of kc ls without changing the old ones . that is , once a string of a given length is allocated it is not changed . to prove the above we need to define what a prefix - free list is , a function to evaluate kraft s inequality , a function which checks whether the lengths of one list match the lengths in another , and a tool to check whether one list extends another . .... fun prefixes : : " nat list = > nat list = > bool " where " prefixes [ ] x = true " consts incomparable : : " nat list = > nat list list = > bool " primrec " incomparable x [ ] = true " " incomparable x ( y # ys ) = ( ~(prefixes x y ) & ( incomparable x ys ) ) " consts prefixfree : : " nat list list = > bool " primrec " prefixfree [ ] = true " " prefixfree ( x # xs ) = ( ( incomparable x xs ) & ( prefixfree xs ) ) " .... if x is a prefix of y , or vice versa , then prefixes x y. for example prefixes [ 0,0,1 ] [ 0,0 ] is true . incomparable x a holds if x is not a prefix of any string in a , for instance incomparable [ 0,0 ] [ [ 1,0 ] , [ 1,1,1 ] ] holds . prefixfree l holds if the list l is prefix - free , for instance prefixfree [ [ 0,0 ] , [ 1,0 ] , [ 1,1,1 ] ] holds . .... consts expn2 : : " nat = > rat " primrec " expn2 0 = 1 " " expn2 ( suc n ) = ( 1/2 ) * expn2 n " consts meas_nat : : " nat list = > rat " primrec " meas_nat [ ] = 0 " " meas_nat ( f#f ) = ( expn2 f + meas_nat f ) " .... we define expn2 n equal to @xmath399 . meas_nat f computes the `` measure '' of a sequence of natural numbers f , for example meas_nat [ 4,3,2 ] equals 7/16 . .... fun lengthsmatch : : " nat list list = > nat list = > bool " where " lengthsmatch [ ] [ ] = true " .... the expression lengthsmatch x y holds if the lengths of each string in x matches the corresponding number in y. for example , we have lengthsmatch [ [ 0,0 ] , [ 1,0 ] , [ 1,1,1 ] ] [ 2,2,3 ] is true . .... fun extends : : " ' a list = > ' a list = > bool " where " extends [ ] [ ] = true " .... finally , extends a b holds if the list a extends the list b , so extends [ 0,1 ] [ 0 ] holds . with the above definitions we can state the three results which establish correctness : .... theorem kc_correct1 : " meas_nat ls < = 1 = = > lengthsmatch ( kc ls ) ls " theorem kc_correct2 : " prefixfree ( kc ls ) " theorem kc_extend : " extends ( rev ( kc ( l2 @ l1 ) ) ) ( rev ( kc l1 ) ) " .... the first says that if ls is a list of natural numbers @xmath125 which satisfies kraft s inequality @xmath400 , then the strings kc ls allocated by running algorithm [ alg : kc ] on this list have exactly the lengths ls we asked for . the second says the strings allocated are prefix - free . the last says that when algorithm [ alg : kc ] allocates additional strings it does not change strings it has previously allocated . to see this , note that when we run kc l the algorithm allocates strings starting from the end of the list l. this means , the first element of kc l is the last string allocated . kc ( l2 @ l1 ) is the list of strings allocated if we allocate strings with lengths in l1 then strings with lengths in l2 . together , establishing these would show that the kc algorithm constructively establishes the kraft - chaitin theorem . all the above merely formalised the algorithm and stated the theorem we wish isabelle to prove . this gets the order mixed slightly , since formalising this theorem unearthed a mistake in the algorithm , so the process was mutual . in some sense this formalisation of the theorem is the major creative work , the rest is just technical detail . as one might guess , however , most of the work is in these details . to prove the above theorems we must guide isabelle to them by establishing numerous intermediate lemmas , and telling isabelle which proof techniques to use to establish each . often we just advise isabelle to induct on a variable then simplify , but sometimes we must give more detailed guidance . the isabelle proof follows the proof given for theorem [ thm : kc ] : we establish that the inner loop preserves some invariants , and use these invariants to establish correctness . recall the algorithm has two variables : the list of allocated strings and the list of free strings . each pass through the loop will ( potentially ) add one new allocated string , and modify the free strings . we then show that these two lists combined remain prefix - free , their joint measure never decreases , and that there are never two free strings of the same length . for reasons of space we give only the definitions required to state the above intermediate results and show how they are formalised in isabelle . the proof in its entirety is available online @xcite . .... fun strictlysorted : : " nat list list = > bool " where " strictlysorted [ ] = true " & ( strictlysorted ( x2 # xs ) ) ) " .... strictlysorted l holds if the strings in l are ordered by ( strictly ) decreasing length . in particular , this means there can be no two strings of the same length in l. .... fun inv1 : : " nat list list * nat list list = > bool " where " inv1 x = strictlysorted ( snd x ) " fun inv2 : : " nat list list * nat list list = > bool " where " inv2 x = prefixfree ( ( fst x ) @ ( snd x ) ) " .... the first invariant is that the list of free strings is strictly sorted . this is needed to show both that there is at most one string of any given length and to show that the algorithm will always select the longest string it is able to . .... fun inv : : " nat list list * nat list list = > bool " where " inv x = ( ( inv1 x ) & ( inv2 x ) ) " theorem kcstep_inv : " inv ( a , f ) = = > inv ( kcstep a f n ) " .... this says simply that if the invariants held of the variables before running through the loop once , then they hold afterwards . .... consts meas : : " nat list list = > rat " ( * the measure of a prefix free set * ) primrec " meas [ ] = 0 " " meas ( x # xs ) = expn2 ( length x ) + meas xs " .... this defines the measure of a list of strings : the usual @xmath401 . .... lemma kcstep_meas : " meas ( ( fst ( kcstep a f n ) ) @ ( snd ( kcstep a f n ) ) ) = meas ( a@f ) " .... this says that measure is preserved at each step of the loop . this measure will be 1 for all the intermediate states of the kc algorithm , but we need this more general result for the inductive proofs to work . a number of further intermediate results are required both to establish the above invariants and to apply them to the main theorems . below are three of the most important , which one may recall from the proof of theorem [ thm : kc ] ( in total , there are 102 theorems and lemmas proved ) . .... theorem meas_alloc : " [ | expn2 n < = meas f ; strictlysorted f | ] = = > length ( last f ) < = n " lemma kcstep_correct1 : " [ |inv ( a , f ) ; expn2 n < = meas f| ] = = > ( tl ( fst ( kcstep a f n ) ) = a ) & ( length ( hd ( fst ( kcstep a f n ) ) ) = n ) " lemma kcstep_correct2 : " [ |inv ( a , f ) ; expn2 n < = meas f| ] = = > meas ( fst ( kcstep a f n ) ) = meas a + expn2 n " .... theorem meas_alloc formalises the result that if @xmath399 is smaller than the measure of a set @xmath402 , and that set has no two strings of the same length , then there is a string of length at most @xmath31 in @xmath402 . lemma kcstep_correct1 says that if the invariants are satisfied by the current variables a and f , and the measure of f is at least @xmath399 , then kcstep succeeds . this means that we allocate one new string of length exactly @xmath31 , leaving the old strings untouched . lemma kcstep_correct2 expresses an implied result : if the algorithm succeeds , then the measure of the list of allocated strings increases by exactly @xmath399 ( isabelle will often not notice conclusions that seem obvious to the prover ; they must be spelt out ) . if pa receives an algorithm for a machine @xmath8 , a proof that @xmath8 is universal and prefix - free , an integer @xmath207 , and a computable increasing sequence of rationals converging to a real @xmath113 , then pa can prove that @xmath209 is c.e . and random . similarly , if pa receives an algorithm for a machine @xmath0 , a proof that @xmath0 is universal and prefix - free , then it can prove that @xmath1 is c.e . and random . this implies that every c.e . random real is provably c.e . and random as stated in solovay s email @xcite . we have offered two representations for c.e . and random reals from which pa can prove that the real is c.e . and random . in the first we fix a provably universal prefix - free machine @xmath8 and we vary the integer @xmath207 and the c.e . real @xmath113 to get via the formula @xmath403 all c.e . and random reals . in the second we vary all provably universal prefix - free machines @xmath0 to get via @xmath68 all c.e . and random reals . a key result was to show that the theorem that `` a real is c.e . and random iff it is the halting probability of a universal machine '' @xcite can be proved in pa . our proof , which is simpler than the standard one , can be used also for the original theorem . we proved two negative results showing the importance of the representation for provability of randomness : a ) there exists a universal machine whose universality can not be proved in pa , b ) there exists a universal machine @xmath0 such that , based on @xmath0 , pa can not prove the randomness of @xmath68 . chaitin @xcite explicitly computed a constant @xmath85 such that if @xmath404 is larger than the size in bits of the program for enumerating the theorems of pa plus @xmath85 , then pa can not prove that a specific string @xmath98 has complexity greater than @xmath404 , @xmath405 . consequently , pa can not prove randomness of almost all random ( finite ) strings . our positive result shows an interesting difference between the finite and the infinite cases of ( algorithmic ) randomness . does our positive result contradict chaitin and solovay s negative results discussed in the introduction ? the answer is negative because the digits of the binary expansion of a random c.e . real are not computable . our positive result would not be satisfactory without demonstrating our proofs with an automatic theorem prover . we have chosen isabelle @xcite to obtain an automatic proof of our version of the kraft - chaitin theorem , one of the key results of this paper . the paper contains a description of the formalisation ( for isabelle ) of the kraft - chaitin theorem and the description of the main steps of the automatic proof ; the full proof is available online @xcite . finally we speculate about the role of the automatic prover . how can an automatic theorem prover help understanding / proving a mathematical statement ? there are at least three possibilities . a ) use the prover to verify the theorem by discovering a proof , call it `` solovay mode '' ( because this corresponds to the result reported in this paper : bob solovay communicated to one of us the statement to be proved and we found a proof ) . it is worth observing that the kraft - chaitin theorem has two `` roles '' : one , as an algorithm , to be executed , the other , as a mathematical statement , to be proved . previous formalisation efforts focused only on the first part ; our present work was directed towards the second . one could imagine that mathematical journals might use such systems in the process of refereeing @xcite . b ) the second possibility is to use the prover to verify a human - made proof a full isabelle proof for all results in this paper is under construction . c ) the third possibility is to use the prover as some kind of `` assistant '' in an interactive process of discovery / proving . during the work to automate the proof of the kraft - chaitin theorem a mistake in our human - made argument was unearthed and corrected . we also used the experience with isabelle to test the adequacy of the representation of a c.e . random real in meeting the goal : to obtain the pa proof of randomness . we thank bob solovay for suggesting the result of this paper and useful comments , jeremy dawson for helpful advice on the isabelle proof , and greg chaitin , liam fearnley , bruno grenet , mathieu hoyrup , andr nies , cristobal rojas , frank stephan , garry tee and the anonymous referee for useful comments which improved our paper . 99 w. s. brainerd , l. h. landweber . _ theory of computation _ , wiley , new york , 1974 . c. s. calude . chaitin @xmath246 numbers , solovay machines and incompleteness , _ theoret . comput . _ 284 ( 2002 ) , 269277 . c. s. calude . a characterization of c.e random reals , _ theoret . _ 271 ( 2002 ) , 314 . c. s. calude _ information and randomness . an algorithmic perspective _ , 2nd edition , revised and extended , springer verlag , berlin , 2002 . c. s. calude , p. hertling , b. khoussainov , and y. wang . recursively enumerable reals and chaitin @xmath246 numbers , in : m. morvan , c. meinel , d. krob ( eds . ) , _ proceedings of the 15th symposium on theoretical aspects of computer science ( paris ) _ , springer verlag , berlin , 1998 , 596606 . full paper in _ theoret . _ 255 ( 2001 ) , 125149 . r. m. solovay . a version of @xmath246 for which zfc can not predict a single bit , in c.s . calude , g. pun ( eds . ) . _ finite versus infinite . contributions to an eternal dilemma _ , springer - verlag , london , 2000 , 323334 . r. m. solovay . _ draft of a paper ( or series of papers ) on chaitin s work done for the most part during the period of sept.dec . 1974 _ , unpublished manuscript , ibm thomas j. watson research center , yorktown heights , new york , may 1975 , 215 pp . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: recent observational surveys ( e.g. , cosmos , goods , gems , sings , sdss , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) have allowed us for the first time to statistically explore issues of galaxy formation . one of the immediate challenges to disk formation theory that is presented by these observations comes in the form of evidence that there has been little change in the sizes of disk galaxies since @xmath2=1 , despite an expectation that disks should be growing in size over this time . observations tell us that there exist large disks by @xmath2=1 ( before the universe was even half of its present age ) , and suggesting that these disks must be assembled prior to this epoch ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? recent observations lend strong support to the existence of disks back to even higher redshifts @xcite , and for disk assembly at even higher redshifts in the form of clump - chain galaxies in the hubble ultra deep field @xcite . results from large surveys suggest that there has been only weak evolution in disk sizes since @xmath2=1 . there is no evidence that the size function of disks has evolved back to @xmath2=1 @xcite . @xcite found that the shape of the size function did not evolve with redshift , though the normalization ( or amplitude ) did . this can be interpreted in two ways . first , the normalization will vary if the number density of disks varies with time . however , observations suggest that the number density of disks is constant to @xmath2=1 @xcite . second , if it is assumed that galaxies dim with time ( e.g. , due to a passively evolving stellar population or decline in star formation rate ) , a 1 to 1.5 magnitude dimming since @xmath2=1 could explain the change in normalization , while keeping the size distribution of disks constant @xcite . hence , there is no immediate evidence for a change in the sizes of galaxy disks with time . studies of the evolution in the magnitude size relationship for disk galaxies back to @xmath2=1 have found similar results . importantly , these studies must use surface brightness evolution to interpret evolution within the magnitude size plane . this is not straightforward , as an increase in disk scale lengths at a fixed magnitude between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 can be mimicked by a decrease in luminosity at a fixed size @xcite . selection effects are difficult to disentangle , and studies that require high and low @xmath2 samples to adhere to the same selection biases have found that large disks are consistent with no evolution in surface brightness @xcite . later studies concluded that this work was too restrictive , and that a careful treatment of completeness as a function of redshift supports surface brightness dimming over time @xcite . most studies conclude that pure size evolution at a fixed magnitude is ruled out @xcite . instead , the observed surface brightness evolution is best explained by luminosity dimming , with the amount of dimming dependent on galaxy size so that lower mass galaxies have undergone more dimming since @xmath2=1 than massive galaxies @xcite . however , some amount of size evolution ca nt be ruled out , and at least weak size evolution is favored @xcite . while magnitude is assumed to scale with the mass of a galaxy , it is obvious from the above discussion that magnitude at a given mass is not necessarily constant in time . the more fundamental relation is between size and stellar mass . magnitude at a given stellar mass is likely to increase back to @xmath2=1 due to the fact that there is an evolving star formation rate ( sfr ) mass relation @xcite . @xcite examined the stellar mass size relation for disk dominated galaxies back to @xmath2=1 , and found weak or no evolution . this result can be interpreted in two ways . first , given the change of @xmath81 magnitude of surface brightness dimming in the same population , the result is consistent with a passively evolving stellar population at a given mass , with no growth of galaxy disks . second , it could imply that galaxies are growing , but that they must grow in such a way as to evolve _ along _ the stellar mass size relation with time . on the other hand , galaxy disk formation theory predicts that the sizes of disks , both individual and as a population , should be growing since @xmath2=1 . in the standard picture , gas in a halo conserves its specific angular momentum ( equal to that of the dark matter ) as it cools to form a centrifugally supported disk that grows from the inside out @xcite . in the simplest model , in which the density profile of galaxies is modeled as a singular isothermal sphere ( sis ) , the radius of the resulting disk is proportional to the parent halo virial radius , which grows inversely with the hubble parameter , @xmath9 . for a concordance @xmath0cdm cosmology @xcite , this relation predicts that disks at @xmath2=1 should be nearly a factor of two smaller than their @xmath2=0 counterparts at the same circular velocity , @xmath10 @xcite . @xcite adopted more reasonable assumptions to update the simple theoretical model that suggests that galaxy disks should grow by nearly a factor of two since @xmath2=1 , primarily by adopting nfw density profiles rather than sis profiles . unlike the sis model , the concentrations of nfw profiles were lower in the past . combined with disk stability arguments @xcite , this model predicts a much weaker evolution in disk sizes ( 15%-20% ) at a fixed stellar mass , consistent with the @xcite results . these semi - analytic models ( sams ) do not follow the evolution of individual disk galaxies with time . rather , they examine an instantaneous population of disks . clearly , this is the type of information derived from observations , but it prevents an interpretation of the evolution in individual disk galaxies based on observations of the population as a whole . @xcite instead follow the evolution of individual disks in their sam , and demonstrate that disks tend to grow along the stellar mass size relation , with only weak evolution , consistent with the results of @xcite . the analytic models discussed above ( e.g. , * ? ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) have until recently been the only available theoretical tool with which to investigate the evolution of galactic disk sizes ( though see * ? ? ? simulations , with their ability to capture complex gas processes in mergers and subsequent sf , should be an ideal tool that allow a better trace of the distribution of stellar light , while sams must assume that light follows mass . however , simulations of disk galaxy formation in a cdm context have historically produced unrealistic disks that are too compact ( dense ) , too small overall , and rotating too fast at a given radius ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this failure has been named the `` angular momentum catastrophe . '' this catastrophe has been largely associated with the overcooling problem , in which baryons cool too quickly at early times and become very dense and concentrated at the center of halos before merging . these halos then experience dynamical friction in subsequent mergers , and the resulting disks show the classic signs of the angular momentum catastrophe @xcite . thus , feedback mechanisms at early times have historically been invoked to prevent overcooling with moderate success @xcite but additional artificial exchange of angular momentum can still occur between baryons and dark matter in sph simulations with low numerical resolution @xcite . hence , to avoid the angular momentum catastrophe and produce realistic disks , simulations must have both a physically motivated feedback prescription , and very high numerical ( mass and force ) resolution @xcite . the simulations used in this study are part of a suite of very high numerical resolution disk galaxy simulations that incorporate a star formation ( sf ) and supernova ( sn ) feedback scheme that has been shown to overcome many of the past problems of disk galaxy simulations to successfully match a number of observed properties of galaxies ( as discussed further below , and shown by the results of this paper ) . in this paper , we use simulations of individual disk galaxies to follow their evolution in the magnitude size plane and the stellar mass size plane . we attempt to mimic the observations of these galaxies in a manner similar to the observed population , generating mock surface brightness images to measure disk scale lengths , avoiding the assumption that light must follow mass . we demonstrate that the simulated galaxies have properties similar to real galaxies . in 2 we describe our small sample of very high resolution simulated disk galaxies that span a representative range of masses , merger histories , and spin values . we show that our limited sample is in excellent agreement with the population of galaxies surveyed at both @xmath2=0 ( 3 ) and @xmath2=1 ( 4 ) . in 5 , we disentangle the evolution of individual galaxies from the evolution seen in the population as a whole . we conclude in 6 . these simulations were run with the n - body + smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) code gasoline @xcite in a fully cosmological @xmath0cdm context using wmap year 3 parameters ( @xmath11 , @xmath0=0.74 , @xmath12 , @xmath13=0.77 , n=0.96 ) . the galaxies were originally selected from either a 25mpc or 50mpc ( depending on their mass ) n - body simulation with uniform mass resolution throughout , and then resimulated at higher resolution with baryons using the volume renormalization technique @xcite . this technique allows for significantly higher resolution on the central galaxy while also capturing the effect of large scale torques that are thought to deliver angular momentum to the galaxy @xcite . the sf / sn scheme used in these simulations has been shown to effectively regulate star formation efficiency as a function of halo mass , resulting in a stellar mass metallicity relationship for the simulated galaxies that is in excellent agreement with observations both locally and at high @xmath2 @xcite . this regulation of star formation also leads to realistic trends in gas fractions , with our lowest mass galaxies being the most gas rich @xcite , reproducing the observed incidence rate of damped lyman @xmath14 systems ( qso - dlas ) at @xmath2 = 3 @xcite , and the column densities of both qso - dlas and grb - dlas at @xmath2 = 3 @xcite . of critical importance for the present study is the fact that these simulated disks maintain sufficient angular momentum to match the observed tully - fisher relationship @xcite and produce galaxies with realistic disk sizes , as shown below . the full details of our physically motivated sn feedback implementation were originally presented in @xcite . briefly , the sf prescription ensures that the sfr density is a function of gas density according to the observed slope of the kennicutt - schmidt law , and a sf efficiency parameter , @xmath15 , sets the normalization of this relation . each star particle represents a simple stellar population , born with a kroupa initial mass function @xcite . as massive stars go sn , energy and metals are deposited into the nearest neighbor gas particles . the sn feedback recipe calculates the radius affected , and turns off cooling in those affected neighboring gas particles until the end of the snowplow phase as described by the sedov - taylor solution @xcite . the amount of energy deposited amongst those neighbors is 0.4@xmath1610@xmath17 ergs , as was adopted in all of our previous work mentioned above . additionally , we include a uniform uv cosmic background following an updated model of @xcite . @xcite demonstrated that when force resolutions @xmath18100pc can be achieved , high density peaks that mimic sf regions in giant molecular clouds can be resolved with several hundreds of gas particles in @xmath810@xmath19 m@xmath7 clumps ( see also * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this allows for the adoption of a realistic density threshold for sf ( 100 amu/@xmath20 , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . to match the kennicutt - schmidt law , the high density sf threshold must be offset by a slightly higher value of @xmath15 = 0.1 . this prescription leads to enhanced gas outflows that remove low angular momentum gas from the central regions of the galaxy ( * ? ? ? * brook et al . , in prep . ) . at low masses , this creates a bulgeless disk with a linearly rising rotation curve , comparable to those observed ( oh et al . , in prep ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the low mass galaxies used in this paper , drawn from a 25mpc volume , can achieve force resolutions @xmath8100pc . hence , these simulations adopt the more realistic feedback prescription with high density sf and @xmath15 = 0.1 . however , the more massive galaxies presented here are drawn from 50mpc volumes , making it computational expensive to achieve similar force resolutions in a reasonable time . hence , these simulated galaxies can not resolve the high density sf peaks easily , and a lower sf density threshold must be adopted , 0.1 amu/@xmath20 , with a lower @xmath15 = 0.05 . these latter values have been adopted in all of our previous work on mw mass galaxies @xcite , and are a compromise that allow realistic disks to form , but are inefficient at driving gas outflows . thus , low angular momentum material that might be lost from the central regions is maintained , helping lead to the creation of large bulges in the mw mass galaxies ( see also * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? additionally , the creation of these large bulges can be due to missing physics . in particular , agn feedback has not yet been added to these simulations , and is potentially a key mechanism to help create realistic bulges . due to our small sample size , it is difficult to quantify if our bulges are substantially different from observed bulges in the same galaxy mass range . the simulated galaxies used in this work were selected to span a range of spin values and merger histories , with the last major merger redshift as low at 0.8 . properties of these simulations are listed in table [ simsum ] . lcccccccccr h516 & 3.9@xmath1610@xmath21 & 2.6@xmath1610@xmath22 & 1.6@xmath1610@xmath23 & 3.3@xmath1610@xmath24 & 0.05 & 0.05 & 1.2 & 87 & 3.5@xmath1610@xmath25 + h799 & 2.2@xmath1610@xmath21 & 1.3@xmath1610@xmath22 & 1.6@xmath1610@xmath23 & 3.3@xmath1610@xmath24 & 0.04 & 0.05 & 3.0 & 87 & 1.9@xmath1610@xmath25 + h603 & 3.8@xmath1610@xmath26 & 3.1@xmath1610@xmath21 & 3.0@xmath1610@xmath27 & 6.3@xmath1610@xmath23 & 0.06 & 0.11 & 1.1 & 231 & 3.8@xmath1610@xmath25 + h986 & 2.1@xmath1610@xmath26 & 2.2@xmath1610@xmath21 & 3.0@xmath1610@xmath27 & 6.3@xmath1610@xmath23 & 0.04 & 0.07 & 0.8 & 231 & 2.4@xmath1610@xmath25 + h239 & 8.5@xmath1610@xmath26 & 7.8@xmath1610@xmath21 & 1.2@xmath1610@xmath25 & 2.1@xmath1610@xmath27 & 0.03 & 0.05 & 1.1 & 347 & 2.8@xmath1610@xmath25 + h258 & 8.0@xmath1610@xmath26 & 7.4@xmath1610@xmath21 & 1.2@xmath1610@xmath25 & 2.1@xmath1610@xmath27 & 0.04 & 0.07 & 0.8 & 347 & 2.8@xmath1610@xmath25 + h277 & 7.1@xmath1610@xmath26 & 6.9@xmath1610@xmath21 & 1.2@xmath1610@xmath25 & 2.1@xmath1610@xmath27 & 0.03 & 0.04 & 3.0 & 347 & 2.3@xmath1610@xmath25 + h285 & 8.7@xmath1610@xmath26 & 8.1@xmath1610@xmath21 & 1.2@xmath1610@xmath25 & 2.1@xmath1610@xmath27 & 0.02 & 0.05 & 1.9 & 347 & 3.0@xmath1610@xmath25 + all of our simulations are of field galaxies that do not undergo major mergers below @xmath280.5 , making them disk dominated at redshift zero . in order to compare our simulated disk scale lengths to observational results in as realistic a way as possible , we wish to fit the _ light _ profile rather than the underlying mass profile . we create artificial surface brightness images of our simulated galaxies using sunrise @xcite , a monte carlo radiative transfer program that produces a spectral energy distribution ( sed ) for each resolution element of the simulations . this is done by identifying the age and metallicity of each star particle , which are then convolved with the starburst99 stellar population synthesis models @xcite to produce an sed . sunrise assumes dust tracks with the metallicity of the gas particles , and performs ray tracing from each star particle to compute the observed sed including absorption and scattering . from this , we generate mock images in chosen filter bands . figure [ fig1 ] shows artificial edge - on and face - on @xmath1 band images , including dust reprocessing , for two different mass galaxies . most of the observational surveys that have investigated the evolution of disk sizes worked in the rest frame @xmath1 band across redshifts . to compare to these results as a function of redshift , we have generated face on @xmath29 band surface brightness images at @xmath2=0.5 and @xmath2=1 that include the effects of surface brightness dimming , and using rest frame face on @xmath1 band surface brightness images for the @xmath2=0 galaxies . two of our disk galaxies are undergoing a major , disruptive merger at @xmath2=1 . for these galaxies , we created face on images for the most massive progenitor at a time just prior to the merger ( @xmath2=1.25 ) while the disk was still rather undisturbed . the face on sunrise images were fit with a sersic bulge component and an exponential disk component using the publicly available 2d surface brightness fitting code galfit @xcite . additionally , bars exist in both h603 and h986 at @xmath2=1 that were fit by a third component , reducing the b / d ratio of these galaxies at this step . the galfit results were checked against a 1d , radially averaged fit generated from the same images , and found to be in good agreement . to mimic observations , the fits were required to be a good match down to a limiting surface brightness value of @xmath826 mag / arcsec@xmath30 ( hence the importance of using surface brightness dimmed images at @xmath2=1 ) . example fits are shown in fig . [ sb ] for the same galaxies shown in fig . [ fig1 ] , with @xmath31 band fits shown simply for a comparison of the @xmath1 band results to those at a longer wavelength . we verified that using redshifted , surface brightness dimmed sunrise images in the @xmath29 band at higher z yielded similar disk scale lengths as the rest frame @xmath1 band . as can be seen in table [ simsum ] , a couple of these galaxies have undergone major mergers since @xmath2=1 , while some galaxies have had a very quiescent history . we note that at @xmath2=1 , two of our galaxies ( h239 and h285 ) had no component that could be well fit by an exponential . this may be due to mergers that occur in these galaxies near this time . galaxy h239 has the most active merger history of our simulated galaxies , with continual mergers ( both major and minor ) until @xmath280.5 . galaxy h285 begins to accrete a satellite with 1/7 of the stellar mass of the main halo at @xmath2=1.25 . however , the core of this satellite does not merge with the main halo until @xmath280.8 . in both cases , we searched in 250 myr periods from 0.75 @xmath32 1.25 to identify a step with a possible exponential disk , but none could be found . hence , those steps have been excluded from the high redshift analysis below . @xcite demonstrated that measuring disk scale lengths based on light rather than a kinematic decomposition could dramatically increase the resulting disk - to - total , d / t , ratio of their simulated galaxies , making measurement technique a potentially important reconciler between observations and simulations . in fig . [ ml ] we plot the @xmath2=0 surface mass density as a function of radius for both the stars ( solid line ) and the gas ( dashed line ) in the simulated galaxies . also shown as the dotted line is the exponential fit derived in the @xmath29 band for these simulations ( listed in table [ simsum ] ) . in a future paper ( mccleary et al . , in prep ) , we will explore in detail the differences between mass / kinematic results and light results ( e.g. , scale lengths , bulge - to - disk ratios , the role of dust and inclination , etc . ) . here , however , we note that an initial comparison of mass versus light exponential scale lengths demonstrates a less dramatic difference in our simulations than in @xcite . as seen in fig . [ ml ] , the @xmath29 band scale length is generally a good match to the stellar surface mass density . for a quantitative comparison , scale lengths were derived for the stellar mass over the same region that the disk dominates the light profile . the two methods were found to agree to within 10% for 75% of the galaxies . variation in the techniques appears to be mostly attributable to varying mass - to - light ratios ( mccleary et al . , in prep ) . the bulge / disk decompositions were performed on the dust extinguished sunrise results . however , disk scale lengths and central surface brightnesses were found to be identical in both the face on sunrise images with and without dust reprocessing , while the central bulge component was dust extinguished . thus , using the dust extinguished versus non dust extinguished decomposition has no effect on the results for the disk analysis presented below . it is generally expected that dust should have some effect on both the central surface brightness and the scale length of the disk component , even for face on orientations @xcite . we speculate that our more massive galaxies have little / no effect from dust due to the fact that they are also more gas poor than observed galaxies ( because they use up gas forming too many stars , discussed in more detail in section [ comp ] ) . our low mass galaxies are gas rich , in agreement with observed galaxies in this mass range @xcite , but metal poor @xcite , making dust negligible . it is important to note that the following analysis purposely focuses on the evolution of the _ disk _ alone . that is , the discussion below of how properties evolve with time neglects the bulge component of the galaxy . this is done for three reasons . first , as discussed above , our mw - mass galaxies tend to have larger bulges than observed . this is a problem that has historically plagued mw - mass simulated disks ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and is likely due to the inability to correctly model sf and feedback at the necessary high resolutions to drive loss of low angular momentum gas , and due to missing physics such as agn feedback . hence , while the disks of our simulated galaxies appear to be in good agreement with observed disks ( as presented below ) , the growth of the bulge in these massive galaxies is probably not modeled correctly . second , observations of the evolution of disk galaxies in the magnitude size plane have either a ) selected galaxies that can be fit with a small pure sersic index , @xmath33 , so that they are disk dominated , or b ) done a bulge / disk decomposition . in either case , the results we wish to compare to are concerned with disks only . finally , our goal here is to examine the growth of _ disks _ using these simulations , not bulges or spheroidal components . `` observable '' properties of the simulated galaxies are listed in table [ obssum ] . total magnitudes in each band are derived from sunrise , with each galaxy being integrated out to roughly 50 comoving kpc ( i.e. , essentially all of the flux from the simulated galaxy is contained ) . table [ obssum ] also lists the @xmath2=0 stellar mass derived for the entire galaxy ( disk + spheroid ) based on sunrise colors using the k_sdss_bell routine in the kcorrect package @xcite . a comparison to table [ simsum ] shows that the simulated stellar masses are generally @xmath840% larger than those derived from the photometric results . a more detailed comparison will be presented in mccleary et al . , ( in prep ) . in table [ obssum ] we list the bulge - to - disk ratios ( b / d ) despite the caveat mentioned above regarding large bulges in our higher mass galaxies . disk scale lengths in the @xmath29 band at @xmath2=0 are given in table [ obssum ] , while the @xmath1 band scale lengths used in the following plots are given in table [ evol ] . as seen in observational studies @xcite , the @xmath1 band scale lengths tend to be longer than the @xmath29 band scale lengths , at least for the six most massive galaxies ( with the two dwarf galaxies exhibiting different behavior ) . it has been debated whether this trend for disk scale lengths to be longer at shorter wavelengths is due to dust effects or age gradients @xcite . as noted above , dust plays no role in our face on _ disk _ fits , meaning that this trend in the simulations is due entirely to age and metallicity gradients . lcccccccc h516 & -16.8 & -15.9 & 0.08 & 0.14 & 0.53 & 3.4@xmath1610@xmath22 & 1.0 & 51 + h799 & -16.2 & -15.6 & 0.00 & 0.00 & 0.37 & 1.1@xmath1610@xmath22 & 0.7 & 43 + h603 & -21.3 & -20.5 & 1.25 & 0.72 & 0.52 & 2.2@xmath1610@xmath21 & 4.0 & 143 + h986 & -21.1 & -20.3 & 0.63 & 0.38 & 0.45 & 1.3@xmath1610@xmath21 & 2.8 & 137 + h239 & -22.5 & -21.8 & 0.35 & 0.16 & 0.41 & 4.2@xmath1610@xmath21 & 2.5 & 246 + h258 & -22.4 & -21.5 & 0.86 & 0.45 & 0.50 & 5.3@xmath1610@xmath21 & 5.3 & 204 + h277 & -22.1 & -21.2 & 0.63 & 0.42 & 0.52 & 4.3@xmath1610@xmath21 & 2.3 & 250 + h285 & -22.3 & -21.3 & 1.33 & 0.78 & 0.55 & 5.6@xmath1610@xmath21 & 4.5 & 203 + size , magnitude ( or mass ) , and rotational velocity make up a fundamental plane for disk galaxies @xcite . * see their figure 5 ) demonstrated that these simulated galaxies lie on the observed magnitude velocity relation for disk galaxies ( also known as the tully - fisher relation ) . in this paper we derive disk scale lengths in order to extend this analysis , and show that our galaxies are also a good match to the observed magnitude size and velocity size relations as well . all of our galaxies have sizes and velocities ( table [ obssum ] ) that agree well with the observed velocity size trend @xcite . two of the more massive galaxies have slightly high velocities for their size ( h239 and h277 ) , but still lie within the 2@xmath34 scatter of observed galaxies . the @xmath1 band disk magnitudes , m@xmath35 , and scale lengths , h@xmath35 , of our simulated galaxies at @xmath2=0 are shown in fig . [ fig : z0 ] . the simulated galaxies ( red circles ) are compared to three observational samples , @xcite and @xcite at the massive end , and @xcite at the low mass end . the @xcite data have adopted a dust correction based on @xcite , while the @xcite data are dust corrected based on inclination , following equations 1 , 2 , and 7 listed in @xcite . again , possibly due to low gas ( and therefore dust ) content , the six more massive galaxies shown here are free of dust effects . as such , they should be compared to dust corrected observational data . at the low mass end , however , @xcite makes no internal dust corrections , as the low metallicities of the dwarf galaxies in her sample are expected to lead to little effect from dust . clearly , the disk sizes of the simulated galaxies are in good agreement with observed disk sizes . we use the @xmath1 band scale lengths of the observational samples in fig . [ fig : z0 ] , which can be compared to the @xmath29 band results at @xmath2=1 in the next section since the @xmath1 band is redshifted into the @xmath29 band at @xmath2=1 . however , the magnitude size ( and stellar mass size ) relation has been measured in multiple bands for a large sample of sdss galaxies @xcite . the sdss results are consistent with the results plotted in fig . [ fig : z0 ] , though we purposely select observational samples that have done a bulge / disk decomposition and fit a pure exponential to the disk surface brightness fit , in order to isolate the evolution of the disk and eliminate any contamination from a central spheroid . as discussed in the introduction , historically it has been a challenge for cosmological disk galaxy simulations to match the observed fundamental relations for galaxy disks ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the failure to reproduce observed trends is the result of the angular momentum catastrophe , exacerbated by the fact that previous studies followed mass / kinematic results rather than light profiles . our success at matching the observed disk scaling relations is a result of the fact that our disk baryons maintain angular momentum through time , due to an increased resolution and a physically motivated feedback mechanism ( see * ? ? ? * for a review of how each of these processes contribute to the formation of realistic disks ) . a number of works have attempted to isolate the separate role of resolution and feedback ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in n - body + sph simulations , dark matter particles are typically an order of magnitude more massive than the gas particles , leading to an exchange of kinetic energy in two body interactions that kinematically heats the disk , randomizing velocity vectors , and potentially turning a disk component into a spheroid @xcite . this effect can be reduced at higher mass resolutions that lower the discrepancy in particle masses . @xcite used controlled ( non - cosmological ) n - body+sph simulations to evaluate the amount of angular momentum that can be lost purely due to resolution . they concluded that 10@xmath19 particles within the virial radius are necessary for a disk galaxy to maintain roughly 90% of its original angular momentum . yet even if resolution can be increased to the point of maximum angular momentum retention , disks will still suffer dramatic angular momentum loss compared to observed disk galaxies if energy feedback is neglected . feedback prevents rapid , early cooling of gas particles ( the overcooling problem discussed in the introduction ; see references therein ) . heating and expansion of the gas creates a hot reservoir , allowing the gas to cool at later times after the era of rapid mergers , and preventing angular momentum loss via dynamical friction in mergers ( e.g. , * ? ? ? additionally , by preventing overcooling , feedback prevents gas from rapidly turning into collisionless star particles . without feedback , halos of all masses are equally efficient at converting gas into stars @xcite , producing galaxies that are too gas poor compared to @xmath2 = 0 disk galaxies . because feedback regulates star formation , it allows for gas reservoirs to develop that allow disks to survive to the present day @xcite . the existence of large , thin disks at the present day thus requires feedback . not all sn feedback schemes lead to disk galaxies that satisfy observed constraints such as the tully - fisher relation , size velocity or size luminosity relations , or the stellar mass metallicity relation . because the nearest neighbor gas particles surrounding sne are dense and cold , a simple energy deposition will quickly be radiated away and not affect the simulation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? two main schemes have been adopted to overcome this problem . in the first , a multiphase model of the ism is implemented with a hot gas reservoir inside each gas particle @xcite , overcoming the problem of thermal energy being spread over the entire particle mass , and preventing the hot gas particles from being artificially influenced by their cold gas nearest neighbors . in the second , cooling is turned off in the gas particles near a sn explosion in order to mimic the sub - resolution adiabatic expansion of the sn @xcite . the `` blastwave '' scheme adopted here also turns off cooling in nearest neighbor particles , but attempts to model this based on what is known about actual sne , determining the radius of each sn remnant based on the analytic blastwave solution for a sn remnant @xcite , and cooling is only turned off for those particles within the blast radius . because many sne typically contribute feedback within a dense star forming region , the thermal energy from all of these sne can combine to create a larger blast radius . the differences in the resulting disk between a simple energy deposition ( `` thermal '' feedback ) and the blastwave model have been examined in @xcite and @xcite . as examined by these previous works , the adoption of the `` blastwave '' feedback model , combined with high resolution ( all simulations presented here have more than 10@xmath19 particles within the virial radius at @xmath2 = 0 , see table [ simsum ] ) , overcome past problems with cosmological disk galaxy simulations and allow for the present study . having established that these simulated disk galaxies match observed disk scaling relations at @xmath2=0 , we now use them to investigate the degeneracy in the magnitude size evolution with time . first , we establish that the simulations also match the available observational data at @xmath2=1 . the evolution of the magnitude size relation for these simulated galaxies is shown in fig . [ fig : magsize ] . the top panel shows the simulation results at @xmath2=0 , 0.5 , and 1 . it is evident that the magnitude size relation for these galaxies is evolving in time , dimming in surface brightness since @xmath2=1 . despite the fact that these are individual galaxies being followed in time , the snapshot of the population of disks at each redshift is consistent with the observations . this is evident in the bottom two panels . the middle panel compares the simulated disk scale lengths at @xmath2=1 to the decomposed @xmath29 band disk scale lengths of galaxies at 0.9 @xmath36 1.2 from @xcite and miller et al.(_in prep _ ) . no dust corrections are applied to the observational @xmath2=1 data , as these galaxies are expected to be low metallicity where corrections are uncertain and often ignored @xcite . any realistic dust corrections are likely to be tiny , and not affect the results . the bottom panel is a reproduction of fig . [ fig : z0 ] , shown again for easy comparison of the results across redshifts . while observational biases allow for a direct comparison only at the massive end at @xmath2=1 , the disk sizes of the simulated galaxies are in good agreement with observed disk sizes , as a function of redshift . we note that observational data that used a single sersic component fit ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) are also in good agreement with the @xmath2=1 data presented here ( and lie in the same magnitude range ) , despite the lack of a bulge / disk decomposition . for clarity , we show only the decomposed data in fig . [ fig : magsize ] . the top panel of fig . [ fig : magsize ] shows that there has been apparent dimming of the surface brightness of the simulated population since @xmath2=1 . [ deltamu ] quantifies this evolution , showing the change in the surface brightness , @xmath37 , of the simulated galaxy disks . we have defined @xmath37 such that @xmath38 data points in fig . [ deltamu ] at @xmath2=0 , 0.5 and 1 are for the mean @xmath37 for the population at that time , and error bars reflect the standard deviation of the sample . because our two dwarf galaxies are too faint to be generally observable at @xmath2=1 , fig . [ deltamu ] shows the evolution of these two galaxies separately from the higher mass galaxies . however , the evolution is roughly similar in both mass ranges , with about 1.5 magnitudes in surface brightness dimming between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 . a dimming of 1.5 magnitudes is consistent with observational studies that have examined the surface brightness evolution of disk dominated galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? lcccccccc h516 & 22.7 & 1.5 & -15.7 & 2.0 & 0.95 & 1.0 & 4.3@xmath1610@xmath39 & 1.69 + h799 & 22.1 & 0.7 & -15.6 & 0.0 & 0.6 & 1.3 & 1.8@xmath1610@xmath39 & 1.32 + h603 & 22.5 & 2.8 & -19.8 & 1.0 & 4.2 & 2.4 & 1.3@xmath1610@xmath21 & 2.78 + h986 & 21.2 & 1.0 & -19.9 & 0.2 & 3.0 & 1.9 & 1.0@xmath1610@xmath21 & 3.22 + h239 & 19.3 & n / a & -21.5 & n / a & 3.2 & n / a & 9.0@xmath1610@xmath6 & 10.17 + h258 & 21.3 & 1.6 & -21.1 & -0.2 & 6.3 & 2.7 & 3.2@xmath1610@xmath21 & 2.53 + h277 & 19.7 & 0.6 & -20.8 & 0.4 & 2.4 & 1.4 & 1.9@xmath1610@xmath21 & 1.95 + h285 & 21.4 & n / a & -20.6 & n / a & 4.6 & n / a & 2.0@xmath1610@xmath21 & 3.07 + the previous section examined the population of simulated disks in terms of surface brightness evolution . we now decompose the surface brightness trends into luminosity and size evolution , and demonstrate how individual galaxies evolve in each property with time . table [ evol ] quantifies the changes in the disk @xmath1 band central surface brightness ( @xmath40 , as opposed to @xmath41 plotted in fig . [ deltamu ] ) , size , and magnitude for each of our simulated galaxies . it is widely expected that galaxies should undergo dimming since @xmath2=1 , due to declining star formation rates . the key question is how much galaxies dim . it is already apparent from fig . [ fig : magsize ] that our more massive galaxies are undergoing growth in size between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 , meaning that the change in surface brightness of @xmath81.5 magnitudes over this time can not be entirely due to luminosity dimming at a fixed size . the changes in size and magnitude that are quantified in table [ evol ] are also visualized in fig . [ dmagsize ] . now it can be seen that there is in fact a dependency on mass in the evolution of the galaxies . our more massive galaxies are growing in size and generally undergoing only a small amount of dimming in total magnitude ; some are even getting brighter with time . meanwhile , there is little change in the scale length of our lowest mass galaxies , but their evolution in luminosity is erratic ( for this sample of two galaxies ) due to their bursting star formation histories . the luminosity evolution of the low mass dwarf galaxies is tied up with their particular star formation histories . while h799 is quiescent between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0.5 so that it dims , it undergoes another burst of sf at low @xmath2 , increasing its magnitude . on the other hand , h516 stays relatively quiescent between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 , so that it undergoes significant luminosity dimming ( of 2.0 magnitudes ) . this large amount of dimming may at first seem to be at odds with the fact that low mass galaxies are generally undergoing more sf today than they were in the past ( this is discussed further in section [ starmass ] , and is one form of galaxy `` downsizing '' ) . however , this extreme dimming for low mass galaxies has been seen in observational results as well @xcite . @xcite concluded that small galaxies ( those with half light radii @xmath18 2 kpc ) have undergone roughly 2.5 magnitudes of dimming since @xmath2=1 . given the bursty sf nature of the two low mass dwarfs we have in our sample , it is not possible to compare statistically to the observations , but there is nothing to suggest that our simulated dwarfs are inconsistent with the @xcite results . at the higher mass end , @xcite find @xmath81.5 mag of dimming since @xmath2=1 for galaxies with half light radii @xmath42 3 kpc ( disk scale lengths @xmath42 1.8 kpc ) , if the strictest interpretation is made that all surface brightness evolution is in luminosity rather than size . clearly , this is not true for our high mass galaxies , which are growing with time . if galaxies are growing with time , then comparing galaxies that are a given size ( e.g. , 3 kpc ) at @xmath2=0 with galaxies that are of similar size at @xmath2=1 means that similar galaxies are _ not _ being compared . those @xmath2=0 galaxies will have been smaller at @xmath2=1 , and it is unknown from our simulation results what size galaxies with scale lengths larger than @xmath82.5 kpc at @xmath2=1 will have evolved to by @xmath2=0 . in summary , if galaxies are growing since @xmath2=1 , this will mimic a larger change in luminosity on the magnitude size relation than actually occurs @xcite . our simulated disk galaxies _ as a population _ appear to match the observational results for the evolution in the size - magnitude plane very well ( fig . [ fig : magsize ] ) . yet [ dmagsize ] demonstrates what the observations can not witness : individual galaxies are growing with time , so that the evolution in the magnitude size plane can not be due to dimming alone . disk scale length evolution for each galaxy is plotted in fig . [ evolsize ] , normalized to their size at @xmath2=1 . these values are also quantified in table [ evol ] . only a few of these galaxies show negligible size evolution , with the two lowest mass galaxies undergoing the smallest size changes . the remaining galaxies show clear growth , and about half evolve by the amount predicted by the simple sis model , ( nearly a factor of two back to @xmath2=1 ) , or more . the dotted line in fig . [ evolsize ] shows the growth predicted for the simple sis model @xcite , while the dashed line shows the growth determined by @xcite using 16 galaxies at @xmath2=1 . however , it is not necessarily expected that any given galaxy should follow the @xmath9 analytic growth predicted by the sis model . @xcite demonstrated that more sophisticated models adopting nfw profiles could bring the observations and theory closer in line . the prediction that sizes scale with @xmath9 is based on the assumption that @xmath43 where @xmath10 is the circular velocity of the halo and @xmath44 is the radius at which the mean density is equal to 200 times the critical density . then @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the dimensionless spin parameter @xcite . if the disk size follows @xmath9 , both @xmath46 and @xmath10 must stay roughly constant with time . while @xmath10 does stay roughly constant back to @xmath2=1 in these galaxies , @xmath46 does not . it is known that @xmath46 may vary for individual halos due to mergers or smooth accretion @xcite . the previous work of analytic models do not require @xmath46 to stay constant , as they simply use a snapshot in time and the spin values of halos at that snapshot . that is , they study a population of galaxies at a given time , and make no attempt to follow an individual galaxy with time as we do here . hence , it is not surprising that some of the simulated galaxies presented here deviate from growing precisely as @xmath9 . a better question , if we want to compare our disk sizes to analytic models , is to ask if the scale lengths measured based on our light profiles are similar to those predicted by analytic models . for an nfw density distribution , the disk scale length , r@xmath47 is @xmath48 where @xmath49 measures the halo concentration , and @xmath50 is nfw the scale radius . @xmath51 uses @xmath52 to determine the energy of the nfw halo compared to the sis model , and @xmath53 is a factor that accounts for the gravitational effect of the disk ( adiabatic contraction ) . @xmath54 and @xmath55 are the fraction of disk angular momentum and mass , respectively , to the total halo . for sizes to scale as @xmath9 , it is assumed that @xmath56 = 1 . this is likely to not be true , though , as demonstrated by @xcite . we have determined the values of @xmath51 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 for each of our galaxy halos at @xmath2=0 , directly from the simulation results . we compared the @xmath60 expected from these quantities , as derived by equation [ eq:4 ] , to the @xmath29 band scale lengths listed in table [ obssum ] . the results agree to within 10% for only the two lowest mass galaxies . for the more massive galaxies , the predicted nfw @xmath60 is consistently shorter than that found for the @xmath29 band , and for four of the six massive galaxies , the measured @xmath29 band results are a factor of 2 - 4 larger than the nfw prediction . the main source of this discrepancy appears to be in the value obtained for the spin value , @xmath46 , for the entire halo . if the spin of the gas , @xmath61 , within the halo is used instead , the discrepancy shrinks so that six of the eight galaxies have nfw @xmath60 and @xmath29 band results within 10% of each other . as listed in table [ simsum ] , the values of @xmath46 are generally lower than @xmath61 for all halos except the two lowest mass galaxies . this trend for @xmath61 to be larger than @xmath46 has been seen previously in simulations @xcite , and has been suggested as one reason why disks may have a smaller fraction of low angular momentum than their dark matter halos @xcite . recently , @xcite used a similar simulation run with gasoline to show that gas that enters the virial radius of a halo and cools toward the disk is torqued by the hot halo gas , so that the angular momentum of the disk gas becomes aligned with the hot halo . this is true even for gas that is initially counter - rotating with the disk , and hence is a powerful method to remove negative and low angular momentum material from the disk . the lack of low angular momentum material for the disk gas will lead to larger values of @xmath61 compared to @xmath46 for the total halo . the disk stars , whose light we trace in the results of this paper , form from this cold gas with larger spin values , and thus @xmath61 will be a better predictor for the nfw @xmath60 than @xmath46 . the result that the disk baryons are lacking a low angular momentum component compared to the dm is not trivial . this result needs to be examined in detail . however , this requires a full evaluation of the history of angular momentum in these halos , which is beyond the scope of the current paper . we reserve such a study for future work . as discussed above , numerous observational studies have found that there has been a decline in the surface brightness of disk galaxies , by a magnitude or more , since @xmath2=1 . due to the fact that there is little evidence for a change in the size function of disk galaxies over this time period ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , the observations can only be interpreted as an upper limit to luminosity evolution . that is , if disks do not change in size , then all of the evolution must be in luminosity . however , due to the degeneracy in the magnitude size plane , the option of possible growth is left open . @xcite investigated this disk growth . after showing that they , too , agreed with @xmath81 magnitude of surface brightness dimming back to @xmath2=1 , they then used galaxy colors to derive stellar masses and considered the stellar mass size relation for their galaxies . they found that this relation , unlike the magnitude size relation , showed little or no evolution back to to @xmath2=1 . disk growth may still occur , but must occur in such a way that galaxies remain on the same stellar mass size relation with time . they concluded that this was evidence for weak inside - out growth of galaxy disks , as did additional later studies @xcite . the right panel of fig . [ dmagsize ] shows the evolution in the stellar mass size plane for our simulated galaxies . in agreement with previous results @xcite , these galaxies are growing along a path that keeps them on the same stellar mass size relation with redshift . the stellar mass shown in the right panel of fig . [ dmagsize ] is for the disk only . to separate the disk growth from total stellar growth of these galaxies ( i.e. , from the bulge and halo spheroidal stellar components ) , a kinematic decomposition was done to identify disk stars at @xmath2=0 . to identify disk particles , the galaxies are first aligned so that the disk angular momentum vector lies along the _ z_-axis . j@xmath62/j@xmath63 is calculated for each star particle in the galaxy , where j@xmath62 is the angular momentum in the _ x - y _ plane , and j@xmath63 is the momentum that a particle would have in a circular orbit with the same orbital energy . disk stars are identified as those having near circular orbits , so that j@xmath62/j@xmath63 @xmath42 0.8 . 0.2 , which matches the eccentricities observed in the milky way disk @xcite . ] these @xmath2=0 disk stars were then searched for in their most massive progenitor at @xmath2=0.5 and @xmath2=1 to find the mass of these stars that had formed at each step , with the results plotted in fig . [ dmagsize ] . if galaxy disks are evolving approximately along the same stellar mass size relation with time , then the surface mass density of disks should show little evolution back to @xmath2=1 @xcite . that is , a galaxy with stellar mass of 10@xmath21 m@xmath7 at @xmath2=1 is roughly the same size ( though maybe just slightly smaller ) as a galaxy at @xmath2=0 with 10@xmath21 m@xmath7 , yielding roughly the same surface densities . [ barden ] tentatively confirms this result , showing that the surface mass density of our population of disks evolves little with time , with surface mass density , @xmath64 defined as @xmath65 the red points with error bars , connected by the solid black line , show the mean and standard deviation for the whole sample at @xmath2 = 0 , 0.5 , and 1 . the colored lines are the results for individual simulated disks with time . we note , however , that the dashed line shows the prediction for the surface mass density evolution for the simple sis model @xcite . the standard deviation within our small sample is large , so that the simulated galaxies are fully consistent with the predicted growth . while our sample is clearly too small to derive statistical results , the change in the mean surface density of the population between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 is only 0.1 dex , half of the evolution predicted by the sis model . we note that an updated model by @xcite that incorporates the evolution of nfw halos derived in n - body simulations predicts only @xmath80.2 dex change in the stellar surface mass density back to @xmath2=1 . this small evolution in surface mass density is due to evolution along a stellar mass size relation that changes little with time . due to the fact that the stellar mass size relation shows little change with time , examining the evolution of galaxy disks at a fixed _ stellar mass _ is similar to examining the evolution at a fixed _ size_. however , because galaxies are growing with time , a galaxy that is , e.g. , 3 kpc in size and 10@xmath21 m@xmath7 in stellar mass at @xmath2=1 has increased in mass and size by @xmath2=0 and another galaxy has moved from a lower mass and smaller size into the same bin . observations , and the results presented here , tell us that these two galaxies of same size at @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 have a different luminosity : a galaxy at @xmath2=1 with similar stellar mass and size to a @xmath2=0 galaxy will be brighter . note that this is _ not _ equivalent to saying that an individual galaxy was brighter in the past . instead , galaxies at fixed stellar mass were brighter in the past . because they are the same stellar mass , the brighter @xmath2=1 galaxy must then be forming more stars . two of our galaxies can be compared in this way . galaxy h603 has a stellar disk mass of 1.28@xmath1610@xmath21 m@xmath7 at @xmath2=0 , while h258 has a stellar disk mass of 1.25@xmath1610@xmath21 m@xmath7 at @xmath2=1 . the sfr within the last 100myr for h258 at @xmath2=1 is 3.1 m@xmath7/yr , while it is 0.6 m@xmath7/yr for h603 at @xmath2=0 . the lower sfr for h603 is due to the fact that it resides in a less massive halo than h258 ( see table [ simsum ] ) . even at @xmath2=1 , h603 had a lower sfr than h258 , of 2.1 m@xmath7/yr . this is because these galaxies follow a sfr stellar mass relation ( which also leads to their reproduction of the observed stellar mass metallicity relation , * ? ? ? [ fig9 ] shows the sfr stellar mass and specific sfr ( ssfr ) stellar mass relations for our simulated disks . the left panels of fig . [ fig9 ] shows the ssfr ( top ) and sfr within the last 100 myr ( bottom ) versus stellar disk mass . these left panels confirm the values listed in the paragraph above . the dwarf galaxies are included in this plot for full disclosure , but lie outside of the mass range observable at high @xmath2 , unlike the higher mass galaxies . two trends among the higher mass galaxies are noteworthy . first , the sfr of any individual galaxy tends to decrease slightly with time , but second , the entire population as a whole can be observed to shift to lower sfrs and ssfrs @xcite . the decline in sfr and ssfr in has been observed extensively in populations of galaxies @xcite , and is one form of `` downsizing '' in galaxy evolution . the right panels of fig . [ fig9 ] also show sfr and ssfr for the simulated galaxy disks , but now as a function of total halo mass . this is included to demonstrate that although , e.g. , h603 at @xmath2=0 and h258 at @xmath2=1 have similar disk stellar masses , this does not correspond to similar virial masses for those redshifts ( colors yellow and purple in the figures , respectively ) . the deeper potential well of the more massive galaxy ( h258 ) leads to a higher sfr.=1.25 due to the fact that it is undergoing a merger at @xmath2=1 . galaxy h258 is 50% more massive than h603 at @xmath2=1 . ] in conclusion , attempting to compare galaxies that are a similar stellar mass at @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 ( and by the tight stellar mass size relation , similar size ) leads to inherently comparing galaxies of two different virial masses . this then leads to the observed difference in luminosity for galaxies of a similar size at @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 , caused by the sfr stellar mass relation , and the corresponding stellar mass halo mass relation @xcite . in fig . [ fig10 ] we reproduce some of the simulated scaling relations , this time with observed scaling relations directly overplotted for comparison . the left panel of fig . [ fig10 ] shows the low redshift relations for sdss galaxies ( solid line , with 2@xmath34 scatter in dotted lines ) from @xcite . it is worth noting that @xcite performed bulge / disk decompositions with the sdss data , so that the sizes plotted are fits to purely exponential disk scale lengths ( converted from the half light radius presented in their paper ) . @xcite also use higher @xmath2 data from the deep2 survey to measure the change in size since @xmath2=0 , finding @xmath80.1 dex of size evolution at a fixed mass back to @xmath2=1 . in the mass range of overlap ( m@xmath4 @xmath42 10@xmath6 m@xmath7 ) , our simulated galaxies are entirely consistent with observed galaxies within the scatter . the central panel of fig . [ fig10 ] reproduces the stellar mass sfr relation , now with observational data from @xcite plotted for @xmath2=0 ( solid line ) and @xmath2=1 ( dashed line ) , corrected from a salpeter imf to a kroupa imf . at both redshifts , the minimum mass observed is roughly 10@xmath6 m@xmath7 . the right panel shows the same data , but now for the ssfr . the data point with error bars in the lower right corner of the right panel provides an estimate of the typical scatter in the @xcite data . while our galaxies are certainly consistent with the data within the scatter , and the general slope at each @xmath2 is consistent with the observations , there is overall a tendency for the simulated galaxies to be more massive than the observations . we believe the discrepancy is in stellar mass rather than sfr , because these simulated galaxies have both @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 disk sfrs in good agreement with observed galaxies in the same halo mass range @xcite . we note that the @xcite data is for total stellar mass , while our simulated results are for the disk only ( bulge excluded ) . however , including the bulge mass will only exacerbate the discrepancy . for the massive galaxies , the discrepancy is probably due to the fact that these simulations are known to form too many stars @xcite . we can learn something about _ when _ this overproduction of stars occurs in the simulations by also examining the stellar mass ssfr plot ( right panel of fig . [ fig10 ] ) . while within the observed scatter , is appears that the ssfrs of the simulated disks are consistently lower than observational results at both @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 @xcite . these plots demonstrate that these simulated galaxies must be forming too many stars at early times , at redshifts higher than plotted here ( @xmath66 1 ) . because the sfrs of the galaxies are in good agreement with observed galaxies in the same halo mass range at both @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 @xcite , the fact that the ssfrs are lower than observed values requires that the stellar mass of these disks be too large by @xmath2=1 . the story is slightly different for the two dwarf disk simulations . these two dwarf galaxies have been published previously in @xcite , where it was demonstrated that their properties are a good match to observed dwarf disk galaxies , including stellar mass @xcite . however , the observed ssfrs of low mass galaxies is on average higher than that of massive galaxies @xcite , indicating that low mass galaxies have been very inefficient in the past at turning gas into stars . clearly , that is not the case with our two simulated dwarf disk galaxies , which have too low ssfrs compared to most observed dwarf galaxies due to the fact that they form the bulk of their stars prior to @xmath2=1 . hence , while approximately the correct mass in stars is formed , the star formation is biased toward @xmath66 1 . we have verified that these two simulations , when run with stronger sn feedback , have burstier sf histories with their sf spread out more evenly down to the present time . this leads to approximately the same mass in stars formed by @xmath2=0 , but with a more uniform sf history . this means that the stronger feedback dwarf runs have higher ssfrs than currently presented here , and ssfr values larger than the massive galaxy simulations shown here . future work will include these new dwarf disks , which show similar stellar masses , rotational velocities , and sizes to those presented in this paper . thus , in all of the simulated galaxies the star formation history is biased toward too much star formation at high @xmath2 . by @xmath2=0 , though , the dwarf galaxies have formed approximately the observed amount of stars for their halo mass , while the more massive galaxies have overproduced the total amount of stars . it is suspected that this overproduction of stars in the massive galaxy disks may be the result of the adopted low sf density threshold , which allows for most of the disk to be capable of sf at any given time , unlike the high density threshold which limits sf only to rare density peaks . however , as discussed in section 2.1 , it is currently computationally expensive to generate the more massive galaxies with the force resolution required to resolve high density peaks where sf occurs , and no simulations of sufficiently high resolution are currently available to test this hypothesis . the adopted sf threshold is a compromise that allows stars to form at radii observed in real galaxy disks , and we have demonstrated that it leads to scale lengths in good agreement with observed galaxies . however , we note that even if our massive galaxies are forming too many stars , it is by roughly a factor of 3 at most , and at early times . this means that the more massive galaxies may shift up to 0.5 dex to lower stellar masses in the stellar mass size plane , but will still grow along the stellar mass size relation , so that our conclusions are unaffected . likewise , the @xmath1 band magnitudes we present here are unlikely to be affected , as the bulk of overproduced stars must occur at @xmath66 1 . since @xmath1 band light is dominated by young stars , and our low @xmath2 sfrs are in good agreement with observed galaxies in the same halo mass range , the magnitude size relations presented in figs . [ fig : z0 ] and [ fig : magsize ] are unlikely to change . hence , the conclusions presented here about the origin of the evolution in the size luminosity relation remain valid . for the first time , a sample of very high resolution galaxy disks simulated within a fully cosmological context have been used to determine the evolution of the galaxy disk size magnitude relation . unlike previous simulations , we determine disk scale lengths and magnitudes by fitting the stellar light profile rather than decomposing our simulations based on kinematics ( and hence mass ) . we generate artificial surface brightness images using sunrise @xcite , in order to derive disk properties using methods used by observers . exponential disk scale lengths were derived using galfit @xcite with redshifted , surface brightness dimmed @xmath29 band images at @xmath2=1 and 0.5 , and rest frame @xmath1 band images at @xmath2=0 . this allows for a direct comparison between simulated and observational results in the size magnitude plane . [ fig : z0 ] demonstrates that these galaxies overcome past inabilities for cosmological disk simulations to retain angular momentum . artificial loss of angular momentum is minimized due to high resolution and a physically motivated sn feedback recipe , and hence we produce disks with realistic sizes compared to observed disks . fig . [ fig : magsize ] shows that the sizes are in agreement with observed disk sizes back to @xmath2=1 . this success , and our previous successes in matching the observed stellar mass metallicity relation with time @xcite , and the tully - fisher relationship @xcite , indicate that these simulated disks reproduce the fundamental scaling relations for disk galaxies . having established this , we can now use these simulated disks to investigate and interpret observational findings . we use the simulated disk properties to investigate the evolution in the magnitude size relation with time . observations have generally concluded that there has been 1 to 1.5 magnitudes of surface brightness dimming since @xmath2=1 @xcite . we find similar evolution for our galaxies ( see fig . [ deltamu ] ) . combined with a lack of evidence for an evolving size function for galaxy disks @xcite , and little to no growth in galaxy disks sizes back to @xmath2=1 @xcite , the observed surface brightness evolution can only be interpreted as an upper limit to luminosity evolution if there has been no change in galaxy disk sizes . we have shown that we 1 ) are in good agreement with the observed magnitude size relation with time and the evolution in surface brightness , but 2 ) a number of the simulated disks are clearly undergoing a large change in size ( figs . [ dmagsize ] and [ evolsize ] ) . our ability to follow individual galaxies with time , unlike the observations , allows us to interpret the evolution in the magnitude size plane . we find that the evolution is dependent on mass , with our massive galaxies undergoing larger changes in size than magnitude . our dwarf galaxies undergo the least change in size , though there is no immediate theoretical expectation that this should be the case . recent results @xcite show that the rate of growth of halos has little dependence on mass , and thus low mass galaxies should grow just as much in size as their more massive counterparts . we conclude that a larger sample is needed to study if low mass galaxies truly grow less than more massive galaxies . on the other hand , the evolution in magnitude for dwarf disk galaxies is dependent on their bursty sf history , but an individual dwarf can undergo significant dimming of at least 2 magnitudes . a dichotomy of evolution with mass has been seen in observations , with low mass galaxies exhibiting significantly more dimming since @xmath2=1 than more massive galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the halo properties for these galaxies ( @xmath67 ) predict a scale length that is generally shorter than the scale lengths derived from the simulated light profiles . fig . [ ml ] demonstrates that the light and mass distributions yield scale lengths in good agreement , so the discrepancy between @xmath60 predicted for nfw halos and from our light profiles can not be due to a discrepancy between light and mass profiles . rather , using @xmath61 , the spin of the gas in the halo , brings the predicted and measured scale lengths into decent agreement . thus , the angular momentum distribution of the gas from which the stars are forming has been modified from that of the dark matter ( see also * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? @xcite have demonstrated that accreted gas is torqued by the hot halo after entering the virial radius , potentially preventing counter - rotating and low angular momentum gas from reaching the disk . a full examination of how this process occurs is beyond the scope of this paper and left for future work . having determined that these galaxies are growing in size with time , we can investigate this growth in stellar mass . like previous theoretical models @xcite , we find that these galaxies grow in such a way as to stay along approximately the same stellar mass size relation with time . hence , at a fixed stellar mass , there is little change back to @xmath2=1 in the size of galaxies . due to the fact that our larger galaxies have grown since @xmath2=1 , we do not have the ability to directly compare results at a fixed size . in particular , we do not have a population of simulated disks at @xmath2=1 with scale length greater than 3 kpc , though these larger disks do exist observationally . presumably we might generate these larger disks if we simulate higher mass halos . however , it is not clear from this study how these larger disks would evolve to @xmath2=0 . observationally , the number density of disk galaxies shows no evidence for change back to @xmath2=1 @xcite . in conjunction with the apparent lack of evolution in the size function of disks , this fact has been interpreted to mean that either galaxies are done growing by @xmath2=1 , or that the rate of destruction of galaxies at given size must be equally matched by the rate of growth of galaxies into that size . the fact that our galaxies are growing , while still matching the size - magnitude evolution , suggests that galaxies are moving into and out of a given bin in size during this time interval . it is beyond the scope of this work to answer what happens to these larger galaxies , though we may speculate . there are two possibilities that arise due to mergers ; perhaps the larger disks undergo mergers and become early type galaxies @xcite , or perhaps mergers cause them to become bulge dominated disks . as the majority of size - magnitude evolution studies have focused on pure disks or disks with small bulges , this would remove them from the sample being considered @xcite . finally , we demonstrate that the simulated galaxy disks follow sfr mass and ssfr mass relations similar to observations . while the growth of dark matter halos is nearly self - similar with mass , observations demonstrate that some process must break this self - similarity in the baryons ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in the mass range of galaxy halos presented here , sn feedback is the process that regulates sf as a function of halo mass , and likely drives gas outflows that vary as a function of mass ( though outflow rates are left for future work ) . the regulation of sf as a function of mass leads to the reproduction of the observed stellar mass metallicity relationship @xcite , and the sfr mass relation shown here that is responsible for the reproduction of the size luminosity relation back to @xmath2=1 . a galaxy at a fixed m@xmath4 at @xmath2=1 will have a higher sfr than a @xmath2=0 counterpart , and thus a higher luminosity as well . in conjunction with the weak evolution of the stellar mass size relation , this tells us that the difference in luminosity observed at a fixed size between @xmath2=1 and @xmath2=0 is due to the fact that the @xmath2=1 galaxy has a higher sfr and luminosity . we would like to thank s. miller and r. ellis for use of their @xmath2=1 disk scale length data . ab acknowledges support from the sherman fairchild foundation . as was supported by the gordon & betty moore foundation . fg and tq were funded by nsf ast-0908499 . fg acknowledges support from a theodore dunham grant , hst go-1125 , nsf grant ast-0607819 and nasa atp nnx08ag84 g . pj acknowledges support from the w. m. keck foundation . simulations were run at tacc , arsc , and nas . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the cosmic star - formation rate peaks between @xmath6 and @xmath7 and marks a critical period for galaxy assembly . in the classic model of galaxy formation , collisional baryons cool and dissipate into the center of dark matter halos while conserving primordial angular momentum , leading to the formation of a thin rotating disk galaxy @xcite . although this gas is expected to collapse to a disk in a few crossing times , external processes can disrupt or destroy disks on timescales shorter than the rotational period . in an emerging new picture , clumpy and smooth accretion from the cosmic web can efficiently carry external angular momentum inside the halo viral radius and directly onto the central galaxy @xcite , disrupting the velocity field @xcite . additionally , ordered disks can be disturbed or destroyed through major mergers @xcite , violent disk instabilities @xcite and stellar feedback @xcite . these processes are prominent at @xmath0 , coincident with the assembly of stellar mass in galaxies and may play a stronger role in the shallow potential wells that host low mass galaxies . in general , the formation and development of a galaxy depends strongly on its mass . massive galaxies tend to assemble their stellar mass first ( downsizing " , e.g. , @xcite ) and develop disks earlier ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in contrast , low mass ( @xmath8 ) galaxies tend to exhibit more disturbed and irregular morphologies at both low and high redshift ( e.g. , @xcite ) , indicating that they lack mature structure . recent evidence from imaging suggests that a significant fraction of low mass galaxies at @xmath91.5 appear to have elongated stellar distributions @xcite . a similar phenomenon has been seen in hydrodynamic simulations of galaxy formation @xcite which indicate that oblate ( stellar ) disks form at late times ( @xmath10 ) , when the central potential becomes baryon - dominated . the star - forming gas in these simulated galaxies starts off in a highly perturbed and triaxial state , eventually collapsing to form thick oblate disks @xcite . from @xmath11 to now , star - forming systems appear to have evolved through kinematic downsizing in a process known as disk settling " @xcite . in this picture , galaxies hierarchically settle from turbulent systems with high dispersion to regularly rotating disks , with more massive galaxies forming disks earlier . locally : the majority of high mass galaxies are ordered rotating disks , with kinematically disordered galaxies appearing only below a stellar mass of @xmath12 @xmath13 @xmath14 9.5 @xcite . however , it is unclear whether the kinematic downsizing picture extends beyond @xmath11 and into the peak of cosmic star - formation . with recent advancements in near infrared detectors and instrumental multiplexing capabilities , space and ground based instruments have provided a wealth of knowledge regarding the physical properties of galaxies during this period , the cosmic noon . ground based kinematic data for high redshift ( @xmath151 ) galaxies is rapidly growing , as reviewed in @xcite , with several recent and ongoing surveys : e.g. , sins @xcite , wigglez @xcite , massiv , mosdef @xcite , kmos3d @xcite and kross @xcite . emerging from these surveys is the general picture that star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 are _ unlike _ the thin disk galaxies that make up the massive end up the local hubble sequence . high redshift galaxies tend to be thick and gas - rich with velocity dispersions that are factors of a few higher than local thin disks . the typical velocity dispersion tends to increase with increasing redshift ( e.g. , ) and may reflect a similar rise in gas fractions @xcite . even still , rotational support appears to be relatively common in the more massive galaxies ( @xmath16 ) at @xmath0 , with @xmath17 of the population exhibiting rotational motions comparable to or greater than their velocity dispersion @xcite . only very recently , kinematic data for low mass galaxies ( @xmath8 ) at high redshift is becoming available in gravitationally lensed systems ( e.g. , @xcite ) and in larger numbers in the ongoing surveys with multi - object single slits ( mosdef ; @xcite ) and integral field spectrographs ( kmos-3d ; @xcite ) . while the imaging data at this epoch indicates that massive galaxies tend to be disk - like and the low mass galaxies tend to be irregular , similar conclusions have not yet been drawn from kinematic measurements , and it is unclear whether kinematic downsizing is in effect at @xmath0 . in this paper we aim to take advantage of the multiplexing capabilities and the high sensitivity of keck / mosfire multi - object near - infrared spectrograph @xcite as well as the high resolution and sensitivity of hubble space telescope ( hst)/wfc3 h - band imaging to explore the kinematic state of star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 . this survey is named sigma , survey in the near - infrared of galaxies with multiple angles . the sample is morphologically diverse and is selected along the star - formation main sequence in two redshift bins from @xmath18 and @xmath19 . in 2 we discuss the observations and sample selection . in 3 we describe measurements of the galaxy physical properties from multi - wavelength imaging . in 4 we detail the measurements of the gas - phase kinematics of our sample , and discuss multi - pa observations . in 5 we present the @xmath0 tully - fisher relation . in 6 we examine trends between the kinematics and physical properties , and in 7 we present a comparison of our galaxies with a model for marginally stable gas - rich disks . in 8 we present our conclusions and in the appendix we present simulations to determine the effects of spatial resolution on the measurement of kinematics . we adopt a @xmath20cdm cosmology defined with ( h , @xmath21 , @xmath22 ) = ( 0.7 , 0.3 , 0.7 ) . the sigma sample is drawn from three of the fields ( goods - s , goods - n and uds ) of the hst / wfc3 candels survey @xcite . all of the spectra in goods - n were taken as a part of the tkrs-2 survey @xcite and a subset of the spectra in goods - s and uds have been presented in previous papers @xcite . the sigma galaxy sample is shown in a star formation rate - stellar mass ( sfr - @xmath23 ) diagram in figure [ fig : m_sfr ] . this sample is a part of the well studied goods - n , goods - s , and uds extragalactic fields , and so extensive multi - wavelength imaging is available for all of the galaxies in this sample . galaxies in sigma are selected from the candels wfc3/f160w catalogs @xcite as follows . selection priority was given to galaxies with spectroscopic redshifts from hst / wfc3 grism observations @xcite , taken as a part of the 3d - hst ( @xcite , pi van dokkum ) and aghast ( pi weiner ) surveys . the majority of the tkrs-2 galaxies were selected on previous spectroscopically confirmed redshifts . photometric redshifts were derived from the broadband seds with eazy @xcite and were used to select the remaining galaxies in our sample . star - forming galaxies were selected down to a sfr of @xmath243 m@xmath25 yr@xmath26 at z @xmath24 1.5 and @xmath2410 m@xmath25 yr@xmath26 at z @xmath24 2.2 . there is no selection cut on morphology . as such , both regular and irregular galaxies are included in the sample . there is a priority weight on galaxy size , half - light v - band diameters of @xmath27 , in order to select galaxies with emission extents that are larger than the typical seeing . the full sigma sample for which we have significant detections ( s / n @xmath28 3 ) in h@xmath29 and/or @xmath305007 contains 97 galaxies . a portion of these were observed at multiple slit position angles ( pa ) : 23 with 2 pas and 11 with 3 + pas . we select galaxies with at least one kinematic measurement coincident with the photometric major axis ( within 45@xmath31 ) , removing 35 of the 97 galaxies . we make a further cut on emission line extent for each spectrum of each galaxy , as described in 3.3 and the appendix , such that the effective radius of the emission extent is at least 0.8 times the size of the seeing fwhm . this selection is shown in figure [ fig : cont_size_em_size ] and removes an additional 9 galaxies from the sample . an additional 4 galaxies are removed due to the presence of a strong overlapping skyline . the final sample used in this paper contains 49 galaxies , 28 in the redshift range 1.3 @xmath14 z @xmath14 1.8 and 21 at 2.0 @xmath14 z @xmath14 2.5 . the properties of the full sample are presented in table [ tab : table1 ] of the appendix . at z @xmath24 1.5 and @xmath32 at z @xmath24 2.3 . the grey dots represent galaxies drawn from the h - band selected goods - s candels catalog in the same redshift range . a small amount of noise ( 0.05 dex ) was added to the grey points to remove striations due to the discreet grid structure searched by the model fits to @xmath23 and star - formation rate ( sfr ) . in the bottom panel , we compare the mass range of our sample , indicated by the red and blue arrows , with the blue galaxy stellar mass functions at the same redshifts , taken from @xcite . ] the strong optical nebular emission lines ( e.g. , h@xmath29 , @xmath305007 ) from which we measure kinematics shift into the near infrared ( nir ) at z @xmath28 1.3 . the multi - object spectrograph , mosfire @xcite on keck - i , is one of the premiere instruments to study spectral features in the nir . the spectra in this sample were taken in the h - band ( 1.46 - 1.81 @xmath33 m ) and k - band ( 1.93 - 2.45 @xmath33 m ) . h@xmath29 can be detected in the h - band from 1.3 @xmath14 z @xmath14 1.8 and in the k - band from 2.1 @xmath14 @xmath34 @xmath14 2.8 . additionally , @xmath305007 falls in the h - band from 2.0 @xmath14 z @xmath14 2.8 . the mosfire slit width was set to 0.7@xmath35 and the instrumental spectral resolution is r@xmath363630 in both bands ( @xmath37 km s@xmath26 ) . the masks were dithered along the slit between symmetric sky positions around the initial pointing to facilitate sky and instrument noise subtraction . the on - source exposure times were between 90 and 120 minutes with individual exposure times of 120 seconds . the 2d spectra were sky - subtracted , wavelength - calibrated and rectified using the mosfiredrp reduction pipeline . spectroscopic redshifts were determined via specpro @xcite . observations were taken in natural seeing conditions and the size of the seeing is estimated from unresolved calibration stars , where available , and marginally resolved compact `` blue nugget '' galaxies @xcite that were observed on the same mask as the galaxies in our sample . the nir seeing ranged between 0.45 and 0.85@xmath35 . example cutouts of the 2d spectra around the h@xmath29 emission line are shown in figure [ fig : kin_example ] . throughout this paper we use two structural parameters measured from the hst / wfc3 images , namely the photometric position angle ( pa , i.e. , the direction of the photometric major axis ) and the photometric axis ratio ( b / a ) . for a well - behaved disk galaxy , the photometric pa will align with the kinematic pa ( the direction of the largest velocity gradient ) and the axis ratio can be used to correct the derived rotation velocity for the inclination of the galaxy to the line of sight . the photometric pa and axis ratio were measured with galfit @xcite by @xcite on the h - band ( f160w ) , j - band ( f125w ) and y - band ( f105w ) for all of the h - band selected candels galaxies in our fields . we refer to these papers for measurement details . for this paper , we adopt the h - band measurements ( rest i at @xmath38 , rest v at @xmath39 ) . the available broadband measurements span from the uv to the nir with ancillary spitzer / mips 24/70@xmath40 photometry and herschel far - ir photometry from the goods - herschel and pacs evolutionary probe surveys . as described in @xcite , integrated stellar masses ( @xmath23 ) were derived from the broadband sed of each galaxy using the fast fitting code @xcite assuming a @xcite initial mass function , @xcite stellar population synthesis models and a @xcite extinction law . the errors on the stellar masses are @xmath410.3 dex @xcite . dust - corrected star - formation rates were derived following the sfr - ladder @xcite . for galaxies with spitzer and herschel far - ir detections , the sfr is calculated from both the obscured ( ir ) and unobscured ( uv ) components ( following ) . for non - detections in the mid - far ir , the star - formation rates are derived from the uv and are extinction - corrected following the best fit attenuation from the sed modeling . in figure [ fig : m_sfr ] we show the star - formation rate vs stellar mass diagrams for our sample , the star - formation main sequence " ( e.g. @xcite ) . galaxies drawn from the full candels catalog in goods - s are shown by black dots in the background . our sample is generally representative of the sf main sequence down to a stellar mass @xmath42 in the 1.3 @xmath14 z @xmath14 1.8 redshift bin and 9.6 in the 1.8 @xmath14 z @xmath14 2.8 bin . we make a comparison with the blue galaxy stellar mass functions at 1.5 @xmath14 z @xmath14 2.0 and 2.0 @xmath14 z @xmath14 2.5 @xcite and note that our sample spans close to the knee of the schechter function , @xmath43 , in both redshift intervals . ) of the emission versus the continuum for each slit on every galaxy used in this paper . resolved observations are marked with red filled circles and the discarded unresolved observations are marked as black x s . the range of seeing conditions during the observations is shown as a grey shaded swath . emission line sizes are seeing corrected from the mosfire 1d emission profile . continuum sizes are measured from sersic fits to the h - band hubble images . as shown in the appendix , kinematic structure can be resolved down to a limiting resolution of d@xmath44 = 0.8@xmath45 seeing@xmath46 , where d@xmath44 is the 1d seeing - corrected emission line size . ] one of the main challenges to measuring rotation with ground based data comes from the effects of beam smearing @xcite . seeing smooths out velocity gradients and artificially boosts the velocity dispersion in the central parts of rotating galaxies . this effect can generally be modeled , except in the cases where the emission extent is comparable to or smaller than the seeing . galaxies with small emission extents can appear dispersion - dominated in seeing - limited data but reveal rotation at higher resolution @xcite . in order to examine the effects of beam - smearing on our data , we produce a suite of simulated mosfire / sigma spectra in the appendix . we conclude that , for the typical signal to noise of the spectra in our sample , we can reliably recover intrinsic kinematics ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) down to d@xmath44 @xmath47 0.8 @xmath45 seeing@xmath46 , where d@xmath44 is the 1d half - light diameter measured from the emission lines and seeing@xmath46 is the full width at half maximum of the seeing . we make size selections using the emission rather than the continuum for a couple of reasons . first , the 2d half - light radii of the emission typically extend beyond the continua @xcite . secondly , seeing tends to blur emission that is not coincident with the slit placement into the slit @xcite . as such , an emission size determined from a projection of the slit onto the hst image may underestimate the extent of the emission measured with the slit . by measuring sizes directly from the seeing - corrected emission lines , we bypass both of these uncertainties . in figure [ fig : cont_size_em_size ] we show the half - light diameter sizes , in both emission and continuum , for the galaxies in our sample . for each slit , the emission line size is measured directly from the spectrally - collapsed emission line . due to the convolution of the intrinsic profile with the seeing , the spatial profiles of the spectrally - collapsed emission lines are generally well described by a 1d gaussian . the seeing is subtracted from the observed profile in quadrature ( @xmath48 ) and the half - light size is measured from the recovered intrinsic profile . continuum radii are measured from the hst / wfc3 h - band image using the galfit software package in @xcite . for the galaxies in our sample , the half - light radii of the intrinsic emission profiles tend to be slightly larger than the continuum sizes . this could be the case for two reasons . first , the half - light radius that is measured by galfit is a 2d quantity measured on concentric ellipses while the emission size is being measured directly from the 1d emission lines , an along - the - slit measurement . since the 1d measurement essentially integrates the light across the slit , these two sizes will not directly scale to one another in general . the difference may also be physical , in the sense that the emission profile can extend beyond that of the continuum ( @xcite ) . kinematics are measured from strong nebular emission lines ( h@xmath29 , @xmath305007 ] ) in the spectra . these lines generally trace the hot ( t@xmath3610@xmath49 k ) ionized gas in hii regions surrounding ongoing star - formation . the kinematics are measured using the code rotcurve @xcite . the instrumental resolution of our spectra ( r@xmath363630 ) allow us to measure the velocity dispersion down to @xmath4120 km s@xmath26 and the rotation velocity uncorrected for inclination ( @xmath50 ) to @xmath4115 km s@xmath26 . the kinematic modeling performed by rotcurve has been described in detail in previous papers , so we will briefly outline it here and refer to @xcite for further details . rotcurve models the spatial profile of the emission line as a 1d gaussian . in each row along the slit , we recover a velocity and velocity dispersion using an uncertainty - weighted least squares fit to a 1d gaussian . nearby , but not overlapping , skylines are manually masked to prevent noise peaks from driving the fit . the velocity structure of the line is modeled with two components : a rotation curve and a dispersion term . due to our limited spatial resolution , the velocity dispersion is kept constant with radius in the model . the rotation velocity is modeled with an arctan function : @xmath51 where r@xmath52 is the knee radius for the turnover of the rotation curve and @xmath53 is the velocity of the flat part of the rotation curve . we note that the flat part of the rotation curve is not reached in a fraction of our galaxy sample ( see appendix ) and in these cases @xmath53 is driven by the scale of the velocity difference reached by the data and the modeled turnover radius . due to the seeing blur , r@xmath52 is not well constrained and so we fix the turnover radius in the model at a fiducial value of 0.2@xmath35 ( 1.7 kpc at @xmath0 ) and adjust to 0.3@xmath35 or 0.4@xmath35 for galaxies that are not well fit initially . the turnover radius and the rotation velocity are moderately covariant with a @xmath540.1change in r@xmath52 resulting in a @xmath540.1 dex change in @xmath53 . the model parameters of @xmath53 and @xmath2 are explored on a grid of 5 km s@xmath26 . the modeled emission line is then spatially convolved with a fixed seeing kernel ( 0.6 fwhm ) , which is the typical seeing of our observations in the nir . the best fit model is determined through a @xmath55 minimization with the data over this grid . the velocity dispersion term that we measure ( @xmath2 ) is unlike a pressure supported stellar velocity dispersion . the hot gas which @xmath2 is tracing can collisionally radiate and so a high dispersion system can not remain in equilibrium after a crossing time . due to the seeing blur , the velocity dispersion is a measure of the small scale velocity gradients below the seeing limit . the velocity dispersion measured from nebular emission lines will be a combination of : ( . ) thermal broadening of the gas ( @xmath2410 km s@xmath26 for h at 10@xmath56 k ) , ( . ) internal turbulence in hii regions ( @xmath24 20 km s@xmath26 for local hii regions ; ) , ( . ) relative motions between hii regions . the inclination is measured as @xmath57 , where @xmath29 is the correction for the thickness of the disk ( @xmath29 = 0.2 ) and b / a is the axis ratio of the galaxy , measured from the hst h - band image . the rotation velocity is then corrected as @xmath58 . as indicated by @xcite , distinguishing late - stage mergers and rotating disks is difficult in low resolution kinematics observations . at high redshift , where galaxy mergers are expected to be common @xcite , disk classifications made from kinematic signatures alone may be biased high . in 2 galaxies in our sample ( i d : 21897 and 4476 ) we identify an interacting neighbor in both the hst image ( @xmath59 ) and the mosfire spectrum ( @xmath60 km s@xmath26 ) . we mask the emission line of the neighboring source in both of these cases . we note that late - stage interactions , for which two galaxies are identified as a single source , may be included in this sample . a joint analysis of the hst imaging and the kinematic data is necessary to disentangle disks from late - stage mergers in our sample . for all subsequent analyses , we interpret the measured velocity gradient of each galaxy as rotation . in figure [ fig : kin_example ] , we show example kinematic fits for three galaxies in our sample : a strongly rotating galaxy , a galaxy with comparable velocity and velocity dispersion , and a dispersion dominated galaxy . even in the dispersion dominated case , we note the presence of a velocity gradient , although it is small compared to the observed dispersion . the rotationally supported system is a well - ordered disk galaxy , similar to disk galaxies today , with the presence of spiral structure and a bar in the hst image . in its spectrum , we find a strong rotation signature ( @xmath24 175 km s@xmath26 ) and a mild velocity dispersion ( @xmath24 35 km s@xmath26 ) . beam smearing tends to blur together spatially separate regions of emission , leading to a flattening of nearby velocity gradients and an elevation in the local velocity dispersion . in the observed line , this effect leads to a classic peak in the velocity dispersion at the center of the galaxy , where the velocity gradient is the steepest . this can be seen in the example kinematic fits in figure [ fig : kin_example ] , particularly for the strongly rotating galaxy . rotcurve models the seeing and accounts for this artificial beam smearing when constructing its model . the best - fit kinematic parameters of the full sample are presented in table [ tab : table2 ] of the appendix . single - slit spectroscopy is a reliable method for recovering rotation velocity and velocity dispersion in observations where the position angle of the slit is aligned with the kinematic major axis of the galaxy . in ordered disk galaxies , the kinematic and photometric major axes are aligned and so the hst / wfc3 image can be used to determine the kinematic major axis . however , the morphologies of high redshift star - forming galaxies can be more severely disturbed than local or low redshift samples ( e.g. , @xcite ) , implying that the photometric and kinematic major axes might be misaligned . in a sample that combines galaxies at both @xmath61 and @xmath0 , @xcite report that kinematic and photometric axes are at least moderately misaligned ( @xmath62 ) in @xmath2440@xmath63 of galaxies and are largely misaligned ( @xmath64 ) in @xmath2420@xmath63 . this fraction declines to @xmath65 in local galaxies . for seeing - limited observations of high redshift galaxies , slit placement is much less stringent than for local galaxies or for higher resolution observations . to recover rotation , the alignment between the slit and the kinematic major axis should be within 45@xmath31 ( see figure 13 of @xcite ) . a total of 26 galaxies in sigma have observations at multiple position angles ( @xmath66 , see figure [ fig : vel_map_combined ] ) . due to the non - uniform coverage of our maps , we do not simultaneously model all of the observed slits on a galaxy . instead we examine the kinematic measurements along each slit separately and adopt measurements for the slit with the highest rotational signature . we require that every galaxy in sigma have at least one slit that is aligned within 45@xmath31 of the photometric major axis ( @xmath67 ) . this requirement ensures that rotation will be recovered in disk galaxies , where the photometric and kinematic axes are aligned . of the 26 galaxies with kinematic measurements at more than one pa , 17 have at least one slit aligned and one slit misaligned with @xmath68 . of these systems , we find the largest velocity gradient in a misaligned slit in 23@xmath63 of the cases ( 4 galaxies ) and in an aligned slit in 77@xmath63 of the cases ( 13 galaxies ) . this result is consistent with @xcite . the 4 galaxies in our sample for which the strongest velocity shear is found in a misaligned slit all display complex morphology in both the hst / acs v - band and hst / wfc3 h - band images . for these 4 galaxies , we adopt the line of sight velocity shear ( @xmath69 ) for our analysis and do not correct the velocity for inclination . these galaxies are marked in all of the figures . as shown in an example in figure [ fig : vel_map_combined ] , these systems tend to have complex velocity profiles . in some of these cases , velocity shear is found in the aligned slit as well , implying that the velocity gradient ( either tracing global rotation or more complex motions ) may lie between both slits . the tully - fisher relation ( tf ; ) is an empirical scaling relating the dynamics and the luminosity , or more recently , stellar mass of galaxies . in the local universe , the relation is relatively tight for massive disk galaxies ( e.g. , @xcite ) but begins to show small residuals to low mass for gas - rich galaxies @xcite and large residuals to low rotation velocity for irregular low mass galaxies ( @xmath70)@xcite . numerous studies have extended the analysis of the tf relation to both intermediate , 0.1 @xmath14 z @xmath14 1.3 ( e.g. , ) , and high redshift , 1.3 @xmath14 z @xmath14 3.0 ( e.g. , @xcite ) . and @xcite were the first to note that intermediate redshift galaxies with perturbed / complex kinematics and irregular morphologies tend to exhibit large scatter from the tf relation , with subsequent studies confirming such findings ( e.g. , ) . recent lensing work at high redshift has also found evidence for scatter to low rotation velocity from the tf relation for a handful of low mass galaxies @xcite . however , due to a combination of sensitivity limitations and survey selection , the low mass regime of the high - redshift tf relation has not been explored with large numbers of galaxies . we will now explore the low mass tf relation at @xmath0 with sigma galaxies . in the top panel of figure [ fig : kinematics ] we plot the stellar mass tully - fisher relation for the galaxies in sigma . the points are color coded to indicate the ratio of ordered ( @xmath1 ) to disordered ( @xmath2 ) motions in each galaxy , which we will refer to as kinematic order " . only one pa , the pa with the strongest velocity gradient , is shown for each galaxy . as described in 4.1 , we do not apply an inclination correction for the 4 galaxies whose largest velocity gradients are measured at a @xmath71 pa @xmath28 45@xmath31 . a few galaxies have a best - fit rotation velocity which is below the nominal resolution limit of our spectra , shown by the dashed line . we set these galaxies at an upper limit of @xmath1 @xmath45 @xmath72 @xmath14 15 km s@xmath26 in subsequent figures . the most massive galaxies in sigma ( @xmath73 ) lie on or above the tf ridge line , which we define using the local relation from @xcite . these galaxies exhibit values of @xmath74 , factors of a few lower than local galaxies at the same mass . we perform a simple linear regression to the stellar mass tf relation for these 12 massive ( @xmath73 ) rotationally - supported galaxies ( @xmath75 ) . we fix the slope to the value from local relation and report an offset to lower @xmath23 of @xmath76 @xmath77 . if these systems are gas - rich , then the baryonic ( @xmath23+@xmath78 ) tf relation is the more applicable scaling relation . although measurements of gas mass are unavailable for the galaxies in our sample , we note that an offset in mass of @xmath79 implies that we may be missing @xmath80 of the baryonic mass . this is consistent with estimates of the molecular gas reservoirs in massive galaxies at high redshift ( e.g. , @xcite ) . as sigma includes both rotationally - supported and dispersion - dominated galaxies , we make no further attempt to characterize an evolution in the slope , scatter or intercept of the stellar mass tf relation for disks , which would require morphological pruning . at low stellar stellar mass ( @xmath81 ) we find significant scatter from the ridge line to low rotation velocity . a large fraction of these galaxies show marginal rotation support , with values of @xmath82 . in the middle panel of figure [ fig : kinematics ] we show the velocity dispersion as a function of stellar mass . as discussed in 3 , the velocity dispersion that we measure is corrected for seeing and modeled as a constant term across the galaxy . due to the finite width of the slit ( 0.7@xmath35 ) and the effects of seeing ( @xmath24 0.6@xmath35 ) , @xmath2 is an integration of small scale velocity gradients , thermal broadening and internal turbulence . the velocity dispersion is only mildly correlated with stellar mass , with more massive galaxies displaying marginally higher velocity dispersions . the mean and rms scatter of @xmath2 for the low mass ( @xmath83 ) and high mass ( @xmath84 ) samples are 57@xmath8519 km s@xmath26 and 64@xmath8529 km s@xmath26 , respectively . the galaxies which fall from the tf ridgeline to low @xmath1 display characteristically higher @xmath2 at fixed stellar mass . in other words , the lower @xmath1/@xmath2 in these galaxies is due to both lower rotation velocity and higher velocity dispersion . star - forming galaxies at z @xmath24 2 tend to have much stronger kinematic contributions from @xmath2 than their local counterparts . for the bulk of our sample there appears to be a floor in velocity dispersion of @xmath2 = 30 km s@xmath26 . this floor is slightly higher than the typical gas velocity dispersion in local disk galaxies , @xmath86 km s@xmath26 @xcite , and higher than the spectral resolution limit of our observations , @xmath24 20 km s@xmath26 . to combine the quantities @xmath1 and @xmath2 into a more fundamental quantity , many authors ( e.g. , ) adopt a joint kinematic parameter , @xmath87 @xcite . a common choice is made for @xmath88 , motivated by virial arguments for a spherically symmetric tracer distribution ( see @xcite ) . the @xmath89 quantity more reliably traces the overall potential of a galaxy system , independent of morphology , recent disturbance or kinematic state @xcite . in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : kinematics ] we show the @xmath90 relation for our sample , which re - establishes the tf relation for all galaxies . this has been found previously at @xmath0 @xcite . we note that our low mass galaxies are relatively consistent with the @xmath91 relation found by @xcite , while the high mass galaxies tend to be offset to higher @xmath89 . @xcite report a similar offset in the @xmath0 @xmath89 relation over their full mass range ( @xmath92 ) . @xcite have argued that it is necessary for the @xmath93 to evolve to higher @xmath89 at fixed mass in order to correctly predict the cosmic stellar mass density . as discussed before , this offset might reflect a rise in @xmath94 at higher redshift . from the local tf ridge line , defined by @xcite . the largest scatter is found at low stellar mass ( @xmath95 ) . middle : the relation between integrated gas velocity dispersion ( @xmath2 ) and @xmath23 is shown . the slowly rotating galaxies that fall from the tf relation have elevated velocity dispersions . bottom : the s@xmath96 tf relation is shown along with the fit and scatter from the @xmath91 deep2 sample @xcite and the local faber - jackson relation , defined by @xcite . the handful of galaxies in which the largest velocity gradient was measured in an off - axis slit are not inclination corrected and are shown as open circles . the resolution limits for measuring rotation and dispersion in sigma is given by the horizontal dashed lines in the top and middle plots . ] we perform a least - squares linear fit to the @xmath89 tf relation , @xmath12 @xmath89 @xmath97 km s@xmath98 = @xmath99 , for the full sample . we report coefficients of @xmath100 and @xmath101 with an rms scatter @xmath102 = 0.19 . even with the apparent dichotomy between the low mass and high mass regions noted above , we find that the slope , amplitude and scatter of the full sample is relatively consistent with the @xmath91 relation ( @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath102 = 0.14 ) found in @xcite and the local faber - jackson relation ( @xmath29 = 0.286 , @xmath105 = 1.965)@xcite . as discussed in 5 , the low mass galaxies in our sample show the strongest residuals from the tf ridge line and the lowest values of @xmath4 . in the settling of disk galaxies , massive galaxies are expected to form ordered disks first , followed later by lower mass galaxies ( kinematic downsizing " ; @xcite ) . to probe the drivers of kinematic disturbance at @xmath0 , we examine the relation between the kinematic order of sigma galaxies ( @xmath1/@xmath2 ) and three of their physical properties : star - formation rate , effective radius and stellar mass . to separate out the dependance of size and sfr on stellar mass , we examine deviations from the size - mass and sfr - mass relations at @xmath0 . we find that , at fixed stellar mass , @xmath1/@xmath2 is only weakly correlated with sfr and mildly correlated with half - light radius . the strongest correlation is found to be with stellar mass , wherein more massive galaxies tend to be the most rotationally supported . we describe these relations in more detail below . we perform a ranked spearman correlation test to quantify the association in each relation . the spearman coefficient ( @xmath106 ) measures the strength of a correlation and we use the common interpretation : @xmath107 ( very weak correlation ) , @xmath108 ( weak / moderate correlation ) , @xmath109 ( moderate / strong correlation ) . the p - value ( @xmath110 ) indicates the probability of uncorrelated data producing the given spearman coefficient . in the left panel of figure [ fig : vsig_others ] we examine the correlation of @xmath4 with stellar mass following k12 for @xmath1111.2 . we note that the trend is the strongest of the three we investigate , with an increasing trend of @xmath1/@xmath2 with stellar mass and a spearman coefficient , @xmath112 ( @xmath113 ) . if we only include the galaxies with detected rotation and inclination corrections ( i.e. , filled circles ) , the trend with stellar mass strengthens to @xmath114 ( @xmath115 ) . next , we examine the departure of our galaxies from the size - mass relation at @xmath0 , as parameterized for late type galaxies in table 1 of @xcite . we use the @xmath116 and @xmath117 size - mass relations for our low and high redshift bins , respectively . the half - light size used for these relations is calibrated to rest - frame 5000 (1.5 @xmath33 m at z@xmath1182 ) and so we adopt the h - band half - light radii for comparison . in the middle panel of figure [ fig : vsig_others ] , we present the differences between the half - light radii of our galaxies and the size - mass relation ( @xmath119r@xmath120 = r@xmath121 - r@xmath122 . ) . the intrinsic scatter of the relation is 0.18 and 0.19 dex for both the low and high redshift bins , respectively , consistent with the rms scatter in our sample of 0.19 . we note that there is a weak / mild correlation between @xmath1/@xmath2 and @xmath71 r@xmath120 , as quantified by the spearman coefficient @xmath123 ( @xmath124 ) . finally , in the right panel of figure [ fig : vsig_others ] , we examine the correlation of kinematic order with a galaxy s departure from the 1.5 @xmath14 z @xmath14 2.6 star - formation main sequence ( @xmath125 ) . if the dispersion - dominated galaxies are being disrupted by internal processes associated with star - formation , we would expect a correlation between @xmath4 and the position of a galaxy on the star - formation main sequence . we adopt the main sequence fit of @xcite as parameterized in @xcite and adjust to a chabrier imf to match with our sample . this relation is valid over @xmath126 , spanning our full mass interval . we find no strong trend with @xmath127 sfr ( defined as @xmath12 sfr@xmath128 - @xmath12 sfr@xmath129 ) and @xmath1/@xmath2 . in other words , at fixed stellar mass the position of a galaxy above or below the star - formation main sequence is not related to its internal gas kinematics . the spearman coefficient between these two values confirms the lack of a trend , @xmath130 ( with @xmath131 ) . combining kinematic measurements at @xmath0 from both the kmos-3d @xcite and mosdef surveys @xcite , @xcite investigated the trend of v/@xmath2 with specific star formation rate ( @xmath132 ) and stellar mass , finding a declining and weakly increasing trend respectively . we find that , when we fix for stellar mass , there is no dependance on sfr . instead , the strongest correlation in the sigma sample is with stellar mass alone . if we consider that the gas mass scales with sfr @xcite , these results would indicate that the kinematic order of a galaxy is more strongly linked with its mass than its gas fraction . in this section we compare our measurements of @xmath1/@xmath2 with a model for gas rich marginally stable disks using the refined toomre analysis given in @xcite . we find that high mass galaxies in our sample are in general agreement with this model , indicating that they have already assembled primitive disks . galaxies which have already settled to become disks by @xmath0 are gas rich ( e.g. , @xcite ) and are expected to be in a marginally stable ( to collapse ) equilibrium ( e.g. , @xcite ) , regulated by ubiquitous inflows , outflows and star - formation @xcite . this regulator model successfully describes the elevated velocity dispersions in high redshift gas - rich disks @xcite . following the work of @xcite and @xcite , @xmath4 of the ionized gas in a marginally stable disk can be estimated from the toomre criterion : @xmath133 where @xmath134 is a constant which is set to @xmath135 for a flat rotation curve , as discussed in @xcite . the quantity @xmath136 is the critical toomre parameter which , considering the range of realistic disks , can vary between 0.67 ( single - component thick disk ; @xcite ) and 2.0 ( two - component thin disk ; @xcite ) . the gas fraction ( @xmath137 ) can be estimated from the gas depletion timescale ( @xmath138 ) and the specific star - formation rate ( @xmath139 ) as @xmath140 . the gas depletion timescale is relatively constant with stellar mass at @xmath0 and we fix it to @xmath141 yr ( @xcite ) . for our analysis we adopt the ssfr - m@xmath142 relation at z = 2 from @xcite using the fit in @xcite . equation 2 is derived assuming that the gravitational force exerted by @xmath143 is supported by rotation , which is not generally true for our dispersion dominated systems . this stability analysis would not directly apply to these galaxies , but we can still compare @xmath4 in these systems with our disk model . in figure [ fig : vsig_m ] we show @xmath1/@xmath2 as a function of stellar mass for the galaxies in our sample and additional publicly available measurements for the following surveys : sins @xcite , massiv , and lensed galaxies from @xcite and @xcite . the sins sample is the high signal - to - noise adaptive optics assisted subset and is representative of the most massive and star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 . the lensed sample and massiv sample are more generally representative of star - forming galaxies at these epochs . we use these samples to extend our mass baseline to @xmath144 and to illustrate the consistency of our measurements with those in the literature . the expected distribution of @xmath1/@xmath2 for marginally stable disks at @xmath0 is shown in figure [ fig : vsig_m ] and follows from the model described above . this range includes a characteristic break above @xmath145 , due to a kink in the @xmath0 stellar mass ssfr relation . we find that high mass galaxies ( @xmath146 ) are in general agreement with the marginally stable disk model , i.e. , high mass galaxies have already assembled their disks by @xmath0 . in general these disks are expected to contain large gas reservoirs which drive violent disk instabilities and maintain elevated velocity dispersions . these galaxies are unlike local disks of the same mass , which have values of @xmath147 as opposed to @xmath148 . as their gas reservoirs deplete , they are expected to stabilize and form well - ordered disks @xcite . below a stellar mass of @xmath149 we find the common occurrence of systems which are dispersion dominated and/or marginally rotationally supported ( @xmath1/@xmath2 @xmath150 1 ) . for comparison , the most dispersion dominated system expected from the disk model is @xmath1/@xmath2 = 0.7 ( f@xmath151 = 1 , q@xmath152 = 2 in eq 2 ) . galaxies with lower @xmath1/@xmath2 would be considered globally stable to gas collapse ( q @xmath28 q@xmath152 ) , even as they are obviously forming stars . although gas - rich disks with high velocity dispersion are expected at @xmath0 , a large fraction of our low mass sample can not be described by this simple model for marginally stable disks . we present the first results of sigma ( survey in the near - infrared of galaxies with multiple position angles ) , a kinematic survey of 49 star - forming galaxies over 1.3 @xmath14 z @xmath14 3.0 in three of the candels fields . sigma is representative of the @xmath0 star - formation main sequence to @xmath153 = 9.2 at @xmath154 and @xmath153 = 9.6 at @xmath155 , and includes galaxies with both disk and irregular morphologies . internal kinematics ( rotation velocity @xmath1 and gas velocity dispersion @xmath2 ) are measured from resolved rest - optical nebular emission lines ( h@xmath29 , @xmath30 5007 ) in keck / mosfire nir spectra . we find that high mass galaxies ( @xmath156 ) at @xmath0 are generally rotationally supported , fall on the tf relation , and have formed primitive disks with high @xmath2 . these marginally stable disks are expected to decline in @xmath2 with time as they deplete their gas supply @xcite . in contrast , a large fraction of low mass galaxies ( @xmath157 ) at this epoch are in the early phases of assembling their disks . they have much lower kinematic order " ( @xmath158 ) and tend to fall to low @xmath1 from the tully - fisher relation . for perspective , these results imply that a milky - way progenitor at @xmath0 ( @xmath159 ; @xcite ) is likely still in the process of forming a disk . combining both @xmath1 and @xmath2 in @xmath89 , all of the galaxies in sigma fall on the @xmath89 tully - fisher relation , indicating that many galaxies at low mass have strong contributions of kinematic support in the form of @xmath2 . following @xcite at @xmath1111 , the tendency for high mass galaxies to develop disks first is referred to as kinematic downsizing " , and these results imply that it is in place at @xmath0 . to gain insight into the underlying drivers of kinematic disruption , we explore the dependance of @xmath1/@xmath2 on three physical parameters of galaxies : size , star - formation rate and stellar mass . we find that the strongest trend is with stellar mass , wherein high mass galaxies have the strongest rotational support ( i.e. , highest values of @xmath4 ) . we examine the relation between @xmath4 and residuals from the star - formation main sequence and we find no correlation , to within the uncertainties of our measurements . given that the star - formation rate is likely tracing the available gas mass @xcite , our results imply that mass may be more fundamental than gas fraction in determining kinematic order . finally , we find a moderate correlation between @xmath4 and size , likely associated with the increased angular momentum of the rotationally supported systems . the strong trend between @xmath4 and mass and the lack of a correlation with sfr at fixed mass implies that the processes that maintain @xmath2 in galaxies should be most efficient at low stellar mass and should be independent on gas fraction . several processes which disrupt disk galaxies are active at @xmath0 , associated with elevated star - formation and rising merger rates @xcite . several of these mechanisms may play a role in preferentially stalling disk formation in low mass galaxies . feedback through stellar winds and supernovae can effectively blow out gas and dynamically heat stars in low mass dwarf galaxies ( @xmath160 ; e.g , @xcite ) . we note that we find no trend between @xmath4 and @xmath161 at fixed mass among the galaxies studied in this sample ( @xmath162 ) , indicating that such feedback mechanisms may only assume a secondary role in disturbing the gas kinematics in these galaxies . mergers play a complicated role in shaping the angular momentum content of disk galaxies . models ( e.g. , @xcite ) and observations ( e.g. , ) indicate that gas - rich disks can survive major mergers , albeit with thick disks and perturbed kinematics . examining mock observations from a suite of simulated galaxy mergers , @xcite find that merger remnants tend to scatter to low @xmath1 from the tfr , similar to the low mass galaxies in our sample . although several channels exist for stalling ( and promoting ) disk formation , it is as of yet unclear what the dominate processes are in maintaining the elevated kinematic disturbance we observe in low mass galaxies at this epoch . in summary , we find that kinematic downsizing is active as far back in time as @xmath0 . while massive star - forming galaxies ( @xmath163 ) appear to have assembled primitive rotating disks by this time ( consistent with e.g. , @xcite ) , low mass galaxies tend to be more kinematically disordered and still in the early process of assembling their disks . the peak of cosmic star - formation is coincident with the epoch of disk assembly for low mass galaxies and the settling of primitive disks in high mass galaxies . the authors would like to thank the anonymous referee who provided useful suggestions that improved this paper . rcs would like to thank sandra faber , joel primack , avishai dekel and the candels - baltimore group for useful comments and discussions which have also improved the paper . rcs and sak gratefully acknowledge the support from a grant through the stsci jdf . we thank g. wirth and the tkrs-2 team for their enormous effort observing , reducing and releasing the mosfire spectra which are used for the sigma galaxies in goods - n . we wish to extend thanks to those of hawaiian ancestry on whose sacred mountain we are privileged guests . this work has made use of the rainbow cosmological surveys database , which is operated by the universidad complutense de madrid ( ucm ) , partnered with the university of california observatories at santa cruz ( uco / lick , ucsc ) . jrt acknowledges support from nasa through hubble fellowship grant @xmath16451330 awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , for nasa under contract nas 5 - 26555 . cp is supported by an appointment to the nasa postdoctoral program at nasa s goddard space flight center . agertz , o. , & kravtsov , a. v. 2015 , arxiv:1509.00853 aumer , m. , burkert , a. , johansson , p. h. , & genzel , r. 2010 , , 719 , 1230 barnes , j. e. , & hernquist , l. 1996 , , 471 , 115 barrera - ballesteros , j. k. , garca - lorenzo , b. , falcn - barroso , j. , et al . 2015 , , 582 , a21 barro , g. , trump , j. r. , koo , d. c. , et al . 2014 , , 795 , 145 begeman , k. g. 1987 , ph.d . thesis , bell , e. f. , & de jong , r. s. 2001 , , 550 , 212 bouch , n. , dekel , a. , genzel , r. , et al . 2010 , , 718 , 1001 bradford , j. d. , geha , m. c. , & van den bosch , f. c. 2016 , arxiv:1602.02757 brammer , g. b. , van dokkum , p. g. , & coppi , p. 2008 , , 686 , 1503 brammer , g. b. , van dokkum , p. g. , franx , m. , et al . 2012 , , 200 , 13 brinchmann , j. , & ellis , r. s. 2000 , , 536 , l77 brooks , a. m. , governato , f. , quinn , t. , brook , c. b. , & wadsley , j. 2009 , , 694 , 396 bruzual , g. , & charlot , s. 2003 , , 344 , 1000 calzetti , d. , armus , l. , bohlin , r. c. , et al . 2000 , , 533 , 682 ceverino , d. , dekel , a. , & bournaud , f. 2010 , , 404 , 2151 ceverino , d. , primack , j. , & dekel , a. 2015 , , 453 , 408 chabrier , g. 2003 , , 115 , 763 conselice , c. j. , bundy , k. , ellis , r. s. , et al . 2005 , , 628 , 160 contini , t. , garilli , b. , le fvre , o. , et al . 2012 , , 539 , a91 contini , t. , epinat , b. , bouch , n. , et al . 2015 , arxiv:1512.00246 cowie , l. l. , songaila , a. , hu , e. m. , & cohen , j. g. 1996 , , 112 , 839 courteau , s. , dutton , a. a. , van den bosch , f. c. , et al . 2007 , , 671 , 203 covington , m. d. , kassin , s. a. , dutton , a. a. , et al . 2010 , , 710 , 279 cresci , g. , hicks , e. k. s. , genzel , r. , et al . 2009 , , 697 , 115 daddi , e. , elbaz , d. , walter , f. , et al . 2010 , , 714 , l118 daddi , e. , bournaud , f. , walter , f. , et al . 2010 , , 713 , 686 dahlen , t. , mobasher , b. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2013 , , 775 , 93 danovich , m. , dekel , a. , hahn , o. , ceverino , d. , & primack , j. 2015 , , 449 , 2087 dav , r. , finlator , k. , & oppenheimer , b. d. 2012 , , 421 , 98 dekel , a. , sari , r. , & ceverino , d. 2009 , , 703 , 785 el - badry , k. , wetzel , a. , geha , m. , et al . 2016 , , 820 , 131 elbaz , d. , dickinson , m. , hwang , h. s. , et al . 2011 , , 533 , a119 elmegreen , b. g. , & burkert , a. 2010 , , 712 , 294 epinat , b. , amram , p. , balkowski , c. , & marcelin , m. 2010 , , 401 , 2113 fall , s. m. , & efstathiou , g. 1980 , , 193 , 189 flores , h. , hammer , f. , puech , m. , amram , p. , & balkowski , c. 2006 , , 455 , 107 frster schreiber , n. m. , genzel , r. , lehnert , m. d. , et al . 2006 , , 645 , 1062 frster schreiber , n. m. , genzel , r. , bouch , n. , et al . 2009 , , 706 , 1364 galametz , a. , grazian , a. , fontana , a. , et al . 2013 , , 206 , 10 gallazzi , a. , charlot , s. , brinchmann , j. , & white , s. d. m. 2006 , , 370 , 1106 genel , s. , dekel , a. , & cacciato , m. 2012 , , 425 , 788 genzel , r. , tacconi , l. j. , eisenhauer , f. , et al . 2006 , , 442 , 786 genzel , r. , burkert , a. , bouch , n. , et al . 2008 , , 687 , 59 genzel , r. , newman , s. , jones , t. , et al . 2011 , , 733 , 101 genzel , r. , tacconi , l. j. , lutz , d. , et al . 2015 , , 800 , 20 glazebrook , k. 2013 , pasa , 30 , e056 grogin , n. a. , kocevski , d. d. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2011 , , 197 , 35 governato , f. , brook , c. b. , brooks , a. m. , et al . 2009 , , 398 , 312 guo , y. , ferguson , h. c. , giavalisco , m. , et al . 2013 , , 207 , 24 hammer , f. , flores , h. , elbaz , d. , et al . 2005 , , 430 , 115 hammer , f. , flores , h. , puech , m. , et al . 2009 , , 507 , 1313 hopkins , p. f. , cox , t. j. , younger , j. d. , & hernquist , l. 2009 , , 691 , 1168 hung , c .- l . , rich , j. a. , yuan , t. , et al . 2015 , , 803 , 62 hung , c .- hayward , c. c. , smith , h. a. , et al . 2016 , , 816 , 99 inoue , s. , dekel , a. , mandelker , n. , et al . 2016 , , 456 , 2052 jones , t. a. , swinbank , a. m. , ellis , r. s. , richard , j. , & stark , d. p. 2010 , , 404 , 1247 juneau , s. , glazebrook , k. , crampton , d. , et al . 2005 , , 619 , l135 kassin , s. a. , de jong , r. s. , & weiner , b. j. 2006 , , 643 , 804 kassin , s. a. , weiner , b. j. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2007 , , 660 , l35 kassin , s. a. , weiner , b. j. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2012 , , 758 , 106 kennicutt , r. c. , jr . 1998 , , 36 , 189 kennicutt , r. c. , jr . 1998 , , 498 , 541 kimm , t. , devriendt , j. , slyz , a. , et al . 2011 , arxiv:1106.0538 koekemoer , a. m. , faber , s. m. , ferguson , h. c. , et al . 2011 , , 197 , 36 kriek , m. , van dokkum , p. g. , labb , i. , et al . 2009 , , 700 , 221 kriek , m. , shapley , a. e. , reddy , n. a. , et al . 2015 , , 218 , 15 law , d. r. , shapley , a. e. , steidel , c. c. , et al . 2012 , , 487 , 338 lehnert , m. d. , nesvadba , n. p. h. , le tiran , l. , et al . 2009 , , 699 , 1660 livermore , r. c. , jones , t. a. , richard , j. , et al . 2015 , , 450 , 1812 madau , p. , & dickinson , m. 2014 , , 52 , 415 mac low , m .- m . , & ferrara , a. 1999 , , 513 , 142 magnelli , b. , popesso , p. , berta , s. , et al . 2013 , , 553 , a132 mandelker , n. , dekel , a. , ceverino , d. , et al . 2015 , arxiv:1512.08791 masters , k. l. , springob , c. m. , & huchra , j. p. 2008 , , 135 , 1738 masters , d. , & capak , p. 2011 , , 123 , 638 mcgaugh , s. s. 2005 , , 632 , 859 mclean , i. s. , steidel , c. c. , epps , h. w. , et al . 2012 , , 8446 , 84460j miller , s. h. , bundy , k. , sullivan , m. , ellis , r. s. , & treu , t. 2011 , , 741 , 115 miller , s. h. , ellis , r. s. , sullivan , m. , et al . 2012 , , 753 , 74 miller , s. h. , ellis , r. s. , newman , a. b. , & benson , a. 2014 , , 782 , 115 mobasher , b. , dahlen , t. , ferguson , h. c. , et al . 2015 , , 808 , 101 mo , h. j. , mao , s. , & white , s. d. m. 1998 , , 295 , 319 momcheva , i. g. , brammer , g. b. , van dokkum , p. g. , et al . 2015 , arxiv:1510.02106 morris , a. m. , kocevski , d. d. , trump , j. r. , et al . 2015 , , 149 , 178 mortlock , a. , conselice , c. j. , hartley , w. g. , et al . 2013 , , 433 , 1185 mortlock , a. , conselice , c. j. , hartley , w. g. , et al . 2015 , , 447 , 2 nelson , e. j. , van dokkum , p. g. , frster schreiber , n. m. , et al . 2015 , arxiv:1507.03999 newman , s. f. , genzel , r. , frster schreiber , n. m. , et al . 2013 , , 767 , 104 noeske , k. g. , weiner , b. j. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2007 , , 660 , l43 papovich , c. , labb , i. , quadri , r. , et al . 2015 , , 803 , 26 peng , c. y. , ho , l. c. , impey , c. d. , & rix , h .- w . 2010 , , 139 , 2097 pizagno , j. , prada , f. , weinberg , d. h. , et al . 2005 , , 633 , 844 price , s. h. , kriek , m. , shapley , a. e. , et al . 2016 , , 819 , 80 puech , m. , flores , h. , hammer , f. , et al . 2008 , , 484 , 173 reddy , n. a. , pettini , m. , steidel , c. c. , et al . 2012 , , 754 , 25 reyes , r. , mandelbaum , r. , gunn , j. e. , pizagno , j. , & lackner , c. n. 2011 , , 417 , 2347 rodriguez - gomez , v. , genel , s. , vogelsberger , m. , et al . 2015 , , 449 , 49 rodriguez - puebla , a. , behroozi , p. , primack , j. , et al . 2016 , arxiv:1602.04813 shapiro , k. l. , genzel , r. , frster schreiber , n. m. , et al . 2008 , , 682 , 231 shields , g. a. 1990 , , 28 , 525 simons , r. c. , kassin , s. a. , weiner , b. j. , et al . 2015 , , 452 , 986 speagle , j. s. , steinhardt , c. l. , capak , p. l. , & silverman , j. d. 2014 , , 214 , 15 stewart , k. r. , brooks , a. m. , bullock , j. s. , et al . 2013 , , 769 , 74 stott , j. p. , swinbank , a. m. , johnson , h. l. , et al . 2016 , , 457 , 1888 swinbank , a. m. , papadopoulos , p. p. , cox , p. , et al . 2011 , , 742 , 11 swinbank , a. m. , sobral , d. , smail , i. , et al . 2012 , , 426 , 935 tacconi , l. j. , neri , r. , genzel , r. , et al . 2013 , , 768 , 74 tomassetti , m. , dekel , a. , mandelker , n. , et al . 2016 , , 458 , 4477 torres - flores , s. , epinat , b. , amram , p. , plana , h. , & mendes de oliveira , c. 2011 , , 416 , 1936 trump , j. r. , konidaris , n. p. , barro , g. , et al . 2013 , , 763 , l6 tully , r. b. , & fisher , j. r. 1977 , , 54 , 661 van der wel , a. , bell , e. f. , hussler , b. , et al . 2012 , , 203 , 24 van der wel , a. , franx , m. , van dokkum , p. g. , et al . 2014 , , 788 , 28 van der wel , a. , chang , y .- y . , bell , e. f. , et al . 2014 , , 792 , l6 vergani , d. , epinat , b. , contini , t. , et al . 2012 , , 546 , a118 verheijen , m. a. w. 2001 , , 563 , 694 weiner , b. j. , willmer , c. n. a. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2006 , , 653 , 1027 weiner , b. j. , willmer , c. n. a. , faber , s. m. , et al . 2006 , , 653 , 1049 wheeler , c. , pace , a. b. , bullock , j. s. , et al . 2015 , arxiv:1511.01095 whitaker , k. e. , franx , m. , leja , j. , et al . 2014 , , 795 , 104 wirth , g. d. , trump , j. r. , barro , g. , et al . 2015 , , 150 , 153 wisnioski , e. , glazebrook , k. , blake , c. , et al . 2011 , , 417 , 2601 wisnioski , e. , frster schreiber , n. m. , wuyts , s. , et al . 2015 , , 799 , 209 wuyts , s. , frster schreiber , n. m. , lutz , d. , et al . 2011 , , 738 , 106 zolotov , a. , dekel , a. , mandelker , n. , et al . 2015 , , 450 , 2327 in this appendix , we perform mock observations of simulated sigma spectra in order to determine the limiting spatial scale from which we can recover rotation velocity , if present , in our observations . we find that we can recover kinematics down to a limit of d@xmath44/seeing@xmath46 = 0.8 . in 2 , we apply this limit to our data set . the spectra presented in this paper were observed in seeing limited conditions , and as such the effects of beam smearing @xcite are important to understand . seeing tends to blur together spatially distinct velocities , leading to a decreased rotation signature and an elevated velocity dispersion . to explore the effective resolution set by beam smearing in sigma , we create a set of model spectra with various sizes and fixed kinematic parameters . as described below , we perform mock observations of the kinematics for these spectra and explore how the results vary with size . our model for a single mock sigma / mosfire spectrum consists of first creating a 1d emission line with a sersic intensity profile : where r@xmath120 is the half - light radius , @xmath166 is the intensity at the half - light radius , @xmath167 is the sersic index and @xmath168 is a numerical constant that depends on @xmath167 ( @xmath169 ) . we set @xmath170 , characteristic of the emission line intensity profile for galaxies at this redshift @xcite . we then draw from an appropriate error spectrum to set the central signal - to - noise per pixel to 15 , typical of sigma spectra . the final integrated s / n of these simulated spectra are well - matched to our sample . next , we apply an arctan velocity profile ( see eq 1 ) and a constant velocity dispersion to the emission line . we fix the rotation velocity to 100 km s@xmath26 and the velocity dispersion to 50 km s@xmath26 , characteristic of @xmath0 disk galaxies . we then apply a seeing kernel of 0.7 " in the spatial direction and mosfire instrumental broadening ( @xmath171 = 40 km s@xmath26 ) in the spectral direction . following the seeing convolution , the emission profile is well described by a gaussian ( @xmath172 ) . we repeat this process 100 times , redrawing from the error spectrum each time to create independent realizations with the same fixed parameters . we then vary the effective radius of the emission line from 0.1 - 0.7 @xmath35 in 30 even steps of 0.02@xmath35/step . at each step we again simulate 100 realizations with the same fixed properties . the final dataset contains 3000 simulated sigma spectra . to measure the kinematics from the mock spectra , we run the same fitting technique used for our observations ( rotcurve ) for each spatial scale modeled , we measure 100 values of @xmath1 and @xmath2 and examine their mean and variance . the results of this study are shown in figure [ fig : model_size ] . the rotation velocity is well recovered with an intrinsic error of @xmath24 15 km s@xmath26 . for simulated spectra with effective diameter at or greater than the seeing , we accurately recover the input rotation and dispersion . below a value of d@xmath44/seeing@xmath46 = 0.8 , the limiting spatial resolution drastically affects the recovered values of @xmath1 and @xmath2 . there is both a larger uncertainty in the measurements and a systematic decline in the measured rotation velocity . based on the results of these models , we determine that the spatial scale for recovering kinematics in our observations is diameter d@xmath44 @xmath28 0.8 @xmath45 seeing@xmath46 . above this value we can reliably recover rotational motion , if present . ccllccccc 5492 & & 03 32 41.78 & @xmath17327 51 35.28 & 1.67 & 22.51 & 10.39 & 1.95 & 0.57 + 14602 & & 03 32 14.66 & @xmath17327 47 02.70 & 1.73 & 22.37 & 10.18 & 1.44 & 0.91 + 16209 & & 03 32 15.82 & @xmath17327 46 22.36 & 1.33 & 23.47 & 9.36 & 0.23 & 0.34 + 16600 & & 03 32 30.71 & @xmath17327 46 17.17 & 1.31 & 21.20 & 10.51 & 1.59 & 0.70 + 16905 & & 03 32 15.75 & @xmath17327 46 04.32 & 1.54 & 22.15 & 10.13 & 2.05 & 0.32 + 17488 & & 03 32 20.18 & @xmath17327 45 49.31 & 1.61 & 23.16 & 9.46 & 1.15 & 0.41 + 17673 & & 03 32 33.86 & @xmath17327 45 42.65 & 1.62 & 22.69 & 10.05 & 1.68 & 0.85 + 18177 & & 03 32 12.48 & @xmath17327 45 30.42 & 1.38 & 22.03 & 10.19 & 1.57 & 0.41 + 19818 & & 03 32 18.07 & @xmath17327 44 33.44 & 1.38 & 22.43 & 9.23 & 1.31 & 0.81 + 20495 & & 03 32 11.86 & @xmath17327 44 13.38 & 1.33 & 21.30 & 10.43 & 1.69 & 0.78 + 20569 & & 03 32 29.19 & @xmath17327 44 13.21 & 1.47 & 23.89 & 9.24 & 1.44 & 0.49 + 20593 & & 03 32 12.77 & @xmath17327 44 07.77 & 1.61 & 23.13 & 10.26 & 1.49 & 0.29 + 20883 & & 03 32 26.77 & @xmath17327 43 58.22 & 1.61 & 23.43 & 9.88 & 1.14 & 0.51 + 21007 & & 03 32 31.83 & @xmath17327 43 56.26 & 1.55 & 21.80 & 10.67 & 1.55 & 0.81 + 21162 & & 03 32 23.95 & @xmath17327 43 49.09 & 1.31 & 22.16 & 9.79 & 1.02 & 0.87 + 21258 & & 03 32 30.75 & @xmath17327 43 45.34 & 1.43 & 23.17 & 9.37 & 0.93 & 0.33 + 21737 & & 03 32 30.14 & @xmath17327 43 35.44 & 1.60 & 22.55 & 10.20 & 1.08 & 0.69 + 21897 & & 03 32 34.08 & @xmath17327 43 28.43 & 1.60 & 22.44 & 9.82 & 1.51 & 0.42 + 22236 & & 03 32 26.19 & @xmath17327 43 17.38 & 1.61 & 23.09 & 9.61 & 1.03 & 0.49 + 22354 & & 03 32 13.66 & @xmath17327 43 13.08 & 1.47 & 22.45 & 9.67 & 1.28 & 0.91 + 22783 & & 03 32 26.30 & @xmath17327 43 01.89 & 1.55 & 23.11 & 9.83 & 0.71 & 0.46 + 23095 & & 03 32 38.50 & @xmath17327 42 27.89 & 1.61 & 21.93 & 10.39 & 1.65 & 0.76 + 23632 & & 03 32 28.13 & @xmath17327 42 48.27 & 1.61 & 23.35 & 9.45 & 1.01 & 0.33 + 25715 & & 03 32 22.72 & @xmath17327 41 40.74 & 1.61 & 22.12 & 10.34 & 1.60 & 0.96 + 25973 & & 03 32 26.08 & @xmath17327 41 38.49 & 1.54 & 22.74 & 9.84 & 0.92 & 0.62 + 26050 & & 03 32 13.89 & @xmath17327 41 58.29 & 1.32 & 22.57 & 9.64 & 1.78 & 0.24 + 26177 & & 03 32 27.28 & @xmath17327 42 05.20 & 1.61 & 21.11 & 10.65 & 1.73 & 0.91 + 26736 & & 03 32 26.41 & @xmath17327 42 28.30 & 1.61 & 22.21 & 10.18 & 2.09 & 0.49 + 1826 & & 12 36 18.78 & @xmath17462 08 39.70 & 2.30 & 23.03 & 9.79 & 1.12 & 0.32 + 2815 & & 12 36 35.56 & @xmath17462 09 20.33 & 2.36 & 23.26 & 9.71 & 1.11 & 0.66 + 4106 & & 12 36 39.37 & @xmath17462 10 06.60 & 2.35 & 22.40 & 10.65 & 1.58 & 0.31 + 4476 & & 12 36 13.13 & @xmath17462 10 21.11 & 2.24 & 23.50 & 9.89 & 0.95 & 0.27 + 4714 & & 12 36 36.08 & @xmath17462 10 29.90 & 2.31 & 23.01 & 10.17 & 1.03 & 0.83 + 4925 & & 12 36 11.51 & @xmath17462 10 33.72 & 2.25 & 22.52 & 10.92 & 1.73 & 0.72 + 4962 & & 12 36 18.77 & @xmath17462 10 37.28 & 2.27 & 23.56 & 9.68 & 1.12 & 0.59 + 9157 & & 12 36 13.56 & @xmath17462 12 21.58 & 2.44 & 23.13 & 9.90 & 1.75 & 0.48 + 9190 & & 12 36 18.27 & @xmath17462 12 22.18 & 2.44 & 23.38 & 9.85 & 1.13 & 0.89 + 10230 & & 12 37 06.71 & @xmath17462 12 44.61 & 2.21 & 23.23 & 10.21 & 0.94 & 0.17 + 11525 & & 12 36 26.94 & @xmath17462 13 17.86 & 2.40 & 23.91 & 9.48 & 2.11 & 0.42 + 13230 & & 12 36 09.05 & @xmath17462 13 59.03 & 2.05 & 24.83 & 9.96 & 1.19 & 0.37 + 13678 & & 12 36 44.08 & @xmath17462 14 10.10 & 2.27 & 26.53 & 9.66 & 0.82 & 0.41 + 14428 & & 12 36 35.59 & @xmath17462 14 24.01 & 2.02 & 25.47 & 11.79 & 3.61 & 0.86 + 15497 & & 12 36 21.74 & @xmath17462 14 52.85 & 2.21 & 26.28 & 10.06 & 1.14 & 0.76 + 16028 & & 12 36 51.82 & @xmath17462 15 04.72 & 2.19 & 26.38 & 10.76 & 1.00 & 0.76 + 16260 & & 12 37 00.46 & @xmath17462 15 08.86 & 2.33 & 24.82 & 10.92 & 1.14 & 0.77 + 10404 & & 02 17 35.93 & @xmath17305 13 05.20 & 2.31 & 22.92 & 10.04 & 1.55 & 0.51 + 12138 & & 02 17 48.89 & @xmath17305 12 30.38 & 2.25 & 23.26 & 9.98 & 1.24 & 0.28 + 14004 & & 02 17 30.72 & @xmath17305 11 56.22 & 2.39 & 23.25 & 10.46 & 1.54 & 0.57 + 14042 & & 02 17 32.78 & @xmath17305 11 55.93 & 2.15 & 22.65 & 9.97 & 1.52 & 0.27 + [ tab : table1 ] ccccccccc 5492 & 1 & 65.0 @xmath175 0.7 & 34.5 & 30.5 & 0.2 & 10 @xmath175 30 & 11 @xmath175 35 & 45 @xmath175 14 + 14602 & 1 & @xmath17311.7 @xmath175 0.7 & 19.0 & 30.7 & 0.2 & 25 @xmath175 37 & 59 @xmath175 87 & 85 @xmath175 23 + 16209 & 2 & 9.4 @xmath175 1.3 & 19.0 & 9.6 & 0.2 & 65 @xmath175 28 & 67 @xmath175 29 & 86 @xmath175 22 + 16600 & 2 & 7.0 @xmath175 0.2 & 10.0 & 3.0 & 0.2 & 171 @xmath175 23 & 234 @xmath175 31 & 35 @xmath175 35 + 16905 & 3 & @xmath17387.0 @xmath175 0.3 & -56.0 & 31.0 & 0.4 & 131 @xmath175 63 & 135 @xmath175 65 & 80 @xmath175 24 + 17488 & 2 & 17.4 @xmath175 1.8 & 19.0 & 1.6 & 0.2 & 5 @xmath175 14 & 5 @xmath175 15 & 45 @xmath175 5 + 17673 & 1 & @xmath1732.8 @xmath175 0.6 & 8.0 & 10.8 & 0.2 & 44 @xmath175 20 & 81 @xmath175 37 & 35 @xmath175 15 + 18177 & 2 & 83.1 @xmath175 0.4 & 56.0 & 27.1 & 0.4 & 161 @xmath175 50 & 172 @xmath175 53 & 90 @xmath175 26 + 19818 & 2 & @xmath17386.6 @xmath175 1.4 & 56.0 & 37.4 & 0.3 & 24 @xmath175 21 & 40 @xmath175 35 & 80 @xmath175 13 + 20495 & 3 & 74.1 @xmath175 0.3 & 56.0 & 18.1 & 0.4 & 120 @xmath175 27 & 187 @xmath175 42 & 65 @xmath175 22 + 20569 & 1 & 22.5 @xmath175 1.8 & 8.0 & 14.5 & 0.2 & 31 @xmath175 27 & 34 @xmath175 30 & 36 @xmath175 15 + 20593 & 2 & 34.1 @xmath175 0.9 & 19.0 & 15.1 & 0.4 & 130 @xmath175 44 & 133 @xmath175 45 & 49 @xmath175 26 + 20883 & 1 & 29.8 @xmath175 2.1 & 8.0 & 21.8 & 0.2 & 51 @xmath175 36 & 58 @xmath175 41 & 89 @xmath175 14 + 21007 & 5 & @xmath17359.5 @xmath175 0.4 & 117.0 & 3.5 & 0.2 & 136 @xmath175 24 & 227 @xmath175 40 & 39 @xmath175 40 + 21162 & 3 & @xmath17382.7 @xmath175 0.7 & 19.0 & 78.3 & 0.2 & 52 @xmath175 19 & & 80 @xmath175 6 + 21258 & 3 & @xmath17352.7 @xmath175 1.4 & 117.0 & 10.3 & 0.4 & 101 @xmath175 78 & 104 @xmath175 80 & 55 @xmath175 38 + 21737 & 1 & @xmath17319.6 @xmath175 0.6 & 8.0 & 27.6 & 0.2 & 157 @xmath175 29 & 212 @xmath175 39 & 30 @xmath175 31 + 21897 & 2 & @xmath17324.5 @xmath175 0.7 & 120.5 & 35.0 & 0.2 & 136 @xmath175 20 & 146 @xmath175 21 & 55 @xmath175 17 + 22236 & 2 & @xmath17315.7 @xmath175 1.5 & 19.0 & 34.7 & 0.2 & 110 @xmath175 32 & 123 @xmath175 35 & 50 @xmath175 23 + 22354 & 2 & 36.0 @xmath175 0.7 & 19.0 & 17.0 & 0.2 & 56 @xmath175 20 & 132 @xmath175 47 & 30 @xmath175 20 + 22783 & 1 & 32.1 @xmath175 1.5 & 10.0 & 22.1 & 0.2 & 5 @xmath175 38 & 5 @xmath175 41 & 40 @xmath175 16 + 23095 & 2 & @xmath17370.9 @xmath175 0.5 & 120.5 & 11.4 & 0.2 & 200 @xmath175 42 & 301 @xmath175 63 & 34 @xmath175 36 + 23632 & 2 & 88.3 @xmath175 1.2 & 78.5 & 9.8 & 0.2 & 34 @xmath175 18 & 35 @xmath175 18 & 39 @xmath175 8 + 25715 & 1 & @xmath17339.7 @xmath175 0.9 & 120.5 & 19.8 & 0.2 & 75 @xmath175 43 & 262 @xmath175 150 & 109 @xmath175 23 + 25973 & 3 & 33.0 @xmath175 0.8 & 19.0 & 14.0 & 0.2 & 79 @xmath175 21 & 98 @xmath175 26 & 40 @xmath175 15 + 26050 & 1 & @xmath17353.0 @xmath175 0.6 & 117.0 & 10.0 & 0.3 & 222 @xmath175 33 & 224 @xmath175 33 & 50 @xmath175 24 + 26177 & 2 & @xmath17320.1 @xmath175 0.2 & 120.5 & 39.4 & 0.2 & 74 @xmath175 18 & 174 @xmath175 42 & 45 @xmath175 13 + 26736 & 2 & @xmath17335.2 @xmath175 0.5 & -10.0 & 25.2 & 0.2 & 242 @xmath175 35 & 272 @xmath175 39 & 75 @xmath175 42 + 1826 & 1 & @xmath17311.7 @xmath175 1.2 & 32.0 & 43.7 & 0.3 & 30 @xmath175 30 & 31 @xmath175 31 & 49 @xmath175 12 + 2815 & 2 & @xmath17312.8 @xmath175 3.4 & 32.0 & 44.8 & 0.3 & 29 @xmath175 40 & 37 @xmath175 52 & 64 @xmath175 12 + 4106 & 2 & @xmath17329.5 @xmath175 0.4 & 32.0 & 61.5 & 0.3 & 82 @xmath175 64 & & 129 @xmath175 25 + 4476 & 1 & 68.0 @xmath175 2.4 & 106.9 & 38.9 & 0.3 & 90 @xmath175 37 & 91 @xmath175 37 & 60 @xmath175 25 + 4714 & 1 & @xmath17347.9 @xmath175 1.2 & 106.9 & 25.2 & 0.3 & 68 @xmath175 38 & 119 @xmath175 66 & 84 @xmath175 30 + 4925 & 3 & @xmath17329.0 @xmath175 1.2 & -21.5 & 7.5 & 0.2 & 318 @xmath175 35 & 448 @xmath175 49 & 25 @xmath175 61 + 4962 & 3 & 24.9 @xmath175 3.9 & 32.0 & 7.1 & 0.2 & 124 @xmath175 25 & 150 @xmath175 30 & 55 @xmath175 20 + 9157 & 3 & 14.6 @xmath175 0.8 & 106.9 & 87.7 & 0.3 & 64 @xmath175 22 & & 85 @xmath175 15 + 9190 & 3 & @xmath17384.2 @xmath175 1.6 & 32.0 & 63.8 & 0.2 & 21 @xmath175 28 & & 36 @xmath175 18 + 10230 & 1 & @xmath1738.3 @xmath175 7.7 & -53.0 & 44.7 & 0.3 & 50 @xmath175 26 & 50 @xmath175 26 & 45 @xmath175 20 + 11525 & 2 & 44.7 @xmath175 2.7 & 32.0 & 12.7 & 0.2 & 256 @xmath175 32 & 276 @xmath175 34 & 10 @xmath175 52 + 13230 & 1 & 22.1 @xmath175 18.5 & -21.5 & 43.6 & 0.3 & 10 @xmath175 22 & 10 @xmath175 23 & 75 @xmath175 7 + 13678 & 1 & @xmath17334.9 @xmath175 0.2 & -53.0 & 18.1 & 0.3 & 60 @xmath175 25 & 64 @xmath175 26 & 61 @xmath175 8 + 14428 & 1 & @xmath17368.3 @xmath175 5.6 & -53.0 & 15.3 & 0.2 & 82 @xmath175 24 & 157 @xmath175 46 & 71 @xmath175 14 + 15497 & 1 & 7.9 @xmath175 21.9 & 32.0 & 24.1 & 0.2 & 49 @xmath175 31 & 73 @xmath175 46 & 54 @xmath175 20 + 16028 & 1 & @xmath17371.4 @xmath175 5.8 & -53.0 & 18.4 & 0.2 & 203 @xmath175 36 & 306 @xmath175 54 & 110 @xmath175 36 + 16260 & 1 & @xmath17363.0 @xmath175 10.3 & -53.0 & 10.0 & 0.2 & 200 @xmath175 48 & 307 @xmath175 73 & 85 @xmath175 51 + 10404 & 1 & 52.2 @xmath175 1.8 & -297.0 & 10.8 & 0.2 & 100 @xmath175 33 & 114 @xmath175 37 & 74 @xmath175 14 + 12138 & 1 & 67.3 @xmath175 1.9 & -297.0 & 4.3 & 0.1 & 46 @xmath175 17 & 46 @xmath175 17 & 55 @xmath175 10 + 14004 & 1 & 40.6 @xmath175 1.3 & -297.0 & 22.4 & 0.2 & 248 @xmath175 68 & 296 @xmath175 81 & 15 @xmath175 83 + 14042 & 1 & 34.9 @xmath175 0.9 & -297.0 & 28.1 & 0.3 & 50 @xmath175 26 & 50 @xmath175 26 & 70 @xmath175 8 + [ tab : table2 ] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the last seven years have been a very exciting time for string theory . a new understanding of nonperturbative features of string theory , such as d - branes , has led to exciting new developments relating string theory to physically interesting systems such as black holes and supersymmetric gauge field theories , as well as to a new understanding of the relationship between yang - mills theories and quantum theories of gravity . despite remarkable progress in these directions , however , a consistent nonperturbative background - independent formulation of string theory is still lacking . this situation makes it impossible at this point , even in principle , to directly address cosmological questions using string theory . string field theory is a nonperturbative approach to string theory which holds some promise towards providing a background - independent definition of the theory . these lecture notes give an introduction to string field theory and review some recent work which incorporates d - branes into the framework of string field theory . this work shows that string field theory is a sufficiently robust framework that distinct string backgrounds can arise as disconnected solutions of the theory , at least for open strings . it remains to be seen whether this success can be replicated in the closed string sector . in this section we review briefly the situation in string theory as a whole , and summarize the goals of this set of lectures . in section 2 we review some basic aspects of d - branes . in section 3 , we describe a particular d - brane configuration which exhibits a tachyonic instability . this tachyon can be seen in the low - energy super yang - mills description of the d - brane geometry . this field theory tachyon provides a simple model which embodies much of the physics of the more complicated string field theory tachyon discussed in the later lectures . in section 4 we give an introduction to witten s cubic bosonic open string field theory and summarize the conjectures made by sen in 1999 , which suggested that the tachyonic instability of the open bosonic string can be interpreted in terms of an unstable space - filling d - brane , and that this system can be analytically described through open string field theory . section 5 gives a more detailed analytic description of witten s cubic string field theory . in section 6 we summarize evidence from string field theory for sen s conjectures . section 7 contains a brief review of some more recent developments . section 8 contains concluding remarks and lists some open problems . much new work has been done in this area since these lectures were presented at valdivia in january 2002 . except for a few references to more recent developments in footnotes and in the last two sections , these lecture notes primarily cover work done before january 2002 . previous articles reviewing related work include those of ohmori @xcite , de smet @xcite , and arefeva _ et al . an expanded set of lecture notes , based on lectures given by the author and barton zwiebach at tasi 01 , will appear in @xcite ; the larger set of notes will include further details on a number of topics . to understand the significance of developments over the last seven years , it is useful to recall the situation of string theory as it was in early 1995 . at that time it was clearly understood that there were 5 distinct ways in which a supersymmetric closed string could be quantized to give a microscopic definition of a theory of quantum gravity in ten dimensions . each of these approaches to quantizing the string gives a set of rules for calculating scattering amplitudes between on - shell string states which describe gravitational quanta as well as an infinite family of massive particles in a ten - dimensional spacetime . these five string theories are known as the type iia , iib , i , heterotic @xmath0 , and heterotic @xmath1 superstring theories . while these string theories give perturbative descriptions of quantum gravity , in 1995 there was little understanding of nonperturbative aspects of these theories . in the years between 1995 and 2000 , several new ideas dramatically transformed our understanding of string theory . we now briefly summarize these ideas and mention some aspects of these developments relevant to the main topic of these lectures . * dualities : * the five different perturbative formulations of superstring theory are all related to one another through duality symmetries @xcite , whereby the degrees of freedom in one theory can be described through a duality transformation in terms of the degrees of freedom of another theory . some of these duality symmetries are nonperturbative , in the sense that the string coupling @xmath2 in one theory is related to the inverse string coupling @xmath3 in a dual theory . the web of dualities relating the different theories gives a picture in which , rather than describing five distinct possibilities for a fundamental theory , each of the perturbative superstring theories appears to be a particular perturbative limit of some other , as yet unknown , underlying theoretical structure . * m - theory : * in addition to the five perturbative string theories , the web of dualities also seems to include a limit which describes a quantum theory of gravity in eleven dimensions . this new theory has been dubbed `` m - theory '' . although no covariant definition for m - theory has been given , this theory can be related to type iia and heterotic @xmath1 string theories through compactification on a circle @xmath4 and the space @xmath5 respectively @xcite . for example , in relating to the type iia theory , the compactification radius @xmath6 of m - theory becomes the product @xmath7 of the string coupling and string length in the 10d iia theory . thus , m - theory in flat space , which arises in the limit @xmath8 , can be thought of as the strong coupling limit of type iia string theory . it is also suspected that m - theory may be describable as a quantum theory of membranes in 11 dimensions @xcite , although a covariant formulation of such a theory is still lacking . * branes : * in addition to strings , all five superstring theories , as well as m - theory , contain extended objects of higher dimensionality known as `` branes '' . m - theory has m2-branes and m5-branes , which have two and five dimensions of spatial extent ( whereas a string has one ) . the different superstring theories each have different complements of d - branes as well as the fundamental string and neveu - schwarz 5-brane ; in particular , the iia / iib superstring theories contain d - branes of all even / odd dimensions . the branes of one theory can be related to the branes of another through the duality transformations mentioned above . through an appropriate sequence of dualities , any brane can be mapped to any other brane , including the string itself . this suggests that none of these objects are really any more fundamental than any others ; this idea is known as `` brane democracy '' . * m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft : * one of the most remarkable results of the developments just mentioned is the realization that in certain space - time backgrounds , m - theory and string theory can be completely described through simple supersymmetric quantum mechanics and field theory models related to the low - energy description of systems of branes . the m(atrix ) model of m - theory is a simple supersymmetric matrix quantum mechanics which is believed to capture all of the physics of m - theory in asymptotically flat spacetime ( in light - cone coordinates ) . a closely related set of higher - dimensional supersymmetric yang - mills theories are related to string theory in backgrounds described by the product of anti - de sitter space and a sphere through the ads / cft correspondence . it is believed that these models of m - theory and string theory give true nonperturbative descriptions of quantum gravity in space - time backgrounds which have the asymptotic geometry relevant to each model . for reviews of m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft , see @xcite . the set of ideas just summarized have greatly increased our understanding of nonperturbative aspects of string theory . in particular , through m(atrix ) theory and the ads / cft correspondences we now have nonperturbative definitions of m - theory and string theory in certain asymptotic space - time backgrounds which could , in principle , be used to calculate any local result in quantum gravity . while these new insights are very powerful , however , we are still lacking a truly background - independent formulation of string theory . the goal of these lectures is to describe progress towards a nonperturbative background - independent formulation of string theory . such a formulation is needed to address fundamental questions such as : what is string theory / m - theory ? how is the vacuum of string theory selected ? i.e. _ , why can the observable low - energy universe be accurately described by the standard model of particle physics in four space - time dimensions with an apparently small but nonzero positive cosmological constant ? ) , and other questions of a cosmological nature . obviously , aspiring to address these questions is an ambitious undertaking , but we believe that attaining a better understanding of string field theory is a useful step in this direction . more concretely , in these lectures we will describe recent progress on open string field theory . it may be useful here to recall some basic aspects of open and closed strings and the relationship between them . closed strings , which are topologically equivalent to a circle @xmath4 , give rise upon quantization to a massless set of spacetime fields associated with the graviton @xmath9 , the dilaton @xmath10 , and the antisymmetric two - form @xmath11 , as well as an infinite family of massive fields . for the supersymmetric closed string , further massless fields associated with the graviton supermultiplet appear these are the ramond - ramond @xmath12-form fields @xmath13 and the gravitini @xmath14 . thus , the quantum theory of closed strings is naturally associated with a theory of gravity in space - time . on the other hand , open strings , which are topologically equivalent to an interval @xmath15 $ ] , give rise under quantization to a massless gauge field @xmath16 in space - time . the supersymmetric open string also has a massless gaugino field @xmath17 . it is now understood that generally open strings should be thought of as ending on a dirichlet @xmath12-brane ( d@xmath12-brane ) , and that the massless open string fields describe the fluctuations of the d - brane and the gauge field living on the world - volume of the d - brane . it may seem , therefore , that open and closed strings are quite distinct , and describe disjoint aspects of the physics in a fixed background space - time containing some family of d - branes . at tree level , the closed strings indeed describe gravitational physics in the bulk space - time , while the open strings describe the d - brane dynamics . at the quantum level , however , the physics of open and closed strings are deeply connected . indeed , historically open strings were discovered first through the form of their scattering amplitudes @xcite . looking at one - loop processes for open strings led to the first discovery of closed strings , which appeared as _ poles _ in nonplanar one - loop open string diagrams @xcite . the fact that open string diagrams naturally contain closed string intermediate states indicates that in some sense all closed string interactions are implicitly defined through the complete set of open string diagrams . this connection underlies many of the important recent developments in string theory . in particular , the m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft correspondences between gauge theories and quantum gravity are essentially limits in which closed string physics in a fixed space - time background is captured by a simple limiting yang - mills description of an open string theory on a family of branes ( d0-branes for m(atrix ) theory , d3-branes for the cft describing ads@xmath18 , etc . ) the fact that , in certain fixed space - time backgrounds , quantum gravity theories can be encoded in terms of open string degrees of freedom through the m(atrix ) and ads / cft correspondences leads to the question of how a global change of the space - time background would appear in the quantum field theory describing the appropriate limit of the open string model in question . if such a change of background could be described in the context of m(atrix ) theory or ads / cft , it would indicate that these models could be generalized to a background - independent framework . unfortunately , however , such a change in the background involves adding nonrenormalizable interactions to the field theories in question . at this point in time we do not have the technology to understand generically how a sensible quantum field theory can be described when an infinite number of nonrenormalizable interaction terms are added to the lagrangian . one example of a special case where this can be done is the addition of a constant background @xmath19 field in space - time . in the associated yang - mills theory , such as that on a system of @xmath20 d3-branes in the case of the simplest ads / cft correspondence , this change in the background field corresponds to replacing products of open string fields with a noncommutative star - product . the resulting theory is a noncommutative yang - mills theory . such noncommutative theories are the only well - understood example of a situation where adding an infinite number of apparently nonrenormalizable terms to a field theory action leads to a sensible modification of quantum field theory ( for a review of noncommutative field theory and its connection to string theory , see @xcite ) . string field theory is a nonperturbative formulation in target space of an interacting string theory , in which the infinite family of fields associated with string excitations are described by a space - time field theory action . for open strings , this field theory is a natural extension of the low - energy yang - mills action describing a system of d - branes , where the entire hierarchy of massive string fields is included in addition to the massless gauge field on the d - brane . integrating out all the massive fields from the string field theory action gives rise to a nonabelian born - infeld action for the d - branes , including an infinite set of higher - order terms arising from string theory corrections to the simple yang - mills action . like the case of noncommutative field theory discussed above , the new terms appearing in this action are apparently nonrenormalizable , but the combination of terms must work together to form a sensible theory . in the 1980 s , a great deal of work was done on formulating string field theory for open and closed , bosonic and supersymmetric string theories . most of these string field theories are quite complicated . for the open bosonic string , however , witten @xcite constructed an extremely elegant string field theory based on the chern - simons action . this cubic bosonic open string field theory ( osft ) is the primary focus of the work described in these lectures . although witten s osft can be described in a simple abstract language , practical computations with this theory rapidly become extremely complicated . despite a substantial amount of work on this theory , little insight was gained in the 1980 s regarding how this theory could be used to go beyond standard perturbative string methods . work on this subject stalled out in the late 80 s , and little further attention was paid to osft until several years ago . one simple feature of the 26-dimensional bosonic string has been problematic since the early days of string theory : both the open and closed bosonic strings have tachyons in their spectra , indicating that the usual perturbative vacua used for these theories are unstable . in 1999 , ashoke sen had a remarkable insight into the nature of the open bosonic string tachyon @xcite . he observed that the open bosonic string should be thought of as ending on a space - filling d25-brane . he pointed out that this d - brane is unstable in the bosonic theory , as it does not carry any conserved charge , and he suggested that the open bosonic string tachyon should be interpreted as the instability mode of the d25-brane . this led him to conjecture that witten s open string field theory could be used to precisely determine a new vacuum for the open string , namely one in which the d25-brane is annihilated through condensation of the tachyonic unstable mode . sen made several precise conjectures regarding the details of the string field theory description of this new open string vacuum . as we describe in these lectures , there is now overwhelming evidence that sen s picture is correct , demonstrating that string field theory accurately describes the nonperturbative physics of d - branes . this new nonperturbative application of string field theory has sparked a new wave of work on witten s cubic open string field theory , revealing many remarkable new structures . in particular , string field theory now provides a concrete framework in which disconnected string backgrounds can emerge from the equations of motion of a single underlying theory . although so far this can only be shown explicitly in the open string context , this work paves the way for a deeper understanding of background - independence in quantum theories of gravity . in this section we briefly review some basic features of d - branes . the concepts developed here will be useful in describing tachyonic d - brane configurations in the following section . for more detailed reviews of d - branes , see @xcite . d - branes can be understood in two ways : _ a _ ) as extended extremal black brane solutions of supergravity carrying conserved charges , and _ b _ ) as hypersurfaces on which strings have dirichlet boundary conditions . _ a _ ) the ten - dimensional type iia and iib supergravity theories each have a set of @xmath21-form fields @xmath22 in the supergraviton multiplet , with @xmath12 even / odd for type iia / iib supergravity . these are the ramond - ramond fields in the massless superstring spectrum . for each of these @xmath21-form fields , there is a solution of the supergravity field equations which has @xmath21-dimensional lorentz invariance , and which has the form of an extremal black hole solution in the orthogonal @xmath23 space directions plus time ( for a review see @xcite ) . these `` black @xmath12-brane '' solutions carry charge under the r - r fields @xmath24 , and are bps states in the supergravity theory , preserving half the supersymmetries of the theory . _ b _ ) in type iia and iib string theory , it is possible to consider open strings with dirichlet boundary conditions on some number @xmath23 of the spatial coordinates @xmath25 . the locus of points defined by such dirichlet boundary conditions defines a @xmath21-dimensional hypersurface @xmath26 in the ten - dimensional spacetime . when @xmath12 is even / odd in type iia / iib string theory , the spectrum of the resulting quantum open string theory contains a massless set of fields @xmath27 and @xmath28 . these fields can be associated with a gauge field living on the hypersurface @xmath26 , and a set of degrees of freedom describing the transverse fluctuations of this hypersurface in spacetime . thus , the quantum fluctuations of the open string describe a fluctuating @xmath21-dimensional hypersurface in spacetime a dirichlet - brane , or `` d - brane '' . the remarkable insight of polchinski in 1995 @xcite was the observation that dirichlet - branes carry ramond - ramond charges , and therefore should be described in the low - energy supergravity limit of string theory by precisely the black @xmath12-branes discussed in _ a _ ) . this connection between the string and supergravity descriptions of these nonperturbative objects paved the way to a dramatic series of new developments in string theory , including connections between string theory and supersymmetric gauge theories , string constructions of black holes , and new approaches to string phenomenology . in this subsection we briefly review the low - energy super yang - mills description of the dynamics of one or more d - branes . as discussed in the previous subsection , the massless open string modes on a d@xmath12-brane in type iia or iib superstring theory describe a @xmath29-component gauge field @xmath30 , @xmath23 transverse scalar fields @xmath31 , and a set of massless fermionic gaugino fields . the scalar fields @xmath31 describe small fluctuations of the d - brane around a flat hypersurface . if the d - brane geometry is sufficiently far from flat , it is useful to describe the d - brane configuration by a general embedding @xmath32 , where @xmath33 are @xmath34 coordinates on the d@xmath12-brane world - volume @xmath35 , and @xmath36 are ten functions giving a map from @xmath35 into the space - time manifold @xmath37 . just as the einstein equations governing the geometry of spacetime arise from the condition that the one - loop contribution to the closed string beta function vanish , a set of equations of motion for a general d@xmath12-brane geometry and associated world - volume gauge field can be derived from a calculation of the one - loop open string beta function @xcite . these equations of motion arise from the classical born - infeld action @xmath38 where @xmath39 , @xmath19 and @xmath10 are the pullbacks of the 10d metric , antisymmetric tensor and dilaton to the d - brane world - volume , while @xmath40 is the field strength of the world - volume @xmath41 gauge field @xmath42 . @xmath43 represents a set of chern - simons terms which will be discussed in the following subsection . this action can be verified by a perturbative string calculation @xcite , which also gives a precise expression for the brane tension @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the string coupling , equal to the exponential of the dilaton expectation value . a particular limit of the born - infeld action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) is useful for describing many low - energy aspects of d - brane dynamics . take the background space - time @xmath46 to be flat , and all other supergravity fields ( @xmath47 ) to vanish . we then assume that the d - brane is approximately flat , and is close to the hypersurface @xmath48 , so that we may make the static gauge choice @xmath49 . we furthermore assume that @xmath50 and @xmath51 are small and of the same order . in this limit , the action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) can be expanded as @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the @xmath12-brane world - volume and the coupling @xmath54 is given by @xmath55 including fermionic terms , the second term in ( [ eq : action - expansion ] ) is simply the dimensional reduction to @xmath21 dimensions of the 10d @xmath56 super yang - mills action @xmath57 where for @xmath58 , @xmath59 is the world - volume u(1 ) field strength , and for @xmath60 , @xmath61 ( setting @xmath62 ) . when multiple d@xmath12-branes are present , the d - brane action is modified in a fairly simple fashion @xcite . consider a system of @xmath20 coincident d - branes . for every pair of branes @xmath63 there is a set of massless fields @xmath64 associated with strings stretching from the @xmath65th brane to the @xmath66th brane ; the indices @xmath67 are known as chan - paton indices . treating the fields ( [ eq : nonabelian - fields ] ) as matrices , the analogue for multiple branes of the born - infeld action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) takes the form @xmath68 this action is known as the nonabelian born - infeld action ( nbi ) . in order to give a rigorous definition to the nonabelian born - infeld action , it is necessary to resolve ordering ambiguities in the expression ( [ eq : nbi ] ) . since the spacetime coordinates @xmath31 associated with the d - brane positions in space - time become themselves matrix - valued , even evaluating the pullbacks @xmath69 involves resolving ordering issues . much work has been done recently to resolve these ordering ambiguities ( see @xcite for some recent papers in this direction which contain further references to the literature ) , but there is still no consistent definition of the nonabelian born - infeld theory ( [ eq : nbi ] ) which is valid to all orders . the nonabelian born - infeld action ( [ eq : nbi ] ) becomes much simpler in the low - energy limit when the background space - time is flat . in the same limit discussed above for the single d - brane , where we find a low - energy limit giving the u(1 ) super yang - mills theory in @xmath34 dimensions , the inclusion of multiple d - branes simply leads in the low - energy limit to the nonabelian u(n ) super yang - mills action in @xmath70 dimensions . this action is the dimensional reduction of the 10d u(n ) super yang - mills action ( analogous to ( [ eq : sym1 ] ) , but with an overall trace ) to @xmath34 dimensions . in this reduction , as before , for @xmath58 , @xmath59 is the world - volume u(1 ) field strength , and for @xmath60 , @xmath61 , where now @xmath71 and @xmath59 are @xmath72 matrices . we furthermore have , for @xmath73 , @xmath74 $ ] in the dimensional reduction . the low - energy description of a system of @xmath20 coincident flat d - branes is thus given by @xmath75 super yang - mills theory in the appropriate dimension . this connection between d - brane actions in string theory and super yang - mills theory has led to many new developments , including new insights into supersymmetric field theories , the m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft correspondences , and brane world scenarios . in this subsection we describe a remarkable feature of d - brane systems , namely a mechanism by which one or more d - branes of a fixed dimension can be used to construct additional d - branes of higher or lower dimension . in our discussion of the d - brane action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) above , we mentioned a group of terms @xmath43 which we did not describe explicitly . for a single d@xmath12-brane , these chern - simons terms can be combined into a single expression of the form @xmath76 where @xmath77 represents a formal sum over all the ramond - ramond fields @xmath78 of various dimensions . in this integral , for each term @xmath78 , the nonvanishing contribution to ( [ eq : chern - simons ] ) is given by expanding the exponential of @xmath79 to order @xmath80 , where the dimension of the resulting form saturates the dimension of the brane . for example , on a d@xmath12-brane , there is a coupling of the form @xmath81 this coupling implies that the u(1 ) field strength on the d@xmath12-brane couples to the r - r field associated with @xmath82-branes . thus , we can associate magnetic fields on a d@xmath12-brane with dissolved @xmath82-branes living on the d@xmath12-brane . this result generalizes to a system of multiple d@xmath12-branes by simply performing a trace on the rhs of ( [ eq : chern - simons ] ) for example , on @xmath20 compact d@xmath12-branes , the charge @xmath83 which is the first chern class of the u(n ) bundle described by the gauge field on the @xmath20 branes , is quantized and measures the number of units of d@xmath82-brane charge living on the d@xmath12-branes , which are encoded in the field strength @xmath59 . similarly , @xmath84 encodes d@xmath85-brane charge on the d@xmath12-branes . just as lower - dimensional branes can be described in terms of the degrees of freedom associated with a system of @xmath20 d@xmath12-branes through the field strength @xmath59 , higher - dimensional branes can be described by a system of @xmath20 d@xmath12-branes in terms of the commutators of the matrix - valued scalar fields @xmath31 . just as @xmath86 measures @xmath82-brane charge , the matrix @xmath87 \label{eq : up - charge}\ ] ] measures @xmath88-brane charge @xcite . the charge ( [ eq : up - charge ] ) should be interpreted as a form of local charge density . the fact that the trace of ( [ eq : up - charge ] ) vanishes for finite sized matrices corresponds to the fact that the net d@xmath12-brane charge of a finite - size brane configuration in flat spacetime vanishes . a simple example of the mechanism by which a system of multiple d@xmath12-branes form a higher - dimensional brane is given by the matrix sphere . if we take a system of d0-branes with scalar matrices @xmath31 given by @xmath89 where @xmath90 are the generators of su(2 ) in the @xmath20-dimensional representation , then we have a configuration corresponding to the `` matrix sphere '' . this is a d2-brane of spherical geometry living on the locus of points satisfying @xmath91 . the `` local '' d2-brane charge of this brane is given by ( [ eq : up - charge ] ) . the d2-brane configuration given by ( [ eq : matrix - sphere ] ) is rotationally invariant ( up to a gauge transformation ) . the restriction of the brane to the desired locus of points can be seen from the relation @xmath92 . we conclude our discussion of d - branes with a brief description of t - duality . t - duality is a perturbative symmetry which relates the type iia and type iib string theories . this duality symmetry was in fact crucial in the original discovery of d - branes @xcite . a more detailed discussion of t - duality can be found in the textbook by polchinski @xcite . using t - duality , we construct an explicit example of a brane within a brane encoded in super yang - mills theory , illustrating the ideas of the previous subsection . this example will be used in the following section to construct an analogous configuration with a tachyon . consider type iia string theory on a spacetime of the form @xmath93 where @xmath94 is a generic 9-manifold of lorentz signature , and @xmath4 is a circle of radius @xmath95 . t - duality is the statement that this theory is precisely equivalent , at the perturbative level , to type iib string theory on the spacetime @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is a circle of radius @xmath98 . t - duality is most easily understood in terms of closed strings , where it amounts to an exchange of winding and momentum modes of the string . the string winding modes on @xmath4 have energy @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the winding number . the t - dual momentum modes on @xmath97 have @xmath101 ; it is straightforward to check that the spectrum of closed string states is unchanged under t - duality . t - duality can also be understood in terms of open strings . under t - duality , an open string with neumann boundary conditions on @xmath4 is mapped to an open string with dirichlet boundary conditions on @xmath97 , and vice versa . thus , a dirichlet @xmath12-brane which is wrapped around the circle @xmath4 is mapped under t - duality to a dirichlet @xmath102-brane of one lower dimension which is localized to a point on the circle @xmath97 . at the level of the low - energy theory on the d - brane , the @xmath29-dimensional yang - mills theory on the @xmath12-brane is replaced under t - duality with the @xmath12-dimensional yang - mills theory on the dual @xmath102-brane . mathematically , the covariant derivative operator in the direction @xmath4 is replaced under t - duality with an adjoint scalar field @xmath31 . formally , this adjoint scalar field is an infinite size matrix , containing information about the open strings wrapped an arbitrary number of times around the compact direction @xmath97 . we can summarize the relevant mappings under t - duality in the following table [ cols=">,^ , > " , ] these numerical calculations indicate that level truncation of string field theory leads to a good systematic approximation scheme for computing the nonperturbative tachyon vacuum . up to level 12 , at level ( 14 , 42 ) the energy becomes @xmath103 , and that the energy continues to decrease , reaching @xmath104 at level ( 18 , 54 ) . in @xcite , it was shown that this calculation could be theoretically extrapolated to higher levels using the result found in @xcite that perturbative amplitudes converge in level truncation with errors described by a power series in @xmath105 . this extrapolation suggests that the energy turns around again near @xmath106 , and then increases again , asymptotically approaching @xmath107 as @xmath108 . further analysis supporting this conclusion was given in @xcite , where the effective tachyon potential was extrapolated to higher order using results calculated up to level 18 . ] it is interesting to consider the tachyon condensation problem from the point of view of the effective tachyon potential . if instead of trying to solve the quadratic equations for all @xmath20 of the fields appearing in ( [ eq : scalar - potential ] ) , we instead fix the tachyon field @xmath109 and solve the quadratic equations for the remaining @xmath110 fields , we can determine a effective potential @xmath111 for the tachyon field . this was done numerically up to level @xmath112 in @xcite@xmath113 . at each level , the tachyon effective potential smoothly interpolates between the perturbative vacuum and the nonperturbative vacuum near @xmath114 . for example , the tachyon effective potential at level ( 2 , 6 ) is graphed in figure [ f : potential ] . in all level truncations other than ( 0 , 0 ) and ( 2 , 4 ) , the tachyon effective potential has two branch point singularities at which the continuous solution for the other fields breaks down ; for the level ( 2 , 6 ) truncation , these branch points occur at @xmath115 and @xmath116 ; the lower branch point is denoted by a solid circle in figure [ f : potential ] . as a result of these branch points , the tachyon effective potential is only valid for a finite range of @xmath109 , ranging between approximately @xmath117 and @xmath118 . in @xcite it was demonstrated numerically that the branch points in the tachyon effective potential arise because the trajectory in field space associated with this potential encounters the boundary of the region of feynman - siegel gauge validity . as mentioned earlier , feynman - siegel gauge is only valid in a finite - size region around the perturbative vacuum . it seems almost to be a fortunate accident that the nonperturbative vacuum lies within the region of validity of this gauge choice . it is also worth mentioning here that in the `` background - independent '' formulation of sft , the tachyon potential can be computed exactly @xcite . in this formulation , there is no branch point in the effective potential , which is unbounded below for negative values of the tachyon . on the other hand , the nontrivial vacuum in the background - independent approach arises only as the tachyon field goes to infinity , so it is harder to study the physics of the stable vacuum from this point of view . another interesting perspective on the tachyon effective potential is found by performing a perturbative computation of the coefficients in this effective potential in the level - truncated theory . this gives a power series expansion of the effective tachyon potential @xmath119 in @xcite , the coefficients up to @xmath120 were computed in the level truncations up to ( 10 , 20 ) . because of the branch point singularity near @xmath121 , this series has a radius of convergence much smaller than the value of @xmath109 at the nonperturbative vacuum . thus , the energy at the stable vacuum lies outside the naive range of perturbation theory . thus , the stable vacuum is in some sense accessible from purely perturbative calculations . ] . we have seen that numerical results from level - truncated string field theory strongly suggest the existence of a classically stable vacuum solution @xmath122 to the string field theory equation of motion ( [ eq : sft - eom ] ) . the state @xmath122 , while still unknown analytically , has been determined numerically to a high degree of precision . this state seems like a very well - behaved string field configuration . while there is no positive - definite inner product on the string field fock space , the state @xmath122 certainly has finite norm under the natural inner product @xmath123 , and is even better behaved under the product @xmath124 . thus , it is natural to assume that @xmath122 defines a classically stable vacuum for the theory , around which we can expand the action to find a new `` vacuum string field theory '' . expanding @xmath125 we get the action @xmath126 where @xmath127 this string field theory around the stable vacuum has precisely the same form as witten s original cubic string field theory , only with a different brst operator @xmath128 , which so far is only determined numerically . note that this formulation of vacuum string field theory is distinct from the vsft model of rastelli , sen , and zwiebach ( rsz ) @xcite . these authors make an ansatz that the brst operator takes a pure ghost form , along the lines of @xmath129 , and they conjecture that the theory with such a brst operator is equivalent to the vsft model given by the brst operator ( [ eq : vsft - q ] ) . we discuss the rsz model again briefly in the next section . sen s third conjecture states that there should be no open string excitations of the theory around @xmath130 . this implies that there should be no solutions of the linearized equation @xmath131 in the vsft ( [ eq : vsft - action ] ) other than pure gauge states of the form @xmath132 . in this subsection we discuss evidence for this conjecture . it may seem surprising to imagine that _ all _ the perturbative open string degrees of freedom will vanish at a particular point in field space , since these are all the degrees of freedom available in the theory . this is not a familiar phenomenon from quantum field theory . to understand how the open strings can decouple , it may be helpful to begin by considering the simple example of the ( 0 , 0 ) level - truncated theory . in this theory , the quadratic terms in the action become @xmath133 \phi ( p ) \ , . \ ] ] taking @xmath134 , we find that the quadratic term is a transcendental expression which does not vanish for any real value of @xmath135 . thus , this theory has no poles , and the tachyon has decoupled from the theory . of course , this is not the full story , as there are still finite complex poles . it does , however suggest a mechanism by which the nonlocal parts of the action ( encoded in the exponential of @xmath135 ) can remove physical poles . to get the full story , it is necessary to continue the analysis to higher level . at level 2 , there are 7 scalar fields , the tachyon and the 6 fields associated with the fock space states @xmath136 note that in this analysis we can not fix feynman - siegel gauge , as we only believe that this gauge is valid for the zero - modes of the scalar fields in the vacuum @xmath122 . an attempt at analyzing the spectrum of the theory in feynman - siegel gauge using level truncation was made in @xcite , with no sensible results . diagonalizing the quadratic term in the action on the full set of 7 fields of level @xmath137 , we find that poles develop at @xmath138 and @xmath139 ( in string units , where the tachyon has @xmath140 ) @xcite . these poles correspond to states satisfying @xmath141 . the question now is , are these states physical ? if they are exact states , of the form @xmath132 , then they are simply gauge degrees of freedom . if not , however , then they are states in the cohomology of @xmath128 and should be associated with physical degrees of freedom . unfortunately , we can not precisely determine whether the poles we find in level truncation are due to exact states , as the level - truncation procedure breaks the condition @xmath142 . thus , we can only measure _ approximately _ whether a state is exact . a detailed analysis of this question was carried out in @xcite . in this paper , all terms in the sft action of the form @xmath143 were determined , where @xmath144 is a scalar zero - mode , and @xmath145 are nonzero - momentum scalars . in addition , all gauge transformations involving at least one zero - momentum field were computed up to level ( 6 , 12 ) . at each level up to @xmath146 , the ghost number 1 states in the kernel @xmath147 were computed . the extent to which each of these states lies in the exact subspace was measured using the formula @xmath148 where @xmath149 are an orthonormal basis for @xmath150 , the image of @xmath128 acting on the space of ghost number 0 states in the appropriate level truncation . ( note that this measure involves a choice of inner product on the fock space ; several natural inner products were tried , giving roughly equivalent results ) . the result of this analysis was that up to the mass scale of the level truncation , @xmath151 , all the states in the kernel of @xmath152 were @xmath153 within the exact subspace , for @xmath154 . this result seems to give very strong evidence for sen s third conjecture that there are no perturbative open string excitations around the stable classical vacuum @xmath122 . this analysis was only carried out for even level scalar fields ; it would be nice to check that a similar result holds for odd - level fields and for tensor fields of arbitrary rank . another more abstract argument that there are no open string states in the stable vacuum was given by ellwood , feng , he and moeller @xcite . these authors argued that in the stable vacuum , the identity state @xmath155 in the sft star algebra , which satisfies @xmath156 for a very general class of string fields @xmath157 , seems to be an exact state , @xmath158 if indeed the identity is exact , then it follows immediately that the cohomology of @xmath128 is empty , since @xmath159 then implies that @xmath160 so to prove that the cohomology of @xmath128 is trivial , it suffices to show that @xmath161 . while there are some subtleties involved with the identity string field , ellwood _ et al . _ found a very elegant expression for this field , @xmath162 ( recall that @xmath163 . ) they then looked numerically for a state @xmath164 satisfying ( [ eq : i - exact ] ) . for example , truncating at level @xmath165 , @xmath166 while the only candidate for @xmath167 is @xmath168 for some constant @xmath169 . the authors of @xcite showed that the state ( [ eq : identity-2 ] ) is best approximated as exact when @xmath170 ; for this value , their measure of exactness becomes @xmath171 which the authors interpreted as a @xmath172 deviation from exactness . generalizing this analysis to higher levels , they found at levels 5 , 7 , and 9 , a deviation from exactness of @xmath173 and @xmath174 respectively . at level 9 , for example , the identity field has 118 components , and there are only 43 gauge parameters , so this is a highly nontrivial check on the exactness of the identity . like the results of @xcite , these results strongly support the conclusion that the cohomology of the theory is trivial in the stable vacuum . in this case , the result applies to fields of all spins and all ghost numbers . given that the witten string field theory seems to have a classical solution with no perturbative open string excitations , in accordance with sen s conjectures , it is quite interesting to ask what the physics of the vacuum string field theory ( [ eq : vsft - action ] ) should describe . one natural assumption might be that this theory should include closed string states in its quantum spectrum . unfortunately , addressing this question requires performing calculations in the quantum theory around the stable vacuum . such calculations are quite difficult ( although progress in this direction has been made in the @xmath12-adic version of the theory @xcite ) . even in the perturbative vacuum , it is difficult to systematically study closed strings in the quantum string from theory . we discuss the question again briefly in the final section . in this section we review briefly some further developments which we do not have time to explore in great detail in these lectures . in subsection 7.1 we discuss the pure ghost brst operator ansatz of rsz ( rastelli , sen , and zwiebach ) for vacuum string field theory . in subsection 7.2 we discuss `` sliver '' states and related states ; these states are projectors in the sft star algebra , and are closely related to d - branes in the rsz vsft model . these topics will be discussed in further detail in @xcite in @xcite , rastelli , sen , and zwiebach made an intriguing proposal regarding the form of witten s string field theory around the stable tachyon vacuum . since the exact form of the brst operator @xmath128 given by ( [ eq : vsft - q ] ) is not known analytically , and is difficult to work with numerically , these authors suggested that it might be possible to `` guess '' an appropriate form for this operator ( after suitable field redefinition ) , using the properties expected of the brst operator in any vacuum . they suggested a simple class of brst operators @xmath175 which satisfy the properties ( a - c ) described in section 4.2 ( actually , they impose the slightly weaker but still sufficient condition @xmath176 instead of condition ( b ) ) . in particular , they propose that after a field redefinition , the brst operator of the string field theory in the classically stable vacuum should be an operator @xmath175 expressable purely in terms of ghost operators . for example , the simplest operator in the class they suggest is @xmath177 , which clearly satisfies @xmath178 , and which also satisfies condition ( c ) and the weaker form of condition ( b ) mentioned above . the rsz model of vacuum string field theory has a number of attractive features . * this model satisfies all the axioms of string field theory , and has a brst operator with vanishing cohomology . * in the rsz model , the equation of motion factorizes into the usual equation of motion @xmath179 for the ghost part of the field , and a projection equation @xmath180 for the matter part of the field , where the full string field is given by @xmath181 thus , finding a solution of the equation of motion reduces to the problem of solving the equation of motion in the ghost sector and identifying projection operators in the string field star algebra . it was also recently shown @xcite that by taking the brst operator @xmath175 to be given by a ghost insertion localized at the string midpoint , the ghost equation also has essentially the form of the projection equation . thus , this seems to be a very natural choice for the brst operator of the rsz model . * a number of projection operators have been identified in the string field star algebra . these projection operators have many of the properties desired of d - branes . we will briefly review some aspects of these projection operators in the next subsection . * given the projection operators just mentioned , the ratio of tensions between d - branes of different dimensionality can be computed and has the correct value @xcite . despite the successes of the rsz model , there are some difficult technical aspects of this picture . first , it seems very difficult to actually prove that this model is related to the vsft around the stable vacuum in the witten model , not least because we lack any analytic control over the witten theory . second , the rsz model seems to have a somewhat singular structure in several respects . formally , the action on any well - behaved fock space state satisfying the equation of motion will vanish @xcite . further , the natural solutions of the projection equation corresponding to the matter sector of the equation of motion have rather singular properties @xcite . some of these singular properties are related to the fact that some of the physics in the rsz model seems to have been `` pushed '' into the midpoint of the string . in the witten model , the condition that , for example , @xmath182 involves a fairly subtle anomaly cancellation between the matter and ghost sectors at the midpoint . in the rsz model , the matter and ghost sectors are essentially decoupled , so that the theory seems to have separate singularities in each sector , which cancel when the sectors are combined . these are all indications of a theory with problematic singularities . while the witten theory seems to be free of singularities of this type , it remains to be seen whether resolving the singularities of the rsz model or finding an analytic approach to the witten theory will be a more difficult problem to solve . from the point of view of the rsz model of vsft just discussed , projection operators in the matter sector of the star algebra play a crucial role in constructing solutions of the equations of motion . such projection operators may also be useful in understanding solutions in the original witten theory . quite a bit of work has been done on constructing and analyzing projectors in the star algebra since the rsz model was originally proposed . without going into the technical details , we now briefly review some of the important features of matter projectors . the first matter projector which was explicitly constructed is the `` sliver '' state . this state was identified in conformal field theory in @xcite , and then constructed explicitly using matter oscillators in @xcite . the sliver state takes the form of a squeezed state @xmath183| 0 \rangle \ , . \label{eq : sliver - squeezed}\ ] ] by requiring that such a state satisfy the projection equation @xmath184 , and by making some further assumptions about the nature of the state , an explicit formula for the matrix @xmath185 was found in @xcite . projectors like the sliver have many properties which are reminiscent of d - branes . this relationship between projection operators and d - branes is familiar from noncommutative field theory , where projectors also play the role of d - brane solitons @xcite ( for a review of noncommutative field theory , see @xcite ) . in the rsz model , by tensoring an arbitrary matter projector with a fixed ghost state satisfying the ghost equation of motion ( [ eq : eom - ghosts ] ) , states corresponding to an arbitrary configuration of d - branes can be constructed . particular projectors like the sliver can be constructed which are localized in any number of space - time dimensions , corresponding to the codimension of a d - brane . under gauge transformations , a rank 1 projector can be rotated into an orthogonal rank 1 projector , so that configurations containing multiple branes can be constructed as higher rank projectors formed from the sum of orthogonal rank one projectors @xcite . this gives a very suggestive picture of how arbitrary d - brane configurations can be constructed in string field theory . while this picture is quite compelling , however , there are a number of technical obstacles which make this still a somewhat incomplete story . as mentioned above , in the rsz model , many singularities appear due to the separation of the matter and ghost sectors . in the context of the matter projectors , these singularities manifest as singular properties of the projectors . for example , the sliver state described above has a matrix @xmath185 which has eigenvalues of @xmath186 for any dimension of d - brane @xcite . such eigenvalues cause the state to be nonnormalizable elements of the matter fock space . in the dirichlet directions , this lack of normalizability occurs because the state is essentially localized to a point and is analogous to a delta function . in the neumann directions , the singularity manifests as a `` breaking '' of the strings composing the d - brane , so that the functional describing the projector state is a product of a function of the string configurations on the left and right halves of the string , with no connection mediated through the midpoint . these geometric singularities seem to be generic features of matter projectors , not just of the sliver state @xcite . these singular geometric features are one of the things which makes direct calculation in the rsz model somewhat complicated , as all these singularities must be sensibly regulated . these singularities do not seem to appear in the witten theory , where the brst operator and numerically calculated solutions seem to behave smoothly at the string midpoint . on the other hand , it may be that further study of the matter projection operators and their cousins in the ghost sector which satisfy ( [ eq : eom - ghosts ] ) will lead to analytic progress on the witten theory . the work described in these lectures has brought our understanding of string field theory to a new level . we now have fairly conclusive evidence that open string field theory can successfully describe distinct vacua with very different geometrical properties , which are not related to one another through a marginal deformation . the resulting picture , in which a complicated set of degrees of freedom defined primarily through an algebraic structure , can produce different geometrical backgrounds at different solutions of the equations of motion , represents an important step beyond perturbative string theory . such an approach , where different backgrounds with different low - energy degrees of freedom arise from a single underlying formalism , is clearly necessary to discuss questions of a cosmological nature in string theory . it is clearly essential , however , to generalize from the work described here in which the theory describes distinct _ open _ string backgrounds , to a formalism where different _ closed _ string backgrounds appear as solutions to an equation of motion for a single set of degrees of freedom . clearly , it is an important goal to have a formulation of string / m - theory in which all the currently understood vacua can arise in terms of a single well - defined set of degrees of freedom . it is not yet clear , however , how far it is possible go towards this goal using the current formulations of string field theory . it may be that the correct lesson to take from the work described here is simply that there _ are _ nonperturbative formulations in which distinct vacua can be brought together as solutions of a single classical theory , and that one should search for some deeper fundamental algebraic formulation where geometry , and even the dimension of space - time emerge from the fundamental degrees of freedom in the same way that d - brane geometry emerges from the degrees of freedom of witten s open string field theory . a more conservative scenario , however , might be that we could perhaps use the current framework of string field theory , or some limited refinement thereof , to achieve this goal of providing a universal nonperturbative definition of string theory and m - theory . following this latter scenario , we propose here a series of questions aimed at continuing the recent developments in open string field theory as far as possible towards this ultimate goal . it is not certain that this research program can be carried to its conclusion , but it will be very interesting to see how far open string field theory can go in reproducing important nonperturbative aspects of string theory . some open problems : 1 . the first important unsolved problem in this area is to find an analytic description of the tachyonic vacuum . despite several years of work on this problem , great success with numerical approximations , and some insight from the rsz vacuum string field theory model , we still have no good analytic understanding of the difference between the d - brane vacuum and the empty vacuum in witten s open cubic string field theory . it seems almost unbelievable that there is not some elegant analytic solution to this problem . finding such an analytic solution would almost certainly greatly enhance our understanding of this theory , and would probably lead to other significant advances . 2 . another interesting and important unsolved problem is to find , either analytically or numerically , a solution of the witten theory describing _ two _ d25-branes . if open string field theory is truly a background - independent theory , at least in the open string sense , it should be just as feasible to go from a vacuum with one d - brane to a vacuum with two d - branes as it is to go from a vacuum with one d - brane to the empty vacuum ( or from the vacuum with two d - branes to the vacuum with one d - brane , which is essentially the same problem as going from one to none ) . despite some work on this problem @xcite , there is as yet no evidence that a double d - brane solution exists for the witten theory on a single d - brane . several approaches which have been tried ( and will be described in more detail in @xcite ) include : _ i _ ) following a positive mass field upward , looking for a stable point ; this method seems to fail because of gauge - fixing problems the effective potential often develops a singularity before reaching the energy @xmath187 , _ ii _ ) following the intuition of the rsz model and constructing a gauge transform of the original d - brane solution which is @xmath188orthogonal to the original d - brane vacuum . it can be shown formally that such a state , when added to the original d - brane vacuum gives a new solution with the correct energy for a double d - brane ; unfortunately , however , we have been unable to identify such a state numerically in level truncation . + there are several other problems closely related to the double d - brane problem . one related problem is the problem of studying a d0-brane lump solution from the tachyon field on a d1-brane wrapped on a small circle . when the circle is sufficiently small , the mass of the d0-brane is larger than that of the wrapped d1-brane . in this case , it seems much more difficult to construct the d0-brane lump solution than it is when the d0-brane has mass smaller than the d1-brane @xcite . another possibly related problem is the problem of translating a single d - brane of less than maximal dimension in a transverse direction . it was shown by sen and zwiebach @xcite ( in a t - dual picture ) that after moving a d - brane a finite distance of order of the string length in a transverse direction , the level - truncated string field theory equations develop a singularity . thus , in level truncation it does not seem possible to move a d - brane a macroscopic distance in a transverse direction . in this case , a toy model @xcite suggests that the problem is that the infinitesimal marginal parameter for the brane translation ceases to parameterize the marginal trajectory in field space after a finite distance , just as the coordinate @xmath189 ceases to parameterize the circle @xmath190 near @xmath191 . this is similar in spirit to the breakdown of feynman - siegel gauge along the tachyon potential discussed in section 6.1 . + to show that open string field theory is sufficiently general to address arbitrary questions involving different vacua , it is clearly necessary to show that the formalism is powerful enough to describe multiple brane vacua , the d0-brane lump on an arbitrary radius circle , and translated brane vacua . it is currently unclear whether the obstacles to finding these vacua are conceptual or technical . it may be that the level - truncation approach is not well - suited to finding these vacua . if this is true , however , we may need a clearer mathematical formalism for describing the theory . there is currently some ambiguity in the definition of the theory , in terms of precisely which states are allowed in the string field . level - truncation in some sense gives a regularization of , and a concrete definition to , the theory . without level truncation , we would need some more definitive mathematical tools for analyzing various features of the theory , such as the other vacua mentioned here . another open question involves the role that closed strings play in open string field theory . as has been known since the earliest days of the subject , closed strings appear as poles in perturbative open string scattering amplitudes . this was shown explicitly for witten s sft in @xcite , where it was shown that closed string poles arise in the one - loop 2-point function . if witten s theory is well - defined as a quantum theory , it would follow from unitarity that the closed string states should also arise in some natural sense as asymptotic states of the quantum open string field theory . it is currently rather unclear , however , whether , and if so how , this might be realized . there are subtleties in the quantum formulation of the theory which have never completely been resolved @xcite . both older sft literature @xcite and recent work @xcite have suggested ways in which closed strings might be incorporated into the open string field theory formalism , but a definitive resolution of this question is still not available . if it is indeed possible to encode closed string degrees of freedom in some way in the quantum open string field theory , it suggests that one could use the witten formalism in principle to not only compute general closed string scattering amplitudes , but perhaps even to address questions of closed string vacua . this is clearly an optimistic scenario , but one can imagine that the open string theory might really contain all of closed string physics as well as open string physics . this scenario is perhaps not so farfetched , as it really represents simply a lifting to the level of string field theory of the ads / cft story , where the massive as well as the massless modes are included . furthermore , the fact that , as discussed in section 5.5 , the open string diagrams precisely cover the moduli space of riemann surfaces with an arbitrary number of handles ( and at least one boundary ) , suggests that by shrinking the boundaries to closed strings , one might neatly describe all perturbative closed string amplitudes in the open string language . on the other hand , it seems quite possible that the closed string sector of the theory is encoded in a singular fashion ( like the encoding of the d - brane in the rsz vsft model ) , so that extracting the closed string physics from the open string field theory may involve such complicated manipulations that one is better off directly working with a closed string formalism . it would certainly be nice to have a clearer picture of how far one can go in this direction purely from the open string point of view . another obvious , but crucial , question is how this whole story can be generalized to superstrings . the naive witten cubic superstring field theory has technical problems arising from contact terms between picture - changing operators @xcite . it has been suggested that these problems can be resolved directly in the cubic theory @xcite . berkovits has also suggested a new non - polynomial string field theory framework which seems to deal successfully with the contact term problem , at least in the ns - ns sector @xcite . some preliminary work indicates that numerical calculations on the tachyon condensation problem for the open superstring can be carried out in the berkovits model with analogous results to those described here for the bosonic open string , although the results to date for the superstring are much more limited @xcite . it would be nice to have a more complete picture for the superstring , and some sense of how issues like the closed string question would work in the supersymmetric framework . perhaps the most important lesson we have learned from the body of work discussed in these lectures is that open string field theory is a consistent framework in which geometrically distinct open string backgrounds can arise as classical solutions of a single theory . a fundamental outstanding problem in string theory is to find a framework in which different closed string backgrounds arise in a similar fashion from some fixed set of degrees of freedom within a single well - defined theory . in principle , we would hope that all the different closed string backgrounds would arise as solutions of the equations of motion for the fundamental underlying degrees of freedom of string field theory , either by incorporating closed strings into the open string field theory framework as described above , or by working directly in some formulation of closed string field theory . it is quite challenging to imagine a single set of degrees of freedom which would encode , in different phases , all the possible string backgrounds we are familiar with . a particularly pressing case is that of m - theory . in principle , a nonperturbative background - independent formulation of type ii string theory should allow one to take the string coupling to infinity in such a way that the fundamental degrees of freedom of the theory are still actually at some finite point in their configuration space in the limit . this would lead to the vacuum associated with m - theory in flat space - time . it would be quite remarkable if this can be achieved in the framework of string field theory . given the nontrivial relationship between string fields and low - energy effective degrees of freedom , however , such a result can not be ruled out . if this picture could be successfully implemented , it would give a very satisfying understanding of how the complicated network of dualities of string and m - theory could be represented in terms of a single underlying set of degrees of freedom . i would like to thank cecs and the organizers of the school on quantum gravity for their support and hospitality , and for an extremely enjoyable summer school experience . thanks to erasmo coletti , ian ellwood , david gross , nicolas moeller , joe minahan , greg moore , leonardo rastelli , martin schnabl , ashoke sen , jessie shelton , ilya sigalov , and barton zwiebach , for many discussions and collaborations which provided the material for these lectures . thanks also to tasi 01 , where some of this material was presented prior to this school . particular thanks to barton zwiebach for suggestions and contributions to these lecture notes , which have substantial overlap with a more extensive set of lecture notes based on lectures by zwiebach and myself at tasi 01 , which will appear presently @xcite . this work was supported by the doe through contract # de - fc02 - 94er40818 . w. taylor and m. van raamsdonk , `` multiple d0-branes in weakly curved backgrounds , '' _ phys . lett . _ * b558 * ( 1999 ) , 63 , hep - th/9904095 ; `` multiple dp - branes in weak background fields , '' _ nucl . phys . _ * b573 * , 703 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/9910052 . n. berkovits , `` super - poincare invariant superstring field theory , '' _ nucl . phys . _ * b450 * ( 1995 ) , 90 , hep - th/9503099 ; `` review of open superstring field theory , '' hep - th/0105230 ; `` the ramond sector of open superstring field theory , '' jhep * 0111 * , 047 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0109100 . s. b. giddings , e. j. martinec and e. witten , `` modular invariance in string field theory , '' phys . b * 176 * , 362 ( 1986 ) . b. zwiebach , `` a proof that witten s open string theory gives a single cover of moduli space , '' commun . phys . * 142 * , 193 ( 1991 ) . d. z. freedman , s. b. giddings , j. a. shapiro and c. b. thorn , `` the nonplanar one loop amplitude in witten s string field theory , '' nucl . b * 298 * , 253 ( 1988 ) . j. a. harvey and p. kraus , `` d - branes as unstable lumps in bosonic open string field theory , '' jhep * 0004 * , 012 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0002117 ; a. a. gerasimov and s. l. shatashvili , `` on exact tachyon potential in open string field theory , '' jhep * 0010 * , 034 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0009103 ; d. kutasov , m. marino and g. moore , `` some exact results on tachyon condensation in string field theory , '' jhep * 0010 * , 045 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0009148 ; d. ghoshal and a. sen , normalisation of the background independent open string field jhep * 0011 * , 021 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0009191 ; d. kutasov , m. marino and g. moore , d. kutasov , m. marino and g. w. moore , `` remarks on tachyon condensation in superstring field theory , '' , hep - th/0010108 ; s. moriyama and s. nakamura , descent relation of tachyon condensation from boundary string phys . b * 506 * , 161 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0011002 ; a. a. gerasimov and s. l. shatashvili , `` stringy higgs mechanism and the fate of open strings , '' jhep * 0101 * , 019 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0011009 ; i. y. arefeva , a. s. koshelev , d. m. belov and p. b. medvedev , `` tachyon condensation in cubic superstring field theory , '' nucl . b * 638 * , 3 ( 2002 ) , hep - th/0011117 ; p. kraus and f. larsen , `` boundary string field theory of the d d - bar system , '' phys . d * 63 * , 106004 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0012198 ; m. alishahiha , h. ita and y. oz , `` on superconnections and the tachyon effective action , '' phys . lett . b * 503 * , 181 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0012222 ; g. chalmers , `` open string decoupling and tachyon condensation , '' jhep * 0106 * , 012 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0103056 ; m. marino , `` on the bv formulation of boundary superstring field theory , '' jhep * 0106 * , 059 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0103089 ; v. niarchos and n. prezas , `` boundary superstring field theory , '' nucl . phys . b * 619 * , 51 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0103102 ; k. s. viswanathan and y. yang , `` tachyon condensation and background independent superstring field theory , '' phys . d * 64 * , 106007 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0104099 ; m. alishahiha , `` one - loop correction of the tachyon action in boundary superstring field theory , '' phys . b * 510 * , 285 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0104164 . m. schnabl , `` wedge states in string field theory , '' jhep * 0301 * , 004 ( 2003 ) , hep - th/0201095 ; `` anomalous reparametrizations and butterfly states in string field theory , '' nucl . b * 649 * , 101 ( 2003 ) , ep - th/0202139 . j. kluson , `` marginal deformations in the open bosonic string field theory for n d0-branes , '' hep - th/0203089 ; `` exact solutions in open bosonic string field theory and marginal deformation in cft , '' hep - th/0209255 . j. a. shapiro and c. b. thorn , `` brst invariant transitions between open and closed strings , '' _ phys . _ * d36 * 432 ( 1987 ) ; `` closed string - open string transitions in witten s string field theory , '' phys . b * 194 * , 43 ( 1987 ) . p. de smet and j. raeymaekers , level four approximation to the tachyon potential in superstring jhep * 0005 * , 051 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0003220 ; a. iqbal and a. naqvi , `` tachyon condensation on a non - bps d - brane , '' , hep - th/0004015 ; Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: it is now widely believed that solar flares are powered by magnetic energy which had been stored in the corona through slow stressing applied from the photospheric boundary . in an idealized model the energy builds up as the coronal magnetic field responds without resistance ( every field line line tied and unbroken ) . the flare then occurs as coronal reconnection exchanges those field line footpoints to achieve a lower energy state . in this process , the footpoints are changed by the reconnection , but the vertical photospheric field in which the field lines are anchored is not . the potential field from this fixed photospheric field has the minimum magnetic energy possible . the maximum energy available for release is the amount by which the initial field exceeds this potential field energy , called the _ free energy_. quantitative simulation of the above scenario has proven to be extremely challenging owing to the vast range of scales involved . magnetic fields of even modest complexity develop , when stressed , current structures many orders of magnitude thinner than the global length scale @xcite . a numerical solution therefore requires additional magnetic diffusion to prevent the development of unresolvable current structures . the corresponding diffusive time is necessarily much shorter than actual diffusive times and generally shorter than the multi - day times governing the stressing phase . as a consequence , direct simulation , for example by time dependent mhd solution , includes artificial ( diffusive ) energy losses competing with the energy build - up . few such computations have been capable of demonstrating pre flare energies comparble to those released by the ensuing flare@xcite . an alternative means of estimating pre flare energy storage is offered by the minimum current corona model ( mcc : * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this is a quasi - static technique using equilibira , called flux constrained equilibria ( fce ) , minimizing magnetic energy subject to a set topological constraints composing a subset of all line - tying constraints . rather than constraining every pair of footpoints , the mcc groups footpoints into unipolar photopsheric regions and constrains the net coronal flux connecting each pair of regions , called _ domain fluxes_. since it uses only a subset of the actual constraints , its fields provide a lower bound on the actual free energy . as the photospheric regions move relative to one another the potential field above changes as do the fluxes by which it would link region pairs ( potential domain fluxes ) . since the actual field is constrained from changing these fluxes , it becomes increasingly different from the potential field and thus gains free energy . significantly , this energy is available for release by the violation of topological constraints , a process which can occur on very small spatial scales . the mcc has been used to estimate pre flare energy storage in a number of flares @xcite . a partitioning algorithm was developed to automatically group photospheric flux into distinct regions @xcite . provided it is permissible to neglect submergence or emergence of flux , the regions can be taken to move relative to one another but with constant flux . this simplified scenario was deemed adequate to model pre flare evolution in several cases @xcite , including the landmark halloween event @xcite . when footpoints within a given region move internally , such as during sunspot rotation , additional constraints must be introduced involving the arrangement of footpoints within regions @xcite . flux emergence is a well known precursor for flares and cmes @xcite and is thus likely to play a role in energy storage for many flares . it has not yet been accounted for in a complete mcc energy estimate owing cheifly to technical hurdles . doing so would require the constraints to be somehow modified to account for flux emergence . two prototypical cases were treated by ignoring all but one constraint to which emergence makes an obvious modification @xcite . a step toward a more general application was made by @xcite , who accounted for emergence and submergence in a computation of coronal reconnection times in the quiet sun . changes in the fluxes of photopsheric regions were used to generate a list of flux changes due to emerging and submerging domains . the algorithm used had several drawbacks , including a tendancy to assign both emerging and submerging domains to the same photopsheric region . the present work introduces a new algorithm by which emerging flux regions may be automatically accommodated in the mcc constraints leading to a pre flare energy estimate . flux changes in photospheric regions are used to generate a list of domain flux changes due to emergence and submergence , as in @xcite . in this case , however , a single region is linked to only emerging or submerging domains according to the sense of its own change . the possibility of artificial photospheric flux changes due to variations in sequential partitioning can be accomodated at the same time using a closely related algorithm . ( this step is independent of the partitioning algorithm . ) we also present a new algorithm for automatically associating domains with separators , a crucial step in the generation of an energy estimate . the new methodology is illustrated by applying it to a flare which occured on 16 oct . 2010 and was observed by instruments on the solar dynamics observatory ( sdo ) spacecraft . new flux emerges into an existing active ( noaa ar 11112 ) for two days prior to the flare ( goes class m3 ) . we derive photopsheric magnetic fluxes from a series of 123 line of sight magnetograms from the hmi instrument @xcite at cadences of @xmath2 minutes , as discussed in the next section . in section [ sec : photosphere ] , we detail our algorithms for partitioning the set of magnetograms into unipolar regions . the flux variations in these regions are used to define a set of emerging and submerging domains which are automatically generated by an algorithm explained in section [ sec : change ] . the emerging domains largely resemble those we would have expected based on inspection of the time series , but still contain some physically dubious assignments that must be fixed by hand . in the future , we would like to completely automate each of these algorithms . in section [ sec : erg ] , we use the magnetograms to derive a coronal topology for the post flare potential magnetic field and use this to place a bound on the free energy of the pre flare field . the post flare potential field includes a coronal null point whose fan surface encloses one of the newly emerged polarities . this is a novel feature in the mcc and requires the development of one additional method . we apply our energy estimate to noaa ar 11112 in section [ sec : ergapp ] , which reveals that most of the pre flare energy is due to currents passing through the coronal null point . though the methods presented here are of general utility , we apply them , for concreteness , to noaa active region 11112 . we base our calculations on magnetograms taken by the helioseismic and magnetic imager ( hmi ) on board the sdo spacecraft . figure [ fig : oldflux ] shows an example line of sight ( los ) magnetogram from oct . 13th , prior to flux emergence . lighter pixels show positive flux , dark pixels negative flux , and gray pixels zero flux ; the grayscale saturates at @xmath3 g . the active region originally contains only previously emerged flux as it crosses the eastern limb in the southern hemisphere on october 9th , 2010 . new flux begins emerging around 08:00 ut on the 14th , and is associated with a goes m2.9 flare several days later , at 19:07 ut on the oct . 16 . the region shows little activity in the 6 days before the flare . our dataset consists of 123 line of sight magnetograms , each consisting of @xmath4 pixels with 1.0 arcsecond resolution and approximately 0.5 arcsecond / pixel@xcite . they have a cadence of @xmath5 2 hours for the first 21 timesteps , from 2010 - 10 - 13 00:04 ut to 2010 - 10 - 14 18:20 ut , and @xmath5 half hour timesteps thereafter , from 2010 - 10 - 14 18:20 ut to 2010 - 10 - 16 23:37 ut . flux emergence begins around timestep 21 . as shown by the supplementary media , a movie of the los magnetograms , the photospheric changes are well characterized by these two cadences . our data window has flux imbalance @xmath6 over the three days leading up to the october @xmath7 flare . hmi los magnetogram of noaa ar 11112 prior to new flux emergence . the grayscale saturates at @xmath8 g , and the axes are in arcseconds from disk center . the boxed area encloses the region of flux emergence , which begins @xmath9 hours after this magnetogram . ] the old flux region has a polarity inversion line , running from southeast to northwest , which coincides with a filament as seen in data from the global high resolution h@xmath10 network , as well as sdo euv images at 94 , 131 , 171 , 193 , 211 , 304 , and 335 . this filament appears unaffected by the 19:07 ut flare . to the north of the filament , the diffuse , old flux , negative polarity field includes a curious ring of flux surrounding a strong core , boxed in figure [ fig : oldflux ] . the new flux of both polarities emerges completely within this ring , sweeping the old negative flux out of its way as it carves out a space for itself . this results in the ( zoomed in ) field shown in figure [ fig : newflux ] , roughly 10 minutes before the flare . a zoomed view of los magnetogram of the emerging flux region , boxed in figure [ fig : oldflux ] , on oct 16th , 2010 , 18:53ut , @xmath11 10 minutes prior to the m2.9 flare . the grayscale saturates at @xmath12 g , and axes are in arcseconds from disk center.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] as the new flux emerges it snow plows the old flux in front of it , the old flux concentrates and a strong horizontal gradient in the los field develops between old and new flux , as seen near s 400 , w 410 in figure [ fig : newflux ] . the flare is centered on this strong polarity inversion line . flare loops connect the newly emerged negative flux ( n55 , n58 , n87 ) within the ring to the diffuse , positive flux to the west ( p4 , p15 , p19 ) . we therefore believe that any analysis of this flare s energetics must explicitly account for flux emergence . our analysis naturally splits into two parts . the first parts works directly with the photospheric magnetic field measurements . we first partition the magnetic field at all times into unique , unipolar regions . second , we track these regions and enforce a consistent labeling scheme as they change geometry over time . geometric changes include changes in size , shape , orientation , and total flux ; merging and splitting of regions ; and the complete emergence or submergence of regions . the final step quantifies flux emergence and submergence between pairs of photospheric sources using a novel algorithm . in the second part of our analysis , we use our characterization of the photospheric field as a set of unique unipolar sources to describe the topology of the coronal field . each distinct photospheric region is replaced by a point source of the same flux located at the region s flux weighted centroid . we then find the flux within each potential field domain , and the null points and separators of the potential field . changes in the potential field s domain flux relative to the actual domain fluxes , assumed fixed , indicates the storage of magnetic energy in excess of the potential field . in an energy minimized field , the free energy stored by the field is manifest by current ribbons that develop along separator field lines . for brevity , we will use the phrase `` energy stored in the separator '' as a shorthand for `` free energy stored in the magnetic field which manifests itself as a a current ribbon at the location of a separator . '' the amount of current flowing along these ribbons places a bound on the free magnetic energy of the system . we begin work on the photospheric data by partitioning the magnetogram using the gradient based tessellation algorithm described by @xcite . the initial los magnetograms are converted to a vertical field by assuming a radial field at each pixel , which amounts to dividing by @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the polar angle from disc center . when determining the flux in each region , we must also account for foreshortening within each pixel , dividing by a second factor of @xmath13 . we then convolve all vertical field , @xmath15 , with the green s function for a potential extrapolation up to a height @xmath16 from an unbounded plane : @xmath17 to reduce the effects of noise , we neglect all the convolved field below a threshold of @xmath18 g . using the smoothed field , we assign a unique label to all local maxima and every pixel strictly downhill with respect to @xmath19 from each maxima . internal boundaries in unipolar regions are eliminated multiple regions are merged into a single region when the saddle point @xmath20 . @xmath21 is the greatest vertical field strength of the saddle s surrounding peaks , and @xmath22 is a threshold value . at the end of this process , each data pixel has an associated label . we call the set of all labels at a given time a mask , and the set of masks at all times a mask array . our goal in this section is to make the mask array consistent from timestep to timestep . in particular , we wish to determine how the newly emerged flux interacts with the old flux , and how that process affects the energetics of the active region . our primary concern is therefore to distinguish between new and old flux , which is a marked departure from previous , similar investigations@xcite . figure [ fig : newflux ] shows an example where the boundary of each unique mask region and its label ( p1 , n1 , p2 , ) have been plotted over the line of sight magnetogram data . all pixels and regions containing flux below our thresholds are given a label of 0 . this figure covers the ring feature of old flux concentrated in regions n1 , n6 , n38 , n49 , n55 , and n67and the newly emerged flux in regions p22 , p29 , p48 , n58 and n87 . the supplimentary material shows that these definitions are not necessarily strict . for instance , n58 , n67 , and n87 initially all break off of n49 . both n58 and n87 are quickly dominated by newly emerged flux , while n67 remains primarily distinct . we refer to `` new flux '' or `` old flux '' regions based on the dominant type of flux determined by inspection of the timeseries ( see supporting media ) . for the present analysis , we have set @xmath23 mm , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 . we also established a minimum flux of @xmath26mx @xmath27 gauss px@xmath28 , after accounting for pixel foreshortening ) for a solitary region . our field of view contains unsigned flux of order @xmath29mx above the 50 gauss threshold , so , a region must contain at least 0.2% of the total unsigned flux before inclusion in our algorithms . for a discussion of how the parameters @xmath16 , @xmath30 , and @xmath22 effect the final partitioning , see @xcite . after partitioning each magnetogram , we attempt to associate the partitions at one timestep to those in the next . to begin with , each region is characterized by its net signed flux and centroid location : @xmath31 for short , we call a region s total flux at the flux weighted centroid the region s associated _ pole_. as a first pass at creating consistently identified regions , we calculate the distance between each pair of centroids at two consecutive timesteps . if centroid a at time @xmath32 , @xmath33 , is closest to centroid b at time @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and b has a as its closest neighbor , and that distance is less than a threshold ( 10 mm ) , then we conclude that region b is region a. both this simple method of association , and exploration of the partitioning parameter space , result in mask arrays that are not to the quality required for mct analysis of an emerging flux region . we therefore developed two more sophisticated automatic procedures . and , described below , provide refinements to the minimum distance identifications . both were heuristically developed to address a prevalent type of inconsistent region labeling . the first algorithm deals with a region that exists for just a single timestep , but is clearly part of another region . the second deals with regions that change labels from one timestep to the next . these problems arise , for instance , when the choice of parameters poorly represents a subset of the timeseries , or when two regions merge or split , and their centroid locations between two timesteps are very different . for clarity , our examples in the following subsections do not directly use masks from our time series , and are only meant to illustrate the action of each algorithm . both algorithms operate directly on pixels in the mask structure , so that there are no physical scales involved . the algorithms only relabel nonzero elements of the mask , so that no external mask boundaries are modified . the first column demonstrates the problem of `` flickering . '' the middle timestep contains a new created region , @xmath36 , inside of the area controlled by region @xmath37 in the surrounding timesteps . @xmath36 only exists for that single timestep , its area reverting back to @xmath37 in the third timestep . the right column shows the effect of running on this region : in the middle timestep , @xmath37 has been completely restored in place of @xmath36.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] attempts to smooth the temporal structure of our mask arrays by better associating regions that last for just a single timestep . this happens when the saddle points in the tessellation algorithm slosh back and forth over the threshold value . figure [ fig : rmvf ] shows an example of this problem . region n2 pops into existence in the middle timestep , occupying some of the territory ascribed to region n1 in the first and third timestep . we see that this is not a `` real '' new region , but should instead be considered part of n1 for the entire time . figure [ fig : rmvf ] column two shows the result of running on this data . the algorithm works on a sliding , three timestep window ( initial , middle , and final timestep ) , and in two steps . in the first step , we find all regions @xmath38 that have nonzero flux only in the middle timestep , and find all mask pixels in the initial and final timestep which overlap @xmath38 . we take each overlapping region @xmath39 and relabel those pixels of @xmath38 which are overlapped by @xmath39 in the initial and final timesteps as @xmath39 . because our source regions change shape and size ( pixel count ) over time , we will usually have leftover pixels after performing the above bulk relabeling . while leftover pixels remain , we relabel the pixel of @xmath38 that currently borders the greatest number of pixels of a single neighbor to that neighbor s label . we have found that , when multiple regions overlap a flickering region , this method divides those pixels between the overlapping regions in decent proportion to their past and future `` control '' of flickering territory . the left column demonstrates the problem of `` vanishing , '' in which a single region n5 in the top left panel cycles through series of different labels . the right column shows the effect of running on this data . the @xmath40 and @xmath41 axes are in arcseconds from disk center , though the physical scale is irrelevant to the algorithm s operation.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] with we dealt with regions that existed for just a single timestep . we now deal with the conceptual inverse problem , where a region exists for some time and then suddenly changes names in the next timestep . figure [ fig : rmvv ] demonstrates the problem , as the region labeled n5 in the top left panel ( and previous , undepicted times ) cycles through a series of names and partitions within a few timesteps . we again begin by considering the mask array in a sliding , three timestep window . we find all non zero flux regions within the window and determine which regions exist in which timesteps . for every region that disappears in the middle timestep , we project its area from the first timestep into the middle and last timesteps . we then find all new regions , in both the middle and final times , that overlap with that projected area . finally , we relabel any new region whose centroid lays within this projected area . figure [ fig : rmvv ] , right column shows the effect of running on data . and each use a sliding , three timestep window , so that it takes many repetitions of each for updated information propagate from the beginning to the end of the mask array . we must therefore repeat each of the algorithms many times . at the same time , acts upon labels that last for just a single timestep ; eventually , all such problems will be fixed . taking these processes into account , we find that the mask arrays best approximate the photospheric field evolution when we switch back and forth between the two algorithms at the beginning of the process , and run just many times at the end of the process . for our noaa ar 11112 data , we ran a total of 35 repetitions , and a total of 1058 repetitions . together , these two algorithms accomplish about nine tenths of the work in creating a consistent set of tessellated masks . part of the remaining tenth may be accounted for by a boundary shift algorithm , described below , between abutting regions of the same polarity . even this does not accurately represent to data , and the final changes to the mask array required for a consistent time series must be done by hand . these changes again mostly involve the placement of the boundary between abutting regions of the same polarity , caused by a failure to distinguish between old flux and actively emerging flux . these boundaries are adjusted manually until each region s flux evolves smoothly . figure [ fig : fluxplot ] top shows the vertical flux in each ( high flux ) region . this includes editing of the masks by both the automatic algorithms and by hand . note that , even after a set of consistent masks have been created , the flux within each region is still rather noisy . to counteract this , we smooth our data with a 7 hour ( 13 timestep ) boxcar function . the result is shown in figure [ fig : fluxplot ] bottom . ( a ) flux in regions with more than @xmath42mx . large , opposing spikes between pairs of curves , for instance between p15 and p19 , show boundary shifts between adjacent regions . ( b ) result of smoothing the data by convolution with a 7 hour boxcar function.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] at this point , we transition from a mostly qualitative treatment of the photospheric field s geometry to a quantitative , topological analysis of a model coronal field : the minimum current corona ( mcc ) model developed in @xcite . we begin by replacing every region in the photospheric field with a magnetic pole defined by the region s total flux and centroid location , as in . with one exception , the rest of this work deals only with the poles and connections between them . the total flux in each pole must be connected to some number of other poles of opposite polarity . this defines the system s connectivity : the undirected , weighted graph , where each vertex of the graph is a pole , and the weight of each edge defines the connectivity between the two vertices . it happens that the graph of noaa ar 11112 is _ simple _ on the eve of the m3 flare , so that each pair of vertices has no more than one associated edge . we refer to edges of the graph as domains . we may additionally define a connectivity graph for the flux _ change _ between two timesteps : if a pole s flux increases , that increase must be distributed among its domains with opposite polarity poles . this is the topological entity we now quantify . the flux in a single photospheric region , and hence that region s associated pole , may vary in two ways . the change is either a true evolution of the field by submergence or emergence through the photosphere , or it is a transfer of flux to / from another like signed region via a shift in the boundary between the regions . that this latter type still exists in our `` consistent '' data can be seen in regions p4 , p15 , and p19 in the smoothed data of figure [ fig : fluxplot ] . these three regions compose the large , diffuse positive region to solar west , as seen in figure [ fig : oldflux ] . if we focus on each of these regions individually , the red , green , and purple lines in figure [ fig : bndry ] , we see several rapid changes in the flux of each . however , if we look at the total flux in these three regions the black line in figure [ fig : bndry]it steadily decreases : the rapid increases and decreases in figure [ fig : fluxplot]b are almost solely due to shifting boundaries between the three . further , the steady decrease shown in the black line is matched by decreases in the old flux part of the flux ring , regions n1 , n6 , n38 , n49 , n55 , and n67 in figure [ fig : newflux ] : the old positive flux is `` submerging '' with the old negative flux . the blue line is a demonstration of the effectiveness of the forthcoming algorithms , and we will revisit it shortly . the submergence of regions p4 , p15 , and p19 ( red , green , purple ) , shown in the total flux of the regions ( black ) . blue shows the calculated submergence by removing flux change due to boundary shifts from the total flux change . ] in order to isolate the different varieties of flux change , we have developed an algorithm which estimates the change in each region s flux due only to boundary displacements between adjacent , like signed regions . these changes necessarily come in pairs : what one region loses in a boundary shift , another gains . our algorithm works as follows . consider a set of like signed poles @xmath43 , and split @xmath43 into submerging and emerging sets , @xmath44 and @xmath45 respectively . each pole has an associated flux change , @xmath46 , with @xmath47 the flux at time @xmath32 given by . we iteratively find the pole with smallest unsigned flux change , @xmath48 , and the pole with closest centroid @xmath49 and opposite sense flux change , @xmath50 . the flux change between these two poles is canceled , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and the cancellation is recorded in a change in connectivity matrix : @xmath53 . this process is repeated until no more connections can be made . @xmath54 is antisymmetric , and the @xmath55@xmath56 element is the flux change of the edge joining @xmath57 and @xmath58 . each row @xmath57 describes the flux change for a given pole , and each column @xmath58 in a row records how much of pole @xmath57 s total flux change is in partnership with @xmath58 . if all of pole @xmath57 s flux change is due to boundary shifts , then @xmath57 s total flux change is given by summation along the @xmath57@xmath56 row of @xmath54 : @xmath59 in this way , we have paired as much shrinking flux with like signed increasing flux as possible , but have only used the total flux and centroid location of each region . we now refer back to the photospheric mask for the last time . for each region in the mask array we find every like signed region with which it shares a border : call this subset of poles @xmath60 . to allow for regions separated by a few pixels to share a boundary and supporting media : at various timesteps , n38 and n49 are separated by several pixels of low field , yet there is a clear transfer of flux across their shared boundary . ] , we pad each region by 5 pixels and look for overlap with other regions . the value of @xmath54 for each pair of such regions is then the amount of flux they exchanged through a shift in the mask boundary . we have chosen to distribute the flux change and then restict to the subset @xmath60 , rather than the reverse , in order to avoid the ill defined problem of assigning shifts when one region shares boundaries with multiple other regions , which in turn share boundaries with multiple other regions , and so on . we see this , for instance , in the triple boundary between regions p4 , p15 , and p19 . qualitatively , any discrepancy is small given that we connect regions in a nearest to farthest order , and nearby regions tend to share boundaries . the sum of all such changes for a given pole gives that pole s total flux change due to boundary shifts . all other change must be ascribed to submergence or emergence through the photosphere . we may describe this mathematically as @xmath61 the middle term on the rhs is the pole s boundary change , determined in this section ; the final term quantifies the pole s flux change due to submergence and emergence through the photosphere , which we now quantify . our algorithm for determining the flux change due to submergence and emergence rests on two assumptions . first , pairs of poles submerge and emerge together , and second , a single region can either consist of submerging or emerging flux , but not both . these assumptions naturally break our connectivity change graph into two disconnected subgraphs : one consisting of submerging vertices , the other emerging . each subgraph is composed of both positive and negative polarity poles , as flux connects only regions of opposite polarity . in determining the flux change in each domain , we use the same algorithm as for boundary shifts , only with the roles of polarity and sense of change reversed : these domains connect opposite polarity poles with same sense flux change , and represent pairs of poles submerging or emerging together . the graph generated in this manner reflects our physical intuition about how these systems should interact . namely , we expect poles to be more connected to those poles closest to them , rather than those further away . we also expect that poles with little flux change should not have that small change spread between a large number of partners . example map of sub / emerging flux , as generated by the algorithm of [ sec : qsef ] . black lines show submerging regions , white lines emerging . labels mark the centroid locations of the high flux regions of figure [ fig : fluxplot ] , which also contribute to the topological analysis of [ sec : ergapp ] . ] we begin by finding the flux difference for each pole between times @xmath32 and @xmath34 , from which we subtract the change due to boundary shifts , found previously . the remainder is each pole s flux change budget , which must be paired with other poles . to accomplish this , we again iteratively find the least changing pole and cancel its flux change with its closest appropriately signed and sensed neighbor . this cancellation is the weight of each edge and is recorded in the source change matrix , @xmath62 . just like the boundary shift matrix , @xmath62 is defined such that , if all of a pole @xmath63 s flux change between times @xmath32 and @xmath34 is due to real photospheric changes , then @xmath64 ; that is , summation over all columns of a given row returns the total flux change for that row s pole . while the combination of our algorithms dealing with boundary shifts and emergence do quite well in most circumstances , occasionally they produce unphysical connections . consider the timestep shown in figure [ fig : smat ] . here , the emerging positive regions ( p22 , p29 , p48 ) each have some flux change , and our knowledge of the location of emergence says that this change is most likely a combination of boundary shifts and emergence for p48 and p29 , as both n87 and n58 are also actively emerging , and primarily boundary shifts for p22 . however , if the boundary shift between p22 and p29 is larger than the emergence of p48 , then our boundary algorithm ascribes the boundary shift to p29p48 , leaving the emergence mostly between p22 and n87 , which is clearly unphysical . for this reason , we allow for `` preferred connections '' , which accounts for emergence between a subset of poles first , and then proceeds to calculate boundary shifts and submergence and emergence for all poles . for this region , we first pair emergence between regions p22 , n55 , n58 , and n87 for the first 3 days ( 77 timesteps ) , and then between regions p48 , n55 , n58 , and n87 during the remaining time . as with the generation of consistent mask structures in the previous section , we ultimately wish to automate this entire process . however , until we develop algorithms that accurately capture the physical evolution of emerging regions , we will rely on a combination of automatic proceedures and ad hoc prescriptions to most accurately model these systems . figure [ fig : smat ] shows a graphical representation of the changing domain fluxes due to submergence and emergence between 12:04 and 12:35 ut on oct 16th , 7 hours before the flare . black lines show submerging domains , white lines emerging . table [ tab : smat ] shows the flux change in each domain . regions p4 , p15 , p22 , p29 , and n55 have flux change ( for these timesteps ) due solely to boundary displacements with neighboring regions . as discussed above , we begin pairing p48 , which increased by @xmath65mx . the closest ( and only ) negative pole with the correct sense of flux change is n87 , which increased by @xmath66mx . these two poles are paired , the domain flux change is set to @xmath66mx , and p48 s flux budget is reduced to @xmath67mx . there are no more available connections between our preferred poles , so we next account for boundary shifts . after doing so , the least changing region is n38 , which loses @xmath68mx . the closest positive pole with the correct sense of flux change is p19 , which lost @xmath69mx . these two poles are paired , the domain flux change is set to @xmath68mx , and p19 s flux budget is reduced to @xmath70mx . we again select the least changing region ( n49 ) , and the process continues until no more pairings can be made . the final results for this timestep are shown in table [ tab : smat ] . lcr domain & sense & @xmath71mx ) + p19n1 & submerge & 245.764 + p19n38 & submerge & 30.6279 + p19n49 & submerge & 145.569 + p19n58 & submerge & 257.030 + p48n87 & emerge & 849.874 + the pairings represent a compromise between reasonable inference and mathematical necessity . due to their proximity , and common increase , it is reasonable to assume p48n87 are feet of the same emerging flux tubes . p19 , on the other hand , is relatively isolated but has steadily decreasing flux . it is necessary to pair it with decreasing negative poles , which turn out to be arranged along the periphery of the old polarity . being separated by @xmath72 , these regions can not be `` submerging '' in any real sense . however , we believe this decrease represents steady cancellation with the small scale field surrounding these old flux regions . this process should be studied in detail in another investigation , but for the moment we note that it is well represented by a reduction in , for instance , the p19n49 domain flux . we repeat this process for each pair of consecutive timesteps . figure [ fig : p29dom ] provides a representative example , showing the cumulative domain flux changes ( designated by the symbol @xmath73 ) due to the emergence , and slight amount of submergence near the end of our analysis , of p29 , one element of the newly emerging flux . we see here that it emerges primarily with region n58 , part of the newly emerging flux . cumulative changes in each of p29 s domain fluxes , as calculated with the algorithm of [ sec : qsef ] . we find that p29 primarily emerges with n58 and n38 . ] the effectiveness of the combined algorithms can be appreciated in figure [ fig : bndry ] , showing the three componenets of the diffuse western region . the blue line illustrates the effectiveness of our algorithms at capturing the system s behavior due to submergence and emergence . as the field shears , the boundaries between the three subregions have a tendency to discontinuously jump , resulting in large variations in the flux in each region , accounted for by the boundary algorithm . however , the combined flux of the three subregions , shown in black , instead displays a fairly steady decrease : this whole region is submerging . the blue line shows our reconstruction of this submergence using the source change matrix at each time . each pole has an initial flux value , to which we add the elements of @xmath62 , so that each pole s flux at time @xmath32 is given by @xmath74 . this measure completely discounts the ( artificial ) boundary shifts between photospherically adjacent regions . we then sum the flux in each pole thus reconstructed , and this is our estimate for the submergence of diffuse western region . we note that the blue and black lines follow each other reasonably well , indicating that our algorithms accurately capture the submerging trend of this region . in the second section of our analysis , we employ the minimum current corona ( mcc ) model @xcite to use the amount of flux change in each domain to calculate the amount of free magnetic energy stored in our system as it evolves away from a potential configuration . to that end , we must define a set of topological elements . these definitions , briefly summarized below , are described more fully in @xcite and references therein . the general idea is to model distributed photospheric sources as point sources . the potential field generated by these sources will have null points , @xmath75 , where the magnetic vector field vanishes : @xmath76 . we may perform a linear expansion of the field about these points @xcite @xmath77 where the jacobian matrix @xmath78 is both symmetric and traceless because @xmath79 . as such , @xmath80 has three orthogonal eigenvectors with three real eigenvalues : the eigenvectors of the two like signed eigenvalues define a plane ( the fan ) ; the eigenvector of the opposite signed eigenvalue defines a line orthogonal to this plane ( the spine ) . from this foundation the rest of the topological description follows . we define a _ pole _ , the photospheric point source , located at the flux weighted centroid of a mask . _ nulls _ are the zeros of the potential magnetic field , and _ spines _ , the fieldlines connecting a pole to a null along the single eigenvector . a _ fan _ ( synonym _ separatrix _ ) is the set of fieldlines ending in a null s like signed eigenvector plane . domain _ is a simply connected space filled with field lines connecting a given pair of poles . finally , a _ separator _ is the field line connecting two nulls , formed at the intersection of their respective fan surfaces . in a nonpotential field , the separator may broaden into a two dimensional ribbon . coronal current sheets form along the separators of the field . we determine the locations of all nulls in two steps . first , we find those laying in the photospheric plane via the newton raphson method of @xcite . second , we check the euler characteristics given in @xcite , which provide both 2d and 3d relations between the number of nulls of each type and the number of sources of each polarity . when the 3d characteristic is not satisfied , at least one coronal null is missing . when then supply a `` by eye '' list of initial @xmath81 guesses to the same newton raphson root finding method until coronal nulls have been found and the euler characteristics are satisfied . other more automated coronal null detection methods have been developed @xcite , but the ad hoc method described here has worked well in this case . after determining the location of all nulls , we located separators via the method of @xcite , with one modification . those authors only treat photospheric nulls , whose separators lay within separatrices above the photosphere . for coronal nulls , we search for separators in all @xmath82 directions within the null s fan surface . our model photosphere consists of a plane @xmath83 of isolated sources surround by regions where the normal component of the magnetic field is zero . this boundary condition may be satisfied using the method of images , as in @xcite6 . with the normal field reflectionally symmetric in @xmath84 , we have that @xmath85 . whenever we introduce current in the corona along a separator , we must introduce its reflection in the mirror corona to maintain this symmetry . in this way , our separators form closed current loops . topology of noaa ar 11112 on the eve of the flare , depicted in a local tangent plane with coordinates . the point of tangency is taken as the center of charge in the initial magnetogram , translated through solar rotation to the present time , and the axes are in mm . pluses and crosses are positive and negative poles , respectively ; triangles are positive ( @xmath86 ) and negative ( @xmath87 ) nulls ; solid black lines depict spines , dashed lines the trace of fans within the photosphere , and the dotted line is a coronal spine , attached to the coronal null b15 . blue and red lines are projections of separators into the photosphere , with red lines those separators connected to the coronal null.,scaledwidth=75.0% ] once we have created the set of matrices describing domain flux changes due to submergence or emergence , we can create similar matrices describing the flux change due to a changing potential field . we calculate the potential field connectivity at each timestep via the monte carlo method of @xcite . this produces a set of connectivity matrices @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the flux connecting sources @xmath57 and @xmath58 at time @xmath32 . from these matrices we calculate the change in connectivity due to the changing potential field : @xmath90 summation along rows of the connectivity matrix returns the total flux of the corresponding pole ; eg . we define @xmath92 to be antisymmetric , as with the matrices @xmath62 and @xmath54 before . the mcc model derives an energy from the discrepency between the actual domain fluxes @xmath93 at time @xmath94 and the potential fluxes then , @xmath95 . in the absence of flux emergence or submergence , the actual fluxes are fixed using the potential field domain fluxes at some initial time : @xmath96 , as in @xcite . any flux emergence or submergence through the photosphere , quantified as @xmath62 in the previous section , modifies these actual domain fluxes , so that @xmath97 because we assume a field , initially potential , whose fluxes are fixed under future evolution , we determine how far removed the field is from a potential field configuration by answering the question , `` what flux must be added to a potential field domain @xmath98 at time @xmath99 to get a potential field domain at time @xmath32 ? '' this question is answered by @xmath100 on the right hand side , the first term is the potential field at the initial time . the second is the total flux change through the photosphere . the final term is flux change due to coronal redistribution , which must be achieved by modifying the connectivity matrix . together , the first two terms give the actual domain flux @xmath101 at time @xmath32 . all flux changes from coronal reshuffling are then given by @xmath102 equation holds for all domains , of course , and we represent this as a matrix equation by dropping the domain subscript @xmath98 . @xmath92 is antisymmetric , and we have defined @xmath62 to be antisymmetric , so @xmath103 is also antisymmetric . while antisymmetry of these matrices carries no physical information , we will later show that it does endow @xmath103 with a nice mathematical property . note that the difference in between the actual domain fluxes and the potential field fluxes depends on the choice of the inital time @xmath104 . when dealing with actual data , we must pick an initial time to apply the mcc flux constraint when we believe the field is in a potential configuration in order to find a meaningful difference relative to a later potential configuration . ideally , we would track a single region from its inception up to an event which redistributes the coronal flux , as in a flare . while noaa ar 11112 does not fit this criteria , it likely matters little in this case . as is apparent from our supporting media , and also as we will show below , noaa ar 11112 has a very stable flux configuration for @xmath105hours prior to flux emergence . this newly emerged flux , fixed in set domains as the photospheric field continues to evolve , rapidly diverges from a potential field configuration at later times . so far this discussion only involves the sources themselves and their interconnections . let us now introduce a set of separators @xmath106 . separators are field lines that run from a null point of one type to a null of the opposite type . in the mcc model , they are the sites of current sheets within the corona@xcite . because current may only flow in loops , the separators themselves must close along some path in the mirror corona . we can then speak of separator fluxes : the flux of domains linked by some separator @xmath107 with its closure . we will discuss closures and explain the concept of linking in detail below , but the general idea is that field lines in a linked domain can not reconnect to another domain except by passing through the separator . let @xmath108 be the flux linked by @xmath107 at time @xmath32 in the actual field , and @xmath109 be flux in the potential field domains @xmath110 linked by @xmath107 . for a given closure , a separator always links the same set of domains throughout time . the fluxes in those domains will generally change over time , however . when a domain s flux goes to zero , the domain no longer exists . the flux constrained equilibrium ( fce ) assumption of the mcc model states that domain fluxes are fixed as the field evolves . minimization of the field s energy subject to these constraints shows that the coronal field will be current free except along the separator , where a current ribbon forms @xcite . this occurs whenever @xmath111 . we therefore define @xmath112 the double sum over elements of the redistribution matrix @xmath113 is the difference between the flux linked by the separator in the actual and potential fields at time @xmath32 . it is also the self flux generated by current flowing along the separator , and therefore , the flux that must be added to the real field to relax the fce constraint of mcc : @xmath114 . our method for calculating energies therefore rests on two assumptions . the first is that at some initial time @xmath115 we assume that the domain fluxes are given by the potential field s domain fluxes , @xmath116 , so that all the separator fluxes @xmath117 . the second assumption is that the evolution of the current ribbon s self flux depends on the evolution of the both the actual and potential field configurations : @xmath118 summed over time , this is just the restatement of itself , namely that the current ribbon s flux at some time @xmath32 is the sum of all changes in each linked domain s flux over the life of the separator . when @xmath119 is small we can estimate the properties of the current ribbon , as in @xcite . for a separator of length @xmath120 carrying current @xmath121 , they determine the self flux to be @xmath122 where @xmath123 is a measure of magnetic shear in the separator s vicinity . from this the excess energy of the mcc field relative to the potential field , i.e. the free energy , is@xcite @xmath124 note that and only take into account energy due to the self inductance of each current loop . in general , we must include the effect of mutual inductance , though for physically separated loops we expect self inductance to dominate the total energy . the fce assumption requires that @xmath125 , which allows us to solve for the current in the current ribbon as a function of @xmath126 : @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the inverse of the function @xmath129 . equation provides a method for determining the current residing in , and hence the energy stored by , each separator : it tells us the current required to change the domain flux enclosed by a separator from that of a potential field to some other value . in the present case that value is given by the non zero elements of @xmath103 . a reverse , cumulative sum over the time index @xmath32 for a given flux domain @xmath63@xmath130 gives the time history of departure from a potential field configuration . as is implicit in , each separator may link more than one domain : the appropriate @xmath119 for a separator is the sum of all changes in domain fluxes for each domain linked by that separator . since all field lines in a given domain are topologically equivalent , we may establish separator linkage using a single representative fieldline and the separator itself . after each of these open curves is closed , their linkage is found using the gauss linking number@xcite , @xmath131 , for each field line separator pair : @xmath132 the linking number not only determines whether a separator links a field line ( @xmath133 ) , but also the sense in which it does so ( @xmath134 an integer ) : to calculate the correct @xmath135 , you must sum over all linked domains , multiplied by their respective linking numbers . in order to use gauss linking formula , we must have two closed curves , whereas our curves ( usually ) begin and end at two separate sources ( nulls for separators ) in the photosphere , never penetrating beneath . so , in order to apply the linking formula in this case we must add to each coronal curve some curve in the mirror corona to form a complete loop . there are , in general , many ways to form the closure for each curve , and not all of them will lead to the same linking number . one requirement is that the separator be closed _ above _ the field line s closure : any closure below the field line will always give a linking number of zero . therefore , we have chosen to close the separator with a straight line between the footpoints in the photosphere , and the field lines with a rectangular path formed by following the footpoints down and connecting them with a straight line in the @xmath136 mm plane . another method would be to close the separator , say , with its projection into the @xmath137 ( photospheric ) plane . either method is valid , so long as the same method is used for all field lines and separators . another requirement for using the linking number to find linked domains is that we follow field lines and separators in a consistent direction . in general , changing the direction of _ one _ of the integrals takes @xmath138 . for definiteness , we always trace separators from negative ( a type ) nulls to positive ( b type ) nulls above the photosphere , and thus close separators from b@xmath139a in the photosphere . because the reconnection matrix @xmath103 is antisymmetric , this same care is unnecessary when tracing the field lines , at least for the purpose of the @xmath135 calculation . let us designate by @xmath140 the difference in flux change for the real versus potential field between times @xmath32 and @xmath34 ( as in ) , when we trace a field line from p1 to n2 in the corona , and close the field line from n2@xmath139p1 below the photosphere . then , @xmath141 we have therefore been justified in simply writing @xmath142 , with no designation of tracing a field line from positive to negative or negative to positive in the corona , because @xmath142 is just a summation of multiple such domains . this holds provided we always trace the separator in the same direction . once determined , the linking number for each separator / field line pair provides the correct method for calculating each separator s total @xmath135 , including all linked domains , and hence the energy stored by each separator . we must account for instances where two photospheric regions merge together or split apart , as illustrated in figure [ fig : constrict ] . therein , we focus on 4 poles@xmath143with four flux domains@xmath144and two separators , @xmath145 and @xmath146 , which link the domains in some fashion . suppose two of the poles are each connected to the same null via its spines . if the flux of one pole is zero before(after ) a split(merger ) , then the null between them does not exist at that time , and the flux in the domains linking the sources goes to zero . now , if either @xmath145 or @xmath146 is attached to that null , then the separator will arise or cease to exist with that null , and the flux linked by it is appropriate . then again , if these separators are attached to some other set of nulls and happen to link these flux domains , our calculated linked flux is still appropriate . say flux domain @xmath147 , for instance , either folds into or breaks out from domain @xmath148 . the actual break or merger constitutes a boundary shift ( with @xmath149 having zero flux either before or after the event ) and so does not contribute to the flux linked by either separator . any additional flux change on top of this is either appropriately picked up by @xmath145 or @xmath146 , but not both . topological depiction of two poles either splitting or merging : @xmath150 . dots depict the sources , lines the domains , and red arcs the separators . ] a second complication arises when we encounter a coronal null , as we see in the topology of noaa ar 11112 in figure [ fig : topo ] near local tangent plane coordinates ( 20,30)mm . if a coronal null has any separators connected to it then it must have at least two : one carrying current up , the other down . if many separators connect to the coronal null , then some must carry current up , and others down , but all balanced according to kirchhoff s rules . in order to calculate the flux within a separator induced domain , we must close the separator somehow . above , we addressed this by prescribing a photospheric closure for separators . now , however , we must first stitch pairs of separators together in order to get back to the photosphere . if we have @xmath151 separators connected to the coronal null , we require @xmath152 separator pairs , or `` isolating loops '' in the terminology of @xcite . we might assume that the currents flowing along the @xmath152 loops would distribute to minimize the energy due to self and mutual inductances . this problem remains to be solved , and for the moment we simply designate one separator linked to a coronal null as the `` shared '' separator . we have found that the energies we calculate do not depend heavily on the choice of common leg , laying within @xmath153 of each other . as shown in figure [ fig : topo ] , we have a single coronal null , b15 , with spine lines leading to @xmath154 and @xmath155 . four separators ( in red ) connect to the coronal null : from null a09 between @xmath156 and @xmath157 , a05 between @xmath157 and @xmath158 , a08 between @xmath158 and @xmath159 , and a07 between @xmath159 and @xmath37 . again , because all current flowing from the photospheric nulls up to the coronal null must be balanced by current flowing back down to the photosphere , we mush combine these four separators into three , all of which share one leg ; it does not matter which one . we have chosen a05b15 leg to be common to all three separators . as we will see below , the a05b15a08 separator generates the greatest amount of energy in this system . this is expected , given the high horizontal shear in the photospheric field between @xmath154 and @xmath158 , and the greatly flux deficient domain between these two poles , relative to the potential field configuration at the time of the flare . we may summarize the previous several sections in the following way . in order to perform an energy calculation , we need a set of poles @xmath160 at a given time final time @xmath161 ; a set of nulls at the same time @xmath162 ; a set of separators at the same time @xmath163 ; a time history of the reconnective changes in domain fluxes from the final time , backwards to a previous time @xmath94 where we may assume the field was potential , @xmath164 ; and a set of domains @xmath165 linked by each separator . having all these pieces , we then calculate the total domain flux difference in each domain at time @xmath161 relative to the initial presumed potential field . for each separator , we find all domains linked by that separator . next , each linked separator s time history of reconnective flux changes is summed . this total flux change for each linked domain is then multiplied by the gauss linking number for that domain / separator pair . finally , the total domain changes are summed for each linked domain to fix the total flux difference of the separator at the final time @xmath161 , relative to the potential field at the initial time @xmath94 . mathematically , this is given by , reproduced here : @xmath166 this flux is generated by the current along the separator , , which may be found by the inversion , and plugged into the energy equation to find the energy in excess of the potential field energy at time @xmath161 in the minimum current corona model with the fce constraint applied at time @xmath94 . this energy is a lower bound for any coronal energy model . by time of the flare ( figure [ fig : newflux ] ) the new flux in noaa ar 11112 has bubbled up and expanded within the interior of the old flux ring . the effect is especially pronounced between regions p22 and n49 , the boundary of which has a very strong horizontal gradient in the vertical field . because this gradient is between old and new flux , prior to reconnection during the flare there is little flux in the domain connecting these two regions , and certainly far less than there would be in the potential configuration at that time . we expect one action of the flare will be to increase the flux within the p22n49 domain . because its flux is conserved , any flux p22 adds to its n49 domain must come at the expense of its other domains . the poles with which p22 shares these other domains primarily n58 , n55 , and n87 with which p22 emerged must in turn shuffle their flux into different domains . in this way , a flare originating in one place propagates its effects throughout the entire magnetic structure until it establishes a new , lower energy equilibrium . cumulative domain flux changes for various p22 domains , relative to the potential field at t=0 . arrows indicate the onset of flux emergence and the ut 19:07 m2.9 flare . there is some `` pre emergence '' flux due to our 13 timestep smoothing function . ] we can get a picture of this process by looking at the cumulative domain flux changes for various p22 domains , shown in figure [ fig : p22rmat ] . here , the flux at each timestep is given by the cumulative sum of all flux changes up to that time , @xmath167 . this figure shows by how much flux a domain must be changed to match the potential field configuration of the initial field , plus the contribution due to emergence . p22 emerges in conjuction with n55 , n58 , and n87 , thus all flux is assigned to domains p22n55 , p22-n58 , and p22-n87 . the potential field , however , assigns less flux to these domains and more ( i.e. some ) to domains such as p22n1 and p22n49 . these latter domains are flux deficient relative to the potential field , and appear above the zero line in figure [ fig : p22rmat ] . the former are flux excessive , as a result of emergence , and appear below . note that the potential field distributes the flux among domains differently at different times , and our analysis captures these changes . in particular , p22 emerges to the east of n1 , then migrates westward . as p22 moves past n1 , the p22n1 domain first becomes deficient , then more sufficient as the p22n38 and p22n67 domains become increasingly deficient . the total flux in p22 only slowly increases throughout much this time ( it is mostly emerged by 50hrs , as shown in figure [ fig : fluxplot ] ) , so these later changes in the potential configuration are largely due to shear motion in the photosphere , rather than the initial emergence . aia 171 images during the flare reveal how reconnection works to restore a flux balance closer to potential . at successive times , we see brightenings of small loops progressing west to east within the newly emerged regions . after this we see a series of loop brightenings connecting the new negative regions within the ring to the old diffuse positive region to the west . we believe that this series of loop brightenings is a direct result of domain restructuring due to the emergence of the new flux and its highly nonpotential original field configuration . two cumulative time sums over @xmath168 . the solid line sums from the initial time , 0 , to time @xmath32 and is the flux required to change the domain at time @xmath32 to an assumed potential field at the initial time . the dotted line sums from time @xmath32 to the final time , @xmath169 , and is the flux required to change the final potential field configuration to a flux configuration fixed at time @xmath32 . the difference between the initial and final values is the same for both sums , and they are mirrors of each other about the average of this difference . ] the fluxes shown in figure [ fig : p22rmat ] provide a good description for understanding the evolution of each domain , and directly follow the calculation outlined in [ sec : seps ] . in this paper , however , we are interested in calculating the free energy due to a difference between domain fluxes fixed at some initial time and potential fluxes at the time of the flare . for a completely new active region , we would assume all domain fluxes are zero except those which emerge together ; in this case , our emergence occurs in a region of substantial old flux . as such , our final time is fixed by the flare , and we must choose an appropriate time of initial constraint . combining equations and , we find that @xmath170 , so that@xmath171 is the flux that must be added to domain @xmath98 to account for change in addition to submergence and emergence , which is accounted for within @xmath172 . figure [ fig : p22rmat ] shows the cumulative flux @xmath173 . wishing to vary the time of constraint , we calculate the reverse of this : @xmath174 . this is the amount of flux that must be added to the domain constrained at time @xmath32 , @xmath175 , to match the potential field domain at time @xmath176 . as we will show below , this summation is basically constant prior to emergence : the old flux region is initially stable , and flux emergence drives a departure from this stable configuration . figure [ fig : twosums ] gives an example of both the forward and reverse summations for domain p22n49 . we set the fluxes for the energy calculation in this way because the assumption of the mcc model is that , barring reconnection , the domain fluxes are fixed , and prior to the flare there is no reconnection . in order to compare with a potential field at the time of a flare , we determine our topology immediately before the flare . this fixes all of the poles , nulls , and separators , and the domains linked by each separator . the energy calculation then answers the question , `` _ _ supposing the domain fluxes are fixed at time @xmath32 , by how much must they be changed to match the potential field at the final time ? _ _ '' this difference for each domain linked by a separator then determines the amount of current along that separator , and hence the amount of energy stored by that separator . a reverse cumulative sum of the total domain fluxes linked by each separator relative to the potential field configuration just prior to the flare , identified by nulls to which they attach . separators with three listed nulls are those which pass through the coronal null , b15 . ] as mentioned previously , a single separator will generally link multiple domains . for instance , one of the separators passing through the coronal null b15 in figure [ fig : topo ] , connecting nulls a05b15a07 , links three domains , n58p22 , n67p22 , and n38p29 , with gauss linking numbers -1 , -1 , and + 1 , respectively . the residual fluxes for two of these domains , n58p22 and n67p22 , are shown in green and purple in figure [ fig : p22rmat ] ; the n38p29 domain residual fluxes is similar , peaking at @xmath177mx around 90 hours . this separator @xmath107 s flux , including all three domains @xmath178 with linking numbers @xmath179 , is then given at each time @xmath32 by @xmath180 the sum for this separator is plotted in red in figure [ fig : sepflux ] . the curve shows that , as we look further back in time , the flux linked by this domain increasingly departs from the final potential field configuration , until around @xmath181 hours when all changes level off . this is when region p22 first emerges . note that every separator shows relatively little change in the linked flux before this time . based on figure [ fig : sepflux ] , we might expect the a11/b03 separator to store the most energy , as it has the most linked flux . however , the amount of current flowing in this separator is 12 orders of magnitude less than in the three separators connected to the coronal null : the longer a separator , the less current necessary to generate the required self flux . figure [ fig : energy ] plots the magnetic free energy when applying the fce assumption at varying timesteps . we see that the energy of the three separators connected to the coronal null , shown in magenta , red , and dark green , completely dominate the magnetic free energy buildup . the blue line shows the total for all separators . we also see that , constraining the domain fluxes at any time before the onset of flux emergence , @xmath182 hours , effects little change in the total energy buildup . essentially all of the flux difference relative to the final potential field configuration is due to the emergence itself . the mcc yields a lower bound on the magnetic free energy of a system . after accounting for all flux linked by all separators , and hence the energy stored in each separator , we conclude that noaa ar 11112 stores a minimum of @xmath183 ergs of free magnetic energy over the 23 days leading up to the october 16@xmath56 , 2010 goes m2.9 flare . free magnetic energy relative to a potential field at the final time , and applying the fce assumption at successively earlier timesteps for each separator , and for the total ( blue ) . our energy estimate is then the value of the initial timestep , @xmath184ergs . arrows indicates the onset of emergence and the time of the m2.9 flare . note that there is some `` pre emergence '' due to our boxcar smoothing function . ] in this work we have extended the application of the minimum current corona model to the estimation of energy stored along separators in the coronal field in active regions where flux submergence and emergence plays a significant role in the photospheric field s evolution . this estimation operates in two distinct parts . in the first , we track the evolution of the photospheric line of sight magnetic field using sdo / hmi magnetograms . we found that the higher cadence and greater resolution of hmi , compared to previous analysis using full disk mdi data at a 96minute cadence , greatly improved this portion of the analysis . we found that a half hour cadence was sufficient to capture the evolution of this active region . analysis of this region began before the hmi 720 second averaged data were available . future investigations will use the high quality averaged dataset . the tracking information is stored in a mask array , which assigns unique labels to contiguous groups of data pixels , and matches these labels across all timesteps . this framework accounts for all processes we see in the data : submergence and emergence , merging , splitting , braiding , and spinning . in the present work we focus on submergence and emergence of magnetic flux . all other processes are implicitly addressed in our work except for spinning . @xcite have accounted for spinning explicitly in their work and found that its importance is case dependent . we do not believe spinning plays a significant role in noaa ar 11112 . in the second part of our analysis we use the tracking information in the mask array to characterize the system wholly in terms of its topology . each region s total flux , together with its flux weighted centroid , defines a magnetic pole . a potential field extrapolation using the poles as sources , together with a mirror corona where @xmath185 yields all null points of the system . the potential field extrapolation determines the locations of separators , which are where current sheets form due to free magnetic energy in the coronal field in the mcc model . the amount of current flowing in each separator , and the amount of free energy in the field , is due directly to the nonpotentiality of each flux domain . a lower bound on the free magnetic energy is calculated from the separators and domain fluxes using the method of @xcite , who found that the mcc estimate may be less than other mhd free energy estimates by a factor of ten or more . for noaa ar 11112 we found a lower bound of @xmath186 ergs . this method requires that all domains linked by each separator are known . this has been done by inspection in the past @xcite , but in the present work we have proposed an efficient automatic method using the gauss linking number . provided the specification of some closure for both field lines and separators , and because domains are simply connected spaces , calculating the linking number for each separator and a single field line from each domain will find all linked domains for each separator , and the sense in which they are linked @xmath187 . it must be noted , however , that domains are not equivalent to connections : a single pair of positive and negatives poles may be multiply connected , with different domains in a single connection distinguished by one or more separators . we found no such instances of this in the case of noaa ar 11112 , but this scenario may be simply dealt with by tracing a large number of random field lines between each pair of multiply connected poles . one may then calculate the gauss linking number of each separator with the suite of field lines , and determine the proportion of field lines linked by each separator . the linked flux may then be divided among the separators , accordingly . our free energy estimation does have some limitations . most important , we can only calculate energy storage , not energy release , for instance , in a flare . this is because we fix the domain fluxes at some point in the past and compare them to the potential field domain fluxes at some given time ; however the flare is a coronal phenomenon , while the potential field configuration is derived purely from photospheric data . using coronal data to quantify how domain fluxes change during a flare would allow for an energy estimation before and after a flare , though we are aware of no method for doing so . second , our energy calculation only takes into account the self inductance of each current ribbon . for a set of currents loops , the total energy is given by both self and mutual inductance terms . when the loops are physically separated , the self inductance terms should dominate . however , if some subset of loops share a common leg ( as is the case when multiple separators are connected to a coronal null point ) , then mutual inductance will significantly contribute to the total energy and must be accounted for . this work remains to be done . graham barnes graciously provided code for producing the potential field connectivity matrices using a monte carlo algorithm with bayesian estimates , as described in @xcite . development of the code was supported by the air force office of scientific research under contract fa9550 - 06-c-0019 . we thank the referee for his / her thorough reading and insightful comments which helped improve the manuscript . we also thank our summer 2010 reu student johanna bridge for her work in assessing the performance of the automatic tracking algorithms . this work was supported by nasa lws . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: many years of effort have been spent on trying to understand the structure and evolution of the super star cluster ngc2070 , at the centre of the 30doradus nebula in the large magellanic cloud ( otherwise known as the tarantula nebula ) since its discovery as such by lacaille in 1751 . in this case , the prize is clearly worth the effort as this object may hold the key to answers to many fundamental questions regarding the physics of the formation of stars , stellar clusters and galaxies and their role in the cosmos ( e.g. brandl 2005 ) . thanks also to this effort , we now know much about the brightest stars more massive than @xmath5m@xmath6that can be more easily detected and resolved . in spite of the rather large distances ( @xmath7kpc ) involved ( hunter et al . 1995a ) , these objects can be studied even in the very compact core of ngc2070 , referred to as r136 , which was first resolved unambiguously by the hubble space telescope ( hst ) using the faint object camera ( weigelt et al . 1991 ; de marchi et al . but we still know very little about the other part of this population consisting of the fainter , low mass main sequence ( ms ) and pre - ms ( pms ) stars and brown dwarfs . these might be present in even larger numbers if the tapered power law imf proposed recently by de marchi , paresce & portegies zwaart ( 2010 ) for young and very old clusters continues to the hydrogen burning limit and beyond . their number and spatial distribution are critical for understanding the low mass star formation process in a cluster of very massive stars and their role in determining the ultimate fate of the cluster itself . the current observational situation regarding low mass stars in ngc2070 is contradictory . although there is good evidence for a significant population of these stars , the precise nature of their spatial and mass distributions is not well understood . sirianni et al ( 2000 ) , using @xmath8- and @xmath9-band hst observations claim that the mass function ( mf ) flattens below @xmath10m@xmath6 , while zinnecker et al . ( 2002 ) and more recently andersen et al . ( 2010 ) , using hst observations in the h band , find no such feature in their data down to their completeness limit around 1m@xmath6 . so far , little can be said of what happens below this limit , mainly because these stars in ngc2070 and its compact core r136 are very difficult to detect and characterize accurately . first , because of their inherent faintness especially with respect to the high background due to the numerous much brighter stars in the field . second , because they scatter widely across the colour magnitude diagram ( cmd ) making accurate subtraction of field stars and older cluster pms stars and subdwarfs near the ms unreliable without useful separation criteria . finally , the patchy extinction across the face of the nebula ( e.g. indebetouw et al . 2009 ) needs to be properly accounted for in order to accurately determine their true brightness . for these reasons , use of the wide field camera 3 ( wfc3 ) , the new panchromatic camera on hst , is , in principle , ideal for the task of establishing the main characteristics of the low mass population in ngc2070 . with its high spatial resolution over a wide field encompassing most of the central part of the cluster and its unprecedented sensitivity in the near uv and ir , the wfc3 allows us to tackle for the first time most of the problems summarised above with some hope of resolving them . in this paper , we present the first results of a deep survey of ngc2070 obtained in 2009 october as part of the early release science programme with the wfc3 camera . this project has as its ultimate objective that of determining as accurately as possible the properties of the low - mass initial mf in this cluster , which could be a prototype of the much larger and distant unresolved super star clusters in starburst galaxies . in order for this type of study to become possible , we must first carefully identify and distinguish from one another stars of different ages , since several generations of objects are known to populate the 30dor region ( e.g. walborn & blades 1997 ) . so far , studies of the star formation history of 30dor have been limited to the most massive stars , typically above 20m@xmath6 , and hence to the past 10myr or so , because these works rely on spectroscopy of individual objects that can not easily be obtained for less massive stars ( e.g. selman et al . 1999 ) . clearly , access to a wider mass range is crucial , so the goal of this paper is to understand how star formation has proceeded for much smaller objects , i.e. stars with masses as low as @xmath11m@xmath6 . therefore , in this work we concentrate on a systematic search for low - mass stars in the pms phase , which we can identify in a reliable way and which allow us to study how star formation has proceeded in this area over the past @xmath3myr . only then will it be possible to address the properties of the mf , which will be the subject of future work . the structure of this paper is as follows . we describe the observations in section2 , the reduction of the data in section3 and the photometric analysis in section4 . the correction for extinction and the resultant corrected cmds are presented in section5 . the hertzsprung russell ( hr ) diagram and its analysis with recent pms models are the topic of section6 , where we also discuss the preliminary physical implications of our results on the star formation history in these regions . a summary is provided in section7 . the observations discussed in this paper were obtained in 2009 october ( 20 27 ) with the wfc3 on board the hst . we refer the reader to dressel et al . ( 2010 ) for information about the wfc3 instrument and its performances . six broad - band and one narrow - band filters were used in these observations , as shown in table[tab1 ] , where the number of exposures and the total exposure times in each filter are also given . note that an extensive dithering pattern was employed , combining both long and short exposures , in order to improve the sampling of the telescope s point spread function ( psf ) , to minimise the effects of detector blemishes , to cover the gap between the two detectors in the field of view , and to recover the magnitudes of the brightest objects that would otherwise saturate in long exposures . lcr[bh ] f336w & 24 & @xmath12 + f438w & 16 & @xmath13 + f555w & 20 & @xmath14 + f656n & 8 & @xmath15 + f814w & 20 & @xmath16 + f110w & 9 & @xmath17 + f160w & 12 & @xmath18 [ tab1 ] for illustration purposes , figure[fig0 ] presents a four - colour composite image of the observed field . the colours result from assigning different hues to each monochromatic image , as indicated in the figure caption . the bright compact star cluster in the upper right - hand side of the frame is r136 , the core of the massive ngc2070 association . a cursory glance at figure[fig0 ] already shows that the centre of the cluster is dominated by bright blue stars , although a handful of bright red objects are seen to the east of it , suggesting the presence of an older generation of stars . this is consistent with the conclusions of selman et al . ( 1999 ) , who found at least three generations of massive stars , with the youngest and bluest members more centrally concentrated . we will return in more detail to the spatial distribution of these objects in section4 . throughout this paper we will concentrate on the observations in the optical wavelength range , and in particular on the f555w , f656n and f814w bands ( hereafter referred to as @xmath8 , @xmath19 and @xmath9 , respectively ) , whereas the entire wfc3 dataset including the observations at ir wavelengths will be covered in more detail in a forthcoming paper ( beccari et al . , in preparation ) . as regards the data reduction , the long and short exposures were treated in a different way . the deep datasets were combined using the iraf _ multidrizzle _ task , with the appropriate calibration files and geometric distortion coefficients for the uvis channel of the wfc3 . given the large number of deep frames available in the uvis filters and the careful dithering strategy adopted for these observations , we were able to derive one single `` drizzled '' image per band , free of cosmic rays and blemishes and with a rather sharp and well sampled psf , ideal for the detection of faint stars . producing a deep , high - quality combined image per filter is particularly useful in a field like 30dor where stars are embedded in extensive nebulosity associated with the gas that makes the photometry and the determination of the background more difficult on individual images . star detection and identification was done by running the automated iraf _ daofind _ routine separately on the @xmath8- and @xmath9-band drizzled frames , with the detection threshold set at @xmath20 above the local background level . in order for objects to be classified as real stars , we required that they be detected in both filters . the presence of numerous gas filaments and irregularities in the background can cause spurious detections , particularly in the h@xmath1 band , where considerable emission is present ( see figure[fig0 ] . for this reason , we visually inspected the detected stars and excluded from the bona - fide list all the detections not clearly associated with point - like sources . more specifically , we applied an unsharp - masking filter ( e.g. malin 1977 ) , with a smoothing radius of 15 pixel meant to subtract the low - frequency signal . unsharp masking makes structures and filaments in the nebular gas easier to see than in the direct image . in this way we compared the structures and filaments with the positions of the detected stars , in order to avoid spurious detections ( see beccari et al . 2010 for an application of this method to the case of the massive galactic cluster ngc3603 observed with the same camera ) . once the master list was defined in this way , we proceeded to measuring the magnitudes of each star with the iraf _ phot _ aperture photometry task . since the central regions are rather crowded , we opted for a photometric aperture of 3 pixel radius and a background annulus enclosing the area between 4 and 7 pixel radius around the stars . following de marchi et al . ( 1993 ) , we took as background value the mode of the counts within the annulus , in such a way to minimise the contamination due to neighbouring objects . this procedure was not applied directly on the combined drizzled frames , but rather on a subset of those . more precisely , having at our disposal 16 deep exposures both in the @xmath8 and @xmath9 bands , we used multidrizzle to build for each filter four drizzled images , each comprising four individual exposures . we then ran the iraf phot task on each of them , using as input coordinates the master list derived before . in this way , we could derive four independent measurements of the magnitude for each object in both the @xmath8 and @xmath9 band and the standard deviation of the four measurements immediately provides the photometric uncertainty . we followed the same procedure in all other visible bands , including h@xmath1 for which the four combined images comprise each two individual exposures . the approach followed for the short exposures ( ranging from a @xmath21s to 30s in duration ) is different , owing to the limited number of exposures available in each filter . in that case we performed the photometry on each individual flat - fielded image using psf fitting , having first built a proper psf model on each frame using isolated and well sampled stars , which was then fitted to each object in the images by means of the standard daophot / allstar routine . the reason why we did not use psf - fitting photometry also for the deep exposures is that image combination with multidrizzle does not necessarily preserve the uniformity of the psf . the two photometric catalogues obtained in this way for the long and short exposures were independently calibrated following the specific recipes developed by kalirai et al . ( 2009 ) for the uvis channel of the wfc3 . briefly , all magnitudes were first rescaled to an aperture of @xmath22 and then transformed into the vegamag system using the synthetic zero points given by kalirai et al . ( 2009 ) . the accuracy of the photometry in both catalogues is very good . the typical photometric uncertainty over the entire sample ranges from @xmath23mag at @xmath24 or @xmath25 to @xmath26mag at @xmath27 or @xmath28 ( note that in the following sections we will limit our study to objects with the smallest uncertainties , as indicated ) . finally , the two photometric catalogues were combined and merged so as to avoid duplications . we used stars in the magnitude range @xmath29 , where errors are small , to verify the integrity of the photometry by comparing the magnitudes derived for the same star in the long and short exposures . we found the match to be excellent , with any differences in magnitude being comparable to the photometric uncertainties in the short exposures ( @xmath30mag ) . the final combined catalogue contains 22291 stars with well defined fluxes in the @xmath8 and @xmath9 bands . of these , 18142 objects are also detected in h@xmath1 . the cmd of all objects with combined photometric uncertainty in the @xmath8 and @xmath9 bands not exceeding @xmath31mag is shown in figure[fig1 ] . the cmd shown in figure[fig1 ] is the deepest so far obtained for this cluster . at @xmath32 it reaches about 3mag deeper than the cmds previously obtained with the wfpc2 camera on board the _ hst _ in these bands ( sirianni et al . 2000 ; hunter et al . note that this is not only due to the improved sensitivity of the wfc3 camera , but also to the considerably shorter exposure times in the i band and the smaller field of view of the wfpc2 camera , which limited the observations to the most crowded regions of the cluster . the striking difference between the cmd of figure[fig1 ] and that of sirianni et al . ( 2000 ) is the prominent lower ms occupying the region fainter than @xmath33 and bluer than @xmath32 and revealing the presence in this field of a considerably older stellar population than the @xmath34myr old stars associated with r136 ( e.g. de marchi et al . 1993 ; hunter et al . 1995a ; massey & hunter 1998 ) . we will discuss the age distribution of the stars in this field in sections5 and 6 . the other interesting feature seen in figure[fig1 ] is the large number of objects in the range @xmath35 that appear brighter than the lower ms . their location is consistent with that of the pms population studied by sirianni et al . ( 2000 ; see also andersen et al . 2009 ) , but their number is much larger than those detected before . we discuss the properties of these stars in section5 , but we first need to address an important issue that affects the cmd , namely interstellar extinction . the width of the upper ms seen in figure[fig1 ] , at @xmath36 , is much larger than the photometric uncertainty at those magnitudes ( indicated by the horizontal bars on the left - hand side of the figure ) , revealing that there is a wide spread of extinction in this field . actually , there is general consensus that differential reddening is present in these regions . from the analysis of high - resolution narrow - band images , hunter et al . ( 1995b ) concluded that the nebulosity in this area is not uniform even on scales of order @xmath37 . however , in a subsequent study of the stellar populations in this region hunter et al . ( 1996 ) opted for a uniform reddening correction across the whole field , since they concluded that uncertainties ( e.g. red leak ) in the response of the wfpc2 filters did not justify a star - by - star correction . also sirianni et al . ( 2000 ) used the same @xmath38 value for all stars , although this may have lead to larger uncertainties in their mass determination of individual pms stars , as selman et al . ( 1999 ) and more recently andersen et al . ( 2009 ) have pointed out . in order to overcome this problem , in section4.1 we will use a robust method based on the determination of the individual reddening corrections for a large group of bright stars ( romaniello 1998 ) , which are then used to derive a correction also for fainter neighbouring objects . the young population in this field , responsible for the upper ms in figure[fig1 ] , has an age of @xmath34myr ( e.g. de marchi et al . 1993 ; hunter et al . 1995a ) or perhaps younger ( @xmath10myr ) if wolf rayet stars are still burning hydrogen ( massey & hunter 1998 ; de koter , heap & hubeny 1998 ; walborn et al . one can therefore determine the reddening towards each of those stars by measuring their colour and magnitude displacements with respect to a theoretical isochrone for the appropriate age , metallicity and distance . as for the metallicity , throughout this paper we will assume @xmath39 or about one third @xmath40 , since this is a typical value for the lmc ( e.g. hill , andrievsky & spite 1995 ; geha et al . 1998 ) . as regards the distance to 30dor , we will use @xmath41kpc since this is the geometrical distance to the neighbouring sn1987 object ( panagia et al . 1991 , later updated in panagia 1999).the resulting distance modulus of @xmath42 is fully consistent with that adopted by ( walborn & blades 1997 ) . we show in figure[fig2 ] as a solid line ( in blue in the online version ) an isochrone for an age of 3myr and a metallicity of @xmath39 , from marigo et al . ( 2008 ) , and the adopted distance modulus of @xmath42 . having assumed a younger age , i.e. 1 or 2myr , would have only affected the shape of the isochrone in the top @xmath43mag range , which we will not consider in this analysis . the isochrone is also already reddened by the amount corresponding to the intervening absorption along the line of sight due to the milky way , which fitzpatrick & savage ( 1984 ) quantified in @xmath44 , in turn corresponding to @xmath45 . the other curves on the left - hand side of the figure ( in blue in the online version ) represent the same isochrone reddened , for purpose of illustration , by an additional amount of extinction , with the long - dashed , short - dashed and dot - dashed lines corresponding respectively to @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 . as for the extinction law , for the portion in addition to the @xmath44 due to the milky way we have used the law determined spectroscopically by scuderi et al . ( 1996 ) for star2 in the field of sn1987a , which we take as representative of the 30dor region as well . the arrow in the figure shows the corresponding reddening vector for @xmath49 . the long - dashed line , corresponding to @xmath46 , forms a natural left envelope to the upper ms at @xmath50 and leaves very few objects in the range @xmath51 at those magnitudes . this is expected because of the considerable amount of foreground extinction known to be present in the lmc towards 30dor : although the @xmath52 value that we find is somewhat larger than the @xmath53 reported by fitzpatrick ( 1985 ) , the latter value has been determined for the brightest stars at the very centre of 30dor that generally lie in evacuated cavities of hii gas of their own making and should therefore have a lower extinction . note that , at magnitudes fainter than @xmath33 , where the photometric uncertainty is still rather small ( see bars in figure[fig1 ] ) , there is a large number of objects between the @xmath46 and @xmath44 solid curves . in fact , the latter offers a much better fit to the lower ms , suggesting that these stars belong to an older foreground population . at least some of them could be members of the much older lmc field , which is known to have ages in excess of @xmath43gyr ( e.g. panagia et al . 2000 ; harris & zaritsky 2004 ) . interestingly , there are also a few objects that appear bluer than the @xmath44 curve . although they are in general consistent with our photometric uncertainties , some of them could actually be very young stars with a circumstellar disc seen at high inclination ( @xmath54 ) . objects of this type would appear somewhat bluer than their photospheric colour due to light scattering on the circumstellar disc , as well as several magnitudes fainter than their photospheric brightness due to extinction along the line of sight caused by an almost edge - on disc . however , according to the models of robitaille et al . ( 2006 ) for the spectral energy distribution of young stars seen at various viewing angles , objects of this type can only account for a few percent of the total young population , so the vast majority of stars near the @xmath44 solid curve must belong to the field in the lmc foreground . the presence of a foreground population of older objects becomes even more obvious when one looks at the other set of curves on the right - hand side of the figure ( shown in orange in the online version ) , corresponding to isochrones for an age of 2gyr and the same metallicity , distance , and reddening values used for the 3myr isochrones , also from the models of marigo et al . the 2gyr isochrones are shown up to a mass of @xmath55m@xmath6 , corresponding to the approximate location of the red giant clump ( rc ) , a characteristic feature of the cmd of low - mass , metal - rich stars experiencing their he - burning phase . it represents the counterpart at high metallicity of the horizontal branch seen in cmds of metal- poor globular clusters . the rc usually appears as a very tight , well defined feature in the cmd of stellar populations that could in principle be used as a distance indicator ( e.g. stanek & garnavich 1998 ; paczynski & stanek 1998 ; cole 1998 ; girardi et al . 1998 ; girardi & salaris 2001 ) . when there is patchy absorption , like in our case , and the amount of extinction varies from place to place , the rc becomes in practice an elongated ellipse running parallel to the direction of the reddening vector . this is precisely the nature of the apparent sequence of points running diagonally between @xmath56 and @xmath57 . this feature can also be used to derive the extinction law ( de marchi , panagia & romaniello 2007 ; panagia , de marchi & romaniello 2008 ) . the implications of this finding for the properties of the absorbing material in this and other lmc fields will be addressed in detail elsewhere ( de marchi & panagia 2011 , in preparation ) , but it is immediately clear from figure[fig2 ] that the young and old stars present in this field have rather different extinction ranges . while stars in the rc span the entire range @xmath58 , there are in practice no objects in the upper ms with @xmath59 . therefore , the reddening correction that we can derive using the objects in the upper ms will only be valid for those stars and , in a statistical sense , for low - mass stars of similar age if they have a similar spatial distribution , but it will not be appropriate for older objects , for which we will have to resort to an average correction . the procedure that we followed for reddening correction is explained in detail in the following subsection . we have used all the upper ms objects inside the box shown in figure[fig2 ] as reference stars for our determination of the reddening distribution across the field , with a total of about 800 stars selected in this way . assuming that they are all ms stars , we have measured their displacement from the solid isochrone along the reddening vector , whose direction is given by the arrow and the tilted sides of the box ( as mentioned above , we adopted the extinction law of scuderi et al . we have explicitly excluded the brightest objects where an age difference of 1 or 2myr could have an effect , albeit small , on the shape of the isochrone . the reddening distribution ranges from @xmath60 or @xmath61 to @xmath62 or @xmath63 , corresponding respectively to the 17% and 83% distribution limits , with a median value of @xmath64 or @xmath49 . the difference between the 17% and 83% limits indicates a @xmath65 spread of @xmath66mag in @xmath67 , indicating that reddening varies considerably in this field . the reddening values towards each of the selected ms stars were then used to derive a reddening correction for the objects in their vicinities . this procedure implicitly assumes that stars projected within a relatively small region of the field have similar extinction values , even though no information is available on the depth of their distribution nor on the uniformity of the absorbing material . in order to verify the validity of this assumption , we first applied the reddening correction to the upper ms stars themselves . each star was corrected using the average of the extinction values of the nearest upper ms stars , excluding the star itself ( no distance weighing was used , since we have no information on the depth of the distribution ) . after experimenting with a different number of neighbours ( namely 1 , 5 , 10 , and 20 ) , we concluded that using the 5 closest neighbours produces the tightest upper ms . this choice corresponds to using reference stars within a radius of less than @xmath68 , with a typical effective radius of @xmath69 . after reddening correction , the @xmath70 spread in the upper ms drops to @xmath71mag and the upper ms itself appears considerably tighter in the cmd than in the raw data ( see figure[fig6 ] ) . this result convinced us that the method , albeit statistical in nature , can be applied to other objects in the field , provided that they have an age and spatial distribution consistent with that of the upper ms stars . the cmd and isochrones in figure[fig2 ] help us to identify stars of similar age . this is the case of ms stars roughly brighter than @xmath72 and bluer than @xmath73 and of young pms objects roughly redder and fainter than the dot - dashed 2gyr isochrone ( these objects are shown as dark dots in the figure ) . however , the cmd alone does not allow us to assign an age to objects falling in the region between the solid and dot - dashed 2gyr isochrones ( shown as light dots ) , since they could be pms stars of various ages , low - mass ms stars , or red giants . therefore , in order to identify bona - fide young objects in this region we have to resort to a more reliable youth indicator , namely a strong h@xmath1 excess emission . this feature is characteristic of low - mass star formation and is attributed to the accretion process , whereby gravitational energy , released by infalling matter , ionises and excites the surrounding gas ( e.g. knigl 1991 ; shu et al . 1994 ) . a detailed account on how to reliably detect these objects using multi - colour photometry is given in de marchi et al . ( 2010 ) and de marchi et al . the method , already employed also by beccari et al . ( 2010 ) to search for objects with h@xmath1 excess in ngc3603 , will be used in section5 for an accurate selection of bona - fide pms stars after reddening correction . briefly , the method uses the median @xmath74 dereddened colour of stars with small ( @xmath75mag ) photometric uncertainties in the three bands ( @xmath76 and @xmath19 ) to define a reference template that is used to identify objects with excess h@xmath1 emission . however , as de marchi et al . ( 2010 ) have shown , even before reddening correction the colour colour diagram @xmath77 , @xmath78 provides a robust identification of stars with h@xmath1 excess , since in these bands the reddening vector runs almost parallel to the median photospheric colours of normal stars . therefore , following that procedure , we looked initially for stars whose @xmath77 colour exceeds by at least three times the photometric uncertainty the @xmath77 colour of normal stars ( i.e. those with no excess ) with the same @xmath78 colour . a more stringent selection will be applied after reddening correction ( see section5 ) . the pms candidates selected in this way , a total of 2374 , are shown as thick dots in figure[fig3 ] , where the dashed line represents the median photospheric @xmath77 colour as a function of @xmath78 . for comparison , we also show as a thin dotted line the corresponding colours derived from the model atmospheres of bessell , castelli & pletz ( 1998 ) for stars with effective temperatures in the range 3500 k @xmath79 40000k , surface gravity @xmath80 and a metallicity index @xmath81=-0.5 $ ] , as appropriate for the lmc ( dufour 1984 ) . the theoretical colours were calculated for the specific filters of the wfc3 camera and were reddened by @xmath82 , following the extinction law of scuderi et al . ( 1996 ) mentioned above for the purpose of comparison with the data . note that , due to the still preliminary calibration of the wfc3 photometric system in the h@xmath1 band , we had to apply a small correction to the @xmath77 colour of @xmath83 mag to force the @xmath77 colour of vega to be 0 at @xmath84 , as is appropriate for the vegamag photometric system . the objects with h@xmath1 excess emission are also shown as thick symbols in the cmd of figure[fig4 ] . besides the 3myr and 2gyr isochrones , we show there also the isochrones for pms stars of age 5myr ( upper thin line ) and 10myr ( lower thin line ) from the models of deglinnocenti et al . ( 2008 ) for the assumed lmc metallicity ( @xmath39 ) and having taken @xmath46 for the reddening . these isochrones allow us to distinguish in an approximate way between younger and older pms stars ( a more accurate age determination requires the reddening correction and will be possible only at the end of this process ) and to study their spatial distribution . using the 5myr pms isochrone as a reference , we have marked as thick dots and crosses respectively the objects above and below that line , and hence approximately younger and older than 5myr . in figure[fig5 ] we show the radial distribution of these low - mass stars with h@xmath1 excess , drawn from the nominal centre of r136 . the short - dashed line corresponds to stars younger than @xmath85myr , the long - dashed line to stars older than 10myr , while the distribution of upper ms stars is shown by the solid line , rescaled by a factor of @xmath86 to make the comparison easier . younger and older pms stars have markedly different distributions : older stars have a rather uniform distribution and are almost absent inside a radius of @xmath87 , while younger objects show a density gradient that follows remarkably well that of upper ms stars down to @xmath37 , where photometric incompleteness starts to dominate as indicated by the rapidly increasing photometric uncertainties in these regions . the choice of which approximate age ( 5myr or 10myr ) to adopt for separating `` younger '' and `` older '' stars is somewhat arbitrary , but the dotted line in figure[fig5 ] , corresponding to stars with age in the range @xmath88myr , suggests that objects with h@xmath1 excess older than @xmath89myr have a radial distribution remarkably different from that of upper ms stars . this is perhaps not surprising , considering that 5myr is about twice the age of the massive members of r136 ( @xmath90myr ; de marchi et al . 1993 ; hunter et al . 1995a ; massey & hunter 1998 ; de koter et al . 1998 ; walborn et al . 1999 ) . we will discuss these differences in the radial distribution in more detail in section6 . for now , figure[fig5 ] confirms that it is appropriate to use the reddening values derived from upper ms stars also for similarly young low - mass objects , but it suggests that this type of correction would not be suitable for older stars outside of the inner @xmath91 . as figure[fig5 ] implies , these objects are uniformly distributed over the field and are thus consistent with being in the foreground of r136 . in order to obtain at least an estimate of their reddening , we can use the stars with h@xmath1 excess that appear bluer than the isochrone for @xmath46 , i.e. the long dashed line in figures[fig2 ] and [ fig4 ] . as mentioned earlier , @xmath46 is the lower limit to the reddening towards the upper ms stars of r136 , so objects bluer than the long - dashed line in those figures are most likely in the foreground . a total of 144 stars satisfy this condition and , assuming that they are in the late stages of pms evolution , i.e. close to the ms , we derive for them a median reddening value of @xmath82 . if these objects were in a considerably earlier stage of their pms evolution , this procedure would give us an upper limit to their reddening . on the other hand , the fact that they are uniformly distributed over the field indicates that they can not be as young as the other much more concentrated objects with h@xmath1 excess ( see figure[fig5 ] ) . we therefore take @xmath82 as a representative value for the reddening towards all these stars and in general for all objects with h@xmath1 excess shown as crosses in figure[fig4 ] . we can now correct for extinction the magnitudes of all objects shown in figure[fig4 ] in the following way . all stars located within @xmath92 of the centre of r136 are corrected individually using the average extinction value of the nearest five upper ms stars . as regards objects outside @xmath92 , those with an age lower than @xmath85myr ( i.e. thick and thin dots in figure[fig4 ] ) are corrected in the same way , whereas older stars with excess ( crosses in figure[fig4 ] , red in the online version ) are corrected using the average @xmath82 value . no correction is attempted for other objects , since we can not determine their ages on the basis of the cmd alone , and they are not considered further in this work . note that when the magnitude of an object is corrected for extinction using its nearest neighbours , it is assumed that the placement of the object with respect to the absorbing material is similar to that of the reference stars in its vicinities . this process is accompanied by some statistical fluctuations , since as we have seen there is an intrinsic spread of @xmath71mag in the @xmath67 distribution of our upper ms reference stars . however , the uncertainties that this assumption can introduce in the final magnitudes of the stars are relatively small . the typical standard deviation of the @xmath67 values of the five nearest neighbours is @xmath93mag and , more generally , over the entire field these statistical uncertainties are not expected to exceed the reddening spread measured for the upper ms reference stars before reddening correction , i.e. @xmath66mag in @xmath67 or @xmath94mag in @xmath38 . the cmd corrected for extinction in this way is shown in figure[fig6 ] . it must be understood that it does not cover all objects that were observed , but only those for which we could determine a reliable correction for reddening . the symbol types are the same as used in figure[fig4 ] , the solid line represents the theoretical isochrone from marigo et al . ( 2008 ) for a ms age of 3myr , a metallicity of @xmath39 and a distance modulus of @xmath42 , whereas the dashed line corresponds to the isochrone of deglinnocenti et al . ( 2008 ) for a pms age of 5myr and the same metallicity and distance modulus . the pms isochrone of deglinnocenti et al . ( 2008 ) has been translated from the theoretical plane ( @xmath95 , @xmath96 ) to the plane of the observations using the model atmospheres of bessell et al . ( 1998 ) folded through the specific wfc3 filters employed here . the pms isochrone meets the ms at @xmath97 and it is reassuring that the two curves are in excellent agreement at brighter magnitudes , since they are based on independent models and different input physics . the cmd corrected for extinction in figure[fig6 ] reveals that at dereddened @xmath98 magnitudes fainter than @xmath99 there is a conspicuous number of objects that are above ( i.e. brighter than ) the ms and , as such , they are consistent with a population of pms stars . these objects extend down to @xmath100 , or more than three magnitudes deeper than the limit reached by sirianni et al . ( 2000 ) and andersen et al . ( 2009 ) , who detected and studied the brightest members of this population . as already mentioned in section4 , having corrected the photometry for extinction allows us to better clarify and confirm the pms nature of these stars by looking at the specific signatures of the mass accretion process that is supposed to accompany this evolutionary phase . the accretion process is believed to be the cause of the strong excess emission observed in these objects ( e.g. knigl 1991 ; shu et al . for example , the presence of a strong h@xmath1 emission line ( with equivalent width in excess of @xmath101 ) in young stellar objects is normally interpreted as the signature of ongoing accretion ( e.g. feigelson & montmerle 1999 ; white & basri 2003 ) . note that , although it is customary to use negative equivalent widths for emission lines , in this work we will use @xmath102 to refer to the equivalent width of the h@xmath1 emission line , defined as a positive quantity . in section4 we used this method for a preliminary coarse identification of stars with h@xmath1 excess emission , but here we employ very conservative criteria to refine the selection of bona - fide pms stars . in particular , we now limit the search only to stars with a combined photometric uncertainty in the @xmath76 and @xmath19 bands of less than @xmath103mag and fainter than @xmath104 ( corresponding to @xmath105l@xmath106 ) and we look for objects with dereddened @xmath107 colour excess at least four times larger than the photometric uncertainty in those bands ( equivalent to a @xmath108 detection limit ) . in section4 we used as a reference template the median photospheric colours of stars with small photometric uncertainty , the majority of which are older ms stars and have no h@xmath1 excess . this approach can not be followed here since many of the objects for which we could compute a reddening correction have h@xmath1 excess . as a reference template we use instead the theoretical photospheric colours derived from model atmospheres . as figure[fig3 ] shows , the models of bessell et al . ( 1998 ) for surface gravity @xmath109 and metallicity @xmath81 = -0.5 $ ] are in excellent agreement with the observed colours . this was also shown to be the case for stars in the field of sn1987a ( de marchi et al . 2010 ) and in ngc346 ( de marchi et al . 2011 ) . besides selecting stars with excess emission above the @xmath108 level , we also imposed constraints on the equivalent width of the h@xmath1 emission , @xmath102 . following the procedure outlined in de marchi et al . ( 2010 ) to derive @xmath102 from the observed colours , we further restricted the selection to objects with @xmath110 in order to avoid contamination by stars with significant chromospheric activity . furthermore , since at temperatures @xmath111k or colours @xmath112 the sample could be contaminated by be stars that are evolving off the ms , for those objects we set a more stringent condition , namely @xmath113 . in a survey of about 100 stars of type be in the galaxy ( cot & waters 1987 ) , only one star is found with @xmath113 and the largest majority have values in the range from @xmath114 to @xmath115 . a total of 1159 objects satisfy these conservative detection conditions : we will take them hereafter as bona - fide pms stars . obviously , less stringent limits would result in a larger number of pms stars , albeit with lower significance , but it must be understood that , even without changing the selection criteria , the actual number of pms stars in this field must be considerably larger . this is because our detection and classification relies on the presence of h@xmath1 excess emission at the time of the observations , but very young populations are known to show large variations in their h@xmath1 emission over hours or days ( e.g. fernandez et al . 1995 ; smith et al . 1999 ; alencar et al . 2001 ) , with only about one third of them at any given time being active h@xmath1 emitters with @xmath116 ( panagia et al . 2000 ; de marchi et al . 2010 ; de marchi et al . 2011 ) . therefore , the 1159 stars identified as bona - fide pms objects are those that were undergoing active mass accretion and therefore showed h@xmath1 excess emission at the time of these observations . on the other hand , since the duty cycles of any two stars are completely independent of one another , the sample of bona - fide pms stars identified in this way is representative of the entire pms population in this field . hereafter , unless otherwise indicated , when talking about pms stars we will refer exclusively to the 1159 bona - fide pms objects identified through their h@xmath1 excess emission . we show in figure[fig7 ] their locations in the cmd ( thick dots ) . the majority occupy the region above the ms where young pms objects are expected , but there are many located at or near the ms , suggesting an older age . a similar situation has already been noticed in other star forming regions , namely the sn1987a field in the lmc ( de marchi et al . 2010 ) , ngc3603 in the milky way ( beccari et al . 2010 ) , and ngc346 in the small magellanic cloud ( de marchi et al . 2011 ) . the skeptical reader might be concerned that the h@xmath1 excess emission of many of the objects near the ms could in reality be due to nebular contamination of the gas present in the field . however , as mentioned in section3 , we specifically excluded from our photometry all objects for which the photometric aperture would be contaminated by gas filaments . if the filament completely fills both the core aperture used to measure the flux of the star and the surrounding background annulus , it will not alter the photometry of the star , since it will be equivalent to a uniform background . obviously , if the background annulus does not properly sample the contamination , for instance because the filament only covers part of it , the emission present in the gas may be erroneously associated to the object ( for an illustration of this effect see beccari et al . precisely for this reason , as discussed in section3 , we have removed from the initial star lists all objects in the vicinity of a filament . therefore , we are confident that the h@xmath1 excess emission of our bona - fide pms stars is an intrinsic feature of those objects and we must interpret their distribution across the cmd as a sign of an age spread . more quantitative information on the age of these objects can be obtained from the comparison with pms isochrones , shown in figure[fig8 ] , where the effective temperatures ( @xmath117 ) and luminosities ( @xmath118 ) of these stars are arranged in the hr diagram . the value of @xmath117 was derived for each star directly from the dereddened @xmath78 colour , since this is an excellent index for temperature determinations in the range @xmath119k ( e.g. von braun et al . 1998 ; bessell et al . 1998 ) . for the conversion we made use of the models of bessell et al . ( 1998 ) already discussed in section4 . as for the bolometric luminosity , it was obtained from the dereddened @xmath8 magnitude and the same models , having assumed a distance modulus of @xmath42 . the solid lines in the figure corresponds to the pms evolutionary track from the pisa group ( deglinnocenti et al . 2008 ; tognelli et al . 2011 ) for metallicity @xmath39 . the tracks correspond to stellar masses from @xmath120m@xmath6to @xmath121m@xmath6and reveal the presence of bona - fide pms stars over the entire mass range . the isochrones ( dashed lines ) correspond , from right to left , to ages ranging from @xmath122myr through to 32myr with a constant age step of a factor of 2 , selected in such a way that our photometric uncertainties are slightly smaller than the typical separation between the isochrones . pms objects are seen across the entire age range . the comparison of the hr diagram with pms evolutionary tracks and isochrones allows us to quantify the age spread of the pms stars that was already evident in the cmd . individual stellar masses and ages were derived via interpolation over a finer grid than the one shown in the figure . we followed the interpolation procedure developed by romaniello ( 1998 ) , which does not make assumptions on the properties of the population , such as the functional form of the imf . on the basis of the measurement errors , this procedure provides the probability distribution for each individual star to have a given value of the mass and age ( the method is conceptually identical to the one presented recently by da rio et al . 2010 ) . an important aspect to consider is the uncertainty associated with the age determination of our pms stars from their location in the hr diagram . besides photometric errors in the @xmath8 and @xmath9-band data ( which are always less than @xmath31mag ) , the major sources of uncertainty are the effects of reddening and the comparison with stellar models . as regards the latter , de marchi et al . ( 2010 ) show that , excluding possible inaccuracies in the models input physics and interpolation errors , the largest source of uncertainty comes from the use of models that do not properly describe the stellar population under study , e.g. because of the wrong metallicity , and from differences between models of various authors . they conclude that systematic uncertainties of order 20% are to be expected for the mass and possibly higher for the age . as for reddening , dust extinction systematically displaces stars in the hr diagram towards lower luminosities and effective temperatures . therefore , if the photometry of a pms star is not corrected for reddening , its age will typically be underestimated . a study currently being conducted ( de marchi & panagia , in prep . ) shows that for reddening @xmath123 there is a rather linear relationship of the type @xmath124 , where @xmath125 and @xmath126 are the ages before and after reddening correction . for example , as discussed in section4 , the spread of the upper ms in figure[fig1 ] corresponds to a reddening spread of @xmath127mag in @xmath67 . therefore , if we had used the average reddening value of @xmath49 to correct the magnitudes of all young stars , instead of using the values of the nearest neighbours , we would have introduced an age uncertainty of a factor of @xmath55 . similarly , if reddening correction for older stars with excess ( i.e. those indicated by crosses in figure[fig4 ] ) had been done using the average @xmath38 value of the nearest upper ms neighbours instead of @xmath82 , the derived ages would be typically twice as old . as a further example , the double arrow in figure[fig8 ] indicates the amount and direction of the displacement in the hr diagram caused by the typical uncertainty of @xmath128mag in @xmath67 associated with our reddening correction ( see section4.1 ) . in the specific case shown , the corresponding uncertainty on the age is a factor of @xmath55 while the uncertainty on the mass is less than 15% . this analysis suggests that the typical uncertainty on the ages that we derive is less than a factor of 2 . for this reason , the age distribution of pms stars is shown in figure[fig9 ] using as bin size a constant logarithmic step of a factor of 2 , which does not suffer from the relative age uncertainties . the solid line gives the number of stars inside each age bin as a function of time , whereas the dashed line provides an apparent value of the star formation rate in units of stars per myr ( i.e. the number of stars in each bin divided by the size of the bin ) . the dashed line seems to suggest a rather uniform star formation rate over the past 4myr , of order @xmath129m@xmath6myr@xmath130 ( the mass of our pms stars younger than 4myr ranges from @xmath131m@xmath6to @xmath132m@xmath6 , respectively the 17 and 83 percentiles , with an average of 2m@xmath6 ) , and a progressive drop at earlier times . obviously , this is necessarily a lower limit to the star formation rate , since our measurements only account for pms stars in the range @xmath133m@xmath6that had h@xmath1 excess emission at the time of the observations . furthermore , since the fraction of pms stars in an active state of accretion is expected to decrease with age ( see de marchi , panagia & sabbi 2011 ) , the apparent drop in the star formation beyond 2myr can at least in part be explained . keeping in mind that we can only provide a lower limit to the star formation rate , near the peak of the distribution , at @xmath43myr , this limit corresponds to @xmath134m@xmath6myr@xmath130 ( the average mass of those objects is @xmath135m@xmath6 ) , while at @xmath136myr it drops by over an order of magnitude to @xmath101m@xmath6myr@xmath130 ( average mass @xmath137m@xmath6 ) . a more detailed study of the star formation rate of 30 dor will be the topic of a future paper , but the histograms in figure[fig9 ] already show quite convincingly that star formation has been present in this region for an extended period of time , exceeding 30myr . from a spectroscopic study of massive stars ( @xmath138m@xmath6 ) within a radius of @xmath139 of r136 , selman et al . ( 1999 ) concluded that recent star formation in this region shows at least three distinct bursts , respectively @xmath140 and @xmath55myr ago , with increasing strength . they also found that the younger generation is considerably more concentrated than the others and is responsible for most of the star - formation within 6pc or @xmath141 of the cluster centre . it is therefore useful to compare this picture with the spatial distribution of our pms stars . although we do not have the age resolution needed to establish unambiguously whether the formation has been continuous during the past 30myr or whether repeated bursts have occurred , we can look at the current age distribution for clues as to the relationships between stars of different ages . the age distribution of these pms stars is characterised by a median of @xmath142myr , with about @xmath143 of the stars being younger than @xmath2myr and an equal number older than @xmath4myr . hereafter we will refer to these two groups , comprising 415 objects each , as `` younger '' and `` older '' pms stars , respectively . note that , with a typical age uncertainty not exceeding a factor of 2 , these two groups are well separated in age , since the former has a median age of @xmath10myr and the latter @xmath144myr . interestingly , also their projected spatial density distributions are very different . they are shown in figure[fig10 ] by contour lines of different colour , with logarithmic scaling , plotted over an image of the field in the h@xmath1 band . the contour plots have been derived after smoothing the distribution with a gaussian beam with size @xmath145 or @xmath43pc , as indicated by the circle in the lower left corner of the figure . the lowest contour level corresponds to a local density of pms stars twice as high as the average pms stars density over the entire field . the step between levels corresponds to a factor of @xmath146 . there is a pronounced difference in the spatial distribution of younger and older pms stars . the former are concentrated near the centre of the r136 cluster , where they form a density plateau , while older pms stars occupy preferentially the region to the east of r136 and are remarkably absent from the cluster centre . since these stars have a rather uniform distribution across the field , we should expect to find them also near the location of the young r136 cluster , contrary to what we observe . furthermore , with a median age of @xmath144myr , these stars are considerably older than the @xmath10myr old members of r136 , so we should not expect any spatial relationship ( either a correlation or anti - correlation ) between the distributions of the two types of objects , unless something else related to the younger population prevents us from detecting older pms stars near the cluster centre . photometric incompleteness due to the young massive stars could seem an obvious culprit , since the younger pms stars are on average brighter than the older objects . however , our analysis shows that the difference in the distribution of younger and older pms stars remains the same as shown in figure[fig10 ] even when we restrict the choice of objects to the same magnitude range ( e.g. @xmath147 ) . therefore , the apparent paucity of older pms stars near the centre is not caused by selection effects in their detection . a more likely explanation is the erosion of circumstellar discs via photo - evaporation caused by the far - ultraviolet ( fuv ) radiation of the young massive members of r136 . if the discs of pms stars are disrupted , the accretion process dwindles and these objects would no longer be detectable through their h@xmath1 excess emission . to test this hypothesis , we have looked at how older pms stars of various h@xmath1 luminosity @xmath148 are distributed in the field . in figure[fig11 ] we show , as an example , all pms stars with ages in the range @xmath149myr ( 115 objects in total ) using different symbols according to their h@xmath1 luminosity . dots correspond to stars with @xmath150l@xmath151 , squares to @xmath152l@xmath151 , and triangles to intermediate values . these values have been selected in such a way to have an equal number of objects in each group . in the background we show as a reference a negative image of the field in the h@xmath1 band . the distribution of the three classes of objects is not random : stars with higher @xmath148 are typically closer to the centre of r136 and located in areas where the background has a higher emission , whereas stars with lower @xmath148 are further away and preferentially in regions where the background emission is low . although systematic differences in the mass of the three classes of objects could produce the observed distribution of @xmath148 , this can be excluded since the median mass of the three groups of stars is the same at @xmath153m@xmath6 . we can also exclude that this is an artefact of our photometry since the background is subtracted locally from each star ( see section3 ) and therefore the diffuse h@xmath1 nebular emission does not affect the intrinsic h@xmath1 brightness of individual objects . however , a fraction of the h@xmath1 luminosity of the stars closest to the centre of r136 could in principle be due to fluorescence of their circumstellar discs caused by the very strong ionising radiation of the massive stars . it is , therefore , important to quantify this effect . according to massey & hunter ( 1998 ) , adopting the temperature calibration of vacca , garmany & shull ( 1996 ) , the total bolometric luminosity of the @xmath3 brightest and most massive stars in r136 is of order @xmath154l@xmath106 and most of them are of spectral type o4 or earlier . based on this information and following panagia ( 1973 ) , we have determined at which distance from the centre of r136 the effects of the ionising radiation impinging face - on on a circumstellar disc of radius 100au would contribute significantly to the h@xmath1 luminosity of its star . the median @xmath148 value of the pms stars shown in figure[fig11 ] is @xmath155l@xmath106 , so we have considered three cases of contamination , at approximately the 10% , 50% and 100% level . the dotted , dot - dashed and solid circles shown in figure[fig11 ] correspond respectively to the distances at which the contribution to the h@xmath1 luminosity due to fluorescence is @xmath156 and @xmath157l@xmath106 ( note that these distances are necessarily upper limits since they are projected on the plane of the sky and we have no information on the distribution of these objects along the line of sight ) . it is immediately clear that the effects of fluorescence can only be important for a handful of stars , leaving the largest majority of old pms objects in this field unaffected . the origin of the apparent correlation between their positions and h@xmath1 luminosities has , therefore , to be found elsewhere . a natural explanation would be that stars in regions of low emission , where the density of the gas is lower , such as those to the east of r136 , are much less shielded from the radiation of massive stars than objects in denser regions , such as those to the north and west of r136 . therefore , their discs have been exposed to photo - evaporation for a longer time and their h@xmath1 luminosity is today further reduced . in support of this hypothesis , the photometry of all stars enclosed in the low - background region resembling a `` christmas tree '' and centered at ( @xmath158 ) , which is better seen in figure[fig0 ] , is consistent with a very low extinction value , close to the @xmath44 indicated by fitzpatrick & savage ( 1984 ) as the contribution of the milky way to the intervening absorption along the line of sight . furthermore , this region is characterised by very low emission at ir ( e.g. indebetouw et al . 2009 ) and radio wavelengths ( e.g. johansson et al . 1998 ; rubio et al . 1998 ) , confirming that it is devoid of both dust and gas . the region also corresponds with a high - velocity structure seen by chu & kennicutt ( 1994 ) in their detailed h@xmath1 echelle study of the kinematics of 30dor . these authors find a bright redshifted knot @xmath159 east of r136 , with a velocity offset of @xmath160 km s@xmath130 and very low emission . the knot is part of a fast expanding shell to the east of the cluster that correlates well with a region of diffuse x - ray emission seen in images obtained with the _ einstein _ satellite . these authors conclude that both the high - velocity features and the x - ray emission are related to high - velocity shocks from fast stellar winds and supernovae . this picture is supported by the later study of 30dor by townsley et al . ( 2006 ) with the _ chandra x - ray observatory_. their observations reveal rather strong diffuse emission in the area of the `` christmas tree '' ( their region 6 , coincident with the east fast shell of chu & kennicutt 1994 ) with an absorption - corrected x - ray surface brightness of @xmath161erg s@xmath130 pc@xmath162 in the @xmath163kev band . a spectral fit to this emission shows a soft thermal plasma with @xmath164kev ( townsley et al . therefore , in such an evacuated region , the discs of pms stars must be much more exposed to photo - evaporation . conversely , as discussed in section4 , extinction towards the young massive stars at the centre of r136 is both higher and highly variable , indicating a much denser environment where gas and dust can intercept a significant fraction of the uv radiation from the massive central stars , thereby reducing the efficiency of the photo - evaporation process . indeed , most of the pms stars with @xmath165l@xmath106 in figure[fig11 ] are in regions of significant @xmath166co@xmath167 emission , suggesting a high density of molecular gas , and the column density in hi in front of r136 is known to be very high ( @xmath168 cm@xmath162 ; de boer , koornneef & savage 1980 ) . thus , although this picture is still necessarily qualitative , it provides a plausible explanation of the observed distribution of h@xmath1 luminosities of older pms stars across the field via the effects of photo - evaporation . these effects have been discussed by de marchi et al . ( 2010 ) in the field of sn1987a . in that environment , located @xmath170 or 300 pc sw of 30dor , the pms stars around the hottest massive young stars are both less numerous and fainter in h@xmath1 emission , suggesting that their circumstellar discs have been eroded more efficiently by enhanced photo - evaporation . unlike the relatively simple case of the sn1987a field where little gas is present , the interstellar medium in 30 dor is known to be much denser and highly fragmented , with considerable density variations across the field ( e.g. poglitsch et al . 1995 ) . from the h@xmath1 echelle study mentioned above , chu & kennicutt ( 1994 ) conclude that the kinematics of 30dor is dominated by a large number of expanding structures , over scales of 2 20pc and with expansion velocities of 100 300 km s@xmath130 and kinetic energies of @xmath171erg . these structures are probably associated with supernova remnants embedded in supershells produced by stellar winds and supernovae explosions . these processes can release a large amount of kinetic energy into the surrounding environment , and as such they could in principle contribute to the dissipation of circumstellar discs , adding to the effects of photo - evaporation . to better understand this , it is useful to calculate the amount of kinetic energy possibly deposited on such a disc by a nearby supernova explosion . we will assume hereafter a total energy release of @xmath172foe @xmath173erg per supernova explosion , a circumstellar radius @xmath174au around a pms star located at a distance of @xmath175pc from the supernova . the maximum fraction of energy deposited on such a disc hit face - on by the blast can be written as @xmath176 and amounts to @xmath177erg for the specific parameters assumed here . the motion that this energy release can impart onto the material of the disc depends on the total mass and size of the disc and hence on its density , which in turn could depend e.g. on the radial location . in the simplified case of a homogeneous disc of mass @xmath178 that we express as a fraction @xmath179 of the total stellar mass @xmath180 , i.e. @xmath181 , the velocity @xmath182 imparted by the ejecta to the disc material can be expressed as : @xmath183^{-1 } \ , \bigg [ \frac{r}{100 \ , { \rm au } } \bigg ] \ , \left [ \phi\ , \frac{m}{{\rm m}_\odot } \right]^{-1/2 } \ , { \rm km~s}^{-1}.\ ] ] de marchi et al . ( 2011 ) have shown that stars in the magellanic clouds accrete a substantial fraction of their total mass during the pms phase , particularly at low masses , so for an order - of - magnitude calculation it is not unreasonable to assume @xmath184@xmath185 . we can see in this way that for a star with @xmath186m@xmath6at a distance of 10pc , the supernova ejecta hitting the disc face - on would impart a motion to its material with a velocity of @xmath43 km s@xmath130 . this value is about a factor of 5 smaller than the escape velocity at the edge of the disc for the typical pms stars that we detect in the `` christmas tree '' ( median mass @xmath187m@xmath6 ) . for a disc seen under a smaller solid angle , the effect would be proportionally smaller . on the other hand , less massive discs around less massive stars located closer to the supernova would obviously experience a much stronger effect . for instance for a star of mass @xmath188m@xmath6at a distance of 1pc from the supernova , the impulse received by the disc material would be sufficient to exceed the escape velocity at @xmath189au . this could significanly affect or possibly even stop the accretion process , eventually limiting the final mass of the star . on the other hand , with an average surface density of @xmath190pms stars per pc@xmath191 , only a very small fraction of the discs around objects in this field would be severely affected by any one supernova explosion . in summary , it is clear that the interplay between shocks and photo - evaporation effects due to the massive members of r136 can have important consequences on disc erosion , potentially affecting the formation of low - mass stars in these regions . however , without more specific kinematical information for individual objects , it remains difficult to quantify the expected effects on the circumstellar discs of pms stars using photometry alone . for a better understanding of this complex region and a more quantitative characterisation of the differences between the regions preferentially occupied by older pms stars with high and low @xmath148 , we may have to await high spectral and spatial - resolution spectroscopic observations to obtain a map of the amount and kinematics of the gas in the interstellar medium along the lines of sight towards these objects . finally , we briefly address the implications of our findings for the current understanding of whether and how different generations of stars in 30 dor are causally connected . walborn & blades ( 1987 ) and walborn ( 1991 ) reported three early o stars embedded in dense nebular knots to the north and west of r136 and suggested that these objects could belong to a younger generation , triggered by the energy released by r136 . using ground - based spectral classification of a large number of ob stars in the 30 dor nebula , walborn & blades ( 1997 ) studied the ages and spatial distribution of these objects , discovering an additional eight early o stars embedded in dense nebular knots . from a morphological analysis of these regions , they concluded that 30 dor has a two - stage starburst structure in which the energetic activity of the @xmath90myr old r136 has triggered the formation of a younger ( @xmath192myr ) generation of stars at a typical projected distance of @xmath193pc , inside the dense molecular clouds that surround r136 to the northeast and west . later ir observations with nicmos ( walborn et al . 1999 ; brandner et al . 2001 ) resolved many of these knots into many new ir sources , including multiple systems , clusters , and nebular structures , indicating active star formation . from mainly morphological considerations in this and other galactic star forming regions , walborn et al . ( 1999 ; see also walborn 2002 ) suggested that this mode of two - stage starburst , with generations separated by @xmath10myr , is ubiquitous . they concluded that in 30 dor the first generation of stars , still present , is now triggering the birth of the second , peripheral generation of very massive stars , which in a few million years will be the only one left , after the most massive stars in the core of r136 have disappeared . these authors predict 30 dor to become a giant shell h ii region like n11 and ngc 604 , with its most massive stars around the periphery . our discovery of a considerable spread in the ages of pms stars in this region , with the younger generation confined to the cluster s centre and older objects uniformly distributed across the field ( see figure[fig10 ] ) , raises some questions as to the validity of this picture at least as regards the formation of low - mass stars triggered by older ( massive ) objects in their vicinities . for instance , if we compare the projected distribution of pms stars with ages of less than 2myr with that of objects in the age - range @xmath194myr we see that they have the same centre , with the former slightly more concentrated , rather than distributed in the periphery of the latter as suggested in walborn s ( 2002 ) triggered massive star formation scenario . as already shown in figure[fig10 ] , the stars around the periphery of r136 are systematically older and not younger than the members of r136 itself . the same conclusion had been reached by selman et al . ( 1999 ) from a spectroscopic study of the massive stars ( @xmath195m@xmath6 ) in these regions . our findings suggest that if causal effects are present between different generations of stars , their interpretation can not rely only on the relative ages and projected distributions of the objects , but must consider proper kinematical and possibly dynamical information . while it is undeniable that we are seeing a case of sequential star formation , in the sense that there are separate generations of stars over time , no clear signs of causal effects are seen . therefore , although the concept of triggered star formation may well be valid , its relevance in the case of 30 dor has yet to be demonstrated . we have studied the properties of the stellar populations in the central regions of the 30dor cluster in the lmc using observations obtained with the wfc3 camera on board the hst in the @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath19 bands . the main results of this work can be summarised as follows . 1 . our photometry delivers the deepest cmd so far obtained for this cluster , reaching down to @xmath196 or about 3 mag deeper than previous hst observations , and reveals for the first time a prominent lower ms fainter than @xmath33 . we attribute this feature to a considerably older stellar population than the @xmath34myr old stars associated with r136 . the cmd shows also a large number of objects in the range @xmath35 that appear brighter than the lower ms and that are consistent with , but extend much deeper than , the population of pms stars detected and studied by sirianni et al . ( 2000 ) and andersen et al . the observations also reveal the presence of considerable differential extinction across the field . we quantify the total extinction towards massive ms stars younger than @xmath34myr to be in the range @xmath197 ( respectively the 17% and 83% levels ) with a median value of @xmath49 . we show that these stars can be used to derive a statistical reddening correction also for stars in their vicinities , if they have a similar age and spatial distribution . however , this is not the case for older stars , which show a broader reddening distribution starting already at @xmath44 ( corresponding to the contribution of the milky way along the line of sight towards 30dor ) . a proper correction for extinction , therefore , requires at least an approximate knowledge of the age of the stars , which is not possible for all objects in the cmd . 3 . in order to distinguish relatively young objects from older stars , we looked for stars with h@xmath1 excess emission , since this feature identifies candidate pms stars , and we studied their distribution both across the field and in the cmd . younger pms stars follow the spatial distribution of massive stars and this allows us to correct them for reddening individually , using the extinction information derived for the massive objects . on the other hand , older pms objects are uniformly distributed over the field and appear to be systematically less reddened than younger pms stars . we derive for them an average extinction correction of @xmath82 . 4 . reddening correction allows us to proceed to a more accurate identification of bona - fide pm stars . we searched for stars with @xmath77 colour exceeding that of normal stars at the @xmath108 level or more and with @xmath198 ( or @xmath199 for stars with @xmath200k ) , in order to avoid contamination by stars with chromospheric activity or by the winds of be stars . a total of 1159 objects satisfy these stringent conditions and we take them as bona - fide pms stars . we derived the age of pms stars through the comparison with theoretical pms isochrones for metallicity @xmath39 , as appropriate for the lmc . about @xmath201 of these objects are younger than 4myr and an equal number are older than 12myr , indicating that star formation in this field has proceeded over a long time , although our age resolution does not allow us to discriminate between an extended episode and a series of short and frequent bursts . as regards the past 4myr , we obtain a lower limit to the star formation rate of @xmath129m@xmath6myr@xmath130 for objects in the range @xmath202m@xmath6 . we find a pronounced difference in the spatial distribution of younger ( @xmath203myr ) and older ( @xmath204myr ) pms stars . the former are concentrated near the centre of r136 , whereas older pms objects are mostly located to the east of it and are remarkably absent near the cluster centre . this effect , which is not due to photometric incompleteness , is in general consistent with the photo - evaporation of the circumstellar discs of older stars caused by the uv radiation of the massive members of r136 . however , not all older pms stars are affected in the same way , since some are in regions where the high density of the molecular gas can reduce the efficiency of the photo - evaporation process . our results show that several generations of stars are present in this field , since there are objects with ages ranging from less than 1 to over 30myr , although no clear signs of causal effects or of triggered star formation are seen . it appears , however , that the presence of the massive r136 cluster is sculpting the region and affecting low - mass neighbouring objects through the effects of photo - evaporation . we thank an anonymous referee , whose suggestions have helped us to improve the presentation of this work . this paper is based on early release science observations made by the wfc3 scientific oversight committee . we are grateful to the director of the space telescope science institute for awarding director s discretionary time for this programme . fp is grateful to the space science department of esa for their hospitality via the visitor programme . np acknowledges partial support by hst nasa grants go11547.06a and go11653.12a , and stsci ddrf grant d0001.82435 . zinnecker , h. , andersen , m. , brandl , b. , brandner , w. , hunter , d. , larson , r. , mccaughrean , m. , meylan , g. , moneti , a. 2002 , in `` extragalactic star clusters , '' iau symp . 207 , eds . d. geisler , e. grebel , d. minniti ( san francisco : asp ) , 531 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: scale invariance is a well - known symmetry @xcite that has been studied in many physical contexts . a strong physical motivation for incorporating scale symmetry in fundamental physics @xcite@xcite@xcite comes from low energy particle physics . namely , the _ classical _ action of the standard model is already consistent with scale symmetry if the higgs mass term is dropped . this invites the idea , which many have considered , that the mass term may emerge from the vacuum expectation value of an additional scalar field @xmath0 in a fully scale invariant theory . another striking hint of scale symmetry occurs on cosmic scales : the ( nearly ) scale invariant spectrum of primordial fluctuations , as measured by wmap and the planck satellite @xcite . this amazing simplicity seems to cry out for an explanation in terms of a fundamental symmetry in nature , rather than as just the outcome of a scalar field evolving along some particular potential given some particular initial condition . in this paper , we consider the incorporation into fundamental physics of _ local conformal symmetry _ ( or weyl - symmetry ) : that is , classical local scaling symmetry in an action that includes the standard model coupled to gravity . a new result of our approach @xcite-@xcite is that using conformal symmetry we are able to solve the classical frw equations across big crunch - big bang transitions , thus obtaining the _ full set of geodesically complete cosmological solutions _ of our conformal standard model given in eq.([action1 ] ) . this follows from the new properties of the standard theory whose couplings to gravity includes _ all patches of field space _ that are required for geodesic completeness of all cosmological solutions for all times and any set of initial conditions ) as described in section ( [ confcosm ] ) . ] . the models we describe contain no mass scales no gravitational constant , no mass for the higgs field , no cosmological constant and no mass parameters for the quarks , leptons or gauge bosons . all of these are prevented by the local conformal symmetry combined with the su@xmath1su@xmath2u@xmath3 gauge symmetry of the standard model . there is only one source of mass which follows from gauge fixing ( in some sense spontaneously breaking ) the weyl symmetry through a scalar field which is a singlet under su@xmath1su@xmath4u@xmath3 or a combination of both su@xmath5su@xmath6u@xmath3 singlet and non - singlet fields , depending on the choice of gauge . this source , which is associated with the emergence of the planck scale , drives the spontaneous breakdown of the electroweak symmetry , which in turn generates the other known masses of elementary constituents , with ratios of masses related to dimensionless constants . our approach to conformal symmetry has new features with significant physical consequences that were not considered before . while we shall work in @xmath7 dimensions throughout , there is a close connection with field theories and gravity or supergravity in @xmath8 dimensions in the context of 2t - physics @xcite-@xcite as will be pointed out occasionally throughout this paper . stated directly in @xmath7 dimensions , some of the novel features and their consequences are as follows : * in section ( [ general ] ) we provide the most general form of coupling gravity or supergravity with any number of scalar fields , fermions and gauge bosons , while maintaining local conformal symmetry . only a specialized form of our general formalism in section ( [ general ] ) coincides with previously known methods for local conformal symmetry . we find that in a gauge symmetric theory , if there is only one physical scalar field ( for example , the higgs field ) _ after all gauge choices are exhausted _ , then there is a unique gauge - invariant and weyl - invariant form for the lagrangian representing the geodesically complete coupling to gravity . * the minimal , realistic and locally conformal standard model coupled to gravity includes the higgs doublet @xmath9 and an additional su@xmath10su@xmath11u@xmath12 singlet @xmath0 . taking into account all of the local symmetry , there is a single physical scalar field identifiable with the observed higgs field . therefore , according to the statement above , this is a geodesically complete conformal standad model provided it utilizes our unique coupling to gravity as shown in eq.([action1 ] ) and as proven in section ( [ generalgrav ] ) . the relative minus sign between @xmath13 and @xmath14 that appears in this action is obligatory and is related to geodesic completeness as will be explained later . the unique structure of local scale symmetry has led to full analytic control of cosmological solutions and , in certain limits , enabled us to obtain the complete set of homogeneous cosmological solutions for all possible initial conditions of the relevant fields . this is discussed in section ( [ confcosm ] ) . * in a particular gauge of the spontaneously broken local scale symmetry ( called @xmath15-gauge ) we recover the usual renormalizable field theory of the standard model in the flat space limit , including a mass scale for the higgs . in this gauge , low energy physics of our model coincides with the familiar form of the standard model unless more fields are included beyond those already observed , such as right handed neutrinos and dark matter which can be accommodated consistently with conformal symmetry following our methods . thus , low energy physics at lhc scales is not sensitive to the conformal structures suggested in our approach . * on the other hand , physics at cosmological scales can be quite sensitive to the conformal structures discussed in this paper as becomes apparent in certain gauges . in section ( [ confcosm ] ) we outline some of the phenomena that follow from our unique conformal coupling . in the minimal conformal standard model of eq.([action1 ] ) , guided by our analytic solutions ( supplemented , where necessary , with numerical methods ) , we propose a _ cyclic conformal cosmology _ driven only by the higgs field with no recourse to other scalar fields such as an inflaton . the higgs - driven cosmological scenario we propose is strongly motivated by the metastability of the higgs vacuum as implied by the renormalization - group flow of the minimal standard model to large higgs vev , with its parameters fixed by the lhc measurements @xcite . the main discussion in this paper is at the classical field theory level , but it is worth commenting briefly on the important question of quantum corrections . there are two enormous hierarchies in the standard model coupled to gravity : the weak scale is around @xmath16 and the dark energy scale is around @xmath17 of the planck scale . it is hard to understand how such tiny numbers enter fundamental physics , and why quantum corrections would not spoil these fine tunings . in both cases , conformal symmetry has been suggested as a solution . we will not explore this here in any detail , except to note that the stability of such hierarchies in the perturbative standard model , which is what attracted attention in the past for the higgs field , should not be in jeopardy from quantum corrections since dimensionless constants in a conformal theory are logarithmically divergent as opposed to the quadratic divergence of a bare higgs mass term . to fully grasp how this can work at the quantum level for fundamental scalars and in particular the higgs , requires a better understanding of how to perform regularization and renormalization consistent with local conformal symmetry in @xmath7 dimensions . elaborating on earlier suggestions @xcite@xcite@xcite , there has been recent progress @xcite in developing a renormalization theory consistent with weyl symmetry . according to this new work , local conformal symmetry remains as a valid symmetry at the quantum level as anticipated in @xcite . the local scale invariance survives quantization even though there is a trace anomaly in the stress tensor of the matter sector of the theory ; this point that caused confusion in the past is clarified by noting that the trace of the _ matter _ stress tensor is _ distinct _ from the generator of local scale transformations that includes the additional fields , such as @xmath18 that implement and establish the local conformal symmetry . in passing , we note that if @xmath7 dimensional conformal symmetry is treated consistently within 2t - physics in @xmath8 dimensions , then scale ( dilation ) symmetry is a part of a _ linearly realized _ so@xmath19 in the flat limit which is presumably not anomalous just as its lorentz subgroup so@xmath20 in @xmath7 dimensions can not be anomalous . this quantum aspect of 2t - physics is under investigation directly in @xmath8 dimensions and this is expected to shed additional light on these issues . a plan of this paper is as follows . in sec . ii , we will review and expand on the motivation for global and local symmetry and show how to recast ( or lift ) the standard model plus gravity into a locally gauge invariant , weyl- symmetric theory by adding new fields and , at the same time , introducing compensating gauge symmetries , in such a way that the theory is _ both weyl invariant and geodesically complete_. the gauge fixed version of this theory reverts back to the familiar minimal form of the standard model at low energies wherever gravity is negligible . however , in regions of spacetime where strong gravity effects are important , such as in cosmology , especially close to the singularity , the geodesically complete weyl lifted version plays a crucial role , as described in sec . in section iii , following @xcite we present a general form for a lagrangian consistent with weyl symmetry for any number of scalar fields . we argue that , if the weyl invariant theory is equivalent to having only a single physical scalar field after gauge fixing ( like the physical higgs ) , then by field redefinitions it is always possible to recast the theory into our version given in eq.([action1 ] ) which includes all patches in field space so as to insure geodesic completeness . as another example of our general formalism , we lift the bezrukov - shaposhnikov higgs inflation model @xcite to a fully scale invariant model , making it logically and physically consistent . based on our formalism for constructing general weyl - invariant actions , we show that the model is not unique . in fact , there are many single - field cosmological higgs models with the same properties , all consistent with conformal symmetry and producing the same inflationary outcome . however , this inflationary scenario is not geodesically complete , furthermore , in view of our complete set of solutions , it is extremely unlikely . in sec . iv , we turn more generally to cosmology . we explain that a weyl - lifted theory can resolve the singularity and enable the geodesic completion of cosmological spacetimes , while also indicating the presence of new phenomena . our previous work in @xcite-@xcite elaborated in some detail on the properties of geodesically complete cosmological analytic solutions in the context of solvable examples of what was supposed to be toy models . however the same models now re - appear in our conformal standard model and hence our previous solutions are now the full set of cosmological solutions for all initial conditions of the familiar standard model . in particular , we point out a model independent attractor mechanism discovered in @xcite that may help to determine the likely initial conditions of our universe just after the big bang . the weyl - invariant formulation also provides a natural framework for incorporating cyclic cosmology @xcite driven only by the higgs field as introduced . in the case that the higgs field is metastable , the higgs inflation model is inoperable , but the minimal single - higgs model is naturally compatible with the cyclic picture @xcite . in general , the weyl - invariant approach also hints at the intriguing possibility that the minimal , electroweak higgs may have played a central role in cosmic evolution as explained in detail in @xcite . there is a deep connection between the ideas presented in this paper and theories in @xmath21-space and @xmath22-time dimensions . many of the ideas discussed here for a global or local conformally symmetric theory emerged progressively from developing the @xmath8 dimensional formalism since 1996 ( for a recent overview see @xcite ) , and then for the standard model as given in @xcite , for gravity in @xcite , for susy in @xcite and supergravity in @xcite . the formulation given in @xcite , with many scalars coupled to gravity and supergravity in @xmath8 and @xmath7 dimensions was the precursor of the general formalism presented in section iii , while the simplest specific models were analyzed cosmologically in some detail in @xcite-@xcite . there are some recent similar examples @xcite that overlap with our conformal symmetry vision in @xmath7 dimensions ; these seem to be oblivious to our previous publications that introduced at an earlier stage the crucial conformal structures with restrictions on scalars in @xmath7 dimensions as predictions from 2t - physics @xcite . the @xmath8 theory has more predictions of hidden symmetries and dualities in @xmath7 dimensions which are mainly understood in classical and quantum mechanical contexts @xcite and are also partially developed in field theory @xcite ; these go well beyond conformal symmetry in their implications for unification and the meaning of spacetime and are bound to play an interesting role in future progress . we emphasize that , despite the name , the physics content in the 2t - physics formalism in @xmath23 dimensions is same as the physics content in the standard 1t - physics formalism in @xmath24 dimensions except that 2 t physics provides a holographic perspective and , due to a much larger set of gauge symmetries , naturally makes predictions that are not anticipated in 1t - physics . these additional gauge symmetries are in phase space rather than position space , and can be realized only if the formalism is developed with two times . nevertheless , the gauge invariant sector of 2t - physics is equivalent to a causal 1-time spacetime without any ghosts . in this paper , we will stick to @xmath7 dimensions , advocating a coherent overall picture of a conformally invariant formulation of fundamental physics and cosmology . however , we will occasionally remind the reader that these outcomes naturally follow from @xmath8 dimensions with appropriate ( but unusual ) gauge symmetries . in this section , we will describe the motivation for and construction of simple theories with global and local scale invariance . an important application is the lift of the standard model plus gravity into a weyl- invariant theory that is also geodesically complete . we begin by examining a scale invariant extension of the standard model of particles and forces . for example consider the usual standard model with all the usual fields , including the doublet higgs field @xmath9 coupled to gauge bosons and fermions , but add also an su@xmath25u@xmath3 singlet @xmath0 ( plus right handed neutrinos and dark matter candidates ) , and take the following purely quartic renormalizable potential involving only the minimal set of scalar fields@xmath26 this model , discussed at some length in section vi of @xcite , is the minimal extension of the standard model that is fully scale invariant at the classical level , globally . see also @xcite-@xcite that use a similar field , and the different approach that also adds a weyl vector field @xcite leading to different physical consequences . the field @xmath0 , which we call the dilaton , absorbs the scale transformations and is analogous to the dilaton in string theory . in the current context , it has a number of interesting features : due to su@xmath1su@xmath25u@xmath3 gauge symmetry , the singlet @xmath13 is prevented from coupling to all other fields of the standard model - except for the additional right handed singlet neutrinos or dark matter candidates . these features of @xmath18 that prevent it from interacting substantially with standard visible matter except via the higgs in eq.([potential ] ) , suggest naturally that @xmath13 itself could be a candidate for dark matter @xcite . the only parameters associated with @xmath18 that are relevant for our discussion , are @xmath27 and @xmath28 . for positive @xmath29 the minimum of this potential occurs at @xmath30 accordingly , the vacuum expectation value of the higgs may fluctuate throughout spacetime , depending on the dynamics of @xmath31 without breaking the scale symmetry . however , if for some reason ( e.g. driven by quantum fluctuations or gravitational interactions ) @xmath13 develops a vacuum expectation value @xmath32 which is constant in some region of spacetime , then the higgs is dominated by a constant vacuum expectation value @xmath33 with @xmath34 fixed by observation to be approximately @xmath35 the higgs vacuum @xmath36 provides the source of mass for all known elementary forms of matter , quarks , leptons , and gauge bosons ( while @xmath32 may be the source of majorana mass for neutrinos ) . the observation at the lhc of the higgs particle , which is just the small fluctuation on top of the vacuum value @xmath34 , has by now solidified the view that this is how nature works in our region of the universe , at least up to the energy scales of the lhc . fig . 1 illustrates how the higgs field slowly relaxes to the spontaneously broken symmetry vacuum described by eq . ( [ v - value ] ) beginning from large oscillations shortly after the big bang . here , as is the case throughout the paper , the solutions are in the limit of negligible gauge and top quark mass coupling so that the higgs evolution is described by classical equations of motion . this time - dependent behavior of the higgs is driven by the evolution of the field @xmath13 , as anticipated in @xcite for this simple model . in fact , it is realized as the generic solution for all homogeneous cosmological solutions if the higgs vacuum is stable . there are other interesting theoretical structures worth noting about this scale invariant setup . instead of supersymmetry , conformal symmetry may explain the stability of the hierarchy between the low mass scale of @xmath37 versus the planck scale of @xmath38 gev , as suggested in @xcite . the conformal protection of the hierarchy is not as clear - cut as susy s protection and requires better understanding of regularization and renormalization techniques consistent with conformal symmetry as outlined in the introduction . what about the dilaton ( fluctuations in @xmath13 ) that emerges in the broken scale invariance scenario above ? at least from the perspective of only the standard model , the dilaton is a massless goldstone boson due to the spontaneous breaking of the global scale invariance . as discussed in some detail in section vi of @xcite , the original doublet field @xmath14 is the only field coupled to known matter , while @xmath13 is decoupled . however , after the spontaneous breaking , @xmath14 must be rewritten as a mixture of the mass eigenstates of the model , which include the observed massive higgs particle and the massless dilaton ( or maybe low - mass dilaton if the scale symmetry is broken by some source ) . the mixing strength is controlled by the dimensionless parameter @xmath39 that appears in eq.([v - value ] ) . therefore , through this mixing , the ( pseudo- ) goldstone dilaton must couple to all matter , just like the higgs does , namely with a coupling given by the mixing angle @xmath40 times the mass of the particle divided by @xmath34 . the largest coupling is to the top quark . if @xmath32 is much larger than @xmath41 gev@xmath42 it is possible for the dilaton to hide from accelerator experiments due to the weak coupling of @xmath27 in eq.([alpha ] ) . such a ( pseudo ) goldstone boson has many other observable consequences , including a long range force that competes with gravity and contributions to quantum effects as a virtual particle in feynman loop diagrams . if such an additional massless ( or low mass scalar ) is observed in experiments , it would be strong evidence in favor of the scale invariant scenario . however , if it is not observed , this could be interpreted merely as setting a lower limit on the scale @xmath43 eventually it must be understood what sets the scale @xmath32 . the model as presented above has no mechanism at the classical level to set the scale @xmath32 ; its equations of motion are self consistent at the minimum of the potential , @xmath44 only if @xmath45 @xcite ; then @xmath32 remains undetermined due to a flat direction in the remaining term in the potential ( [ potential ] ) . the value for @xmath32 would then be obtained phenomenologically from experiment , without a theoretical explanation . quantum corrections , such as those discussed in @xcite , may alleviate this problem by removing the flat direction . however , if the quantum corrections are small , there is the danger that @xmath32 would be so low that it is not possible to obtain the small value of @xmath27 in eq.([alpha ] ) required to protect the dilaton from current experimental limits . since at present there is no sign of the dilaton in low energy physics , suppose it does not exist at all as a degree of freedom . is this incompatible with the idea that conformal symmetry underlies fundamental physics ? not at all , because any possible phenomenological problems associated with a goldstone boson fluctuation of @xmath13 can be overcome if the scaling symmetry is a _ local _ gauge symmetry , known as the weyl symmetry . then the massless fluctuations of the dilaton can be eliminated by fixing a unitary gaugeu@xmath3 scalar field as part of the general theory that we will discuss in section ( [ generalgrav ] ) . but for simplicity in this section we will first concentrate on the minimal model that contains only the confirmed observed degrees of freedom up to now , thus allowing the fluctuations of a single @xmath13 to be eliminated by a gauge symmetry in this minimal model . ] . the standard model decoupled from gravity has no local scale symmetry that could remove a goldstone dilaton . but such a gauge symmetry can in fact be successfully incorporated as part of the standard model provided it is coupled to gravity in the right way . coupling the standard model to einstein gravity in the conventional way makes no sense because the dimensionful newton constant explicitly breaks scale invariance . if scale invariance is already broken in one sector of the theory , then there is no rationale for requiring that it be a good symmetry in another part of the theory . at best , it would occur as an accidental symmetry of low energy physics and only when gravity is negligible . this is not the scenario we have in mind ; we argue for a fully scale invariant approach to all physics , a natural outcome of the larger gauge symmetries in @xmath8 dimensions , as formulated in 2t - physics . happily , the idea of an underlying @xmath8 dimensions with appropriate extra gauge symmetry fits all known physics in @xmath7 dimensions , from dynamics of particles and field theory @xcite-@xcite all the way to supergravity @xcite . so , consistency with this larger underlying structure is well motivated . in fact , there is a locally scale invariant field theory in @xmath7 dimensions , compatible with 2t - physics in @xmath8 dimensions , that couples the standard model and gravity with no dimensionful constants . we do not mean conformal gravity which has ghost problems , but rather the non - minimal conformal coupling of the curvature @xmath46 to scalar fields @xcite which is invariant under weyl transformations as a gauge symmetry . in the next section we will discuss a generalized weyl invariant coupling with many scalar fields also predicted by 2t - physics , but in this section we begin with the well known method of conformally coupled scalars , as follows @xcite@xcite,@xmath47 these two terms form an invariant unit ( up to a total derivative ) under _ local _ scale transformations , @xmath48 , with a local parameter @xmath49 when there are more scalar fields , the most general way of achieving local conformal symmetry is discussed in section ( [ genweyl ] ) . however , when there is only one additional scalar field beyond @xmath18 which is in a single representation of a yang - mills gauge group , there is a unique way to also achieve geodesic completeness as explained in more detail in sections ( [ generalgrav],[confcosm ] ) . hence , _ for geodesic completeness _ we require that not only the field @xmath18 but also the doublet higgs field be a set of conformally coupled scalars consistent with su@xmath2u@xmath3 . namely using the unit @xmath50 which is also locally invariant ( up to a total derivative ) , we can lift the globally scale invariant standard model of the last section into a locally invariant one , while also being coupled to gravity in a gedesically complete theory . all other terms present in the usual standard model , namely all fermion , gauge boson and yukawa terms , when minimally coupled to gravity are already automatically invariant under the local weyl symmetry . hence a _ weyl invariant _ action @xmath51 that describes the coupling of gravity and the standard model is given by @xmath52{c}\frac{1}{12}\left ( \phi^{2}-2h^{\dagger}h\right ) r\left ( g\right ) \\ + g^{\mu\nu}\left ( \frac{1}{2}\partial_{\mu}\phi\partial_{\nu}\phi - d_{\mu } h^{\dagger}d_{\nu}h\right ) \\ -\left ( \frac{\lambda}{4}\left ( h^{\dagger}h-\alpha^{2}\phi^{2}\right ) ^{2}+\frac{\lambda^{\prime}}{4}\phi^{4}\right ) \\ + l_{\text{sm}}\left ( \begin{array } [ c]{c}\text{{\small quarks , leptons , gauge bosons,}}\\ \text{{\small yukawa~couplings to~}}{\small h\&\phi,~}\text{{\small dark~matter.}}\end{array } \right ) \end{array } \right ] \label{action1}\ ] ] the only yukawa couplings of @xmath13 allowed by su@xmath5su@xmath6u@xmath3 are to the right handed neutrinos for which it becomes a source of mass . note the relative minus sign between @xmath13 and @xmath14 terms , which is required , as explained below . here @xmath53 is the well known standard model lagrangian minimally coupled to gravity , except for the higgs kinetic and potential terms , which are now modified and explicitly written out in the first three lines . this action is invariant under weyl rescaling with an arbitrary local parameter @xmath54 as follows@xmath55{c}g_{\mu\nu}\rightarrow\omega^{-2}g_{\mu\nu},~\phi\rightarrow\omega \phi,\;h\rightarrow\omega h,\;\\ \psi_{q , l}\rightarrow\omega^{3/2}\psi_{q , l},\;a_{\mu}^{\gamma , w , z , g}\rightarrow\omega^{0}a_{\mu}^{\gamma , w , z , g } , \end{array } \label{weylrescaling}\ ] ] where @xmath56 are the fermionic fields for quarks or leptons , and @xmath57 are the gauge fields for the photon , gluons , @xmath58 and @xmath59 note that the gauge bosons do not change under the weyl rescaling . we note that the lagrangian ( [ action1 ] ) is the one obtained in the second reference in @xcite from the @xmath8 version of the standard model @xcite@xcite coupled to 2t- gravity @xcite , by a method of gauge fixing and solving some kinematical equations associated with constraints related to the underlying gauge symmetries . in that approach we learned that the weyl symmetry is not an option in @xmath7 dimensions , it is a prediction of 2t - physics : the @xmath8 dimensional theory is not weyl invariant , but yet the local weyl symmetry in @xmath7 dimensions emerges as a remnant gauge symmetry associated with the general coordinate transformations as they act in the extra @xmath60 dimensions . so the weyl symmetry is a required symmetry in @xmath7 dimensions as predicted in the @xmath8 dimensional approach ; this symmetry carries information and imposes properties related to the extra @xmath60 space and time dimensions @xcite . the weyl gauge symmetry of the action in ( [ action1 ] ) does not allow any dimensionful constants : no mass term in the higgs potential , no einstein - hilbert term with its dimensionful newton constant , or any other mass terms . this is a very appealing starting point because it leads to the emergence of all dimensionful parameters from a single source . that source is the field @xmath0 that motivated this discussion in the previous section , and the only scale is then generated by gauge fixing @xmath13 to a constant for all spacetime @xmath61 in the gauge fixed version of the lagrangian where @xmath62 we can express the physically important dimensionful parameters , namely , the newton constant @xmath63 , the cosmological constant @xmath64 associated with dark energy , and the electro - weak scale @xmath34 , in terms of @xmath32 : @xmath65 since the field @xmath0 in this gauge ceases to be a degree of freedom altogether , the massless dilaton is absent and the potential problem with global scaling symmetry is avoided . nevertheless , there still is an underlying hidden conformal symmetry for the full theory . we can explain now why it is necessary to have the opposite signs for @xmath13 and @xmath14 in the first two lines of the action in eq.([action1 ] ) . the positive sign for @xmath13 is necessary in order to obtain a positive gravitational constant in ( [ dimensionfulconstants ] ) . however , conformal symmetry then forces the kinetic term for @xmath13 to have the wrong sign , so @xmath13 is a ghost . this can be seen to be a gauge artifact , though , since in a unitary gauge the ghost @xmath13 is fixed to a constant or expressed in terms of other degrees of freedom . this also explains why @xmath14 must have the opposite sign , since otherwise @xmath14 would be a real ghost . this relative sign has important consequences in cosmology as follows . in flat space @xmath66 where experiments such as those at the lhc are conducted , the lagrangian above becomes precisely the usual standard model , including the familiar tachyonic mass term for the higgs . furthermore , in weak gravitational fields , at low energies , the gravitational effect of the higgs field coupling to the curvature , @xmath67 is ignorable since @xmath14 ( order of @xmath68 gev ) is tiny compared to the planck scale ( @xmath6910@xmath70 gev ) . actually , the gravitational constant measured at low energies is corrected by the electroweak scale , namely @xmath71 @xmath72 instead of ( [ dimensionfulconstants ] ) , but in practice this is a negligible correction since @xmath73 so , at low energies there is no discernible difference between our weyl - lifted theory and the usual standard model . the practically isolated standard model appears as a renormalizable theory decoupled from gravity . however , in the cosmological context , the conformally coupled @xmath14 can and will be large at some stages in the evolution of the universe . working out the dynamics of cosmological evolution , it turns out that , for generic initial conditions , @xmath74 typically grows to large scales over cosmological times , hitting @xmath75 in the vicinity of a big bang or big crunch singularity . this behavior plays an essential role in cosmological evolution , as well as in the resolution of the singularity via geodesic completeness . in our conformal theory , the standard model is not isolated from gravity , and we posit that the higgs field can play a bigger role in nature than originally anticipated . we may take the higgs doublet in the unitary gauge of the su@xmath25u@xmath3 gauge symmetry @xmath76{c}0\\ \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}s\left ( x\right ) \end{array } \right ) . \label{unitary}\ ] ] the field @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the higgs field fluctuation on top of the electroweak vacuum , is then identified with the generic field @xmath79 that appeared in our cosmological papers @xcite-@xcite . the action for @xmath80 has the exact same form in those papers as here . thus , our previous analytical cosmological solutions can now be applied to investigate the cosmological properties of the higgs field . when the parameter @xmath27 vanishes , our previous work provides the full set of geodesically complete analytic cosmological solutions for all initial conditions of the relevant fields in the standard model coupled to gravity . the non - zero @xmath27 is then easily taken into account with numerical methods . this much analytic control over cosmological properties of a realistic theory is unprecedented . this became a very valuable tool that led us into a new cosmological scenario driven only by the higgs field , as outlined in section ( [ confcosm ] ) and completed in @xcite . the gauge symmetries derived from 2t - gravity and 2t - supergravity in @xmath8 dimensions lead to the general weyl invariant coupling described below for any number of scalar fields in @xmath7 dimensions @xcite . this generalizes the possible forms of conformally coupled scalar theories beyond those encompassed by eq.([confscalar ] ) and allows for richer possibilities for model building consistent with local scale invariance . we ignore the spinors and gauge bosons whose minimal couplings to gravity are already automatically weyl symmetric . we begin with gravity without supersymmetry . in the next subsection we will indicate the additional constraints that emerge in supergravity . we assume any number of _ real _ scalar fields @xmath81 labeled by the index @xmath82 if there are complex fields , we can extract their real and imaginary parts and treat those as part of the @xmath83 we introduce a weyl factor @xmath84 a sigma - model - type metric in field space @xmath85 and a potential @xmath86 the general lagrangian takes the form @xmath87 the results given in @xcite are the following constraints on these functions . * @xmath88 must be homogeneous of degree two , @xmath89 and @xmath90 must be homogeneous of degree four@xmath91 and @xmath92 must be homogeneous of degree zero@xmath93 * the following differential constraints must also be satisfied . these may be interpreted as homothety conditions on the geometry in field space@xmath94 the second and third equations follow from the first one and the homogeneity requirements . * physics requirements also include that @xmath95 can not have more than one negative eigenvalue because the local scale symmetry is just enough to remove only one negative norm ghost . however , if more gauge symmetry that can remove more ghosts is incorporated , then the number of negative eigenvalues can increase accordingly . the gauged r - symmetry in supergravity ( which is automatic in the @xmath8 approach ) is such an example . in @xcite these rules emerged from gauge symmetries in 2t- gravity . since weyl symmetry is an automatic outcome from @xmath8 dimensions , we can check that these same requirements follow directly in @xmath7 dimensions by imposing weyl symmetry on the general form in eq.([genweyl ] ) . as an example , it is easy to check that all these conditions are automatically satisfied by the action given in eq.([action1 ] ) , with one @xmath13 and four real fields in the doublet @xmath96 using the symbol @xmath97 as @xmath98 we write it in the form @xmath99 where @xmath100 is a flat minkowski metric in the 5-dimensional field space with a single negative eigenvalue - this reduces to a 2-dimensional @xmath101 in the unitary gauge of eq.([unitary ] ) since indeed there is only a single physical field @xmath102 . in our work @xcite-@xcite generally we let the potential @xmath103 to be an arbitrary function of its argument @xmath104 as allowed by the weyl symmetry conditions above . in eq.(1 ) we have a purely quartic renormalizable potential , @xmath105 . when quantum corrections are included , @xmath103 contains logarithmic corrections , but by re - examining the underlying symmetry , the effective quantum potential can again be rewritten in the form @xmath106 consistent with the local conformal symmetry . we use the quantum corrected potential in our discussion of higgs cosmology . next we give the general solution of the requirements above in a convenient parametrization for @xmath107 fields labelled with @xmath108 namely , @xmath109 where @xmath110 is distinguished , while @xmath111 with @xmath112 are all the other scalar fields . then the general solution to the conditions above for weyl gauge symmetry takes the following form @xmath113 where the ratio @xmath114 is gauge invariant . thus , after using the chain rule , @xmath115 the general weyl invariant action becomes @xmath116{c}\frac{1}{12}u\left ( \phi , s\right ) r\left ( g\right ) -v\left ( \phi , s\right ) \\ + \frac{1}{2}\left ( u - s^{i}\frac{\partial u}{\partial s^{i}}-s^{k}s^{l}g_{kl}\right ) \left ( \partial^{\mu}\ln\phi\right ) \left ( \partial_{\mu}\ln\phi\right ) \\ -\frac{1}{2}g_{ij}\left ( \partial^{\mu}s^{i}\partial_{\mu}s^{j}\right ) + \left ( 2g_{ij}s^{j}+\frac{\partial u}{\partial s^{i}}\right ) \partial^{\mu } s^{i}\partial_{\mu}\ln\phi \end{array } \right ) \label{weylgrav}\ ] ] with the @xmath117 in eqs.([sol - u]-[solg ] ) . it should be noted that @xmath118 are not determined by weyl symmetry alone . various other symmetries in a given model could restrict them . any choice consistent with additional symmetries is permitted in the construction of physical models . for example , the model in eq.([action1 ] ) has the su@xmath1su@xmath25u@xmath3 symmetry . in particular , local superconformal symmetry gives more severe restrictions by relating @xmath95 and @xmath119 from the beginning , as discussed below . as the number of scalar fields increases , the restrictions imposed by weyl symmetry become less severe . for example , an additional su@xmath120su@xmath6u@xmath3 gauge singlet field beyond @xmath13 that would be needed to reproduce the phenomenology of the dilaton - like singlet discussed in section ( [ gscaleinv ] ) can be included with slightly more freedom on its coupling parameters . keeping such possibilities in mind for more general phenomenological considerations , we the define the minimal model to include only the standard higgs doublet and the singlet @xmath13 as in the previous section . hence , for clarity we will write out the general weyl invariant lagrangian for the case of only the higgs doublet field @xmath14 plus @xmath121 this generalizes eq.([action1 ] ) , but we suppress the other fields in our discussion . furthermore , we will work directly with the gauge fixed version of the higgs field in eq.([unitary ] ) , so the higgs doublet is reduced to a single field @xmath79 as in ( [ unitary ] ) . in that case , from eqs.([sol - u]-[sol - g00 ] ) we obtain @xmath52{c}\frac{1}{12}\phi^{2}u\left ( s/\phi\right ) r\left ( g\right ) -\phi ^{4}f\left ( s/\phi\right ) \\ + g^{\mu\nu}\left ( \begin{array } [ c]{c}\frac{1}{2}\left ( u-\frac{s}{\phi}u^{\prime}-\frac{s^{2}}{\phi^{2}}\bar { g}\right ) \partial_{\mu}\phi\partial_{\nu}\phi\\ -\frac{1}{2}\bar{g}\partial_{\mu}s\partial_{\nu}s+\left ( u^{\prime}+2\frac { s}{\phi}\bar{g}\right ) \partial_{\mu}\phi\partial_{\nu}s \end{array } \right ) \end{array } \right ] \label{action2}\ ] ] where @xmath122 reduces to @xmath123 for the single field . generally , @xmath124 in eq.([action2 ] ) are three arbitrary functions of the higgs field , @xmath125 which may be used for model building . as an example , if we take @xmath126 and @xmath127 we obtain a relatively simple kinetic term with an arbitrary potential@xmath52{c}\frac{1}{12}\left ( \phi^{2}+\xi s^{2}\right ) r\left ( g\right ) -\phi ^{4}f\left ( s/\phi\right ) \\ + \left ( \begin{array } [ c]{c}\frac{1}{2}\left ( 1-\frac{s^{2}}{\phi^{2}}\left ( 1+\xi\right ) \right ) \partial_{\mu}\phi\partial^{\mu}\phi\\ -\frac{1}{2}\partial_{\mu}s\partial_{\nu}s+2\frac{s}{\phi}\left ( 1+\xi\right ) \partial_{\mu}\phi\partial^{\mu}s \end{array } \right ) \end{array } \right ] \label{xi}\ ] ] this lagrangian is weyl invariant for any value of the constant parameter @xmath128 but we see now a simple generalization of the special simplifying role played by @xmath129 that corresponds to the conformally coupled scalars of eq.(1 ) . in the general single-@xmath102 lagrangian ( [ action2 ] ) , field redefinitions of the gauge invariant variable @xmath130 ( or @xmath131 ) may be used to map one of these three functions , @xmath132 to any desired function of @xmath133 without changing the form of the lagrangian in ( [ action2 ] ) . for example it may be convenient to take @xmath127 and still obtain all single-@xmath102 weyl - symmetric models by using all possible @xmath134 . another option is to take all possible @xmath135 with a fixed @xmath136 as in eq.([action1 ] ) , which has certain advantages for understanding geodesic completeness @xcite of all the fields @xmath137 in cosmological spacetimes , as discussed in sec . if we choose @xmath138 and demand renormalizability of the action in the limit of @xmath139 ( where gravity effectively decouples , as seen in the gauge @xmath140 with @xmath141 , we are forced to @xmath142 and @xmath143 being a quartic polynomial . the last form is actually quite unique . we now give a proof that the general model of eq.([action2 ] ) with a single @xmath102 ( which corresponds to our minimal realistic model ) can always be written in the geodesically complete form that we advocated in our previous work @xcite-@xcite and implemented in proposing the action in eq.([action1 ] ) . we begin in the notation of eq.([genweyl ] ) with only two fields @xmath144 labelled by @xmath145 using well known results of geometry in 2 dimensions , the metric in field space @xmath146 can always be diagonalized by general field reparametrizations ( as in general relativity ) and put into the conformally flat form @xmath147 where @xmath100 is the flat metric in 2 dimensions . using further field reparametrizations with an overall rescaling consistent with weyl transformations , the factor @xmath148 can also be set equal to the constant @xmath149 having arrived at @xmath150 as still the most general metric in field space , the only possible form of @xmath88 that is consistent with the local weyl symmetry is @xmath151 this completes the general proof that the action in eq.([action1 ] ) is the most general weyl invariant theory without losing generality . then the complete analysis of homogeneous cosmological solutions provided in our previous work @xcite-@xcite shows that this form is the general geodesically complete version of the theory . certain other forms for @xmath88 arrived at by field reparametrizations , in particular purely positive forms of @xmath152 always end up putting restrictions in field space inadvertently , and such specialized restrictions on fields is what leads to geodesic incompleteness . hence , the a class of well motivated models that we used in many of our studies amounts to @xmath153 @xmath154 and the low energy renormalizable quartic potential @xmath155 @xmath156 with @xmath157 this is the model that now is identical to the conformally symmetric standard model we proposed . its homogeneous cosmological equations have been solved analytically exactly in @xcite for all possible initial conditions of the fields , including radiation and curvature , and all possible values of the parameters @xmath158 but with @xmath159 . after this much analytic control , a small @xmath27 is easily handled with numerical methods and still have a full understanding of all the cosmological solutions of the standard model . this forms the basis of our further work in cosmology that is discussed in the following sections . for further discussion , a useful gauge choice is @xmath160 for all spacetime as in eq.([c - gauge ] ) . this is the gauge called the @xmath15-gauge in our previous work . because we use also other gauges , we attach the letter @xmath15 to each field in this gauge , thus @xmath161 will remind us that we are in the @xmath15-gauge , where @xmath162 in @xmath15-gauge we rename @xmath163 to recall that in this gauge we obtain the simplest connection to the higgs field @xmath164 at low energy , in nearly flat spacetime , @xmath165 as discussed in the paragraphs before eq.([unitary ] ) . the lagrangian in eq.([action2 ] ) with general @xmath166 takes the following greatly simplified form in the @xmath15-gauge @xmath167 . \label{action3}\ ] ] if we apply a weyl transformation to go to the einstein frame after an integration by parts of the last term ( or by dropping a total derivative ) we obtain the given result . ] , @xmath168 then we obtain@xmath169 \label{e - frame}\ ] ] without loss of generality , a particularly simplifying choice for @xmath170 , namely @xmath171 is the one that yields a canonically normalized higgs field . in this form , the theory can be interpreted directly as an einstein frame formulation of the standard model with a canonically normalized higgs field it is possible to do a field redefinition such that @xmath172 is written in terms of a canonically normalized field @xmath173 where the relation between @xmath174 and @xmath175 is given by the first order differential equation @xmath176=u\left ( h/\phi_{0}\right ) .$ ] then the lagrangian rewritten in terms of the canonically normalized @xmath174 is again of standard form with the same potential @xmath177 as eq.([veff ] ) , except for expressing @xmath172 in terms of @xmath178 this complicated procedure is avoided by the simple choice of @xmath63 in eq.([gchosen ] ) . [ fieldredef ] ] and an effective higgs potential @xmath179 given by @xmath180 this potential can be crafted by various choices of @xmath103 and @xmath181 to fit cosmological observations , while still being consistent with an underlying local conformal symmetry . however , since this gauge led to an overall positive coefficient in front of the ricci scalar , it could not recover all field configurations that are demanded in the geodesically complete theory ; inevitably the _ generic _ solutions in this gauge are geodesically incomplete as we have learned in our previous work . for example , the best fit inflaton potentials based on recent planck satellite data @xcite are plateau " models @xcite . using the geodesically incomplete form of the theory in ( [ e - frame ] ) it is possible to construct examples with plateaus at large @xmath182 , by choosing @xmath183 and @xmath184 such that the potential @xmath185 is very slowly varying and approaches a constant at large @xmath172 and by requiring @xmath179 becomes approximately the familiar higgs potential needed to fit low energy physics for @xmath186 . the bezrukov - shaposhnikov ( bs ) model for higgs inflation @xcite is a special case of our more general form in eq.([action3 ] ) , namely their proposal@xmath187 , \label{shoposh}\ ] ] follows from eq.([action3 ] ) by taking @xmath188and @xmath189 this leads to an effective potential @xmath190 of the type above in eq.([veff ] ) , @xmath191 in the bs model , because @xmath63 is chosen as @xmath192 , the field @xmath172 is not canonically normalized , so @xmath172 must be replaced through a field redefinition @xcite to obtain a canonically normalized higgs , @xmath173 as described more generally in footnote ( [ fieldredef ] ) . hence , the bs model has a fully weyl symmetric formulation which was not noticed before . its presentation in the literature has included various ambiguities and inconsistencies , with clashing ideas on scaling symmetries at the classical level and quantum corrections . for example , in some cases , the coupling to gravity has a dimensionful newton constant that is inconsistent with the scaling symmetry of the rest of the theory ; a massless dilaton is said to exist in cases where global scaling symmetry is explicitly broken at low energies ; unimodular gravity has been introduced but this is inconsistent with scale symmetry ; and there is ambiguity about which renormalization scheme is appropriate for computing quantum corrections . these issues are fully resolved with the underlying weyl symmetric formulation discussed here . also , now that we have recast the bs model into a fully conformally invariant form , we can see in the gauge fixed einstein frame ( [ e - frame]-[veff ] ) that it is not unique . rather , it is just a special case of a larger set of conformally invariant models including a range that have similar plateau properties . furthermore , since @xmath193 is purely positive , it means the fields in the bs model form a basis that is geodesically incomplete , and hence its generic solutions can describe only a subsector of the available field space . we make further comments in sec . ( [ confcosm ] ) including the effects of geodesic incompleteness . we do not know if supersymmetry ( susy ) is a property of nature , but theoretically it is an attractive possibility . therefore , it is of interest to investigate whether it is compatible with an underlying local conformal symmetry . as a superconformal local symmetry , the generalization of the weyl invariant formalism of the previous section produces stronger constraints on scalar fields . this was derived in @xcite from the gauge symmetry formalism in @xmath8 dimensions . it is possible to arrive at the results given below directly in @xmath7 dimensions by requiring supergravity with a local superconformal symmetry , but provided the usual einstein - hilbert term is dropped ( which is unusual in the supergravity literature ) , and instead a weyl symmetric formulation like the previous sections is implemented . in the @xmath8 dimensional approach of 2t - physics there is no option : it is a prediction that the emergent @xmath7 dimensional theory is automatically invariant under a local symmetry su@xmath194 where su@xmath195so@xmath19 is the connection to @xmath8 dimensions , the subgroup so@xmath196so@xmath197so@xmath198so@xmath199 is the weyl subgroup that acts on the extra @xmath60 dimensions , and the supersymmetrization in @xmath8 dimensions promotes su@xmath200 to su@xmath201 for @xmath202 supersymmetries @xcite , with @xmath203 in the present case @xcite . the scalar - field sector of the emergent @xmath7 dimensional locally superconformal theory is presented here briefly in a streamlined fashion , including some simplifications and extensions . first note that a scalar field in a chiral supermultiplet must be complex . thus susy requires the singlet @xmath13 to be complexified so that it is a member of a supermultiplet . then to describe all the scalar fields we use a complex basis @xmath204 and denote their complex conjugates as @xmath205 with the barred index @xmath206 the notation is reminiscent of standard supergravity as reviewed in @xcite . however now there is no einstein - hilbert term ; instead there is a weyl plus an additional @xmath207 gauge symmetry that can gauge fix a complex scalar @xmath13 into a dimensionful real constant @xmath32 that plays the role of the planck scale . recalling the discussion about removing the ( real ) ghost scalar field @xmath13 in sec . iib , it should be noticed that the complex @xmath13 amounts to two real ghosts , and therefore two gauge symmetries are needed to remove them . this role is played by the weyl symmetry so@xmath208 that acts on the extra 1 + 1 dimensions and the local r - symmetry u@xmath3 , both of which are included in the local su@xmath209 outlined above . the local u@xmath3 is a crucial ingredient as a partner of the weyl symmetry to remove the additional ghost from a complexified dilaton field @xmath13 that is demanded by susy . like before , we have @xmath210 but susy requires that the metric @xmath211 be derived from the derivatives of @xmath212 like a khler metric@xmath213 the metric must be non - singular and @xmath214 can not contain any more than one negative eigenvalue ( because no more than one complex ghost can be removed ) . we denote its inverse formally as @xmath215 a simple quadratic example similar to eq.([action1 ] ) is @xmath216 in this example , all scalars in the theory are conformally coupled , and u and g are automatically invariant under a global su(1,n ) symmetry . this global symmetry , which will continue to be a hidden symmetry in some gauges , may be broken explicitly by some terms in the potential @xmath217 , depending on the model considered . nevertheless , keeping track of this ( broken ) symmetry in physical applications can be useful . the scalar field sector of the supergravity theory with local weyl symmetry is given as follows . @xmath218 .\ ] ] the khler metric and khler potential structure is reminiscent of general supergravity @xcite , however the absence of the einstein - hilbert term , and the corresponding scale invariance is the important difference . here , @xmath219 is homogeneous of degree two and satisfies homothety constraints similar to eq.([homothety]),@xmath220 the potential energy has two parts @xmath221 the potential @xmath222 must be derived from an analytic superpotential @xmath223 that depends only on @xmath204 and not on @xmath205 , and is homogeneous of degree three so that @xmath224 is homogeneous of degree four @xmath225 the potential @xmath226 is derived from another independent analytic function @xmath227 with adjoint group indices @xmath228 that appears in yang - mills terms as , @xmath229 . this @xmath227 should be homogeneous of degree zero @xmath230 then @xmath231 takes the form @xmath232 where @xmath233 is the matrix representation of the yang - mills group as it acts on the scalars @xmath234 the fermionic terms are added consistently with the usual rules of supergravity @xcite . this is the general setup for the weyl invariant matter coupled to weyl invariant supergravity as derived from the @xmath8 dimensional theory . the simplest example that corresponds to the supersymmetric generalization of eq.([action1 ] ) would be the minimal supersymmetric standard model extended with an additional singlet supermultiplet , whose scalar component is the complex field @xmath121 then @xmath119 takes the quadratic form suggested in @xcite @xmath235 where @xmath236 are the two higgs doublets needed in the supersymmetric version of the standard model . the superpotential @xmath237 and the matrix @xmath238 are chosen to fit the usual practice of supersymmetric model building @xcite . an example is @xmath239 , and @xmath240 where @xmath241 is the only su@xmath6u@xmath3 invariant which is analytic in both @xmath242 and @xmath243 . in an effective ( rather than renormalizable ) low energy theory , these can be modified by replacing the dimensionless coupling constants @xmath244 by an arbitrary function of the ratio @xmath245 and similarly for @xmath246 when the complex @xmath0 is gauge fixed to the real constant @xmath247 this approach generates all the dimensionful parameters from the same source @xmath32 which is of order of the planck scale . then we see that the modification of @xmath244 and @xmath248 by arbitrary functions of @xmath249 is negligible at low energies . more general scale invariant models with more fields ( such as generalizations of the minimal susy model ) are easily constructed by using the rules on scalar fields given in this section . with special forms of the superpotential @xmath223 , it is possible to construct so called no - scale models @xcite-@xcite in which the cosmological constant is guaranteed to be zero at the classical level even after spontaneous breakdown of symmetries . simple examples of no - scale models , that are lifted to be fully weyl invariant , are given in @xcite . in this paper we will not explore any further the general superconformal structures discussed above although this could be of interest in some future applications . some of our examples that are very similar to the weyl invariant supersymmetric cases previously discovered in @xcite were later explored in a cosmological context in @xcite . however their discussion , which is focussed on very specialized initial conditions that are so non - generic , is difficult to be convincing especially in the face of the complete set of solutions that we now understand much better . in this paper we have emphasized the geodesically complete nature of our conformal standard model . in this section we first describe what we mean by geodesic completeness and the related notion of completeness in field space , and then discuss some applications of our conformal standard model in cosmology . there are two required properties for geodesic completeness : the first is smooth local geodesic continuation through singularities across all space - time patches ; the second is infinite action for geodesics that reach arbitrarily far into the past so that unnatural initial conditions are avoided . both properties are satisfied in our theory which is insured to also be complete in field space . geodesics @xmath250 are computed by extremizing the particle action @xmath251 where @xmath252 is the mass and @xmath253 is a gravitational field . in our weyl invariant standard model ( [ action1 ] ) all particle masses are generated by the higgs field , so @xmath252 is proportional to the higgs field @xmath172 , @xmath254 where @xmath255 is the dimensionless coupling constant for the corresponding particle as prescribed by the standard model . then this particle action is locally invariant under weyl transformations @xmath256 and @xmath257 for our cosmological discussion , geodesics @xmath258 in a spatially homogeneous space are computed when both homogeneous fields that appear in the particle action @xmath259 , @xmath260 and @xmath261 where @xmath262 is the conformal time , correspond to consistent solutions of the field equations of our conformal standard model in ( [ action1 ] ) . the full solution to the geodesic equation ( neglecting curvature and anisotropy for simplicity ) is @xmath263 where @xmath264 is the conserved spatial component of the particle momentum vector , @xmath265 while @xmath266 , and @xmath267 is the initial position . these expressions are invariant under reparametrizations of the affine parameter @xmath268 since they depend only on the physical spacetime variables @xmath269 then , the local continuation property of a geodesic @xmath270 in a homogeneous space is satisfied automatically when one insures that all the fields , including @xmath271 and @xmath272 are given in all the patches of homogeneous field space and that the fields are smoothly continued through singularities . in @xcite@xcite , we showed how local weyl invariance , in the special weyl frame displayed in eq.([action1 ] ) that covers all the patches , are essential ingredients to insure that all homogeneous cosmological solutions of our conformal standard model ( [ action1 ] ) have this continuation property . the global action for a geodesic ( [ geodesicx ] ) is given by @xmath273 the combination @xmath274 that appears in @xmath275 is invariant under weyl transformations , so it can be computed in any convenient gauge ( see e.g. eqs.([egaugeu]-[detxu ] ) ) . in particular in the @xmath276-gauge used in the solutions in @xcite@xcite , where @xmath277 we have shown that in all cyclic solutions in @xcite , @xmath278 oscillates with a fixed maximum amplitude many times within a cycle , and for an infinite number of times over an infinite number of cycles , leading to an infinite action , since @xmath279 receives the same positive finite contribution in each cycle . for these solutions the average magnitude of @xmath280@xmath281@xmath280 in the @xmath282-gauge ( usual einstein frame , see eq.([egaugeu ] ) ) is the same in each cycle . recently , we have also constructed @xcite solutions with increasing entropy in each future cycle such that the average @xmath280@xmath281@xmath280 in the @xmath282-gauge increases in each future cycle . for these solutions , @xmath275 diverges to the past @xcite even faster as compared to our solutions in @xcite . hence , unlike inflation scenarios @xcite , we may expect that the universe described by our conformal standard model has no unnatural initial conditions . next , we discuss various potential applications of weyl invariant theories to cosmology . early universe cosmology near the singularity is a natural place to look for uses because the interactions imposed by weyl invariance ( more profoundly @xmath8 dimensional gauge symmetries ) produce their most significant changes relative to conventional physics in the limit of strong gravity , as noted in some of the examples above . black hole phenomena is another interesting arena for study , but we will not discuss them here . the first important application was to use weyl invariance to construct geodesically complete cosmological solutions . conventional cosmological analysis is usually confined to theories coupled to einstein gravity with a dimensionful newton s constant . in this framework , all cosmological solutions of interest are geodesically incomplete . however , we have observed that a weyl - invariant theory can be cast in einstein frame , as illustrated by eq.([e - frame ] ) , and in other frames . the observation made in @xcite-@xcite is that geodesically incompleteness is an artifact of an unsuitable frame choice : geodesically incomplete solutions in einstein frame may be completed in other frames , even though the theories are entirely equivalent away from the singularity . the einstein frame can always be reached directly from a weyl invariant theory in ( [ action2 ] ) by making the einstein - gauge choice @xmath283 we label this the @xmath282-gauge and mark the fields in this gauge with the subscript @xmath282 ( as in @xmath284 ) to distinguish them from the @xmath15- gauge fields @xmath285 note that the @xmath282-gauge can be valid only in a patch in field space since restrictions must be imposed on the fields to require that @xmath286 is positive . the same theory can easily be transformed to other gauges . for example , the relations between the @xmath282- and @xmath15-gauge fields can be easily derived by considering the weyl gauge invariants such as @xmath287 and @xmath288 @xmath289 etc . , for example we deduce @xmath290 from these , we can express @xmath291 and @xmath292 in terms of the single field @xmath293 so that the gauge condition ( [ egaugeu ] ) is satisfied . inserting these expressions into the gauge invariant action ( [ action2 ] ) we arrive at the same @xmath282-frame action as eq.([e - frame ] ) . as argued in our work @xcite-@xcite , classically geodesically complete solutions can be obtained for all single - scalar theories that can be cast in the form of eq.([action2 ] ) . but , for all patches of field space @xmath294 to be included , as demanded by the geodesics derived from @xmath179 in the einstein frame , @xmath295 must be brought to an appropriate form by using the field redefinitions discussed below eq.([xi ] ) . the patches of field space @xmath294 that are missing in the einstein frame can then be added in order to obtain a geodesically complete space . we have argued in @xcite , and provided a proof in section ( [ generalgrav ] ) , that geodesic completeness is accomplished when we bring @xmath119 to the form @xmath296 where @xmath297 is the sum of all scalars other than @xmath121 geodesics remain incomplete when they hit the singularity in all frames in which @xmath119 is always positive , or the equivalent einstein frame , such as the one in eq.([shoposh ] ) . when we rewrite those , by field redefinitions , in terms of new fields in which @xmath296 then the patches of field space @xmath298 are equivalent to the einstein frame , or to the other frames with positive @xmath119 . geodesic completion is achieved by allowing all regions of field space in the parametrization that has @xmath299 for this form , @xmath119 is allowed to smoothly go negative . in these coordinates the gauge invariant vanishing point of @xmath300 given by the gauge invariant expression @xmath301 has a special significance ; it corresponds to the singularity of the scale factor of the universe in the einstein gauge . this is seen by equating the gauge invariant @xmath302 in the einstein gauge , in which @xmath303 and the unimodular gauge ( labelled with @xmath276 ) , in which @xmath304 as follows @xmath305 at spacetime points or regions where @xmath306 which is where the gauge invariant quantity @xmath307 hits unity in all gauges , @xmath308 @xmath309 the geometry in the einstein gauge fails completely since @xmath310 , and this is how the cosmological singularity occurs at some point in time @xcite . then , as we can see in the @xmath15-gauge , the region @xmath311 ( higgs of planck size ) is the region of the big crunch or big bang singularity , where @xmath312 in any gauge . the behavior of the universe in this region is governed by a universal attractor mechanism that is independent of the scalar potential , therefore independent of the details of the model @xcite . although in the classical theory , cosmological singularities of frw - type are typically resolved in the weyl - lifted theory with @xmath313 in suitable weyl gauges , one should still worry about quantum gravity corrections . when @xmath119 vanishes , the coefficient of the ricci scalar in the gravitational action vanishes so there is no suppression of metric fluctuations and quantum gravity corrections should become large . however , it is notable that for certain types of cosmic singularities , including realistic ones , the metric and fields possess a unique continuation around the singularity in the complex time plane . a complex time path can be chosen to remain far from the singularity so that @xmath119 is always large and gravity remains weak . thus , we are able to find an analytic continuation of our classical solutions connecting big crunches to big bangs along which quantum gravity corrections are small . this issue is under active investigation and we defer further discussion to future work . a particularly interesting application of weyl - invariance is to higgs cosmology , which the geodesically complete solutions show can be much more interesting than conventionally assumed . in fact , there is the possibility that the higgs field alone may be sufficient to explain the large - scale features of the universe , as suggested by the bezrukov - shaposhnikov higgs inflation model @xcite and our recent work on the higgs in cyclic cosmology @xcite@xcite . in considering higgs cosmology or other models of the early universe , we believe that the cosmological solutions found for geodesically complete theories provide some important new insights on the question of the likely initial conditions just after the big bang . for example , the _ generic _ behavior of the higgs after the bang when @xmath314 is dramatically different than the contrived initial conditions that are commonly assumed in higgs inflation scenarios . this is easily seen by examining the analytic work in @xcite@xcite , where for the simple model in eq.([action1 ] ) with @xmath315 all homogeneous solutions including curvature and radiation are obtained and the effects of anisotropy are determined @xcite . emphasizing that this is not only the contrived solutions , but all solutions , it serves as an example of the richness of the phenomena that occur in a model even with a simple potential . the results make clear a point that is obvious , but often forgotten : for a given scalar potential , there is an enormous range of cosmological solutions . by comparison , it is clear that the slow - roll initial conditions frequently assumed in the analysis of cosmic inflation are very special and unlikely . for example , by transforming the inflationary solution in the bezrukov - shaposhnikov higgs inflation model @xcite to a field basis in which @xmath313 , it may be possible to trace cosmic evolution right back to the singularity and to judge whether the inflation is likely in the space of geodesically complete cosmological solutions . fig.(1 ) is an illustration of our solution for the _ generic _ cosmological behavior of the higgs field just after the big bang if the higgs potential has a stable non - trivial minimum , as in eq.([action1 ] ) , as usually assumed and as required for the bezrukov - shaposhnikov higgs inflation model @xcite . this figure describes the generic cosmological evolution of the higgs field , that must start with fluctuations of planck size and energy ( due to the universal attractor near the singularity @xcite ) , and quickly reduce its amplitude by losing energy to the gravitational field ; then after a phase transition , settle down to an almost constant value at the electroweak scale @xmath34 determined by the dimensionless parameter @xmath27 in eq.([alpha ] ) . cosmohiggs-stable.eps + fig.(1 ) - after the big bang the higgs field oscillates initially around zero with a large amplitude of the order of the planck scale . it slowly loses energy to the gravitational field , causing its amplitude to diminish . as it approaches the time or energies of the electroweak scale , it undergoes the phase transition seen in the figure , and then slowly settles to a constant vacuum value @xmath34 at a stable minimum of the potential . [ cosmohiggs-stable.eps ] the solution of fig.(1 ) changes drastically if the vacuum is metastable after including quantum corrections , which is a possibility suggested by the most recent lhc data for the higgs and the top quark masses @xcite , and assuming no new physics up to the planck scale . metastability is incompatible with higgs inflation and generally causes problems for inflation because the higgs will typically escape from the metastable phase right after the big bang and roll to a state of negative energy density that can prevent inflation of any sort from occurring . the exact solutions of the weyl - invariant theory suggest an alternative cosmology in this case . the generic solution at first behaves as in fig.(1 ) after the big bang , all the way through the electroweak phase transition . but after some time ( order of the lifetime of the universe ) the higgs oscillations in the electroweak vacuum grow larger and larger , like the mirror image of fig.(1 ) , taking away energy from the gravitational field and eventually causing a collapse of the universe to a big crunch , while the higgs does a quantum tunneling to a lower state of the potential . at that stage our exact analysis near the singularity given in @xcite takes over to describe interesting new phenomena that occur just after the crunch and before another rebirth of the universe with a big bang . the result is a regularly repeating sequence in which the higgs field is trapped in its metastable state after a big bang , remains there for a long period of expansion followed by contraction , escapes as the universe approaches the big crunch , passes through to a big bang and becomes trapped again . the evolution can be considered a higgs - driven cyclic theory of the universe . the details are presented in a separate paper @xcite . this research was partially supported by the u.s . department of energy under grant number de - fg03 - 84er40168 ( ib ) and under grant number de - fg02- 91er40671 ( pjs ) . research at perimeter institute is supported by the government of canada through industry canada and by the province of ontario through the ministry of research and innovation . the work of nt is supported in part by a grant from the john templeton foundation . the opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the john templeton foundation . ib thanks cern and pjs thanks perimeter institute for hospitality while this research was completed . f. englert , e. gunzig , c. truffin , p. windey , conformal invariant general relativity with dynamical symmetry breakdown , phys.lett . b57 ( 1975 ) 73 ; f. englert , c. truffin and r. gastmans , conformal invariance in quantum gravity , nuclear physics * b117 * ( 1976 ) 407 . i. bars , s .- h . chen , p. j. steinhardt and n. turok , complete set of homogeneous isotropic analytic solutions in scalar - tensor cosmology with radiation and curvature , phys . * d86 * ( 2012 ) 083542 [ arxiv:1207.1940 ] . i. bars , traversing cosmological singularities , complete journeys through spacetime including antigravity , arxiv:1209.1068 , in _ beyond the big bang , competing scenarios for an eternal universe _ , ed . rudy vaas , springer [ 2013 ] , isbn 978 - 3 - 540 - 71422 - 4 . i. bars , gravity in 2t - physics , phys . * d77 * ( 2008 ) 125027 [ arxiv:0804.1585 ] ; i. bars , s. h. chen geometry and symmetry structures in 2 t gravity , phys . rev . * d79 * ( 2009 ) 085021 [ arxiv:0811.2510v2 ] . i. bars and y - c kuo , field theory in 2t - physics with @xmath202=1 supersymmetry , phys . * 99 * ( 2007 ) 041801 [ hep - th/0702089 ] ; supersymmetric field theory in 2t - physics , phys . rev . * d76 * ( 2007 ) 105028 [ hep - th/0703002 ] ; @xmath202=2,4 supersymmetric gauge field theory in 2t - physics , phys . rev . * d79 * ( 2009 ) 025001 [ arxiv:0808.0537 ] ; super yang - mills theory in 10 + 2 dimensions , the 2t - physics source for n=4 sym and m(atrix ) theory , arxiv:1008.4761 . k. meissner and h. nicolai , conformal symmetry and the standard model , phys . lett . * b648 * ( 2007 ) 312 , [ arxiv : hep - th/0612165 ] . effective action , conformal anomaly and the issue of quadratic divergences , phys.lett . * b660 * ( 2008 ) 260 [ arxiv:0710.2840 ] . itzhak bars , at conference on conformal nature of the universe , perimeter institute , may 2012 ; neil turok , cern colloquium , july 2012 ; t.w.b . kibble 80th birthday conference , imperial college , march 2013 ; yale physics department colloquium , april 2013 ; paul steinhardt , at davis conference , may 2013 . s. ferrara , r. kallosh , a. linde , a. marrani and a. van proeyen , superconformal symmetry , nmssm , and inflation , phys . * d83 * ( 2011 ) 025008 [ arxiv:1008.2942 ] ; r. kallosh and a. linde superconformal generalization of the chaotic inflation model arxiv:1306.3211 and superconformal generalizations of the starobinsky model , arxiv:1306.3214 . i. bars , s - h chen and g. quelin , dual field theories in @xmath316 emergent spacetimes from a unifying field theory in d+2 spacetime , phys . rev . * d76 * ( 2007 ) 065016 [ arxiv:0705.2834 ] ; i. bars and g. quelin , dualities among one - time field theories with spin , emerging from a unifying two- time field theory , phys . rev . * d77 * ( 2008 ) 125019 [ arxiv:0802.1947 ] . r. foot , a. kobakhidze and r. r. volkas , electroweak higgs as a pseudo - goldstone boson of broken scale invariance , phys . lett . * b655 * ( 2007 ) 156 [ arxiv:0704.1165 ] . r. foot , a. kobakhidze , k. mcdonald , r.volkas , r. foot , a. kobakhidze , k. mcdonald , r.volkas , neutrino mass in radiatively - broken scale - invariant models , arxiv:0706.1829 ; a solution to the hierarchy problem from an almost decoupled hidden sector within a classically scale invariant theory , arxiv:0709.2750 . h. cheng , the possible existence of weyl s vector meson , phys . rev . lett . * 61 * ( 1988 ) 2182 ; h. nishino and s. rajpoot , broken scale invariance in the standard model , hep - th/0403039 ; _ ibid . _ class . & gr . * 28 * ( 2011 ) 145014 ; aip conf . proc . * 881 * ( 2007 ) p. 82 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: consider the isentropic compressible navier - stokes equations @xmath2 on the quarter - plane @xmath3 , where @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 denote density , velocity , and pressure at spatial location @xmath7 and time @xmath8 , with @xmath0-law pressure function @xmath9 and noncharacteristic constant `` inflow '' or `` outflow '' boundary conditions @xmath10 or @xmath11 as discussed in @xcite . the sign of the velocity at @xmath12 determines whether characteristics of the hyperbolic transport equation @xmath13 enter the domain ( considering @xmath14 as a lower - order forcing term ) , and thus whether @xmath15 should be prescribed . the variable - coefficient parabolic equation @xmath16 requires prescription of @xmath17 in either case , with @xmath18 . by comparison , the purely hyperbolic isentropic euler equations @xmath19 have characteristic speeds @xmath20 , hence , depending on the values of @xmath21 , may have one , two , or no characteristics entering the domain , hence require one , two , or no prescribed boundary values . in particular , there is a discrepancy between the number of prescribed boundary values for and in the case of mild inflow @xmath22 small ( two for , one for ) or strong outflow @xmath23 large ( one for , none for ) , indicating the possibility of _ boundary layers _ , or asymptotically - constant stationary solutions of : @xmath24 indeed , existence of such solutions is straightforward to verify by direct computations on the ( scalar ) stationary - wave ode ; see @xcite or section [ profsec ] . these may be either of `` expansive '' type , resembling rarefaction wave solutions on the whole line , or `` compressive '' type , resembling viscous shock solutions . a fundamental question is whether or not such boundary layer solutions are _ stable _ in the sense of pde . for the expansive inflow case , it has been shown in @xcite that _ all _ boundary layers are stable , independent of amplitude , by energy estimates similar to those used to prove the corresponding result for rarefactions on the whole line . here , we concentrate on the complementary , _ compressive case _ ( though see discussion , section [ discussion ] ) . linearized and nonlinear stability of general ( expansive or compressive ) _ small - amplitude _ noncharacteristic boundary layers of have been established in @xcite . more generally , it has been shown in @xcite that linearized and nonlinear stability are equivalent to spectral stability , or nonexistence of nonstable ( nonnegative real part ) eigenvalues of the linearized operator about the layer , for boundary layers of arbitrary amplitude . however , up to now the spectral stability of _ large - amplitude compressive _ boundary layers has remained largely undetermined . we resolve this question in the present paper , carrying out a systematic , global study classifying the stability of all possible compressive boundary - layer solutions of . our method of analysis is by a combination of asymptotic ode techniques and numerical evans function computations , following a basic approach introduced recently in @xcite for the study of the closely related shock wave case . here , there are interesting complications associated with the richer class of boundary - layer solutions as compared to possible shock solutions , the delicate stability properties of the inflow case , and , in the outflow case , the nonstandard eigenvalue problem arising from reduction to lagrangian coordinates . our conclusions are , for both inflow and outflow conditions , that compressive boundary layers that are uniformly noncharacteristic in a sense to be made precise later ( specifically , @xmath25 bounded away from @xmath26 , in the terminology of section [ profsec ] ) are _ unconditionally stable _ , independent of amplitude , on the range @xmath27 $ ] considered in our numerical computations . we show by energy estimates that _ outflow boundary layers are stable also in the characteristic limit_. the omitted characteristic limit in the inflow case , analogous to the small - amplitude limit for the shock case should be treatable by the singular perturbation methods used in @xcite to treat the small - amplitude shock case ; however , we do not consider this case here . in the inflow case , our results , together with those of @xcite , completely resolve the question of stability of isentropic ( expansive or compressive ) uniformly noncharacteristic boundary layers for @xmath28 $ ] , yielding _ unconditional stability independent of amplitude or type . _ in the outflow case , we show stability of all compressive boundary layers without the assumption of uniform noncharacteristicity . the small - amplitude results obtained in @xcite are of `` general type '' , making little use of the specific structure of the equations . essentially , they all require that the difference between the boundary layer solution and its constant limit at @xmath29 be small in @xmath30 . be small in @xmath30 . ( for monotone profiles , @xmath31 . ) ] as pointed out in @xcite , this is the `` gap lemma '' regime in which standard asymptotic ode estimates show that behavior is essentially governed by the limiting constant - coefficient equations at infinity , and thus stability may be concluded immediately from stability ( computable by exact solution ) of the constant layer identically equal to the limiting state . these methods do not suffice to treat either the ( small - amplitude ) characteristic limit or the large - amplitude case , which require more refined analyses . in particular , up to now , _ there was no analysis considering boundary layers approaching a full viscous shock profile _ , _ not even a profile of vanishingly small amplitude_. our analysis of this limit indicates why : the appearance of a small eigenvalue near zero prevents uniform estimates such as would be obtained by usual types of energy estimates . by contrast , the large - amplitude results obtained here and ( for expansive layers ) in @xcite make use of the specific form of the equations . in particular , both analyses make use of the advantageous structure in lagrangian coordinates . the possibility to work in lagrangian coordinates was first pointed out by matsumura nishihara @xcite in the inflow case , for which the stationary boundary transforms to a moving boundary with constant speed . here we show how to convert the outflow problem also to lagrangian coordinates , by converting the resulting variable - speed boundary problem to a constant - speed one with modified boundary condition . this trick seems of general use . in particular , it might be possible that the energy methods of @xcite applied in this framework would yield unconditional stability of expansive boundary - layers , completing the analysis of the outflow case . alternatively , this case could be attacked by the methods of the present paper . these are two further interesting direction for future investigation . in the outflow case , a further transformation to the `` balanced flux form '' introduced in @xcite , in which the equations take the form of the integrated shock equations , allows us to establish stability in the characteristic limit by energy estimates like those of @xcite in the shock case . the treatment of the characteristic inflow limit by the methods of @xcite seems to be another extremely interesting direction for future study . finally , we point to the extension of the present methods to full ( nonisentropic ) gas dynamics and multidimensions as the two outstanding open problems in this area . new features of the present analysis as compared to the shock case considered in @xcite are the presence of two parameters , strength and displacement , indexing possible boundary layers , vs. the single parameter of strength in the shock case , and the fact that the limiting equations in several asymptotic regimes possess zero eigenvalues , making the limiting stability analysis much more delicate than in the shock case . the latter is seen , for example , in the limit as a compressive boundary layer approaches a full stationary shock solution , which we show to be spectrally equivalent to the situation of unintegrated shock equations on the whole line . as the equations on the line possess always a translational eigenvalue at @xmath32 , we may conclude existence of a zero at @xmath32 for the limiting equations and thus a zero _ near _ @xmath32 as we approach this limit , which could be stable or unstable . similarly , the evans function in the inflow case is shown to converge in the large - strength limit to a function with a zero at @xmath32 , with the same conclusions ; see section [ description ] for further details . to deal with this latter circumstance , we find it necessary to make use also of topological information provided by the stability index of @xcite , a mod - two index counting the parity of the number of unstable eigenvalues . together with the information that there is at most one unstable zero , the parity information provided by the stability index is sufficient to determine whether an unstable zero does or does not occur . remarkably , in the isentropic case we are able to compute explicitly the stability index for all parameter values , recovering results obtained by indirect argument in @xcite , and thereby completing the stability analysis in the presence of a single possibly unstable zero . we begin by carrying out a number of preliminary steps similar to those carried out in @xcite for the shock case , but complicated somewhat by the need to treat the boundary and its different conditions in the inflow and outflow case . the analyses of @xcite in the shock wave case were carried out in lagrangian coordinates , which proved to be particularly convenient . our first step , therefore , is to convert the eulerian formulation into lagrangian coordinates similar to those of the shock case . however , standard lagrangian coordinates in which the spatial variable @xmath33 is constant on particle paths are not appropriate for the boundary - value problem with inflow / outflow . we therefore introduce instead `` psuedo - lagrangian '' coordinates @xmath34 in which the physical boundary @xmath12 remains fixed at @xmath35 . straightforward calculation reveals that in these coordinates becomes @xmath36 on @xmath37 , where @xmath38 so that @xmath39 is the negative of the momentum at the boundary @xmath40 . from now on , we drop the tilde , denoting @xmath33 simply as @xmath7 . for the inflow case , @xmath22 so we may prescribe _ two _ boundary conditions on , namely @xmath41 where both @xmath42 are constant . for the outflow case , @xmath23 so we may prescribe _ only one _ boundary condition on , namely @xmath43 thus @xmath44 is an unknown in the problem , which makes the analysis of the outflow case more subtle than that of the inflow case . our next step is to rescale the equations in such a way that coefficients remain bounded in the strong boundary - layer limit . consider the change of variables @xmath45 where @xmath46 is chosen so that @xmath47 where @xmath25 is the limit as @xmath48 of the boundary layer ( stationary solution ) @xmath49 under consideration and @xmath50 is the limit as @xmath51 of its continuation into @xmath52 as a solution of the standing - wave ode ( discussed in more detail just below ) . under the rescaling , becomes @xmath53 where @xmath54 , @xmath55 , on respective domains @xmath56 stationary boundary layers @xmath57 of satisfy @xmath58 where ( d ) is imposed at @xmath59 in the inflow case , @xmath60 in the outflow case and ( imposing @xmath61 ) @xmath62 . using ( a ) we can reduce this to the study of the scalar ode , @xmath63 with the same boundary conditions at @xmath12 and @xmath64 as above . taking the antiderivative of this equation yields @xmath65 where @xmath66 is a constant of integration . noting that @xmath67 is convex , we find that there are precisely two rest points of whenever boundary - layer profiles exist , except at the single parameter value on the boundary between existence and nonexistence of solutions , for which there is a degenerate rest point ( double root of @xmath67 ) . ignoring this degenerate case , we see that boundary layers terminating at rest point @xmath25 as @xmath48 must either continue backward into @xmath52 to terminate at a second rest point @xmath50 as @xmath51 , or else blow up to infinity as @xmath51 . the first case we shall call _ compressive _ , the second _ expansive_. in the first case , the extended solution on the whole line may be recognized as a standing viscous shock wave ; that is , _ for isentropic gas dynamics , compressive boundary layers are just restrictions to the half - line @xmath68 [ resp . @xmath69 of standing shock waves . _ in the second case , as discussed in @xcite , the boundary layers are somewhat analogous to rarefaction waves on the whole line . from here on , we concentrate exclusively on the compressive case . with the choice @xmath70 , we may carry out the integration of once more , this time as a definite integral from @xmath60 to @xmath7 , to obtain @xmath71 where @xmath72 is found by letting @xmath73 , yielding @xmath74 in particular , @xmath75 in the large boundary layer limit @xmath76 . this is exactly the equation for viscous shock profiles considered in @xcite . linearizing about @xmath77 , we obtain @xmath78 where @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 denote perturbations of @xmath82 . in the inflow case , @xmath83 , yielding @xmath84 on @xmath37 , with full dirichlet conditions @xmath85 . letting @xmath86 , @xmath87 , and denoting by @xmath88 the operator associated to the linearization about boundary - layer @xmath89 , @xmath90 where @xmath91 we have @xmath92 , with associated eigenvalue equation @xmath93 where @xmath94 . to eliminate the nonstandard inhomogeneous term on the righthand side of , we introduce a good unknown " ( c.f . @xcite ) @xmath95 since @xmath96 by differentiation of the boundary - layer equation , the system expressed in the good unknown becomes simply @xmath97 or , equivalently , with boundary conditions @xmath98 solving for @xmath99 in terms of @xmath100 and recalling that @xmath101 by , we obtain finally @xmath102 [ outrmk ] problems and are evidently equivalent for all @xmath103 , but are not equivalent for @xmath32 ( for which the change of coordinates to good unknown becomes singular ) . for , @xmath104 by inspection is a solution of , but is not a solution of . that is , we have introduced by this transformation a spurious eigenvalue at @xmath32 , which we shall have to account for later . [ @xcite ] [ profdecay ] for each @xmath105 , @xmath106 , has a unique ( up to translation ) monotone decreasing solution @xmath107 decaying to endstates @xmath108 with a uniform exponential rate for @xmath25 uniformly bounded away from @xmath70 . in particular , for @xmath109 , [ decaybd ] @xmath110 where @xmath111 is defined by @xmath112 . existence and monotonicity follow trivially by the fact that is a scalar first - order ode with convex righthand side . exponential convergence as @xmath48 follows by @xmath113 whence @xmath114 by @xmath115 for @xmath116 . exponential convergence as @xmath51 follows by a similar , but more straightforward calculation , where , in the `` centered '' coordinate @xmath117 , the constants @xmath118 are uniform with respect to @xmath119 . see @xcite for details . the following estimates are established in appendices [ basicproof ] and [ outbasicproof ] . [ hf ] nonstable eigenvalues @xmath120 of , i.e. , eigenvalues with nonnegative real part , are confined for any @xmath121 to the region @xmath122 for the inflow case , and to the region @xmath123 for the outflow case . setting @xmath124 , we may express as a first - order system @xmath125 where @xmath126 where @xmath127 with @xmath128 as in and @xmath72 as in , or , equivalently , @xmath129 [ shockrel ] the coefficient matrix @xmath130 may be recognized as a rescaled version of the coefficient matrix @xmath131 appearing in the shock case @xcite , with @xmath132 the choice of variables @xmath133 may be recognized as the modified flux form of @xcite , adapted to the hyperbolic parabolic case . eigenvalues of correspond to nontrivial solutions @xmath134 for which the boundary conditions @xmath135 are satisfied . because @xmath136 as a function of @xmath137 is asymptotically constant in @xmath7 , the behavior near @xmath138 of solutions of is governed by the limiting constant - coefficient systems @xmath139 from which we readily find on the ( nonstable ) domain @xmath140 , @xmath103 of interest that there is a one - dimensional unstable manifold @xmath141 of solutions decaying at @xmath142 and a two - dimensional stable manifold @xmath143 of solutions decaying at @xmath144 , analytic in @xmath120 , with asymptotic behavior @xmath145 as @xmath146 , where @xmath147 and @xmath148 are eigenvalues and associated analytically chosen eigenvectors of the limiting coefficient matrices @xmath149 . a standard choice of eigenvectors @xmath150 @xcite , uniquely specifying @xmath151 ( up to constant factor ) is obtained by kato s ode @xcite , a linear , analytic ode whose solution can be alternatively characterized by the property that there exist corresponding left eigenvectors @xmath152 such that @xmath153 where `` @xmath154 '' denotes @xmath155 ; for further discussion , see @xcite . in the inflow case , @xmath156 , we define the _ evans function _ @xmath157 as the analytic function @xmath158 where @xmath159 are as defined above , and @xmath160 is a solution satisfying the boundary conditions @xmath161 at @xmath12 , specifically , @xmath162 with this definition , eigenvalues of @xmath163 correspond to zeroes of @xmath157 both in location and multiplicity ; moreover , the evans function extends analytically to @xmath32 , i.e. , to all of @xmath140 . see @xcite for further details . equivalently , following @xcite , we may express the evans function as @xmath164 where @xmath165 spans the one - dimensional unstable manifold of solutions decaying at @xmath144 ( necessarily orthogonal to the span of @xmath166 and @xmath167 ) of the adjoint eigenvalue ode @xmath168 the simpler representation is the one that we shall use here . in the outflow case , @xmath169 , we define the _ evans function _ as @xmath170 where @xmath171 is as defined above , and @xmath172 are a basis of solutions of satisfying the boundary conditions , specifically , @xmath173 or , equivalently , as @xmath174 where @xmath175 is the solution of the adjoint eigenvalue ode dual to @xmath176 and @xmath177 . [ outevansrmk ] as discussed in remark [ outrmk ] , @xmath178 has a spurious zero at @xmath32 introduced by the coordinate change to `` good unknown '' . we can now state precisely our main results . taking a formal limit as @xmath76 of the rescaled equations and recalling that @xmath179 , we obtain a limiting evolution equation @xmath180 corresponding to a _ pressureless gas _ , or @xmath181 . the associated limiting profile equation @xmath182 has explicit solution @xmath183 @xmath184 ; the limiting eigenvalue system is @xmath185 @xmath186 where @xmath187 convergence of the profile and eigenvalue equations is _ uniform _ on any interval @xmath188 , or , equivalently , @xmath189 , for @xmath190 any positive constant , where the sequence of coefficient matrices is therefore a _ regular perturbation _ of its limit . following @xcite , we call @xmath191 the `` regular region '' . for @xmath192 on the other hand , or @xmath193 , the limit is less well - behaved , as may be seen by the fact that @xmath194 as @xmath195 , a consequence of the appearance of @xmath196 in the expression for @xmath197 . similarly , @xmath136 does not converge to @xmath198 as @xmath48 with uniform exponential rate independent of @xmath25 , @xmath0 , but rather as @xmath199 . as in the shock case , this makes problematic the treatment of @xmath200 . following @xcite we call @xmath200 the `` singular region '' . to put things in another way , the effects of pressure are not lost as @xmath76 , but rather pushed to @xmath144 , where they must be studied by a careful boundary - layer analysis . ( note : this is not a boundary - layer in the same sense as the background solution , nor is it a singular perturbation in the usual sense , at least as we have framed the problem here . ) [ newparam ] a significant difference from the shock case of @xcite is the appearance of the second parameter @xmath201 that survives in the @xmath76 limit . observe that the limiting coefficient matrix @xmath202 is nonhyperbolic ( in ode sense ) for all @xmath120 , having eigenvalues @xmath203 ; in particular , the stable manifold drops to dimension one in the limit @xmath76 , and so the prescription of an associated evans function is _ underdetermined_. this difficulty is resolved by a careful boundary - layer analysis in @xcite , determining a special `` slow stable '' mode @xmath204 augmenting the `` fast stable '' mode @xmath205 associated with the single stable eigenvalue @xmath206 of @xmath207 . this determines a _ limiting evans function _ @xmath208 by the prescription , of section [ evanssec ] , or alternatively via as @xmath209 with @xmath210 defined analogously as a solution of the adjoint limiting system lying asymptotically at @xmath144 in direction @xmath211 orthogonal to the span of @xmath212 and @xmath213 , where `` @xmath214 '' denotes complex conjugate , and @xmath215 defined as the solution of the limiting eigenvalue equations satisfying boundary condition , i.e. , @xmath216 . we have no such difficulties in the outflow case , since @xmath217 remains uniformly hyperbolic , and we may define a limiting evans function @xmath218 directly by , , , at least so long as @xmath201 remains bounded from zero . ( as perhaps already hinted by remark [ newparam ] , there are complications associated with the double limit @xmath219 . ) with the above definitions , we have the following main theorems characterizing the strong - layer limit @xmath76 as well as the limits @xmath220 . [ mainthm ] for @xmath221 and @xmath120 in any compact subset of @xmath140 , @xmath222 and @xmath223 converge uniformly to @xmath208 and @xmath224 as @xmath76 . [ main3 ] for @xmath120 in any compact subset of @xmath140 and @xmath25 bounded from @xmath26 , @xmath222 , appropriately renormalized by a nonvanishing analytic factor , converges uniformly as @xmath225 to the evans function for the ( unintegrated ) eigenvalue equations of the associated viscous shock wave connecting @xmath70 to @xmath25 ; likewise , @xmath224 , appropriately renormalized , converges uniformly as @xmath226 to the same limit for @xmath120 uniformly bounded away from zero . by similar computations , we obtain also the following direct result . [ main2 ] inflow boundary layers are stable for @xmath201 sufficiently small . we have also the following parity information , obtained by stability - index computations as in @xcite . [ index ] for any @xmath105 , @xmath201 , and @xmath25 , @xmath227 , hence the number of unstable roots of @xmath228 is even ; on the other hand @xmath229 and @xmath230 . likewise , @xmath231 , @xmath232 , @xmath233 , hence the number of nonzero unstable roots of @xmath234 , @xmath178 , @xmath218 is even . finally , we have the following auxiliary results established by energy estimates in appendices [ stronglimit ] , [ outnonv ] , [ char ] , and [ nonvanish - expansive - inflow ] . [ redenergy ] the limiting evans function @xmath234 is nonzero for @xmath235 on @xmath236 , for all @xmath237 . the limiting evans function @xmath218 is nonzero for @xmath235 on @xmath236 , for @xmath238 , where @xmath239 is determined by the functional equation @xmath240 . [ charsmallamp ] compressive outflow boundary layers are stable for @xmath25 sufficiently close to @xmath26 . [ expansive ] expansive inflow boundary layers are stable for all parameter values . collecting information , we have the following analytical stability results . [ v01 ] for @xmath201 or @xmath25 sufficiently small , compressive inflow boundary layers are stable . for @xmath201 sufficiently small , @xmath25 sufficiently close to @xmath26 , or @xmath241 and @xmath25 sufficiently small , compressive outflow layers are stable . expansive inflow boundary layers are stable for all parameter values . stability of inflow boundary layers in the characteristic limit @xmath242 is not treated here , but should be treatable analytically by the asymptotic ode methods used in @xcite to study the small - amplitude ( characteristic ) shock limit . this would be an interesting direction for future investigation . the characteristic limit is not accessible numerically , since the exponential decay rate of the background profile decays to zero as @xmath243 , so that the numerical domain of integration needed to resolve the eigenvalue ode becomes infinitely large as @xmath242 . [ weakreg ] stability in the noncharacteristic weak layer limit @xmath244 [ resp . @xmath26 ] in the inflow [ outflow ] case , for @xmath25 bounded away from the strong and characteristic limits @xmath246 and @xmath26 has already been established in @xcite . indeed , it is shown in @xcite that the evans function converges to that for a constant solution , and this is a _ regular _ perturbation . [ extra ] stability of @xmath234 , @xmath218 may also be determined numerically , in particular in the region @xmath247 not covered by proposition [ redenergy ] . the asymptotic results of section [ analytical ] reduce the problem of ( uniformly noncharacteristic , @xmath25 bounded away from @xmath70 ) boundary layer stability to a bounded parameter range on which the evans function may be efficiently computed numerically in a way that is uniformly well - conditioned ; see @xcite . specifically , we may map a semicircle @xmath248 enclosing @xmath249 for @xmath28 $ ] by @xmath234 , @xmath218 , @xmath228 , @xmath178 and compute the winding number of its image about the origin to determine the number of zeroes of the various evans functions within the semicircle , and thus within @xmath249 . for details of the numerical algorithm , see @xcite . in all cases , we obtain results consistent with stability ; that is , a winding number of zero or one , depending on the situation . in the case of a single nonzero root , we know from our limiting analysis that this root may be quite near @xmath32 , making delicate the direct determination of its stability ; however , in this case we do not attempt to determine the stability numerically , but rely on the analytically computed stability index to conclude stability . see section [ computations ] for further details . as in the shock case @xcite , our results indicate _ unconditional stability _ of uniformly noncharacteristic boundary - layers for isentropic navier stokes equations ( and , for outflow layer , in the characteristic limit as well ) , despite the additional complexity of the boundary - layer case . however , two additional comments are in order , perhaps related . first , we point out that the apparent symmetry of theorem [ main3 ] in the @xmath226 outflow and @xmath225 inflow limits is somewhat misleading . for , the limiting , shock evans function possesses a single zero at @xmath32 , indicating that stability of inflow boundary layers is somewhat delicate as @xmath225 : specifically , they have an eigenvalue near zero , which , though stable , is ( since vanishingly small in the shock limit ) not `` very '' stable . likewise , the limiting evans function @xmath234 as @xmath76 possesses a zero at @xmath32 , with the same conclusions . by contrast , the evans functions of outflow boundary layers possess a spurious zero at @xmath32 , so that convergence to the shock or strong - layer limit in this case implies the _ absence _ of any eigenvalues near zero , or `` uniform '' stability as @xmath76 . in this sense , strong outflow boundary layers appear to be more stable than inflow boundary layers . one may make interesting comparisons to physical attempts to stabilize laminar flow along an air- or hydro - foil by suction ( outflow ) along the boundary . see , for example , the interesting treatise @xcite . second , we point out the result of _ instability _ obtained in @xcite for inflow boundary - layers of the full ( nonisentropic ) ideal - gas equations for appropriate ratio of the coefficients of viscosity and heat conduction . this suggests that the small eigenvalues of the strong inflow - layer limit may in some cases perturb to the unstable side . it would be very interesting to make these connections more precise , as we hope to do in future work . since the structure of is essentially the same as that of the shock case , we may follow exactly the treatment in @xcite analyzing the flow of in the singular region @xmath48 . as we shall need the details for further computations ( specifically , the proof of theorem [ main2 ] ) , we repeat the analysis here in full . our starting point is the observation that @xmath250 is approximately block upper - triangular for @xmath107 sufficiently small , with diagonal blocks @xmath251 and @xmath252 that are uniformly spectrally separated on @xmath236 , as follows by @xmath253 we exploit this structure by a judicious coordinate change converting to a system in exact upper triangular form , for which the decoupled `` slow '' upper lefthand @xmath254 block undergoes a _ regular perturbation _ that can be analyzed by standard tools introduced in @xcite . meanwhile , the fast , lower righthand @xmath255 block , since scalar , may be solved exactly . we first block upper - triangularize by a static ( constant ) coordinate transformation the limiting matrix @xmath256 at @xmath144 using special block lower - triangular transformations @xmath257 where @xmath258 denotes the @xmath254 identity matrix and @xmath259 is a @xmath260 row vector . [ pretranslem ] on any compact subset of @xmath236 , for each @xmath261 sufficiently small , there exists a unique @xmath262 such that @xmath263 is upper block - triangular , @xmath264 where @xmath265 and @xmath266 , satisfying a uniform bound @xmath267 block of @xmath268 to zero , we obtain the matrix equation @xmath269 where @xmath270 , or , equivalently , the fixed - point equation @xmath271 by @xmath272 , @xmath273 is uniformly bounded on compact subsets of @xmath236 ( indeed , it is uniformly bounded on all of @xmath236 ) , whence , for @xmath274 bounded and @xmath25 sufficiently small , there exists a unique solution by the contraction mapping theorem , which , moreover , satisfies . defining now @xmath275 and @xmath276 we have converted to an asymptotically block upper - triangular system @xmath277 with @xmath278 as in . our next step is to choose a _ dynamic _ transformation of the same form @xmath279 converting to an exactly block upper - triangular system , with @xmath280 uniformly exponentially decaying at @xmath144 : that is , a _ regular perturbation _ of the identity . [ dyntranslem ] on any compact subset of @xmath236 , for @xmath190 sufficiently large and each @xmath261 sufficiently small , there exists a unique @xmath281 such that @xmath282 is upper block - triangular , @xmath283 and @xmath284 , satisfying a uniform bound @xmath285 independent of the choice of @xmath190 , @xmath25 . setting the @xmath286 block of @xmath287 to zero and computing @xmath288 we obtain the matrix equation @xmath289 where @xmath290 and the forcing term @xmath291 by derivative estimate @xmath292 together with the mean value theorem is uniformly exponentially decaying : @xmath293 initializing @xmath284 , we obtain by duhamel s principle / variation of constants the representation ( supressing the argument @xmath120 ) @xmath294 where @xmath295 is the solution operator for the homogeneous equation @xmath296 or , explicitly , @xmath297 for @xmath274 bounded and @xmath25 sufficiently small , we have by matrix perturbation theory that the eigenvalues of @xmath298 are small and the entries are bounded , hence @xmath299 for @xmath300 . recalling the uniform spectral gap @xmath301 for @xmath236 , we thus have @xmath302 . combining and , we obtain @xmath303 defining @xmath304 and recalling we thus have @xmath305 where @xmath306 is uniformly bounded , @xmath307 , and @xmath308 is contractive with arbitrarily small contraction constant @xmath309 in @xmath310 for @xmath311 for @xmath190 sufficiently large , by the calculation @xmath312 it follows by the contraction mapping principle that there exists a unique solution @xmath313 of fixed point equation with @xmath314 for @xmath315 , or , equivalently ( redefining the unspecified constant @xmath316 ) , . making now the further change of coordinates @xmath317 and computing @xmath318 we find that we have converted to a block - triangular system @xmath319 related to the original eigenvalue system by @xmath320 where @xmath321 since it is triangular , may be solved completely if we can solve the component systems associated with its diagonal blocks . the _ fast system _ @xmath322 associated to the lower righthand block features rapidly - varying coefficients . however , because it is scalar , it can be solved explicitly by exponentiation . the _ slow system _ @xmath323 associated to the upper lefthand block , on the other hand , by , is an exponentially decaying perturbation of a constant - coefficient system @xmath324 that can be explicitly solved by exponentiation , and thus can be well - estimated by comparison with . a rigorous version of this statement is given by the _ conjugation lemma _ of @xcite : [ conjugation ] let @xmath325 , with @xmath326 continuous in @xmath120 and @xmath327 , for @xmath120 in some compact set @xmath249 . then , there exists a globally invertible matrix @xmath328 such that the coordinate change @xmath329 converts the variable - coefficient ode @xmath330 to a constant - coefficient equation @xmath331 satisfying for any @xmath190 , @xmath332 a uniform bound @xmath333 see @xcite , or appendix c , @xcite . by proposition [ conjugation ] , the solution operator for is given by @xmath334 where @xmath335 is a uniformly small perturbation of the identity for @xmath315 and @xmath336 sufficiently large . with these preparations , we turn now to the proofs of the main theorems . we begin by recalling the following estimates established in @xcite on @xmath337 , that is , the value of the dual mode @xmath338 appearing in at the boundary @xmath339 between regular and singular regions . for completeness , and because we shall need the details in further computations , we repeat the proof in full . [ matching ] for @xmath120 on any compact subset of @xmath236 , and @xmath336 sufficiently large , with @xmath338 normalized as in @xcite , latexmath:[\[\label{wcon } @xmath76 , uniformly in @xmath120 , where @xmath66 , @xmath341 are independent of @xmath190 and @xmath342 is the limiting direction vector appearing in the definition of @xmath234 . [ matching2 ] under the hypotheses of lemma [ matching ] , latexmath:[\[\label{limcon } latexmath:[\[\label{wcon2 } as @xmath76 , uniformly in @xmath120 , where @xmath66 , @xmath341 are independent of @xmath190 and @xmath344 is the solution of the limiting adjoint eigenvalue system appearing in definition of @xmath345 . first , make the independent coordinate change @xmath346 normalizing the background wave to match the shock - wave case . making the dependent coordinate - change @xmath347 @xmath348 as in , reduces the adjoint equation @xmath349 to block lower - triangular form , @xmath350 with `` @xmath214 '' denoting complex conjugate . denoting by @xmath351 a suitably normalized element of the one - dimensional ( slow ) stable subspace of @xmath352 , we find readily ( see @xcite for further discussion ) that , without loss of generality , @xmath353 as @xmath76 , while the associated eigenvalue @xmath354 uniformly for @xmath120 on an compact subset of @xmath355 . the dual mode @xmath356 is uniquely determined by the property that it is asymptotic as @xmath48 to the corresponding constant - coefficient solution @xmath357 ( the standard normalization of @xcite ) . by lower block - triangular form , the equations for the slow variable @xmath358 decouples as a slow system @xmath359 dual to , with solution operator @xmath360 dual to , i.e. ( fixing @xmath361 , say ) , solutions of general form @xmath362 @xmath363 arbitrary . denoting by @xmath364 therefore , the unique ( up to constant factor ) decaying solution at @xmath59 , and @xmath365 , we thus have evidently @xmath366 which , as @xmath76 , is uniformly bounded by latexmath:[\[\label{weakexp } @xmath309 and , by , converges for @xmath7 less than or equal to @xmath368 for any fixed @xmath369 simply to @xmath370 defining by @xmath371 the fast coordinate of @xmath372 , we have , by , @xmath373 whence , by duhamel s principle , any decaying solution is given by @xmath374 where @xmath375 recalling , for @xmath236 , that @xmath376 , combining and , and noting that @xmath72 converges uniformly on @xmath377 as @xmath76 for any @xmath378 to @xmath379 we obtain by the lebesgue dominated convergence theorem that @xmath380 recalling , finally , , and the fact that @xmath381 for @xmath25 sufficiently small , we obtain as claimed . again , make the coordinate change @xmath346 normalizing the background wave to match the shock - wave case . applying proposition [ conjugation ] to the limiting adjoint system @xmath382 we find that , up to an @xmath383 coordinate change , @xmath384 is given by the exact solution @xmath385 of the limiting , constant - coefficient system @xmath386 this yields immediately , which , together with , yields . the rest of our analysis is standard . [ regconj ] on @xmath387 for any fixed @xmath336 , there exists a coordinate - change @xmath388 conjugating to the limiting equations , @xmath389 , satisfying a uniform bound latexmath:[\[\label{tbd } make the coordinate change @xmath346 normalizing the background profile . for @xmath391 $ ] , this is a consequence of the _ convergence lemma _ of @xcite , a variation on proposition [ conjugation ] , together with uniform convergence of the profile and eigenvalue equations . for @xmath392 $ ] , it is essentially continuous dependence ; more precisely , observing that @xmath393 for @xmath392 $ ] , setting @xmath394 , and writing the homological equation expressing conjugacy of and , we obtain @xmath395 which , considered as an inhomogeneous linear matrix - valued equation , yields an exponential growth bound @xmath396 for some @xmath118 , giving the result . make the coordinate change @xmath346 normalizing the background profile . lemma [ regconj ] , together with convergence as @xmath76 of the unstable subspace of @xmath397 to the unstable subspace of @xmath398 at the same rate @xmath399 ( as follows by spectral separation of the unstable eigenvalue of @xmath400 and standard matrix perturbation theory ) yields @xmath401 gives @xmath402 where @xmath403 denotes the solution operator of the limiting adjoint eigenvalue equation @xmath404 . applying proposition [ conjugation ] to the limiting system , we obtain @xmath405 by direct computation of @xmath406 , where @xmath407 is independent of @xmath336 . together with and , this gives latexmath:[\[|\tilde w_1^+(0,\lambda)- \tilde w_1^{0+}(0,\lambda)|\le c(l)v_+ @xmath274 bounded , @xmath409 taking first @xmath410 and then @xmath76 , we obtain therefore convergence of @xmath411 and @xmath412 to @xmath413 and @xmath414 , yielding the result by definitions and . straightforward , following the previous argument in the regular region only . first make the coordinate change @xmath346 normalizing the background profile location to that of the shock wave case , where @xmath415 as @xmath225 . by standard duality properties , @xmath416 is independent of @xmath417 , so we may evaluate at @xmath12 as in the shock case . denote by @xmath418 , @xmath419 the corresponding modes in the shock case , and @xmath420 the resulting evans function . noting that @xmath421 and @xmath422 are asymptotic to the unique stable mode at @xmath59 of the ( same ) adjoint eigenvalue equation , but with translated decay rates , we see immediately that @xmath423 @xmath424 on the other hand is initialized at @xmath425 ( in the new coordinates @xmath426 ) as @xmath427 whereas @xmath418 is the unique unstable mode at @xmath60 decaying as @xmath428 , where @xmath429 is the unstable right eigenvector of @xmath430 denote by @xmath431 the associated dual unstable left eigenvector and @xmath432 the eigenprojection onto the stable vector @xmath433 . by direct computation , @xmath434 yielding @xmath435 for @xmath436 , on which @xmath437 . once we know , we may finish by a standard argument , concluding by exponential attraction in the positive @xmath7-direction of the unstable mode that other modes decay exponentially as @xmath438 , leaving the contribution from @xmath439 plus a negligible @xmath440 error , @xmath341 , from which we may conclude that @xmath441 collecting information , we find that @xmath442 @xmath341 , yielding the claimed convergence as @xmath225 , @xmath443 . for @xmath120 uniformly bounded from zero , @xmath444 converges uniformly as @xmath226 to @xmath445 whereas the shock evans function @xmath446 is initiated by @xmath447 proportional to @xmath448 agreeing in the first two coordinates with @xmath449 . by the boundary - layer analysis of section [ estw1 ] , the backward ( i.e. , decreasing @xmath7 ) evolution of the adjoint eigenvalue ode reduces in the asymptotic limit @xmath76 ( forced by @xmath226 ) to a decoupled slow flow @xmath450 in the first two coordinates , driving an exponentially slaved fast flow in the third coordinate . from this , we may conclude that solutions agreeing in the first two coordinates converge exponentially as @xmath7 decreases . performing an appropriate normalization , as in the inflow case just treated , we thus obtain the result . we omit the details , which follow what has already been done in previous cases . following @xcite , we note that @xmath222 is real for real @xmath120 , and nonvanishing for real @xmath120 sufficiently large , hence @xmath451 is well - defined and constant on the entire ( connected ) parameter range . the number of roots of @xmath228 on @xmath140 is therefore even or odd depending on the _ stability index _ @xmath452.\ ] ] similarly , recalling that @xmath453 , we find that the number of roots of @xmath178 on @xmath140 is even or odd depending on @xmath454.\ ] ] examining the adjoint equation at @xmath32 , @xmath455 @xmath456 , we find by explicit computation that the only solutions that are bounded as @xmath48 are the _ constant solutions _ @xmath457 . taking the limit @xmath458 as @xmath459 along the real axis of the unique stable eigenvector of @xmath460 , we find ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) that it lies in the direction @xmath461 , where @xmath462 is the positive characteristic speed of the hyperbolic convection matrix @xmath463 , i.e. , @xmath464 , @xmath465 . thus , @xmath466 as claimed . on the other hand , the same computation carried out for @xmath467 yields @xmath468 . ( note : @xmath469 as @xmath76 . ) similarly , as @xmath226 , @xmath470 finally , note @xmath227 implies that the stability index , since continuously varying so long as it does nt vanish and taking discrete values @xmath471 , must be constant on the connected set of parameter values . since inflow boundary layers are known to be stable on some part of the parameter regime by energy estimates ( theorem [ main2 ] ) , we may conclude that the stability index is identically one and therefore there are an even number of unstable roots for all @xmath472 . to establish that @xmath473 , we compute @xmath474 since @xmath475 is independent of @xmath120 , we need only show that the first component of @xmath476 is nonzero . note that @xmath477 solves the limiting adjoint variational equations @xmath478 with @xmath479 by , and the fact that @xmath480 , @xmath481 is chosen so that asymptotically at @xmath144 it lies in the direction of @xmath482 . . then the third component solves @xmath484 which has solution @xmath485 where @xmath486 integrating the equation for the first component of @xmath487 yields @xmath488 using the condition @xmath489 we have @xmath490 so that @xmath491 finally , note that by using we have @xmath492 so that for all @xmath493 , @xmath494 which implies @xmath495 [ apparent ] the result @xmath227 at first sight appears to contradict that of theorem [ main3 ] , since @xmath496 for the shock wave case . this apparent contradiction is explained by the fact that the normalizing factor @xmath497 is exponentially decaying in @xmath111 for @xmath32 , since @xmath498 , while @xmath499 . recalling that @xmath443 as @xmath225 , we recover the result of theorem [ main3 ] . similarly , we compute @xmath500 where @xmath501 satisfies the variational equation @xmath502 , or , written as a first - order system , @xmath503 which may be solved exactly for the unique solution decaying at @xmath60 of @xmath504 recalling from that @xmath505 , hence @xmath506 we thus find that @xmath507 as claimed . the proof that @xmath233 goes similarly . finally , as in the proof of the inflow case , we note that nonvanishing implies that the stability index is constant across the entire ( connected ) parameter range , hence we may conclude that it is identically one by existence of a stable case ( corollary [ v01 ] ) , and therefore that the number of nonzero unstable roots is even , as claimed . by proposition [ redenergy ] we find that @xmath228 has at most a single zero in @xmath140 . however , by our stability index results , theorem [ index ] , the number of eigenvalues in @xmath140 is even . thus , it must be zero , giving the result . by theorem [ main3 ] , @xmath178 , suitably renormalized , converges as @xmath226 to the evans function for the ( unintegrated ) shock wave case . but , the shock evans function by the results of @xcite has just a single zero at @xmath32 on @xmath436 , already accounted for in @xmath178 by the spurious root at @xmath32 introduced by recoordinatization to `` good unknown '' . finally , we treat the remaining , `` corner case '' as @xmath25 , @xmath201 simultaneously approach zero . the fact ( lemma [ index ] ) that @xmath508 shows that this limit is quite delicate ; indeed , this is the most delicate part of our analysis . consider again the adjoint system @xmath509 by the boundary analysis of section [ estw1 ] , @xmath510 where @xmath511 , and @xmath512 is the unique stable eigenvalue of @xmath513 , satisfying ( by matrix perturbation calculation ) @xmath514 and thus @xmath515 as @xmath226 ( hence @xmath76 ) on bounded subsets of @xmath140 . combining these expansions , we have @xmath516 for @xmath201 sufficiently small . from the @xmath517 equation @xmath518 , we thus obtain @xmath519 observing , finally , that , for @xmath140 , the ratio of real to imaginary parts of @xmath520 is uniformly positive , we find that @xmath521 for @xmath201 sufficiently small , which yields nonvanishing of @xmath222 on @xmath140 as claimed . in this section , we show , through a systematic numerical evans function study , that there are no unstable eigenvalues for @xmath522\times(0,1],\ ] ] in either inflow or outflow cases . as defined in section [ evanssec ] , the evans function is analytic in the right - half plane and reports a value of zero precisely at the eigenvalues of the linearized operator . hence we can use the argument principle to determine if there are any unstable eigenvalues for this system . our approach closely follows that of @xcite for the shock case with only two major differences . first , our shooting algorithm is only one sided as we have the boundary conditions and for the inflow and outflow cases , respectfully . second , we `` correct '' for the displacement in the boundary layer when @xmath523 in the inflow case and @xmath524 in the outflow case so that the evans function converges to the shock case as studied in @xcite ( see discussion in section [ sectionshocklimit ] ) . @xmath525{inflow1 } & \includegraphics[width=6.4cm , height=4.5cm]{inflow2 } \\ \mbox{\bf ( a ) } & \mbox{\bf ( b)}\\ \includegraphics[width=5.75cm]{inflow3 } & \includegraphics[width=5.6cm]{inflow4 } \\ \mbox{\bf ( c ) } & \mbox{\bf ( d ) } \end{array}$ ] the profiles were generated using matlab s bvp4c routine , which is an adaptive lobatto quadrature scheme . the shooting portion of the evans function computation was performed using matlab s ode45 package , which is the standard 4th order adaptive runge - kutta - fehlberg method ( rkf45 ) . the error tolerances for both the profiles and the shooting were set to abstol=1e-6 and reltol=1e-8 . we remark that kato s ode ( see section [ evanssec ] and @xcite for details ) is used to analytically choose the initial eigenbasis for the stable / unstable manifolds at the numerical values of infinity at @xmath526 . finally in section [ errorstudy ] , we carry out a numerical convergence study similar to that in @xcite . @xmath527{outflow1 } & \includegraphics[width=5.75cm]{outflow2 } \\ \mbox{\bf ( a ) } & \mbox{\bf ( b)}\\ \includegraphics[width=5.75cm]{outflow3 } & \includegraphics[width=5.3cm]{outflow4 } \\ \mbox{\bf ( c ) } & \mbox{\bf ( d ) } \end{array}$ ] the high - frequency estimates in proposition [ hf ] restrict the set of admissible unstable eigenvalues to a fixed compact triangle @xmath249 in the right - half plane ( see and for the inflow and outflow cases , respectively ) . we reiterate the remarkable property that @xmath249 does not depend on the choice of @xmath25 or @xmath201 . hence , to demonstrate stability for a given @xmath0 , @xmath25 and @xmath201 , it suffices to show that the winding number of the evans function along a contour containing @xmath249 is zero . note that in our region of interest , @xmath528 $ ] , the semi - circular contour given by @xmath529 contains @xmath249 in both the inflow and outflow cases . hence , for consistency we use this same semicircle for all of our winding number computations . a remarkable feature of the evans function for this system , and one that is shared with the shock case in @xcite , is that the evans function has limiting behavior as the amplitude increases , section [ analytical ] . for the inflow case , we see in figure [ first ] , the mapping of the contour @xmath530 for the monatomic case ( @xmath531 ) , for several different choices of @xmath201 , as @xmath532 . we remark that the winding numbers for @xmath533 are all zero , and the limiting contour touches zero due to the emergence of a zero root in the limit . note that the limiting case contains the contours of all other amplitudes . hence , we have spectral stability for all amplitudes . the outflow case likewise has a limiting behavior , however , all contours cross through zero due to the eigenvalue at the origin . nonetheless , since the contours only wind around once , we can likewise conclude that these profiles are spectrally stable . we remark that the outflow case converges to the limiting case faster than the inflow case as is clear from figure [ second1 ] . indeed , @xmath534 and the limiting case @xmath535 , as well as all of the values of @xmath25 in between , are virtually indistinguishable . @xmath527{index1 } & \includegraphics[width=5.75cm]{index2 } \\ \mbox{\bf ( a ) } & \mbox{\bf ( b ) } \end{array}$ ] in our study , we systematically varied @xmath201 in the interval @xmath536 $ ] and took the @xmath532 limit at each step , starting from a @xmath537 ( or some other appropriate value , for example when @xmath538 ) on the small - amplitude end and decreased @xmath25 steadily to @xmath539 for @xmath540 , followed by evaluation at @xmath535 . for both inflow and outflow cases , over @xmath541 contours were computed . we remark that in the @xmath532 limit , the system becomes pressureless , and thus all of the contours in the large - amplitude limit look the same regardless of the value of @xmath0 chosen . as an additional verification of stability , we computed the evans function along the unstable real axis on the interval @xmath542 $ ] for varying parameters to show that there are no real unstable eigenvalues . since the evans function has a root at the origin in the limiting system for the inflow case , and for all values of @xmath25 in the outflow case , we can perform in these cases a sort of _ numerical stability index analysis _ to verify that the evans function cuts transversely through the origin and is otherwise nonzero , indicating that there are no unstable real eigenvalues as expected . in figure [ second2 ] , we see a typical example of @xmath543 the inflow and @xmath544 outflow cases . note that in both images , the evans function cuts transversally through the origin and is otherwise nonzero as @xmath120 increases . @xmath545{limit1 } & \includegraphics[width=5.9cm]{limit2 } \\ \mbox{\bf ( a ) } & \mbox{\bf ( b ) } \end{array}$ ] when @xmath201 is far from the midpoint @xmath546 of the end states , the the evans function of the boundary layer is similar to the evans function of the shock case evaluated at the displacement point @xmath417 . hence , when we compute the boundary layer evans function near the shock limits , @xmath523 for the inflow case and @xmath524 for the outflow case , we multiply for the correction factor @xmath547 so that our output looks close to that of the shock case studied in @xcite . the correction factors are @xmath548 for the inflow case and @xmath549 for the outflow case , where @xmath550 is the growth mode of @xmath551 and @xmath552 is the decay mode of @xmath198 . in figure [ second3 ] , we see that these highly displaced profiles appear to be very similar to the shock cases with one notable difference . these images have a small dimple near @xmath32 to account for the eigenvalue there , whereas those in the shock case @xcite were computed in integrated coordinates and thus have no root at the origin . ccccccc + @xmath190 & @xmath553 & @xmath554 & @xmath555 & @xmath556 & @xmath557 & @xmath558 + 8 & 7.8(-1 ) & 8.4(-1 ) & 9.2(-1 ) & 1.0(0 ) & 1.2(0 ) & 1.3(0 ) + 10 & 1.4(-1 ) & 1.2(-1 ) & 9.2(-2 ) & 6.8(-2 ) & 4.4(-2 ) & 2.8(-2 ) + 12 & 1.4(-2 ) & 7.9(-3 ) & 3.6(-3 ) & 1.3(-3 ) & 3.1(-4 ) & 7.3(-5 ) + 14 & 1.3(-3 ) & 4.9(-4 ) & 1.3(-4 ) & 2.4(-5 ) & 8.7(-6 ) & 8.2(-6 ) + 16 & 1.2(-4 ) & 3.0(-5 ) & 4.7(-6 ) & 2.8(-6 ) & 2.7(-6 ) & 2.6(-6 ) + 18 & 1.1(-5 ) & 5.8(-6 ) & 8.0(-6 ) & 8.1(-6 ) & 8.0(-6 ) & 8.0(-6 ) + + @xmath190 & @xmath553 & @xmath554 & @xmath555 & @xmath556 & @xmath557 & @xmath558 + 8 & 5.4(-3 ) & 5.4(-3 ) & 5.4(-3 ) & 5.4(-3 ) & 5.4(-3 ) & 5.4(-3 ) + 10 & 9.2(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) + 12 & 1.5(-4 ) & 1.5(-4 ) & 1.5(-4 ) & 1.5(-4 ) & 1.5(-4 ) & 1.5(-4 ) + 14 & 2.5(-5 ) & 2.7(-5 ) & 2.0(-5 ) & 2.0(-5 ) & 2.0(-5 ) & 2.0(-5 ) + 16 & 2.3(-6 ) & 2.6(-6 ) & 2.6(-6 ) & 2.5(-6 ) & 2.5(-6 ) & 2.5(-6 ) + 18 & 6.6(-6 ) & 3.6(-6 ) & 8.7(-6 ) & 8.7(-6 ) & 8.7(-6 ) & 8.7(-6 ) + ccccccc + abs / rel & @xmath553 & @xmath554 & @xmath555 & @xmath556 & @xmath557 & @xmath558 + @xmath559 & 5.4(-4 ) & 4.1(-4 ) & 4.0(-4 ) & 5.0(-4 ) & 3.4(-4 ) & 8.6(-4 ) + @xmath560 & 3.1(-5 ) & 4.6(-5 ) & 3.4(-5 ) & 3.3(-5 ) & 3.3(-5 ) & 3.2(-5 ) + @xmath561 & 2.9(-6 ) & 3.6(-6 ) & 3.9(-6 ) & 6.8(-6 ) & 2.7(-6 ) & 2.5(-6 ) + @xmath562 & 4.6(-7 ) & 9.9(-7 ) & 1.1(-6 ) & 6.0(-7 ) & 2.9(-7 ) & 3.2(-7 ) + + abs / rel & @xmath553 & @xmath554 & @xmath555 & @xmath556 & @xmath557 & @xmath558 + @xmath559 & 9.2(-4 ) & 9.2(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.1(-4 ) & 9.2(-4 ) + @xmath560 & 5.3(-5 ) & 4.9(-5 ) & 5.3(-5 ) & 5.3(-5 ) & 5.3(-5 ) & 5.3(-5 ) + @xmath561 & 6.7(-5 ) & 6.7(-5 ) & 6.7(-5 ) & 6.7(-5 ) & 6.7(-5 ) & 6.7(-5 ) + @xmath562 & 2.9(-6 ) & 2.9(-6 ) & 2.9(-6 ) & 2.9(-6 ) & 2.9(-6 ) & 2.9(-6 ) + as in @xcite , we carry out a numerical convergence study to show that our results are accurate . we varied the absolute and relative error tolerances , as well as the length of the numerical domain @xmath563 $ ] . in tables 12 , we demonstrate that our choices of @xmath564 , abstol=1e-6 and reltol=1e-8 provide accurate results . our starting point is remark [ shockrel ] , in which we observed that the first - order eigensystem in variable @xmath565 may be converted by the rescaling @xmath566 to a system identical to that of the integrated equations in the shock case ; see @xcite . artificially defining @xmath567 , we obtain a system [ ep ] @xmath568 identical to that in the integrated shock case @xcite , but with boundary conditions @xmath569 imposed at @xmath12 . this new eigenvalue problem differs spectrally from only at @xmath32 , hence spectral stability of is implied by spectral stability of . hereafter , we drop the tildes , and refer simply to @xmath5 , @xmath570 . with these coordinates , we may establish by exactly the same argument used in the shock case in @xcite , for completeness reproduced here . the following identity holds for @xmath571 : @xmath572 we multiply by @xmath573 and integrate along @xmath7 . this yields @xmath574 we get by taking the real and imaginary parts and adding them together , and noting that @xmath575 . [ kawashima ] the following identity holds for @xmath571 : @xmath576 |v'|^2\ ] ] we multiply by @xmath577 and integrate along @xmath7 . this yields @xmath578 using on the right - hand side , integrating by parts , and taking the real part gives @xmath579 = { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\left[\frac{h(\bv)}{\bv^{\gamma+1 } } + \frac{\bv_x}{2 \bv^2 } \right ] |v'|^2 + \r(\lambda){\int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\frac{|v'|^2}{\bv}.\ ] ] the right hand side can be rewritten as @xmath580 = \frac{1}{2 } { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\left[\frac{h(\bv)}{\bv^{\gamma+1 } } + \frac{a\gamma}{\bv^{\gamma+1 } } \right ] |v'|^2 + \r(\lambda){\int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\frac{|v'|^2}{\bv}.\ ] ] now we manipulate the left - hand side . note that @xmath581 hence , by taking the real part we get @xmath579 = { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}|u'|^2 - 2\r(\lambda)^2 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}|v|^2.\ ] ] this combines with to give . [ hlem ] for @xmath582 as in , we have @xmath583 where @xmath584 is the profile solution to . defining @xmath585 we have @xmath586 for @xmath587 , hence the maximum of @xmath588 on @xmath589 $ ] is achieved at @xmath590 . substituting into and simplifying yields . using young s inequality twice on right - hand side of together with , we get @xmath591 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\bv |u|^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming that @xmath592 and @xmath593 , this simplifies to @xmath594 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\bv @xmath595 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^+}}\bv |u|^2,\ ] ] or equivalently , @xmath596 setting @xmath597 gives . similarly as in the inflow case , we can convert the eigenvalue equations into the integrated equations as in the shock case ; see @xcite . artificially defining @xmath598 , we obtain a system [ outep ] @xmath599 identical to that in the integrated shock case @xcite , but with boundary conditions @xmath600 imposed at @xmath12 . we shall write @xmath601 for @xmath602 , for any function @xmath603 . this new eigenvalue problem differs spectrally from only at @xmath32 , hence spectral stability of is implied by spectral stability of . hereafter , we drop the tildes , and refer simply to @xmath5 , @xmath570 . the following identity holds for @xmath571 : @xmath604 we multiply by @xmath573 and integrate along @xmath7 . this yields @xmath605 we get by taking the real and imaginary parts and adding them together , and noting that @xmath606 . [ outkawashima ] the following inequality holds for @xmath607 : @xmath608 |v'|^2 & + \r(\lambda){\int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\frac{|v'|^2}{\bv}+ \frac { |v'_0|^2}{4\bv_0 } + 2\r\lambda ^2{\int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}|v|^2\notag \\&\le { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}|u'|^2 + \bv_0|u_0|^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we multiply by @xmath577 and integrate along @xmath7 . this yields @xmath609 using on the right - hand side , integrating by parts , and taking the real part gives @xmath610 = { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\left[\frac{h(\bv)}{\bv^{\gamma+1 } } + \frac{\bv_x}{2 \bv^2 } \right ] { |v'_0|^2}{2\bv_0}.\ ] ] the right hand side can be rewritten as @xmath611 \notag\\&= \frac{1}{2 } { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\left[\frac{h(\bv)}{\bv^{\gamma+1 } } + \frac{a\gamma}{\bv^{\gamma+1 } } \right ] |v'|^2 + \r(\lambda){\int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\frac{|v'|^2}{\bv}+ \frac { |v'_0|^2}{2\bv_0}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we manipulate the left - hand side . note that @xmath612 hence , by taking the real part and noting that @xmath613 we get @xmath610 = { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}|u'|^2 - 2\r\lambda ^2{\int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}|v|^2 - \r\lambda |v_0|^2 + \r(\lambda u_0\bar v_0).\ ] ] this combines with to give @xmath614 |v'|^2 & + \r(\lambda){\int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\frac{|v'|^2}{\bv}+ \frac { |v'_0|^2}{2\bv_0 } + 2\r\lambda ^2{\int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}|v|^2\\ & + \r\lambda we get by observing that and young s inequality yield @xmath615 here we used @xmath616 . note that @xmath617 and @xmath618 . using young s inequality twice on right - hand side of together with , and denoting the boundary term on the right by @xmath619 , we get @xmath620 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\bv |u|^2+i_b.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we treat the boundary term by @xmath621 therefore using , we simply obtain from the above estimates @xmath622 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\bv |u|^2+\frac 1\theta |\alpha|^2 \bv_0|u_0|^2\\ & < 2\theta { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}|u'|^2 + \left[\frac{\gamma}{2\theta } + \frac{1}{4 \epsilon}\right ] { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\bv |u|^2+j_b\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath623 assuming that @xmath624 , this simplifies to @xmath625 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\bv |u|^2+j_b.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath626 . therefore for @xmath627 , we get @xmath628 and @xmath629 for sake of simplicity , choose @xmath630 and @xmath631 . this shows that @xmath632 can be absorbed into the left by the term @xmath633 and thus we get @xmath634 { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\bv |u|^2 = \left [ 3\gamma+ \frac{3}{8}\right ] { \int_{\mathbb{r}^-}}\bv |u|^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] provided that @xmath635 . this shows @xmath636 working in @xmath637 variables as in , the limiting eigenvalue system and boundary conditions take the form [ limitep ] @xmath638 corresponding to a pressureless gas , @xmath181 , with @xmath639 hereafter , we drop the tildes . multiplying by @xmath640 and integrating on @xmath641\subset\mathbb{r}^+$ ] , we obtain @xmath642 integrating the third and fourth terms by parts yields @xmath643 u'\bar{u } dx \\ & \quad+ \int^b_0 \frac{|u'|^2}{1-\bv } dx + \int^b_0 v ( \overline{\lambda v + v ' } ) dx \\ & = \left [ v \bar{u } + \frac{u'\bar{u}}{1-\bv } \right ] \big|^b_0.\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the real part , we have @xmath644 |u|^2 - \frac{|v|^2 } { 2 } \right ] \big|^b_0,\label{mnen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath645.\ ] ] note that @xmath646 thus , @xmath647 and the third term on the right - hand side vanishes , leaving @xmath648 \big|^b_0\\ & \quad = \left [ \r(v \bar{u } ) + \frac{\r(u'\bar{u})}{1-\bv } - \frac{|v|^2 } { 2 } \right](b).\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] we show finally that the right - hand side goes to zero in the limit as @xmath649 . by proposition [ conjugation ] , the behavior of @xmath5 , @xmath570 near @xmath650 is governed by the limiting constant coefficient systems @xmath651 , where @xmath652 and @xmath653 . in particular , solutions @xmath134 asymptotic to @xmath654 at @xmath144 decay exponentially in @xmath655 and are bounded in coordinate @xmath5 as @xmath48 . observing that @xmath656 as @xmath48 , we thus see immediately that the boundary contribution at @xmath657 vanishes as @xmath658 . thus , in the limit as @xmath658 , @xmath659 but , for @xmath355 , this implies @xmath660 , or @xmath661 , which , by @xmath662 , implies @xmath663 . this reduces to @xmath664 , yielding the explicit solution @xmath665 . by @xmath666 , therefore , @xmath667 for @xmath355 . substituting into , we obtain @xmath668 . it follows that there are no nontrivial solutions of , for @xmath355 except at @xmath32 . [ symmetrizers ] the above energy estimate is essentially identical to that used in @xcite to treat the limiting shock case . working in @xmath637 variables as in , the limiting eigenvalue system and boundary conditions take the form [ outlimitep ] @xmath669 corresponding to a pressureless gas , @xmath181 , with @xmath670 @xmath671 in particular , @xmath672 hereafter , we drop the tildes . multiplying by @xmath640 and integrating on @xmath673\subset\mathbb{r}^-$ ] , we obtain @xmath674 integrating the third and fourth terms by parts yields @xmath675 u'\bar{u } dx \\ & \quad+ \int^0_a \frac{|u'|^2}{1-\bv } dx + \int^0_a v ( \overline{\lambda v + v ' } ) dx \\ & = \left [ v \bar{u } + \frac{u'\bar{u}}{1-\bv } \right ] \big|^0_a.\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the real part , we have @xmath676 |u|^2 - \frac{|v|^2 } { 2 } \right ] \big|^0_a,\label{mnen2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath645\equiv 0\ ] ] and the third term on the right - hand side vanishes , as shown in section [ stronglimit ] , leaving @xmath677 \big|^0_a.\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] a boundary analysis similar to that of section [ stronglimit ] shows that the contribution at @xmath72 on the righthand side vanishes as @xmath678 ; see @xcite for details . thus , in the limit as @xmath678 we obtain @xmath679 ( 0)\\ & \quad = \left[(1-v_0)\r(v \bar{u } ) - \frac{|v|^2 } { 2 } \right ] ( 0),\\ & \quad \le \left[(1- v_0 ) |v||u| - \frac{|v|^2 } { 2}\right](0)\\ & \quad \le ( 1- v_0 ) ^2\frac{|u(0)|^2}{2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second equality follows by and the final line by young s inequality . next , observe the sobolev - type bound @xmath680 together with @xmath681 hence @xmath682 for @xmath683 , where @xmath684 is the unique solution of @xmath685 thus , for @xmath683 , @xmath686 for @xmath687 . for @xmath355 , this implies @xmath660 , or @xmath661 , which , by @xmath688 , implies @xmath689 . this reduces to @xmath664 , yielding the explicit solution @xmath665 . by @xmath666 , therefore , @xmath667 for @xmath355 . it follows that there are no nontrivial solutions of , for @xmath355 except at @xmath32 . by iteration , starting with @xmath690 , we obtain first @xmath691 then @xmath692 , then @xmath693 , then @xmath694 , then @xmath695 and @xmath696 , terminating with @xmath697 . [ smallcase ] our evans function results show that the case @xmath201 small not treated corresponds to the shock limit for which stability is already known by @xcite . this suggests that a more sophisticated energy estimate combining the above with a boundary - layer analysis from @xmath12 back to @xmath339 might yield nonvanishing for all @xmath237 . we now show stability of compressive outflow boundary layers in the characteristic limit @xmath242 , by essentially the same energy estimate used in @xcite to show stability of small - amplitude shock waves . as in the above section on the outflow case , we obtain a system [ charep ] @xmath698 identical to that in the integrated shock case @xcite , but with boundary conditions @xmath671 in particular , @xmath699 this new eigenvalue problem differs spectrally from only at @xmath32 , hence spectral stability of is implied by spectral stability of . hereafter , we drop the tildes , and refer simply to @xmath5 , @xmath570 . [ proof of proposition [ charsmallamp ] ] we note that @xmath700 . by multiplying by both the conjugate @xmath701 and @xmath702 and integrating along @xmath7 from @xmath60 to @xmath246 , we have @xmath703 integrating the last three terms by parts and appropriately using to substitute for @xmath704 in the third term gives us @xmath705\big|_{x=0}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we take the real part and appropriately integrate by parts to get @xmath706 } dx } + { \int_{-\infty}^0 { g(\bv ) |u|^2 } dx } + { \int_{-\infty}^0 { \frac{\bv^\gamma}{h(\bv)}|u'|^2 } dx}= g(0),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath707\ ] ] and @xmath708|u|^2 + \r\left[v\bar u+\frac{v^\gamma u'\bar u}{h(\bv)}\right ] - \frac{|v|^2}{2}\ ] ] evaluated at @xmath12 . here , the boundary term appearing on the righthand side is the only difference from the corresponding estimate appearing in the treatment of the shock case in @xcite . we shall show that as @xmath709 , the boundary term @xmath710 is nonpositive . observe that boundary conditions yield @xmath711\big|_{x=0 } = \r(v(0)\bar u(0))\left[1+\frac{\bv^\gamma \bv'}{h(\bv)}\right]\big|_{x=0}.\ ] ] we first note , as established in @xcite , that @xmath712 on @xmath713 $ ] , under certain conditions including the case @xmath709 . straightforward computation gives identities : @xmath714 using and , we abbreviate a few intermediate steps below : @xmath715\right]\notag\\ & = -\frac{\bv_x}{2}\left [ \frac{\bv^\gamma\left((\gamma+1)h(\bv ) - \bv h'(\bv)\right)}{h(\bv)^2 } + \frac{d}{d\bv}\left [ \frac{\gamma h(\bv)-\bv h'(\bv)}{h(\bv)^2 } ( a\gamma - h(\bv ) ) \right]\right]\notag\\ & = -\frac{a\bv_x\bv^{\gamma-1}}{2 h(\bv)^3 } \times\notag\\ & \qquad\left [ \gamma^2(\gamma+1)\bv^{\gamma+2 } - 2 ( a+1)\gamma(\gamma^2 - 1)\bv^{\gamma+1}+(a+1)^2\gamma^2(\gamma-1)\bv^\gamma\right.\notag\\ & \qquad\qquad + \left . a\gamma(\gamma+2)(\gamma^2 - 1)\bv - a ( a+1 ) \gamma^2 ( \gamma^2 - 1 ) \right]\notag\\ & = -\frac{a\bv_x\bv^{\gamma-1}}{2 h(\bv)^3}[(\gamma+1)\bv^{\gamma+2}+\bv^\gamma(\gamma-1)\left((\gamma+1)\bv-(a+1)\gamma\right)^2 \label{charpremn}\\ & \qquad + a\gamma(\gamma^2 - 1)(\gamma+2)\bv - a ( a+1)\gamma^2(\gamma^2 - 1)]\notag\\ & \geq -\frac{a\bv_x\bv^{\gamma-1}}{2 h(\bv)^3}[(\gamma+1)\bv^{\gamma+2}+ a\gamma(\gamma^2 - 1)(\gamma+2)\bv - a ( a+1)\gamma^2(\gamma^2 - 1)]\notag\\ & \geq-\frac{\gamma^2 a^3 \bv_x ( \gamma+1)}{2 h(\bv)^3 v_+}\left[\left(\frac{v_+^{\gamma+1}}{a\gamma}\right)^2 + 2(\gamma-1)\left(\frac{v_+^{\gamma+1}}{a\gamma}\right)-(\gamma-1)\right].\label{charmn}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this verifies @xmath716 as @xmath709 . second , examine @xmath717|u(0)|^2+\left[1+\frac{\bv^\gamma \bv'}{h(\bv)}\right]\r(v(0)\bar u(0))- \frac{|v(0)|^2}{2}.\ ] ] applying young s inequality to the middle term , we easily get @xmath718|u(0)|^2 = : -\frac 12 i|u(0)|^2.\ ] ] now observe that @xmath258 can be written as @xmath719\bv ' - \frac{\bv^\gamma h'(\bv)}{h^2(\bv)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using and , we get @xmath720 and thus @xmath721\bv ' - \frac{\bv^\gamma h'(\bv)}{h^2(\bv)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now since @xmath722 , as @xmath723 , @xmath724 . therefore , as @xmath725 is close to @xmath26 , @xmath726 . this , @xmath727 , and give , as @xmath725 is close enough to @xmath26 , @xmath728 } dx } & + { \int_{-\infty}^0 { \frac{\bv^\gamma}{h(\bv)}|u'|^2 } dx}\le 0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which evidently gives stability as claimed . for completeness , we recall the argument of @xcite in the expansive inflow case . * profile equation . * note that , in the expansive inflow case , we assume @xmath729 . therefore we can still follow the scaling to get @xmath730 l. q. brin and k. zumbrun . analytically varying eigenvectors and the stability of viscous shock waves . , 22:1932 , 2002 . seventh workshop on partial differential equations , part i ( rio de janeiro , 2001 ) . k. zumbrun . stability of large - amplitude shock waves of compressible navier - stokes equations . in _ handbook of mathematical fluid dynamics . iii _ , pages 311533 . north - holland , amsterdam , 2004 . with an appendix by helge kristian jenssen and gregory lyng . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: with the advent of wide field surveys our knowledge of galaxy properties has significantly improved . the large amount of high quality data of nearby and high redshift objects obtained so far is allowing astronomers to shed light on how galaxies formed and evolved at different redshifts and in different environments ( e.g. @xcite ) . however our picture of the universe still remains limited since it is mostly based on the study of rest - frame optical selected objects . first of all optically - selected galaxies already contain , by definition , a large amount of stars which may not be the case in younger or less evolved galaxies . secondly , surface brightness selection is very dramatic and nearly all catalogued objects lie in an extremely narrow range of surface brightnesses @xcite . + since each wavelength has its own selection effects and traces different baryonic components , the combination of blind surveys at various frequencies is of vital importance . alternative methods of baryon selection will allow us to have a less biased view of our universe and enable us to correctly reconstruct the evolutionary history of galaxies ( e.g. @xcite ) . in particular , the most interesting results can come from the comparison of optical surveys with blind surveys tracing components not directly related to stellar emission like , for example , neutral and molecular hydrogen . for molecular hydrogen we will have to wait a couple of years for the first results from alma , but with the advent of multi - beam instruments on large single dish radio telescopes it has become possible during the last decade to carry out fully sampled blind hi surveys of the sky ( e.g. @xcite ) . neutral hydrogen is extremely important because it represents the fuel for the future star formation activity of a galaxy . it is also one of the galactic components that can most easily be affected by environmental mechanism ( e.g. ram pressure , tidal interaction ) influencing its star formation history . therefore hi line observations of galaxies can provide us with some of the most powerful diagnostics on the role of the environment in regulating the evolution of galaxies @xcite . what we lack is deep and high spatial resolution hi blind surveys of cluster of galaxies and their outskirts . the hi parkes all sky survey ( hipass ) has represented a real breakthrough for hi blind surveys , but its low spatial resolution ( @xmath115 arcmin ) has made it very difficult to carry out detailed studies of high density regions . fortunately , with the refurbishing of the 305 m arecibo radio telescope , blind hi surveys with much improved sensitivity , spatial ( 3.5 arcmin @xmath2 ) and velocity ( 5 @xmath3 ) resolution have become possible thanks to the installation of the alfa multi beam instrument . the abell cluster 1367 , due to its proximity ( [email protected] , v@xmath16500 ) and to the fact that it is currently forming at the intersection of two filaments in the great wall @xcite , represents an ideal target for hi surveys ( e.g. @xcite ) . it is ideal for the study of the properties of hi selected galaxies and environmental effects . for these reasons , abell 1367 is one of the region observed as a part of the arecibo galaxy environment survey ( ages , @xcite ) , one of the new hi blind survey carried out with the alfa multi - beam system . ages aims to study the atomic hydrogen properties of different galactic environments to faint sensitivity limits ; low hi masses ( 6@xmath4 , assuming a 200 velocity width at 92.8 mpc , the distance of the a1367 cluster ) and column densities of @xmath1 3@xmath5 ( for a source that fills the beam ) . the environments ages will survey range from apparent voids in the large - scale structure of galaxies , via isolated spiral galaxies and their haloes , to galaxy - rich regions associated with galaxy clusters and filamentary structures . ages plans to cover @xmath6 square degrees centered on abell 1367 . here we report on the early results obtained from observations of a subset of the whole ages - a1367 region : a @xmath7 square degree area centered on the cluster core . as part of the ages , we observed the abell 1367 region in may 2006 and april 2007 using the alfa feed array at the 305-m arecibo telescope . a total of @xmath163 hours observing time were allocated with an average observing time of @xmath12.3 hours per night . since the allocated time was insufficient to cover all the ages - a1367 region ( 5@xmath04 square degrees ) we decided to give the highest priority to the cluster center and its immediate outskirts covering a strip of @xmath15@xmath01 square degrees ( 11:34:[email protected].(j.2000)@xmath811:54:15 , 19:15@xmath8dec(j.2000)@xmath820:20 ) centered on the cluster core . the observation and data reduction techniques adopted by ages are extensively described in @xcite ; here we will only provide a brief summary of them . + ages uses the 7-feed alfa multi - beam receiver and a spectral line backend capable of instantaneously recording spectra from the two linear polarizations of each beam and covering a bandwidth of 100 mhz . the angular resolution is given by the size of the alfa beams ( @[email protected] arcmin ) and the velocity resolution is @xmath125khz , corresponding to @xmath1 5.5 . observations are performed in _ drift scan mode _ ( e.g. @xcite ) : the array is kept at a fixed azimuth and elevation while the sky drifts overhead . the earth s rotation rate governs the on source time in a drift scan . for arecibo this means that each point in the sky takes @xmath112 s to cross the beam . twenty - five separate scans are then required to reach the 300 s / beam integration time . in order to compensate for the change in parallactic angle , and thus achieve uniform sky coverage , alfa must be rotated before every scan and , in order to attain fully sampled sky coverage , it is necessary to stagger the declination ( dec . ) of individual scans by @xmath11 arcmin ( half the beam separation ) . we record data every second and total power values for each of the seven beams , both polarizations and 4096 channels , are recorded as four - bit floating point numbers . calibration is performed at the beginning of every scan using a high - temperature noise diode that is injected into each beam for a duration of 1 s. a uniform final depth of @xmath1 300 sec was achieved for all of the area observed . data reduction was performed using the aips++ packages livedata and gridzilla @xcite , developed by the australian telescope national facility ( atnf ) . livedata performs bandpass estimation and removal , doppler tracking and calibrates the residual spectrum . gridzilla is a gridding package that co - adds all the spectra using a suitable algorithm , to produce 3d data cubes . the abell 1367 5@xmath01 square degrees region was gridded using a median gridding technique into 1@xmath01 square arcmin pixels , each of which contains a 4096 channel spectrum , and was smoothed at a velocity resolution of 10 . the ages observing strategy is highly successful at reducing sidelobe variations by making a nyquist - sampled map with every alfa beam individually . thus , when the observations are median combined , the variations across the beams are removed , leaving a circular beam with symmetrical sidelobes at a @xmath15 - 10% level @xcite . the output data cube has two spatial dimensions and the spectral dimension can be chosen by the user to be frequency , wavelength or velocity . the noise distribution is fairly gaussian with a standard deviation of [email protected] mjy , consistent with the expected value @xcite for minimal smoothing of the beam . the cube is publicly available and can be downloaded at the following link @xmath10 . radio frequency interference ( rfi ) represents a constant source of contamination in certain regions of the observed spectral window . in particular two main rfi sources were present in all the scans : the san juan faa radar at 1350 mhz and its 3rd harmonic at 1387.8 mhz . in addition an intermittent source of rfi ( gps satellite l3 ) appeared only in some of the scans at approximately 1381 mhz . the strong constant sources at 1350 mhz ( v@xmath114620@xmath9140 ) and 1387.8 mhz ( v@xmath17009@xmath919 ) completely obscure a part of the cosmic volume : in particular the 1387.8 mhz rfi lies approximately at the velocity of abell 1367 making part of the cluster volume inaccessible . the intermittent gps source at 1381 mhz ( v@xmath18500 ) reduces our sensitivity limit and could significantly influence the number of sources detected in a frequency range @xmath1 300 wide . in addition to the rfi another two sources of contamination affect our data . the first one is the galaxy : livedata is not able to correctly subtract the strong emission from the milky way , resulting in a blindness of our survey in about the velocity range -50@xmath11 + 50 . moreover the abell 1367 region includes the 3c264 radio galaxy ( r.a.=11:45:05.5 , dec=+19:36:23 ) . this strong radio source has a 1.4ghz continuum flux of @xmath15 jy , producing strong spectral standing waves and making a @xmath14 arcmin radius region around the galaxy inaccessible . in every blind survey a crucial step in the data reduction is represented by the source extraction . the objective is to obtain a catalogue of confirmed sources to well defined selection limits : as the signal - to - noise ratio ( s / n ) decreases , the contamination by spurious noise signals quickly rises . detection techniques need to be optimized to discriminate real from spurious signals as well as possible . currently source extraction is carried out using three different methods : the cube is visually inspected independently by two of us ( in this case rra and lc ) and by an automatic extractor ( polyfind , written by r. f. minchin ) based on a peak flux threshold . the automatic extractor is essentially based on the cross - correlation with templates method described by @xcite . the program initially looks for peak values above a pre - defined value ( in this case 4@xmath12 ) and then cross - correlates with templates accepting the best fit as long as the correlation coefficient is above 0.75 and the total signal - to - noise ratio of the detection is above 4 @xcite . automatically extracted candidates are then checked by eye , visually inspecting the full ages spectrum summed from a 5@xmath13 box around the position of the detection . the aim of this process is to quickly remove obvious spurious detections while not rejecting any real source . these methods provided a list of 104 candidate hi sources 210 . these systems are described in the appendix of this paper . ] , of which 78 were detected by all the three different signal extraction techniques . in the following we will refer to these 78 objects as `` sure '' sources and to the remaining 26 as `` possible '' sources . the distribution of the total 21 cm flux as a function of the line width at the 50% level of peak maximum for our 104 candidate sources is shown in fig.[ftotw ] . filled circles indicate `` sure '' sources while empty circles are `` possible '' sources . the void in the bottom right part of the plot ( i.e. large velocity widths and small fluxes ) is due to a selection effect present in the source extraction technique : at fixed low total flux it is easier to detect a narrow hi source , since the survey is not flux but surface brightness limited . in order to compare the ages s / n threshold with the recent results presented by alfalfa @xcite we plotted in fig.[ftotw ] a s / n limit of @xmath14=6.5 for our survey , where @xcite : @xmath15 @xmath16 is the total flux in jy , @xmath17 is the velocity width measured at the 50% level , @xmath18 is either @xmath19 for @xmath20 or 400/@xmath21 for @xmath22 , @xmath23 is the spectral velocity resolution and @xmath24 is the r.m.s . noise across the spectrum measured in mjy at @xmath25 spectral resolution . in our case @xmath25=10 . the great majority of our `` sure '' sources lie well above @xmath14=6.5 while the `` possible '' sources have @xmath266.5 , in agreement with @xcite . this suggests that also for our sample @xmath14=6.5 is a reliable threshold for discriminating between `` sure '' and `` possible '' sources . in order to test the reliability of our extraction technique and the real nature of the 26 `` possible '' sources , 10 hours of telescope time where scheduled with the arecibo single pixel l - band wide ( lbw ) receiver in april 2007 . the lbw observations were made covering a spectral band of 12.5 mhz ( 2048 spectral channels ) centered at the expected source recessional velocity . the integration time varied between 5 and 10 minutes depending on the intensity of the source , reaching an rms in the range @xmath10.5 - 0.8 mjy beam@xmath27 at a velocity resolution of 10 km s@xmath27 . all observations were taken using the position - switching technique , with each blank sky ( or off ) position observed for the same duration , and over the same portion of the telescope dish ( az and el ) as the on - source ( on ) observation . each 5 min + 5 min on + off pair was followed by a 10 s on + off observation of a calibrated noise diode . none of the 26 observed sources lies within the sidelobes of a `` sure '' hi detection , making unlikely a sidelobe contamination of the l - wide follow - up observations . of the 26 `` possible '' sources , only 4 ( indicated with crosses in fig.[ftotw ] ) were not confirmed by arecibo follow - up observations . we therefore have a sample of 100 sure hi sources detected in the 5@xmath01 square degrees observed by ages in the abell 1367 region . all the 100 sources in the sample were inspected and parametrized using the miriad task mbspect @xcite . the source position was estimated from a gaussian fit to the moment map within the galaxy velocity range and the spectrum was then extracted from the data cubes . this spectrum is a weighted average , with the weight depending on the distance of each pixel from the fitted position . velocity widths were then measured at the 20% and 50% levels ( @xmath28 and @xmath17 ) relative to the peak signal , using a width - maximizing algorithm @xcite . the uncertainties in each derived quantity are computed following the recipes given by @xcite . in table [ suretab ] we present the main parameters of all the 100 hi sources detected in the cube , namely : + col.1 : hi source i d + col.2 - 3 : hi r.a . ( j.2000 ) coordinate and relative error + col.4 - 5 : hi dec . ( j.2000 ) coordinate and relative error + col.6 : heliocentric velocity and relative error ( @xmath29 , i.e. optical reference frame ) , measured as the midpoint between the velocities where the flux density reaches 50% of peak maximum level . + col.7 : velocity width and relative error of the source line profile measured at the 50% level of peak maximum . + the velocity widths are not corrected for instrumental broadening , turbulent motions , disk inclination or cosmological effects . + col.8 : velocity width and relative error of the source line profile measured at the 20% level . + col.9 : peak flux density and relative error in mjy . + col.10 : total flux and relative error in jy . + col.11 : object flag , defined as follows : flag 0 indicates sources detected by all the three independent methods used for source extraction making them reliable sources . flag 1 indicates objects confirmed only after lwide follow - up observations . flag 2 indicates objects which are contaminated by rfi : they are in general sure detections but the hi parameters ( e.g. flux , velocity width , etc . ) can be strongly affected and should not be used . + the ages source catalogue and the spectra for all the hi sources are publicly available at the following link @xmath10 . the results of the lbw follow - up observations are presented in table [ lwidetab ] , which lists the following : + col.1 : hi source i d + col.2 : heliocentric velocity and relative error of the source ( @xmath29 ) , measured as the midpoint between the channels at which the flux density drops to 50% . + col.3 : velocity width and relative error of the source line profile measured at the 50% level . + the velocity widths are not corrected for instrumental broadening , turbulent motions , disk inclination or cosmological effects . + col.4 : velocity width and relative error of the source line profile measured at the 20% level . + col.5 : total flux and relative error in jy . + col.6 : the rms noise per channel at 10 km s@xmath27 velocity resolution . + in fig.[lwide ] we compare the measurements obtained using the alfa and l - wide receivers for the 22 sources confirmed during follow - up observations ( filled circles ) . although these are the lowest s / n sources within our sample , the agreement between the dataset is quite good with an average dispersion of 19 in recessional velocity , 35 in velocity width and @xmath114% in total flux . the coma - a1367 supercluster is one of the regions most intensively investigated by optically selected hi surveys ( i.e. @xcite ) . however only 21 out of the 100 sources detected by ages had a previous hi measurement . the high number of new hi detections in ages ( @xmath179% ) confirms once more the importance of hi blind surveys for having an unbiased view of the neutral hydrogen distribution in the local universe . among the 21 sources previously known @xcite , three of these objects ( namely cgcg97 - 079 , cgcg97 - 087 and cgcg127 - 052 ) are strongly contaminated by rfis in the ages cube , and can not be used for a comparison with the literature . our measurements for the remaining 18 objects are in satisfactory agreement with past works as illustrated in fig.[lwide ] ( empty circles ) . there is quite a good agreement in both fluxes and velocity width measurements and the average scatter is @xmath110% in flux and @xmath1 28 in velocity width . in one case ( cgcg97 - 138 ) our velocity width estimate differs considerably from literature values : @xcite gives a velocity width of 160whereas we measure only 62 ) . however our new l - wide measurement is consistent with the value obtained from the ages cube ( w=58 ) . the abell 1367 region has been covered in the optical by the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) as part of data release 5 . we have used this homogenous dataset to look for optical counterparts of our hi sources . we cross - correlated our list of hi detections with the sdss galaxy catalogue using a search radius of 4 arcmin . in the few cases in which no candidate optical counterpart was found , we visually inspected the sdss plates to look for low surface brightness galaxies not included in the sdss catalogue . once a candidate optical counterpart was found , we looked into the literature and ned for an estimate of its optical recessional velocity . in addition for 5 of the 46 candidates without an available redshift in the literature we obtained new optical recessional velocity estimates in january - febrary 2007 using the imaging spectrograph bfosc attached to the cassini 1.5 m telescope at loiano ( italy ) . observations and data reduction techniques applied are described in @xcite . confirmed optical counterparts are defined as those optical galaxies lying within 4 arcmin and having a recessional velocity within @xmath9200 from the radio velocity . candidate optical counterparts are galaxies which lie within 4 arcmin but do not have a published optical recessional velocity . of the 100 hi sources in our sample , 55 have confirmed optical counterparts , 34 have a unique candidate ( i.e. no optical recessional velocity available ) optical counterpart , 7 have two or more candidate counterparts and 4 sources appear to have no optical counterparts . three of these objects are associated with the interacting groups in the outskirts of abell 1367 described in the appendix of this paper . a list of the optical counterparts ( confirmed and candidate ) associated with the hi sources is presented in table [ optcounttab ] . in fig.[centroid ] we show the distribution of the difference between the optical and hi positions and recessional velocities for the 55 sources having confirmed optical counterparts . optical and radio measurements show a very good agreement with a median offset of only 18 arcsec in position ( consistent with the typical error of 16 arcsec in the estimate of the centroid for radio sources ) and of @xmath14@xmath916 in recessional velocity . for all the hi sources having 1 optical counterpart ( confirmed or candidate ) we downloaded sdss - dr5 @xmath30 images @xcite and performed aperture photometry and surface brightness profile decomposition using the task _ ellipse _ within iraf . the radial profiles have been constructed by integrating the available images within elliptical , concentric annuli . the ellipticity and position angles have been determined and then fixed using the @xmath31 band image . total magnitudes , effective radii ( @xmath32 ) and effective surface brightness ( @xmath33 , i.e. average surface brightness within @xmath32 ) have been determined following the procedure of @xcite . fig.[distrall ] illustrates the sky ( upper panel ) and the hi mass vs distance distributions ( lower panel ) for all the 100 sources detected in the a1367 cube . over half of the sources ( 54 ) belongs to the abell 1367 cluster and its outskirts , lying in the velocity range 4000@xmath119000 . this roughly explains why in this cube we detect twice the number of sources than in other ages fields : excluding the abell 1367 region ( 4000@xmath119000 ) we are left with 46 sources consistent with the number found in ngc628 @xcite , ngc1156 ( auld et al . in prep . ) and ngc7332 @xcite . the bottom panel of fig.[distrall ] allows a direct comparison of ages with alfalfa @xcite showing that , in the same area of sky , alfalfa would miss @xmath1 half of the sources detected here . this is quite expected since alfalfa has an integration time @xmath1 6.3 times shorter ( @xmath148 sec instead of @xmath1300 sec ) than ages . more impressive is the difference between ages and the northern hipass extension @xcite : whereas ages finds 100 sources , hipass does not detect a single galaxy in the 5@xmath01 square degrees here studied . we use the hi data from ages and the optical data from sdss to derive the physical properties of our sample . the hi mass ( @xmath34 ) is defined as : @xmath35 where @xmath16 is the integrated hi flux in jy and d is the galaxy distance in mpc . for those galaxies belonging to abell 1367 ( 4000@xmath119000 ) we assume @xmath36=92.8 mpc @xcite while we assume @xmath37 with @xmath38 70 @xmath39 for the rest of the sample . the stellar mass is obtained from the optical colors and luminosity as defined in @xcite : @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the absolute magnitude in the @xmath31 band . therefore the total amount of baryons is @xmath42=@xmath43+@xmath34 ( e.g. @xcite ) . this quantity does not include the contribution of helium and metals ( usually assumed equal to 1.4@xmath0m(hi ) ) , the molecular hydrogen and any warm or hot gas component . therefore @xmath42 must be considered as a lower limit of the real value . finally we define the galaxy dynamical mass as : @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the gravitational constant , @xmath46 is the radius containing 75% of the @xmath31 band flux , @xmath47 is the hi velocity width ( here we use the average between @xmath17 and @xmath28 hi velocity widths ) corrected for inclination and @xmath48 is the ratio between @xmath46 and the extension of the hi emission ( i.e. @xmath49 ) . @xmath48 should lie between 2 - 3 @xcite , but for our galaxies radio interferometric data ( necessary to estimate @xmath50 ) is not available , so this remains unknown and we leave it as a free parameter . the galaxy inclination is obtained from the ellipticity determined in the @xmath31 band via : @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the galaxy ellipticity and @xmath53 is the intrinsic axial ratio of the galaxy here assumed equal to 0.13 @xcite . we excluded from this analysis face - on galaxies having @xmath54 ( 20 galaxies ) , for which it is not possible to accurately estimate the dynamical mass . the correlations between different optical and hi quantities and their distributions for our sample are presented in fig.[paramall ] . from left to right : the ratio of the gas to stellar mass , the baryon fraction ( @xmath55 ) , the total hi mass , the effective surface brightness in @xmath31 band , the @xmath56 color and the dynamical mass are presented . only galaxies with one optical counterpart and @xmath54 ( 69 galaxies ) are shown : filled dots are objects with confirmed optical counterparts while empty dots indicate objects with optical counterpart candidates . our sample covers almost three orders of magnitude in both hi and dynamical mass . the optical surface brightness distribution shows a significant tail at low surface brightness ( @xmath5722.5 - 24 mag @xmath58 ) as usually observed in hi selected sample ( e.g. @xcite ) . hi selected samples are often considered as composed of only blue , gas - rich galaxies . this is not the case for our sample which spans over 1 magnitude in the @xmath56 color , as is typically observed in optically selected samples @xcite , and covers a wide range of gas to stars ratios ( @xmath59 ) : from gas poor objects ( @xmath60 0.1 ) to extremely gas rich galaxies ( @xmath60 10 ) . more massive galaxies appear to be redder , have higher surface brightness and lower gas content than dwarf systems . this is also found to be the case in optically selected samples @xcite . well known relations like color - mass , surface brightness - mass and hydrogen - dynamical mass are here rediscovered . unfortunately the small number of objects in our sample does not allow a more detailed comparison between the slopes , scatters and distributions of the relations followed by hi and optically selected galaxies . we postpone this kind of analysis to the moment when we will have a significantly large ages database at our disposition . + the most intriguing result presented in fig.[paramall ] is the absence of any correlation involving the baryon fraction . on the contrary all galaxies in our sample appear to have almost the same baryon fraction @xmath61=(-0.2-log(@xmath48))@xmath90.13 independently from their mass , surface brightness or gas content . the little dispersion in the baryon fraction distribution is in fact well within the observational errors . assuming 0.1 dex error in the hi mass ( see sec.4.1 ) , in the stellar mass @xcite and in the dynamical mass , the uncertainty on the estimate of the baryon fraction is @xmath10.17 dex . the gas and stellar mass fraction cover a larger dynamical range ( i.e. have a larger dispersion : @xmath62=(-0.4-log(@xmath48))@xmath90.24 and @xmath63=(-0.6-log(@xmath48))@xmath90.3 ) ) than the baryon fraction , as shown in fig.[massratios ] and accordingly to the kolmogorov - smirnov test the baryon fraction distribution is not compatible with the gas and star fraction distributions at a 99.99% confidence level . we can therefore conclude that our sample shows approximately the same baryon fraction . a constant baryonic mass fraction in galaxies implies a direct correlation between dynamical mass and baryonic mass : exactly what is usually required for the tully - fisher relation @xcite . this result is also consistent with the recent study of an optically selected sample of extremely low mass dwarf galaxies carried out by @xcite . to our knowledge , this is the first confirmation of a constant baryonic fraction coming from an hi selected sample . this observational evidence is also consistent with models of galaxy formation @xcite but in contradiction with recent models of galaxy evolution which invoke supernova feedback and other physical mechanisms to remove baryons preferentially from low mass systems and to reproduce the observed scaling relations @xcite . even if our sample includes low surface brightness galaxies it appears that physical mechanisms that preferentially remove baryons from low mass galaxies are not effective in the mass range and selection criteria of our sample . we remark that the only way to obtain a correlation between the baryon fraction and the dynamical mass in our sample would be to assume that @xmath48 ( i.e. the ratio of the hi to optical radius ) is a strong function of the mass and/or the contribution of molecular hydrogen , hot and warm gas to the total baryon mass varies with the mass of the galaxy . we can not a priori exclude the first possibility , even if unlikely since @xcite found that the ratio of the hi to optical radius varies by only 20% along the hubble sequence . conversely , the molecular hydrogen represents only @xmath115% of the total gas reservoir in normal , late - type galaxies @xcite and the contribution of hot and warm gas components is a few percents ( @xmath641 - 2% ) of the total gas mass ( e.g. @xcite ) making the second scenario extremely unlikely . more than half of the hi sources detected in the cube belong to the abell 1367 volume . this includes not only the cluster core but also a part of the great wall : a large scale filament of galaxies connecting abell 1367 to the coma cluster @xcite . all galaxies in the filament lie approximately at the same distance from us as abell 1367 , implying that the system a1367+great wall constitutes a volume limited sample . at the distance of abell 1367 ( @xmath192.8 mpc ) the surveyed sky area has a physical size of [email protected] @xmath65 and our sensitivity limit for a source with @xmath17=200 is @xmath16@xmath4 . since the virial radius of abell 1367 is @xmath1 2.3 mpc @xcite , our region covers the cluster virialized region and its immediate neighborhood . in order to compare the hi and optical properties of the abell 1367 region we extracted an optically selected sample of galaxies from sdss - dr5 . we select all galaxies in the ages region having @xmath66 mag ( corresponding to @xmath67 at the abell 1367 distance ) : 259 galaxies in total , of which 208 have optical redshift available and 155 are confirmed cluster members ( 4000@xmath119000 ) . we note that the time necessary to carry out a hi targeted survey of this optically selected sample ( reaching the same ages noise level ) would be similar to the observing time needed by ages to cover all the 5@xmath01 square degrees in abell 1367 . the sky distribution of the 54 hi sources belonging to the a1367 region ( 4000@xmath119000 ) is shown in fig.[skya1367 ] . it is interesting to note that no significant over - density of sources is observed corresponding to the cluster center : the only hi galaxy lying well within the x - ray cluster contours belongs to a small group of galaxies infalling for the first time into the cluster , suggesting that it is just entering the cluster and it is only projected on the center of abell 1367 @xcite . this appears much more evident when we compare the sky distribution of our sample with the typical sky distribution obtained for the optically selected sample . in fig.[skya1367 ] we show the distribution of the 155 confirmed cluster members ( empty circles ) and of the 51 galaxies without redshift available mag , suggesting that a not negligible fraction is composed by background galaxies @xcite . ] ( empty stars ) extracted from the optically selected sample . the optical selected sample is strongly clustered on the cluster center and almost half of the sources detected lie within the x - ray emitting region . moreover the `` finger of god '' feature , typical of clusters of galaxies , is not observed in the hi selected sample ( see fig.[wedge ] ) . conversely the hi - selected galaxies show a different pattern in the wedge diagram shown in fig.[wedge ] : galaxies on the east side of the cluster have a lower recessional velocity than galaxies in the west side . this probably suggests the presence of two different infalling directions into the cluster core as proposed by @xcite . the differences observed between the optically and hi selected samples are somehow expected since clusters of galaxies are made hi deficient structures through the combination of the morphology - density relation @xcite and of the `` gas - density '' relation @xcite . this is also consistent with recent determinations of the correlation function for hi selected samples @xcite which show that hi galaxies are among the least clustered objects in the universe . the influence of the harsh cluster environment is barely visible when we look for radial variations of the gas to star mass ratio and of the hi - deficiency ( see fig.[defradius ] ) . the hi deficiency is defined as the difference , in logarithmic units , between the observed hi mass and the value expected from an isolated galaxy with the same morphological type t and optical linear diameter d : hi def = @xmath68 @xcite . we used the equations in @xcite to calculate the expected hi mass from the optical diameter . the hi deficiency does not significant vary with the cluster - centric distance ( fig.[defradius ] , bottom panel ) , contrary to what usually observed in optically selected samples ( i.e. @xcite ) . a slight decrease on the average value of the gas to star mass ratio is observed in correspondence of the cluster center , however also in this case no strong gradients have been found . we can therefore conclude that when observed in hi the abell cluster 1367 almost completely disappears and the only evidence of its hidden presence is a slightly higher number of galaxies with a low gas to star mass ratio near the cluster core . the abell 1367 local volume can be used for a more detailed analysis of selection effects representing a unique dataset for which complete samples independently selected at optical and radio wavelengths are available . we are particularly interested in the comparison of the hi mass distribution and optical luminosity function estimated from the two samples . in the past , different authors have used optically selected samples to determine the hi mass distributions of galaxies in the local universe obtaining results significantly different from radio selected samples @xcite . we therefore used the optically selected sample extracted from sdss - dr5 , complete to @xmath66 mag , in order to compare the hi distribution and the @xmath69 band luminosity function for optically and hi selected galaxies . contrary to the hi selected sample , the sdss sample is not complete in redshift , but the redshift completeness rapidly drops below 50% for @xmath70 mag ( @xmath71 ) . this complicates the estimate of the luminosity function at low luminosities . in order to overcome the redshift incompleteness of cluster samples we used the _ completeness corrected _ method proposed by @xcite . this method is based on the assumption that the spectroscopic sample ( i.e. galaxies with redshift available ) is representative of the entire cluster , i.e. the fraction of galaxies that are cluster members is the same in the ( incomplete ) spectroscopic sample as in the ( complete ) photometric one . the hi mass distributions obtained from the optically and hi selected samples are shown in fig.[lfhi ] . as expected the two samples produce hi distributions significantly different . the optical selected sample drops quicker at low hi masses and does not include nearly half of the hi sources in the a1367 volume . the two samples start to differ at @xmath722@xmath73 , well before our sensitivity limit . low luminosity , low surface brightness , gas rich objects are in fact not included in the optical sample , but they represent a significant fraction of the total hi budget in abell 1367 . this result is consistent with the recent work by @xcite who showed that the faint end slope of the hi mass function for an optically selected sample is less steep than the one obtained from a 21 cm selected sample . our analysis suggests that this difference is mainly due to selection effects and that hi distributions obtained from optically selected samples can not be generally considered as good proxies of the hi mass function in the local universe . the hi and optically selected samples also differ in the estimate of the optical luminosity functions ( fig.[lfopt ] , lower panel ) . the luminosity function ( lf ) for the hi selected galaxies is flatter and includes fewer objects ( i.e. lower @xmath74 ) than the one obtained from the optically selected sample . a great part of this difference is due to the overabundance of red ( @xmath750.9 ) , gas poor galaxies in the center of abell 1367 : more than 80% of bright red galaxies ( @xmath76 ) in the a1367 region are not detected at 21 cm ( see fig.[lfopt ] , upper panel ) . the difference between the two samples is less evident if we compare the luminosity functions obtained only for blue galaxies ( fig.[lfopt ] , middle panel ) , but even in this case the hi sample misses @xmath130% of blue cluster galaxies . this result is quite interesting since we generally associate hi deficiency to red colors . in order to further investigate the properties of these blue galaxies not detected in hi , in fig.[colmag ] we compare the color @xmath56 , @xmath31 magnitude relation for the confirmed cluster members in the optically ( empty circles ) and hi selected ( triangles ) samples . almost all the hi galaxies lie on the blue sequence , but the opposite is not true : not all the galaxies in the blue sequence are detected in hi . this could be due to a number of different reasons . first of all we have to take into account our sensitivity limit ( @xmath726@xmath4 for w@xmath77 @xmath1 200 ) which we need to relate to optical color and magnitude . to do so we have used the correlation between the hi mass and @xmath31 band luminosity ratio and the @xmath56 color observed for our sample . the best bisector linear fitting gives the following relation : @xmath78 with a dispersion of 0.37 dex . we can use this equation to estimate our sensitivity limit , which is indicated by the solid line in fig.[colmag ] . we consider undetected blue galaxies those objects not detected by ages , lying outside the one @xmath12 region and with a @xmath56 color bluer than 0.9 mag : 10 galaxies in total . some of these sources lie within ( in both space and velocity ) strong hi galaxies and can be missed , due to the size of the arecibo beam ( [email protected] arcmin ) and to the fact that in these cases the hi emission is totally assigned to the bright source . moreover some galaxies have a recessional velocity within the rfis frequencies and can not be detected . excluding these cases ( indicated with crosses in fig.[colmag ] , left ) we are left with eight blue galaxies which are not detected in hi . these objects have a @xmath69 band luminosity in the range 2@xmath010@xmath79 10@xmath80 l@xmath81 ( i.e. -19.4@xmath82 - 17.9 mag ) , implying that we are dealing with intermediate mass galaxies and not dwarf systems . moreover their broad - band morphology and structural parameters are indistinguishable from the other blue hi detected galaxies . the limits obtained from eq.[ml ] imply that the undetected galaxies have a hi deficiency @xmath830.37 , suggesting that we are dealing with blue , deficient objects , consistent with the marginal detection of two of these galaxies ( cgcg97 - 092 , cgcg97 - 093 ) by deeper surveys @xcite implying an hi deficiency 0.31 and 0.57 respectively . this suggests that we are dealing with the same population of hi poor , star forming spirals originally observed in nearby clusters by @xcite . only when observed in h@xmath84 emission of a galaxy is due to the hydrogen ionized in hii regions by massive ( @xmath8510 m@xmath81 ) , young ( @xmath8 2 @xmath0 10@xmath86 yr ) stars . ] these galaxies appear different from healthy spirals , showing a truncation of the star forming disk . in particular , in all but one object for which h@xmath84 data are available ( 8 galaxies , @xcite ) the h@xmath84 radius ( e.g. the isophotal radius within @xmath87 ) is @xmath12 - 4 times less extended than the @xmath88 band 24th mag @xmath58 isophotal radius ( see table [ nodettab ] ) . this is consistent with various independent studies @xcite which have shown that the hi deficiency is associated with a truncation of the star forming disk . all the deficient objects lie at a projected distance of less than @xmath11 degree from the center of abell 1367 , suggesting that the absence of hi and the truncation of the star formation disk is likely due to their interaction with the cluster environment . the fact that these objects have lost almost 40% of their original gas content but their broadband morphology and optical colours are still those typical of normal star forming spirals implies that they are recent arrivals within the cluster environment . it appears that the neutral hydrogen has been already stripped well within the optical radius quenching the star formation in the galaxy outskirts , but a type stars have not yet died and the galaxies still appear as blue as they were before losing their gas . given that h@xmath84 traces stars younger than @xmath89 yr and the typical lifetime of a stars is @xmath11 gyr , we can speculate that our galaxies started to loose their gas @xmath1100myr ago , in agreement with the typical timescale for gas stripping observed in virgo cluster galaxies ( e.g. @xcite ) and predicted by numerical models ( e.g. @xcite ) . in less than 1 gyr , when all the a stars are dead , these objects will lie in the @xmath56 red sequence and will not be any different from the bulk of the gas - poor ( red ) galaxy cluster population . only future detailed spectroscopic investigation will allow us the better estimate the time scale of this transformation . finally , it is interesting to note that this population of blue gas - poor galaxies corresponds to @xmath1 one third of the whole population of blue galaxies in the a1367-volume , supporting the idea that a1367 is a cluster still young and a considerable number of objects are infalling into the cluster core for the first time @xcite . we have presented the results of a hi blind survey of 5@xmath01 square degrees centered on the core of abell 1367 as part of the arecibo galaxy environment survey . one hundred hi galaxies have been detected ( 79 new measurements and 50 new redshifts ) , half of which belong to the abell 1367 volume . comparing the properties of the hi selected galaxies with an optically selected sample extracted from sdss - dr5 we have shown that the large scale distribution of galaxies is strongly wavelength dependent : in hi the cluster core almost completely disappears and hi selected galaxies are homogeneously distributed in the cluster volume . the difference between the two samples is even more evident when we compare their luminosity and hi distribution . our optically selected sample misses a considerable number of low luminosity , low surface brightness galaxies underestimating by almost a factor 2 the number of hi rich galaxies present in the cluster volume . on the contrary our hi sample contains a factor 3 less bright galaxies than the optical one . these are mainly ellipticals or early type , red spirals but also a not negligible fraction of the blue sequence cluster spirals is missed . all these blue gas - poor objects are located near the edge of the x - ray cluster contours suggesting that their gas has been recently ( @xmath1 100 myr ) stripped by ram pressure so that the galaxies are already gas poor whereas their stellar populations are still young . + although the spatial and number distribution of samples selected at different wavelengths are significantly different , the internal properties of galaxies seem not to be significantly wavelengths dependent . hi galaxies seem to follow the same scaling relations observed in optical and bigger galaxies are redder , have a higher surface brightness and a lower gas content than lower luminosity galaxies . the most interesting result of our analysis is that the baryon fraction of our sample appears to be almost constant , suggesting the difference in the star to gas ratio observed between bright and faint galaxies is only due to a different star formation efficiency ( i.e. the time scale necessary to convert gas into stars ) . this is the first time that such a result is obtained from an hi selected sample and even if consistent with models of galaxy formation it suggests that during their evolutionary history less massive galaxies do not lose a larger fraction of their baryons than bigger objects . the analysis presented in this paper points out the importance of hi blind surveys like ages in order to have an unbiased view of the properties of galaxies in the local universe . once the survey is at a more advanced stage and the size of our sample is significantly bigger than the one presented here it will be possible to carry out more detailed quantitative studies and comparisons between optically and hi selected samples , gaining more insight into the evolutionary history of nearby galaxies . lc wishes to thank all the ages consortium and in particular elias brinks & noah brosh for useful discussions and comments on this manuscript . lc is supported by the uk particle physics and astronomy research council . this work is based on observations collected at arecibo observatory . the arecibo observatory is part of the national astronomy and ionosphere center , which is operated by cornell university under a cooperative agreement with the national science foundation . we wish to thank the arecibo observatory for granting us the time to complete this part of the project and its staff for the help during the observations and data reduction . the tac of the loiano telescope is acknowledged for the time allocation to this project . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract to nasa and of the goldmine database @xcite . funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s . department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england . the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions . the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , university of cambridge , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington . 83 natexlab#1#1 , m. g. , moore , b. , & bower , r. g. 1999 , , 308 , 947 , j. k. , ageros , m. a. , allam , s. s. , et al . 2007 , , 172 , 634 , r. , minchin , r. f. , davies , j. i. , et al . 2006 , , 371 , 1617 , i. k. , glazebrook , k. , brinkmann , j. , et al . 2004 , , 600 , 681 , d. g. , staveley - smith , l. , de blok , w. j. g. , et al . 2001 , , 322 , 486 , s. , plionis , m. , kova , k. , & voglis , n. 2007 , , 370 , e. f. , mcintosh , d. h. , katz , n. , & weinberg , m. d. 2003 , , 585 , l117 , e. f. , mcintosh , d. h. , katz , n. , & weinberg , m. d. 2003 , , 149 , 289 , a. , boissier , s. , cortese , l. , et al . 2006 , , 651 , 811 , a. & gavazzi , g. 2006 , , 118 , 517 , a. , lequeux , j. , & gavazzi , g. 2002 , , 384 , 33 , f. h. & rao , s. 1993 , , 417 , 494 , v. , takeuchi , t. t. , iglesias - paramo , j. , et al . 2007 , apjs in press ( astro - ph/0609738 ) , j. s. , dekel , a. , kolatt , t. s. , et al . 2001 , , 555 , 240 , b. , haynes , m. p. , & giovanelli , r. 2005 , , 130 , 1037 , v. , kotanyi , c. , balkowski , c. , & van gorkom , j. h. 1994 , , 107 , 1003 , g. l. , giovanelli , r. , & haynes , m. p. 1983 , , 269 , 13 , s. , lacey , c. g. , baugh , c. m. , & frenk , c. s. 2000 , , 319 , 168 , l. , boselli , a. , gavazzi , g. , et al . 2005 , , 623 , l17 , l. , gavazzi , g. , boselli , a. , et al . 2006 , , 453 , 847 , l. , gavazzi , g. , boselli , a. , iglesias - paramo , j. , & carrasco , l. 2004 , , 425 , 429 , l. , gavazzi , g. , iglesias - paramo , j. , boselli , a. , & carrasco , l. 2003 , , 401 , 471 , l. , marcillac , d. , richard , j. , et al . 2007 , , 376 , 157 , l. l. , songaila , a. , hu , e. m. , & cohen , j. g. 1996 , , 112 , 839 , r. a. , eke , v. r. , frenk , c. s. , et al . 2007 , , 377 , 41 , j. , minchin , r. , sabatini , s. , et al . 2004 , , 349 , 922 , j. i. , de blok , w. j. g. , smith , r. m. , et al . 2001 , , 328 , 1151 , r. , colless , m. , driver , s. p. , et al . 2003 , , 342 , 725 , a. 1980 , , 236 , 351 , k. c. 1970 , , 160 , 811 , w. , staveley - smith , l. , calabretta , m. , et al . 2005 , in bulletin of the american astronomical society , vol . 37 , bulletin of the american astronomical society , 1316+ , g. 1987 , , 320 , 96 , g. 1989 , , 346 , 59 , g. , boselli , a. , donati , a. , franzetti , p. , & scodeggio , m. 2003 , , 400 , 451 , g. , boselli , a. , van driel , w. , & oneil , k. 2005 , , 429 , 439 , g. , franzetti , p. , scodeggio , m. , boselli , a. , & pierini , d. 2000 , , 361 , 863 , g. , oneil , k. , boselli , a. , & van driel , w. 2006 , , 449 , 929 , g. , pierini , d. , & boselli , a. 1996 , , 312 , 397 , m. , blanton , m. r. , masjedi , m. , & west , a. a. 2006 , , 653 , 240 , r. & haynes , m. p. 1985 , , 292 , 404 , r. , haynes , m. p. , herter , t. , et al . 1997 , , 113 , 22 , r. , haynes , m. p. , kent , b. r. , et al . 2005 , , 130 , 2598 , r. , haynes , m. p. , kent , b. r. , et al . 2007 , , 133 , 2569 , m. , giuricin , g. , mardirossian , f. , mezzetti , m. , & boschin , w. 1998 , , 505 , 74 , f. , willman , b. , mayer , l. , et al . 2007 , , 374 , 1479 , m. p. & giovanelli , r. 1984 , , 89 , 758 , m. p. , giovanelli , r. , herter , t. , et al . 1997 , , 113 , 1197 , p. a. , springob , c. m. , catinella , b. , et al . 2006 , in american astronomical society meeting abstracts , vol . 208 , american astronomical society meeting abstracts , 53.04+ , p. a. , staveley - smith , l. , ekers , r. d. , et al . 2000 , , 119 , 2686 , s. j. u. , armus , l. , higdon , j. l. , soifer , b. t. , & spoon , h. w. w. 2006 , , 648 , 323 , j. , boselli , a. , cortese , l. , vlchez , j. m. , & gavazzi , g. 2002 , , 384 , 383 , g. , heckman , t. m. , white , s. d. m. , et al . 2003 , , 341 , 33 , jr . , r. c. , bothun , g. d. , & schommer , r. a. 1984 , , 89 , 1279 , r. a. , haynes , m. p. , & catinella , b. 2006 , , 131 , 716 , b. s. , staveley - smith , l. , kilborn , v. a. , et al . 2004 , , 128 , 16 , r. h. , boyce , p. j. , kilborn , v. a. , et al . 2003 , , 342 , 738 , b. m. 1983 , , 88 , 962 , s. & de blok , e. 1998 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 136 , galactic halos , ed . d. zaritsky , 210+ , s. s. , schombert , j. m. , bothun , g. d. , & de blok , w. j. g. 2000 , , 533 , l99 , m. j. , zwaan , m. a. , webster , r. l. , brown , m. j. i. , & staveley - smith , l. 2007 , , 654 , 702 , r. f. , auld , r. , davies , j. i. , et al . 2007 , in iau symposium , vol . 235 , iau symposium , ed . f. combes & j. palous , 227229 , r. f. , disney , m. j. , boyce , p. j. , et al . 2003 , , 346 , 787 , r. f. , momjian , e. , cortese , l. , et al . 2006 , in american astronomical society meeting abstracts , 95.03+ , e. & brggen , m. 2007 , , 765 , j. l. & schneider , s. e. 2000 , , 130 , 177 , a. 2007 , , 133 , 2087 , s. , mould , j. r. , hughes , s. m. g. , et al . 2000 , , 529 , 698 , e. e. & hoffman , g. l. 1996 , , 465 , 595 , r. j. , teuben , p. j. , & wright , m. c. h. 1995 , in asp conf . 77 : astronomical data analysis software and systems iv , ed . r. a. shaw , h. e. payne , & j. j. e. hayes , 433+ , y. , bekki , k. , couch , w. j. , & de propris , r. 2002 , , 565 , 223 , j. m. , giovanelli , r. , & haynes , m. p. 1996 , , 461 , 609 , j. m. , manrique , a. , garca - gmez , c. , et al . 2001 , , 548 , 97 , j. g. & schneider , s. e. 1998 , , 119 , 159 , c. m. , haynes , m. p. , & giovanelli , r. 2005 , , 621 , 215 , c. m. , haynes , m. p. , giovanelli , r. , & kent , b. r. 2005 , , 160 , 149 , iii , w. t. , bates , b. , bothun , g. d. , & schommer , r. a. 1981 , , 86 , 919 , r. a. , van albada , t. s. , van der hulst , j. m. , & sancisi , r. 2002 , , 390 , 829 , d. , bomans , d. j. , hensler , g. , & junkes , n. 2001 , , 380 , 40 , b. , balkowski , c. , cayatte , v. , van driel , w. , & huchtmeier , w. 2004 , , 419 , 35 , b. , cayatte , v. , balkowski , c. , & duschl , w. j. 2001 , , 561 , 708 , b. c. , gilmore , d. m. , & jones , c. 1993 , , 407 , 489 , o. i. , ryan - weber , e. v. , garcia - appadoo , d. a. , et al . 2006 , , 371 , 1855 , a. i. , geller , m. j. , huchra , j. p. , & ramella , m. 1993 , , 106 , 1301 [ [ high - velocity - clouds ] ] high velocity clouds + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + two extended features well separated from the milky way emission and probably associated with high velocity clouds ( hvcs ) have been detected in the velocity range 140@xmath11210 ( fig.[hvc ] ) . the first lies in the range 11:50@xmath9011:55 and probably extends outside the region observed . the brightest region is in the south - east corner of the cube ( 11:54:00 , + 19:20:00 , 160@xmath11210 ) and a low column density stream seems to extend to the north - west . the second and strongest hvc occupies great part of the east part of the cube and extends over 1.5 degrees ( 11:40@xmath9011:46 , 19:25@xmath9120:15 ) with a velocity in the range 140@xmath11175 . the cgcg97027-group is located at a projected distance of @xmath12 degrees ( @xmath13.2 mpc ) from the centre of abell 1367 . it is composed of two star forming spirals cgcg97027 ( v@xmath16630 ) and cgcg97026 ( v@xmath16220 ) and one lenticular cgcg97023 ( v@xmath16320 ) . at a projected distance of @xmath113 arcmin ( @xmath10.7 mpc ) sw from the group lies the elliptical galaxy cgcg97 - 021 ( v@xmath16648 ) . our data show the presence of diffuse hi emission all over the region occupied by the four bright zwicky galaxies ( see fig.[97027 ] ) . in particular and high velocity 6500@xmath116800 streams extends from cgcg97 - 021 to the north ( fig.[97027 ] , left ) and two of the hi sources without optical counterparts belong to this stream ( ages j113614 + 195910 and ages j113626 + 195102 ) . extended emission is also detected in the north part of the cgcg97 - 027 group in the velocity range 6000@xmath116500 ( fig.[97027 ] , right ) . : the cgcg97041-group is located at a projected distance of 1 degrees ( 1.6 mpc ) from the centre of abell 1367 and , as the cgcg97027-group , it is composed of two spirals cgcg97036 ( v@xmath16595 ) and agc210559 ( v@xmath16825 ) and one lenticular cgcg97041 ( v@xmath16778 ) . we detect hi emission extended over @xmath1200 kpc north of the three group members , apparently not associated with either of them ( see fig.[97041 ] ) . this source ( @xmath92 7382 ) has no optical counterpart catalogued in the sdss database . however in the sdss plates a low surface brightness ( @xmath93 24 @xmath94 galaxy is present in correspondence of the hi coordinates . we considered this object as candidate optical counterpart and labeled it as sdsslsb in table [ optcounttab ] . this source lies at a projected distance of @xmath15.8 arcmin from the starburst galaxy cgcg97 - 068 . no galaxies or extended features are found in deep cfht b - band @xcite and galex nuv - fuv @xcite data in correspondence with the peak of hi emission , suggesting that it could be a stream of gas stripped from cgcg97 - 068 . unfortunately the distance of the source from cgcg97 - 068 is consistent with the region in which the first sidelobe is expected and the fact that ages j114239 + 201150 lies at exactly the same recessional velocity of the starburst galaxy makes impossible to discard the possibility that this source is sidelobe contaminated . vla d - configuration observations has been recently obtained for the interacting groups described above and for cgcg97 - 068 and will be used to study in detail the properties of these sources . the results of these observations will be presented in a forthcoming work . band luminosity function for galaxies in the a1367 volume as obtained from the optically ( empty circles ) and hi ( histogram ) selected sample . all galaxies in the two samples are shown in the bottom panel , while blue ( @xmath970.9 ) and red galaxies ( @xmath750.9 ) are shown in the middle and upper panel respectively.,width=302 ] color @xmath41 magnitude relation for confirmed cluster members in the abell 1367 region . triangles indicate galaxies detected in the ages cube . crosses indicate those galaxies lying in the rfis velocity range or within the beam occupied by brighter sources . the solid ( dashed ) line indicate our sensitivity limit ( @xmath91 @xmath12 ) obtained converting the hi sensitivity into color limit using the @xmath56 versus @xmath98 relation given by eq.[ml ] . , width=302 ] @xmath101j114017 + 194718 & 11:40:17.26 & 19:47:19.1 & -- \\ ages~j114027 + 192429 & kug1137 + 196 & 11:40:26.15 & 19:24:51.9 & 3421 \\ ages~j114039 + 195455 & [ ibc2002]j114038 + 195437 & 11:40:38.99 & 19:54:38.5 & 7784 \\ ages~j114113 + 193240 & kug1138 + 198 & 11:41:13.43 & 19:32:21.7 & 10011 \\ ages~j114118 + 200829 & kug 1138 + 204 & 11:41:17.45 & 20:08:33.4 & 14500 \\ ages~j114129 + 200550 & sdssj114130.18 + 200629.8 & 11:41:30.18 & 20:06:29.8 & -- \\ & sdssj114129.01 + 200550.4 & 11:41:29.01 & 20:05:50.4 & -- \\ & sdssj114129.74 + 200506.0 & 11:41:29.74 & 20:05:06.0 & -- \\ ages~j114131 + 201912 & sdssj114134.75 + 201917.9 & 11:41:34.75 & 20:19:17.9 & -- \\ & sdssj114128.58 + 201803.8 & 11:41:28.58 & 20:18:03.8 & -- \\ ages~j114143 + 193536 & maps - ngpo\_434\_0037838 & 11:41:43.22 & 19:35:26.2 & -- \\ ages~j114148 + 194538 & [ ibc2002]j114149 + 194605 & 11:41:49.83 & 19:46:04.4 & 7789 \\ ages~j114204 + 194536 & sdssj114205.74 + 194611.7 & 11:42:05.74 & 19:46:11.7 & -- \\ ages~j114209 + 201924 & ngc3821 & 11:42:09.09 & 20:18:56.6 & 5788 \\ ages~j114211 + 195827 & kug1139 + 202 & 11:42:14.77 & 19:58:35.2 & 7815 \\ ages~j114216 + 200302 & kug1139 + 203 & 11:42:15.66 & 20:02:55.5 & 6102 \\ ages~j114224 + 200710 & cgcg097 - 068 & 11:42:24.48 & 20:07:09.9 & 5974 \\ ages~j114239 + 201150 & -- & -- & -- & -- \\ ages~j114243 + 200143 & cgcg097 - 072 & 11:42:45.21 & 20:01:56.6 & 6332 \\ ages~j114255 + 195734 & cgcg097 - 073 & 11:42:56.46 & 19:57:58.4 & 7275 \\ ages~j114308 + 194210 & kug1140 + 199 & 11:43:07.96 & 19:41:57.4 & 12988 \\ ages~j114311 + 200032 & cgcg097 - 079 & 11:43:13.32 & 20:00:17.5 & 7000 \\ ages~j114312 + 193655 & [ ibc2002]j114313 + 193645 & 11:43:13.02 & 19:36:46.6 & 6121 \\ ages~j114331 + 193747 & cgcg097 - 083 & 11:43:31.22 & 19:37:40.6 & 13126 \\ ages~j114347 + 195820 & ugc06697 & 11:43:49.11 & 19:58:06.2 & 6725 \\ ages~j114358 + 200430 & ngc3840 & 11:43:59.01 & 20:04:37.3 & 7368 \\ ages~j114402 + 202313 & 2masxj11435706 + 2022383 & 11:44:01.92 & 20:22:51.6 & 11962 \\ ages~j114416 + 201309 & cgcg097 - 102 & 11:44:17.22 & 20:13:23.9 & 6368 \\ ages~j114435 + 192841 & maps - ngpo\_434\_0047286 & 11:44:36.39 & 19:28:40.1 & -- \\ ages~j114447 + 200737 & ugc06719 & 11:44:47.12 & 20:07:30.2 & 6571 \\ ages~j114451 + 192723 & ngc3859 & 11:44:52.24 & 19:27:15.2 & 5468 \\ ages~j114452 + 194635 & cgcg097 - 125 & 11:44:54.85 & 19:46:34.9 & 8271 \\ ages~j114503 + 195832 & ngc3861 & 11:45:03.87 & 19:58:25.1 & 5085 \\ ages~j114508 + 200837 & [ ibg2003 ] j114506 + 200849 & 11:45:06.40 & 20:08:49.2 & 3822 \\ ages~j114543 + 200147 & cgcg097 - 138 & 11:45:44.67 & 20:01:51.6 & 5313 \\ ages~j114545 + 194210 & [ ibg2003]j114545 + 194130 & 11:45:45.27 & 19:41:30.7 & 6123 \\ ages~j114612 + 202403 & ngc3884 & 11:46:12.19 & 20:23:29.9 & 6946 \\ ages~j114625 + 193024 & sdssj114626.45 + 193011.9 & 11:46:26.45 & 19:30:11.9 & -- \\ ages~j114638 + 194854 & sdssj114636.47 + 194834.1 & 11:46:36.47 & 19:48:34.1 & -- \\ & sdssj114640.32 + 194820.8 & 11:46:40.32 & 19:48:20.8 & -- \\ ages~j114646 + 191906 & 2masxj11464700 + 1919462 & 11:46:47.03 & 19:19:46.2 & -- \\ ages~j114724 + 192324 & maps - ngpo\_434\_0048296 & 11:47:25.08 & 19:23:31.4 & -- \\ ages~j114727 + 194906 & sdssj114730.39 + 194859.0 & 11:47:30.39 & 19:48:59.0 & -- \\ ages~j114730 + 195353 & 2masxj11473099 + 1952201 & 11:47:30.99 & 19:52:20.8 & 5778 \\ ages~j114739 + 195621 & cgcg097 - 152 & 11:47:39.35 & 19:56:22.0 & 6166 \\ ages~j114739 + 200924 & sdssj114737.57 + 200900.6 & 11:47:37.57 & 20:09:00.6 & -- \\ ages~j114809 + 192109 & -- & -- & -- & -- \\ ages~j114823 + 194244 & sdssj114825.21 + 194217.0 & 11:48:25.21 & 19:42:17.0 & -- \\ ages~j114824 + 202331 & lsbcd571 - 02 & 11:48:26.40 & 20:23:19.0 & 6796 \\ ages~j114829 + 194529 & maps - ngpo\_434\_0031444 & 11:48:28.43 & 19:45:36.0 & -- \\ ages~j114956 + 192840 & sdssj114956.75 + 192840.4 & 11:49:56.76 & 19:28:40.4 & -- \\ & sdssj114956.93 + 192830.7 & 11:49:56.93 & 19:28:30.7 & -- \\ ages~j115030 + 200505 & maps - ngpo\_434\_0021239 & 11:50:29.99 & 20:05:08.2 & -- \\ ages~j115034 + 194301 & sdssj115033.61 + 194250.1 & 11:50:33.61 & 19:42:50.1 & -- \\ ages~j115052 + 193102 & kug1148 + 197a & 11:50:52.48 & 19:31:10.8 & -- \\ ages~j115101 + 193728 & 2masxj11510128 + 1937311 & 11:51:01.29 & 19:37:31.3 & -- \\ ages~j115101 + 202355 & ugc06821 & 11:51:01.12 & 20:23:57.3 & 6438 \\ ages~j115120 + 192931 & kug1148 + 197 & 11:51:21.28 & 19:29:33.9 & -- \\ ages~j115147 + 192057 & kug1149 + 196 & 11:51:48.37 & 19:21:29.3 & 6932 \\ \noalign{\smallskip } \hline \end{array}\ ] ] * : new optical redshift obtained in winter 2007 using the loiano 1.5 meter telescope . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: a basic problem in database theory is _ query evaluation in probabilistic databases _ : given a ( boolean ) query @xmath0 and a probabilistic database @xmath1 , where each tuple has a given probability , compute the probability of the lineage of @xmath0 over @xmath1 . the problem is computationally hard , even for fixed queries in simple syntactic forms @xcite . the _ lineage of a ( boolean ) query @xmath0 over a database @xmath1 _ is a monotone boolean function @xmath2 over the tuples in @xmath1 that accepts a subset @xmath3 of tuples of @xmath1 if and only if @xmath0 is true in @xmath3 . a standard approach to probabilistic query evaluation is _ query compilation _ * chapter 5 ) . here , the lineage @xmath2 , given as a boolean circuit , which is computable in polynomial time if @xmath0 is fixed , is implemented within a succinct circuit class where its probability is efficiently computable . in other words , to avoid computing the probability of a circuit , which is hard , the circuit is first _ compiled _ to a tamer form . circuit classes supporting tractable probability computation , and model counting in particular , are central in _ knowledge compilation _ @xcite ; particular emphasis is posed on the hierarchy of deterministic decomposable circuits . a circuit is _ decomposable _ if its and gates represent independent probabilistic events @xcite , and _ deterministic _ if its or gates represent exclusive probabilistic events @xcite : probability computation is then feasible in linear time on deterministic decomposable circuits . aimed at a detailed syntactic classification of tractable cases of probabilistic query evaluation , jha and suciu amply explored the compilability of various classes of queries into various classes of deterministic decomposable circuits , fruitfully bridging database theory and knowledge compilation @xcite . in this context , they studied the compilability of queries whose lineages have small circuit treewidth into decision diagrams , obdds in particular @xcite ; a study we continue in this article . an _ ordered binary decision diagram _ ( obdd ) is a deterministic read - once branching program where every path from the root to a leaf visits the boolean variables in the same order @xcite . the obdd size of a boolean function is the size ( number of nodes ) of its smallest obdd implementation . the width of an obdd is the largest number of nodes labeled by the same variable , and the obdd width of a boolean function is the smallest width attained by its obdd implementations . unifying several known tractable cases of the probability computation problem , jha and suciu introduce a structural parameter for boolean functions , called _ expression width _ @xcite or _ circuit treewidth _ @xcite , that measures , for any boolean function , the smallest treewidth of a circuit computing the function . they show that a boolean function of @xmath4 variables and circuit treewidth @xmath5 has obdd size @xmath6 where @xmath7 is a fast growing ( double exponential ) function @xcite . the bound is tight in the sense that there are boolean functions of @xmath4 variables and circuit treewidth @xmath5 whose obdd size is @xmath8 @xcite . the bound ( [ eq : intr-1 ] ) gives polynomial size obdd implementations for circuits of bounded treewidth , but the degree of the polynomial depends ( badly ) on the treewidth . however , as jha and suciu show @xcite , restricting to functions of small _ circuit pathwidth _ resolves this issue . indeed , a boolean function of @xmath4 variables and circuit pathwidth @xmath5 has obdd width @xmath9 , hence obdd size @xmath10 and conversely , every boolean function of obdd width @xmath5 has circuit pathwidth @xmath11 . therefore , _ a class of boolean functions has bounded circuit pathwidth if and only if it has bounded obdd width . _ as jha and suciu conclude , the quest naturally arises for a similar characterization of bounded circuit treewidth . the quest involves , for starters , identifying a circuit class ideally as tractable as obdds but more succinct , and therefore capable of matching the bound ( [ eq : intr-2 ] ) . natural candidates , like fbdds or even nondeterministic read - once branching programs fail @xcite . the question is natural and nontrivial . compared to the substantial understanding of the compilability of cnf circuits parameterized by treewidth , or even cliquewidth @xcite , the parameterized compilability of general circuits is relatively unexplored and poorly understood ; which is unsatisfactory because , in theory , the circuit treewidth of a class of boolean functions can be bounded on general circuits and unbounded on cnfs ( * ? ? ? * example 2.9 ) ; and in practice , query lineages are often presented by circuits rather than by cnfs @xcite . the only bound on the size of a compilation for a circuit that avoids a dependence on its treewidth in the exponent , like in ( [ eq : intr-2 ] ) as opposed to ( [ eq : intr-1 ] ) , is a compilation of _ size _ @xmath12 circuits into _ decomposable _ forms of size @xmath13 by petke and razgon @xcite , where @xmath14 is an exponential function . this compilation , however , lacks two features that are either needed by or desirable in its intended application to query compilation . the crucial missing feature is that decomposable circuits , in the absence of determinism , do not support model counting ( nor , then , probability computation ) . besides , in the upper bound ( [ eq : intr-3 ] ) , the size of the compilation depends on the size of the circuit , @xmath12 , not just on the number of its variables , @xmath4 , and the former can be much larger than the latter . indeed , petke and razgon ask whether decomposable forms of size linear in @xmath4 are attainable for circuits of bounded treewidth ( * ? ? ? * section 5 ) . in the first part of the article ( section [ sect : part1 ] ) , we show that _ a class of boolean functions has bounded circuit treewidth if and only if it has bounded sdd width _ , which perfectly complements the aforementioned characterization of circuit pathwidth via obdd width by jha and suciu . more precisely , we prove the following ( theorem [ th : linear - sdd - size ] and surrounding discussion ) . result 1 . : : _ a boolean circuit of @xmath4 variables and treewidth @xmath5 has sdd width @xmath9 , thus sdd size @xmath15 where @xmath7 is a triple exponential function . conversely , every boolean function of sdd width @xmath5 has circuit treewidth @xmath11 . _ introduced by darwiche @xcite , _ sentential decision diagrams _ ( sdds ) are a relaxation of obdds based on a generalized form of shannon decomposition . an obdd respecting the variable ordering @xmath16 takes a _ binary decision _ of the form @xmath17 , where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are obdds respecting the variable ordering @xmath20 . intuitively , based on a binary case distinction on @xmath21 , the obdd executes subobdds respecting the subordering @xmath20 . an sdd respecting the variable tree @xmath22 , whose left and right subtrees split the variables in two disjoint blocks @xmath23 and @xmath24 , takes a _ sentential decision _ of the form @xmath25 . here , based on an @xmath12-ary ( exhaustive and disjoint ) case distinction on @xmath23 , implemented by the @xmath12 sdds @xmath26 respecting the left subtree of @xmath22 , the @xmath12 sdds @xmath27 respecting the right subtree of @xmath22 are executed . sdds are theoretically very robust , being essentially as tractable as obdds @xcite but exponentially more succinct @xcite . they are also appealing in practice since an sdd compiler is reasonable to design and implement ( as opposed to an fbdd compiler for instance , whose design is already fairly elusive ) . indeed , available sdds compilers already yield more succinct sdds than obdds , leveraging the additional flexibility offered by variable trees compared to variable orders @xcite . moreover , sdds have canonical forms , and hence carry a natural notion of width which in particular implies , if bounded , linear size implementations , exactly as obdd width does for obdds @xcite . thus , quite remarkably , our study unveils that circuit treewidth is characterized by an independently introduced , theoretically solid , and practically useful notion of circuit width , namely , sdd width . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3284,2549)(6189,-10343 ) ( 7164,-9063)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7793,-8476)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7111,-10231)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7059,-9650)(0,0)[lb ] figure [ fig : bf ] illustrates the compilability panorama for boolean functions relative to bounded circuit pathwidth / obdd width , bounded circuit treewidth / sdd width , and polynomial obdd and sdd size . the class @xmath28 contains all boolean functions of obdd width @xmath29 , and similarly for sdds ; the class @xmath30 contains all boolean functions of circuit treewidth @xmath29 , and similarly for cpw and circuit pathwidth . we have @xmath31 jha and suciu leave open the question whether the circuit treewidth of a boolean function is computable ( * ? ? ? * section 6 ) . using the fact that satisfiability of mso - sentences is decidable on graphs of bounded treewidth @xcite , we answer the question positively ( proposition [ prop : seese ] ) . result 2 . : : _ the circuit treewidth of a boolean function is computable . _ ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3284,2549)(6189,-10343 ) ( 7762,-8479)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7059,-9650)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7111,-10231)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7164,-9063)(0,0)[lb ] in the second part of the article ( section [ sect : part2 ] ) , we study the implications of our compilability results in query compilation , refining the picture drawn by jha and suciu for unions of conjunctive queries ( ucqs ) with and without inequalities @xcite . we prove the following statement ( theorem [ th : main - ineq ] ) . result 3 . : : _ a union of conjunctive queries with or without inequalities containing inversions has lineages of exponential deterministic structured size . _ introduced by dalvi and suciu @xcite , _ inversion freeness _ is a syntactic property of ucqs and ucqs with inequalities that implies compilability of their lineages in constant width ( linear size ) obdds and polynomial size obdds @xcite . on the other hand , if a query contains inversions , then it has lineages with large obdd @xcite , and even sdd @xcite , implementations . _ structuredness _ is a strong form of decomposability where not only for every and gate the circuits leading into the gate are defined on disjoint sets of variables @xcite , but their variables are partitioned accordingly to an underlying variable tree @xcite . as alluded in their informal description above , sdds as well as obdds are special deterministic structured forms . therefore result 3 formally generalizes analogous previous incompilability results for sdds and obdds @xcite . the proof has the main and sole merit to combine proof ideas of jha and suciu together with lower bound techniques for deterministic structured circuits based on single partition communication complexity @xcite . a careful inspection of the proof shows that result 3 also exponentially separates disjunctive normal forms ( dnfs ) , and even prime implicant forms ( ips ) , from structured deterministic negation normal forms ( nnfs ) . in this interpretation result 3 settles a special case of the much harder problem of separating dnfs ( and ips ) and deterministic decomposable nnfs ( d - dnnfs ) ; which , thanks to the recently established separation of decomposable nnfs ( dnnfs ) and d - dnnfs @xcite , is the last open question about the relative succinctness of the compilation languages considered in the classic article by darwiche and marquis @xcite . figure [ fig : ucq ] and figure [ fig : ucqneq ] give an overview of query compilability for lineages of ucqs with and without inequalities . for lineages of ucqs we have that @xmath32 because by result 3 inversions imply large structured deterministic forms , hence large sdds ; on the other hand , inversion freeness implies constant width obdds @xcite , so that @xmath33 . the picture for lineages of ucqs with inequalities is @xmath34 because again result 3 implies large sdds in the presence of inversions , and inversion freeness implies polynomial size obdds @xcite ; thus @xmath35 . in a symmetric fashion , jha and suciu conjecture that , for lineages of ucqs with inequalities , it also holds that @xmath36 . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3284,2549)(6189,-10343 ) ( 7762,-8479)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7164,-9063)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7111,-10231)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7059,-9650)(0,0)[lb ] our bound ( [ eq : int-4 ] ) amounts to a vast improvement of the available bounds . compared to ( [ eq : intr-1 ] ) , it attains linear size versus ( large degree ) polynomial size compilation on bounded circuit treewidth classes . compared to ( [ eq : intr-3 ] ) , it answers abundantly the quest for linear size decomposable forms for boolean functions of bounded treewidth : our forms are not just linear size and decomposable , but even deterministic and structured . pushing the dependency of the compilation size down from @xmath12 ( the size of the given circuit , as in ( [ eq : intr-3 ] ) ) to @xmath4 ( the number of its inputs , as in ( [ eq : int-4 ] ) ) required an entirely new compilation idea . of boolean variables of the query lineage @xmath2 is the ( large ) number of tuples in the database @xmath1 , and @xmath12 is the size of the circuit implementation of @xmath2 . roughly @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the size of the query @xmath0 . hence , avoiding a dependence on @xmath12 means obtaining a bound where the degree of the polynomial is a universal constant , not just independent of the circuit treewidth of @xmath2 , but also independent of @xmath0 . ] the idea used by petke and razgon @xcite to obtain ( [ eq : intr-3 ] ) was the following . given a circuit @xmath39 of @xmath40 variables and @xmath41 gates , first compute its tseitin cnf @xmath42 ; the circuit treewidth of the latter is ( linearly ) related to the former . to obtain a decomposable form for @xmath39 , existentially quantify the ( gate ) variables @xmath43 in a decomposable form @xmath44 for @xmath42 : @xmath45 this indirect approach via tseitin forms , however , introduces two critical issues . on the one hand , the size of @xmath44 depends on @xmath46 , so that the size of the compiled form will depend on @xmath12 ( as opposed to depending on @xmath4 only ) . on the other hand , for @xmath47 to have size polynomial in that of @xmath44 , the latter can not be deterministic @xcite ; hence the resulting compiled form will not be deterministic either . our compilation approach avoids tseitin forms and compiles the circuit directly ; it relies on a new insight on boolean functions , and more specifically on the combinatorics of their _ subfunctions _ or _ cofactors _ @xcite . dually to the notion of cofactor , we introduce ( definition [ def : factor ] ) the notion of _ factor _ of a boolean function @xmath48 , that is , a function @xmath49 whose models correspond exactly to the assignments of @xmath24 generating some cofactor of @xmath50 . we then show ( lemma [ lemma : factors ] ) that first , the rectangle @xmath51 formed by multiplying any two factors @xmath49 and @xmath52 of @xmath48 is either disjoint from @xmath50 , that is @xmath53 , or contained in @xmath50 , that is @xmath54 . and @xmath52 is a boolean function over @xmath55 whose models are exactly those assignments of @xmath55 whose restriction to @xmath24 ( @xmath56 ) models @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) . ] and second ( lemma [ lemma : drc ] ) , the pairs of factors @xmath49 and @xmath52 of @xmath48 satisfying the latter condition , call them implicants , form a disjoint rectangle cover of @xmath50 , that is , @xmath59 where the disjunction is deterministic and the conjunctions are decomposable ( structured , indeed ) . we then elaborate on the main technical lemma of jha and suciu ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2.12 ) to turn the above structural insight into a compilation of small size . we show that a circuit of small treewidth computing a function @xmath50 naturally delivers a variable tree where the number of cofactors of @xmath50 generated by assigning the variables below every node in the tree is small ( lemma [ lemma : jhasuciu ] ) . it follows that the disjoint rectangle covers described above are small for every factor of @xmath50 ; we then obtain the desired compilation by an inductive construction up the variable tree ( lemma [ lemma : dsdnnf - sub ] and theorem [ th : factorized - forms - main ] ) . indeed result 1 is proved for a more basic canonical deterministic structured class of circuits ( theorem [ th : factorized - forms - main ] and proposition [ prop : fiw - ctw ] ) , which is equivalent to sdds as far as the boundedness of their widths , and reduces to obdds in the special case of linear variable trees ; the class is of independent interest and gives a fresh structural insight into sdds ( see also the conclusion ) . our construction , significantly shorter to describe and easier to analyze than its precursors , effectively encompasses the construction by jha and suciu in that , if carried out in the special case of circuit pathwidth , it compiles a circuit of @xmath4 variables and pathwidth @xmath5 into an obdd ( not just an sdd ) of width @xmath9 and size @xmath60 . the article is organized as follows . the required notions from knowledge compilation and communication complexity are given in section [ sect : prel ] . the part of the article devoted to circuit treewidth and sentential decision ( section [ sect : part1 ] ) deals first with the introduction and the development of the notion of factor and factor width for a boolean function , and the relation of the latter with circuit treewidth ( section [ sect : fwbf ] ) ; next , it presents the actual compilations in canonical deterministic structured nnfs and sdds ( section [ sect : impl - sdnnf ] ) . section [ sect : part2 ] is devoted to query compilation . we present questions and directions for future research in section [ sect : concl ] . for every integer @xmath61 , we let @xmath62=\{1,\ldots , n\}$ ] . we refer the reader to a standard source for the notions of treewidth , tree decomposition , and nice tree decomposition @xcite . we consider ( boolean ) circuits over the standard basis , namely dags whose non - source nodes , called internal gates , are unbounded fanin conjunction ( @xmath63 ) and disjunction ( @xmath64 ) gates and fanin @xmath65 negation ( @xmath66 ) gates , and whose source nodes , called input gates , are pairwise distinct variables or constants ( @xmath67 and @xmath68 ) . a designated sink node is called the output gate . a circuit is in _ negation normal form _ , in short an _ nnf _ , if its negation gates are only wired by input gates . the size @xmath69 of a circuit @xmath70 is the number of its gates . let @xmath23 be a finite set of variables . a circuit @xmath70 over @xmath23 is a circuit whose input gates are labelled by variables in @xmath23 or by constants . a circuit @xmath70 on @xmath23 computes a boolean function @xmath71 over the boolean variables @xmath23 , @xmath72 in the usual way . we let @xmath73 denote the models of @xmath70 and @xmath74 . two circuits @xmath70 and @xmath75 over @xmath23 are equivalent , in symbols @xmath76 , if @xmath77 ; we also write @xmath78 or say that @xmath70 computes @xmath50 if @xmath79 . for a gate @xmath14 in a circuit @xmath70 over @xmath23 , we let @xmath80 denote the subcircuit of @xmath70 rooted at @xmath14 . in particular , @xmath81 if @xmath14 is the output gate of @xmath70 . for a circuit @xmath70 over variables @xmath23 and a gate @xmath82 , we let @xmath83 denote the variables appearing at input gates of @xmath80 . let @xmath14 be an @xmath64-gate in a circuit @xmath70 , and let @xmath84 and @xmath85 be two distinct gates wiring @xmath14 in @xmath70 . then @xmath14 is called _ deterministic _ if @xmath86 , viewing each circuit involved in the equation as a circuit over @xmath87 . the determinism of @xmath14 in @xmath70 implies that the two subcircuits @xmath88 and @xmath89 are independent in the sense that @xmath90 where each circuit involved in the equation is viewed as a circuit over @xmath87 . a circuit where all @xmath64-gates are deterministic is called _ let @xmath24 be a finite nonempty set of variables . a _ variable tree _ ( in short , a _ vtree _ ) for the variable set @xmath24 is a rooted , ordered , binary tree @xmath22 whose leaves correspond bijectively to @xmath24 ; for simplicity , we identify each leaf in @xmath22 with the variable in @xmath24 it corresponds to . for technical convenience , we slightly relax the standard definition not requiring for a vtree to be a full binary tree . for every internal node @xmath91 of the vtree @xmath22 with two children , we let @xmath92 and @xmath93 denote resp . the left and right child of @xmath91 . moreover , we denote by @xmath94 the subtree of @xmath22 rooted at node @xmath91 , and by @xmath95 ( the variables corresponding to ) the leaves of @xmath96 . let @xmath70 be a circuit over the variable set @xmath23 , and let @xmath22 be a vtree for the variable set @xmath24 . let @xmath14 be a fanin @xmath97 @xmath63-gate in @xmath70 , having wires from gates @xmath84 and @xmath85 , and let @xmath98 have two children @xmath92 and @xmath93 . we say that @xmath14 is _ structured by @xmath91 _ if @xmath99 and @xmath100 . we say that @xmath70 _ structured by @xmath22 _ if each @xmath63-gate in @xmath70 ( has fanin @xmath97 and ) is structured by some node in @xmath22 . a circuit is called _ structured _ if it is structured by some vtree . a class of structured nnfs is _ canonical _ if , for every boolean function @xmath101 and vtree @xmath102 with @xmath103 , if two circuits @xmath70 and @xmath75 in the class both compute @xmath50 and are structured by @xmath22 , then they are syntactically equal ( not just semantically equivalent ) . note that if a gate @xmath82 is structured , then it is also _ decomposable _ , i.e. , every two distinct gates @xmath84 and @xmath85 wiring @xmath14 satisfy @xmath104 . the decomposability of @xmath14 in @xmath70 implies that the two subcircuits @xmath88 and @xmath89 are independent in the sense that @xmath105 when viewing each circuit involved in the equation as a circuit over its own variables . a _ sentential decision diagram _ , in short _ sdd _ , is a deterministic structured nnf @xmath70 over @xmath23 of the form @xmath106 } ( p_i \wedge s_i ) \text{,}\ ] ] structured by a vtree @xmath102 , @xmath103 , such that the following holds . there exists a node @xmath98 with two children @xmath107 and @xmath108 structuring each @xmath63-gate appearing in ( [ eq : sdd - def ] ) , the @xmath109 s are sdds over @xmath110 structured by @xmath111 , the @xmath112 s are sdds over @xmath113 structured by @xmath114 , and moreover : * @xmath115}p_i \equiv \top$ ] ; * @xmath116 for all @xmath117 in @xmath118 $ ] . constants ( @xmath67 and @xmath68 ) are sdds ( over any variable set ) structured by any vtree , and a literal ( @xmath119 or @xmath120 ) is an sdd ( over any variable set containing @xmath119 ) structured by any vtree containing @xmath119 . sdds become canonical forms if , in addition to the above , the following holds @xcite : * @xmath121 for all @xmath117 in @xmath118 $ ] . let @xmath23 be a finite set of variables . a partition of @xmath23 is a sequence of pairwise disjoint subsets ( blocks ) of @xmath23 whose union is @xmath23 . let @xmath122 be a partition of @xmath23 . for @xmath123 and @xmath124 , we let @xmath125 denote the assignment of @xmath23 whose restriction to @xmath126 equals @xmath127 for @xmath128 . also , for @xmath129 and @xmath130 , we let @xmath131 . a _ ( combinatorial ) rectangle _ over @xmath23 is a boolean function @xmath132 over the boolean variables @xmath23 such that there exist a partition @xmath122 of @xmath23 and boolean functions @xmath133 for @xmath128 such that @xmath134 . we also call a subset @xmath135 of @xmath136 a rectangle over @xmath23 , with underlying partition @xmath122 , if there exists a rectangle @xmath137 , with underlying partition @xmath122 , such that @xmath138 . let @xmath139 be a boolean function over the boolean variables @xmath23 . a finite set @xmath140\}$ ] of rectangles over @xmath23 is called a _ rectangle cover _ of @xmath50 if @xmath141 } \mathsf{sat}(r_i ) \text{;}\ ] ] the rectangle cover is called _ disjoint _ if the union in ( [ eq : rect - cover ] ) is disjoint . disjoint rectangle covers and deterministic structured nnfs are tightly related . @xcite[th : struct ] let @xmath70 be a ( deterministic ) structured nnf computing a function @xmath139 and respecting a vtree @xmath22 for @xmath23 . for every node @xmath98 , @xmath50 has a ( disjoint ) rectangle cover of size at most @xmath69 where each rectangle has underlying partition @xmath142 . let @xmath101 be a boolean function , and let @xmath122 be a partition of @xmath23 where @xmath143 . the _ communication matrix _ of @xmath50 relative to @xmath122 , denoted by @xmath144 is a boolean matrix whose rows and columns are indexed by boolean assignments of @xmath145 and @xmath146 , resp . , and whose @xmath147th entry equals @xmath148 . we regard communication matrices as matrices over the reals . a basic fact in communication complexity is that the rank of the communication matrix is a lower bound on the size of disjoint rectangle covers of a function . * section 4.1)[th : rklb ] let @xmath149 be a partition of the variables of a function @xmath50 , where @xmath143 . every disjoint rectangle cover of @xmath50 into rectangles with underlying partition @xmath149 contains at least @xmath150 rectangles . a typical application of the above statement is the _ disjointness function _ , @xmath151 where @xmath152 and @xmath153 . it is folklore that @xmath154 i.e. , the communication matrix of @xmath155 relative to @xmath156 has full rank ( * ? ? ? * exercise 7.1 ) . thus every disjoint rectangle cover of @xmath155 into rectangles with underlying partition @xmath157 has at least @xmath158 rectangles . in this section , we introduce the notion of factor width of a boolean function , relate it with its circuit treewidth , and show that , when parameterized by its factor width , a boolean function admits a linear size compilation into some natural classes of canonical deterministic structured nnfs ( including sdds ) . we introduce the notion of _ factor width _ , and recall from the literature the notion of circuit treewidth @xcite . let @xmath159 be a boolean function over a finite set of variables @xmath23 . for a set of variables @xmath24 we use the notation @xmath160 to display a partition of the variables of @xmath50 into the two blocks @xmath161 and @xmath162 . it is intended that if @xmath163 and @xmath164 , then @xmath165 . the _ cofactor _ ( or _ subfunction _ ) of @xmath50 induced by @xmath163 is the boolean function @xmath166 such that @xmath167 for all @xmath164 . a function @xmath168 is called a _ cofactor of @xmath101 relative to @xmath162 _ if it is equal to the cofactor of @xmath50 induced by some @xmath163 . [ ex : cofactors ] let @xmath169 be boolean implication , i.e. @xmath170 iff @xmath171 , for all @xmath172 . the cofactors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath173 , induced by boolean assignments of @xmath119 , are @xmath174 and @xmath175 . the cofactors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath119 , induced by boolean assignments of @xmath173 , are @xmath176 and @xmath177 . the cofactors of @xmath50 induced by boolean assignments of both @xmath119 and @xmath173 are @xmath178 and @xmath179 . the only cofactor of @xmath50 induced by boolean assignments of no variables is @xmath180 itself . we introduce notation to denote the cofactor of a boolean function @xmath101 generated by replacing , in a partition of @xmath23 , the variables in certain blocks by constants . let @xmath181 be a partition of @xmath23 , let @xmath182 $ ] , and let @xmath183 for all @xmath184 . we write @xmath185 where @xmath186 if @xmath184 and @xmath187 otherwise , for all @xmath188 $ ] , to denote the cofactor of @xmath50 induced by @xmath189 , i.e. the boolean function over the variables @xmath190\setminus l } y_i$ ] defined , for every @xmath190\setminus l } ( b_i \colon y_i \to \{0,1\})$ ] , by @xmath191\setminus l } b_i \mapsto f(b_1,\ldots , b_l)\text{.}\ ] ] [ ex : notation ] let @xmath50 be as in example [ ex : cofactors ] , so that @xmath139 for @xmath192 . let @xmath193 . we write @xmath194 . let @xmath195 . we write @xmath196 to denote the cofactor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath162 induced by @xmath197 . if @xmath198 , then @xmath199 . let @xmath200 . intuitively , a factor of @xmath201 is a function @xmath49 whose models correspond exactly to the assignments of @xmath24 that induce some fixed cofactor @xmath202 of @xmath50 . [ def : factor]let @xmath24 and @xmath23 be finite sets of variables and let @xmath203 be a boolean function . a boolean function @xmath204 is called a _ factor of @xmath101 relative to @xmath24 _ if there exists a cofactor @xmath205 of @xmath50 such that @xmath206 the factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath24 are denoted by @xmath207 . [ ex : factors ] let @xmath169 be boolean implication as in example [ ex : cofactors ] . the function @xmath208 is a factor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath119 , because there exists a cofactor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath173 , namely @xmath209 , such that @xmath210 iff @xmath211 . the function @xmath212 is a factor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath119 , because there exists a cofactor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath173 , namely @xmath213 , such that @xmath210 iff @xmath211 . note that cofactors and factors of a boolean function relative to a variable set are , in general , distinct . [ ex : fneqcof ] let @xmath169 be boolean implication as in example [ ex : cofactors ] . then @xmath208 is a factor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath119 ( example [ ex : factors ] ) , but it is not a cofactor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath119 , since the only cofactors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath119 are equivalent to @xmath120 and @xmath214 ( example [ ex : cofactors ] ) . note that , by definition [ def : factor ] , @xmath215 but we insist on @xmath24 being an arbitrary set of variables for technical convenience . moreover , again by definition [ def : factor ] , @xmath216 and the union is disjoint . in words , @xmath207 naturally determines a partition of @xmath217 whose blocks , of the form @xmath218 for @xmath219 , correspond to the cofactors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath220 . finally , we introduce the notion of factor width of a boolean function . let @xmath139 be a boolean function and let @xmath22 be a vtree for @xmath221 . the _ factor width of @xmath50 relative to @xmath22 _ , in symbols @xmath222 , is defined by @xmath223 the _ factor width _ of @xmath50 is defined by @xmath224 the _ treewidth of a circuit _ @xmath70 , in symbols @xmath225 , is the treewidth of the undirected graph underlying ( the directed acyclic graph underlying ) @xmath70 . the _ circuit treewidth _ @xmath226 of a boolean function @xmath50 is the minimum treewidth of a circuit computing @xmath50 . a crucial fact in our development is that the factor width of a boolean function is bounded above by a function of its circuit treewidth . the proof is a revisitation of ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2.12 ) . [ lemma : jhasuciu ] for all boolean functions @xmath50 , @xmath227 let @xmath70 be a treewidth @xmath228 circuit computing the boolean function @xmath101 . let @xmath135 be a _ tree decomposition of the gates of @xmath70 , witnessing treewidth @xmath228 ; without loss of generality , the root of @xmath135 is the empty bag , therefore each input gate of @xmath70 ( i.e. , each variable in @xmath23 ) is forgotten exactly once in @xmath135 . we associate to @xmath135 a vtree @xmath22 for @xmath23 as follows . let @xmath229 be a set of fresh variables in a bijective correspondence with the leaves of @xmath135 . label the leaves of @xmath135 by pairwise distinct ( dummy ) variables in @xmath229 . for every variable @xmath230 , append a fresh leaf labelled @xmath119 to the node forgetting @xmath119 in @xmath135 . the resulting tree @xmath22 is a vtree for @xmath231 . for every @xmath98 , let @xmath232 denote the variables in @xmath23 appearing in @xmath96 ( or equivalently , the variables in @xmath96 that are not dummy variables ) . in light of ( [ eq : dummyvars ] ) , to show that @xmath233 it is sufficient to prove that @xmath234 matches the bound for all @xmath98 . if @xmath91 is a leaf in @xmath22 , then @xmath235 for some @xmath230 and @xmath236 , or @xmath91 is labelled by some dummy variable in @xmath229 , so that @xmath237 and @xmath238 . otherwise @xmath91 is a bag @xmath239 in @xmath135 and in this case @xmath232 contains the variables in @xmath23 forgotten by nodes in the subtree of @xmath135 rooted at @xmath91 . for a gate @xmath14 in @xmath70 , let @xmath240 be the gates in @xmath239 with a directed path to @xmath14 in ( the dag underlying ) @xmath70 whose intermediate gates are not in @xmath239 . namely , @xmath241 iff @xmath242 and there exists a directed path @xmath243 in the dag underlying @xmath70 such that @xmath244 . let @xmath14 be a gate in @xmath70 . we freely identify @xmath80 , the subcircuit of @xmath70 rooted at @xmath14 , with the boolean function on @xmath23 it computes . [ cl : main - cl ] for every @xmath82 , it holds that @xmath245 be a set of fresh variables . let @xmath246 denote the circuit obtained from @xmath80 by transforming each gate @xmath241 into an input gate labelled by the variable @xmath247 . we distinguish two cases depending on whether or not @xmath14 is in @xmath239 . if @xmath248 , then observe that @xmath249 , or @xmath250 ; otherwise , if @xmath251 uses variables in both @xmath232 and @xmath252 then , in the graph underlying @xmath70 , there exists a path from @xmath232 to @xmath252 not intersecting @xmath239 , contradicting the properties of @xmath135 . if @xmath249 then , for every @xmath253 , @xmath254 is a function of @xmath43 among at most @xmath255 possibilities . otherwise , if @xmath250 , then every @xmath253 yields the same function @xmath256 of @xmath257 . since each variable @xmath247 in @xmath251 represents the subcircuit @xmath258 of @xmath70 for @xmath241 , it follows that @xmath259 if @xmath260 , then each proper subcircuit of @xmath251 uses only variables in @xmath261 or only variables in @xmath257 ; otherwise we obtain a contradiction as above . let @xmath262 and @xmath263 be a bipartition of the immediate subcircuits of @xmath251 such that the @xmath264 s only use variables in @xmath261 and the @xmath265 s only use variables in @xmath257 . if @xmath14 is an @xmath63-gate , then @xmath266 for every @xmath253 , @xmath267 is a function @xmath268 over @xmath43 ; on the other hand , every @xmath253 yields the same function @xmath269 over @xmath257 , namely @xmath270 . therefore , for all @xmath253 , @xmath254 is a function over @xmath257 of the form @xmath271 where @xmath268 is a function over @xmath43 , so that @xmath272 recalling that each variable @xmath247 in @xmath251 represents the subcircuit @xmath258 of @xmath70 for @xmath241 , we have @xmath259 the cases where @xmath14 is a @xmath64-gate or a @xmath66-gate are similar , and the claim is proved . for all @xmath82 , let @xmath273 . by induction on @xmath274 we prove that for all @xmath260 it holds that latexmath:[\[\label{eq : ind } for the base case , let @xmath260 be such that @xmath276 . then @xmath277 where the first inequality holds by ( [ eq : rec ] ) as @xmath278 in this case . for the inductive case , let @xmath260 be such that @xmath279 . then , resp . by ( [ eq : rec ] ) and the induction hypothesis as @xmath280 for all @xmath241 , @xmath281 but @xmath282 where @xmath283 justifies the last inequality . we now conclude the proof . let @xmath14 be the output gate of @xmath70 , i.e. , @xmath284 . then , justifying the first and second inequalities resp . by ( [ eq : rec ] ) and by ( [ eq : ind ] ) , @xmath240 and @xmath285 , @xmath286 and we are done . we conclude the section observing that circuit treewidth is computable , thus answering a question posed by jha and suciu ( * ? ? ? * section 6 ) . [ prop : seese ] the circuit treewidth of a boolean function is computable . let @xmath287 be a variable set . say that a graph ( with loops ) @xmath57 _ implements _ a circuit over @xmath23 iff there exists a circuit @xmath70 over @xmath23 such that @xmath57 is ( isomorphic to ) the graph whose edge set @xmath288 is defined relative to @xmath70 as follows : * for every wire @xmath289 in @xmath70 , add to @xmath288 a path @xmath290 , @xmath291 , @xmath292 from @xmath14 to @xmath293 with a loop on @xmath85 , where @xmath84 and @xmath85 are fresh vertices . * add to @xmath288 a loop on the output gate @xmath14 of @xmath70 . * let @xmath294 for every @xmath295-gate @xmath14 in @xmath70 , add to @xmath288 a @xmath296-star @xmath297 , @xmath298 , @xmath299 centered at @xmath14 , where @xmath300 are fresh vertices . intuitively a graph ( with loops ) @xmath57 implementing a circuit @xmath70 is a faithful representation of @xmath70 in the vocabulary of graphs , where the arcs and labels used to represent @xmath70 in the vocabulary of circuits are suitably expressed by edges ( and loops ) . let @xmath50 be a boolean function over @xmath23 . it is a tedious but straightforward exercise to write an mso sentence @xmath301 that is true on a graph ( with loops ) @xmath57 iff @xmath57 implements a circuit @xmath70 on @xmath23 computing @xmath101 ( * ? ? ? * examples 4.10 , 4.13 , and 4.18 ) . also note that , if the graph ( with loops ) @xmath57 implements a circuit @xmath70 , then the treewidth of @xmath57 is equal to the treewidth of @xmath70 . now , let @xmath5 be an upper bound on the circuit treewidth of @xmath50 ( for instance , the treewidth of the dnf whose terms are exactly the models of @xmath50 ) . seese proves that , given an mso sentence on the vocabulary of graphs , it is decidable whether it is satisfied by a graph ( with loops ) of treewidth @xmath5 @xcite . we therefore cycle for @xmath302 until we find @xmath303 such that @xmath301 is modeled by a graph of treewidth @xmath304 . we show that boolean functions of small factor width have implementations of small width within natural canonical subclasses of deterministic structured nnfs ( including canonical sdds ) ; conversely , small width implementations within such circuit classes imply small circuit treewidth . thus a class of boolean functions has bounded circuit treewidth iff it has bounded width implementations in some natural , canonical classes of deterministic structured nnfs , including sdds . we introduce the notion of _ factorized implicant _ of a boolean function @xmath48 , roughly @xmath305 where @xmath24 and @xmath56 are disjoint sets of variables , @xmath306 ( resp . , @xmath307 ) is a factor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath24 ( resp . , @xmath56 ) . the first key insight is that the rectangle formed by multiplying any two factors @xmath308 and @xmath309 of @xmath48 is either disjoint from @xmath50 or contained in @xmath50 . [ lemma : factors ] let @xmath139 be a boolean function . let @xmath24 and @xmath56 be disjoint subsets of @xmath23 . let @xmath269 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 be factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath55 , @xmath24 , and @xmath56 , respectively . then either @xmath310 or @xmath311 if @xmath312 , then let @xmath313 and @xmath314 be such that @xmath315 . let @xmath316 and @xmath317 . it suffices to show that @xmath318 . below , @xmath319 . assume for a contradiction that @xmath320 . therefore , by definition , the cofactors of @xmath50 induced by @xmath321 and @xmath322 are distinct , i.e. , @xmath323 on the other hand , by definition , @xmath324 implies that @xmath325 , and similarly @xmath326 implies that @xmath327 . in particular , @xmath328 and @xmath329 . then @xmath330 a contradiction . intuitively , a factorized implicant of a function @xmath48 is a pair of factors @xmath308 and @xmath309 entirely contained in @xmath50 , as in ( [ eq : rect - cont ] ) . formally , let @xmath139 be a boolean function . let @xmath269 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 be factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath55 , @xmath24 , and @xmath56 , resp . , where @xmath24 and @xmath56 are disjoint subsets of @xmath23 . then @xmath331 is a _ factorized implicant of @xmath269 relative to @xmath332 _ if @xmath57 and @xmath58 satisfy ( [ eq : rect - cont ] ) relative to @xmath269 . we denote by @xmath333 the set of factorized implicants of @xmath269 relative to @xmath332 . the second key insight is that the factorized implicants of @xmath48 naturally induce a disjoint rectangle cover for @xmath48 . [ lemma : drc ] let @xmath139 be a boolean function and let @xmath269 be a factor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath55 , where @xmath24 and @xmath56 are disjoint subsets of @xmath23 . then @xmath334 forms a disjoint rectangle cover of @xmath269 , i.e. , @xmath335 and the union is disjoint . a circuit interpretation of lemma [ lemma : drc ] is that @xmath336 where @xmath337 , @xmath338 , and @xmath339 are circuits using variables in @xmath55 , @xmath24 , and @xmath56 computing @xmath269 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 , respectively . the @xmath63-gates are decomposable as @xmath24 and @xmath56 are disjoint , and by lemma [ lemma : drc ] the @xmath64-gate is deterministic . we claim that the union on the right of ( [ eq : main - node-1 ] ) is disjoint . indeed if @xmath340 and @xmath341 are distinct implicants in @xmath333 , then @xmath342 or @xmath343 . if @xmath342 , then @xmath344 because distinct factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath24 have disjoint models by ( [ eq : part ] ) . similarly , if @xmath343 , then @xmath345 therefore , @xmath346 , and we are done . we prove the equality in ( [ eq : main - node-1 ] ) . for the nontrivial inclusion ( @xmath347 ) , let @xmath348 be in @xmath349 . by ( [ eq : part ] ) , there exist @xmath219 such that @xmath350 and @xmath351 such that @xmath352 . then @xmath353 . it follows by lemma [ lemma : factors ] that @xmath354 . then @xmath355 and @xmath197 is contained in the union on the right . the above insight can be exploited recursively to implement boolean functions within a natural , canonical class of deterministic structured forms . let @xmath50 be a function and let @xmath22 be a vtree , both over the variables @xmath23 . for every node @xmath98 and every factor @xmath269 of @xmath50 relative to @xmath232 , we construct a circuit @xmath356 as follows . if @xmath91 is a leaf of @xmath22 , then @xmath235 for some variable @xmath230 . there are two cases . either @xmath357 , or @xmath358 . in the former case , @xmath359 and @xmath360 in the latter case , @xmath361 and @xmath362 if @xmath91 is a node of @xmath22 with children @xmath107 and @xmath108 , we put @xmath363 finally we put @xmath364 where @xmath365 is the root of @xmath22 ; note that @xmath50 itself is a factor of @xmath50 relative to @xmath23 ; its models induce the cofactor @xmath366 of @xmath50 , the identically @xmath65 function ( over @xmath367 ) . [ lemma : dsdnnf - sub ] let @xmath50 be a boolean function and let @xmath22 be a vtree , both over the variables @xmath23 . let @xmath98 and let @xmath368 . the following holds . * @xmath356 is a deterministic structured nnf respecting the vtree @xmath96 . * @xmath356 computes @xmath269 . the proof is a routine induction on the depth of @xmath91 in @xmath22 . the base case holds by inspection of ( [ eq : base-1])-([eq : base-3 ] ) . the inductive case holds by inspection of ( [ eq : main - node ] ) , using ( [ eq : main - node-1 ] ) in lemma [ lemma : drc ] and the induction hypothesis ; indeed , note that the disjunction arising in ( [ eq : main - node ] ) is deterministic because the union in ( [ eq : main - node-1 ] ) is disjoint , and the conjunctions arising in ( [ eq : main - node ] ) are structured by @xmath96 ( namely the left and right conjuncts are over variables @xmath369 and @xmath370 resp . , where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are the children of @xmath91 in @xmath22 ) by the induction hypothesis . note that , by lemma [ lemma : dsdnnf - sub ] , it follows that @xmath371 is a deterministic structured nnf computing @xmath50 , canonical in that it is uniquely determined by the vtree @xmath22 and @xmath50 ; the notion of _ factorized implicant width _ of @xmath50 relative to @xmath22 arises naturally . let @xmath50 be a boolean function and let @xmath22 be a vtree , both over the variables @xmath23 . factorized implicant width of @xmath50 relative to @xmath22 _ , in symbols @xmath372 , is defined by is an @xmath63-gate arising from ( [ eq : main - node ] ) , we say that @xmath14 is _ structured _ by @xmath98 . ] @xmath373 the _ factorized implicant width _ of @xmath50 , in symbols @xmath374 , is defined by @xmath375 relative to its factorized implicant width , a boolean function ( of @xmath4 variables ) has linear ( in @xmath4 ) size compilations into canonical deterministic structured forms . [ th : factorized - forms - main ] a boolean function @xmath50 of @xmath4 variables and factorized implicant width @xmath5 has canonical deterministic structured nnfs of size @xmath376 . let @xmath23 be the variables of @xmath50 , so that @xmath377 , and let @xmath22 be a vtree for @xmath23 witnessing factorized implicant width @xmath5 for @xmath50 . the circuit @xmath371 in ( [ eq : cft ] ) is a canonical deterministic structured nnf computing @xmath50 by lemma [ lemma : dsdnnf - sub ] . moreover , we claim that @xmath371 has size @xmath376 . the @xmath4 leaves of @xmath22 contribute at most @xmath378 input gates and @xmath4 @xmath66-gates in @xmath371 . the @xmath379 internal nodes of @xmath22 contribute each at most @xmath5 @xmath63-gates ( by the definition of factorized implicant width ) , and each such gate is linked with at most @xmath380 @xmath64-gates . hence @xmath371 contains at most @xmath381 gates . we conclude the section showing that a class of boolean functions has bounded circuit treewidth iff it has bounded factorized implicant width . it is sufficient to prove that the factorized implicant width of a boolean function is bounded below and above by computable functions of its circuit treewidth . for the upper bound , we have @xmath382 where the first inequality is justified by the observation that every @xmath63-gate @xmath14 in @xmath371 , structured by a node @xmath98 , corresponds to a pair of factors of @xmath50 , and the second inequality follows by lemma [ lemma : jhasuciu ] . for the lower bound , we verify that small factorized implicant width implies small circuit treewidth . [ prop : fiw - ctw ] for all boolean functions @xmath50 , @xmath383 let @xmath22 be a vtree for @xmath23 such that @xmath384 we claim that @xmath385 , so that @xmath386 by lemma [ lemma : dsdnnf - sub ] . for every gate @xmath387 , let @xmath388 denote the closed neighborhood of @xmath14 in the undirected graph underlying @xmath371 . we define a tree decomposition for the undirected graph underlying @xmath371 , as follows . the bags of the tree decomposition have the form @xmath389 for all @xmath98 . the root of the tree decomposition is @xmath390 . the bag @xmath391 has an arc to the bag @xmath392 iff @xmath107 has an arc to @xmath108 in @xmath22 . by definition , @xmath393 contains all the @xmath63-gates structured by the node @xmath98 ; there are at most @xmath5 such gates in @xmath371 by definition , and each such gate has indegree @xmath97 and outdegree @xmath65 by construction ( therefore degree @xmath380 in the undirected graph underlying @xmath371 ) . hence @xmath394 . we check the desired properties . since every wire of @xmath371 enters or leaves an @xmath63-gate and every @xmath63-gate is structured by some @xmath98 , the edges of the undirected graph underlying @xmath371 are covered by the tree decomposition . moreover let @xmath14 be a gate of @xmath371 occurring in two distinct bags @xmath391 and @xmath392 . then @xmath395 where @xmath84 is a @xmath63-gate structured by @xmath107 and @xmath85 is a @xmath63-gate structured by @xmath108 . by construction of @xmath371 , either @xmath107 has an arc to @xmath108 in @xmath22 or @xmath108 has an arc to @xmath107 in @xmath22 . hence @xmath391 and @xmath392 are adjacent . we show that the notion of factorized implicant lies at the core of ( and provides fresh insight on ) the canonical construction of sdds for boolean functions . we prepare the actual description of the construction in two steps . the first step yields , by a straightforward generalization of lemma [ lemma : drc ] , a factorized implicant decomposition reminiscent of ( [ eq : syntactic - fif ] ) for unions of factors . [ lemma : union - drc ] let @xmath139 be a boolean function , let @xmath24 and @xmath56 be disjoint subsets of @xmath23 , and let @xmath396 . then @xmath397 forms a disjoint rectangle cover of @xmath398 . in terms of circuits , the statement means that @xmath399 where @xmath337 , @xmath338 , and @xmath339 are as in ( [ eq : syntactic - fif ] ) , the @xmath64-gate is deterministic , and the @xmath63-gates are decomposable . we have @xmath400 where the second equality follows by applying lemma [ lemma : drc ] to @xmath269 . we claim that the union is disjoint . indeed , by ( [ eq : part ] ) , distinct factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath55 , in particular those in @xmath401 , have disjoint models ; moreover , by lemma [ lemma : drc ] , distinct implicants of a factor have disjoint models . the second step enforces the properties of a proper sentential decision over the factorized implicant form ( [ eq : syntactic - sdd ] ) given by lemma [ lemma : union - drc ] , as follows . for each @xmath219 , let @xmath402 and observe that @xmath403 where empty disjunctions are implemented by @xmath67 , is equivalent to @xmath404 and is a sentential decision form as the factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath24 partition @xmath405 . however , ( [ eq : noncanonical - sdd - form ] ) is not a canonical form because distinct @xmath406 and @xmath407 in @xmath207 can give @xmath408 . let @xmath409 for all @xmath410 $ ] , and @xmath411 it is readily observed that @xmath412 is equivalent to @xmath413 and moreover : * @xmath414}\bigvee_{p \in \mathcal{p}_i } c_p$ ] ; * @xmath415 for @xmath117 in @xmath118 $ ] ; * @xmath416 for @xmath117 in @xmath118 $ ] . we now use the above development to describe a recursive construction of a canonical sdd for a given boolean function . let @xmath50 be a boolean function and let @xmath22 be a vtree , both over @xmath23 . for every node @xmath98 and every subset @xmath401 of factors of @xmath50 relative to @xmath232 , we construct a circuit @xmath417 , as follows . if @xmath91 is a leaf of @xmath22 , then @xmath235 for some variable @xmath230 . there are two cases . either @xmath357 , or @xmath358 . in the former case , @xmath359 and : @xmath418 ; @xmath419 . in the latter case , @xmath361 and : @xmath418 ; @xmath420 ; @xmath421 ; @xmath422 . if @xmath91 is a node of @xmath22 with children @xmath107 and @xmath108 , we put @xmath423 finally we put , where @xmath365 is the root of @xmath22 , @xmath424 [ lemma : sdd - constr - correct ] let @xmath50 be a boolean function and let @xmath22 be a vtree , both over the variables @xmath23 . let @xmath98 and let @xmath425 . * @xmath417 is a canonical sdd respecting the vtree @xmath96 . * @xmath417 computes @xmath426 . by induction on the depth of @xmath91 in @xmath22 . the base case holds by construction . the inductive case holds inspection of ( [ eq : cvh ] ) , using ( [ eq : canonical - sdd - form ] ) together with ( sd1)-(sd3 ) , ( [ eq : noncanonical - sdd - form ] ) , lemma [ lemma : union - drc ] , and the induction hypothesis . therefore @xmath427 is the canonical sdd computing @xmath50 , uniquely determined by the vtree @xmath22 . we recall the notion of _ sentential decision width _ of @xmath50 relative to @xmath22 . [ def : sdd - width ] let @xmath50 be a boolean function and let @xmath22 be a vtree , both over @xmath23 . the _ sentential decision width of @xmath50 relative to @xmath22 _ , in symbols @xmath428 , is defined by @xmath429 the _ sdd width _ of @xmath50 , in symbols @xmath430 , is defined by @xmath431 it is well known that obdds are canonical sdds respecting linear vtrees , i.e. vtrees where every left child is a leaf @xcite ; in this case , the notion of sdd width in definition [ def : sdd - width ] reduces to the usual notion of obdd width @xcite . moreover , as a boolean function ( of @xmath4 variables ) has linear ( in @xmath4 ) obdd size parameterized by its obdd width , likewise it has linear sdd size parameterized by its sdd width . [ th : linear - sdd - size ] a boolean function @xmath50 of @xmath4 variables and sdd width @xmath5 has canonical sdd size @xmath376 . let @xmath23 be the variables of @xmath50 , so that @xmath377 , and let @xmath22 be a vtree for @xmath23 witnessing sdd width @xmath5 for @xmath50 . the circuit @xmath427 in ( [ eq : sdd - root ] ) is a canonical sdd by lemma [ lemma : sdd - constr - correct ] . moreover , we claim that @xmath427 has size @xmath376 . the @xmath4 leaves of @xmath22 contribute at most @xmath432 input or negation gates in @xmath371 . the @xmath379 internal nodes of @xmath22 contribute each at most @xmath5 @xmath63-gates ( by the definition of sdd width ) , and each such gate is linked with at most @xmath380 @xmath64-gates . hence @xmath371 contains at most @xmath433 gates . we conclude observing that , for classes of boolean functions , bounded circuit treewidth and bounded sdd width collapse . indeed , on the one hand , the sdd width of a boolean function @xmath50 is bounded above by a computable function of its circuit treewidth , namely , @xmath434 since in the canonical sdd @xmath427 for @xmath22 every @xmath63-gate @xmath14 structured by a node @xmath98 corresponds to a pair of sets of factors of @xmath50 ( plus @xmath67 ) , and @xmath435 is bounded above by @xmath226 as in lemma [ lemma : jhasuciu ] . on the other hand , for all boolean functions @xmath50 , along the lines of proposition [ prop : fiw - ctw ] , @xmath436 by combining ( [ eq : fiw - ub])-([eq : fiw - lb ] ) and ( [ eq : sdd - ub])-([eq : sdd - lb ] ) , the factorized implicant width ( resp . , sdd width ) of a boolean function is squeezed between computable functions of its sdd width ( resp . , factorized implicant width ) . in this section , we show that inversions in unions of conjunctive queries , with or without inequalities , imply large deterministic structured circuits for their lineages . let @xmath437 be a relational vocabulary . union of conjunctive queries ( ucqs ) with inequalities _ @xmath0 is a disjunction of existentially closed conjunctions of atoms @xmath438 and inequalities @xmath439 , where @xmath440 and @xmath119 , @xmath173 , @xmath441 are variables , @xmath410 $ ] . we call @xmath0 a ucqs if it does not contain inequalities . the _ lineage of a boolean query @xmath0 over a database @xmath1 _ is a boolean function @xmath2 whose boolean variables are the tuples in @xmath1 such that , for every subdatabase @xmath442 , it holds that @xmath443 iff @xmath444 , where @xmath445 is defined by @xmath446 iff @xmath447 . a _ lineage of a boolean query _ is a lineage of the query over some database . we prove the main result . for all @xmath448 , let @xmath449 \}$ ] , @xmath450 \}$ ] , @xmath451 \}$ ] for @xmath452 $ ] , and @xmath453}z^i$ ] . for @xmath454 $ ] , let : @xmath455 } ( x_{l } \wedge z^1_{l , m})\text{,}\\ h^i_{k , n}(z^i , z^{i+1 } ) & = \bigvee_{l , m \in [ n ] } ( z^i_{l , m } \wedge z^{i+1}_{l , m})\text{,}\\ h^k_{k , n}(z^k , y ) & = \bigvee_{l , m \in [ n ] } ( z^k_{l , m } \wedge y_{m})\text{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in ( * ? ? ? * proposition 7 ) and ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.9 ) jha and suciu show the following , resp . for ucqs and ucqs with inequalities . [ lemma : inv - impl - h ] let @xmath0 be a ucqs with or without inequalities . if @xmath0 contains an inversion of length @xmath456 , then for every @xmath61 there exist a lineage @xmath101 of @xmath0 on @xmath457 variables and assignments @xmath458 for @xmath459 and @xmath460 such that @xmath461 as we only need the implication stated in lemma [ lemma : inv - impl - h ] , we omit the technical definition of the notion of inversion @xcite . the following statement unifies and generalizes analogous results by jha and suciu for ucqs with inequalities vs. obdds ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.9 ) and by beame and liew for ucqs vs. sdds ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.6 ) . [ th : main - ineq ] let @xmath0 be a ucqs with or without inequalities . if @xmath0 contains an inversion of length @xmath456 , then for every @xmath61 there exists a lineage @xmath50 of @xmath0 on @xmath457 variables whose deterministic structured nnf size is @xmath462 . let @xmath0 be a query with inequalities . if @xmath0 contains an inversion of length @xmath456 , then by lemma [ lemma : inv - impl - h ] for every @xmath61 there exist a lineage @xmath101 of @xmath0 on @xmath457 variables and assignments @xmath458 for @xmath459 and @xmath460 such that @xmath463 . let @xmath70 be a deterministic nnf of size @xmath464 computing @xmath50 , structured by the vtree @xmath22 . then by the properties of deterministic structured nnfs dblp : conf / aaai / pipatsrisawatd08 , it holds that @xmath465 is a deterministic nnf of size @xmath466 that computes @xmath467 and is structured by @xmath22 , for all @xmath460 . by lemma [ lemma : main - inversion ] , there exists @xmath468 such that @xmath469 has size @xmath470 . therefore @xmath70 has size @xmath462 . the proof idea is that , if a query @xmath0 contains inversions , then it has a lineage @xmath2 of which each @xmath471 is a cofactor ( @xmath460 ) . if @xmath70 is a small deterministic form for @xmath2 respecting a vtree @xmath22 , then small deterministic structured forms for each @xmath471 , _ all _ respecting the vtree @xmath22 , can be mined from @xmath70 by suitably assigning its inputs . but this is impossible for communication complexity reasons ( lemma [ lemma : main - inversion ] ) . [ lemma : main - inversion ] for every vtree @xmath22 for @xmath472 and every family @xmath473 of deterministic structured nnfs , where @xmath469 is structured by @xmath22 and computes @xmath471 ( @xmath460 ) , there exists @xmath468 such that @xmath469 has size @xmath462 . we let @xmath232 denote the variables in @xmath474 , @xmath475 denote the variables in @xmath476 , and @xmath477 denote the variables in @xmath478 . [ cl : find - node ] there exists @xmath98 such that @xmath479 . let @xmath480 , for all @xmath98 . let @xmath481 be a root - leaf path in @xmath22 such that , letting @xmath482 , @xmath483 for all @xmath484 . let @xmath188 $ ] be minimum such that @xmath485 so that @xmath486 by construction , @xmath487 hence , letting @xmath488 , we have @xmath489 and we are done . by claim [ cl : find - node ] , let @xmath98 be such that @xmath479 . let @xmath490 and @xmath491 . assume without loss of generality that @xmath492 ; otherwise the argument is similar . it follows by the choice of @xmath91 that @xmath493 and that @xmath494 we enter a case distinction . the first case is covered by the following claim . [ cl : h0-hard ] if there exists @xmath495 $ ] such that for all @xmath496 $ ] it holds that @xmath497 implies @xmath498 , then @xmath499 has size @xmath500 . for @xmath495 $ ] , let @xmath501 . by hypothesis , there exists @xmath495 $ ] such that @xmath502 . write @xmath503 then @xmath504 is a deterministic nnf structured by @xmath22 of size @xmath505 @xcite . it follows from theorem [ th : struct ] that @xmath506 has a disjoint rectangle cover of size at most @xmath507 where each rectangle has underlying partition @xmath508 . by the choice of @xmath91 , it holds that @xmath232 contains @xmath509 variables in @xmath23 . for the sake of notation , say that @xmath510 , so that @xmath511 . then , since @xmath512 , we have that @xmath513 note that @xmath514 is the complement of the disjointness function @xmath515 in ( [ eq : df ] ) . therefore the complement of the communication matrix of @xmath506 relative to @xmath508 is equal ( up to a permutation of rows and columns ) to the communication matrix of @xmath516 , i.e. , @xmath517 where @xmath65 denotes the @xmath518 all-@xmath65 matrix . therefore , by ( [ eq : rkdf ] ) and basic linear algebra , @xmath519 hence @xmath520 therefore , by theorem [ th : rklb ] and ( [ eq : lb - compl - df ] ) , every disjoint rectangle cover of @xmath506 into rectangles with underlying partition @xmath508 contains at least @xmath521 rectangles . summarizing , @xmath506 has a disjoint rectangle cover of size at most @xmath507 where each rectangle has underlying partition @xmath508 , but every such rectangle cover contains at least @xmath521 rectangles . hence @xmath522 and we are done ( recall ( [ eq : nx - lb ] ) ) . the second ( and complementary ) case is covered by the following claim . [ cl : hkp - hard ] if for all @xmath495 $ ] there exists @xmath496 $ ] such that @xmath497 and @xmath523 , then there exists @xmath524 $ ] such that @xmath525 has size @xmath462 . define a set @xmath135 of pairs @xmath526 as follows . for each @xmath495 $ ] such that @xmath527 , choose @xmath496 $ ] such that @xmath523 , and add @xmath526 to @xmath135 . note that @xmath528 , let @xmath529 be such that @xmath530 iff @xmath531 and @xmath532 . also , let @xmath533 note that @xmath534 form a partition of @xmath135 , so that @xmath535 which implies that there exists @xmath524 $ ] such that @xmath536 , and we are done . let @xmath537 $ ] . for all @xmath530 , it holds that @xmath538 and @xmath532 . let @xmath539 and @xmath540 . write @xmath541 and let @xmath542 so that @xmath543 is a deterministic nnf structured by @xmath22 of size @xmath544 @xcite . it follows from theorem [ th : struct ] that @xmath543 has a disjoint rectangle cover of size at most @xmath545 where each rectangle has underlying partition @xmath546 . since @xmath547 , we have that @xmath548 and along the lines of claim [ cl : h0-hard ] we obtain @xmath549 and we are done . the third inequality holds by plugging the convex function @xmath550 in jensen s inequality @xmath551 . claim [ cl : h0-hard ] and claim [ cl : hkp - hard ] imply the statement . we have related the circuit treewidth of a boolean function with the width of its sdd implementation ( and more generally its width in natural canonical classes of deterministic structured forms ) , and we have incorporated constant width sdds and polynomial size sdds in the panorama of query compilation for union of conjunctive queries with and without negations . the comparison of theorem [ th : main - ineq ] and ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.6 ) reiterates the question about the relative succinctness of deterministic structured forms and sdds @xcite . as beame and liew observe , a natural candidate function for an exponential separation is the _ indirect access storage _ ( _ isa _ ) function , which is known to have large obdds but whose small deterministic structured forms deviate substantially from the sdd syntax ( * ? ? ? * section 6 ) . however , as we prove in appendix [ app : isaproof ] , isa has small sdd size , which unfortunately leaves us with no candidates for a separation . the canonical structured deterministic forms induced by factorized implicants , introduced in section [ sect : fimpldec ] , deserve in our opinion both a direct investigation in the framework of the knowledge compilation map @xcite , and a thorough comparison with the data structures used in _ factorized databases _ , which are more than just reminiscent of structured deterministic forms @xcite . the question remains whether bounded circuit treewidth lineages imply bounded obdd width for ucqs with inequalities , as conjectured by jha and suciu @xcite . another intriguing conjecture is that sdds with or gates of bounded fanin are quasipolynomially simulated by obdds . the containment of bounded width sdds in polynomial size obdds , discussed in the introduction and obtained in section [ sect : part1 ] , imply a polynomial simulation of bounded width sdds , which have indeed bounded fanin ors , by obdds . this research was supported by the fwf austrian science fund ( parameterized compilation , p26200 ) . 10 a. amarilli , p. bourhis , and p. senellart . provenance circuits for trees and treelike instances . in _ proc . of icalp 2015 _ , pages 5668 . springer , 2015 . a. amarilli , p. bourhis , and p. senellart . tractable lineages on treelike instances : limits and extensions . in _ proc . of pods 2016 _ , pages 355370 . acm , 2016 . p. beame and v. liew . new limits for knowledge compilation and applications to exact model counting . in _ proc . of uai 2015 _ , pages 131140 . auai press , 2015 . s. bova . sdds are exponentially more succinct than obdds . in _ proc . of aaai 2016 _ , pages 929935 . aaai , 2016 . s. bova , f. capelli , s. mengel , and f. slivovsky . on compiling cnfs into structured deterministic dnnfs . in _ proc . of sat 2015 _ , pages 199214 . springer , 2015 . s. bova , f. capelli , s. mengel , and f. slivovsky . knowledge compilation meets communication complexity . in _ proc . of ijcai 2016 _ , pages 10081014 . ijcai / aaai , 2016 . r. e. bryant . graph - based algorithms for boolean function manipulation . , 35(8):677691 , 1986 . a. choi and a. darwiche . dynamic minimization of sentential decision diagrams . in _ proc . of aaai 2013_. aaai , 2013 . n. n. dalvi and d. suciu . the dichotomy of conjunctive queries on probabilistic structures . in _ proc . of pods 2007 _ , pages 293302 . acm , 2007 . n. n. dalvi and d. suciu . efficient query evaluation on probabilistic databases . , 16(4):523544 , 2007 . a. darwiche . decomposable negation normal form . , 48(4):608647 , 2001 . a. darwiche . on the tractable counting of theory models and its application to truth maintenance and belief revision . , 11(1 - 2):1134 , 2001 . a. darwiche . new canonical representation of propositional knowledge bases . in _ proc . of ijcai 2011 _ , pages 819826 . ijcai / aaai , 2011 . a. darwiche and p. marquis . a knowledge compilation map . , 17:229264 , 2002 . g. v. den broeck and a. darwiche . on the role of canonicity in knowledge compilation . in _ proc . of aaai 2015 _ , pages 16411648 . aaai , 2015 . j. flum and m. grohe . . springer , 2010 . e. grdel , y. gurevich , and c. hirsch . the complexity of query reliability . in _ proc . of pods 1998 _ , pages 227234 . acm , 1998 . t. j. green , g. karvounarakis , and v. tannen . provenance semirings . in _ proc . of pods 2007 _ , pages 3140 . acm , 2007 . a. k. jha and d. suciu . knowledge compilation meets database theory : compiling queries to decision diagrams . in _ proc . of icdt 2011 _ , pages 162173 acm , 2011 . a. k. jha and d. suciu . on the tractability of query compilation and bounded treewidth . in _ proc . of icdt 2012 _ , pages 249261 . acm , 2012 . a. k. jha and d. suciu . knowledge compilation meets database theory : compiling queries to decision diagrams . , 52(3):403440 , 2013 . s. jukna . . springer , 2012 . t. kloks . . springer , 1994 . s. mengel . parameterized compilation lower bounds for restricted cnf - formulas . in _ proc . of sat 2016 _ , pages 312 . springer , 2016 . d. olteanu . factorized databases : a knowledge compilation perspective . , 2016 . u. oztok and a. darwiche . a top - down compiler for sentential decision diagrams . in _ proc . of ijcai 2015 _ , pages 31413148 . aaai , 2015 . k. pipatsrisawat and a. darwiche . new compilation languages based on structured decomposability . in _ proc . of aaai 2008 _ , pages 517522 . aaai , 2008 . t. pipatsrisawat and a. darwiche . a lower bound on the size of decomposable negation normal form . in _ proc . of aaai 2010_. aaai , 2010 . i. razgon . on obdds for cnfs of bounded treewidth . in _ proc . of kr 2014_. aaai , 2014 i. razgon . on the read - once property of branching programs and cnfs of bounded treewidth . , 75(2):277294 , 2016 . i. razgon and j. petke . cliquewidth and knowledge compilation . in _ proc . of sat 2013 _ , pages 335350 . springer , 2013 . d. seese . the structure of models of decidable monadic theories of graphs . , 53(2):169195 , 1991 . d. suciu , d. olteanu , r. christopher , and c. koch . . morgan & claypool publishers , 2011 . i. wegener . . siam , 2000 . let @xmath5 and @xmath12 be positive integers such that @xmath552 . the _ indirect access storage _ ( in short , _ isa _ ) function on @xmath553 variables @xmath554 also displayed as @xmath555 accepts input @xmath556 also displayed as @xmath557 iff , letting @xmath558 be the number whose binary representation is @xmath559 and @xmath560 be the number whose binary representation is @xmath561 , it holds that @xmath562 . let @xmath565 be the vtree for variables @xmath566 formed by a right - linear subtree @xmath567 whose left leaves correspond to the variables in @xmath568 and whose ( unique ) right leaf @xmath91 is the root of a left - linear subtree @xmath569 whose ( unique ) left leaf corresponds to @xmath570 and whose right leaves correspond ( in a postorder traversal ) to @xmath571 . for instance , the vtree @xmath572 is depicted in figure [ fig : isaproof ] . we liberally identify the leaves of @xmath573 with their labels ( so that we simply call @xmath119 the leaf of @xmath573 labelled by the variable @xmath119 ) . for @xmath452 $ ] , we let @xmath574 denote the node in @xmath573 whose left child is @xmath575 ; for @xmath576 $ ] , we let @xmath577 denote the node in @xmath573 whose right child is @xmath578 . a term on @xmath579 is a conjunction of literals on @xmath579 . and a term containing both literals of a variable is denoted by @xmath67 . ] we call a term on @xmath579 _ small _ if it contains at most @xmath580 distinct variables . note that the number of small terms on @xmath579 is @xmath581 since @xmath582 . we now construct an sdd @xmath70 computing @xmath563 and respecting @xmath573 , where each @xmath63-gate structured by a node of the form @xmath577 ( @xmath576 $ ] ) conjoins one small term on @xmath579 and an input gate ( namely , a literal on @xmath577 or a constant ) . as @xmath70 has at most @xmath583 input gates , it follows that the number of @xmath63-gates in @xmath70 structured by nodes of the form @xmath584 ( @xmath576 $ ] ) is @xmath585 moreover , @xmath70 is such that the number of @xmath63-gates structured by nodes of the form @xmath574 ( @xmath452 $ ] ) is @xmath586 since @xmath587 . it follows immediately that @xmath70 has size polynomial in @xmath4 . indeed , as each @xmath63-gate in @xmath70 contributes a constant number of @xmath64-gates , @xmath70 contains at most @xmath564 internal gates . also , @xmath70 has at most @xmath583 input gates . hence @xmath588 the upper part of @xmath70 is isomorphic to an obdd respecting the order @xmath589 and having @xmath590 source gates . each such source , say @xmath591 , corresponds to the boolean assignment @xmath592 , @xmath452 $ ] , of the variables in @xmath568 and implements the cofactor @xmath593 as an sdd respecting the vtree @xmath569 , as follows . we start observing that each cofactor in ( [ eq : isacof ] ) is expressible as a sentential decision , respecting the root node of @xmath569 and involving only small terms on @xmath579 ( and literals on @xmath594 ) . case @xmath598 : in this case , we have to implement @xmath599 , which is equivalent to @xmath600 here @xmath601 corresponds to the term @xmath602 where @xmath603 represents @xmath560 in binary , and @xmath604 , @xmath605 , @xmath606 $ ] . for all @xmath607 and @xmath608 $ ] we say that _ orbits on @xmath304 _ if @xmath610 represents @xmath611 in binary . if @xmath609 orbits on @xmath304 , we let @xmath609 orbits on @xmath304 denote the term @xmath612 by direct inspection , @xmath599 is equivalent to a sentential decision @xmath613 as in ( [ eq : sdd - def ] ) , namely , @xmath614 where @xmath615 ranges over all pairs such that @xmath609 orbits on @xmath304 . here , the interesting @xmath63-gates ( marked with @xmath616 ) are structured by the node @xmath617 in @xmath573 . moreover , the @xmath109 s are small terms as they contain @xmath618 variables by construction . [ ex : hec ] assume @xmath619 , so that we compute @xmath620 . in this case @xmath621 and @xmath622 . the following lists the disjuncts corresponding to @xmath623 for @xmath624 ( we use @xmath625 and @xmath626 as shortenings ) : @xmath627 if @xmath615 gives @xmath628 , then the corresponding subdisjunction reduces to one disjunct only ; and , if @xmath615 gives @xmath629 , then the corresponding subdisjunction reduces to two disjuncts only , as the following example illustrates . case @xmath634 : say that @xmath635 represents @xmath636 . we implement @xmath637 , which is equivalent to @xmath638 where the notation is as in the previous case ; note that @xmath639 . an equivalent sentential decision of the form ( [ eq : sdd - def ] ) is obtained by disjoining @xmath640 and the following : @xmath641 where the interesting @xmath63-gates ( marked with @xmath616 ) are structured by the node @xmath617 in @xmath573 . moreover , the @xmath109 s are small terms as they contain @xmath580 variables by construction . the construction implements each gate @xmath591 by the sentential decision given by claim [ cl : base ] . we now claim that the construction can continue recursively by implementing the resulting @xmath109 s as sdds respecting subtrees of the subtree of @xmath573 rooted at @xmath648 . [ cl : isarec ] let @xmath649 be a small term on @xmath579 . then @xmath649 is equivalent to a sentential decision @xmath596 of the form ( [ eq : sdd - def ] ) , where the @xmath63-gates are structured by some @xmath650 ( @xmath576 $ ] ) and the @xmath109 s are small terms . let @xmath609 be the assignment of @xmath657 to @xmath658 such that @xmath659 by direct inspection , @xmath649 is equivalent to the sentential decision @xmath613 of the form ( [ eq : sdd - def ] ) @xmath660 where @xmath197 ranges over the assignments of @xmath657 in @xmath658 distinct from @xmath609 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: blind surveys for optical transients have revealed a class of super - luminous supernovae ( sl ) sne that may in some cases be powered by a collision between the sn ejecta and a massive shell or wind of circumstellar material ( csm ) ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? examples include sn 2003ma @xcite , 2006gy ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and 2008es @xcite , among others . as a consequence of the collision with the csm , a significant fraction of the kinetic energy is converted into radiation via shock dissipation , which is responsible for the observed emission ( see figure 1 ) . the rate of slsne with absolute magnitude @xmath1 is order of @xmath2 , @xmath3% of the normal core - collapse sn rate @xcite , but some normal - luminosity sne such as sn 2005ip @xcite , 2006jc @xcite , 2008iy @xcite and ptf 09uj @xcite , which may also be powered by ejecta - csm interactions , are more common @xcite . finally , recent observations of sn 2009ip and 2010mc suggest that the csm eruption is timed to occur months - to - years before the core collapse @xcite . interaction - powered sne may be efficient cosmic - ray ( cr ) accelerators , where one can expect that the diffusive shock acceleration mechanism operates at the forward and reverse shocks by a collision between the sn ejecta and csm . for a range of csm parameters ( mass and shock dissipation radius ) , the shock is radiation - mediated the thomson optical depth is larger than @xmath4 @xcite , where @xmath5 is the shock velocity and efficient cr acceleration is not expected because the cr collisionless mean free path is much shorter than the deceleration length . however , as the shock propagates in the csm , photons can stream out ahead of the shock , and photon energy can no longer support the shock ( i.e. , shock breakout ) . after the breakout , for wind - like csm profiles , the shock will become collisonless and cr acceleration can be efficient @xcite . recently , murase et al . ( 2011 ) considered a collision between the sn ejecta with a csm shell and found that cr protons may be accelerated , and furthermore that the protons may experience strong pionic losses via inelastic @xmath0 collisions , producing gamma - rays and neutrinos . thus , interaction - powered sne may be interesting cr accelerators and high - energy / multi - messenger emitters . in this work , we continue our study of the possibility of the non - thermal emission from the shock interaction of a sn embedded in a dense csm . in particular , we focus on the secondary electrons and positrons expected from the same @xmath0 collisions that give rise to neutrinos and gamma rays . importantly , we show that these secondaries can emit detectable synchrotron radiation at high - frequency radio wavelengths including mm / submm and fir bands . in section 2 , we review the shock physics and the potential for cr acceleration in interaction - powered sne , providing a much more detailed discussion than murase et al . section 3 gives a brief discussion of the high - energy emission expected , and recipes that connect the observed optical emission to the non - thermal signatures are provided in appendix a. in section 4 we discuss high - frequency radio diagnostics . for a range of csm parameters , we show that secondary leptons from @xmath0 interactions should radiate synchrotron at @xmath6 , and with fluxes of @xmath7 mjy at distances of hundreds of mpc . in section 5 , we summarize our results . throughout this work , we use the notation @xmath8 in cgs unit unless we give notice . in this preparatory section , before we discuss non - thermal signatures , we explain the picture of interaction - powered sne and describe the basic physical setup . let us consider sn ejecta with the kinetic energy @xmath9 and the velocity @xmath10 . noting @xmath11 for the ejecta mass @xmath12 , the momentum and energy conservation laws give @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the total csm mass and @xmath15 is the csm velocity . the total dissipated energy @xmath16 is written as @xmath17 where @xmath18 is used in the last equality . the above equation suggests that a significant fraction of @xmath9 can be dissipated if the csm mass is large ( see also , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? density profiles of both the ejecta and csm are important for detailed predictions . for example , when the density profile of the ejecta is steep enough and most of its energy is carried by lower - velocity ejecta material , the explosion has driven waves that can be described by chevalier - nadezhin self - similar solutions @xcite . when the shock wave sweeps up ambient mass comparable to @xmath12 and it is non - radiative , we expect blast waves that can be described by sedov - taylor - like self - similar solutions ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . in this work , to push the basic idea and avoid uncertainty in the ejecta profile and many other complications due to radiation processes , we discuss non - thermal properties without relying on such details . our treatment still provides an order of magnitude estimate of expected non - thermal signals , and a more detailed study will be presented in an accompanying paper @xcite . hereafter , we assume that the csm has a wind - like power - law density profile and extends to the edge radius of the wind , @xmath19 . we expect that this is reasonable ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , although details are uncertain due to poor understandings of the csm eruption mechanism . then , the csm density is written as @xmath20 where @xmath21 should be expressed in cm , @xmath22 cm , and @xmath23 is defined that is different from ours . ] for the mass - loss rate of @xmath24 and the wind velocity of @xmath25 . this can also be expressed by @xmath26 the csm mass within @xmath21 is estimated to be @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the csm inner edge radius . in particular , in the wind case ( @xmath29 ) , we have @xmath30 where we have used @xmath31 and @xmath32 . note that , in the one - zone model where the calculation is performed for a csm density @xmath33 at a given radius @xmath21 , qualitative pictures for different density profiles are simply obtained by using @xmath14 instead of @xmath34 ( although the dynamics and temporal evolution depend on density profiles ) . the deceleration is significant after the ejecta accumulates the csm mass equivalent to its own mass , whose radius is characterized by @xmath35 if @xmath36 , most of the ejecta energy is dissipated by the ejecta - csm collision . one of the important quantities is the thomson optical depth . using the csm electron density , @xmath37 the thomson optical depth is estimated to be @xmath38 for @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the thomson cross section . the thomson optical depth in the downstream is also @xmath41 although the density in the thin , interacting shell is compressed by the shock compression ratio . as seen below , the emission is mostly observed when @xmath42 after photons can leave the system . however , while the interaction with a dense csm shell happens at @xmath43 , hard x rays and soft gamma rays produced at the shock can not avoid compton down - scattering and a significant fraction of the emission would be thermalized @xcite . equal lines of various optical depths , csm density and luminosities in the ( @xmath21 , @xmath44 ) plane and ( @xmath21 , @xmath14 ) plane are shown in figures 2 and 3 , respectively . the equal csm density line , @xmath45 , is also overlaid . explanations for the optical depths other than the thomson optical depth are given below . as argued by murase et al . ( 2011 ) , efficient cr acceleration is possible at @xmath42 , and for @xmath46 we expect almost all the accelerated cr ions to produce neutrinos , hadronic gamma rays , and secondary electrons and positrons . in the system , hadronic gamma rays can interact with photons via the two - photon annihilation process and/or matter via the bethe - heitler ( bh ) pair - production process , respectively ( see section 3 ) . the attenuation of gev gamma rays due to the bh process is insignificant at @xmath47 , which is not far from @xmath48 . in this work , we consider the forward shock , so the shock velocity @xmath5 is regarded as the forward shock velocity @xmath49 . the reverse shock power is smaller when the ejecta profile is steep ( e.g. , * ? ? ? but this might not be the case if the profile is changed , e.g. , possibly by experiencing many interactions with many csm shells . , @xmath44 ) plane . see the text for meanings of @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 . the shaded region suggests the range where we do not expect either production or escape of gamma rays . the thick curves represent @xmath54 while the thin curves do @xmath55 . with quadruplicate - dotted cures , lines of the constant csm density ( @xmath33=const . ) , constant post - breakout radiation luminosity ( @xmath56=const . ) , constant optically - thin free - free luminosity ( @xmath57=const . ) , and constant csm mass ( @xmath14=const . ) are also shown for comparison . ] , @xmath14 ) plane , where @xmath14 has the solar - mass unit . lines of the constant csm density ( @xmath33=const . ) , constant post - breakout radiation luminosity ( @xmath56=const . ) , and constant optically - thin free - free luminosity ( @xmath57=const . ) are also shown for comparison . for explanations of specific sn examples , see sub - section 2.6 . ] when a collision with csm occurs at @xmath58 , photons should experience many compton scatterings , and it takes time for them to leave the system . the photon diffusion time is roughly @xmath59 , which can further be approximated to be @xmath60 for the wind profile if @xmath61 ( c.f . * ; * ? ? ? photons can not essentially diffuse out from the system , when @xmath62 is longer than the dynamical timescale is @xmath63 . hence , when the collision begins at @xmath64 , we start to observe a significant fraction of the emissions in the rise time @xmath65 such that @xmath66 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? we define the breakout radius @xmath67 , where photons can essentially leave the system . when the effective diffusion radius @xmath68 is sufficiently smaller than @xmath19 ( for @xmath69 ) , we have @xmath70 , and the shock breakout radius can be written as @xmath71 . when the csm is so dense that @xmath68 is larger than @xmath19 , the rise time can be smaller than @xmath72 because @xmath73 at the breakout @xcite . we expect that thermal radiation carries a significant fraction ( @xmath74 ) of the energy carried by the interacting shell ( @xmath75 ) , where the radiated energy , @xmath76 is obtained in the mini - shell model @xcite . see also ofek et al . ( 2014 ) . ] is @xmath77 and @xmath75 after the collision is roughly comparable to @xmath16 ( see equation 3 ) . noting @xmath78 , the ( bolometric ) radiation luminosity just after the breakout is @xmath79 the constant radiation luminosity line , @xmath80 ( with @xmath81 ) , is depicted in figures 2 and 3 . a more sophisticated model is given by chevalier & irwin ( 2011 ) , which is summarized in appendix a and @xmath82 @xcite ] . the collision between the sn ejecta and the csm may start from the optically - thick regime . then , after the shock breakout , the interaction eventually enters the optically - thin regime . this regime typically comes after the time of @xmath83 when @xmath19 is large enough . hence , for optically slsne such as sn 2006gy , it usually happens only after the shock crosses @xmath84 . in order to expect optically - thin ejecta - csm interactions within @xmath19 , relatively large @xmath85 and/or low @xmath14 are needed . alternately , the collision may occur at @xmath42 if csm effectively has an inner edge and can be regarded as a shell . especially for optically - thin interactions at @xmath86 , hard x rays easily leave the system although ultraviolet photons and soft x rays may be attenuated due to bound - free absorption . indeed , such x - ray and radio emissions have been observed in some sne like sn 1988z @xcite and 2006jd @xcite . let us consider a csm extending to @xmath19 . for @xmath87 , the characteristic duration of emission is expected to be @xmath88 ( or @xmath89 ) . when the dominant loss process for thermal electrons is the free - free emission , the ( bolometric ) radiation luminosity mainly comes from bremsstrahlung emission . in the non - radiative case , we have @xcite @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the gaunt factor , @xmath92 for hydrogen is used , and absorption is not considered yet . here the compression factor @xmath93 is taken to be 4 but can be larger . the constant radiation luminosity line , @xmath94 , is depicted in figures 2 and 3 . when the shock is radiative , @xmath95 should be limited by the kinetic luminosity as in equation ( 11 ) . it roughly occurs when the cooling time @xmath96 is shorter than time @xmath97 . note that @xmath57 is proportional to @xmath98 and @xmath99 k is assumed , otherwise cooling by line emissions becomes relevant ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . whether efficient cr acceleration occurs or not depends on the shock properties . when an ejecta - csm collision occurs at sufficiently small radii , the shock is initially radiation - mediated in the sense that the upstream shock structure is modified by radiation from the downstream . for non - relativistic shocks where effects of pairs are irrelevant , the shock is radiation - mediated when @xmath64 @xcite . when coupling with radiation is strong enough , electrons transfer their energy to photons . in the thermal equilibrium limit , at the far downstream , photons , electrons and protons have the temperature of @xmath100 where @xmath101 is used and @xmath102 is the gray - body factor . note that this emission does not have to be the observed emission since photons start to escape only after @xmath103 . thermal equilibrium may not be realized if sufficient photons are not produced by the bremsstrahlung process @xcite . at the nearer downstream , protons and electrons have much higher temperatures . in the absence of collisionless - plasma processes , the electron temperature is determined by the balance between coulomb heating and cooling processes . when the relevant cooling process is the compton cooling , we have @xcite @xmath104 over the length scale of @xmath105 ( where @xmath106 is the ion - electron collision frequency ) , where is defined for the downstream energy density . on the other hand , as in murase et al . ( 2011 ) , @xmath107 is defined for the total energy while @xmath108 is defined for the ram pressure of the upstream flow . ] @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the energy density of photons . note that the above equation is valid for sufficiently high - velocity shocks , since @xmath111 is limited by the proton temperature @xmath112 @xcite . in reality , collisionless - plasma processes can be faster than coulomb collisional processes , where @xmath111 can be higher than in equation ( 14 ) , but should be lower than the equipartition temperature . after @xmath42 , the shock is no longer radiation - mediated , and we expect collisionless ( or collisional ) shocks . for strong , non - relativistic shocks , the proton temperature at the immediate downstream is @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the adiabatic index . when the adiabatic index is @xmath115 , we have a well - known result , @xmath116 . the electron temperature is affected by energy transfer from protons , which may be coulomb heating or faster collisionless plasma processes . if @xmath115 and when electrons and protons achieve the equipartition , we have ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) @xmath117 therefore , in the interaction - powered sn scenario , we can naturally expect x rays via bremsstrahlung or inverse - compton ( ic ) processes since electrons should be heated by the shock ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? also , we may assume the material is highly ionized at least in the immediate upstream . detections of x rays allow us to probe the existence of strong shocks , supporting the scenario @xcite . however , there are several complications . first , free - free emission may be suppressed if thermal electrons mainly cool via the ic process . secondly , when the ejecta - csm interaction occurs at @xmath118 , hard x rays lose their energies in both the emission zone ( downstream ) and screen zone ( upstream ) , and softer x rays are down - graded via bound - free absorption . if the amount of non - ionized atoms similarly exists in the far upstream , the bound - free optical depth for soft x rays is roughly estimated to be ( e.g. , * ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) @xmath119 at @xmath120 kev . naively , the x - ray luminosity is then ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the suppression by other losses , @xmath123 is the optical depth in the emission zone and @xmath124 is the optical depth in the screen zone . predictions for both the thermal and non - thermal x rays depend on details including the frequency - dependent opacity and the ionization in the upstream ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . this work does not study x - ray emissions in detail , since non - thermal x rays can be largely contaminated or masked by thermal x rays . now , we consider particle acceleration . cr acceleration may become efficient when the shock is no longer radiation - mediated and becomes collisionless , which can be realized when @xmath42 @xcite . strong small - scale magnetic fields are expected as a result from plasma instabilities , and mhd mechanisms such as the turbulent dynamo can also play crucial roles especially in the downstream ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? in addition , crs themselves excite turbulence via cr stream instabilities , which can be important in the upstream ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . since details of these processes are uncertain , for simplicity , we parameterize the magnetic field with the ratio of @xmath125 to @xmath126 as @xmath127 . then , we obtain @xmath128 in the bohm limit , the proton acceleration time scale is estimated to be ( see a review * ? ? ? * ) @xmath129 and the proton maximum energy is estimated by comparing it to various cooling time scales ( see below ) . in the fully - ionized plasma ( that is the case in the vicinity of the shock ) , the coulomb cooling time of thermal protons @xcite , @xmath130 where @xmath131 is assumed but the velocity of injected protons may be higher , depending on details of injection processes . the ratio between the two is @xmath132 when the upstream is cold enough . hence , the coulomb energy loss timescale is longer than their acceleration time , so cr proton acceleration is possible . note that the coulomb cooling is much less relevant in the immediate downstream , where the temperature is much higher . as protons are accelerated above the pion production threshold , @xmath133 , inelastic @xmath0 interactions occur , leading to production of electrons and positrons via @xmath134 . their minimum injection lorentz factor is @xcite @xmath135 the important point here is that the minimum injection lorentz factor is unique for hadronic injections , which is different from the case of primary electron acceleration . primary electrons can also be shock accelerated via the fermi acceleration mechanism . however , the larmor radius of thermal electrons is smaller than that of thermal protons . thus , electrons need to be energized via some plasma processes to cross the shock length and to get injected to the fermi acceleration process . in other words , the larmor radius of relativistic electrons , @xmath136 , should be larger than that of thermal protons , @xmath137 . the lorentz factor of elections that can be accelerated by the conventional shock acceleration mechanism satisfies @xmath138 keeping this in mind and introducing the energy fraction ( @xmath139 ) and number fraction ( @xmath140 ) of relativistic electrons distributed with a power law , the injection lorentz factor of primary shock - accelerated electrons ( @xmath141 ) is expressed as @xmath142 where @xmath143 for @xmath144 and @xmath145 for @xmath146 . here , @xmath147 is the injection spectral index of accelerated electrons and @xmath148 is the maximum lorentz factor of accelerated electrons . note that equation ( 24 ) is obtained from @xmath149 and @xmath150 . the values of @xmath139 and @xmath140 are uncertain . the cr spectra observed at the earth imply @xmath151 , and such values are inferred from modeling of radio emission from type iib sne ( e.g. , * ? ? ? smaller values of @xmath152 are obtained in the leptonic scenario for young sn remnants ( e.g. , * ? ? ? sufficiently large values of @xmath140 imply @xmath153 , where other electron acceleration processes in the shock transition layer should be relevant , and the spectrum for @xmath154 may be steeper than that for @xmath155 . the energy carried by accelerated crs can be summarized as follows . the cr acceleration is efficient only after the radiation escapes from the system and the strong shock jump is formed by collisionless shocks . hence , if @xmath156<r_{\rm bo}$ ] , we do not expect many crs . normal sne correspond to @xmath157 , so only a fraction of the sn explosion energy @xmath9 is converted to crs at the time the shock reaches @xmath19 . if the csm is massive and @xmath158 ( thus @xmath159 ) , we expect @xmath160 , so a significant fraction of the sn explosion energy can be converted into the energy of crs . the energy of accelerated cr protons in interaction - powered sne ( @xmath161 ) is roughly estimated to be @xmath162<r_{\rm bo}$ ) } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] here equation ( 3 ) is used . note that , for @xmath163 ( i.e. , @xmath164 ) , only the fraction of the sn explosion energy can be dissipated by one collision . also , @xmath165 is the energy fraction carried by crs above @xmath166 , and @xmath167 is typically used in the context of sn remnants . when particles are accelerated up to very high energies , high - energy gamma rays and neutrinos should be accompanied via hadronuclear interactions like the @xmath0 reaction . in particular , cr protons interact with nucleons while they are advected to the downstream , so neutrinos and pionic gamma rays are expected in the gev - pev range @xcite . by comparing the @xmath0 interaction time scale @xmath168 and @xmath169 , we get the @xmath0 optical depth as @xmath170 where @xmath171 is used . from figures 2 and 3 , one sees large parameter space satisfying @xmath42 and @xmath46 , where neutrinos and gamma rays provide promising signals of cr proton acceleration at collisionless shocks . even if @xmath172 , we can say that a significant fraction of the cr energy is converted into hadronic emission via @xmath0 interactions . from equation ( 26 ) , one sees @xmath173 or @xmath174 . thus , as seen from figure 3 , @xmath0 processes are typically efficient for ejecta - csm interactions at radii of @xmath175 cm , for @xmath176 . note that @xmath0 interactions are relevant even in the optically - thin regime of @xmath86 . we here discuss several examples of sne to see if ejecta - csm interactions satisfying @xmath42 and @xmath177 are indeed indicated by recent observations . first , we consider the optically - thick regime around the shock breakout . observationally , the csm nucleon density @xmath33 ( or @xmath34 ) can be estimated from the radiation luminosity @xmath95 ( or the radiated energy @xmath178 ) at the time of the shock breakout , the rise time @xmath65 , and the shock velocity @xmath5 ( or @xmath67 that is the radius at the shock breakout ) . note that the approximation @xmath61 is valid when @xmath179 . 1 . sn 2006gy : sn 2006gy is one of the slsne ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the radiated energy is @xmath180 and the breakout time is @xmath181 d @xcite . the breakout radius is estimated to be @xmath182 cm , corresponding to @xmath183 . these observational parameters imply @xmath184 ( see appendix a ) , leading to @xmath185 and @xmath186 within @xmath67 . these are roughly consistent with numerical modeling of optical light curves @xcite . 2 . sn 2009ip : sn 2009ip is one of the luminous type iin sne , which showed re - brightening in 2012 . the radiated energy is @xmath187 and the rising time given here , are regarded as an upper limit . ] is @xmath188 d. the breakout radius is estimated to be @xmath189 cm , corresponding to @xmath190 . these observational parameters imply @xmath191 , @xmath192 and @xmath193 within @xmath67 @xcite , which are consistent with observational constraints @xcite . in figure 3 , both of the examples roughly lie on the @xmath50 lines . the condition @xmath194 is satisfied , so neutrinos and gamma rays should be produced in the presence of cr protons . sn 2006gy almost lies on the constant luminosity line of @xmath195 . note that @xmath160 can be expected for sn 2006gy but not for sn 2009ip . next , we consider post - breakout emission in the later phase . for @xmath42 , the shock crossing time @xmath196 or the deceleration time @xmath197 can also be used instead of @xmath65 . then , one can observationally estimate @xmath33 ( or @xmath34 ) from @xmath95 , @xmath198 ( or @xmath199 ) , and @xmath5 . alternatively , if we assume that the csm is not completely ionized , then the x - ray measurements of the bound - free absorption can provide an estimate ( or at least a lower limit ) on @xmath200 . two examples are given below . 1 . sn 2006jd : sn 2006jd was a type iin sn , showing bright x - ray emission with the unabsorbed x - ray luminosity of @xmath201 in the @xmath202 kev range @xcite . radio emission was detected after @xmath203 d. with @xmath54 , we expect @xmath204 at @xmath205 d. then , with the temperature @xmath206 kev , @xmath207 implies @xmath208 and @xmath209 within @xmath21 . this estimated csm density is comparable to @xmath210 obtained with @xmath211 , @xmath212 ( for @xmath22 cm ) , and @xmath213 cm @xcite . on the other hand , x - ray absorption allows us to estimate the column density of non - ionized hydrogen atoms ( @xmath214 ) that may exist in the far upstream . it is also suggested that this density is different from values based on x - ray observations , which may imply that the csm is highly ionized even in the far upstream so there are not many non - ionized atoms in the line of sight of x rays . however , detections of radio emission may imply the absence of too strong free - free absorption in the upstream . 2 . sn 2010jl : sn 2010jl was also a type iin sne , showing bright x - ray emission without radio detections . the unabsorbed x - ray luminosity of @xmath215 is obtained in the @xmath202 kev range @xcite . however , ofek et al . ( 2014 ) suggested a higher intrinsic luminosity and obtained @xmath216 from modeling of the optical emission in the early phase around @xmath217 , which is consistent with a value indicated by x - ray observations . with @xmath218 , we expect @xmath219 at @xmath220 d , implying @xmath221 and @xmath222 at that time . although there is uncertainty , the csm with several solar masses is likely @xcite , and this energetic sn seems one of the promising targets of dedicated searches for neutrinos and gamma rays . based on these parameters , sn 2010jl has @xmath194 , indicating efficient neutrino and gamma - ray production . on the other hand , @xmath223 is suggested for sn 2006jd , but the @xmath0 efficiency is still significant . sn 2006jd also lies on the constant luminosity line of @xmath224 . note that another estimate is possible based on detailed modeling of radio sne ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , although this work does not focus on such more model - dependent studies . most of type iin sne have not been seen by low - frequency radio observations , but we show that some of them may be detectable at high - frequency radio wavelengths including mm / submm and fir bands ( see below ) . in the figure 3 , we indicate the above examples by stars for the purpose of demonstration . note that their parameters have large uncertainty so such plots do not have to be very precise . also , @xmath21 increases as the observation time @xmath97 , so one can ideally draw evolution curves in the ( @xmath21 , @xmath44 ) plane and ( @xmath21 , @xmath14 ) plane . in addition to the four sne , we indicate sn 2006jc and 2008iy , which are also likely to be interaction - powered sne . for sn 2006jc , we use @xmath225 and @xmath226 cm at the x - ray peak time of @xmath227 d based on immler et al . ( 2008 ) . for sn 2008iy , we adopt @xmath228 and @xmath229 cm at the peak time of @xmath230 d from miller at al . ( 2010 ) . sn remnants have been largely believed to be the origin of galactic crs up to the knee of @xmath231 gev ( see a review * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . it would also be interesting to consider interaction - powered sne as potential accelerators of high - energy crs . the maximum energy of accelerated protons , @xmath232 , is determined by comparing @xmath233 to the cooling time @xmath234 and dynamical time @xmath169 . if the time scales of energy losses ( including adiabatic losses ) are long enough , the maximum energy is limited by the dynamical time , @xmath235 then , the maximum energy is @xcite @xmath236 note that the larmor radius ( @xmath237 ) of protons is smaller than the system size ( @xmath21 ) , where the protons are confined . at small @xmath21 and/or large @xmath44 , the maximum energy is limited by energy losses . the @xmath0 cooling time of protons is expressed as @xmath238 where @xmath239 is the proton inelasticity . equating @xmath240 and @xmath241 gives @xcite @xmath242 before crs propagate in a galaxy , they need to escape from the system without significant losses ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? while the ejecta interacts with a csm , cr escape may be limited by the free escape boundary @xmath243 , which could be determined , e.g. , by magnetic field amplification processes or wave damping via ion - neutral collisions @xcite . by comparing the diffusion length @xmath244 ( in the bohm limit ) to @xmath243 , we obtain @xmath245 where @xmath246 is the maximum energy of escaping protons . if @xmath232 is too low for crs to escape within @xmath169 , crs are confined and their escape is non - trivial . if magnetic fields rapidly decay after the shock crossing time ( as often supposed in gamma - ray bursts ) , the condition can be @xmath247 , otherwise it depends on diffusion and adiabatic losses . as a reasonable condition for crs not to be depleted , we here assume @xmath248 and @xmath223 . in figures 4 and 5 , we show the parameter range allowing @xmath249 ev protons . parameter space allowing for higher @xmath246 is narrower . if an ejecta - csm interaction occurs at @xmath46 , crs are largely depleted . we need @xmath250 to expect @xmath251 , and @xmath252 cm is typically favored for escaping crs to avoid significant @xmath0 cooling . higher - energy protons can generate pairs via the bh process , which occurs at @xmath253 , i.e. , @xmath254 . sufficiently high - energy protons may dominantly lose their energies via the bh process , especially in the optically - thick regime . for @xmath118 , the number density of thermalized photons is @xmath255 , where @xmath256 is the luminosity of thermalized ( re - processed ) photons and @xmath257 is their energy fraction . assuming @xmath258 , the bh cooling time @xmath259 becomes @xmath260 where @xmath261 is used at @xmath262 in the proton rest frame @xcite . this is typically longer than the @xmath0 cooling time , so we may mainly consider the @xmath0 reaction . as indicated in figures 4 and 5 , on the other hand , the optically - thin regime of @xmath263 is more likely in cases where protons with @xmath264 gev survive . x - ray photons interact with tev protons and the number density of optically - thin bremsstrahlung photons is @xmath265 , so we have @xmath266 which is negligible compared to @xmath241 . in addition , photomeson production may also occur at @xmath267 . although it seems that the proton energy has to be quite high , some interactions with x - ray photons are possible in the attenuation scale of x rays . finally , we briefly discuss a possible contribution of interaction - powered sne to the observed galactic crs . contributions from various types of sne including `` hypernovae '' erg , which are usually broadline type ibc sne . note that only a fraction of them are trans - relativistic sne that show a mildly relativistic component . ] have been considered ( e.g. , * ? ? ? it is still under debade which astrophysical accelerator is responsible for crs around the knee , although normal sne have been commonly believed as a leading candidate . an issue is how cr protons are accelerated up to the knee , and interaction - powered sne could have some advantages because of higher densities and possible stronger fields . the observed cr energy flux at @xmath268 gev is smaller than that at @xmath269 gev by @xmath270 . the contribution of interaction - powered sne at @xmath271 compared to the contribution of normal sne at @xmath272 is ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) @xmath273 where @xmath274 is the conversion factor from the total energy to the energy spectrum ( see appendix a ) , @xmath275 is the rate of interaction - powered sne , @xmath276 is the sn rate , and @xmath277 is the confinement time of galactic crs . although the confinement time is highly uncertain , if @xmath278 and @xmath279 , interaction - powered sne could contribute to the observed cr flux around the knee if the rate of interaction - powered sne is as high as @xmath280 . ev protons in the ( @xmath21 , @xmath44 ) plane . cr acceleration is possible at @xmath42 and @xmath281 and @xmath282 are required to achieve @xmath283 ev in the acceleration region . the shaded region suggests the range where we do not expect either production or escape of @xmath284 ev protons . ] , @xmath14 ) plane , where @xmath14 has the solar - mass unit . ] by taking into account the inelasticity @xmath239 , we obtain the effective @xmath0 optical depth as @xmath285 which gives the meson production efficiency . using @xmath286 , the neutrino energy fluence ( per flavor ) is estimated to be @xmath287e_p^2\frac{dn_p}{de_p}\nonumber\\ & \simeq&1.4\times{10}^{-4}~{\rm erg}~{\rm cm}^{-2}~{\rm min}[1,f_{pp}]{\left(\frac{e_\nu}{0.05m_pc^2}\right)}^{2-q_p}\nonumber\\ & \times&\epsilon_{p,-1}{\mathcal e}_{51}{(d/10~{\rm mpc})}^{-2}{\mathcal r}_{p0,1}^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath288 is the power - law index of the proton spectrum and @xmath289 is @xmath290 at @xmath166 ( see appendix a ) . when the csm mass is sufficiently large , assuming @xmath291 at the collision , we expect the typical energy fluence of @xmath292 due to @xmath293 . on the other hand , when the csm mass is not large enough , assuming @xmath291 at the collision , the typical energy fluence is expected to be @xmath294 due to @xmath295 . the typical neutrino energy is @xmath296 , so we expect gev - pev neutrino emission given that @xmath232 reaches @xmath297 pev . the icecube effective area for muon neutrinos is order of @xmath298 in the 100 tev range while @xmath299 in the 1 tev range , implying the fluence sensitivity of @xmath300 @xcite . hence , high - energy neutrinos are detectable by icecube for nearby sne that occur at @xmath301 mpc , and stacking analyses for aggregated signals from a number of interaction - powered sne will also be useful @xcite . in appendix a , we provide recipes that connect the observed optical emission to the neutrino signal . the pionic gamma - ray energy fluence is 2 times larger than the neutrino fluence per flavor ( after neutrino mixing ) , so we expect @xmath302e_p^2\frac{dn_p}{de_p}\nonumber\\ & \simeq&2.8\times{10}^{-4}~{\rm erg}~{\rm cm}^{-2}~{\rm min}[1,f_{pp}]{\left(\frac{e_\gamma}{0.1m_pc^2}\right)}^{2-q_p}\nonumber\\ & \times&\epsilon_{p,-1}{\mathcal e}_{51}{(d/10~{\rm mpc})}^{-2}{\mathcal r}_{p0,1}^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] or using @xmath303 , the typical gamma - ray energy flux is @xmath304e_p^2\frac{dn_p}{de_pdt}\nonumber\\ & \sim&1.1\times{10}^{-11}~{\rm erg}~{\rm cm}^{-2}~{\rm s}^{-1}~{\rm min}[1,f_{pp}]\nonumber\\ & \times&{\left(\frac{e_\gamma}{0.1m_pc^2}\right)}^{2-q_p}\epsilon_{p,-1}d_*\nonumber\\ & \times&{(v_s/5000~{\rm km}~{\rm s}^{-1})}^{3}{(d/10~{\rm mpc})}^{-2}{\mathcal r}_{p0,1}^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the _ fermi _ 1 yr sensitivity at gev energies is @xmath305 @xcite , so interaction - powered sne may be detectable with _ fermi _ for powerful explosions at @xmath306 mpc @xcite . stacking analyses are useful for gev gamma rays as well as neutrinos ( see appendix a ) . in addition , future ground cherenkov detectors will be more sensitive . for example , the cta 100 hr sensitivity at tev is @xmath307 @xcite , whereas the hawc 3 yr sensitivity at 2 tev is @xmath305 @xcite . if the cr spectrum is as hard as @xmath308 , we expect that detections are possible up to @xmath309 mpc via followup observations by cta within days - to - years . for extragalactic gamma rays , one has to keep in mind attenuation processes . there are two effects : attenuation by the extragalactic background light ( ebl ) and attenuation by target photons in the source . the attenuation by ebl is relevant above @xmath310 tev @xcite , so we can neglect it to discuss the detestability in the gev - tev range . the attenuation in the source can be relevant especially for emission from the reverse shock , but we show below that gamma rays from the shocked csm can typically escape from the source after the shock breakout , @xmath42 . gamma rays around mev energies are downgraded via compton scattering with electrons in the matter . the bh pair - creation process occurs at @xmath311 and becomes dominant over the compton scattering above the gev range , where the compton scattering is reduced by the klein - nishina suppression . at sufficiently high energies , the approximate cross section of the bh process is @xcite @xmath312.\ ] ] then , the bh opacity for gamma rays is expressed as @xmath313 where @xmath314 is evaluated at @xmath315 . the parameter space such that @xmath316 is shown in figures 2 and 3 . interestingly , it is comparable to the parameter space such that @xmath317 for typical shock velocities , since gamma - ray attenuation due to the bh process is irrelevant when @xmath5 is higher than @xmath318 . note that the bh opacity may be even smaller . several observations have suggested that csm is clumpy rather than uniform . the bh opacity becomes irrelevant when the csm is anisotropic or so clumpy that most of the csm mass is concentrated in dense clumps . for example , if the density enhancement in the clumps is @xmath319 , the bh opacity is changed by @xmath320 , where the attenuation by the bh process becomes even less relevant . gamma rays interact with photons via @xmath321 . the interaction typically happens at @xmath322 , and the @xmath323 opacity for sufficiently high - energy gamma rays is @xmath324 where @xmath325 is the photon number density at @xmath326 . when the collision with csm occurs at @xmath43 , most of the emissions are thermalized . using @xmath327 , we obtain @xmath328 at @xmath329 . above this energy , interactions mainly happen in the klein - nishina regime , so the @xmath330 opacity decreases as @xmath331e_\gamma^{-1}$ ] . hard x rays , which can be produced by bremsstrahlung emission in the downstream , could potentially prohibit lower - energy gamma rays from leaving the emission region because the pair - creation threshold energy is lower for target photons with higher energies . using @xmath322 and @xmath332 , the typical energy of gamma rays interacting with x - ray photons is estimated to be @xmath333 as explained below we expect that gev gamma rays can leave the system without significant attenuation . first , we consider an optically - thin collision at @xmath86 with @xmath334 . the black - body approximation is invalid , and hard x - ray emission becomes largely visible . the number density of optically - thin bremsstrahlung photons is @xmath265 , so we obtain @xmath335 so gamma rays will be able to leave the emission region for ejecta - csm interactions at @xmath86 . the radiation luminosity may be limited by the kinetic luminosity , and interactions with x rays can be relevant in the length scale of @xmath336 even in the optically - thick regime of @xmath337 . then , we may roughly expect @xmath338 and @xmath339 at @xmath67 . therefore , given @xmath74 , gev gamma rays would be able to escape from the system . note that the bh attenuation is also avoidable for sufficiently high shock velocities . electrons and positrons ( for which we simply say electrons ) can generate synchrotron emission . the synchrotron cooling time of relativistic electrons is @xmath340 on the other hand , the ic cooling timescale is @xmath341 where @xmath342 is the compton @xmath343 parameter , @xmath344 is the synchrotron self - compton ( ssc ) @xmath343 parameter , and @xmath345 is the external inverse - compton ( eic ) @xmath343 parameter . the ic emission is bolometrically more important than the synchrotron emission if @xmath346 . we expect that the ssc emission is typically weak . this is because the ssc @xmath343 parameter in the thomson regime ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , @xmath347 is less than unity . here , @xmath348 $ ] and @xmath349 ( or @xmath350 ) , where @xmath351 ( or @xmath352 ) is the injection lorentz factor and @xmath353 is the cooling lorentz factor defined below . external radiation fields are mainly supplied by sn emission , which is more relevant in our cases . if the system is optically thin , the energy density of thermal photons is @xmath354 whereas the magnetic field energy density is @xmath355 because of @xmath356 , we see that the synchrotron cooling would be typically stronger than the eic cooling , although the situation can be altered depending on parameters such as @xmath357 . as a result , non - thermal x rays can be expected mainly due to eic emission . but they will be weaker than thermal x rays ( except at hard x rays ) , and this work focuses on radio signals . in the dense csm environment , one also has to care about other losses such as bremsstrahlung and coulomb losses . the relativistic bremsstrahlung cooling time scale is @xcite @xmath358 which is longer than @xmath169 , @xmath359 and @xmath360 for our typical parameters . the coulomb loss time scale of relativistic electrons is @xcite @xmath361)}\nonumber\\ & \simeq&2.2\times{10}^8~{\rm s}~\gamma_{e,2}\mu_ed_{*,-1}^{-1}r_{16}^{2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which suggests that sufficiently high - energy electrons typically cool via the synchrotron emission . at lower energies , however , the coulomb loss can be the shortest time scale , and the resulting synchrotron spectrum becomes complicated . the cooling lorentz factor is given by equating @xmath362 as @xmath363 if @xmath364 , the system is in the fast cooling regime , so the energy flux has a peak at @xmath365 . if @xmath366 , the system is in the slow cooling regime , so the energy flux has a peak at @xmath367 . primary protons with @xmath133 lead to inelastic @xmath0 reactions , providing secondary electrons . the characteristic frequency of electrons with @xmath352 is @xmath368 for our typical parameters , @xmath369 and @xmath370 cm , we expect @xmath371 ghz . we here point that these secondary electrons can be more relevant in the interaction - powered sn scenario . very naively , the secondary electronic emission dominates over the primary electronic emission when @xmath372\epsilon_p>\epsilon_e,\ ] ] which is likely to be realized if @xmath286 is as high as @xmath373 . one should keep in mind that this is the crude argument applied to the bolometric emission , and the relative importance changes with frequency , depending on spectral energy distributions of cr protons and electrons . assuming the fast cooling regime , the resulting synchrotron flux from hadronically - injected electrons ( at @xmath374 ) is @xmath375e_p^2\frac{dn_p}{de_pdt}\nonumber\\ & \sim&2.7\times{10}^{-14}~{\rm erg}~{\rm cm}^{-2}~{\rm s}^{-1}\nonumber\\ & \times&{\rm min}[10,f_{pp,-1}]{\left(\frac{\nu}{\nu_h}\right)}^{2-q_p}\epsilon_{p,-1}\nonumber\\ & \times&d_{*,-1}{(v_s/5000~{\rm km}~{\rm s}^{-1})}^{3}{\mathcal r}_{p0,1}^{-1}{(d/10~{\rm mpc})}^{-2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to @xmath376 for @xmath308 . hence , the synchrotron signal is detectable with high - frequency radio telescopes when several absorption processes we discuss below are irrelevant . in particular , the alma sensitivity at 100 ghz is @xmath377 , allowing detections up to @xmath378 gpc if followup observations are successful . primary electrons can also emit synchrotron photons , and the corresponding characteristic frequency of electrons with @xmath141 is @xmath379 it suggests that studying radio sne at relatively low frequencies can probe electron acceleration in the shock transition layer , whereas investigations at high frequencies allow us to see the conventional shock acceleration of electrons and/or hadronic injections . the synchrotron energy flux ( at @xmath380 ) in the fast cooling case is @xmath381 where @xmath147 is the electron spectral index and we expect @xmath382 for @xmath383 . note that @xmath147 may naturally be different from values expected in the conventional diffuse shock acceleration theory at @xmath384 , corresponding to electrons with @xmath385 , and steep indices of @xmath386 are indeed indicated in non - relativistic radio sne . the synchrotron signal from primary electrons is also detectable by current radio telescopes and mm / submm facilities including alma if secondary electrons are sub - dominant . for a given @xmath326 , the secondary electronic emission dominates over the primary electronic emission when @xmath387\frac{\epsilon_{p,-1}}{\epsilon_{e,-3}}{\left(\frac{\nu_l}{\nu_h}\right)}^{2-q}\gtrsim0.06,\ ] ] where the fast cooling regime is assumed for @xmath388 . hence , we expect that secondaries are typically more important for high - frequency radio emission from interaction - powered sne . however , detecting radio signals may suffer from scattering and various absorption processes . first , if @xmath43 , the synchrotron emission can be modified by comptonization due to thermal electrons . in particular , thermal electrons in the hot downstream may up - scatter low - energy photons the condition that the comptonization does not change the synchrotron spectrum is roughly given by @xmath389\lesssim1 $ ] , so we focus on ejecta - csm collisions satisfying @xmath390 . in addition , there are three important absorption processes that can hinder observations at the radio band , razin - tsytovich ( rt ) suppression , synchrotron self - absorption ( ssa ) and free - free absorption . we discuss these suppression and absorption processes below . , @xmath44 ) plane , at @xmath391 ghz , where @xmath54 , @xmath392 and @xmath393 and @xmath394 are used . the suppression or absorption of radio emission is insignificant at @xmath395 , @xmath396 , @xmath397 and @xmath398 . the light shaded region indicates the forbidden region for the radio emission in the pessimistic case , where the upstream is assumed to be ionized with @xmath399 k. the dark shaded area indicates the forbidden region in the optimistic case , which may be realized for different upstream properties . the downstream temperature is set to @xmath400 kev . from this figure , one sees that radio emission from interaction - powered sne satisfying @xmath401 is suppressed at this band . ] , @xmath14 ) plane , where @xmath14 has the solar - mass unit . ] ghz . from this figure , one sees that observations at 100 ghz are useful for probing interaction - powered sne satisfying @xmath401 . ] , @xmath14 ) plane , where @xmath14 has the solar - mass unit . ] ghz . ] , @xmath14 ) plane , where @xmath14 has the solar - mass unit . ] synchrotron emission in a plasma is different from that in a vacuum . when a cold plasma plays a role , it is suppressed at low frequencies due to collective effects . the suppression occurs at the rt frequency @xcite , @xmath402 the line of @xmath403 is shown in figures 6 - 11 . instead , given a frequency , we can obtain the upper limit on @xmath34 as @xmath404 the ssa opacity is estimated to be ( see appendix b ) @xmath405 where @xmath406 is the spectral index of electrons ( that is generally different from @xmath407 for injected particles ) , @xmath408 , and @xmath409 here , when the coulomb cooling is irrelevant , @xmath410 $ ] and @xmath411 is evaluated as a function of @xmath406 , which is order of @xmath412 ( see appendix b ) . when only synchrotron and ic ( in the thomson regime ) losses are relevant , we have @xmath413 at @xmath414 in the fast cooling case or @xmath415 when @xmath416 ( i.e. , the slow cooling case ) . here , @xmath417 is related to the number of electrons swept by the shock as @xmath418 where @xmath419 is the number fraction of electrons defined against @xmath420 . note that , for primary electron acceleration , the different parameter @xmath140 satisfies @xmath421 assuming a power - law injection spectrum , we have @xmath422 for @xmath423 and @xmath424 for @xmath425 , and we typically expect @xmath426 . for secondary electrons , we have @xmath427\epsilon_p}{6\gamma_h\ln(\gamma_p^m)}\frac{m_p}{m_e},\ ] ] for @xmath423 and @xmath427\epsilon_p(q-2)}{6\gamma_h(q-1)}\frac{m_p}{m_e},\ ] ] for @xmath425 . the proton spectrum is assumed to be a power law above @xmath428 , where we typically obtain @xmath429 $ ] . introducing @xmath419 allows us to discuss primary and secondary electrons in parallel . setting @xmath430 , the ssa frequency is estimated to be @xmath431 for @xmath413 ( leading to @xmath432 ) , and @xmath433 for @xmath434 ( leading to @xmath435 ) . instead , given a frequency , we can obtain the upper limit on @xmath34 as @xmath436 for @xmath413 , and @xmath437 for @xmath434 . note that we should use @xmath438 and @xmath413 for the fast cooling case . results for @xmath423 and @xmath439 are shown in figures 6 - 11 . in this work , we assume the case of @xmath440 $ ] , although ssa heating is relevant when @xmath441 $ ] @xcite . the free - free absorption is important especially when photons propagate in the ionized plasma . for simplicity , here we assume that ions are protons . in the hot downstream , the free - free opacity for photons with @xmath442 is @xcite @xmath443 where @xmath444 is the free - free absorption coefficient and @xmath91 is the gaunt factor . high temperatures of @xmath445 k are expected in the immediate downstream , while the temperature is lower at the far downstream due to bremsstrahlung cooling especially if the shock is radiative . the free - free absorption frequency is given by @xmath446 , and we have @xmath447 instead , given a frequency , we can obtain the upper limit on @xmath34 as @xmath448 if the free - free absorption in the emission region is dominant , we expect the suppression factor of @xmath449 at @xmath450 . however , one typically expects that upstream material would be more crucial for absorbing low - frequency emission ( but see * ? ? ? the upstream temperature is lower than the immediate downstream temperature , so the free - free optical depth can be much larger . before the shock reaches @xmath19 , assuming ionized material , the free - free optical depth in the upstream is @xmath451 the free - free absorption frequency is given by @xmath452 , and we have @xmath453 instead , given a frequency , we can obtain the upper limit on @xmath34 as @xmath454 note that , if the free - free absorption in the screen region is dominant , we expect the suppression of @xmath455 , which can be in principle distinguished from the other possibilities . as shown in figures 8 and 9 , at @xmath456 ghz , the free - free absorption is typically the most important attenuation process in sne with dense csm . even at @xmath457 ghz , it is the dominant attenuation process for ejecta - csm interactions at @xmath458 cm . this process is sensitive to the electron temperature , and @xmath459 k is used in figures 6 - 11 . the temperature may indeed be high enough , as suggested by successful radio detections of sn 2006jd @xcite . in figure 7 , sn 2006jd lies near the lines of @xmath452 and @xmath430 . on the other hand , non - detections of radio emission from many other type iin sne like sn 2010jl seem consistent with the large absorption that is easily realized with more conservative values of @xmath460 k @xcite . at @xmath457 ghz , as shown in figures 6 and 7 , the free - free absorption and ssa processes suppress radio signals , and the parameter space around @xmath401 is located in the dark shaded area . so it is difficult to see hadronic signatures with synchrotron emission at radio wavelengths . but the situation drastically changes at higher frequencies . at @xmath456 ghz , the free - free absorption is still an obstacle for ejecta - csm interactions at @xmath461 cm , but not for @xmath458 cm . importantly , as shown in figures 8 and 9 , a large parameter space of @xmath401 is free of absorption and scattering processes . so observations at high - frequency radio wavelengths including mm / submm and fir bands are indeed powerful to test the hadronic model and probe cosmic - ray proton acceleration . at higher frequencies such as 1000 ghz , all the absorption processes discussed here are negligible compared to the comptonization due to thermal electrons . not all interaction - powered sne allow us to expect high - frequency radio signals from secondaries . as pointed out by murase et al . ( 2011 ) , except at sufficiently late phases , optically - bright slsne are difficult to detect with synchrotron emission at radio bands . on the other hand , as shown in figures 9 and 11 , some type iin sne such as sn 2006jd and 2008iy seem very promising . there are some possibilities that we have effectively lower values of @xmath462 . first , the csm may be anisotropic or clumpy as suggested in several type iin sne like sn 2005ip @xcite and 2009ip ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , where the emission more easily escape from partial regions where the csm density is much lower . secondly , @xmath462 is smaller when the csm is little ionized , which may be realized especially in the far upstream . this is different from soft x rays that are more strongly absorbed in the non - ionized csm . such more transparent cases correspond to the light shaded area in figures 6 - 11 . note that the free - free optical depth declines after the shock reaches the outer edge of csm , @xmath19 . after @xmath463 , it becomes @xmath464 where @xmath465 ( at @xmath466 ) is assumed . for example , a possible value of @xmath467 is suggested in the late phase of the re - brightening of sn 2009ip @xcite . in this work , we provide a broad discussion of multi - messenger diagnoses of interaction - powered sne including type iin sne and some slsne , focusing on non - thermal signals . the shock would be radiation - mediated at very early times , and thus cr acceleration is inefficient . however , as photons escape the system , a collisionless shock can form and cr acceleration becomes possible . while shock heating leads to x rays , crs are expected to produce broadband non - thermal emission , including gamma rays , x rays , radio waves and neutrinos . photon emission in general may be largely thermalized depending the optical depth , which in turn depends on details of the csm . neutrinos are the most direct probe in the sense that they do not suffer from attenuation in the source . in addition , by advancing the idea proposed by murase et al . ( 2011 ) , we have shown that gev gamma rays can typically escape after the shock breakout , although tev gamma rays are attenuated due to the two - photon annihilation process . along with neutrinos , gev gamma rays can provide unique opportunities to probe the formation of collisionless shocks and the onset of cr acceleration . interestingly , the physical parameters suggested by observed interaction - powered sne imply densities similar to those inferred from gamma - ray novae @xcite , allowing us to expect analogous high - energy emission and to probe the physics of cr acceleration in the dense environment . detecting signals from one sn requires a nearby event , but stacking analyses are still useful . gamma rays and neutrinos are especially powerful for optically - bright slsne , for which the recipes provided in appendix a can be used . for normal luminosity interaction - powered sne , broad - band non - thermal emissions from radio to tev gamma - ray bands are possible . in particular , high - frequency radio observations in the mm / submm and fir bands can probe cr proton acceleration and test the hadronic model . we pointed out that secondary electrons produced via @xmath0 reactions play an important pole role in the synchrotron emission from some interaction - powered sne such as sn 2006jd . comprehensive observations from ghz to 1000 ghz may also be relevant to study acceleration of primary electrons that may not be accelerated by the conventional shock acceleration . our work demonstrates the importance of multi - messenger approaches in revealing the mechanism of type iin sne and cr acceleration in real time . the interaction - powered sn scenario has been commonly used to interpret slsne , but slsne are diverse and other scenarios also possible . for example , some slsne such as sn 2007bi may be rather pair - instability sne originating from progenitors with @xmath468 , where the stellar collapse is caused by the pressure decrease due to electron - positron pair - production @xcite . or luminous sne including slsne ic ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) may be driven by newborn pulsars ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? some slsne seem difficult to explain using these scenarios @xcite . high - energy emissions including gamma rays and neutrinos have been predicted in both the interaction - powered sn scenario @xcite and the pulsar - driven sn scenario @xcite . detecting thermal and non - thermal signals from shocks in the dense csm and studying time - dependent spectra are crucial in order to discriminate among the scenarios . the most important point of this work is that secondary electrons and positrons from inelastic @xmath0 collisions will radiate detectable synchrotron photons efficiently at high - frequency radio wavelengths including the mm / submm and fir bands . although details depend on the mass of csm , its physical location relative to the progenitor star at the time of explosion , and the velocity of the ejecta , for typical parameters , we expect the synchrotron spectrum to peak at @xmath469 ghz and with flux of @xmath7 mjy for 2006jd - like interaction - powered sne at distances of hundreds of mpc . in particular , high - frequency radio signals using instruments like the high - frequency channels of the vla and alma can be very powerful to probe physics of collisionless shocks . for this reason , we encourage followup observations especially at the mm / submm band within months - to - years and at the gev - tev gamma - ray band within days - to - years . k. m. thanks john beacom , roger chevalier , boaz katz , brian lacki , keiichi maeda , jose prieto , masaomi tanaka and ryo yamazaki for useful discussions . k. m. is supported by nasa through hubble fellowship , grant no . 51310.01 awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , for nasa , under contract no . nas 5 - 26555 . k. m. also thanks supports by ccapp since this project was started in the beginning of 2011 when k. m. was a member of ccapp . the preliminary results of this work was presented in march 2013 , hubble fellows symposium . here , we provide recipes to test the hadronic model for gamma - ray and neutrino emissions from interaction - powered sne . basically , we need to know two quantities , the cr energy @xmath470 and the @xmath0 efficiency @xmath286 . the latter depends on @xmath33 , @xmath21 and @xmath5 , which can be determined from the breakout emission . the more sophisticated approach is possible based on self - similar solutions in the engine - driven case @xcite . we here overview the prescription by chevalier & irwin ( 2011 ) . let us consider the ejecta whose outer density profile is @xmath471 at @xmath472 . the shock is initially radiation - mediated and the flows are radiation - dominated since @xmath473 . the contact discontinuity is located at @xmath474 , where @xmath475 . the forward shock radius is estimated to be @xmath476 and the forward shock velocity is @xmath477 . the energy carried by the interacting shell is estimated to be @xmath478 , where @xmath479 . for @xmath480 , the radiation energy is @xmath481 , so we have @xmath482 in the wind case , the photon diffusion timescale is comparable to the breakout time , and we have @xmath483 as long as the breakout happens at @xmath484 . the breakout radius can also be estimated from the evolution of the radiation luminosity and temperature if the black - body approximation is valid , or if @xmath49 is known . as a result , if we can observe @xmath178 , @xmath65 and @xmath49 ( or @xmath67 ) , we can evaluate @xmath44 , @xmath485 and @xmath486 as @xcite @xmath487 @xmath488 @xmath489 one should keep in mind that the engine - driven self - similar solution is valid as long as @xmath490 . then , we can estimate @xmath33 , allowing us to calculate @xmath286 and resulting neutrino and gamma - ray spectra . there are two important free parameters , the cr spectral index ( @xmath288 ) and cr energy ( @xmath470 ) . for @xmath491 , the cr proton spectrum is given by @xmath492 and @xmath493 for our typical parameters . for @xmath494 , we have @xmath495 here , @xmath274 is the conversion factor from the total energy to the differential energy spectrum and @xmath496 is the minimum proton energy . these equations can be rewritten as @xmath497 where @xmath498 . the cr energy is parametrized as @xmath499 where @xmath500 is the cr loading parameter that is commonly introduced in the literature of hadronic emissions from gamma - ray bursts @xcite . since both @xmath165 and @xmath501 are order of 0.1 , we expect @xmath502 and we can make predictions for breakout high - energy emissions , based on observational quantities . such an application was done in margutti et al . note that high - energy emissions continue after the breakout . given sufficient time - dependent data , later contributions can easily be taken into account by more detailed modeling . for example , one can directly use self - similar solutions for @xmath480 or @xmath115 at @xmath42 @xcite . most naively , instead , the overall contribution can be incorporated in the cr loading parameter . here we provide formulas to calculate ssa . for a power - law electron distribution , the ssa coefficient is @xcite @xmath503 where @xmath504 is the angle between the electron velocity and magnetic field . the normalization is determined by @xmath505 assuming @xmath506\gg\gamma_n={\rm min}[\gamma_i,\gamma_c]$ ] , we have @xmath507 , where @xmath508 for @xmath509 and @xmath510 for @xmath511 . when only the synchrotron emission is relevant , we have @xmath413 at @xmath414 in the fast cooling case or @xmath415 at @xmath416 in the slow cooling case . averaged over @xmath504 , the ssa coefficient is written as @xmath512 where @xmath513 for example , we obtain @xmath514 for @xmath413 and @xmath515 for @xmath434 , respectively . note that the spectrum in the optically - thick limit is obtained from @xmath516 , where @xmath517 is the synchrotron emissivity @xcite . the coefficient agrees with katz ( 2012 ) . one should keep in mind that the @xmath518 is obtained only if @xmath519 , whereas we expect @xmath520 if @xmath521 . balberg , s. , loeb , a. , 2012 , mnras , 414 , 1715 bell a. r. , 2004 , mnras , 353 , 550 bell , a. r. , 2013 , astropart . phys . , 43 , 56 bykov , a. m. , brandenburg , a. , malkov , m. a. , osipov , s. m. , 2013 , space sci . , 178 , 201 budnik , r. , katz , b. , macfadyen , a. , waxman , e. , 2008 , apj , 673 , 928 caprioli , d. , blasi , p. , amato , e. , 2009 , mnras , 396 , 2065 the cta consortium , 2011 , experimental astronomy , 32 , 193 chandra , p. , chevalier , r. a. , chugai , n. , fransson , c. , irwin , c. m. , soderberg , a. m. , chakraborti , s. , immler , s. , 2012a , apj , 755 , 110 chandra , p. , chevalier , r. a. , irwin , c. m. , chugai , n. , fransson , c. , soderberg , a. m. , 2012b , apj , 750 , l2 chevalier , r. a. , 1982a , apj , 258 , 790 chevalier , r. a. , 1982b , apj , 259 , 302 chevalier , r. a. , 1984 , apj , 285 , l63 chevalier , r. a. , 1998 , apj , 499 , 810 chevalier r. a. , fransson c. , 2003 , in weiler k. , ed . , lecture notes in physics vol . 598 , supernovae and gamma - ray bursters . springer - verlag , berlin , p. 171 chevalier , r. a. , irwin , c. m. , 2011 , apj , 729 , l6 chevalier , r. a. , irwin , c. m. , 2012 , apj , 747 , l17 chodorowski , m. j. , zdziarski , a. a. , sikora , m. , 1992 , apj , 400 , 181 chornock , r. et al . , 2013 , apj , 767 , 162 chugai , n. n. , danziger , i. j. , 1994 , mnras , 268 , 173 falk , s. w. and arnett , w. d. , 1973 , apj , 180 , l65 fransson , c. , lundqvist , p. , chevalier , r. a. , 1996 , apj , 461 , 993 fransson , c. et al . , 2013 , arxiv:1312.6617 funk , s. , hinton , j. a. , for the cta consortium , 2013 , astropart . , 43 , 348 immler , s. et al . , 2008 , apj , 674 , l85 inoue , t. , yamazaki , r. , inutsuka , s. , 2009 , apj , 695 , 825 inoue , t. , yamazaki , r. , inutsuka , s. , fukui , y. , 2012 , apj , 744 , 71 inserra , c. et al . , 2013 , apj , 770 , 128 kasen d. , bildsten l. , 2010 , apj , 717 , 245 kashiyama , k. , murase , k. , horiuchi , s. , gao , s. , mszros , p. , 2013 , apj , 769 , l6 katz , b. , 2012 , mnras , 420 , l6 katz , b. , budnik , r. , waxman , e. , 2010 , apj , 716 , 781 katz , b. , sapir , n. , waxman , e. , 2011 , arxiv:1106.1898 katz , b. , waxman , e. , 2008 , jcap , 01 , 018 kotera , k. , phinney , e. s. , olinto , a. v. , 2013 , mnras , 432 , 3228 kulsrud , r. m. , cesarsky , c. j. , 1971 , al , 8 , 189 maeda , k. , 2012 , apj 758 , 81 mauerhan , j. c. et al . , 2013 , mnras , 430 , 1801 metzger , b. d. , giannios , d. , thompson , t. a. , bucciantini , n. , quataert , e. , 2011 , mnras , 413 , 2031 miller , a. a. et al . , 2009 , apj , 690 , 1303 miller , a. a. et al . , 2010 , mnras , 404 , 305 margutti , r. et al . , 2014 , apj , 780 , 21 moriya , t. j. , blinnikov , s. i. , tominaga , n. , yoshida , n. , tanaka , m. , maeda , k. , nomoto , k. , 2013a , mnras , 428 , 1020 moriya , t. j. , maeda , k. , taddia , f. , sollerman , j. , blinnikov , s. i. , sorokina , e. i. , 2013b , mnras , 435 , 1520 murase , k. , mszros , p. , zhang , b. , 2009 , phys . d , 79 , 103001 murase , k. , nagataki , s. , 2006 , phys . d , 73 , 063002 murase , k. , thompson , t. a. , lacki , b. c. , beacom , j. f. , 2011 , phys . d , 84 , 043003 murase , k. et al . , 2014 , in preparation ofek , e. o. , lin , l. , kouveliotou , c. , younes , g. , ggs , e. , kasliwal , m. m. , cao , y. t. , 2013a , apj , 768 , 47 ofek , e. o. et al . , 2007 , apj , 659 , l13 ofek , e. o. et al . , 2013b , apj , 763 , 42 ofek , e. o. et al . , 2010 , apj , 724 , 1396 ofek , e. o. et al . , 2013c , nature ( london ) , 494 , 65 ofek , e. o. et al . , 2014 , apj , 781 , 42 ohira , y. , murase , k. , yamazaki , r. , 2010 , a&a , 513 , a17 quimby , r. m. et al . , 2011 , nature , 474 , 487 quimby , r. m. , yuan , f. , akerlof , c. , wheeler , j. c. , 2013 , mnras , 431 , 912 rest , a. et al . , 2011 , apj , 729 , 88 rybicki g. b. , lightman a. p. , 1986 , radiative processes in astrophysics . wiley , new york sari , e. , & esin , a. a. , 2001 , apj , 548 , 787 schlickeiser , r. , 2002 , cosmic ray astrophysics , ( new york : springer ) smith , n. , 2013 , mnras , 429 , 2366 smith , n. , chornock , r. , silverman , j. m. , filippenko , a. v. , foley , r. j. , 2010 , apj , 709 , 856 smith , n. , foley , r. j. , filippenko , a. v. , 2008 , apj , 680 , 568 smith , n. et al . , 2007 , apj , 666 , 1116 smith , n. , mccray , r. , 2007 , apj , 671 , l17 smith , n. et al . , 2009 , apj , 695 , 1334 sveshnikova , l. g. , 2003 , a&a , 409 , 799 svirski , g. , nakar , e. , sari , r. , 2012 , apj , 759 , 108 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: magnetic fields are now generally acknowledged to be essential to accretion @xcite . amplified exponentially from weak seed fields by the magneto - rotational instability ( mri ) , they are stretched in a consistent direction so as to produce a net stress @xmath0 capable of carrying enough angular momentum outward through the disk to support sizable accretion rates . because the nonlinear state of the mri is fully - developed magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) turbulence , it is often thought ( or at least hoped ) that its properties have little to do with the character of the seed magnetic field brought to the disk with the accretion flow . however , there are certain properties of the magnetic field that are preserved despite the development of nonlinear turbulence . because magnetic fields are divergence - free and the plasma in accretion flows has very little electrical resistivity , the global topology of the field persists , no matter what happens . it is therefore natural to ask whether any interesting properties of the accretion flow may depend on the global field topology . for example , could the field topology alter the relation between surface density and accretion rate ? or how the stress varies through the marginally stable region ? in addition to swallowing matter , accreting black holes often expel relativistic jets . although the mechanisms by which these jets are launched have long been the subject of investigation and speculation , the current consensus focuses on a combination of large - scale magnetic fields and the rotation of either the central hole , the accretion disk , or both . two specific mhd models have received the greatest attention : the blandford - znajek mechanism @xcite and the blandford - payne mechanism @xcite . in the blandford - payne model a large - scale vertical magnetic field is anchored in the disk , rotating with the orbital frequency . above and below the disk magnetic tension dominates , and the field lines force the matter to rotate with this same frequency . if the fieldlines are angled outward sufficiently with respect to the disk , there can be a net outward force , accelerating the matter along the rotating fieldlines . the blandford - znajek model also depends upon rotating field lines , but the source of that rotation ( and the source of the power in the jet ) is the black hole rather than the disk : any field lines connecting the immediate vicinity of the black hole to infinity are forced to rotate by frame - dragging , so that poynting flux carries off the energy . given the strong dependence of both the blandford - znajek and the blandford - payne mechanisms on the nature of the magnetic field in the disk and near the black hole , it is equally natural to inquire whether the topology of the field embedded in the accretion flow has any influence on their operation . it is the goal of this paper to begin to investigate these questions , both as they relate to accretion disk dynamics and as they relate to jet properties . unfortunately , it is difficult even to scratch the surface by purely analytic techniques ( although there have been some attempts using highly - simplified models : * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? on the other hand , direct numerical simulations provide a means by which aspects of these problems can be investigated in detail . @xcite made a first exploration of the dependence of accretion properties on field topology in a highly - simplified approximation : newtonian dynamics in a pseudo - newtonian potential . they found that a purely toroidal initial field led to a systematically smaller accretion rate than one whose initial field was dipolar . more recently , fully general relativistic mhd ( grmhd ) simulations have become possible @xcite . these works have focused primarily on a single initial field structure : a set of nested dipole field loops contained entirely within the initial gas torus . other field geometries have been examined , but only in rather limited fashion . for example , @xcite simulated the evolution of a torus with an initial toroidal field around a schwarzschild black hole and noted the lack of any resulting jet , but did not consider why no jet formed . @xcite , using axisymmetric simulations , compared the electromagnetic luminosity of the standard dipole jet with that resulting from a few alternate magnetic field topologies . in particular , they studied cases in which the initial field was arranged in loops of alternating sign arranged either vertically or horizontally within the initial torus . the principal effect they reported was a factor of 23 reduction in the ratio of the time - averaged jet poynting flux to the mean mass accretion rate . they also noted that an initial field that is purely vertical led to significant enhancements in both the mean mass accretion rate and the time - averaged jet poynting flux . axisymmetric simulations of tori threaded by net vertical field led @xcite to concur that such a field can greatly enhance jet power . on the basis of these results , @xcite proposed that black holes inevitably become threaded by an organized vertical field if the initial disk contains a large - scale poloidal field with few parity changes . the intriguing character of these results motivates a more systematic study , one that employs three - dimensional simulations , considers the accretion flow as well as the jet , and investigates time - dependence . the question immediately arises : how can one best attempt to describe the very complex mixture of topologies likely to be found in real accretion flows ? the magnetic field near a black hole can be thought of as simply what the accretion process itself has self - consistently brought there from whatever source supplies it . in order to gain understanding of what , in realistic circumstances , must be a truly complex combination of structures , in this paper we do not try to construct a single realistic " field geometry ; instead , we study the effects due to individual members of a basis set " of field topologies . our hope is that by understanding the action of pure types , we can gain some understanding of how realistic mixtures behave . to be specific , we will begin with a carefully chosen set of different kinds of closed field loops that we expect to be generic . closed field loops have the advantage of requiring many fewer free parameters to describe them fully within a simulation than do field geometries with net flux . net flux geometries may well exist in nature and have important effects ; we will consider them in the second stage of this project . we begin with the conjecture that , at a qualitative level , the different sorts of closed field loop behavior can all be represented by a combination of those due to : dipolar loops , or fieldlines initially entirely poloidal and which cross the equatorial plane at well - separated radii ; toroidal loops , which encircle the black hole ; and quadrupolar loops , which ( again , in the initial state ) are poloidal , but close without crossing the equatorial plane . for each of these cases , we have run a lengthy three - dimensional grmhd simulation whose results we hope characterize the accretion flow structure created by that field topology . we have also run a series of high resolution axisymmetric simulations of each of the initially poloidal topologies ( i.e. dipole and quadrupole ) . in addition , in order to understand better the implications of the finite lifetimes of closed loops , we have performed an axisymmetric simulation whose initial magnetic field structure was a series of dipolar loops , each contained within a span of radii narrow enough that the difference in inflow times across a loop is comparable to the equilibration time for the magnetic field in the jet . the rest of this work is structured as follows . in [ numerics ] we briefly review the numerical scheme employed to solve the equations of grmhd and give a detailed description of the initial conditions used to generate each topology . in [ flowstructure ] we examine the late time accretion flow structure that evolves from each of the initial field topologies , paying attention to each of the structures ( main disk body , magnetized corona ) that were identified by @xcite as arising from the evolution of the dipole field topology . in [ jets ] we examine the properties of the third structure identified by @xcite , the unbound outflow , and examine how the initial evolution of the field during the linear growth phase of the mri gives rise to the components of the accretion flow at late times . finally in [ conclusion ] we summarize our results and highlight their importance for jets in astrophysical settings . in this work we undertake a study of both two- and three - dimensional simulations to investigate the influence of magnetic field topology on both the evolved accretion flow structure and relativistic jet formation . in doing so we continue a program of black hole accretion disk simulations begun in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . three - dimensional simulations , such as those presented in the previous work , are the only means by which one can gain insight into the evolved accretion flow properties due to the fundamental restriction posed by the anti - dynamo theorem @xcite . further , toroidal field models can not be studied in axisymmetry , since the toroidal mri requires nonzero azimuthal wavevectors . on the other hand , because jet formation occurs promptly during the evolution of the flow @xcite , restrictions due to the anti - dynamo theorem are less critical for jet studies . in this case the higher resolution afforded by the two - dimensional simulations is particularly valuable . the simulation code we use is described in @xcite . this code solves the equations of ideal non - radiative mhd in the static kerr metric of a rotating black hole using boyer - lindquist coordinates . values are expressed in gravitational units @xmath1 with line element @xmath2 and signature @xmath3 . since we are focusing in this paper on the influence of the magnetic field topology , we fix the black hole spin to @xmath4 for all of the new simulations reported here . the relativistic fluid at each grid zone is described by its density @xmath5 , specific internal energy @xmath6 , @xmath7-velocity @xmath8 , and isotropic pressure @xmath9 . the relativistic enthalpy is @xmath10 . the pressure is related to @xmath5 and @xmath6 via the equation of state for an ideal gas , @xmath11 . the magnetic field is described by two sets of variables . the first is the constrained transport magnetic field @xmath12 f_{jk}$ ] , where @xmath13 $ ] is the completely anti - symmetric symbol , and @xmath14 are the spatial components of the electromagnetic field strength tensor . from the constrained transport ( ct ) magnetic field components , we derive the magnetic field four - vector , @xmath15 , and the magnetic field scalar , @xmath16 . the electromagnetic component of the stress - energy tensor is @xmath17 . in all of the simulations , the initial condition for the matter is an isolated , hydrostatic torus orbiting near the black hole . the initial state of the three - dimensional simulations was chosen so as to be consistent with that used in earlier simulations in this series ( see * ? ? ? the matter s adiabatic index , @xmath18 was @xmath19 and the angular momentum distribution was slightly sub - keplerian , with a specific angular momentum at the inner edge of the torus ( located at @xmath20 m ) @xmath21 ( we define @xmath22 ) . for this choice of @xmath23 , the pressure maximum is at @xmath24 . in the two - dimensional simulations , our fiducial torus was chosen to have a constant angular momentum distribution with @xmath25 , @xmath18 was 4/3 , and the inner edge was again located at @xmath20 m . this torus is significantly thicker than the nearly - keplerian torus used for the three - dimensional simulations ; its density scale height at the pressure maximum , measured along surfaces of constant radius , is a factor @xmath26 greater than that of the three - dimensional torus . this thicker configuration makes it easier to resolve the multiple field loop model , where several field loops must fit into a restricted space . this specific combination of @xmath27 and @xmath18 was also necessary to manipulate the shape of the torus so that there was an appropriate balance in magnetic flux between the different components of the multiple dipole loop simulation . in the quadrupolar field case , in order to study how the evolution of the field depends on its detailed geometry , we examined what happened as @xmath27 varied from 4.9 to 5.2 in steps of 0.05 . the initial torus is overlaid with a variety of magnetic field configurations , all with zero net flux . the initial poloidal magnetic field is determined from the curl of the four - vector potential , i.e. , @xmath28 with only @xmath29 . for a single dipolar loop , we set @xmath30 for a quadrupole , the azimuthal component of the vector potential is @xmath31 in both of these cases @xmath32 is set to zero where the density is less than @xmath33 ; this device confines the initial field to lie well inside the torus . in all the poloidal simulations , the initial field intensity ( i.e. , the parameter @xmath34 ) is determined by setting the volume - averaged ratio of gas to magnetic pressure @xmath35 . the vector potential for @xmath36 dipolar loops ( used only for the two - dimensional simulations ) is more complicated . it is given by @xmath37,\ ] ] where the total vector potential is the superposition of the ( non - relativistic ) vector potentials from @xmath36 current loops ( see * ? ? ? 182 , eqn . 5.37 ) . here @xmath38 is the current in the @xmath39th loop , located at radius @xmath40 in the equatorial plane . @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds , and @xmath43 . the @xmath44 are chosen so that the difference between the inflow times of adjacent loops is approximately equal to one jet equilibration time , @xmath45@xmath46 . the signs of the @xmath47 alternate with increasing radius so that the senses of the dipolar field loops alternate . the magnitudes of the currents were chosen with the goal of ensuring that the evolution of the two radially innermost loops was governed by the field local to those loops . the purpose of this simulation was to study the interaction of the two inner loops as they accrete ; in that context , the only function of the two outer loops is to supply the outer part of the torus with magnetic field , so that it could accept the angular momentum brought to it from the true accretion flow . thus , the most appropriate outer field structure for this particular numerical experiment is one that has the least influence on dynamics inside the pressure maximum . after some experimentation , we found that this goal could be achieved only by giving the two outer loops relatively small currents . when that was done , the outer two loops moved outward with the outer portion of the disk and were quickly destroyed ( i.e. forced to reconnect ) as the second loop from the inside expanded toward them . we make no pretense that this choice is a fair representation of generic four - loop evolution , but it does support our study of what happens when two complete loops of opposite sense are brought into the inner disk one after the other . for a purely toroidal initial field , all that is necessary is to set @xmath48 and determine @xmath49 by a choice of volume - averaged @xmath50 . here we use @xmath51 , as , in the purely toroidal case , accretion can occur only once mri - induced turbulence on the large scales has grown to sufficiently large amplitude , and long wavelength modes grow comparatively slowly . beginning with a comparatively strong field ensured that accretion activity started soon after the simulation began . after saturation , the field ( in relative terms ) actually weakened somewhat : the volume - averaged @xmath50 grew to @xmath52 ( see section [ diskbody ] ) . as before , the initial magnetic field is set to zero for densities below @xmath33 . we take the dipole simulation kdpg ( originally presented in * ? ? ? * where further discussion of our boundary conditions and grids may be found ) as our fiducial three - dimensional run . the three - dimensional quadrupole simulation is designated qdpa and the three - dimensional toroidal simulation is tdpa . kdpg and qdpa were run for @xmath53 in time , which corresponds to approximately @xmath54 orbits at the initial pressure maximum . the toroidal field model , tdpa , evolves initially at a slower rate ; it was run to @xmath55 in time . for each simulation , the time step @xmath56 was determined by the minimal light crossing time for a zone on the spatial grid and remained constant for the entire simulation @xcite . each of the three - dimensional simulations used @xmath57 @xmath58 grid zones . the radial grid extends from an inner boundary located at @xmath59 , which lies just outside the black hole event horizon , to an outer boundary located at @xmath60 . for the two poloidal topologies , the radial grid was graded using a hyperbolic cosine distribution ; for the toroidal case a logarithmic distribution was used . an outflow condition is applied at both the inner and outer radial boundary . the @xmath61-grid spans the range @xmath62 using an exponential distribution that concentrates zones near the equator . a reflecting boundary condition is used along the conical cutout surrounding the coordinate axis . the @xmath63-grid spans the quarter plane , @xmath64 , with periodic boundary conditions applied in @xmath63 . the use of this restricted angular domain significantly reduces the computational requirements of the simulation . the two - dimensional simulations were performed on a @xmath65 @xmath66 grid in which the radial cells are graded logarithmically , and the polar angle cells are concentrated toward the equator in the same way as for the three - dimensional simulations . the @xmath61 grid , however , goes much closer to the axis than in the three - dimensional simulations , with a cut - out of only @xmath67 radians . in addition to allowing higher poloidal resolution at a reasonable computational cost , two - dimensional simulations have the additional advantage that field - lines can be easily visualized as level surfaces of the vector potential component @xmath32 . using this approach , we illustrate the magnetic field topologies for the three different poloidal configurations in figure [ topologies ] . we begin by examining the average properties of the accretion flows in simulations kdpg , qdpa and tdpa . @xcite described the accretion flow structure in terms of three distinct regions : the main disk body , the coronal envelope , and the unbound outflow . in this section , we study the first two , paying special attention to contrasts ( or lack of contrast ) when the magnetic topology changes . we will discuss the unbound outflow in the following section . much of the analysis will be in terms of various time- and space - averaged quantities . the radial profile of the time - averaged shell integral of @xmath68 is defined as @xmath69 similarly , the shell average of a quantity @xmath68 at a radius @xmath70 is defined to be : @xmath71 the angular profile of the time - average of @xmath68 at radius @xmath70 is defined by @xmath72 lastly , the time- and volume - average of @xmath68 is : @xmath73 in these equations @xmath74 is the time over which the integral is computed , and @xmath75 is the usual metric determinant . typically @xmath76 ; for kdpg and qdpg this is the last @xmath77 of the full evolution , while for tdpa we choose a @xmath77 window in the middle of the simulation after the accretion flow is established . the spatial extent of the shell integration is the full @xmath61 and @xmath63 computational domain . during a given simulation , various shell integrals and radial fluxes are computed and stored every @xmath78 in time . this data can then be integrated over time to obtain quantities such as the total or time - averaged jet outflow or accretion rate . it is also useful to divide the shell and volume integrals into two parts , one for bound and one for unbound flow . for simplicity we define a particular zone to be unbound " if @xmath79 . unbound outflow can further be defined as those unbound cells with @xmath80 . in these simulations only the outflow near the axis ( the jet outflow ) is unbound ; the coronal backflow from the disk itself remains bound . the initial evolution of the accretion disks in kdpg and qdpa is qualitatively similar . both field configurations begin with considerable radial field within the torus . this is sheared out , generating toroidal field which , by @xmath81 , is sufficiently strong that the resulting poloidal gradient in @xmath82 begins to drive the inner edge of the torus ( initially located at @xmath83 ) inward . the inner edge of the disk arrives at the black hole at @xmath84 . within the disk body , the mri generates the turbulence that will determine the subsequent evolution of the disk , and by @xmath85 a statistically stationary turbulent accretion flow has been established inside the radius of the inner edge of the initial torus . the toroidal field model tdpa evolves more slowly than the two poloidal field cases , consistent with the results from earlier toroidal field pseudo - newtonian simulations @xcite . as discussed at length in @xcite , this behavior stems both from the absence of an initial radial field ( which means that there is no toroidal field amplification due to shear ) and from the fact that long - wavelength modes which are the most effective in driving accretion grow relatively slowly . inflow can begin only when the mri has produced turbulence of sufficient amplitude , which occurs by @xmath86 , corresponding to about 5 orbits at the radius of the torus pressure maximum . the accretion rate into the hole increases until about @xmath87 , after which it shows large fluctuations without an overall trend . figure [ bndavgplt1 ] shows time - averaged , shell - integrated radial profiles of a number of quantities relevant to the accretion flow : accretion rate @xmath88 , surface density @xmath89 , the net accreted angular momentum per unit rest mass , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , the electromagnetic poynting flux @xmath92 and the em angular momentum flux @xmath93 . the subscripts fl and em denote the fluid and electromagnetic contributions to the stress - energy tensor , respectively . all quantities are computed in the coordinate frame after the turbulent accretion flow is established , and in all cases the volume integral was restricted to cells where the matter was bound . the poloidal field simulations were averaged over time @xmath94@xmath95 while the toroidal field data were averaged over @xmath96@xmath97 . these six plots may be divided into two groups : those with little dependence on initial field topology ( surface density and accreted angular momentum per unit mass ) , and those with a stronger dependence ( accretion rate , magnetic field strength , poynting flux , and electromagnetic angular momentum flux ) . although the radial distribution of the surface density in all three cases is fairly similar , there is a slight distinction between the two poloidal models on the one hand and the toroidal on the other . the surface density in the toroidal model rises somewhat more steeply with radius , with lower density near the black hole and higher values outside of @xmath98 . for all three topologies , the specific angular momentum carried into the hole is close to the angular momentum of the marginally stable orbit . for tdpa , the value is essentially equal to that of the isco , while both qdpa and kdpa have smaller values , indicative of continued stress operating near or inside the isco . in all three cases , the time - averaged accretion rate is constant with radius out to @xmath9910 ; in this sense , all three have achieved a quasi - steady state within @xmath100 , where @xmath101 is the radial coordinate of the innermost stable circular orbit , @xmath102 ( the rise in @xmath103 and @xmath104 at large radius in tdpa is likely an artifact of the stronger magnetic field with which that simulation was begun ; equilibration takes place on timescales proportional to the local orbital period , which is , of course , @xmath105 , so inflow equilibration is slower at large radius ) . however , the actual value of the accretion rate is significantly different in the three simulations . the time - averaged mass accretion rate is highest in qdpa , exceeding that of kdpg by about @xmath106 , while @xmath107 is lower in tdpa by more than a factor of 2 compared to qdpa . accretion is , of course , driven by angular momentum transport , which is largely due to magnetic torques . to support these torques , the shell - integrated electromagnetic angular momentum flux must increase outward , as the net torque on the matter is the divergence of the em angular momentum flux . the dependence of the electromagnetic angular momentum flux on initial field topology is therefore similar to that of the mass accretion rate : it is consistently greater for kdpg and qdpa than for tdpa . the most significant difference between the kdpg and qdpa curves is that in the region near the isco , the electromagnetic angular momentum flux in kdpg becomes almost constant with decreasing radius ; this effect has previously been seen in other simulations that begin with dipole magnetic field loops @xcite . in the other two cases , the em angular momentum flux continues to decline inward . the mean magnetic field strength and poynting flux show a very similar dependence on initial field topology : qdpa and kdpg closely resemble each other , tdpa is somewhat weaker . in the toroidal case , the disk body average magnetic energy density is weaker by a factor of several than in the other two simulations , and decreases inward toward the horizon rather more rapidly . correspondingly , the time- and volume - averaged @xmath50 parameter was 11 in qdpa , 16 in kdpg , and 30 in tdpa ( because this is a volume - average , the corona is weighted heavily in this statistic ) . the electromagnetic energy flux shows the greatest variation between models . @xmath108 in kdpg is consistently larger than the value in qdpa : by a factor of two at @xmath109 and a factor of six at @xmath110 . the value in tdpa is smaller still by a factor of @xmath111 at these same radii . all these relations can be understood in a straightforward fashion : there is a nearly - constant ratio between the em angular momentum flux ( and therefore the accretion rate ) , the poynting flux , and the magnetic field intensity . in figure [ ratio ] , we plot the ratios of @xmath103 , @xmath108 and@xmath93 to @xmath91 . the inter - simulation contrast in the means of these quantities falls by a factor of several from the plot of their absolute values ( fig . [ bndavgplt1 ] ) to the plot of their ratios to @xmath82 ( fig . [ ratio ] ) . thus , we see that their primary dependence is on the magnetic field strength . only in the ratio of the electromagnetic energy flux to magnetic field strength do we see any global variation between the field topologies : @xmath108 in kdpg is consistently a factor of two above qdpa and tdpa . this contrast arises from the strong poynting flux in kdpg associated with the slower - moving , bound portion of the funnel - wall outflow ( as can be seen from figure 10 of * ? ? ? * see [ jets ] ) . the behavior of the fluid - frame stress can be seen in figure [ maxwell ] , which depicts its time - averaged vertically - integrated value as a function of radius . to compute this quantity , we project the stress tensor onto a local tetrad system in each cell and multiply by the fluid - frame cell volume , which is computed by a similar projection @xcite . after integrating over the bound matter on that spherical shell , we normalize the result to the surface area that this finite - thickness shell occupies in the equatorial plane . we present the result in this form in order to compare with the conventional representation of the vertically - integrated stress given by @xcite , which is presented in these terms . the novikov - thorne fluid - frame stress , unlike ours , is _ assumed _ to be zero at and within the isco . in the figure , the novikov - thorne stress is normalized by the time - averaged value of the accretion rate in the simulation . outside the isco , the radial profile of the maxwell stress is similar to the prediction of the novikov - thorne model , but in no case is there a roll - over in the value near the isco . as has been noted previously for the initial dipole field topology @xcite , the @xmath112 stress does not go to zero at the isco , but is continuous down to the event horizon . this is true for all three field topologies , at least in a time - averaged sense , although the amplitude of the stress declines as one goes from dipole to quadrupole to toroidal field topology . in the dipole case , the logarithmic gradient of the stress as a function of radius actually steepens as the accretion flow approaches the horizon . as can be seen from figure [ bndavgplt1 ] , this extra stress does reduce the specific angular momentum carried into the hole by the accretion flow . at the isco the accretion flow in the toroidal field simulation has @xmath113 ( where @xmath114 is the specific angular momentum of the isco ) and the accretion flows in the dipole and quadrupole simulations have @xmath115 ( a change of @xmath116 compared to @xmath117 ) . below the isco , @xmath104 in the quadrupole and toroidal cases remains constant with decreasing @xmath70 . in the dipole simulation , @xmath104 decreases to @xmath118 at @xmath119 , a decrease of @xmath120 compared to @xmath117 . the fall off in the dipole case below the isco is presumably due to the steepening of the maxwell stress in this region . as has been remarked in earlier papers @xcite , @xcite , when @xmath121 , the magnitude of the maxwell stress ( i.e. , the electromagnetic angular momentum flux ) is smaller than the angular momentum flux associated directly with matter ( @xmath122 ) in the inner disk . it follows ( as shown in figure [ ratio ] ) , that the mean accreted angular momentum per unit rest - mass is only slightly below the novikov - thorne value ( i.e. , @xmath123 at the isco ) . nonetheless , this continuity in the stress is important for other reasons : because the dissipation is rather more centrally - concentrated than the stress , this additional stress can be significant in the disk heat budget ; and the relative importance of the additional stress increases sharply for higher black hole spins . thus , we see that the initial magnetic field geometry makes relatively little qualitative difference to the character of the accretion flow . the sense of its ( weak ) influence is that the simulation beginning with a purely toroidal magnetic field results in a saturated field amplitude a factor of two smaller than those resulting from poloidal seed fields . the poynting flux , electromagnetic angular momentum flux , and accretion rate scale in direct proportion to the magnetic field energy density . in their study based on axisymmetric simulations , @xcite also found that certain disk properties are largely independent of the initial field configuration . they found that the shell - averages of magnetic field quantities within the bound portion of the accretion flow ( strictly speaking , where @xmath124 ) follow power - law distributions that are the same regardless of the initial field topology . for example , they found that the field amplitude @xmath125 from the isco out to about @xmath126 . integrating the same magnetic field quantities ( magnetic field strength and the lab - frame projections of the ct - fields ) over the bound portion of the flow in our simulations reveals that these quantities do scale roughly as power - laws in radius , but with shallower gradients than as determined by @xcite . in addition , we see a slow trend with field topology , as well as significant fluctuations in time : @xmath127 in simulation kdpg ( where @xmath128 denotes 1 std . deviation about the time - average ) , @xmath129 in simulation qdpa , and @xmath130 in simulation tdpa . the contrast between our results and @xcite could result from a number of considerations : the initial torus configurations differed in their radial pressure and angular momentum profiles , and our simulations are fully three - dimensional , rather than axisymmetric . these scalings may or may not be universal , but they appear to have little to do with the jet . as we will shortly show in [ jets ] , jet properties differ strongly from one initial magnetic topology to another ; it must be , then , that jets depend on other properties in addition to the current distribution in the disk . @xcite noted that the main disk body is surrounded by a low density region where the magnetic and thermal energies are in approximate equipartition . this region was designated as the coronal envelope . in contrast to the main disk body , where poloidal fluid velocities are dominated by turbulence , the poloidal motions in the coronal envelope are smooth on small scales and create an outgoing , but bound , backflow . figure [ beta ] displays the spatial distribution of the time- and azimuthally - averaged @xmath50 parameter overlaid with contours of the gas density for each of the three different topologies . kdpg shows the familiar strongly - magnetized axial funnel and a corona with relatively large regions of @xmath131 . qdpa shows a lower level of magnetization in the funnel region , while tdpa has much larger regions with @xmath132 overall . to quantify these impressions , we adopt a more precise definition of the corona than that given in @xcite . we define it as those regions of _ bound _ material that lie outside of @xmath133 density - scale heights from the mid - plane , that is those cells that satisfy both @xmath134 and @xmath135 , where @xmath136 is the equatorial density and we measure along curves of constant @xmath70 . using this definition , we integrate over the corona and over time to compute the average total volume and mass fraction in the corona , the volume - averaged @xmath50 parameter , and the mean fluid - frame thermal and magnetic energy per unit mass . these data are given in table [ corona ] . the coronal regions for all three simulations take up half or more of the total simulation volume but contain only @xmath137 of the mass . the volume assigned to the corona for kdpg is a smaller percentage compared to the other models , but kdpg also contains an unbound jet along the funnel axis , which is excluded from the corona by definition . within the coronal volume , the average thermal and magnetic energies per mass are similar , with volume averaged @xmath50 values of @xmath1384 . figure [ angcor ] plots the angular profiles of density @xmath139 , gas pressure @xmath140 , magnetic pressure @xmath141 and @xmath50 @xmath142 at @xmath126 . all three magnetic topology cases have very similar density profiles in the disk body , but appear to differ in the corona . although our averaging period of @xmath77 is 30 orbital periods at the radius shown ( @xmath143 ) , it is not long enough to erase completely fluctuations in the coronal density profile : observe that the quadrupolar case is the most extended in the southern hemisphere " corona while the toroidal case is the most extended in the northern hemisphere " . consistent with the general behavior we have already emphasized , the gas and magnetic pressure profiles in the disk body are very similar in the dipolar and quadrupolar cases , but both pressures are rather smaller in the toroidal field case . nonetheless , all three cases share one important property : the magnetic pressure is almost flat for several scale - heights around the midplane . this finding is consistent with results from shearing - box simulations with much better vertical resolution @xcite . in the corona , the magnetic pressure drops rapidly with height in qdpa and tdpa , but remains nearly constant in kdpg . in all three cases , the magnetic and gas pressures track each other closely , so that the @xmath50 profiles in the three runs are very similar . figure [ angtrptrt ] plots the angular profiles of the electromagnetic contributions to @xmath144 and @xmath145 ( @xmath146 and @xmath147 respectively ) at two different radii , @xmath110 and @xmath109 . at the larger radius , it should come as no surprise that the profile of magnetic pressure shown at that radius in figure [ angcor ] accurately predicts the profile of these two electromagnetic quantities . at the smaller radius , as we have already shown ( fig . [ bndavgplt1 ] ) , the magnetic field is considerably more intense in the dipole case than in the other two , so both the electromagnetic angular momentum flux and energy flux follow suit . to summarize this section , we have found that , just as for the main disk body , the character of disk coronae is only weakly dependent upon the initial field topology . there are modest quantitative contrasts of the same sort as seen in the disk body dipolar and quadrupolar initial fields both create somewhat stronger magnetic fields on average than does initial toroidal field but that is all . the formation of unbound outflows , or jets , is one of the most striking features of the kd models @xcite , all of which were initialized with single - loop dipolar magnetic fields . these outflows generically have two components : a poynting flux jet inside the axial funnel formed by the centrifugal barrier , and a sheath of much denser unbound gas moving outward at sub - relativistic speed along the funnel s outer edge . as described in @xcite , energy for the poynting flux comes from the rotation of the black hole , in a manner closely related to the classical blandford - znajek mechanism . in the case of the schwarzschild hole , the absence of black hole rotation means that the magnetic field in the funnel , although relatively strong , is mostly radial and carries no poynting flux . the funnel wall jet , on the other hand , appears to be powered by the significant gas and magnetic pressure near the isco . the gas retains enough angular momentum to be excluded from the funnel and is squeezed outward along the centrifugal barrier . in contrast , the three - dimensional quadrupole and toroidal field simulations have substantially weaker unbound outflows , if any . figure [ ubndavgplt1 ] shows the time - averaged shell - integrals of the mass outflow rate @xmath148 , magnetic field strength@xmath91 ; along with the electromagnetic energy flux , @xmath92 and angular momentum flux @xmath149 in unbound material between @xmath150 m and @xmath151 m . the values in kdpg are 10100 times larger than those in qdpa , whose outflow quantities are , in turn , an order of magnitude larger than those in tdpa . for example , the unbound mass outflow rate at @xmath152 in kdpg is @xmath153 times that of qdpa , while the mass outflow rate in tdpa is 10 times smaller than in qdpa . the strength of the outflow is directly related to the strength of the funnel field . in kdpg the time - averaged funnel magnetic energy density is 20@xmath154 times greater than in the quadrupole model , while the toroidal model is weaker by another factor of 10 . the mean poynting flux in kdpg is therefore @xmath155 times the poynting flux for qdpa . in other words , unlike the qualitative similarity of the accretion flows produced by these different field topologies , the outflows differ dramatically . to understand better the origin of this sharp contrast , in the next section we focus more closely on exactly how field is introduced into the funnel , and how its magnitude is controlled . we have seen that the strength of the poynting flux jet is very sensitive to the initial magnetic field topology . because the establishment of large - scale field within the funnel appears to be critical to driving a jet with substantial poynting flux , we devote the remainder of this section to a close examination of just how different magnetic topologies lead to different funnel magnetic fields , leaning heavily on high - resolution 2-d axisymmetric simulations . we begin by analyzing the axisymmetric simulation whose initial condition has already been shown to produce a significant jet , the dipole . figure [ dfpevln ] shows a time series of color plots of the @xmath50 parameter overlaid with white contours depicting poloidal field lines . as the radial field is sheared , a toroidal field ( visible in fig . [ dfpevln ] through its effect on @xmath50 ) is created and amplified , leading to poloidal magnetic pressure gradients @xcite . because the initial radial field has opposite sign on opposite sides of the equatorial plane , the toroidal field created by the shear also changes sign across the equator . the inner edge of the torus begins to move inward toward the event horizon , dragging the magnetic field with it . as the gas moves inward , its rotation velocity increases , further strengthening the toroidal field . as the magnetic pressure increases , gas is forced toward the equator where the field is comparatively weak , bringing the regions of oppositely - directed toroidal field closer together ( see , e.g. , the panel illustrating @xmath156 ) . as a result , a strong current sheet forms along the equatorial plane . once the inner edge of the accretion flow arrives at the black hole ( @xmath157 ) , field lines attach to the event horizon , and gas rapidly drains off them . field lines slide toward the poles as they expand outward at relativistic speed , driven by the contrast between the high magnetic pressure near the equatorial plane and the much lower pressure higher up along the axis . this flow moves outward so swiftly because it is almost entirely unencumbered by the inertia of matter . as discussed in @xcite , a magnetic tower forms , similar to the one predicted on analytic grounds @xcite and seen in other simulations @xcite however , in contrast to these models , tightly - wrapped field lines persist only briefly ; the large vertical gradient in magnetic pressure propels the upper loops so rapidly outward that in the steady - state the field lines are better described as loosely helical than as a tightly - wrapped coil . the radial field inside the funnel has the same sign as the vertical component of the initial dipole loop inside the initial pressure maximum ; these field lines close outside of @xmath151 m , reentering the problem volume throughout the corona . a time history of the unbound poynting flux at @xmath152 , normalized by the instantaneous ( coordinate frame ) magnetic field energy within the bound accretion flow , is shown in figure [ 2dtrtdu ] for both the three - dimensional simulation kdpg and the high - resolution axisymmetric model . in both cases , once the jet is established ( a process taking @xmath158 ) , the poynting flux jet persists . it is frequently perturbed , and the amplitude undergoes fluctuations , but its basic properties persist throughout the simulation . excluding initial transients ( i.e. @xmath159 ) , the jet histories of the two simulations are very similar to one another , despite the differences in dimensionality , ( poloidal ) resolution , torus configuration and equation of state : in both cases , the ratio of jet em luminosity to energy density in magnetic energy is @xmath1600.2 per time - unit . this similarity demonstrates that , for this topology at least , the properties of the funnel field depend primarily on the field strength within the initial accretion flow , and that funnel field creation is a primarily axisymmetric process . although the initial magnetic field had structure only on the scale of the disk thickness , the _ essentially laminar _ dynamics of initial inflow lead quickly to the formation of truly large - scale field . on the other hand , because the accretion flow takes longer to be established than the jet does , the magnetic field in the funnel acts in effect as a permanent boundary condition for the accretion flow . in other words , these simulations mimic the long - term behavior of an accretion flow in which there is large - scale net magnetic flux threading the event horizon and filling a cone around the axis , but no large - scale flux piercing the disk proper . as both the three - dimensional and two - dimensional simulations demonstrate , it is entirely possible for long - term quasi - stationary accretion to coexist with a strong poynting flux jet whose foundation is magnetic flux trapped long before . we next consider the evolution of an initial quadrupolar field in high resolution axisymmetry . figure [ qfpevln ] shows a time series of plots illustrating @xmath50 and the poloidal field line structure for this case . initially , the loops of weak poloidal magnetic field enclose two regions , located above and below the pressure maximum ( see figure [ topologies ] , center panel ) . in a similar fashion to the dipole case , these loops are sheared out , creating ever growing toroidal field and producing strong poloidal magnetic pressure gradients . in contrast to the dipole case , however , two current sheets are formed , one above the equatorial plane , one below . the magnetic pressure forces gas toward these current sheets , where the magnetic pressure has a local minimum . as the inner edge of the torus moves radially inward toward the black hole , the current sheets maintain their structure . when the field reaches the black hole , the current sheets are located above and below the equator . as with the dipole , gas drains off the field lines , which anchor themselves in the event horizon , and the field lines between the current sheets and the axis slide toward the poles , where the density and pressure are very low . these field lines expand outward relativistically , filling the funnel region and establishing a large - scale quadrupole field . while this field is in place it supports a poynting - flux jet , but the power in the jet is significantly less than that in the axisymmetric dipolar simulation . averaged from @xmath161 to @xmath162 , the em flux in the dipolar case is twice as strong as in the quadrupolar simulation when measured at @xmath126 , and 10 times stronger measured at @xmath152 ( we will discuss later why the contrast was more than an order of magnitude greater in the 3-d simulations ) . figure [ trtducomp ] compares the dipole jet poynting flux with that of the quadrupole simulation as a function of time at @xmath152 , normalized by the total magnetic field energy in the disk . in terms of this normalized power , the jet in the quadrupole simulation is a factor of 210 weaker than that associated with dipole model ; in other words , much of the actual power contrast between the dipolar and quadrupolar cases can be explained in terms of a reduction in this magnetic efficiency " . unlike the situation for accretion properties , contrasts in jet luminosity from one topology to another can not be described solely in terms of contrasts in mean magnetic field strength . @xcite reported that replacing the dipole with a quadrupole field led to a jet that is weaker by a factor of 23 , but for several reasons one should expect only qualitative , not quantitative agreement with our results . they measured the jet luminosity at @xmath163 and their initial pressure maximum was much closer to the black hole ( @xmath164 ) , so that the radial dynamic range of their genuine accretion flow was considerably smaller . their disk was also geometrically thicker , partly because their code solved a total energy equation , and partly because their initial state was hotter . simple geometry accounts for the qualitative contrast between the jet produced by an initially quadrupolar magnetic geometry and that driven by an initially dipolar field . in the quadrupolar case , relatively small amplitude vertical oscillations in the inner region of the accretion flow can lead to reconnection between magnetic field in the funnel and magnetic field in the disk because vertical field of both signs is available in the same hemisphere . the result is to break the magnetic connection between the black hole horizon and large radius . put another way , the presence of closed field loops on the same side of the equator offers the opportunity for easy collapse of these loops to zero . in the dipole case , however , the sign of the vertical magnetic field passing through the equator is the same everywhere inside @xmath165 . the net result of this geometric contrast is that , while quadrupolar field configurations can pump magnetic field into the outflow funnel and support a jet , they can also equally easily destroy such a jet by reconnection with oppositely - directed field . jets in this case are consequently very unsteady , and exhibit strong variability in the poynting flux , as shown in figure [ trtducomp ] . this variability is a major factor in depressing the time - averaged em luminosity of jets driven by quadrupolar fields . because the code simulates the equations of ideal mhd , reconnection is numerical and occurs at the grid scale . as such , the reconnection rate is resolution dependent ( lower resolution promotes reconnection ) . we can not therefore make specific predictions regarding the variability characteristics of jets in nature , as this is determined ( in our simulations at least ) by competition between processes that are physical in character ( e.g. , orbital dynamics , magnetic forces ) and purely numerical ( the reconnection rate ) . the rate of reconnection is also determined by details of the field geometry , in addition to its basic topology . to investigate this sort of dependence , we have conducted a series of lower resolution ( @xmath166 ) axisymmetric quadrupolar simulations in which we varied the size of the initial torus , and hence the scale of the initial field loops . we kept the inner edge of the torus fixed at @xmath83 , but reduced the angular momentum @xmath27 in order to reduce the vertical thickness of the torus , and consequently reduce the vertical extent of the quadrupolar loops . simulations were carried out for a variety of values of @xmath27 , ranging from @xmath167 to @xmath168 in steps of @xmath169 . for the purposes of our discussion here , we focus on the @xmath170 torus , which serves to illustrate the impact of vertical scale height on the evolution of the quadrupole topology . specifically , setting @xmath171 results in a torus which is initially a factor of two thinner ( in terms of the density scale height , measured along surfaces of constant radius at the location of the pressure maximum ) than the @xmath25 torus previously discussed . the vertical thickness of the resulting quadrupolar field loops is then very similar to that of loops in the sub - keplerian torus used in qdpa . the initial evolution of this system is shown in figure [ qnpevln ] . the evolution proceeds as before : current sheets form above and below the equatorial plane as the inner edge of the torus moves toward the black hole . this time , however , the two current sheets are much closer to the equatorial plane ( contrast fig . [ qnpevln ] with fig . [ qfpevln ] ) . around @xmath172 the current sheets buckle , apparently due to an instability , and the coherent poloidal field structure is destroyed . a similar phenomenon was observed in qdpa , which had a similar scale - height : the current sheets destabilized far from the black hole , destroying the coherent poloidal field structure . as a result , no large scale poloidal field was dragged into the near horizon region by the torus , and the resulting field inside the funnel region is substantially reduced . we note that in three - dimensions the presence of non - axisymmetric mri modes are likely to enhance the rate of reconnection , further decreasing the likelihood that an organized quadrupole configuration will survive to create a significant funnel field . these additional simulations show that the strength of poynting - dominated jets depends on field geometry in two senses : it is topology - dependent and shape - dependent . quadrupolar magnetic topology leads to easier reconnection , and therefore weaker funnel fields and jets , than does dipolar topology , and geometrically thinner quadrupole loops make reconnection still more rapid . we have shown how large dipolar loops can create strong jets , but what happens if the oppositely - directed vertical field on the far side of the loop is accreted ? this did not occur in kdpg , in part because it did not run long enough and in part because the finite mass in our torus meant that the matter outside the pressure maximum moves outward over time , not inward . in a real accretion disk , however , continuing mass re - supply will force the far sides of even large dipolar loops to accrete . to explore this sort of event , we ran a two - dimensional simulation whose initial state contained a series of four narrow dipolar loops ( described in [ numerics ] ) . the initial evolution of this topology is shown in figures [ mfpevln1 ] and [ mfpevln2 ] . the first of these figures shows the descent of the innermost radial loop into the near - horizon region and the establishment of a poynting flux jet . the second figure shows the descent of the second ( moving out in radius ) of these loops and its interaction with the field structures established by the first loop . over the timescale considered , the evolution of this model is determined by the two innermost loops , both initially inside the pressure maximum ( see fig . [ topologies ] ) . as for a single dipole loop , the first loop forms a funnel dipole field by @xmath173 . however , its shape differs significantly from the single loop because the second loop begins its descent toward the inner disk even before the inner edge of the first loop nears the event horizon ( fig . [ mfpevln1 ] ) . as the second loop moves inward , it displaces the field lines of the first loop , forcing the midplane portions of the outer half of the first loop inward , and the off - plane portions of the first loop to higher altitude at their original radius . the result is that the first loop is very nearly transformed into a pair of loops , one on each side of the midplane . after arriving in the inner disk , the field of the second loop expands rapidly toward the funnel region . it pushes on the almost closed sections of the first loop , triggering rapid reconnection where its oppositely - directed segments pass very close to one another at small radius ( fig . [ mfpevln2 ] ) . at this point , the transformation of the first loop into a disconnected quadrupolar loop pair is complete , and the loops fly off to large distance , emptying the funnel of magnetic field . the funnel is then refilled with flux from the second loop . these dramatic events are mirrored in the very large fluctuations in normalized poynting luminosity shown in figure [ trtducomp ] . jumps in output even greater in relative terms than those displayed by the quadrupolar simulation are frequent , and can be associated with these episodes of funnel field establishment and annihilation . note that while the multiple - loop jet is highly variable , similar to the quadrupolar jet , the instantaneous strength of the poynting - flux jet ( when it is strong ) is similar to that of model kdpg when normalized for disk magnetic field strength . in this sense , the efficiency " of these systems in using magnetic field generated in the disk for jets appears to be a function of poloidal field character , declining as the relative importance of higher multipole moments increases . in interpreting this simulation , it is important to bear in mind that , unlike any of the others reported in this paper , its accretion flow never achieves anything resembling a quasi - stationary state . the multiple loop structure also requires high resolution to prevent reconnection from occurring at too rapid a rate . it is for this reason that , unlike the large dipolar loop and quadrupolar caess , we report no 3-d simulation results for this field geometry . thus , we can be less confident than in the other cases that the specific phenomenology we observe may be associated with real systems in a state of continuing accretion . what it _ does _ demonstrate , however , is that accretion of a series of closed dipolar loops can lead to a sequence of field establishment and destruction rather similar to what was seen in the quadrupolar case , and through mechanisms that also resemble those seen when the initial field is quadrupolar . it also supports our qualitative inference that maintenance of a consistent sign of vertical field is essential to the long - term support of a poynting - dominated jet . the lifetime for an episode of strong outflow is roughly the inflow time for the outer anchor point of the loop . in the poloidal cases , magnetic field is injected into the funnel by strong toroidal field pressure in the plunging region . one might expect that this process could act equally efficiently when the magnetic field is toroidal from the start . if the toroidal field has a consistent sign , the radial component created when it expands outward would also have a consistent sign , satisfying the coherent vertical field criterion we have inferred from study of the poloidal simulations . if so , the toroidal field case should also drive a powerful jet . however , it does nothing of the sort . figures [ tdpevln1 ] [ tdpevln2 ] are a series of snapshots of the @xmath50 parameter and the radial field structure in the evolving torus of simulation tdpa . in contrast to the poloidal loop simulations , there is no initial radial field to generate toroidal field through shear . instead , the evolution is governed entirely by the development of the nonaxisymmetric mri . the fastest - growing modes for the mri in this context have large @xmath174 and azimuthal wavelength @xmath175 , which is much shorter than the disk thickness when the field is weak @xcite . the magnetic structures that develop are then predominantly on short lengthscales . note the rapid spatial variation in sign in the radial field in figure [ tdpevln2 ] . with time , the radial field features become somewhat more radially elongated , but field lines do not connect extended regions ; no large - scale coherent poloidal field is generated from the initial toroidal field . magnetic field amplification is less than in the poloidal field initial conditions , and @xmath50 never becomes less than 1 near the hole . matter tends to remain with the field rather than drain either into the hole or toward a localized region such as the equator , as seen in the dipole case . any vertical expansion of the field would therefore have to overcome the inertia of the matter and , as can be seen from figure [ tdpevln2 ] , this does not occur . the absence of a funnel - field in the toroidal topology follows directly from the specific properties of the toroidal field mri : the poloidal fields created by the mri are typically small scale . no radially - extended poloidal field connects the near horizon region to the disk . what radial field there is is accreted faster than it can tap into the differential rotation and generate strong near - hole fields . the main disk - body in the toroidal case remains gas pressure - dominated at all times , and there are no strong magnetic pressure gradients to drive an expansion of the field into the funnel region . the absence of a funnel field means there is no poynting flux jet . it appears , then , that creation of a strong funnel field , and therefore a strong poynting jet when the black hole spins rapidly , depends essentially on the existence of some coherent poloidal field in the initial state . purely toroidal field initial conditions can lead to short coherence - length poloidal loops with rapidly alternating sign , but no large - scale poloidal field components . through a series of numerical studies , we have examined the influence of the initial field topology on the properties of magnetized black hole accretion flows . in particular , we have performed full three - dimensional simulations of three different initial field topologies : a large - scale dipolar loop , a pair of quadrupolar loops separated by the equatorial plane , and a purely toroidal field . apart from the imposed initial field topologies , the initial conditions used in each of these simulations were identical : a @xmath176 hydrostatic torus with a slightly sub - keplerian distribution of angular momentum around a rotating ( @xmath177 ) black hole . the two poloidal field topologies were evolved to @xmath178 m , while the toroidal case was evolved to @xmath179 m . @xcite described the late - time structure of the resulting accretion flow in terms of distinct components : the main disk body , the coronal envelope , and an unbound outflow which itself could be separated into a matter - dominated funnel - wall jet and a poynting - flux jet in the funnel interior . we have found that the late - time averaged properties of the main disk body exhibit only modest quantitative contrasts attributable to different initial field topologies : the dipolar and quadrupolar cases are roughly similar , and both create somewhat stronger magnetic fields than the toroidal case . so long as there is some weak magnetic field present , the mri generates turbulence and drives accretion , although the character of the purely toroidal mri is somewhat different from that produced by poloidal fields . because the maxwell stress controls the surface density required to support a given accretion rate , and the cascade of energy to smaller scales in the mhd turbulence leads ultimately to disk heating , we expect that the radiation emitted by the disk will likewise be only weakly dependent on magnetic topology . it is possible that different magnetic topologies could produce different vertical profiles of dissipation ( which these simulations are not designed to study ) , but the similarity in magnetic pressure profiles ( fig . [ angcor ] ) suggests that even those differences are likely to be minor . in regard to the accretion flow , we found only two dependences on field topology worth noting : for fixed outer torus mass , the initial toroidal field simulation gives a somewhat lower accretion rate . in addition , the magnetic field in the plunging region is , in relative terms , somewhat stronger in the large dipolar loop case than for quadrupolar or toroidal fields , so that stresses near the isco are somewhat stronger when the field topology is dipolar . in other words , the short - wavelength behavior of the mri - driven mhd turbulence in the disk produces near - universal behavior , independent of magnetic field structure . jets are quite different . _ laminar _ flow dynamics can , given the right conditions ( e.g. , the right field topology ) , inflate field with no pre - existing structure on scales larger than a disk scale - height into a truly global field . simulations that begin with a large dipole loop in the initial torus produce a strong poynting - flux jet in the axial funnel and a comparably strong matter - dominated funnel - wall outflow . the inner field lines of the dipolar loop move quickly inward to fill the funnel , and remain there until the opposite side of the loop is accreted , an event which may not happen until quite a long time later . thus , this case mimics a situation in which net magnetic flux has been trapped against the black hole event horizon by previous accretion . when this trapped flux creates a coherent poloidal field in the funnel , the black hole s spin forces nearby field lines into rotation and drives a large outward - directed poynting flux . this sequence of events is not as easily achieved with any of the other field geometries we explored . unlike the dipole configuration , the quadrupole features a pair of current sheets located above and below the equator . these current sheets are subject to instabilities that can lead to reconnection in the magnetic field and loss of extended field coherence . even when the quadrupole is successful in establishing a funnel field , the jet may live only briefly because fluctuations in the accretion flow can generate reconnection events . by the same token , quadrupolar field can also restore field to an empty funnel . consequently , any jet based on quadrupolar field tends to be unstable and episodic , with the timescale and amplitude of changes set both by details of the field geometry and the rate of reconnection . unfortunately , it is very hard to obtain any information about the former in real systems , and in our simulations the latter is controlled by numerical effects and resolution , so it is impossible for us to make predictive statements about the timescale or amplitude of jet variability in this case . all of the models reported on above used a black hole with a spin @xmath180 . to test our conclusions against other black hole spins we also ran two three - dimensional initially quadrupolar simulations with black hole spins @xmath181 and , @xmath182 . the effect of a wide range of black hole spins ( including a counter - rotating hole ) on dipolar models was studied by @xcite . no poynting flux jet is present for a schwarzschild hole regardless of the initial field topology . the energy to drive the poynting flux originates with the spin of the hole . however , the funnel is still filled with radial field , which is considerably stronger in the dipole case compared to the quadrupole . on the other hand , the funnel field strength increases with black hole spin for a given field topology . for the rapidly - spinning hole , the poynting flux jet is stronger than in the @xmath121 simulations for both topologies , but as we have discussed , it is considerably weaker when the initial field is quadrupolar than when it is dipolar . specifically , the ratio between the time - averaged poynting luminosity with dipolar field to the poynting luminosity with quadrupolar field is @xmath183 for @xmath184 and @xmath185 for @xmath121 . thus , the accretion dynamics control what sort of field is brought to the vicinity of the black hole and fill the funnel , and the black hole spin determines how energetic the resulting jet is . the purely toroidal field topology does not generate any jet at all . the only way for toroidal field to create any poloidal field is by initiating non - axisymmetric perturbations of alternating sign . the lengthscales of these perturbations must be relatively short , and the portions of opposite sign must balance in magnitude . fields of this sort can do very little to fill the funnel region because they are even more subject to reconnection than is the quadrupolar field . when the initial field is a single dipolar loop that wraps around the initial pressure maximum of the simulation , all the vertical field brought down to the funnel by the initial accretion has the same direction . in real disks containing closed dipolar loops , oppositely directed vertical field will , sooner or later , arrive in the inner disk , and it may cancel the funnel field . to investigate this possibility , we ran a high - resolution axisymmetric simulation that began with four narrow dipolar loops within the initial torus . its subsequent evolution qualitatively supports this conjecture . the innermost loop produces a funnel field as in the single dipole loop model . when the second loop , oriented oppositely from the first one , descends , it displaces the field established by the first loop . the funnel field established by the first loop reconnects , detaches from the event horizon , and is rapidly expelled from the grid . the second loop then expands poloidally and reestablishes the funnel field . in other words , the accretion of dipolar field loops leads to jet creation , but its structure is highly - variable : the narrower the dipolar loops present in the accretion flow , the more variability we can expect in the jet . when a simulation is initialized with ( possibly multiple ) dipolar field loop(s ) that cross the equatorial plane , the strength of the resulting poynting - flux jet depends on the strength of the magnetic field within the disk itself and on the spin of the hole . poynting - flux jets that are formed from quadrupolar fields are generically much weaker than their dipolar counterparts , even when magnetic field strength in the disk body is taken into account . how much weaker depends on other factors as well , including disk thickness , location of the inner edge of the initial torus , and numerical resolution . in the limited range of numerical experiments reported here , we have seen suppression factors ranging from several to several hundred . real accretion flows are likely to have a mixture , possibly time - varying , of all these field topologies . real jets from black holes will exhibit behavior combining the sorts of events we have seen in this paper : stability over longer timescales when the field is mostly made of large dipolar loops , greater variability and occasional jet quenching when the field has a larger contribution from higher multipoles , jet elimination when the field is mostly toroidal . it is possible that in addition to the sort of coherent funnel field spontaneously created by large closed - loop poloidal structures , there is a large - scale field imposed by external boundary conditions . we plan to investigate the impact of such an externally - imposed field in future work . this study is only one small step in the process of exploring the mechanisms to create large scale field configurations within accretion flows . here the large scale field formation process we have observed results from an interaction between poloidal field components in the accretion flow and the boundary represented by the black hole . the mechanism operates in axisymmetry as well as in three dimensions , so it is not a dynamo if that word is defined as in the antidynamo theorem . many authors have conjectured that an inverse cascade within the three dimensional turbulent disk itself might generate large scale fields ; we see no evidence in these simulations of any disk field with structure on scales more than a few scale - heights , but we caution that the resolution limitations of three dimensional global simulations make this observation less than definitive . the results we have reported also stimulate speculations about whether the contrasts in jet phenomenology from one object , or class of objects , to another is due in part to differences in the mixture of different field topologies , or the interaction of different topologies in the flow . for example , could the jet outbursts sometimes seen in galactic black hole binaries when they cross the jet line " @xcite be due to rapid field annihilation and loop expulsion of the sort observed in the multiple dipolar loop simulation ? perhaps the radio - weakness of most agn ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) is due to the predominance of small - scale multipolar field in their accretion flows as a result of accreting from a turbulent interstellar medium ? as we learn more about how it acts , we may find that magnetic topology can , in fact , be inferred from phenomenology . surface normalized to the total magnetic field strength within the disk for simulation kdpg ( black lines ) and the high resolution axisymmetric simulation of the dipole ( magenta line).,scaledwidth=50.0% ] surface normalized by the total magnetic field strength within the disk . the kdpg dipole simulation is shown in black , the quadrupole simulation in blue , and the multiple loop simulation is green.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: since the prediction of keldysh and kopaev , @xcite there has been a long and intense pursuit to realise a condensed phase in solid state excitonic , and related , systems . in particular , polaritons in semiconductor microcavities , the coupled eigenstates of an exciton with a cavity photon , @xcite represent ideal candidates for observing condensation phenomena . the very light mass of these composite bosonic particles promises relatively high transition temperatures . in the past decade , improvements in the growth technology of semiconductor heterostructures have made the study of high - quality strongly - coupled planar microcavities almost routine for iii - v and ii - vi semiconductors . the high degree of external control of these systems , and the possibility of direct detection for them has opened the route towards a new generation of fast optical matter - wave lasers and amplifiers . @xcite more recently , concerted experimental efforts have been devoted to the realisation of a bose - einstein condensate of microcavity polaritons . @xcite on the experimental side , a challenge to the realisation of a condensed polariton phase might be represented by the finite quality of the cavity mirrors and the resultant short polariton lifetime , of the order of picoseconds . in addition , due to the ` bottleneck effect ' , @xcite the relaxation of polaritons to the zero momentum state can be delayed , hindering the creation of a thermal population in the lowest energy state . it has however been recently shown @xcite that thermalization processes due to particle - particle scattering can be dramatically magnified by increasing the value of the ( non - resonant ) pump power , and by positively detuning the cavity energy above the excitonic energy . under these conditions , the progress towards a zero momentum quasi - equilibrium condensate has been significant , @xcite including a non - linear threshold behaviour in the emission intensity at zero momentum , @xcite the investigation of the second order coherence function , @xcite a characteristic change in the momentum space distribution above threshold , @xcite and evidence that the equilibration time is shorter than the polariton lifetime has been seen . @xcite finally , very recently , a clear demonstration of condensation of cavity polaritons has been demonstrated in cdte . @xcite kasprzak and collaborators have shown that condensation of equilibrated polaritons can be achieved for effective temperatures around @xmath0k and evidence for condensation has been seen in the occupation function , the first order coherence ( both in time and in space ) and in the spontaneous appearance of linear polarisation of the condensate emission . alongside the experimental effort , a significant theoretical effort has been invested in analysing properties and predicting signatures of polariton condensation . @xcite much of this work focuses on modelling the conditions under which condensation can occur , both in equilibrium , @xcite and considering the effects of pumping and decay . @xcite possible signatures include the nonlinear relation of emission at zero momentum to pumping power , @xcite changes to the linewidth , @xcite the pl spectrum and the angular distribution of radiation , @xcite and spontaneous polarisation of emitted radiation . @xcite in this paper , we discuss the optical properties of condensed polaritons , focusing our interests on absorption , photoluminescence ( pl ) and resonant rayleigh scattering ( rrs ) . from our study we conclude that rrs , the coherent scattering by disorder of polaritons into directions other than that of the original probe , represents a powerful tool for investigating the condensed phase . we will show that signatures of condensation are visible in the rrs spectrum , allowing a direct probe of the collective excitation properties of the polariton condensate . in particular , we will show that , above the threshold for condensation , strong emission from the collective sound mode both above and below the chemical potential can be seen in the rrs spectra ( see fig . [ fig : rrsca ] ) . in contrast such features are expected to be much harder to observe in usual pl emission spectra , where the spectrum is dominated by the very strong condensate emission at the chemical potential , which is likely to mask these more subtle features . in addition , we will show that the rrs spectra directly reflects the disorder averaged density of states of excitonic particle - hole like excitations , i.e. bound excitons coupled to the coherent photon field . for @xmath1 as a function of the dimensionless momentum @xmath2 and rescaled energy @xmath3 , for zero detuning , rabi splitting @xmath4mev , temperature @xmath5k , and a disorder strength characterize by an inverse scattering time @xmath6mev . ( a ) non - condensed regime ( dimensionless density @xmath7 ) ; ( b ) condensed regime ( @xmath8 ) ; ( c ) condensed regime ( @xmath9 ) . ( the parameters chosen for these plots are the same as those used later for spectral weight and photoluminescence . ) the value of the chemical potential is explicitly marked [ horizontal green ( gray ) line ] . while in the non - condensed regime , rrs emission is always above the chemical potential , in the condensed phase , emission from the collective sound mode is seen both above and below the chemical potential . ] resonant rayleigh scattering depends on disorder to scatter polaritons between momentum states . in order to carry on our analysis , we introduce a realistic description of disorder and analyse its effects on rrs and more generally on other optical probes , like absorption and pl . to do this , we make use of a quantitatively accurate model for exciton disorder , @xcite and numerically evaluate the distribution of excitonic energies and oscillator strengths associated with a given disorder potential . an accurate treatment of exciton disorder for quantum wells in microcavities is important because the large ratio of exciton mass to photon mass means that those exciton states contributing most to the thermally populated polaritons are strongly localised , i.e. can not be treated within the first born approximation . such a treatment shows that , for a given exciton energy and momentum , there is still a distribution of possible oscillator strengths . for the exciton states relevant to polariton formation , the distribution of oscillator strengths varies from a narrow gaussian at low energies ( below the band edge ) to a porter - thomas distribution at high energies , as is known from previous works . @xcite here , we study the effect of this distribution on the many - body physics , and in particular , on rrs and pl spectra . in this paper , we consider the case relevant to the existing cdte or gaas microcavities of high - quality quantum wells , where the typical excitonic disorder amplitude is smaller than the rabi splitting . in this regime , we can make use of the _ coupled oscillator model _ or wave vector conserving approximation , as explained in ref . . as will be explained in more detail later on , this corresponds to approximating the full exciton green s function by its momentum - diagonal part ( or equivalently considering its disorder average ) , and treating perturbatively the off - diagonal terms . in this way , the translational invariance broken by the presence of the disorder is restored , polaritons have a defined wave vector and , at high enough densities , condense in the lowest momentum state . such a treatment implies that excitonic disorder , being on short length scales , does not lead to spatial inhomogeneity on the length scale associated with the polariton . extended polaritons are formed from a superposition of many localised excitons , therefore recovering translational invariance at the level of polaritons . at low densities , in the non - condensed state , many observable properties can be adequately described by the coupled oscillator model and so can be found from the mean squared oscillator strength at a given energy . in this limit our method recovers the well known results for the inhomogeneous broadening of the polariton pl , @xcite and by considering in addition the mean fourth power of the oscillator strength the averaged rrs response . @xcite however , when condensed , there are observable effects associated with the full distribution of oscillator strengths . in particular , the non - vanishing probability of excitons to have arbitrarily small oscillator strengths has direct consequences for optical probes , including both rrs and pl . in ref . , we considered specific aspects of resonant rayleigh scattering arising from the model discussed in this paper . here , we provide and compare further experimental probes of condensation , and discuss the underlying physical mechanisms involved . all these optical probes , including rrs , are in addition to a non - resonant pumping of the microcavity polaritons . a related problem is studied in ref . . there , the rayleigh scattering of a strong resonant pump is considered ( treating disorder perturbatively ) , thus the probe is the pump . in this paper , in contrast , one has to distinguish two types of coherence . the first type is the internal coherence of the condensed system , which arises spontaneously following non - resonant pumping . the second type is the coherent scattering of an external laser probe on disorder , which can be strongly modified by the presence of the condensate . the form of the density of states , optical density , and distribution of oscillator strengths found from the numerical calculations are also important in other thermodynamic properties and probes of polaritons . one such example is the calculation of the linear blue - shift vs. density in the low density regime . the inclusion of exciton states that couple weakly to photons extends the validity of the current model to densities beyond those in similar treatments , @xcite and provides a stronger basis for the use of those models in the regimes where they are valid . the paper is arranged in the following sections : we describe the effect of quantum well disorder on the exciton oscillator strength in sec . [ sec : disor ] . there , we also give details of the numerical analysis ( sec . [ sec : numer ] ) , which will be used in the many - body model introduced in sec . [ sec : model ] to describe the thermodynamics of polariton condensation ( sec . [ sec : phase ] ) . section [ sec : photo ] describes the optical probes such as spectral weight and photoluminescence ( sec . [ sec : spect ] ) and resonant rayleigh scattering ( sec . [ sec : rrsca ] ) . conclusions are collected in sec . [ sec : concl ] , while appendix [ sec : phase - sens - detect ] explains how one can detect rrs using phase sensitive measurements . the problem of an exciton in a disordered quantum well has been studied at some length in the last two decades . @xcite quantum well disorder can arise due to interface and alloy fluctuations and affects the properties of the excitonic linewidth and absorption spectrum . similarly to refs . , we will assume the external disorder potential to be correlated on a length scale larger than the exciton bohr radius . accordingly , we factorise the excitonic in - plane relative and centre of mass coordinates @xmath10 and assume that the disorder affects only the excitonic centre of mass motion @xmath11 , while the internal degrees of freedom can be restricted to the ground state hydrogenic state @xmath12 . here , @xmath13 is the exciton bohr radius and @xmath14 the reduced mass ( henceforth we will set @xmath15 ) . neglecting the transverse degrees of freedom related to the confinement of the excitons in the qw , the energy associated to the wavefunction @xmath16 is given by the sum of the relative motion energy @xmath17 [ i.e. , the band gap minus the exciton binding energy , @xmath18 and the energy related to the centre of mass motion @xmath19 : @xmath20 \phi_{\alpha } ( { { \mathbf r } } ) = \varepsilon_{\alpha } \phi_{\alpha } ( { { \mathbf r}})\ ; . \label{eq : centr}\ ] ] here , the effective disorder potential @xmath21 represents the microscopic structural disorder averaged over the electron - hole motion . @xcite this can be approximated , e.g. , with a gaussian noise correlated on a length scale @xmath22 with variance equal to @xmath23 : @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the quantisation area . it will be convenient , later on , to introduce the scattering time @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the two - dimensional density of states in the clean limit . in two dimensional non - interacting systems , all states are localised by the disorder potential . however , the localisation length and the character of the excitonic wavefunction change significantly from below to above the band edge @xmath17 . well below the band edge , low - energy lifshitz tail states , @xcite are well localised in deep potential minima , with a nodeless ( roughly gaussian ) shape . these states are rare , because they occur due to large , rare , fluctuations of the disorder potential . in contrast , higher energy states above the band edge have a fractal - like shape with many nodes and can be approximated by a random superposition of plane waves with the same momentum @xmath28 . here , the localisation mechanism is closely related to quantum mechanical interference effects . accordingly , the change of the shape of the centre of mass wavefunctions across the band edge is accompanied by a dramatic change in the excitonic oscillator strength . @xcite the oscillator strength describing coupling of a quantum well exciton to light , @xmath29 , is given by the probability amplitude of finding an electron and a hole at the same position and with centre of mass momentum equal to the photon momentum @xmath30 and is therefore proportional to the fourier transform of the centre of mass wave function , @xmath31 : @xmath32 where , @xmath33 is the dipole matrix element . the dispersion for photons in a microcavity of width @xmath34 is given by @xmath35 , where @xmath36 , and can be approximated , for small momenta , by a parabolic dispersion @xmath37 , with the photon mass given by @xmath38 . because there may be many different exciton wavefunctions corresponding to similar exciton energies , the oscillator strength @xmath39 is a random quantity , which varies both in phase and magnitude . considering many disorder realisations , we find a distribution of squared oscillator strengths , @xmath40 as a function of the energy @xmath19 and momentum @xmath30 . this distribution reflects the statistical properties of the centre of mass excitonic wave functions . to compare to experimentally relevant observables , we introduce the density of states ( dos ) , @xmath41 and the mean squared oscillator strength : @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the average over different disorder realisations . these quantities are related to the excitonic optical density by the relation : @xmath44 experimentally , the excitonic optical density can be measured by dividing the pl emission by the excitonic occupation . @xcite focusing for the moment on average properties , rather than on the entire distribution , a simple expression exists for the mean squared oscillator strength in the high energy limit . in this limit , where the dos is flat and energy independent , @xmath45 , making use of the born approximation , the squared average oscillator strength @xmath46 does not depend separately on the disorder potential correlation length @xmath47 and variance @xmath48 , but instead only on the scattering time @xmath49 ( see fig . [ fig : gepsp ] ) : @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the free particle dispersion . from this form , and the effectively constant density of states , one can see that both the mean squared oscillator strength and the excitonic optical density are symmetrical . the comparison of this approximate form to the numerical simulation is shown in fig . [ fig : gepsp ] , in contrast , for energies much below the band edge , the specific asymptotic expression of @xmath46 depends whether the correlation length @xmath47 is smaller or larger than the localisation length @xmath52 . in the white noise limit,@xcite @xmath53 , one can show that the centre of mass wavefunction @xmath11 can be approximated by a gaussian centred at a randomly distributed site @xmath54 , @xmath55 and therefore giving a squared oscillator strength proportional to : @xmath56 thus , here the distribution of squared oscillator strengths is very narrow , with a mean square value given by the above form . similarly , much theoretical ( and numerical ) work has been done to establish the energy dependence of the density of states . in the low energy tail , as before , the specific asymptotic form of the dos depends on the value of the correlation length @xmath47 . in the white noise limit , one can show that @xmath57 , while , in the opposite ( classical ) limit , @xmath58 , instead one has @xmath59 ( see , e.g. , ref . ) . in general , for the finite values of the disorder correlation length corresponding to typical experiments , the regions in energy where one of these two analytical regimes apply are very restricted , and therefore a numerical analysis is required . numerical analysis is also essential in order to account for the distribution of squared oscillator strengths @xmath60 near the band edge . this distribution changes substantially from low energy states to high energy ones . as we discuss more in detail in the next section , for high energy states the oscillator strength distribution is governed by a porter - thomas law , while for lifshitz tail states the distribution follows a narrow gaussian - like distribution . neither of these distributions apply for energies around the band edge . however , it is states near the band edge that have the largest optical density , and so the distribution of oscillator strengths in this region has a significant impact on derived quantities . it thus becomes essential to use numerical analysis to find the entire distribution of oscillator strengths . to photons of momentum @xmath61 ( a ) ( from ref . , for comparison ) and @xmath62 ( b ) , where all exciton states found numerically . results are taken from 160 different realizations of disorder potential , and for ( b ) , coupling strengths from eight different photon momenta @xmath63 with the same value of @xmath64 are combined . the mean squared averaged oscillator strength @xmath65 for the same value of momentum [ lower red ( gray ) points ] and the density of states @xmath66 [ upper green ( gray ) points ] are also explicitly plotted . inset : fit of @xmath67 to the expression with a renormalized energy @xmath68 . ] to photons of momentum @xmath61 ( a ) ( from ref . , for comparison ) and @xmath62 ( b ) , where all exciton states found numerically . results are taken from 160 different realizations of disorder potential , and for ( b ) , coupling strengths from eight different photon momenta @xmath63 with the same value of @xmath64 are combined . the mean squared averaged oscillator strength @xmath65 for the same value of momentum [ lower red ( gray ) points ] and the density of states @xmath66 [ upper green ( gray ) points ] are also explicitly plotted . inset : fit of @xmath67 to the expression with a renormalized energy @xmath68 . ] versus energy and momentum [ or equivalently angle @xmath69 . note that the scale in angle is not linear . the free particle dispersion @xmath70 [ solid green ( gray ) line ] , and the a trace of the mean squared oscillator strength for two representative values of momenta , @xmath71 ( @xmath72 ) and @xmath73 ( @xmath74 ) [ red ( gray ) plus symbols ] are explicitly plotted ( cf fig . [ fig : gepsp ] ) . the figure is adapted from ref . . ] to solve eq . , we exactly diagonalise this problem within a finite basis set , using conjugate - gradient minimisation with pre - conditioning of the steepest descent wavevector ( for a detailed discussion of this method , see ref . ) . we find the exact eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in a finite basis on a grid of @xmath75 points for a system of size @xmath76 m , @xmath77mev , @xmath78 and excitonic mass @xmath79 . these parameters give an inverse scattering time of @xmath80mev . for this choice of the grid , one can show that convergence is reached . from the evaluated eigenvalues @xmath81 and eigenstates @xmath82 over 160 realisations of the disorder potential , we can derive the excitonic density of states , the oscillator coupling strength and its squared average , eq . , which we plot in figs . [ fig : gepsp ] , and [ fig : geps2 ] , while the corresponding optical density is plotted in fig . [ fig : optic ] . the lower panel of fig . [ fig : gepsp ] shows the squared coupling strength @xmath60 versus energy for a fixed value of momentum , @xmath83 , corresponding , for a cavity of @xmath84ev , to an angle of @xmath85 . note that , because of the presence of disorder in the quantum well , one photon with a given momentum couples with many exciton states with different energies . we will see later on therefore that a polariton with a given momentum is formed by the superposition of one photon state @xmath86 and many exciton states @xmath87 . these states are more or less strongly coupled depending on the distribution of oscillator strength for that given momentum . as fig . [ fig : gepsp ] shows , by probing a quantum well at a large angle , i.e. with high momenta photons , the excited excitons with larger oscillator strength are the ones which are almost - delocalised in nature and with a many - node fractal - like shape . by taking the average over many ( 160 ) disorder realisations , the squared average oscillator strength @xmath65 shown in the inset in fig . [ fig : gepsp ] is well described by the lorentzian shape predicted by the born approximation of eq . , with a fitted width of @xmath88mev in good agreement with the theoretical value @xmath80mev . however , the peak of the lorentzian does not coincide with the energy of the clean limit , @xmath68 , but is renormalised down in value , as can be shown by employing a self - consistent born approximation . in contrast , as shown in the upper panel of fig . [ fig : gepsp ] , for photons with zero momentum , the maximum value of the oscillator strength characterises excitonic states below the band edge which are more localised in nature . this can be easily understood by the following qualitative argument : at very low energies , the excitonic state is strongly localised in a deep potential minimum and has no nodes . increasing the energy , at first the localisation length increases [ e.g. , @xmath89 in the white noise limit ] and thus increases the oscillator strength . however , eventually , the wavefunction starts developing nodes and consequently the squared average oscillator strength decreases . when @xmath90 , only the high energy side of @xmath91 can be described by the born limit . for the chosen values of the disorder potential correlation length @xmath47 and variance @xmath48 , an analytical expression for the low energy ( lifshitz ) tail is not known . the crossover from localised to more plane - wave - like excitonic states obtained by increasing the value of the photon momentum is plotted in fig . [ fig : geps2 ] . at high momenta , the maximum of the squared average oscillator strength @xmath65 shown in fig . [ fig : geps2 ] follows the free particle dispersion , plus a renormalisation down in energy , which decreases for higher photon momenta , i.e. these states are described well by free particles , including disorder in the first born approximation . at low momenta , the states which have the stronger oscillator strength are effectively localised . the crossover , as seen in the contour plot , happens at relatively large angle , @xmath92 , because of the large ratio of exciton to photon mass : the crossover momentum is set by exciton mass , but its conversion to an angle depends on effective photon mass . for a connected reason , the thermally populated polariton states are formed out of strongly localised ( i.e. beyond first born approximation ) excitonic states : for values of temperature and photon mass relevant for experiments , thermal population of polaritons extends up to around @xmath93 in momentum , which as seen in fig . [ fig : geps2 ] corresponds to exciton states not accurately described by the born approximation . for this reason , in the following we will concentrate on the oscillator strength corresponding to @xmath94 , @xmath95 . mev and the fwhm @xmath96mev . ] finally we plot in fig . [ fig : optic ] the optical density . for the chosen values of @xmath47 and @xmath48 , the optical density shows a maximum around @xmath97mev below the band edge , a full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of approximatively @xmath96mev and a clear asymmetry of the line - shape . it is well known @xcite that , by indicating with @xmath98 the confinement energy of the lowest state in a typical potential minimum , the excitonic line shape is determined by the ratio @xmath99 and , for a finite value of this , the optical density develops an asymmetry towards higher energies . for our choices of parameters , @xmath100 . asymmetry of the optical density of quantum well excitons has been also measured experimentally ( see , e.g. , ref . ) , by dividing the measured pl by the excitonic occupation . as mentioned earlier , the full distribution of oscillator strengths , and not just its mean squared value will be important . it is useful to discuss here some technical details of how this is extracted . the numerical analysis provides the excitonic eigenvalues and eigenstates only within a finite interval in energy . ( the lowest energy states arise from rare potential fluctuations , which would require a larger region of space to be sampled ; the highest energy states have spatial variation on lengthscales finer than our grid . ) within the interval of energies found , averages are performed making use of the raw data coming from 160 realisations of the disorder potential ; outside this interval , averages are taken by extrapolating the numerics . in particular , in the low energy lifshitz tail , as the oscillator strengths have a narrow gaussian distribution around its squared averaged value , we approximate the distribution of @xmath95 with a delta function at its extrapolated value @xmath101 . in the very high energy region , instead , we make use of the porter - thomas distribution , @xmath102}{\sqrt{2 \pi x \bar{x } } } } \ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath103 , again extrapolating the fitted value for the squared averaged oscillator strength . in addition , we fix the overall scale of @xmath95 to match integrated optical intensity with half the experimentally measured rabi splitting @xmath104 squared : @xmath105 this normalisation accounts for factors other than the wavefunction in eq . ( [ eq : oscil ] ) . having described the effect of quantum well disorder on the energies of excitons and on their dipole coupling to the cavity photons , we will next introduce the many - body hamiltonian that will allow us to describe a system of thermalized interacting polaritons which , for a given density and temperature , can condense to a superfluid phase . the hamiltonian describing a model of excitons with random energies @xmath19 , corresponding to the centre of mass eigenstate from eq . , dipole coupled to a cavity mode can be written as @xmath106 the description of exciton - exciton interaction in this model is somewhat simplified : it imposes the constraint that two excitons can not occupy the same energy level @xmath19 , because of their composite fermionic nature . this constraint is implemented by representing each energy level [ where energy levels are distributed according to the density of states , @xmath66 ] by two possible states , respectively @xmath108 and @xmath109 . these two states are then represented by occupation of two fermionic states , so that the ground state @xmath110 , and an excitonic state @xmath111 , eliminates the unphysical states @xmath112 and @xmath113 . in this way saturation effects are introduced to all orders . note that these fermionic operators @xmath114 can not be written as a linear combination of free electron and hole operators this is a result of having already included the intra - exciton coulomb interaction . the transition matrix element between a photon state @xmath115 and an exciton state , @xmath116 , is given by @xmath29 from eq . and evaluated numerically , as explained in the previous section . it is convenient to rescale this coupling according to @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the inverse level spacing @xmath119 , measured in units of the excitonic rydberg energy . this corresponds to measuring the density of particles per bohr radius squared . using these units , we may write the total number of excitations @xmath120 n a dimensionless form by introducing a dimensionless density of particles @xmath121 , or equivalently @xmath122 , where @xmath123 is the physical areal density of particles . and thermal occupation factor [ red ( gray ) line starting at top left ] for @xmath124mev and @xmath125k . ] in the limit of vanishing density , our occupancy constraint has no effect , and so this description is equivalent to one treating excitons as bosons . as will be shown later , in sec . [ sec : blues ] , for low densities , our occupancy constraint is also equivalent to a model of excitons as bosons , but with some effective saturation interaction . thus , as in the bosonic case , saturation effects are linear @xcite and the blue - shift increases linearly in density . there is however an important difference to those previous works . in contrast to the clean systems studied there , our effective saturation interaction has a coefficient related to disorder and temperature rather than to the rabi splitting and bohr radius only . however , increasing the density , saturation effects , and thus the underlying fermionic degrees of freedom become more and more important , and the conventional linear treatment becomes inadequate . in our treatment saturation effects are introduced exactly and taken into account to all orders . our model is accurate as far as the occupancy is restricted to the strongly localised lifshitz states in the tail below the band edge ( see fig . [ fig : occup ] ) . all the results described here respect this limit . one can moreover show that it is this density regime which is relevant for on - going experiments in cdte . @xcite higher energy states , beyond the lifshitz tail , contribute to the optical response , however they are only weakly occupied , and so the above limit remains valid . what the model eq . does not include is the coulomb interaction between excitons with different energies @xmath19 , i.e. , at low densities , on different localisation sites @xmath54 . this contribution is expected to be small in the low density regime . this low density regime will be observed all the way through this paper . at the same time we are not including double - occupancy of a single exciton energy level , which could be important at higher densities . in the following , we will make extensive use of the numerical analysis of oscillator strength distributions explained in the previous section . let us note here again that in the non - condensed regime , the full distribution is unnecessary the excitonic optical density is sufficient to derive the polariton dispersion and its inhomogeneous broadening . however , in the condensed phase , and in order to correctly describe resonant rayleigh scattering mechanisms , we will see that it is of fundamental importance to consider the entire distribution of oscillator strength . we consider a thermal equilibrium system of polaritons , as describing the situation with non - resonant pumping and strong thermalization processes . this limit has been recently demonstrated to be accessible in on - going experiments . @xcite the total density of polaritons is fixed by introducing a chemical potential @xmath126 . making use of standard path integral techniques and of the grand canonical ensemble , @xmath127 , we integrate over the fermionic fields , and thus write the partition function @xmath128 $ ] , with @xmath129 , in terms of the following imaginary time action : @xmath130 = \int_0^\beta d\tau \sum_{{{\mathbf p } } } \psi_{{{\mathbf p}}}^ * \left(\partial_\tau + \tilde{\omega}_{{{\mathbf p}}}\right ) \psi_{{{\mathbf p } } } - \operatorname{tr}\ln g^{-1 } \ ; . \label{eq : actio}\ ] ] here , @xmath131 is the , energy level diagonal , inverse single - particle green s function : @xmath132 where @xmath133 and @xmath134 are respectively the excitonic and photonic energies measured with respect to the chemical potential . within this path integral formulation , it is possible to show @xcite that the constraint on the site occupation can be taken into account elegantly by shifting the fermionic matsubara frequencies according to @xmath135 which we will assume from here on in . we will see later in section [ sec : photo ] how the formation of polaritons , the result of strong coupling between photons and excitons , influences the optical response and in particular how the optical response is affected when the system enters a condensed phase . this section will discuss the mean - field equations , and resultant phase diagram ; however first we wish to stress an important point . as observed previously , the relevant polariton states form from the mixing of a photon with a given momentum to many localised excitonic states with different energies . the strength of this mixing is determined by the distribution of oscillator strengths . although the quantum well excitons may be disorder - localised , for a weak disorder potential , with @xmath136 , and in the absence of strong photon disorder ( which in some cases can also be relevant @xcite ) the resultant polaritons are delocalised . as such , polaritons will be described by a momentum quantum number , and condense , as in the usual picture , in the lowest momentum state . the static and uniform minimum @xmath137 of the action can be found from the equation of motion , or saddle - point equation , which has to be solved together with the mean - field equation for the total number of excitations : @xmath138\ ; . \label{eq : homo2}\end{gathered}\ ] ] here , the spectrum of particle - hole excitations , i.e. the quasi - particle spectrum discussed later , is controlled by the energy of an exciton in presence of a coherent photon field @xmath139 , and is given by : @xmath140 in the following , we will solve simultaneously these coupled equations , both above ( @xmath141 ) and below ( @xmath142 ) the critical temperature for condensation . it is interesting to compare these with similar equations which have been already considered , e.g. , in the bcs theory of superconductivity , @xcite or in models describing gases of fermionic atoms close to a feshbach resonance.@xcite considering particularly the case of feshbach resonance , the density of particles is typically kept fixed , while the interaction strength can be varied externally to span across a bec condensate of tightly bound fermionic molecules and a bcs state of loosely bound fermionic pairs . in our case , two main important differences arise . firstly , density is the parameter which is changed . secondly , the coupling strength of excitons with cavity light depends on the excitonic energy . there is a wide variety of behaviour that can come from these coupled equations and , controlled by the distribution of oscillator strengths and by changing the density of states . by solving the ` gap equation ' eq . in the limit @xmath143 , let us concentrate for the moment on the critical temperature @xmath144 as a function of the chemical potential @xmath126 , forgetting about the corresponding excitation density . at the phase boundary , where @xmath145 , in contrast to inside the condensed phase , the squared oscillator strength appears only linearly in eq . , this expression therefore involving only the optical density @xmath146 . it is clear that the standard bcs result can be thought of as a limiting case where the effective optical density is much wider than the temperature . @xcite in the opposite limit , of a narrow delta - like optical density , one can solve the gap equation analytically . @xcite by taking into account the density equation , the critical temperature can be expressed as a function of the excitation density rather than as a function of the chemical potential . in the standard bcs theory there is no modulation of the interaction strength and therefore no difference between optical density @xmath146 and density of states @xmath66 . in our system instead one has to introduce separately both quantities , and further a realistic description of the dos is required in order to measure the density in physical units . in previous treatments , @xcite where the dos has been attributed an arbitrary gaussian - like shape ( and moreover where the coupling strength was kept fixed ) , the density was measured in arbitrary units . note however that , the fact that the density of states asymptotes to a constant at large densities , and the presence of those exciton states that couple only weakly to light , is responsible only for the asymptotic form of the phase boundary at large densities ( well beyond the range shown in fig . [ fig : criti ] and beyond the validity of our model ) . at smaller densities , such states have a little effect on the phase boundary . in order to calculate the phase boundary using our numerically calculated distributions , we will solve eq . ( [ eq : homo1 ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : homo2 ] ) numerically . how the disorder averaged sums in these equations are to be evaluated has been discussed sec . [ sec : numer ] . versus the dimensionless density @xmath147 for effective zero detuning @xmath148mev ( @xmath149 is the energy at which the excitonic optical density has its maximum , and so as seen in fig . [ fig : optic ] , @xmath150 implies @xmath151mev ) ( solid black ) and for positive detuning @xmath152mev ( @xmath153mev ) ( dotted - dashed black ) and @xmath4mev . the mean - field boundaries for the two different detunings are cut - off by the expected linear dependence of the critical temperature , as indicated at extremely low densities [ orange ( gray ) solid and dotted - dashed lines ] . the horizontal dashed line marks the temperature of @xmath125k which will be used in later figures . ] the critical temperature @xmath144 at which the system , for a given density , goes from a non - condensed phase to a condensed phase , is plotted in fig . [ fig : criti ] for two different values of the detuning @xmath154 , where @xmath149 is the energy at which the excitonic optical density has its maximum ( see fig . [ fig : optic ] ) . it is clear that increasing the detuning of the cavity mode above the excitonic one decreases the overall photonic fraction and therefore decreases the value of the critical temperature at a given density of excitations . conversely , if one fixes temperature , the critical density for condensation is higher for larger detuning , as fig . [ fig : criti ] clearly shows . this dependence is easy to understand in the extremely low density limit , where the critical temperature varies linearly with density , and is inversely proportional to the polariton mass : by increasing the detuning , the polariton mass also increases . having discussed the thermodynamics via the mean - field equations , we now turn in the rest of this paper to the analysis of the optical responses and probes of microcavities , both below and above threshold for condensation , with particular emphasis on the resonant rayleigh scattering emission . such optical responses are described by considering fluctuations about the mean - field theory outlined in this section . the spectrum of these fluctuations , and the various optical response functions that these fluctuations describe is the subject of sec . [ sec : photo ] . as well as describing the optical response , fluctuations about the mean field theory can also be important in describing , in the extremely low density limit , corrections to the mean field thermodynamics . since the subject of this paper is optical probes , we will not discuss the subject of fluctuation corrections to the critical temperature here , as they have been discussed elsewhere @xcite . for low densities , a bosonic form can be recovered from our hamiltonian by using the holstein - primakoff transformation to express the two - level systems in terms of bosonic operators , and so this low density limit can of course be treated within our model . a smooth crossover between the low density ( fluctuation dominated ) , and the higher density ( long - range interaction dominated ) regimes can be found by considering fluctuation corrections to the density , as was studied in ref . the optical absorption and emission spectra of a microcavity can be derived by first finding the green s function describing photon propagation . the non - condensate part of these response functions ( i.e. away from zero momentum ) may be found in practice by considering the green s function for fluctuations about the mean - field solution , @xmath155 , where @xmath156 is a bosonic matsubara frequencies , and expanding the action up to quadratic terms : @xmath157 this gives the matsubara inverse photonic green s function : @xmath158 physical response functions can be found by analytic continuation of the imaginary time matsubara green s function to real times . @xcite the matrix elements of @xmath159 can be expressed in terms of the bare photon energy @xmath160 and the excitonic quasi - particle energy @xmath161 as follows , @xmath162 where @xmath163 it is useful to decompose the photonic green s function into its momentum diagonal and off - diagonal contributions : @xmath164 by treating the off - diagonal terms perturbatively , the translational invariance can be recovered and polariton eigenstates can be labelled by momentum vectors . in the next section , we will focus on the diagonal terms , which characterise both the spectral weight and the photoluminescence emission . section [ sec : rrsca ] is then dedicated to rrs , for which we will see that the off - diagonal terms are necessary in order to describe the scattering of an incident photon ( via the excitonic component of the microcavity polariton mode ) into directions other than its original direction . @xcite secondary emission from a semiconductor microcavity after optical excitation is the source of both incoherent pl and coherent rrs . at short times , this emission is dominated by rrs , the coherent scattering from disorder , and so is at the energy of , and coherent with , the incident radiation . at longer times , phonon and particle - particle scattering destroy coherence , and redistribute the energy , leading to a quasi - equilibrium distribution of energies , and thus the incoherent pl emission intensity , @xmath165 is given by the bose occupation factor @xmath166 times the spectral weight : @xmath167 the spectral weight can be interpreted as an absorption coefficient @xcite ( the probability to absorb a photon minus the probability to emit a photon ) , where negative values of @xmath168 represent gain . in contrast , the pl @xmath169 is always positive . in calculating the pl , it is convenient to make an approximation by neglecting multiple polariton scattering , while still including the effects of exciton - disorder scattering to all orders . this is discussed in ref . , where comparison between this approximation and exact numerical calculations show this approximation to be remarkably good . physically , this is a good limit to consider because the typical exciton - disorder scattering times are very short compared to the inverse frequencies considered in pl . as pl depends on the momentum diagonal part of the photon green s function , neglect of multiple scattering means in practice averaging over disorder realisations at the level of the inverse photon green s function , @xmath159 . since off - diagonal terms in the inverse green s function , eq . , break translational invariance , they average to zero , and so scattering between different photon momentum states can thus be neglected . the off - diagonal terms neglected here will however play a crucial role in the case of rrs response , as discussed below . the spectral weight calculated from this formula , along with the quasi - particle density of states is shown in fig . [ fig : spwei ] . as a function of the dimensionless momentum @xmath2 and rescaled energy @xmath3 , for zero detuning @xmath170 = 0 ( @xmath171mev ) , @xmath4mev , @xmath5k and photon mass @xmath172 . right column : plot of the quasi - particle dos for the same choice of parameters as the left column , respectively : ( a ) non - condensed ( @xmath7 , @xmath173mev ) ( the bare exciton and photon dispersions [ blue ( dark gray ) dotted line ] and the upper and lower polariton dispersions [ red ( gray ) solid line ] obtained from the effective coupled oscillator model are shown for comparison ) ; ( b ) condensed ( @xmath174 , @xmath175mev ) ; ( c ) condensed ( @xmath9 , @xmath176mev ) . ] we first discuss this in the non - condensed case , where @xmath177 , and so @xmath178 , and the photon s green function becomes diagonal in particle - hole space , and simplifies to : @xmath179 this expression describes the coupling of one harmonic oscillator ( the photon mode ) to many harmonic oscillators ( the exciton modes ) . in the limit of small density , the chemical potential is far below all exciton modes , and so @xmath180 . in this limit , the result is identical to a bosonic description of excitons sometimes also called the _ linear dispersion model_. the underlying fermionic structure appears as a reduction of the effective exciton - photon coupling , due to saturation effects described by the @xmath181 term , and discussed in more detail below . from this _ linear dispersion model _ , describing one oscillator coupled to many , there are in general two broadened modes at high and low energies here these are the lower polariton ( lp ) and upper polariton ( up ) and a continuum of modes associated with the exciton optical density . however , when considering the corresponding spectral weight , modes are weighted by their photonic component , so one primarily sees the lp and up modes , and only weak emission near the bare excitonic states the excitonic ` dark ' states . these three features are clearly visible in fig . [ fig : spwei ] , and have been previously predicted by houdr _ et al . _ @xcite making use of a simplified and exactly solvable model . note that in the limit of an infinitely narrow spectral width , these dark exciton states become entirely dark , having vanishing photon component . the presence of ` dark ' exciton states , coexisting with strong coupling polaritons can explain the simultaneous observation of large rabi splittings and long decay times seen in some experiments . @xcite when the rabi splitting is substantially larger than the exciton inhomogeneous broadening , ( in our case we have @xmath182mev and the fwhm of the optical density @xmath183mev ) , there is a substantial difference between broadening of lower and upper polaritons . this is because the high energy tail of the optical density decays as a power law , while the low energy lifshitz tail decays exponentially . thus , the optical density has a larger value at the up mode than at the lp mode , giving a larger broadening compared to the almost vanishing width of the lp . this description of the polariton linewidth due to the excitonic inhomogeneous broadening coincides with that of whittaker @xcite , and it has been well tested experimentally . @xcite in addition , the location of the lp and up can be found by making use of an effective two - oscillator model , i.e. assuming a narrow delta - like optical density , @xmath184 where @xmath149 is the location of the maximum optical density and effectively , the exciton energy . in this case the system reduces to two coupled oscillators , giving unbroadened lp and up poles at @xmath185 where , @xmath186 is the reduced rabi splitting , due to saturation effects at higher densities . the reduction of @xmath187 splitting thus translates directly into a reduction of the lp up splitting , and thus a blue - shift of the lp , which at small densities can be shown to be linear . for comparison , the results of this formula are shown by the solid ( red ) lines in panel ( a ) of fig . [ fig : spwei ] . in sec . [ sec : blues ] we will discuss the calculation of this linear blue - shift in the low density regime , by evaluating @xmath187 as a function of density , making use of the full density of states . let us now turn to the signatures of condensation as seen in the spectral weight , and thus in the pl emission ( but which are most probably masked in the pl emission by strong emission from the condensate mode ) . when condensed , the polariton modes are replaced by new collective modes : @xcite the lower polariton becomes the linear goldstone mode , and two branches appear below the chemical potential . the appearance of new excitation branches below the chemical potential is generic to condensation , @xcite however the experiments required to probe these modes are not easy in other bose condensed systems , such as atomic gases . for this reason , let us briefly discuss the physical origin of these new branches , and the reason they may be observed in optical response of polariton systems . the bogoliubov spectrum arises because of the possibility of processes that spontaneously either create or destroy two non - condensed particles . ( such processes arise due to scattering from or to the condensate . ) as a result of these processes , there is mixing between the propagation of an extra particle , or propagation of a missing particle ( i.e. a hole ) . ( such a language of particle and hole refers to the normal state quasi - particles , in the current case the normal state polaritons . ) in the normal state , one can separately calculate the spectral weight of particle excitations , which have weight only above the chemical potential , and hole excitations which have weight only below the chemical potential . when condensed , as the `` particle '' and `` hole '' spectral weights become mixed , this mixing can lead to spectral weight below the chemical potential that is associated with particle propagation . to observe this weight it is however necessary to have the ability to inject a particle which is not a quasi - particle of the condensed system , i.e. not a bogoliubov quasiparticle . in atomic experiments this is hard to achieve , but for polaritons can be naturally achieved by injecting a photon . these new branches below the chemical potential are seen as optical gain in the spectral weight ( see fig . [ fig : spwei ] ) . note that the presence of pumping and decay will modify the linear dispersion of the goldstone mode at low momentum , making it diffusive , @xcite and that quantisation by disorder may also have some effect . @xcite the spectral weight also contains information about the excitonic quasi - particle dos of the system . as discussed above for the non - condensed case , this is visible via the appearance of ` dark ' exciton states [ see figs . [ fig : vsdet ] and [ fig : spwei](a ) ] . when condensed , there is a coherent field that modifies the energies of these excitonic quasi - particle states , as given in eq . ( [ eq : quasi ] ) , and thus modifies their density of states . the density of states given by taking the energy of such modes is shown by the right column of fig . [ fig : spwei ] , and can be compared to the corresponding faint features seen in the photon spectral weight in the left column . for @xmath90 as a function of the detuning @xmath170 and energy @xmath188 , for a fixed and very low value of density ( @xmath189 , @xmath190mev ) and @xmath191k ( @xmath192 ) . the bare exciton and photon dispersions [ blue ( dark gray ) dotted line ] and the upper and lower polariton dispersions [ red ( gray ) solid line ] obtained from the effective coupled oscillator model are explicitly shown . ] the change to the quasi - particle density of states that occurs on condensation requires some explanation . as mentioned earlier , the change of this spectrum is similar to that seen in the bcs theory of superconductivity , as such it is surprising that there is no gap in the density of states of fig . [ fig : spwei ] . in fact , there would be a gap if the distribution of oscillator strengths were replaced with the mean square oscillator strength . in that case , there would be a branch cut , and a @xmath193 singularity in the density of states . however , with the full distribution of oscillator strengths , one finds that there is always a non - vanishing probability of arbitrarily small oscillator strengths . ( note that if the oscillator strength were zero , the corresponding state would not contribute to any photon response , but for an arbitrarily small coupling , it has some contribution . ) thus , the contribution of these weakly coupled exciton states in effect smoothes out the gap . thus , this system can be vaguely described as ` gapless fermion condensation ' , analogous to ` gapless superconductivity ' , but through a mechanism very different to the standard abrikosov - gorkov mechanism considered in superconductors . @xcite as one moves away from the chemical potential , the mixing of ` particle ' and ` hole ' modes described by the bogoliubov spectrum reduces . as a result , far above the chemical potential , the modes are much as the uncondensed case , and the far below the chemical potential , the new modes disappear . to explain this quantitatively , it is clearer to discuss the case of weakly interacting bose gas . @xcite writing the bogoliubov mode energy as @xmath194 , where @xmath195 is the mean - field value , the spectral weight is given by : @xmath196 it is thus clear that at large momenta , where @xmath197 , the coefficient of the first delta function ( modes above the chemical potential ) will go to one , and the the coefficient of the second ( modes below ) will be suppressed to zero ( roughly quadratically in energy ) . in contrast to the power law suppression of the spectral weight of modes far below the chemical potential , the pl signal from modes far above zero is suppressed exponentially by the thermal occupation of these modes [ see eq . ] , while below the chemical potential , there is no such decay . however , this discussion neglects emission from the condensate mode , which should included at zero momentum , as defined in eq . . to see a noticeable change of the normal modes requires a relatively large condensate density . due to instrumental broadening , the presence of emission from this large condensate density might obscure emission from the normal modes , so they may only be weakly visible , as shown in fig . [ fig : plumi ] . as discussed below , rrs may provide a means of escape from this problem . as a function of the dimensionless momentum @xmath2 and rescaled energy @xmath198 , for detuning @xmath199mev , @xmath4mev , @xmath5k and @xmath200 : ( a ) non - condensed ( @xmath7 , @xmath173mev ) ; ( b ) condensed ( @xmath201 , @xmath202mev ) ; ( c ) condensed ( @xmath9 , @xmath203mev ) . ] before discussing the rrs response , let us briefly discuss a point mentioned above the calculation of the lp blue - shift as a function of density , making use of the full density of states , and our model of saturation effects . this can be observed in pl experiments by the change of blue - shift as a function of intensity of the non - resonant pumping . in the non condensed regime , the blue - shift of the lp in our model is a consequence of the saturation of the ( disordered ) energy levels . following the narrow band - width limit described in eq . ( [ eq : lpeup ] ) , this saturation blue - shift can be found if one has an expression for the chemical potential at a given temperature and density . in the low density limit , the expression for density @xmath147 as a function of @xmath126 [ eq . ( [ eq : homo2 ] ) with @xmath177 ] can be inverted in terms of elementary functions . as illustrated by fig . [ fig : occup ] , in the low density limit , the chemical potential is far below the band edge . thus , there are two significant contributions to density : one from low energies , in the tail of the dos , but at large occupation , and one from high energies , in the tail of the occupation , but at large dos , thus : @xmath205 here @xmath206mev is the energy which characterises the exponential decay of dos in the tail of the lifshitz states this coefficient is extracted by an exponential fit to our numerical dos . at a temperature of @xmath207mev , the dominant contribution to the density is given by the second integral and the chemical potential increases logarithmically with the density : @xmath208 from this expression , and from the coupled oscillator expressions of the lp eq . , we can explicitly derive the reduced rabi splitting due to saturation effects , @xmath209 and the lp blue - shift , which is thus linear in this low - density regime : @xmath210 where we have reintroduced here the density @xmath211 per unit volume . remaining at small densities , but now considering the low temperature limit , @xmath212 , then the dominant term in eq . ( [ eq : density - assympt ] ) is the first , and so eq . ( [ eq : appbl ] ) should be modified by replacing the thermal length @xmath213 , by a characteristic disorder length @xmath214 . it is instructive to compare this result with that for a clean system ; in this case blue - shift of the lp has been attributed either due to coulomb interaction @xcite or to saturation effects @xcite ( where the expression given here is valid only in the dilute limit ) : @xmath215 because the excitonic rydberg @xmath216 can be of the same order of magnitude as the rabi splitting @xmath104 , in a clean system the two shifts can be expected to be of the same order of magnitude . considering just saturation effects , the difference between clean and dirty systems is that , at low temperature , in a clean system blue - shift depends on exciton number per square bohr radius , while in a disordered system the relevant length is that characteristic of the disorder potential , which is in general larger than the bohr radius . finally , we wish to observe that there is a distinction between coulomb and saturation effects : coulomb interactions result in a blue - shift of both the lp and up , while saturation leads to a blue - shift of the lp and a red shift of the up , i.e. a collapse of the rabi splitting . thus , these effects can be experimentally distinguished , and their relative magnitudes determined . in the condensed regime , the equivalent of the lp is the goldstone linear mode , which by definition starts at the chemical potential . thus , the observed blue - shift is a direct observation of chemical potential vs. density . figure [ fig : vsden ] shows the variation of the spectral weight at zero momentum as a function of density , from which the energy of the zero momentum lp and up modes can be extracted . also shown , for comparison , is the chemical potential vs.density ( dashed green line ) . the locking of the lp mode to the chemical potential beyond the critical density ( red solid line ) is clearly visible , and the behaviour of the lp mode vs density allows the extraction of density from an experimental measurement of lp blue - shift . for @xmath90 as a function of the dimensionless density @xmath147 and the rescaled energy @xmath217 , for zero detuning ( @xmath218mev ) and @xmath191k ( @xmath192 ) . the rescaled chemical potential @xmath219 [ green ( light gray ) dashed ] , the non - condensed lower and upper polariton modes from the two coupled oscillator model [ blue ( dark gray ) dotted ] , and the critical density for condensation @xmath220 [ vertical solid red ( dark gray ) line ] are shown for comparison . ] as described in refs . , the rrs intensity describes the probability to inject a photon into the cavity with momentum @xmath30 , and detect a coherent photon at @xmath221 with @xmath222 . the intensity of such a signal may be written as : @xmath223 since this involves the off - diagonal momentum space components of the green s function , it is necessary to include the off - diagonal momentum components of the inverse green s function eq . . however , as discussed in sec . [ sec : photo ] , we will consider only a single polariton scattering and again neglect multiple polariton scattering ( but include all orders of exciton - disorder scattering ) . such an approximation is reasonable for the same reasons discussed at the start of sec . [ sec : photo ] . in the following , we propose using the rrs signal to probe the excitation spectrum in the presence of a polariton condensate . it is therefore necessary to be able to separate the rrs signal from the strong photoluminescence that would arise from the equilibrium state with large polariton density . further , since a condensed polariton system may have a strong nonlinear response to an applied probe ( i.e. stimulated scattering if the probe significantly affects the population of polariton modes ) , it is necessary to use a weak rrs probe . fortunately , the coherent nature of rrs allows exactly this : one can detect a weak rrs signal by phase sensitive measurement , as is discussed in detail in appendix [ sec : phase - sens - detect ] . hence , the limit on intensity of the probe is provided by the sensitivity of the ccd camera , and not by the incoherent photoluminescence background . this therefore allows a probe sufficiently weak that only the linear rrs response is seen , and nonlinear effects can be avoided . when non - condensed , the single polariton scattering expansion of the photon green s function in the off - diagonal terms gives @xmath224 the factors @xmath225 appearing here can be interpreted as a filter , allowing a response only when the outgoing ( or equivalently incoming for @xmath226 ) momentum has an energy close to the polariton mode at the given energy . this means that @xmath227 and so is responsible for the ring - shaped rrs signal observed in experiments . @xcite in contrast , the term @xmath228 describes scattering between momentum states via polariton - exciton - polariton scattering . this term has a large variation from disorder realization to disorder realization , and is the reason for the speckle seen in rrs experiments . this speckle , and the disorder averaged rrs intensity are shown for comparison in fig . [ fig : excsp ] . as the precise speckle pattern depends on the precise disorder realization , the most we can reasonably do is to describe the statistical properties of this speckle , thus the disorder averaged rrs signal shown in fig . [ fig : rrsca ] would in experiment represent the envelope of the rrs speckle pattern . for a single disorder realization ( gray dotted line ) and its disorder average ( black cross symbols ) versus energy for @xmath229 and a @xmath230 azimuthal angle , @xmath231 and @xmath232 . for comparison , we also plot the excitonic optical density [ green ( light gray ) plus symbols ] . ] when condensed , the expression for the rrs intensity becomes more complicated , but can still be written in the form of a filter and scattering part : @xmath233 where the filter and scattering terms are respectively : @xmath234 as in the non - condensed case , the filter function @xmath235 restricts the allowed incoming and outgoing momenta to those for which the normal modes have the injected energy . however , as discussed earlier , in the presence of a condensate , the normal modes supported are no longer the lp and up , but instead the new bogoliubov - like quasi - modes . the decay of spectral weight associated with modes far below the chemical potential , as discussed in sec . [ sec : spect ] still applies ( this can clearly be seen in fig . [ fig : rrsca ] , fig . [ fig : spwei ] and fig . [ fig : plumi ] ) . however , since the energy of the rrs signal is controlled by the energy of the incident photon , it is possible to study modes far above the chemical potential , which would have negligible equilibrium occupation , and thus negligible weight in the pl signal . both for this reason , and because of the ability to discriminate between the coherent rrs signal and inchoherent photoluminescence , rrs provides a very powerful tool to study the interesting properties of condensed polariton systems . in this paper we have analysed and compared different optical responses of a condensate of microcavity polaritons . one of the conclusions of this work is that , compared to photoluminescence studies , the energy and momentum resolved resonant rayleigh scattering spectra provides many advantages in probing a condensed phase and in studying the associated coherent excitation spectrum . in particular , resonant rayleigh scattering , by collecting the signal at a different angle from that at which the system is probed , allows one to look directly at characteristic features of the condensed phase excitation spectrum . such features , like the goldstone modes both above and below the chemical potential , are weak in photoluminescence emission and are likely to be masked by the strong emission from the condensate in the lowest momentum state . in contrast , rayleigh scattering , being coherent with the probe , can be distinguished from condensate emission . one can ask why the accurate description of excitonic disorder considered in this paper is necessary , when the microcavity photon introduces a long length scale which averages over disorder . one might also compare this system with other excitonic systems , such as double quantum wells , @xcite where high density of dipole - dipole interacting excitons quickly screens the disorder . @xcite the answer to this question is that the large ratio of exciton to photon mass means firstly that exciton density required for condensation in microcavities is far less than in double quantum wells ; and secondly that those exciton states involved in forming the thermally occupied polariton modes are strongly localised exciton states ( i.e. influenced by disorder beyond born approximation ) . one of the consequences of an accurate treatment of disorder in microcavities is that the blue - shift of the lower polaritons due to saturation effects depends on a length scale characteristic of disorder and temperature , which can be much larger than the bohr radius , this length playing an equivalent role in the clean system . this effect can be important in determining the polariton densities from the measured blue - shift in current experiments . an important consequence of disorder is that the exciton - light coupling strength is characterised by a full distribution . in the non - condensed phase , the optical density alone determines the photoluminescence response , while for resonant rayleigh scattering the averaged fourth power of the oscillator strength is required . however , in the condensed phase one has to consider the entire distribution for each exciton energy . for energies close to and above the band edge , there is always a non - vanishing probability of an arbitrarily small oscillator strength . for this reason , in contrast to examples like bcs superconductivity , one can show that the quasi - particle spectrum does not have a hard gap . in conclusion , we have considered how an accurate treatment of disorder on the single - particle excitonic level , when elevated to the many body problem of interacting microcavity polaritons , leads to a variety of interesting features in various optical responses and probes of the condensed phase . we are grateful to roland zimmermann , wolfgang langbein and ben simons for suggestions and useful discussions . f.m.m . and m.h.s would like to acknowledge financial support from epsrc . j.k . would like to acknowledge financial support from the lindemann trust . this work is supported by the eu network `` photon mediated phenomena in semiconductor nanostructures '' hprn - ct-2002 - 00298 . in this appendix we show how the coherent nature of the resonant rayleigh signal allows a weak coherent probe to be detected in the presence of strong incoherent photoluminescence . the rayleigh scattering probe is a perturbation , @xmath236 , which in the rotating wave approximation may be written as : @xmath237 this describes a probe at wavevector @xmath30 , frequency @xmath238 , of strength @xmath239 . the rrs signal is the coherent scattering of this probe to other wavevectors . to isolate the part of the emission that is coherent with the probe , one may use a homodyne measurement , interfering the emission with part of the probe signal . this corresponds to measuring the spectrally resolved emission intensity : @xmath240 where @xmath241 \left[\hat{\psi}^{}_{{\mathbf q}}(0 ) + a_1e^{i\phi } \right ] |n\rangle \ ; , \end{gathered}\ ] ] and where @xmath242 is the strength of the homodyne mixing , and @xmath243 is a phase delay introduced between the probe and the homodyne signal . the states @xmath244 are the eigenstates of the system without the probe , given by @xmath245 ; @xmath246 is the free energy , for normalization . the principle of phase sensitive detection is to vary the phase delay , and to extract the part of @xmath247 which depends on this phase delay . since the background pl does not depend on the phase delay , this allows one to separate a small but phase dependent signal from a strong but phase independent background . the part of the signal that depends on phase is : @xmath248 \ ; . \label{eq:4}\end{gathered}\ ] ] standard first order time - dependent perturbation theory , using the perturbation in eq . yields : @xmath249e^{-i \omega t } + [ \ldots ] e^{i\omega t } \ ; . \label{eq:5}\end{gathered}\ ] ] the term written @xmath250 $ ] is similar to the first term , but with @xmath251 and @xmath252 . inserting this signal into eq . and then into eq . ( [ eq:1a ] ) , it can be seen that such a term gives a signal at frequency @xmath253 , and so can be clearly separated and ignored . inserting the first term into eq . , one can write : @xmath254 \frac { \langle n | \hat{\psi}^{\dagger}_{{\mathbf q } } | m \rangle \langle m | \hat{\psi}^{}_{{\mathbf p } } | n \rangle } { e_n - e_m - \omega - i \eta } \ ; , \label{eq:6 } \end{gathered}\ ] ] which is the definition of the retarded green s function , @xcite @xmath255 . by repeating the same analysis for the second term in eq . ( [ eq:4 ] ) , one can then write : @xmath256 where @xmath257 is the phase of the retarded green s function . hence , the phase - dependent part of the luminescence is given by the off - diagonal in momentum space part of the retarded green s function , i.e. the rrs signal . h. deng , d. press , s. gotzinger , g. s. solomon , r. hey , k. h. ploog , y. yamamoto , phys . * 97 * , 146402 ( 2006 ) . j. kasprzak , m. richard , s. kundermann , a. baas , p. jeanbrun , j. keeling , f. m. marchetti , m. h. szymanska , r. andr , j. l. staehli , v. savona , p. b. littlewood , b. devaud , and le si dang , nature , * 443 * , 409 ( 2006 ) . m. h. szymanska and p. b. littlewood , solid sate commun . * 124 * , 103 ( 2002 ) ; m. h. szymanska , p. b. littlewood , and b. d. simons , phys . a * 68 * , 013818 ( 2003 ) . a. kavokin and g. malpuech , _ cavity polaritons _ , in thin films and nanostructures vol . 32 ( elsevier , ny , 2003 ) . j. keeling , p. r. eastham , m. h. szymanska , p. b. littlewood , phys . lett . * 93 * , 226403 ( 2004 ) ; phys . b * 72 * , 115320 ( 2005 ) . f. m. marchetti , b. d. simons , and p. b. littlewood , phys . b * 70 * , 155327 ( 2004 ) ; f. m. marchetti , m. h. szymanska , p. r. eastham , b. d. simons , and p. b. littlewood , solid state commun . * 134 * , 111 ( 2005 ) . d. sarchi and v.savona , aip conf . proc . * 893 * , 401 ( 2007 ) . p. schwendimann and a. quattropani , phys . b * 74 * , 045324 ( 2006 ) . r. zimmermann , f. grosse , and e. runge , pure and appl . chem . * 69 * , 1179 ( 1997 ) ; r. zimmermann and e. runge , phys . ( a ) * 164 * , 511 ( 1997 ) . i. carusotto and c. ciuti , phys . lett . * 93 * , 166401 ( 2004 ) ; c. ciuti and i. carusotto , phys . status solidi b * 242 * , 2224 ( 2005 ) . s. d. baranovskii and a. l. fros , fiz . . poluprovodn . * 12 * , 2233 ( 1978 ) [ sov . . semicond . * 12 * , 1328 ( 1979 ) ] . r. zimmermann , e. runge , and v. savona , `` theory of resonant secondary emission : rayleigh scattering versus luminescence '' , in _ quantum coherence , correlation and decoherence in semiconductor nanostructures _ ( ed . t. takagahar ) , elsevier science ( 2003 ) . m. holland , s.j.j.m.f . kokkelmans , m.l . chiofalo , and r. walser , phys . * 87 * , 120406 ( 2001 ) ; e. timmermans , k. furuya , p.w . milonni , and a.k . kerman , phys . a * 285 * , 228 ( 2001 ) ; y. ohashi , a. griffin , phys . lett . * 89 * , 130402 ( 2002 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: with recent advances in the field of ultra - cold atomic gases , trapped bose - einstein condensates ( bec s ) have become an important system to study many - body physics such as quantum phase transitions . in particular , the ability to dynamically control the lattice structure and the strength of interaction as well as the absence of impurities in bec s confined in optical lattices , have led to the recent observation of the superfluid to mott - insulator transition @xcite . at the same time , there has been a tremendous interest in studying rotating bec s in harmonic traps ; at sufficient rotation an abrikosov lattice of quantized vortices has been observed @xcite and the realization of strongly correlated quantum states similar to the fractional quantum hall states has been predicted to occur at higher rotation rates @xcite . in these proposals , the rotation can play the role of an effective magnetic field for the neutral atoms and in analogy with electrons , the atoms may enter into a state described by the laughlin wavefunction , which was introduced to describe the fractional quantum hall effect . while this approach yields a stable ground state separated from all excited states by an energy gap , in practice this gap is rather small because of the weak interactions among the particles in the magnetic traps typically used . in optical lattices , the interaction energies are much larger because the atoms are confined in a much smaller volume , and the realization of the fractional quantum hall effect in optical lattices could therefore lead to a much higher energy gap and be much more robust . in a recent paper @xcite , it was shown that it is indeed possible to realize the fractional quantum hall effect in an optical lattice , and that the energy gap achieved in this situation is a fraction of the tunneling energy , which can be considerably larger than the typical energy scales in a magnetic trap . in addition to being an interesting system in its own right , the fractional quantum hall effect , is also interesting from the point of view of topological quantum computation @xcite . in these schemes quantum states with fractional statistics can potentially perform fault tolerant quantum computation . so far , there has been no direct experimental observation of fractional statistics although some signatures has been observed in electron interferometer experiments @xcite . strongly correlated quantum gases can be a good alternative where the systems are more controllable and impurities are not present . therefore , realization of fractional quantum hall states in atomic gases can be a promising resource for topological quantum computation in the future . as noted above the fqh effect can be realized by simply rotating and cooling atoms confined in a harmonic trap . in this situation , it can be shown that the laughlin wavefunction exactly describes the ground state of the many body system @xcite . in an optical lattices , on the other hand , there are a number of questions which need to be addressed . first of all , it is unclear to which extent the lattices modifies the fractional quantum hall physics . for a single particle , the lattice modifies the energy levels from being simple landau levels into the fractal structure known as the hofstadter butterfly @xcite . in the regime where the magnetic flux going through each lattice @xmath0 is small , one expects that this will be of minor importance and in ref . it was argued that the fractional quantum hall physics persists until @xmath1 . in this paper , we extent and quantify predictions carried out in ref . . whereas ref . only considered the effect of infinite onsite interaction , we extent the analysis to finite interactions . furthermore , where ref . mainly argued that the ground state of the atoms was in a quantum hall state by considering the overlap of the ground state found by numerical diagonalization with the laughlin wavefunction , we provide further evidence for this claim by characterizing the topological order of the system by calculating chern numbers . these calculations thus characterize the order in the system even for parameter regimes where the overlap with the laughlin wavefunction is decreased by the lattice structure . in addition to considering these fundamental features of the fqh states on a lattice , which are applicable regardless of the system being used to realize the effect , we also study a number of questions which are of particular interest to experimental efforts towards realizing the effect with atoms in optical lattices . in particular , we show that adding dipole interactions between the atoms can be used to increase the energy gap and stabilize the ground state . furthermore , we study bragg spectroscopy of atoms in the lattice and show that this is a viable method to identify the quantum hall states created in an experiment , and we discuss a new method to generate an effective magnetic field for the neutral atoms in the lattice . the paper is organized as follows : in sec . [ section - no_hardcore ] , we study the system with finite onsite interaction . in sec . [ section - chern ] we introduce chern numbers to characterize the topological order of the system . the effect of the dipole - dipole interaction has been elaborated in sec . [ section - dipole ] . [ nu1/4 ] studies the case of @xmath2 filling factor . [ bragg ] is dedicated to explore bragg spectroscopy of the system . [ magnetic ] outlines a new approach for generating the type of the hamiltonian studied in this paper . the fractional quantum hall effect occurs for electrons confined in a two dimensional plane under the presences of a perpendicular strong magnetic field . if @xmath3 is the number of electrons in the system and @xmath4 is the number of magnetic fluxes measured in units of the quantum magnetic flux @xmath5 , then depending on the filling factor @xmath6 the ground state of the system can form highly entangled states exhibiting a rich behaviors , such as incompressibility , charge density waves , and anyonic excitations with fractional statistics . in particular , when @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is an integer , the ground state of the system is an incompressible quantum liquid which is protected by an energy gap from all other states , and in the landau gauge is well described by the laughlin wavefunction @xcite : ( z_1,z_2, ... ,z_n)=_j > k^n ( z_j - z_k)^m _ j=1^n e^- y^2_i/2 [ laughlin ] , where the integer @xmath8 should be odd in order to meet the antisymmetrization requirement for fermions . although the fractional quantum hall effect occurs for fermions ( electrons ) , bosonic systems with repulsive interactions can exhibit similar behaviors . in particular , the laughlin states with even @xmath8 correspond to bosons . in this article , we study bosons since the experimental implementation are more advanced for the ultra - cold bosonic systems . we study a system of atoms confined in a 2d lattice which can be described by the bose - hubbard model @xcite with the peierls substitution @xcite , @xmath9 + where @xmath10 is the hopping energy between two neighboring sites , @xmath11 is the onsite interaction energy , and @xmath12 is the phase acquired by a particle going around a plaquette . this hamiltonian is equivalent to the hamiltonian of a u(1 ) gauge field ( transverse magnetic field ) on a square lattice . more precisely , the non - interacting part can be written as -j_<ij > a^_i a_j ( ^j_i ) where @xmath13 is the vector potential for a uniform magnetic field and the path of the integral is chosen to be a straight line between two neighboring sites . in the symmetric gauge , the vector potential is written as @xmath14 . hence , @xmath0 will be the amount of magnetic flux going through one plaquette . while the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) occurs naturally for charged particles in a magnetic field , the realization of a similar hamiltonian for neutral particles is not straightforward . as we discuss in sec . [ magnetic ] this may be achieved in a rotating harmonic trap , and this have been very successfully used in a number of experiments in magnetic traps @xcite , but the situation is more complicated for an optical lattice . however , there has been a number of proposals for lattice realization of a magnetic field @xcite , and recently it has been realized experimentally @xcite . @xcite have studied the realization of fractional hall states for a few particles in individual lattice sites . a new approach for rotating the entire optical lattice is discussed in sec . [ magnetic ] . the essence of the above hamiltonian is a non - zero phase that a particle should acquire when it goes around a plaquette . this phase can be obtained for example by alternating the tunneling and adding a quadratic superlattice potential @xcite or by simply rotating the lattice ( sec.[magnetic ] ) . the advantage of confining ultra - cold gases in an optical lattice is to enhance the interaction between atoms which consequently result in a higher energy gap comparing to harmonic trap proposals ( e.g. ref . ) . this enhancement in the energy gap of the excitation spectrum can alleviate some of the challenges for experimental realization of the quantum hall state for ultra - cold atoms . in order to approximate a large system , we study the system with periodic boundary condition , i.e. on a torus , where the topological properties of the system is best manifested . there are two energy scales for the system : the first is the magnetic tunneling term , @xmath15 , which is related to the cyclotron energy in the continuum limit @xmath16 and the second is the onsite interaction energy @xmath11 . experimentally , the ratio between these two energy scales can be varied by varying the lattice potential height @xcite or by feshbach resonances @xcite . let us first assume that we are in the continuum limit where @xmath17 , i.e. the flux through each plaquette is a small fraction of a flux quantum . a determining factor for describing the system is the filling factor @xmath18 , and in this study we mainly focus on the case of @xmath19 , since this will be the most experimentally accessible regime . we restrict ourself to the simplest boundary conditions for the single particle states @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the magnetic translation operator which translates the single particle states @xmath22 around the torus . the definition and detailed discussion of the boundary conditions will be elaborated in section [ section - chern ] . the discussed quantities in this section , such as energy spectrum , gap and overlap , do not depend on the boundary condition angles ( this is also verified by our numerical calculation ) . in the continuum case , for the filling fraction @xmath19 , the laughlin state in landau gauge @xmath23 is given by eq . ( [ laughlin ] ) with @xmath24 . the generalization of the laughlin wavefunction to a torus takes the form @xcite ( z_1,z_2, ... ,z_n)=f_rel(z_1,z_2, ... ,z_n)f_cm(z)e^-_i y^2_i/2 [ laughlin - torus ] , + where @xmath25 is the relative part of the wave function and is invariant under collective shifts of all @xmath26 s by the same amount , and @xmath27 is related to the motion of the center of mass and is only a function of @xmath28 . for a system on a torus of the size @xmath29 , we write the wavefunction with the help of theta functions , which are the proper oscillatory periodic functions and are defined as @xmath30 } ( z|\tau)=\sum_n e^{i \pi \tau ( n+a)^2 + 2\pi i ( n+a)(z+b)}$ ] where the sum is over all integers . for the relative part we have , f_rel=_i < j ( |i ) ^2 . according to a general symmetry argument by haldane @xcite , the center of mass wave function @xmath27 is two - fold degenerate for the case of @xmath19 , and is given by f_cm(z)=(|2i ) where @xmath31 refers to the two degenerate ground states . this degeneracy in the continuum limit is due to the translational symmetry of the ground state on the torus , and the same argument can be applied to a lattice system when the magnetic length is much larger than the lattice spacing @xmath32 . for higher magnetic filed , the lattice structure becomes more pronounced . however , in our numerical calculation for a moderate magnetic field @xmath33 , we observe a two - fold degeneracy ground state well separated from the excited state by an energy gap . we return to the discussion of the ground state degeneracy in sec . [ section - chern ] . in the continuum limit @xmath32 , the laughlin wavefunction is the exact ground state of the many body system with a short range interaction @xcite . the reason is that the ground state is composed entirely of states in the lowest landau level which minimizes the magnetic part of the hamiltonian , the first term in eq . ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) . the expectation value of the interacting part of the hamiltonian , i.e. the second term in eq . ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) , for the laughlin state is zero regardless of the strength of the interaction , since it vanishes when the particles are at the same position . to study the system with a non - vanishing @xmath0 , we have performed a direct numerical diagonalization of the hamiltonian for a small number of particles . since we are dealing with identical particles , the states in the hilbert space can be labeled by specifying the number of particles at each of the lattice sites . in the hard - core limit , only one particle is permitted on each lattice site , therefore for @xmath3 particles on a lattice with the number of sites equal to @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is the unit lattice side , the hilbert space size is given by the combination @xmath36 . on the other hand , in case of finite onsite interaction , the particles can be on top of each other , so the hilbert space is bigger and is given by the combination @xmath37 . in our simulations the dimension of the hilbert can be raised up to @xmath38 and the hamiltonian is constructed in the configuration space by taking into account the tunneling and interacting terms . the tunneling term is written in the symmetric gauge , and we make sure that the phase acquired around a plaquette is equal to @xmath39 , and that the generalized magnetic boundary condition is satisfied when the particles tunnels over the edge of the lattice [ to be discussed in sec . [ section - chern ] , c.f . ( [ twist_angles ] ) ] . by diagonalizing the hamilton , we find the two - fold degenerate ground state energy which is separated by an energy gap from the excited states and the corresponding wavefunction in the configuration space . the lauhglin wave function ( [ laughlin - torus ] ) can also be written in the configuration space by simply evaluating the laughlin wave function at discrete points , and therefore we can compared the overlap of these two dimensional subspaces . the energy gap above the ground state and the ground state overlap with the laughlin wavefunction for the case of @xmath19 in a dilute lattice @xmath40 , are depicted in figure . [ tuning_u ] . the laughlin wavefunction remains a good description of the ground state even if the strength of the repulsive interaction tends to zero ( fig . [ tuning_u ] a ) . below , we discuss different limits : first , we consider @xmath41 : if the interaction energy scale @xmath11 is much larger than the magnetic one @xmath42 , all low energy states lie in a manifold , where the highest occupation number for each site is one , i.e. this corresponds to the hard - core limit . the ground state is the laughlin state and the excited states are various mixtures of landau states . the ground state is two - fold degenerate @xcite and the gap reaches the value in for the hard - core limit at large @xmath43 , as shown in fig . [ fig : gap ] ( a ) . in this limit the gap only depends on the tunneling @xmath10 and flux @xmath0 , and the gap is a fraction of @xmath10 . these results are consistent with the previous work in ref . . secondly , we consider @xmath44 . in this regime , the magnetic energy scale @xmath45 is much larger than the interaction energy scale @xmath11 . for repulsive regime ( @xmath46 ) , the ground state is the laughlin state and the gap increases linearly with @xmath47 , as shown in fig . [ fig : gap ] b. thirdly , we study @xmath48 where the interaction is absent and the ground state becomes highly degenerate . for a single particle on a lattice , the spectrum is the famous hostadfer s butterfly @xcite , while in the continuum limit @xmath49 , the ground state is the lowest landau level ( lll ) . the single particle degeneracy of the lll is the number of fluxes going through the surface , @xmath50 . so in the case of @xmath3 bosons , the lowest energy is obtained by putting @xmath3 bosons in @xmath50 levels . therefore , the many - body ground state s degeneracy should be : @xmath51 for example , 3 bosons and 6 fluxes gives a 336-fold degeneracy in the non - interacting ground state . if we increase the amount of phase ( flux ) per plaquette ( @xmath52 ) we are no longer in the continuum limit . the landau level degeneracy will be replace by @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the amount of flux per plaquette and @xmath55 and @xmath56 are coprime @xcite . then , the many - body degeneracy will be : @xmath57 . fourthly , we consider @xmath58 : when u is negative ( i.e. attractive interaction ) in the limit strong interaction regime , the ground state of the system will become a _ pillar _ state . in a pillar state , all bosons in the system condensate into a single site . therefore , the degeneracy of the ground state is @xmath59 and the ground state manifold can be spanned as , _ i ( a^)_i^n | vac . these states will very fragile and susceptible to collapse @xcite . in a lattice , it is also possible to realize the fractional quantum hall states for attractive interaction in the limit when @xmath60 . assume that the occupation number of each site is either zero or one . since the attraction energy @xmath11 is very high and there is no channel into which the system can dissipate its energy , the probability for a boson to hop to a site where there is already a boson is infinitesimally small . therefore , the high energy attraction will induce an effective hard - core constraint in the case of ultra - cold system . the energy of these state should be exactly equal to their hard - core ground state counterparts , since the interaction expectation value of the interaction energy is zero for the laughlin state . the numerical simulation shows that these two degenerate states indeed have a good overlap with the laughlin wavefunction similar to their repulsive hard - core counterparts and also their energies are equal to the hard - core ground state . these states are very similar to repulsively bound atom pairs in an optical lattice which have recently been experimentally observed @xcite . is varied by changing the size of the lattice ( the size in the two orthogonal directions differ at most by unity ) . the laughlin state ceases to be a good description of the system as the lattice nature of the system becomes more apparent @xmath61 . the overlap is only calculated at the positions shown with dots and the color coding is an extrapolation between the points . ] is varied by changing the size of the lattice ( the size in the two orthogonal directions differ at most by unity ) . the laughlin state ceases to be a good description of the system as the lattice nature of the system becomes more apparent @xmath61 . the overlap is only calculated at the positions shown with dots and the color coding is an extrapolation between the points . ] so far we have mainly considered a dilute lattice @xmath62 , where the difference between a lattice and the continuum is very limited . we shall now begin to investigate what happens for larger values of @xmath0 , where the effect of the lattice plays a significant role . [ high - alpha - overlap ] , shows the ground state overlap with the laughlin wavefunction as a function of the strength of magnetic flux @xmath0 and the strength of the onsite interaction @xmath11 . as @xmath0 increases the laughlin overlap is no longer an exact description of the system since the lattice behavior of the system is more pronounced comparing to the continuum case . this behavior does nt depend significantly on the number of particles for the limited number of particles that we have investigated @xmath63 . we have , however , not made any modification to the laughlin wave function to take into account the underlying lattice , and from the calculations presented so far , it is unclear whether the decreasing wave function overlap represents a change in the nature of the ground state , or whether it is just caused by a modification to the laughlin wave function due the difference between the continuum and the lattice . to investigate this , in the next section , we provide a better characterization of the ground state in terms of chern numbers , which shows that the same topological order is still present in the system for higher values of @xmath0 . as a summary , we observe that the laughlin wavefunction is a good description for the case of dilute lattice ( @xmath32 ) , regardless of the strength of the onsite interaction . however , the protective gap of the ground state becomes smaller for weaker values of interaction and in the perturbative regime @xmath64 is proportional to @xmath47 for @xmath65 . in the theory of quantum hall effect , it is well understood that the conductance quantization , is due to the existence of certain topological invariants , so called chern numbers . the topological invariance was first introduced by avron _ _ et al.__@xcite in the context of thouless _ et al . _ ( tkndn ) s original theory @xcite about quantization of the conductance . tkndn in their seminal work , showed that the hall conductance calculated from the kubo formula can be expressed into an integral over the magnetic brillouin zone , which shows the quantization explicitly . the original paper of tkndn deals with the single - particle problem and bloch waves which can not be generalized to topological invariance . the generalization to many - body systems has been done by niu _ _ et al.__@xcite and also tao _ _ et al.__@xcite , by manipulating the phases describing the closed boundary conditions on a torus ( i.e. twist angles ) , both for the integer and the fractional hall systems . these twist angles come from natural generalization of the closed boundary condition . to clarify the origin of these phases , we start with a single particle picture . a single particle with charge ( @xmath66 ) on a torus of the size @xmath67 in the presence of a magnetic field @xmath68 perpendicular to the torus surface , is described by the hamiltonian h_s= , where @xmath13 is the corresponding vector potential ( @xmath69 ) . this hamiltonian is invariant under the magnetic translation , t_s(*a*)=e^i * * ak**^s / where @xmath70 is a vector in the plane , and @xmath71 is the pseudomomentum , defined by @xmath72 the generalized boundary condition on a torus is given by the single - particle translation @xmath73 where @xmath74 and @xmath75 are twist angles of the boundary . the origin of these phases can be understood by noting that the periodic boundary conditions corresponds to the torus in fig . [ torus](a ) . the magnetic flux through the surface arises from the field perpendicular to the surface of the torus . however , in addition to this flux , there may also be fluxes due to a magnetic field residing inside the torus or passing through the torus hole , and it is these extra fluxes which give rise to the phases . the extra free angles are all the same for all particles and all states in the hilbert space , and their time derivative can be related to the voltage drops across the hall device in two dimensions . the eigenstates of the hamiltonian , including the ground state will be a function of these boundary angles @xmath76 . by defining some integral form of this eigenstate , one can introduce quantities , that do not depend on the details of the system , but reveal general topological features of the eigenstates . first we discuss the simplest situation , where the ground state is non - degenerate , and later we shall generalize this to our situation with a degenerate ground state . the chern number is in the context of quantum hall systems related to a measurable physical quantity , the hall conductance . the boundary averaged hall conductance for the ( non - degenerate ) @xmath0th many - body eigenstate of the hamiltonian is @xcite : @xmath77 , where the chern number @xmath78 is given by [ twist ] ) ( b ) redefining the vector potential around the singularities : @xmath79 is not well - defined everywhere on the torus of the boundary condition . therefore , another vector field @xmath80 with different definition should be introduced around each singularity @xmath81 of @xmath79 . @xmath79 and @xmath80 are related to each other by a gauge transformation @xmath82 and the chern number depends only on the loop integrals of @xmath82 around those singularities regions , c.f . , eq.([chern_gauge]).,title="fig : " ] [ gauge ] ) ( b ) redefining the vector potential around the singularities : @xmath79 is not well - defined everywhere on the torus of the boundary condition . therefore , another vector field @xmath80 with different definition should be introduced around each singularity @xmath81 of @xmath79 . @xmath79 and @xmath80 are related to each other by a gauge transformation @xmath82 and the chern number depends only on the loop integrals of @xmath82 around those singularities regions , c.f . , eq.([chern_gauge]).,title="fig : " ] c()= _ 0 ^ 2 d_1 _ 0 ^ 2 d_2 ( _ 1 _ 2^()-_2 _ 1^ ( ) ) [ eq : chern ] , where @xmath83 is defined as a vector field based on the eigenstate @xmath84 on the boundary torus @xmath85 by _ j^()(_1,_2 ) i ^()||^ ( ) . it should be noted that the wave function @xmath76 is defined up to a phase factor on the boundary - phase space . therefore , @xmath76 and @xmath86 are physically equivalent for any smooth function @xmath87 . under this phase change , @xmath83 transforms like a gauge : @xmath88 hence , the chern number integral is conserved under this gauge transformation and it encapsulates general properties of the system . chern numbers has been used extensively in the quantum hall literature , for characterization of the localized and extended states ( ref . and refs . therein ) . in this paper , we use the chern number as an indicator of order in the system . moreover , it enables us to characterize the ground state in different regimes , especially where the calculation of the overlap with the laughlin wave function fails to give a conclusive answer . before explaining the method for calculating the chern number , we clarify some issues related to the degeneracy of the ground state . in some systems , the ground state can be degenerate , this can be intrinsic or it can be as a result of the topology of the system . if the ground state is degenerate , we should generalize the simple integral form of eq . ( [ eq : chern ] ) to take into account the redundancy inside the ground state manifold . for example , in the case of a two - fold degenerate ground state , an extra gauge freedom related to the relative phase between two ground states , and this freedom should be fixed . in other words , as we change the twist angles , we can not keep track of the evolution of both states , since one can not distinguish them from each other . therefore , to uniquely determine the chern number of the ground state(s ) , we should resolve this gauge invariance , which is treated in section [ section - impurity ] and [ gauge - fixing ] . it important to note that the degeneracy in the non - interacting regime is fundamentally different from the degeneracy in the interacting case . in the non - interacting limit , the degeneracy can be lifted by a local perturbation e.g. impurity , while in the hardcore case , the degeneracy remains in the thermodynamic limit @xcite . the latter degeneracy in the ground state is a consequence of the global non - trivial properties of the manifold on which the particles move rather than related to a symmetry breaking which happens in conventional models e.g. ising model . the topological degeneracy is not a consequence of breaking of any symmetry only in the ground state , instead it is the entire hilbert space which is split into disconnected pieces not related by any symmetry transformation . with a general argument , wen @xcite showed that if the degeneracy of a chiral spin system moving on a simple torus is @xmath89 , then it should be @xmath90 on a torus with @xmath91 handles ( riemann surface with genus @xmath91 ) , therefore the topological detergency is an intrinsic feature of the system . in particular , in the context of quantum hall effect , this multicomponent feature of the ground state on a torus has a physical significance , while the single component ground state on a sphere boundary condition gives zero conductance , the torus geometry with multicomponent ground state results in a correct conductance measured in the experiment , since the torus boundary condition is more relevant to the experiment . changing twists angles of the boundary will rotate these components into each other and gives an overall non - zero conductance @xcite . as studied in a recent work by m. oshikawa and t. senthil @xcite , as a universal feature , it has been shown that in presence of a gap , there is a direct connection between the fractionalization and the topological order . more precisely , once a system has some quasiparticles with fractional statistics , a topological degeneracy should occur , which indicates the presence of a topological order . therefore , the amount of the degeneracy is related to the statistics of the fractionalized quasiparticles e.g. in the case of @xmath19 , the two - fold degeneracy is related to 1/2 anyonic statistics of the corresponding quasiparticles . chern number has been also studies for spin @xmath92 system on a honeycomb lattice @xcite for identifying abelian and non - abelian anyons . _ @xcite studies chern number for disordered fermi system using a non - commutative geometry . to resolve the extra gauge freedom related to the two degenerate ground states , we consider two possibilities : i. lifting the degeneracy by adding some impurities , ii . fixing the relative phase between the two states in the ground state . below , we explore both cases . in the first case , we introduce some fixed impurities to lift the degeneracy in the ground state for all values of the twist angles . this is an artifact of the finite size of the system which we take advantage of . in the presence of perturbation , we show that the system has a topological order in spite of poor overlap with the laughlin state . in the second approach , we use a scheme recently proposed by hatsugai @xcite which is a generalized form for degenerate manifolds . in this section , we introduce some perturbation in the finite system in form of local potentials ( similar to local impurities in electronic systems ) to split the degeneracy of the ground state and resolve the corresponding gauge invariance , which allows us to compute the chern number . furthermore , the fact that we can still uniquely determine the chern number in the presence of impurities , shows that the system retains its topological order , even when the impurities distort its ground state wavefunction away from the laughlin wavefunction . in the context of the quantum hall effect , the conventional numerical calculation of various physical quantities such as the energy spectrum , screening charge density profile , wave functions overlaps , and the density - density correlation functions , can not be used for understanding the transport properties of electrons in the presence of impurities ( although useful for studying of isolated impurities @xcite ) . recently , d. n. sheng _ et al . _ @xcite calculated the chern number as an unambiguous way to distinguish insulating and current carrying states in the @xmath93 quantum hall regime which correspond to zero and non - zero chern number , respectively . in this work , a weak random disorder was used to lift the degeneracy of the ground state ( three - fold for @xmath93 ) for a finite number of electrons . the energy splitting between the lowest three states then decreased with increasing number of particles , which indicates the recovery of the degeneracy in the thermodynamic limit . moreover , the mobility gap can be determined by looking at the energy at which the chern number drops towards zero . this energy gap is comparable to the energy gap obtained from the experiment and it is not necessarily equal to the spectrum gap which separates the degenerate ground state from the excited states this shows the significance of chern number calculations for understanding these systems . in a finite system , the coupling to a single - body interaction , e.g. impurities , can lift the degeneracy and one can uniquely determine the chern number for the individual states by direct integration of eq . ( [ eq : chern ] ) . on one hand , the impurity should be strong enough to split the energy in the ground state ( in this case @xmath94 , where @xmath95 denotes the energy of the @xmath96th energy level ) for all values of the twist angles . on the other hand , these impurities should be weak enough so that the energy splitting in the ground state remains smaller than the thermodynamic gap ( in this case @xmath97 ) . to calculate the chern number of individual level , as mentioned in the pervious section , we have to fix the phase of the wavefunction . the method that we explore in this section can be considered as a simplified version of the general method developed by hatsugai @xcite which we will explore in the next section . following kohmoto s procedure @xcite , we assume that the ground state @xmath98 may be expanded for all twist angles on a @xmath99-dimensional hilbert discrete space @xmath100 . if @xmath101 in eq . ( [ eq : chern ] ) is a periodic function on the torus of the boundary condition , then by application of stoke s theorem , the chern number will be always zeros . the non - triviality ( non - zero conductance in the case of quantum hall system ) occurs because of the zeros of the wave function , where the phase is not well - defined . therefore , @xmath102 is not well defined everywhere and its flux integral can be non - zero . to uniquely determine the chern number , we assume that the wave function and the vector field are not defined for certain points @xmath81 in @xmath103 regions on the torus of the boundary condition . for simplicity , we first discuss this procedure , in the case of a non - degenerate ground state . for calculating the integral , we should acquire another gauge convention for the wave function inside these @xmath103 regions , e.g. in a discrete system , we may require an arbitrary element of the wave function to be always real , and thereby we can define a new vector field @xmath104 , which is well defined inside these regions . these two vector fields differ from each other by a gauge transformation ( fig . [ torus ] ) : _ j^()(_1,_2)- _ j^()(_1,_2 ) = _ j ( _ 1,_2 ) , [ eq:1d_gauge]and the chern number reduces to the winding number of the gauge transformation @xmath105 over small loops encircling @xmath81 , i.e. @xmath106 , c()= _ n _ s_n d [ chern_gauge ] . the one - dimensional gauge eq . ( [ eq:1d_gauge ] ) should be resolved by making two conventions . for example , in one convention the first element and in the other the second element of the wavefunction in the hilbert space should be real i.e. transforming the ground state @xmath107 into @xmath108 where @xmath109 is a @xmath99-dimensional vector and @xmath110 is a projection into the ground state and similarly with the other reference vector @xmath111 . since the gauge that relates two vector fields is the same as the one that relates the corresponding wavefunctions ( similar to eq.([eq : gauge_wavefunction ] ) ) , we can uniquely determine the gauge transformation function @xmath82 by evaluating @xmath112 . therefore , the chern number will be equal to the number of windings of @xmath82 around regions where @xmath113 is zero . counting the vorticities has a vigorous computational advantage over the conventional method of direct integration of eq . ( [ eq : chern ] ) . in the direct integration , we need to choose a large number of mesh points for the boundary angles , because of the discrete approximation of derivatives in eq . ( [ eq : chern ] ) , and this makes the calculation computationally heavy . we note that for the system on a lattice , we should exactly diagonalize the hamiltonian which is a sparse matrix as opposed to the continuum case where the hamiltonian is a dense matrix residing on a smaller projected hilbert space ( lowest landau level ) . and @xmath114 , for the first and the second energy state , respectively . the results are for 3 atoms on a 6x6 lattice ( @xmath115 ) in the hard - core limit . ( b ) @xmath116 for the first level has no vorticity . however , for the second level , as shown in ( c ) , @xmath116 has vorticity equal to one associated with regions where either @xmath117 or @xmath118 vanishes . , width=566 ] for removing the degeneracy , in our numerical simulations , we add a small amount of impurity which is modeled as delta function potentials located at random sites with a random strength , of the order of the tunneling energy @xmath10 . this is described by a hamiltonian of the form @xmath119 , where @xmath120 numerates the lattice site , @xmath121 is the atom number operator and @xmath122 is the strength of the impurity at site @xmath120 . we choose reference states @xmath123 and @xmath124 to be eigenvectors of the numerically diagonalized hamiltonian at two different twist angles . in fig . [ impurity ] , vorticities of @xmath125 associated with the first and the second energy level is depicted . it is easy to see that the chern number associated to the two ground states is one . number of vortices may vary for the first and second ground states , but their sum is always equal to one . the hard - core limit ( @xmath126 ) is very similar to the case of fractional quantum hall effect , which in the context of hall systems , means a share of @xmath92 ( in @xmath127 unit ) for each ground state @xcite . when the onsite interaction strength is small ( @xmath128 ) , the thermodynamic gap becomes comparable to the ground state energy splitting @xmath129 , the chern number can not be uniquely determined , and the system does nt have topological order . on the other hand , in the limit of strong interaction ( @xmath130 ) , the total chern number associated to the ground states is equal to one , regardless of the impurity configuration . moreover , in the hard - core limit , although the ground state is not described by the laughlin wavefunction , since it is distorted by the impurity ( in our model it can be as low as @xmath131 ) , the chern number is unique and robust . this is an indication that the topological order is not related to the symmetries of the hamiltonian and it is robust against arbitrary local perturbations @xcite . these results indicate the existence of a topological order in the system and robustness of the ground states against local perturbations . the method developed in the previous section has the graphical vortex representation for the chern number which makes it computationally advantageous compared to the direct integration of eq . ( [ eq : chern ] ) . it can not , however , be applied directly to a degenerate ground state , and therefore we had to introduce an impurity potential which lifted the degeneracy . on the other hand , a significant amount of impurity in the system may distort the energy spectrum , so that the underlying physical properties of the lattice and fluxes could be confounded by the artifacts due to the impurities , especially for large @xmath0 . to address this issues , in this section , we explore a generalized method of the previous section based on refs . and , which works for a degenerate ground state . as arrows for fixed @xmath123 and @xmath124 . ( b ) and ( c ) : surface plots of @xmath132 and @xmath133 ( blue is lower than red ) . @xmath74 and @xmath75 changes from zero to @xmath134 . these plots have been produced for 3 atoms with @xmath135 ( @xmath136 ) in the hard - core limit on a 5x5 lattice . the total vorticity corresponding to each of the reference wave functions ( @xmath123 or @xmath124 ) indicates a chern number equal to one . ] as arrows for fixed @xmath123 and @xmath124 . ( b ) and ( c ) : surface plots of @xmath132 and @xmath133 ( blue is lower than red ) . @xmath74 and @xmath75 changes from zero to @xmath134 . these plots have been produced for 3 atoms with @xmath135 ( @xmath136 ) in the hard - core limit on a 5x5 lattice . the total vorticity corresponding to each of the reference wave functions ( @xmath123 or @xmath124 ) indicates a chern number equal to one . ] as arrows for fixed @xmath123 and @xmath124 . ( b ) and ( c ) : surface plots of @xmath132 and @xmath133 ( blue is lower than red ) . @xmath74 and @xmath75 changes from zero to @xmath134 . these plots have been produced for 3 atoms with @xmath135 ( @xmath136 ) in the hard - core limit on a 5x5 lattice . the total vorticity corresponding to each of the reference wave functions ( @xmath123 or @xmath124 ) indicates a chern number equal to one . ] by generalizing the chern number formalism for a degenerate ground state manifold , instead of having a single vector field @xmath137 , a tensor field @xmath138 should be defined , where @xmath139 for a @xmath140-fold degenerate ground state _ j^(,)(_1,_2 ) i ^()||^ ( ) similar to the non - degenerate case , when @xmath141 is not defined , a new gauge convention should be acquired for the regions with singularities . this gives rise to a tensor gauge transformation @xmath142 on the border of these regions _ j^(,)(_1,_2)- _ j^(,)(_1,_2 ) = _ j ^(,)(_1,_2 ) . following hatsugai s proposal@xcite for fixing the ground state manifold gauge , we take two reference multiplets @xmath123 and @xmath124 which are two arbitrary @xmath143 matrices ; @xmath66 is the ground state degeneracy ( equal to 2 in our case ) . in our numerical simulation , we choose the multiplets to be two sets of ground state at two different twist angles far from each other , e.g. @xmath144 and @xmath145 . we define an overlap matrix as @xmath146 where @xmath147 is again the projection into the ground state multiplet , and consider the regions where @xmath148 or @xmath149 vanishes ( similar to zeros of the wave function in the non - degenerate case ) . hence , the chern number for @xmath140 degenerate states , will be equal to the total winding number of @xmath150 for small neighborhoods , @xmath103 , in which @xmath148 vanishes for fixed @xmath123 and @xmath124 . @xmath74 and @xmath75 changes form zero to @xmath134 . this plot has been produced for 4 atoms with @xmath151 in the hard - core limit on a 5x5 lattice ( @xmath152 ) . although , there are more vortices here compared to fig . [ omega ] , the total vorticity corresponding to each of the trial functions ( @xmath123 or @xmath124 ) indicates a chern number equal to one . ] @xmath153 which is the same as the number of vortices of @xmath154 . it should be noted that the zeros of det @xmath155 and det@xmath156 should not coincide in order to uniquely determine the total vorticity . in fig . [ omega ] , we have plotted @xmath157 , @xmath132 , and @xmath158 , found by numerical diagonalization of the hamiltonian for a mesh ( @xmath159 ) of winding angles @xmath74 and @xmath75 . in this figure , the chern number can be determined be counting the number of vortices and it is readily seen that the winding number is equal to one for the corresponding zeros of @xmath148 ( or @xmath160 ) . .chern number for different configurations in the hard - core limit for fixed filling factor @xmath19 . the laughlin state overlap is shown in the last column . although it deviates from the laughlin state . although the ground state deviates from the laughlin state , the chern number remains equal to one half per state before reaching some critical @xmath161 where the energy gap vanishes . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we have calculated the chern number for fixed @xmath19 and different @xmath0 s by the approach described above . the result is shown in table [ chern ] . for low @xmath32 , we know from sec . [ section - no_hardcore ] that the ground state is the laughlin state and we expect to get a chern number equal to one . for higher @xmath0 , the lattice structure becomes more apparent and the overlap with the laughlin state decreases . however , in our calculation , the ground state remains two - fold degenerate and it turns out that the ground state chern number tends to remain equal to one before reaching some critical @xmath161 . hence , also in this regime we expect to have similar topological order and fractional statistics of the excitations above these states on the lattice . the degeneracy of the ground state is a function of twist angles . the shown results are for 5 atoms on a 5x5 lattice i.e. @xmath162 ( a ) shows first three energy manifolds as a function of the toroidal boundary condition angles , ( b ) shows a cross section of ( a ) at @xmath163 for seven lowest energy levels . the first and the second energy levels get close to each other at @xmath164 . ] the degeneracy of the ground state is a function of twist angles . the shown results are for 5 atoms on a 5x5 lattice i.e. @xmath162 ( a ) shows first three energy manifolds as a function of the toroidal boundary condition angles , ( b ) shows a cross section of ( a ) at @xmath163 for seven lowest energy levels . the first and the second energy levels get close to each other at @xmath164 . ] for the arguments above to be applicable , it is essential that we can uniquely identify a two - fold degenerate ground state which is well separated from all higher lying states . for higher flux densities , @xmath165 , the two - fold ground state degeneracy is no longer valid everywhere on the torus of the boundary condition . in this regime , the issue of degeneracy is more subtle , and the finite size effect becomes significant . the translational symmetry argument @xcite , which was used in the section [ section - no_hardcore ] , is not applicable on a lattice and as pointed out by kol _ et al_. @xcite the degeneracy of the ground state may vary periodically with the system size . some of the gaps which appear in the calculation may be due to the finite size and vanish in the thermodynamic limit , whereas others may represent real energy gaps which are still present in the thermodynamic limit . to investigate this , we study the ground state degeneracy as a function of boundary angles ( @xmath166 ) which are not physical observable and therefore the degeneracy in thermodynamic limit should not depend on their value . in particular , fig . [ level - crossing ] shows the energy levels of five particles at @xmath167 for different values of the twist angles . the first and the second level are split at ( @xmath168 ) , while they touch each other at ( @xmath164 ) . we have observed similar behavior for different number of particles and lattice sizes e.g. 3 and 4 atoms at @xmath169 . in this case , the system seems to not have a two - fold degeneracy . therefore , the ground state enters a different regime which is a subject for further investigation . for having the topological order , it is not necessary to be in the hard - core limit . even at finite interaction strength @xmath170 , we have observed the same topological order with the help of the chern number calculation . if @xmath11 gets further smaller , the energy gap above the ground state diminishes ( as seen in sec . [ section - no_hardcore ] ) and the topological order disappears . we conclude that the chern number can be unambiguously calculated for the ground state of the system in a regime where laughlin s description is not appropriate for the lattice . the non - zero chern number of a two - fold degenerate ground state , in this case equal to one half per state , is a direct indication of the topological order of the system . in sections [ section - no_hardcore ] and [ section - chern ] above , we have investigated the conditions under which the fractional quantum hall effect may be realized for particles on a lattice . the motivation for this study is the possibility to generate the quantum hall effect with ultra cold atoms in an optical lattice but the results of these sections are applicable regardless of the method used to attain this situation . in this and the following sections , we investigate some questions which are of particular relevance to ultra cold atoms in an optical lattice . first , we introduce a long range , e.g. , dipole - dipole , interaction which turn out to increase the energy gap and thereby stabilizes the quantum hall states . we then turn to the case of @xmath2 and show that in order to realize this state , it is essential to have some kind of long range interaction . in an experimental realization of the quantum hall effect on a lattice , it is desirable to have as large an energy gap as possible in order to be insensitive to external perturbations . so far , we have studied effect of the short range interaction , and we have shown that the gap increases with increasing interaction strength , but the value of the gap saturates when the short range interaction becomes comparable to the tunneling energy @xmath10 . in this section , we explore the possibility of increasing the gap by adding a long - range repulsive dipole - dipole interaction to the system . previously , such dipole - dipole interaction has also been studied in ref . + onlinecitecooper2005 as a method to achieve read - rezayi states @xcite of rapidly rotating cold trapped atoms for @xmath171 and as a means to realize fractional quantum hall physics with fermi gases @xcite . the dipole - dipole ( magnetic or electric ) interaction is described by the hamiltonian : h_d - d = u_dipole _ 1i < jn where @xmath172 . @xmath173 are unit vectors representing the permanent dipole moments and the position vectors @xmath174 are in units of the lattice spacing @xmath175 . for simplicity , we assume that all dipoles are polarized in the direction perpendicular to the plane . with time independent dipoles , the strength of the interaction is given by @xmath176 ( or @xmath177 ) where @xmath178 s ( @xmath179 s ) are the permanent magnetic ( electric ) dipole moment . static dipoles will thus give repulsive interaction @xmath180 , but experimentally time varying fields may be introduced which effectively change the sign of the interaction@xcite . for completeness , we shall therefore both investigate positive and negative @xmath181 , but the repulsive interaction corresponding to static dipoles will be the most desirable situation since it stabilizes the quantum hall states . experimentally the dipole - dipole interaction will naturally be present in the recently realized bose - einstein condensation of chromium@xcite which has a large magnetic moment . however , for a lattice realization , polar molecules which have strong permanent electric dipole moments is a more promising candidate . for typical polar molecules with the electric moment @xmath182 debye , on a lattice with spacing @xmath183@xmath184 m , @xmath185 can be up to few khz , an order of magnitude greater than the typical tunneling @xmath186 which can be few hundreds of hz @xcite . versus @xmath0 . the results are shown for @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 ] versus @xmath0 . the results are shown for @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 ] to study the effect of the dipole - dipole interaction , we again numerically diagonalize the hamiltonian for a few hardcore bosons ( @xmath130 ) , in the dilute regime @xmath190 , while varying strength of the dipole - dipole interaction . the results of this simulation is shown in fig . [ dipole ] ( a ) . after adding the dipole interaction , the ground state in a dilute lattice remains two - fold degenerate , since the interaction only depends on the relative distance of the particles and keeps the center of mass motion intact . if the dipole interaction becomes too strong @xmath191 , the ground state wave function deviates from the laughlin wavefunction , but the topological order remains the same as for the system without dipole interaction . we verified this by calculating the chern number as explained in sec . [ section - chern ] for different values of the dipole - dipole interaction strength @xmath192 and observed that the total chern number of the two - fold degenerate ground state is equal to one . moreover , as it is shown in fig . [ dipole ] ( b ) adding such an interaction can increase the gap : the lower curve corresponds to the hard - core limit discussed in the previous work @xcite and the upper curve corresponds to the system including the dipole - dipole interaction . this enhancement varies linearly with the flux density @xmath0 in a dilute lattice and does nt depend on the number of particles and consequently , it is expected to behave similarly in the thermodynamic limit . one of the impediment of the experimental realization of quantum hall state is the smallness of the gap which can be improved by adding dipole - dipole interaction . in this section , we showed that this improvement is possible and moreover , by chern number evaluation , we verified that adding dipole interaction does nt change the topological behavior of the ground state manifold . so far we have concentrated on the case of @xmath19 . in this section , we briefly investigate the case of @xmath2 . it is expected that the laughlin wavefunction remains a good description for the ground state of a bosonic system for any even @xmath66 , where @xmath193 . following haldane s argument@xcite , due to the center of mass motion , the degeneracy of the ground state is expected to be @xmath66-fold on a torus . similar to the case of @xmath19 , the laughlin wavefunction should be a suitable description for any @xmath66 provided that the magnetic field is weak so that we are close to the continuum limit , i.e. @xmath194 . also the chern number is expected to be equal to one for the q - fold degenerate ground state , which in the context of quantum hall effect means a share of @xmath195 of the conduction quantum @xmath127 for each state in the q - fold degenerate ground state manifold . we have done both overlap and the chern number calculation to check those premises . in the case of @xmath2 , significant overlap occurs at low @xmath196 . the average wave function overlap of four lowest energy eigenstates with the laughlin wavefunction is depicted in figure [ overlap_laughlin_1_4 ] , where we have used a generalization of the laughlin wavefunction for periodic boundary conditions similar to eq . ( [ laughlin - torus ] ) @xcite . we observe that the laughlin wavefunction is a reliable description of the system with @xmath2 but only for much more dilute lattices ( @xmath196 ) compared to @xmath19 where significant overlap occurs for @xmath197 . contrary to @xmath19 , where the gap is a fraction of the tunneling energy @xmath10 , the gap for @xmath2 between the 4-fold degenerate ground state and the next energy level is infinitesimal . the reason for the vanishing gap can be understood in the continuum limit from the argument put forward in ref . : as noted previously the laughlin wavefunction is an exact eigenstate of the hamiltonian with an energy per particle equal to the lowest landau level energy . the energy of the @xmath198 state is thus equal to the @xmath24 state . it thus costs a negligible energy to compress the @xmath2 state to the @xmath19 state , and therefore there is no gap . in an external trap the system will always choose the highest density state which is the @xmath19 state . note , however that this argument only applies to short range interactions . for long range interactions , we expect to see a non vanishing gap . even though that with short range interactions , the gap is very small in our numerical calculations , it is still sufficiently large that it allows us to unambiguously determine the chern number for the ground state manifold as described in sec . [ gauge - fixing ] . as expected the calculation shows that the chern number is equal to one corresponding to a four - fold degenerate ground state consistent with the generalization of the fermionic case in the fractional quantum hall theory @xcite . in fig . [ overlap_laughlin_1_4 ] , the overlap of the first four lowest energy state with the laughlin wavefunction is depicted . in the absence of the dipole interaction , the ground state overlap is significant only for @xmath199 , however , by adding a moderate dipole interaction ( @xmath200 ) , the overlap becomes more significant for a larger interval of the flux density , i.e. @xmath201 . this is due to the fact that state with lower density become more favorable in the presence of a long - range repulsive interaction . we observed that adding a dipole interaction would lead to an improvement of the gap for @xmath19 and make the laughlin overlap more significant for larger interval of magnetic field strength @xmath0 in the case of @xmath2 . therefore this long - range interaction can be used as an tool for stabilizing the ground state and make the realization of these quantum states , experimentally more feasible . on a torus . the dashed ( dotted ) line shows the overlap for the system without ( with ) dipole interaction ( @xmath200 ) . the laughlin state is only a good description for a more dilute lattice @xmath202 compared to @xmath19 . the dipole interaction stabilizes the system and the overlap is more significant for higher values of @xmath203 . ] in an experimental realization of the quantum hall states , it is essential to have an experimental probe which can verify that the desired states were produced . in most experiments with cold trapped atoms , the state of the system is probed by releasing the atoms from the trap and imaging the momentum distribution . in ref . , it was shown that this technique provide some indication of the dynamics in the system . this measurement technique , however , only provides limited information , since it only measures the single particle density matrix , and provides no information about the correlations between the particles . in refs . and a more advanced measurement techniques were proposed , where the particle correlation is obtained by looking at the correlations in the expansion images . in this section , we study bragg scattering as an alternative measurement strategy which reveals the excitation spectrum of the quantum system . in ref . bosonic quantum hall system responses to a perturbative potential is studied . we focus on bragg scattering where two momentum states of the same internal ground state are connected by a stimulated two - photon process @xcite . by setting up two laser beams with frequencies @xmath204 and @xmath205 and wave vectors @xmath206 and @xmath207 in the plane of the original lattice , a running optical superlattice will be produced with frequency @xmath208 and wave vector @xmath209 . ( both frequencies @xmath204 and @xmath205 should be close to an internal electronic dipole transition in the atoms ) . the beams should be weak and sufficiently detuned so that direct photon transitions are negligible , i.e. @xmath210 , where @xmath211 is the frequency of the transition , @xmath212 is the corresponding spontaneous decay rate and @xmath213 are the rabi frequencies related to the laser - atom coupling . in this perturbative regime , the inelastic scattering of photons will be suppressed ; the atom starts from the internal ground state , absorbs one photon from e.g. beam 1 by going to a virtual excited state and then emits another photon into beam 2 by returning to its internal ground state . after this process , the system has acquired an energy equal to @xmath214 and a momentum kick equal to @xmath215 . therefore , the overall effect of the recoil process is a moving ac stark shift as a perturbing moving potential , and the effective hamiltonian represents the exchange of the two - photon recoil momentum and the energy difference to the system and is proportional to the local density i.e. @xmath216 . this process can be used to probe density fluctuations of the system and thus to measure directly the dynamic structure factor @xmath217 and static structure factor @xmath218 . this kind of spectroscopy has been studied for a bec in a trap by blakie _ _ @xcite and zambelli _ et al . _ @xcite and has been realized experimentally in refs . . ] . ] also , bragg spectroscopy in an optical lattice is discussed in ref . in a mean - field approach and also in ref . as a probe of the mott - insulator excitation spectrum . on the other hand , in the context of quantum hall effect , the static structure factor has been studied for probing the magnetoroton excitations @xcite and charge density waves @xcite . the dynamic and static structure factors are given respectively as s(,)=_n , 0| n | ^()| 0|^2 ( -e_n+e_0 ) , s()=_n,0 | n | ^()| 0|^2 = _ n,0 | n | _ e^i | 0|^2 , where the density fluctuation operator is defined as @xmath219 and the coefficient are defined as fourier transforms of the wannier functions : @xmath220 , where the wannier function @xmath221 is the wave function of an atom localized on a site centered at @xmath222 . below , we focus on deep optical lattices , where @xmath223 . in the structure factor , there is a sum over the excited states @xmath224 and ground states @xmath225 and the self - term is thus excluded . the ground state on a torus is two - fold degenerate and therefore in our numerics , we add the contribution of both . since we are working on a discrete lattice , there will be a cut - off in the allowed momentum given by the lattice spacing @xmath226 , where @xmath227 is the distance between lattice sites . [ 3atoms - structure](a ) shows the structure factor for the case @xmath19 for a small @xmath0 calculated from our numerical diagonalizations . in the data presented here , we have chosen @xmath228 and but the result should be similar in other directions in the lattice plane . we see that @xmath218 is modulated at a momentum corresponding to the magnetic length . for the parameters that we have investigated , the general features of the structure factor is independent of the size of the system . we obtain the excitation spectrum shown in fig . [ 3atoms - structure ] ( b ) similar to ref . by the feynman - bijl approximation . in the continuum limit ( @xmath229 ) , we assume that the low - lying excitations are long - wavelength density oscillations and their wave functions can be approximated to have the form @xmath230 . therefore , the variational estimate for the excitation energy is @xmath231 . at zero momentum and at the momentum corresponding to the magnetic length , there are gaps , and we also observe a deviation from the free particle spectrum similar to the magneoroton case as a reminiscent of the wigner crystal . it should be noted that the deviation does not depend on the size or the number of particles in the system . as clearly seen in the fig . [ 3atoms - structure ] the energy spectrum and structure factor deviate from those of free particles , therefore , it could be used as an experimental probe of the system . the structure factor and excitation spectrum imply some general features that are very different from that of the mott - insulator and superfluid states , and can be used a powerful experimental indication of the quantum hall states . recently , there has been several proposals for producing artificial magnetic field for neutral atoms in optical lattices @xcite , however , the implementation of each of them is still experimentally demanding . recently , there has been an experimental demonstration of a rotating optical lattice @xcite which is equivalent to an effective magnetic field ( see below ) . the technique used in this experiment , however , generates a lattice with a large lattice spacing , because it uses laser beam which are not exactly counter propagating . this longer spacing reduces the energy scale in the lattice and thereby also reduces quantities such as energy gaps . here , we shall now introduce an alternative method for generating a rotating optical lattice , which does not result in an increased lattice spacing . this method consists of rotating the optical lattice by manipulating laser beams . in a frame of reference rotating with angular velocity @xmath232 around the @xmath233 , the hamiltonian for a particle of mass @xmath8 in an ( planar ) harmonic trap of natural frequency @xmath234 is @xmath235 at resonance @xmath236 the form is equivalent to the hamiltonian of a particle of charge @xmath66 experiencing an effective magnetic field @xmath237 . therefore , by simply rotating the optical lattice , we can mimic the magnetic field for neutral atoms . to rotate the optical lattice , we propose to set up four acousto - optic modulators ( aom ) and four focusing composite lenses as shown in the fig . [ lattice_rotation ] . by sweeping the acoustic wave frequency , the beams can be focused and make a rotating optical lattice . in an aom , for the first order diffracted light we have @xmath238 , where @xmath239 is the wavelength of sound in the medium , @xmath240 is the light wavelength and @xmath241 is half of the angle between a diffracted beam and the non - diffracted beam ( fig . [ lattice_rotation ] ) . by increasing the frequency of the acoustic wave , the diffraction angle increases . however , the beam should be focused by a large aperture lens so that it always passes the region where we want to make the optical lattice . by focusing a similar but counter - propagating beam , we can make a rotating standing wave ( fig . [ lattice_rotation ] ) . by repeating the same configuration in the transverse direction , we can make a rotating optical lattice . in particular , if the aom is far from the composite lenses , @xmath242 , then @xmath243 and @xmath244 where @xmath245 , where the parameters are defined in fig . [ lattice_rotation ] . if we consider a square lattice with dimensions @xmath246 , the number of magnetic flux given by rotation is n_== where @xmath247 is the atomic recoil frequency . on the other hand , the upper limit for the magnetic field comes from the single bloch band approximation which we made in writing the hamiltonian for the optical lattice . in order for the particles to remain in the first band , the traveling lattice beams should move them adiabatically . from ref . , the adiabaticity condition for a moving lattice with an acceleration @xmath248 equal to @xmath249 at the edge , is @xmath250 , where @xmath251 is the frequency difference between the first and the second band in the lattice . this puts a limit on how large the lattice can become @xmath252 . hence , for @xmath19 with a lattice filling fraction @xmath253 and a typical recoil frequency @xmath254 khz , one can enter the regime of fractional quantum hall effect by rotating the lattice at @xmath255 hz . if a deep optical lattice is used e.g. @xmath256 , the adiabaticity condition is easily satisfied for a lattice of size @xmath257 . the experimentally challenging part will , however , likely be to mitigate the instability of the lattice caused by the thickness of the beam and aberration of the lenses at the turning points i.e. near @xmath258 . an extended study of the realization of the fractional quantum hall states in optical lattices has been presented . we showed that a hamiltonian similar to that of a magnetic field for charged particles can be constructed for neutral ultra cold atoms and molecules confined in an optical lattice . by adding an onsite interaction for the case of @xmath19 , an energy gap develops between the ground state and the first excited state , which increases linearly as @xmath47 and saturates to its value in the hardcore limit @xmath126 . we learned that the laughlin wavefunction is a reliable description of the system for low flux densities @xmath201 . for higher @xmath0 s , the lattice structure becomes more pronounced and a better description of the system can be carried out by investigating the chern number associated to the ground state manifold . the chern number indicates that the system has topological order up to some critical flux density @xmath161 , where the properties of the ground state manifold starts to change . we have also studied @xmath2 , where compared to @xmath19 , the laughlin wavefunction only describes the ground state for lower values of the flux @xmath199 . we showed that a dipole - dipole interaction can enhance the gap and stabilize the system , and therefore make the ground state more experimentally realizable . bragg spectroscopy has been studied as a potential experimental tool to diagnose theses incompressible states . characterization of the ground state by evaluating the chern number , developed in sec . [ gauge - fixing ] , can be generalized to other interesting many - body systems where the conventional overlap calculation fails to work . in particular , this method can be applied to ground states with non - abelian statistics which are appealing candidates for fault - tolerant quantum computation . we thank k. yang , m. greiner , s. girvin and j. i. cirac for fruitful discussions . this work was partially supported by the nsf career award , packard foundation , afsor and the danish natural science research council . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: as molecular dynamics ( md ) is limited to microscopic systems and time scales , most chemical or biological reactions can not be simulated using straightforward md . one can literally wait ages before detecting a single event in a typical computer simulation . in the early 1930s , wigner and eyring made the first attempts to overcome this problem by introducing the concept of the transition state ( ts ) and the so - called ts theory ( tst ) approximation @xcite . later on , keck @xcite demonstrated how to calculate the dynamical correction , the transmission coefficient . this work has later been extended by bennett @xcite , chandler @xcite and others @xcite , resulting in a two - step approach . first the free energy as function of a reaction coordinate ( rc ) is determined . this can be done by e.g. umbrella sampling ( us ) @xcite or thermodynamic integration ( ti ) @xcite . then , the maximum of this free energy profile defines the approximate ts dividing surface and the transmission coefficient can be calculated by releasing dynamical trajectories from the top . this approach is , in principle , exact and independent of the choice of rc . however , the method becomes inefficient when the transmission coefficient is small . a proper choice of the rc can maximize the transmission coefficient and is hence crucial for the efficiency of the method . there exist different formalisms for the transmission coefficient formula which differ in the way trajectories are counted . we discuss the standard bennett - chandler ( bc ) @xcite , the history dependent bc ( bc2 ) @xcite , and the effective positive flux ( epf ) @xcite formalism . we show that the latter should always be preferred due to a lower average pathlength and a faster convergence . however , whenever a lot of correlated recrossings occur , the transmission coefficient will be very low and all these methods become inefficient . in high dimensional complex systems it can be a very difficult task to find a proper rc . moreover , whenever the dynamics is diffusive , even an optimal rc can result in a very low transmission and hence a poor efficiency . a new approach came with transition path sampling ( tps ) @xcite that is not based on the free energy barrier as starting point . tps is rather an importance sampling of dynamical trajectories . hence , it is a monte carlo ( mc ) sampling in path space rather than phase space . the tps method has been advocated as a method that does not need a rc and is akin to throwing ropes in the dark @xcite . this might be true if one wants to sample a set of reactive trajectories , but it is not for the calculation of reaction rates . in fact , the original approach to calculate reaction rates within the framework of tps required the definition of an order parameter and the calculation of the reversible work when the endpoint of the path is dragged along this parameter . for the sampling of reactive pathways , the order parameter needs only to distinguish between the two stable states . however , in the algorithmic procedure to calculate reaction rates with tps , the order parameter becomes very similar to a rc . still , it has been speculated that this approach is less sensitive to the problems related to an improper rc ( or order parameter ) . indeed , in this article we prove for the first time that this is true using the approach of transition interface sampling ( tis ) @xcite . tis increases the efficiency of the original tps rate calculation considerably by allowing the pathlength to vary and by counting only positive effective crossings . the overall reaction rate in tis is obtained from an importance sampling technique that uses a discrete set of interfaces between the stable states . hence , tis could be considered a dynamical analogue of us in path space . for diffusive systems the partial path tis ( pptis ) was invented that uses the assumption of memory loss @xcite . in this article we discuss the case of sharp barriers . here recrossings occur mainly due to the wrong choice of rc . in a follow - up article we will treat the diffusive case . up to now , it is not clear how these methods compare in efficiency and the need for benchmark systems has been put forward several times . it is not always easy to perform comparative calculations since it is not simple to know if each method is equally optimized for a specific system . therefore , in this paper we analyze a system for which the efficiency of the methods can be calculated analytically with only a few approximations . this does not only give a transparent comparison of the efficiency of the different methods , but also allows to obtain scaling laws for how this efficiency changes as function of the barrier height and width . moreover , we give some rules for how the methods can be optimized , for instance , by choosing the proper width of the us windows and the position of interfaces in tis . these rules are important for the simulation community , as they can be used as a rule of thumb in daily practice , when any method needs to be optimized . the principal component to measure the efficiency of the methods will be the _ cpu efficiency time _ @xmath0 which is the lowest computational cost needed to obtain an overall statistical error equal to one . we give a detailed analysis of how @xmath0 can be calculated for some very general cases in the appendix sections [ sgn ] and [ secect ] . it also gives the important result of how one should divide a total fixed simulation time over a set of different simulations to obtain the best overall efficiency . in sec . [ secmet1 ] , we outline the first class of methods , the reactive flux ( rf ) methods , and present their principal formulas . in sec . [ secmet2 ] , we do the same for the second class of methods , the path sampling methods . [ secsys ] introduces the 2d benchmark system where the angle @xmath1 indicates how far the chosen rc is deviated from the optimal one . [ secres ] is the main section of our paper in which we apply the different methods of sec . [ secmet1 ] and [ secmet2 ] to the analytical benchmark system of sec . [ secsys ] . finally , we discuss the important point of hysteresis for the two types of methods and show that this is less likely to occur for the path sampling methods . we summarize the results in sec . [ seccon ] . moreover , to support the readability of this paper we have added a list of symbols and abbreviations in app . [ alos ] and [ aloa ] . in all combined free energy and transmission coefficient based methods , the rate equation follows from @xmath2 where the reaction rate @xmath3 is expressed as a quasi - plateau value at a time @xmath4 of a time dependent reaction rate function @xmath5 . this function is given by the corrected flux through an hypersurface @xmath6 , that is is a collection of phase points @xmath7 , defined by the reaction coordinate @xmath8 and transition state ( ts ) value @xmath9 . the ts value @xmath9 is standardly taken as the maximum in the free energy profile along @xmath10 . both tst , bc , bc2 and epf can be expressed as @xmath11 { \rangle}}{{\langle}\theta(\lambda^*-\lambda(x_0 ) ) { \rangle } } , \label{kgen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is the dirac delta function , @xmath13 the heaviside step function , @xmath14 is the phase point at a time @xmath15 , and @xmath16 is a trajectory that includes @xmath17 . ensemble averages @xmath18 in phase and path space are defined in app . [ subsensem ] . ( [ kgen ] ) measures the flux contributed by pathways leaving the surface @xmath9 at @xmath19 under the influence of a correction functional @xmath20 $ ] . the functional @xmath21 has different forms for tst , bc , bc2 , and epf . the rate equation ( [ kgen ] ) can be rewritten as a product of two factors : the probability to be on top of the barrier times the transmission function @xmath22 : @xmath23 with @xmath24 and @xmath25 { \rangle}_{\delta(\lambda(x_0)-\lambda^*)}. \label{defr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath26 implies that the ensemble @xmath27 is constrained at the surface @xmath28 . substitution of eqs . ( [ defr],[defrp ] ) in eq . ( [ kpk ] ) using eq . ( [ wens ] ) gives back eq . ( [ kgen ] ) . eqs . ( [ kpk]-[defrp ] ) show the two - step procedure . the probability @xmath29 and the time dependent transmission function @xmath22 are calculated in two separate simulations . as for the rate @xmath3 , the unnormalized transmission coefficient @xmath30 follows from a plateau in this time dependent function : @xmath31 . this factor corrects for the correlated recrossings . in [ subsfe ] , we discuss the methods to compute @xmath29 or , equivalently , the free energy barrier @xmath32 . then , in [ sectrans ] we discuss the methods to determine the transmission coefficient @xmath30 . define the following @xmath33 box functions : @xmath34 \theta[\lambda_r+i\gamma+\gamma-\lambda(x ) ] , \nonumber \\ w_m(x)&=\theta[\lambda(x)+d\lambda-\lambda^ * ] \theta[\lambda^*-\lambda(x ) ] , \nonumber \\ w_0(x)&=\theta[\lambda^*-\lambda(x ) ] , \label{windows1 } \\ w_j(x)&= \theta[\lambda(x)-\lambda_r-(j-1 ) \gamma ] \theta[\lambda_r+j \gamma+\gamma - \lambda(x ) ] , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath35 and @xmath36 . here @xmath9 is the ts , @xmath37 is a value in the reactant well and @xmath38 is a small length scale . @xmath39 and @xmath40 represent the dimensions of the us windows ; @xmath41 is the width of the window and @xmath39 is the overlap such that @xmath42 ( see fig . [ umbrel ] ) . neglecting higher orders terms in @xmath38 , we can write @xmath43 to calculate eq . ( [ freeensam ] ) , we can simply run an md simulation and count the number of times that the transition state region interval is visited . the weight function @xmath44 in the ensemble acts like an infinite wall at @xmath45 and prevents the unnecessary exploration of the product region . however , as @xmath46 is vanishingly small for high barriers , this straight - forward method will usually fail . using eq . ( [ wens ] ) and the relations @xmath47 , @xmath48 for all @xmath49 we can rewrite eq . ( [ freeensam ] ) as @xmath50 the final property is now calculated from a series of simulations in which each pair @xmath51 so that they can be determined accurately . the implementation of us using rectangular windows via mc is straightforward . the standard mc sampling is performed starting from a point inside the window . as soon as the mc procedure generates a point outside this window , this point is automatically rejected and the old point is kept . if the procedure is performed by means of md , the window boundaries simply act as infinitely hard walls . however , due to practical problems related to a discontinuous force profile , md simulations are usually performed with parabolic windows instead of rectangular ones . instead of performing several simulations using rectangular windows , one can also use a single biasing function @xmath52 : @xmath53 again , the equivalence between eq . ( [ freeensam ] ) and eq . ( [ ussb ] ) is easy to prove via eq . ( [ wens ] ) . the advantage of eq . ( [ ussb ] ) is that the error does not propagate as in the case of several windows . on the other hand , one needs to have already a good idea about the shape of the barrier to construct a good bias @xmath54 . the series of rectangular windows is a more robust way to explore the barrier region when no knowledge is available . the algorithmic procedure to sample points in the biased ensemble @xmath55 is explained in sec . [ subsensem ] . many other methods exist for the calculation of free energy surfaces . ti is of equally importance and is based on the constrained sampling at surfaces from which the free energy s derivative can be obtained at a given value of @xmath10 . integration of these derivatives results in the requested free energy profile . in addition , many variations of us have been devised , such as wang - landau sampling @xcite , meta dynamics @xcite , and flooding @xcite , where the optimal biasing potential is created on the fly . in tst , all pathways leading towards the product site @xmath56 are assumed to stay in @xmath56 for a very long time . the tst approximation uses eq . ( [ defr ] ) with @xmath57= \theta(\dot{\lambda}(x_0 ) ) . \label{chitst}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the barrier is sharp and a proper rc is taken , tst is a very good approximation or can even be exact . the calculation of @xmath30 , in tst , requires a simple numerical or analytical calculation . for instance , suppose that @xmath10 is a simple cartesian coordinate with mass @xmath58 , then @xmath59 and @xmath60 therefore , the free energy profile is sufficient to obtain @xmath3 whenever tst is valid . the bc equation is obtained using @xmath61 = \theta[\lambda(x_t)-\lambda^ * ] \label{chibc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq . ( [ defr ] ) . the evaluation of @xmath22 in eq . ( [ defr ] ) consists of releasing many trajectories that start from the top of the barrier . these trajectories only make a contribution different from zero if they end up at the product side of the barrier . it is important to note that a trajectory with @xmath62 that leaves the surface heading to the reactant state @xmath63 but finally ends up at the product state @xmath56 at a time @xmath15 , gives a negative contribution . the final value , which has to be positive per definition , results from a cancellation of positive and negative terms . the bc2 equation uses @xmath64 & = \theta[\lambda(x_t)-\lambda^ * ] \theta[\lambda^*-\lambda(x_{-t } ) ] . \label{chibc2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , besides ending in the product state , the trajectories integrated backward in time also have to end in the reactant state to give a nonzero contribution to eq . ( [ defr ] ) . however , here as well , the contribution of some trajectories are negative . this happens when the systems starts with a negative @xmath65 , but the forward and backward trajectories end up in the product @xmath56 and reactant state @xmath63 , respectively . these so - called s - curves ( trajectories that cross the ts surface more than 2 times within a short time ) are less likely to occur for sharp barriers . the epf equation arises when we take @xmath20=\chi^{\rm epf}[x , t]$ ] in eq . ( [ defr ] ) with @xmath66 & = \begin{cases } 0 , & \textrm{if } \dot{\lambda}(x_0 ) < 0,\\ & \textrm{or if } \lambda_{t ' } > \lambda^ * \textrm { for any } t ' \in [ -t:0],\\ & \textrm{or if } \lambda(x_t ) < \lambda^ * , \\ 1 , & \textrm{otherwise . } \end{cases } \label{chiepf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] despite the apparent mathematical more complicated form of eq . ( [ chiepf ] ) compared to eqs . ( [ chibc ] ) and ( [ chibc2 ] ) , the relation is quite is natural . the approach counts only the first crossings and only when they are in the positive direction ( see fig . [ figepf ] ) . in the effective flux formalism ( [ chiepf ] ) , all contributions are either zero or positive . in ref . [ ] , we presented a similar transmission coefficient formula . in this approach the pathway was stopped whenever the stable state regions @xmath63 and @xmath56 were reached . for a formal mathematical proof of the equivalence between bc- and epf - type equations see ref . [ ] . some other relations for the transmission different from eq . ( [ chibc]-[chiepf ] ) have been proposed . for instance , hummer @xcite proposed a relation that uses all the crossing velocities , in case of correlated recrossings , instead of just @xmath65 . ruiz - montero _ et al . _ @xcite devised a transition zone method for diffusive barrier crossings . this will be treated in more detail in the follow up article that will discuss the diffusive barrier case . suppose @xmath67 and @xmath68 are such that any @xmath7 with @xmath69 is at the reactant side @xmath63 and any @xmath7 with @xmath70 is at the product side @xmath56 of the unknown optimal ts dividing surface . it is important to note that @xmath8 does not have to be a proper rc to fulfill this criterion , but only has to distinguish between the two stable states . the tis expression is now given by @xmath71 here @xmath72 gives the flux through interface @xmath67 and @xmath73 is a history dependent function describing whether the system was more recently in @xmath63 or in @xmath56 : @xmath74 , for a phase point @xmath7 and its corresponding trajectory , if the system was more recently in @xmath63 than in @xmath56 and @xmath75 otherwise . in practice , the whole factor @xmath76 is calculated by counting the number of crossings in a straight - forward md simulation , divided by the number of cycles with @xmath74 , divided by the time step @xmath77 . the calculation of this factor is very cheap as interface @xmath67 is very close to the basin of attraction of state @xmath63 . on the other hand , the crossing probability @xmath78 is a very small number and can not be accurately determined by straightforward md . this is the probability that whenever the system crosses interface @xmath67 , it will cross interface @xmath79 before crossing interface @xmath67 again . as interface @xmath79 is an interface at the other side of the barrier , this probability is very small . the tis method overcomes this by defining @xmath80 interfaces between @xmath81 and @xmath82 . then , the total crossing probability can be expressed in a formula that contains conditional short - distance crossing probabilities @xcite @xmath83 here , @xmath84 is a generalization of the previously described overall crossing probability and denotes the conditional probability that , whenever the system leaves state @xmath63 by crossing @xmath67 and crosses @xmath85 in turn , it will also cross @xmath86 before returning to @xmath63 . if the distances @xmath87 are sufficiently small , the probabilities @xmath84 will be large enough so that they can be computed using a shooting algorithm @xcite . the shooting algorithm takes a random time slice from the old existing path and makes a slight randomized modification of this phase point ( usually only the momenta are changed ) . then , this new phase point is used to propagate forward and backward in time yielding a new trajectory . in tis , this propagation of the trajectory is stopped whenever the system enters @xmath63 or @xmath56 or , equivalently , whenever @xmath88 or @xmath89 are crossed . the pathway is accepted only if the backward trajectory ends in @xmath63 _ and _ the total trajectory has at least one crossing with @xmath85 . the fraction of these paths that cross @xmath86 as well , determines @xmath84 . although the form of eq . ( [ tiseq ] ) deceptively resembles a markovian factorization , no assumption has been made . as @xmath84 are not simple hopping probabilities , but incorporate the full history - dependence from @xmath67 to @xmath85 , the relation is actually non - markovian and exact @xcite . in analogy with us , instead of using a discrete set of interfaces , we could also bias the trajectory in a continuous way using a bias on @xmath90 @xcite . first we can write @xmath91-\lambda_b ) { \rangle}. \label{plm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath92 where the path @xmath16 is terminated when it leaves @xmath63 and enters region @xmath63 or @xmath56 . then , as in eq . ( [ ussb ] ) we can write @xmath93-\lambda_b ) \omega^{-1}(\lambda_{\max } ) { \rangle}_{\omega } } { { \langle}\omega^{-1}(\lambda_{\max } ) { \rangle}_{\omega } } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the algorithmic procedure would be the same as tis without the interface crossing constraint . instead , the acceptance - rejection criterion is adjusted as explained in sec . [ subsensem ] . a continuous bias has been applied within the original tps scheme . in ref . [ ] a bias on the end point of the path was used . alternatively , one can also bias the direction of the momenta change at the shooting point as was done in ref . the original tps rate calculation algorithm was introduced in refs . it first creates ensemble of reactive trajectories of a fixed length . these trajectories should constitute a time interval that is longer than @xmath4 where @xmath5 reach its plateau . then , a second series of simulations is required that combines the mc of pathways with a us technique . also these simulations use a fixed pathlength , but these can be shorter using a rescaling approach @xcite . in the end , the final rate constant can be constructed from the results of these two types of simulations . moroni showed that this algorithm is always less efficient than the tis technique and that the computational advancement of tis is at least a factor two @xcite . the tis improvement is partly due to the flexible pathlength so that each individual path can be limited to its strictly necessary minimum . moreover , tis has abandoned the shifting moves and has a stronger convergence ( no cancellation positive and negative terms ) . depending on the system and the required accuracy , the tis approach can easily become more than an order of magnitude faster than the original approach . the pptis method reduces the average pathlength even further as compared to tis using the assumption of memory - loss @xcite . in this method , the trajectories do not have to start at @xmath67 . instead , an ensemble of trajectories is generated that start and end at either @xmath86 or @xmath94 , but must have at least one crossing with the middle interface @xmath85 . from this , four crossing probabilities can be constructed that still inhibit some history dependence . once these are known for each @xmath49 , the final overall crossing probability can be constructed via a recursive relation @xcite . the milestoning method @xcite is very similar to pptis , but relies on a stronger markovian assumption that the system remains in an equilibrium distribution at each interface . on the other hand , milestoning uses time - dependent hopping probabilities which supplies a very general way to coarse - grain a dynamical system . the two aspects of pptis and milestoning could be combined as was suggested in ref . [ ] . finally , we mention forward flux sampling ( ffs ) @xcite . ffs uses the same rate equation ( [ tiseq ] ) as tis , but the sampling is different . in ffs @xcite , the crossing points at the next interface of the successful pathways are stored . the next simulation uses this set of points to initiate new pathways . the advantage is that ffs does not require any knowledge on the distribution @xmath95 . this allows to treat non - equilibrium systems as well . moreover , ffs creates effectively more pathways than tis with the same amount of md steps and does not rely on a markovian assumption as in pptis . however , the correlation between the different pathways is much stronger than in tis or pptis . therefore , ffs can only be applied when the process is sufficiently stochastic . we consider the following 2d potential : @xmath96 with @xmath97 and @xmath98 here , @xmath99 is the height of our barrier , @xmath100 is the barrier width and @xmath101 are the dimensions of the reactant region ( see fig . [ f2d ] ) . ) . @xmath99 and @xmath100 are the barrier height and width . @xmath102 and @xmath103 are the dimensions of the reactant ( and product ) well . @xmath104 is the assumed rc , while @xmath105 is another important degree of freedom . @xmath106 and @xmath107 are the maxima of the free energy functions for these coordinates . @xmath1 is the angle between the chosen reaction coordinate @xmath104 and the optimal one @xmath108 of eq . ( [ lamortho ] ) . [ f2d],width=302 ] the chosen rc is @xmath104 , while @xmath105 represents another important degrees of freedom . @xmath108 is the unknown optimal rc as its direction is orthogonal to the barrier ridge , the exact ts dividing surface . the angle @xmath1 is , hence , a measure of the quality of the chosen rc . to facilitate the analytics we assume a simplified dynamics : the particles propagate without dissipation and move only along the @xmath104 direction . once they collide with the walls , they obtain a new random @xmath105 coordinate @xmath109 $ ] and velocities @xmath110 taken from a maxwellian distribution . this type of dynamics satisfies ergodicity and ensures that the reaction rate is well defined for high barriers . although the low dimensionality and this dynamics might seem artificial , this minimalistic model already illustrates clearly the problems that occur in complex systems when no adequate rc can be found as we will see in the forth - coming sections . moreover , the potential can be viewed as a projection of a high - dimensional complex system . in that case , eq . ( [ v2d ] ) represents a free energy in which @xmath104 and ( the unknown but important coordinate ) @xmath105 can be any non - linear function of all cartesian coordinates . for instance , @xmath104 could be the simple distance between two atoms to describe the formation or breaking of a bond , while @xmath105 represents a complex solvent rearrangement . the surface potential energy at the barrier @xmath111 equals @xmath112 and , hence , @xmath113 here , we assumed that @xmath114 . the transmission coefficient can be obtained using eq . ( [ defr ] ) and @xmath115 of eqs . ( [ chibc2],[chiepf ] ) . the two equations are identical since there are no trajectories that can cross the surface @xmath116 more than two times before colliding with the outer walls . eqs . ( [ chibc2],[chiepf ] ) have only non - zero contributions whenever the backward and forward trajectory end , respectively , at the left and right side of the barrier after a short time @xmath4 , which is deterministically determined by @xmath117 . hence , @xmath118=\chi(\dot{\lambda}_x , \lambda_y)|_{t=0}= \theta[\dot{\lambda}_x-\sqrt{2(h - v(\lambda_x^*,\lambda_y))/m}]$ ] , which gives @xmath119 with @xmath120 hence , @xmath121 which yields by eq . ( [ kpk ] ) @xmath122 the reaction rate is , thus , independent of the angle @xmath1 . to quantify the efficiency of the different methods , we will calculate the cpu efficiency time , @xmath0 , that is defined as the minimal computational cost to obtain an overall relative error equal to one . efficiency _ is sometimes defined as the inverse @xmath123 of this quantity @xcite . in app . [ secect ] , we show how this quantity can be computed for some very generic cases . as the force calculations are the predominant steps in any ab initio or large scale classical simulations , all cpu values will be expressed as an integer representing the number of required md steps . in this way , we obtain a measure that is independent of the computational resources . in the following , we make two assumptions : * the correlation number is assumed to be the same for each simulation @xmath49 in the simulation series : @xmath124 * the mean cycle length @xmath125 of the path - simulations and transmission coefficient calculations are proportional to the average pathlength @xmath126 of the accepted paths : @xmath127 where @xmath128 are given in app . [ sgn ] and [ secect ] and @xmath129 is the average number of md steps of the accepted trajectories . hence , we neglect the fact that @xmath130 and @xmath131 can differ for each simulation @xmath49 in a simulation series . in fact , the equations that we will derive for tis are true even if a softer assumption is valid , i.e. that @xmath132 is constant for each @xmath49 . in general , @xmath133 is smaller than 1 as rejected pathways are usually shorter than the accepted ones . some rejections are even immediate @xcite and do not require any force calculations . the transmission coefficient calculation has @xmath134 as each point on the ts , obtained from the first free energy calculation , with randomized maxwellian distributed velocities is automatically accepted . still , the pathlengths @xmath129 can differ . as explained in sec . [ secmet1 ] , the rf methods consist of two independent types of calculations : the free energy and the transmission coefficient calculation . moreover , there exist several techniques to determine these two quantities . as the tst approximation ( [ rtst ] ) is exact for the @xmath135 case ( which basically reduces the problem to one - dimension ) , the only computational cost follows from the free energy calculation . contrary , when @xmath1 is significantly larger than zero we can expect that the transmission coefficient calculation is the dominant computational factor even though the free energy calculation becomes problematic as well ( see sec . [ susechys ] ) . focusing on the most dominant contributions we will therefore assume @xmath135 for the free energy and @xmath136 for the transmission coefficient calculations . first , to compare the enhanced efficiency of us techniques we need to know the cpu efficiency time @xmath0 of straightforward md . examination of eq . ( [ freeensam ] ) reveals that it simply corresponds to the calculation of the ensemble average of a binary function as in eq . ( [ taubin ] ) with @xmath137 . henceforth , using our assumptions ( [ assum],[asstaucyc ] ) we have @xmath138 . it is clear that the exponentially dependence on @xmath139 make straightforward md prohibitive for any high barrier or low temperature system . to obtain the overall efficiency for us using rectangular windows as expressed in eq . ( [ usrw ] ) , we first need the efficiency time @xmath140 for a single window . the principal result of this simulation @xmath49 equals @xmath141 . the general approach to calculate the efficiency time for a composite of two averages that are obtained simultaneously within the same simulation is explained in sec . [ subscq ] . in the app . [ uscpu ] , eqs . ( [ covij]-[partcov ] ) , we derive that the efficiency time for this single window is given by @xmath142 where @xmath143 . here , @xmath144 is a system - specific parameter , @xmath145 is an intrinsic of the simulation , and @xmath39 and @xmath40 have to be optimized . if we assume that @xmath146 is very large , we can neglect the difference of the first @xmath44 and last @xmath147 windows . following eq . ( [ effconst ] ) , the overall efficiency time is given by @xmath148 and as @xmath149 is not dependent on @xmath39 , we can minimize @xmath140 as function of @xmath39 to obtain also the lowest overall efficiency time . this optimum is achieved for half infinite windows @xmath150 where @xmath151 for all @xmath49 . as a result , the overall efficiency time equals @xmath152 eq . ( [ tefftot ] ) has a minimum for @xmath153 which gives @xmath154 the efficiency time is quadratically dependent on the barrier height @xmath99 and the inverse temperature @xmath155 . compared to straightforward md this is an enormous improvement . the optimal window boundaries imply that the fraction of phase points that is sampled in the right part of the window is given by @xmath156 . hence , @xmath40 should be adjusted to have approximately one fifth of the sampled points in the most right up - hill part of the window . in appendix [ uscpu ] , eqs . ( [ sigmacovw],[teffbcw ] ) , we derive the efficiency time for an ensemble average @xmath157 when it is obtained via a different ensemble using a weight function @xmath54 : @xmath158 . then , @xmath0 is given by : @xmath159 \nonumber \\ & + \big({\langle}\omega^{-1}{\rangle}{\langle}\omega { \rangle}-1 \big ) \big [ 1 + 2 n_c^{cc } \big ] \nonumber \\ & - 2 \big ( \frac{{\langle}\hat{a } \omega^{-1}{\rangle}{\langle}\omega { \rangle}}{a } -1 \big ) \big [ 1 + n_c^{bc } + n_c^{cb } \big ] \big\ } \tau_{\rm cyc } \label{teffbias}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath160 and @xmath161 . note that the correlation functions @xmath162 ( and @xmath163 for path sampling ) can depend in principle on @xmath54 as well . as eq . ( [ teffbias ] ) does not change whenever @xmath54 is multiplied by a single factor , we apply the normalization @xmath164 . assuming that eqs . ( [ assum],[asstaucyc ] ) are also valid in the biased ensemble , we write @xmath165 if we assume that @xmath145 has only a weak dependency on @xmath54 , we can minimize eq . ( [ teffbias2 ] ) by taking the functional derivative @xmath166 which gives ( see eqs . ( [ taueffbiasl]-[w2 ] ) ) @xmath167 as optimal weight function . coming back to eq . ( [ ussb ] ) using @xmath168 , the optimal bias follows directly from eq . ( [ optw ] ) and is given by @xmath169 where we used eq . ( [ freeensam ] ) and @xmath170 . substitution of eq . ( [ bias ] ) and @xmath171 in eq . ( [ teffbias2 ] ) and using that @xmath172 ^ 2 $ ] and @xmath173 gives @xmath174 hence , a scaling behavior independent of the barrier height or system size can be achieved . we have assumed here that @xmath145 is independent of the biasing function @xmath54 which is only true for certain types of mc such as those in which each cycle can be generated really independently ( hence @xmath175 ) . in general , mc sampling is a diffusive type of motion and the bias ( [ optw],[bias ] ) should also aid the exploration from the top to the reactant well and back . therefore optimal bias function should result in a more or less uniform sampling distribution , which is achieved when @xmath176 . taking this into account , the efficiency time is a bit larger @xmath177 , but still independent of @xmath139 . for the reasons explained in sec . [ eff1d ] , here we will study the case @xmath178 and , in particular , we assume that @xmath179 . substituting @xmath180=\chi[x]$ ] in eq . ( [ taueff ] ) and using eqs . ( [ std],[defr],[r2d],[assum],[asstaucyc ] ) , we can write a general formula for the cpu efficiency time @xmath0 for the rf method : @xmath181 where we used @xmath182 . we remind you that @xmath134 for the transmission algorithm as all generated phase points on the surface @xmath106 are accepted and used to generate trajectories . in [ bc2d ] and [ bc22d ] , we will use formula ( [ teffr2d ] ) to calculate the efficiency of the bc , bc2 and epf method . [ [ bc2d ] ] bc ^^ in the bc algorithm the pathways are propagated only forward in time . say @xmath183 is the longest time that the system takes to leave the barrier when released somewhere at the surface @xmath106 . hence , to have a guaranteed plateau in the @xmath184 and @xmath5 functions we simply have to integrate @xmath185 timesteps so that @xmath186 . the second unknown factor in eq . ( [ teffr2d ] ) is @xmath187 . for the simplified dynamics we are considering eq . ( [ chibc ] ) can be reduced to @xmath188 with @xmath189 and @xmath190 . following the same lines as in eqs . ( [ r2d0]-[r2d ] ) gives @xmath191 with @xmath192}{\int { { \mathrm d}}v e^{-\beta \frac{1}{2 } m v^2}}. \label{fbc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eqs . ( [ v2chibc],[fbc ] ) we made use of the mirror symmetry along @xmath107 . as the gaussian integral ( [ fbc ] ) has a symmetry as well along the @xmath193 axis , we can rewrite eq . ( [ fbc ] ) as follows @xmath194 substitution of eq . ( [ fbc2 ] ) in eq . ( [ v2chibc ] ) reduces eq . ( [ teffr2d ] ) to @xmath195 for large barriers , the exponential dependence on @xmath196 makes the method already prohibitive for relatively small angles @xmath1 . in bc2 the trajectories have to be followed until both forward and backward trajectories are no longer on the barrier . in epf , the generated point on the surface heading toward reactant state are accepted , but assigned zero without further integration . points on the surface with a positive velocity are first integrated backward and , then , integrated forward in time . this gives the advantage that whenever the backward trajectory recrosses the surface @xmath106 within a short period , this trajectory s contribution is assigned zero as well and the forward trajectory can be omitted . hence , we have @xmath197 and @xmath198 moreover , as s - curves are absent in this system the two path - functionals are identical : @xmath199=\chi^{\rm epf}[x]$ ] for all @xmath16 . a non - zero contribution of @xmath21 occurs only when both the backward trajectory ends in the reactant state and the forward trajectory ends in the product state . this implies that the velocity @xmath200 should be positive with kinetic energy higher than @xmath201 . hence , @xmath202 therefore , we can write the same equations as ( [ v2chibc],[fbc ] ) with @xmath203 instead of @xmath204 in eq . ( [ fbc ] ) , which gives @xmath205\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can neglect the @xmath206-term by invoking eq . ( [ erfc ] ) and omitting the terms of order @xmath207^{-1/2})$ ] . substitution of this in eq . ( [ v2chibc ] ) gives @xmath208 and , hence , eq . ( [ teffr2d ] ) yields @xmath209 although , the efficiency of eq . ( [ tbc2epf ] ) has been quadratically improved compared to eq . ( [ tbc2d ] ) , the exponential dependence of @xmath210 makes this method prohibitive as well when @xmath1 is significantly different from zero . as for the rf methods , the tis methods consist also of two types of simulations : the initial flux through @xmath88 and the crossing probability . however , contrary to the rf methods , in tis we might expect that the crossing probability is always the computational bottleneck . as @xmath88 is placed in the low potential energy region at the foot of the barrier , this flux is easy to compute for all values of @xmath1 . we will henceforth concentrate on the crossing probability for the two cases @xmath135 and @xmath211 . say @xmath212 , @xmath213 , and @xmath214 . for the pathlength we write @xmath215 where the constants @xmath216 and @xmath217 will be determined later on . as @xmath218 is basically an average of a binary function , that is 1 for the successful trajectories and 0 otherwise , we can invoke eq . ( [ taubin ] ) and use eqs . ( [ assum],[asstaucyc ] ) : @xmath219 @xmath84 is the flux through @xmath85 that reaches @xmath86 divided by the total flux through @xmath85 @xcite for trajectories that come from @xmath88 . hence , @xmath220 where @xmath221 equals 1 only if the backward ( forward ) trajectory crosses @xmath222 before @xmath223 @xcite . otherwise it is 0 . for the case @xmath224 , we can write @xmath225 and @xmath226 with @xmath227 the difference in potential energy of the two surfaces . hence , @xmath228 we take an equidistant interface separation such that @xmath229 and @xmath230 . moreover , @xmath231^m={\mathcal p}_a(\lambda_{m}|\lambda_0)=e^{- \beta h}$ ] or , equivalently , @xmath232 . this allows to rewrite eq . ( [ tefftisas ] ) as @xmath233 since we know the efficiency times for each simulation @xmath49 , we can calculate the total efficiency time of the whole simulation series . it is , however , important to note that @xmath140 is not a constant as in eq . ( [ taueffas],[tinf ] ) , but depends on @xmath49 . this raises an additional question of how one should divide a given total simulation time among the different simulations . a logical choice would be to use the same simulation time for each @xmath49 or to adjust the simulation times to obtain the same relative error in each part . we denote the total efficiency times using these two strategies @xmath234 and @xmath235 . surprisingly , for this case the two approaches are equally efficient and given by @xmath236 where we used eqs . ( [ effprod12],[effprod ] ) and @xmath237 . as we show in app . [ subsser ] , these two approaches do not yield the optimum efficiency , this would be attained when we assign each part @xmath49 a simulation time proportional to @xmath238 which yields @xmath239 minimizing eqs . ( [ efftistot ] ) with respect to @xmath218 shows that @xmath0 reaches a minimum for @xmath240 . hence , the tis procedure is optimized when approximately one out of five trajectories are successful . see the correspondence with us sampling [ usrec ] where one fifth was also the optimum for fraction of sampling point in the right uphill part of the window . using @xmath241 in eq . ( [ efftistot ] ) gives @xmath242 and @xmath243 . in practice , we have found a linear dependence ( @xmath244 ) of the pathlength on a steep barrier@xcite and quadratically dependence ( @xmath245 ) on a diffusive barrier @xcite . hence , @xmath0 is about 12 % and 33 % lower than @xmath234 and @xmath235 . note that eq . ( [ efftis ] ) has the same quadratically dependence on @xmath139 as us ( [ tauusrw ] ) . one should realize that normally @xmath246 and that @xmath247 usually has a strong @xmath100 dependence except for exceptional cases where mc cycles can be generated really independently . hence , the efficiency scaling of tis is comparable with that of us sampling using rectangular windows . as us has more flexibility to reduce @xmath145 than tis to reduce @xmath129 , us is probably a bit more efficient than tis by a single prefactor . in this specific system , the @xmath99 dependence of the tis efficiency is even a bit favorable than @xmath244 . in the app . [ app_efftis ] , eqs . ( [ tispath]-[erfc ] ) we derive that @xmath248 yielding @xmath249 due to a decreasing average pathlength , tis seems to have a slightly better scaling as function of @xmath99 than us using rectangular windows ( [ tauusrw ] ) . assuming a lower prefactor for us , this will imply that the tis efficiency approaches the us efficiency eq . ( [ tauusrw ] ) at increasing barrier heights . however , eqs . ( [ ggtis],[tefftisgg ] ) break down for very high barriers as the average tis pathlength @xmath129 can , of course , in practice never decrease below one md step . we can exactly follow the same lines as eqs . ( [ teffbias],[effussw ] ) which gives for the ideal biasing function [ biasmax ] @xmath250 and the overall efficiency @xmath251 hence , the ideal bias function ( [ tisbias ] ) allows to obtain a scaling independent of @xmath139 as in eq . ( [ effussw ] ) . note once more that generally @xmath252 . as for us , if we take into account the diffusive behavior of the sampling , @xmath145 is likely very large when the bias ( [ tisbias ] ) is used . this bias favors only trajectories that reach state @xmath56 , but does not aid the system to climb the barrier in successive cycles . therefore , a bias that generates a more uniform distribution is more advantageous than eq . ( [ tisbias ] ) . however , this does not affect the scaling dependency on @xmath139 . the estimation of the optimal interface separation on a straight slope is a bit difficult for path sampling methods like pptis , milestoning , and ffs ( note that the pptis memory - loss assumption is satisfied on the strictly increasing barrier even if the system is not diffusive @xcite ) . an efficiency analysis of ffs @xcite using the approximation ( [ assum_unc ] ) revealed that @xmath0 is constantly decreasing as function of the number of interfaces . the same result would be valid for pptis . however , as correctly stated in ref . [ ] , the apparent conclusion , that the computational cost can be made vanishingly small using an infinite set of infinitesimal spaced interfaces , is purely artifical . if one takes into account that there is a minimum path length ( of at least 1 md step ) , also the pptis and ffs show a quadratic dependence on @xmath139 . considering the lower path length , the efficiency is likely to be very close to us using rectangular windows . we take @xmath253 and @xmath254 ( see fig . [ top2d ] ) . , and @xmath89 . , width=302 ] with these outer - interface @xmath255 ensures that the system is at the flat left side of the barrier and @xmath256 ensures that the system has crossed the barrier ridge . as in eq . ( [ r2d ] ) we can write @xmath257 with @xmath258 the crossing probability along the line @xmath105 . now , the optimization of the full tis algorithm would yield an extended and tedious calculation . therefore , we derive an upper bound of the cpu efficiency time instead which is relatively easy . as in eq . ( [ patis ] ) , we can write for @xmath258 : @xmath259}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the additional @xmath260-term compared to eq . ( [ patis ] ) is because the potential energy can decrease from @xmath85 to @xmath86 along some coordinate @xmath105 . using equidistant interfaces with spacing @xmath261 , we have @xmath262 . hence , @xmath263 and @xmath264 we remind you that the higher @xmath265 the lower @xmath140 due to eq . ( [ taubin ] ) . the equal sign in eq . ( [ pg ] ) for all @xmath49 , would correspond to the @xmath135 case with barrier height @xmath266 and barrier width @xmath267 . therefore , we can simply invoke eq . ( [ efftis ] ) and write @xmath268 which has only a quadratic dependence on @xmath269 . this is far superior to exponential scaling of eqs . ( [ tbc2d],[tbc2epf ] ) . as a result , for high barriers and non - vanishing angles @xmath1 , the tis method becomes orders of magnitude more efficient than the reactive flux methods . of course , one might object that the reactive flux methods for this 2d system improve dramatically if we would chose @xmath270 instead of @xmath104 as rc . the reactive flux efficiency is then again identical to the @xmath135 case . however , this is exactly the crucial point . it is quite simple to find a proper rc in a low dimensional system , but in high dimensional complex systems this is certainly not the case . some methods have been devised that systematically search for rcs , but they have their limitations . the optimal hyperplane method @xcite and the string method @xcite rely on harmonic approximations and on the assumptions that these hyperplanes can be described as a linear combination of cartesian coordinates . complex reaction mechanism , notably chemical reactions in solution , require a highly nonlinear function as rc . the inclusion of important solvent degrees of freedom is not an easy task . some success has been made using the coordination number as rc @xcite . however , the influence of the solvent can be more subtle . in ref . [ ] , we found that electric contributions due to nearby spontaneous formations of tetrahedral ordered water molecules can be crucial to give a last push over the potential energy barrier . to incorporate such an effect in a one - dimensional rc would be an enormous task and can not be made without a priori insight in the mechanism . automated multidimensional us sampling approaches @xcite allow to explore the free energy surface efficiently in a predetermined set of order parameters . from the reduced free energy potential the most optimal one - dimensional rc could be estimated @xcite . however , as the predetermined order - parameter space is still limited to e.g. 6 coordinates , it is still likely that important coordinates such as solvent degrees of freedom can be missed . up to now , we have given expressions for the efficiency times while treating the effective correlation @xmath145 as a simple constant factor . the calculation of this factor is difficult as it depend on the intrinsic diffusive behavior of the mc / md sampling itself . fact is that @xmath145 can be significant larger 1 and usually has a scaling dependence on some system parameters ( like @xmath101 , @xmath100 , and @xmath1 ) . especially , the @xmath1-dependence can be severe and will be discussed in this section . us sampling and ti constrain the system in a small window or on a surface that drags the system over the barrier . we have assumed that the time consuming step in the rate calculation for the 2d barrier is the transmission coefficient calculation . in fact , the calculation of the free energy barrier can also be very hard due to an improper rc . this problem is known as the hysteresis problem which basically results in a diverging @xmath145 . evidently , one could ask whether this problem occurs in tis as well . if this would be the case , the tis efficiency would be much less advantageous as suggested by eq . ( [ efftis2d ] ) . we will show that sampling of paths instead of phase points alleviates or even eliminates the hysteresis problem entirely . the hysteresis problem does not occur in the 2d system we are considering , but can still persist , although still less than in free energy methods , for systems that have multiple reaction channels . consider the potential defined by eq . ( [ v2d ] ) and the hypersurfaces @xmath271 and @xmath89 as depicted in fig . [ top2d ] . suppose that we apply ti or us using small windows located at these surfaces . the distribution at these surfaces along the @xmath105 direction is then given by @xmath272 where @xmath85 can be either @xmath271 and @xmath89 . in tis , we could look at the distribution of first crossing points with the @xmath85 interface . this distribution is given by ( @xmath189 ) @xmath273 the additional @xmath200-term in the nominator and denominator of eq . ( [ disttis ] ) compared to eq . ( [ distrf ] ) is due to the fact that tis looks at crossing points while the free energy distribution looks at points on the surface . a crossing point is a point that can cross the surface in a single timestep and because @xmath274 @xcite the additional @xmath200-term appears . the other term @xmath275 in eq . ( [ disttis ] ) that is missing in eq . ( [ distrf ] ) ensures that not all velocities are considered . starting from @xmath7 going backward in time , @xmath88 should be hit before @xmath85 . this implies that we can write @xmath276 if @xmath277 and @xmath278 for @xmath279 . substituting this in eq . ( [ disttis ] ) yields @xmath280 with @xmath281 . [ disttitis ] shows the distributions of eqs . ( [ titis ] ) for three interfaces for the case @xmath282 , @xmath283 and @xmath284 . coordinate for three surfaces and the ti / us and tis methods . , width=226 ] at the first interface in fig . [ disttitis ] , the two sampling distributions of eqs . ( [ titis ] ) are exactly the same . the distribution is maximized at the left side of @xmath107 . however , at the interface @xmath111 the two distributions are very different . the ti / us distribution has now two maxima at either side of @xmath107 . as md and most mc schemes generate a new phase points by making small displacements from the previous point , the low probability region in the middle needs to be crossed to sample the distribution at either side . however , as crossing this low probability region is a rare event on itself , the system might not cross this region during whole simulation period . on the other hand , once the ti surface or us window is dragged over the barrier , the distribution is peaked at the right side of @xmath107 as can been seen from the shape of the distribution at @xmath89 . if we move the surface back from @xmath89 to @xmath106 , the system would be stuck again , but now at the right side of @xmath107 , which illustrates the hysteresis problem . only when the sampling is done extensively long , both maxima at the surface @xmath106 can be sampled in a single simulation . however , all measurements between two crossing events are correlated and basically contribute as a single uncorrelated measurement . hence , @xmath285 becomes exceedingly large . tis does not have this problem . the distribution at @xmath106 has still only one maxima . the distribution becomes uniform at @xmath89 . the divergence of @xmath286 is , hence , not to be expected . only when there are distinctive different reaction channels , ergodic sampling becomes difficult as for any method . still the sampling of multiple reaction channels is likely more effective using path sampling than ti or us due to the non - locality of the shooting move @xcite . these findings and the results of [ tis2d ] actually prove the relative insensitivity of tis to the rc as compared to the rf methods . this quality has been assigned to path sampling methods before , but to our knowledge , this is the first time that this is rigorously proven for reaction rate calculation methods . this points out a significant advantage of tis for systems for which a proper rc can not easily be derived . it is important to note that other path sampling approaches such as pptis ( or milestoning ) and ffs do not have this advantage . the pptis approximation fails for @xmath211 except when the interfaces are very far apart . for instance , consider the interfaces @xmath287 with @xmath288 . the pptis memory - loss assumption reveals that the trajectories that start at @xmath94 and cross @xmath289 have on average the same probability to reach @xmath86 as the trajectories that start at @xmath290 and cross @xmath289 . this can only be valid if @xmath291 ( see fig . [ top2d ] ) . if @xmath94 is set closer to @xmath85 , many trajectories that cross @xmath94 along a lines @xmath292 will not come from @xmath88 if they are followed backward in time and the pptis approximation results in an overestimation of the reaction rate . in turn , the large interface distances results that some of the pptis crossing probabilities are very small and can only be determined efficiently using tis . ffs , although in principle exact , also has a problem for non - zero angles @xmath1 . as ffs only propagates forward in time using the successful paths from the previous simulation , all the simulations become correlated . this implies that whenever the simulation at the first interface is in error , all other simulation results will be erroneous as well even if these simulations are performed infinitely long . this is a direct effect of the non - validity of eq . ( [ assum_unc ] ) for ffs . coming back to fig . [ disttitis ] , the flat distribution at @xmath89 can only be reproduced using ffs when at the previous interfaces ( as @xmath106 and @xmath293 ) a significant number of pathways is sampled in low - populated right tail of the path distribution which requires the sampling of an extremely large number of pathways . we have derived analytical expressions to determine the efficiency of different computational methods for the calculation of reaction rates . the efficiency has been expressed as the computational cost to obtain an overall relative error of 1 when all algorithmic parameters are optimized . we have called this property the cpu efficiency time @xmath0 . in app . [ secect ] , we have derived the cpu efficiency for very general cases . this also reveals an important generic result of how one should divide a fixed total simulation time among a set of independent simulations to get the lowest overall error . after a first round of simulations , reasonable estimates of @xmath140 can be obtained . then , the minimal additional simulation time , needed in each simulation , to obtain the overall best performance can be calculated and used for a second round of simulations . this approach can be very profitable and it is not restricted to rate calculations . we have applied these rules to determine the efficiency of a simple 2d benchmark system that allows an analytical approach . this offers a way to compare the efficiency of the different methods in a very transparent way . the two classes of methods that we compared are the rf methods and the path sampling methods . the rf methods consists of the calculation of the free energy barrier and the calculation of the transmission coefficient . both for the free energy as for the transmission coefficient calculation different methods exist . for the free energy calculation we compared two approaches of us . one using a series of rectangular windows and one using a single optimal biasing potential . for the path sampling methods , we have concentrated on the tis technique which is an improvement upon the original tps algorithm to calculate rates . the pptis approach reduces the computational cost even more but relies on the approximation of memory loss. as for us , we suggest that a single bias potential based on @xmath294 $ ] could replace the discrete set of interfaces . the @xmath135 case corresponds to the situation where the chosen rc is optimal . the tst approximation is then exact so that the free energy calculation is sufficient for the rf methods . we found an efficiency scaling equal to @xmath295 for us using rectangular windows . we obtained the same scaling rules for standard tis . using a single continuous bias potential , the us and tis efficiency can , in the optimal case , become independent of the barrier height and temperature . however , knowing the optimal bias basically implies that one already knows the answer . us using several windows and standard tis are more robust approaches if no a - priori knowledge of the system is available . this shows that tis and us compare very well in efficiency for all barrier heights and temperatures and that the difference can only rely in a single prefactor . it is likely that us is a bit better than tis that has to be faithful to the natural dynamics of the system . us has more flexibility to optimize the method such as choosing the best mc moves that minimizes the number of correlations . when @xmath211 , the chosen rc , @xmath104 , is no longer optimal . in contrast to the @xmath135 case , the principal computational effort of the rf method lies in the calculation of the dynamical correction . we showed that the bc method scales as @xmath296 , while the bc2 and epf methods are quadratically more efficient . the epf method is , however , a bit more than a factor 2 more faster than the bc2 method . the exponential dependence on @xmath297 indicates that a small deviation from the optimal rc can have dramatic consequences for the efficiency of the rf methods if they are applied to high barrier or low temperature systems . in contrast , the tis efficiency scaling is only @xmath298 . we also discuss the potential problem of hysteresis in us and ti when a non - optimal rc is chosen and why this problem does not occur for tis for the 2d barrier . this gives another evidence that the tis method is less sensitive the choice of rc . the advantage that path sampling does not require a rc has been advocated many times . however , although this statement is quite evident if the main object is to sample a representative set of reactive trajectories , it is not so evident for the calculation of reaction rates . the calculation of the reaction rate still requires a rc ( the only exception we know of is the method proposed in ref . [ ] using the pathlength as transition parameter ) . however , we are now the first to prove that a path sampling - based reaction rate calculation method , using tis , is potentially orders of magnitude faster than the rf - based methods whenever the right rc can not be determined . the reason is because tis uses an importance sampling technique to calculate the dynamical factor . the importance sampling of the rf methods only concentrates on the free energy . therefore , whenever the dynamical factor is low ( e.g. due to a wrong choice of rc ) , these methods automatically run into problems . the main question remains whether it is more profitable to search for a good rc and use the rf methods , or take a simple order parameter ( non - optimal rc ) and use the tis method . this question has not an easy answer and depends on the complexity of the system . i would like to thank daniele moroni for fruitful discussions and carefully reading this paper . i am also grateful to rosalind allen who made useful suggestions to improve the first version of this paper . this work was support by a marie curie intra - european fellowships ( meif - ct-2003 - 501976 ) within the 6th european community framework programme . we denote with @xmath7 a phase space point @xmath299 where @xmath300 are the cartesian coordinates and @xmath301 the momenta . the examples presented here consider only 1 particle in a two - dimensional potential , but @xmath302 are in general multidimensional vectors . the distribution of @xmath7 is given by the probability density @xmath95 . in case of boltzmann statistics @xmath303 with @xmath304 the total energy at phase point @xmath7 and @xmath305 with @xmath306 the temperature and @xmath307 the boltzmann constant . suppose @xmath308 is the value of a quantity we want to compute . in many cases such a quantity equals the expectation value of a certain observable . we denote this observable with @xmath309 which is a function of @xmath7 . then the expectation value or population mean @xmath310 is given by @xmath311 and @xmath312 for this specific case . path sampling simulations require a more extensive formulation especially when stochastic dynamics is applied . the discrete representation of a path is the most convenient , where a path @xmath16 is defined as a set of @xmath313 successive phase points that determine the system at intervals of @xmath77 along a certain trajectory : @xmath314 . in tis , the backward @xmath315 and forward @xmath316 time indices are not fixed , but depend on when a certain interface is crossed . the weight of the path is given by the initial distribution at time @xmath19 and the probability densities corresponding to the history and future of the path : @xmath317=\rho(x_0 ) & \prod_{i=1}^{\tau^b } p_{\rm n}(x_{(1-i)\delta t } \leftarrow x_{-i \delta t})\nonumber \\ \times & \prod_{i=1}^{\tau^f } p_{\rm n}(x_{(i-1)\delta t}\rightarrow x_{i \delta t } ) \label{pathweight1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath318 is the probability that the natural dynamics of the system brings you from @xmath7 to @xmath319 given you are in @xmath7 , and @xmath320 is the probability that if you are in @xmath7 you came from @xmath319 in the past . as shown in ref . [ ] , whenever the system is in a steady state , eq . ( [ pathweight1 ] ) is identical to @xmath317=\rho(x_{-\tau^b \delta t})\prod_{i=1}^{\tau^b+\tau^f } & p_{\rm n}(x_{(i-\tau^b-1)\delta t } \rightarrow x_{(i-\tau^b)\delta t } ) \label{pathweight2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to the path weight as expressed in the original tps papers @xcite with the only difference that the starting index is @xmath321 instead of 0 . now , if @xmath180 $ ] is a function defined in path space , the population mean is given by @xmath322 { \rangle}=\frac{\int { \mathcal d}x \ , \hat{a}[x ] p[x ] } { \int { \mathcal d}x \ , p[x ] } , \label{pathav}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath323 and @xmath324 $ ] given by eq.([pathweight1 ] ) . in the following , we use @xmath325 as a point that is defined in either phase or path space , i.e. @xmath325 can either represent @xmath7 or @xmath16 . besides the simple ensemble averages ( [ phaseav ] ) and ( [ pathav ] ) , we can also define the biased ensemble average @xmath326 using a weight function @xmath327 . this biased ensemble is defined as @xmath328 in practice , sampling the biased ensemble @xmath329 by means of md simply requires the addition of a term @xmath330 to the potential of the system . in mc , this is achieved by a change of the acceptance - rejection criterion from @xmath331 $ ] to @xmath332 $ ] with @xmath333 and @xmath334 the new and old generated mc points @xcite . ensemble averages in path space @xmath335 { \rangle}$ ] can depend on the type of dynamics ( hence , on the hopping probabilities @xmath336 ) . to specify this dependency , explicitly , we use @xmath337 , which allows to generalize these path ensemble averages to arbitrary dynamics . the hopping probabilities of a simulation method @xmath338 can be of any type , for instance monte carlo , and do not need to be related to the natural dynamics of the system . therefore , these ensemble averages are annotated by @xmath339 . when @xmath340 is not specified , we assume that the natural dynamics is applied or that the property is independent of the hopping probability @xmath301 . hence , in our notation @xmath335 { \rangle}={\langle}a[x ] { \rangle}_1={\langle}a[x ] { \rangle}_{;p_{\rm n}}= { \langle}a[x ] { \rangle}_{1;p_{\rm n}}$ ] . the standard deviation of @xmath341 is defined as @xmath342 related to the standard deviation is the variance of @xmath341 @xmath343 and the covariance of two functions @xmath341 and @xmath344 @xmath345 with @xmath346 . a simulation @xmath49 , which can either be mc , md , or tps / tis generates a set of points @xmath347 in either phase or path space . each point @xmath348 is simulated with a certain probability @xmath349 and the chance that after @xmath348 another point @xmath350 is sampled is given by @xmath351 . we denote @xmath352 . now , the sample mean @xmath353 for a simulation of length @xmath354 is given by @xmath355 eq . ( [ sammean ] ) converges to the exact value , @xmath356 , in the limit @xmath357 . the standard deviation in the mean @xmath358 is defined as the standard deviation in the set of points @xmath359 that is obtained after performing a large number of independent simulations , @xmath360 , each of length @xmath354 and with result @xmath361 . hence , we can write @xmath362 using time translation invariance , we can show that @xmath363 and @xmath364 . now , we assume an exponentially decay in correlation for large @xmath365 which yields for large @xmath354 : @xmath366 \big\ } \label{stdm2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which gives @xmath367 in eq . ( [ stdm ] ) , @xmath368 is the correlation number or the integrated auto - correlation function , which is a special case of @xmath369 , defined as @xmath370 with @xmath371 if two functions @xmath341 and @xmath344 are uncorrelated , @xmath372 . hence , if the simulation data are not correlated @xmath373 and @xmath374 and @xmath375 . let @xmath376 be the absolute error of a quantity @xmath308 and let @xmath377 be the relative error . for a sequence of measurements @xmath378 , the absolute error in the average @xmath353 is defined as the standard deviation in the mean : @xmath379 using eq . ( [ stdm ] ) , the absolute and relative errors are @xmath380 this shows that it is of eminent importance for the efficiency of the method that the trajectories generated by the computer algorithm minimize the correlation number @xmath162 as much as possible . in mc , this gives rise to conflicting strategies . in general mc algorithms select a new phase point by making a random displacement from a previous point , which is then accepted or rejected . when the displacement is small , the new point resembles strongly to the old one which can be a source of correlations . on the other hand , if the randomized displacement is too large , it is likely rejected after which the old phase point is counted again . therefore , a high rejection probability also introduces correlations . the optimum maximum displacement is a compromise between these two effects . the creation of a single step in path sampling is much more expensive than standard mc or md , but , on the other hand , the correlation number @xmath162 is usually much lower . suppose a quantity @xmath308 is not equal to the expectation value of a single operator , but , for instance , depends on two other quantities @xmath381 and @xmath382 via a function @xmath383 : @xmath384 . the error in @xmath308 can then be determined using the error propagation rules . say @xmath385 and @xmath386 are the approximations of @xmath381 and @xmath382 after @xmath58 and @xmath354 simulation cycles respectively . the resulting error @xmath387 can then be derived as follows . as @xmath388 and @xmath389 are small for large values of @xmath58 and @xmath354 , we can invoke following taylor expansion : @xmath390 as in eq . ( [ deferr ] ) the error @xmath387 equals the standard deviation of the mean @xmath391 . hence , @xmath392 substitution of eq . ( [ defcov ] ) , ( [ deferr ] ) and ( [ stdm ] ) yields @xmath393 then , from @xmath394 , @xmath395 , @xmath396 we get the propagation rule for the relative error @xmath397 ^ 2 \delta b^2(m)+ \big[c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \delta c^2(n ) \nonumber \\ & + 2 \big [ \frac{\partial f}{\partial b}\frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f^2 \big ] { \rm cov}(\bar{b}(m),\bar{c}(n ) ) . \label{da2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs . ( [ damn ] ) and ( [ da2 ] ) are the most general rules for the propagation of errors when @xmath308 depends on two quantities @xmath381 and @xmath382 . it can straightforwardly be generalized to more arguments such that @xmath398 . let us define @xmath163 as the average cpu time to perform a single mc , md or path sampling cycle . moreover , we denote @xmath399 as the total cpu simulation time after @xmath354 cycles . we introduce now the cpu efficiency time @xmath400 to obtain a relative error @xmath401 equal to one . putting @xmath402 in eq . ( [ errs ] ) and using @xmath403 gives @xmath404 this is the general cpu efficiency time to obtain a relative error of 1 in a single simulation average . this cpu efficiency time is a characteristic property of the quantity @xmath308 ( actually of the whole function @xmath341 ) and the simulation method ( via the @xmath405 hopping probabilities and @xmath163 ) . whenever @xmath400 is known the absolute and relative errors after a simulation period @xmath406 are directly given by : @xmath407 if @xmath341 is a binary operator such that @xmath408 is either 1 or 0 , then @xmath409 in eq . ( [ std ] ) and eq . ( [ taueff ] ) equals @xmath410 therefore , the @xmath400 becomes very large for small values of @xmath308 and , hence , an accurate evaluation becomes problematic . the cpu efficiency time for a composite value @xmath384 , where @xmath411 and @xmath412 are determined simultaneously in a single simulation , can be derived following the the same lines as in eq . ( [ stdm2 ] ) for the covariance @xmath413 \big\ } \nonumber \\ & \approx \frac{1}{n } \big\ { { \langle}(\hat{b}-b)(\hat{c}-c ) { \rangle}\times \big [ 1 + \nonumber \\ & \sum_{l=1}^\infty \frac { { \langle}(b_0-b)(c_l - c ) { \rangle}_{;p_{\rm s } } + { \langle}(c_0-c)(b_l - b ) { \rangle}_{;p_{\rm s } } } { { \langle}(\hat{b}-b)(\hat{c}-c ) { \rangle } } \big ] \big\ } \nonumber \\ & = \frac{1}{n } { \rm cov}(\hat{b},\hat{c } ) \big [ 1 + n_c^{bc}+n_c^{cb } \big ] \label{cov2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we inserted eq . ( [ defcov ] ) and ( [ corfun ] ) in the last line . substitution of eqs.([erreff ] ) and ( [ cov2 ] ) into eq . ( [ da2 ] ) and using @xmath414 gives @xmath415 ^ 2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(b)}{\tau_{\rm sim}}+ \big[c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(c)}{\tau_{\rm sim } } \label{da3 } \nonumber \\ & + 2 \big [ \frac{\partial f}{\partial b}\frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f^2 \big ] { \rm cov}(\hat{b},\hat{c } ) \big\{1 + n_c^{bc}+n_c^{cb } \big\ } \frac{\tau_{\rm cyc}}{\tau_{\rm sim}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking @xmath416 and @xmath417 directly results in @xmath418 ^ 2 \tau_{\rm eff}(b)+ \big[c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \tau_{\rm eff}(c ) \label{cpucomp } \\ & + 2 \big [ \frac{\partial f}{\partial b}\frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f^2 \big ] { \rm cov}(\hat{b},\hat{c } ) \big\ { 1 + n_c^{bc}+n_c^{cb } \big\ } \tau_{\rm cyc } \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath419 and @xmath420 are given by eq . ( [ taueff ] ) . for example , if @xmath421 , the efficiency time of @xmath308 equals @xmath422 suppose @xmath384 and @xmath385 and @xmath386 are obtained via two different simulations . hence , @xmath354 and @xmath58 are not necessarily the same . in the following we assume that the different simulations are uncorrelated . thus , we assume that for two different simulations ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) the following holds @xmath423 here , the subscript @xmath424 indicates that the ensemble average can depend on how the two simulations are connected . assumption ( [ assum_unc ] ) is , for instance , true for us when two independent simulations are performed using two overlapping windows . it also holds for tis where the outcome of an interface sampling simulation at a certain interface is independent of the result of the previous interface simulation results . ( [ assum_unc ] ) does not hold for the most common implementation of the reactive flux method . in this approach , the importance sampling to determine the free energy barrier is simultaneously used to obtain a representative set of configuration points at the ts dividing surface . these configurations with randomized gaussian distributed velocities initiate the dynamical trajectories that determine the transmission coefficient @xcite . moreover , at variance with tis , eq . ( [ assum_unc ] ) is not true for the forward flux sampling ( ffs ) method , that was devised by allen _ et al . _ @xcite . here , the result of the interface sampling at one interface depends on the results of all the previous interfaces . the importance of eq . ( [ assum_unc ] ) is further discussed in sec . [ susechys ] . if the total simulation time @xmath425 is fixed , we still have some freedom in choosing @xmath354 and @xmath58 or , equivalently , choosing @xmath426 and @xmath427 . first , by substitution of eqs . ( [ erreff ] ) and ( [ assum_unc ] ) into eq . ( [ da2 ] ) we obtain @xmath428 ^ 2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(b)}{\tau_{\rm sim}(b ) } + \big [ c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(c)}{\tau_{\rm sim}(c)}. \label{d2a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] a logical approach , although not the optimum , is to give each simulation the same simulation time . we will denote the efficiency time that results from this strategy @xmath429 . taking @xmath430 for @xmath431 and @xmath416 gives @xmath432 ^ 2 \tau_{\rm eff}(b ) + \big [ c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \tau_{\rm eff}(c ) \big ] . \label{teffa1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] alternatively , we could try to obtain the same error in each simulation . the corresponding efficiency time will be annotated as @xmath235 . then , we need to use simulation times proportional to @xmath433 . hence , we take @xmath434 $ ] and @xmath435 $ ] in eq . ( [ d2a ] ) which results in @xmath436 ^ 2 + \big [ c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \big ] . \label{teffa2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to determine the lowest @xmath0 , we add lagrange - multipliers constrains to eq . ( [ d2a ] ) in order to fix the total simulation time @xmath437 @xmath438 \equiv \big [ b \frac{\partial f}{\partial b}/f \big]^2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(b)}{\tau_{\rm sim}(b ) } \nonumber \\ & + \big [ c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big]^2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(c)}{\tau_{\rm sim}(c ) } -\eta^2 \big\ { \tau_{\rm sim}(a ) - \tau_{\rm sim}(b)-\tau_{\rm sim}(c ) \big\ } \label{lagrange}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and minimize eq . ( [ lagrange ] ) with respect to all its arguments . taking the derivative to @xmath426 gives @xmath439 ^ 2 \frac{\tau_{\rm eff}(b)}{\big ( \tau_{\rm sim}(b ) \big)^2 } + \eta^2 = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , @xmath440 \frac{\sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}(b ) } } { \eta } \big| . \label{tsimb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have put the absolute signs @xmath441 as the simulation times needs to be positive . the same relation holds for @xmath427 . @xmath442 \frac{\sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}(c ) } } { \eta } \big| . \label{tsimc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can sum up eqs . ( [ tsimb ] ) and ( [ tsimc ] ) and use @xmath443 which gives the solution for @xmath444 @xmath445 \sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}(b ) } \big| + \big| \big [ c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big ] \sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}(c ) } \big| \big ) . \label{relq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , substitution of eq . ( [ relq ] ) in eqs . ( [ tsimb],[tsimc ] ) completes the equations for @xmath426 and @xmath427 . substitution of these two equations in eq . ( [ d2a ] ) results in @xmath446 \big| \sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}(b ) } + \big| \big [ c \frac{\partial f}{\partial c}/f \big ] \big| \sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}(c ) } \big)^2 . \label{ect2sim}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the efficiency time @xmath400 of eq ( [ ect2sim ] ) is always strictly less than or equal to @xmath447 and @xmath448 of eqs . ( [ teffa1],[teffa2 ] ) . these cpu efficiency times are straightforwardly generalized to simulation series of any number . suppose that the final desired value @xmath308 is obtained by @xmath449 , where @xmath218 refers to the exact value that should be produced by simulation @xmath49 and @xmath146 is the total number of independent simulations that are needed to determine @xmath308 . then , the cpu efficiency times eqs ( [ teffa1]-[ect2sim ] ) yield @xmath450 ^ 2 \tau_{\rm eff}^{(s ) } \big ] , \nonumber \\ \tau_{\rm eff}''(a ) & = \big ( \sum_{s=1}^m \tau_{\rm eff}^{(s ) } \big ) \big [ \sum_{s=1}^m \big [ a^{(s ) } \frac{\partial f}{\partial a^{(s)}}/f \big]^2 \big ] , \nonumber \\ \tau_{\rm eff}(a)&=\big ( \sum_{s=1}^m \big| \big [ a^{(s ) } \frac{\partial f}{\partial a^{(s)}}/f \big ] \big| \sqrt { \tau_{\rm eff}^{(s ) } } \big)^2 , \label{teffa12m}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath451 is the efficiency time of simulation @xmath49 . for example , in many methods , the final value @xmath308 is given by a product of simulation results : @xmath452 . then , @xmath453|=1 $ ] for any @xmath49 after which eqs . ( [ teffa12 m ] ) become @xmath454 and @xmath455 the same eqs . ( [ effprod12],[effprod ] ) are valid for the case @xmath456 with any @xmath457 $ ] . whenever @xmath140 is the same for all @xmath49 , eq . ( [ effprod12 ] ) and ( [ effprod ] ) become identical and equal to @xmath458 we will derive the efficiency time @xmath140 of a single window in us as depicted in fig . [ umbrel ] . the factor that needs to be computed in simulation @xmath49 is @xmath459 . here , @xmath460 , @xmath461 , @xmath462 , and @xmath463 . then , we can use eq . ( [ taucomij ] ) with @xmath464 and @xmath465 @xmath466 and applying the assumptions eqs . ( [ assum],[asstaucyc ] ) gives @xmath467 via eq . ( [ defcov ] ) , eq . ( [ taubin ] ) , and eqs . ( [ assum],[asstaucyc ] ) we get @xmath468 then using eq . ( [ windows1 ] ) and ( [ v2d ] ) and writing @xmath469 and @xmath470 we arrive at @xmath471 moreover , @xmath472 is only nonzero in case @xmath473 . hence , @xmath474 substitution of eqs ( [ bcus],[partcov ] ) in eqs . ( [ teffcov ] ) and , after that , substitution of eqs . ( [ teffcov ] ) in eq . ( [ covij2 ] ) yields eq . ( [ taueffas ] ) . + in order to derive the efficiency time for an ensemble average @xmath157 when it is obtained by a weighted ensemble via @xmath158 , we write again @xmath475 with @xmath476 , @xmath160 , @xmath477 , and @xmath161 . applying eq . ( [ wens ] ) gives @xmath478 and @xmath479 . then applying eqs . ( [ std ] ) , ( [ defcov ] ) using the ensemble @xmath329 gives : @xmath480 substitution of eqs . ( [ sigmacovw ] ) in eq . ( [ taueff ] ) yields @xmath481 \tau_{\rm cyc } , \nonumber \\ \tau_{\rm eff}(c)&=\big ( { \langle}\omega^{-1 } { \rangle}{\langle}\omega { \rangle}-1 \big ) \big[1 + 2 n_c^{cc}\big ] \tau_{\rm cyc}. \label{teffbcw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substitution of eqs . ( [ sigmacovw],[teffbcw ] ) in eq . ( [ covij ] ) yields eq . ( [ teffbias ] ) . to obtain the optimal biasing function , we add a lagrange multiplier to eq . ( [ teffbias2 ] ) to fulfill the normalization constraint @xmath482 the functional derivative of @xmath483 to @xmath54 for any operator @xmath341 and function @xmath383 is given by @xmath484 with @xmath485 . hence taking @xmath486 in eq . ( [ taueffbiasl ] ) results in @xmath487 { \mathcal n_c}+\eta^2 \big\}p(x)=0\end{aligned}\ ] ] which has as solution @xmath488=\frac{{\mathcal n_c}}{\eta^2 } \big ( 1 - \frac{\hat{a}(x)}{a } \big)^2 . \label{w2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath489 can be obtained , if necessary , via the normalization requirement @xmath164 . moreover , from eq . ( [ w2 ] ) follows directly eq . ( [ optw ] ) as @xmath54 should also obey @xmath490 for each @xmath7 . the tis pathlength ( [ ggtis ] ) can be obtained as follows . say @xmath200 is the velocity at the foot of the barrier ( @xmath88 ) at a time @xmath19 . the returning time is obtained by solving following equation @xmath491 , which has a solution for @xmath492 . within the path ensemble @xmath49 all trajectories should cross @xmath85 . hence , at the foot of the barrier the kinetic energy @xmath493 must be larger than @xmath494 . therefore , for the average pathlength we can write @xmath495 with @xmath77 the md timestep that is required to express @xmath129 as an integer representing the average number of discrete timesteps . in eq . ( [ tispath ] ) , we have first used the approximation @xcite @xmath496 and , then , neglected the @xmath497 terms . using @xmath498 and @xmath499 results in eq . ( [ ggtis ] ) . [ cols= " < , < " , ] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in the context of quantum information and quantum technology the idea of reading classical data by means of quantum states arises quite naturally @xcite . in general , the standard implementations of reading are based on optical technologies : the task is the readout of a digital optical memory , where information is stored by means of the optical properties of the memory cells that are in turn probed by shining light , e.g. a laser beam , on them . the probing light is usually denoted as the _ transmitter_. interesting features arise in the regime in which the transmitter has to be treated quantum mechanically . the maximum rate of reliable readout defines the quantum reading capacity @xcite . the latter can overcome the classical reading capacity , obtained by probing with classical light , in several relevant settings . the ( possibly quantum ) transmitter that is needed to extract the encoded information is prepared in some initial state . by scanning a particular cell the transmitter changes its properties in a way depending on the cell . the task is to recognize which cell occurs based on the output state of the transmitter after it has been detected and measured . therefore the problem of reading reduces to the problem of distinguishing the output states of the transmitter . in such optical settings one needs to consider two main coding protocols depending on the trade off between energy and coherence of the transmitters and the channels that are being used the first protocol is the so - called _ amplitude shift keying _ ( ask ) in which the changes in the state of the transmitter are caused by the cell - dependent losses in the intensity of the transmitted signal @xcite . the second main protocol is the so - called _ phase shift keying _ ( psk ) @xcite . this is a type of coding which does not produce energy dissipation . on the other hand , it requires a very high coherence of the transmitter , a feature that might be realized in realistic implementations @xcite . if the transmitter is quantum , the cells play the role of effective quantum channels . the ask protocol then corresponds to a dissipative channel coding , while the psk protocol is a particular case of unitary coding corresponding to a unitary channel . within the ask protocol , it can be shown that in the low - energy regime there is an energy threshold above which the maximally entangled transmitter , i.e. a two - mode squeezed state , yields a better reading efficiency than any of the classical states with the same energy @xcite . the general result is still valid in the presence of some noise - induced decoherence . within the ask protocol , coding is then realized by local channels corresponding to cells with different reflectivities . in the psk protocol , the coding is realized by means of local unitary operations , specifically local phase shifts @xcite . in the ideal , noise - free protocol the transmitter is taken to be in a pure gaussian quasi - bell state , i.e. a bell - type superposition of quasi - orthogonal coherent states . in this scheme , the resulting quantum advantage is absolute , in the sense that quantum reading of the classical information encoded via a phase shift of @xmath0 is achieved with vanishing error , while any classical state of the transmitter always yields a finite error probability . in both the ask and psk protocols the transmitter is assumed to be a bipartite system such that only one part of it scans the memory cell . this choice is motivated by the fact that it maximizes distinguishability at the output when the state of the transmitter is quantum . as already mentioned , the reading efficiency is characterized by the probability of error . information is encoded in binary memory cells with indices @xmath1 and @xmath2 . it is thus written using only two local channels that are assumed to occur with equal _ a priori _ probabilities . given the bi - partite input transmitter @xmath3 , the two possible output states will be denoted by @xmath4 and @xmath5 . the probability of error in distinguishing the two output states when reading a memory cell by means of the same input @xmath3 is given by the well - known helstrom formula @xcite : @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the trace distance , with @xmath8 . with our normalization convention , the trace distance ranges from @xmath1 to a maximum of @xmath9 for orthogonal pure states . in the original reading protocols the goal is to minimize @xmath10 over the set of possible transmitter states @xmath3 at fixed encoding in the memory cells @xcite . the problem is thus dependent on the type of memory device being used . here instead we wish to provide a device - independent characterization of a given transmitter by considering the worst - case scenario that maximizes the probability of error @xmath10 over all possible codings . once the worst - case scenario is identified , one can then compare different classes of transmitter states to identify the ones that minimize the maximum probability of error @xmath11 . we will show that the maximum probability of error @xmath11 is a monotonically decreasing function of the amount of quantum correlations present in the transmitter state @xmath3 , as quantified by a recently introduced measure of quantum correlations , the so - called discord of response @xcite in its gaussian version @xcite ( for general reviews on quantum correlations and distinguishability of quantum states and on discord - like correlations see @xcite ) . as a consequence , every state with non - vanishing discord of response is able to read any type of memory device with maximal @xmath12 . on the other hand , for each classical transmitter , i.e. for transmitter with vanishing discord of response , there will always exist at least one memory device which is completely invisible , i.e. for which @xmath13 . in these considerations we exclude the situations when two channels are chosen to be arbitrarily similar . in this case the probability of error always approaches @xmath14 independently on the chosen transmitter . in sec . [ errorprobdiscord ] we derive the exact analytical relation between the maximum probability of error and the gaussian discord of response . in sec . [ gausstrans ] we discuss the properties of classical and quantum gaussian transmitters , comparing squeezed - thermal , thermal - squeezed and coherent - thermal states ; in subsection [ gausstransa ] we derive upper and lower bounds on the maximum probability of error , and in subsection [ phaseshiftreading ] we identify the unitary coding that maximizes the quantum chernoff bound , namely the upper bound on the maximum probability of error , for the classes of quantum gaussian transmitters considered . the unitary channel which maximizes the bounds on the probability of error turns out to be a particular psk coding , namely the unique traceless one , which is realized for a @xmath15 phase shift . in sec . [ comparisonclass ] we compare the performance of gaussian quantum states of light with classical states ( coherent thermal states ) . we show that strongly discordant squeezed thermal states possess a higher reading efficiency than the corresponding classical states of light , that is non - discordant gaussian coherent thermal transmitters with the same total number of photons ( fixed energy ) . this realizes an important instance of noise - enhanced quantum advantage over the corresponding noisy classical resources . in sec . [ comparisonquant ] we compare different families of discordant gaussian states , the squeezed thermal and the thermal squeezed states at fixed total number of photons or squeezing . while for both classes of states the entanglement obviously decreases with increasing thermal noise , we show that for squeezed thermal states the discord is an increasing function of the number of thermal photons at fixed squeezing , while the opposite holds for thermal squeezed states . moreover , for squeezed thermal transmitters , the quantum chernoff bound is independent of thermal noise . as a consequence , this type of transmitter plays a privileged role in the considered class of quantum gaussian resources because the associated quantum efficiency is either enhanced or unaffected by increasing the thermal noise . thus squeezed thermal transmitters realize an instance of noise - enhanced or noise - independent quantum resources at fixed squeezing . both in the classical - to - quantum comparison and in the comparison of different quantum resources , the key enhancement of quantum advantage is realized in the situation of strongest asymmetry of the distribution of thermal noise among the field modes : _ local _ noise enhancement leads to _ global _ enhancement of quantum correlations . the main results are summarized and some outlook perspectives for future work are discussed in sec . [ summary ] . detailed calculations and auxiliary reasonings are reported in four appendixes . in protocols of quantum reading with unitary coding the two local channels acting on the input probe state @xmath3 are unitary , and denoted as @xmath16 and @xmath17 . therefore , in this type of protocol @xmath18 and @xmath19 , so that the probability of error reads @xmath20 since the trace norm is invariant under local unitary transformations , one has equivalently @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 is still a local unitary transformation acting on the transmitted subsystem @xmath24 . the absolute upper bound for the probability of error is thus @xmath14 , corresponding to a situation in which there is no way to distinguish the two output states and therefore the memory device becomes completely invisible to the transmitter . in general , computing the trace distance proves to be extremely challenging @xcite , even more so for gaussian states of infinite - dimensional continuous - variable systems @xcite . therefore one has to look for analytically computable _ a priori _ upper and lower bounds . a natural upper bound on the probability of error , eq . ( [ helstrom ] ) , in distinguishing two states @xmath25 and @xmath26 occurring with the same probability is provided by the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 @xcite : @xmath28 \ ; . \label{qcb}\ ] ] if the states @xmath25 and @xmath26 are not arbitrary , but they are qubit - qudit states related by a local , single - qubit unitary transformation , as in the case of the quantum reading protocol with unitary coding , for which @xmath29 and @xmath30 , then the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 is achieved for @xmath31 in eq . ( [ qcb ] ) , as discussed in appendix [ chbm ] : @xmath32 \ ; , \label{qcblu}\ ] ] and its expression coincides with the quantum bhattacharyya coefficient @xcite , which provides an upper bound on @xmath27 for arbitrary quantum states . the same result , eq . ( [ qcblu ] ) , holds for gaussian states related by traceless local symplectic transformations , as discussed in the following sections and in appendix [ chbm ] . next , considering the uhlmann fidelity yields a complete hierarchy of lower and upper bounds @xcite : @xmath33 where the lower bound on the probability of error @xmath34 , and the uhlmann fidelity @xmath35 between two quantum states @xmath36 is defined as @xmath37 . for the quantum reading protocol with unitary coding , let us consider the maximum probability of error in distinguishing the output of a binary memory cell encoded using one identity and one arbitrary unitary channel @xmath38 chosen in the set of local unitary operations with non - degenerate harmonic spectrum . the latter is the spectrum of the complex roots of the unity and its choice is motivated by observing that it excludes unambiguously the identity from the set of possible operations : indeed , unitary operations with harmonic spectrum are orthogonal ( in the hilbert - schmidt sense ) to the identity . we further assume that the coding is unbiased , that is the two channels are equiprobable . the worst - case scenario is defined by the probability of error eq . ( [ proberr ] ) being the largest possible : @xmath39 let us now consider a recently introduced measure of quantum correlations , the so - called discord of response @xcite : @xmath40 where the index @xmath41 denotes the possible different types of well behaved , contractive metrics under completely positive and trace - preserving ( cptp ) maps . the normalization factor @xmath42 depends on the given metrics and is chosen in such a way to assure that @xmath43 varies in the interval @xmath44 $ ] . finally , the set of local unitary operations @xmath45 includes all and only those local unitaries with harmonic spectrum . in the following , we will need to consider both the probability of error and different types of upper and lower bounds on it . therefore we will be concerned with three different discords of response corresponding to three types of contractive distances : trace , hellinger , and bures . the trace distance @xmath46 between any two quantum states @xmath25 and @xmath26 is defined as : @xmath47 \ , . \label{tracedistance}\ ] ] the bures distance , directly related to the fidelity @xmath35 , is defined as : @xmath48 finally , the hellinger distance is defined as : @xmath49 } \ ; \ , . \label{helldistance}\ ] ] for each discord of response , trace , hellinger , and bures , the normalization factor in eq . ( [ discofresp ] ) is , respectively : @xmath50 , @xmath51 . if the two states @xmath25 and @xmath26 are bipartite gaussian states related by local traceless symplectic transformations or bipartite qubit - qudit states related by a local single - qubit unitary operation , that is @xmath29 and @xmath52 , then , by exploiting eq . ( [ qcblu ] ) , it is straightforward to show that the quantum chernoff bound is a simple , monotonically non - increasing simple function of the hellinger distance : @xmath53 it is then immediate to show that the maximum of @xmath27 over the set of local unitary operations @xmath54 with completely non - degenerate harmonic spectrum is a simple linear function of the hellinger discord of response : @xmath55 the discord of response quantifies the response of a quantum state to least - disturbing local unitary perturbations and satisfies all the basic axioms that must be obeyed by a _ bona fide _ measure of quantum correlations @xcite : it vanishes if and only if @xmath3 is a classical - quantum state ; it is invariant under local unitary operations ; by fixing a well - behaved metrics such as trace , bures , or hellinger , it is contractive under cptp maps on subsystem @xmath56 , i.e. the subsystem that is not perturbed by the local unitary operation @xmath57 ; and reduces to an entanglement monotone for pure states , for one of which it also assumes the maximum possible value ( @xmath2 ) . by comparing eqs . ( [ perrmax ] ) and ( [ discofresp ] ) with @xmath58 , it is immediate to relate the maximum probability of error @xmath59 to the trace discord of response @xmath60 : @xmath61 from eq . ( [ perrdiscord ] ) it follows that half of the square root of the trace discord of response yields the difference between the absolute maximum of the probability of error ( i.e. @xmath14 ) and the maximum probability of error at fixed transmitter state @xmath3 . a vanishing trace discord of response implies that there exists at least one memory that can not be read by classical - quantum transmitters . a maximum trace discord of response ( @xmath62 ) implies that , irrespective of the coding , the maximally entangled transmitter will read any memory without errors : indeed , any local unitary operation with harmonic spectrum transforms a maximally entangled state into another maximally entangled state orthogonal to it , and therefore yields perfect distinguishability at the output . in the following , in order to compare the efficiency of classical ( non - discordant ) and quantum noisy sources of light in reading protocols , we will consider two - mode gaussian states of the electromagnetic field . the states with vanishing first moments of the quadratures are fully described by their covariance matrix @xmath63 @xcite : @xmath64 the range of values of @xmath65 and @xmath66 for which the corresponding states are physical ( i.e. correspond to positive density matrices ) is determined by the heisenberg uncertainty relation stated in symplectic form : @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the symplectic form . in all the paper , if we refer to the symmetric states we mean @xmath69 . in the following we will focus on two rather general classes of ( undisplaced ) gaussian states , the squeezed thermal states ( sts ) and the thermal squeezed states ( tss ) . the former are defined by two - mode squeezing @xmath70 applied on , possibly non - symmetric , two - mode thermal states . notice that the denomination sts is sometimes used in the literature to denote any gaussian states characterized by the covariance matrix eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) with @xmath71 . in the present work we adopt the convention that stss describe a physically rather frequent situation in which the thermal noise acts possibly non - symmetrically on the two modes , that is @xmath72 , and thus the total number of thermal photons is @xmath73 . here @xmath74 is the two - mode squeezing parameter and @xmath75 are the annihilation operators in each of the two modes ( @xmath76 ) . the diagonal and off - diagonal covariance matrix elements for these states , respectively @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 , read : where @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the number of squeezed photons . thermal squeezed states ( tsss ) describe the reverse physical situation : an initially two - mode squeezed vacuum is allowed to evolve at later times in a noisy channel and eventually thermalizes with an external environment characterized by a total number of thermal photons @xmath73 . the covariance matrix elements of tsss , respectively @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 , are : @xmath85 the same covariance matrix , eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) , also describes classical uncorrelated tensor product states , which we assume to be gaussian . thermal states are obtained letting @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 . these gaussian states are classical in the sense that they can be written as convex combinations of coherent states and , moreover , they are the only gaussian states with vanishing discord @xcite . notice that in the standard quantum optics terminology the wording classical states is used to denote any state with positive glauber - sudarshan @xmath89-representation . in the following , without loss of generality , we will identify party @xmath24 with mode @xmath90 and party @xmath56 with mode @xmath91 . for unitary - coding protocols with gaussian transmitters , gaussian local ( single - mode ) unitary operations acting on an infinite - dimensional hilbert space are implemented by local ( single - mode ) symplectic transformations acting on the covariance matrix @xmath63 of two - mode gaussian input states @xmath92 . in the following we will consider only traceless transformations . the traceless condition must be imposed in order to exclude trivial coding by two identical channels , for which the maximum probability of error is always @xmath14 . moreover , imposing tracelessness allows to investigate and determine the correspondence between reading efficiency and quantum correlations , as will be shown in the following . denoting by @xmath93 the local traceless symplectic transformations acting on mode @xmath24 , the two local unitary operations implementing the encodings of the binary memory cells are the identity @xmath94 and @xmath95 . in order to assess the performance of quantum and classical gaussian resources in the unitary - coding quantum reading protocol we need to evaluate the upper and lower bounds , eqs . ( [ qcb ] ) and ( [ errorineq ] ) , on the maximum probability of error @xmath59 , eqs . ( [ perrmax ] ) and ( [ perrdiscord ] ) , for gaussian two - mode transmitters @xmath92 . to this end , we introduce first the _ gaussian _ discord of response @xcite , i.e the discord of response obtained by minimizing over local unitaries restricted only to the subset of local symplectic , traceless , transformations @xmath93 : @xmath96 where the index @xmath97 stands for trace , hellinger , or bures distance with the same normalization factors @xmath98 as before , and @xmath99 is the transpose of the symplectic matrix @xmath93 and @xmath100 . the gaussian discord of response provides an upper bound to the true discord of response of gaussian states and vanishes on and only on gaussian classical states ( subset of separable states that are in product form ) . the main properties of the gaussian discord of response are reported in appendix [ appdiscord ] . in complete analogy with eq . ( [ perrdiscord ] ) the maximum probability of error in discriminating two gaussian transmitters related by a local symplectic transformation can be expressed as a simple function of the trace gaussian discord of response : @xmath101 specializing the bounds given by eq . ( [ errorineq ] ) to the maximum probability of error in distinguishing gaussian states , one has : @xmath102 where the lower bound @xmath103 is a simple monotonically non - increasing function of the bures gaussian discord of response : @xmath104 and the upper bound @xmath27 is a simple linear , monotonically non - increasing function of the hellinger gaussian discord of response : @xmath105 therefore , for increasing gaussian discords of response the bounds on the probability of error decrease correspondingly . the explicit expressions of the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 , the hellinger gaussian discord of response , the uhlmann fidelity , and the bures gaussian discord of response are derived in appendices [ uhlmanngaussian ] and [ chernoffgaussian ] . the probability of error in distinguishing @xmath92 from @xmath100 is given by eq . ( [ proberr ] ) with the local symplectic transformations @xmath93 replacing @xmath38 . among the local unitary operations @xmath93 which can implement the unitary - coding reading protocol , an important subset includes the single - mode phase shifts @xmath106 acting on mode @xmath90 , parameterized by the angle parameter @xmath107 : @xmath108 . under a local phase shift the local mode @xmath90 is transformed as follows : @xmath109 , while the two - mode covariance matrix @xmath110 transforms according to @xmath111 , where the symplectic matrix @xmath112 reads @xmath113 for the maximum probability of error , eq . ( [ gaussperrdiscord ] ) , the upper bound is achieved , from eqs . ( [ gaussbounds ] ) and ( [ qcbmax ] ) , in terms of a simple linear function of the hellinger gaussian discord of response . the latter , in turn , is obtained by minimizing the hellinger distance over the entire set of local unitary operations implemented on the covariance matrix by local symplectic , traceless , transformations . for squeezed thermal and thermal squeezed states one finds that this minimum is realized by the @xmath15 phase shift @xmath114 , that is the only possible traceless phase shift . therefore the extremal unitary - coding protocol in the ensemble of local traceless symplectic operations is realized by a particular psk coding , the phase shift @xmath15 , which is the only traceless psk coding . the details of the proof are reported in appendix [ chbm ] . on the other hand the quantity @xmath115 , eq . ( [ lbpmax ] ) , evaluated at @xmath15 , may not be optimal but certainly still provides a lower bound on the maximum probability of error : @xmath116 since for a @xmath15 phase shift the corresponding transformation is implemented by the traceless symplectic matrix @xmath117 , the expectation values of the canonical quadrature operators @xmath41 and @xmath118 transform as follows : @xmath119 and @xmath120 . therefore , undisplaced thermal gaussian states ( @xmath121 ) are left invariant , and the worst - case psk coding @xmath122 is completely invisible to classical transmitters ( thermal states ) since the @xmath123 shift does not change their covariance matrix . the probability of error @xmath10 for every such classical transmitter always achieves the absolute maximum @xmath14 . viceversa , the very same coding can always be read by any quantum gaussian transmitter with nonvanishing gaussian discord of response . as a consequence , quantum transmitters always outperform undisplaced classical transmitters in device - independent , worst - case scenario quantum reading . the situation changes when we consider displaced thermal states , as displacement unavoidably increases distinguishability . indeed the coherent and thermal coherent states are very efficient in detecting phase shift transformations . nonetheless , in the next section we will show that thermal coherent transmitters are outperformed by noisy quantum ones provided that the distribution of the thermal noise among the modes in the quantum resource is strongly _ non - symmetric_. we have seen that without displacement classical transmitters ( thermal states ) are completely blind to reading . introducing displacement enhances the distinguishability of output states and turns classical states ( thermal coherent states ) in useful transmitters . it is straightforward to show that distinguishability and the reading efficiency increase by implementing a single - mode displacement rather than a two - mode one with equal single - mode amplitudes . let us then consider a scenario in which one compares discordant quantum transmitters with displaced classical ones . we will show that in this case , that is comparing noisy quantum resources with distinguishability - enhanced noisy classical ones , discordant transmitters can outperform classical ones , and that the quantum advantage increases with increasing ( thermal ) noise . stated precisely , given the same coding @xmath124 acting locally on the first mode , we want to identify the regimes in which the probability of error associated to a quantum transmitter is smaller than the probability of error associated to a thermal coherent one . from eqs . ( [ qcb ] ) and ( [ errorineq ] ) this is equivalent to identifying the regimes in which the upper bound @xmath27 on the probability of error using squeezed thermal transmitters , denoted by @xmath125 , is smaller than the lower bound @xmath126 using thermal coherent states , that will be denoted by @xmath127 . obviously , only a constrained comparison at given fixed physical quantities is meaningful . we will thus compare squeezed thermal states and displaced thermal states at fixed purity and fixed total number of photons . we will observe that the quantum advantage is achieved provided the covariance matrix is not symmetric with respect to exchange of the modes . with these notations , the requirement for a _ bona fide _ quantum advantage reads as follows : @xmath128 both the coherent thermal and squeezed thermal states are two extremal classes of the general family of states which can be described as squeezed displaced thermal states ( sdts ) , defined as : @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the two - mode squeezing operator and we assume that squeezing parameter @xmath74 is real . here @xmath131 is the single - mode displacement operator and @xmath132 is the non - symmetric two - mode thermal state , where @xmath133 . the purity @xmath134 of the sdts is a function of the covariance matrix @xmath63 and depends only on the number of thermal photons : @xmath135 the total number of photons , @xmath136 , in the sdts reads : @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the number of squeezed photons . putting @xmath139 , sdtss reduce to thermal coherent states @xmath140 with total number of photons @xmath141 . decreasing the displacement amplitude @xmath142 the distinguishability of coherent thermal transmitters is reduced . we want to investigate whether this loss of distinguishability can be compensated by the quantum contribution due to increase of @xmath74 keeping @xmath143 and the purity fixed . in the limiting situation when @xmath144 the corresponding quantum state @xmath145 is a squeezed thermal state ( sts ) . in the following we will show that for stss @xmath145 and thermal coherent states @xmath140 with equal total number of photons @xmath143 , ineq . ( [ uplow ] ) is satisfied for some ranges of @xmath146 and @xmath147 . the condition of equal total number of photons @xmath143 implies @xmath148 . in order to evaluate the uhlmann fidelity @xmath35 and the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 in eq . ( [ uplow ] ) we need to know how the phase shift @xmath149 transforms the transmitters that we wish to compare : the squeezed thermal states and the thermal coherent states . the dependence of @xmath35 and @xmath27 on the displacement vector and on the covariance matrix of general gaussian states is reported in appendices [ uhlmanngaussian ] and [ chernoffgaussian ] . the uhlmann fidelity providing the lower bound on @xmath10 for thermal coherent states depends only on the displacement vector , since the covariance matrix of thermal coherent states is unaffected by the action of the symplectic transformation @xmath150 , where @xmath151 . without loss of generality , the displacement vector of a thermal coherent state can be written as @xmath152^t$ ] . under a @xmath15 phase shift the difference @xmath153 between the final and the initial displacement vectors reads as follows : @xmath154 the uhlmann fidelity of a thermal coherent state is then @xmath155 where @xmath156 . the @xmath27 of non - symmetric , undisplaced squeezed thermal state depends only on the covariance matrix , eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) , with entries eqs . ( [ ccvsqth ] ) , and its explicit expression is reported in appendix [ chernoffgaussian ] . in fig . [ boundsenergy ] , upper panel , we report the exact values of @xmath157 for a squeezed vacuum with squeezing @xmath74 , @xmath158 for a coherent state @xmath159 , and @xmath160 for a squeezed displaced vacuum with squeezing @xmath161 and displacement @xmath162 , in the absence of noise , @xmath163 , and at fixed total photon number @xmath164 . the coherent states outperform the quantum resources given by the undisplaced squeezed vacuum . the coherent transmitters are then compared with squeezed displaced vacua of the same energy . even if the latter include a classical contribution due to displacement and a quantum contribution due to squeezing they are still outperformed by the classical coherent states . the quantum efficiency converges to the classical one in the high - energy limit . for completeness , in fig . [ boundsenergy ] we also report the quantum chernoff bound @xmath165 for the squeezed - vacuum transmitters . , of the probability of error @xmath10 in the absence of thermal noise ( @xmath163 ) . blue dotted line : probability of error @xmath157 of squeezed vacuum states . black dashed line : @xmath158 of coherent states . green dot - dashed line : @xmath160 of squeezed displaced vacuum states with displacement @xmath166 . red solid line : quantum chernoff bound @xmath165 of squeezed vacuum states yielding the upper bound on @xmath10 with quantum transmitters . no quantum gain is not observed in this regime . central panel : behavior of quantum and classical bounds on @xmath10 as functions of @xmath143 at fixed asymmetric thermal noise : @xmath167 , @xmath168 . red solid line : quantum upper bound @xmath125 on @xmath10 with undisplaced squeezed thermal states . black dashed line : classical lower bound @xmath127 on @xmath10 with thermal coherent states . lower panel : same as central panel , but with stronger thermal noise : @xmath169 , @xmath168 . with increasing @xmath143 the quantum upper bound goes below the corresponding classical figures of merit and quantum transmitters certainly outperform classical ones.,width=264 ] in the presence of symmetric thermal noise , @xmath170 , there is no improvement in the quantum efficiency relative to the classical one . introducing non - symmetric thermal noise , e.g. @xmath171 , the gaussian discords of response , that are intrinsically asymmetric quantities with respects to the subsystems in a given bipartition , increase dramatically , and so does the corresponding quantum reading efficiency . as a consequence , for sufficiently strong non - symmetric thermal noise the quantum resources outperform the classical ones . in the presence of non - symmetric noise exact expressions for @xmath10 are no longer available . therefore , in the central and lower panels of fig . [ boundsenergy ] we report the exact lower and upper bounds on @xmath10 based on the uhlmann fidelity @xmath35 and on the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 . we observe that at intermediate values of the total number of photons @xmath143 the quantum upper bound @xmath125 on @xmath10 is strictly lower than the classical lower bound @xmath127 , assuring that the quantum resources outperform the classical ones . the classical transmitters ( thermal coherent states ) recover the quantum efficiency for large values of the total photon number . moreover , comparing the central and the lower panels in fig . [ boundsenergy ] , we observe that as the number of thermal photons @xmath146 is increased , the range of values of the total photon number @xmath143 for which one has a quantum advantage increases . in fig . [ rconstans ] we provide a plot of the contour lines for the differences @xmath172 for different asymmetries : @xmath168 ( upper panel ) and @xmath173 ( lower panel ) as functions of the total photon number @xmath143 and of the purity ( or , equivalently of the number of thermal photons @xmath146 ) . when these differences become negative , ineq . ( [ uplow ] ) is satisfied and the quantum resources certainly outperform the classical ones . from the upper panel of fig . [ rconstans ] , for @xmath168 comparing noisy quantum transmitters with noisy coherent ones , one observes that @xmath174 in a large region of parameters . fixing the squeezing , so that the change in the total photon number @xmath143 is due only to the change in the number of thermal photons @xmath146 , corresponds to a straight line in the plane ( in the figure , drawn at @xmath175 ) . remarkably , for these iso - squeezed states the quantum advantage increases with increasing number of thermal photons . this is an instance of noise - enhanced quantum efficiency that will be discussed further in sec . [ comparisonquant ] . in the lower panel of fig . [ rconstans ] we decrease the asymmetry @xmath176 . we observe that the quantum gain is also achieved but in the range of much higher @xmath177 . again , fixing the squeezing , e.g. at @xmath175 , we notice that the quantum advantage increases with thermal noise . we remark that these results are obtained in a scenario in which we compare the minimum quantum efficiency ( upper bound on the error probability using quantum transmitters ) with the maximum classical efficiency ( lower bound on the error probability using coherent thermal transmitters ) . therefore the actual quantum advantage will be even larger . for @xmath168 ( upper panel ) and for @xmath173 ( lower panel ) as functions of the total photon number @xmath178 and of the number of thermal photons @xmath146 . the region in which these quantities assume negative values corresponds to quantum transmitters certainly outperforming coherent thermal ones . the red dashed curve identifies its boundary . the straight solid yellow lines in both panels corresponds to a fixed degree of squeezing @xmath175 . moving along this lines in the direction of increasing number of thermal photons @xmath146 one observes that as noise grows there is a growing advantage in using quantum transmitters over classical ones . this behavior provides an instance of noise - enhanced quantum performance . the effect is reduced when the asymmetry @xmath179 decreases.,width=264 ] the quantum advantage disappears in the symmetric situation @xmath180 . indeed , the inequality @xmath181 expresses the condition that the mode which passes through the coding channels is more noisy . this condition is unfavorable for thermal coherent states and favorable for stss . namely , in stss with fixed finite squeezing , increasing the number of thermal photons in the first mode certainly increases the discord of response and , as a consequence , increases also the reading efficiency for this type of transmitters . this phenomenon is further analyzed in the following sections on the comparison of different quantum transmitters . these two concatenated effects cause the advantage of quantum states over the classical transmitters in the protocol of quantum reading with noisy transmitters . the asymmetry between the local thermal noise terms is the crucial element for realizing the enhancement of the reading efficiency . as we will see in the next section , the behavior of stss with increasing number of thermal photons in the symmetric situation @xmath180 , although not sufficient to realize a quantum advantage over classical resources , favors stss among other noisy quantum transmitters in the previous section we compared classical and quantum transmitters and for worst - case scenario we identified the regimes in which noisy but discordant quantum resources outperform classical thermal coherent ones . we also observed that the quantum advantage can increase , at fixed squeezing , with increasing thermal noise . we will now compare the behavior of squeezed - thermal and thermal - squeezed states in order to investigate how thermal noise affects the quantum efficiency of different classes of quantum transmitters . we shall compare symmetric squeezed thermal and thermal squeezed transmitters either at fixed number of thermal photons or at fixed squeezing . we will then consider how non - symmetric noise further enhances the quantum efficiency by suppressing the upper bound on the probability of error . finally , we will investigate how the quantum efficiency of different quantum transmitters improves when multiple reading operations are implemented at fixed thermal noise . let us start by comparing quantum reading with symmetric squeezed thermal and symmetric thermal squeezed transmitters at fixed number of thermal photons and its performance as a function of the total number of photons . this comparison is motivated by the fact that the interplay between quantum and thermal fluctuations is very different for these two classes of quantum states . squeezed thermal states ( stss ) are obtained by applying on thermal states , namely states that have already thermalized ( e.g. at the output of a noisy channel ) a purely quantum operation , two - mode squeezing , that can be interpreted as a re - quantization of the thermal vacuum . viceversa , thermal squeezed states ( tsss ) are realized by letting pure squeezed vacua evolve and eventually thermalize in a noisy channel . both squeezed thermal and thermal squeezed states are two extremal classes of the very general family of squeezed thermal squeezed displaced states ( stsdss ) which are defined as follows : @xmath182 s(r)^{\dagger } \ , . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath183 and @xmath184 are two - mode squeezing operators with different squeezing parameters @xmath74 and @xmath161 , @xmath185 is a single - mode displacement operator , @xmath186 is a noisy channel introducing @xmath146 and @xmath147 thermal photons respectively in the first and in the second mode . the channel acts on a given gaussian state adding the number of thermal photons to the diagonal entries of its covariance matrix . finally , @xmath187 denotes the two - mode vacuum state . we study this family of states at constant fixed values of the parameters @xmath146 and @xmath147 . the total number of photons in a stsds is : @xmath188 consider first the situation without displacement , @xmath144 , and with symmetric thermal noise @xmath189 . putting @xmath139 , stsdss reduces to thermal squeezed states tsts @xmath190 . decreasing @xmath161 and correspondingly increasing @xmath74 while keeping @xmath143 and @xmath191 fixed , in the limit @xmath192 one recovers the squeezed thermal states stss @xmath193 . let us compare these two extremal classes of quantum gaussian transmitters that coincide for @xmath194 and differ for @xmath195 or , in non symmetric situations , when either @xmath196 and/or @xmath197 . in fig . [ quantumquantum ] , upper left panel , we observe that for nonvanishing but small number of thermal photons @xmath191 the upper bound on the probability of error @xmath10 using stss still remains above the lower bound on @xmath10 using tsss . by further increasing thermal noise , as shown in the upper right panel of fig . [ quantumquantum ] , all bounds with stss are below all bounds with tsss and the stss certainly outperform the tsss . due to the different effects of the noise in stss and tsss we observe the clear advantage of using stss over tsss in a quantum reading protocol . the lower panels of fig . [ quantumquantum ] show the comparison done for displaced thermal squeezed states @xmath198 and displaced squeezed thermal states @xmath199 . at fixed total number of photons we observe that single - mode displacement always increases the reading efficiency for both classes of states , while decreasing the squeezing reduces and eventually wipes out the quantum advantage of stss over tsss these two classes of states coincide in the limiting case @xmath200 in which they both recover the classical thermal coherent states . as we have seen in the previous section , the advantage of stss over classical states is recovered by considering non - symmetric thermal noise . , of the upper and lower bounds on the probability of error @xmath10 using either undisplaced squeezed thermal states ( stss ) or undisplaced thermal squeezed states ( tsss ) with fixed , symmetric , thermal noise : @xmath201 . upper right panel : the same but with @xmath202 . in this case one observes that beyond a threshold value of @xmath177 the stss certainly outperform the tsss . lower panels similar to the upper panels but with nonvanishing displacement @xmath203 . the upper bounds on the probability of error are given here by the quantum bhattacharyya coefficient @xmath204 , which for states that include displacement does not necessary coincide with the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 . the displacement increases the efficiency of the reading , however it does not guarantee with certainty the noise - enhanced performance of stss with respect to tsss.,width=340 ] when comparing the behavior of the uhlmann fidelity , quantum chernoff bound , and the gaussian discords of response under variations of the classical noise at a fixed level of quantum fluctuations ( squeezing ) , we expect a radically diverging behaviors of the stss with respect to the tsss . on intuitive grounds , since fidelity , chernoff bound , and discord are measures of distinguishability between an input state and the corresponding output after a local disturbance , if we compare stss and tsss we notice from the structure of their covariance matrices , see eqs . ( [ cthsq ] ) , that as @xmath191 increases the correlation part of the stss increases , while it remains constant in tsss . indeed , the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 and of the uhlmann fidelity @xmath205 for any two gaussian states of the form eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) with @xmath69 and @xmath206 , related by a @xmath15 phase shift , take the form : @xmath207 @xmath208^{2 } } \ ; . \label{derivfidel}\ ] ] in fig . [ e18 ] we report the behavior of the upper bound on the probability of error @xmath27 , eq . ( [ derivchernoff ] ) , and of the lower bound @xmath126 ( which is a monotonic increasing function of the uhlmann fidelity @xmath205 , eq . ( [ derivfidel ] ) ) for the squeezed thermal and thermal squeezed states as functions of the number of thermal photons at fixed squeezing . we observe that for tsss @xmath205 and @xmath27 both increase with increasing thermal noise , converging asymptotically to the absolute maximum ( @xmath14 ) of the probability of error . therefore , the quantum efficiency of tsss is suppressed by increasing the thermal noise . on the contrary , for stss @xmath27 remains constant and @xmath126 decreases . this behavior guarantees that the probability of error , at fixed squeezing , is bound to vary in a restricted interval below @xmath209 . in the given example , the squeezing amplitude @xmath74 has been fixed at a relatively low value @xmath210 . increasing the level of squeezing will further reduce the maximum value achievable by the probability of error . in conclusion , the quantum advantage associated to squeezed thermal states is paramount at fixed , even moderate , squeezing , and increases monotonically with increasing thermal noise . and of the lower bound on the probability of error @xmath126 as functions of the number of thermal photons @xmath191 , at fixed number of squeezed photons @xmath211 , for thermal squeezed and squeezed thermal states . blue dashed line : @xmath27 for thermal squeezed states . dotted red line : @xmath126 for thermal squeezed states . solid black line : @xmath27 for squeezed thermal states . orange dot - dashed line : @xmath126 for squeezed thermal states . the colored areas between the upper and lower bounds denote the admissible intervals of variation for the probability of error @xmath10 . increasing thermal noise suppresses the efficiency of thermal squeezed transmitters and increases the efficiency of squeezed thermal ones.,width=298 ] a more detailed understanding of these opposite behaviors can be gained by looking at the variation of the measures of distinguishability with respect to the variations of the thermal noise and of the parameters of the covariance matrix . consider a generic measure of distinguishability denoted by @xmath212 where @xmath213 , among others , includes the uhlmann fidelity @xmath205 and the quantum chernoff bound @xmath27 . consider then the _ total _ derivative of @xmath213 with respect to @xmath191 , keeping @xmath74 constant : @xmath214 specializing to either @xmath205 or @xmath27 we obtain the explicit expressions of their derivatives , as reported in appendix [ derivatives ] . from these explicit expressions it follows that it is always @xmath215 irrespective of the type of quantum transmitter considered . hence , if @xmath213 represents either the uhlmann fidelity or the quantum chernoff bound , the derivative @xmath216 . this behavior agrees with the intuition that the operation of increasing the diagonal entries of the covariance matrix and keeping the off - diagonal entries constant acts like a thermal channel which makes the initial state and the final state after the phase shift less distinguishable . the behavior @xmath217 for both @xmath205 and @xmath27 is also intuitively clear , since changes in @xmath63 under @xmath149 are the greater the larger the off - diagonal entries when keeping the diagonal @xmath218 constant . let us now discuss the state - dependent derivatives : for stss and tsss the partial derivatives @xmath219 and @xmath220 are non - negative , therefore they can not oppose the behavior of the state - independent part . for stss they are given by @xmath221 and @xmath222 respectively , while for tsss @xmath223 and @xmath224 . the behavior of @xmath225 or @xmath27 with increasing @xmath191 depends then on the ratio of the positive and negative parts on the left hand side of eq . ( [ derivative ] ) . for tsss there is only a positive contribution in eq . ( [ derivative ] ) and both @xmath205 and @xmath27 increase with increasing number of thermal photons . as a consequence , both the lower and the upper bounds on the probability of error must increase , as observed in fig . [ e18 ] . on the other hand , for stss the negative contribution always prevails when considering the uhlmann fidelity , while the positive and negative contributions always cancel exactly when considering the quantum chernoff bound , leading to a constant upper bound on the probability of error , as observed in fig . [ e18 ] . the constant behavior of @xmath27 as a function of thermal noise for stss can be also seen directly from eq . ( [ derivchernoff ] ) . this equation can be rewritten straightforwardly only in terms of @xmath226 . indeed , this ratio for stss does not depend on @xmath191 . in this section we have considered reading protocols with binary coding given by the identity and the phase shift @xmath15 , and transmitters implemented by symmetric stss . this is actually a worst - case scenario in two respects . on the one hand , the phase shift @xmath15 provides the worst possible coding among all traceless local symplectic operations ( maximum probability of error , device - independent reading ) . on the other hand , the _ symmetric _ stss provide the worst possible transmitters among general stss . indeed , in the next subsection we will show that non - symmetric stss provide much larger quantum efficiencies and even effectively suppress the probability of error . one might speculate that the increment of the bures discord of response for increasing thermal noise and the corresponding decrement of the lower bound on the probability of error are due to the particular relation with the bures metrics induced by the uhlmann fidelity . however , this is not the case . we will now show that if one considers non - symmetric two - mode stss then also the hellinger discord of response increases under increasing local thermal noise and therefore the corresponding upper bound on the probability of error decreases as well . this is a strong indication that the true probability of error decreases as well with increasing thermal noise and thus that the use of discordant , non - symmetric stss yields an absolute advantage , even over the use of entangled pure states , namely two - mode squeezed vacua with the same amount of squeezing as in the corresponding stss . the covariance matrix of non - symmetric two - mode stss is given in eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) with the parameters given in eqs . ( [ ccvsqth ] ) . the corresponding @xmath27 achieves its maximum for the @xmath15 phase shift , as proven in appendix [ chbm ] , and the exact expression of @xmath27 for non - symmetric stss related by a @xmath15 phase shift is : @xmath227 let us consider the variation @xmath228 of the quantum chernoff bound , at constant squeezing @xmath74 and constant number of thermal photons @xmath147 in the second mode , whose analytical expression is provided in appendix [ derivatives ] . from this expression it is clear that there is a range of values of @xmath146 and @xmath147 , namely @xmath181 , for which @xmath229 . therefore , in this regime @xmath27 decreases with increasing @xmath146 . on the other hand , @xmath27 increases with increasing @xmath146 if @xmath230 . henceforth , in the symmetric situation @xmath189 the quantum chernoff bound is maximum and constant , independent of @xmath191 , as discussed in the previous section . , as a function of @xmath146 . in each panel the number of thermal photons @xmath147 in the second mode is fixed at a constant value . upper left panel : @xmath231 . upper right panel : @xmath232 . lower left panel : @xmath233 . lower right panel : @xmath233 and extended range of values of @xmath146 , in order to show the asymptotic vanishing of @xmath27 with increasing local thermal noise . for all panels the two - mode squeezing is fixed at @xmath234 . the maximum of @xmath27 is achieved for symmetric stss and provides the upper bound on the maximum probability of error @xmath235 of the worst - case scenario.,width=340 ] in fig . [ qcbnth1 ] we report the behavior of @xmath27 as a function of @xmath146 for different fixed values of @xmath147 and fixed squeezing @xmath74 . in this physical situation the quantum chernoff bound decreases with increasing _ local _ thermal noise and vanishes asymptotically for @xmath236 . therefore the probability of error in a gaussian quantum reading protocol can be made arbitrarily small by using non - symmetric stss transmitters with very large _ local _ thermal noise . this very remarkable result may look at first quite counter - intuitive . in fact , the crucial point is that this feature is obtained by the _ global quantum _ operation of two - mode squeezing applied to a two - mode thermal state with very strong asymmetry in the _ local _ thermal noises affecting the two field modes . it is therefore not entirely unexpected that the consequences can be dramatic . while entanglement certainly decreases , the operation of squeezing a larger amount of noise can increase quantum state distinguishability by _ `` orthogonalizing '' _ on a larger portion of hilbert space with respect to the thermal states . collecting all the previous results we are finally in the position to compare the best resources of device - independent gaussian quantum reading , namely the noisy and discordant non - symmetric stss , to the best absolute resources of gaussian quantum reading , namely pure entangled two - mode squeezed vacuum states ( tmsvss ) . in the limit of infinite squeezing the tmsvss are maximally entangled pure einstein - podolsky - rosen ( epr ) states whose probability of error in a quantum reading protocol vanishes identically . in absolute terms , tmsvss are certainly the best among classical and quantum resources in a reading protocol with continuous variables . indeed , in fig . [ sqthsqvac ] we report the behavior of the exact probability of error for tmsvss and the lower bound on it for non - symmetric stss as functions of the total number of photons at fixed thermal noise , that is for _ arbitrarily increasing squeezing _ as the total number of photons increases . one observes that the lower bound on the probability of error for non - symmetric stss is always above the exact probability of error for tmsvss , converging towards it only asymptotically . of the probability of error @xmath157 for two - mode squeezed vacuum transmitters ( tmsvs ) and of the lower bound on the probability of error @xmath237 for two - mode squeezed thermal transmitters ( stss ) with @xmath238 and @xmath168 . tmsvs have better reading efficiency than stss . the squeezing in tmsvs is larger than the one in stss at each fixed value of @xmath143 . the two efficiencies converge asymptotically with increasing total number of photons.,width=302 ] on the other hand , it is also important to compare tmsvss and non - symmetric stss in terms of the concrete use of resources in realistically feasible experimental scenarios . in fig . [ stsvstmsvs ] and fig . [ stsvstmsvs1 ] we report the behavior of the exact probability of error @xmath157 associated to tmsvs transmitters compared to the upper and lower bounds @xmath125 and @xmath237 for non - symmetric sts transmitters as functions of the total number of photons . in the case of tmsvss the total number of photons obviously depends only on the squeezing and the behavior of the probability of error is the same as the one reported in fig . [ sqthsqvac ] . however , at variance with fig . [ sqthsqvac ] , in fig . [ stsvstmsvs ] and [ stsvstmsvs1 ] we compare it with the lower and upper bounds for st transmitters at a _ fixed _ finite value , low and comparably easy to produce experimentally , of the squeezing . in this case , the total number of photons in stss varies only with the amount of thermal photons . [ stsvstmsvs ] shows the behavior of the exact probability of error for tmsvs transmitters and the bounds on the probability of error for non - symmetric stss , as functions of the total number of photons @xmath143 and constant squeezing parameter fixed at @xmath234 . for comparison , in fig . [ stsvstmsvs1 ] we report the same quantities but for a larger fixed two - mode squeezing @xmath239 . indeed , the higher the squeezing , the better the bounds on the probability of error using sts transmitters approximate the exact probability of error for tmsvs transmitters . the crucial difference is that in real - world experimental setups it is comparatively much easier and less resource - demanding to implement a scheme relying on non - symmetric stss with enhanced thermal noise and quantum discord than to produce pure ( noise - free ) tmsvss with enhanced squeezing and entanglement . therefore , at _ fixed _ squeezing , we can compare the two classes of transmitters for _ different _ values of the total number of photons @xmath143 and ask for the threshold value of @xmath146 above which the discordant stss certainly perform better than the entangled tmsvss at the same fixed level of squeezing ( the noise on the second mode being also fixed at a given reference value , say e.g. @xmath168 ) . this threshold is thus determined by the condition @xmath240 . we give here two numerical examples for two different realistic values of the two - mode squeezing achievable in the laboratory with current technologies . for @xmath234 , we have that @xmath241 as soon as @xmath242 . for @xmath239 , we have that @xmath241 as soon as @xmath243 . therefore , the higher the fixed level of squeezing , the lower is the level of thermal noise and quantum discord required to match the performance of pure entangled tmsvss . alternatively , increasing @xmath146 further above the threshold , we can also look for the complementary information on the minimum threshold values of @xmath74 ( more easily realizable in the laboratory ) above which stss match or surpass the performance of tmsvss at higher values of the squeezing ( harder to achieve experimentally ) . in other words , we can introduce the concept of _ effective _ squeezing @xmath244 associated to the value @xmath245 such that for @xmath246 stss perform better than tmsvss with given squeezing @xmath247 . in conclusion , device - independent quantum reading is a remarkable protocol of quantum technology with noisy resources for which the best transmitters are discordant non - symmetric squeezed thermal states whose performance is optimized by realizing a fine trade - off between increased local thermal noise and fixed global two - mode squeezing , yielding noise - enhanced quantum correlations and state distinguishability . of the probability of error @xmath157 for two - mode squeezed vacuum transmitters , and of the lower and upper bounds on the probability of error @xmath237 and @xmath125 for non - symmetric two - mode squeezed thermal transmitters . the latter two quantities are plotted for variable @xmath146 at _ fixed _ squeezing @xmath234 , as well as fixed reference thermal noise in the second field mode @xmath248.,width=302 ] of the probability of error @xmath157 for two - mode squeezed vacuum transmitters , and of the lower and upper bounds on the probability of error @xmath237 and @xmath125 for non - symmetric two - mode squeezed thermal transmitters . the latter two quantities are plotted for variable @xmath146 at _ fixed _ squeezing @xmath239 , as well as fixed reference thermal noise in the second field mode @xmath248.,width=302 ] let us now analyze the case in which the total number of photons can vary by considering many copies of the transmitter , that is repeating the reading protocol many times independently . using @xmath249 copies of the system the uhlmann fidelity and the quantum chernoff bound decrease as powers of @xmath249 . therefore , the probability of error can decrease both in the case of squeezed thermal and thermal squeezed states . the interesting question which arises here is how many copies we need in both cases to achieve a given level of probability of error . the number of copies defines for instance the time needed for reading one bit of information in the given coding . therefore this process is interesting from the point of view of assessing the reading time and the strength of the sources of squeezed light that one needs . and @xmath250 . blue dashed line : @xmath27 for thermal squeezed states . dotted red line : @xmath126 for thermal squeezed states . solid black line : @xmath27 for squeezed thermal states . orange dot - dashed line : @xmath126 for squeezed thermal states . in order to achieve @xmath251 it is enough to take at most @xmath252 copies of stss , while the needed number of copies of tsss is at least @xmath253.,width=302 ] let us for instance assume that we require a value of the probability of error @xmath254 , having for each copy of the squeezed thermal transmitter the thermal noise fixed at @xmath250 and the weak squeezing fixed at @xmath255 , see fig . looking at the upper bound ( worst - case scenario ) , the number of copies which are needed , in order to achieve the desired level of probability of error , is at most @xmath252 . taking instead the thermal squeezed transmitter with the same squeezing and thermal noise in each copy , we see from fig . [ en ] that one needs , considering the lower bound ( best - case scenario ) , at least @xmath253 copies . these behaviors illustrate very clearly the advantage of using noise - enhanced quantum correlations . indeed , comparing figs . [ en ] and [ e18 ] , we see that by keeping a fixed level of squeezing and increasing the thermal noise , the number of copies of squeezed thermal transmitters needed to achieve a given level of precision stays constant , while the number of copies of thermal squeezed transmitters must increase . we have investigated gaussian quantum reading protocols realized by weak optical sources in the worst - case scenario for quantum transmitters with respect to classical ( thermal coherent ) ones . for protocols that involve local unitary operations in the process of reading by continuous - variable gaussian optical fields , we have showed that the maximum probability of error in reading binary memory cells is directly related to the amount of quantum correlations in a given transmitter , as quantified by the trace gaussian discord of response . this relation allows to quantify the reading efficiency in terms of quantum correlations , providing a natural operational interpretation to the gaussian discord of response . indeed , the latter is a well - defined measure of quantum state distinguishability under the action of local unitary operations . therefore , the more discordant is the transmitter , the smaller is the maximum probability of error when using quantum resources . this relation then allows to determine the physical regimes of state purity and signal strength for which one has a net advantage in using quantum resources over classical thermal coherent ones . since the trace distance is in general uncomputable for gaussian states , we have introduced exact upper and lower bounds on the maximum probability of error . we have showed that these bounds are expressed in terms of other type of quantum discords . in particular , the lower bound is expressed in terms of the bures gaussian discord of response , while the upper bound , provided by the quantum chernoff bound maximized over the set of possible local unitary operations , is expressed in terms of the hellinger gaussian discord of response for squeezed thermal states and thermal squeezed states . both bounds decrease with an increasing amount of quantum correlations , providing a precise quantitative estimate of the quantum advantage obtained by using discordant resources over the corresponding thermal coherent ones . moreover , the bures and hellinger discords of response are of further independent interest , as they play a central role in other quantum protocols studied recently , ranging from the assessment and use of local quantum uncertainty in optimal phase estimation @xcite , the efficiency of black - box quantum metrology @xcite , and the quantum advantage of discordant resources in the protocol of quantum illumination @xcite . after comparing quantum and classical resources , we have discussed two fundamental classes of gaussian quantum transmitters : symmetric squeezed thermal states ( stss ) and symmetric thermal squeezed states ( tsss ) . we have shown that the actual beneficial or detrimental effects of environmental noise depend on the type of quantum state being considered . considering stss as quantum transmitters , the upper and lower bounds on the probability of error decrease with increasing thermal noise and therefore the quantum reading efficiency increases . the opposite behavior is observed when considering tsss : in this case both the upper and the lower bounds on the maximum probability of error increase and therefore the quantum reading efficiency decreases with increasing thermal noise . finally , we went a step further and investigated the use of non - symmetric stss . for such transmitters , also the quantum chernoff bound decreases when the local thermal noise increases in one mode and remains fixed in the second mode . indeed , the quantum chernoff bound vanishes asymptotically with very large local thermal noise and therefore the probability of error must also vanish . in other words , non - symmetric two - mode stss with imbalanced thermal noise between the two modes achieve an asymptotically vanishing probability of error for very large values of the noise imbalance . for such asymptotic states the hellinger and bures gaussian discords of response attain their maximum value , and the quantum chernoff bound and uhlmann fidelity vanish . as a consequence , all upper and lower bounds on the probability of error vanish , the probability of error itself vanishes , and perfect reading is approached asymptotically . since the quantum reading efficiency of non - symmetric two - mode squeezed thermal states is a non - decreasing function of thermal noise , there is no evident advantage in using pure - state squeezed transmitters , the two - mode squeezed vacuum states , or low - noise ones over non - symmetric two - mode stss with large noise imbalance between the field modes , _ as long as _ the squeezing is kept _ fixed _ at a realistic , finite constant value achievable in concrete experiments with currently available technology . hence , noisy stss transmitters _ can _ provide a better quantum efficiency at _ fixed _ two - mode squeezing , provided thermal noise ( number of thermal photons ) is enhanced beyond the threshold value above which the upper bound on the probability of error ( quantum chernoff bound ) for stss goes below the exact probability of error for tmsvss with the same , fixed level of squeezing . this remarkable phenomenon of noise - assisted quantum correlations and quantum efficiency is eventually due to the fact that quantum state distinguishability is intimately related to the concept of geometric quantum correlations , as measured by the discords of response , and the observation that the former can increase under increasing thermal noise . in particular , maximum _ local _ noise enhancement leads to maximum _ global _ enhancement of quantum correlations . in forthcoming studies we will provide a general characterization and quantification of noise - suppressed vs. noise - enhanced quantum correlations for different classes of quantum states @xcite , and we will investigate the relations between different types of quantum correlations according to states , metrics , and operations @xcite . f.i . acknowledges valuable discussions with gerardo adesso . the authors acknowledge financial support from the italian ministry of scientific and technological research under the prin 2010/2011 research fund , and from the eu fp7 strep projects iqit , g.a . 270843 , and equam , g.a . here we discuss the gaussian discord of response , given by eq . ( [ intdr ] ) , and prove that it is a _ bona fide _ measure of quantum correlations . more general discussion can be found in @xcite . the minimal set of axioms with universal consensus includes the following : @xmath256 invariance under local unitary transformations , @xmath257 contractivity under the action of completely positive and trace preserving ( cptp ) maps acting on mode @xmath56 , @xmath258 vanishing of quantum correlations if and only if the state is classically - quantum correlated , i.e. with block - diagonal covariance matrix , @xmath259 reduction to an entanglement monotone for pure states . the first condition is guaranteed by unitary invariance of the chosen distance and the procedure of minimization . the second condition is satisfied due to the fact that we consider only contractive distances in order to define the discord of response . the third condition is verified as follows . it is known that classical - quantum two - mode gaussian states are those and only those which can be represented by the tensor product @xmath260 of single - mode gaussian states @xcite . up to displacements , such states are characterized by the block diagonal covariance matrices @xmath261 . let us consider the local traceless symplectic transformation @xmath93 which can be decomposed as @xmath262 , where @xmath263 and @xmath264 is a symplectic matrix which diagonalize @xmath265 , i.e. @xmath266 . here @xmath267 are two equal symplectic eigenvalues of @xmath265 . the transformation given by @xmath149 is symmetry - preserving and therefore @xmath262 leaves @xmath265 invariant . this shows that if the state is classically correlated there exists at least one local traceless transformation @xmath93 that leaves the state invariant . we now prove the reverse statement that only in the case of classically correlated states there exists such a symplectic traceless transformation that leaves the state invariant . assume that the covariance matrix left invariant by a traceless transformation @xmath268 has the form @xmath269 . local symplectic transformation can bring the covariance matrix in the so called normal form in which @xmath270 . if the state is not changed by the local transformation we have @xmath271 . since @xmath272 is reversible we obtain that @xmath273 which contradicts the assumption on the spectrum of @xmath93 . this shows that condition @xmath258 is satisfied . condition @xmath259 is guaranteed by the fact that for pure states the gaussian discord of response reduces to the gaussian entanglement of response @xcite ( the gaussian counterpart of the entanglement of response @xcite ) which is a _ bona fide _ measure of entanglement . the uhlmann fidelity for two - mode gaussian states can be computed as follows @xcite . let us define the matrix of the symplectic form @xmath274 the displacement vector is the vector of the averages of the amplitude and phase field quadratures @xmath41 and @xmath118 i.e. @xmath275 , where @xmath276 stands for transposition . denote the difference of the displacement vectors of two gaussian states @xmath25 and @xmath26 by @xmath277 . we need also the auxiliary formulas defined using the covariance matrices @xmath278 and @xmath279 of the respective gaussian states : @xmath280 , \\ \lambda & = & 2 ^ 4 \det(\sigma_1+\frac{i}{2}\omega)\det(\sigma_2+\frac{i}{2}\omega).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the uhlmann fidelity for two mode gaussian states is then @xmath281 } \notag \\ & \times&\left[(\sqrt{\gamma}+\sqrt{\lambda})-\sqrt{(\sqrt{\gamma}+ \sqrt{\lambda})^2-\delta}\right]^{-1}. \label{gfidelity}\end{aligned}\ ] ] any @xmath249-mode gaussian state can be represented in its normal mode decomposition parameterized by @xmath282 in which @xmath283 is the vector of the averages of the quadratures and @xmath284u_{{\langle}u{\rangle},s}^{\dagger},\ ] ] where @xmath285 is a thermal state with mean photon number @xmath286 and @xmath287 are the eigenstates of the operator of the number of photons in mode @xmath288 . the set @xmath289 identifies the symplectic spectrum . in this way the covariance matrix is decomposed as @xmath290 for two arbitrary gaussian states with normal mode decompositions @xmath291 and @xmath292 , assuming that @xmath293 , we have @xcite @xmath294^{-1}\delta\ } } , \label{appchs}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath295 } } \label{qubar}\ ] ] and @xmath296 moreover @xmath297s_1^t,\label{v1 } \\ v_2(1-t)&=&s_2\left[\bigoplus_{k=1}^n\lambda_{1-t}(\beta_k)\mathbbm{1}_k\right]s_2^t,\label{v2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath298 the quantum chernoff bound for arbitrary states @xmath25 and @xmath26 is @xmath299 which for gaussian states is expressed by means of eq . ( [ appchs ] ) , i.e. @xmath300 . let us discuss the extremizations of the quantum chernoff bound , @xmath27 , between two states related by a local unitary transformation . lemma 1 in ref . @xcite shows that in the finite - dimensional case if @xmath301 , where @xmath302 is a hermitian matrix , the infimum is achieved for @xmath31 in eq . ( [ appchernoff ] ) . the same proof can be applied as well to @xmath302 one - qubit traceless unitary matrix , since it is hermitian . for gaussian states of infinite - dimensional , continuous - variable systems , we are able to formulate and prove the following theorem : for two - mode gaussian states @xmath303 with covariance matrix @xmath63 of the form eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) with @xmath71 , the @xmath27 for the pair @xmath304 , where @xmath264 is any traceless local symplectic transformation , is achieved for @xmath31 , namely : @xmath305 first let us notice that for any two quantum states @xmath25 and @xmath26 function @xmath306 is convex in @xmath307 , which is proven in @xcite . we will show that if the two states @xmath25 and @xmath26 satisfy the assumptions of the theorem , @xmath306 is symmetric with respect to exchange @xmath308 . these two properties imply the theorem . let us show the symmetry with respect to exchange @xmath308 . from @xcite we know that for the states with vanishing first moments @xmath306 is given in eq . ( [ qubar ] ) . the numerator of this formula is already symmetric with respect to exchange @xmath308 for the states related by any unitary transformation . to proof the theorem we only need to show the symmetry of the determinant in denominator of eq . ( [ qubar ] ) , @xmath309 , for the states which have the covariance matrices @xmath310 and @xmath311 . consider the determinant from the above formula @xmath312 the last equality is implied by the following argument . the form of the most general single - mode traceless symplectic transformation ( euler decomposition ) @xcite is : @xmath313 where @xmath314 is positive . the traceless condition is obtained by imposing @xmath315 . immediate check gives us that @xmath316 . the minus sign is irrelevant in expression @xmath317 and can be omitted . this completes the proof . to express the upper bound on the maximum probability of error for undisplaced gaussian states of the covariance matrix given in eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) with @xmath71 and its counterpart related to it by traceless symplectic transformations @xmath264 we maximize the quantum chernoff bound over the set of these transformations . formula eq . ( [ appchs ] ) with @xmath31 is maximized if @xmath318}$ ] is minimized over the set @xmath319 . the most general gaussian single - mode unitary transformation is given in eq . ( [ apps ] ) . the determinant @xmath318}$ ] does not depend on @xmath320 and achieves its minimum for @xmath321 . this can be proved by direct check of the first and second derivatives . substituting @xmath321 in eq . ( [ apps ] ) yields the transformation which maximizes the quantum chernoff bound , namely @xmath322 which is the transformation corresponding to a local @xmath15 phase shift @xmath114 . here we discuss the derivatives of the distinguishability functions and their behavior . for the quantum chernoff bound , @xmath27 , the derivatives over the entries of the covariance matrix , eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) , read @xmath323 it is immediate to verify that the partial derivative of @xmath27 , eq . ( [ dqda ] ) , is always positive and the partial derivative , eq . ( [ dqdc ] ) , is always negative . the derivatives of the uhlmann fidelity are over the entries @xmath218 and @xmath325 of the covariance matrix , eq . ( [ sqthcorm ] ) , in the range of values corresponding to physical states , eq . ( [ uncert ] ) . the partial derivative @xmath326 is always positive while @xmath327 is always negative.,width=188 ] also in the case of @xmath205 the derivative over the diagonal entry of the covariance matrix at constant off - diagonal elements is positive , while the derivative over the off - diagonal entries at constant diagonal entries is negative . in the case of non - symmetric @xmath328 discussed in sec . [ noiseenhancedqcb ] , the partial derivative of @xmath27 , eq . ( [ derivchernoffas ] ) , with respect to @xmath146 at constant @xmath147 and @xmath74 reads @xmath329 where since @xmath331 the derivative , eq . ( [ derivovernth1 ] ) , is positive only if @xmath332 , negative only if @xmath181 , and vanishes identically for symmetric stss , namely for @xmath170 , yielding a noise - independent @xmath27 . from the above results it follows that in the range @xmath181 the @xmath27 is a monotonically decreasing function of the number of thermal photons in the first mode ( increasing local thermal noise ) and vanishes asymptotically , together with the probability of error , as @xmath236 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: _ cosmic magnetism _ , the origin and nature of magnetic fields in our universe , is one of outstanding problems of modern astrophysics ( see * ? ? ? exploration of the galactic magnetic field ( gmf ) and the intergalactic magnetic field ( igmf ) is listed as one of key science projects for the square kilometer array ( ska ) , and is one of the important science projects for jansky very large array ( jvla ) , murchison widefield array ( mwa ) , the low frequency array ( lofar ) , the australian ska pathfinder ( askap ) , and the south african karoo array telescope ( meerkat ) ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? measuring faraday rotation , the rotation of the plane of linearly - polarized radio emission due to the birefringence of magneto - ionic medium , is a powerful method to observe the gmf as well as the igmf . up to now , there have been a number of studies of faraday rotation measure ( rm ) to elucidate the structure and statistical properties of the gmf and the igmf . for the igmf , there have been a number of observations of rm in clusters of galaxies ( see * ? ? ? * for a review ) . observations have been also extended to the outside of clusters , toward the cosmic web , and extragalactic contributions of rm due to the igmf or others have been discussed ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? there are several theoretical works for rm in filaments of galaxies @xcite . for instance , @xcite investigated rm in filaments using a model igmf based on a turbulent dynamo @xcite . they found that the root - mean - square ( rms ) value of rms through a single filament is expected to be @xmath3 in the local universe . @xcite extended this work by using the redshift distribution of polarized background radio sources against which rm is observed . they found that the rms value of rms through filaments up to redshift @xmath4 would be @xmath5 . they also found that the second - order structure function ( sf ) has a nearly - flat profile in angular separations of @xmath6 , meaning that rms through filaments decorrelate on angles less than @xmath7 . recently , the rms toward the north and south galactic poles ( ngp and sgp , respectively ) have been investigated to study the gmf as well as the igmf . @xcite studied the rm data from the nrao vla sky survey ( nvss ) , and estimated non - zero vertical strengths of the gmf , about @xmath8 and @xmath9 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively . @xcite used rm data from the westerbork radio synthesis telescope ( wsrt ) and the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) , and found that the median value of rms toward the sgp is @xmath10 ( corresponding to a vertical gmf strength of @xmath11 ) , while that toward the ngp is @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) . the standard deviations of rms were @xmath14 and @xmath15 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively . @xcite also put an upper limit of @xmath16 on the strength of random magnetic field at high galactic latitudes . @xcite examined the nvss data in detail , and found that the second - order sfs of rm at angular separations of @xmath17 have a value @xmath18 toward the ngp and @xmath19 toward the sgp . in addition , based on the latitude dependence of rm , @xcite examined the galactic and extragalactic contributions to rm in the nvss data . he estimated that the galactic contribution is @xmath20 and the extragalactic contribution ( including those intrinsic to the polarized background radio sources and due to the igmf ) is @xmath21 for the northern ( southern ) hemisphere . the separation of the galactic and extragalactic contributions in observed rms , however , is not trivial . it requires good understandings of the gmf and its contribution to observed rms . there have been a number of theoretical works to model the galactic rm ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) ( see also works on cosmic - ray propagation : * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the galactic rm arises from the global , regular component as well as from the turbulent , random component of the gmf . while the regular component has been modeled with analytic fitting formulae based on observations , the random component has been modeled using power - law spectra with random phases in fourier space . for instance , @xcite used the publicly - available hammurabi code @xcite , and adopted a kolmogorov - like power spectrum with average amplitude @xmath22 in a box of 10 pc size . they found that at galactic latitudes @xmath23 , the second - order sf has a magnitude of up to a few @xmath24 at angular scales of @xmath25 . previous studies have successfully reproduced the observed properties of the galactic rm as well as those of the radio continuum emission toward low and mid - galactic latitudes ( e.g. , * ? ? ? there is , however , a lack of studies that can be compared with recent observations of rms toward the galactic poles . in this paper , we simulate the galactic rm toward high galactic latitudes and investigate its statistical properties . while we model the regular component of the gmf based on a number of observations , we use the data of three - dimensional magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) turbulence simulations to model the random component . we obtain simulated maps of the galactic rm toward the galactic poles in a field - of - view ( fov ) of @xmath26 to compare with recent observations and in a @xmath27 fov to predict future ska observations . we estimate how much the gmf can contribute to observed rms and discuss how the statistics of simulated rms compare with those of observed rms . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 , we describe our models . the results are shown in section 3 . discussion and summary follow in sections 4 and 5 , respectively . we first briefly describe our models for the global , regular components of the electron density and the gmf . the details along with the definitions of the coordinate systems used in the paper are described in appendices . we also briefly describe models for the electron temperature and the rms speed of random flow motions , which are used in modeling the electron density fluctuations and the turbulent , random magnetic field in the next subsection . for the electron density , @xmath28 , we employ the ne2001 model @xcite displayed in figure [ figure1 ] . we take the original parameters of the model except for the scale height of the thick disk , @xmath29 , and the mid - plane electron density for the thick disk , @xmath30 ; we use @xmath31 and @xmath32 @xcite , which better reproduce both the dispersion measure ( dm ) and emission measure ( em ) toward high galactic latitude in our model ( appendices ) . the top - left panel of figure [ figure2 ] shows one - dimensional profiles of @xmath28 from the sun along the ngp and sgp . the electron density in the northern sky is smaller than that in the southern sky at low altitudes this is due to the presence of a local , hot bubble with @xmath33 , centered at @xmath34 in kpc @xcite . for the regular magnetic field , @xmath35 , we use combinations of the axi - symmetric spiral ( ass ) or bi - symmetric spiral ( bss ) field introduced by @xcite , the halo toroidal field of @xcite , and the halo poloidal fields of @xcite or @xcite . the top panels of figure [ figure3 ] show one - dimensional profiles of the strength of the regular field , @xmath36 , and the line - of - sight ( los ) field strength , @xmath37 , from the sun along the galactic poles . for instance , adpn indicates a model toward the ngp ( n ) including the ass field ( a ) and the dipole toroidal field ( d ) with the dipole poloidal field ( p ) . for the full list of models and the model name convention , refer to table 1 . we note that the dipole and quadrupole models are identical toward the ngp , but differ toward the sgp . the ds models tend to have larger @xmath36 than other models , since in other models the spiral and toroidal fields partly cancel each other . the spiral field dominates @xmath36 at @xmath38 , while the toroidal field dominates at @xmath39 . for the los field strength , the field strength is @xmath40 if the poloidal field exists . otherwise , @xmath41 . for the electron temperature distribution , we employ the analytic expression adopted by @xcite @xmath42 where @xmath43 is in units of k and the galactocentric cylindrical coordinates @xmath44 and @xmath45 are in kpc . the bottom - left panel of figure [ figure2 ] shows the one - dimensional profile from the sun along the galactic poles . for the rms speed of random flow motions , @xmath46 , @xmath47 observations provide a weak constraint on the plausible range of values , @xmath48 @xcite . @xcite studied the distribution of emission measure ( em ) , and found that the rms mach number @xmath49 for @xmath50 and @xmath51 is smaller at higher galactic latitudes . studies of polarization gradients also broadly constrain @xmath52 @xcite . we employ the simplest case , i.e. , a uniform distribution of @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) or @xmath55 ( @xmath56 ) , as shown in the right panels of figure [ figure2 ] . the bottom panels of figure [ figure3 ] show one - dimensional profiles of @xmath57 , the ratio of the gas pressure to the magnetic pressure due to @xmath35 . our @xmath57 is in the range of @xmath58 . here , we assume that hydrogen is fully - ionized , helium is neutral , and that their mass fractions are @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively . observations suggest the presence of electron density fluctuations and turbulent magnetic fields , in addition to smooth components in the galaxy . for instance , the volume filling factor of electrons , @xmath61 , which quantifies the clumpiness , has been estimated from dispersion measures ( dms ) and emissions / absorptions ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . highly disturbed distributions of rm and polarization angle clearly indicate turbulent structures of the gmf ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the random , turbulent components of the electron density and the gmf could be modeled analytically with preassigned spectra and random phases in fourier space . as mentioned in section 1 , @xcite followed such an approach with a constant amplitude everywhere . @xcite and @xcite introduced an ordered " or striated " field component . these works successfully reproduced the galactic rm mainly toward low and mid - galactic latitudes . however , it is not clear whether such treatments are good enough for studies of the galactic rm toward high galactic latitudes , where the random components are the dominant contribution to the rm . and constant rms amplitudes for electron density fluctuations and turbulent magnetic field would not be justified for broad distributions of @xmath51 and @xmath57 toward high altitudes ( see figures [ figure2 ] and [ figure3 ] ) , since they depend on @xmath51 and @xmath57 ( see appendix ) . in addition , in turbulent flows , phases are not really random . an alternative approach would be to use the random electron density given by the ne2001 model for the electron density fluctuations . but we would then need to model the turbulent magnetic field separately . we therefore do not adopt this approach . as in @xcite , we model the random components with mhd turbulence simulations in a closed box , as described below . in principle , if we performed full mhd simulations of the galaxy , we could reproduce the electron density fluctuations and the turbulent magnetic field as well as the regular components in the galactic disk and halo . but currently available computational resources do not allow a numerical resolution high enough to simultaneously reproduce both the large - scale global components and the small - scale turbulent components . we embed the data of mhd turbulence simulations in the galactic halo described by the global distributions of @xmath28 and @xmath35 of the previous subsection . for this purpose , we carried out three - dimensional simulations of driven , isothermal , compressible mhd turbulence without self - gravity , using a multi - dimensional mhd code based on the total variation diminishing ( tvd ) scheme @xcite . this is an mhd extension of the explicit , second - order finite - difference , upwinded , conservative scheme of @xcite for hydrodynamics . the version of the code used includes a flux constraining scheme that maintains @xmath62 up to the machine accuracy @xcite . in uniform , static medium with @xmath35 assumed to be along the @xmath63-direction , turbulence was driven by imposing a solenoidal forcing with perturbations drawn from a gaussian random field at wavenumbers around @xmath64 in fourier space . the amplitude of the forcing was fixed in such a way that turbulence saturates at preassigned mach numbers . simulations were done in a periodic computational box with @xmath65 grid zones . the size of the simulation box , @xmath66 , and the outer scale or the driving scale of turbulence , @xmath67 , were determined as follows . observations suggest that @xmath68 is on the order of @xmath69 and @xmath70 in spiral arms and in interarm regions , respectively @xcite . these are ascribed to stellar sources such as stellar winds and protostellar outflows , or supernova and superbubble explosions . @xcite adopted @xmath71 for studies of rm in low and mid - galactic latitudes ( @xmath68 is not defined in their approach ) . on the other hand , @xcite studied the em distribution estimated with the wisconsin @xmath47 mapper ( wham ) . using mhd turbulence simulations , they found that the em distribution depends on @xmath66 and @xmath68 ; larger @xmath66 and @xmath68 results in smaller ems . they argued that the histogram of the wham data on the warm ionized medium that includes high galactic latitude data could be reproduced with @xmath72 pc and @xmath73 pc . adopting the results of @xcite , we set @xmath74 and @xmath75 . the grid of @xmath65 uniform zones for the box of @xmath74 corresponds to the spatial resolution of @xmath69 . we note that this resolution is enough to resolve the characteristic scales of turbulence ; for instance , the most energy containing scale and the integral scale , @xmath76 and @xmath77 , respectively ( see * ? ? ? * ) , are sufficiently large compared to the spatial resolution . representative simulations were performed for @xmath78 and @xmath79 , in order to cover the ranges of @xmath51 and @xmath57 toward the ngp and sgp ( figures [ figure2 ] and [ figure3 ] ) . table 2 lists the simulations along with the rms values of density and magnetic field strength . for the case of @xmath80 at high galactic altitudes ( @xmath81 kpc , figure [ figure3 ] ) , we use the data for @xmath82 . since the contribution from high altitudes to the integrated rm is at most several per cent , this approximation does not seriously affect our results . in turbulence simulations , @xmath46 saturates roughly in one flow - crossing time , @xmath83 @xcite . for the length scale of @xmath84 , the corresponding timescale of @xmath85 and @xmath86 for the rms flow speed of @xmath87 and @xmath88 is sufficiently short compared to the age of the galaxy . we thus use the data at the saturation stage of turbulence . the data of simulations are stacked ( or piled up ) from the galactic mid - plane up to the outer edge of the ne2001 model , @xmath89 ( figure [ figure1 ] ) . in the stacking , we try to align the direction of the regular field in simulation data with that of the analytic model as follows . as we already noted , the regular field is dominated by the spiral field at @xmath38 and by the toroidal field at @xmath39 ( see figure [ figure3 ] ) . in each domain , the regular field direction is close to either the @xmath90 or @xmath91 direction in our coordinate systems , except narrow transition regions with a width @xmath92 . we divide each of the northern and southern hemispheres into four blocks : @xmath93 where @xmath45 is in units of kpc . we calculate the average values of @xmath51 and @xmath57 in each block and seek the simulation of closest parameters . table 1 summarizes the direction of the regular magnetic field and the values of @xmath51 and @xmath57 adopted in each block . for example , in block 1 of adon15 , where 15 means @xmath53 , we choose the simulation with @xmath94 and @xmath95 , and align the regular field with the @xmath90-direction . the stacked data are renormalized in such a way that we match the average electron density and magnetic field in the computational box with those of the regular components of section 2.1 . after the renormalization , each grid keeps the fluctuations based on mhd turbulence simulations . examples of profiles of the resulting electron density , magnetic field , and rm ( see section 2.3 ) from the sun along the ngp , including both the regular and random components , are shown in figure [ figure4 ] . it is apparent that fluctuations in the case with @xmath96 @xmath97 are larger than those for @xmath98 @xmath97 , as expected . the strength of the turbulent magnetic field ( @xmath99 ) is at most a few @xmath100 , and mostly @xmath101 . this seems to be smaller than the strength of the random field , a few to several @xmath100 , in the galactic disk ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , but consistent with @xmath102 a few kpc from the galactic plane estimated by assuming equipartition between the thermal and nonthermal pressures @xcite , as well as with the recent estimates of @xmath103 and @xmath104 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively @xcite . the sign of los magnetic field changes several times . @xmath105 increases with the path length , and then saturates around @xmath106 kpc where the electron density becomes small . we check our model for the electron density distribution by comparing the resulting dm and em with observed values @xcite . dm , which is determined only by the global , regular component , is 22 and 25 @xmath107 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , while the observed value is @xmath108 @xmath107 . we note that the ne2001 model , from which we get the regular component , was designed to reproduce observations including dm . the em in our model is 1.5 ( 1.0 ) and 2.3 ( 1.6 ) @xmath109 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , for @xmath110 30 ( 15 ) @xmath97 , which is in a good agreement with the observed value , @xmath111 @xmath109 . our model also reproduces the overall distribution of em at @xmath112 presented by @xcite . details are given in the appendix . the rm toward a source outside the galaxy is defined as @xmath113 where @xmath114 , @xmath115 , and the path length @xmath116 are in units of @xmath117 , @xmath100 , and pc , respectively . conventionally rm is positive when the los magnetic field points toward us , and @xmath118 is the maximum distance along the los up to the outer edge of our model space . in this paper , we calculate the rm only due to the gmf . we do not include other possible contributions , such as the rm due to the igmf , the intrinsic rm at sources , and observational errors . we discuss those in section 4 . we consider a square fov of @xmath26 with @xmath119 on a side centered on each of the galactic poles , which is comparable to the fovs of rm observations toward the ngp and sgp @xcite . in addition , we also consider a square fov of @xmath27 with @xmath120 on a side . the smaller fov is roughly that proposed for the dense aperture array of the ska @xcite . the smaller fov is also used to check the fov dependence of rm statistics . to see structures in angular separations of @xmath121 for which the second - order sf of observed rms is available @xcite , we choose the angular resolution of pixels to be @xmath122 . the numbers of pixels we use are @xmath123 and @xmath124 for @xmath26 and @xmath27 fovs , respectively . we calculate rms with equation ( [ eq : rm ] ) assuming one extragalactic radio source in each pixel , and construct mock rm maps . for each map , we randomly rotate stacked simulation boxes around the axis parallel to the regular magnetic field in table 1 ( keeping the direction of the regular magnetic field ) and randomly shift box centers to avoid the repeat of the same grid zones which would make artifacts in statistics . when the integration reaches the top of a simulation box , the integration proceeds into the next stacked box and the integration is continued . if the integration reaches the side of the simulation box , we apply the periodic boundary condition to the side , and replicate the box beyond the side . we obtain 200 mock maps for each model listed in table 1 and each fov , and calculate statistical quantities . the quantities shown below in sections 3.3 and 3.4 are the averages for 200 rm maps . figure [ figure5 ] shows sample maps over a @xmath125 fov . maps due to the regular components in the model adon ( leftmost panel ) and due to the random components in one of 200 simulations for adon30 ( second panel ) are shown . the combined map due to the regular and random components ( third panel ) as well as the binned map of median rms in @xmath126 pixels ( rightmost panel ) are also shown . we can see that the regular components of density and magnetic field alone produce large - scale structures of up to the fov size . the structures highlight @xmath37 as induced by the radial and azimuthal components of the spiral and toroidal fields ( the model shown does not include a poloidal field ) . the random components of density and magnetic field , on the other hand , produce complex structures , such as clump - like and filament - like features , on angular scales of @xmath127 . such structures persist in the combined map . @xcite showed binned maps of median rms in @xmath126 pixels toward the ngp and sgp , which were produced from observational data . the maps display structures of a few to several degrees . in our model , such structures are mostly the consequence of the random components of density and magnetic field ( rightmost panel ) . our results indicate that the random components mainly produce the observed rm structures on scales less than several degrees , while the regular components contribute to larger scale structures . we first examine the statistics of rms in maps due to the regular components alone . we calculated the average , @xmath128 , and the standard deviation , @xmath129 , in maps for the models and fovs we consider . the resulting values are shown in table 3 . the average is mainly determined by the existence of the poloidal component of the gmf ; @xmath130 without the poloidal component , or @xmath131 and @xmath132 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , if the dipole poloidal component exists , and @xmath133 and @xmath134 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , if the x - field poloidal component exists . the absolute values toward the ngp are a little smaller than those toward the sgp , due to the existence of a low density , local hot bubble centered in the northern sky ( figure [ figure2 ] ) . the averages for the @xmath27 fov are slightly smaller than those for the @xmath26 fov , since the smaller fov includes high latitude regions only where the density and magnetic field strength are both smaller . the standard deviations are @xmath135 and @xmath136 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , for the @xmath26 fov . these are caused mostly by contributions from the radial and azimuthal components of the gmf ( see also the leftmost panel of figure [ figure5 ] ) . the ds models tend to have larger standard deviations than the dn and qs models , because the ds models have larger @xmath36 at mid and high altitudes as noted in section 2.1 . larger values toward the sgp than those toward the ngp are again due to the existence of a local hot bubble near the sun . the standard deviations for the @xmath27 fov are smaller by a factor of @xmath137 than those for the @xmath26 fov , since the smaller fov includes a narrower range of rm values . we next examine the statistics of rms due to both the regular and random components . figure [ figure6 ] shows the probability distribution functions ( pdfs ) of rms in maps of @xmath26 fov , averaged over 200 rm maps , for all models we consider . the pdfs roughly follow the gaussian distribution , as pointed out by @xcite . the figure also shows the observed pdfs of @xcite . the average and standard deviation of @xmath138 ( the average of rms for a map ) and @xmath139 ( the standard deviation of rms for a map ) over 200 maps were calculated . figure [ figure7 ] shows the resulting values for @xmath26 fov as well as for @xmath27 fov . the value of @xmath138 , which approximates the peak positions for the nearly - symmetric pdfs in figure [ figure6 ] , is determined mostly by the regular components . so the average of @xmath138 is close to @xmath138 of the regular components alone in section 3.1 ; @xmath140 @xmath141 , without the poloidal component of the gmf , or @xmath142 and @xmath143 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , if the poloidal component exists . as noted in section 1 , the medians of observed rms toward the ngp and sgp are @xmath0 and @xmath1 , respectively @xcite . hence , the models with poloidal components better reproduce the observed average toward the sgp , but the models without poloidal components are preferred for the ngp . on the other hand , the fluctuation of @xmath138 over the 200 maps is rather small ; the standard deviations of @xmath138 for 200 maps are @xmath144 for models with @xmath145 and @xmath146 for models with @xmath147 , as shown with error bars in figure [ figure7 ] . these values are much smaller than the difference between the observed averages , @xmath148 @xmath141 , toward the ngp and sgp . this means that the difference can not be explained by the statistical fluctuation caused by the random components in our models . these results indicate that none of our models can simultaneously reproduce the observed averages of rms toward the ngp and sgp . in figure [ figure6 ] , the simulated pdfs have narrower and more sharply peaked profiles than the observed pdfs . the width of the pdfs is quantified by @xmath139 . in figure [ figure7 ] , the averages of @xmath139 are @xmath149 toward the ngp and @xmath150 toward the sgp for models with @xmath145 , and @xmath151 toward the ngp and @xmath152 toward the sgp for models with @xmath147 . the fluctuation of @xmath139 in 200 maps is again small ; the standard deviations of @xmath139 for 200 maps are @xmath153 for models with @xmath145 and @xmath154 for models with @xmath147 , as shown with error bars . on the other hand , the estimations of @xcite with their observed rms are @xmath155 and @xmath15 toward the ngp and sgp . so our estimations of @xmath139 with simulated rms are substantially smaller than the values of @xcite . we argue that all of our models fail to reproduce not only the peak positions but also the widths of the pdfs of observed rms toward the ngp and sgp ( see further discussions in sections 4 and 5 ) . from figure [ figure7 ] , we see the average and standard deviation of @xmath138 are not sensitive to the size of fov . but the values of @xmath139 for the @xmath27 fov are somewhat smaller than those for the @xmath26 fov , as expected . we also calculated the two - dimensional power spectrum ( ps ) and structure function ( sf ) with the sky map of rm . they tell us at which angular scales most power of rm resides and the spatial structure of rm decorrelates . figure [ figure8 ] shows the ps of rms due to both the regular and random components in maps of @xmath26 fov , averaged over 200 rm maps , for all models we consider . the ps toward the sgp are larger than those toward the ngp . this is again attributed to the presence of a local hot bubble in the northern sky . toward the sgp , the ps for the models with a dipole toroidal field ( d ) are larger than those for the models with quadrupole toroidal field ( q ) . this is because the dipole models have larger @xmath36 , as shown in figure [ figure3 ] . ( the dipole and quadrupole models are identical toward the ngp , as noted in section 2.1 . ) the amplitude of the ps depends on the rms flow speed ; the ps for @xmath156 are larger by up to a factor of @xmath157 than those for @xmath158 . the slope also depends on the rms flow speed . larger @xmath46 s result in shallower profiles . this is because the density and magnetic field ps of supersonic flows ( @xmath55 corresponds to @xmath159 ) are shallower than those of subsonic flows ( @xmath53 corresponds to @xmath160 ) ( e.g. , see * ? ? ? we quantified the slope of ps , @xmath161 , defined with @xmath162 in the angular range of @xmath127 , and show the resulting values in figure [ figure9 ] for @xmath26 fov as well as for @xmath27 fov . these are the averages for 200 maps . the figure confirms the dependence of @xmath161 on @xmath46 ; @xmath161 s for @xmath55 are larger by up to @xmath163 than those for @xmath53 for the models shown in figure [ figure8 ] ( with @xmath26 fov ) . some of the ps have slopes consistent with the kolmogorov slope @xmath164 , but others have steeper slopes , indicating that the gmf model influences the slope of the ps . from the observer s point of view , the sf of rms is a statistical quantity that is easier to obtain than the ps . the @xmath165-th order sf is defined as @xmath166 with @xmath167 , where the subscript indicates the averaging over the data domain of @xmath168 . figure [ figure10 ] shows the second - order sfs @xmath169 in maps of @xmath26 fov , averaged over 200 rm maps , for all models we consider . the sfs monotonically increase with angular separation , and reach up to @xmath170 toward the ngp and @xmath171 several @xmath172 toward the sgp , respectively , at the angular separation of @xmath173 . the sfs toward the sgp are larger than those toward the ngp . toward the sgp , the sfs for the models with dipole toroidal fields are larger than those for the models with quadrupole toroidal fields . as for the ps , the sfs for @xmath156 have amplitudes larger by up to a factor of @xmath157 than those for @xmath158 . figure [ figure10 ] also shows the observed sfs toward the ngp and sgp @xcite . it is clear that the sfs of our simulated rms do not match the observed sfs at any angular scales . at the largest observed scale of @xmath173 , the simulated sfs are smaller by an order of amplitude or so than the observed sfs . but the difference is even larger at smaller angular separations . not just the amplitudes , but also the slopes of the sfs of our simulated rms are quite different from the observed ones ; the slopes of simulated rms are much steeper . we quantify the slope of sf , @xmath174 , defined with @xmath175 over the angular separations of @xmath127 , and show the resulting values in figure [ figure9 ] for a @xmath26 fov as well as for a @xmath27 fov . again these are the averages for 200 maps . for the @xmath26 fov , @xmath176 for @xmath158 , and @xmath177 for @xmath156 . the slopes of observed sfs are @xmath178 @xcite . so our models fail to reproduce the observed sfs not only in the amplitude but also in the slope . the results suggest that the observed rms may contain contributions due to structures smaller than those typically found in the galactic halo . the ps and sfs for the @xmath27 fov ( not shown ) show behaviors similar to those for the @xmath26 fov , except that there are no data beyond a scale of @xmath179 . quantitatively , the slopes of ps and sf , @xmath161 and @xmath174 , for the @xmath27 fov are a bit smaller than those for the @xmath26 fov , as shown in figure [ figure9 ] . in our models , the average or median of the rm toward high galactic latitudes , @xmath138 , is determined mostly by the halo poloidal component of the gmf , while the standard deviation , @xmath139 , is determined mostly by the random component of the gmf . our models fail to simultaneously reproduce the medians of observed rms toward the ngp and sgp , @xmath0 and @xmath1 @xcite . the models that contain a poloidal component of the gmf have a vertical magnetic field of @xmath180 in the earth vicinity , which induces @xmath181 toward the ngp and @xmath182 toward the sgp . the models without a poloidal component have @xmath183 , so @xmath184 . the different values , @xmath185 toward the ngp and @xmath186 toward the sgp , which would explain the observed medians , however , is not accommodated in our models . the difficulties of mixed regular field geometries in the steady state are discussed by @xcite . the fluctuation ( standard deviation ) of @xmath138 in simulations , @xmath146 , is too small to account for the difference between the observed medians toward the ngp and sgp . to see whether larger fluctuations of @xmath138 are possible with different model parameters , simulations with larger values of @xmath68 and @xmath46 were carried out ( not shown ) . we found that the fluctuation of @xmath138 increases with increasing @xmath68 and becomes @xmath187 for @xmath188 . however , with such large value of @xmath68 , the em distribution estimated from wham data @xcite can not be explained ( see appendix ) . the fluctuation of @xmath138 increases with increasing @xmath46 also . we find a sufficiently large fluctuation for @xmath189 , which corresponds to @xmath190 . but such large @xmath51 is clearly inconsistent with the value constrained from the em distribution @xcite and from polarization gradients @xcite . our models also fail to reproduce the standard deviations of observed rms , @xmath155 and @xmath15 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively @xcite . our estimates , @xmath191 , are substantially smaller . the values are not consistent even with the galactic contributions estimated by @xcite , @xmath192 and @xmath193 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively . ( note that the data of @xcite and @xcite are different . ) we would get @xmath194 if we adopt @xmath195 . but again such a value is too large to explain the observed em distribution . we could explain the observed medians and standard deviations if there are additional global or local structures not represented in our models for the gmf ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? such structures could have been produced , for instance , by the parker instability or supernova explosions . in addition , @xcite have shown that transient structures can be produced in three - dimensional mhd simulations of turbulent gaseous disks . we could also address the discrepancy between the simulations and the data if the regular field is stronger than that in our models . for instance , we would have simulated the observed @xmath139 s , if the regular field strength was increased by a factor of @xmath137 . but then , the corresponding regular field strength near the galactic plane would be @xmath196 ( see figure [ figure3 ] ) , which is larger than that adopted in recent observational studies @xcite . on the other hand , after investigating rms toward the perseus arm region , @xcite argued that observed rms are consistent with a toroidal field of strength @xmath102 toward the north , but @xmath197 toward the south ( note that the observation covers a rather thin region of @xmath198 and @xmath199 ) . this indicates that there may be room for additional modeling of the gmf , which we leave for future studies . even with additional structures and stronger regular fields , however , the observed sfs are difficult to reproduce @xcite . the second - order sfs of simulated rms are substantially smaller than the observed sfs , especially at small angular separations of @xmath200 . this means that we need structures that would provide significant powers on scales of a parsec or so , but there is no observational support for such structures ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the slope of observed sfs , @xmath201 @xcite , is much flatter than that of simulated sfs , @xmath202 . we note that two - dimensional , white noise results in a flat sf ; @xmath203 , where @xmath204 is the standard deviation of the noise . we would get @xmath205 for @xmath206 . observational errors should follow the distribution of white noise . but @xcite estimated that the observational errors in their data are @xmath4 and @xmath207 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively . @xcite estimated that the error in their data is @xmath208 . so observational errors may not be enough to explain the observed flat sfs of @xmath209 ( see also * ? ? ? it is expected that radio sources against which rms are observed have their own intrinsic rms . the rms of radio sources should also follow the distribution of white noise and contribute to a flat sf . @xcite and @xcite showed that the observed sf toward the ngp deviates from a flat behavior at very small scales ; the square value of rm difference between two sources at @xmath210 and @xmath211 , @xmath212 ( not the second - order sf ) , is around @xmath170 at angular separations of @xmath213 . this tells us that even if the square value is solely due to the rms of radio sources , it is unlikely that the rms make up the observed flat sfs of @xmath209 . in fact , @xcite claimed that many observed sources possess little intrinsic rm from the fact that the fractional polarization percentage is nearly constant with increasing wavelength . finally , there exists clear evidences for an extragalactic component to the rms , from three different papers taking different approaches @xcite . although @xcite and @xcite attribute the excess scatter in rm to individual intervening absorbers along the line of sight , an alternative origin which can contribute to the observed rm toward high galactic latitudes too is the igmf . as mentioned in section 1 , using simulations for the large - scale structure formation in the universe , @xcite predicted that the rm due to the igmf would have @xmath214 and @xmath215 several @xmath141 . they also predicted that the sf of the rm has a flat profile of @xmath216 amplitude at angular separations larger than @xmath217 ; the sf is expected to decrease to the order of @xmath170 at @xmath213 from @xmath218 at @xmath219 , consistent with the observation of @xcite . the work of @xcite suggests the possibility that a substantial fraction of the rm toward the ngp and sgp can be attributed to the rm due to the igmf . if so , the observed standard deviations and sfs can be explained . but reproducing the observed medians of rm still needs additional components or / and structures of the gmf . we have studied the galactic rm toward high galactic latitudes . we have considered a number of models for the global , regular components of the gmf and the electron density in the galaxy , based on observations . the turbulent , random components were modeled with three - dimensional mhd turbulence simulations . the strength of the regular magnetic field in our models is a few @xmath138 g close to the disk and smaller at high altitudes . the strength of the turbulent field is at most a few @xmath100 , and mostly @xmath101 . we obtained rm maps for @xmath26 fov toward the galactic poles , and compared the results with observations . we also considered a smaller fov of @xmath27 , designed to simulate the fov of future surveys with the ska . our models fail to simultaneously reproduce the observed medians of rms toward the ngp and sgp . the observations require vertical magnetic fields of @xmath220 toward the ngp and @xmath221 toward the sgp in the earth s vicinity , but such field geometries are not accommodated in the gmf models we considered . the pdfs of simulated rms are narrower and more sharply peaked than the observed pdfs , meaning that the standard deviations of simulated rms are smaller than the observed values . the second - order sfs of simulated rms are one to two orders of magnitude smaller than the observed sfs at small angular separations . in addition , the slopes of the sfs of simulated rms are substantially larger than the observed ones . we argue that observational errors and the intrinsic rm of background radio sources are not enough to explain the discrepancies between the statistics of our simulated rms and observed rms . we suggest that the rm due to the igmf may account for a fraction of the rm toward high galactic latitudes and could explain the discrepancies in the standard deviation and sf of the rms . as a subsequent project , the rm due to the igmf as well as observational errors and the intrinsic rm of background radio sources would be incorporated in the modeling of the rm toward high galactic latitudes , to check quantitatively whether some of the discrepancies , such as those in the standard deviation and sf , would be explained . but we expect that reproducing the observed medians will still need additional components or / and structures of the gmf . we should note , however , that current observations of rms still contain large uncertainties . new and the future observational facilities such as the jvla , mwa , lofar , askap , meerkat , and the ska will produce much better data . for instance , askap will detect radio sources with average angular separations of @xmath219 . with such a dense rm grid , the quality of the observed rm data will be dramatically improved . better quality data will hopefully enable us to better quantify the contributions due to the gmf , the igmf , the intrinsic rm of background radio sources , and observational errors . finally , we note that better measurements of the mach number of turbulence in the halo by observations of @xmath222 line profiles @xcite as well as by radio polarization gradients @xcite will help us improve the constraints on the magnitude and structures of the rm toward high galactic latitudes . the following coordinate systems are used throughout the paper : cartesian coordinates , @xmath223 , galactocentric cylindrical coordinates , @xmath224 , galactocentric polar coordinates , @xmath225 , and galactic celestial coordinates , @xmath226 , respectively , defined in figure [ figure1 ] . here , @xmath227 is the galactocentric radius , @xmath228 is the azimuth angle starting from @xmath229 and increasing in the counterclockwise direction , and the @xmath63-@xmath230 plane coincides with the galactic plane with @xmath63 pointing to @xmath229 and @xmath230 to @xmath231 . the sun is located at @xmath232 in kpc , and thus @xmath233 kpc . the ne2001 model we employ for the electron density , @xmath28 , consists of three global components ( thick disk , thin disk , and five spiral arms ) , four local components ( local hot bubble , loop i , local super bubble , and low density region in quadrant 1 ) , and more than a hundred isolated components such as clumps and voids , as displayed in figure [ figure1 ] . the electron density of the model was obtained from the average of the dm for pulsars at known distances . we take the original parameters in the ne2001 packagecordes / ne2001/. ] , except for the scale height of the thick disk , @xmath29 , and the mid - plane electron density for the thick disk , @xmath30 . @xcite obtained @xmath234 kpc from an analysis of pulsars at high galactic latitudes . we adopt @xmath235 kpc , instead of @xmath236 kpc in the package . the corresponding mid - plane electron density for the thick disk is @xmath32 . the revised scale height improves fits of the galactic rm and radio continuum emission at low and mid - galactic latitudes @xcite . the changes of the scale height and mid - plane electron density of the thick disk , however , may not be consistent with the construction of the ne2001 model , because these parameters are highly covariant with others in the model . in order to justify our modification and make sure the consistency with observations , we compare the dm and em from the ne2001 model with the original scale height and mid - plane density ( hereafter the original ne2001 model ) and the ne2001 model with the modified scale height and mid - plane density ( our modified ne2001 model ) . we also tested the exponential model fitted by @xcite ( the plane - parallel model ) for comparison . figure [ figure11 ] shows the distribution of dm as a function of height above the galactic plane . at a height of @xmath237 kpc , both the original and modified ne2001 models reproduce the distribution of @xcite well toward the sgp , but predict smaller dm by a factor of @xmath137 toward the ngp , likely due to the local hot bubble . at the height of @xmath238 kpc , the original ne2001 model overestimates dm by a factor of @xmath239 toward south . on the other hand , the modified ne2001 model reproduces the observed dm well ; the resultant dms for the modified ne2001 are @xmath240 and @xmath241 toward the ngp and sgp , respectively , which are roughly consistent with observations @xcite . next , we calculated the pdf of em . there is a well - known issue that models with smooth electron density profile do not reproduce the observed em well ; the discrepancy can be resolved by introducing volume filling factor , @xmath242 . we adopted @xmath243 , @xmath45 in kpc , for @xmath244 kpc and @xmath245 for @xmath246 kpc @xcite . the resulting em is shown in figure [ figure12 ] . with the adopted @xmath242 , the original ne2001 does not correctly reproduce the em distribution from the wham observation @xcite . on the other hand , the modified ne2001 model and the plane - parallel model produce results , which are better consistent with the observed distribution . it is interesting to see that the cases with @xmath98 @xmath247 ( or the rms mach number of turbulence is close to @xmath248 ) better reproduce the observed em . it should be pointed that @xcite claimed smaller @xmath242 ( that is , more clumpy ) at both low and high altitudes . if smaller @xmath242 is adopted , our model gives larger dispersion of em , so that even smaller @xmath46 would be preferable . then , the corresponding standard deviation of rm would be even smaller ( figure [ figure7 ] ) . finally , figure [ figure13 ] shows the second - order sf of simulated rms in a 900 @xmath249 fov . the amplitude of sf for the original ne2001 model is somewhat larger than that for the modified ne2001 and plane - parallel models . the slope of sf does not significantly depend on the electron density model , and again the sf for the three models does not match the observed one ( see section 3.4 ) . the global , regular magnetic field , @xmath35 , is conventionally described as the combination of the disk spiral field , @xmath250 , the halo toroidal field , @xmath251 , and the halo poloidal field , @xmath252 , so that @xmath253 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? there are a number of analytic models intended to reproduce the observed structure of @xmath35 . the models have been tuned by fitting the data mostly at low and mid - galactic latitudes , but can be used for studies of the galactic rm toward high galactic latitudes as well . specifically , we employ the models introduced by @xcite for the spiral field , by @xcite for the toroidal field , by @xcite for the dipole poloidal field , and by @xcite for the x - field poloidal field , unless otherwise specified . we note that our combined model does not take account of detailed theoretical consistencies , such as the continuity , divergence - free nature , and closeness of @xmath35 . we expect that those do not significantly affect our results . the large - scale disk fields of spiral galaxies including our galaxy have been classified into two types based on the spiral pattern , the axi - symmetric spiral ( ass ) field with no dependence on the azimuthal angle , or the bi - symmetric spiral ( bss ) field with a symmetry of @xmath254 . the functional form for the disk spiral field can be written as @xmath255 where @xmath256 is the pitch angle of arms which is positive for leading spirals and negative for trailing spirals such as in our galaxy , and @xmath257 for the ass model , we adopt the ass + reversals of the magnetic field directions : @xmath258 where @xmath259 means the clockwise direction as seen from the north pole . we also adopt @xmath260 , @xmath261 , @xmath262 , @xmath263 , @xmath264 , and @xmath265 . for the bss model , we adopt the spiral structure of @xmath266 we also adopt @xmath267 , @xmath261 , @xmath268 , @xmath263 , and @xmath264 . in addition , @xmath269 and @xmath270 for @xmath271 , and otherwise @xmath272 and @xmath273 . note that the trigonometric function is minus cosine if the azimuth angle , @xmath274 , starting from @xmath231 is adopted ( e.g. , * ? ? ? reversals in the sign of rm across the galactic plane and across the galactic center ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) suggest the existence of a halo toroidal field . global three - dimensional mhd simulations of gas disks @xcite have indicated the azimuthal magnetic field component in the halo as a result of the buoyant escape of the azimuthal magnetic flux from the disk . the halo toroidal ( azimuthal ) field can be expressed as @xmath275 where @xmath276 is the sign of @xmath45 , and @xmath277 introduces the parity of the toroidal field configuration ; @xmath278 if we consider the asymmetries in longitude and latitude relative to the galactic plane and the center , respectively ( dipole ) , or @xmath279 if we consider the axisymmetric configuration without reversals relative to the galactic plane ( quadrupole ) . we adopt @xmath280 , @xmath281 , @xmath282 , and @xmath283 for @xmath284 and @xmath285 otherwise . we note that @xcite adopted smaller @xmath286 for high @xmath45 ( and also similarly small @xmath287 in their model ) , which results in @xmath288 of order @xmath289 at @xmath290 . we adopt the parameters based on @xcite , which gives @xmath291 at high @xmath45 ( see also figure [ figure3 ] ) . such a strong halo field at high @xmath45 is also motivated by recent studies of halo magnetic fields ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? nonthermal filaments observed near the galactic center imply the existence of a central , vertical magnetic field @xcite , which is also predicted from global three - dimensional mhd simulations of gas disks ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . the vertical field can be due to the galactic - center poloidal ( dipole ) field ; a strong dipole field would be observed as the vertical magnetic field in the earth vicinity . the dipole field can be expressed as @xmath292 here , we set @xmath293 @xcite to make the vertical component of @xmath294 from the poloidal field . the vertical field could be due to the out - of - plane x - field recently studied by @xcite . this model is motivated by the x - shaped field structure seen in radio observations of external , edge - on galaxies @xcite . we define the elevation angle of magnetic field , @xmath295 , with respect to the galactic mid - plane . then , the x - field can be expressed as @xmath296 we take the field at @xmath297 to have a constant elevation angle , @xmath298 , with respect to the mid - plane , where @xmath299 is the radius at which the field line passing through @xmath300 crosses the mid - plane . this means that if @xmath301 , then @xmath302 , @xmath303 , and @xmath304 . otherwise , @xmath305 @xmath306 and @xmath307 . we adopt @xmath308 , @xmath309 , @xmath310 , and @xmath311 . we thank the referee for constructive comments . we also thank p. l. biermann for comments on the manuscript , m. machida and x. sun for discussions on the galactic magnetic field model , s. a. mao for providing the data used in figure 6 , and j. stil for providing the data used in figures 9 and 12 . t.a . acknowledges the supports of the korea research council of fundamental science and technology ( krcf ) and the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) . d.r . acknowledges the support of the national research foundation ( nrf ) of korea through grant 2007 - 0093860 . j.k . acknowledges the support by the international research & development program of the national research foundation ( nrf ) funded by the ministry of education , science and technology ( mest ) of korea ( grant k20903001740 - 11b1300 - 02610 ) . b.m.g . acknowledges the support of the australian research council through grant fl100100114 . akahori , t. , & ryu , d. 2010 , , 723 , 476 akahori , t. , & ryu , d. 2011 , , 738 , 134 beck , r. , brandenburg , a. , moss , d. , shukurov , a. , & sokoloff , d. 1996 , , 34 , 155 beck , r. 2009a , ( serie de conferencias ) , 36 , 1 beck , r. 2009b , ap&ss , 320 , 77 berkhuijsen , e. m. , mitra , d. , & mller p. , 2006 , an , 327 , 82 bernet , m. l. , miniati , f. , lilly , s. j. , accepted ( arxiv:1209.2410 ) burkhart , b. , lazarian , a. , & gaensler , b. m. 2012 , , 749 , 145 carilli , c. l. & taylor , g. b. 2002 , , 40 , 319 carilli , c. l. & rawlings s. 2004 , new astronomy review , 48 , 979 cho , j. , & ryu , d. 2009 , , 705 , l90 cordes , j. m. , & lazio , t. j. w. 2002 , preprint ( astro - ph/0207156 ) cordes , j. m. , & lazio , t. j. w. 2003 , preprint ( astro - ph/0301598 ) cox , d. p. 2005 , , 43 , 337 dolag , k. , crasso , d. , springel , v. , & tkachev , i. 2005 , j. cosmology astropart . phys . , 1 , 9 faulkner , a. j. , et al . , ska memo 122 : aperture arrays for the ska - the skads white paper " , 2010 gaensler , b. m. , beck , r. , & feretti , l. 2004 , new astronomy review , 48 , 1003 gaensler , b. m. , haverkorn , m. , staveley - smith , l. , dickey , j. m. , mcclure - griffiths n. m. , dickel , j. r. , & wolleben , m. , 2005 , science , 307 , 1610 gaensler , b. m. , madsen , g. j. , chatterjee , s. , & mao , s. a. 2008 , pasa , 25 , 184 gaensler , b. , landecker , t. , & taylor , r. 2010 , bulletin of the american astronomical society , 42 , 515 gaensler , b. m. , haverkorn , m. , burkhart , b. , newton - mcgee , k. j. , ekers , r. d. , lazarian , a. , mcclure - griffiths , n. m. , robishaw , t. , dickey , j. m. , & green , a. j. 2011 , nature , 478 , 214 giacinti , g. , kachelrie , m. , demikov , d. v. , & sigl , g. 2010 , journal of cosmology and astroparticle physics , 8 , 36 haffner , l. m. , reynolds , r. j. , tufte , s. l. , madsen , g. j. , jaehnig , k. p. , & percival , j. w. 2005 , , 149 , 405 haffner , l. m. , reynolds , r. j. , madsen , g. j. , hill , a. s. , barger , k. a. , jaehnig , k. p. , mierkiewicz , e. j. , percival , j. w. & chopra , n. 2010 , in the dynamic interstellar medium : a celebration of the canadian galactic plane survey , ed . r. kothes , t. l. landecker , & a. g. willis ( san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific ) , 388 ( arxiv:1008.0612 ) hammond , a. m. , robishaw , t. , & gaensler , b. m. , submitted ( arxiv:1209.1438 ) han , j. l. 2009 , iau symp . , 259 , 455 , arxiv:0901.1165 harten , a. 1983 , j. comp . , 49 , 357 haverkorn , m. , brown , j. c. , gaensler , b. m. , & mcclure - griffiths , n. m. 2008 , , 680 , 362 hill , a. s. , benjamin , r. a. , kowel , g. , reynolds , r. j. , haffner , l. m. , & lazarian , a. 2008 , , 686 , 363 jansson , r. , & farrar , g. r. 2012 , apj , submitted . jaffe , t. r. , leahy , j. p. , banday , a. j. , leach , s. m. , lowe , s. r. , & wilkinson , a. 2010 , , 401 , 1013 kim , j. , ryu , d. , jones , t. w. , & hong , s. s. 1999 , , 514 , 506 krause , m. , alexander , p. , bolton , r. , geisbsch , j. , green , d. a. , & riley , j. 2009 , , 400 , 646 krause , m. 2009 , ( serie de conferencias ) , 36 , 25 kronberg , p. p. , bernet , m. l. , miniati , f. , lilly , s. j. , short , m. b. , & higdon , d. m. 2008 , , 676 , 70 machida , m. , matsumoto , r. , nozawa , s. , takahashi , k. , fukui , y. , kudo , n. , torii , k. , yamamoto , h. , fujishita , m. , & tomisaki , k. 2009 , , 61 , 411 machida , m. , nakamura , k. , kudo , t. , akahori , t. , sofue , y. , & matsumoto , r. , 2012 , , submitted mao , s. a. , gaensler , b. m. , haverkorn , m. , zweibel , e. g. , madsen , g. j. , mcclure - griffiths , n. m. , shukurov , a. & kronberg , p. p. 2010 , , 714 , 1170 mao , s. a. , mcclure - griffiths , n. m. , gaensler , b. m. , brown , j. c. , van eck , c. l. , haverkorn , m. , kronberg , p. p. , stil , j. m. , shukurov , a. , & taylor , a. r. 2012 , , accepted nishikori , h. , machida , m. , & matsumoto 2006 , , 641 , 862 ohno , h. , & shibata , s. 1993 , , 262 , 953 padoan , p. , jimenez , r. , nordlund , . , & boldyrev , s. 2004 , , 92 , 19 peterson , j. d. , & webber , w. r. 2002 , , 575 , 217 pshirkov , m. s. , tinyakov , p. g. , kronberg , p. p. , & newton - mcgee , k. j. 2011 , , 738 , 192 prouza , m. , & @xmath312 , r. 2003 , , 410 , 1 ryu , d. , kang , h. , & biermann , p. l. 1998a , , 335 , 19 ryu , d. , miniati , f. , jones , t. w. & frank , a. 1998b , , 509 , 244 ryu , d. , kang , h. , cho , j. , & das , s. 2008 , science , 320 , 909 schnitzeler , d. h. f. m. 2010 , , 409 , 99 simonetti , j. h. , cordes , j. m. , & spangler , s. r. , 1984 , , 284 , 126 simonetti , j. h. , & cordes , j. m. 1986 , , 310 , 160 stasyszyn , f. , nuza , s. e. , dolag , k. , beck , r. , & donnert , j. 2010 , , 408 , 684 stil , j. m. , taylor , a. r. , & sunstrum , c. 2011 , , 726 , 4 sun , x. h. , reich , w. , waelkens , a. , & enlin , t. a. 2008 , , 477 , 573 sun , x. h. , & reich , w. 2009 , , 507 , 1087 sun , x. h. , & reich , w. 2010 , research in astronomy and astrophysics , 10 , 1287 takami , h. , & sato , k. 2010 , , 724 , 1456 taylor , a. r. , stil , j. m. , & sunstrum , c. 2009 , , 702 , 1230 tinyakov , p. g. , & tkachev , i. i. 2005 , astropart . , 24 , 32 tufte , s. l. , reynolds , r. j. , & haffner , l. m. 1999 , in interstellar turbulence , ed . j. franco , & a. carraminana ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 27 van eck , c. l. , brown , j. c. , stil , j. m. , rae , k. , mao , s. a. , gaensler , b. m. , shukurov , a. , taylor , a. r. , haverkorn , m. , kronberg , p. p. , & mcclure - griffiths , n. m. 2011 , , 728 , 97 waelkens , a. , jaffe , t. , reinecke , m. , kitaura , f. s. , & enlin , t. a. , 2009 , , 495 , 697 xu , y. , kronberg , p. p. , habib , s. , & dufton , q. w. 2006 , , 637 , 19 wu , q. , kim , j. , ryu , d. , cho , j. , & alexander , p. 2009 , , 705 , l86 wu , q. , kim , j. , & ryu , d. 2012 , , submitted lcccc adon15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + ados15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + aqos15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adpn15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adps15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + aqps15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adxn15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adxs15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + aqxs15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdon15 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdos15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bqos15 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 3.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdpn15 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdps15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bqps15 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdxn15 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdxs15 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bqxs15 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adon30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + ados30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + aqos30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adpn30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adps30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + aqps30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adxn30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + adxs30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + aqxs30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdon30 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdos30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bqos30 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdpn30 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdps30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bqps30 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdxn30 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bdxs30 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath90 , 2.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath90 , 0.5 , 0.1 + bqxs30 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 2.0 , 1.0 & @xmath91 , 1.0 , 0.1 & @xmath91 , 0.5 , 0.1 llrr 0.5 & 0.1 & 1.02702 & 1.00360 + & 1.0 & 1.03139 & 1.03748 + & 10 . & 1.02755 & 1.34981 + 1.0 & 0.1 & 1.09307 & 1.01275 + & 1.0 & 1.11417 & 1.14356 + & 3.0 & 1.10303 & 1.40630 + & 10 . & 1.11177 & 2.09291 + 2.0 & 0.1 & 1.29744 & 1.04641 + & 1.0 & 1.32886 & 1.45009 + & 10 . & 1.32293 & 3.04786 lrrcrr adon & 0.00 & 0.18 & & 0.06 & 0.44 + ados & 0.02 & 1.92 & & 0.03 & 4.21 + aqos & 0.02 & 0.39 & & 0.03 & 0.90 + adpn & -4.76 & 0.45 & & -4.83 & 0.87 + adps & 5.58 & 1.95 & & 5.66 & 4.22 + aqps & 5.58 & 0.36 & & 5.65 & 0.78 + adxn & -4.12 & 0.13 & & -4.12 & 0.29 + adxs & 4.69 & 1.97 & & 4.70 & 4.28 + aqxs & 4.69 & 0.51 & & 4.70 & 1.11 + bdon & 0.00 & 0.14 & & 0.05 & 0.35 + bdos & 0.02 & 1.87 & & 0.03 & 4.08 + bqos & 0.02 & 0.32 & & 0.03 & 0.75 + bdpn & -4.76 & 0.41 & & -4.83 & 0.80 + bdps & 5.58 & 1.90 & & 5.65 & 4.09 + bqps & 5.58 & 0.31 & & 5.65 & 0.66 + bdxn & -4.12 & 0.10 & & -4.12 & 0.24 + bdxs & 4.69 & 1.91 & & 4.70 & 4.14 + bqxs & 4.68 & 0.44 & & 4.70 & 0.96 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: optical spectra of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) exhibit an extremely wide variety of properties . the emission - line regions of agn have proven to be among the most complex of all astrophysical environments @xcite . agn have also been known to emit a substantial fraction of their luminosity as x - rays . multi - wavelength observations of well - defined source samples are effective in understanding the physical processes in agn . in the last decade , several correlations between optical emission line properties and x - ray properties were noted @xcite : for instance , the strong correlations between optical fe ii , [ o iii]@xmath1 line strengths , velocity width of h@xmath0 and the slope of soft x - ray continuum ( @xmath2 ) . these correlations received great interest previously and were expected to give important insight into the agn phenomenon . still , however , their interpretation remained unclear . it is therefore of great importance to test whether these correlations are fundamental properties or subtle selection effects , and search for new ones . clearly , a large and homogeneous x - ray selected sample would be advantageous in addressing these issues . we present such a sample here . x - ray agn samples are also of great interest for a number of other issues . agn of different types are the major contributors to the extragalactic soft and hard x - ray background ( xrb ) . the definitions of statistically significant agn samples using x - ray data are key to test agn number - flux relations , luminosity functions and cosmological evolution . in the course of the rosat all sky survey ( rass ) @xcite , many new agn have been identified by different teams , confirming that x - ray surveys are very efficient in finding new agn . @xcite performed an unbiased survey of all bright , @xmath3 , high galactic latitude sources in the rass without applying other selection criteria . * paper i ) identified a sample with high x - ray to optical flux ratio . @xcite and @xcite presented a catalog of sources in selected areas down to the rass limit . @xcite drew a high galactic latitude sample from the rass with soft pspc spectra ( @xmath4 ) , the corresponding sample of point - like x - ray sources with relatively hard x - ray spectra ( @xmath5 ) was presented by @xcite . @xcite published a catalog of northern agn in the rass based on their schmidt plate survey . these authors presented new agn , but they did not use their samples to address correlations issues . this will be done with the present sample . in paper i we described and presented the optical identification of a sample of 165 x - ray sources with high x - ray to optical flux ratio ( @xmath6 ) discovered in the rass . about 73% of the sources were identified as agn , including 115 emission line agn ( qsos and seyferts ) as well as 2 bl lac objects and 4 bl lac candidates . in this paper we investigate the optical emission line properties of the emission line agn that were identified as main optical counterparts of the sample and discuss their connection with x - ray properties . not included in the following discussion are the bl lac objects . the initial identification program excluded known x - ray sources that have counterparts in the simbad , ned and agn catalogs . motivated by the need of larger and better samples , we have cross - referenced the rass bright source catalog with the ned and agn catalogs . we find that 40 known emission line agn meet our selection criteria . , where cr and r represent x - ray count rate and r magnitude respectively ; declination @xmath7 ; galactic latitude @xmath8 ; optical counterparts within a circle with radius @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the rass position error given by voges et al.(1996 ) ; optical counterparts with r magnitudes between 13.5 and 16.5 . ] in order to keep consistent emission line properties measurements , new optical spectra have been acquired for the 40 additional sources . these data , combined with the previous optical identifications , provide a large , bright and ( @xmath6 ) limited sample of emission line agn in the rosat x - ray band . the relatively complete sample is the largest x - ray selected agn sample with intense optical investigation so far . as described in paper i , our classifications and identifications were based on low resolution spectra obtained with a 2.16 m telescope at xinglong station , national astronomical observatories of china ( naoc ) . these spectra were exposed to reach a s / n suitable for a reliable classification . the quality of the majority spectra is sufficient to measure the properties of the emission lines , such as the line widths and line strengths . for spectra with inadequate s / n , new low resolution ( @xmath1110 fwhm ) optical spectroscopy was performed using the 2.16 m telescope at naoc . all objects in our emission line agn subsample are found to be seyfert 1 type agn . throughout this paper seyfert 1 galaxies and qsos will be discussed jointly , since these two classes are distinguished only by a certain luminosity level according to our classification criterion . we do not divide the seyfert 1 class into subclasses such as seyfert 1.5 - 1.9 or nls1 galaxies ( as defined by @xcite , @xcite ) , since the definitions of seyfert classifications depend on the resolution of the spectra used and the noise in the spectra @xcite . the paper is organized as follows . detailed optical measurements are given in sect . the statistical properties are investigated in sect . 3 . several diagnostically important correlations that exist between emission line and continuum properties are studied . 4 discusses the implications of the results , followed by a brief summary of the main conclusions of the paper . throughout this paper , a hubble constant of @xmath12 and a deceleration parameter of @xmath13 are assumed and all measured parameters are quoted for the rest frame of the source . the known sources as well as sources without high quality observations in the identification campaign were investigated during several observing runs performed from november 1998 through december 2000 . the low resolution spectra were taken with the naoc 2.16 m telescope and the omr spectrograph , using a tektronix @xmath14 ccd as detector . the grating of 300 g mm@xmath15 was employed in order to get large wavelength coverage . all observations were made through a 2.3@xmath16 slit that produced a resolution of 10 to 11 as measured from the comparison spectra . this set - up provided similar wavelength coverage ( 3800 8200 ) and resolution to the identification data . exposure time was generally between 1200s and 3600s depending on the brightness of the object . for a few objects , multiple exposures were performed in order to get a higher s / n spectrum . the exposures were combined prior to extraction where possible in order to help remove cosmic ray contamination . in cases when the target source moved across the ccd chip between exposures , the data were extracted separately from each frame and then combined . the raw data were reduced following standard procedures using iraf . the ccd reductions included bias subtraction , flatfield correction and cosmic - ray removal . wavelength calibration was carried out using helium - neon - argon lamps taken at the beginning and end of each exposure . the resulting wavelength accuracy is better than 1 . the flux calibration was derived with 2 to 3 observations of kpno standard stars @xcite per night . in many of the spectra there is a clear contribution from blends of fe ii line emission on both the blue and red sides of the h@xmath0-[o iii ] complex . these blends contaminate strong lines such as [ o iii]@xmath174959,5007 , and may alter the flux and width of h@xmath0+[o iii]@xmath174959,5007 . in order to reliably measure line parameters and to determine the strength of the fe ii emission , we have carefully removed the fe ii multiplets following the method described by @xcite , which relies on an fe ii template . the template used in the present work is the same as that of @xcite , namely the fe ii lines of i zw 1 , a bright nls1 widely known for the strong and narrow permitted fe ii emission @xcite . the observed spectra were wavelength - shifted to the rest frame according to the redshift.@xmath185007 to be the systemic redshift as most commonly used . the redshift was derived from fitting a gaussian to the upper half of the observed [ o iii]@xmath185007 line in each spectrum . ] the whole template was broadened to the fwhm of the broad h@xmath0 line by convolving with a gaussian and scaled to match the line intensities . the best match was then searched for in the two - dimensional parameter space of line width and line strength . from each object the best - fit fe ii spectrum was then subtracted . a successful fe ii subtraction showed a flat continuum between the h@xmath19 and h@xmath0 and between 51005400 ( which covers the fe ii multiplets 48 , 49 ) . the fe ii flux was measured between the rest wavelength 4434 and 4684 as in @xcite . the characteristic property of seyfert 1 type agn is the presence of broad emission lines . the line widths and their distributions provide important information on masses of the central black holes and mass distributions . the broad balmer lines in agn exhibit a wide variety of profile shapes and a large range in width @xcite and they are often strongly asymmetric @xcite . in many cases h@xmath0 is a mixture of broad and narrow components . differences in the relative strengths of these components account for much of the diversity of broad line profiles @xcite . the fe ii subtracted spectra were used to measure the non - fe ii line properties . in order to isolate the broad h@xmath0 component in all spectra , we have assumed that the emission line profiles can be represented by a single or a combination of gaussian profiles . @xcite claimed that the broad emission lines in nls1 galaxies were better fitted with lorentzian profiles than with gaussian profiles . however , as noted in @xcite , the choice of gaussian or lorentzian profiles as representatives of the observed emission lines may bear no physical meaning . we performed a multiple gaussian fit in the present work for its simplicity and a direct comparison with the measurements of previous studies ( e.g. @xcite ) . we adopted the method described by @xcite and used the iraf package specfit to measure blended lines . as a first step we tried to fit the emission lines with a single gaussian component . it worked well for most forbidden lines , e.g. , [ o iii]@xmath185007 . however , this simplest representation could not fit adequately the wings of h@xmath0 , although its core was nicely fitted in most of targets . in such cases , we then included one narrow component and one broad component to describe adequately the observed profile . ( note that when h@xmath0 measurements were taken from the literature , many of them refer to the whole line . ) for each assumed component , a first guess of the central wavelength , the total flux , and width of that component were specified . there were two parameters for each continuum component , i.e. , the flux and the slope . initially , we constructed a narrow component with a width determined from fitting the [ o iii ] lines . in some spectra such a guess failed to give a good fit and needed an additional component . we then left the width of the narrow component as a free parameter . it led to a nice fitting result by checking the residual , i.e. , the narrow component could be well isolated from the broad component . for h@xmath0 lines with asymmetric profile , the two gaussian components are not stationary in wavelength . the velocity shift between the broad and narrow components is defined as the shift of the broad component relative to the narrow component in units of km s@xmath15 ( see also zheng et al 2002 ) . as an illustration , we show the decomposition in figure 1 . the observed profile is represented by a solid line , the total fit by a dashed line , the individual gaussian components by a dot - dashed line and the differences between the data and the fit ( the residual ) by the lower dotted line . the broad component is referred as h@xmath20 , and the narrow component as h@xmath21 . the fwhm h@xmath20 is what we consider as representative of the broad line region ( blr ) . the instrumental resolution was determined from the fwhms of night sky spectra taken with each of the exposures and tested by comparison - lamp spectra . all quoted line widths were corrected for the instrumental resolution . the uncertainty of h@xmath0 velocity shift measurement is within 150 km s@xmath15 . to measure line fluxes and equivalent widths ( ew ) , power - law continua were fitted and subtracted from underneath the lines and the remaining line flux was integrated . for most objects , the uncertainty of flux measurement of emission lines is about 10% to 15% . the continuum level at the position of h@xmath0 @xmath184861 was measured from the fe ii subtracted spectra . all equivalent widths measurements in this paper refer to the continuum at that point to allow direct comparison with the measurements for other samples @xcite . the optical index @xmath22 was calculated using the continuum flux density at 4000 and 7000 in the rest frame . for the x - ray analysis , a single power law description was employed . this application has proven to be a fairly good approximation for agn in previous studies ( e.g. fiore et al . 1994 , brinkmann & siebert 1994 , schartel et al . 1996 , grupe et al . 1998 ) . because of the limited signal - to - noise ratio of the rass spectra we assumed that the absorption comes from our galaxy only . the assumption usually improves the reliability of the estimation of spectral index because of the reduced number of free parameters . the x - ray spectral slope @xmath23 was estimated using the rosat hardness ratios hr1 and hr2 , which are defined as @xcite : @xmath24 @xmath25 here , a , b , c and d denote the count rate in the energy range 0.10.4 kev , 0.52.0 kev , 0.50.9 kev and 0.92.0 kev , respectively . the full optical dataset was used to define the statistical properties of the sample and explore the correlations between various observed parameters . according to paper i , 115 sources ( about 73% of the total ) were identified as new seyfert 1s and qsos , together with 40 known emission line agn that meet our sample selection criteria , the agn subsample comprises 49 `` ultrasoft '' ( @xmath26 ) sources and 106 `` normal '' objects with mean @xmath27 . in the catalog in paper i we listed the absolute magnitude m@xmath28 and redshift @xmath29 . the distributions of the m@xmath28 values and redshift are plotted in figure 2 . as shown by these figures , the sample is dominated by moderate luminosity objects ( @xmath30 ) with an average redshift @xmath31 . table 1 lists the derived parameters . the columns list the following information : ( 2 ) redshift ; ( 3 ) fwhm of broad h@xmath0 ; ( 4 ) fwhm of narrow h@xmath0 ; ( 5 ) fwhm of [ o iii]@xmath185007 ; ( 6 ) , ( 7 ) and ( 8) the local equivalent widths of h@xmath0 broad component , fe ii and [ o iii]@xmath185007 ; ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) ratio of fluxes of [ o iii]@xmath185007 to broad and narrow h@xmath0 ; ( 11 ) ratio of fluxes of fe ii to broad h@xmath0 ; ( 12 ) velocity shift between h@xmath0 broad and narrow components , where a positive velocity corresponds to a redshifted broad component relative to narrow component ; ( 13 ) and ( 14 ) h@xmath0 broad and narrow components velocity shift with respect to the systemic frame , where a positive velocity indicates a redward shift with respect to systemic ; ( 15 ) and ( 16 ) spectral indices defined above ; ( 17 ) the monochromatic 250ev luminosity . the distribution of the broad h@xmath0 line width of the objects in our emission line agn subsample shows a significantly smaller fraction ( 3% ) of objects with fwhm @xmath32 2000 km s@xmath15 compared to another x - ray selected sample ( 18% ) @xcite . however , the fwhm measurements in @xcite refer to the full line profile and the widths of the broad components may have been underestimated . therefore , the real difference should be smaller . five out of 155 objects in our sample are nls1 galaxies without detectable broad balmer line components of fwhm @xmath33 2000 km s@xmath15 but with strong fe ii emission , which agrees within the error limits with that of @xcite ( about 2% ) . the distribution of the fwhm of the broad component of h@xmath0 in the sample is displayed in figure 3 . the mean value of 4350 km s@xmath15 is similar to the hard sample of @xcite . the velocity shift distribution of h@xmath34 with respect to [ o iii]@xmath1 is shown in figure 4a . positive velocity corresponds to a redward h@xmath0 with respect to systemic , while a negative velocity represents a blueshift . the peak of this distribution is near zero , but has a mean redshift of 78 km s@xmath15 with standard deviation of 305 km s@xmath15 . this shift is in good agreement with the previous studies @xcite , i.e. , balmer emission lines gives the same redshift to within 100 km s@xmath15 of narrow forbidden emission ( _ e.g. _ [ o iii]@xmath185007 ) in low redshift ( @xmath35 ) qsos and seyfert galaxies . in contrast , a systematic mean redward shift of 520 km s@xmath15 was found for a high redshift ( @xmath36 ) qsos sample @xcite . @xcite proposed this observed trend of increased balmer redshift with increased systemic redshift represents a luminosity dependency . for comparison , we also present the h@xmath21 [ o iii]@xmath1 shift in figure 4b . the mean of the distribution is 8 km s@xmath15 with a standard deviation of 176 km s@xmath15 . we can see from the figures that the dispersion of the h@xmath21 [ o iii]@xmath1 shift is significantly narrower than the h@xmath34 [ o iii]@xmath1 shift , which is expected by the different emitting regions between h@xmath0 broad component and narrow component , as well as [ o iii]@xmath1 . in a similar manner to the h@xmath34 [ o iii]@xmath1 shift , figure 4c illustrates the velocity differences between the broad and narrow components of h@xmath0 . the redshift ( or blueshift ) is defined as the shift of the broad component relative to the narrow component in units of km s@xmath15 . positive velocities refer to redshifts with respect to the narrow component velocities , whereas negative velocities indicate blueshifts . we emphasis that both the h@xmath0 redshift ( or blueshift ) in the present work and the asymmetry parameter in @xcite are measures for line profile , but characterized differently . the latter is a measure of the shift between the centroids at @xmath37 and @xmath38 maximum . the mean redshift of the distribution is found to be 70 km s@xmath15 with a standard deviation of 357 km s@xmath15 . correlation analyses involving the line profiles of h@xmath0 are investigated in section 3.3 . in this subsection , we explore whether the various emission - line and continuum properties correlate with one another . for this purpose , we calculated the spearman rank - order correlation matrix @xcite , along with its significance matrix for measured properties . the complete correlation coefficient matrix is shown in table 2 . the number of parameter pairs included in the trials ranges from 86 to 149 . spectra with s / n @xmath39 were excluded from the analyses including optical properties . the probability of the null correlation , ps , for a sample with corresponding correlation coefficient rs is also given in table 2 for entries with @xmath40 . a set of 12 different properties results in @xmath41 correlation coefficients ; therefore , at this level of significance , we would expect @xmath42 spurious events . among 66 trials , 31 correlations ( both positive and negative ) are found with two - sided probabilities @xmath40 . four are due to the dependent parameters , e.g. , relative strength of fe ii to h@xmath0 and fe ii ew ; 12 are degenerate correlations , i.e. , different measures of the same property ( e.g. , [ o iii ] ew , [ o iii]/h@xmath34 and [ o iii]/h@xmath21 ) all correlate with another property ( e.g. , fe ii ew ) ; and therefore 15 are independent correlations at the @xmath43 confidence level . the well - known anti - correlation between the x - ray spectral slope @xmath44 and the fwhm of h@xmath0 @xcite is not prominent in our sample ( @xmath45 , @xmath46 ) as is the case in the @xcite sample ( @xmath47 , @xmath48 ) . @xcite suggested that the relation between h@xmath0 width and @xmath44 is not a linear correlation , but probably resulted from a `` zone of avoidance '' @xcite , i.e. , broad line objects always tend to show flat x - ray spectra , whereas there is a very large scatter in the x - ray spectral steepness of nls1 galaxies , with several as flat as normal seyfert 1s ( xu et al . the correlation is more pronounced among the agn with higher luminosity as in the samples of @xcite and @xcite . for objects with @xmath49 the significance becomes @xmath50 . the correlation between @xmath44 and h@xmath34 is illustrated in figure 5 . the anti - correlation between the width of h@xmath0 and fe ii / h@xmath0 @xcite is strong ( @xmath51 , @xmath52 ) in the present data whereas it is only weak ( @xmath47 , @xmath53 ) if fwhm h@xmath0 is compared directly with ew fe ii . instead , there is a strong correlation ( @xmath54 , @xmath52 ) between fwhm h@xmath0 and ew h@xmath0 . the lack of correlation between the line width and fe ii strength ( when measured independently with h@xmath0 ) in @xcite , @xcite and the present work has confirmed that the anti - correlation arises because h@xmath0 gets weaker as the lines get narrower @xcite . in addition to our confirmation of well documented correlations between different agn properties , we report on three newly discovered correlations involving the h@xmath0 redshift ( or blueshift ) , flux ratios of fe ii to h@xmath0 broad component ( fe ii / h@xmath34 ) and [ o iii ] to h@xmath0 narrow component ( [ o iii]/h@xmath21 ) . the correlations covering [ o iii]/h@xmath21 have never been investigated by other authors so far . we find the relative strength of fe ii to h@xmath34 ( fe ii / h@xmath34 ) significantly correlated to both the h@xmath0 redshift blueshift and flux ratio of fe ii to h@xmath0 whole line was detected in @xcite . we emphasize that our ratio refers to the broad component in h@xmath0 only . note the sign difference between this paper and @xcite . the positive correlation quoted by @xcite becomes negative in the notation used herein . ] ( @xmath55 , @xmath52 ) and the relative strength of [ o iii ] to h@xmath21 ( [ o iii]/h@xmath21 , @xmath56 , @xmath52 ) . a correlation test was also applied between h@xmath0 redshift and [ o iii]/h@xmath21 . the correlation is prominent in our sample ( @xmath57 , @xmath58 ) . figure 6 shows the correlations . there is a trend that strong fe ii / h@xmath34weak [ o iii]/h@xmath21 objects tend to have blueshifts in h@xmath0 while strong [ o iii]/h@xmath21 weak fe ii / h@xmath34 objects tend to have redshifts in h@xmath0 . these strong correlations between fe ii / h@xmath34 , h@xmath0 redshift and [ o iii]/h@xmath21 must reflect some physical connection between broad and narrow line emitting regions . one key to understand the central engines of agn lies in examining their local environment . the standard paradigm proposes that the surrounding gas is photoionized in physically distinct regions by radiation emerging from the central power source@xcite . however , the segregation of the ionized gas into broad - line region ( blr ) and narrow - line region ( nlr ) , as well as the details of the gas kinematics are still far from clear . optical spectroscopy of the ionized gas around galactic nuclei provides strong constraints on the excitation mechanisms . the following discussion addresses three key points : ( 1 ) how do the present results compare to previous work ; ( 2 ) which new correlations do we find and how can we understand them ; and ( 3 ) which future observations can we perform to distinguish between different suggested scenarios . a number of consistent correlations among observational parameters have been searched in order to understand the basic properties underlying the observed spectra . in particular , @xcite made a landmark study of the optical emission - line properties and continuum properties ( radio through x - ray ) of 87 low redshift pg quasars . a principal component analysis revealed `` eigenvector 1 '' ( ev1 ) links stronger fe ii emission , weaker [ o iii ] emission from the nlr , and narrower h@xmath0 ( blr ) with stronger line blue asymmetry . more recently , @xcite found these optical properties also go along with steeper soft x - ray spectra and claimed the soft x - ray slope as a related part of ev1 . we confirm these trends and present in addition three newly discovered correlations involving the h@xmath0 redshift , fe ii / h@xmath34 and [ o iii]/h@xmath21 . potentially , ev1 represents a fundamental physical driver that control the energy producing and radiation emitting processes . the two leading interpretations by far are that ev1 is driven by ( 1 ) the eddington ratio @xmath59 @xcite and ( 2 ) orientation effect . @xcite argued strongly that viewing angle is unlikely to drive ev1 , by assuming [ o iii ] emission is isotropic , originating from radii large enough to be free from orientation dependent obscuration . the isotropy of [ o iii ] emission has been questioned by the studies of radio - loud agn @xcite . however , a recent study of radio - quiet quasars @xcite showed a significant correlation between ev1 and orientation independent [ o ii ] emission , which implied that ev1 is not driven by orientation . moreover , the correlation between [ o ii ] and [ o iii ] emission indicated [ o iii ] emission is not dependent on orientation . the most promising interpretation at present is that ev1 is mostly governed by @xmath59 @xcite . this suggestion was based on the notion that the vertical thickness of the accretion disk , driven by the eddington ratio , controls the line strengths and continuum parameters . the striking correlations between the h@xmath0 redshift , fe ii / h@xmath34 and [ o iii]/h@xmath21 found in the present work give us linkages of the gas kinematics and ionization between blr and nlr . the question raised is what is the physical process behind the correlations ? can both the new and previous correlations be explained within one single scenario ? indeed , the @xmath59 interpretation provides plausible explanations for the observed trends . one of the two general scenarios in agn to explain asymmetric profile is in terms of an outflowing component in the blr with a change in obscuration by a central disk of clouds on the receding side . accreting systems in high @xmath59 agn will drive relatively thick outflows due to their larger photon luminosities per unit gravitational mass . as the velocity of the outflow increases , the h@xmath0 develops an increasing excess on the blue wing . the corresponding blue h@xmath34 velocity shift in comparison with [ o iii ] can be also well predicted because both the line asymmetry and the shift of the line centroids are effects of the same process . the link between blr and nlr in terms of density is less straight forward to predict . e.g. , due to the strong outflow , the nlr might be replaced by denser clouds . given a typical radial distribution of nlr clouds , [ o iii]/h@xmath21 peaks around densities of @xmath60 = 24 ( e.g. , komossa & schulz 1997 ) . high - density nlr clouds would therefore lead to a suppression of [ o iii ] strength . the same is true for the other limit , a low - density nlr . some authors favored a low - density blr of nls1 galaxies ( see , e.g. , the discussion in rodriguez - pascual et al . 1997 and komossa & mathur 2001 ) , which may indicate a low - density nlr as well , if both regions are coupled . the best way to measure directly the density of the nlr of nls1s in the future is to employ the density - sensitive line ratios [ o ii]@xmath183729/[o ii]@xmath183726 or [ s ii]@xmath186716/[s ii]@xmath186731 . these ratios are presently generally not reported in the literature . their measurements requires high s / n spectroscopy and/or resolution to detect and resolve these lines .- ratio measured by @xcite . this yields @xmath61 2.8 and does not deviate significantly from the values found for , e.g. , seyfert 1 and 2 galaxies . however , ngc 4051 is not an extreme nls1 in terms of x - ray steepness and fe ii emission . ] more indirectly , other line - ratios will also change in dependence of density and thus allow a density determination . for instance , a higher - density nlr would strongly boost the [ o i]@xmath186300 line @xcite . although it is more difficult to illustrate the direct connection between strong fe ii emission and large @xmath59 , some suggestions have been proposed . @xcite suggested the x - ray spectrum becomes steeper in high @xmath59 agn . if the euv x - ray spectrum plays an important role in the formation and confinement of the blr clouds ( e.g. , krolik , mckee & tarter 1981 ) , a steep x - ray spectrum coupled to a flatter euv spectrum will lead to a thicker blr ( e.g. , komossa & meerschweinchen 2000 ) , and thus stronger fe ii emission if the the low - excitation part of the blr is mechanically heated @xcite . increased metal abundances in more extreme nls1 galaxies @xcite would enhance these trends , i.e. lead to thicker blrs @xcite . supersolar iron abundance may additionally boost the strength of fe ii . in another model by @xcite , fe ii line emission is produced in an accretion disk . the agn with higher @xmath59 might simply have more mass in the accretion disk to produce stronger fe ii emission by postulating collisional excitation @xcite as the origin of the fe ii emission in general . the strong correlations of properties linking dynamics ( line widths ) , kinematics ( line shifts ) , ionization in blr and nlr ( fe ii and [ o iii ] strengths ) , and radiation process ( x - ray spectral shape ) are likely driven by an intrinsic properties , i.e. , the @xmath59 . in order to further test the favored scenario ( and get more constraints on , e.g. , the density of the nlr ) , larger and even more complete agn sample with higher resolution optical data is needed . this paper presents the statistical study of optical emission line properties of a bright agn sample selected from rass . the sample comprises 155 seyfert 1 type agn . our conclusions based on the correlation analysis can be succinctly summarized as follows : * the previously reported correlations between the strengths of fe ii , [ o iii ] emission and the x - ray slope are confirmed . strong optical fe ii blends go along with weak forbidden emission lines ( e.g. , [ o iii ] ) and steep x - ray slopes . * the anti - correlation between the x - ray spectral slope @xmath62 and the fwhm of h@xmath0 becomes prominent as far as the high luminosity agn are concerned . * striking correlations between the h@xmath0 redshift , fe ii / h@xmath34 and [ o iii]/h@xmath21 are found . there is a general trend that strong fe ii / h@xmath34weak [ o iii]/h@xmath21 objects tend to have blueshifts in h@xmath0 while strong [ o iii]/h@xmath21 weak fe ii / h@xmath34 objects tend to have redshifts in h@xmath0 . * we add new arguments that the observed trends are likely driven by @xmath59 and describe some future observations that could further test this suggestion . we thank drs . todd a. boroson and richard f. green for providing the fe ii template , drs . dirk grupe , simon vaughan , mira vron , philippe vron , tinggui wang , dieter engels for helpful discussions on the optical measurements , and the anonymous referee for many useful comments and suggestions . special thanks go also to the staff at xinglong station for their instrumental and observing help . d.x . acknowledges a mpg - cas exchange program . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , caltech , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . the rosat project is supported by the bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung ( bmbf ) and the max - planck - gesellschaft . this work was supported by nsfc under grant 19973014 . appenzeller , i. , zickgraf , f.j . , krautter , j. , & voges , w. 2000 , , 364 , 443 appenzeller , i. , thiering , i. , zickgraf , f .- j . , et al . 1998 , , 117 , 319 bade , n. , engels , d. , & voges , w. 1998 , , 127 , 145 bade , n. , fink , h. , engels , d. , et al . 1995 , , 110 , 469 baker , j.c . 1997 , , 286 , 23 boller , th . , brandt , w.n . , & fink , h. 1996 , , 305 , 53 boroson , t.a . , & green , r.f . 1992 , , 80 , 109 brinkmann , w. , & siebert , j. 1994 , , 285 , 812 brotherton , m.s . , wills , b.j . , francis , p.j . , & steidel , c.c . 1994 , , 430 , 495 corbin , m.r . 1995 , , 447 , 496 corbin , m. r. , & boroson , t. a. 1996 , , 107 , 69 corbin , m.r . 1997 , , 113 , 245 creshaw , d.m . 1986 , , 62 , 821 de robertis , m.m . 1985 , , 289 , 67 evans , i.n . 1988 , , 67 , 373 fiore , f. , elvis , m. , mcdowell j. c. , et al . 1994 , , 431 , 515 fischer , j .- u . , hasinger , g. , schwope , a.d . , et al . 1998 , astron . nachr . , 319 , 347 francis , p.j . , hewett , p.c . , foltz , c.b . , & chaffee , f.h . 1992 , , 398 , 476 gaskell , c. m. 1982 , , 263 , 79 gaskell , c.m . 1985 , , 291 , 112 gaskell , c.m . 2000 , new astronomy review , 44 , 563 goodrich , r.w . 1989a , , 340 , 190 goodrich , r.w . 1989b , , 342 , 224 grupe , d. , beuermann , k. , thomas , h .- c . , mannheim , k. , & fink h.h . 1998 , , 330 , 25 grupe , d. , beuermann , k. , mannheim , k. , & thomas , h .- c . 1999 , , 350 , 31 he s , r. , barthel , p.d . , & fosbury , r.a.e . 1993 , , 362 , 326 joly , m. 1987 , , 184 , 33 komossa , s. , grupe , d. , & janek , m. 2001 , in aip conf . 599 , x - ray astronomy 999 : stellar endpoints , agn and the diffuse background , ed . n. white , g. malaguti , & g. palumboi , 686 komossa , s. , & schulz , h. 1997 , , 323 , 31 komossa , s. , & mathur , s. 2001 , , 374 , 914 komossa , s. , & meerschweinchen , j. 2000 , , 354 , 411 krolik , j.h . , mckee , c.f . , tarter , c.b . 1981 , , 249 , 422 kuraszkiewicz , j. , wilkes , b.j . , brandt , w.n . , et al . 2000 , , 542 , 631 kwan , j. , cheng , f. , fang , l. , et al . 1995 , , 440 , 628 laor , a. , bahcall , j. n. , jannuzi , b.t . , schneider , d.p . , & green , r.f . 1995 , , 99 , 1 laor , a. , fiore , f. , martin , e. , et al . 1997 , , 477 , 93 lawrence , a. , elvis , m. , wilkes , b.j . , mchardy , i. & brandt , n. 1997 , , 285 , 879 massey , p. , & strobel , k. 1988 , , 328 , 315 mathur , s. 2000 , , 314 , l17 mcintosh , d.h . , rix , h .- w . , rieke , m.j . , & foltz , c.b . 1999 , , 517 , l73 miller , p. , rawlings , s. , saunders , r. , & eales , s. 1992 , , 254 , 93 netzer , h. , & wills , b.j . 1983 , , 275 , 445 oke , j.b . , & lauer , t.r . 1979 , , 230 , 360 osterbrock , d.e . 1977 , , 215 , 733 osterbrock , d.e . , & shuder , j.m . 1982 , , 49 , 149 osterbrock , d.e . , & pogge , r.w . 1985 , , 297 , 166 osterbrock , d.e . 1989 , astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei ( university science books : mill valley , ca ) pounds , k.a . , done , c. , osborne , j.p . , 1995 , , 277 , l5 press , w.h . , teukolsky , s.a . , vetterling , w.t . , & flannery , b.p . 1992 , numerical recipes in fortran : the art of scientific computing ( 2nd ed . ; cambridge : university press ) phillips , m.m . 1978 , , 226 , 736 rodriguez - ardila , a. , pastoriza , m.g . , & donzelli , c.j . 2000a , , 126 , 63 rodriguez - ardila , a. , binette , l. , pastoriza , m.g . , & donzelli , c.j . 2000b , , 538 , 581 rodriguez - pascual p.m. , mas - hesse j.m . , santos - lleo m. , 1997 , , 327 , 72 schartel , n. , walter , r. , fink , h.h . , et al . 1996 , , 307 , 33 schwope , a.d . , hasinger , g. , lehmann , i. , et al . 2000 , astron . nachr . , 321 , 1 stripe , g.m . 1991 , , 247 , 3 thomas , h .- c . , beuermann , k. , reisch , k. , et al . 1998 , , 335 , 467 tytler , d. , & fan , x .- m . 1992 , , 79 , 1 vaughan , s. , edelson , r. , warwick , r.s . , et al . 2001 , , 327 , 673 veilleux , s. 1991 , , 369 , 331 vron - cetty , m.p . , vron , p. , & gonalves , a.c . 2001 , , 372 , 730 vron - cetty , m.p . , & vron , p. 2000 , , 10 , 81 voges , w. , boller , th . , dennerl , k. , et al . 1996 , in mpe report 263 , rontgenstrahlung from the universe , ed . zimmermann , j. trmper , & h. yorke , 637 voges , w. , et al . 1999 , , 349 , 389 wang , t. , brinkmann , w. , & bergeron , j. 1996 , , 309 , 81 wei , j.y . , xu , d.w . , dong , x.y . , & hu , j.y . 1999 , , 139 , 575 ( paper i ) wills , b.j . , brotherton , m.s . , fang , d. , steidel , c.c . , & sargent , w.l.w . 1993 , , 415 , 563 wills , b.j . , netzer , h. , & wills , d. 1985 , , 288 , 94 wills , b. 1982 , in iau symp . 97 , extragalactic radio sources , ed . heeschen & c.m . wade ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 373 xu , d.w . , wei , j.y . , & hu , j.y . 1999 , , 517 , 622 zheng , x.z . , xia , x.y . , mao , s. , et al . 2002 , , 124 , 18 zickgraf , f .- j . , thiering , i. , krautter , j. , et al . 1997 , , 123 , 103 llrrrrrrrrrrrrrcc 1.0 mm 1rxs j000011.9 + 052318&0.040 & 3050 & 1050 & 600 & 37.3 & 26.7 & 22.5 & 0.6 & 1.8 & 0.7 & 40 & -50 & -90 & 1.2&[email protected] & 43.6 + 1rxs j000055.5 + 172346&0.215 & 6420 & 2290 & 830 & 75.5 & 64.9 & 8.5 & 0.1 & 0.9 & 0.9 & 640 & 150 & -490 & 0.6&[email protected] & 44.3 + 1rxs j000550.0 + 102249&0.095 & 4240 & - & 660 & 58.6 & 0.0 & 45.8 & 0.8 & - & 0.0 & 380 & 340 & -40 & 2.0&[email protected] & 43.4 + 1rxs j000915.0 + 243758&0.118 & 3880 & 1540 & 640 & 34.0 & 13.5 & 12.9 & 0.4 & 2.3 & 0.4 & -70 & -150 & -80 & 1.4&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j000953.0 + 371906&0.154 & 4240 & - & 1380 & 27.6 & 34.6 & 22.8 & 0.8 & - & 1.3 & - & 70 & - & - & [email protected] & 44.3 + 1rxs j001121.2 + 373919&0.104 & 3770 & 1010 & 860 & 52.7 & 38.2 & 12.4 & 0.2 & 1.7 & 0.7 & 480 & 290 & -190 & - & [email protected] & 43.5 + 1rxs j001452.7 + 270549&0.086 & 3350 & 870 & 760 & 28.7 & 25.5 & 24.4 & 0.8 & 2.3 & 0.9 & 230 & 200 & -30 & 1.1&[email protected] & 43.9 + 1rxs j002007.2 + 324423&0.082 & 3820 & 1380 & 950 & 38.1 & 78.7 & 3.6 & 0.1 & 0.3 & 2.1 & -230 & -260 & -30 & - & [email protected] & 43.6 + 1rxs j002445.3 + 082047&0.067 & 1660 & 690 & 690 & 31.0 & 72.2 & 6.2 & 0.2 & 4.0 & 2.3 & -170 & -220 & -50 & - & [email protected] & 43.3 + 1rxs j002811.6 + 310342&0.500 & - & - & 762 & - & - & 8.8 & - & - & - & - & - & - & 2.1&[email protected] & 45.5 + 1rxs j002902.7 + 195717&0.264 & 5720 & 740 & 720 & 71.0 & 24.7 & 14.4 & 0.2 & 6.2 & 0.3 & 720 & 260 & -460 & - & [email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j003121.2 + 301558&0.200 & 3940 & 715 & 630 & 23.8 & 27.2 & 33.1 & 1.4 & 9.9 & 1.1 & -370 & -310 & 60 & - & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j003221.1 + 242359&0.066 & 3460 & 1180 & 620 & 13.2 & 38.2 & 14.1 & 1.1 & 0.9 & 2.9 & -260 & -230 & 30 & - & [email protected] & 43.1 + 1rxs j004459.4 + 192143&0.179 & 3900 & 1380 & 750 & 20.3 & 64.6 & 9.5 & 0.5 & 0.4 & 3.2 & -520 & -470 & 50 & 0.8&[email protected] & 44.6 + 1rxs j005034.2 + 044152&0.097 & 1780 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 43.5 + 1rxs j005050.6 + 353645&0.058 & 5470 & 2300 & 1230 & 48.1 & 27.3 & 10.8 & 0.2 & 0.5 & 0.6 & 160 & 0 & -160 & 0.7&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j005607.6 + 254802&0.153 & 6600 & 1960 & 1230 & 73.3 & 61.9 & 13.8 & 0.2 & 0.9 & 0.8 & -760 & 90 & 850 & 1.1&[email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j011655.1 + 254937&0.099 & 4000 & 910 & 1070 & 56.4 & 40.1 & 43.1 & 0.8 & 3.0 & 0.7 & -50 & -110 & -60 & 0.0&- & - + 1rxs j011745.5 + 363718&0.107 & 3770 & 1720 & 700 & 68.3 & 51.8 & 17.2 & 0.3 & 0.6 & 0.8 & 40 & 230 & 190 & 0.7&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j011848.2 + 383626&0.216 & 5040 & 1590 & 1070 & 68.0 & 50.0 & 13.5 & 0.2 & 0.8 & 0.7 & -150 & 40 & 190 & - & [email protected] & 44.8 + 1rxs j012556.6 + 351039&0.312 & 6790 & - & 570 & 78.3 & 21.0 & 12.6 & 0.2 & - & 0.3 & - & 0 & - & - & [email protected] & 44.3 + 1rxs j012923.0 + 223100&0.231 & 4730 & 980 & 800 & 65.7 & 39.4 & 17.3 & 0.3 & 2.2 & 0.6 & 170 & 0 & -170 & - & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j013738.5 + 852414&0.499 & 4270 & - & 710 & - & - & 8.0 & 0.2 & - & - & - & 180 & - & - & [email protected] & 44.8 + 1rxs j014023.0 + 240255&0.072 & 4620 & 1300 & 1260 & 48.3 & 44.0 & 13.7 & 0.3 & 0.9 & 0.9 & -200 & -70 & 130 & 1.6&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j014025.2 + 382400&0.067 & 3110 & 800 & 620 & 72.2 & 38.2 & 22.6 & 0.3 & 4.0 & 0.5 & 380 & 290 & -90 & 1.7&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j015536.7 + 311525&0.135 & 3830 & 1750 & 910 & 24.8 & 42.6 & 9.3 & 0.4 & 0.6 & 1.7 & 60 & 270 & 200 & 0.5&[email protected] & 44.1 + 1rxs j015546.4 + 071902&0.069 & 3750 & 1090 & 800 & - & - & 26.7 & - & - & - & - & - & - & 0.0&[email protected] & 43.2 + 1rxs j015555.6 + 040620&0.136 & 6980 & 2030 & 750 & 51.9 & 63.1 & 9.9 & 0.2 & 1.1 & 1.2 & 0 & 0 & 0 & - & [email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j015621.6 + 241838&0.155 & 3770 & 940 & 660 & 51.5 & 70.7 & 18.9 & 0.4 & 2.7 & 1.4 & -60 & -20 & 40 & - & [email protected] & 44.3 + 1rxs j023601.9 + 082124&0.228 & 4390 & 1250 & 1230 & 82.1 & 74.2 & 21.2 & 0.3 & 1.7 & 0.9 & 250 & 80&-170 & - & [email protected] & 45.5 + 1rxs j023739.9 + 181945&0.168 & 4560 & 950 & 850 & 87.4 & 58.1 & 15.8 & 0.2 & 5.1 & 0.7 & 160 & 30 & -130 & 0.8&- & - + 1rxs j024214.5 + 074442&0.451 & 4950 & 1410 & 700 & 59.2 & 0.0 & 17.2 & 0.3 & 0.9 & 0.0 & 60 & 0 & -60 & - & [email protected] & 45.5 + 1rxs j033522.6 + 190739&0.189 & 6180 & - & 800 & 30.8 & 5.8 & 19.3 & 0.6 & - & 0.2 & - & 200 & - & 0.9&[email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j034308.0 + 185836&0.110 & 3420 & 1300 & 830 & 75.0 & 56.5 & 44.4 & 0.6 & 1.5 & 0.8 & 280 & 410 & 130 & 1.6&[email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j035147.6 + 103618&0.185 & 5100 & 1040 & 910 & 70.1 & 0.0 & 28.9 & 0.4 & 7.3 & 0.0 & 580 & 460 & -120 & 1.9&[email protected] & 45.2 + 1rxs j035345.9 + 195825&0.029 & 3800 & 1150 & 710 & 23.0 & 14.0 & 6.4 & 0.3 & 1.2 & 0.6 & 0 & 0 & 0 & - & [email protected] & 43.2 + 1rxs j040513.2 + 173647&0.098 & 3850 & - & 920 & 67.9 & - & 9.0 & 0.1 & - & - & - & -310 & - & - & - & - + 1rxs j041147.1 + 132417&0.277 & 2960 & 1010 & 790 & 49.1 & 49.5 & 8.8 & 0.2 & 0.4 & 1.0 & -30 & 170 & 200 & - & [email protected] & 45.8 + 1rxs j044428.6 + 122113&0.089 & 3140 & 1320 & 1280 & 33.8&106.3 & 30.5 & 0.9 & 1.4 & 3.1 & -490 & -250 & 240 & 1.2&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j062334.6 + 644542&0.086 & 4400 & 1550 & 990 & 53.0 & 0.0&117.3 & 2.2 & 3.6 & 0.0 & 680 & 490 & -190 & 2.0&[email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j065136.5 + 563732&0.286 & 4810 & 1320 & 670 & 52.0 & 55.5 & 13.8 & 0.3 & 2.0 & 1.1 & -630 & -680 & -50 & - & [email protected] & 44.6 + 1rxs j065211.3 + 553436&0.064 & 2750 & 1010 & 620 & 25.8 & 40.3 & 39.4 & 1.5 & 3.1 & 1.6 & -510 & -400 & 110 & - & [email protected] & 43.1 + 1rxs j071006.0 + 500243&0.154 & 4030 & 1600 & 620 & 43.7 & 60.4 & 7.3 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 1.4 & 40 & 250 & 210 & 0.0&[email protected] & 44.1 + 1rxs j071339.7 + 382043&0.123 & 4140 & 1200 & 700 & 58.0&102.5 & 17.0 & 0.3 & 0.7 & 1.8 & -490 & -340 & 150 & 0.5&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j071858.2 + 705920&0.066 & 4810 & 1310 & 850 & 20.3 & 57.7 & 38.2 & 1.9 & 1.6 & 2.8 & -280 & -250 & 30 & - & [email protected] & 43.2 + 1rxs j071923.7 + 570840&0.175 & 6540 & 1150 & 960 & 102.7 & 0.0 & 81.4 & 0.8 & 3.2 & 0.0 & 670 & 560 & -110 & 0.2&[email protected] & 44.3 + 1rxs j072220.6 + 732041&0.350 & 3570 & 1320 & 820 & 59.7 & 76.4 & 10.6 & 0.2 & 0.7 & 1.3 & -150 & 300 & 450 & - & [email protected] & 45.1 + 1rxs j072408.4 + 355309&0.138 & 7260 & 820 & 680 & 94.4 & 0.0 & 74.0 & 0.8&11.1 & 0.0 & -450 & -510 & -60 & 0.6&[email protected] & 44.7 + 1rxs j072826.6 + 303407&0.100 & 3980 & 1010 & 600 & 59.7 & 48.1 & 15.3 & 0.3 & 2.2 & 0.8 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1.4&[email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j072912.9 + 410552&0.103 & 4460 & 1580 & 1040 & 47.6 & 41.6 & 29.4 & 0.6 & 3.7 & 0.9 & -230 & 190 & 420 & - & [email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j073308.7 + 455511&0.142 & 8070 & 3240 & 930 & 58.1 & 48.9 & 16.7 & 0.3 & 0.3 & 0.8 & -440 & -190 & 250 & 0.1&[email protected] & 44.5 + 1rxs j073735.8 + 430856&0.119 & 4500 & 670 & 660 & 33.8 & - & 51.7 & 1.5&14.9 & - & 0 & 0 & 0 & - & - & - + 1rxs j074228.1 + 465648&0.170 & 4050 & - & 620 & 99.3 & 69.3 & 25.4 & 0.3 & - & 0.7 & - & 330 & - & 1.4&- & - + 1rxs j074311.3 + 742926&0.332 & 7380 & 1060 & 840 & 94.0 & 32.1 & 31.4 & 0.3 & 4.4 & 0.3 & -50 & -140 & -90 & - & [email protected] & 44.9 + 1rxs j074759.2 + 205229&0.156 & 5540 & 820 & 690 & 71.7 & 48.7 & 12.4 & 0.2 & 3.5 & 0.7 & 130 & 70 & -60 & 1.2&[email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j074906.2 + 451039&0.192 & 4500 & 800 & 800 & 100.4 & 55.1 & 80.4 & 0.8 & 8.4 & 0.6 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.4&[email protected] & 43.6 + 1rxs j075026.6 + 270726&0.154 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j075039.5 + 624205&0.194 & 6300 & 1330 & 1500 & 58.5 & 18.0 & 22.3 & 0.4&11.0 & 0.3 & 20 & -90 & -110 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j075408.7 + 431611&0.350 & - & - & 570 & - & - & 31.5 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 45.0 + 1rxs j075409.5 + 512436&0.331 & 3680 & - & 730 & 99.0&108.2 & 11.0 & 0.1 & - & 1.1 & - & 0 & - & - & -&- + 1rxs j075634.7 + 362232&0.884&-&- & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 45.8 + 1rxs j075910.0 + 115152&0.050 & 4470 & 1180 & 700 & 25.9 & 52.8 & 12.7 & 0.5 & 0.6 & 2.0 & -190 & -190 & 0 & 1.4 & [email protected] & 43.3 + 1rxs j080132.3 + 473618&0.157 & 7840 & - & 900 & 119.0 & 69.7 & 13.1 & 0.1 & - & 0.6 & -530 & -190 & 340 & 0.4 & [email protected] & 44.6 + 1rxs j080358.9 + 433248&0.451 & 5580 & 1340 & 670 & 75.6 & 0.0 & 38.4 & 0.5 & 1.3 & 0.0 & 390 & 570 & 180 & - & [email protected] & 45.3 + 1rxs j080534.6 + 543132&0.406 & 5780 & 1530 & 730 & 51.5 & - & 30.1 & 0.6 & 1.5 & - & -370 & -250 & 120 & - & [email protected] & 45.5 + 1rxs j080548.5 + 112617&0.144 & 4480 & 880 & 770 & 89.6 & 0.0 & 50.0 & 0.6 & 5.0 & 0.0 & 260 & 0 & -260 & 0.7 & [email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j080639.9 + 724831&0.099 & 1760 & 740 & 820 & 13.7 & 34.4 & 61.9 & 4.5 & 6.2 & 2.5 & -190 & -220 & -30 & 0.7 & [email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j080727.2 + 140534&0.074 & 2450 & - & - & 51.7 & 70.2&@xmath3220&@xmath320.4 & -&1.4 & - & 0 & - & - & [email protected] & 43.3 + 1rxs j081237.9 + 435636&0.183 & 4110 & - & 700 & 51.5 & 21.6 & 11.8 & 0.2 & - & 0.4 & - & -90 & - & 0.4 & [email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j081502.4 + 525304&0.126 & 4110 & 1080 & 770 & 75.8 & 41.2 & 14.7 & 0.2 & 1.7 & 0.5 & 360 & 230 & -130 & 0.2 & [email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j081651.4 + 180252&0.158 & 3890 & 810 & 700 & 68.4 & 0.0 & 84.6 & 1.2 & 9.0 & 0.0 & 620 & 680 & 60 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.5 + 1rxs j081718.6 + 520200&0.040&2170 & 470 & - & - & 25.2 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 42.6 + 1rxs j081738.0 + 242333&0.283 & 5560 & 960 & 740 & 73.0 & 14.9&125.4 & 1.7 & 8.6 & 0.2 & 390 & 350 & -40 & - & [email protected] & 44.3 + 1rxs j082633.1 + 074259&0.312 & 3460 & 1010 & 880 & 50.0 & 65.6 & 6.0 & 0.1 & 1.3 & 1.3 & -130 & 310 & 440 & - & - & - + 1rxs j082942.2 + 415442&0.126 & 7960 & 800 & 910 & 70.1 & 0.0 & 98.6 & 1.4&12.1 & 0.0 & 750 & 700 & -50 & 1.8 & [email protected] & 43.5 + 1rxs j083737.3 + 254746&0.080 & - & - & 960 & 0.0 & - & 13.3 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + 1rxs j083820.6 + 241025&0.043 & 4980 & 780 & 750 & 26.0 & 18.0 & 11.0 & 0.0 & 3.0 & 0.0 & -680 & -770 & -90 & - & [email protected] & 43.2 + 1rxs j084026.2 + 033316&0.060 & 4940 & 1510 & 990 & 55.6 & 0.0 & 28.5 & 0.5 & 1.6 & 0.0 & 430 & 390 & -40 & 0.3 & [email protected] & 43.6 + 1rxs j084302.0 + 030226&0.512 & 1920 & - & - & 53.1 & 43.3 & - & - & - & 0.8 & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 45.4 + 1rxs j084622.3 + 031318&0.107 & 4380 & 1000 & 960 & 71.6 & 49.7 & 24.2 & 0.3 & 4.1 & 0.7 & 0 & -150 & -150 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.1 + 1rxs j084856.8 + 584150&0.134 & - & - & 890 & - & 0.0 & 23.3 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j084918.7 + 531806&0.112 & 2750 & 810 & 990 & 23.3 & 20.6 & 29.7 & 1.3 & 7.6 & 0.9 & -150 & -20 & 130 & 1.5 & [email protected] & 43.2 + 1rxs j085233.3 + 422539&0.137 & 2670 & 750 & 700 & 14.8 & 43.3 & 22.8 & 1.5 & 2.7 & 2.9 & -250 & -220 & 30 & 1.1 & [email protected] & 43.9 + 1rxs j085358.8 + 770054&0.106 & 5480 & 2300 & 620 & 23.1 & 40.8 & 11.7 & 0.5 & 0.8 & 1.8 & -640 & -540 & 100 & 1.6 & [email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j085443.8 + 401912&0.152 & 5520 & 1100 & 810 & 60.6 & 37.1 & 19.7 & 0.3 & 1.9 & 0.6 & 460 & 440 & -20 & 1.8 & [email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j085706.2 + 621050&0.160 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 43.4 + 1rxs j085820.6 + 642100&0.115&3060 & 1260 & 970 & -&-&63.7 & -&- & - & - & -&- & - & [email protected] & 43.6 + 1rxs j085902.0 + 484611&0.083 & 4420 & 1300 & 910 & 80.0 & 72.2 & 36.1 & 0.5 & 2.3 & 0.9 & -150 & -130 & 20 & 0.6 & [email protected] & 44.1 + 1rxs j190910.3 + 665222&0.191 & 3830 & 600 & 670 & 97.0&111.7 & 7.0 & 0.1 & 1.1 & 1.2 & -290 & -40 & 250 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.8 + 1rxs j193929.8 + 700752&0.116 & 4850 & 1690 & 1160 & 60.9 & 54.1 & 14.1 & 0.2 & 0.4 & 0.9 & -20 & 80 & 100 & 0.2 & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j210550.5 + 041435&0.139 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 43.9 + 1rxs j212654.3 + 112403&0.096 & 2730 & 1600 & 1120 & 66.7 & 33.3 & 14.1 & 0.2 & 0.8 & 0.5 & 780 & 350 & -430 & 0.7 & [email protected] & 44.1 + 1rxs j214309.6 + 153658&0.385 & 7610 & - & 1230 & 72.7 & 0 & 10.9 & 0.1 & - & 0 & - & 120 & - & - & [email protected] & 44.9 + 1rxs j214655.2 + 092102&0.984&- & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 45.6 + 1rxs j215912.7 + 095247&0.102 & 5380 & - & 1110 & 71.4 & 26.0 & 50.0 & 0.7 & - & 0.4 & - & 0 & - & 1.3 & [email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j221537.8 + 290239&0.229 & 5980 & 600 & 640 & 70.0 & 0.0 & 54.5 & 0.8&11.8 & 0.0 & 150 & 220 & 70 & - & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j221918.8 + 120757&0.082&2080 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & -&- & - & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j222537.5 + 225917&0.173 & 2150 & 1100 & 1100 & 52.5 & 39.4 & 17.8 & 0.3 & 4.7 & 0.7 & -40 & 0 & 40 & 0.6 & [email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j222846.3 + 333500&0.090 & 3270 & 900 & 1260 & 44.4 & 24.1 & 46.1 & 1.0&11.0 & 0.5 & -70 & 0 & 70 & - & [email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j222934.3 + 305720&0.319 & 7930 & 1390 & 1110 & 88.0 & 0.0 & 30.0 & 0.3 & 6.3 & 0.0 & 800 & 900 & 100 & - & [email protected] & 44.8 + 1rxs j223019.5 + 163114&0.084 & 4270 & 1740 & 1310 & 55.8 & 34.9 & 17.2 & 0.3 & 1.2 & 0.6 & -20 & 80 & 100 & 0.8 & [email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j224621.7 + 314206&0.145 & - & - & 660 & 0 & - & 25.3 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 44.4 + 1rxs j224939.6 + 110016&0.084 & 4390 & 1440 & 1220 & 24.7 & 47.2 & 3.5 & 0.1 & 0.3 & 1.9 & -430 & -180 & 250 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.0 + 1rxs j225148.5 + 341937&0.132 & 3050 & 1120 & 590 & 51.4 & 55.5 & 10.5 & 0.2 & 0.6 & 1.1 & 40 & 220 & 180 & 0.6 & [email protected] & 44.5 + 1rxs j225209.6 + 264236&0.069 & 2160 & 700 & 700 & 16.7 & 39.4 & 15.5 & 0.9 & 1.3 & 2.4 & -200 & -200 & 0 & 1.3 & [email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j225639.4 + 261846&0.176 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 43.8 + 1rxs j230328.0 + 144341&0.080 & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & [email protected] & 42.9 + 1rxs j231456.0 + 224325&0.171 & 3750 & 1230 & 1170 & 62.8&127.8 & 22.4 & 0.4 & 0.7 & 2.0 & -360 & -360 & 0 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.1 + 1rxs j231517.5 + 182825&0.104 & 3310 & 1190 & 1200 & 25.0 & 18.3 & 10.7 & 0.4 & 6.4 & 0.7 & 0 & 0 & 0 & - & -&- + 1rxs j232554.6 + 215310&0.120 & 5260 & 950 & 770 & 125.2 & 0.0 & 62.5 & 0.5 & 5.5 & 0.0 & 390 & 330 & -60 & 1.1 & [email protected] & 44.5 + 1rxs j232841.4 + 224853&0.129 & 5400 & - & 810 & 121.7 & 0.0 & 34.6 & 0.3 & - & 0.0 & - & 0 & - & 1.5 & [email protected] & 43.7 + 1rxs j234728.8 + 242743&0.159 & 4270 & 2550 & 1350 & 105.1 & 0.0 & 75.2 & 0.7 & 2.2 & 0.0 & 980 & 770 & -210 & 1.7 & [email protected] & 44.2 + 1rxs j234734.6 + 271910&0.646&- & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & -&- + 1rxs j235152.7 + 261938&0.040 & 3750 & 1850 & 1460 & 47.7 & 19.0 & 36.7 & 0.8 & 1.8 & 0.4 & -300 & -250 & 50 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 43.3 + 1rxs j235754.3 + 132418&0.115 & 4290 & 2000 & 1480 & 102.3&101.9 & 35.5 & 0.3 & 0.9 & 1.0 & 40 & 380 & 340 & 1.5 & [email protected] & 44.2 + iii zw 2 & 0.090 & 4990 & 700 & 630 & 72.1 & 33.3 & 47.1 & 0.7&10.0 & 0.5 & 140 & 0 & -140 & 0.5 & [email protected] & 44.0 + 4c 25.01 & 0.284 & 4310 & 1050 & 840 & 74.6 & 79.1 & 38.8 & 0.5 & 8.2 & 1.1 & 140 & 140 & 0 & - & [email protected] & 44.9 + pg 0026 + 12 & 0.142 & 4890 & 1120 & 690 & 36.1 & 19.2 & 14.8 & 0.4 & 1.5 & 0.5 & 0 & 360 & 360 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.5 + s 10785 & 0.134 & 5970 & 1290 & 850 & 89.1 & 65.4 & 26.2 & 0.3 & 5.6 & 0.7 & 60 & 260 & 200 & 1.5 & [email protected] & 44.6 + mark 1148 & 0.064 & 5560 & 840 & 800 & 135.3 & 22.8 & 55.0 & 0.4 & 8.4 & 0.2 & 190 & 290 & 100 & 1.2 & [email protected] & 43.5 + pg 0052 + 251 & 0.155 & 5110 & 780 & 780 & 68.8 & 19.2 & 30.0 & 0.4 & 8.6 & 0.3 & 60 & 20 & -40 & 0.6 & [email protected] & 44.9 + b2 0110 + 29 & 0.363 & 7360 & 680 & 750 & 77.6 & 0.0 & 63.1 & 0.8&15.0 & 0.0 & 490 & 520 & 30 & - & [email protected] & 44.8 + 3c 48.0 & 0.367 & 4080 & 1840 & 1200 & 31.0 & 46.2 & 37.2 & 1.2 & 2.8 & 1.5 & -220 & 270 & 490 & 0.3 & [email protected] & 45.9 + ms 02448 + 1928 & 0.176 & 4510 & 2000 & 780 & 70.0 & 59.5 & 23.9 & 0.3 & 1.1 & 0.9 & 780 & 720 & -60 & - & [email protected] & 44.7 + ms 03574 + 1046 & 0.182 & 4160 & 1660 & 890 & 42.2 & 72.2 & 13.0 & 0.3 & 0.5 & 1.7 & -380 & -90 & 290 & 1.1 & [email protected] & 45.3 + rx j04506 + 0642 & 0.118 & 3460 & 1150 & 940 & 22.5 & 45.2 & 11.0 & 0.5 & 0.6 & 2.0 & -460 & -360 & 100 & 0.7 & [email protected] & 44.0 + ms 07007 + 6338 & 0.152 & 5070 & 2070 & 840 & 49.8 & 63.6 & 8.4 & 0.2 & 0.4 & 1.3 & 710 & 450 & -260 & 0.2 & [email protected] & 44.4 + vii zw 118 & 0.079 & 4910 & 2300 & 860 & 58.1 & 71.4 & 14.3 & 0.2 & 0.5 & 1.2 & 490 & 680 & 190 & 0.5 & [email protected] & 44.7 + f07144 + 4410 & 0.061 & 3820 & 1380 & 830 & 95.8 & 65.3&105.1 & 0.8 & 2.4 & 0.7 & -120 & -70 & 50 & 0.7 & [email protected] & 44.1 + ms 07199 + 7100 & 0.125 & 4020 & 1330 & 680 & 54.8 & 50.9 & 26.3 & 0.5 & 7.2 & 0.9 & 800 & 230 & -570 & - & [email protected] & 44.1 + rx j07491 + 2842 & 0.345 & 4710 & 820 & 620 & 84.3 & 57.7 & 12.3 & 0.1 & 4.8 & 0.7 & 250 & 140 & -100 & - & [email protected] & 44.7 + rx j07527 + 2617 & 0.082 & 2940 & 1060 & 780 & 38.3 & 55.0 & 7.9 & 0.2 & 0.4 & 1.4 & -40 & -40 & 0 & - & [email protected] & 44.0 + b3 0754 + 394 & 0.096 & 3840 & 1430 & 870 & 57.3 & 46.8 & 38.1 & 0.7 & 1.7 & 0.8 & -170 & -130 & 40 & 0.6 & [email protected] & 43.9 + kuv 07549 + 4228&0.210 & 4620 & 1520 & 780 & 57.5 & 74.2 & 48.5 & 0.8 & 2.4 & 1.3 & 170 & 70 & -100 & 0.3 & [email protected] & 44.9 + pg 0804 + 761 & 0.100 & 5490 & 2380 & 950 & 65.4 & 85.1 & 11.3 & 0.2 & 0.3 & 1.3 & -300 & -60 & 240&-0.2 & [email protected] & 44.7 + rx j08297 + 3252 & 0.127 & 3420 & 820 & 710 & 33.7 & 30.9 & 44.2 & 1.3 & 3.2 & 0.9 & 150 & 150 & 0 & 1.3 & [email protected] & 43.9 + rx j08307 + 3405 & 0.063 & 4500 & 1090 & 680 & 37.7 & 21.6 & 36.9 & 1.0 & 4.1 & 0.6 & 110 & 140 & 30 & 1.6 & [email protected] & 43.6 + us 1329 & 0.249 & 5180 & 1280 & 760 & 112.4 & 48.2 & 55.8 & 0.5 & 2.7 & 0.4 & 170 & 120 & -50 & - & [email protected] & 45.2 + vii zw 244 & 0.131 & 4510 & 2000 & 770 & 60.1 & 88.0 & 15.2 & 0.3 & 0.7 & 1.5 & -440 & -190 & 250 & 0.8 & [email protected] & 44.2 + kuv 08482 + 4146 & 0.134 & 4130 & - & 740 & 62.2 & 39.4 & 11.4 & 0.2 & - & 0.7 & - & -520 & - & 1.2 & [email protected] & 44.0 + mark 1220 & 0.064 & 4050 & 770 & 930 & 30.7 & 23.9 & 25.8 & 0.8 & 6.1 & 0.8 & -90 & 140 & 220 & - & [email protected] & 43.5 + 4c 73.18 & 0.303 & 5670 & 1770 & 870 & 53.6 & 0.0 & 10.3 & 0.2 & 0.6 & 0.0 & -60 & 50 & 110 & - & [email protected] & 45.1 + rx j20389 + 0303&0.137 & 4410 & 1410 & 750 & 65.5 & 67.7 & 31.3 & 0.3 & 0.7 & 1.0 & 40 & -100 & -140 & 1.3 & [email protected] & 44.1 + s5 2116 + 81 & 0.086 & 4130 & - & 740 & 122.7 & 22.5 & 92.6 & 0.8 & - & 0.2 & - & 0 & - & 1.8 & [email protected] & 44.0 + ms 21283 + 0349 & 0.094 & 4900 & 1330 & 660 & 105.4 & 50.9 & 54.8 & 0.5 & 2.5 & 0.5 & -370 & -310 & 60 & 0.4 & [email protected] & 44.6 + ii zw 136 & 0.063 & 3770 & 980 & 760 & 81.4 & 72.5 & 17.4 & 0.2 & 0.9 & 0.9 & 250 & 120 & -130 & 0.9 & [email protected] & 44.7 + ms 22102 + 1827 & 0.079 & 2950 & 870 & 900 & 27.3 & 68.9 & 6.2 & 0.1 & 0.3 & 2.5 & -120 & -120 & 0 & 1.3 & [email protected] & 44.0 + rx j22186 + 0802 & 0.120 & 2530 & 780 & 810 & 22.5 & 36.1 & 23.7 & 1.1 & 3.5 & 1.6 & -140 & 90 & 220 & 1.6 & -&- + rx j22198 + 0935 & 0.060 & 2520 & 910 & 740 & 15.1 & 7.9 & 11.4 & 0.8 & 1.2 & 0.5 & -160 & -100 & 60 & - & [email protected] & 43.1 + pg 2233 + 134 & 0.325 & 4750 & 1340 & 740 & 41.1 & 67.8 & 10.4 & 0.3 & 0.4 & 1.7 & -570 & -410 & 160 & - & [email protected] & 44.3 + akn 564 & 0.025 & 3860 & 970 & 720 & 31.6 & 23.1 & 50.6 & 1.6 & 2.2 & 0.7 & -100 & -150 & -50 & 1.4 & [email protected] & 44.5 + kuv 22497 + 1439 & 0.135 & 4140 & 1560 & 1040 & 47.5&110.1 & 4.2 & 0.1 & 0.2 & 2.3 & -470 & 0 & 470 & 0.6 & [email protected] & 44.5 + rx j2256.6 + 0525 & 0.065 & 4240 & 1230 & 730 & 82.9 & 37.0 & 53.5 & 0.6 & 1.3 & 0.4 & -160 & -50 & 110 & 1.1 & [email protected] & 43.8 + kaz 320 & 0.034 & 4430 & 1230 & 830 & 48.3 & 17.8 & 53.8 & 1.1 & 1.2 & 0.4 & 90 & 220 & 130 & 1.3 & [email protected] & 43.1 + rx j23171 + 0838 & 0.165 & 5440 & 910 & 690 & 85.7 & 21.1 & 31.1 & 0.4&10.1 & 0.2 & 250 & 60 & -190 & 0.7 & [email protected] & 44.2 + lllllllllllll ( 1)fwhm(h@xmath34)& & 0.002 & 0.032 & -0.32 & 0.35 & -0.59 & -0.05 & 0.34 & -0.20 & -0.04 & 0.38 & 0.48 + & & & & ( 0.0020)&(0.0009 ) & ( 0.0000 ) & & ( 0.001 ) & & & ( 0.0003)&(0.0000 ) + ( 2)fwhm(h@xmath21 ) & & & 0.46 & 0.30 & -0.263 & 0.23 & -0.294 & -0.15 & 0.23 & -0.104 & -0.66 & 0.11 + & & & ( 0.0000 ) & ( 0.004 ) & & & ( 0.005 ) & & & & ( 0.0000 ) & + ( 3)fwhm([oiii ] ) & & & & -0.03 & 0.004 & -0.02 & -0.08 & 0.02 & -0.06 & -0.166 & -0.15 & -0.01 + & & & & & & & & & & & & + ( 4)ew feii & & & & & -0.59 & 0.81 & -0.546 & -0.471 & 0.41 & -0.129 & -0.544 & 0.06 + & & & & & ( 0.0000 ) & ( 0.0000 ) & ( 0.0000 ) & ( 0.0000)&(0.0001 ) & & ( 0.0000 ) & + ( 5)ew [ oiii ] & & & & & & -0.64 & 0.73 & 0.33 & -0.39 & 0.195 & 0.67 & 0.05 + & & & & & & ( 0.0000 ) & ( 0.0000 ) & ( 0.0019)&(0.0002 ) & & ( 0.0000 ) & + ( 6)feii / h@xmath34 & & & & & & & -0.23 & -0.64 & 0.34 & -0.055 & -0.60 & 0.24 + & & & & & & & & ( 0.0000)&(0.0011 ) & & ( 0.0000 ) & + ( 7)[oiii]/h@xmath34 & & & & & & & & 0.009 & -0.33 & 0.27 & 0.45 & -0.314 + & & & & & & & & & ( 0.0017 ) & & ( 0.0000)&(0.0038 ) + ( 8)@xmath64 & & & & & & & & & -0.24 & 0.147 & 0.375 & 0.14 + & & & & & & & & & & & ( 0.0003 ) & + ( 9)@xmath65 & & & & & & & & & & -0.236 & -0.37 & 0.36 + & & & & & & & & & & & ( 0.0004)&(0.001 ) + ( 10)@xmath66 & & & & & & & & & & & 0.109 & -0.29 + & & & & & & & & & & & & ( 0.0069 ) + ( 11)[oiii]/h@xmath21 & & & & & & & & & & & & 0.1 + & & & & & & & & & & & & + ( 12)log @xmath67l@xmath68 & & & & & & & & & & & & + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: hierarchical models of structure formation , in which galaxies formed at high redshift and rapidly coalesced into groups and clusters through accretion and mergers , have become a compelling paradigm for understanding galaxy evolution . in such dynamically rich environments , galaxies are subject to an array of physical processes that affect their evolution . these physical processes form two broad classes : ( 1 ) tidal interactions such as those induced by major mergers ( e.g. , lavery & henry 1988 ) , off - axis galaxy collisions ( mller et al . 1989 ) , galaxy harassment ( moore et al . 1996 ) or galaxy fly - bys near the core of the cluster potential ( byrd & valtonen 1990 ) , and ( 2 ) gas - gas interactions , notably ram pressure by the intracluster gas ( icm ) on the galaxy s interstellar medium ( ism ) , due to the galaxy s motion through the surrounding icm ( gunn & gott 1972 ) , or ism - ism interactions produced in galaxy - galaxy collisions ( kenney et al . these gas - dynamical processes may be enhanced by turbulence and viscous effects ( nulsen 1982 ; quilis et al . 2000 ) or inhomogeneities and bulk motions in the icm gas ( kenney et al . 2004 ) . combes ( 2004 ) and references therein provide a recent overview . no model for galaxy evolution can be complete without a detailed understanding of the gas - dynamics of these interactions . similarly no model for the evolution of the intracluster medium can be complete without understanding the feedback of gas and energy from the galaxy into the icm by these gravitational and hydrodynamical stripping processes . the actions of tidal forces are identified by the appearance of disturbed stellar morphologies , such as stretched stellar tails ( see e.g. gnedin 2003 , vollmer 2003 ) ; while the characteristic signatures of hydrodynamic stripping ( see e.g. stevens et al . 1999 ; toniazzo & schindler 2001 ; acreman et al . 2003 and references therein ) are imprinted on the structure of the hot x - ray emitting gas in and near the galaxy . notably the ram - pressure experienced by galaxies moving through the dense icm can produce sharp surface brightness edges ( `` cold fronts '' ) along the leading interface between the galaxy and the icm ( acreman et al . 2003 ; machacek et al . these cold fronts are contact discontinuities where a sharp rise in surface brightness ( gas density ) is accompanied by a corresponding drop in gas temperature , and are the galaxy - sized analogues of similar subcluster - scale features identified near the cores of rich clusters ( see e.g. markevitch et al . 2000 , vikhlinin et al . 2001 ; mazzotta et al . the higher pressure found in the cold front compared to that in the cluster gas is balanced by the ram pressure caused by the motion of the cloud ( in our case , galaxy ) through the surrounding icm . tails of stripped galaxy gas have been found to extend @xmath18 to @xmath19kpc behind the galaxy before fading into the background emission of the ambient cluster gas ( see e.g. forman et al . 1979 , white et al . 1991 , rangarajan et al . 1995 for m86 ; irwin & sarazin 1996 , biller et al . 2004 for ngc 4472 ; sakelliou et al . 1996 for 4c34.16 ; wang et al . 2004 for c153 ; machacek et al . 2005a , scharf et al . 2005 for ngc 1404 ) . detailed studies of these x - ray features in nearby systems ( see , for example , biller et al . 2004 ; machacek et al . 2005a , 2005b ; sun & vikhlinin 2005 ; sun , jerius & jones 2005 ) , made possible by the high angular resolution of _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ , not only reveal the nature of the gas - dynamics of the stripping process , but also are one of the few ways to constrain the three dimensional motion of the galaxy as it passes through the group or cluster core ( merrifield 1998 ; dosaj et al . 2002 ) . ngc 4552 ( @xmath20,@xmath21 , j2000 ) is an elliptical galaxy located @xmath22 east of m87 in subcluster a of the virgo cluster . measurement of ngc 4552 s distance modulus using surface brightness fluctuations ( tonry et al . 2001 ) places it at nearly the same luminosity distance as m87 , while ngc 4552 s low line of sight velocity ( @xmath23kms@xmath15 , ned ; smith et al . 2000 ) compared to that of m87 ( @xmath24kms@xmath15 , ned ; smith et al . 2000 ) implies that ngc 4552 is moving supersonically through the virgo icm with at least @xmath25kms@xmath15towards us relative to m87 . thus ngc 4552 is a likely candidate for ram - pressure stripping by the cluster gas . since ngc 4552 is a member of the large sample of nearby elliptical galaxies used to establish correlations between x - ray emission and other ism tracers ( see e.g. osullivan et al . 2001 and references therein ) , its global x - ray properties are well studied . early observations with the _ einstein _ observatory ( forman , jones & tucker 1985 ; canizares , fabbiano & trinchieri 1987 ; roberts et al . 1991 ; kim , fabbiano , & trinchieri 1992 ; eskridge , fabbiano , & kim 1995 ) focused on the measurement of ngc 4552 s total x - ray luminosity to establish the @xmath26 @xmath27 relation . subsequent _ rosat _ observations of ngc 4552 were used to study the possible dependence of this relation on environment ( brown & bregman 2000 ; osullivan et al . fits to the mean x - ray spectrum for ngc 4552 using _ rosat _ resulted in mean temperatures for the x - ray gas in the galaxy of @xmath28kev depending on the spectral model ( davis & white 1996 ; brown & bregman 2000 ; matsushita 2001 ) . using _ asca _ data , matsushita , ohashi , & makishima ( 2000 ) modelled the mean spectrum of ngc 4552 using variable abundance thermal plasma models including an additional bremsstrahlung component in the spectral models to account for the contribution of unresolved point sources in low spatial resolution data . they found mean temperatures @xmath29kev for ngc 4552 , in agreement with the _ rosat _ studies , but with generally higher abundances ( @xmath30 ) . most recent studies , across a wide range of wavelengths , have concentrated on the nuclear properties of ngc 4552 . a brief review of prior work on the nucleus can be found in machacek et al . ( 2006 ; hereafter known as paper ii ) , where we present our results from chandra observations of the central regions of ngc 4552 that show shocks close to the center of ngc 4552 that were produced by recent nuclear activity . in this paper we use _ chandra _ x - ray observations to focus on the properties of gas in the outer regions of ngc 4552 where hydrodynamic gas stripping is occuring . our discussion is organized as follows : in [ sec : obs ] we describe the observations and our data reduction and processing procedures . in [ sec : ramresult ] we present the background subtracted , exposure corrected image of ngc 4552 showing the prominent x - ray emission features of the system : a sharp surface brightness edge to the north , horns of emission extending away to the south from the surface brightness edge , a ram pressure stripped x - ray tail , a bright nucleus , and bright ringlike features ( discussed in detail in paper ii ) near the galaxy center . we then discuss our analysis method and main results , including the determination of the gas density and temperature , for gas stripping from the outer regions of the galaxy . we use these results to constrain the velocity of ngc 4552 through the virgo icm . in [ sec : conclude ] we summarize our results . unless otherwise indicated all errors correspond to @xmath31 confidence levels and coordinates are j2000 . taking the distance to the dominant elliptical m87 as representative of the distance to subcluster a of the virgo cluster containing ngc 4552 , the luminosity distance to the cluster is @xmath32mpc ( tonry et al . 2001 ) and @xmath33 corresponds to a distance scale of @xmath34pc . for our analysis , we used a @xmath0ks observation of the elliptical galaxy ngc 4552 in virgo taken with _ chandra _ on 2001 april 22 using the advanced ccd imaging spectrometer array ( acis , garmire et al . 1992 ; bautz et al . 1998 ) with acis - s ( chip s3 ) at the aimpoint . the focal plane temperature of the instrument was @xmath35c throughout the observation . the data were analyzed using the standard x - ray processing packages , ciao version @xmath2 , ftools and xspec version @xmath36 . filtering removed events with bad grades ( @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 ) and those with significant flux in border pixels of the @xmath40 event islands ( vfaint mode ) , as well as any events falling on hot pixels . use of vfaint mode improves background rejection by as much as a factor of @xmath41 in the s3 chip for soft x - ray energies ( @xmath42kev ) important to this observation . the data were reprocessed and response files created using the most recent gain tables and instrumental corrections . these included correcting for the time - dependent declining efficiency of the acis detector due to the buildup of contaminants on the optical filter ( plucinsky et al . 2003 ) , which is important at energies below @xmath43kev , and for the slow secular drift ( tgain ) of the average pha values for photons of fixed energy . periods of anomalously high background ( flares ) were identified and removed from the data , along with periods of anomalously low count rates at the beginning and end of the observation . this resulted in a useful exposure time of @xmath44s . backgrounds for use in the imaging analyses and spectral measurements of the virgo cluster gas were created from the @xmath45ks period d source free dataset ( aciss_d_7_bg_evt_271103 ) appropriate for the date of observation and instrument configuration .. identical cleaning , energy and spatial filters were applied to source and background data throughout . we checked the standard normalization of the source free background , set by the ratio of the exposure times , by comparing count rates between the source and background files in the @xmath46kev energy range , where particle background dominates . we found the standard normalization was @xmath47 too high and renormalized the source free data by a factor of @xmath48 to correct for this difference . point sources were identified in the @xmath49 field of the s3 chip in the @xmath50kev energy band using a multiscale wavelet decomposition algorithm set with a @xmath51 detection threshold . the resulting @xmath52 source identifications were excluded from the spectral and surface brightness analyses that follow . in figure [ fig : image ] we present the @xmath1kev _ chandra _ image of the diffuse emission in ngc 4552 overlaid with x - ray surface brightness contours showing the x - ray features of interest for our analysis . point sources were removed from the image and the point source regions filled with the local average emission level using ciao tool _ dmfilth_. the image was then background subtracted , corrected for telescope vignetting and detector response using exposure maps created with standard ciao tools . first , two narrow band ( @xmath53 and @xmath54kev ) images were background subtracted and exposure corrected using monoenergetic instrument maps of @xmath55 and @xmath43kev , respectively . the fluxed narrow band images were then summed and smoothed with a @xmath33 gaussian kernel to produce the image in figure 1 . we chose conservative gaussian smoothing for our images to minimize potential numerical artifacts from the smoothing algorithm . the @xmath33 smoothing scale represents a compromise between the need for high spatial resolution to map sharp or narrow features and the need to smooth over larger scales to highlight faint extended emission features . we see a sharp , flattened discontinuity ( edge ) in the surface brightness @xmath2kpc ( @xmath56 ) north of ngc 4552 s center . horns of emission extend @xmath57kpc ( @xmath58 ) to the southeast and southwest away from each side of the flattened edge . an x - ray tail extends @xmath6kpc ( @xmath59 ) to the south - southeast before becoming indistinguishable from the ambient icm . in fig . [ fig : hehwtsig ] we show projections across the horns and tail in a @xmath60kev image of the diffuse emission ( binned to pixel size @xmath61 but without background subtraction ) , demonstrating that these features are highly significant . we see in figure [ fig : image ] an enhanced region of x - ray emission in the southwest quadrant of the galaxy , near the beginning of the tail , that we denote as the southern lump sl . in figure [ fig : panda ] we show the @xmath60kev emission in the galaxy for radii @xmath62 in @xmath63 equal sectors numbered counterclockwise from @xmath37 . as shown in the right panel of figure [ fig : panda ] , x - ray emission from the outer radii of the galaxy is very asymmetric . enhanced soft emission occurs both in the northen galaxy regions ( sectors @xmath64 ) , behind the leading edge of the galaxy , and in the southern galaxy regions ( sectors @xmath65 ) near the beginning of the tail . the peak in the soft emission for these regions occurs in the southwest quadrant of the galaxy in sectors @xmath66 , at the position of the southern lump ( sl ) . thus we see that the southern lump sl , as well as the horns and the tail , is also highly significant . disturbed x - ray morphologies may arise from tidal interactions caused by a recent or ongoing merger , winds of outflowing material due to a recent starburst , or outflows from a central agn , as well as from ram pressure stripping of the galaxy ism due to the motion of the galaxy through the ambient virgo icm . for ngc 4552 these first three scenarios are disfavored . tidal ( gravitational ) interactions act on both stars and gas , producing characteristic stellar tidal streams or tails ( gnedin 2003 ; combes 2004 ) . there is no evidence for disturbed morphology in the stellar distribution of ngc 4552 or for significant extragalactic stellar light that might result , if the observed features were of tidal origin ( bettoni et al . 2003 ) . a second possibility , given the classification of ngc 4552 as a transition nucleus ( ho et al . 1997 ) , is that the distorted x - ray morphology may be due to winds from a compact nuclear starburst . however , the transition nucleus classification for ngc 4552 is weak , due to @xmath67 uncertainties in the measurement of the h@xmath68 line emission ( ho et al . 1997 ) , and the radio spectrum of ngc 4552 is inconsistent with that expected from such a starburst . the nucleus of ngc 4552 exhibits a compact core radio source with a flat spectrum , whose peak brightness temperature of @xmath69k ( filho et al . 2004 ) is several orders of magnitude above the @xmath70k upper limit ( condon et al . 1991 ) for the brightness temperature of a compact nuclear starburst . in addition , starburst winds tend to produce conical outflows with associated optical line ( h@xmath71 ) emission from the interaction between the supernova driven ejecta and the surrounding ism ( see , e.g. , strickland et al . 2000 for ngc 253 and cecil , bland - hawthorn & veilleux 2002 for ngc 3079 ) , which are not seen in ngc 4552 . a third possibility is that agn outbursts could be responsible for the distorted x - ray morphology seen at large radii in ngc 4552 . the nucleus of ngc 4552 does harbor a supermassive black hole ( filho et al . 2004 ) and does undergo outbursts , as evidenced by the ring structures seen in figure [ fig : image ] and analyzed in detail in paper ii . however , the x - ray signatures of such outbursts are residual bright - rimmed cavities and buoyant bubbles , as found in m87 ( e.g. , forman et al . 2005 ) , and/or x - ray edges corresponding to shocks driven into the ambient medium by the outburst ( e.g. , fabian et al . 2003 for ngc 1275 in perseus and nulsen et al . 2005 for hydra a ) . this is quite different from the ` flattened leading edge - trailing tail ' morphology seen in figure [ fig : image ] . in contrast , the qualitative correspondence between the main x - ray features shown in figure [ fig : image ] , i.e. the leading edge , horns , and tail , and those found in simulations ( e.g. see stevens et al . 1999 ; toniazzo & schindler 2001 ; acreman et al . 2003 ) of ram - pressure stripping of elliptical galaxies moving through surrounding cluster gas is striking . however , since none of these simulations model the specific galaxy , orbital , or cluster characteristics of ngc 4552 in virgo , only a qualitative , not quantitative , comparison of these simulations to our observation should be made . for supersonic stripping , the galaxy ism is initially pushed back and fanned out ( stevens et al . 1999 , model 1b , figure 2 ; toniazzo & schindler 2001 , figure 3 ; acreman et al . 2003 , figure 2c , @xmath72gyr slice ) causing the edge between the galaxy gas and the icm to flatten , as is seen for ngc 4552 ( fig . [ fig : image ] ) . this sharp surface brightness discontinuity , @xmath2kpc north of the galaxy s center , coupled with a gas tail in the opposite direction , fixes the galaxy s direction of motion in the plane of the sky . irregular filaments of stripped material also are seen in simulation images extending back from the leading edge , similar to the horns we observe in ngc 4552 . these filaments signal the onset of kelvin - helmholtz instabilities , where stripping is occurring at the boundary between galaxy and icm gas . in the simulation images , galaxy gas , once stripped and decelerated , forms a distinctive tail of emission behind the galaxy , again similar to what we see in figure [ fig : image ] . the three - dimensional simulations of toniazzo & schindler ( 2001 ) demonstrate that the tail is in general not axisymmetric with respect to the direction of motion , but may appear angular or curved , as is also found in our image . thus the most likely explanation for the origin of the features shown in figure [ fig : image ] is ram - pressure stripping of galaxy gas due to the motion of ngc 4552 through the virgo cluster icm . in order to investigate quantitatively these complex gas - dynamical processes and test our ram - pressure - stripping hypothesis , we first determine the spectral properties and densities of hot gas in the surrounding icm and in ngc 4552 s main emission features . spectral extraction regions were chosen to isolate , as much as possible given our limited photon statistics , emission from the individual features . the geometries of these spectral extraction regions are listed in table [ tab : specregs ] and are shown in figure [ fig : specimage ] . these regions are he and hw for the eastern and western horns extending from the northern surface brightness edge to either side of the galaxy , oa for galaxy emission at large radii but inside the northern edge , sl for the region ( lump ) of enhanced emission in the southwestern quadrant of ngc 4552 , and t for the tail of emission extending from the galaxy to the south . to determine source existence , one compares the source plus background counts in a region to that expected from the background alone . we also can determine how well the flux can be measured for each feature . we compute both these statistics for regions he , hw , sl , and t. the background regions we used to compute these measures are listed in table [ tab : bgsigregs ] , and the respective areas and observed counts are given in table [ tab : fluxsigdat ] . we note that the background region ( sl_bg ) used for region sl , that is embedded in the galaxy , was a neighboring region that included the surrounding galaxy emission . neighboring virgo cluster emission regions were used as local backgrounds to compute these statistics for features he , hw , and t , since those regions extend outward from ngc 4552 into the virgo cluster emission . for each region we find that the cumulative poisson probability that the observed or greater number of counts could have arisen from a fluctuation of the expected background is @xmath73 . thus the detection of these features is highly significant . the precision to which the flux can be measured for each feature is given in table [ tab : fluxsigdat ] , as the net source counts and the total uncertainty in each measurement . for the analysis below , since the spectra for gas in ngc 4552 and in the x - ray tail are soft , we restrict the spectral fit energy range for the tail ( t ) , horns ( he+hw ) and galaxy regions outside the rings to @xmath74kev , where the source count rates are above background . we initially separated the outer annular region ( oa ) for ngc 4552 into two separate rectangular regions , one just inside the northern leading edge ( ng ) and one to the south near the beginning of the tail ( sg ) , to look for temperature differences between these two regions . however , since we found no statistically significant difference between the spectral fits for these regions ( see table [ tab : allspectra ] ) , we combined them into the annular region ( oa ) shown , in order to improve statistics and sharpen our measurement of the temperature and abundance for galaxy gas outside the central region . we chose a @xmath75 rectangular region ( vn ) centered @xmath76 north of ngc 4552 , comprising approximately @xmath77 of the area of the s3 chip , to determine the spectrum of the virgo cluster gas in the vicinity of ngc 4552 . we fit the spectrum for the virgo icm ( region vn ) over the full @xmath78kev energy band , where the s3 detector has good efficiency . we fix the hydrogen absorbing column at @xmath79@xmath80 , the galactic value ( dickey & lockman 1990 ) and allow the temperature , abundance and normalization to vary . we find the temperature of the virgo cluster icm to be @xmath81kev with metal abundance @xmath82 . we then allowed the absorbing column to vary and found no suggestion for increased absorption . our results are in excellent agreement with previous spectral analyses of the virgo cluster icm using data from _ ginga _ ( takano et al . 1989 ) , _ rosat _ ( bhringer et al . 1994 ) , and _ asca _ ( ohashi et al . 1998 , shibata et al . 2001 ) , that find , with galactic hydrogen absorption , temperatures @xmath83kev and metal abundances of @xmath84 , at projected distances ( @xmath85kpc from m87 ) comparable to that of ngc 4552 . we note that the temperature and x - ray emissivity of the virgo icm are relatively insensitive to the metal abundance over the abundance range ( @xmath86 ) determined by our fit . if we allow the abundance to vary over this range , we find variations in the virgo icm temperature of @xmath87kev , within the @xmath31 confidence level for the canonical fit , and variations in the inferred @xmath1kev x - ray emissivity for the cluster gas of @xmath88 . region vn also was used as a local background region for galaxy source regions at large radii ( ng , sg , oa , sl ) , the horns ( hw+he ) and the tail ( t ) , to remove contamination from virgo cluster emission . for spectral fitting , counts were grouped both by using predefined bins resulting in channels of approximately logarithmic width , and by using a minimum @xmath89 counts per bin . both methods gave consistent spectral model fits . the spectra for all of the above regions are well represented by single - temperature apec or vapec thermal plasma models ( smith et al . 2001 ) corrected for absorption using wisconsin photo - electric cross - sections ( morrison & mccammon 1983 ) . our results for these regions are summarized in table [ tab : allspectra ] . we checked that our results were not sensitive to the position of the local background region ( vn ) on the detector by recomputing the spectral fits using a second @xmath90 circular region @xmath91 east of ngc 4552 ( ve in table [ tab : specregs ] ) and found no significant differences in the fitted parameters . we also fit the spectra to these regions using blank sky backgrounds ( as for vn ) and a two component apec + apec model . we fixed the temperature and abundance of one apec component at our best fit values for the virgo cluster emission ( @xmath92kev and @xmath93 , see table [ tab : allspectra ] ) , while allowing the temperature and abundance of the second apec component and both component normalizations to vary , and found consistent results . thus our results are not biased by our choice of vn as the local background . since the models agree within their @xmath31 cl , we present only those results ( using background region vn ) for the tail and galaxy emission at large radii in table [ tab : allspectra ] . for fixed galactic absorption , we find the temperature and abundance of the outer galaxy gas in region oa to be @xmath94kev and @xmath95 , a metallicity marginally higher than that for the virgo icm , but with large uncertainty . to check the stability of the fit , we allowed the absorbing column to vary and found no suggestion for increased absorption above the galactic value . to assess the effect of any residual unresolved x - ray binaries on our results , we also fit the spectrum for region oa , galaxy emission within the northern edge , over the @xmath96kev energy range with an absorbed two component model consisting of an apec component for emission from the diffuse gas and a @xmath38kev bremsstrahlung component to model unresolved x - ray binaries ( kraft et al . we fix the hydrogen absorbing column at its galactic value , while allowing the temperature and abundance in the apec component and both component normalizations to vary . we find that the fitted temperature ( @xmath97kev ) and abundance ( @xmath98 ) for the thermal component in this two component model agree , within their @xmath31 confidence limits , with the single apec model results listed in table [ tab : allspectra ] . the bremsstrahlung ( unresolved binary ) component contributes only @xmath99 to the @xmath1kev luminosity of region oa . this is consistent with theoretical expectations for the contribution of x - ray binaries to the flux in region oa found by integrating the average x - ray luminosity function for lmxb s ( gilfanov , 2004 ) below our observed @xmath100 kev point source detection threshold ( @xmath101ergs@xmath15@xmath80 ) in that region . thus , the effects of residual unresolved x - ray binaries on the measured properties of the diffuse gas in region oa do not bias the single temperature apec model results for the properties of the galaxy gas which are important to our analysis . we find that the temperature of the ism on the galaxy side of the ( leading ) northern edge ( @xmath102kev ) is a factor @xmath103 lower than the temperature of the gas in the ambient virgo icm ( @xmath104kev ) . as shown in figure [ fig : image ] , this temperature drop corresponds to a sharp increase in surface brightness ( and thus gas density as quantified in [ sec : sboutprofile ] ) . this is consistent with the interpretation of the northern edge as a cold front , the leading edge of the galaxy ism as it undergoes ram pressure stripping , in broad agreement with expectations from simulations ( e.g. see stevens et al . 1999 , figure 2 , model 1b ; acreman et al . 2003 , figures 10a & c and 11b & d , @xmath105gyr time slice ) . figures [ fig : image ] and [ fig : panda ] show a bright region ( lump ) of emission in the outer southwest quadrant of the galaxy . we use a @xmath106 circular region centered at ( @xmath107 , @xmath108 ) surrounding the lump ( region sl in figure [ fig : specimage ] ) to isolate the spectrum for this region . although we find , using an apec model with galactic absorption , a temperature @xmath109kev and abundance @xmath110 formally consistent with the properties of galaxy gas elsewhere outside the central rings in ngc 4552 , the @xmath111 is large . the fit is improved ( @xmath112 ) by using an absorbed vapec model with a higher iron abundance , while fixing all other abundances at @xmath113 , the mean abundance for the galaxy ism in region oa . the hydrogen absorbing column remained fixed at the galactic value . we include this fit in table [ tab : allspectra ] . in this vapec model , the temperature of the gas in the southern lump is @xmath114kev , consistent with previous results for gas at large radii , but the iron abundance is increased to near solar values ( @xmath115 ) . this may suggest that the southwest quadrant of the galaxy has either experienced a recent episode of star formation itself or has had metals transported from star forming activity near the galaxy center ( expected for a transition type nucleus ) to larger radii in the galaxy as a result of outflows . the regions he and hw for the horn - like features are faint , with region he and hw containing only @xmath116 and @xmath117 net source counts , respectively , in the @xmath74kev energy band . in order to improve statistics , we combine these regions and fit their average spectrum ( he+hw in table [ tab : allspectra ] ) . we restrict our models to those with three or fewer free parameters . neither an absorbed bremsstrahlung model nor absorbed power law model , each with all parameters free to vary , can fully describe the data , giving @xmath118 of @xmath119 and @xmath120 , respectively . a thermal apec model with galactic absorption provides a better fit to the data with temperature @xmath121kev and abundance @xmath122 ( @xmath123 ) . the probability of obtaining this value of @xmath124 or higher , given @xmath125 degrees of freedom , is @xmath126 ( @xmath127 confidence ) . the @xmath124 for the model fit to the combined spectrum for the horns might suggest that these two regions are not homogeneous in their spectral properties . we investigate this possibility by fitting the spectrum for each horn individually . using absorbed apec thermal plasma models with fixed abundance and galactic absorption , we find the temperature of gas in the eastern horn he to be @xmath128kev ( @xmath129 ) and in the western horn hw to be @xmath130kev ( @xmath131 ) for @xmath132 abundance , taken from the fit to the combined horn regions he+hw ( see table [ tab : allspectra ] ) . these temperatures vary by @xmath133 when the abundance is varied between @xmath134 to @xmath135 ( see table [ tab : metalscool ] ) . although suggestive , the fitted temperatures agree within their @xmath31 confidence limits . thus with these data , we can not conclude that the temperatures of the eastern and western horns are significantly different . however , if such a temperature difference were to be confirmed in a deeper exposure , it would not be surprising . the horns are spatially separated and most likely correspond to different stripping events . temperature differences between gas in the two horns could arise from hydrodynamical effects caused by local temperature and pressure gradients in the different turbulent eddies responsible for the stripping process in each region . the main conclusion that can be drawn from the current data is that the temperature of the gas in the horns is cool , similar to that measured throughout the outer regions of ngc 4552 ( see table [ tab : allspectra ] . these temperatures agree within their @xmath31 confidence limits with the temperature ( @xmath136kev ) for gas in the outer radii of ngc 4552 ( region oa ) . in contrast , they are @xmath137 times lower than the @xmath138kev temperature of the surrounding virgo cluster icm . this is the key property of the gas in the horns that identifies it as galaxy ( and not cluster ) gas , likely in the process of being stripped . these results are consistent with simulations of ram - pressure stripping ( see , e.g. stevens et al . 1999 , figure 2 , model 1b ) , where irregular filaments due to the onset of hydrodynamical instabilities during stripping are cooler and denser than the surrounding icm . in figure [ fig : edgeimage ] we show the angular sector used to construct the @xmath1kev surface brightness profile to the north across the flattened surface brightness edge between galaxy gas and the virgo cluster icm , as a function of the mean distance from the center of ngc 4552 . the profile is constructed from elliptical annuli constrained to lie within the angular sector centered on the galaxy nucleus and extending from @xmath139 to @xmath140 measured clockwise from east , that was chosen to exclude the horns of emission extending southward from each side of the northern leading edge . the elliptical annuli are concentric to a ` bounding ' ellipse , with semi - major ( -minor ) axes of @xmath141 ( @xmath142 ) and position angle of @xmath143 , that traces the shape of the northern surface brightness edge within the angular sector . the radial extent of each elliptical annulus varies logarithmically inward and outward from the bounding ellipse with logarithmic step size @xmath144 . in the left panel of figure [ fig : sbprof ] , we show the @xmath1kev surface brightness profile as a function of the mean distance from the center of ngc 4552 to the north across the flattened surface brightness edge between galaxy gas and the virgo cluster icm . two sharp surface brightness discontinuities ( denoted by vertical dashed lines ) are evident in figure [ fig : sbprof ] : the outer , ` leading ' edge is at the northern interface between the galaxy cold front and virgo cluster gas , and the inner discontinuity is at the position of the rim of the bright northern ring . we analyse the leading edge of the cold front in this paper and the central rings in paper ii . the observed surface brightness profile is proportional to the product of the x - ray emissivity and the square of the electron density , integrated along the line of sight . by fitting the surface brightness profile , we are able to determine the shape of the density distribution , the location of the edge , and the ratio of electron densities on either side of the edge , averaged over the respective profile bins . if the density is slowly varying over the profile bin , as is the case for a cold front , this measured density ratio is a good measure of the physical density discontinuity across the edge . as was done for other cold fronts ( markevitch et al . 2000 ; vikhlinin et al . 2001 ; machacek et al . 2005a ) , we assume a spherically symmetric power law distribution of the form @xmath145 for the electron density in ngc 4552 inside the leading edge of the cold front ( but outside the central rings ) , where @xmath146 and @xmath147 are the normalization and power law index for the electron density of ngc 4552 in the cold front , respectively . the radial distance @xmath148 and location @xmath149 of the leading surface brightness discontinuity are measured from the optical center of ngc 4552 , i.e. the center of the bounding ellipse . we model the electron density in the virgo cluster icm ( within subcluster a ) using a spherically symmetric , isothermal @xmath68 model centered on m87 with @xmath150 , and core radius @xmath151 taken from a fit by schindler et al . ( 1999 ) to _ rosat _ all - sky survey data of the virgo icm out to a radius of @xmath152 from m87 . we normalize the cluster @xmath68 model using the surface brightness @xmath153kpc away from ngc 4552 , in the undisturbed virgo icm ( cluster free stream region ) . we find the central electron density ( density @xmath68 model normalization ) for the virgo icm to be @xmath154@xmath5 , in agreement with previous results ( schindler et al . 1999 ) . however , to model the electron density , at the interface between galaxy gas in the cold front and the virgo icm , requires additional assumptions about the three - dimensional geometry of ngc 4552 relative to the cluster center . we assume that the distance of m87 is representative of the cluster center , at least for subcluster a containing both m87 and ngc 4552 . measurements of distance moduli @xmath155 for ngc 4552 ( @xmath156 ) and m87 ( @xmath157 ) , using i - band surface brightness fluctuations ( tonry et al . 2001 ) , agree within uncertainties , suggesting the two galaxies are at comparable distances . we thus assume that the @xmath158 projected distance between ngc 4552 and m87 is representative of their true physical separation . the electron density of the virgo icm , just outside the leading edge , is then @xmath159@xmath5 . we then use a multivariate minimization algorithm to fit the surface brightness profile across the leading edge , allowing the location of the edge ( @xmath149 ) , the power law index of the electron density inside the edge ( @xmath147 ) , and the discontinuity ( @xmath160 ) to be free parameters . the discontinuity ( @xmath160 ) is given by @xmath161 where @xmath162(@xmath163 ) and @xmath164(@xmath165 ) are the x - ray emissivity ( electron density ) inside ( @xmath166 ) and outside ( @xmath167 ) the leading edge of the cold front . we find the best fit position of the leading , northern edge ( cold front ) to be @xmath168kpc from the galaxy center , the slope of the electron density inside the cold front to be @xmath169 , and the discontinuity @xmath160 ( given by equation [ eq : jump ] ) to be @xmath170 . the uncertainties on the discontinuity reflect the @xmath31 cl uncertainties in the slope found for @xmath147 . while the surface brightness discontinuity @xmath160 depends only on the slope of the power law distribution given by the fit to the surface brightness profile , we see from equation [ eq : jump ] that the ratio of the electron densities inside and outside the leading edge is sensitive , through the x - ray emissivity , to the spectral properties of the gas . in table [ tab : metalscool ] we show the dependence of the spectral fit parameters on the galaxy abundances for all the galaxy regions of interest and list the parameters for the nearby virgo cluster icm for comparison . as this table shows , the temperature found for gas in each region is insensitive to the abundance over the range of interest ( @xmath171 ) . on the other hand , since metal lines dominate the cooling function for temperatures @xmath172kev ( tucker & gould 1966 ; raymond & smith 1977 ; smith et al . 2001 ) , the spectral model normalization , and thus x - ray emissivity , vary by a factor of @xmath173 over the same range . as shown for the infalling elliptical galaxy ngc 1404 in the fornax cluster ( machacek et al . 2005a ) , this may introduce significant uncertainties in modeling the electron density in the galaxy from the surface brightness discontinuity between galaxy and cluster gas . we use @xmath1kev x - ray emissivities given in table [ tab : metalscool ] derived from our spectral fits , the cluster icm density outside the cold front ( @xmath174@xmath5 ) determined from the cluster icm @xmath68-model , and the measured discontinuity ( @xmath170 ) in equation [ eq : jump ] to infer the electron density @xmath175 inside the cold front . in table [ tab : properties ] we show the effect of the uncertainty in ngc 4552 s abundance ( and thus emissivity ) on the ratio of electron densities inside and outside the leading edge ( cold front ) and the propagation of that uncertainty through the analysis of the galaxy motion that follows . since we found no strong metallicity gradients within the galaxy ( see table [ tab : allspectra ] ) , we adopt a common mean metallicity for gas in the whole galaxy of @xmath176 , determined from a spectral fit to the galaxy emission within a radius of @xmath177 , excluding resolved point sources and the nucleus . from table [ tab : metalscool ] , the @xmath1 kev emissivity for @xmath178kev galaxy gas at large radii ( region oa ) with abundance @xmath179 is @xmath180erg@xmath181s@xmath15 . we take the @xmath1kev x - ray emissivity for @xmath93 virgo icm gas ( also from table [ tab : metalscool ] ) to be @xmath182erg@xmath183s@xmath15 . the density ratio across the cold front is then found to be @xmath184 , and the electron density at @xmath185kpc , inside ngc 4552 in the cold front , is @xmath186@xmath5 . following vikhlinin et al . ( 2001 ) , we use the gas temperature and density ratios across the leading edge in ngc 4552 to calculate the pressure ratio @xmath187 between galaxy gas in the cold front inside the leading edge and undisturbed virgo cluster gas in the free - stream region . we assume the galaxy gas in ngc 4552 just inside the edge is in pressure equilibrium with cluster gas at the stagnation point just outside the edge , where the relative velocity between ngc 4552 and the cluster gas is zero . thus @xmath187 is a measure of the pressure ratio between cluster gas at the stagnation point and in the free - stream region , and can be used to determine the mach number @xmath188 of ngc 4552 s motion relative to the icm ( landau & lifschitz 1959 ; vikhlinin et al . 2001 ) . in table [ tab : properties ] we summarize the dependencies of this velocity analysis for ngc 4552 on the metallicity of the galaxy gas over the abundance range @xmath189 . it is important to note that , because the motion lies on the supersonic , steeply rising branch of the pressure ratio versus mach number curve ( eq . @xmath41 in vikhlinin et al . 2001 ) , the mach number remains well constrained , despite the uncertainties in the density and pressure ratios caused by uncertainties in ngc 4552 s poorly constrained metallicity . we find that ngc 4552 is moving at mach @xmath190 through the virgo cluster gas . given the speed of sound in @xmath138kev gas of @xmath191kms@xmath15 , the speed of ngc 4552 relative to the icm is @xmath192kms@xmath15 . taking @xmath193kms@xmath15 , the relative radial velocity between ngc 4552 and m87 ( ned , smith et al . 2000 ) , as the relative radial velocity between ngc 4552 and the surrounding virgo icm , we find the component of velocity in the plane of the sky to be @xmath194kms@xmath15and the inclination angle of the motion with respect to the plane of the sky to be @xmath195 towards the observer . with the motion of ngc 4552 through the icm constrained by the properties of the leading cold front , we can examine the properties of the hot gas in the tail . from table [ tab : allspectra ] , we see that the temperature ( @xmath196kev ) of x - ray - emitting gas in the tail is consistent ( given the large uncertainties ) with the temperature of gas in the outer region of the galaxy oa ( @xmath94 ) and in the horns ( @xmath121 ) , where stripping is expected to be occurring . the gas temperature in the tail is @xmath173 times lower than that of the virgo icm , proving that the tail is composed predominantly of ram - pressure - stripped galaxy gas rather than virgo icm gas concentrated into a wake . although poorly constrained due to our limited statistics , the metallicity of gas in the tail ( @xmath197 ) is also consistent with that in the galaxy . the @xmath1kev luminosity for hot gas in the tail ( from region t ) is @xmath198ergs@xmath15 . we estimate the mean electron density @xmath199 for gas in the tail from the xspec apec spectral model normalization @xmath200 , where @xmath201 @xmath202 is the angular size distance to the source , @xmath203 is the source redshift , @xmath199 and @xmath204 are the mean electron and hydrogen number densities , respectively , @xmath205 is the gas filling factor , and @xmath206 is the volume of the tail emission region . all quantities are in cgs units . if we assume gas in the tail uniformly fills a cylindrical volume ( corresponding to the spectral extraction region t ) of radius @xmath207kpc ( @xmath208 ) and length @xmath209 , where @xmath210 is the inclination angle of the motion with respect to the plane of the sky , we find a mean electron density for hot gas in the tail of @xmath211@xmath5 . as shown in table [ tab : metalscool ] and reflected by the large uncertainties , the apec model normalization @xmath200 , and thus the inferred mean electron density , are strongly dependent on the metallicity of the tail . assuming the `` best fit '' model for the tail ( @xmath212 , @xmath213kev , @xmath214 ) , the mean electron density in the tail ( region t ) is @xmath215@xmath5 . thus the tail is cooler and denser than the surrounding icm , as expected from simulations ( see , e.g. stevens et al . 1999 , figure 2 , model 1b ) . in figure [ fig : tailicmproj ] we compare the surface brightness in a rectangular region of width @xmath38kpc projected onto the tail s central axis in @xmath43kpc bins along the length of the tail ( filled circles ) to the projection of the surface brightness of the surrounding virgo icm in a parallel region of the same dimensions , orientation , and bin size ( open squares ) . we define the beginning of the tail ( and @xmath216 of the projection in figure [ fig : tailicmproj ] ) at the point @xmath173kpc south of ngc 4552 s center , where the tail visually appears distinct from the galaxy s more spherical , hot gas halo ( see figure [ fig : image ] ) . the solid and long - dashed lines denote the best linear fits to the projected surface brightness of the tail and virgo icm , respectively . as expected from the @xmath68-model for the virgo icm ( schindler et al . 1999 ) , the projected surface brightness of the virgo icm at the distance of the tail from m87 is very flat , consistent with being constant . in contrast the projected surface brightness of the tail declines by a factor @xmath103 before becoming indistinguishable from the surrounding virgo icm . defining the length of the observed tail , in the plane of the sky , as the distance from where the tail appears distinct from ngc 4552 to where it fades into the virgo icm , we estimate this length to be @xmath217kpc ( from figure [ fig : tailicmproj ] ) , corresponding to a physical length ( given @xmath218 ) of @xmath219kpc . using our derived mean density of @xmath220@xmath5and assuming uniform filling of a cylindrical volume of radius @xmath207kpc and physical length @xmath221kpc , we estimate the gas mass in the observed tail to be @xmath222 . we find the mean thermal pressure for gas in the tail to be @xmath223kev@xmath5 , where the errors reflect the @xmath31 cl combined uncertainties due to the measured tail gas temperature and metallicity and ngc 4552 s inclination angle @xmath210 . we estimate the mean pressure of the surrounding icm using the virgo icm @xmath68-model evaluated at the midpoint of the cylindrical emission region ( t ) . since the perpendicular ( @xmath210 dependent ) component of the distance between the midpoint of region t and the virgo cluster center ( taken to be m87 ) is small ( @xmath224 for @xmath225 ) compared to the transverse component ( @xmath22 ) , the @xmath210 dependence of the cluster gas electron density can be ignored . we find the mean thermal pressure for undisturbed virgo cluster gas at the location of the tail to be @xmath226kev@xmath5 . although the uncertainties are large , these data suggest that the thermal pressure of the undisturbed icm alone may not be sufficient to establish pressure equilibrium with the stripped gas in the tail . this is in agreement with simulations that find the stripped ism may not be in pressure equilibrium with the ambient medium , but that gas in the tail expands while it is removed ( toniazzo & schindler 2001 ; heinz et al . 2003 ) . if we assume the gas , once heated and stripped from the galaxy , is free to expand adiabatically at approximately the tail sound speed ( @xmath227kms@xmath15for @xmath228kev gas ) , we can use the initial tail radius @xmath229 to estimate the time @xmath230 needed for gas in the tail to reach pressure equilibrium with the undisturbed icm ( machacek et al . 2005b ) , i.e. @xmath231 for a monatomic ideal gas with adiabatic index @xmath232 , where @xmath233 and @xmath234 are the initial and final thermal pressures in the tail . assuming thermal pressures dominate , the final tail pressure @xmath234 is approximately the pressure of the surrounding icm . using the best apec model fit parameters for the tail gas , @xmath235 , and initial radius @xmath236kpc ( from region t ) , we find the time for the tail to expand to equilibrium to be @xmath6myr . given ngc 4552 s transverse velocity of @xmath237kms , gas at the end of the observable tail ( @xmath217kpc downstream in the plane of the sky ) has had @xmath153myr more time to expand than gas now found near the beginning of the tail , and so the southern end of the tail may be nearly in pressure equilibrium with the icm . as the gas density in the tail decreases due to adiabatic expansion , we would expect the tail to broaden and fade . from conservation of entropy , the mean density and temperature of the tail gas at pressure equilibrium would be @xmath238@xmath5and @xmath239kev , with an expected corresponding decrease in surface brightness by a factor @xmath153 . although our statistics are too limited to directly observe a temperature decline in the tail , the observed rapid fading of the tail , by a factor @xmath240 from figure [ fig : tailicmproj ] , is broadly consistent with that expected from adiabatic expansion . for supersonic motion one would expect a bow shock to form in the virgo icm in front of the galaxy . however , the bow shock is likely to be the least visible of the three features ( cold front , tail , bow shock ) expected from supersonic ram pressure stripping ( stevens et al . the primary reason for this is that the shock front is narrow and the observed properties are very sensitive to projection effects . while the rankine - hugonoit conditions ( @xmath241 landau & lifshitz 1959 ) predict a peak density and temperature jump of @xmath242 and @xmath243 at the shock front for mach @xmath138 motion through the cluster gas , the observed temperature and density jumps will be much lower , primarily due to integration along the line of sight that crosses mostly through unshocked cluster gas , and to projection effects caused by the fact that the motion of ngc 4552 is not in the plane of the sky , but at an inclination angle of @xmath244 out of the plane towards the observer . following vikhlinin et al . ( 2001 ) we estimate the approximate location of the bow shock in front of ngc 4552 from the mach number and the location ( @xmath245 ) of the body sonic point , i.e. the point on the body where the flow velocity equals the sound speed of the cluster gas . @xmath246 is the coordinate of the body sonic point measured along the axis of symmetry and @xmath247 is the radial distance of the body sonic point from the axis of symmetry ( see vikhlinin et al . 2001 , figure 9 ) . as vikhlinin et al . ( 2001 ) describe , we derive the shock position using moeckel s ( 1949 ) figure 7 , that shows the ratio of the shock detachment distance @xmath248 , where @xmath249 is the location of the bow shock along the symmetry axis , versus the radial coordinate of the body sonic point @xmath247 as a function of the mach number . for a mach @xmath138 shock , @xmath250 . thus if the body sonic point is known , the calculation of the shock position is well determined . if the body being stripped has a well defined shoulder , as in a3667 ( vikhlinin et al . 2001 ) , the body sonic point is at the location of the shoulder . however , in ngc 4552 ( see figure [ fig : image ] ) , the ` horns ' make the precise location of the shoulder difficult to discern . instead we use figure 9 of moeckel ( 1949 ) to find the body sonic point for mach @xmath138 motion as that point on the body surface where the angle , @xmath251 , of the tangent line from the symmetry axis to the body surface is @xmath252 . again the precise shape of the body surface is uncertain due to the irregular ` horns ' . we estimate the ` body surface ' of the galaxy by a sphere centered on the galaxy nucleus with a radius of @xmath2kpc ( the radial distance to the leading edge ) . this approximately spherical shape is consistent with the distribution of optical light and broadly consistent with the galaxy gas excluding the horns and the tail . we then find @xmath253kpc , the shock detachment distance @xmath254 , and the distance @xmath255 , between the position of the leading edge @xmath256 and the body sonic point along the symmetry axis , of @xmath257kpc . rewriting the shock detachment distance @xmath258 , we expect the bow shock to intersect the symmetry axis at @xmath257kpc outside the leading edge or equivalently at @xmath259kpc from ngc 4552 s center . it is interesting to note that the surface brightness outside the leading edge , shown in figure [ fig : sbprof ] , does increase by a factor @xmath83 between @xmath260kpc , broadly consistent with this picture . while suggestive , a much deeper observation is needed to establish whether or not this rise is actually evidence for the expected bow shock . the density and thus surface brightness are also expected to rise in the stagnation region as the gas behind the shock slows and is adiabatically compressed in front of the leading edge ( vikhlinin et al . 2001 ) . again a rise in the surface brightness is observed in figure [ fig : sbprof ] in front of the northern edge ( @xmath261kpc ) . however , this observed rise in surface brightness also could partly be due to galaxy gas being stripped by instabilities to form the horns . the expected temperature rise in the gas behind the shock front , as seen , e.g. , in simulation slices by stevens et al . ( 1999 ) , would not be observable in our data due to dilution by unshocked gas projected along the line of sight and our limited statistics over the small region ( mach angle @xmath262 ) between the shock front and the galaxy . in this work we analysed a @xmath0ks _ chandra _ observation of the elliptical galaxy ngc 4552 in the virgo cluster and found x - ray evidence for ram - pressure stripping in the outer regions of the galaxy , due to its supersonic motion through the virgo icm . we find the following : 1 . the @xmath1kev x - ray emission shows the classic features of a cold front and ram - pressure stripping as a gas rich galaxy moves supersonically within a rich cluster . we see : ( 1 ) a sharp , flattened leading surface brightness edge located @xmath2kpc from the center of ngc 4552 due to the ram - pressure of the virgo icm , ( 2 ) two horns of emission extending @xmath7kpc to either side of the edge that are composed of galaxy gas in the process of being stripped due to the onset of kelvin - helmholtz instabilities , and ( 3 ) a tail of emission extending @xmath6kpc behind ngc 4552 opposite the leading edge . galaxy gas inside the leading edge is cool ( @xmath263kev ) compared to the surrounding @xmath138kev virgo icm . the surface brightness distribution inside the leading edge is well fit by a power law density distribution @xmath264@xmath5 ( for @xmath265 ) , where @xmath266kpc is the position of the edge . the density ratio between gas inside the cold front and the surrounding virgo icm , found from fitting the surface brightness profile , is @xmath267 for galaxy ism metal abundances from @xmath134 to @xmath268 . 3 . assuming ngc 4552 and m87 both lie in the plane of the sky , the resulting pressure ratio ( @xmath12 ) between the free - streaming icm and cluster gas at the stagnation point implies that ngc 4552 is moving supersonically ( mach @xmath16 ) through the cluster gas with speed @xmath14kms@xmath15at an angle @xmath269 towards us with respect to the plane of the sky . 4 . the properties of the x - ray tail behind ngc 4552 are consistent with it being composed primarily of ram - pressure stripped galaxy gas . the tail is cool , with mean temperature @xmath196kev , and denser than the virgo icm , with @xmath270@xmath5 for @xmath271 . although the errors are large , mostly due to uncertainties in the tail gas metallicity , the mean thermal pressure of gas in the tail suggests that it is over - pressured with respect to the ambient icm . the subsequent adiabatic expansion of gas in the tail may partially explain the rapid fading of the tail with distance from the galaxy . this work is supported in part by nasa grant go3 - 4176a and the smithsonian institution . this work has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . we wish to thank maxim markevitch for the use of his edge analysis codes . acreman , d. , stevens , i. , ponman , t. , & sakelliou , i. 2003 , , 341 , 1333 bautz , m.w . , et al . 1998 , x - ray optics , instruments and missions , ed . hoover & a.b . walker , proc . spie , 3444 , 210 bettoni , d. , galletta , g. & garcia - burill0 , s. 2003 , a & a , 405 , 5 biller , b.a . , jones , c. , forman , w.r . , kraft , r. & ensslin , t. 2004 , , 613 , 238 bhringer , h. , briel , u. g. , schwarz , r. a. , voges , w. , hartner , g. , & trmper , j. 1994 , nature , 368 , 828 brown , b. & bregman , j. 2000 , , 539 , 592 byrd , g. & valtonen , m. 1990 , , 350 , 89 canizares , c. , fabbiano , g. & trinchieri , g. 1987 , , 312 , 503 cecil , g . , bland - hawthorn , j. & veilleux , s 2002 , , 576 , 745 combes , f. 2004 , in iau symposium 217 : recycling intergalactic and interstellar matter , ed . duc , j.braine , & e. brinks , asp conference series , vol . 217 ( san franscisco , astronomical society of the pacific ) , 440 condon , j. , huang , z .- p . , yin , q.f . , thuan , t.x . 1991 , , 378 , 65 davis , d & white , r. 1996 , , 470 , l35 dickey , j.m . & lockman , f.j . , 1990 , araa , 28 , 215 dosaj , a. , forman , c. , forman , w.r . , markevitch , m. , & vikhlinin , a. 2002 , baas , 34 , 712 eskridge , p. , fabbiano , g. & kim , d .- w . 1995 , , 97 , 141 fabian , a.c . , sanders , j.s . , allen , s.w . , crawford , c.s . , iwasawa , k. , johnstone , r.m . , schmidt , r.w . , & taylor , g.b . 2003 , , 344 , l43 filho , m.e.,fraternali , f. , markoff , s. , nagar , n.m . , barthel , p.d . , ho , l.d . , and yuan , f. 2004 , a & a , 418 , 429 forman , w. , jones , c. & tucker , w. 1985 , , 293 , 102 forman , w. , schwarz , j. , jones , c. , liller , w. , & fabian , a. 1979 , , 234 , l27 forman , w. , nulsen , p. , heinz , s. , owen , f. , eilek , j. , vikhlinin , a. , markevitch , m. , kraft , r. , churazov , e. , jones , c. 2005 , , in press , eprint astro - ph/0312576 garmire , g.p . et al . 1992 , aiaa , space programs and technologies conference , march 24 - 27 , 1992 ( paper 92 - 1473 ; new york : aiaa ) gilfanov , m. 2004 , , 349 , 146 gnedin , o.j . 2003 , , 582,141 gunn , j. , & gott , j. 1972 , , 176 , 1 heinz , s. , churazov , e. , forman , w. , jones , c. , & briel , u.g . ( 2003 ) , , 346 , 13 ho , l.c . , filippenko , a.v . & sargent , w.l.w . 1997 , , 112 , 315 irwin , j.a . & sarazin , c.l . 1996 , , 471 , 683 kenney , j. , et al . 1995 , , 438 , 135 kenney , j. , van gorkom , j.h . & vollmer , b. 2004 , astro - ph/0403103 kim , d .- w . , fabbiano , g. , & trinchieri , g. 1992 , , 80 , 645 kraft , r. , kregenow , j.m . , forman , w.r . , jones , c. , & murray , s.s . 2005 , , 560 , 675 landau , l.d . & lifshitz , e.m . 1959 , fluid mechanics ( london : pergamon ) , chapter ix lavery , r. & henry , j.p . 1988 , , 330 , 596 machacek , m. , dosaj , a. , forman , w. , jones , c. , markevitch , m. , vikhlinin , a. , warmflash , a. , & kraft , r. 2005a , , 621 , 663 machacek , m. , nulsen , p. , stirbat , l. , jones , c. & forman , w.r . 2005b , , 630 , 280 machacek , m. , nulsen , p.e.j . , jones , c. , & forman , w.r . 2006 , , submitted ( paper ii ) markevitch , m. et al . 2000 , , 541 , 542 matsushita , k 2001 , , 547 , 693 matsushita , k. , ohashi , t. & makishima , k. 2000 , pasj , 52 , 685 mazzotta , p. , markevitch , m. , vikhlinin , a. , forman , w.r.,david , l. & vanspeybroeck , l. 2001 , , 555 , 205 merrifield , m.r . 1998 , , 294 , 347 moore , b. , katz , n. , lake , g. , dressler , a. , & oemler , a. 1996 , nature , 379 , 613 moekel , w.e . 1949 , approximate method for predicting form and location of detached shock waves ahead of plane or axially symmetric bodies , naca technical note 1921 , available online at http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/reports/1949/naca-tn-1921 morrison , r. & mccammon , d. 1983 , , 270 , 119 mller , m. , mair , g. , & hillebrandt , w. 1989 , , 216 , 19 nulsen , p.e.j . 1982 , , 198 , 1007 nulsen , p.e.j . , mcnamara , b.r . , wise , m.w . , & david , l.p . 2005 , , 628 , 629 ohashi , t. et al . in iau symposium 188 , the hot universe , ed . k koyama , s. kitamoto , & m. itoh ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 317 osullivan , e. , forbes , d.a . & ponman , t. j. 2001 , mnras , 328 , 461 plucinsky , p.p . , schulz , n.s . , marshall , h.l . , grant , c.e . , chartas , g. , sanwal , d. , teter , m. , vikhlinin , a.a . , edgar , r.j . , wise , m.w . , allen , g.e . , virani , s.n . , depasquale , j.m . & raley , m.t . 2003 , in proceedings of the spie x - ray and gamma - ray telescopes and instruments for astronomy , ed . trluemper & h. tannenbaum , proceedings of the spie , 4851 , 89 quilis , v. , moore , b. , & bower , r. 2000 , science,288 , 1617 rangarajan , f.v.n . , white , d.a . , ebeling , h. & fabian , a. 1995 , mnras , 277 , 1047 raymond , j.c . & smith , b.w . 1977 , , 35 , 419 roberts , m. , hogg , d. , bregman , j. , forman , w.r . & jones , c. 1991 , , 75 , 751 sakelliou , i. , merrifield , m.r . , & mchardy , i.m . 1996 , , 283 , 673 scharf , c.a.,zurek , d.r . , & bureau , m. 2005 , , 633 , 154 schindler , s. , binggeli , b. , bhringer , h. 1999 , a & a , 343 , 420 shibata , r. , matsushita , k. , yamasaki , n.y . , ohashi , t. , ishida , m. , kikuchi , k , bhringer , h. , & matsumoto , h. 2001 , apj , 549 , 228 smith , r.j . , lucey , j.r . , hudson , m.j . , schlegel , d.j . & davies , r.l . 2000 , , 313 , 469 smith , r.k . , brickhouse , n.s . , liedahl , d. a. & raymond , j.d . 2001 , , 556 , l91 stevens , i.r . , acreman , d. & ponman , t.j . 1999 , , 310 , 663 strickland , d , heckman , t. , weaver , k. , & dahlem , m. 2000 , , 120 , 2965 sun , m. & vikhlinin , a. 2005 , , 621 , 718 sun , m. , jerius , d. & jones , c. 2005 , , submitted , eprint astroph/0501501 takano , s. et al . , 1989 , nature , 340 , 289 toniazzo , t. , & schindler , s. 2001 , , 325 , 509 tonry , j.l . , dressler , a. , blakeslee , j.p . , ajhar , e.a . , fletcher , a.b . , luppino , g.a . metzger , m.r . & moore , c.b . 2001 , , 546 , 681 tucker , w. & gould , r. 1966 , , 144 , 244 vikhlinin , a. , markevitch , m. & murray , s.s . 2001 , , 551 , 160 vollmer , b. 2003 , , 398 , 525 wang , q.d . , owen , f. , ledlow , m. , & keel , w. 2004 , in proc . iau colloq . 195 , outskirts of galaxy clusters : intense life in the suburbs , ed . a. diaferio ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 78 white , d. , fabian , a. , forman , w. , jones , c. & stern , c. 1991 , , 375 , 35 ccccc vn & rectangular & @xmath272 , @xmath273 & @xmath274,@xmath275 & @xmath276 + ve & circular & @xmath277 , @xmath278 & @xmath279 & + ng & rectangular & @xmath280 , @xmath281 & @xmath221 , @xmath282 & @xmath283 + sg & rectangular & @xmath280 , @xmath284 & @xmath285 , @xmath286 & @xmath283 + oa & annular & @xmath287 , @xmath288 & @xmath289 , @xmath290 & + sl & circular & @xmath291 , @xmath292 & @xmath293 & + hw & elliptical & @xmath294 , @xmath295 & @xmath296 , @xmath297 & @xmath298 + he & elliptical & @xmath299 , @xmath300 & @xmath301 , @xmath18 & @xmath302 + t & rectangular & @xmath299 , @xmath303 & @xmath304 , @xmath305 & @xmath306 + cccc he_bg & circular & @xmath307 , @xmath308 & @xmath309 + hw_bg & circular & @xmath307 , @xmath308 & @xmath309 + sl_bg & elliptical & @xmath280 , @xmath281 & @xmath310 , @xmath63 + t_bg & circular & @xmath311 , @xmath312 & @xmath313 + ccccccc he & @xmath314 & @xmath315 & he_bg & @xmath316 & @xmath317 & @xmath318 + hw & @xmath319 & @xmath320 & hw_bg & @xmath316 & @xmath317 & @xmath321 + sl & @xmath322 & @xmath323 & sl_bg & @xmath324 & @xmath325 & @xmath326 + t & @xmath327 & @xmath328 & t_bg & @xmath329 & @xmath330 & @xmath331 + ccccc vn & @xmath332 & @xmath81 & @xmath333 & @xmath334 + ng & @xmath335 & @xmath336 & @xmath337 & @xmath338 + sg & @xmath339 & @xmath340 & @xmath341 & @xmath342 + oa & @xmath343 & @xmath344 & @xmath345 & @xmath346 + sl & @xmath347 & @xmath348 & @xmath349 & @xmath350 + sl@xmath351 & @xmath347 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 & @xmath354 + he+hw & @xmath355 & @xmath356 & @xmath357&@xmath358 + he & @xmath359 & @xmath360 & @xmath361 & @xmath362 + hw & @xmath363 & @xmath364 & @xmath361 & @xmath365 + t & @xmath366 & @xmath228 & @xmath367 & @xmath368 + t & @xmath369 & @xmath228 & @xmath370 & @xmath371 + cccccc vn & & & & & + & @xmath372 & @xmath373 & @xmath374 & @xmath375 & @xmath376 + & @xmath134 & @xmath377 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 & @xmath376 + & @xmath380 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 & @xmath383 & @xmath384 + oa & & & & & + & @xmath134 & @xmath385 & @xmath310 & @xmath386 & @xmath387 + & @xmath388 & @xmath389 & @xmath390 & @xmath55 & @xmath391 + & @xmath386 & @xmath97 & @xmath392 & @xmath393 & @xmath394 + & @xmath395 & @xmath396 & @xmath397 & @xmath398 & @xmath399 + & @xmath400 & @xmath401 & @xmath402 & @xmath105 & @xmath403 + & @xmath393 & @xmath404 & @xmath405 & @xmath406 & @xmath407 + t & & & & & + & @xmath134 & @xmath408 & @xmath409 & @xmath395 & @xmath410 + & @xmath388 & @xmath228 & @xmath411 & @xmath393 & @xmath371 + & @xmath386 & @xmath412 & @xmath242 & @xmath398 & @xmath413 + & @xmath395 & @xmath414 & @xmath415 & @xmath416 & @xmath417 + & @xmath400 & @xmath418 & @xmath105 & @xmath419 & @xmath420 + & @xmath393 & @xmath421 & @xmath422 & @xmath138 & @xmath423 + he+hw & & & & & + & @xmath372 & @xmath424 & @xmath425 & @xmath380 & @xmath426 + & @xmath134 & @xmath427 & @xmath428 & @xmath386 & @xmath429 + & @xmath380 & @xmath430 & @xmath242 & @xmath431 & @xmath432 + & @xmath388 & @xmath430 & @xmath433 & @xmath55 & @xmath434 + he & & & & & + & @xmath372 & @xmath435 & @xmath2 & @xmath380 & @xmath436 + & @xmath134 & @xmath360 & @xmath415 & @xmath386 & @xmath362 + & @xmath380 & @xmath437 & @xmath43 & @xmath395 & @xmath438 + & @xmath388 & @xmath439 & @xmath398 & @xmath400 & @xmath440 + & & & & & + hw & & & & & + & @xmath372 & @xmath441 & @xmath243 & @xmath388 & @xmath442 + & @xmath134 & @xmath364 & @xmath43 & @xmath395 & @xmath365 + & @xmath380 & @xmath443 & @xmath144 & @xmath400 & @xmath444 + & @xmath388 & @xmath443 & @xmath445 & @xmath393 & @xmath446 + cccccccc @xmath134 & @xmath447 & @xmath134 & @xmath448 & @xmath449 & @xmath450 & @xmath451 & @xmath301 + @xmath388 & @xmath282 & @xmath134 & @xmath452 & @xmath243 & @xmath453 & @xmath454 & @xmath455 + @xmath386 & @xmath456 & @xmath134 & @xmath457 & @xmath138 & @xmath458 & @xmath459 & @xmath460 + @xmath395 & @xmath460 & @xmath134 & @xmath461 & @xmath415 & @xmath462 & @xmath463 & @xmath290 + @xmath400 & @xmath464 & @xmath134 & @xmath465 & @xmath433 & @xmath466 & @xmath467 & @xmath468 + @xmath393 & @xmath301 & @xmath134 & @xmath405 & @xmath406 & @xmath469 & @xmath470 & @xmath282 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: one of the methods for studying extensive air showers of high energies ( @xmath1 ev ) is to register their images in the optical ( mainly fluorescence ) light . this can be done by observing showers from the side in order to avoid the more intense cherenkov light emitted rougly in the shower direction . the observations are made by a number of optical telescopes , each containing a large mirror and a camera with a matrix of photomultipliers ( pmts ) placed at the focus of the optical system ( hires @xcite , the pierre auger observatory @xcite , the telescope array @xcite ) , so that photons arriving from a given direction on the sky are focused on a particular pmt ( pixel ) . photon arrival time can also be measured if the time structure of the pmt signals is recorded . a cosmic ray induced shower produces at a given time a light spot on the camera which moves across it as the shower develops in the atmosphere so that succeeding pmts are being hit . + it would have been ideal if the light producing a shower image had contained the fluorescence photons only . this is because there exists experimental evidence that the number of fluorescence photons induced by a charged electron in the atmosphere is proportional to the energy lost by it for ionisation @xcite . as practically all primary particle energy is eventually used for ionisation , this energy can be determined by measuring the fluorescence light emitted along the shower track in the atmosphere . + however , there are several problems in deriving the flux of the fluorescence light emitted by a shower from that arriving at the detector . firstly , the arriving light contains not only the fluorescence but also cherenkov photons . if the viewing angle ( the angle between the line of sight and the shower direction ) is large ( say , @xmath2 ) then it is mainly the cherenkov light _ scattered _ in the atmosphere region just passed by the shower and observed by the detector ( this light , before being scattered , travels roughly along the directions of the shower particles ) . typically its fraction at the detector is about @xmath3 of the fluorescence flux . for smaller viewing angles it is the cherenkov light _ produced _ at the observed part of the shower that may dominate even the fluorescence signal . the contribution of the cherenkov light , which has to be subtracted from the total signal , has been extensively studied @xcite . + the subject of this paper is another phenomenon , affecting shower images , most commonly called the multiple scattering ( ms ) of light . photons produced at the observed shower element , whatever their origin ( fluorescence or cherenkov ) , may undergo scattering in the atmosphere on their way from the shower to the detector , causing an attenuation of the light flux arriving at the detector and a smearing of the image . this scattering may take place on the air molecules ( rayleigh scattering ) or on larger transparent particles , aerosols ( mie scattering ) . most of the scattered photons change their directions , so that they no longer arrive at the pixel registering the not scattered ( direct ) light . moreover , they arrive later having longer path lengths to pass . on the other hand , photons emitted by the shower at earlier times and scattered somewhere , may fall in the field of view of the pixels just registering the direct photons emitted at a later time . the net effect is that the scattered light forms its own instantaneous image superimposed on that in the direct light . + our aim is to calculate the shower images in the multiply scattered light , so that this effect could be allowed for ( subtracted ) when determining the shower primary energy from the pmt signals . this problem was already studied by roberts @xcite , by us in several , short conference contributions @xcite and more recently by pkala et al @xcite . the approach of the other authors was based on monte carlo simulations of photons emitted by a shower . photons were followed up to 5 - 6 scatterings and their arrival directions and time were registered by the detector . many shower simulations were needed to obtain the ms images for various distances , heights , viewing angles of the observed shower parts . finally , a phenomenological parametrisation of the number of ms photons was made as a function of the parameters found as relevant . + in contrast to roberts and pkala et al this approach is based on an analytical treatment . the main idea is to consider the arriving ms light as a sum of the photons scattered only once ( the first generation ) , of those scattered two times ( the second generation ) and so on and calculate separately the angular and temporal distributions for each generation . + we start ( section 2 ) with a consideration of the simplest situation when a point source of isotropic light flashes for a very short time in an uniform medium . we derive analytical expressions for the angular and temporal distributions of the first and next generations of light arriving at a particular distance from the source . + as our aim is to apply our results to cosmic ray showers we need to consider a non - uniform medium like the atmosphere . assuming an exponential distribution of the gas density and similarly for aerosols we show that an effective scattering length between any two points in the atmosphere can be easily calculated analytically . signals of the first two generations arriving at a particular detector within a given angle @xmath4 to the direction to the source are found as a function of time ( section 3 ) . + using these it is straightforward to derive the corresponding distributions if the source moves across the atmosphere , integrating the point source distributions over changing distance and time of light emission . in section 4 we consider a moving light source , modelling a distant shower . we calculate angular distributions of ms light arriving at a detector at the same time as the direct ( not scattered ) photons emitted by the shower . this particular approach is quite natural because the data from optical detectors consist of the recorded signals by the camera pmts within short time intervals @xmath5 so that one needs to know how much of the ms light has to be subtracted from the main , direct signal . the method for calculating images in the ms light _ simultaneous _ with images in the direct light is relatively simple ( for the first and the second generations ) as it is based on the geometry of the scattered photons in the particular generation . it does not require time - consuming monte - carlo simulations that were done for various shower - observer geometries . making some approximations we derived analytical formula for a shower image produced by the first generation ( section 4.2 ) . our analytical derivations allowed us to choose easily the variables on which and how to parametrise the ms signals . they also made us to realise that the dependence of it on the viewing angle was different for rayleigh and mie scatterings . thus , we introduced a new , simple parametrisation of the fraction of the scattered photons arriving at the telescope within a given viewing cone , depending on the viewing angle of the shower ( what has not been done before ) , separately for the two scatterings . for the same reason we also parametrised separately the second generation ( section 4.3 ) . + a discussion of the results and the implication of the ms effect on the derivation of shower parameters is given in section 5 . the last section ( 6 ) contains a summary and conclusions . at any fixed time a distant shower can be regarded as a point source emitting isotropically fluorescence light ( about cherenkov light see later ) . as explained above , we treat the light scattered in the medium as a sum of consecutive generations consisting of photons scattered only once , twice , and so on , on their way from the source to the observation point . of a sphere with radius @xmath6 . two rays shown are scattered at points @xmath7 and @xmath8 , correspondingly , arriving at the surface of the sphere with radius @xmath6 at angles @xmath9 and @xmath10.,width=288 ] let us consider the first generation , consisting of photons scattered once only . we shall calculate the flux of these photons , @xmath11 , at a distance @xmath6 from the source , such that @xmath12 is the number of photons scattered only once , arriving at time @xmath13 after the flash , within a solid angle @xmath14 at the surface @xmath15 ( perpendicular to the arrival direction ) located at a distance @xmath6 . to do this we shall calculate first the number of photons crossing the sphere of radius @xmath6 ( from inside ) at an angle ( @xmath16 ) with respect to the normal , at time ( @xmath17 ) ; see fig . the average number of photons , per one photon emitted , interacting at a distance ( @xmath18 ) from the source and scattered at an angle @xmath19 within @xmath20 , equals @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the mean scattering path length , @xmath23 is the probability that , once the scattering has occured , the scattering angle is @xmath19 within . to each pair of variables @xmath24 there corresponds another pair @xmath25 related to the former by @xmath26 and @xmath27 where @xmath28 and @xmath29 is the speed of light . + the jacobian of the transformation gives @xmath30 thus , we obtain @xmath31 finally , the number of photons arriving at a unit surface at an angle @xmath32 ( all azimuths ) at time @xmath13 equals @xmath33 and @xmath34 for the rayleigh scattering we have @xmath35 expressing @xmath19 as a function of @xmath36 and @xmath37 ( eq . 2 ) we obtain @xmath38\ ] ] where @xmath39 . thus , the flux @xmath40 of the first generation , defined above , equals @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the mean free path length for the rayleigh scattering . however , @xmath22 in the exponent depends on all the scattering processes active . in general it is determined by @xmath43 for @xmath44 processes . thus , if both molecular and aerosol scatterings are active but one wants to calculate the flux of photons scattered by the rayleigh process only , @xmath22 in the exponent equals @xmath45 but in the denominator one has @xmath42 . + from eq . 10 one can find the number of photons @xmath46 arriving per unit time at a unit surface within a given angle @xmath4 , as a function of time . + we have @xmath47 the integral can be found analytically , giving the result @xmath48\cdot\frac{y_2^{i+1}-y_1^{i+1}}{i+1}+ \nonumber \\ & & + \big [ ( \tau^2 + 1)a_0-a_{-1 } \big ] ln \frac{y_2}{y_1}-a_2 \frac{y_2 ^ 3-y_1 ^ 3}{3 } \bigg)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 . + we have also calculated analytically a similar distribution @xmath56 if the scattering was isotropic . i.e. if @xmath57 ( appendix a ) . + one can also find analytically the angular distribution @xmath58 of the arriving light ( integrated over time ) , but for small angles only ( appendix b ) . the result is @xmath59 \bigg ) \nonumber\\ \,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath60 , @xmath61 , if there is no mie scattering and @xmath62 is the euler constant . + the ratio of all photons arriving within a small angle @xmath36 to those not scattered @xmath63 , equals @xmath64 where terms @xmath65 have been neglected . in the next paragraph we shall consider the scattering of light emitted by showers developing in the real atmosphere , i.e. with the density depending on height . in addition to the rayleigh process one has to take into account the mie scattering occurring on particles ( aerosols ) larger that the light wavelength . the mie angular distribution is concentrated at rather small angles , in contrast to the rayleigh case . moreover , in the deeper parts of the atmosphere the mean free path length for the mie scattering may be comparable to that for rayleigh , so that it is necessary to calculate the distribution of the light scattered by the mie process only . + as before , we start with a simpler case - a uniform medium . the angular distribution of light scattered on particles with sizes larger than the light wavelength depends on the distribution of the sizes and is not a well known function . roberts @xcite adopts a function of the form @xmath66 here , however , we prefer an expression allowing us to perform some integrations analytically . most crucial is to have the number of numerical integrations for the second generation as few as possible . we shall see that to find @xmath67 for the rayleigh scattering ( section 2.3 ) there is only one integration ( over @xmath68 ) to be done numerically since the form of @xmath69 enables one to integrate analytically over @xmath70 and @xmath71 ( eq . 25 and 26 ) . thus , we adopt the following form for the mie angular distribution : @xmath72 where @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 . + this function is normalised as follows @xmath76 it describes quite reasonably the distribution used by roberts . + from eq . 6 and 7 we have @xmath77}{2\pi \lambda_m r^2(\tau^2 - 2\tau\,cos\theta+1)}\ ] ] where @xmath78 if @xmath79 + and @xmath80 if @xmath81 + since @xmath82 we obtain @xmath83\ ] ] where @xmath84 , and @xmath85 is determined as before . in principle , it is possible to find analytically the number of photons @xmath86 arriving within an angle @xmath4 after time @xmath87 per unit time . however , each of the nine integrals @xmath88 contains many terms itself , so that an analytical dependence on @xmath4 and/or @xmath37 would be practically lost . thus , we have found @xmath89 by integrating the flux ( eq . 21 ) numerically ( similarly to eq . + finally , the total flux of the first generation is the sum of the two fluxes arising from the two active mechanisms of the scattering @xmath90 and the detector is the surface of the sphere with radius @xmath6 . the picture shows the last scattering.,width=288 ] these are the photons scattered exactly two times . we shall consider first a general case when there are more than one scattering processes ( as rayleigh and mie ) . let us call the process of the first scattering as @xmath91 and this of the second one as @xmath92 . both @xmath91 and @xmath92 can be either rayleigh or mie . we denote their mean scattering path lengths by @xmath93 and @xmath94 , and the angular distribution functions of the scattering by @xmath95 and @xmath96 , correspondingly . the light source flashes isotropically at the centre of a sphere with radius @xmath6 at time @xmath97 ( fig . 2 ) . as before we want to calculate the number of photons crossing the surface of the sphere from inside at a given angle @xmath36 , at time @xmath87 , per unit time . + let us consider the photons scattered for the second time at a distance @xmath98 from the source . the number of photons incident on a small surface @xmath99 at an angle @xmath71 ( within @xmath100 ) at time @xmath101 and scattered within a spherical shell of thickness @xmath102 by an angle @xmath103 ( within @xmath104 ) equals @xmath105 where @xmath106 . as now both processes are active the meaning of @xmath22 in the factor @xmath107 in the expression for @xmath108 is the effective mean path length for both processes . + the direction of the scattered photons is at an angle @xmath19 to the radius of the sphere and @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the azimuth of the photons scattered for the second time . for any given direction @xmath111 before and @xmath112 after the second scattering , the scattering angle @xmath103 fulfils the relation @xmath113 . the only function depending on the azimuth angle @xmath70 of the incident photons is @xmath114 . denoting @xmath115 and integrating ( 25 ) over @xmath71 we obtain for the number of photons incident on @xmath99 and scattered within @xmath102 into the solid angle @xmath20 the following expression @xmath116 where the function @xmath117 is defined by the integral in the l.h.s . of ( 26 ) . + the pair of fixed variables @xmath98 and @xmath19 defines another pair @xmath68 and @xmath36 , where @xmath68 is the photon path length after the second scattering . the jacobian of the transformation gives the relation @xmath118 putting @xmath119 , the contribution of photons scattered for the second time at a distance @xmath120 to arrive at an angle @xmath32 at the sphere with radius @xmath6 equals @xmath121\cdot } \nonumber \\ & & \cdot 4\pi r^2\cdot 2\pi sin\theta\,|cos\theta| \ , \ , dx'd\theta dt\end{aligned}\ ] ] the factor @xmath122 multiplied by @xmath123 in the expression for @xmath108 gives @xmath124 , independent of @xmath68 . integration over @xmath68 gives the total number of the above photons @xmath125 where @xmath126 . + the maximum value of @xmath68 results from fixing time @xmath87 . we have that @xmath127 thus , the flux of the second generation @xmath128 equals @xmath129 and , integrated over @xmath36 for @xmath130 , gives @xmath131 . with the rayleigh and mie processes active we must take into account all four cases @xmath132 or @xmath133 and @xmath134 or @xmath133 . finally , the flux of the combined second generation photons is a sum of all specific fluxes @xmath135 some of the integrals defined in this section can be found as analytical functions ( appendix c ) . it is of some importance when calculating higher generations ( see the next section ) . any next generation of the scattered photons can be calculated in the same way as the second one has been found from the previous one ( the first ) . to calculate the flux @xmath136 of the @xmath137 generation , given @xmath138 we proceed as before when calculating the second generation from the first one ( eq . the number of photons , incident on @xmath99 at an angle @xmath139 within @xmath140 at time @xmath141 and scattered along @xmath142 into @xmath143 equals : @xmath144 if there are two scattering processes , @xmath145 , then @xmath146 is the scattering probability by an angle @xmath147 by any process per unit distance per unit solid angle . the rest of the derivation of @xmath148 is the same as in the previous section . however , for each next generation the number of numerical integrations increases , unless values of @xmath149 are stored as a 3-dimension matrix . thus , it is convenient to find analytical solutions of the integrals @xmath150 and/or @xmath151 , if possible . fig . 3a shows the number of photons arriving at the detector within an angle @xmath152 per unit area per unit @xmath28 as a function of @xmath153 . the upper curves refer to the first generation , the lower - to the second one . we also compare here the time distributions obtained for the rayleigh with those for the isotropic scattering . the distance detector- source equals to one scattering length ( @xmath154 ) . + first of all we notice that for short times ( @xmath155 ) the first generation dominates over the second one , and ( as we can guess ) over the higher ones . it can be seen from the formulae for the isotropic scattering ( appendix a ) that the ratio @xmath156 for any given time should be proportional to @xmath157 , so that the importance of the second ( and the higher ) generation will be bigger for larger @xmath158 . + we can also see that the number of photons arriving within an opening angle @xmath4 reaches the dependence @xmath159 only at later times . this reflects the fact that the initial angular distribution of light is steep and becomes almost flat at times @xmath160 or so . when comparing the rayleigh curves with the isotropic ones one can see that the latter are slightly flatter for shorter times , as might be expected but become parallel to the former for later times . + next , we consider a situation when there are two scattering processes , rayleigh and mie with quite different angular distributions @xmath161 ( as discussed before ) . we adopt @xmath162 and @xmath163 for simplicity . + the result for the first and the second generation depending on time is shown in fig . 3b . there is now more light at earlier times than in the previous case ( fig . 3a ) due to the strong mie scattering in the forward directions . however , the flux of the first generation decreases about 3 times quicker over the considered time region . although the ratio of the second to the first generation is practically the same at @xmath164 in both cases @xmath165 . the importance of the second one is reached at later times when the mie scattering is present . , shown by numbers , looking from the detector ( at @xmath166 , @xmath167 ) to a point on the line , for @xmath168 and @xmath169 at the ground and the scale heights @xmath170 and @xmath171.,height=326 ] now we shall study the situation when a point light source flashes in a non - uniform medium , such as the atmosphere . we assume that the atmosphere is composed of two sorts of matter , molecules and aerosols , each having its density decreasing with height exponentially with a different scale heights , @xmath172 - for molecules and @xmath173 for aerosols , and having the corresponding mean path lengths for scattering at the ground @xmath174 and @xmath175 . it is not difficult to derive that the effective mean free path for a scattering for light travelling between two arbitrary points @xmath176 and @xmath177 equals @xmath178 where @xmath179 and @xmath180 are the heights of points @xmath176 and @xmath177 above the level , where the rayleigh and mie scattering path lengths are correspondingly @xmath174 and @xmath175 . if the source ( point @xmath176 ) is at a distance @xmath6 from the detector ( point @xmath181 on the ground ) then the ratio @xmath158 , of @xmath6 to the mean free path length along @xmath182 equals @xmath183 \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be seen that increasing the distance @xmath6 to infinity ( keeping @xmath184 constant ) the ratio @xmath158 reaches its maximum finite value @xmath185 this situation is illustrated in fig . a vertical cross - section of the atmosphere is shown . detector is at @xmath186 and lines represent constant values of @xmath158 corresponding to the straight path from the detector to the point on the line . we have adopted the following values : @xmath187 , @xmath188 and @xmath189 . these values describe approximately the atmospheric conditions at the pierre auger observatory @xcite . + from fig . 4 one can also deduce that relevant values of @xmath158 , if light sources are at distances @xmath190 ( as extensive air showers seen by auger ) are @xmath191 . thus , this will be the region of our interest . , detector at @xmath181 . scattering takes place at @xmath177.,width=288 ] after time @xmath192 . the corresponding numbers are equal to @xmath193 . light source is at @xmath176 , detector at @xmath181 . , width=288 ] as the medium is non - uniform , we can not use the idea of a sphere to be crossed by the scattered photons , as in section 2 . now their flux will depend on the zenith angle @xmath184 of the source and on the azimuth angle @xmath110 around the direction towards it . 5 shows a trajectory @xmath194 of a first generation photon scattered at @xmath177 . we want to calculate the angular distribution of the first generation as a function of time , for a fixed @xmath6 and @xmath184 , @xmath195 , crossing a unit area perpendicular to the direction towards the source . + we notice that for a fixed arrival direction of photons @xmath196 and time @xmath87 , the scattering point @xmath177 is uniquely determined . to arrive at the detector at angles @xmath197 within @xmath198 after time @xmath13 , photons have to cross the surface @xmath199 ( shaded in the figure ) and be scattered along a path length @xmath142 by the angle @xmath19 determined by eq.2 . the number of such photons equals @xmath200 where @xmath201 , @xmath202 , @xmath203 is the angle between the normal to the surface @xmath199 and the direction of the incident photons @xmath204 , @xmath205 is the solid angle determined by the unit area at @xmath181 and the scattering point @xmath177 ( @xmath206 ) . there is no need to calculate @xmath203 because @xmath207 , so that it cancels out . it can be shown that @xmath208 inserting this into ( 40 ) we obtain @xmath209 one can see that this formula is practically the same as ( 7 ) for the uniform medium , the only difference being in the scattering path lengths depending not only on distances but also on the geometry . + the height of the scattering point @xmath177 necessary to calculate @xmath210 and @xmath211 equals : @xmath212 we calculate numerically the time distributions of light @xmath213 , arriving at the detector at angles smaller than @xmath4 for different zenith angles of the source . the results , in the form of the ratio : @xmath214 are presented in figs . 7 , 8 and 9 , where @xmath215 are the distributions obtained in the previous section for a uniform medium . + in real atmosphere to that in uniform medium @xmath215 as a function of time ( @xmath216 ) for the rayleigh scattering only for various values of zenith angle of the source . solid lines - @xmath217 , dashed lines - @xmath218 , @xmath219.,height=288 ] . , height=288 ] . each group of lines is for @xmath220 , and @xmath221 from bottom to top ( at @xmath164 ) . , height=288 ] to compare the light flux obtained for the real atmosphere with that for a uniform medium we adopt the same value of @xmath158 and the same distance from the source to detector for both cases . to understand the effect of a purely exponential atmosphere we start with considering only the rayleigh scattering ( fig . 7 ) , neglecting mie ( @xmath222 ) . understanding the behaviour of the curves in this figure is easier with the help of fig . 6 . each ellipse is a cross - section of a rotational ellipsoid with the symmetry axis determined by point @xmath181 - the detector and point @xmath176 - the light source . these are the focal points of all the ellipses . photons arriving at the detector at @xmath181 after some fixed time @xmath223 ( in units of the distance pd ) must have been scattered on the surface of an ellipsoid with the eccentricity @xmath224 equal @xmath225 the ellipses refer to @xmath226 and @xmath227 keeping the right proportions . the detector field of view cuts only a part of the ellipsoid surface where the photons registered after time @xmath228 must have been scattered . we notice that all ratios @xmath229 in fig . 7 are smaller than 1 and decrease with time ( although those for @xmath217 are practically constant ) and ratios for @xmath218 are larger than those for @xmath217 . all this becomes clear when inspecting fig . 6 and the corresponding scattering sites . for example - the constancy of @xmath230 ) for times @xmath231 reflects the fact that the scattering takes place very close to point @xmath176 during all this time and starts to move away from it ( higher in the atmosphere ) only for larger times i.e @xmath232 . since the scattering path length in the uniform medium is chosen equal to the effective path length in the atmosphere @xmath233 ( eq . 36 ) , we have that @xmath234 and the scattering probability at @xmath176 is smaller in the exponential atmosphere . + let us consider now a more realistic atmosphere with both processes , rayleigh and mie at work . fig . 8 shows time dependence of the ratio @xmath235 for @xmath217 and @xmath236 and zenith angles let us take a closer look at the case @xmath217 and @xmath238 ( upper solid curve ) . it may seem strange that the ratio @xmath229 increases since in the case of the rayleigh scattering only it decreases , although very slowly . we have checked that a similar slow decrease takes place if the scattering is only mie . the behaviour of the curves in this figure would be hard to understand without the presentation of the scattering sites in fig . it can be seen that for @xmath193 smaller than a few @xmath239 the scattering sites are close to the source at @xmath176 . thus , we may approximate the ratio @xmath229 as follows @xmath240 where @xmath241 are some effective angular distributions of photons scattered by rayleigh ( mie ) on the cut surface . as time increases , none of the @xmath242 changes much . however , the typical scattering angles increase , what affects much more @xmath243 than @xmath244 , so that @xmath245 decreases . since @xmath246 the numerator decreases by a smaller factor than the denominator so that the ratio @xmath229 increases . it can be seen from fig . 6 that for @xmath247 the scattering angles of the registered photons do not change much ( the denominator stays constant ) but now @xmath248 and @xmath249 have to be substituted by @xmath250 and @xmath251 , where @xmath177 is an effective scattering point with growing height . as @xmath252 , the ratio @xmath253 decreases and so does @xmath229 . + a different behaviour of @xmath254 can be explained also with the help of fig . at first @xmath229 decreases ( the smaller @xmath184 - the stronger decrease ) because the detector field of view cuts out a growing part of the deep atmosphere where the scattering is strong in the real atmosphere . at @xmath255 @xmath229 starts to increase for the same reason as just described in the case @xmath217 . it must finally decrease since the scattering takes places further and further behind the source , where @xmath256 and @xmath257 are growing in the real atmosphere . 9 we show @xmath258 for @xmath259 for several intermediate values of @xmath4 , and for two values @xmath260 and @xmath261 . note that changing @xmath262 must result in changing @xmath6 - the distance to the source . this is the main reason why the curves for @xmath263 are lower than those for @xmath260 . it can be seen from fig . 5 that for @xmath259 ( the scales on both axes are the same so in the figure the angles are correctly represented ) the distance @xmath6 is much shorter for @xmath260 than for @xmath263 , implying that the corresponding heights of the source differ considerably . inspecting fig . 6 we can estimate that for @xmath264 and @xmath217 the curves for @xmath263 should be down with respect to those for @xmath260 by a factor @xmath265 where @xmath266 and @xmath267 are positions of the source referring to @xmath260 and 1 respectively , with the meaning of all @xmath242 as defined before . in our example @xmath268 , @xmath269 , @xmath270 , @xmath271 so that the above factor equals @xmath272 whereas the exact ratio from fig . 9 @xmath273 . to the first generation @xmath274 as a function of time ( @xmath216 ) from a flash ( at @xmath97 ) of a point source at zenith angle @xmath238 in the real atmosphere . fluxes are integrated within @xmath217 ( solid lines ) and @xmath218 ( dashed lines ) . three curves for each @xmath4 refer to @xmath275 ( from bottom to top ) . dotted line refers to a uniform medium with rayleigh scattering only , for @xmath263 , @xmath217.,height=288 ] we proceed like in the case of the first generation ( fig . 5 ) , but now point @xmath177 refers to the second scattering . photons scattered only once arrive at the surface @xmath199 from all directions according to @xmath276 , where @xmath277 . thus , the number of photons @xmath278 incident on @xmath199 and scattered for the second time towards the detector ( to arrive there within @xmath279 after time @xmath13 equals @xmath280 where the integration has to be done over full solid angle @xmath281 , @xmath282 is the path length for the second scattering to occur ( @xmath283 ) and @xmath284 is the angle of the second scattering . now the pair of variables , @xmath36 and @xmath87 , does not determine uniquely the positions of the second scattering , since the times @xmath285 elapsed from photon emission to their arrival at @xmath177 ( or strictly speaking , at @xmath199 ) have some distribution . however , @xmath285 can not be smaller than @xmath286 , thus @xmath287 . expressing @xmath288 as a function of @xmath36 , @xmath87 and @xmath6 only we obtain @xmath289 and the distribution of the second generation equals @xmath290 finally , the number of photons within an angle @xmath4 equals @xmath291 the above integrals have been calculated numerically . + the ratio @xmath292 as a function of @xmath293 in the real atmosphere , where the source is at @xmath259 at the distance @xmath294 corresponding to @xmath263 , within two opening angles of the detector @xmath217 and @xmath295 , is presented in fig . 10 . for comparison we have also drawn there the same ratio for the uniform medium , for @xmath263 with rayleigh scattering active only ( following from fig . 3a for @xmath217 ) . first we see that the contribution of the second generation increases with time as it should be expected . next , it is considerably larger for the uniform medium than for the real atmosphere , which may not be so obvious at first sight . in fact , at @xmath296 the curve for the uniform medium is @xmath297 times higher than that for the real atmosphere . this factor equals ( for simplicity we neglect the operators @xmath298 ) @xmath299 the numerator @xmath300 as explained in the previous paragraph . the denominator refers to photons scattered exactly two times . for small @xmath193 the scatterings must take place close to the source or along the field of view ( @xmath217 in our example ) . thus we should have that @xmath301 our calculations show that @xmath302 for @xmath303 few @xmath239 so that @xmath304 , in agreement with the exact calculations . so far we have been interested in the light signals from a flash of a stationary point source in a detector at a given distance , within a given field of view , as a function of time . + now , we shall consider a moving point emitting light on its way through the atmosphere . this is a reasonable model of a distant cosmic ray shower exciting atmosphere what results in emitting isotropic fluorescence light . moreover , the cherenkov light produced by @xmath305 of shower electrons @xcite , propagating alongside the particles will be scattered to the sides by the rayleigh and mie processes in an anisotropic way . thus , in principle , a shower is a moving source , emitting light anisotropically . our aim is to find an instantaneous optical image of the shower , produced by the scattered light at _ the same time _ as the shower image in the direct ( not scattered ) light . + the image obtained for a small integration time @xmath5 is a radially symmetric light spot , corresponding ( roughly ) to the emission distribution at the shower lateral cross - section @xcite . it is produced mainly by the direct light . but at the same time as the direct light , there arrive also photons produced by shower particles at an earlier stage of shower evolution and scattered in the atmosphere . as shower parameters follow straightforwardly from the amount of the direct light , it is important to calculate this effect and to take it into account when deriving the flux of the direct light . + let us assume that we know the geometry and the timing of the shower . if the source is at point @xmath306 at time @xmath87 and emits @xmath307 photons per unit length , the telescope will record the following number of the direct photons at time @xmath308 , in the time bin @xmath5 : @xmath309 where @xmath310 is the angle between the shower direction and the direction from point @xmath306 to the detector @xmath181 , @xmath311 is the effective mean free path for attenuation along the distance @xmath6 , @xmath91 is the diaphragm area determining the collection solid angle and @xmath312 is the angular distribution of the emitted light . + in the case of isotropic fluorescence light @xmath313 and @xmath307 equals to the number of photons produced per unit length ( @xmath314 , per one electron ) . in the case of the scattered cherenkov photons , or those from a laser , @xmath315 for the rayleigh scattering ( or a corresponding distribution for mie ) and @xmath316 , where @xmath317 is the mean free path ( in length units ) for the process in consideration at point @xmath306 and @xmath318 is the number of cherenkov photons at the observed shower level propagating ( approximately ) in the direction of the shower . the number of the scattered cherenkov photons to the fluorescence ones is typically @xmath319 , and a lot of the former are scattered by rayleigh , what is not far from isotropic . thus , with a good approximation one can treat a shower as a moving isotropic light source . this is what has been adopted in this paper : @xmath320 . + simultaneously with the direct light some photons produced earlier ( above point @xmath306 ) will also arrive at the telescope . however , as we already mentioned , they must have been scattered on their way to the telescope . our earlier calculations @xcite showed that if the distance to the shower is not very much longer than the mean scattering path , then the main contribution to the scattered light is due to the photons scattered only once ( the first generation ) . here , we will calculate the fraction of the total light consisting of the first and the second generations . let us consider photons produced at point @xmath176 , along a shower path element @xmath282 ( fig . the first generation photons arriving at the detector @xmath181 at the same time as the direct photons produced at @xmath306 must have been scattered on the surface of the rotational ellipsoid with the focal points at @xmath181 and @xmath176 , with the @xmath321 line being the rotational symmetry axis of the ellipsoid . + as we have already mentioned , the main interest of the shower experiments is to measure the direct light . thus , we are interested in the light arriving from the direction of point @xmath306 and the region around it . in practice ( as it is in the pierre augere experiment ) the light signal arriving simultaneously with the direct light from point @xmath306 is measured within a certain angle @xmath4 around the line @xmath322 . the cone with the opening angle @xmath4 cuts out on the surface of the ellipsoid a region of our interest ( the shaded surface ) . it is at this part of the ellipsoid that the photons produced at @xmath176 have to be scattered to arrive simultaneously with the direct light produced at @xmath306 , within an angle smaller than @xmath4 with respect to the latter . thus , to find the contribution of the first generation to the direct light one has to integrate the number of the scattered photons over the cutout surface , and then integrate the result over the distance @xmath323 ( the upper part of the shower ) . + , scattered once and arriving at detector @xmath181 within its field of view simultaneously with direct photons produced at @xmath306 . @xmath324.,height=288 ] and scattered on the shaded surface ( inside field of view of detector @xmath181 ) of the ellipsoid arrives at @xmath181 simultaneously with the direct light produced at @xmath306 . , width=288 ] the proportions in fig . 11 have not been preserved . for example the actual distance from point @xmath176 to the detector at @xmath181 is much longer than @xmath325 ( although in principle the integration over @xmath326 should go far up the shower , the distances contributing to the total scattered light are rather close to point @xmath306 ) . also the angle @xmath4 does not need to be larger than a few degrees , but on the figure it is much larger for the sake of clarity . + let us first find the contribution to the first generation from photons produced by the shower at point @xmath176 along a path length element @xmath282 , assuming that @xmath176 lies outside the detector field of view . [ [ a - theta_pzeta - fig.-11 ] ] _ a ) _ @xmath327 _ ( fig . 11 ) _ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + @xmath328\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath329 , @xmath330 , @xmath331 , @xmath36 is the arrival angle ( with respect to the direction to the source at @xmath176 ) , and @xmath332 . + the azimuth angle @xmath110 is measured in the plane perpendicular to the axis @xmath182 and @xmath333 refer to points on the shower - detector plane ( fig . 11 plane ) . the length @xmath334 can be found from the triangle @xmath335 : @xmath336 and @xmath337 . [ [ b - theta_pzeta ] ] _ b ) _ @xmath338 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( fig . + it is clear from the figure that now the integration limits of @xmath36 and @xmath110 are different so that one has to add to the integral in case a ) the following term @xmath339\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the lower limit of @xmath36 in the term a ) changes sign , so that @xmath340 . to find the total flux of the first generation arriving at the same time as the direct light from point @xmath306 one has to integrate over @xmath326 the contribution from case b ) from 0 to @xmath341 , ( where @xmath342 ) , and add to it the contribution from a ) integrated from @xmath343 to @xmath344 . ( it turns out that contribution from points with @xmath345 are negligible ) . + if there are two scattering processes the first generation means the sum of the number of photons scattered by rayleigh and those by mie and then @xmath346 , and in the attenuation exponent @xmath347 and @xmath348 are the effective mean free paths for both processes . by making some approximations we have found an analytical solution of the shower image in the first generation light scattered by the rayleigh process . + we shall treat separately light produced within the detector field of view @xmath350 and that outside it , @xmath351 , starting with the former ( fig . as the scattering points lie close to point @xmath306 we assume that @xmath352 . for the same reason we assume that the exponential factor describing light attenuation equals @xmath353 . our main assumption , however , consists in integrating over the symmetric ( with respect to axis @xmath182 ) part of the ellipsoid so that we could solve the integrals over @xmath354 and finally @xmath326 . expressing scattering angle @xmath19 as a function of @xmath36 and @xmath355 ( eq . 2 ) we obtain that the contribution from a shower path element @xmath282 equals @xmath356 where @xmath357 , @xmath358 . + we adopt @xmath359 being the mean of the limiting values of @xmath36 in the exact integration . + in the air shower experiments it is the direct light which should be measured so that the viewing angle @xmath4 is small ( a few degrees ) and so are angles @xmath36 . this leads to @xmath360 . taking all this into account the result of the integration over @xmath36 is @xmath361\frac{dl}{r'^2}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath362 . from geometrical considerations it can be derived that @xmath363d\tau'\simeq } \\ & & \simeq\frac{d\tau'}{r(1-cos\delta ) } = \frac{\zeta dx}{r(1-cos\delta ) } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have dropped the second term @xmath364 . + to obtain @xmath365 it remains to integrate ( 59 ) over @xmath366 ( including ( 60 ) from @xmath367 to @xmath368 , corresponding to point @xmath176 lying on the edge of the viewing cone ( @xmath369 ) . again , assuming that @xmath370 , it can be derived that @xmath371 ( for @xmath372 ) . the result of the integration is the following @xmath373 where @xmath374 . + must be scattered for the second time ( point @xmath375 ) within detector @xmath181 field of view . first scattering ( @xmath267 ) must occur on the surface of the ellipsoid with focal points at @xmath176 and @xmath375 . direct light from @xmath306 arrives at @xmath181 at the same time : @xmath376.,height=288 ] to calculate the contribution from the outer part of the shower i.e. outside the field of view we keep the previous approximate assumptions . however , since now the scattering surface looks differently ( fig . 11 ) we make another simplifications . we assume that all scattering angles equal @xmath310 so that @xmath377 . next , as @xmath4 is small we assume that all @xmath378 . integration over @xmath379 , the solid angle of the field of view , is then reduced to multiplying the integrand for @xmath378 by @xmath380 . thus we have @xmath381 it can be derived that the denominator in the above expression equals @xmath382 assuming needs to allow for light attenuation along @xmath326 in the integration over @xmath326 . the correction to @xmath383 is a few percent , being negligible for the total @xmath384 . ] that @xmath385 , we obtain @xmath386 since @xmath387 we have @xmath388 and @xmath389 expressing the number of photons @xmath390 as the ratio to that of the direct light ( eq . 54 for @xmath391 ) we finally obtain @xmath392\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath374 ( in radians ) . terms @xmath393 and of higher order have been neglected . we can see that , with the approximations adopted , the ratio @xmath394 is proportional to @xmath395 reflecting the fact ( as we shall see below ) that most scatterings take place close to point @xmath306 since @xmath396 is proportional to the shower path segment seen by the detector . for @xmath397 and the dependence on @xmath310 separates from that on other parameters . it becomes also obvious that it must be different for different angular distributions @xmath161 , of photons at scattering . as @xmath398 is quite different from @xmath399 which is peaked in forward directions , we expect another dependence on @xmath310 for the latter . + while deriving the analytical formula ( 66 ) we have also assumed that the length of the shower segment cut out by the detector field of view is small when compared to the distance @xmath6 . for @xmath370 it is fulfilled for almost all @xmath310 , apart from the case when @xmath310 is close to 0 or @xmath400 . we have calculated analytically the ratio @xmath394 for @xmath401 for @xmath402 . however , as the derivation is lengthy and ( as it will be seen later ) agrees with the exact , numerical results only at @xmath403 , we present here only the final result : @xmath404 these values are marked as stars ( for @xmath403 ) in fig . + we have not tried to calculate @xmath405 because the function @xmath399 is not well known , depending on the sizes of the aerosol particles and , anyway , our analytical approach is approximate . thus , it seems better to calculate it exactly numerically and , being led by our analytical solutions for rayleigh , find an appropriate parametrisation of the numerical results . the ratio of the first generation to the direct light arriving simultaneously is obtained by numerical integration of point contributions over @xmath326 ( shower track above point @xmath306 ) and dividing the result by @xmath408 . 14 shows the ratio for the rayleigh a ) and mie b ) scattering as a function of @xmath409 for @xmath410 and @xmath411 and for several different distances @xmath6 . it can be seen that for the rayleigh case the ratio is proportional to @xmath412 and @xmath4 , as it has been derived analytically . for mie the dependence follows a power law , with the indices depending slightly on @xmath4 . however , in each case there is practically no dependence on the distance @xmath6 itself . these results are for @xmath413 . + the dependence on @xmath310 is shown in fig . 15a , b for @xmath414 1 and @xmath415 and @xmath411 . one can see the difference of the behaviour of this dependence between rayleigh and mie . in the figure a comparison of our analytical calculations with the exact ones is also shown . the biggest difference reaches some @xmath416 at large @xmath310 . there is no normalisation there . we find this agreement quite satisfactory . + nevertheless , as the agreement is not perfect we have parametrised the exact numerical results . for the rayleigh scattering the ratio @xmath417 can be expressed as @xmath418 where @xmath419 , @xmath4 is in degrees , and @xmath420 for mie the factorisation is not as complete as for rayleigh , and our fit to the numerical results is the following : @xmath421 @xmath422 these fits are also shown in fig . 14 and 15 . it is seen that they do not deviate from the exact values by more than a few percent . + the second generation has been calculated numerically . 13 should be helpful for understanding the calculation . the thin solid line shows a path of a photon produced at @xmath176 , scattered at points @xmath267 and @xmath375 and arriving at @xmath181 . the point @xmath375 of the second scattering must lie somewhere inside the viewing cone . fixing it at a distance @xmath423 from the detector corresponds to fixing the value of the remaining photon path length @xmath424 . we have that @xmath425 where @xmath426 and @xmath427 . + in order to assure that the photons scattered twice arrive at @xmath181 at the same time as the direct light emitted at @xmath306 , point @xmath267 must lie anywhere on the surface of the ellipsoid with focal points at @xmath176 and @xmath375 . thus , to calculate the number of photons produced at @xmath176 and scattered twice one has to integrate the contributions like in ( 49 ) over the position of the first scattering ( the whole surface of the ellipsoid ) and then integrate the result over the volume of the viewing cone . finally , the integration has to be performed over the distance @xmath428 . + the ratio @xmath407 , including rayleigh and mie scatterings as a function of @xmath429 for @xmath430 and as a function of @xmath310 for @xmath431 is presented in fig various point signs refer to different distances @xmath6 . as in the case of the first generation the ratios depend on @xmath432 rather than @xmath6 itself . however , now they are proportional to the second power of it . we have parametrise the obtained numerical results as follows @xmath433 as we see the numbers of the scattered photons , @xmath435 and @xmath436 , depend on the angle @xmath4 within which they arrive at the detector . this angle has to be chosen in such a way as to encompass the total direct signal from the shower . it is obvious that for closer showers @xmath4 has to be larger and for those more distant - smaller , so that @xmath396 - meaning the lateral spread of the direct light - should remain constant . our approximations show that in this case ( @xmath437 ) @xmath438 depends only on height ( by @xmath317 ) and @xmath310 . the power indices in the dependence of @xmath406 on @xmath6 and @xmath4 are close to @xmath261 , whereas @xmath439 ( roughly ) , so that their dependence on the distance @xmath6 itself should be weak . 17 presents the contributions of the individual components of the scattered light as a function of height , for @xmath440 , @xmath430 and two ( quite different ) values of @xmath6 : 12 and 36 @xmath441 . the dependence of the sum @xmath434 on @xmath6 is very weak , indeed , the more so as the ratios @xmath442 and @xmath407 change in opposite directions . the chosen value @xmath443 corresponds to a shower lateral radius of @xmath444 , equal to @xmath445 ( molire radii ) . this may seem too large to contain the total fluorescence signal . however , deep in the atmosphere it is the shower cherenkov light what determines its lateral dimensions and it goes up to @xmath446 @xcite . + as the typical viewing angles @xmath310 are not far from @xmath447 one can draw a conclusion that the maximum contribution of the ms light is @xmath448 for @xmath449 and the adopted atmospheric parameters . , dashed lines @xmath452 . curves denoted by `` rayleigh '' and `` mie '' refer to the first generation , by `` n2 '' - to the second one . if a constant lateral dimension is chosen ( @xmath453 , @xmath430 ) the ratios do not ( practically ) depend on shower distance @xmath6 . , height=288 ] let us estimate how not allowing for the ms effect would affect a reconstructed value of a shower primary energy @xmath450 . the total signal would then be treated as the direct light , therefore the primary energy would be overestimated . to estimate how much it would be let us consider a typical ( for auger ) shower with @xmath454 ev , falling to the ground 25@xmath441 away from the light detector , at @xmath455 and azimuthal angle @xmath456 ( angle between the direction from the detector to the shower core and the projection of the shower axis on the ground ) . if the primary is a proton the mean depth of its maximum equals @xmath457 , corresponding to the height above auger level ( @xmath458 ) @xmath459 . from fig . 17 we see that the contribution of the scattered light is @xmath460 if @xmath443 , what corresponds to @xmath461 . however , in the auger telescopes the individual pixel has a diameter of @xmath462 , so that it would be necessary to choose also the neighbouring pixels around the one with the stronger signal to collect the total direct light . thus , we choose @xmath463 . within this angle the ms light grows to @xmath464 , overestimating the number of particles at @xmath451 by this value . for shower parts near the ground , where shower age equals 1.25 , this number grows to @xmath465 . to find the shower primary energy @xmath450 ( by integrating the energy deposit over depth @xmath466 ) it is necessary to extrapolate the shower for larger ages , so that the overestimation from these parts would be even larger . we estimate that not allowing for the ms effect would increase the reconstructed @xmath450 by @xmath0 . + not allowing for the ms light would also lead to an overestimation of the depth of the shower maximum @xmath451 . fitting a new cascade curve to that from the previous example with the increased values according to the ms contribution , we obtain that the overestimation equals @xmath467 . with the difference between the depths of an average proton and iron showers being @xmath468 , this is not a negligible number for drawing conclusions about the mass composition of the highest energy cosmic rays . at first sight it may seem odd that it is only the first two generations that contribute to the scattered light . one might expect that the main contribution should come from the generation with the number closest to the value @xmath469 , according to the poisson distribution ( although we have shown that the first two generations scale with @xmath470 rather than with @xmath469 ) . for @xmath471 and @xmath472 and a shower close to the ground we have @xmath473 . thus , if the distance @xmath474 then @xmath475 , so should one expect the third and the fourth generations to contribute even more than the first one ? the answer is no , since the scattered photons should fall into the detector field of view , so that it is not the path length of a scattering _ by any angle _ ( what @xmath311 means ) that counts but by some _ particular values _ of it . this decreases the probability of such a scattering and can be viewed as an increase of the ( actually ) effective mean free path length @xmath476 for the process _ we are interested in _ ( i.e. photons arriving at the detector ) . one could estimate its value from the ratio @xmath477 or @xmath478 adopting for this aim a poisson distribution of the number of contributing generations . the two obtained values differ typically by 30 - 60@xmath479 , so that an estimation of the share of the remaining generations on the basis of this uncertain @xmath476 is uncertain as well . however , let us take an example : @xmath480 , elevation angle @xmath481 , @xmath482 , what are typical conditions for registered showers in the auger observatory . the two values of the mean number of ( effective ) scatterings are @xmath483 ( from @xmath477 ) and @xmath484 ( from @xmath478 ) . assuming the larger one , one gets @xmath485 for a fraction of the third and higher generations . + however , as our earlier work for a uniform medium @xciteb ) shows , where the third generation was calculated , its share was two times smaller than that deduced from the poisson model and the ratios @xmath477 and @xmath478 , so that this estimation may be too high . thus , we estimate that the contribution of the higher number generations should be small , at least for the conditions of auger . integrated within angle @xmath4 , for shower 24 @xmath441 away from the detector , at elevation angle @xmath221 . our results ( first and second generation ) are represented by thick solid lines for @xmath486 and thin solid lines - for @xmath487 and @xmath488 ( second generation ) . parametrisation from monte - carlo works : roberts - dashed line and pkala et al - dotted line.,height=288 ] the problem of the influence of the scattered light on the shower image in the direct light was first undertaken by roberts @xcite . he treated it by monte - carlo simulations of tracks of individual photons emitted by vertical showers . such shower ( although , strictly speaking , non - existing ) enabled the author to introduce a detector in a form of a ring around the shower as its symmetry axis , increasing dramatically the number of registered photons . although the author appreciate that the singly scattered photons dominated the total ms signal , his simulations went to more than five scatters , including both rayleigh and mie . he obtained a parametrisation of the ratio of the ms signal to the total signal ( ms + direct ) in the form @xmath489 where @xmath490 is the total optical depth ( molecular and aerosol ) between the detector and the light source , @xmath19 - total scattering coefficient ( in @xmath491 ) at the source . in our terms @xmath492 , @xmath493 , where @xmath311 is determined by formula ( 36 ) and @xmath317 depends only on the height in the stable atmosphere , so that ( 74 ) would mean the following @xmath494 this parametrisation differs from those obtained in the present work although not very much . it has a weaker dependence on the angle @xmath4 , which in our case is as ( about ) @xmath495 . the smaller power index at @xmath496 ( @xmath497 in our case ) is to some extent compensated by the term @xmath498 . + another work , dealing with the present problem was that of pkala et al @xcite . the calculation method was monte - carlo as well . this paper did consider inclined showers so that the cylindrical symmetry , as in the previous case did not apply . instead large `` packages '' of photons were assumed to behave in the same way , according to simulated points and directions of their scattering . after extensive simulations the authors arrived at a parametrisation of the ratio @xmath133 of the ms signal to the direct one as follows @xmath499 with @xmath500 . for a one component exponential atmosphere with the scale height @xmath501 we would have @xmath502 indeed , it is not difficult to check that an effective scale height of the two - component atmosphere used by the authors for @xmath503 is about @xmath504 what approximately equals @xmath501 . thus , their parametrisation would be as @xmath505 it is not far from our derivation for the first generation , where the term @xmath506 does not appear . a comparison of the ratio of the total ms signal to the direct one as a function of @xmath4 , obtained in this study with that of roberts and pkala et al is presented in fig . the agreement is quite good for @xmath507 but for larger @xmath4 the other authors seem to have underestimated a little the effect . previous studies of the influence of the scattering of photons on their way from the shower to the detector on the shower image used monte - carlo simulations . the effect has been called `` the multiple scattering '' since it was not clear how many times the photons arriving simultaneously with the direct light actually scatter . although roberts @xcite appreciated the importance of photons scattered one time only he went on with simulating till several scatterings . + the main idea of this study was to divide the scattered light into separate generations : the first generation being photons scattered exactly one time , the second one two times , and so on . this enabled us to find analytically the angular distributions of photons as a function of time for the first generation which turned out to be the most important one . we also showed that any next generation can be found by some numerical integrations of the previous one . these results were obtained for a point source in a uniform medium as well as in the actual atmosphere ( although more numerical integrations were needed in the latter case ) . by considering separately the first generation it was easy to understand the differences between the two cases . the ratio of the second to the first generation is very small for small times after the light emission which will turn out to be relevant when considering the scattered light from extensive air showers what is a final aim of this study . + in particular , this aim was to calculate the angular distributions of scattered photons arriving simultaneously with the direct ( not scattered ) light emitted by an extensive air shower and find relevant parameters determining these distributions . the solutions for a point source were useful here since a shower could be treated as a series of consecutive ( in space and time ) point sources . for the first and the second generations ( the most important ) we have explained where actually the scattering points took place , so that we were able to integrate over all of them . + we have derived an analytical expression ( although approximate ) for the angular distribution of the first generation photons , scattered by the rayleigh process , fitting quite well the exact numerical distributions . the analytical solutions have led us to a proper choice of the independent variables for a final parametrisation of the numerical results . for example the number of photons in the n - th generation turns out to be proportional to @xmath508 , at least for @xmath509 ( although for mie with some correction ) . knowing the positions of the scatterings we were able to show that there should be a dependence on the viewing angle @xmath310 , not taken into account in the considerations of the previous authors . moreover , this dependence should be different for the rayleigh and the mie scatterings . thus , we parametrised the first generation separately for these two processes . concerning the second generation we combined all four possibilities of the two scatterings ( rr , rm , mr and mm ) to give just one parametrisation since its contribution was rather small . + from our parametrisation it follows that for @xmath510 ( corresponding to a constant observed lateral dimension of a shower ) the contribution of the ms component to the direct light depends practically only on the height of the observed shower element and on the viewing angle ( the latter dependence being rather mild ) . a typical overestimation of the primary shower energy ( if the ms effect was ignored ) would be @xmath0 and of the depth of shower maximum @xmath467 . our analytical and numerical approach gives similar results as the previous monte - carlo work of other authors , although the parametrisation obtained in this paper is different . only for larger opening angles @xmath511 the prediction of the ms contribution obtained here is a bit larger , what would have some implications for a reconstruction of very close showers . + summarising we conclude that the ms effect is not to be neglected while reconstructing parameters of the extensive air showers . to be properly allowed for a good knowledge of the atmospheric conditions is necessary @xcite for determining values of @xmath317 , as the shower traverses the atmosphere . + [ [ acknowledgements ] ] acknowledgements + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this work has been financially supported by polish ministry of science and higher education , grant no n n202 200239 . it was stimulated by our participation in the pierre auger collaboration . we thank the collaboration for fruitful discussions . 00 t. abu - zayyad et . al , astroparticle physics 12 ( 1999 ) 121 - 134 the pierre auger collaboration : j. abraham et al , nucl . instrum . meth . a 620 ( 2010 ) 227 - 251 t. nonaka et al , nuclear physics b proc . suppl . 190 ( 2009 ) 26 - 31 the macfly collaboration : p. colin et al , astroparticle physics 30 ( 2009 ) 312 - 317 m. giller et al , j. phys . ( 2004 ) 97 - 105 m. giller et al , j. phys . g : nucl . part . ( 2005 ) 947 - 958 f. nerling at al , astroparticle physics 24 ( 2006 ) 421 m. giller and g. wieczorek , astroparticle physics 31 ( 2009 ) 212 - 219 m. d. roberts , j. phys . g : nucl . part . ( 2005 ) 1291 - 1301 a ) m. giller and a. miakowski , ( 2005 ) proceedings of the 29th int . cosmic ray conference , pune , india + b ) m. giller and a. miakowski , ( 2007 ) proceedings of the 30th int . cosmic ray conference , merida , mexico + c ) m. giller and a. miakowski , ( 2011 ) proceedings of the 32nd int . cosmic ray conference , beijing , china j. pkala et al , nucl . a605 ( 2009 ) 388 - 398 p. sommers , astroparticle physics 3 ( 1995 ) 349 - 360 the pierre auger collaboration : j. abraham et al , astroparticle physics 33 ( 2010 ) 108 - 129 it may be of some value to know how much the fluxes @xmath512 for the rayleigh scattering differ from those when the scattering function @xmath513 , so when the scattering is isotropic . to calculate it we proceed as in section 2 putting @xmath514 in eq . we obtain @xmath515 and @xmath516 \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second generation can be obtained by proceeding as in section 2.2 , giving the result @xmath517 where @xmath518 ; @xmath519 and @xmath520 . to find @xmath521 one must integrate the flux over @xmath36 numerically . how does the ratio of the two generations depend on the distance ? we can represent the first generation ( a.2 ) in the form @xmath522 where @xmath523 depends on @xmath87 and @xmath4 only . + the flux of the second generation equals @xmath524 where @xmath525 , @xmath526 , @xmath527 . + we see that the integral depends on @xmath37 and @xmath36 only so that @xmath528 thus @xmath529 so that for a given time the ratio is proportional to the distance @xmath6 measured in units of @xmath22 . it can be verified that this relation holds for any scattering process in a uniform medium , not only for isotropy . the formula for the angular distribution of the first generation integrated over time , can be rewritten in the following form @xmath531f(\beta+\theta)d\beta \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath532 is the angular distribution of the scattering angle @xmath19 , normalised to @xmath261 when integrated over the full solid angle . + for the rayleigh scattering we obtain @xmath533\big[1+cos^2(\beta+\theta)\big ] d\beta \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] to find the above integral for @xmath60 we divide the integration region into two parts : @xmath534= } \nonumber \\ & & = c(i_1+i_2)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath535 . + choosing @xmath536 it will be possible to find analytically the integrals @xmath537 and @xmath538 . each of them is a sum of the two integrals : @xmath539d\beta+ \\ \displaystyle + \int_{\beta_{i1}}^{\beta_{i2 } } exp\big[-k\frac{sin\beta+sin\theta}{sin(\beta+\theta)}\big]cos^2(\beta+\theta)d\beta=\\ \displaystyle = i_{i1}+i_{i2 } \end{array}\ ] ] for @xmath540 and @xmath541 , @xmath542 , @xmath543 . + using @xmath60 we have @xmath544d\beta\simeq \nonumber \\ & \simeq & \int_0^{\pi-\theta-\epsilon } exp\big[-k(1+\frac{\theta}{sin\beta}-\theta\ , ctg\beta)\big]d\beta = \nonumber \\ & = & e^{-k}\int_0^{\pi-\theta-\epsilon } exp\big(-k\,\theta \,tg\frac{\beta}{2}\big)d\beta\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have neglected all terms @xmath545 . note that in the integration region @xmath546 so that our approximation @xmath547 is justified . for the same reason the exponential index @xmath548 so that @xmath549\simeq \nonumber \\ & & \simeq e^{-k}(\pi-\theta-\epsilon+2k\theta\,ln\frac{\epsilon}{2 } ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the integral @xmath550 can be found easily : @xmath551\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath552\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] when calculating @xmath538 we introduce an angle @xmath553 to take advantage of @xmath554 being small in the integration region of @xmath538 . + we have @xmath555 } { \chi(1-\frac{\chi^2}{6 } ) } \big\}d\chi\simeq \nonumber \\ & \simeq & e^{-k}\int_0^{\epsilon}exp\bigg(-\frac{2k\theta}{x}\bigg)dx = e^{-k}2k\theta\int_{\frac{2k\theta}{\epsilon}}^{\infty}\frac{e^{-y}dy}{y^2 } \nonumber \\ & \simeq & e^{-k}\big[2k\theta\big(c_{eu}-ln\frac{\epsilon}{2}+ln\,k\theta -1\big)+\epsilon\big]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath556 is the euler constant . + the last integral , @xmath557 , equals @xmath558\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second integral is of the order of @xmath559 , so that @xmath560 and @xmath561 + 2\epsilon\big\}\nonumber \\ \,\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath562\big\}\nonumber \\ \,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and finally @xmath563\nonumber \\ \,\end{aligned}\ ] ] as should be expected , the terms depending on @xmath193 have cancelled in the final result . + the ratio of the scattered light arriving within a certain angle @xmath4 to the point source direction to that non - scattered ( direct ) equals @xmath564\big\}\nonumber\\ \,\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we present results of some analytical integrations of functions @xmath565 and @xmath566 defined in section 2.2 . for the rayleigh scattering we have @xmath567 since @xmath568 , @xmath569 ( eq . 25 ) can be easily found analytically @xmath570 \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the calculation of a corresponding function @xmath571 for the mie scattering is a little more complicated . the adopted here form of @xmath572 has been chosen in such a way as to make the integration over @xmath70 analytically possible . we have ( eq . 16 ) @xmath573 the angle of the second scattering @xmath103 changes within limits @xmath574 where @xmath575 since @xmath576 separates the two regions of @xmath103 where @xmath572 has different shapes , the solution of ( c.3 ) depends on the positions of @xmath577 on the @xmath103 axis with respect to the point @xmath576 . there are three cases to be considered + then , of course , @xmath579 as well and the function @xmath580 applies to the whole region of @xmath70 ( @xmath581 ) . thus we have @xmath582 \nonumber \\ & = & 2\big[a_1\sum_{k=0}^8c_k\int_0^{\pi } cos^k\phi'\,d\phi'+\pi b\big]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath583 , @xmath584 and @xmath585 . + for odd @xmath158 the integrals in ( c.5 ) vanish . for even @xmath586 we have @xmath587 hence @xmath588\ ] ] this case is a bit more complicated since there are both parts @xmath590 and @xmath591 involved . the value @xmath592 corresponding to @xmath576 equals @xmath593 . + we have @xmath594= \nonumber\\ & = & 2\sum_{k=0}^8c_k\big[a_1\int_0^{\phi'_*}cos^k\phi'd\phi'+\nonumber \\ & + & a_2\int_{\phi'_*}^{\pi}cos^k\phi'd\phi'\big]+2\pi b\end{aligned}\ ] ] solving the integrals we finally obtain @xmath595+\nonumber \\ & & + \frac{a_2}{2^{2n}}{2n \choose n}\pi\big\ } \sum_{n=0}^3 c_{2n+1}(a_1-a_2)g'_n(\phi'_*)+b\pi\bigg]\nonumber\\ & & \quad\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath596}{2n-2i } \\ g'_n(\phi ' _ * ) & = & \frac{1}{2^{2n}}\sum_{i=0}^{n}{2n+1 \choose i}\frac{sin[(2n-2i+1)\phi'_*]}{2n-2i+1}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , of course @xmath597 as well and for all values of @xmath70 we have that @xmath598 , so that @xmath599 . the calculation of @xmath600 is the same as in case a ) but @xmath601 . thus @xmath602\ ] ] the next integration over @xmath71 ( eq . 26 ) defining @xmath117 can be found analytically only , @xmath603 and @xmath604 the result could also be found analytically but due to the high power of @xmath605 ( index = 8) there would be very many terms making such an effort worthless . ] for @xmath606 . the calculation is lengthily so that we will present here only the final result for the flux of the second generation @xmath607 where @xmath608\cdot\big(\sum^2_{i=-2 \atop i\neq 0 } a_i\frac{x_2^i - x_1^i}{i}+\nonumber \\ & + & a_0\ , ln\frac{x_2}{x_1}+ \frac{b}{4\tau'^2}\bigg[\sum_{i=1}^4 a_{i-2}\cdot\frac{x_2^i - x_1^i}{i}+a_{-2}ln\frac{x_2}{x_1}+\nonumber\\ & -&2(\tau'^2 + 1)\cdot \big(\sum^3_{i=-1 \atop i \neq 0}a_{i-1}\frac{x_2^i - x_1^i}{i}+a_{-1}ln\frac{x_2}{x_1 } \big ) \bigg]\bigg\ } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the aim of this paper is to investigate an optimal stopping problem under partial observation for piecewise - deterministic markov processes ( pdmp ) both from the theoretical and numerical points of view . pdmp s have been introduced by davis @xcite as a general class of stochastic models . they form a family of markov processes involving deterministic motion punctuated by random jumps . the motion depends on three local characteristics , the flow @xmath1 , the jump rate @xmath2 and the transition measure @xmath3 , which selects the post - jump location . starting from the point @xmath4 , the motion of the process @xmath5 follows the flow @xmath6 until the first jump time @xmath7 , which occurs either spontaneously in a poisson - like fashion with rate @xmath8 or when the flow hits the boundary of the state space . in either case , the location of the process at @xmath7 is selected by the transition measure @xmath9 and the motion restarts from @xmath10 . we define similarly the time until the next jump and the next post - jump location and so on . one important property of a pdmp , relevant for the approach developed in this paper , is that its distribution is completely characterized by the discrete time markov chain @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the @xmath13-th post - jump location and @xmath14 is the @xmath13-th inter - jump time . a suitable choice of the state space and local characteristics provides stochastic models covering a large number of applications such as operations research @xcite , reliability @xcite , neurosciences @xcite , internet traffic @xcite , finance @xcite . this list of examples and references is of course not exhaustive . in this paper , we consider an optimal stopping problem for a partially observed pdmp @xmath5 . roughly speaking , the observation process @xmath15 is a point process defined through the embedded discrete time markov chain @xmath11 . the inter - arrival times are given by @xmath16 and the marks by a noisy function of @xmath17 . for a given reward function @xmath18 and a computation horizon @xmath19 , we study the following optimal stopping problem @xmath20,\ ] ] where @xmath21 is the @xmath22-th jump time of the pdmp @xmath5 , @xmath23 is a stopping time with respect to the natural filtration @xmath24 generated by the observations @xmath15 . in some applications , it may be more appropriate to consider a fixed optimization horizon @xmath25 rather than the random horizon @xmath21 . this is a difficult problem with few references in the literature , see for instance @xcite where the underlying process is not piecewise deterministic . regarding pdmp s , this problem could be addressed using the same ideas as in @xcite . it involves the time - augmented process @xmath26 . although this process is still a pdmp , its local characteristics may not have the same good properties as those of the original process leading to several new technical difficulties . a general methodology to solve such a problem is to split it into two sub - problems . the first one consists in deriving the filter process given by the conditional expectation of @xmath27 with respect to the observed information @xmath28 . its main objective is to transform the initial problem into a completely observed optimal stopping problem where the new state variable is the filter process . the second step consists in solving this reformulated problem , the new difficulty being its infinite dimension . indeed , the filter process takes values in a set of probability measures . our work is inspired by @xcite which deals with an optimal stopping problem under partial observation for a markov chain with finite state space . the authors study the optimal filtering and convert their original problem into a standard optimal stopping problem for a continuous state space markov chain . then they propose a discretization method based on a quantization technique to approximate the value function . however , their method can not be directly applied to our problem for the following main reasons related to the specificities of pdmps . firstly , pdmps are continuous time processes . although the dynamics can be described by the discrete - time markov chain @xmath11 , this optimization problem remains intrinsically a _ continuous - time _ optimization problem . indeed , the performance criterion is maximized over the set of stopping times defined with respect to the _ continuous - time _ filtration @xmath29 . consequently , our problem can not be converted into a fully discrete time problem . secondly , the distribution of a pdmp combines both absolutely continuous and singular components . this is due to the existence of forced jumps when the process hits the boundary of the state space . as a consequence the derivation of the filter process is not straightforward . in particular , the absolute continuity hypothesis * ( h ) * of @xcite does not hold . thirdly , in our context the reformulated optimization problem is not standard , unlike in @xcite . as already explained , this reformulated optimization problem combines _ continuous - time _ and _ discrete - time _ features . consequently , this problem does not correspond to the classical optimal stopping problem of a discrete - time markov chain . moreover , it is different from the optimal stopping problem of a pdmp under complete observation mainly because the new state variables given by the markov chain @xmath30 are not the underlying markov chain of some pdmp . therefore the results of the literature @xcite can not be used . finally , a natural way to proceed with the numerical approximation is then to follow the ideas developed in @xcite namely to replace the filter @xmath31 and the inter - jump time @xmath14 by some finite state space approximations in the dynamic programming equation . however , a noticeable difference from @xcite lies in the fact that the dynamic programming operators therein were lipschitz continuous whereas our new operators are only lipschitz continuous between some points of discontinuity . we overcome this drawback by splitting the operators into their restrictions onto their continuity sets . this way , we obtain not only an approximation of the value function of the optimal stopping problem but also an @xmath0-optimal stopping time with respect to the filtration @xmath29 that can be computed in practice . our approximation procedure for random variables is based on quantization . there exists an extensive literature on this method . the interested reader may for instance consult @xcite and the references within . the quantization of a random variable @xmath32 consists in finding a finite grid such that the projection @xmath33 of @xmath32 on this grid minimizes some @xmath34 norm of the difference @xmath35 . roughly speaking , such a grid will have more points in the areas of high density of @xmath32 . as explained for instance in @xcite , under some lipschitz - continuity conditions , bounds for the rate of convergence of functionals of the quantized process towards the original process are available , which makes this technique especially appealing . quantization methods have been developed recently in numerical probability or optimal stochastic control with applications in finance , see e.g. @xcite . the paper is organized as follows . section [ section - def ] introduces the notation , recalls the definition of a pdmp , presents our assumptions and defines the optimal stopping problem we are interested in , especially the observation process . the recursive formulation of the filter process is derived in section [ section - filtre ] . in section [ section - dynamic ] , we reduce our partially observed problem for the pdmp @xmath5 to a completely observed one involving the process @xmath36 for which we provide the dynamic programming equation and construct a family of @xmath0-optimal stopping times . then , our numerical methods to compute the value function and an @xmath0-optimal stopping time are presented in section [ section - quantif ] where we also prove the convergence of our algorithms after having recalled the main features of quantization . finally , an academic example is discussed in section [ section - example ] while technical results are postponed to the appendices . in this first section , let us define a piecewise - deterministic markov process ( pdmp ) and introduce some general assumptions . for any metric space @xmath37 , we denote @xmath38 its borel @xmath23-field , @xmath39 the set of real - valued , bounded and measurable functions defined on @xmath37 and @xmath40 the subset of functions of @xmath39 that are lipschitz continuous . for @xmath41 , denote @xmath42 and @xmath43 . let @xmath37 be an open subset of @xmath44 . let @xmath45 be its boundary and @xmath46 its closure and for any subset @xmath47 of @xmath37 , @xmath48 denotes its complement . a pdmp is defined by its local characteristics @xmath49 . * the flow @xmath50 is continuous . for all @xmath51 , @xmath52 is an homeomorphism and @xmath53 is a semi - group : for all @xmath54 , @xmath55 . for all @xmath56 , define the deterministic exit time from @xmath37 : @xmath57 we use here and throughout the convention @xmath58 . * the jump rate @xmath59 is measurable and satisfies : @xmath60 * finally , @xmath3 is a markov kernel on @xmath61 which satisfies : @xmath62 from these characteristics , it can be shown @xcite that there exists a filtered probability space @xmath63 on which a process @xmath64 is defined . its motion , starting from a point @xmath65 , may be constructed as follows . let @xmath66 be a nonnegative random variable with survival function : @xmath67 where for @xmath65 and @xmath68 $ ] , @xmath69 one then chooses an @xmath37-valued random variable @xmath70 with distribution @xmath71 . the trajectory of @xmath72 for @xmath73 is : @xmath74 starting from the point @xmath75 , one selects in a similar way @xmath76 the time between @xmath7 and the next jump time @xmath77 , as well as @xmath78 the next post - jump location and so on . davis showed @xcite that the process so defined is a strong markov process @xmath79 with jump times @xmath80 ( @xmath81 ) . the process @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the @xmath13-th post - jump location and @xmath84 ( @xmath85 ) is the @xmath13-th inter - jump time is clearly a discrete - time markov chain . the following non explosion assumption about the jump - times is standard ( see for example @xcite ) . [ hyp - tk_goes_to_infty ] for all @xmath86 , @xmath87<+\infty$ ] . it implies that @xmath88 a.s . when @xmath89 . moreover , we make the following assumption about the transition kernel @xmath3 . we assume that there exists a finite set @xmath90 such that for all @xmath65 , one has @xmath91 . in other words , for all @xmath92 , @xmath12 may only take its values in the finite set @xmath93 . this assumption ensures that the filter process , defined in the next section , has finite dimension . this is required to derive a tractable numerical method in section [ section - quantif ] . when this assumption does not hold , one may consider a preliminary discretization of the transition kernel to introduce it . [ hyp - ts - bounded ] we assume that the function @xmath94 is bounded on @xmath93 i.e. for all @xmath95 , we assume that @xmath96 . [ def - ts - order ] for all @xmath95 , denote @xmath97 and assume that @xmath98 , , @xmath99 are numbered such that @xmath100 @xmath101 . moreover , let @xmath102 . for any function @xmath103 in @xmath39 , introduce the following notation @xmath104 for any lipschitz continuous function @xmath103 in @xmath40 , denote @xmath105 $ ] its lipschitz constant @xmath106=\sup_{x\neq y \in e}\frac{|w(x)-w(y)|}{|x - y|}.\ ] ] the jump rate @xmath2 is in @xmath107 i.e. is bounded by @xmath108 . denote @xmath109 the set of finite signed measures on @xmath93 and @xmath110 the subset of probability measures on @xmath93 . we equip @xmath109 with the norm @xmath111 given by @xmath112 where @xmath113 denotes @xmath114 . we consider from now on a pdmp @xmath5 of which the initial state @xmath115 is a fixed point @xmath116 . we assume that this pdmp is observed through a noise and we now turn to the description of our observation procedure . for all @xmath92 , we assume that @xmath14 is perfectly observed but that @xmath12 is not ( except for the initial state @xmath117 ) . in some examples , it seems reasonable to consider that the jump times of the process are observed ( for instance , if the jumps correspond to changes of environment ) and that , when a jump occurs , the actual post - jump location is measured with a noise . the _ observation _ process of @xmath12 , denoted by @xmath118 is assumed to be of the following form : @xmath119 ( deterministic ) and for @xmath120 , @xmath121 where @xmath122 and where the _ noise _ @xmath123 is a sequence of @xmath44-valued , i.i.d . random variables with bounded density function @xmath124 that are also independent from @xmath11 . in order to define real - valued stopping times adapted to the observation process , we need to consider a continuous time version of the observation process . we therefore define the piecewise - constant process @xmath125 with a slight abuse of notation represents the value of the process @xmath15 at time @xmath126 and must not be confused with the value of the process at time @xmath127 . ] as @xmath128 let @xmath24 be the filtration generated by @xmath15 ( the _ observed _ filtration ) and @xmath129 be the filtration generated by @xmath130 ( the _ total _ filtration ) . without changing the notation , we then complete these filtrations with all the @xmath131-null sets . this leads us to the following definition . denote @xmath132 the set of @xmath29-stopping times that are a.s . finite and for @xmath92 , define @xmath133 for all @xmath92 , we define the filter @xmath134 . the quantity @xmath135 , denoted by @xmath136 , represents the probability of the event @xmath137 given the information available until time @xmath138 i.e. @xmath139.\ ] ] finally , let @xmath19 be the _ horizon _ and @xmath140 the _ reward function _ , we are interested in maximizing the following _ performance criterion _ @xmath141\ ] ] with respect to the stopping times @xmath142 . the _ value function _ associated to this partially observed optimal stopping problem is given by @xmath143,\ ] ] where @xmath144 is a probability measure in @xmath110 . the solution of our problem is then obtained by setting @xmath145 . for some applications , it would be interesting to consider a more general form for the reward function such as an integral term also possibly depending on the observation process , see for instance @xcite . however , this new setup would lead to several technical difficulties . in particular , the dynamic programming would be more complex . thus the derivation of the error bounds for the numerical approximation would be possibly intractable . we will also need the following assumption about the reward function @xmath18 associated with the optimal stopping problem . [ hyp - g - lip ] the function @xmath18 is in @xmath107 i.e. bounded by @xmath146 and there exists @xmath147_{2}\in \mathbb{r}^+$ ] such that for all @xmath148 and @xmath149 $ ] , one has : @xmath150_{2}|t - u|.\ ] ] now , the aims of this paper are first to explicit the filter process @xmath151 ( section [ section - filtre ] ) ; second to rewrite the partially observed optimal stopping problem as a totally observed one for a suitable markov chain on @xmath152 ( section [ sec - opt - stop - complete ] ) ; third to derive a dynamic programming equation and construct a family of @xmath0-optimal stopping times ( section [ section - dynamic - eq ] ) ; and finally to propose a numerical method to compute an approximation of the value function and an @xmath0-optimal stopping time ( section [ section - quantif ] ) . as a starting point , we will derive , in the next section , a recursive construction of the optimal filter that is the key point of our approach . the goal of this section is to obtain a recursive formulation of the filter @xmath31 . as far as we know , there is no result concerning the filter process for generic pdmps . we may however refer to @xcite for a recursive formulation of the filter for point processes , that can be seen as a sub - class of pdmp s . for all @xmath92 , we denote @xmath153 . the continuous - time observation process @xmath15 being a point process in the sense developed in @xcite , one has @xmath154 ( see ( * ? ? ? * , theorem t2 ) ) . moreover , @xmath155 . concerning the filter @xmath31 , first notice that , since it is an @xmath156-measurable random variable , there exists for all @xmath92 a measurable function @xmath157 such that @xmath158 as in the case of the kalman - bucy filter , the iteration leading from @xmath159 to @xmath31 can be split into two steps : prediction and correction . for all @xmath120 , let @xmath160 be the conditional distribution of @xmath161 given @xmath162 . thus , @xmath160 is a transition kernel defined on @xmath163 for all @xmath164 and @xmath165 by @xmath166 [ lemme - filtre - zys ] for all @xmath165 , we have the following equality of probability measures on @xmath167 , for all @xmath164 , @xmath168 [ [ proof ] ] proof + + + + + set @xmath169 in @xmath170 , using eq . that defines @xmath118 , one has @xmath171}\\ & = & \sum_{j=1}^{q}\int h(x_{j},\varphi(x_{j})+w , s){\mathbf{p}}(z_{n}=x_{j},s_{n}\in ds , w_{n}\in dw|\mathcal{g}_{n-1}=\gamma_{n-1}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , @xmath172 is independent from @xmath173 and admits the density function @xmath124 . consequently , one easily obtains the result by using the change of variable @xmath174 . @xmath175 + + integrating w.r.t . to the first variable in the previous lemma ( i.e. summing w.r.t . @xmath176 ) yields the following result . [ lemme - filtre - ys ] for all @xmath165 , we have the following equality of probability measures on @xmath177 , @xmath178dy.\ ] ] [ lemme - filtre - mu ] for all @xmath120 , @xmath165 and @xmath179 , the distribution @xmath160 , defined by eq . , satisfies @xmath180{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[\}}\left(\sum_{i = m+1}^{q}\pi_{n-1}^{i}(\gamma_{n-1})\lambda(\phi(x_i , s))e^{-\lambda(x_i , s)}q(\phi(x_i , s),x_j)\right)ds\\ & & + \sum_{m=1}^{q}\left(\pi_{n-1}^{m}(\gamma_{n-1})e^{-\lambda(x_m,{t^{*}}_m)}q(\phi(x_m,{t^{*}}_m),x_j)\right)\delta_{{t^{*}}_m}(ds).\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ [ proof-1 ] ] proof + + + + + let @xmath169 be a function of @xmath181 . since @xmath182 , the law of iterated conditional expectations yields @xmath183={\mathbf{e}}\left[{\mathbf{e}}\left[h(z_{n},s_{n})\big|{\mathfrak{f}}_{t_{n-1}}\right]\big|\mathcal{g}_{n-1}=\gamma_{n-1}\right].\ ] ] besides , @xmath184 so that @xmath185={\mathbf{e}}\left[h(z_{n},s_{n})\big|z_{0},s_{0},\ldots , z_{n-1},s_{n-1}\right],\ ] ] by independence of the sequences @xmath186 and @xmath11 . now , we apply the markov property of @xmath11 and a well - known special feature of the transition kernel of the underlying markov chain of a pdmp to obtain @xmath185={\mathbf{e}}\left[h(z_{n},s_{n})\big|z_{n-1},s_{n-1}\right]={\mathbf{e}}\left[h(z_{n},s_{n})\big|z_{n-1}\right].\ ] ] moreover , the transition kernel can be explicitly expressed in terms of the local characteristics of the pdmp , and this yields the next equations @xmath187}\\ & = & { \mathbf{e}}\big[\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{n-1}=x_{i}\}}{\mathbf{e}}[h(z_{n},s_{n})|z_{n-1}=x_{i}]\big|\mathcal{g}_{n-1}=\gamma_{n-1}\big]\\ & = & { \mathbf{e}}\big[\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{n-1}=x_{i}\}}\sum_{j=1}^{q}\big[\int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{+ } } h(x_{j},s)\lambda(\phi(x_i , s))e^{-\lambda(x_i , s)}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s<{t^{*}}_i\}}q(\phi(x_i , s),x_j)ds\\ & & + h(x_{j},{t^{*}}_i)e^{-\lambda(x_i,{t^{*}}_i)}q(\phi(x_i,{t^{*}}_i),x_j)\big]\big|\mathcal{g}_{n-1}=\gamma_{n-1}\big]\\ & = & \sum_{j=1}^{q}\big(\int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{+ } } h(x_{j},s)\sum_{i=1}^{q}\pi_{n-1}^{i}(\gamma_{n-1})\lambda(\phi(x_i , s))e^{-\lambda(x_i , s)}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s<{t^{*}}_i\}}q(\phi(x_i , s),x_j)ds\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}h(x_{j},{t^{*}}_i)\pi_{n-1}^{i}(\gamma_{n-1})e^{-\lambda(x_i,{t^{*}}_i)}q(\phi(x_i,{t^{*}}_i),x_j)\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this can be written equivalently as @xmath188}\\ & = & \sum_{j=1}^{q}\bigg(\sum_{m=0}^{q-1}\bigg(\int_{{t^{*}}_{m}}^{{t^{*}}_{m+1 } } h(x_{j},s)\sum_{i = m+1}^{q}\pi_{n-1}^{i}(\gamma_{n-1})\lambda(\phi(x_i , s))e^{-\lambda(x_i , s)}q(\phi(x_i , s),x_j)\bigg)ds\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}h(x_{j},{t^{*}}_i)\pi_{n-1}^{i}(\gamma_{n-1})e^{-\lambda(x_i,{t^{*}}_i)}q(\phi(x_i,{t^{*}}_i),x_j)\bigg).\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence the result . @xmath175 + + we now state the main result of this section , namely the recursive formulation of the filter sequence @xmath151 . [ prop - rec - filtre ] let @xmath189 be defined as follows : for all @xmath179 , @xmath190{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[\}}\frac{\psi^{j}_{m}(\pi , y , s)}{\overline{\psi}_{m}(\pi , y , s)}+\sum_{m=1}^{q}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s={t^{*}}_{m}\}}\frac{\psi^{*j}_{m}(y)}{\overline{\psi}^{*}_{m}(y)},\ ] ] where @xmath191 then , the filter , defined in eq . , satisfies @xmath192 and the following recursion : for all @xmath120 , @xmath193 [ [ proof-2 ] ] proof + + + + + fix @xmath194 in @xmath195 . bayes formula yields for all @xmath179 , @xmath196 lemma [ lemme - filtre - zys ] and corollary [ lemme - filtre - ys ] yield @xmath197dy.\end{gathered}\ ] ] with respect to @xmath198 , one recognizes the equality of two absolutely continuous measures which implies the equality a.e . of the density functions . thus , one has for almost all @xmath199 w.r.t . the lebesgue measure , @xmath200.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . states the equality of two measures of the variable @xmath201 that contain both an absolutely continuous part and some weighted dirac measures . denote @xmath202 ( respectively @xmath203 ) the left - hand ( resp . right - hand ) side term of the previous equality . eq . means that for all function @xmath204 and for almost all @xmath199 w.r.t . the lebesgue measure , one has @xmath205 recall that , from lemma [ lemme - filtre - mu ] , the distribution @xmath206 has a density on the interval @xmath207{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[$ ] denoted by @xmath208 and given by @xmath209 first , take @xmath210{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[\}}$ ] in equation with @xmath211 . one has from equation ( [ eq - egal - mesures ] ) @xmath212 and thus on @xmath207{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[$ ] , almost surely w.r.t . the lebesgue measure , one has @xmath213 finally , for @xmath214 , choosing @xmath215 in eq . yields the equality of the weights at the point @xmath216 thus , using lemma [ lemme - filtre - mu ] , @xmath217 thus there exists two measurable sets @xmath218 and @xmath219 , negligible w.r.t . the lebesgue measures on @xmath44 and @xmath220 respectively , such that for all @xmath221 , @xmath222 , @xmath223 , one has @xmath224 on the one hand , one has @xmath225 by absolute continuity of the distribution of @xmath172 . on the other hand , @xmath226 because the distribution of @xmath14 is absolutely continuous on @xmath227 and one has @xmath228 . we therefore conclude from eq . that @xmath131-a.s . , one has @xmath229 the result follows since @xmath131-a.s . , one has @xmath230 and @xmath231 . @xmath175 + + this proposition will play a crucial part in the sequel . on the one hand , this result will enable us to prove the markov property of the sequence @xmath30 w.r.t . the observed filtration . on the other hand , the recursive formulation allows for simulation of the process @xmath232 which is crucial to obtain numerical approximations . finally , notice that the specific structure of the pdmp appears in the recursive formulation of the filter which contains both an absolutely continuous part and some weighted points . the main objective of this section is to derive the dynamic programming equation for the value function of the partially observed optimal stopping problem . the proof of this result can be roughly speaking decomposed into two steps . the first point consists in converting the partially observed optimal stopping problem into an optimal stopping problem under complete observation where the state variables are described by the _ discrete - time _ markov chain @xmath30 ( see section [ sec - opt - stop - complete ] ) . it is important to remark that under this new formulation , the optimization problem remains intrinsically a _ continuous - time _ optimization problem because the performance criterion is maximized over the set of stopping times with respect to the _ continuous - time _ filtration @xmath29 . we show in the second step ( see section [ section - dynamic - eq ] ) that the value function associated to the optimal stopping problem can be calculated by iterating a functional operator , labelled @xmath233 ( see definition [ def - g - h - i - j - l ] ) . as a by - product , we also provide a family of @xmath0-optimal stopping times . we would like to emphasize that the results obtained in this section are not straightforward to obtain due to the specific structure of this optimization problem . indeed , as already explained , it combines _ continuous - time _ and _ discrete - time _ features . consequently , this problem does not correspond to the classical optimal stopping problem of a discrete - time markov chain . moreover , it is different from the optimal stopping problem of a pdmp under complete observation mainly because the new state variables given by the markov chain @xmath30 are not the underlying markov chain of some pdmp . therefore the results of the literature @xcite can not be used . these derivations require some technical results about the structure of the stopping times in @xmath234 . for the sake of clarity in exposition , they are presented in the appendix [ stop - time ] . we start with a technical preliminary result required in the sequel , investigating the markov property of the filter process . [ prop - markov ] the sequences @xmath235 , @xmath236 and @xmath237 are @xmath238-markov chains . [ [ proof-3 ] ] proof + + + + + let @xmath239 . the law of iterated conditional expectations yields @xmath240 = { \mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbf{e}}[h(\pi_{n},y_{n},s_{n})| { \mathfrak{f}}_{t_{n-1}}]\big|{\mathfrak{f}^{y}}_{t_{n-1}}\big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] from proposition [ prop - rec - filtre ] and eq . which defines @xmath118 one obtains @xmath241}\\ & = & { \mathbf{e}}\big[h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},\varphi(z_{n})+w_{n},s_{n}),\varphi(z_{n})+w_{n},s_{n}\big)\big| { \mathfrak{f}}_{t_{n-1}}\big]\\ & = & \sum_{j=1}^{q}\int h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},\varphi(x_{j})+w , s),\varphi(x_{j})+w , s\big)\\ & & \times { \mathbf{p}}(z_{n}=x_{j},w_{n}\in dw , s_{n}\in ds|{\mathfrak{f}}_{t_{n-1}}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] yet , @xmath172 is independent from @xmath242 and admits the density function @xmath124 . as in the proof of lemma [ lemme - filtre - zys ] one thus obtains @xmath241}\\ & = & \sum_{j=1}^{q}\int h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},y , s),y , s\big){\mathbf{p}}(z_{n}=x_{j},s_{n}\in ds|{\mathfrak{f}}_{t_{n-1}})f_{w}(y-\varphi(x_{j}))dy.\end{aligned}\ ] ] besides , we have @xmath243 as in the proof of lemma [ lemme - filtre - mu ] , so that one has @xmath241}\\ & = & \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{n-1}=x_{i}\}}\sum_{j=1}^{q}\int \big(\int_{0}^{{t^{*}}_{i } } h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},y , s),y , s\big)\lambda\big(\phi(x_i , s)\big)e^{-\lambda(x_i , s)}q\big(\phi(x_{i},s),x_{j}\big)ds\\ & & + h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},y,{t^{*}}_{i}),y,{t^{*}}_{i}\big)e^{-\lambda(x_i,{t^{*}}_{i})}q\big(\phi(x_{i},{t^{*}}_{i}),x_{j}\big)\big)f_{w}(y-\varphi(x_{j}))dy.\end{aligned}\ ] ] take now the conditional expectation w.r.t . @xmath162 , to obtain @xmath241}\\ & = & \sum_{i=1}^{q}\pi_{n-1}^{i}\sum_{j=1}^{q}\int \big(\int_{0}^{{t^{*}}_{i } } h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},y , s),y , s\big)\lambda\big(\phi(x_i , s)\big)e^{-\lambda(x_i , s)}q\big(\phi(x_{i},s),x_{j}\big)ds\\ & & + h\big(\psi(\pi_{n-1},y,{t^{*}}_{i}),y,{t^{*}}_{i}\big)e^{-\lambda(x_i,{t^{*}}_{i})}q\big(\phi(x_{i},{t^{*}}_{i}),x_{j}\big)\big)f_{w}(y-\varphi(x_{j}))dy.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence @xmath244 $ ] is merely a function of @xmath159 yielding the result for the three processes . @xmath175 + in this section , we show how our optimal stopping problem under partial observation for the process @xmath5 can be converted into an optimal stopping problem under complete observation involving the markov chain @xmath245 . more precisely , for a fixed stopping time @xmath246 , we show in proposition [ lemme value fonction ] that the performance criterion @xmath247 $ ] can be expressed in terms of the discrete - time markov chain @xmath245 . we would like to emphasize the following important fact . although the performance criterion can be written in terms of _ discrete - time _ process , the optimization problem remains intrinsically a _ continuous - time _ optimization problem . indeed , the performance criterion is maximized over the set of stopping times with respect to the _ continuous - time _ filtration @xmath29 . [ lemme value fonction ] let @xmath248 and @xmath120 . for all @xmath249 one has @xmath250}\\ & = & \sum_{k=0}^{n-1}\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \sigma\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{k}<{t^{*}}_{i}\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k})e^{-\lambda(x_{i},r_{k})}\pi_{k}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi]\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{n}\leq \sigma\}}g(x_{i})\pi_{n}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath251 is the sequence of non negative random variables associated to @xmath23 as introduced in theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] . [ [ proof-4 ] ] proof + + + + + we split @xmath252 $ ] into several terms depending on the position of @xmath23 w.r.t . the jump times @xmath253 @xmath254 } & = & \sum_{k=0}^{n-1}\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \sigma < t_{k+1}\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{k}=x_{i}\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k})|\pi_0=\pi]\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{n}\leq \sigma\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{n}=x_{i}\}}g(x_{i})|\pi_0=\pi].\end{aligned}\ ] ] for notational convenience , consider @xmath255 on the one hand , one has @xmath256=g(x_{i}){\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{n}\leq \sigma\}}\pi_{n}^{i}$ ] since @xmath257 ( see for instance ( * ? ? ? * , theorem t7 ) ) . on the other hand , to compute @xmath258 $ ] , we use lemma [ lemme - tech - event ] to obtain @xmath259 & = { \mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \sigma\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k}){\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{k+1}>r_{k}\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{k}=x_{i}\}}|{\mathfrak{f}^{y}}_{t_{k}}]\\ & = { \mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \sigma\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k}){\mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{k}=x_{i}\}}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{k+1}>r_{k}\}}|{\mathfrak{f}}_{t_{k}}]\big|{\mathfrak{f}^{y}}_{t_{k}}\big]\\ & = { \mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \sigma\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k}){\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{z_{k}=x_{i}\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{k}<{t^{*}}(z_{k})\}}e^{-\lambda(z_{k},r_{k})}|{\mathfrak{f}^{y}}_{t_{k}}]\\ & = { \mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \sigma\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k}){\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{k}<{t^{*}}_{i}\}}e^{-\lambda(x_{i},r_{k})}\pi_{k}^{i}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] details to obtain the third line in the above computations are provided by lemma [ lemme - tech - esp - cond ] . the result follows . @xmath175 + based on the new formulation , the main objective of this section is to derive the backward dynamic programming equation . it involves some operators introduced in definition [ def - g - h - i - j - l ] . by iterating the operator , labelled @xmath233 , we define a sequence of real valued functions @xmath260 in definition [ def - vn ] . theorem [ value - fonction ] establishes that @xmath261 is the value function of our partially observed optimal stopping problem with horizon @xmath262 and in particular that @xmath263 is the value function of problem defined in equation . another important result of this section is given by theorem [ theo - sn - epsilon ] which constructs a sequence of @xmath0-optimal stopping times . [ def - g - h - i - j - l ] the operators @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , and @xmath267 are defined for all @xmath268 and @xmath269 by @xmath270,\\ hh(\pi , u)&=&{\mathbf{e}}\big[\sum_{i=1}^qh\circ\phi(x_i , u)\pi_0^i{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{u < t^*_i\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{1 } > u\}}| \pi_0=\pi\big],\\j(v , h)(\pi , u)&=&hh(\pi , u)+gv(\pi , u),\\ l(v , h)(\pi)&=&\sup_{u\geq 0 } j(v , h)(\pi , u).\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ def - vn ] the sequence @xmath260 of real - valued functions is defined on @xmath110 by @xmath271 the following theorem is the main result of this section showing that the operator @xmath233 is the dynamic programming operator associated to the initial optimization problem . [ value - fonction ] for all @xmath272 and @xmath273 , one has @xmath274 = v_{n - n}(\pi).\ ] ] [ [ proof-5 ] ] proof + + + + + the proof of this result is based on proposition [ theo - value - fonction ] and theorem [ theo - sn - epsilon ] . proposition [ theo - value - fonction ] proves that @xmath275 is an upper bound for the value function of the problem with horizon @xmath138 . the reverse inequality is derived in theorem [ theo - sn - epsilon ] by constructing a sequence of @xmath0-optimal stopping times . @xmath175 + + [ theo - value - fonction ] for all @xmath272 and @xmath273 , one has @xmath274\leq v_{n - n}(\pi).\ ] ] [ [ proof-6 ] ] proof + + + + + let @xmath276 . consider @xmath251 the sequence associated to @xmath23 as introduced in theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] . we prove the theorem by induction on @xmath13 . for @xmath277 , proposition [ lemme value fonction ] yields @xmath278 & = & { \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{0}<{t^{*}}_{i}\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{0})e^{-\lambda(x_{i},r_{0})}\pi_{0}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi ] } \nonumber \\ & & + { \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{1}\leq\sigma\}}g(x_{i})\pi_{1}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi]}. \label{beben}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath279 is deterministic and by using lemma [ lemme - def - op - h ] , we recognize that the first term of the right hand side of equation ( [ beben ] ) is @xmath280 . we now turn to the second term of the right hand side of equation ( [ beben ] ) which is given by @xmath281 & = & { \mathbf{e}}[v_{n}(\pi_{1}){\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{1}\leq r_{0}\}}|\pi_0=\pi ] \\ & = & \ gv_{n}(\pi , r_{0}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] from lemma [ lemme - tech - event ] and the definition of @xmath282 . recall that from definition [ def - g - h - i - j - l ] one has @xmath283 thus , one obtains @xmath278 \ = \ j(v_{n},g)(\pi , r_{0 } ) & \leq & \sup_{u\geq 0}j(v_{n},g)(\pi , u)\\ & = & l(v_{n},g)(\pi)= v_{n-1}(\pi).\end{aligned}\ ] ] set now @xmath284 and assume that @xmath285\leq v_{n-(n-1)}(\pi)$ ] , for all @xmath286 . proposition [ lemme value fonction ] yields @xmath287}\\ & = & \sum_{k=0}^{n-1}\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\ { t_{k}\leq \sigma\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{k}<{t^{*}}_{i}\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{k})e^{-\lambda(x_{i},r_{k})}\pi_{k}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi]\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{n}\leq \sigma\}}g(x_{i})\pi_{n}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi].\end{aligned}\ ] ] as in the case @xmath277 , the term for @xmath288 equals @xmath280 . notice that for @xmath289 , @xmath290 and that @xmath291 is @xmath292-measurable . by taking the conditional expectation w.r.t . @xmath292 it follows that @xmath293={\mathbf{e}}[\xi |\pi_0=\pi]$ ] where @xmath294 is defined by @xmath295.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , we obtain @xmath296= hg(\pi , r_{0})+{\mathbf{e}}[\xi{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{1}\leq r_{0}\}}|\pi_0=\pi].\ ] ] we now use the markov property of the chain @xmath297 . indeed , for @xmath289 , one has @xmath298 , where @xmath299 is the translation operator of the @xmath238-markov chain @xmath235 . moreover , when @xmath300 , one has , from proposition [ propb4 ] , @xmath301 ( indeed , we pointed out in remark [ rq - rn - rnbar ] that @xmath302 can be replaced by @xmath303 defined in lemma [ lemmeb2 ] ) and @xmath304 where @xmath305 and @xmath306 are defined in definition [ defb3 ] and proposition [ propb4 ] ( with @xmath307 in the present case ) . since for @xmath289 , @xmath308 , one has @xmath309 . finally , combining the markov property of the chain @xmath297 and proposition [ lemme value fonction ] we have @xmath310 with @xmath311 $ ] . moreover , one has @xmath312 from the induction assumption since @xmath313 ( indeed , both @xmath306 and @xmath314 are @xmath29-stopping times from corollary [ corb6 ] and lemma [ prop - tn - stop - time ] respectively ) . one has then @xmath315 finally , combining eq . and , one has @xmath316 \leq hg(\pi , r_{0})+{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n-(n-1)}(\pi_{1}){\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{1}\leq r_{0}\}}|\pi_0=\pi].\ ] ] in the second term , we recognize the operator @xmath282 and one has @xmath317 & \leq & hg(\pi , r_{0})+gv_{n-(n-1)}(\pi , r_{0})\\ & = & j(v_{n-(n-1)},g)(\pi , r_{0})\\ & \leq & \sup_{u\geq 0 } j(v_{n-(n-1)},g)(\pi , u)\\ & = & l(v_{n-(n-1)},g)(\pi ) \ = \ v_{n - n}(\pi),\end{aligned}\ ] ] that proves the induction . @xmath175 + + we now prove the reverse inequality by constructing a sequence of @xmath0-optimal stopping times . [ def - sn - epsilon]for @xmath318 , @xmath272 and for @xmath319 , we define @xmath320 consider @xmath321 and for @xmath284 , @xmath322 and finally set @xmath323 the following lemma describes the effect of the translation operator @xmath299 on the sequence @xmath324 . [ rnk - epsilon - theta ] for @xmath325 and @xmath326 , on the set @xmath327 , one has @xmath328 [ [ proof-7 ] ] proof + + + + + for @xmath329 , one just has to prove that on the event @xmath330 , one has @xmath331 . yet , from the definition of the sequence @xmath324 , one has @xmath332 and @xmath333 . the result follows since we are on the event @xmath334 . for a fixed @xmath335 , we prove the lemma by induction on @xmath326 . set @xmath336 . one has from the definition on the sequence @xmath324 , @xmath337 and @xmath338 . we obtain @xmath339 because we have assumed that we are on the event @xmath340 . the propagation of the induction is similar to the case @xmath336 . @xmath175 + + equipped with this preliminary result , we may now prove that @xmath341 is a sequence of @xmath0-optimal stopping times with respect to the filtration . generated by the observations . [ theo - sn - epsilon ] for all @xmath272 and @xmath318 , one has @xmath342 and @xmath343\geq v_{n - n}(\pi)-\epsilon.\ ] ] [ [ proof-8 ] ] proof + + + + + let @xmath344 . first notice that , as a direct consequence of proposition [ propb5 ] , @xmath345 is an @xmath29-stopping time since , by construction , the @xmath346 are @xmath347-measurable and satisfy the condition @xmath348 on the event @xmath349 . it is also clear that @xmath350 . thus , one has @xmath342 . let us now prove the second assessment by induction . set @xmath277 . let @xmath319 , we denote @xmath351 . since @xmath352 is deterministic , one has clearly @xmath353 . consequently , by using the same arguments as in the proof of proposition [ theo - value - fonction ] , we obtain @xmath354= & hg(\pi , r_{0}^{\epsilon})+gv_{n}(\pi , r_{0}^{\epsilon})=j(v_{n},g)(\pi , r_{0}^{\epsilon}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , the definition of @xmath355 yields @xmath356 thus one has @xmath357\geq v_{n-1}(\pi)-\epsilon.\ ] ] now set @xmath284 and assume that @xmath358\geq v_{n-(n-1)}(\pi)-\epsilon$ ] , for all @xmath318 . proposition [ lemme value fonction ] yields @xmath359}\\ & = & \sum_{k=0}^{n-1}\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}\left[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq u_{n}^{2\epsilon}\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{n , k}^{2\epsilon}<{t^{*}}_{i}\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},r_{n , k}^{2\epsilon})e^{-\lambda(x_{i},r_{n , k}^{2\epsilon})}\pi_{k}^{i}\big|\pi_0=\pi\right]\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{n}\leq u_{n}^{2\epsilon}\}}g(x_{i})\pi_{n}^{i}|\pi_0=\pi].\end{aligned}\ ] ] denote @xmath360 . as in the case @xmath277 , the term for @xmath288 equals @xmath361 since @xmath362 . take the conditional expectation w.r.t . @xmath292 in the other terms . one has then , @xmath363= hg(\pi , r_{n-1}^{\epsilon})+{\mathbf{e}}[\xi'{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{1}\leq u_{n}^{2\epsilon}\}}|\pi_0=\pi],\ ] ] with @xmath364.\end{aligned}\ ] ] our objective is to apply the markov property of @xmath365 in the term @xmath366 . recall that , from lemma [ rnk - epsilon - theta ] , one has @xmath367 for @xmath325 and @xmath326 on the event @xmath368 ( the equality of these events stems from lemma [ lemme - tech - event ] ) . thus , on this set one has @xmath369 besides , recall that @xmath370 , for @xmath371 . consequently , on the set @xmath327 , one has @xmath372 and thus , combining the markov property of the chain @xmath297 and proposition [ lemme value fonction ] , we have @xmath373 with @xmath374 $ ] . moreover , thanks to the induction assumption , one has @xmath375 so that one obtains @xmath376 finally , combining equation and and noticing that , according to lemma [ lemme - tech - event ] , @xmath377 , one obtains @xmath378 } & \geq & hg(\pi , r_{n-1}^{\epsilon})+{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n-(n-1)}(\pi_{1}){\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{1}\leq r_{n-1}^{\epsilon}\}}|\pi_0=\pi]-\epsilon\\ & = & j(v_{n-(n-1)},g)(\pi , r_{n-1}^{\epsilon})-\epsilon\\ & \geq & v_{n - n}(\pi)-2\epsilon,\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition of @xmath379 , showing the result . in this section , we are interested in the computational issue for our optimal stopping problem under partial observation . indeed , we want to compute a numerical approximation of the value function ( [ opt - stop - pb ] ) and propose a computable @xmath0-optimal stopping time . as we have seen in the previous section , the value function @xmath380 can be obtained by iterating the dynamic programming operator @xmath233 . however , the operator @xmath233 involves conditional expectations that are in essence difficult to compute and iterate numerically . we manage to overcome this difficulty by combining two special properties of our problem . on the one hand , the underlying process @xmath381 in the expression of the operator @xmath233 is a markov chain . therefore , it can be discretized using a quantization technique which is a powerful method suitable for numerical computation and iteration of conditional expectations . on the other hand , the recursion on the functions @xmath382 involving the operator @xmath233 can be transformed into a recursion on suitably defined random variables . thus they are easier to iterate numerically as we do not need to compute an approximation of each @xmath383 on the whole state space . this section is organized as follows . we first explain how the recursion on the functions @xmath382 can be transformed into a recurrence on random variables involving only the markov chain @xmath381 . then , we present a quantization technique to discretize this markov chain . afterwards , we construct a discretized version of the main operators in definition [ def op chapeau ] that is used to build an approximation of the value function in definition [ def v chap ] , and a computable @xmath0-optimal stopping time . the main results of this section are theorems [ theo - conv ] and [ th arret chap ] that prove the convergence of our approximation scheme and provide a rate of convergence . we first explain how the dynamic programming equations on the functions @xmath382 yield a recursion on the random variables @xmath384 . introduce now the sequence @xmath385 of random variables defined by @xmath386 in other words , one has @xmath387,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath388 . notice that @xmath389 is known and the expression of @xmath390 involves only @xmath391 and the markov chain @xmath381 . thus , the sequence @xmath392 is completely characterized by the system ( [ def vn ] ) . in addition , @xmath393 . thus to approximate the value function @xmath380 at the initial point of our process , it is sufficient to provide an approximation of the sequence of random variables @xmath394 . there exists an extensive literature on quantization methods for random variables and processes . we do not pretend to present here an exhaustive panorama of these methods . however , the interested reader may for instance , consult the following works @xcite and references therein . consider @xmath32 an @xmath395-valued random variable such that @xmath396 where @xmath397 denotes the @xmath34-nom of @xmath32 : @xmath398)^{1/p}$ ] . let @xmath399 be a fixed integer , the optimal @xmath34-quantization of the random variable @xmath32 consists in finding the best possible @xmath34-approximation of @xmath32 by a random vector @xmath33 taking at most @xmath399 values : @xmath400 . this procedure consists in the following two steps : 1 . find a finite weighted grid @xmath401 with @xmath402 . 2 . set @xmath403 where @xmath404 with @xmath405 denotes the closest neighbour projection on @xmath406 . the asymptotic properties of the @xmath34-quantization are given by the following result , see e.g. @xcite . [ theore ] if @xmath407<+\infty$ ] for some @xmath408 then one has @xmath409 where the distribution of @xmath32 is @xmath410 with @xmath411 , @xmath412 a constant and @xmath413 the lebesgue measure in @xmath414 . there exists a similar procedure for the optimal quantization of a markov chain . our approximation method is based on the quantization of the markov chain @xmath415 . thus , from now on , we will denote , for @xmath416 , @xmath417 . the clvq ( competitive learning vector quantization ) algorithm ( * ? ? ? * section 3 ) provides for each time step @xmath416 a finite grid @xmath418 of @xmath419 as well as the transition matrices @xmath420 from @xmath418 to @xmath421 . let @xmath422 such that for all @xmath423 , @xmath424 and @xmath425 have finite moments at least up to order @xmath426 and let @xmath427 be the nearest - neighbor projection from @xmath419 onto @xmath418 . the quantized process @xmath428 with value for each @xmath429 in the finite grid @xmath418 of @xmath419 is then defined by @xmath430 we will also denote by @xmath431 , the projection of @xmath418 on @xmath110 , and by @xmath432 , the projection of @xmath418 on @xmath433 . some important remarks must be made concerning the quantization . on the one hand , the optimal quantization has nice convergence properties stated by theorem [ theore ] . indeed , the @xmath434-quantization error @xmath435 goes to zero when the number of points in the grids goes to infinity . however , on the other hand , the markov property is not maintained by the algorithm and the quantized process is generally not markovian . although the quantized process can be easily transformed into a markov chain , this chain will not be homogeneous . it must be pointed out that the quantized process @xmath436 depends on the starting point @xmath437 of the process . in practice , we begin with the computation of the quantization grids , which merely requires to be able to simulate the process . notice that in our case , what is actually simulated is the sequence of observation @xmath438 . we are then able to compute the filter @xmath439 thanks to the recursive equation provided by proposition [ prop - rec - filtre ] . the grids are only computed once and for all and may be stored off - line . our schemes are then based on the following simple idea : we replace the process by its quantized approximation within the different recursions . the computation is thus carried out in a very simple way since the quantized process has finite state space . our approximation scheme of the sequence @xmath385 follows the same lines as in @xcite , but once more , the results therein can not be applied directly as the markov chain @xmath440 is not the underlying markov chain of some pdmp . our approach decomposes in two steps . the first one will be to discretize the time - continuous maximization of the operator @xmath233 to obtain a maximization over a finite set . the second step consists in replacing the markov chain @xmath441 by its quantized approximation @xmath442 within the dynamic programming equation . thus , the conditional expectations will become easily tractable finite sums . let us first build a finite time grid to discretize the continuous - time maximization in the expression of the operator @xmath233 . the maximum is originally taken over the set @xmath443 . however , it can be seen from definition [ def - g - h - i - j - l ] that @xmath444 for all @xmath445 . indeed , the random variable @xmath446 is bounded by the greatest deterministic exit time @xmath447 that is finite thanks to assumption [ hyp - ts - bounded ] . therefore , the maximization set can be reduced to the compact set @xmath448 $ ] . instead of directly discretizing the set @xmath448 $ ] , we will actually discretize the subsets @xmath207t^*_m , t^*_{m+1}[$ ] . the reason why we want to exclude the points @xmath449 from our grid is technical and will be explained with lemma [ xi3-indicator ] . now , it seems natural to distinguish wether @xmath450 or @xmath451 . let @xmath452 be the set of indices @xmath453 such that @xmath451 . notice that @xmath454 is not empty because it contains at least the index 0 since we assumed that @xmath455 . we can now build our approximation grid . let @xmath456 be such that @xmath457 for all @xmath458 , let @xmath459 be the finite grid on @xmath207{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[$ ] defined as follows @xmath460 where @xmath461 . we also denote @xmath462 [ rq - grm]let @xmath458 . notice that , thanks to eq . , @xmath459 is not empty . moreover , it satisfies two properties that will be crucial in the sequel : a. : : for all @xmath463 $ ] , there exists @xmath464 such that @xmath465 , b. : : for all @xmath464 and @xmath466 , one has @xmath467\subset ] { t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[$ ] . a discretized maximization operator @xmath468 is then defined as follows . [ def k ] let @xmath468 : @xmath469 be defined for all @xmath319 by @xmath470 with @xmath471.$ ] we now proceed to our second step : replacing the markov chain @xmath441 by its quantized approximation @xmath442 within the operators involved in the construction of the value function . [ def op chapeau ] we define the _ quantized operators _ @xmath472 , @xmath473 , @xmath474 , @xmath475 and @xmath476 for @xmath477 , @xmath478 , @xmath479 , @xmath480 and @xmath481 as follows @xmath482,\\ \widehat{h}_{n}h(\pi , u)=&\hspace{0.3cm}\sum_{i=1}^{q}\pi^{i}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{u < { t^{*}}_{i}\}}h\circ\phi(x_{i},u){\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{\widehat{s}_{n } > u\}}| \widehat \pi_{n-1}=\pi],\\ \widehat{j}_{n}(v , h)(\pi , u)=&\hspace{0.3cm}\widehat{h}_{n}h(\pi , u)+\widehat{g}_{n}v(\pi , u),\\ \widehat{k}_{n}v(\pi)=&\hspace{0.3cm}\widehat{j}_{n}(v , h)(\pi , t^*_q)=\hspace{0.3cm}{\mathbf{e}}[v(\widehat{\pi}_{n})| \widehat \pi_{n-1}=\pi],\\ \widehat l^{d}_{n}(v , h)(\pi)=&\hspace{0.3cm}\max_{m\in m}\big\{\max_{u\in gr_{m}(\delta)}\ { \widehat j_{n}(v , h)(\pi , u)\}\big\}\vee \widehat k_{n}v(\pi).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quantized approximation of the value functions naturally follows . [ def v chap ] for @xmath483 , define the functions @xmath484 on @xmath485 as follows @xmath486 for @xmath483 , let @xmath487 we may now state our main result for the numerical approximation . [ theo - conv ] suppose that for all @xmath388 , @xmath488 then , one has the following bound for the approximation error @xmath489\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_{p},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath490_{2}+2c_{g}c_{\lambda}$ ] , @xmath491 and @xmath492 + 4c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}]$ ] with @xmath493 $ ] , @xmath494 $ ] defined in proposition [ prop - lip - v ] and @xmath147_{2}$ ] defined in assumption [ hyp - g - lip ] . theorem [ theo - conv ] establishes the convergence of our approximation scheme and provides a bound for the rate of convergence . more precisely , it gives a rate for the @xmath34 convergence of @xmath495 towards @xmath496 . indeed , one has @xmath497 , so by virtue of theorem [ theo - conv ] @xmath498 can be made arbitrarily small when the quantization errors @xmath499 go to zero i.e. when the number of points in the quantization grids goes to infinity . in order to prove theorem [ theo - conv ] , we proceed similarly to @xcite and split the approximation error into four terms @xmath500 , with @xmath501 to obtain bounds for each of these terms , one needs to study the regularity of the operators and the value functions @xmath383 . the results are detailed in appendix [ apx lip ] . in particular , we establish in proposition [ prop - lip - v ] that the value functions @xmath383 are lipschitz continuous , yielding a bound for the first term . the first term @xmath502 is bounded as follows @xmath503\|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}\|_{p}.\ ] ] the other error terms are studied separately in the following sections . for the second error term , we investigate the consequences of replacing the continuous maximization in operator @xmath233 by a discrete one on @xmath504 . for all @xmath458 , @xmath505 and @xmath319 one has @xmath506_{2}+c_{g}c_{\lambda}+c_{v}c_{\lambda}\right)\delta.\ ] ] [ [ proof-9 ] ] proof + + + + + we use definition [ def - op - j - l ] to split operator @xmath507 into a sum of continuous operators @xmath508 . thus , one has @xmath509 } j^m(v , g)(\pi , u).\ ] ] the function @xmath510 being continuous , there exists @xmath511 $ ] such that @xmath512 } j^{m}(v , h)(\pi , u)=j^{m}(v , h)(\pi,\overline{t})$ ] . moreover , from remark [ rq - grm].a , one may chose @xmath513 so that @xmath514 . propositions [ prop - lip - h ] and [ prop - lip - g ] stating the lipschitz continuity of @xmath515 then yield @xmath516 } j^{m}(v , h)(\pi , u)-\max_{u\in gr_{m}(\delta ) } j^{m}(v , h)(\pi , u)\\ & \leq j^{m}(v , h)(\pi,\overline{t})-j^{m}(v , h)(\pi,\overline{u})\\ & \leq \left([g]_{2}+c_{g}c_{\lambda}+c_{v}c_{\lambda}\right)|\overline{t}-\overline{u}|\leq \left([g]_{2}+c_{g}c_{\lambda}+c_{v}c_{\lambda}\right)\delta,\end{aligned}\ ] ] showing the result . @xmath175 + the second term @xmath517 is bounded as follows @xmath518_{2}+2c_{g}c_{\lambda}\right)\delta.\ ] ] [ [ proof-10 ] ] proof + + + + + this is a straightforward consequence of the previous lemma once it has been noticed that for all @xmath519 , @xmath520 , @xmath521 , @xmath522 , one has @xmath523 . notice also that proposition [ prop - lip - v ] provides @xmath524 . @xmath175 + to investigate the third error term , we use the properties of quantization to bound the error made by replacing an operator by its quantized approximation . as in @xcite , we must first deal with non - continuous indicator functions . the fact that the @xmath449 and a small neighborhood around them do not belong to the discretization grid @xmath504 is crucial to obtain the following lemma . [ xi3-indicator ] for all @xmath388 , @xmath458 and @xmath466 , one has @xmath525\big\|_{p } \leq \eta^{-1}{\|s_{n+1}-\widehat s_{n+1}\|_{p}}+2\eta c_{\lambda}.\ ] ] [ [ proof-11 ] ] proof + + + + + let @xmath466 . the difference of the indicator functions equals 1 if and only if @xmath526 and @xmath527 are on different sides of @xmath528 . therefore , if the difference of the indicator functions equals 1 , either @xmath529 , or @xmath530 and in the latter case @xmath531 too since @xmath532 . one has @xmath533 leading to @xmath534\big\|_{p}\\ \leq \|{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{|s_{n+1}-\widehat s_{n+1}| > \eta\}}\|_{p } + \big\|\max_{u\in gr_{m}(\delta)}{\mathbf{e } } [ { \mathbbm{1}}_{\{|s_{n+1}-u|\leq \eta\ } } |\widehat \pi_{n}]\big\|_{p}.\end{gathered}\ ] ] on the one hand , markov inequality yields @xmath535 on the other hand , since @xmath464 , one has @xmath467\subset ] { t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[$ ] from remark [ rq - grm].b , thus @xmath526 has an absolutely continuous distribution on the interval @xmath467 $ ] since it does not contain any of the @xmath536 . besides , recall that @xmath537 , hence , the following inclusions of @xmath23-fields @xmath538 . we also have @xmath539 , the law of iterated conditional expectations provides @xmath540 & = & { \mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbf{e } } [ { \mathbbm{1}}_{\{|s_{n+1}-u|\leq \eta\ } } | { \mathfrak{f}}_{t_{n}}]\big| { \mathfrak{f}^{y}}_{t_{n}}\big]\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big]\\ & \leq & { \mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbf{e } } [ \int_{u-\eta}^{u+\eta}\lambda\big(\phi(z_{n},s)\big)ds\big| { \mathfrak{f}^{y}}_{t_{n}}]\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big]\\ & = & { \mathbf{e}}\big [ \sum_{i=1}^{q } \pi_{n}^{i}\int_{u-\eta}^{u+\eta}\lambda\big(\phi(x_{i},s)\big)ds\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , one obtains @xmath541\leq 2\eta c_{\lambda},$ ] showing the result . @xmath175 + [ xi3-k ] for all @xmath388 , one has @xmath542{\mathbf{e}}\big[|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big]+(2c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}]){\mathbf{e}}\left[|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right].\end{gathered}\ ] ] [ [ proof-12 ] ] proof + + + + + by the definitions of operators @xmath543 and @xmath544 , one has @xmath545-{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\widehat \pi_{n+1})| \widehat \pi_{n } ] |\nonumber\\ & \leq&{|{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})| \pi_{n}=\widehat \pi_{n } ] -{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})| \widehat \pi_{n } ] |}\nonumber\\ & & + { |{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})-v_{n+1}(\widehat \pi_{n+1})| \widehat \pi_{n } ] |}.\label{eq dif k}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second term in the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eq dif k ] ) is readily bounded by using proposition [ prop - lip - v ] stating that @xmath546 is lipschitz continuous @xmath547|\leq[v_{n+1}]{\mathbf{e}}\big[|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big].\ ] ] to deal with the first term in the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eq dif k ] ) , we need to use the special properties of quantization . indeed , one has @xmath548 so that we have the inclusion of @xmath23-fields @xmath549 . the law of iterated conditional expectations gives @xmath550={\mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})|(\pi_{n},s_{n})]\big| \widehat \pi_{n } \big].\ ] ] moreover , proposition [ prop - markov ] yields @xmath551={\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})|\pi_{n}]$ ] , as the conditional distribution of @xmath552 w.r.t . @xmath553 merely depends on @xmath31 . in addition , @xmath554 $ ] is @xmath555-measurable . one has then @xmath556-{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})| \widehat \pi_{n } ] |}\\ & = & \left|{\mathbf{e}}\big[{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})| \pi_{n}=\widehat \pi_{n } ] -{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})| \pi_{n } ] \big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big]\right|\\ & = & |{\mathbf{e}}[kv_{n+1}(\widehat \pi_{n})-kv_{n+1}(\pi_{n})|\widehat \pi_{n}]|,\end{aligned}\ ] ] by definition of @xmath543 . finally , one has @xmath557-{\mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\pi_{n+1})| \widehat \pi_{n } ] |}}\\ & \leq&2(c_g+[v_{n+1}]){\mathbf{e}}\left[|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] thanks to propositions [ prop - lip - k ] and [ prop - lip - v ] stating the lipschitz continuity of operator @xmath543 and function @xmath546 . @xmath175 + [ lemme - xi3 ] if @xmath558 satisfies condition ( [ conditiondelta ] ) , a upper bound for the third term @xmath559 is @xmath560\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_{p}+(4c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}])\|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}\|_{p}\\ & & + 2c_{g } ( 2 c_{\lambda})^{1/2}{\|s_{n+1}-\widehat s_{n+1}\|_{p}}^{1/2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ [ proof-13 ] ] proof + + + + + one has @xmath561 the term involving operator @xmath543 was studied in the previous lemma . let us now study the term involving operator @xmath507 . set @xmath453 in @xmath454 , @xmath528 in @xmath459 and define @xmath562 . one has then @xmath563-{\mathbf{e}}[\alpha(\widehat \pi_{n},\widehat \pi_{n+1},\widehat s_{n+1})|\widehat \pi_{n}]\right|\leq a+b,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where@xmath564-{\mathbf{e}}[\alpha(\pi_{n},\pi_{n+1},s_{n+1})|\widehat\pi_{n}]\right|,\\ b=&|{\mathbf{e}}[\alpha(\pi_{n},\pi_{n+1},s_{n+1})-\alpha(\widehat \pi_{n},\widehat \pi_{n+1},\widehat s_{n+1})\big|\widehat \pi_{n}]| . \ ] ] using the boundedness of @xmath18 and @xmath546 as well as the lipschitz continuity of @xmath546 given in proposition [ prop - lip - v ] , we get a upper bound for the second term @xmath565 + [ v_{n+1}]{\mathbf{e}}\big[|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big]\nonumber\\ & & + 2c_{g}{\mathbf{e}}\left[|{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{n+1}\leq u\}}-{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{\widehat s_{n+1}\leq u\}}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the first term , we use the properties of quantization as in the previous proof to obtain @xmath566-{\mathbf{e}}[\alpha(\pi_{n},\pi_{n+1},s_{n+1})|\pi_{n}]\big| \widehat \pi_{n}\big]\right|.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now recognize operator @xmath515 , and from propositions [ prop - lip - h ] and [ prop - lip - g ] , one has @xmath567\nonumber\\ & \leq & ( 3c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}]){\mathbf{e}}\left[|\widehat{\pi}_{n}-\pi_{n}\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we gather the bounds provided by eq . and to obtain @xmath568){\mathbf{e}}\big[|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}\big ] + [ v_{n+1}]{\mathbf{e}}\big[|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\big]\nonumber\\ & & + 2c_{g}{\mathbf{e}}\left[|{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{n+1}\leq u\}}-{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{\widehat s_{n+1}\leq u\}}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , combining the result for operators @xmath507 and lemma [ xi3-k ] , we obtain @xmath569{\mathbf{e}}\left[|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right]+(4c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}]){\mathbf{e}}\left[|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right]\\ & & + 2c_{g}\max_{u\in gr(\delta)}{\mathbf{e}}\left[|{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{n+1}\leq u\}}-{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{\widehat s_{n+1}\leq u\}}|\big|\widehat \pi_{n}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we conclude by taking the @xmath34 norm in the equation above and using lemma [ xi3-indicator ] to bound the last term @xmath570\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_p+(4c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}])\|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}\|_p\\ & & + 2c_{g}(\eta^{-1}{\|s_{n+1}-\widehat s_{n+1}\|_{p}}+2\eta c_{\lambda}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] for some @xmath466 . the best choice for @xmath571 minimizing the error is when @xmath571 satisfies @xmath572 which yields @xmath573 . if @xmath558 satisfies condition ( [ conditiondelta ] ) , one has @xmath574 as required for this optimal choice . @xmath175 + finally , the fourth error term is bounded using lipschitz properties . [ lemme - xi4 ] the fourth term @xmath575 is bounded as follows @xmath576\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_{p}+\|v_{n+1}-\widehat v_{n+1}\|_{p}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ [ proof-14 ] ] proof + + + + + one has @xmath577\nonumber\\ & & \vee { \mathbf{e}}[v_{n+1}(\widehat{\pi}_{n+1})-\widehat v_{n+1}(\widehat{\pi}_{n+1})| \widehat{\pi}_{n } ] \big\|_{p}\nonumber\\ & \leq&\|v_{n+1}(\widehat{\pi}_{n+1})-\widehat v_{n+1}(\widehat{\pi}_{n+1})\|_{p}.\label{jvchap}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now introduce @xmath578 to split this term into two differences . the lipschitz continuity of @xmath546 stated by proposition [ prop - lip - v ] allows us to bound the first term while we recognize @xmath391 and @xmath579 in the second one . @xmath580\left\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\right\|_{p}+\|v_{n+1}-\widehat v_{n+1}\|_{p}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , the result . @xmath175 + as in the previous section , we follow the idea of @xcite and we use both the markov chain @xmath581 and its quantized approximation @xmath582 to approximate the expression of the @xmath0-optimal stopping time introduced in definition [ def - sn - epsilon ] . we check that we thus obtain actual stopping times for the observed filtration @xmath29 and that the expected reward when stopping then is a good approximation of the value function @xmath496 . for all @xmath583 and @xmath483 , we denote @xmath584 . let @xmath585 for @xmath272 and @xmath319 , we define @xmath586 let now for @xmath120 , @xmath587 and set @xmath588 the following result is a direct consequence of proposition [ propb5 ] . it is a very strong result as it states that the numerically computable random variables @xmath589 are actual @xmath29-stopping times . for @xmath483 , @xmath589 is an @xmath29-stopping time . we now intend to prove that stopping at time @xmath590 provides a good approximation of the value function @xmath496 . for all @xmath591 and @xmath483 we therefore introduce the performance when abiding by the stopping rule @xmath592 and the corresponding random variables @xmath593,\qquad \overline{v}_{n}=\overline{v}_{n}(\pi_{n}).\ ] ] [ th arret chap ] suppose that for all @xmath388 , @xmath594 one has then the following bound for the error between the expected reward when stopping at time @xmath589 and the value function @xmath595\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_{p}\\ & & + b\|s_{n+1}-\widehat s_{n+1}\|_{p}^{1/2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath596 , @xmath597 $ ] , @xmath494 $ ] defined in proposition [ prop - lip - v ] . it is important to notice that @xmath598 and thus @xmath599 . therefore , the previous theorem proves that @xmath600 goes to zero when the quantization errors @xmath601 go to zero . in other words , the expected reward @xmath602 when stopping at the random time @xmath590 can be made arbitrarily close to the value function @xmath496 of the partially observed optimal stopping problem and hence @xmath590 is an @xmath0-optimal stopping time . [ [ proof-15 ] ] proof + + + + + the first step consists in finding a recursion satisfied by the sequence @xmath603 in order to compare it with the dynamic programming equation giving @xmath604 . let @xmath388 . first of all , proposition [ lemme value fonction ] gives @xmath605}\\ & = & \sum_{k=0}^{n - n-1}\sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{k}\leq \widehat{u}_{n - n}\}}{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{\widehat{r}_{n - n , k}<{t^{*}}_{i}\}}g\circ\phi(x_{i},\widehat{r}_{n - n , k})e^{-\lambda(x_{i},\widehat{r}_{n - n , k})}\pi_{k}^{i}|\pi_0]\\ & & + \sum_{i=1}^{q}{\mathbf{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{n - n}\leq \widehat{u}_{n - n}\}}g(x_{i})\pi_{n}^{i}|\pi_0].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the term corresponding to @xmath288 in the above sum equals @xmath606 . taking the conditional expectation w.r.t . @xmath292 in the other terms and noticing that one has @xmath607 yield @xmath608=hg(\pi_{0},\widehat{r}_{n - n,0})+{\mathbf{e}}[\xi''{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{s_{1}\leq \widehat{r}_{n - n,0}\}}|\pi_0],\ ] ] with @xmath609.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now make use of the markov property of the sequence @xmath151 in the term @xmath610 . similarly to lemma [ rnk - epsilon - theta ] , for @xmath120 , on the set @xmath611 , one has @xmath612 for all @xmath326 . thus , on the set @xmath611 , one has @xmath613 . recall that @xmath614 . we may therefore apply the markov property . using proposition [ lemme value fonction ] , we now obtain @xmath615 . finally , we have @xmath616 recall that @xmath617 and apply the translation operator @xmath618 to obtain the following recursion @xmath619 we are now able to study the error between @xmath620 and @xmath621 . let us recall that , from its definition , @xmath622 equals either @xmath623 or @xmath624 . in the latter case , notice that @xmath625 . eventually , one has @xmath626 to bound the first term @xmath47 , we introduce the function @xmath546 . one has @xmath627 let us study these four terms one by one . by definition of @xmath543 , the first term @xmath628 is bounded by @xmath629 $ ] . for the second term @xmath630 , we use proposition [ prop - lip - k ] stating the lipschitz continuity of the operator @xmath543 . the term third term @xmath631 is bounded by lemma [ xi3-k ] and a upper bound of the fourth term @xmath632 is given by eq . ( [ jvchap ] ) . thus , one obtains @xmath633)\|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}\|_{p}\\ & & + 2[v_{n+1}]\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_{p}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] we now turn to the second term @xmath634 . in the following computations , denote @xmath635 . its definition yields we split this expression into four differences again . on the set @xmath637 , one has the equality @xmath638 . hence , one this set , one obtains from eq . ( [ prog dyn vbar ] ) @xmath639 for the other terms , we use propositions [ prop - lip - h ] and [ prop - lip - g ] for the lipschitz continuity of @xmath507 and eq . ( [ eq j - jchap ] ) and ( [ jvchap ] ) to obtain @xmath640)\|\pi_{n}-\widehat \pi_{n}\|_{p}+2[v_{n+1}]\|\pi_{n+1}-\widehat \pi_{n+1}\|_{p}\\ & & + 2c_g(2c_{\lambda})^{1/2}\|s_{n+1}-\widehat s_{n+1}\|_{p}^{1/2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] after optimizing @xmath571 . the result is obtained by taking the maximum between @xmath47 and @xmath634 . we apply our procedure to a simple pdmp similar to the one studied in @xcite . let @xmath641 . for @xmath65 and @xmath642 , the flow is defined by @xmath643 so that @xmath644 . we set the jump rate to @xmath645 for some @xmath646 and the transition kernel @xmath647 to the uniform distribution on a finite set @xmath648 . thus , the process evolves toward 1 and the closer it gets to 1 , the more likely it will jump back to some point of @xmath93 . a trajectory is represented in figure [ plotecg ] . jump time with @xmath649 , @xmath650 and @xmath651 . the dotted lines represent the possible post - jump values.,width=302 ] the observation process is @xmath652 where @xmath653 and @xmath654 for some @xmath655 . finally , we choose the reward function @xmath656 . our assumptions thus clearly hold . simulations are run with @xmath649 , @xmath650 , @xmath657 , @xmath658 and @xmath659 . the numerical approximation is implemented as follows . first , we make an exact simulator for the sequence @xmath660 . from the values of @xmath661 , one builds the observation sequence @xmath662 that allows for a recursive computation of the filter process thanks to proposition [ prop - rec - filtre ] . thus , we can simulate trajectories of the markov chain @xmath381 that we feed into the clvq algorithm to obtain quantization grids . by monte carlo simulations , we can also estimate the quantization errors . to run our numerical procedure , one then needs to choose the parameter @xmath558 satisfying conditions ( [ eq - condition - delta ] ) and ( [ conditiondelta ] ) . in this special case , they boil down to @xmath663 we have chosen @xmath558 just above the monte carlo approximation of the lower bound . the values are given in the second column of table [ ecg_table ] for different grids sizes . then , we recursively compute the approximated value functions @xmath664 on the quantization grids . the conditional expectations are now merely weighted sums . the approximation we obtain for the value function of the partially observed optimal stopping problem are given in the fourth column of table [ ecg_table ] . finally , we implemented the construction of our @xmath0-optimal stopping time and ran @xmath665 monte carlo simulations to compute its mean performance . the results are given in the third column of table [ ecg_table ] . the exact value of @xmath496 is unknown but one has as in @xcite , @xmath666 \leq v_{0}=\sup_{\sigma\in\sigma_{n}^{y}}{\mathbf{e}}[g(x_{\sigma } ) ] \leq { \mathbf{e}}\big [ \sup_{0\leq t \leq t_{n}}g(x_{t})\big].\ ] ] both the first and the last term may be estimated by monte carlo simulations . one has thus , with @xmath667 trajectories , @xmath668=0.9944 $ ] . the theoretical bound @xmath669 of the error @xmath670 provided by theorem [ theo - conv ] is computed using the approximated quantization errors . this bound decreases as the number of points in the quantization grids increases , as expected . moreover , we computed the empirical bound given by eq . @xmath671-\widehat v_{0}| \big\}$ ] . .simulation results . the terms @xmath672 and @xmath669 respectively denote an empirical bound and the theoretical bound provided by theorem [ theo - conv ] for the error @xmath670 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in this section , we study the special structure of @xmath29-stopping times . [ prop - tn - stop - time ] for all @xmath673 , @xmath138 is an @xmath29-stopping time . [ [ proof-16 ] ] proof + + + + + notice that for all @xmath92 , @xmath674 . this stems from the absolute continuity of the distribution of the random variables @xmath186 since @xmath675 hence , for all @xmath92 and @xmath676 , one has @xmath131 a.s . @xmath677 where we denote @xmath678 . the process @xmath679 is @xmath680-adapted thus @xmath681 and since the filtration @xmath680 contains the @xmath131-null sets , one has @xmath682 . for all @xmath92 , @xmath138 is therefore an @xmath29-stopping time . @xmath175 + + we now recall theorem a2 t33 from @xcite concerning the structure of the stopping times for point processes and apply it in our case . define the filtration @xmath683 as follows @xmath684 [ theo - bremaud ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath683-stopping time . for all @xmath92 , there exists a @xmath685-measurable non negative random variable @xmath686 , such that one has @xmath687 our observation process @xmath15 being a point process that fits the framework developed in @xcite , we apply this theorem to @xmath29-stopping times . for all @xmath642 , one has @xmath688 . [ [ proof-17 ] ] proof + + + + + first prove that @xmath689 . let @xmath690 and @xmath691 , one has @xmath692 indeed , in the above equation , we used that @xmath693 and @xmath694 are assumed to be deterministic . for the reverse inclusion , let @xmath690 , @xmath120 and @xmath691 . recall that @xmath695 . one has @xmath696 since @xmath15 is @xmath680-adapted and @xmath138 is an @xmath29-stopping time from lemma [ prop - tn - stop - time ] . therefore , one has @xmath697 , showing the result . @xmath175 + + we may therefore apply theorem [ theo - bremaud ] to @xmath29-stopping times . [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath29-stopping time . for all @xmath92 , there exists a non negative random variable @xmath686 , @xmath156-measurable such that one has @xmath687 we outline the following result , which is a direct consequence of the above theorem , because it will be used several times in our derivation . [ lemme - tech - event ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath29-stopping time and @xmath698 be the sequence of random variables associated to @xmath23 as introduced in theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] . for all @xmath673 , @xmath699 [ [ proof-18 ] ] proof + + + + + theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] states that on the event @xmath700 , on has @xmath701 so that , still on the event @xmath700 , one has @xmath702 . we deduce the result from this observation . @xmath175 + + we now investigate the effect of the translation operator of the markov chain @xmath703 on the @xmath29-stopping times . proposition [ prop - markov ] states that @xmath703 is a @xmath238-markov chain . let us consider its canonical space @xmath704 . thus , for @xmath705 , one has @xmath706 . besides , we define the _ translation operator _ @xmath707 we then define @xmath708 and recursively for @xmath709 , @xmath710 . thus , for all @xmath711 , one has @xmath712 . as @xmath713 , one has @xmath714 the next results of this section are given without proof because their proofs follow the very same lines as in @xcite from which they are adapted . however , notice that the results from @xcite can not be applied directly to our case because the sequence @xmath703 , although it is a markov chain , is not the underlying markov chain of some pdmp . set now @xmath276 . from theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] , for all @xmath92 , there exists a non negative @xmath156-measurable random variable @xmath686 , such that , on the event @xmath715 , one has @xmath716 [ lemmeb2 ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath29-stopping time and @xmath698 be the sequence of random variables associated to @xmath23 as introduced in theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] . let @xmath717 and for @xmath289 , @xmath718 . one has then @xmath719 [ rq - rn - rnbar ] this lemma proves that in theorem [ theo - bremaud - adapted ] , the sequence @xmath720 can be replaced by @xmath721 . therefore , we can assume , without loss of generality that the sequence @xmath720 satisfies the following condition : for all @xmath92 , @xmath722 on the event @xmath723 . since @xmath724 and @xmath302 is @xmath347-measurable , there exists a sequence of real - valued measurable functions @xmath725 defined on @xmath726 such that @xmath727 , where @xmath728 . [ defb3 ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath29-stopping time and @xmath729 be the sequence of functions associated to @xmath23 as introduced in remark [ rq - rn - rnbar ] . let @xmath730 and @xmath731 be a sequence of functions defined on @xmath732 by @xmath733 and for @xmath289 , @xmath734 [ propb4 ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath29-stopping time and @xmath735 ( respectively , @xmath731 ) be the sequence of functions associated to @xmath23 as introduced in lemma [ lemmeb2 ] ( respectively , in definition [ defb3 ] ) . assume that @xmath736 . for all @xmath737 , one has then @xmath738 and @xmath739 , with @xmath306 : @xmath740 defined as @xmath741 [ propb5 ] let @xmath742 be a sequence of non negative random variables such that for all @xmath13 , @xmath743 is @xmath156-measurable and @xmath744 on @xmath745 . we define @xmath746 then @xmath747 is an @xmath29-stopping time . [ corb6 ] let @xmath23 be an @xmath29-stopping time and @xmath306 be the mapping associated to @xmath23 introduced in proposition [ propb4 ] . for all @xmath748 , @xmath749 is a @xmath29-stopping time . the objective of this section is to prove the technical lemma [ lemme - tech - esp - cond ] used in the proof of proposition [ lemme value fonction ] . [ lemme - tech - esp - cond ] for all @xmath750 , one has @xmath751={\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r_{k}<{t^{*}}(z_{k})\}}e^{-\lambda(z_{k},r_{k})}.$ ] [ [ proof-19 ] ] proof + + + + + first recall some results concerning the random variables @xmath752 , details may be found in @xcite . after a jump of the process to the point @xmath753 , the survival function of the time until the next jump is @xmath754 define its generalized inverse @xmath755 . then , for all @xmath737 , one has @xmath756 , where @xmath757 are i.i.d . random variables with uniform distribution on @xmath758 $ ] independent from @xmath759 . thus , one has @xmath751={\mathbf{e}}[f(\upsilon_{k},z_{k},r_{k})|{\mathfrak{f}}_{t_{k}}]$ ] where @xmath760 . as @xmath761 is @xmath759-measurable , @xmath757 is independent from @xmath759 and @xmath762={\mathbbm{1}}_{\{r<{t^{*}}(z)\}}e^{-\lambda(z , r)}$ ] , ( * ? ? ? * proposition 11.2 ) yields the result . in this section , we derive the lipschitz properties of our operators in order to obtain them for the value functions @xmath260 . similarly to the proof of proposition [ prop - markov ] , we first derive the integral form of operators @xmath282 and @xmath763 . now , notice that the functions @xmath767 and @xmath768 are not continuous . however , they are cdlg with a finite number of jumps . therefore , they can be rewritten as sums of continuous functions as follows . [ rq - continu - hm ] for all @xmath769 and for all @xmath479 , @xmath505 and @xmath764 , the functions @xmath780 , @xmath781 and @xmath510 are continuous . moreover , they are constant on @xmath782 $ ] and on @xmath783 and one has @xmath784 since the function @xmath781 is constant on the intervals @xmath782 $ ] and @xmath783 , we may assume that @xmath528 , @xmath787 $ ] so that one has @xmath788 and similarly for @xmath789 . then , on the one hand , one has @xmath790 on the other hand , lemma a.1 in @xcite yields @xmath791_{2}+c_{g}c_{\lambda})|u-\tilde u|,\ ] ] showing the result . @xmath175 + + the following technical lemma will be useful to derive the lipschitz properties of the operator @xmath792 . the first part of its proof is adapted from @xcite . let @xmath795{t^{*}}_{m};{t^{*}}_{m+1}[$ ] and @xmath796 . in the following computation , we denote @xmath797 and @xmath798 , one has @xmath799 notice that @xmath800 so that the second sum above reduces to @xmath801 . finally , one has @xmath802 as @xmath803 and @xmath804 , one obtains on the one hand , one clearly has @xmath810 on the other hand , one has @xmath811 besides , we have assumed that @xmath380 is lipschitz continuous so that one has @xmath812\big|\psi(\pi , y',s')-\psi(\tilde \pi , y',s')\big|.\ ] ] thus , one has @xmath813\sum_{i=1}^{q}\pi^{i}\int_{0}^{{t^{*}}_{i}}\int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{d}}\big|\psi(\pi , y',s')-\psi(\tilde \pi , y',s')\big|\\ & & \sum_{j=1}^{q}q\big(\phi(x_{i},s'),x_{j}\big)f_{w}(y'-\varphi(x_{j}))\lambda\circ\phi(x_{i},s')e^{-\lambda(x_{i},s')}dy'ds'\\ & \leq & c_{v}|\pi-\tilde \pi|+[v]\sum_{m=0}^{q-1}\sum_{i = m+1}^{q}\pi^{i}\int_{{t^{*}}_{m}}^{{t^{*}}_{m+1}}\int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{d}}\big|\psi(\pi , y',s')-\psi(\tilde \pi , y',s')\big|\\ & & \times\sum_{j=1}^{q}q\big(\phi(x_{i},s'),x_{j}\big)f_{w}(y'-\varphi(x_{j}))\lambda\circ\phi(x_{i},s')e^{-\lambda(x_{i},s')}dy'ds'\\ & \leq & c_{v}|\pi-\tilde \pi|+[v]\sum_{m=0}^{q-1}\int_{{t^{*}}_{m}}^{{t^{*}}_{m+1}}\int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{d}}\big|\psi(\pi , y',s')-\psi(\tilde \pi , y',s')\big|\overline{\psi}_{m}(\pi , y',s')dy'ds'.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the previous lemma provides the result . @xmath175 + as in the proof of proposition [ prop - lip - h ] , we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath528 , @xmath787 $ ] so that one has @xmath815 and similarly for @xmath816 . the second term does not depend on @xmath528 thus @xmath817 as @xmath818 by proposition [ prop - rec - filtre ] . this yields the result . @xmath175 + we proved that @xmath261 is the value function of the optimal stopping problem with horizon @xmath262 thus one has @xmath828\leq c_{g}.$ ] therefore @xmath261 is bounded and @xmath827 . the second assessment is proved by backward induction . let @xmath144 , @xmath829 . one has @xmath830 therefore , we have the result for @xmath831 with @xmath832\leq c_{g}$ ] . moreover , since @xmath833 for @xmath388 , proposition [ prop - lip - l ] yields @xmath493\leq 3c_{g}+2[v_{n+1}]$ ] which proves the propagation of the induction . @xmath175 + g. pags , h. pham , and j. printems . optimal quantization methods and applications to numerical problems in finance . in _ handbook of computational and numerical methods in finance _ , pages 253297 . birkhuser boston , boston , ma , 2004 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the question of the causal behavior of superluminal propagations has been often debated , in rather different contexts : tachyonic particles ( e.g. @xcite ) , field theories @xcite and quantum induced superluminal propagations @xcite . the issue is however controversial , even on specific contexts , and we intend to clarify it . we will focus on classical field theories _ whose full action is lorentz invariant _ ( or diffeomorphism invariant whenever einstein s gravity is taken into account ) . in that case , superluminal behavior can only arises from spontaneous breaking of local lorentz invariance by non trivial backgrounds ( or vacua ) . superluminal behavior then occurs when some sector of the theory is left unbroken , so that some degrees of freedom can propagate faster than other ones @xcite . superluminal propagations induced by vacuum polarization provide well - known examples of this phenomenon . note that we define superluminal behavior as going faster than gravitons [ i.e. , gravitational waves ] . we denote @xmath0 the speed of gravitons in vacuum . this maybe unconventional definition will not affect our arguments . in the standard theory of gravity photons propagate along the gravitational metric so that this definition is the usual one in that case . our general analysis will enable us to investigate the causal behavior of any field coupled to standard gravity . we will illustrate our arguments in three important cases : k - essence scalar fields , bimetric theories of gravity and quantum induced superluminal propagations . we will make constant use of many important ideas and tools that were developed in order to investigate the causal behavior of gr , and we refer notably to @xcite . in sec . [ causalite ] , we analyze in detail the meaning of causality in classical field theories . we stress the important role played by the notions of chronology , time arrow and cauchy problem in its definition . as an illustration , we show how causality is usually formulated in the theory of general relativity ( gr ) . we stress that superluminal propagations are automatically discarded if one assumes that causality should be defined with respect to the chronology induced by the gravitational metric . this _ postulate _ actually `` sets the [ gravitational ] metric apart from the other fields on @xmath1 and gives it its distinctive geometrical character '' @xcite . this prior assumption can not be supported by any mathematical reason but only by experiment . if superluminal propagations were found in the laboratory , it would thus _ not _ mean that causality , locality , or the entire framework of special relativity would be lost , but simply that the gravitational field does not have any fundamental geochronological character . in particular , causality should not be expressed in terms of the chronology induced by the gravitational metric field . as a consequence , it is necessary to drop such prior assumptions to address the issue of the causal behavior of superluminal fields . in sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] we thus look for a minimal expression of causality in which no prior chronology is assumed . in that framework , superluminal propagations are generically allowed . before moving to superluminal and causal theories , we display two well known examples of noncausal theories and notably the tachyonic one . it enables us to stress how noncausal behaviors are related to constraints on initial data . we also comment on the causal paradoxes that arise in a non causal theory . we finally briefly investigate what kind of field theory can lead to superluminal propagation . we consider in sec . [ sectionkessence ] a k - essence scalar field @xmath2 , which can propagate superluminally along an effective metric @xmath3 $ ] . we find that the scalar field is causal provided that the spacetime embedded with the effective metric @xmath4 is globally hyperbolic . here @xmath4 is the effective metric evaluated on a solution @xmath5 to the field equation ( the background ) . this condition puts some generic constraints on the free function defining the theory , and is generally satisfied on reasonable backgrounds . we emphasize that the claim that such scalar fields are not causal even on globally hyperbolic backgrounds @xcite can only hold if a prior role is attributed to the gravitational ( or flat ) metric , an assumption that , we believe , was implicit in these works . the only threat for causality actually lies in global properties of backgrounds @xcite , and this can be related to the so - called chronology protection conjecture . in sec . [ bimetrictheories ] , we investigate the question of causality in a bimetric theory of gravity , in which the matter sector is universally coupled to a metric @xmath6 that can differ from the einstein - hilbert metric @xmath7 . these two metrics generally define two distinct `` causal '' cones . photons can travel faster than gravitons , and conversely . if causality is defined with respect to the chronology induced by the gravitational metric , then causality forces the matter metric @xmath6 to define a cone which coincide or lie within the gravitational cone , and conversely . these two choices of chronology have been considered in the literature , thus leading to opposite requirements on the theory . this will illustrate the fact that there is no clear reason why a metric , or a chronology , should be preferred to the other . we argue that the theory is actually causal if no prior chronology is assumed , but the solution to the cauchy problem depends , of course , on the precise dynamics of the matter sector . in sec . [ sectionqed ] , we briefly show how our analysis apply to the case of quantum induced superluminal propagations . this enables us to conclude that superluminal velocities do not threaten causality , a point that were still controversial . let us emphasize that the question of causality in k - essences or bimetric theories is not just of academical interest , since these theories have drawn much attention recently . quite generally , it is claimed that causality forces one of the cone to be wider than the others ones ( be it the gravitational or the matter one ) @xcite and this puts some constraints on the theory . our motivated definition of causality will however not support these claims . such a k - essence scalar field was notably used as a ( dynamical ) dark energy fluid responsible of the late time acceleration of the universe @xcite , as well as a fluid that drives inflation @xcite . it is also used as a new gravitational field in addition to the metric one in some relativistic theories of modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ) , that are intended to account for the mass discrepancy at astrophysical scales without invoking dark matter @xcite . some of these models were notably discarded because of the presence of superluminal propagations . bimetric theories are also an essential piece of some recent mond - like theories @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . moreover , it represents the best motivated framework that reproduces a varying speed of light scenario @xcite that may address the problems of standard cosmology in a rather different way than inflation does . indeed some vsl theories , in which the speed of light @xmath0 is replaced by a changing velocity @xmath8 _ inside _ the equation of motions @xcite , however interesting phenomenologically , are not satisfying theoretically @xcite ( the resulting theory can not be derived from an action ) . in the last section [ applications ] , we consider some applications of our work to these field theories . we investigate the links between causality and stability in k - essences theories . we show that ( k - essence ) ghosts stabilization might suffer from a serious problem . we also show that , if one reproduces the mond phenomenology with the help of a k - essence scalar field , then a slight modification of milgrom s law is necessary for the theory to be causally well - behaved . it leads to a non trivial modification of the phenomenology in the very low acceleration regime . we also comment on a simpler theory that reproduces the mond phenomenology , using only one scalar field . the initial value formulation of this theory has still to be checked and we leave it for further work . we briefly show how this framework can account for the pioneer anomaly , and we finally make some comments about vsl theories . we use , throughout the paper , the sign conventions of @xcite and notably the mostly @xmath9 signature . the flat metric is denoted @xmath10 or @xmath11 in a coordinate system . we denote @xmath7 the gravitational metric field ( which obeys the einstein equation ) and @xmath6 the matter metric to which matter field couples . unless specified , indices are moved with the help of the gravitational metric @xmath7 . in the present paper , we are interested in the superluminal behavior of some matter fields in a gr - like context . the metric field @xmath7 follows the dynamics induced by the einstein - hilbert action . by spacetime we will always mean a couple ( @xmath12 ) , where @xmath1 is a four - dimensional differentiable manifold and @xmath13 some non degenerate lorentzian metric on it . a superluminal signal , _ by definition _ , propagates along spacelike curves of the gravitational metric @xmath7 . by causality we usually mean the ability to find a cause to an effect . since cause and effects are both described in terms of some physical variables , the usual principle of causality states that physical variables should be unambiguously determined at a given time from their values at a time before . we also demand that this retrodiction can be converted forward in time , so that we should also be able to predict a future situation from a present one . the principle of causality thus requires that determinism holds `` in both directions of time '' . causality demands the existence and uniqueness of solutions to the equations of motion given some initial data . in mathematical words , equations of motion must have a well - posed cauchy problem , or initial value formulation . note that this definition shows that a time - ordering , or chronology , must exist between two spacetime points that are causally connected . unlike newton s theory where a global chronology preexists to dynamics because of the prior topology assigned to spacetime , namely @xmath14 , field theories ( including einstein s gravity ) do _ not _ involve a preexistent notion of time and chronology . on the contrary , any relativistic field @xmath15 defines its own chronology on @xmath1 by means of the metric @xmath16 along which it propagates . any lorentzian metric indeed induces a local chronology in the tangent space through the usual special relativistic notions of absolute ( i.e. , lorentz invariant ) future and past . let us consider one particular field @xmath17 that propagates along a metric @xmath13 . it is important to note that this metric may not induce a global chronology on the whole spacetime . this is the case if local causal cones of @xmath13 are distributed on the manifold in such a way that there exists a curve over @xmath1 which is everywhere future - directed timelike but closed . in that case , the field @xmath17 propagates along a closed curve and an event could be _ both _ the cause and the effect of another event . causality requires that it does not happen . the strongest way to prevent it is to require the global hyperbolicity exists @xcite . it can then be proved that the spacetime has the topology of @xmath18 , so that a global time function , i.e. , a global chronology exists . ] of the spacetime ( @xmath12 ) . let us emphasize that causality also requires a notion of time flow . it is indeed worth recalling that even if the above metric @xmath13 defines a global notion of future and past , we have also to require that the field @xmath17 can only propagate in the future . if it could , on the contrary , propagate both in future and in past , one could always form a closed timelike curve with it . on the other hand , global hyperbolicity is enough to guarantee that no closed _ future - directed _ timelike curves ( cftc ) exists . when there is a finite number of metrics @xmath16 on @xmath1 , the discussion of global properties is slightly more involved , see sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] . let us illustrate the previous discussion . in gr , causality is generally expressed by the following properties @xcite : 1 . the gravitational metric @xmath7 must define a global chronology on spacetime . 2 . `` the null cones of the matter equations coincide or lie within the null cone of the spacetime metric @xmath7 '' . @xcite 3 . the whole set of equations of motion must admit a well - posed cauchy problem . the point ( a ) guarantees the existence of a global time ordering on @xmath1 and the point ( c ) is the formal expression of determinism . note that it is a non trivial mathematical property of systems of differential equations . its satisfaction in gr therefore critically depends on the precise dynamics of the matter sector . the point ( b ) excludes faster - than - graviton propagation . equivalently then , it means that any initial data set on spacelike hypersurfaces with respect to the gravitational metric @xmath7 are allowed . since the metric @xmath7 defines a global chronology on spacetime , so does any other metric @xmath16 associated to the propagation of some matter fields ) is globally hyperbolic and if @xmath19 is a metric whose null cone coincide or lie within the null cone of the metric @xmath13 _ everywhere on _ @xmath1 , then ( @xmath20 ) is globally hyperbolic . ] . the conditions ( a ) and ( b ) therefore ensures that no cftc exist for any metric ( be it @xmath7 or any metric @xmath16 ) . let us emphasize that , in the above formulation ( a)(c ) , the gravitational metric field clearly plays a preferred role . both conditions ( a ) and ( b ) are such that causality is actually defined with respect to the chronology induced by the metric @xmath7 . this can be understood as a `` _ _ postulate _ _ which sets the metric * g * apart from the other fields on @xmath1 and gives it its distinctive geometrical character '' ( @xcite @xmath21 , emphasis added ) . the chronology defined by @xmath7 is thus assumed to be a preferred one on @xmath1 . this postulate is however arguable because , as we pointed out , any relativistic field induces its own chronology on spacetime . it notably means that if a signal made of waves of some field @xmath15 propagates between two spacetime points , then these points can be time - ordered with the help of the metric @xmath16 , and causality may be preserved even if the field propagates superluminally . the gravitational metric field @xmath7 is just one particular field on @xmath1 and there is no clear reasons why it should be favored . let us finally stress that the three conditions ( a)(c ) are actually not sufficient to guarantee ( usual ) causality . indeed , if information were allowed to travel as well forward as backward in time , as it is the case in any time reversal invariant theories , then it would be always possible to have information running along a closed curve in spacetime . thus the absence of cftc does not suffice to guarantee the usual notion of causality , unless one specifies that a _ flow _ of time exists and that information can only go forward in time . the three points ( a)(c ) are clearly time - reversal invariant statements and therefore can not address this issue . note that both classical and quantum field theories are time - reversal invariant so that they may not be considered as `` causal '' in the usual sense . the emergence of the flow of time from thermodynamics in quantum field theory is a quite involved question that we will not consider here . in the present paper , we will therefore restrict ourselves to such a time - reversal invariant notion of causality , but one should keep in mind that thermodynamics may be the key to understand fully the ( coarse - grained ) notion of causality . we stressed that superluminal behaviors are automatically discarded by the above postulate . one may try to justify it by arguing that , since @xmath7 reduces locally to @xmath10 and therefore gives to the tangent space its special relativistic ( minkowskian ) structure , going faster than gravitons would `` undermine the entire framework of relativity theory '' @xcite . let us however stress that any other metric @xmath16 can also be reduced locally to its fundamental form in adapted `` inertial '' coordinates . these coordinates transform under the action of the lorentz group @xmath22 with an invariant speed @xmath23 _ that can differ from _ @xmath0 , if the cones of @xmath16 and @xmath7 do not coincide [ due for instance to some spontaneous breaking of local lorentz invariance , see sec . [ causatheoriessuperluminiques ] ] . these coordinates are actually relevant if one uses rods and clocks made of the field @xmath17 that propagates along @xmath13 . the fact that @xmath7 reduces locally to the flat spacetime metric can therefore not be used to claim that @xmath7 should be a preferred field on @xmath1 . we will come back to this important point later , see sec . [ bimetricsuperlum ] . we may therefore drop the above postulate and look for a minimal expression of causality in which no prior chronology is assumed . let us consider a collection of fields @xmath15 that propagate along some metrics @xmath16 ( gravity included ) . we are led to the picture of a finite set of `` causal '' cones at each points of spacetime . we do not want to prefer one metric with respect to the others , because there is no reason why , locally , some sets of coordinates , or some rods and clocks should be preferred : coordinates are meaningless in gr . the cones defined by the metrics @xmath16 may therefore be in any relative position with respect to one another . moreover , these cones may even tip over each others depending on the location on spacetime . we have however to guarantee that no signal can propagate along a closed curve . for this it is not sufficient to require the global hyperbolicity of each spacetime ( @xmath24 ) . indeed , fields may interact together , and we may form a physical signal which propagates on spacetime along different metrics . we shall rather define a extended notion of future - directed timelike curves , by requiring that at each point of the curve , the tangent vector is future - directed timelike with respect to _ at least _ one of the metrics @xmath16 . such a construction have been already advocated in @xcite . all the ( extended ) notions of future , past , domains of dependence , achronal sets , cauchy surfaces , global hyperbolicity then follow . this corresponds to a `` mixed '' notion of chronology : a point @xmath25 is in the ( extended ) future of @xmath26 if it is in the future of @xmath26 for at least one of the metrics @xmath16 , see fig . ( [ figurefuture ] ) . a spacetime interval is thus spacelike in the extended sense if it is spacelike with respect to _ all _ metrics @xmath16 . the hatched part shows the extended future defined by two metrics ( solid and dashed lines ) in the case where one metric defines a wider cone than the other one ( left ) , and in the opposite case ( right).,width=6 ] causality then requires that a global ( mixed ) chronology on spacetime exists . in other words , spacetime must be globally hyperbolic in that extended sense . this straightforward generalization enables us to express the miniminal formulation of causality by the following properties : 1 . the mixed chronology defined by the set of metrics @xmath16 must be a global chronology on spacetime . the whole set of equations of motion must admit a well - posed cauchy problem . the formulation of causality ( a)(c ) is immediately obtained from these more general requirements whenever the matter light cones coincide or lie within the gravitational one . we thus see that fields can propagate superluminally without threatening causality provided that we do not refer to any preferred chronology on spacetime . the cauchy problem of some field @xmath17 will be well posed depending on the precise equation of motion , and if initial data are set on surfaces that are spacelike with respect to the metric @xmath13 along which it propagates . moreover , if we are interested in the whole theory ( gravity included ) , the cauchy problem will be well posed if initial data are set on surfaces that are spacelike in the extended sense , that is _ spacelike with respect to all metrics @xmath16 _ ) . it must be stressed that , in gr , the fact that @xmath7 defines a global chronology can not be proved , for the reason that local physics does not determine the topology of spacetime , which could however prevent the existence of a global chronology . this the case for instance , of non time - orientable spacetimes . moreover , there exists exact solutions to the einstein equations that do not describe globally hyperbolic spacetimes , as explicitly shown by the kerr solution , which possess closed timelike curves , or gdel s universe . einstein equations thus admit solutions that violate causality . this difficulty is entirely subsumed into the so - called chronology protection conjecture @xcite that asserts that the local laws of physics are such that they prevent the formation of cftcs in spacetime . this has not been proved yet , so that we usually assume from the beginning that spacetime ( @xmath27 ) is globally hyperbolic . as long as the conjecture is not proved , such a restriction is not dynamical , but of epistemological nature@xcite . let us stress that in our extended framework , and notably in presence of superluminal matter fields , we will not be able to prove either that the condition ( a ) holds . we will have to _ assume _ that spacetime is globally hyperbolic in the extended sense . again , if we were able to prove the chronology protection conjecture , we would not have to make such a non trivial assumption . we will discuss further this point in sec . [ kessencesglobal ] . in other words , the condition ( a ) will have to be imposed by hand , just as in gr . as we already explained , we will not consider the issue of the existence of the flow of time , and thus , in the following , we will mostly be concerned by the point ( b ) . we provide in the next section two examples of theories that do not admit a well - posed cauchy problem . it enables us to show the deep relationship between non causal behaviors , closed curves in spacetime and constraints on initial data . an obviously non causal theory is an elliptic klein - gordon scalar field with an equation of motion @xmath28 , and where the metric @xmath13 has the signature @xmath29 . this elliptic equation does not have a well posed cauchy problem . it can be simply interpreted as the fact that this euclidean metric does not select the time coordinate as special compared to the spatial one . there is thus no available notion of propagation and initial data on three - surfaces can not be propagated in four dimensions . on the contrary , a lorentzian signature for @xmath13 guarantees that the equation is hyperbolic and that , by virtue of well - known theorems @xcite , the cauchy problem is well posed . we consider now the more interesting case of tachyonic particles . by tachyons we mean particles or signals that can be sent at a superluminal speed relative to the emitter ) ] . as correctly recognized in many papers in the literature , tachyons are not causal ( see , e.g. @xcite ) . indeed , they can always be used construct closed curves in spacetime along which a ( tachyonic ) signal propagate . consider for instance an observer @xmath30 who sends at time @xmath31 a signal to observer @xmath32 ( event @xmath33 ) , who in turn sends a signal back to @xmath30 , at time @xmath34 ( event @xmath35 ) . this last signal can be received by @xmath30 at a time @xmath36 ( event @xmath37 ) , if signals can be sent from @xmath32 at a superluminal speed and if @xmath30 and @xmath32 are in some relative motion at a speed @xmath38 , see fig . ( [ figuretachyons ] ) . information can therefore propagate along the closed curve in spacetime ( @xmath39 ) . the closed curve followed by the tachyonic signal viewed in the rest frame of @xmath30 . the tachyon is sent by @xmath30 at time @xmath31 ( event @xmath33 ) and received by @xmath32 at time @xmath34 ( event @xmath35 ) . since @xmath32 moves with respect to @xmath30 , the tachyonic signal he sends back to @xmath30 is actually received before it was sent , at time @xmath40 ( event @xmath37 ) . the thin line represents the minkowski cone , and horizontal and vertical lines are the space and time axis in the frame of @xmath30.,width=6 ] the theory is not causal because an event along this curve will influence itself , after the signal had gone one time round the curve . such an event is thus not freely specifiable , and we see that propagation of information along a closed curve in spacetime _ always _ lead to constraints on initial data . on the contrary , if the cauchy problem were well posed for such a theory , it would notably mean that there exists surfaces on which initial data can be freely specified ( up to possible constraints arising from gauge invariance , if any ) and unambiguously evolved with time . it shows that the present theory can not possess a well posed cauchy problem . before going further , let us comment the previous experimental device . suppose ( situation @xmath41 ) that , if @xmath32 receives a signal from @xmath30 , he sends a signal backwards in time to @xmath30 . then @xmath30 receives a signal at time @xmath42 and is thereby _ forced _ to send a signal to @xmath32 an instant later . it explicitly shows the constraints that appear in the case of propagations along closed curves . a temporal ( or causal ) paradox can even arise if we consider the following experimental device ( situation @xmath43 ) : when @xmath32 receives a signal from @xmath30 , he sends him back a signal , and @xmath30 sends a signal to @xmath32 _ only if _ he did not receive anything from @xmath32 . one may wonder what happens in that case . if @xmath30 receives a signal from @xmath32 , he will not send a signal to @xmath32 who in turn would not send a signal back to @xmath30 , and this contradicts the hypothesis . the other possibility , when @xmath30 does not receive anything from @xmath32 , is also inconsistent . this is in fact a version of the famous `` grandfather paradox '' . remarkably , there is no answer to the above question `` what happens ? '' . it is however immediate to see that this question implicitly assumes that the knowledge of the initial data at time @xmath42 for instance ( @xmath30 receives a signal from @xmath32 or not ) is enough to determine what will happen `` later '' along the curve . this question thus assumes that causality ( or determinism ) holds , whereas it can not even be defined , since there is no available notion of time - ordering along a closed curve . on the contrary , we have seen that such a closed curve leads to constraints on initial data . the event at time @xmath42 is strongly correlated to itself so that the only relevant question reads `` are any of the two initial conditions : @xmath30 receives -or does not receive- a signal from @xmath32 allowed ? '' . clearly the answer to this last question is negative . let us emphasize that situation @xmath43 ( the grandfather s paradox ) is often taken as an example of bad causal behavior induced by tachyonic particles ( or accordingly , induced by the use of time machines ) . this point is however not justifiable because the paradox only arises if we ask the wrong question . this experimental device simply _ can not _ exist since there is no initial data consistent with it . there is nothing to do here with causality , but only with logics : temporal paradoxes do not exist . on the other hand , the noncausal situation @xmath41 can exist ( constrained initial data exists that correspond to this experiment ) . tachyonic particles propagate superluminally and violate causality . this does not mean however that any superluminal propagations does . indeed , the closed curve in fig . ( [ figuretachyons ] ) can only be constructed if the speed of the tachyonic signal depends on the speed of the emitter in the rest frame of @xmath32 , and then deduces , using a lorentz boost , that it travels backward in time in the frame of @xmath30 , see @xcite . ] . this is not the case in metric description of superluminal propagations that we will mostly be concerned with . here we wish to investigate briefly what may look like a field theory that involves superluminal propagation . in a theory whose whole action is lorentz - invariant , the only possibility to open up the causal cones is to modify the propagational part of the dispersion relation . it can be achieved by adding higher - order derivatives in the action , but unless these terms arise from the low energy limit of some uv - complete theory , the theory is generically unstable @xcite . superluminal behavior for instance arises from quantum corrections to electrodynamics in non trivial vacua , see sec . [ sectionqed ] . on the other hand , we could still have second order , but nonlinear , equations of motions . we will consider two examples of such theories in the following sections . this nonlinearity , which is essential to obtain unusual dispersion relations , leads to a background - dependent cauchy problem . accordingly , lorentz invariance of the action is spontaneously broken through non trivial backgrounds and it allows superluminal propagations . note also that the speed of small perturbations around the background only depends on the background and _ not _ of the motion of the emitter . superluminal signals in field theories are not tachyonic in the sense indicated in the previous section . note that we could also have considered non - lorentz invariant lagrangians like @xmath44 , where @xmath45 . we will not consider such lagrangian in the present paper . in practice , the theories we will consider will lead to similar field equations , but only through a spontaneous breaking of local lorentz invariance by non trivial backgrounds . let us consider a so - called k - essence scalar field theory , whose action reads @xmath46.\ ] ] where @xmath47 and @xmath48 and @xmath49 are some functions , @xmath50 some mass scale and @xmath51 . hereafter we also take @xmath52 . note that the more general form @xmath53 is often considered , but the following arguments also apply to this case . let us first neglect the coupling to gravity which will be considered later , and consider that @xmath7 is flat . the field equation then reads @xmath54 where the effective metric @xmath55 is given by @xmath56 and a prime denotes derivation with respect to @xmath57 . scalar waves propagate inside the `` scalar cone '' defined by this effective metric . this cone generally differs from the gravitational one unless @xmath58 , see sec . [ superluminalkessence ] . this equation is a special case of quasilinear second order differential equation . a theorem due to leray then proves @xcite that this equation has a well posed cauchy problem if spacetime ( @xmath59 ) is globally hyperbolic , where @xmath4 is the effective metric evaluated on a solution @xmath5 to the field equation eq . ( [ eqchampkessencemat ] ) . hereafter , we will refer to @xmath5 as the background . the initial data have to be specified on three - surfaces that are spacelike with respect to the background metric @xmath4 , in deep connection with the discussion of sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] . a necessary but not sufficient condition for global hyperbolicity is the lorentzian signature of the background metric @xmath4 , which notably ensures that the field equation is hyperbolic . by diagonalization of the matrix @xmath4 , we find that its signature is @xmath60 everywhere over @xmath1 if and only if [ condhyperkessencemat ] @xmath61 @xmath62 where @xmath63 . _ in particular _ , if the function @xmath48 is such that the above inequalities are satisfied for all @xmath57 , the metric @xmath4 will have a signature @xmath60 on any background . notice that the sign of the above inequalities eq . ( [ condhyperkessencemat ] ) can be reversed . this would however correspond to a metric @xmath4 with signature @xmath64 and the scalar waves would carry negative energy . the theory would therefore be unstable when coupled to other fields ( notably gravity ) . we exclude here this possibility , although it should be stressed that it comes from a stability argument , and not from some causal requirement . in presence of gravity the cauchy problem has to be solved simultaneously for the gravitational variables and for the matter ones . it has been proved ( see for instance @xcite ) that the cauchy problem is well posed if matter fields satisfy `` reasonable '' equations of motion and if the stress - energy tensor of the matter fields only involve matter variables , the gravitational metric , and their first derivatives . this is notably the case of k - essence theories , as can be easily checked . locally therefore , the whole theory has a well - posed cauchy problem . the analysis of the characteristic of the field equation eq . ( [ eqchampkessencemat ] ) shows that the scalar field propagates superluminally if @xmath65 , where we used that @xmath66 by virtue of eq . ( [ condhyperpositive ] ) . as it will be useful later , let us remind that any field which propagates along an effective metric of the form ( up to some positive conformal factor ) : @xmath67 where @xmath32 and @xmath68 are respectively some scalar and vector field , is superluminal if @xmath69 . notice that the opposite sign for @xmath32 is found in @xcite because of the opposite choice of signature . the above theorem and our analysis of the meaning of causality in sec . [ causalite ] enable us to conclude that k - essences theories are causal in flat spacetime whenever the background ( @xmath70 ) is globally hyperbolic , even in presence of superluminal scalar waves . again , this conclusion holds only if we do not refer to any preferred chronology . it was however claimed @xcite that k - essences theories are not causal even if the background is globally hyperbolic . here we emphasize that these claims can only be supported by the postulate that the gravitational ( here , the flat ) metric induces a preferred chronology on @xmath1 , a point that , we believe , is implicitly assumed in these references . the main argument which rules out superluminal propagations is indeed that the cauchy problem for the scalar field is not well posed for initial data that are set on surfaces which are spacelike _ with respect to the flat metric _ but timelike or null with respect to the background metric . in that case , initial data can not be evolved because of caustics @xcite , and the hamiltonian formalism is singular @xcite . let us however stress that it is not surprising in view of leray s theorem , since it proves that initial data surfaces for the scalar field must be spacelike _ with respect to the background metric_. if initial data are set on these surfaces , the theory is free of such singular behaviors . this claim therefore only arises from an unadapted choice of initial data surfaces , i.e. , from the postulate that the gravitational metric defines a preferred chronology . this postulate actually prevents _ any _ superluminal propagation , as we explained in sec . [ causalitegr ] . in such a case , superluminal behavior is ruled out _ from the beginning _ , but not by some intrinsic ( mathematical ) arguments . the only threat for causality lies in fact in global properties of the background . it has been correctly recognized in @xcite that the spacetime ( @xmath71 ) may not be always globally hyperbolic . in particular closed timelike curves ( with respect to the effective metric ) could exist . let us first stress that in general however , the spacetime ( @xmath59 ) is globally hyperbolic . it is notably the case in trivial backgrounds @xmath72 , and in non trivial but homogeneous ( in a certain lorentz frame ) backgrounds @xmath73 , which may be relevant in a cosmological context . note that these backgrounds have to be solutions to the equation of motion eq . ( [ eqchampkessencemat ] ) . in the first case , @xmath5 has thus to be an extremum of the potential , whereas in the second one , @xmath5 is not constant in spacetime and the potential must be flat over some range , or more simply vanish . in these two important cases , the spacetime ( @xmath74 ) is globally hyperbolic and , by virtue of the previous theorem , the cauchy problem is well posed and the theory is causal . since the global hyperbolicity of spacetime ( @xmath75 ) must be assumed in gr , as we explained in sec . [ causaliteglobal ] , we may as well assume that spacetime is globally hyperbolic in the extended sense , see sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] . such an assumption obviously requires that eq . ( [ condhyperkessencemat ] ) hold , and automatically ensure that the whole theory of the k - essence scalar field and gravity is causal . the relevant cauchy surfaces in that case are hypersurfaces that are spacelike with respect to all metrics ( gravitational , scalar and others matter metrics ) . note that this is a non trivial ( and maybe arguable ) assumption . let us however stress that it must also be assumed in the context of gr and standard matter alone so that the fact that non trivial global properties may break causality does not appear to be rooted in superluminal propagations . this assumption may actually be linked to the chronology protection conjecture , as shown by the following example . let us consider the highly non trivial and non globally hyperbolic background invoked in @xcite . it consists of two `` bubbles '' of non trivial backgrounds @xmath76 that move rapidly in opposite directions with a finite impact parameter . the space is otherwise empty ( trivial background @xmath77 ) . small scalar perturbations thus travel superluminally inside the two bubbles , and along null rays of the flat metric outside them . the fact that the two bubbles are in relative motion implies the existence of cftc ( timelike with respect to the background metric @xmath4 ) . it should however be stressed that such a background is _ not _ relevant since it is not a solution to the equation of motion eq . ( [ eqchampkessencemat ] ) . indeed , the derivative of the field @xmath5 is not continuous at the transition between the bubbles and the empty space . some dirac - like source terms should be added to the equation of motion to accommodate such a background . on the contrary , a physical solution involving such two bubbles should exhibit a continuous transition from their interior to the empty space . of course it may turns out that even in this more realistic situation the background is still not globally hyperbolic , but the contrary could also happen , and it would be an illustration of the chronology protection conjecture . we did not try to perform this analysis , but it may be interesting . a very similar case was discussed in @xcite in the context of casimir experiment , see sec . [ sectionqed ] . note that an analogous case has also been found in the context of gr by gott @xcite , who showed that two straight infinite cosmic strings moving in opposite directions with a finite impact parameter lead to the formation of cftc in spacetime . again , it shows that these difficulties with causality at a global level already exists in the context of gr and subluminal matter , and should not be related to some intrinsic problems of superluminal propagations . by multi - metric theories of gravity we mean theories of gravity in which some degrees of freedom of the matter sector are coupled to some matter metrics @xmath78 distinct from the gravitational one @xmath7 . the fact that different matter fields are coupled to different metrics breaks the weak equivalence principle ( wep ) , which has been tested with great accuracy . as a special case , a bimetric theory of gravity is a theory where all the matter fields are coupled to the same metric @xmath6 . this ensures that the wep is satisfied . gr is just the special case @xmath79 . a typical example is scalar - tensor theories of gravity in which @xmath80 , at each point of @xmath1 , and where @xmath81 is a smooth real - valued function over @xmath1 . dynamics of the scalar field @xmath81 arises from a standard kinetic term ( but could also be of k - essence type ) . because of the conformal relationship between @xmath7 and @xmath6 , the two cones defined by these two metrics coincide , and there is no superluminal propagations . in general however , we could have non conformal relation between these two metrics . consider for instance , the so - called disformal relation @xcite @xmath82 where @xmath30 and @xmath32 are some functions of the scalar quantity @xmath83 , and @xmath84 is a vector field . when this matter metric is of lorentzian signature , the matter light - cone ( defined by @xmath6 ) can be wider than the gravitational cone ( defined by @xmath7 ) , depending on the sign of @xmath32 . this disformal relation is an essential piece of some recent relativistic field theories of the mond paradigm @xcite . throughout this paper , we defined superluminality as the propagation along spacelike curves of the gravitational metric . but we could also have defined it as going faster than light ( photons ) . these definitions coincide in gr but not in bimetric theories since @xmath85 . in that framework , there are two opposite definitions of superluminal behaviors . photons can travel faster than gravitational waves and conversely . it is thus not clear which of these two superluminal behavior we have to worry about . this is closely related , again , to the choice of a preferred chronology . if one assumes that the gravitational metric field induces a preferred chronology with respect to which causality should be defined , then , as in sec . [ causalitegr ] , the matter light - cone must coincide or lie within the gravitational one everywhere on spacetime . it was , on the contrary , claimed in @xcite that , since rods and clocks are made of matter , the matter metric @xmath6 should be somewhat favored , in the sense that in order to preserve causality , no propagations should escape the matter light - cone . in particular , this cone should be wider than the gravitational one . very interesting is the fact that this postulate is the exact opposite of the previous one . it is perhaps the best way to show that there is no clear reason why one metric should be preferred to the other . this confusion can be easily understood . let us go further in the discussion of sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] . whenever @xmath6 is lorentzian and disformally related to @xmath7 , we have at hand two metrics which reduce locally to constant metrics @xmath86 and @xmath87 . as a consequence , there exist two classes of inertial coordinates for which one of these two metrics _ but not both _ , reduce to its fundamental form @xmath10 . inertial coordinates of each class transform under the action of the lorentz group @xmath22 with a _ _ different invariant speed _ _ , see @xcite . ] . let us emphasize that in gr , superluminality is defined as the propagation on spacelike curves with respect to the gravitational metric mainly because the latter is thought to be `` the '' spacetime metric , since it reduces locally to @xmath10 . we already stressed in sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] that any lorentzian can actually take this form locally , so that it could also be viewed as the spacetime metric . the framework of bimetric theories considerably enlighten this point . in a sense , indeed , we have two `` natural '' metrics and there is simply no way to decide which of these two metrics should be `` the '' spacetime metric . accordingly , there are two natural chronologies and two locally invariant speeds . the above two classes of inertial coordinates corresponds to rods and clocks made of matter or gravitons . bimetric theories thus clearly show the irrelevance of postulating a preferred chronology . let us also stress that without such a postulate , the notion of superluminal behavior becomes itself irrelevant . the only point , as far as bimetric theories are concerned , is actually that the ratio of the speed of gravitational waves to the speed of photons for instance , vary in space and time . this is the reason why such a framework should be considered as the best motivated one that reproduces varying speed of light theories , see sec . [ bimetricvsl ] . following the discussion of sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] , let us define causality by ( a)(c ) . it is clear that the matter metric has to be lorentzian for the cauchy problem to be well posed . this condition reads @xmath88 and @xmath30 must be non zero . we wrote the conformal factor as @xmath89 in order to ensure that matter fields carry positive energy . the matter stress - energy tensor only depends on the matter fields , the vector field , the gravitational metric , and their first derivatives . depending on the precise form of the action of the vector and matter fields , the whole set of equations of motion ( including gravity ) may be a diagonal , second order , and quasilinear hyperbolic system . note that when @xmath84 is given by the gradient of a scalar field @xmath90 , the initial value formulation of the scalar equation is a quite involved question , see sec . [ bimetricscalaire ] . on the other hand , when @xmath84 is a `` true '' vector field , the cauchy problem is generically well posed and is thereby not diagonal . it does not mean however that the cauchy problem is not well posed , but rather than a careful analysis is in order . generic vector field actions have been considered in @xcite ( and references therein ) . ] . we have also to consider the global structure of spacetime . as in the case of gr , or gr and k - essences , we have to assume that spacetime is globally hyperbolic in the extended sense of sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] . this assumption , together with the above conditions on equations of motion of the matter fields and the vector field ensures that the whole theory is causal . in quantum electrodynamics , effects of temperature , electromagnetic or gravitational backgrounds , or boundaries ( e.g. casimir plates ) break local lorentz invariance at the loop level through vacuum polarization , thus leading , in some cases , to faster - than-@xmath0 light propagation @xcite ; see also @xcite and references therein . note that these results are derived within some range of approximation using the effective action formalism , up to the one or two loop level . generically the results only hold at frequencies less than the electron mass @xmath91 . one therefore only derives the phase velocity of soft photons , whereas the actually relevant speed is the wavefront velocity , which is the phase velocity at infinite frequency and which corresponds to the analysis of the characteristics @xcite . the computation of wavefront velocities is a non - perturbative task that we will not be concerned with . an argument based on the standard kramers - kronig relation @xcite actually gives some hints on the value of the wavefront velocity . in the case of casimir vacua , it was shown that the wavefront velocity might be greater than @xmath0 in the direction orthogonal to the plates ( breaking of lorentz invariance by the boundaries ) . the wavefront velocity has to be equal to @xmath0 in the parallel direction because lorentz invariance is left unbroken in that direction , at least if the casimir plates are infinite ( or if boundary effects are negligible ) . let us assume the validity of this result . of course , `` light does not travel faster than light '' , but the point is that gravity does not see the plates in first approximation , so that lorentz invariance is not broken in the gravitational sector and gravitons still propagate at the velocity @xmath0 . the ratio of the speed of photons to the one of gravitons is thus greater than one . our discussion of sec . [ causalite ] enables to give an immediate answer to the question of causality in that case . it can be shown that photons propagate inside the plates along an effective metric of the form of eq . ( [ metriqueeffective ] ) , where @xmath32 is some positive constant in that case , and @xmath68 is the unit spacelike vector orthogonal to the plates ( see @xcite and references therein ) . outside the plates , photons propagate along the flat metric @xmath10 ( here we neglect curvature ) . it was correctly recognized in @xcite that such a metric is stably causal , so that photons _ can not _ propagate along closed curves , contrary to the claim made in @xcite ( see also the criticism of @xcite ) . actually , this spacetime is even globally hyperbolic and therefore _ perfectly causal _ , even if photons propagate faster - than-@xmath0 inside the plates . causality may however be lost if two casimir vacua are moving rapidly towards each other @xcite . in that case , spacetime may possess cftc ( with respect to the effective metric ) . this case is strictly analogous to the case of two bubbles made of non trivial background in k - essence theory , see sec . [ kessencesglobal ] . authors of @xcite then invoked the chronology protection conjecture , and notably noted that the two casimir vacua should be confined within plates that can not be infinite , so that non trivial boundaries effects may prevent the formation of cftc . we essentially reached the same conclusion in sec . [ kessencesglobal ] . similar arguments may be applied to others vacua . in particular , note that vacuum polarization induces some effective metric along which photons propagate . this effective metric only differs from the flat one by terms of order @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the fine structure constant . these corrections are therefore small ( at least in `` reasonable '' vacua ) , so that the effective metric is still lorentzian and the spacetime is still globally hyperbolic . we briefly comment some applications of our results to recent interesting developments on possible modification of gravity . k - essence scalar field theories have been suggested as promising candidates of the dark energy fluid @xcite ( see also the review @xcite and relevant references therein ) . such an effective action can also be motivated by the low energy regime of some string theories @xcite . the hyperbolicity conditions eq . ( [ condhyperkessencemat ] ) on the function @xmath48 have been correctly derived in the literature , but in a different way ( except in @xcite ) . authors usually require the stability of scalar perturbations around some backgrounds . it depends on the reality of the `` sound speed '' @xmath94 and is thus equivalent to the lorentzian character of the effective metric @xmath55 . this ( un)stability is therefore directly related to the hyperbolic ( resp . elliptic ) character of the scalar field equation . note that the signature can still be @xmath60 or @xmath64 . authors then demand that these small perturbations carry positive energy , and it implies @xmath95 . here we wish to stress that these results also arise from the analysis of causality , and , moreover , that they are actually non - perturbative results . it can be shown , indeed , that the positivity of the whole hamiltonian and not only the one of perturbations , is guaranteed whenever the two conditions eq . ( [ condhyperkessencemat ] ) hold @xcite . unusual kinetic terms have also been considerably debated because phantom scalar fields can reproduce an equation of state @xmath96 @xcite , which indeed reads @xmath97 whenever the density @xmath98 is positive @xmath99 is equivalent to @xmath100 . thus only phantom ( ghost ) matter can lead to super - acceleration of the universe . since ghosts are usually associated with a fatal instability at the quantum level and notably in the uv regime , authors have suggested a stabilization mechanism of the ghost field at the uv scale . the function @xmath48 could be such that @xmath101 ( we reestablish the mass scale @xmath50 ) . in that case the ghost only appear at low energy @xmath102 , but could be stabilized at higher energies by higher - order terms , and the timescale of the instability can be made arbitrarily high @xcite . such a mechanism may however suffers serious diseases . notice indeed that the sign of @xmath103 must change for some values of @xmath104 and the squared sound speed may become negative . accordingly , the effective metric may become euclidean and the cauchy problem will not well posed anymore . the hyperbolicity seems however still guaranteed if @xmath105 also changes of sign at the same value @xmath104 . notice that the function @xmath48 must then be quite fine - tuned : @xmath104 may be equal to @xmath106 or @xmath104 must be a turning point as well as an inflexion point of @xmath48 . moreover , in that already fine tuned case , the effective metric becomes totally degenerate ( vanishes ) at the point @xmath104 . there is a caustic , and the theory is not well defined . it has been shown in @xcite that this point @xmath104 is however not reached through the cosmic evolution ( or at a time @xmath107 ) , and the theory may thus be free of singular behaviors . however the cosmological background is not the only relevant one . the theory must also apply at local ( e.g. astrophysical ) scales , and we expect the scalar field to have some inhomogeneities . local physics then drives @xmath57 to positive values , and the above singular point @xmath104 will generically be crossed . moreover , at a quantum level , it is not clear if we can still make sense of summing momentum from zero to some cutoff , whereas the propagator is not defined for some value of the momentum . in conclusion , k - essences field theories are quite relevant causal theories that can account for the dynamics of the dark energy fluid with an equation of state @xmath108 . on the other hand , k - essences phantom theories , even if stabilized , suffer serious diseases and it is very unlikely that such a fluid could drive the super - acceleration of the universe @xmath99 , if any . note that it was recently found that inhomogeneities of the matter distribution in the universe may be described by an effective scalar field which could be a phantom in certain cases @xcite . because only effective , this field does not suffer from quantum instabilities . k - essences theories are also used to account for the mass discrepancy in galaxies and clusters , without the need for dark matter . milgrom @xcite first pointed out that rotation curves of spiral galaxies exhibit a discrepancy at an universal acceleration scale @xmath109 , and therefore that a modification of newton dynamics ( mond ) of the form @xmath110 where @xmath111 is the newtonian gravitational field and @xmath112 the acceleration , could account for the observed discrepancy without dark matter . the @xmath113 function must behave asymptotically as @xmath114 if @xmath115 and @xmath116 if @xmath117 . the @xmath113 function is otherwise free . the choice @xmath118 is a quite standard one which fits well the data . such a behavior in the low acceleration regime automatically leads to flat rotation curves far from the source , and also reproduces the well established tully - fisher law @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is the plateau velocity and @xmath121 is the luminosity of the galaxy . this successful phenomenology @xcite can be reproduced with the help of relativistic aquadratic lagrangians ( raqual ) @xcite , i.e. , a k - essence scalar field . consider indeed a scalar field @xmath2 coupled to matter via a conformal metric @xmath122 . the scalar field equation then reads @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the covariant derivative corresponding to the metric @xmath7 , @xmath125 is newton s constant appearing in the eintein - hilbert action , and @xmath126 is the trace of the stress - energy tensor of the matter fields ( defined by variation and contraction with respect to @xmath7 ) . if we consider a static distribution of matter @xmath127 , this equation reduces to a static modified poisson equation for the scalar gravitational potential @xmath2 : @xmath128 it is then clear , after restoring the appropriate dimensionfull constants , that the function @xmath129 plays the role of the milgrom s function @xmath130 . note that @xmath131 in the static case . if we require that @xmath132 behaves as @xmath57 if @xmath133 , and as @xmath134 if @xmath135 , we thus recover the mond phenomenology . note that , since the @xmath113 function is generally taken as a monotonic ( increasing ) function of its argument , the second derivative of @xmath48 is positive and the scalar waves propagate superluminally . the theory were thus thought to be acausal @xcite . we however argued in sec . [ causalite ] and sec . [ sectionkessence ] that this conclusion is correct only if the gravitational metric defines a favored chronology , an assumption that may be dropped . a critical point is however that the free function @xmath48 ( related to @xmath113 ) must satisfy the conditions eq . ( [ condhyperkessencemat ] ) . it is however immediate to note that the asymptotic conditions on @xmath113 implies that when @xmath57 goes to @xmath106 , @xmath103 and @xmath136 also go to zero and the effective metric is completely degenerate . what it means is that , in such a theory , in an astrophysical context , there must exist around each galaxy or cluster a singular surface on which the scalar degree of freedom does not propagate . the reason is that , near the source , @xmath57 must be positive , but negative far from it due to the cosmological background . this theory can therefore not lead to a consistent picture of local physics imbedded into a cosmological background . this major objection also applies to the recent relativistic model of mond of @xcite . a trivial modification of the asymptotic form of the @xmath113 function however cures the problem . let us consider that @xmath137 if @xmath117 , or equivalently that @xmath138 if @xmath135 . it ensures that the theory is well behaved at the transition between local and cosmological physics . this slight modification induces a significant change in the phenomenology because there is a return to a newtonian behavior very far from the source , with a renormalized value of the gravitational constant . such a theory thus predicts that rotation curves are only approximatively flat on a finite range of @xmath139 , and current data requires @xmath140 to be at most of order @xmath141 . more details on this can be found in @xcite . interestingly , in that kind of theory , mond only appears as an intermediate regime between two newtonian ones only differing by the value of the gravitational constant , the transition , driven by the scalar field , occurring at milgrom s acceleration scale . mond - like theories of gravity must also predict enhanced light deflection in order to be consistent with the data . in the previous theory however , the conformal coupling of the scalar field to the matter metric implies that light is not coupled to the scalar field because of the conformal invariance of electromagnetism in four dimensions . this led authors to consider more general bimetric theory of gravity in which matter is coupled to a disformal metric of the type eq . ( [ disformalmetric ] ) @xcite . in these first models , the vector field @xmath84 in eq . ( [ disformalmetric ] ) was assumed to be the gradient of the k - essence scalar field , and @xmath30 and @xmath32 were some functions of @xmath2 and @xmath57 . it was however proved that when the matter light - cone is wider than the gravitational one ( see sec . [ bimetrictheories ] ) then there is actually less light deflection than in gr . we have seen however that causality does not require the matter light - cone to be wider than the gravitational one . on the contrary , it could be inside the gravitational one and the light deflection would be enhanced ( compared to gr ) . such a framework is therefore relevant for relativistic theories of the mond paradigm , as we stress in @xcite . the cauchy problem is very likely to be well posed , since the ( einstein ) equation of the metric field is still diagonalized , hyperbolic and of the second order . the scalar field equation in vacuum has a well - posed cauchy problem . the scalar field equation inside the matter is however quite complicated and is not diagonalized . the cauchy problem inside the matter is thus a quite involved question , but we expect that some generic requirements on the free functions @xmath30 and @xmath32 and on energy conditions of the matter sector will guarantee it , and by the way , that the whole theory has a well posed cauchy problem . this is left for further investigation ( see also @xcite ) . let us briefly consider another application of bimetric theories of gravity . conventional physics did not succeeded so far in explaining the anomalous motion of the two pioneer spacecrafts @xcite that experience a small anomalous acceleration ( roughly directed towards the sun ) . unconventional theories of gravity could however explain it . the two pioneer spacecrafts are moving along geodesics of the matter metric @xmath6 , and we shall look for a slight modification of the schwarzschild solution to explain the pioneer anomaly . it is worth noting that this anomaly was detected soon after jupiter s flyby @xcite so that we have to check that the suggested modification is compatible with the motion of outer planets . outer planets are moving along quasi - circular orbits , and are thereby mostly sensitive to the time - time component of the matter metric @xmath142 . very sensitive tests of kepler s third law @xcite then put stringent bounds on the deviation from the leading order of the time - time component of the schwarzschild metric . these bounds are actually too small to account for the pioneer anomaly . this fact leads to the wrong statement in @xcite that the pioneer anomaly can not be of gravitational origin . this is indeed not justifiable since the two spacecrafts evolve on hyperbolic trajectories and are thereby also sensitive to the radial - radial component of the matter metric , which is not well constrained in the outer solar system . let us stress that , if spherical symmetry is assumed , a slight modification of @xmath143 compared to the schwarzschild solution is the only way to give the pioneer anomaly a gravitational origin in a metric theory of gravity . this was notably realized in @xcite . here we provide , with the help of bimetric theories of gravity , a framework that realizes this modification of the radial - radial component . the action of the theory is given by the eintein - hilbert action , a canonical action for the scalar field , and the matter fields are coupled to the matter metric @xmath144 where @xmath57 is still defined by eq . ( [ defdex ] ) . as we already stressed , non trivial properties of @xmath30 , @xmath32 and energy conditions of the matter sector may be required to ensure the hyperbolicity of the scalar equation inside matter . in addition , the matter metric has to be lorentzian and this reads @xmath145 . in a static and spherical symmetric situation , we have @xmath146 and @xmath147 . the bare metric @xmath7 is given by the solution of einstein equations and it can be shown that it coincides with the schwarzschild solution to the leading order . this theory is thus a realization of the above phenomenology . such models predict `` pioneer - like '' anomalies in the precession of perihelion that could notably be found in precise measures of the orbit of mars . more details on the pioneer anomaly and disformal theories can be found in @xcite . the first varying speed of light theories were constructed by replacing @xmath0 by @xmath8 in the equations of motion of gr , where @xmath148 could be the cosmic time @xcite . this however leads to equations of motion that do not conserve stress - energy anymore . in other words , this theory can not be obtained from a variational principle @xcite . some authors thus made use of the disformal matter metric eq . ( [ metriquedisfscalaire ] ) to reproduce vsl within a consistent framework @xcite . note that in all of these models , the free functions were taken as constants @xmath149 and @xmath150 . let us stress that if one insists on the weak equivalence principle there can not be any coupling between @xmath2 and the standard model matter other than through the matter metric . then , by varying the action with respect to @xmath2 , one finds that the scalar field is not created by the matter sources ( @xmath151 is always a solution ) . the scalar field can only be generated by some ( non constant ) function @xmath152 , like in scalar - tensor theories . note also that the choice of @xmath153 in these works does not guarantee the lorentzian character of the matter metric , which can actually be euclidean in a cosmological background such that @xmath154 . one could however circumvent this problem by arguing that the theory is only an effective model valid for @xmath155 , and where @xmath50 could be of the order of the gut s scale . as we already stressed , the initial value formulation of the scalar field equation in such models is a quite involved question . this point has not been pointed out although the existence of an initial value formulation is a basic requirement that must be checked in order to give any sense to such vsl models . let us finally remark that , since the fine structure constant @xmath93 is proportional to the inverse of the speed of light , it has been argued that vsl theories could also account for the variation of @xmath93 with cosmic time , if any @xcite . however , in this bimetric framework of vsl theories , if one analyzes atomic rays at some redshift by usual techniques , one is observing electromagnetic phenomenon using matter rods and clocks , so that no variations of @xmath93 are actually observable . the fact that the ratio of the speed of light to the speed of gravitational waves varies in space and time does not lead to a variation of @xmath93 ( if it is measured in the usual way ) , but simply to a redefinition of the redshift @xmath156 of distant objects . we provided a careful analysis of the meaning of causality in classical field theories . this led us to the conclusion that superluminal behaviors are generically found to be non causal _ only if _ one refers to a _ prior _ chronology on spacetime . this postulate actually states that , locally , some sets of inertial coordinates must be preferred ones , and this appears to be in great conflict with the spirit of general relativity , and more precisely with the spirit of general covariance . on the contrary , we derived in sec . [ causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] , by means of the conditions ( a)(c ) , a formulation of causality in which coordinates are still physically meaningless . note that while referring to a preferred chronology may seem natural in gr since all fields ( both gravity and matter ) propagate along the gravitational metric @xmath7 , it becomes somewhat unnatural whenever spontaneous breaking of lorentz invariance occur , be it driven by quantum polarization ( and in general , the solution of field equations ) , nonlinearities of some new fields , etc . the resulting spacetime is generically endowed with a finite set of lorentzian metrics @xmath16 which may not be conformally related to each others . in that case rods and clocks made of different fields lead to different systems of coordinate that do not transform under the same lorentz group . there is not only one , but at least two invariant speeds in that case . note that it would be misleading to think that there is a preferred lorentz invariance in the theory because of the symmetry of the action . actually , in a gr - like context , the action is not lorentz invariant but diffeomorphism invariant . this notably means that all local system of coordinates are equivalent . on the contrary , the existence of a preferred chronology means that ( as far as causality is concerned ) there exists some preferred class of inertial coordinates , or equivalently some preferred rods and clocks . this seems to be physically unacceptable . as a consequence , one _ can not _ refer to causality in order to assert that nothing can travel faster than one of these speeds . accordingly , causality does not require one of these metric to define a wider cone than the others everywhere on spacetime . bimetric theories of gravity greatly enlightened this point , since both the gravitational and the matter metric could be used to define a `` natural '' chronology on spacetime . depending on the choice made , one then finds that nothing can travel faster than gravity or light . these two opposite requirements can be found in the literature . on the contrary , our definition of causality in which no prior chronology is assumed ( by means of our `` mixed '' chronology , see sec.[causalityandsuperluminalbehav ] ) , enables a causal theory to involve `` superluminal '' propagations . actually the very notion of superluminal behavior is no more meaningful in that framework , and the only point is that some degrees of freedom can propagate faster than other ones . moreover the causal cones may even tip over each other depending on the location on spacetime . as an application , in k - essences theories , causality does _ not _ require the sign of @xmath157 to be fixed ( and notably negative ) , and , in bimetric theory causality does not require either the gravitational light - cone to be wider than the matter one ( nor conversely ) . what actually requires causality is first that the equations of motion have a well - posed cauchy problem . this strongly depends on the precise form of the dynamics , and throughout this paper we used classical results @xcite on that subject . we also discussed in detail the fact that global properties of spacetimes may break causality . we pointed out that this already occurs in standard gr _ so that it can not be related to some intrinsic disease of superluminal propagation_. we discuss three very similar cases : gott s cosmic strings @xcite , the two bubbles of non trivial vacua in k - essences theories @xcite and the two casimir experiments of @xcite . what thus became clear was that such non trivial global properties may be actually suppressed by subtle boundaries effects . this would be an illustration of the chronology protection conjecture . r. c. tolman _ the theory of relativity of motion _ ( university of california press , berkeley , 1917 ) g. a. benford , d. l. book and w. a. newcomb , phys . rev . d**2 * * , 263 ( 1970 ) s. liberati , s. sonego and m. visser , annals phys.*298 * , 167 ( 2002 ) a. d. dolgov and i. d. novikov , phys . lett . b**442 * * , 82 ( 1998 ) m. yu konstantinov , russ . j. * 45 * , 23 ( 2002 ) ; g - qc/9810019 y. aharonov , a. komar and l. susskind , phys . rev . * 182 * , 1400 ( 1969 ) a. adams , n. arkani - hamed , s. dubovsky , a. nicolis and r. rattazzi , _ causality , analyticity and an ir obstruction to uv completion _ , hep - th/0602178 e. a. lim , phys . d**71 * * , 063504 ( 2005 ) c. bonvin , c. caprini , r. durrer _ a no - go theorem for k - essences dark energy _ , astro - ph/0606584 j. w. elliott , g. d. moore and h. stoica , jhep 0508 , 066 ( 2005 ) j. d. bekenstein , phys . d**48 * * , 3641 ( 1992 ) j. d. bekenstein , astrophys . j. * 429 * , 480 ( 1994 ) j. d. bekenstein , phys . d**70**,083509 ( 2004 ) i. t. drummond and s. j. hathrell , phys . d**22**,343 ( 1980 ) ; k. scharnhorst , phys . lett . b**236 * * , 354 ( 1990 ) ; j. i. lattore , p. pascual and r. tarrach , nucl . phys . b**437 * * , 60 ( 1995 ) ; w. dittrich and h. gies , phys . d**58 * * , 025004 ( 1998 ) g. m. shore , venice 2002 time and matter , 45 - 66 ; gr - qc/0302116 k. scharnhorst , annalen phys . * 7 * , 700 ( 1998 ) j. w. moffat , found . * 23 * , 411 ( 1993 ) s. w. hawking and g. f. r. ellis , _ the large scale structure of spacetime _ , cambridge university press ( 1973 ) r. m. wald , _ general relativity _ , the university of chicago press ( 1984 ) m. a. clayton and j. w. moffat , int . phys . d**11 * * , 187 ( 2002 ) j. d. bekenstein and m. milgrom , astrophys.j . * 286 * , 7 ( 1984 ) t. chiba , t. okabe and m. yamaguchi , phys . rev d**62 * * , 023511 ( 2000 ) ; c. armendriz - picn , v. mukhanov and p.j . steinhardt , phys . rev d**63 * * , 103510 ( 2001 ) c. armendriz - picn , t. damour and v. mukhanov , phys . lett . b**458 * * , 219 ( 1999 ) m. milgrom , astrophys . j. * 270 * , 365 ( 1983 ) r. h. sanders , astrophys . j. * 480 * , 492 ( 1997 ) i. t. drummond , _ variable light - cone theory of gravity _ , gr - qc/9908058 ; i. t. drummond , phys . rev . d**63**,043503 ( 2001 ) m. a. clayton and j. w. moffat , phys . lett . b**460 * * , 263 ( 1999 ) ; m. a. clayton and j. w. moffat , phys . lett . b**477 * * , 269 ( 2000 ) b. a. bassett , s. liberati , c. molina - pars and m. visser , phys . rev . d**62 * * , 103518 ( 2000 ) j. d. barrow and j. magueijo , phys . lett . b**443 * * , 104 ( 1998 ) ; j. d. barrow , phys . rev . d**59 * * , 043515 ( 1999 ) ; a. albrecht and j. magueijo , phys . rev . d**59 * * , 043516 ( 1999 ) ; j. d. barrow and j. magueijo , class . * 16 * , 1435 ( 1999 ) g. f. r. ellis and j .- p . uzan , am . * 73 * , 240 ( 2005 ) c. w. misner , k. s. thorne and j. a. wheeler , _ gravitation _ ( freeman , san francisco , 1973 ) . s. w. hawking , phys . d**46 * * , 603 ( 1992 ) e. bois and e. trelut , _ limpact de la structure chrono - gomtrique de lespace - temps sur la causalit . _ , astro - ph/0304520 j. z. simon , phys . rev . d**41 * * , 3720 ( 1990 ) ; r. p. woodard _ avoiding dark energy with 1/r modifications of gravity _ , astro - ph/0601672 r. courant and d. hilbert , _ methods of mathematical physics , vol ii _ , interscience , new york ( 1962 ) j. r. gott , phys . . lett . * 66 * , 1126 ( 1991 ) t. jacobson and d. mattingly , phys . rev . d**64 * * , 024028 ( 2001 ) e. j. copeland , m. sami and s. tsujikawa , _ dynamics of dark energy _ , hep - th/0603057 c. armendariz - picon and e. a. lim , `` haloes of k - essence '' jcap 0508 ( 2005 ) j .- p . bruneton and g. esposito - farse , _ field - theoretical formulations of mond - like gravity _ , to be published . r. r. caldwell , phys . b**545 * * , 23 - 29 ( 2002 ) s. m. carroll , m. hoffman and m. trodden , phys . d**68 * * , 023509 ( 2003 ) j. m. cline , s. jeon and g. d. moore , phys . rev . d**70 * * , 043543 ( 2004 ) n. arkani - hamed , h - c . cheng , m. a. luty and s. mukohyama , jhep 0405 , 074 ( 2004 ) t. buchert , j. larena and j - m . alimi , _ correspondence between kinematical backreaction and scalar field cosmologies - the ` morphon field ' _ , gr - qc/0606020 r. h. sanders ans s. s. mcgaugh , ann . . astrophys . * 40 * , 263 ( 2002 ) j. d. anderson , p. a. laing , e. l. lau , a. s. liu , m. m. nieto and s. g. turyshev , phys . rev . d**65 * * , 082004 ( 2002 ) ; v. t. toht and s. g. turyshev _ the pioneer anomaly : seeking an explanation in newly recovered data _ gr - qc/0603016 c. talmadge , j .- p . berthias , r. w. hellings and e. m. standish , phys . 61 * , 1159 ( 1988 ) k. tangen , _ could the pioneer anomaly have a gravitational origin ? _ , gr - qc/0602089 m .- t . jaekel and s. reynaud , mod . * * , 1047 ( 2005 ) ; m .- t . jaekel and s. reynaud , class . * 23 * , 777 ( 2006 ) n. kaloper , phys . b**583 * * , 1 - 13 ( 2004 ) j. k. webb , v. v. flambaum , c. w. churchill , m. j. drinkwater and j. d. barrow , phys . lett . * 82 * , 884 ( 1999 ) a. v. ivanchik , e. rodriguez , p. petitjean and d.a . varshalovich , astron . lett . * 28 * , 423 ( 2002 ) Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: recently , the theoretical and empirical foundations of the physics of traffic flow ( for a review see refs . @xcite ) has come into the focus of the physical community . the motion of individual cars has many peculiarities , since it is controlled by motivated driver behavior , together with some physical boundaries . nevertheless , on macroscopic scales the vehicle ensembles displays phenomena like phase formation and phase transitions widely met in physical systems ( see , e.g. , refs . so , the cooperative behavior of cars treated as active particles seems to be of a more general nature than the mechanical laws and constructing a consistent theory of traffic flow `` from scratch '' is up to now a challenging problem . to describe individual car dynamics a great variety of microscopic models have been proposed . these models differ in the details of the interaction between cars and the time update rule , ranging from differential equations to cellular automata @xcite . there has been a big deal of work on the macroscopic behavior emerging from the microscopic dynamics when exploring the behavior of systems of interacting cars . however , there is still a lot of controversy in both the macroscopic behavior when compared to reality @xcite , and in the microscopic foundations of the individual car dynamics itself @xcite . one currently adopted approach to specify the microscopic governing equations of the individual car motion is the so - called social force model . more details can be found in refs . @xcite ; here only the basic ideas are touched on . at each moment @xmath0 of time , a driver @xmath1 changes the speed @xmath2 of her car depending on the road conditions and the arrangement of the neighboring cars : @xmath3 the term @xmath4 describes the motion of car @xmath1 on the empty road , whereas the term @xmath5 allows for the interaction of car @xmath6 with car @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) . the interaction is due to the necessity for driver @xmath6 to keep a certain safe headway distance between the cars . all the models mentioned above use various _ anstze _ for the last term . the most interesting special case , which covers the majority of all traffic flow situations , is that of single - lane traffic . here , all cars can be ordered according to their position on the road in the car motion direction @xmath9 , here @xmath10 . most models take into account solely nearest neighboring cars @xmath6 and @xmath11 , i.e. , @xmath12 for @xmath13 and , may be , @xmath14 only . however , more complicated models exist that can be described as models with anticipation @xcite or the so - called intelligent driver model @xcite . the earliest `` follow - the - leader '' models @xcite relate the acceleration @xmath15 of car @xmath1 to the velocity difference @xmath16 only , i.e. , @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the characteristic time scale of the velocity relaxation . in subsequent generalizations of this model @xmath18 became a function of the car motion state , in particular , of the current velocity @xmath19 and the headway @xmath20 ( for a review see refs . @xcite ) . here , @xmath21 is the car length . in refs . @xcite another approach called the optimal velocity model is proposed that describes the individual car motion by @xmath22\ , , \label{int.2}\ ] ] where @xmath23 is the steady - state velocity ( the optimal velocity ) chosen by drivers as function of the headway @xmath24 between the cars . it should be noted that this approach is related to much earlier safety distance models @xcite . concerning the fundamentals of approximations such as @xmath25 , it is noted that there are actually two stimuli affecting the driver behavior . one of them is the necessity to move at the mean speed of traffic flow , in the given case at the speed @xmath26 of car @xmath11 . so , first , driver @xmath1 should control the velocity difference @xmath16 . the other is the necessity to maintain a safe headway distance @xmath27 depending on the current velocity @xmath28 . the `` following - the - leader '' models mainly take into account the former stimulus . the optimal velocity model , conversely , allows for the latter stimulus only . more sophisticated approximations , e.g. , refs . @xcite to name but a few , allow for both stimuli . note also a simple _ ansatz _ called the combined model in ref . @xcite which is also related to the intelligent driver model @xcite : [ imodels ] @xmath29\\ & & { } -\frac{\kappa}{\tau_v}\left[v_\alpha -\vartheta _ { \text{opt}}(h_\alpha ) \right ] \ , . % -\vartheta _ { \text{opt}}(x_{\alpha + 1}-x_{\alpha } ) \right ] \ , , \label{cm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this equation takes into account both stimuli via a phenomenological coefficient @xmath30 . this is also the case for the helly model @xcite which can be written as ( cf . ref . @xcite ) @xmath31\\ & & { } + \frac1{\tau_v l_h}\left [ ( x_{\alpha + 1}-x_\alpha)-h_{\text{opt}}(v_\alpha)\right ] \ , , \label{helmod}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath32 is a certain spatial scale and @xmath33 is the optimal headway distance chosen by drivers when moving at speed @xmath34 . ref . @xcite used a linear _ ansatz _ for @xmath33 . later @xcite , this model was generalized to allow for the dependence of the kinetic coefficients on the motion state . however , the question whether a collection of variables such as @xmath35 specifies the acceleration @xmath36 completely is not trivial . drivers are characterized by the motivated behavior rather than physical regularities . for example , memory effects may be essential and can destroy the direct relationship @xmath37 . up to now , memory effects in car following modelling have been treated only in a simplified version . this has been done by relating the current acceleration @xmath38 to the velocities @xmath39 , @xmath40 and the headway distance @xmath41 taken at a previous moment ( @xmath42 ) of time ( for a review of such an approach concerning with the `` following - the - leader '' models see refs . @xcite , regarding the optimal velocity model see refs . @xcite ) . here @xmath43 is the formal delay time in the driver response which is treated as a constant . such an approach , however , is rather formal , because , first , it is not clear why the memory effects relate only two moments of time instead of a certain interval as a whole . second , a simple physiological delay in the driver response as well as the mental driver estimation of the surrounding situation should contribute to the value of @xmath43 . if the latter contribution is essential the delay time @xmath43 is to depend substantially on the state of car motion . moreover , from our point of view the memory effects stem from the fact that the description of individual car motion is a boundary value problem rather than an initial value problem . indeed , at the current moment of time the headway distance and the car velocity are quantities given for the driver beforehand . correcting the car motion she should choose such a driving strategy that in a certain time interval the car velocity and headway distance attain their optimal stationary values , at least , approximately . these memory effects are the topic of this paper . we propose that drivers plan their behavior for a certain time in advance @xcite instead of simply reacting to the surrounding situation . similar ideas related to the optimum design of a distance controlling driver assistance system are discussed in ref . mathematically , the driver s planning of the further motion is just to find extremals of a certain priority functional that ranks outcomes of different driving strategies . the derivation of microscopic governing equations for systems with motivated behavior based on a certain `` optimal self - organization '' principle has been discussed recently @xcite . the assumption adopted in these works is that individuals try to minimize the interaction strength or , equivalently , to optimize their own success and to minimize the efforts required for this . the approach discussed here applies to the concepts of mathematical economics , namely , to the notion of preferences and utility ( see , e.g. , ref . @xcite ) . in ref . @xcite a specific form of the priority functional has been proposed . from that , a certain _ ansatz _ like the combined model ( [ cm ] ) or the helly model ( [ helmod ] ) could be _ derived_. nevertheless , the question how to find the priority functional `` from scratch '' remains open . in the present paper the priority functional is constructed by applying to general properties of the driver behavior for a simplified situation . a car following ( no overtaking allowed ) a lead car which is driven with constant speed @xmath44 is considered . the task is to derive governing equations for the following car motion specified by the time dependence of the velocity @xmath45 and the headway distance @xmath46 . assuming a driver to be able of comparing any two states @xmath47 , @xmath48 , the phase plane @xmath49 can be ordered by a preference relation @xmath50 . therefore , the existence of a cost function @xmath51 may be assumed such that : @xmath52 typically , @xmath53 is called the utility function and ( for it ) the relation @xmath50 matches the inequality @xmath54 . here , the use of condition ( [ 1.1 ] ) is preferred , because then the cost function @xmath51 is similar to the free energy of physical systems , with the minima as the stationary states . obviously , the cost function @xmath51 can not be specified completely because a composite function @xmath55 $ ] also meets condition ( [ 1.1 ] ) for any increasing function @xmath56 $ ] . therefore , at the current stage of the theory development any approximation or _ ansatz _ adopted for the cost function @xmath51 has no meaning . to overcome this problem and to fix a certain class of the cost functions the preference relation defined on a set of car motion paths @xmath57 is considered . a car moving from one point to another can meet different states of traffic flow . it enables one to unite various points on the phase plane in an element treated as a whole with respect to the driver preference , reducing the numerical uncertainty in their evaluation . these parts are supposed , first , to connect the same origin - destination pair @xmath58 and , second , to go through a traffic flow pattern whose structure is known to the driver beforehand . such a set obviously can be ordered by the driver preference and the corresponding cost functional @xmath59 is assumed to exist . here , only the fact that a car motion path can consist of various fragments of the phase plane is concerned with . analysis of the real car dynamics is postponed to the following section . and @xmath60 illustrating the property of the cost functional with respect to path partitioning . letters @xmath61 and @xmath62 stand for the origin and destination points , respectively , and the symbols @xmath63 denote the local states of traffic flow.[f2],width=264 ] figure [ f2 ] shows two paths @xmath1 and @xmath60 which are equivalent with respect to the driver preference . they differ from each other only in the order of passing through the traffic states , @xmath64 for the path @xmath1 and @xmath65 for the path @xmath60 . it demonstrates the fact that if a path goes through a certain small neighborhood of the point @xmath66 one or many times then only the cumulative time interval @xmath67 during which the system was located in the given neighborhood contributes to the cost functional . the corresponding weight coefficient @xmath51 obviously plays the role of a certain cost function for the given traffic state . the resulting cost functional for the whole path is @xmath68dt\ , . \label{1.2}\ ] ] if the driver has incomplete information about the traffic flow pattern ahead she plans the further motion only within some limits , spatial and temporal ones . this can be taken into account by introducing a certain cofactor in front of the function @xmath51 which depends on spatial coordinates or time . the initial introduction of the cost function remains the freedom of its choice too `` wide '' , as was noted above . the constructed form of the cost functional reduces this freedom substantially . namely , let @xmath69 and @xmath70 be two functions entering a cost functional similar to ( [ 1.2 ] ) with the prediction effect such that they preserve the preference relation with respect to the car motion paths on an one - lane road . then , as shown in appendix [ appp : a ] , these cost functions are related by the expressions @xmath71 depending on the spatial or temporal limitation in the driver prediction . here @xmath72 is an arbitrary positive constant and @xmath73 , @xmath74 are some functions of the headway distance @xmath24 or the time @xmath0 . in other words , relations ( [ cf.4 ] ) , ( [ cf.11 ] ) specify the family of the admissible type of cost functions preserving the driver preference relation and , in addition , correspond to linear transformation of the cost functional ( appendix [ appp : a ] ) . for example , @xmath75^{2}$ ] is also a cost functional . however , formula ( [ 1.2 ] ) enables us to fix its specific form being linear with respect to time integration along car motion paths . we note that this construction conforms with regarding the motion cost as the `` physiological '' cost of driving per time , i.e. , having the meaning of a rate . both of these families possess the same freedom in choosing a specific form of the cost function especially dealing with the extremals of the cost functional . in fact , the type ( [ cf.11 ] ) is chosen in the following . in the following , the priority function of the car motion state with respect to the velocity @xmath34 and the reciprocal value @xmath76 of the headway distance will be characterized . note , that the value @xmath77 is not the real car density on a highway . the present analysis ignores the car length , so we have preferred to use the value @xmath77 defined as above . the most preferable state is the motion on an empty road ( @xmath78 ) at maximum speed @xmath79 . this maximum speed is determined by external factors . so , at @xmath80 the cost function @xmath81 has its global minimum : @xmath82 set equal to zero keeping in mind the aforesaid about the freedom in specifying the cost function . since there is no other minimum for the motion on an empty road,@xmath83 can be fixed . because of the car construction a driver can visually control the headway distance within some value @xmath842 m. when the headway distance @xmath24 attains such values a driver has to stop her car because of possible collision even at sufficiently slow velocities . so , @xmath85 coincides with the characteristic headway distance in dense jams where the car density attains the possible maximum . in the following , all headway distances are related to the scale @xmath85 and the dimensionless variable @xmath86 is used . when not moving at all ( @xmath87 ) and the density of cars surrounding the given car does not come close to the limit values , i.e. , @xmath88 , it does not matter how many cars are located in the vicinity . so the assumption that at @xmath87 and for @xmath89 the cost function is independent of @xmath77 can be used : @xmath90 in all other cases , @xmath91 depends on certain combinations of @xmath77 and @xmath34 rather than on @xmath77 individually , at least when @xmath92 . considering the behavior of @xmath91 for a fixed speed @xmath34 it can be stated that driving with small values of @xmath24 ( large values of @xmath77 ) requires a lot of effort . thus , @xmath91 increases with @xmath77 . the opposite case of small values of @xmath77 ( large values of @xmath24 ) deserves special attention . without the possibility of overtaking no especially attractive headway distance can be marked . therefore , we assume that the cost function @xmath93 possesses the only one minimum attained at the boundary point @xmath94 provided the velocity @xmath34 is fixed . keeping in mind the aforesaid it is reasonable to write @xmath95 for @xmath96 . here the exponent @xmath97 is a constant and the function @xmath98 as @xmath99 . since the cost function attains its minimum at the boundary point we may set @xmath100 . moreover , the latter term on the right - hand side of exp . ( [ 1.6na ] ) can be interpreted as a certain `` interaction '' potential between the following and lead cars which is long - distant one for @xmath100 . a detailed analysis of effects caused by the value of the exponent @xmath97 requires an individual study . here the value @xmath101 is actually chosen as just a simple reasonable assumption . since the effect of the surrounding cars is depressed for small values of the car velocity @xmath34 the function @xmath102 is also to attain its minimum at @xmath103 . therefore , @xmath104 as @xmath105 should hold . in other words , inside a certain neighborhood of the origin @xmath106 the following expansion @xmath107 can be adopted . ) .[f3 ] ] taking into account these speculations about the behavior of the cost function @xmath108 caused by variations of both its arguments , the following simple _ ansatz _ will be used subsequently : @xmath109 figure [ f3 ] displays this function . it has only one global minimum at @xmath78 and @xmath110 . for a fixed velocity @xmath34 it attains a local minimum at the boundary @xmath78 . _ ansatz _ ( [ 1.7 ] ) generalizes the adopted assumptions about the cost function . the former term takes into account relations ( [ 1.3 ] ) , ( [ 1.4 ] ) , the latter one is based on approximation ( [ 1.6n ] ) . of course , the parabolic _ ansatz _ ( [ 1.7 ] ) is approximate only in the limit @xmath111 . since this is the main region of interest , this does not constrain its usefulness . to deal with the car dynamics we should construct the cost functional @xmath112 for the car motion paths @xmath113 treated now as continuous functions of time @xmath0 . we note that the time dependence of headway distance @xmath46 gives us the complete information about the car dynamics due to the relationship @xmath114 . leaping ahead , we say that facing this problem it is necessary to introduce additional notions . first , we should expand the phase space in describing the car motion state because transient processes are now the subject of consideration . second , drivers plan their behavior for a certain time in advance instead of simply reacting to the surrounding situation . so we should specify the region inside which a driver can monitor the traffic flow evolution and , thus , plan driving her car . a priority functional similar to eq . ( [ 1.2 ] ) must span the time interval corresponding to this region . beyond it the contribution of the path fragments to evaluating the car motion quality at the given moment of time has to be fairly minor . dealing with transient processes in the car motion we should consider once more the collection of phase variables characterizing the cost of car motion at the current moment of time . keeping in mind conventional driver experience , we will expand the current state of car motion given by headway @xmath24 and velocity @xmath34 with the car acceleration @xmath115 . this is essential because a driver can not change the position and velocity of her car immediately , they vary continuously in time and contain no sharp jumps . conversely , a driver controls the acceleration directly governing the car motion . besides , she can change the acceleration practically without delay because in the present analysis it is quite reasonable to ignore time scales related to physiological properties of the driver or to the mechanical properties of the car . so , the cost function @xmath116 for the motion state @xmath117 can be written : @xmath118 where the time scale @xmath119 s characterizes the acceleration capability of the car . in writing this expression we have assumed that driving without acceleration is preferable . then , the cost function @xmath120 had been expanded into a taylor series with respect to @xmath115 , keeping the leading term only . according to the result to be obtained the time scale @xmath121 entering expression ( [ 2.1 ] ) and the one used in equation ( [ cm ] ) are practically the same . it should be noted that confining ourselves to expansion ( [ 2.1 ] ) with respect to @xmath115 the difference between acceleration and deceleration processes has been lost . in reality , they are different . ignoring this difference leads to models where cars can crash . it is possible to take into account this effect using the approach under development , which , however , is worthy of individual investigation and will be done somewhere else . and its relationship with the limit angle of perception @xmath122.[f4 ] ] for a real driver , various thresholds in the driver recognition of hazards and obstacles exist @xcite . one of them is the distance @xmath123 at which a driver can recognize the behavior of other objects . this distance is usually related to the threshold of the visual angle @xmath122 subtended , for example , by vehicles ahead ( fig . [ f4 ] ) . the value of @xmath122 can be estimated as @xmath12430 min of arc @xcite . the critical angle @xmath122 , the characteristics height @xmath125 of cars , and the corresponding mean distance @xmath123 are related by @xmath126 this allows for the estimation of the recognition distance as @xmath127400 m setting @xmath128 m and @xmath12915 minutes of arc . as previously @xcite , we relate the driver anticipation with the region of size @xmath123 in front that is clearly observable and where she can recognize the car behavior . a driver plans her motion based on the information received by monitoring traffic flow inside the observable region . under normal conditions this region should enable her to govern the motion effectively , for example , to decelerate in advance avoiding a possible accident . therefore its size @xmath123 has to meet the inequality @xmath130 . leaping ahead , we introduce the value @xmath131 treated as a small parameter in the theory to be developed . in particular , for @xmath132 s , @xmath133 km / h , and @xmath134 m we have @xmath135 the size @xmath123 of the recognition distance can be estimated using another argumentation . if @xmath136 s is the typical deceleration time from the velocity @xmath79 attained on the given empty road to zero value then the estimate @xmath137 should hold . for @xmath138 km / h we have again @xmath139 m. now the cost functional of car motion can be written in an integral form as expression ( [ 1.2 ] ) containing the integrand ( [ 2.1 ] ) . the car is assumed to be located at point @xmath140 along the road and to move with speed @xmath34 at the current moment @xmath0 of time . the possible paths of further motion @xmath141 form the set @xmath142 on which the cost functional is defined . here and below gothic letters will be used to label the path variables . the function @xmath143 allows for a derivation of all the dynamical variables , the headway distance @xmath144 , the car velocity @xmath145 , and the acceleration @xmath146 of the trial car path . the cost functional evaluating the quality of the path @xmath143 can be written as @xmath147 \mathcal{f}^d(\mathfrak{h},\mathfrak{u},\mathfrak{a})\,d\mathfrak{t}\,,\\ \intertext{or } \mathcal{l}\{\mathfrak{h}\ } & = \int_t^\infty \exp\left[-\frac{v}{\lambda}(\mathfrak{t}-t ) \right ] \mathcal{f}^d(\mathfrak{h},\mathfrak{u},\mathfrak{a})\,d\mathfrak{t}\ , . \label{2.7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] forms ( [ 2.4n ] ) and ( [ 2.7 ] ) correspond to the driver prediction with spatial or temporal limitations , respectively . the cost functional of form ( [ 2.4n ] ) was used in @xcite . subsequently , functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) is used because its form simplifies the mathematical manipulations when the velocity @xmath44 of the lead car is fixed . in particular , dealing with functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) we can specify directly the set of trial paths @xmath148 using solely the time dependence of @xmath149 of the headway distance . the path variables @xmath150 , @xmath151 are completely determined by the dependence @xmath149 : @xmath152 furthermore , the cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) matches the driver prediction with temporal limitation , the mechanism which also allows for the interpretation of the recognition region size in terms of @xmath153 . however , both of the cost functionals lead practically to the same results for the analyzed situation . each one of trial paths originates at time @xmath0 and starts from @xmath154 on the phase plane determined by the headway distance and velocity of the car at the current time @xmath0 . since we investigate the car motion inside traffic flow but not processes of leaving it we assume that time variations @xmath46 of the headway distance are bounded . therefore the trial paths fulfil @xmath155 and do exhibit bounded variations only as time goes to infinity . in other words , there is a constant @xmath156 with @xmath157 in what follows , the driver behavior will be described by the extremals of the cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) . using the standard variational technique and taking into account conditions ( [ 2.5 ] ) , ( [ 2.6 ] ) the governing equation for these extremals can be derived : @xmath158 to study the spectral properties of eq . ( [ 2.8 ] ) it is linearized around the stationary solution @xmath159 . its eigenfunctions can be found by the _ ansatz _ @xmath160 the obtained eigenvalue equation is given by @xmath161 with the coefficients @xmath162 and the derivatives are taken at the stationary point @xmath159 . the inequality @xmath163 is supposed to hold beforehand , in particular , it is the case for the cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) . equation ( [ 2.800 ] ) possesses four roots , one pair @xmath164 of them have positive real parts , the other @xmath165 have negative ones . since the eigenfunctions with the eigenvalues @xmath165 diverge as @xmath166 we must omit them by virtue of condition ( [ 2.6 ] ) . roughly speaking , these divergent eigenfunctions describe the process of a driver leaving traffic flow , for example , to stop the car . such processes are not under consideration . the former pair of eigenvalues are given by : @xmath167^{\tfrac{1}{2}}. \label{2.804}\ ] ] so , in a small neighborhood of the stationary point @xmath159 of equation ( [ 2.8 ] ) any extremal @xmath168 can be written as @xmath169 where @xmath170 and @xmath171 are some constants . equation ( [ 2.8 ] ) is of fourth order , so its general solution is specified by four conditions . solutions that diverge as time goes to infinity have to be omitted ( they are related to @xmath165 ) . their divergence is due to the exponential cofactor in integral ( [ 2.7 ] ) so it is retained beyond a small neighborhood of the stationary point @xmath172 . therefore , only two conditions are needed to specify the desired solution of eq . ( [ 2.8 ] ) . in particular , the initial headway distance @xmath24 and the car velocity @xmath34 determine it completely . the latter statement can also be proved for the more general form ( [ 2.4n ] ) of the cost functional @xcite . containing the current time @xmath0 as its argument . so the found optimal paths @xmath168 depend on the time @xmath0 when the driver plans the further motion . the right panel presents the ideal case where the driver is able to evaluate the motion cost precisely and the corresponding cost function @xmath173 does not contain the time @xmath0 . so , the optimal path family degenerates into one curve . it should be noted that the latter is correct even if the time @xmath174 enters the cost function via variations of the lead car velocity . [ fn ] ] in the previous section the dynamical cost functional was stated . at the next step the driver strategy based on this evaluation of the motion quality should be described ( fig . following @xcite , it is supposed that the driver , first , in planning the further motion chooses the path @xmath175 minimizing the motion cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) , @xmath176 to do this the driver `` solves '' equation ( [ 2.8 ] ) subject to conditions ( [ 2.5 ] ) , ( [ 2.6 ] ) and , thus , get the optimal path of further driving , @xmath177 . as noted in the previous section the optimal path choice is completely determined by the current car velocity @xmath34 and the headway distance @xmath24 . the terminal conditions , i.e. , the goal of reaching the steady - state motion is implied . since the driver controls the car motion through choosing the adequate value @xmath115 of acceleration she has to `` find '' the second derivative of @xmath168 with respect to the former argument @xmath174 ( see exp . ( [ 2.4 ] ) ) and , then , to `` calculate '' the result at the current time . therefore , @xmath178 relates the current car acceleration @xmath115 to the current headway distance @xmath24 and the car velocity @xmath34 . formula ( [ 2.61 ] ) describes the driver s choice at the current moment @xmath0 of time . to convert it into the governing equation of car motion we adopt the second assumption that the driver performs this choice continuously : @xmath179 all the car following models based on this equation , but with different particular forms of the cost function @xmath180 may be categorized as the rational car dynamics approximation . equation ( [ 2.62 ] ) holds even if the cost function @xmath181 depends explicitly on the time @xmath0 at which the driver plans her further motion . then , the driver evaluation of traffic flow state will change in time . therefore , the resulting path @xmath182 of the real car motion envelops the family of the optimal paths @xmath183 generated at different moments @xmath0 of time ( fig . [ fn ] , left panel ) . the present paper assumes driving to be perfect . the driver s choice is based on the precise knowledge of the cost function @xmath184 depending solely on the current headway distance @xmath24 , car velocity @xmath34 , acceleration @xmath115 , and , may be , the current time @xmath0 . it does not depend on the moment of time when the driver evaluates the possible paths of her further motion . this assumption leads to what is called the nash equilibrium in game theory @xcite . if , at time @xmath185 the driver has found the optimal path @xmath186 of the car motion ( which meets equation ( [ 2.8 ] ) and does not contain explicitly @xmath185 ) , then any re - computation a certain time @xmath187 later gives the same result , @xmath188 for @xmath189 . in other words , if at time @xmath185 the driver has chosen an optimal path @xmath190 then the further motion will be described by it independently of either the driver follows it without correction or optimizes the car motion continuously ( fig . [ fn ] , right panel ) . the nash equilibrium in the driver strategy enables us to conclude that equation ( [ 2.8 ] ) describes the real car dynamics , not only the imaginary paths existing in the driver s mind during her planing of the further motion . in particular , it can be rewritten in a form containing the real acceleration @xmath115 , velocity @xmath34 , and headway distance @xmath24 : @xmath191 in the vicinity of the stationary point @xmath192 its solution is actually given by _ ansatz _ ( [ 2.56 ] ) , which immediately leads us to the following expressions for the amplitudes [ 2.13 ] @xmath193 and relates the car acceleration @xmath115 to the car velocity @xmath34 and the headway distance @xmath24 : @xmath194 . \label{2.13aa}\ ] ] these results are analyzed individually . the stationary point @xmath195 of equation ( [ 2.9 ] ) gives the headway @xmath196 which the driver chooses in order to follow the lead car at speed @xmath44 . in particular , the expression @xmath197 specifies the relationship between the values of the headway @xmath24 and the car velocity @xmath34 for the stationary traffic flow imitated by the given car following problem . solving eq . ( [ 2.11 ] ) for the car velocity @xmath34 the optimal velocity approximation is obtained , @xmath198 . in particular , for the specific form ( [ 1.7 ] ) of the cost function @xmath51 we immediately get for @xmath199 @xmath200 where the spatial scale @xmath62 is given by expression @xmath201 relation ( [ 2.12 ] ) or similar sigmoid functions are widely used in current literature . in particular , for @xmath202 m and @xmath203 m exp . ( [ 2.51 ] ) gives the estimate @xmath204 m typically ascribed to the spatial scale @xmath62 . and the ratio @xmath205 vs @xmath206 . in drawing these curves exp . ( [ 2.804 ] ) with @xmath207 and @xmath208 was used . the solid curve is @xmath209 , the dashed curve is @xmath210 . [ fbrdm],title="fig:",width=264 ] + by introducing the time scale @xmath211 and the coefficient @xmath212 the car dynamics equation ( [ 2.13aa ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath213.\ ] ] equation ( [ lge ] ) plays a significant role in models that describe non - rational driver behavior @xcite , where expression ( [ lge ] ) specifies an optimal acceleration that could be chosen by rational drivers and the parameter @xmath214 was introduced phenomenologically . here , @xmath214 can be computed using the cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) . it is plotted as well as the ratio @xmath205 as a function of the variable @xmath206 ( fig . [ fbrdm ] ) . this representation is due to the fact that the coefficient @xmath215 ( for the cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) @xmath216 for @xmath217 ) , the coefficient @xmath218 by virtue of the adopted assumption ( [ 2.sigma ] ) , whereas the coefficient @xmath206 varies around unity . below , the latter will be justified and the dependence of the coefficient @xmath206 on the car motion state will be analyzed . as seen in fig . [ fbrdm ] the time scales @xmath18 and @xmath121 practically coincide with each other and the parameter @xmath214 is a small value . using again the cost function eq . ( [ 1.7 ] ) , and taking into account @xmath219 and @xmath216 , the optimal velocity dependence @xmath220 is given by eq . ( [ 2.12 ] ) . the parameter @xmath206 depends as follows on the car motion state @xmath221 it attains the maximum @xmath222 at @xmath223 . using @xmath224 s , @xmath138 km / h , @xmath225 m , and @xmath226 m , respectively , @xmath227 is obtained . of course , this is not a precise numerical value , but in general @xmath228 may be assumed . ( labelled by numbers in squares ) . the solid curves display the relaxation caused by a perturbation in the headway , the dashed one shows the same for a velocity perturbation . the variations in the headway distance and relative velocity are measured either in units of the initial values @xmath229 and @xmath230 or @xmath231 and @xmath232 , respectively . [ frc],title="fig:",width=264 ] + ( labelled by numbers in squares ) . the solid curves display the relaxation caused by a perturbation in the headway , the dashed one shows the same for a velocity perturbation . the variations in the headway distance and relative velocity are measured either in units of the initial values @xmath229 and @xmath230 or @xmath231 and @xmath232 , respectively . [ frc],title="fig:",width=264 ] + the precise value of @xmath233 matters . according to sec . [ sec : ee ] the car dynamics is characterized by two eigenfunctions with eigenvalues given by eq . ( [ 2.804 ] ) . when @xmath234 , the relaxation is a pure fading process characterized by time scales @xmath235 and @xmath236 . otherwise , @xmath237 , the relaxation process is characterized by the complex eigenvalues , @xmath238 , @xmath239 . however in this region their dependence on @xmath206 is sufficiently weak , @xmath240{\omega}$ ] for @xmath241 as follows from exp . ( [ 2.804 ] ) . therefore the car relaxation processes should be rather insensitive to the value of @xmath206 as it varies from unity to about ten . figure [ frc ] demonstrates this fact showing the relaxation curves induced by deviations from the stationary values of the headway and the car velocity individually . all the corresponding curves lie near each other , only for @xmath242 a larger deviation is visible . this is because for such values of @xmath206 the eigenvalues @xmath243 differ essentially . by contrast , the cost of acceleration , i.e. , the cost of correcting the car motion depends strongly on @xmath206 because this component of the cost function ( [ 2.1 ] ) varies linearly with @xmath206 to the first approximation . since the maximum @xmath233 of the parameter @xmath206 is attained at @xmath244 this means that the greater the value of @xmath206 , the larger is the cost of the car governing with respect to the cost of motion in its own accord . keeping in mind the aforementioned speculations let us assume that the composed parameter @xmath233 takes a certain fixed numerical value , @xmath245 . it leads immediately to a certain relationship between the initial quantities of the model , @xmath79 , @xmath123 , @xmath121 , @xmath85 . in this collection only the optimal velocity @xmath246 on empty road is determined solely by the driver behavior . the other parameters , namely , the size @xmath123 of recognition region , the characteristic time scale @xmath121 of the car ability to accelerate or decelerate , and the characteristic headway @xmath85 that drivers can control reliably and should be about the typical headway distance in dense jams are determined by other mechanisms , e.g. , car properties , driver physiology , visual conditions and the like . at first glance such relations seem to be impossible , because a driver chooses the optimal velocity on empty road depending on the road conditions , speed regulations , weather , _ etc_. nevertheless , there is an additional factor affecting the car motion on empty roads , the driver experience . if the driver preference for the empty road velocity stems from here experience of driving in low density traffic flow then such relations can exist . in the given model this assumptions lead to the expression @xmath247^{\tfrac12 } \frac{l^{\frac14}\lambda^{\frac34}}{\tau}\ ] ] naturally , the specific form of relation ( [ 2.vmax ] ) will change if , for example , another _ ansatz _ of the cost function is used , however , its qualitative features should be retained . these speculations , definitely , are not enough to regard relations similar to formula ( [ 2.vmax ] ) as an established theoretical result . we have presented it for discussion only . as discussed already there are two stimuli for a driver to change the current motion state . one is the velocity difference @xmath248 between the leading car and her car . the second is the difference between the current speed @xmath34 and the optimal speed @xmath23 as function of headway . models like ( [ imodels ] ) take into account both of them , leaving the determination of the weight coefficients to appropriate empirical or experimental data . the results obtained so far actually allow to predict these coefficients . of the combined model ( [ cm ] ) vs the stationary headway @xmath249 . for comparison , the dashed curve shows the optimal velocity , eq . ( [ 2.12]).[fkap],width=264 ] this can be demonstrated with the combined model ( [ cm ] ) . linearizing eq . ( [ cm ] ) around the stationary point @xmath172 and comparing the result with eq . ( [ 2.13aa ] ) we get @xmath250 ^{-1}. \label{2.cfp4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression gives @xmath251 as function of the car motion state . figure [ fkap ] plots this dependence for the cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) . as seen in fig . [ fkap ] the weight coefficient @xmath251 is small for all interesting values of the headway distance in the car following regime . only for small headways @xmath252 ( dense jams ) or for large headways @xmath249 exceeding @xmath62 substantially ( free flow ) @xmath251 approaches unity . as the headway distance @xmath249 varies in the interval @xmath253 the coefficient @xmath254 changes essentially , leading to qualitatively different car dynamics . as mentioned before , when @xmath255 the relaxation exhibits damped oscillations around the stationary point @xmath172 . this is due to the eigenvalues @xmath256 ( see exp . ( [ 2.804 ] ) ) having non - zero imaginary parts . since for @xmath257 their real and imaginary parts are of the same order the car motion relaxation is characterized by one time scale about one ( in units of @xmath121 ) . this is true also for @xmath258 because @xmath259 there , although the dynamics is a pure fading process now . for still smaller values of @xmath260 the ratio @xmath261 of these eigenvalues becomes smaller than one half , which may be defined as the two - scale regime of the dynamics , see fig . [ fro ] . of the corresponding eigenfunctions describing the car motion relaxation as a function of @xmath206 or the headway @xmath249 when @xmath262 is fixed . computations in this figure used cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) and @xmath263.[fro],width=302 ] the change between the two - scale and the one - scale regime corresponds to a value of @xmath2641.5 @xmath62 . below this value , the dynamical behavior is one - scale , above it is two - scale and will be called `` fast - and - slow '' in the following . concerning with the `` fast - and - slow '' dynamics the velocity relaxation and the headway relaxation can be analyzed individually . according to exps ( [ 2.13 ] ) the initial difference @xmath265 contributes mainly to the eigenfunction with the eigenvalue @xmath239 . thereby , the velocity difference @xmath248 contributes mostly to the amplitude @xmath266 . the amplitude @xmath267 also contains the term of the same magnitude , however , the time scale @xmath236 on which the corresponding eigenfunction varies is much bigger than the time scale @xmath235 of the other eigenfunction . so , the velocity relaxation falls on the first eigenfunction . thus , the velocity difference @xmath248 disappears practically completely during the time @xmath235 , which forms the `` fast '' stage of the car relaxation . at the next `` slow '' stage of duration @xmath235 the headway deviation from the equilibrium value @xmath249 disappears . to summarize , the `` fast - and - slow '' car dynamics is a two - stage process where the velocity difference between the cars is eliminated first . later on , the headway is optimized . while this is being done , the resulting velocity difference is not essential and the driver can govern the car motion without the necessity of responding fast . . [ fol],width=264 ] another important characteristics , separating dense traffic and quasi - free flow can be derived as follows . the solution of the eigenvalue equation ( [ 2.800 ] ) depend actually on two values , @xmath268 and @xmath206 , since @xmath216 for the cost functional ( [ 1.7 ] ) . the parameter @xmath269 by virtue of the adopted assumption ( [ 2.sigma ] ) . the maximum of @xmath206 attained at @xmath270 is much larger than @xmath271 as it results from exp . ( [ 2.omegamax ] ) . however , as the headway distance increases the value @xmath254 decreases as @xmath272 ( see exp . ( [ 2.omega ] ) ) whereas @xmath273 . so there is a value @xmath274 of the headway distance at which both these terms contribute to the eigenvalues to the same extent . to find @xmath274 consider @xmath275 where @xmath276 and @xmath277 , thereby , @xmath278 and @xmath279 by virtue of formula ( [ 2.804 ] ) so , @xmath274 is specified by @xmath280 the value @xmath274 divides the headway distance region into two parts , see fig . [ fol ] . when @xmath281 the velocity of the following car is close to @xmath79 , so this type of car motion will be referred to as the quasi - free flow . in this case the eigenvalue equation ( [ 2.800 ] ) can not be simplified , so to describe the quasi - free flow the cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) only in its full form may be used . in the opposite case , @xmath282 , which will be called dense traffic mode , the term @xmath268 is ignorable , reducing the eigenvalue equation ( [ 2.800 ] ) to @xmath283 moreover , in the latter case the description of car dynamics can be reduced to the standard form of classical mechanics , enabling us to analyze the nonlinear stage of the car dynamics . in the dense traffic limit @xmath282 , the variational principle based on optimizing the cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) can be simplified essentially . in the given limit the characteristic time scales of the car dynamics are @xmath121 and @xmath284 , with both of them being small in comparison with @xmath285 . the latter follows from the adopted assumption ( [ 2.sigma ] ) and the condition @xmath286 for @xmath282 . in this case , as shown in appendix [ app : b ] , the cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) can be replaced by the following effective functional whose integrand does not contain a time dependent factor @xmath287 where the integrand , which will be called the lagrangian of the car dynamics is given by @xmath288 interestingly , @xmath289 contains the lead car velocity @xmath44 as a parameter and attains its extremal value with respect to @xmath24 at the point @xmath196 corresponding to the optimal driving with the velocity @xmath44 . the term @xmath290 has been introduced for the sake of convenience only , it does not affect the extremal equation but enables the lagrangian to attain a minimum with respect to the car velocity @xmath34 at the stationary point @xmath172 . both functionals ( [ 2.7 ] ) and ( [ 10.2 ] ) possess the same extremals to the first order in the small parameter @xmath291 . in particular , the extremals of functional ( [ 10.2 ] ) meet the equation @xmath292 it corresponds directly to the initial full equation ( [ 2.9 ] ) where the second and third terms in the former parentheses are ignored whereas the second term in the latter parentheses is replaced by its value taken at the stationary point . it is justified because these terms are due to variations of the time dependent cofactor . keeping in mind its following applications we rewrite lagrangian @xmath289 also in the form @xmath293 in particular , for the cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) we get @xmath294 in obtaining formula ( [ 10.302 ] ) we have taken into account the expression ( [ 2.12 ] ) relating the velocity @xmath44 to the headway distance @xmath249 , expression ( [ 2.omega ] ) , and omitted some insignificant terms . the latter term in expression ( [ 10.301 ] ) can be also omitted because it has no effect on the extremal equation . the most essential feature of the effective cost functional ( [ 10.2 ] ) is the absence of a time dependent cofactor . this enables us to reformulate the car dynamics in terms of autonomous hamiltonian equations . finding the extremals of functional ( [ 10.2 ] ) can be done as follows . the phase space @xmath295 is expanded to @xmath296 by adding the relationship between the headway distance @xmath24 and the car velocity @xmath34 as an additional constraint : @xmath297 and the initial and final conditions , @xmath298 for the sake of simplicity the parameter @xmath44 has been omitted in the list of variables of @xmath299 , the current time is set to zero . by using a lagrange multiplier , the problem ( [ app.4 ] ) is rewritten in the standard form . namely , the extremals of @xmath300dt \label{app.7}\ ] ] are sought . they are defined on the extended set of variables @xmath301 and subject to conditions ( [ app.6a ] ) , ( [ app.6b ] ) . the extremals of functional ( [ app.7 ] ) obey the classical lagrange equations . in constructing the hamiltonian @xmath302 that produces the same extremal equations the pontryagin technique is used @xcite . introducing the new variable @xmath303 @xmath304 and solving for @xmath305 , i.e. , finding @xmath306 , the desired hamiltonian is written as @xmath307 it can be demonstrated directly that the desired extremals meet the standard hamiltonian system of equations @xmath308 again , the optimization of functional ( [ app.4 ] ) actually leads to a boundary value problem because the extremal is specified by both the initial and final conditions ( [ app.6a ] ) , ( [ app.6b ] ) . the hamiltonian approach ( [ app.h1])([app.h2 ] ) also shares this property . namely , the initial values of the variables @xmath24 and @xmath34 are given by conditions ( [ app.6a ] ) , whereas the initial values @xmath309 and @xmath310 of the quasi - momenta @xmath311 and @xmath303 should be chosen such that the system tend to the stationary point @xmath172 as @xmath312 . it is the same situation that we met in dealing with equation ( [ 2.9 ] ) however , the hamiltonian description has a certain advantage . first , the hamiltonian itself is conserved,@xmath313 second , an additional autonomous first integral of the system ( [ app.h1 ] ) , ( [ app.h2 ] ) , can be found , at least , for a certain stage of the car dynamics . fortunately , this is the case for the `` fast - and - slow '' car dynamics analyzed below . note , that this hamiltonian description of the car motion relaxation towards the stationary state does not contradict the conservation of phase volume being the general property of hamiltonian systems . the matter is that the relaxation process is described by only _ one _ path leading to the stationary point of the saddle type . other possible paths are not considered . the two eqns ( [ app.h1 ] ) can be understood readily . the equation for @xmath314 is just @xmath315 , while the equation for @xmath316 , or , what is the same , expression ( [ app.q ] ) shows that the quasi - momentum @xmath303 is proportional to the car acceleration @xmath317 : @xmath318 the physical meaning of the quasi - momentum @xmath311 is more complex . to clarify it , rewrite the equation line ( [ app.h2 ] ) in terms of partial derivatives of the lagrangian @xmath319 . namely , the definitions of the quasi - momentum @xmath303 ( [ app.q ] ) and the hamiltonian ( [ app.h ] ) enables us to represent these equations as @xmath320 in particular , expressions ( [ 10.100])([10.102 ] ) immediately lead , as it must , to equation ( [ 10.0 ] ) . expression ( [ 10.101 ] ) demonstrates that the quasi - momentum @xmath311 includes the rate @xmath321 of acceleration variations . in this way the variable @xmath321 implicitly enters the hamiltonian @xmath302 specifying a hyper - surface in the four - dimensional phase space @xmath322 . even more , by ignoring the dependence of @xmath319 on the headway distance @xmath24 , the velocity relaxation towards the stationary value @xmath44 is governed by the equation @xmath323 it results from the effective cost functional ( [ 10.2 ] ) where the car velocity @xmath34 is treated as a primary argument . as will be seen below , there is a stage of the car dynamics where this assumption is justified and the quasi - momentum @xmath324 is conserved . only the dependence of the lagrangian @xmath319 on the headway distance @xmath24 , see eq . ( [ 10.102 ] ) , causes variations in the quasi - momentum @xmath311 . since the velocity control is of primary importance in the driving strategy , the variable @xmath311 can be regarded as a certain measure of the necessity to control also the headway distance when eliminating the velocity difference . for @xmath325 the last term on the right - hand side of exp . ( [ 10.3b ] ) is small . since the headway @xmath24 enters the hamiltonian ( [ app.h ] ) exactly via this term time variations in the quasi - momentum @xmath311 are retarded by virtue of the first equation at line ( [ app.h2 ] ) . the same follows from eq . ( [ 10.102 ] ) . the other variables @xmath24 , @xmath34 , @xmath303 can vary substantially on scales independent of the value @xmath325 . then , the car dynamics can exhibit multi - scale relaxation . in particular , sec . [ sec : tcmd ] demonstrated this fact , namely , it has been shown that in the given limit the system dynamics comprises the fast and slow stages . exactly the time scale of the latter stages depends on the value @xmath326 . during the former stage the quasi - momentum @xmath311 should be practically constant , i.e. , it is approximately a first integral of the system ( [ app.h1 ] ) , ( [ app.h2 ] ) . this property , together with the conservation of hamiltonian ( [ app.h ] ) , allows the integration of the system of equations ( [ app.h1 ] ) , ( [ app.h2 ] ) . during the following slow stage a quasi - stationary approximation can be used to analyze the system evolution . the results below are exemplified with the cost function ( [ 1.7 ] ) . they can be easily generalized to other cost functions . at the zeroth approximation in the small parameter @xmath206 the quasi - momentum @xmath311 is a constant . during the fast stage mainly the velocity deference @xmath248 is eliminated , so eq . ( [ 10.101 ] ) formally describes the relaxation process of the car velocity @xmath34 to the stationary value @xmath44 . therefore , by virtue of exp . ( [ 10.301 ] ) , the quasi - momentum @xmath311 takes zero value , @xmath327 . in this limit the lagrangian component @xmath328 as well as the additive constant of the component @xmath329 can be omitted . so , the hamiltonian ( [ app.h ] ) becomes @xmath330 and the non - canonical variables @xmath295 are used . since the hamiltonian @xmath331 is conserved and the fast stage describes the velocity relaxation to @xmath44 the car dynamics obeys the equation @xmath332 this immediately gives the relationship between the acceleration @xmath115 and the velocity @xmath34 @xmath333 the sign in the latter equation has been chosen so to allow for the system relaxation . equation ( [ fs.1 ] ) is , in fact , of the general form and the linear form of eq . ( [ nad12 ] ) is due to the adopted quadratic _ ansatz _ of the cost function but not a consequence of linearization . besides , equality ( [ fs.1 ] ) can be read as follows . the comparison of the hamiltonian parts @xmath334 and @xmath335 with the corresponding components of lagrangian ( [ 10.3b ] ) demonstrates that the function @xmath334 actually measures the cost of the car acceleration and the function @xmath335 does the same with respect to the car motion relative to the optimal driving conditions . thereby , during the fast stage the driver corrects the car dynamics so that the cost of acceleration be equal to the cost of current motion measured relative to the stationary conditions . and the car velocity @xmath336 where the car dynamics is collisionfree ( based on equation ( [ nad13])).[fcol ] ] the headway distance @xmath24 does not enter explicitly the governing equation of the fast stage . however , it varies during the fast stage and finally attains a value @xmath337 differing from the initial value @xmath338 . in the adopted simple approximation of the cost function eq . ( [ nad12 ] ) enables to estimate easily the value @xmath337 . namely , the direct integration of eq . ( [ nad12 ] ) yields the relationship @xmath339 applying to formula ( [ nad1010 ] ) it can be seen that expression ( [ nad13 ] ) holds until the headway distance @xmath24 becomes too small and it is impossible to ignore the effect of the term @xmath340 , i.e. , when @xmath341{\omega}\ , h_v \ll h_v\,.\ ] ] the car dynamics in the region of small values of the headway distance when the probability of collision is high is worth of an individual consideration . here we only touch on this problem by assuming the collision to happen when the value @xmath337 given by exp . ( [ nad13 ] ) becomes equal to zero . this assumption is justified as a rough approximation due to estimate ( [ nad14 ] ) , see fig . the boundary of the collisionless region can be shifted to the right substantially by dropping the assumed quadratic dependence of the cost function on acceleration . this will be done elsewhere . when the system attains a quasi - equilibrium with respect to the car velocity @xmath34 its further evolution is due to the direct dependence of the hamiltonian @xmath342 on the headway distance @xmath24 . it enters the hamiltonian via @xmath328 . as a result , the velocity difference @xmath248 and the acceleration @xmath115 should be small . keeping this in mind , eq . ( [ 10.101 ] ) can be solved for @xmath311 . substitution of the obtained expression into eq . ( [ 10.102 ] ) , and the further linearization with respect to the variable @xmath248 and the component @xmath343 results in @xmath344 if @xmath345 is the characteristic time scale of the slow stage then @xmath346 these estimates together with eq . ( [ st.1 ] ) lead to @xmath347 in particular , the rate @xmath348 of time variations in the quasi - momentum @xmath303 scales as @xmath349 for @xmath350 . since the lagrangian @xmath299 has a minimum at @xmath351 the quasi - momentum @xmath311 can be estimated as @xmath352 by virtue of eq . ( [ 10.102 ] ) . in the limit @xmath325 the term @xmath348 can be ignored in comparison with the quasi - momentum @xmath311 . then , eq . ( [ 10.101 ] ) immediately leads to the relation @xmath353 which is no more than the standard expression for the momentum of a system described by the lagrangian @xmath354 with @xmath355 . by the same reasons all the terms in hamiltonian ( [ app.h ] ) containing the quasi - momentum @xmath303 may be omitted . then the substitution of ( [ st.3 ] ) into ( [ app.h ] ) yields the hamiltonian of the slow stage @xmath356 in the lagrangian component @xmath328 the car velocity @xmath34 has been replaced by its stationary value @xmath44 , and some negligible terms have been omitted . then the conservation of the hamiltonian @xmath357 during the system dynamics gets the form @xmath358 the conservation law ( [ st.6 ] ) can be understood in analogy to that for the fast stage . however , during the slow stage of the car dynamics the car velocity plays the role of the control parameter . the driver changes the speed to correct the headway distance . again the cost of deviation of the car velocity from the stationary value is chosen to be equal to the cost of the car motion measured relative to the optimal conditions . it should be pointed out that the slow stage of the car dynamics is governed by the conservation law , exp . ( [ st.6 ] ) , which contains only the headway distance @xmath24 and the velocity @xmath34 . at the first approximation , the acceleration @xmath115 does not enter at all . in this meaning , the slow stage is similar to other physical systems . however , the stationary point of the car dynamics is a saddle point rather than a minimum . up to now , the two different stages of car - following discussed already in sec . [ sec : tcmd ] have been identified with two different conservation laws . both of them can be unified into just another effective conservation law interpolating exps . ( [ fs.1 ] ) and ( [ st.6 ] ) : @xmath359 within the same accuracy it is possible to interpolate directly eqs . ( [ nad12 ] ) and ( [ st.7 ] ) , leading to @xmath360 . \label{nad1010}\ ] ] besides , the proposed interpretations of the conservation laws ( [ fs.1 ] ) and ( [ st.6 ] ) enable us to formulate a generalized principle of adequate control . it declares that the effective cost of correcting the car motion via changing the car acceleration ( fast stage ) or the car velocity ( slow stage ) is equal to the cost of the current state of car motion measured with respect to the optimal driving conditions . a variational approach to the description of car dynamics has been developed in case of a car following a lead car moving at a constant speed . to derive governing equations for the following car motion the driver preference has been used to construct a cost functional . its extremals specify the optimal paths of the further motion for the following car . applying to the general properties of the driver behavior we analyzed the basic properties of the cost function and proposed a simple parabolic _ ansatz _ , which , nevertheless , catches typical features of traffic properties . the concept of a rational driver is formulated . it comprises the assumptions that the driver follows the optimal paths and corrects the car motion continuously . in this case the optimal path is a nash equilibrium of the system , which is defined as follows . if the driver has chosen an optimal path at a certain moment of time then no further correction of the car motion is necessary because it leads to the same result . as the consequence of the nash equilibrium the extremals of the cost functional specify the real dynamics of cars with rational drivers although originally they determine only the imaginary paths in the driver s mind when planning the further motion . in this way we obtained several results . the optimal velocity approximation has been derived . the weight coefficient entering a car following model combining the `` following - the - leader '' model and the optimal velocity model has been found depending on the headway distance . as an important result it has been shown that the car dynamics can be categorized under different types according to its properties . first , we have shown that there can be two types of the car relaxation towards the stationary motion , the mono - scale dynamics and the `` fast - and - slow '' dynamics . second , we singled out the quasi - free motion and the dense traffic mode . the variational technique for the latter mode can be simplified essentially . namely , it is possible to reformulate the cost functional so that it does not contain a time dependent cofactor . as a result , the autonomous hamiltonian description for the car dynamics has been constructed . for the dense traffic mode the `` fast - and - slow '' dynamics has been analyzed for the nonlinear stage . in particular , different conservation laws for this stages have been found . a generalized principle of adequate car motion control has been proposed . we assumed that the lead car moves at a fixed speed . if it is not the case two different situations should be singled out . for perfect drivers who can predict rigorously the motion of the car ahead the main results still hold . otherwise the cost function will depend not only on the current time but also , what is crucial , on the time when the driver has started to evaluate the further car dynamics . this disturbs the nash equilibrium and the car correction should be carried out continuously . briefly this problem was studied in @xcite but it actually requires a more detailed investigation . real drivers have certain limitations . they are not capable of finding the optimal path precisely and they can not correct the car motion continuously . so , the concept of rational driver behavior is just the first approximation of the real situation and deviations from this perfect behavior should be analyzed consistently . a first step towards this problem can be found in ref . here we justify some assumptions adopted there and substantiated them in a different way . let us again concern the driver evaluation of the car motion quality . for a given path of the car s further motion @xmath361 the cost functional ( [ 2.7 ] ) is written as @xmath362 \,.\end{gathered}\ ] ] expression ( [ br.1 ] ) can be represented also in the form @xmath363 \nonumber\\ & + \frac{2v}{\vartheta_{\text{max}}^{2}}(h - h_{v})+\mathcal{l}_{0}\ , , \label{br.2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath364 describes the deviation of the given path from the stationary car motion trajectory , @xmath365 here , @xmath366 is the cost of stationary car motion , @xmath367 in addition , when deriving expression ( [ br.1 ] ) we have used @xmath368 integrated various fragments of eq . ( [ br.1 ] ) by parts , assuming @xmath369 , and dropped terms like @xmath370 where ever possible . when the driver plan her further motion the current values of the headway @xmath24 and the velocity @xmath34 are regarded as the initial conditions . so , when choosing the optimal path she can minimize only the first term @xmath371 of expression ( [ br.2 ] ) . this optimization is implemented through the adequate control over the car acceleration @xmath115 , so , exactly the acceleration plays the role of the control parameter available for the driver actions . a real driver can only approximately evaluate the quality of motion . let us describe the threshold in the driver perception of the motion quality by @xmath372 where @xmath373 is a small constant , @xmath374 , because definitely a driver can recognize the difference in the state of staying and freely motion on an empty road . when the controllable part @xmath375 of the cost motion is much smaller then the threshold ( [ br.4 ] ) the driver actually has no information of how to govern the car motion . in this case it is natural to assume that he will not do anything with respect to the car driving and , so , will fix the car motion at the current state , including the current acceleration @xmath115 . thereby the inequality @xmath376 determine the region in the phase space @xmath295 inside which the driver can not control the car motion . in evaluating such a driver behavior with expression ( [ br.2 ] ) we can formally treat @xmath377 , @xmath378 , and @xmath379 as constants independent of one another . so setting @xmath380 , @xmath381 , and @xmath382 and taking into account the relation between @xmath196 and @xmath44 we get from condition ( [ br.5 ] ) the approximate boundary of this region in the following form @xmath383 we recall that the parameter @xmath214 entering eq . ( [ lge ] ) coincides with @xmath384 . so we reproduced here the expression for the rational driving boundary as has been introduced in paper @xcite by a different line of reasonings . these investigations were supported in part by rfbr grants 01 - 01 - 00389 , 00439 , ur grant 01.03.005/2 , intas grant 00 - 0847 , and russian program `` integration '' project b0056 , during a stay of one of the authors ( il ) at the institute for transport research of the german aerospace centre . a set @xmath385 of one - dimensional paths @xmath386 of car motion is considered . all the paths are supposed to originate from one point @xmath387 at the initial time @xmath388 , i.e. @xmath389 , and to go to infinity , @xmath390 , as @xmath312 such that the car velocity @xmath391 is bounded during the motion , @xmath392 ( here @xmath62 is some constant ) . it is assumed that the set @xmath385 is ordered by a certain preference relation @xmath393 and there is a functional @xmath394 of the form @xmath395 measuring numerically the preference relation , i.e. meeting the condition @xmath396 here , first , the integrand @xmath397 depends on the car position on the road @xmath398 , the velocity @xmath45 , and , may be , the current moment @xmath0 of time . it plays the role of cost function , i.e. evaluates the quality of the car motion state at current time . second , the weight factor takes one of the forms @xmath399 where @xmath400 and @xmath401 as @xmath402 or @xmath403 . the functions @xmath404 and @xmath405 describe the spatial or temporal limitations in the driver prediction , respectively . the examples @xmath406 where @xmath407 and @xmath44 are some constants , enable us to relate the cost functional ( [ appp1 ] ) to ones used in the main text . the specific form of @xmath404 and @xmath405 , however , does not affect the results to be obtained in this appendix . let @xmath408 be another cost functional of form ( [ appp1 ] ) with its own integrand @xmath409 that also describes the same preference relation . the purpose of the present appendix is to derive the relationship between the cost functions @xmath397 and @xmath409 . for this purpose the path set @xmath385 is divided into classes @xmath410 of equivalent paths , i.e. @xmath411 if @xmath412 or , what is the same , @xmath413 . the cost functional @xmath414 based on the integrand @xmath409 has to preserve this class partition . so the condition @xmath415 must hold for any infinitesimal perturbation @xmath416 of a path @xmath398 within the class @xmath417 $ ] . using the lagrange multiplier technique and taking into account the initial condition @xmath418 ( thus , @xmath419 ) the latter requirement is reduced to the equation @xmath420 where the function @xmath421 and @xmath422 is a certain constant for all the points @xmath423 on the phase plane @xmath424 related by the given curve @xmath398 . let us show that the value of @xmath425 is constant for _ all _ the points of the phase plane . the cost functions @xmath409 , @xmath397 are chosen , thereby , if the _ quasi - local _ equation ( [ appp4 ] ) holds , the value of @xmath426 must be determined by any fragment of the path @xmath398 under consideration , for example , by a fragment @xmath427 . for @xmath428 and @xmath429 any point @xmath430 can be joined to the fragment @xmath431 by a certain path @xmath432 which must be characterized by the same value of @xmath425 . the latter proves this statement because the time moments @xmath433 have been taken arbitrary . the cost function @xmath397 ( as well as @xmath409 ) and the weight factor @xmath434 describe different effects of the car driving , so they are not related to each other . thus the terms of eq . ( [ appp4 ] ) containing @xmath435 , @xmath436 , or @xmath437 should be equal to zero individually . thereby @xmath438 and @xmath439 the solutions of system ( [ appp5 ] ) , ( [ appp6a ] ) and system ( [ appp5 ] ) , ( [ appp6b ] ) have the forms @xmath440 respectively , where @xmath441 and @xmath442 are arbitrary functions of @xmath140 and @xmath0 . thereby the desired relationship of the cost functions @xmath397 , @xmath409 is given for @xmath443 by the expression @xmath444 where the constant @xmath445 must be positive , @xmath446 . formulae ( [ appp7a ] ) and ( [ appp7b ] ) specify the admissible family of cost functions entering cost functional ( [ appp1 ] ) that preserve the preference relation . as seen directly , integral ( [ appp1 ] ) with the integrands @xmath441 and @xmath442 is independent of a particular form of the path @xmath398 . so the transformations ( [ appp7a ] ) and ( [ appp7b ] ) correspond to the linear transformation of the cost functional . the problem of finding the extremals of the functional @xmath447 defined on a set of paths @xmath448 is considered . here , first , the integrand @xmath449 is a given function of the headway distance @xmath24 , the current velocity @xmath450 , and the acceleration @xmath451 . second , the weight factor @xmath452 is a function of time @xmath0 confined within some time interval @xmath453 , i.e. , @xmath454 , @xmath455 for @xmath456 , and @xmath457 sufficiently fast as @xmath403 . so , @xmath458 can be adopted without lost of generality . third , the trial paths @xmath182 meet the initial conditions @xmath459 and do not diverge as time goes on , i.e. , there is a number @xmath460 so that @xmath461 the properties of the functional extremals have been studied already . keeping in mind the results in sec@xmath462[sec:2 ] , a special case is analyzed in the following . let @xmath463 be the characteristic time scale of the velocity relaxation to the stationary value @xmath44 . in particular , the values of @xmath463 are estimated by the eigenvalues of the corresponding extremal equation linearized near the stationary point . the case @xmath464 is considered here to show how the functional ( [ appb.1 ] ) can be rewritten to eliminate the time dependent factor @xmath465 . in this way the problem of finding the extremals gets the classical form met in theoretical mechanics . the stationary point @xmath466 is determined by the properties of both the function @xmath449 and the factor @xmath465 ( see exp . ( [ 2.11 ] ) ) . as a result , at the stationary point ( see again exp . ( [ 2.11 ] ) ) @xmath467 the derivative @xmath468 does not contain factors similar to @xmath469 . so , @xmath465 can not be omitted directly . as a first step the function @xmath449 is replaced by the difference @xmath470 . this does not affect the extremals . the difference @xmath471 as a function of @xmath0 is practically confined within a time interval @xmath472 whose upper boundary @xmath473 and , so , @xmath474 . therefore , at the next step expression ( [ appb.1 ] ) is rewritten as @xmath475 which is justified to the first order in the small parameter @xmath476 by virtue of expressions ( [ appb.4 ] ) and the fact that the second term in exp . ( [ appb.5 ] ) plays a substantial role only when the path @xmath46 tends to the stationary point . here the symbol @xmath477 means that functional ( [ appb.5 ] ) possesses the same collection of the extremals as the initial functional @xmath478 within the adopted accuracy and the time dependent factor @xmath465 has been approximated by @xmath479 formula ( [ appb.6 ] ) can be regarded actually as the definition of the time scale @xmath480 ^{-1}$ ] . taking into account the relation @xmath481 and integrating the second term in exp . ( [ appb.5 ] ) by parts yields @xmath482 omitting the constant components of the integrand which does not affect the extremals the required result follows @xmath483 minimization of functional ( [ appb.8 ] ) gives the desired extremals and integral ( [ appb.8 ] ) does not contain a time dependent factor . the function @xmath484 can be regarded as a lagrangian of the car dynamics . r. wiedemann , simulation des straenverkehrsflues , ph.d .- thesis , heft 8 der schriftenreihe des ifv , karlsruhe , in german ( 1974 ) , c. l. barrett , m. wolinsky , and m. w. olesen , in : _ proceedings of international workshop of traffic and granular flow _ , editors d. e. wolf , m. schreckenberg , and a. bachem ( world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) , p. 169 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the need for a relativistic methodology that is broadly applicable to nuclear physics has never been more apparent . one of our most important sets of problems involves understanding the transition between the ( baryon , meson ) and the ( quark , gluon ) degrees of freedom . using a relativistic formulation of the hadronic degrees of freedom is necessary to avoid a misinterpretation of a kinematic effect as a signal for the transition . the goal of understanding future high momentum studies of nuclear targets using exclusive , nearly exclusive or inclusive processes can only be met through using relativistic techniques . the light front approach of dirac@xcite in which the time variable is taken as @xmath0 and the spatial variables are @xmath1 @xcite is one of the promising approaches because the momentum canonically conjugate to @xmath2 , @xmath3 , is directly related to the observables . it is worthwhile to begin with a qualitative explanation of the utility of these light cone variables and this light front approach in a qualitative fashion . consider lepton - nucleus deep inelastic scattering as a first example . the observed structure function depends on the bjorken variable @xmath4 which in the parton model is the ratio of the quark plus momentum to that of the target . if one regards the nucleus as a collection of nucleons , @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the plus momentum of a nucleon bound in the nucleus . thus , a more direct relationship between the necessary nuclear theory and experiment occurs by using a theory in which @xmath6 is one of the canonical variables . since @xmath6 is conjugate to a spatial variable @xmath7 , it is natural to quantize the dynamical variables at the equal light cone time variable of @xmath8 . to use such a formalism is to use light front quantization , since the other three spatial coordinates ( @xmath9 ) are on a plane perpendicular to a light like vector@xcite . this use of light front quantization requires a new derivation of the nuclear wave function , because previous work used the equal time formalism . are these light cone variables useful only in nuclear deep inelastic scattering ? let s answer this by examining the origin of such coordinates . the four momentum of the incident virtual photon , q , can be said to have the components @xmath10 , with @xmath11 , and @xmath12 very large but @xmath13 finite ( the bjorken limit ) . then @xmath14 the condition that the reaction be elastic scattering from the quarks is that @xmath15 or @xmath16 . thus @xmath5 results from having only one large momentum in the problem , which can be taken in the negative z - direction , so that minus component is enhanced . more generally , one expects to be able to use light cone coordinates @xmath17 whenever there is such a large momentum in the problem as in any high energy scattering process . diverse applications are shown in the text by cheng and wu@xcite . examples of most relevance include high energy projectile nuclear scattering and high momentum transfer quasi - elastic reactions involving nuclear targets . light front techniques have previously been applied to systems of two hadrons . the two main approaches have been the relativistic quantum mechanics of directly interacting particles @xcite and relativistic field theory @xcite . we choose here to employ specific lagrangians which embody chiral and other symmetries , and thus use field theory . the light front quantization procedure necessary to treat nucleon interactions with scalar and vector mesons was derived by soper@xcite , and by yan and collaborators@xcite . here we combine the previous formalisms to obtain a light front treatment of a lagrangian which contains pions , vector and scalar mesons , and which respects the constraints of chiral symmetry . here is an outline . the bulk of the formalism is presented in sect . , a chiral lagrangian which includes pions , scalar mesons and neutral vector mesons is presented . the field equations are derived , and the quantization procedure for the free and interacting fields are quantized at the zero of light cone time @xmath18 . the energy momentum tensor , the light front hamiltonian @xmath19 and plus momentum operator @xmath20 are derived . the necessary contact interactions involving the exchange of instantaneous fermions and vector bosons are obtained . the principal purpose of the present work is to develop a technique that could have wide application in nuclear physics . thus we study and check the present formalism by applying it to three different examples- @xmath21 and @xmath22 scattering , and a mean field treatment of infinite nuclear matter- of relevance to nuclear physics . dealing successfully with each of these subjects is a prerequisite for making progress . 3 shows how light front field theory leads to a chiral treatment of low energy pion - nucleon scattering , which is consistent with the results of soft pion theorems . then nucleon - nucleon scattering is handled in a manifestly covariant manner , within the one - boson approximation , in sect . 4 . a discussion of the impact of chiral symmetry on the two - nucleon intermediate state contribution to the two pion exchange potential is also included . the mean field approximation is applied to infinite nuclear matter in sect 5 . glazek and shakin@xcite used a lagrangian containing nucleons and scalar mesons to study infinite nuclear matter . here vector mesons are included and the rotational - invariance arguments used in sect . 4 are used to derive the glazek - shakin @xmath6 variable . the energy of nuclear matter is computed and shown to be the same as found in the equal time formalism . the unique feature of the present formalism is the ability to obtain the nuclear and mesonic plus - momentum distributions from the energy momentum tensor . we find that that mesons can carry a significant fraction of the nuclear plus momentum , but have support only at 0 plus - momentum . some the results for nuclear matter have been presented in an earlier publication@xcite ; here the calculation is performed in two different ways and explained in more detail . sect . 6 summarizes the new results , presents a critique and discusses possible future applications . appendix a contains a summary of notation and some useful equations . we use a non - linear chiral model in which the nuclear constituents are nucleons @xmath23 ( or @xmath24 , pions @xmath25 scalar mesons @xmath26@xcite and vector mesons @xmath27 . the lagrangian @xmath28 is given by @xmath29 where the bare masses of the nucleon , scalar and vector mesons are given by @xmath30 @xmath31 , and @xmath32 . the unitary matrix @xmath33 can be chosen from amongst three forms @xmath34 : @xmath35 which correspond to different definitions of the fields . the pion - nucleon coupling here is chosen as that of linear representations of chiral symmetry used by gursey @xcite , with the the lagrangian approximately @xmath36 ) invariant under the chiral transformation @xmath37 one may transform the fermion fields , by taking @xmath38 as the nucleon field . one then gets lagrangians of the non - linear representation , as explained by weinberg @xcite . in this case the early soft pion theorems are manifest in the lagrangian , and the linear pion - fermion coupling is of the pseudovector type . however , the use of light front theory , requires that one find an easy way to solve the constraint equation that governs the fermion field . we shall show that the constraint can be handled in a simple fashion by using the linear representation . moreover , we shall see that the early soft pion theorems are indeed manifest from the form of the light front hamiltonian . the constant @xmath39 plays the role of the bare pion - nucleon coupling constant . if @xmath40 is chosen to be the pion decay constant , the goldberger - trieman relation yields the result that the axial vector coupling constant @xmath41 , which would be a problem for the lagrangian , unless loop effects can make up the needed 25% effect . corrections of that size are typical of order @xmath42 effects found in the cloudy bag model@xcite for many observables , including @xmath43 . there are no explicit @xmath44 in the above lagrangian . those will be handled in a future publication . for the moment we note that treating the higher order effects of the pion - nucleon inherent in this lagrangian is likely to lead to a resonance in the ( 3,3 ) channel of pion nucleon scattering . such effects can be included in the two - pion exchange contribution to nucleon - nucleon scattering . however , such an approach seems cumbersome . the choice of using an explicit @xmath45 instead of the iterated @xmath46 interaction is analogous to our use of a scalar meson even though the effects of @xmath47 interactions , which could lead to similar effects , are included in the lagrangian . we follow many authors ( see the review @xcite ) and include a scalar meson to simplify calculations . in this treatment , which follows that of refs.@xcite , the scalar meson @xmath26 is not a chiral partner of the pion- the chiral transformation is that of eq . ( [ chiral ] ) . the present lagrangian may be thought of as a low energy effective theory for nuclei under normal conditions . a more sophisticated lagrangian is reviewed in @xcite and used in @xcite ; the present one is used to show that light front techniques can be applied to hadronic theories relevant for nuclear physics . this hadronic model , when evaluated in mean field approximation , gives@xcite at least a qualitatively good description of many ( but not all ) nuclear properties and reactions . there are a variety of problems occuring when higher order terms are included@xcite . the aim here is to use a reasonably sophisticated lagrangian to study the effects that one might obtain by using a light front formulation . we could also have used the linear sigma model . the light front quantization for that model can be accomplished using a simple generalization of the work of refs . @xcite and @xcite , and is not shown here . according to the review @xcite the use of such a lagrangean precludes a successful description of nuclei at the mean - field level . the next step is to examine the field equations . the relevant dirac equation for the nucleons is @xmath48 the field equations for the mesons are @xmath49 @xmath50 @xmath51 = -m\bar\psi ' { \partial u\over \partial \pi_i}\psi ' , \label{pimeson}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 . the next step is obtain the light front hamiltonian ( @xmath19 ) as a sum of a free , non - interacting and a set of terms containing all of the interactions . this is accomplished by using the energy momentum tensor as @xmath53 the usual relations determine @xmath54 , with @xmath55 in which the degrees of freedom are labelled by @xmath56 . it is worthwhile to consider the limit in which the interactions between the fields are removed . this will allow us to define the free hamiltonian @xmath57 and to display the necessary commutation relations . the energy momentum tensors of the non - interacting fields are defined as as @xmath58 and @xmath59 the fermion fields are quantized in the next sub - section . then the use of eq.([tmunu ] ) leads to the result @xmath60,\ ] ] with @xmath61 the scalar field can be expressed in terms of creation and destruction operators : @xmath62,%\bbox{k}\cdot\bbox{x}}\right],\ ] ] where @xmath63 with @xmath64 , and @xmath65 . the @xmath66 function restricts @xmath6 to positive values . the commutation relations are @xmath67= \delta(\bbox{k}_\perp-\bbox{k}'_\perp ) \delta(k^+-k'^+)\label{comm}\ ] ] with @xmath68=0 $ ] . it is useful to define @xmath69 which will be used throughout this paper . the derivatives appearing in the quantity @xmath70 are evaluated and then one sets @xmath18 to 0 to obtain the result @xmath71 which has the interpretation of an operator the counts the light front energy @xmath64 of all of the particles . the pion field is treated in a similar manner , with the result @xmath72,\ ] ] and @xmath73 with commutation relations analogous to that of eq.([comm ] ) . the energy momentum tensor for the free vector meson field is obtained directly from the defining relation ( [ tmunu ] ) as @xmath74.\ ] ] it is desirable to obtain the symmetric energy momentum tensor . this is done by using @xmath75 , subtracting a total divergence and using the free field equations . the result is @xmath76.\ ] ] the component relevant for the light front hamiltonian can be shown to be @xmath77 the expression for the vector meson field operator is @xmath78,\label{vfield}\ ] ] where the polarization vectors are the usual ones : @xmath79 once again the four momenta are on - shell with @xmath80 the light front commutation relations : @xmath81=\delta_{\omega\omega ' } \delta^{(2,+)}(\bbox{k}-\bbox{k}'),\ ] ] with the others vanishing , lead to commutation relations amongst the field operators that are the same as in ref . the expression for @xmath82 can now be obtained from eqs.([t+- ] ) and ( [ vfield ] ) as @xmath83 this subject is complicated by the presence of massive vector meson fields . various difficulties were handled by soper@xcite and yan@xcite . the key features that we use are summarized here . in particular , the fields @xmath84 are chosen as the three independent fields , with the others expressible in terms of these . we shall need only one of these relationships in which the plus component of eq.([vmeson ] ) can be used to obtain @xmath85.\label{vpm}\ ] ] with @xmath86 and the inverse of @xmath87 is defined in refs . @xcite-@xcite . a more recent discussion is given by harindrinath and zhang@xcite , and the essentials are presented here in appendix a , we turn to the case of spin 1/2 fermions . although described by four - component spinors , these fields have only two independent degrees of freedom . the light front formalism allows a convenient separation of dependent and independent variables via the projection operators @xmath88@xcite , with @xmath89 . the independent fermion degree of freedom is chosen to be @xmath90 . the properties of the projection operators are discussed in appendix a. one gets two coupled equations for @xmath91 by multiplying eq.([dirac ] ) by @xmath92 and @xmath93 : @xmath94 the relation between @xmath95 and @xmath90 is very complicated unless one may set the plus component of the vector field to zero@xcite . this is a matter of a choice of gauge for qed and qcd , but the non - zero mass of the vector meson prevents such a choice here . instead , one simplifies the equation for @xmath95 by@xcite transforming the fermion field according to @xmath96 with @xmath97 this transformation leads to the result @xmath98 where @xmath99 note that all of the previously obtained fermionic sources of meson fields are unchanged by the transformation ( [ trans ] ) : @xmath100 the eigenmode expansion for @xmath101 is needed to compute the interaction between nucleons . ( [ vfield ] ) and ( [ vbar ] ) can be used to obtain @xmath102,\label{nvfield}\ ] ] where the polarization vectors @xmath103 are given by@xcite : @xmath104 with the properties @xmath105 the path towards the light front hamiltonian proceeds via the energy momentum tensor , which is given by @xmath106\psi'\nonumber\\ + \partial^\mu\phi\partial^\nu\phi + \partial^\mu\bbox{\pi}\cdot \partial^\nu \bbox{\pi } + \bbox{\pi}\cdot\partial^\nu\bbox{\pi } { \bbox{\pi}\cdot\partial^\mu\bbox{\pi}\over\pi^2}(1-{f^2\over \pi^2 } \mbox{sin}^2{\pi\over f}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the use of the fermion field equation allows one to obtain the light front hamiltonian density @xmath107 it is now worthwhile to discuss a subtle feature regarding chiral symmetry in light front formalisms . chiral invariance is defined as invariance under the transformation defined by eq.([chiral ] ) if the equal time formalism is used . now the independent fermion variable is @xmath108 and @xmath109 is a functional of this . thus chiral invariance is the invariance under the transformation @xmath110 which is not the same as eq.([chiral ] ) because eq.([newchiral ] ) produces a change in @xmath109 that is different than using @xmath111 @xcite . the @xmath70 ( or equivalently the light front hamiltonian ) of eq.([tpm1 ] ) is invariant under the transformation ( [ newchiral ] ) if the pion mass is neglected so the usual chiral properties are obtained in these light front dynamics . the expression ( [ tpm1 ] ) is useful for situations , such as in the mean field approximation case for infinite nuclear matter examined below , for which a simple expression for @xmath108 is known . this is not always the case , so it is worthwhile to use the dirac equation to express @xmath70 in an alternate form : @xmath112 it is convenient to consider @xmath109 as a sum of terms , one @xmath113 whose relation with @xmath108 is free of interactions@xcite , the other @xmath114 containing the interactions . that is , rewrite the second of eq . ( [ yan ] ) as @xcite @xmath115 furthermore , define @xmath116 , so that @xmath117 where @xmath118 . the purpose of the above decomposition is to separate the dependent and independent parts of @xmath23 and to allow one to expand @xmath119 in terms of eigenstates of momentum . one may make a similar treatment for the vector meson fields . the operator @xmath120 , determined by eq ( [ vpm ] ) , is relevant for the hamiltonian . part of this operator is determined by a constraint equation . to see this examine eq ( [ vpm ] ) , and make a definition : @xmath121 where @xmath122 next use equations ( [ fcon ] ) and ( [ vcon ] ) to rewrite the hamiltonian as a sum of a free and interacting terms . the sum of the last term of eq . ( [ tpm2 ] ) and the terms involving @xmath123 is the density of the interaction hamiltonian , @xmath124 , plus the free fermion term , @xmath125 . use equations ( [ fcon ] ) and ( [ vcon ] ) in the expression ( [ tpm2 ] ) for @xmath70 along with the field equations and integration by parts to find : @xmath126 and @xmath127 with @xmath128 @xmath129 and @xmath130 the term @xmath131 accounts the emission or absorption of a single vector or scalar meson , as well as the emission or absorption of any number of pions through the operator @xmath132 . the term @xmath133 includes contact terms in which there is propagation of an instantaneous fermion . the term @xmath134 accounts for the propagation of an instantaneous vector meson . we may now quantize the fermion fields using @xmath135 , \label{dq}\ ] ] where again the momenta are on shell : @xmath136 , and the anti - commutation relations are given by @xmath137 the properties of the dirac spinors are described in appendix a. the term @xmath125 of eq . ( [ freef ] ) can now be expressed as @xmath138 the component that is related to the plus momentum is @xmath139 . the necessary expression is given by @xmath140 we begin by showing that , if one starts with a non - linear representation of chiral symmetry , the requirement of solving the constraint equation for the @xmath141 component of the fermion field leads one to a lagrangian of the gursey - type linear representation . the focus is on chiral properties and pion - nucleon scattering , so we dispense with the vector and non - chiral @xmath26 meson fields for this section , and it is sufficient to examine only the following fermion - pion term of a non - linear representation@xcite : @xmath142n.\ ] ] next obtain the fermion field equation and make the usual decomposition : @xmath143 with @xmath144n_-\label{nn } \nonumber\\ \left(i\partial^+-o^+\right)n_-= [ \bbox{\alpha}_\perp\cdot\bbox{(p}_\perp-\bbox{o}_\perp)+\beta m]n_+,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the operator @xmath145 has been defined as @xmath146 we wish to remove the @xmath147 term from the left hand side of the equation for @xmath148 . this can be done by defining a unitary operator @xmath149 and fermion field @xmath150 such that @xmath151 with @xmath152 the identity@xcite @xmath153 where @xmath154 is given in eq . ( [ us ] ) , helps a good deal . its use in eq . ( [ feq ] ) , combined with the condition @xmath155 , leads to the result @xmath156 so that using eqs . ( [ ff ] ) and ( [ defchi ] ) in ( [ nn ] ) yields @xmath157\chi_- \nonumber\\ i\partial^+\chi_-=\left [ \bbox{\alpha}_\perp\cdot\bbox { p}_\perp+\beta mu_2\right]\chi_+.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is of the desired form in which no interactions appear on the left - hand - side of the equation for @xmath158 . thus the use of light front quantization mandates that the pion - nucleon interactions be of the form of eq . ( [ lag ] ) . the first test for any chiral formalism is to reproduce the early soft pion theorems@xcite . here we concentrate on low energy pion nucleon scattering because of its relation to the nucleon - nucleon force . we work to second order in @xmath159 in this first application . in this case , each of the @xmath34 takes the same form : @xmath160 this expression is to be used in the potentials @xmath131 and @xmath133 of eqs . ( [ v1 ] ) and ( [ v2 ] ) . the second order scattering graphs are of three types and are shown as time @xmath18 ordered perturbation theory diagrams in fig . 1 . the kinematics are such that @xmath161 , with @xmath162 and @xmath163 . the iteration of @xmath131 to second order yields the direct and crossed graphs of fig . 1a . in this formalism @xmath131 is proportional to the matrix element of @xmath164 between @xmath165 spinors , so it is proportional to the momentum of the absorbed or emitted pion . thus the terms of fig . 1a vanish near threshold . the terms of fig . 1b are generated by the @xmath166 terms of @xmath131 . using the various field expansions in the expression ( [ v1 ] ) for @xmath131 leads to the result that plus - momentum is conserved and the plus momentum of every particle is greater than zero . this means that the first of fig.1b vanishes identically and the second vanishes for values of the initial pion plus momentum that are less than twice the nucleon mass . the net result is that only the instantaneous term of @xmath133 and the @xmath167 term of @xmath131 ( shown in fig . 1c ) remain to be evaluated . proceeding more formally , we evaluate the s - matrix given by @xmath168 where @xmath169 is the @xmath18 ( light - front time ) ordering operator and @xmath170 is the interaction representation light front hamiltonian . then @xmath171 with @xmath172 the evaluation proceeds by using the field expansions in the expressions for @xmath131 and @xmath133 . integrating over @xmath173 and evaluating the result between the relevant initial and final pion - nucleon states leads to the result that each contribution to the s - matrix is proportional to a common factor , @xmath174 which combines with the result of the required integration over the light cone time ( @xmath18 ) to provide the necessary momentum conservation and flux factors . the remaining factor of each term is its contribution to the invariant amplitude @xmath175 . the result is @xmath176 where the three terms here correspond to the three terms of fig . the role of cancellations in the reduction of the term proportional to @xmath177 is already apparent . to understand the threshold physics take @xmath178 and @xmath179 . then one finds @xmath180 to leading order in @xmath181 . the weak nature of the @xmath177 term and the presence of the second weinberg - tomazowa term is the hallmark of chiral symmetry@xcite . the same results could be obtained using the linear sigma model , with @xmath182 exchange playing the role of the @xmath167 term of eq.([um1 ] ) . the ultimate aim is to derive the nuclear wave function including correlation effects . the first step is to understand nucleon - nucleon scattering using our light front formalism . we start with the one boson exchange approximation , discuss the light front wave equation and show that this procedure gives the same scattering amplitude as the usual procedure of computing the one - boson exchange contributions to the invariant amplitudes and using the blankenbeckler - sugar reduction of the bethe - salpeter equation@xcite . this usual procedure is covariant , so that our construction shows that the light front wave procedure respects rotational invariance . this invariance is the result of strikman and frankfurt@xcite and others . the present treatment explicitly includes the effects of nucleon spin and the nucleon - nucleon interaction can derived from an underlying chiral lagrangian . the starting point is the s matrix of eqs . ( [ smat1 ] ) and ( [ smat2 ] ) . here the initial state @xmath183 consists of nucleons with quantum numbers labeled by 1 and 2 , and the state @xmath40 consists of nucleons 3 and 4 . to be definite , we take the plus momentum of nucleon 1 to be greater than that of nucleon 3 , and the momentum transfer @xmath184 to be @xmath185 so that @xmath186 . the lowest order contributions to the invariant amplitude are represented by the light - front - time ordered graphs shown in fig . the graphs of fig . 2a represent terms of the form @xmath187 , and that of fig . 2b accounts for the instantaneous massive vector boson exchange term of @xmath134 . these terms may be evaluated by using the field expansions and doing the relevant integrals over the @xmath188 coordinate space . each term has a common factor of @xmath189 where the factor @xmath190 in the numerator is compensated by dividing the invariant amplitude by @xmath190 . it is simplest to consider the effects of scalar @xmath26 and pseudoscalar @xmath191 exchanges at the same time . the scattering amplitudes @xmath192 take the form @xmath193 where the notation is that @xmath194 is the spinor for a nucleon of quantum numbers @xmath183 , and @xmath195 is either of the form @xmath196 or @xmath197 . the momentum of the exchanged meson is @xmath198 , and it is necessary to realize that @xmath199 but @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the mass of the exchanged scalar meson or pion . the factor @xmath202 arises from the denominators of the field expansions and @xmath203 is the result of evaluating the light front energy denominator @xmath204 . define the energy denominator of eq.([gen ] ) to be @xmath205 so that @xmath206 using eqs . ( [ off ] ) and ( [ off1 ] ) immediately yields @xmath207 so the amplitude @xmath208 takes the form @xmath209 this is the usual @xcite expression for a one - boson exchange potential , if no form factor effects are included . note that the klein - gordon propagator is obtained using only a single time - ordered graph . the calculation with the equal - time formulation requires the summation of two time - ordered graphs . the derivation of the contribution of vector meson exchange proceeds by adding the terms of fig 2a and 2b . the term of fig . 2a can immediately seen to be @xmath210.\ ] ] the factor in brackets arises from the polarization sum , recall eq . ( [ ebar ] ) . it is worthwhile to define the contribution of the second two terms in the bracket , which result from the difference between @xmath101 and @xmath27 fields , as @xmath211 , with @xmath212 next use the relations @xmath213 and the equality of the @xmath214 and @xmath215 components of @xmath198 with those of @xmath184 to obtain the results @xmath216 but @xmath217 , which leads to a compact rewriting of eq . ( [ bar ] ) as @xmath218 the term of fig . 2b is obtained by using the field expansion in the equation for @xmath134 , ( [ v3 ] ) , integrating over coordinate space and removing the common factor . the result is @xmath219 which exactly cancels the term @xmath211 . the net result is that the amplitude for vector meson exchange , @xmath220 , takes the familiar form : @xmath221 the sum of the amplitudes arising from each of the individual one boson exchange terms : @xmath222 gives the invariant amplitude to second order in each of the coupling constants . these amplitudes are strong , so computing the nucleon - nucleon scattering amplitude and phase shifts requires including higher order terms . one may include a sum which gives unitarity by including all iterations of the scattering operator @xmath223 through intermediate two - nucleon states : @xmath224 where @xmath225 is the negative - momentum in the initial state and @xmath226 projects on to two - nucleon intermediate states . more explicitly , eq . ( [ iter ] ) is given by @xmath227 after removing the common factor and accounting for the momentum conserving delta functions . one realizes that this is of the form of the weinberg equation@xcite by expressing the plus - momentum variable in terms of a light - front momentum fraction @xmath228 such that @xmath229 and using the relative and total momentum variables : @xmath230 then @xmath231 where @xmath232 is square of the total initial four - momentum , otherwise known as the invariant energy @xmath233 and @xmath234 is the corresponding quantity for the intermediate state . because the kernal @xmath223 is itself an invariant amplitude the procedure of solving this equation to determine observables is manifestly covariant . equation ( [ 419 ] ) can in turn can be re - expressed as the blankenbecler - sugar ( bbs ) equation @xcite by using the variable transformation@xcite : @xmath235 with @xmath236 . the result is : @xmath237 which is the desired equation . the three - dimensional propagator is exactly that of the bbs equation ; there is one difference . our one boson exchange potentials depend on the square of the four momentum @xmath238 transferred when a meson is absorbed or emitted by a nucleon . thus the energy difference between the initial and final on - shell nucleons is included and @xmath239 . the derivation of the bbs equation from the bethe - salpeter equation specifies that @xmath240 is used in the meson propagator . including @xmath241 instead of @xmath240 increases the range of the potential . such an effect can be hidden in phenomenological potentials by changing the pion - nucleon coupling constant or form factor . one can easily convert eq . ( [ bsbs ] ) into the lippman - schwinger equation of non - relativistic scattering theory by removing the factor @xmath242 with a simple transformation@xcite . the present results are that one can use the light front technique to derive nucleon - nucleon potentials in the one - boson exchange obe approximation and use these in an appropriate wave equation . therefore our procedure is directly comparable to the one used in constructing the realistic bonn one - boson exchange potentials used in momentum space . those potentials also have a close connection with an underlying lagrangian . our purpose here is to argue that the present procedure can yield potentials essentially identical to the bonn obep potentials and therefore would lead to a good description of the nn data . the bonn one - boson exchange potentials employ six different mesons @xmath243 and the ( isovector scalar ) @xmath244 meson . the present techniques can be used to handle all of these mesons and their couplings , with the possible exception of the tensor @xmath245 part of the @xmath246-nucleon interaction . the presence of such a tensor interaction makes it difficult ( or impossible ) to write the equation for @xmath109 as @xmath247 this is relevant because the standard value of the ratio of the tensor to vector @xmath246-nucleon coupling @xmath248 is 6.1 , based upon ref . @xcite and subsequent papers . reproducing the observed values of @xmath249 and p - wave wave phase shifts requires a large value @xmath248 ; see ref . however the lagrangian compensates for its lack of a @xmath246-n interaction with tensor coupling by generating such a term via vertex correction diagrams ( which are the origin of the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron in qed ) . such diagrams probably do not generate the phenomenologically required values of the coupling constants , but all that is needed here is that terms of the correct form be produced . this is because the standard procedure is to choose the values of the coupling constants so as to yield a good description of the nn scattering data . indeed the potentials a , b , and c are defined by the parameters which account for the mesonic masses , coupling constants and form factors . thus we end up with the same procedure that is used in the bonn one boson exchange potentials . this brings us to the treatment of divergent terms in our procedure . the definition of any effective lagrangian requires the specification of such a procedure . for the present , it is sufficient to say that we introduce form factors , @xmath250 which reduce the strength of the @xmath228 meson - nucleon coupling for large values of @xmath251 . this is also the procedure of ref @xcite . the net result is that the one - boson exchange treatment of the nucleon - nucleon potential and the t - matrix resulting from its use in the bbs equation is essentially the same as the one - boson exchange procedure of ref . thus our light front treatment is guaranteed to be consistent with nucleon - nucleon nucleon scattering data measured in the standard energy range . such a similarity has also been obtained using relativistic hamiltonian dynamics@xcite . the dominant contribution to the two pion exchange potential arises from contributions to intermediate states that include one or two @xmath45s@xcite , and a treatment of such effects based on chiral symmetry has been provided by van kolck and collaborators@xcite . including the effects of @xmath45 s is beyond the scope of the present work , but we are able to discuss the two pion exchange contribution ( of order @xmath252 ) to the nucleon nucleon potential . the property that a sum of light cone time - ordered diagrams is equal a single feynman graph can be used to simplify the calculation . the relevant feynman graphs are displayed in fig . 3 ; the terms originating from the linear @xmath253 coupling ( a , b ) , from the quadratic @xmath254 coupling ( c ) and from a combination of the linear and quadratic interactions ( d ) are indicated . the line through the two - nucleon intermediate state of fig . 3a is meant to indicate that the contribution arising from iterating the one pion exchange interaction is removed . this has been a standard procedure since the work of ref . @xcite , and will not be discussed further . the sum of the terms of fig . 3a and 3b is equal to the partovi - lomon two pion exchange potential , as they used the pseudoscalar pion - nucleon interaction . this interaction certainly simplifies the calculation ; in particular the diagrams of fig . 3a , b and d are convergent ( whereas they would be strongly divergent if pseudovector coupling were to be used . one can use such a pseudoscalar coupling , and include the effects of chiral symmetry , provided one also includes the effects of the @xmath254 coupling shown in fig . 3c , and the combined effects of the linear and quadratic interactions , fig . the quadratic interaction term cancels the large pair terms in pion - nucleon scattering and should also play a significant role here in reducing the size of the computed potential . thus we expect that the partovi - lomon potential contains too large an attraction . next turn to the procedure used in constructing the full bonn potential . this potential is constructed by ignoring all of the z - graphs and including the the effects of the two - nucleon intermediate states which arise from the crossed graph , fig . 3b , as well as the parts of fig . 3a arising from time ordered terms in which two pions exist at the same time . ( for such contributions to the tpep the linear pseudoscalar and pseudovector interactions are are evaluated between on shell positive energy nucleon spinors , and are therefore equivalent . the resulting contribution to the tpep is small , but is comparable to that of the iterated opep . the neglect of the z graphs goes a long way towards including the effects of chiral symmetry . however , terms involving the weinberg - tomazowa interaction at one or two vertices are ignored . the computation of the graphs of fig . 3 would include such effects implicitly as well as that of pair suppression . thus a detailed comparison would be useful . however , the small nature of the effects that we discuss now indicate that the dominance of the tpep by effects of intermediate @xmath45 s will remain unchallenged . the nucleon - nucleon interaction of the previous section can be used as the basis for a light front brueckner theory of nuclei . we study the mean field approximation for infinite nuclear matter as a first step . the nuclear mean field model- the shell model- occupies pre - eminence in understanding nuclear structure . we need to see if our formalism can describe this physics . in the mean field approximation@xcite , the coupling constants are considered strong and the fermion density large . then the meson fields can be approximated as classical- the sources of the meson fields are replaced by their expectation values . in this case , the nucleon mode functions will be plane waves and the nuclear matter ground state can be assumed to be a normal fermi gas , of fermi momentum @xmath255 , and of large volume @xmath256 in its rest frame . we consider the case that there is an equal number of protons and neutrons . first we examine the mesonic field equations ( [ vmeson])-([pimeson ] ) . the baryon source of the pion field is a pseudoscalar operator , so its expectation value vanishes in the ground state . thus this mean field approximation leads to the result that @xmath257 . the other meson fields are constants , independent of space and time , given by @xmath258 where the brackets denote expectation values of the nuclear ground state in its rest frame and the baryon density is @xmath259 this result that @xmath27 is a constant , along with eqs . ( [ vbar ] ) and ( [ mfa ] ) , can be used to determine @xmath101 . in particular , @xmath260 by construction . furthermore , the conditions that @xmath261 and @xmath262 tell us that @xmath263 . finally @xmath264 , so that @xmath265 , so the net result is that the only non - vanishing component of @xmath101 is @xmath266 . with this mean field approximation , the fermionic field equations ( [ yan ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath267 now @xmath26 and @xmath268 are constants so we expect the mode functions for the field expansion of @xmath23 to be of the plane wave form @xmath269 and can be obtained from eq . ( [ nyan ] ) as@xcite @xmath270 the light front eigenenergy @xmath271 is the sum of a kinetic energy term in which the mass is shifted by the presence of the scalar field , and an energy arising from the vector field . comparing this equation with the one for free nucleons , @xmath272 , shows that the nucleons have a mass @xmath273 and move in plane wave states . the nucleon field operator is constructed using the solutions of eq . ( [ sol ] ) as the plane wave basis states . this means that the nuclear matter ground state , defined by operators that create and destroy baryons in eigenstates of eq . ( [ sol ] ) , is the correct wave function and that equations ( [ mfa ] ) and ( [ sol ] ) represent the solution of the approximate field equations , and the diagonalization of the hamiltonian . one question remains . we are going to fill up a fermi sea , but @xmath255 is the magnitude of a three vector . how is this three vector defined ? this was answered in the paper of glazek and shakin @xcite who showed that rotational invariance is manifest if one uses the definition : @xmath274 which implicitly defines @xmath275 . using eq . ( [ kplus ] ) allows one to maintain the equivalence between energies computed in the light front and equal time formulations of scalar field theories@xcite . a similar equation has been used to restore manifest rotational invariance in light - front qed@xcite . we shall show that this same expression also restores rotational invariance in this mean field problem when vector mesons are included . equation ( [ kplus ] ) has the correct form in the limit of non - interacting nucleons and therefore seems natural@xcite . we attempt a heuristic derivation of this equation using the requirement that manifest rotational invariance be restored . the starting point is the observation that eq . ( [ alpha ] ) , with its definition of @xmath228 as the plus momentum fraction carried by a nucleon , restores manifest rotational invariance in the two - nucleon system . let s consider the mean field approximation as involving an interaction between a nucleon and a very heavy particle containing a-1 nucleons ( with @xmath276 ) . then the variable @xmath277 , which is the fraction of the nuclear plus - momentum carried by a nucleon , is given by @xmath278 and is a suitable generalization of the variable @xmath228 . the nucleon mass is taken to be @xmath273 , because it is this mass that appears in the nucleon field equations . the mass of the @xmath279 body system is dominated by the mass of the ( a-1 ) nucleons mass ( the binding energy per particle is 16 mev @xmath280 compared with 940 mev ) , so that we may write @xmath281 in which the last line results from the limit @xmath282 . the key feature is that the variable @xmath277 is defined as a momentum fraction , so that @xmath283 comparing eq . ( [ approx ] ) and eq . ( [ begin ] ) leads to eq . ( [ kplus ] ) . the computation of the energy and plus momentum distribution proceeds from taking the appropriate expectation values of the energy momentum tensor @xmath284 discussed in sect . 2 and @xmath285 we are concerned with the light front energy @xmath19 and momentum @xmath20 . the relevant components of @xmath284 are presented in eqs . ( [ tpm1 ] ) and ( [ tpp ] ) . within the mean field approximation(mfa ) , the derivatives of the meson fields are zero so that one finds @xmath286 taking the nuclear matter expectation value of @xmath70 and @xmath139 and performing the spatial integral of eq . ( [ pmu ] ) leads to the result @xmath287 the subscript f denotes that @xmath288 with @xmath275 defined by the relation ( [ kplus ] ) . equations ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) along with the expression for @xmath6 , ( [ kplus ] ) allow an evaluation of @xmath19 and @xmath20 . this shall be done in two different ways . in the first method we evaluate the energy of the a - nucleon system @xmath289@xcite , which turns out to be the same as in the usual equal - time treatment@xcite . this can be seen by summing equations ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) to obtain @xmath290 then replace the integration over @xmath6 by one over @xmath275 , using eq . ( [ kplus ] ) so that @xmath291 where @xmath292 then eq . ( [ ei ] ) takes the form : @xmath293 which is the expression familiar from the walecka model , this confluence of energies is a nice check on the present result because a manifestly covariant solution of the present problem , with the usual energy , has been obtained@xcite . we consider the system to be at a fixed large volume , @xmath256 , so that @xmath294 depends on @xmath26 and @xmath255 . the ground state energy is determined by minimizing @xmath294 with respect to those two parameters . setting @xmath295@xcite to zero reproduces the field equation for @xmath26 ( [ smf ] ) as is also the case in the equal - time formalism . the next step is to minimize the energy per particle @xmath296 at fixed volume with respect to @xmath255 . ( one may also minimize the energy with respect to the volume@xcite . ) start this calculation by using @xmath297 to obtain : @xmath298 using eq . ( [ e ] ) followed by eqs . ( [ smf ] ) and ( [ mfa ] ) leads to the result @xmath299 where @xmath300 . this is a transcendental equation which determines @xmath255 , so that the calculation of @xmath301 is complete . it is useful to note that the relation @xmath302 ( which must hold for a system in its rest frame ) also emerges as a result of this minimization . to see this rewrite the left hand side of eq . ( [ mid ] ) as @xmath303 using this in eq . ( [ mid ] ) leads to @xmath304 which is just the relation that one obtains by setting @xmath302 with the versions of eqs . ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) obtained by replacing the variable @xmath6 by @xmath275 . another way to obtain the energy of the ground state is to minimize the value of @xmath305 subject to the constraint that @xmath306 , or to minimize the quantity @xmath307 with @xmath308 where @xmath309 is a lagrange multiplier . setting @xmath310 leads to @xcite @xmath311 but the field equation ( [ smf ] ) for @xmath26 can be restated as @xmath312 combining eqs.([mini ] ) and ( [ rew ] ) leads to the result that @xmath313 so that the minimization of @xmath314 with respect to @xmath255 is the same as minimizing @xmath294 with respect to @xmath255 . this ends the discussion of how the expressions for @xmath315 are used to determine the energy of the system . solving the field equations and minimizing the energy density determines the properties of nuclear matter , once the meson - nucleon coupling constants and masses are chosen . one can now discuss the properties of the resulting system . of course the necessary calculations have been done long ago . in particular , the parameters @xmath316 and @xmath317 have been chosen @xcite so as to give the binding energy per particle of nuclear matter as 15.75 mev with @xmath255=1.42 fm@xmath318 . in this case , solving the equation for @xmath26 gives @xmath319 . the light front formalism embodies the use of @xmath6 as a canonical variable which allows us to study the nucleonic and mesonic contributions to the nuclear plus momentum . the study of the plus momentum content is motivated by the desire to obtain a better understanding of lepton - nucleus deep inelastic scattering . the emc effect@xcite that the structure function of a bound nucleon differs from that of a free one , showed a principal effect that the plus momentum carried by the valence quarks is less for a bound nucleon than for a free one . many different interesting interpretations and related experiments@xcite were stimulated by these experiments . but a correct interpretation requires that the role of conventional effects , such as nuclear binding , be assessed and understood . our formalism employs plus component of the momentum so that it s use in assessing the nucleon s ( and therefore the valence quark s ) plus - momentum is necessary . we therefore examine the @xmath320 component of the energy momentum tensor eq . ( [ pplus ] ) to determine how much momentum is carried by nucleons and how much by mesons . rewrite eq . ( [ pplus ] ) as a sum of mesonic @xmath321 and nucleonic @xmath322 terms @xmath323 with @xmath324 and @xmath325 the parameters of eqs . ( [ cv ] ) and ( [ cc ] ) leads to @xmath326 and the use of eq . ( [ cv ] ) in eq . ( [ pm ] ) gives : @xmath327 while performing the integral involved in eq . ( [ nuc ] ) leads to @xmath328 the result is that 65% of the nuclear plus momentum must be carried by the nucleons and the remainder of 35% is carried by the mesons . how do these numbers relate to experiments ? to answer we need to recall that the nuclear structure function @xmath329 can be obtained from the light front distribution function @xmath330 ( which gives the probability for a nucleon to have a plus momentum fraction @xmath331 ) and the nucleon structure function @xmath332 using the relation@xcite : @xmath333 where @xmath331 is the @xmath334 times the fraction of the nuclear plus - momentum carried by the nucleon , and @xmath335 is the bjorken variable computed using the nuclear mass divided by @xmath334 ( @xmath336 ) : @xmath337 . this formula is the expression of the convolution model in which one means to assess , via @xmath330 , only the influence of nuclear binding . other effects such as the nuclear modification of the nucleon structure function ( if @xmath332 is obtained from deep inelastic scattering on the free nucleon ) and any influence of the final state interaction between the debris of the struck nucleon and the residual nucleus@xcite are neglected . our formalism enables us to calculate the function @xmath330 from the integrand of eq.([pplus ] ) . since the integral gives the total plus - momentum carried by nucleons , the integrand which multiplies the factor @xmath6 can be interpreted as the necessary probability distribution . thus : @xmath338 @xmath339 the function @xmath330 can be obtained by replacing @xmath6 by the dimensionless variable @xmath331 using @xmath340 with @xmath341 mev . then using eq.([fdef ] ) leads to the result @xmath342 , \label{fy}\ ] ] where @xmath343 and @xmath344 . knowing the following integrals is useful : @xmath345 with the 0.65 representing the earlier 65% result . we may now assess the implications of the statement that nucleons carry only 65% of the nuclear plus - momentum . this number is to be compared with the value obtained by frankfurt and strikman@xcite . they used data for @xmath329 and @xmath332 along with eq . ( [ deep ] ) to determine the average value of @xmath331 required by experiments with the result that @xmath346 this means that nucleons carrying 95% of the nuclear plus momentum ( a 5% depletion effect ) is sufficient to explain the 10 - 15% depletion effect observed for the fe nucleus . our 35% depletion seems to be rather large , but one must remember that it results from nuclear matter . a result that compares more closely with experiment could be obtained in a version of the present model for which the value of @xmath273 is closer to @xmath347 . however , determining specific features of the present model is not the goal of the present work . instead we wish to demonstrate that the light front formalism can be used to obtain a nuclear wave function expressed in terms of the plus - momentum variable which is closely related to experiment . indeed we can verify that the ability to obtain the nucleonic plus momentum , feature that requires the use of a light front front formalism , instead of an equal time formalism . to do this compare the 0.65 fraction with the result of a relativistic calculation using the equal time ( et ) formalism@xcite . in this calculation , which uses eq . ( [ lag ] ) ) and for which the scalar and vector fields are the same as here , the plus momentum of a nucleon was chosen as the sum of the dirac eigenenergy and @xmath275 : @xmath348 using this leads to an average nucleon plus momentum fraction @xmath349 , which when evaluated with our parameters for @xmath350 and @xmath268 , leads to @xmath351 ! the big difference between our result and the earlier equal time result -compare eqs . ( [ kplus ] ) and ( [ ident])- arises from our use of the plus momentum as a canonical momentum variable and the consequent use of @xmath54 to construct the light front momentum and energy density . in particular , the first line of eq.([ident ] ) is only a reasonable guess . we note also that the baryon number distribution @xmath352 ( number of baryons per @xmath331 , normalized to unity ) can be determined from the expectation value of @xmath353 . the result is @xmath354 -{1\over 2y^2}({k_f^4\over \bar { m}^4}-({e_f\over \bar{m}}-y)^4 ) \right].\label{fby}\ ] ] some phenomenological models treat the two distributions @xmath330 and @xmath352 as identical . the distributions have the same normalization , but they are different as shown by eqs . ( [ fy ] ) and ( [ fby ] ) . consider that the average value of @xmath331 equal to 0.65 represents a very strong binding effect on lepton - nucleus deep inelastic scattering . one might think that the mesons , which cause this binding , would also have huge effects on deep inelastic scattering . it is therefore certainly necessary to determine the momentum distributions of the mesons . the mesons contribute 0.35 of the total nuclear plus momentum , but we need to know how this is distributed over different individual values . the paramount feature is that @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the same constants for any and all values of the spatial coordinates @xmath355 ( and also @xmath18 ) . this means that the related momentum distribution can only be proportional to a delta function setting both the plus and @xmath215 components of the momentum to zero . this result is attributed to the mean field approximation for infinite nuclear matter , in which the meson fields are treated as classical quantitates . thus the finite plus momentum can be thought of as coming from an infinite number of quanta , each carrying an infinitesimal amount of plus momentum . a plus momentum of 0 can only be accessed experimentally at @xmath356 , which requires an infinite amount of energy . thus , in the mean field approximation , the scalar and vector mesons can not contribute to deep inelastic scattering . the usual term for a field that is constant over space is a zero mode , and the present lagrangian provides a simple example . for finite nuclei , in the mean field approximation , the mesons would carry a very small momentum of scale given by the inverse of the nuclear radius , under the mean field approximation . if fluctuations were to be included , the relevant momentum scale would be of the order of the inverse of the average distance between nucleons ( about 2 fm ) . we can understand the significance of the presence of components of a wave function that carry plus momentum but do not participate deep inelastic processes by reviewing a bit of history . the nuclear binding effect is that the plus momentum of a bound nucleon is reduced by the binding energy , and so is that of its confined quarks . conservation of momentum implies that if nucleons lose momentum , other constituents such as nuclear pions@xcite , must gain momentum . this partitioning of the total plus momentum amongst the various constituents is called the momentum sum rule . pions are quark anti - quark pairs so that a specific enhancement of the nuclear antiquark momentum distribution , mandated by momentum conservation , is a testable @xcite consequence of this idea . a nuclear drell yan experiment @xcite , in which a quark from a beam proton annihilates with a nuclear antiquark to form a @xmath357 pair , was performed . no influence of nuclear pion enhancement was seen , leading bertsch et al.@xcite to question the idea that the pion is a dominant carrier of the nuclear force . in the present situation , we have a huge depletion effect of 35% , but with no consequence for either the nuclear deep inelastic scattering or drell - yan experiments . we hasten to add that the lagrangian of eq . ( [ lag ] ) and its evaluation in mean field approximation for nuclear matter have been used to provide a simple but semi - realistic example . it would be premature to compare the present results with data before obtaining light front dynamics for a model in which the correlational corrections to the mean field approximation are included , and which treats finite nuclei . thus the specific numerical results of the present work are far less relevant than the central feature that the mesons responsible for nuclear binding need not be accessible in deep inelastic scattering . however , the present model may be regarded as being one of a class of models in which the mean field plays an important role@xcite . for such models nuclei would have constituents that contribute to the momentum sum rule but do not contribute to deep inelastic scattering . in particular , a model can have a large binding effect , nucleons can carry a significantly less fraction of @xmath20 than unity , and it is not necessary to include the influence of mesons that could be ruled out in a drell - yan experiment . the present paper shows how the light front quantization of a chiral lagrangian can be accomplished . the resulting formalism can be applied to many problems of interest to nuclear physics . in particular , pion - nucleon , nucleon - nucleon scattering , and infinite nuclear matter ( in the mean field approximation ) are presented here . soft pion theorems for pion - nucleon scattering are reproduced . the treatment of nucleon - nucleon scattering is shown to be manifestly covariant in the one boson exchange approximation . the implications of chiral symmetry for the two - nucleon intermediate state contribution to the two pion exchange potential are discussed . the present results mainly constitute a feasibility study , in that the emphasis here is on checking the formalism by reproducing known results . but this light front treatment does allow the effects of chiral symmetry to be incorporated within a relativistic formalism , and therefore should have a broad applicability in the future . one remaining technical problem is to provide a light front quantization of a lagrangian for spin 3/2 particles . the special feature of the light front formalism is its use of the plus momentum as one of the canonical variables . this enables a close contact with the experimental variables used to analyse deep inelastic scattering and any experiment in which there is one large momentum . this feature is exploited here in the derivation ( within the mean field approximation ) of the nucleonic and mesonic distribution functions for infinite nuclear matter . the mesons are shown to carry a significant fraction of the nuclear plus momentum , but only a zero plus - momentum ( a zero mode ) , and therefore do not participate in nuclear deep inelastic scattering or drell - yan experiments . the ultimate validity of the above ( perhaps startling ) statement depends on whether or not the dominance of mesonic zero modes survives calculations performed for finite nuclei and calculations which include the effects of nucleon - nucleon correlations . there seems to be no technical barrier precluding such calculations . this work is partially supported by the usdoe . i thank the slac theory group and the national int for their hospitality . i thank p. blunden , s.j . brodsky , l. frankfurt , s. glazek , r. machleidt , r.j . perry , c.m . shakin , m. strikman and u. van kolck for useful discussions . this is patterned after the review of harindrinath@xcite the light - front variables are defined by @xmath358 so the four - vector @xmath359 is denoted @xmath360 with this notation the scalar product is denoted by @xmath361 the metric tensor @xmath362 with @xmath363 is obtained from the usual one by using ( [ def ] ) ( i.e. @xmath364 ) . then @xmath365 , with the other elements vanishing . the term @xmath366 is obtained from the condition that @xmath367 . its elements are the same as those of @xmath368 except for @xmath369 . thus @xmath370 and the partial derivatives are similarly given by @xmath371 the step function is defined as @xmath372 for @xmath373 , and @xmath374 for @xmath375 . the antisymmetric step function is given by @xmath376 with @xmath377 in this notation , @xmath378 . the above few definitions allow us to express the inverse operators appearing in the text in terms of integrals : @xmath379 @xmath380 the hermitian projection operators @xmath383 are given by @xmath384 and obey the following relations @xmath385 @xmath386 @xmath387 @xmath388 and @xmath389 the dirac spinors are given by @xmath390 \ ; \chi_{\lambda } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath391 the anti - particle spinors are given by @xmath392 where @xmath393 is the charge conjugation operator , so that @xmath394 \ ; \eta_{\lambda } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath395 other useful relations are @xmath396 @xmath397 and @xmath398 note that in the above three equations @xmath399 is an on - shell four vector with @xmath400 and @xmath401 . 99 p. a. m. dirac , rev . * 21 * , 392 ( 1949 ) . s. j. brodsky , g. mccartor , h. c. pauli , s. s. pinsky part . world * 3 * , 109 ( 1993 ) ; s. j. brodsky , h - c pauli , s.s . pinsky , slac - pub-7474 , hep - ph/9705477 m. burkardt adv . * 23 * , 1 ( 1993 ) . j. m. namyslowski(1985 ) : progress in particle and nuclear physics , vol . * 14 * , faessler a. ( ed . ) ( pergamon press ) ; s. j. brodsky and g. p. lepage in _ perturbative quantum chromodynamics _ , a. mueller ( ed . ) . ( world scientific , singapore 1989 ) ; x. d. ji comments nucl . * 21 * , 123 ( 1992 ) w .- m . zhang , chinese j. phys . * 32 * , 717 ( 1994 ) . theory of hadrons and light - front qcd " edited by s.d . glazek , world scientific , ( singapore ) 1994 . a. harindranath , an introduction to light front dynamics for pedestrians , hep - ph/9612244 our notation is that a four vector @xmath402 is defined by the plus , minus and perpendicular components as @xmath403 and @xmath404 . see the appendix for more on this . h. cheng and t. wu expanding protons : scattering at high energies " , mit press cambridge ( 1987 ) f. coester , helv . phys . acta . * 38 * , 7 ( 1965 ) ; and in constraint s theory and relativistic dynamics , edited by g. longhi and l.lusanna ( world scientific singapore , 1987 ) , p. 159 and in the three body force in the three - nucleon system " edited by b.l.berman and bf gibson ( springer new york , 1986 ) b.d . keister and w. n.polyzou relativistic hamiltonian dynamics in nuclear and particle physics in _ advances in nuclear physics_. j.w . negele and e. vogt ( ed . ) . * 20*,1 ( 1991 ) ( plenum press , new york ) m. g. fuda and y.zhang , phys.rev . * c51 * , 23 ( 1995 ) ; phys . * c54 * , 495 ( 1996 ) . l. l. frankfurt and m. i.strikman phys . 76 * , 215 ( 1981 ) . frankfurt and m.i . strikman , phys . rep . * 160 * , 235 ( 1988 ) . soper , `` field theories in the infinite momentum frame '' , slac pub-137 ( 1971 ) ; d.e . soper , phys . rev d4 , 1620 ( 1971 ) ; j.b . kogut and d.e . soper , phys . rev . * d1 * , 2901 ( 1971 ) . s - j chang , r.g . root , and t - m yan , phys . rev . * d7 * , 1133 , 1147 ( 1973 ) . t - m yan phys . rev . * d7 * , 1760 , 1780 ( 1974 ) . miller , a light front treatment of the nucleus- implications for deep inelastic scattering " , to be published phys . rev . c. rapid communications , nucl - th/9702036 the use of scalar mesons is meant as a simple representation of part of the two pion exchange potential which causes much of the the medium range attraction between nucleons , as well as the effects of a possible fundamental scalar meson . f. gursey , nuovo cimento * 16 * 230 ( 196 ) ; ann . phys . ( n.y.)*12 * 91 ( 1961 ) ; p. chang and f. gursey , phys . rev . * 164 * , 1752 ( 1967 ) . s. weinberg , phys . rev . * 166 * , 1568 ( 1968 ) . s. thberge , a. w. thomas and g. a. miller , phys . d22 * ( 1980 ) 2838 ; * d23 * ( 1981 ) 2106(e ) . a. w. thomas , s. thberge , and g. a. miller , phys . rev . * d24 * , 216 ( 1981 ) ; a. w. thomas , adv . * 13 * ( 1984 ) 1 ; g. a. miller , p 190 in int . * 2 * ( 1984 ) . b.d . serot and j.d . walecka , adv . . phys . * 16*,1 ( 1986 ) . furnstahl , b.d . serot , h - b tang , nucl - th/9608035 . nucl.phys . * a615 * , 441 ( 1997 ) . serot and j.d . walecka , iu - ntc-96 - 17 , jan . 1997 nucl - th/9701058 the determination of the inverse of the operator @xmath405 is discussed in the original literature @xcite and in other places . the equations in appendix a are sufficient for our calculations . for a more recent discussion see a. harindrinath and w - m zhang , phys . rev . * d48 * , 4861 , 4881 , 4903 ( 1993 ) . the most general non - linear realization does not specify the ratio of the two pion - nucleon couplings . b.h . brandsden and r.g . moorhouse , `` the pion - nucleon system '' ( princeton university press , princeton , 1973 ) ; s.l . adler and r.f . dashen , `` current algebras '' , ( w.a . benjamin , new york , 1968 ) . r. machleidt , k. holinde , ch . elster , phys . rep . * 149 * , 1 ( 1987 ) ; r. machleidt , adv . * 19 * , 189 ( 1989 ) . r. brockmann and r. machleidt , `` the dirac - brueckner approach '' , prepared for `` open problems in nuclear matter '' , m. baldo , ed ( world scientific , singapore , to be published ) , chapt . nucl - th/9612004 . nucleon - nucleon interaction , g.e . brown and a.d . jackson north - holland ( amsterdam ) 1976 ; `` pions and nuclei '' , t. ericson and w. weise oxford science publications , ( new york ) 1987 . s. weinberg phys . rev . * 150 * , 1313 ( 1966 ) r. blankenbecler and r. sugar , phys.rev . * 142 * , 1051 ( 1966 ) . terentev , sov . * 24 * , 106 ( 1976 ) . m - h partovi , and e.l . lomon , phys . rev . * d2 * , 1999 ( 1970 ) . g. hoehler and h. pietarinen , nucl . phys . * b95 * , 210 ( 1975 ) ; g.e . brown and r. machleidt , phys . rev . * c50 * , 1731 ( 1994 ) . c. ordonez , l. ray , and u. van kolck , phys . rev . * c53 * , 2086 ( 1996 ) ; phys . rev . lett . * 72 * , 1982 ( 1994 ) ; c. ordonez , and u. van kolck phys.lett . * b291*,459 ( 1992 ) . the symbol for the nucleon field operator and the mode functions of that field is taken to be the same -@xmath23 to reduce the amount of notation . bartnik and st . glazek , phys . * d39 * , 1249 ( 1989 ) . m. brisudov and r. perry , phys . rev . * d54 * , 6453 ( 1996 ) . minimal substitution would require that the plus component of the vector field would enter into the equation ( [ kplus ] ) for @xmath6 , but we are using a formalism for which that component vanishes . serot , and r.j . furnstahl , phys . rev . * c43 * , 105 ( 1991 ) . minimizing @xmath301 with respect to @xmath26 ( for fixed @xmath255 ) is the same as minimizing @xmath294 with respect to @xmath26 ( for fixed @xmath255 ) because the volume @xmath256 is held fixed . s. a. chin , and j.d . walecka , phys . lett . * b52 * , 24 ( 1974 ) j. aubert _ et al . , b123 * , 275 ( 1982 ) . et al.,_phys . * 52 * 727 ( 1984 ) . a. bodek , _ et al.,_phys . * 51 , * 534 ( 1983 ) . see e.g. the reviews : r.l . jaffe , in relativistic dynamics and quark - nuclear physics . ed . by m. b. johnson and a. picklesimer ; m. arneodo , phys . 240 , 301 ( 1994 ) . geesaman , k. saito , a.w . thomas , ann . nucl . part . sci . * 45 * , 337 ( 1995 ) . ( [ deep ] ) is essentially eq . ( 5.2 ) of frankfurt and strikman , @xcite , with a correspondence between our @xmath406 and their @xmath407 . k. saito , and a.w . thomas , nucl . phys . * a574 * , 659 ( 1994 ) . birse , phys . lett . * b299 * , 186 ( 1930 ) . the standard nuclear shell model is one model of finite nuclei in which the mean field is dominant . the quark meson coupling model , see e.g. p.a.m . guichon , k. saito , e. rodionov , and a.w . thomas , nucl . * a601 * , 349 ( 1996 ) ; and p.g . blunden and g.a . miller , phys.rev . * c54 * , 359 ( 1996 ) is another . bjorkenand s.d . relativistic quantum fields _ ( mcgraw - hill , new york ) ( 1965 ) . fig . 1 @xmath18-ordered graphs for low energy pion - nucleon scattering . ( a ) second - order effects of the @xmath408 term @xmath131 . ( b ) second - order effects of the @xmath166 and @xmath409 terms of @xmath131 . ( c ) effects of the instantaneous fermion propagation terms of @xmath133 , and of the @xmath167 term of @xmath131 . the terms @xmath410 are defined in eqs , ( 2.46)-(2.48 ) . @xmath18-ordered graphs for one boson exchange contributions to nucleon - nucleon scattering . the numbers 1 - 4 represent the momentum , spin and charge states of the nucleons . here ( a ) meson propagation terms ( b ) instantaneous vector meson exchange of @xmath134 , eq . ( 2.48 ) fig . 3 feynman graphs for the two - pion exchange potential ( a ) uncrossed box diagram- the horizontal line represents the subtraction of the contribution arising from the iterated one pion exchange potential . ( b ) crossed box diagram ( c ) second order effect of the @xmath167 term of @xmath131 , eq . ( 2.46 ) ( d ) terms with one @xmath167 term . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: _ monadic second - order logic _ ( @xmath6 ) is one of the most expressive logics for which the theories of many interesting classes of structures are still decidable . in particular , the infinite binary tree and many linear orders have a decidable @xmath6-theory @xcite and the same holds for many classes of ( finite or infinite ) structures with bounded _ tree - width _ @xcite . furthermore , for every fixed @xmath6-sentence @xmath7 and every class @xmath8 of finite structures with bounded tree - width , there is a linear - time algorithm that checks whether a given structure from @xmath8 satisfies @xmath7 @xcite . examples of monadic second - order expressible graph properties are @xmath9-colourability , various types of connectivity , and planarity ( via kuratowski s well - known characterisation by forbidden configurations ) . a variant of monadic second - order logic called _ guarded second - order logic _ ( @xmath10 ) allows quantification not only over sets of elements but also over sets of edges ( i.e. , tuples from the relations ) @xcite . the above mentioned linear - time algorithms can be adapted to this logic . there are tight links between guarded second - order logic and tree - width.08em : every class of ( finite or infinite ) relational structures with a decidable @xmath10-theory has bounded tree - width . this gives a sort of converse to the above mentioned decidability results @xcite . the proof of this result uses a deep theorem of graph minor theory by robertson and seymour.08em : a set of graphs has bounded tree - width if and only if it excludes some planar graph as a minor @xcite . to compare the @xmath6-theories or @xmath10-theories of two classes of structures we can use _ monadic second - order transductions , _ a certain kind of interpretations suitable both , for monadic second - order logic and , using a detour via incidence structures , also for guarded second - order logic @xcite . in the present article we classify classes of finite structures according to their ` combinatorial complexity ' . ( note that we do not consider decidability issues . ) we will consider two ways to measure the complexity of such classes . on the one hand , we can use their tree - width and its variants . on the other hand , we can compare them via transductions . as it turns out , these two approaches are equivalent and they give rise to the same hierarchy . this indicates the robustness of our definitions and their intrinsic interest . other possible hierarchies , based on different logics , will be briefly mentioned in section [ sect : conclusion ] . let us give more details . an @xmath6-transduction is a transformation of relational structures specified by monadic second - order formulae . as graphs can be represented by relational structures , we can use @xmath6-transductions as transformations between graphs . an @xmath6-transduction is a generalisation of the following kind of operations ( see definition [ def : transduction]).08em : \(i ) the definition of a relational structure `` inside '' another one ( in model theory this is called an _ interpretation_).08em ; \(ii ) the replacement of a structure @xmath11 by the union of a fixed number of disjoint copies of @xmath11 , augmented with appropriate relations between the copies.08em ; \(iii ) the expansion of a given structure @xmath11 by a fixed number of unary predicates , called _ parameters . _ usually , these predicates are arbitrary subsets of the domain , but we also may have a formula imposing restrictions on them . because of the possibility to use parameters , a transduction @xmath1 is a many - valued map in general . ( we may also think of it as non - deterministic . ) each relational structure @xmath11 has several images @xmath12 depending on the choice of the parameters @xmath13 . if @xmath14 we can consider the tuple @xmath15 as an _ encoding _ of @xmath16 in @xmath11 . the transduction @xmath1 is the corresponding _ decoding function . _ each transduction @xmath1 extends in a canonical way to a transformation between classes of structures . if @xmath8 and @xmath17 are classes of relational structures with @xmath18 , we can think of @xmath1 as a way of encoding the structures in @xmath8 by elements of @xmath17 . for instance , every finite graph can be encoded in a sufficiently large finite square grid ( by a fixed transduction @xmath1 ) . every finite tree of height at most @xmath4 ( for fixed @xmath4 ) can be encoded in a sufficiently long finite path . but it is not the case that all finite trees can be encoded by paths ( by a single transduction ) . the purpose of this article is to classify classes of finite relational structures according to their _ encoding powers . _ we will compare classes @xmath8 and @xmath17 of structures by the following preorder.08em : @xmath19 we attack the problem of determining the structure of this preorder . since , at the moment , a complete description of this hierarchy seems to be out of reach , we concentrate on a variant where we replace monadic second - order logic by _ guarded second - order logic . _ in this case , the corresponding hierarchy can be described completely . to obtain a corresponding notion of transduction we can not simply change the definition of an @xmath6-transduction to use @xmath10-formulae since the resulting notion of transduction would not yield a reduction between @xmath10-theories , and it even would not be closed under composition . instead , we will take a detour by combining ordinary @xmath6-transductions with a well - known translation between @xmath10 and @xmath6 . this translation is based on _ incidence structures . _ let us first describe this notion for undirected graphs where it is very natural . there are two canonical ways to encode a graph @xmath20 by a relational structure . we can use its _ adjacency representation _ which is a structure @xmath21 where the domain @xmath22 consists of all vertices of @xmath20 and @xmath23 is a binary relation containing all pairs of adjacent vertices . but we also can use the _ incidence representation _ of @xmath20 . this is the structure @xmath24 where the domain @xmath25 contains both , the vertices and the edges of @xmath20 , and @xmath26 is the incidence relation between vertices and edges . in a similar way , we can associate with every relational structure @xmath11 its incidence structure @xmath27 ( see definition [ def : incidence structure ] ) where the domain also contains elements for all tuples in some relation of @xmath11 . it is shown in @xcite that every @xmath10-formula @xmath7 talking about some structure @xmath11 can be translated into an @xmath6-formula talking about the incidence structure @xmath27 , and vice versa . hence , we can use incidence structures to obtain an analogue @xmath28 of the preorder @xmath29 suitable for guarded second - order logic . we set @xmath30 where @xmath31 . the main result of the present article is a complete characterisation of the resulting hierarchy for classes of finite structures . we show that the preorder @xmath28 is linear of order type @xmath32 . it turns out that every class of finite structures is equivalent to one of the following classes , listed in increasing order of generality.08em : * trees of height at most @xmath4 , for each @xmath33.08em ; * paths.08em ; * arbitrary trees ( equivalently , binary trees).08em ; * ( square ) grids . each of these levels can be characterised in terms of tree decompositions . hence , we also obtain a corresponding hierarchy of complexity measures on structures that are compatible with @xmath6-transductions transforming incidence structures . the upper levels of the hierarchy can be determined easily using techniques from graph minor theory developed by robertson and seymour , such as the notions of a minor and a tree decomposition . in particular , we employ two results characterising bounded tree - width and bounded path - width in terms of excluded minors @xcite . for the lower levels , which consist of classes of bounded path - width , the characterisation is more complicated and requires new results relating tree decompositions and monadic second - order logic . in sections [ sect : preliminaries ] and [ sect : mso ] we give basic definitions . section [ sect : tree decompositions ] collects some known results from graph minor theory . we also introduce a new variant of tree - width and prove some of its basic properties . in section [ sect : tree decompositions and transductions ] we expound the connections between tree - width and monadic second - order transductions . in section [ sect : hierarchy ] we introduce the transduction hierarchy and we state our main theorem . its proof is contained in sections [ sect : hierarchy2 ] and [ sect : hierarchy3 ] . in the first one , we prove that the hierarchy is strict while , in the second one , we show that it covers every class . the final section [ sect : conclusion ] contains some extension of our results to other logics and some open problems in this direction . let us fix our notation . we set @xmath34 : = \{0,\dots , n-1\}$ ] and we write @xmath35 for the power set of a set @xmath36 . we denote tuples @xmath37 with a bar . the components of @xmath37 will be @xmath38 where the length @xmath4 will usually be implicit . we sometimes identify a tuple @xmath37 with the set of its components . for instance , we write @xmath39 to express that @xmath40 , for some @xmath41 . in this article all graphs , trees , and relational structures are finite . we will not repeat this finiteness assumption . a relational structure @xmath11 is of the form @xmath42 with domain @xmath43 and relations @xmath44 . the _ signature _ of such a structure is the set @xmath45 of relation symbols . in some proofs we will also use signatures with constant symbols denoting elements of the domain . we write @xmath46 for the arity of a relation @xmath47 . for a signature @xmath48 , we denote by @xmath49 $ ] the class of all @xmath48-structures . we write @xmath50 for the _ disjoint union _ of the structures @xmath11 and @xmath16 . we mainly consider _ incidence structures . _ these are representations of structures @xmath11 where we have added new elements to the domain , one for each tuple in the relations of @xmath11 . [ def : incidence structure ] let @xmath51 be a structure and let @xmath52 be the maximal arity of a relation @xmath53 . the _ incidence structure _ of @xmath11 is the structure @xmath54 where we extend the domain @xmath43 by @xmath55 and the relations are @xmath56 the class of all incidence structures is @xmath57 : = \set { \fraka_{\mathrm{in } } } { \fraka \in { \mathbb{str}}[\sigma ] } $ ] . note that incidence structures are binary ( i.e. , their relations have arity at most @xmath58 ) . hence , they can be regarded as bipartite labelled directed graphs . one important property of incidence structures is the fact that they are _ sparse , _ i.e. , their relations contain few tuples . let @xmath59 . a structure @xmath60 is _ _ @xmath9-sparse__-sparse hypergraphs _ and _ uniformly @xmath9-sparse hypergraphs . _ what we call @xmath9-sparse is a slight modification of the uniform version of @xcite . ] if , for every subset @xmath61 and all relations @xmath53 , we have @xmath62 every incidence structure is @xmath63-sparse . let us fix our notation regarding trees and graphs . a _ directed graph _ is a pair @xmath64 where @xmath22 is the set of _ vertices _ and @xmath65 is the _ edge relation . thus , graphs are by definition simple ( without parallel edges ) . an _ undirected graph _ is a graph where the edge relation @xmath66 is symmetric . when speaking of a _ graph _ we will always mean an undirected one . we regard a _ coloured graph _ as a relational structure @xmath67 with binary relations @xmath68 and unary relations @xmath69 that encode the colours of , respectively , the edges and the vertices . we allow graphs whose edges and vertices have several colours . trees play a major role in this article . intuitively , a tree is a directed graph @xmath70 with a unique vertex @xmath52 of indegree @xmath71 , called the _ root _ of @xmath70 , such that every vertex is reachable from @xmath52 by a unique directed path . the actual definition we will use is slightly more concrete . it is based on the usual encoding of the vertices of a tree by finite sequences describing the path from the root to the given vertex . in fact , we introduce two notions of a tree.08em : _ order - trees _ and _ successor - trees . _ the latter use the usual edge relation , while the former are equipped with the tree - order instead . let @xmath72 be a set . \(a ) for an ordinal @xmath73 , we denote by @xmath74 the set of all sequences of elements of @xmath72 of length less than @xmath73 . the _ prefix relation _ on @xmath75 is defined by @xmath76 the infimum of @xmath77 and @xmath78 with respect to @xmath79 , i.e. , their longest common prefix , is denoted by @xmath80 . \(b ) a finite prefix closed subset @xmath81 is called a _ tree domain . _ following our intuition that a vertex is represented by the path leading to it , we call the empty sequence @xmath82 the _ root _ of @xmath83 and the maximal elements of @xmath83 its _ leaves . _ the domain of the _ complete @xmath84-ary tree of height @xmath4 _ is @xmath85 . hence , @xmath86 is the empty tree , @xmath87 the one consisting only of the root , and @xmath88 consists of a root and @xmath84 leaves . given a tree domain @xmath83 we can define the _ successor relation _ @xmath66 on @xmath83 by setting @xmath89 in this case we call @xmath78 a _ successor _ of @xmath77 and @xmath77 the _ predecessor _ of @xmath78 . a structure of the form @xmath90 ( and every structure isomorphic to it ) is called a _ successor - tree . _ sometimes it is convenient to replace the successor relation @xmath66 by the tree order @xmath79 . structures of the form @xmath91 are called _ order - trees . _ a _ coloured tree _ is the expansion of a ( order- or successor- ) tree by unary predicates @xmath92 . ( we do not require these predicates to be pairwise disjoint . hence , every vertex may have none , one , or several colours . ) we write @xmath93 for the class of all order - trees @xmath94 with @xmath84 colours . the set of _ leaves _ of a tree @xmath70 is denoted by @xmath95 . \(c ) let @xmath96 be an order - tree . the _ level _ of an element @xmath97 is the number of vertices @xmath98 with @xmath99 . we denote it by @xmath100 . the _ height _ of @xmath70 is the least ordinal @xmath73 greater than the level of every element of @xmath83 . hence , the empty tree has height @xmath71 and the tree with a single vertex has height @xmath63 . the _ out - degree _ of @xmath70 is the maximal number of successors of a vertex of @xmath70 . for successor - trees we define these notions analogously . \(d ) let @xmath70 be a tree and @xmath101 a vertex of @xmath70 . the _ subtree _ of @xmath70 _ rooted _ at @xmath101 is the subtree @xmath102 consisting of all vertices @xmath103 with @xmath104 , i.e. , all vertices below @xmath101 . sometimes it is possible to reduce statements about relational structures to statements about graphs . one way to do so consists in replacing a structure by its _ gaifman graph . _ the _ gaifman graph _ of a structure @xmath60 is the undirected graph @xmath105 with the same domain @xmath43 and with the edge relation @xmath106 monadic second - order logic ( @xmath6 ) is the extension of first - order logic by set variables and quantifiers over such variables . an important variant of @xmath6 is guarded second - order logic ( @xmath10 ) where one can quantify not only over sets of elements but also over sets of tuples from the relations ( see @xcite for details ) . hence , guarded second - order logic over a given structure @xmath11 is equivalent to monadic second - order logic over its incidence structure @xmath27 . + for every @xmath10-sentence @xmath7 , we can effectively construct an @xmath6-sentence @xmath107 such that @xmath108 for every @xmath6-sentence @xmath7 , we can effectively construct a @xmath10-sentence @xmath107 such that @xmath109 throughout the article we will consistently work with incidence structures , thereby avoiding the treatment of guarded second - order logic . in particular , all formulae are tacitly assumed to be @xmath6-formulae . besides @xmath6 and @xmath10 we also consider their _ counting extensions _ @xmath110 and @xmath111 . these add predicates of the form @xmath112 to , respectively , @xmath6 and @xmath10 , where @xmath36 is a set variable and @xmath113 are numbers . all of our results for @xmath10 go through also for @xmath111 , i.e. , for @xmath110-transductions between incidence structures . in section [ sect : conclusion ] we will give a partial characterisation of the hierarchy for @xmath110-transductions of graphs ( not of incidence graphs ) . in this case the availability of counting predicates does make a difference . to state the composition theorem below it is of advantage to work with a variant of @xmath6 without first - order variables . this variant has atomic formulae of the form @xmath114 and @xmath115 , for set variables @xmath116 , where a formula of the form @xmath115 states that there are elements @xmath117 such that the tuple @xmath37 is in @xmath47 . note that every general monadic second - order formula with first - order variables can be brought into this restricted form by replacing all first - order variables by set variables and adding the condition that these sets are singletons . whenever we speak of @xmath6 we will have this version in mind . in particular , the following definition of the rank of a formula is based on this variant . when writing down concrete formulae , on the other hand , we will allow the use of first - order variables to improve readability . we regard every such formula as an abbreviation of a formula of the restricted form . similarly , when we use structures with constants we actually regard each constant as a singleton set . \(a ) the _ rank _ @xmath118 of a formula @xmath7 is the nesting depth of quantifiers in @xmath7 . formulae of rank @xmath71 are called _ quantifier - free . _ \(b ) the _ monadic theory of rank @xmath84 _ of a structure @xmath11 is @xmath119 for a tuple @xmath37 of elements of @xmath11 , we also consider the monadic theory @xmath120 of the expansion @xmath121 . we use the term ` rank ' instead of the more natural ` quantifier rank ' since in section [ sect : conclusion ] below we will consider @xmath110 where the notion of rank has to be adapted for our results to go through . in order to compare the monadic theories of two classes of structures we employ @xmath6-transductions . to simplify the definition we introduce three simple operations and we obtain @xmath6-transductions as compositions of these . [ def : transduction ] ( a ) let @xmath122 be a natural number . the operation @xmath123 maps a structure @xmath11 to the expansion @xmath124 of the disjoint union of @xmath9 copies of @xmath11 by the following relations . denoting the copy of an element @xmath125 in the @xmath41-th component of @xmath126 by the pair @xmath127 , we define @xmath128 for @xmath129 , we set @xmath130 . \(b ) for @xmath131 , we define the operation @xmath132 that maps a structure @xmath11 to all possible expansions by @xmath84 unary predicates @xmath133 . note that this operation is many - valued and that @xmath134 is just the identity . basic @xmath6-transduction _ is a partial operation @xmath1 on relational structures described by a list @xmath135 of @xmath6-formulae called the _ definition scheme _ of @xmath1 . given a structure @xmath11 that satisfies the formula @xmath136 the operation @xmath1 produces the structure @xmath137 where @xmath138 if @xmath139 then @xmath140 remains undefined . \(d ) a _ @xmath9-copying @xmath6-transduction _ @xmath1 is a ( many - valued ) operation on relational structures of the form @xmath141 where @xmath142 is a basic @xmath6-transduction . when the value of @xmath9 does not matter , we will simply speak of a _ transduction . _ note that , due to @xmath132 , a structure can be mapped to several structures by a transduction . consequently , we consider @xmath140 as the _ set _ of possible values @xmath143 where @xmath92 ranges over all @xmath84-tuples of subsets of @xmath43 . for a class @xmath8 , we set @xmath144 \(a ) the expansion by @xmath84 unary predicates corresponds , in the terminology of @xcite , to using @xmath84 _ parameters . _ we will use this terminology , for instance , in the proof of theorem [ thm : interpretable implies tree decomposable ] . \(b ) note that every basic @xmath6-transduction is a @xmath63-copying @xmath6-transduction without parameters . [ exam : gf interpretable ] ( a ) let @xmath48 be a signature and let @xmath52 be the maximal arity of a relation in @xmath48 . the operation mapping an incidence structure @xmath145 $ ] to the structure @xmath146 is a @xmath9-copying @xmath6-transduction where @xmath147 , for @xmath148 , and @xmath129 , for @xmath149 . \(b ) for every fixed number @xmath33 , we describe a transduction @xmath1 transforming a path @xmath150 of length @xmath151 into the class of all trees of height @xmath4 with @xmath152 vertices . we can encode a tree @xmath83 of height @xmath4 with @xmath84 vertices as a finite word @xmath153 of length @xmath84 over the alphabet @xmath34 $ ] as follows . let @xmath154 be the enumeration of the vertices of @xmath83 in lexicographic order , and let @xmath155 be the level of @xmath156 . we encode @xmath83 by the word @xmath157 . a transduction can recover @xmath83 from @xmath153 as follows . each position in @xmath153 corresponds to a vertex . the predecessor of the @xmath41-th vertex @xmath101 is the maximal vertex to the left of @xmath101 whose label is less than @xmath155 . clearly , this predecessor relation is definable in monadic second - order logic . the two most important properties of @xmath6-transductions are summarised in the following lemmas . [ lem : transductions are comorphisms ] let @xmath1 be a transduction . for every @xmath6-sentence @xmath7 , there exists an @xmath6-sentence @xmath158 such that , for all structures @xmath11 , @xmath159 furthermore , if @xmath1 is quantifier - free , then the rank of @xmath158 is no larger than that of @xmath7 . [ cor : transductions operate on theories ] for every quantifier - free transduction @xmath1 and every @xmath131 , there exists a function @xmath160 on monadic theories of rank @xmath84 such that @xmath161 for all transductions @xmath162 there exists a transduction @xmath163 such that @xmath164 . as a further example note that we can use transductions to translate between order - trees and successor - trees . there exists a transduction @xmath1 mapping an order - tree to the corresponding successor - tree . there exists a transduction @xmath165 mapping a successor - tree to the corresponding order - tree . similarly there are transductions translating between a structure and its incidence structure . for every signature @xmath48 , there exists a transduction @xmath1 such that @xmath166 , for all @xmath167 $ ] . the converse statement is a much deeper result and requires the structure in question to be @xmath9-sparse for some fixed @xmath9 . for every signature @xmath48 and all numbers @xmath59 , there exists an @xmath6-transduction @xmath1 such that @xmath168 , for all @xmath9-sparse structures @xmath167 $ ] . we have seen in lemma [ lem : transductions are comorphisms ] that transductions relate the monadic theories of two structures . we also need techniques to relate the monadic theory of a structure to those of its substructures . the disjoint union operation can frequently be used for this purpose ( for a proof of the following theorem see , e.g. , theorem 7.11 of @xcite , or @xcite ) . [ thm : composition for unions ] let @xmath48 and @xmath169 be relational signatures with constants . for every @xmath131 , there exists a ( computable ) binary operation @xmath170 on monadic theories of rank @xmath84 such that @xmath171 for all @xmath48-structures @xmath11 and @xmath169-structures @xmath16 . below we will mainly make use of the following corollary . [ lem : composition for trees ] let @xmath70 be an order - tree and @xmath97 a vertex . suppose that @xmath172 is the order - tree obtained from @xmath70 by replacing the subtree @xmath102 by some tree @xmath173 . let @xmath174 be a tuple of vertices of @xmath70 with @xmath175 , for all @xmath41 . if @xmath37 are vertices of @xmath102 and @xmath176 are vertices of @xmath173 such that @xmath177 then it follows that @xmath178 let @xmath179 be the tree obtained from @xmath70 by replacing the subtree @xmath102 by a single vertex @xmath153 . we define the following auxiliary predicates.08em : @xmath180 we construct a quantifier - free transduction @xmath1 such that @xmath181 if @xmath160 is the function from corollary [ cor : transductions operate on theories ] and @xmath170 the operation from theorem [ thm : composition for unions ] , it follows that @xmath182 as desired . hence , it remains to define @xmath1 . let @xmath183 be the signature of @xmath184 , and @xmath185 the signature of @xmath186 and @xmath187 . for @xmath1 we can use the basic @xmath6-transduction consisting of the following formulae.08em : @xmath188 -- some properties of the transduction hierarchy , which we will introduce in section [ sect : hierarchy ] below , can be deduced from results about graph minors . \(a ) let @xmath189 be an undirected graph and @xmath190 a set of edges . we denote by @xmath191 the reflexive and transitive closure of @xmath192 . note that @xmath191 is an equivalence relation . the graph @xmath193 is obtained by contracting all edges in @xmath192 . formally , we have @xmath194 where @xmath195 is the set of equivalence classes and @xmath196 contains an edge between classes @xmath197 $ ] and @xmath198 $ ] if and only if @xmath197 \neq [ y]$ ] and there are representatives @xmath199 $ ] and @xmath200 $ ] with @xmath201 . \(b ) a _ minor _ of a graph @xmath20 is a graph that can be obtained from @xmath20 by first deleting some vertices and edges and then contracting some of the remaining edges . for a class @xmath8 of graphs , we denote by @xmath202 the class of all minors of graphs in @xmath8 . one central tool in graph minor theory is the notion of a tree decomposition and the related complexity measures called tree - width and path - width . these notions extend in a natural way to relational structures . let @xmath60 be a structure . \(a ) a _ tree decomposition _ of @xmath11 is a family @xmath203 of ( possibly empty ) subsets @xmath204 indexed by a rooted tree @xmath83 such that * for every element @xmath125 , the set @xmath205 is nonempty and connected in @xmath83.08em ; * for every tuple @xmath206 , there is some index @xmath97 with @xmath207 . we call the sets @xmath208 the _ components _ of the decomposition , and @xmath83 is its _ underlying tree . _ the _ height _ of a tree decomposition @xmath203 is the height of @xmath83 , while its _ width _ is the number @xmath209 \(b ) the _ tree - width _ @xmath210 of @xmath11 is the minimal width of a tree decomposition of @xmath11 . \(c ) the _ path - width _ @xmath211 of @xmath11 is the minimal width of a tree decomposition of @xmath11 where the underlying tree is a path . \(d ) the _ @xmath4-depth tree - width _ @xmath212 of @xmath11 is the minimal width of a tree decomposition of @xmath11 whose underlying tree has height at most @xmath4 . \(e ) for a class @xmath8 of structures , we define @xmath213 as the supremum of @xmath210 , for @xmath214 , and similarly for @xmath215 and @xmath216 . \(a ) the @xmath4-depth tree - width of a graph @xmath20 is related to its _ tree - depth _ @xmath217 as introduced by neetil and ossona de mendez @xcite . the tree - depth of a graph @xmath20 is the least number @xmath4 such that some orientation of @xmath20 is a subgraph of some order - tree of height @xmath4 . for a graph @xmath20 , it follows that * @xmath218 implies @xmath219.08em ; * @xmath220 implies @xmath221 . these facts are easy to establish . we will not need them in the following . \(b ) there are some simple relations between @xmath4-depth tree - width , path - width , and tree - width . for every graph @xmath20 , we have @xmath222 ( let us sketch the proof of the last inequality.08em : let @xmath223 be a tree decomposition of @xmath20 of height @xmath4 and width @xmath224 . as the components of a path decomposition of @xmath20 we take all sets of the form @xmath225 , where @xmath226 is a path from the root @xmath227 to some leaf @xmath228 of @xmath83 . ) the next lemma shows that most questions regarding tree decompositions of a structure can be reduced to the corresponding questions about its gaifman graph . for many of the following results it is therefore sufficient to consider graphs . let @xmath11 be a structure . a family @xmath223 is a tree decomposition of @xmath11 if and only if it is a tree decomposition of @xmath229 . @xmath230 is immediate . @xmath231 follows from the fact that every tree decomposition of a clique has one component @xmath208 containing the whole clique . this implies that , for every clique @xmath232 in @xmath229 induced by some tuple @xmath206 , there is some vertex @xmath97 with @xmath233 . hence , every tuple @xmath206 is contained in some component @xmath208 . in order to separate the higher classes of the hierarchy , we shall employ two deep results of robertson and seymour about excluded minors . [ thm : excluded tree theorem ] for each tree @xmath70 , there exists a number @xmath59 such that @xmath234 [ thm : excluded grid theorem ] for each planar graph @xmath235 , there exists a number @xmath59 such that @xmath236 a class of graphs has bounded path - width if and only if it excludes some tree as a minor . a class of graphs has bounded tree - width if and only if it excludes some planar graph as a minor . we also need a variant of these theorems for @xmath4-depth tree - width . the next lemma contains the main technical argument . suppose that @xmath20 is a graph that does not contain a path of length @xmath151 . then @xmath20 has a tree decomposition of height at most @xmath151 and width at most @xmath237 . let @xmath238 be a depth - first spanning order - tree of @xmath20 , i.e. , a spanning tree such that , for every edge @xmath239 of @xmath20 we have @xmath240 or @xmath104 ( for details see , e.g. , @xcite where such spanning trees are called _ normal _ ) . we define a tree decomposition @xmath223 of @xmath20 by setting @xmath241 since @xmath83 is depth - first , it follows that every edge @xmath239 of @xmath20 is contained in some component @xmath242 where @xmath153 is the maximum of @xmath103 and @xmath101 . the height of the tree @xmath83 can be at most @xmath151 since @xmath20 contains no path of length @xmath151 . furthermore , we have @xmath243 . hence , the width of the tree decomposition is at most @xmath237 . [ thm : excluded path theorem ] for each path @xmath150 , there exist numbers @xmath244 such that @xmath245 suppose that @xmath246 and let @xmath151 be the length of @xmath150 . then the preceding lemma implies that @xmath247 . a class of graphs has bounded @xmath4-depth tree - width , for some @xmath4 , if and only if it excludes some path as a minor ( equivalently , as a subgraph ) . a class of graphs has bounded tree - depth if and only if it excludes some path as a minor ( equivalently , as a subgraph ) . we can also compute a bound on the @xmath4-depth tree - width in terms of the @xmath248-depth tree - width . it will be needed in the proof of theorem [ thm : covering for lower part ] below . we say that the tree @xmath249 can be _ embedded _ into a tree @xmath91 if there exists an order - preserving injective mapping @xmath250 , i.e. , if @xmath251 , regarded as relational structure , is isomorphic to an induced substructure of @xmath238 . for instance , we have an embedding as indicated by the labels . if @xmath252 can be embedded in @xmath83 then @xmath252 is isomorphic to a minor of @xmath83 , when we consider @xmath252 and @xmath83 as graphs . let @xmath203 be a tree decomposition and let @xmath253 be a set of edges of ( the successor - tree corresponding to ) @xmath83 . the tree decomposition @xmath254 obtained by _ contracting _ the edges in @xmath253 is @xmath255})_{[v ] \in t / f}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath256 } : = \bigcup_{u \in [ v ] } u_u$ ] . [ lem : bound on twd - n ] let @xmath20 be a graph and let @xmath257 be a tree decomposition of @xmath20 of width @xmath9 and height at most @xmath258 . if @xmath131 is some number such that the tree @xmath259 can not be embedded into @xmath83 , then @xmath260 . we construct a tree decomposition @xmath261 of height at most @xmath4 and width at most @xmath262 as follows . let @xmath263 be the minimal ( w.r.t . @xmath264 ) set of vertices that contains * every leaf of @xmath83 at level @xmath4 and * every vertex that has at least @xmath84 successors in @xmath265 . since @xmath259 can not be embedded into @xmath83 it follows that @xmath265 does not contain the root of @xmath83 . let @xmath253 be the set of all edges of @xmath83 linking a vertex in @xmath266 to a vertex in @xmath265 . by definition of @xmath265 it follows that ( i ) every vertex of @xmath83 has less than @xmath84 @xmath253-successors.08em ; ( ii ) every path of @xmath83 from the root to some leaf on level @xmath4 contains at least one edge from @xmath253.08em ; and ( iii ) no such path contains two consecutive edges from @xmath253 . the decomposition @xmath267 obtained by contracting all edges in @xmath253 has width at most @xmath268 furthermore , the height of the underlying tree is at most @xmath4 . [ cor : bound on twd - n ] let @xmath8 be a class such that @xmath269 and let @xmath131 . if every structure @xmath214 has a tree decomposition @xmath223 of width @xmath9 and height at most @xmath258 such that the tree @xmath259 can not be embedded into @xmath83 , then @xmath270 . we conclude this section with a lemma that will be useful when constructing transductions @xmath271 that transform a structure into their tree decompositions of height @xmath4 . our construction works for all tree decompositions that are _ strict _ in the following sense . [ def : strict tree decomposition ] let @xmath223 be a tree decomposition of a structure @xmath11 . we define a function @xmath272 by @xmath273 note that @xmath274 is well - defined since , by the definition of a tree decomposition , there is at least one @xmath97 such that @xmath275 . for @xmath97 , we set @xmath276 the tree decomposition @xmath277 is _ strict _ if , for every @xmath97 , * @xmath278 ( equivalently , @xmath279 , where @xmath103 is the predecessor of @xmath101 ) and * if @xmath101 is not the root of @xmath83 , then the subgraph of @xmath229 induced by the set @xmath280 is connected . we conclude this section by a result implying that , for our purposes , it will be sufficient to consider only strict tree decompositions . [ lem : existence of strict tree decompositions ] let @xmath20 be a graph . for every tree decomposition @xmath223 of @xmath20 , there exists a strict tree decomposition @xmath281 of @xmath20 whose width and height are at most those of @xmath223 . by induction on @xmath33 , we will construct a sequence @xmath282 of tree decompositions such that @xmath283 is connected , for every @xmath284 with level @xmath285 . ( recall that @xmath100 denotes the level of @xmath101 , and the root is the only vertex of level @xmath71 . ) furthermore , the restriction of @xmath286 to the set of vertices of level at most @xmath4 will coincide with the corresponding restriction of @xmath287 , and we have @xmath288 , for all @xmath289 with level @xmath290 . it will follow that the sequence has a limit @xmath291 where @xmath292 we start the construction with @xmath293 and @xmath294 . suppose that we have already defined @xmath282 . for every vertex @xmath284 of level @xmath295 we modify the tree decomposition as follows . let @xmath296 be an enumeration of the connected components of @xmath283 . we replace in @xmath286 the subtree rooted at @xmath101 by @xmath84 copies @xmath297 of the subtree , all attached to the predecessor of @xmath101 . for @xmath298 we define @xmath299 . we can do these modifications for all vertices of level @xmath258 simultaneously . let @xmath300 be the resulting tree decomposition . the limit @xmath291 of this sequence satisfies the connectedness requirement of a strict tree decomposition . to also satisfy the other condition we proceed as follows let @xmath253 be the set of all edges @xmath239 of @xmath301 such that @xmath302 . ( note that this implies @xmath303 . ) we construct the tree decomposition @xmath281 by contracting all edges in @xmath253 . the details and the remaining verifications are left to the reader . in this section we relate the material presented in the preceding one to monadic second - order transductions . let us start by showing that there is a transduction computing the minors of a graph . [ lem : minors interpretable ] there exists a transduction @xmath1 such that @xmath304 , for every graph @xmath20 . a minor @xmath305 of @xmath20 is obtained by deleting vertices , deleting edges , and contracting edges . hence , we can encode @xmath305 by four sets.08em : the set of vertices we delete , the set of edges we delete , the set of edges we contract , and a set of vertices containing one representative of each contracted subgraph of @xmath20 ( these vertices serve as vertices of the resulting graph @xmath305 ) . with the help of these parameters we can define @xmath305 inside of @xmath306 by @xmath6-formulae . there is a close relationship between tree decompositions and transductions . [ lem : tree decomposable implies interpretable ] for every signature @xmath48 and every number @xmath59 , there exists a transduction @xmath307 $ ] that maps an order - tree @xmath83 to the class of all incidence structures @xmath27 such that the corresponding @xmath48-structure @xmath11 has a tree decomposition of width at most @xmath9 with underlying tree @xmath83 . suppose that @xmath11 is a structure which has a tree decomposition @xmath223 of width @xmath9 . we prove that @xmath11 can be defined from a colouring of @xmath83 where the number of colours depends only on @xmath48 and @xmath9 . let @xmath308 be an enumeration of all @xmath48-structures whose domain is a subset of @xmath309 $ ] . for each @xmath97 , let @xmath310 be the substructure of @xmath11 induced by @xmath208 . it follows that , for every @xmath97 , we can find some index @xmath311 such that @xmath312 . let @xmath313 be the corresponding isomorphism . furthermore , we associate with each edge @xmath239 of @xmath83 the binary relation @xmath314 \times [ k+1]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can recover @xmath11 from @xmath83 with the help of the vertex colouring @xmath315 and the edge colouring @xmath47 . we form the disjoint union of all structures @xmath316 , for @xmath97 , and we identify two elements @xmath317 and @xmath318 if @xmath239 is an edge of @xmath83 such that @xmath319 . this can be performed by an @xmath4-copying @xmath6-transduction where @xmath4 is the maximal size of the structures @xmath320 , @xmath321 . we have just seen that we can map a class of trees to a class of structures with these trees as tree decompositions . conversely , if we only consider strict tree decompositions , we can define a transduction mapping a class of structures to the corresponding class of trees . recall the function @xmath272 from definition [ def : strict tree decomposition ] . that assigns to an element @xmath125 the minimal index @xmath97 such that @xmath275 . [ prop : strict tree decompositions definable ] for each number @xmath33 , there exists an @xmath6-formula @xmath322 such that , for every strict tree decomposition @xmath203 of a graph @xmath20 of height at most @xmath4 , there are sets @xmath323 such that @xmath324 given @xmath72 we use the sets @xmath325 of all elements that first appear at level @xmath41 of the tree . in particular , @xmath326 is the root component of the tree decomposition . for @xmath327 , let @xmath328 be the subgraph of @xmath20 induced by @xmath329 . for @xmath330 and @xmath331 we define @xmath332 clearly , the relation @xmath79 is @xmath6-definable with the help of the parameters @xmath333 . we claim that , for @xmath334 , we have @xmath335 @xmath231 suppose that @xmath336 . then @xmath337 . furthermore , @xmath338 is connected since @xmath72 is strict . hence , @xmath338 is a connected component of @xmath339 containing both @xmath340 and @xmath341 . since @xmath342 it follows that @xmath343 . @xmath230 suppose that @xmath343 . then there exists an undirected path @xmath344 in @xmath345 connecting @xmath340 and @xmath341 . since @xmath346 , for all @xmath347 such that @xmath348 , it follows that @xmath344 is contained in some @xmath280 such that @xmath349 . since @xmath340 is a vertex of @xmath344 we must have @xmath350 . furthermore , @xmath337 since @xmath341 is also a vertex of @xmath344 . this implies that @xmath336 . [ thm : strict tree decompositions can be computed by a transduction ] for each constant @xmath33 , there exists a transduction @xmath271 mapping a graph @xmath20 to the class of all ( underlying trees of ) strict tree decompositions of @xmath20 of height at most @xmath4 . let @xmath203 be a strict tree decomposition of @xmath20 , and let @xmath351 be the formula from proposition [ prop : strict tree decompositions definable ] with parameters @xmath323 . we can define the tree @xmath83 underlying @xmath72 as follows.08em : * its root is any element of @xmath326 . * for the other vertices of @xmath83 , we choose one vertex in each @xmath352-class different from @xmath353 . note that @xmath352 is definable with the help of @xmath354 . * the ordering of @xmath83 is defined by @xmath354 . hence , we obtain a transduction with parameters @xmath333 that transforms a graph into a ` candidate ' tree decomposition . via a backwards translation we can write down a formula stating that the candidate given by the parameters @xmath333 corresponds to an actual strict tree decomposition . we omit the details which are standard for this type of construction . in lemma [ lem : tree decomposable implies interpretable ] we have seen how to obtain classes of bounded tree - width from classes of trees . conversely , it is the case that every class obtained from a class of trees via a transduction has a bounded tree - width . [ thm : interpretable implies tree decomposable ] for every transduction @xmath355 $ ] , there exists a number @xmath59 such that , for each @xmath84-coloured tree @xmath70 with image @xmath356 , the structure @xmath11 has a tree decomposition of width at most @xmath9 where the underlying tree is @xmath70 . \(a ) courcelle and engelfriet @xcite have shown that an incidence structure @xmath27 obtained via a transduction @xmath1 from an @xmath84-coloured tree @xmath70 has bounded tree - width . theorem [ thm : interpretable implies tree decomposable ] strengthens this result by proving that , if @xmath27 is the image of a tree @xmath70 , then we can use the same tree @xmath70 as the tree underlying a tree decomposition of the given width . \(b ) lapoire has announced in @xcite a result somewhat related to theorem [ thm : strict tree decompositions can be computed by a transduction ] . he claims that , for every @xmath59 , there exists a transduction that transforms a given graph @xmath20 of tree - width at most @xmath9 to a coloured tree ( like in the proof of lemma [ lem : tree decomposable implies interpretable ] ) that encodes some tree decomposition of @xmath20 of width at most @xmath9 . our result is less ambitious in the sense that we only consider tree decompositions of a fixed height . this enables us to give a precise description of which tree decompositions ( the strict ones ) our transduction returns . note that one can show that , for @xmath122 , there is no such transduction that would return _ all _ tree decompositions of @xmath20 of width at most @xmath9 . we split the proof into several lemmas . as a technical tool we introduce a second kind of hierarchical decompositions of structures and a corresponding notion of width . to simplify the definition we will only consider incidence structures . let @xmath357 be an incidence structure . \(a ) a _ partition refinement _ of @xmath27 is a family @xmath358 of pairs consisting of a subset @xmath359 and an equivalence relation @xmath360 on @xmath361 with the following properties.08em : * the index set @xmath83 is a tree . * for the root @xmath82 , we have @xmath362 * for every internal vertex ( i.e. , non - leaf ) @xmath98 with successors @xmath363 , the sets @xmath364 form a partition of @xmath365 . * @xmath366 , for every leaf @xmath98 . * @xmath367 and @xmath240 implies @xmath368 . * if @xmath103 is an internal vertex of @xmath83 , @xmath369 successors of @xmath103 , not necessarily distinct , and @xmath370 , @xmath371 elements , then @xmath368 implies either @xmath372 note that it follows that , for every element @xmath373 , there is some leaf @xmath98 such that @xmath374 . \(b ) the _ width _ of a partition refinement @xmath358 is the maximum number of equivalence classes realised in some component @xmath361.08em : @xmath375 the _ partition - width _ of the structure @xmath27 is the minimal width of a partition refinement of @xmath27 . the notion of a partition refinement and of partition - width are adaptations of definitions from @xcite . up to a factor of @xmath58 , the partition - width of an incidence structure and its clique - width coincide . let @xmath376 be a structure with domain @xmath377 and a ternary relation @xmath378 its incidence structure is @xmath379 with @xmath380 . we obtain a partition refinement where we have indicated the partition into @xmath360-classes by vertical bars . this partition refinement has width @xmath381 . [ lem : tree decomposition bounded by partition width ] for every partition refinement @xmath358 of an incidence structure @xmath382 , there exists a tree decomposition @xmath203 of @xmath11 with the same underlying tree @xmath83 such that @xmath383 let @xmath384 be the function assigning to every @xmath373 the unique leaf @xmath385 of @xmath83 such that @xmath386 . we claim that the desired tree decomposition @xmath387 of @xmath11 is given by @xmath388 note that the connectedness condition holds since @xmath389 implies that @xmath101 belongs to precisely those components @xmath390 such that @xmath103 lies on the path from @xmath391 to @xmath392 . it remains to prove that @xmath393 . if @xmath394 , for some @xmath395 , then @xmath396 consists of the components of @xmath174 . hence , @xmath397 therefore , we may assume that @xmath398 $ ] . let @xmath399_u : = \set { y \in w_u } { y \approx_u x } \end{aligned}\ ] ] denote the @xmath400-class of @xmath77 . we prove the following bounds . @xmath401_u } = 1 $ ] , for all @xmath402 . @xmath401_u \cap u_u } \leq 2 $ ] , for all @xmath403 . @xmath404 . since @xmath405 it then follows that @xmath406 . \(1 ) let @xmath402 . there is some tuple @xmath407 and some index @xmath41 such that @xmath408 and @xmath409 . we have @xmath410 , for every @xmath411 such that @xmath412 . since @xmath77 is the only such element it follows that @xmath197_u = \{x\}$ ] . \(2 ) let @xmath403 . there is some tuple @xmath407 and some @xmath41 such that @xmath408 and @xmath413 . let @xmath101 be the successor of @xmath103 such that @xmath414 . we have @xmath410 , for all @xmath415 such that @xmath412 . hence , @xmath197_u \smallsetminus w_v = \{x\}$ ] . suppose that there is some element @xmath416_u \cap w_v \cap u_u$ ] . by definition of @xmath390 there is some tuple @xmath417 and some @xmath418 such that @xmath419 and @xmath420 . as above it follows that @xmath197_u \cap w_v = \{y\}$ ] . consequently , we have @xmath401_u \cap u_u } \leq 2 $ ] . \(3 ) let @xmath421 and consider some tuple @xmath407 such that @xmath408 and @xmath422 . set @xmath423 for @xmath424 , it follows that @xmath425 furthermore , we obviously have @xmath426 . it follows that @xmath427 contains at most @xmath428 vertices . [ lem : partition width of simple tree interpretations ] let @xmath355 $ ] be a basic @xmath6-transduction such that , for every @xmath84-coloured order - tree @xmath70 with image @xmath356 , we have @xmath429 then there exists a number @xmath33 such that , for every order - tree @xmath70 , we can find a partition refinement @xmath430 of @xmath431 of width at most @xmath4 . let @xmath432 be the definition scheme of @xmath1 , and let @xmath433 be the maximal rank of these formulae . given @xmath70 we define the desired partition refinement @xmath434 by setting @xmath435 \prefixtext{and } & x \approx_u y \quad\defiff\quad \begin{aligned}[t ] & { \mathrm{mth}}_h(\frakt_v , x ) = { \mathrm{mth}}_h(\frakt_w , y)\ , , \\ & \text{where $ v , w$ are the successors of $ u$ with } x \in w_v \text { and } y \in w_w\ , . \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( if @xmath103 is a leaf of @xmath83 then @xmath374 and we take the equality relation for @xmath400 . ) note that the index of @xmath360 is finite and that it only depends on @xmath433 and not on the input tree @xmath70 . it remains to show that @xmath436 is actually a partition refinement . first , let us prove that @xmath367 and @xmath240 implies @xmath368 . it is sufficient to consider the case that @xmath103 is the predecessor of @xmath101 . then the general case follows by induction . hence , suppose that @xmath101 is a successor of @xmath103 , that @xmath437 are successors of @xmath101 , and that @xmath438 are leaves with @xmath439 and @xmath440 such that @xmath367 . then we have @xmath441 which , by lemma [ lem : composition for trees ] , implies that @xmath442 consequently , we have @xmath368 . we also have to show that the incidence relation is invariant under @xmath400 . let @xmath369 be successors of @xmath103 and suppose that @xmath438 are leaves with @xmath443 and @xmath444 such that @xmath368 . we distinguish two cases . suppose that @xmath445 and let @xmath446 be an edge . since @xmath447 it follows that @xmath448 hence , @xmath408 iff @xmath410 . now , suppose that @xmath449 and let @xmath450 be an element . since @xmath447 it follows that @xmath451 hence , @xmath452 iff @xmath453 . \(1 ) first , suppose that @xmath355 $ ] is a basic @xmath6-transduction such that , for every @xmath84-coloured order - tree @xmath454 with image @xmath356 , we have @xmath429 it follows by lemma [ lem : partition width of simple tree interpretations ] that there is a number @xmath455 such that , for every tree @xmath70 , we can find a partition refinement of @xmath356 with underlying tree @xmath70 whose width is at most @xmath153 . by lemma [ lem : tree decomposition bounded by partition width ] it follows that @xmath11 has a tree decomposition @xmath223 with underlying tree @xmath70 and whose width is less than @xmath456 . \(2 ) if @xmath1 is a basic @xmath6-transduction such that @xmath457 then we can argue similarly . let @xmath458 be the @xmath6-transduction mapping @xmath70 to the structure obtained from @xmath431 by adding one isolated element for every leaf of @xmath70 that does not correspond to an element of @xmath431 . then @xmath458 is of the form considered in ( 1 ) and we obtain a tree decomposition @xmath223 of @xmath459 . deleting from every component @xmath208 all elements not in @xmath431 we obtain the desired tree decomposition of @xmath431 . \(3 ) suppose that @xmath1 is a non - copying @xmath6-transduction as in ( 2 ) but with @xmath460 parameters . we can regard @xmath1 as a basic @xmath6-transduction @xmath461 $ ] . by ( 2 ) it follows that , for every value of the parameters @xmath92 , the structure @xmath462 has a tree decomposition of the required form . \(4 ) finally , consider the general case . suppose that @xmath1 is @xmath151-copying . given @xmath70 let @xmath463 be the tree obtained from @xmath70 by adding @xmath151 new successors to every vertex of @xmath70 . formally , suppose that @xmath81 , for some finite set @xmath72 . w.l.o.g . we may assume that @xmath464 = \emptyset$ ] . we define the domain @xmath465)^{<\omega}$ ] of @xmath463 by @xmath466)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] furthermore , we add new colour predicates @xmath467\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that every element of @xmath431 is of the form @xmath468 where @xmath469 $ ] and @xmath97 . hence , each such element corresponds to a leaf @xmath470 \subseteq t^+$ ] . using the parameters @xmath471 we can construct a basic @xmath6-transduction @xmath472 $ ] satisfying the conditions of ( 3 ) such that @xmath473 . by ( 3 ) , we obtain a tree decomposition @xmath474 of @xmath473 . let @xmath475 be the tree decomposition obtained from @xmath476 by contracting every edge leading to a leaf in @xmath477 . then we have @xmath478 -- the focus of our investigation lies on the following preorder on classes of structures which compares their ` encoding powers ' with respect to @xmath6-transductions . our main result is a complete description of the hierarchy induced by this preorder . it will be given in theorem [ thm : hierarchy ] . let @xmath479 . we define the following relations . @xmath480 if there exists a transduction @xmath1 such that @xmath18 . @xmath481 if @xmath480 and @xmath482 . @xmath483 if @xmath480 and @xmath484 . @xmath485 if @xmath481 and there is no class @xmath486 with @xmath487 . @xmath488 if @xmath489 . the relations @xmath490 , @xmath491 , and @xmath492 are defined analogously to @xmath493 , @xmath494 , @xmath495 by replacing @xmath29 everywhere by @xmath28 . the _ transduction hierarchy _ is the hierarchy of classes @xmath496 induced by the relation @xmath28 . as the class of transductions is closed under composition , it follows that the relation @xmath28 is a preorder , i.e. , it is reflexive and transitive . @xmath28 is a preorder on @xmath497 . we consider the following subclasses of @xmath498 $ ] . ( all trees below are considered to be successor - trees . ) @xmath499 is the set of all complete @xmath84-ary trees of height @xmath4 . @xmath500 is the class of all binary trees . @xmath501 is the class of all trees . @xmath502 is the class of all paths . @xmath503 is the class of all rectangular grids . the following description of the transduction hierarchy is the main result of the present paper . [ thm : hierarchy ] we have the following hierarchy.08em : @xmath504 for every signature @xmath48 , every class @xmath505 $ ] is @xmath491-equivalent to some class in this hierarchy . there is a lot of flexibility in the choice of representatives for the various levels . for instance , we could replace @xmath506 by the class of _ all _ trees of height at most @xmath4 , @xmath501 by @xmath500 or @xmath507 , and @xmath503 by the class of square grids . it is straightforward to show that the above classes form an increasing chain . the hard part is to prove that the chain is strictly increasing and that there are no further classes . we have @xmath508 in the example before lemma [ lem : transductions are comorphisms ] , we have constructed transductions @xmath271 such that @xmath509 . hence , @xmath510 . the remaining assertions follow from the observation that , by lemma [ lem : minors interpretable ] , @xmath511 implies @xmath488 . let us collect some easy properties of the hierarchy . our first result states that @xmath503 is a representative of the top level of the transduction hierarchy . [ lem : g is top ] @xmath49 \sqsubseteq_{\mathrm{in}}\calg$ ] recall that the @xmath512 grid is the undirected graph @xmath189 with vertices @xmath513 \times [ n]$ ] and edge relation @xmath514 before encoding arbitrary structures in such grids we describe a transduction mapping @xmath20 to its directed variant @xmath515 where @xmath516 this can be done with the help of the parameters @xmath517 where @xmath518 then @xmath519 it is easy to write down a formula checking that the parameters @xmath520 and @xmath521 are correctly chosen ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . to show that @xmath49 \sqsubseteq_{\mathrm{in}}\calg$ ] , suppose that @xmath167 $ ] is a structure with @xmath522 . fix enumerations @xmath523 of @xmath43 and @xmath524 of @xmath192 . by the above remarks , it is sufficient to encode @xmath27 in the directed @xmath512 grid . consider the following subsets of @xmath525 \times [ n]$].08em : @xmath526 \times \{0\}\,,\qquad & p'_r & : = \set { \langle 0,k\rangle } { e_k \in p_r } \ , , \\ e ' & : = \{0\ } \times [ n]\,,\qquad & i'_l & : = \set { \langle i , k\rangle } { ( a_i , e_k ) \in { \mathrm{in}}_l } \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then @xmath27 can be recovered from @xmath20 by an @xmath6-transduction using these sets as parameters . @xmath527 . for one direction , note that @xmath528 implies @xmath529 . conversely , each finite tree can be obtained as minor of a binary tree . therefore , we have @xmath530 . we have @xmath531 if and only if @xmath8 is finite and contains at least one nonempty structure . as indicated in the example before lemma [ lem : transductions are comorphisms ] , there exists a transduction mapping an incidence structure @xmath27 to the incidence structure @xmath146 of the gaifman graph of @xmath11 . [ lem : gaifman graph interpretable ] for every class @xmath8 of structures , we have @xmath532 . the next result is just a restatement of lemma [ lem : minors interpretable ] in our current terminology . [ lem : minor equivalent ] for every class @xmath8 of graphs we have @xmath533 . in this section we prove that the hierarchy is strict . using the results of section [ sect : tree decompositions and transductions ] we can characterise each level of the hierarchy in terms of tree - width and its variants . [ thm : characterisation of pwd , twd ] let @xmath505 $ ] . @xmath534 @xmath535 . @xmath536 @xmath537 . @xmath538 @xmath539 . in each case @xmath231 follows from lemma [ lem : tree decomposable implies interpretable ] and @xmath230 follows from theorem [ thm : interpretable implies tree decomposable ] . let @xmath8 be a class of @xmath48-structures . @xmath540 implies @xmath541 . @xmath542 implies @xmath543 . \(a ) suppose that @xmath540 . then theorem [ thm : excluded tree theorem ] implies that @xmath544 . hence , the claim follows from lemmas [ lem : gaifman graph interpretable ] and [ lem : minor equivalent ] . \(b ) suppose that @xmath542 . then theorem [ thm : excluded grid theorem ] implies that @xmath545 . as in ( a ) , the claim follows from lemmas [ lem : gaifman graph interpretable ] and [ lem : minor equivalent ] . [ cor : nothing between p , t , g ] let @xmath505 $ ] . @xmath546 implies @xmath541 . @xmath547 implies @xmath548 . in particular , it follows that the upper part of the hierarchy is strict.08em : [ cor : upper part ] @xmath549 both assertions follow from theorem [ thm : characterisation of pwd , twd ] and corollary [ cor : nothing between p , t , g ] . for the first one , note that we have @xmath550 since @xmath551 . conversely , @xmath552 implies , by theorem [ thm : characterisation of pwd , twd](a ) , that @xmath553 . hence , @xmath554 . finally , if @xmath555 then @xmath534 , by corollary [ cor : nothing between p , t , g](a ) . consequently , we have @xmath556 . similarly , the fact that @xmath557 follows from lemma [ lem : g is top ] . since @xmath558 , theorem [ thm : characterisation of pwd , twd](b ) implies that @xmath559 . finally , we obtain @xmath560 by corollary [ cor : nothing between p , t , g](b ) . let us turn to the lower part . we start with two technical lemmas . let @xmath561 be an order - tree . vertices @xmath562 of @xmath83 are _ horizontally related via _ a vertex @xmath153 if all @xmath156 are at the same level of the tree and @xmath563 , for all @xmath564 . [ lem : large degree is preserved ] let @xmath70 be a coloured order - tree of height @xmath4 , and suppose that @xmath1 is a parameterless @xmath9-copying @xmath6-transduction of rank @xmath52 such that @xmath431 is a successor - tree of height at most @xmath258 . consider vertices @xmath562 of @xmath70 that are horizontally related via @xmath153 and fix some number @xmath565 . let @xmath566 be the successor of @xmath153 with @xmath567 . if , for all @xmath568 , we have @xmath569 then at least @xmath570 elements of the set @xmath571 ( these are elements of the domain of @xmath431 ) are horizontally related in @xmath431 . let @xmath572 be the formula defining the successor relation in @xmath431 between vertices of the form @xmath573 and @xmath574 . by assumption the rank of @xmath572 is at most @xmath52 . first , note that a vertex @xmath575 is on level @xmath433 in @xmath431 if and only if there are indices @xmath576 such that @xmath577 \exists y_0\cdots\exists y_{h-1}\bigl[\land_{i < h-1 } \varphi_{s_is_{i+1}}(y_i , y_{i+1 } ) & \land \varphi_{s_{h-1}l}(y_{h-1},v ) \\ & \land \neg \exists z\lor_{s < k } \varphi_{ss_0}(z , y_0)\bigr ] \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] expresses that there exists a path of the form @xmath578 from the root @xmath579 of @xmath431 to the vertex @xmath575 . by assumption on @xmath156 and lemma [ lem : composition for trees ] , we have @xmath580 since the rank of @xmath581 is @xmath582 it follows that @xmath583 hence , all vertices @xmath584 are on the same level @xmath433 in @xmath431 . we prove by induction on @xmath433 that @xmath585 implies that all but at most one of @xmath584 are horizontally related . let @xmath586 be the predecessor of @xmath587 in @xmath431 , that is , @xmath588 we distinguish two cases . first suppose that @xmath589 in @xmath70 . by @xmath590 and lemma [ lem : composition for trees ] , we have @xmath591 for all @xmath41 such that @xmath592 . note that there can be at most one index @xmath41 that does not satisfy this condition since , if we had @xmath593 and @xmath594 , for @xmath595 , then we would have @xmath596 and @xmath562 would not be horizontally related via @xmath153 . it follows that @xmath597 hence , @xmath598 is the common predecessor of all the @xmath587 , except for possibly one of them . ( for an index @xmath41 with @xmath593 our composition argument does not work since in that case @xmath590 does not imply that the theories of @xmath599 and @xmath600 coincide . ) it remains to consider the case that @xmath601 . setting @xmath602 we have @xmath603\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the rank of this formula is @xmath604 it follows that @xmath605\ , , \quad\text{for all } i < m\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] consequently , we have @xmath606 , for all @xmath41 , and @xmath607 are horizontally related via @xmath153 . since the vertices @xmath608 are on level @xmath609 in @xmath431 , we can apply the induction hypothesis and it follows that all but at most one of then are horizontally related via some vertex @xmath610 . therefore , the same holds for their successors @xmath584 . we denote by @xmath611 the number of functions @xmath612)$ ] with @xmath613 . intuitively , each such function corresponds to a vertex - colouring of the tree @xmath85 with @xmath614 colours . for @xmath615 and @xmath122 , we have @xmath616 for @xmath617 , we have @xmath618 since @xmath619^{<n } } = \sum_{i < n } m^i = m^{n-1 } + \sum_{i < n-1 } m^i$ ] it follows that @xmath620^{<n } } \leq 2m^{n-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , we can bound @xmath621^{<n}}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from above by @xmath622 and from below by @xmath623 -- [ lem : lower part strict ] @xmath624 for a contradiction , suppose that there exists a transduction @xmath1 such that @xmath625 . let @xmath626 be the class of all order - trees corresponding to successor - trees in @xmath506 , and let @xmath627 be the class of all coloured successor - trees with one colour whose underlying tree is in @xmath628 . since the successor - trees in @xmath506 are @xmath63-sparse we can construct an @xmath6-transduction @xmath629 such that @xmath630 . since @xmath631 we can combine @xmath1 and @xmath629 to a transduction @xmath165 such that @xmath632 . by lemma [ lem : large degree is preserved ] , it follows that there is some constant @xmath633 such that every tree @xmath634 with out - degree at most @xmath9 is of the form @xmath635 where @xmath636 has out - degree at most @xmath637 . ( the out - degree of an order - tree is the out - degree of the corresponding successor - tree . ) suppose that @xmath165 uses @xmath614 parameters . there are @xmath638 colourings of trees in @xmath626 with out - degree at most @xmath637 . on the other hand , there are @xmath639 trees in @xmath640 with out - degree at most @xmath9 . for large @xmath9 it follows that @xmath641 consequently , there is some tree in @xmath640 that is not the image of a tree in @xmath626 . a contradiction . we have shown that the hierarchy presented in theorem [ thm : hierarchy ] is strict . to conclude the proof of the theorem it therefore remains to show that there are no additional classes . we have already seen in corollary [ cor : upper part ] that @xmath501 and @xmath503 are the only classes above @xmath502 . next we shall prove that @xmath642 . [ lem : embeddable trees means interpretable ] let @xmath8 be a class of structures . if , for every number @xmath131 , there exists a structure @xmath214 such that we can embed @xmath259 into every tree underlying a tree decomposition @xmath223 of @xmath11 of width @xmath9 , then @xmath643 . by lemma [ lem : existence of strict tree decompositions ] , it follows that , for every @xmath131 , there is a structure in @xmath8 with a strict tree decomposition of width at most @xmath9 and with an underlying tree @xmath83 into which we can embed the tree @xmath259 . according to proposition [ prop : strict tree decompositions definable ] there is a transduction mapping @xmath8 to the class of trees underlying these strict tree decompositions . hence , there exists a class @xmath644 of successor - trees containing , for every @xmath131 , some tree into which we can embed @xmath259 . hence , @xmath645 . [ thm : covering for lower part ] let @xmath8 be a class of structures . then @xmath646 implies @xmath539 . suppose that @xmath646 . then @xmath647 since @xmath648 . by lemmas [ lem : gaifman graph interpretable ] and [ lem : minor equivalent ] , this implies that @xmath649 . therefore , we can find a path that is not in @xmath650 . by theorem [ thm : excluded path theorem ] , it follows that there are numbers @xmath651 such that @xmath652 . by induction on @xmath151 , we prove that @xmath653 implies @xmath539 . for @xmath654 , there is nothing to do . for @xmath655 , we have @xmath656 , which implies that @xmath657 . consequently , it follows by lemma [ lem : embeddable trees means interpretable ] and corollary [ cor : bound on twd - n ] that @xmath658 . by induction hypothesis , the result follows . by lemma [ lem : tree decomposable implies interpretable ] we obtain the following results . [ cor : nothing between tn and tn+1 ] if @xmath646 then @xmath538 . [ cor : lower part covers ] @xmath659 . to conclude the proof of theorem [ thm : hierarchy ] it remains to show that there are no classes between the lower part of the hierarchy and its upper part . [ lem : calt_n dense below calp ] let @xmath8 be a class of structures . if @xmath660 , for all @xmath33 , then @xmath661 . we show the contraposition . suppose that @xmath647 . we have to show that there is some @xmath4 such that @xmath662 . as in the proof of theorem [ thm : covering for lower part ] it follows that there are numbers @xmath651 such that @xmath652 . hence , we can use lemma [ lem : tree decomposable implies interpretable ] to obtain a transduction @xmath1 witnessing that @xmath663 . by theorem [ lem : lower part strict ] we have @xmath664 . it follows that @xmath665 , as desired . [ cor : noting between lower and upper part ] if @xmath666 then there is some @xmath33 such that @xmath538 . by lemma [ lem : calt_n dense below calp ] , there is some @xmath33 such that @xmath646 . hence , corollary [ cor : nothing between tn and tn+1 ] implies that @xmath538 . together , corollaries [ cor : upper part ] , [ cor : lower part covers ] , and [ cor : noting between lower and upper part ] ( and the fact that every class @xmath8 satisfies @xmath667 ) show that every class of @xmath48-structures is @xmath491-equivalent to some of the classes in theorem [ thm : hierarchy ] . this completes the proof of this theorem . above we have obtained a complete description of the transduction hierarchy for classes of finite incidence structures . the most surprising result is that the hierarchy is linear . at this point there are at least three natural directions in which to proceed . an answer to ( ii ) seems within reach , at least if we restrict our attention to countable structures . although the resulting hierarchy is no longer linear we can adapt most of our techniques to this setting . ( for an example of nonlinearity , note that the class of all countable trees and the class of all finite grids are incomparable . ) concerning question ( iii ) , let us remark that all results above go through if we use @xmath110 instead of @xmath6 . we only need the right definition of rank for @xmath110 . in the proof of theorem [ lem : lower part strict ] we needed the fact that there are only finitely many theories of bounded rank . we can ensure this for @xmath110 by defining the rank as the least number @xmath4 such that for logics much weaker than @xmath6 , on the other hand , it seems unrealistic to hope for a complete description of the corresponding transduction hierarchy . for instance , a related hierarchy for first - order logic was investigated by mycielski , pudlk , and stern in @xcite . the results they obtain indicate that the structure of the resulting hierarchy is very complicated . finally , let us address question ( i ) . when using transductions between structures instead of their incidence structures , we can transfer some of the above results to the corresponding hierarchy . but we presently have no complete description since we miss some of the corresponding excluded minor results . note that all classes in theorem [ thm : hierarchy for mso ] are @xmath58-sparse . for @xmath58-sparse classes @xmath8 and @xmath17 , lemma [ lem : relation between ad and in ] implies that @xmath679 consequently , the result follows from theorem [ thm : hierarchy ] . if we only consider classes of graphs and if we use @xmath110-transductions instead of @xmath6-transductions , then the following result can be used as replacement of theorem [ thm : excluded grid theorem].08em : this eliminates some possibilities for intermediate classes of graphs in the hierarchy of theorem [ thm : hierarchy for mso ] , but to complete the picture we still need analogues of proposition [ prop : strict tree decompositions definable ] and of theorems [ thm : excluded tree theorem ] and [ thm : excluded path theorem ] . furthermore , the techniques of @xcite are specific to graphs ( or , more generally , to relational structures where all relations are binary ) . even with the results of @xcite one can not exclude the existence of a class @xmath8 of arbitrary relational structures strictly between @xmath501 and @xmath503 in the @xmath110-transduction hierarchy . let us make a final comment about relational structures . an incidence structure @xmath27 can be seen as a bipartite labelled directed graph ( see the remark after definition [ def : incidence structure ] ) . furthermore , it is @xmath63-sparse . hence , our results use tools from graph theory , in particular those of @xcite . however , there is currently no encoding of relational structures as labelled graphs that could help to solve question ( i ) above . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ since all men have imperfections + hanging bones inside their closets + that they trust no one will notice + absent tips on where to find them , + it will shock no one to learn that + even mighty hiawatha + famous chief of myth and legend + did some things he was not proud of + while a brother in a frat house + with a surly reputation + at an unknown little college + that his father helped to finance + so that he would get admitted + by the shores of gitche - gumee . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ far from loving fields and flowers + and the odor of the forest + as one reads in all the textbooks + hiawatha hated woodlands + and the animals one finds there , + whom he felt were always pooping , + and the plants the critters fed on + down in dank and swampy bottoms , + nearly perfect grounds for breeding + mighty hordes of great mosquitoes + who were always lean and hungry + and equipped with maps and radar + could detect where you were hiding + to inflict their bites and torments , + with their sneaky friends the black flies , + and their angry friends the green flies , + and the rocks ensnared by tree roots + that existed just to trip you + and would look improved as concrete + in foundation for a condo . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the kindly , thoughtful image + of a noble man of nature + was a total fabrication + of a team of gifted spin docs + hired later for this purpose . + he was really just a tech nerd + who cared only for equations + and explaining all behavior + from the basic laws of physics + armed with only mathematics . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha hated woodlands . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus , instead of lakes and forests , + hiawatha worshipped newton , + whose account of kepler s orbits + built on rules that galileo + had inferred from observation + plus the innocent assumption + of a law of gravitation + was a cosmic inspiration ; + and the brilliant sadie carnot , + whose insightful laws of heat flow + were deduced from working engines + absent microscopic theories ; + and the tragic ludwig boltzmann + who ascribed these laws to counting + but fell victim to depression + when he found no one believed him + and so killed himself by jumping + from an adriatic tower . + hiawatha saw that maxwell s + guessing missing laws of motion + needed for predicting light waves , + was the most transcendent genius , + as was albert einstein s insight + that the speed of light being constant + must mean time was not consistent + and that mass could be converted + into heat and vice versa . + just as clear was that the planck law + must imply debroglie s wavelength + was in force in any matter + so that sharp atomic spectra + and distinct atomic sizes + and the laws of bond formation + came from quantum interference . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus it was that hiawatha + came to be infatuated + with the laws of quantum matter , + which means liquid noble gases , + neutrons in a burnt - out star core , + or just rocks so cryogenic + they can not get any colder , + even with improved equipment , + like the state of too much sliding + on the ice of gitche - gumee + after dark in dead of winter + in an inexpensive loincloth . + pain and danger notwithstanding + quantum matter s simple structure + makes the eager physics tyro + quite unable to resist it . + hiawatha learned how atoms + self - assemble into crystals , + how electrons move right through them , + waving past the rigid ions + thereby making them metallic + in the absence of a bandgap + which arises from diffraction + and prevents the charge from moving + thereby causing insulation , + but by means of wires and doping + with atomic imperfections + when the bandgap is a small one + can be used to make transistors . + in addition to the basics + he learned how electric forces + like those seen in clinging woolens + cause some things to be magnetic + up until the lowly phonon , + quantum particle of sound wave , + storing heat the way that light does + mediates a strong attraction + that can pair up two electrons + causing them to move together + overcoming all resistance + and producing other magic + such as quantum oscillations . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ they were little more than con men . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ at this quite untimely moment + of his fragile student history + when his mind was most suggestive + our poor hapless hiawatha + had the terrible misfortune + to fall in with wicked people + who were little more than con men + and advanced in their profession + making theories of such matter + that were not at all deductive + but instead used mathematics + as a way to sow confusion + so that no one would discover + that their stuff was pure opinion + spiced with politics and chutzpah + so it looked somewhat like science + even though it really was nt . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ how they did this was ingenious + for it s not a simple matter + to produce concrete equations + that are absolutely hokum + and escape without detection + when they represent relations + of some quantities one measures + written down as abstract symbols + that could easily be tested . + what they did was deftly prey on + prejudicial ways of thinking + that their colleagues thought were reasoned + but were simply misconceptions , + generated during training + they had all received as students , + that the properties one wanted + were completely universal + so details did not matter . + but the data did not say this + and , moreover , had they done so + there would have been no good reason + to think any more about it . + so , while everyone was watching , + they swapped in some new equations + that they said would solve the problem + on account of being much simpler + but in fact described a system + very different from the first one + and , moreover , was unstable , + balanced at competing phases , + so that nobody could solve it + thus betraying the deception . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ adding to the dazzling brilliance + of this coldly thought - out swindle + they declared it _ fundamental _ + so that all the strange creations + made by people trying to solve it + and quite clearly not succeeding + proved it was a fount of deepness + one should struggle to unravel + even if it took a lifetime . + as a nifty added bonus + any hint you dropped in public + that it might have no solution + simply meant you were nt a genius , + told the world that you were stupid , + that you were a hopeless failure + who should not command a pencil . + no one wanted to admit this + so they d cover up their failure + and pretend that they had solved it + even though they clearly had nt . + this succeeded , for the most part , + but in one respect it did nt , + for their desperate need to publish + and thereby maintain their funding + caused a massive flood of papers , + each quite different from the others , + to descend upon the journals + and to overwhelm and clog them . + this would have been very funny + had it not been so pathetic . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ it just meant you were nt a genius . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha bought the story + took the bait , hook , line , and sinker + and , like many other students + who d been victimized before him , + got convinced that his strong math skills , + far exceeding those of others , + would reveal nature s mysteries + when he solved the hubbard model + and its child the t - j model + and the lattice kondo model + and the quantum spin glass model , + all of which possessed the feature + that no human being could solve them . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ nature has a sense of humor , + as one learns by working with it , + but it is an opportunist , + so that life s most bitter lessons + often wind up learned the hard way + when it moves to take advantage + of a single bad decision + and compound it with some mischief + custom made for the occasion . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ just when he d resolved to strike out + on his suicidal mission + there occurred a bold announcement + in a well - known german journal + that a tiny lab near zrich + had discovered a material + with the structure of perovskite + made of oxygen and copper + and some other stuff like strontium + that when cooled to thirty kelvin + lost all traces of resistance . + this event was simply shocking + for existing quantum theory + said it had to get much colder + for this special thing to happen , + as did all the careful surveys + of the properties of metals , + which were very comprehensive + and agreed well with the theory . + since the chemists were ambitious + to somehow transcend this limit , + which they thought too academic , + and someday kill all resistance + using no refrigeration , + there ensued a feeding frenzy + worthy of a horror movie , + like what happens when a trawler + dumps its hold of tuna entrails + off a reef in north australia . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ one example of this madness + was the _ physics woodstock _ conference + that took place in mid - manhattan + shortly after the announcement + where attendees got together , + comandeered a giant ballroom , + and gave talks not on the program + in a special all - night session + dedicated to the cuprates + which was packed to overflowing . + there was talk of maglev transport , + new kinds of computer circuit , + mighty , compact little motors + and efficient power cables , + all of which would soon be coming + thanks to this momentous breakthrough . + but it turns out we do nt have them + for they were nt a big improvement + over things we had already + and were hopelessly expensive . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ then there were the frantic searches + to find compounds that were better , + which one knew could be accomplished + if one spent enough time looking , + since this stuff had lots of phases + subtly different from each other , + and there had to be a best one . + there was very rapid progress + culminating in a patent + for a more complex material + in the same broad class of structure + which performed at ninety kelvin , + so much higher than the theory + would allow to ever happen + even with extreme assumptions + that one knew it was in trouble . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ almost overnight one found that + every spectrum known to science + had been taken on a cuprate . + their alleged profound importance + was , of course , a major factor , + but what mattered most was tactics . + without need to tell one s funders , + since it could be done so quickly , + one could telephone a chemist , + cut a deal to get some samples , + put them in one s apparatus + presto ! out would come a paper + that would instantly get published + even if it was a stinker . + this produced a pile of data , + growing without bound , like cancer , + that completely overwhelmed you + by being mostly unimportant , + like the growing list of options + coming from your cable service . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ presto ! out would come a stinker . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ often spectra were nt consistent , + but , instead of getting angry + as one would have in the old days , + one would handle it maturely + and just chalk it up to errors + that occur when one is hasty + or has had bad luck with samples . + but this tolerance , it turns out , + was a bargain with the devil + for it later was discovered + that enormous variation + was endemic to the cuprates , + and that things not reproducing + due to complex phase inclusions , + foreign atoms in the sample , + careless oxygen annealing , + surface preparation methods , + and a thousand other factors + was essential to their nature . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ sadly , by the time this surfaced + shameful habits of denying + that the differences existed + had become enshrined in writing , + and so wedded to the culture , + that they could not be corrected . + it was now accepted practice + in a public presentation + of experimental findings + not to mention other data + even if your own group took them . + grounds for this were rarely stated , + other than the innuendo + that one s sorry competition + were a hopeless bunch of bozos + who did not know how to measure + and therefore could not be trusted . + it was likewise viewed as kosher + to make up a little theory + or adopt somebody else s + that gave all your findings meaning + although not those of your colleagues , + which were , sadly , so imperfect + they were simply inconsistent . + but one never heard recanting , + since it would have meant admission + that one s judgement had been faulty . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the cuprates weird caprices + long escaping understanding + transformed into pseudotheories + that , like gods on mount olympus , + were political creations + that could not be killed with reason + and , empowered as immortals , + took control of their creators , + warred among themselves for power , + schemed to have a lot of children , + and , in general , made a circus + of the scientific method . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , being a student , + and , quite frankly , rather callow + did not have the slightest inkling + that such nonsense ever happened . + he believed the claims of science + to be rather more objective + than competing kinds of knowledge + on account of its precision + and the fact that you could test it . + rather than the yawning snake pit + seething with disinformation + that was really there before him , + certain death for young beginners , + he saw just a chance for glory + something of immense importance , + judging from the acrimony + coursing through the talks and papers , + and a vast supply of data + on which one could build a theory + and thereby become a hero , + much the way the dumber brother + of the famous brave odysseus + that no one has ever heard of , + sure he could outfox the sirens , + ordered that the men unbind him + and , of course , succumbing quickly + dove right in and bashed his brains out . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s misconceptions were not shared by everybody . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s misconceptions + of the nature of the problem + he was setting out to conquer + were not shared by everybody . + just as buzzards , with keen noses , + circling high above their breakfast + wait until it can not hurt them , + to swoop down and get to business , + and ichneuman wasps impregnate + larval caterpillar victims + with some eggs that grow to eat them , + thus not let them reach adulthood + when they might be hard to handle , + hiawatha s crafty mentors + sensed that science had stopped working + in the sub - field of the cuprates , + as it had before in others + where their scams had been successful . + smelling death was close upon it , + they resolved the time was ready . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ what ensued was simply awesome , + destined to go down in legend . + they proposed a cuprate theory + so magnificent in concept , + so much bolder than the others + that it blasted them to pieces + like some big atomic warhead , + so outshined them in its glory + like a nova in the heavens + that it blinded any person + who would dare to gaze upon it . + cuprates did these things , it stated , + just because a quirk of nature + made them like the _ hubbard model _ , + which , as had been long established , + did some things quite fundamental , + not yet known to modern science , + which explained the crazy data , + so to understand the cuprates + one would have to solve this model . + how colossal ! how stupendous ! + it was absolutely foolproof ! + no one could disprove this theory + with existing mathematics + or experimental data + for exactly the same reasons + nor could they admit they could nt , + so they d spend their whole lives trying , + blame themselves for being so stupid , + and pay homage in each paper + with the requisite citation ! + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ they left clues in great abundance + that they d made a vast deception + far surpassing p. t. barnum s + most creative whims and musings + trusting that no one would catch them + on account of being so guileless , + which they knew was part of science , + rather like the clever killer , + sure he can outsmart columbo , + leaving marks upon the crime scene + then in later verbal sparring + hints at them in brazen taunting . + one was that its short description , + resonating bonds of valence , + was the name that linus pauling + used for common bonds of benzene , + something so profoundly different + from the physics of the cuprates + that its use on this occasion + seemed to show a lousy word sense . + but , in fact , it was inspired , + for the permanent confusion + left by its uncertain meaning + like the data it reflected , + was defense against attackers , + made it very hard to target , + left its enemies bewildered . + and the thoughtful usurpation + of a well - established brand name + had the lovely added feature + of dispatching pesky pauling , + who had always been a nuisance , + down to davy jones s locker + in the minds of younger people . + _ getting rid of pesky pauling . _ there was also the assertion + running rampant through the theory + that the essence of the cuprates + was coulombic insulation , + which , on close inspection , turned out + no one could define precisely , + with a few concrete equations , + but was nonetheless a concept + people thought they comprehended , + like the fancy secret contents + of competing brands of toothpaste + that , of course , are total fictions + made up during lunch by ad guys . + but the best clue by some margin + was the _ deus ex machina _ + known as gutzwiller projection , + which began life as a method + for controlling the equations + but was morphed on this occasion + to a monsterous distortion + of the basic mathematics + on the grounds it was insightful . + but , in fact , it came from nowhere , + and was just a simple dictat + that an off - the - shelf conductor + could not be a quantum magnet + while one forced it to become one + thus creating awful conflict + when , in fact , there simply was none . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , being clever , + quickly saw that he could do this , + saw that such manipulations + were , in fact , extremely easy , + that a high school kid could do them , + once he got the key idea + that one should evade the problem + of deducing the behavior + from the actual equations + by declaring that some answer + was correct because one said so + and proceeding to defend it + with a lot of complex symbols + simply cooked up to confuse things . + thus emboldened to abandon + his perverse outdated fear of + uncontrolled approximations + hiawatha bit the bullet + and jumped into cuprate theory + with the fury of a madman , + doing reckless calculations + based on nothing but some gas fumes + that produced some fine predictions , + as one was inclined to call them , + matching some existing data + but , of course , not matching others , + since they were not all consistent . + he would then just pick and choose them + as one would an orange or lemon + in the local supermarket + and declare the rest defective . + then he wrote up his conclusions + in a little physics paper + loaded up with fearsome symbols + proving that he had credentials + to make all these speculations , + sent it in for publication + and then found an awful problem + he had not anticipated . + for the paper to be published + it must get past refereeing + which , in theory , was for stopping + false results from being reported + but , in practice , was to censor + anyone whose work you hated , + somewhat of a sticky wicket + for someone who s main objective + was to publish speculation . + hiawatha soon discovered + though the process of rejection + that his papers could not make it + if they championed new ideas + or in any way conflicted + with the viewpoints of the experts + which , of course , were simply made up . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the mighty hiawatha + found his plans to be a scholar + had an unexpected down side + that would later prove quite fatal + in that he was forced to pander + in his writing for the public + to a set of flakey concepts + that he d found extremely useful + but had not had time to question , + in exchange for recognition + needed for career advancement . + for a while it did not matter + but the problem slowly festered + and one day poor hiawatha , + waking to a huge disaster , + found himself up to his eyeballs + in a soup of black corruption . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ he would simply pick and choose them . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s revelation + took a while to find its footing + for , as happens in such cases , + many awful misconceptions + were embedded in his thinking + where they had been put on purpose + and could only be uncovered , + if at all , through painful hours + scrutinizing tiny details , + contemplating reams of data , + finding out who s stuff was careful , + tracking down suspicious rumors , + reading through a mass of papers , + slowly tossing out the bad ones , + racking up the airline mileage + going to humongous meetings , + thereby building up a fact base + cleansed of all manipulations . + over time , as things got clearer , + hiawatha grew unhappy + trying to reconcile his viewpoint + with the facts that he had winnowed , + always finding that he could nt . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied transport + both electrical and thermal + that , one argued , showed the absence + of the landau fermi surface + symptomatic of a metal + thereby proving one was dealing + with a strange new state of matter . + but he found in every instance + that a sample made its coldest , + so one knew what one was doing , + either showed disorder problems + generated by the chemists + or agreed with classic theory . + thus , like all those dot - com profits + that they claimed would make you wealthy , + but , in fact , were nonexistent , + arguments for novel physics + built upon the facts of transport + did not hold up on inspection . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied optics + by and large his favorite spectrum + for he knew that light reflection + measured dielectric functions + in a way that used no theory , + and it showed how loose electrons + moved about and caused the bonding . + but , alas , the data varied + from one sample to another + even after years of efforts + to ensure that they were stable ! + this left lack of clear consensus + even over things that mattered . + understanding why this happened + was not really rocket science , + for the kramers - krnig process + amplified the defect signals + that were there in great abundance , + even though they all denied it , + and depended on the process + by which one prepared the sample , + something different for each grower + and a closely - guarded secret . + also , things would change with doping , + something very hard to measure + and which often was nt constant + as one moved across the sample + due to troubles in the furnace + which they claimed they d licked but had nt . + thus the stories of new physics + built upon results of optics , + like the troubled u. s. census + or the the streets of downtown boston + after weeks of too much snowing , + were polluted by disorder , + and , moreover , were deceptive + in that aspects of the spectra + that were reasonably stable + like the strange non - drude lineshapes + happened at such tiny wavelengths + one could plausibly ascribe them + to a nearby phase transition + rather than the state in question . + thus the stories were fantastic , + and , like those that richard nixon + told while he was in the white house , + or that pop star michael jackson + claimed occurred in los olivos + for the pleasure of the children , + in the end would not hold water . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the stories were fantastic . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied neutrons + which he found he liked immensely + since they flowed from a reactor + with big purple signs upon it + warning you of radiation + that would kill you if allowed to , + since the neutrons went right through you + but would sometimes choose to stop there + and decay like little time bombs , + thus inducing stomach cancer . + but they went through cuprates also , + and that made them very useful , + since a few of them would scatter , + and detecting those that did so + gave you lots of information + from down deep inside the sample , + such as how the atoms ordered , + how they moved when something hit them + and if they were little magnets . + but the bad news was the signal + was quite small and hard to measure , + so one needed a detector + bigger than a dempsey dumpster + and a truly mammoth sample , + leading to big compromises + in the sample growing process + they preferred deemphasizing + but one knew was wreaking havoc + on the meaning of the data . + they would also never tell you + what the measurement itself was , + since the neutron kinematics + made it sensitive to factors + like the speed spread of the neutrons + and the tip of the detector + and the path on which one moved things + to survey deflection angles + that were messy and annoying , + so they d first massage the data + using big computer programs + to remove these nasty factors + and report the program output , + representing you should trust it + just because they were the experts . + but , of course , there were those upgrades + and the quiet little tweaking + that one always did at run time + that one never heard reported . + once he caught these key omissions + hiawatha got suspicious , + and quite quickly found the practice + of reporting neutron spectra + in some secret custom units + given names like `` counts '' to fool you , + like those helpful content labels + found on packs of sandwich slices + listing salt and beef by - products , + thus preventing one from telling + there was very poor agreement . + all this made a clearer picture + but it also meant the data + like the air - brushed prints in _ playboy _ + were , in fact , manipulated , + and that many strange behaviors + like the famous funny phonon + dogma said was nonexistent + got removed as standard practice + on the grounds they should not be there . + thus his plan to use those spectra + to pin down the magnetism + present sometimes in the cuprates + on account of all the errors + ended up a dismal failure . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ever helpful content labels . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied currents + made when cold electrons tunnel + right across an insulator + where they should have been forbidden , + something very close to magic + rather like the twinkly transport + people undergo on star trek , + and it s also quite revealing + of important quantum pairing + that goes on inside the cuprate . + in the old days one would simply + oxidize a thin - film sample , + coat the oxide with another , + solder on two tiny contacts , + dunk the whole thing into vapors + made so cold that they were liquid , + then just measure plain resistance + of the two protruding wires , + which would vary with the voltage + thus producing useful data . + hiawtha read these papers + with a mounting sense of horror , + for the wild disagreement + even in the basic features + from one sample to another + was so large it left one breathless . + and , of course , the accusations + that the other guys were morons + who just could not make good junctions + rose to unmatched heights of grandeur + even though the real villain , + obvious from spectral sharpness , + was the sample variation . + hiawatha s indignation + escalated when he found that + over time this fact got buried + since each group soon found a method + of preparing stable samples + different from that used by others + and producing different spectra + that they marketed as products , + thus evading any need to + answer penetrating questions . + an important fact , however , + that emerged from all these studies , + was that steady lossless currents + could indeed be made to flow from + films of lead into the cuprates + if one made a pitted surface , + proving that the state of matter + operating in the cuprates + was not new and was not different . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied spectra + made when light shined on a sample + causes it to lose electrons + which fly out in all directions + and one can detect by counting , + thus obtaining information + of their status in the sample + just before the light removed them . + hiawatha saw at once that + peaks for plain undressed electrons + that were not supposed to be there + in this great new state of matter + always were and had a sharpness + at the resolution limit + of the latest new detector + for the special ones at threshold , + where one knew what one was doing . + in addition they were beaming + in a lovely fourfold pattern + with the symmetry of d - wave , + something that had been suggested + they might do if they were simple , + just like those in other metals . + thus the arguments for strangeness + based on counting these electrons + lost their force as things got better , + and in time were proved a failure . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied muons , + which he thought were even neater + than the more prosaic neutrons , + since they came from atom smashers + that could also quickly kill you + if you chose to be so careless , + but they d stop inside much better + and once there , decay to gammas + that were easily detected + since they d even go through concrete , + and , moreover , they d be beaming + in the muon s spin direction + just before it went to heaven . + thus , implanted in a cuprate + they d arrest at some location + known to no one but their maker + and precess like little searchlights , + if there was some magnetism , + thus allowing you to see it + way deep down inside the sample . + thus with knowledge of their trapping + and a batch of big detectors + one could then back out the distance + of magnetic penetration . + hiawatha found this distance + shortened with increasing doping + just as theory said should happen , + if one forced the hubbard model + not to be a quantum magnet + by just saying that it was nt , + which might well have been important + had it not been for the problem + that this depth would not continue + to decline with increased doping + but instead would turn and lengthen . + this effect was quite perplexing , + since no theory of the cuprates + even twisted hubbard models , + could account for such behavior , + for it violated sum rules , + hence one just did not discuss it . + but the meaning was transparent + if one faced the facts with courage , + for the samples were degrading + in extremes of overdoping + in some ways that were nt predicted + and , moreover , were nt detected + by techniques except for this one . + this , in turn , implied these problems + might occur at other dopings + and likewise escape detection + or , what s worse , be used to argue + that new physics was occurring + when , in fact , it was just garbage . + thus the trail blazed by muons + led out in the woods to nowhere . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ dental pamphlets make you tired . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied spin flips + that the nuclei of atoms + undergo in great big magnets + near a radio transmitter + causing them to be antennas , + which absorb with complex lineshapes + one can read if one s a genius + but not , sadly , if one is nt , + since they , by and large , consist of + just a simple blobby bell curve + with a width and displaced center , + to which one must give some meaning + not a simple undertaking . + thus the all - important knight shift + and spin - lattice relaxation , + noms de plume for width and center , + vastly different for the copper + and the oxygen of cuprates , + were the source of endless theories , + often very thought - provoking , + stunning in sophistication , + but , like all those glossy pamphlets + found in waiting rooms of dentists + urging you to practice flossing , + soon began to make you tired , + since the data mainly showed you + that the stuff was not a metal + in the sense of gold or iron + which , in fact , one knew already + and was not a revelation . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied structure + of the surfaces of cuprates + freshly cleaved inside a vacuum + so that air would not get on them + and then probed with tiny needles + one could move with great precision , + by adjusting some piezos + on which everything was standing . + what he found was quite disturbing , + for while atoms at the surface + all had unperturbed positions , + showing that the cleave succeeded , + there were also complex patterns + on the scale of twenty atoms + that appeared to be diffraction . + this behavior might have come from + atoms underneath the surface + that were missing or defective + or some novel magnetism + of a kind unknown to science , + but the thing that so upset him + was that quantum interference + of the kind that he was seeing + could not happen if the lifetimes + were as short as he had thought them , + and which had been used to argue + for a brand new state of matter . + thus he soberly concluded + that this matter was nt different + and the whole confounded story + was a misinterpretation + of a plain materials problem . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the mighty hiawatha + through the patient application + of the practices of science + tested over generations + slowly sloughed off misconceptions + and , in face of mounting failure , + sadly came to the conclusion + he d been taken to the cleaners . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ given all the clever swindles + lurking there to take our money , + that , of course , are part of living , + like a virus for pneumonia + or a hungry venus fly trap , + we must all be very thankful + that the celebrated law of murphy + strikes at random without warning + causing even brilliant concepts , + that appear completely foolproof + like distributing tobacco + or the business plan of enron , + to sometimes become derailed + due to something unexpected + one was sure could never happen , + like a lawsuit from consumers , + that requires intervention + of the most creative nature + to prevent strategic meltdown . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ sure enough , that s just what happened . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ as it turns out , the idea + that the conflict in the models + one was using for the cuprates + due to nearby phase transitions + would both hamper their solution + and engender rampant fibbing , + thus enshrining mass confusion + one would then call proof of meaning + with no need to fear exposure + had the unexpected weakness + that someone might _ solve _ the model + using tons and tons of money + and some capable computers + to a crude degree sufficient + to unmask the real problem + thus revealing the deception . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ sure enough , that s just what happened . + when the cuprates were discovered + and the whole endeavor started + one had not the slightest worry + that these guys would ever solve it , + since the accuracy needed + was not clear in the beginning , + so they uniformly low - balled + with the too - familiar outcome + that results were inconsistent . + so they quarrelled over method + and who had convergence problems + and whose code was most clairvoyant + even though a child could see that + they were different apparati , + so the test that they were working + was agreement with each other . + but , unlike the other issues + that had come and gone before it , + cuprates lingered on as timely + long enough to cause a shake - out , + for the money kept increasing + even as machines got cheaper + and their power kept on growing + due , of course , to needs of gaming , + rather than the ones of lanczos + or the quantum monte carlo + that one used for basic physics . + so the robots kept on plugging + as their owners upped the ante + very slowly , as did wagner + when composing _ ring _ and _ tristan _ + and their stuff began converging ! + there , of course , was no agreement + over matters of the phases + such as whether it conducted + when one cooled it down to zero , + since a crystal of electrons + was one state in competition . + but at length scales one could access + there was clearly dissipation + of a most peculiar nature + in the dielectric function + and the quantum magnetism , + just exactly as predicted + by an ancient bunch of papers + over quantum phase transitions , + which these guys had never studied + since it was too esoteric + and had not been seen in nature + and was hated by their funders . + but the thing that really clinched it + was the endless disagreement , + that got worse as things proceeded + and was very clearly cronic , + over type and shape of edges + that would best produce convergence , + since one found that subtle changes + in the way one built the model + would turn on and off the striping + and therefore the insulation , + so that whether it was present + in the limit of large sample + simply could not be determined + with the codes that they had written . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ soon their stuff began converging . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this , of course , was a disaster + for the plan to keep things murky + and required drastic action + to somehow repair the damage + all this progress had created , + and prevent these guys from seeing + what was right beneath their noses . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ and one was not disappointed . + once again a flash of brilliance + like a great big city - buster + brighter than the sun at midday , + blazed across the dome of heaven + toward its final destination + in the guinness book of records . + they declared the problem _ over _ ! + the computer guys had solved it ! + for their codes had proved the cuprates + were indeed the hubbard model , + and that s why the stuff conducted . + thus there was no urgent reason + to pursue the matter further ! + one could zero out their budgets + with no loss to human knowledge + and , in fact , perhaps improve it + since this money was incentive + to continue calculations + that were clearly unimportant + and report them in the journals + thus just adding to the clutter . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , now much wiser + through his labors as a scholar + and , quite frankly , some maturing + watched these things unfold before him , + as he had on past occasions , + but this time with eyes wide open + and was filled with understanding . + it was not a happy moment , + for it meant that his own judgement + as to what was good and worthy + had been faulty from the outset , + something for which he must answer . + but instead of indignation + and a passion to get even + that he might have felt when younger + hiawatha , deep in thinking , + found himself consumed with sadness . + he was not the only victim , + for the guys who manned those robots , + and were heroes of the cuprates + for through focussed dedication + they had stumbled on the answer + that the models were unstable + and did _ not _ describe the cuprates , + since a modest perturbation + would profoundly change their nature + were about to have their triumph + snatched from them by clever scoundrels + who , pretending to befriend them , + would then redefine their output + to mean something that it did nt , + thus protecting their investment , + but , of course , destroying others . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s knowing sadness , + like the darkening at twilight + or a gathering storm in winter , + slowly gained in strength and deepened + as he spent time in reflection , + working through the implications + of the things that he had witnessed + for the cause of noble science + that thus far had so beguiled him . + it would simply not be manly + to pretend he was nt guilty + of ignoring frequent warnings + that the needed path to nature + was obscured or nonexistent . + it was clear that he d been foolish + to have bought this awful fiction + and that blame must fall quite squarely + on himself and not on others . + but this candid _ mea culpa _ , + made in silence where it mattered , + while it comforted his conscience , + did not quite assuage the wounding , + for it begged the nagging question + of how they could have succeeded + in hoodwinking all the people + for so long without some doubting . + it was simply not an option + to presume these guys were stupid , + since the instruments they dealt with , + often built by hand from nothing , + needed great sophistication + to deploy and mine for data . + there was clearly something larger + and extremely fundamental + working in the group dynamic + that involved access to funding + and the policy of journals + and the need to service markets + and the mythos of the subject + one must use to make a living + that these crooks had first deciphered , + then reduced with understanding , + then usurped to do their bidding . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , turning inward , + thought for weeks about this problem + during which he was obnoxious + due to his preoccupation . + but at last he got an answer + that made sense and was quite simple , + thus withstanding occam s razor , + so he thought that he believed it . + when he d set out on his mission + he had understood the challenge + of the mastery of nature + but not basic economics + and the fact that art and science + both require sacrifices + of a clear financial nature + that one sometimes just ca nt handle + nor , in fairness , should one do so + since a good guy pays the mortgage + and supports the kids in college + and the other things a body + has to do to keep the lights on . + but , in fact , the compromises + that one makes as part of living + such as saying what one has to + for maintaining healthy cash flow + often toss big monkey wrenches + in the fine machine of science + and can stop it altogether + in conflicted situations . + then the body , badly weakened , + barely able to keep breathing , + gets exploited by diseases , + such as villains lacking scruples + who descend on it like termites + to a house that s been neglected , + wreaking terrible destruction + on the lives of those affected . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the conclusion of this story + is well known from all the textbooks . + hiawatha never wavered + in his deep respect for physics , + but he came by this adventure + to the deeper understanding + that to get things done that mattered + often was a social question , + not just logical abstraction , + and , as well , a part of nature , + just the thing he thought he d hated + and had thrilled at desecrating + as a tender freshman student + in the little private college + by the shores of gitchee - gumee . + it was true that all the creatures + living in those swamps and woodlands + generated lots of pooping , + but then so did real people , + and the people poop was stronger , + so that one could not ignore it . + but one really would not want to , + for the lesson of the cuprates + was that lack of understanding + of these basic group dynamics , + was a recipe for failure + since they were the central issue + for most things that were essential . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the mighty hiawatha + turned his mind to other problems + such as how to use resources + that were his by luck and birthright + through the power of his father + which he d been inclined to squander , + but now realized he should nt . + thus he studied like a madman + to acquire the skills of statecraft , + such as how to plan a project , + how to give effective orders , + how to make sure they were followed , + how to get things done with meetings , + and to leave the money grubbing + up to folks his father hired + such as all those gifted spin docs + who created key revisions + necessary for his image + to be something people honored . + thus the pain of too much sliding + on the ice in dead of winter + in an inexpensive loincloth + and his other misadventures + got removed , as did the cuprates , + from his long official story . + but the memory persisted + and it helped to make him wiser + for , of course , as he got older + he had many bad encounters + not so different from the cuprates . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ but whenever he was troubled + with a problem that would vex him + he would cheer himself by thinking + of the special room in hades + into which these happy people + on account of their transgressions + would be ushered when they bagged it + and be stuck in there forever , + forced to listen to each other + giving lectures on the cuprates . + it would always leave him smiling . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the oort cloud @xcite remains the most mysterious part of our solar system , primarily because it can not be directly observed . our only observational clues to the size , shape , mass and composition of the oort cloud come from observations of long - period comets . the demographics of observed long - period comets have been the starting point of almost all attempts to model the oort cloud ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . until the last ten or so years , the vast majority of comets were discovered by systematic eyeball searches , using small telescopes @xcite . these surveys have been highly effective at identifying large samples of comets , and in deriving their orbital parameters . they do , however , have three major drawbacks : * unknown selection function : it is very unclear how often different parts of the sky are surveyed , and to what depth . surveys are clearly more sensitive to comets with bright absolute magnitudes and perihelia close to the earth , but the strength of this effect is very hard to estimate @xcite . * limited range of comets observed : eyeball surveys find few comets fainter than an absolute magnitude of 10 and with perihelia beyond 3au . * poorly defined photometry : these surveys quote the `` total brightness '' of a comet . total cometary magnitudes are notoriously unreliable . they are typically measured by defocussing a standard star to the same apparent size as the comet , but this apparent size is heavily dependent on observing conditions and observational set - up . despite these drawbacks , many attempts have been made to derive the basic parameters of the long period comet population from eyeball - selected historic samples . the most heroic and influential attempt was that of @xcite . everhart carried out an exhaustive analysis of the historical circumstances in which comets were discovered , over a 127 year period . he developed a model for the sensitivity of the human eye , and used it to calculate the period over which a given historical comet could have been seen . this was then used to estimate the completeness of the comet sample : if a given type of comet was typically seen early in its visibility window , surveys should be complete for this type of comet . if the mean time to find a given type of comet is , however , comparable to the length of the estimated visibility window , the completeness is probably low . using this method , everhart estimated that for every comet seen , another 31 were missed . a more modest and recent attempt was that of @xcite . he restricted himself to the brightest and nearest comets , for which he claimed ( on the basis of discovery trends ) historical surveys were highly complete . the statistics of these comets were simply extrapolated to larger perihelia and fainter absolute magnitudes , with no correction for observational incompleteness . as one would expect , the flux of long - period comets through the inner solar system estimated by @xcite is much lower that that estimated by @xcite . despite these attempts , several basic questions about the demographics of long - period comets remain unresolved . one question concerns small comets @xcite : those with nuclear radii less than @xmath0 km ( absolute magnitudes @xmath1 ) . extrapolating the everhart data implies that there should be a large population of such comets . @xcite was unable to tell whether his model predicted a large population of such comets or not . a second question concerns the number of comets per unit perihelion . @xcite found that this number rises from the sun out to 1au , but was unable to determine whether it keeps rising at larger perihelia . @xcite found no significant rise , but had large enough error bars to bracket both of everhart s possibilities . the observational situation has changed radically in the last few years . the advent of large format sensitive ccds has allowed automated surveys to supplant eyeball searches as the main mechanism for finding new long - period comets . most long period comets are now being found as by - products of various automated searches for near - earth objects , such as the lincoln near - earth asteroid research ( linear ) project @xcite , the catalina sky survey , loneos and neat @xcite . many are also found by space - based coronagraphs as they approach very close to the sun @xcite , though these are mostly fragments of recently disintegrated larger comets @xcite . in this paper , i attempt to deduce the statistical properties of the long - period comet population from one of these ccd surveys : the linear survey . this has a far better defined selection criterion than any historical eyeball survey , and extends to much larger perihelia and fainter absolute magnitudes . it thus allows both an independent check and an extension of previous estimates of the long - period comet population . near earth asteroid ( neo ) surveys are not optimized for comet detection . while they find many long - period comets , they do not publish their raw data , nor all the details one would like of their exact detection algorithms and sky coverage . in particular , they do not publish on - going photometry of the comets they discover . nonetheless , enough information is available to make a first pass at estimating the true population of long - period comets from their data . there have been previous attempts to use these surveys to detemine the true populations of neos ( eg . * ? ? ? * ) and dormant comets @xcite , but this paper is the first attempt of which i am aware to do this for active comets . in the next few years , the situation should further improve , with the advent of a new generation of wide - field survey telescopes , such as skymapper , pan - starrs @xcite and gaia @xcite . these surveys will predominantly find comets much fainter and more distant than historical surveys . the analysis in this paper allows a first estimate of just how many long - period comets these surveys can find , and how best to identify them . i start off by defining a sample of comets drawn from the linear sample , and examining its properties , which are very different from those of eyeball samples ( [ sample ] ) . a model of the long - period comet population is then generated ( [ model ] ) based on and extrapolating the historical eyeball - selected surveys . a monte - carlo simulation of this comet population as it would be observed by linear is then developed ( [ montecarlo ] ) . the results are compared to the observed sample in [ compmodels ] : i find that the hughes model is quite a good fit to the data , but that the everhart model is not . i derive my own best - fit model of long - period comet demographics . the consequences of this new model are many : i examine them in [ discussion ] before drawing conclusions in [ conc ] . of the several near - earth asteroid surveys now under - way , the lincoln near - earth asteroid research ( linear ) project @xcite was most suitable for constraining the long - period comet population . this is because : * they discover more comets than any other single survey . * they publish sky charts on their web page showing the area of the sky observed during each lunation , with the point - source magnitude limit reached at each location . * their sky coverage and magnitude limit is relatively simple and uniform across this period . the comet sample was defined as follows : 1 . the comet has an orbital period longer than 200 years . 2 . the comet reached perihelion between 2000 jan 1 and 2002 dec 31 . the comet was either discovered by linear between these dates , or could have been discovered by linear between these dates had it not already been discovered by someone else , or discovered prior to 2000 jan 1 . the 2000 - 2002 date range was chosen because comet details ( from the catalog of cometary orbits , * ? ? ? * ) and sky - maps ( including limiting magnitudes ) are available . @xcite listed 25 comets as having been discovered or co - discovered by linear which met our criteria . i needed , however , to add two additional sub - samples : * comets discovered prior to 2000 , but which reach perihelion in the period 2000 - 2002 , and which could have been first discovered by linear within this period , had they not already been found . * comets discovered in 2000 - 2002 inclusive by other surveys , but which would subsequently have been seen by linear during this period . potential members of the two additional sub - samples were selected from @xcite . each candidate was checked for its detectability by linear , using the ephemerides and predicted magnitudes generated by the minor planet center . the predicted positions and brightnesses were compared to the maps of linear sky coverage . these maps show only the integrated coverage per lunation , not the night - by - night or hour - by - hour coverage , but most of these comets move slowly enough that this should nt much matter . this process added another 27 comets to our sample . 8 had been detected by linear during 1999 , but reached perihelion in 2000 or 2001 . most of the remainder were first identified by other near - earth asteroid surveys , particularly the catalina sky survey , loneos and neat . for every comet in our final sample , the original discovery details ( as distributed by the central bureau of astronomical telegrams ) were checked . from these , the discovery date , discovery magnitude @xmath2 and discovery circumstances were noted . the discovery magnitudes are total magnitudes ( m1 ) . it is not clear how reliable and homogeneous these magnitudes are , but no better source of ccd photometry is available . they are based on ccd observations by professional astronomers of typically barely resolved objects , and so should be good to @xmath3mag . absolute magnitudes @xmath4 were computed from these discovery magnitudes @xmath2 . the standard equation was used : @xmath5 ( eg . * ? ? ? * ) , where @xmath2 is the observed total magnitude at discovery and @xmath6 a power - law parameterization of the dependence on heliocentric distance . as is conventional for solar system work , the absolute magnitude is defined as the observed magnitude if the object were at a distance of 1 au from both the earth and the sun . following @xcite , the dynamically new and old comets were treated differently ( the new ones are much brighter at large heliocentric radii , at least on their way in ) . a comet is classed as dynamically new if its original semi - major axis @xmath7 is @xmath8 10,000 au , old if @xmath9 10,000 au , and undetermined if the orbit class in @xcite is ii or worse . for new comets , @xmath10 was used if they are seen pre - perihelion and @xmath11 if seen afterward . for old comets , the values are 5.0 and 3.5 respectively . the canonical value of @xmath12 is used for comets of undetermined orbit type . this is uncertain both because real comets show a dispersion in @xmath6 , and because the @xmath6 values in @xcite are based on observations at smaller heliocentric distances . it is , however , self - consistent with the analysis used in our monte - carlo simulations . our sample is listed in table [ sampletab ] . lcccc c/1999 f1 & 5.7869 & 7.82 & 0.000038 & 1a + c/1999 j2 & 7.1098 & 6.39 & 0.000019 & 1a + c/1999 k5 & 3.2558 & 9.75 & 0.000024 & 1a + c/1999 k8 & 4.2005 & 6.33 & 0.000681 & 1a + c/1999 l3 & 1.9889 & 10.21 & 0.013741 & 1b + c/1999 n4 & 5.5047 & 9.99 & 0.000068 & 1a + c/1999 s4 & 0.7651 & 7.84 & 0.000720 & ii + c/1999 t1 & 1.1717 & 4.36 & 0.000173 & ii + c/1999 t2 & 3.0374 & 6.05 & 0.000596 & 1a + c/1999 t3 & 5.3657 & 5.12 & 0.000231 & 1b + c/1999 u4 & 4.9153 & 7.60 & 0.000037 & 1a + c/1999 y1 & 3.0912 & 9.80 & 0.000044 & 1a + c/2000 a1 & 9.7431 & 8.13 & 0.000044 & 1a + c/2000 ct54 & 3.1561 & 10.71 & 0.000051 & 1a + c/2000 h1 & 3.6366 & 10.29 & & + c/2000 j1 & 2.4371 & 12.62 & 0.001406 & 1a + c/2000 o1 & 5.9218 & 7.03 & 0.000037 & 1a + c/2000 of8 & 2.1731 & 14.07 & 0.000048 & 1b + c/2000 sv74 & 3.5416 & 9.40 & 0.000090 & 1a + c/2000 u5 & 3.4852 & 9.88 & 0.000358 & 1a + c/2000 w1 & 0.3212 & 10.44 & & + c/2000 wm1 & 0.5553 & 6.81 & -0.000459 & ii + c/2000 y1 & 7.9747 & 9.54 & 0.000063 & 1a + c/2000 y2 & 2.7687 & 9.65 & 0.001934 & 1b + c/2001 a1 & 2.4062 & 10.71 & 0.005738 & 2a + c/2001 a2 & 0.7790 & 14.22 & 0.000447 & ii + c/2001 b1 & 2.9280 & 11.14 & 0.000071 & 1b + c/2001 b2 & 5.3065 & 5.60 & 0.000187 & 1b + c/2001 c1 & 5.1046 & 10.30 & 0.000020 & 1a + c/2001 g1 & 8.2356 & 7.45 & 0.000024 & 1a + c/2001 ht50 & 2.7921 & 3.15 & 0.000878 & 1a + c/2001 k3 & 3.0601 & 9.80 & 0.000072 & 1b + c/2001 k5 & 5.1843 & 8.10 & 0.000029 & 1a + c/2001 n2 & 2.6686 & 5.77 & 0.000455 & 1a + c/2001 rx14 & 2.0576 & 6.06 & 0.000776 & 1a + c/2001 s1 & 3.7500 & 11.36 & 0.018168 & + c/2001 u6 & 4.4064 & 7.42 & 0.000998 & 1a + c/2001 w1 & 2.3995 & 14.04 & & + c/2001 x1 & 1.6976 & 12.54 & 0.002285 & 2a + c/2002 b2 & 3.8430 & 10.12 & & + c/2002 b3 & 6.0525 & 7.92 & & + c/2002 c2 & 3.2538 & 8.88 & 0.000393 & 1b + c/2002 e2 & 1.4664 & 10.34 & 0.000173 & 1b + c/2002 h2 & 1.6348 & 13.29 & 0.004024 & 2a + c/2002 k2 & 5.2378 & 7.62 & & + c/2002 l9 & 7.0316 & 5.60 & 0.000035 & 2a + c/2002 o4 & 0.7762 & 13.59 & -0.000772 & 2a + c/2002 p1 & 6.5307 & 8.55 & 0.002023 & 2a + c/2002 q2 & 1.3062 & 16.09 & & + c/2002 q5 & 1.2430 & 16.59 & 0.000058 & 1b + c/2002 u2 & 1.2086 & 14.63 & 0.001075 & 1b + the linear sample has very different properties from historical samples ( as typified by the everhart sample ) . figure [ everhart_compare ] shows that the linear sample extends around 4 magnitudes deeper , and to much larger perihelia . the overlap is small : only @xmath13 of the linear comets lie within the absolute magnitude and perihelion region sampled by historical samples . analysis of the discovery telegrams indicates that almost all of the comets in the sample were originally identified as moving point sources . they were posted on the near earth object ( neo ) confirmation page at the minor planet center . follow - up observations then determined that the sources were spatially extended and hence comets . 77% were discovered before reaching perihelion ( fig [ discover_hist ] ) , and 73% were were first detected when more than 3au from the sun . the necessity for follow - up potentially introduces two sources of incompleteness into this sample . firstly , some fraction of objects posted on the neo confirmation page are never followed up in enough detail to determine whether they are comets or not . timothy spahr kindly provided records of all objects posted to the neo confirmation page in 2000 - 2002 . only 11% of these were not followed - up well enough to determine an orbit : this places an upper limit on the fractional incompleteness of our sample due to failed follow - up . this is probably a conservative upper limit : most of these lost objects were most likely either not real to begin with or fast - moving objects only visible for a short window of time . secondly , some comets might have been inactive at these large heliocentric distances , and hence classified as minor planets . the minor planet centre database was checked for non - cometary objects on long - period , highly eccentric orbits , but only one was found which reached perihelion within the period 2000 - 2002 : 2002 rn109 . thus this too is not a major source of incompleteness . it also shows that most comets down to the linear magnitude limit are still active out to 10au from the sun . fig [ q_a ] shows an intriguing correlation between perihelion distance and semi - major axis in the linear sample . this correlation was first noted by @xcite at smaller perihelia . they suggested that it was a selection effect . dynamically new comets are brighter at large heliocentric radii ( eg . * ? ? ? * ) , presumably due to extra outgassing at large heliocentric distances from their relatively pristine surfaces , due perhaps to @xmath14 or a water ice phase transition . the whipple data did not extend to distances beyond 4au from the sun . if this trend continues to larger heliocentric distances , however , it would make dynamically new comets far brighter than older comets with the same absolute magnitude . this could thus , in principle , bias the sample heavily towards new comets , and hence larger semi - major axes . the distribution of perihelion positions is shown in fig [ peripos ] . the comets are weakly concentrated at intermediate galactic latitudes ( fig [ bhist ] ) , consistent with the galactic tide playing a major part in making them observable @xcite . the galactic latitude distribution is not , however , significantly different from the predictions of a best - fit model ( [ best ] ) assuming a random distribution , as measured by the kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test or the kuiper statistic . there are also no significant great - circle alignments @xcite . the linear comet sample was compared against a monte - carlo simulation of the long period comet distribution . in this section i discuss the parameters used in this simulation . the @xcite and @xcite studies are based on comets with a limited range of perihelion distances q and hence give only weak constraints on this distribution . everhart found a factor of two rise in the number of comets per unit perihelion between 0 and 1 au , but beyond that the data are consistent either with a continuing rise or a flat distribution . hughes found no significant trend in number of comets against perihelion , but his data are quite consistent with such a trend . on theoretical grounds , however , a gentle rise in the number of comets as a function of perihelion is expected , as comets diffuse into the solar system past the barrier of giant planet perturbations ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? as a first guess , i chose to model the perihelion distribution as an unbroken straight line : @xmath15 where @xmath16 gives a reasonable fit to the @xcite distribution . the @xcite slope is shallower , but only shown out to 3au . the distribution of semi - major axes @xmath7 makes no significant difference to the conclusions , as the comets are all very close to being on parabolic orbits . i chose to randomly class 40% of comets as dynamically new and given them all @xmath1720,000 , while the remainder were given a value of @xmath7 randomly and uniformly distributed between 1000 and 20,000 au . the time of perihelion passage , orbital inclination and perihelion direction were randomly chosen to give a uniform distribution on the celestial sphere . this ignores possible great - circle alignments @xcite and galactic tidal effects @xcite . @xcite found that the absolute magnitude distribution of comets was best fit by a broken power - law , with the break at @xmath18 . @xcite also found a break at about the same absolute magnitude , but was unable to decide whether it was a real break or simply the effect of increasingly incomplete samples at fainter magnitudes . to bracket the possibilities , i use a broken power - law of the form . @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the break magnitude , @xmath21 is the bright end slope and @xmath22 is the faint end slope . everhart gives @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 . hughes gives @xmath26 and @xmath27 . if i assume that his observed break is real and not an artefact of sample incompleteness , his plots imply a faint end slope of @xmath28 , which i adopt to bracket the possibilities . this version of the hughes formulation thus predicts dramatically fewer faint comets , as would be expected as these are the ones for which everhart applies the largest incompleteness correction fraction . @xcite and @xcite give different estimates of the long - period comet flux through the inner solar system . everhart estimates a flux of 8000 comets with @xmath29 and @xmath30 over 127 years . hughes estimates a flux of 0.53 comets per year brighter than @xmath31 per unit perihelion . i ran the simulations using both . for a given model comet population , the aim is to simulate the observable properties of a sample that matches the selection effects of the linear sample . the simulation starts off by generating a set of comets that reach perihelion within a three year period . the comets are randomly generated using the model distributions in the previous section . the model extends down to @xmath32 and out to @xmath33 . i generated two model populations : one using the everhart absolute magnitude distribution and flux , the other using the hughes absolute magnitude distribution and flux . in the everhart model 260,000 comets are generated , while only 4,000 are needed in the hughes model . the position of each comet is then calculated at 24 hour intervals throughout the three year period , and its heliocentric distance @xmath34 , distance from the earth @xmath35 , apparent celestial coordinates and apparent angular velocity written to file . pure elliptical orbits are used : no attempt is made to allow for planetary perturbations . at each location , the apparent total magnitude is then calculated . comets are notoriously variable in how rapidly their apparent magnitude varies as a function of heliocentric distance . i parameterize this , as is conventional , using equation [ eqabsmag ] . two values of @xmath6 are randomly assigned to each comet : one for before perihelion and another for after . for the 40% of our simulated comets that i set as dynamically new , the pre - perihelion value of @xmath6 is chosen from a gaussian distribution of mean 2.44 and standard deviation 0.3 . post - perihelion , the mean is 3.35 with a scatter of 0.27 . for the remaining comets , the pre - perihelion numbers are 5.0 with a scatter of 0.8 , and after perihelion 3.5 with a scatter of 0.5 . all these values are taken from @xcite . at large distances from the sun , cometary activity will presumably stop , and a bare nucleus will have @xmath36 . the near - ubiquitous detection of fuzz around the linear comets implies , however , that this only happens further from the sun than our models reach . this approach can only be a rough approximation to the real radial brightness dependence . the value of @xmath6 for an individual comet is typically time dependent , and all the tabulated values are for comets within @xmath37 au of the sun , whereas our simulation tracks them out beyond 10au . in addition , comets show occasional flares above and beyond this power - law behavior , which i have not attempted to model . such flares might introduce an amplification bias , with comets being pushed over the detection threshold . as we will see , however , the slope of the absolute magnitude distribution is so gentle that this is unlikely to be a major effect . the apparent total magnitude of each simulated comet can now be calculated at any given point in its orbit . unfortunately , in any ccd - based survey , it is the peak surface brightness of the coma that determines whether something has been seen , not the total magnitude . the linear skymaps , furthermore , list only the magnitude limit _ for a point source _ at any given location on the sky ( typically around 19 ) . as discussed in the introduction , total cometary magnitudes are notoriously unreliable . quantitative studies prefer more reproducible and physically meaningful parameters such as @xmath38 ( eg . * ? ? ? unfortunately , not enough long period comets have been studied in this way to derive the @xmath39 distribution . we are therefore forced to attempt some conversion between total magnitudes and point - source equivalent magnitudes . for bright and near - by comets , this correction can be as large as @xmath13 magnitudes ( eg . * ? ? ? the comets in the linear sample were , however , typically first seen when very faint ( fig [ maghist ] ) , and were generally mistaken for point sources in the initial observation . we might therefore expect the correction factor to be much smaller , at least when close to the detection threshold . the histogram of detection magnitudes ( fig [ maghist ] ) climbs steeply down to @xmath40 , and then falls off fast ( the one comet discovered when fainter than 20th mag was found by spacewatch , which has a fainter magnitude limit ) . this fall - off occurs at almost exactly the same magnitudes as linear s point source limit , which ranged from around 18 to 20 . i thus conclude that near the linear detection threshold , total magnitudes and point source equivalent magnitudes are similar . when generating mock samples , it is only the magnitude near the detection threshold that determines whether or not a given model comet is included in the mock catalog . the exact value of this correction value was set iteratively . i initially guess that the point - source equivalent ( pse ) magnitude and total magnitude ( tm ) are the same , and run the simulations of the comet sample . i use the model that best fits the data ( [ best ] ) to calculate the predicted discovery magnitude distribution , and compare this to the observed distribution . i then tweak the pse@xmath41tm correction to bring the histograms into agreement . the best match is obtained when pse@xmath41tm@xmath42 ( fig [ maghist ] ) . i use a value of @xmath43 throughout this paper , except where otherwise noted . the predicted magnitude is corrected for the effects of trailing . linear exposure times vary from 3 to 12 sec : the latter was used in the correction as it minimised the predicted number of very faint comets . 2 seeing ( fwhm ) was assumed . trailing makes very little difference , except for the very faintest comets . linear uses unfiltered ccd magnitudes while the historical surveys use unfiltered visual magnitudes . these will be somewhat different , due to the different wavelength sensitivity of the human eye and of the linear ccds , but the discrepancy should only be a few tenths of a magnitude at most , and hence is not a dominant source of error . anoher possible worry : the absolute magnitudes i quote for the comets in the linear sample ( table [ sampletab ] ) are derived from total magnitudes measured when the comets were barely resolved and far from the sun , using a model for the heliocentric brightness variation . the absolute magnitudes fit by everhart and hughes are based on observations of highly extended comets observed close to the sun and earth . these are thus very different quantities , and might well be systematically different , if there is some error in our heliocentric brightness correction , if total magnitudes for barely resolved comets are systematicaly different from total magnitudes for greatly extended comets , or if there is some systematic bias in the discovery magnitudes reported to the central bureau of astronomical telegrams . to test this , i picked out the five comets in the linear sample which were discovered when far ( more than 3.5 au ) from the sun , but which subsequently passed close enough to the earth and sun for traditional small telescope visual magnitude estimates ( within 2au ) . dan green kindly provided me with compilations of visual magnitude estimates of these comets while they were close to the earth and sun , taken from the archives of the international comet quarterly . these visual / small telescope magnitude estimates should be broadly comparable to the data on which the everhart and hughes papers were based . i then compared the predicted magnitudes when close to the sun ( based on the discovery magnitude and the model in this paper ) with the tabulated observations . there was a considerable scatter in the measured visual magnitudes for each comet : i simply averaged all visual small telescope magnitudes made when the comet was as close as possible to 1au from both sun and earth . my predicted magnitudes were consistent with the observed values , albeit with a large scatter . the mean difference ( predicted magnitude minus observed magnitude ) was @xmath44 , where the error indicates the @xmath45 dispersion of the mean . this is not , alas , a strong constraint , but does indicate that the two magnitude scales are not grossly discrepant . the final step is to determine whether linear imaged a part of the sky in which the comet was detectable and within its magnitude limit . the published linear skymaps show that during each dark period in 2000 - 2002 , they attempted to survey the region whose midnight hour angle is in the range @xmath46 , and in the declination range @xmath47 . in winter months with good weather , they surveyed more than 90% of this whole region down to a point - source magnitude limit of better than 19 . in bad months , this dropped to a magnitude limit of around 18.5 over 60% of this region , and occasionally worse . in the mean month , 72% of this region was surveyed to a visual magnitude limit of 18.5 or better . the exact pattern surveyed was complex and variable : the only constant was that the densest regions of the galactic plane were avoided . each field was imaged five times in succession , with 3 12 sec per exposure , once in every dark period . this sky coverage was approximated as follows . each comet that enters the @xmath46 , @xmath47 region at any point , with a point - source equivalent ( pse ) magnitude brighter than 19 is considered to have been potentially observable , unless it was within ten degrees of the galactic plane . if a comet is predicted to be detectable for an entire lunation , it is given a 80% chance of having been detected during that lunation . if it was predicted to be visible for less than the whole lunation , it is given a probability of having been detected equal to 80% of the fraction of the lunation for which is was potentially observable . does this approximation match the real , more complex selection function ? this was tested by manually checking 100 simulated comet ephemerides , containing monthly positions and magnitudes , against the real linear sky - maps . the approximation was found to give a number and absolute magnitude distribution of detected comets indistinguishable from the manually checked sample . this approach should slightly overestimate the probability of a comet being observed , as comets could be blended with star or galaxy images . experience suggests that at this relatively bright magnitude limit , this is only a few percent effect at worst , at least away from the denser regions of the galactic plane , which the survey did not cover . another possible source of error is sky subtraction . it is unclear exactly how the linear survey do their sky subtraction , but if some of the extended coma emission is included in the sky value , this will artificially suppress the point source equivalent magnitude . the worst case sky subtraction algorithm would be to measure the sky brightness from an annulus close to the comet nucleus . if i assume that the sky is measured only 5 from the nucleus ( unlikely ) , we can used the observed @xmath48 surface brightness profiles of cometary comae @xcite to show that this sky subtraction algorithm would reduce the measured comet brightness by @xmath49 mag . more plausible sky subtraction schemes would reduce it by less , or not at all . thus this too is not a dominant source of error . in this section , i compare the data to the monte - carlo simulations of what linear would have seen over a three year period . in the scatter plots , the data are compared to a single run of the simulation . in all histograms and quoted statistics , however , the data are compared against the average or sum ( as appropriate ) of five monte - carlo runs based on the same comet population model . this summation should suppress the error due to small number statistics in the simulated samples to well below that of the observed sample . the observed sample properties are first compared against the monte - carlo prediction using the @xcite flux normalization and absolute magnitude distribution . figs [ complot_eve ] , [ qhist ] and [ hhist ] compare the distribution of model and observed comets in perihelion @xmath50 and absolute magnitude @xmath4 . the upper boundary to the locus of points is set by the magnitude limit , and seems a reasonable fit to the data . but the model clearly predicts far too many comets : 2228 as compared to the 52 observed . the discrepancy is primarily at fainter absolute magnitudes : brighter than @xmath51 the model and data are consistent . the worst discrepancy is for comets fainter than @xmath52 : ie . fainter than the data on which everhart based his model . it is thus a test of the power - law extrapolation . the model predicts that linear should have seen 1848 comets fainter than @xmath53 , whereas only 12 were seen . irrespective of the flux normalization , the shape of the absolute magnitude distribution ( fig [ hhist ] ) is wrong : a ks - test comparison with the observed distribution shows that they are inconsistent with @xmath54 confidence . is this discrepancy real , or is there some reason why linear would miss faint comets close to the earth ? the model comets with @xmath55 are predicted to be observable for a median period of 52 days , at a median distance from the earth of @xmath56 au . their typical apparent angular velocity is predicted to be @xmath57 degrees per day . their observational properties are thus typical of near earth objects , which linear finds in profusion . it is thus hard to see what selection effect could prevent their detection . grant stokes ( personal communication ) confirms that there is nothing in their data analysis which should preclude the discovery of comets like these . image trailing and short observability windows do reduce the number of these comets seen , but these are already taken into account by the monte - carlo simulation . could the discrepancy be an artifact of the various approximations made in the model ? the discrepancy is insensitive to assumptions about the dependence of brightness or comet number on heliocentric distance , as these sources are observed at close to 1au . one possibility is that i have incorrectly estimated the effective magnitude limit of linear for sources with these apparent total magnitudes . to test this , i repeated the analysis with a magnitude limit set two magnitudes brighter than my best estimate . this reduced the discrepancy but did not remove it : the prediction dropped to 577 observed comets fainter than @xmath58 , still more than two orders of magnitude above the data . none of the plausible incompletenesses in the data , nor other assumptions in the model can come close to removing this discrepancy . i therefore conclude that the everhart model can not be extrapolated to absolute magnitudes fainter than @xmath58 . even at brighter absolute magnitudes , however , there remains a substantial discrepancy . the model predicts that 188 comets with @xmath59 and @xmath60 should have entered the solar system within the three year period , and that 86% of them ( 162 ) would have been detected by linear . only 21 such comets were observed . it is hard to see that linear could have missed many comets this bright passing this close to the sun . the model predicts that these comets should remain visible for a median 208 days ( 7 lunations ) , so almost regardless of position on the sky , they should have had several opportunities to be observed . they spend much of this time many magnitudes above the survey detection limit . indeed , the 21 comets observed with these properties were discovered a median 11 months before perihelion , at a median heliocentric distance of 4.3au , confirming that these are easy targets . the discrepancy occurs mostly at the fainter magnitudes within this range : brighter than @xmath51 there is no significant difference between the everhart predictions and the linear observations . i conclude , therefore , that the everhart model fails in two ways . firstly , the quoted normalization of 8,000 comets per 127 years with @xmath29 and @xmath60 is too high by a factor of @xmath61 . secondly , the faint end slope of the everhart absolute magnitude relation is much too steep , and immensely over - predicts the number of faint comets . this second conclusion was first reached by @xcite : the current paper independently confirms their result . both discrepancies suggest that everhart overestimated the incompleteness of his sample of long - period comets . the discrepancy goes away where the incompleteness correction is small , but is largest at the faint magnitudes where the correction is large . a discrepancy here is perhaps not surprising , as the correction factors calculated by everhart were so large : he corrected the 256 observed comets to a flux of 8000 : a factor of 31 . my analysis reduces this correction factor to only @xmath62 . one possible reason for the difference : everhart calculated the detection threshold for typical historical comet searchers , and assumed that the same threshold applied when searching for comets initially , and when making follow - up observations of known comets . his model was validated by noting that the last observations of comets occurred close to the time when his model suggested that they dropped below detectability . but let us hypothesize that comets just above the detection threshold might be missed as the telescope speeds past during a scan for new comets , even though they could be detected when looking hard for an already known comet at a known position . this would reduce the length of time over which a given comet could have been detected . detections would thus have occurred earlier in the detectability window , and the correction factor for incompleteness would thus decrease . i now compare the data against a monte - carlo simulation using my version of the @xcite absolute magnitude distribution and normalization , combined with the linearly rising perihelion distribution ( figs [ qhist ] , [ hhist ] , [ complot_hug ] ) . once again , the overall envelope of points agrees well with the model , giving some confidence that the selection effects have been modeled correctly . the predictions from the hughes model are in much better agreement with the data . there is no vast excess of faint predicted comets , implying that the break seen in hughes data was real , and hence that the flatter faint - end slope of the absolute magnitude distribution is more accurate . neither the perihelion nor absolute magnitude distributions , however , are formally consistent with the observations at the 99% confidence level , as measured by the ks - test . the overall flux normalization is also too high : the model predicts that linear should have seen 171 comets , rather than the 52 observed . there is no significant discrepancy within the region in which hughes quoted his flux normalization ( 0.54 comets per year with @xmath63 per unit perihelion ) : the discrepancy is at fainter absolute magnitudes and larger perihelia . once again the discrepancy is fairly robust against the exact detection limit : dropping the detection threshold by a magnitude reduces the predicted comet numbers to 148 - still too high . how can this discrepancy be addressed ? possible incompletenesses in the linear sample were discussed in [ prop ] and they can at best increase the observed numbers by @xmath64% . the hughes flux normalization is unlikely to be too low , as it was based on observed counts of very bright comets and made no correction for incompleteness . i therefore tried to improve the match by tinkering with the absolute magnitude and perihelion distributions . i first tried reducing the faint end slope of the absolute magnitude relation . if we assume that the linear sample is 20% incomplete , we need to reduce the faint end slope from 1.07 down to 0.8 to bring the number of predicted comets down to the observed number . unfortunately , this changes the observed absolute magnitude distribution too much : a ks test shows that a model with this slope predicts an observed @xmath4 distribution inconsistent with the data with greater than 99.99% confidence . i then tried changing the perihelion distribution . decreasing the slope @xmath65 in eqn [ perieq ] to zero brought the predicted number of comets down to 95 , but the perihelion distribution is now too skewed towards small values of @xmath50 ( 99.96% confidence ) . i next tried combining both approaches . decreasing the faint end slope to 1.0 , combined with a flat perihelion distribution , brought the predicted numbers into line with the observed numbers . both the perihelion and absolute magnitude distributions were individually marginally acceptable ( ks - test gave 8 and 5% probabilities of them coming from the same population as the data ) but the joint probability was still uncomfortably low ( though the magnitude limit cut means that the two distributions are not independent , so this should not be taken too seriously ) . the model predicted too many comets with @xmath66 and @xmath67 , and too few in the middle . moving the location of the break in the absolute magnitude relation to fainter magnitudes was also a failure : given that the comet flux normalisation is at brighter magnitudes , this simply increased the number of fainter comets still further above the observations . i therefore adopted a different perihelion distribution : one that rises from @xmath68 out to @xmath69 , and is a power - law beyond that . this preserves the everhart observation of a drop in comet numbers below @xmath70 , while allowing us to tinker with the distribution further out . the parameterization used was : @xmath71 where @xmath72 controls the behavior at large perihelia . i then ran a grid of models , varying @xmath72 and the faint end slope of the absolute magnitude distribution ( @xmath22 in equation [ heq ] ) . each simulated population was tested against the data in three ways : a ks - test on the perihelion distribution , a ks - test on the absolute magnitude distribution , and a chi squared test on the overall predicted number of comets . the latter was done for both the observed number of comets and a number 10% higher , to allow for possible incompletenesses . the lowest of these three significance values was used to compute the goodness - of - fit conutours in fig [ contour ] . note that these contours include only random errors : the systematic errors are almost certainly larger , especially on @xmath72 . the lowest probability rather than the joint probability was used becuase the three tests are not strictly independent . quite a tight constraint could be placed on @xmath22 : @xmath73 ( 95% confidence , not including systematic errors ) . the constraint on @xmath72 was weaker : @xmath74 . no useful constraint could be placed on the bright - end slope @xmath21 : in the modeling i use the @xcite value of 2.2 , but it makes little difference . note that these slopes are often described in the literature using the @xmath75 parameter : @xmath76 , so our best - fit faint end slope has @xmath77 . the predicted distribution of comets for the best fit model is shown in figs [ qhist ] , [ hhist ] and [ complot_f ] . models generated using this model predict @xmath78 ( @xmath45 ) observed comets , in excellent agreement with the data . this model was used to predict the discovery magnitude distribution ( fig [ maghist ] ) . this comparison was used to set the equivalent point source vs. total magnitude offset , as described in [ mags ] . my preferred model thus approximately preserves the faint - end slope and normalization derived by hughes . a flat perihelion distribution is marginally ruled out , and best fits are obtained for one that rises from the sun out to @xmath79 and is either flat or gently falling beyond that . the best - fit model can be used to estimate the flux of long - period comets through the inner solar system . by definition , this model uses the @xcite flux of 0.53 comets per year per unit perihelion , brighter than @xmath80 . @xcite estimated a flux of 8000 long - period comets per 127 years with @xmath29 and @xmath60 . my model suggests that the flux of comets with these parameters is much lower : 11 long - period comets per year ( 1600 per 127 years ) . the model suggests that linear is picking up over 60% of comets with these parameters . i estimate a true flux of 37 comets / year with @xmath81 and @xmath82 , of which linear is detecting @xmath83% . many published estimates of the number of comets in the oort cloud use the @xcite comet flux as their starting point , and hence should be revised down . estimates include @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . the linear sample includes 22 comets with @xmath29 and @xmath60 over a three year period . 5 of these were dynamically new , 11 dynamically old , and 6 had orbit determinations too poor to tell . if we assume that the comets without good orbit determinations break up between new and old in the same ratio as the other comets , we find a flux of 7 dynamically new comets over the three years . my model suggests that the linear sample is @xmath84% complete for finding comets in this range , implying a total flux of dynamically new comets of @xmath37 per year . this corresponds to @xmath85 per unit perihelion per year if a uniform perihelion distribution is assumed . this is a factor of @xmath86 lower than was assumed by @xcite and @xcite . @xcite and @xcite assume long - period comet fluxes ( not just the dynamically new ones ) of @xmath87 per year per au down to @xmath29 , compared to my value of @xmath88 . after correction , all these estimates come out roughly the same : 1 3 @xmath89 in the outer oort cloud , down to @xmath29 . if this is extended to fainter absolute magnitudes , i estimate an outer oort cloud population of @xmath90 comets down to @xmath91 . my model has a much shallower slope of the absolute magnitude distribution than that of @xcite , so the average mass of a comet _ increases_. this cancels out the decreased number of oort cloud comets i predict to give a similar total oort cloud mass to previous estimates ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , both of which used a mean mass computed by integrating the everhart curve . i used two suggested mass - brightness relations to estimate masses from the observed absolute magnitudes : one from @xcite and one from @xcite . note that this relation is extremely uncertain - very few long - period comets have had even their nuclear magnitudes measured . the average mass is crucially dependent on the slope of the bright end of the absolute magnitude distribution , which the data in this paper do not constrain . i bracket the possibilities by using both the everhart and hughes values ( 3.54 and 2.2 respectively ) . i use my own estimate of the faint - end slope . for the everhart bright - end slope , the total mass converges as you go to brighter magnitudes : the bulk of the mass resides in comets with @xmath92 . for the hughes bright - end slope , however , the total mass diverges as you count brighter comets . the bright comets are rare , but their mass goes up faster than their number goes down at bright magnitudes . thus for the weissman mass relation , comets with @xmath93 are 10,000 times more massive than those with @xmath94 . the hughes bright - end slope , however , suggests that they are only 2,600 times less common , so the total mass in the brighter comets is actually four times greater . for the everhart bright - end slope , however , the brighter comets would be 300,000 times less common . the everhart slope is thus physically more appealing , as it avoids the need for a bright cut - off . given the success of both the hughes normalization and faint - end slope in fitting our sample , however , his bright - end slope should perhaps be taken seriously , leading to the prospect of an oort cloud dominated ( in mass terms ) by very large comets . in this section , i will cut off the magnitude range of comets at @xmath95 , but this is arbitrary and will have a large effect on the total oort cloud mass if the hughes distribution is assumed . @xcite showed that kuiper belt objects have a break in their mass distribution at sizes of @xmath96 km , which corresponds to @xmath97 ( [ small ] ) . this may or may not apply to oort cloud comets . if i take the everhart slope , the mean mass of comets down to @xmath58 is @xmath98 g for the @xcite mass relation , and @xmath99 g for the @xcite relation . if i take the hughes slope , however , the average masses rise to @xmath100 g and @xmath101 g respectively . these values translate into total outer oort cloud masses of 2 40 earth masses . my model can be used to calculate the probability of a long - period comet impacting the earth . @xcite calculated that the probability of a given long - period comet with @xmath102au impacting the earth is @xmath103 per perihelion passage . my model suggests that the flux of comets brighter than @xmath32 with @xmath66au is 8 per year . the mean time between comet collisions with the earth is thus @xmath83 million years : very comparable to the figure calculated by @xcite , and to the mean time between global extinction events . most of these comets will , however , be quite small . using the conversion between absolute magnitude and radius described in [ small ] , a comet with @xmath104 has a radius of only @xmath64 m : too small to cause a global extinction event . comets with radii of 1 km or greater ( @xmath105 ) are rarer - the mean time between collisions with comets this large is @xmath106 million years . the shallow faint end slope means that collisions with even small long - period comets are rare . if , for example , the tunguska impact was caused by a comet ( eg . * ) , it would have a mass of @xmath107 g @xcite and hence an absolute magnitude of @xmath108 . the probability of such a long - period comet impacting the earth in the last 100 years is thus @xmath109 . the tunguska impactor must therefore be either asteroidal ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) or associated with a _ short - period _ comet ( eg . * ? ? ? no comet has ever been detected with a strongly hyperbolic original orbit @xcite : ie . a comet that was not gravitationally bound to the solar system . several authors have discussed this ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , with many claiming that this is surprising . oort cloud formation models predict that for every comet that reaches the classical outer oort cloud , a factor @xmath110100 more are expelled into interstellar space ( eg . if most stars have planets , and if planetary formation is usually accompanied by comet ejection , then there should be a substantial population of free - floating interstellar comets . by some estimates , we should have expected to have seen one or more such comets by now , passing through the inner solar system . the results in this paper impact upon this question in two ways . firstly , the non - detection of interstellar comets in the linear sample places an upper limit on their space density . secondly , most previous estimates of the expected number of interstellar comets relied upon the @xcite comet flux : our lower comet flux thus leads to smaller predictions of the interstellar comet density . what limit can we place upon the space density of interstellar comets ( those with strongly hyperbolic orbits ) from the non - detection of any by linear ? i will assume that interstellar comets have the same absolute magnitude distribution that i derive for long period comets , and that their apparent brightness varies with heliocentric distance in the same way as dynamically new inbound comets in our model . given these assumptions , and an assumed magnitude limit of 19 ( point source equivalent ) , one can derive the distance @xmath34 out to which a comet with any given absolute magnitude could have been detected . to convert this into the volume surveyed during the three years of the survey , one must allow for the motion of the comets with respect to the solar system , which can carry new comets into range . typical motions of nearby stars with respect to the sun are @xmath111 @xcite . the volume surveyed in a survey of duration @xmath112 is thus @xmath113 the product of this equation and the absolute magnitude distribution ( equation [ heq ] ) was integrated to calculate the number of comets potentially within linear s magnitude limit , for a given assumed space density of interstellar comets ( defined as the number of interstellar comets per cubic astronomical unit brighter than @xmath58 ) . the integral suggests that the bulk of interstellar comets detected will be those with absolute magnitudes near the break at @xmath31 . the results are quite sensitive to the adopted bright - end slope of the absolute magnitude distribution , being 40% lower for the everhart slope as compared to the hughes slope . not all of these comets will be seen : my model suggests that linear finds @xmath114% of the oort cloud comets within its magnitude limit . the fraction may be lower for interstellar comets because they move faster and hence are not observable for long , but the velocity difference is only @xmath115% . furthermore , a larger fraction of interstellar comets will be brght ones seen at large heliocentric distances , where the visibility period is larger . i adopt a conservative 50% detection probability , which should be ample to include comets not being followed up or not having good orbit determinations . the mean number of comets seen over the three years is then evaluated as a function of the assumed average density . if more than 5 comets are predicted to have been observed , the poisson probability of us having not seen any interstellar comets is less than 5% : this is our adopted limit . i thus derive an upper limit on the local space density of interstellar comets of @xmath116 per cubic au ( 95% confidence ) if the hughes bright - end slope is assumed . for the everhart bright - end slope , this limit increases to @xmath117 per cubic au . these limits are very comparable to the best existing limit : that of @xcite . sekanina s limit is , however , based upon everhart s papers and should thus be regarded with some suspicion . i can extend this calculation by noting that linear has not discovered any interstellar comets in other years . from 1999 through to the end of 2004 their monthly sky coverage ( though not available in detail ) is at least comparable to that during my sample period . these extra three years of data reduce our upper limits to 3 4.5 @xmath118 per cubit au . i now evaluate the expected space density of interstellar comets , given our reduced oort cloud population estimate . following @xcite , the number density of interstellar comets @xmath119 is given by : @xmath120 where @xmath121 is the local number density of stars , @xmath122 is the mean number of outer oort cloud comets per star , and @xmath123 is the ratio of comets expelled from a solar system to the number ending up in the outer oort cloud . i adopt @xmath124 per cubic parsec , from the 8pc sample of @xcite : this is consistent with the value used by @xcite but considerably lower than the value used by @xcite . for @xmath122 , i assume that the number of comets generated per star is proportional to its mass and metallicity . this may or may not be true , but is consistent with the observed tendency for low mass stars to lack hot jupiter planets ( eg . * ? ? ? * and refs therein ) . the local stellar population is dominated by low mass dwarfs : the average stellar mass of the nearby stars in the @xcite catalogue is only @xmath125 . the average metallicity of near - by f and g stars is @xmath126 \sim -0.14 $ ] @xcite : no information is available for local dwarf stars , so i assume the same value . assuming that the outer oort cloud population derived in [ number ] is typical of local stars with solar mass and metallicity , i therefore derive @xmath127 . the most uncertain parameter is @xmath123 : literature values range from 3 100 ( eg . * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? . given these parameters , @xmath128 . thus even in the most optimistic case , the predicted flux is an order of magnitude below current limits . could future surveys reach these predicted densities ? i ran the simulation for five year surveys reaching to deeper magnitude limits . a survey reaching 24th magnitude ( perhaps panstarrs ) would place 95% upper limits of @xmath129 , and might hence detect one or two interstellar comets if @xmath123 is very large . @xcite reached similar conclusions . a survey reaching 26th magnitude ( lsst ? ) would push the limit down to @xmath130 , which would be enough to detect or rule out a large value of @xmath123 . this prediction does , however , depend crucially on the assumed brightness behavior of comets a long way from the sun . simple models which assume that oort cloud comets have an isotropic velocity dispersion imply a constant number of comets per unit perihelion . @xmath6-body integrations ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , in contrast , imply a rising number of comets at larger perihelia , due to the diffusion process of comets past the perturbations of the giant planets . both @xcite and @xcite , for example , predict an increase in the number of comets per unit perihelion of @xmath131 between @xmath69 and @xmath132 ( though this is an extrapolation of the wiegert & tremaine model which is only shown out to @xmath133 ) . is this consistent with the linear sample ? the best - fit model has the number of comets per unit perihelion ( beyond @xmath134 ) going as a power law of index @xmath74 ( 95% confidence ) , ie . a gentle _ fall_. to get a rise in numbers consistent with the @xcite and @xcite predictions , we require @xmath135 , which is inconsistent with our model with 99% confidence . the measured perihelion distribution is , however , somewhat degenerate with the assumed dependence of comet brightness on heliocentric distance : @xmath6 in equation [ eqabsmag ] . as i have repeatedly noted , the choice of @xmath6 is an approximation based on extrapolations of observations obtained at much smaller heliocentric distances . we can estimate the change in @xmath6 that would be needed to bring our observations into line with the @xcite predictions . we need to drop the predicted brightnesses of comets with @xmath136 by enough to reduce the observed numbers by 50% , to meet our 95% upper limit . given our best - fit absolute magnitude relation , this requires that @xmath6 be increased by @xmath137 . this is quite a small rise - well within the observed scatter of @xmath6 values seen at lower perihelia . if , for example , i had used the canonical value of @xmath12 for all comets , rather than our more complex scheme , this would make dynamically new comets much fainter when far from the sun , as required ( at the expense of the correlation seen in fig [ q_a ] ) . the data in this paper , while suggestive , are not therefore significantly at odds with the theoretical predictions . a better understanding of heliocentric brightness variations when distant from the sun will be needed to see if this anomaly is real . the faint - end slope of the absolute magnitude relation derived in this paper ( @xmath138 ) is very flat : the number of comets per unit magnitude barely increases as you go fainter . this presumably indicates that small comets are not that much more abundant than large ones . if the absolute magnitudes are converted to nuclear masses , using either the @xcite or @xcite relations , i find that the differential number of comets per unit mass @xmath139 goes as : @xmath140 @xcite made the case for the existence of small comets : those with nuclei only meters to tens of meters in radius . if we assume the @xcite relationship between mass and absolute magnitude , and a density of @xmath141 , 100 m radius corresponds to @xmath142 and 10 m to @xmath143 . linear is therefore detecting at least a few comets with nuclei smaller than 100 m . similar small comets are also detected by the lasco instrument on the soho spacecraft @xcite , though these are mostly fragments of recently disintegrated larger comets @xcite . @xcite was unclear on whether the shallow faint - end slope was real or a selection effect : i confirm that it is real . @xcite pointed out that small long - period comets must be rare from statistics of comets passing close to the earth . @xcite found a similar paucity of small jupiter - family comets . in this section , i point out that the shallowness of the faint - end slope is actually quite interesting theoretically . collisions are rare in the oort cloud @xcite , so the nuclear size distribution should remain largely unchanged from when the proto - comets were planetesimals expelled from the protoplanetary disk @xcite . @xcite modeled the size distribution of planetesimals in the protoplanetary disk . these models imply that 100 m diameter objects should outnumber 2 km sized objects by a factor of @xmath144 ( per unit log radius ) in the oldest disks modeled . our faint - end slope , however , if combined with the @xcite mass / absolute magnitude relation , implies a ratio of only @xmath145 . the size distribution of planetesimals may be greatly modified by collisions while they lie within the dense environment of the proto - planetary disk . most models of this collisional evolution also , however , predict much flatter size distributions than we see : they typically predict an increase in comet numbers , even at faint magnitudes , of a factor of @xmath146 per magnitude @xcite . this is much greater than my measurement ( @xmath147 ) . as noted in [ eve ] , our shallow faint - end slope is quite robust to sample incompletenesses and model assumptions . the conversion of absolute magnitudes to radii is , however , highly uncertain even at bright magnitudes , let alone the faint absolute magnitudes of relevance here . theoretical predictions are also quite uncertain @xcite , and may be consistent with this slope . another possibility , however , is that the probability of a planetesimal escaping the protoplanetary disk and reaching the oort cloud is size - dependent . @xcite , for example , suggested that collisions between planetesimals would act to circularize their orbits , and would prevent them from escaping into the oort cloud until the density of planetesimals was greatly depleted ( see also * ? ? ? the square - cube law would suggest that this effect is most serious for smaller planetesimals , which may be ground down to dust before escaping . this could thus explain the deficit of small comets . alternatively , gas drag could play the same role : the largely gaseous nature of the giant planets indicates that the protoplanetary disk was still full of gas when the giant planets formed . no published modelling currently includes this effect . another possibility : the square - cube law implies that small comets may loose their volatiles faster than large ones . fading may thus be more severe for these comets , making them harder to detect . a final possibility is that comets have been exposed to high temperatures at some point in their history . the resultant loss of volatiles could thus destroy small comets without much affecting the numbers of large ones . @xcite tentatively suggest this as a reason for the lack of jupiter - family comets with small nuclei . long period comets might have been exposed to high temperatures while still in the proto - planetary disk . once in the oort cloud , temperatures are much lower . nearby supernovae and o - stars may have temporarily heated them enough to remove some volatiles @xcite , but this should not appreciably affect the numbers of small comets . i note in passing that my models are strongly inconsistent with the claims by @xcite for an immense population of small comets bombarding the earth . these claims have , however , already been ruled out in many other ways ( eg . * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . the model in this paper can be used to guide future automated comet - searches . the most basic conclusion follows from the shallow faint - end slope of the number / absolute magnitude relation . this means that to find more comets , a survey should always try to maximize the area covered rather than going deep in a small area . if linear , for example , exposed for six times as long per field , it would be sensitive to fainter comets , and would hence see @xmath148 times more comets per unit area . but it would cover a six times smaller area . the more frequently a survey covers a given area of sky , the higher the probability of a given comet being detected . in fig [ freq ] , however , i show that this is not an enormous effect : decreasing the survey frequency for a hypothetical survey from weekly to biannual only drops the number of detected comets by @xmath64% . the comets lost are primarily those with fainter absolute magnitudes , because their visibility period is small . the small number lost is a direct consequence of the shallow faint - end slope : there are few small comets to lose . in fig [ faint ] , i show the predicted samples that would be found by telescopes using a similar survey technique to linear , but going deeper . the deeper limit essentially increases the absolute magnitude limit reached at all perihelia , and by increasing the time over which comets are visible , also improves the completeness for brighter comets . over 3 years , a survey to 20th mag would detect 103 comets , to 22nd mag would detect 150 and to 24th mag , 186 comets . this is much fewer than @xcite estimated . the discrepancy is probably due to my shallow inferred absolute magnitude and perihelion distributions , which mean that the dramatic increase in sensitivity of these surveys as compared to linear only yields a relatively small increase in sample size . i conclude that telescopes such as skymapper , panstarrs and lsst , each capable of surveying large areas to deeper than 22nd magnitude , should be capable of detecting more than 50 long - period comets per year . a substantial fraction of these are forecast to have perihelia beyond 10au , though this conclusion relies upon the rather shaky assumptions of how brightness varies with heliocentric distance this far out . thus five years should suffice to build up a quantitatively selected sample of long - period comets equal in size to any historical sample . six main conclusions can be drawn from this analysis : 1 . the outer oort cloud contains @xmath90 comets down to @xmath91 ( @xmath149 comets down to @xmath58 ) . this is 2 10 times fewer comets than previous published estimates . 2 . the average mass of these comets is , however , higher than previous estimates . down to @xmath58 , the average mass is between @xmath99 g and @xmath101 g , leading to a total mass in the outer oort cloud of 2 40 earth masses , comparable to or larger than previous estimates . the mass of the oort cloud may be dominated by a few large comets . small comets do exist , but are rarer than predicted by many models . this may be because they have difficulty escaping from the protoplanetary disk . the probability of the earth being hit by a long - period comet similar in energy to the tunguska impactor is only one in forty million per year . i place an upper limit on the space density of interstellar comets of @xmath150 per cubic au ( 95% confidence ) . this is still an order of magnitude above our revised prediction for the space density of interstellar comets . the number of long - period comets per unit perihelion seems to decline , or at best rise slowly beyond 2au . this does not agree with theoretical predictions . the discrepancy may be resolved if comets are fainter at large heliocentric distances than i assume . future survey telescopes should be able to assemble samples of several hundred long - period comets in a few years of operation . the major weakness in this analysis is in the photometry : in particular in our limited understanding of how the brightness of comets varies with heliocentric distance when far from the sun , and in how to convert ill - defined total magnitudes into more reproducible and physically meaningful parameters such as @xmath39 . the data exist to address these problems , but are not publicly available . i would like to thank grant kennedy , eriita jones and chris weekes for their work on aspects of this paper , stephen pravdo and grant stokes for responding to e - mail questions about their neo surveys , timothy spahr for providing details of objects posted to the neo confirmation page , and dan green for provide magnitude measurements from the archives of the international comet quarterly . paul weissmann was referee on an earlier version of this paper : his detailed comments were invaluable in educating the author ( an extragalactic astronomer by training ) in comet lore . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: amongst the highest quality data available for exploring galaxy evolution are the long exposures of the hubble deep field ( williams et al . 1996 ) , which register the faintest and sharpest images of galaxies ever detected . the counts of faint galaxies are found to increase to the completeness limit ( @xmath10 ) , roughly doubling in number per magnitude , @xmath11 ( williams et al . 1996 ; see tables 9 - 10 ) , in all bands . this trend is accompanied by a marked decline in angular size , so that most faint galaxies are barely resolved . while much of this light must arise from the epoch when galaxies and stars were first forming , the photometric limit of the hdf far exceeds the practical limit of spectroscopy ( some @xmath12 of the hdf galaxies do not have measured redshifts ) , hence for the foreseeable future interpretation of these images rests principally on photometric information . a major impediment in analysing the hdf images is our ignorance of the ultraviolet ( uv ) properties of ordinary galaxies , since at high redshift it is the restframe uv light that is detected in the optical bands . despite the rather modest uv performance of imaging satellites it has become apparent that the appearance of even ordinary hubble - sequence galaxies is knotty and irregular in the uv , governed by the spatial distribution of high contrast star - forming regions ( oconnell & markum 1996 ; giavalisco et al . hence , it is unclear to what extent the large numbers of blue and irregular looking objects reported in hst images ( glazebrook et al . 1995 ; driver , windhorst , & griffiths 1995 ; abraham et al . 1996b ; colley et al.1997 ) simply result from redshifted uv light rather than evolution . there have been several efforts to obtain images of representative nearby galaxies . the foca balloon experiment at 2000 @xmath5 has measured six uv images of local galaxies ( blecha et al . 1990 ) , the astro-1 ( astro-2 ) mission measured 27 ( 45 ) uv images of objects using the ultraviolet imaging telescope ( stecher et al . 1992 ) , and maoz et al . ( 1997 ) have recently compiled uv images of 110 galaxies using the foc on hst ( @xmath13 ) . cognizant of the importance of these uv images for assessing galaxy evolution , researchers ( bohlin et al.1991 ; giavalisco et al . 1996a ; maoz 1997 ) have already used these data to comment on deep hst images . while these studies have been very illustrative , the samples are either incomplete or register only the inner regions of galaxies so that a quantification of galaxy evolution in deep hst images has hitherto not been attempted . due to the inadequacies of uv instrumentation , it is interesting to note that even the gross effect of the lyman - limit is more easily observed in the _ optical _ , by virtue of the high redshifts of some faint galaxies ( steidel et al . the restframe uv morphologies of several tens of these high redshift galaxies are measured directly with hst , particularly in the hubble deep field ( steidel et al . 1996b ; giavalisco et al . 1996b ; lowenthal et al . 1997 ) down to the lyman limit . these galaxies lie in the range @xmath14 and are reported to have a generally compact appearance , but many have faint plumes and some are up to 3 in length ( object c4 - 06 of steidel et al . the uv continuum flux places some constraint on the luminosity density of star - forming galaxies at high - z ( madau et al.1996 ) at least for galaxies blue enough to be dominated by the light of o - stars . comparison of the implied high mass star - formation rate with local estimates from from h@xmath15 emission ( gallego et al.1995 ) , provides an indirect means of estimating the evolution of the integrated uv - luminosity density ( madau et al . 1996 ) . in this paper , we outline a simple and practical method for measuring evolution in deep space images , by constructing empirical `` no - evolution '' fields of galaxies as a benchmark , matched in image properties to the data , in this case the hdf . our method has the distinct advantages of being purely empirical and entirely free of parameterizations , so that our conclusions are liberated from the usual caveats . we first establish the k - correction for each pixel belonging to a given galaxy image drawn from a complete sample of relatively bright galaxies with redshifts ( selected from the hdf ) . we then scale the numbers of these k - corrected galaxy images out to high redshift in proportion to the product of the volume and the space density of each galaxy , the latter being set by its value of @xmath0 . finally , we correct the psf , add the appropriate noise and sampling of the hdf observations and compare these `` no - evolution '' fields with the hdf at fainter magnitudes ( @xmath6 ) . this approach is feasible due to the relatively high quality @xmath16 images of the brighter galaxies detected in the hdf ( @xmath17 ) , as well as the many subsequent redshift measurements of hdf galaxies with the keck telescope ( cohen et al . 1996 ; lowenthal et al . 1997 ) . together these observations allow us to construct a statistically useful complete sample of 31 galaxies with sufficient uv - optical coverage for construction of an entirely empirical and parameter free `` no - evolution '' deep field for comparison with the hdf . the universal geometry is the only unknown , dictating the volume and angle - redshift relations , and bearing somewhat on the degree of evolution derived in the @xmath18 band . by following this procedure , we make no recourse to the usual parameterizations of morphological or colour classes , galaxy luminosity functions , and light profiles . implicitly , such parameterizations have tended to assume one - parameter relationships , particularly between morphological type and spectral type , reducing the inherent richness of the general galaxy population and potentially introducing artificial model dependencies . in light of this , it is not very surprising that simulations of two - dimensional images look artificial , appearing more `` hygienic '' than reality , and hence of limited value in reliably quantifying evolution . designating a morphological class has in itself proven to be problematic for well - resolved galaxies . naim et al . ( 1995 ) , for example , have found from a comparison of the classification of six human ` experts ' that classification exhibits a variance of 2 morphological types relative to one another . hence there is still no clear way to map an observed image onto a given morphological type or to produce a realistic image given a morphological type . finally , we emphasize that our procedure is free of the many internal selection biases which have long haunted low - redshift to high - redshift comparisons , e.g. , where deep ccd data have lower surface brightness thresholds than photographic surveys used to construct the local luminosity functions . we begin this paper by describing the manner in which we select our bright galaxy sample in 2 . in 3 , we discuss our empirical procedure for deriving pixel - by - pixel spectral energy distributions and number densities for each of these bright galaxies . in 4 , we assess both the fairness of our sample and the viability of the method by making some simple predictions chiefly with regard to the canada france redshift survey ( cfrs ; lilly et al . 1995 ) . in 5 , we describe the simulation procedure in detail , and in 6 we describe our analysis of the simulations and the hdf data using sextractor . in 7 we present our results , in 8 we discuss these results , and in 9 we present a summary . we adopt @xmath19 and express all magnitudes in this paper in the ab ( oke 1974 ) ] magnitude system ( defined in terms of a flat spectrum in frequency ) . also , to associate the hdf bands with their more familiar optical counterparts , we shall refer to the @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath16 bands as @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 , respectively , throughout this paper . we select our sample of bright galaxies from the hdf . first we measure the photometry of all galaxies detected in the hdf by applying the sextractor photometry package 1.2b5 ( bertin & arnouts 1996 ) to the publicly released version 2 images of the hdf . in using sextractor we require objects to be at least 2 @xmath27 above the sky noise in the @xmath23 image over an area of at least 10 contiguous pixels , after first mildly smoothing the images by a gaussian of width 0.06-arcsec sigma ( the approximate width of the psf ) . we take the deblending parameter ( @xmath28 ) to be 0.04 , which we found to be a good compromise between splitting too many faint objects apart and merging too many different objects together . for photometry , we use isophotal magnitudes ( @xmath29 ) corrected with a gaussian extrapolation to approximate the light beyond the isophotes for all non - crowded ( almost all ) objects , where we take our isophotes to be equal to 2 @xmath27 times the sky noise ( @xmath30 ) . objects with half - light radii less than 0.15 arcsec are excluded as stars ( 5 objects with @xmath31 ) . only objects on the three wide field camera chips lying within 4 arcsecs of the edges are included , beyond which the image quality is diminished . we match up our resulting photometric catalogues redshifts measured by various groups ( cohen et al . 1996 ; lowenthal et al . 1997 ) to construct a strictly magnitude - limited subset , bright enough to be highly complete in redshift . we settle for a conservative limit of @xmath31 , which contains 32 objects in total only one of which is without a redshift and for which we know of no attempt to measure a redshift nor any reason to suppose that its measurement would prove difficult . consequently , we shall assume that the 31 objects with redshifts are representative , and simply scale volume densities by @xmath32 . as more redshifts become available this analysis can be extended , although clearly the limited area of the hdf means that new fields are required in order to significantly enlarge the bright galaxy sample and to help average over the possible effects of clustering . the resultant bright sample is listed in table 1 , along with our determination of its coordinates , @xmath23 magnitude , absolute magnitude , surface brightness ( taken to be @xmath33 ) , ( where @xmath34 is the rest - frame @xmath35 apparent magnitude and @xmath36 is the half - light radius ) , our eye - ball determination of the morphological type , and the known redshift . for reference we also include our determination of the k - correction over the surface of each galaxy at @xmath37 . the calculation of k - corrections , rest - frame absolute magnitudes , and rest - frame surface brightnesses are described below . in addition , the redshift distribution of our bright subset is shown in figure 1 , for comparison with all of the redshifts measured in the compilation by cohen et al . ( 1996 ) , which includes the hdf and its flanking fields . we display the images of the bright sample in figures 2a and figure 2b , as a set of colour images ( @xmath25 , @xmath24 , and @xmath23 bands ) as they appear if k - corrected to the mean bright sample redshift , @xmath38 , and also to @xmath37 , using the pixel - by - pixel k - corrections described in the next section . we treat our bright galaxies as two - dimensional pixelated light - emitting surfaces for the purpose of k - correction , avoiding the unnecessary step of parameterizing their light profiles . we do not attempt to alter the inclination of each galaxy in the simulations , with the attendant problems regarding extinction this would entail , since by default our sample already contains galaxies of all orientations . the question arises as to the best method of k - correction when the redshift extends to wavelengths short enough that no uv information is available . the spectrum of any given pixel is only sampled by 4 broad passbands and no information exists shortward of 2000 @xmath5 in the restframe of the typical bright galaxy ( for which @xmath39 ) , allowing a reliable k - correction to @xmath40 in the longest wavelength band , @xmath23 . in order to extend this work to higher redshift and in order to implement a smooth interpolation between the four passbands we adopt empirical template spectra . to indicate the robustness of the results to the choice of templates , we compare simulations for two independent sets of templates , one based on the small but large aperture uv sample of coleman , wu & weedman ( 1980 ) and the other on the larger but small aperture sample of template spectra carefully compiled and combined from the iue archive by kinney et al . these data sets provide useful uv spectra for a range of optically selected galaxies nicely spanning the observed spectral range ( see connolly et al . 1996 ) , so that a reasonable empirical interpolation and extrapolation can be performed by matching these templates to the 4 passbands of the hdf and improved by interpolating between these spectra to provide a smooth result . additionally , we include the average effects of the hi lyman continuum and series forest absorption at high redshift , as parameterized by madau ( 1995 ) for distant qso s , since they significantly affect the broad - band colours of high redshift galaxies . formally , we represent each element @xmath41 in the two - dimensional template of a galaxy by @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the surface brightness template at element @xmath44 in the @xmath45 band and where @xmath46 is the spectral energy distribution shape at the element @xmath44 . we take the surface brightness template to equal that observed in the hdf in band @xmath45 , the band with the highest integrated signal - to - noise ( either the @xmath23 or the @xmath24 band for the objects in our sample . ) for clarity we use the word `` element '' when referring to a pixel in the original bright galaxy image because these pixels are transformed in area and flux by redshift , and therefore distinct from the pixel scale of the simulations which is set by the hdf . we take the sed shape , @xmath46 , for each element @xmath44 from two different compilations of spectral templates : the coleman , wu , & weedman ( 1980 ) ( hereinafter , cww ) set supplemented with the ngc4449 spectrum ( bruzual & ellis 1985 , unpublished ) and the kinney et al . 1996 ( k96 ) spectra . cww includes seds intended to be representative of the dust - free e , sbc , scd , sdm , and starburst ( ngc4449 ) galaxies , and the k96 set includes seds intended to represent ellipticals , sa , sb , and sb1 ( starburst ; @xmath47 ) galaxies . we extend these observed sed templates below 1200 @xmath5 and 1400 @xmath5 respectively , by extrapolating the slope of the sed at these wavelengths down to the lyman break at 912 @xmath5 , below which we set the observed flux to zero ( see figure 3 ) . we also interpolate linearly between spectra to form a smoothly continuous set for better fitting the observed 4 passband flux measurements . integrating the seds over the transmission curve of the 4 passbands , we then find the most - likely spectral template for each element @xmath44 , which we shall call @xmath48 , such that the sum of the squares of the differences between the sed template fluxes and the observed fluxes divided by the expected error in these fluxes is a minimum . the expected error is taken to be the error in the value of the pixel fluxes added in quadrature with the typical cosmic variance in the model sed fluxes ( @xmath49 ) we find . note that where the signal in a pixel is less than twice the sky noise , we have set the signal in that pixel equal to the value given by eq . ( 1 ) , adopting the surface brightness profile and the spectral energy template which best matches the mean value determined in a 1.0 arcsec diameter aperture . we have not attempted to realign the hdf images in the different bands , nor have we tried to correct for the different shapes that the psf has in the different bands , since checks indicate that these effects are small and induce changes on scales smaller than the hdf pixel scale , i.e. , 0.04 arcsec . this wavelength independence is due to the undersampling of images by wfpc , the effective hdf psf being more set by the wavelength independent sub - sampling grid pattern than by the wavelength dependent diffraction of the telescope . clearly , we should take the spatial extent of each prototype image to be as large as possible within the limits of the signal . in practice , we take this to be the radius at which the mean pixel signal within an elliptical annulus is equal to the sky noise . inspection of each image allows us to filter out the small number of obviously unrelated galaxies within this extended aperture , the pixels affected being replaced by their reflected counterparts . to be sure of including the `` whole '' object we extend its 2d profile by 50% , using the radial gradient . for this extended region we produce the noise by adding poisson noise from modeled signal in quadrature with the general background noise . except for the very brightest `` cloned '' galaxies , this extrapolation is not relevant , since the vast majority of replicated images generated from a given template galaxy are much fainter than the original , lying at higher redshift where these outer regions of the profile lie further into the noise . the question arises as to the utility of the hdf @xmath26 images for generating the higher redshift images in the redder bands , since the sensitivity of the redder bands of the hdf is greater than that of the @xmath26 band . as it turns out , the signal in the hdf @xmath26 images is more than sufficient for our purposes , due to the strong @xmath50 cosmological surface brightness dimming . to see this , consider the s / n at a given @xmath27 in a pixel through the @xmath26 filter at the observed redshift . this translates into a lower s / n at higher redshift in the other bands , given their relative sensitivities and exposure times . taking the worst case that the spectrum of a given pixel is flat in frequency ( though in practice the spectral indices of some starburst systems are somewhat steeper than this ) , the surface brightness dims by a factor @xmath51 , or @xmath52 , or a decrease of the surface brightness by 1.3 , 2.3 , and 3.3 @xmath53 , for the @xmath25 , @xmath24 and @xmath23 bands respectively . however , the measured 1-@xmath27 @xmath26 noise level for the hdf is 32.4 @xmath54 , compared to the 32.2 , 34.0 , and 32.6 @xmath54 levels in the @xmath25 , @xmath24 , @xmath23 bands . clearly , then , since few pixels are as blue or bluer than a flat spectrum in our template galaxy sample , the s / n of any pixel in a redder band at higher redshift will always be less than that of the observed @xmath26 image . while it is apparent that a number of objects in our input sample have extremely low values of s / n in the @xmath26 band ( see the ellipticals in figure 2a ) , we emphasize that the s / n in @xmath26 is _ always _ sufficient to determine the appearance of these galaxies at higher redshifts in the redder bands of the hdf given the relative band sensitivities and exposure times used in these passbands . greater inequities between bands would limit the simulations to depths less than the limiting magnitudes of these passbands . we set the space density of each galaxy in our sample equal to @xmath55 , determined by the maximum redshift , @xmath56 , to which each galaxy could have potentially been selected given our chosen magnitude limit . @xmath57 is given by @xmath58 where @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the solid angle of the surveyed area and where @xmath61 is the well - known luminosity distance at redshift @xmath56 . @xmath56 is determined by : @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the observed redshift and @xmath64 is the @xmath65-correction in the @xmath23 band at redshift @xmath66 . we determine the @xmath65-correction for the galaxy from the total spectral energy distribution , which incorporates the contribution of all the elements in our two - dimensional representation of each galaxy . note this procedure avoids the usual steps of constructing a luminosity function , parameterizing it , and then assigning k - corrections . we simply treat each galaxy as a class of its own with a space density set by its own value of @xmath0 , allowing a fully unbinned , individual treatment of each template galaxy . astronomers have long used the @xmath3 distribution ( schmidt 1968 ) to assess the completeness and uniformity of a sample , where @xmath67 is the volume up to and including the redshift of the galaxy in question and @xmath57 is the volume in which this galaxy could have been observed , given the selection criteria . for a uniform distribution of galaxies in a volume one expects a uniform distribution of @xmath3 between 0 and 1 , in the absence of evolution and clustering , and for a sample with @xmath68 galaxies the average value of this quantity us given by : @xmath69 the distribution of @xmath3 for our template sample is shown in figure 4 , for @xmath70/@xmath71 , @xmath70 , and @xmath72 , where the k - correction is formed from the sed averaged over the whole object . the average value for the @xmath3 distribution is 0.48 , 0.51 , and 0.53 for the @xmath70/@xmath73 , @xmath70 , and @xmath74 geometries , which is within the expected deviations for the @xmath3 statistic @xmath75 and not inconsistent with the rate of evolution detected in a larger redshift survey to a similar magnitude limit ( lilly et al . we could have chosen to derive @xmath57 by redshifting each pixel of the object and performing the photometry on the redshifted image for greater self consistency , but this turns out to be virtually irrelevant because the magnitudes we recover from the redshifted images placed at @xmath56 are on average displaced by only 0.07 magnitudes faintward of our magnitude limit ( @xmath76 ) . a slight faintward shift is expected for aperture magnitudes since the lower surface brightnesses at @xmath56 results in some small loss of the light on the wings . to illustrate this point , we compare the recovered magnitudes at @xmath56 with the magnitude limit chosen for our bright sample in figure 5 . to provide a basic context for understanding the no - evolution simulations described above we display the luminosity function obtained for this sample in figure 6 , for two different representative cosmologies . we compare this luminosity function with the @xmath77-band luminosity functions determined by loveday et al . ( 1992 ) and zucca et al . ( 1997 ) in the apm and esp surveys , respectively correcting our sample to restframe @xmath77 directly using our pixel - by - pixel best - fit seds . we see that our luminosity function is shifted to larger luminosity and/or space density than that of the local universe , broadly consistent with the findings of ellis et al . ( 1996 ) and lilly et al . ( 1995 ) where the luminosity function of blue objects is observed both to brighten and to steepen . we can also compare our sample with the redshift distribution , n(z ) , of the canada - france redshift survey ( cfrs ) , a survey of similar depth , by simulating ( as described in detail below ) its survey parameters . the cfrs sample covers @xmath78 over 112 @xmath79 . scaling by these criteria and the 19% redshift incompleteness of the cfrs , we can construct a prediction for n(z ) using our method ( figure 7 ) . we make a small correction , inferable from figure 5 of lilly et al . ( 1995 ) , to convert from isophotal to total magnitudes by a uniform 0.1 mag . a noticeable difference between our predicted n(z ) and that of the cfrs is found in the amplitude of the distributions , our redshift distribution being 28% higher , consistent with the differences in the respective luminosity functions ( figure 6 ) . despite this , the shape of our predicted n(z ) is very similar to that of the cfrs , which is not surprising given the wide spread of @xmath3 for our sample ( figure 4 ) . this basic agreement is quite satisfactory , showing that our bright galaxy sample fairly samples the range , if not quite the average density , of galaxies comprising the general field population . according to the number density derived for each template galaxy , @xmath0 , and assuming homogeneity , we generate monte - carlo catalogues of the objects out to very large redshift ( @xmath80 ) over the solid angle of the hdf , each object being assigned a random redshift , position , and position angle . we then generate mock images on the basis of these catalogues . each redshifted image must be scaled in size and resampled with more noise and additional psf smoothing to account for its higher redshift and generally smaller size relative to its brighter counterpart . since the two - dimensional surface brightness profiles of the bright galaxies already contain noise , we find it useful to simultaneously generate both a signal @xmath18 and noise @xmath68 image . the noise image @xmath68 keeps track of how much noise has been implicitly added to each pixel in the signal image @xmath60 by virtue of each galaxy template implicitly containing noise . such an accounting allows the proper amount of noise to be added to each pixel in the signal image after all the scaled galaxy templates have been laid down . to generate an image at a chosen redshift , we must calculate the change in size and surface brightness of each element @xmath44 in our two - dimensional galaxy templates . for a galaxy with redshift , @xmath66 , we take the angular size of each element in our two - dimensional galaxy template , @xmath81 , to be equal to @xmath82 where @xmath63 is the redshift of the object as measured in the hdf , @xmath83 is the angular distance ( peebles 1993 ) , and @xmath84 is the angular size of each element in our two - dimensional galaxy template image at @xmath63 , i.e. the pixel size of galaxies in the hdf ( 0.04 arcsec ) . we calculate the surface brightness @xmath85 that each element @xmath44 of our two - dimensional galaxy template has at redshift @xmath66 for a given passband @xmath86 as @xmath87 where @xmath88 and @xmath89 are the @xmath65-corrections and @xmath90 @xmath91 colours calculated based on the spectral energy distribution @xmath92 of element @xmath44 . we have included the line blanketing by the lyman - alpha forest as given by madau ( 1995 ) as well as lyman - limit absorption in our calculations of the @xmath65-corrections since these corrections become important at @xmath93 in the @xmath26 band and at @xmath94 in the @xmath25 band . in calculating both the signal and the noise at each pixel on the images @xmath18 and @xmath68 , we break up each pixel into 25 smaller subpixels , and calculate the contribution of each redshifted element @xmath44 to each of these smaller subpixels to account for the generally much larger area covered by a data pixel than that of the redshifted image element , for the purpose of rebinning . because the real psf has smoothed each galaxy template , to correctly calculate the appearance of each prototype galaxy in our sample at higher redshifts we must add more smoothing present in each object in the @xmath18 image , depending on the reduction in angular size for the object in question . for simplicity , we simply smooth each object with a kernel derived from a relatively isolated , unsaturated star from the hubble deep field reduced in size so that its scale length is simply @xmath95 times that of the original scale length . the above expression is exact for the case of a perfectly gaussian psf and is also close to exact in those cases where the angular size of the simulated galaxy laid down in the @xmath18 image is much smaller than the hdf . of course , it is true that the real hdf psf differs from a gaussian in that it has much more extended wings , but for the most part the differences that this makes are small . to verify this , we compared the angular sizes recovered using the present procedure and from assuming the psf to be exactly gaussian ( the @xmath27 s for which we determined by fitting to the same unsaturated star in the hdf ) , and we found little if any dependence on these differences . for a pixel in which the contribution to the signal image @xmath18 from an element in the template image is @xmath96 , the noise contribution to the same pixel in the noise image @xmath68 is taken to be @xmath97 added in quadrature , where @xmath98 is the s / n ratio calculated for the element @xmath44 for the @xmath43 template drawn from the hdf , and account is made of both the background and poissonian noise associated with the measured pixel - by - pixel signal . having generated the signal image , we want to calculate the appropriate noise for each pixel in our simulated hdf , which we take to be : @xmath99 where @xmath27 is the background noise level in the hdf , @xmath100 is the signal at pixel @xmath44 , and @xmath101 is the gain . having already calculated the amount of noise which each pixel in the signal image had by virtue of implicit noise in the templates , i.e. the noise image @xmath68 , we can bring the noise in each pixel up to the appropriate value @xmath102 by adding pixel - by - pixel gaussian - distributed noise with standard deviation @xmath103 , smoothing this added noise with the noise kernel specified in table 4 of williams et al . ( 1996 ) so as to approximate the observed correlation properties of the noise in the hdf . while the outlined procedure will add the appropriate amount of noise to pixels if noise is lacking in those pixels , it is possible that some pixels will already have more noise added to them than is present per pixel in the hdf . in particular , this occurs when the redshift for an object is lower than that of the prototype , since of course we can not improve on the s / n of the prototype galaxy image . to artificially prevent this possibility , we simply replace every galaxy in our mock catalogue whose redshift is lower than its observed redshift , with another galaxy from our bright sample placed at the same redshift whose observed redshift is lower than the mock catalogue redshift . though this results in a bright galaxy population which is slightly unrepresentative ( and , in fact , this is the cause of the slight disagreement observed in the distribution of bright hdf galaxies and the simulations found later in the paper ) , it does not appreciably bias the measured properties of the cloned galaxies at the fainter magnitudes of interest . the simulations cover a sky area four times that of the hdf in each of the four broadbands @xmath26 , @xmath25 , @xmath24 , and @xmath23 . we perform these simulations self - consistently for @xmath104/@xmath71 , @xmath70 , and @xmath74 , by which we mean that the @xmath57 of the bright sample uses the same geometry as the volume used in constructing the simulation . in figure 8 we compare a no - evolution simulation assuming @xmath72 , @xmath104 , and @xmath105/@xmath106 with an area of the same size selected from the hdf . a simple test of our procedure is to construct images of the 31 prototype galaxies at their observed redshifts ( @xmath63 ) . good agreement is found between these images and their originals at @xmath63 , within the errors expected on the basis of our pixel - by - pixel sed fits . to illustrate this agreement more quantitatively , we plot a comparison of the recovered values for the half - light radius , petrosian radius ( petrosian 1976 ) , and apparent @xmath23 magnitudes in figure 9 . on both the simulations and the hdf itself , we perform the object identification and photometry using sextractor version 1.2b5 ( bertin & arnouts 1996 ) . after smoothing the @xmath23 images with a gaussian of 0.06-arcsec radius ( the approximate psf ) within sextractor , we require that objects be at least 2 sigma above the noise over an area of at least 10 contiguous pixels , and we use a cleaning parameter of 1.0 . we select our apparent magnitudes to be equal to sextractor s @xmath29 estimate , which for non - crowded objects is equivalent to an isophotal magnitude extrapolated beyond the isophotes . we exclude objects with half - light radii less than 0.15 arcsec and @xmath107 as stars , fainter than which the contamination is relatively small . then , based upon the detected objects , we used sextractor to determine the apparent magnitudes in the other bands with the @xmath23 apertures . we set the deblending parameter ( @xmath28 ) , which is important in determining the extent to which sextractor breaks up objects , to be equal to 0.04 . we found some dependence of our results on the value chosen for this parameter , particularly the break - up rate , but for the most part this dependence was small . our chosen value of the deblending parameter is very close to that ( 0.05 ) used by clements & couch ( 1997 ) ( couch , private communication ) . with this choice of parameter , we obtained the reasonable result that no bright galaxy from our sample broke up into smaller pieces when placed at its @xmath56 , in agreement with our qualitative impressions in looking at these images . we derive two different measures of the angular size for each object in our image , a petrosian radius ( petrosian 1976 ) and a half - light radius . we take the petrosian radius to equal the smallest radius for which the surface brightness at that radius equals half the average surface brightness interior to that radius . the half - light radius is equal to the radius of the aperture which contained half the light as determined by sextractor s best estimate of the total light . we performed some simulations to test our method for recovering half - light radii and found that our recovered half - light radii are only slightly scattered about sizes 10% smaller than the input half - light radii at @xmath108 . the scatter in this relationship partially derives from the uncertainty in the overall photometry performed by sextractor . it is natural to begin our comparison of the faint galaxy population in the hdf by looking at the counts in @xmath23 , the longest wavelength band and hence least affected by uncertainty in the k - correction . figure 10 compares the number counts recovered from both our simulations and the observations ( a description of the plotted @xmath109 estimates based on the size of our bright sample is given in appendix a. ) for all geometries , we find that our no - evolution predictions fall steadily short of the observations with increasing apparent magnitude . for @xmath105/@xmath106 , the shortfall is noticeably less pronounced due to the relatively larger volume available . at @xmath110 , for example , the counts fall short by a factor @xmath111 for @xmath105/@xmath106 compared to @xmath112 for @xmath113 and @xmath114 for @xmath106 . of course , the counts recovered at bright magnitudes , @xmath115 , are in fair agreement with the observations , as one would expect given the definition of our sample up to approximately the same bright limit , @xmath76 . it is reassuring to find that there little dependence of the number counts on the choice of spectral template , whether it be the cww set or the k96 set . finally , as discussed in appendix b , we note that the present no - evolution faint counts ( @xmath116 ) are compromised of a non - negligible number of the input prototype galaxies ( @xmath117 ) . given our knowledge of the positions , redshifts , magnitudes , and types of galaxies laid down in each simulated image , it is simple to determine systematic uncertainties such as incompleteness in the number counts , by matching up the object catalogues from the simulations created by sextractor with our input monte - carlo catalogues . figure 11 shows that the incompleteness becomes significant in the range @xmath118 for both our no - evolution simulations . this incompleteness stems from the fact that at fainter magnitudes , we are sensitive to smaller and hence the higher surface brightness galaxies , so that large fraction of the population of galaxies at faint magnitudes subtend areas too large for detection given their redshifted surface brightnesses . in a similar manner , we can determine the rate of overcounting of in our simulated fields . as explained in colley et al . ( 1997 ) , it is possible to overcount the number of faint galaxies by misidentifying individual parts of a galaxy as distinct galaxies , especially at higher redshifts , where the rest - frame ultraviolet light is accessed and hii regions have a higher contrast ( cf . the galaxy at @xmath119 in figure 2b ) . for simplicity , rather than perform an angular correlation analysis like colley et al . ( 1997 ) , we have chosen to measure this number directly . in figure 12 , we display the rate of overcounting for all the simulations performed by comparison of the input random catalogue with those recovered . clearly , in our no - evolution simulations , using the parameters chosen for the photometry , overcounting is never an important effect for any of the cosmologies examined . the clustering seen in the hdf redshift data at bright magnitudes ( figure 1 ) is responsible for the overdensity at bright magnitudes @xmath120 in the hdf relative to the mean field counts measured in wider field surveys . compared to the cfrs , for example , this amounts to a @xmath121 overdensity ( figure 7 ) . at fainter magnitudes , however , the count variance should be less affected by clustering , given the greater projected volume and the expectation of less well developed structure at earlier times . we provide a quick test of the plausibility of this hypothesis using other deep hst @xmath23 data . figure 13 shows the count variance between 6 pointings ( two sets of 3 hst pointings separated by 3 hours on the sky from another program ) . these data show that the count variance in @xmath23 band decreases steadily to the poissonian limit ( @xmath122 ) over the area of wfpc2 , consistent with isotropy at faint magnitudes . we compare the distributions of half - light radii recovered from the hdf with those of our `` no - evolution '' simulations in figure 14 . the hatched area represents the @xmath123 uncertainty range based on the finite size of our bright sample for the no - evolution model using the cww sed templates . the solid curve indicates the angular size distribution recovered from simulations using the k96 sed templates . at bright magnitudes ( @xmath124 ) , the angular sizes recovered from the simulations agree quite well with the observations as expected given the fact that we defined our bright sample in terms of many of these same galaxies . in contrast , at fainter magnitudes , the half - light radii from the no - evolution simulations become significantly larger than those from the observations : larger by 43% , 44% , and 57% in the magnitude range @xmath125 and larger by 35% , 42% , and 53% in the magnitude range @xmath126 for the @xmath127/@xmath70 , @xmath70 , and @xmath74 geometries , respectively , where the median of the angular size distribution in each magnitude bin is used for comparison . as expected , we see that galaxies in the @xmath71/ @xmath70 geometry tend to possess smaller angular sizes than galaxies in the @xmath70 geometry and especially galaxies in the @xmath72 geometry because of the somewhat larger angular - diameter distances . we repeat the above comparisons using the petrosian radii instead of the half - light radii . ideally , petrosian radii provide a more reliable surface brightness - independent estimator of the angular size than half - light radii , though one might question its meaningfulness given the increasingly lumpy appearance and small sizes of faint galaxies . in any case , an inspection of figure 15 shows that the same general trends and conclusions hold here as for the half - light radii . in figure 16 - 17 , we plot a comparison between the colour distributions recovered from the observations and our ` no - evolution ' simulations in three different magnitude ranges for two different colours , @xmath128 and @xmath129 . good agreement is found at the bright magnitudes ( @xmath124 ) as expected given that our bright sample is selected up to this magnitude limit . at fainter magnitudes , however , a clear excess of bluer galaxies is observed relative to our no - evolution simulations . in addition , in the faintest magnitude bin ( @xmath126 ) , there also appears to be an excess of red galaxies relative to that found in the no - evolution simulations . this is somewhat unexpected because one would expect the real universe , for which our sample is representative at @xmath9 to have a younger and therefore bluer appearance than that of our extrapolated sample . this excess may , therefore , reflect the presence of dust and lyman - series forest absorption at moderate to high - redshift . conceivably , an ad - hoc maximal dwarf - model , might also account for this red excess in terms of faded dwarfs at low redshift . in figure 18 , we plot the redshift distributions of the galaxies recovered by sextractor by matching them up with our input catalogues . it is apparent that in the absence of evolution very few galaxies lie beyond a redshift @xmath130 , even at the faintest magnitude , with little dependence on the choice of geometry . a dramatic illustration of the relative unobservability of high redshift galaxies for @xmath70 is given in figure 19 , where we have broken up the simulation of a 52 x 72 hdf exposure into 4 redshift slices . it is interesting to see how these distributions compare with the photometric redshift estimates derived from fits to the 4 passbands of the hdf , and from subsequent near - ir imaging of this field from the ground . surprisingly enough , the redshift distribution recovered from our `` no - evolution '' simulations agree remarkably well with the approximate distribution of lanzetta , yahil , & fernandez - soto ( 1996 ) . given that similar coincidences have been found for redshift surveys at somewhat brighter magnitude limits ( broadhurst et al . 1988 ; colless et al . 1993 ; cowie et al . 1996 ) , it is somewhat tempting to suppose that this result might hold to yet fainter magnitudes . despite such hopes , clearly this relationship begins to break down in the @xmath8 band at fainter magnitudes ( @xmath131 ) , at least , as cowie et al . ( 1996 ) have shown , and presumably a similar break down will occur in the redder bands at fainter magnitudes . in figures 20 and 21 , we plot several colour - colour diagrams , and overplot the @xmath26-dropout and @xmath25-dropout selection criteria given by madau et al . ( 1996 ) , criteria , useful for selecting galaxies at redshifts @xmath132 and @xmath133 , respectively . we count the number of recovered galaxies satisfying these criteria and provide a sumary in table 2 . as expected from the recovered redshift distributions plotted in figure 18 , it is clear that the no - evolution simulations contain manifestly fewer dropouts than the observations . clearly then , the high - redshift universe contains a larger number of objects which of greater luminosity in the ultraviolet than the galaxy population in our redshift - complete sample . we have compared the numbers of dropouts in the hdf found by madau et al . ( 1996 ) with our values listed in table 2 , using the same colour - magnitude window . our dropout rate is higher for the hdf , a finding which might result from our use of sextractor for photometry rather than focas as employed by madau et al . given that these programs likely differ with regard to the degree to which they successfully estimate the magnitudes of detected objects , our analyses probably probe slightly different depths , even though we choose for comparison the same nominal magnitude limit ( @xmath134 ) . imposing a magnitude limit @xmath135 brighter , we can reproduce their dropout rate . also , as stated by madau et al . ( 1996 ) , their focas magnitudes are in general estimated to be too faint by about @xmath136 . in the light of recent work attempting to quantify the morphology of faint galaxies , we compare the properties of the faint galaxies from the hdf against those from our simulations with the @xmath137 statistic proposed by abraham et al . ( 1996a,1996b ) , in order to provide an approximate estimate of the extent to which evolution may affect the asymmetry of galaxies , where @xmath137 is defined as the sum of the absolute value of the differences between a galaxy image and itself rotated 180 degrees about the center of the image . the approximate contribution of the noise to the apparent asymmetry is calculated and subtracted . we plot the distribution of this asymmetry parameter recovered both from our simulations and from the hdf in figure 22 , for two different magnitude bins . we find a clear trend toward larger values of this parameter with increasing magnitude . at the simplest level , this would seem to imply that the faint galaxies are less smooth than the redshifted field population at @xmath138 used in our simulations . some caution must be exercised in interpreting the @xmath137 statistic since it appears to be extremely sensitive to the manner in which one determines the center about which to rotate for evaluating the statistic ( abraham & brinchmann , private communication ) and can exhibit a fair amount of scatter ( @xmath139 ) depending upon whether one takes the centroid or the maximum as the for the center . because of this , the statistic , or at least the present implementation , seems to become increasingly unreliable for the smallest galaxies and hence we restrict our comparison to the bright magnitudes ( @xmath140 ) where we are more confident in the reliability of the statistic from our own internal tests . note that along similar lines , based upon pixel - by - pixel k - corrections of the frei , guhathakurta , & gunn ( 1996 ) sample and systematic applications of asymmetry ( @xmath137 ) & central - concentration ( @xmath141 ) statistics , abraham et al . ( 1996a,1996b ) have argued that the fainter galaxy population is quite unlike the local galaxy population broadly represented by the frei et al . ( 1996 ) sample , which is nevertheless somewhat ill - defined , lacking a firm magnitude limit or well - defined selection criteria . since the novelty of the hdf is principally its angular size information obtained to unprecedentedly faint magnitudes , it is not too surprising that our most interesting finding relates to the sizes of the faint images . the count excess is clearly composed of galaxies with smaller projected areas than expected on the basis of relatively low - redshift galaxies ( @xmath2 ) for any interesting geometry . the evolution of angular - size has not been completely clear in the literature to date . previously , in the range @xmath142 , roche et al . ( 1996 ) find an apparent excess of galaxies with small angular sizes relative to their no - evolution models which are designed to replicate the angular sizes of galaxies in the local universe . at brighter magnitudes ( @xmath143 ) , the study by i m et al . ( 1995 ) on the prerefurbished hst data indicates that the angular sizes of this population is also smaller than expected based upon more local , brighter measures . however , there have also been some studies based on this parallel data indicating no changes in size ( mutz et al . 1994 ; casertano et al . 1995 ) . we also find that the number density of dropouts discovered at faint magnitudes exceeds that recovered from our no - evolution simulation , a finding which clearly indicates that the real high - redshift universe contains a larger density of galaxies with high uv surface brightnesses . note , however , that despite this finding , the estimated integrated star - formation rates in these redshift ranges are similar ( madau et al . 1996 ) . clearly , then , as argued in steidel et al.(1996 ) and lowenthal et al . ( 1997 ) ( cf . figure 7 ) , more star - formation took place on relatively small scales at high - redshift . it remains unclear whether this is the result of the intrinsically smaller baryonic aggregations or the increasing prominence of starbursts at high redshifts . our finding that overcounting rates do not seem to be very important ( see also the companion paper : bouwens , broadhurst , & silk 1998 ) is somewhat contrary to the claims of colley et al . ( 1997 ) , even though we used a similar program ( sextractor ) with similar values of the deblending parameter as one catalogue ( clements & couch 1997 ) used in their study . of course , the galaxy population we have used for our study is more evolved than expected in the real universe at higher redshifts , so we might expect our value to be an underestimate . note that in any case , the small scale correlation claimed is a statistically marginal result , ( @xmath144 , colley et al 1997 ) . less contentious are our findings regarding the colours and the number counts . in agreement with most authors we find clear evidence that the predictions without evolution are redder than observed ( lilly et al . 1995 ) and that the number counts fall short of the data at faint magnitudes ( lilly 1993 ; pozzetti et al . 1996 ) . as we have already argued , it is possible to see the present work as a demonstration that the trends found in comparing the local ( @xmath145 ) population with intermediate - redshift galaxies ( @xmath9 ) extend to yet fainter magnitudes and presumably higher redshifts . at these intermediate magnitudes a larger number of faint , blue , irregular , and presumably small galaxies ( ellis et al . 1996 ; lilly et al . 1995 ; brinchmann et al . 1998 ; guzman et al . 1997 ) have been reported at @xmath146 relative to local expectations . the present study demonstrates that the these trends extend to yet fainter magnitudes , in that there continues to be both an increase in the number and apparent starburst activity of the faint galaxy population as well as a decrease in mean galaxy size . uncertainty estimates for the present study are somewhat `` internal '' and , therefore , might underestimate a field - averaged variance in our measurements . certainly , at bright magnitudes the hdf is @xmath121 overdense with respect to the cfrs . however , since 90% of our bright galaxy sample ranges over a wide spread in distance , some 1500 mpc / h , and @xmath3 is evenly spread over the interval [ 0,1 ] , most bright galaxies should be considered as independent . clearly , we would prefer a larger , more local sample of redshift - complete bright galaxies for our simulations , and other deep multicolour hdf imaging would be useful in the first two respects . we have developed a technique for generating a model - independent faint galaxy population based on pixel - by - pixel k - corrected images of the bright galaxy population , for comparison with deep high - resolution images . our technique has the virtue of being model - independent and completely empirical , except for the usual choice of geometry . we have made use of the hdf for the purposes of defining a redshift - complete bright galaxy sample from which to construct empirical simulations and also for evaluating the evolution of the much fainter galaxies detected in the hdf . we have made use of all four passbands and have been able to make concrete statements about the evolution of the image properties with estimated uncertainties based on the size of a volume - limited sample . we find that , relative to our simulations based on the bright galaxy sample , the faint galaxies are smaller , more numerous , bluer , less regular , and contain more dropouts for any interesting geometry . of particular note is our finding with regard to angular sizes , for which a variety of nebulous and seemingly contradictory statements may be found in the literature . our bright galaxy sample is small , and it will be important to see if our conclusions remain valid when a larger sample is available . nonetheless , we believe this work is an important foundation on which to build , in particular , as we look forward to independent deep fields and the very significant improvement in the quality of uv and optical imaging promised by the advanced camera ( ford et al . 1996 ) . we would like to thank daniela calzetti , marc davis , mike fall , holland ford , andy fruchter , nick kaiser , and alex szalay for some very useful conversations , emmanuel bertin for answering several of our questions regarding sextractor , gordon squires and nick kaiser for the use of several routines from their software package imcat , harry ferguson for his help in producing colour images and answering a few of our questions , jarle brinchmann and roberto abraham for a number of useful tips and comments with regard to the routine we incorporated into sextractor for measuring the @xmath137 parameter , and finally harry ferguson , steve zepf , eric gawiser , and jonathan tan for some helpful comments on near - final drafts of this document . rjb acknowledges support from an nsf graduate fellowship , tjb acknowledges the nasa grant go-05993.01 - 94a , and js acknowledges support from nsf and nasa grants . here we quantify the empirical model uncertainties due to the finite size of our input sample . we look at this uncertainty in terms of an arbitrary quantity describing the surface density of objects on the sky satisfying some observational criteria . for any faint sample of objects satisfying a certain set of observable criteria ( @xmath147 ) , it is possible to express the probability distribution for the number of these objects as the sum of the probability distributions for this variable over all possible galaxy morphologies , luminosities , and sizes , i.e. , @xmath148 . we suppose that this faint sample of galaxies is derived in a monte - carlo manner from our bright sample on the basis of no - evolution assumptions , so that it is possible to express this probability distribution for each galaxy type as the product of the probability distribution for the number of times this object will appear in our bright sample , call it @xmath149 , and the probability distribution for the number of times such a galaxy would be expected to appear in the faint sample in question ( @xmath147 ) , call it @xmath150 . in this way , the overall probability distribution for the number of galaxies observed in a given faint sample ( @xmath147 ) can be expressed as @xmath151 we shall suppose that each galaxy in our bright sample is sufficiently unique to be represented by its own term in the above equation . furthermore , since each of these galaxies appeared in our bright sample once and only once , we suppose that @xmath149 is poisson - distributed with a mean of 1 , which we approximate as a normal distribution about this mean . for lack of something better , we shall take the probability distributions @xmath149 for all other galaxy types to be delta functions at 0 . , i.e. , with relatively larger contributions at faint magnitudes than at bright magnitudes , could result in large systematic errors in this distribution . ] now , it is possible to estimate the uncertainty in the expectation value for the number of galaxies in our faint sample based on the finite number of galaxies we have in our bright sample . because our simulated area is , in principle , unlimited , the uncertainty in the expectation value of @xmath150 is vanishingly small , and in practice we take this uncertainty to be zero . as such , the above probability distribution is simply the sum of normal distributions with various weights , and therefore its 1-sigma uncertainty is simply equal to @xmath152 . we have used this expression throughout our paper in the estimation of errors for each observable calculated from our no - evolution simulations . at fainter magnitudes , one expects a smaller number of the galaxy prototypes to make up an increasing fraction of our faint galaxy sample , as a result both of the differential k - corrections and of the relatively greater volume available to lower luminosity objects at fainter magnitudes . to quantify the importance of this trend , we compute a weighted measure of the effective number of galaxies which contribute to the counts in each magnitude bin , a quantity we take to equal @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the number of galaxies of a given prototype per magnitude per square degree recovered from our simulations and @xmath68 is the number of prototypes considered ( i.e. 31 ) . basically , the above expression equals the square of the number counts divided by the estimated poissonian error based on the size of the contributing sample at the magnitude in question , the derivation of which is given in appendix a. in the case that all the @xmath154 s are the same , the expression reduces to @xmath68 as required . we compute the above expression from our simulations , and we plot the results in figure 23 . at bright magnitudes , the bright galaxy catalogues are still dominated by shot noise so that the number of galaxies estimated from the above expression to contribute at any magnitude is lower than the real number ( @xmath155 ) which contribute . at fainter magnitudes , the effective of number of galaxies decreases again for the reasons stated above , i.e. , a relatively smaller differential volume for the more luminous galaxies and the k - correction . for the sake of clarity , we emphasize that at each magnitude , every galaxy prototype contributes some fraction to the number counts there . abraham , r.g . , tanvir , n.r . , santiago , b.x . , ellis , r.s . , glazebrook , k. , van den bergh , s. , , 1996a , , 279 , l47 . abraham , r.g . , van den bergh , s. , glazebrook , k. , ellis , r.s . , santiago , b. , surma , p. , & griffiths , r.e . , 1996b , , 107 , 1 . bertin , e. , & arnouts , s. 1996 , , 117 , 393 . blecha , a. , golay , m. , huguenin , d. , reichen , d. , bersier , d. 1990 , , 233 , l9 - 12 . bohlin , r.c . , et al . 1991 , , 368 , 12 . bouwens , r.j . , broadhurst , t.j . , & silk , j. 1998 , , submitted . brinchmann , j. , et al . 1998 , , submitted . broadhurst , t.j . , ellis , r.s , & shank , t. 1988 , , 235 , 827 . casertano , s. , ratnatunga , k.u . , griffiths , r.e . , i m . , m. , neuschaeffer , l.w . , ostrander , e.j . , windhorst , r.a . 1995 , , 453 , 699 . clements , d. , & couch , w. 1997 , , 280 , l43 - 48 . cohen , j.g . , cowie , l.l . , hogg , d.w . , songaila , a. , blandford , r. , hu , e.m . , shopbell , p. 1996 , , 471 , l5 . colless , m. , ellis , r.s . , taylor , k. , broadhurst , t.j . , peterson , b.a . 1993 , , 261 , 19 . colley , w.n . , rhoads , j.e . , ostriker , j.p . , spergel , d.n . 1996 , , 473 , l63 . connolly , a.j . , szalay , a.s . , bershady , m.a . , kinney , a.l . , & calzetti , d. 1996 , , 110 , 1071 . coleman , g.d . , wu , c .- c . , & weedman , d.w . 1980 , , 43 , 393 . cowie , l.l . , songaila , a. , hu , e.m . , cohen , j.d . 1996 , , 112 , 839 . driver , s.p . , windhorst , r.a . , & griffiths , r.e . 1995 , , 453 , 48 . ellis , r.s . , colless , m. , broadhurst , t.j . , heyl , j.s . , glazebrook , k. 1996 , , 280 : 235 - 251 . ford , h.c . , et al . 1996 . , 2807 , 184 . frei , z. , guhathakurta , p. , gunn , j.e . 1996 , , 111 , 174 . gallego , j. , zamorano , j. , aragon - salamanca , a. , rego , m. 1995 , , 445 , l1 . giavalisco , m. , livio , m. , bohlin , r.c . , macchetto , f.d . , stecher , t.p . 1996a , , 112 , 369 . giavalisco , m. , steidel , c.c . , macchetto , f.d . 1996b , , 470 , 189 . glazebrook , k. , ellis , r.s . , santiago , b. , griffiths , r. 1995b , , 275 , l19 . guzman , r. , gallego , j. , koo , d.c . , phillips , a.c . , lowenthal , j.d . , faber , s.m . , illingworth , g.d . , vogt , n.p . 1997 , , 489 , 559 . i m , m. , casertano , s. , griffiths , r.e . , & ratnatunga , k.u . 1995 , , 441 , 494 . kinney , a.l . , calzetti , d. , bohlin , r.c . , mcquade , k. , storchi - bergmann , t. , & schmitt , h.r . 1996 , , 467 , 38 . lanzetta , k.m . , yahil , a. , fernandez - soto , a. 1996 , , 381 , 759 . leitherer et al . 1996 , , 108 , 996 . lilly , s.j . 1993 , , 411 , 502 . lilly , s.j . , tresse , l. , hammer , f. , crampton , d. , lefevre , o. 1995 , , 455 , 108 . loveday , j. , peterson , b.a . , efstathiou , g. , & maddox , s.j . 1992 , , 390 , 338 . lowenthal , j. , et al . 1997 , , 481 , 673 . madau , p. 1995 , , 441 , 18 . madau , p. , ferguson , h.c . , dickinson , m.e . , giavalisco , m. , steidel , c.c . , & fruchter , a. 1996 , , 283 , 1388 . maoz , d. 1997 , , 490 , l135 . maoz , d. , filippenko , a.v . , ho , l.c . , macchetto , f.d . , rix , h .- w . , schneider , d.p . 1997 , , 107 , 215 . mutz , s.b . , et al . 1994 , , 434 , l55 . naim , a. , et al . 1995 , , 274 , 1107 . oconnell , r.w . , & marcum , p. 1996 , in _ hst and the high redshift universe _ ( 37th hertstmonceux conference ) , eds . tanvir , a. aragon - salamanca , and j.v . wall , 1996 , astro - ph/9609101 . oke , j.b . 1974 , , 27 , 21 . peebles , p.j.e . 1993 , principles of physical cosmology , princeton university press , princeton . petrosian , v. 1976 , , 209 , l1 . pozzetti , l. , bruzual , g. , zamorani , g. 1996 , , 274 , 832 . roche , n. , ratnatunga , k. , griffiths , r.e . , i m , m. , & neuschaefer , l. 1996 , , 282 , 1247 . schmidt , m. 1968 , , 151 , 393 . stecher , t. , et al . 1992 , , 395 , l1 . steidel , c.c . , dickinson , m. , persson , s.e . 1994 , , 437 , l75 . steidel , c.c . , giavalisco , m. , pettini , m. , dickinson , m. , adelburger , k.l . 1996a , , 462 , l17 . steidel , c.c . , giavalisco , m. , dickinson , m. , adelburger , k.i . 1996b , , 112 , 352 . williams , r.e . , et al . 1996 , , 112 , 1335 . zucca , e. , et al . 1997 , , 326 , 477 12:36:49.351 & 62:13:47.934 & 0.089 & 18.2 & -19.2 & 4.4 & 19.7 & e + 12:36:50.971 & 62:13:21.738 & 0.199 & 19.6 & -20.2 & 1.0 & 21.9 & sp + 12:36:56.572 & 62:12:46.478 & 0.517 & 20.1 & -21.8 & 4.1 & 21.6 & sp + 12:36:47.992 & 62:13:10.107 & 0.475 & 20.5 & -21.2 & 4.3 & 19.9 & e + 12:36:50.138 & 62:12:40.811 & 0.474 & 20.7 & -21.4 & 1.1 & 20.7 & mrg + 12:36:42.827 & 62:12:17.400 & 0.454 & 20.7 & -21.1 & 1.2 & 20.5 & sp + 12:36:41.654 & 62:11:32.961 & 0.089 & 20.8 & -18.4 & 0.6 & 21.9 & sp + 12:36:43.713 & 62:11:43.907 & 0.764 & 20.9 & -22.5 & 3.8 & 19.2 & e + 12:36:53.820 & 62:12:55.070 & 0.642 & 20.9 & -21.8 & 2.0 & 20.4 & sp + 12:36:41.850 & 62:12:06.478 & 0.432 & 21.0 & -20.7 & 1.5 & 20.6 & sp + 12:36:46.952 & 62:12:37.901 & 0.318 & 21.0 & -19.9 & 0.9 & 20.7 & e + 12:36:51.708 & 62:13:54.832 & 0.557 & 21.1 & -21.2 & 2.1 & 20.5 & ir + 12:36:46.082 & 62:11:43.119 & 1.012 & 21.3 & -23.1 & 1.5 & 20.3 & sp + 12:36:58.690 & 62:12:53.457 & 0.319 & 21.3 & -19.7 & 1.0 & 22.6 & sp + 12:36:46.262 & 62:14:05.706 & 0.960 & 21.3 & -23.0 & 2.9 & 18.5 & e + 12:36:57.230 & 62:13:00.701 & 0.473 & 21.4 & -20.8 & 0.5 & 21.7 & sp + 12:37:00.485 & 62:12:35.720 & 0.562 & 21.4 & -20.8 & 3.3 & 20.1 & e + 12:36:50.193 & 62:12:46.807 & 0.677 & 21.5 & -21.5 & 4.4 & 20.1 & e + 12:36:49.634 & 62:13:14.095 & 0.475 & 21.5 & -20.4 & 2.3 & 21.7 & sp + 12:36:44.287 & 62:11:34.292 & 1.013 & 21.6 & -23.5 & 4.7 & 18.9 & e 12:36:51.640 & 62:12:21.247 & 0.299 & 21.6 & -19.0 & 2.5 & 21.1 & sp + 12:36:44.097 & 62:12:48.868 & 0.555 & 21.7 & -20.8 & 0.4 & 20.6 & sp + 12:36:43.066 & 62:12:43.258 & 0.847 & 21.8 & -22.2 & 4.8 & 18.9 & e + 12:36:49.416 & 62:14:07.778 & 0.752 & 21.8 & -21.4 & 1.7 & 19.5 & e + 12:36:55.493 & 62:12:46.551 & 0.790 & 22.0 & -21.5 & 1.6 & 20.4 & sp + 12:36:46.422 & 62:11:52.360 & 0.504 & 22.0 & -19.9 & 3.5 & 19.6 & e + 12:36:49.559 & 62:12:58.629 & 0.475 & 22.0 & -19.9 & 1.7 & 20.7 & sp + 12:36:49.288 & 62:13:12.300 & 0.478 & 22.2 & -19.9 & 0.9 & 19.3 & e + 12:36:43.936 & 62:12:50.496 & 0.556 & 22.2 & -21.3 & 2.0 & 20.5 & irr + 12:36:38.882 & 62:12:20.817 & 0.608 & 22.2 & -20.4 & 1.0 & 21.2 & sp + 12:36:39.920 & 62:12:08.424 & 1.015 & 22.3 & -22.5 & 4.5 & 18.3 & e + ccc observations ( madau et al . 1996 ) & 58 & 14 + observations ( this work ) & 90 & 19 + ne ( @xmath70/@xmath71/cww ) & @xmath156 & @xmath157 + ne ( @xmath70/cww ) & @xmath158 & @xmath159 + ne ( @xmath74/cww ) & @xmath160 & @xmath161 + ne ( @xmath70/@xmath71/k96 ) & @xmath162 & @xmath157 + ne ( @xmath70/k96 ) & @xmath158 & @xmath159 + ne ( @xmath74/k96 ) & @xmath157 & @xmath162 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the end products of stellar evolution for 98% of all stars will be white dwarfs . this final state results because most stars are not massive enough to ignite c and o , so that nuclear reactions cease with the formation of a degenerate core of he or a combination of he , c , and o. with the cessation of nuclear reactions , white dwarfs emit light only via their cooling and become dimmer as time passes . these remnants have very thin surface layers of h and/or he , the bulk of the envelope having been blown away during relatively quiescent stages of mass loss in the progenitor star . for the oldest stellar populations , @xmath215% of the entire present day mass of the system is tied up in white dwarfs , and therefore their distribution and detailed properties represent a unique link to explore the nature of the now - evolved population ii progenitors . such studies are enhanced in star clusters where all of the remnants are co - spatial , have the same total age , and evolved from stars with the same metallicity , yet over a range in initial mass . milky way globular star clusters have been dated to a formation time roughly 12 gyr ago ( e.g. , krauss & chaboyer 2003 ) , and therefore represent the first structures to form in the galaxy . these systems are one of the most important tools that we have to probe the formation and evolution processes of galaxies @xcite . given their ages , the present day main - sequence turnoff mass in globulars is about 0.8 @xmath0 , and therefore the bulk of their population has evolved through post main - sequence evolution , the majority having formed faint white dwarf stars . through almost 400 orbits of hubble space telescope imaging observations this decade , our team has uncovered the complete white dwarf cooling sequences of the two nearest globular clusters , m4 and ngc 6397 @xcite , and will target the third nearest cluster , 47 tuc , in cycle 17 ( go-11677 ) . a shallower study of the massive globular omega cen by @xcite and @xcite has successfully uncovered over 6500 remnants in this single cluster , roughly a quarter of the total known white dwarf population in the entire milky way from all other studies combined ( e.g. , eisenstein et al . 2006 , and subsequent sloan digital sky survey work ) . the color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) of these clusters , extending to impressively faint magnitudes , are presented in figure [ fig : globswds ] ( see also bedin et al . 2009 for a more recent acs study of m4 ) . the white dwarf cooling sequences of nearby globular clusters have been analyzed to independently ( e.g. , of main - sequence stars and turnoff morphology ) derive the distances and ages of the clusters @xcite , explore age variations between metal - rich and metal - poor systems using stars whose evolution is almost completely independent of metallicity @xcite , possibly suggest large fractions of helium - core white dwarfs produced through binary interactions @xcite , and hint that mass loss stages leading to the formation of white dwarfs may involve small asymmetric kicks @xcite . for each of these studies , the interpretation of the photometry to yield the results depends on knowledge of the mass of the brightest white dwarfs that are forming today in these old systems . yet , at present , _ no direct measurements of the masses of such population ii white dwarfs exists _ , although several indirect arguments suggest that the value should be @xmath3 @xmath4 0.53 @xmath0 . as discussed in @xcite and @xcite , stellar evolution theory and our understanding of the maximum luminosity of red giant ( rg ) and asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars , as well as the luminosity of the horizontal branch ( hb ) , predict that white dwarfs forming in globular clusters today should have 0.51 @xmath5 0.55 @xmath0 . the best observational verification of this theoretical prediction in the case of cluster white dwarfs was provided recently by @xcite , who reported the masses of white dwarfs in ngc 6752 to be 0.53 @xmath0 . however , their spectroscopic measurements were only of sufficient quality to yield the temperatures of the white dwarfs , and therefore the photometry from the cmd was leveraged to derive masses . recently , a study of the masses of field white dwarfs was also presented from the spy project ( eso sn ia progenitor survey ) . pauli et al . ( 2006 ) find several hundred thin disk and thick disk white dwarfs , and seven candidate halo objects based on kinematic analysis . the masses of six of these white dwarfs range from 0.44 0.51 @xmath0 , with an additional lower mass star at 0.35 @xmath0 . in this paper we present the first results from a new study aimed at _ directly _ ( i.e. , purely from spectroscopic absorption line fitting ) measuring the masses of known population ii white dwarfs in different environments . our goal is to target the brightest white dwarfs in the nearest globular star clusters ( such as m4 , ngc 6397 , and 47 tuc ) and in the halo field , with ground - based spectroscopic instruments on 810 m telescopes . the clusters listed above span an appreciable range in metallicity ( factor of 20 ) and are located at distances such that the brightest white dwarfs with @xmath6 = 10.5 have apparent magnitudes of @xmath7 = 22 24 . the faintness of these stars , crowding issues in the cluster , and the need to obtain high signal - to - noise ( s / n ) spectra of the higher order balmer lines at @xmath8 4000 @xmath9 make this a difficult , but possible , project with current telescopes . below , we discuss the results from our first study , in which we target two dozen white dwarfs in m4 with the gemini / gmos and keck i / lris multiobject spectrographs over several observing runs . the spectra for six of these stars , that are confirmed as cluster members and that have sufficient s / n to yield accurate mass measurements , are consistent with @xmath3 = 0.53 @xmath1 0.01 @xmath0 . the impact of this measurement for bettering our knowledge of stellar structure and evolution , and for dating halo globular clusters through white dwarf cooling theory , are discussed . an analysis of the remaining m4 spectra that did not yield masses , e.g. , to define the spectral types of population ii white dwarfs , is presented in the companion paper by @xcite . the deep hst imaging data of m4 illustrated in figure [ fig : globswds ] ( left ) were collected with the wide field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) camera in 2001 as a part of go-8679 @xcite . the observations spanned a total of 123 orbits , in the broadband @xmath10 and @xmath11 filters , and were centered on a field located at ( @xmath12,@xmath13 ) = ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 ) , 2.4 pc ( 4.8@xmath16 ) s - e of the center of the cluster . although the hst photometry is very accurate , and there is no ambiguity on the membership of the white dwarfs , the bulk of the stars are too faint to be useful for spectroscopic follow up with modern day facilities . additionally , the wfpc2 field of view is 5.3 square arcminutes , about six times smaller than our ground based instruments , and therefore the spectroscopic program would be highly inefficient with just this input list of targets . below we first discuss supplemental imaging of these data with the gemini south telescope ( [ geminiimaging ] ) , followed by spectroscopic follow up ( [ geminispect ] ) . in [ keckspect1 ] and [ keckspect ] , we discuss additional spectroscopic observations of m4 s white dwarf population with the keck i telescope . we reobserved m4 with the gemini south telescope and gemini multiobject spectrograph ( gmos ) , anchoring the deep hst field near the south - eastern edge of the ground based image and placing shallower hst pointings near the western side . the gmos photometry , over a 5.5@xmath17 5.5@xmath16 area , has the added advantage that it extends continuous imaging into the denser region towards the center of m4 and therefore provides a higher density of targets down to a given magnitude limit . of course , crowding in the ground - based data prevents the targeting of white dwarfs near bright stars , and this increases in the direction of the cluster center . a footprint of the hst and gmos images is provided in figure [ fig : foot ] . = 20 and 24 , and colors less than @xmath18 0.5 ) are shown as dots . the objects targeted for gmos spectroscopy are shown as diamonds and those for lris spectroscopy are represented with pluses . the center of m4 is located at ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) = ( 254.898@xmath19,@xmath2026.526 ) and is indicated with an asterisk . [ fig : foot],width=315 ] as this map illustrates , less than half of the gemini / gmos field of view overlaps the hst / wfpc2 observations . in order to effectively select white dwarf candidates over the entire gmos field , we obtained imaging in both the @xmath21@xmath22 and @xmath23@xmath22 filters , down to a depth of @xmath425th mag . the images were corrected for bias and flat fielding by the gemini iraf pipeline , version 1.4 . the processed images were then reduced with the standard daophot / allstar photometry package to yield psf photometry @xcite . further details on the steps involved in our application are provided in @xcite for a similar study . the matched catalog of wfpc2 and gmos sources contains @xmath24 stars . we calibrate the @xmath21@xmath22 and @xmath23@xmath22 magnitudes to hst @xmath25 and @xmath11 ( hereafter called @xmath7 and @xmath26 ) using derived transformations for the common stars in the space- and ground - based systems ( see davis et al . 2009 for details on the transformations ) . these offsets are then applied to the entire gmos catalog . the positions of all stars on the gmos image were carefully measured with respect to both hst positions and standard usno guide stars to yield precise astrometry . with an approximate color of @xmath27 = 0.3 ( one brighter object is also present ) . this cmd is contaminated by a more distant field population , located blueward of the main sequence . there is also contamination in the white dwarf region of the cmd from field white dwarfs and possibly blue compact galaxies , which we address in [ membership ] . the open circles encircling the dots represent those objects which were targeted by keck / lris for spectroscopy ( see [ keckspect ] ) . the red open circles are additional objects that were targeted by gemini / gmos , and that are not in the keck sample due to slit conflicts ( see [ geminispect ] and [ keckspect ] ) . the open circles lacking small dots are hst detections for which we do not have ground based photometry ( two of these stars are off the plot ) . these latter objects were selected for the sole purpose of filling the mask in relatively empty regions , and therefore no pre - selection was used . [ fig : cmd3],width=321 ] the gemini / gmos cmd of m4 is presented in figure [ fig : cmd3 ] . both the main - sequence and white dwarf cooling sequence are well measured , the latter containing about two dozen candidates brighter than @xmath7 = 24 . the location of these white dwarf candidates are illustrated on figure [ fig : foot ] as smaller points . the selection here includes stars with 20 @xmath28 @xmath7 @xmath28 24.5 and colors @xmath27 @xmath28 0.5 . note the paucity of ground based candidates in the two inner wfpc2 fields ( top - left ) . there are in fact many white dwarfs at these positions , however , the crowding limits their detection from the ground . we further subdivide the sample of white dwarf candidates into two bins , with priority 1 stars being our strongest white dwarf candidates in the dominant part of the cooling sequence , and priority 2 objects being somewhat more uncertain objects that are located off the cooling sequence ( e.g. , redder or bluer ) and/or near a bright star . these latter objects are only included in the spectroscopic mask if they do not overlap a priority 1 star ( hence , we get a spectrum of the potential white dwarf for free ) . any of the confirmed members of m4 , based on hst proper motions in the region of overlap , were also targeted as priority 1 objects . finally , we include several redder stars that are candidate cvs in the priority 2 sample ; most of these are hst proper motion members as well . in total , 21 white dwarf candidates were targeted with gemini / gmos for follow up spectroscopy . note , a few of the very red or faint objects shown in the cmd were included without pre - selection for the purpose of filling the spectroscopic mask ( these objects were not detected from the ground ) . an example of the gmos and wfpc2 photometry , astrometry , and a postage stamp image of the white dwarf candidate wd 09 is shown in figure [ fig : l09 ] . similar figures for all other white dwarf candidates are provided in the appendix . , width=302 ] in total , we obtained approximately 14.5 and 9 hours of queue scheduled spectroscopic science exposures with gemini / gmos in june / august 2005 and august / september 2006 , respectively . the observations were taken with the b600 grating , covering a broad wavelength region of @xmath42700 @xmath9 centered at 4680 @xmath9 . the data were binned by a factor of two in the spectral direction to improve the s / n . all science exposures were obtained in sub - arcsecond seeing conditions and photometric skies . the raw data frames were downloaded from the canadian astronomy data center ( cadc ) in multi - extension fits ( mef ) format and reduced with the gemini iraf package , version 1.4 . the reductions are described in detail in @xcite . of the 21 targeted white dwarfs , a spectrum was recovered for all but three . remarkably , all 18 of the recovered spectra show pressure - broadened absorption lines indicative of white dwarfs . the spectra for these 18 stars , as well as an analysis of their spectral types is also presented in davis et al . unfortunately , in order to determine reliable spectroscopic masses , characterization of h@xmath29 is crucial , and even h@xmath30 ( 3889 @xmath9 ) is very useful . the lack of flux at these wavelengths in our gemini data limited the utility of the gmos spectra for the central goals of this paper . although we could derive mass measurements from the spectra ( see [ modelfit ] ) , the uncertainties are several tenths of a solar mass and therefore we decided to supplement these data with higher s / n observations , especially at bluer wavelengths . with a sample of confirmed white dwarfs established from the gmos observations , we applied for keck i telescope time to reobserve the targets using the lris multiobject spectrograph . not only does keck provide a larger aperture than gemini , but the spectrograph is very efficient in the blue and has an atmospheric dispersion corrector to minimize light loss at large airmasses ( this is important for this study since keck is in the north and m4 is in the south ) . given the similarities in the field of view ( lris has a 5@xmath31 7@xmath16 footprint ) , we simply used as many of the _ confirmed _ sample of white dwarfs from gemini as our input , as well as several additional redder stars in the same brightness range . the location of the 31 lris targets in the ground - based cmd are shown in figure [ fig : cmd3 ] as larger open circles . the objects marked in red circles are those that were targeted with gemini , but not keck . the lris footprint is also shown in figure [ fig : foot ] . keck / lris spectroscopic observations ( r. m. rich , pi ) of the single m4 mask proved challenging . half nights , required due to the low declination of m4 , were scheduled in 2005 june , 2007 april / july , and 2008 april , with the 2007 and 2008 observations benefiting from the lris atmospheric dispersion correction system . the multiple allocations were required due to poor weather that resulted in the loss of a significant number of scheduled hours . altogether , we obtained 10.6 hours of useful exposure time . even these data are of highly variable quality , with seeing measurements ranging from 08 to over 20 . in these crowded fields , our final spectra are dominated by a few of the contributions from the best nights . lris @xcite has a dichroic that splits the spectrum into two channels at @xmath45500 @xmath9 . on the blue side , we use the 400/3400 grism ( dispersion = 1.09 @xmath9/pixel ) which covers a wavelength region from the atmospheric cutoff to the dichroic . for the red side , we use the 600/7500 grating ( dispersion = 1.28 @xmath9/pixel ) , centered at 6600 @xmath9 , which covers a wavelength baseline of 2620 @xmath9 . at our resolution and central wavelength , only h@xmath12 , which is a rather poor mass indicator , landed on the red side . hence , we chose not to reduce the red - side data for this paper . the blue - side lris spectra were reduced using standard iraf tasks . the trace , sky subtraction , and extraction were all performed with the apall task . as expected given the better blue sensitivity of lris compared to gmos , the trace at blue wavelengths was far more certain . given the high levels of crowding and background light from bright m4 stars in the field , our ability to obtain a reliable trace , and perform accurate sky subtraction is dependent on the particulars of each individual slitlet ( see [ culling ] ) . the wavelength calibration was calculated in iraf from spectra of three lamps containing hg , zn , and cd . the typical final dispersion of the wavelength solution was well constrained , with uncertainties of @xmath40.1 @xmath9 . the reduced , wavelength calibrated lris spectra were flux calibrated using the spectrophotometric standard hz44 . finally , the individual spectra were combined using scombine , with weights assigned according to the individual s / n ratios . we summarize the identification , positions , and brightnesses of all white dwarf candidates in table [ targtab.tab ] . the four stars that have slit conflicts , and therefore were not observed with keck , are listed at the bottom of the table . altogether , 31 objects were targeted with keck / lris . note , the identification of these stars as `` wd '' at this stage does not confirm their nature , although we will find later that most are in fact white dwarfs . we use this naming scheme for convenience as we will refer back to this table in future sections . lcccc wd 00 & 245.9579 & @xmath2026.5589 & 0.32 & 23.32 + wd 01 & 245.9256 & @xmath2026.5540 & 1.18 & 22.77 + wd 02 & 245.9406 & @xmath2026.5531 & 0.30 & 21.32 + wd 03@xmath32 & 245.9710 & @xmath2026.5511 & 0.93 & 25.21 + wd 04 & 245.9638 & @xmath2026.5511 & 0.27 & 22.69 + wd 05 & 245.9224 & @xmath2026.5480 & 0.27 & 22.71 + wd 06 & 245.9262 & @xmath2026.5442 & 0.28 & 22.65 + wd 07 & 245.9844 & @xmath2026.5414 & 0.82 & 21.99 + wd 08 & 245.9763 & @xmath2026.5396 & 0.67 & 22.65 + wd 09 & 245.9419 & @xmath2026.5328 & 0.26 & 22.50 + wd 10@xmath32 & 245.9120 & @xmath2026.5281 & 2.03 & 22.28 + wd 11@xmath32 & 245.9867 & @xmath2026.5300 & 1.31 & 26.96 + wd 12 & 245.9427 & @xmath2026.5241 & 0.22 & 23.52 + wd 13@xmath32 & 245.9764 & @xmath2026.5240 & 2.54 & 24.31 + wd 14@xmath32 & 245.9890 & @xmath2026.5214 & 0.85 & 24.99 + wd 15 & 245.9625 & @xmath2026.5190 & 0.26 & 22.73 + wd 16@xmath32 & 245.9276 & @xmath2026.5175 & 0.28 & 23.53 + wd 17 & 245.9515 & @xmath2026.5147 & 0.32 & 23.20 + wd 18 & 245.9521 & @xmath2026.5125 & 0.25 & 23.64 + wd 19 & 245.9281 & @xmath2026.5092 & 0.43 & 23.33 + wd 20 & 245.9436 & @xmath2026.5090 & 0.32 & 23.01 + wd 21 & 245.9263 & @xmath2026.5067 & 1.22 & 22.15 + wd 22 & 245.9521 & @xmath2026.5037 & 0.19 & 23.41 + wd 23 & 245.9364 & @xmath2026.4994 & 0.51 & 22.54 + wd 24 & 245.9216 & @xmath2026.4984 & 0.26 & 22.72 + wd 25 & 245.9442 & @xmath2026.4941 & 0.39 & 23.21 + wd 26 & 245.9168 & @xmath2026.4860 & 1.89 & 24.53 + wd 27 & 245.9006 & @xmath2026.4856 & 0.58 & 23.44 + wd 28 & 245.9179 & @xmath2026.4840 & 0.30 & 22.81 + wd 29 & 245.9674 & @xmath2026.4789 & 0.30 & 22.94 + wd 30 & 245.9353 & @xmath2026.4719 & 1.07 & 22.86 + gemwd 05 & 245.9195 & @xmath2026.4860 & 1.33 & 22.48 + gemwd 11 & 245.9633 & @xmath2026.5174 & 0.40 & 23.39 + gemwd 15 & 245.9349 & @xmath2026.5426 & 0.25 & 22.75 + gemwd 17 & 245.9504 & @xmath2026.5344 & 1.10 & 21.31 + the ground - based cmd of our targets in figure [ fig : cmd3 ] shows that the dominant , blue white dwarf cooling sequence of m4 extends from @xmath7 = 22.5 to 23.5 , and contains eleven stars that were spectroscopically observed with lris ( note , the clump at @xmath33 22.7 , @xmath27 @xmath4 0.3 contains five lris targets ) . an additional target , wd 02 , is almost one magnitude brighter than the family of fainter points and has @xmath7 = 21.3 , another four stars are found fainter and bluer than the cooling sequence at @xmath7 @xmath4 23.5 , @xmath27 @xmath4 0.25 ( including the one object without ground based photometry ) , and two stars are at the faint end and redder than the cooling sequence at @xmath7 = 23.2 and @xmath27 = 0.4 . most of the stars that are redder than this sample of 18 objects ( i.e. , @xmath27 @xmath2 0.5 ) yielded spectra that are not interesting for the goals of this paper and will be commented upon further in @xcite . in table 1 , these objects are wd 01 , 03 , 07 , 08 , 10 , 11 , 13 , 14 , 21 , 23 , 26 , 27 , and 30 . the one exception to this is possibly the relatively bright star just beyond the @xmath27 = 0.5 color cut at @xmath7 = 22.54 , @xmath27 = 0.51 ( wd 23 ) . this star is a proper motion member of m4 but , as shown in the appendix in figure [ fig : wd18_26 ] , is located very close to a bright neighbor . likely , the color ( and spectrum ) of this star is contaminated from the neighboring star and we therefore eliminate it from our analysis . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ tab : wdresults ] the family of 18 white dwarf candidates in m4 s pseudo cooling sequence are all confirmed to be white dwarfs ( see davis et al . 2009 ) . for our primary goal of measuring accurate masses , we want to first restrict this sample to only include well measured , isolated white dwarfs with robust s / n ( see [ modelfit ] ) . the stars along the cooling sequence in our sample vary in brightness by about a factor of three , and therefore the fainter stars will intrinsically have much less signal than their brighter counterparts . added to this , we note that the final quality of the spectrum for any star will depend on several factors and therefore not always correlate with the brightness . for example , the spatial length of the given slit effects the quality of the sky subtraction , the position of the star relative to m4 s center effects the sky background level , and any astrometric mis - centering of the star within the slit causes light loss . we first eliminate three ( fainter ) stars that are located within @xmath3430 pixels ( @xmath42@xmath35 ) of a bright neighbor . these stars , wd 16 , 19 , and 22 , all exhibit a noisy spectrum that is likely contaminated with light from the nearby , brighter star ( see figures [ fig : wd09_17 ] & [ fig : wd18_26 ] in the appendix ) . we also eliminate five white dwarfs , four of which are isolated , for which our extractions resulted in s / n @xmath28 10 spectra , wd 12 , 17 , 18 , 25 , and 28 . the extracted spectra for these white dwarfs suffer from unusable line profiles blueward of h@xmath13 , but with improved s / n , these particular sources could also be analyzed as described below . our final sample has ten white dwarfs , all of which are close to the m4 cooling sequence and have @xmath36 23.4 ( seven of which have @xmath36 23 ) . as we demonstrate in [ membership ] , four of these ten white dwarfs , wd 00 , 09 , 20 , and 24 , are hst proper motion members of m4 . we present the spectra for these ten white dwarfs in figure [ fig : wdspectram4 ] ( left ) . all of the spectra clearly show pressure - broadened balmer lines extending from h@xmath37 to h8 . these are therefore all da ( hydrogen ) spectral type white dwarfs . we report the spectral types of all of our white dwarfs , including stars that are too faint for mass constraints , in @xcite . the s / n per resolution element in our ten stars is generally 40 50 , and at best 60 for one star ( wd 02).4030 @xmath9 as discussed in [ syntheticspectra ] . ] we also present a detailed view of the white dwarf cooling sequence in the cmd , and indicate the positions of these ten white dwarfs in the bottom - right panel of figure [ fig : wdspectram4 ] ( dotted circles ) . the remaining open circles ( without dots ) in this diagram are those stars that were spectroscopically targeted in this narrow region of cmd space . we note that the magnitudes and colors of wd 15 and 24 are almost identical and so the two dots can not be discerned . we also illustrate a theoretical white dwarf cooling model for @xmath38 = 0.5 @xmath0 @xcite , which cuts through our sample nicely . from this plot , it is clear that wd 02 is well removed from the dominant sequence of points and the cooling model . although it is possible that the photometry for this star is in gross error , it is more likely that the star is a field white dwarf along m4 s sightline ( see [ membership ] for more information ) . the technique of measuring masses of white dwarfs from balmer line fitting has been widely employed for field stars , such as in the palomar - green ( pg ) sample @xcite and sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite . the technique has also been cross - checked against independent measures of the mass of a white dwarf such as astrometry for binary systems ( e.g. , sirius b , barstow et al . 2005 ) , fits to the mass - radius relation for stars with trigonometric parallaxes @xcite , the gravitational redshift method @xcite , and pulsation mode analysis @xcite . for temperatures hotter than @xmath412,000 k , these methods are in excellent agreement with the spectroscopic line fitting technique @xcite . in this section , we first briefly describe our method to calculate masses for the ten white dwarfs discussed above . we then verify the uncertainties in the masses using synthetic spectra of the same quality as the observations , and fit using the same methods described below . finally , we remove field white dwarfs from the sample and analyze the mass of the confirmed m4 members . fitting the balmer lines of a white dwarf to model atmospheres involves reproducing multiple line profiles from h@xmath37 to higher order transitions @xcite . typically , four or five well measured lines are enough to constrain the temperature ( @xmath39 ) and surface gravity ( log @xmath21 ) of the star @xcite . the fifth balmer line in this sequence , h@xmath30 , is the weakest and bluest ( at @xmath40 = 3889 @xmath9 ) , and therefore a spectrograph with high throughput in the blue is needed to characterize the feature accurately in faint stars . general details of the fitting technique used to derive @xmath39 and log @xmath21 are provided in @xcite , and recent refinements to this method are given in @xcite . additional information on the fitting of white dwarf spectra similar to these observations , and taken with our instrumental setup , are presented in 6 of @xcite . specifically , the improved method to normalize the line profiles described in @xcite is used in our work . simultaneous fits of model atmospheres to all of the balmer lines , in each of the ten white dwarfs discussed above , are presented in figure [ fig : wdspectram4 ] ( top - right ) . within each panel , the absorption lines of a given white dwarf are arranged with h@xmath37 at the bottom , and successive higher order transitions on top . the model fits are shown as smooth red curves and are excellent in all cases . we also confirmed that the two anomalous features , small spikes caused by bad sky subtraction in the h@xmath37 line of wd 00 and 29 , do not affect the results of the fit . this line is least sensitive to changes in the gravity of the star . the output from the spectroscopic fits are the @xmath39 and log @xmath21 for each star , which we summarize in table 2 . the masses of these ten stars ( @xmath3 ) are simply calculated by combining the measured surface gravity of the stars with the well established mass - radius relation for white dwarfs . in general , most of the white dwarf masses are @xmath40.5 @xmath0 with an uncertainty of @xmath3410% . we also estimate both the cooling ages , @xmath41 , and the theoretical luminosity of each star by interpolating the @xmath39 and log @xmath21 within evolutionary models similar to @xcite , but assuming a 50/50 carbon - oxygen core mix . our default calculations assume thick hydrogen layers with @xmath42 = @xmath43 = 10@xmath44 and helium layers of @xmath45 = 10@xmath46 , and are summarized in table 2 and discussed further below . we also tested the sensitivity of our results to models ( e.g. , wood 1995 ) with pure carbon cores and to models with very thin hydrogen layers ( e.g. , @xmath42 = 10@xmath47 ) . the results from these comparisons , for both the final remnant masses and the theoretical luminosities , are identical to our default values within the measured uncertainties in these properties ( which are small , see table 2 ) . we note , however , that the cooling ages of these bright , young white dwarfs are systematically larger in the pure c core models by 20 30% . at the time of writing this paper , tremblay & bergeron ( 2009 ) have just presented the first results from an improved calculation of the stark broadening of hydrogen lines in dense plasmas that are representative of white dwarf atmospheres . their new results , including non - ideal effects , suggest that the masses measured through the spectroscopic technique require a slight upward revision of 0.034 @xmath0 . as the temperatures of the stars using the new calculations are also slightly hotter ( e.g. , 1,000 2,000 k ) , the luminosities are unaffected . the full implications of this study have not yet been investigated and the dependency of this offset on mass is not well constrained . in the results that follow , we have adjusted our default masses by @xmath480.034 @xmath0 to be consistent with these new calculations ( including the reported masses in table 2 ) . we have not corrected the individual @xmath39 and log @xmath21 values by a common offset ( which would be approximately 1,500 k and 0.1 dex , respectively ) . the s / n of the ten white dwarfs in our sample is listed in column 8 of table 2 . this is calculated from the pseudo - continuum between the h@xmath13 and h@xmath29 balmer lines , at @xmath44030 @xmath9 . the pixel - to - pixel rms scatter is converted to a s / n per resolution element by multiplying by the square root of the number of pixels per fwhm ( six , in our case ) . the bulk of the stars have s / n = 40 50 , although a few are as low as @xmath430 and one object is above s / n = 60 . note , these s / n values should only be used as a relative ranking of the quality of each spectra , and are not indicative of the global s / n . we can see that , due to the throughput , the s / n decreases blueward of the wavelength at which we made this measurement . in figure [ fig : synthetic ] ( top ) , we produce simulated white dwarf spectra over a range of s / n . these spectra have been convolved with a gaussian profile with 6 @xmath9 fwhm . directly comparing the quality of our data in figure [ fig : wdspectram4 ] to these simulated spectra , we can conclude that most of our objects are better than the s / n = 30 case , and similar , if not better , than the s / n = 40 case . for the latter , we generate a monte - carlo with 500 trials and fit each of these spectra in our fitting code . the prescription used in the fitting is identical to that for our actual white dwarfs , namely , the same models are used in the fit with five balmer lines . the results from this test are shown in the middle panel of figure [ fig : synthetic ] . the input stellar parameters for the synthetic white dwarf are @xmath39 = 25,000 k , log @xmath21 = 7.80 , and @xmath38 = 0.536 @xmath0 . from the distribution of recovered masses , we find @xmath49@xmath38@xmath50 = 0.54 @xmath0 with a dispersion of 0.06 @xmath0 . therefore , we expect to measure the masses of our white dwarfs to roughly 10% precision based on this test , which agrees nicely with our reported uncertainties in mass ( see table 2 , column 5 ) . in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : synthetic ] , we extend the test above for other s / n values and plot the associated error from this fitting . thus far , we have established masses for ten white dwarfs in the m4 direction . as we have reported in previous spectroscopic studies of white dwarfs in star clusters , some fraction of the stars along these lines of sight are actually members of the field population and therefore need to be removed before discussing the mass distribution of bonafide members . the best method to establish such membership is through proper motion analysis , and we have such data from the hst overlap of a portion of our lris field ( see figure [ fig : foot ] ) . out of these ten white dwarfs , we can confirm that wd 00 , 09 , 20 , and 24 are proper motion members ( as are wd 16 and 23 ; these are rejected from our sample based on the poor quality of the recovered spectra and/or contamination from a nearby neighbor see [ culling ] ) . this is not a surprising result since the proper motions were folded into the selection process to target white dwarfs in the region of overlap with our hst field . in addition to these five confirmed m4 white dwarfs , we note that the remaining objects in our sample closely follow the 0.5 @xmath0 cooling sequence , and are consistent in position in the cmd with the confirmed members . although we do not have proper motions for these stars , some of them are likely members of m4 . to distinguish members from non - members , we can use the theoretical luminosity of each star to calculate its distance modulus . any stars that have significantly discrepant values from the known distance of m4 , ( @xmath51)@xmath52 = 12.51 @xmath1 0.09 @xcite , should be eliminated from our sample as they likely represent field white dwarfs along the line of sight , binary white dwarfs , or possibly objects for which the spectroscopic fit is incorrect due to some unknown artifact in the spectrum . we compare the calculated distance modulus of each of our ten white dwarfs with the known m4 distance in figure [ fig : mags ] . the 1@xmath53 uncertainty in the theoretical magnitude ( i.e. , from spectral fitting ) is plotted as a horizontal bar for each star , and the mean distance of m4 and @xmath12@xmath53 uncertainties are indicated with the solid and dashed lines . we can use the proper motion members of the cluster as a rough guide to establish the expected scatter of known members in this diagnostic . the calculated distances of three of the four proper motion members of the cluster , wd 00 , 20 , and 24 , are close to , but slightly larger than the distance of m4 , whereas the fourth star ( wd 09 ) appears to be 0.7 mags closer than the cluster . this object could therefore be a non - member that shares the proper motion of the cluster . alternatively , if the object is a member , its overluminous nature may suggest an unresolved double degenerate in the cluster . we note that the mass derived from the spectrum of this star yields the unexpectedly high value of @xmath38 = 0.79 @xmath0 ( see table 2 ) . three additional white dwarfs are clearly members of the cluster , wd 04 , 06 , and 15 , whereas three other stars wd 02 , 05 , and 29 are possibly field white dwarfs . to summarize , our final secure sample of singly evolved , m4 member white dwarfs includes three objects that are proper motion members ( wd 00 , 20 , and 24 ) and three objects which are on the cooling sequence and have the correct distance from spectral fitting ( wd 04 , 06 , and 15 ) . theory predicts that the masses of white dwarfs forming in old , population ii systems such as globular clusters are expected to be in the range 0.51 @xmath54 0.55 @xmath0 @xcite . as table 2 indicates , the six single white dwarfs that we have confirmed as members of m4 have masses that range from 0.50 0.59 @xmath0 . the uncertainties in our mass measurements are all roughly the same , under 10% , and therefore the un - weighted mean mass of the sample of six white dwarfs is measured to be @xmath3 = 0.53 @xmath1 0.01 @xmath0 . the present day temperature of these cooling remnants is also well measured from our data . there is a group of four stars in our sample with @xmath7 @xmath4 22.6 ( @xmath6 = 10.1 ) and all have the same temperature , @xmath55 = 25,000 k. the two fainter stars , wd 00 and 20 , are cooler than this group by about 5,000 k , as expected . the surface gravities , log @xmath21 , of all six stars are in the range log @xmath21 = 7.68 7.95 . as mentioned earlier , the exact @xmath39 and log @xmath21 values have not been adjusted to reflect the small corrections required by the new stark broadening calculations @xcite . our sampling of m4 cluster member white dwarfs in this study puts us in the fortunate situation of having characterized a group of four remnants at the same position on the cmd . @xcite demonstrate that the mass difference between white dwarfs at the tip of the cooling sequence to those five magnitudes fainter at the limit of the hst study is only @xmath40.1 @xmath0 . these four white dwarfs , wd 04 , 06 , 15 , and 24 , differ in luminosity by just 0.07 mag , and therefore should have the same mass , and have evolved from stars with the same progenitor mass . the expected temperature range in this group of four stars should only be @xmath42% . as these differences are much smaller than our uncertainties , we can verify our mean mass measurement of m4 white dwarfs by creating a composite white dwarf spectrum , with very high s / n , from the coaddition of these individual spectra . @xcite have shown that for unresolved double degenerate systems , the atmospheric parameters derived from assuming a single star are in fact an average of the parameters of both components of the system . therefore , spectra with identical gravities should yield the same average gravity in a coaddition as compared to the true individual values . such a coaddition has the advantage that the resulting fit will be minimally influenced by any artifact affecting a given balmer line in one spectrum ( e.g. , presence of a cosmic ray ) . this method has several disadvantages as well , for example , the spectral lines in the composite may be artificially blurred if the wavelength solution is not well determined in each of the individual spectra . we stress that this test is only intended as a verification of our results and should not be attempted in samples where the mass variation between individual white dwarfs is non - negligible ( e.g. , similar studies in younger clusters ) . the composite spectrum from this analysis is shown in figure [ fig : composite ] ( top ) , and exhibits a s / n @xmath4 100 at @xmath40 = @xmath44030 @xmath9 . the balmer lines in this spectrum are very accurately characterized ; the resulting best fit model to the five lines is shown in the lower panel . the spectroscopic mass from the fit is measured to be @xmath38 = 0.54 @xmath1 0.02 @xmath0 , in excellent agreement with our findings above . overall , from our spectroscopic study of white dwarfs in m4 , we can conclude that the mass of population ii remnants forming today is @xmath3 = 0.53 @xmath0 and the temperature of stars presently at the tip of the white dwarf cooling sequence is @xmath39 = 25,000 k. the mass distribution of white dwarfs in nearby open star clusters has been mapped since 1977 when volker weidemann compared theoretical models of mass loss ( e.g. , fusi - pecci & renzini 1976 ) to the observed masses of a few remnants in the hyades and pleiades clusters @xcite . since this pioneering work , similar mass measurements have been made for over 100 stars in a dozen open star clusters . a review of the earlier work is provided in weidemann ( 2000 ) and a compilation of some more recent results is presented in @xcite , excluding very recent studies by @xcite . the mass distribution of the remnants varies as a function of the turnoff mass of their parent cluster , suggesting that more massive progenitors produce more massive white dwarfs ( see salaris et al . 2009 for a detailed analysis of the present relation ) . new measurements by our team in three older star clusters with ages of a few gyrs have recently permitted , for the first time , a purely empirical fit to the data without the need for a theoretical anchor at low masses ( see below ) . with the present study , we can once again extend the initial - final mass relation to new bounds . as the initial mass function in most ( all ? ) stellar populations is bottom heavy , the characterization of mass loss from these low mass stars affects our understanding of stellar evolution for the bulk of all stars today . in figure [ fig : ifmr ] , we present all of the constraints to date at the low mass end of the relation , corrected by @xmath480.034 @xmath0 from our previous reporting to reflect the new stark broadening calculations ( see [ modelfit ] ) . the data includes the two confirmed cluster members in the 1.4 gyr cluster ngc 7789 @xcite , the two white dwarfs in the 2.5 gyr cluster ngc 6819 @xcite , the single carbon - oxygen core white dwarf in the 8.5 gyr cluster ngc 6791 @xcite , and the six white dwarfs in m4 from this study . for the latter , we have fixed the progenitor mass to the expected mass at the turnoff in an old , metal - poor population , @xmath56 = 0.80 @xmath0 , with an adopted error of 0.05 @xmath0 . = @xmath201.1 and @xmath57 = 12.0 gyr , the vandenberg , bergbusch , & dowler ( 2006 ) models yield a turnoff mass of 0.82 @xmath0 . ] the data points for individual white dwarfs in these clusters are shown as open circles and binned averages of the population in each cluster are illustrated with larger , filled circles . for older clusters , all of the white dwarfs at the top of the cooling sequence evolved from progenitors just above the present day turnoff , and therefore we expect a single mass at the cooling sequence in a given cluster . of course , in younger clusters , our spectroscopic measurements can include stars along the entire cooling sequence of the cluster and therefore there can be a large dispersion in white dwarf masses in a single cluster ( e.g. , ngc 2099 , kalirai et al . 2005 and ngc 2168 , williams , bolte , & koester 2009 ) . 0.034 @xmath0 to reflect the new stark broadening calculations presented in @xcite . as discussed in [ masslossmetallicity ] and @xcite , the single white dwarf in ngc 6791 is much more massive than the mean mass of remnants in the cluster , most of which are low mass helium - core white dwarfs ( and not shown here ) . the individual white dwarf progenitor pairs are shown as open circles and the binned averages in each cluster are shown as larger filled circles . the relation shows a linear decline of final remnant mass with decreasing initial progenitor mass , extending down to the extreme low mass end , anchored by our m4 measurement at @xmath56 = 0.80 @xmath1 0.05 @xmath0 and @xmath3 = 0.53 @xmath1 0.01 @xmath0 . the solid line shows the best fit empirical relation to all individual data points excluding the new m4 white dwarfs , and the dashed curve shows the mass of the core at the first thermal pulse ( see [ ifmr ] ) . [ fig : ifmr],width=302 ] the low mass end of the initial - final mass relation in figure [ fig : ifmr ] now contains a total of eleven data points , and shows a roughly linear decrease in white dwarf mass with initial mass , anchored at the extreme left end by the new m4 measurement , @xmath56 = 0.80 @xmath1 0.05 @xmath0 and @xmath3 = 0.53 @xmath1 0.01 @xmath0 . given that the oldest observable stellar populations in the universe are the same age as m4 , this relation is now complete at the lower limit and can not be observationally extended further to lower masses . as discussed earlier , several predictions of stellar evolution theory have long suggested that the masses of population ii white dwarfs forming today should be 0.51 @xmath5 0.55 @xmath0 @xcite , and therefore our first direct measurement is in perfect agreement with these predictions . based on our measurements , the total integrated post main - sequence mass loss of low mass stars in old population ii systems will be @xmath434% . theoretically , there is an expected lower limit to the masses of carbon - oxygen core white dwarfs . this is given by the mass of the stellar core at the first thermal pulse on the asymptotic giant branch , an evolutionary point before the core has had a chance to grow on the branch . this core mass has a very small dependency on the stellar metallicity . in figure [ fig : ifmr ] , we illustrate this expected core mass as a dashed curve @xcite . over the range of initial masses on this plot , the core mass is expected to remain roughly the same at @xmath3 = 0.52 @xmath0 , showing a flat relation for @xmath56 @xmath4 1 2 @xmath0 . at 0.8 @xmath0 , our first observational constraint from a half dozen white dwarfs in this single star cluster suggests the actual remnant masses are just slightly larger than the minimum core mass ( with a slight extrapolation ) . this implies that the progenitors of such low mass stars had just enough mass to experience thermal pulses on the asymptotic giant branch and that the cores of these stars will not grow appreciably during this evolution . as m4 is a typical population ii system in terms of its old age and low metallicity , it is reasonable to assume that these trends may extend to stars that are presently in similar phases of stellar evolution both in the general field halo population and in other globular clusters with similar properties to m4 . in addition to extending the initial - final mass mapping to lower masses , m4 represents the first star cluster with a significantly sub - solar metallicity in which white dwarf masses have been measured . the mean metallicity of the cluster is [ fe / h ] = @xmath201.10 @xcite , 13 times more metal - poor than the bulk of the open clusters used to define the relation and 40 times more metal - poor than the metal - rich system ngc 6791 ( [ fe / h ] = @xmath480.40 , peterson & green 1998 ) . for this cluster , after accounting for the new stark broadening calculations discussed earlier , @xcite actually measured a mean mass for nine white dwarfs of @xmath3 = 0.46 @xmath1 0.06 @xmath0 , much lower than expected . as they show , the bulk of these white dwarfs contain helium - cores , after evolving through a channel involving intense mass loss on the red giant branch , likely driven by the high metallicity of the cluster . the single data point shown in figure [ fig : ifmr ] is based on the only clearly non he - core white dwarf in that sample , and does not affect the discussion above . however , the results from ngc 6791 suggest strong dependencies of mass loss on metallicity , especially at super - solar metallicities . to date , we lack a good theoretical understanding of the dependence of post main - sequence mass loss on metallicity . the general expectation in evolutionary models is for more efficient transport of material outward from the star if the metallicity is higher , and therefore higher rates of mass loss . however , the exact treatment depends on the modeling of winds on the red giant branch and thermal pulses on the asymptotic giant branch ( e.g. , see weidemann 2000 and habing 1996 ) , phases of stellar evolution that are poorly understood . as @xcite summarizes , mass loss prescriptions along the red giant branch alone show very different behaviors with metallicity . for example , over a 1 dex metallicity change from [ fe / h ] = @xmath201.0 to 0.0 , the @xcite and @xcite laws predict that @xmath58@xmath59 should increase by @xmath340.05 @xmath0 whereas the @xcite and @xcite laws suggest @xmath58@xmath38 increases by 0.15 0.25 @xmath0 . to qualitatively compare the dependence of mass loss in post main - sequence evolution with metallicity to these estimates , we can first parameterize the initial - final mass relation . the solid line in figure [ fig : ifmr ] is a linear fit to the entire sample of _ open cluster _ white dwarf main - sequence progenitor mass pairs from @xcite , @xmath60 the zero point of this relation has been adjusted to reflect a global offset of @xmath480.034 @xmath0 in the white dwarf mass measurements , although the slope may in fact also be affected if the offset is found to vary with mass ( see figure 11 and 12 in tremblay & bergeron 2009 ) . the bounds on this relation range from the oldest open cluster white dwarf in ngc 6791 to the youngest white dwarfs in the pleiades , and therefore are @xmath56 = 1.1 6.5 @xmath0 . a small extrapolation of the empirical relation to the mass of the present day turnoff in m4 ( e.g. , @xmath40.8 @xmath0 ) yields @xmath3 = 0.52 @xmath1 0.02 @xmath0 , which is therefore consistent ( at 1@xmath53 ) with our measured value of the masses of m4 s white dwarf population . these data therefore _ hint _ that mass loss rates have a weak or no dependence on metallicity , at least over the range extending from metal - poor populations such as m4 to roughly solar metallicity . interestingly , we know from our study of ngc 6791 that mass loss rates are strongly correlated with metallicity at extremely high [ fe / h ] , and therefore this may lead to an interesting shape for the empirical mass loss metallicity relation from white dwarf spectroscopy . of course , stronger conclusions will benefit greatly from additional observations of clusters spanning a wide range of metallicities , especially at the metal - poor end . for completion , if we add our new data point for m4 to the initial - final mass relation and recalculate the best fit ignoring any possible metallicity - related biasses , we find a slightly shallower relation with @xmath3 = ( 0.101 @xmath1 0.006 ) @xmath56 + 0.463 @xmath1 0.018 @xmath0 . finally , we note that the metallicity of m4 , [ fe / h ] = @xmath201.10 , is only slightly more metal - rich than the global metallicity of both the stellar halo of the milky way ( [ fe / h ] = @xmath201.6 , @xmath53 = 0.6 ; morrison et al . 2003 ) and m31 ( [ fe / h ] = @xmath201.5 , @xmath53 = 0.7 ; kalirai et al . 2006 ) . assuming the dominant population in these galactic components is old ( e.g. , @xmath6110 gyr ) , the same 34% stellar mass loss fraction should be representative of stars evolving in these populations . by directly inputing this mass loss into general stellar evolution models of similar age and metallicity ( e.g. , girardi et al . 2000 ) , we can add an important observational constraint to the modeling of light from the stellar halos of spiral galaxies using population synthesis techniques ( e.g. , bruzual & charlot 2003 ) . in section [ introduction ] we introduced the extensive hst observations that have defined some of the deepest cmds ever measured , with any instrument ( e.g. , the hst cycle 13 observations of ngc 6397 in richer et al . although these data sets have led to a wide range of astrophysical studies , the primary goal of the observations has aimed to accurately establish turnoff - independent white dwarf cooling ages for population ii star clusters . in this respect , the present study serves to establish several of the input ingredients that are needed to make this measurement . for example , knowledge of the masses and spectral types of white dwarfs , and the initial - final mass relation , are all required to fully model an observed white dwarf cooling sequence ( e.g. , hansen et al . 2004 ; 2007 ) . for m4 , two recent studies have modeled the white dwarf cooling sequence using independent data sets , and both have concluded with similar ages ( however , see discussion below ) . first , @xcite used a full 2-d treatment of the white dwarf cooling sequence in the observed hst wfpc2 cmd ( i.e. , luminosity and color information are used ) , and just recently , @xcite have used a more simplified technique of age dating based solely on the luminosity function in newer and deeper acs data . an analysis of these studies illuminates several interesting choices relative to the findings in this paper : * the present day mass of cluster white dwarfs forming today sets the normalization for the masses along the entire cooling sequence . in their modeling , @xcite assume the mass at the tip to be 0.55 @xmath0 and @xcite assume 0.54 @xmath0 . as we have shown , the actual mass of white dwarfs at the bright end of the cooling sequence is only slightly lower at 0.53 @xmath0 , and therefore the mass distribution ( and hence cooling rates ) along the entire cooling sequence are not very different from the assumptions in these studies . * hydrogen ( da ) and helium ( db ) atmosphere white dwarfs have different cooling rates , and so the fraction of stars cooling with these spectral types leads to structure in the luminosity and color function that must be modeled correctly to infer the age of the population from white dwarf cooling theory . for m4 , ngc 6397 , and ngc 6752 , spectroscopy of the white dwarf cooling sequence indicates that 100% of the stars at the bright end have hydrogen atmospheres ( see moehler et al . 2004 and davis et al . @xcite treated the fraction of db white dwarfs as a free parameter and found the best fit to yield an upper limit of 40% ( good fits were obtained as long as more than 60% of the white dwarfs are da ) , whereas @xcite choose an arbitrary value of 30% ( e.g. , the field disk ratio ) . * the initial - final mass relation is required to properly evolve the progenitor stars on to the white dwarf cooling sequence . the normalization and form of the initial - final mass relation adopted in both of these studies ( e.g. , wood 1992 ) , is based on empirical constraints from solar metallicity data points at higher masses , and a theoretical anchor at low masses . this can now be updated to our new result given earlier . we encourage future theoretical modeling efforts to make full use of this new information in their analysis , preferably on the newer acs imaging data of m4 . of course , the white dwarf models themselves should also be updated with new physical insights . for example , the contribution to the opacity of cool white dwarfs from the far red wing of the ly@xmath12 line ( kowalski 2007 ) alone can yield ages of globular clusters ( e.g. , ngc 6397 ) that are higher by @xmath40.5 gyr ( kowalski 2007 ; b. hansen 2009 , private communication ) . we noted above that the @xcite and @xcite studies concluded with similar white dwarf cooling ages for m4 . formally , @xcite reported an age of 12.1 gyr ( 2@xmath53 lower limit of 10.3 gyr ) and @xcite measured an age of 11.6 @xmath1 0.6 gyr ( internal errors ) . a deeper look at these two studies suggests they are , in fact , grossly _ inconsistent _ with one another given differences in white dwarf cooling models and uncertainties in the cluster distance modulus . as our present work is closely linked to obtaining very accurate absolute age measurements of globular clusters ( through the study of white dwarfs ) , we briefly summarize these two studies below and highlight the respective assumptions and differences that are being made . in the @xcite study , the authors compare their data to three sets of models and adopt a distance to m4 based on the well established technique of subdwarf distance fitting . they find @xmath62 = 1.73 @xmath1 0.10 kpc for m4 ( e.g. , richer et al . 1997 ) , which is identical to independent distance measurements for the cluster from the baade - wesselink distance using the m4 rr lyrae stars ( @xmath62 = 1.73 @xmath1 0.01 kpc , liu & janes 1990 ) and from astrometry ( @xmath62 = 1.72 @xmath1 0.14 kpc , peterson et al . 1995 ) . at present , it appears the latter estimate is the most secure . for the subdwarf measurement , the comparison was based on pre - hipparcos parallaxes , and for some other clusters , a calculation with post - hipparcos parallaxes indicates a longer distance by @xmath40.2 mags than initially estimated ( gratton et al . similarly , the baade - wesselink method yields luminosities for m4 s rr lyrae stars that are fainter by @xmath40.2 mags as compared to the @xmath6[fe / h ] relation derived by gratton et al . ( 1997 ) for clusters with low extinction ( using post - hipparcos main - sequence fitting techniques ) . unfortunately , re - deriving the distance to m4 using any photometric technique is problematic given the very high extinction along the line of sight ( @xmath63 @xmath2 1 ) , the variation in @xmath63 across the face of the cluster , and the non - standard shape of the extinction curve along this line of sight ( which passes through the scorpius - ophiucus dark cloud complex vrba , coyne , & tapia 1993 ) . irrespective of the adopted distance ( although see below ) , @xcite find that the white dwarf cooling age they derive for m4 from their own models ( e.g. , hansen 1999 ) is consistent with that measured using the @xcite models , however they rule out the @xcite models which yield ages that are older than the universe . therefore , this suggests that , for the same distance modulus and data set , simply changing the white dwarf model yields an absolute age difference of 2 gyr . in the recent @xcite study , the authors use only the @xcite white dwarf models , and still conclude with an age similar to that derived by @xcite . the difference is actually reflected in the distance to m4 ; @xcite use a much larger ( i.e. , 15% ) value of @xmath62 = 1.98 kpc . this value is formally inconsistent with the three independent studies above . @xcite measure the distance to m4 by simply fitting a single isochrone of approximately the correct metallicity to the turnoff and horizontal branch . in principle , this method can of course yield the distance to any stellar population with a measured turnoff , however it has almost always been avoided for a large number of reasons . first , and most importantly , there are uncertainties in both the microphysics built into the stellar evolution models ( e.g. , opacities , equation of state effects , and nuclear reaction rates ) and in the treatment of processes that do not come from first principles ( e.g. , convection , core - rotation , diffusion , gravitational settling , etc . ) . because of these unknowns , simply adopting an isochrone from another groups models would lead to a different measured distance modulus for the cluster ( e.g. , different models predict different horizontal branch luminosities ) . second , such comparisons of data and models to yield distances require transformation of the model from the theoretical to the observational plane , resulting in another source of error . finally , in this specific case , this comparison does not alleviate any of the aforementioned uncertainties related to our lack of knowledge of the reddening and extinction along this line of sight . in the end , the application of the @xcite models and the longer distance modulus derived by @xcite effectively offset each other , yielding a derived age similar to that of @xcite . summarizing , there are clearly both intrinsic differences in white dwarf models calculated by different groups and there is a lack of consensus on the correct distance to m4 . for the former , increased testing of the white dwarfs models on star clusters with well known fundamental parameters ( e.g. , distance , metallicity , and foreground reddening ) are sure to resolve the correct prescriptions . for the latter , it appears that only the @xcite astrometric measurement is free of the unknown reddening and extinction laws along this line of sight , and therefore should be preferred . until these differences are unambiguously resolved ( e.g. , the space interferometry mission could directly measure the distance to m4 to within a few percent ) , the error budget from these uncertainties will remain large and the new physical constraints on masses , spectral types , and the initial - final mass relation are secondary to the analysis . of course , if the properties of bright white dwarfs in other population ii systems are similar to m4 , the new results can have immediate significance on those studies . this is especially exciting given the remarkable data set that has been presented for ngc 6397 by @xcite and will soon be available for 47 tuc ( h. richer , cycle 17 acs / wfc3 proposal go-11677 ) . the mass measurement of white dwarfs in a globular cluster provides important leverage to the use of these stars as distance calibrators . although the white dwarf cooling sequence is fainter than the bright part of the main - sequence in a star cluster , uncovering the sequence can offer several advantages over canonical techniques involving main - sequence distance fitting . for example , the location of the bulk of the white dwarf cooling sequence in a cmd does not depend on the metallicity or age of the population , or on any of the other systematics that plague main - sequence evolution ( e.g. , convection theory ) . however , the location does depend on mass ( e.g. , wood 1995 ) , with a 0.1 @xmath0 difference translating to a @xmath58(mag ) = 0.25 shift ( i.e. , a 12% distance offset ) . so , first , a simple offset can now be calculated to correct the location of any local calibrating sample of white dwarfs with parallax measurements ( usually 0.60 @xmath0 for field white dwarfs ) to the expected location of 0.53 @xmath0 stars . following this , a straightforward comparison with the apparent luminosity of the globular cluster white dwarf cooling sequence can yield the distance to the population ( e.g. , see renzini et al . unfortunately , it is difficult to actually make this measurement and independently derive the distance of m4 given the aforementioned uncertainties in the slope of the extinction curve along this line of sight . however , the true distances of other clusters with well constrained reddenings and extinctions can be easily calculated from their cooling sequences and the new mass measurements . we have presented the first directly determined spectroscopic mass measurements of white dwarfs that are known to be population ii members . our measurements suggest that the final remnant mass at the tip of the white dwarf cooling sequence in the globular cluster m4 is @xmath3 = 0.53 @xmath1 0.01 @xmath0 , in nice agreement with expectations based on stellar evolution theory . these results suggest that low mass population ii stars will lose @xmath434% of their mass through post main - sequence stellar evolution . if , in fact , all milky way globular clusters have the same age , then this mass loss rate should be applicable to the evolution of stars in all but the most metal - rich galactic globular clusters . we use this measurement to first extend the initial - final mass relation of stars to the lowest possible limit , given the age of the universe . this single observation also hints that mass loss rates are not significantly different for metal poor stars when compared to solar metallicity stars of the same mass . finally , we offer several pieces of new input that are required to measure more accurate white dwarf cooling ages of globular clusters in the galactic halo . imaging observations of globular clusters with ground and space based telescopes have now uncovered thousands of white dwarfs in population ii clusters ( e.g. , see figure [ fig : globswds ] ) . the science that results from these purely photometric surveys is greatly enhanced with spectroscopic follow up , which we have shown can yield the spectral types of the remnants @xcite , the mapping of initial to final mass , and the mass at the tip of the observed cooling sequence ( and therefore a calibration for the masses along the entire cooling sequence ) . all of the nearest globular clusters are in the southern hemisphere , and given their larger distances compared to m4 , an extension of this work to these systems will require superior blue sensitivity and throughput , and much larger allocations of spectroscopic time on 8-meter class telescopes ( e.g. , see moehler et al . future white dwarf spectroscopy in these clusters will benefit greatly from a 30-m telescope with a multiobject spectrograph with the bluest sensitivity . such a telescope would not only allow a direct measurement of the mass loss rates in an expanded set of open and globular clusters , but would permit the first initial - final mass relations to be built from observations of a set of white dwarfs in a _ single _ cluster . deep spectroscopy of white dwarfs over a range in luminosity ( and therefore mass ) can be engaged in a given cluster , minimizing the systematics introduced by metallicity variations in samples of clusters . fortunately , the nearest three globular clusters also sample a wide range in metallicity ( e.g. , a factor of 20 from ngc 6397 at [ fe / h ] = @xmath202.0 to 47 tuc at [ fe / h ] = @xmath200.7 ) , and therefore the dependence of mass loss on metallicity can be probed in detail with such observations . we wish to thank d. reitzel for help with designing the spectroscopic masks in this program . we also wish to thank j. hurley for useful discussions related to stellar evolution , white dwarfs , and binarity . jsk s research is supported in part by a grant from the stsci director s discretionary research fund . the research of hbr is supported by grants from the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada . he also thanks the canada - us fulbright program for the award of a fulbright fellowship . pb is supported in part by the nserc canada , by the fund fcar ( qubec ) , and is a cottrell scholar of research corporation for science advancement . support for mc is provided by proyecto basal pfb-06/2007 , by fondap centro de astrofsica 15010003 , by proyecto fondecyt regular # 1071002 , and by a john simon guggenheim memorial foundation fellowship . rmr acknowledges support from grant ast-0709479 from the national science foundation . barstow , m. a. , bond , h. e. , holberg , j. b. , burleigh , m. r. , hubeny , i. , & koester , d. 2005 , , 362 , 1134 wood , m. a. 1995 , proceedings of the 9th european workshop on white dwarfs held at kiel , germany , 29 august - 1 september 1994 . lecture notes in physics , 443 , edited by detlev koester and klaus werner . springer - verlag , berlin heidelberg new york , 41 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: supernova remnants ( snrs ) are one of prominent objects in ir emission . @xmath0 m . ] in the milky way , among the three hundred known snrs , about 20%30% are usually seen in unbiased surveys using the the _ infrared astronomical satellite _ ( ) , _ spitzer space telescope _ , and @xcite . this low fraction , however , is likely mainly because the snrs are located in the galactic plane where the confusion from foreground and background emission is severe . in nearby external galaxies such as the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) , the fraction is much higher , e.g. , @xmath1% @xcite . a primary mechanism for the ir emission in snrs is thermal dust emission . dust grains swept - up by sn blast waves are heated by collisions with hot x - ray emitting plasma and emit mid- and far - infrared emission . it has been pointed out that the resulting ir dust emission is the dominant cooling mechanism for snrs and could be more luminous than the x - ray emission in snrs over most of its lifetime even with dust destruction taken into account @xcite . @xcite and @xcite examined the ratio of ir - to - x - ray ( irx ) fluxes of nine galactic and four magellanic snrs using data , respectively , and they found that all the examined snrs have ratios greater than unity , so dust ir cooling is indeed more efficient than x - ray cooling in snrs . however , there was a large scatter in the observed ratios over three orders of magnitudes , with a majority of snrs having ratios significantly less than the theoretical flux ratio expected for hot gas in thermal equilibrium with the dust - to - gas ratio ( dgr ) of the general interstellar medium ( ism ) . @xcite pointed out that the snrs might have low irx flux ratios because of the destruction of dust grains by snr shocks or the low dgr in the ambient medium , while they could have high irx flux ratios because of the extra contribution from ir line emission and emission from dust heated by shock radiation . for large snrs such as the cygnus loop , it was shown that the ir emission can be decomposed into two components : one associated with x - rays , which might be from collisionally heated dust grains , and the other associated with optical filaments , which could be heated by both collision and radiation within the filament @xcite . however , with the data , which have a resolution of several arcminutes , it was difficult to confirm the true nature of the ir emission for most snrs . practical use of the irx flux ratio for studying dust heating and processing has been regained with sensitive , high - resolution far - infrared ( fir ) data from recent high - resolution ir space missions . @xcite found that in sn 1987a , the irx flux ratio decreased significantly over three years and showed that the change is consistent with the destruction and heating of swept - up circumstellar dust behind the sn shock wave . @xcite and @xcite derived irx flux ratios for the snrs puppis a and rcw 86 , respectively , which were found to be considerably smaller than the theoretical irx flux ratio even with dust destruction taken into account , and they concluded that the dgr in the ambient medium of these snrs should be lower than that of the general ism by a factor of several . it is interesting that , in other studies of galactic and magellanic snrs , in which the dgr is obtained by directly comparing the dust mass derived from the ir sed ( spectral energy density ) modeling and the x - ray emitting mass derived from x - ray spectral analysis @xcite , a similar conclusion was reached . @xcite performed a systematic study of the snrs in the inner galaxy ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 , @xmath4 ) using the mipsgal survey ( survey of the inner galactic plane using mips ; @xcite ) in which they derived irx flux ratios of 13 snrs among the 39 snrs that they detected . the derived irx flux ratio ranged from 1.6 to 240 , which confirmed the earlier conclusion that the dust ir cooling is dominant over the x - ray cooling but the result was not discussed further . more recently , @xcite explored the ir and x - ray characteristics of the lmc snrs , and showed that the irx flux ratios of the lmc snrs are systematically lower than those of the galactic snrs to be consistent with the low dgr in the lmc . in this paper , we use the ir and x - ray images from recent space missions , mainly from the and the x - ray telescope , to explore the nature of the ir emissions from snrs and the characteristics of their irx flux ratios . these arcsecond - resolution images make it possible to pursue the detailed investigation of the association between the ir and x - ray emissions . we limit our study to galactic snrs in this paper . the twenty galactic snrs studied in this paper are composed of eleven0.7 are not included because these remnants are not clearly visible in the fir band . ] snrs studied by @xcite and nine other snrs that are well - defined in fir band ( e.g. , from 20 @xmath0 m to @xmath5 @xmath0 m ) . in 2 , we summarize ir and x - ray parameters of these snrs , introducing an index for the irx morphological correlation . it is found that the irx flux ratio has a systematic dependence on the irx morphology . in 3 , we compare the observed irx flux ratios to the theoretical ratios expected for hot shocked plasma where dust grains are heated by collisions , and we show that time - dependent dust destruction and non - equilibrium ionization can explain the observed ratios of some snrs but not for most snrs . this result is discussed in 4 together with their irx morphological correlation . we will see that we can infer the natural and/or environmental characteristics of snrs from their irx flux ratios without a prior knowledge on them , which will be very useful to study snrs in external galaxies where we do not have the luxury of observing their morphology . the parameters characterizing global properties of the ir emission from snrs are the ir flux ( @xmath6 ) and color temperature of dust emission ( @xmath7 , hereafter ` dust temperature ' ) . we have derived these parameters for 13 snrs in this work , including 11 snrs studied by @xcite and two large snrs ic 443 and puppis a. for the rest , we adopted the parameters obtained in previous studies . eleven snrs from @xcite are all covered by the mipsgal survey @xcite and the infrared galactic plane survey ( hi - gal ; molinari et al . the former survey is a legacy program of the _ spitzer space telescope _ covering the inner galactic plane ( @xmath863@xmath9 and @xmath10@xmath11 ) in two wavebands ( 24 and 70 @xmath0 m ) using mips , while the latter survey is an open time key project of the _ herschel space observatory _ covering a similar galactic longitude range , i.e. , @xmath860@xmath9 and @xmath12@xmath11 , in five wavebands between 70 and 500 @xmath0 m using the photodetector array camera and spectrometer ( pacs ) and the spectral and photometric imaging receiver ( spire ) . the latitude coverage is @xmath4 except for @xmath13 where the coverage in the mipsgal survey is @xmath14 . we used the fully calibrated mips 24 @xmath0 m images ( version 3.0 ) and pacs 70 @xmath0 m images ( level 2.5 ) , which are available from the _ spitzer _ heritage archive and from the _ herschel _ science archive , respectively . the mips 24 @xmath0 m and pacs 70 @xmath0 m images have comparable spatial resolutions , i.e. , @xmath15 and 5.@xmath16 . @xcite derived total ir fluxes of their sources using 24 and 70 @xmath0 m fluxes , but we have not used 70 @xmath0 m images because they have considerably lower angular resolution ( @xmath17 ) than the 70 @xmath0 m images and are often contaminated by artifacts . the measured 24 and 70 @xmath0 m fluxes of the snrs are listed in table 1 . for most snrs , we simply measured the background - subtracted total flux density inside a circular area surrounding the entire snr with the background level estimated from an annulus just outside the circle . for some snrs , however , the contamination from the foreground and/or background emission is dominant , particularly at 70 @xmath0 m , and an accurate total flux density could not be obtained from such simple analysis . if , for example , we can measure the total 24 @xmath0 m flux density but can measure the 70 @xmath0 m flux density of only a limited region , we scaled the measured 70 @xmath0 m flux density using the ( 70 @xmath0m)/(24 @xmath0 m ) flux ratios of that area to obtain total 70 @xmath0 m flux . for snrs that required a special remedy , we have added notes in table 1 . two large snrs , ic 443 and puppis a , have been observed by @xcite and @xcite , respectively , using the mips in fast scan mode . we have downloaded the archive images from the heritage archive and derived their 24 and 70 @xmath0 m fluxes as above . total ir fluxes and dust temperatures are derived by assuming a single - temperature dust component with a power - law opacity of index 2 , i.e. , @xmath18 and @xmath19 where @xmath20 , with @xmath21 ) is the mass absorption coefficient , @xmath22 and @xmath23 are reference wavelengths of the 24 and 70 @xmath0 m fluxes , and @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the planck functions at the temperature of @xmath7 at wavelengths @xmath22 and @xmath23 , respectively . the reference wavelengths for the 24 and 70 @xmath0 m fluxes are 23.68 and 71.42 @xmath0 m , respectively , while it is 70.0 @xmath0 m for the 70 @xmath0 m flux . note that @xmath26 and @xmath27 in the above equations are the _ color - corrected _ fluxes , which differ from the observed fluxes usually by no more than a few percent . the derived @xmath7 and @xmath28 values are listed in table 1 . for the snrs whose parameters are adopted from previous studies , the references are given in the last column of the table . the fluxes in table 1 should be close to the total ir fluxes of snrs except for rcw 86 , for which the value is the flux of a small portion of the snr ( see note in table 1 ) . there is one caveat . at 24 and 70 @xmath0 m bands , there are ionic lines which can make a significant contribution to the observed fluxes , e.g. , [ fe ii ] 24.5 @xmath0 m , [ fe ii]/[o iv ] 26.0 @xmath0 m , [ s i ] 25.2 @xmath0 m , and [ o i ] 63 @xmath0 m lines . this can happen for snrs where the shock is radiative . for kes 17 , for example , the estimated line contributions are @xmath29% and @xmath30% to the mips 24 and 65 @xmath0 m fluxes , respectively @xcite . if we derive the ir parameters of this remnant using the continuum fluxes only , @xmath6 will be @xmath31% lower , and @xmath7 will be 1.5 k lower than those in table 1 . @xcite obtained mips spectra of 14 galactic snrs with radiative shocks in dense environment , and kes 17 has the highest line contribution to the total ir flux . therefore , we consider that @xmath6 and @xmath7 in table 1 could be overestimated for some snrs because of fir ionic lines but the difference is probably not signicant to affect our analysis in this paper . essential x - ray parameters that we need in this study are the temperature of the x - ray emitting plasma ( @xmath32 ) and soft - x - ray ( 0.32.1 kev ) flux ( @xmath33 ) . another useful parameter is the ionization timescale @xmath34 ( @xmath35 for a constant electron density @xmath36 ) , which is the ` time ' for the plasma to have reached the current ionization state . both the dust and gas cooling rates , and therefore the ratio of irx fluxes , are time - dependent , and can be used as a time parameter ( see the next section ) . x - ray parameters of the 20 snrs are given in table 2 . for snrs whose parameters had been derived from detailed modeling in previous studies , we adopted those parameters . the flux values in the literature are sometimes given in a different energy range than the range of 0.3 @xmath37 2.1 kev adopted in this work . for such cases , we converted the flux value in the literature to the flux of 0.3 @xmath37 2.1 kev by applying a correction factor based on the model and the model fit parameters in the literature . there are remnants where no suitable flux value was available . for these remnants , we extracted spectra of an entire remnant and conducted a spectral fitting adopting the hydrogen column density of the x - ray absorbing gas ( @xmath38 ) from the literature . we note that the unabsorbed flux is insensitive to detailed fit parameters except for the @xmath38 value . for three remnants ( [email protected] , kes 73 and rcw 103 ) , we derived improved fit parameters by conducting a full spectral analysis . for each remnant , the spectra from smaller regions are extracted and are fit with a single non - equilibrium ionization ( nei ) model . @xmath38 , @xmath32 and in table 2 represent ensembles of these values . to derive the flux , the spectrum of the entire region is extracted and fitted with @xmath38 fixed at the value from the previous step . figure 1 shows the ir and x - ray images of the snrs listed in tables 1 and 2 . we see that some snrs such as kepler , [email protected] , and puppis a have similar ir and x - ray morphology , whereas some snrs such as 3c391 , w49b , and ic 443 have either uncorrelated or anticorrelated ir and x - ray morphologies . to represent their formal resemblance in two wavebands , we use pearson s linear correlation coefficient between the ir and x - ray intensities as an index . the pearson s @xmath39 is defined as the covariance of the variables divided by the product of their standard deviations , and it varies from + 1 ( perfect correlation ) to @xmath371 ( perfect anticorrelation ) . it can be obtained straightforwardly once we define the pixels for correlation , e.g. , using the idl procedure correlate . we use the bright pixels contributing 50% of total ir or total x - ray fluxes . that is , we first examine the cumulative brightness distribution of pixels in ir image of a source and determine the brightness level at which the cumulative flux becomes 50% of the total ir flux of the source ( @xmath40 ) . the same can be done for the x - ray image to obtain @xmath41 . then the pixels for the correlation will be the ones with _ either _ its ir brightness greater than @xmath40 _ or _ its x - ray brightness greater than @xmath41 . the adopted percentage ( i.e. , 50% ) is somewhat arbitrary , but it yields correlation coefficients that reasonably characterize the morphological relation between the bright ir and x - ray emissions dominating the fluxes . before deriving the correlation coefficient , we remove strong point sources in the ir and x - ray images and subtract a constant background . we also convolved the ir and x - ray images to the same resolution of 6@xmath4210@xmath42 for sources from / images and 30@xmath42 for sources from x - ray images and resampled them onto the same grid to have the same pixel scale of 1@xmath425@xmath42 per pixel depending on the image size . the computed correlation coefficients are listed in table 3 , while figure 2 shows the scattered diagrams of ir versus x - ray brightnesses used for the computation of for puppis a and w49b which have the largest positive ( 0.76 ) and the largest negative ( @xmath43 ) , respectively . the snrs with relatively large ( @xmath44 ) positive are kepler , [email protected] , g15.9 + 0.2 , kes 73 , kes 75 , the cygnus loop , cas a , puppis a , msh 11@xmath3754 , rcw 86 and rcw 103 . all these snrs appear to have similar ir and x - ray morphologies in figure 1 . the snrs with relatively large ( @xmath45 ) negative are 3c391 , w49b , w44 , and kes 17 . all these snrs appear to have anticorrelated ir and x - ray morphology in figure 1 . the snrs 3c396 , 3c397 , tycho , ic 443 , and g349.7 have close to 0 ( i.e. , @xmath46 to 0.20 ) . these snrs seem to have both correlated and anticorrelated components ( see fig . we emphasize that the correlation coefficients in table 3 are based on the images in figure 1 which are mostly 24 @xmath0 m and 0.32.1 kev images ( see the caption of figure 1 ) . if there are more than one heating mechanism for dust , they could depend on wavelength . we note that the snrs with large negative belong to the category of thermal composite " or mixed - morphology " snrs ( hereafter mm snrs ) that appear shell or composite type in radio but with thermal x - rays inside the snr @xcite , e.g. , 3c391 , w44 , and ic 443 . the ir morphologies of these snrs are very similar to their radio morphologies , which explains their large negative . the correlation coefficient of the mm snrs , which gives , in a sense , the degree of mixed morphology , ranges from @xmath43 to @xmath47 excluding g292.0 + 1.8 which has an unusually large positive ( @xmath48 ) . most of these snrs are thought to be middle - aged snrs interacting with dense ism , e.g. , molecular clouds , and the origin of center - filling thermal x - rays is considered to be either dense clumps evaporating inside hot plasma or the result of large - scale conduction @xcite . however , not all snrs interacting with mcs are mm snrs and vice versa , so their nature is still unclear . for example , g292.0 + 1.8 is a young snr of mixed morphology because of thermal x - rays from sn ejecta and the swept - up circumstellar medium . ( it also has a large positive . ) we will discuss the nature of the snrs with large negative further in 4 . in this section , we first obtain the irx flux ratios of snrs and investigate the relation to their irx morphology . we then compare the observed irx flux ratios to the theoretical ratios expected for hot shocked plasma where dust grains are heated by collisions . we note that the theoretical irx flux ratios of hot dusty plasma are not applicable for some snrs , e.g. , young snrs such as tycho where the x - ray emission is mostly from shocked sn ejecta while the fir emission is from shocked ambient medium or evolved snrs such as ic 443 where the fir emission is mostly from radiatively heated dust . we will see that the irx flux ratios of such snrs are significantly different from theoretical irx flux ratios , so that , even without a prior knowledge , one can infer the natural or / and environmental characteristics of an snr from its irx flux ratio . we define the observed irx flux ratio as @xmath49 and the of 20 snrs obtained from @xmath50 and @xmath51 in tables 1 and 2 are given in table 3 . ranges from 0.32 to 204 . for comparison , @xcite and @xcite obtained @xmath52 to 990 and 1.6240 , respectively . for some snrs , our values differ from those of previous results by more than an order of magnitude , e.g. , ours : those of @xcite are 0.32:6.2 ( 3c397 ) , 15.5:1.6 ( rcw 103 ) , and 62.6:5.1 ( w49b ) . the difference from @xcite values originates mostly from the adopted x - ray fluxes . @xcite used the x - ray fluxes in the snr catalog ] , some of which need to be updated . the difference from the values of @xcite , however , is partly due to different definitions of irx flux ratios . @xcite used x - ray fluxes corrected for nei effects and , for young snrs such as tycho and cas a , they used x - ray fluxes from the swept - up ambient medium while we simply used total fluxes . these factors , which need to be considered in interpreting the irx flux ratios , are discussed in the following sections . figure 3 plots versus . we note that the values of the snrs with negative @xmath53 are generally larger than those of the snrs with positive @xmath53 , or , alternatively , the snrs with high ( @xmath54 ) values have @xmath55 . this suggests that the large scatter could at least be partly explained by the ir emission from these snrs being of different origin , e.g. , the snrs of large negative @xmath53 and high values are mm snrs ( marked by squares in the figure ) where the ir emission is probably from radiatively - heated dust _ not _ from collisionally - heated dust in x - ray emitting plasma ( see 4.2 ) . previous studies showed that the values of snrs are @xmath56 , from which they concluded that dust ir cooling dominates over the x - ray cooling ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? all except two in our sample have @xmath57 which is consistent with the conclusion of previous studies . we have two snrs , i.e. , 3c397 ( 0.32 ) and tycho ( 0.74 ) , that have @xmath58 , but they might have additional x - ray emission ( see 4.1 ) . in figure 4-(a ) , we plot versus the temperature of hot gas @xmath32 for 20 snrs . the figure is similar to figure 1 of @xcite , but there are now 20 snrs ( compared to their 9 ) and their locations in the diagram have been largely shifted . we first note that there is a large scatter in the observed irx flux ratio : snrs of the same x - ray temperature ( @xmath59 k ) have values that differ by more than two orders of magnitude . the dotted line in figure 4-(a ) represents the expected irx ratios for hot , dusty plasma _ in thermal and collisional equilibrium _ ( see * ? ? ? if the plasma is in thermal equilibrium , its cooling rate by dust emission is equal to the heating rate of dust by collisions with electrons , so that the dust cooling function @xmath60 ( erg @xmath61 s@xmath62 ) becomes independent of @xmath36 and @xmath63 but depends on gas temperature @xmath32 and dust composition and size . if the plasma is in collisional equilibrium ( cie ) , the x - ray ( 0.32.1 kev ) gas cooling function @xmath64 is also a function of @xmath32 only . we have calculated the theoretical irx ratio @xmath65 , and the dotted line is for the ism dust model of @xcite , who assumed that 70% of c atoms are locked in graphite grains and all si atoms are locked in silicate ( mgfesio@xmath66 ) grains . for the grain size distribution , we adopted the mrn size distribution @xcite , with minimum and maximum grain radii of @xmath67 m and @xmath68 m , respectively . for @xmath64 , we have used the chianti code ( v7.1.4 ; * ? ? ? * ) assuming the solar abundance of @xcite . we note that , by assuming solar abundance for the hot gas , we repeatedly include heavy elements in gas and dust cooling rates . however , if is to be compared to the ratio of ir and x - ray fluxes obtained from the entire snr , this is not an entirely unacceptable assumption . furthermore , the physical condition for the shocked gas is expected to be very different from this equilibrium condition anyway ( see below ) . figure 4-(a ) shows that all snrs except w44 are below the dotted line . the equilibrium curve in figure 4-(a ) , however , is not applicable to the irx flux ratio of snrs for at least two reasons : first , dust grains are destroyed behind the shock front and therefore the dgr decreases with time . second , it takes time for the swept - up ions to reach cie , so the x - ray cooling rate at the beginning could be much lower or higher than that in the cie model . we have developed a simple plane - shock model to calculate time - dependent curve . ( similar models can be found in previous works , e.g. , see @xcite . ) we assume that dust grains with characteristics of the above equilibrium model are continuously injected into shocked gas . after being injected , they are destroyed by thermal and non - thermal sputtering with ions and the grain size distribution is modified . ( we neglect grain - grain shattering which is important for slow radiative shocks . ) the erosion rates ( @xmath69 ) by sputtering depends on the chemical composition and temperature of the shocked gas as well as the speed of grains through the plasma ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . we adopt @xmath70 and @xmath71 @xmath72 for graphite and silicate grains , respectively . these constant erosion rates are good within about 50% for the temperature range of our sample snrs , i.e. , between @xmath73 k and @xmath74 k ( table 2 ) . the gas density and temperature behind the shock front are assumed to remain the same . we calculated the cooling function of a fluid element and obtained a volume - averaged cooling rate by integrating it . for the x - ray cooling , it is necessary to incorporate the increase of the heavy element abundance of shocked gas with time owing to dust destruction and the different that they experience , but we have found that the flux obtained by assuming a single gives a satisfactory result . figures 5-(a ) and ( b ) show the resulting dust and x - ray cooling functions , respectively . the dust cooling function starts to deviate from the non - destruction case at @xmath75 @xmath76 s , while the x - ray cooling function is much lower or higher than the cie curve initially but approaches to it at @xmath77 @xmath76 s. the resulting time - dependent curves are shown as solid lines in figure 4-(b ) . fluctuates about the equilibrium ratio initially , but it steadily decreases as a result of dust destruction . as increases from @xmath78 to @xmath79 @xmath76 s , decreases in general at @xmath80 k. therefore , the scatter of the observed irx flux ratio in figure 4-(b ) appears to be attributable to an evolutionary effect . the values of snrs derived from the x - ray spectral analysis , however , are mostly @xmath81 @xmath76 s except for the mm snrs ( table 2 ) whereas , if we exclude the snrs with high negative , most snrs excluding the young snrs appear to lie between the two curves of @xmath82 and @xmath79 @xmath76 s in figure 4-(b ) . this inconsistency can be also seen in figure 6 where we plot versus of snrs . if we exclude the snrs with high negative , which are well above the theoretical curves , the snrs are all below the theoretical curve and there appears to be no obvious correlation between and . hence , the scatter in figure 4 may be partly due to an evolutionary effect , but not entirely . we have derived values for the individual snrs from their and @xmath32 in table 2 , and the results are listed in table 3 . figure [ fig7 ] shows that the snrs with negative have @xmath83 , whereas most other snrs have @xmath84 . in conclusion , only for a small number of snrs are the values consistent with that of hot plasma where dust grains are collisionally heated . in this section , we first consider possible physical explanations for the snrs with lower or higher than ( hereafter refered to as snrs with low and high irx flux ratios ) . we then discuss the implication on recent results from the lmc snrs . among the snrs with low values , the most prominent are kepler , cas a , tycho , and 3c397 . these remnants deviate from the curve by an order of magnitude in figure [ fig7 ] . the first three are young historical snrs , and their small values might be due to additional x - ray emission . in cas a and tycho , the x - ray emission is dominated by the x - ray emission from sn ejecta and not by thermal emission from shocked surrounding gas @xcite . in kepler , the x - ray emission from the circumstellar medium is not negligible @xcite . we estimate that @xmath85% of the x - ray flux is from sn ejecta from its soft band ( 0.30.7kev ) image . it is interesting that these snrs do have high positive because the ir and x - ray emissions originate from spatially distinct regions unless the snr contains a large amount of newly - formed sn dust such as cas a. however , such positional shifts between the ir and x - ray sources are small and not apparent in their . the nature of another prominent snr 3c397 is uncertain . it had been proposed to be a middle - aged ( @xmath86 yr ) mm snr evolving in a molecular cloud @xcite . co observation revealed a large molecular cloud along the sight line toward 3c397 @xcite , although there is no direct evidence ( e.g. , h@xmath87 emission ) for the interaction . however , its hard x - ray emission is dominated by sn ejecta , and it has been proposed that 3c397 is a young type ia snr evolving in a medium of low ( @xmath88 @xmath76 ) density @xcite . the location of 3c397 in figure 7 is very different from those of the other evolved mm snrs that have high irx flux ratios , and our result seems to support the latter interpretation , i.e. , a young type ia snr where the x - ray emission inside the snr is largely from sn ejecta . however , the x - ray absorbing column is large ( @xmath89 @xmath90 ) and there is a nearby hii region northwest of the remnant ( 3c397w ; * ? ? ? * ) which is bright in infrared ( see fig . 1 ) , so this conclusion needs to be confirmed by further studies . there are two other mm snrs with small values : g292.0 + 1.8 and 3c396 . g292.0 + 1.8 has significant x - ray emission from sn ejecta @xcite , which explains its small value . note that it has ( @xmath91 ) very different from other mm snrs . for 3c396 , we have not found a plausible explanation . its x - ray emission is partly non - thermal , but its contribution to the soft x - ray flux appears to be negligible @xcite . the other snrs with considerably small values are g15.9 + 0.2 , kes 75 , puppius a , and rcw 86 . these snrs have large and thus the fir emission is thought to be mainly from collisionally - heated dust . their values , however , are smaller than those of by a factor of 25 . ( note that we have excluded the x - ray emission from the central pulsar and the pulsar wind nebula in kes 75 . ) a possible explanation for this difference is that the dgr values in the surrounding media of these snrs are lower than that of the general ism @xcite . indeed , a similar conclusion has been reached for other galactic and magellanic snrs in previous studies @xcite . among the snrs with large , [email protected] , kes 73 , the cygnus loop , and rcw 103 have consistent with , which appears to indicate that the dgr in the ambient or circumstellar medium of these snrs might be equal to that of the general ism . it is , however , noteworthy that there could be some extra contribution to the ir emission , e.g. , ir line and/or radiatively heated dust emission ( see the next section ) . in the cygnus loop , for example , @xcite estimated that about 25% of the iras 60 @xmath0 m emission is from the dust in recombined gas in the postshock layer . from their analysis of a non - radiative shock in the cygnus loop , @xcite concluded that the dgr in the ambient medium is about half that of the general ism . therefore , it is not impossible that these snrs do also have dgr values somewhat below that of the general ism . all the snrs with values significantly larger than those of are mm snrs with large negative , e.g. , w44 , w49b , 3c391 , ic 443 , kes 17 , and g349.7 + 0.2 . the values of some of these snrs are greater than those of by almost by an order of magnitude . the fir emission in these snrs is not correlated with x - rays , and therefore is probably not from collisionally heated dust grains . there could be some contribution from ionic lines to the observed ir flux , but , as we discussed in 2.1 , it is considered to be less than a few tens of percent . another distinct property of these snrs indicating a different origin of the fir emission is their low dust temperatures ( figure 8 ; see also table 1 ) . these snrs have @xmath9251 k whereas most other snrs have @xmath9367 k except for the young snrs kepler and cas a. for collisionally heated dust in hot ( @xmath94 k ) plasma , dust temperature is mainly determined by electron density ( @xmath36 ) , and , for a typical electron density of @xmath95 @xmath76 and silicate grains of radius 0.010.1 @xmath0 m , @xmath9650 k @xcite . therefore , dust temperatures of 5767 k are consistent with the fir emission being largely from collisionally - heated dust grains of radius @xmath97 @xmath0 m , but 4351 k might be rather low . in figure 8 , there appears to be a weak correlation ( correlation coefficient @xmath98 ) between @xmath99 and @xmath7 , and if we naively perform a least - squares fitting excluding the snrs with low values in figure 7 , we obtain @xmath100 where the dust temperature ( @xmath7 ) is in k. if dust grains are heated by collisions in hot plasma , then we do not expect such a correlation because @xmath7 is mainly determined by @xmath36 whereas the irx flux ratio is independent of @xmath36 . instead , the apparent correlation in figure 8 might represent different origins for the dust ir emissions at low and ` high ' temperatures . the low dust temperature and large values of the mm snrs with large negative in figure 8 probably indicate that the fir emission in these snrs is largely from dust heated by shock radiation . all these snrs , e.g. , w44 @xcite , w49b @xcite , ic 443 @xcite , kes 17 @xcite , and g349.7 + 0.2 @xcite , are indeed known to be interacting with dense ambient medium and the shock is largely radiative . in a radiative shock , essentially all the shock energy is converted into uv and x - ray radiation . this uv and x - ray radiation from the hot shocked gas ionizes and heats the surrounding gas to produce an extended temperature plateau region in the postshock cooling layer and also a ` radiative precursor ' in the preshock gas , both of which are at @xmath101 k ( see , for example , @xcite for the structure of radiative shock ) . since at shock speeds @xmath102 , dust grains are mostly not destroyed although their size distribution may be modified by grain - grain shattering @xcite , we expect dust grains in these hot and warm regions that will be mainly heated by attenuated x - ray and uv radiation and also by the recombination radiation from the ionized gas in those regions @xcite . if there are enough gas and dust columns beyond these hot and warm regions , the dust ir emission could be further absorbed by cold dust and re - emitted at longer wavelengths . therefore , we expect that , in these snrs , a significant fraction of the shock energy might be converted into ir radiation of a broad spectral energy distribution at color temperature considerably lower than that of the collisionally heated dust . it would be interesting to determine what fraction of shock energy is converted into the ir emission in these snrs . we define the characteristic efficiency of converting shock energy into ir radiation ( @xmath103 ) for an snr by the following equation @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the ir luminosity , @xmath106 is the hydrogen nuclei number density of the ambient medium , @xmath107 and @xmath108 are the shock speed and radius of the snr , and @xmath109 g is the mean mass per hydrogen nucleus for a gas of cosmic abundance . in the second equation , we normalized the parameters by their typical values , i.e. , @xmath110 ) , @xmath111 ) , and @xmath112 ) . note that @xmath113 is the incoming energy flux , so @xmath103 would be the ratio of ir luminosity to the energy incoming rate for a spherically symmetric snr of radius @xmath108 in a uniform medium with a density of @xmath106 . of course real snrs are not spherically symmetric , and @xmath106 and @xmath107 usually vary over the remnant . for radiative portion of the snrs , we expect @xmath114 @xmath76 and @xmath115 , so the cooling time , @xmath116 yr @xcite , becomes shorter than the age of the snr . we may obtain a constraint on @xmath106 and @xmath107 from x - ray observation by assuming that there is a pressure equilibrium between the shock pressure and the thermal pressure of the x - ray emitting gas , i.e. , @xmath117 where @xmath36 and @xmath32 are the electron density and temperature of hot gas , respectively . ( we assume fully ionized gas with @xmath118 . ) the shock speed then is given by @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the volume filling factor of the x - ray emitting gas and @xmath121 . note that we used @xmath122 ( instead of @xmath36 ) because it is the parameter obtained from x - ray observation , e.g. , x - ray flux is proportional to @xmath123 . if we substitute this shock speed into equation ( 5 ) , the ir luminosity is given by @xmath124 in the above equation , @xmath105 is from the ir observation ( table 1 ) and @xmath122 and @xmath125 are from the x - ray observation ( table 2 ) , so that if we know @xmath120 and @xmath106 we can determine @xmath103 ( assuming that we know the distance to the snr and therefore @xmath108 ) . table 4 summarizes the physical parameters of six snrs with high irx ratios and their @xmath103 . we fixed @xmath126 because the volume filling factors are uncertain , although it has been estimated for some snrs , e.g. , 0.36 ( w49b ; * ? ? ? * ) and @xmath127 ( ic 443 ; * ? ? ? * ) . the ambient density is also uncertain . @xcite showed that some of these snrs , i.e. , w44 , ic 443 , and 3c391 , are well described by an snr model expanding within a molecular cloud with an interclump density of 525 @xmath76 , while @xcite derived a somewhat lower density ( @xmath128 @xmath76 ) for w44 from 21 cm line observations ( see also * ? ? ? we adopted 315 @xmath76 for @xmath106 ( see note in table 4 ) . it is not unusual to observe both atomic and molecular shocks in these snrs , so the @xmath106 values in table 4 should be considered as reference values . note that we can scale the result using @xmath129 ( equation 7 ) . although there are considerable uncertainties in @xmath103 for a particular snr , our result shows that @xmath130% in general . we can imagine that this ` global ' efficiency @xmath103 will be proportional to the fraction of surface area encountering dense ambient medium and thus the local efficiency of converting shock energy into ir radiation could be higher . for comparison , the fraction of shock energy that goes into the collisional - heating of dust is 1%10% for shocks with speeds of 100200 @xcite . therefore , as we expect from their large irx flux ratios , the ir luminosities of these snrs are significantly greater than those from collisionally - heated dust . recently @xcite conducted a systematic study of the lmc snrs using and _ chandra _ data , and showed that the irx flux ratios of the lmc snrs are systematically lower than those of the galactic snrs , which is consistent with the low dgr and the low metallicity of the lmc , i.e. , the dust cooling rate is proportional to the dgr which is one - fourth of the galactic value while the gas cooling rate is proportional to metallicity which is one - half of the galactic value . they further classified the snrs into three groups , i.e. , snrs with definite , partial , and lack of irx correlation , and found that the irx flux ratios of the snrs with a partial or lack of irx morphological correlation are systematically higher than the ones with definite correlation . in figure 9 , we plot the values of the lmc snrs against their dust temperatures . the irx flux ratios are from @xcite while dust temperatures are derived here from the 24 and 70 @xmath0 m fluxes in @xcite . we can see that the snrs with a lack of irx morphological correlation not only have large values but also have low temperatures as we have found for the galactic snrs . their temperature ranges from 45 to 56 k , the maximum of which is a little higher than the 51 k of the galactic snrs . however , the dust temperature of the snrs with definite irx morphological correlation extends over a broad range from 48 to 80 k ( excluding 1987a , for which @xmath7 is 166 k ) . there is one snr ( [email protected] ) with a definite correlation that has an exceptionally low ( @xmath131 k ) dust temperature . @xcite derived a comparable dust temperature ( 4055 k ) for the northern shell of this snr . its low @xmath7 could be due to low electron density combined with low electron temperature , e.g. , @xmath132 @xmath76 and @xmath133 kev @xcite . figure 9 also shows that about two - thirds of the lmc snrs are below the dashed line , which confirms the conclusion of @xcite that the irx flux ratio of the lmc snrs are systematically lower than those of the galactic snrs . ( note that @xcite used the x - ray flux from the chandra snr catalog , so that their irx flux ratios are different from ours . ) in figure 9 , however , the snrs at low and high dust temperatures are not necessarily below the dashed line . this may be because , as we have found in the galactic snrs , the ir emission of the snrs at low temperatures is dominated by radiatively - heated dust grains while the x - ray emission of the snrs at high temperatures is dominated by sn ejecta , so that the low dgr and the low metallicity do not explicitly appear in the irx flux ratio . indeed the snrs with high dust temperatures , i.e. , n132d , n103b , [email protected] , and [email protected] , are all the youngest ( @xmath134 yr ) snrs in the lmc . in conclusion , the location of snrs in the ( , @xmath7 ) diagram reflects the snr environment as well as their natural properties . fir dust emission is a dominant emission for snrs , and it has been pointed out that fir cooling by collisionally - heated dust could be more important than the x - ray cooling by hot gas in snrs over most of their lifetimes . with the development of ir astronomy , this was confirmed by comparing the ir to x - ray fluxes . the observed irx flux ratios however , scatter over three orders of magnitudes , and with the data of several arcminute resolution , it was difficult to explore the true nature of the ir emission for most snrs . in this paper , we conducted a systematic study of the ir and x - ray properties of 20 snrs using the data from recent space missions to reveal details of morphology . we first showed that snrs have diverse relative ir and x - ray morphologies , from very similar to very different , and that their resemblance may be represented by the correlation parameter ( 2.3 ) . we then have derived irx flux ratios ( ) of the snrs and found that there is a systematic dependence on . by comparing to the expected irx flux ratios ( ) for hot plasma where dust grains are collisionally heated , we explored how the irx flux ratios and irx morphology are related to the snr environment and their natural properties . we summarize our main results as follows : \2 . the values of all snrs except a few are all below the expected ratio for hot , dusty plasma of constant dgr in collisional ionization equilibrium . this can be attributed to dust destruction and nei gas cooling behind the shock front in some snrs , but for most snrs values are either considerably larger or smaller than those of . \3 . among the snrs with values significantly less than those of , the most prominent are young snrs such as cas a , kepler , and tycho . in these snrs , the x - ray emission is dominated by metal - rich sn ejecta and our values are not applicable . we consider that this might be also the case for other young snrs with anticorrelated irx morphology in this category . there are , however , also snrs without apparent x - ray emission from sn ejecta . they exhibit good irx morphological correlation . for these snrs , a low dgr of the ambient medium seems to be a plausible explanation . all snrs with values significantly greater than ones have large negative , i.e. , are with anticorrelated irx morphology . the dust temperature of these snrs is systematically lower than those of the other snrs . these snrs are known to be interacting with a dense environment , and the ir emission in these snrs is probably from dust heated by shock radiation rather than by collisions . the global conversion efficiency of shock energy to ir emission is estimated to be more than a few tens of percent . our results show that the irx flux ratios together with dust temperature are useful indicators for the snr environment as well as their natural properties . we may infer that the snrs with small and high @xmath7 values are young snrs with x - ray emission dominated by sn ejecta , whereas the snrs with large and low @xmath7 are evolved snrs interacting with a dense environment . this was confirmed for the snrs in the lmc . such information might be particularly useful for the study of snrs in galaxies where the snrs are not resolved . we thank the anonymous referee and jeonghee rho for their comments which helped to improve the manuscript . this research was supported by the basic science research program through the national research foundation of korea(nrf ) funded by the ministry of science , ict and future planning ( 2014r1a2a2a01002811 ) . k. was supported by nrf(national research foundation of korea ) grant funded by the korean government ( nrf-2012-fostering core leaders of the future basic science program ) . this work is based on observations made with the _ spitzer space telescope _ , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa , data obtained from the _ chandra _ data archive , and observations obtained with _ xmm - newton _ , an esa science mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by esa member states and nasa . this publication makes use of data products from the _ wide - field infrared survey explorer _ , which is a joint project of the university of california , los angeles , and the jet propulsion laboratory / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the _ rosat _ data archive of the max - planck - institut fr extraterrestrische physik ( mpe ) at garching , germany . andersen , m. , rho , j. , reach , w. t. , hewitt , j. w. , & bernard , j. p. 2011 , , 742 , 7 arendt , r. g. 1989 , , 70 , 181 arendt , r. g. , dwek , e. , blair , w. p. , et al . 2010 , , 725 , 585 arendt , r. g. , dwek , e. , & leisawitz , d. 1992 , , 400 , 562 asplund , m. , grevesse , n. , sauval , a. j. , & scott , p. 2009 , , 47 , 481 barlow , m. j. , krause , o. , swinyard , b. m. , et al . 2010 , , 518 , l138 blair , w. p. , ghavamian , p. , long , k. s. , et al . 2007 , , 662 , 998 borkowski , k. j. , williams , b. j. , reynolds , s. p. , et al . 2006 , , 642 , l141 braun , r. , & strom , r. g. 1986 , , 164 , 208 burkey , m. t. , reynolds , s. p. , borkowski , k. j. , & blondin , j. m. 2013 , , 764 , 63 burton , m. , & spyromilio , j. 1993 , proceedings of the astronomical society of australia , 10 , 327 carey , s. j. , noriega - crespo , a. , mizuno , d. r. , et al . 2009 , , 121 , 76 cassam - chena , g. , hughes , j. p. , ballet , j. , & decourchelle , a. 2007 , , 665 , 315 chen , y. , su , y. , slane , p. o. , & wang , q. d. 2004 , , 616 , 885 chevalier , r. a. 1999 , , 511 , 798 cox , d. p. , & raymond , j. c. 1985 , , 298 , 651 cox , d. p. , shelton , r. l. , maciejewski , w. , et al . 1999 , , 524 , 179 draine , b. t. 1981 , , 245 , 880 draine , b. t. 2011 , physics of the interstellar and intergalactic medium ( princeton , nj : princeton univ . press ) draine , b. t. , & mckee , c. f. 1993 , , 31 , 373 draine , b. t. , & salpeter , e. e. 1979 , , 231 , 438 dubner , g. , loiseau , n. , rodrguez - pascual , p. , et al . 2013 , , 555 , a9 dwek , e. 1981 , , 247 , 614 dwek , e. 1987 , , 322 , 812 dwek , e. , arendt , r. g. , bouchet , p. , et al . 2008 , , 676 , 1029 dwek , e. , petre , r. , szymkowiak , a. , & rice , w. l. 1987 , , 320 , l27 dyer , k. k. , & reynolds , s. p. 1999 , , 526 , 365 ferland , g. j. , porter , r. l. , van hoof , p. a. m. , et al . 2013 , , 49 , 137 gelfand , j. d. , castro , d. , slane , p. o. , et al . 2013 , , 777 , 148 gomez , h. l. , clark , c. j. r. , nozawa , t. , et al . 2012 , , 420 , 3557 graham , j. r. , evans , a. , albinson , j. s. , bode , m. f. , & meikle , w. p. s. 1987 , , 319 , 126 green , d. a. 2014 , bulletin of the astronomical society of india , 42 , 47 harrus , i. m. , hughes , j. p. , singh , k. p. , koyama , k. , & asaoka , i. 1997 , , 488 , 781 harrus , i. m. , & slane , p. o. 1999 , , 516 , 811 helfand , d. j. , collins , b. f. , & gotthelf , e. v. 2003 , , 582 , 783 hines , d. c. , rieke , g. h. , gordon , k. d. , et al . 2004 , , 154 , 290 hollenbach , d. , & mckee , c. f. 1979 , , 41 , 555 hollenbach , d. , & mckee , c. f. 1989 , , 342 , 306 hwang , u. , & gotthelf , e. v. 1997 , , 475 , 665 hwang , u. , & laming , j. m. 2012 , , 746 , 130 hwang , u. , petre , r. , & flanagan , k. a. 2008 , , 676 , 378 jeong , i .- g . , koo , b .- c . , & 2012 , publication of korean astronomical society , 27 , 235 jiang , b. , chen , y. , wang , j. , et al . 2010 , , 712 , 1147 jones , a. p. , tielens , a. g. g. m. , & hollenbach , d. j. 1996 , , 469 , 740 kawasaki , m. , ozaki , m. , nagase , f. , inoue , h. , & petre , r. 2005 , , 631 , 935 keohane , j. w. , reach , w. t. , rho , j. , & jarrett , t. h. 2007 , , 654 , 938 koo , b .- c . 2014 , iau symposium , 296 , 214 koo , b .- c . , & heiles , c. 1995 , , 442 , 679 ku , w. h .- m . , kahn , s. m. , pisarski , r. , & long , k. s. 1984 , , 278 , 615 landi , e. , del zanna , g. , young , p. r. , dere , k. p. , & mason , h. e. 2012 , , 744 , 99 lazendic , j. s. , slane , p. o. , hughes , j. p. , chen , y. , & dame , t. m. 2005 , , 618 , 733 lazendic , j. s. , wardle , m. , whiteoak , j. b. , burton , m. g. , & green , a. j. 2010 , , 409 , 371 lee , h .- g . , koo , b .- c . , moon , d .- s . , et al . 2009 , , 706 , 441 lee , j .- , koo , b .- c . , snell , r. l. , et al . 2012 , , 749 , 34 lee , h .- g . , moon , d .- s . , koo , b .- c . , et al . 2011 , , 740 , 31 lee , j .- j . , park , s. , hughes , j. p. , et al . 2010 , , 711 , 861 lee , j .- j . , park , s. , hughes , j. p. , & slane , p. o. 2014 , , 789 , 7 mathis , j. s. , rumpl , w. , & nordsieck , k. h. 1977 , , 217 , 425 molinari , s. , swinyard , b. , bally , j. , et al . 2010 , , 122 , 314 noriega - crespo , a. , hines , d. c. , gordon , k. , et al . 2009 , the evolving ism in the milky way and nearby galaxies , 46 nozawa , t. , kozasa , t. , & habe , a. 2006 , , 648 , 435 ostriker , j. , & silk , j. 1973 , , 184 , l113 park , g. , koo , b .- c . , gibson , s. j. , et al . 2013 , , 777 , 14 park , s. , hughes , j. p. , slane , p. o. , et al . 2004 , , 602 , l33 pinheiro gonalves , d. , noriega - crespo , a. , paladini , r. , martin , p. g. , & carey , s. j. 2011 , , 142 , 47 reach , w. t. , rho , j. , & jarrett , t. h. 2005 , , 618 , 297 raymond , j. c. 1979 , , 39 , 1 reynolds , s. p. , borkowski , k. j. , hwang , u. , et al . 2006 , , 652 , l45 rho , j. 1995 , ph.d . thesis ( univ . of maryland , college park ) rho , j. , & petre , r. 1998 , , 503 , l167 safi - harb , s. , dubner , g. , petre , r. , holt , s. s. , & durouchoux , p. 2005 , , 618 , 321 saken , j. m. , fesen , r. a. , & shull , j. m. 1992 , , 81 , 715 sankrit , r. , williams , b. j. , borkowski , k. j. , et al . 2010 , , 712 , 1092 seok , j. y. , koo , b .- , & hirashita , h. 2015 , , submitted seok , j. y. , koo , b .- c . , & onaka , t. 2013 , , 779 , 134 shull , j. m. , & mckee , c. f. 1979 , , 227 , 131 sibthorpe , b. , ade , p. a. r. , bock , j. j. , et al . 2010 , , 719 , 1553 troja , e. , bocchino , f. , & reale , f. 2006 , , 649 , 258 tsunemi , h. , katsuda , s. , nemes , n. , & miller , e. d. 2007 , , 671 , 1717 vink , j. 2012 , , 20 , 49 weingartner , j. c. , & draine , b. t. 2001 , , 548 , 296 white , r. l. , & long , k. s. 1991 , , 373 , 543 williams , b. j. , borkowski , k. j. , reynolds , s. p. , et al . 2006 , , 652 , l33 williams , b. j. , blair , w. p. , blondin , j. m. , et al . 2011 , , 741 , 96 williams , b. j. , borkowski , k. j. , reynolds , s. p. , et al . 2011 , , 729 , 65 yamaguchi , h. , badenes , c. , foster , a. r. , et al . 2015 , , 801 , l31 llccccc [email protected] & kepler & 9.50 ( 1.0 ) & 10.2 ( 2.7 ) & 75.0 ( -3.5,+5.2 ) & 1.83 ( -0.45,+0.91 ) & 1 + [email protected] & & 38.6 ( 1.5 ) & 124.7 ( 14.0 ) & 61.6 ( -1.1,+1.2 ) & 12.8 ( -1.3,+ 1.6 ) & this work + [email protected] & & 10.1 ( 0.4 ) & 49.1 ( 2.7 ) & 57.8 ( -0.5,+0.6 ) & 4.32 ( -0.24,+0.27 ) & this work + [email protected] & kes 73 & 30.1 ( 1.2 ) & 76.6 ( 4.1 ) & 64.1 ( -0.7,+0.7 ) & 8.73 ( -0.53,+0.61 ) & this work + [email protected] & kes 75 & 10.2 ( 0.4 ) & 27.9 ( 4.9 ) & 63.3 ( -1.6,+2.1 ) & 3.08 ( -0.45,+0.66 ) & this work + [email protected] & 3c391 & 33.9 ( 1.4 ) & 434.9 ( 21.9 ) & 50.3 ( -0.4,+0.4 ) & 28.6 ( -1.3,+ 1.5 ) & this work + [email protected] & w44 & 94.4 ( 9.5 ) & 2243 . ( 114 . ) & 46.5 ( -0.6,+0.7 ) & 129.2 ( -9.2,+11.3 ) & this work + [email protected] & 3c396 & 6.4 ( 0.6 ) & 26.8 ( 1.6 ) & 59.1 ( -0.9,+1.1 ) & 2.49 ( -0.22,+0.28 ) & this work + [email protected] & 3c397 & 18.8 ( 0.8 ) & 101.4 ( 11.9 ) & 56.9 ( -0.9,+1.1 ) & 8.60 ( -0.82,+1.06 ) & this work + [email protected] & w49b & 62.8 ( 2.5 ) & 750 . ( 38 . ) & 50.8 ( -0.4,+0.4 ) & 50.2 ( -2.3,+ 2.6 ) & this work + [email protected] & cygnus loop & 172 . ( 17 . ) & 1430 . ( 140 . ) & 47.5 ( -1.3,+1.7 ) & 85.3 ( -12.6,+20.4 ) & 2 + [email protected] & cas a & 202 . ( 20 . ) & 120 . ( 12 . ) & 85.0 ( -2.4,+3.0 ) & 32.1 ( -5.1,+ 7.3 ) & 3 , 4 + [email protected] & tycho & 19.5 ( 3.0 ) & 38.5 ( 10.8 ) & 66.9 ( -3.0,+4.7 ) & 4.94 ( -1.20,+2.50 ) & 1 + [email protected] & ic 443 & 68.8 ( 6.9 ) & 1349 . ( 202 . ) & 47.6 ( -0.9,+1.2 ) & 80.7 ( -8.9,+12.5 ) & this work + [email protected] & puppis a & 187 . ( 19 . ) & 955 . ( 143 . ) & 56.8 ( -1.3,+1.7 ) & 82.9 ( -10.8,+15.6 ) & this work + [email protected] & msh 11@xmath3754 & 12.0 ( 0.7 ) & 30.6 ( 6.1 ) & 64.0 ( -1.9,+2.5 ) & 3.48 ( -0.58,+0.91 ) & 5 + [email protected] & kes 17 & 2.2 ( 0.4 ) & 75 . ( 15 . ) & 44.4 ( -1.1,+1.6 ) & 4.08 ( -0.59,+0.96 ) & 6 + [email protected] & rcw 86 & 0.69 ( 0.19 ) & 3.10 ( 1.06 ) & 58.5 ( -3.0,+5.5 ) & 0.28 ( -0.08,+0.20 ) & 7 + [email protected] & rcw 103 & 75.0 ( 7.5 ) & 137.0 ( 17.2 ) & 67.9 ( -1.7,+2.1 ) & 18.3 ( -2.6,+ 3.7 ) & this work + g349.7@xmath136 & & 39.6 ( 3.9 ) & 435.0 ( 21.8 ) & 51.4 ( -0.7,+0.8 ) & 29.8 ( -2.3,+ 2.8 ) & this work + llllllc [email protected] & kepler & 0.52 ( ... , ... ) & 1.2 ( ... , ... ) & 1.1 ( ... , ... ) & 1.02 ( ... , ... ) & 2 , 2 , 2 , 1 + [email protected] & & 2.2 ( -0.4 , 0.6 ) & 0.7 ( -0.1 , 0.2 ) & 0.86 ( -0.19 , 3.4 ) & 0.87 ( -0.42 , 1.08 ) & 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 + [email protected] & & 3.9 ( -0.2 , 0.2 ) & 0.9 ( -0.1 , 0.1 ) & 0.54 ( -0.14 , 0.26 ) & 0.46 ( -0.01 , 0.06 ) & 3 , 3 , 3 , 1 + [email protected] & kes 73 & 2.35 ( -0.15 , 0.65 ) & 0.75 ( -0.15 , 0.15 ) & 0.90 ( -0.1 , 0.6 ) & 0.43 ( -0.07 , 0.61 ) & 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 + [email protected] & kes 75 & 3.96 ( ... , ... ) & 0.69 ( -0.02 , 0.01 ) & 1.5 ( -0.7 , 0.7 ) & 0.42 ( ... , ... ) & 4 , 4 , 4 , 4 + [email protected] & 3c391 & 3.1 ( -0.1 , 0.1 ) & 0.56 ( -0.01 , 0.01 ) & @xmath137 & 0.49 ( ... , ... ) & 5 , 5 , 5 , 5 + [email protected] & w44 & 1.0 ( -0.2 , 0.6 ) & 0.88 ( -0.14 , 0.14 ) & 2.0 ( -0.7 , 4.3 ) & 0.64 ( ... , ... ) & 6 , 6 , 6 , 6 + [email protected] & 3c396 & 4.65 ( -0.26 , 0.11 ) & 0.62 ( -0.03 , 0.1 ) & 1.20 ( -0.48 , 0.66 ) & 0.46 ( ... , ... ) & 7 , 7 , 7 , 7 + [email protected] & 3c397 & 3.05 ( -0.2 , 0.2 ) & 0.21 ( -0.01 , 0.02 ) & 1.4 ( -0.6 , 0.7 ) & 27 . ( -6 , 8) & 8 , 8 , 8 , 1 + [email protected] & w49b & 5.2 ( ... , ... ) & 0.25 ( -0.03 , 0.03 ) & @xmath138 & 3.40 ( ... , ... ) & 9 , 9 , 9 , 9 + [email protected] & cygnus loop & 0.04 ( ... , ... ) & 0.23 ( -0.01 , 0.01 ) & 2.0 ( -0.1 , 0.1 ) & 9.98 ( ... , ... ) & 10,10,10,11 + [email protected] & cas a & 1.4 ( -0.5 , 0.5 ) & 1.7 ( -0.4 , 0.4 ) & 2.5 ( -1.5 , 1.5 ) & 18.7 ( ... , ... ) & 12,13,13 , 1 + [email protected] & tycho & 0.70 ( ... , ... ) & 0.85 ( -0.15 , 0.25 ) & 1.00 ( -0.21 , 0.3 ) & 6.7 ( ... , ... ) & 14,15,15 , 1 + [email protected] & ic 443 & 0.69 ( -0.15 , 0.15 ) & 0.42 ( -0.16 , 0.16 ) & @xmath139 & 2.9 ( -1.3 , 1.3 ) & 16,16,16,16 + [email protected] & puppis a & 0.24 ( -0.1 , 0.11 ) & 0.63 ( -0.11 , 0.1 ) & 1.7 ( -1 , 1 ) & 21 . ( ... , ... ) & 17,17,17,18 + [email protected] & msh 11@xmath3754 & 0.54 ( -0.04 , 0.04 ) & 0.66 ( -0.04 , 0.12 ) & 7.2 ( -1.7 , 2.5 ) & 2.04 ( -0.44 , 0.58 ) & 19,20,20 , 1 + [email protected] & kes 17 & 3.79 ( -0.14 , 0.03 ) & 0.76 ( -0.01 , 0.03 ) & @xmath140 & 0.09 ( ... , ... ) & 21,21,21,21 + [email protected] & rcw 86 & 0.63 ( -0.05 , 0.03 ) & 0.28 ( -0.01 , 0.02 ) & 0.99 ( -0.12 , 0.12 ) & 0.13 ( ... , ... ) & 22,22,22,22 + [email protected] & rcw 103 & 0.55 ( -0.25 , 0.15 ) & 0.50 ( -0.1 , 0.1 ) & 1.55 ( -0.35 , 0.95 ) & 1.18 ( -0.68 , 0.13 ) & 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 + g349.7@xmath136 & & 7.10 ( -0.1 , 0.1 ) & 0.76 ( -0.03 , 0.05 ) & @xmath138 & 0.37 ( ... , ... ) & 23,23,23,23 + [email protected] & kepler & s & 0.56 & 1.82 ( -0.70 , 1.05 ) & 30.6 ( ... , ... ) + [email protected] & & c & 0.48 & 15.1 ( -7.4 , 18.8 ) & 18.0 ( -2.6 , 6.2 ) + [email protected] & & s & 0.42 & 9.59 ( -0.56 , 1.39 ) & 20.2 ( -2.4 , 3.9 ) + [email protected] & kes 73 & s ? & 0.45 & 20.8 ( -3.6 , 29.5 ) & 19.2 ( -3.5 , 5.2 ) + [email protected] & kes 75 & c & 0.38 & 7.50 ( -2.49 , 2.76 ) & 19.0 ( -1.7 , 0.6 ) + [email protected] & 3c391 & s(y ) & -0.49 & 58.8 ( -17.8 , 17.9 ) & @xmath141 + [email protected] & w44 & c(y ) & -0.55 & 203.8 ( -62.8 , 63.6 ) & 24.3 ( -6.8 , 3.0 ) + [email protected] & 3c396 & c(y ) & -0.16 & 5.52 ( -1.72 , 1.76 ) & 16.7 ( -1.4 , 3.3 ) + [email protected] & 3c397 & s(y ) & 0.02 & 0.32 ( -0.08 , 0.10 ) & 9.72 ( -1.21 , 2.55 ) + [email protected] & w49b & s(y ) & -0.59 & 15.0 ( -4.6 , 4.6 ) & @xmath142 + [email protected] & cygnus loop & s & 0.40 & 12.3 ( -3.9 , 4.1 ) & 8.63 ( -0.27 , 0.26 ) + [email protected] & cas a & s & 0.30 & 1.74 ( -0.59 , 0.65 ) & 50.2 ( -18.4 , 13.7 ) + [email protected] & tycho & s & 0.20 & 0.75 ( -0.29 , 0.44 ) & 21.5 ( -3.6 , 7.9 ) + [email protected] & ic 443 & c(y ) & -0.15 & 27.8 ( -12.8 , 13.2 ) & @xmath143 + [email protected] & puppis a & s & 0.76 & 4.01 ( -1.31 , 1.42 ) & 17.4 ( -3.5 , 3.0 ) + [email protected] & msh 11 - 54 & s(y ) & 0.46 & 1.75 ( -0.47 , 0.67 ) & 14.6 ( -2.8 , 4.6 ) + [email protected] & kes 17 & s(y ) & -0.28 & 43.4 ( -14.5 , 16.5 ) & @xmath144 + [email protected] & rcw 86 & s & 0.69 & 2.23 ( -0.91 , 1.68 ) & 10.7 ( -0.3 , 0.3 ) + [email protected] & rcw 103 & s & 0.47 & 15.8 ( -9.4 , 3.6 ) & 13.8 ( -2.6 , 2.7 ) + g349.7@xmath136 & & s(y ) & 0.05 & 81.6 ( -25.3 , 25.7 ) & @xmath145 + lrrllrllll 3c391 & 8.0 & 7.5 & 9.8e+02 & 0.65 & 2.04 & 7.5e+04 & 10 & 144 & 0.76 + w44 & 3.0 & 11.0 & 1.8e+02 & 1.02 & 0.43 & 5.7e+04 & 3 & 152 & 0.64 + w49b & 11.4 & 6.6 & 1.4e+04 & 0.29 & 12.23 & 2.6e+05 & 10 & 237 & 0.80 + ic 443 & 1.5 & 7.0 & 2.0e+02 & 0.49 & 1.14 & 1.5e+04 & 15 & 76 & 0.39 + kes17 & 10.0 & 10.0 & 2.8e+02 & 0.88 & 0.69 & 4.2e+04 & 10 & 98 & 0.24 + g349.7 + 0.2 & 22.0 & 6.4 & 5.6e+03 & 0.88 & 6.04 & 4.4e+05 & 10 & 290 & 1.0 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: let @xmath0 be a coxeter system . there is a canonical real representation of @xmath1 which is called the _ geometric representation _ of @xmath0 and which is known to be faithful by the work of tits in the 1960s ( a proof can be found in @xcite . in the proof he considers a convex cone @xmath2 in the dual module which is stabilized under the action of @xmath1 . by means of the standard generating set @xmath3 he defines an open simplicial cone @xmath4 which turns out to be a prefundamental domain for the action of @xmath1 on @xmath2 . it is now the standard terminology to call the cone @xmath2 the _ tits cone _ and @xmath4 the _ ( open ) fundamental chamber_. the conjugates of the fundamental generators act as linear reflections on the module and its dual . their reflection hyperplanes yield a simplicial decomposition of @xmath2 and thus provide a simplicial complex which is the _ coxeter complex _ of @xmath0 . the geometric representation of @xmath0 , the geometry of the tits cone , and the properties of the coxeter complex are fundamental tools for the investigation of coxeter groups . coxeter systems play an important role in various branches of mathematics . in combinatorics and geometric group theory they are a rich source of interesting phenomena ( @xcite , @xcite ) . in representation theory and the theory of algebraic groups the _ crystallographic _ coxeter systems occur as _ weyl groups _ of several structures . there , they play the role of basic invariants , often called the _ type _ of the algebraic object under consideration . in @xcite and @xcite _ weyl groupoids _ and their root systems have been introduced as basic invariants of nichols algebras . their definition emerged from earlier work in @xcite and @xcite , they are natural generalizations of weyl groups . weyl groupoids of finite type are those which generalize finite weyl groups . these have been studied intensively in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , where a classification has been obtained . this classification is considerably harder than the classification of the finite weyl groups . it was observed by the first two authors in 2009 that the final outcome of this classification in rank 3 is intimately related to grnbaum s list of simplicial arrangements in @xcite . there is an obvious explanation of this connection : to each weyl groupoid one can associate a tits cone which is the whole space if and only if the weyl groupoid is of finite type . based on these considerations , _ crystallographic _ arrangements have been introduced in @xcite , where it is shown that their classification is a consequence of the classification of finite weyl groupoids . in view of the importance of the tits cone and the coxeter complex for the understanding of coxeter systems it is natural to investigate their analogues in the context of weyl groupoids . although it is intuitively clear what has to be done in order to generalize these notions , there are instances where things have to be modified or some extra argument is needed . our intention is to provide the basic theory of the tits cone and the coxeter complex of a weyl groupoid . this paper deals with the combinatorial aspects of this project and therefore the crystallographic condition does nt play a role at all . hence , here we deal with _ tits arrangements _ rather than with weyl groupoids . the basic strategy for setting up the framework is to start with a simplicial arrangement @xmath5 on a convex open cone @xmath2 and to investigate the abstract simplicial complex @xmath6 associated with it . this is a _ gated chamber complex _ and has therefore a natural type function . we call a simplicial arrangement on a convex open cone a tits arrangement if @xmath7 is a thin chamber complex and introduce the notion of a root system of a tits arrangement . given a simplicial arrangement of rank @xmath8 on an open convex cone , there are two canonical procedures to produce simplicial arrangements of smaller rank . we would like to point out that this paper is meant to be a contribution to the foundations of the theory of weyl groupoids of arbitrary type . the concepts and ideas are at least folklore and several of the results for which we give proofs are well established in the literature . the only exception is probably our systematic use of gated chamber complexes at some places . our principal goal here is to provide a fairly complete account of the basic theory of the tits cone of a weyl groupoid by developing the corresponding notions to the extent that is needed for just this purpose . therefore , we have decided to include short proofs for standard facts and refer to other sources only when we need a more elaborate result . we are not able to give a systematic account of the origins of the concepts and ideas which play a role in this paper . here are some comments based on the best of our knowledge : 1 . simplicial arrangements were first introduced and studied by melchior @xcite and subsequently by grnbaum @xcite . shortly afterwards , simplicial arrangements attracted attention in the seminal work of deligne @xcite : they are a natural context to study the @xmath9 property of complements of reflection arrangements , since the set of reflection hyperplanes of a finite coxeter group is a simplicial arrangement . they further appeared as examples or counterexamples to conjectures on arrangements . 2 . we do not know where arrangements of hyperplanes on convex cones were considered for the first time . the concept seems most natural and they are mentioned in @xcite without further reference . of course , our definition of a simplicial arrangement on an open convex cone is inspired by the tits cone of a coxeter system . the fact that arrangements of hyperplanes provide interesting examples of gated sets in metric spaces appears in @xcite for the first time . at least in the simplicial case it was observed much earlier @xcite . the observation that there is a natural link between root systems and simplicial arrangements is quite natural . we already mentioned that it was our starting point to investigate the tits - cone of a weyl groupoid . but it also appears in dyer s work on rootoids @xcite , @xcite . it is conceivable that the observation was made much earlier by other people and is hidden somewhere in the literature . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : ex ] we will provide some basic examples for our objects of interest . these will be used for later reference , since they are either basic examples or counterexamples for the properties which we introduce . like in example [ exm : thinf ] , the geometric representation of a coxeter group is a prominent sample for simplicial arrangements . in section [ sec : hyp ] we fix notation and develop the notion of a hyperplane arrangement on an open convex cone in a real vector space @xmath10 . we introduce the common substructures for these objects , i. e. subarrangements and restrictions . furthermore we define the chamber graph of an arrangement and show that parabolic subsets of the set of chambers are gated subsets with respect to the canonical metric . in section [ sec : tits ] we introduce simplicial arrangements and tits arrangements . we add additional combinatorial structure to a tits arrangement by associating to the set of hyperplanes a set of roots , linear forms which define the hyperplanes . with respect to the study of nichols algebras root systems with additional properties will be interesting , however in this paper we deal with roots systems as very general objects . we also associate to a simplicial arrangement a canonical simplicial complex . the main results regarding this complex are proven in the appendix . in section [ subarr ] we consider subarrangements and restrictions of simplicial arrangements and tits arrangements . we give criteria when the substructures of a simplicial / tits arrangement is again a simplicial / tits arrangement , and in the case of a tits arrangement we describe canonical root systems . the appendix provides proofs for the properties of the poset associated to a simplicial hyperplane arrangement which are stated in section 4 . while most of these properties are quite intuitive , a rigid proof can be tedious . appendix [ app : simpcomp ] recalls the basic definitions of simplicial complexes as we need them . in appendix [ app : s ] we show that the poset @xmath11 associated to a simplicial hyperplane arrangement @xmath12 is indeed a simplicial complex . the results of this section are summarized in proposition [ ssimpcomp ] . in particular , we provide an equivalent definition for simplicial cones , which has an implicit simplicial structure . appendix [ app : scc ] provides the remaining properties of @xmath13 . the first part recalls the definitions of chamber complexes and type functions . in the second part it is shown that @xmath13 is a gated chamber complex with a type function , a collection of the results can be found in proposition [ prop - sproperties ] . we also show that the notions of being spheric and thin , which we introduced for simplicial hyperplane arrangements before , coincide with the classical notions for chamber complexes . * acknowledgements . * part of the results were achieved during a mini - workshop on nichols algebras and weyl groupoids at the mathematisches forschungsinstitut oberwolfach in october 2012 , and during meetings in kaiserslautern , hannover , and giessen supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft within the priority programme 1388 . one of the authors was partly funded by a scholarship of the justus - liebig - universitt giessen . consider the following setting . let @xmath14 then @xmath15 consists of two connected components @xmath16 let @xmath17 , @xmath18 be the dual basis in @xmath19 to @xmath20 , then we can write @xmath21 we will later define objects which can be written in this way , i. e. as intersections of half spaces , as simplicial cones . both @xmath22 and @xmath23 are cones with exactly two bounding hyperplanes , for @xmath22 these are @xmath24 and @xmath25 , for @xmath23 these are @xmath26 and @xmath27 . note that in this example only one of the bounding hyperplanes , namely @xmath26 , of @xmath22 , @xmath23 meets @xmath2 , while the other meets @xmath28 , but not @xmath2 itself . . ] [ exm : notthin ] let @xmath10 and @xmath2 be as before . define for @xmath29 the lines @xmath30 then the connected components of @xmath31 are again simplicial cones for suitable linear forms . the number of connected components is not finite in this case , and every component has bounding hyperplanes which meet @xmath2 ( see figure [ fig : thinf ] ) . . ] [ exm : thinf ] let @xmath32 and @xmath33 then @xmath2 is a convex open cone . consider the universal coxeter group @xmath1 in 3 generators , i. e. @xmath34 the geometric representation ( see ( * ? ? ? * chapter 5.3 ) ) of @xmath1 yields a set of reflection hyperplanes @xmath35 , which meet @xmath2 after choosing a suitable basis . we obtain the picture in figure [ fig : univ3 ] by intersecting @xmath2 with a hyperplane parallel to @xmath36 , which corresponds to the beltrami - klein model of hyperbolic 2-space . . ] the connected components of @xmath37 are again cones which carry a simplicial structure . however , the vertices of the simplices are not contained in @xmath2 , but in its boundary @xmath38 . [ exm : univ3 ] throughout this paper , all topological properties are with respect to the standard topology of @xmath39 , unless stated otherwise . let @xmath40 . a subset @xmath41 is called a _ cone _ , if @xmath42 for all @xmath43 , @xmath44 . for a subset @xmath45 we call @xmath46 the _ cone over @xmath47_. let @xmath35 be a set of linear hyperplanes in @xmath40 , and @xmath2 an open convex cone . we say that _ @xmath35 is locally finite in @xmath2 _ , if for every @xmath48 there exists a neighborhood @xmath49 of @xmath50 , such that @xmath51 is a finite set . a _ hyperplane arrangement ( of rank @xmath8 ) _ is a pair @xmath12 , where @xmath2 is a convex open cone in @xmath10 , and @xmath35 is a ( possibly infinite ) set of linear hyperplanes such that 1 . @xmath52 for all @xmath53 , 2 . @xmath35 is locally finite in @xmath2 . if @xmath2 is unambiguous from the context , we also call the set @xmath35 a hyperplane arrangement . let @xmath54 . then the _ support of @xmath47 _ is defined as @xmath55 if @xmath56 is a singleton , we write @xmath57 instead of @xmath58 , and we omit the index @xmath35 , if @xmath35 is unambiguous from the context . in this paper we call the set @xmath59 the _ section of @xmath47 ( in @xmath35)_. again , we will omit @xmath35 when there is no danger of confusion . the connected components of @xmath37 are called _ chambers _ , denoted with @xmath60 or just @xmath61 , if @xmath62 is unambiguous . let @xmath63 . define the _ walls of @xmath64 _ as @xmath65 define the _ radical of @xmath35 _ as @xmath66 . we call the arrangement _ non - degenerate _ , if @xmath67 , and _ degenerate _ otherwise . a hyperplane arrangement is _ thin _ , if @xmath68 for all @xmath69 . 1 . by construction , the chambers @xmath70 are open sets . 2 . in our notation , if @xmath62 is a hyperplane arrangement , @xmath35 being locally finite in @xmath2 implies : for every point @xmath48 there exists a neighborhood @xmath49 of @xmath50 such that @xmath71 is finite . let @xmath12 be a hyperplane arrangement . then for every point @xmath48 there exists a neighborhood @xmath72 such that @xmath73 . furthermore the set @xmath74 is finite for every compact set @xmath75 . [ compfin ] let @xmath48 , in particular there exists an open neighborhood @xmath76 of @xmath50 such that @xmath77 is finite . by taking the smallest open @xmath78-ball contained in @xmath76 and centred at @xmath50 , we can assume @xmath79 . let @xmath80 , with @xmath81 . let @xmath82 , then @xmath83 , and @xmath84 is an open subset such that @xmath85 . since @xmath77 is finite , @xmath86 is finite . we can therefore repeat this process finitely many times until we find an open ball @xmath87 such that @xmath88 . the second assertion is a consequence of the first : let @xmath47 be compact , and for @xmath89 let @xmath72 denote an open subset such that @xmath90 . then @xmath91 as @xmath92 . but the @xmath72 are open and @xmath47 is compact , therefore there exists a finite set @xmath93 , @xmath94 , such that @xmath95 consequently , if @xmath96 , then there exists an index @xmath97 such that @xmath98 and @xmath99 . hence @xmath100 and @xmath74 is finite . we want to say more about hyperplane arrangements arising as @xmath101 for points @xmath102 . let @xmath103 be a hyperplane arrangement and let @xmath102 . if @xmath104 , we call @xmath105 a _ subarrangement of @xmath62_. define @xmath106 , we call @xmath107 the _ induced arrangement at @xmath50 _ or the _ parabolic subarrangement at @xmath50_. a _ parabolic subarrangement of @xmath62 _ is a subarrangement @xmath108 of @xmath62 , such that @xmath109 for some @xmath102 . furthermore set @xmath110 . let @xmath111 be a connected metric space . define the segment between @xmath112 to be @xmath113 when referring to the metric of @xmath39 , we will use the more common notion of the _ interval _ between two points @xmath50 and @xmath114 : @xmath115 & : = \sigma(x , y ) = \{\lambda x + ( 1 - \lambda ) y \in { { \mathbb{r}}}^r \mid \lambda \in [ 0,1 ] \},\\ ( x , y ) & : = \sigma(x , y)\setminus \{x , y\ } = \{\lambda x + ( 1 - \lambda ) y \in { { \mathbb{r}}}^r \mid \lambda \in ( 0,1 ) \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the intervals @xmath116 $ ] , @xmath117 can be defined analogously . note that every hyperplane @xmath118 separates @xmath10 into half - spaces . one way to describe the half - spaces uses linear forms . choose an arbitrary linear form @xmath119 such that @xmath120 . then @xmath121 and @xmath122 ( @xmath123 and @xmath124 ) are the two _ open ( closed ) half - spaces bounded by @xmath118_. for an arbitrary subset @xmath75 , if @xmath47 is contained in one open half space bounded by @xmath118 , we denote this particular half - space by @xmath125 . in this case we write @xmath126 for the unique half - space not containing @xmath47 . by definition every chamber @xmath64 is contained in a unique half space of @xmath53 , therefore the sets @xmath127 exist for all @xmath53 , @xmath128 . let @xmath129 be chambers , we say that @xmath53 _ separates _ @xmath64 and @xmath26 , if @xmath130 . we also say that two closed chambers @xmath131 are _ separated _ by @xmath53 , if @xmath118 separates @xmath64 and @xmath26 . we denote by @xmath132 the set of hyperplanes separating @xmath129 . if @xmath133 , @xmath134 , then @xmath135 . [ starsep ] assume @xmath136 , then the half - space @xmath137 is well defined and unique . as a consequence we have @xmath138 , and @xmath118 does not separate @xmath64 and @xmath26 . the pair @xmath139 is a hyperplane arrangement with chambers corresponding to @xmath140 . [ lem : subarr ] the set @xmath107 is locally finite in @xmath2 since @xmath35 is locally finite in @xmath2 , and every @xmath135 meets @xmath2 . let @xmath141 denote the connected components of @xmath142 . assume @xmath143 are both contained in @xmath144 . then there exists a hyperplane @xmath53 such that @xmath22 , @xmath23 are contained in different half - spaces with respect to @xmath118 , in contradiction to lemma [ starsep ] . since @xmath145 , every chamber in @xmath140 is therefore contained in a unique chamber in @xmath141 . likewise , every chamber in @xmath146 contains a chamber in @xmath147 , which completes the proof . we note that it is always possible to mod out the radical of an arrangement to obtain a non - degenerate one . assume that @xmath62 is a hyperplane arrangement , set @xmath148 and 1 . @xmath149 , 2 . @xmath150 , 3 . @xmath151 , 4 . @xmath152 . note that the set @xmath107 is clearly finite if @xmath48 . the set @xmath153 is an open convex cone in @xmath154 . the set @xmath155 is open as the image of an open set and @xmath156 is open . furthermore , if @xmath157 $ ] is an interval in @xmath155 , then there exist @xmath158 with @xmath159 , @xmath160 . the interval @xmath161 $ ] is contained in @xmath2 as @xmath2 is convex , and we find @xmath162 ) = [ y , z]$ ] . finally , @xmath153 is a cone , since for @xmath163 we find @xmath164 with @xmath165 . since @xmath2 is a cone , for every @xmath166 we have @xmath167 , so @xmath168 . we gather basic properties of @xmath169 . the pair @xmath170 is a non - degenerate hyperplane arrangement with chambers @xmath171 . the chambers are furthermore in one to one correspondence to @xmath70 . [ lem : red ] the set @xmath169 is a set of hyperplanes in @xmath154 , since @xmath172 for all @xmath53 . let @xmath173 with @xmath174 for @xmath53 , then @xmath175 , since @xmath52 . we show that @xmath169 is locally finite in @xmath153 . let @xmath176 , then there exists an @xmath164 such that @xmath177 . since @xmath35 is locally finite in @xmath2 , there exists a neighborhood @xmath178 containing @xmath179 such that @xmath180 is finite . as @xmath156 maps open sets to open sets , @xmath181 is a neighborhood of @xmath114 in @xmath153 . now let @xmath182 for some @xmath183 . let @xmath173 with @xmath184 and assume @xmath185 . then there exists @xmath186 with @xmath187 and @xmath188 with @xmath189 , thus @xmath190 for some @xmath191 . hence @xmath192 as well , and we can conclude that @xmath193 . we have thus established for @xmath53 @xmath194 therefore @xmath195 is finite . for the chambers , note that @xmath196 is a connected component of @xmath197 , in particular , as @xmath198 , @xmath199 , furthermore for a connected component @xmath146 of @xmath197 , @xmath200 is a connected component of @xmath37 . this completes the proof . let @xmath62 be a hyperplane arrangement , @xmath102 . then set @xmath201 , @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath205 . the pair @xmath206 is a non - degenerate hyperplane arrangement with chambers @xmath207 . [ cor : redsub ] this follows from lemma [ lem : subarr ] and lemma [ lem : red ] , since @xmath208 . the hyperplane arrangement in example [ exm : notthin ] is degenerate , as @xmath209 . reducing this arrangement yields the non degenerate and thin hyperplane arrangement @xmath210 . [ exm : deg ] we now consider the structure given by the chambers and their adjacency . let @xmath62 be a hyperplane arrangement . we call two chambers @xmath211 _ adjacent _ , if @xmath212 is a hyperplane . if @xmath129 are are adjacent and @xmath213 , then we also call @xmath129 to be _ adjacent by @xmath118_. define the _ chamber graph _ @xmath214 to be the simplicial graph with vertex set @xmath70 , @xmath215 is an edge if and only if @xmath64 and @xmath26 are adjacent . we call a path in @xmath216 connecting @xmath217 a _ gallery from @xmath64 to @xmath26_. we say a gallery from @xmath64 to @xmath26 is _ minimal _ , if it is of length @xmath218 , where @xmath219 is the distance in @xmath216 . let @xmath220 , @xmath221 , @xmath222 . then @xmath223)$ ] , and @xmath224 is finite . [ finsep ] as @xmath2 is convex , the line @xmath225 $ ] is contained in @xmath2 , and is compact . therefore , as @xmath35 is locally finite , by lemma [ compfin ] @xmath226)$ ] is finite . let @xmath53 and assume @xmath227 $ ] is empty , then @xmath228)$ ] is well - defined and @xmath229 ) = d_h(l)$ ] , so @xmath118 does not separate @xmath64 and @xmath26 . we can conclude @xmath230)$ ] . on the other hand , let @xmath231)$ ] . since @xmath221 , @xmath222 , the interval @xmath225 $ ] is not contained in @xmath118 and neither @xmath232 nor @xmath233 is in @xmath118 . assume @xmath234 , since @xmath235 is convex , we obtain @xmath225 \subset d_h(\{v\})$ ] , contradicting our assumption . therefore @xmath236 . this yields @xmath226 ) \subseteq s(k , l)$ ] . two chambers @xmath220 are adjacent by @xmath118 if and only if @xmath237 . in this situation @xmath26 is the unique chamber adjacent to @xmath64 by @xmath118 . [ adjsep ] assume first that @xmath129 are adjacent by @xmath118 . so @xmath238 . note that @xmath239 by definition . since @xmath240 , the set @xmath241 is a convex cone spanning @xmath118 . take a point @xmath50 in the interior of @xmath242 . for a suitable @xmath243 we find @xmath244 and @xmath245 . the hyperplane @xmath118 separates @xmath246 into two connected components , say @xmath247 and @xmath248 . since @xmath64 is open , @xmath249 , w. l. o. g. @xmath64 meets @xmath247 . since @xmath245 , indeed we find @xmath250 . assuming that @xmath26 meets @xmath247 implies that @xmath251 , but then @xmath252 generates @xmath10 , contradicting the assumption of @xmath64 and @xmath26 being adjacent . thus @xmath253 , and @xmath118 separates @xmath64 and @xmath26 . assume @xmath254 such that @xmath255 separates @xmath64 and @xmath26 . then @xmath256 and @xmath257 , in particular @xmath258 . this implies @xmath259 , therefore @xmath260 . for the other implication assume that @xmath118 is the unique hyperplane separating @xmath64 and @xmath26 . in this case , note that @xmath64 and @xmath26 are distinct . if @xmath118 is not in @xmath261 , @xmath64 and @xmath26 are on the same side of every wall of @xmath64 , thus equal , a contradiction . therefore @xmath239 . consider @xmath221 and @xmath222 . the interval @xmath225 $ ] meets only @xmath118 by lemma [ finsep ] . therefore @xmath225 \cap h = \{p\}$ ] , with @xmath262 . since @xmath35 is locally finite , by lemma [ compfin ] we find a neighborhood @xmath76 of @xmath263 such that @xmath264 . again @xmath76 is separated by @xmath118 into two connected components , one contained in @xmath64 , one in @xmath26 . therefore @xmath265 is contained in @xmath266 and this set generates @xmath118 . thus @xmath64 and @xmath26 are adjacent . for the second statement assume @xmath267 is a chamber adjacent to @xmath64 by @xmath118 . then we established @xmath268 . if @xmath269 , there exists a hyperplane @xmath255 separating @xmath26 and @xmath267 , and we can assume @xmath270 and @xmath271 . then @xmath255 separates @xmath64 and @xmath267 , which implies @xmath259 . this contradicts the fact that @xmath270 . let @xmath69 , @xmath272 . then there exists a chamber @xmath26 adjacent to @xmath64 by @xmath118 . [ lem : adjex ] take a point @xmath50 in the interior of @xmath273 with respect to @xmath118 and a neighborhood @xmath76 of @xmath50 contained in @xmath2 with @xmath264 . since @xmath53 , @xmath274 is contained in a chamber @xmath26 , which is adjacent to @xmath64 by @xmath118 . in the case where @xmath62 is not thin , we need to be able to handle hyperplanes which are not in @xmath35 but occur as a wall of a chamber . assume @xmath69 , @xmath240 and @xmath275 . then @xmath276 . in particular for all @xmath220 the set @xmath127 is well defined and @xmath277 holds . [ boundwalls ] assume @xmath278 , then @xmath118 separates @xmath2 into two half spaces . as @xmath118 is a wall of @xmath64 and @xmath275 , we find that @xmath64 is not a connected component of @xmath279 . therefore @xmath276 , which proves our claim . let @xmath217 . then there exists a minimal gallery of length @xmath224 connecting @xmath64 and @xmath26 . [ sepisdis ] by lemma [ finsep ] @xmath280 is finite , so let @xmath281 . for @xmath282 , we have @xmath277 for every @xmath283 and all @xmath284 by lemma [ boundwalls ] . this implies that @xmath64 and @xmath26 are the same connected component . let @xmath285 , then we obtain the statement from lemma [ adjsep ] . we now use induction on @xmath286 , let @xmath287 . we can sort @xmath280 in a way , such that @xmath288 . by lemma [ lem : adjex ] and lemma [ adjsep ] there exists a unique chamber @xmath146 adjacent to @xmath64 such that @xmath289 . we will show @xmath290 , then the statement of the lemma follows by induction . since we have @xmath291 , we have @xmath292 for @xmath293 . assuming that there exists an additional @xmath254 , @xmath294 for @xmath295 with the property that @xmath255 separates @xmath146 and @xmath26 , provides a contradiction as @xmath255 also separates @xmath64 and @xmath26 . by induction this yields a gallery of length @xmath286 from @xmath64 to @xmath26 . we show that this gallery is also minimal . for this purpose let @xmath296 be an arbitrary gallery connecting @xmath129 and let for @xmath297 the hyperplane @xmath298 such that @xmath299 . note that @xmath300 is unique with that property by lemma [ adjsep ] . assume @xmath134 , then there exists an index @xmath301 such that @xmath118 separates @xmath302 and @xmath26 but not @xmath303 and @xmath26 . so @xmath304 and @xmath305 , @xmath118 separates @xmath306 and @xmath303 . we obtain @xmath307 , as @xmath308 are adjacent by @xmath300 and @xmath300 is unique with that property by lemma [ adjsep ] . thus @xmath309 and this yields @xmath310 . above we constructed a gallery of length @xmath224 , hence the gallery is already minimal . the graph @xmath216 is connected . [ cor : gammacon ] let @xmath311 be a connected metric space . let @xmath312 and @xmath313 . a point @xmath314 is called a _ gate of @xmath50 to @xmath315 _ or _ the projection of @xmath50 on @xmath315 _ if @xmath316 for all @xmath317 . the gate of @xmath50 to @xmath315 is uniquely determined , if it exists , and we will then denote it by @xmath318 . the set @xmath315 is called gated if every @xmath312 has a gate to @xmath315 . let @xmath102 . define the graph @xmath319 , where @xmath320 . then @xmath321 is a subgraph of @xmath216 and is called the _ parabolic subgraph at @xmath50_. a subgraph @xmath322 of @xmath216 is called _ parabolic _ , if it is a parabolic subgraph at @xmath50 for some @xmath102 . the parabolic subgraphs and subarrangements correspond to the residues in the case where @xmath35 is a hyperplane arrangement coming from a coxeter group . parabolic subgraphs are connected . [ kxcon ] the graph @xmath321 corresponds to the chamber graph of the hyperplane arrangement @xmath139 , and is therefore connected by corollary [ cor : gammacon ] . let @xmath102 , @xmath69 . then there exists a unique chamber @xmath323 , such that @xmath324 for all @xmath135 . [ starunique ] we prove existence first . let @xmath69 and consider the intersection @xmath325 then @xmath3 is a chamber of @xmath326 , since it is a non - empty connected component of @xmath2 . by lemma [ lem : subarr ] @xmath3 corresponds to a unique chamber @xmath327 in @xmath140 , and @xmath328 holds . so let @xmath329 be another chamber in @xmath140 . then there exists an element @xmath53 such that @xmath118 separates @xmath327 and @xmath330 . by lemma [ starsep ] we obtain @xmath135 , but this implies @xmath331 . hence @xmath327 is unique with the property that @xmath324 for all @xmath135 . for @xmath332 the set @xmath140 are gated subsets of @xmath333.[stargate ] let @xmath102 and @xmath321 be a parabolic subgraph . let @xmath69 . by lemma [ starunique ] there exists a unique chamber @xmath334 such that @xmath335 for all @xmath135 . we will prove that @xmath336 is a gate of @xmath64 to @xmath140 . so let @xmath337 . if @xmath53 separates @xmath336 and @xmath26 , we immediately get by lemma [ starsep ] that @xmath135 . on the other hand we get that if @xmath254 separates @xmath336 and @xmath64 , by construction of @xmath336 we find @xmath338 . now assume @xmath339 , we find that since @xmath135 , @xmath118 does not separate @xmath336 and @xmath64 and therefore must separate @xmath336 and @xmath26 . assume on the other hand that @xmath340 , then it can not separate @xmath26 and @xmath336 , and therefore must separate @xmath336 and @xmath64 . summarized this yields @xmath341 we thus find for all @xmath337 that @xmath342 . so @xmath336 is indeed a gate for @xmath64 to @xmath321 . we will now consider the structure induced on hyperplanes @xmath118 by the elements in @xmath35 . let @xmath62 be a simplicial arrangement . let @xmath343 be a hyperplane in @xmath10 , such that @xmath52 . set @xmath344 this is a set of hyperplanes in @xmath118 which have non empty intersection with @xmath345 , if @xmath345 is not empty itself . we also define the connected components of @xmath346 as @xmath347 . the pair @xmath348 is a hyperplane arrangement of rank @xmath349 with chambers @xmath347 . by definition for @xmath350 we find @xmath351 . the set @xmath345 is an open convex cone in @xmath118 , which is isomorphic to @xmath352 . let @xmath353 , @xmath76 a neighborhood of @xmath50 such that @xmath77 is finite . then @xmath354 is also finite , hence @xmath355 is locally finite in @xmath345 . by definition @xmath347 are the chambers of this arrangement . in the case where @xmath53 , we need some basic relations between chambers in @xmath70 and in @xmath347 . assume @xmath53 and let @xmath69 . if @xmath240 , then @xmath273 is the closure of a chamber in @xmath347 . for every @xmath356 there exists exactly two chambers @xmath357 , such that @xmath358 and @xmath359 for @xmath360 . [ indfaces ] for the first statement , @xmath273 is contained in the closure of a chamber @xmath146 of @xmath348 , since its interior with respect to @xmath118 does not meet any hyperplane . let @xmath361 . then @xmath362 for some chamber let @xmath364 . assume @xmath365 , then @xmath366 , while @xmath273 is either contained in @xmath255 or in @xmath367 . a contradiction to @xmath368 . thus we find @xmath369 . since @xmath370 , there exists a wall of @xmath64 separating @xmath64 and @xmath50 . a contradiction , hence @xmath371 . for the second statement , take @xmath368 , then @xmath372 and @xmath373 . choose a neighborhood @xmath76 of @xmath47 such that @xmath264 , which is possible by lemma [ compfin ] . the hyperplane @xmath118 separates @xmath76 into two connected components , which are each contained in chambers @xmath374 . by definition @xmath22 and @xmath23 are adjacent by @xmath118 , and by lemma [ adjsep ] there can not exist another chamber being adjacent to @xmath22 or @xmath23 by @xmath118 . in this section we introduce simplicial cones and collect some basic properties . as before , throughout this section let @xmath40 . let @xmath119 be a linear form , then @xmath375 let @xmath87 be a basis of @xmath19 , then the _ open simplicial cone ( associated to @xmath87 ) _ is @xmath376 with notation as above we find @xmath377 let @xmath87 be a basis of @xmath19 . we can then define the _ closed simplicial cone ( associated to @xmath87 ) _ as @xmath378 we say a cone is _ simplicial _ if it is open simplicial or closed simplicial . a simplicial cone can also be defined using bases of @xmath10 . let @xmath4 be a basis of @xmath10 , then the open simplicial cone associated to @xmath4 is @xmath379 and the closed simplicial cone associated to @xmath4 is @xmath380 both concepts are equivalent , and it is immediate from the definition that if @xmath381 and @xmath382 are bases , then @xmath383 if and only if @xmath87 is , up to positive scalar multiples and permutation , dual to @xmath4 . a simplicial cone @xmath64 associated to @xmath87 carries a natural structure of a simplex , to be precise : @xmath384 is a poset with respect to inclusion , which is isomorphic to @xmath385 with inverse inclusion . if @xmath4 is the basis of @xmath10 dual to @xmath87 , we find @xmath386 to be the set of all convex combinations of subsets of @xmath4 , and @xmath386 is also isomorphic to @xmath387 . moreover , @xmath388 is the vertex set of the simplex @xmath386 . for a simplicial cone @xmath64 , we denote with @xmath389 a basis of @xmath19 such that @xmath390 . [ rem : scs ] an open or closed simplicial cone is convex and has non - empty interior . [ cone : simpprop1 ] let @xmath64 be an open simplicial cone and @xmath389 a basis associated to @xmath64 . then @xmath64 is convex and open as an intersection of convex and open subsets . furthermore let @xmath4 be dual to @xmath391 , then we obtain that @xmath392 , hence @xmath64 is not empty and thus has non - empty interior . if @xmath2 is a closed simplicial cone , it contains the closure of an open simplicial cone , and has non - empty interior . the common notation for cones introduces _ properness _ of a cone @xmath64 as the property of having non - empty interior and being closed , convex , and pointed , the latter meaning that @xmath393 . thus all closed simplicial cones are proper . in our context being proper is not of interest , the cones we are dealing with are either convex and open or already simplicial . in the following let @xmath40 and @xmath394 be an open convex cone . in this section we establish a notion of tits arrangements on @xmath2 . the interesting cases the reader may think of are @xmath395 , or a half - space @xmath396 for some @xmath119 . we can now define our main objects of interest . let @xmath394 be a convex open cone and @xmath35 a set of linear hyperplanes in @xmath10 . we call a hyperplane arrangement @xmath12 a _ simplicial arrangement ( of rank @xmath8 ) _ , if every @xmath397 is an open simplicial cone . the cone @xmath2 is the _ tits cone _ of the arrangement . a simplicial arrangement is a _ tits arrangement _ , if it is thin . 1 . the definition of `` thin '' requires that all possible walls are already contained in @xmath35 . if we do not require this , a bounding hyperplane may arise as a bounding hyperplane of @xmath2 itself . this happens in example [ exm : notthin ] , which is not thin . consider also the case where @xmath2 itself is an open simplicial cone . even the empty set then satisfies that the one chamber , which is @xmath2 itself , is a simplicial cone . however , it has no walls in @xmath35 , hence it is not thin . 2 . from the definition it follows that in dimensions @xmath398 and @xmath399 , there are very few possibilities for simplicial arrangements and tits arrangements . + in dimension @xmath398 , the empty set is the only possible tits arrangement . + in the case @xmath400 , we find @xmath401 or @xmath402 or @xmath403 . in the first case , @xmath404 is a tits arrangement and in the other two cases , @xmath404 is a simplicial arrangement , but not thin any more . 3 . later in this section we introduce the notion of @xmath405-spherical arrangements , which is a refinement of being thin . 4 . in the case where @xmath395 , the property of @xmath35 being locally finite is equivalent to @xmath35 being finite , as @xmath398 is contained in every hyperplane . furthermore @xmath395 is the only case where @xmath406 , as the cone over every neighborhood of @xmath398 is already @xmath39 . \(i ) consider example [ exm : notthin ] , there @xmath22 and @xmath23 are simplicial cones , with @xmath407 and @xmath408 . the set @xmath409 is therefore a simplicial arrangement of rank 2 in @xmath2 , which is finite and hence also locally finite . but @xmath410 is not thin , as @xmath411 note that this particular example can be turned into a thin arrangement by factoring out the radical ( cp . example [ exm : deg ] ) . however , one can easily find examples of non - degenerate simplicial arrangements which are not thin . \(ii ) in example [ exm : thinf ] , the set @xmath412 of hyperplanes is not finite , but it is locally finite in @xmath2 . if @xmath413 , we can not find a neighborhood @xmath76 of @xmath414 which meets only finitely many hyperplanes if and only if @xmath415 or @xmath416 , and hence @xmath417 . a chamber @xmath64 satisfies one of the following : 1 . @xmath418 for some @xmath419 , or 2 . @xmath420 for some @xmath419 . therefore , @xmath421 is a tits arrangement of rank 2 . likewise , the hyperplane arrangement in example [ exm : univ3 ] is a tits arrangement of rank 3 in @xmath2 . the vertices of the simplicial cones are contained in @xmath38 , but all walls meet @xmath2 . \(iii ) figure ( [ extits ] ) shows a tits arrangement coming from the weyl groupoid of an infinite dimensional nichols algebra . tits arrangements are non - degenerate . [ lem : titsnd ] let @xmath69 , @xmath87 a basis of @xmath19 such that @xmath422 . since @xmath68 and @xmath87 is a basis , we find @xmath423 . some of the `` classical '' cases are the following choices for @xmath2 . a simplicial arrangement @xmath62 is _ spherical _ , if @xmath395 . we say @xmath62 is _ affine _ , if @xmath424 for some @xmath425 . for an affine arrangement we call @xmath426 the _ imaginary root _ of the arrangement . the tits cone of a tits arrangement @xmath62 resembles the tits cone for compact hyperbolic coxeter groups . the geometric representation of an irreducible spherical or affine coxeter group is a prototype of spherical or affine tits arrangements . let @xmath40 , a _ root system _ is a set @xmath427 such that 1 . @xmath428 , 2 . @xmath429 for all @xmath430 , 3 . there exists a tits arrangement @xmath62 such that @xmath431 . if @xmath432 is a root system , @xmath62 as in 3 ) , we say that the tits arrangement @xmath12 is _ associated to @xmath432_. let @xmath432 be a root system . we call a map @xmath433 a _ reductor of @xmath432 _ , if for all @xmath430 1 . @xmath434 for some @xmath435 , 2 . @xmath436 . a root system @xmath432 is _ reduced _ , if @xmath437 is a reductor . given @xmath432 and a reductor @xmath438 , when no ambiguity can occur , we denote @xmath439 . we note some immediate consequences of this definition . let @xmath432 be a root system and @xmath62 be a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , @xmath438 a reductor of @xmath432 . then 1 . @xmath440 is a reduced root system and @xmath62 is associated to @xmath432 . 2 . @xmath432 is reduced if and only if @xmath441 for all @xmath442 . if @xmath432 is reduced , @xmath437 is the only reductor of @xmath432 . for i ) , as @xmath443 , we find that @xmath444 , so @xmath445 is a root system . due to the properties of @xmath438 , we find that @xmath446 , so @xmath437 is a reductor of @xmath432 . for the second statement assume @xmath441 for all @xmath430 , then the identity is a reductor . assume that the identity is a reductor , then for @xmath447 with @xmath448 , @xmath449 , we find that @xmath450 . for the third statement assume that @xmath432 is reduced , so @xmath437 is a reductor of @xmath451 . let @xmath430 , then @xmath441 . if @xmath438 is a reductor of @xmath432 , @xmath452 , as @xmath453 is positive , we find @xmath454 and @xmath455 . in the case where for @xmath430 the set @xmath456 is finite , the canonical choice for @xmath438 is such that @xmath457 is minimal in @xmath458 ; with respect to an arbitrary scalar product . the notion of a reductor of @xmath432 is very general , the intention is to be able to reduce a root system even in the case where for @xmath430 the set @xmath456 does not have a shortest or longest element . in this most general setting , the existence of a reductor requires the axiom of choice . furthermore we find that , given a tits arrangement @xmath62 , root systems always exist . let @xmath12 be a tits arrangement , @xmath459 the unit sphere in @xmath39 with respect to the standard metric associated to the standard scalar product @xmath460 . let @xmath461 then @xmath462 is a reduced root system for @xmath35 . furthermore every reduced root system @xmath463 associated to @xmath12 is of the form @xmath464 , and every such set is a reduced root system associated to @xmath12 . [ rsx ] as @xmath53 is @xmath349-dimensional , @xmath465 , so @xmath466 for some vector @xmath467 , with @xmath468 . so @xmath451 is a root system associated to @xmath35 . let @xmath469 for some @xmath449 , then @xmath470 . as the map @xmath471 is bijective , we find @xmath472 . therefore @xmath432 is reduced . for the second statement note that the hyperplane @xmath283 determines @xmath473 uniquely up to a scalar . so any @xmath463 of the given form satisfies @xmath474 . furthermore it is reduced , as @xmath475 for @xmath430 . let @xmath12 be a tits arrangement associated to the root system @xmath432 , and fix a reductor @xmath438 of @xmath432 . let @xmath64 be a chamber . the _ root basis of @xmath64 _ is the set @xmath476 if @xmath477 is a tits arrangement associated to the root system @xmath432 , @xmath69 , then @xmath478 also , as a simplicial cone @xmath479 has exactly @xmath8 walls , the set @xmath480 is a basis of @xmath19 . furthermore , @xmath481 . the following proposition is crucial for the theory and motivates the notion of root bases . let @xmath62 be a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , @xmath64 a chamber . then @xmath482 . in other words , every root is a non - negative or non - positive linear combination of @xmath480 . [ posorneg ] the proof works exactly as in the spherical case , see ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2.2 ) . it is useful to identify tits arrangements which basically only differ by the choice of basis , therefore we make the following definition . let @xmath62 , @xmath483 be tits arrangements associated to the root systems @xmath432 and @xmath463 respectively . then @xmath62 and @xmath484 are called _ combinatorially equivalent _ , if there exists an @xmath485 such that @xmath486 , @xmath487 , @xmath488 . here @xmath489 denotes the dual action of @xmath490 on @xmath19 , defined by @xmath491 . let @xmath12 be a simplicial arrangement . the set of chambers @xmath61 gives rise to a poset @xmath492 with set - wise inclusion giving a poset - structure . note that we do not require any of these intersections to be in @xmath2 . by construction they are contained in the closure of @xmath2 , as every @xmath64 is an open subset in @xmath2 . we will at this point just note that @xmath13 is a simplicial complex . this will be elaborated in appendix [ app : s ] . the poset @xmath493 is a simplicial complex . [ ssimpcomp ] the complex @xmath493 is furthermore a chamber complex , which justifies the notion of chambers and is shown in appendix [ app : scc ] . we have a slight ambiguity of notation at this point , as a chamber in the simplicial complex @xmath493 is the closure of a chamber in @xmath70 . for the readers convenience , a chamber will always be an element @xmath69 , while we will refer to a chamber in @xmath493 as a _ closed chamber _ , written with the usual notation @xmath494 . we show in appendix [ app : scc ] that the closed chambers are indeed chambers in a classical sense . 1 . depending on @xmath2 , the above mentioned simplicial complex can also be seen as canonically isomorphic to the simplicial decomposition of certain objects , arising by intersection with the respective simplicial cones . in case @xmath395 , @xmath13 corresponds to a simplicial decomposition of the sphere @xmath495 . if @xmath396 for @xmath119 , we find @xmath13 to be a decomposition of the affine space @xmath496 , which we identify with the set @xmath497 . if @xmath2 is the light cone and @xmath35 is ch - like as defined in definition [ def : spherical ] below , we can find a corresponding decomposition of @xmath498 . 2 . in the literature ( see ( * ? ? ? * chapter v , 1 ) ) the simplicial complex associated to a finite or affine simplicial hyperplane arrangement is defined in a slightly different manner . let @xmath10 be a euclidean space , @xmath35 a locally finite set of ( possibly affine ) hyperplanes . define for @xmath499 , @xmath500 the set @xmath501 to be the halfspace with respect to @xmath118 containing @xmath232 . set @xmath502 then @xmath503 is an equivalence relation , its classes are called facets . facets correspond to simplices , and form a poset with respect to the inclusion @xmath504 . + one obtains immediately that every point in @xmath10 is contained in a unique facet . however , when the space is not the entire euclidean space but a convex open cone , it is desirable to consider some of the points in the boundary , as they contribute to the simplicial structure of @xmath13 . therefore , we prefer our approach before the classical one . 3 . the above approach could also be used to define being @xmath405-spherical ( see below ) for hyperplane arrangements , which are not necessarily simplicial . using the simplicial complex @xmath13 , it is now possible to refine the notion of being thin for a simplicial arrangement . a simplicial arrangement @xmath62 of rank @xmath8 is called _ @xmath405-spherical _ for @xmath505 if every simplex @xmath3 of @xmath493 , such that @xmath506 , meets @xmath2 . we say @xmath12 is _ ch - like _ if it is @xmath349-spherical . [ def : spherical ] immediate from the definition are the following : 1 . a simplicial hyperplane arrangement of rank @xmath8 is @xmath398-spherical , as @xmath69 is constructed as an open subset of @xmath2 . the hyperplane arrangement @xmath62 is spherical if and only if it is @xmath8-spherical . @xmath12 is thin and therefore a tits arrangement if and only if it is @xmath399-spherical . 4 . as @xmath493 is a simplicial complex w. r. t. inclusion , being @xmath405-spherical implies being @xmath507-spherical for @xmath508 . 5 . examples of ch - like arrangements are all arrangements belonging to affine weyl groups , where the affine @xmath349-plane is embedded into a real vector space of dimension @xmath8 , as well as all arrangements belonging to compact hyperbolic coxeter groups , where @xmath2 is the light cone . the notion ch - like is inspired by exactly this property for groups , i. e. being * * c**ompact * * h**yperbolic . 6 . as a generalization of ( 5 ) , take a coxeter system @xmath0 of finite rank . then @xmath1 is said to be @xmath405-spherical if every rank @xmath405 subset of @xmath3 generates a finite coxeter group . the geometric representation of @xmath1 then yields a hyperplane arrangement which is @xmath405-spherical in the way defined above . therefore , being @xmath405-spherical can be seen as a generalization of the respective property of coxeter groups . an equivalent condition for @xmath62 to be @xmath405-spherical , which we will use often , is that every @xmath509-simplex meets @xmath2 . this uses just the fact that simplices of codimension @xmath405 are exactly @xmath509-simplices . the arrangement in example [ exm : notthin ] yields the simplicial complex @xmath13 , with maximal elements @xmath22 , @xmath23 , vertices @xmath510 , @xmath511 , @xmath512 , and the set @xmath513 as the minimal element . thus @xmath410 is @xmath398-spherical , but not @xmath399-spherical , as it is not thin . the arrangement in example [ exm : thinf ] is thin and therefore @xmath399-spherical and ch - like . the vertices are the rays @xmath514 , @xmath515 , the minimal element , which has codimension @xmath516 , is @xmath513 . since @xmath517 , it is not @xmath516-spherical and in particular not spherical . in example [ exm : univ3 ] , the arrangement @xmath12 is thin and therefore 1-spherical , but since all vertices are contained in @xmath38 , it is not 2-spherical and thus not ch - like . note that the group @xmath1 from this example is not compact hyperbolic . an important observation is the fact that the cone @xmath2 can be reconstructed from the chambers . for a simplicial hyperplane arrangement @xmath12 we find @xmath518 furthermore @xmath62 is ch - like if and only if @xmath519 holds . [ tchambers ] as @xmath520 , the inclusion @xmath521 holds . if @xmath48 , either @xmath522 for some @xmath69 , or @xmath50 is contained in a finite number of hyperplanes , thus in a simplex in @xmath13 and also in the closure of a chamber , and therefore @xmath523 . so let @xmath524 . assume further that @xmath50 is not contained in any simplex in @xmath13 , else the statement follows immediately as above . therefore @xmath525 , and as @xmath2 is convex , this means @xmath50 is in the boundary of @xmath2 . so let @xmath526 be the open @xmath527-ball with center @xmath50 , then @xmath528 . as @xmath76 is open , @xmath529 is open again . the set @xmath530 can not be empty , else @xmath531 is not contained in a chamber , in a contradiction to the construction of chambers . so let @xmath532 be the set of chambers @xmath64 with @xmath533 . if @xmath50 is not contained in the closure of @xmath534 , we find an @xmath535 such that the open ball @xmath246 does not intersect any @xmath536 . but @xmath537 must again meet some chambers @xmath64 , which are then also in @xmath532 , a contradiction . so @xmath523 and equality holds . for the second statement , if @xmath62 is ch - like , note that every @xmath48 is contained in some simplex @xmath538 , so @xmath539 holds . now if @xmath540 for some @xmath69 , @xmath50 is contained in some simplex @xmath249 . now @xmath35 is ch - like , so @xmath541 meets @xmath2 . boundaries of simplices are simplices , hence the intersection @xmath542 is again a simplex in @xmath13 , being ch - like yields that this intersection is empty , which proves the other inclusion . the other direction of the second statement is immediate from the definition of being @xmath349-spherical . for a tits arrangement @xmath62 it is possible to show that we can also describe @xmath2 as the convex closure of @xmath543 , or alternatively as @xmath544.\ ] ] we will require the existence of a type function of @xmath13 ( for the definition , see definition [ def : numb ] ) , which is given by the following proposition , proven in appendix [ app : scc ] . let @xmath62 be a simplicial arrangement . the complex @xmath545 is a chamber complex of rank @xmath8 with @xmath546 the complex @xmath13 is gated and strongly connected . furthermore there exists a type function @xmath547 of @xmath13 , where @xmath548 . the complex @xmath13 is thin if and only if @xmath12 is thin , and @xmath13 is spherical if and only if @xmath62 is spherical . [ prop - sproperties ] we will now take a closer look at the relations between the bases of adjacent chambers . again the proof follows ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2.8 ) closely . let @xmath62 be a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , and let @xmath217 be adjacent chambers . assume @xmath549 for @xmath550 . if @xmath551 , then either 1 . @xmath552 or 2 . @xmath553 . holds . [ adjcham1 ] by lemma [ posorneg ] we can assume @xmath554 is either as in case ii ) or @xmath555 with @xmath556 . using that for arbitrary @xmath557 we have @xmath558 , we get @xmath559 . we also observe that @xmath560 , therefore we get @xmath561 . by choice of @xmath17 and since the elements in @xmath480 , @xmath562 are reduced , we find @xmath563 and @xmath552 . assume for @xmath69 that @xmath480 is indexed in some way , i.e. @xmath564 . for any set @xmath565 , define the map @xmath566 by @xmath567 . set @xmath568 . for every simplex @xmath249 there exists a description of the form @xmath569 for some @xmath570 by remark [ rem : scs ] , which gives an index set @xmath571 . finally this gives rise to a type function of @xmath494 in @xmath493 , by taking the map @xmath572 . by theorem [ numbext ] the map @xmath573 yields a unique type function @xmath574 of the whole simplicial complex @xmath13 . so let @xmath363 be another chamber , then the restriction @xmath575 is a type function of @xmath576 as well . assume @xmath577 , this yields a second type function of @xmath576 in the same way we acquired a type function of @xmath494 before , @xmath578 we now call the indexing of @xmath562 _ compatible with @xmath480 _ , if @xmath579 . note that since the type function @xmath574 is unique , there is a unique indexing of @xmath562 compatible with @xmath480 . the existence of the type function and lemma [ adjcham1 ] allow us to state the following lemma , which gives another characterization root bases of adjacent chambers . assume that @xmath12 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 . let @xmath220 be adjacent chambers and choose a indexing @xmath564 . let the indexing of @xmath577 be compatible with @xmath480 . assume @xmath580 for some @xmath508 . then @xmath581 . [ adjcham15 ] if @xmath582 , this is immediate from lemma [ adjcham1 ] . so let @xmath583 and assume w.l.o.g . @xmath584 . consider the type function @xmath585 of @xmath494 and @xmath586 of @xmath576 as restrictions of the unique type function @xmath574 . being compatible yields that @xmath587 . then @xmath588 holds and we get @xmath589 . we conclude that @xmath590 , and as @xmath591 we find @xmath592 . then we find @xmath593 , so @xmath594 is a linear combination of @xmath17 and @xmath595 , which proves our claim . we will note more properties about parabolic subarrangements of tits arrangements , in particular we will give suitable root systems associated to these subarrangements . remember from corollary [ cor : redsub ] that @xmath206 is a hyperplane arrangement . assume @xmath62 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 . let @xmath102 , define @xmath596 . for @xmath597 set @xmath598 . with notation as above , let @xmath597 , then @xmath599 . in particular , @xmath600 is a basis of @xmath601 . [ indeqdim ] the inclusion @xmath602 holds due to @xmath603 . now the space @xmath604 is a subspace of @xmath10 and @xmath605 is a face of @xmath494 containing @xmath50 . assume @xmath541 is a face of @xmath605 containing @xmath50 . then @xmath541 is also a face of @xmath494 and has the structure @xmath606 for some @xmath607 . then by definition @xmath608 for @xmath297 , and @xmath609 , so @xmath605 is a minimal face of @xmath494 containing @xmath50 . the inclusion @xmath602 implies @xmath610 , therefore the set @xmath611 is also a face of @xmath494 , furthermore it contains @xmath50 by definition . we can conclude @xmath612 , which yields the equality . the second claim follows since @xmath613 and the elements in @xmath480 are linearly independent . note that @xmath614 defines a map @xmath615 by @xmath616 , which is well defined since @xmath617 . we will identify this map with @xmath618 and think of @xmath619 as a subset of @xmath620 . most of the time we are interested only in @xmath619 and its combinatorial properties , therefore it does not matter whether we consider these in @xmath620 or in @xmath19 . but formally the transition to @xmath621 is necessary to obtain a root system in the strict sense . we will consider @xmath622 as a topological space with respect to the topology in @xmath623 , which comes from the standard topology on @xmath39 . assume @xmath12 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , @xmath102 . the hyperplane arrangement @xmath206 is simplicial . the chambers of this arrangement correspond to @xmath140 . moreover , if @xmath48 , then @xmath206 is spherical . if @xmath624 , @xmath625 , and @xmath12 is @xmath405-spherical for some @xmath626 , then @xmath206 is @xmath627-spherical . in particular @xmath628 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath619 . [ indatpoint ] assume @xmath625 , so @xmath629 and @xmath630 . let @xmath597 , @xmath631 denote the standard epimorphism . let @xmath141 be the connected components of @xmath632 . the set @xmath633 is a basis for @xmath622 by lemma [ indeqdim ] and we find @xmath634 by definition . denote this intersection by @xmath146 . first we show that @xmath635 . assume there exists @xmath636 such that there exist @xmath637 with @xmath638 , @xmath639 . then we find @xmath640 with the properties : @xmath641 , @xmath642 , @xmath643 for all @xmath644 . for any @xmath645 and @xmath644 we find @xmath646 and @xmath647 as @xmath648 . so for @xmath649 the points @xmath650 , @xmath651 still satisfy the above inequalities . now let @xmath652 , then @xmath653 . so choosing @xmath649 large enough we find that the points @xmath654 , @xmath655 are close enough to @xmath50 to satisfy @xmath656 , @xmath657 and @xmath658 for all @xmath659 . so @xmath660 , in contradiction to the simplicial structure of @xmath13 . by its definition , @xmath146 is a simplicial cone , the arrangement @xmath206 therefore is simplicial . it remains to determine for which @xmath405 the pair @xmath206 is @xmath405-spherical . in the case where @xmath48 , @xmath661 and @xmath662 is spherical . construct a simplex @xmath663 in the following way : since @xmath64 is a simplicial cone , there exists an closed simplex @xmath3 with the property @xmath664 ( for details , see remark [ rem : chse ] ) . let @xmath665 denote the minimal face of @xmath3 such that @xmath666 , and let @xmath667 be the vertex set of @xmath665 . then the vertices @xmath668 span a face of @xmath3 , denote this face by @xmath663 . the vertices @xmath669 are linearly independent : assume @xmath670 , then @xmath671 . furthermore note that @xmath672 is spanned by @xmath667 . so we get a linear combination of the form @xmath673 . linear independence of @xmath674 yields @xmath675 for all @xmath676 . this also gives us @xmath677 . assuming inequality , we find more than @xmath678 vertices in @xmath672 , a contradiction to @xmath630 . so @xmath679 spans indeed an @xmath680-simplex in @xmath622 . we show @xmath681 . in general for every @xmath682 there exists a unique @xmath659 such that @xmath683 by remark [ rem : scs ] , all other @xmath684 satisfy @xmath685 . since for @xmath686 the vector @xmath232 is not contained in any proper face of @xmath494 containing @xmath50 , we find a unique @xmath644 such that @xmath683 . let @xmath687 , then @xmath688 with @xmath689 for all @xmath686 . then @xmath690 for all @xmath691 , @xmath692 yields @xmath693 . therefore @xmath694 . so assume @xmath695 , then @xmath696 and there exists a @xmath697 such that @xmath698 . now there exists a unique @xmath644 such that @xmath699 , so we find @xmath700 . therefore @xmath701 holds , and therefore @xmath702 . we can conclude @xmath681 . now assume @xmath624 and @xmath35 is @xmath405-spherical . let @xmath663 be as above , then @xmath703 is isomorphic as a simplicial complex to the closed chamber @xmath704 and all simplices contained therein . a face of @xmath663 meets @xmath2 if and only if a face of @xmath705 meets @xmath621 . now @xmath663 is an @xmath680-simplex , as it is spanned by @xmath706 vertices , likewise @xmath665 is an @xmath707-simplex . let @xmath708 be a face of @xmath663 , and assume @xmath709 is an @xmath710-simplex . then @xmath711 generate an @xmath712-simplex @xmath713 of @xmath13 . as @xmath35 is @xmath405-spherical , @xmath713 therefore meets @xmath2 if @xmath714 is satisfied , or equivalently @xmath715 . under this condition also @xmath716 meets @xmath621 , we can conclude that @xmath662 is @xmath405-spherical . since @xmath662 will not be more than @xmath706-spherical , since it is an arrangement of rank @xmath706 , we find that @xmath662 is @xmath717-spherical . so as @xmath62 is thin , @xmath206 is a tits hyperplane arrangement with root system @xmath619 . since chambers @xmath597 and in @xmath635 are uniquely determined by the sets @xmath600 and @xmath718 we find that @xmath156 induces a bijection between @xmath147 and @xmath146 . 1 . the tits arrangement @xmath206 is not so much dependent on the point @xmath50 as on the subspace spanned by @xmath50 , as one gets the same arrangement for every @xmath719 , @xmath720 . this hints to the fact that one can see a simplicial arrangement as a simplicial complex in projective space . however , we will not elaborate this further . 2 . it may be worth mentioning that the chambers @xmath140 and the underlying simplicial complex correspond to the star of the smallest simplex in @xmath13 containing @xmath50 . 3 . its possible to show that for a simplicial hyperplane arrangement @xmath62 , the arrangement @xmath206 is also simplicial . however , the existence of a root system simplifies the proof . 4 . when @xmath624 , @xmath628 may become @xmath721-spherical for some @xmath722 . the reason for this is that @xmath35 not being @xmath721-spherical does not imply that every @xmath723-simplex contained in a chamber in @xmath140 does not meet @xmath2 . note that the above statements make sense if @xmath724 , this occurs if and only if either @xmath48 is in the interior of a chamber , or @xmath624 does not meet any hyperplane @xmath53 . however , in this case we have @xmath725 and the induced arrangement is the empty arrangement . this is not a problem , since in this case @xmath726 and @xmath727 , but this case is somewhat trivial . therefore the requirement @xmath728 is quite natural to make , and we will assume this from now on . another trivial case occurring can be @xmath729 , in which case @xmath730 , @xmath731 and @xmath732 . we can also give an exact criterion to when @xmath662 is a spherical arrangement : assume @xmath62 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 with rank @xmath733 . let @xmath102 . then @xmath107 and @xmath619 are finite if and only if @xmath48 . in particular , a simplicial arrangement is finite if and only if it is spherical . [ axfin ] if @xmath48 , @xmath107 , @xmath619 are finite by proposition [ indatpoint ] . so assume @xmath107 , @xmath619 are finite and let @xmath102 . then also @xmath140 is a finite set , so let @xmath734 and by lemma [ kxcon ] we find @xmath735 such that @xmath736 is maximal . note that any minimal gallery between chambers in @xmath140 is already in @xmath140 , since for @xmath53 with @xmath737 we obtain @xmath738 by lemma [ starsep ] . let @xmath625 , then the @xmath706 adjacent chambers @xmath739 of @xmath146 exist , since @xmath35 is thin , and are all closer to @xmath64 than to @xmath146 . let @xmath740 be adjacent by @xmath300 to @xmath64 , we can conclude @xmath741 for @xmath742 . let @xmath76 be an open ball with center @xmath50 , and let @xmath743 , @xmath744 , then @xmath745 and @xmath746 are open as well and contained in @xmath2 . take @xmath747 , so @xmath748 and @xmath749 is in @xmath746 . we find @xmath750 , which shows our first statement . the last statement is obtained by taking @xmath751 . we finish this section with two observations . the root system @xmath432 is reduced if and only if @xmath619 is reduced for every @xmath48 . this follows immediately since @xmath619 is constructed as a subset of @xmath432 and @xmath752 , note that for @xmath614 we find @xmath753 . let @xmath62 be a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 . let @xmath102 with @xmath728 . let @xmath754 be adjacent by @xmath17 , and @xmath755 , @xmath756 indexed compatible with @xmath480 . then @xmath757 is a bijection . [ restmap ] we know by lemma [ indeqdim ] that @xmath758 . since @xmath759 consist of linear independent vectors , we get @xmath760 . it remains to show that the map is well defined . for @xmath761 we find @xmath762 . we have @xmath763 and @xmath608 . now @xmath764 for some @xmath765 by lemma [ adjcham15 ] , so @xmath766 and we are done . in this section , we will discuss how a tits arrangement @xmath62 induces a tits arrangement on hyperplanes in @xmath35 . in the classical theory of hyperplane arrangements this is also called the restriction of an arrangement [ cp . @xcite ] . let @xmath62 be a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , and let @xmath118 be a hyperplane . define @xmath767 and set @xmath768 we can also define the connected components of @xmath346 as @xmath347 . note that in the case @xmath769 there exists no hyperplane which is not in the arrangement . in the case @xmath770 the set @xmath355 is just the point @xmath513 or empty . our statements will remain true in these cases , but most of the time they will be empty . in particular we will examine the case where @xmath53 , since otherwise we will not necessarily see an induced simplicial complex . an interesting special case occurs for affine arrangements with imaginary root @xmath426 and @xmath771 , since in many cases this yields as @xmath772 a root system associated to a spherical tits arrangement . with notation as above , we find @xmath773 . this follows immediately from the definition . the elements @xmath356 are simplicial cones in @xmath774 . [ indsimp ] if @xmath769 , the statement is empty , so let @xmath775 . lemma [ indfaces ] yields that for @xmath776 the set @xmath777 is actually an maximal face of some chamber @xmath69 . this is a simplicial cone by remark [ rem : scs ] . the following observation is immediate from a geometric point of view , but necessary to point out : let @xmath343 be an arbitrary hyperplane , and let @xmath430 . then we find @xmath778 , @xmath779 and @xmath780 . [ indroots ] first note that @xmath781 by definition of @xmath782 . the equalities follow immediately by considering the cases @xmath648 or @xmath783 . the above lemma immediately yields the following . @xmath784 . let @xmath62 be a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , @xmath69 , @xmath240 . let @xmath785 . then 1 . @xmath786 for a unique @xmath356 , 2 . @xmath787 and @xmath788 for @xmath789 . 3 . @xmath790 . [ indbases ] part i ) is clear by the definition of @xmath70 and @xmath347 , since @xmath791 is a unique maximal face of @xmath792 . for the second statement assume @xmath793 for @xmath794 . we use that @xmath795 is a maximal face of @xmath494 . the maximal faces of @xmath795 are exactly the sets of the form @xmath796 for @xmath797 , by lemma [ indroots ] we obtain that the faces can also be written as @xmath798 for @xmath789 . as the maximal face @xmath798 spans a hyperplane in @xmath118 contained in @xmath799 , we conclude @xmath787 for @xmath789 and ii ) holds . assertion iii ) is a direct consequence of lemma [ indroots ] . let @xmath62 be a @xmath405-spherical simplicial arrangement , @xmath800 and @xmath53 . then @xmath801 is a @xmath507-spherical simplicial arrangement . if @xmath348 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath432 , @xmath772 is a root system for @xmath802 . [ indarrange ] note that @xmath772 does not contain @xmath398 by definition , and if @xmath803 , we find @xmath804 with @xmath805 , so @xmath806 and @xmath807 . by lemma [ indroots ] we know that @xmath784 and by definition we have @xmath808 . furthermore we know that the connected components in @xmath347 are simplicial cones by corollary [ indsimp ] . let @xmath356 and @xmath69 such that @xmath146 is a face of @xmath64 . let @xmath794 such that @xmath809 . by ii ) in lemma [ indbases ] we find @xmath810 , and together with iii ) in lemma [ indbases ] we find reduced roots @xmath811 with the property @xmath812 . hence @xmath355 is a simplicial arrangement in @xmath345 , and @xmath813 holds . so if @xmath355 is thin , @xmath772 is a root system for @xmath355 . now assume @xmath541 is an @xmath706-simplex in the simplicial complex @xmath814 associated to the simplicial arrangement @xmath802 . since this is a subset of @xmath493 , @xmath541 meets @xmath345 if and only if @xmath541 meets @xmath2 , and therefore @xmath801 is @xmath507-spherical if @xmath62 is @xmath405-spherical . assume that @xmath348 is a tits arrangement associated to @xmath772 . let @xmath69 such that @xmath815 . then the set @xmath816 is a basis of @xmath817 . [ projbasis ] by proposition [ indarrange ] the set @xmath718 is a basis of @xmath817 , by lemma [ indbases ] iii ) we find that the elements in @xmath818 are non zero scalar multiples of @xmath718 . if @xmath12 is a simplicial arrangement , we call @xmath819 for @xmath53 as above the _ induced simplicial hyperplane arrangement ( by @xmath62 ) on @xmath118 _ or the _ restriction of @xmath62 to @xmath118_. the notation in this chapter is mostly taken from ( * ? ? ? * appendix a ) and @xcite . we recall the notion of partially ordered sets : let @xmath820 be a poset . for @xmath821 we write @xmath822 let @xmath820 , @xmath823 be posets . morphism of posets _ is a map @xmath824 , such that for @xmath825 we have @xmath826 it is called an isomorphism if it is bijective and @xmath827 is a morphism as well . [ def : simpcomp ] there are two different approaches to define what a simplex is , since we want to use both , we will introduce them here . a _ simplex _ can be seen as a poset @xmath828 isomorphic to @xmath829 for some set @xmath830 , where @xmath831 denotes the set - wise inclusion . simplicial complex _ is then a poset @xmath832 such that 1 . @xmath833 is a simplex for all @xmath834 , 2 . @xmath835 have a unique greatest lower bound , denoted by @xmath836 . a _ vertex _ of @xmath837 is an element @xmath838 such that @xmath839 and @xmath840 imply @xmath841 . another way to define a simplicial complex is to take a set @xmath830 , and let @xmath842 . then @xmath843 is a poset . it is a simplicial complex if furthermore for @xmath834 also @xmath844 . the set of vertices corresponds to the set @xmath830 . the first definition makes it easier to describe the star of a simplex , which will often be useful . so let @xmath832 be a simplicial complex . for @xmath845 we say that @xmath846 _ is a face of _ @xmath847 if @xmath848 . we will write @xmath849 if @xmath848 and @xmath850 . due to the second property , there exists a unique minimal element in @xmath837 which is denoted by @xmath851 . let @xmath834 , then the _ rank of _ @xmath846 , @xmath852 is the cardinality of the set of vertices contained in @xmath846 . we define the rank of @xmath837 , @xmath853 . for @xmath834 define the _ star of @xmath846 _ as @xmath854 . this is again a simplicial complex with minimal element @xmath846 . a _ chamber _ of @xmath837 is a maximal element in @xmath837 , we will denote the set of chambers as @xmath855 or @xmath61 , if @xmath837 is unambiguous . let @xmath856 be a map between simplicial complexes @xmath837 and @xmath857 . then @xmath618 is called a _ morphism of simplicial complexes _ if it is a morphism of posets and furthermore @xmath858 is an isomorphism for all @xmath859 . a subcomplex @xmath857 of @xmath837 is a subset of @xmath837 such that the inclusion @xmath860 is a morphism of simplicial complexes . for @xmath848 , the _ codimension of @xmath846 in @xmath847 _ is the rank of @xmath847 in @xmath861 , denoted by @xmath862 . we say that @xmath846 is a _ maximal face _ of @xmath847 , if @xmath863 . for simplices occurring as subsets of @xmath864 it is convenient to consider the dimension of a simplex rather than the rank . we will denote an @xmath286-dimensional simplex simply as an @xmath286-simplex . therefore , an @xmath286-simplex will be of rank @xmath865 . fix a simplicial arrangement @xmath62 . we will show that @xmath493 is actually a simplicial complex and furthermore a chamber complex with set of chambers @xmath70 . we already showed in remark [ rem : scs ] that the simplicial structure on a closed chamber @xmath494 is induced from the simplicial structure of @xmath866 , where @xmath3 is an open simplex such that @xmath867 . recall the notion of the convex hull of a set . let @xmath111 be a connected metric space . for an arbitrary subset @xmath45 the convex hull of @xmath47 is the smallest convex set @xmath868 , such that @xmath869 . for a different approach , define the segment between @xmath870 to be @xmath871 this can be used to define @xmath872 we can then recursively define @xmath873 then the convex hull of @xmath47 is the set @xmath874 . for @xmath40 and a linearly independent set @xmath875 the convex hull of @xmath47 can be more easily described as @xmath876 in this setting , we will refer to the set @xmath877 as the _ open convex hull of @xmath47_. if @xmath875 is linearly independent , then its convex hull @xmath3 is exactly a simplex of rank @xmath349 , with vertex set @xmath878 . the simplicial structure coincides with the poset @xmath879 . moreover , if @xmath4 is a basis of @xmath39 , and @xmath3 is the open convex hull of @xmath4 , the cone @xmath880 coincides with @xmath881 as defined in remark [ rem : scs ] . if @xmath541 is a face of @xmath3 , there exists a subset @xmath882 such that @xmath541 is the convex hull of @xmath883 . then @xmath884 is a face @xmath494 in the simplicial complex @xmath885 . therefore @xmath387 , @xmath3 , and @xmath886 are all isomorphic simplices , via the isomorphisms @xmath887 [ rem : chse ] let @xmath888 , @xmath889 be bases of @xmath10 such that @xmath890 . then , up to permutation , @xmath891 for some @xmath892 for all @xmath893 . the same holds for two bases @xmath894 of @xmath19 such that @xmath895 . [ equalcones ] let @xmath3 be open convex hull of @xmath4 . . one can choose positive scalars @xmath897 such that @xmath898 . then @xmath899 with @xmath900 , @xmath901 . let @xmath902 , we find @xmath903 . hence @xmath904 with @xmath905 and @xmath906 . therefore the matrix @xmath907 describing the base change is non - negative , and the same holds for its inverse @xmath908 . it is well known ( see theorem 4.6 in chapter 3 of @xcite for example ) that the inverse of a non - negative matrix is non - negative if and only if the matrix is monomial . adding the fact that the sum of every column adds up to @xmath399 , we get that @xmath907 and @xmath908 are already permutation matrices . the statement for @xmath909 just follows from remark [ rem : scs ] by considering the dual basis . for the following statement recall from [ rem : scs ] that for a basis @xmath87 of @xmath19 the cone @xmath910 is given by @xmath911 for a basis @xmath4 of @xmath10 the cone @xmath881 is given by @xmath912 let @xmath913 for a basis @xmath4 of @xmath10 and a basis @xmath87 of @xmath19 . let @xmath914 . then @xmath915 for all @xmath916 if and only if @xmath917 . likewise @xmath918 for all @xmath916 if and only if @xmath919.[purelc ] let @xmath920 . by remark [ rem : scs ] we find that @xmath87 is dual to @xmath4 up to positive scalar multiples . denote with @xmath921 the dual to @xmath916 . so @xmath922 . applying this to @xmath4 yields @xmath923 for all @xmath916 . this immediately yields both equivalences . let @xmath538 . for every @xmath53 , either @xmath242 or @xmath541 is contained in a unique closed half space of @xmath118 , denoted by @xmath924 . furthermore @xmath925 , and if @xmath926 for some @xmath69 , then @xmath927 . [ facintwal ] in case @xmath242 , there is nothing to show , so assume @xmath928 . then the first statement is an immediate consequence of corollary [ purelc ] and the fact that the elements @xmath64 are defined as connected components of @xmath929 . let @xmath119 such that @xmath930 and @xmath931 . let @xmath541 be the convex hull of the vertices @xmath932 , where @xmath800 as we assume @xmath928 . for the same reason we can assume @xmath933 for some @xmath934 , and without loss of generality we can assume @xmath935 . then @xmath936 is the convex hull of @xmath937 . by remark [ rem : scs ] @xmath885 is a simplicial complex , hence @xmath936 is a simplex in @xmath13 contained in @xmath885 . _ proof of proposition [ ssimpcomp ] . _ let @xmath538 , then @xmath938 for some @xmath69 , @xmath939 . in particular @xmath940 carries the structure of a simplex , since by remark [ rem : scs ] @xmath885 is a simplex . so let @xmath941 , we have to show @xmath942 . the intersection @xmath943 is not empty , as it contains @xmath944 . assume @xmath945 , for @xmath946 , @xmath947 . in the case @xmath948 there is nothing to show , as @xmath949 is a simplicial complex by remark [ rem : scs ] . so from now on let @xmath950 . consider the case that @xmath951 , we find @xmath952 . the set @xmath795 can be written as @xmath953 by remark [ rem : scs ] . by lemma [ facintwal ] the intersection @xmath954 for @xmath955 is either @xmath541 , in case that @xmath956 contains @xmath541 , or equals @xmath936 . in both cases , it is again a simplex in @xmath885 . we can conclude that @xmath957 for every @xmath538 . now let @xmath958 , then @xmath959 is a simplex in @xmath885 by lemma [ facintwal ] . but @xmath943 can be written as @xmath960 , using the previous part of the proof shows our claim . in this section we recall definitions and basic facts regarding chamber complexes and type functions following @xcite . note that the first property is always satisfied if @xmath966 is finite . in this case it is easy to see ( cp . * , p.15 ) ) that every chamber has the same rank . a consequence from 2 ) is that every element in a gallery is again a chamber . for two chambers @xmath967 and @xmath859 with @xmath968 and @xmath969 we have @xmath970 ( cp . this allows us to define the _ corank of @xmath315 _ as @xmath971 for any chamber @xmath4 containing @xmath315 . we call @xmath4 and @xmath965 _ adjacent _ , if @xmath972 . a type function @xmath574 with index set @xmath565 induces a weak type function @xmath979 . conversely , we show in lemma [ wnumisnum ] that a weak type function @xmath980 on a strongly connected chamber complex gives rise to a type function @xmath574 such that @xmath981 . let @xmath837 be a chamber complex , such that all sets @xmath985 are gated for @xmath986 with @xmath987 . let @xmath4 be a chamber and @xmath574 be type function of @xmath988 , there exists a unique weak type function @xmath989 such that @xmath990 . [ gsimpwn ] by definition every maximal element in @xmath13 is of the form @xmath494 for some @xmath69 . assume @xmath995 for @xmath996 , then @xmath494 is contained in some @xmath53 by remark [ rem : scs ] , which contradicts to the definition of @xmath70 . this proves @xmath994 . two closed chambers @xmath1005 are adjacent , if @xmath1006 . with respect to lemma [ adjsep ] we find that @xmath129 are adjacent if and only if @xmath1007 is a unique minimal gallery from @xmath64 to @xmath26 . the complex @xmath13 is a chamber complex , since every simplex is contained in a chamber and two chambers @xmath217 are connected by a gallery of length @xmath224 by lemma [ sepisdis ] and @xmath224 is finite by lemma [ finsep ] . for two elements @xmath217 we can therefore define the distance @xmath1011 as the length of a minimal gallery connecting @xmath129 . let @xmath541 be a simplex in @xmath13 , and consider the simplicial complex @xmath1012 with chambers @xmath1013 . let @xmath1014 and assume @xmath1015 , so @xmath1016 . the fact that @xmath1014 implies @xmath1017 . we need to show that there exists a gallery in @xmath1018 from @xmath64 to @xmath26 , which we do by induction on @xmath1011 . for @xmath1019 we have that @xmath129 are adjacent . so let @xmath1020 and assume @xmath946 with the properties that @xmath982 are adjacent , @xmath1021 and @xmath287 . then @xmath1022 by lemma [ starsep ] , and @xmath1023 implies @xmath1024 . in particular we get @xmath1025 and by induction there exists a gallery from @xmath146 to @xmath26 in @xmath1013 , so we are done . let @xmath538 , then there exists @xmath69 and @xmath1027 such that @xmath1028 . in particular , @xmath1029 . a point @xmath50 as above exists , since @xmath541 has nonempty interior with respect to @xmath1030 . let @xmath837 be a strongly connected chamber complex . if @xmath837 is weakly numbered , it is already numbered . in particular , if @xmath1031 is a weak type function , there exists a type function @xmath574 such that @xmath1032 for all @xmath1033 . [ wnumisnum ] assume @xmath986 , and let @xmath129 be chambers with @xmath1038 . since @xmath837 is strongly connected , @xmath1018 is connected , and we find @xmath1039 . thus we find a gallery @xmath1040 from @xmath64 to @xmath26 with all @xmath1041 , so in particular @xmath1042 for all @xmath1043 . also @xmath1044 and @xmath302 are adjacent for @xmath1045 , therefore @xmath1046 and inductively we obtain @xmath1047 . this allows us to define @xmath1048 for every simplex @xmath541 and every chamber @xmath64 containing @xmath541 . by definition @xmath574 coincides with @xmath1049 on all simplices @xmath663 contained in @xmath64 , in particular @xmath1050 is a type function and thus a morphism of chamber complexes . the construction of the weak type function is actually quite simple . begin with a chamber @xmath64 and consider a type function @xmath574 of @xmath949 . let @xmath26 be adjacent to @xmath64 such that @xmath1051 . then set @xmath1052 . let @xmath1053 be the unique index such that @xmath1054 , then @xmath574 maps the vertex not contained in @xmath541 to @xmath97 , so @xmath1055 must map the vertex @xmath232 in @xmath1056 not contained in @xmath541 to @xmath97 as well . so as every simplex @xmath1057 is either contained in @xmath541 or contains @xmath232 , if @xmath3 is contained in @xmath541 then @xmath1058 is already defined , if it contains @xmath232 set @xmath1059 . one can check that @xmath1055 is a morphism of chamber complexes , and furthermore @xmath1055 is the only possible type function of @xmath1056 satisfying @xmath1052 . in this way we can inductively construct type functions for all chambers with arbitrary distance to @xmath64 . this construction works always , however being well defined arises as a problem : given a chamber @xmath26 with @xmath1060 , there may be two chambers @xmath1061 with @xmath1062 and @xmath1061 adjacent to @xmath26 . then @xmath26 has induced type functions from @xmath22 as well as from @xmath23 . now theorem [ numbext ] yields that these two induced type functions coincide , and thus the method gives us a weak type function of @xmath13 . we say that a complex @xmath837 is _ spherical _ if it contains a pair of chambers @xmath982 such that @xmath1063 for all panels @xmath1064 containing @xmath64 . the chamber @xmath146 with such a property is called _ opposite _ to @xmath64 . thin : since @xmath1067 has two connected components , the complex @xmath13 is meager . it is thin if and only if for every chamber @xmath4 and every wall @xmath1068 there exists a chamber @xmath1069 which is @xmath118-adjacent to @xmath4 . in this case @xmath1070 , since @xmath2 is convex . then @xmath1071 , therefore @xmath118 meets @xmath2 and is contained in @xmath35 . let @xmath13 be spherical . by definition we find two opposite chambers @xmath4 and @xmath1073 . as @xmath13 is meagre by construction , we also know @xmath1074 . in particular @xmath1075 , and @xmath70 is finite as well as @xmath35 . assume @xmath4 has no @xmath97-adjacent chamber for an @xmath1053 and let @xmath1064 be the @xmath97-panel containing @xmath4 , then @xmath1076 for all @xmath1077 , a contradiction . thus @xmath13 is also thin . by our previous argument therefore @xmath62 is thin . let @xmath1078 . since @xmath2 can not be written as a finite union of hyperplanes , we can assume that @xmath81 for all @xmath53 . thus take a neighborhood @xmath76 of @xmath50 and consider the chambers intersecting @xmath76 . by taking a smaller @xmath76 we can also assume that only a single chamber @xmath965 intersects @xmath76 . thus there exists a wall of @xmath965 not meeting @xmath2 , a contradiction to @xmath35 being thin . hence @xmath38 is empty and @xmath1072 holds . a. berman and r. j. plemmons , _ nonnegative matrices in the mathematical sciences _ , academic press [ harcourt brace jovanovich , publishers ] , new york - london , 1979 , computer science and applied mathematics . a. bjrner , m. las vergnas , b. sturmfels , n. white , and g. m. ziegler , _ oriented matroids _ , second ed . , encyclopedia of mathematics and its applications , vol . 46 , cambridge university press , cambridge , 1999 . b. grnbaum , _ arrangements of hyperplanes _ , proceedings of the second louisiana conference on combinatorics , graph theory and computing ( louisiana state univ . , baton rouge , la . , 1971 ) ( baton rouge , la . ) , louisiana state univ . , 1971 , pp . 41106 . l. paris , _ lectures on artin groups and the @xmath9 conjecture _ , groups of exceptional type , coxeter groups and related geometries , springer proc . math . stat . , vol . 82 , springer , new delhi , 2014 , pp . 239257 . to3em , _ uvres / collected works . i , ii , iii , iv _ , heritage of european mathematics , european mathematical society ( ems ) , zrich , 2013 , edited by francis buekenhout , bernhard matthias mhlherr , jean - pierre tignol and hendrik van maldeghem . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: we define a _ sociotechnical system _ as one involving interactions between _ autonomous _ social entities such as people and organizations mediated by technical components . by emphasizing the autonomous nature of social entities , our definition generalizes over , yet more precisely captures , the traditional connotation of the interaction between humans and societal infrastructure . our definition contrasts with one of the conventional uses of the term , which covers any interaction between people and computers . researchers in software engineering ( se ) picked up the theme of sociotechnical systems in two major directions : ( 1 ) how to model a sociotechnical system as a combination of social and software components , as in @xcite ; and ( 2 ) how to elicit , model , and manage the requirements of the social components so that suitable software components may be designed @xcite . often , there is substantial overlap between the two directions , for example , as in i * @xcite . baxter and sommerville conceptualize a sociotechnical system as one that _ actively pursues goals _ in an organizational setting ; that is , a sociotechnical system is one actor : a single locus of control . therefore , we refer to such systems as being _ conceptually centralized_. the centralized conception is shared by current se approaches . for clarity , we reserve the term _ principal _ to refer to an autonomous social party who participates in a system at runtime and the term _ stakeholder _ to refer to one who originates some of the requirements . in general , any principal would also be a stakeholder in the system ( suitably abstracted via the notion of _ roles _ ) . we restrict our attention to systems whose membership and structure can change dynamically . open _ sociotechnical systems are properly viewed as _ societies _ of principals : we can not build a `` complete '' system but can only specify how its members may _ interact _ , leaving as out of our scope the engineering of the members themselves . thus whether the members _ comply _ with the specified interactions is crucial . because of its emphasis on interaction , we term our approach interaction - oriented software engineering or _ iose_. we claim that iose is necessary and show that the centralized conception is not applicable in sociotechnical systems . common settings such as business services and social computing realize open sociotechnical systems . consider schield et al.s description of a healthcare system in the united states , including its key stakeholders and their ( presumed ) objectives . * us society : the collective public , private , and personal interests of the united states citizens . * regulatory bodies : public and private that make and enforce policies . * mco : managed care organizations ( i.e. , licensed insurance organizations ) , who offer and administer managed care plans . * institutional providers : hospitals and laboratories . * clinical or professional providers : individual doctors and communities of practice . * employers : fully insured and self - funded organizations who offer managed care plans to their employees . * consumers : the enrollees of managed care plans . * medicaid or medicare beneficiaries . schield et al . find that the stakeholders objectives often conflict . for example , payers must keep costs down whereas providers must maximize revenue ; insurers want to shift risk to providers and consumers for matters of cost control whereas both providers and consumers want protection from potentially catastrophic costs . consumers want shorter waiting periods for appointments with their physicians whereas physicians want to increase their panel of patients . further , schield et al . point out how one principal can , in pursuing its own objectives , compromise the objectives of others . for example , making a patient wait longer may compromise the patient s health , thereby increasing the cost of care and decreasing patient satisfaction . regulatory bodies have the objective of making sure mcos and providers play by the rules and ensuring that cost , quality , and access criteria are met but that conflicts with society s goals of lower - cost healthcare . assume that the stakeholders for a healthcare system manage to resolve their differences and specify a system that meets their stated collective requirements . now , individual _ principals _ such as specific mcos , hospitals , physicians , employees , and consumers can join or leave the managed healthcare system of their own volition . the principals act according to their own private business policies , some of which may not have been envisaged by the stakeholders . for example , an mco may have a private objective to acquire an independent call center . further , principals would generally employ their own internal information systems to support their interactions with other principals . for example , providers may set up appointment systems to handle appointment - related communications with consumers . hospitals and mcos may use complex information systems that help process payments from each other and the consumers . mcos may employ complex actuarial and decision - support processes in handling claims . recognizing and addressing conflicts among stakeholders requirements has been a longstanding area of research in software engineering . once the conflicts are addressed , through whichever means , engineers would seek to model and realize a system that meets those requirements . this paper treats conflict analysis as out of scope and instead focuses on identifying modeling assumptions and criteria that capture sociotechnical systems more faithfully . this paper makes two main contributions . first , it shows via conceptual analysis why iose is ( 1 ) a novel paradigm and ( 2 ) well - suited for the software engineering of open sociotechnical systems . our argument proceeds as follows . one , we show that the foundational models of traditional se are conceptually centralized . this is because traditional se concerns itself with the engineering of what is conceptually a single machine ( section [ sec : machine - orientation ] ) . two , we present the conceptual model of a system in iose ( section [ sec : iose ] ) and discuss how it accommodates multiple perspectives . three , based on the characteristics of sociotechnical systems , namely , autonomy , accountability , and loose coupling , we formulate criteria that any se approach for them should meet and show that whereas machine - orientation , and therefore traditional se , fails the criteria , iose meets them ( section [ sec : eval - machine - iose ] ) . the second contribution of this paper lies in reinterpreting the broad se principles of modularity , encapsulation , abstraction , and the separation of concerns in accordance with the above criteria ( section [ sec : principles - iose ] ) . the reinterpretation provides the elements of a methodology for iose . further , we discuss in detail well - known software methodologies that are motivated either by sociotechnical systems or the modeling of interactions among principals and show how they violate one or more of these principles ( section [ sec : prominent - approaches ] ) . section [ sec : literature ] discusses additional literature that is relevant to iose . section [ sec : discussion ] concludes the paper with pointers to future directions . figure [ fig : re - conceptual - model ] ( from van lamsweerde ) shows the traditional conceptual model for se . the _ system as is _ represents the system with identified problems , inefficiencies , and limitations . the _ system to be _ , whose _ objectives _ are to avoid those deficiencies , is to be engineered . the idea is to understand the problem domain in order to come up with a set of _ services _ , _ constraints _ , and _ assumptions _ under which the stated objectives would be met . some of these would be met by the _ software to be _ as part of the system to be ; the rest would be assigned as responsibilities to components in the _ environment _ , namely , _ people _ , _ devices _ , and _ existing software_. = [ blue!40!black , font= * * ] = [ font= ] = [ align = center ] * * = [ draw , rectangle , align = center , minimum height=5ex , text width=8ex ] ( why ) at ( 0,5.5 ) why ? ; ( what ) at ( 0,3.2 ) what ? ; ( who ) at ( 0,0 ) who ? ; ( cloud ) at ( 7.0,5.75 ) objectives ; ( core ) at ( 2.4,5.55 ) [ cols="^ " , ] ; background ( lbl.north-| e.east ) rectangle ( p.south-| p.west ) ; even more generally , given a set of requirements , the essential idea is to come up with the specification of a _ machine _ ( equivalently , the software to be above ) that along with reasonable domain assumptions satisfies the requirements of the stakeholders @xcite . the _ system as is _ is the system as it exists without the machine and helps us understand the environment in which the machine will be introduced . the system to be is what the system will be when the machine is introduced . if all goes well in the system to be , the stakeholders requirements are satisfied . it is important to understand the nature of the machine . figure [ fig : machine - environment ] ( from @xcite but based on @xcite ) illustrates an operational conceptualization of the machine - environment interface . here , the _ software to be _ represents the machine . a machine is a _ controller _ that maps inputs from its environment ( by monitoring certain variables ) to outputs or effects in the environment ( by setting certain variables ) . in other words , it processes inputs to produce outputs . to its users ( in the environment ) , a machine provides computational services ( functionality ) . in its very conception , a machine corresponds to a single locus of control . indeed , it is common in software engineering to talk of machines as acting in pursuit of goals @xcite . traditional se is machine - oriented it concerns itself with the specification of a machine ( even if implemented via distributed components ) that would meet stakeholder requirements . thus traditional se reflects a _ conceptually centralized _ perspective , namely , of the stakeholders , considered collectively . = [ thick , draw = none , text width=15ex , align = center ] = [ box , fill = blue!20!gray!40 ] = [ box , fill = black!10 ] = [ box , draw = black , thin , fill = white , text = black ] = [ blue!40!black , draw = none , text width=10ex , align = center ] = [ font= ] = [ align = center ] ( machine_envt ) [ draw = none , row sep=1 mm , column sep=3 mm ] ( empty - tl ) ; & ( input ) input devices + ( sensors ) ; & ( empty - tr ) ; + ( environment ) environment ; & & ( software ) software to be ; + ( empty - bl ) ; & ( output ) output devices + ( actuators ) ; & ( empty - br ) ; + ; ( environment ) .. controls ( empty - tl ) .. node [ edge_label , above ] monitored + variables ( input ) ; ( input ) .. controls ( empty - tr ) .. node [ edge_label , above ] input + data ( software ) ; ( output ) .. controls ( empty - bl ) .. node [ edge_label , below ] controlled + variables ( environment ) ; ( software ) .. controls ( empty - br ) .. node [ edge_label , below ] output + data ( output ) ; the above account of machine - orientation , taken from leading writings on se , is agnostic to particular software methodologies . machine - orientation manifests itself in specific modeling notations and methodologies , some of which have been highly influential in se . many existing requirements - based approaches , although differing in their details , instantiate the same concepts at their core : machine , environment , system as is , and system to be . tropos @xcite and i * @xcite refer to a model of the system as is and the system to be as the early and late requirements models , respectively . in their terminology , the environment is a set of _ actors _ ; the machine itself is the _ system actor_. for example , tropos would create a system actor for an entire healthcare system . this actor would capture ( a consistent subset of ) the goals of all stakeholders , thereby functioning as a logically centralized machine . following kaos @xcite , one would create a set of _ agents _ with designer - assigned individual goals . however , the set of agents is conceptually a single machine because there is a single locus of design . this follows from the fact that goals are assigned to agents and , therefore , at a high - level the agents have already been specified . indeed , referring specifically to kaos ( and to feather s work , which provides the conceptual basis for kaos ) , zave and jackson observe that even though kaos supports multiple agents , it is only a refinement of their more basic single - machine framework . let us apply the above conceptual model of systems to the healthcare scenario . imagine that a healthcare machine were built to a specified set of stakeholder requirements . the machine would control various medical devices and other equipment . users such as consumers , providers , mcos , and so via on would interface with the machine via a web interface . consider the example of scheduling an appointment with a physician . the physician would have configured his or her preferences in the machine : his or her daily schedule , how long a time period to allot each patient , and so on . those are the physician s inputs to the machine , which the machine uses in scheduling patient appointments . the patient s interface would display the available slots and enable him or her to choose from among those slots . the machine records each selection , and produces as output a confirmation of the appointment , perhaps also by email . further , the machine grays out the slot for future scheduling . the machine additionally supports the processing of claims and payments among hospitals and insurers . the machine would encode the insurance company s process of queuing claims above $ 10,000 separately for detailed examination . the insurance company through its interface can obtain the claims from the appropriate queues . the machine would implement the appropriate access control so that users can access the appropriate functionality . traditional se , in spite of its conceptually centralized perspective , may be applied to yield a physically distributed machine . web applications suggest physical distribution and applying kaos would result in a physically distributed set of agents . in general , techniques from software architecture may be applied to internally decompose a machine into distributed components . rapanotti et al . employ such an approach in the decomposition of machines in the problem frames approach . we define a _ protocol _ of a sociotechnical system as a specification of how interactions among its roles would proceed . in business settings , the protocol can take the form of a business contract that principals would enter into upon adopting different roles . for example , in texas , if medco wishes to play the role of mco , it must enter into a _ uniform managed care _ contract with the state health commission ( which alone plays the regulatory body role ) @xcite . at any point during the interaction , the set of social expectations represents the _ social state _ of the system . a protocol serves three purposes . one , it makes public the social expectations of the participants while giving them the flexibility to follow their individual objectives . for example , public funding agencies may expect that mcos , upon notification , refund payments made in error within 30 days . two , it identifies which participant is accountable to which participant for what expectation . for instance , if medco , who plays mco , does not refund an erroneous payment in time , the funding agency may hold medco accountable . three , it frees participants to implement their information systems as they please as long as they satisfy the given protocol . for example , medco might employ any representation it chooses and may apply its policies in deciding whether to provide a refund early or late within the 30-day window . = [ thick , draw = none , text width=11ex , align = center ] = [ box , fill = green!10!blue!30!gray!60 ] = [ box , fill = black!10 ] = [ box , fill = green!10!blue!30!gray!40 ] = [ box , draw = black , thin , fill = white , text = black ] = [ blue!40!black , draw = none , text width=10ex , align = center ] = [ font= ] = [ align = center ] ( machine_envt ) [ draw = none , row sep=1 mm , column sep=3 mm ] ( environment - l ) environment ; & & & ( environment - r ) environment ; + & ( empty - top - l ) ; & ( empty - top - r ) ; + ( empty - principal - l ) ; & ( principal - l ) principal ; & ( principal - r ) principal ; & ( empty - principal - r ) ; + ; + ( empty - ml ) ; & ( role - l ) role ; & ( role - r ) role ; & ( empty - mr ) ; + ; + & ( empty - bcl ) ; & ( empty - bcr ) ; + ; ( sociotechnical system ) sociotechnical system as protocol ; ( protocol ) + meanings ; ( principal-l.south ) .. controls ( protocol.south ) .. ( principal-r.south ) ; ( environment-l.south ) .. controls ( empty - principal - l ) .. ( principal-l.west ) ; ( environment - r ) .. controls ( empty - principal - r ) .. ( principal - r ) ; background ( empty - top - l.north-| principal-r.east ) rectangle ( protocol.south-| principal-l.west ) ; accordingly , the objective of iose is to specify a _ sociotechnical system _ as a protocol that defines two or more _ roles_. figure [ fig : system ] describes how iose applies . for the sociotechnical system to be instantiated , principals adopt roles in the protocol . each principal continues to interact with its environment even after it joins the system . the principals communicate with each other within the scope of the system , which means that they are subject to the meanings defined in the protocol that specifies the system . in engineering terms , the main artifact produced by iose is the protocol which , through its roles , itself serves as a requirement for the principals who would adopt those roles . whereas traditional se seeks to specify a machine , iose seeks to specify a protocol . whereas a machine captures a single locus of control , iose naturally supports multiple perspectives as roles in a protocol . in iose , each principal , who adopts one or more roles , is a locus of control a reasoner and a sender and receiver of communications . we introduce commitment protocols @xcite as an example iose approach . a ( social ) commitment captures an elementary business relationship between a debtor and a creditor @xcite . specifically , the commitment @xmath0 says that the debtor @xmath1 commits to the creditor @xmath2 that if the antecedent @xmath3 comes to hold , then it will bring the consequent @xmath4 . the elementary operations on commitments are create , release , cancel , delegate , and assign . the social nature of commitments owes to the fact that they progress due to interactions among principals , not due to the internal reasoning of any principal . commitment protocols exploit this connection by specifying the meanings of _ messages _ in terms of how they affect commitments , thus enabling principals to interact flexibly . other abstractions could potentially be used in addition to commitments but , for simplicity , we confine the present discussion to commitments . table [ table : scheduling - protocol ] shows a partial appointment scheduling protocol . the protocol involves two roles , phy ( for physician ) and pat ( for patient ) . assume that via the enactment of some other protocol , ( any physician playing ) phy is committed to ( any patient playing ) pat to provide the latter with a list of available appointment slots upon the latter s request for appointment ( this commitment , for instance , could be set up when a patient registers with a physician for the first time ) . we represent this commitment as @xmath5 . the availableslots message from phy to pat conveys the list of available slots to the pat : it means that phy commits to pat that if pat commits to show up for one of those slots , then phy will commit to showing up for that slot as well . the select message from pat to phy commits pat to a selected slot . the confirmslot message from phy to pat for a particular slot commits phy to the slot . a complete and effective meeting scheduling protocol would additionally include messages that deal with meeting cancellation and rescheduling . figure [ fig : ms - progression ] depicts the progression of social state according to the meanings in table [ table : scheduling - protocol ] and using the commitments introduced in table [ table : scheduling - protocol - commitments ] . alessia plays phy and bianca plays pat . upon bianca sending the requestappointment message to alessia , the antecedent of @xmath6 is satisfied . this makes alessia unconditionally committed to sending her the available slots ( @xmath7 ) . when alessia sends the list of available slots ( at 1400 and 1600 hours ) , she discharges @xmath7 and creates @xmath8 . bianca communicates her selection of 1400 , which makes alessia unconditionally committed to confirming it ; in other words , bianca creates @xmath9 , which creates @xmath10 ( the unconditional version of @xmath8 ) . finally , alessia confirms the selected slot , thus creating @xmath11 and discharging @xmath10 . in the final state of figure [ fig : ms - progression ] , both alessia and bianca are committed to each other for showing up at the selected time . = [ thick , draw = none , text width=7ex , minimum height=7ex , align = center ] = [ box , fill = green!10!blue!30!gray!60 ] = [ blue!40!black , auto = true , font= ] = [ edge_label , fill = white , auto = false ] ( soc-1 ) [ draw = blue!20!black , row sep=25 , column sep=0 ] ( alessia-1 ) alessia + mi ; + ( bianca-1 ) bianca + mp ; + ; ( soc-2 ) [ draw = blue!20!black , row sep=25 , column sep=0,right of = soc-1 ] ( alessia-2 ) alessia + mi ; + ( bianca-2 ) bianca + mp ; + ; ( soc-3 ) [ draw = blue!20!black , row sep=25 , column sep=0,right of = soc-2 ] ( alessia-3 ) alessia + mi ; + ( bianca-3 ) bianca + mp ; + ; ( soc-4 ) [ draw = blue!20!black , row sep=25 , column sep=0,below of = soc-3,left of = soc-3,node distance=90 ] ( alessia-4 ) alessia + mi ; + ( bianca-4 ) bianca + mp ; + ; ( soc-5 ) [ draw = blue!20!black , row sep=25 , column sep=0,left of = soc-4 ] ( alessia-5 ) alessia + mi ; + ( bianca-5 ) bianca + mp ; + ; ( alessia-1.south ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath12 ( bianca-1.north ) ; ( alessia-2.south ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath13 ( bianca-2.north ) ; ( alessia-3.south ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath14 ( bianca-3.north ) ; ( alessia-4.240 ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath15 ( bianca-4.120 ) ; ( bianca-4.60 ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath16 ( alessia-4.300 ) ; ( alessia-5.240 ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath17 ( bianca-5.120 ) ; ( bianca-5.60 ) to node [ edge_label_in ] @xmath16 ( alessia-5.300 ) ; ( soc-1.east ) to node [ pos=0.5,edge_label_in ] requestappointment ( ) ( soc-2.west ) ; ( soc-2.east ) to node [ pos=0.5,edge_label_in ] availableslots(1400,1600 ) ( soc-3.west ) ; ( soc-3.south ) to node [ pos=0.5,edge_label_in , xshift=10 ] selectslot(1400 ) ( soc-4.east ) ; ( soc-4.west ) to node [ pos=0.5,edge_label_in ] confirmslot(1400 ) ( soc-5.east ) ; protocols for handling claims between providers and mco would be more complex than those for appointment scheduling . desai et al . specify protocols for automobile insurance and show how to compose protocols . we focus on appointment scheduling because ( 1 ) it illustrates the essential concepts of iose , and ( 2 ) it bears similarity to meeting scheduling , an application that has been studied extensively in the literature , and which we discuss in detail in section [ sec : prominent - approaches ] . figure [ fig : system - types ] describes three takes on a sociotechnical system . figure [ fig : old ] shows the most traditional setting , which even predates it . here , one can imagine a sociotechnical system as realized by two or more principals , each with its own ledgers , and interacting via the postal service or foot messenger . the principals are autonomous . the same situation holds in the case of digital communication , where we can think of the messaging system as providing the necessary message delivery functionality . in this case too , the messages the principals send and receive are opaque to the communication network . in either case , there is no computational support for the social state . indeed , there is no computational support for anything beyond message transport and , possibly operational constraints such as message ordering . each principal maintains its expectations and commitments in its ledgers and acts according to its local policies . for example , a physician may send a request to a laboratory to find a patient s cholesterol and the laboratory may send back the results along with an invoice . = [ thin , draw , align = center , anchor = center , minimum height=20,inner sep=2pt , font= ] = [ box , fill = blue!20!gray!20,draw = none , minimum height=6ex , rounded corners ] = [ box , draw = none , circle , fill = green!10!blue!30!gray!60,minimum width=6 ] = [ shape = cloud , align = center , thick , aspect=4,fill = green!10!blue!30!gray!40 ] = [ blue!40!black , draw = none ] = [ annotation , midway , anchor = south , align = center ] = [ align = center ] = [ anchor = base east ] = [ anchor = base east ] 0.3 ( trust ) [ draw = none , matrix of nodes , row sep=10,column sep=0 ] ( xx ) ; & [ 35]&[35 ] ( yy ) ; + ( empty - tl ) ; & & ( empty - tr ) ; + ( empty - ml ) ; & & ( empty - mr ) ; + ( empty - bl ) ; & & ( empty - br ) ; + ; let 1 = ( xx.west ) , 2 = ( yy.east ) , 3 = ( empty-bl.south west ) , 4 = ( empty - ml ) in node ( bl ) at ( 1 + 0,3 ) node ( br ) at ( 2 - 0,3 ) node ( tl ) at ( 1 + 0,4 - 10 ) node ( tr ) at ( 2 - 0,4 - 10 ) ; node [ activity , fit= ( bl ) ( br ) ( tl ) ( tr ) ( empty-bl.south ) ( empty-br.south),inner sep=0,minimum height=40 ] ( communication ) ; let 1 = ( communication.west ) , 2 = ( communication.east ) , 3 = ( communication.north ) in node [ font=,draw = none , align = center , minimum height=40,anchor = north ] at ( 3,3 - 0 ) + ; ( yy.south ) |-(yy.south|-communication.center)-| ( xx.south ) ; 0.3 ( trust ) [ draw = none , matrix of nodes , row sep=10,column sep=0 ] ( xx ) ; & [ 35]&[35 ] ( yy ) ; + ( empty - tl ) ; & ( empty - tr ) ; + ( empty - ml ) ; & ( empty - mr ) ; + ( empty - bl ) ; & & ( empty - br ) ; + ; let 1 = ( xx.west ) , 2 = ( yy.east ) , 3 = ( empty-bl.south west ) , 4 = ( empty - ml ) in node ( bl ) at ( 1 + 0,3 ) node ( br ) at ( 2 - 0,3 ) node ( tl ) at ( 1 + 0,4 - 10 ) node ( tr ) at ( 2 - 0,4 - 10 ) ; node [ activity , fit= ( bl ) ( br ) ( tl ) ( tr ) ( empty-bl.south ) ( empty-br.south),inner sep=0,minimum height=40 ] ( communication ) ; let 1 = ( communication.west ) , 2 = ( communication.east ) , 3 = ( communication.north ) in node [ font=,draw = none , align = center , minimum height=40,anchor = north ] at ( 3,3 - 0 ) + ; ( xx.south ) to node [ edge_label , right ] api ( xx.south|-communication.north ) ; ( yy.south ) to node [ edge_label , left ] api ( yy.south|-communication.north ) ; 0.3 ( trust ) [ draw = none , matrix of nodes , row sep=10,column sep=0 ] ; & ( social ) ; & ; + ( xx ) ; & & ( yy ) ; + ( empty - tl ) ; & [ 70 ] ( empty - tr ) ; + ( empty - ml ) ; & & ( empty - mr ) ; + ( empty - bl ) ; & & ( empty - br ) ; + ; let 1 = ( xx.west ) , 2 = ( yy.east ) , 3 = ( empty-bl.south west ) , 4 = ( empty - ml ) in node ( bl ) at ( 1 + 0,3 ) node ( br ) at ( 2 - 0,3 ) node ( tl ) at ( 1 + 0,4 - 10 ) node ( tr ) at ( 2 - 0,4 - 10 ) ; node [ activity , fit= ( bl ) ( br ) ( tl ) ( tr ) ( empty-bl.south ) ( empty-br.south),inner sep=0,minimum height=40 ] ( communication ) ; let 1 = ( communication.west ) , 2 = ( communication.east ) , 3 = ( communication.north ) in node [ font=,draw = none , align = center , minimum height=40,anchor = north ] at ( 3,3 - 0 ) + ; \(xx ) to node [ edge_label , anchor = north ] protocol ( yy ) ; ( yy.south ) |-(yy.south|-communication.center)-| ( xx.south ) ; ( social.south ) |-(social.south|-xx.east ) ; figure [ fig : machine ] shows a more sophisticated , but traditional , approach wherein a machine mediates all interactions among the principals . the machine offers an api to the principals through which they can request changes in the social state . such conceptually centralized machines are not common for healthcare today , so we use ebay as an example and then return to healthcare . the auctioneer ebay offers a machine for conducting auctions that provides an api ( requiring little more than a web browser ) through which sellers can list items for sale and buyers can bid for listed items . the machine determines the social state : whether something is on sale , its reserve price , the time an auction closes , whether a bid is legitimate , the winning bid , and so on . the principals can represent their local view in their ledgers but what matters is the ebay machine s view . the machine happens to usually respect the requests of buyers and sellers but it does not need to . returning to the healthcare machine of section [ sec : machine - orientation ] , the patient may attempt to schedule an appointment with the physician , but the machine determines whether the appointment holds , i.e. , whether the patient and physician are each committed to showing up at the appointed time . the patient and the physician may maintain their local views of the social state but what the machine maintains is definitive . the same situation arises between the hospital and medco regarding their payments . in this setting , the only way the parties can interoperate is if they maintain their local views tightly synchronized with the central machine . in contrast , figure [ fig : iose ] shows how the principals enact a protocol with one another . the enactment takes advantage of infrastructure such as for communication . however , the social state is determined not by the infrastructure but through the enactment of the protocol . that is , the protocol specifies how the social state progresses . here too the principals can maintain their individual ledgers but what the protocol specifies is definitive . the important challenge of formalizing protocols to ensure that the local views remain sufficiently consistent with the protocol - specified `` public '' state without synchronization is out of our present scope . chopra and singh present a relevant approach . let us use the healthcare example of section [ sec : healthcare ] to motivate the key criteria that any software engineering methodology for sociotechnical systems must support . accommodate autonomy the autonomy of a principal ( a human , organization , or other social entity ) means that it is an independent locus of control with its own goals and policies , which reflect its business motivations and are normally private . thus even as a participant in a system , each principal is free in principle to act in pursuit of its own goals , without any consideration of others . for example , a hospital may decide not to entertain patients with a particular insurance provider , or physicians may increase the panel of patients they treat at the expense of reducing availability . figure [ fig : old ] is compatible with autonomy only to the extent that it does not model social state . figure [ fig : machine ] violates autonomy because the machine not only determines the definitive social state but also controls transitions on it . the principals have no direct relationship with each other . for example , a bid may be declined and a seller may not be able to change his mind and accept a bid lower than the reserve price . contrast the above with protocols . a protocol is not a computationally active entity and can not provide a service . a protocol simply specifies the correctness criteria for interaction among the participants . figure [ fig : iose ] expresses a protocol that specifies the appropriate social relationships among potential principals , capturing their legitimate expectations of each other . further , principals would enter into these relationships of their own volition ; no relationship is forced upon a principal , not even to ensure compliance . support accountability accountability is the flip side of autonomy . a participant is free to act as it pleases ; however , it is accountable to those that have legitimate social expectations of it . for example , a laboratory may legitimately expect that the mco transfer funds for services provided within a certain time after submission of claims . this means that the mco is accountable to the laboratory for transferring funds in time ; if it does not , it violates the laboratory s expectation . figure [ fig : old ] provides no support for accountability because it does not represent the social state . figure [ fig : machine ] holds each principal accountable to the central authority and , if it permits , to the other principals . for example , a buyer is accountable to ebay to pay in time . but if she persuades ebay to grant her an extension , the seller has no recourse within the ebay system . figure [ fig : iose ] bases accountability on a protocol and thus each principal is accountable to any other principal in whom it has created a legitimate expectation . in particular , through the protocol , each principal ought to be able to judge the compliance with its expectations of each principal with whom it interacts . accommodate loose coupling loose coupling captures the idea that each principal is an independent locus of design . it has full control over the design of its own information systems but no control over the design of other principals information systems . for example , a hospital may store information about a surgeon s willingness to work the night shift whereas the insurance company may capture the total charges for procedures led by that surgeon . and , hospitals in different jurisdictions may capture different patient monitoring data during a surgery . figure [ fig : old ] is compatible with loose coupling insofar as it elides the treatment of social state . in practice , it forces an ad hoc design of the interaction ( e.g. , message formats ) . because the message meanings are hidden , the principals who adapt their information systems risk failing interoperability . figure [ fig : machine ] requires that the principals adopt the same representation of the social state as the machine . the meanings of the messages sent over the api could be explicit but they usually are hardcoded in the machine , and sometimes in the principals information systems , if any . this produces a tighter coupling than desirable between the principals and the machine ( both considered as endpoints ) : when the machine changes , the principals must potentially change their own behaviors and any information systems that support them accordingly . by contrast , figure [ fig : iose ] employs a protocol with explicit meanings ( not hardcoded in any principals information system ) for the interactions . the iose approach , in effect , makes public the extent of the coupling . the principals may adapt their information systems without consideration of others as long as they follow the protocol . we introduce the core principles of iose . specifically , we contrast how the key principles of se : modularity and encapsulation @xcite , separation of concerns @xcite , and abstraction are manifested in current modeling approaches with how they are manifested in iose . we find that although the intuitions behind the principles hold , the technical details are completely different and , in many cases , antithetical to what we encounter in conventional se . modularity refers to the functional , most commonly hierarchical , decomposition of systems @xcite . the benefit of appropriately modularizing systems is composability . in the extreme , modules from different vendors may be composed as needed . as figure [ fig : machine - environment ] shows , the first - level application of modularity in se is the decomposition of the system into the environment and the machine . rapanotti et al . apply architectural patterns to decompose a problem frame into its constituent problem frames . kaos , i * , and tropos , being agent - oriented , support finer grained units of modularity . the agents therein may have responsibilities or provide services , as captured by the dependencies among them . in iose , a principal as an autonomous social entity is the natural unit of modularity . with autonomy comes accountability , as motivated by mamdani and pitt . without the ability to check compliance , though , accountability would be meaningless . _ example . _ although bianca is free to not show for the appointment once she commits to a slot , she is accountable for her commitment . _ benefit . _ promotes autonomy by not unduly restricting a principal s course of action . promotes accountability by providing a basis for ensuring _ correctness _ : a principal who does not comply may face sanctions from principals to whom it is accountable for the given expectation each principal autonomously becomes the debtor of any commitments @xcite . that is , the debtor must have initiated an interaction ( sent a message ) that leads to it being committed . in some cases , the message could itself create the commitment . in other cases , the debtor may have created some commitment ( as debtor ) whereby actions by other parties could lead to the creation of the given commitment . because commitments are created ultimately due to the communications of the debtor , the debtor is accountable for them . demands placed on a principal other than as the debtor of a commitment have no bearing on compliance or enforcement . abstraction refers to the level of the concepts used in a specification . the ideal abstraction is sufficiently high - level to hide details and reduce complexity , yet sufficiently low - level to support drawing the necessary conclusions . tropos and i * offer high - level abstractions such as goals , capabilities , and goal dependencies . sommerville et al . apply high - level notions of responsibility and delegation to requirements modeling . using high - level abstractions places requirements away from low - level notions such as tasks , plans , and state machines . in contrast , iose emphasizes abstractions that capture the meaning of an interaction . explicit social meaning make all social expectations explicit in the system specification . the meanings of individual communications must be explicitly formalized in terms of what they _ count as _ in the society being designed . in general , the meaning involves the creation or other manipulation of the commitments among the parties involved . _ example . _ table [ table : scheduling - protocol ] specifies the message meanings in an appointment scheduling protocol . _ benefit . _ explicit social meaning promotes loose coupling . as figure [ fig : ms - progression ] illustrates , the meaning captures how the principals social state progresses . the true social state progresses even if we have no computational representation of it . but lacking an explicit meaning , each principal could interpret messages in incompatible ways . for example , in the healthcare setting , a laboratory may interpret the messages with the claim information as leading to an unconditional commitment from the mco to honor the claim . the mco , however , may interpret the commitment as being conditional on the claim being valid . such misalignments could have serious repercussions for the principals ( e.g. , in producing their balance sheets ) and may lead to legal disputes . if the principals negotiate the meanings of the messages and hard - code them in their information systems , they would produce hidden couplings among themselves : changes in how one principal handles messages would need to be propagated to the others . additionally , explicit social meaning promotes accountability because if the meanings are public , then principals can potentially check the compliance of themselves and others . solely social meaning a system specification must specify _ only _ the possible communications and their meanings and nothing else . further , the meaning must be expressed in terms of social abstractions such as commitments . specifications of any operational details that have significance at the social level ( e.g. , a convention to pay first ) , must be captured via social abstractions ( e.g. , commitments ) . specifications that capture ordering and occurrence constraints separately from the meaning violate this principle . for example , one could specify in the appointment scheduling protocol that availableslots follow requestappointment . but here no one is accountable for the constraint : is the physician at fault for not delaying sending availableslots or is the patient at fault for not sending requestappointment ? instead , if this constraint is necessary as a social requirement , one or more of the principals should commit to enforcing it , e.g. , adopting marengo et al.s approach and placing temporal constraints in commitments . further , specifying the technical infrastructure does not capture a sociotechnical system . we might either model the social actor who provides the infrastructure and engage it via commitments or omit such technical constraints altogether since they apply at a lower level of abstraction . _ example . _ the above ordering constraint can be expressed @xcite as @xmath18 where the dot ( ` @xmath19 ' ) means _ occurs before_. _ benefit . _ promotes autonomy and accountability . no central controller enforces constraints in a sociotechnical system . every constraint logically ought to be some principal s responsibility . expressing a constraint as a hard constraint to be enforced magically by the environment either under - specifies the functioning of the system or ( in most current thinking ) postulates a central entity that is the sole autonomous principal and can impose its will upon all the other participants . separation of concerns refers to the treatment of each aspect of a problem independently of _ yet _ in relation to others . it refers to the sorting out of the different threads from what would otherwise be a tangled mess . often , the invocation of this principle is implicit . for example , zave and jackson s identification of domain assumptions , machine requirements , and user requirements as the separate but essential categories for re is at its heart an application of this principle . dardenne et al . and yu express early requirements in the form of goal models , thus separating the exploration of the problem space from the solution space . mylopoulos et al . separate nonfunctional from functional requirements . finkelstein et al . separate concerns explicitly based on stakeholders , acknowledging the fact that , in general , each stakeholder has different concerns and may employ different representations for expressing them . for sociotechnical systems , we must separate social and technical considerations . principals such as people and organizations must be distinguished from technical entities such as resources , legacy systems , software components , devices , communication infrastructure , and other technical objects in the environment . this is because social relationships are meaningful only among principals . a principal may only bear a control relationship ( e.g. , ownership , invocation , or access ) toward a technical entity as may one such entity toward another . only principals are autonomous and accountable : a patient can not sue an operating table but can sue a surgeon or a hospital . _ example . _ as figure [ fig : ms - progression ] shows , alessia and bianca maintain a social relationship . however , each of them maintains and controls an information system , which is not socially visible . _ benefit . _ separating the social and technical entities makes clear the kinds of relationships that would make sense among them . promotes accountability by making clear only principals are accountable to each other in the social sense . enables engineers of sociotechnical systems to focus solely on the social aspects . encapsulation refers to the principle that a module reveal no more information than is necessary to effectively use it , in particular , that it reveal no implementation details . figure [ fig : machine - environment ] highlights the interface between the machine and the environment but does not bind the machine to any particular internal implementation . zave and jackson characterize re as the process by which you arrive at the machine - environment interface ; anything more would amount to prematurely determining an implementation . in i * and tropos , dependencies among actors correspond to their interfaces . the idea of encapsulation , namely , to avoid examining the internals of a component , remains appropriate in iose . a direct consequence of this principle is that a sociotechnical system can not be specified in terms of mental abstractions such as beliefs , goals , intentions , and so on neither of its stakeholders nor of the principals who may participate in it . in particular , roles can not be specified in terms of mental abstractions . in iose , each role in a protocol refers only to the social commitments resulting from the communications that a principal adopting it would be involved in . _ example . _ neither the phy role nor the pat role has goal of scheduling appointment ; neither do they have a shared ( joint ) goal to schedule appointments . _ benefit . _ promotes loose coupling by hiding details not relevant to the interaction . also promotes accountability : a key reason we can not use mental concepts to specify a sociotechnical system is that they make determining compliance impossible @xcite . as mentioned earlier , accountability is meaningless if we can not check compliance . table [ table : principles ] presents the principles and their benefits at a glance . we now evaluate iose with some prominent approaches from se . we choose these either because ( 1 ) they are representative of broad classes of approaches for modeling sociotechnical systems ( i * , tropos , kaos ) , or ( 2 ) they give emphasis to interaction and protocols ( gaia and choreographies ) . lacking a treatment of healthcare in i * and tropos approaches , we study yu s treatment of meeting scheduling in i * @xcite , which is similar in spirit to the appointment scheduling protocol discussed earlier . despite its simplicity , meeting scheduling provides sufficient subtlety to demonstrate various modeling approaches @xcite and is extensively used in the literature . the main requirement in this scenario is to automate and make efficient some aspects of meeting scheduling so that the meeting initiator s burden is reduced . figure [ fig : sd - system - to - be ] shows the _ system to be _ for a meeting scheduling system in the i * notation . the circles represent the actors in the system : meeting initiator ( mi ) , meeting participant ( mp ) , and meeting scheduler ( ms ) . the directed links between the actors represent _ dependencies_. for example , mi depends on mp for achieving the goal that _ the participant attend the meeting _ ( ) . in the i * terminology , figure [ fig : sd - system - to - be ] is a _ strategic dependency _ ( sd ) diagram . according to yu , in _ early requirements engineering _ , i * helps come up with an initial set of requirements . specifically , i * helps identify the goals of the various stakeholders and their dependencies in achieving those goals . a new system actor is introduced unto which some of these goals are _ delegated_. the system actor represents the machine to be designed to meet stakeholder goals . this _ goal - modeling _ phase helps refine the system actor s goals and its dependencies with the other actors . in figure [ fig : sd - system - to - be ] , the meeting scheduler ms is the system actor and is responsible for many tasks that mi was responsible for in the system as is ( not shown ) , such as obtaining availability information from participants and choosing a date that suits all participants . = [ draw , rectangle , rounded corners=4pt , inner sep=2pt , text width=8ex , align = center ] = [ draw , ellipse , text width=6ex , align = center ] = [ draw , rectangle , text width=8ex , align = center ] = [ draw , circle , text width=6ex , align = center ] = [ myarrow data=0.5 ] = [ font= ] ( as - is ) [ draw = none , row sep=0 mm , column sep=2mm , align = center ] ( empty - tl ) ; & [ 0 mm ] & ( attends ) attends + meeting ; & [ 4 mm ] ( empty - tr ) ; + & ( scheduled ) meeting scheduled ; & & ( empty - two - r ) ; + & ( empty - three - l ) ; & ( available ) available dates ; & + ( initiator ) meeting + initiator + ( mi ) ; & ( scheduler ) meeting + scheduler + ( ms ) ; & ( proposed ) proposed dates ; & ( participant ) meeting + participant + ( mp ) ; + & & ( agreed ) agreement ; + & ( range ) date range ; & ( subgoal ) attends + meeting ; + ( empty - bl ) ; & ( assured ) assured ; & & ( important ) important + participant + ( ip ) ; + ; ( important ) to ( participant ) ; ( initiator ) .. controls ( empty - tl ) .. ( attends ) ; ( attends ) .. controls ( empty - tr ) .. ( participant ) ; ( initiator ) to [ bend left ] ( scheduled.west ) ; ( scheduled ) to ( scheduler ) ; ( initiator ) to [ bend right ] ( range ) ; ( range ) to ( scheduler ) ; ( scheduler ) .. controls ( empty - three - l ) .. ( available.west ) ; ( available.east ) to [ bend left ] ( participant ) ; ( scheduler ) to ( proposed ) ; ( proposed ) to ( participant ) ; ( scheduler ) to ( agreed.west ) ; ( agreed.east ) to ( participant ) ; ( initiator ) .. controls ( empty - bl ) .. ( assured ) ; ( assured ) to ( important ) ; ( initiator.south ) to ( subgoal ) ; ( subgoal ) to ( important ) ; tropos is an agent - oriented software engineering ( aose ) methodology that builds on the i * metamodel @xcite . tropos follows i * s goal modeling phase with an architectural phase that maps the system actor to new actors that are interconnected through appropriate data and control dependencies . the detailed design phase models each of these actors as one or more belief - desire - intention agents . the implementation phase realizes the agents , thereby completely implementing the system actor . both i * and tropos would create a system actor for an entire healthcare system . this actor would capture ( a consistent subset of ) the goals of all stakeholders , thereby functioning as a logically centralized machine . the comments below apply equally to i * and tropos . * _ accountability modularity : _ violated . there is no discrete principal behind the system actor and it is not meaningful to talk of its accountability . for example , ms , the system actor in figure [ fig : sd - system - to - be ] is not accountable to the stakeholders . in general , dependencies in i * do not support accountability just because an actor depends on another for a goal does not make the latter accountable for it . for example , figure [ fig : sd - system - to - be ] shows that the mi depends on the mp for attending the meeting ; however it does not automatically follow ( without reasoning about communication and the resulting commitments , as in iose ) that the mp is accountable for showing up . * _ explicit social meaning : _ partially fulfilled . the purpose behind the notion of dependencies in i * was to capture interactor relations in terms of high - level abstractions . however , i * dependencies refer to actors mental states , and are not social , as further explained under encapsulation below . * _ solely social meaning : _ partially fulfilled . dependencies are the only interactor abstraction . however , as we mentioned above , i * dependencies are not social abstractions . * _ separating social from technical : _ partially fulfilled . i * treats social and technical actors alike with the same kinds of dependencies between any pair of actors . for example , ms is a technical actor whereas mp and mi are stakeholders but ms s dependencies with mi and mp are of the same nature as those between mi and mp . however , to its credit , in the early requirements modeling phase , all the actors are stakeholders and only in the later phases ( starting from late requirements modeling ) are technical actors introduced . * _ no principal internals : _ violated . an i * goal dependency between two actors @xmath1 and @xmath2 for some goal @xmath20 means that @xmath1 has a goal @xmath20 , and @xmath2 is _ able _ to achieve @xmath20 and in addition _ intends _ to deliver @xmath20 . for example , as figure [ fig : sd - system - to - be ] shows , mi depends on ms for its goal . this dependency means that ( 1 ) mi has a goal to have the meeting ; ( 2 ) ms is able to schedule the meeting ; and ( 3 ) ms intends to schedule the meeting . in other words , a goal dependency expresses a shared goal , indicating _ joint intentionality _ , among the actors . ( soft goal , task , and resource dependencies are interpreted analogously . ) thus the connection expressed between actors is rooted in their internals . indeed , yu states this : `` the strategic dependency model aims to present a picture of agents by explicitly modeling only their external intentional relationships with each other . the semantics of these external relationships , however , are characterized in terms of some _ presumed internal intentional features _ of the agent '' ( * ? ? ? * , emphasis added ) . in summary , the good points about i * and tropos are that they model stakeholders and stakeholder relations explicitly as actors and dependencies . their shortcomings include the machine - orientation underlying the notion of system actor ; mentalist dependencies ; and violation of encapsulation . that is , i * and tropos can help design a machine in a cooperative setting , where autonomy is not a consideration , but do not adequately address the engineering of a sociotechnical system . dardenne et al.s kaos resembles tropos in its goal - orientation . kaos first elicits stakeholders goals and represents them as and - or graphs . next , it selects a particular variant of the graph as the basis for further engineering . domain analysis reveals the possible sets of agents in the system to be along with their capabilities . kaos s strength lies in the methodological details of deriving operational constraints from goals and assigning them to particular agents as responsibilities depending on their capabilities . for uniformity , we consider examples from van lamsweerde et al.s study of the meeting scheduler . the notion of _ agents _ in kaos is fundamentally different from that of principals in iose . agents in kaos may be social ( human ) or technical , e.g. , devices and software programs . further , an agent is considered a performer of actions , which are themselves defined in terms of input , output , precondition , and postcondition . for example , van lamsweerde et al . specify a agent that has the capability to perform the action , whose preconditions are that the meeting be requested but not scheduled and whose postconditions are ( 1 ) if the meeting is feasible , it is scheduled and ( 2 ) if it is not , the scheduling attempt fails . other agents in van lamsweerde et al.s meeting scheduling system are and , which are analogously specified . in kaos , a system specification captures adequately refined goals ( operational in nature ) and their assignment to agents with the requisite capabilities . for example , the goal of notifying participants is assignable either to the or because they are both capable of notifying participants ; the goal of maintaining an up - to - date agenda that the could consult is the responsibility of every ; and so on . the idea is that if the agents are appropriately specified and the goals are appropriately assigned , then overall system goals would be met . kaos specifications capture neither communications among the agents nor explicit relationships among them . instead kaos conceptualized agents as monitoring and setting the appropriate system - level ( meaning global ) variables and predicates . kaos would model the healthcare system via multiple agents but assign the goals of each agent , thereby creating a conceptually centralized machine . the contrast with iose principles is stark : * _ accountability modularity : _ violated . kaos s notion of composite system is exactly that of figure [ fig : machine - environment ] : the two components are the automated system and the environment @xcite . the users are considered part of the environment . the automated system consists of software agents . thus kaos supports the specification of a distributed machine ( for example , above , we discussed the kaos specification of agents for the meeting scheduler system ) . the automated system represents the realization of the stakeholder requirements ; hence it is meaningless to talk its accountability to anyone . we note here that the notion of responsibility in kaos in not a social one : a responsibility is simply an operational constraint that is assigned ( and therefore , designed ) into an agent . * _ explicit social meaning : _ violated . kaos does not model communication nor employ any communication - related social abstractions . further , unlike tropos , it does not have abstractions to capture any interagent relations . all interaction between agents is captured only indirectly through the setting of the appropriate variables and predicates in the environment . * _ solely social meaning : _ violated . since kaos does not support social meaning . * _ separating social from technical : _ violated . kaos models a sociotechnical system in a purely technical way . neither stakeholders nor principals are accommodated in the system model . in fact , kaos does not even model the goals as being of particular stakeholders : there is just one goal tree , which is progressively refined until the leafs can be assigned to agents . the names of the agents in the meeting scheduling system ( , and so on ) may suggest that kaos accommodates principals . however , that would be misleading : agent specifications together with goal assignments are essentially abstract programs . the entire automated system is a collection of programs interacting via variables . * _ no principal internals : _ violated . the system is ultimately a collection of agents whose assigned responsibilities determine their implementations . since the system s correct functioning depends on the goals assigned to its member agents , kaos breaks encapsulation . like tropos , kaos applies in designing a technical system in a cooperative setting , but its machine - orientation precludes engineering an open sociotechnical system . zambonelli et al.s gaia is one of the earliest aose methodologies . later aose methodologies bear many conceptual similarities with gaia . hence , it deserves an in - depth discussion . gaia takes an organization - based approach in which agents may adopt roles . zambonelli et al . consider a conference management system in which agents may adopt the appropriate roles ( such as reviewer , pc member , author , and so on ) . a role defines the permissions and responsibilities of a prospective agent . permissions describe what an agent could do with resources in the environment . responsibilities are algebraic expressions over the protocols and internal activities that an agent must perform . for reviewer , the permissions are and and the responsibilities are first ( a protocol ) , second ( an internal activity ) , and third ( a protocol ) . below we discuss gaia with respect to the iose principles . * _ accountability modularity : _ violated . in gaia , technical components such as mail clients and active databases are agents . it is meaningless to talk about their accountability . even if the agents represented only stakeholders , gaia says nothing about to whom they are accountable . for example , if a reviewer may not send a review form , would it be responsible to the overseeing pc member ? gaia says nothing about that . + zambonelli et al . conceptualize the multiagent system as an organization that `` can exploit , control or consume when it is working towards the achievement of the organizational goal '' ( p. 328 ) . further , gaia specifies _ organizational rules _ `` that the organization should respect and enforce in its global behavior '' ( p. 335 ) . both these points seem to hint toward a conceptually central entity in the system . although gaia never explicitly mentions it , perhaps all agents that adopt roles are accountable only to this central entity . however , this resembles a conceptually centralized perspective and makes the system conception in gaia similar to the one in figure [ fig : machine ] . * _ explicit social meaning : _ partially fulfilled . whereas gaia supports specifying interaction among roles , it does not specify the meaning of the communications itself . gaia has the notions of permissions and responsibilities at the role level . the intent behind these notions seems to have been to capture social aspects of organizations ; however , gaia falters in important details . as stated above , permissions and responsibilities in gaia are not interagent relationships . for example , the reviewer has the permissions and . but this seems to assume a computational intermediary ( left unspecified in gaia ) with resources ( the papers ) where these activities must be performed . ( in iose , would be modeled as a communication from the reviewer to the program chair or the overseeing pc member and its body would contain the updated review . ) responsibilities specify what an agent adopting the role ought to do but again this seems to assume an unspecified entity to whom the agent would be responsible . * _ solely social meaning : _ violated . as we noted above , gaia does not have any true social abstractions . * _ separating social from technical : _ partially fulfilled . gaia aspires to social - level modeling by modeling systems as organizations and having agents adopt roles in organizations . gaia , to its credit , distinguishes between open systems and closed systems . it explicitly mentions that agents could represent different stakeholders . however , unlike a principal in iose , an agent in gaia is anything that has its own thread of control . specifically , even in open systems , `` active '' components such as active databases , are modeled as agents . * _ no principal internals : _ violated . gaia makes internal agent behavior ( e.g. , ) explicit by placing activities in role specifications , thereby exposing an agent s internal decision - making . ( would not appear in an iose protocol because it does not involve communication it is an internal activity . ) in summary , gaia aspires to modeling open systems via roles and protocols , but falters in important details . although it is not explicitly machine - oriented , it betrays a conceptually centralized mindset . as such , it is not adequate for the modeling of open sociotechnical systems . a choreography specifies the schemas of the messages exchanged as well as constraints on their ordering and occurrence . a choreography is conceptually decentralized and involves roles that principals may potentially adopt . interestingly , choreographies fit in the paradigm of figure [ fig : old ] . principals adopting roles in a choreography would potentially maintain their own ledgers and interact via a digital messaging system that carries their messages to each other . however , there is no computational support for the social state : choreographies do not specify the social meanings of messages and as a result do not capture the social expectations interacting principals may have of each other . choreography description languages , e.g. , ws - cdl @xcite , support specifying the internal activities of principals in the choreography itself . for instance , the ws - cdl notion of _ workunits _ may be used to specify conditional actions by a principal . likewise , mendling and hafner use workunits to specify the internal compliance checks that a tax adviser would make in handling a client s annual statement ( p. 532 ) , thereby violating encapsulation . * _ accountability modularity : _ partially fulfilled . choreographies support compliance at the technical level : principals must send messages in the prescribed order , otherwise they are not compliant with the choreography . however , lacking representation of social meaning and social state , a violation of a choreography does not necessarily amount to a violation at the social level . * _ explicit social meaning : _ violated . lack a representation of social meaning . * _ solely social meaning : _ violated . follows from the lack of a representation of social meaning . * _ separating social from technical : _ fulfilled . choreographies specify interactions with reference to roles that principals may adopt . * _ no principal internals : _ partially fulfilled . in principle , choreographies seek to specify interactions ; however , in practice , they also specify the internal activities of principals . choreographies seek to model interactions ; however , they do so in terms of low - level control and data flow abstractions and often specify aspects of principals internal behavior . therefore , they also do not fare well with respect to the iose principles . table [ table : principles - evaluation ] contrasts traditional approaches with commitment protocols , explained in section [ sec : principles - iose ] as an exemplar of iose . i * , tropos , and kaos are all machine - oriented since their primary specification artifact is that of a machine ( the system actor in i * and tropos and a collection of agents in kaos ) that would meet stakeholder requirements . nonetheless , i * and tropos perform better than kaos in our evaluation because unlike kaos , they model stakeholders and their relations explicitly . in the foregoing , we have extensively discussed the literature most pertinent to our claims . here , we discuss other relevant literature . commitments . commitments are recognized in the literature as a key social abstraction . singh introduced social commitments as a way of formalizing agent communication that was suited to open systems . fornara and colombetti gave an operational semantics for commitments . yolum and singh specified commitment protocols in the event calculus . newer work has tended more toward se themes : methodologies for composing commitment protocols @xcite , patterns @xcite , the relationship of commitments with the notion of goals in tropos @xcite , and monitoring requirements via commitments @xcite . young and antn apply commitments to identify software requirements from regulatory policies and paja et al . to extract security requirements for organizations . baldoni et al . present commitment protocols that support temporal properties . the value we add to this body of work is making explicit connections between the ontology and principles implicit in commitment - based approaches with those implicit in traditional se . iose , as a new paradigm for the sociotechnical systems , provides a natural home for commitments . agent - oriented software engineering despite the apparent similarity between the notion of agents and principals and talk of interaction in many aose methodologies , they ( as exemplified by gaia and tropos ) violate key iose principles . some aose approaches are logically centralized , e.g. , geared toward efficient problem - solving . gaia and other aose methodologies acknowledge the distinction between open and closed systems and emphasize interactions . they correctly classify problem solving systems that distribute a problem across agents as closed . however , aose methodologies betray , if not centralized mindsets , at least considerable conceptual difficulties . vsquez - salceda et al . model the objectives of social systems as goals and the systems as controllers ( p. 338 ) : `` facilitation roles are usually provided by agents controlled by the society , and follow a trivial contract . '' but in a sociotechnical system , there is no unitary multiagent system or society that controls resources . and an organization has no goals that overarch the goals of other participants that is , an organization would be one of many participants in a sociotechnical system . van riemsdijk et al . too are motivated by the modeling of open systems but conceptualize a multiagent system as having collective goals . wagner s agent - object - relationship ( aor ) ontology proposes two kinds of models to support the design of a multiagent system : _ external _ ( observer s perspective , including interaction models ) and _ internal _ ( agent s perspective ) . newer work by guizzardi et al . is based on the aor ontology . wagner s internal - external distinction aligns well with iose . unfortunately , aor subverts the internal - external distinction by including in external models aspects of the internal organization of agents , such as their beliefs ( in _ agent diagrams _ ) as well as reactive rules that specify how an agent would respond to events . singh introduced social commitment as a concept distinct from the mentalist concept of _ internal commitment _ @xcite . aor , tropos , and i * employ internal commitments . serrano and leite map i * concepts to agent programming concepts such as beliefs , desires , and intentions . they map dependencies between two agents to the joint desires of those agents . using their methodology , one specifies the internals of one or more agents . thus even though serrano and leite do nt involve an explicit system actor , the approach is conceptually centralized . how can we reconcile the facts that many aose methodologies are conceptually centralized yet model interactions ? aose methodologies yield physically distributed systems of agents that pursue centrally assigned goals . interactions in aose are focused on the technical means to achieve such goals whereas interactions in iose have social standing . information systems modeling mccarthy proposed rea as a generalized model for accounting that is based on _ resources _ , _ events _ , and _ agents _ and relations among them . rea is finding applications in services and information systems modeling , e.g. , @xcite . rea seeks to capture the fundamental economic model underlying accounting . our endeavor is analogous : to develop a general model of sociotechnical systems , based on social abstractions . the key distinction between iose and rea is that rea models ultimately represent an organization s internal perspective , not its interactions with others . this is evident from rea s inside - outside distinction . one of rea s _ accountability _ relations identifies the responsible agent for an event _ inside _ an organization ; another is between an outside agent and an event . iose commitments are more general : each commitment identifies the accountable party and the party to whom it is accountable for what . the second distinction stems from the _ duality _ of events and the corresponding _ reciprocity _ of commitments reflecting the roots of rea in accounting . duality in rea relates two events that together characterize the give - and - take of an economic exchange ( e.g. , and ) . these events _ execute _ ( i.e. , fulfill ) the corresponding reciprocal commitments . iose does not give any special place to either duality or reciprocity . no iose commitment is necessarily reciprocal : if @xmath1 is committed to @xmath2 , there is no requirement that @xmath2 be committed to @xmath1 ( though it is allowed ) . gordijn and akkermans propose the @xmath21-value ontology and associated methodology in order to specify and analyze so - called business models to evaluate their profitability for all stakeholders involved . a business model represents stakeholders as actors ( e.g. , customer ) . other important concepts are _ value objects _ ( e.g , online articles ) , and _ value exchanges _ among actors ( e.g. , with an article provider for articles and their payment ) . commitment protocols could be used to capture the notion of value exchange among actors ; further commitment protocols could be analyzed for feasibility @xcite . however , unlike commitment protocols and in violation of iose principles , @xmath21-value models also depict the internal flow of values in petri net - like notation . human - computer interaction ( hci ) following developments in hci , the term `` social '' is often associated in re with the interplay between social factors and the design of technical artifacts ( as in the _ design of work _ , e.g. , see @xcite ) , especially as concerns user interface and experience ( e.g. , see @xcite ) . the iose treatment of `` social '' is more general and includes not just people but entities such as enterprises and organizations that may be conceptualized as social actors which enables iose to tackle sociotechnical systems as we define them . compliance compliance with service - level agreements , regulations , and business contracts is gaining interest in software engineering . organizations are increasingly concerned with the question of compliance with regulatory frameworks such as hipaa @xcite and sarbanes - oxley . the challenges here are threefold : one , how to model regulations ; two , how to determine the compliance of a principal s behavior with regulations ; and , three , how to design a principal s information systems such that it is ( likely to be ) compliant with the regulations . siena et al . develop a tropos - inspired modeling language to capture and reason about such regulations . iose can potentially support a more flexible notion of compliance geared toward open systems . although high - level concepts such as obligations , permissions , and so on are often employed in software engineering , they are used to capture behavioral constraints abstractly but are not grounded in communication as commitments are . a more detailed discussion is out of the scope of this paper but interested readers are referred to @xcite for an in - depth discussion . our work began from the recognition that open sociotechnical systems are conceptually decentralized and their principals are autonomous social entities . specifying a sociotechnical system amounts to specifying a protocol , i.e. , a specification of the interactions among its potential participants . we showed that existing approaches take a fundamentally centralized view of sociotechnical systems design : they are geared toward the specification of a machine , not a protocol . we presented iose as a new approach for the engineering of sociotechnical systems . iose is driven by key technical demands : autonomy , accountability , and loose coupling . to illustrate iose , we introduced protocols in which the meanings of the messages are specified in terms of commitments as a natural way to address these technical demands . we formulated the iose principles inspired by , but distinct from , the traditional se principles . we undertook a detailed analysis of some leading relevant se approaches to show which iose principles they violate . traditional se falls short not because the abstractions it employs are low level , but because they deemphasize interaction . to support this claim , we consider well - known requirements modeling approaches , which emphasize high - level abstractions such as goals and dependencies @xcite but do not accord first - class status to interactions . even in the simple appointment scheduling setting , the benefits of iose are obvious : what was previously seen as the problem of specifying a meeting scheduler , under iose turns into two independent problems of ( 1 ) specifying the meeting scheduling protocol , and ( 2 ) specifying principals to participate in the protocol . this reflects parnas conception of modularity as the _ division of labor_. our evaluation of the traditional approaches is not a blanket criticism but rather a critical examination that highlights the differences in their assumptions from the principles of iose . further , our evaluation was limited to the system models or specifications that existing approaches advocate . we did not , for instance , dwell upon the modeling of functional versus nonfunctional requirements or the elicitation of requirements from stakeholders , areas in which current sociotechnical systems approaches ( including i * , tropos , and kaos ) have made substantial progress . although we carefully differentiate iose from traditional se , the two complement each other . iose deals with systems ( viewed as protocols ) whereas traditional re deals with components or principals behaviors ( viewed as machines ) . the former is typified by commitments and other social constructs ; the latter by goals and other mental constructs . recent works @xcite have begun to relate these views from the standpoint of building agents who can function effectively in sociotechnical systems characterized by commitments . we have recently @xcite , sought to apply tropos - like models towards the specification of sociotechnical systems . these works replace intentional dependencies with commitments and do not consider a system actor . further , each actor is understood as a role , i.e. , inert and lacking any goals . goals are applied in the modeling the principals who may potentially adopt roles in the sociotechnical system . we defer the task of systematically laying out the methodological elements of iose , as they overlay the main concepts and principles we introduced above . we expect to go beyond methodologies for specifying and composing protocols , e.g. , @xcite , by incorporating the key re considerations of stakeholders and requirements . the nature of requirements for protocols appears quite different from requirements for machines . for example , a requirement such as `` a meeting is scheduled within three hours of the request '' makes sense for a machine but not a protocol though it could be negotiated between the principals playing the mi and mp roles . a requirement that `` a principal can observe whether another principal is complying with some commitment '' makes sense for a protocol but less so for a machine . the bases from which to engineer protocols is a timely and pertinent direction of research . we imagine that existing re methodologies would provide a useful starting point for investigations into a methodology for iose . amit chopra was supported by a marie curie trentino cofund grant and the erc advanced grant 267856 . we thank fabiano dalpiaz , paolo giorgini , michael huhns , michael jackson , john mylopoulos , and erik simmons for helpful discussions . , dalpiaz , f. , giorgini , p. , and mylopoulos , j. 2010a . modeling and reasoning about service - oriented applications via goals and commitments . in _ proceedings of the 22nd international conference on advanced information systems engineering ( caise)_. lncs series , vol . springer , 113128 . , dalpiaz , f. , giorgini , p. , and mylopoulos , j. 2010b . reasoning about agents and protocols via goals and commitments . in _ proceedings of the ninth international conference on autonomous agents and multiagent systems ( aamas)_. 457464 . , narendra , n. c. , and singh , m. p. 2008 . checking correctness of business contracts via commitments . in _ proceedings of the 7th international conference on autonomous agents and multiagent systems ( aamas)_. ifaamas , estoril , portugal , 787794 . \2002 . operational specification of a commitment - based agent communication language . in _ proceedings of the 1st international joint conference on autonomous agents and multiagent systems ( aamas)_. acm press , 535542 . requirements engineering as the reconciliation of technical and social issues . in _ requirements engineering : social and technical issues _ , m. jirotka and j. goguen , eds . academic press , 165200 . , baldoni , m. , baroglio , c. , chopra , a. k. , patti , v. , , and singh , m. p. 2011 . commitment with regulations : reasoning about safety and control in regula . in _ proceedings of the 10th international conference on autonomous agents and multiagent systems ( aamas)_. 467474 . , dalpiaz , f. , poggianella , m. , roberti , p. , and giorgini , p. 2012 . : using commitments to specify socio - technical security requirements . in _ proceedings of the er 2012 workshops_. lncs series , vol . springer , 396399 . development of agent - driven systems : from i * architectural models to intentional agents code . in _ proceedings of the 5th international i * workshop_. ceur workshop proceedings series , vol . 766 . ceur-ws.org , 5560 . , armellin , g. , mameli , g. , mylopoulos , j. , perini , a. , and susi , a. 2010 . establishing regulatory compliance for information system requirements : an experience report from the health care domain . in _ proceedings of the 29th international conference on conceptual modeling_. lncs series , vol . springer , 90103 . commitments in multiagent systems : some history , some confusions , some controversies , some prospects . in _ the goals of cognition : essays in honor of cristiano castelfranchi _ , f. paglieri , l. tummolini , r. falcone , and m. miceli , eds . college publications , london , chapter 31 , 591616 . in press ; available at http://www.csc.ncsu.edu/faculty/mpsingh/papers . , lock , r. , storer , t. , and dobson , j. 2009 . deriving information requirements from responsibility models . in _ proceedings of the 21st international conference on advanced information systems engineering_. amsterdam , 515529 . \2009 . enhancing tropos with commitments : a business metamodel and methodology . in _ conceptual modeling : foundations and applications _ , a. borgida , v. chaudhri , p. giorgini , and e. yu , eds . number 5600 in lncs . springer , 417435 . , yorke - smith , n. , and singh , m. p. 2012 . relating goal and commitment semantics . in _ proceedings of the 9th international workshop on programming multiagent systems ( promas 2011)_. lncs series , vol springer , taipei , 2237 . , darimont , r. , and massonet , p. 1995 . elaboration of requirements for a meeting scheduler : problems and lessons learnt . in _ proceedings of the second ieee international symposium on requirements engineering_. 194203 . , hindriks , k. , and jonker , c. 2009 . programming organization - aware agents : a research agenda . in _ engineering societies in the agents world x _ , h. aldewereld , v. dignum , and g. picard , eds . lncs series , vol . springer , 98112 . , johannesson , p. , andersson , b. , arachchige , j. j. , and bergholtz , m. 2011 . management services a framework for design . in _ proceedings of the 23rd international conference on advanced information systems engineering ( caise)_. lncs series , vol . 6741 . springer , 582596 . flexible protocol specification and execution : applying event calculus planning using commitments . in _ proceedings of the 1st international joint conference on autonomous agents and multiagent systems_. acm press , 527534 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: a computer is a machine which processes data according to a set of instructions . every computer is a composition of hardware on which information is processed and software by which information is processed . hardware is the physical part of a computer , while software is a collection of computer programs ( algorithms ) designed to perform a required task . a quantum computer ( qc ) emerges when the computation is executed under the framework of quantum mechanics . there are several models for quantum computation . the first conceptual model of a qc , the quantum turing machine ( qtm ) , was given by deutsch @xcite . it is rather an abstract model and useful for investigating the computational complexity . " the qtm is a quantum version of its classical analogue which allows the superposition of different computational paths . later on , a rather practical model of a qc the unitary - evolution - based quantum computation model ( uqcm)was established @xcite . the uqcm is a quantum edition of the reversible classical circuit model . " in the step from classical to quantum , the bits are replaced by the qubits , and the logic gates are replaced by the quantum gates ( coherent unitary evolution ) . unlike the bits , the qubits can exist in a superposition of different computational states . unlike the logic gates , the quantum gates are able to create and destroy a superposition as well as an entanglement . the computation in uqcm is run by a sequence of unitary gates and represented by its circuit diagram , where the connecting wires stand for the logical qubits or bits which carry the information , and the information is processed by the sequence of quantum gates . in the end , the result of the computation is read out by the projective measurements on the qubits . in the well - known textbook by nielsen and chuang @xcite , many popular algorithms such as deutsch s algorithm @xcite , grover s search algorithm @xcite , and shor s factoring algorithm @xcite are narrated in terms of the uqcm . the measurement - based quantum computation model ( mqcm ) is another well recognized model of a qc @xcite . here , a multi - qubit entangled state known as a cluster state @xcite , or more generally a graph state @xcite is the main ingredient , and it provides all the entanglement beforehand for the subsequent computation . the computation in this model is run by a sequence of single - qubit ( adaptive ) projective measurements on the graph state . the methods of mqcm enable one to simulate any quantum circuit on a sufficiently large two - dimensional graph state by arranging the spatial pattern of measurement bases for the graph qubits according to the temporal order of quantum gates in the circuit . in the mqcm , the measurements on graph qubits are performed in a certain temporal order for the purpose of running the computation deterministically . furthermore , the measurement outcomes are recorded classically and are used for setting the measurement bases for the subsequent measurements @xcite . by contrast , in the uqcm there is no such temporal order of measurements , but an order in which the unitary gates are executed . the task of a qc is to `` simulate a quantum circuit . '' both the uqcm and the mqcm are universal : they can simulate any quantum circuit . where the uqcm uses the unitary gates , the mqcm uses the measurements for simulating a circuit . in this paper our focus will be on constructing a hybrid " model of the uqcm and the mqcm , which we call hybrid quantum computation model " ( hqcm ) , that combines elements of both the uqcm and the mqcm with the aim of exploiting the strengths of both models . of course , the hqcm is universal as well . there are two main objectives of the present investigation . the first objective is to develop a theoretical understanding of the hqcm , where part of a quantum circuit is simulated by unitary gates and the rest by measurements on small graph states . the second objective is the investigation of the experimental optimization . both the uqcm and the mqcm possess their own advantages along with some similarities . for example , where the implementation of an arbitrary single - qubit operation in the mqcm costs a chain of five qubits graph state @xcite , it can be implemented rather simply by a unitary evolution in the uqcm . in return , certain multi - qubit gates that are complicated in the uqcm can be realized in one shot " in the mqcm . here is an overview of the paper . in sec . [ sec : mqcm ] we give a brief review of the mqcm , it has two main parts . the first part contains the methodology for the computation in mqcm with an example and the second part is the classical information processing in the mqcm . we use a portion of sec . [ sec : mqcm ] in sec . [ sec : hqcm ] . section [ sec : hqcm ] is reserved for a detailed discussion on the hqcm , it has three main parts . the first part is the methodology for the computation in hqcm and the second part is the classical information processing in the hqcm . the third part is about the implementation of multi - qubit controlled rotations with the hqcm , and this we are going to use in sec . [ sec : ga ] , which is about grover s search algorithm within the hqcm . finally , we conclude our report in sec . [ sec : conc ] with a summary and outlook . three appendices deal with technical details . we start this section with a short introduction about the preparation of graph states @xcite , and then we proceed towards the methods for the computation in mqcm @xcite . we conclude this section with an example . throughout the text we represent the pauli vector operator @xmath2 by @xmath3 and the identity operator by @xmath4 . graph states can be realized in many physical systems by first preparing all the qubits of graph @xmath5 in an eigenstate of their respective pauli operator @xmath6 . in other words , every qubit ` @xmath7 ' of @xmath5 is initialized in the state @xmath8 , where @xmath9 . then , entanglement between each pair of nearest - neighbor qubits is established by the controlled-@xmath0 gate @xmath10 here , the indices @xmath7 and @xmath11 stand for the qubits at the lattice site ` @xmath7 ' and its nearest - neighbor lattice site ` @xmath11 ' of the graph @xmath5 , respectively . a unitary gate of this kind can be generated by turning on the ( controlled ) ising - type nearest - neighbor interaction for an appropriately chosen time period . experimentally , graph states have been generated by using controlled collisions between cold atoms in optical lattices @xcite and by using linear optics @xcite . mathematically , quantum correlations among the qubits of a graph are specified by correlation operators @xmath12 s , which are given below . the resultant graph state @xmath13 is an eigenstate of these operators , and it is completely specified by the set of eigenvalue equations @xmath14 with the set of eigenvalues @xmath15 . here , @xmath16 stands for the set of all nearest - neighbor qubits which are entangled ( connected ) to the qubit ` @xmath7 ' by the @xmath17 operations . for every qubit ` @xmath7 ' of the graph state @xmath13 , there exists a correlation operator @xmath12 and an eigenvalue @xmath9 . the physical meaning of eq . ( [ eigenvalue ] ) is this : there exists either a correlation ( @xmath18 ) or an anti - correlation ( @xmath19 ) between the outcome of the measurement on qubit ` @xmath7 ' in the @xmath6 eigenbasis and the outcomes of the measurements on all the qubits of @xmath16 in the @xmath0 eigenbasis . these quantum correlations provide the framework for the computation in mqcm . once the resource graph state is ready , then the logical qubits holding the input information are attached to the resource via the same entangling operations given by eq . ( [ cz ] ) . unlike the quantum error - correction , here , one logical qubit stands for one physical qubit . now , the computation is carried out by a sequence of single - qubit ( adaptive ) projective measurements in a certain direction of the bloch sphere and in a certain temporal order . the bloch sphere offers an adequate geometrical description for the direction of single - qubit projective measurement , where the direction of measurement is completely specified by the bloch vector @xmath20 and the corresponding projector is given by @xmath21 the measurement outcomes @xmath22 and @xmath23 mean that the measured qubit is projected onto the states with the kets @xmath24 and @xmath25 respectively . in other words , the choice of measurement basis is characterized by the direction of measurement @xmath26 in the bloch sphere . there are three kinds of measurements in the mqcm @xcite . measurements along the @xmath1-axis effectively detach the measured ( redundant ) qubits from the graph state . measurements along the bloch vector @xmath27it lies in @xmath28,@xmath29 plane of the bloch sphere process the information as well as teleport it from one place to another on the graph . the significance of this kind of measurements is revealed by the example given in appendix [ sec : sqr ] . measurements along the bloch vector @xmath30it lies in @xmath1,@xmath29 plane of the bloch sphere only process the information . this remark will be illustrated by the example given below . the two measurement outcomes @xmath31 for every qubit of the graph state are equally probable because the reduced density matrix for each qubit is the completely mixed state @xmath32 . in the process of getting the desired operations on the logical qubits , one also gets some additional operations . these additional operations are called `` byproduct operators , '' and they belong to the pauli group . these byproduct operators depend on the random measurement outcomes and the eigenvalues of the graph state @xmath13 . the measurement outcome @xmath33 for every graph qubit and the eigenvalues @xmath34 are binary numbers , so one can record them classically in order to take care of the byproduct operators . the classical information processing of this data makes the computation deterministic and helps to set the measurement bases for the subsequent measurements . section [ sec : ci - mqcm ] contains a comprehensive discussion about this matter . right now we are content with illustrating the procedure of mqcm with an example . @xmath35 the unitary operation for the @xmath36-qubit rotation around the @xmath1-axis is @xmath37 where the superscripts @xmath38 symbolize the logical qubits on which this operation will be carried out @xcite . one can accomplish this operation by performing a single measurement on a @xmath39-qubits star graph state , the associated star graph is shown in fig . [ fig:1](i ) . in fig . [ fig:1](i ) , the input quantum register of @xmath36 qubits is displayed by the circles and the ancilla qubit ` @xmath7 ' by the diamond . the input register is in a @xmath36-qubit input state @xmath40 , and the ancilla qubit is prepared in the state @xmath8 . then we perform @xmath36 @xmath17 operations , represented by the bonds in the figure and given by eq . ( [ cz ] ) , between the qubit ` @xmath7 ' and every logical qubit . in principle , all the @xmath17 operations can be performed in one shot , " because they all commute with each other . this series of steps leads us to the resultant star graph state @xmath41 . \label{g2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the subscript @xmath42 reveals that the final graph state is of one ancilla qubit and @xmath36 logical qubits . a measurement on the ancilla qubit ` @xmath7 ' in the basis @xmath43 transforms the input state of the quantum register into the output state @xmath44 here , the direction of measurement lies in @xmath1,@xmath29 plane of the bloch sphere , and @xmath45 is the measurement outcome . @xmath46 is the byproduct operator , which is represented by the dotted - boxes on all the logical qubits in fig . [ fig:1](ii ) . after the measurement , all bonds ( illustrated in fig . [ fig:1](i ) ) are broken and the qubit ` @xmath7 ' gets projected either onto the state @xmath47 ( if @xmath48 ) or onto the state @xmath49 ( if @xmath50 ) . we shall use this kind of multi - qubit rotations for the hqcm in sec . [ sec : hqcm ] . in contrast to the example @xmath51 given in appendix [ sec : sqr ] where the qubits used for input and output are different , in the case of @xmath52 the input and output states reside in the same @xmath36 logical qubits . in other words , here the information gets processed , but does not get transferred from one place to another . as a side remark , the resultant byproduct operator @xmath53 in the case of @xmath51 ( see eq . ( [ out1 ] ) ) and the measurement basis @xmath43 in the case of @xmath52 depend on the eigenvalue @xmath54 . every quantum gate from the generating set of the clifford group the @xmath55 gate @xmath56 ( the labels @xmath7 and @xmath11 are for the control and target qubits , respectively ) , the hadamard gate @xmath57 the @xmath58-phase gate @xmath59can be executed in a single time step in the mqcm @xcite . this holds because every measurement in these cases is performed either in the @xmath6 eigenbasis or in the @xmath60 eigenbasis and is not influenced by the result of any other measurement . hence all the measurements can be performed simultaneously . a @xmath55 gate can be achieved with a 15-qubit graph state , and both the hadamard gate and the @xmath58-phase gate can be implemented with a chain of five qubits graph state @xcite . single - qubit and @xmath55 gates together constitute a universal set of gates , and they are realizable in the mqcm . in this sense , the mqcm is also universal like the uqcm . in order to simulate a complex unitary gate in the mqcm , it is customary to first decompose it efficiently into a sequence of elementary gates from the universal gate set . then , the temporal order of gates is transformed into the spatial pattern of measurement bases for the graph qubits . afterwards , the measurements are performed in the required order . up to now , we were dealing with the individual gate simulations only , where we need not to worry about the byproduct operators . but in the next section , our focus shall be on the simulation of a sequence of gates , where the study of classical information processing and the temporal order of measurements become necessary . classical information processing is needed for taking care of the byproduct operators . a comprehensive discussion about it is provided in the following section . this section serves as a summary of the results which were discussed in ref . @xcite . when a sequence of gates is simulated in the mqcm , the byproduct operator which originates from the implementation of gates `` passes through '' the sequence . the propagation of the byproduct operator either transforms the next gates in the sequence or the byproduct operator in itself gets transformed . the first part of this section is about propagation relations for some elementary gates , and in the second part we shall define an information flow vector . the third part which concludes this section is reserved for the propagation matrices for some elementary gate based on their propagation relations . we shall use a portion of this section for the hqcm in sec . [ sec : hqcm ] . the structure of the byproduct operator on the logical qubit @xmath61 is @xmath62 , where @xmath63 and @xmath64 are non - negative integers . both @xmath63 and @xmath64 depend on the outcomes of measured qubits and the eigenvalues @xmath34 @xcite . their dependence on @xmath34 is in our control . for example , the @xmath34 dependent parts disappear from the calculation by preparing a graph state with @xmath65 for all the graph qubits . but we can not control the dependence of the byproduct operators on the measurement outcomes which are intrinsically random . in ref . @xcite , the authors took @xmath66 , but we find it simpler to take both @xmath63 and @xmath64 as non - negative integers . this is permissible because in @xmath67 and @xmath68 only the modulo-2 values of @xmath63 and @xmath64 matter . throughout the paper , we reserve the sign ` + ' for the ordinary addition and the sign ` @xmath69 ' for the modulo-2 addition . in principle , we can correct the byproduct operators step by step after completing each gate of the sequence under simulation . but it is more convenient to choose not to correct them and let them pass through the gates , and just keep track of the measurement outcomes in a systematic way using simple classical information processing . at the end of the computation , either we set the measurement bases for the final readout depending on the history of outcomes or we just perform the final measurements in the computational basis and interpret the result with the help of the record of measurement outcomes . the propagation of the byproduct operator through a gate is given by the propagation relation . the euler decomposition of an arbitrary single - qubit rotation @xmath70 is @xmath71 and the propagation relation for @xmath72 is @xmath73 an arbitrary single - qubit rotation @xmath72 gets transformed to @xmath74 , but the byproduct operator stays as it is . we can take eq . ( [ pror ] ) as an illustration of the importance of `` the temporal order of the measurements . '' this is because , when @xmath72 is a part of a circuit , the superscripts @xmath28 and @xmath1 are functions of the earlier measurement outcomes . in order to determine the right sign for the measurement angles @xmath75 , @xmath76 , and @xmath77 , we have to wait until the necessary measurements are completed @xcite . equation ( [ pror ] ) also justifies the following points . the measurement directions for these qubits lie in @xmath28,@xmath29 plane of the bloch sphere , @xmath78 with @xmath79 , their measurement bases depend on the results of previous measurements ( see appendix [ sec : sqr ] and ref . when @xmath80 , then the directions for @xmath81 and @xmath82 coincide and do not get influenced by the outcomes of other measurements . measurements of this kind are either in the @xmath6 ( @xmath83 ) or the @xmath60 ( @xmath84 ) eigenbasis . the gates from the generating set of the clifford group ( given by eqs . ( [ cnot])([rz ] ) ) are realized by such measurements . the propagation relation for the gate @xmath85 is @xmath86 where @xmath87 and @xmath88 in case of the @xmath85 gate , eq . ( [ procnot ] ) , the gate stays as it is , but the byproduct operator @xmath89 gets transformed to @xmath90 . this is also the case for the other two gates from the generating set of the clifford group . the propagation relation for the hadamard gate @xmath91 is @xmath92 and for the @xmath58-phase gate @xmath93 it is ( up to a phase factor @xmath94 ) @xmath95 the propagation relations ( [ procnot ] ) , ( [ proh ] ) , and ( [ prophase ] ) can also be understood from the definition of the clifford group which maps the pauli group into itself under conjugation . now , let us define an information flow vector . at every stage of the computation , the accumulated byproduct operator @xmath96 upon the logical qubits @xmath97 is of the form @xmath98 . after the implementation of a gate , only the values @xmath99 and @xmath100 get changed , and the new values determine the measurement bases for the subsequent gates . these values are processed by a classical computer . there is a one - to - one correspondence between the byproduct operator @xmath96 ( ignoring the global phase @xmath101 ) and a @xmath102-component `` information flow vector '' @xmath103 which is given as follows : @xmath104 where @xmath105 here , the multiplication of byproduct operators ( up to a phase factor @xmath101 ) corresponds to the component - wise addition of information flow vectors . the information flow vector @xmath106 keeps track of the sign(s ) of the measurement angle(s ) for a gate . in accordance with eq . ( [ pror ] ) , the signs of the measurement angles for the operation @xmath107 on the qubit @xmath108 are determined by the current value of @xmath63 and @xmath64 in @xmath106 . the propagation relations ( [ procnot ] ) , ( [ proh ] ) , and ( [ prophase ] ) suggest that none of the gates from the generating set of the clifford group gets altered under the propagation of the byproduct operator . so , the measurement angles for these gates are independent of the values stored in @xmath106 . we can also define a @xmath109 `` propagation matrix '' @xmath110 for a gate @xmath111 , representing the transformation in the information flow vector when the corresponding byproduct operator passes through the gate @xmath111 . the propagation matrices given below are derived from the propagation relations ( [ pror ] ) , ( [ procnot ] ) , ( [ proh ] ) , and ( [ prophase ] ) with the help of the one - to - one correspondence given by eq . ( [ i ] ) , and the entries in the information flow vectors and the propagation matrices are given only for relevant qubits . for the case of @xmath36 logical qubits , the propagation matrices for the @xmath70- , @xmath55- , @xmath91- , and @xmath93-gate are given in appendix [ sec : pm ] . the byproduct operator passes through an arbitrary single - qubit rotation @xmath72 without getting transformed . so the information flow vector stays as it is , @xmath112 the information flow vector gets transformed when the associated byproduct operator passes through the @xmath85 gate in the following way : @xmath113 under the one - to - one correspondence given by eq . ( [ i ] ) , the propagation relation ( [ proh ] ) for the hadamard gate @xmath91 becomes @xmath114 and the propagation relation ( [ prophase ] ) for the @xmath58-phase gate @xmath93 becomes @xmath115 the information flow vector and the propagation matrices provide a simple description , and they are easily handled by a classical computer . as a side remark , the temporal order of the measurements does not typically follow the temporal order of gates in a circuit which we want to simulate with the mqcm . in the mqcm , there exists an efficient measurement scheme where measurements are performed round by round , and in each round all the measurements are executed at the same time @xcite . the information flow vector is updated after every round . after the final round , the result of the computation is interpreted from the @xmath28-part of the information flow vector @xmath116 . an extended discussion of this efficient measurement scheme is provided in appendix [ sec : ems ] . in this section , we formulate the methodology of the hybrid quantum computation model ( hqcm ) by combining the advantages of the uqcm and the mqcm . before going into the details , let us first focus on what benefits we can get from each of the models in different situations . here , we consider the preparation of a graph state , the set of elementary gates for the hqcm , and the simulation of a quantum circuit with the hqcm one by one . the very first experimental step in the mqcm is the preparation of a resource graph state , whereas in the uqcm no such preparation of a resource is needed . while preparing a graph state , in principle , the initialization of every graph qubit in the @xmath6 eigenbasis can be completed in one shot . to this end , we have to `` talk '' to every graph qubit simultaneously . consequently , this requires a lot of experimental resources , and the very many interactions are difficult to control . likewise , the subsequent two - qubit entangling operations ( @xmath117 s given by eq . ( [ cz ] ) ) to create the resource graph state can be performed in one step , because they commute with each other . and , the larger the graph state , the more difficult it is to prepare and control the state and to protect it against decoherence . so , for the hqcm , we choose not to prepare the whole two - dimensional universal graph state at once , but instead prepare small ( non - universal ) graph states step - by - step as we need them when the computation progresses . only the star graph states , such as @xmath118 given in eq . ( [ g2 ] ) , are required for the hqcm . we choose single - qubit operations , the @xmath17 gate and the multi - qubit rotation around the @xmath1-axis @xmath52 for an arbitrary value of @xmath119 given by eq . ( [ nr ] ) as the elementary gates for hqcm . in analogy to the procedure for the uqcm , first we `` efficiently decompose '' any big unitary gate we are trying to simulate into a sequence of elementary gates in such a way that the number of elementary gates grows polynomially with the number of logical qubits , and then every elementary gate is implemented one after another . every single - qubit operation and the @xmath17 gate are carried out by the unitary evolution under the formalism of uqcm . the rotation @xmath52 is implemented by the method given in sec . [ sec : methodology1qc ] ( see the example ) under the formalism of mqcm . the motivation behind these choices is explained in the following . the implementation of an arbitrary single - qubit rotation in the mqcm costs us at least a chain of five qubits graph state and four measurements @xcite . but it can be realized quite simply by the unitary evolution of the respective single qubit . furthermore , the euler decomposition for an arbitrary single - qubit rotation @xmath72 given in eq . ( [ ro ] ) is not needed . the @xmath17 operations themselves are part of the experimental setup for constructing the graph states , and for this we have to execute them by the unitary evolution . that is why we consider the @xmath17 gate as an elementary gate for the hqcm . furthermore , it is more economical to implement @xmath85 by the unitary evolution @xmath120 instead of first preparing a 15-qubit graph state and then implement it with the mqcm @xcite . although we already have the universal set of gates ( single - qubit and @xmath17 gates ) , we prefer to include @xmath52 as an elementary gate in the hqcm . this is because of two reasons . the first reason is the optimization . the resource @xmath39-qubit graph state @xmath118 ( given by eq . ( [ g2 ] ) ) needed for the implementation of @xmath52 is relatively easy to create experimentally . it has only one ancilla qubit , and the entanglement can be established in one shot . furthermore , a single measurement on the ancilla qubit is enough to realize @xmath52 all together on @xmath36 logical qubits . while it is also possible to decompose the rotation @xmath52 in terms of the gates from the universal gate set and implement it under the formalism of uqcm , its implementation there will not be so optimal , and we can not regard it as a single unit . generally , one is using either unitary evolution ( uqcm ) or measurements on the graph state ( mqcm ) in order to simulate a quantum circuit . so , the second reason for including @xmath52 as an elementary gate in the hqcm is to investigate a model of qc in which a part of a circuit ( @xmath52 rotations ) is simulated by the measurements and the rest by the unitary evolution , and to see how the classical information processing plays its role in such a model . the importance of looking at the classical information - processing parts is explained in the following . now let us consider the simulation of a sequence of gates with the hqcm in which the classical information processing becomes crucial . the classical processing does not come into the picture of uqcm where the measurements are used only for the readout of the final result of computation . in all those schemes where measurements are needed for the computation ( for example quantum teleportation @xcite ) , the classical information processing in parallel is essential . in the hqcm also , classical information processing is needed , because the rotations @xmath52 are executed by the measurements . but here the classical information - processing parts are rather simple and straightforward , requiring only the information flow vector and the propagation matrices . a comprehensive discussion of this is given in the following section . in this section , our focus will be on the classical information - processing parts of the hqcm . we only need the information flow vector and the propagation matrices for the elementary gates . we first redefine the information flow vector in the context of hqcm , and then discuss the propagation relations as well as the propagation matrices for the elementary gates . at every computation step @xmath121 , the form of the byproduct operator is the same , as given in eqs . ( [ i ] ) and ( [ byprombqcm ] ) , @xmath122 so , the form of the related information flow vector @xmath123 is also the same as given by the @xmath124 column vector in eqs . ( [ i ] ) and ( [ iso ] ) . but in the hqcm , there are some differences in comparison to the efficient measurement scheme of mqcm given in appendix [ sec : ems ] . in that scheme of mqcm , the index ` @xmath125 ' of @xmath126 stands for ` the measurement round . ' but in the hqcm , every elementary gate is taken as a single computational step , and the index ` @xmath121 ' of @xmath127 is the label for them . in the mqcm , @xmath126 gets updated after each round , but in the hqcm it is updated after each gate . in this scheme of mqcm , the initial value of the information flow vector @xmath128 is determined by the set of eigenvalues @xmath34 and by some particular gates . but in the hqcm , just before starting the computation all the entries of @xmath129 are zeros , i.e. , both @xmath130 and @xmath131 for all @xmath132 . that means that the byproduct operator at @xmath133 is the identity operator @xmath4 on every logical qubit . in fact , the first relevant byproduct operator appears in the computation when the first multi - qubit rotation is implemented , and then the information flow vector gets some nonzero entries . in the mqcm , the information flow vector gets updated from @xmath134 to @xmath126 after the @xmath125th measurement round . in the hqcm , the information flow vector gets updated from @xmath135 to @xmath127 after the implementation of @xmath121th gate . @xmath127 influences the @xmath136th gate of a quantum circuit under simulation . similar to the case of the uqcm , the total number of computation steps ( the logical depth ) is denoted by @xmath137 , which is the total number of elementary gates used for the computation . furthermore , @xmath137 is also the total number of steps taken by a classical computer for the classical information processing in the hqcm . let us turn to the issue how one can interpret the final result of the computation in the hqcm . in the case of uqcm , every gate of a circuit is executed by their respective unitary evolution , and the final readout measurements are performed in the computational basis . in this case , the output state @xmath138 gets projected onto the state @xmath139 after the final readout measurements , @xmath140 where @xmath141 are the readout measurement outcomes for the logical qubits @xmath142 . in the case of hqcm , the final state of the output register will be @xmath143 after performing the last gate of the same circuit . without loss of generality , like above , we consider the computational basis for the final readout , where @xmath144 are the readout measurement outcomes for the logical qubits @xmath142 . that means that the output state @xmath143 gets projected onto the state @xmath145 after the readout measurements , @xmath146 we can transform eq . ( [ outh ] ) with the help of eq . ( [ byprohqcm ] ) into @xmath147 the inference we get by comparing eq . ( [ outu ] ) and eq . ( [ out2h ] ) is : the readout measurements on the state @xmath138 with the results @xmath148 give the same circuit - output as the readout measurements on the state @xmath143 with the results @xmath149 , and these sets of results are related by @xmath150 that is how one can interpret the final result of the computation with the help of @xmath151 in the hqcm . let us turn to the propagation relations for the elementary gates . an arbitrary single - qubit rotation around an axis @xmath152 ( defined in eq . ( [ r ] ) ) by an angle @xmath75 is @xmath153 the byproduct operator passes through this gate without any change , but it changes the axis of rotation of the gate from @xmath154 to @xmath155 . the propagation relation for @xmath156 is given by @xmath157 where @xmath158 in other words , the angles @xmath119 , @xmath159 that define the axis of rotation @xmath154 get transformed as @xmath160 and @xmath161 . the byproduct operator passes through @xmath156 without getting transformed , that means that the propagation matrix @xmath162 is the same identity matrix as given in eqs . ( [ cr ] ) and ( [ ccr ] ) . every single - qubit unitary operator in su(2 ) follows this propagation relation , and it becomes the propagation relation ( [ proh ] ) for the hadamard gate when @xmath163 and the propagation relation ( [ prophase ] ) for the @xmath58-phase gate when @xmath164 . so , the hadamard- and the @xmath58-phase - gate remain special cases in the sense that the byproduct operator changes under the propagation but not these gates . they are executed by the unitary evolution like any other single - qubit gate , but for the classical information - processing parts of the hqcm we shall use their propagation matrices given by eqs . ( [ cch ] ) and ( [ ccphase ] ) . the propagation relation for the next elementary gate @xmath117 ( defined in eq . ( [ cz ] ) ) is @xmath165 where @xmath166 and @xmath167 under the one - to - one correspondence given in eq . ( [ i ] ) the propagation relation ( [ hqcprocz ] ) becomes @xmath168 when the control qubit ` @xmath7 ' and the target qubit ` @xmath11 ' belong to the set of @xmath36 logical qubits @xmath169 , then the propagation matrix @xmath170 can be generated by the following relations : @xmath171_{kl}&= \left[\textbf{c}_{zz}(\textsc{cz}(a , b))\right]_{kl}=\delta_{kl},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{xz}(\textsc{cz}(a , b))\right]_{kl}&=\delta_{ka}\delta_{lb}+\delta_{kb}\delta_{la},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{zx}(\textsc{cz}(a , b))\right]_{kl}&= 0.\label{cccz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that eqs . ( [ ccz ] ) and ( [ cccz ] ) are different from eqs . ( [ ccnot ] ) and ( [ cccnot ] ) . the @xmath17 and @xmath55 gates are interconvertible by using the hadamard gate , i.e. , @xmath172 and the same is true for their propagation matrices , i.e. , @xmath173 the propagation relation for @xmath52 is @xmath174 where @xmath96 is the same as given in eq . ( [ i ] ) and @xmath175 in this case , the measurement angle @xmath119 gets modified under the propagation , but the byproduct operator stays as it is . so , the propagation matrix @xmath176 will be the identity matrix , which can be defined in the same way as the @xmath162 in eq . ( [ ccr ] ) . the inferences we get here are the following : ( 1 ) the hadamard- , the @xmath58-phase- and the @xmath17-gate remain unchanged under the propagation , while the byproduct operator gets altered . ( 2 ) the single- and multi - qubit rotations ( with nontrivial angles ) get transformed , while the byproduct operator stays unaltered under the propagation . now we have all the basic tools for the hqcm . we shall first describe some important examples , and then proceed to the implementation of grover s search algorithm within the hqcm . in this section we are considering @xmath36-qubit controlled rotations around the @xmath1-axis , which are defined by @xmath177 where the qubits labeled 1 to @xmath178 are the control qubits and the qubits labeled @xmath179 to @xmath36 are the target qubits . only if every control qubit is in the state @xmath180 , then the @xmath181-qubit rotation @xmath182 operates on the target qubits . we discuss the hqcm implementation for three different values of @xmath178 : @xmath178 = 1 ( single - control ) , @xmath178 = 2 ( double - control ) and @xmath183 ( triple - control ) . first , we decompose @xmath184 in terms of multi - qubit rotations like @xmath52 given by eq . ( [ nr ] ) . in order to have the logical qubit 1 as the control and the rest as the target qubits , we express the @xmath36-qubit rotation about the @xmath1-axis as @xmath185 consequently , we get the required decomposition : @xmath186 we observe that @xmath52 is symmetric under permutation of the qubits , so we can take any qubit as the control and the remaining qubits as targets . we consider a ` multi - qubit rotation about the @xmath1-axis ' as a single unit , and then @xmath184 costs only two units of this kind . the circuit representation of eq . ( [ c1u ] ) is given in fig . [ fig:2 ] . in fig . [ fig:2](i ) , the first and the second rectangular boxes depict @xmath52 ( the first rotation ) and @xmath187 ( the second rotation ) , respectively . in practice , both of them are realized by using a single ancilla qubit and a single measurement with the methodology given in sec . [ sec : methodology1qc ] ( see the example ) . moreover , after executing the first rotation we bring back the ancilla qubit into an eigenstate of @xmath6 and use it for the second rotation . the implementation of @xmath52 and @xmath187 require @xmath39-qubit and @xmath36-qubit star graph states , respectively ( see fig . [ fig:1](i ) ) , where the ancilla qubit is connected to the relevant logical qubits . the eigenvalues of the ancilla qubit corresponding to the first and the second rotation are @xmath188 and @xmath189 , and the measurement outcomes are @xmath190 and @xmath191 , respectively . the classical information processing for this case has three main parts . the first part deals with the change in the measurement angles due to the byproduct operator @xmath192 . @xmath192 appears just before implementing the first rotation and is denoted by the dashed vertical line at the input section in fig . [ fig:2 ] . when the gate @xmath184 in itself is a part of a circuit under simulation , then due to the implementation of previous gates the byproduct @xmath192 has emerged prior to the execution of @xmath184 . without loss of generality , we take @xmath193 the same as given in eq . ( [ i ] ) . only the @xmath28-part of the corresponding information flow vector @xmath194 influences the measurement bases @xmath195 for both rotations . according to eq . ( [ hqcprou ] ) , the angles @xmath119 for the first and @xmath196 for the second rotation get altered . @xmath197 where @xmath28 is given by eq . ( [ x ] ) . the second part deals with the eigenvalues @xmath188 and @xmath189 , which influence the azimuthal angle @xmath58 of the measurement bases in the following way : @xmath198 the third part manages the contribution of measurement outcomes @xmath190 and @xmath191 to the byproduct operator @xmath199 . the implementation of both the first and the second rotation cause the byproduct operators @xmath200 and @xmath201 on the relevant logical qubits . furthermore , these byproduct operators update @xmath199 to @xmath202 . @xmath202 is denoted by the dashed vertical line at the output section in fig . [ fig:2 ] . only the @xmath1-part of the information flow vector @xmath203 gets changed , while the @xmath28-part remains as it is , i.e. , @xmath204 , @xmath205 we have to combine two additional units @xmath207 ( the third rotation ) and @xmath208 ( the fourth rotation ) with @xmath184 for the purpose of getting the gate @xmath206 . in other words , @xmath206 with two control qubits 1 and 2 , is made up of four rotations , and its decomposition is given by @xmath209 figure [ fig:3](i ) illustrates the temporal ordering of the multi - qubit rotations given in eq . ( [ c2u ] ) by the rectangular boxes . the treatment for @xmath206 is similar to that of sec . [ sec : c1 ] . all the rotations@xmath52 ( first ) , @xmath187 ( second ) , @xmath207 ( third ) , and @xmath208 ( fourth)are performed one after another under the scheme given in sec . [ sec : methodology1qc ] ( see the example ) . after initializing the ancilla qubit in the @xmath6 eigenbasis , we prepare a necessary star graph state for the first rotation , and then the ancilla qubit is measured in the appropriate basis . the measurement outcome is recorded , and the ancilla qubit is brought back again into an eigenstate of @xmath6 ( recycled ) for executing the next rotation . in this way , we can use the same ancilla qubit for all the rotations . @xmath188 , @xmath189 , @xmath210 , and @xmath211 are the eigenvalues of the ancilla qubit , and @xmath190 , @xmath191 , @xmath212 , and @xmath213 are the measurement outcomes corresponding to the first , second , third , and fourth rotation . as a side remark , one can also choose to perform these four rotations at the same time by using four different ancilla qubits , but this would require more hardware resources . we can take @xmath206 as a single time step , because , in principle , all the four rotations can be executed at the same time . the classical information processing for this case also has three main parts . the first part deals with the modification in the measurement angles because of the byproduct operator @xmath214 , which is represented by the dashed vertical line at the input section in figs . [ fig:3](i ) and [ fig:3](iii ) . here also , only @xmath215 influences the measurement angle @xmath216 for every rotation . @xmath217 where @xmath28 is the same given by eq . ( [ x ] ) . the second part manages the influence of the eigenvalues @xmath218 and @xmath211 on the azimuthal angle @xmath58 of the measurement bases @xmath195 in the following way : @xmath219 the third part handles the random measurement outcomes @xmath190 , @xmath191 , @xmath212 , and @xmath213 ; which cause the byproduct operators @xmath220 , @xmath221 , @xmath222 , and @xmath223 , respectively , on the relevant logical qubits . furthermore , they change @xmath199 into @xmath202 by their contribution . @xmath202 is denoted by the dashed vertical line at the output section in figs . [ fig:3](i ) and [ fig:3](iii ) . so , only the @xmath1-part of the corresponding information flow vector @xmath203 gets changed to @xmath224 , while @xmath204 . @xmath225 where @xmath226 we emphasize two points . first , @xmath206 is symmetric under permutation of the qubits . so , we can take any two qubits as controls and the rest of the qubits as targets by using only four multi - qubit rotations . if we continue along the same direction , then the controlled rotation @xmath227 with @xmath178 control qubits requires @xmath228 units of rotation . the number @xmath228 is independent of the number of target qubits @xmath181 , but when @xmath178 becomes order of @xmath36 , then @xmath228 becomes exponential in @xmath36 . in order to fix this exponential growth problem , we need some extra work qubits @xcite . our next example will justify this remark . second , @xmath206 becomes @xmath229 for @xmath230 . the gate @xmath229 is equivalent to the deutsch s universal gate @xmath231 $ ] @xcite up to single - qubit gates , provided the angle ` @xmath232 ' is incommensurate with @xmath233 . we are going to use @xmath234 with two work qubits for implementing our next gate @xmath235 . we put the bits and pieces of the hqcm together as a summary by taking the gate @xmath235 as an example . the complete scheme about its implementation in terms of its circuit diagram is shown in fig . [ fig:4 ] , and the associated classical information - processing parts are given in table [ table : cip ] . first , we efficiently decompose the gate @xmath235 into a sequence of elementary gates ( single - qubit gates , the @xmath17 gate , and @xmath52 ) . the temporal order of the elementary gates for @xmath235 is depicted by the circuit diagram in fig . [ fig:4 ] , where the qubits 1 , 2 , and 3 act as the control qubits and the qubit 6 as the target qubit , and they all are represented by the black horizontal lines . the work qubits 4 and 5 are initialized in the state @xmath236 , and they are represented by the gray horizontal lines in the figure . the work qubits are used to make the decomposition of @xmath235 economical . the 3-qubit gates @xmath237 ( 1st gate ) , @xmath238 ( 3rd gate ) , @xmath239 ( 7th gate ) , and @xmath240 ( 9th gate ) are represented by rectangular boxes with double - control . every 3-qubit gate is further decomposed into four rotations around the @xmath1-axis according to eq . ( [ c2u ] ) , here @xmath241 and @xmath242 . furthermore , each rotation is executed by preparing a required star graph state , followed by the measurement in the appropriate basis . the detailed methodology is already mentioned in sec . [ sec : c2 ] . the hadamard gates @xmath91 are displayed by rounded rectangles , and the two - qubit gate @xmath243 is shown by the rounded rectangle on the qubit 6 with the qubit 5 as control in fig . [ fig:4 ] . the hadamard and the @xmath243 gates are executed by the unitary evolution . the classical information - processing parts for @xmath235 are handled by a classical computer according to table [ table : cip ] . in this table , the first column is for the computational steps @xmath121 , which are represented by the dashed vertical lines in fig . [ fig:4 ] . there are ten vertical lines in the figure and ten rows in the table for the ten computational steps from @xmath244 to @xmath245 . at each vertical line the information flow vector @xmath127 gets updated . the second and the third columns are reserved for @xmath246 and @xmath247 respectively . if required , the change in the measurement angles for the next gate based on the updated value of @xmath127 is calculated ; they are given in the fourth column . after performing the measurements in the appropriate bases , the measurement outcomes are recorded in the fifth column . @ c c c p5 cm p5 cm @xmath121 & @xmath246 & @xmath247 & angle @xmath216 ( here @xmath248 ) & measurement outcomes + * 0 * & @xmath249 & @xmath249 & @xmath250 & @xmath251 @xmath252 + * 1 * & @xmath249 & @xmath253 & & + * 2 * & @xmath254 & @xmath255 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 @xmath258 + * 3 * & @xmath254 & @xmath259 & & + * 4 * & @xmath260 & @xmath261 & & + * 5 * & @xmath260 & @xmath262 & & + * 6 * & @xmath254 & @xmath263 & @xmath264 & @xmath265 @xmath266 + * 7 * & @xmath254 & @xmath267 & & + * 8 * & @xmath268 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 @xmath271 & @xmath272 @xmath273 + * 9 * & @xmath268 & @xmath274 + [ table : cip ] let us go through the table row by row . before starting the computation ( in the first row @xmath275 ) , all the entries of both @xmath276 and @xmath277 are zeros ( initialization ) . so , there is no change in the measurement angle for each of the four rotations associated with the gate @xmath237 ( 1st gate ) . the measurement outcomes @xmath278 , @xmath279 , @xmath280 , and @xmath281 corresponding to the four rotations @xmath282 , @xmath283 , @xmath284 , and @xmath285 are recorded . these outcomes give some nonzero entries to @xmath286 according to eq . ( [ ivector ] ) . the measurement outcome @xmath287 corresponds to the @xmath288th rotation of the @xmath108th 3-qubit gate . the next gate in the circuit is the hadamard gate @xmath289 , which does not change under the propagation of the byproduct operator ; that is why the forth column of the second row @xmath290 is empty . the @xmath91-gate is realized by the unitary evolution , that is why the fifth column of the second row is also empty . but the @xmath91-gate changes the information flow vector @xmath291 into @xmath292 under the propagation relation given by eq . ( [ proh ] ) , and the propagation matrix for the @xmath91-gate is given by eqs . ( [ ch ] ) and ( [ cch ] ) . the @xmath293rd gate is @xmath238 . the measurement angles @xmath216 only for the rotation @xmath294 and @xmath295 get influenced by @xmath296 according to eq . ( [ thetax ] ) . the measurement outcomes @xmath297 , @xmath298 , @xmath299 , and @xmath300 only transform @xmath301 into @xmath302 . in this way going through table [ table : cip ] along with fig . [ fig:4 ] explains the whole scheme , and the final output result is interpreted according to eq . ( [ sx ] ) with the help of @xmath303 . here , the @xmath1-part of the information flow vector @xmath247 gets the new entries from the implementation of 3-qubit gates only according to eq . ( [ ivector ] ) . the entries of @xmath127 get manipulated under the propagation of the byproduct operator through the hadamard gates and the @xmath243 gate according to the propagation relations ( [ proh ] ) and ( [ hqcprocz ] ) , respectively . but the propagation of the byproduct operator does not change the @xmath91- and @xmath17-gate . the @xmath28-part of the information flow vector @xmath246 influences the measurement angles @xmath216 of the rotations for every 3-qubit gate according to eq . ( [ thetax ] ) . as a side remark , the sign of the azimuthal angle @xmath58 of the measurement bases for the rotations also depends on the eigenvalues of the ancilla qubit according to eq . ( [ phik ] ) , which is not mentioned in the table . we can easily generalize this example up the @xmath36-qubit gate @xmath304 . where the @xmath305 logical qubits @xmath306 are the control qubits and the last one is the target qubit . for implementing this gate we need @xmath307 work qubits , which are initialized in the state @xmath308 . in grover s search algorithm this gate plays a very important role , which we are discussing in the next section . in this section , we illustrate the use of the hqcm in the context of a practical example : grover s search algorithm ( ga ) @xcite . here , we shall see that the @xmath36-qubit gate @xmath304 along with the single - qubit operations is sufficient to perform ga . the best known quantum algorithm , for an unstructured database search , is ga . we have an unstructured database of total @xmath309 items , out of which only one item matches with our query . where a classical computer takes an average @xmath310 steps , a qc with ga takes only @xmath311 steps ( grover s iterations ) to find out the marked item . a `` step '' is a query of the oracle in the current context . a brief description of ga is given as follows : we can recognize each item of our database by a @xmath36-bit string . for simplicity , we choose @xmath312 = the total number of @xmath36-bit strings , and only one string out of @xmath309 is marked . the task of the search problem is to recover the marked @xmath36-bit string in the end of computation . ga begins with the hadamard operation on each qubit , which were initially prepared in the state @xmath313 , and that creates the superposition of the kets for all possible @xmath36-bit strings with equal amplitude . the next step is the implementation of grover s iteration , which is a rotation in effect . it can be decomposed into two reflection operations . the first reflection operator is the oracle @xmath314 , which has the ability to recognize the solution of the search problem . mathematically , @xmath314 gives a conditional phase shift of @xmath233 to the matching string only . the second reflection operator is the diffusion operator @xmath315 , which gives an inversion about the average . like other quantum algorithms , ga is also probabilistic in nature . after @xmath311 steps ( iterations ) the amplitude of the marked string becomes significantly larger than those of the unmarked strings . finally , we read the output by performing measurements on all the qubits . there have been many successful attempts at the implementation of ga , for @xmath316 or @xmath317 , in different physical setups such as with nmr system @xcite , with cavity quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) @xcite , with optics @xcite , and with the mqcm @xcite . now , let us take a look at the structure of these two reflection operators . if only one out of @xmath309 item matches with our query ; then there exist @xmath309 different @xmath314 operations ( one for each item ) . mathematically , the oracle corresponds to the @xmath108th item can be written as @xmath318 the case of @xmath319 , @xmath320 , corresponds to @xmath321 and is nothing but the @xmath36-qubit gate @xmath304 . we already discussed its implementation with the hqcm for @xmath322 in sec . [ sec : c3 ] , and its circuit diagram is shown in fig . [ fig:4 ] . any other oracle can be derived by performing the gate(s ) @xmath323 on the relevant qubit(s ) before and after performing the gate @xmath304 . for example , the oracle associated with the item @xmath324 can be derived as @xmath325x^{\otimes n}. \label{o1}\ ] ] so the gate @xmath304 is used for implementing every oracle . the information , which of the oracle is executed by the black box ? " , is hidden to us . in other words , we do not know on which qubit(s ) the black box is implementing the @xmath6 gate(s ) along with @xmath304 . the mathematical structure of the diffusion operator is @xmath326x^{\otimes n}h^{\otimes n}. \label{d}\ ] ] it can also be constructed by performing the hadamard- and the @xmath6-gate on every logical qubit before and after performing the gate @xmath304 . in summary , the gate @xmath304 together with the hadamard and the @xmath6 gates is sufficient to realize ga in the framework of hqcm . we have established the hqcm , which is a hybrid model of the mqcm and the uqcm , where at first , a big unitary gate under simulation is decomposed into a sequence of elementary gates . the elementary gates in the hqcm are an arbitrary single - qubit gate , the @xmath17 gate and the multi - qubit rotation around the @xmath1-axis . every single - qubit gate and the @xmath17-gate are realized by a unitary evolution . every multi - qubit rotation is executed by preparing a respective star graph state followed by a single measurement . the hqcm is a model where a portion of the quantum circuit is simulated by the unitary evolution , and the rest is by the measurements . the choice of elementary gates is governed by the experimental easiness in terms of resources and computational steps . the implementation of an arbitrary single - qubit gate with the unitary evolution is straightforward in comparison with its implementation with the mqcm . the @xmath17-gate in itself is the part of experimental setup for creating the graph states . the star graph states for the multi - qubit rotations can be realized in one shot , and a single measurement is enough for executing these rotations . the classical information processing in the hqcm is very simple in comparison with the mqcm . in the hqcm , only the @xmath102-component information flow vector and the propagation matrices for the elementary gates are needed for the classical information processing , and the total number of steps are taken by a classical computer in parallel for doing this is the total number of gates in a quantum circuit under simulation . furthermore , no preprocessing and no additional computational steps are required for classical information processing in the hqcm . we also have shown that how one can realize efficiently the multi - control gates ( like @xmath304 ) with the hqcm , which play a very important role in the implementation of ga . the gate @xmath304 together with the hadamard and the @xmath6 gates is sufficient to realize ga in the framework of hqcm . one can carry on the investigation in the following directions . in addition to the multi - qubit rotations in the set of elementary gates for the hqcm , one could include some more gates which can be executed in one shot by the mqcm without adding further complications in the model in the set of elementary gates . further , implementation errors need to be considered for any practical realization . in order to establish the fault - tolerance version of hqcm , one needs to design the elementary gates in a fault - tolerant manner but this is beyond the scope of the present paper . in this appendix , we discuss the implementation of the single - qubit rotation around the @xmath1-axis @xmath327 with the mqcm @xcite . a two - qubit graph state corresponding to the graph depicted in fig . [ fig:5](i ) is sufficient for accomplishing the job . the logical qubit 1 ( represented by the circle ) is in a general input state @xmath328 , and this is the single - qubit state on which we want to apply @xmath51 . in order to generate the required graph state , we prepare the qubit @xmath7 ( represented by the diamond ) in the state @xmath8 . then both the qubits are connected by the operation @xmath17 , which is represented by the bond in fig . [ fig:5](i ) and given by eq . ( [ cz ] ) . the resulting graph state @xmath329 \label{g1}\ ] ] is ready for the computation . here , the subscript 1 + 1 indicates that this graph state is made of two qubits , the logical qubit 1 and the ancilla qubit @xmath7 . in order to generate the desired effect on the input state , we measure the qubit 1 in the basis @xmath330 and the value of @xmath190 is the result of the measurement . after the measurement , the output state ( up to a global phase ) @xmath331 is obtained from the qubit @xmath7 , and the qubit 1 gets projected either onto the state @xmath332 ( if @xmath333 ) or onto the state @xmath334 ( if @xmath335 ) . the net effect on the input state is the required operation @xmath51 followed by the hadamard gate @xmath336 ( represented by the boxes in fig . [ fig:5](ii ) ) and the byproduct operator @xmath53 ( represented by the dotted - box in fig . [ fig:5](ii ) ) . here , the direction of measurement lies in @xmath28,@xmath29 plane of the bloch sphere , and the input information is not only teleported from one lattice site to other but also gets processed by the measurement . as we know , every rotation in the bloch sphere corresponds to a single - qubit operation ( up to a global phase ) . owing to the euler decomposition of an arbitrary rotation @xmath337 , where @xmath338 , one can generate an arbitrary single - qubit operation with a chain of five qubits graph state with the measurement direction for each qubit ( the angles @xmath339 ) in @xmath28,@xmath29 plane of the bloch sphere @xcite . the realization of an arbitrary rotation by such a sequence of two @xmath1 rotations sandwiching an @xmath28 rotation illustrates the importance of the temporal ordering of the measurements in the mqcm . in this appendix , the propagation matrices for the @xmath70- , @xmath55- , @xmath91- , and @xmath93-gate for the case of @xmath36 logical qubits are given . the propagation matrix @xmath340 is a @xmath109 matrix of the form @xmath341 , where @xmath342 and @xmath343 are @xmath344 matrices with binary - valued entries @xcite . one can generate the propagation matrices for an arbitrary single - qubit rotation @xmath345 on the logical qubit ` @xmath108 ' with @xmath346_{kl}&= \left[\textbf{c}_{zz}(r^{(j)})\right]_{kl}=\delta_{kl},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{zx}(r^{(j)})\right]_{kl}&= \left[\textbf{c}_{xz}(r^{(j)})\right]_{kl}=0;\label{ccr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath347_{kl}$ ] stands for the entry in @xmath288th row and @xmath348th column of the matrix @xmath349 corresponding to the @xmath345 gate . the same notation apply for the propagation matrices defined below . the propagation matrix for the @xmath85 gate ( both the control qubit ` @xmath7 ' and the target qubit ` @xmath11 ' belong to the set of @xmath36 logical qubits ; @xmath350 ) is given by @xmath351_{kl}&= \delta_{kl}+\delta_{kb}\delta_{la},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{zz}(\textsc{cnot}(a , b))\right]_{kl}&=\delta_{kl}+\delta_{ka}\delta_{lb},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{zx}(\textsc{cnot}(a , b))\right]_{kl}&=\left[\textbf{c}_{xz}(\textsc{cnot}(a , b))\right]_{kl}= 0;\label{cccnot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the hadamard gate @xmath352 on the logical qubit ` @xmath108 ' is given by @xmath353_{kl}&= \left[\textbf{c}_{zz}(h^{(j)})\right]_{kl}=\delta_{kl}\oplus\delta_{kj}\delta_{lj},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{zx}(h^{(j)})\right]_{kl}&= \left[\textbf{c}_{xz}(h^{(j)})\right]_{kl}=\delta_{kj}\delta_{lj};\label{cch}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for the @xmath58-phase gate @xmath354 on the logical qubit ` @xmath108 ' is given by @xmath355_{kl}&= \left[\textbf{c}_{zz}(r^{(j)}_{z}(\pi/2))\right]_{kl}=\delta_{kl},\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{zx}(r^{(j)}_{z}(\pi/2))\right]_{kl}&= 0,\nonumber\\ \left[\textbf{c}_{xz}(r^{(j)}_{z}(\pi/2))\right]_{kl}&=\delta_{kj}\delta_{lj}.\label{ccphase}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is advantageous to deal with the information flow vector @xmath106 together with the propagation matrices ( eqs . ( [ ccr])([ccphase ] ) ) by a classical computer , than directly dealing with the corresponding byproduct operator @xmath96 together with the propagation relations ( eqs . ( [ pror ] ) , ( [ procnot ] ) , ( [ proh ] ) , and ( [ prophase ] ) ) . this appendix holds a discuss on an efficient measurement scheme of the mqcm where the temporal order of the measurements plays an important role @xcite . on one hand in the uqcm , we can not parallelize two gates of a sequence that do not commute . on the other hand in the mqcm , all the gates from the generating set of the clifford group can be executed in a single time step irrespective of their positions in the circuit . in other words , the temporal order of the measurements in the mqcm is not pre - imposed by the temporal order of the gates . so , the most efficient scheme for the measurements does not necessarily follow the temporal order of the gates in a circuit under simulation . first , the spatial pattern of the measurement bases is assigned to the graph qubits according to the sequence of gates . then the measurements are performed round by round according to the scheme which is given as follows . first , the graph @xmath5 is divided into disjoint subsets of qubits @xmath356 , where index @xmath125 stands for the round of measurements and @xmath357 . mathematically , @xmath358 and @xmath359 for all @xmath360 . the subset @xmath356 is a collection of all those qubits which will be measured simultaneously in @xmath125th round . all the measurements in the @xmath6 , @xmath60 and @xmath0 eigenbasis are put together in the very first round ( @xmath361th round ) , and there is no need for adjusting the measurement bases according to the previous measurement results for the qubits of @xmath362 . in the first measurement round , the `` redundant graph qubits '' are removed by the @xmath0-measurements , the `` readout qubits '' are measured in the @xmath0 eigenbasis , and the clifford part of the circuit is executed by the @xmath6- , @xmath60-measurements @xcite . in the mqcm , the `` readout qubits '' which play the role of `` output register '' are not the last ones to be measured , they are among the first ones . the observables for all subsequent measurement rounds are of the form @xmath363 with @xmath79 , where the measurement bases for the qubits are decided by the measurement outcomes from the previous rounds . all those qubits whose measurement bases depend on the outcomes from the first measurement round belong to the next subset @xmath364 . similarly , the measurement outcomes from the subset @xmath364 together with @xmath362 decide the measurement bases for the qubits in @xmath365 , and so on . these subsets are measured one by one up to the final measurement round @xmath366 . one can think of the total number of measurement rounds ( @xmath367 ) as the logical depth ( temporal complexity ) for the mqcm . parallel to the measurement rounds , the classical data - processing parts are taken care of by a classical computer . after preparing the graph state and just before starting the measurements , the information vector is initialized to @xmath368 . @xmath368 depends on the eigenvalues @xmath34 of the graph and some particular gates ( like @xmath55 , @xmath93 ) which appear in a quantum circuit under simulation @xcite . after executing the first measurement round on the set @xmath362 , @xmath368 gets updated to @xmath369 through the measurement results . @xmath369 then determines the measurement bases for the qubits of @xmath364 . similarly , the measurement outcomes from round @xmath125 update the information flow vector from @xmath134 to @xmath126 . the corresponding byproduct operator is given by @xmath370 then , @xmath371 sets the measurement bases for the @xmath372th round . after the final measurement round @xmath366 , the @xmath28-part of the information flow vector @xmath373 enables us to interpret the result of the computation . in this measurement scheme , the following technical points are worth emphasizing , which are discussed in ref . @xcite : ( 1 ) in order to construct the subsets of graph qubits @xmath374 , a classical computer needs the forward cones for all the graph qubits . the forward cones decide a strict partial ordering among the qubits , and the sets @xmath374 are constructed accordingly . ( 2 ) in order to account for the influence of the measurement outcomes and the set of eigenvalues @xmath34 on @xmath126 , a classical computer needs the byproduct images for all the graph qubits . ( 3 ) @xmath34 , the byproduct images , and @xmath126 are required for setting the measurement bases for the as - yet unmeasured qubits . a classical computer uses the symplectic scalar product for doing this . centre for quantum technologies is a research centre of excellence funded by ministry of education and national research foundation of singapore . d. z. would like to express his gratitude to cqt for its kind hospitality , and further thanks to h. j. briegel and w. dr . s. wishes to thank h. j. briegel and iqoqi for their warm hospitality . a. s. also wishes to express his grateful feelings to w. dr , hui khoon , le huy nguyen , and philippe raynal for enlightening comments and friendly discussions . 17 d. deutsch , proc . london ser . a * 400 * , 97 ( 1985 ) . d. deutsch , proc . london ser . a * 425 * , 73 ( 1989 ) . a. barenco , c. h. bennett , r. cleve , d. p. divincenzo , n. margolus , p. shor , t. sleator , j. a. smolin and , h. weinfurter , phys . rev . a * 52 * , 3457 ( 1995 ) . d. p. divincenzo , science * 270 * , 255 ( 1995 ) . m. a. nielsen and i. l. chuang , quantum computation and quantum information , cambridge university press , cambridge ( 2007 ) . d. deutsch , r. jozsa , proc . london ser . a * 439 * , 553 ( 1992 ) . l. k. grover , phys . lett . * 79 * , 325 ( 1997 ) . p. w. shor , e - print arxiv : quant - ph/9508027v2 . c. h. bennett , g. brassard , c. crpeau , r. jozsa , a. peres , and w. k. wootters , phys . * 70 * , 1895 ( 1993 ) . h. j. briegel and r. raussendorf , phys . lett . * 86 * , 910 ( 2001 ) . m. hein , j. eisert , and h. j. briegel , phys . a * 69 * , 062311 ( 2004 ) . r. raussendorf and h. j. briegel , phys . * 86 * , 5188 ( 2001 ) . r. raussendorf , d. e. browne , and h. j. briegel , phys . a * 68 * , 022312 ( 2003 ) . r. raussendorf and h. j. briegel , quant . inf . comp . * 6 * , 443 ( 2002 ) , eprint arxiv : quant - ph/0108067v2 . d. browne and h. j. briegel , e - print arxiv : quant - ph/0603226v2 . d. jaksch , h. j. briegel , j. i. cirac , c. w. gardiner , and p. zoller , phys . lett . * 82 * , 1975 ( 1999 ) . m. a. nielsen , phys . * 93 * , 040503 ( 2004 ) . d. e. browne and t. rudolph , phys . * 95 * , 010501 ( 2005 ) . t. p. bodiya and l .- m . duan , phys . lett . * 97 * , 143601 ( 2006 ) . c. y. lu , x. q. zhou , o. ghne , w. b. gao , j. zhang , z. s. yuan , a. goebel , t. yang , and j. w. pan , nature physics * 3 * , 91 ( 2007 ) . j. a. jones , m. mosca , and r. h. hansen , nature * 393 * , 344 ( 1998 ) . i. l. chuang , n. gershenfeld , and m. kubinec , phys . lett . * 80 * , 3408 ( 1998 ) . m. s. anwar , d. blazina , h. a. carteret , s. b. duckett , and j. a. jones , chem . . lett . * 400 * , 94 ( 2004 ) . f. yamaguchi , p. milman , m. brune , j. m. raimond , and s. haroche , phys . a * 66 * , 010302(r ) ( 2002 ) . z. j. deng , m. feng , and k. l. gao , phys . a * 72 * , 034306 ( 2005 ) . w. l. yang , c. y. chen , and m. feng , phys . a * 76 * , 054301 ( 2007 ) . p. g. kwait , j. r. mitchell , p. d. d. schwindt , and a. g. white , j. mod . opt . * 47 * , 257 ( 2000 ) . n. bhattacharya , h. b. vanlindenvandenheuvell , and r. j. c. spreeuw , phys . * 88 * , 137901 ( 2002 ) . p. walther , k. j. resch , t. rudolph , e. schenck , h. weinfurter , v. vedral , m. aspelmeyer , and a. zeilinger , nature * 434 * , 169 ( 2005 ) . k. chen , c. m. li , q. zhang , y. a. chen , a. goebel , s. chen , a. mair , and j. w. pan , phys . lett . * 99 * , 120503 ( 2007 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the astrophysicist subrahmanyan chandrasekhar once referred to black holes as `` the most perfect macroscopic objects there are in the universe : the only elements in their construction are our concepts of space and time.''@xcite this special issue of journal of physics a is devoted to a completely different topic , the quantum - mechanical amplitudes for the scattering of relativistic particles , in which a revolution in our understanding has been taking place recently . however , scattering amplitudes represent a kind of short - distance complement to the perfection chandrasekhar saw in black holes . we might consider them to be the most perfect microscopic structures in the universe . black holes are gigantic and ( almost ) eternal . scattering amplitudes , in contrast , portray events that wink in and out of existence much faster than the blink of an eye . they describe processes at the shortest distance scales that can be probed in the laboratory . when gravitons scatter , interacting via einstein s field equations , again in some sense the only elements in the construction are our concepts of space and time although the boundary conditions at infinity can be more detailed than for black holes , involving multiple plane - wave ripples ( the gravitons ) propagating in various directions through minkowski space - time . when other relativistic particles scatter , as in non - abelian gauge theory , more information has to be provided , such as the gauge group , the coupling constant , the matter content of the theory , the particle masses , and the precise set of particle types and spins being scattered . however , in the ultra - relativistic limit , if there are only gauge interactions , much of the group - theoretical information can be stripped from the amplitudes , and certain color - ordered `` primitive '' amplitudes can be defined which are quite universal . these amplitudes have intricate analytic properties , which have been teased out over the decades , but especially in the past few years . a variety of new , efficient techniques have been found to construct amplitudes , and hidden symmetries have been identified which illustrate the amplitudes `` perfection . '' in the real universe , black holes are not found in an absolute vacuum . typically they are surrounded by accretion disks of gas and dust , which muddy their perfection somewhat , but also enrich the range of phenomena involving them , and make them much easier to observe , albeit indirectly . similarly , scattering amplitudes for quantum chromodynamics , or qcd , the most relativistic non - abelian gauge theory we can study in the laboratory , are shrouded from direct view by confinement . the quarks and gluons that theorists scatter mentally are never seen experimentally . in the initial state of a hadronic collision they are bound into a proton or other hadron . in the final state they emerge as collimated jets of particles . despite this fact , quantities that are sensitive only to very short distances , so - called infrared - safe observables such as jet production cross sections , can be computed reliably in terms of quarks and gluons , in a systematic expansion in the strong coupling @xmath1 . if we could go to asymptotically high energies , so that @xmath1 were infinitesimal , it would be enough to consider just the leading order in this expansion , which is generated by the born approximation , or tree - level amplitudes . the tree - level amplitudes of qcd have even more `` perfection '' than the generic , loop - level amplitudes , because they coincide with the tree amplitudes of a much more symmetric theory , @xmath0 supersymmetric yang - mills theory ( @xmath0 sym ) . this theory , which is the subject of many of the articles in this special issue , has the maximum amount of supersymmetry possible in a gauge theory . its four supercharges can be used to transform the helicity @xmath2 gluon state , by @xmath3 unit of helicity at a time , all the way to the helicity @xmath4 cpt conjugate gluon state . all states in the theory belong to a single supermultiplet , transforming in the adjoint representation of the gauge group . therefore all interactions are related by supersymmetry to the triple - gluon vertex , and the theory has a single dimensionless coupling @xmath5 . the @xmath6 function for @xmath0 sym vanishes exactly for any gauge group , @xmath7 , so that the theory is exactly conformally invariant at the quantum level , as well as classically . ( the classical conformal invariance of qcd with massless quarks is of course spoiled by its nonvanishing one - loop @xmath6 function , which leads to asymptotic freedom . ) in investigations of scattering amplitudes in @xmath0 sym , the gauge group under consideration is usually su@xmath8 . quite often , the limit @xmath9 is also taken , at a fixed value of the t hooft coupling , @xmath10 . for @xmath11 , perturbation theory can be applied , and for large @xmath12 only planar feynman diagrams contribute . for @xmath13 , perturbation theory breaks down , but the ads / cft correspondence @xcite can be used . in the large-@xmath12 or planar limit of @xmath0 sym , even more remarkable symmetries and relations emerge for scattering amplitudes . as we will discuss further below , these properties include dual conformal ( super)symmetry , which is part of a larger yangian invariance ; a description of amplitudes in terms of spaces of complex planes ( grassmannians ) ; and in terms of various types of twistors ; and a relation between scattering amplitudes and the expectation values of wilson loops for closed polygons bounded by light - like edges . many of these properties are intimately connected with a strong - coupling picture of gluon scattering in terms of strings moving in anti - de - sitter space @xcite . the exceptional simplicity and numerous hidden symmetries of @xmath0 sym have made it a playground for theorists interested in scattering amplitudes for a couple of decades . this interest has accelerated rapidly in the past few years . because the tree - level amplitudes of qcd and @xmath0 sym coincide , the early discoveries about qcd helicity amplitudes , motivated by the physics of jet production , were also discoveries about @xmath0 sym . for example , the parke - taylor formula @xcite for the maximal - helicity - violating ( mhv ) sequence of @xmath14-gluon amplitudes , which is just a single - term expression , even for an arbitrarily large value of @xmath14 , is also consistent with all the symmetries of @xmath0 sym @xcite , including some that were only unveiled decades later . many general properties of tree amplitudes were understood early on , such as their factorization properties @xcite and the ( @xmath15 or @xmath16 ) supersymmetry ward identities that they obey @xcite . however , a fuller understanding and exploitation of these properties have come only in recent years . for instance , the complete solutions of the long - known @xmath0 supersymmetry ward identities , and the corresponding @xmath17 identities in supergravity , have been worked out recently by elvang , freedman and kiermaier @xcite , and are reviewed here @xcite . several years ago , witten @xcite discovered that the twistor space developed decades earlier by penrose @xcite gave a natural description of tree - level amplitudes in massless gauge theory . as discussed in , such amplitudes have a natural description in terms of two - component weyl spinors , a left - handed and a right - handed spinor for each external state . to go to twistor space , one performs a fourier transform on half the variables , namely the left - handed spinors , leaving the right - handed ones alone . witten found that gauge theory could be reformulated in terms of a topological string moving in twistor space . gauge amplitudes turn out to be localized on particular curves in twistor space . in one approach , the curves are intersecting lines : a single line for the simplest mhv amplitudes , a pair of lines for the next - to - maximally - helicity - violating ( nmhv ) amplitudes , and so on . this version gave rise to the csw or mhv rules for gauge theory @xcite , whose mhv vertices are a particular off - shell continuation of the parke - taylor formulae . these developments are reviewed here by brandhuber , spence and travaglini @xcite , and by adamo , bullimore , mason and skinner @xcite . the latter reference also discusses another class of twistors , namely momentum twistors , which also provides a natural set of kinematic variables for amplitudes , in that they automatically satisfy the kinematic constraints of momentum conservation and the mass - shell conditions . finally , the correspondence between wilson loops and scattering amplitudes is described in this article @xcite from the perspective of twistor space . britto , cachazo , feng and witten ( bcfw ) @xcite recognized that factorization properties are powerful enough to allow the derivation of recursion relations @xcite for tree amplitudes , in terms of on - shell lower - point amplitudes , which are evaluated at particular complex momenta . this observation , reviewed here by brandhuber , spence and travaglini @xcite , makes essential use of the analyticity , or _ plasticity _ , of amplitudes ; that is , how they vary under smooth deformations of the kinematics . bcfw embedded an amplitude @xmath18 into a one - complex - parameter family of on - shell amplitudes @xmath19 with shifted complex momenta , and associated the poles of @xmath19 in the @xmath20 plane with factorization of the amplitude onto simpler lower - point amplitudes . one can also construct a supersymmetrized version of the bcfw recursion relation , in which grassmann variables @xmath21 associated with @xmath0 supersymmetry are shifted along with the momenta @xcite . this recursion relation can be solved explicitly to yield all tree amplitudes in @xmath0 sym @xcite ; the solution and its many symmetries are reviewed here by drummond @xcite . scattering amplitudes in massless gauge theories all have quite similar structure at tree level , once the color factors have been stripped off , as discussed in . on the other hand , the structure of loop amplitudes depends critically on the theory . the simplicity of one - loop multi - gluon amplitudes in @xmath0 sym played a key role in the development of the unitarity method @xcite . this method reconstructs loop amplitudes from their unitarity cuts , again exploiting analyticity . in general at one loop , as explained in this issue by britto @xcite and ita @xcite , unitarity cuts are matched against a decomposition of the amplitude in terms of a set of scalar integrals boxes , triangles , bubbles and ( sometimes ) tadpoles in order to determine the coefficients of the integrals . in @xmath0 sym , the high degree of supersymmetry implies that only boxes have non - vanishing coefficients . using unitarity , an infinite sequence of one - loop amplitudes ( the mhv amplitudes ) could be determined in @xmath0 sym from just the product of two tree - level mhv ( parke - taylor ) amplitudes @xcite . later , generalized unitarity was applied to the problem of computing one - loop amplitudes , by extracting additional information from products of three and four tree amplitudes , the so - called triple @xcite and quadruple @xcite cuts . quadruple cuts have four on - shell conditions . these four equations determine the four components of the ( four - dimensional ) loop momenta completely , up to a ( possible ) two - fold degeneracy . this realization allows the box coefficients to be computed very simply in terms of the product of four tree amplitudes , glued together as the four corners of a box , and evaluated at each of the two solutions for the loop momenta @xcite . for @xmath0 sym , there are no other coefficients to determine , so the one - loop problem has been `` reduced to quadrature . '' ( it turns out that maximal @xmath17 supergravity can be proven to have the same `` no - triangle '' property @xcite , so it too is solved at one loop by the quadruple cuts . ) generalized unitarity can also be applied very effectively at the multi - loop level . in principle it can be used for any gauge ( or gravitational ) theory . as an example , the two - loop four - gluon scattering amplitudes in qcd have been computed in this way @xcite . in practice the method has been pushed the furthest in @xmath0 sym . the basic techniques of multi - loop generalized unitarity are reviewed here by bern and huang @xcite , and by carrasco and johansson @xcite . returning now to one - loop amplitudes for generic gauge theories , including qcd , the triangle and bubble coefficients have to be determined , as well as certain _ rational parts _ , which have no unitarity cuts in four dimensions . the triple cuts contain information about the triangle coefficients , but they also receive contributions from boxes . similarly , the ordinary double cuts determine the bubble coefficients , once the contributions of triangles and boxes are removed . this separation can be done analytically , by making use of the different analytic behavior of the different types of cut integrals , as reviewed by britto @xcite . it can also be done numerically , by a suitable sampling of the continuum of loop momenta solving the triple or double cut on - shell conditions @xcite , as described by ita @xcite . these two articles also review methods for computing the rational parts of one - loop amplitudes . although the rational parts have no unitarity cuts in four dimensions ( by definition ) , they can be constructed via their cuts in dimensional regularization in @xmath22 dimensions . alternatively , it is possible to construct them recursively in the number of legs @xcite . on - shell loop amplitudes in massless non - abelian gauge theories always contain infrared divergences , due to the exchange of soft gluons or virtual collinear splittings . in qcd it is conventional to regulate these divergences , as well as the ultraviolet ones , using dimensional regularization . in supersymmetric theories , dimensional reduction @xcite , or the related four - dimensional helicity scheme @xcite , can be used to keep the number of bosonic and fermionic states the same , and preserve ward identities for ordinary supersymmetry . the general structure of the infrared divergences is well understood from decades of work in qed as well as qcd @xcite . it has been worked out in the most detail in the context of dimensional regularization @xcite . the basic picture is shown in . soft divergences and collinear divergences associated with the amplitude @xmath23 each have a universal form . they can be factorized from each other and from a hard , short - distance part of the amplitude . soft divergences , denoted by the blob marked @xmath24 , come from exchange of long - wavelength gluons . these gluons do not have the resolving power to probe the internal structure of the `` jets '' @xmath25 of virtual collinear particles which capture the collinear divergences . soft gluons can only see the overall color charges of the jets . an individual jet function @xmath26 depends on the type of particle @xmath27 , but not on the full amplitude kinematics . the soft function @xmath24 does not depend on the particle types , but only on their momenta and color quantum numbers . in general these quantum numbers can be mixed by gluon exchange , so @xmath24 is a matrix in color space . the hard function @xmath28 has no infrared singularities , but generically depends on the particle types , colors and kinematics . 4.5 truein in the planar or large-@xmath12 limit , the picture simplifies considerably , to that shown in . now @xmath23 represents the coefficient of a particular color structure , such as @xmath29 ( assuming that all external states are in the adjoint representation ; see ) . in the planar limit , individual soft gluons can only connect color - adjacent external partons . there is no mixing of different color structures at large @xmath12 . one can absorb the entire soft function @xmath24 into jet functions , which corresponds to breaking up the right - hand side of into @xmath14 wedges . each wedge is bounded by two hard lines , and is composed of `` half '' of each of the two jet functions , as well as the soft gluons exchanged between them . up to nonsingular terms , the wedge controlling the infrared divergences represents the square root of the sudakov form factor , which is defined as the amplitude for a color - singlet state to decay into a pair of ( adjoint ) gluons . 4.5 truein in dimensional regularization , the sudakov form factor obeys a particular differential equation @xcite , whose source term is called the cusp anomalous dimension @xmath30 @xcite . there is an additional constant of integration , called @xmath31 . these two functions ( along with the @xmath6 function in a non - conformal theory ) control the infrared divergences to all orders for any amplitude in a planar massless gauge theory . in planar @xmath0 sym , the cusp anomalous dimension has been determined to all orders in the coupling using integrability @xcite . the bds ansatz @xcite was built up from this description of the infrared singularities of planar amplitudes , plus the observation for the two- and three - loop four - point amplitudes that the hard function @xmath28 essentially reduces to a constant , independent of the kinematics . besides the cusp anomalous dimension , another place that integrability certainly enters multi - loop scattering amplitudes is in multi - regge - kinematics , a particular class of high - energy or small - angle limits of @xmath32 particle scatterings . these kinematics gave the first indication that the bds ansatz for mhv amplitudes has to be corrected beginning at the six - point level @xcite . ( it was previously argued @xcite using the properties of wilson loops , that the ansatz should be corrected at two loops for a large value of @xmath14 , unless the correspondence between mhv amplitudes and wilson loops were to break down . the hexagon wilson loop was then computed and found to differ from the ansatz prediction @xcite . ) the dynamics of gluons in the transverse plane is given , in the leading - logarithmic approximation , by the hamiltonian for a integrable open spin chain , as reviewed here by bartels , lipatov and prygarin @xcite . in planar @xmath0 sym , another infrared regulator is more convenient for many purposes , in particular for exploring the loop - level consequences of dual conformal symmetry , which is not preserved by dimensional regularization . the features of a recently - developed `` higgs regulator '' @xcite are reviewed in this issue by henn @xcite . for this regulator , vacuum expectation values are given to some of the adjoint scalar fields in the theory , breaking the gauge symmetry in such a way that ( in the planar limit ) the amplitudes are regulated by massive particles circulating around the outside of the loop diagrams . dual conformal symmetry remains exact in a certain sense . when the particle masses @xmath33 are taken to be much less than the momentum - invariants for the scattering process , logarithmic divergences develop , the analogs of the @xmath34 infrared poles in dimensional regularization . there is a hierarchy of simplicity in the scattering amplitudes for various types of gauge theory , as sketched in . this hierarchy begins to be revealed at one loop . the outer region of the diagram stands for a generic gauge theory with massive matter fields , and perhaps massive gauge bosons , if the gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken , as in electroweak theory . one - loop amplitudes in such a theory generically contain tadpole integrals . one - particle cuts are nontrivial , and are particularly delicate because of external - leg contributions @xcite . the cut structure of loop integrals containing massive propagators in the loop is generically somewhat more complicated than the purely massless case . massive particles in the loop can be unstable , which usually necessitates complex masses . when one enters the `` massless '' ring in , corresponding to massless gauge bosons and matter fields , most of these complications vanish , although there are still generically rational parts to compute . the ring `` sym '' stands for supersymmetric gauge theories . their one - loop amplitudes can be constructed from four - dimensional unitarity cuts alone , _ i.e. _ there are no non - trivial rational parts @xcite . 5.2 truein moving further inward in , we arrive at @xmath0 sym . as mentioned earlier , at one loop the coefficients of bubble and triangle integrals now vanish , as well as the independent rational parts . ( there are other gauge theories with vanishing bubble and triangle coefficients , at least for their @xmath14-gluon amplitudes @xcite . ) the theory becomes conformally invariant . it has been conjectured that the _ leading singularities _ the multi - loop analogs of the quadruple cuts are sufficient to determine the amplitudes at any loop order @xcite . in addition , scattering amplitudes have empirically a predictable , uniform transcendental weight @xcite . this weight refers to their construction out of polylogarithms , logarithms , and riemann @xmath35 values . for example , the finite ( @xmath36 ) terms in one - loop @xmath0 sym amplitudes are of weight two : they contain some terms proportional to the polylogarithm @xmath37 , and others which are products of two logarithms , or proportional to @xmath38 , but they do not contain any terms of lower transcendentality . ( at one loop this result just follows from the absence of bubble and tadpole integrals . ) wherever analytic results are available , this uniform transcendentality property holds . for example , at two loops ( weight four for the finite terms ) it holds for the non - planar , subleading - color terms as well as the planar ones @xcite . finally , for planar @xmath0 sym , as mentioned earlier , additional symmetries appear , dual superconformal invariance and an associated yangian symmetry . the extra symmetries are related to integrability . they give rise to the prospect of adapting methods developed for other integrable systems to determine the @xmath24-matrix exactly , at least in the large @xmath12 limit . indeed , as reviewed by drummond @xcite , an integrand exhibiting manifest yangian invariance has been proposed recently @xcite for the general @xmath39-loop @xmath14-point amplitude , based on the bcfw recursion relations ; see also ref . @xcite . at the level of integrated amplitudes , dual conformal invariance has an anomaly due to the need for an infrared regulator . the anomaly was first understood in terms of wilson loops rather than amplitudes @xcite ( for which divergences are ultraviolet in nature , rather than infrared ) . nevertheless , dual conformal symmetry completely fixes the form of the four- and five - point amplitudes . the form to which they are fixed turns out to be precisely the abdk / bds ansatz @xcite , which was developed earlier based on the structure of infrared divergences of amplitudes , plus patterns observed at two and three loops . as discussed in , for six external legs one can build three different combinations of kinematic variables that are invariant under all dual conformal transformations , the cross - ratios @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 . at the six - point level , the abdk / bds ansatz fails at the first nontrivial order , two loops @xcite , and dual conformal symmetry allows for an additional `` remainder function '' , @xmath43 , which depends on the three cross - ratios . at strong coupling , large @xmath44 and large-@xmath12 , alday and maldacena used the ads / cft correspondence to map the problem of gluon scattering to that of strings moving in anti - de - sitter space @xcite . the ads background is weakly curved in this limit , relative to the string scale . another way of saying this is that the two - dimensional string world - sheet stretches over a large area , relative to the scale on which strings fluctuate , allowing a semi - classical expansion to be used at large @xmath44 . in the leading term in the expansion , different helicity configurations are not distinguished . the amplitude is given simply by @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is the classical action that minimizes the area ( at least for scattering configurations with a euclidean interpretation ) . using a @xmath47-duality transformation in string theory , alday and maldacena showed that the boundary conditions for the world - sheet are closed polygons , where each edge is a light - like segment given by the momentum @xmath48 of the @xmath49 gluon . the solution to the minimal area problem was found explicitly for four - gluon scattering . more recently , in order to handle more complicated kinematical configurations than the four - point case , the integrability of the string sigma - model action @xcite has been exploited . the minimal area problem has been solved by mapping it to a system of equations identical to those of the thermodynamical bethe ansatz @xcite . the first computation at strong coupling was for the four - gluon amplitude , and matched precisely the prediction of the abdk / bds ansatz @xcite . but it also suggested a weak - coupling correspondence between scattering amplitudes and wilson loops for closed light - like polygons , which was rapidly established for a variety of cases , initially for the simplest case of mhv scattering amplitudes @xcite . the wilson - loop correspondence has been very important both conceptually and technically . conceptually , it is still not entirely clear why it happens at all at weak coupling . technically , given its existence , it allows amplitudes to be computed in terms of wilson line integrals , which are generally somewhat more tractable than feynman loop integrals . some recent conceptual advances have come from considering certain correlation functions with close - to - light - like separations @xcite . the relative simplicity of the wilson line integrals for the six - point ( hexagon ) case allowed the remainder function @xmath43 to be evaluated analytically in terms of goncharov polylogarithms @xcite . the expression in ref . @xcite was then simplified considerably , to a few lines involving classical polylogarithms @xmath50 , using properties of the symbol operation which captures all of the essential analytic behavior of a multi - variable function @xcite . these results open the door to the possibility of finding simple analytic results for more general kinematic configurations . for some configurations in which the external momenta are restricted to two space - time dimensions , two - loop analytic results are already available beyond six external legs @xcite . there is certainly the prospect of more multi - loop analytic results on the horizon , for both wilson loops and scattering amplitudes in planar @xmath0 super - yang - mills theory . gravity seems to be a completely separate force from gauge theory . it has a spin two force carrier instead of spin one , no color degrees of freedom , and a dimensionful coupling constant . nevertheless , the two theories are intimately connected . the ads / cft correspondence @xcite relates the two , holographically , as a _ weak - strong _ duality . as mentioned earlier , strong - coupling scattering of gluons has an alternate description in terms of strings moving in a weakly - curved five - dimensional gravitational background . on the other hand , there is also a _ weak - weak _ duality of some kind between gravity and gauge theory , directly in four dimensions : it is possible to write perturbative scattering amplitudes for gravitons in terms of `` double copies '' of gluon amplitudes . the original examples of such relations are due to kawai , lewellen and tye ( klt ) @xcite , who found them by first deriving relations between closed and open string theory tree amplitudes , whose low - energy limits give tree - level relations in field - theory . graviton amplitudes are represented in terms of sums of products of pairs of gluon amplitudes with different color orderings . the klt relations hold not only for pure - graviton scattering , in terms of pure - gauge theory , but also for @xmath17 supergravity ( or any subsector of it ) in terms of amplitudes for @xmath0 sym . more recently it has been recognized that other double - copy formulas exist @xcite . the new formulas are simpler in some sense than the klt relations ; they involve the direct squares of gauge - theory components , whereas the klt relations employ multiple permutations of full gauge - theory amplitudes . as reviewed in this issue by carrasco and johansson @xcite , these relations , combined with generalized unitarity , have important consequences for multi - loop amplitudes in @xmath17 supergravity , because they map the problem to a much simpler one , the corresponding multi - loop amplitudes for ( non - planar ) @xmath0 sym . in the next two sections we discuss a few of the basic tools used to organize and illuminate the color and kinematic structure of amplitudes , which underlay the discussions in many of the other articles in this special issue . in this section we describe some common conventions for organizing the color structure of su@xmath8 gauge theory amplitudes , which are used elsewhere in this special issue . most of the articles implicitly discuss color - ordered partial amplitudes , which are particularly convenient in the large-@xmath12 limit in which planar diagrams dominate . color - ordered amplitudes emerge from a `` trace - based '' color decomposition ( as also reviewed in _ e.g. _ refs . @xcite ) . however , in some cases , in particular for describing subleading - color terms in amplitudes , and color - kinematic duality relations @xcite , decompositions based on the su@xmath8 structure constants are more useful . in general , we consider two different su@xmath8 representations for the external states : * the adjoint representation , for the gluon and any of its superpartners ( _ i.e. _ for all states in @xmath0 sym ) . adjoint color indices are denoted by @xmath51 . * the fundamental ( defining ) representation @xmath12 , and its conjugate representation @xmath52 , for quarks and anti - quarks respectively . fundamental color indices are denoted by @xmath53 , and anti - fundamental @xmath52 indices by @xmath54 . the generators of su@xmath8 in the fundamental representation are traceless hermitian @xmath55 matrices , denoted by @xmath56 . it is conventional when discussing helicity amplitudes to normalize the generators by @xmath57 , in order to avoid a proliferation of @xmath58 s . in qcd , the group theory ( color ) factors in feynman diagrams are of two types : @xmath56 for the gluon - quark - antiquark vertex , and the su@xmath8 structure constants @xmath59 ( or products of @xmath59 s ) for all other vertices . ( it is also convenient to normalize the structure constants differently , using @xmath60 , where @xmath59 is the standard , textbook normalization . ) the color factors can be represented diagrammatically @xcite using feynman - diagram notation , as in . lines with arrows ( quarks ) carry fundamental representation indices ; curly lines ( gluons ) carry adjoint indices . the adjoint representation is also a bi - fundamental ( @xmath61 ) representation from which the singlet , or trace component , has been projected out , as in the second equation for @xmath62 in the figure . this relation also gives rise to the su@xmath8 fierz identity , ( t^a)_i_1^ _ 1 ( t^a)_i_2^ _ 2 = _ i_1^ _ 2 _ i_2^ _ 1 - 1n_c _ i_1^ _ 1 _ i_2^ _ 2 , [ sunfierz ] which allows one to simplify products of traces of @xmath63 s . 4.8 truein color - ordering @xcite is related to the t hooft double - line formalism @xcite . we begin by rewriting the color factors entirely in terms of the @xmath63 generators , using the relation ^abc if^abc= ( [ t^a , t^b ] t^c ) , [ removefabc ] which follows from the definition of the structure constants , and is depicted graphically in . after inserting repeatedly into the color factor for a typical feynman diagram , one obtains a large number of traces of the generic form @xmath64 . if the amplitude has external quark legs , then there will also be strings of @xmath63 s terminated by fundamental indices , of the form @xmath65 , one for each external quark - antiquark pair . the number of traces can be reduced considerably by repeated use of the su@xmath8 fierz identity ( [ sunfierz ] ) . in the case of tree - level amplitudes with external states in the adjoint representation , such as @xmath14-gluon amplitudes , sketches how the color factors all may be reduced to a single trace , @xmath66 , for some permutation @xmath67 of the @xmath14 gluons . this reduction leads to the _ trace - based color decomposition _ for @xmath14-gluon tree amplitudes , -20 mm a^_n(\{k_i , h_i , a_i } ) = g^n-2 -1.3 mm _ s_n / z_n -1.3 mm ( t^a_(1)t^a_(n ) ) a_n^((1^h_1), ,(n^h_n ) ) . [ treegluecolor ] here @xmath68 is the full amplitude , with dependence on the external gluon momenta @xmath48 , @xmath69 , helicities @xmath70 , and adjoint indices @xmath71 . in qcd , the gauge coupling @xmath5 is related to the strong coupling by @xmath72 . the _ partial amplitudes _ ( or _ primitive _ or _ color - stripped amplitudes _ ) @xmath73 have had all the color factors removed , but contain all the kinematic information . cyclic permutations of the arguments of a partial amplitude , denoted by @xmath74 , leave it invariant , because the associated trace is invariant under these operations . however , all @xmath75 non - cyclic permutations , or orderings , of the partial amplitude appear in . these permutations are denoted by @xmath76 . 5.0 truein looking again at the way the different trace factors arise in , one sees that the partial amplitude @xmath77 only receives contributions from tree - level feynman diagrams that can be drawn on a plane , in which the cyclic ordering of the external legs , @xmath78 , matches the ordering of the arguments in @xmath79 . therefore each partial amplitude can only have singularities in momentum invariants formed by squaring color - adjacent sums of momenta , such as @xmath80 , @xmath81 , _ etc . _ , where all indices are defined modulo @xmath14 . in this way , the color decomposition ( [ treegluecolor ] ) disentangles the kinematic complexity of the full amplitude @xmath82 . similarly , tree amplitudes with two external quarks and @xmath83 gluons can be reduced to single strings of @xmath63 matrices , ^_n(q_1,g_3, ,g_n-1,|q_n ) & = & g^n-2 -1.3 mm _ s_n-2 -1.3 mm ( t^a_(2)t^a_(n-1))_i_1^ _ n + & & 1.3 cm a_n^(1_q,(2), ,(n-1),n_|q ) , [ treequarkgluecolor ] where we have omitted the helicity labels , and numbers without subscripts in the argument of @xmath79 refer to gluons . in this case there are @xmath84 terms , corresponding to all possible gluon orderings between the quarks . color decompositions for amplitudes containing additional external quark pairs have also been described @xcite . we note that the partial amplitudes appearing in could also be used to describe the scattering of two fermions with different color quantum numbers , and @xmath83 gluons . for example , if the fermions are gluinos in the adjoint representation , then the color decomposition has the form of , but the partial amplitudes , with two external fermions , are of the type given in . this is easy to see if the two fermions are color - adjacent ; essentially all one needs to do to go between the two cases is remove one color line running between the two gluinos . however , the other cyclic orderings can also be obtained from @xmath85 , using the kleiss - kuijf relations discussed in the next subsection . this property illustrates the universality of the color - ordered primitive amplitudes alluded to in the introduction . many articles in this issue consider loop - level amplitudes in which all of the external states are gluons in the adjoint representation . the general color decomposition here is similar to , except that multiple color traces are now possible . roughly speaking , a loop of gluons carries a fundamental and an anti - fundamental index around the loop with it , and an external gluon can attach to either index . the number of traces at @xmath39 loops is equal to @xmath86 . at one loop , the full color decomposition for @xmath14 gluons is @xcite -24 mm a^_n(\{k_i , h_i , a_i } ) & = & g^n . [ loopgluecolor ] here @xmath87 are the partial amplitudes , @xmath74 and @xmath88 are the subsets of @xmath89 that leave the corresponding single and double trace structures invariant , and @xmath90 is the greatest integer less than or equal to @xmath91 . the formula is more complicated than at tree level , but only by the need to keep track of more distinct trace structures and their various symmetries . if there are @xmath92 flavors of quarks in the loop , it is easy to see that they only contribute to the single - trace coefficient @xmath93 in , and with a weight @xmath94 relative to the adjoint gluons . ( similar color decompositions are available for one - loop amplitudes with an external quark pair @xcite . ) when one constructs the color - summed cross section , as is usually required for qcd applications , the contribution of the double - trace coefficients , @xmath87 for @xmath95 , is suppressed by a power of @xmath96 with respect to that of @xmath93 . ( it also turns out that the @xmath87 are not really independent , but can be computed as a sum over permutations of the @xmath93 @xcite . ) thus simplifies a lot in the large-@xmath12 limit . the factor of @xmath97 simply comes from those terms in which all external gluons attach to the same fundamental index line , leaving the trace of the identity matrix for the untouched line . correspondingly , if we only want the leading terms in the large-@xmath12 limit at @xmath39 loops , we can write the compact color decomposition , & & -1.5 cm a^_n(\{k_i , h_i , a_i})|_leadingcolor + & & -0.5 cm = g^n-2 ( g^2 n_c)^l _ s_n / z_n ( t^a_(1)t^a_(n ) ) a_n^(l)((1^h_1), ,(n^h_n ) ) , [ lloopleadingcolor ] where we have dropped the `` ; 1 '' index on the leading - color partial amplitude . the t hooft coupling @xmath10 emerges naturally in this limit . the articles in this issue about multi - loop amplitudes in planar @xmath0 sym are generally concerned with the @xmath98 in . because each loop integration typically brings a factor of @xmath99 ( or @xmath100 when using dimensional regularization in @xmath22 ) , in some cases the precise normalizations of the @xmath98 will differ by this factor , as well as possibly other conventional factors . there is another type of color decomposition that is actually more useful than the above trace - based decomposition for addressing certain issues , and particularly for working beyond the large-@xmath12 approximation . we could call this approach the @xmath101-based decomposition , because it goes back to the original color factors built out of the structure constants @xmath59 . ( now we assume that all states are in the adjoint representation . ) the diagrammatic representation of a general @xmath101-based color factor at tree level has the structure of a cubic tree graph , with vertices given by @xmath102 s and propagators given by @xmath62 s . however , these color factors are not all independent , due to the color jacobi identity . this identity can be written in different ways . one way , ^dae ^bce - ^dbe ^ace = ^abe ^cde , [ colorjacobiidentity ] which is also depicted in , corresponds to the fact that the structure constants are also the su@xmath8 generators in the adjoint representation , @xmath103 , so that their commutator gives @xmath104 contracted with @xmath105 . 4.0 truein at tree level , one can use the identity ( [ colorjacobiidentity ] ) repeatedly to transform all @xmath101-based color factors into a `` multi - peripheral '' form in which two selected gluons , say 1 and @xmath14 , are always at the end of a long chain of structure constants , and the other @xmath83 gluons are emitted from along the ladder @xcite , -20 mm a_n^(\{a_i } ) & = & g^n-2 _ s_n-2 ^a_1 a_(2 ) x_1 ^x_1 a_(3 ) x_2 ^x_n-3 a_(n-1 ) a_n + & & a_n^(1,(2), ,(n-1),n ) + & = & g^n-2 _ s_n-2 ( f^a_(2 ) f^a_(n-1 ) ) _ a_1 a_n a_n^(1,(2), ,(n-1),n ) . [ gluondecompnew ] notice that this representation is identical in form to the decomposition for two quarks and @xmath83 gluons in , except for the representation used for the su@xmath8 generator matrices . although correspond to the cases of fundamental and adjoint representations , respectively , the same type of decomposition clearly holds for two external matter fields in an arbitrary su@xmath8 representation . the fact that the coefficients of the @xmath101-based decomposition ( [ gluondecompnew ] ) are identical to the color - ordered partial amplitudes @xmath79 appearing in the trace - based decomposition can be demonstrated by contracting both representations with @xmath29 and keeping only the leading terms at large @xmath12 @xcite . note that there are only @xmath84 terms in the @xmath101-based color decomposition , in contrast to the @xmath75 terms in the trace - based decomposition ( [ treegluecolor ] ) . therefore there are identities between the @xmath79 , which are group - theoretical in nature generalizations of certain @xmath106 decoupling identities @xcite . these identities can be used to put any two legs next to each other , for example legs 1 and @xmath14 : a_n^(1,\{},n,\ { } ) = ( -1)^n _ _ \{}\{^t } a_n^(1,(\{}\{^t}),n ) , [ kkequation ] where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are two sets of external gluons , whose union is @xmath109 . also , @xmath110 is the number of elements in the set @xmath108 , the set @xmath111 is @xmath108 with the ordering reversed , and @xmath112 is the set of ordered permutations , or `` mergings '' , of the two sets @xmath107 and @xmath111 that preserve the ordering of the @xmath113 within @xmath107 and of the @xmath114 within @xmath111 , while allowing for all possible relative orderings of the @xmath113 with respect to the @xmath114 . these relations are known as the kleiss - kuijf relations @xcite . they can be derived from by expanding out the @xmath102 factors using , identifying the coefficients of the trace structures , and comparing them with the original trace - based decomposition ( [ treegluecolor ] ) @xcite . in fact , it has been realized recently that there are not even @xmath84 independent color - ordered amplitudes @xmath79 , but only @xmath115 @xcite , as reviewed in this issue by carrasco and johansson @xcite . the additional linear relations between @xmath79 s are not purely group - theoretical in nature , but also involve kinematical factors . they allow one to put any _ three _ external gluon legs next to each other . for example , for legs 1 , 2 and @xmath14 , the identities take the form , -1.0 cm a_n^((1),(2), ,(n ) ) = _ s_n-3 k^ ( ) _ a_n^(1,2,(3), ,(n-1),n ) , [ bcj3 ] where @xmath116 and @xmath117 are permutations and @xmath118 are kinematic - dependent ( but not state - dependent ) coefficients @xcite . these relations were first proved using open string theory @xcite , using a contour deformation argument @xcite similar to that used in deriving the klt relations @xcite between gravity and gauge theory amplitudes . they have also been proven directly in field theory , using a recursive argument @xcite . although expresses the consequences of certain color - kinematic identities in the trace basis , the identities themselves are more naturally stated in an @xmath101-based approach . for this purpose it is useful to _ not _ transform the @xmath101-based color factors into multi - peripheral form , but leave the color decomposition free , in terms of the set of all cubic graphs @xmath119 , writing _ n^= g^n-2 _ i_3 . [ bcjtreerep ] the color factors @xmath120 are products of structure constants for each vertex @xmath121 of the @xmath49 graph , contracted together along the propagators , @xmath122 . the factors of @xmath123 are scalar propagators , one for each internal line in the graph , while the @xmath124 are kinematical numerator factors . consider a triplet of graphs in @xmath119 , which are identical except for a region from which four lines emanate . within this region they differ according to the three ways of joining four legs with two cubic vertices , shown in . call the three graphs @xmath125 , @xmath126 and @xmath127 , and let the color factors @xmath128 be normalized ( signed ) so that they obey the jacobi identity ( [ colorjacobiidentity ] ) as @xmath129 . then the statement of color - kinematic duality @xcite is that the associated numerator factors should be related by @xmath130 , for every such triplet of graphs . a simple and intuitive argument for these relations has been provided based on the heterotic string @xcite . the existence of such a representation with _ @xmath124 ( _ i.e. _ polynomials in the momenta ) has been checked in various examples , not only at tree level , but also through three loops for @xmath0 sym amplitudes @xcite . as reviewed here by carrasco and johansson @xcite , the existence of a representation for gauge theory amplitudes satisfying @xmath130 for each triplet of jacobi - related cubic graphs has important implications . large classes of numerator factors are related to each other , and gravitational amplitudes are easily constructed from gauge theory ones . now that we have described two different ways to organize the color quantum numbers for scattering amplitudes , let us turn to kinematical issues , including convenient choices of external states and kinematical variables . in qcd , the helicities of massless quarks are conserved by their chirality - preserving interactions with gluons . hence it is natural to use a helicity basis for the quark amplitudes . in four - component notation , the spinors for the external states are taken to be @xmath131 for a quark with momentum @xmath132 , and @xmath133 for an anti - quark . however , in the massless limit these spinors can be chosen to be equal to each other , @xmath134 , and we can use two - component weyl spinors as well . we will see that helicity amplitudes for external gluons can be built from the same objects . we want to consider amplitudes with @xmath14 different momenta @xmath48 , @xmath69 , and to do so in a way that respects crossing symmetry . thus we take all the momenta to be outgoing , so that momentum conservation reads @xmath135 . in a realistic process with some incoming particles , the physical momentum for each of the incoming particles is simply the _ negative _ of the corresponding @xmath48 . also , the physical helicity @xmath136 is the negative of the one by which we label the amplitude . ( the spin @xmath137 does not reverse under crossing , but @xmath138 does . ) the two - component spinor for the @xmath49 state , if it is an outgoing fermion with helicity @xmath139 , has several notations @xcite : ( _ i ) _ & & |i^+ |k_i^+ [ u_+(k_i ) ] _ = [ v_-(k_i ) ] _ , + ( _ i ) _ & & |i^- |k_i^- [ u_-(k_i ) ] _ = [ v_+(k_i ) ] _ . similarly , the conjugate spinors are ( _ i)^ & & i^+| k_i^+| [ ] ^= [ ] ^ , + ( _ i)^ & & i^-| k_i^-| [ ] ^ = [ ] ^. two - component indices are raised and lowered with the two - dimensional antisymmetric tensors @xmath140 , @xmath141 , _ etc . _ the spinor inner products come from contracting spinors for different momenta with these tensors , .l & = & ^ ( _ j)_(_l ) _ = j^- | l^+ = u_+(k_l ) , [ spadef ] + .l & = & ^ ( _ j ) _ _ = j^+ | l^- = u_-(k_l ) . [ spbdef ] spinor products are antisymmetric under exchange of labels , @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 . lorentz vectors can be written as bi - spinors , or @xmath145 matrices , by contracting them with the pauli matrices . a massless vector written in this way factorizes into the product of two massless spinors , as ( _ i ) _ k_i^ ( _ ) _ = u_+(k_i ) = ( _ i)_(_i ) _ . [ masslesskfact ] this factorization plays a role in the bcfw complex - momentum shift , which is best described in terms of the @xmath44 and @xmath146 variables @xcite , as is done elsewhere in this issue @xcite . amplitudes with external gluons can also be described in terms of the @xmath147 and @xmath148 variables , thanks to the spinor - helicity formalism @xcite . the polarization vector @xmath149 for an outgoing massless vector particle with momentum @xmath132 and helicity @xmath150 , is required to be transverse to @xmath132 , @xmath151 . in the spinor - helicity formalism , @xmath152 is also chosen to be transverse to another massless momentum @xmath153 , called the _ reference momentum _ ( which should not be parallel to @xmath132 but is otherwise arbitrary ) . note that @xmath132 and @xmath153 span a two - dimensional subspace of four - dimensional space - time . because @xmath154 , the two orthogonal directions to this subspace are spanned by @xmath155 and @xmath156 . the spinor - helicity polarization vectors live in this subspace ; indeed , they are proportional to these two vectors , and are normalized by the condition that @xmath157 : _ ^(k , q ) = . [ spinorheldef ] as a bi - spinor , @xmath158 is given by -1 cm [ ^+(k_i , q_i ) ] _ = , _ = - . [ spinorheldef2 ] if each @xmath159 is chosen to be another momentum in the process , say @xmath160 , then it is clear from the general form of the feynman rules ( using also ) that the full amplitude can be built entirely out of the spinor products @xmath161 and @xmath162 , for @xmath163 . what are the basic properties of the spinor products which make them so convenient variables for helicity amplitudes ? first of all , for real momenta , the two types of spinor products are complex conjugates of each other , @xmath164 . also , for either real or complex momenta they `` square '' to give the ordinary dot products of momenta , .j.l = = 2 k_jk_l = s_jl . [ sfromspinors ] ( is written in the convention usually used in the qcd literature , but the reader should be aware that another convention exists , in which the sign of @xmath162 is reversed so that @xmath165 . ) for real momenta , the conjugation property and imply that .l = e^i_jl , .l = e^-i_jl , [ realmomsqrt ] where @xmath166 is a phase this phase shifts as @xmath160 and @xmath167 are rotated in azimuthal angle around the axis corresponding to their sum , @xmath168 . one way of seeing the utility of the spinor products for helicity amplitudes is to examine the limits in which two particles become collinear , @xmath169 . ( a ) shows that the typical behavior of amplitudes in a massless scalar field theory is @xmath170 , coming just from the scalar propagator . however , in massless gauge theory , there are numerator factors in the feynman diagrams which lessen this divergence . more physically , the factorization in the collinear limit should be onto a physical gluon state with helicity @xmath171 . however , the sum of the two external helicities must be @xmath172 or 0 . therefore there is at least a @xmath171 mismatch of the spin angular momentum along the @xmath173 axis , as illustrated in ( b ) . the spin angular - momentum mismatch requires some orbital angular momentum , which in turn causes a suppression of the magnitude of the amplitude , from @xmath174 to @xmath175 . it also dictates a phase shift under azimuthal rotation of @xmath160 and @xmath167 about the @xmath173 axis . both of these properties are captured by the spinor products , making them ideal for describing helicity amplitudes . 4.5 truein the simplest nonvanishing tree - level gluon amplitudes are the parke - taylor or mhv amplitudes @xcite , a_n^(1^+, ,l^-, ,m^-, ,n^+ ) = i .m^4 1.22.3.1 . [ mhvpt ] here exactly two gluons , @xmath176 and @xmath177 , have negative helicity , and the remaining @xmath83 gluons have positive helicity . the amplitudes with zero or one negative gluon helicity vanish by supersymmetry ward identities @xcite . the only denominator factors in these amplitudes are the spinor products for color - adjacent pairs of momenta , @xmath178 . they capture such universal collinear limits @xcite as , & & -1 cm a_n^(1^+, ,l^-, ,m^-, ,(n-1)^+,n^+)|_n-1n [ collimitexample ] + & ~ & a_n-1^(1^+, ,l^-, ,m^-, ,p^+ ) , where legs @xmath179 and @xmath14 are becoming parallel , with @xmath180 , @xmath181 and @xmath182 . another way to see why the spinor products are so useful is to consider the special case @xmath183 for the mhv amplitudes , a_3^(1 ^ -,2 ^ -,3^+ ) = i .2 ^ 4 1.22.33.1 . [ mmp ] one might think that the scattering of three massless particles is singular , because all of the @xmath184 vanish since they are equal to the squared momentum of the remaining particle . indeed , for real momenta , implies that all the spinor products vanish too , and there is no way to build a nonvanishing and nonsingular amplitude . however , for complex momenta , the complex - conjugation relation @xmath164 no longer holds , and it is possible for half the spinor products to be nonvanishing , while the other half vanish . specifically , we can choose the three negative - helicity two - component spinors to be proportional @xcite , _ 1^ _ 2^ _ 3 ^ . [ spbvanish ] then according to we have @xmath185 . however , the other three spinor products , @xmath186 , @xmath187 and @xmath188 , are allowed to be nonzero . ( this is consistent with the vanishing of , which still holds for complex momenta . ) for this choice of complex kinematics , the mhv three - point amplitude ( [ mmp ] ) is nonvanishing and nonsingular , while the conjugate `` @xmath189 '' amplitude , a_3^(1^+,2^+,3 ^ - ) = -i 1.2 ^ 41.22.33.1 , [ ppm ] vanishes . in contrast , for the conjugate kinematics with _ 1^ _ 2^ _ 3 ^ , [ spavanish ] vanishes while is nonvanishing and nonsingular . the three - point amplitudes ( [ mmp ] ) and ( [ ppm ] ) , as well as related amplitudes with two matter particles and one gluon , are very important in massless gauge theory . the bcfw relations build all tree - level scattering amplitudes recursively from them , using factorization onto multi - particle poles , as well as onto complex - momentum versions of the collinear poles shown in . of course feynman diagrams can also be used to build amplitudes from three- and four - point vertices . however , feynman vertices are typically evaluated with off - shell lines emanating from them , which makes them gauge - dependent . in contrast , are on shell , albeit for complex momenta , and therefore they are fully gauge invariant . in the recursive construction of @xmath14-gluon amplitudes , the four - gluon vertex is never needed , essentially because it is related to the three - vertex by gauge transformations . another reason why the three - point amplitudes are important is for building up loop amplitudes through generalized unitarity , as reviewed in this issue by ita @xcite and britto @xcite at one loop , and by bern and huang @xcite and carrasco and johansson @xcite at the multi - loop level . typically , generalized unitarity cuts place many propagators on shell , so they very often contain at least one three - point tree amplitude . finally , the relations between gravity and gauge theory tree amplitudes are the simplest of all for the three - point case , where they can be written as an exact square , m_3^(1,2,3 ) = [ a_3^(1,2,3 ) ] ^2 , [ klt3 ] ignoring overall coupling - constant factors . for planar ( large @xmath12 ) gauge theory amplitudes which includes all tree - level amplitudes new sets of kinematic variables have proved very useful for identifying new structures and symmetries . because the external legs have a definite cyclic order in the planar case , they carve the plane into sectors . to each such sector , one can assign a vertex @xmath190 for a dual graph , as shown in ( a ) . lines connecting vertices of the dual graph cross lines of the original graph . the latter lines carry momenta . differences between @xmath191 s are computed according to the net momentum flowing through the lines of the original graph . thus in ( a ) , adjacent sectors are separated by @xmath192 , or more generally , x_i , j^x_i^- x_j^= k_j^+ k_j+1^+ + k_i-1^. [ sectorvariable ] the @xmath191 are often called _ dual coordinates _ ( or sometimes region or sector variables ) , but they are essentially momenta , not coordinates . in a planar loop graph we can assign additional @xmath191 variables to the faces inside each loop , corresponding to the independent loop momenta . ( b ) shows a two - loop example . here the thick lines of the dual graph that are shown each cross ( and therefore correspond to ) one propagator of the planar double box integral . 4.5 truein more precisely , differences of the @xmath191 are momenta . the @xmath191 themselves are not constrained by momentum conservation . they are constrained by on - shell conditions , @xmath193 . however , unlike momenta , it is possible to invert the @xmath191 s , according to x_i^ , x_i , j^2 . [ dualinversion ] remarkably , this inversion is a symmetry of both integrands and amplitudes in planar @xmath0 sym . the integrands are functions of the combinations @xmath194 , which are manifestly invariant under lorentz transformations and translations of the @xmath191 s . ( translation invariance is guaranteed simply because the amplitude depends on momenta , which are differences of @xmath191 s . ) therefore the inversion ( [ dualinversion ] ) combines with poincar invariance to generate the conformal group so(4,2 ) . this group acts on the dual variables @xmath191 , not on space - time coordinates ; hence the symmetry is referred to as dual conformal invariance . at the loop level , dual conformal invariance can be spoiled by the infrared regulator needed for on - shell amplitudes . a loop - integration measure in four dimensions , @xmath195 , transforms under an inversion ( [ dualinversion ] ) as , @xmath196 . in @xmath197 this factor precisely cancels terms from inverting the associated propagators in graphs such as the one in ( b ) . however , in dimensional regularization , we have @xmath198 , and the invariance is lost due to extra factors in the transformation of the loop integration measure . as discussed in detail in this issue by henn @xcite , for planar @xmath0 sym it is possible to retain dual conformal invariance at the loop level by using instead a higgs regulator @xcite , which generates particle masses that can also be thought of as extra components of the @xmath190 . although amplitude computations with the higgs regulator have not been pushed quite as far yet as in dimensional regularization , there are certain advantages to this approach . for example , in dimensional regularization , terms in lower - loop amplitudes that vanish as @xmath199 often have to be computed , because they can multiply pole terms , @xmath200 , in other amplitudes ( or in the squares of amplitudes needed to construct differential cross sections ) . the article by schabinger in this issue discusses such @xmath201 contributions @xcite . in contrast , with the higgs regulator , the singularities have the form of powers of logarithms , @xmath202 , and power - suppressed terms of the form @xmath203 can always be dropped , because they vanish faster than any power of a logarithm . how constraining is dual conformal symmetry ? in general it can only determine amplitudes up to arbitrary functions of the cross - ratios , u_ijkl , [ genu ] because these variables are invariant under the inversion ( [ dualinversion ] ) . however , the on - shell constraints @xmath204 imply that there are no non - trivial cross ratios for four- and five - particle scattering . at the six - point level there are three non - trivial cross ratios , utilizing the allowed @xmath205 and @xmath206 kinematic invariants : [ defu ] -1.8 cm u_1 = = , u_2 = = , u_3 = = . as mentioned earlier , the remainder function @xmath207 characterizing the two - loop mhv six - point amplitude in planar @xmath0 sym is a function of these three variables , and this function is now known analytically in terms of polylogarithms @xcite . in planar @xmath0 sym , dual conformal invariance combines with dual @xmath0 supersymmetry to generate dual superconformal symmetry @xcite . it is natural to consider super - amplitudes , which package sets of amplitudes together by using an @xmath0 on - shell superfield @xcite , [ super - wave ] -2.3 cm ( ) = g^+ + ^a g_a + ^a ^b _ ab + ^a^b^c _ abcd |g^d + ^a^b^c ^d _ abcd g^- . here @xmath208 are the @xmath209 helicity gluons , @xmath210 and @xmath211 the four flavors of @xmath212 helicity gluinos , and @xmath213 the six real @xmath214 helicity scalar states . integrations over the grassmann variables @xmath21 , @xmath215 , can be used to pick off the desired component amplitudes from the super - amplitudes , defined by [ super - amplitude ] a_n(_i ) a ( _ 1(_1 ) , , _ just as the @xmath191 bosonic variables automatically satisfy momentum conservation , @xmath216 , one can construct their superpartners @xmath217 , whose differences satisfy _ i^a - _ i+1^a = _ i^_i^a , [ dualsuper ] for @xmath69 . super - momentum conservation constitutes eight constraints : q^a _ i=1^n _ i^_i^a = 0 . [ supercons ] like ordinary momentum conservation , it is satisfied by virtue of the periodicity of the dual coordinates , @xmath218 , @xmath219 . the mhv super - amplitude generalizing is _ n^,mhv = i = i . [ mhvsuper ] it transforms covariantly under dual superconformal transformations @xcite which extend so(4,2 ) to the superalgebra psu(2,2@xmath2204 ) . furthermore , the solutions to the bcfw super - recursion relation for amplitudes with more negative helicities ( nmhv , nnmhv , _ etc . _ ) are given by the product of this super - amplitude with collections of dual superconformal invariants , generically denoted by @xmath221 @xcite . superconformal and dual superconformal symmetry are separate symmetries , which partly overlap . they close into a very large symmetry group called the yangian @xcite , as discussed in this issue by bargheer , beisert and loebbert @xcite and by drummond @xcite . the generic generator of the yangian is not local in the sense of being a sum of single - particle terms ( like @xmath132 and @xmath153 ) ; rather it is a sum of multi - particle operators . ( for the dual superconformal generators , the nonlocality is mild ; only the sum of two - particle operators appears . ) there are certain `` anomalies '' in the action of the yangian on amplitudes . at tree level , the anomalies only act at the boundary of the @xmath14-particle phase space , where two particles become collinear , as in @xcite . at loop - level they act in the full phase - space , due to singularities in the loop integration @xcite . however , it is possible to deform either the symmetry algebra or the representation in a suitable way so as to preserve the invariance @xcite . it will be very interesting to see whether the constraints from the yangian are sufficient to determine multi - loop amplitudes directly , without having to pass through the computation of loop integrals . another very recent development , in the same vein of using symmetries or dynamical principles to bypass standard loop ( or wilson line ) integrals , concerns polygonal wilson loops . one considers an operator - product - like expansion for the wilson loop , associated with a limit in which multiple momenta become collinear @xcite . this expansion can be carried out at both weak and strong coupling . at weak coupling it has been used to compute the discontinuity of the integrated two - loop amplitude , directly in terms of one - loop quantities @xcite . there has been a remarkable array of breakthroughs in our understanding of scattering amplitudes over the past few years , as described in the review articles in this special issue of journal of physics a. this article has represented an overview of many of these developments , as well as providing some basic material as an introduction to the remaining contributions . however , it certainly did not do justice to all of the directions being pursued currently . one of the other remarkable features of this field has been the interplay and cross - fertilization between formal developments and phenomenology . the parke - taylor tree amplitudes were found in the course of trying to understand patterns arising in the structure of five- and six - gluon tree - level amplitudes . a similar analysis of the structure of the five - gluon amplitude at one loop in qcd led to the development of the unitarity method , which has been indispensable for computing high - loop - order amplitudes in maximally supersymmetric gauge theory and gravity , but which has also produced new nlo qcd results for colliders @xcite . a `` radiation zero '' found over thirty years ago in the electroweak process @xmath222 @xcite was studied for a general gauge theory soon thereafter @xcite ; the relations found there were recognized much later as the four - point versions of a more general color - kinematics duality @xcite . wilson loops , used to characterize the effects of soft gluons in qcd , also turned out to be in exact correspondence to full mhv amplitudes in planar @xmath0 super - yang - mills theory . this special issue should be of interest , not only to experienced practitioners in the field , but also to newcomers who want to get started . as the history of the field shows , new developments can and will come from totally unanticipated angles . many of the new ideas in the future may well come to physicists whose interest in the remarkable aspects of scattering amplitudes was sparked , at least in part , by reading the articles assembled in this special issue . * acknowledgments * i am grateful to radu roiban , mark spradlin and anastasia volovich for inviting me to contribute this introductory article , and i thank radu roiban also for valuable comments on the manuscript . this work was supported by the us department of energy under contract de ac0276sf00515 . the figures were generated using jaxodraw @xcite , based on axodraw @xcite . 10 j. m. maldacena , adv . phys . * 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) [ int . j. theor . phys . * 38 * , 1113 ( 1999 ) ] [ hep - th/9711200 ] ; + s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , phys . b * 428 * , 105 ( 1998 ) [ hep - th/9802109 ] ; + o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , phys . rept . * 323 * , 183 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/9905111 ] . l. f. alday and j. m. maldacena , jhep * 0706 * , 064 ( 2007 ) [ 0705.0303 [ hep - th ] ] . s. j. parke and t. r. taylor , phys . lett . * 56 * , 2459 ( 1986 ) . v. p. nair , phys . b * 214 * , 215 ( 1988 ) . m. l. mangano and s. j. parke , phys . * 200 * , 301 ( 1991 ) [ hep - th/0509223 ] . m. t. grisaru , h. n. pendleton and p. van nieuwenhuizen , phys . d * 15 * , 996 ( 1977 ) . m. t. grisaru and h. n. pendleton , nucl . b * 124 * , 81 ( 1977 ) . s. j. parke and t. r. taylor , phys . b * 157 * , 81 ( 1985 ) [ erratum - ibid . * 174b * , 465 ( 1986 ) ] ; + z. kunszt , nucl . phys . b * 271 * , 333 ( 1986 ) . h. elvang , d. z. freedman and m. kiermaier , jhep * 1010 * , 103 ( 2010 ) [ 0911.3169 [ hep - th ] ] . h. elvang , d. z. freedman and m. kiermaier , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1012.3401 [ hep - th ] ] . e. witten , commun . phys . * 252 * , 189 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0312171 ] . r. penrose , j. math . * 8 * , 345 ( 1967 ) . f. cachazo , p. svrek and e. witten , jhep 0409:006 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0403047 ] . a. brandhuber , b. spence and g. travaglini , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1103.3477 [ hep - th ] ] . t. adamo , m. bullimore , l. mason and d. skinner , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1104.2890 [ hep - th ] ] . r. britto , f. cachazo , b. feng and e. witten , phys . lett . * 94 * , 181602 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0501052 ] . r. britto , f. cachazo and b. feng , nucl . b * 715 * , 499 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0412308 ] . n. arkani - hamed , f. cachazo and j. kaplan , jhep * 1009 * , 016 ( 2010 ) [ 0808.1446 [ hep - th ] ] . a. brandhuber , p. heslop and g. travaglini , phys . d * 78 * , 125005 ( 2008 ) [ 0807.4097 [ hep - th ] ] . j. m. drummond and j. m. henn , jhep * 0904 * , 018 ( 2009 ) [ 0808.2475 [ hep - th ] ] . j. drummond , to appear in j. phys . a. z. bern , l. j. dixon , d. c. dunbar and d. a. kosower , nucl . b * 425 * , 217 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9403226 ] . z. bern , l. j. dixon , d. c. dunbar and d. a. kosower , nucl . b * 435 * , 59 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9409265 ] . r. britto , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1012.4493 [ hep - th ] ] . z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , nucl . b * 513 * , 3 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9708239 ] . r. britto , f. cachazo and b. feng , nucl . b * 725 * , 275 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0412103 ] . n. e. j. bjerrum - bohr and p. vanhove , jhep * 0804 * , 065 ( 2008 ) [ 0802.0868 [ hep - th ] ] ; jhep * 0810 * , 006 ( 2008 ) [ 0805.3682 [ hep - th ] ] ; fortsch . phys . * 56 * , 824 ( 2008 ) [ 0806.1726 [ hep - th ] ] . z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , jhep * 0001 * , 027 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0001001 ] ; + z. bern , a. de freitas and l. j. dixon , jhep * 0203 * , 018 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0201161 ] . z. bern and y .- t . huang , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1103.1869 [ hep - th ] ] . g. ossola , c. g. papadopoulos and r. pittau , nucl . b * 763 * , 147 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0609007 ] ; jhep * 0803 * , 042 ( 2008 ) [ 0711.3596 [ hep - ph ] ] . r. k. ellis , w. t. giele and z. kunszt , jhep * 0803 * , 003 ( 2008 ) [ 0708.2398 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. f. berger _ _ , phys . d * 78 * , 036003 ( 2008 ) [ 0803.4180 [ hep - ph ] ] . w. siegel , phys . lett . b * 84 * , 193 ( 1979 ) ; + d. m. capper , d. r. t. jones and p. van nieuwenhuizen , nucl . b * 167 * , 479 ( 1980 ) ; + l. v. avdeev and a. a. vladimirov , nucl . b * 219 * , 262 ( 1983 ) . z. bern and d. a. kosower , nucl . b * 379 * , 451 ( 1992 ) ; + z. bern , a. de freitas , l. dixon and h. l. wong , phys . rev . d * 66 * , 085002 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0202271 ] . r. akhoury , phys . d * 19 * , 1250 ( 1979 ) ; + a. h. mueller , phys . d * 20 * , 2037 ( 1979 ) ; + j. c. collins , phys . d * 22 * , 1478 ( 1980 ) ; in _ perturbative qcd _ , ed . a. h. mueller , advanced series on directions in high energy physics , vol . 5 ( world scientific , singapore , 1989 ) [ hep - ph/0312336 ] ; + a. sen , phys . rev . d * 24 * , 3281 ( 1981 ) ; phys . d * 28 * , 860 ( 1983 ) . l. magnea and g. sterman , phys . d * 42 * , 4222 ( 1990 ) . s. catani , phys . b * 427 * , 161 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9802439 ] . g. sterman and m. e. tejeda - yeomans , phys . b * 552 * , 48 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0210130 ] . g. p. korchemsky , mod . lett . a * 4 * , 1257 ( 1989 ) ; + g. p. korchemsky and g. marchesini , nucl . b * 406 * , 225 ( 1993 ) [ hep - ph/9210281 ] . n. beisert , b. eden and m. staudacher , j. stat . mech . * 0701 * , p01021 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0610251 ] . z. bern , l. j. dixon and v. a. smirnov , phys . d * 72 * , 085001 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0505205 ] . j. bartels , l. n. lipatov and a. sabio vera , phys . d * 80 * , 045002 ( 2009 ) [ 0802.2065 [ hep - th ] ] ; eur . j. c * 65 * , 587 ( 2010 ) [ 0807.0894 [ hep - th ] ] . j. bartels , l. n. lipatov and a. prygarin , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1104.0816 [ hep - th ] ] . l. f. alday , j. m. henn , j. plefka and t. schuster , jhep * 1001 * , 077 ( 2010 ) [ 0908.0684 [ hep - th ] ] . j. m. henn , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1103.1016 [ hep - th ] ] . r. k. ellis , w. t. giele , z. kunszt and k. melnikov , nucl . b * 822 * , 270 ( 2009 ) [ 0806.3467 [ hep - ph ] ] . s. lal and s. raju , phys . d * 81 * , 105002 ( 2010 ) [ 0910.0930 [ hep - th ] ] . a. v. kotikov , l. n. lipatov , a. i. onishchenko and v. n. velizhanin , phys . b * 595 * , 521 ( 2004 ) [ erratum - ibid . b * 632 * , 754 ( 2006 ) ] [ hep - th/0404092 ] . z. bern , m. czakon , l. j. dixon , d. a. kosower and v. a. smirnov , phys . d * 75 * , 085010 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0610248 ] . s. g. naculich , h. nastase and h. j. schnitzer , jhep * 0811 * , 018 ( 2008 ) [ 0809.0376 [ hep - th ] ] . n. arkani - hamed , j. l. bourjaily , f. cachazo , s. caron - huot and j. trnka , jhep * 1101 * , 041 ( 2011 ) [ 1008.2958 [ hep - th ] ] . r. h. boels , jhep * 1011 * , 113 ( 2010 ) [ 1008.3101 [ hep - th ] ] . j. m. drummond , j. henn , g. p. korchemsky and e. sokatchev , nucl . b * 826 * , 337 ( 2010 ) [ 0712.1223 [ hep - th ] ] . c. anastasiou , z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , phys . lett . * 91 * , 251602 ( 2003 ) [ hep - th/0309040 ] . j. m. drummond , j. henn , g. p. korchemsky and e. sokatchev , nucl . b * 815 * , 142 ( 2009 ) [ 0803.1466 [ hep - th ] ] ; + z. bern , l. j. dixon , d. a. kosower , r. roiban , m. spradlin , c. vergu and a. volovich , phys . d * 78 * , 045007 ( 2008 ) [ 0803.1465 [ hep - th ] ] . i. bena , j. polchinski and r. roiban , phys . d * 69 * , 046002 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0305116 ] . l. f. alday , d. gaiotto and j. maldacena , 0911.4708 [ hep - th ] ; + l. f. alday , j. maldacena , a. sever and p. vieira , j. phys . a * 43 * , 485401 ( 2010 ) [ 1002.2459 [ hep - th ] ] . j. m. drummond , g. p. korchemsky and e. sokatchev , nucl . b * 795 * , 385 ( 2008 ) [ 0707.0243 [ hep - th ] ] ; + a. brandhuber , p. heslop and g. travaglini , nucl . b * 794 * , 231 ( 2008 ) [ 0707.1153 [ hep - th ] ] ; + j. m. drummond , j. henn , g. p. korchemsky and e. sokatchev , nucl . b * 795 * , 52 ( 2008 ) [ 0709.2368 [ hep - th ] ] . l. f. alday , b. eden , g. p. korchemsky , j. maldacena and e. sokatchev , 1007.3243 [ hep - th ] ; + b. eden , g. p. korchemsky and e. sokatchev , 1007.3246 [ hep - th ] ; + l. j. mason and d. skinner , jhep * 1012 * , 018 ( 2010 ) [ 1009.2225 [ hep - th ] ] ; + s. caron - huot , 1010.1167 [ hep - th ] ; + a. v. belitsky , g. p. korchemsky and e. sokatchev , 1103.3008 [ hep - th ] . v. del duca , c. duhr and v. a. smirnov , jhep * 1003 * , 099 ( 2010 ) [ 0911.5332 [ hep - ph ] ] ; jhep * 1005 * , 084 ( 2010 ) [ 1003.1702 [ hep - th ] ] . a. b. goncharov , m. spradlin , c. vergu and a. volovich , phys . lett . * 105 * , 151605 ( 2010 ) [ 1006.5703 [ hep - th ] ] . v. del duca , c. duhr and v. a. smirnov , jhep * 1009 * , 015 ( 2010 ) [ 1006.4127 [ hep - th ] ] ; + p. heslop and v. v. khoze , jhep * 1011 * , 035 ( 2010 ) [ 1007.1805 [ hep - th ] ] . h. kawai , d. c. lewellen and s .- h . h. tye , nucl . b * 269 * , 1 ( 1986 ) . z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco and h. johansson , phys . d * 78 * , 085011 ( 2008 ) [ 0805.3993 [ hep - ph ] ] . z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco and h. johansson , phys . * 105 * , 061602 ( 2010 ) [ 1004.0476 [ hep - th ] ] . l. j. dixon , in _ qcd & beyond : proceedings of tasi 95 _ , ed . d. e. soper ( world scientific , 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9601359 ] . p. cvitanovi , _ group theory _ ( nordita , 1984 ) . f. a. berends and w. giele , nucl . b * 294 * , 700 ( 1987 ) ; + m. l. mangano , s. j. parke and z. xu , nucl . phys . b * 298 * , 653 ( 1988 ) ; + m. l. mangano , nucl . b * 309 * , 461 ( 1988 ) . g. t hooft , nucl . b * 72 * , 461 ( 1974 ) ; nucl . b * 75 * , 461 ( 1974 ) . z. bern and d. a. kosower , nucl . b * 362 * , 389 ( 1991 ) . z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , nucl . b * 437 * , 259 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9409393 ] . v. del duca , a. frizzo and f. maltoni , nucl . b * 568 * , 211 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9909464 ] . v. del duca , l. j. dixon and f. maltoni , nucl . b * 571 * , 51 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9910563 ] . r. kleiss and h. kuijf , nucl . b * 312 * , 616 ( 1989 ) . n. e. j. bjerrum - bohr , p. h. damgaard and p. vanhove , phys . lett . * 103 * , 161602 ( 2009 ) [ 0907.1425 [ hep - th ] ] ; + s. stieberger , 0907.2211 [ hep - th ] . e. plahte , nuovo cim . a * 66 * , 713 ( 1970 ) . b. feng , r. huang and y. jia , phys . b * 695 * , 350 ( 2011 ) [ 1004.3417 [ hep - th ] ] ; + y. x. chen , y. j. du and b. feng , jhep * 1102 * , 112 ( 2011 ) [ 1101.0009 [ hep - th ] ] . s .- h . h. tye and y. zhang , jhep * 1006 * , 071 ( 2010 ) [ 1003.1732 [ hep - th ] ] . f. a. berends , r. kleiss , p. de causmaecker , r. gastmans and t. t. wu , phys . b * 103 * , 124 ( 1981 ) ; + p. de causmaecker , r. gastmans , w. troost and t. t. wu , nucl . b * 206 * , 53 ( 1982 ) ; + r. kleiss and w. j. stirling , nucl . b * 262 * , 235 ( 1985 ) ; + j. f. gunion and z. kunszt , phys . b * 161 * , 333 ( 1985 ) ; + z. xu , d. h. zhang and l. chang , nucl . b * 291 * , 392 ( 1987 ) ; + r. gastmans and t. t. wu , _ the ubiquitous photon : helicity method for qed and qcd _ ( clarendon press , 1990 ) . n. berkovits and j. maldacena , jhep * 0809 * , 062 ( 2008 ) [ 0807.3196 [ hep - th ] ] . n. beisert , r. ricci , a. a. tseytlin and m. wolf , phys . d * 78 * , 126004 ( 2008 ) [ 0807.3228 [ hep - th ] ] . j. m. drummond , j. m. henn and j. plefka , jhep * 0905 * , 046 ( 2009 ) [ 0902.2987 [ hep - th ] ] . t. bargheer , n. beisert and f. loebbert , to appear in j. phys . a [ 1104.0700 [ hep - th ] ] . t. bargheer , n. beisert , w. galleas , f. loebbert and t. mcloughlin , jhep * 0911 * , 056 ( 2009 ) [ 0905.3738 [ hep - th ] ] . n. beisert , j. henn , t. mcloughlin and j. plefka , jhep * 1004 * , 085 ( 2010 ) [ 1002.1733 [ hep - th ] ] . l. f. alday , d. gaiotto , j. maldacena , a. sever and p. vieira , jhep * 1104 * , 088 ( 2011 ) [ 1006.2788 [ hep - th ] ] . d. gaiotto , j. maldacena , a. sever and p. vieira , 1102.0062 [ hep - th ] . k. o. mikaelian , m. a. samuel and d. sahdev , phys . rev . lett . * 43 * , 746 ( 1979 ) . d. zhu , phys . d * 22 * , 2266 ( 1980 ) ; + c. j. goebel , f. halzen and j. p. leveille , phys . rev . d * 23 * , 2682 ( 1981 ) . d. binosi and l. theussl , comput . commun . * 161 * , 76 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0309015 ] ; + d. binosi , j. collins , c. kaufhold and l. theussl , comput . commun . * 180 * , 1709 ( 2009 ) [ 0811.4113 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. a. m. vermaseren , comput . commun . * 83 * , 45 ( 1994 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: increasingly the collective behavior displayed by groups of interacting dynamical components , each of which may be capable of a full range of complex dynamics , is essential to understanding and ultimately designing systems . examples in biology , physics , and engineering are diverse , ranging from understanding sensory perception to the design of antennas capable of simultaneously sending and receiving signals at the same frequency . while in general the dynamical components may be functionally distinct and heterogeneous , in many examples one is interested in the collective behavior displayed by a group of similar coupled elements . one commonly studied example is the synchronization of oscillating subsystems that interact . the ability of a group of coupled oscillators to synchronize despite a distribution in individual frequencies is a broadly applicable phenomenon . in physical systems coherent oscillations can be used to enhance detector sensitivity or increase the intensity of a power source . synchronization is also important in biological systems where the collective behaviors in populations of animals , such as the synchronized flashing of fireflies or the coherent oscillations observed in the brain , serve as examples . including a distribution in individual frequencies in an otherwise homogeneous ensemble captures some of the inevitable differences that group members will possess . although synchronization is often put forward as an example of the importance of understanding nonlinear phenomena , the intuition for it , and indeed the subsequent mathematical discussion , often reduces to simple linear ideas . for example , the famous example of huygens clocks @xcite can be understood in terms of a linear coupling of the two pendulums through the common mounting support . then the larger damping of the symmetric mode ( coming from the larger , dissipative motion of the common support ) compared with the antisymmetric mode leads at long times to a synchronized state of the two pendulums oscillating in antiphase . the nonlinearity in the system is simply present in the individual motion of each pendulum ; specifically in the mechanism to sustain the oscillations . without the drive , the oscillators would still become synchronized through the faster decay of the even mode , albeit in a slowly decaying state . rather than this mode - dependent dissipation mechanism , one might expect synchronization to arise from the intrinsically nonlinear effect of the frequency pulling of one oscillator by another . furthermore , the model describing the two pendulums , as well as most other models used to show synchronization , has dissipative coupling between the oscillators . in contrast , many physical situations have mainly reactive coupling . nanoscale mechanical oscillator arrays are one example that offer significant potential in a range of technologies @xcite,@xcite . due to the scales and numbers in these arrays , active control of individual oscillators poses a number of challenging problems . synchronization offers a potentially appealing alternative in some applications . one notable characteristic of these arrays is the predominantly reactive coupling due to elastic or electrostatic interactions . this context is the motivation for our work . in particular , we study the model@xmath0 where @xmath1 is a complex number representing the amplitude @xmath2 and phase @xmath3 of the mth oscillator @xmath4 . the natural frequency @xmath5 of each oscillator is chosen from a distribution @xmath6 . we call the width of the distribution @xmath7 . coefficients of the terms for nonlinear frequency pulling ( @xmath8 ) , dissipative coupling ( @xmath9 ) , and reactive coupling ( @xmath10 ) serve as model parameters . the coupling is taken to be infinite range or all - to - all . in this paper we study the roles of nonlinear frequency pulling and reactive coupling in the absence of the dissipative coupling using eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) with @xmath11 . in addition the distribution @xmath6 of the @xmath5 must be specified . we study the case of positive @xmath8 and @xmath10 ; for a symmetric distribution @xmath6 the results are the same changing the sign of both @xmath8 and @xmath10 . alternatively , when only nonlinear saturation and dissipative coupling are present ( @xmath12 ) eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) reduces to @xmath13 the behavior for general @xmath7 and @xmath9 of eq . ( [ amplitudephase ] ) has been analyzed by matthews et al . if the width @xmath7 of the distribution @xmath6 is narrow , so that the time evolution of the magnitudes @xmath14 is fast compared with that of the phase dispersion , and @xmath9 is small , @xmath14 rapidly relaxes to a value close to unity , and the only remaining variable for each array member is the phase @xmath3 . equation ( [ amplitudephase ] ) can then be reduced to a simple form @xcite,@xcite , often known as the kuramoto model @xmath15 that has been the subject of numerous studies @xcite . in the absence of coupling each oscillator in this model would simply advance at a rate that is constant in time , but with some dispersion of frequencies over the different elements . equation ( [ kuramoto ] ) is an abstraction from the equations describing most real oscillator systems , leaving out many important physical features . the complex notation of eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) suggests the introduction of a complex order parameter @xmath16 to measure the coherence of the oscillations@xmath17 with @xmath18 for the kuramoto model , and then the equation of motion can be written [ take the imaginary part of @xmath19 in eq . ( [ orderparameter ] ) to evaluate the sum appearing in eq . ( [ kuramoto ] ) ] as@xmath20 thus the behavior of each oscillator is given by its tendency to lock to the phase of the order parameter . the term @xmath21 acts as a locking force , and locking occurs for all oscillators with frequencies satisfying @xmath22 , with the locked oscillator phase given by @xmath23 . the magnitude @xmath24 of the order parameter must then be determined self - consistently via eq . ( [ orderparameter ] ) . the generalization of the locking force to apply to the model eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) will be a conspicuous feature of our work . equation ( [ kuramoto ] ) is known to show rich behavior , including , in the large @xmath25 limit , a sharp synchronization transition at some value of the coupling constant @xmath26 @xcite , which depends on the frequency distribution of the uncoupled oscillators @xmath6 . the transition is from an unsynchronized state with @xmath27 in which the oscillators run at their individual frequencies , to a synchronized state with @xmath28 in which a finite fraction of the oscillators lock to a single frequency . the transition at @xmath29 has many of the features of a second order phase transition , with universal power laws and critical slowing down @xcite , as well as a diverging response to an applied force @xcite . we present a detailed analysis of the model eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) with @xmath30 describing the synchronization of an oscillator ensemble involving reactive coupling between the elements , which then leads to synchronization through nonlinear frequency pulling . we begin in sec . [ sec_derive ] by deriving eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) as a description of arrays of nanoelectromechanical oscillators . we then discuss the solutions to eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) for a variety of symmetric distributions in intrinsic frequencies @xmath6 . common solution types exist for the three distinct types of frequency distributions we studied . in sec . [ sec_examples ] we introduce these solutions and the measures we use to describe them . we begin the analysis in sec . [ sec_form ] by moving to a continuum description to derive synchronization conditions . we are able to analyze the existence of two behavior types in closed form : the unsynchronized solution in sec . [ sec_onset ] and the fully locked synchronized behavior in sec . [ sec_fulllocking ] . results from our analytical arguments are combined with those from simulations to present the solutions and associated phase diagram for each frequency distribution in sec . [ sec_results ] . we begin these by considering an unbounded symmetric frequency distribution in the form of a lorentzian in sec . [ sec_lort ] . continuing in this section we then approximately double the distribution width to discuss some interesting characteristics of the well - ordered synchronized solutions as well as changes to the bifurcations . in contrast , sec . [ sec_top ] presents the results for a bounded distribution when all frequencies over some range are equally likely ( a top - hat distribution ) . this is followed in sec . [ sec_tri ] by the case of a symmetric unimodal frequency spread , namely a triangular distribution . finally , conclusions are made in sec . [ sec_conclude ] . a brief account of some results for the model eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) has been reported previously @xcite . although the main focus of this paper is analyzing the behavior of eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) we first show how such an equation might arise from the equations of motion of physical oscillators . as an example consider the system defined by@xmath31=0 . \label{eq_dv}\ ] ] the first two terms describe uncoupled harmonic oscillators . we suppose the uncoupled oscillators have a linear frequency that is near unity by an appropriate scaling of the time variable@xmath32 the third term is a _ negative _ linear damping , which represents an energy source to sustain the oscillations , and positive nonlinear damping , so that the oscillation amplitude saturates at a finite value . again this saturation value is chosen to be of order unity by an appropriate scaling of the displacements @xmath33 . for an example of an effective negative linear damping term in a micromechanical oscillator see references @xcite . one could also imagine implementing such an effect with an electronic feedback loop sensing each oscillator velocity and driving the oscillator with an appropriate phase . the first three terms of eq . ( [ eq_dv ] ) comprise a set of uncoupled van der pohl oscillators . the term @xmath34 describes a stiffening of the spring constant ( for @xmath35 ) and is a reactive nonlinear term that leads to an amplitude dependent shift of the resonant frequency . with @xmath36 this would give us _ duffing _ oscillators . the final term is a nearest neighbor coupling between the oscillators , depending on the difference of the displacements . this is a reactive term , that conserves the energy of the system . others @xcite have considered nonlinear oscillators coupled through their velocities ; this is a dissipative coupling that would lead to @xmath37 in the amplitude - phase reduction . the complex amplitude equation ( [ eq_cross ] ) holds if the parameters @xmath38 are sufficiently small . in this case the equations of motion are dominated by the terms describing simple harmonic oscillators at frequency one , and the time dependence remains close to @xmath39 . to formalize the smallness of @xmath38 we introduce a small parameter @xmath40 and write @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 . the oscillating displacement is written as a slow modulation of oscillations at frequency one , plus corrections @xcite@xmath45 + \epsilon x_{n}^{(1)}(t)+\ldots\label{ansatz1}\ ] ] with @xmath46 a slow time scale . , as in ref . however in the present case inspection of the van der pohl term shows that the oscillations will grow until @xmath47 . the nonlinear effects are small because the multiplying coefficients @xmath48 and @xmath49 are small . of course , this difference results from a choice of scaling of the @xmath33 variables ; for example choosing @xmath50 would result in the more familiar procedure . ] the variation of @xmath51 gives us the extra freedom to eliminate secular terms and ensure that the perturbative correction @xmath52 , as well as all higher - order corrections to the linear response , do not diverge ( as they do if one uses naive perturbation theory ) . using the relation @xmath53 ( denoting a time derivative with respect to the slow time @xmath54 by a prime ) we calculate the time derivatives of the trial solution ( [ ansatz1 ] ) [ eq : derivs]@xmath55e^{it}+c.c.\right ) + \epsilon\dot{x}_{n}^{(1)}(t)+\ldots\\ \ddot{x}_{n } & = \left ( [ -a_{n}+2i\epsilon a_{n}^{\prime}+\epsilon^{2}a_{n}^{\prime\prime}]e^{it}+c.c.\right ) + \epsilon\ddot{x}_{n}^{(1)}(t)+\ldots\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting these expressions back into the equation of motion ( [ eq_dv ] ) , and picking out all terms of order @xmath56 , we get the following equation for the first perturbative correction @xmath57 . \label{eq_xone}\ ] ] the collection of terms proportional to @xmath58 on the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eq_xone ] ) , called the secular terms , act like a force driving the simple harmonic oscillator on the left - hand side at its resonance frequency . the sum of all the secular terms must vanish so that the perturbative correction @xmath52 will not diverge . ( terms varying as @xmath59 contribute a finite response to @xmath60 . ) this gives us an equation for determining the slowly varying amplitudes @xmath51 @xmath61=0 . \label{duffingampa}\ ] ] more informally , we might write @xmath62 so that @xmath63 and eq . ( [ duffingampa ] ) can be written in terms of the original small parameters without the formal scaling@xmath64=0 \label{duffingamp}\ ] ] with a rescaling of time @xmath65 eq . ( [ duffingamp ] ) reduces to the form eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) except that in eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) the nearest neighbor coupling is replaced by the all - to - all coupling convenient for theoretical analysis . in this section we introduce the types of dynamical states encountered for the model eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) as well as diagnostic tools to characterize these states . the types of states we find for the different distributions investigated are largely the same , and so we use a particular example a lorentzian distribution of oscillator frequencies with some convenient choice of parameters @xmath8 and @xmath10and discuss how the behavior depends systematically on the distribution and other parameters later in the paper . we are mainly interested in the behavior for large numbers of oscillators @xmath66 . for the numerical simulations we are of course restricted to finite @xmath25 ( we typically use @xmath67 , but have gone up to @xmath68 to investigate some subtle effects ) . in our discussion we focus on those results that we expect to be largely independent of @xmath25 for large @xmath25 . a key diagnostic for synchronization is the complex order parameter @xmath69 defined by eq . ( [ orderparameter ] ) , introduced by kuramoto @xcite , with magnitude @xmath24 and phase @xmath70 where @xmath71 . in the large @xmath25 limit , we could use a nonzero value of the order parameter at each time as the basic criterion for a synchronized state . a synchronized periodic state with frequency @xmath72 would then have @xmath73 with @xmath74 constants . more complicated dynamical states might also occur . for a finite number of oscillators @xmath25 a precise diagnostic is harder , since there are fluctuations of order @xmath75 that make the instantaneous @xmath76 nonzero even in an unsynchronized state . for a synchronized periodic state we could require that the time average @xmath77 scales as @xmath25 as the number of oscillators changes for some frequency @xmath78 that becomes constant for large enough @xmath25 , and use this as a measure of the synchronization . in practice we use the simpler criterion that the time averaged magnitude @xmath79 is nonzero and does not appear to decrease to zero as @xmath25 increases . ( a @xmath76 fluctuating about zero with an amplitude of order @xmath75 will of course lead to a nonzero @xmath80 of this same order . ) this definition can also be applied to aperiodic synchronized states . another useful diagnostic uses the actual frequency of each oscillator defined by@xmath81 , \label{frequencylocking}\ ] ] where @xmath82 is some long averaging time and @xmath83 is a starting time sufficient to eliminate transients . a _ frequency locked _ state has a fraction of oscillators with the same frequency @xmath84 . ( the fraction should be @xmath85 and a value not decreasing to zero as @xmath25 increases ) . if not all the oscillators have the same frequency ( i.e. the fraction is not unity ) we call the state _ partially locked_. if all the oscillators have the same average frequency , we call the state _ fully locked_. to make contact with the analytic results we actually use a stricter criterion , and also require the magnitudes @xmath86 to be time independent in the fully locked state . usually we find that a nonzero @xmath80 is associated with frequency locking , but this is not always the case . _ phase locking _ is a stricter requirement than eq . ( [ frequencylocking ] ) . for phase locking we would require that @xmath87 does not diverge as @xmath88 for @xmath89 taken from some finite fraction of the oscillators . ( frequency locking is , for example , consistent with phase differences that grow diffusively proportional to @xmath90 . ) we do not investigate this stricter locking criterion . to investigate whether each locked oscillator in a frequency locked state is tightly locked in phase to the phase of the order parameter , or is fluctuating about this value , we define a _ phase synchronization index _ for each oscillator@xmath91 with @xmath92 the phase of the @xmath93th oscillator relative to the order parameter phase@xmath94 when the phase of oscillator @xmath93 is locked to the order parameter one , @xmath95 is constant and the phase synchronization index is unity , whereas as @xmath95 tends towards a uniform distribution from @xmath96 to @xmath97 the index approaches zero . we define the number of oscillators with @xmath98 very close to one as the _ tightly locked cluster_. [ tbh ] of frequencies for cutoff lorentzian with @xmath99 and cutoff @xmath100 for @xmath67 oscillators . the main graph shows the individual frequencies , and the inset a histogram.,width=316,height=282 ] we now show results of numerical simulations for the lorentzian distribution of frequencies . we have chosen to cut off the distribution at some large @xmath101 otherwise there would be a few very fast oscillators restricting the time stepping of the numerics . thus we use@xmath102{ll}$g(0)\frac{w^{2}}{\omega^{2}+w^{2}}$ & for $ \left\vert \omega\right\vert < \omega_{c}$\\ $ 0 $ & for $ \left\vert \omega\right\vert > \omega_{c}$\end{tabular } \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \right . \label{eq_para_lort}\ ] ] for a given choice of @xmath103 , with @xmath7 then fixed by the normalization condition@xmath104 ( it is useful to parameterize the distribution in terms of @xmath103 , since this quantity determines the values of @xmath8 and @xmath10 at which synchronization occurs in the large @xmath105 limit where the model reduces to the kuramoto phase model eq . ( [ kuramoto ] ) . ) in presenting the results we choose a distribution width such that @xmath99 . for a cutoff @xmath100 this gives @xmath106 , with @xmath107 . with no cutoff , we would have @xmath108 . the distribution of frequencies is generated from a uniform distribution of @xmath25 values @xmath109 on the interval @xmath110 using the transformation@xmath111 we present results for a deterministic set of @xmath112@xmath113 /(n-1),\ ] ] but have also used @xmath112 generated randomly on the interval . the distribution of frequencies for @xmath67 oscillators and a cutoff @xmath114 is shown in fig . [ fig_lor_dist ] . [ tbh ] oscillators with the cutoff lorentzian distribution of intrinsic frequencies of fig . [ fig_lor_dist ] . shown is the time averaged order parameter magnitude @xmath115 over a range of @xmath10 values at constant @xmath116 . solid lines are the observed solutions . the overlapping symbols are representative results from simulations following different solution branches with increasing @xmath10 ( @xmath117 ) and decreasing @xmath10 ( @xmath118 and @xmath119 ) . time traces associated with the solid symbols are shown in fig . [ fig_orderparameters ] . the dot - dashed line is at a value of @xmath120 , the order of magnitude expected for random fluctuations of the order parameter about zero.,width=316 ] a plot of the dependence of the mean magnitude of the order parameter @xmath121 as a function of @xmath10 for fixed value of @xmath116 and @xmath67 is shown in fig . [ fig_lorentzian_cut ] . this plot shows three types of states : an unsynchronized state with @xmath122 essentially zero ; and two synchronized states , one with small @xmath121 , growing from @xmath96 to about @xmath123 as @xmath10 decreases below about @xmath124 , and one with large @xmath122 that exists for all @xmath125 . ( we will discuss later such issues as whether the growth of the large @xmath126 is continuous or discontinuous near @xmath127 . ) [ tbh ] as a function of time observed at the solid symbols in fig . the three traces are for the unsynchronized state at @xmath128 ( lower trace ) , and the small amplitude synchronized state ( middle trace ) and large amplitude synchronized state ( upper trace ) both at @xmath129.,width=316 ] the variation of @xmath130 for representative examples of these three states is shown in fig . [ fig_orderparameters ] . the lower trace shows the unsynchronized state at @xmath128 in fig . [ fig_lorentzian_cut ] . the fluctuations in @xmath130 are consistent with fluctuations of the order parameter about zero with magnitude of order @xmath75 as expected for a collection of @xmath25 oscillators with different frequencies and random phases . the average frequency distribution @xmath84 ( not shown ) is unchanged from the bare distribution @xmath131 shifted by @xmath132 . this shift can be understood as arising from the nonlinear frequency shift with @xmath133 , and the coupling to a distribution of oscillators with @xmath134 and random phases . : ( a ) - actual frequency distribution ( solid line ) and bare frequency distribution shifted by @xmath132 ( dotted line ) ; ( b ) - synchronization index @xmath98.,width=288 ] the state corresponding to the middle trace in fig . [ fig_orderparameters ] is the low amplitude state at @xmath129 in fig . [ fig_lorentzian_cut ] . the mean order parameter magnitude @xmath135 is much larger than @xmath136 , suggesting this is a synchronized state . the corresponding frequency distribution and synchronization index are shown in fig . [ fig_smr_plateau ] . the frequency distribution @xmath84 ( a ) shows a small plateau of constant frequency over about 60 oscillators towards the high frequency end of the distribution ; these are the frequency locked oscillators . the synchronization index ( b ) shows that @xmath98 approaches unity for most of the locked oscillators , which means that @xmath137 for these oscillators is essentially time independent once the rotation of the phase at the order parameter frequency is subtracted out . a careful scrutiny of the two panels reveals that the plateau in @xmath84 is sharper and more extended than the one in @xmath98 , so that not all the frequency locked oscillators are time independent in the rotating frame . the dynamical state is actually quite complicated , as a review of @xmath138 shows . and order parameter @xmath76 in the complex plane at a time after transients have decayed . the + towards the center of the plot gives the value of the order parameter . the squares are oscillators locked to the order parameter frequency ( i.e. those with @xmath139 ) : solid squares are stationary when the @xmath140 dependence is removed , open squares show an additional dynamics rotating around the tail of the fixed distribution in the rotating system . the @xmath141 are oscillators that are not locked to the order parameter.,width=288 ] figure [ l_matlab_fig2 ] shows a plot of a snapshot of the complex amplitude @xmath137 of each oscillator . the + is the order parameter . the other points correspond to @xmath137 for each oscillator . it is useful to study the dynamics of this plot after rotation at the mean order parameter frequency is eliminated . as time evolves , the square symbols remain fixed in such a plot ( except for very small fluctuations ) : these represent oscillators that are locked to the order parameter . for the solid squares the complex amplitudes are essentially time independent once the phase of the order parameter is extracted . the oscillators represented by an @xmath142 on the other hand rotate clockwise or anticlockwise about the origin : these correspond to unlocked or running oscillators . the open squares exhibit a more complicated dynamics undergoing small amplitude orbits around the tail of the locked oscillator distribution . these oscillators are locked to the order parameter , since the difference of their phases from the order parameter phase does not drift over arbitrary long times . the values of @xmath84 for these oscillators are on the locked plateau in fig . [ fig_smr_plateau ] . however the amplitudes are not constant in the rotating plot , the values of @xmath98 are less than unity , and the oscillators contribute to fluctuations of the order parameter . thus the fluctuations of @xmath130 shown in fig . [ fig_orderparameters ] are not just due to finite @xmath25 effects , and we believe they would persist in the @xmath66 limit . we have not explored larger @xmath25 to pin down whether these intrinsic fluctuations are periodic or aperiodic in the large @xmath25 limit . as we discuss in more detail later , for a bounded distribution of frequencies it is possible to find a low amplitude synchronized state with @xmath143 , but with a smooth frequency distribution showing that there is no frequency locking . in fact for this state the distribution of actual oscillator frequencies does not overlap the order parameter frequency . the nonzero order parameter is caused by a systematic slowing of the phase rotation of the oscillators in the vicinity of the order parameter phase , rather than by a fraction of the phases becoming locked to the order parameter phase . for an unbounded distribution such as the lorentzian , this same effect occurs but is supplemented by the small fraction of locked oscillators . but for the large amplitude synchronized state.,width=288 ] for the same parameter values as for the previously described low amplitude synchronized state for the lorentzian distribution there is a second dynamical state that may be reached depending on the initial conditions of the simulation . this state has a much larger value of the order parameter @xmath144 and the plot of the distribution of frequencies , fig . [ fig_lgr_plateau](a ) , shows a correspondingly larger fraction of locked oscillators . ( this should be compared with panel ( a ) of fig . [ fig_smr_plateau ] . ) for the cutoff lorentzian distribution used , all the oscillators at the high frequency end of the distribution are locked , leaving only a small fraction of free running oscillators at the low end of the frequency distribution . for the @xmath66 limit and a lorentzian distribution without a cutoff , unlocked oscillators remain at both the high and low frequency ends of the distribution . for a bounded distribution of bare frequencies , such as triangular or top - hat , a fully locked state in which all the oscillators rotate with the same frequency and fixed magnitude may be found . we now turn to the analysis of the synchronization of oscillators described by eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) . since we are interested in the behavior for a large number of oscillators , it is convenient to go to a continuum description , where we label the oscillators by their uncoupled linear frequency @xmath145 rather than the index @xmath93 , @xmath146 . introducing the order parameter eq . ( [ orderparameter ] ) , the oscillator equations can be written in magnitude - phase form as [ theta_r]@xmath147 where @xmath148 is the oscillator phase relative to that of the order parameter as before , and @xmath149 is the bare oscillator frequency shifted by @xmath132 and measured relative to the order parameter frequency @xmath150 @xmath151 note that if the order parameter is zero @xmath152 , the magnitude @xmath153 will relax to @xmath154 , and the @xmath93th oscillator will evolve at the frequency @xmath155 . the first component of this frequency shift is just the nonlinear shift at @xmath156 , and the second is from the interaction of each oscillator with the incoherent motion of the other oscillators . at each time @xmath82 the oscillators are specified by the distribution @xmath157 where @xmath158 is the fraction of the oscillators with shifted frequency @xmath149 that at time @xmath82 have magnitude between @xmath153 and @xmath159 and shifted phase between @xmath160 and @xmath161 . the order parameter is given by the self - consistency condition@xmath162 where @xmath163 is the distribution of oscillator frequencies expressed in terms of the shifted frequency @xmath149 . it is useful to split this expression into real and imaginary parts . the imaginary part is@xmath164 because the phases @xmath165 are measured relative to the orientation of the order parameter , this expresses the fact that the components of the complex amplitudes @xmath166 normal to the order parameter must average to zero . note that unlike the cases of the kuramoto model [ eq . ( [ kuramoto ] ) ] and the dissipatively coupled complex amplitude model [ eq . ( [ amplitudephase ] ) ] studied by matthews et al . , this condition is not trivially satisfied even for the case of a symmetric distribution @xmath6 , and in fact serves to determine the frequency @xmath72 of the order parameter . the frequency @xmath72 is also not trivially related to the mean frequency of the oscillator distribution . the real part of eq . ( [ selfconsistency ] ) is@xmath167 this is the condition that the components @xmath168 along the direction of the order parameter must average to the magnitude @xmath24 . this condition serves to self - consistently fix the value of @xmath24 . the expectation that eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) might lead to synchronization follows from the behavior for narrow frequency distributions and large @xmath8 . if the width of the distribution of frequencies is small compared to the relaxation rate of the magnitude , which is of order one in the time units used in eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) , the magnitude relaxes rapidly to the value given by the instantaneous value of @xmath160 , i.e. to the solution of@xmath169 if @xmath153 is close to one , which we will see applies at the onset of synchronization for large @xmath8 , this gives@xmath170 in this case eq . ( [ theta ] ) becomes , ignoring @xmath171 compared with @xmath172,@xmath173 this equation is the same as the one derived from the kuramoto model in eq . ( [ kuramotofield ] ) with @xmath105 playing the role of the coupling constant @xmath9 , and therefore predicts an onset of synchronization at @xmath174 @xcite . to uncover more fully the behavior of eq . ( [ eq_cross ] ) we consider two issues : the onset of synchronization , detected as the linear instability of the unsynchronized @xmath152 state , as a function of @xmath8 and @xmath10 for some given frequency distribution @xmath6 ; and the existence of a fully locked state for large values of @xmath105 . we first consider the initial onset of partial synchronization from the unsynchronized state in which each oscillator runs at its own frequency @xmath131 . we identify synchronization through a nonzero value of the order parameter . this often arises because a finite fraction of the oscillators become locked to the same frequency , which we call a partially ( fully if the fraction is unity ) locked state . however we also find situations where @xmath143 , but there is no frequency locking . the onset of synchronization can be determined by a linear instability analysis of the unsynchronized state . this is calculated by linearizing the distribution @xmath175 around the unsynchronized distribution , which is a uniform phase distribution at @xmath156 , and seeking the parameter values at which deviations from the uniform phase distribution begin to grow exponentially . this follows the method of matthews et al . @xcite , although care is needed in the analysis due to the more important role the magnitude perturbations @xmath153 play in the present case . introducing the small expansion parameter @xmath40 characterizing the small deviations from the unsynchronized state , we write@xmath176[1+\varepsilon f_{1}(\bar{\theta},\bar{\omega},t ) ] . \label{rhoexpansion}\ ] ] note that for @xmath177 this does indeed give the appropriately normalized distribution for the unsynchronized state , in which all the oscillators have unit magnitude , @xmath156 , and the phase distribution is constant . also , for nonzero @xmath40 , @xmath175 remains normalized to linear order@xmath178 providing the average of @xmath179 over @xmath160 is zero . the equation for the evolution of the radial perturbation of the distribution @xmath180 is given by noting that@xmath181 the left hand side is evaluated by expanding eq . ( [ r ] ) to first order in @xmath40 and also expanding the magnitude of the order parameter @xmath182 . , and the right hand side by the replacement @xmath183 and assuming an exponential growth or decay of the perturbation @xmath184 . the result is@xmath185 equation ( [ r1 ] ) is solved by@xmath186 with [ ab]@xmath187 to extract the equation for @xmath179 integrate the equation for the conservation of probability @xmath188 over radius . here @xmath189 is the velocity in complex amplitude space , which in polar coordinates is @xmath190 given by eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) . again replacing @xmath191 by @xmath192 , and evaluating @xmath180 from eqs . ( [ r1ab],[ab ] ) , this gives at @xmath193@xmath194 this is solved by@xmath195 with [ cd]@xmath196}{\left ( \bar{\omega}^{2}+\lambda ^{2}\right ) \left [ \bar{\omega}^{2}+(\lambda+2)^{2}\right ] } , \label{c}\\ d & = \beta\frac{4\alpha\bar{\omega}(\lambda+1)+\lambda\lbrack\bar{\omega } ^{2}+(\lambda+2)^{2}]}{\left ( \bar{\omega}^{2}+\lambda^{2}\right ) \left [ \bar{\omega}^{2}+(\lambda+2)^{2}\right ] } . \label{d}\ ] ] we now evaluate the self - consistency condition eq . ( [ selfconsistency ] ) to first order in @xmath40 . the imaginary part is @xmath197 which to first order in @xmath40 gives@xmath198 = 0 . \label{perpint}\ ] ] similarly the real part of the self - consistency condition is@xmath199 = 2 . \label{parint}\ ] ] we want to evaluate eqs . ( [ perpint ] ) and ( [ parint ] ) at the onset of instability where the growth rate @xmath200 . we can set @xmath201 in eqs . ( [ perpint],[parint ] ) with eqs . ( [ ab ] ) and ( [ cd ] ) except in terms with @xmath202 in the denominator , since such terms may give large contributions to the integral from the region of small @xmath149 . a term involving just @xmath203 gives a finite integral , but if this is multiplied by powers of @xmath149 or @xmath204 the integral goes to zero in the @xmath200 limit . similarly for a term involving @xmath205 we must take the limit @xmath200 after doing the integral ( this is equivalent to the principal value integral ) , whereas if this term is multiplied by powers of @xmath149 we can put @xmath201 immediately . the needed integrals are [ integrals]@xmath206 the imaginary part of the self consistency condition eq . ( [ perpint ] ) becomes @xmath207 and the real part reduces to the condition for @xmath208@xmath209 we have explicitly evaluated the integrals for top - hat , triangular , and lorentzian distributions of bare frequencies . these results will be presented after we discuss full locking . we define the fully locked state as one in which all the phases are rotating at the same frequency as the order parameter , and the magnitudes are constant in time . these solutions are defined by eq . ( [ theta ] ) with @xmath210 , which with eq . ( [ rconstant ] ) can be written@xmath211 where the solution to the cubic equation ( [ rconstant ] ) for @xmath212 is to be used to form the function of phase alone @xmath213 . the function @xmath213 acts as the force pinning the locked oscillators to the order parameter , generalizing the notion introduced below eq . ( [ kuramotofield ] ) , and plays a central role in our discussion of locking . a particular oscillator , identified by its shifted frequency @xmath149 , will be locked to the order parameter if eq . ( [ locked ] ) has a solution @xmath214 [ and then @xmath153 is given by solving eq . ( [ rconstant ] ) ] and if this solution is stable . the stability is tested by linearizing eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) about the solution . the fully locked solution will only exist if stable , locked solutions to eq . ( [ locked ] ) exist for _ all _ the oscillators in the distribution . we are thus led to investigate the properties of the function @xmath215 . in addition the self consistency condition eq . ( [ selfconsistency ] ) must be satisfied . for small @xmath171 , the magnitude @xmath216 given by eq . ( [ rconstant ] ) remains bounded away from zero for all @xmath160 , and the function @xmath213 varies continuously between minimum and maximum values @xmath217 . in this case , we immediately see that the fully locked solution only occurs for bounded distributions , @xmath218 nonzero only between finite @xmath219 and @xmath220 . in such cases we define @xmath221 , which is equal to the range of unshifted frequencies @xmath222 , as @xmath7 the width of the distribution . more generally , although @xmath213 can vary over an infinite range ( because @xmath153 may become zero ) we find that only a finite range yields stable solutions , so that again complete locking only occurs for a bounded distribution of oscillator frequencies . we first look at the fully locked solution for large values of @xmath105 . in this case the phases of the locked oscillators cover a narrow range of angles , since the range of the pinning force @xmath223 becomes large for large @xmath105 . the imaginary part of the self consistency condition eq . ( [ imselfconsistency ] ) shows that the range of phases must be around @xmath224 . equation ( [ locked ] ) can now be approximated by expanding around @xmath224 ( note @xmath225 here ) and becomes for large @xmath8@xmath226 the imaginary part of the self - consistency condition reduces to @xmath227 ( the average is over the distribution of frequencies ) , and the real part to simply @xmath228 . finally , averaging eq . ( [ alphalarge ] ) over the distribution of frequencies fixes the order parameter frequency ( the common frequency of all the oscillators)@xmath229 thus the order parameter , and all the oscillators , evolve at a frequency given by the mean of the distribution @xmath6 shifted by the nonlinear effect for @xmath156 . we now investigate the limit to the fully locked regime as we lower @xmath8 . we first summarize the argument , and then present the details . the fully locked solutions are determined by a rather complicated set of interconnected equations . they can be found by the following algorithm . for fixed values of @xmath230 solve eq . ( [ rconstant ] ) for real positive @xmath216 and hence calculate @xmath213 . using eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) the stability of each solution is tested : the eigenvalues of this analysis are ( see eq . ( [ eigenvalues_2 ] ) below)@xmath231 with @xmath232 . from this we can identify a range @xmath233 corresponding to the range of existence and stability of locked oscillators . a fully locked solution must then satisfy the constraints@xmath234 together with the condition given by the imaginary part of the self consistency condition@xmath235\,d\bar{\omega}=0 , \label{transverse}\ ] ] where @xmath236 , and @xmath237 is then the solution to eq . ( [ rconstant ] ) . the boundary of the fully locked region occurs either when @xmath238 or when @xmath239 . this equation can be interpreted as fixing the order parameter frequency @xmath72 in terms of @xmath8 and @xmath240 . notice that eq . ( [ eigenvalues ] ) shows that for @xmath241 one eigenvalue certainly has a positive real part indicating instability , so that for stable solutions @xmath242 and @xmath243 is finite . since @xmath244 or @xmath220 is now determined , and @xmath245 , eq . ( [ transverse ] ) is an implicit equation relating the values of @xmath8 , @xmath240 and @xmath7 at the locking transition . to complete the solution , the real part of the self consistency equation@xmath246\,d\bar{\omega}=r \label{longitudingal}\ ] ] then serves to fix @xmath24 at locking , from which the value of @xmath247 at the transition to full locking can be found . we first consider the _ existence _ of a locked solution for an individual oscillator , i.e. a _ stationary _ solution of eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) . equation ( [ rconstant ] ) gives the cubic equation for @xmath216 for each @xmath248@xmath249 of course , for the physical solution @xmath153 must be real and positive . thus we need to analyze the properties of the real positive solutions to@xmath250 as @xmath251 varies . [ tbh ] ) as @xmath251 varies . the dashed lines are @xmath252.,width=268 ] for @xmath253 the solutions to the cubic are @xmath254 . as @xmath255 increases , the solutions remain real until two of the roots collide and become complex . since the sum of the roots to eq . ( [ cubic ] ) is zero , at the collision the equation takes the form@xmath256 matching coefficients shows that collision occurs at @xmath257 when @xmath258 . the form of eq . ( [ cubic ] ) is actually already in what is known as the depressed form of a cubic equation , for which the solution is relatively simple . inspecting the form of these solutions shows that for @xmath259 there is one real solution and a complex pair in the form @xmath260 . the product of the roots is determined by the constant in the cubic , giving@xmath261 and so for @xmath262 the real root is negative , and for @xmath263 the real root is positive . these results are confirmed by numerical solution as shown in fig . [ cubic_fig ] . [ tbh ] for @xmath264 . the dashed line is @xmath265 and the dotted line @xmath266 . the condition @xmath267 is necessary ( but not sufficient ) for the solution to be stable . the lower branch always satisfies @xmath268 , and so only the upper branch may have stable regions.,width=268 ] [ tbh ] for @xmath269 . solutions exist for @xmath270 with @xmath271 . the dashed line is @xmath265 and the dotted line @xmath266.,width=268 ] thus we find the following behavior for the real positive solutions to eq . ( [ r_theta ] ) . for @xmath264 there is a root that is positive with @xmath272 for all @xmath160 , a root that varies between positive and negative values with magnitude less than @xmath273 , and a root that is negative for all @xmath160 . we have seen that the stability analysis shows that any solution with @xmath241 is unstable@xmath274 thus only the first root is relevant ( see fig . [ r_theta_bs ] ) . for @xmath269 real positive roots exist for @xmath270 with @xmath275 . in the range where there are two real positive roots , @xmath276 and @xmath277 , only the larger may be in the stable range @xmath278 , ( see fig . [ r_theta_bl ] ) . having found the stationary solutions @xmath216 , the condition for stationary phase @xmath279 can be written@xmath280 with@xmath281 the function @xmath213 acts as the force acting on each oscillator tending to pin its frequency to the order parameter frequency . the range of possible @xmath149 for locked oscillators is limited by the range of @xmath223 corresponding to stable stationary solutions . the stability of the locked solution for an individual oscillator mentioned in the previous section is given by linearizing eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) about the stationary solutions . the linearized equations are@xmath282 the eigenvalues are@xmath283 with @xmath284 this immediately shows us @xmath278 is a necessary condition for stability , since @xmath285 ( with the equality if @xmath286 is negative so that @xmath287 are complex ) . let us first seek the condition for a root @xmath287 to become zero , signaling a stationary bifurcation . it is convenient to go back to the original equations eqs . ( [ theta_r ] ) in the form [ linear ] @xmath288 with@xmath289 then the determinant of the linear matrix derived from eqs . ( [ linear ] ) is@xmath290{cc}-\frac{\partial f}{\partial\bar{\theta } } & -\frac{\partial f}{\partial r}\\ \beta r\cos\bar{\theta } & 1 - 3r^{2}\end{array } \right\vert = -(1 - 3r^{2})\frac{\partial f}{\partial\bar{\theta}}+\beta r\cos\bar{\theta}\frac{\partial f}{\partial r}. \label{det}\ ] ] the stationary solution @xmath216 satisfies eq . ( [ r_theta ] ) and so eq . ( [ det ] ) can be written@xmath291 since@xmath292 thus a zero eigenvalue occurs at and only at stationary points of @xmath213 or at @xmath265 . the latter is where @xmath216 has a vertical tangent ( cf . [ r_theta_bl ] ) but always occurs outside the range of stable solutions , for which we know @xmath278 . the only other possibility for an instability is @xmath293 , @xmath294 . this can occur only at @xmath295 , and if @xmath296 . another result can be derived : if @xmath297 and @xmath272 then the determinant @xmath298 . this implies that the eigenvalues are real ( since the product of a complex conjugate pair is always positive ) , one positive and one negative . thus a negative slope of @xmath213 implies instability . also the hopf bifurcation can only occur at values of @xmath160 where @xmath299 . to satisfy the imaginary part of the self - consistency condition eq . ( [ transverse ] ) , the range of phases of locked oscillator phases must straddle @xmath224 . the oscillator solution here , @xmath300 is always stable for positive @xmath301 , since here @xmath302 . thus the range of possible stable stationary solutions for locked oscillators is given by the range of @xmath160 bounded on either side of @xmath224 by the closest stationary bifurcation point or by a hopf bifurcation occurring at @xmath266 , whichever is closest . we now derive the properties of the locking force , @xmath213 . for small @xmath248 , ( [ rconstant ] ) yields a stationary solution with @xmath303 and so@xmath304 with @xmath305 . thus @xmath213 is a sinusoidal function of angle in this limit . the stable solutions are the positive slope region for @xmath160 between @xmath306 and @xmath307 . [ tbh ] as @xmath240 increases , the behavior becomes quite complicated , and we have not succeeded in proving any results about the full range of possible behavior of @xmath213 . some examples are shown in fig . [ f_lambda ] . for @xmath264 we have not uncovered parameters leading to an @xmath223-curve qualitatively different from that in panel ( a ) , i.e. a single maximum and minimum . note however , that for @xmath308 values of @xmath241 are encountered , and so the hopf bifurcation may limit the range of stable solutions moving away from @xmath224 , before the maximum or minimum of @xmath223 is reached . for @xmath269 the physical solutions are limited to the range @xmath270 , and the slope of @xmath216 diverges at the end points : @xmath309 for @xmath310 and @xmath311 for @xmath312 . since@xmath313 we see that when @xmath314@xmath315 so that @xmath316 with the sign given by the sign of @xmath223 for @xmath317 ( where @xmath318 ) and opposite to the sign of @xmath223 for @xmath319 ( where @xmath320 ) . this shows , for example , that for the parameters such as those in panel ( c ) of fig . [ f_lambda ] where @xmath321 , the slope @xmath322 approaches @xmath323 as @xmath317 . this implies that either there is an additional minimum between the maximum of @xmath223 and @xmath324 as in this panel , or the maximum disappears and @xmath213 becomes monotonically increasing in this region , as for the parameters in panel ( b ) . on the other hand for @xmath325 , parameters between those of panels ( a ) and ( c ) , it turns out that @xmath326 , so that @xmath327 as @xmath328 , and @xmath213 may decrease monotonically between the maximum and @xmath317 . [ tbh ] ) for the first instability of the locked oscillator solution either side of @xmath329 for @xmath330 the value of @xmath331 is nonzero above the dashed curve , and for @xmath332 it is nonzero above the solid curve.,width=268 ] in fig . [ hopf_stationary ] the regions where the first instability on either side of @xmath224 is a hopf bifurcation ( @xmath333 when @xmath334 , with @xmath335 the eigenvalue with larger real value for @xmath330 , and @xmath336 for @xmath332 ) are plotted as a function of @xmath8 and @xmath240 . note that there may be discontinuous jumps from @xmath337 to a finite nonzero value of @xmath331 : for example on the negative @xmath160 side , the minimum in @xmath223 , giving a stationary bifurcation , may disappear by colliding with the maximum , and then the first instability jumps to the hopf bifurcation that was previously not the closest bifurcation to @xmath338 . figure [ hopf_stationary ] does not tell the whole story about whether the boundary of the locked state is a stationary or hopf bifurcation , because in general only the instability on one side of @xmath224 determines the boundary , and which side this is depends on the distribution of oscillator frequencies via the transverse self - consistency condition . this is considered further below . [ tbh ] acting on each oscillator as a function of the phase relative to the order parameter @xmath339 . the dashed portions of the curve correspond to _ stable _ solutions , and the dotted to _ unstable_. the thick solid portion denotes the distribution of oscillator frequencies that must be placed on the stable portion of @xmath223 and must also satisfy the transverse consistency condition.,width=268 ] we have found a range of @xmath160 straddling @xmath224 giving stable locked solutions for individual oscillators . for a fully locked solution , all the oscillators must have solutions to eq . ( [ omega_f ] ) in this range . in addition the imaginary part of the self consistency condition eq . ( [ imselfconsistency ] ) must be satisfied . this can be written in the form@xmath340\,d\bar{\omega}=0 , \label{perp_int_omega}\ ] ] since now there is a unique @xmath160 and @xmath153 for each oscillator frequency . changing the integration variable in eq . ( [ perp_int_omega ] ) to the angle @xmath160 yields@xmath341 the degree of freedom , for fixed @xmath301 and width of frequency distribution @xmath7 , to be determined by this condition is the order parameter frequency @xmath72 . the scheme of imposing the condition is sketched in fig . [ upper_lower ] . the thick solid line , of fixed length @xmath7 along the @xmath223 axis , is to be slid along the curve @xmath213 ( corresponding to varying @xmath72 ) until the integral eq . ( [ perp_int ] ) is zero . all quantities , except @xmath342 are positive , and so this line must straddle the origin . this must be done with all of the solid line lying within the stable ( dashed ) range of @xmath213 . for a bounded frequency distribution we can always find a fully locked solution for large enough @xmath105 . the argument is as follows . first , there is always a range of stable locked oscillator solutions straddling @xmath224 . if we define @xmath343 as the center of the distribution @xmath6 then the order parameter frequency is given by@xmath344 where @xmath345 is @xmath213 evaluated at the center ( with respect to the ordinate ) of the solid portion of the curve in fig . [ upper_lower ] , once eq . ( [ perp_int ] ) is satisfied . since it follows from eqs . ( [ f_bar_theta ] ) and ( [ rconstant ] ) that the slope of @xmath213 at @xmath224 is@xmath346 the range of phase angles of the locked oscillators of order @xmath347 is small for large enough @xmath240 or @xmath348 , and there is always a fully locked solution for a bounded frequency distribution in this limit . the center of the band can then be evaluated as @xmath343 , and so@xmath349 also , in this limit all the oscillators have essentially the same phase , so that @xmath350 and @xmath351 . this gives the complete solution for the fully locked state for very large @xmath10 . it is easiest to understand the limit of the fully locked solution by decreasing @xmath240 at fixed @xmath352 . as @xmath240 decreases , the range of the locking force @xmath223 decreases . we can continue to construct the solution as in fig . [ upper_lower ] , with the portion of the @xmath213 covered by the locked oscillators determined by the transverse self consistency condition , until the first value @xmath353 is reached for which _ either _ the lower end of the locked band would pass below @xmath243 , _ or _ the upper end of the locked band would pass beyond @xmath354 . this signals the onset of instability of the corresponding locked oscillator , either by a stationary or hopf bifurcation depending on @xmath331 at the appropriate @xmath355 or @xmath356 . @xmath355 or @xmath356 may jump discontinuously as a function of @xmath240 if a new bifurcation occurs when @xmath357 , and a new minimum and maximum of @xmath213 are created at a previously interior point of the stable band . in such a case there may be no value of @xmath240 for which one end of the band coincides with @xmath355 or @xmath356 signaling the onset of instability . presumably this corresponds to a first order transition out of the fully locked state . ] [ tbh ] plane for which the instability from the fully locked state is hopf ( shaded ) or stationary ( unshaded ) for a top - hat distribution . the dashed line shows the range of @xmath301 for which @xmath358 for a top - hat distribution . ( note the change of range of @xmath301 plotted compared with fig . [ hopf_stationary].),width=316 ] we could also imagine increasing the width of the distribution @xmath7 from the fully locked solution which occurs at small @xmath7 for fixed @xmath8 and @xmath240 , until one end of the growing band of locked oscillator solutions reaches @xmath355 or @xmath356 . for a top - hat distribution of oscillator frequencies the integral@xmath359 where the integration extends over the whole stable range of @xmath160 , provides an indicator of whether the limit is reached at the lower or upper bound of the stable band : if @xmath360 is _ positive _ , then to satisfy eq . ( [ perp_int ] ) the integral must be _ reduced _ by _ lowering _ the _ upper _ integration bound , and so the range of integration extends from the _ lower _ stability bound . this gives the condition for the maximum @xmath7@xmath361 with @xmath243 the lowest @xmath223 for stable solutions and @xmath345 the value of @xmath223 at the center of the band for @xmath362 . on the other hand if @xmath360 is negative , then the integral eq . ( [ perp_int ] ) must be _ increased _ by _ raising _ the _ lower _ integration bound , and so the range of integration extends to the _ upper _ stability bound . this gives the condition@xmath363 with @xmath354 the largest @xmath223 for stable solutions . we can then find the range of @xmath301 for which the locked state disappears by a hopf or by a stationary bifurcation , fig . [ hopf_stationary_1 ] . this is constructed from fig . [ hopf_stationary ] , giving the conditions for the instabilities at @xmath243 and @xmath354 to be hopf or stationary , and the result just determined for which of these instabilities limits the range of the fully locked solution . numerical results show that for the top - hat distribution the condition @xmath358 occurs only for a restricted range of parameters : large @xmath8 and @xmath240 near @xmath364 , the region to the right of the dashed line in fig . [ hopf_stationary_1 ] . combining these results yields a hopf bifurcation from the fully locked state in the shaded region of fig . [ hopf_stationary_1 ] . for other oscillator distribution shapes we do not have a criterion for the nature of the instability without a detailed solution of the self consistency condition for each width . so far the solution has been developed in terms of @xmath301 . we now determine the magnitude @xmath24 of the order parameter from the parallel self - consistency condition , the real part of eq . ( [ selfconsistency ] ) which can be written in the form@xmath365 where the range of integration is that determined from the transverse self - consistency condition , see fig . [ upper_lower ] . from @xmath366 we can calculate @xmath247 at the boundary of locked solutions . if the dependence @xmath367 is smooth and monotonic , we can map the results depending on @xmath368 onto functions of @xmath369 however , discontinuities in @xmath367 might well occur due to the jumps in the stability range , for example when the stationary bifurcation disappears as described before . this might lead to values of @xmath10 for which no prediction , e.g. for @xmath370 , has been yielded by the algorithm . we do not have results for such cases . [ tbh ] for @xmath371 , @xmath372 , @xmath373 ( top panel ) , and @xmath371 , @xmath374 , @xmath375 ( lower panel ) corresponding to the boundary of the fully locked solution : solid curve - stable solutions ; dashed curve - unstable solutions . the dash - dotted lines straddle the range of @xmath376 of locked oscillators , between @xmath355 and @xmath377 . the values of the order parameter are 0.92 ( upper panel ) and 0.93 ( lower panel).,width=268 ] two examples of the construction of locked solutions for the triangular distribution , defined below in eqs . ( [ triangular ] ) , are shown in fig . [ twobeta ] : the first for small @xmath248 , where a solution @xmath216 exists for all @xmath160 ; and the second for larger @xmath240 where there are ranges of @xmath160 for which no physical solution for the magnitude ( i.e. real and positive ) exists . the value of @xmath240 for which eq . ( [ transverse ] ) is satisfied in each case was found by simple bisection applied to the numerical results of the integration . in both the cases shown the boundary of the fully locked region occurs when @xmath378 . for the smaller value of @xmath240 this condition corresponds to the limit of the existence range of solutions . for the larger value of @xmath240 the limit occurs at the instability of the locked oscillator solution , which develops via a hopf bifurcation ( @xmath379 ) . results for the boundary of the fully locked state for a top - hat distribution with @xmath99 are shown in fig . [ th_pd ] , and for the triangular distribution with @xmath99 in fig . [ tri_pd ] . in this section we present detailed results for the case of a lorentzian distribution of frequencies . we concentrate on a distribution with @xmath99 , but also present some results for a wider distribution @xmath380 , which shows some novel features . we begin this section by calculating the linear stability of the unsynchronized state . since the lorentzian distribution is unbounded , there is no fully locked solution . for the purposes of analysis we choose , without loss of generality , a lorentzian distribution @xmath6 centered about zero frequency@xmath381 the half width at half height is @xmath7 . in terms of the shifted frequency @xmath149 the distribution is@xmath382 with@xmath383 the integrals eqs . ( [ integrals ] ) are @xmath384 the imaginary part of the self consistency condition eq . ( [ perp_integrals ] ) reduces to @xmath385 this serves to fix the frequency of the order parameter @xmath72 at the onset of synchronization via eq . ( [ define_delta ] ) in terms of the parameters of the system @xmath386 . there are _ two _ solutions for @xmath387@xmath388 for large @xmath8 or small @xmath7 the approximate solutions are @xmath389 giving a locking frequency near the center of the band of the free running oscillators , and @xmath390 giving a locking frequency far in the tails . note that the requirement that @xmath387 is real means that @xmath8 must be sufficiently large @xmath391 with@xmath392 for @xmath393 the unsynchronized state is linearly stable for all values of @xmath10 . the critical value of @xmath10 is determined from eq . ( [ par_integrals ] ) and evaluates to@xmath394 where the expression eq . ( [ delta ] ) for @xmath387 is to be substituted . given a width @xmath7 of the oscillator distribution , for each @xmath395 there are two critical values of @xmath10 : @xmath396 and @xmath397 [ corresponding to the minus and plus signs in the expression eq . ( [ delta ] ) for @xmath387 ] , such that the unsynchronized state is _ unstable _ for @xmath399 . it is remarkable that for very strong coupling , @xmath10 large , the unsynchronized state remains stable . however , as we have already seen and will discuss in more detail , a large amplitude synchronized state is also stable in this regime . for @xmath400 the results for @xmath208 reduces to @xmath401 and @xmath402 . in the limit @xmath403 the former result reproduces the result @xmath404 expected from the reduction to the phase equation valid in this limit . we have used simulations to confirm the boundaries for instability of the unsynchronized state as well as to study the behavior subsequent to the instability . the numerical results use the cutoff lorentzian form introduced in eq . ( [ eq_para_lort ] ) . two widths are considered : a narrow one with a peak height of @xmath99 and one approximately twice as wide with @xmath405 . in all cases the distribution tails are removed above some large frequency . qualitative differences in the phase diagrams are observed for the two distribution widths . [ tbh ] . solid and dashed lines show analytical results of the linear stability of the unsynchronized state . numerics show the bifurcations are supercritical along the solid portions and subcritical along the dashed portion . dash - dotted lines are saddle - node bifurcations observed in numerical simulations . states are : @xmath406 - unsynchronized ; @xmath407 synchronized with small and large amplitude respectively.,width=316 ] the phase diagram for the ( narrow ) lorentzian distribution with @xmath99 is shown in fig . [ lorentzianpd ] . the solid and dashed lines are the analytically obtained stability boundaries of the unsynchronized solution . the numerical simulations show that over the dashed portion of the linear instability curve the bifurcation is subcritical , giving a jump in the order parameter magnitude @xmath24 at onset . in addition the sweeps yield a number of saddle - node bifurcations identified as discontinuous jumps in @xmath24 ; these are denoted by dash - dotted lines in fig . [ lorentzianpd ] ; we do not have closed form relations for these boundaries . thus along the dashed or dash - dotted portions of the boundaries , discontinuous jumps in @xmath24 occur , either between the unsynchronized state and a synchronized state , or between two synchronized states with different values of @xmath24 . the two synchronized states are labelled @xmath408 and @xmath409 in fig . [ lorentzianpd ] . when they coexist at the same @xmath8 and @xmath10 the state @xmath409 has the larger value of @xmath24 , but for both states @xmath24 may go to zero , connecting continuously with the unsynchronized state @xmath406 , for some values of @xmath410 . [ tbh ] showing the time averaged order parameter magnitude @xmath411 as a function of @xmath10 from numerical simulations of the cutoff lorentzian distribution with @xmath99 . in panel ( a ) the only solutions are the unsynchronized ( @xmath406 ) and large @xmath24 synchronized ( @xmath409 ) states , while in panels ( b ) and ( c ) the small @xmath24 synchronized solution is also stable . arrows denote discontinuous jumps that were observed as simulations followed the various solution branches.,width=316 ] representative phase diagram slices for the lorentzian case with @xmath99 , showing the time - averaged order parameter magnitudes @xmath115 as a function of @xmath10 at fixed @xmath8 , are presented in fig . [ fig_cuts_ahalf_d8 ] . in agreement with eq . ( [ eq_amin ] ) the unsynchronized state is stable for all @xmath10 provided @xmath412 . simulations find the @xmath409 solution is bistable with @xmath406 over this @xmath8 range at larger @xmath10 values , as shown in fig . [ fig_cuts_ahalf_d8](a ) . for @xmath413 the unsynchronized state is unstable over a range in @xmath10 . as shown in fig . [ fig_cuts_ahalf_d8](b ) for a range of @xmath8 near @xmath414 a subcritical bifurcation occurs at @xmath396 as the @xmath406 solution becomes unstable and @xmath409 forms . with increasing @xmath10 @xmath409 is the only stable solution until a region of bistability where both synchronized solutions coexist . as shown in the phase diagram there is a small region ( labelled @xmath415 ) over which all three solutions are simultaneously stable . this region of tristability can be observed in fig . [ fig_cuts_ahalf_d8](b ) , over the @xmath10 range of hysteric transition between @xmath408 and @xmath406 near @xmath416 . with increasing @xmath8 the system passes through a tricritical point where the subcritical bifurcation at @xmath396 becomes supercritical . the tricritical point has a codimension of 2 . an example slice at @xmath8 sufficiently large that the bifurcation is supercritical is shown in fig . [ fig_cuts_ahalf_d8](c ) , where with increasing @xmath10 regions of bistability between the synchronized solutions and then @xmath406 and @xmath409 are observed . [ tbh ] slices from numerical simulations of the cutoff wide lorentzian with @xmath405 . shown is the time averaged order parameter magnitude @xmath115 for a range of @xmath10 at three @xmath8 values : ( a ) @xmath417 , ( b ) @xmath418 , and ( c ) @xmath419 . these solutions are observed in an array of @xmath67 oscillators with a lorentzian frequency distribution with @xmath405 and a cutoff frequency of @xmath420 . the dashed box region in panel ( c ) is examined more closely in fig . [ fig_zig_zag].,width=316 ] we now consider a lorentzian frequency distribution of approximately twice the width . specifically , we take @xmath405 in eq . ( [ eq_para_lort ] ) or eq . ( [ lorentzian_analytic ] ) . there are a number of changes to the details of the phase diagram that we do not discuss in detail . several of these are straightforward consequences of the wider frequency spread : for example the instability of the unsynchronized solution moves to larger @xmath8 and @xmath10 . instead we focus on two particular features . the first new feature that is evident from the fixed @xmath8 cuts shown in fig . [ fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16 ] is the reconnection of the branches of synchronized solutions that occurs as @xmath8 is decreased . in fig . [ fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16](c ) , typical of larger values of @xmath8 , the synchronized state growing from the @xmath397 instability ends at a saddle - node bifurcation , with the order parameter jumping to larger values as @xmath10 is decreased . this is the same as the behavior for the narrower distribution , fig . [ fig_cuts_ahalf_d8 ] . on the other hand for smaller values of @xmath8 , as in fig.[fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16](a ) , this state merges continuously with the larger magnitude state . this change in the topology of the solution branches as @xmath8 increases occurs through the development of two additional saddle - nodes , as shown in fig.[fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16](b ) near @xmath421 , and the collision of one of these with the saddle - node terminating the large-@xmath10 upper branch . [ tbh ] synchronized solution for a lorentzian frequency distribution ( color online ) . shown are the results for @xmath67 , @xmath419 , and a cutoff lorentzian distribution with @xmath405 and @xmath420 . the arrows denote the direction of the @xmath10 sweep , and the states are colored red for an upward sweep , green for a downward sweep , and black if both directions lead to the same state . the + symbols denote the starting point for particular sweeps to traverse a state interior to the band ( green for the start of a downward sweep , red for an upward sweep ) . panel ( a ) is a magnification of the dashed box in fig . [ fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16](c ) showing the @xmath115 over a range of @xmath10 . in ( b ) the corresponding size of the synchronized cluster measured by the synchronization index is shown.,width=316 ] another apparent difference with the wider frequency distribution is the steps displayed by the large amplitude synchronized state at larger @xmath10 in fig . [ fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16 ] . while these steps also occur with the narrow frequency distribution , their increased amplitude with the wider frequency distribution facilitates the presentation of the behavior . as an example , the dashed region in fig . [ fig_soln_cuts_a1_d16](c ) is shown enlarged in fig . [ fig_zig_zag ] . panel ( a ) in this figure plots the time averaged order parameter magnitude @xmath411 , while ( b ) shows that the solution changes correlate exactly with changes in the number of oscillators locked to the synchronized cluster . interestingly , the solution follows different trajectories depending on the history of changing @xmath10 . for example , if @xmath10 is monotonically increased the system settles onto the upper trajectory of solution steps ( colored red ) while the lower trajectory of solution steps ( colored green ) is observed when @xmath10 is monotonically decreased . these solutions overlap at smaller @xmath10 ( colored black ) . the two solution trajectories are in fact the boundaries of a band of multistable solution branches . this structure is demonstrated in fig . [ fig_zig_zag](a ) by beginning the system on each of these two boundaries and reversing the direction of @xmath10 variation . now as @xmath10 changes the solution moves off its boundary along a continuous line to the other boundary where it follows the expected path for that sense of @xmath10 changes . starting solutions are represented by the + symbols colored for the direction that @xmath10 is to be varied . beginning on the lower boundary , that is observed when decreasing @xmath10 , and increasing @xmath10 from the lower ( red ) + the oscillators follow the solid ( black ) line in the direction of the upward arrow to the upper boundary . likewise , beginning on the upper boundary , that is observed when increasing @xmath10 , and decreasing @xmath10 the oscillators display a series of states beginning with the upper ( green ) + and follow the solid ( black ) line to the lower boundary in the direction of the downward arrow . in this way , the synchronized solution with large time - averaged order parameter magnitude turns out to be a band of solutions , with striations that can be accessed by appropriate changes in @xmath10 . the same is true for the narrow lorentzian , however the band is smaller . the steps in the magnitude of the order parameter are found to be associated with jumps in the number of oscillators locked to the phase of the order parameter . defining a synchronized cluster as the oscillators locked to @xmath70 we find the discrete steps in @xmath24 are due to a small group of oscillators leaving the cluster , and then recombining with the cluster one at a time as @xmath10 increases . in fig . [ fig_zig_zag](b ) the cluster size is measured by the phase synchronization index , defined by eq . [ eq_sync_ind ] , as the number of oscillators with @xmath422 , where @xmath56 is some small number , @xmath423 , to allow for some phase variation over the finite time of measurement . with increasing system size any small group of oscillators leaving the cluster can be expected to have decreasing influence on the order parameter . as the number of oscillators tends to infinity the solution band becomes a region densely populated by these striations as the discrete steps become closer and decrease in length . for the simulations in fig . [ fig_zig_zag ] @xmath67 oscillators were used . to investigate finite size effects we also studied this solution using @xmath424 and @xmath425 . with increasing system size the individual steps on each solution boundary occur over a more narrow range in @xmath10 , becoming shorter in length , and correspondingly more densely packed . thereby , while the discrete steps will disappear in the infinite size limit the width of the band of synchronized solutions remains nearly the same . in this limit synchronized states will move along one of the striations to the band boundary appropriate for the direction of the @xmath10 sweep . for bounded distributions we can calculate the linear stability boundaries of both the unsynchronized and the fully synchronized states . we first do this for a uniform bounded distribution , which we call a top - hat distribution . a top hat distribution centered on @xmath343 is given by@xmath102{cc}$w^{-1}$ & for $ \left\vert \omega\right\vert \leq w/2$\\ $ 0 $ & for $ \left\vert \omega\right\vert > w/2$\end{tabular } \ \ \ \ \right.\ ] ] the integrals eqs . ( [ integrals ] ) for this distribution are @xmath426 , \\ i_{2 } & = \frac{1}{w}\ln\left\vert \frac{w-2\delta}{w+2\delta}\right\vert , \\ i_{3 } & = \frac{1}{2w}\ln\left [ \frac{1+(w-2\delta)^{2}/16}{1+(w+2\delta ) ^{2}/16}\right ] , \\ i_{4 } & = \left\ { \begin{tabular } [ c]{cc}$\frac{\pi}{w}$ & for$~\delta < w/2$\\ $ 0 $ & for $ \delta > w/2$\end{tabular } \ \ \ \right . .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the self consistency equations ( [ perp_integrals ] ) and ( [ par_integrals ] ) can be solved numerically . the equations simplify in the limit of small @xmath7 , and the results here can be displayed in closed form . in small @xmath7 limit there is one solution of eq . ( [ perp_integrals ] ) giving a locked frequency within the band of ( shifted ) oscillator frequencies , @xmath427 , for which @xmath428 and @xmath429 may be neglected in the small @xmath7 limit . equation ( [ perp_integrals ] ) then gives the explicit expression for the frequency offset from mid band @xmath430 and eq . ( [ par_integrals ] ) gives the condition of the parameters at the onset of synchronization@xmath431 notice that for large @xmath8 the locking frequency is close to the center of the band , and the critical condition reduces to@xmath432 the value expected from the mapping onto the kuramoto model for large @xmath433 . for small @xmath8 on the other hand @xmath387 approaches @xmath434 giving us the result that the locking frequency approaches the upper edge of the band . in this case the onset occurs at @xmath435 . even for moderate values of @xmath8 such as @xmath436 , the locking frequency is far off the band center ( a fraction @xmath437 of the half band width for @xmath436 ) . the second solution to eq . ( [ perp_integrals ] ) in the small @xmath7 limit gives an order parameter frequency _ outside _ of the band , @xmath438 . for small @xmath7 the frequency is given by@xmath439 and the onset of synchronization occurs at@xmath440 the solution that grows from this instability is a remarkable state in that it is _ synchronized _ in the sense that there is a nonzero value of the order parameter @xmath441 , but there are no oscillators _ frequency locked _ to one another or to the frequency of the order parameter : a plot of the actual frequency distribution as in figs . [ fig_smr_plateau](a ) and [ fig_lgr_plateau](a ) shows a smooth curve with no plateau . numerical investigation of this state shows that instead , the distribution of oscillators @xmath442 is enhanced for phases near the phase of the order parameter : oscillators slow down in this vicinity ( i.e.@xmath443 becomes smaller ) , but do not come to rest relative to the order parameter . now the ordered oscillator frequency plot is continuous , with no plateau of locked oscillators . [ tbh ] such that @xmath99 . the solid and dashed lines are from the linear stability analysis of the unsynchronized state : the unsynchronized state is unstable for @xmath10 values between the two portions of these lines . the numerical results show that the solid portion is supercritical , whereas the dashed portion is subcritical . dash - dotted lines are saddle - node bifurcations from numerical simulations . the dotted line is the stability boundary of the fully locked solution calculated using the methods of sec . [ sec_fulllocking ] . states are as in fig . [ lorentzianpd ] with , in addition , @xmath444 denoting the fully locked state.,width=316 ] the linear instability boundaries for a top - hat distribution of full width @xmath445 ( giving @xmath99 ) are shown as the solid and dashed lines in fig . [ th_pd ] . the approximate solutions eqs . ( [ u - approx1]-[u - approx4 ] ) turn out to be quite accurate even for @xmath445 : the approximate curves are indistinguishable from the numerical curves in fig . [ th_pd ] . note that unlike the case of the lorentzian distribution , the linear instability persists for @xmath446 . in this limit the frequency of the order parameter is right at the edge of the distribution of oscillator frequencies . the discontinuity of the distribution of oscillator frequencies at the band edge seems to be responsible for the persistence of the instability to small values of the coupling constants . [ tbh ] over a range of @xmath10 is shown for constant @xmath8 : ( a ) @xmath447 , ( b ) @xmath448 , ( c ) @xmath449 , and ( d ) @xmath450 . in these simulations @xmath67 and the width @xmath445.,width=316 ] the boundary of the fully - locked solution calculated using the analysis of sec . [ sec_fulllocking ] is also shown on fig.[th_pd ] as the dotted line . in addition we have performed a careful numerical scan of the @xmath451 plane for @xmath67 or @xmath452 oscillators with a uniform distribution of full width unity . these results confirm the analytic predictions , and again show additional transitions that are inaccessible to our analytic calculations . the numerics shows that the linear instability from the unsynchronized state is subcritical over the dashed portion of the linear instability curves as shown in the figure . other saddle - node bifurcations are shown as dash - dotted lines . the complete phase diagram is quite complicated . some representative numerical sweeps are shown in fig . [ fig_cuts_tophat ] . [ tbh ] oscillators having a triangular frequency distribution with @xmath99 . the time - averaged order parameter magnitude @xmath115 is plotted over a range of @xmath10 at fixed @xmath8 : ( a ) @xmath453 , ( b ) @xmath454 , and ( c ) @xmath455.,width=316 ] we finally present results for when the oscillators have a triangular frequency distribution@xmath102{cc}$(4/w^{2})(w/2-\left\vert \omega\right\vert ) $ & for $ \left\vert \omega\right\vert \leq w/2$\\ $ 0 $ & for $ \left\vert \omega\right\vert > w/2$\end{tabular } \ \ \ \ \ \ .\ \right . \label{triangular}\ ] ] this is the case studied in reference @xcite . the triangular distribution is bounded , and so can have a fully locked state as for the top - hat distribution , but does not have the discontinuity in @xmath6 at the edge of the distribution leading to singular behavior as @xmath456 for that distribution . the results are compiled from the linear stability analysis of the unsynchronized and fully locked state , as well as numerical investigation , usually of @xmath457 oscillators , as shown in fig . [ fig_tri_cuts ] . the integrals eqs . ( [ integrals ] ) needed for the stability analysis of the unsynchronized state can again be done in closed form , but the results are too cumbersome to list here . [ tbh ] such that @xmath99 . symbols and lines are as in fig . [ th_pd].,width=316 ] the results for @xmath458 for @xmath99 ( a width @xmath375 ) given by numerically solving eqs . ( [ perp_integrals ] ) and ( [ par_integrals ] ) are shown as the full and dashed lines in fig . [ tri_pd ] . simulations show that this transition is subcritical over the dashed portions . in addition , as in fig . [ th_pd ] , saddle - node bifurcations identified by jumps in the order parameter magnitude @xmath24 in the simulations are shown by dash - dotted curves . as for the top - hat distribution , the large @xmath10 limit of the instability region corresponds to an order parameter frequency _ outside _ of the band of shifted oscillator frequencies , so that there is no oscillator with a frequency equal to that of the order parameter . this seems to be the typical result for a bounded distribution . for the unbounded lorentzian distribution on the other hand , there are some oscillators that lock to the order parameter frequency at the large @xmath10 instability . however even for this distribution , for most values of @xmath8 the order parameter frequency is far in the tails of the distribution , and there are few oscillators at this frequency . presumably the effect of these locked oscillators on the critical @xmath10 is small , so that the dominant physics at this transition for bounded and unbounded distributions is not very different . near the smallest @xmath8 where the upper and lower stability boundaries meet , the order parameter frequencies of the two solutions approach the edge of the band ( from either side ) . in summary , we have analyzed in detail a model for the synchronization of nonlinear oscillators where the ordering arises from the reactive coupling between the oscillators , combined with the nonlinear frequency pulling of the individual oscillators . such a model may be a more realistic description than previous models for a variety of physical systems where dissipation plays a relatively minor role , for example high - q mechanical oscillators and some optical systems . more generally , the model may give a more complete description of synchronization where the individual frequencies are internally tuned in response to a mismatch with other frequencies in the ensemble , such as might occur in biological systems . we have presented detailed analytic calculations for the onset of partial synchronization from the unsynchronized state , as well as the existence and bounds of the fully locked synchronized state at large coupling and nonlinearity for the cases of bounded frequency distributions . the analytical calculations together with numerical simulations have been used to construct detailed phase diagrams of the different synchronized states as a function of the two parameters of the model , the coefficient of the nonlinear frequency pulling @xmath8 and the coupling constant @xmath10 , for various frequency distributions . the intersections of the various synchronized states lead to rich phase diagrams . there are a number of interesting features of these phase diagrams . the instability of the unsynchronized state occurs over a limited range of @xmath10 at fixed @xmath8 , so that the unsynchronized state regains stability at very large values of the coupling strength , although a large amplitude synchronized state also occurs here , often terminated by a saddle - node bifurcation as @xmath10 is decreased . this large amplitude synchronized state may also survive down to @xmath447 , i.e. even in the absence of the nonlinear frequency pulling . for bounded distributions the state that develops from the linear instability of the unsynchronized state as @xmath10 is decreased is synchronized ( the order parameter is nonzero ) but there is no frequency locking . the phase diagrams also show a wide variety of multistability , with one or more synchronized states and the unsynchronized state coexisting over various parameter ranges , leading to hysteresis as the parameters are varied . the multistability may be particularly dramatic for the large amplitude synchronized states such as displayed in fig . [ fig_zig_zag ] where many synchronized states coexist , leading to a band of solutions in the large @xmath25 limit . this paper is based upon work supported by the national science foundation under grant no . dmr-0314069 , hrl laboratories , llc under contract no . sr04209 , the u.s .- israel binational science foundation grant no . 2004339 , and the physbio program with funds from the european union and nato . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in this paper we study the optimal stopping problems in an uncertain environment . the classical solution to the optimal stopping problems based on the dynamic programming principle assumes that there is a unique subjective prior distribution driving the reward process . however , for example , in incomplete financial markets , we have to deal with multiple equivalent martingale measures not being sure which one underlies the market . in fact under the presence of the multiple possible distributions , a solution of the optimal stopping problem by maximization with respect to some subjective prior can not be reliable . instead , it is reasonable to view the multitude of possible distributions as a kind of _ model uncertainty risk _ which should be taken into account while formulating an optimal stopping problem . here one may draw on concepts from the theory of risk measures . as the established generic notion for static risk assessment at present time @xmath14 , convex risk measures are specific functionals @xmath15 on vector spaces of random variables viewed as financial risks ( see @xcite and @xcite ) . they typically have the following type of robust representation @xmath16 - \gamma_{0}({\mathrm{q}})\bigr\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 denotes the set of probability measures which are absolutely continuous w.r.t . a given reference probability measure @xmath18 and @xmath19 is some penalty function ( see e.g. @xcite and @xcite ) . in this way , model uncertainty is incorporated , as no specific probability measure is assumed . moreover , the penalty function scales the plausibility of models . turning over from static to dynamic risk assessment , convex risk measures have been extended to the concept of conditional convex risk measures @xmath20 at a future time @xmath21 which are specific functions on the space of financial risks with random outcomes ( see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ) . under some regularity conditions , they have a robust representation of the form ( see e.g. @xcite , @xcite or ( * ? ? ? 11 ) ) @xmath22-\gamma_t({\mathrm{q}})\bigr\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath23 is a ( random ) penalty function and @xmath24 consists of all @xmath25 with @xmath26 as in ( [ rhostatic ] ) , the robust representation mirrors the model uncertainty , but now at a future time @xmath8 in recent years the optimal stopping with families @xmath27}$ ] of conditional convex risk measures was subject of several studies . for example , the works @xcite and @xcite are settled within a time - discrete framework , where in addition the latter one provides some dual representations extending the well - known ones from the classical optimal stopping . optimal stopping in continuous time was considered in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . all these contributions restrict their analysis to the families @xmath27}$ ] satisfying the property of time consistency , sometimes also called recursiveness , defined to mean @xmath28 hence the results of the above papers can not be , for example , used to solve optimal stopping problems under such very popular convex risk measure as average value at risk . the only paper which tackled the case of non time - consistent families of conditional convex risk measures so far is @xcite , where the authors considered the so - called distorted mean payoff functionals . however , the analysis of @xcite excludes the case of average value at risk as well . moreover , the class of processes to be stopped is limited to the functions of a one - dimensional geometric brownian motion . the main probabilistic tool used in @xcite is the skorokhod embedding . in this paper we consider a rather general class of conditional convex risk measures having representation with @xmath29 $ ] for some lower semicontinuous convex mapping @xmath1.$ ] the related class of risk measures @xmath15 known as the class of _ divergence risk measures _ or _ optimized certainty equivalents _ was first introduced in @xcite , @xcite . any divergence risk measure has the representation @xmath30\ ] ] with @xmath31,\ , y\mapsto\sup_{x\geq 0}(xy - \phi(x)).\ ] ] ( cf . @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , or appendix [ appendixaa ] ) . here we study the problem of optimally stopping the reward process @xmath32 where @xmath9}$ ] is an adapted nonnegative , right - continuous stochastic process with @xmath33 } y_t$ ] satisfying some suitable integrability condition . we do not assume any time - consistency for the family @xmath34 and basically impose no further restrictions on @xmath35 . our main result is the representation @xmath36\right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which allows one to apply the well known methods from the theory of ordinary optimal stopping problems . in particular , we derive the so - called additive dual representation of the form : @xmath37}\big(\phi^{*}(x+ y_{t } ) - x - m_{t}\big)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath38 is the class of adapted martingales vanishing at time 0 . this dual representation generalizes the well - known dual representation of rogers , @xcite . the representation together with can be used to efficiently construct lower and upper bounds for the optimal value by monte carlo . the paper is organised as follows . in section [ setup ] we introduce notation and set up the optimal stopping problem . the main results are presented in section [ main_results ] where in particular a criterion ensuring the existence of a saddle - point in is formulated . section [ discussion ] contains some discussion on the main results and on their relation to the previous literature . a monte carlo algorithm for computing lower and upper bounds for the value function is formulated in section [ mc ] , where also an example of optimal stopping under average value at risk is numerically analized . the crucial idea to derive representation is to consider the optimal stopping problem @xmath39 where @xmath40 denotes the set of all randomized stopping times on @xmath11.$ ] it will be studied in section [ optimalrandomizedstoppingtimes ] , where in particular it will turn out that this optimal stopping problem has the same optimal value as the originial one . finally , the proofs are collected in section [ proofs ] . let @xmath41 be a probability space and denote by @xmath42 the class of all finitely - valued random variables ( modulo the @xmath4-a.s . equivalence ) . let @xmath43 be a young function , i.e. , a left - continuous , nondecreasing convex function @xmath44 $ ] such that @xmath45 and @xmath46 . the orlicz space associated with @xmath43 is defined as @xmath47<\infty~ \mbox { for some $ c>0$}\big\}.\ ] ] it is a banach space when endowed with the luxemburg norm @xmath48\leq 1\right\}.\ ] ] the orlicz heart is @xmath49<\infty~ \mbox { for all $ c>0$}\big\}.\ ] ] for example , if @xmath50 for some @xmath51 then @xmath52 is the usual @xmath53space . in this case @xmath54 where @xmath55 stands for @xmath53norm . if @xmath43 takes the value @xmath56 , then @xmath57 and @xmath58 is defined to consist of all @xmath59essentially bounded random variables . by jensen inequality , we always have @xmath60 in the case of finite @xmath61 we see that @xmath62 is a linear subspace of @xmath63 which is dense w.r.t . @xmath64 ( see theorem 2.1.14 in @xcite ) . let @xmath65 and let @xmath66 be a filtered probability space , where @xmath67}$ ] is a right - continuous filtration with @xmath68 containing only the sets with probability @xmath14 or @xmath69 as well as all the null sets of @xmath70 . furthermore , consider a lower semicontinuous convex mapping @xmath1 $ ] satisfying @xmath71 for some @xmath72 @xmath73 and @xmath74 its fenchel - legendre transform @xmath75 is a finite nondecreasing convex function whose restriction @xmath76 to @xmath77 is a finite young function ( cf . lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] in appendix [ appendixaa ] ) . we shall use @xmath78 to denote the orlicz heart w.r.t . @xmath79 then we can define a conditional convex risk measure @xmath80}$ ] via @xmath81- { \mathbb{e}}\left[\left.\phi\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{q}}}{d{\mathrm{p}}}\right)\right |{\mathcal f}_{t}\right]\right)\ ] ] for all @xmath82 where @xmath83 denotes the set of all probability measures @xmath3 which are absolutely continuous w.r.t . @xmath4 such that @xmath84 is @xmath59integrable and @xmath5 on @xmath6 note that @xmath85 is @xmath59integrable for every @xmath86 and any @xmath87 due to the young s inequality . consider now a right - continuous nonnegative stochastic process @xmath88 adapted to @xmath89 furthermore , let @xmath10 contain all finite stoping times @xmath90 w.r.t . @xmath89 the main object of our study is the following optimal stopping problem @xmath91 if we set @xmath92 for @xmath93 and @xmath94 otherwise , we end up with the classical stopping problem @xmath95.\ ] ] it is well known that the optimal value of the problem may be viewed as a risk neutral price of the american option with the discounted payoff @xmath96}$ ] at time @xmath97 however , in face of incompleteness , it seems to be not appropriate to assume the uniqueness of the risk neutral measure . instead , the uncertainty about the stochastic process driving the payoff @xmath98 should be taken into account . considering the optimal value of the problem ( [ stoppproblem ] ) as an alternative pricing rule , model uncertainty risk is incorporated by taking the supremum over @xmath83 where the penalty function is used to assess the plausibility of possible models . the more plausible is the model , the lower is the value of the penalty function . let us illustrate our setup in the case of the so called average value at risk risk measure . the average value at risk risk measure at level @xmath990,1]$ ] is defined as the following functional : @xmath100 where @xmath101 and @xmath102 denotes the left - continuous quantile function of the distribution function @xmath103 of @xmath104 defined by @xmath105 for @xmath990,1[$ ] . note that @xmath106 $ ] for any @xmath107 moreover , it is well known that @xmath108\quad\mbox{for}\ , x\in l^{1},\ ] ] where @xmath109 is the young function defined by @xmath110 for @xmath111 and @xmath112 otherwise ( cf . * theorem 4.52 ) and @xcite ) . observe that the set @xmath113 consists of all probability measures on @xmath70 with @xmath114a.s .. hence the optimal stopping problem ( [ stoppproblem ] ) reads as follows @xmath115 the family @xmath116}$ ] of conditional convex risk measure associated with @xmath109 is also known as the conditional av@r @xmath117}$ ] at level @xmath118 ( cf . * definition 11.8 ) ) . [ entropicriskmeasure ] let us consider , for any @xmath119 the continuous convex mapping @xmath120 } : [ 0,\infty[\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}}$ ] defined by @xmath120}(x ) = ( x\ln(x ) - x + 1)/\gamma$ ] for @xmath121 and @xmath120}(0 ) = 1/\gamma.$ ] the fenchel - legendre transform of @xmath120}$ ] is given by @xmath120}^{*}(y ) = ( \exp(\gamma y ) - 1)/\gamma$ ] for @xmath122 in view of lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixaa ] ) the corresponding risk measure @xmath123}}$ ] has the representation @xmath124}}(x ) = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{\exp(\gamma x - \gamma x ) - 1}{\gamma } - x\right ] = \frac{\ln\big({\mathbb{e}}[\exp ( - \gamma x)]\big)}{\gamma}\ ] ] for @xmath125}^{*}}.$ ] this is the well - known entropic risk measure . optimal stopping with the entropic risk measures is easy to handle , since it can be reduced to the standard optimal stopping problems via @xmath126}}(-y_{\tau } ) = \frac{1}{\gamma}\cdot\ln\big(\sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}\big[\exp(\gamma y_{\tau})\big]\big).\ ] ] [ polynomial ] set @xmath127 } = x^{p}/p$ ] for any @xmath1281,\infty[,$ ] then the set @xmath129},0}$ ] contains all probability measures @xmath3 on @xmath70 with @xmath130 and @xmath131}}(x ) = \sup\limits_{{\mathrm{q}}\in { \mathcal q}_{\phi^{[p]},0}}\left({\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathrm{q}}}[- x ] - \frac{1}{p}~{\mathbb{e}}\left[\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{q}}}{d{\mathrm{p}}}\right)^{p}\right]\right)\quad\mbox{for}~x\in l^{p/(p - 1)}.\ ] ] let @xmath132 denote the topological interior of the effective domain of the mapping @xmath1.$ ] we shall assume @xmath133 to be a lower semicontinuous convex function satisfying @xmath134 the following theorem is our main result . [ new_representation ] let @xmath135 be atomless with countably generated @xmath136 for every @xmath137 furthermore , let ( [ annahmen young function ] ) be fulfilled , and let @xmath33}y_{t}\in h^{\phi^{*}},$ ] then @xmath138\\ & = & \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x ] < \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ optimalstoppingoptimizedcertainty ] the functional @xmath139\ ] ] is known as the optimized certainty equivalent w.r.t . @xmath140 ( cf . @xcite,@xcite ) . thus the relationship @xmath141 = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] may also be viewed as a representation result for optimal stopping with optimized certainty equivalents . let us illustrate theorem [ new_representation ] for the case @xmath142 with some @xmath990,1].$ ] the young function @xmath109 satisfies the conditions of theorem [ new_representation ] if and only if @xmath143 the fenchel - legendre transform @xmath144 of @xmath133 is given by @xmath145 and it fullfills the inequality @xmath146 for @xmath147 then , as an immediate consequence of theorem [ new_representation ] , we obtain the following primal representation for the optimal stopping problem ( [ av@rstopping ] ) . [ representation av@r ] let @xmath148 be atomless with countably generated @xmath136 for every @xmath137 if @xmath33}y_{t}\in l^{1},$ ] then it holds for @xmath990,1[$ ] @xmath149\\ & = & \inf_{x\leq 0}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{\alpha}\ , ( x + y_{\tau})^{+ } - x\right ] < \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us now consider the case @xmath150}$ ] for some @xmath1511,\infty[.$ ] this mapping meets all requirements of theorem [ new_representation ] , and @xmath127^{*}}(x ) = \phi^{\left[p/(p-1)\right]}(x^{+}).$ ] then by theorem [ new_representation ] , we have the following primal representation of the corresponding optimal stopping problem . [ primalrepresentation ] let @xmath148 be atomless with countably generated @xmath136 for every @xmath137 if @xmath33}y_{t}\in l^{p/(p-1)}$ ] for some @xmath1511,\infty[,$ ] then @xmath152}}(-y_{\tau } ) = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{(p-1)\ , \big((x + y_{\tau})^{+}\big)^{p/(p-1)}}{p } - x\right ] < \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] a natural question is whether we can find a real number @xmath153 and a @xmath154-stopping time @xmath155 which solve . we may give a fairly general answer within the context of discrete time optimal stopping problems . in order to be more precise , let @xmath156 denote all stopping times from @xmath10 with values in @xmath157 where @xmath158 is any finite subset of @xmath11 $ ] containing @xmath159 consider now the stopping problem @xmath160 turning over to the filtration @xmath161}$ ] defined by @xmath162}$ ] with @xmath163 : = { \max}\{s\in{\mathbb{t}}\mid s\leq t\},$ ] we see that @xmath164}$ ] with @xmath165}$ ] describes some @xmath166adapted process . hence we can apply theorem [ new_representation ] to get @xmath167\\ & = & \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this section we want to find conditions which guarantee the existence of a saddle point for the optimization problems @xmath168\,\mbox{over}\,\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}\,\ ] ] and @xmath169\,\mbox{over}\ , x\in{\mathbb{r}}.\ ] ] to this end , we shall borrow some arguments from the theory of lyapunoff s theorem for infinite - dimensional vector measures . a central concept in this context is the notion of _ thin subsets _ of integrable mappings . so let us first recall it . for a fixed probability space @xmath170 a subset @xmath171 is called thin if for any @xmath172 with @xmath173 there is some nonzero @xmath174 vanishing outside @xmath175 and satisfying @xmath176 = 0 $ ] for every @xmath177 ( cf . @xcite , or @xcite ) . best known examples are finite subsets of @xmath178 or finite - dimensional linear subspaces of @xmath178 if @xmath179 is atomless ( cf . @xcite , or @xcite ) . [ saddle - point ] let the assumptions of theorem [ new_representation ] be fulfilled , and let @xmath180 with @xmath181 moreover , let @xmath182\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\right\}$ ] be a thin subset of @xmath183 for @xmath184 with @xmath185 and @xmath186 then there are @xmath187 and @xmath188 satisfying @xmath189 & = & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\\ & = & \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\\ & = & \sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x^ { * } + y_{\tau } ) - x^{*}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , it holds @xmath190 \leq { \mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x^ { * } + y_{\tau^ { * } } ) - x^ { * } ] \leq { \mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau^ { * } } ) - x]\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath191 and @xmath192 the proof of proposition [ saddle - point ] can be found in section [ proof of saddle - point ] . let the mapping @xmath193 be defined by @xmath194 for some @xmath195 obviously , @xmath196 is convex , nondecreasing , and satisfies @xmath197 as well as @xmath198 hence @xmath199 defines a lower semicontinuous convex function which satisfies , and whose fenchel - legendre transform coincides with @xmath200 since @xmath196 is continuous . moreover , for any @xmath184 such that @xmath201 and @xmath202 the set @xmath203\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\right\}$ ] is contained in the finite - dimensional linear subspace of @xmath183 spanned by the sequence of r. v. @xmath204 ~\big|~ \ , k=0,\dots , n\right\},\ ] ] where by definition @xmath205 as a result , @xmath203\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\right\}$ ] is a thin subset of @xmath183 in the case of atomless @xmath148 ( cf . e.g. ( * ? ? ? * proposition 2.6 ) ) . in this section we generalize the celebrated additive dual representation for optimal stopping problems ( see @xcite ) to the case of optimal stopping under uncertainty . the result in @xcite is formulated in terms of martingales @xmath206 with @xmath207 satisfying @xmath208}|m_{t}|\in l^{1}.$ ] the set of all such adapted martingales will be denoted by @xmath209 [ dualrepresentation ] let @xmath210 $ ] be the snell envelope of an integrable right - continuous stochastic process @xmath211}$ ] adapted to @xmath212 if @xmath208}|z_{t}|\in l^{p}$ ] for some @xmath213 then @xmath214 = \inf_{m\in { \mathcal m}_{0}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\sup_{t\in [ 0,t]}(z_{t } - m_{t})\right],\ ] ] where the infimum is attained for @xmath215 with @xmath216 being the martingale part of the doob - meyer decomposition of @xmath217}.$ ] even more it holds @xmath218 = \sup_{t\in [ 0,t]}({z}_{t } - m^{*}_{t})\quad{\mathrm{p}}-\mbox{a.s.}.\ ] ] [ relaxed ] by inspection of the proof of theorem 2.1 in @xcite , one can see that the assumption @xmath208}{\mathbb{e}}[z_{t}]\in l^{p}$ ] for some @xmath219 is only used to guarantee the existence of the doob - meyer decomposition of the snell envelope @xmath217}.$ ] therefore this assumption may be relaxed , if we consider discrete time optimal stopping problems on the set @xmath158 for some finite @xmath220 $ ] containing @xmath159 in this case , the doob - meyer decomposition always exists if @xmath221 is integrable , and theorem [ dualrepresentation ] holds with @xmath10 replaced by @xmath222 and @xmath11 $ ] replaced by @xmath158 ( see also ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.5 ) ) . theorem [ new_representation ] allows us to extend the additive dual representation to the case of stopping problems . we shall use the following notation . for a fixed @xmath133 and @xmath191 we shall denote by @xmath223}$ ] the snell - envelope w.r.t . to @xmath224}$ ] defined via @xmath225.\ ] ] the application of theorem [ new_representation ] together with theorem [ dualrepresentation ] provides us with the following additive dual representation of the stopping problem . [ dualrepresentation_utility ] under assumptions on @xmath133 and @xmath226 of theorem [ new_representation ] and under the condition @xmath33}|\phi^{*}(x + y_{t})|\in l^{p}$ ] for some @xmath219 and any @xmath227 the following dual representation holds @xmath228}\big(\phi^{*}(x + y_{t } ) - x - m_{t}\big)\big]\\ & = & \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}\big[\sup_{t\in [ 0,t]}\big(\phi^{*}(x + y_{t } ) - x - m^{*,\phi , x}_{t}\big)\big]\\ & = & { \mathop{\mathrm{ess\,inf}}\displaylimits}_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup_{t\in [ 0,t]}\big(\phi^{*}(x + y_{t } ) - x - m^{*,\phi , x}_{t}\big ) \quad { \mathrm{p}}-\mbox{a.s.}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath229 stands for the martingale part of the doob - meyer decomposition of the snell - envelope @xmath230 [ relaxed2 ] under the assumptions of theorem [ new_representation ] , we have that @xmath33}y_{t}\in h^{\phi^{*}}.$ ] furthermore , @xmath140 is convex and nondecreasing with @xmath231 ( see lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] in appendix [ appendixaa ] ) so that for any @xmath232 @xmath233 where @xmath234 denotes the right - sided derivative of @xmath235 using the monotonicity of @xmath140 again , we conclude that @xmath236}y_{t})\in l^{1}\ ] ] for all @xmath191 and @xmath237.$ ] hence the application of theorem [ dualrepresentation_utility ] to is already possible under the assumptions of theorem [ new_representation ] . the dual representation for the optimal stopping problem under average value at risk reads as follows . [ cor_dual_avar ] let the assumptions on @xmath133 and @xmath226 be as in theorem [ new_representation ] . if @xmath33}y_{t}\in l^{p}$ ] for some @xmath213 then it holds @xmath4-a.s . @xmath238}\left(\frac{1}{\alpha}\ , ( x + y_{t})^{+ } - x - m_{t}\right)\right]\\ & = & \nonumber \inf_{x\leq 0}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\sup_{t\in [ 0,t]}\left(\frac{1}{\alpha}\ , ( x + y_{t})^{+ } - x - m^{*,\alpha , x}_{t}\right)\right]\\ & = & \label{dual_avr } { \mathop{\mathrm{ess\,inf}}\displaylimits}_{x\leq 0}\sup_{t\in [ 0,t]}\left(\frac{1}{\alpha}\ , ( x + y_{t})^{+ } - x - m^{*,\alpha , x}_{t}\right)\quad { \mathrm{p}}-\mbox{a.s.}. \ ] ] here @xmath239 denotes the martingale part of the doob - meyer decomposition of the snell - envelope @xmath240 [ relax3 ] let us consider a discrete time optimal stopping problem @xmath241 for some finite @xmath220 $ ] with @xmath242 in view of remark [ relaxed2 ] , the assumptions of theorem [ new_representation ] are already sufficient to obtain the dual representation with @xmath10 replaced by @xmath243 and @xmath11 $ ] replaced by @xmath244 in @xcite the optimal stopping problems of the type @xmath245 were studied , where for any @xmath246 the functional @xmath247 maps a linear subspace @xmath248 of the space @xmath249 into @xmath250 and satisfies @xmath251 for @xmath252a.s .. in fact there is a one - to - one correspondence between conditional convex risk measures @xmath27}$ ] and dynamic utility functionals @xmath253}$ ] satisfying the following two properties : * * conditional translation invariance : * + @xmath254 for @xmath255 and @xmath256 * * conditional concavity : * + @xmath257 for @xmath258 and @xmath259 with @xmath260 more precisely , any conditionally translation invariant and conditionally concave dynamic utility functional @xmath261}$ ] defines a family @xmath262}$ ] of conditional convex risk measures via @xmath263 and vice versa . the results of @xcite essentially rely on the following additional assumptions * * regularity : * + @xmath264 for @xmath265 and @xmath256 * * recursiveness : * + @xmath266 for @xmath267 recursiveness is often also referred to as time consistency . obviously , the dynamic utility functional @xmath268},$ ] defined by @xmath269 satisfies the regularity and the conditional translation invariance , but it fails to be recursive ( cf . * example , 11.13 ) ) . even worse , according to theorem 1.10 in @xcite for any @xmath270 there is in general no regular conditionally translation invariant and recursive dynamic utility functional @xmath271 such that @xmath272 this means that we can not in general reduce the stopping problem ( [ av@rstopping ] ) to the stopping problem ( [ dmu ] ) with a regular , conditionally translation invariant and recursive dynamic utility functional @xmath271 . note that this conclusion can be drawn from theorem 1.10 of @xcite , because @xmath273 is law - invariant , i.e. , @xmath274 for identically distributed @xmath104 and @xmath275 , and satisfies the properties @xmath276 as well as @xmath277 for any @xmath278 and @xmath279 with @xmath280 the stopping problem ( [ av@rstopping ] ) may also be viewed as a special case of the following stopping problem : @xmath281 where @xmath282\mapsto[0,1]$ ] is a so - called distortion function , i.e. , @xmath283 is nondecreasing and satisfies @xmath284 @xmath285 indeed , if for @xmath990,1[$ ] the distortion function @xmath286 is defined by @xmath287 then the stopping problems ( [ av@rstopping ] ) and ( [ osf_distortion ] ) coincide . recalling theorem 1.10 of @xcite again , we see that the stopping problem ( [ osf_distortion ] ) is not in general representable in the form ( [ dmu ] ) with some regular , conditionally translation invariant and recursive dynamic utility functional . the stopping problem ( [ osf_distortion ] ) was recently considered by @xcite . however , the analysis in @xcite relies on some additional assumptions . first of all , the authors allow for all finite stopping times w.r.t . to some filtered probability space @xmath288 instead of restricting to those which are bounded by a fixed number . secondly , they assume a special structure for the process @xmath289 namely it is supposed that @xmath290 for an absolutely continuous nonnegative function @xmath291 on @xmath77 and for a one - dimensional geometric brownian motion @xmath292 . thirdly , the authors focus on strictly increasing absolutely continuous distortion functions @xmath283 so that their analysis does not cover the case of average value at risk . more precisely , in @xcite the optimal stopping problems of the form @xmath293 are studied , where @xmath294 denotes the set of all finite stopping times . a crucial step in the authors argumentation is the reformulation of the optimal stopping problem as @xmath295 where @xmath296 and @xmath297 are derivatives of @xmath291 and @xmath298 respectively , and @xmath299 denotes the set of all distribution functions @xmath300 with a nonnegative support such that @xmath301 the main idea of the approach in @xcite is that any such distribution function may be described as the distribution function of @xmath302 for some finite stopping time @xmath303 and this makes the application of the skorokhod embedding technique possible . hence , the results essentially rely on the special structure of the stochastic process @xmath304 and seem to be not extendable to stochastic processes of the form @xmath305 where @xmath306 is a multivariate markov process . moreover , it remains unclear whether the analysis of @xcite can be carried over to the case of bounded stopping times , as the skorokhod embedding can not be applied to the general sets of stopping times @xmath10 ( see e.g. @xcite ) . in this section we illustrate how our results can be used to price bermudan - type options in uncertain environment . specifically , we consider the model with @xmath307 identically distributed assets , where each underlying has dividend yield @xmath308 . the dynamic of assets is given by @xmath309where @xmath310 , are independent one - dimensional brownian motions and @xmath311 are constants . at any time @xmath312 the holder of the option may exercise it and receive the payoff @xmath313if we are uncertain about our modelling assumption and if the average value at risk is used to measure the risk related to this uncertainty , then the risk - adjusted price of the option is given by @xmath314}av@r_{\alpha}(-y_{\tau})&= & { \sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}[t_0,\ldots , t_j]}\sup\limits_{{\mathrm{q}}\in{\mathcal q}_{\phi_{\alpha},0}}{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathrm{q}}}[-y_{\tau } ] } \\ \label{opt_stop_ex } & = & \inf_{x\leq 0}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}[t_0,\ldots , t_j]}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{\alpha}\ , ( x + y_{\tau})^{+ } - x\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath315 consists of all probability measures @xmath316 on @xmath70 with @xmath317 if we restrict our attention to the class of generalised black scholes models of the type @xmath318 with adapted processes @xmath319 @xmath320 and independent brownian motions @xmath321 then @xmath322 with @xmath323 and the condition transforms to @xmath324 due to corollary [ representation av@r ] , one can use the standard methods based on dynamic programming principle to solve and @xmath325 $ ] stands for a set of stopping times with values in @xmath326 indeed , for any fixed @xmath327 the optimal value of the stopping problem @xmath328}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{\alpha}\ , ( x + y_{\tau})^{+ } - x\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] can be , for example , numerically approximated via the well known regression methods like longstaff - schwartz method . in this way one can get a ( suboptimal ) stopping rule @xmath329 where @xmath330 are continuation values estimates . then @xmath331 is a low - biased estimate for @xmath332 . note that the infimum in can be easily computed using a simple search algorithm . an upper - biased estimate can be constructed using the well known andersen - broadie dual approach ( see @xcite ) . for any fixed @xmath333 this approach would give us a discrete time martingale @xmath334 which in turn can be used to build an upper - biased estimate via the representation ( [ dual_avr ] ) : @xmath335\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that remains upper biased even if we replace the infimum of the objective function in by its value at a fixed point @xmath336 in table [ max_call_2d ] we present the bounds @xmath337 and @xmath338 together with their standard deviations for different values of @xmath339 as to implementation details , we used @xmath340 basis functions for regression ( see @xcite ) and @xmath341 training paths to compute @xmath342 in the dual approach of andersen and broadie , @xmath343 inner simulations were done to approximate @xmath344 in both cases we simulated @xmath345 testing paths to compute the final estimates . for comparison let us consider a problem of pricing the above bermudan option under entropic risk measure . due to , we need to solve the optimal stopping problem @xmath346}{\mathbb{e}}\big[\exp(\gamma y_{\tau})\big].\ ] ] the latter problem can be solved via the standard dynamic programming combined with regression as described above . in table [ max_call_2d_entrop ] the upper and lower mc bounds for @xmath347 are presented for different values of the parameter @xmath348 unfortunately for larger values of @xmath349 the corresponding mc estimates become unstable due to the presence of exponent in . in figure [ fig : bounds ] the lower bounds for av@r and the entropic risk measure are shown graphically . as can be seen the quality of upper and lower bounds are quite similar . however due to above mentioned instability , av@r should be preferred under higher uncertainty . [ max_call_2d ] .bounds ( with standard deviations ) for @xmath350-dimensional bermudan max - call with parameters @xmath351 , @xmath352 @xmath353 under av@r at level @xmath118 [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] in order to prove theorem [ new_representation ] we shall proceed as follows . first , by lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixaa ] ) , we obtain immediately @xmath354- { \mathbb{e}}\left[\phi\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{p}}}{d{\mathrm{q}}}\right)\right]\right ) = \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x].\ ] ] the proof of theorem [ new_representation ] would be completed , if we can show that @xmath355 = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x].\ ] ] using fubini s theorem , we obtain for any @xmath356 and every @xmath191 @xmath357 = \int_{x^{-}}^{\infty}\phi^{*'}(x + z)[1 - f_{y_{\tau}}(z)]~dz + \phi^{*}(x^{+ } ) - x,\ ] ] where @xmath358 stands for the distribution function of @xmath359 and @xmath234 denotes the right - sided derivative of the convex function @xmath235 in the same way we may also find @xmath360 = -\int_{0}^{x^{-}}\phi^{*'}(x + z)f_{y_{\tau}}(z)~dz.\ ] ] hence the property @xmath361 for @xmath191 yields @xmath362 = \int_{0}^{\infty}\phi^{*'}(x + z)[1 - f_{y_{\tau}}(z)]~dz + \phi^{*}(x ) - x\ ] ] for @xmath356 and @xmath363 since the set @xmath364 of distribution functions @xmath358 of @xmath359 is not , in general , a convex subset of the set of distribution functions on @xmath365 we can not apply the known minimax results . the idea is to first establish ( [ minimaxrelationship ] ) for the larger class of randomized stopping times , and then to show that the optimal value coincides with the optimal value @xmath366.$ ] let us recall the notion of randomized stopping times . by definition ( see e.g. @xcite ) , a randomized stopping time w.r.t . @xmath66 is a mapping @xmath367\rightarrow [ 0,\infty]$ ] which is nondecreasing and left - continuous in the second component such that @xmath368 is a stopping time w.r.t . @xmath67}$ ] for any @xmath369.$ ] notice that any randomized stopping time @xmath370 is also an ordinary stopping time w.r.t . the enlarged filtered probability space @xmath371,{\mathcal f}\otimes { \mathcal b}([0,1 ] ) , \big({\mathcal f}_{t}\otimes { \mathcal b}([0,1])\big)_{t\in [ 0,t]},{\mathrm{p}}\otimes { \mathrm{p}}^{u}\big).$ ] here @xmath372 denotes the uniform distribution on @xmath373,$ ] defined on @xmath374),$ ] the usual borel @xmath375algebra on @xmath373.$ ] we shall call a randomized stopping time @xmath370 to be degenerated if @xmath376 is constant for every @xmath377 there is an obvious one - to - one correspondence between stopping times and degenerated randomized stopping times . consider the stochastic process @xmath378 defined by @xmath379\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}},\ , ( \omega , u)\mapsto y_{t}(\omega).\ ] ] which is adapted w.r.t . the enlarged filtered probability space . denoting by @xmath380 the set of all randomized stopping times @xmath381 we shall study the following new stopping problem @xmath382~\mbox{over}~\tau^r\in{\mathcal t^{r}}.\ ] ] obviously , @xmath383 = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{{\tau^{r } } } ) - x]$ ] is valid for every stopping time @xmath384 where @xmath385 is the corresponding degenerated randomized stopping time such that @xmath386 @xmath369.$ ] thus , in general the optimal value of the stopping problem ( [ randomstop ] ) is at least as large as the one of the original stopping problem ( [ stoppproblem ] ) due to ( [ hilfsstoppproblem ] ) . one reason to consider the new stopping problem is that it has a solution under fairly general conditions . [ solution ] let @xmath96}$ ] be quasi - left - continuous , defined to mean @xmath387 @xmath59a.s . whenever @xmath388 is a sequence in @xmath10 satisfying @xmath389 for some @xmath356 . if @xmath390 is countably generated , then there exists a randomized stopping time @xmath391 such that @xmath392 = \sup_{{\tau^{r}}\in { \mathcal t^{r}}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{{\tau^{r } } } ) - x\right].\ ] ] proposition will be proved in section [ proof of solution ] . moreover the following important minimax result for the stopping problem ( [ randomstop ] ) holds . [ minimax ] if ( [ annahmen young function ] ) is fulfilled , and if @xmath33}y_{t}\in h^{\phi^{*}},$ ] then @xmath393 = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau^{r}\in{\mathcal t}^{r}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{{\tau^{r}}}^{r } ) - x].\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , if @xmath96}$ ] is quasi - left - continuous and if @xmath390 is countably generated , then there exist @xmath394 and @xmath188 such that @xmath395 \leq { \mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x^ { * } + y^{r}_{\tau^{r * } } ) - x^ { * } ] \leq { \mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{\tau^{r * } } ) - x]\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath191 and @xmath396 the proof of proposition [ minimax ] can be found in section [ beweis minimax ] . in the next step we shall provide conditions ensuring that the stopping problems ( [ stoppproblem ] ) and ( [ randomstop ] ) have the same optimal value . [ derandomize2 ] let @xmath148 be atomless with countably generated @xmath136 for every @xmath137 if ( [ annahmen young function ] ) is fulfilled , and if @xmath33}y_{t}$ ] belongs to @xmath397 then @xmath393 & = & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\\ & = & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\sup_{{\mathrm{q}}\in{\mathcal q}_{\phi,0}}\left({\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathrm{q}}}[y_{\tau}]- { \mathbb{e}}\left[\phi\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{p}}}{d{\mathrm{q}}}\right)\right]\right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] the proof of proposition [ derandomize2 ] is delegated to section [ beweis derandomize2 ] . we shall start with some preparations which also will turn out to be useful later on . let us recall ( cf . @xcite ) that every @xmath385 induces a stochastic kernel @xmath398)\rightarrow [ 0,1 ] $ ] with @xmath399 being the distribution of @xmath376 under @xmath372 for any @xmath377 here @xmath400)$ ] stands for the usual borel @xmath375algebra on @xmath11.$ ] this stochastic kernel has the following properties : @xmath401)~\mbox{is}~{\mathcal f}_{t}-\mbox{measurable for every}~t\geq 0,\\ & & k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\omega,[0,t ] ) = \sup\{u\in [ 0,1]\mid { \tau^{r}}(\omega , u)\leq t\}. \ ] ] the associated stochastic kernel @xmath402 is useful to characterize the distribution function @xmath403 of @xmath404 [ stopped distribution ] for any @xmath385 with associated stochastic kernel @xmath405 the distribution function @xmath406 of @xmath407 may be represented in the following way @xmath408\mid y_{t}\leq x\})]\quad\mbox{for}~ x\in{\mathbb{r}}.\ ] ] let @xmath409 and let us fix @xmath363 then @xmath410-\infty , x]}(y_{{\tau^{r}}}^{r } ) ] & = & \int_{0}^{1}{\mathbb{e}}[{\mathbbm{1}}_{]-\infty , x]}(y_{{\tau^{r}}(\cdot , u)}^{r})]\,du\\ & = & { \mathbb{e}}\left[\int_{0}^{1}{\mathbbm{1}}_{]-\infty , x]}(y_{{\tau^{r}}(\cdot , u)}^{r})\ , du\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] holds ( cf . * theorem 4.5 ) ) , where the last equation on the right hand side is due to fubini - tonelli theorem . then by definition of @xmath405 we obtain for every @xmath411 @xmath412-\infty , x]}(y^{r}_{{\tau^{r}}}(\omega , u))\ , du & = & { \mathbb{e}}_{{\mathrm{p}}^{u}}\left[{\mathbbm{1}}_{]-\infty , x]}(y^{r}_{{\tau^{r}}(\omega,\cdot)}(\omega))\right]\\ & = & { \mathrm{p}}^{u}\left(\left\{y^{r}_{{\tau^{r}}(\omega,\cdot)}(\omega)\leq x\right\}\right)\\ & = & k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\omega,\{t\in [ 0,t]\mid y_{t}(\omega)\leq x\ } ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] this completes the proof . following a suggestion by one referee we placed the proof of proposition [ solution ] in front of that of proposition [ minimax ] . let us introduce the filtered probability space @xmath413 defined by @xmath414 we shall denote by @xmath415 the set of randomized stopping times according to @xmath416 furthermore , we may extend the processes @xmath96}$ ] and @xmath417}$ ] to right - continuous processes @xmath418}$ ] and @xmath419}$ ] in the following way @xmath420 recall that we may equip @xmath415 with the so called baxter - chacon topology which is compact in general , and even metrizable within our setting because @xmath390 is assumed to be countably generated ( cf . theorem 1.5 in @xcite and discussion afterwards ) . next , consider the mapping @xmath421.\ ] ] by assumption on @xmath96}$ ] , the processes @xmath418}$ ] and @xmath419}$ ] are quasi - left - continuous . moreover , @xmath140 is continuous due to lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] , ( i ) in appendix [ appendixaa ] , so that @xmath422}$ ] is a quasi - left - continuous and right - continuous adapted process . hence in view of ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.7 ) , the mapping @xmath423 is continuous w.r.t . the baxter - chacon topology for every @xmath424 and thus @xmath425 is upper semicontinuous w.r.t . the baxter - chacon topology . then by compactness of the baxter - chacon topology , we may find some randomized stopping time @xmath426 such that @xmath427 this completes the proof because @xmath428 and @xmath429 belongs to @xmath380 for every @xmath430 @xmath431 let us define the mapping @xmath432 by @xmath433.\ ] ] since @xmath33}y_{t}$ ] is assumed to belong to @xmath397 the mapping @xmath434 is finite and convex , and thus continuous . moreover , by lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixaa ] ) @xmath435 hence @xmath436 } \sup\limits_{{\tau^{r}}\in{\mathcal t^{r}}}h({\tau^{r}},x)$ ] for some @xmath437 thus @xmath438 attains its minimum at some @xmath439 due to continuity of @xmath440 moreover , if @xmath96}$ ] is quasi - left - continuous and if @xmath390 is countably generated , then @xmath441 for some @xmath394 due to proposition [ solution ] . it remains to show that @xmath442 following the same line of reasoning as for the derivation of , we may rewrite @xmath443 in the following way . @xmath444~dz + \phi^{*}(x ) - x,\ ] ] where @xmath403 stands for the distribution function of @xmath445 and @xmath234 denotes the right - sided derivative of the convex function @xmath235 obviously , we have @xmath446 set @xmath447 + 1 { = \inf\limits_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau^{r}\in{\mathcal t}^{r}}h({\tau^{r}},x ) + 1}$ ] which is a real number because @xmath448 has been already proved to be a finite function which attains its minimum on some compact interval of @xmath449 . furthermore , we may conclude from @xmath450 for @xmath191 that @xmath451 and @xmath452 by ( [ infcompact ] ) we verify @xmath453 and @xmath454 we want to apply fan s minimax theorem ( cf . * theorem 2 ) or @xcite ) to @xmath455 . in view of and it remains to show that for every @xmath456 and any @xmath4570,1[$ ] there exists some @xmath385 such that @xmath458 to this end let @xmath459 with associated stochastic kernels @xmath460 and @xmath4570,1[.$ ] first , @xmath461)\rightarrow [ 0,1]$ ] defines a stochastic kernel satisfying @xmath462)~\mbox{is}~{\mathcal f}_{t}-\mbox{measurable for every}~t\in [ 0,t],\\ & & k(\omega,[0,t ] ) = 1.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then @xmath463\mid k(\omega,[0,t])\geq u\}\ ] ] defines some @xmath385 with @xmath464 furthermore , we obtain @xmath465 due to lemma [ stopped distribution ] . in view of ( [ rewrite ] ) this implies ( [ concave ] ) and the proof of proposition [ minimax ] is completed . @xmath431 the starting idea for proving proposition [ derandomize2 ] is to reduce the stopping problem ( [ randomstop ] ) to suitably discretized random stopping times . the choice of the discretized randomized stopping times is suggested by the following lemma . [ discretize ] for @xmath385 the construction @xmath466(\omega , u ) : = \min\{k/2^{j}\mid k\in{\mathbb{n } } , { \tau^{r}}(\omega , u)\leq k/2^{j}\}\wedge t\ ] ] defines a sequence @xmath467)_{j\in{\mathbb{n}}}$ ] in @xmath380 satisfying the following properties . 1 . @xmath468\searrow{\tau^{r}}$ ] pointwise , in particular it follows @xmath469(\omega , u)}(\omega , u ) = y^{r}_{{\tau^{r}}(\omega , u)}(\omega , u)\ ] ] for any @xmath411 and every @xmath369.$ ] 2 . @xmath470}}(x ) = f^{r}_{y_{{\tau^{r}}}}(x)$ ] holds for any continuity point @xmath471 of @xmath472 3 . for any @xmath191 and every @xmath473 we have @xmath474}}(x ) = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\widehat{y}_{t_{1j}}^{x } k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\cdot,[0,t_{1j}])\right ] + \sum\limits_{k=2}^{\infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\widehat{y}_{t_{kj}}^{x}\ , k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\cdot,]t_{(k-1)j } , t_{kj}])\right],\ ] ] where @xmath475 for @xmath476 and @xmath477-\infty , x]}\circ y_{t}$ ] for @xmath237.$ ] statements ( i ) and ( ii ) are obvious , so it remains to show ( iii ) . to this end recall from lemma [ stopped distribution ] @xmath478}}(x ) = { \mathbb{e}}[k_{{\tau^{r}}[j]}(\cdot,\{t\in [ 0,t]\mid y_{t}\leq x\})]\quad\mbox{for}~ x\in{\mathbb{r}}.\ ] ] since @xmath479}(\omega,\cdot)$ ] is a probability measure , we also have @xmath480}(\omega,\{t\in [ 0,t]\mid y_{t}(\omega)\leq x\})\\ \nonumber & = & k_{{\tau^{r}}[j]}(\omega,\{t\in [ 0,t_{1j}]\mid y_{t}(\omega)\leq x\})\\ \nonumber & & \qquad + \sum_{k = 2}^{\infty } k_{{\tau^{r}}[j]}(\omega,\{t\in ] t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}]\mid y_{t}(\omega)\leq x\})\\ \nonumber & = & k_{{\tau^{r}}[j]}(\omega,\{t\in [ 0,t_{1j}]\mid \widehat{y}_{t}^{x}(\omega ) = 1\})\\ & & \qquad + \sum_{k = 2}^{\infty } k_{{\tau^{r}}[j]}(\omega,\{t\in ] t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}]\mid \widehat{y}_{t}^{x}(\omega ) = 1\})\end{aligned}\ ] ] for every @xmath377 then by definitions of @xmath479}$ ] and @xmath405 @xmath481}(\omega,\{t\in ] t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}]\mid \widehat{y}_{t}^{x}(\omega ) = 1\ } ) \\ \nonumber & = & { \mathrm{p}}^{u}(\{{\tau^{r}}[j](\omega,\cdot)\in ] t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}],\,\widehat{y}_{{\tau^{r}}[j](\omega,\cdot)}^{x}(\omega ) = 1\})\\ \nonumber & = & { \mathrm{p}}^{u}(\{{\tau^{r}}[j](\omega,\cdot ) = t_{kj},\,\widehat{y}_{t_{kj}}^{x}(\omega ) = 1\})\\ \nonumber & = & \widehat{y}^{x}_{t_{kj}}(\omega)\,{\mathrm{p}}^{u}(\{{\tau^{r}}[j](\omega,\cdot ) = t_{kj}\})\\ \nonumber & = & \widehat{y}^{x}_{t_{kj}}(\omega)\,{\mathrm{p}}^{u}(\{{\tau^{r}}(\omega,\cdot)\in ] t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}]\})\\ & = & \widehat{y}^{x}_{t_{kj}}(\omega)\ , k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\omega,]t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}])\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath411 and @xmath482 with @xmath483 analogously , we also obtain @xmath484}(\omega,\{t\in [ 0,t_{1j}]\mid \widehat{y}_{t}^{x}(\omega ) = 1\ } ) = \widehat{y}_{t_{1j}}(\omega)\ , k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\omega,[0,t_{1j}]).\ ] ] then statement ( iii ) follows from ( [ ausgangspunkt ] ) combining ( [ auseinanderziehen ] ) with ( [ anwendungkerndefinition ] ) and ( [ anwendungkerndefinition2 ] ) . the proof is finished . we shall use the discretized randomized stopping times , as defined in lemma [ discretize ] , to show that we can restrict ourselves to discrete randomized stopping times in the stopping problem ( [ randomstop ] ) . [ discretizedstop ] if ( [ annahmen young function ] ) is fulfilled , then for any @xmath409 we have 1 . @xmath485 } ) - x_{j } ] = { \mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{{\tau^{r } } } ) - x ] $ ] for any sequence @xmath486 in @xmath487 converging to some @xmath488 2 . @xmath489 } ) - x ] = \inf\limits_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{{\tau^{r } } } ) - x ] . $ ] let the mapping @xmath490 be defined by @xmath491.$ ] for every @xmath409 the mapping @xmath492 is convex and thus continuous . recalling that @xmath493 a direct application of lemma [ discretize ] , ( i ) , along with the dominated convergence theorem yields part ( i ) . using terminology from @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , statement ( i ) implies that the sequence @xmath494,\cdot))_{j\in{\mathbb{n}}}$ ] of continuous mappings @xmath495,\cdot)$ ] epi - converges to the continuous mapping @xmath496 moreover , in view of ( [ infcompactneu ] ) and ( [ infcompact ] ) , we may conclude @xmath497,x ) = \inf\limits_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}h({\tau^{r}},x),\ ] ] drawing on theorem 7.31 in @xcite ( see also satz b 2.18 in @xcite ) . the following result provides the remaining missing link to prove proposition [ derandomize2 ] . [ missinglink ] let ( [ annahmen young function ] ) be fulfilled . furthermore , let @xmath409 and let us for any @xmath473 denote by @xmath498 $ ] the set containing all nonrandomized stopping times from @xmath10 taking values in @xmath499 with probability @xmath500 if @xmath148 is atomless with countably generated @xmath136 for every @xmath501 and if @xmath502 for @xmath501 then @xmath503 } ) - x ] \leq \sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}[j]}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x].\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath504 if @xmath505 then the statement of lemma [ missinglink ] is obvious . so let us assume @xmath506 set @xmath475 and let the mapping @xmath507 be defined via @xmath508.$ ] we already know from lemma [ discretize ] that @xmath509}}(x ) = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\widehat{y}_{t_{1j}}^{x } k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\cdot,[0,t_{1j}])\right ] + \sum\limits_{k=2}^{k_{j}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\widehat{y}_{t_{kj}}^{x } k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\cdot,]t_{(k-1)j},t_{kj}])\right]\ ] ] holds for any @xmath363 here @xmath477-\infty , x]}\circ y_{t}$ ] for @xmath237.$ ] next @xmath510)&k = 1\\ k_{{\tau^{r}}}(\cdot,]t_{(k-1 ) j},t_{kj}])&k\in\{2, ... ,k_{j}\ } \ecswitch\ ] ] defines a random variable on @xmath511 which satisfies @xmath512 @xmath59a.s .. in addition , we may observe that @xmath513 holds @xmath59a.s .. since the probability spaces @xmath514 @xmath515 are assumed to be atomless and countably generated , we may draw on corollary [ dichtheit ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixc ] ) along with lemma [ banachalaoglu ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixc ] ) and proposition [ angelic ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixa ] ) to find a sequence @xmath516 in @xmath517{$\scriptstyle k=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle k_{j}$ } } \end{picture } } } { \mathcal f}_{t_{kj}}$ ] such that @xmath518 is a partition of @xmath519 for @xmath520 and @xmath521 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[z_{k}\cdot g\right]\ ] ] holds for @xmath522 and @xmath523 in particular we have by ( [ eins ] ) @xmath474}}(x ) = \lim\limits_{n\to\infty } \sum\limits_{k=1}^{k_{j}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\widehat{y}_{t_{kj}}^{x } { \mathbbm{1}}_{b_{kn}}\right]\ , \mbox{for}\ , x\in{\mathbb{r}}.\ ] ] so by fatou s lemma along with , @xmath524,x ) \leq \liminf\limits_{n\to\infty } \int_{0}^{\infty}\phi^{*'}(x + z)\,\big ( 1 - \sum\limits_{k=1}^{k_{j}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\widehat{y}_{t_{kj}}^{z } { \mathbbm{1}}_{b_{kn}}\right]\big)\ , dz + \phi^{*}(x ) - x\ ] ] for @xmath363 here @xmath234 denotes the right - sided derivative of @xmath235 next we can define a sequence @xmath388 of nonrandomized stopping times from @xmath498 $ ] via @xmath525 the distribution function @xmath526 of @xmath527 satisfies @xmath528\ , \mbox{for}\ , x\in{\mathbb{r}}\ ] ] so that by ( [ rewrite ] ) @xmath529\big)\ , dz + \phi^{*}(x ) - x\ ] ] for @xmath363 the crucial point now is to show that ( @xmath530 ) : : @xmath531\big\}$ ] is equicontinuous , where @xmath532 is the interval defined in . note that @xmath533 is a sequence in @xmath534 and that @xmath535\big\}$ ] is bounded for every @xmath363 thus , in view of ( [ convex ] ) the statement ( @xmath530 ) together with arzela - ascoli theorem implies that we can find a subsequence @xmath536 such that @xmath537 for some continuous mapping @xmath538 hence , we may conclude from ( [ drei ] ) and ( [ zwei ] ) @xmath539,x)\ , \mbox { for } \ , x\in i_{\beta}.\ ] ] for any @xmath540 we may find some @xmath541 such that @xmath542 which implies by ( [ vier ] ) together with ( [ infcompact ] ) : @xmath543,x ) - \varepsilon\\ & \geq & \inf\limits_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}h({\tau^{r}}[j],x ) - \varepsilon\end{aligned}\ ] ] and is proved . therefore it remains to show the statement ( @xmath530 ) . [ [ proof - of - star ] ] proof of ( @xmath530 ) + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + first , observe that for @xmath544 $ ] and real numbers @xmath545 the inequality @xmath546 holds . hence @xmath547 - { \mathbb{e}}\left[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau})\right ] + & = & \sum\limits_{k = 1}^{k_{j } } { \mathbb{e}}\big[{\mathbbm{1}}_{\{t_{kj}\}}\circ \tau\ , \underbrace{\big(\phi^{*}\big(y + y_{t_{kj}}\big ) - \phi^{*}\big(x + y_{t_{kj}}\big)\big)}_{\geq 0}\big ] + |x - y| \nonumber\\ & \leq & \sum\limits_{k = 1}^{k_{j } } { \mathbb{e}}\big [ \phi^{*}\big(y + y_{t_{kj}}\big ) - \phi^{*}\big(x + y_{t_{kj}}\big)\big ] + |x - y| \nonumber\\ & \leq & \sum\limits_{k = 1}^{k_{j}}|h(t_{kj},x ) - h(t_{kj},y)| + ( k_{j } + 1)\ , |x - y|\end{aligned}\ ] ] by convexity , the mappings @xmath548 @xmath549 are also locally lipschitz continuous . thus , in view of ( [ fuenf ] ) , it is easy to verify that @xmath550 is equicontinuous at every @xmath551 this proves ( @xmath530 ) . now , we are ready to prove proposition [ derandomize2 ] . by ( [ hilfsstoppproblem ] ) we have @xmath552 & \geq & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\\ & = & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\sup_{{\mathrm{q}}\in{\mathcal q}_{\phi,0}}\left({\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathrm{q}}}[y_{\tau}]- { \mathbb{e}}\left[\phi\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{p}}}{d{\mathrm{q}}}\right)\right]\right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , due to ( ii ) of corollary [ discretizedstop ] and lemma [ missinglink ] we conclude that for any @xmath385 @xmath553 & = & \lim_{j\to\infty}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{{\tau^{r}}[j ] } ) - x]\\ & \leq & \sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x].\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus proposition [ derandomize2 ] is proved . @xmath431 first , we get from propositions [ minimax ] and [ derandomize2 ] @xmath554 & = & \sup\limits_{\tau^{r}\in{\mathcal t}^{r}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y^{r}_{{{\tau^{r } } } } ) - x]\\ & = & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] furthermore , @xmath554 & \geq & \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\\ & \geq & \sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}\inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x].\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath555 = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x]\ ] ] which completes the proof of theorem [ new_representation ] . @xmath431 just simplifying notation , we assume that @xmath556 with @xmath557 being a positive integer . by we have @xmath558 = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}\sup\limits_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x].\ ] ] so it is left to show that there exists a solution @xmath559 of the maximization problem and a solution @xmath439 of the minimization problem . indeed such a pair @xmath560 would be as required . in view of , we may find some compact interval @xmath561 of @xmath449 such that @xmath562 = \sup_{\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{\mathbb{t}}}\inf_{x\in i}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\phi^{*}(x + y_{\tau } ) - x\right].\ ] ] let @xmath563 denote the space of continuous real - valued mappings on @xmath564 this space will be equipped with the sup - norm @xmath565 whereas the product @xmath566 is viewed to be endowed with the norm @xmath567 defined by @xmath568 the key in solving the maximization problem is to show that @xmath569 is a weakly compact subset of @xmath566 w.r.t . the norm @xmath570 here @xmath571 stands for the set of all @xmath572 satisfying @xmath573 for @xmath574 as well as @xmath575 for @xmath576 and @xmath577 furthermore , define @xmath578\quad\mbox{for}~t\in\{1,\dots , t\},~a_{t}\in{\mathcal f}_{t}.\ ] ] notice that any mapping @xmath579 is extendable to a real - valued convex function on @xmath449 , and therefore also continuous . before proceeding , we need some further notation , namely @xmath580 denoting the set of all @xmath581 satisfying @xmath582 with @xmath583a.s . for @xmath584 and @xmath585a.s .. obviously , the subset @xmath586 consists of extreme points of @xmath587 any @xmath582 may be associated with the mapping @xmath588\quad(t \in\{1,\dots , t\}).\ ] ] it is extendable to a real - valued convex function on @xmath449 , and thus also continuous . hence , the mapping @xmath589{$\scriptstyle t=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle t$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}(\omega,{\mathcal f}_{t},{\mathrm{p}}|_{{\mathcal f}_{t}})\rightarrow { \mathcal c}(i)^{t},~ ( f_{1},\dots , f_{t})\mapsto ( h_{1,f_{1}},\dots , h_{t , f_{t}})\ ] ] is well - defined , and obviously linear . in addition it satisfies the following convenient continuity property . [ kompaktheitparti ] let @xmath517{$\scriptstyle t=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle t$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{t},l^{1}_{t})$ ] be the product topology of @xmath590 @xmath591 on @xmath517{$\scriptstyle t=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle t$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}(\omega,{\mathcal f}_{t},{\mathrm{p}}|_{{\mathcal f}_{t}}),$ ] where @xmath590 denotes the weak * topology on @xmath592 then , @xmath580 is compact w.r.t . @xmath517{$\scriptstyle t=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle t$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{t},l^{1}_{t}),$ ] and the mapping @xmath593 is continuous w.r.t . @xmath517{$\scriptstyle t=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle t$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{t},l^{1}_{t})$ ] and the weak topology induced by @xmath570 in particular the image @xmath594 of @xmath580 under @xmath593 is weakly compact w.r.t . @xmath570 the continuity of @xmath593 follows in nearly the same way as in the proof of proposition 3.1 from @xcite . moreover , @xmath580 is obviously closed w.r.t . the product topology @xmath517{$\scriptstyle t=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle t$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{t},l^{1}_{t}),$ ] and even compact due to banach - alaoglu theorem . then by continuity of @xmath595 the set @xmath594 is weakly compact w.r.t . @xmath570 this completes the proof . we need some further preparation to utilize lemma [ kompaktheitparti ] . [ thin ] let @xmath596 with @xmath201 and let @xmath186 if @xmath148 is atomless and if @xmath182\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\right\}$ ] is a thin subset of @xmath183 , then @xmath597\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\right\}$ ] is a thin subset of @xmath598 let @xmath265 with @xmath280 since @xmath148 is atomless , we may find disjoint @xmath599 contained in @xmath175 with @xmath600 then by assumption there exist nonzero @xmath601 such that @xmath602 vanishes outside @xmath603 as well as @xmath604~\right ] = 0 $ ] for @xmath191 and @xmath605 moreover , we may choose @xmath606 with @xmath607 for at least one @xmath608 and @xmath609 = 0.$ ] finally , @xmath610 and , setting @xmath611 @xmath612~\right]\\ & = & \sum_{i=1}^{2}\lambda_{i}~{\mathbb{e}}\left[~f_{i}\cdot{\mathbb{e}}\left[{\mathbbm{1}}_{a}\cdot\phi^{*}(x + y_{s } ) ~|~{\mathcal f}_{t}\right]~\right ] - x~{\mathbb{e}}\left[\left(\lambda_{1 } f_{1 } + \lambda_{2 } f_{2}\right)\cdot{\mathbbm{1}}_{a}\right ] = 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath363 this completes the proof . the missing link in concluding the desired compactness of the set @xmath613 from is provided by the following auxiliary result . [ schlussel ] let @xmath148 be atomless for @xmath584 and furthermore let the subset @xmath182\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\right\}$ ] of @xmath183 be thin for arbitrary @xmath596 with @xmath185 and @xmath186 then for any @xmath614 there exist @xmath615 and mappings @xmath616 @xmath617 such that @xmath618 and @xmath619 let @xmath596 with @xmath185 and @xmath186 we may draw on lemma [ thin ] to observe that @xmath620\mid x\in{\mathbb{r}}\}$ ] is a thin subset of @xmath598 then the statement of lemma [ schlussel ] follows immediately from proposition [ kreinmilman ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixc ] ) applied to the sets @xmath621 ( @xmath622 ) , where @xmath623 under the assumptions of lemma [ schlussel ] , the set @xmath613 defined in coincides with @xmath624 which in turn is weakly compact w.r.t . @xmath625 due to lemma [ kompaktheitparti ] . [ kompaktheitpartii ] under the assumptions of lemma [ schlussel ] , the set @xmath613 ( cf . ) is weakly compact w.r.t . @xmath570 now we are ready to select a solution of the maximization problem . : + let the assumptions of proposition [ saddle - point ] be fulfilled . in view of it suffices to solve @xmath626\,\mbox{over}\,\tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}.\ ] ] let us assume that @xmath627 > \inf_{x\in i}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + y_{0 } ) - x]$ ] because otherwise @xmath628 would be optimal . since @xmath629 for @xmath630 by assumption , any stopping time @xmath631 is concentrated on @xmath632 by corollary [ kompaktheitpartii ] , the set @xmath613 ( cf . ) is weakly compact w.r.t . the norm @xmath570 furthermore , the concave mapping @xmath633 defined by @xmath634 is continuous w.r.t . @xmath570 this means that @xmath635 is convex as well as well as @xmath636continuous , and thus also weakly lower semicontinuous because @xmath636closed convex subsets are also weakly closed . hence @xmath637 is weakly upper semicontinuous , and therefore its restriction to @xmath613 attains a maximum . in particular , the set @xmath638\mid \tau\in{\mathcal t}_{{\mathbb{t}}}\setminus\{0\}\right\ } = l(k)\ ] ] has a maximum . this shows that we may find a solution of .@xmath431 : + by @xmath639 $ ] we may define a convex , and therefore also continuous mapping @xmath640 moreover by lemma [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] ( cf . appendix [ appendixaa ] ) , @xmath641 this means that @xmath642}l(x)$ ] for some @xmath437 hence @xmath643 attains its minimum at some @xmath644 $ ] because @xmath643 is continuous . any such @xmath439 is a solution of the problem . @xmath431 [ optimizedcertaintyequivalent ] let @xmath1 $ ] be a lower semicontinuous , convex mapping satisfying @xmath73 and @xmath645 furthermore , let @xmath646 denote the set of all probability measures @xmath3 on @xmath70 which are absolutely continuous w.r.t . @xmath4 such that the radon - nikodym derivative @xmath647 satisfies @xmath648 < \infty.$ ] then the following statements hold true . 1 . if @xmath71 for some @xmath72 then the fenchel - legendre transform @xmath649 of @xmath133 is a nondecreasing , convex finite mapping . in particular its restriction @xmath650 to @xmath77 is a finite young - function , which in addition satisfies the condition @xmath651 if @xmath652 and @xmath653 in the case of @xmath654 2 . if @xmath655 for some @xmath656 then for any @xmath104 from @xmath657 we obtain @xmath658- { \mathbb{e}}\left[\phi\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{q}}}{d{\mathrm{p}}}\right)\right]\right ) = \inf_{x\in{\mathbb{r}}}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x + x ) - x],\ ] ] where the supremum on the left hand side of the equality is attained for some @xmath659 let @xmath660 for some @xmath661 obviously , @xmath140 is a nondecreasing convex function satisfying the properties @xmath662 next , we want to verify the finiteness of @xmath235 since @xmath140 is nondecreasing , and @xmath663 holds for any @xmath664 it suffices to show that @xmath665 for every @xmath666 for that purpose consider the mapping @xmath667 by assumption on @xmath668 we have @xmath669 hence for any @xmath670 we may find some @xmath671 such that we obtain @xmath672 moreover , @xmath673 is upper semicontinuous for @xmath666 hence , for every @xmath670 there is some @xmath674 $ ] with @xmath675 as a finite convex function @xmath140 is continuous . since it is also nondecreasing , we may conclude from that its restriction to @xmath77 is a finite young function . let us now assume that @xmath676 then @xmath677 analogously , @xmath678 may be derived in the case of @xmath654 thus we have proved the full statement ( i ) . let us turn over to the proof of statement ( ii ) , and let us consider the mapping @xmath679\ ] ] then , due to convexity of @xmath680 we may apply jensen s inequality along with statement ( i ) to conclude @xmath681\geq \lim_{x\to - \infty}([\phi^{*}(x - { \mathbb{e}}[x])]-x ) = \infty\quad\mbox{for}\ , x\in h^{\phi^{*}},\ ] ] and @xmath682\geq \lim_{x\to \infty}[\phi^{*}(x - { \mathbb{e}}[x ] ) - x ] = \infty\quad\mbox{for}\ , x\in h^{\phi^{*}}.\ ] ] thus , for any @xmath82 we find some @xmath683 such that @xmath684}{\mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x - x ) - x].\ ] ] in addition , for @xmath82 the mapping @xmath685 $ ] is a convex mapping on @xmath365 hence its restriction to @xmath686 $ ] is continuous . this implies that @xmath687 is a real - valued function . moreover , it is easy to check that @xmath687 is a so called convex risk measure , defined to mean that it satisfies the following properties . * monotonicity : @xmath688 for all @xmath689 with @xmath690 , * cash - invariance : @xmath691 for all @xmath87 and @xmath692 , * convexity : @xmath693 for all @xmath694 @xmath695.$ ] then we obtain from theorem 4.3 in @xcite that @xmath696- \rho^{*}({\mathrm{q}})\right)\ ] ] holds for all @xmath82 where @xmath697 - \rho(x)\right).\ ] ] by routine procedures we may verify @xmath698 - { \mathbb{e}}[\phi^{*}(x)]\right)\ ] ] for @xmath659 since @xmath699 = \lim_{x\to \infty}[\phi^{*}(x ) - x ] = \infty$ ] due to statement ( i ) , we may conclude from ( * ? ? ? * ( 5.23 ) ) @xmath700 - { \mathbb{e}}[\rho^{*}(x)]\right ) = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\phi\left(\frac{d{\mathrm{q}}}{d{\mathrm{p}}}\right)\right]\quad\mbox{for all}\ , { \mathrm{q}}\in{\mathcal q}_{\phi,0}.\ ] ] this completes the proof . let @xmath701 be a filtered probability space , and let the product space @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] be endowed with the product topology @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})$ ] of the weak * topologies @xmath702 on @xmath703 ( for @xmath704 ) . [ angelic ] let @xmath705 be separable w.r.t . the weak topology @xmath706 for @xmath707 and let @xmath708{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] be relatively compact w.r.t . @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i}).$ ] then for any @xmath104 from the @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})-$]closure of @xmath709 we may find a sequence @xmath710 in @xmath711 which converges to @xmath104 w.r.t . the @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i}).$ ] setting @xmath712{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}}),$ ] we shall denote by @xmath713 the topological dual of @xmath714 w.r.t . @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i}).$ ] it is easy to check that @xmath715,\ ] ] where @xmath716 and @xmath717 ( for @xmath704 ) defines a linear operator from @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{1}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] onto @xmath713 which is continuous w.r.t . the product topology @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{1}_{i},l^{\infty}_{i})$ ] of the weak topologies @xmath718 and the weak topology @xmath719 since @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{1}_{i},l^{\infty}_{i})$ ] is separable by assumption , we may conclude that @xmath720 is separable too . then the statement of the proposition [ angelic ] follows immediately from @xcite , p.30 . let for @xmath721 denote by @xmath722 a filtered probability space , and let the set @xmath723 gather all sets @xmath724 from @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } { \overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}$ ] satisfying @xmath725 for @xmath726 and @xmath727 we shall endow respectively the product spaces @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] with the product topologies @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})$ ] of the weak * topologies @xmath702 on @xmath703 ( for @xmath728 and @xmath729 ) . fixing @xmath728 and nonnegative @xmath730 the subset @xmath731{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] is defined to consist of all @xmath732{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] such that @xmath733 @xmath734a.s . for any @xmath735 and @xmath736 @xmath734a.s .. for abbreviation we shall use notation @xmath737 [ banachalaoglu ] @xmath738 is a compact subset of @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] w.r.t . the topology @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})$ ] for @xmath728 and arbitrary nonnegative @xmath739 the statement of lemma [ banachalaoglu ] is obvious in view of the banach - alaoglu theorem . [ kreinmilmanallgemein ] let @xmath740 be nonvoid for @xmath741 such that @xmath742\mid f\in m_{j}\}$ ] is a thin subset of @xmath705 for @xmath743 with @xmath744 and any @xmath745 furthermore , let us fix @xmath746 and consider the set @xmath747 consisting of all @xmath748 from @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] satisfying @xmath749 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[f_{i}\cdot \varphi_{i}\right]$ ] for any @xmath750 @xmath751 then the set @xmath752 has extreme points , and for each extreme point @xmath753 there exists some @xmath754 such that @xmath755 @xmath734 a.s . holds for @xmath756 we shall use ideas from the proof of proposition 6 in @xcite . first , let us , for any @xmath728 , denote by @xmath757 the set of all @xmath758 from @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } l^{\infty}({\overline{\omega}},{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i},{\overline{{\mathrm{p}}}}|_{{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}})$ ] satisfying @xmath749 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[f_{i}\cdot \varphi_{i}\right]$ ] for @xmath759 and @xmath760 it is closed w.r.t . @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i}).$ ] hence by lemma [ banachalaoglu ] , the set @xmath761 is compact w.r.t . @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i = k$ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})$ ] for every nonnegative @xmath739 since it is also convex , we may use the krein - milman theorem to conclude that each set @xmath762 has some extreme point if it is nonvoid . notice that @xmath763 contains at least @xmath764 so that it has some extreme point . we shall now show by backward induction that for any @xmath728 and any nonnegative @xmath765 with nonvoid @xmath762 * each of its extreme points @xmath766 satisfies @xmath767 @xmath734a.s . ( @xmath729 ) for some @xmath754 with @xmath768 if @xmath769 obviously , this would imply the statement of proposition [ kreinmilmanallgemein ] . for @xmath770 the set @xmath771 is nonvoid iff @xmath772 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[f_{m}\cdot\varphi_{m}\right]$ ] holds for every @xmath773 in this case , @xmath443 is the only extreme point , which has trivial representation @xmath774 corresponding to @xmath775 now let us assume that for some @xmath776 and every nonvoid @xmath762 statement @xmath777 is satisfied . let @xmath778 be nonnegative with @xmath779 and select any extreme point @xmath780 of @xmath781 then @xmath782 belongs to @xmath783 and is nonnegative . moreover , @xmath784 and it is easy to check that @xmath785 is even an extreme point of @xmath786 hence by assumption , there exists some @xmath754 satisfying @xmath768 if @xmath787 and @xmath788 @xmath734a.s . for @xmath789 setting @xmath790 we want to show @xmath791 this will be done by contradiction assuming @xmath792 then @xmath793 for some @xmath540 where @xmath794 we may observe by assumption that @xmath795\mid \varphi_{i } \in m_{i}\}$ ] ( with @xmath729 ) as well as @xmath796 are all thin subsets of @xmath797 since finite unions of thin subsets are thin subsets again ( cf . * proposition 2.1 ) ) , we may find some nonzero @xmath798 vanishing outside @xmath799 and satisfying @xmath800 = 0 $ ] for @xmath801 as well as @xmath802 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[g\cdot{\mathbb{e}}\left[{\mathbbm{1}}_{a_{i}}\cdot\varphi_{i}~|~{\overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{k-1}\right]\right ] = 0 \quad ( \varphi_{i}\in m_{i},~i\in\{k,\dots , m\}).\ ] ] according to theorem 2.4 in @xcite , we may choose @xmath803 such that @xmath804 holds . now , define @xmath805 and @xmath806 by @xmath807 since @xmath725 for @xmath726 and @xmath808 we obtain @xmath809 @xmath734a.s .. so by construction , @xmath810 differ , and belong both to @xmath781 moreover , @xmath811 for @xmath812 this contradicts the fact that @xmath780 is an extreme point of @xmath781 therefore , @xmath791 now define @xmath813{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } { \overline{{\mathcal f}}}_{i}$ ] by @xmath814 obviously , @xmath815 for @xmath726 follows from @xmath725 for @xmath816 moreover , @xmath817 in particular @xmath818 finally , it may be verified easily that @xmath819 @xmath734a.s . holds for @xmath820 hence @xmath821 fulfills statement @xmath777 completing the proof . [ kreinmilman ] let @xmath740 be nonvoid for @xmath741 such that @xmath742\mid f\in m_{j}\}$ ] is a thin subset of @xmath705 for @xmath743 with @xmath744 and any @xmath745 then for any @xmath822 there exist @xmath754 and @xmath823 @xmath824 such that @xmath825 = 0\quad\mbox{for}~\varphi_{i}\in m_{i}~\mbox{with}~i = 1,\dots , m,\ ] ] and @xmath826 let us fix any @xmath827 and let @xmath747 denote the set consisting of all @xmath828 where @xmath829 such that @xmath749 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[f_{i}\cdot \varphi_{i}\right]$ ] for @xmath830 by proposition [ kreinmilmanallgemein ] , we may select an extreme point @xmath748 of @xmath752 and some @xmath754 such that @xmath831 @xmath734a.s . holds for @xmath751 then @xmath832 and @xmath724 are as required . [ dichtheit ] if @xmath833 is atomless for every @xmath707 then @xmath834 is the @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})-$]closure of @xmath835 let @xmath746 be arbitrary . consider the subsets @xmath836 < \varepsilon~\mbox{for}~f\in m_{i}\},\ ] ] where @xmath540 and @xmath837 any nonvoid , finite subset of @xmath838 the sets @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } u_{i\varepsilon}(m_{i})$ ] constitute a basis of the @xmath517{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } \sigma(l^{\infty}_{i},l^{1}_{i})-$]neighbourhoods of @xmath839 so let us select any @xmath840 and nonvoid finite subsets @xmath837 of @xmath705 for @xmath751 let @xmath743 with @xmath841 and @xmath745 then the set consisting of all @xmath842 $ ] with @xmath843 is a nonvoid finite subset of @xmath844 in particular it is thin because @xmath833 is assumed to be atomless ( cf . * lemma 2 ) ) . hence we may apply proposition [ kreinmilman ] to select some @xmath754 satisfying @xmath845 = 0 $ ] for @xmath846 and @xmath847 this means @xmath848{$\scriptstyle i=1 $ } } \put(5.00,18.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{$\scriptstyle m$ } } \end{picture } } } u_{i\varepsilon}(m_{i}),\ ] ] and completes the proof . the authors would like to thank alexander schied and mikhail urusov for fruitful discussions and helpful remarks . 0 anantharaman , r. ( 2012 ) . _ thin subspaces of @xmath849_. quaestiones mathematicae * 35 * , 133 143 . andersen , l. and broadie , m. ( 2004 ) . _ a primal - dual simulation algorithm for pricing multidimensional american options . _ management sciences , * 50*(9 ) , 1222 - 1234 . ankirchner , s. and strack , p. ( 2011 ) . _ skorokhod embeddings in bounded time . _ stochastics and dynamics * 11 * , 215226 . baxter , j. r. and r. v. chacon ( 1977 ) . _ compactness of stopping times . _ z. wahrscheinlichkeitstheorie verw . gebiete * 40 * , 169 181 . bayraktar , e. , karatzas , i. and yao , s. ( 2010 ) . _ optimal stopping for dynamic convex risk measures . _ illinois j. math . * 54 * , 1025 1067 . bayraktar , e. and yao , s. ( 2011 ) . _ optimal stopping for non - linear expectations . _ stochastic process . appl . * 121 * , 185 211 . bayraktar , e. and yao , s. ( 2011 ) . _ optimal stopping for non - linear expectations . _ stochastic process . * 121 * , 212 264 . belomestny , d. ( 2013 ) . _ solving optimal stopping problems by empirical dual optimization . _ annals of applied probability , * 23*(5 ) , 19882019 . ben - tal , a. and teboulle , m. ( 1987 ) . _ penalty functions and duality in stochastic programming via @xmath850divergence functionals research * 12 * , 224 240 . ben - tal , a. and teboulle , m. ( 2007 ) . _ an old - new concept of convex risk measures : the optimized certainty equivalent finance * 17 * , 449 476 . biagini , s. and frittelli , m. ( 2008 ) . _ a unified framework for utility maximization problems : an orlicz space approach . _ annals of applied probability * 18 * , 929 966 . borwein , j. m. and zhuang , d. ( 1986 ) . _ on fan s minimax theorem . _ mathematical programming * 34 * , 232 - 234 . cheng , x. and riedel , f. ( 2013 ) . _ optimal stopping under ambiguity in continuous time . _ math . * 7 * , 29 68 . cheridito , p. and li , t. ( 2009 ) . _ risk measures on orlicz hearts . _ mathematical finance * 19 * , 189214 . edgar , g. a. , millet , a. and sucheston , l. ( 1981 ) . on compactness and optimality of stopping times , _ lnm 939 _ , springer , 36 - 61 . edgar , g.a . and sucheston , l. ( 1992 ) . _ stopping times and directed processes_. cambridge university press , cambridge . edwards , d. a. ( 1987 ) . _ on a theorem of dvoretsky , wald , and wolfowitz concerning liapunov measures_. glasgow math . j. * 29 * , 205 220 . fan , k. ( 1953 ) . _ minimax theorems_. proc . u. s. a. * 39 * , 42 - 47 . floret , k. ( 1978 ) . weakly compact sets , _ lnm 801 _ , springer . fllmer , h. and a. schied ( 2010 ) . _ stochastic finance_. de gruyter , berlin , new york ( 3rd . ed . ) . fllmer , h. and i. penner ( 2006 ) . _ convex risk measures and the dynamics of their penalty functions _ , statistics decisions * 24 * , 6196 . haugh , m. b. and kogan , l. ( 2004 ) . _ pricing american options : a duality approach_. oper . 52 * , 258 270 . kaina , m. and rschendorf , l. ( 2009 ) . _ on convex risk measures on @xmath53spaces_. math . methods oper . 69 * , 475 495 . kingman , j. f. c. and robertson , a. p. ( 1968 ) . _ on a theorem of lyapunov_. j. london math . soc . * 43 * , 347 351 . krtschmer , v. and schoenmakers , j. ( 2010 ) . _ representations for optimal stopping under dynamic monetary utility functionals_. siam j. financial math . * 1 * , 811832 . khn , z. and rsler , u. ( 1998 ) . _ a generalization of lyapunov s convexity theorem with applications in optimals stopping_. proceedings of the american mathematical society * 126 * , 769 777 . kupper , m. and schachermayer , w. ( 2009 ) . _ representation results for law invariant time consistent functions_. math . econ * 2 * , 189 210 . peng , s. ( 1997 ) . backward sde and related g - expectations , in : el karoui , n. and mazliak , l. ( eds . ) , backward stochastic differential equations , pitman res . notes math . 364 , longman , harlow , 1997 , pp . 141 - 159 . riedel , f. ( 2009 ) . _ optimal stopping with multiple priors_. econometrica , * 77*(3 ) , 857 - 908 . rockafellar , r.t . and wets , j - b . ( 1998 ) . _ variational analysis _ , springer , berlin / heidelberg . rogers , l. c. g. ( 2002 ) . _ monte carlo valuation of american options_. mathematical finance * 12 * , 271 286 . witting , h. and mller - funk , u. ( 1995 ) . _ mathematische statistik ii , _ teubner , stuttgart . xu , z. q. and zhou , x. y. ( 2013 ) . _ optimal stopping under probability distortion_. annals of applied probability * 23 * , 251 282 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: it is generally expected that in a full description of quantum gravity the geometry of space - time at small scales will not resemble that of a manifold . the nature of this `` quantum geometry '' is one of the fundamental issues in the search for a quantum theory of gravity . one argument for quantum geometry is that quantum field theories give our best descriptions of microscopic physics , yet they must be regularized in order to yield meaningful predictions . the trouble being that quantum field theory suffers from ultra - violet divergences due to physical processes occurring at arbitrarily large momenta , or equivalently , arbitrarily small distances . some fundamental regularization that fixes these divergences can probably be interpreted as a modification of geometry at extremely short distances , perhaps even such that the concept of arbitrarily small distances is meaningless . another argument extends heisenberg s classic _ gedankenexperiment _ in support of the uncertainty relations . the observation of structures at very small distances requires radiation of very short wavelength and correspondingly large energy . attempting to observe a sufficiently small structure would thus require such a high concentration of energy that a black hole would be formed and no observation could be made . if this is so , then distances below about the plank scale are unobservable and thus operationally meaningless . if short distances are meaningless , then perhaps precise locations are as well . this suggests the possibility of uncertainty relations between position and position , analogous to the standard ones between position and momentum ; this has been argued on physical grounds ( see @xcite , or @xcite for a review ) and from string theory ( see @xcite ) . an uncertainty relation between , say , @xmath4-position and @xmath5-position , would mean that the @xmath4 and @xmath5 coordinates do not commute . since coordinates are just functions on space(-time ) this suggests that the algebra of functions on space might not be commutative ( see @xcite ) . that is the fundamental idea of noncommutative geometry . in noncommutative geometry ( see @xcite ) , familiar geometric concepts ( metric , measure , bundle , etc . ) are reformulated in an entirely algebraic way . this allows the generalization of geometry by replacing the algebra of functions on space with a noncommutative algebra . it may be that such a noncommutative generalization of ordinary geometry can describe the true quantum geometry of space - time . as i will explain , noncommutativity is no guarantor of regularization ( see also @xcite ) . in this paper , i will discuss a specific class of noncommutative geometries which do have the requisite regularization property . these models are not physically realistic ; they generalize euclidean ( space ) rather than lorentzian ( space - time ) geometry ( a sin shared by lattice models ) and they are not gauge theories . however , it is plausible that more realistic models may share some of the characteristics of these ones . although regularization in these geometries is quite manifest , a toolkit for coaxing actual predictions from field theory there has been lacking . my aim here is to present an approximation technique for field theory calculations in this regularization . this will show the leading order effects of noncommutativity on quantum field theory . the existing theory of noncommutative geometry ( see @xcite ) is largely inspired by the so - called gelfand theorem . according to this theorem , there is an exact correspondence between commutative c@xmath6-algebras and locally compact topological spaces . for any locally compact topological space , the algebra of continuous functions vanishing at @xmath7 is a commutative c@xmath6-algebra , and any commutative c@xmath6-algebra can be realized in this way . this suggests that c@xmath6-algebras in general should be considered as noncommutative algebras of `` continuous functions '' , and thus that the category of c@xmath6-algebras is the category of noncommutative topologies . the next step is to go from noncommutative topology to noncommutative geometry ; the most versatile noncommutative version of a riemannian metric is given by a dirac operator . on an ordinary manifold , taking the commutator of the dirac operator , @xmath8 , with a differentiable function gives @xmath9_- = i\gamma^jf_j \mbox.\ ] ] taking the norm of this gives @xmath10_-\rvert } = { \lvert\nabla f\rvert}$ ] ; thus , the dirac operator can detect the maximum slope of a function . from this , a construction for the distance between two points can be obtained ( see @xcite ) . this shows that the dirac operator contains all information of the riemannian metric . it also knows which functions are differentiable , smooth , lipschitz , etc . a c@xmath6-algebra with a dirac operator thus constitutes a noncommutative riemannian geometry . using a couple of additional structures , it is possible to characterize noncommutative riemannian manifolds axiomatically ( see @xcite ) . unfortunately , it is only known how to do this for what amounts to metrics of _ positive definite _ signature . this does not allow for the noncommutative generalization of space - time . another problem with these noncommutative manifolds is that they _ do not _ tend to regularize quantum field theory . a variation of noncommutative geometry that does have this property is matrix geometry ( see @xcite ) . in matrix geometry , every structure has only finite degrees of freedom . unfortunately , there is no axiomatic characterization of matrix geometries , as for noncommutative manifolds . the problem of characterizing noncommutative space - time is daunting ( see @xcite ) . the trouble is that the analytic properties of the dirac operator which are essential in the positive - definite case are not there in space - time . with everything finite , all analytic considerations evaporate in the case of matrix geometry , suggesting that the problem of noncommutative space - time might be solvable once matrix geometry is better understood . most existing applications of noncommutative geometry to physics have concerned connes - lott models . in these ( with the question of space - time deferred ) a simple type of noncommutative manifold provides an interesting interpretation of the standard model of particle physics . in particular , the higgs field and gauge bosons are unified . here , i am pursuing a different way of applying noncommutative geometry to physics . i am following @xcite and exploring the regularization effects of matrix geometry . i will begin in sec . [ regularization ] by discussing what it takes to regularize quantum field theory and describing the geometric quantization construction that is the basis of my approach . in sec . [ regularized.action ] , i discuss how to construct the action functional in this regularization , in slightly greater generality than has previously been discussed explicitly . this is followed by a brief speculation on convergence when the regularization is removed . perturbation theory in this regularization has not been described in detail before ; i present this in sec . [ feynman ] . in sec . [ scales ] , i explain ( heuristically ) how the infra - red and ultra - violet cutoff scales are balanced around the noncommutativity scale . in particular , the ultra - violet cutoff only exists when there is an infra - red cutoff . in sec . [ flat ] , i describe the weyl quantization of flat space and the effect of this on quantum field theory , giving a geometric algorithm for the modification . this is a prelude to the main result of this paper . i present , in sec . [ deformation ] , an approximation technique for perturbative calculations in this regularization . i illustrate exact and approximate calculations with a few examples in sec . [ examples ] , and in sec . [ divergences ] , i discuss the effect on noncommutativity on degrees of divergence . a euclidean quantum field theory can be defined by a path integral over the space of classical field configurations . given an action functional @xmath11 $ ] , the vacuum expectation value of some functional , @xmath12 $ ] , of the quantum fields is defined by z0f [ ] 0:= _ f [ ] e^-s [ ] , [ pathint]where the partition function , @xmath13 , is a normalizing factor such that @xmath14 . the celebrated divergences which plague quantum field theory are primarily due to the fact that the space of classical field configurations , @xmath15 , is infinite - dimensional ; this leaves the functional integral measure @xmath16 formal and awkwardly ill - defined . in the usual treatment of quantum field theory , perturbative feynman rules are derived from the formal path integral . unfortunately , these feynman rules typically lead to infinite results . in order to get meaningful results from computations , the feynman rules are usually regularized _ ad hoc_. this is quite effective for perturbative calculations since the details are independent of the choice of regularization . however , reality is not a perturbation . physical phenomena such as quark confinement are not reflected in strictly perturbative theories . a complete description of reality will presumably involve a nonperturbative regularization . in a euclidean quantum field theory , a nonperturbative regularization is implemented at the level of the path - integral rather than perturbation theory . one approach to regularization is to replace the original space of field configurations with some finite - dimensional approximation ; this essentially guarantees a finite theory . if @xmath17 is a single scalar field on a compact manifold , @xmath18 , then the space of field configurations is the algebra of smooth functions , @xmath19 . where algebra goes , other structures will surely follow ; for this reason , and simplicity , i shall largely restrict attention to a scalar field . to regularize , we would like to approximate @xmath20 by a finite dimensional algebra . the standard approach is to use the algebra of functions on some finite set of points a lattice which approximates @xmath18 . unfortunately , a lattice is symmetry s mortal enemy . if the space @xmath18 possesses a nontrivial group of isometries , it would be desirable to preserve these as symmetries in the regularized theory ; but for instance , in a lattice approximation to @xmath1 , the best possible approximation to the @xmath21-symmetry is the 60-element icosahedral group . we can maintain much greater symmetry with noncommutative approximating algebras . geometric quantization provides a method of constructing noncommutative approximations . as the name suggests , geometric quantization was originally intended as a systematic mathematical procedure for constructing quantum mechanics from classical mechanics . geometric quantization applies to a symplectic manifold ( originally , phase space ) with some additional structure ( a `` polarization '' ) . the terminology of quantization is unfortunate here , since i am concerned with quantum field theory . insofar as geometric quantization goes here , the manifold is not to be interpreted as phase space , the hilbert spaces are not to be interpreted as spaces of quantum - mechanical states , and the algebras do not consist of observables . in this paper , `` quantization '' and `` quantum '' have nothing to do with each other . here i shall use geometric quantization with a `` complex polarization '' . for a compact khler manifold , @xmath18 , this generates a sequence of finite - dimensional matrix algebras @xmath22 which approximate the algebra @xmath20 in a sense that i shall explain below . a khler manifold is simultaneously a riemannian , symplectic , and complex manifold . these structures are compatible with each other , such that raising one index of the symplectic 2-form , @xmath23 , with the riemannian metric gives the complex structure . ] i shall assume , for a length @xmath25 ( roughly , the size of @xmath18 ) , that the integral of @xmath26 over any closed 2-surface is an integer ; this implies the existence of a line bundle ( 1-dimensional , complex vector bundle ) , @xmath27 , with a connection @xmath28 and curvature @xmath29 . if @xmath18 is simply connected , then @xmath27 is unique . there is also a unique fiberwise , hermitian inner product on @xmath27 compatible with the connection . given two sections @xmath30 , their inner product is a function @xmath31 . compatibility with the connection means that for smooth sections , @xmath32 . using the fiberwise inner product , we can construct a global inner product , : = _ | .[inner.product]it is an elementary property of any khler manifold that the riemannian volume form can also be written in terms of the symplectic form as @xmath33 , where @xmath34 . a holomorphic section of @xmath27 is one satisfying the differential equation @xmath35 , or in index notation @xmath36 . the space of holomorphic sections @xmath37 is finite dimensional , and the inner product , , makes it a hilbert space . with this notation and structure , i can now present the geometric quantization construction . the tensor power bundle @xmath38 is much like @xmath27 ; it is a line bundle with an inner product , but with curvature @xmath39 . as @xmath40 increases , the spaces of holomorphic sections are increasingly large , finite - dimensional hilbert spaces , @xmath41 the dimension of @xmath42 grows as a polynomial in @xmath40 ( given by the riemann - roch formula , eq . ) . the algebra @xmath22 is now defined as @xmath43 that is , the space of @xmath44-linear maps from @xmath42 to itself in other words , matrices over @xmath42 . the inner product on @xmath42 gives @xmath22 an involution ( hermitian adjoint ) @xmath45 ; this makes @xmath22 a finite - dimensional c@xmath6-algebra . the collection of algebras @xmath46 alone knows nothing of @xmath18 . in order to connect @xmath22 with @xmath18 , we will need a structure such as the toeplitz quantization map @xmath47 . for any function @xmath48 , the matrix @xmath49 is defined by giving its action on any @xmath50 . since @xmath51 is a section of @xmath52 , the product @xmath53 is also a ( not necessarily holomorphic ) section of @xmath38 . using the inner product we can project @xmath53 orthogonally back to @xmath42 and call this @xmath54 . this implicitly defines @xmath55 . if @xmath18 were a phase space then @xmath49 would be interpreted as the quantum observable , @xmath56 , corresponding to @xmath57 . the toeplitz maps have the important property of being _ approximately _ multiplicative ; that is , for any two continuous functions on @xmath18 , @xmath58 according to rieffel @xcite , quantization should be expressed in terms of a continuous field of c@xmath6-algebras . a continuous field @xmath59 of c@xmath6-algebras over a compact topological space @xmath60 is essentially a vector bundle whose fibers are c@xmath6-algebras ( see @xcite ) . the space of continuous sections @xmath61 is a c@xmath6-algebra . for every point @xmath62 , the evaluation map from @xmath61 onto the fiber over @xmath63 is a @xmath64-homomorphism ( a c@xmath6-algebra map ) . the product of a continuous function on @xmath60 with a continuous section of @xmath59 is again a continuous section of @xmath59 . a continuous field of c@xmath6-algebras is completely specified by describing its base space , its fibers , and which sections are continuous . the geometric quantization of @xmath18 leads to a natural continuous field of c@xmath6-algebras , @xmath59 . the fibers of @xmath59 are each of the algebras @xmath22 and @xmath65 . this is one algebra for every natural number @xmath66 , plus one extra . the notion is that the sequence of algebras @xmath67 tends toward @xmath65 , so the natural topology for the base space is the one - point compactification @xmath68 , in which @xmath7 is the limit of any increasing sequence . the field @xmath59 is implicitly defined by the requirement that for every @xmath48 , there exists a section @xmath69 whose evaluation at @xmath40 is @xmath49 and at @xmath7 is @xmath57 . the existence of this continuous field is the sense in which the algebra @xmath22 approximates @xmath65 , but we can do better than this . there is a sense in which @xmath22 approximates the algebra of smooth functions @xmath19 . as i discussed in @xcite , the field @xmath59 has a further structure as a sort of _ smooth _ field of c@xmath6-algebras . obviously , our base space , @xmath70 is not a manifold . however , there is a reasonable notion of smooth functions on @xmath70 . we can identify @xmath70 with the homeomorphic set @xmath71 , and define the smooth functions @xmath72 as those which are restrictions of smooth functions on @xmath73 . equivalently , a smooth function on @xmath70 is one which can be approximated to arbitrary order by a power series in @xmath74 . the smooth structure of @xmath59 is given by a dense @xmath64-subalgebra @xmath75 of `` smooth '' sections . the product of a smooth function on @xmath70 with a smooth section of @xmath59 is again a smooth section of @xmath59 . the evaluation of any smooth section at @xmath7 is a smooth function on @xmath18 . the algebra @xmath76 is essentially defined by the condition that any smooth function @xmath77 gives a smooth section @xmath78 . some of the simplest spaces to work with are homogeneous spaces those such that any point of @xmath18 is equivalent to any other point under some isometry . in a homogeneous space with semisimple symmetry group , @xmath79 , we can do many calculations by simply using group representation theory . the homogeneous khler manifolds with semisimple symmetry group are the _ coadjoint orbits_. a coadjoint orbit of a lie group , @xmath79 , is simply a homogeneous space that is naturally embedded in the dual space , @xmath80 , of the lie algebra , @xmath81 , of @xmath79 . the coadjoint orbits of @xmath79 are classified by positive weight vectors of @xmath79 . weight vectors are naturally embedded in @xmath80 , and corresponding to the weight vector @xmath82 is its @xmath79-orbit @xmath83 , the set of images of @xmath82 under the action of elements of @xmath79 . in the case of @xmath84 , the space @xmath85 is 3-dimensional , and the coadjoint orbits are the concentric 2-spheres around the origin . the weight , @xmath82 , is simply a positive number , the radius . the geometric quantization of a coadjoint orbit is especially simple and respects the action of the symmetry group , @xmath79 . the hilbert space , @xmath42 , constructed in the geometric quantization of @xmath83 carries an irreducible representation of @xmath79 . namely , the representation with `` highest weight '' @xmath86 . in the case of @xmath87 , the hilbert space , @xmath42 , carries the representation of spin @xmath88 . the algebras are again defined by @xmath89 . again , we need to tie these together into a smooth field , @xmath59 , of c@xmath6-algebras . in the case of a coadjoint orbit , this can be done by using the lie algebra structure rather than the toeplitz quantization maps . let s briefly consider what can be said about @xmath59 , given only the collection of algebras @xmath46 . the restriction of @xmath59 to @xmath90 is a rather trivial continuous field ; since @xmath91 is discrete , any section is continuous . a section of @xmath59 over @xmath91 is nothing more than a sequence of matrices , one taken from each @xmath22 . the bounded sections of @xmath59 over @xmath91 ( norm - bounded sequences ) form a c@xmath6-algebra . so , you see , we already knew the restriction of @xmath59 to @xmath91 . since @xmath42 carries a @xmath79-representation , there is a linear map @xmath92 , taking lie brackets to commutators . because the representation is irreducible , the image of @xmath81 is enough to generate the entire associative algebra @xmath22 . in fact , @xmath22 can be expressed in terms of generators and relations based on this . let @xmath93 be a basis of self - adjoint generators of the complexified lie algebra , @xmath94 . the @xmath95 s can be thought of as sections of @xmath59 over @xmath91 , but they are unbounded sections , because their norms diverge linearly with @xmath40 . we can get bounded sections by dividing by @xmath40 . the operators @xmath96 are noncommutative embedding coordinates for the coadjoint orbit , @xmath83 , of radius @xmath97 . i would like to work with a coadjoint orbit of radius @xmath25 , so i define x_i:=j_i .[x ] we can construct @xmath98 as the c@xmath6-subalgebra of bounded sections of @xmath59 over @xmath91 that is generated by the @xmath99 s . this implicitly defines @xmath59 as a continuous field . the algebra @xmath22 can be expressed in terms of the generators @xmath95 or @xmath99 and three types of relations . in the @xmath87 case , the @xmath95 s are the three standard angular momentum operators , and @xmath100 . the first relations are the commutation relations that define the lie algebra . in the @xmath87-case , these are @xmath101_-=ij_3 $ ] and cyclic permutations thereof . in terms of the @xmath99 s these relations have a factor of @xmath74 on the right hand side , as @xmath102_-=\frac{i}2rn^{-1}x_3 $ ] . in the limit of @xmath103 , the relations simply become that the @xmath99 s commute . the second relations are casimir relations . these enforce that the various casimir operators have the correct eigenvalues . in the @xmath87-case , there is only one independent casimir , the quadratic one . the relation is @xmath104 , or in terms of the @xmath99 s , @xmath105 . the third relations are the serre relations . these enforce finite - dimensionality . in the @xmath87-case , this can be expressed as @xmath106 . the serre relations are equivalent to the requirement that @xmath22 is a c@xmath6-algebra , and become redundant in the @xmath103 limit . heuristically at least , in the case of @xmath87 , as @xmath103 , the relations become that the @xmath99 s commute and satisfy @xmath107 . clearly , this does generate the algebra of functions on @xmath1 of radius @xmath25 . in general , as @xmath103 , the @xmath99 s commute and satisfy polynomial relations which determine the relevant coadjoint orbit . only a few facts about the smooth structure of @xmath59 will be needed later . specifically , the @xmath99 s and @xmath74 are smooth sections , and any smooth section vanishing at @xmath108 is a multiple of @xmath74 . for a single real scalar field , @xmath109 , the general , unregularized action functional is s [ ] : = _ , [ general.action ] where @xmath110 is the volume form on @xmath18 , and @xmath111 is a lower - bounded polynomial self - coupling . complex conjugation on @xmath19 corresponds to the adjoint on @xmath22 , so our approximation to the space of real functions on @xmath18 will be the subspace @xmath112 of self - adjoint elements . to construct the regularized theory , we need a regularized action defined on @xmath113 that approximates . let s be precise about what it means to approximate an action functional in this way . we need a sequence of action functionals , @xmath114 , which converge to the unregularized action @xmath115 . this is nontrivial to define because these are functionals on different spaces . let @xmath116 be an arbitrary , self - adjoint , smooth section , and denote its evaluations as @xmath117 ; the sequence @xmath118 can be considered to converge well to the smooth function @xmath119 . my definition for convergence of @xmath120 is simply that for any such @xmath17 , @xmath121 \mbox.\ ] ] several ingredients are needed to construct a regularized action . the simplest is the product . it is the most elementary property of geometric quantization that multiplication in @xmath19 is approximated by multiplication in @xmath22 . the normalized trace on @xmath22 approximates the normalized integral on @xmath18 . that is , for any @xmath122 , @xmath123 the unregularized kinetic term can be written in terms of the laplacian , @xmath124 , using the elementary identity , @xmath125 mimicking this , we can safely write the regularized kinetic term as @xmath126 \mbox,\ ] ] since in fact , _ any _ quadratic functional can be written in this form . in the coadjoint orbit case , which i will mainly discuss , the laplacian is simply a multiple of the quadratic casimir operator . however , the discussion in this section will apply equally to any khler manifold for which a suitable approximate laplacian can be constructed . for this reason , i will write the approximate laplacian as @xmath127 until a more explicit form is required for examples . the regularized action approximating is ( using @xmath128 ) s_n ( ) = .[regact]this regularized action was originally formulated by grosse , klimk , and prenajder @xcite in the special case of @xmath1 ; however , the corresponding perturbation theory has not previously been discussed in detail . using the action , we can now define the regularized theory using a path integral formula , z0f ( ) 0:= _ _ n^ f ( ) e^-s_n ( ) d.[pathint2]this is formally identical to eq . , but it differs in that it is not merely a formal expression . the measure @xmath129 is simply the lebesgue measure on the finite - dimensional vector space @xmath113 . because @xmath130 increases at least quadratically in all directions , eq . is finite for all polynomial functionals @xmath131 . in the standard lattice regularization , it is necessary to verify that a theory is sufficiently well behaved in the `` continuum limit '' as the regularization is removed . the limit of removing the regularization in the present case is the commutative limit , @xmath103 . at this stage , it is not entirely clear what the correct definition of convergence in the commutative limit should be . certainly , renormalization is necessary . that is , the bare mass , @xmath132 , and coupling constants ( the coefficients in @xmath111 ) must depend on @xmath40 , and the field @xmath17 must also be renormalized by an @xmath40-dependent factor . some condition of convergence is then applied to the sequence of renormalized , regularized theories . a plausible form of the convergence condition is in terms of the one - particle irreducible generating functionals , @xmath133 . these are functions @xmath134 , derived from the path - integral . if the generating functionals are renormalized so that @xmath135 , then the condition may be that for any smooth , self - adjoint section @xmath116 , with evaluations @xmath117 , the sequence @xmath136 is convergent . the derivation of feynman rules from the path integral can now proceed in essentially the standard , heuristic way ( see , e. g. , @xcite ) , except that now it is not just a formal calculation . before we can discuss perturbation theory on a noncommutative space , we must first understand what green s functions are from an algebraic perspective . i begin in greater generality than just a scalar field . in general , the space of classical field configurations , @xmath15 , need not be a vector space . such is the case for nonlinear @xmath137-models . however , for a free field theory , @xmath15 is always a vector space . since we are going to apply perturbation theory about a free field theory , we must assume that @xmath15 is a vector space here . a green s function is the vacuum expectation value of a product of fields . an expectation value of a quantum field @xmath138 is an element of the space of classical field configurations , @xmath15 , since @xmath138 is thought of as a quantum field valued in @xmath15 . an expectation value of a product of two fields is an element of the ( real ) tensor product @xmath139 . carrying on like this , we see that a @xmath140-point green s function is an element of the real tensor power @xmath141 . the use of real tensor products here is actually not restrictive ; for a complex field , @xmath17 , a real tensor product will include all possible combinations of @xmath17 and its conjugate field . actually , i am overoptimistically allowing a great deal to fall into the ambiguity in a tensor product of infinite dimensional spaces . in the case of a real scalar field , @xmath142 , so the tensor product @xmath139 should intuitively be a space of functions of two points on @xmath18 . indeed , a 2-point green s function for a scalar field is a function of two points ; however , it has a singularity where the points coincide . this shows that the tensor product needs to be interpreted liberally . fortunately this issue is irrelevant to the case at hand . once @xmath15 is finite - dimensional , there is no ambiguity in the tensor product . in discussing divergences , one deals primarily with one - particle - irreducible ( 1p.08emi ) green s functions . these can be constructed as derivatives of an @xmath73-valued generating functional on @xmath15 . this shows immediately that a @xmath140-point , 1p.08emi greens function is a linear map from @xmath141 to @xmath73 . one - particle - irreducible green s functions thus live in the dual space of the corresponding ordinary green s functions . because of the coefficient in front of the action , there are powers of ( in the case of ) @xmath143 coming from the vertices and propagators . if , instead of setting @xmath144 , we had kept explicit factors of @xmath145 , then the combination @xmath146 multiplying the action would be the only appearance of @xmath145 in the functional integral . this means that the overall power of @xmath147 for a feynman diagram is the same as the overall power of @xmath145 namely , the number of loops plus @xmath148 . actually , implicit in most action functionals is an inner product on @xmath15 . this means that @xmath15 can be more or less naturally identified with a subspace of @xmath149 in general , and with all of @xmath149 when it is finite - dimensional . this inner product on @xmath15 tends to suffer an ambiguity of normalization . the most natural inner product of two functions is given by multiplying them and integrating . the most natural inner product on @xmath22 is given by multiplying matrices and taking the trace . unfortunately , these inner products disagree when we pair @xmath148 with itself . in @xmath65 that gives @xmath150 ; in @xmath22 it gives @xmath151 . we must correct the inner product on @xmath22 by a factor of @xmath147 , for consistency with that on functions . the natural form of the 1p.08emi green s functions is not actually the most useful normalization for comparison with the results of standard perturbation theory . in practice , we deal with ordinary feynman diagrams in momentum space . the quantities we usually deal with are not the momentum - space green s functions themselves , but have an overall , momentum - conserving @xmath152-function divided out . consider 2-point green s functions in a scalar theory . in momentum space , with the @xmath152-function divided out , these are simply functions of a single momentum . multiplying two such functions in momentum space corresponds to convolution of green s functions . in this normalization , a 2-point green s function is a convolution operator ; that is a linear map @xmath153 . in general , a @xmath140-point 1p.08emi green s function in this normalization is a linear map @xmath154 . in the regularized theory , this change simply amounts to dividing our amplitudes by @xmath147 . this simplifies the feynman rules slightly , so that the overall power of @xmath147 is now simply the number of loops . i ll now specialize to the theory given by the action , although most of the considerations are more general . as usual , the action splits into a free part ( the first two terms ) and an interaction part ( the @xmath111 term ) . the free part gives the propagator @xmath155 ; each monomial of @xmath156 gives a vertex whose valence is the degree of the monomial . a vertex of valence @xmath157 essentially represents the trace of a product of @xmath157 matrices . the term corresponding to a standard feynman diagram is a sum of terms with different orderings of the products . it is convenient to represent these subterms diagrammatically . for each vertex , the multiplicands correspond to incoming edges . because only the cyclic order matters in a trace , we only need to indicate a cyclic order to the edges . this is easily done graphically by drawing the vertex in the plane . the order of multiplication is indicated by the counterclockwise order of the attached edges . the distinct terms are thus labeled by `` framings '' of the feynman diagram in the plane . in ordinary quantum field theory involving a real field , there are symmetry factors to deal with . the contribution of a given diagram is divided by the number of its symmetries . in this case there is an additional type of combinatorial factor present . since a given ordinary feynman diagram corresponds to several framed diagrams , these framed diagrams are weighted by coefficients adding up to @xmath148 . determining these coefficients is a matter of enumerating the cyclic orientations of all vertices , and sorting the resultant framings into equivalence classes . to express the exact feynman rules , it is convenient to adapt the notation invented by t hooft for discussing the large @xmath40 limit of @xmath158-gauge theories ( see @xcite ) . in that diagrammar , the gluon propagator is represented by a double line ( two directed lines in opposite directions ) . an outgoing arrow indicates an upper index and an ingoing arrow indicates a lower index . the way lines are connected indicates how indices are contracted . in these diagrams , the two lines of a gluon propagator do not touch . this is appropriate , since they really have nothing to do with each other . the propagator is not just invariant under @xmath158 , but under 2 separate actions of @xmath158 corresponding to the 2 separate edges . in the present context , however , the notation needs to be modified . the propagator is not invariant under arbitrary unitary transformations ; it is only invariant under the isometries of @xmath18 ( if there are any ) . the two lines of the propagator are thus no longer independent , and i indicate this by linked double lines as shown in fig [ propagator ] . ] the upper indices ( outgoing arrows ) are factors of @xmath42 , while the lower indices ( ingoing arrows ) are factors of @xmath159 . each factor of @xmath160 thus gives an upper and a lower index , or an incoming and an outgoing arrow . ] figure [ doubled ] shows a more complicated doubled diagram . note that no distinction is made between overcrossings and undercrossings . a reader might reasonably question that this is truly a regularization of _ real _ scalar field theory . after all , the subspace @xmath112 is not closed under multiplication , so why should these feynman rules respect this subspace ? the issue is whether the green s functions are self - adjoint , in the obvious sense for elements of a tensor power of @xmath22 . in fact , a given ( framed ) feynman diagram may not be self - adjoint . however , its adjoint is the mirror - image diagram , which is another framing of the same diagram and therefore contributes to the same green s function . this makes the green s functions themselves self - adjoint , order - by - order in perturbation theory . this is a convenient point at which to introduce some further notation . there are three different length scales that are pertinent to quantum field theory on a quantized , compact space , and there are parameters characterizing each of these scales . i have already introduced the length @xmath25 . this characterizes the overall size of the manifold @xmath18 . it is relevant to quantum field theory as the infra - red cutoff scale ; that is , there do not exist modes of wavelength more than about @xmath25 . the second parameter , @xmath161 , characterizes the scale of noncommutativity . as i have mentioned ( sec . [ gq ] ) , geometric quantization was originally intended as a tool for deriving quantum mechanics from classical mechanics , so there is an analogy between some constructions here and in that problem . in this analogy , @xmath162 corresponds to @xmath145 . like a classical phase space , the khler manifold @xmath18 has a poisson bracket . the poisson bracket of two differentiable functions on @xmath18 is defined as @xmath163 , where the poisson bivector , @xmath164 , is in turn the inverse of the symplectic form in the sense that @xmath165 . the analogy continues with commutation relations , @xmath166_- = -i{\kappa}t_n(\{f , g\ } ) + { \mathcal{o}}^{2}({\kappa } ) \mbox,\ ] ] or heuristically , @xmath167_-\approx -i{\kappa}\{f , g\ } \mbox.\ ] ] note that @xmath162 has the dimensions of an area ; this balances the two derivatives occurring in the poisson bracket . in quantum mechanics , noncommutativity of observables leads to uncertainty relations . likewise , noncommutativity here should intuitively lead to uncertainty relations between coordinates ( _ roughly _ , something like @xmath168 ) . this suggests that the best that we can specify a point is to an uncertainty of the order @xmath169 in all directions . naively , we might conclude from this that @xmath18 is broken up into `` cells '' of this size and that the noncommutativity effects an ultraviolet cutoff at the mass scale @xmath170 , but this is not so . actually , if we divide @xmath18 into cells of size about @xmath169 , then the number of cells will be about @xmath151 . using the fact that the todd class , @xmath171 is equal to @xmath148 plus higher degree cohomology classes , the riemann - roch formula shows , _ n= _ te^ = + ^1-n ( ) .[riemann - roch]this shows that these cells correspond to the degrees of freedom of @xmath42 rather than of the scalar field . but what is the ultra - violet cutoff scale really ? the number of degrees of freedom associated to a scalar field is @xmath172 , so the volume belonging to each degree of freedom is @xmath173 the length scale of this cutoff is thus of the order @xmath174 , or as a mass ( inverse length ) , @xmath175 the noncommutativity scale set by @xmath162 is the geometric mean between the infra - red and ultra - violet scales . if we attempt to remove the infra - red cutoff ( decompactify the space ) by sending @xmath176 without @xmath162 diverging , then we must let @xmath177 . in other words , if the infra - red cutoff is taken away , then the ultra - violet cutoff goes away . this implies that noncommutativity only achieves an ultra - violet cutoff in the presence of an infra - red cutoff ! that will be proven in sec . [ flatqft ] . this is in marked contrast to lattice regularization . for one thing , an unbounded lattice can certainly achieve an ultra - violet cutoff . in a lattice , there is a sharply defined minimum separation between points ( the lattice spacing ) ; this is also the scale of the ultra - violet cutoff . on a quantized space , there is a fuzzy minimum observable distance , but this is much larger than the length scale of the ultra - violet cutoff . just because a computation is well - defined and possible in principle , does nt necessarily mean it is easy or practicable . doing exact calculations on coadjoint orbits requires working with representations of the symmetry group . while this is better than working on a space with no symmetry at all , it is not as easy as working on flat space . for flat space , calculations in quantum field theory are considerably simplified by the fact that momentum space is a vector space . locally , any manifold looks like flat space . topologically , this is the very definition of a manifold . geometrically , this is the content of einstein s principle of equivalence . if we are concerned with issues of small - scale physics ( like renormalization ) then it would be nice to do calculations in the simplified setting of flat space and not worry about the global structure of our manifold . the heuristic arguments of sec . [ scales ] have already indicated that things are not so simple . we can not ignore global structure , because ultra - violet regularization is dependent upon the global property of compactness . nevertheless , i will introduce in sec . [ deformation ] an approximation technique which takes advantage of the local resemblance to flat space . before i can describe this approximation i must discuss flat space itself . specifically , i will discuss quantized flat space , which does not have the effect of regularizing quantum field theory , but does modify it in a relevant way . if we `` zoom in '' around any point of a symplectic ( or even poisson ) manifold , then it will resemble a flat , affine space , with a poisson bracket determined by a constant poisson bivector , @xmath164 , as @xmath178 although the symplectic case is what we are really interested in , there is no need to assume that @xmath164 is nondegenerate in this section . a tensor product of two functions on the flat space @xmath179 is naturally regarded as a function on @xmath180 . the multiplication map @xmath181 is equivalent to the diagonal evaluation map , @xmath182 so that @xmath183 . if we regard @xmath164 as a second order differential operator on @xmath180 , then the poisson bracket can be expressed as @xmath184 with this notation , the weyl product corresponding to @xmath164 is defined as @xmath185 if we treat this as simply a formal power series in @xmath162 , then @xmath186 is an associative product . the space @xmath187 $ ] is defined to consist of formal power series in @xmath162 whose coefficients are smooth functions on @xmath179 . the formal deformation quantization algebra @xmath188 is @xmath187 $ ] with the product @xmath186 . unfortunately , if we insert an arbitrary pair of smooth functions into eq . , the series will typically diverge . fortunately , there is a sufficiently large space of functions for which @xmath186 does converge , that we can construct a sensible , concrete quantization of @xmath179 from this . the archetypal functions for which eq . is convergent are plane - wave functions . the weyl product of two plane - wave functions is simply e^-ipx * _ e^-iqx = e^i2\{p , q}e^-i(p+q ) x , [ expprod]using the shorthand @xmath189 since this combination will occur frequently . this notation is justified by the fact that if we think of @xmath190 and @xmath191 as linear functions on @xmath179 , then @xmath192 really is their poisson bracket . the `` good '' subalgebra @xmath193 consists of those functions whose dependence on @xmath162 is entire , and whose fourier transforms ( on @xmath179 ) are compactly supported . @xmath194 is algebraically closed , and consists of _ convergent _ power series in @xmath162 , so we can actually assign @xmath162 a concrete value . the mathematically sanctioned way to assign @xmath162 a concrete value , @xmath195 , is to quotient @xmath194 by the ideal generated by @xmath196 . the quotient algebra @xmath197 can then be completed to a c@xmath6-algebra . this is the concrete weyl quantization of @xmath179 at @xmath195 . this is the same algebra that would be obtained by geometric quantization . if we tried to construct the concrete weyl algebra directly from @xmath198 , we would have failed because the ideal generated in @xmath198 by @xmath196 is all of @xmath198 . the quotient @xmath199 is thus trivial . we can construct perturbative quantum field theory on quantized @xmath179 . the derivation of feynman rules is formally the same as on a quantized compact space ; because of noncommutativity , we still have to distinguish cyclic orderings of edges around vertices . however , there will again be divergent feynman diagrams which demand regularization ; thus justifying the claim that ultra - violet regularization is contingent upon infra - red regularization . in terms of momentum space , the feynman rules for vertices are modified by momenta dependent phase factors . these can be understood geometrically . in momentum space , which is dual to the position space @xmath179 , the bivector @xmath164 becomes a 2-form . the @xmath200 in eq . is precisely the flux of @xmath201 through the triangle formed by @xmath190 and @xmath191 ( see fig . [ triangle ] ) . ] for a valence @xmath157 vertex draw an @xmath157-sided polygon in momentum space such that the difference of the ends of a side is equal to the ingoing momentum of the corresponding propagator line . momentum conservation requires that the momenta add up to @xmath202 , which ensures that the polygon is closed . decomposing the polygon into triangles shows that the phase associated to the vertex is @xmath162 times the flux of @xmath201 through the polygon . note that this polygon is only fixed modulo an overall translation . in conventional euclidean real scalar field theory , the amplitudes are real ; the same is true here . we must again remember to sum over all framings of a feynman diagram . the phases lead to cosines of products of momenta . if the evaluation of a feynman diagram involves phases depending on internal momenta , then the resulting oscillatory integral may give a finite result where there once was a divergence . however , consistent with the heuristic argument about @xmath177 in sec . [ scales ] , this will not eliminate all divergences . ] planar diagrams remain just as divergent as those for commutative @xmath179 . the following proof is equivalent to that already given by filk @xcite ; however , i interpret it geometrically rather than in terms of `` special graph - topological properties of cocycles '' . consider a planar feynman diagram @xmath203 , such as that shown in fig . we can construct a dual polygonalization ( 2-dimensional cw - complex ) @xmath204 . this has a vertex for each open space in the planar rendering of @xmath203 , including both spaces enclosed by internal edges and spaces between external edges . the edges of @xmath204 are in one - to - one correspondence with the edges of @xmath203 . the 2-cells ( polygons ) of @xmath204 correspond to the vertices of @xmath203 . just as for a single vertex , we can embed @xmath204 in momentum space so that the separation between adjacent vertices of @xmath204 is the momentum associated to the connecting edge . equivalently , we can construct a polygon for each vertex of @xmath203 ( as above ) and fit these together . the total phase associated to @xmath203 is then given by the total flux of @xmath205 through all polygons of @xmath204 . however , @xmath164 is a constant and thus closed differential form , so the the flux only depends on the shape of the boundary of @xmath204 in momentum space . thus , the phase only depends on the momenta of the external lines . indeed the phase is the same as if the external lines entered a single vertex . a generalization of this construction to non - planar diagrams will be employed in sec . [ divergences ] . the deformation quantization of @xmath179 in sec . [ qflat ] is the archetype of a more general construction ( see @xcite for overview ) . in the formal deformation quantization of a manifold @xmath18 , the product @xmath186 is a formal power series in @xmath162 whose terms are bidifferential operators on @xmath18 ( as in eq . ) . just as for flat space , the algebra @xmath206 is equivalent as a vector space to the space , @xmath207 $ ] , of formal power series in @xmath162 with smooth functions as coefficients . in general , a deformation quantization can always be constructed to fit @xmath167_-=-i{\kappa}\{f , g\ } \mod { \kappa}^2 \mbox,\ ] ] for any poisson bracket on @xmath18 ; see @xcite . a deformation quantization can also be derived from a geometric quantization . geometric quantization can be loosely thought of as making the product of functions on @xmath18 variable ( dependent on @xmath162 ) ; the corresponding deformation quantization is the result of asymptotically expanding the product as a power series in @xmath162 . as i explained in @xcite , this algebra can be constructed from the smooth field of c@xmath6-algebras , @xmath59 , given by geometric quantization . the parameter @xmath162 is itself a smooth function on @xmath70 and vanishes at the point @xmath108 . in fact , any smooth section of @xmath59 which vanishes at @xmath7 is a multiple of @xmath162 . the space of smooth sections which vanish to order @xmath208 at @xmath7 is thus @xmath209 ; this is a 2-sided ideal . in the quotient algebra @xmath210 ( the algebra of `` jets '' about @xmath7 ) , the variability of the product is preserved to order @xmath211 . these quotient algebras naturally form an algebraic inverse system . taking the algebraic inverse limit gives the deformation quantization algebra corresponding to @xmath59 , @xmath212 we have just seen how to construct a deformation quantization from the geometric quantization . in sec . [ qflat ] , i described the opposite process reconstructing the geometric quantization from a deformation quantization in the case of flat space . this involved a `` good '' subalgebra @xmath193 . it may or may not be possible to make an analogous construction in all cases , but it can be done for coadjoint orbits . in this section i will describe a good subalgebra of @xmath213 . let @xmath59 be the smooth field given by geometric quantization of the coadjoint orbit @xmath83 . the sections defined in eq . are smooth sections , @xmath214 . since smooth sections form an algebra , any product of @xmath99 s , or linear combination thereof , is also a smooth section . such sections form a subalgebra i denote @xmath215 , the polynomial sections . since this is a subalgebra of the smooth sections , there is , for each @xmath208 , a natural homomorphism _ ( , ) ^(,)/^j+1 .[inclusion.quotient]the kernel of this is just @xmath216 , which vanishes as @xmath217 . when the @xmath217 limit is taken , becomes a natural , injective homomorphism , @xmath218 thus , @xmath215 is a subalgebra of both @xmath98 and @xmath198 . in the identification of @xmath213 with @xmath219 $ ] as a vector space , @xmath215 corresponds to @xmath220 $ ] , the space of polynomials in @xmath162 whose coefficients are polynomial functions on @xmath83 . this is the good subalgebra i wanted . in @xmath198 , @xmath221 is invertible , so the ideal it generates is all of @xmath198 ; thus we can not assign @xmath162 a concrete value in @xmath198 . on the other hand , the functions of @xmath162 in @xmath215 are all polynomials ; therefore , @xmath221 is not invertible and generates a nontrivial ideal in @xmath215 . we can meaningfully take the quotient algebra , @xmath222 in terms of the generators and relations representation of @xmath22 in sec . [ coadjoint ] , the quotient algebra @xmath223 is what we get by discarding the serre relations . there is therefore a natural surjective homomorphism e:_n^-14mu_n.[truncation]by characterizing the kernel of @xmath224 , we can effectively reconstruct the geometric quantization from the deformation quantization . as a @xmath79-representation , @xmath223 is indistinguishable from the space of polynomial functions on @xmath83 ; this is the direct sum of all irreducible @xmath79-representations appearing in @xmath225 . in @xmath22 , this lattice of irreducible representations is cut off ; @xmath22 is finite - dimensional . the kernel of @xmath224 is spanned by those @xmath79-representations which occur in @xmath225 , but not in @xmath22 . this is the key to doing approximate calculations . imagine that @xmath25 is very large . if we sit at some point of @xmath83 , then the region around us appears very close to the flat space @xmath226 ( where @xmath227 ) . we would like to describe the geometric quantization of @xmath83 in this approximation , but the geometric quantization of the noncompact space @xmath226 is very different from that of compact @xmath83 . their deformation quantizations , however , are similar , because the deformation quantization product is constructible locally from bidifferential operators . the geometric quantization of @xmath83 can be approximated using the weyl quantization of @xmath226 , and an approximation for the cutoff on representations . i refer to this as the deformation approximation if we are concerned with some field theory on a quantized coadjoint orbit then we would like to exploit the deformation approximation and the relationship with flat space in order to approximate the values of feynman diagrams for large @xmath40 . to accomplish this , we must characterize the kernel of the surjective homomorphism @xmath224 in in terms of momentum space . consider the case of @xmath1 . as an @xmath87-representation , @xmath228 contains all the irreducible representations of integer spin . on the other hand , @xmath22 is the direct sum of representations of integer spin @xmath229 . the kernel of @xmath224 consists of those representations of @xmath87 which are contained in @xmath228 but not @xmath22 . that means modes whose spin exceeds @xmath40 . the laplacian on @xmath1 with radius @xmath25 is @xmath230 , so the eigenvalue on a spherical harmonic with spin @xmath231 is @xmath232 . it is thus possible to characterize @xmath233 in terms of the laplacian : @xmath233 is spanned by the eigenfunctions of @xmath127 with eigenvalue greater than @xmath234 . now take the flat space approximation . in terms of momentum space , an eigenvalue of @xmath127 is simply the magnitude - squared of a momentum vector . modes with momentum greater than @xmath235 belong to the kernel of @xmath224 . we can approximate the algebra @xmath22 by the weyl product on @xmath236 , with modes of momentum greater than @xmath235 set to @xmath202 . as i have said , geometric quantization can be thought of as a modification of the product . in the feynman rules , products occur at the vertices . _ ab initio _ , one might expect that the feynman rules for the deformation approximation would differ from the flat space feynman rules only at the vertices . however , it is actually more convenient to shift some of the modification to the propagators . in the deformation approximation for @xmath1 , the product of a sequence of plane - wave functions is equal to their weyl product , _ if _ all the momenta have magnitude @xmath237 , otherwise the product is @xmath202 . in terms of the feynman rules , this translates into restricting ( `` cutting off '' ) momentum integration to the region in which all momenta have magnitude @xmath237 . in general , the cutoff can be more complicated . momenta are restricted to some region of size @xmath235 . this `` shape '' of the cutoff depends on the particular coadjoint orbit being considered , although it is significantly limited by symmetry . in our approximation of zooming in around one point of @xmath83 , there is still a symmetry group of rotations about that point ( isotropies ) . momentum space carries a representation of the isotropy group , and the cutoff must be invariant under this . this is a difference with lattice regularization ; that is much more arbitrary because features of the cutoff are not constrained by symmetry ; here , there is no arbitrariness . as examples , i shall consider the coadjoint orbits of dimension @xmath238 . there are really only three of these : @xmath1 , @xmath239 , and @xmath3 . for @xmath1 we have just seen that the cutoff shape is @xmath240 , a disc of radius @xmath235 , which is the only convex shape allowed by symmetry anyway . for @xmath2 , the cutoff shape derives from that of @xmath1 and is clearly @xmath241 . for @xmath3 , the cutoff can again be characterized by the laplacian ; it is @xmath242 , a ball of radius @xmath235 . again , this is the only convex shape allowed by symmetry . the feynman rules in the deformation approximation are a modification of those for quantized flat space . the cutoff is implemented by modifying the propagator . i summarize the feynman rules here . for each internal edge carrying momentum @xmath190 , there is a propagator s(p ) = , [ cutoff.propagator]where @xmath243 is a step function , equal to @xmath148 inside the cutoff and @xmath202 outside . to each independent closed loop in the diagram , there is an integration over the corresponding momentum and a factor of @xmath244 , where @xmath245 is the dimension of the space . a diagram may contain vertices of valence @xmath157 if the potential , @xmath111 , contains a monomial of degree @xmath157 . to each such vertex there is a coupling constant factor coming from the coefficient of the monomial . there is also a phase factor given by the flux of @xmath205 through a polygon in momentum space formed by the momenta entering the vertex . as always , the momenta entering a vertex add up to @xmath202 . as with the exact feynman rules , there are combinatorial factors coming from the symmetries of the diagram , and from the numbers of alternative framings . as examples , i shall consider ( in progressively diminishing detail ) the evaluation of some one - particle - irreducible feynman diagrams for the @xmath0 model on quantized coadjoint orbits of small dimension . in this case , the potential is @xmath246 , so all vertices are of valence 4 and carry a factor of @xmath247 . on a coadjoint orbit , the cutoff laplacian can be expressed in terms of the appropriately normalized quadratic casimir operator as @xmath248 . this has the insurpassable property that @xmath249 . the propagator is thus @xmath250 the first diagram to consider is the planar , 1-loop propagator correction , fig . [ diag1 ] . planar , one - loop propagator correction . ] ordinarily , this diagram would have a symmetry factor of @xmath251 . however , only 2 out of 6 framings are equivalent to this diagram . therefore , there is an overall combinatorial factor of @xmath252 . this is about the only diagram that can easily be evaluated exactly . the doubled diagram is shown in fig . [ ddiag1 ] . .[ddiag1 ] ] notice that the bottom line is detached from the rest of the diagram ; this shows that the diagram factorizes as the tensor product of the identity on @xmath159 with some linear map from @xmath42 to @xmath42 . this must be @xmath79-invariant , and since @xmath42 is an irreducible @xmath79-representation , this map must be proportional to the identity . in other words , the diagram must evaluate to a number . to determine this number , close up the upper part of fig . [ ddiag1 ] and divide by @xmath253 ( a circle ) to normalize . the factor of @xmath151 cancels the factor from the feynman rules . closing up the diagram amounts to taking a trace . the exact evaluation is thus @xmath254 now turn to the deformation approximation . because the diagram is planar , the phase factor can only depend on external momenta , but because there is only one external momentum , there is no phase factor . indeed , the diagram is independent of the external momentum it is simply a number , as in the exact evaluation . in the deformation approximation , @xmath255 for the exact evaluation , it remains to calculate the trace of the propagator @xmath256 . this is an @xmath87-invariant linear operator on the algebra @xmath22 . as an @xmath87 representation , @xmath22 is the direct sum of the irreducible representations of integer spin @xmath202 through @xmath40 . the spin @xmath231 subspace has dimension @xmath257 , and on that subspace the quadratic casimir reduces to @xmath258 . using @xmath259 , the exact evaluation is @xmath260 however , this is precisely the @xmath261-part midpoint approximation to the integral _ 0^n+1 dt = [ approxs2a ] . now evaluate fig . [ diag1 ] in the deformation approximation . the momentum cutoff is a disc of radius @xmath235 . this gives @xmath262 \label{approxs2b}\mbox.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order for the deformation approximation to be valid , we must assume that @xmath263 . this means simply that the compton wavelength ( the distance , @xmath264 , determined by the bare mass ) should be much smaller than the universe and that @xmath132 should be much smaller than the cutoff mass . we need not assume that @xmath132 is smaller than the noncommutativity scale . using the formula for the leading correction to the midpoint approximation , we can find the leading order correction to ; this is @xmath265 so , in this case , the deformation approximation indeed converges if we take @xmath266 . as an @xmath267-representation , the algebra @xmath22 decomposes into a direct sum of irreducible subspaces numbered @xmath202 through @xmath40 . the @xmath231 subspace has dimension @xmath268 , and the quadratic casimir reduces to @xmath269 . for @xmath3 of circumference @xmath270 , the volume is @xmath271 . the exact evaluation of fig . [ diag1 ] is , @xmath272 as i have said , the momentum cutoff for @xmath3 is a ball of radius @xmath235 . so , in the deformation approximation , @xmath273 \label{planarcp } \mbox.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the resemblance to eq . is hopefully apparent . here , the exact evaluation is the double sum , @xmath274 the cutoff shape is the more complicated @xmath241 . this gives the deformation approximation as , @xmath275 \label{planarss } \mbox.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this demonstrates the effect of the cutoff shape . for @xmath276 , the results of eq.s and differ by a factor of @xmath277 . the only reason for this difference is the nontrivial cutoff shape for @xmath2 . the only nonplanar 1-loop propagator correction is shown in fig . [ diag2 ] . ] this is equivalent to all 4 out of 6 other framings of the original diagram ; so , the combinatorial factor is @xmath278 . the doubled diagram is shown in fig . [ ddiag2 ] . .[ddiag2 ] ] observe that fig . [ ddiag2 ] is really just the bare propagator ( fig . [ propagator ] on p. ) with the lines rearranged . the evaluation of fig . [ ddiag2 ] is @xmath279 times the propagator with the @xmath42 s exchanged . because this is a nonplanar diagram , there is a nontrivial phase factor . this makes the evaluation more interesting . with external momentum @xmath190 , it is ( again using the brace notation of eq . ) @xmath280 where @xmath281 is the fourier transform of the cutoff propagator and @xmath24 is the complex structure ( a @xmath282-rotation ) . equation is independent of any details of the propagator ; eq . used rotational invariance . it seems that rearranging lines in the doubled diagram corresponds to rotating by @xmath24 and taking a fourier transform . since the propagator is @xmath87-invariant , it can be written as a linear combination of projectors on irreducible representations . the rearranged version is also invariant and can also be so decomposed . calculating the rearrangement comes down to transforming between these two decompositions . the coefficients for this transformation are the famous 6-@xmath208 symbols ( see @xcite ) . since the value of this diagram is an invariant linear operator on @xmath22 , it can most conveniently be described by giving its eigenvalues on the irreducible subspaces of @xmath22 . the evaluation of fig . [ ddiag2 ] , acting on the spin @xmath231 subspace is @xmath283 this corresponds to evaluating with external momentum , @xmath190 , of magnitude @xmath284 . following eq . , the deformation approximation for fig . [ ddiag2 ] is , @xmath285 if we take @xmath177 while keeping @xmath162 fixed , then this becomes a hyperbolic bessel function , @xmath286 . this has a logarithmic singularity at @xmath287 , and falls off exponentially for large @xmath190 . aside from @xmath287 , it is finite . this means that this diagram , unlike the previous , planar diagram , is actually regularized by noncommutativity alone . the deformation approximation gives , @xmath288 if we take @xmath177 , this becomes @xmath289 . as in 2 dimensions , this falls off exponentially . the singularity is of the form @xmath290 , which is rather mild in 4 dimensions . there are several distinct framings of the one - loop vertex correction diagram . one of these is shown in fig . [ diag3 ] . ] the external momenta are all incoming ; the internal momentum @xmath191 is directed counterclockwise . by momentum conservation , @xmath291 . the phase associated to this diagram can be split into two factors . the first , @xmath292}$ ] is the same as for a bare vertex with the external edges oriented in this way . the second factor is @xmath293 . except for the combinatorial factors , the evaluation of fig . [ diag3 ] in the deformation approximation is e^2 s(q ) s(p_1+p_2-q ) e^i\{p_1,q } d^2nq .[diag3val]@xmath294 again denotes the cutoff propagator . note that this essentially amounts to a fourier transform of the product of propagators . in four dimensions , the 1-loop vertex correction is divergent , but if we take @xmath177 with @xmath162 fixed then remains finite except at @xmath295 let s consider how these amplitudes diverge when regularization is removed . actually , since there are both infra - red and ultra - violet cutoffs ( controlled by @xmath25 and @xmath235 ) , there are many possible ways to remove the cutoffs , one - by - one or simultaneously . as i have said , what has been described is far from a realistic physical model . despite this , we can optimistically juxtapose this model with reality and hope that some properties of the model are pertinent to reality . the kind of noncommutativity considered here has not yet been noticed in experiments . this means that the noncommutativity scale set by @xmath162 is , at best , about the smallest length scale explored by current experiments . on the other hand , @xmath25 should be something like the size of the universe a far larger scale , so @xmath40 must be _ very _ large . this shows that the cutoff mass , @xmath235 should be well beyond the scale of @xmath162 and thus far beyond the reach of experiments . the approximation relevant to physical predictions of noncommutativity is thus the limit of @xmath177 with @xmath162 fixed . note that this means simultaneously taking @xmath176 ; in other words , we remove the ultra - violet and infra - red cutoffs in unison . in this limit , the quantized compact space becomes , at least formally , quantized flat space . we should thus expect this limit of field theory to be described by field theory on quantized flat space . as i have claimed , and the above examples have corroborated , nonplanarity of a feynman diagram tends to decrease its degree of divergence . in the standard regularizations , the ultra - violet divergences are associated with the loops in the feynman diagram . it appears that the divergences when @xmath177 with @xmath162 fixed are associated more closely with the loops in the doubled diagram index loops , in the terminology of t hooft @xcite . the number of index loops is always less than or equal to the number of loops in the original diagram . although an arbitrary framed feynman diagram , @xmath203 , may not fit into the plane , it will always fit onto some oriented surface . such a surface , @xmath296 , can be constructed systematically by filling in a 2-cell for each line in the doubled diagram . it will have the topology of a riemann surface with at least one puncture ; each external leg of @xmath203 ends at a puncture . our first example , fig . [ diag1 ] , is planar ; thus @xmath296 is the plane ( equivalently , a sphere with 1 puncture ) . for both fig s [ diag2 ] and [ doubled ] , @xmath296 is a torus with 1 puncture . for fig . [ diag3 ] , @xmath296 is a sphere with 2 punctures . by construction , an index loop is always contractible in @xmath296 . we can make this more precise using homology . the group @xmath297 is trivial because @xmath296 is not closed ; the group @xmath298 is trivial because @xmath296 is obtained from @xmath203 by attaching 2-cells . inserting these facts into the long exact sequence for the pair @xmath299 , gives the short exact sequence , @xmath300 the group @xmath301 is generated by the 2-cells in @xmath296 that do not touch punctures ; these are in one - to - one correspondence with the index loops . the group @xmath302 classifies the loops of @xmath203 . the group @xmath303 classifies incontractible loops in @xmath296 . these are all free groups , so the sequence splits ( unnaturally ) . the loops of @xmath203 can therefore be divided into index loops and incontractible loops of @xmath296 . consider some loop @xmath304 in @xmath203 which is incontractible in @xmath296 , and examine what happens when we integrate over the momentum , @xmath190 , circulating around @xmath304 . if we leave the momenta in @xmath203 otherwise fixed and then add @xmath190 at each edge of @xmath304 . ] , then the part of the phase which depends on @xmath190 will be of the form @xmath305 , where @xmath191 is a linear combination of the other momenta in @xmath203 . in fact , @xmath191 is the momentum flowing across @xmath304 . the other part of the feynman integrand depending on @xmath190 is the product of propagators on the edges of @xmath304 ; each of these has the form @xmath306 ^ 2+m^2)^{-1}$ ] . taking the integral over @xmath190 effectively means taking the fourier transform of this product of propagators . the result may have an integrable singularity at @xmath307 ( an infra - red divergence because @xmath176 ) , but is otherwise finite , and falls of exponentially . this means that integration over @xmath190 does not contribute to the ultra - violet divergence ; moreover , if @xmath191 is also an internal momentum , then integration over @xmath191 will not contribute to the divergence either . the other important limit is the commutative limit . this is when @xmath25 is fixed , but @xmath308 and @xmath177 . in light of the deformation approximation , it appears that the behavior in this limit will be very much like that of the most elementary regularization , a simple momentum cutoff . for a single , complex scalar field , the general @xmath309-invariant action is s[]:=_,[complex.action]where @xmath310 is some real polynomial , lower bounded on the positive axis . the standard perturbation theory for this complex scalar field is not much different from that of the real field . every edge of a feynman diagram is now directed , and each vertex must have an equal number of ingoing and outgoing edges . the regularized action corresponding to this is a simple generalization of the real case . the only new ingredient is the fact that complex conjugation in @xmath20 corresponds to the hermitian adjoint in @xmath22 . the regularized version of is s_n ( ) : = .[complex.regact ] in every product inside the trace in eq . , @xmath17 alternates with @xmath311 . as a consequence , in the framed diagrams , ingoing and outgoing edges alternate around each vertex . except for this restriction , the feynman rules for the complex field are formally the same as for a real field . this restriction has an interesting interpretation in terms of the doubled diagram . there are really two types of lines in the doubled diagram , those on the left of a directed edge in the original diagram , and those on the right . the restriction is simply that left edges only connect to left edges and right to right . so far , i have only discussed topologically trivial scalar fields . a section of a nontrivial vector bundle is not a function , so sections of a vector bundle are not approximated by the algebra @xmath22 . as i have argued in @xcite , the noncommutative generalization of a vector bundle is a ( finitely generated , projective ) module of an algebra , so the geometric quantization of a vector bundle should be a module of @xmath22 . for the matrix algebra @xmath312 , any module is of the form , @xmath313 , a space of linear maps from some vector space to @xmath42 . i present a general construction in @xcite . in the simplest case a holomorphic vector bundle @xmath314 ; this generalizes @xmath315 . the simplest action for a nontrivial vector field is a trivial generalization of , although it requires a fiberwise , hermitian inner product on @xmath111 . the action is simply with @xmath316 and inner products understood between successive @xmath311 s and @xmath17 s . for the regularized fields , the inner product on @xmath111 leads to an inner product on @xmath317 ; because of this , for @xmath318 , we can define the product @xmath319 to be an element of @xmath22 . the regularized action for a nontrivial field is just with @xmath318 . in the doubled diagrams , the left and right lines are now truly distinct . left lines correspond to @xmath42 ; right lines correspond to @xmath317 . the complex scalar field really just wanted to be twisted . there is not much to be said about topologically nontrivial fields in the deformation approximation . from a local perspective , a nontrivial vector bundle is just a vector bundle with a fixed background gauge field . in the limit as @xmath176 , this gauge field vanishes . fermi statistics do not pose any particular obstacle in this regularization scheme . however , the kinetic terms for fermion action functionals may be more difficult to construct than that for bosons . whereas constructing a cutoff laplacian is elementary on coadjoint orbits , it is less obvious how to deal with the dirac operator . even on @xmath1 , there may be trouble . when the spinor bundle on @xmath1 is quantized by my prescription , the left and right chiral subspaces have different dimensions . this means that there does not exist a cutoff dirac operator which both anti - commutes with the chirality operator ( @xmath320 ) and has no kernel . in fact , the difference of the dimensions of the left an right subspaces grows linearly with @xmath40 ; so , if we require the dirac operator to anti - commute with the chirality operator , then the size of the kernel will diverge as @xmath103 . whether these problems can be circumvented , or whether they are really problems at all , remains to be seen . in all this i have largely dwelt on the regularization effects of noncommutativity . however , if there are effects of noncommutativity which are directly detectable by experiment , then these will probably be tree - level effects . in field theory on quantized flat space , the phase factors from different framings add up to a sum of cosines of products of momenta . this can , for instance , cause the amplitudes for processes with certain combinations of momenta , to vanish . this paper is essentially my thesis in physics at penn . state ; i would thus like to thank the members of my committee : lee smolin , abhay ashtekar , shyamoli chauduri , and paul baum . this material is based upon work supported in part by nsf grant phy95 - 14240 , by a gift from the jesse phillips foundation , and by the eberly research fund of the pennsylvania state university . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: since the discovery of the first known pulsating x - ray sources her x-1 and cen x-3 more than three decades ago ( giacconi et al . 1971 ; tananbaum et al . 1972 ) , over 50 new sources have been detected in the galaxy and the magellanic clouds , with luminosities in the range @xmath0 and pulsation periods @xmath1 . x - ray pulsars include a variety of objects powered by rotation or accretion , as well as several anomalous x - ray pulsars whose energy source is currently unclear . the emission from x - ray pulsars in binary systems is fueled by the accretion of material from the `` normal '' companion onto the neutron star , with the flow channeled onto one or both of the magnetic poles by the strong field . during the accretion process , gravitational potential energy is converted into kinetic energy , which escapes from the column in the form of x - rays as the gas decelerates through a radiative shock before settling onto the stellar surface . in the accretion - powered sources , which are the focus of this paper , the x - ray spectra are often well fitted using a combination of a power - law spectrum plus a blackbody component with a temperature in the range @xmath2k ( e.g. , coburn et al . 2002 ; di salvo et al . 1998 ; white et al . 1983 ) . most spectra also display quasi - exponential cutoffs at @xmath3kev , and there are indications of cyclotron features and iron emission lines in a number of sources . the observations suggest typical magnetic field strengths of @xmath4 g . although accretion - powered x - ray pulsars are among the most luminous sources in the galaxy , previous attempts to calculate their spectra based on static or dynamic theoretical models have generally yielded results that do not agree very well with the observed profiles ( e.g. , mszros & nagel 1985a , b ; nagel 1981 ; yahel 1980 ; klein et al . hence there is still no clear understanding of the basic spectral formation mechanism in x - ray pulsars ( see the discussion in coburn et al . 2002 ) . given the lack of a viable theoretical model , x - ray pulsar spectral data have traditionally been fit using multicomponent forms that include absorbed power - laws , cyclotron features , iron emission lines , blackbody components , and high - energy exponential cutoffs . the resulting parameters are sometimes difficult to relate to the physical properties of the source . motivated by the lack of a comprehensive theoretical model for x - ray pulsar spectral formation , we reconsider here the physical picture originally proposed by davidson ( 1973 ) , in which the accreting gas passes through a radiative , radiation - dominated shock before settling onto the surface of the star . we illustrate the accretion / emission geometry schematically in figure 1 . most of the photons emitted from the accretion column are produced in the dense `` thermal mound '' located inside the column , just above the stellar surface . the blackbody photons created in the mound are upscattered in the shock , and eventually diffuse through the walls of the column . the escaping photons carry away the kinetic energy of the gas , thereby allowing the plasma to settle onto the surface of the star . the strong compression that occurs as the plasma crosses the radiative shock renders it an ideal site for first - order fermi energization ( i.e. , `` bulk '' or `` dynamical '' comptonization ) of the photons produced by the thermal mound . in the bulk comptonization process , particles experience a mean energy gain if the scattering centers they collide with are involved in a converging flow ( e.g. , laurent & titarchuk 1999 ; turolla , zane , & titarchuk 2002 ) . by contrast , in the thermal comptonizaton process , particles gain energy due to the _ stochastic _ motions of the scattering centers via the second - order fermi mechanism ( e.g. , sunyaev & titarchuk 1980 ; becker 2003 ) . in the x - ray pulsar application , the scattering centers are infalling electrons , and the energized `` particles '' are photons . since the inflow speed of the electrons in an x - ray pulsar accretion column is much larger than their thermal velocity , bulk comptonization dominates over the stochastic process except at the highest photon energies ( titarchuk , mastichiadis , & kylafis 1996 ) , as discussed in 7 . the failure of the current models to generate the power - law spectral shape characteristic of x - ray pulsars probably stems from the neglect of the critical contribution of the shock in upscattering the soft radiation produced in the thermal mound ( e.g. , burnard , arons , & klein 1991 ) . we demonstrate in this paper that bulk comptonization of the radiation in the accretion shock can produce spectra very similar to the power - law continuum seen in many x - ray pulsars . the main results presented here were summarized by becker & wolff ( 2005 ) . dynamical comptonization has been considered by a number of previous authors in a variety of astrophysical situations , including spherical inflows ( payne & blandford 1981 ; colpi 1988 ; schneider & bogdan 1989 ; titarchuk , mastichiadis , & kylafis 1997 ) , accretion disks around black holes ( laurent & titarchuk 2001 ; titarchuk , cui , & wood 2002 ; titarchuk & shrader 2002 ) , spherical outflows ( becker & begelman 1986 ; titarchuk , kazanas , & becker 2003 ) , and the transport of cosmic rays in the solar wind ( parker 1965 ; stawicki , fichtner , & schlickeiser 2000 ) . the process was also studied in the context of neutron star accretion by titarchuk , mastichiadis , & kylafis ( 1996 ) and mastichiadis & kylafis ( 1992 ) , although their results are not applicable to x - ray pulsar accretion columns due to the assumption of spherical symmetry and the imposition of a power - law velocity profile . lyubarskii & sunyaev ( 1982 ) analyzed dynamical comptonization in the context of plane - parallel pulsar shocks , but the velocity profile they utilized is not consistent with the dynamics of x - ray pulsar accretion , and furthermore they did not account for the escape of radiation through the walls of the column . the relevance of the bulk comptonization process for spectral formation in x - ray pulsars was also recognized by burnard , arons , & klein ( 1991 ) , who pointed out that thermal spectra alone are much too soft to explain the observed emission , and suggested that upscattering in the shock could provide the required hardening . the fundamental character of the green s function describing both thermal and bulk comptonization was studied by titarchuk & zannias ( 1998 ) for the case of accretion onto a black hole . these authors established that the green s function can be approximated using a broken power - law form with a central peak between the high- and low - energy portions of the spectrum , for either type of comptonization . furthermore , they concluded that bulk comptonization dominates over the thermal process if the electron temperature @xmath5k . the theory developed in the present paper represents an extension of the same idea to neutron star accretion , resulting in the exact green s function for the x - ray pulsar spectral formation process . in agreement with titarchuk & zannias ( 1998 ) , we find that the bulk comptonization process is dominant for the temperature range relevant for x - ray pulsars . however , the presence of the event horizon in the black - hole application treated by these authors makes their problem fundamentally different from the neutron star accretion problem studied here , because the neutron star obviously possesses a solid surface . our work therefore represents the first exact , quantitative analysis of the role of bulk comptonization in the x - ray pulsar spectral formation process . radiation pressure governs the dynamical structure of the accretion flows in bright pulsars when the x - ray luminosity satisfies ( becker 1998 ; basko & sunyaev 1976 ) @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the polar cap radius , @xmath8 and @xmath9 denote the stellar mass and radius , respectively , @xmath10 is the thomson cross section , and @xmath11 and @xmath12 represent the electron scattering cross sections for photons propagating parallel or perpendicular to the magnetic field , respectively . when the luminosity of the system is comparable to @xmath13 , the radiation flux in the column is super - eddington and therefore the radiation pressure greatly exceeds the gas pressure ( becker 1998 ) . in this situation the gas passes through a radiation - dominated shock on its way to the stellar surface , and the kinetic energy of the gas is carried away by the high - energy radiation that escapes from the column . the strong gradient of the radiation pressure decelerates the material to rest at the surface of the star . the observation of many x - ray pulsars with @xmath14 implies the presence of radiation - dominated shocks close to the stellar surfaces in these systems ( white et al . 1983 ; white et al . note that radiation - dominated shocks are _ continuous _ velocity transitions , with an overall thickness of a few thomson scattering lengths , unlike traditional ( discontinuous ) gas - dominated shocks ( blandford & payne 1981b ) . in luminous x - ray pulsars , the pressure of the radiation determines the dynamics of the flow , while the dynamics in turn determines the shape of the radiation spectrum . hence the flow dynamics and the radiative transport are intimately connected , which makes this a complex and nonlinear `` photohydrodynamical '' problem . one implication is that the photons scattering through the column can not be regarded as `` test particles '' since it is their pressure that dictates the structure of the flow . we must therefore solve for the radiation spectrum and the velocity profile in a self - consistent manner . radiation pressure may also play an important role in the dynamics of moderate - luminosity pulsars due to the strong dependence of the electron scattering ( cyclotron ) cross section on the magnetic field strength ( langer & rappaport 1982 ) . becker ( 1998 ) and basko & sunyaev ( 1976 ) have considered the dynamics of radiation - dominated pulsar accretion flows , including the effect of the shock and the escape of radiation energy from the column . they find that the gas is decelerated to zero velocity in a manner consistent with accretion onto a solid body , but they do not consider the shape of the escaping radiation spectrum . conversely , the dynamics and the radiation spectrum have been worked out self - consistently by blandford & payne ( 1981b ) for the case of a `` standard '' ( rankine - hugoniot ) radiation - dominated shock , which does not include radiation escape . in the blandford & payne approach , the radiation spectrum everywhere in the flow is determined by solving the transport equation using the incident radiation field as a boundary condition . the solutions have a power - law character at high energies , with a spectral index that depends on the mach number of the upstream flow . since the rankine - hugoniot shocks studied by blandford & payne have a conserved energy flux , the downstream velocity is never less than one - seventh its upstream value . consequently the associated spectral solutions are not applicable to the x - ray pulsar case , since pulsar shocks must be _ radiative _ in nature so that the kinetic energy of the infalling material can be removed and the flow brought to rest at the stellar surface . the analytical approach employed here parallels the work of blandford & payne ( 1981b ) , except that the velocity profile they utilized is replaced with the appropriate solution for an x - ray pulsar accretion column , and the loss of radiation energy from the column is incorporated into the transport equation using an escape - probability formalism . in the spirit of the blandford & payne study of spectral formation in radiation dominated rankine - hugoniot shocks , we are interested here in exploring the direct effect of the radiative accretion shock on the spectrum emerging from an x - ray pulsar . hence it is not our goal in this paper to develop complete models that include additional processes such as free - free emission and absorption , cyclotron features , and iron emission lines . however , even without including any of these processes , we are able to demonstrate qualitative agreement with x - ray pulsar spectra . this suggests that energization in the accretion shock is one of the most important aspects of spectral formation in x - ray pulsars . -1.0truein the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in 2 we briefly review the conservation equations and discuss the resulting dynamical solution for the velocity profile of the accreting gas . the transport equation governing the scattering of the radiation inside the accretion column is analyzed in 3 , and various constraints are derived in order to ensure that the radiative transfer is modeled in a manner consistent with the flow dynamics . in 4 we obtain the exact analytical solution for the green s function and convolve it with the planck distribution emitted at the thermal mound to compute the radiation spectrum emerging from the accretion column . in 5 we present results obtained for the count - rate spectra using parameters corresponding to specific pulsars , and we compare the theoretical spectra with the observational data . the implications of our results for the production of x - ray spectra in pulsars are discussed in 7 . additional mathematical details are provided in a series of appendices . the model analyzed here is based on the dynamical picture suggested by davidson ( 1973 ) , which is illustrated schematically in figure 1 . the accretion scenario corresponds physically to the flow of a mixture of gas and radiation inside a magnetic `` pipe '' that is sealed with respect to the gas , but is transparent with respect to the radiation . the accretion column incorporates a radiation - dominated , radiative shock located above the stellar surface . although the shock is extended and the velocity profile is continuous , the flow possesses a well - defined sonic surface , as indicated in figure 1 . the model also includes a dense thermal mound located at the base of the flow , where local thermodynamic equilibrium prevails . due to its blackbody nature , the thermal mound acts as both a photon source ( emitting a planck spectrum ) and a photon sink ( absorbing all incident radiation ) . hence the surface of the mound represents the `` photosphere '' for photon creation and absorption , and the opacity is dominated by electron scattering above this point . in our approach to the problem , we assume that the upstream flow is composed of pure , fully ionized hydrogen gas moving at a highly supersonic speed , which is the standard scenario for accretion - powered x - ray pulsars ( basko & sunyaev 1975 , 1976 ) . our transport model employs a cylindrical , plane - parallel geometry , and therefore the velocity , density , and pressure are functions of the distance above the stellar surface , but they are all constant across the column at a given height . in this situation , the vertical variation of the flow velocity is given by the exact analytical solution obtained by becker ( 1998 ) and basko & sunyaev ( 1976 ) , which describes the settling of the transonic flow onto the surface of the star . a detailed consideration of the angular and energy dependences of the electron scattering cross section is beyond the scope of the present paper . we shall therefore follow wang & frank ( 1981 ) and becker ( 1998 ) by treating the directional dependence of the electron scattering in an approximate way in terms of the energy - averaged cross sections @xmath11 and @xmath12 , describing respectively the scattering of photons propagating either parallel or perpendicular to the magnetic field . the gas in the accretion column is radiation - dominated , and therefore it is the pressure of the photons that decelerates the infalling plasma to rest . we will use this fact in 6.1 to evaluate the self - consistency of the coupled radiative transport / dynamical model based on the analytical solution for the radiation pressure profile obtained below . the one - dimensional , time - dependent euler equations governing the flow of a radiation - dominated gas with mass density @xmath15 , flow velocity @xmath16 , and photon energy density @xmath17 inside a cylindrical accretion column are @xmath18 @xmath19 @xmath20 where the mass , momentum , and energy fluxes are given respectively by @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 with @xmath24 denoting the radiation pressure . the spatial coordinate @xmath25 increases along the column axis , in the direction of the flow , and @xmath26 denotes the associated electron - scattering optical depth , which is related to @xmath25 via @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the electron number density , @xmath29 is the proton mass , and @xmath11 is the electron scattering cross section parallel to the magnetic field ( i.e. , the column axis ) . the two coordinates @xmath25 and @xmath26 are calibrated so that they each vanish at the sonic point , as explained below . the quantities @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 appearing in equation ( [ eq2.3 ] ) represent the rates per unit volume at which radiation energy escapes through the column walls , or is absorbed or emitted by the gas , respectively . when the system is radiation - dominated as assumed here , the gas itself has little thermal energy to contribute to the radiation field , although it does possess a large reservoir of _ bulk _ kinetic energy which is transferred to the photons through the first - order fermi energization process in the shock . in this situation , the emission and absorption processes must nearly balance throughout the flow , and therefore we can write @xmath33 in which case equation ( [ eq2.3 ] ) reduces in a steady state to @xmath34 although emission and absorption do not effect the flow dynamics in this situation , these processes profoundly influence the _ shape _ of the radiation spectrum , as discussed in 3 and 4 within the context of our one - dimensional picture , the rate at which radiation energy diffuses through the walls of the column can be approximated using an escape - probability formalism . if the column cross section is optically thick to electron scattering , as expected , then the rate at which radiation energy escapes through the walls is given by @xmath35 where the mean escape time , @xmath36 , is given by @xmath37 with @xmath38 denoting the diffusion velocity perpendicular to the @xmath25-axis , and @xmath39 representing the perpendicular optical thickness of the cylindrical accretion column with radius @xmath40 . note that @xmath39 and @xmath36 are functions of @xmath25 through their dependence on @xmath41 . becker ( 1998 ) confirmed that the diffusion approximation employed in equation ( [ eq2.10 ] ) is valid because @xmath42 for typical x - ray pulsar parameters . equations ( [ eq2.4 ] ) and ( [ eq2.11 ] ) can be combined to express the mean escape time as @xmath43 since the escape timescale is inversely proportional to the flow velocity , the column becomes completely opaque at the surface of the neutron star due to the divergence of the electron number density there . the relationship between the escape - probability approximation and the physical distribution of radiation inside the accretion column is further discussed in 6.3 . in the steady - state situation of interest here , the mass flux @xmath44 and the momentum flux @xmath45 are both conserved , but the energy flux @xmath46 decreases as the gas accretes onto the surface of the neutron star due to the emission of radiation through the column walls . the momentum , energy , and mass conservation equations can be combined in this case to show that the flow velocity @xmath16 satisfies the second - order nonlinear differential equation ( becker 1998 ) @xmath47 where @xmath48 here , @xmath49 represents the flow velocity at the sonic point , where we set @xmath50 and @xmath51 , with the radiation mach number @xmath52 defined by @xmath53 the quantity @xmath54 denotes the speed of sound in the radiation - dominated gas . in the far upstream region , we assume that @xmath55 which is an excellent approximation in pulsar accretion flows ( basko & sunyaev 1975 , 1976 ) . becker ( 1998 ) showed that in order for the flow to come to rest at the stellar surface , the parameters @xmath40 , @xmath44 , @xmath12 , and @xmath11 must satisfy the relation @xmath56 the corresponding exact solution for the velocity @xmath16 as a function of @xmath57 in the steady - state situation of interest here is given by @xmath58\right\ } \ , \label{eq2.17}\ ] ] where @xmath59 note that @xmath60 at the sonic point ( @xmath61 ) as required . the velocity can also be written as an explicit function of the position @xmath25 using ( basko & sunyaev 1976 ) @xmath62 \ , \label{eq2.19}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the distance between the sonic point and the stellar surface , which can be evaluated using equation ( 4.16 ) from becker ( 1998 ) to obtain @xmath64 note that @xmath25 increases in the direction of the flow , which comes to rest at the surface of the star as expected . the height above the stellar surface @xmath65 is related to the coordinate @xmath25 via @xmath66 the incident ( upstream ) velocity of the infalling material is expected to be close to the free - fall velocity onto the stellar surface , @xmath67 , given by @xmath68 since @xmath69 in the upstream region according to equation ( [ eq2.19 ] ) , it follows that @xmath70 , and therefore the flow velocity at the sonic point is given by @xmath71 with the velocity solution given by equation ( [ eq2.19 ] ) , the corresponding pressure profile can be obtained by combining equations ( [ eq2.4 ] ) and ( [ eq2.5 ] ) , which yields @xmath72 the pressure increases to a maximum value at the surface of the star , where @xmath73 . based on equations ( [ eq2.4 ] ) and ( [ eq2.15 ] ) , we can reexpress the mach number as @xmath74 since the mach number approaches infinity in the far upstream region and @xmath69 , it follows that @xmath75 must vanish asymptotically and consequently the upstream momentum flux is dominated by the ram pressure of the freely falling matter . we therefore obtain @xmath76 by combining equations ( [ eq2.23 ] ) , ( [ eq2.24 ] ) and ( [ eq2.25 ] ) , we find that the pressure profile is related to the velocity variation by @xmath77 \ . \label{eq2.26}\ ] ] using equation ( [ eq2.19 ] ) to eliminate the velocity @xmath78 yields the closed - form result @xmath79 the pressure vanishes in the upstream limit ( @xmath80 ) as expected , and at the surface of the star ( @xmath81 ) , the pressure achieves the stagnation value @xmath82 if the gas is radiation - dominated and fully ionized , then the photons interact with the matter primarily via electron scattering , which controls both the spatial transport and the energization of the radiation . in this situation the opacity is dominated by electron scattering , and therefore absorption is negligible , except at the surface of the thermal mound located inside the cylindrical accretion column at @xmath83 . we are interested in obtaining the photon distribution , @xmath84 , measured at position @xmath25 and energy @xmath85 resulting from the reprocessing of blackbody radiation emitted from the mound . the normalization of @xmath86 is defined so that @xmath87 gives the number density of photons in the energy range between @xmath85 and @xmath88 , and therefore @xmath89 , where @xmath90 is the occupation number . the self - consistency of the solution obtained for the radiation distribution @xmath86 will be confirmed by verifying that the associated pressure distribution agrees with the dynamical result given by equation ( [ eq2.27 ] ) . in the cylindrical geometry employed here , the photon distribution @xmath86 satisfies the transport equation ( e.g. , blandford & payne 1981a ; becker 1992 ; parker 1965 ; becker & wolff 2005 ) @xmath91 where @xmath85 is the photon energy , @xmath25 is the spatial coordinate along the column axis , and @xmath92 is the flow velocity at the top of the thermal mound . the terms on the right - hand side of equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) represent advection , first - order fermi energization ( `` bulk comptonization '' ) in the converging flow , spatial diffusion parallel to the column axis , the blackbody source , escape of radiation from the column , and the absorption of radiation at the thermal mound , respectively . we are interested here in the steady - state version of equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) with @xmath93 . the photon number and energy densities associated with the distribution @xmath86 are given respectively by @xmath94 in the present application , we are primarily interested in exploring the effect of the dynamics itself ( i.e. , the radiative shock ) on the observed x - ray emission . the transport equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) therefore does not include additional processes such as thermal comptonization or cyclotron emission and absorption that are likely to be important in x - ray pulsars . in general , the neglect of thermal comptonization is reasonable because at the temperatures typical of x - ray pulsars ( @xmath95k ) , the kinetic energy associated with the bulk flow far surpasses the thermal energy . however , the failure to include the electron recoil associated with thermal comptonization renders the model unable to reproduce the quasi - exponential cutoffs often observed in x - ray pulsar spectra at high energies . furthermore , in some sources thermal comptonization appears to be necessary in order to flatten the spectrum in the energy range @xmath96kev . we provide further discussion of this issue in 7 . when integrated over the photon energy spectrum , the first - order fermi process considered here corresponds to the @xmath97 work done on the radiation by the compression of the background plasma as it accretes onto the stellar surface . the mean escape time , @xmath36 , is given by equation ( [ eq2.12 ] ) , and the source term @xmath98 is defined so that @xmath99 represents the number of photons injected into the accretion column per second in the energy range between @xmath85 and @xmath100 from the blackbody surface at @xmath83 . the absorption term in equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) containing the dimensionless constant @xmath101 must be included due to the blackbody nature of the thermal mound , which acts as both a source and a sink of radiation . in the radiation - dominated situation considered here , essentially all of the pressure is provided by the photons , and therefore the rate of absorption of radiation energy at the top of the mound must equal the energy emission rate when integrated with respect to the photon frequency ( see eq . [ [ eq2.8 ] ] ) . we will use this energy balance argument to compute a self - consistent value for @xmath101 below . next we need to specify the appropriate form for the source term @xmath98 in order to treat the injection of the blackbody radiation from the surface of the thermal mound . the flux per unit energy measured at the surface of an isotropically radiating object is equal to @xmath102 times the intensity ( rybicki & lightman 1979 ) . it therefore follows that the amount of energy emitted per second from the upper surface of the thermal mound ( with area @xmath103 ) in the energy range between @xmath85 and @xmath100 is given by @xmath104 where @xmath105 denotes the blackbody intensity and @xmath106 is the gas temperature at the surface of the mound . note that the units for @xmath107 are @xmath108 . hence we obtain for the source term @xmath109 and consequently the total energy injection rate is given by @xmath110 where @xmath111 is the stephan - boltzmann constant . in a radiation - dominated x - ray pulsar accretion column , the emission of fresh blackbody radiation energy at the surface of the thermal mound is almost perfectly balanced by the absorption of energy , as expressed by equation ( [ eq2.8 ] ) . most of the energy appearing in the emergent x - rays is therefore not supplied from the internal energy of the gas , but rather from its bulk kinetic energy , which is transferred directly to the photons via collisions with infalling electrons . we can gain some insight into the energy balance at the thermal mound by rewriting the steady - state version of the transport equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) in the flux - conservation form ( skilling 1975 ; gleeson & axford 1967 ) @xmath112 where @xmath113 represents the `` specific flux '' ( becker 1992 ) . by operating on equation ( [ eq3.7 ] ) with @xmath114 and utilizing equations ( [ eq3.2 ] ) and ( [ eq3.6 ] ) , we arrive at the photon energy equation @xmath115 where the integrated photon energy flux , @xmath116 , is given by @xmath117 equation ( [ eq3.9 ] ) states that the divergence of the radiation energy flux @xmath116 is equal to the net rate of change of the photon energy density @xmath17 due to the combined influence of compression , escape , absorption , and photon injection . note that @xmath116 is related to the _ total _ energy flux @xmath46 via ( see eq . [ [ eq2.6 ] ] ) @xmath118 since the absorption and emission of radiation energy must balance at the surface of the mound in the radiation - dominated situation of interest here , we can integrate equation ( [ eq3.9 ] ) with respect to @xmath25 across the mound location to obtain @xmath119 where @xmath120 denotes the radiation energy density at the mound surface . the fact that the photon energy flux @xmath116 is continuous at @xmath83 therefore requires that the dimensionless absorption constant @xmath101 in the transport equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) be given by @xmath121 by utilizing this expression for @xmath101 , we ensure that the results obtained for the radiation spectrum @xmath84 are consistent with the dynamical structure of the accretion column . this is confirmed after the fact by calculating the radiation pressure @xmath122 using equation ( [ eq3.2 ] ) and comparing the result with the dynamical solution given by equation ( [ eq2.27 ] ) . in our approach to solving equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) for the spectrum @xmath84 inside the accretion column , we shall first obtain the green s function , @xmath123 , which is the radiation distribution at location @xmath25 and energy @xmath85 resulting from the injection of @xmath124 photons per second with energy @xmath125 from a monochromatic source at location @xmath126 . the determination of the green s function is a useful intermediate step in the process because it provides us with fundamental physical insight into the spectral redistribution process , and it also allows us to calculate the particular solution for the spectrum @xmath86 associated with an arbitrary continuum source @xmath98 using the integral convolution ( becker 2003 ) @xmath127 note that the upper bound of integration is set equal to @xmath85 because in our model all of the injected photons gain energy via the first - order fermi process , and none lose energy . the technical procedure used to solve for the green s function involves the derivation of eigenfunctions and associated eigenvalues based on the set of spatial boundary conditions for the problem ( see , e.g. , blandford & payne 1981b ; payne & blandford 1981 ; schneider & kirk 1987 ; colpi 1988 ) . the steady - state transport equation governing the green s function is ( cf . [ [ eq3.1 ] ] ) @xmath128 and the associated radiation number and energy densities are given by ( cf . [ [ eq3.2 ] ] ) @xmath129 further simplification of the mathematical derivation is possible if we work in terms of the new spatial variable @xmath130 , defined by @xmath131 where @xmath63 is given by equation ( [ eq2.20 ] ) . note that @xmath132 in the far upstream region ( @xmath80 ) , and @xmath133 at the surface of the star ( @xmath134 ) . based on equations ( [ eq2.19 ] ) and ( [ eq4.4 ] ) , we find that the variation of the velocity @xmath16 as a function of the new variable @xmath130 is given by the simple expression @xmath135 likewise , we can also combine equations ( [ eq2.27 ] ) and ( [ eq4.4 ] ) to show that the exact dynamical solution for the radiation pressure profile as a function of @xmath130 is given by @xmath136 note that in the limit @xmath133 , the pressure approaches the stagnation value @xmath137 in agreement with equation ( [ eq2.28 ] ) . equations ( [ eq2.27 ] ) and ( [ eq4.6 ] ) will prove useful when we seek to confirm the validity of the results obtained for the photon distribution @xmath84 in 5 . utilizing equations ( [ eq2.4 ] ) , ( [ eq2.12 ] ) , ( [ eq2.16 ] ) , and ( [ eq4.5 ] ) along with the differential relation @xmath138 we find that equation ( [ eq4.2 ] ) can be transformed from @xmath25 to @xmath130 to obtain @xmath139 where we have made the definition @xmath140 so that @xmath141 denotes the value of @xmath130 at the top of the thermal mound ( see eq . [ [ eq4.4 ] ] ) . according to equation ( [ eq4.5 ] ) , the flow velocity at the top of the mound , @xmath142 , is related to @xmath141 via @xmath143 note that we can now write the green s function as either @xmath144 or @xmath145 since @xmath146 and @xmath147 are interchangeable via equations ( [ eq4.4 ] ) and ( [ eq4.9 ] ) . when @xmath148 , equation ( [ eq4.8 ] ) is separable in energy and space using the functions @xmath149 where @xmath150 is the separation constant , and the spatial function @xmath151 satisfies the differential equation @xmath152 in order to avoid an infinite spatial diffusion flux at @xmath153 , the function @xmath151 must be continuous there , and consequently we obtain the condition @xmath154 we can also derive a jump condition for the derivative @xmath155 at the top of the mound by integrating equation ( [ eq4.12 ] ) with respect to @xmath130 in a very small region around @xmath153 . the result obtained is @xmath156 where we have also used equation ( [ eq4.10 ] ) . the spatial eigenfunctions for our problem are denoted by @xmath157 where @xmath158 represents the @xmath159th eigenvalue . these functions satisfy the continuity and derivative jump conditions given by equations ( [ eq4.13 ] ) and ( [ eq4.14 ] ) , respectively , as well as the boundary conditions discussed below . the homogeneous version of equation ( [ eq4.12 ] ) for @xmath151 obtained when @xmath160 has fundamental solutions given by @xmath161 @xmath162 where @xmath163 denotes the hypergeometric function ( abramowitz & stegun 1970 ) , and the parameters @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 are defined by @xmath167 the `` seed '' photons injected into the flow from the thermal mound located near the base of the column are unable to diffuse very far up into the accreting gas due to the extremely high speed of the inflow . most of the photons therefore escape through the walls of the column within a few scattering lengths of the mound , forming a `` fan '' type beam pattern , as expected for accretion - powered x - ray pulsars ( e.g. , harding 1994 , 2003 ) . based on this physical picture , we conclude that the eigenfunction @xmath168 must _ vanish _ in the upstream limit , @xmath169 . conversely , in the downstream limit , @xmath133 , the gas settles onto the surface of the star and the radiation pressure achieves the stagnation value given by equation ( [ eq2.28 ] ) . since this is a finite pressure , we conclude that @xmath168 must approach a constant as @xmath133 . analysis of the asymptotic behaviors of the hypergeometric functions @xmath170 and @xmath171 shows that the first function vanishes and the second diverges as @xmath169 . hence in the region upstream from the thermal mound ( @xmath172 ) , the eigenfunction @xmath168 must be given by @xmath170 . however , in the downstream region ( @xmath173 ) , the situation is more complicated because the two functions @xmath170 and @xmath174 each diverge logarithmically as @xmath133 . we must therefore utilize a suitable linear combination of these functions in order to obtain a convergent solution in the downstream region . consequently we define the new function ( see appendix a for details ) @xmath175 which remains finite in the limit @xmath133 as required . by utilizing the various relations derived above , we find that the global solution for the spatial eigenfunction @xmath176 ( eq . [ [ eq4.15 ] ] ) can now be written as @xmath177 where the constant @xmath178 is determined using the continuity condition ( eq . [ [ eq4.13 ] ] ) , which yields @xmath179 we can combine equations ( [ eq4.14 ] ) , ( [ eq4.20 ] ) , and ( [ eq4.21 ] ) to show that the eigenvalue equation for @xmath150 is given by @xmath180 the left - hand side of this expression can be evaluated using the exact solution for the wronskian ( see appendix b ) , @xmath181 which is applicable for arbitrary values of @xmath150 and @xmath130 . equations ( [ eq4.22 ] ) and ( [ eq4.23 ] ) can be combined to obtain the alternative form for the eigenvalue equation , @xmath182 where @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 are functions of @xmath150 given by equations ( [ eq4.18 ] ) . the roots of this expression are the eigenvalues @xmath183 , and the associated eigenfunctions are evaluated using equation ( [ eq4.20 ] ) . the first eigenvalue , @xmath184 , is especially important because it determines the slope of the high - energy spectrum emerging from the accretion column according to equation ( [ eq4.11 ] ) . the spectral index of the emitted photon count rate distribution , @xmath185 , is related to @xmath184 via @xmath186 . in figure 2 we plot the photon index @xmath185 as a function of the dimensionless parameters @xmath101 and @xmath141 . note that @xmath185 is a double - valued function of @xmath141 for fixed @xmath101 , which is a consequence of the imposed velocity profile ( eq . [ [ eq4.5 ] ] ) . physically , this behavior reflects the fact that it is always possible to achieve a desired amount of compression ( first - order fermi energization ) by placing the source in a specific location in either the upstream or downstream region of the flow . we also observe that if we increase the absorption parameter @xmath101 while holding @xmath141 fixed , then @xmath185 increases monotonically , and therefore the high - energy spectrum becomes progressively steeper . this behavior is expected physically because as the absorption parameter is increased , the injected photons spend less time on average being energized by collisions with electrons before either escaping from the column or being absorbed at the source location . the reduction in the amount of energization naturally leads to a steepening of the radiation spectrum . when @xmath187 , no absorption occurs , and the index @xmath185 achieves it minimum ( limiting ) value of 2 . this limit is unphysical , however , since it yields a divergent result for the total photon energy density @xmath188 according to equation ( [ eq4.3 ] ) . we demonstrate in appendix c that the eigenfunctions @xmath176 form an orthogonal set , as expected since this is a standard sturm - liouville problem . once the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions are determined , the solution for the green s function can therefore be expressed as the infinite series @xmath189 where the expansion coefficients @xmath190 are computed by employing the orthogonality of the eigenfunctions along with the condition @xmath191 which is obtained by integrating the transport equation ( [ eq4.8 ] ) with respect to @xmath85 in a very small range surrounding the injection energy @xmath125 . the result obtained for the @xmath159th expansion coefficient is @xmath192 where the quadratic normalization integrals @xmath193 are defined by @xmath194 in appendix d , we show that the normalization integrals can be evaluated using the closed - form expression @xmath195 where @xmath196 \ , \label{eq4.30}\ ] ] and @xmath197 this provides an extremely efficient alternative to numerical integration for the computation of @xmath193 . the eigenfunction expansion converges fairly rapidly and therefore we are able to obtain an accuracy of at least five significant figures in our calculations of @xmath198 by terminating the series in equation ( [ eq4.25 ] ) after the first 20 terms . equation ( [ eq4.25 ] ) represents the exact solution for the green s function describing the radiation spectrum inside a pulsar accretion column resulting from the injection of @xmath124 seed photons per unit time from a monochromatic source located at @xmath153 ( or , equivalently , at @xmath83 ) . in the escape probability approach employed here , the associated green s function for the _ photon spectrum _ emitted through the walls of the cylindrical column is defined by @xmath199 so that @xmath200 represents the number of photons escaping from the column per unit time between positions @xmath25 and @xmath201 with energy between @xmath85 and @xmath100 . we remind the reader that the quantities @xmath146 and @xmath147 are interchangeable via equations ( [ eq4.4 ] ) and ( [ eq4.9 ] ) , and therefore we are free to work in terms of the more convenient parameters @xmath147 without loss of generality . by substituting for @xmath36 using equation ( [ eq2.12 ] ) we can obtain the alternative expression @xmath202 eliminating @xmath44 using equation ( [ eq2.16 ] ) and substituting for @xmath16 and @xmath198 using equations ( [ eq4.5 ] ) and ( [ eq4.25 ] ) , respectively , yields the equivalent result @xmath203 where the expansion coefficients @xmath204 are defined by @xmath205 the green s function @xmath206 describes the photon distribution escaping from the accretion column as a function of energy @xmath85 and location @xmath130 for the case of monoenergetic photon injection . analysis of @xmath206 therefore reveals some interesting details about the energization of the photons as they are transported through the column via diffusion and advection , and ultimately escape through the column walls . we plot @xmath206 as a function of the energy ratio @xmath207 and the location @xmath130 in figure 3 for the parameter values @xmath208 and @xmath209 . in this case the first eigenvalue is given by @xmath210 , and the corresponding photon index is @xmath211 ( see fig . 2 ) . the selected value of @xmath141 corresponds to a source located near the bottom of the accretion column , just above the stellar surface . at the source location , @xmath212 , the energy spectrum extends down to the injection energy , @xmath125 . however , at all other radii the spectrum displays a steep turnover above that energy because all of the photons at these locations have experienced fermi energization due to collisions with the infalling electrons . the photons with energy @xmath213 at the source location have been injected so recently that they have not yet experienced significant energization . note that for small values of @xmath130 , the escaping spectrum is greatly attenuated due to the inability of the photons to diffuse upstream through the rapidly infalling plasma . the escaping spectrum is also attenuated in the far downstream region ( @xmath214 ) due to the very high opacity of the flow , which inhibits the diffusion of photons through the walls . this latter effect stems from the divergence of the electron density near the stellar surface . the energy of maximum brightness , corresponding to the peak in @xmath206 , achieves its maximum value as @xmath169 because the photons that manage to diffuse far upstream from the source are the ones that have resided in the flow the longest and therefore experienced the most energy amplification . we plot @xmath206 as a function of energy and location in figure 4 for the parameters @xmath215 and @xmath216 , in which case we obtain for the first eigenvalue and the photon index @xmath217 and @xmath218 , respectively . in this scenario the source is located in the upstream region and the absorption is stronger than that in figure 3 . due to the increased absorption resulting from the larger value of @xmath101 , the photons spend less time on average in the flow being energized by collisions with the electrons before they escape through the column walls or are `` recycled '' by absorption . this causes a steepening of the spectrum at high energies , as evidenced by the increase in the photon index @xmath185 . in this situation the energy of maximum brightness ( where @xmath206 displays a peak ) achieves its greatest value in the downstream region . this is the reverse of the behavior displayed in figure 3 because in the present example , the source is located in the upstream region and therefore the photons that diffuse further upstream towards @xmath219 do not experience as much compression as those that are advected downstream . the escaping photon distribution in the far upstream and downstream regions is strongly attenuated due to the same processes operative in figure 3 , and therefore most of the escaping radiation is emitted from the accretion column around the source location . the analytical results for the green s function obtained in this section provide the basis for the consideration of any source distribution since the fundamental differential equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) is linear . this is further discussed in 5 , where we use equations ( [ eq3.5 ] ) and ( [ eq4.1 ] ) to convolve the green s function with the blackbody spectrum produced by the thermal mound . by integrating over the vertical structure of the accretion column , we can compute the total emitted radiation distribution , which corresponds to the phase - averaged spectrum of the x - ray pulsar . in the cylindrical geometry employed here , the formal integration domain is the region @xmath220 , where @xmath63 is the distance between the sonic point and the stellar surface ( see eq . [ [ eq2.20 ] ] ) . for the case of a monochromatic source , we define the _ column - integrated green s function _ by writing @xmath221 where @xmath222 represents the number of photons escaping from the column per unit time with energy between @xmath85 and @xmath100 . using equation ( [ eq4.7 ] ) , the variable of integration can be transformed from @xmath25 to @xmath130 to obtain the alternative form @xmath223 where @xmath141 is related to @xmath126 via equation ( [ eq4.9 ] ) . despite the appearance of the factor @xmath224 inside the integral in equation ( [ eq4.37 ] ) , the contribution from small values of @xmath130 is actually negligible because the spectrum declines exponentially in the upstream region due to advection . furthermore , the escaping spectrum is also strongly attenuated in the downstream region due to the divergence of the electron density . hence most of the radiation is emitted from the column around @xmath225 , as indicated in figures 3 and 4 . by combining equations ( [ eq4.34 ] ) , ( [ eq4.35 ] ) , and ( [ eq4.37 ] ) , we can reexpress the column - integrated green s function as @xmath226 where the quadratic normalization integrals @xmath193 are evaluated using equation ( [ eq4.29 ] ) and we have made the definition @xmath227 in appendix e , we demonstrate that the integral in the expression for @xmath228 can be carried out analytically to obtain @xmath229 + { \varphi_1^*(\lambda_n , y_0 ) \over ( a-1 ) \ , ( b-1 ) \ , \gamma(1-c ) } \bigg [ f(a , b\,;c-1;y_0 ) \nonumber \\ & + & { ( c-2 ) \over ( a-2 ) \ , ( b-2 ) } \ , f(a , b;c-2;y_0)\bigg ] \bigg\ } + { ( 1-c ) \over ( a-1 ) \ , ( b-1 ) } \left[1 + { ( c-2 ) \over ( a-2 ) \ , ( b-2)}\right ] \ , \qquad \label{eq4.40}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath230 , @xmath231 , and @xmath232 are given by equations ( [ eq4.16 ] ) , ( [ eq4.17 ] ) , and ( [ eq4.19 ] ) , respectively , and the constants @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 are computed in terms of @xmath158 using equations ( [ eq4.18 ] ) . in figure 5 we plot the dependence of the column - integrated green s function @xmath233 on the radiation energy @xmath85 using the same parameters employed in figures 3 and 4 . note that when @xmath234 and @xmath209 , which corresponds to the thin line in figure 5 , the column - integrated spectrum displays a peak at @xmath235 . the peak forms because the source is located close to the bottom of the accretion column , whereas most of the photons escape from higher altitudes around @xmath225 ( see fig . the escaping radiation has therefore experienced significant compression in the flow and consequently the photon energies are generally boosted well above the injection energy @xmath125 . on the other hand , when @xmath215 and @xmath216 , which corresponds to the thick line in figure 5 , the absorption is so strong that the spectrum is quite steep and therefore the peak is suppressed . consequently the column - integrated spectrum achieves it maximum value at the injection energy in this case . the closed - form solutions for the green s function @xmath206 ( eq . [ [ eq4.34 ] ] ) and for the column - integrated green s function @xmath233 ( eq . [ [ eq4.38 ] ] ) provide a very efficient means for computing the x - ray spectrum escaping through the walls of the accretion column due to the injection of monochromatic seed photons . however , in our physical application to x - ray pulsars , we are primarily interested in computing the emitted spectrum resulting from the reprocessing of _ blackbody radiation _ injected into the accretion column from the thermal mound . in the escape probability approach utilized here , the photon distribution emitted through the walls of the cylindrical column at position @xmath25 , denoted by @xmath236 , is computed using @xmath237 where the particular solution @xmath84 is evaluated using equation ( [ eq4.1 ] ) , and @xmath238 represents the number of photons escaping from the column per unit time between positions @xmath25 and @xmath201 with energy between @xmath85 and @xmath100 . by combining equations ( [ eq4.1 ] ) and ( [ eq4.41 ] ) , we find that the escaping photon spectrum can be expressed as @xmath239 where the blackbody source function @xmath240 is evaluated using equation ( [ eq3.5 ] ) . the spatial variables @xmath146 and @xmath147 are interchangeable by virtue of equations ( [ eq4.4 ] ) and ( [ eq4.9 ] ) , and therefore we can use equations ( [ eq4.32 ] ) and ( [ eq4.42 ] ) to write @xmath241 where @xmath242 is computed using equation ( [ eq4.34 ] ) . by analogy with equation ( [ eq4.36 ] ) for the green s function , we define the particular solution for the _ column - integrated _ photon spectrum escaping from the plasma due to the blackbody source , @xmath243 , by writing @xmath244 so that @xmath245 gives the number of photons escaping from the column per unit time with energy between @xmath85 and @xmath246 . the variable of integration can be transformed from @xmath25 to @xmath130 using equation ( [ eq4.7 ] ) , which yields @xmath247 where @xmath141 is related to @xmath126 by equation ( [ eq4.9 ] ) . by substituting for @xmath248 using equation ( [ eq4.43 ] ) and employing equation ( [ eq4.37 ] ) , we can obtain the alternative form @xmath249 the column - integrated green s function @xmath250 is evaluated using equation ( [ eq4.38 ] ) . in 5 we will utilize equations ( [ eq4.43 ] ) and ( [ eq4.46 ] ) to compute the photon spectrum emitted from the accretion column using parameters corresponding to specific x - ray pulsars . for given values of the stellar mass @xmath251 and the stellar radius @xmath252 , our model has three free parameters , namely the column radius @xmath40 , the temperature at the top of the thermal mound @xmath253 , and the accretion rate @xmath254 . in this section we investigate the relationship between these quantities and the dimensionless parameters @xmath141 and @xmath101 appearing in the theory . although it is not our intention in this paper to develop complete models for x - ray pulsar spectra , it is nonetheless interesting to compare the simplified model developed here with actual data for a few sources . hence in this section we will also compute the spectrum emerging from the accretion column for parameters corresponding to two specific x - ray pulsars . in order to understand how the theory developed here can be related to observables such as the temperature and the luminosity , we first need to determine how the position of the thermal mound , @xmath126 ( or , equivalently , @xmath141 ) , depends on the values of @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath255 . the blackbody surface of the mound represents the photosphere for photon creation and destruction in this problem , and therefore the opacity is dominated by free - free absorption inside the mound . for a given value of the temperature @xmath253 , the density at the top of the mound , @xmath256 , can be calculated by setting the free - free optical thickness of the column equal to unity , so that @xmath257 where the rosseland mean of the free - free absorption coefficient is evaluated in cgs units using ( rybicki & lightman 1979 ) @xmath258 for pure , fully - ionized hydrogen with the gaunt factor set equal to unity . the density at the top of the thermal mound is therefore given by @xmath259 the velocity at the top of the mound , @xmath142 , is related to @xmath256 via the continuity equation @xmath260 , so that @xmath261 by combining this result with equations ( [ eq2.23 ] ) and ( [ eq4.10 ] ) , we find that the value of @xmath141 is given by @xmath262 or , equivalently , @xmath263 the values obtained for @xmath141 are extremely close to unity , indicating that the top of the thermal mound is just above the stellar surface . once @xmath141 is computed , we can determine @xmath126 by using equation ( [ eq4.9 ] ) to write @xmath264 where @xmath63 is the distance between the sonic point and the stellar surface given by equation ( [ eq2.20 ] ) . the height of the thermal mound above the stellar surface is then given by ( see eq . [ [ eq2.21 ] ] ) @xmath265 or , equivalently , @xmath266 where we have substituted for @xmath63 using equation ( [ eq2.20 ] ) . specific numerical examples are given in 5.4 . for typical x - ray pulsar parameters , we find that the mound is situated very close to the surface of the star , as expected . in order to compute the eigenvalues @xmath158 using equation ( [ eq4.24 ] ) , we must also evaluate the dimensionless absorption parameter @xmath101 appearing in the transport equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) . based on energy conservation considerations in the radiation - dominated plasma , we have shown in 3.2 that the photon energy flux @xmath116 must be continuous across the location of the thermal mound . this leads to equation ( [ eq3.13 ] ) , which can be rewritten as @xmath267 where @xmath268 is the radiation pressure at the top of the thermal mound . according to equation ( [ eq4.6 ] ) , @xmath269 , and therefore @xmath270 by substituting for @xmath49 and @xmath142 using equations ( [ eq2.23 ] ) and ( [ eq4.10 ] ) , respectively , and setting @xmath271 , we can obtain the alternative form @xmath272 or , equivalently , @xmath273 taken together , equations ( [ eq5.6 ] ) and ( [ eq5.13 ] ) allow the determination of the two dimensionless model parameters @xmath141 and @xmath101 in terms of @xmath252 , @xmath251 , @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 . this closes the system and facilitates the calculation of the emergent photon number spectrum @xmath248 using equation ( [ eq4.43 ] ) , and the calculation of the column - integrated spectrum @xmath274 using equation ( [ eq4.46 ] ) . the values of the parameters @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 can therefore be extracted by comparing the theoretically predicted photon count - rate distributions with x - ray pulsar spectral data . the eigenvalues @xmath158 are functions of the dimensionless parameters @xmath141 and @xmath101 . based on the dependences of these parameters on @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 expressed by equations ( [ eq5.6 ] ) and ( [ eq5.13 ] ) , we note that the eigenspectrum _ remains unchanged _ if @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 are simultaneously varied according to the prescription @xmath275 in this case , the column - integrated green s function ( eq . [ [ eq4.38 ] ] ) also remains unchanged since it depends only on the values of @xmath101 and @xmath141 . these findings suggest that it is useful to introduce the new `` similarity variables '' @xmath276 and @xmath277 , defined by @xmath278 in terms of these parameters , equations ( [ eq5.6 ] ) and ( [ eq5.13 ] ) for @xmath141 and @xmath101 now become @xmath279 and @xmath280 the introduction of the new variables @xmath276 and @xmath277 is convenient because it reduces the dimensionality of the parameter space that determines the eigenvalues @xmath158 from the three - dimensional domain @xmath281 to the two - dimensional space @xmath282 . in figure 6 we plot the spectral index @xmath186 of the photon count - rate spectrum as a function of @xmath276 and @xmath277 , where @xmath184 is the first eigenvalue and we have set @xmath283 km and @xmath284 ( the same quantity was plotted as a function of @xmath141 and @xmath101 in figure 2 ) . note that when @xmath277 is increased for a fixed value of @xmath276 , the values of @xmath141 and @xmath101 both increase according to equations ( [ eq5.16 ] ) and ( [ eq5.17 ] ) . the source therefore moves further downstream , and the absorption at the source location becomes stronger . this causes the spectrum to steepen as we move upwards along a vertical line in figure 6 . however , if @xmath277 becomes very large , the spectrum starts to harden again due to the increasing amount of compression experienced as the source approaches the base of the accretion column . our primary goal in this paper is to explore the effect of bulk comptonization on the shape of the x - ray continuum spectrum emerging from a pulsar accretion column . the development of complete models that include additional effects such as thermal comptonization , cyclotron processes , free - free emission and absorption , and iron line formation will be pursued in future work . here we compare spectra computed using our simplified model with the observations for a few sources in order to focus attention on the role of the accretion shock in the formation of the x - ray continuum . in figures 7 and 8 we plot the position - dependent photon count rate spectra @xmath248 ( eq . [ [ eq4.43 ] ] ) escaping from the accretion column computed using the two sets of model parameters listed in table 1 . these results were obtained using 20 eigenvalues and eigenfunctions , which yields extremely high precision due to the rapid convergence of the expansion . the theoretical spectra describe the upscattering of planckian seed photons injected into the base of the accretion column from the surface of the thermal mound . in both cases we use @xmath285 and @xmath283 km for the stellar mass and radius , respectively . for model 1 ( fig . 7 ) , the parameters adopted are @xmath286 km , @xmath287 , and @xmath288 . in model 2 ( fig . 8) we set @xmath289 km , @xmath290k , and @xmath291 . we use equations ( [ eq5.15 ] ) , ( [ eq5.16 ] ) , and ( [ eq5.17 ] ) to compute the theoretical parameters @xmath276 , @xmath277 , @xmath141 and @xmath101 based on the selected values for @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 . in model 1 we obtain @xmath292 and @xmath293 , and in model 2 we find that @xmath294 and @xmath295 . additional parameters are provided in table 1 . the fact that the thermal mound location @xmath141 is extremely close to unity in both cases indicates that the mound lies just above the surface of the star , as expected . it is interesting to compute the actual physical distance between the thermal mound and the stellar surface , @xmath296 , which is given by equation ( [ eq5.9 ] ) . using the parameters corresponding to models 1 and 2 yields @xmath297 cm and @xmath298 cm , respectively . note that in model 2 the thermal mound is essentially on the surface of the star , whereas in model 1 there is a much larger separation . this reflects the fact that the accretion rate in model 1 is over 800 times larger than in model 2 . the results obtained for the first eigenvalue and for the photon index in model 1 are @xmath299 and @xmath300 , respectively . in model 2 , we find that the spectrum is significantly steeper , with @xmath301 and @xmath302 . the steeper spectrum obtained in model 2 results from the large value obtained for @xmath101 , as indicated in table 1 . in general , the escaping spectrum has a power - law shape at high energies , as expected for a fermi process , and a low - energy turnover due to the planck distribution of the seed photons . note that the emitted radiation is concentrated in a layer just above the thermal mound location , around @xmath225 . this reflects the fact that advection due to collisions with the infalling stream of high - speed electrons tends to keep the photons trapped at low altitudes in the column , and therefore few of them are able to escape through the column walls for @xmath303 . since the spin axis and the column axis are not aligned in pulsars , the portion of the accretion column visible along the line of sight to the earth changes as the pulsar rotates . when combined with the vertical variation of the energy dependence of the escaping photon distribution , this effect will produce a pulse - phase dependence in the observed x - ray spectrum . in figures 9 and 10 we plot the photon count rate flux measured at earth , @xmath304 computed using models 1 and 2 , respectively , where @xmath305 is the distance to the source and the column - integrated spectrum @xmath306 is evaluated using equation ( [ eq4.46 ] ) . also included in figures 9 and 10 for comparison are plots of the unfolded phase - averaged spectra for the x - ray pulsars 4u 1258 - 61 ( gx 304 - 1 ) and 4u 0352 + 30 ( x persei ) , respectively . the 4u 1258 - 61 data was reported by white et al . ( 1983 ) , and the 4u 0352 + 30 data is the result of xspec analysis of an archival rxte observation taken in july 1998 and reported by delgado - mart et al . ( 2001 ) . based on estimates from negueruela ( 1998 ) , the values adopted for the distance @xmath305 are 2.5kpc for 4u 1258 - 61 and 0.35kpc for 4u 0352 + 30 . the observational data represent the de - convolved ( incident ) spectra , which depend weakly on the detector response model . the theoretical spectra were computed using 20 eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for high accuracy , and various amounts of interstellar absorption were included as indicated in the figures . although the results presented here are not fits to the data , we note that the general shape of the pulsar spectrum predicted by the theory agrees fairly well with the observations in each case , including both the turnover at low energies and the power law at higher energies . several other sources yield similar agreement . in our model , the turnover at @xmath307kev is due to planckian photons that escape from the accretion column without experiencing many scatterings . this effect will tend to reduce the amount of absorption required to fit the observational data , compared with the amount required using the standard ad hoc models usually employed in x - ray pulsar spectral analysis ( see the discussion in hickox , narayan , & kallman 2004 ) . the second source , x persei , presents an interesting test for the model due to its relatively low luminosity , @xmath308 . the agreement between the theory and the observations suggests that radiation pressure may still be playing an important role in the dynamics of this source , despite its low luminosity . in fact , langer & rappaport ( 1982 ) pointed out that radiation pressure may have a strong effect on the flow dynamics of low - luminosity pulsars if the photon energies are close to the cyclotron resonance , which greatly increases the electron scattering cross section . furthermore , the dynamical importance of the gas pressure in this luminosity range may lead to the development of a gas - mediated `` subshock '' within the overall gradual compression of the radiation - dominated shock . this type of hybrid shock is analogous to the `` two - fluid '' model of cosmic - ray mediated supernova shocks ( e.g. , drury & vlk 1981 ) . it is know that in the cosmic - ray case , multiple flow solutions can occur for the same set of upstream boundary conditions ( e.g. , becker & kazanas 2001 ) . there is some possibility that the same type of multi - state behavior may occur in x - ray pulsars , which could have interesting observational implications . the analytical approach employed in this paper is based on the conservation of energy and momentum in the radiation - dominated flow . this leads to the self - consistent determination of the thermal mound location , @xmath126 , for given values of the fundamental parameters @xmath40 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 , as discussed in 5.1 . in this section we verify that the model satisfies the self - consistency conditions required for global energy conservation . we also examine the implications of the one - dimensional escape probability formalism that has been utilized to model the emission of radiation from the column . the exact dynamical solution for the radiation pressure inside the pulsar accretion column is given by equation ( [ eq2.27 ] ) , which states that @xmath309 where @xmath63 is the distance between the sonic point and the stellar surface , given by equation ( [ eq2.20 ] ) . in principle , the radiation pressure can also be computed by integrating the particular solution for the photon distribution @xmath86 inside the accretion column . since @xmath24 , we can use equation ( [ eq3.2 ] ) to write @xmath310 where @xmath86 is computed using the convolution ( see eq . [ [ eq4.1 ] ] ) @xmath311 here , the blackbody source @xmath240 is given by equation ( [ eq3.5 ] ) and the green s function @xmath198 is evaluated using equation ( [ eq4.25 ] ) , bearing in mind that the quantities @xmath146 and @xmath147 are interchangeable via equations ( [ eq4.4 ] ) and ( [ eq4.9 ] ) . we can check the accuracy of the entire solution technique , including the determination of the eigenfunctions and the eigenvalues , by comparing the exact dynamical result for @xmath75 with that obtained by integrating the spectrum . in figure 11 we plot the exact analytical solution for the radiation pressure computed using equation ( [ eq5.19 ] ) along with the results obtained by integrating the model 1 and 2 spectra using equation ( [ eq5.20 ] ) . note that the agreement between the various solutions for @xmath75 is excellent , and in each case the pressure achieves the correct stagnation value @xmath312 ( eq . [ [ eq2.28 ] ] ) as the gas approaches the stellar surface . the agreement between the various results for the pressure confirms that our solution for the radiation spectrum is consistent with the dynamics of the accretion flow . in order to further explore the self - consistency of the formalism developed here , we have also computed the total x - ray luminosity , @xmath313 , emerging from the column by integrating the escaping number spectrum @xmath274 ( eq . [ [ eq4.44 ] ] ) using @xmath314 we have confirmed that the values obtained using this expression agree precisely with the accretion luminosity given by @xmath315 the calculations performed in this section and in 6.1 validate our entire solution procedure for the determination of the radiation spectrum by demonstrating that our results are fully consistent with global energy conservation . within the context of our one - dimensional model , the diffusion of radiation through the walls of the accretion column is treated in an approximate manner using an escape - probability formalism . in this approach , the probability per unit time that a randomly - selected photon at location @xmath25 inside the column will escape through the walls is equal to @xmath316 , where the mean escape time @xmath36 is a function of @xmath25 given by ( see eqs . [ [ eq2.11 ] ] ) @xmath317 with @xmath40 and @xmath12 denoting the radius of the cylindrical column and the electron scattering cross section for photons propagating perpendicular to the column axis , respectively . the escape of radiation through the walls of the accretion column can therefore be modeled approximately using a term of the form @xmath318 which is incorporated into the transport equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) . from a technical point of view , the utilization of the escape - probability formalism implies that the distribution of the photon number density across the column is proportional to the first eigenfunction of the operator describing the diffusion of radiation perpendicular to the column axis ( e.g. , sunyaev & titarchuk 1980 ) . in a comprehensive , multidimensional calculation , the diffusion of photons perpendicular to the column axis is treated by replacing the escape - probability term @xmath319 in the transport equation ( [ eq3.1 ] ) with the more rigorous expression @xmath320 where @xmath321 is the radial coordinate measured from the central axis of the cylindrical accretion column . if the gas density is constant across the column at a given height , as assumed here , then equation ( [ eq5.26 ] ) can be separated to obtain for the first eigenfunction the solution @xmath322 where @xmath323 is a constant , @xmath324 denotes the first eigenvalue , @xmath325 represents the zeroth - order bessel function , and @xmath326 is the electron scattering mean free path for photons propagating perpendicular to the column axis . the value of @xmath324 is determined by satisfying the flux boundary condition at the surface of the column . by employing the eddington approximation , we can write the boundary condition as @xmath327 where @xmath328 is a positive constant of order unity and we have assumed that no radiation is incident on the column from the outside . the precise value of @xmath328 is somewhat arbitrary , with rybicki & lightman ( 1979 ) setting @xmath329 and sunyaev & titarchuk ( 1980 ) setting @xmath330 . combining equations ( [ eq5.27 ] ) and ( [ eq5.29 ] ) , we find that @xmath324 is the smallest positive root of the equation @xmath331 where @xmath332 denotes the order - unity bessel function . the rate of change of the first eigenfunction ( eq . [ [ eq5.27 ] ] ) is given by @xmath333 comparison of equations ( [ eq5.25 ] ) and ( [ eq5.31 ] ) reveals that the escape - probability approximation and the rigorous diffusion model yield the same result for the logarithmic time derivative @xmath334 if the mean escape time @xmath36 and the first eigenvalue @xmath324 are related via @xmath335 this equation is well satisfied in all of our sample calculations , which suggests that the escape - probability formalism provides a reasonable description of the leakage of photons from the accretion column . we have shown that the simplified model considered here , comprising a radiation - dominated accretion column with a blackbody source / sink at its base and a radiative shock , is able to reproduce the power - law continuum spectra observed in accretion - powered x - ray pulsars with a range of luminosities , as indicated in figures 9 and 10 . our results represent the first ab initio calculations of the x - ray spectrum associated with the physical accretion scenario first suggested by davidson ( 1973 ) . for given values of the stellar mass @xmath251 and the stellar radius @xmath252 , our model has only three free parameters , namely the column radius @xmath40 , the temperature at the top of the thermal mound @xmath253 , and the accretion rate @xmath254 . we have confirmed that the solution obtained for the radiation spectrum is consistent with the dynamics of the flow in the accretion column ( see fig . many pulsars are found to have spectra that are well fitted using a combination of a power - law plus a blackbody component , but until now this form has been adopted in a purely ad hoc manner . the new model described here finally provides a firm theoretical foundation for this empirical result . our analytical solution , based on a rigorous eigenfunction expansion , is relatively straightforward to implement computationally because it avoids numerical integration of the transport equation . the work presented here therefore represents a significant step in the development of a comprehensive theory for the spectral formation process in x - ray pulsars . the photon spectral index @xmath185 is related to the first eigenvalue @xmath184 via @xmath336 , and therefore the leading eigenvalue determines the slope of the high - energy portion of the x - ray spectrum . the value of @xmath185 is quite sensitive to the strength of the absorption at the thermal mound , which is determined by the parameter @xmath101 . according to equation ( [ eq5.13 ] ) , @xmath101 in turn is a strong function of the mound temperature @xmath253 . the higher the temperature , the stronger the emission and absorption at the blackbody surface of the mound . model 2 has a higher temperature than model 1 , and therefore the value of @xmath101 is larger . hence the spectrum is steeper in model 2 because the photons spend less time on average upscattering in the flow before either escaping through the column walls or being `` recycled '' by absorption at the mound location . acceptable values for @xmath185 , in the range between 2 and 4 , are obtained for reasonable source parameters , as indicated in figures 2 and 6 . although a broad range of spectral indices can be produced , we must have @xmath337 in order to avoid an infinite photon energy density since the model considered here does not include a high - energy cutoff . the shape of the green s function spectrum derived here is qualitatively similar to the results obtained using the `` bulk motion comptonization '' model coded into the xspec package using the bmc function ( see shrader & titarchuk 1998 , 1999 ; borozdin et al . 1999 ) . the bmc model includes parameters corresponding to the high - energy spectral index , the temperature of the soft photon source , the fraction of the comptonized component in the resulting spectrum , and the size of the emitting region . however , the bmc model is designed to treat spectral formation in black - hole accretion flows , whereas our focus here is on neutron star accretion . hence the model developed in this paper can be viewed as a parallel formalism that is optimized for the treatment of the spectral formation process in accretion - powered x - ray pulsars . in this sense , our theory translates the free parameters of a generalized bulk comptonization model into specific values for the accretion rate , temperature , and column radius for a particular x - ray pulsar . our goal in this paper is to explore the direct role of the accretion shock in producing the observed continuum spectra in x - ray pulsars via the first - order fermi process . although the model produces spectra that are quite similar to those observed from several x - ray pulsars , it can not explain the spectra from other sources . for example , the observed spectra for several of the brightest pulsars with luminosities in the range @xmath338 ( e.g. , her x-1 ) are very flat power - laws leading up to a sharp exponential cutoff . the photon index in these sources is typically @xmath339 , which is outside the range allowed by our model since it does not include a high - energy cutoff . in order to understand spectral formation in the brightest pulsars , additional effects such as thermal comptonization , cyclotron features , bremsstrahlung , and iron emission must be incorporated into the model . in principle , one should also consider higher - order relativistic effects that can alter the form of the fundamental transport equation ( psaltis & lamb 1997 ) . thermal comptonization is particularly important since this process redistributes energy from the highest frequency photons to lower energies via electron recoil . this naturally leads to the development of a high - energy exponential turnover and a concomitant flattening of the spectrum at moderate energies , as observed . the thermal comptonization process was studied by lyubarskii & sunyaev ( 1982 ) and becker ( 1988 ) in the context of plane - parallel shocks . however , the velocity profiles employed by these authors are not consistent with the structure of an x - ray pulsar accretion column . poutanen & gierliski ( 2003 ) computed x - ray pulsar spectra based on the thermal comptonization of soft radiation in a hot layer above the magnetic pole , but their model did not include a complete treatment of the bulk process , which is of crucial importance in x - ray pulsars . in this paper we have carefully analyzed the effect of bulk comptonization on the emitted spectrum , while neglecting the corresponding thermal process . the inclusion of thermal comptonization is beyond the scope of the present paper because it renders the transport equation insoluble via analytical means . however , in future work we intend to develop a comprehensive numerical model that incorporates both the bulk and thermal processes . the authors would like to thank drs . lev titarchuk , philippe laurent , and nikos kylafis who provided useful comments on the manuscript . the authors are also grateful to the anonymous referee whose careful reading and stimulating suggestions led to significant improvements in the paper . pab would also like to acknowledge generous support provided by the office of naval research . in the following sections we provide further details regarding the various mathematical methods that form the foundation of our model . when @xmath160 , the spatial separation functions @xmath340 satisfy the homogeneous differential equation ( cf . eq . [ [ eq4.12 ] ] ) @xmath341 which has the fundamental solutions @xmath342 @xmath343 where @xmath163 denotes the hypergeometric function ( abramowitz & stegun 1970 ) , and we have made the definitions @xmath344 as explained in the discussion following equation ( [ eq4.18 ] ) , in the downstream limit the radiation pressure approaches the finite stagnation value given by equation ( [ eq2.28 ] ) . the spatial separation functions @xmath340 should mimic this behavior , and therefore we require that @xmath151 approaches a constant in the limit @xmath133 . this does not happen in general , but only if the separation constant @xmath150 is equal to one of the eigenvalues @xmath158 , in which case we obtain the eigenfunction @xmath345 the hypergeometric functions appearing in equations ( [ eqa.2 ] ) and ( [ eqa.3 ] ) can be evaluated at @xmath346 using equation ( 15.1.20 ) from abramowitz & stegun ( 1970 ) , which gives for general values of @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 @xmath347 however , for the values of @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 in the current application , we find that @xmath348 and therefore the hypergeometric functions @xmath349 and @xmath350 each _ diverge _ in the downstream limit @xmath133 . based on the asymptotic behaviors of the hypergeometric functions appearing in the expressions for @xmath170 and @xmath174 , we conclude that in the downstream region ( @xmath173 ) , the eigenfunction @xmath168 must be represented by a suitable linear combination of @xmath170 and @xmath174 that remains finite as @xmath133 . in order to make further progress , we need to employ equation ( 15.3.10 ) from abramowitz & stegun ( 1970 ) , which yields for general @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath130 @xmath351 ( 1-y)^n \ , \label{eqa.8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath352 by making use of this expression , we note that the logarithmic divergences of the two functions @xmath170 and @xmath174 in the limit @xmath133 can be balanced by creating the new function @xmath353 which remains finite as @xmath133 . hence @xmath354 represents the fundamental solution for @xmath168 in the region downstream from the thermal mound located at @xmath355 . we can use the asymptotic behaviors of @xmath170 and @xmath174 as @xmath133 to conclude that @xmath356 \over \gamma(a ) \ , \gamma(1-b ) } \ . \label{eqa.11}\ ] ] since the solutions @xmath170 and @xmath354 are applicable in the upstream and downstream regions , respectively , the global expression for the eigenfunction @xmath168 is therefore @xmath357 where the constant @xmath178 is evaluated using the continuity condition @xmath358 it follows from equations ( [ eqa.11 ] ) , ( [ eqa.12 ] ) , and ( [ eqa.13 ] ) that the downstream value of @xmath168 is given by @xmath359 \over \gamma(a ) \ , \gamma(1-b ) } \ , { \varphi_1(\lambda_n , y_0 ) \over \varphi_2(\lambda_n , y_0 ) } \ , \label{eqa.14}\ ] ] where @xmath164 and @xmath165 are evaluated using equations ( [ eq4.18 ] ) . the derivation of the eigenvalue equation ( [ eq4.24 ] ) in 4.2 makes use of the wronskian of the two functions @xmath170 and @xmath354 , defined by @xmath360 it is useful to derive an analytical expression for @xmath361 based on the differential equation ( [ eq4.12 ] ) governing the two functions @xmath170 and @xmath354 , which can be rewritten in the self - adjoint form @xmath362 + { \lambda \over 4 \ , y^{3/4 } } \ , \varphi - t \ , \varphi = 0 \ , \label{eqb.2}\ ] ] where @xmath363 by applying equation ( [ eqb.2 ] ) to the function @xmath354 and multiplying the result by @xmath170 , and then subtracting from this the same expression with @xmath170 and @xmath354 interchanged , we obtain @xmath364 - \varphi_2 \ , { d \over dy}\left[y^{1/4 } \ , ( 1-y ) \ , { d\varphi_1 \over dy}\right ] = 0 \ , \label{eqb.4}\ ] ] which can be rewritten as @xmath365 = 0 \ , \label{eqb.5}\ ] ] where we have made use of the result @xmath366 equation ( [ eqb.5 ] ) can rearranged in the form @xmath367 \ , \label{eqb.7}\ ] ] which can be integrated to obtain the exact solution @xmath368 where @xmath369 is an integration constant that may depend on @xmath150 but not on @xmath130 . the exact dependence of @xmath305 on @xmath150 can be derived by analyzing the behaviors of the functions @xmath170 and @xmath354 in the limit @xmath169 . for small values of @xmath130 , we have the asymptotic expressions ( abramowitz & stegun 1970 ) @xmath370 we therefore find that asymptotically , @xmath371 comparing this result with equation ( [ eqb.8 ] ) , we conclude that @xmath372 and therefore the exact solution for the wronskian is given by @xmath373 this result is used in 4.2 in the derivation of the eigenvalue equation ( [ eq4.24 ] ) . the evaluation of the green s function @xmath198 using equation ( [ eqc.1 ] ) relies on knowledge of the expansion coefficients @xmath190 , which are given by @xmath384 where the quadratic normalization integrals @xmath193 are defined by @xmath385 the direct computation of the normalization integrals @xmath193 via numerical integration is costly and time consuming , and therefore it is desirable to have an alternative procedure available for their evaluation . in fact , it is possible to derive an analytical expression for the normalization integrals based on manipulation of the fundamental differential equation ( [ eq4.12 ] ) governing the eigenfunctions @xmath176 . let us suppose that @xmath340 is a general solution to equation ( [ eq4.12 ] ) for an arbitrary value of @xmath150 ( i.e. , not necessarily an eigenvalue ) that has the asymptotic upstream behavior @xmath386 we shall also require that @xmath151 be continuous at @xmath153 , and that it satisfy the derivative jump condition ( see eq . [ [ eq4.14 ] ] ) @xmath387 after a bit of algebra , we find that the global solution for @xmath151 can be expressed as @xmath388 where @xmath389 and @xmath390 are given by @xmath391 and the wronskian @xmath361 is evaluated using equation ( [ eqb.12 ] ) . in 4.5 we demonstrated that the column - integrated green s function @xmath411 can be written as ( see eq . [ [ eq4.38 ] ] ) @xmath412 where the quadratic normalization integrals @xmath193 are computed using equation ( [ eq4.29 ] ) , and @xmath413 as an alternative to numerical integration for the evaluation of the integral @xmath228 , here we shall derive an analytical expression for this quantity . first we use equation ( [ eq4.20 ] ) to substitute for @xmath176 in equation ( [ eqe.2 ] ) to obtain @xmath414 substitution for @xmath354 using equation ( [ eq4.19 ] ) and rearranging terms , we can write @xmath415 where @xmath416 to make further progress , we need to evaluate the fundamental indefinite integrals @xmath417 fortunately , these integrals can be carried out analytically . by applying equation ( 15.2.1 ) from abramowitz & stegun ( 1970 ) twice , we obtain for @xmath418 the result @xmath419 where @xmath420 is an integration constant . likewise , we can apply equation ( 15.2.4 ) from abramowitz & stegun ( 1970 ) twice to find that @xmath421 where @xmath422 is another integration constant . combining relations and simplifying , after some algebra we obtain the final result @xmath229 + { \varphi_1^*(\lambda_n , y_0 ) \over ( a-1 ) \ , ( b-1 ) \ , \gamma(1-c ) } \bigg [ f(a , b\,;c-1;y_0 ) \nonumber \\ & + & { ( c-2 ) \over ( a-2 ) \ , ( b-2 ) } \ , f(a , b;c-2;y_0)\bigg ] \bigg\ } + { ( 1-c ) \over ( a-1 ) \ , ( b-1 ) } \left[1 + { ( c-2 ) \over ( a-2 ) \ , ( b-2)}\right ] \ . \qquad \label{eqe.9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this formula allows the efficient computation of the integrals @xmath228 appearing in equation ( [ eq4.38 ] ) for the column - integrated green s function . cccccccccccccc 1 & 6.0 & @xmath423 & @xmath424 & 0.890 & 1.087 & 0.999770 & @xmath425 & 2.0398 & @xmath426 & @xmath427 + 2 & 1.3 & @xmath428 & @xmath429 & 0.286 & 0.954 & 0.999998 & @xmath430 & 2.6382 & @xmath431 & @xmath432 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: for almost a century now after its discovery , the schwarzschild solution describing a static , spherically symmetric vacuum spacetime in einstein s theory of general relativity ( gr ) has been a valuable tool for a wealth of theoretical and experimental studies , including in particular weak - field tests of the theory . for more than half a century , the validity of the solution beyond the schwarzschild radius @xmath0 and the consequent existence of bhs was thought to be a mathematical artifact of the field equations . this picture has changed dramatically in more recent decades . crucial events in this sense were the mathematical discovery of the kerr solution describing rotating bhs @xcite , and the astrophysical x - ray and radio observations in the 1960s and 1970s . cosmic x - ray sources , first detected in 1963 @xcite , were soon associated with compact stellar objects and , in particular , with mass exchange from an ordinary star onto a compact object in binary systems @xcite . this interpretation received further support when the x - ray source cyg x-1 was identified with the supergiant boib star hd 226868 @xcite , which established cyg x-1 as the first observed x - ray binary . over the next few years , the explanation of these systems in terms of accretion onto compact stellar objects in binary systems became widely accepted ( see @xcite for a review ) . measurements of the binary period and radial velocity provide lower limits on the mass of the compact companion . the values obtained for some x - ray binaries comfortably exceed the upper mass limit of about @xmath1 for neutron stars . recent investigations of cyg x-1 , for example , predict @xmath2 for the compact member @xcite . also starting in the early 1960s , optical and radio observations identified `` star like '' objects with surprisingly large redshifts @xcite . if interpreted as cosmological in origin , the redshifts implied enormous distances and , accordingly , luminosities . over the next decade the cosmological origin of these `` quasi - stellar '' sources ( or quasars ) became clear , and accretion onto supermassive bhs ( smbhs ) @xcite was accepted as the most plausible explanation of their energetics @xcite . by now , observations of stellar dynamics near the centers of galaxies and iron k@xmath3 emission line profiles provide strong evidence that many galaxies harbor bhs at their centers @xcite . bh masses are generally closely correlated to the bulge velocity dispersion and luminosity @xcite . for the milky way , astrometric and radial velocity observations of short - period stars orbiting the galactic center @xcite predict an unseen gravitational mass of @xmath4 . electromagnetic observations provide strong but _ indirect _ evidence for the existence of astrophysical bhs . a more direct way of probing the bh nature of astrophysical compact objects is offered by the newly emerging field of gw astronomy . first - generation ground - based laser - interferometric detectors ( such as ligo , virgo and geo600 ) have reached design sensitivity , and advanced versions of these detectors will be operational within a few years @xcite . one of the most prominent sources of detectable gws for these detectors is the inspiral and coalescence of stellar mass and , possibly , intermediate - mass bh ( imbh ) binaries . at lower frequencies , space - based laser interferometric observations @xcite have the potential to complement ground - based efforts with high signal - to - noise ratio observations of massive bh binaries . space - based detectors are guaranteed to observe galactic binaries containing white dwarfs and/or neutron stars , and they may also detect the inspiral of stellar compact objects into massive bhs . due to the weak interaction of gws with any type of matter , including the detectors , digging physical signals from the noisy data stream represents a daunting task and heavily relies on so - called _ matched filtering _ techniques @xcite . matched filtering is a common choice to search for signals of known form in noisy data , and works by cross - correlating the actual `` signal '' ( i.e. , the detector s output ) with a set of theoretical templates . accurate modeling of the gw sources thus plays a vital role in maximizing the scientific output from these experimental efforts . event rate estimates for imbhs and stellar - mass bh binaries are very uncertain , but advanced earth - based detectors are expected to observe several events per year ( see @xcite for a review ) . _ noted that recent metallicity measurements require revisions in the population synthesis models used for event rate estimates , suggesting that stellar - mass bh - bh binaries may be the first gw sources to be detected @xcite . the observations of two possible x - ray binary precursors of bh - bh binaries provide a much needed observational constraint on compact binaries containing at least one bh , suggesting again that bh - bh binary mergers may be more common than anticipated @xcite . population synthesis models have large uncertainties , related e.g. to the poorly known common envelope phase , and some models would necessarily be ruled out if advanced ligo does _ not _ detect bh binaries . in this sense , gw detectors are _ guaranteed _ to put constraints on compact binary formation in the near future . schutz @xcite also pointed out that coherent data analysis using three or more detectors may further increase event rates by factors of a few , making prospects of doing astrophysics with earth - based detectors even brighter . estimates for event rates of smbh binaries detectable by space - based interferometers range from @xmath5 to @xmath6s per year , with a most likely estimate of @xmath7 @xcite . over the past decade , bh modeling has also attracted a great deal of interest in the context of high - energy physics . according to the gauge / gravity duality , gravitational physics in anti - de sitter ( ads ) backgrounds describes field theories on the boundary of that spacetime @xcite . according to this duality , bhs in ads are dual to an equilibrium field theory , and therefore interacting bhs or bhs off - equilibrium may represent interesting physics from the dual point of view . in fact , there is some evidence that some of the physics behind quark - gluon plasma formation in heavy - ion collisions is captured by this duality , which on the gravitational side corresponds to shock wave collisions and bh formation in ads @xcite . understanding bh spacetimes is also of interest for high - energy physics in connection with extra - dimensional scenarios . solutions to the hierarchy problem in physics have been developed where all standard - model interactions are confined to a 3 + 1 dimensional brane embedded in a spacetime with large extra dimensions or an extra dimension with a warp factor @xcite . in these models gravity propagates in the entire higher - dimensional spacetime ( the `` bulk '' ) , and the fundamental planck scale could be as low as @xmath8 . these energy scales are accessible to experiments such as the large hadron collider ( lhc ) . if the fundamental planck scale is so low , thorne s hoop conjecture suggests the exciting possibility of bh production in high - energy parton - parton collisions @xcite , i.e. a direct observable signature of the existence of extra - dimensions . accurate modeling of energy and momentum losses in the form of gws during the collisions and determination of the bh formation cross section will be crucial for the analysis of data from such experiments ( see e.g. @xcite ) , and they should be amenable to classical calculations in @xmath9-dimensional gr @xcite . finally , the understanding of bh dynamics under extreme conditions is fascinating from a mathematical - physics point of view . questions such as bh stability , cosmic censorship , etcetera can only be addressed by solving the full nonlinear set of the field equations . for many of these scenarios , it is convenient to divide the coalescence of a bh binary in the framework of gr into three stages which mirror the different tools used for their modeling : ( i ) the inspiral phase , where the interaction between the individual holes is still sufficiently weak to justify the use of post - newtonian ( pn ) techniques @xcite ; ( ii ) the final orbits , plunge and merger , which are governed by the strong - field regime of einstein s equations and can be described only by fully numerical simulations ; ( iii ) the ringdown of the remnant bh , which is amenable to a perturbative treatment @xcite . in this article we will focus on the second , strong - field stage , on the numerical tools dedicated to its study , and results obtained following the 2005 breakthroughs @xcite . as we shall see , however , a comprehensive understanding of bh dynamics requires a close interplay of numerical and analytical studies , and we will discuss in various cases the interface between numerical relativity and approximation techniques . following a brief summary of the framework employed in numerical relativity ( sec . [ sec : numerics ] ) , in secs . [ sec : gws]-[sec : highenergy ] we will present the main results obtained from numerical studies of bhs in the context of gw detection , astrophysics and high - energy physics , respectively . we conclude in sec . [ sec : conclusions ] with a discussion of future applications of numerical relativity . at the end of each section we will provide references to the literature for further reading . * _ notation : _ * we shall be using geometrical units , such that the gravitational constant @xmath10 and the speed of light @xmath11 . we denote spacetime indices @xmath12 by greek letters , and spatial indices @xmath13 by latin letters . in einstein s gr , spacetime is modelled as a @xmath9-dimensional manifold with a metric @xmath14 of lorentzian signature @xmath15 . with the exception of sec . [ sec : highenergy ] we will restrict our discussion to @xmath16 , i.e. three spatial and one time dimension . the metric is determined by the einstein equations @xmath17 with @xmath18 in vacuum . while analytic solutions ( as , for example , the schwarzschild and kerr solutions and the friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker solution ) have been found for systems with high symmetry , solutions for dynamical configurations without special symmetries generally require the use of numerical tools . for this purpose the einstein equations need to be cast as an _ initial value formulation _ such that the cauchy - kowalewski theorem guarantees a uniquely determined evolution of appropriately chosen initial data . in the case of einstein s equations , it is not obvious that such a formulation can be obtained : a straightforward calculation shows that eq . ( [ eq : einstein ] ) contains second time derivatives of the metric components @xmath19 , but not of @xmath20 . this fact mirrors the coordinate or gauge freedom characteristic of gr , and implies the existence of so - called _ constraint _ equations which impose conditions on the metric components and their first derivatives on each spatial slice with constant coordinate time @xmath21 . in the following we will discuss two approaches which provide an initial value formulation of the einstein equations and have led to successful , long - term stable numerical evolutions : the generalized harmonic ( gh ) formulation employed in pretorius breakthrough bh binary simulations @xcite and the canonical arnowitt - deser - misner ( adm ) split @xcite , reformulated by york @xcite , which forms the starting point for the _ moving puncture _ breakthroughs @xcite . * _ adm 3 + 1 split : _ * spacetime is decomposed into a one - parameter family of three - dimensional spatial slices . we choose coordinates adapted to this formulation , such that the coordinate time @xmath21 labels each slice and @xmath22 denotes points on the slice . on each hypersurface , there exists a unique timelike , future pointing unit normal field @xmath23 which defines a projection operator @xmath24 onto the hypersurface . the geometry of the hypersurface is completely determined by the _ three - metric _ or _ first fundamental form _ the coordinate freedom is represented by the shift vector @xmath26 and the lapse function @xmath27 ( with @xmath28 ) , which relate spatial coordinates on ( and measure separation in proper time between ) different hypersurfaces . the projections @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 of the einstein equations then lead to six evolution equations for the three - metric @xmath32 , three momentum constraints and the hamiltonian constraint : @xmath33 where @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 denote the ricci tensor , ricci scalar and covariant derivative associated with the three - metric , and the extrinsic curvature @xmath37 has been introduced to obtain a first - order system in time . it turns out that this formulation of the einstein equations is only _ weakly hyperbolic _ @xcite , and therefore not suitable for long - term stable numerical evolutions . motivated by these stability problems , several modifications of the adm system have been investigated . the most popular is the baumgarte - shapiro - shibata - nakamura ( bssn ) formulation @xcite , which rearranges the degrees of freedom via a split of the extrinsic curvature into trace and trace - free parts , a conformal transformation and promotion of the contracted conformal christoffel symbols to the status of independent variables : @xmath38 the resulting set of evolution and constraint equations is given in eqs . ( 15)-(30 ) of @xcite . subject to minor modifications , such as replacing the conformal factor by @xmath39 or adding the auxiliary constraint arising from the definition of @xmath40 in eq . ( [ eq : bssn ] ) , this formulation is employed in the present generation of moving puncture evolution codes @xcite which fix the gauge via `` 1+log '' slicing and the @xmath41-driver condition @xcite . * _ gh formulation : _ * harmonic coordinates are defined by the condition @xmath42 , where @xmath43 represents the scalar wave operator . these coordinates have played an important role in the analysis of the cauchy problem in gr @xcite . in harmonic coordinates , the einstein equations take on a manifestly hyperbolic form , which allows for a generalization to arbitrary coordinate or gauge choices @xcite . the first step is to introduce four arbitrary source functions @xmath44 such that the coordinates obey @xmath45 and treat these functions as independent evolution variables . then one considers the gh system @xmath46 where @xmath47 . ( [ eq : gh ] ) is equivalent to the einstein equations , subject to the validity of the constraint ( [ eq : h ] ) . in expanded form , the gh system is given by @xmath48 and the constraints @xmath49 are preserved by virtue of the bianchi identities provided that @xmath50 and @xmath51 vanish on the initial hypersurface @xmath52 . a key ingredient in the numerical evolution of the gh system is the addition of a constraint damping term @xmath53 c_{\mu}$ ] to the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq : ghexpanded ] ) @xcite . here , @xmath54 is a non - vanishing timelike vector field . finally , it is interesting to note that the hamiltonian and momentum constraints are automatically satisfied on the initial hypersurface if @xmath55 @xcite . the coordinates were determined in pretorius initial simulations by @xmath56 and the evolution of the metric proceeds according to eq . ( [ eq : ghexpanded ] ) with the constraint damping term of gundlach _ et al . _ @xcite . for further discussion of gauge choices in the ghg system , see also @xcite . the spectral code originally developed by the caltech - cornell group ( see @xcite and references therein ) employs a first - order version of the gh system @xcite with dual - coordinate frames and bh excision . furthermore , the first - order gh formulation facilitates the specification of constraint - preserving boundary conditions @xcite . during the inspiral phase , they evolve the gauge functions @xmath57 such that they remain constant in a frame comoving with the bhs , but switch to a dynamic evolution during the plunge and ringdown ; see sec . iii in @xcite . while more complex in structure , this framework enables their code to generate bh evolutions with exceptional accuracy @xcite . * _ initial data : _ * the construction of initial data requires solving the hamiltonian and momentum constraints . here we only summarize the key concepts ; we refer the reader to cook s review article @xcite for details . most work on the construction of initial data is based on the york - lichnerowicz split @xcite , which involves a conformal transformation of metric and extrinsic curvature and separates the latter into trace and trace - free part . more recently , the _ thin - sandwich _ construction @xcite , which replaces the extrinsic curvature by the time derivative of the metric , has become a popular alternative . in either case , the resulting elliptic equations simplify substantially under the assumption of conformal flatness and a spatially constant @xmath58 . while this formalism provides a convenient method to solve the constraint equations , we still need to ensure that the initial data represent a physically realistic system , typically two bhs with specific spins and momenta . this can be achieved by generalizing the schwarzschild solution , which is obtained in the above framework in conformally flat form with conformal factor @xmath59 . a generalization to initial data of @xmath60 bhs starting from rest is directly obtained by the construction of misner @xcite or brill and lindquist @xcite . remarkably , an analytic solution for the extrinsic curvature can still be obtained for bhs with initial linear momenta @xmath61 and spins @xmath62 @xcite . by applying a compactification to the internal asymptotically flat region , brandt & brgmann @xcite arrived at the so - called _ puncture data _ construction , which is the method of choice for most numerical evolutions employing the bssn formulation . in order to overcome an upper limit of @xmath63 for the dimensionless spin of bhs in puncture type initial data @xcite , lovelace _ et al . _ @xcite generated initial data based on a generalization of the kerr - schild solution @xcite and were thus able to evolve a bh binary with spin magnitude 0.95 . in alternative to generalizing analytically known bh solutions , the presence of horizons in the initial data can be encoded in the form of boundary conditions for the metric and extrinsic curvature @xcite as determined by the isolated horizon framework @xcite . initial data along these lines have been constructed in @xcite , and form the starting point of most of the numerical evolutions using the gh system ( see e.g. @xcite ) . * _ diagnostics : _ * extracting physical information from numerical simulations of the einstein equations is nontrivial for two reasons . first , the evolved variables are dependent on the coordinate conditions ; second , it is often not possible to define local quantities familiar from newtonian physics . the first difficulty requires the calculation of gauge - independent variables . the second difficulty is alleviated by the _ isolated horizon _ framework @xcite , which facilitates the calculation of bh mass and spin in the limit of isolated bhs ; in practice , this framework is often applied when the bhs are farther apart and their interaction is considered negligible . local properties of the bhs are encoded in their apparent horizon @xcite . in particular , the irreducible mass can be expressed in terms of the apparent horizon area : @xmath64 . in the limit of an isolated bh , the spin can be derived from the integration of the rotational killing vectors over the horizon according to eq . ( 8) of @xcite . in practice it has been found that using _ flat - space _ rotational killing vectors yields reasonable results @xcite , but we also note the improved method to compute approximations to killing vectors in @xcite and an alternative method @xcite based on weyl scalars to compute quasi - local bh quantities without solving the killing equation . it is important to bear in mind , however , the approximate nature of any spin calculation in bh binary simulations . in comparison , it is more straightforward to extract global quantities of the spacetime , most notably the total mass - energy @xmath65 and the linear and angular momentum @xmath66 , @xmath67 @xcite . these are given by surface integrals at spatial infinity , see e.g. eqs . ( 7.15 ) , ( 7.56 ) and ( 7.63 ) in @xcite . arguably the most important diagnostic quantity in bh simulations is the gw signal . the most common method to extract gws is based on the newman - penrose formalism @xcite and derives the complex newman - penrose scalar @xmath68 from contraction of the weyl tensor with suitably chosen tetrad vectors @xcite , sec . iii a in @xcite . it is often convenient to decompose @xmath68 into multipoles @xmath69 using spherical harmonics of spin - weight @xmath70 : @xmath71 . contemporary numerical codes typically evaluate @xmath68 at finite coordinate radius . this results in systematic errors , due to ambiguities in the tetrad choice and the neglect of gw backscattering . while these errors can be reduced by extracting gws at a sequence of radii and extrapolating to infinite radius ( @xmath68 asymptotically falls off @xmath72 @xcite ) , a cleaner method is to calculate @xmath68 at infinity as provided by _ cauchy - characteristic extraction _ methods @xcite . from @xmath68 , one straightforwardly obtains the energy , linear and angular momentum radiated in the form of gws ; see e.g. eqs . ( 49)-(51 ) in @xcite . in gw data analysis it is more common to work with the wave strain @xmath73 decomposed into multipoles : @xmath74 . in practice , after integrating @xmath68 twice in time the signal can be severely affected by nonlinear drifts , which can be controlled to a significant extent by performing the integration in the frequency domain @xcite . alternatively , gws can be extracted by viewing the metric in the far field regime as a perturbation of the schwarzschild spacetime and employing the formalism of regge , wheeler @xcite and zerilli @xcite . one thus obtains the regge - wheeler - moncrief and zerilli - moncrief master functions @xmath75 , @xmath76 , which can be converted into the multipolar components of the gw strain @xmath77 according to eq . ( 49 ) of @xcite . for a comprehensive summary of the numerical framework for evolving einstein s field equations , we refer the reader to the books by alcubierre @xcite and baumgarte and shapiro @xcite . further details , including mathematical aspects of the equations and characteristic techniques , can be found in the review articles @xcite . bh binary systems represent one of the most promising sources of detectable gws . the parameters of a bh binary are commonly divided into _ intrinsic _ and _ extrinsic _ @xcite . intrinsic parameters characterize physical properties of the system , such as the total mass @xmath78 , the mass ratio @xmath79 , the individual bh spins @xmath80 , @xmath81 and the orbital eccentricity . extrinsic parameters such as sky position , distance , orbital inclination angle , arrival time and initial phase of the wave , in contrast , depend on the source location relative to the observer , and do not directly enter the gw source modeling process . the majority of numerical studies of bh binary spacetimes performed to date have focussed on comparable mass - ratios @xmath82 and moderate spin magnitudes @xmath83 , with particular emphasis on spins ( anti-)aligned with the orbital angular momentum . we note , however , the following explorations outside this `` best charted '' subset of the parameter space . circular binaries with mass ratios up to @xmath84 have been studied in @xcite ; comparisons for this value of @xmath85 with fully perturbative calculations have been obtained in the limit of head - on collisions in @xcite , who report a discrepancy of @xmath86 in gw energy and momentum , probably in large part due to the discretization error of the numerical simulations . the first direct comparison of numerical results with leading - order self - force prediction was studied in the context of periastron advance in bh binaries in @xcite . bh binaries with spins @xmath87 have been evolved in @xcite , but exceeding an apparent barrier of @xmath88 @xcite requires departure from the conformal flatness assumption @xcite . the present maximum is @xmath89 for aligned spins evolved for 12.5 orbits by lovelace _ finally , we note that emission of gws efficiently circularizes bh binary orbits @xcite . bh binaries are therefore expected to have vanishing eccentricity by the time they enter the frequency window of ground - based detectors , and for this reason most work on gw source modeling has focused on the quasi - circular limit . the derivation of bh momenta , including a small radial component , for quasi - circular initial data in numerical relativity is based either on integrating the pn equations of motion @xcite or iterative procedures using several numerical simulations @xcite . the decay of eccentricity during the inspiral phase as well as periastron advance has been measured in numerical simulations in @xcite . for numerical studies of bh binaries with significant eccentricity as well as arguments why eccentric binaries may represent relevant sources of gws after all , especially in the more extreme mass ratio regime and for space - based detectors , we refer the reader to @xcite . * _ gravitational waveforms from bh binaries : _ * for illustration , we display in fig . [ fig : hlm ] the real parts of the @xmath90 and @xmath91 multipoles of the gw strain @xmath77 obtained for the inspiral and coalescence of a binary and @xmath91 obtained from the inspiral and merger of a nonspinning binary with mass - ratio @xmath92 . the dashed red curve represents pn predictions matched to the numerical ( solid black ) signal . the vertical dotted lines mark the time when the frequency of the @xmath93 multipole has reached @xmath94.,height=238 ] of nonspinning bhs with mass ratio @xmath92 @xcite . in the course of the inspiral , both amplitude and frequency of the gw signal gradually increase . close to merger , defined as formation of a common apparent horizon , the gw amplitude reaches a maximum . eventually it drops exponentially as the merged hole rings down to a stationary kerr state : see e.g. fig . 18 in @xcite . the qualitative features of the gw signal emitted by different types of binaries can be summarized as follows . ( i ) the inspiral of two nonspinning , equal - mass bhs is the case most intensively studied by numerical relativity . the wave signal is dominated by the @xmath93 multipolar component , which carries @xmath95 of the total radiated energy . the longest numerical simulation by scheel _ @xcite covers 16 orbits and reports a ratio of final to initial bh mass @xmath96 and a final spin @xmath97 . ( ii ) as the mass - ratio decreases , higher - order modes become more prominent @xcite and the fractional energy in @xmath93 drops to about @xmath98 in the limit @xmath99 @xcite . motivated by the strong relation of phase and frequency of different @xmath100 multipoles , baker _ _ @xcite view the @xmath100 radiation modes as being generated by the corresponding momenta of an _ implicit rotating source _ ; see also @xcite . ( iii ) gw multipoles with odd @xmath101 are suppressed in the equal - mass limit due to symmetry . ( iv ) bh binaries with spins aligned with the orbital angular momentum emit stronger gw signals due to an effect sometimes referred to as _ orbital hang - up _ : equal - mass binaries with @xmath102 radiate about twice as much energy and angular momentum when compared to the nonspinning case @xcite . for anti - aligned spins the gw energy decreases by a similar factor . ( v ) orbital eccentricity introduces a nonmonotonic behavior of the gw frequency ; cf . fig . 6 in @xcite . ( vi ) spin - spin and spin - orbit couplings cause a precession of the orbital plane in the case of bh binaries with spins that are not aligned or anti - aligned with the orbital angular momentum . this precession manifests itself in a modulation of the gw amplitude emitted in a fixed angular direction : cf . fig . 1 in @xcite . * _ tests of general relativity : _ * numerical simulations of binary bh mergers provide an opportunity to study the nonlinearities of the theory and to test the kerr nature of astrophysical bhs . if gr is the correct theory of gravitation , all bhs in the universe should be described by the kerr solution @xcite , which depends on two parameters : the mass @xmath78 and the dimensionless spin @xmath103 . the remnant of a binary bh merger settles down to the kerr solution by emitting gravitational radiation at characteristic ( complex ) quasinormal frequencies @xmath104 that depend only on @xmath103 . here @xmath100 are the usual angular indices , and @xmath105 is the `` overtone number '' : modes with small @xmath105 have a longer damping time and should dominate the radiation @xcite . the measurement of the real and imaginary part of a single quasinormal mode contains , in principle , enough information to determine the mass and spin of the bh . together with the accurate determination of the individual bh masses from the inspiral phase this already allows for tests of gr , by testing the gr prediction for mass loss during inspiral and merger and at the same time the strong field dynamics of gr . the measurement of _ any _ other frequency or damping time then provides a further interesting test of the kerr nature of the final bh @xcite . the feasibility of these tests depends on the characteristics of a given gw detector and on the relative excitation of the modes ( see @xcite for detailed studies ) . quantifying the excitation of quasinormal modes for generic initial data is a formidable technical problem @xcite , but numerical merger simulations allow sensible estimates of the relative quasinormal mode amplitudes @xcite . the relative mode amplitude depends on the binary parameters , and therefore , in principle , the measurement of a multi - mode signal with single or ( better ) multiple gw detectors can be used to measure the binary mass ratio or the inclination of the final bh spin with respect to the line of sight . we also remark that the increased signal - to - noise ratio coming from the merger has been shown to _ improve _ the bounds on alternative theories of gravity that could come from observations of the inspiral only . keppel and ajith , for example , discussed this possibility in the context of massive graviton theories , where the graviton mass would modify the dispersion relation of gws @xcite . formulations of the evolution equations in alternative theories of gravity are in their infancy @xcite and the numerical exploration of bh binaries in alternative theories of gravity has just started @xcite . this is an interesting line of research , and in the near future we may have more concrete ways to quantify deviations from gr in strong - field mergers . * _ gw template banks : _ * the key challenge in gw data analysis is to accurately predict and isolate the features of gravitational waveforms in the data stream from gw detectors . this is necessary in order to ( i ) detect the presence of a gw signal of astrophysical origin , and ( ii ) determine the parameters of the emitting source . these goals can be achieved by matched filtering , i.e. by cross - correlating the data stream @xmath106 ( composed of detector noise @xmath105 plus a potential gw signal @xmath77 ) with a bank of theoretical waveform templates @xmath107 , where the indices @xmath108 @xmath109 denote the @xmath110 intrinsic and extrinsic source parameters . for this purpose it is imperative to construct a large set of accurate numerical waveforms which cover the relevant parameter space . this task far exceeds the capacity of purely numerical methods . if we assume a seven - dimensional parameter space one mass ratio and three spin parameters per hole a mere ten waveforms per parameter would correspond to @xmath111 waveforms . furthermore , using binary waveform models including the long inspiral phase plus merger optimizes the signal - to - noise ratio in gw observations , and the inclusion of merger and ringdown has been shown to provide significant improvements in source localization and distance calculation @xcite . because current numerical simulations cover only about 30 cycles of the inspiral , the generation of complete waveforms requires the combined use of pn and numerical methods . the construction of such gw template banks currently proceeds along either of the following two paths . \(i ) the _ effective - one - body _ ( eob ) approach @xcite maps the dynamics of the two - body problem in gr into the motion of a particle in an effective metric . the components of the effective metric are currently determined to 3pn order . the eob method improves upon this model by using additional _ pseudo - pn _ terms of higher order between @xmath112 and @xmath113 @xcite . ] which are not derived from pn expressions , but calibrated via comparison with numerical results @xcite . further improvements come from using a resummed version of the pn expanded results and from modeling nonadiabatic effects in the inspiral : see e.g. sec . iv in @xcite . the inspiral - plunge waveform resulting from this construction is then matched to a merger - ringdown signal composed of a superposition of quasinormal oscillation modes of a kerr bh . the total number of free parameters varies between the individual eob models currently investigated , but in all cases , the general strategy is to calibrate these parameters by comparison with a finite number of numerical simulations . ( ii ) _ phenomenological waveform templates _ are based on _ hybrid waveforms _ : the early inspiral is modeled by pn techniques , and the resulting signal is matched ( within a specified window ) to a numerical waveform describing the last orbits , merger and ringdown . the resulting set of hybrid waveforms are then approximated by a model containing a number of phenomenological parameters which are mapped to the physical parameters of the binaries , such as the mass ratio @xmath85 . the phenomenological models initially developed for nonspinning binaries in @xcite , and then extended to the case of spins aligned with the orbital angular momentum @xcite , are based on hybrid waveforms matched in the _ time domain _ , whereas the more recent study by santamaria _ et al . _ @xcite performs the matching in the frequency domain . in spite of such differences in their construction , the final result of all these phenomenological models are closed - form analytic expressions for the waveforms in the frequency domain . an exploration of phenomenological models for equal - mass binaries with spin precession is given in @xcite . both types of template banks are employed in the analysis of gw data . the recent search for gws from binary bh inspiral , merger and ringdown @xcite used phenomenological models for injection , and an eob model for injection and for the search templates . this search constrained the rate of mergers of binaries with individual masses in the range @xmath114~m_{\odot}$ ] to be no more than @xmath115 at 90% confidence . numerical waveforms have also been used inside the gw community - wide _ ninja _ project @xcite to study the sensitivity of existing gw search algorithms used in the analysis of observational data . for this purpose , numerical relativity waveforms were injected into a simulated data stream designed to mimic ground - based detector noise . the algorithms detected a significant fraction of the injections , but likely require further development , in particular for the purpose of measuring source parameters @xcite . a further community wide effort , the _ nrar _ project @xcite , is dedicated to a systematic exploration of the complete bh binary parameter space to develop optimally - calibrated template families to be used in gw data analysis . one of the most exciting prospects of gw detection is the idea of looking for electromagnetic counterparts to the gw signal . while a _ network _ of earth - based detectors is required to localize a gw source by triangulation ( see e.g. @xcite ) , a single space - based detectors like lisa may suffice to localize low - redshift sources and determine their luminosity distance . the inclusion of merger and/or of higher multipolar components of the radiation in the waveform models has been shown to provide significant improvements in source localization and distance determination @xcite . for this reason it is very important to construct phenomenological models including higher multipoles of the full inspiral / merger / ringdown waveform . the eob model has recently been extended in this direction @xcite . * _ accuracy requirements : _ * clearly , the two approaches for template construction mentioned above require accurate numerical waveforms . quantifying these accuracy requirements is a nontrivial task . numerical uncertainties due to finite resolution are directly tested by _ convergence analysis _ , and the error incurred by extracting gws at finite radius can be estimated using extrapolation of results from various radii to infinity @xcite . the uncertainties in phase and amplitude thus derived , however , depend on the alignment of the waveforms in phase and time ; see e.g. fig . 2 in @xcite . because offsets in phase and time are free parameters in gw data analysis , it is more convenient to measure accuracy and agreement of different waveforms in terms of quantities which take such alignment into account by construction . such a measure is obtained from the inner product between two waveforms @xmath116 and @xmath117 used in the theory of parameter estimation @xcite : @xmath118 where the tilde and asterisk denote fourier transform and complex conjugate , respectively , and @xmath119 is the one - sided power spectral density of the detector strain noise @xcite . in practice , this inner product is to be understood as maximized over constant offsets in time and phase ( @xmath120 and @xmath121 ) between the two waveforms . the signal - to - noise ratio that would be obtained for a physical signal @xmath122 and a model waveform @xmath123 is then given by @xmath124 . it is related to the optimal signal - to - noise ratio @xmath125 for a perfect model waveform by the _ mismatch _ @xcite : @xmath127 to leading order in @xmath128 , this definition of the mismatch implies @xcite @xmath129 where @xmath130 is that part of the waveform error parallel to @xmath122 . based on these definitions , accuracy requirements are obtained as follows . two waveforms differing by @xmath131 will be indistinguishable for a detector if @xmath132 @xcite , such that acceptable waveform models to be used in parameter estimation must lie within a sphere of unit radius of the exact waveform . for the purpose of event detection , we note that the fractional loss in detection of gw signals due to imperfect templates is proportional to the third power of the reduction in the snr , i.e. @xmath133 . a value of @xmath134 is typically deemed acceptable , corresponding to a mismatch @xmath135 . for detection efficiency , there arises , however , a complication due to the discrete nature of the template bank . as discussed in detail in sec . ii b of @xcite , the effective mismatch in a real gw search is given by a contribution due to the actual modeling procedure , plus a term which accounts for the discrete spacing in the parameter space : see their fig . 3 and eq . template banks adopted in ligo searches use 0.3 for the latter @xcite and , in consequence , lindblom _ at al . _ @xcite recommend a maximum mismatch @xmath136 . in terms of the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eq : mm2 ] ) , dubbed _ inaccuracy function _ in ref . @xcite , we summarize the accuracy requirements as ( cf . ( 10 ) in ref . @xcite ) @xmath137 accuracy measurements employing the mismatch or @xmath128 have been used to study numerical , semi - analytic and hybrid waveforms . according to the samurai project @xcite , relative mismatches of the @xmath138 mode between a variety of purely numerical waveforms for binaries with total mass @xmath139 are better than @xmath140 . _ @xcite found errors in the construction of hybrid waveforms to be dominated by pn contributions . numerical waveforms should be long enough to enable matching at lower frequencies , where pn approximations are more accurate : @xmath141 orbits before merger for the equal - mass , nonspinning case , and @xmath142 orbits for binaries with spins @xmath143 . @xcite report significantly more demanding requirements of @xmath144 orbits for nonspinning , equal - mass binaries . similarly , boyle @xcite concludes that longer nr waveforms or more accurate pn predictions will be required . the discrepancy largely arises from the use of more stringent accuracy thresholds : @xmath136 in @xcite ( instead of @xmath145 in @xcite ) for detection , and @xmath146 for parameter estimation . most recently , ohme _ et al . _ @xcite have argued that maximising the match over intrinsic source parameters as well as phase and time shifts may reduce length requirements on numerical waveforms . a comparison of phenomenological and eob template banks based on the inaccuracy function has been performed by damour _ et al . _ @xcite . for advanced ground - based detectors , they conclude that current phenomenological models deviate from the eob ( considered as a target model ) beyond acceptable thresholds over a wide range of the parameter space , for both , detection and parameter estimation . further reading on bh simulations in the context of gw physics is available in @xcite . astrophysical observations have provided the strongest evidence to date that bhs exist and play an important role in many physical processes in our universe . astrophysical observations of x - ray binaries or quasars , as mentioned in sec . [ sec : intro ] , have a good deal to tell us about bhs . in recent years , numerical relativity simulations of bhs have also deepened our insight into a variety of astrophysical systems . we will first summarize what we have learned from `` traditional '' electromagnetic observations about the populations of bhs we can expect to exist in the universe . then we will discuss some astrophysical implications of numerical relativity . * _ expected bh populations : _ * we have already mentioned the two main classes of bhs identified by astrophysical observations . ( i ) solar - mass bhs with @xmath147 are usually found in x - ray binaries @xcite and are formed as the end - product of the evolution of massive stars . ( ii ) smbhs with @xmath148 are believed to reside in most active galactic nuclei ( agn ) @xcite . the assembly of these smbhs is likely to result from a combination of bh mergers and accretion of surrounding matter over cosmological timescales . evidence for a third class of bhs with @xmath149 ( imbhs ) is tentative at present @xcite . gw frequencies are inversely proportional to the system s total mass , and therefore bh masses play a crucial role in binary bh detectability . earth - based detectors , such as ligo and virgo , have an optimal sensitivity band corresponding to stellar - mass bhs and imbhs , while the planned space - based detector lisa is most sensitive to high - mass imbhs and smbhs . as discussed in the previous section , the expected gw pattern from bh binaries depends on the masses and spins of the binary members . we shall further see below that the gravitational recoil imparted upon the remnants of coalescing binaries strongly depends on spins and mass ratio . so , what do `` traditional '' electromagnetic observations tell us about bh masses and spins ? current spin estimates for accreting , stellar mass bhs are usually obtained by modeling the shape of their x - ray spectrum or by analyzing the skew in fe k@xmath3 emission lines . the resulting estimates are all , to some extent , model - dependent , but frequently yield moderate values @xmath150 and , for some cases , values close to the kerr limit @xmath151 ; see e.g. @xcite and references therein . theoretical arguments and observations suggest that stellar - mass bhs in binaries _ retain the spin they had at birth _ : neither accretion nor angular momentum extraction are likely to change significantly their mass or spin @xcite . for smbhs , spin estimates relying on the shape of the fe k@xmath3 line yield values ranging from moderate @xmath152 ( e.g. @xcite to near - critical spins ( e.g. @xcite ) . smbhs are expected to grow by a combination of mergers and accretion . their spin depends sensitively on the details of these processes and of their growth @xcite . smbh assembly via bh mergers does not appear to be able to account for the large observed spin values ; this may indicate that accretion dominates over mergers @xcite . in any case , bh spins encode the history of their formation , and it would be extremely useful to have detailed knowledge of the bh spin distribution function . ultimately , such a detailed census of bh parameters is one of the key targets of future gw observations @xcite . for the purpose of numerical modeling of bhs , present measurements indicate that all spin magnitudes ( @xmath153 ) should be covered . we have already noted that stellar - mass bhs typically have masses in the range @xmath154~m_{\odot}$ ] . unfortunately , there are no confirmed observations of stellar - mass _ binary _ bh candidates , so estimates of mass ratios must rely on theoretical models . for stellar - mass binaries , population synthesis codes suggest that @xmath85 should always be quite close to unity @xcite . measurements of smbh masses are obtained by observations of stellar motion near galactic centers , as mentioned in sec . [ sec : intro ] , as well as motion of gas discs @xcite , applications of the virial theorem to the velocity dispersion of stars @xcite and reverberation mappings applied to more distant agns @xcite . an exhaustive list of galaxies with smbh mass measurements in the range @xmath155 is presented by graham _ the impact of different smbh assembly models on the mass and mass ratio distribution of detectable binaries has been discussed by various authors . the general consensus is that mass ratios @xmath156 ( and down to @xmath157 ) should be common @xcite . in contrast with the case of stellar - mass bhs , there is by now some observational evidence for smbh binaries @xcite . these observations are not sufficient to tightly constrain smbh merger rates , but they are at least broadly consistent with merger - tree models predicting tens to hundreds of events during the typical lifetime of a space - based gw detector @xcite . a more speculative kind of source for earth - based detectors consists of the intermediate mass ratio inspiral of a compact object ( neutron star or bh ) into an imbh . another promising source for advanced earth - based interferometers ( albeit with highly uncertain event rates ) are imbh - imbh mergers . the initial inspiral of these binaries could be detected via space - based interferometers , while the ringdown phase is in the optimal bandwidth for second- and third - generation detectors such as advanced ligo and et , that could therefore be used for `` follow - up '' ringdown searches @xcite . as in the case of bh spins , the observations imply that numerical relativity needs to cover a wide range in @xmath85 . this can be done most efficiently by bridging the gap between numerical studies and the perturbative modeling of extreme - mass - ratio binaries ( e.g. @xcite ) . from this discussion , it is clear that a detailed knowledge of the spin evolution as well as the generation of gravitational recoil in bh binary mergers is important for understanding the cosmological evolution of smbhs over cosmological times . we will discuss these effects in turn . * _ black - hole spins resulting from mergers : _ * prior to the 2005 numerical relativity breakthroughs , it was known that `` minor mergers '' ( @xmath158 ) of a large , rotating bh with an isotropic distribution of small objects would tend to spin down the hole @xcite . numerical merger simulations showed that the merger of comparable - mass , nonspinning bhs leads to a final kerr bh with spin parameter @xmath159 . the simulations were followed by the development of several models to predict the spin of merger remnants as a function of the binary parameters for generic mass ratios and spins . the first studies focussed on performing numerical evolutions of the last few orbits of bh binaries , and used the results to calibrate formulae that map the initial binary parameters to values for the spin of the merged hole @xcite . it became clear , however , that the binary inspiral up to the last orbits has the potential to significantly affect the spin distribution ( e.g. @xcite ) and therefore should be included , for example via pn modeling , in the derivation of maps from initial parameters to the merger remnant properties @xcite . predictions for the final spin based on the extrapolation of test - particle calculations to finite mass ratios have been developed in @xcite , and show remarkably good agreement with numerical results in the comparable - mass regime . a comprehensive review of all spin formulae is beyond the scope of this article , but we refer the reader to the review in @xcite and the discussion in sec . v of @xcite . if we assume an ensemble of bh binaries with initially randomly oriented spins , the final spin distribution is peaked around @xmath160 @xcite . @xcite reported spin flips by @xmath161 with respect to the initial spin direction of the larger hole ; spin flips of this magnitude could provide an explanation for x - shaped radio sources @xcite . _ @xcite demonstrated that spin precession over the course of a long inspiral of thousands of orbits tends to align ( antialign ) the binary bh spins with each other if the spin of the more massive bh is initially partially aligned ( antialigned ) with the orbital angular momentum , thus increasing ( decreasing ) the average final spin . spin precession is stronger for comparable masses , and it could produce significant spin alignment before merger for both smbhs and stellar - mass bh binaries . * _ gravitational recoil : _ * one of the most spectacular results obtained from numerical bh binary simulations is the quantitative prediction of the magnitude of _ gravitational recoils _ ( or _ kicks _ ) . in the 1960s it was realized that the emission of linear momentum via gws must impart a kick on the source due to momentum conservation @xcite . in the 1980s , the kick generated in compact binary inspirals and plunges was studied in the framework of pn theory and bh perturbation theory @xcite . however , the astrophysical relevance of the gravitational recoil following bh binary mergers remained an open question until the recent numerical relativity breakthroughs . for the case of an equal - mass , nonspinning bh binary , the net linear momentum emitted in gws vanishes due to symmetry . nonzero recoils are therefore only generated in systems where this symmetry is broken through ( i ) a mass ratio @xmath162 ( equivalently , a symmetric mass - ratio parameter @xmath163 ) or ( ii ) nonvanishing spins . for zero spins , early numerical studies in the range @xmath164 $ ] found that the kick velocity is well approximated by @xcite @xmath165 this result ( whose functional form is inspired by fitchett s analytical work @xcite ) was confirmed by simulations for smaller mass ratios ( @xmath166 , @xcite ) and by analytical work @xcite . the maximal recoil obtained from eq . ( [ eq : nonspinningkick ] ) is @xmath167 for @xmath168 . small orbital eccentricity @xmath169 should introduce corrections proportional to @xmath170 @xcite . spinning binaries are characterized by seven free parameters ( the mass ratio plus three components for each bh spin ) , and numerical studies inevitably focussed on subsets of the parameter space . it soon became clear that the spin interaction dominates over mass ratio effects . the first studies for equal - mass binaries with spins parallel to the orbital angular momentum revealed kicks of several hundreds km / s , with an extrapolated maximum of @xmath171 for extremal spin magnitudes @xcite . shortly thereafter , the discovery of the so - called _ superkicks _ marked one of the most surprising outcomes of numerical relativity : binaries for which the spins are perpendicular to the orbital angular momentum and anti - aligned with each other can generate kicks of _ thousands _ of km / s , with an extrapolated maximum @xmath172 for near - extremal spin magnitudes @xcite . most recently , bh binaries with spins partially aligned with the orbital angular momentum but whose spin projections into the orbital plane still correspond to the superkick configurations have been found to result in even larger maximum recoils of up to @xmath173 km / s @xcite , so - called `` hang - up kicks '' . many galaxies harbor smbhs at their centers , and galaxy mergers should generally lead to the merger of their central bhs @xcite . typical escape velocities range from @xmath174 for dwarf galaxies up to @xmath175 for giant elliptic galaxies @xcite . large kicks would displace or eject the merged hole from its host , with possibly observable consequences : a softening of the stellar density gradient in the galactic nucleus , off - center radio - loud active galactic nuclei , off - nuclear x - ray sources in nearby galaxies and the generation of electromagnetic signals via interaction of the bh with its gaseous environment @xcite . bh ejection represents a potential obstacle for bh growth via merger , and thus puts constraints on merger - history models , which must be able to explain the assembly of smbhs by redshifts @xmath176 @xcite . observed redshifts of broad - line relative to narrow - line regions in quasar spectra may be interpreted as a smoking gun of bh ejection due to gravitational recoil @xcite , but alternative interpretations ( such as a bh binary , or superposed emission regions from two interacting galaxies ) are possible @xcite . the interest in astrophysical consequences of large recoils led to numerical studies of the bh parameter space @xcite . phenomenological kick formulas inspired by pn studies @xcite and similar to eq . ( [ eq : nonspinningkick ] ) were proposed to map the input parameters of a given binary configuration to the final kick velocity . available numerical results span mass ratios in the range @xmath177 and spin magnitudes @xmath178 , and are well described by eq . ( 2 ) of ref . @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . the apparent incompatibility between large recoils and the existence of bhs at galactic centers can be resolved by mechanisms that would _ align _ the individual bh spins with the orbital angular momentum of the binary . one such mechanism are gas torques in the so - called `` wet '' ( gas - rich ) mergers , that would produce partial alignment `` early on '' in the inspiral phase @xcite . if partial alignment in gas - rich mergers is the norm , as suggested also by the spin measurements discussed above , pn spin effects will lead to _ further _ alignment of the spins with the orbital angular momentum , significantly reducing the typical values of recoil velocities @xcite . this mechanism has even been shown capable of efficient suppression of large recoil velocities in the case of the above mentioned hang - up kicks @xcite . * _ merger simulations with matter and the blandford - znajek effect : _ * many numerical relativity groups are presently working on binary bh simulations in the presence of matter . most of this work is trying to understand the signature of electromagnetic counterparts to binary bh mergers : for example , such a signature could be produced by merger events @xcite or recoiling bhs @xcite `` shocking '' the surrounding accretion disks . the georgia tech group presented the first simulations in full gr of equal - mass , spinning bhs merging in a gas cloud . they found that shocks , accretion and relativistic beaming can produce electromagnetic signatures correlated with gws , especially when spins are aligned with the orbital axis @xcite . later work by the group focussed on hot , radiatively inefficient accretion flows . in this case , bh binaries exhibit a flare followed by a sudden drop in luminosity associated with the merger , and quasi - periodic oscillations correlated with the gws during inspiral @xcite . the urbana group simulated equal - mass , nonspinning bh binaries embedded in gas clouds under different assumptions for the motion of the binary with respect to the gas . they found evidence that the accretion rate and luminosity due to bremsstrahlung and synchrotron emission would be enhanced with respect to a single bh of the same mass as the binary , possibly being detectable by lsst @xcite . recent work suggest that the circumbinary disk surrounding bh binaries should not produce detectable electromagnetic counterparts @xcite . however , the _ magnetic fields _ produced by the circumbinary disk could affect the binary dynamics @xcite , produce stronger electromagnetic counterparts @xcite and extract energy from the orbiting bhs , which ultimately merge within the standard blandford - znajek scenario , generating electromagnetic emission along dual or single jets that could be observable to large distance @xcite ( but see also @xcite ) . for further reading , we recommend the following reviews . an excellent summary of bh mass and spin measurements and ( possible ) evidence for event horizons based on `` traditional '' electromagnetic astronomy is given by narayan @xcite . the use of electromagnetic observations of bhs and neutron stars to probe strong - field gravity is reviewed by psaltis @xcite . a more extended summary of numerical results on gravitational recoil can be found in zlochower _ _ @xcite . for a more general review of numerical bh simulations we recommend centrella _ the breakthroughs in numerical relativity have opened the door to tackle many fundamental problems in bh physics and to address questions of wider interest . a new golden era in bh physics is just starting . we summarize below what we think have been the main developments in this relatively short period of time . * _ mathematical physics and fundamental issues . _ * a decades - old problem in gr concerns the high - energy collision of two bhs . due to the dominance of the gravitational interaction at large energies , this process is thought to describe general trans - planckian scattering of particles : at very large center of mass ( cm ) energies all interactions are `` frozen '' while gravity is boosted , thus all the details about internal structure of the colliding particles should be washed out . this is further supported by thorne s hoop conjecture ( recently tested in highly dynamical situations @xcite ) , which predicts bh formation from generic high - energy collisions of particles @xcite . because the final bh horizon cloaks all details about the structure of the colliding objects , _ matter does not matter _ and one can for simplicity study bhs as representing a wide class of colliding objects @xcite . for large cm energies , bh collisions are arguably the most violent and nonlinear process one could conceive of . evolving einstein s equations in such extreme regimes poses new problems , such as the need to deal with all the different scales involved , and raises several questions . a fundamental issue concerns cosmic censorship . in four spacetime dimensions , bhs have an upper bound on their angular momentum , given by , while that of a spinning top @xmath179 , so ( even though the event horizon generators move at the speed of light ) bhs rotate `` slowly '' , as measured by their kerr parameters . ] @xmath180 is it possible to tune the impact parameter in such a way as to produce a final object spinning above the kerr bound , or does nature somehow conspire to always radiate enough angular momentum as to produce a bh ? this problem has been addressed in recent years @xcite . > b_{\rm scat}$ ] ) , a prompt merger ( @xmath181<b^*$ ] ) and a nonprompt merger ( @xmath182<b_{\rm scat}$ ] ) . taken from ref . , width=151 ] we show the trajectory of two equal - mass , nonspinning , colliding bhs in fig . [ fig : crit_traj ] , for cm velocities of around @xmath183 . we notice three distinct regimes . for impact parameters above the _ scattering threshold _ ( @xmath184 , the gravitational interaction between the two colliding bhs is relatively weak and they scatter to infinity . for impact parameters below the _ threshold of immediate merger _ ( @xmath185 ) , the bhs promptly collide and merge into a single bh . the transition between these two states for @xmath186 is a nonprompt merger , which puts the bhs in a so - called zoom - whirl orbit , i.e. the number of orbits @xmath187 . the results show that delayed mergers are necessary in order for the system to radiate excess angular momentum , so that the end product obeys ( [ kerrbound ] ) . the radiated energy and angular momentum increase strongly as the impact parameter approaches the threshold of immediate merger , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : e_b ] . for _ head - on _ collisions , numerical results suggest that a fraction @xmath188 of the cm energy is radiated in the limit of very large cm energy @xcite . for finely tuned impact parameters , the total radiated energy ( in gws ) can be of order @xmath189 for a collision with @xmath190 in the cm frame , while the spin of the final hole can reach @xmath191 of the bound ( [ kerrbound ] ) . an open issue is how much cm energy can be radiated for larger boosts . finally , peak luminosities of around @xmath192 are attained in these simulations . this number is orders of magnitude above any electromagnetic phenomena and close to the maximum conjectured possible value @xcite . the scattering threshold as a function of boost was studied by shibata _ et al . _ and sperhake _ _ @xcite . for the range of boosts studied it is well approximated by @xmath193 here @xmath78 is the total adm mass and @xmath194 the velocity of each hole as measured in the cm frame . * _ higher - dimensional black holes . _ * although bh solutions and their properties should in principle fall under the `` mathematical physics '' category , the activity in this specific field has been so intense that it deserves a subsection of its own . asymptotically flat higher - dimensional black objects have a much richer structure than their four - dimensional counterparts . for instance , spherical topology is not the only allowed topology for objects with a horizon . one can also have , _ e.g. _ , black rings , with a donut - like topology . remarkably , these two different horizon topologies coexist for certain regions in phase - space @xcite . explorations of the stability of general higher - dimensional bhs are in their infancy . generically it has been conjectured that , for @xmath195 , ultra - spinning myers - perry bhs will be unstable @xcite . this instability has been confirmed by an analysis of linearized axisymmetric perturbations in @xmath196 @xcite . clearly , the study of the nonlinear development of these instabilities requires numerical methods , such as the ones reviewed here . a study of this type was very recently presented for nonaxisymmetric perturbations in @xmath197 @xcite , where it was found that a single spinning five dimensional myers - perry bh is unstable , for sufficiently large rotation parameter ( confirming previous conjectures @xcite ) . general equilibrium states in anti - de sitter backgrounds only recently started to be explored : nonaxisymmetric solutions have finally been built @xcite , confirming previous conjectures about their existence @xcite , and braneworld bhs are now also starting to be explored @xcite . fully dynamical situations are still uncharted territory . * _ tev - scale gravity scenarios . _ * the above studies are of direct relevance to some high - energy scenarios . an outstanding problem in high - energy physics is the extremely large ratio between the four dimensional planck scale , @xmath198 gev , and the electroweak scale , @xmath199 gev . it has been proposed that this _ hierarchy problem _ can be resolved by confining the standard model to a brane in a higher dimensional space @xcite . in such models , the fundamental planck scale the energy at which gravitational interactions become strong could be as low as 1 tev . thus , high - energy colliders , such as the large hadron collider ( lhc ) , may directly probe strongly coupled gravitational physics @xcite . in fact , such tests may even be routinely available in the collisions of ultra high - energy cosmic rays with the earth s atmosphere @xcite , or in astrophysical bh environments @xcite ( for reviews see @xcite ) . the production of bhs at trans - planckian collision energies ( compared to the fundamental planck scale ) should be well described by using classical gr extended to @xmath9 dimensions @xcite . the challenge is then to use the classical framework to determine the cross section for production and , for each initial setup , the fractions of the collision energy and angular momentum that are lost in the higher - dimensional space by gw emission . this information will be of paramount importance to improve the modelling of microscopic bh production in event generators . the first models for bh production in parton - parton collisions used a simple black disk approach to estimate the cross section for production @xcite . as we already described , only recently exact results for highly relativistic collisions where obtained in four dimensions , using numerical relativity techniques @xcite . the extension to higher - dimensional spacetimes is a topic of current investigations @xcite . the first numerical results concerning low - energy collisions have been reported last year @xcite , initial data for boosted bh binaries have been constructed using an extended puncture approach in @xcite and some results for high - energy collisions have been presented in @xcite . * _ ads / cft and holography . _ * in 199798 , a powerful new technique known as the ads / cft correspondence or , more generally , the gauge - gravity duality , was introduced and rapidly developed @xcite . this holographic correspondence provides an effective description of a nonperturbative , strongly coupled regime of certain gauge theories in terms of higher - dimensional classical gravity in ads backgrounds . in particular , equilibrium and nonequilibrium properties of strongly coupled thermal gauge theories are related to the physics of higher - dimensional bhs , black branes and their fluctuations . these studies revealed intriguing connections between the dynamics of bh horizons and hydrodynamics , and offer new perspectives on notoriously difficult problems , such as the bh information loss paradox , the nature of bh singularities and quantum gravity . numerical relativity in anti - de sitter backgrounds is bound to contribute enormously to our understanding of the gauge - gravity duality and is likely to have important applications in the interpretation of observations @xcite . for instance , in the context of the gauge - gravity duality , high - energy collisions of bhs have a dual description in terms of _ a ) _ high - energy collisions with balls of deconfined plasma surrounded by a confining phase , and _ b ) _ the rapid localized heating of a deconfined plasma . these are the type of events that may have direct observational consequences for the experiments at brookhaven s relativistic heavy ion collider ( rhic ) @xcite . numerical relativity in anti - de sitter is particularly difficult , and so far only very special situations have been handled @xcite . among these , we note the recent numerical proof that pure ads space is unstable against collapse to bhs @xcite . bhs in the context of high - energy physics have also been discussed by pretorius @xcite and in the white paper @xcite . a recent review of numerical simulations of black strings in five spacetime dimensions is given by lehner and pretorius @xcite . an overview about numerical results on bhs in @xmath200 dimensions is given in @xcite . finally we note kanti s review on bhs at the lhc @xcite . we conclude this review with a brief summary of the most urgent problems to be tackled by numerical relativity in the three main areas in the near future . * _ gravitational wave physics : _ * in order to meet tight accuracy requirements in gw template generation , especially for parameter estimation , we either need longer numerical waveforms or a denser spacing of templates in the parameter space . both approaches will require computational resources that grow non - linearly as a function of the accuracy , either because of the slow nature of the inspiral at larger bh separations ( see sec . 2 in @xcite for a quantitative discussion ) or because of the dimensionality of the parameter space . a second major task is the extension of existing template models to generic binaries with precessing spins and/or smaller mass ratios , bridging the gap to perturbative modeling of extreme mass ratio binaries . * _ astrophysics : _ * while existing formulae for the kick and final spin resulting from the coalescence of bhs have been helpful for astrophysical studies , the calibration of generic models as proposed by boyle _ @xcite requires a more comprehensive exploration of the parameter space . the relatively young field of numerical relativity simulations of bhs surrounded by accretion disks will likely improve our insight into expected optical counterparts to bh binary mergers , and thus provide a vital tool for the area of _ multi - messanger astrophysics_. * _ high - energy physics : _ * arguably the most urgent task is the determination of the scattering cross - section and the loss of energy and momentum in gws in trans - planckian scattering of bhs in _ arbitrary _ dimensions . in view of the stability problems encountered in present studies , it also appears desirable to obtain a better understanding of the well - posedness of the formulations currently employed for such studies . second , the modeling of bhs in generic spacetimes such as de sitter and anti - de sitter is still in its infancy , even if preliminary studies of bhs in non - asymptotically flat spacetimes are encouraging . a better understanding of boundary issues , well - posedness of the formulations and diagnostics such as wave extraction tools and horizon finders will be required to open up this uncharted and fertile ground of research . * acknowledgements : * u.s . acknowledges support from the ramn y cajal programme and grant no . fis2011 - 30145-c03 - 03 of the ministry of education and science of spain , the fp7-people-2011-cig grant _ cbheo 293412 _ , nsf grants phy-0601459 , phy-0652995 and the sherman fairchild foundation to caltech . e.b.s research is supported by nsf grant phy-0900735 and by nsf career grant phy-1055103 . this work was supported by the dybho-256667 erc starting grant , and by fct - portugal through projects ptdc / fis/098025/2008 , ptdc / fis/098032/2008 , cte - ast/098034/2008 , cern / fp/116341/ 2010 and cern / fp/123593/2011 . this research was supported by the dybho256667 erc starting grant , the nrhep295189 fp7people2011irses grant by allocations through the teragrid advanced support program at the san diego supercomputing center and the national institute for computational sciences under grant phy-090003 , the centro de supercomputacin de galicia ( cesga ) under project numbers icts - cesga-175 , icts - cesga-200 and icts - cesga-221 , the barcelona supercomputing center ( bsc ) under project aect-2011 - 2 - 0006 , aect-2011 - 3 - 0007 , aect-2012 - 1 - 0008 , the deisa extreme computing initiatives deci-6 and deci-7 prace-2ip project dybho . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in relatively close primordial binaries which contain at least one star that can evolve substantially by the current epoch , mass transfer from the primary to the secondary is assured . the course of the evolution of each system depends on its initial orbital period , the two stellar masses , whether the binary is part of a triple system , spin and tidal interactions , and so forth . some of the possible evolutionary channels have been explored and even systematically mapped out by rappaport et al . ( 1994 ) , iben & tutukov ( 1995 ) , nelson & eggleton ( 2001 ) , han et al . ( 2002 ; 2003 ) , podsiadlowski et al . ( 2003a ) , and nelemans ( 2010 ) . depending largely upon the mass ratio and the initial orbital period , the mass transfer may be stable and mostly conservative , stable and mostly non - conservative , or dynamically unstable . in the case of a close binary that comprises a primordial primary star with mass @xmath5 and a secondary star that has @xmath6 , the mass transfer is most likely to be stable . however , depending on the ratio of thermal timescales of the two stars , the mass transfer may range from highly non - conservative for small @xmath7 ratios to mostly conservative for values of @xmath7 close to unity . whether the orbit ultimately evolves to be longer or shorter than the original orbital period depends on how much specific angular momentum is carried away with the matter ejected from the binary . in principle the best way to model such binary evolution is via a stellar evolution code that can simultaneously handle the nuclear and mass loss / gain evolution of _ both _ stars as well as the orbital evolution . the recently developed _ code ( paxton et al . 2011 ) is capable of doing such binary evolution studies , but , to our knowledge , no systematic studies have yet been carried out of ordinary close primordial binaries . we know empirically , and from some theoretical studies , that such evolution can lead to systems such as algol binaries ( see , e.g. , nelson & eggleton 2001 ) where the mass transfer is stable and the envelope of the primary has not yet been exhausted ; sdb binaries ( see , e.g. , han et al . 2002 ; 2003 ) which may have evolved from unstable mass transfer in a common envelope ; systems with hot , bloated , low - mass white dwarfs ( see , e.g. , van kerkwijk et al . 2010 ; carter et al . 2011 ) , where the envelope of the primary has been completely removed ; and even double - degenerate binaries ( marsh et al . 2004 ; iben , tutukov , & yungelson 1995 ; nelemans 2010 ) . in low - mass binaries where the mass transfer proceeds stably , regardless of whether it is or is not conservative , there is a fairly tight relation between the white dwarf mass , @xmath8 , and the final orbital period , @xmath9 ( see , e.g. , joss & rappaport 1983 ; savonije 1983 ; paczyski 1983 ; savonije 1987 ; rappaport et al . 1995 ; fig . 5 of lin et al . 2011 ; tauris & van den heuvel 2014 ) . for orbital periods @xmath10 years , and white dwarf masses , @xmath8 , up to 1.4 @xmath0 , in systems where the initial masses of the primaries , @xmath11 , were no larger than @xmath3@xmath12 , the following expression gives the final orbital period in terms of the white dwarf mass : @xmath13 for orbital periods up to @xmath320 days , which apply to systems with primaries of initial masses up to @xmath3@xmath12 , a more recently derived expression ( lin et al . 2011 ) is : @xmath14 these expressions have been checked against a number of binary radio pulsars ( fig . 3 of rappaport et al . 1995 ; fig . 2 of tauris & van den heuvel 2014 ) , and against a number of _ kepler _ binaries containing low - mass hot white dwarfs ( van kerkwijk et al . 2010 ; fig . 6 of carter et al . 2011 ) . prior to this work , only four low - mass white dwarf systems in the _ kepler _ field that can be used to study this relation between orbital period and white dwarf mass were identified . they are koi 74 , koi 81 ( rowe et al . 2010 ; van kerkwijk et al . 2010 ) , khwd3 ( koi 1375 ; carter et al . 2011 ) , and koi 1224 ( breton et al . 2012 ) . in this work we report the discovery of new low - mass , highly thermally bloated white dwarfs in the _ kepler _ binaries kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 . the orbital periods of these binaries are 1.267 and 2.305 days , the shortest periods among the six _ kepler _ binaries containing low - mass hot white dwarfs . the white dwarf in kic 9164561 is by far the most thermally bloated of any of the six white dwarfs . in section [ sec : data ] we discuss the search that led to these two systems among the _ kepler _ binaries , and indicate how the data were prepared for analysis . folded light curves are presented in section [ sec : lcs ] along with a simple geometric analysis , including a harmonic decomposition of the out - of - eclipse portions of the light curve . the masses of the primary a stars are inferred from information on their temperatures and mean densities in sect . [ sec : astars ] . in sect . [ sec : rv ] we present the radial velocity and spectral studies of kic 9164561 . the mass ratio of kic 10727668 is examined in the context of the doppler boosting effect in sect . [ sec : db ] . inferences about the mass ratios in the two systems are drawn from evaluating the ellipsoidal light variations in sect . [ sec : elv ] . in sect . [ sec : wds ] the system parameters for these two binaries are evaluated with emphasis on the white dwarf properties . evidence for a third star in kic 9164561 is presented in sect . [ sec : third ] . finally , in sect . [ sec : discuss ] we discuss kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 in the context of different binary evolution scenarios and white dwarf cooling models . in the process of searching for third - body companions to the binary stars in the _ kepler _ sample ( see , e.g. , rappaport et al . 2013 ; see also conroy et al . 2014 ) , we produced both an @xmath15 curve for the eclipses ( `` observed minus computed '' eclipse times ) as well as a folded light curve for each of the @xmath32600 cataloged _ kepler _ binaries ( matijevic et al . 2012 ; kirk et al . we used the _ kepler _ long - cadence time - series photometric data ( 29.4 min samples ) obtained from quarters 0 through 17 . for all the known binary systems for which at least one quarter of photometry is available , the version 5.0 fits files , which are available for all quarters , were downloaded from the stsci mast website . we used the data that had been processed with the pdc - map algorithm ( stumpe et al . 2012 ; smith et al . 2012 ) , which is designed to remove many instrumental artifacts from the time series while preserving any astrophysical variability . we also made use of the information in the file headers to obtain estimates of the combined differential photometric precision ( cdpp ) . we then examined by eye all 2600 @xmath15 curves for interesting variations . some of the results have been reported elsewhere ( rappaport et al . 2013 ; tran et al . the @xmath15 curve for kic 9164561 is discussed in sect . [ sec : third ] . we also searched for folded light curves that ( i ) exhibit a flat - bottomed eclipse that is deeper than the other eclipse , and ( ii ) are associated with hot _ kepler _ targets , i.e. , targets that have a reported @xmath16 k. the deep flat - bottomed eclipse - high temperature combination is a signature of a hot white dwarf in orbit with a normal , f , a , or b star . in addition to the four known _ kepler _ low - mass bloated hot white dwarfs , we found two others , previously unreported , in the binaries kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 . the nondegenerate components of kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 are , according to the kepler input catalog , hot with effective temperatures of @xmath38000 k and 10,000 k , respectively , and thus are not susceptible to the starspot modulations that are exhibited by cooler stars . an examination of the fourier transform of the kic 10727668 flux time series shows no evidence for any periodicities , including those from stellar pulsations , other than that of the orbit . in the case of kic 9164561 , the fourier transform of the flux time series shows a set of pulsations at frequencies @xmath17 cycles / day , which does not significantly affect our light curve or timing analysis . we therefore made no corrections to the data except for normalizing each quarter to its median value . the orbital periods given in the _ kepler _ binary catalog ( matijevic et al . 2012 ; kirk et al . 2015 ) were used to produce initial folds of the data . from these folds , we established a trial template for the orbital light curve . this profile was then used to fit each individual eclipse in the time series , thereby determining a set of 893 and 108 eclipse times for kic 9164561 and 10727668 , respectively . we then fit a linear function to the sequence of eclipse times of the form : @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the nth eclipse . the two orbital periods thus determined are in good agreement with those given in the _ kepler _ binary catalog , but have somewhat smaller uncertainties . the periods and their uncertainties for these two systems are listed in table [ tab : sys ] . we also fit the eclipse times for each system including a quadratic term to allow for possible changes in the orbital period or light travel time effects that might occur if the binary is part of a triple system . these are discussed in sect . [ sec : third ] below . the data for both kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 were folded at the orbital periods we determined from fitting the individual eclipses , as described above . the results were averaged into 3-minute bins , and are shown in figures [ fig:916 ] and [ fig:107 ] . due to the small curvature observed in the eclipse timing residuals for kic 9164561 ( see sect . [ sec : third ] ) we removed a quadratic term from the eclipse phases before producing the folded light curve in fig . [ fig:916 ] . the phase corrections amount to less than 0.002 days ( or 0.0016 orbital cycles ) . in each case , the light curves are normalized to unity at the bottom of the deeper eclipse when the hot white dwarf has been totally eclipsed . this is then the light level of the primary a star at a minimum of its ellipsoidal variations . the relatively small separation of the two components of kic 9164561 is manifest by the short orbital period , the large amplitude of the ellipsoidal light variations ( `` elv '' ) , and the duration of the eclipse relative to the orbital period . the light curves of these two binaries were analyzed with a relatively simple geometrical model which involves 13 free parameters . in brief , there are 7 free parameters associated with the eclipses : @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , two limb - darkening coefficients , and @xmath24 , where subscript `` 1 '' refers to the primary a star , @xmath25 is the orbital separation , @xmath22 the orbital inclination angle , and @xmath24 , the time of the middle of a primary eclipse . the out - of - eclipse phases are fitted with a set of 6 terms , i.e. , a sine and a cosine term for each of the orbital frequency and its next two higher harmonics . each of these can be associated with different contributions to the elvs , the illumination term , and the doppler boosting effect , as described in some detail in carter et al . ( 2011 ) . once the best - fitting parameters were found with a levenberg - marquardt fitting algorithm , the allowed region in parameter space was defined with a markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) routine , which used the gibbs sampler and the metropolis - hastings algorithm , and a likelihood proportional to @xmath26 ( see , e.g. , holman et al . 2006 ; sanchis - ojeda et al . 2013 ) . the results for the fitted model are plotted as red curves in figs . [ fig:916 ] and [ fig:107 ] . the high quality of the fit in each case is indicated by the white - noise appearance of the residuals . the results for the fitted parameters and their uncertainties are summarized in table [ tab : sys ] . the mass and radius of the primary star in each system are essential to quantitative models of the two binaries . there are two accessible parameters that can be utilized to estimate the primary mass : the effective temperature , @xmath27 , and the mean stellar density , @xmath28 . the _ kepler _ input catalog ( kic ) gives @xmath298059 k for the primary star of kic 9164561 and 9696 k for the primary of kic 10727668 . these temperatures are based on 5-color photometry . for kic 9164561 we measured @xmath30 k from the same spectra used for the radial velocity measurements ( see sect . [ sec : spec ] ) . in the case of kic 10727668 , where we have no additional spectral information , we estimate the uncertainty in the kic value of @xmath27 at approximately @xmath31 300 k ( huber et al . 2104 ) . the second readily , and more accurately , determined parameter associated with each primary star is its mean density , @xmath32 . this mean density is a function only of the light curve - determined parameters @xmath33 and @xmath34 , with a weak dependence on @xmath35 ( the mass ratio @xmath36 ) . the dependence of @xmath28 on these parameters may be found by dividing kepler s third law by @xmath37 to obtain : @xmath38 this relation was pointed out by seager & malln - ornelas ( 2003 ) in the context of transiting exoplanets . for exoplanets , the value of @xmath35 is much smaller than the error in @xmath34 so that @xmath28 can be determined independently of any mass information . while the same is not quite true with our two binaries , the value of @xmath35 is still sufficiently small , i.e. , @xmath39 that a rather accurate value of @xmath28 may be determined nearly independently of @xmath35 . in particular , by using eqn . ( 3 ) with the results from our photometric analysis of @xmath21 and with , as a first approximation , @xmath40 , we find that @xmath41 g @xmath42 for kic 9164561 , and @xmath43 g @xmath42 for kic 10727668 . these values are refined below using estimates for @xmath35 that are based on estimates of the masses of the two component stars . figure [ fig : yy ] shows stellar evolution tracks for stars of a range of initial masses in the @xmath44@xmath45 plane . the locations of the two target primary stars are indicated by the rectangular boxes . we conclude from this that the mass of the primary star in kic 9164561 must be @xmath46 ( kic 9164561 ) and that of the primary in kic 10727668 must be @xmath47 @xmath0 . the spectroscopic follow - up of kic9164561 was carried out with the fibre - fed chelle spectrograph ( fies ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) mounted at the 2.56-m nordic optical telescope ( not ) of roque de los muchachos observatory ( la palma , spain ) . spectra were taken under clear and stable sky conditions at 11 epochs between may and september 2014 . we used the @xmath48 _ med - res _ fibre , which provides a resolving power of about 47000 in the spectral range 36007400 . the observations taken at each epoch were split into two or three consecutive sub - exposures of 1200 seconds each to remove cosmic ray hits . following the observing strategy described in @xcite , we monitored the radial velocity drift of the instrument by acquiring long - exposed ( t@xmath49=15 - 30 sec ) thar spectra in sandwich mode " , i.e. , right before and after each epoch observation . the data were reduced using a customized idl software suite , which includes bias subtraction , flat fielding , order tracing and extraction , and wavelength calibration . radial velocities ( rvs ) were determined by cross - correlating the target spectra with the spectrum of vega , for which we adopted a heliocentric radial velocity of @xmath50@xcite . table [ rv - table ] lists the fies rv measurements , the signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratio per pixel at 4650 , and the full - width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the fies cross - correlation function ( ccf ) . full - widths at half maximum were extracted by fitting a gaussian to the ccfs between the observed spectra and the atlas9 model spectrum having the same photospheric parameters as the target star ( see sect.[sec : spec ] ) and smoothed to the fies spectral resolution . figure [ fig : rvs ] shows the phase - folded rv curve of kic9164561 , based on the phase established from the _ kepler _ photometry , and the keplerian circular - orbit fit to the results . the k velocity of the primary a star is 21.64 @xmath31 0.35 km s@xmath51 , and the corresponding @xmath52-velocity is -28.43 @xmath31 0.25 km s@xmath51 . the corresponding mass function is @xmath53 for an orbital inclinational angle of @xmath54 ( see table [ tab : sys ] ) , this implies : @xmath55 the mass for the a star of @xmath56m@xmath57 obtained above may be combined with the mass function to obtain a white dwarf mass of @xmath58 . the mass ratio for the kic 9164561 system is therefore @xmath59 . because kic 10727668 is faint , i.e. , 2.6 _ kepler _ magnitudes fainter than kic 9164561 , we were unable to obtain any useful rv measurements for that system . [ rv - table ] ccccccc bjd@xmath60 & rv & @xmath61 & ccf@xmath62 fwhm & @xmath63 & s / n / pixel@xmath64 & date of obser.@xmath65 + ( @xmath66 2450000 ) & & & & & @4650 & ( at start ) + 6783.67056 & -9.397 & 0.673 & 103.6 & 1.4 & 23 & 06 may 2014 + 6833.58987 & -38.015 & 0.714 & 106.7 & 1.2 & 19 & 25 jun 2014 + 6833.67106 & -43.987 & 0.768 & 102.9 & 1.2 & 17 & 25 jun 2014 + 6844.66674 & -7.539 & 0.968 & 112.1 & 1.2 & 11 & 06 jul 2014 + 6845.43519 & -38.741 & 0.794 & 109.1 & 1.0 & 15 & 06 jul 2014 + 6845.71215 & -11.787 & 0.690 & 102.8 & 1.2 & 23 & 07 jul 2014 + 6901.37427 & -22.004 & 0.847 & 107.6 & 1.2 & 15 & 31 aug 2014 + 6902.40137 & -43.375 & 0.743 & 104.6 & 1.3 & 17 & 01 sep 2014 + 6915.38485 & -12.215 & 0.784 & 106.5 & 1.3 & 15 & 14 sep 2014 + 6915.55901 & -7.337 & 0.820 & 107.2 & 1.1 & 14 & 15 sep 2014 + 6920.43515 & -14.633 & 0.791 & 105.6 & 1.3 & 13 & 19 sep 2014 + \(a ) width of the cross correlation function . ( b ) s / n ratio per pixel at 4650 . ( c ) calendar date in ut at the beginning of the target observation . we started the spectral analysis by coadding all the fies spectra , after shifting them to a zero - velocity reference frame , which yielded a s / n of @xmath67 55 per pixel at 4650 . the spectral parameters of the primary component in kic 9164561 were then derived by fitting this spectrum to a grid of synthetic spectra calculated with the spectrum code @xcite using atlas9 models @xcite . we assumed a secondary - to - primary flux ratio of 0.0285 , as estimated from the eclipse light curve modeling ( table [ tab : sys ] ) . we adopted the calibration equations from @xcite and @xcite for the purpose of estimating the microturbulent @xmath68 and macroturbulent @xmath69 velocities . these equations were extrapolated to the effective temperature of the star . the spectral type was determined following the method described in @xcite . the estimated stellar parameters are listed in table [ star - parm ] . figure [ fies_spectrum ] shows the co - added fies spectrum in the spectral region encompassing the h@xmath70 , h@xmath71 , and mgi b lines , along with the best fitting synthetic model . lc parameter & + effective temperature @xmath72 ( k ) & @xmath73 + spectroscopic surface gravity log@xmath74 ( log@xmath75 cms@xmath76 ) & @xmath77 + metallicity [ m / h ] ( dex ) & @xmath78 + microturbulent velocity @xmath79 ( kms@xmath51 ) & @xmath80 + macroturbulent velocity @xmath81 ( kms@xmath51 ) & @xmath82 + projected rotational velocity @xmath83sin@xmath22 ( kms@xmath51 ) & @xmath84 + spectral type & 7 + we looked for the spectroscopic signature of a third ( bound ) component to kic 9164561 by cross - correlating the fies spectra with a set of a- through m - type observed templates . the templates were gathered between 2011 and 2014 , as part of the on - going rv follow - up of _ corot _ and _ kepler _ stars carried out with fies@not ( e.g. , gandolfi et al . 2013 ) . assuming that the third star is on or near the zams , its mass can not exceed @xmath32 @xmath0 corresponding to an a7v spectral type without significantly violating a number of observational constraints ( see below ) . the eclipse timing variations detected in the _ kepler _ light curve ( see sect . [ sec : third ] ) constrain the orbital period of a putative third star in the system to lie between 8 and 19 years , implying that its rv is within @xmath312 km s@xmath51 of the @xmath52 velocity of the binary system . the fies rv follow - up covers a time span of about 4.5 months , which corresponds to less than 4.6% of the orbital period of the third component , constraining its rv variation to be less than @xmath34 km s@xmath51 within the observing window . because of the relatively high projected rotational velocity of the primary star ( see table [ star - parm ] ) , the almost `` stationary '' ccf peak of the third source is expected to be blended with the broad peak of the a7v component . the fies ccfs show neither a peak with constant rv superimposed on top of the broad peak of the a7v star , nor a skewed profile that would suggest the presence of a another rapidly rotating star ) . ] . in order to assess the significance of the non - detection and constrain the parameters of a possible third body , we built up a set of synthetic double - lined spectroscopic binary ( ` sb2 ' ) spectra using atlas9 model atmospheres . we adopted gray s ( 2005 ) calibration for dwarf stars to convert spectral types to stellar parameters . we combined the rotationally broadened model spectrum of an a7v star resembling the primary component with that of dwarf stars with different spectral types ( from a7v to m5v ) and values of @xmath83sin@xmath22 . we added random noise to account for the average s / n ratio of the fies spectra and the contaminant light of the second source to account for the white dwarf . we assumed a zero velocity for the third light and radial velocities in the range @xmath85rv@xmath86 kms@xmath51 for the a7v primary star . finally , we cross correlated the combined sb2 spectra with narrow - lined synthetic spectra covering different spectra types , in the same fashion as for the observed spectra . since the contrast of a ccf peak decreases with increasing @xmath83sin@xmath22 , we considered the following two cases . _ spectral type later than f5v_. we used gyro - chronology to constrain the @xmath83sin@xmath22 of the third star . given the age of the system ( @xmath3925 myr ; see sect . [ sec : cool ] ) , the rotation period of the third component is expected to be longer than about 4 days for spectral later than f5v ( barnes et al . this places an upper limit of 18 km s@xmath51 on @xmath83sin@xmath22 . although this value likely overestimates the true @xmath83sin@xmath22 for the late - type stars , we conservatively assumed 18 km s@xmath51 to be the projected rotational velocity associated with the third light . we found that any stars with spectral type between k2v and f5v would be detectable in the fies ccf ( for an example see fig . [ fig : simccfs ] ) . for later spectral types the peak of the third light is embedded in the noise of the ccf , owing to the relatively low s / n ratio of the spectra and the low flux of the third star . sin@xmath87km / s and a k0v star with @xmath83sin@xmath88km / s ( see text for details ) . the dashed red and blue lines mark the rv of the k0v ( 0 km / s ) and the a7v star ( 21.6 km / s ) , respectively . the black curve , shown for reference , is the same ccf , but without the presence of the k0v star . ] _ spectral type between f5v and a7v_. for @xmath83sin@xmath89 km s@xmath51 the ccf peak of the third component is clearly visible on top of the peak of the primary star , as described in the previous case . for @xmath83sin@xmath90 km / s the ccf would assume a variable skewed profile , whose shape changes with the changing rv of the primary star , which we do not observe . finally , for @xmath91sin@xmath92 km / s the two ccf peaks are merged together and larger actual rv variations of the primary component would be needed to account for the measured rvs ( see below ) . in the case of comparable amounts of light contributed by the a7v star and a putative third star , we can say two things . first , the fwhm of the ccf would vary in a correlated way with the measured rvs . the extra widening can be estimated analytically , and the broadening factor is given by @xmath93 $ ] , where @xmath94 is the observed ( i.e. , ` diluted ' ) instantaneous value of the a7v star rv , and @xmath95 is the gaussian width of the ccf curve . since the ccf fwhm remains constant at 106.5 km s@xmath51 to within an rms scatter of @xmath33 km s@xmath51 ( see table [ rv - table ] ) , and a 42 km s@xmath51 shift ( i.e. , @xmath96 km s@xmath51 ) is expected to widen the ccf by 12 km s@xmath51 , which is distinctly not observed , we conclude that there is no other a- to early f - type star of comparable brightness in the system . second , as mentioned above , a stationary line would ` dilute ' the actual doppler shift by a factor of @xmath3@xmath97 , where @xmath98 and @xmath99 are the fluxes of the a7v star and the third body , respectively . in this case , the properly inferred mass of the white dwarf ( based on the rv amplitude ) would be a factor of approximately @xmath100 higher . this , in turn , would yield an implausibly high mass for the white dwarf when @xmath99 exceeds @xmath98 by even a factor of 2 . therefore , the mass of an early - type third body is independently constrained to be @xmath101 . thus , based on our simulations , we can exclude nearly any plausible near - ms third star that has a spectral type earlier than k2v . while there is still some small ` wiggle room ' left in parameter space , these constraints likely imply an upper limit for the mass of any third star to be about 0.8 @xmath0 . in principle , the doppler boosting amplitude ( loeb & gaudi 2003 ; van kerkwijk et al . 2010 ) can serve as a surrogate in place of radial velocity ( ` rv ' ) measurements for measuring the binary k velocity . as formulated by carter et al . ( 2011 ) the doppler boosting ( hereafter ` db ' ) amplitude in a binary is given by : @xmath102\ ] ] where the @xmath103 s are the fluxes of the two stars in the _ kepler _ band . the @xmath104 s are doppler boosting pre - factors calculated from : @xmath105 where @xmath106 is the spectral flux density at frequency @xmath107 , and @xmath104 must be evaluated using stellar atmosphere models averaged over the _ kepler _ band . the second term in eqn . ( [ eqn : db ] ) represents the contribution to the db amplitude from the white dwarf in the system ( note the minus sign ) . this method for evaluating the k velocities has been verified by ehrenreich et al . ( 2011 ) and bloemen et al . ( 2012 ) for the case of koi 74 , a system quite analogous to the ones discussed in this paper . _ kic 9164561 _ : the measured doppler boosting amplitude in this system , i.e. , the amplitude of the @xmath108 term , where @xmath109 is the orbital frequency , and @xmath110 is time , is -10 @xmath31 26 parts per million ( ` ppm ' ) . given the @xmath111 velocity obtained from the rv measurements ( see sect . [ sec : rv ] ) , for nominal values of @xmath112 , @xmath113 for this system should be @xmath67160 ppm . one possible explanation for this discrepancy is based on the large illumination semi - amplitude , i.e. , the coefficient of the @xmath114 term , that is measured to be 2385 @xmath31 36 ppm . in this case , if the phase of the illumination is shifted in the proper sense from its nominal alignment with the eclipses by as little as 4@xmath115 , the entire db effect would be cancelled . we note that in koi 74 the illumination term is 600 times smaller because of the wider orbital separation and the lower luminosity of the white dwarf , and is therefore very unlikely to materially affect the observed doppler boosting amplitude . in order for the phase of the illumination effect in kic 9164561 to be shifted by the amount required to cancel most of the doppler boosting signal , the a - star primary would have to be rotating faster than the rate that is synchronous with the orbit , such that some of the heated surface material is carried into the night side of the star . the measured rotation velocity of this star is @xmath67 75 @xmath31 5 km s@xmath51 , a value that is to be compared with the equatorial rotation velocity of a star of radius 2.5 @xmath116 ( see table [ tab : sys ] ) rotating with a period of 1.267 days , i.e. , @xmath67 100 km s@xmath51 . thus , if anything , the primary is rotating subsynchronously and the db signal is therefore expected to be enhanced relative to its nominal amplitude . this is a potentially important discrepancy which merits follow - up study . _ kic 10727668 _ : in this system , the doppler boosting signal is measured to have a significantly non - negative value , 143 @xmath31 20 km s@xmath51 . the illumination amplitude , 557 ppm , is 4 times smaller than in the case of kic 9164561 ; this system may therefore be less susceptible to an illumination - induced perturbation of the db amplitude . if eqn . ( [ eqn : db ] ) is used to evaluate @xmath111 we find : @xmath117 where we have taken @xmath118 , @xmath119 ( van kerkwijk , private communication ) , and @xmath120 ( see fig . [ fig:107 ] ) . this expression for @xmath111 may be entered into the mass function , and the cube root of the result taken to obtain the following equation involving the masses of the two stars : @xmath121 where we have taken the orbital inclination angle to be 86.4@xmath115 ( see table [ tab : sys ] ) . this equation can be solved numerically for @xmath122 given any specific value for @xmath123 . for a primary star mass of 2.2 @xmath0 ( see fig . [ fig : yy ] ) , the mass of the secondary is @xmath124 where the error bar takes into account the uncertainty in @xmath123 as well as the uncertainty in @xmath111 . again we caution that this estimate for @xmath122 does not take into account any systematic error due to an `` amplitude leak '' in the db term . the ellipsoidal light variations ( ` elvs ' ) seen in the out - of - eclipse region of the light curves also contain information on the mass ratios , @xmath125 . the basic expression for the elvs ( kopal 1959 ; morris & naftilan 1993 ; carter et al . 2010 ) is : @xmath126 and @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the amplitude of the cosine term at twice the orbital frequency , @xmath129 is the linear limb - darkening coefficient , and @xmath130 is the gravity darkening coefficient . for the hot primary stars in kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 we take @xmath131 and @xmath132 . this leads to a numerical value for @xmath133 of 1.68 . we can then utilize the measured values of @xmath128 of @xmath134 ppm and @xmath135 ppm for the two systems , respectively ( see table [ tab : sys ] ) . similarly , we take the values for @xmath21 and @xmath22 for each system from table [ tab : sys ] . finally , we solve for @xmath35 to find : @xmath136 where the error bars are statistical only and do not include any systematic uncertainties in the use of eqn . ( [ eqn : elv ] ) to evaluate @xmath35 from the elv amplitude . the value of @xmath35 found for kic 9164561 from the rvs is @xmath137 ( sect . [ sec : spec ] ) which is in quite satisfactory agreement with @xmath138 . on the other hand , the value of @xmath35 for kic 10727668 found from the elv analysis ( eqn . ( [ eqn : qelv ] ) ) , while still in marginal agreement with the value obtained from the doppler boosting analysis ( @xmath139 ) , would imply a white dwarf mass as high as @xmath140 . this is quite on the high side of what we expect for this system ( see sect . [ sec : discuss ] ) . in order to determine the sizes of the binary systems we need the total masses . in the case of kic 9164561 , where a direct rv measurement has been made , the total system mass is 2.22 @xmath31 0.07 @xmath0 . with the application of kepler s third law , this leads immediately to an orbital separation of @xmath141 . for kic 10727668 the doppler boosting analysis yielded a mass ratio @xmath142 . if we tentatively accept this mass ratio , and apply kepler s third law , we find the orbital separation is @xmath143 . the reason that the uncertainty is quite small , in spite of the larger uncertainty in @xmath35 for this system , is that @xmath25 depends only on the cube root of the total system mass , and @xmath35 is a small number . these values for the orbital separation are summarized in table [ tab : sys ] . the radii of the primary and secondary stars follow immediately from the @xmath21 and @xmath144 values derived from the light curve analyses and the values of the orbital separations . these radii are summarized in table [ tab : sys ] . of particular note are the large radii of the two white dwarfs , 0.277 @xmath116 and 0.151 @xmath116 for kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 , respectively , which indicate that these stars are quite thermally bloated . the degenerate radii for cold white dwarfs of either he or hybrid heco compositions , are given by eqn . ( 4 ) in nelson & rappaport ( 2003 ) . the degenerate radii for the white dwarfs in kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 are 0.020 @xmath116 and 0.018 @xmath116 , respectively , implying thermal bloating factors of 14 and 8 . we carried out an eclipse timing analysis for both binaries discussed in this paper . we used a code to produce the observed minus calculated curve ( ` @xmath15 ' curve ) that was tested in our search for triple star systems ( rappaport et al . only the @xmath15 curve for kic 9164561 showed an interesting non - linear behavior . the results are shown in fig . [ fig : omc ] with black points for the average of the @xmath15 curves for the primary and secondary eclipses . the @xmath15 curve shows two notable features : ( i ) a clear curvature , and ( ii ) small - amplitude oscillations with a period of @xmath3170 days . the small amplitude oscillations are due to an artifact that results from a beat between the orbital period and _ kepler _ long - cadence sampling ( see eqns . ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) in rappaport et al . 2013 ) . the quadratic behavior in the @xmath15 curve is highly significant ( 35 @xmath95 ) , and can be interpreted as either a change in the orbital period , or as a roemer delay due to the motion of the binary induced by a third body . the first option requires changes in the binary orbital period on a characteristic timescale of @xmath145 years . since there is no significant mass transfer taking place in the system at the current time , this can not be the cause of the apparent orbital period changes . one would have to invoke another mechanism , such as the applegate effect ( applegate & patterson 1987 ; applegate 1992 ; kotze & charles 2010 ) to explain the short timescale changes in the orbit . we focus here on a more interesting and , in our view , more likely scenario , i.e. , that there is a third body in the system . it is then possible to constrain the orbital radius of such a third body as well as its mass , if we restrict our attention to coplanar and circular orbits . otherwise , the possibilities are nearly limitless . the results of such constraints are shown in fig . [ fig : constraints ] . we find that the orbital period must lie in the range of @xmath146 years in order to provide at least a somewhat satisfactory fit to the @xmath15 curve ( @xmath147 limits ) . the blue curve shows the best fit ( projected ) orbital radius as a function of @xmath148 . the red curve is the corresponding mass function , while the green curve is the mass of the third body under the assumptions that the mass of the inner binary is @xmath149 and that the orbital inclination of the third body orbit is @xmath150 . since the mass of the third body , if it is assumed to be on or near the zams , can not exceed @xmath32 @xmath0 without affecting the spectrum , rv analysis , and the third light of the system in ways that are not observed ( see sects . [ sec : spec ] and [ sec : ccf ] ) , the orbital period is further restricted to the range of @xmath151 years . if we adopt the formal constraint on the mass of a main - sequence third star in the system from sec . [ sec : ccf ] of @xmath152 we find that : @xmath153 and @xmath154 years . to this point we have not yet considered the possibility that the putative third body might be a white dwarf . the orbital period would then be restricted to the range @xmath155 years since the mass would have to be @xmath156 ( see fig . [ fig : constraints ] ) . if there had been a prior episode of mass transfer from the progenitor of the outer body white dwarf to the inner binary ( kic 9164561 ; see , e.g. , tauris & van den heuvel 2014 ) then , according to eqn . ( [ eqn : mwd_p ] ) , the mass would lie in the range of @xmath157 . such white dwarfs would have cooled to the point where they would contribute very little light to the system ( @xmath158 ) . based on the inferred luminosity of kic 9164561 , and the appropriate bolometric corrections , we infer that its distance from the earth is @xmath159 pc . typical orbital separations to the putative third body , for periods in the range of @xmath160 years , are expected to be @xmath161 au . at a distance of 390 pc , the corresponding angular separations are then @xmath162 mas . this may be detectable with _ gaia_. c c c parameter & kic 9164561 & kic 10727668 + [ 0.5ex ] ra ( j2000 ) & 19h 42 m 27.64s & 19h 21 m 45.58s + dec ( j2000 ) & 45@xmath115 30@xmath163 17.0@xmath164 & 48@xmath115 02@xmath163 42.4@xmath164 + @xmath33 [ days ] & 1.2670400 @xmath165 & 2.305897 @xmath166 + @xmath24 [ mjd]@xmath167 & 64.61956 @xmath168 & 1207.3677 @xmath169 + @xmath170 [ mag . ] & 13.71 & 16.32 + @xmath171 & 0.1091 @xmath172 & 0.0893 @xmath173 + @xmath21 & 0.397 @xmath174 & 0.170 @xmath175 + @xmath25 [ @xmath116 ] & 6.40 @xmath177 & 9.95 @xmath31 0.15 + @xmath178@xmath179 & 0.0285 @xmath180 & 0.0245 @xmath180 + inclin . [ deg ] & 71.59 @xmath181 & 86.45 @xmath182 + + @xmath123 @xmath183 $ ] & @xmath184 & @xmath185 + @xmath186 [ @xmath116 ] & 2.54 @xmath31 0.03 & 1.69 @xmath31 0.04 + @xmath27 [ k ] & 7870 @xmath31 150 & 9696 @xmath31 300 + @xmath187 [ @xmath188 & 22.3 @xmath31 1.5 & 22.9 @xmath31 3.1 + @xmath189 [ g / cc ] & 0.171 @xmath310.04 & 0.63 @xmath31 0.04 + @xmath190 [ cgs ] & 3.93 @xmath31 0.02 & 4.32 @xmath31 0.04 + + @xmath122 [ @xmath0 ] & 0.197 @xmath31 0.005 & 0.266 @xmath31 0.035 + @xmath192 [ @xmath116 ] & 0.277 @xmath31 0.005 & 0.151 @xmath31 0.004 + @xmath193 [ k ] & 10410 @xmath31 200 & 14110 @xmath31 440 + @xmath194 [ @xmath188 & 0.82 @xmath31 0.07 & 0.82 @xmath31 0.11 + @xmath195 [ g / cc ] & 12.8 @xmath31 1.2 & 120 @xmath3119 + @xmath196 [ cgs ] & 4.84 @xmath31 0.04 & 5.55 @xmath31 0.06 + + @xmath197 [ @xmath198@xmath199 & @xmath200 @xmath31 27 & 143 @xmath31 20 + @xmath201 [ @xmath202@xmath203 & 2385 @xmath31 36 & 557 @xmath31 22 + @xmath204 [ @xmath205 & @xmath206 @xmath31 27 & @xmath207 @xmath31 20 + @xmath208 [ @xmath209@xmath210 & @xmath134 @xmath31 35 & @xmath135 @xmath31 21 + @xmath211 [ @xmath212 & @xmath213 @xmath31 28 & @xmath214 @xmath31 19 + @xmath215 [ @xmath216 & @xmath217 @xmath31 36 & @xmath218 @xmath31 23 + [ tab : sys ] here we discuss the properties of the kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 systems and some of the evolutionary paths that may have led to their formation . we can then check whether the expected system parameters match those determined empirically . there are two important evolutionary pathways that could lead to the formation of low - mass helium white dwarfs in close binaries ( see , e.g. , van kerkwijk et al . 2010 ; carter et al . 2011 ; breton et al . the first channel includes one episode of common envelope ( ce ) evolution wherein the more massive star of the primordial binary overflows its roche lobe after having become a giant with a degenerate core , and then undergoes dynamically unstable mass transfer onto its binary companion ( see , e.g. , taam et al . 1978 ; webbink 1984 ; taam and bodenheimer 1992 ) . the rapid rate of mass transfer causes the companion to spiral inward towards the degenerate core of the giant while concomitantly expelling the envelope of the giant into the ism . the resulting binary is composed of a degenerate white dwarf in a tight circular orbit with a largely unchanged companion star . the second channel involves stable mass transfer between the components of the progenitor binary . unfortunately the degree to which mass transfer is conservative and the effectiveness of orbital angular momentum loss mechanisms ( e.g. , magnetic braking ; see , for example , verbunt & zwaan 1981 ) are uncertain . for reasonable physical assumptions in regard to the mass transfer and angular momentum loss processes , this channel can explain the formation and observed properties of these two systems ( see nangreaves et al . 2015 , and references therein ) . _ ( i ) the common envelope channel _ although a physically realistic 3-d hydrodynamic simulation of ce evolution has not yet been carried out , a reasonably good approximation of the effects of the process can presumably be obtained from first principles using energy conservation . as the companion star moves at high velocity through the envelope of the giant , a fraction @xmath219 of the orbital energy is transferred to the tenuous envelope material . the companion star then spirals inward and more and more energy and angular momentum are transferred to the giant envelope . the gravitational potential energy that is released may be sufficient to eject the envelope . it is assumed that this process occurs on a timescale much shorter than the thermal timescale of the giant star . one of the more commonly used ce energy constraints was analyzed by dewi & tauris ( 2000 ) . it is given by @xmath220 \label{eqn : ce}\ ] ] where @xmath221 , @xmath222 , and @xmath223 are the core and envelope masses of the wd progenitor , and the mass of primordial secondary , respectively ( see , e.g. , webbink 1984 ; pfahl et al . note that @xmath219 is a dimensionless measure of the efficiency of the conversion of orbital energy that goes toward unbinding the envelope of the giant ( the energy required to eject the envelope , @xmath224 , must satisfy @xmath225 ) and is usually taken to be @xmath226 . the dimensionless factor @xmath227 is intended to take into account the actual binding energy of the giant at the onset of the ce phase . it largely depends on the ratio of the core mass to the pre - ce - phase mass of the giant . values of @xmath227 have been tabulated for many different evolutionary states and masses of giants by tauris & dewi ( 2001 ) and podsiadlowski et al . ( 2003b ) . for the types of giants that could produce helium white dwarfs , @xmath227 is of order unity , normally having a value between 0.5 and 1.0 , which is possible in certain circumstances , this only makes the argument presented here more robust . ] . also note in equation ( [ eqn : ce ] ) that @xmath221 , the core mass of the giant , is approximately equal to the final white dwarf mass , @xmath8 . thus the original mass of the primary can be written as @xmath228 and its radius is given by @xmath229 . finally , @xmath230 is the separation of the white dwarf and secondary star in their mutual circular orbit after the ce phase while @xmath231 is the separation of the components of the progenitor binary . using kepler s third law , equation ( [ eqn : ce ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath232\left(\frac{r_{1,0}}{a_0}\right)=1 \label{eqn : ce2}\ ] ] where @xmath233 is a dimensionless parameter that is @xmath226 . also @xmath234 ) and @xmath235 ) are the mass ratios of the primordial and present day binaries , respectively . at the onset of ( unstable ) mass transfer , the ratio , @xmath236 , is approximately equal to the roche lobe radius of the progenitor primary divided by the primordial separation ; its value is constrained by roche geometry and can be expressed as a simple function of @xmath237 ( see , eggleton 1983 ) . given that the radius of the red giant will have a very strong dependence on @xmath238 and a very weak dependence on @xmath11 , the constraint of roche geometry allows the approximation of @xmath239 by a function of @xmath221 ( see , e.g. , rappaport et al . 1995 ) . assuming a specific value of @xmath240 , and using the observed orbital period of the binary ( @xmath241 ) and the inferred mass of the present - day companion @xmath123 ( @xmath242 ) , strong limits can be imposed on the possible values of the white dwarf mass ( we take @xmath243 ) , by solving eqn . ( [ eqn : ce2 ] ) implicitly for @xmath8 and applying the constraint that @xmath244 ( i.e. , @xmath245 ) . it is reasonable to suppose that @xmath240 will lie in the range 0.5 to 1.0 . taking the upper limit of this range for @xmath240 , we find that the only acceptable values of the core mass for kic 9164561 are @xmath246 while for kic 10727668 they are @xmath247 . assuming the lower limit of this range of @xmath240 , we find that the only acceptable values of the core mass for kic 9164561 are @xmath248 , while for kic 10727668 they are @xmath249 . these ranges of values , by definition , while the upper limits correspond to @xmath250 to take into account the fact that we are considering only primaries of masses @xmath251 so that only he wds are produced . ] of @xmath221 are clearly incompatible with the estimated values of @xmath8 for both kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 based on the cooling evolution of the white dwarfs ( see the next section ) , as well as with the empirically determined value for kic 9164561 from rvs . we conclude that for a reasonable range of common envelope efficiencies , the formation of either or both of these systems via the ce channel is rather unlikely . _ ( ii ) the algol channel _ the other channel involves stable mass transfer during the evolution of the progenitor binary . in this scenario , the star that is more massive ( the donor ) evolves more quickly and fills its roche lobe on its nuclear timescale before its less massive companion ( the accretor ) can do so . even if the mass ratio is as large as @xmath252 , it is entirely possible for the mass transfer to proceed stably , if the donor has a substantial radiative envelope ( nelson & goliasch 2014 ) . as an example of evolution that could explain the formation of the two observed systems , consider a 1.5 @xmath0 donor that has evolved beyond the tams and lies in the hertzsprung gap when it fills its roche lobe . this star can stably transfer mass to a 1.2 @xmath0 companion on approximately a nuclear and/or thermal timescale ( case ab evolution ) . at this mass transfer rate ( of @xmath3@xmath253 yr@xmath51 ) , the accretor is not likely to expand and fill its own roche lobe . during the mass transfer process , the donor can evolve up the red giant branch and form a substantial degenerate helium core . since the radius of the giant has a very strong dependence on @xmath221 but a very weak dependence on its total mass , the giant will continuously expand with a concomitant increase in the core mass until the envelope surrounding the core is so depleted ( to a mass of the order of 0.01 @xmath0 ; the remainder having been transferred to the companion star ) that it can not be sustained and ultimately collapses onto the remnant degenerate helium core . if approximately 1@xmath0 is transferred conservatively to the accretor during this process , the resulting system may then resemble either of the observed ones . details concerning the possible progenitor evolutions will be discussed in a future paper ( nangreaves et al . 2015 ) . assuming that stable mass transfer from a red giant led to the formation of the bloated helium wds in both kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 , it is possible to check whether the observed properties of the wds are consistent with cooling models of degenerate helium dwarfs . moreover , if the properties of either wd are found to be consistent , it is then possible to use it as a chronometer in order to determine the age of the binary after the termination of mass transfer , i.e. , just after the collapse of the giant to form a helium wd ( hewd ) . the study of the formation and cooling of hewds from progenitor red giants has been carried out by a number of groups ( see , e.g. , podsiadlowski et al . 2003 ; nelson et al . 2004 ; althaus et al . 2005 , 2013 ; istrate et al . we use the code described by nelson et al . ( 2004 ) to analyze the cooling evolution of very low - mass helium wds . it is assumed that the giant ( i.e. , the wd progenitor ) had a solar metallicity ( @xmath254 ) , and that its initial mass was between 1.0 and 1.5 @xmath0 . the initial hydrogen abundance ( by mass ) of the progenitor star while on the zams is taken to be equal to 0.71 and the ratio of the mixing length to the pressure scale - height ratio ( @xmath255 ) is set equal to 1.5 . the initial orbital separation was carefully selected so that only very low mass helium wds were created . diffusion ( gravitational settling and radiative levitation ) was not included in the computations because diffusion is a very fragile physical process that can be negated by turbulence in the outer layers of these rapidly rotating ( proto-)white dwarf stars . moreover , the inclusion of diffusion has little effect on the cooling times for the models of interest ( i.e. , bloated helium wds ) because these systems are very young and have not even evolved to reach their maximum surface temperatures before joining the usual wd cooling track in the hr diagram . it is only after the wds have passed through their maximum @xmath45 that the compression of the outer hydrogen - rich layers , due to contraction , can cause the residual hydrogen to start to burn , leading to a rapid expansion of the outer layers as a result of a thermonuclear runaway ( tnr ) . in figure [ fig : cooling ] , we show the results of the cooling evolution of several models that have masses near or smaller than the tnr lower mass limit , i.e. , @xmath256 . the evolution of the radius of the wd is shown as a function of its effective temperature , @xmath45 . when the envelope of the progenitor giant collapses , the radius of the proto - wd continually decreases , as long as no tnrs occur , until it asymptotically reaches its zero - temperature radius . the surface temperature of the object initially increases ( this increasing temperature defines the proto - wd phase ) until it reaches a maximum value of @xmath45 where it then follows a cooling track and asymptotically approaches zero temperature . assuming that the white dwarfs in both kic 9164561 and kic 10727668 formed according to the scenario discussed above , we can infer reasonably precise values of the mass based on the observed radii and @xmath45 values superposed on the cooling tracks ( see fig . [ fig : cooling ] ) . we find that the mass of the wd in kic 9164561 is @xmath257 , and that of the wd in kic 10727668 is @xmath258 . these masses agree with those inferred from the cooling evolutions of althaus et al . ( 2013 ) to within 5 to 10% ( their values of the mass being smaller ) , and to within @xmath259% for the values inferred from the work of istrate et al . we also carried out this same type of wd cooling calculations with the mesa code ( paxton et al . 2011 ) and found very similar results . the ages of these objects as measured from the cessation of mass transfer are approximately 925 myr and 950 myr , respectively . if the companion star in kic 9164561 has a mass of @xmath260 , then the time required to reduce its average density to the inferred value of 0.17 g @xmath42 is in good agreement with the theoretical predictions for the evolution of a solar metallicity star . the orbital period predicted by our models is approximately 1.7 days , but it should be noted that our assumptions about the degree of mass conservation during the mass - transfer phase and the magnitude of angular momentum losses leading to the formation of the giant are not precisely known , and this uncertainty could have a significant impact on the final value of the orbital period . as for kic 10727668 , the predicted orbital period from our models almost matches the observed one . however , the predicted age and somewhat higher mass of the companion star are very problematic because the observationally inferred average density implies that the companion star has not significantly evolved from its initial position on the zams . based on the implied cooling age of the system and a mass of 2.2 @xmath0 , we would expect the star to be much closer to the tams with a correspondingly lower density ( contrary to what is implied in figure 3 ) . if the mass of the companion were substantially less ( say , @xmath671.7 @xmath0 ) , then a wd composed primarily of helium and with a mass of @xmath261 would be entirely compatible with the observations . based on the cooling evolution , we conclude that the theoretical models for the evolution of kic 9164561 lead to properties that agree well with the observationally inferred properties . the predictions for kic 10727668 are problematic , especially given the implied cooling age of the white dwarf in the system . for an age in the range of 100200 myr , a white dwarf mass of @xmath262 ( inferred from the doppler boosting effect ; see sect . [ sec : db ] ) , and @xmath263 , it is very difficult to model the properties with any type of solar metallicity hewd . to understand why this is true , consider the evolutionarily limiting case for which all of the hydrogen has been stripped from the atmosphere and envelope of the hewd . based on the wd cooling tracks of nelson & davis ( 2000 ) , a 0.27 @xmath0 wd of this type can reach a temperature of 14,000k at either of two ages : ( i ) considerably less than 10 myr ; or , ( ii ) @xmath264 myr . the luminosity of the wd for the latter case is two orders of magnitude smaller than what is inferred ( see table [ tab : sys ] ) and can be automatically ruled out . for the other solution ( corresponding to the early - wd phase before the maximum @xmath45 is reached ) , the luminosity is approximately correct but a cooling age of only several million years after the birth of the wd seems to be unacceptably small based on probability arguments . if a thick layer of hydrogen were to be added to the envelope , the cooling would be slowed but incompatibilities with the observations would persist . for example , the luminosity of the hewd while it is still young would be considerably higher and it would likely undergo a tnr . perhaps we are observing the hewd while it is undergoing one of its tnr cycles ; the probability of observing it at this epoch may be unacceptably small . another possible explanation might be a difference in the actual metallicity from that which we assumed ; however , making the metallicity smaller generally makes the incompatibilities larger . thus if the mass of the wd in kic 10727668 is actually about 0.27 @xmath0 , then it might have been derived from a higher mass progenitor ( @xmath265 ) or perhaps via a different evolutionary pathway than we have considered here . we plan to investigate all of these possibilities in a future paper . for the sake of completeness , we have included the robust measurements of effective temperatures and radii of eight other eclipsing or tidally distorted , extremely - low mass wds ( found in double degenerate systems ; see hermes et al . the observations are plotted in fig . [ fig : cooling ] as open blue circles . it should be noted that these additional wds have properties that are reasonably similar to the six hot wds found by kepler except that they are typically less bloated . based on the cooling models , we expect the masses of all of these systems to reside in the range of 0.15 - 0.25 @xmath0 , which is generally consistent with the values reported in hermes et al . ( 2014 ) . finally , in this regard , we note that these white dwarfs have a very different evolutionary scenario from the systems examined in our work in that they are likely the result of two common - envelope episodes . here we examine very briefly what the future holds for systems such as koi 74 , koi 81 , koi 1224 , koi 1375 , kic 9164561 , and kic 10727668 . when these systems evolve to the point where the primary a star fills its roche lobe and commences mass transfer onto the white dwarf , their he core masses will range from 0.19 to 0.27@xmath266 for the shortest ( kic 9164561 ) and longest ( koi 81 ) orbital periods of these systems , respectively ( as estimated using eqn . ( [ eqn : mwd_p2 ] ) ) . once the mass transfer onto the white dwarf begins , it will be dynamically unstable due to the very large mass ratio ( typically 10:1 ) , and a common envelope will ensue . using eqn . ( [ eqn : ce ] ) , we can compute an approximate expression for the ratio of the final orbital separation to the initial orbital separation , and we find : @xmath267 where @xmath8 is the mass of the hot white dwarfs being studied in these systems , @xmath222 and @xmath221 will be the envelope and core mass of the a star when it evolves to fill its roche lobe , @xmath268 , @xmath240 is the common envelope parameter of order unity discussed above , and @xmath269 is the roche - lobe radius of the a star in units of the orbital separation ( with an expected numerical value of @xmath270 ) . if we apply eqn . ( [ eqn : aoai ] ) to estimate the final orbital separation that will result from this upcoming common envelope phase , we find that @xmath271 . the current orbital separations of the six bloated hot white dwarfs in the _ kepler _ field range from 6.4 to 48@xmath272 . from this we can infer that the final orbital separations will be @xmath273 , for kic 9164561 to koi 81 , respectively . all of these will be binaries comprised of two roughly equal mass white dwarfs each of @xmath274 , if the core of the a star does not merge with the initial low - mass white dwarf in the system . the corresponding orbital periods and roche - lobe radii would range from 3/4 to 14 min , and @xmath275 , respectively . all but the largest of these roche - lobe radii are too small to harbor the white dwarf cores that will be unveiled by the common envelope . thus , we conclude that the orbital periods of the group of double degenerate systems recently studied by brown et al . ( 2014 ) and hermes et al . ( 2014 ) result from much wider systems . this is emphasized by the fact that the masses of the primary in the double degenerate binaries in the latter studies are typically much more massive than would result from the six binaries containing bloated hot white dwarfs in the _ kepler _ field . in this study we report two new low - mass , thermally bloated , hot white dwarfs in binary systems with companion a stars . the systems are similar in their basic nature to those in koi 74 , koi 81 , koi 1224 , and koi 1375 . this brings to six the total number of such systems in the _ kepler _ field . of the six systems , the two new systems have the shortest orbital periods at 1.27 d and 2.3 d , while kic 9164561 has the largest , i.e. , the most thermally bloated , of the six white dwarfs its white dwarf has a radius that is 14 times larger than its fully degenerate radius it is more than 1/2 @xmath116 in _ diameter _ ! the mass of the white dwarf in kic 9164561 is 0.197 @xmath31 0.005 @xmath0 and is determined from direct rv measurements of the primary a star as well as some inferences about the mass of the a star ( i.e. , the mean density and @xmath45 lead to an estimate for @xmath123 ) . by contrast , the mass of the white dwarf in kic 10727668 is more uncertain at 0.27 @xmath31 0.03 @xmath0 . since there are no rv measurements of this fainter system , we relied on measurements of the doppler boosting effect to determine the orbital velocity of the a star . the accuracy of this latter mass is not quite sufficient for detailed comparisons with binary evolution or white - dwarf cooling models . we strongly advocate that a larger telescope be used to determine an accurate rv for this system . binary evolution scenarios involving two low - mass , e.g. , @xmath67 1.1 and 1.5 @xmath0 , primordial stars that undergo stable , conservative mass transfer can nicely explain the current mass and evolutionary state of both the companion star and the hot white dwarf in kic 9164561 . for this system , we estimate an age of @xmath3925 myr since the envelope of the white dwarf progenitor was transferred to the current a star . by contrast , it is more difficult to explain the current state of both the a star and its white dwarf companion in kic 10727668 . if the white dwarf actually has a mass as high as is indicated by the doppler boosting technique ( i.e. , 0.27 @xmath0 ) then it is difficult to understand how the white dwarf can still be so thermally bloated . if , on the other hand , we take the uncertainty seriously , and allow for a mass as low as , say , 0.22 @xmath0 , then there is still a discrepancy between the inferred cooling age of @xmath67 950 myr , and the apparent location of the a star in the hr diagram which is still near the zams . the growing statistical ensemble of these systems should make it worthwhile to ( 1 ) make renewed attempts to measure the rvs in four of the remaining bloated hot white dwarf systems in order to better determine @xmath8 , and ( 2 ) directly model the binary evolution of such systems with a code that can evolve two stars _ simultaneously _ , e.g. , mesa ( paxton et al . 2011 ) . _ note added in manuscript _ : after this work was completed we became aware of an impressive collection of 18 similar bloated hot white dwarf systems found in the wasp photometric database ( maxted et al . 2013 ; 2014 ; and references therein ) . two of these have accurate measurements of the mass , radius , and @xmath45 for the bloated hot white dwarf and show multi - periodic pulsations . these are now also shown in fig . [ fig : cooling ] . we are grateful to the entire _ kepler _ team for making this study possible . we thank jon swift for taking exploratory spectra of kic 10727668 to see if rv measurements can be acquired in the future , and dave latham for his early contribution to this project . the rv observations were made with the nordic optical telescope , operated by the nordic optical telescope scientific association at the observatorio del roque de los muchachos , la palma , spain , of the instituto de astrofisica de canarias . we gratefully acknowledge that two of the rv points were acquired by pilar montaes - rodrguez , and an additional one was obtained during time allocated to hans j. deeg . we thank antonio frasca of catania astrophysical observatory for some important tips in combining the model spectra . mattia gandolfi was quite inspirational for this work . we are grateful for the cat and not service time awarded to this project , and to the staff members at the not for their valuable and unique support during the observations . this research was supported in part by the mineco esp2013 - 48391-c4 - 2-r grant . thanks the natural sciences and engineering research council ( nserc ) of canada for financial support , calcul qubec for providing computing facilities , and ernie dubeau and heather nangreaves for technical assistance . r.s.o . acknowledges nasa support through the kepler participating scientist program . this research has made use of the nasa exoplanet archive , which is operated by the california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration under the exoplanet exploration program . the data presented in this article were obtained from the mikulski archive for space telescopes ( mast ) . stsci is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 . support for mast for non - hst data is provided by the nasa office of space science via grant nnx09af08 g and by other grants and contracts . we made use of j - band images that were obtained with the united kingdom infrared telescope ( ukirt ) which is operated by the joint astronomy centre on behalf of the science and technology facilities council of the u.k . brown , w.r . , kilic , m. , allende prieto , c. , gianninas , a. , & kenyon , s. 2013 , apj , 769 , 66 allende prieto c. , barklem p. s. , lambert d. l. , cunha k. , 2004 , a&a , 420 , 183 althaus , l.g . , serenelli , a.m. , panei , j.a . , crsico , a.h . , garca - berro , e. , & scccola , c.g . 2005 a&a , 435 , 631 althaus , l.g . , miller bertolami , m.m . , crsico , a.h . 2013 , a&a , 435 , 631 applegate , j.h . 1992 , apj , 385 , 621 applegate , j.h . , & patterson , j. 1987 , apj , 322 , l99 barnes , s.a . 2007 , apj , 669 , 1167 batalha , n. , et al . 2010 , apj , 713 , l109 bloemen , s. , marsh , t.r . , degroote , p. , et al . 2012 , mnras , 422 , 2600 breton , r. , rappaport , s. , van kerkwijk , m.h . , & carter , j.a . 2012 , apj , 748 , 115 bruntt , h. , bedding , t.r . , quirion , p .- o . , et al . 2010 , , 405 , 1907 buchhave , l.a . , bakos , g.a . , hartman , j.d . , et al . 2010 , apj , 720 , 1118 carter , j.a . , rappaport , s. , & fabrycky , d. 2011 , apj , 728 , 139 castelli , f. & kurucz , r.l . 2004 , eprint arxiv : astro - ph/0405087 conroy , k. e. , pra , a. , stassun , k. g. , et al . 2014 , , 147 , 45 eggleton , p.p . 1983 , apj , 268 , 368 ehrenreich , d. , lagrange , a .- m . , bouchy , f. et al . 2011 , a&a , 525 , a85 . frandsen , s. & lindberg , b. 1999 , in `` astrophysics with the not '' , proceedings eds : karttunen , h. & piirola , v. , anot . conf , 71 gandolfi , d. , alcal , j.m . , leccia , s. , et al . 2008 , , 687 , 1303 gandolfi , d. , parviainen , h. , fridlund , m. , et al . 2013 , a&a , 557 , 74 gray , r.o . & corbally , c.j . 1994 , aj , 107 , 742 gray , d.e . 2005 , ` the observation and analysis of stellar photospheres ' , ( uk : cambridge university press ) . han , z. , podsiadlowski , ph . , maxted , p.f.l . , marsh , t.r . , & ivanova , n. 2002 , mnras , 336 , 449 han , z. , podsiadlowski , ph . , maxted , p.f.l . , & marsh , t.r . 2003 , mnras , 341 , 669 hermes , j.j . , brown , w.r . , kilic , m. , et al . 2014 , apj , 792 , 39 holman , m.j . , winn , j.n . , latham , d.w . 2006 , apj , 652 , 1715 huber , d. , silva aguirre , v. , matthews , j. m. , et al . 2014 , apjs , 211 , 2 iben , i. , tutukov , a.v . , & yungelson , l.r . 1995 , apjs , 100 , 233 istrate , a.g . , tauris , t.m . , langer , m. , & antoniadis , j. 2014 , a&a , in press joss , p.c . , & rappaport , s. 1983 , nature , 304 , 419 kotze , m.m . , & charles , p.a . 2010 , mnras , 402 , l16 kirk , b. , pra , a. et al . 2015 , in preparation . lin , j. , rappaport , s. , podsiadlowski , ph . , nelson , l. , paxton , b. , & todorov , p. 2011 , apj , 732 , 70l loeb , a. , & gaudi , b.s . 2003 , apj , 588 , l117 matijevic , g. , prsa , a. , orosz , j.a . , welsh , w. , bloemen , s. , & barclay , t. 2012 , aj , 143 , 123 marsh , t.r . , nelemans , g. , & steeghs , d. 2004 , mnras , 350 , 113 maxted , p.f.l . , serenelli , a.m. , miglio , a. , et al . 2013 , nature , 498 , 463 . maxted , p.f.l . , serenelli , a.m. , marsh , t.r . , cataln , s. , mahtani , d.p . , & dhillon , v.s . 2014 , mnras , 444 , 208 morris , s.l . , & naftilan , s.a . 1993 , apj , 419 , 344 . nangreaves , h. , nelson , l. et al . 2015 , in preparation nelemans , g. 2010 , ap&ss , 329 , 25 nelson , l. & rappaport , s. 2003 , apj , 598 , 431 nelson , c. & eggleton , p.p . 2001 , apj , 552 , 664 nelson , l.a . , dubeau , e. , & maccannell , k.a . 2004 , apj , 616 , 1124 nelson , l.a . , & goliasch , j. 2014 , in preparation paxton , b. , bildsten , l. , dotter , a. , herwig , f. , lesaffre , p. , & timmes , f. 2011 , apjs , 192 , 3 paczyski , b. 1983 , nature , 304 , 421 pfahl , e. , rappaport , s. , & podsiadlowski , ph . 2003 , 597 , 1036 podsiadlowski , ph . , han , z. , & rappaport , s. 2003a , mnras , 340 , 1214 podsiadlowski , ph . , rappaport , s. , & han , z. 2003b , mnras , 341 , 385 rappaport , s. , di stefano , r. , & smith , j.d . 1994 , apj , 426 , 692 rappaport , s. , podsiadlowski , ph . , joss , p.c . , de stefano , r. , & han , z. 1995 , mnras , 273 , 731 rappaport , s. , deck , k. , levine , a. , borkovits , t. , carter , j. , el mellah , i. , sanchis - ojeda , r. , & kalomeni , b. 2013 , apj , 768 , 33 rowe , j. , borucki , w. , koch , d. , et al . 2010 , apj , 713 , 150 sanchis - ojeda , r. , rappaport , s. , winn , j.n . , levine , a. , kotson , m.c . , latham , d.w . , & buchhave , l.a . 2013 , apj , 774 , 54 savonije , g.j . 1983 , nature , 304 , 422 savonije , g.j . 1987 , nature , 325 , 416 seager , s. , & malln - ornelas , g. 2003 , apj , 585 , 1038 smith , j.c . , et al . 2012 , pasp , stumpe , m.c . , van cleve , j.e . , et al . 124 , 1000 stumpe , m.c . , smith , j.c . , van cleve , j.e . , et al . 2012 , pasp , 124 , 985 taam , r.e . , bodenheimer , p. , & ostriker , j.p . 1978 , apj , 222 , 269 taam , r.e . & bodenheimer , p. 1992 , in `` nato advanced research workshop on x - ray binaries and the formation of binary and millisecond radio pulsars '' , p. 281 tauris , t.m . & dewi , j.d.m . 2001 , a&a , 369 , 170 tauris , t.m . & van den heuvel , e.p.j . 2014 , apj , 781 , 13 telting , j.h . , avila , g. , buchhave , l. , et al . 2014 , an , 335 , 41 tran , k. , levine , a. , rappaport , s. , borkovits , t. , csizmadia , sz . , & kalomeni , b. 2013 , apj , 774 , 81 . van kerkwijk , m.h . , rappaport , s. , breton , r. , justham , s. , podsiadlowski , ph . , & han , z. 2010 , apj , 715 , 51 verbunt , f. , & zwaan , k. 1981 , a&a , 100 , l7 webbink , r.f . 1984 , apj , 277 , 355 yi , s. , demarque , p. , kim , y .- c . , lee , y .- w . , ree , c. h. , lejeune , t. , & barnes , s. 2001 , apjs , 136 , 417 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: turbulence is a generic phenomenon observed in the relaxation dynamics of many - body systems far from thermal equilibrium @xcite . it comprises a quasi - stationary flow of energy within certain inertial regimes in momentum space @xcite . correlation functions like the energy spectrum and higher momenta of the velocity distribution exhibit universality and scaling @xcite . this , and quasistationarity are the key characteristics rendering turbulence a nonthermal fixed point of the system s dynamics . in quantum many - body systems , from the formation of bose - einstein condensates in ultracold gases to quark - gluon plasmas produced in heavy - ion collisions and reheating after early - universe inflation , nonequilibrium dynamics governs many interesting phenomena . in this context , turbulence during thermalization is being studied with increasing effort @xcite . a nonthermal fixed point of the evolution of a many - body system has the potential to strongly affect the equilibration process by forcing the evolution to critically slow down before the system can thermalize . new scaling laws were found by analyzing non - perturbative quantum field dynamic equations @xcite . analogous predictions for a dilute ultracold bose gas were given in @xcite , proposing strong matter - wave turbulence in the regime of long - range excitations . superfluid turbulence , also referred to as quantum turbulence ( qt ) has been the subject of extensive studies in the context of helium @xcite and dilute bose gases @xcite . in contrast to eddies in classical fluids , vorticity in a superfluid is quantized @xcite , and the creation and annihilation processes of quantized vortices are distinctly different @xcite . the observation of a kolmogorov 5/3-law @xcite in experiments with superfluid helium @xcite received much attention @xcite . in particular , the role of the normal - fluid as compared to the superfluid component in the turbulent flow is under debate @xcite . superfluid turbulence plays an important role in the context of the kinetics of condensation and the development of long - range order in a dilute bose gas . this , as well as turbulence in its acoustic excitations has been discussed in refs . a possible observation of qt in ultracold atomic gases presently poses an exciting task for experiments @xcite . here we emphasize that the experimental study of superfluid turbulence and , more generally , of nonthermal fixed points in ultracold bose gases has strong potential implications for many other areas of physics . besides vortical excitations this also includes other ( quasi-)topological excitations such as solitary waves in one - dimensional gases . a satisfactory ab - initio mathematical description of both quantum and classical turbulence is inherently difficult due to the strong correlations building up within the system . analytical results are known , however , in regimes where kinetic theory applies : in a dilute , degenerate bose gas the normal - fluid component can vary at the expense or gain of the superfluid part . as a consequence , the gas is compressible and so - called weak wave - turbulence phenomena can occur for which scaling laws can be derived by analyzing kinetic equations @xcite . generically , however , the description in terms of wave kinetic equations such as the quantum boltzmann equation breaks down in the infrared ( ir ) regime of long wavelengths . for a bose gas in this regime , single - particle occupation numbers grow large and the description in terms of , for example , elastic two - to - two collisions becomes unreliable . in the infrared limit , so - called strong wave turbulence is expected to occur . recent developments presented in refs . @xcite allow one to set up a unifying description of scaling , both in the ultraviolet ( uv ) quantum boltzmann kinetic regime and in the infrared limit . in the ir regime , new scaling laws were found for a relativistic scalar field by analyzing non - perturbative kadanoff - baym dynamic equations with respect to nonthermal stationary solutions @xcite . in this article , we present the details of our studies of the relaxation of two and three dimensional dilute bose gases through stages of superfluid turbulence and the approach of a nonthermal fixed point , by means of simulations in the classical - wave limit of the underlying quantum field theory . in section [ sec : dyncritpoints ] , we summarize the quantum - field theoretical predictions of refs . @xcite , in particular for the scaling exponents of the single - particle momentum distribution and compare these with the numerically determined scaling . while we find excellent agreement , our results provide an interpretation of the nonthermal fixed points proposed in refs . @xcite for the case of an ultracold bose gas : the appearance of nonperturbative infrared scaling reflects the presence of statistically independent vortices , as previously reported in brief in ref . @xcite , see also figs . [ fig:2dphase512]-[fig : modeoccupation3g8 ] . this phenomenon appears to be distinctly different from the weak wave turbulence we observe in the uv part of the spectrum . in section [ sec : randomvortexmodel ] , we describe a model of independent as well as pair - correlated vortical excitations @xcite which allows the more refined interpretation of the scaling behavior during the different stages of the evolution presented in section [ sec : results ] . we show that the stationary scaling is maintained by the presence of energy ( uv ) and particle ( ir ) fluxes , further supporting the analytic theory . in section [ sec : vorticesand ] , we study the power - law distributions of the compressible and incompressible contributions to the flow pattern . this adds to the clear understanding of the bimodal scaling laws in the overall momentum spectrum . ir power - law spectra of subdominant compressible excitations suggest the presence of acoustic turbulence @xcite on the top of the vorticity - bearing quasicondensate . in comparison with recent experiments and analytical predictions , the velocity field probability distribution as well as the velocity statistics of individual vortices are studied . this observable is of great interest , since it has recently been used to experimentally verify a distinction between classical and quantum turbulence @xcite . we finally show that the complete decay of the turbulent scaling is anticipated by the appearance of weaker ir power laws reflecting vortex - antivortex pairing correlations . we begin with a brief summary of the analytical and numerical results on dynamical fixed points and matter - wave turbulence reported in refs . @xcite before we discuss these results in terms of a statistical model of vortex excitations . motivated by the original work presented in ref . @xcite nonthermal fixed points of kadanoff - baym dynamic equations for time - dependent green functions were analysed , for the case of an ultracold bose gas , in ref . @xcite . at these fixed points of the dynamical evolution of the system , the single - particle momentum distribution @xmath0 becomes ( quasi-)stationary , @xmath1 . it furthermore exhibits a characteristic universal power - law behavior , i.e. , it scales according to @xmath2 in a certain regime of momenta @xmath3 . here @xmath4 is some positive , real number and @xmath5 a universal exponent which was determined from the dynamic equations for the field correlation functions . different exponents resulted in different momentum regimes . exponents valid in the ultraviolet regime of large @xmath6 were found to correspond to well - known fixed points of weak wave turbulence @xcite in the respective systems . in addition to these , new , larger exponents were predicted in the infrared regime of small @xmath6 on the basis of a non - perturbative analysis of the kadanoff - baym dynamic equations derived from the two - particle - irreducible ( 2pi ) effective action @xcite . simulations of the classical field equations for a relativistic @xmath7-symmetric scalar model , for @xmath8 , confirmed the existence of the analytically derived scalings in the infrared regime @xcite . as reported in ref . @xcite , corresponding simulations were performed for an ultracold , degenerate bose gas in two and three spatial dimensions which demonstrated that for these systems the infrared scalings predicted in @xcite reflect and are caused by the presence of quantized vortical excitations of the superfluid . in this way , the nonthermal fixed points can be related in a clear manner to topological excitations of the interacting coherent matter - wave field which shows that both , weak wave turbulence and macroscopic , topological excitations of the field can be described within a unified field - theoretic approach . differently expressed , both , weak turbulent flow and non - linear solitary bulk excitations are described in a unified manner as representing a nonthermal critical fixed point of the system . in turn , the approach also implies that superfluid turbulence can be studied in a new way , in the frame of a universal quantum field theoretical approach . we remark that the relation between the new infrared exponents and topological excitations of the background ( i.e. , condensate ) field gains further support by the topological pattern formation described in ref . @xcite for a relativistic @xmath9-symmetric scalar model , which serves as a particular model for the reheating period after early - universe inflation . we will discuss in detail vortical excitations in a degenerate bose gas and their relation to the above nonthermal fixed points . before this we summarize briefly the relevant results of refs . @xcite . to be specific , throughout this article we consider an ultracold bose gas of atoms in @xmath10 , @xmath11 space dimensions interacting through @xmath4-wave collisions which is described by the hamiltonian @xmath12 \,,\ ] ] where the time and space dependent fields @xmath13 satisfy bose commutation relations , and where the coupling @xmath14 in three dimensions is defined in terms of the @xmath4-wave scattering length @xmath15 . here and in the following we set @xmath16 , see appendix [ app : classfields ] for more details . suppose the generic case that for sufficiently large momenta @xmath17 occupation numbers @xmath18 are small enough such that for a given coupling @xmath19 the quantum boltzmann equation ( qbe ) @xmath20 , \label{eq : kinscattint}\end{aligned}\ ] ] describes the evolution of @xmath21 under the effects of collisions . in our case , the transition matrix element squared @xmath22 is a numerical constant proportional to @xmath23 and thus independent of momenta . zeroes of the scattering integral @xmath24 correspond to fixed points of the time evolution within the regime of applicability of the qbe @xcite . most prominent amongst these are the thermal fixed point corresponding to the system in thermal equilibrium and the trivial fixed point where the occupation number is independent of @xmath3 . at both fixed points the scattering integral vanishes and @xmath0 becomes independent of @xmath25 . note that both , the trivial distribution and the thermal bose - einstein distribution in the rayleigh - jeans regime , for @xmath26 , show a power - law behavior of the form ( [ eq : scale ] ) with @xmath27 and @xmath28 , respectively . the theory of weak wave turbulence @xcite allows to analytically derive further , nonthermal fixed points at which the occupation number @xmath29 obeys a scaling law of the form ( [ eq : scale ] ) and , in general , @xmath30 . as in classical turbulence of an incompressible fluid one assumes that universal scaling appears within a certain regime of momenta , the inertial range . according to this picture , outside the scaling regime kinetic energy enters the system from an external source and/or is dissipated into heat , whereas there are no sources and sinks within the inertial interval . instead , kinetic energy is transported from momentum shell to momentum shell without loss or gain . to a good approximation , this process is described by a continuity equation in momentum space , with a momentum - independent , radially oriented current vector . a central aspect of weak - wave - turbulence theory is that the qbe can be cast into different such equations @xcite , for the radial number density @xmath31 and the energy density @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 depending on whether the radial particle current @xmath35 or energy current @xmath36 is taken to be independent of @xmath37 , one derives different scaling exponents . the resulting exponents are @xmath38 these exponents can be obtained by simple power counting : combining eqs . ( [ eq : qkineq ] ) and ( [ eq : baleqq ] ) gives the radial relation @xmath39 which implies that stationarity requires @xmath40 to become @xmath37-independent , i.e. scale like @xmath41 . counting all powers of @xmath37 in @xmath42 , eq . ( [ eq : kinscattint ] ) , in the wave - kinetic regime where the terms of third order in the occupation numbers dominate the scattering integral , this requires @xmath43 . analogously one infers the exponent @xmath44 from the balance equation ( [ eq : baleqp ] ) for the energy density @xmath45 . despite this simple procedure , the existence of the respective scaling solutions has to and can be derived rigorously from the qbe by means of zakharov conformal integral transforms @xcite . we note that , similar to classical turbulence , the case @xmath10 is special , where the scaling exponent @xmath46 equals that of a thermal distribution in the rayleigh - jeans regime . given a positive scaling exponent @xmath5 momentum occupation numbers @xmath47 grow large in the ir regime of small @xmath37 . as a consequence , for a given coupling @xmath19 , the qbe fails in this regime , where contributions to the scattering integral @xmath42 which are of higher order than @xmath48 become important . to find scaling solutions in the ir , an approach beyond kinetic theory is required . this is available through quantum - field dynamic equations derived from the two - particle irreducible ( 2pi ) effective action or @xmath49-functional @xcite beyond the 2-loop order in the expansion of the self - energy . see ref . @xcite for details of the procedure summarized in the following . the 2pi equations include the dyson equation for the time - ordered green function @xmath50 ( here , we use four - vector notation @xmath51 ) , from which a time evolution equation ( [ eq : qkineq ] ) for @xmath29 is derived . as before one considers zeros of the scattering integral which in the dynamic theory reads @xmath52 . \label{eq : stationarity}\ ] ] here , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 and @xmath55 are the spectral and statistical components of @xmath56 , respectively , defined in coordinate space by @xmath57 , @xmath58\rangle$ ] , @xmath59 . the corresponding contributions to the self energy @xmath60 are defined in terms of @xmath56 through a loop expansion of the 2pi effective action , see fig . [ fig:2pi ] . resumming an infinite set of such loop diagrams contributing to the 2pi effective action @xcite leads to a non - perturbative , effectively renormalized coupling in the dynamic equations @xcite . to derive the scaling solutions of the dynamic equations for green functions @xmath61 one assumes separate scaling of its spectral and statistical components according to @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 . here , @xmath65 is the dynamical scaling exponent accounting for a different scaling in @xmath66 as compared to @xmath3 . the scaling exponent @xmath5 is related to @xmath67 by @xmath68 . @xmath67 is derived from the condition that the scattering integral ( [ eq : stationarity ] ) vanishes , making use of zakharov transformations , while the anomalous scaling exponent @xmath69 remains undetermined by this and , for the first , can be assumed to vanish for the @xmath10 and @xmath11 dimensional cases considered in this paper . the ir scaling exponents for radial quasiparticle flow ( @xmath70 ) and radial energy flow ( @xmath71 ) in @xmath72 dimensions were predicted in ref . @xcite to be @xmath73 in situations where a quasiparticle picture applies the dynamical exponent @xmath65 corresponds to the homogeneity index of @xmath66 : @xmath74 . in this case the nonperturbatively resummed effective coupling can be related to the diagonal elements of an effective many - body @xmath75-matrix , @xmath76 in the kinetic boltzmann formulation . in the scaling regimes this scales as @xmath77|$ ] , @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is some constant which fine - tunes the position of the transition from uv to ir scaling : for small @xmath80 and @xmath81 one recovers the uv case discussed in the previous section , i.e. , @xmath82 is a constant independent of @xmath37 . for large @xmath80 , the second term in the denominator dominates which , assuming scaling of @xmath83 , implies a power - law behavior @xmath84 and , in turn , the modified scaling ( [ eq : kappair ] ) of @xmath85 in the infrared regime of small wave numbers as compared to the uv regime discussed before . physically , the renormalized @xmath75-matrix implies a reduction of the effective interaction strength in the ir regime of strongly occupied modes @xcite . as a consequence , single - particle occupation numbers rise , towards smaller wave numbers , in an even steeper way than in the weak - turbulence regime . at the time shown in fig . [ fig:2dphase512 ] . @xmath37 is in lattice units , see app . [ app : classfields ] . note the double - logarithmic scale . the development of a ir scaling with @xmath86 coincides with the presence of superfluid vortices , with additional wave - turbulent or thermal background short - wavelength fluctuations in the uv . dashed lines indicate the filling of the initially occupied modes with @xmath87.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] at the time shown in fig . [ fig:2dphase512 ] . @xmath37 is in lattice units , see app . [ app : classfields ] . note the double - logarithmic scale . the development of a ir scaling with @xmath86 coincides with the presence of superfluid vortices , with additional wave - turbulent or thermal background short - wavelength fluctuations in the uv . dashed lines indicate the filling of the initially occupied modes with @xmath87.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] for the snapshot in fig . [ fig : phase512 ] . @xmath37 is in lattice units . note the double - logarithmic scale . the development of a ir scaling @xmath88 coincides with the presence of superfluid vortex lines . dashed lines indicate the filling of the initially occupied modes with @xmath87.,scaledwidth=41.0% ] for the snapshot in fig . [ fig : phase512 ] . @xmath37 is in lattice units . note the double - logarithmic scale . the development of a ir scaling @xmath88 coincides with the presence of superfluid vortex lines . dashed lines indicate the filling of the initially occupied modes with @xmath87.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] we now briefly review the relation between wave - turbulent scaling and the appearance of vortical excitations in an ultracold degenerate bose gas . in @xcite the results of semiclassical simulations of the gas dynamics were reported , obtained by solving the classical field equation @xmath89 \phi(\mathbf{x},t)\ ] ] in a box with periodic boundary conditions . see appendix [ app : classfields ] for details on the simulations and on lattice units . the initial field @xmath90 was prepared by macroscopically populating a few of the lowest momentum modes in the computation such that the resulting condensate density in configuration space varied between zero and some maximum value . quantum noise is taken into account by adding a small random contribution to each field mode . vortical excitations were created in large numbers , within shock - waves forming during the non - linear evolution of the coherent matter - wave field . [ fig:2dphase512 ] shows an example of the condensate phase distribution over a numerical lattice in @xmath10 dimensions , with vortices and antivortices indicated by white crosses and circles , respectively . [ fig : phase512 ] depicts the location of vortex - ring cores in a @xmath91-dimensional system . for videos of the evolution see @xcite . both figures show a snapshot of the system at some time after the vortical excitations have formed . at these times , in @xmath10 , part of the vortex - antivortex pairs have re - annihilated with each other already , and in @xmath91 some of the rings have undergone reconnections and also disappeared by shrinking to zero size . runs were repeated many times ( @xmath92 times in @xmath10 and @xmath93 times in @xmath91 ) for an ensemble of initial configurations differing by statistical noise . the number of runs was chosen such that the statistical error arising from run - to - run fluctuations was reduced to a value on the order of the size of the symbols used in the figures . in the regime of momenta with large occupation numbers where quantum statistical fluctuations play little role , correlation functions like the spectrum @xmath80 could be computed in a quasi exact way by averaging at a given time over the ensemble . in this way , the flow was analysed in terms of the ensemble- and angle - averaged single - particle spectrum @xmath94 as a function of radial momentum @xmath78 . [ fig:2dmodeoccupation ] and [ fig : modeoccupation3g8 ] show this spectrum for @xmath10 and @xmath11 , at the times chosen in figs . [ fig:2dphase512 ] and [ fig : phase512 ] , respectively . most importantly , these spectra show scaling , eq . ( [ eq : scale ] ) , within a range of momenta between about the maximum of the initially occupied momentum modes indicated by the vertical lines and @xmath95 in lattice units . the exponent @xmath5 is in agreement with the field theoretical prediction @xmath96 given in eq . ( [ eq : kappauv ] ) . it was found that the annihilation processes which eventually destroy the vortical structure while coherence builds up in the system are very slow and thus stabilize the scaling solution over a long time . in particular , only after the last vortex - antivortex pair has annihilated and the last ring shrunk to zero the power law @xmath97 breaks down and a thermal distribution of particles is left over . characteristic times are @xmath98 for vortex formation , @xmath99 for stabilization of the scaling solution and @xmath100 for the last vortices to annihilate . as we have seen above , the scaling of the momentum occupation numbers in the ir regime of large wave numbers , predicted within a non - perturbative analysis of strong wave - turbulence , correspond , for @xmath101- and @xmath11-dimensional degenerate bose gases , to the appearance of macroscopic vortical excitations . in the following , we analyse the observed scaling spectra by comparing them to the single - particle momentum distributions for a set of randomly positioned point vortices ( vortex lines ) in @xmath10 ( @xmath91 ) dimensions . we will show that uncorrelated vortices ( vortex lines ) are sufficient to yield the infrared scaling with exponent @xmath102 , see eq . ( [ eq : kappair ] ) . we will also show that beyond this , pair correlations between vortices and antivortices as well as configurations with small rings well separated from each other can give rise to a further scaling exponent deviating from @xmath102 ( see fig . [ fig : vortexsystemrandom ] ) . the point ( line ) vortex model employed here was introduced by onsager in 1949 @xcite . it describes the complex flow pattern in terms of the statistical mechanics of interacting classical point objects . this model has been constructed as a discrete vorticity approximation of classical fluid turbulence , but it is even more suitable to describe superfluid turbulence consisting of quantized vortices . further applications include plasma physics or stellar dynamics @xcite . in the following , we study the spectrum of a set of vortices , finding different scaling regimes dependent on vortex correlation functions . with this approach , nonthermal fixed points in an ultracold bose gas can be related to the statistics of vortices . numerical calculations , sampling field configurations of static randomly positioned vortices , confirm the analytical result . finally , the velocity probability distribution of a vortex - dominated flow @xcite is derived and numerically confirmed . in two dimensions , an isolated , singly quantized vortex is described by the complex field @xmath103 . as the @xmath104-dependence of the density @xmath105 only becomes important at small scales on the order of the healing length @xmath106 where our simulations are dominated by thermal excitations , we will omit it in the following and assume @xmath107 to be uniform . a system of @xmath108 vortices in @xmath10 dimensions can be defined as @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the single vortex field centered around @xmath111 . we derive the corresponding particle spectrum by considering the hydrodynamic velocity field @xmath112 . denoting the velocity field of a single vortex as @xmath113 ( see appendix [ app : singlevortex ] ) we can express the mean classical kinetic energy density of the velocity field as @xmath114 where @xmath115 defines the spatial distribution of vortices with winding number @xmath116 . here and in the following , @xmath117 denotes an ensemble average over different realizations of the classical field @xmath118 . we derive the low-@xmath37 scaling of @xmath119 from the kinetic - energy spectrum @xmath120 , given by the angle - averaged fourier transform of @xmath121 , taking into account that at low @xmath37 , the single - particle spectrum is dominated by the superfluid velocity field @xmath122 , i.e. , @xmath123 one has , from eq . ( [ eq : energyspec ] ) @xmath124 with @xmath125 ( lattice units ) , the modulus of the velocity field of a single vortex scales as @xmath126 and is radially symmetric in momentum space . hence , the angle - averaged single - particle spectrum scales like @xmath127 here , @xmath128 denotes the zeroth - order bessel function and @xmath129 is the distance between vortices @xmath130 and @xmath131 . assuming that the positions @xmath132 of the vortices are uncorrelated one can take the average over relative positions @xmath133 within the area @xmath134 , @xmath135 and , for fixed @xmath37 , the limit @xmath136 . hence , the second term in brackets in eq . ( [ eq : ve ] ) vanishes and one finally obtains the scaling @xcite @xmath137 in a two - dimensional superfluid containing vortices and antivortices an effectively attractive force between the two species can lead to pair correlations . we study a signature of this feature in the single - particle momentum spectrum by applying the point vortex model introduced above to the case of vortex - antivortex pairs . as a first step we calculate the velocity field @xmath138 for a vortex - antivortex pair with the vortex situated at @xmath139 and the antivortex at @xmath140 , @xmath141 the squared velocity field far away from the center of the pair can be obtained via a dipole approximation @xmath142 which yields the scaling @xmath143 . hence , in fourier space , the pair velocity field scales as @xmath144 for low momenta . in this regime , the vortex - antivortex pair can again be treated as a point - like object with modified velocity scaling . to obtain the infrared scaling of a set of random vortex - antivortex pairs , we define a spatial pair distribution @xmath145 , with @xmath111 denoting the center of the @xmath130-th vortex - antivortex pair . then , the analysis performed for random vortices above can be adopted . therefore , in the case of independently distributed pairs , the approach predicts the infrared scaling of the occupation number to be the same as for a single pair , i.e. @xmath146 . the considerations from sect . [ subsec : indpairs ] are only valid in the far ir ( or equivalently for pair size going to zero ) . in our numerical simulations we found , however , that for large evolution times , a finite minimum distance emerged between vortices and antivortices , and also between vortices with the same circulation , see sect . [ subsec : pairingspectrum ] . to take into account this observation and to analyse the full spectrum , we go back to writing the distribution @xmath147 as the sum of distributions @xmath148 of @xmath108 vortices and @xmath149 of @xmath108 antivortices . hence , @xmath150 with @xmath151 . this allows for a derivation of the kinetic - energy distribution in terms of correlation functions of vortex positions . we model pairing by the density - density correlation functions @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the area in which the theta function equals one . the contributions @xmath154 take into account that , besides the pairing , vortices and antivortices avoid each other in the dilute gas , keeping a minimum distance @xmath155 . this is due to vortex - vortex repulsion and fast vortex - antivortex annihilation on small distances . the functions @xmath156 cancel out in eq . ( [ eq : cf ] ) . apply for vortices and antivortices , the terms do not cancel , but the remaining term does not alter the results for pair scaling derived here . ] inserting eqs . ( [ eq : rhovrhov ] ) , ( [ eq : rhovrhoa ] ) into eq . ( [ eq : cf ] ) , evaluating the fourier transform and angular averaging gives @xmath157 the expansion of the integral for @xmath158 yields the leading - order result @xmath159 and , from eqs . ( [ eq : nkfromevk ] ) and ( [ eq : evk ] ) , the same occupation - number scaling as for independent pairs , @xmath160 at momenta @xmath161 the independent - vortex scaling @xmath86 is restored . we note that the infrared result ( [ eq : ps ] ) can also be achieved by choosing more general pair correlations of the form @xmath162^{-1}|\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x'}|^{\epsilon-2}\theta(\lambda_{\mathrm{max } } - |\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x'}| ) \theta ( |\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x'}| -\lambda_{\mathrm{min } } ) + p_{\mathbf{x},\mathbf{x}'}$ ] , with @xmath163 and @xmath164 , which is closer to our numerical observations and includes the case of a fixed `` binding length '' @xmath165 . as before , pair scaling @xmath166 is found for @xmath167 , critical scaling @xmath168 for @xmath169 , irrespective of @xmath170 . bound vortex - antivortex pairs , on a @xmath171 grid . note the double - logarithmic scale . the vortices are positioned according to the probability distribution ( [ eq : pd ] ) . at low momenta the power law is consistent with the existence of random vortex pairs @xmath172 . above @xmath173 , the distribution exhibits the scaling of an ensemble of independent vortices , @xmath174 , while at momenta larger than the healing - length scale @xmath175 one observes the vortex - core scaling @xmath176 . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] we supplement our discussion of scaling in the point vortex model with numerical data obtained by averaging over an ensemble of field configurations in @xmath10 dimensions . these configurations were constructed by multiplying uncorrelated single - vortex fields centered at positions according to the probability distribution @xmath177 with @xmath178 , where we neglect that unpaired vortices avoid each other , i.e. , choose @xmath179 . they do not represent stable solutions of the classical field equation nor do they contain sound - wave and related excitations yet which would build up through the interactions of the field and the vortices . the resulting momentum spectrum is presented in fig . [ fig : randomvortex ] . three scaling regimes can be observed . at low momenta the power law is consistent with the existence of random vortex pairs @xmath172 . above @xmath180 , choosing @xmath181 ( lattice units ) , the distribution exhibits the scaling of an ensemble of independent vortices , @xmath174 , while at momenta larger than the healing - length scale @xmath175 one observes the vortex - core scaling @xmath176 . the above results reflect that in a vortex dominated flow , particles with low momenta are found far away from vortex cores . in the case of pairing , the flow field far away from the cores is given by the field of a vortex pair , and the low - momentum scaling follows the pair - field scaling . particles closer to the vortex cores pick up a higher momentum . above @xmath173 the field will be dominated by the field of a single vortex . note that fig . [ fig : randomvortex ] shows the result of a numerical calculation in which we have sampled field configurations of random static vortices . dynamical simulations of the classical field equation eq . ( [ eq : gpe ] ) will be shown in sect . [ sec : results ] . we close with recalling the picture onsager developed in ref . @xcite of thermodynamic equilibrium states of a fixed number of vortices and antivortices in two dimensions . he used the hamiltonian of vortical flow in two dimensions @xcite , @xmath182 to describe the dynamics of a system of @xmath108 vortices in a superfluid which hence behave like a coulomb gas . here , the position of the @xmath130-th vortex is denoted as @xmath183 . due to the fact that the @xmath184 and @xmath185 coordinates of each vortex are canonical conjugates , phase space is identical with configuration space of the vortex positions . hence , for vortices moving in a volume @xmath186 the total phase space is given by @xmath187 . the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) implies that low - energy configurations feature vortices of opposite sign close to each other , whereas high - energy configurations require vortices of equal sign to group . due to these constraints , the number of configurations @xmath188 available for the system at a given energy @xmath189 decreases towards high and low energies , with a maximum at some intermediate @xmath190 . according to boltzmann , the entropy is @xmath191 and the inverse temperature @xmath192 is positive for @xmath193 and negative for @xmath194 . it follows that positive - temperature states are characterized by vortex - antivortex pairing , while negative - temperature states feature vortices of the same circulation to cluster . at the point of maximum entropy @xmath195 and infinite temperature , onsager expected a state of uncorrelated vortices and antivortices . this understanding of the nonthermal fixed point as a quasi - equilibrium state of vortices corroborates our result that the ir scaling behavior at the fixed point corresponds to the appearance of topological excitations . grid . note the double - logarithmic scale . the major and minor radius scales @xmath196 , for @xmath197 , and @xmath198 , for @xmath199 , respectively , are indicated . these scales separate pair scaling @xmath146 as for a near - circular vortex ring , scaling @xmath200 for two anti - circulating vortex lines , and @xmath201 , as for a vortex ring or of a pair of straight vortex lines , corresponding to the scaling exponent @xmath202 at the nonthermal fixed point . see sect . [ subsec : vortexloops ] for more details.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] we now consider the three - dimensional case of vortex lines and loops . a formulation similar to the onsager point vortex model in sect . [ subsec : independentvortices ] is possible @xcite . see also refs . @xcite for an extension including the dynamics of tangles of vortex lines . we write the classical kinetic energy spectrum of the velocity field in terms of the vorticity density @xmath203 as @xmath204 the vorticity is vanishing everywhere but on the vortex lines , i.e. , assuming @xmath108 individual vortex loops , @xmath205 in this expression , the vortex filaments are represented by the connected curves @xmath206 , parametrized by the one - dimensional coordinate @xmath207 , @xmath208 being the arc length of filament @xmath130 . the loops are closed , @xmath209 , possibly also accross the walls of the 3-dimensional volume in accordance with periodic boundary conditions . @xmath210 is the tangent vector along the filament at @xmath206 , of unit length @xmath211 . we parametrize the @xmath130-th vortex loop in terms of a single center coordinate and a relative curve , @xmath212 and write the vorticity as @xmath213 hence , in fourier space , @xmath214 where @xmath215 is the fourier transform of the vorticity of the @xmath130-th vortex loop , given by @xmath216 the ensemble - averaged vorticity @xmath217 becomes @xmath218 assuming that the shapes of the individual vortex loops are statistically independent of their position , it follows that @xmath219 . if the loops are also uncorrelated among themselves , then @xmath220 . hence , for statistically identical loops , @xmath221 which means that the vorticity spectrum scales in the same way as the average vorticity of a vortex loop centered at the origin . finally , the scaling of the momentum spectrum @xmath222 follows from that of the angle - averaged vorticity , @xmath223 for the case of two straight parallel vortex lines of opposite circulation eq . ( [ eq : energyspeccorrfinal ] ) is evaluated in appendix [ app : vortexline ] , for an ensemble of such paired lines in appendix [ app : vortexlines ] . making use of the procedure developed there , the case of circular vortex rings of radius @xmath104 is discussed in appendix [ app : vortexring ] . for the latter , the resulting angle - averaged momentum spectrum scales like @xmath224 for momenta @xmath225 and @xmath88 for momenta @xmath226 . to include effects from squeezed vortex loops , we consider elliptical filaments . the ellipse is defined by a major radius @xmath227 and minor radius @xmath228 . in fig . [ fig : vortexellipse ] , the angle - averaged momentum spectrum of an elliptical vortex loop is shown . three scaling regimes can be distinguished . for the lowest momenta , one has @xmath146 , which equals the infrared scaling for a vortex ring . for momenta @xmath229 , one finds @xmath200 , which coincides with the infrared scaling of two anti - circulating vortex lines ( see app . [ app : vortexline ] ) . for the ellipse , above @xmath198 , the momentum distribution scales like @xmath201 , which is the same as the high - momentum scaling of a vortex ring ( see app . [ app : vortexring ] ) or of a pair of straight vortex lines ( app . [ app : vortexlines ] ) . ) as obtained from a random distribution of @xmath230 bound vortex - antivortex pairs , on a @xmath171 grid , as in fig . [ fig : randomvortex ] . note the double - logarithmic scale . at low momenta the velocity field follows the scaling of vortex - antivortex pairs ( @xmath231 ) , whereas at higher momenta the distribution reflects the presence of vortices ( @xmath232 ) . note , that there is a deviation from @xmath231 in the regime of low velocities . from simulations with higher resolution , we find the best agreement for @xmath233 . we remark , that in the limit @xmath234 the velocity distribution is expected to be gaussian @xcite.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the vortex model can provide insight into another observable accessible in our numerical simulations , the velocity distribution . @xcite for discussions of the velocity distribution and ref . @xcite for recent experimental results . as discussed above , the velocity field scales , far away from any core , as @xmath235 , with @xmath232 for a single vortex and @xmath231 for a vortex - antivortex pair in two dimensions . the velocity probability distribution @xmath236 is calculated as @xmath237 , with spatial vortex distribution function @xmath238 . for a uniform distribution @xmath239 , it follows after angular averaging that @xmath240 it is numerically convenient to calculate the probability density of a single component of the field , e.g. @xmath241 in fig . [ fig : vortexvelocity ] , the corresponding velocity distribution @xmath242 is shown . in accordance with the analytical predictions two scaling regimes are observed . at low momenta the velocity field follows the scaling of vortex - antivortex pairs , whereas at higher momenta the distribution reflects a random distribution of vortices . in this section we return to the process of the formation of vortical excitations and of the bose gas approaching the nonthermal fixed point characterized by the wave - turbulent scaling solutions discussed in sect . [ sec : dyncritpoints ] and refs . thereby we first focus on the evolution of the single - particle momentum distributions and the emergence of nonthermal power laws . we relate these to structure formation in the form of vortical excitations . in order to identify in a clearer way the relevant processes in approaching the fixed point we compute the fluxes in momentum space . remarkably , we find that the appearance of the particle scaling exponent @xmath243 in the ir and of the energy exponent @xmath244 in the uv are compatible with predictions based on general arguments of irreversibility as well as energy and number conservation in a collision process @xcite . , for four different times of a run in @xmath10 dimensions . parameters are : @xmath245 , @xmath246 , @xmath247 . note the double - logarithmic scale . an early development of a scaling @xmath248 is followed by a quasi - stationary period of bimodal scaling with @xmath86 in the ir , due to the presence of vortices , and @xmath224 in the uv , corresponding to weak wave turbulence or thermal equilibrium.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] , for the four different times of a run in @xmath91 dimensions . parameters are : @xmath249 , @xmath250 , @xmath251 . note the double - logarithmic scale . a period of bimodal scaling @xmath88 ( vortex lines , ir ) and @xmath248 ( weak wave turbulence , uv ) is followed by trimodal scaling , which also exhibits pairing , i.e. , @xmath248 in the far ir , induced by a set of far separated small vortex rings , in addition to @xmath88 ( ir ) , and thermal scaling @xmath224 in the uv.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] as discussed in sect . [ subsec : summaryvortexnumerics ] , vortical excitations can be created in large numbers , within shock waves forming during the non - linear evolution of the coherent matter - wave field . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] show the angle- and ensemble - averaged radial momentum spectra , eq . ( [ eq : spectrumdef ] ) , for a bose gas in a box with periodic boundary conditions , in @xmath10 and @xmath91 dimensions , respectively . four snapshots are shown , taken at the dimensionless times @xmath252 as indicated in each panel . see appendix [ app : classfields ] for details on the simulations and on lattice units . the initial field configurations were prepared by macroscopically populating a few of the lowest momentum modes in the computation such that the resulting condensate density in configuration space varied between zero and some maximum value . in figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] , the panels representing the earliest times show the system after a brief initial evolution during which momentum is rapidly transported from the few initially occupied modes near zero over a comparatively large range of wave numbers . shortly after this , vortical excitations are created which immediately causes the spectrum in @xmath10 dimensions to exhibit a power - law behavior @xmath253 within a range of momenta @xmath254 $ ] , see the upper right panel of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] . subsequently , the evolution slows down and a quasi - stationary period is entered . during an intermediate stage ( bottom left panel of fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and upper right panel of fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] ) of the vortex - bearing phase two distinct power laws develop which are in excellent agreement with the analytical prediction in eqs . ( [ eq : kappauv ] ) and ( [ eq : kappair ] ) . while in the ultraviolet the exponent @xmath255 exhibits weak wave turbulence , eq . ( [ eq : kappauv ] ) , in the infrared , the exponent confirms the field theory prediction @xmath256 , cf . ( [ eq : kappair ] ) . more specifically , in two dimensions , at @xmath257 , one observes scaling exponents @xmath258 within a range of momenta @xmath259 $ ] and @xmath260 within a range of momenta @xmath261 $ ] , see the lower left panel of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] . at @xmath262 , @xmath263 within a range of momenta @xmath259 $ ] , see the lower right panel of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] . in @xmath91 dimensions , at @xmath264 , one observes @xmath265 within a range of momenta @xmath266 $ ] and @xmath267 within a range of momenta @xmath268 $ ] , see the upper right panel of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] . at @xmath269 , @xmath270 within a range of momenta @xmath271 $ ] , see the lower left panel of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] . the appearance of the bimodal power laws corroborates results for a relativistic @xmath7 model reported in refs . @xcite . during the ensuing evolution , the weak - wave - turbulence scaling decays towards @xmath28 , reflecting a thermal uv tail . note that in @xmath10 , the weak - turbulence exponent @xmath272 is identical to that in thermal equilibrium in the rayleigh - jeans regime , @xmath273 @xcite . in @xmath91 we observe , at late times , a change of the infrared scaling behavior from @xmath274 to @xmath275 , pointing to the development of pairing correlations , cf . sects . [ subsec : correlatedvortices ] , [ subsec : vortexloops ] , and sect . [ subsec : pairingspectrum ] below . more specifically , at @xmath276 , one observes a scaling exponent @xmath277 within a range of momenta @xmath278 $ ] , see the lower right panel of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] . at late times , after the last vortical excitations have disappeared , we observe the entire spectrum to become thermal , i.e. , exhibit rayleigh - jeans scaling with @xmath28 ( not shown ) . we emphasize that thermal scaling of the single - particle occupation number with @xmath28 applies despite the fact that quasiparticles with a linear dispersion are expected to thermalize in the regime of wave numbers smaller than the inverse healing length @xmath279 ( @xmath10 ) and @xmath280 ( @xmath10 ) . in the bogoliubov approximation this is seen by taking into account the power - law dependence of the coefficients @xmath281 which contribute to @xmath282 @xcite . we are going to study more details of the time evolution of the system in a forthcoming publication and focus in the remainder of this paper on properties of the stationary scaling distributions . an important question in this context is , why the system selects the particular exponents @xmath255 and @xmath256 from the set of four possible exponents given in eqs . ( [ eq : kappauv ] ) and ( [ eq : kappair ] ) . for this , the fluxes underlying the stationary but non - equilibrium distributions are relevant . ( upper set ) and @xmath91 ( lower set ) , for the four different snapshots of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] , respectively . note the logarithmic @xmath37-axes . the appearance of the bimodal scaling coincides with a positive kinetic energy flux in the uv , and a negative particle flux in the ir . flux units : @xmath283=[gnq]=(4m^2a_s^{d+4})^{-1}$ ] , cf . [ app : classfields ] . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] + ( upper set ) and @xmath91 ( lower set ) , for the four different snapshots of figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] , respectively . note the logarithmic @xmath37-axes . the appearance of the bimodal scaling coincides with a positive kinetic energy flux in the uv , and a negative particle flux in the ir . flux units : @xmath283=[gnq]=(4m^2a_s^{d+4})^{-1}$ ] , cf . [ app : classfields ] . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] the timeline of distributions shown in figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] suggests that the evolution of the gas involves a transport process from intermediate momenta around @xmath284 both towards lower and higher wave numbers , building up a bimodal power - law distribution . to describe the character of these transport processes we plot , in fig . [ fig : pflux2d3d ] for @xmath10 ( upper set of four panels ) and @xmath91 ( lower set ) , the radial particle and kinetic - energy flux distributions @xmath285 and @xmath286 , respectively . note that the radial particle flux density @xmath285 is multiplied by @xmath287 to have the same units as the energy flux density @xmath288 . these flux densities are defined through the balance equations ( [ eq : baleqq ] ) and ( [ eq : baleqp ] ) , respectively , with kinetic energy density @xmath289 . the initial stage is governed by an infrared particle transport towards larger @xmath37 , also causing a flux @xmath290 of interaction energy . at intermediate times , @xmath291 changes sign . this is accompanied by a positive kinetic energy transport in the uv , as observed in two - dimensional simulations in ref . @xcite . we emphasize that the negative particle flux in the ir and the positive kinetic - energy flux in the uv coincide with the appearance of the bimodal momentum distributions in figs . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] and [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] ( bottom left panels ) . although the derivation of the ir exponents requires the full dynamical theory with non - perturbatively resummed self - energies , the signs of the fluxes correspond to the respective scaling exponents , i.e. , @xmath202 in the ir , and @xmath292 in the uv , cf . [ subsec : wwt ] . moreover , at late times , the kinetic - energy flux @xmath71 vanishes due to a thermalized uv momentum distribution , but @xmath70 still reshuffles particles and therefore interaction energy , keeping the system out of equilibrium close to the nonthermal fixed point . we finally remark that , as discussed in detail in ref . @xcite , one can show on the general grounds of the boltzmann @xmath293-theorem that a necessary condition for a non - equilibrium stationary distribution in our systems is energy damping in the region of large @xmath37 . moreover , energy and particle number conservation in the interaction of different momentum modes can be shown to imply the existence of at least one more sink , i.e. , a region where the right - hand sides of eq . ( [ eq : baleqq ] ) effectively has an additional damping term @xmath294 , with negative @xmath295 . in between these sinks , a source region supplies the input to the bidirectional flux pattern towards the uv and ir . it was shown , moreover , in ref . @xcite , within wave - kinetic theory , that generally , a positive , @xmath37-independent flux transports energy , @xmath296 while a negative flux transfers particles , @xmath297 . the only exception is the case of @xmath10 where the thermal and the weak - wave - turbulence exponent @xmath292 can not be distinguished . remarkably , this pattern remains valid in our case , beyond the uv weak - wave - turbulence regime , in the ir region where the exponent emerges from a fixed point of the full dynamic equations . as already pointed out in ref . @xcite , however , the derivation of the ir exponent @xmath256 requires the existence of a sufficiently well defined quasi - particle dispersion relation , suggesting a treatment in terms of the quantum boltzmann equation with a momentum dependent scattering matrix element to be applicable . from this point of view , the negative flux @xmath70 and scaling in the ir and the positive flux @xmath71 and weak wave turbulence in the uv , as observed in the numerics , emerge as a necessary consequence of conservation laws and transport processes described by wave - kinetic transport equations . in this last section we analyse the single - particle momentum spectra obtained in our numerical simulations in view of their interpretation in terms of vortical excitations and wave - turbulence as implied by the point- and line - vortex models introduced in sect . [ sec : randomvortexmodel ] . for this we first decompose the flow pattern of the system which has closely approached the nonthermal fixed point , into transverse ( incompressible ) and longitudinal ( compressible ) contributions . in this way we can show that the ir scaling is dominated by the incompressible part while in the uv the particles mainly belong to the compressible as well as a quantum pressure components . we find a further scaling exponent @xmath298 for the subdominant compressible component in the ir which is interpreted as a signature of acoustic turbulence . moreover , going beyond the results presented in @xcite we identify signs of pair formation in the final stage . the scaling caused by this goes beyond the predictions from dynamical quantum field theory summarized in section [ sec : dyncritpoints ] , and we interpret it as a signature for the system leaving the fixed point again for final thermalization . , as defined in eqs . ( [ eq : ev])([eq : decomposition ] ) : total single - particle occupation number @xmath119 ( black dots ) , incompressible ( solenoidal - flow ) component @xmath299 ( red circles ) , compressible ( rotationless ) component @xmath300 ( blue filled squares ) , quantum - pressure component @xmath301 ( grey open squares ) . parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] ( lower right panel ) , for the run in @xmath10 dimensions at the time @xmath262 . note the double - logarithmic scale . a scaling with @xmath302 corresponds to a power - law exponent @xmath303 for the kinetic energy in @xmath10 . see text for more details on the scaling exponents . inset : phase angle @xmath304 as in fig . [ fig:2dphase512].,scaledwidth=45.0% ] , as defined in eqs . ( [ eq : ev])([eq : decomposition ] ) ( see caption of fig . [ fig : energyspectrum ] for more information ) . parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] ( lower left panel ) , for the run in @xmath91 dimensions at the time @xmath269 . note the double - logarithmic scale . a scaling with @xmath305 corresponds to a power - law exponent @xmath303 for the kinetic energy in @xmath91 . inset : the black spots mark points around the vortex line cores where the density falls below 5% of the mean density @xmath107.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] to exhibit vortical flow and define the decomposition we use the polar representation @xmath306 of the field in terms of the density @xmath307 and a phase angle @xmath308 . this allows to express the particle current @xmath309 in terms of the velocity field @xmath310 . with this , we decompose the kinetic - energy spectrum following ref . @xcite , splitting the total kinetic energy @xmath311 as @xmath312 into a ` classical ' part @xmath313 and a ` quantum - pressure ' component @xmath314 the radial energy spectra for these fractions involve the fourier transform of the generalised velocities @xmath315 and @xmath316 , @xmath317 following ref . @xcite , the velocity @xmath318 , which due to the multiplication of @xmath122 with the density @xmath107 becomes regularized and can be fourier transformed , is furthermore decomposed into ` incompressible ' ( divergence free ) and ` compressible ' ( solenoidal ) parts , @xmath319 , with @xmath320 , @xmath321 , to distinguish vortical superfluid and rotationless motion of the fluid . for comparison of the kinetic - energy spectrum with the single - particle spectra @xmath119 , we determine occupation numbers corresponding to the different energy fractions as @xmath322 the resulting spectra @xmath323 , @xmath324 , and @xmath325 add up to @xmath326 , which agrees with the single - particle spectrum up to small corrections , see appendix [ app : hydro ] . in figs . [ fig : energyspectrum ] and [ fig : modeoccupationboltzmann3 ] , we depict the momentum distributions of the occupation numbers @xmath323 , @xmath324 , and @xmath325 , together with the previously shown total single - particle spectrum @xmath119 , each at a late time when the system is close to the fixed point , i.e. , shows the predicted scaling both in the ir and the uv . red circles denote @xmath327 , filled blue squares @xmath328 , and open grey squares @xmath329 . qualitatively , the results are similar for @xmath10 and @xmath91 . in the range of large wavenumbers , the spectrum is dominated by the compressible and quantum - pressure components . the scaling of these excitations exhibits the weak - wave - turbulence exponent @xmath255 . for smaller wave numbers the scaling changes to @xmath330 . the decomposition into the various components now shows that this switching to a different scaling in the ir is clearly due to the take - over of a different character of the excitations with a modified flow pattern accounted for by the incompressible ( solenoidal ) component of @xmath318 . the fact that in this regime contributions from vortical flow @xmath327 dominate is in accordance with our interpretation of the strong ir scaling by a model of an ensemble of vortical excitations . as we have discussed in the previous section the analytically predicted infrared power laws @xmath330 are consistent with a finite density of independent vortices and antivortices ( @xmath10 ) or vortex lines ( @xmath91 ) . moreover , we find that the compressible component in the ir represents the second strongest contribution to the flow and develops a nonthermal scaling as @xmath331 . we will discuss this result in more detail in sect . [ subsec : acousticturbulence ] below . for momenta larger than about @xmath332 for @xmath10 and @xmath333 for @xmath91 the compressible and quantum - pressure components dominate the momentum distributions . in the regime of intermediate momenta , above the scale @xmath334 with @xmath335 the mean inter - vortex spacing , where the incompressible flow and the rest are of roughly equal strength one finds a scaling of approximately @xmath336 , corresponding to @xmath337 for both the two- and the three - dimensional case . scaling with this exponent , which is the same as in classical kolmogorov turbulence in an incompressible fluid , has been found in simulations of superfluid turbulence in @xmath338 before @xcite . in some of these cases , turbulent flow appeared in the time evolution of a system starting from a taylor - green configuration of vortex line tangles . we emphasize that our configuration after the creation of vortical excitations resembles more a state of the kind usually termed chaotic turbulence . it is unclear whether chaotic turbulence can be related to classical kolmogorov turbulence as this does not bear near - classical bundles of equal - orientation vortex lines . nonetheless we observe such @xmath303 scaling in the range of intermediate momenta where the interplay between the incompressible and compressible components is most pronounced . ) ([eq : decomposition ] ) are shown as functions of the radial momentum @xmath37 , from an average over @xmath339 single runs in @xmath10 dimensions ( upper panel ) and @xmath91 ( lower panel ) , at times @xmath340 ( @xmath10 ) and @xmath341 ( @xmath91 ) , triggered on the decay of the last vortical excitation . see caption of fig . [ fig : energyspectrum ] for more information . parameters are : @xmath10 : @xmath245 , @xmath342 , @xmath247 ; @xmath91 : @xmath249 , @xmath343 , @xmath344 . note the double - logarithmic scale . the figure shows that , shortly after the last vortex ring has disappeared ( incompressible component breaks down ) , compressible excitations exhibiting acoustic turbulence scaling @xmath345 remain present.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] + ) ([eq : decomposition ] ) are shown as functions of the radial momentum @xmath37 , from an average over @xmath339 single runs in @xmath10 dimensions ( upper panel ) and @xmath91 ( lower panel ) , at times @xmath340 ( @xmath10 ) and @xmath341 ( @xmath91 ) , triggered on the decay of the last vortical excitation . see caption of fig . [ fig : energyspectrum ] for more information . parameters are : @xmath10 : @xmath245 , @xmath342 , @xmath247 ; @xmath91 : @xmath249 , @xmath343 , @xmath344 . note the double - logarithmic scale . the figure shows that , shortly after the last vortex ring has disappeared ( incompressible component breaks down ) , compressible excitations exhibiting acoustic turbulence scaling @xmath345 remain present.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] the ir scaling @xmath331 of the compressible component ( blue filled squares ) in figs . [ fig : energyspectrum ] , [ fig : modeoccupationboltzmann3 ] , and also fig . [ fig : pairingspectrum ] below suggests an interpretation in terms of acoustic turbulence @xcite and corroborates the numerical findings reported in ref . the scaling is persistent until late times , see , e.g. , fig . [ fig : pairingspectrum ] , but decays after the vortices have disappeared . to check that the nonthermal scaling of the incompressible component is not an artefact of the decomposition of the vortical flow into compressible and incompressible parts , we show the momentum spectrum for an average over selected runs in @xmath91 , see fig . [ fig : acoustic ] ( lower panel ) , where the snapshot is taken shortly after the last vortex ring has disappeared . one can observe that acoustic turbulence can survive for a limited period , @xmath346 , beyond the time when vortical excitations are negligible . in the case of @xmath10 , the effect is weaker but still present , see fig . [ fig : acoustic ] ( upper panel ) , where we show the averaged spectrum shortly after the last vortex - antivortex annihilation . our interpretation of this finding is that acoustic turbulence coexists with the dominant vortical flow . it is driven by vortex motion and especially vortex annihilation processes , which are known to produce compressible excitations . in @xmath10 , signatures of acoustic turbulence are less pronounced , which we attribute to reduced vortex dynamics or , equivalently , weaker driving of compressible excitations . , for the run in @xmath91 dimensions , at the time @xmath269 . note the double - logarithmic scale . the black line is a gaussian fit to the data which shows that in the low - velocity regime , the distribution is dominated by gaussian fluctuations . a high - velocity scaling with @xmath347 reflects the presence of uncorrelated vortices , cf . ( [ eq : pvelx]).,scaledwidth=45.0% ] dimensions at @xmath348 . at this time an average of @xmath349 vortices are present in the system . parameters : @xmath350 @xmath351 , @xmath352 . note the double - logarithmic scale . a high - velocity scaling with @xmath347 reflects the presence of uncorrelated vortices , cf . ( [ eq : pvelx ] ) . gaussian fluctuations are suppressed in the distribution of velocities of the individual vortices , measured through the motion tracking of the vortex cores.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] we furthermore investigated the velocity - field probability distribution in the turbulent regime to compare our data with the expectations summarized in sect . [ subsec : spectrumvelo ] . in @xmath91 dimensions , see fig . [ fig : velocitydistribution3 ] , the results corroborate theoretical and experimental results reported in refs . @xcite . the low - momentum distribution is characterized by gaussian statistics , whereas the uv regime clearly shows scaling @xmath353 predicted by the model of randomly distributed , uncorrelated vortex lines , see eq . ( [ eq : pvelx ] ) . note that even at late times , when vortex rings shrink in size , no signs of vortex pairing , @xmath354 , can be seen in the velocity distribution . this is due to dominating gaussian fluctuations in the low momentum region . in @xmath10 dimensions , see fig . [ fig : velocitydistribution2 ] , we compare the velocity - field distribution with the velocity distribution of the positions of the individual vortices . similar to the three - dimensional case the ir part of the velocity - field distribution is characterized by gaussian statistics , whereas the uv regime shows single - vortex scaling @xcite . the vortex velocity distribution is obtained from the statistical analysis of a vortex - tracking algorithm which is designed to detect regions of low density accompanied by a winding number equal to one . the method is analogous to the experimental set - up of ref . @xcite , where particles are trapped inside vortex cores to study vortex velocities in @xmath91 . in agreement with the experiment , fig . [ fig : velocitydistribution2 ] shows that gaussian random motion is suppressed for vortices , but @xmath355 scaling clearly persists . in this way , quantum turbulence can be distinguished from classical turbulence , where a continuous distribution of vorticity favors a gaussian velocity distribution . . parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] , for the run in @xmath91 dimensions , at the time @xmath276 ( lower right panel ) . note the double - logarithmic scale . the scaling @xmath356 in the far ir reflects pair correlations present in far - separated small vortex loops . ( see caption of fig . [ fig : energyspectrum ] for more information).,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in @xmath10 dimensions , at the time @xmath262 : occupation number obtained from averaging over all runs ( black dots ) ; occupation number obtained from averaging over selected runs featuring tightly bound vortex antivortex pairs with maximum pair correlation length @xmath357 ( red circles ) . parameters : @xmath358 , @xmath359 , @xmath251 . note the double - logarithmic scale . a scaling with @xmath166 reflects the presence of correlated vortex - antivortex pairs in @xmath10.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in fig . [ fig : pairingspectrum ] we show the decomposition of the single - particle spectrum into the previously defined incompressible , compressible , and quantum - pressure components , see eq . ( [ eq : decomposition ] ) , for the 3-dimensional system at @xmath360 , as in the lower right panel of fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] . at this time , only a small density of vortex rings has survived , which decays under the influence of the noise field , cf . also refs . @xcite . during the period when only a few small vortex rings remain one can observe a decrease of the infrared scaling exponents of the occupation number and its incompressible part to the value @xmath275 . since vortical excitations are still dominating the spectrum , we can interpret this observation in terms of the statistical point vortex model introduced in sect . [ sec : randomvortexmodel ] , as vortex - antivortex pair correlations , see sect . [ subsec : vortexloops ] . this is consistent with the snapshots of individual runs showing small vortex ellipses ( see inset of fig . [ fig : pairingspectrum ] ) . the scaling transition can be identified with the scale @xmath361 , with estimated minor radius @xmath362 . [ fig : pairingspectrum2 ] shows the average occupation number spectrum at @xmath262 in @xmath10 dimensions , as in the lower right panel of fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] . in the average over all generated runs pairing effects can hardly be observed . however , for selected runs with small maximum pair correlation length @xmath357 , as introduced in sect . [ subsec : correlatedvortices ] , the pair scaling appears . we find that in the selected runs ( @xmath363 of total number of runs ) , at the chosen point of time one or at most a few vortex - antivortex pairs with pairing length smaller than the distance between pairs are present . this constitutes the final period of the evolution , shortly before the last pair has disappeared through mutual annihilation and the system fully thermalizes . the generic configuration in @xmath10 dimensions during the preceding time interval of critical slowing down close to the nonthermal fixed point is characterized by randomly positioned vortices and antivortices , with pairing correlations nevertheless present . pairing is seen in the density - density correlation function between vortices and antivortices shown in fig . [ fig : paircorr2d ] , from which we read off a largest scale @xmath364 , cf . sect . [ subsec : correlatedvortices ] . this implies pair scaling below @xmath365 , not visible in the few ( black ) full circles in fig . [ fig : pairingspectrum2 ] . . parameters as in fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] , at the time @xmath366 . red crosses : pair correlations of vortices and antivortices within the same circulation . blue stars : pair correlations between vortices and antivortices . the rise above @xmath367 indicates an effective `` binding '' . black crosses : resulting correlation function @xmath368 introduced in eq . ( [ eq : cf ] ) . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] we observe that , in @xmath10 , scattering between the vortices of equal and opposite circulation can lead to the increase of the pairing length between correlated vortices and antivortices . this is in contrast to the situation for @xmath91 where the scattering between vortex rings rarely leads to an increase in the size of the rings . it is energetically advantageous for the rings to shrink in size , and thus , at a particular late time of the evolution the presence of separated small rings is generic and pairing is seen in the spectrum . in summary , our analysis gives a picture of the necessary conditions and the character of the nonthermal fixed point . it also shows that pairing effects are a first signature for the system leaving this fixed point again for the final move to thermal equilibrium . we have studied in detail superfluid turbulence in two- and three - dimensional dilute bose gases by means of simulations in the classical - wave limit of the underlying quantum field theory . a focus is set on the identification and characterization of stationary scaling solutions , in particular for single - particle momentum distributions . characteristic exponents @xmath5 of @xmath119 corroborate the analytical predictions made in ref . our findings suggest that local field expectation values and short- to intermediate - range coherence , including topological excitations , are at the basis of the infrared power laws predicted within a full nonperturbative dynamical field theory @xcite employing two - particle - irreducible effective action techniques . we have shown that the stationary scaling is maintained by the presence of particle ( ir ) and energy ( uv ) fluxes , originating at intermediate scales and directed towards the low- and high - frequency limits , respectively . the respective fluxes were found to be consistent with the particular scaling exponents of the momentum distribution in the respective regimes . our main result is the identification of the nonthermal fixed - point with the appearance of topological excitations in the system . we could successfully employ statistical models of point vortices in two dimensions and vortex rings in three dimensions to interpret the ir scaling exponent of the spectra . moreover , we observed in our simulations , during the final thermalization stage , decay of the turbulence scaling into a scaling derived from the assumption of vortex - antivortex pairing . to characterize further the bimodal power spectra developed close to the nonthermal fixed point we have analysed the decomposition of the overall flow pattern into compressible and incompressible components . we found that the ir power spectra of underlying compressible excitations suggest an understanding in terms of acoustic turbulence on top of the vorticity - bearing quasicondensate . finally , to compare with the results of recent experiments and analytical predictions , the velocity - field probability distribution as well as the velocity statistics of individual vortices has been studied . this observable is of great interest , as it can be used to experimentally distinguish between classical and quantum turbulence . the connection of qt phenomena with ab - initio dynamical field theoretic methods points a way to unified analytical studies of turbulence . moreover , it provides hints of how the proposed nonthermal fixed points in relativistic systems @xcite are realized in nature . a manifestation of the approach of a nonthermal fixed - point in terms of quasi - solitary pattern formation and charge separation in a relativistic scalar model has recently been reported in ref . @xcite . experimental studies of universal phenomena in nonequilibrium dynamics of ultracold atoms have great potential since universal effects do not depend significantly on initial conditions and details of the system . following this idea , our numerical protocol was chosen such that an experimental verification of our findings is within reach of present - day cold - atom experiments . the study of turbulence in ultracold gases may have great impact on many other fields of physics . prominent examples are strongly correlated nuclear matter produced in heavy - ion collisions and early - universe cosmology . t. g. and d. s. thank j. berges and c. scheppach for collaboration on related work . the authors thank j. berges , n. berloff , e. bodenschatz , m. j. davis , g. falkovich , s .- c . gou , h. horner , r. kerr , g. krstulovic , m. k. oberthaler , j. m. pawlowski , b. shivamoggi , b. svistunov , and m. tsubota for useful discussions . they acknowledge support by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( ga 677/7,8 ) , by the university of heidelberg ( frontier , excellence initiative , center for quantum dynamics ) , by the helmholtz association ( ha216/emmi ) , and by the university of leipzig ( grawp - cluster ) . the authors furthermore thank kitp , santa barbara , for its hospitality . this research was supported in part by the national science foundation under grant no . phy05 - 51164 . [ appendix ] a singly quantized vortex with circulation @xmath369 in two dimensions is described , in polar coordinates , by the solution @xmath370 of the gross - pitaevskii equation ( [ eq : gpe ] ) , where @xmath371 is real and approaches the square root of the bulk density @xmath372 for large distances @xmath104 from the vortex core where @xmath373 . a vortex is a stationary solution of eq . ( [ eq : gpe ] ) , evolving as @xmath374 with @xmath375 . the velocity field of the vortex is @xmath376 the fourier transform of this field can be conveniently evaluated by the help of the first - order bessel function , @xmath377 , as @xmath378 based on eq . ( [ eq : vorticity ] ) , we calculate the vorticity of two straight vortex lines in three dimensions , with circulation @xmath379 , @xmath380 , placed at positions @xmath381 and @xmath382 in the @xmath184-@xmath185 plane and relate it to the momentum spectrum , see eq . ( [ eq : spectrumfromvorticity ] ) . the lines are parametrized by @xmath383 with @xmath384 $ ] . in fourier space , the vorticity density , defined in eq . ( [ eq : vorticity ] ) , reads @xmath385 the vorticity spectrum follows from eq . ( [ eq : vorticity ] ) , @xmath386 ) @xmath387 ) one obtains @xmath388 we regularize the delta distribution , giving it a finite width @xmath389 . the angle average of eq . ( [ eq : lines1 ] ) then reads @xmath390,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath391 is the length of the system in @xmath65-direction and @xmath392 . one obtains the scaling behaviour @xmath393 which is the scaling of a single line . with eq . ( [ eq : spectrumfromvorticity ] ) , we conclude @xmath88 . following the same reasoning , the angle average of eq . ( [ eq : lines2 ] ) is given as @xmath394\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath395 @xmath396 which gives @xmath248 . for @xmath397 @xmath398 which gives @xmath88 . these scalings are confirmed in fig . [ fig : straightvortexline ] . on a @xmath399 lattice . the distance scale @xmath400 is indicated . note the double - logarithmic scale.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] on a @xmath399 lattice . the radius scale @xmath401 is indicated . note the double - logarithmic scale.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in sects . [ subsec : indpairs ] and [ subsec : correlatedvortices ] , we have discussed the scaling of the momentum distribution for ensembles of independent and pair correlated vortices in two dimensions , respectively . in this appendix we generalize the scaling derived above for straight vortex lines to the case of many such lines in @xmath91 . we derive an expression for the momentum spectrum of a system of @xmath108 straight vortex lines oriented along the @xmath65 direction . the average vorticity squared is given by eq . ( [ eq : energyspeccorr3 ] ) where @xmath402 are vectors in the two - dimensional @xmath184-@xmath185 plane pointing to the @xmath130-th vortex line with circulation @xmath403 . the vorticity of the single line is @xmath404 hence , eq . ( [ eq : energyspeccorr3 ] ) has the same form as eq . ( [ eq : vortexdensity ] ) for @xmath10 , @xmath405 up to a @xmath406 term , which arises from the infinite extent of the vortex lines in @xmath65-direction . as in app . [ app : vortexline ] , we regularize the delta distributions , and averaging ( [ eq : energyspeccorr3line ] ) over solid angles yields @xmath407 which is analogous to eq . ( [ eq : ve ] ) in two dimensions . as the position of the @xmath130-th vortex line is determined by @xmath402 , statistical averaging of ( [ eq : energyspeccorr3linefinal ] ) can be done in the same way as in @xmath10 . a vortex ring with radius @xmath104 lying in the @xmath184-@xmath185 plane can be parametrized as @xmath408 with @xmath409 $ ] . in fourier space , similar steps as above lead to the angle - averaged vorticity density @xmath410 for @xmath411 and @xmath412 for @xmath413 , corresponding to @xmath224 and @xmath88 . this is shown in fig . [ fig : vortexring ] . both scalings are also found in the momentum spectrum of a vortex ellipse , discussed in sect . [ subsec : vortexloops ] . in this paper , a dilute superfluid gas of bosons of mass @xmath414 is considered , with contact interactions quantified by a coupling constant @xmath19 . its dynamics is described , in the classical wave limit , by the gross - pitaevskii equation ( gpe ) ( [ eq : gpe ] ) . we use units where @xmath16 . we consider the gas to be contained in a box of size @xmath415 , @xmath416 , with periodic boundary conditions . in @xmath91 , the coupling constant @xmath19 is related to the @xmath4-wave scattering length @xmath15 by @xmath417 . in @xmath10 , one has @xmath418^{-1}$ ] where @xmath419 is the chemical potential and @xmath420 is a scattering length in two dimensions which , for a gas of hard - spheres of radius @xmath15 is given by @xmath421 , with the euler - mascheroni constant @xmath422 @xcite . for a two - dimensional gas created by trapping a three - dimensional one tightly in one dimension , with harmonic - oscillator length @xmath423 , the effective 2d scattering length is given by @xmath424 , where @xmath425 @xcite . diluteness implies that @xmath426 , the interparticle spacing @xmath427 being determined by the mean density @xmath428 . the initial values for the real and imaginary parts of the field @xmath429 are randomly chosen from a gaussian distribution with width @xmath430 , centered around @xmath431 , where @xmath432 is the occupation number at time @xmath25 and @xmath433 is a random phase angle . correlation functions including @xmath0 are obtained by averaging over many trajectories . to induce transport from small to large wave numbers , only a few modes near @xmath434 are chosen to be macroscopically occupied at the initial time , @xmath435 . such an initial state can be prepared , e.g. , by bragg scattering of photons from a bose - einstein condensate . our numerical simulations are performed on space - time lattices with side lengths @xmath436 , with lattice spacing @xmath437 and in total @xmath438 gridpoints . we use periodic boundary conditions and @xmath439 for @xmath10 and @xmath440 for @xmath91 . ( [ eq : gpe ] ) is written in terms of the dimensionless variables @xmath441 , @xmath442 and @xmath443 . all quantities in the figures are either dimensionless or shown in lattice units , with the length unit given by @xmath444 . the dimensionless lattice momenta are @xmath445^{1/2 } , \mathbf{k}=2\pi\mathbf{n}/n_s , \ , ,n_d),\ , n_i= -n_s/2, ... ,n_s/2 $ ] . in order to relate our simulations to a typical situation in experiment , we give parameters for rb-87 . we estimate the total energy of the gas in equilibrium to be given by the interaction energy which , by equipartition is related to the temperature , @xmath446 . at the transition to degeneracy the thermal de broglie wave length @xmath447 is of the order of the interparticle spacing and hence @xmath448 . inserting this into the expression for the interaction energy allows to express the lattice spacing in terms of the density and the scattering length as @xmath449 inserting parameters for a typical rb-87 experiment in @xmath91 , viz . , @xmath450 nm , @xmath451 kg , @xmath452m@xmath453 we obtain @xmath454@xmath419 m . hence , time scale as @xmath455s . our lattice time typically runs until @xmath456 , which therefore represents a realistic observation timescale in experiments . typical parameter choices in our simulations are @xmath343 , @xmath344 , @xmath249 for @xmath91 and @xmath342 , @xmath247 , @xmath245 for @xmath10 . as a function of the radial momentum @xmath37 at different times , for @xmath10 ( left panel ) and @xmath91 ( right panel ) . parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence2 ] , for the run in @xmath10 dimensions and in fig . [ fig : modeoccupationsequence3 ] , for @xmath91 . note the logarithmic scale . , scaledwidth=48.0% ] in sect . [ subsec : superfluidturbulence ] , we have defined occupation numbers corresponding to the incompressible , compressible and quantum pressure components of the kinetic energy . numerically , the resulting spectra @xmath323 , @xmath324 , and @xmath325 add up to @xmath458 which is equal to the full single - particle spectrum @xmath119 up to small corrections . in particular , the scaling behavior emerges as the same for both , @xmath458 and @xmath119 . to make this more explicit , we calculate @xmath459 in terms of generalized velocities @xmath460v , q@xmath461 , @xmath462 @xmath463 denotes the real part and @xmath464 the fourier transform . the middle term vanishes since the expectation value is purely imaginary due to isotropy . it follows that @xmath465 since phase and phase velocity are expected not to be correlated , the main contribution to the 4-point correlation functions is assumed to arise from terms of the form @xmath466 , @xmath467v , q@xmath461 . in the superfluid regime , the phase of the field is a slowly varying function in position space . therefore , @xmath468-terms are strongly peaked at zero momentum , effectively acting as regularized delta functions under the convolution . hence , @xmath469 this approximative identity is supported by fig . [ fig : differencespectrum2d3d ] . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the weak equivalence principle states that the trajectories of small test bodies , neither affected by gravitational tidal forces nor by forces other than gravity , are independent of their internal structure and composition @xcite . experimentally , this principle is confirmed with extremely high precision @xcite ; in gravity theory it has been implemented already by newton who postulated that gravitational mass should equal inertial mass , and then by einstein who formulated the motion of test bodies in terms of geodesics on lorentzian spacetime . these trajectories extremize the lorentzian length integral which is interpreted physically as proper time . the fundamental geometric object entering this construction is the lorentzian spacetime metric . this observation led einstein to the development of a gravity theory that determines the metric and so provides a dynamical background geometry for point particles , observers and physical fields . the essential point in einstein s implementation of the weak equivalence principle by a clock postulate is the use of geometric concepts , not the particular choice of metric geometry . indeed , more general geometries can be used which automatically realize this principle . here we consider finsler geometry @xcite which generalizes metric geometry by providing a very general length functional for curves @xmath0 on a manifold @xmath1 , @xmath2=\int d\tau\ , f(\gamma(\tau ) , \dot \gamma(\tau))\,.\ ] ] the finsler function @xmath3 maps the points of the curve and the attached four - velocities into real numbers and is homogeneous of degree one in its second argument to ensure the reparametrization invariance of @xmath4 $ ] . the usual length measure associated to a lorentzian metric @xmath5 is obtained for the special case @xmath6 . physically , we interpret the integral above as a generalized clock postulate and point particle action . on this basis we will develop a consistent gravity theory which determines the finsler function dynamically . our construction builds on the precise definition of physical finsler spacetimes in @xcite , where we established a minimal set of requirements on the function @xmath3 so that it can describe a geometric spacetime background suitable for physics . in particular , finsler spacetimes provide a well - defined notion of causality and the possibility to formulate field theory actions . a generalization of gravity based on finsler geometry has the potential to explain various issues that are not naturally explained by einstein gravity . indeed , it has been argued that finsler geometry in principle can address the rotational curves of galaxies and the acceleration of the universe without introducing dark matter @xcite or dark energy @xcite , and that it admits sufficiently complex causal structures that allow a consistent geometric explanation of superluminal neutrino propagation @xcite . here we will find that finsler gravity may also explain the fly - by anomaly @xcite in the solar system . our presentation is structured as follows . we will begin in section [ sec : fstreview ] with a brief review of our definition of finsler spacetimes and of the mathematical tools and geometric objects needed . moreover , we will define field theory action integrals on finsler spacetimes . equipped with these concepts we will show in section [ sec : obs ] how to model observers on finsler spacetimes and discuss how they perform measurements . we will prove that two different observers are related by a transformation composed out of a certain parallel transport and a lorentz transformation . the set of these transformations has the algebraic structure of a groupoid that reduces to the usual lorentz group in the metric geometry limit . in section [ sec : gravdyn ] we will present our new theory of finsler gravity , including a matter coupling principle , which geometrically extends einstein gravity without introducing new fundamental scales . we will derive the finsler gravity field equation by variation and prove that it reduces consistently to the einstein field equations in the metric limit . symmetries of finsler spacetimes will be introduced in section [ sec : fsym ] . the maximally symmetric solution of vacuum finsler gravity turns out to be standard minkowski spacetime . section [ sec : corr ] considers a spherically symmetric perturbation around this vacuum which is found to be a refinement of the schwarzschild solution that shows how finsler gravity could resolve the fly - by anomaly . we conclude in section [ sec : disc ] . appendix [ app : details ] presents technical details of our derivations . the central idea behind the generalization of einstein gravity presented in this article is the description of spacetime and its dynamics by finsler geometry instead of metric geometry . in this section we will review the basic geometric concepts available on finsler spacetimes @xcite . these were introduced as a generalization of lorentzian metric spacetimes ; they allow full control of the null geometry and a clean definition of causality , which is essential for the description of light and observers . in particular , we will describe non - linear connections and curvature ; moreover , we will explain how to obtain well - defined field theory actions . the definition of finsler spacetimes involves the eight - dimensional tangent bundle @xmath7 which is the union of all tangent spaces to the underlying four - dimensional event manifold @xmath1 . thus , any point @xmath8 is a tangent vector to @xmath1 at some point @xmath9 ; there is a natural projection @xmath10 . it is convenient to use the so - called induced coordinates on the tangent bundle which are constructed as follows . let @xmath11 be coordinates on some open neighbourhood @xmath12 of @xmath13 . with respect to these we can express @xmath14 ; the induced coordinates of @xmath15 are then @xmath16 . the corresponding induced coordinate basis of @xmath17 will be denoted by @xmath18 and that of its dual @xmath19 by @xmath20 . * definition 1 . * _ geometric structures implemented in every tangent space @xmath21 by definition 1 of finsler spacetimes . the solid lines show the guaranteed cone of timelike vectors with the shells of unit timelike vectors and null boundary . the dotted lines indicate a potentially more complex null structure._,scaledwidth=30.0% ] lorentzian metric spacetimes @xmath22 arise from definition 1 in case @xmath23 ; then @xmath24 and @xmath25 is the set of unit @xmath5-timelike vectors . for general function @xmath26 , the relation between the inverse finsler metric @xmath27 and the inverse lagrange metric @xmath28 is given by @xmath29 the definition of finsler spacetimes guarantees a well - defined causal structure by the existence of timelike vectors that form an open convex cone with null boundary in every local tangent space , see figure [ fig : nullstructure ] . it provides full control of the geometry along the null directions where @xmath30 : we could show that the geometric concepts of connections and curvature that will be discussed below can be extended to this set , which is not possible in standard textbook formulations of finsler spaces . furthermore , by constructing a theory of electrodynamics on finsler spacetimes we proved that light propagates along null directions . for further details see @xcite . the geometry of finsler spacetimes is formulated by extending the standard language of finsler geometry , see e.g. @xcite ; this is a special geometry on the tangent bundle based on the finsler function @xmath3 that appears in the clock postulate . the basic geometric object deduced from the finsler function is the cartan non - linear connection . any non - linear connection on @xmath7 is equivalent to a unique decomposition of all tangent spaces to @xmath7 as @xmath31 , see figure [ fig : verthori ] . while the vertical bundle @xmath32 is canonically spanned by @xmath33 , the horizontal bundle @xmath34 is spanned by @xmath35 where the @xmath36 are the coefficients of the non - linear connection . then the dual bundle @xmath37 is spanned by @xmath38 , and @xmath39 by @xmath40 . for the cartan non - linear connection , the connection coefficients are determined by the fundamental functions @xmath3 or @xmath26 as @xmath41=\frac{1}{4}\bar\partial_b\big[g^{laq}\big(y^p\partial_p\bar\partial_ql-\partial_ql\big)\big ] .\ ] ] the equality of the two expressions for @xmath42 follows from the proof of theorem 2 in @xcite which makes particular use of the euler theorem @xmath43 for @xmath44-homogeneous functions . note that the right hand side is also valid on the null structure where @xmath3 is not even differentiable . _ tangent bundle geometry : decomposition of @xmath45 into horizontal and vertical parts._,scaledwidth=60.0% ] under tangent bundle changes of coordinates induced from coordinate transformations @xmath46 of the manifold , the non - linear connection coefficients @xmath42 transform in such a way that the horizontal / vertical basis @xmath47 of @xmath17 and the dual basis @xmath48 transform as vectors or one - forms over the manifold , @xmath49 tensors on @xmath7 that obey the standard tensor transformation law under manifold induced coordinate changes are called distinguished , or , in short , d - tensors . an example for a d - vector is the horizontal lift @xmath50 of a vector @xmath51 in @xmath21 to @xmath52 , @xmath53 the inverse map is given by the pushforward along the projection , @xmath54 . the horizontal tangent spaces to @xmath7 can thus be identified with the tangent spaces to the manifold @xmath1 ; this will be important for the identification of field components of tensors over the tangent bundle with field components measured over the spacetime manifold . a d - tensor of particular importance for our construction of gravitational dynamics for finsler spacetimes is the curvature of the cartan non - linear connection which measures the integrability of the horizontal bundle @xmath34 . it is defined as @xmath55^a =- y^q\big(\delta_b\gamma^{\delta a}{}_{qc}-\delta_c\gamma^{\delta a}{}_{qb}+\gamma^{\delta a}{}_{pb}\gamma^{\delta p}{}_{qc}-\gamma^{\delta a}{}_{pc}\gamma^{\delta p}{}_{qb}\big),\ ] ] using as a short - hand notation the generalized christoffel symbols @xmath56 which are related to the non - linear connection coefficients via @xmath57 . the proof of the above equality is given in theorem 2 of @xcite . in order to formulate covariant differential equations in the language of finsler geometry , a linear covariant derivative @xmath58 that acts on tensor fields over @xmath7 is needed . this must be compatible with the horizontal / vertical structure so that the identification of horizontal tangent spaces with tangent spaces to the manifold stays intact under transports . in the literature exist four such covariant derivatives with slightly different properties . we will employ the cartan linear covariant derivative defined by @xmath59 in later sections we will often need the cartan linear covariant derivative with respect to horizontal directions ; we will then use the abbreviation @xmath60 . the action of @xmath58 on the following sasaki type metric on @xmath7 , @xmath61 gives zero . hence this metric is covariantly constant with respect to the cartan linear connection ; it will play a crucial role as an integration measure on @xmath7 . this completes our quick review of geometric objects needed in this article . for later use observe that all the objects definable from @xmath3 , i.e. , the finsler metric @xmath27,the cartan non - linear connection @xmath42 , its curvature , and the cartan linear connection , are invariant under the transformation @xmath62 . in the metric limit @xmath23 they reduce to known constructions from metric geometry : the curvature essentially becomes the riemann curvature tensor , @xmath63 ; the generalized christoffel symbols become the usual christoffel symbols , @xmath64 ; the non - linear connection now is a linear connection , @xmath65 ; the cartan linear covariant derivative in horizontal directions becomes the levi - civita covariant derivative while it becomes trivial in vertical directions . we saw that all geometric objects on finsler spacetimes are homogeneous tensor fields on the tangent bundle ; the same will be true for physical fields in our construction . the formulation of field theory actions needs the well - defined integration procedure developed in @xcite . since integrals over the tangent bundle over homogeneous functions diverge , we must consider integrals over the unit tangent bundle @xmath66 on this domain we have a natural volume element constructed from the pull back of the sasaki - type metric ( [ eq : sasaki ] ) . thus , actions arise as integrals of scalar functions @xmath67 on @xmath7 restricted to @xmath68 as @xmath69 . to perform such integrals explicitly , we change coordinates on @xmath7 from the induced @xmath70 to the more convenient coordinates @xmath71 , where @xmath72 , the @xmath73 are zero - homogeneous , and @xmath74 . now @xmath68 is defined by @xmath75 and described by coordinates @xmath76 . the coordinate transformation matrices on @xmath7 are @xmath77,\qquad \frac{\partial z^a}{\partial \hat z^b } = \left[\begin{array}{c|c } \delta^a_b&\begin{array}{cc}0\quad & \;0 \end{array}\\ \hline \hat\partial_by^a & \begin{array}{cc } \partial_{u^\beta } y^a & \frac{y^a}{r } \end{array } \end{array}\right].\ ] ] and satisfy the invertibility properties [ eq : invvv ] @xmath78 = \left[\begin{array}{c|c}\delta^a_b & 0 \\ \hline \begin{array}{c}0 \\ 0 \end{array } & \begin{array}{cc } \delta^\alpha_\beta & 0 \\ 0 & 1 \end{array}\end{array}\right],\ ] ] @xmath79 = \left[\begin{array}{c|c}\delta^a_b & 0 \\ \hline 0 & \delta^a_b \end{array}\right].\ ] ] we now calculate the pullback of the sasaki type metric to @xmath68 in order to determine the relevant volume form . first we transform ( [ eq : sasaki ] ) to the new coordinates @xmath80 , which yields @xmath81 in terms of @xmath82 and @xmath83 . then the pull - back to @xmath68 with @xmath75 becomes @xmath84 using the shorthand notation @xmath85 and @xmath86 , a well - defined integral over @xmath68 of a homogeneous tangent bundle function @xmath67 now reads @xmath87 for tangent bundle functions @xmath88 that are homogeneous of degree @xmath44 the following formulae for integration by parts hold [ eq : intbp ] @xmath89_{|\sigma}\,,\\ \int_\sigma d^4\hat x d^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}{}_{|\sigma}\big(\bar\partial_a a^a\big)_{|\sigma } & = & - \int_\sigma d^4\hat x d^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}{}_{|\sigma}\big[\big(g^{f\,pq}\bar\partial_ag^f_{pq } - ( m+3 ) y^p g^f_{pa}\big)a^a\big]_{|\sigma}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath90 and @xmath91 . these formulae can be proven with the help of the coordinate transformation relations ( [ eq : invvv ] ) . the definitions and mathematical techniques presented in this section are the foundation of the following new developments . in the next section we present how observers are modelled and perform measurements before we turn to the construction of a gravity theory for finsler spacetimes . in order to study physics on general finsler spacetimes it is necessary to define a mathematical model of physical observers and to determine how they measure time , spatial distances , and physical fields . guided by general relativity , freely falling observers move on trajectories that extremize the proper time integral ; variation of ( [ eq : fact ] ) here leads to finsler geodesics . moreover a model of observers requires four tangent vectors that build an orthonormal frame ; then measurable quantities are the components of physical fields with respect to this frame , evaluated at the observers position . we explicitly calculate the illustrative example of an observer s measurement of the speed of light on which the results of @xcite are based . to compare measurements of different observers it is necessary to communicate the results obtained by one observer to another . this communication is realized by a certain class of transformations between different observers ; we will show that these transformations have the algebraic structure of a groupoid that generalizes the usual lorentz group in metric geometry . an observer moves along a spacetime curve @xmath92 in @xmath1 with timelike tangents . the parametrization can be chosen so that @xmath93 is unit timelike ; according to definition 1 we now have @xmath94 and the signature of @xmath95 is lorentzian . for points of the tangent bundle @xmath96 , which is analogous to the coordinate representation @xmath97 . ] then the clock postulate ( [ eq : fact ] ) tells us that @xmath98 must be interpreted as the local unit time direction of the observer . we may write the normalization condition in the form @xmath99 using the horizontal lift @xmath100 of @xmath101 , see ( [ eq : horlift ] ) . to identify the three - space seen by an observer , we will complete @xmath102 to a four - dimensional basis @xmath103 of @xmath104 ; as explained before the projections of the @xmath105 for @xmath106 by @xmath107 into @xmath108 then are identified as the spatial tangent directions to the manifold . we determine the three horizontal vectors @xmath105 by the condition @xmath109 . this construction is justified by the observation that a horizontal three - space is defined by a conormal horizontal one - form . the only linearly independent one - form available in terms of geometric data is the vertical form @xmath110 . this can be mapped globally to the horizontal one - form @xmath111 , which is proportional to the cartan one - form known from finsler geometry and is a lagrangian analogue of the poincar one - form in hamiltonian mechanics . the condition @xmath112 on @xmath105 is equivalent to that stated above in terms of the finsler metric . we remark that the @xmath105 may depend less trivially on @xmath113 than in lorentzian geometry because of their defining equation @xmath114 . the definition of unique unit directions in the three - dimensional span @xmath115 requires orthonormalization . for this purpose we use the finsler metric to set @xmath116 , assuming definite signature . the choice of the metric @xmath27 for orthonormalization is preferred over that of @xmath28 , since only @xmath27 is invariant under @xmath62 as are the geometrical objects on finsler spacetimes , see section [ sec : basic ] . we will now prove a useful theorem on the relation between the signatures of the metrics @xmath28 and @xmath27 where both are defined ; a corollary will then confirm our assumption of a definite signature of the finsler metric on @xmath115 . * theorem 1 . * _ on the set @xmath117 the metric @xmath28 is nondegenerate of signature @xmath118 for natural numbers @xmath119 with @xmath120 . then the finsler metric has the same signature where @xmath121 , and reversed signature @xmath122 where @xmath123 . _ the observer s time direction @xmath102 is in @xmath124 which is contained in @xmath117 . this tells us that the metric @xmath125 has signature @xmath126 for @xmath127 and @xmath128 for @xmath129 . we also know that @xmath99 . hence we conclude from theorem 1 : * corollary . * _ the finsler metric @xmath130 evaluated at the tangent bundle position of an observer has lorentzian signature @xmath126 , and the unit spatial directions satisfy @xmath131 . _ _ proof of theorem 1 . _ by the definition of finsler spacetimes the metric @xmath28 is non - degenerate on @xmath132 , hence also on the smaller set excluding the null structure on which @xmath27 is defined . now observe that if an inner product is given by a matrix @xmath133 and @xmath134 has indefinite signature @xmath118 , then the signature of @xmath135 is found to be @xmath136 for @xmath137 and @xmath118 for @xmath138 ; for @xmath139 the result is the once degenerate signature @xmath140 . this can be seen in a sylvester normal form basis for @xmath141 by using the remaining @xmath142 freedom . we can apply this result to our situation by identifying @xmath143 from equation ( [ eq : gftogl ] ) . it follows that @xmath144 ; then the signature of @xmath27 is the signature of @xmath141 , i.e. , that of @xmath28 up to the sign of @xmath26 . @xmath145 we summarize our construction of observers frames and measurements into a precise definition . * definition 2 . * the minkowski metric @xmath146 in this definition has signature @xmath128 . we emphasize again that the frame @xmath147 in @xmath104 can be identified one to one with a frame @xmath148 in @xmath108 , or reversely by the horizontal lift . from ( [ eq : gftogl ] ) , one can show that the observer frame has the nice property to diagonalize @xmath27 and @xmath28 simultaneously . we will now discuss the measurement procedure in more detail and present the example of how an observer measures the speed of light . definition 2 of the observer frame includes the statement that a physical observable is given by the components of a horizontal tensor field with respect to the observer s frame , evaluated at her position on the tangent bundle , i.e. , at her position on the manifold and her four - velocity . the motivation for this is as follows . the geometry of finsler spacetimes is formulated on the tangent bundle @xmath7 , and hence matter tensor fields coupling to this gravitational background must also be defined over @xmath7 . not all such tensor fields can be interpreted as tensor fields from the perspective of the spacetime manifold @xmath1 . this interpretation requires that the tensor fields be horizontal ; then they are multilinear maps built on the horizontal space @xmath149 and its dual which are identified with the tangent space @xmath150 and its dual . consider the example of a 2-form field @xmath151 over @xmath7 ; in the horizontal / vertical basis this expands as @xmath152 only the purely horizontal part @xmath153 has a clear interpretation . note that such horizontal tensor fields are automatically d - tensor fields , and have the same number of components as a tensor field of same rank on @xmath1 . the difference is that the components depend on the tangent bundle position . the measurement of a horizontal tensor field by an observer at the tangent bundle position @xmath154 clearly requires an observer frame of @xmath104 in order to read out the components . we emphasize that the dependence of observables on the four - velocity of the observer is not surprising . neither is it problematic as long as observers can communicate their results . in general relativity , observables are the components of tensor fields over @xmath1 with respect to the observer s frame in @xmath108 ; they clearly depend on @xmath101 which induces the splitting of @xmath108 into time and space directions . on finsler spacetimes the dependence of observables on the observer s four - velocity is not only present in the time / space split of @xmath104 , but also in the argument of the tensor field components . as a simple example we discuss the measurement of the spatial velocity of a point particle that moves on a worldline @xmath155 with horizontal tangent @xmath156 this can be expanded in the orthonormal frame of an observer as @xmath157 , where we recall that @xmath158 is the observer s four velocity . the time @xmath159 passes while the particle moves in spatial direction @xmath160 , so the spatial velocity @xmath161 and its square @xmath162 are @xmath163 as a consequence of this formula we may derive the speed of light seen by a given observer . as discussed in @xcite light propagates on null worldlines @xmath155 with @xmath164 which is equivalent to @xmath165 . we can use this fact to replace the finsler metric in the formula for the velocity above . taylor expanding @xmath166 around @xmath167 yields @xmath168 evaluating this formula at the position of the observer @xmath169 and dividing by @xmath170 , we immediately obtain an expression for the speed of light @xmath171 , i.e. , the speed of light traveling in spatial direction @xmath172 and measured by the observer @xmath154 : @xmath173 the @xmath159 are determined by solving the null condition @xmath174 ; on a generic finsler spacetime there can be more than one solution since the null structure can be very complicated . from equation ( [ eq : speedlight ] ) we see that the measured speed of light depends on the higher than second order derivatives of the squared finsler function ; these vanish in the metric limit where we thus reobtain @xmath175 independent of the observer and the spatial direction of the light ray . the formulae ( [ eq : v2 ] ) and ( [ eq : light ] ) enable us to compare experimental results on particle and light velocities with predictions on specific finsler spacetime models . in @xcite we used this to study the possibility of superluminal particle propagation . we already stressed the importance that observers should be able to communicate their measurements . consider two observers whose worldlines meet at a point @xmath176 . since observers by definition 2 measure the components of horizontal tensor fields in their frame and at their tangent bundle position , we need to determine which transformation uniquely maps an observer frame @xmath147 in @xmath52 to a second observer frame @xmath177 in @xmath178 . their respective four - velocities , or time directions , @xmath179 and @xmath180 generically are different , so that the two observer frames are objects in tangent spaces to @xmath7 at different points . as a consequence , we will now demonstrate that the transformations between observers consist of two parts : the first is a transport of the frame @xmath147 from @xmath181 to @xmath182 , the second will turn out to be a lorentz transformation . * theorem 2 . * _ proof . we first show that the curve @xmath183 required in _ ( i ) _ exists . the verticality condition @xmath184 implies @xmath185 ; the definition of the cartan linear connection ( [ eq : cartanlin ] ) then tells us that @xmath186 is equivalent to solving @xmath187 . this has a unique solution connecting @xmath181 to any point @xmath182 in a sufficiently small neighbourhood in @xmath21 . now let @xmath188 be the parallelly transported vector fields @xmath189 with @xmath190 . the properties of the cartan linear connection ensure that the @xmath191 are horizontal fields . observe also that @xmath192 along the curve @xmath183 since @xmath27 is covariantly constant under @xmath58 . it follows that @xmath193 is independent of @xmath194 , and holds in particular at the final point of the transport @xmath195 . now @xmath196 and @xmath177 are orthonormal frames with respect to @xmath27 in @xmath178 ; hence they are related by a unique lorentz transformation as stated in point _ ( ii ) _ of the theorem . @xmath145 the procedure described in theorem 2 provides a map between the frames of two observers at the same point of the manifold @xmath176 , but with different four - velocities @xmath197 ; we display the two parts of this procedure as @xmath198 , i.e. , as parallel transport followed by lorentz transformation , which is illustrated in figure [ fig : trafo ] . the combined maps transform observers uniquely into one another as long as the autoparallel @xmath183 connecting the vertically different points in @xmath7 exists and is unique . this is certainly the case if @xmath181 and @xmath182 are sufficiently close to each other . whether the geometric structure of a specific , or maybe all , finsler spacetimes is such that unique transformations between all observers exist requires requires further investigation . in the observer transformations on generic finsler spacetimes there appears an additional ingredient that is not present on metric spacetimes . before applying the lorentz transformation to the frame , one has to perform a parallel transport in the vertical tangent space . in the metric limit the vertical covariant derivative becomes trivial so that the parallely transported frame does not change at all along the curve @xmath183 . in this special case the transformation of an observer thus reduces to @xmath199 which is fully determined by a lorentz transformation . _ transformation between two observer frames : the frame @xmath147 in @xmath52 is first parallely transported to @xmath200 in @xmath178 , second lorentz transformed into the final frame @xmath177._,scaledwidth=55.0% ] the observer transformations on finsler spacetimes essentially have the algebraic structure of a groupoid that reduces to the lorentz group in the metric limit . we first review the general definition of a groupoid and then show how this applies to our case . * definition 3 . * _ a groupoid @xmath201 consists of a set of objects @xmath202 and a set of arrows @xmath203 . every arrow @xmath141 is assigned a source @xmath204 and a target @xmath205 by the maps @xmath206 and @xmath207 ; one writes this as @xmath208 . for arrows @xmath141 and @xmath209 whose source and target match as @xmath210 there exists an associative multiplication @xmath211 with @xmath212 a unit map @xmath213 where @xmath214 exists so that @xmath215 for every arrow @xmath141 exists an inverse arrow @xmath216 that satisfies @xmath217 _ groupoids are generalizations of groups . these can be expressed as groupoids with a single object in @xmath202 ; then the arrows correspond to group elements all of which can be multiplied since sources and targets always match . the multiplication is associative , the identity element and inverse elements exist . consider @xmath218 as the set of unit timelike vectors which contains the different four - velocities of observers at the point @xmath176 . let the arrows in @xmath203 be the set of all maps between two observer frames at @xmath219 which are defined by the procedure stated in theorem 2 . in case the involved vertical autoparallels connect the four - velocities uniquely , the sets @xmath202 and @xmath203 define a groupoid : source and target of a map @xmath220 between two frames @xmath221 and @xmath222 are simply given by @xmath223 and @xmath224 ; the multiplication @xmath225 is defined by applying the procedure of theorem 2 to construct the map between @xmath226 and @xmath227 , which gives the properties ( [ eq : mult ] ) ; we choose the unit map @xmath228 that provides ( [ eq : one ] ) as @xmath229 , i.e. , as trivial parallel transport of the frame @xmath221 with respect to the cartan linear connection along the vertical autoparallel that stays at @xmath181 followed by the identity lorentz transformation . finally , we define the inverse @xmath230 , where @xmath231 denotes parallel transport backwards along the unique vertical autoparallel connecting @xmath181 and @xmath182 which is also used for @xmath232 ; to check the properties ( [ eq : inv ] ) , one simply shows that parallel transport of the frames and lorentz transformation commute . thus we have shown the following result : * theorem 3 . * _ on finsler spacetimes @xmath233 the transformations between observer frames @xmath234 at @xmath176 that are attached to points @xmath235 define a groupoid @xmath201 under the condition that any pair of points in @xmath236 can be connected by a unique vertical autoparallel of the cartan linear connection . _ we already discussed that the transformations of observer frames reduce to the form @xmath237 in the limit of metric geometry . hence the only information contained in the reduced groupoid @xmath238 with @xmath239 and @xmath240 is given by the lorentz transformations . in mathematically precise language this can be expressed as the equivalence of @xmath238 to the lorentz group seen as a groupoid @xmath241 with a single object @xmath242 and arrows @xmath243 . the functor @xmath244 establishing the equivalence can be defined by the projection @xmath245 and by @xmath246 . indeed , @xmath247 can be checked to be injective , full and essentially surjective , and so it makes @xmath248 and @xmath241 equivalent . see @xcite for details on the required mathematical definitions . we have now reviewed the basic concept of finsler spacetime geometry and laid the foundations for the interpretation of physics on these backgrounds . we have seen that well - defined observers exist which communicate with each other by means of groupoid transformations that generalize the lorentz group in metric geometry . as emphasized in previous work @xcite , physical predictions in our generalized geometric framework require gravitational dynamics for the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 to determine specific spacetime solutions . in this section we for the first time present a finsler gravity action along with a consistent minimal coupling principle between gravity and matter . we begin our presentation with the variation of the pure gravity action , before the coupling of finsler gravity to matter is discussed in section [ sec : gravmat ] ; the full field equation is derived in section [ sec : gravmateq ] . moreover , we prove that the finsler gravity field equation becomes equivalent to the einstein equations in the metric limit . on finsler spacetime the simplest curvature scalar built from the non - linear curvature tensor @xmath249 , which is relevant for the tidal acceleration of finsler geodesics , is @xmath250 . this contains the lowest number of derivatives on the fundamental function @xmath26 without involving additional d - tensors besides the curvature , like @xmath251 or @xmath252 . recall that integrals are well - defined over the seven - dimensional unit tangent bundle @xmath68 with coordinates @xmath76 , as discussed in section [ sec : int ] . these two facts directly lead to our finsler gravity action @xmath253=\int d^4\hat xd^3u \left[\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ \mathcal{r}\right]_{|\sigma}\,.\ ] ] the gravitational field equation in vacuum now is obtained by variation with respect to @xmath26 . to perform this variation for an @xmath44-homogeneous function @xmath254 on @xmath7 restricted to @xmath68 it is useful to realise that @xmath255 where @xmath256 is the homogeneity of @xmath26 . with the help of this formula and the results for integration by parts in ( [ eq : intbp ] ) we can derive the vacuum field equations in three steps . the first uses the variation formula above with @xmath257 and @xmath258 , which yields @xmath259=\int d^4\hat xd^3u \left[\delta\big(\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ \mathcal{r}\big)-\frac{5}{n}\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ \mathcal{r } \frac{\delta l}{l}\right]_{|\sigma}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second step is the variation of the volume element which leads to @xmath260=\int d^4\hat xd^3u \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma } \left [ \big(g^{f\,pq}\delta g^f_{pq}-\frac{6}{n}\frac{\delta l}{l}\big)\mathcal{r}+y^b\delta r^a{}_{ab } \right]_{|\sigma}\,,\ ] ] while in the third step we use the following identities [ eq : calcgrav ] @xmath261_{|\sigma } = \int d^4\hat xd^3u \left[\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ g^{f\,ab}\bar\partial_a\bar\partial_b\mathcal{r}\frac{\delta l}{nl}\right]_{|\sigma}\,,\ ] ] @xmath262_{|\sigma } = \int d^4\hat xd^3u \left[\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ 2g^{f\,ab}\big(\nabla_as_b+s_as_b+\bar\partial_a\nabla s_b\big)\frac{\delta l}{nl}\right]_{|\sigma}\,,\ ] ] to arrive at the final form of the variation of the finsler gravity action ( [ eq : gravact ] ) : @xmath263=\int d^4\hat xd^3u \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma}\left [ g^{f\,ab}\bar\partial_a\bar\partial_b\mathcal{r}-6\mathcal{r}+2g^{f\,ab}\big(\nabla_as_b+s_as_b+\bar\partial_a\nabla s_b\big)\right]_{|\sigma}\frac{\delta l}{nl}\,.\ ] ] for further details of this variation we refer the reader to appendix [ app : vargrav ] . now we can read off the vacuum field equation on @xmath68 as @xmath264_{|\sigma } = 0 \,.\ ] ] observe that all terms in the bracket are zero - homogeneous on @xmath7 , except the second term @xmath265 that has homogeneity two . since @xmath266 we can replace the second term by @xmath267 which is now also zero - homogeneous . hence the equation can be lifted to @xmath7 in the form @xmath268 it seems as if this equation could be invalid on @xmath269 where @xmath3 is not differentiable so that the finsler metric @xmath27 does not exist . however , this is not the case : the equation is valid also on the null structure . to see this , one expresses @xmath27 through @xmath28 with the help of formula ( [ eq : gftogl ] ) and multiplies by @xmath270 . the resulting equation is well - defined whereever @xmath28 is nondegenerate , and in particular on the null structure . note that equation ( [ eq : gravvac ] ) is invariant under the transformation @xmath271 , which will be a guiding principle for matter coupling below . in the metric limit @xmath272 , the tensors in the the finsler gravity equation reduce as @xmath273 and @xmath274 , where @xmath275 is the ricci tensor of the metric @xmath5 . accordingly , the field equation becomes @xmath276 which is equivalent to the einstein vacuum equations @xmath277 by differentiating twice with respect to @xmath278 . we conclude that a family of solutions of the finsler gravity vacuum equation ( [ eq : gravvac ] ) is induced by solutions @xmath279 of the vacuum einstein equations via the fundamental functions @xmath280 . in section [ sec : corr ] we will present a solution of the finsler gravity vacuum equation beyond metric geometry . above we have achieved a consistent generalization of vacuum einstein gravity from metric spacetimes to finsler spacetimes . next we will show that this generalization can be completed by the coupling of matter fields . for this purpose we will discuss a minimal coupling principle that generates consistent matter field actions on finsler spacetimes from their well - known counterparts on metric spacetimes . in the discussion we restrict our attention to @xmath281-form fields ; spinor fields have to be investigated further . in section [ sec : gravmateq ] we will deduce the complete gravity equations with energy - momentum source term . consider an action @xmath282 $ ] for a physical @xmath281-form field @xmath283 on a lorentzian spacetime @xmath22 , @xmath284 = \int_m d^4x\ \sqrt{g}\ \mathcal{l}(g,\phi , \mathrm{d}\phi)\,.\ ] ] the corresponding matter action on finsler spacetime is obtained by lifting @xmath285 to the tangent bundle @xmath7 equipped with the sasaki - type metric @xmath286 defined in ( [ eq : sasaki ] ) in the following way : a. consider the lagrangian density @xmath287 of the standard theory on @xmath1 as a contraction prescription that forms a scalar function from various tensorial objects ; b. replace the lorentzian metric @xmath288 in @xmath287 by the sasaki - type metric @xmath286 ; c. replace the @xmath281-form field @xmath289 on @xmath1 by a zero - homogeneous @xmath281-form field as in ( [ eq:2form ] ) , for example , is zero - homogeneous if and only if its components @xmath290 , @xmath291 and @xmath292 have the homogeneities @xmath293 , @xmath294 and @xmath295 , respectively ; these are cancelled by the homogeneity of @xmath296 . ] @xmath297 on @xmath7 ; d. introduce lagrange multipliers @xmath298 for all not purely horizontal components of @xmath151 ; e. finally integrate over the unit tangent bundle @xmath68 with the volume form given by the pull - back @xmath299 of the sasaki - type metric . the result of this procedure is the finsler spacetime field theory action @xmath300=\int_\sigma d^4\hat xd^3u \big[\sqrt{g^fh^f } \big(\mathcal{l}(g,\phi , \mathrm{d}\phi)+\lambda ( 1-p^h)\phi \big)\big]_{|\sigma}\,.\ ] ] the projection @xmath301 projects to the purely horizontal part of the @xmath281-form @xmath151 ; in the example of the general two - form on @xmath7 displayed in equation ( [ eq:2form ] ) we have @xmath302 the lagrange multiplier guarantees that the on - shell degrees of freedom of @xmath151 are precisely those with a clear physical interpretation as fields along the manifold @xmath1 , as discussed in section [ sec : measure ] . the minimal coupling principle for matter to finsler spacetime presented above is a slightly refined version of that in @xcite where we discussed electrodynamics on finsler spacetime . the only modification here is in the definition of the sasaki - type metric @xmath286 that is now defined in terms of the finsler metric @xmath27 instead of @xmath28 . this change ensures that the resulting matter action @xmath303 $ ] is invariant under @xmath62 in the same way as the pure gravity action . nevertheless , the results obtained for electrodynamics on finsler spacetime in @xcite are unchanged by the refined coupling principle presented here . the matter field equations obtained by extremizing the action with respect to the @xmath281-form field @xmath151 and the lagrange multiplier @xmath298 can be studied most easily if expressed in components with respect to the horizontal / vertical basis . the calculation is performed in detail in appendix [ app : varmat ] . we display the results with the convention that barred indices denote vertical components , unbarred indices now denote horizontal components , and capital indices both horizontal and vertical components . variation with respect to the lagrange multiplier yields the constraints @xmath304 variation for the purely horizontal components of @xmath151 gives @xmath305 which determines the evolution of the physical field components , while variation with respect to the remaining components produces @xmath306 which fixes the components of the lagrange multiplier . the @xmath307 are the commutator coefficients of the horizontal / vertical basis . our coupling principle is consistent with the metric limit , i.e. , the equations of motion obtained from the finsler spacetime action reduce to the equations of motion on lorentzian spacetime in the case @xmath272 and @xmath308 . then we have the geometric identity @xmath274 ; moreover @xmath309}\ ] ] using the constraints ( [ eq : cons ] ) and the fact that the horizontal derivative acts as a partial derivative on the @xmath278-independent @xmath281-form components . finally , @xmath310 because , as a consequence of our coupling principle where the sasaki - type metric is block - diagonal in the horizontal / vertical basis , the vertical index of @xmath311 must appear in @xmath312 contracted via @xmath27 into either a vertical derivative or into components of @xmath151 with at least one vertical index . in the metric limit , vertical derivatives give zero , while the constraints ( [ eq : cons ] ) guarantee that all components of @xmath151 with at least one vertical index vanish . combining these observations shows that equation ( [ eq : eom1 ] ) reduces to @xmath313 where @xmath58 now operates in the same way as the levi civita connection of the metric @xmath5 . again , as a consequence of our minimal coupling principle with the block - diagonal form of the sasaki - type metric in the horizontal / vertical basis , we can conclude in the metric limit that @xmath314 so that ( [ eq : red ] ) becomes equivalent to the standard @xmath281-form field equation of motion on metric spacetime . our minimal coupling procedure for matter fields to finsler spacetime can be applied immediately for instance to the scalar field , as done in @xcite . note that it can be easily extended to the case of interacting form fields of any degree with metric spacetime action @xmath315 = \int_m d^4x\ \sqrt{g}\ \mathcal{l}(g,\phi_1 , \mathrm{d}\phi_1,\phi_2,\mathrm{d}\phi_2, ... )\,.\ ] ] the minimal coupling procedure then leads to the action @xmath316\nonumber\\ & = & \int_\sigma d^4\hat xd^3u \big[\sqrt{g^fh^f } \big(\mathcal{l}(g,\phi_1 , \mathrm{d}\phi_1,\phi_2 , \mathrm{d}\phi_2, ... )+\sum_i \lambda_i ( 1-p^h)\phi_i \big)\big]_{|\sigma}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equations of motion for each field @xmath317 have the same form as in the single field case , and the metric limit leads to the standard field equations by arguments that proceed in a completely analogous way as before . in the standard formulation of electrodynamics , the action is a functional @xmath318 $ ] of a one - form potential @xmath141 , but the classical physical field is @xmath319 . our minimal coupling principle to obtain an action on finsler spacetimes can not be applied immediately to this situation : the problem is that the lagrange multiplier then only kills the vertical components of the lift of @xmath141 , but does not guarantee that the lift of @xmath3 is purely horizontal . this problem is solved in @xcite by starting from an equivalent interacting action of the form @xmath320 $ ] which provides the complete set of maxwell equations @xmath319 and @xmath321 by variation . now the minimal coupling principle entails that both the lifted fields @xmath141 and @xmath3 are purely horizontal and can be interpreted physically . we are now in the position to study the interplay between the matter actions @xmath322 introduced in ( [ eq : matact ] ) and the pure finsler gravity action @xmath323 in ( [ eq : gravact ] ) . their sum provides a complete description of gravity and classical matter fields on finsler spacetimes : @xmath324 & = & \kappa ^{-1}s_g[l]+s_m[l,\phi,\lambda ] \nonumber\\ & = & \kappa^{-1}\int d^4\hat xd^3u \left[\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ \mathcal{r}\right]_{|\sigma}+ \int d^4\hat xd^3u\ \big[\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ ( \mathcal{l}(g,\phi , \mathrm{d}\phi)+\lambda(1-p^h)\phi)\big]_{|\sigma}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as usual , the matter field equations following from this are the same as for the pure matter action . the gravitational field equations are obtained by variation with respect to the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 . the variation of @xmath322 with respect to @xmath26 is @xmath325 and leads us to the definition of the energy momentum scalar @xmath326 on the unit tangent bundle as @xmath327 with this definition the complete gravitational field equations on finsler spacetime including energy - momentum sources formally become @xmath328_{|\sigma}=-\kappa t_{|\sigma}\,.\ ] ] as in the vacuum case with @xmath329 , these equations can be lifted to @xmath7 . the terms in the bracket on the left hand side are all zero - homogeneous and can be lifted trivially . the terms in @xmath330 without the restriction on the right hand side in principle can result from variation with different homogeneities ; to lift these one simply multiplies each term by the appropriate power of @xmath3 in order to make it zero homogeneous . this is the same procedure applied in section [ sec : gravvac ] to the gravity side . the gravitational constant @xmath331 will now be determined so that the gravitational field equation on finsler spacetimes becomes equivalent to the einstein equations in the metric limit . variation with respect to @xmath26 of the concrete form of the matter action in ( [ eq : compact ] ) and performing the metric limit , i.e. , @xmath332 for observers and @xmath333 , the gravity equation ( [ eq : fgrav ] ) becomes @xmath334 the detailed calculation of this result is involved and can be found in appendix [ app : varmat ] . introducing the standard energy momentum tensor of @xmath281-form fields on lorentzian metric spacetimes @xmath335 and its trace @xmath336 we can rewrite the equation above as @xmath337 if evaluated at @xmath5-timelike observer four - velocities @xmath278 . now we take a second derivative with respect to @xmath278 , contract with @xmath338 , reinsert the result , and conclude @xmath339 since there is no @xmath278-dependence beyond the explicit one , a second derivative with respect to @xmath278 yields the einstein equations , if we choose the gravitational constant @xmath340 . the gravity equation on finsler spacetime including the coupling to matter therefore is @xmath341 with zero homogeneous source function @xmath330 on @xmath7 . observe that this field equation including the matter part is invariant under @xmath271 by construction of the coupling principle , as the vacuum equation is . this leads to the interesting conclusion that every solution @xmath279 of the einstein equations induces a family @xmath342 of solutions of the finsler gravity solution with @xmath343 . in order to find further solutions of this highly complicated partial differential equation we will study symmetries of finsler spacetimes in the next section . then we present a solution of the linearised finsler gravity equation in section [ sec : corr ] which turns out to be a geometric refinement of the linearised schwarzschild solution of general relativity . in the previous section we have deduced the finsler gravity field equation including matter sources and shown that it is consistent with the einstein equations in the metric geometry limit . our new field equation is a highly complex differential equation ; in order to simplify the task of finding analytic solutions we wish to consider symmetric spacetimes . we begin this section by defining symmetries of finsler spacetimes and show how this concept is a generalisation of the symmetries of lorentzian spacetimes . we explicitly present the general structure of the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 for the spherically , cosmologically and maximally symmetric case . in the next section we will then use our results about symmetric finsler spacetimes to solve the linearised finsler gravity equation . on a symmetric lorentzian manifold @xmath22 , the metric is invariant under certain diffeomorphisms ; similarly we wish to define symmetries of a finsler spacetime @xmath233 as an invariance of the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 . consider a diffeomorphism generated by the vector field @xmath344 ; this acts as a coordinate change on local coordinates on @xmath1 as @xmath345 , and on the induced coordinates on the tangent bundle @xmath7 as @xmath346 . hence the diffeomophism on @xmath1 induces a diffeomorphism on @xmath7 that is generated by the vector field @xmath347 , called the complete lift of @xmath51 . the idea of implementing symmetries via complete lifts in a finsler geometry setting appears already in @xcite ; here we want to make this concept precise for finsler spacetimes : * definition 4 . * _ a symmetry of a finsler spacetime @xmath233 is a diffeomorphism generated by a vector field @xmath348 over the tangent bundle @xmath7 so that @xmath349 and @xmath348 is the complete lift @xmath350 of a vector field @xmath51 over @xmath1 . a finsler spacetime is called symmetric if it possesses at least one symmetry . _ the following theorem summarizes important properties of finsler spacetime symmetries . the symmetry generators form a lie algebra with the commutator of vector fields on @xmath7 , and they are isomorphic to a lie algebra of vector fields on @xmath1 which becomes the usual symmetry algebra of lorentzian manifolds in the metric geometry limit . this not only shows that definition 4 of symmetry is consistent with that of lorentzian spacetimes , but also that the usual killing vectors , e.g. , those for spherical symmetry , can be used to study symmetries of finsler spacetimes . * theorem 4 . * _ proof . _ _ ( i ) _ let @xmath351 ; then @xmath349 and @xmath352 . both properties are linear , so that @xmath353 is a vector subspace of the lie algebra of all vector fields on @xmath7 . it remains to be proven that the commutator of two elements @xmath354 closes in @xmath353 . it is clear that @xmath355(l)=0 $ ] ; to show that @xmath356)^c=[y_1,y_2]$ ] , one uses that @xmath357 for some vector fields @xmath358 on @xmath1 and that @xmath359=[x_1,x_2]^c$ ] , see @xcite . _ ( ii ) _ the inverse for @xmath107 on @xmath360 is given by the complete lift , hence @xmath353 and @xmath360 are isomorphic as vector spaces . the lie algebra structure is preserved in both directions because of @xmath359=[x_1,x_2]^c$ ] , and hence also @xmath361=[\pi_*y_1,\pi_*y_2]$ ] . _ ( iii ) _ for @xmath362 , we have @xmath363 . in the metric geometry limit @xmath23 , and hence @xmath364 . since the lie - derivative of the metric @xmath5 does not depend on the fibre coordinates of the tangent bundle we conclude @xmath365 . this is the condition that defines @xmath51 as the symmetry generator of a metric spacetime . we now wish to study the implications of spherical , cosmological and maximal symmetry for the fundamental function @xmath26 of a finsler spacetime . consider a finsler spacetime @xmath233 and coordinates @xmath366 on its tangent bundle . spherical symmetry is defined by the following three vector fields , that generate spatial rotations and form the algebra @xmath367 , @xmath368 their complete lifts are obtained via the procedure described in the previous section [ eq : ssymc ] @xmath369 applying the symmetry condition @xmath370 implies @xmath371 , while using @xmath372 and @xmath373 to deduce @xmath374 and @xmath375 yields @xmath376 in order to analyze the implications of these equations on @xmath26 we introduce new coordinates @xmath377 while keeping @xmath378 . the associated transformation of the derivatives @xmath379 makes the equations ( [ eq : spherical ] ) equivalent to the simple constraints @xmath380 and @xmath381 . hence we conclude from the analysis of the symmetry conditions @xmath382 that the most general spherically symmetric finsler spacetime is described by a fundamental function which is @xmath256-homogeneous in @xmath383 and of the form @xmath384 where @xmath385 is defined in ( [ eq : c1 ] ) . after our discussion of the spherically symmetric case in full detail above , we will now present the results of a similar analysis first for cosmologically and second for maximally symmetric finsler spacetimes . cosmological symmetry describes an isotropic and homogeneous spacetime . this is a much more symmetric situation than in the spherically symmetric scenario , and is implemented by requiring the following six vector fields to be symmetry generators , see @xcite , [ eq : csym ] @xmath386 where we write @xmath387 and @xmath388 is constant . the complete lifts of these vector fields are listed in appendix [ app : compl ] . applying the symmetry conditions @xmath389 to the fundamental function @xmath26 and introducing the new coordinates @xmath390 while keeping @xmath391 yields the following result : the cosmological fundamental function @xmath26 is @xmath256-homogeneous in @xmath392 and has the form @xmath393 the constant @xmath388 only appears in the expression for the coordinate @xmath394 . the value of @xmath394 can be understood as the metric length measure on a three - dimensional manifold of constant curvature @xmath388 . the same metric appears in the spatial part of the standard robertson walker metric . for the study of maximally symmetric finsler spacetimes we use some notation from @xcite , where such spacetimes are constructed from embeddings into a five - dimensional manifold . symmetry vectors generating maximal symmetry are given by @xmath395 with @xmath396 , constant @xmath397 , and constant @xmath398 matrices @xmath135 and @xmath399 . there are four linearly independent vector fields @xmath400 and six @xmath401 by requiring the condition @xmath402 ; their complete lifts are @xmath403 evaluating the symmetry conditions @xmath404 and @xmath405 on the fundamental function , and introducing new coordinates @xmath406 where @xmath407 runs over any three indices in @xmath408 , yields the following result : the maximally symmetric fundamental function @xmath26 is @xmath256-homogeneous in @xmath409 , and of the form @xmath410 the final equality is obtained from euler s theorem for homogeneous functions . observe that the maximally symmetric fundamental function always describes a metric geometry , see ( [ eq : c3 ] ) . hence all maximally symmetric finsler spacetimes are lorentzian spacetimes , and the gravity equation ( [ eq : complgrav ] ) is equivalent to einstein s equations . thus we can immediately conclude that the only maximally symmetric , source free vacuum solution of our finsler gravity equation is the minkowski metric induced fundamental function @xmath411 and its powers . in the expression for @xmath409 above this corresponds to @xmath412 and @xmath413 . maximally symmetric spacetimes with @xmath414 can only be obtained as solutions of the finsler gravity equation by adding a cosmological constant term , similarly as in general relativity . in this section we will study finsler spacetimes that describe mild deviations from lorentzian geometry . in this situation , the complicated finsler gravity field equation allows a simplified treatment . after a general discussion of the linearised field equation , we will employ what we learned about spacetime symmetries to present a spherically symmetric solution . this particular model turns out to be a refinement of the linearised schwarzschild solution of general relativity , and we will argue that it should be capable of modelling unexplained effects in the solar system like the fly - by anomaly . recall that the fundamental functions @xmath415 and @xmath416 define the same geometry , and that this is respected by the finsler gravity field equation . hence the following class of fundamental functions gives us good control over deviations from lorentzian metric geometry , @xmath417 here , @xmath418 is a @xmath419-homogeneous function that causes the finsler modifications of the lorentzian metric spacetime @xmath22 . the abbreviation @xmath286 should not be confused with the sasaki - type metric on @xmath7 . recall the finsler gravity vacuum field equation from ( [ eq : gravvac ] ) : @xmath420 we will now expand this equation to linear order in the modification @xmath418 , where @xmath421 . in the following calculations we suppress all higher order terms . we introduce @xmath422 and @xmath423 to expand the finsler function and finsler metric as @xmath424 the coefficients of the nonlinear connection are calculated from equation ( [ eq : nonlin ] ) : @xmath425 here , the @xmath426 are the christoffel symbols of the metric @xmath5 , and in the following @xmath58 acts as the levi civita connection . note that the zeroth order term , for @xmath427 , is the metric linear connection . the curvature and the tensor @xmath428 can be expressed with help of the shorthand notation @xmath429 as @xmath430- \nabla_a ( y^by^ct^a{}_{bc})+ \nabla(y^ct^a{}_{ac})\,,\\ s_a&=&\gamma^{\delta p}{}_{pa}-\bar\partial_p n^p{}_a \simeq -y^q\bar\partial_at^p{}_{pq}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the zeroth order term in @xmath265 is determined by the ricci tensor of @xmath5 , while @xmath431 . collecting all terms in the gravitational field equation ( [ eq : gravvac2 ] ) finally yields @xmath432+\frac{6}{g}y^ay^br_{ab}[g]\\ & + & \big[2 \frac{g}{|g| } l^{ab}r_{ab}[g]+\frac{6g-2l}{g^2}y^ay^br_{ab}[g]+g^{ab}\bar\partial_a\bar\partial_b(-\nabla_a ( y^by^ct^a{}_{bc})+\nabla(y^ct^a{}_{ac}))\nonumber \\ & & \quad- \frac{6}{g } ( -\nabla_a ( y^by^ct^a{}_{bc})+\nabla(y^ct^a{}_{ac}))-2 g^{ab}(\nabla_ay^q\bar\partial_bt^p{}_{pq}+\bar\partial_a\nabla y^q\bar\partial_bt^p{}_{pq})\big]\,.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the zeroth order contribution in the first line is equivalent to the einstein vacuum equations , as discussed in section [ sec : gravvac ] . the first order terms in square brackets determine the finsler modification of the unperturbed metric background solution . the details of how to rewrite the different terms of this equation in terms of the perturbation @xmath433 in the fundamental function @xmath26 , see ( [ eq : lpert ] ) , instead of @xmath434 can be found in appendix [ app : lin ] . we will now use our results on symmetries and on the linearisation of vacuum finsler gravity around metric spacetimes to derive a particular model that refines the linearised schwarzschild solution and can be used to study solar system physics . recall from section [ sec : sphsym ] that the dependence of the general spherically symmetric fundamental function in tangent bundle coordinates induced by @xmath435 is restricted to @xmath436 where @xmath437 . we wish to study such a spherically symmetric fundamental function that describes a finsler modification of lorentzian geometry . for simplicity , we consider a bimetric four - homogeneous finsler spacetime that perturbs the maximally symmetric vacuum solution of finsler gravity which is given by minkowski spacetime . we assume @xmath438 with @xmath439 . this ansatz has the explicit form @xmath440y^{t^2}+[1+b(r)]y^{r^2}+[1+c(r)]r^2w^2\big).\ ] ] observe that the function @xmath441 can not be transformed away by defining a new radial coordinate . although this could remove @xmath441 from the metric in the right hand bracket , such a coordinate change would generate extra terms in the metric appearing in the left hand bracket . therefore , the existence of the function @xmath441 as a physical degree of freedom is a finsler geometric effect that appears as a consequence of the bimetric spacetime structure assumed here . we will now solve the linearised finsler gravity equation ( [ eq : line ] ) for @xmath442 , @xmath443 and @xmath441 with the ansatz ( [ eq : bisphl ] ) . sorting the equation with respect to powers in @xmath444 and @xmath445 gives rise to three equations that have to be satisfied : @xmath446 the solution of these equations is @xmath447 we will now study the properties of this specific first order finsler spacetime solution and compare it to the linearized schwarzschild spacetime . we use the linearised expression for the non - linear connection coefficients in ( [ eq : nlinfirst ] ) to analyze the finsler geodesic equation that is derived by extremizing the proper time integral ( [ eq : fact ] ) . for a curve with coordinates @xmath448 this has the form @xmath449 . as usual in spherical symmetry , setting @xmath450 solves one of the four component equations immediately ; the remaining equations are @xmath451 from these equations we find two constants of motion @xmath452 these can be used to deduce the orbit equation from the affine normalization condition that @xmath453 along the finsler geodesic ; we employ ( [ eq : f2 ] ) and write @xmath454 for the sign of @xmath455 to obtain @xmath456 the geodesic equations , the constants of motion and the orbit equation are well suited to compare the bimetric linearised finsler solution with the linearised schwarzschild solution . to see the differences to this solution of einstein gravity we first note that @xmath457 can be absorbed into a redefinition of @xmath458 , hence can be assumed to be zero . second we introduce the schwarzschild radius @xmath459 to redefine @xmath460 , @xmath461 and @xmath462 in terms of dimensionless small constants @xmath463 , @xmath464 and @xmath465 . then the orbit equation becomes @xmath466 in the special case @xmath467 this is precisely the orbit equation in the linearized schwarzschild geometry , see @xcite ; the same limit also applies to the geodesic equations and the constants of motion . the finsler geometric refinements of the metric schwarzschild geometry are encoded in the constants @xmath468 and @xmath465 . these can in principle be fitted to data from solar system experiments . indeed , there are certain observations that can not be fully explained by the schwarzschild solution @xcite , for instance , the fly - by anomaly : for several spacecrafts it has been reported that swing - by manoeuvres lead to a small unexplained velocity increase . this corresponds to a change in the shape of the orbit of the spacecraft . such a change can in principle be modelled by finsler refinements ; the perturbations @xmath463 , @xmath464 and @xmath465 certainly provide possibilities to alter the wideness of the swing - by orbit as compared to that expected from einstein gravity . this can be confirmed by simple numerical calculations , see figure [ fig : flyby ] . _ numerical fly - by solutions of the geodesic equations for linearized schwarzschild geometry ( dashed line ) and the bimetric finsler refinement ( solid line ) with @xmath469 , @xmath470 and @xmath471 . the mass is centred at the origin an has schwarzschild radius @xmath472 . the initial conditions are @xmath473 , @xmath474 , @xmath475 , @xmath476 and @xmath477 for both curves , and @xmath478 is calculated from the respective unit normalization condition @xmath453._,scaledwidth=50.0% ] we have seen that finsler geometries exist that are extremely close to metric geometries . our specific example of a spherically symmetric bimetric perturbation around minkowski spacetime could be reinterpreted as a geometry close to the linearized schwarzschild solution of einstein gravity . the more complex causal structure , however , leads to additional constants that modify the geodesic equations and in particular the shape of test particle orbits . this could be a means to explain the fly - by anomaly in the solar system . we emphasize that this consequence already at first order perturbation theory gives a glimpse on the potential of finsler gravity . finsler geometry is fundamentally based on the reparametrization invariant length integral ( [ eq : fact ] ) . in physics , this integral can be used as a very general clock postulate on the one hand , and on the other as an action for massive point particles which automatically guarantees the very precisely tested weak equivalence principle . in previous work @xcite we formulated a set of minimal requirements for the application of finsler geometry to the description of spacetime . this led us to definition 1 of finsler spacetimes @xmath233 which have sufficient structure to provide notions of causality and are mathematically controlled generalizations of lorentzian geometry . in this article , we constructed an action for finsler gravity from first principles . our theory of finsler gravity ( [ eq : compact ] ) fully includes the description of matter fields which are coupled to finsler spacetime by a lifting principle that generates the appropriate action from the standard lagrangian on lorentzian spacetime . we derived the gravitational field equation by variation with respect to the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 , and could show that it consistently becomes equivalent to the einstein field equations in the metric geometry limit . hence einstein gravity can be seen as special case of our gravity theory based on finsler geometry . we presented the geometric definition 2 of observers on finsler spacetimes along with a clear interpretation of how they measure physical fields . by theorem 2 we were able to characterize the class of transformations that relates two different observers at the same point of the spacetime manifold ; these transformations have the algebraic structure of a groupoid as proven in theorem 3 . any observer transformation can be understood as the composition of a usual lorentz transformation and an identification of the two observers four - velocities by a geometrically well - defined parallel transport . for the limiting case of metric geometries , this parallel transport trivializes so that the transformation groupoid becomes equivalent to the standard lorentz group . in this sense , finsler spacetimes generalize lorentz invariance instead of violating it . as a further formal development we presented definition 4 of symmetries of finsler spacetimes and theorem 4 that shows some of their basic properties . we applied this notion to determine the most general fundamental geometry functions consistent with spherical , cosmological , or maximal symmetry . maximally symmetric finsler spacetimes are in fact maximally symmetric metric spacetimes , and the only maximally symmetric source - free vacuum solution of finsler gravity is minkowski spacetime . as a concrete application of the results of this article we studied a simple spherically symmetric bimetric perturbation around this flat metric vacuum . we found a first order solution of the finsler gravity equation which is a refinement of the linearized schwarzschild solution of einstein gravity . with a special choice of the parameters in our solution the resulting geodesics are identical to those of linearized schwarzschild spacetime . this demonstrates that weak field gravitational experiments may not be sufficient to distinguish finsler spacetimes from lorentzian metric spacetimes . but we saw that the full set of parameters in our model solution could be capable to resolve the fly - by anomaly in the solar system . this is very promising , and creates a strong motivation for more intensive studies of our new theory of gravity . it is natural to ask whether the additional degrees of freedom of finsler spacetime solutions as compared to metric spacetimes may lead to new insights on the dark matter distributions in galaxies or dark energy in the universe . these could be effects of a fundamentally more complex spacetime geometry instead of being particle physics phenomena . it will be possible to study these questions once solutions of finsler gravity , especially for spherical symmetry and cosmology , become available . for cosmology , it will also be necessary to study perfect fluid sources for finsler spacetimes . we saw in @xcite that finsler spacetimes can provide a geometric explanation of the opera measurements of superluminal neutrinos @xcite . the velocity difference between the neutrinos and the speed of light recognized as the boundary velocity of observers depends not only on the energy and mass of the neutrino , but also on the underlying spacetime geometry . so also in this context , solutions for spherical symmetry and cosmology are needed in order to understand the size of the effect for the different observed neutrino sources . further important topics for future research are the coupling of spinor fields , the analysis of field theories on the generalized causal structure of finsler spacetimes and their quantization . cp and mnrw thank niklas hbel , claudio dappiaggi , andreas degner , klaus fredenhagen , manuel hohmann , matthias lange , falk lindner , gunnar preuss and felix tennie for inspiring discussions . they acknowledge full financial support from the german research foundation dfg under grant wo 1447/1 - 1 . this appendix presents technical details for several derivations in the main text . in particular , we show how to perform the variation of the finsler gravity and matter field actions on the unit tangent bundle ; for completeness we state the complete lifts of the cosmological symmetry generators ; and we display some additional material on the linearized finsler gravity equations . the finsler gravitational field equation presented in section [ sec : gravvac ] can be deduced from our new finsler gravity action as follows . before we consider the variation of the matter part with respect to the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 in the next section , we here take a look at the pure gravity action ( [ eq : gravact ] ) : @xmath479=\int d^4\hat xd^3u \left[\sqrt{g^fh^f}\ r^a{}_{ab}y^b\right]_{|\sigma}\,.\ ] ] the integrand is homogeneous of degree five ; to obtain the first intermediate step ( [ eq : calcgrav1 ] ) of the variation we use the facts that for @xmath254 homogeneous of degree @xmath388 holds @xmath480 and that @xmath481 . the second step ( [ eq : calcgrav2 ] ) is obtained by using the coordinate transformation formulae ( [ eq : invvv ] ) and the fact that @xmath482 to calculate @xmath483 which in turn is used to deduce @xmath484r^a{}_{ab}y^b+\delta r^a{}_{ab}\,y^b\big).\ ] ] the formulae ( [ eq : calcgrav ] ) used in the third step of the variation are basically obtained by means of integration by parts ( [ eq : intbp ] ) . for a function @xmath254 that is @xmath388-homogeneous in @xmath278 the following holds @xmath485 choosing @xmath486 which has @xmath487 proves formula ( [ eq : calcgrav31 ] ) . to show equation ( [ eq : calcgrav32 ] ) we first write @xmath488 and use @xmath489d}+2y^ps^a{}_{q[b}\gamma^{\delta q}{}_{c]p}\ ] ] to equate @xmath490q}-\frac{1}{2}s_{c}\delta\gamma^{\delta c}{}_{bq}\big)\nonumber\\ & = & -\nabla_a ( y^by^q\delta \gamma^{\delta a}{}_{bq})+y^b\nabla_b(y^q\delta \gamma^{\delta a}{}_{aq})+s_{c}\delta\gamma^{\delta c}{}_{bq}y^by^q\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the integration by parts formulae ( [ eq : intbp ] ) and @xmath491 then yield the desired equation @xmath492 combining these three steps as we did in section [ sec : gravvac ] finally produces the finsler gravity vacuum field equation ( [ eq : gravvac ] ) . in section [ sec : gravmat ] we presented a coupling principle of matter fields to finsler gravity . the crucial steps of the derivation of the constraints ( [ eq : cons ] ) , equations of motion ( [ eq : eom1 ] ) and ( [ eq : eom2 ] ) , and of the metric limit of the complete gravity equation ( [ eq : fgrav ] ) including the matter source terms shall be presented here . recall the matter action for a @xmath281-form field @xmath297 on finsler spacetime arises from a lift of the standard @xmath281-form action on lorentzian spacetime as @xmath493=\int_\sigma d^4xd^3u\ \big[\sqrt{g^fh^f } \big(\mathcal{l}(g,\phi , \mathrm{d}\phi)+\lambda ( 1-p^h)\phi\big ) \big]_{|\sigma}\,.\ ] ] in order to perform the variation we consider all objects in the horizontal / vertical basis of @xmath17 where @xmath494 is diagonal , see ( [ eq : sasaki ] ) . in the following the @xmath495 label both horizontal and vertical indices , @xmath496 label vertical indices , and @xmath497 label horizontal indices . then @xmath498 and the variation of this lagrangian can now be written as follows @xmath499 we can immediately read off the variation with respect to the lagrange multiplier components which produces ( [ eq : cons ] ) . hence the lagrange multiplier @xmath298 sets to zero all components of @xmath151 with at least one vertical index , so that only purely horizontal components remain on - shell . the expansion of @xmath500 in components with respect to the horizontal / vertical basis yields @xmath501 } - \frac{p(p+1)}{2}\gamma^q{}_{[nm_1}\phi_{|q|m_2 ... m_p]}\,,\ ] ] where we write @xmath502 , and @xmath503 denote the commutator coefficients of the horizontal / vertical basis . their only non - vanishing components are given by @xmath504^{\bar a}=r^{\bar a}{}_{bc}$ ] and @xmath505^{\bar a}=\bar\partial_b n^{\bar a}{}_c$ ] . one now uses the integration by parts formulae ( [ eq : intbp ] ) to obtain the variation of the matter action with respect to @xmath151 ; this produces the equations of motion ( [ eq : eom1 ] ) and ( [ eq : eom2 ] ) . finally the source term for the gravity field equation is obtained by variation of the matter action @xmath322 in ( [ eq : actm ] ) with respect to the fundamental geometry function @xmath26 . this not only includes the variation ( [ eq : vari ] ) but also that of the volume element which can be read off from ( [ eq : volu ] ) . we will now show that the metric limit of finsler gravity plus matter is consistent ; this can be done on - shell where we may use the lagrange multiplier constraints to set all explicitly appearing @xmath506 to zero . then the variation of @xmath322 with respect to @xmath26 becomes @xmath507&=&\int_\sigma d^4xd^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma } \big[\big(g^{fab}\bar\partial_a\bar\partial_b\mathcal{l}+4\mathcal{l}\big)\frac{\delta l}{nl}\nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad+\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial g_{mn}}\delta g_{mn}+\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial ( \mathrm{d}\phi_{nm_1 ... m_k})}\delta ( \mathrm{d}\phi_{nm_1m_k})\big]_{|\sigma}\nonumber\\ & = & \int_\sigma d^4xd^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma } \big[\big(g^{fab}\bar\partial_a\bar\partial_b\mathcal{l}+4\mathcal{l}\big)\frac{\delta l}{nl}\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad+\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial g^f_{ab}}\delta g^f_{ab}+\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial g^f_{\bar a\bar b}}\delta\big ( \frac{g^f_{\bar a \bar b}}{f^2}\big)+\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial ( \mathrm{d}\phi_{ba_1 ... a_k})}\delta ( \delta_{[b}\phi_{a_1 .. a_k]})\big]_{|\sigma}\,.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to determine the energy momentum scalar @xmath326 defined in ( [ eq : ems ] ) on a generic finsler spacetime one has to calculate all terms in the expression above carefully . however , in the metric geometry limit the last two terms vanish . indeed , @xmath508 is always composed from terms with vertical indices that must be either of the type @xmath509 or contain components of @xmath151 with at least one vertical index ; the last term is proportional to @xmath510 ; in the metric limit @xmath511 vanishes and the vertical index components of @xmath151 are zero on - shell . therefore the remaining terms that are relevant in the metric limit are @xmath512 \rightarrow \int_\sigma d^4xd^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma } \big[\big(g^{fab}\bar\partial_a\bar\partial_b\mathcal{l}+4\mathcal{l}\big)\frac{\delta l}{nl}+\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial g^f_{ab}}\delta g^f_{ab}\big]_{|\sigma}\,.\ ] ] the rewriting @xmath513 and subsequent integration by parts yields @xmath514_{|\sigma}\\ & = & \int_\sigma d^4xd^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma } \big[-\bar\partial_c k^c+\big(-g^{fij}\bar\partial_cg^f_{ij}+4g^f_{ic}y^i\big)k^c\big]_{|\sigma}\frac{\delta l}{nl}\nonumber\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath515 applying the metric limit now means to consider @xmath23 with the consequence that @xmath516 for timelike @xmath278 . the expression for @xmath517 reduces to @xmath518 and @xmath519 . collecting all terms in the variation of the matter action in the metric geometry limit finally yields @xmath512 \rightarrow \int_\sigma d^4xd^3u\ \sqrt{g^fh^f}_{|\sigma } \big[4\mathcal{l}-4g_{cd}\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial g_{cd}}-24y^cy^d\frac{\partial \mathcal{l}}{\partial g_{cd}}\big]_{|\sigma}\frac{\delta l}{nl}\,,\ ] ] from which we can read off the expression for the source term @xmath326 , @xmath520 the lift of this expression to @xmath7 requires making all terms zero homogeneous by multiplication with the appropriate powers of @xmath521 , which here means multiplication of the third term by @xmath522 . the result confirms equation ( [ eq : tsig ] ) that was used to prove the consistency of finsler gravity with einstein gravity in the metric geometry limit . we deduced the most general fundamental geometry function @xmath26 for finsler spacetimes with cosmological symmetries in section [ sec : fsym ] . the derivation requires the complete lifts of the symmetry - generating vector fields ( [ eq : csym ] ) which we display here explicitly : @xmath523 @xmath524 @xmath525 the complete lifts @xmath526 , @xmath527 and @xmath528 are stated in equations ( [ eq : ssymc ] ) . in the formulae above we use the abbreviation @xmath387 and primes denote differentiation with respect to the coordinate @xmath529 . in order to study the finsler gravitational field equation perturbatively we have considered a class of finsler spacetimes that are mild deviations from metric geometry in section [ subsec : modlgeom ] . here we list for completeness how to rewrite the appearing geometric objects in terms of the perturbation @xmath433 instead of the variable @xmath434 used in the main text . these identities can now be employed to determine the curvature scalar @xmath250 of the cartan non - linear connection which we use as the basic ingredient in our construction of finsler gravity : @xmath531-\frac{g^{1-k}}{2k}g^{ag}\big(\nabla_a\nabla \bar\partial_q h-\nabla_a\nabla_q h-\frac{1}{2}\nabla\nabla \bar\partial_a\bar\partial_q h\big)\\ & & { } -\frac{2(1-k)g^{-k}}{2k}g^{aq}\big(g_{qi}y^i\nabla_a\nabla h-\frac{1}{2}\nabla\nabla\big(g_{qi}y^i\bar\partial_a h+g_{ai}y^i\bar\partial_qh+(g_{aq}-\frac{2k}{g}g_{ai}y^ig_{qj}y^j ) h\big)\big)\nonumber\\ & = & -y^ay^br_{ab}[g(x)]-\frac{g^{1-k}}{2k}g^{ag}\big(\nabla_a\nabla \bar\partial_q h-\nabla_a\nabla_q h-\frac{1}{2}\nabla\nabla \bar\partial_a\bar\partial_q h\big)+\frac{(1-k)(1+k)g^{-k}}{k}\nabla\nabla h\,.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] c. m. will , living rev . rel . * 9 * ( 2005 ) 3 [ gr - qc/0510072 ] . s. baessler , b. r. heckel , e. g. adelberger , j. h. gundlach , u. schmidt and h. e. swanson , phys . * 83 * ( 1999 ) 3585 . d. bao , s.s . chern and z. shen , _ an introduction to riemann - finsler geometry _ , springer new york 2000 . z. chang and x. li , phys . b * 668 * ( 2008 ) 453 [ arxiv:0806.2184 [ gr - qc ] ] . z. chang and x. li , phys . b * 676 * ( 2009 ) 173 [ arxiv:0901.1023 [ gr - qc ] ] . c. pfeifer and m. n. r. wohlfarth , arxiv:1109.6005 [ gr - qc ] . c. lammerzahl , o. preuss and h. dittus , gr - qc/0604052 . j. c. baez , a. e. hoffnung and c. d. walker , arxiv:0812.4864 [ math.qa ] . x. li and z. chang , arxiv:1010.2020 [ gr - qc ] . k. yano and s. ishihara , tangent and cotangent bundles , marcel dekker , new york 1973 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: a detailed description of flow in porous media is essential for building mathematical models with applications in , for example , water management , oil and gas recovery , carbon dioxide ( co@xmath0 ) sequestration or nuclear waste disposal . in order to set up a reliable numerical model , one needs to have a good knowledge of the problem geometry and input parameters . for example , the flow of water in granite rock , which is a suitable site for nuclear waste disposal , is driven by the complex system of vugs , cavities and fractures with various topology and sizes . these alter the effective permeability , and therefore should be accurately accounted for in the numerical model . there are two main approaches : either the fractures are considered as free - flow regions , or the fractures contain debris and are also modelled as porous media with specific permeabilities . in the first case , a unified approach to modelling free - flow and porous media regions can be provided by the so called stokes - brinkman equation , which reduces to either the stokes or darcy model in certain parameter limits , e.g. , within the multiscale mixed finite - element ( msmfe ) framework @xcite . in this paper , we consider the latter case , and apply darcy s law to the flow in the reservoir and in the fractures as well ; see @xcite for a related approach . in either case , the preferential flow in large geological dislocations and their intersections should be considered as two- and one - dimensional flows , respectively . due to the quite complex structure of the domains , the discretisation is performed using finite element methods ( fem ) . the resulting meshes are therefore unstructured , and they combine different spatial dimensions ( line elements in 1d , triangles in 2d , and tetrahedrons in 3d ) . the systems of linear equations obtained from the fem discretisation are often very large , so that using direct methods is prohibitive and iterative solvers are warranted . the systems are typically also bad - conditioned due to the mixing of spatial dimensions , large jumps in permeability coefficients and presence of elements of considerably different sizes , and so they are challenging for iterative solvers as well . the matrices have a saddle - point structure @xmath1{cc}a & \ol{b}^{t}\\ \ol{b } & -\ol{c } \end{array } \right ] , \label{eq : sp - matrix}\ ] ] where @xmath2 is symmetric positive definite on the kernel of @xmath3 , @xmath4 is symmetric positive semi - definite , and it is positive definite on the kernel of @xmath5 . the ` penalty ' block @xmath6 arises from connecting meshes of different spatial dimensions . the iterative solution of systems with this structure is a frequently studied topic ; see , for example , @xcite , the monographs @xcite or toselli-2005-ddm and the references therein . however , efficient methodologies for solving saddle - point problems are typically problem dependent . in this paper , we develop a robust and scalable solver for linear systems with the saddle - point structure as in ( [ eq : sp - matrix ] ) with the block@xmath7 either zero or nonzero . the solver is tailored to the mixed - hybrid formulation of flow in porous media using the lowest order raviart - thomas ( @xmath8 ) finite elements with combined mesh dimensions ( 1d , 2d and 3d ) . in particular , we adapt the balancing domain decomposition by constraints ( bddc ) method to this type of problems . the bddc method is currently one of the most popular methods of iterative substructuring . it has been proposed independently in @xcite ; see @xcite for the proof of equivalence . even though bddc has been originally formulated for elliptic problems , it has been successfully extended , for example , beyond elliptic cases @xcite and to multiple levels @xcite . an optimal set - up has been studied in @xcite . a closely related bddc preconditioner for vector field problems discretised with raviart - thomas finite elements has been studied in @xcite . we are interested in applications of the bddc method to saddle - point problems . if @xmath9 in ( [ eq : sp - matrix ] ) , one possible approach is to use an algebraic trick and constrain the iterative solution of the indefinite problem into a _ balanced _ subspace , which is sometimes also called _ benign _ , where the operator is positive definite ; see @xcite for the stokes problem , and @xcite for flow in porous media . however , due to the mixed - hybrid formulation and possible coupling of meshes with different spatial dimensions , @xmath6 in general , and we will favour an alternative , _ dual _ approach here . our methodology is as follows . the mixed - hybrid formulation @xcite is used in order to modify the saddle - point problem to one which is symmetric and positive definite by means of iterative substructuring . in particular , we introduce a symmetric positive definite schur complement with respect to interface lagrange multipliers , corresponding to a part of block @xmath4 . the reduced system is solved by the preconditioned conjugate gradient ( pcg ) method , and the bddc method is used as a preconditioner . from this perspective , our work can be viewed as a further extension of @xcite . our main effort here is in accommodating the bddc solver to flows in porous media with combined mesh dimensions . in addition , the presentation of the bddc algorithm is driven more by an efficient implementation , while it is more oriented towards underlying theory in @xcite . we take advantage of the special structure of the blocks in matrix ( [ eq : sp - matrix ] ) studied in detail in @xcite . in particular , the nonzero structure of block @xmath4 resulting from a combination of meshes with different spatial dimensions is considered in @xcite . we describe our parallel implementation of the method and study its performance on several benchmark and real - world problems . another original contribution of this paper is proposing a new scaling operator in the bddc method suitable for the studied problems . we note that if there is no coupling of meshes with different spatial dimensions present in the discretisation , the block @xmath9 in ( [ eq : sp - matrix ] ) and our method is almost identical to the one introduced in @xcite . the paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec : model ] , we introduce the model problem . in section [ sec : fractures ] , we describe the modelling of fractured porous media and combining meshes of different dimensions . in section [ sec : substructuring ] , we introduce the substructuring components and derive the interface problem . in section [ sec : bddc ] , we formulate the bddc preconditioner . in addition , the selection of interface weights for bddc is studied in detail in section [ sec : scaling ] . in section [ sec : solver ] , we describe our parallel implementation , and in section [ sec : numerical ] we report the numerical results and parallel performance for benchmark and engineering problems . finally , section [ sec : conclusion ] provides a summary of our work . our notation does not , for simplicity , distinguish between finite element functions and corresponding algebraic vectors of degrees of freedom , and between linear operators and matrices within a specific basis the meaning should be clear from the context . the transpose of a matrix is denoted by superscript @xmath10 and the energy norm of a vector@xmath11 is denoted by @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is a symmetric positive definite matrix . let @xmath14 be an open bounded polyhedral domain in @xmath15 . we are interested in the solution of the following problem , combining darcy s law and the equation of continuity written as @xmath16 subject to boundary conditions on @xmath17 , where @xmath18 stands for the part of the boundary with _ natural _ ( dirichlet ) boundary condition , and @xmath19 for the part with _ essential _ ( neumann ) boundary condition . in applications , the variable@xmath20 describes the velocity of the fluid and @xmath21 the pressure ( head ) in an aquifer @xmath14 , @xmath22 is a symmetric positive definite tensor of the hydraulic conductivity , @xmath23 is the gravity term , and @xmath24 is the outer unit normal vector of @xmath25 . the term @xmath26 is present due to the fact , that @xmath27 satisfies @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the piezometric head . for a thorough discussion of application background we refer , e.g. , to monographs @xcite . let @xmath30 be the triangulation of domain @xmath14 consisting of @xmath31 simplicial elements with characteristic size @xmath32 . we introduce a space @xmath33 equipped with the standard norm . let @xmath34 be the space consisting of the lowest order raviart - thomas ( @xmath8 ) functions and let @xmath35 be the space consisting of piecewise constant functions on the elements of the triangulation @xmath30 . we refer , e.g. , to monograph @xcite for a detailed description of the mixed finite elements and the corresponding spaces . in the _ mixed finite element approximation _ of problem ( [ eq : problem-1])([eq : problem-4 ] ) we look for a pair @xmath36 that satisfies @xmath37 in the discrete formulation , we need @xmath38 and @xmath39 only sufficiently regular so that the integrals in the weak formulation ( [ eq : mixed-1])([eq : mixed-2 ] ) make sense , namely @xmath40 , @xmath41 . next , we recall the mixed - hybrid formulation . it was originally motivated by an effort to modify the saddle - point problem ( [ eq : mixed-1])([eq : mixed-2 ] ) to one which leads to symmetric positive definite matrices . nevertheless , this formulation is also suitable for a combination of meshes with different spatial dimensions , which will be described in detail in the next section . let @xmath42 denote the set of inter - element _ faces _ of the triangulation @xmath30 . we now introduce several additional spaces . first , let us define the space @xmath43 by relaxing the condition of continuity of the normal components in the space @xmath44 on inter - element boundaries @xmath42 . more precisely , we define local spaces @xmath45 for each element @xmath46 , @xmath47 , by @xmath48 and put @xmath49 . next , we define the space of lagrange multipliers @xmath50 consisting of functions that take constant values on individual inter - element faces in @xmath42 , @xmath51 in particular , @xmath52 on @xmath25 for any @xmath53 . in the _ mixed - hybrid finite element approximation _ of problem ( [ eq : problem-1])([eq : problem-4 ] ) , we look for a triple @xmath54 that satisfies @xmath55 & \label{eq : hybrid-1}\\ = -\int_{\partial\omega_{n}}p_{n}\mathbf{v}\cdot\mathbf{n}\,ds-\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}}\int_{t^{i}}v_{z}\,dx,\quad\forall\mathbf{v } & \in\mathbf{v}^{-1},\nonumber\\ -\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}}\left [ \int_{t^{i}}q\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}\,dx\right ] & = -\int_{\omega}fq\,dx,\quad\forall q\in q,\label{eq : hybrid-2}\\ \sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}}\left [ \int_{\partial t^{i}\setminus\partial\omega}\mu(\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n})|_{\partial t_{i}}\,ds\right ] & = 0,\quad\forall\mu\in\lambda . \label{eq : hybrid-3}\ ] ] equation ( [ eq : hybrid-3 ] ) imposes a continuity condition on the normal component of the velocity ( also called _ normal flux _ ) @xmath56 across @xmath42 which guarantees that @xmath57 . this condition also implies the equivalence of the two formulations ( [ eq : mixed-1])([eq : mixed-2 ] ) and ( [ eq : hybrid-1])([eq : hybrid-3 ] ) . we note that the lagrange multipliers @xmath58 can be interpreted as the approximation of the trace of @xmath21 on @xmath42 , see @xcite for details . let us now write the matrix formulation corresponding to ( [ eq : hybrid-1])([eq : hybrid-3 ] ) as @xmath1{ccc}a & b^{t } & b_{\mathcal{f}}^{t}\\ b & 0 & 0\\ b_{\mathcal{f } } & 0 & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}\mathbf{u}\\ p\\ \lambda \end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}g\\ f\\ 0 \end{array } \right ] . \label{eq : hybrid - m}\ ] ] it is important to note that @xmath2 is block diagonal with @xmath31 blocks , corresponding to elements @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and each of the blocks is symmetric positive definite , cf . the first term in ( [ eq : hybrid-1 ] ) . it was shown in @xcite that the system of equations ( [ eq : hybrid - m ] ) can be reduced ( twice ) to the schur complement corresponding to the lagrange multipliers @xmath58 and solved efficiently by a direct or iterative solver . here , we will look for an efficient solution of a slightly modified , and in general also block dense , system which is introduced in the next section . in this section , we recall the main ideas of the discrete model of the flow in fractured porous media that is based on connection of meshes of different dimensions as described in @xcite . let us denote the full domain by @xmath61 . next , consider lower - dimensional domains @xmath62 , @xmath63 , such that @xmath64 consists of polygons and @xmath65 consists of line segments . we will also assume that @xmath66 . the first condition requires that a domain of a lower dimension can not poke out of the domain of higher dimension , while the second condition prevents domains of lower dimension from having boundaries in the interior of domains of higher dimension . we impose these conditions to avoid technical difficulties in the analysis . however , numerical evidence suggests that these conditions are not necessary , and in fact , they are not satisfied for the real - world problems presented in section [ sec : results_engineering ] . for every dimension @xmath67 , we introduce a triangulation @xmath68 of the domain @xmath69 that consists of finite elements @xmath70 @xmath71 and satisfies the compatibility conditions @xmath72 for every @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath63 . this means that elements of a lower dimension match faces of elements of the higher dimension . we consider equations ( [ eq : problem-2])([eq : problem-4 ] ) on the domains @xmath69 , @xmath67 , completed by a slight modification of the darcy s law ( [ eq : problem-1 ] ) : @xmath75 where @xmath76 stands for the velocity integrated over the cross - section for @xmath77 , i.e. the units of @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath80 are ms@xmath81 , m@xmath82s@xmath81 , and m@xmath83s@xmath81 , respectively . in addition , @xmath84 , @xmath85 is the thickness of a fracture , and @xmath86 is the cross - section of a 1d preferential channel . the effective fluid source @xmath87 on @xmath64 is given as @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the density of external fluid sources , and the normal fluxes from the two faces of the 3d continuum surrounding the fracture are given through the robin ( also called newton ) boundary conditions @xmath90 in the last formula , @xmath91 are the transition coefficients ( cf . @xcite for possible choices ) and @xmath92 , @xmath93 are the traces of pressure @xmath94 on the two sides of the fracture . the effective fluid source @xmath95 on @xmath65 is similar , @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the density of external fluid sources . in the 3d ambient space , the 1d channel can be connected to @xmath98 faces of 2d fractures . thus @xmath99 is the normal flux from the connected fracture @xmath98 , @xmath100 is the transition coefficient , and @xmath101 is the trace of pressure @xmath102 on the face of fracture @xmath98 . in the following , we describe the discrete mixed - hybrid formulation of the problem . the formulation and discussion of the continuous problem can be found in @xcite . let us consider spaces@xmath103 for the definition of the space @xmath50 , we can not follow ( [ eq : lambda_space ] ) directly , since e.g. on @xmath64 , we need to distinguish values of @xmath104 on two sides of a fracture . thus , we introduce a separate value for every non - boundary side of every element : @xmath105 where @xmath106 is defined in the same way as the space @xmath44 but on the domain @xmath69 . further , we identify values on faces / points that are not aligned to the fractures / channels : @xmath107 finally , we redefine @xmath108 . in the _ mixed - hybrid finite element approximation _ of the flow in fractured porous media we seek a triple @xmath109 that satisfies @xmath110 with @xmath111 , \label{eq : weak_term_a}\\ b\left ( \mathbf{u},q\right ) & = -\sum_{d=1}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\left [ \int_{t_{d}^{i}}q_{d}\,\left ( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}_{d}\right ) \,dx\right ] , \\ b_{\mathcal{f}}\left ( \mathbf{u},\lambda\right ) & = \sum_{d=1}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\left [ \int_{\partial t_{d}^{i}\setminus\partial \omega_{d}}\lambda|_{\partial t_{d}^{i}}\,\left ( \mathbf{u}_{d}\cdot\mathbf{n}\right ) \,ds\right ] , \\ c\left ( p , q\right ) & = \sum_{d=2}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\left [ \int_{\partial t_{d}^{i}\cap\omega_{d-1}}\sigma_{d}\,\,p_{d-1}\,q_{d-1}\,ds\right ] , \label{eq : weak_term_cbar}\\ c_{\mathcal{f}}\left ( p,\mu\right ) & = -\sum_{d=2}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\left [ \int_{\partial t_{d}^{i}\cap\omega_{d-1}}\sigma_{d}\ p_{d-1}\,\mu_{d}\,ds\right ] , \label{eq : weak_term_cf}\\ \widetilde{c}\left ( \lambda,\mu\right ) & = \sum_{d=2}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\left [ \int_{\partial t_{d}^{i}\cap\omega_{d-1}}\sigma _ { d}\,\,\lambda_{d}\,\mu_{d}\,ds\right ] , \label{eq : weak_term_ctilde}\\ \left\langle g,\mathbf{v}\right\rangle & = -\sum_{d=1}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\int_{\partial t_{d}^{i}\cap\partial\omega_{n}}p_{n}\,\left ( \mathbf{v}\cdot\mathbf{n}\right ) \,ds { -\sum_{d=1}^{3}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{e}^{d}}\int_{t_{d}^{i}}v_{z}\,dx},\\ \left\langle f , q\right\rangle & = -\sum_{d=1}^{3}\int_{\omega } \delta_{d}\,\tilde{f}_{d}\,q_{d}\,dx . \label{eq : weak_term_f}\ ] ] the system ( [ eq : hybrid - frac-1])([eq : hybrid - frac-3 ] ) now leads to the matrix form @xmath1{ccc}a & b^{t } & b_{\mathcal{f}}^{t}\\ b & -c & -c_{\mathcal{f}}^{t}\\ b_{\mathcal{f } } & -c_{\mathcal{f } } & -\widetilde{c}\end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}\mathbf{u}\\ p\\ \lambda \end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}g\\ f\\ 0 \end{array } \right ] . \label{eq : hybrid - m - fractured}\ ] ] we note that ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) is related to ( [ eq : hybrid - frac-1])([eq : hybrid - frac-3 ] ) in the same way as ( [ eq : hybrid - m ] ) is related to ( [ eq : hybrid-1])([eq : hybrid-3 ] ) . the main difference in the structure of the matrices between ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) and ( [ eq : hybrid - m ] ) is the additional block @xmath112{cc}c & c_{\mathcal{f}}^{t}\\ c_{\mathcal{f } } & \widetilde{c}\end{array } \right ] $ ] related to the normal fluxes between dimensions and arising from ( [ eq : newton-1])([eq : newton-2 ] ) and ( [ eq : newton-3 ] ) via ( [ eq : weak_term_cbar])([eq : weak_term_ctilde ] ) . in particular , the modified right - hand side of the continuity equation for two - dimensional and one - dimensional elements , @xmath87 and @xmath95 , incorporates pressure unknowns on 2d and 1d elements , and traces of pressure on 3d and 2d elements at the fracture , which are nothing but the lagrange multipliers on 3d and 2d elements in the mixed - hybrid method . consequently , @xmath113 in ( [ eq : newton-1])([eq : newton-2 ] ) , and @xmath114 in ( [ eq : newton-3 ] ) . assuming @xmath115 bounded and greater than zero , and using the fact that @xmath116 corresponds to a symmetric positive definite matrix , we see from ( [ eq : weak_term_a ] ) that block @xmath2 in ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) is symmetric positive definite . block @xmath4 is symmetric positive semi - definite since @xmath117 .\ ] ] the following theorem is a standard result , e.g. brezzi-1991-mhf . here , we rewrite it in a form suitable for our setting and we verify the assumptions for the specific blocks of the matrix in ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) . we will further denote @xmath118 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 , and @xmath121 . [ th : regular ] let natural boundary conditions ( [ eq : problem-3 ] ) be prescribed at a certain part of the boundary , i.e. @xmath122 for at least one @xmath123 . then the discrete mixed - hybrid problem ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) has a unique solution . let us first investigate the structure of the matrix in ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) more closely . let us number the unknowns within each block of ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) with respect to spatial dimension @xmath123 . the matrix then takes the form of 9@xmath1249 blocks , @xmath125.\ ] ] suppose for a moment that we solve a problem only on domain @xmath69 , @xmath126 ( i.e. @xmath127 for @xmath128 ) . if no natural boundary conditions are imposed , there is a single @xmath129 entry on each row of @xmath130 and a single @xmath131 entry on each row of @xmath132 . since @xmath69 is a simply connected set , the matrix @xmath133 $ ] has a nontrivial nullspace of constant vectors . enforcing natural boundary condition on a part of @xmath134 changes the @xmath131 value on the corresponding row of matrix @xmath132 to @xmath135 , in which case @xmath136 has only a trivial nullspace , i.e. full column rank ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * section iv.1 ) or ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3.2 ) ) . the nullspace becomes more complicated for domains with fractures , in which case @xmath69 typically has more simply connected components separated by fractures ( cf . [ fig : schemes ] ) . let us denote them @xmath137 , @xmath138 , regardless of the dimension . in particular , @xmath137 , @xmath139 will be components without natural condition boundary , i.e. @xmath140 , while for @xmath141 we get components with prescribed natural boundary condition . we also denote @xmath142 the characteristic vector of the component @xmath137 that takes value @xmath131 for degrees of freedom associated with elements and faces of the component @xmath137 . with such notation , the basis of the nullspace of the whole matrix @xmath143\ ] ] consists of characteristic vectors @xmath144 , @xmath145 and has dimension @xmath146 . next , we show that matrix @xmath4 is not only symmetric positive semi - definite , as seen from ( [ eq : c_semi_definite ] ) , but also positive definite on @xmath147 . to this end , take @xmath148 , a vector that is piecewise constant on components , having value @xmath149 on the component @xmath137 of dimension @xmath150 for @xmath139 , and value @xmath151 for other components . then @xmath152 implies @xmath153 . indeed , every component @xmath137 of dimension @xmath63 has some component @xmath154 of dimension @xmath155 on its boundary , and therefore all @xmath149 have the same value , cf . ( [ eq : c_semi_definite ] ) . this value is zero , since there is at least one component with natural boundary condition . applying the congruence transformation , @xmath156 = \left [ \begin{matrix } i & \\ \ol{b } a^{-1 } & i \end{matrix } \right ] \left [ \begin{matrix } a & \\ & -\left ( \ol{b}a^{-1}\ol{b}^t + \ol{c } \right ) \end{matrix } \right ] \left [ \begin{matrix } i & a^{-1 } \ol{b}^t \\ & i \end{matrix } \right].\ ] ] matrix @xmath2 is symmetric positive definite ( spd ) from ( [ eq : weak_term_a ] ) and therefore @xmath157 is spd on range @xmath3 , which is the orthogonal complement of the nullspace of @xmath5 . thus @xmath158 is spd on whole @xmath159 . from the sylvester law of inertia , the number of positive , negative and zero eigenvalues is preserved by the congruence transformation . since the block diagonal matrix on the right - hand side of ( [ eq : congruence1 ] ) has only ( strictly ) positive and ( strictly ) negative eigenvalues , the matrix on the left - hand side also must be nonsingular , and problem ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) has a unique solution . example of a two - dimensional problem : even single fracture gives rise to two components of the two - dimensional mesh ( left ) ; example of three ( shaded ) triangles sharing a single lagrange multiplier in 3d ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=25.0% ] example of a two - dimensional problem : even single fracture gives rise to two components of the two - dimensional mesh ( left ) ; example of three ( shaded ) triangles sharing a single lagrange multiplier in 3d ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] for our purposes of combining meshes with different spatial dimensions , we define _ substructures _ as subsets of finite elements in the mesh rather than parts of a physical domain , cf . @xcite . to begin , let us define the combined triangulation @xmath160 as the union of triangulations for each spatial dimension , i.e. , @xmath161 . the triangulation @xmath160 is subsequently divided into substructures@xmath162 . note that in general a substructure can contain finite elements of different dimensions . we define the interface @xmath163 as the set of degrees of freedom shared by more than one substructure . note that @xmath164 for the current setting . thus , let us split the lagrange multipliers@xmath165 into two subsets . first , we denote by@xmath166 the set of multipliers corresponding to the interface@xmath167 . the remaining multipliers , corresponding to substructure interiors , will be denoted by@xmath168 . the interface@xmath169 of substructure@xmath170 is defined as a subset of@xmath167 corresponding to@xmath171 . next , let @xmath172 be defined as the space of lagrange multipliers corresponding to @xmath173 , @xmath174 , and define a space @xmath175 the substructure problems are obtained by assembling contributions of finite elements in each@xmath170,@xmath1{cccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it}\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma } ^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}{\gamma}}^{i}\end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}\mathbf{u}^{i}\\ p^{i}\\ \lambda_{i}^{i}\\ \lambda_{\gamma}^{i}\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}g^{i}\\ f^{i}\\ 0\\ 0 \end{array } \right ] , \qquad i=1,\dots , n_{s } , \label{eq : hybrid - fractured - substructure}\ ] ] where the blocks @xmath176 are block diagonal with blocks corresponding to finite element matrices , and the blocks @xmath177 only if the substructure @xmath178 contains coupling of elements of different dimensions . we note that the global problem ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) could be obtained from ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - substructure ] ) by further assembly at the interface . in _ the iterative substructuring _ ( see e.g. @xcite ) , we first reduce the problem to substructure interfaces . in our context we can eliminate normal fluxes , pressure unknowns , and lagrange multipliers at interiors of substructures , and we can define the substructure schur complements@xmath179 , @xmath180 , formally as @xmath181{ccc}b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i}\end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{ccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it}\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i}\end{array } \right]^{-1 } \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it}\\ -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it}\\ -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{it}\end{array } \right ] . \label{eq : substructure - schur}\ ] ] however , in an implementation of a krylov subspace iterative method , we only need to compute the matrix - vector product @xmath182 for a given vector@xmath183 . therefore , the matrix is not constructed explicitly , and the multiplication is obtained as follows . [ alg : s - mult ] given @xmath184 , determine @xmath185 in the following two steps : 1 . solve a local _ dirichlet problem _ @xmath1{ccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it}\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i}\end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}\mathbf{w}^{i}\\ q^{i}\\ \mu_{i}^{i}\end{array } \right ] = -\left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it}\\ -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it}\\ -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{it}\end{array } \right ] \lambda_{\gamma}^{i } , \label{eq : discrete - dirichlet - problem - substructure}\ ] ] 2 . perform two sparse matrix - vector multiplications @xmath186{ccc}b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i}\end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}\mathbf{w}^{i}\\ q^{i}\\ \mu_{i}^{i}\end{array } \right ] \right ) . \label{eq : substructure - schur - multiple}\ ] ] next , let @xmath187 be the space of global degrees of freedom , such that the values of degrees of freedom from @xmath188 coincide on@xmath167 . the vectors of the local substructure degrees of freedom @xmath184 and the vector of the global degrees of freedom @xmath189 are related by @xmath190 where @xmath191 are the restriction operators . more specifically , each @xmath191 is a @xmath135-@xmath192 matrix such that every row contains one entry equal to one , and @xmath193 . the global schur complement @xmath194 can be obtained as @xmath195 equation ( [ eq : schur - assembly ] ) represents the formal assembly of substructure schur complements into the global schur complement . the global schur complement system , which we would like to solve iteratively , reads @xmath196 where vector @xmath197 is obtained from substructure reduced right - hand sides @xmath198{ccc}b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i}\end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{ccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it}\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i}\end{array } \right ] ^{-1}\left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}g^{i}\\ f^{i}\\ 0 \end{array } \right ] .\label{eq : reduced - rhs}\ ] ] in our implementation , we factor and store the matrices from ( [ eq : discrete - dirichlet - problem - substructure ] ) . the factors are then used to compute the vectors@xmath199 in ( [ eq : reduced - rhs ] ) , and especially in algorithm [ alg : s - mult ] , which is used in connection to formula ( [ eq : schur - assembly ] ) to evaluate @xmath200 within each iteration of a krylov subspace iterative method . this algorithm allows a straightforward parallel implementation . after an approximate solution of ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) is found , solution in interiors of substructures , including all primal variables , is recovered from ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - substructure ] ) using the factors from ( [ eq : discrete - dirichlet - problem - substructure ] ) . there are other ways to derive the interface problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) . the authors of @xcite use a mixed - hybrid formulation with lagrange multipliers introduced only at the interface @xmath163 as their starting point . while problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) is equivalent to the interface problems considered in @xcite , the substructure problems therein have a different structure from ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - substructure ] ) . in particular , there are no blocks corresponding to @xmath201 , and the matrices corresponding to @xmath176 are no longer block diagonal element - wise . next , the authors of @xcite construct explicit schur complement with respect to the whole block of lagrange multipliers @xmath58 and they show that , due to the special structure of @xmath2 , the complement is both sparse and reasonably cheap to construct . if this was performed substructure by substructure , this could be again seen as an intermediate step in obtaining problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) by additional elimination of the interior lagrange multipliers @xmath202 . however , this would again lead to different substructure problems based on explicit local schur complements . the following result allows an application of the bddc method to problems with fractures . [ th : sspd ] let natural boundary conditions ( [ eq : problem-3 ] ) be prescribed at a certain part of the boundary , i.e. @xmath122 for at least one @xmath123 . then the matrix @xmath203 in ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) is symmetric positive definite . using the notation of ( [ eq : blocks_matrix])([eq : congruence1 ] ) , let us introduce a matrix @xmath204 . the matrix @xmath205 is symmetric positive definite by theorem [ th : regular ] ( and its proof ) . applying another congruence transformation to @xmath205 and denoting the rows corresponding to the interface lagrange multipliers by subscript @xmath206 and the interior by @xmath207 , we obtain @xmath208 = \left [ \begin{matrix } i & \\ \mathcal{s}_{\gamma i } \mathcal{s}_{ii}^{-1 } & i \end{matrix } \right ] \left [ \begin{matrix } \mathcal{s}_{ii } & \\ & \mathcal{s}_{\gamma \gamma } - \mathcal{s}_{\gamma i } \mathcal{s}_{ii}^{-1 } \mathcal{s}_{\gamma i}^{t } \end{matrix } \right ] \left [ \begin{matrix } i & \mathcal{s}_{ii}^{-1 } \mathcal{s}_{\gamma i}^{t } \\ & i \end{matrix } \right].\ ] ] since the matrix on the left - hand side is spd , both diagonal blocks @xmath209 and @xmath210 are also symmetric positive definite from the sylvester law of inertia . it remains to note that the schur complement @xmath203 in ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) is symmetric positive definite because @xmath211 . theorem [ th : sspd ] allows us to use the conjugate gradient method for the iterative solution of ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) . in the next section , we describe the bddc method used as a preconditioner for @xmath203 . in this section , we formulate the bddc method for the solution of ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) . the algorithm can be viewed as a generalisation of @xcite . however , we follow the original description from @xcite , which better reflects our implementation . one step of bddc provides a two - level preconditioner for the conjugate gradient method applied to solving problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) . it is characterised by the selection of certain _ coarse degrees of freedom _ based on primary degrees of freedom at interface @xmath163 . the main coarse degrees of freedom in this paper are arithmetic averages over _ faces _ , defined as subsets of degrees of freedom shared by the same two substructures . in addition , _ corner _ coarse degrees of freedom , defined as any selected lagrange multiplier at the interface , are used . substructure _ edges _ , defined as subsets of degrees of freedom shared by several substructures , may also appear ( see remark [ rem : constraints ] ) . the bddc method introduces _ constraints _ which enforce continuity of functions from @xmath212 at coarse degrees of freedom among substructures . this gives raise to the space @xmath213 , which is given as the subspace of @xmath212 of functions which satisfy these continuity constraints . in particular , @xmath214 [ rem : constraints ] in three spatial dimensions , several triangular elements can be connected at a single lagrange multiplier in a star - like configuration ( cf . fig . [ fig : schemes ] ) . a similar statement holds for line elements considered in two- or three - dimensional space . this fact may lead to the presence of substructure _ edges _ and even _ vertices _ ( defined as degenerate edges consisting of a single degree of freedom ) , and we may prescribe also edge averages as constraints . as mentioned above , we also select _ corners _ as coarse degrees of freedom . while essentially any degree of freedom at the interface @xmath163 can be _ a corner _ , we select them by the face - based algorithm @xcite . this algorithm considers all vertices as corners , and , in addition , it selects three geometrically well distributed degrees of freedom from the interface between two substructures sharing a face into the set of _ although considering corners is not the standard practice with @xmath8 finite elements , in our experience , corners improve convergence for numerically difficult problems , as can be observed for the engineering applications presented in section [ sec : numerical ] . we now proceed to the formulation of operators used in the bddc method . the choice of constraints determines the construction of matrices @xmath215 . each row of@xmath216 defines one coarse degree of freedom at substructure @xmath178 , e.g. , a corner corresponds to a single @xmath192 entry at a row and an arithmetic average to several @xmath192 s at a row . the _ coarse basis functions _ @xmath217 , one per each substructure coarse degree of freedom , are computed by augmenting the matrices from ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - substructure ] ) with @xmath215 , and solving the augmented systems with multiple right - hand sides @xmath1{ccccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it } & 0\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma } ^{it } & 0\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{it } & 0\\ b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}{\gamma}}^{i } & d^{it}\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & d^{i } & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}x^{i}\\ z^{i}\\ \phi_{i}^{i}\\ \phi_{\gamma}^{i}\\ l^{i}\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}0\\ 0\\ 0\\ 0\\ i \end{array } \right ] , \quad i=1,\dots , n_{s } , \label{eq : hybrid - fractured - augmented - substructure}\ ] ] where @xmath218 is the identity matrix , and @xmath219 , @xmath220 , and @xmath221 are auxiliary matrices not used any further . as shown in @xcite , the _ local coarse matrix _ @xmath222 is obtained as a side product of solving ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - augmented - substructure ] ) as @xmath223 \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{cccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it}\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma } ^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{it}\\ b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}{\gamma}}^{i } \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}x^{i}\\ z^{i}\\ \phi_{i}^{i}\\ \phi_{\gamma}^{i}\end{array } \right ] = -l^{i}. \label{eq : scci_def}\ ] ] let us define , similarly to ( [ eq : r ] ) , operators@xmath224 that relate vectors of local coarse degrees of freedom@xmath225 to the vector of global coarse degrees of freedom@xmath226 as @xmath227 the _ global coarse matrix _ @xmath228 is then obtained by assembling the local contributions as @xmath229 finally , let us define the scaling operators @xmath230 which are given as diagonal matrices of weights that satisfy @xmath231 more details on the selection of diagonal entries in @xmath232 are given in section [ sec : scaling ] . with this selection of spaces and operators , we are ready to formulate the bddc preconditioner . [ alg : bddc]the bddc preconditioner @xmath233 is defined in the following steps : 1 . compute the local residuals @xmath234 2 . compute the _ substructure corrections _ @xmath235 by solving the local _ neumann problems _ @xmath1{ccccc}a^{i } & b^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{it } & 0\\ b^{i } & -c^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{it } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma } ^{it } & 0\\ b_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{ii}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{it } & 0\\ b_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -c_{\mathcal{f},\gamma}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}i}^{i } & -\widetilde{c}_{{\gamma}{\gamma}}^{i } & d^{it}\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & d^{i } & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}x^{i}\\ z^{i}\\ \eta_{i \delta } ^{i}\\ \eta_{\gamma \delta}^{i}\\ l^{i}\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}0\\ 0\\ 0\\ r_{\gamma}^{i}\\ 0 \end{array } \right ] , \quad i=1,\dots , n_{s}.\label{eq : bddc - substructure - problem}\ ] ] 3 . compute the _ coarse correction _ @xmath236 by collecting the coarse residual @xmath237 solving the global _ coarse problem _ @xmath238 and distributing the coarse correction@xmath239 4 . combine and average the corrections@xmath240 we note that the factorisations of the matrices from ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - augmented - substructure ] ) are also used for each solution of ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem ] ) . in order to apply the existing bddc theory for elliptic problems ( e.g. @xcite ) to the proposed preconditioner , we introduce some additional notation and make a few observations . due to ( [ eq : substructure - schur ] ) , the substructure corrections in ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem ] ) can be written equivalently as @xmath1{cc}-s^{i } & d^{it}\\ d^{i } & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}\eta_{\gamma \delta}^{i}\\ l^{i}\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}r_{\gamma}^{i}\\ 0 \end{array } \right ] , \label{eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur}\ ] ] and the construction of coarse basis functions @xmath217 in ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - augmented - substructure ] ) as @xmath1{cc}-s^{i } & d^{it}\\ d^{i } & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c } \phi_{\gamma}^{i}\\ l^{i}\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}0\\ i \end{array } \right ] . \label{eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur - for - coarse - basis}\ ] ] next , let us formally write the operators and vectors in the block form @xmath241{c}\lambda_{\gamma}^{1}\\ \vdots\\ \lambda_{\gamma}^{n_{s}}\end{array } \right ] , \ r=\left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}r^{1}\\ \vdots\\ r^{n_{s}}\end{array } \right ] , \ w=\left [ \begin{array } [ c]{ccc}w^{1 } & & \\ & \ddots & \\ & & w^{n_{s}}\end{array } \right ] , \ s=\left [ \begin{array } [ c]{ccc}s^{1 } & & \\ & \ddots & \\ & & s^{n_{s}}\end{array } \right ] .\ ] ] by grouping the steps of algorithm [ alg : bddc ] and using ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur ] ) , the operator of the bddc preconditioner can be formally written as @xmath242 where @xmath243{cc}i_{{\lambda}_{\gamma}^{i } } & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{cc}-s^{i } & d^{it}\\ d^{i } & 0 \end{array } \right]^{-1 } \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}i_{{\lambda}_{\gamma}^{i } } \\ 0 \end{array } \right ] \right ) + \left ( \sum_{i=1}^{n_{s}}r_{c}^{it}\phi_{\gamma}^{it } \right)^t s_{cc}^{-1 } \left ( \sum_{i=1}^{n_{s}}r_{c}^{it}\phi_{\gamma}^{it } \right ) \right\}.\ ] ] the first term in @xmath244 corresponds to substructure corrections and the second term to the coarse correction ( steps 2 and 3 of algorithm [ alg : bddc ] ) , and @xmath245 is the identity matrix in @xmath246 . from ( [ eq : mbddc - formal ] ) and ( [ eq : stilde ] ) , one can readily see that @xmath247 is symmetric . [ as : nulls]let us assume that @xmath248 in order to satisfy assumption [ as : nulls ] , we must prescribe enough coarse degrees of freedom as constraints along with robin boundary conditions ( [ eq : newton-1])([eq : newton-2 ] ) and ( [ eq : newton-3 ] ) at each fracture within substructure@xmath170 . since constrains in @xmath215 are linearly independent , @xmath249 has full column rank . in particular , assumption [ as : nulls ] is satisfied when arithmetic averages are used on each substructure face ( and eventually edge ) as constraints . [ lemma : positive_definite_preconditioner ] the operator @xmath244 in preconditioner @xmath247 is symmetric and positive definite on the space @xmath213 . the space @xmath213 is decomposed into the substructure spaces and the coarse space , @xmath250 to achieve this splitting , each local space @xmath246 is decomposed into subspaces @xmath251 corresponding to the _ substructure space _ @xmath252 , and the _ coarse space _ on substructure @xmath178 , @xmath253 , respectively . to analyse this decomposition , let us recall that @xmath254 is a positive semi - definite matrix and write ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur - for - coarse - basis ] ) in detail as @xmath255 from ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur - for - coarse - basis-1 ] ) , @xmath256 which in turn , similarly to ( * ? ? ? * lemma 8) , gives for any @xmath257 and @xmath258 @xmath259 from ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur - for - coarse - basis-2 ] ) , the matrix @xmath217 has full column rank , and @xmath260 finally , from assumption [ as : nulls ] and ( [ eq : decomposition_of_subdomain_space ] ) , @xmath261 decomposition of the subdomain space ( [ eq : decomposition_of_subdomain_space ] ) implies decomposition of a function @xmath262 to @xmath263 , where @xmath264 , @xmath265 , and @xmath266 by ( [ eq : s - orthogonality2 ] ) . let us first analyse the substructure corrections . following ( * ? ? ? * section 3.3 ) , the matrix of ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem - with - schur ] ) is invertible due to assumption [ as : nulls ] . if we define , in addition , a matrix @xmath267 with orthonormal columns forming a basis of @xmath268 , i.e. @xmath269 we have @xmath1{cc}i_{{\lambda}_{\gamma}^{i } } & 0 \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{cc}-s^{i } & d^{it}\\ d^{i } & 0 \end{array } \right]^{-1 } \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{c}i_{{\lambda}_{\gamma}^{i } } \\ 0 \end{array } \right ] = -q^{i}\left(q^{it } s^{i } q^{i}\right)^{-1}q^{it}.\ ] ] the matrix @xmath270 is symmetric positive definite , and consequently , for any @xmath262 , @xmath271 with equality if @xmath272 . next , let us turn towards the coarse correction . formula ( [ eq : scci_def ] ) for@xmath273 can be written equivalently as @xmath274 since the term on the right - hand side is just a ( negative ) galerkin projection of the positive semi - definite matrix @xmath254 , matrix @xmath222 is symmetric negative semi - definite . if at least one substructure is equipped with natural boundary conditions , the matrix @xmath228 assembled by ( [ eq : scc_def ] ) becomes symmetric negative definite , and so is @xmath275 . we have just verified the negative definiteness of the principal parts of @xmath244 , and the desired positive definiteness is obtained through the change of sign in front of the braces in ( [ eq : stilde ] ) . in view of lemma [ lemma : positive_definite_preconditioner ] , the standard condition number bound follows from ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2 ) . [ th : bddc_bound ] the condition number @xmath276 of the preconditioned operator @xmath277 satisfies @xmath278 the norms in ( [ eq : cond - bound - algebraic ] ) are induced by the matrix @xmath279 defined in ( [ eq : block_operators ] ) for all functions @xmath280 . in addition , in the case of a single mesh dimension in either 2d or 3d , and under the assumption of substructure - wise constant hydraulic conductivities , it has been also derived in ( * ? ? ? * lemma 5.5 and theorem 6.1 ) that the condition number bound@xmath281 satisfies @xmath282 where @xmath283 is the characteristic size of geometric substructures . we note that the bound ( [ eq : cond - bound - analytic ] ) implies that , for a fixed relative subdomain size @xmath284 , the condition number is independent of the problem size . it is worth emphasising that theorem [ th : bddc_bound ] is also valid for combined mesh dimensions . however , several simplifications are employed in @xcite to obtain ( [ eq : cond - bound - analytic ] ) , which are not satisfied in the set - up considered in this paper . in particular ( i ) hydraulic conductivity coefficient here is , in general , not substructure - wise constant nor isotropic , ( ii ) it is not clear whether , in presence of fractures , the interpolation operator onto a conforming mesh introduced in @xcite can be constructed and bounded in the @xmath285 norm . let us now discuss the choice of entries in the diagonal weight matrices @xmath232 . these matrices play an important role in the bddc method , both in the theory , cf . theorem [ th : bddc_bound ] or @xcite , and in the computations , cf . three possible choices are also studied numerically in section [ sec : results_engineering ] . the basic choice is presented by the _ arithmetic average _ taken from values at the neighbouring substructures . in this simplest construction , the entry corresponding to lagrange multiplier @xmath286 is given by the inverse counting function as @xmath287 where @xmath288 is the number of substructures in the set @xmath289 of indices of substructures to which @xmath286 belongs . for 2d or 3d meshes without fractures , @xmath290 for raviart - thomas elements . however , since several two - dimensional fractures can meet in our setting , smaller weights can occasionally appear at such regions . while arithmetic average is sufficient for problems with homogeneous coefficients , it is well known that for problems with large variations in material properties along the interface , it is necessary to incorporate their values into the ( weighted ) average to obtain a robust method . this gives rise to the @xmath291-scaling , for which @xmath292 where @xmath293 is a material characteristic for substructure @xmath294 . this choice is robust with respect to jumps in coefficients across the interface , cf . @xcite ; however , coefficients are assumed constant for each substructure . this requirement is very restrictive for practical computations with quickly varying coefficients , and we employ a generalisation which takes into account the material coefficient of the element to which the lagrange multiplier @xmath286 corresponds . in our case , we use @xmath295 , where @xmath123 is the dimension of the element @xmath59 . this value can be seen as a representative hydraulic conductivity on the element . finally , we propose a modification of the popular scaling by diagonal stiffness @xcite . in the usual diagonal stiffness approach , the optimal weight , which is the diagonal entry of the schur complement , is approximated by the diagonal entry of the original substructure matrix . however , this is not directly applicable to the indefinite system ( [ eq : hybrid - fractured - substructure ] ) , as , in general , matrix @xmath296 contains only seldom nonzeros on the diagonal . for this reason , we approximate the diagonal of the schur complement as @xmath297 where the index @xmath98 corresponds to the row in block @xmath176 of the element face to which the lagrange multiplier @xmath286 belongs . using the diagonal stiffness scaling in connection with the standard lagrange finite elements may lead to poor convergence for problems with rough interface @xcite , for which the diagonal stiffness can vary quickly even for smooth problems with constant coefficients on uniform meshes . this is a severe issue for practical computations , in which graph partitioners are typically used for creating substructures . however , this issue is not as pronounced for raviart - thomas elements , for which only one element contributes to the stiffness on the diagonal at an interface degree of freedom , and thus irregularities caused by changing number of elements contributing to an interface weight can not occur . on the other hand , an advantage of the diagonal stiffness scaling is the fact , that unlike the @xmath291-scaling it takes into account the shape and relative sizes of elements , which vary considerably in engineering applications , as well as the effect of @xmath115 introduced in ( [ eq : weak_term_a ] ) and ( [ eq : weak_term_f ] ) . unless stated otherwise , scaling ( [ eq : scaling_diagonal ] ) is used in the computations presented in section [ sec : numerical ] . the basis for an efficient parallel implementation of the method described in previous sections was obtained by combining two existing open - source software packages : the finite element package _ _ flow123d _ _ ( version 1.6.5 ) for underground fluid flow simulations and the bddc - based solver _ _ bddcml _ _ ( version 2.0 ) used for the solution of the resulting system of equations . however , minor changes have been made to both codes to support the specific features , such as the weights ( [ eq : scaling_rho ] ) and ( [ eq : scaling_diagonal ] ) . the _ flow123d _ package has been developed for modelling complex behaviour of underground water flow and pollution transport . however , only the simple flow in a fully saturated porous media described by darcy s law is considered in this paper . to accurately account for fractures in the medium , such as granite rock , the solver allows us to combine finite elements of different dimensions : the three - dimensional elements of porous media are combined with two - dimensional elements modelling planar fractures , which may be in turn connected in one - dimensional elements for channels . raviart - thomas elements are consistently used throughout such discretisation . although the fractures are also modelled as porous media , their hydraulic conductivity is by orders of magnitude higher than that of the main porous material of the domain . in addition , the finite element discretisations are typically not uniform within the domain , and the relative sizes of elements may also vary by orders of magnitude . both these aspects give rise to very poorly conditioned linear systems , which are very challenging for iterative solvers . the _ flow123d _ solver has been developed for over 10 years and it is written in c / c++ programming language with object - oriented design and parallelism through mpi . the _ bddcml _ is a library for solving algebraic systems of linear equations by means of the bddc method . the package supports the adaptive - multilevel bddc method @xcite suitable for very high number of substructures and computer cores , although we only use the standard ( non - adaptive two - level ) bddc method from @xcite for the purpose of this paper . the _ bddcml _ library is typically interfaced by finite element packages , which may provide the division into substructures . this feature is used in our current implementation , in which the division into non - overlapping substructures is constructed within the _ flow123d _ using the _ metis _ ( version 5.0 ) package @xcite . one substructure is assigned to a processor core in the current set - up of the parallel solver , although _ bddcml _ is more flexible in this respect . the library performs the selection of additional corners by the face - based algorithm from @xcite . the _ bddcml _ package is written in fortran 95 and parallelised through mpi . the _ bddcml _ solver relies on a serial instance of the _ mumps _ direct solver @xcite for the solution of each local discrete dirichlet problem ( [ eq : discrete - dirichlet - problem - substructure ] ) as well as for the solution of each local discrete neumann problem ( [ eq : bddc - substructure - problem ] ) . the coarse problem ( [ eq : bddc - coarse - problem ] ) is solved by a parallel instance of _ mumps_. the main difference from using _ bddcml _ for symmetric positive definite problems is the need to use the @xmath298 factorisation of general symmetric matrices for problems ( [ eq : discrete - dirichlet - problem - substructure ] ) , which are saddle - point ( i.e. indefinite ) systems in the present setting . although the original system ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) is indefinite , system ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) is symmetric positive definite , which allows the use of the preconditioned conjugate gradient ( pcg ) method . one step of bddc is used as the preconditioner within the pcg method applied to problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) . the matrix of problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) is not explicitly constructed in the solver , and only its actions on vectors are computed following ( [ eq : discrete - dirichlet - problem - substructure])([eq : schur - assembly ] ) . in our implementation , we change the sign neither in the action of @xmath299 ( [ eq : substructure - schur - multiple ] ) nor in the action of the preconditioner @xmath247 ( [ eq : bddc - preconditioner ] ) . since both are then strictly negative definite , the product @xmath277 is the same as if both signs were changed , and the pcg method runs correctly . in this way , no changes are necessary in an implementation developed for symmetric positive definite problems . in this section , we investigate the performance of the algorithm and its parallel implementation on several benchmark problems in 2d and 3d , and on two geoengineering problems of existing localities in 3d . for the two benchmark problems without fractures we perform weak scaling tests . for the benchmark problem with fractures and for the geoengineering problems , we perform strong scaling tests with the problem size fixed and increasing number of processor cores . in all cases , the pcg iterations are run until the relative norm of residual @xmath300 . if not stated otherwise , the proposed scaling by diagonal stiffness ( [ eq : scaling_diagonal ] ) is used within the averaging operator of bddc . first , the performance of the solver is investigated on a unit square and a unit cube discretised solely using two - dimensional and three - dimensional finite elements , respectively . for this reason , block @xmath4 in system ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) , which is related to combining elements of different dimension , is zero , and the problem reduces to the standard problem ( [ eq : hybrid - m ] ) . the sequence of unstructured meshes is approximately uniform for both problems , and the problems do not contain any jumps in material coefficients . in figs . [ fig : square2d_problem ] and [ fig : cube3d_problem ] , example meshes and the resulting pressure head and velocity fields are presented . while gravity is present in the 3d case , its effect is not considered in the 2d case . the results of the weak scaling tests are summarised in tables [ tab:2d_square_weak_scaling ] and [ tab:3d_cube_100k_weak_scaling ] . to give a better view , the resulting solution times for different problem sizes are also visualised in fig . [ fig : timing_100k ] . in these tables , @xmath301 denotes the number of substructures and processors , @xmath302 is the size of the global problem ( [ eq : hybrid - m - fractured ] ) , @xmath303 is the size of the interface problem ( [ eq : s_hat - system ] ) , @xmath304 denotes number of faces , @xmath305 denotes number of corners , ` its . ' stands for resulting number of pcg iterations , and ` cond . ' is the approximate condition number computed from the lanczos sequence in pcg . we report separately the time spent in preconditioner set - up , the time spent by pcg iterations , and the total time for the whole solve . in these weak scaling tests , the number of unknowns per core is kept approximately constant around @xmath306 . these weak scaling tests were performed using up to 64 cores of the sgi altix uv supercomputer at the supercomputing centre of the czech technical university in prague . the computer contains twelve intel xeon processors , each with six cores at frequency 2.67 ghz . intel compilers version 12.0 were used . the numbers of pcg iterations and condition number estimates in tables [ tab:2d_square_weak_scaling ] and [ tab:3d_cube_100k_weak_scaling ] confirm the expected numerical scalability of the bddc method , which is well known for symmetric positive definite problems as well as for darcy s flow problems @xcite . the slight irregularities in the condition number in table [ tab:3d_cube_100k_weak_scaling ] are probably caused by using non - nested unstructured meshes . looking at times in these tables and in fig . [ fig : timing_100k ] , we can see almost optimal scaling , with only mild growth of times with number of cores . the numbers of pcg iterations are higher in 3d , and the time spent in pcg iterations grows proportionally , while the time spent in the set - up phase does not differ considerably between two - dimensional and three - dimensional setting and dominates the overall time . example of solution to the model square problem containing only 2d elements , plot of pressure head with mesh ( left ) and velocity vectors ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] example of solution to the model square problem containing only 2d elements , plot of pressure head with mesh ( left ) and velocity vectors ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] example of solution to the model cube problem containing only 3d elements , plot of pressure head with mesh ( left ) and velocity vectors ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] example of solution to the model cube problem containing only 3d elements , plot of pressure head with mesh ( left ) and velocity vectors ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] [ c]|ccc|ccc|cc|ccc| & & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & & set - up & pcg & solve + 2 & 207k & 103k & 155 & 1 & 2 & 7 & 1.37 & 8.3 & 1.6 & 9.9 + 4 & 440k & 110k & 491 & 5 & 10 & 8 & 1.60 & 12.2 & 2.2 & 14.4 + 8 & 822k & 103k & 1.2k & 13 & 26 & 9 & 1.78 & 11.0 & 2.5 & 13.5 + 16 & 1.8 m & 111k & 2.8k & 33 & 66 & 8 & 1.79 & 14.3 & 2.7 & 17.0 + 32 & 3.3 m & 104k & 5.9k & 74 & 148 & 9 & 1.79 & 12.1 & 3.3 & 15.4 + 64 & 7.2 m & 113k & 13.0k & 166 & 332 & 9 & 1.85 & 14.8 & 4.4 & 19.2 + [ c]|ccc|ccc|cc|ccc| & & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & & set - up & pcg & solve + 2 & 217k & 108k & 884 & 1 & 3 & 11 & 2.88 & 11.7 & 2.3 & 14.0 + 4 & 437k & 109k & 2.3k & 6 & 18 & 12 & 3.04 & 11.7 & 2.5 & 14.2 + 8 & 945k & 118k & 5.7k & 21 & 63 & 15 & 12.00 & 15.4 & 4.0 & 19.3 + 16 & 1.6 m & 103k & 12.8k & 56 & 168 & 16 & 6.58 & 12.9 & 4.0 & 17.0 + 32 & 3.4 m & 106k & 29.8k & 132 & 401 & 18 & 10.10 & 15.4 & 5.2 & 20.6 + 64 & 6.1 m & 95k & 59.6k & 307 & 931 & 19 & 16.58 & 13.7 & 6.3 & 20.0 + weak scaling test for the 2d square problem ( left ) , and the 3d cube problem ( right ) , approx . 100k unknowns per core . computational times separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] weak scaling test for the 2d square problem ( left ) , and the 3d cube problem ( right ) , approx . 100k unknowns per core . computational times separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] the next benchmark problem is considerably more complicated . it consists again of a unit cube , which now contains four planar fractures aligned with diagonals of a 2d cross - section . these four planar fractures meet at a 1d channel in the centre of the cross - section . therefore , the problem contains the full possible combination of 3d , 2d and 1d finite elements . the tensor @xmath22 is isotropic , thus it is just a scalar multiple of identity . the corresponding scalar value is set to 10 , 1 , and 0.1 for 1d , 2d , and 3d elements , respectively . we perform a strong scaling test with this problem , keeping the mesh size fixed with approximately 2.1 million elements and 14.6 million degrees of freedom . in fig . [ fig : cube123d_problem ] , the computational mesh and the resulting pressure head and velocity fields are presented . this scaling test was computed on the cray xe6 supercomputer _ hector _ at the edinburgh parallel computing centre . this supercomputer is composed of 2816 nodes , each containing two amd opteron interlagos processors with 16 cores at 2.3 ghz . gnu compilers version 4.6 were employed . results of the strong scaling test are summarised in table [ tab:123d_cube_strong_scaling ] , and the computing times are visualised also in fig . [ fig : timing_strong_123d ] together with the parallel speed - up . the reference value for computing speed - up is the time on 16 cores , and the speed - up on @xmath307 processors is computed as @xmath308 where @xmath309 is the time on @xmath307 processors . we can see that the number of pcg iterations grows with the number of substructures for this problem which is also confirmed by the growing condition number estimate . while the time spent in set - up phase scales very well , the time spent in pcg grows together with the number of iterations . the reason for this growth seem to be related to the larger interface , at which more numerical difficulties appear . this seems to be related to more 1d-2d and 2d-3d connections at the interface and makes this difficult problem a good candidate for using the _ adaptive bddc _ . however , this will be the subject of a separate study . example of solution to the model cube problem containing 1d , 2d , and 3d elements , plot of pressure head with mesh and fractures ( left ) and velocity vectors ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] example of solution to the model cube problem containing 1d , 2d , and 3d elements , plot of pressure head with mesh and fractures ( left ) and velocity vectors ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] [ c]|cc|ccc|cc|ccc| & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & set - up & pcg & solve + 16 & 912k & 47k & 53 & 159 & 26 & 59.3 & 171.6 & 84.5 & 256.2 + 32 & 456k & 65k & 126 & 380 & 48 & 2091.0 & 90.1 & 109.8 & 200.0 + 64 & 228k & 86k & 301 & 914 & 81 & 1436.1 & 36.8 & 77.1 & 114.0 + 128 & 114k & 116k & 689 & 2076 & 109 & 2635.8 & 14.3 & 43.1 & 57.4 + 256 & 57k & 151k & 1436 & 4365 & 164 & 1700.5 & 6.7 & 31.2 & 38.0 + 512 & 28k & 196k & 3021 & 9244 & 254 & 42614.5 & 4.0 & 26.9 & 30.9 + strong scaling test for the cube problem with 1d , 2d , and 3d elements and 14.6 m unknowns , computational time ( left ) and speed - up ( right ) separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] strong scaling test for the cube problem with 1d , 2d , and 3d elements and 14.6 m unknowns , computational time ( left ) and speed - up ( right ) separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] the performance of the algorithm and its parallel implementation has been investigated on two engineering problems of underground flows within real geologic locations . for both problems , the porous medium is fractured granite rock , with the fractures modelled by two - dimensional elements . the first problem is the _ melechov locality _ , which models one of the candidate sites for a nuclear waste deposit to be build within the czech republic in future . the goal is to model the underground flow and estimate the speed at which an eventual radioactive pollution would spread . the computational mesh contains 2.1 million finite elements resulting in 15 million unknowns . the geometry of the problem with the resulting distribution of piezometric head and the finite element mesh is presented in fig . [ fig : melechov_1 ] . the problem contains vertical two - dimensional fractures visualised in fig . [ fig : melechov_2 ] . the maximal hydraulic conductivity within the fractures is 6.3@xmath31010@xmath311 ms@xmath81 , while the minimal conductivity of the outer material is 6.0@xmath31010@xmath312 ms@xmath81 , the transition coefficient @xmath313 = 1 s@xmath81 , and the effective thickness of fractures @xmath85 = 0.1 m. we perform a strong scaling test for this problem , keeping the problem size fixed and increasing the number of substructures and computing cores . an example of division into 64 substructures is presented in fig . [ fig : melechov_2 ] . the scaling test was computed on the _ hector _ supercomputer . table [ tab : melechov_large_strong_scaling ] summarises the results of this test . we can still see some growth of the number of iterations with the number of substructures , which is however much milder than the growth observed for the unit cube with fractures in table [ tab:123d_cube_strong_scaling ] . correspondingly , the times reported in table [ tab : melechov_large_strong_scaling ] and visualised in fig . [ fig : timing_melechov_large ] show an optimal scaling of the solver over a large range of core counts . graphics / melechov_image1_piezo ( 9,5)@xmath314 ( 9,9)@xmath315 ( 6,11.5)@xmath316 ( -10,18)@xmath3179940 m ( 25,45)@xmath31812100 m ( 87,35)@xmath3191410 m the problem of the _ melechov locality _ ; the system of fractures ( left ) and an example division into 64 substructures ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] the problem of the _ melechov locality _ ; the system of fractures ( left ) and an example division into 64 substructures ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] [ c]|cc|ccc|cc|ccc| & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & set - up & pcg & solve + 16 & 934k & 36k & 32 & 96 & 40 & 53.0 & 131.4 & 144.1 & 275.6 + 32 & 467k & 54k & 76 & 228 & 70 & 878.3 & 47.5 & 112.9 & 160.4 + 64 & 233k & 82k & 186 & 561 & 67 & 202.4 & 17.4 & 50.2 & 67.7 + 128 & 117k & 116k & 528 & 1592 & 69 & 237.6 & 7.9 & 23.1 & 31.1 + 256 & 58k & 155k & 1235 & 3747 & 96 & 5577.0 & 4.0 & 14.7 & 18.8 + 512 & 29k & 207k & 2699 & 8256 & 106 & 1658.1 & 2.2 & 8.3 & 10.5 + 1024 & 15k & 271k & 5711 & 17581 & 119 & 11554.5 & 2.1 & 7.0 & 9.2 + strong scaling test for the problem of the _ melechov locality _ containing 2d and 3d elements and 15 m unknowns , computational time ( left ) and speed - up ( right ) separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] strong scaling test for the problem of the _ melechov locality _ containing 2d and 3d elements and 15 m unknowns , computational time ( left ) and speed - up ( right ) separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] the second engineering model is the locality around the _ bedichov tunnel_. the main purpose of this 2.1 km long tunnel near the city of liberec in the north of the czech republic to accommodate water pipes , which supply the city by drinking water from a reservoir in the mountains . however , this locality is also a valuable site for experimental geological measurements performed inside the tunnel . the model aims at describing the flow in the granite rock surrounding the tunnel . the computational mesh consists of 1.1 million elements leading to 7.8 million unknowns . the mesh with the plot of resulting piezometric head is presented in fig . [ fig : tunel_1 ] . the system of fractures and an example division into 256 substructures are visualised in fig . [ fig : tunel_2 ] . the hydraulic conductivity of the fractures is 10@xmath320 ms@xmath81 , while the conductivity of the outer material is 10@xmath321 ms@xmath81 , the transition coefficient @xmath313 = 1 s@xmath81 , and the effective thickness of fractures @xmath85 = 1.1 m. although the mesh contains fewer finite elements than the one of the _ melechov locality _ model , this problem is considerably more complicated . this is caused mainly by the presence of relatively very small and irregularly shaped finite elements in the vicinity of the tunnel and near the cross - sections of fractures ( see fig . [ fig : tunel_3 ] ) generated by the mesh generator . the results of a strong scaling test are summarised in table [ tab : tunnel_strong_scaling ] . as before , the times are also plotted in fig . [ fig : timing_tunnel ] . although the number of iterations is not independent of the number of substructures , the growth is still small . consequently , the computing times , and especially the time for set - up , scale very well over a large range of numbers of substructures . the observed super - optimal scaling may be related to faster factorisation of the smaller local problems by the direct solver for indefinite matrices . table [ tab : tunnel_corner_effect ] summarises an experiment performed to analyse the effect of using corners in the construction of the coarse space in bddc . as has been mentioned in section [ sec : bddc ] , using raviart - thomas finite elements does not lead to ` natural ' corners as cross - points shared by several substructures . on the other hand , the notion of corners was generalised to any selected interface degree of freedom , at which continuity of functions from the coarse space is required . such generalisation is important for the well - posedness of the local problems for unstructured meshes e.g. in elasticity analysis @xcite . this is also the default option for _ bddcml _ , in which selection of corners is performed at each face between two substructures . adding corners improves the approximation properties of the coarse space at the cost of increasing the size of the coarse problem . table [ tab : tunnel_corner_effect ] compares the convergence for variable number of substructures without and with constraints at corners . column ` with corners ' in table [ tab : tunnel_corner_effect ] corresponds to results in table [ tab : tunnel_strong_scaling ] , and it is repeated for comparison . we can see that while the effect of corners on convergence is small for smaller number of substructures , the improvement of the coarse problem and the approximation of bddc becomes more significant for higher numbers of cores . looking at times in table [ tab : tunnel_corner_effect ] , the additional time spent in the set - up phase due to higher number of constraints when using corners is compensated by the lower number of pcg iterations , resulting in lower overall times . thus , using additionally selected corners appears beneficial for complicated engineering problems like this one . graphics / tunel_image1_piezo ( 2,12)1754 m ( width ) ( 16,57)2655 m ( length ) ( 98,43)458 m ( height ) the _ bedichov tunnel _ problem ; the system of fractures ( left ) and an example division into 256 substructures ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] the _ bedichov tunnel _ problem ; the system of fractures ( left ) and an example division into 256 substructures ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] example of difficulties in the mesh of the _ bedichov tunnel _ problem ; detail of the tunnel geometry with fine elements ( left ) and enforced refinement at an intersection of fractures ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.5% ] example of difficulties in the mesh of the _ bedichov tunnel _ problem ; detail of the tunnel geometry with fine elements ( left ) and enforced refinement at an intersection of fractures ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] [ c]|cc|ccc|cc|ccc| & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & set - up & pcg & solve + 32 & 245k & 20k & 106 & 322 & 112 & 1514.1 & 110.3 & 144.0 & 254.3 + 64 & 123k & 28k & 192 & 597 & 63 & 117.7 & 42.2 & 36.0 & 78.3 + 128 & 61k & 45k & 413 & 1293 & 75 & 194.4 & 13.4 & 16.8 & 30.3 + 256 & 31k & 72k & 902 & 2791 & 119 & 526.7 & 4.2 & 10.9 & 15.1 + 512 & 15k & 110k & 2009 & 6347 & 137 & 1143.4 & 1.8 & 7.1 & 9.0 + 1024 & 8k & 155k & 4575 & 14725 & 173 & 897.0 & 1.6 & 8.0 & 9.7 + strong scaling test for the problem of the _ bedichov tunnel _ containing 2d and 3d elements and 7.8 m unknowns , computational time ( left ) and speed - up ( right ) separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] strong scaling test for the problem of the _ bedichov tunnel _ containing 2d and 3d elements and 7.8 m unknowns , computational time ( left ) and speed - up ( right ) separately for set - up and pcg phases , and their sum ( solve).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] [ c]|cc|ccccc|ccccc| & & & + & & & & & & & + & & & & set - up & pcg & solve & & & set - up & pcg & solve + 32 & 245k & 131 & 1789.6 & 107.5 & 175.0 & 282.5 & 112 & 1514.1 & 110.3 & 144.0 & 254.3 + 64 & 123k & 70 & 122.2 & 40.3 & 40.4 & 80.7 & 63 & 117.7 & 42.2 & 36.0 & 78.3 + 128 & 61k & 96 & 208.5 & 10.9 & 21.6 & 32.6 & 75 & 194.4 & 13.4 & 16.8 & 30.3 + 256 & 31k & 139 & 541.9 & 3.7 & 12.5 & 16.2 & 119 & 526.7 & 4.2 & 10.9 & 15.1 + 512 & 15k & 197 & 1418.9 & 1.4 & 10.0 & 11.4 & 137 & 1143.4 & 1.8 & 7.1 & 9.0 + 1024 & 8k & 312 & 3779.4 & 1.0 & 14.5 & 15.6 & 173 & 897.0 & 1.6 & 8.0 & 9.7 + in the final experiment , we compare the effect of different averaging techniques on the convergence of bddc . in table [ tab : tunnel_averaging ] , results of the strong scaling test for arithmetic averaging ( [ eq : scaling_arithmetic ] ) , the modified @xmath291-scaling ( [ eq : scaling_rho ] ) , and the proposed scaling by diagonal stiffness ( [ eq : scaling_diagonal ] ) are summarised . the final column corresponds to the results from table [ tab : tunnel_strong_scaling ] , which are repeated here for comparison . table [ tab : tunnel_averaging ] suggests , that while the simple arithmetic averaging does not lead to satisfactory convergence for this problem , the modified @xmath291-scaling and the diagonal scaling mostly lead to similar convergence . however , while the former provides slightly better convergence for several cases , it also leads to irregularities for certain divisions , for which the bddc method with this averaging converges rather poorly . therefore , the proposed scaling ( [ eq : scaling_diagonal ] ) can be recommended as the most robust choice among the three tested options . [ c]|cc|ccc|cc|cc|cc| & & & & & & & + & & & & & its . & cond . & its . & cond . & its . & cond . + 32 & 245k & 20k & 106 & 322 & 637 & 9811.7 & 110 & 1467.8 & 112 & 1514.1 + 64 & 123k & 28k & 192 & 597 & 618 & 10254.1 & 62 & 115.1 & 63 & 117.7 + 128 & 61k & 45k & 413 & 1293 & 2834 & 1.0e+11 & 206 & 401641.4 & 75 & 194.4 + 256 & 31k & 72k & 902 & 2791 & 799 & 11172.9 & 117 & 512.9 & 119 & 526.7 + 512 & 15k & 110k & 2009 & 6347 & 883 & 15449.6 & 136 & 1160.1 & 137 & 1143.4 + 1024 & 8k & 155k & 4575 & 14725 & n / a & 2.5e+10 & 504 & 99023.6 & 173 & 897.0 + a parallel solver for the mixed - hybrid finite element formulation based on darcy s law has been presented . the software combines an existing package _ flow123d _ developed for problems in geophysics with _ bddcml _ , a parallel library for solution of systems of linear algebraic equations by the bddc method . in geoengineering applications , the mathematical model is applied to geometries with the presence of fractures . in the present approach , the flow in these fractures is also modelled by darcy s law , although the hydraulic conductivity of the porous media is considered by orders of magnitude higher . these fractures are modelled by finite elements of a lower dimension . in the discretised model , 1d , 2d and 3d finite elements are coupled together through robin boundary conditions . these coupling terms lead to a modification of the usual saddle - point matrix of the system , in which a new non - zero block appears on the diagonal . the bddc method is employed for the solution of the resulting system of linear algebraic equations . bddc is based on iterative substructuring , in which the problem is first reduced to the interface among substructures . the schur complement is not built explicitly . instead , only multiplications by the matrix are performed through solving a discrete dirichlet problem on each substructure . in the setting of the mixed - hybrid problem , the interface is built only as a subset of the block of lagrange multipliers , while remaining unknowns belong to interiors of substructures . although the original problem is symmetric indefinite , the system reduced to the interface is symmetric positive definite . this is also shown to hold for the case with fractures in the present paper . consequently , the pcg method is used for the solution of the reduced problem . however , unlike the symmetric positive definite problems , a direct solver for symmetric indefinite matrices needs to be used for the factorisation and repeated solution of local problems on substructures . one step of the bddc method is used as the preconditioner for the pcg method run on the interface problem . a modification of the diagonal stiffness scaling has been introduced . it is motivated by difficult engineering problems , for which it performs significantly better than other two applicable choices the arithmetic averaging and the modified @xmath291-scaling . arithmetic averages over faces between substructures are used as the basic constraints defining the coarse space . in addition , corners are selected from unknowns at the interface using the face - based algorithm . while corners are not required by the theory , they are shown to improve both the convergence and the computational times for complicated problems . the performance of the resulting solver has been investigated on three benchmark problems in 2d and 3d . both weak and strong scaling tests have been performed . on benchmark problems with single mesh dimension , the expected optimal convergence independent of number of substructures has been achieved . correspondingly , the resulting parallel scalability has been nearly optimal for the weak scaling tests up to 64 computer cores . the strong scaling tests were presented for a benchmark problem of a unit cube and for two engineering problems containing large variations in element sizes and hydraulic conductivities , using up to 1024 computer cores and containing up to 15 million degrees of freedom . the convergence for the unit cube problem with all three possible dimensions of finite elements slightly deteriorated by using more substructures , and this translated to sub - optimal parallel performance . however , for the two engineering applications , in which only 3d and 2d elements are combined , the bddc method has also maintained good convergence properties with the growing number of substructures , resulting in optimal , or even super - optimal parallel scalability of the solver . it has been also shown that the proposed modification of the diagonal stiffness scaling plays an important role in achieving such independence for the challenging engineering problems presented in the paper . elman hc , silvester dj , wathen aj . _ finite elements and fast iterative solvers : with applications in incompressible fluid dynamics_. numerical mathematics and scientific computation , oxford university press , 2005 . cros jm . a preconditioner for the schur complement domain decomposition method . _ domain decomposition methods in science and engineering _ , herrera i , keyes de , widlund ob ( eds . ) . national autonomous university of mexico ( unam ) , mxico , 2003 ; 373380 . 14th international conference on domain decomposition methods , cocoyoc , mexico , january 612 , 2002 . fragakis y , papadrakakis m. the mosaic of high performance domain decomposition methods for structural mechanics : formulation , interrelation and numerical efficiency of primal and dual methods . _ computer methods in applied mechanics and engineering _ 2003 ; * 192*:37993830 . mandel j , sousedk b. adaptive selection of face coarse degrees of freedom in the bddc and the feti - dp iterative substructuring methods . _ computer methods in applied mechanics and engineering _ 2007 ; * 196*(8):13891399 . oden j , lee j. dual - mixed hybrid finite element method for second - order elliptic problems . _ mathematical aspects of finite element methods _ , _ lecture notes in mathematics _ , vol . 606 , galligani i , magenes e ( eds . ) . springer berlin heidelberg , 1977 ; 275291 . maryka j , rozlonk m , tma m. schur complement systems in the mixed - hybrid finite element approximation of the potential fluid flow problem . _ siam journal on scientific computing _ 2000 ; * 22*(2):704723 . bezina j , hokr m. mixed - hybrid formulation of multidimensional fracture flow . _ proceedings of the 7th international conference on numerical methods and applications _ , nma10 , springer - verlag : berlin , heidelberg , 2011 ; 125132 . ertkov m , stek j , burda p. on selection of interface weights in domain decomposition methods . _ proceedings of programs and algorithms of numerical mathematics 16 , doln maxov , czech republic , june 38 , 2012_. institute of mathematics as cr , 2013 ; 3544 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the non - equilibrium green function ( negf ) method@xcite potentially has several advantages to investigate electronic transport properties of nano - scale materials such as single molecules,@xcite atomic wires,@xcite carbon based materials,@xcite and thin layers.@xcite the potential advantages are summarized by the following features of the negf method : ( i ) the source and drain contacts are treated based on the same theoretical framework as for the scattering region . @xcite ( ii ) the electronic structure of the scattering region under a finite source - drain bias voltage is self - consistently determined by combining with first principle electronic structure calculation methods such as the density functional theory ( dft ) and the hartree - fock ( hf ) method . @xcite ( iii ) many body effects in the transport properties , e.g. , electron - phonon@xcite and electron - electron interactions,@xcite might be included through self - energies without largely deviating the theoretical framework . ( iv ) its applicability to large - scale systems can be anticipated , since the negf method relies practically on the locality of basis functions in real space , resulting in computations for sparse matrices.@xcite due to those potential advantages , recently several groups have implemented the negf method coupled with the dft or hf method using atomic - type or the other local basis functions with successful applications for calculations of the electronic transport properties . @xcite however , a highly accurate and efficient implementation method must be still developed from the following two reasons : the first obvious reason is to extend the applicability of the negf method to large - scale systems . the efficient implementation might lead to more challenging applications of the negf method to very large - scale complicated systems . the majority part in the computational effort of the negf method mainly comes from the evaluation of the density matrix which is decomposed into the evaluation of green functions and numerical integrations . thus , the efficient calculation of the part is a key factor for extending the applicability to large - scale systems . nevertheless , accurate and efficient methods for evaluating density matrix within the negf method have not been fully developed , although several methods have been already proposed . @xcite to extend the applicability of the negf method to large - scale systems , a remarkably efficient method that we have recently developed@xcite will be applied for the problem in this study , and we will show that the new method is much faster than the other method.@xcite the second reason is that spurious scattering should be negligible when the negf method is extended to include the many body effects beyond the one particle picture.@xcite the spurious scattering accompanied by the inaccurate implementation might make the many body effects indistinct in the electronic transport properties . one can imagine that the spurious scattering can be easily produced in the negf method , since unlike the conventional band structure calculations negf has to be evaluated by a patch work that the self consistent field ( scf ) calculations of the source and drain leads are performed beforehand , and the calculated results are incorporated in the negf calculations through the self energy and the boundary conditions between the scattering region and leads . therefore , a careful treatment to handle the boundary conditions should be developed to avoid the spurious scattering . in this paper , to address the above two issues we present an accurate and efficient implementation of the negf method , in combination with dft using pseudo - atomic orbitals ( paos ) and pseudopotentials , using a contour integration method which is based on a continued fraction representation of the fermi - dirac function . for the accurate treatment of the boundary conditions between the scattering region and leads , we also develop a method for calculating the hartree potential by a combination of the two dimensional fast fourier transform ( fft ) and a finite difference method so that the boundary condition can be correctly reproduced . in addition , we discuss a careful treatment to construct the charge density near the boundaries . the efficiency and accuracy of our implementation are demonstrated by several numerical test calculations on convergence of the density matrix . this paper is organized as follows : in sec . ii the details of our implementation for treating the equilibrium state of the scattering region are discussed by focusing on the evaluation of the equilibrium density matrix , the treatment for constructing the charge density near the boundaries , and an efficient method for calculating the hartree potential . in sec . iii our implementation for the nonequilibrium state is described . in sec . iv we demonstrate the accuracy and efficiency of the implementation by a series of numerical calculations and several applications . in sec . v our implementation of the negf method is summarized . since most of practical aspects in the implementation of the negf method coupled with dft using the localized paos@xcite appear in the ground state calculation of the system at equilibrium , we start our discussion from the electronic structure calculation of the equilibrium ground state by using the green function method with dft . let us consider a system where one dimensional infinite cells are arranged with two dimensional periodicity as shown in fig . 1 . throughout the paper , we assume that the electronic transport along the * a*-axis is of interest , and that the two dimensional periodicity spreads over the * bc*-plane . the one dimensional infinite cell consists of the central region denoted by @xmath2 and the cells denoted by @xmath3 and @xmath4 , where @xmath5 . all the cells @xmath3 and @xmath4 , arranged semi - infinitely , contain the same number of atoms with the same structural configuration , respectively , but the cells @xmath3 and @xmath4 can be different from each other . in the equilibrium state with a common chemical potential everywhere in the system , the electronic structure of the system may be determined by dft.@xcite is an extended central region consisting of @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 . , width=302 ] due to the periodicity of the * bc*-plane the one - particle kohn - sham ( ks ) wave function in the system is expressed by the bloch function on the * bc*-plane using paos @xmath9 located on site @xmath10 as : @xmath11 where @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 are indices for the spin , eigenstate , site , and basis orbital , respectively . the lattice vector @xmath16 and the bloch wave vector @xmath17 are given by @xmath18 , where @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the lattice vectors , and @xmath21 , where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the reciprocal lattice vectors , respectively . the summation over @xmath14 and @xmath15 is considered for all the basis orbitals in the one dimensional infinite cell , which indicates no periodicity along the @xmath24-axis . considering the variation of the total energy , within the conventional dft , of the system expressed by the ks wave function eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 1 ] ) with respect to coefficients @xmath25 we obtain the following ks matrix equation : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is a column vector consisting of the coefficients @xmath28 . the hamiltonian @xmath29 and overlap matrices @xmath30 are given by @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the hamiltonian and overlap matrix elements between two basis functions @xmath34 and @xmath35 , respectively . the overlap matrix arises from the non - orthogonality of the pao basis functions.@xcite now we consider an extended central region @xmath36 composed of the regions @xmath2 , @xmath37 , and @xmath38 as shown in figs . 1 ( a ) and ( b ) . the extension of the central region @xmath2 is made so that the relaxation of electronic structure around the interfaces between the leads , @xmath37 and @xmath38 , and the central region @xmath2 can be allowed . in addition , we impose two conditions : 1 . the localized basis orbitals @xmath39 in the region @xmath2 overlap with those in the regions @xmath37 and @xmath38 , but do not overlap with those in the regions @xmath40 and @xmath41 . the localized basis orbitals @xmath39 in the @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) region has no overlap with basis orbitals in the cells beyond the nearest neighboring cells @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) and @xmath44 ( @xmath45 ) . in our implementation the basis functions are strictly localized in real space because of the generation of basis orbitals by a confinement scheme.@xcite therefore , once the localized basis orbitals with specific cutoff radii are chosen for each region , the two conditions can be always satisfied by just adjusting the size of the unit cells for @xmath3 and @xmath4 . this is a benefit in the use of the strictly localized basis orbitals compared to other local basis orbitals such as slater- and gaussian - type orbitals . in the use of the strictly localized basis orbitals , the eigenvalue problem in the hilbert space spanned by the basis orbitals are solved without introducing any cutoff scheme . on the other hand , in the green function method the matrix elements of the hamiltonian and overlap matrices have to be truncated so as to satisfy the above two conditions in case of the other localized basis orbitals with the small but long tail . with the above two conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) , the hamiltonian matrix given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 3 ] ) is written by a block tridiagonal form as follows : @xmath46 where @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 are hamiltonian matrices of the central @xmath36 , left @xmath50 and right @xmath51 regions of which matrix size are the same as the number of basis orbitals @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 in the regions @xmath36 , @xmath40 , and @xmath41 , respectively . the other block components in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 5 ] ) are the hamiltonian matrices connecting two regions among the regions , and these matrix sizes are deduced from those of the two regions . also the completely same structure is found in the overlap matrix . thus , the electronic structure of the system given by fig . 1(a ) can be obtained by solving the one dimensional block chain model , being @xmath17-dependent , given by fig . 1(b ) and the corresponding eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 2 ] ) . by noting @xmath55 and making use of the block tridiagonal form of the hamiltonian and overlap matrices , the green function of the central region @xmath36 can be written by @xmath56 with self energies @xmath57 and @xmath58 defined by @xmath59 where @xmath60 and @xmath61 are surface green functions of the left and right regions . it is worth pointing out that there is a total energy functional which can be variationally minimized with respect to charge density @xmath62 if eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) is self - consistently solved . the details of derivation for the functional is given in appendix a. in general , the surface green function @xmath63 is defined by @xmath64 , where @xmath65 and @xmath66 are the hamiltonian and overlap matrices for the lead regions , and the suffix , @xmath67 , is @xmath68 or @xmath69 . it is noted that due to the two conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) mentioned above the hamiltonian and overlap matrices for the lead regions can be written by a block tridiagonal form as follows : @xmath70 where the hamiltonian can be spin and @xmath17-dependent , while the indices for them are omitted for simplification of the notation , and also the index @xmath14 appearing in @xmath71 corresponds to the cell number for the lead @xmath72 or @xmath73 . it seems to be difficult to directly diagonalize the ks equation eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 2 ] ) for the one dimensional block chain model because of the infinite dimension of the matrices . however , instead by focusing on only the central region one can evaluate the green function of the central region as a rather small problem of @xmath74 in size . the effect of semi infinite regions @xmath68 and @xmath69 are included through the corresponding self energies @xmath57 and @xmath58 . in order to practically calculate the green function of the central region given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) , we introduce an approximation where the regions @xmath75 are all equivalent to each other with respect to the spatial charge distribution , the ks hamiltonian , and the relevant density matrix which are calculated in advance by adopting the system of which unit cell is @xmath40 and by using the conventional band structure calculation . the same approximation also applies for the regions @xmath76 . strictly speaking , the assumption is not correct , since the charge distribution must be affected by the interaction between the central region @xmath36 and the regions @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) . however , if the size of the unit vector along the @xmath24-axis for the regions @xmath37 and @xmath38 in the extended central region @xmath36 is large enough , the assumption will be asymptotically correct as the unit vector becomes larger . the approximation enables us to evaluate the surface green function by the iterative method.@xcite the efficient iterative scheme can be performed by the following procedure : @xmath77 with a set of initial values @xmath78 by the iterative calculation , in most cases the inverse of @xmath79 rapidly converges at a part of the surface green function : @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the ( 1,1 ) block element of the surface green function @xmath82 . the ( 1,1 ) block element @xmath81 of @xmath83 ( or @xmath84 ) in size has all the necessary information to calculate the self - energies @xmath57 and @xmath58 , since there is no contribution from the other block elements because of the two conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) mentioned above . in practice , the convergence in the iterative calculation is very fast and the frobenius norm , defined by @xmath85 , of @xmath86 ( ev ) is obtained by typically only 7 iterations . one of practical difficulties in the implementation of the green function method is how the equilibrium density matrix is evaluated efficiently and accurately.@xcite in our implementation , the equilibrium density matrix is highly efficiently computed using the contour integration method with a special treatment of the fermi - dirac function @xmath87.@xcite if the hamiltonian and overlap matrices associated with eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) are @xmath17-dependent , it turns out that the spectrum function in the lehmann representation of the central green function is complex number in general as discussed in appendix b of ref . then , the density matrix @xmath88 , where one of the associated basis orbitals is in the central cell and the other is in the cell denoted by @xmath16 , is given by making use of both the retarded and advanced green functions @xmath89 and @xmath90 as @xmath91 with @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the volume of the unit cell , @xmath94 represents the integration over the first brillouin zone , @xmath95 a positive infinitesimal , and @xmath96 a chemical potential . the integration over @xmath17-space is numerically performed by using the monkhorst - pack mesh.@xcite it is also noted that the phase factor @xmath97 appears through eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 1 ] ) . if the hamiltonian and overlap matrices are @xmath17-independent , eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 22 ] ) can be simplified into a well - known formula : @xmath98 . \label{eq : c1 - 24}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in case of the @xmath17-independent problem , the simplified formula is used , since the number of the evaluation of the green function is reduced by half . for the efficient integration in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 23 ] ) , in our implementation the fermi - dirac function is expressed by a continued fraction representation derived from a hypergeometric function@xcite so that the structure of poles can be suitable for the integration associated with the green function as follows : @xmath99 where @xmath100 with @xmath101 , @xmath102 is electronic temperature , @xmath103 and @xmath104 are complex variables . also , @xmath105 and @xmath106 are the poles and the associated residues of the continued fraction representation eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 25 ] ) , which are obtained via an eigenvalue problem derived from eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 25]).@xcite since all the @xmath105 are real numbers , the poles @xmath107 are located on the imaginary axis . one may find an interesting distribution of the poles on the complex plane that the interval between neighboring poles are uniformly located up to about 61 % of the total number of poles on the half complex plane with the same interval @xmath108 , and from then onward it increases very rapidly as the distance between the pole and the real axis increases . the structure of the poles in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 25 ] ) allows us to efficiently evaluate eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 23 ] ) because of the asymptotic change , @xmath109 , of the green function in the faraway region of the real axis . in other words , the denser poles are allocated for the rapidly varying range of the green function , and the coarser for smoothly . in addition , there is no ambiguity in the choice of the path in the contour integration unlike the other schemes,@xcite which is one of advantages in our method . by terminating the summation of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 25 ] ) at a finite number of poles @xmath110 , the integration of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 23 ] ) can be performed by the contour integration where the poles in the upper and lower half planes are taken into account for the terms with plus and minus signs in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 23 ] ) , respectively , and the explicit formula is given by @xmath111 where @xmath112 , and @xmath113 is the zeroth order moment of the green function @xmath114 . the zeroth order moment @xmath113 is easily calculated by @xmath115 which can be derived from the moment representation of the green function,@xcite where @xmath69 is a large real number and in this study @xmath116 ( ev ) is used in order to make the higher order moments negligible . although the number of poles in the summation of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 26 ] ) required for the sufficient convergence depends on the electronic temperature @xmath102 , the fully convergent result within double precision is achieved by the use of only 100 poles in case of @xmath117 as shown later . if forces on atoms are calculated based on the conventional dft scheme using the non - orthogonal basis orbitals,@xcite the evaluation of the energy density matrix @xmath118 is needed . in appendix b , we derive the calculation scheme of the equilibrium energy density matrix @xmath119 based on the contour integration method . even though the basis functions we used are strictly localized in real space , there is the nonnegligible contribution for the charge density near the boundary between the central and lead regions from the basis functions located in the lead regions . note that any treatment for the contribution to the charge density has not been clarified in the other implementations.@xcite thus , we carefully calculate the charge density in the central region by considering three contributions : @xmath120 where the suffix , s , is @xmath68 or @xmath69 , and @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 are the charge densities contributed from the basis functions located in the central , the lead and central , and the lead regions , respectively . note that the summation over s is not required in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 43 ] ) because of the conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) . each charge contribution is explicitly given by @xmath124 where * a * is the lattice vector of the unit cell for the @xmath37 or @xmath38 region along the * a*-axis . the displacement of @xmath125 ( @xmath126 ) denotes that the basis function is placed in the @xmath40 ( @xmath41 ) region in the configuration shown in fig . 1 . the charge density given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 44 ] ) is calculated by the equilibrium density matrix @xmath127 given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 22 ] ) . although eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 44 ] ) can give a finite electron density on the outside of the central cell with @xmath128 because of the overlap of basis functions , the contribution is reflected in the central cell with @xmath128 by considering the periodicity on the * bc*-plane . in the nonequilibrium case , the equilibrium density matrix is only replaced by the nonequilibrium density matrix which will be discussed in the next section . each term in the summations for the two contributions @xmath122 and @xmath123 survive only if the overlap of the associated two basis orbitals is not zero in the central region . since the original central region @xmath2 is extended by adding the @xmath37 and @xmath38 regions , it is expected that the density matrix elements @xmath129 and @xmath130 in eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 45 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 46 ] ) are close to those of the leads in the equilibrium condition . therefore , the density matrix elements of the leads calculated by the conventional band structure calculations are used for eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 45 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 46 ] ) . due to the treatment the charge densities @xmath122 and @xmath123 are independent of the scf iteration so that for the computational efficiency they can be computed on a numerical mesh and stored before the scf iteration . the factor 2 for @xmath122 in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 43 ] ) is due to taking account of the contribution from @xmath131 , while the factor does not appear for @xmath123 , since all the paired terms are included by the double summation in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 46 ] ) . we add a note that the same consideration has to be applied even for the calculation of the density of states ( dos ) . in this case , the contribution from off - diagonal block green functions connecting the central and lead regions should be added to the dos of the central region @xmath36 calculated by @xmath132 . the off - diagonal block green functions can be calculated from @xmath132 and the surface green functions , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , by making use of the identity @xmath55 as follows : @xmath135 where s is @xmath68 or @xmath69 . the hartree potential in the central region is calculated under the boundary condition that the hartree potential at the boundary between the central @xmath36 and @xmath136 regions is same as that of the lead , where the hartree potential in both the lead regions is calculated using the conventional band structure calculation before the calculation of the infinite @xmath137 in fig . 1(b ) using the green function . in our implementation , the hartree potential for the central region with the boundary condition is efficiently evaluated by a combination of the two dimensional fft and a finite difference method , while other schemes are used in the other implementations.@xcite the majority part of the hartree potential in our treatment is accurately calculated by considering the neutral atom potential which is the sum of the local potential of the pseudopotential and the hartree potential by the confined charge for the neutralization.@xcite the neutral atom potential depends on only the atomic structure and atomic species , and has no relation with the boundary condition . the effect of the relaxation of charge distribution on the hartree potential is taken into account by the remaining minority part of the hartree potential @xmath138 given by @xmath139 where @xmath140 is defined by the difference between the electron density @xmath141 calculated by the green function and the atomic electron density@xcite @xmath142 calculated by superposition of each atomic electron density @xmath143 at atomic site @xmath14 as follows : @xmath144 the fourier transformation of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 35 ] ) on the yz plane , corresponding to the * bc*-plane depicted in fig . 1(a ) , yields @xmath145 where @xmath146 with integer numbers @xmath147 and @xmath148 . by approximating the second derivative in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 37 ] ) with the simplest finite difference , @xmath149 we obtain a simultaneous linear equation @xmath150 of @xmath151 in size with a tridiagonal matrix defined by @xmath152 and a vector defined by @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the interval between neighboring points @xmath155 and @xmath156 , @xmath62 runs from @xmath157 to @xmath158 , and @xmath159 and @xmath160 are the boundary conditions . since the lattice vector of the extended central region @xmath36 along the * a*-axis is divided by @xmath161 for the discretization , the positions @xmath162 and @xmath163 are situated at the boundary , along the * a*-axis , of the unit cell of the central region @xmath36 . thus , @xmath159 and @xmath160 can be calculated from the hartree potential at the left boundaries along the * a*-axis of the left and right leads , respectively . after solving the simultaneous linear equations for all the @xmath164 points , the inverse two dimensional fft on the * bc*-plane yields the difference hartree potential @xmath138 under the boundary conditions . it is apparent that there is no ambiguity for the inclusion of the boundary conditions in the method . although the treatment can be easily extended to the higher order finite difference to the second derivative , we restrict ourselves to the simplest case in the implementation because of its sufficient accuracy . employing fft for two dimensional fourier transformation , the whole computational effort to solve the poisson equation eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 35 ] ) under the boundary conditions is estimated to be @xmath165 which is slightly superior to that of the three dimensional fft , where @xmath161 , @xmath166 , and @xmath167 are the number of meshes for the discretization along the @xmath24- , @xmath19- , and @xmath20-axes . our implementation of the negf method with dft is based on the strictly localized paos@xcite and a norm - conserving pseudopotential method.@xcite within the scheme , the calculation of the matrix elements such as the overlap and kinetic energy integrals , consisting of two center integrals , is performed using a fourier transform method,@xcite while the other matrix elements for @xmath168 and @xmath138 , which can not be decomposed into two center integrals , are evaluated by the numerical integration on the regular mesh in real space.@xcite the further details on how the elements of the hamiltonian and overlap matrices are calculated can be found in ref . @xcite . in addition to the above evaluation of the hamiltonian and overlap matrix elements , the hamiltonian matrix elements associated with the basis orbitals situated at near the boundary are treated in a special way as explained below . if the tails of two basis orbitals located on atoms in the central region @xmath36 go beyond the boundary between the central and the lead regions , the associated hamiltonian matrix element is replaced by the corresponding element in the lead region calculated by the conventional band structure calculation . the case can happen only if the two basis orbitals are located in the region @xmath37(@xmath38 ) because of the condition ( i ) so that the replacement of the hamiltonian matrix element can be always possible . the replacement is made by assuming that the potential profile near the boundary is similar to that near the boundary between the regions @xmath169 and @xmath170 , and can be justified if the size of the region @xmath171 is large enough . compared to conventional band structure calculations , it seems that the negf method tends to suffer from difficulty in obtaining the scf convergence . our observation in several cases suggests that the difficulty may come from charge sloshing along the * a*-axis during the scf iteration . the difference hartree potential @xmath138 change largely by imposition of the boundary condition even for a small variation in the charge density distribution , resulting in a serious charge sloshing along the * a*-axis . thus , we consider suppression of the charge sloshing along the * a*-axis by introducing the following weight factor @xmath172 : @xmath173 where @xmath174 is a smaller one of either @xmath175 or @xmath176 , and @xmath177 and @xmath178 are adjustable parameters , while keeping @xmath179 . the prefactor @xmath180 is given by @xmath181 with definitions : @xmath182 where @xmath183 is an adjustable parameter . noting that @xmath184 is the number of difference electron density of each layer indexed by @xmath185 , and that the coulomb potential induced by each charged layer depends linearly on the distance from the layer , one can notice that @xmath186 is proportional to the electric field at position @xmath14 . therefore , eq . ( [ eq : b1 - 1 ] ) takes charge density under a large electric field into significant account in addition to the suppression of the charge sloshing in the * bc*-plane in a sense by the kerker method.@xcite in our implementation , the weight factor given by eq . ( [ eq : b1 - 1 ] ) is combined with the kerker method@xcite and the residual minimization method in a direct inversion iterative subspace ( rmm - diis)@xcite with substantial improvement . a technical remark should also be added to avoid a local trap problem in the scf calculation . in systems having a long * a*-axis , a unphysical charge distribution , corresponding to a large charge separation in real space , tends to be obtained even after achieving the self consistency . in this case the hamiltonian of the central region @xmath36 at the first scf iteration , which are calculated via superposition of atomic charge density , is far from the self - consistently converged one , while the hamiltonian matrix used in the calculation for the self - energy is determined in a self - consistent manner beforehand . the inconsistency between the two matrices tends to produce a unphysical charge distribution at the first scf iteration . once the situation happens at the first scf iteration , in many cases the electronic structure keeps trapped during the subsequent scf iteration , which is a serious problem in practical applications . however , the local trap problem can be overcome by a simple scheme that the first few scf iterations are performed by using the conventional band scheme and then onward the solver is switched from the band scheme to the negf method . in the band structure calculation for the first few iterations , such a unphysical charge distribution does not appear due to no self - energy involved . in most cases we find that the simple scheme works well to avoid the local trap problem in the scf convergence . based on the negf theory mainly developed by schwinger@xcite and keldysh@xcite , the density matrix in the nonequilibrium state of the central region is evaluated by@xcite @xmath187 in addition to the equilibrium density matrix @xmath88 given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 22 ] ) , a correction term defined by @xmath188 is taken into account , where @xmath189 is defined by @xmath190 with @xmath191 and @xmath192 either the left @xmath193 or right chemical potential @xmath194 which is lower than the other is used for the calculation of the equilibrium density matrix in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 40 ] ) . as well , in eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 52 ] ) the chemical potentials are given by the rule that @xmath195 and @xmath196 if @xmath197 , and @xmath198 and @xmath199 if @xmath200 . starting from the negf theory , the formula , eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 40 ] ) , may be derived by introducing two assumptions . the first assumption is that the occupation of the wave functions incoming from the left ( right ) region still obeys the fermi - dirac function with the left ( right ) chemical potential even in the central region . the assumption can be justified within at least the one - particle picture , since the same result can be obtained from the lippmann - schwinger equation for a non - interacting system.@xcite the second assumption is that in the central region the states in the energy regime below the lower chemical potential is in equilibrium due to the other physical obstacles such as the electron - phonon@xcite and electron - electron interactions,@xcite which are not considered explicitly in our implementation , although the definite role of those obstacles is obscure as for the occupation of the states . the second assumption allows electrons to occupy in highly localized states below the lower chemical potential through the first term of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 40 ] ) . only the states in the energy regime between two chemical potentials are treated as in the nonequilibrium condition in which the contribution of the wave functions incoming from the lead with the higher chemical potential is taken into account to form the correction term given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 41 ] ) . the integrand in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) is not analytic apart from the real axis , since the integrand is a function of both @xmath201 and @xmath202 . thus , one can not apply the contour integration method that we use for the equilibrium density matrix . instead , a simple rectangular quadrature scheme is applied to the integration of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) on the real axis with a small imaginary part @xmath203 . since the integrand contains the difference between two fermi - dirac functions , the energy range for the integration can be effectively reduced to a narrow range that the difference is larger than a threshold , where the threshold of @xmath204 is used in this study . with the threshold and the step width of 0.01 ( ev ) , the number of meshes on the real axis is 152 for @xmath205 ( ev ) at @xmath206 . the convergence speed depends on the shape of the integrand and how large @xmath203 is employed for smearing the integrand , which will be discussed later . the source - drain bias voltage applied to the left and right leads is easily incorporated by adding a constant electric potential @xmath207 to the hartree potential in the right lead region . the effect of the bias voltage appears at three places . the first effect is that the hamiltonian matrix in the right region given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 9 ] ) is replaced using eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 10 ] ) as @xmath208 this can be easily confirmed by noting that the matrix elements for the constant potential @xmath207 is @xmath209 . the off - diagonal block elements @xmath210 , @xmath211 @xmath212 , and @xmath213 appearing eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 7 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 8 ] ) are also replaced in the same way . the second effect is that the chemical potential of the right lead is replaced as @xmath214 the treatment is made so that the first replacement can be regarded as just shifting the origin of energy in the right lead . the last effect is that the boundary condition in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 39 ] ) is replaced as @xmath215 where @xmath216 is calculated by the fourier transformation on the * bc*-plane for @xmath138 at @xmath163 plus @xmath207 . since only the difference of the bias voltages applied to the left and right leads affects the result , one can consider the replacements on only the right lead at the three places as shown above . it is noted that the replacement by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 55 ] ) corresponds to adding a linear potential @xmath217 to the hartree potential in the central region @xmath36 , where @xmath218 and @xmath219 are determined by the boundary conditions : @xmath216 and @xmath220 . in our implementation , the gate voltage @xmath221 is treated by adding an electric potential defined by @xmath222 , \label{eq : c1 - 56}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath223 is a constant value corresponding to the gate voltage , @xmath224 the center of the region @xmath2 , and @xmath225 the length of the unit vector along * a*-axis for the region @xmath2 . due to the form of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 56 ] ) , the applied gate voltage affects mainly the region @xmath2 in the central region @xmath36 . the electric potential may resemble the potential produced by the image charges.@xcite the spin resolved transmission is evaluated by the landauer formula for the non - interacting central region @xmath36 connected with two leads : @xmath226 where @xmath227 is the spin and @xmath228-resolved transmission defined by @xmath229 \label{eq : c1 - 58}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the transmission formula , the current is evaluated by @xmath230 the formula can be derived by starting from a more general formula of the current for the interacting central region @xmath36 and by replacing the involved green functions with the non - interacting green functions as shown by meir and wingreen.@xcite we perform the integration in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 59 ] ) on the real axis with a small imaginary part @xmath203 by the same way as for the nonequilibrium density matrix of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) . all the calculations in this study were performed by the dft code , openmx.@xcite the paos centered on atomic sites are used as basis functions.@xcite the pao basis functions we used , generated by a confinement scheme,@xcite are specified by h5.5-s2 , c4.5-s2p2 , o5.0-s2p2d1 , fe5.0-s2p2d1 , mg5.5-s2p2 , la7.0-s3p2d1f1 , sr7.0-s3p2d1f1 , and mn6.0-s3p2d2 , where the abbreviation of basis functions , such as c4.5-s2p2 , represents that c stands for the atomic symbol , 4.5 the cutoff radius ( bohr ) in the generation by the confinement scheme , and s2p2 means the employment of two primitive orbital for each of s- and p - orbitals . norm - conserving pseudopotentials are used in a separable form with multiple projectors to replace the deep core potential into a shallow potential.@xcite also , a local density approximation ( lda ) to the exchange - correlation potential is employed.@xcite , while a generalized gradient approximation ( gga)@xcite is used only for calculations of the lamno@xmath0srmno@xmath1 superlattice . the real space grid techniques are used with the cutoff energies of 120 - 200 ry in numerical integrations and the solution of poisson equation using fft.@xcite in addition , the projector expansion method is employed in the calculation of three - center integrals for the deep neutral atom potentials.@xcite ) per atom of a linear carbon chain with a bond length of 1.4 under the zero bias voltage at electronic temperature of 300 , 600 , and 1200 k , where the regions @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath2 contain four carbon atoms , respectively . for comparison the same calculation _ ( closed contour ) _ using a closed contour method@xcite is also shown for t=600 k. the definitions of @xmath231 and @xmath232 are found in appendix a. the reference values are obtained from calculations with a large number of poles . ( b ) total dos of the carbon linear chain , calculated by the conventional band structure calculation ( solid line ) and the egf method ( dotted line ) , under the zero bias voltage at 300 k , where 160 poles are used for the integration of the equilibrium density matrix . it is hard to distinguish two lines due to the nearly equivalent results.,width=302 ] the accuracy and efficiency of the implementation are mainly determined by the evaluation of density matrix given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 40 ] ) which consists of two contributions : the equilibrium and non - equilibrium terms given by eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 22 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 41 ] ) , respectively . in this subsection , we discuss the convergence properties of the equilibrium and non - equilibrium terms in the density matrix as a function of numerical parameters . ) per atom of the same linear carbon chain as in fig . 2 , calculated by various imaginary parts , under a finite bias voltage of 0.5 v , where the other calculation conditions are same as for fig . the number pointed by the arrow denotes a grid spacing ( ev ) corresponding to the number of grid points . the reference values are obtained from calculations with a large number of grid points . ( b ) mulliken populations in the carbon chain . the sequential numbers 1 and 12 correspond to the most left and right hand side atoms in the central region @xmath36 , respectively.,width=302 ] since the majority part of the density matrix given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 40 ] ) is the equilibrium contribution , let us first discuss convergency of the equilibrium density matrix as a function of poles . the absolute error in @xmath233 of a carbon linear chain is shown in fig . 2(a ) as a function of the number of poles in order to illustrate the convergence property for the equilibrium density matrix under zero bias voltage , where @xmath233 can be regarded as a conventional expression of the total energy in dft , and the definitions of the two energy terms @xmath231 and @xmath232 with the fermi - dirac function are given in appendix a. for comparison the result calculated by a closed contour method is also shown.@xcite one can see that the accuracy of @xmath234 ev per atom is obtained using 140 , 100 , and 70 poles for the electronic temperature of 300 , 600 , and 1200 k , respectively , while about 400 energy points are needed to obtain the same accuracy using the closed contour method at 600 k.@xcite for most cases , we find that the convergence rate is similar to the case shown in fig . in general , the number of poles to achieve the accuracy of @xmath234 ev per atom must be proportional to the inverse of @xmath102 , since the interval between neighboring poles of the continued fraction given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 25 ] ) is scaled by @xmath235 . this fact implies that the computational effort increases as the electronic temperature decreases . however , we generally use electronic temperature from 300 to 1000 k for practical calculations , which means that the use of 100 poles is enough for practical purposes . therefore , it can be concluded that the most contribution of the density matrix can be very accurately evaluated with a small number of poles , i.e. , 100 . to demonstrate the proper treatment of the boundary between the lead and the central regions in our implementation , in fig . 2(b ) we show a comparison between the conventional band structure and the egf calculations with respect to dos of the carbon linear chain . the comparison provides a severe test to check whether the egf method is properly implemented or not . it can be confirmed that dos calculated by the egf method is nearly equivalent to that by the conventional band structure calculation , which clearly shows the proper treatment of the boundary between the lead and the central regions in our scheme . as explained before , the integration of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) required for the evaluation of the nonequilibrium term in the density matrix has to be performed on the real axis with a small imaginary part because contour integration schemes may not be applied due to the non - analytic nature of the integrand . the treatment might suffer from numerical instabilities in the scf iteration , since the integrand can rapidly vary due to the existence of poles of green function located on the real axis . a remedy to avoid the numerical problem is to smear the green function by introducing a relatively large imaginary part.@xcite to investigate convergency of the nonequilibrium term in the density matrix , in fig . 3(a ) we show the absolute error in @xmath233 of the same infinite carbon chain as in fig . 2 but under a finite bias voltage of 0.5 ev as a function of the number of regular grid points used for the evaluation of the nonequilibrium term in the density matrix given by eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 41 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) . we also tested the gauss - legendre quadrature for the integration of the nonequilibrium term besides the integration using the regular grid , but found that the convergence rate of the gauss - legendre quadrature is rather slower than the simple scheme possibly due to the spiky structure of the integrand . thus , we have decided to use the simple scheme using the regular grid . as expected , it turns out that the number of grid points to achieve the accuracy of @xmath234 ev per atom increases as the imaginary part becomes smaller . however , the accuracy of @xmath234 ev is attainable using about 100 grid points in case of the imaginary part of 0.01 ev , while a few thousands grid points have to be used to achieve the same accuracy for the imaginary part of 0.0001 ev . although the accuracy of @xmath234 ev can be achieved by introducing the smearing scheme , however , one may consider that results can be affected by the introduction of an imaginary part . in order to find a compromise between the accuracy and efficiency , the mulliken population of the carbon linear chain under the finite bias voltage of 0.5 ev is shown in fig . we see that the use of the imaginary part of 0.01 ev gives a result comparable to that obtained by the use of 0.0001 ev . thus , the imaginary part of 0.01 ev can be a compromise between the accuracy and efficiency in this case . as a result , one can find that the energy points of 200 ( 100 and 100 for the equilibrium and nonequilibrium density matrices , respectively ) are enough to achieve the accuracy of @xmath234 ev per atom in @xmath233 at 600 k. however , it should be mentioned that a proper choice of the imaginary part must depend on the electronic structure of systems , and the careful consideration must be taken into account especially for a case that the spiky dos appears in between two chemical potentials of the leads , while for the equilibrium part of the density matrix the convergence property is insensitive to the electronic structure . we also note that the accurate evaluation of the density matrix makes the scf calculation stable even under a finite bias voltage . in fact , for the case with the bias voltage of 0.5 v the number of the scf iterations to achieve the residual norm of @xmath236 for the charge density difference is 29 which is nearly equivalent to that , 30 , for the zero bias case . since for large - scale systems it is very time - consuming to perform the scf calculation at each bias voltage , here we propose an interpolation scheme to reduce the computational cost in the calculations by the negf method . the interpolation scheme is performed in the following way : ( i ) the scf calculations are performed for a few bias voltages which are selected in the regime of the bias voltage of interest . ( ii ) when the transmission and current are calculated , a linear interpolation is made for the hamiltonian block elements , @xmath47 and @xmath237 , of the central scattering region and the right lead , and the chemical potential , @xmath238 , of the right lead by @xmath239 where the indices @xmath157 and @xmath240 in the superscript mean that the quantities are calculated or used at the corresponding bias voltages where the scf calculations are performed beforehand . note that it is also possible to perform the interpolation for @xmath17-independent hamiltonian matrix elements instead of eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 60 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 61 ] ) . in general , @xmath241 should range from 0 to 1 for the moderate interpolation . a comparison between the fully self consistent and the interpolated results is shown with respect to the current and transmission in the linear carbon chain in figs . 4(a ) and ( b ) . in this case , the scf calculations at three bias voltages of 0 , 0.5 , and 1.0 v are performed , and the results at the other bias voltages are obtained by the interpolation scheme . for comparison we also calculate the currents via the scf calculations at all the bias voltages . it is confirmed that the simple interpolation scheme gives notably accurate results for both the calculations of the current and transmission . although the proper selection of bias voltages used for the scf calculations may depend on systems , the result suggests that the simple scheme is very useful to interpolate the effect of the bias voltage while keeping the accuracy of the calculations . v. the zigzag edges are terminated by hydrogen atoms . the isosurface value of @xmath242 is used for drawing the spin density.,width=302 ] as an illustration of our implementation , we investigate transport properties of zigzag graphene nanoribbons ( zgnrs ) with different magnetic configurations . a characteristic feature in the band structure of zgnr is the appearance of flat bands around x - point near the fermi level , resulting in spin - polarization of associated states located at the zigzag edges.@xcite thus , so far several intriguing transport properties have been theoretically predicted especially for zgnrs among gnrs by focusing on the spin polarized edge states.@xcite for instance , it is found that zgnrs might exhibit an extraordinary large magnetoresistance ( mr ) effect and a spin polarized current.@xcite -@xmath207 curves for ( a ) the up - spin and ( b ) the down - spin states in the fm junction , and ( c ) the up - spin and ( d ) the down - spin states in the afm junction of 7- and 8-zgnrs.,width=302 ] here we focus on the current - bias voltage ( @xmath243-@xmath207 ) characteristic of @xmath244- and @xmath245-zgnrs with two magnetic configurations : ferromagnetic ( fm ) and antiferromagnetic ( afm ) junctions as shown in figs . 5(a ) and ( b ) , respectively , where the number , @xmath244 or @xmath245 , is the number of carbon atom in the sublattice being across zgnr along the lateral direction . the odd and even cases will also be referred to as _ asymmetric _ and _ symmetric _ , respectively . the extended central region @xmath36 consists of one sublattice and four unit cells , and contains 72 and 82 atoms for 7- and 8-zgnrs , respectively . the poles of 100 is used for the evaluation of the equilibrium density matrix with the electronic temperature of 300 k , while the nonequilibrium term in the density matrix is evaluated using the simple quadrature method with the imaginary part of 0.01 ev and the grid spacing of 0.02 ev . the geometric structures used are optimized under the periodic boundary condition until the maximum force is less than @xmath246 hartree / bohr . at each bias voltage the electronic structure of zgnr is self - consistently determined . for the fm junction of 8-zgnr under various applied source - drain bias voltages @xmath207.,width=302 ] figures 6(a ) and ( b ) show the current - voltage ( @xmath243-@xmath207 ) curves for the up- and down - spin states in the fm junctions of 7- and 8-zgnrs . it is found that the current for 7-zgnr linearly depends on the bias voltage , while the current for 8-zgnr is saturated at the bias voltage of about @xmath247 . the distinct behavior of 8-zgnr from 7-zgnr can be more definitely seen in the afm junction as shown in figs . 6(c ) and ( d ) . interestingly , 8-zgnr with the afm junction exhibits a diode behavior for the spin resolved current . only the up - spin state contributes substantially to the current in the negative bias regime . in contrary in the positive bias regime only the down - spin state contributes to the current . it is worth mentioning that the effect can also be regarded as a spin filter effect . on the other hand , the @xmath243-@xmath207 characteristics for 7-zgnr is nearly equivalent to that for the fm junction . the considerable difference between 7- and 8-zgnrs in the @xmath243-@xmath207 characteristics can be attributed to the symmetry of two wave functions , @xmath248 and @xmath249 states , around the fermi level . for 8-zgnr the wave functions of the @xmath248 and @xmath249 states are antisymmetric and symmetric with respect to the @xmath12 mirror plane which is the mid plane between two edges , respectively , while those wave functions for 7-zgnr are neither symmetric nor antisymmetric . from a detailed analysis@xcite , it can be concluded that the unique distinction in the @xmath243-@xmath207 characteristics arises from an interplay between the symmetry of wave functions and band structures of zgnrs . in addition , we find that spin moments are reduced by applying the finite bias voltage as shown in fig . since the flat bands around x - point of the minority spin state are located about 0.25 ev above the fermi level , the spin moments at the zigzag edges are largely reduced by increasing the occupation of the flat bands for the minority spin states when the bias voltage exceeds the threshold as shown in fig . 7.@xcite the details of the analysis on the unique spin diode and filter effect of zgnrs is discussed elsewhere.@xcite region , sandwiched by fe(100 ) , being the @xmath37 and @xmath38 regions . the red large and small and blue circles denote fe , o , and mg atoms , respectively . ( b ) the net charge and spin magnetic moment of a fe or mg atom belonging to each layer in the parallel magnetic configuration between the left and right leads . the position in the horizontal axis exactly corresponds to that of the layer in the above figure.,width=321 ] the applicability of our implementation to bulk systems is demonstrated by an application to a tunneling junction consisting of mgo(100 ) layers sandwiched by iron . the magneto - tunneling junction was theoretically predicted to exhibit a large tunneling - magnetoresistance ( tmr),@xcite and subsequently the tmr effect has been experimentally confirmed.@xcite we consider four mgo(100 ) layers sandwiched by iron with the ( 100 ) surface of which atomic configuration is shown in fig . 8(a ) , where the lattice constant of the * bc*-plane used is 2.866 , and they are 2.866 and 4.054 in iron and mgo regions along the * a*-axis , and the distance between the mgo and iron layers is assumed to be 2.160 . the four mgo(100 ) layers corresponds to the region @xmath2 in fig . 1(a ) , and four fe layers of the left and right hand correspond the region @xmath37 and @xmath38 , respectively . the scf calculations were performed at 1000 k under zero bias voltage using * k*-points of @xmath250 and 130 poles for the integration of the equilibrium density matrix . it is found that obtaining the scf is much harder than the case of zgnr discussed before , and that a careful and modest treatment for the charge mixing is required . were used.,width=302 ] as shown in fig . 8(b ) , the net charge of iron atoms in the interfacial layer is positive due to the coordination to an oxygen atom , and the reduction of electrons leads to the increase of the magnetic moment of iron atoms at the interfacial layer . the increase of the magnetic moment at the interfacial layer makes the distinction of the majority and minority spin states at the fermi energy clear , i.e. , the nature of the majority and minority spin states at the fermi energy can be assigned to @xmath251- and @xmath225-states , respectively . the * k*-resolved transmissions at the chemical potential for the majority and minority spin states for the parallel magnetic configuration between the left and right leads are shown in figs . 9(a ) and ( b ) , respectively . the large peak at the @xmath252 point in the majority spin state can be attributed to the @xmath251-state , while sharp peaks around four pillars come from the @xmath225-state as discussed in ref.@xcite . note that the position of the sharp peaks is rotated by 45 degrees because of the unit cell rotated by 45 degrees compared to that in ref.@xcite . the conductances , @xmath253 and @xmath254 , for the majority and minority spin states , calculated from the average transmission integrated over the first brillouin zone , are 11.99 and 2.82 @xmath255 , respectively , which implies that the tunneling junction may behave as a spin filter . the distinction in the conductance should be attributed to decay properties of states in the insulating mgo region coupled with the two states.@xcite for the antiparallel magnetic configuration the * k*-resolved transmission at the chemical potential is understood as a multiplication of the transmissions for the majority and minority spin states in the parallel configuration as shown in fig . the conductance , @xmath256 , of the antiparallel magnetic configuration is 0.34 ( @xmath257 ) which is smaller than those of the parallel case . by defining tmr@xmath258 , we obtain tmr of 2082 % , which is compared to 3700 % for a 5 layer mgo case reported in ref.@xcite . when the transmission of a system with the periodicity along the * a*-axis as well as the periodicity of the * bc*-plane is evaluated under zero bias voltage , it can be easily obtained by making use of the hamiltonian calculated by the conventional band structure calculation without employing the green function method described in the paper . this scheme enables us to explore transport properties for a wide variety of possible geometric and magnetic structures with a low computational cost , and thereby can be very useful for many materials such as supperlattice structures . once the hamiltonian and overlap matrices are obtained from the conventional band structure calculation for the periodic structure , the transmission is evaluated by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 57 ] ) , where all the necessary information to evaluate eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 57 ] ) can be reconstructed by the result of the band structure calculation . as an example of the scheme , we calculate the conductance of a ( lamno@xmath1)/(srmno@xmath1 ) superlattice with four different magnetic structures , i.e. , ferromagnetic , a - type , g - type , and c - type antiferromagnetic configurations of mn sites.@xcite ) /(srmno@xmath1 ) superlattice with the ferromagnetic spin configuration of mn sites . the middle sized blue and small red circles denote mn and o atoms , while sr and la atoms are denoted by the mark . density of states ( dos ) of the ( lamno@xmath1)/(srmno@xmath1 ) superlattice for ( b ) ferromagnetic and ( c ) a - type antiferromagnetic configurations . , width=302 ] in recent years , it has been found experimentally that the superlattice structures consisting of lamno@xmath1 and srmno@xmath1 layers exhibit a metal - insulator transition in terms of the layer thickness.@xcite bhattacharya et al . fabricated ( lamno@xmath1)@xmath259/(srmno@xmath1)@xmath260 superlattices on a srtio@xmath1 ( 001 ) substrate , and measured the in - plane resistivity as a function of temperature.@xcite the resistivity measurement indicates that the superlattices are metallic and insulating for @xmath261 and @xmath262 , respectively . on the other hand , the ( lamno@xmath1)@xmath263/(srmno@xmath1)@xmath263 superlattices fabricated on the same substrate by nakano et al . exhibit a sample dependence in the resistivity measurement , i.e. , one of three samples is metallic and the others are insulating.@xcite they argued that the metallic behavior observed in the one sample may be attributed to a certain structural incompleteness in the superlattice structure , and that the ideal superlattice should become insulating based on their experimental results . a theoretical model calculation for the ( lamno@xmath1)@xmath259/(srmno@xmath1)@xmath260 superlattices suggests that the metal - insulator transition at @xmath264 can be explained by existence of the g - type antiferromagnetic barrier in the srmno@xmath1 layers sandwiched by the lamno@xmath1 layers with the ferromagnetic configuration.@xcite since the analysis by nakano et al . suggests that the charge transfer between the lamno@xmath1 and srmno@xmath1 layers is rather localized in the vicinity of the interface,@xcite the model should be applicable to the case of ( lamno@xmath1)@xmath263/(srmno@xmath1)@xmath263 without significantly depending on the ratio between the thicknesses of ( lamno@xmath1 ) and ( srmno@xmath1 ) layers , indicating that ( lamno@xmath1)@xmath263/(srmno@xmath1)@xmath263 is metallic . however , the naive consideration evidently contradicts the experimental result.@xcite as a first step towards comprehensive understanding of transport properties of the superlattice structures by the first principle calculations , we consider the simplest superlattice , i.e. , ( lamno@xmath265srmno@xmath1 ) . in the calculations , the in - plane lattice constant is fixed to be 3.905 which is equivalent to that of the srtio@xmath1 substrate . the out - of - plane lattice constant is assumed to be 7.735 , since those are experimentally determined to be 3.959 and 3.776 for the lamno@xmath1 and the srmno@xmath1 layers , respectively , grown on the srtio@xmath1 substrate and the average out - of - plane lattice constant for the superlattices is nearly equivalent to the average of the two values.@xcite with those lattice constants internal structural parameters are optimized for each magnetic configuration without any constraint until the maximum force is less than @xmath266 hartree / bohr . the optimized structure for the ferromagnetic configuration is shown in fig . it is found that the position of oxygen atoms is largely distorted due to the different ionic radii between la and sr atoms , showing that mn atoms are located in the center of each distorted octahedron . also , bond angles of mn - o - mn are found to be 167.4 and 161.6 ( degree ) for the in - plane and out - of - plane , respectively . the total energies relative to the ferromagnetic configuration are listed in table [ l1m1-tb ] . the calculated ground state is the ferromagnetic configuration , and the a - type antiferromagnetic configuration lies just above 5 mev per formula unit . it may be considered that the nearly degeneracy between the two configurations corresponds to the neighborhood of the boundary at @xmath267 and @xmath268 in the phase diagram for the tetragonal la@xmath269sr@xmath270mno@xmath1.@xcite the two configurations have both a metallic dos , while the ferromagnetic configuration is half - metallic as shown in figs . 10(b ) and ( c ) , reflecting the large in - plane and out - of - plane conductances as shown in table [ l1m1-tb ] . from a detailed analysis ( not shown ) of doss , we see that the electronic states at the fermi level are composed of @xmath271 orbitals of mn atoms and @xmath272 orbitals of oxygen atoms . also , the mulliken population analysis ( not shown ) suggests that the charge state of mn atoms in the superlattice is in between those in the lamno@xmath1 and srmno@xmath1 bulks . this implies that the metallic band structures are induced by partial filling of the @xmath271 bands . since the bond angle of mn - o - mn for the out - of - plane is slightly acute , therefore , this may be attributed to reduction of the conductance of the ferromagnetic state in the out - of - plane as shown in table [ l1m1-tb ] . a systematic study for the thicker cases and the effect of coulomb interaction@xcite in the @xmath271 orbitals is highly desirable , and the details will be discussed elsewhere . .total energy ( mev ) per formula unit , lamno@xmath0srmno@xmath1 , and conductance @xmath273 ( @xmath257 ) of the ( lamno@xmath265srmno@xmath1 ) supperlattice with four different magnetic configurations , i.e. , ferromagnetic ( f ) , a - type ( a ) , g - type ( g ) , and c - type ( c ) antiferromagnetic configurations of mn sites . the total energy is measured relative to that of the ferromagnetic configuration . @xmath274 is the in - plane conductance for the up spin state , and the others are construed in the similar way . for the conductance calculations * k*-points of @xmath275 were used . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] , where @xmath276 and @xmath277 are the elapsed times by a single core and a parallel calculations . the cores used in the mpi and openmp parallelizations are called _ process _ and _ thread _ , respectively . the parallel calculations were performed on a cray xt5 machine consisting of amd opteron quad core processors ( 2.3ghz ) . in the benchmark calculations , the number of processes is taken to be equivalent to that of processors . therefore , in the parallelization using 1 or 2 threads , 3 or 2 cores are idle in a quad core processor.,width=302 ] the computation in the the negf method can be parallelized in many aspects such as * k*-points , energies in the complex plane at which the green functions are evaluated , spin index , matrix multiplications , and calculation of the inverse of the matrix . here we demonstrate a good scalability of the negf in the parallel computation by a hybrid scheme using the message passing interface ( mpi ) and openmp which are used for inter - nodes and intra - node parallelization , respectively . the green function defined by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) is specified by the * k*-point , energy @xmath278 , and spin index @xmath12 . since the calculation of the green function specified by each set of three indices can be independently performed without any communication among the nodes , we parallelize triple loops corresponding to the three indices using mpi . each node only has to calculate the green functions for an allocated domain of the set of indices , and partly sum up eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 26 ] ) or ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) in a discretized form . after all the calculations finish , a global summation among the nodes is required to complete the calculation of eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 26 ] ) or ( [ eq : c1 - 42 ] ) , which , in most cases , is a very small fraction of the computational time even including the mpi communication among the nodes . thus , the reduction of scalability for the parallelization of the three indices is mainly due to imbalance in the allocation of the domain of the set of indices . the imbalance can happen in the case that the number of combination for the three indices and the number of processes in the mpi parallelization are relatively small and large , respectively . in addition to the three indices , one may notice that the matrix multiplications and the calculation of the matrix inverse can be parallelized , which are situated in the inner loops of the three indices . the evaluation of the central green function given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) and the surface green functions given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 21 ] ) , and the self energies given by eqs . ( [ eq : c1 - 7 ] ) and ( [ eq : c1 - 8 ] ) are mainly performed by the matrix multiplications and the calculation of the matrix inverse . we parallelize these two computations using openmp in one node . since the memory is shared by threads in the node , the communication of the data is not required unlike the mpi parallelization . however , the conflict in the data access to the memory can reduce the scalability in the openmp parallelization . as a whole , in our implementation the * k*-point , energy @xmath278 , and spin index @xmath12 are parallelized by mpi , and the matrix multiplications and the calculation of the matrix inverse are parallelized by openmp . in fig . 11 we show the speed - up ratio in the elapsed time for the evaluation of the density matrix of 8-zgnr under a finite bias voltage of 0.5 ev . the geometric and magnetic structures and computational conditions for 8-zgnr are same as before . the energy points of 197 ( 101 and 96 for the equilibrium and nonequilibrium terms , respectively ) are used for the evaluation of the density matrix . only the @xmath252 point is employed for the * k*-point sampling , and the spin polarized calculation is performed . thus , the combination of 394 for the three indices are parallelized by mpi . it is found that the speed - up ratio of the flat mpi parallelization , corresponding to 1 thread , reasonably scales up to 64 processes . furthermore , it can be seen that the hybrid parallelization , corresponding to 2 and 4 threads , largely improves the speed - up ratio . by fully using 64 quad core processors , corresponding to 64 processes and 4 threads , the speed - up ratio is about 140 , demonstrating the good scalability of the negf method . we have presented an efficient and accurate implementation of the negf method for electronic transport calculations in combination with dft using pseudo - atomic orbitals and pseudopotentials . in the implementation , we have developed accurate methods for the evaluation of the density matrix and the treatment of the boundary between the scattering region and the leads . a contour integration method with a continued fraction representation of the fermi - dirac function has been successfully applied for the evaluation of the equilibrium term in the density matrix , which evidently outperforms the previous method,@xcite while a simple quadrature scheme on the real axis with a small imaginary part is employed for that for the nonequilibrium term in the density matrix . it has been demonstrated by numerical calculations that the accuracy of @xmath234 ev per atom in @xmath233 is attainable using the energy points of 200 in the complex plane even under a finite bias voltage of 0.5 v at 600 k. however , the evaluation of the nonequilibrium density matrix still requires a careful treatment where the pole structure of the green functions has to be smeared by introducing a finite imaginary part . the numerical calculations suggest that the number of energy points required for the convergence can be largely reduced by introducing the imaginary part of 0.01 ev without largely changing the calculated results in a practical sense . we also note that the accurate evaluation of the density matrix provides another advantage that the scf calculations even under a finite bias voltage smoothly converge in a similar fashion as the conventional band structure calculation does . we have also developed an efficient method for calculating the hartree potential by a combination of the two dimensional fft and a finite difference method without any ambiguity in reproducing the boundary conditions . in addition , a careful evaluation of the charge density near the boundary between the scattering region and the leads is presented in order to avoid the spurious scattering accompanied by the inaccurate construction of the charge density . the proper treatment for the charge evaluation in our implementation can definitely be verified by a comparison between the conventional band structure calculation and the egf method with respect to the dos of the carbon chain . finally , we have demonstrated the applicability of our implementation by calculations of spin resolved @xmath243-@xmath207 characteristics of zgnrs , showing that the @xmath243-@xmath207 characteristics depend on the symmetry of zgnr , and that the symmetric zgnr exhibits a unique spin diode and filter effect . also , the applicability of our implementation to bulk systems is demonstrated by applications to a fe / mgo / fe tunneling junction and a lamno@xmath0srmno@xmath1 superlattice . based on the above discussions and the good parallel efficiency in the hybrid parallelization shown in the study , it is concluded that our implementation of the negf method can be applicable to challenging problems related to large - scale systems , and can be a starting point , apart from numerical spurious effects , to include many body effects beyond the one particle picture in the electronic transport . the authors would like to thank h. kondo for providing a prototype fortran code of the negf method . this work is partly supported by crest - jst , the next generation supercomputing project , nanoscience program , and nedo ( as part of the nanoelectronics project ) . let us introduce the following density functional which may define the total energy of the central region @xmath36 being a part of the extended system at equilibrium with a common chemical potential @xmath96 : @xmath279 where @xmath280 is the coulomb interaction energy between electrons and the external potential of the central region @xmath36 given by @xmath281 and @xmath282 is the hartree energy defined by @xmath283 where @xmath284 is an additional electron density which arises from the boundary condition between the central and lead regions . in fact , the additional electron density @xmath284 can be obtained by back fourier transforming eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 39 ] ) divided by @xmath285 within our treatment . the last term of eq . ( [ eq : a-1 ] ) , @xmath232 , is a self energy density functional , which may correspond to the energy contribution from the self energy due to the semi infinite leads , given by @xmath286 \label{eq : a-4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath287 where @xmath288 , the factor of 2 is due to the spin multiplicity , and the self energy @xmath289 is the sum of the self energies arising from the left and right leads . although we neglect the spin and * k*-dependency on the formulation for the simplicity throughout the appendix , its generalization with the dependency is straightforward . the kinetic energy @xmath290 can be evaluated by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) as the band energy @xmath291 minus double counting corrections as follows : @xmath292\\ \nonumber & = & e_{\rm band } - \int dr^3 n({\bf r } ) v_{\rm eff}({\bf r})\\ \nonumber & & - { \rm tr}\left [ -\frac{2}{\pi } { \rm i m } \int_{-\infty}^{\mu } de g_{c}(e^+ ) \sigma(e^+ ) \right ] \label{eq : a-6},\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath291 is defined by @xmath293 . \label{eq : a-7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is noted that the last term in eq . ( [ eq : a-6 ] ) cancels the contribution from the first term in eq . ( [ eq : a-5 ] ) . the effective potential @xmath294 in the second term of eq . ( [ eq : a-6 ] ) will be defined later . also , the exchange - correlation energy @xmath295 in eq . ( [ eq : a-1 ] ) is considered to be a density functional such as local density approximations ( lda ) and generalized gradient approximations ( gga ) evaluated using electron density @xmath62 in the central region @xmath36 . we now consider the variation of the total energy @xmath231 with respect to @xmath62 . the variations of @xmath280 and @xmath282 are simply given by @xmath296 = \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) v_{\rm ext}({\bf r } ) \label{eq : a-8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath297 = \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) \int dr'^3 \frac{n({\bf r}')+n'({\bf r } ' ) } { \vert { \bf r } - { \bf r } ' \vert}. \label{eq : a-9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by noting the dyson equation and @xmath298 which are both derived from eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) , and @xmath299 , the variation of @xmath291 is given by two contributions : @xmath300 } \\ \nonumber & & = \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) { \rm tr}\left [ -\frac{2}{\pi } { \rm i m } \int_{-\infty}^{\mu } de\right.\\ \nonumber & & \qquad\qquad \left . \times e g_{c}(e^+ ) \frac{\delta h_{v } } { \delta n({\bf r } ) } g_{c}(e^+ ) s_{c } \right]\\ \nonumber & & = \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) { \rm tr}\left [ -\frac{2}{\pi } { \rm i m } \int_{-\infty}^{\mu } de \right.\\ & & \nonumber \left . \qquad\qquad \times e\left ( \frac{-\delta h_{v } } { \delta n({\bf r } ) } \right ) \frac{\partial g_{c}(e^+)}{\partial e } \right]\\ \nonumber & & \quad + \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) { \rm tr}\left [ -\frac{2}{\pi } { \rm i m } \int_{-\infty}^{\mu } de \right.\\ \nonumber & & \qquad \qquad \left . \times e g_{c}(e^+ ) \frac{\delta h_{v}}{\delta n({\bf r } ) } g_{c}(e^+ ) \frac{\partial \sigma(e^+)}{\partial e } \right].\\ \label{eq : a-10}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the trace in the first term of eq . ( [ eq : a-10 ] ) can be transformed by considering a partial integral and assuming the system to be insulating as follows : @xmath301 } \\ \nonumber & & = -{\rm tr}\left [ -\frac{2}{\pi } { \rm i m } \int_{-\infty}^{\mu } de \left ( \frac{-\delta h_{v}}{\delta n({\bf r } ) } \right ) g_{c}(e^+ ) \right]\\ & & = \int dr'^3 n({\bf r } ' ) \frac{\delta v_{\rm eff}({\bf r}')}{\delta n({\bf r})}. \label{eq : a-11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is also noted that the second term in eq . ( [ eq : a-10 ] ) cancels the variation of the contribution from the second term in eq . ( [ eq : a-5 ] ) . the variation of the second term in eq . ( [ eq : a-6 ] ) is easily found as @xmath302 & = & \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) v_{\rm eff}({\bf r})\\ \nonumber & + & \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r } ) \int dr'^3 n({\bf r } ' ) \frac{\delta v_{\rm eff}({\bf r}')}{\delta n({\bf r})}.\\ \label{eq : a-12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , it turns out using eqs . ( [ eq : a-8])-([eq : a-12 ] ) that the variation of the total energy @xmath231 is given by @xmath303 } \\ \nonumber & & = \int dr^3 \delta n({\bf r})\\ \nonumber & & \times \left ( -v_{\rm eff}({\bf r } ) + v_{\rm ext}({\bf r } ) + \int dr'^3 \frac{n({\bf r}')+n'({\bf r } ' ) } { \vert { \bf r } - { \bf r } ' \vert } + \frac{\delta e_{\rm xc}}{\delta n({\bf r } ) } \right).\\ \label{eq : a-13}\end{aligned}\ ] ] letting @xmath304 $ ] be zero so that the variation of the total energy @xmath231 can be always zero with respect to @xmath62 , we obtain a form of the effective potential : @xmath305 it is found that the effective potential takes the same form as in the kohn - sham method.@xcite the fact implies that the self consistent solution of the green function under the zero bias condition may correspond to the minimization of the total energy functional defined by eq . ( [ eq : a-1 ] ) , since in practice the green function defined by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 6 ] ) is calculated using the effective potential given by eq . ( [ eq : a-14 ] ) as a consequence of combining the negf method with dft . the generalization of the functional to the metallic case with a finite temperature and the nonequilibrium state might be an important direction in the future study so that forces on atoms can be _ variationally _ calculated from the functional , since the existence of a variational functional has been recently suggested for the nonequilibrium steady state.@xcite the equilibrium energy density matrix @xmath306 , where one of the associated basis orbitals is in the central cell and the other is in the cell denoted by @xmath16 , is calculated using the contour integration method applied to the equilibrium density matrix as follow : @xmath307 with @xmath308 if the hamiltonian and overlap matrices are @xmath17-independent , as well as eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 22 ] ) , eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 28 ] ) can be simplified to : @xmath309 . \label{eq : c1 - 29}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the general case with the @xmath17-dependent hamiltonian and overlap matrices , eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 28 ] ) is evaluated by the contour integration method with the special form of fermi - dirac function given by eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 25 ] ) as follows : @xmath310 with @xmath311 where @xmath312 is the first order moment of the green function @xmath114 . in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 30 ] ) , a term , @xmath313 , which appears mutually for @xmath314 , is omitted , since the diverging terms cancel each other out in eq . ( [ eq : c1 - 27 ] ) . by making use of the moment representation of the green function,@xcite the following simultaneous linear equation is derived for the zero and first order moments : @xmath315 letting @xmath316 and @xmath317 be @xmath318 and @xmath319 , respectively , the zero and first order moments can be evaluated by @xmath320 where @xmath69 is a large real number so that the higher order moments can be neglected . for the nonequilibrium green function , the nonequilibrium contribution @xmath321 in the the energy density matrix @xmath322 can be calculated using the simple quadrature scheme in the same way as for the nonequilibrium term in the density matrix . in a similar fashion to the charge density , the atomic electron density @xmath142 in the central region consists of two contributions . one of them comes from atoms located in the central region @xmath36 , and the other is the contribution by the tail of atomic electron densities associated with atoms in the leads regions . since the latter is independent of the the scf iteration , it is computed on the regular mesh before the scf iteration . we used @xmath323 ev , eb=27.21 ev , and @xmath324 , being the parameters in the closed contour integration depicted in fig . 2 of ref.@xcite . the value for @xmath325 gives four enclosed matsubara poles for @xmath326 k. the path @xmath68 toward the positive direction is extended by @xmath327 from the chemical potential . the paths @xmath68 and @xmath36 are integrated using the gauss - legendre quadrature scheme , respectively . it turns out that 40 grid points for the path @xmath36 is enough to achieve the fully convergent result within double precision . so , we used 40 grid points for the path @xmath36 , and only changed the number of grid points for the path @xmath68 in the calculation for fig . 2(a ) of ref.@xcite . therefore , the number of energy points in the closed contour integration is given by 4 ( the enclosed matsubara poles ) plus 40 ( the path @xmath36 ) plus the number of grid points for the path @xmath68 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: ground - based doppler radial velocity surveys and space - based photometric surveys have established that planets are very common , and perhaps ubiquitous , around sun - like stars . in particular , analysis of detections by the nasa _ kepler _ mission show that planets with radii of 1 - 2 earth radii ( r@xmath2 ) are far more common than larger planets @xcite . comparisons between estimates or upper limits on mass from doppler radial velocity measurements and radii from _ kepler _ also suggest that the densities of planets ( at least planets on short - period orbts ) smaller than 1.5m@xmath2 are consistent with a `` rocky '' ( silicates + metals ) composition , while larger planets have an additional low - molecular weight ( e.g. hydrogen ) envelope @xcite . however , the data are insufficiently precise to inform as to the exact composition of these planets and regardless there are degeneracies in mass and radius with different bulk compositions . the photospheres of dwarf stars on the main sequence are broadly representative of the material from which the star and any circumstellar disk formed . additional information about planet composition might therefore be inferred by determining elemental abundances in the host - star photosphere . this connection is supported by the observation that the abundances of refractory elements in the solar photosphere are , to a large extent , mirrored by that in primitive chondritic meteorites , the latter widely used as an analog of the primordial building blocks of planets ( e.g. , * ? ? ? to a lesser extent , these abundances are reflected in the bulk composition of the planets such as earth , but with some important exceptions . the two most abundant heavy elements in the galaxy and sun ( and presumably planet - forming disks ) are carbon ( c ) and oxygen ( o ) . in the cool interstellar medium ( ism ) , star - forming regions , and molecular cloud cores , c and o are present primarily as the co molecule ( e.g. , * ? ? ? because of the unit stochiometry of the co molecule , whether c or o is in excess controls which element is available to form other compounds and thus the chemistry of the gas and solids that condense or equilibrate with the gas . the solar ratio of these two elements is presently estimated at @xmath3 ( * ? ? ? * see also asplund et al . 2009 ) , however this value is not necessarily universal . the two elements differ in their predicted pathways of stellar nucleosynthesis and c / o has a strong positive correlation with metallicity @xcite . motivated by condensation scenarios for the solar nebula @xcite and observations of widely varying c / o among solar - type stars @xcite , @xcite proposed that c / o controls the abundance of water in planetary systems . during condensation from a hot gas with c / o @xmath4 , excess oxygen forms refractory silicate minerals and eventually h@xmath5o . however , in systems with c / o near a critical value ( about 0.88 ) , no o for water is available after silicate condensation and planets accrete from `` dry '' material . at still higher c / o , the deficiency in o causes carbides and graphite to become more stable and replace silicates in the condensation sequence ; thus `` carbide planets '' with very un - earth - like mineralogies , interior structures , and atmospheres might form around stars with c / o @xmath0 . many analyses of the spectra of solar - type stars obtained for galactic chemical evolution ( gce ) studies @xcite and doppler radial velocity surveys found that a significant fraction have c / o @xmath0 @xcite . a series of subsequent works have predicted the final bulk composition of planets by modeling ( i ) the sequential condensation of elements and formation of planetesimals from a cooling gas disk with an initial composition set by host star abundances ; and ( ii ) the accretion of those planetesimals into planets via integration of the dynamical equations of motion . these scenarios have been applied to specific systems where the photospheric abundances of elements have been estimated , variously predicting water - rich `` ocean planets '' and `` carbon planets '' lacking any water @xcite . one question at the foundation of these works is whether c / o really varies widely among galactic disk stars in the solar neighborhood and ever approaches unity . abundances of c and o are more uncertain than for many other elements because of the limited number of usable absorption lines , confusion with lines of other elements , and non - lte corrections . recent studies have revised the c / o of nearby solar - type stars , including those that host known planets , downwards @xcite . these newer studies find no cases where c / o @xmath6 , the threshold where carbide minerals are expected to first form . @xcite has pointed out that the occurrence of c - rich systems in surveys of solar - type stars conflicts with the lack of known c - rich ultracool t dwarfs , as the latter are easily distinguished by their spectra @xcite . a second issue is the assumption that the solids in planetary systems condense from a cooling gas of stellar composition in a circumstellar disk . equilibrium condensation can explain some solids in primitive chondrites , widely considered analogs to the building blocks of planets , but these solids constitute only a small fraction of those meteorites . calcium aluminum inclusions ( cais ) and amoeboid olivene agregates , the most abundant refractory condensates in chondritic meteorites , have volume abundances @xmath7% and typically @xmath8% @xcite . the dominant constituents of chondritic meteorites are chondrules and fine - grained matrix , and there is compelling evidence that these are the product of incomplete sublimation and chemical alteration of pre - existing solids , e.g. older generations of solids and even pre - solar dust from the parent molecular cloud @xcite . this processing occurred under conditions that were very different from a gas of solar composition , i.e. an oxygen - rich environment and dust - to - gas ratios @xmath9 @xcite . this environment could have been created by gravitational settling to the mid - plane of the protoplanetary disk . because of this , the composition of planeteismals reflects the composition of dust grains in the molecular clouds cores that collapse to form stars and planets , plus subsequent thermal processing at mid - plane conditions . ism dust was , in turn , the product of processing in the interstellar medium involving cycling of order @xmath10 times between denser , cooler clouds , where it accreted mantles of atoms , and the hotter intercloud phase , where shock - heated ions and high - energy radiation ( uv , x - rays , cosmic rays ) sputtered atoms from the grains @xcite . an equally intriguing possibility is that the compositions of planetesimals and/or planets can be _ inferred _ from differential measurements of abundances in the photospheres of stars . this approach is motivated by the detection of small differences in stellar abundances of elements that are more refractory ( higher condensation temperature @xmath11 ) and thus more likely to be incorporated into planets ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . these differences could arise either from the accretion of planetesimals or planets onto the star , after the dissipation of disk gas , or the sequestration of solids into planets , and accretion of the dust - poor gas onto the star . this leads to a prediction that these differences correlate with the presence or properties of planetary systems , and provides a potential `` short - cut '' to discovering planets as well as estimating their chemical composition . however , subsequent analyses of larger samples of stars does not support such a correlation @xcite , and alternative explanations for these differences should be considered . in this work , i critically examine the hypothesis that c / o varies significantly among neighboring stars in the galactic disk ( and hence the host stars of doppler - detected exoplanets ) from both theoretical ( sec . [ sec.gce ] ) , observational ( sec . [ sec.mdwarfs ] ) , and cosmochemical ( sec . [ sec.grains ] ) perspectives . for the first i develop a gce model to predict the abundance of c and o over the history of the galactic disk in the vicinity of the sun . for the second , i use the spectra obtained in m dwarf surveys to place strict upper limits on the occurrence of c - rich single m dwarfs among recent large surveys . for the third , i combine a simple model of interestellar dust evolution with uv measurements of the depletion of heavy elements in the ism to determine what controls the c / o ratio and by how much it may vary . finally , i develop an alternative explanation that can explain the observed elemental relative abundance differences between solar - type stars , without resorting to possible signatures of planet formation ( sec . [ sec.gasdust ] ) . galactic chemical evolution ( gce ) models predict changes in the abundances of elements and isotopes with time in both stars and the ism @xcite . they combine yields of nucleosynthetic products in stellar winds and ejecta with the stellar initial mass function ( imf ) and a prescription for star formation rate to estimate the production of elements and isotopes . these are integrated with descriptions of the flow of heavy elements back into the ism and subsequent incorporation in long - lived low - mass stars and remnants from high - mass stars . production varies with both stellar progenitor mass and metallicity , thus the changing metallicity of new generations of stars must be tracked in a gce . carbon and oxygen are synthesized in stars more massive than 1.5m@xmath12 and injected into the interstellar medium through winds and type ii supernovae ( sn ) : type i sn are predicted to contribute @xmath13% @xcite . gce models generally predict a positive trend of c / o with metallicity ( and hence time ) as well as variation between stellar populations with different chemical histories ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? these trends are broadly observed within disk stars and between the thin , thick - disk and bulge populations , and even between massive and metal - poor irregular dwarf galaxies @xcite . at least two effects are thought to contribute to this correlation : ( i ) the short main - sequence lifetime of massive stars , which are major contributors to @xmath14-elements including c and o , compared to intermediate mass asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) progenitors , which contribute comparatively more to the c budget ; ( ii ) increased mass loss and c yield from younger , more metal - rich agb stars at the expense of o. mass - loss rates depends on metallicity through its effect on the opacity of outer stellar atmospheres and the impact on their structure . the implications of the abundance dependence of c / o yields for the chemical evolution of galaxies has been previously pointed out ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the c / o of bulge and disk populations diverge due to a combination of differences in the stellar imf , wind - driven mass loss in the former and the accretion of primordial metal - poor gas in the former . the flatter imf of bulge stars implies a higher relative production of o from more abundant massive stars . addition ( loss ) of mass from a star - forming system will increase ( decrease ) the amount of star formation required to arrive at a given metal abundance and therefore the c / o at that abundance . one feature of the statistics of stellar metallicities of the galactic disk in the neighborhood of the sun is the relatively narrow dispersion and paucity of metal - poor stars . this is often called the `` g dwarf problem '' and translates into a flat age - metallicity relation for the most of the history of the galactic disk , at least in the solar neighborhood . it is actually not a problem for gce models if addition of metal - poor gas to the disk is admitted to balance stellar nucleosynthesis ( e.g. , * ? ? ? if c / o is strongly correlated with metallicity then a flat age - metallicity relation might mean that c / o evolves very little ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . to re - visit the question of the evolution of c / o in the solar neighborhood , the abundances of the two elements were calculated on an isotope - by - isotope basis using the model described in detail in the appendix . the model simulates the production of these isotopes and release into the ism in sn explosions , winds from massive stars and agb stars , sequestration of isotopes into long - lived low - mass stars , and addition of metal - poor gas by infall onto the galactic disk . the ism is described by two components ; an inter - cloud medium which produces molecular clouds but no stars , and a star - forming giant molecular cloud component . yields for intermediate- and massive stars are taken from a variety of recent sources . best - fit parameters describing the timescale of exponentially - declining gas infall on the disk , the initial metallicity of the infalling gas , the age of the stellar population at the solar galactocentric radius , the index of the power - law describing the imf for massive stars , and the power - law relationship between star formation rate and gas surface density were found by a monte - carlo markov chain analysis : the observational constraints were the age of the sun , the present mass surface density of stars , stellar remanants , and gas at the solar galactocentric radius , solar metallicity ( here taken to be c+o ) , the current metallicity of the ism , and its intrinsic standard deviation . the prediction evolution of c / o is compared to the solar value from @xcite in fig . [ fig.co ] . after initial transients that die away after a few hundred myr , there is only moderate evolution in c / o during most of the history of the galactic disk . the c / o ratio rises from 0.5 to about 0.65 over the first 6 gyr in response to increasing input from stars of lower mass and higher metallicity , as described above , and declines slightly thereafter . the predicted value at the time of the sun s formation is 0.64 , withinin @xmath15 of the @xcite value . the formal error in the predicted value , based on the standard deviation of the mcmc chain after removal of the `` burn in '' , is only 0.003 , but this value does not reflect the dominant source of uncertainty in these calculations the nucleosynthetic yields . although the model is unable to exactly reproduce the solar values of c and o abundances , correctly reproducing these using gce been always been challenging . @xcite also found that satisfactorily reproducing a `` flat '' c / o places constraints on the remnant or `` cut - off '' mass at the center of a sn progenitor which is not injected into the ism . figure [ fig.co2 ] plots the predicted c / o evolution vs. predicted [ o / h ] , again compared to the sun . also plotted are the values found by @xcite for galactic disk stars ( filled points ) and bulge or halo stars ( open points ) and converted to absolute values assuming a solar c / o of 0.55 . the predicted trend is perfectly consistent with the disk values if an offset of about 16% with the predicted vs. measured solar value is artificially removed . the absence of data for disk stars at low [ o / h ] is a consequence of the age - metallicity relationship : comparatively little time elapsed ( @xmath8 gyr according to the model ) and few stars formed in this interval . the predicted constancy of c / o contrasts with previous predictions for an increase in c / o with metallicity / time . for example , both @xcite and @xcite predict a positive slope of @xmath16 dex / dex in [ c / o ] vs. [ o / h ] , and thus a c / o of about 0.06 at [ o / h ] = -1 . since the model and the best - fit parameter values presented here are similar to those of previous works the most likely cause of this difference is in the particular nucleosynthetic yields that were used . the yields from agb stars have been significantly revised @xcite but in the model these are minority contributors to the c and o budgets . indeed , if there contribution is completely removed , c / o still changes little and the predicted solar c / o is slightly closer to the @xcite value . instead , the predictions of this model probably stand out from previous results because of the dominant contribution of massive stars to both c and o. since these stars have very short lives compared to the chemical evolution of the disk , there is no effect from delayed contribution , and the c / o rapidly approaches a steady - state value . previous works have pointed to favorable comparisons of model predictions with observations , but the latter are _ combined _ data on bulge , halo , and thick- and thin - disk populations , therefore assuming a common origin for these populations that may not exist . for example , the [ c / o ] of thin disk stars presented by @xcite and @xcite show no correlation with [ o / h ] and it is only when bulge and thick disk stars are added that such a correlation appears . the apparent consistency between the predicted and observed trends of [ c / o ] vs. [ o / h ] @xcite belies the fact that the models were tuned for the ( thin ) disk population in the solar neighborhood and should not be compared with other stellar populations . it is indisputable that metal - poor bulge / halo stars have low c / o compared to the solar neighborhood @xcite . the model presented here can not , and was not designed to , explain these populations , but their abundances might be a result of a flatter imf , early loss of gas and/or truncation of star formation . but bulge / halo stars are rare in the solar neighborhood and because their lines are very weak they are usually avoided by planet searches using the doppler radial velocity method . c / o may also vary at some level within the solar galactocentric annulus because the sources of nuclides ( stars and stellar clusters ) are discrete and mixing by rotational shear and epicyclic dynamics is not completely efficient . however , gce is occurring on a timescale much longer ( few gyr ) than the rotational time of the galaxy at 8 kpc ( @xmath17250 myr ) which governs the rate of mixing , and thus this limits the magnitude of such heterogeneities . . the @xcite solar value is plotted as well as values for galactic disk stars ( filled points ) and bulge / halo stars ( open points ) from @xcite and tied to the solar value.,width=317 ] in solar - type stars , the absorption lines of c and o are weak and c / o has little effect on the overall spectrum . @xcite pointed out that cooler stars , i.e. brown dwarfs , offer more obvious constraints on the occurrence of high c / o systems . the spectra of m dwarfs , with effective temperatures @xmath18 @xmath19k , also include absorption bands of o - containing molecules , e.g. tio , vo , and caoh , which are sensitive to the available o abundance @xcite , and hence c / o . at c / o @xmath9 , tio is absent and the schwan bands of c@xmath5 , cn , and ch should appear . such spectra are characteristic of carbon stars , evolved stars in which dredge - up of carbon - righ interiors has occurred ( agb stars ) . if the initial mass function of star formation is chemically invariant , a limit on the occurrence of c - rich m dwarfs is also a limit on c - rich g dwarfs . dwarf carbon ( dc ) star have been identified @xcite but these probably accreted carbon - rich gas from a present or former evolved companion @xcite . overall , dc stars are uncommon @xcite . carbon enhanced metal - poor ( cemp ) stars in the galactic halo appear are also rare overall but more prevalent among ( initially ) metal - poor systems because less accreted c is required to increase c / o @xcite . any tally of _ intrinsically _ carbon - rich dwarfs must remove these interlopers or be considered an upper limit . i considered three spectral indices which are continuum - normalized measures of the emission in specific bands @xcite : cah , which is the mean of the cah2 ( 6814 - 6846 ) and cah3 ( 6960 - 6990 ) indices ; tio5 ( 7126 - 7135 ) ; and caoh ( 6230 - 6240 ) . values of these temperature- and gravity - sensitive indices are highly and positively correlated among solar - metallicity m dwarfs . carbon - rich stars can be identified by relatively weak bands of oxygen - containing tio and caoh , i.e. high tio5 or caoh indices , for a given strength of the non - oxygen - containing cah . however , indices of metal - poor subdwarfs or `` extreme '' subdwarfs exhibit similar behavior @xcite . to guide discrimination between c - rich m dwarfs and metal - poor stars based on indices , synthetic spectra were generated using the bt - settl version of the phoenix models @xcite . four cases were considered : a solar - metallicity star , a star with [ m / h ] = 0 but c and o adjusted so that c / o=1 , a metal - poor subdwarf ( sd ) with [ m / h ] = -1 , and an extreme subdwarf ( esd ) with [ fe / h ] = -2 . the last two cases also had an alpha - element enhancement [ @xmath14/fe ] = + 0.4 . effective temperatures over the entire m dwarf and late - k dwarf range in steps of 100 k were considered . all cases had @xmath20 , except for the esd which had @xmath21 . the visible and far - red portions of the spectra are plotted and compared in fig . [ fig.spectra ] . the bands used to compute the cah , tio5 , and caoh indices are indicated . the current bt - settl line lists do not actually include caoh , but the bandpass also includes the tio @xmath22 line which is also sensitive to c / o . k , @xmath20 , and solar abundances ( * ? ? ? * red line ) , metal - poor subdwarf ( [ fe / h ] = -1 , [ @xmath14/fe ] = 0 , green line ) , extreme subdwarf ( [ fe / h ] = -2 , [ @xmath14/fe ] = + 0.4 , @xmath21 , blue line ) , and solar - metallicity star except some o as c such that c / o=1 ( red line ) . bottom : ratios of the three non solar - metallicity spectra described above to the solar metallicity spectrum.,width=317 ] as expected , in the c / o=1 case ( black lines in fig . [ fig.spectra ] ) the tio bands at around 6235 and 6700 are dramatically weakened relative to the solar case ( red line ) while those of cah are essentially unchanged . this is also true for the esd case ( but not the subdwarf case ) . the differential response of tio5 and cah is the basis for the `` @xmath23 '' parameter developed by @xcite . however , the c / o=1 and esd cases differ markedly at 4700 - 5300 and below 4500 because fe lines are very weak in the esd case . there are also difference at @xmath24 ( fig . [ fig.spectra ] ) . absorption by h@xmath5o over a broad wavelength range centered at 1.9@xmath25 m is also weaker in the c / o=1 case , but this would be difficult to ascertain from the ground . index values were calculated for the four cases at each @xmath18 . i searched for carbon - rich m dwarfs in three spectroscopic catalogs : the conch - shell spectroscopic catalog of nearby , bright m dwarfs @xcite , the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) catalog of m dwarfs constructed by @xcite , and the lamost spectroscopic catalog of m dwarfs in @xcite . stars in the conch - shell catalog were selected based on brightness ( @xmath26 ) , parallaxes or proper motions consistent with main sequence status , and colors . although some sets of stars in the catalog were selected based on optical and infrared colors consistent with `` normal '' m dwarfs , this criterion was relaxed for another set , thus admitting any c - rich dwarfs with peculiar colors . the selection for `` red '' ( @xmath27 ) stars is not relaxed , and this inevitably eliminates some metal - poor early m - type dwarfs , although not necessarily c - rich examples . figure [ fig.indices ] plots the tio5 vs. cah indices for conchshell stars . the red line is the best - fit quadratic to the locus and the black points and lines are the values computed from phoenix bt - settl spectra . i identified 18 conch - shell stars with a tio5 band that is significantly ( @xmath28 ) weaker ( larger index ) compared to a best - fit second - order fit of tio5 as a function of cah . when calculating the significance of a deviation , an intrinsic dispersion of 0.032 in tio5 was added in quadrature to the formal measurement errors . none of these 18 stars had indices that deviate to the extent predicted for a c / o=1 star . the most deviant star is pm i20050 + 5426/gj 781/wolf 1130 , with a tio5 index that is 0.17 above the best - fit locus value . this was previously identified as an active m1.5 subdwarf @xcite with a metallicity based on an infrared spectrum of @xmath29 @xcite . interestingly , @xcite identified wolf 1130 as a single - lined spectroscopic binary ( @xmath30 d ) and proposed that the unseen companion was a 0.3m@xmath12 helium white dwarf . a hubble space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) spectrum of the star ( fig . [ fig.stis ] ) exhibits some tio absorption and no diagnostic carbon - star features . there is also no indication of a wd companion , although this would be consistent with an advanced age and hence low uv luminosity of any such object . spectra of the other candidates indicate they are metal - poor stars , or have systematic errors . ) . some atomic lines and molecular bands are labeled ; the red dashed lines mark the locations of some cn and c@xmath5 schwan bands observed in carbon stars , but not in this star.,width=317 ] i examined the molecular indices for two much larger samples of m dwarfs from the sdss and lamost @xcite . figure [ fig.dr7 ] shows the tio5 and caoh indices vs. cah index for 70,841 m dwarfs with spectra in data release 7 of the sloan digital sky survey @xcite . the grey scale is linearly related to the density of stars in the tio5- or caoh - vs . cah plots . the black dashed line is the best - fit to the stellar locus , and the red , aquamarine , dashed purple , and black solid lines are the predictions from the bt - settl models for the solar metallicity , subdwarf , extreme subdwarf , and c / o=1 cases , respectively . stars for which either index value is significantly ( @xmath28 ) higher than the best - fit polynomial to the stellar locus , and within @xmath15 of or above the predicted c / o=1 locus and are plotted as open points . the 30 stars where both indices satisfy these criteria are plotted as filled points . inspection of the sdss spectra of these 30 stars found that all are consistent with template spectra of solar - metallicity or metal - poor stars and do not have the featuers expected of c / o=1 stellar atmospheres . figure [ fig.lamost ] is the analogous set of plots for 67,082 candidate m dwarfs from a pilot survey of the large area multi - object fiber spectroscopic telescope ( lamost , * ? ? ? * ) . the intrinsic scatter in index values , after correcting for measurement errors , is much larger for this sample , perhaps due to systematic errors . only two stars have both tio5 and caoh values significantly above the locus , and within 1@xmath31 of the predicted c / o line . however , the index values of these stars are all @xmath32 and probably spurious . the paucity of high c / o candidates in the lamost survey compared to the sdss dr7 sample is undoubtedly due to the larger uncertainties in the indices . based on the conch - shell sample alone , high c / o @xmath16 stars constitute less than @xmath33 of m dwarfs with 95% confidence , a stricter constraint than the limits placed by @xcite based on spectroscopy of 66 solar - type stars . the null result from the dr7 sample places an an even more stringent upper limit of @xmath34 at 99% confidence . it is possible that manual screening performed by @xcite to remove corrupted spectra could have excluded carbon - rich stars , but at the resolution and signal - to - noise of the spectra , the differences that distinguish c / o=1 spectra from the solar case would not make them overwhelmingly abberant . theoretical studies linking the abundances in the photospheres of host stars to the composition of rocky planets generally assume that the building blocks of planetesimals condensed directly from a cooling gaseous disk of the same composition , but there is accumulating meteoritic evidence that primitive solids in the solar system were by and large _ not _ produced by de nova condensation from a gas of solar composition . instead , this material was the outcome of partial thermal processing of pre - existing solids under high dust / gas ratios and oxygen abundance ( fugacity , @xmath35 ) brought about by growth and settling of grains to the nebular mid - plane and/or inward migration of water - rich ( and hence o - rich ) planetesimals @xcite . this evidence includes ( i ) the survival of pre - solar grains and isotopic anomalies inherited from the molecular cloud and older generations of stars @xcite ; ( ii ) the gradual variation in the abundance of elements with condensation temperature in primitive meteorites , which contradicts the sharp cutoff predicted by equilibrium condensation and which can not be explained by radial transport in the disk @xcite ; ( iii ) the retention of volatile sodium and sulfur and lack of isotopic mass fractionation for potassium and silicon in chondrules @xcite ; and ( iv ) molybdenum and tungsten depletions in refractory inclusions @xcite . the equilibrium oxygen fugacities of minerals in many meteorites also suggest high ambient @xmath35 , but some could also be explained by alteration on the parent bodies of the meteorites @xcite . dust growth and settling to the midplane of a disk is predicted to occur in @xmath36-@xmath37 yr , depending on the intensity of turbulence in the disk @xcite . dust settling , as well as growth , might be observed via its effect on the spectral energy distribution of a disk @xcite . tentative evidence for significant dust settling and depletion from the upper layers of the disks of t tauri stars ( ages of @xmath38 yr ) has been presented @xcite , but unambiguous detection of settling is challenging @xcite . if settling occurs faster than the viscous accretion time of a disk ( @xmath39 yr , * ? ? ? * ) then grains will experience high temperatures only in a dust - rich environment . if the precursor material of planetesimals is dust , rather than gas , then to a large extent the composition of interstellar grains governs the composition of rocky exoplanets . interstellar dust begins its existence as condensates in the cooling envelopes and winds of agb and red giant branch stars but these grains are subsequently and completely altered by many cycles of erosion and formation of mantles in the ism . erosion takes place in the lower - density , higher - temperature inter - cloud phase of the ism , principally by sputtering by ions heated by the passage of supernova shocks as well as uv photons . condensation takes place onto surviving grains that are incorporated into the denser , cooler cloud phase of the ism . the cycling time between these two phases ( @xmath40 yr , set by the cloud lifetime ) is short compared to the mean time since formation in a circumstellar wind ( @xmath41 yr ) , hence the bulk elemental composition of ism grains is set by the balance between condensation and sputtering @xcite . the bulk composition of dust can be inferred by measuring the depletion of elements from the gas phase , i.e. using the strength of uv absorption lines along different lines of sight through the ism to some suitable background source . following @xcite , the equations of motion of the depletions @xmath42 in the cloud ( @xmath43 ) and inter - cloud ( @xmath44 ) medium of any particular element can be written as : @xmath45 and @xmath46 respectively . in these equations , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 are the rate of mixing from the intercloud to the cloud medium , the rate of mixing from the cloud to the intercloud medium , the rate of grain destruction in the intercloud medium , and the rate of grain growth from molecular cloud gas , respectively . the nucleosynthetic rate of production of an element is much slower than any of the rates of the formation of clouds , dissipation of clouds , destruction by sputtering in the inter - cloud phase , and growth condensation in the cloud phase , respectively , and is ignored here . the steady state solutions are : @xmath51 and @xmath52 thus , the steady - state abundances are governed by only two parameters , the amount of growth in the clouds @xmath53 , and the amount of erosion between clouds : @xmath54 . i estimated parameter values for some elements using the data compiled by @xcite . i set @xmath55 and @xmath56 to @xmath57_1 $ ] ( maximum depletion ) and @xmath58_0 $ ] ( minimum depletion ) , respectively , and solved for @xmath54 and @xmath53 . figure [ fig.rates ] plots these two parameters . three elements with data in @xcite are not shown : to explain the abundances of p , cl , and zn in the context of this model requires _ negative _ destruction in the intercloud medium . this may be an artifact of photoionization since the abundance of these elements is estimated from their singly ionized forms . the comparatively low condensation rates of kr , c , and o reflect the volatility of these elements . the behavior of o deviates strongly from that of the refractory elements , perhaps because the primary carrier of o is not silicates but a much more volatile substance such as water ice . likewise c does not behave as a refractory such as graphite @xcite . this suggests that c is present as relatively volatile organic matter @xcite . kr is not expected to condense and the non - zero value of @xmath53 may be a consequence of measurement errors or departures from solar relative abundances @xcite . the differences in the parameters for c and o manifest themselves as a modified c / o ratio in interstellar dust with respect to the total ( gas+dust ) abundance . in the case of the nominal rates inferred from the data of @xcite , the degree of depletion from cold molecular cloud gas shows that the c / o of the dust is 0.92 times that of the bulk ism , i.e. slightly more oxygen - rich than the current bulk ism value . although o is depleted more rapidly from interstellar grains , it is also accreted more rapidly . one caveat of this estimate for the dust c / o is that the gas - phase depletion of c is more uncertain than other elements because there are few suitable absorption lines @xcite . the c / o could also vary between locations as a result of varying @xmath54 and/or @xmath53 . @xcite estimated the residence time @xmath59 in the warm inter - cloud phase of the ism as @xmath60 yr assuming that it is set by the timescale for shocking by sn and subsequent cooling and collapse into clouds . this was consistent with an ism mass fraction in the warm phase of @xmath1710% . however , the mass in the warm phase is probably comparable to the dense molecular h@xmath5 ( cloud ) phase @xcite and thus the residence time in the inter - cloud phase is similar to the cloud lifetime @xmath61 yr @xcite . over this time , dust grains may experience @xmath62 sn shocks before becoming incorporated into molecular clouds . in contrast , @xmath53 would be expected to vary only to the extent that the lifetimes of molecular clouds varies . i estimated the sensitivity to variations in these rates by multiplying each of the parameter ratios by varying factors @xmath63 $ ] . figure [ fig.contour ] plots the predicted variation of c / o with contours intervals of 10% . the unadjusted parameter values , which predict [ c / o]@xmath64 ( heavy contour ) , are at unit value abcissa and ordinate ( circle ) . variation in the efficiency of grain destruction in the intercloud medium ( @xmath54 ) have more effect on dust c / o than variation in the efficiency of grain growth in molecular clouds ( @xmath53 ) . this difference is a consequence of the larger dispersion ( a ratio of @xmath65 ) in the removal of o vs. c during grain destruction compared to the dispersion in the incorporation of o vs. c during grain growth ( a ratio of @xmath66 , fig . [ fig.rates ] ) . the very volatile behavior of o compared to the other elements is presumably because some of it is incorporated as water ice mantles around dust grains . this model predicts that large ( factors of two ) variation in dust lifetime produced by different shock and uv conditions in the intercloud medium will produce modest ( @xmath1720% ) variation in bulk dust c / o , with dust in the vicinity of massive sn progenitors more carbon - rich . by the arguments presented above , variation in dust c / o could generate diversity in the composition of planeteismals , but this will be limited by the extent that water ice is retained on dust grains ( see below ) . a pronounced correlation between the metallicity of the host star and the occurrence of giant planets was discovered early in the history of exoplanet science @xcite . increasingly precise measurements of the relative abundances of elements in stellar photospheres have permitted more nuanced investigations of correlations with planet occurrence ( e.g. , * ? ? ? @xcite found that the solar composition was anomalous compared to 9 out of a sample of 11 solar `` twins '' and that the sun is deficient ( @xmath67 dex ) in refractory elements ( condensation temperature @xmath68 k ) compared to more volatile elements . they proposed that this was a signature of the sequestration of those elements in rocky planets and cores of gas giants . @xcite also found a statistical correlation between planets and a deficit of refractory elements among larger samples of solar - type stars in doppler surveys . if differences in relative photosphere abundances are a signature of rocky planets or giant planet cores , this would provide a short - cut to planet detection and even a means to probe the composition of the planets themselves @xcite . on the other hand , @xcite find no clear correlation between the slope of the relative abundance vs. @xmath69 and the presence or absence of planets . one factor that may contribute to these contrasting results is the removal of galactic chemical evolution trends , e.g. decreasing [ @xmath14/fe ] with increasing metallicity , by @xcite . moroever , @xcite found no trend with @xmath69 in the relative abundances of members of the solar - age , solar - metallicity cluster m67 . observations of physical pairs of stars with and without ( detected ) planets provide the clearest test of the planet - abundance relation , as both stars should have formed from the same molecular cloud . but the available observations do unambiguously support such a correlation @xcite . in fact , the trend of increasing differential abundance with increasing condensation temperature approximately mirrors the pattern of depletion of elements in ism gas @xcite . this simply reflects the preferential condensation of refractory elements onto interstellar grains and the universality of chemistry . if interstellar dust does not perfectly follow the gas , this will produce variation in element abundances that are proportional to the extent of gas - dust segregation and the dust composition . all else being equal , the abundances of the more refractory elements ( which are mostly in the dust ) would be expected to vary more than volatile elements ( which are mostly in the gas ) , in a manner that roughly correlates with @xmath69 . there is evidence for , and theoretical predictions of , dust - gas segregation in the ism . @xcite found that the power - law describing the spatial distribution of extinction ( a tracer of the column density of dust ) on the sky is shallower than that of @xmath70co ( a tracer of the gas column density ) , such that in the densest regions of the ism , extinction by dust is less than that predicted by perfect correspondence with the gas . this could be explained by grain growth in excess of that predicted by models . ( co condensation would presumably act in the opposite sense * ? ? ? * ) . but @xcite offer spatial variation in dust - to - gas ratio as an alternative explanation . dust - gas segregation could occur at three different scales ; ( i ) over the extent of a giant molecular cloud or star - forming region ; ( ii ) in cloud cores that collapse to form individual stellar systems ; and ( iii ) in the accretion disks around young stellar objects . @xcite estimated that dust drift due to radiation pressure from o stars can remove dust from the centers of h ii regions in @xmath71 myr , but since such low - density regions are not themselves the site of star formation , this effect should not manifest itself in the relative abundances of stellar photospheres . @xcite showed that the different dynamics of dust and gas during bondi - type accretion flow can enhance dust - to - gas ratios by an order of magnitude in cloud cores . the mechanism modeled by @xcite relies on dust velocities of several km sec@xmath72 relative to the gas around the growing cloud core . the size distribution of interstellar dust grains peaks sharply near 0.2 - 0.3 @xmath25 m @xcite . these grains may be dynamically decoupled from the diffuse interstellar medium ( number density @xmath73 @xmath74 , stopping distance @xmath75 pc ) , and there is tentative evidence for this in the trajectories of interstellar meteors @xcite and _ ulysses _ spacecraft measurements @xcite . however , these grains will be tightly coupled to the molecular gas ( @xmath76 @xmath74 ) surrounding a cloud core , i.e. over length scales @xmath4 pc and much smaller than a typical cloud size . under such conditions it seems unlikely that dust acceleration mechanisms ( * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * e.g. , ) can achieve equipartion of energy between ism and dust and speeds of @xmath1710 km s@xmath72 . the second scenario which could produce variation in the dust - to - gas ratio in cloud cores is drift induced by radiation pressure . @xcite showed that the inward radial drift of 0.1-@xmath25 m grains under the influence of a typical radiation field can treble the dust concentration in a static gas sphere of a few solar masses at 10 k in 10 myr . the effect scales linearly with the intensity of the external radiation field and the inverse of the characteristic cloud column density . grains reach terminal velocity on a timescale of @xmath10 yr , i.e. much shorter than the cloud lifetime . thus any density enhancement can be expected to grow linearly and the total dust enhancement can be expected to scale with the total external radiation experienced by the cloud core over its lifetime . @xcite numerically simulated this effect , including gas dynamics as well as coupling between the gas and dust , and found that the dust concentration is enhanced by about an order of magnitude in a narrow , inward - propagating shell , and depleted exterior to that shell . while the mean dust - to - gas ratio of a cloud is not changed by migration , truncation of the cloud by photoevaporation or internal collapse ( to the exclusion of outer regions ) would produce a metal - enhanced object . both @xcite and @xcite point out the relevance of this process to the metallicities of stars and the formation of their planets . a third scenario for dust - gas segregation involves accreting protostars and their disks , or concomitant bondi - hoyle accretion from the molecular cloud @xcite . photoevaporation of gas , but not dust , from a disk produces an enhancement in the dust - to - gas ratio which is inherited by the star as disk accretion continues . photoevaporation of disks driven by x - rays from the central star has been proposed to explain the final , rapid stage of circumstellar disk clearing @xcite . observations of blue - shifted lines of ne ii @xcite and o i @xcite indicate that heavy volatile elements as well as h and he are lost in these winds . the temperature of the x - ray - heated `` surface '' of the disk from which the winds flow is heated to a few thousand k @xcite , but gravitational settling ( and the formation of planetesimals ) keeps dust near the cooler mid - plane . disk masses are typically 1% of the central star , with a large scatter @xcite ; assuming the convection zone of a young solar - mass star contains 0.1m@xmath12 , accretion of an entire disk which has been severaly gas - depleted would increase relative elemental abundances by @xmath77 dex , or @xmath78 dex if the convection zone contains 0.4m@xmath12 . this may fall short of explaining some of the observations . two important clues to the mechanism(s ) of the observed variation are the spatial scale on which the variation occurs , and the @xmath69 of the `` elbow '' in the relative abundance variation below which abundances do not vary in any systematic manner . surveys of nearby , solar - age field stars offer little information on the spatial scale of the segregation as the stars are far from their birthplace . @xcite found no significant difference between m67 cluster stars and the sun , and proposed that the sun also formed in a dense cluster analogous to m67 . they suggested that the common pattern of relative abundances was established by the removal of dust by radiation drift . but there are several problems with this explanation . star formation does not take place in hii regions but in surrounding neutral gas , and , as they point out , the expansion of an hii region should outpace dust drift . this explanation also requires most stars to form after an earlier generation of massive stars that move the dust . it also requires that the vast majority of nearby solar - type stars have _ not _ formed in dense stellar clusters , something not supported by cluster statistics @xcite . finally , abundance differences between stars in physical pairs requires gas - dust segregation on scales smaller than the cloud core . the other clue is the value @xmath69 below which relative abundance variation disappears , as this suggests the temperature and hence location where the dust and gas segregation occurs . if this `` knee '' in the abundance variation vs. @xmath69 is 1000 k , as many data sets suggest @xcite , this would seem to rule out a molecular cloud setting with @xmath79 k where even some c and o condense as organics and ices . all of these observations point to gas - dust segregation during the formation or subsequent evolution of an accretion disk as a plausible explanation of the abundance trends . neither observations of m dwarfs nor models of galactic chemical evolution support the premise that there are a significant number of stellar systems with primordial c / o @xmath16 in the solar neighborhood , i.e. within the samples of doppler radial velocity surveys . moreover , if the process of planet formation is universal , then studies of primitive meteorites show that the chemical composition of small , rocky planets is controlled largely by the composition and thermal processing of pre - existing dust from the parent molecular cloud , rather than condensation from gas with the stellar composition , and that this dust is likely to have a c / o reflecting that of the bulk ism . finally , small differences in the relative patterns between the sun and solar `` twins '' can best be explained by dust - gas segregation at stellar scales and temperatures of up to 1000 k , i.e. in accreting protostars , rather than planet formation per se . when comparing the sun to the solar neighborhood it is usually assumed that they share a common history . however , it is also possible that the two are not related . @xcite estimated `` cosmic '' standard abundances ( rather the present - day abundances in the solar neighborhood ) using bright , slowly - rotating , early - type b stars . due to their short main sequence lives , b stars contain abundance information that is both contemparaneous and local , and their purely radiative atmospheres are comparatively simple to model , although uv photoionization rates must be correctly modeled @xcite . @xcite report metallicities that are very close to solar , depsite 4.5 gyr of intervening gce , and a mean c / o of 0.37 , lower than the solar value of 0.55 . they explain both discrepancies by appealing to outward migration of the sun in the galactic disk . these findings warrant further investigation . depletion patterns in the ism suggest that the c / o of dust largely reflects the ism ; o is incorporated more rapidly in grains than c in molecular clouds but it is depleted from grains more quickly in the intercloud medium , and these two effects approximately balance . variation in the efficiency of grain erosion by sn shocks and uv radiation could produce modest variations in the c / o , however . while the phases of o in interstellar grains are clearly water ice and silicates , the phases of c are more controversial . volatility patterns suggest c is _ not _ in refractory phase(s ) like graphite and carbides but instead more volatile organic molecules , in particular aromatic hydrocarbons @xcite . aliphatic hydrocarbons have been suggested as the source of the ubiquitious ism absorbtion feature at 3.4@xmath25 m but the absence of polarization in this line is difficult to reconcile with a scenario of condensation of carbonaceous mantles onto silicate cores @xcite . surface reactions could explain why growth rate of c in grains is very slow with respect to other elements . while these considerations plus a bulk ism c / o@xmath8 are sufficient to explain the oxidized nature of dust in the solar system , it remains to be explained why primitive meteorites in the solar system are very depleted in both c and o , especially c. based on the meteorite abundances and associated uncertainties compiled by @xcite and solar abundances and uncertainties from @xcite , the depletion has a stochiometric ratio of @xmath80 , i.e. consistent with unity and depletion by the formation and removal of co. in this scenario the removal of c or o is not controlled by volatility , otherwise either c or o would be far more depleted than the other , depending on the effective @xmath69 . this can occur if the reaction occurs in situ , i.e. at temperatures lower than the @xmath69s of the c and o phases ( @xmath81k ) where both elements are retained in grains , and/or where vapor is not lost by turbulent mixing , i.e. in `` dead zone '' where turbulence is suppressed . primitive meteorites , considered analogs to the now - lost building blocks of the solar system , also include the highly - reduced enstatite chondrites . enstatite chondrites contain carbide minerals but virtually no water and have been explained by equilibration of solids with a gas having c / o = 0.83 @xcite . interestingly , removal of an amount of c and o equal to that incorporated in ci chondrites produces a residual gas with a c / o of 0.93 . @xcite have proposed that removal of refractories from a gas of solar composition and equilibration of solids with the remaining gas could produce the precursors for enstatite chondrites . if enstatite chondrites formed from recycling of the precursors of terrestrial planets in an oxygen - poor gas it could explain why the enstatite chondrites and earth lie along the same mass - dependent fractionation line in a three oxygen - isotope plot . this equilibration would necessarily have occurred at a comparatively low dust - to - gas ratio and lower temperatures where moderately volatile elements such as fe would not be lost . al - mg isotopes of cais in unequilibrated enstatite chondrites indicate that these refractory inclusions formed in the same region as cais in other chondrites , but were subsequently exposed to reducing conditions @xcite . reducing conditions could have been established sequentially or in a different part of the protoplanetary disk . the formation times of enstatite chondrites is an area of active research . dating of sulfides in unequilibrated e chondrites using the fe - ni and mn - cr short - lived radionuclide chronometers gives ages of 12 - 13 myr after cai formation @xcite . re - analysis of the mn - cr isotope data for a single sulfide in the macalpine hills 88136 el3 chondrite @xcite plus an initial @xmath82mn/@xmath83mn of @xmath84 @xcite gives an age of 10 myr . in summary , i propose the following scenario for the chemistry of rocky planets : * planet formation proceeds from a two - component ism ( gas and dust ) which are never fully equilibraxted during the formation process . * the composition of the precursor material of solar system material is interstellar dust with refractory abundances and a c / o ratio approximately equal to the bulk ism ; this was set by grain growth in molecular clouds and destruction between clouds . * planetesimals , as represented by carbonaceous ( ci ) chondrites , formed under the oxidizing , high dust - to - gas ratio conditions established by settling of interstellar grains to the disk mid - plane and subsequent depletion of c and o by formation and removal of co. * enstatite chondrites represent reduced material that equilibrated with gas after removal of solids in approximately ci proportions , possibly during a second generation of planetesimal formation . * the chemical composition of rocky exoplanets could be set by mixing of oxidized and reduced generations of planetesimals . the mixing ratio could be determined by the effiency with which the first , oxidizing generation incorporated disk solids , as well as the dynamics of accretion in the disk . giant planets , unlike the small , rocky planets considered in this work , accrete massive gas envelopes that would include volatile species such as co , and the considerations described above do not preclude the possibility of c - rich atmospheres in giant planets . detections of such objects have been claimed , but are controversial ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? if the core - first model of giant planet formation is correct , removal of o as silicates and sequestration into a core increases the c / o ratio of the gas that is subsequently captured into the planet s envelope . beyond the ice - line , condensation of water and removal of more o would drive the c / o of the gas even closer to unity @xcite . dissociation of co in the disk and removal of the o as water ice would further enhance this ratio , and indeed the enrichment of planetary water in @xmath85o and @xmath86o relative to the sun is thought to be a signature of this process @xcite . these processes may facilitate the formation of reduced , enstatite chondrite - like planetesimals as discussed above . the author thanks derek homeier and france allard for generating the c / o=1 cases with the phoenix atmosphere model , gary huss for discussions which stimulated this work , and larry nittler for comments . this research was supported by nasa grants nnx10aq36 g and nnx11ac33 g to eg . 139 natexlab#1#1 , c. m. o. , & ebel , d. s. 2012 , meteoritics and planetary science , 47 , 1157 , f. , homeier , d. , & freytag , b. 2011 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 448 , 16th cambridge workshop on cool stars , stellar systems , and the sun , ed . c. johns - krull , m. k. browning , & a. a. west , 91 , s. m. , rosenfeld , k. a. , kraus , a. l. , & wilner , d. j. 2013 , , 771 , 129 , s. s. , & lewis , j. s. 1976 , , 14 , 81 , t. c. , preston , g. w. , & shectman , s. a. 1992 , , 103 , 1987 , n. t. , bonifacio , p. , ludwig , h .- g . , et al . 2010 , , 513 , a72 , p. m. 2008 , , 678 , 1099 , t. , & feltzing , s. 2008 , in nuclei in the cosmos ( nic x ) , 197 , a. d. , wolfire , m. , & leroy , a. k. 2013 , , 51 , 207 , j. c. , obrien , d. p. , & lauretta , d. s. 2010 , , 715 , 1050 , c. , kleine , t. , dauphas , n. , & wieler , r. 2012 , earth and planetary science letters , 357 , 298 , e. , ludwig , h .- g . , steffen , m. , freytag , b. , & bonifacio , p. 2011 , , 268 , 255 , j. c. , obrien , d. p. , & raymond , s. n. 2012 , , 760 , 44 , s. i. b. , meyer , d. m. , & lauroesch , j. t. 2003 , , 597 , 408 , g. , matteucci , f. , mcwilliam , a. , & chiappini , c. 2009 , , 505 , 605 , j. e. , tielens , a. g. g. m. , adamson , a. j. , & ricca , a. 2013 , , 770 , 78 , l. , & povich , m. s. 2011 , , 142 , 197 , f. j. 2007 , , 654 , l159 ciesla , f. j. 2008 , meteoritics & planetary science , 43 , 639 , r. n. 2002 , , 415 , 860 , i. j. m. , barman , t. , hansen , b. m. s. , tanaka , i. , & kodama , t. 2012 , , 760 , 140 , c. c. , liebert , j. , kron , r. g. , spinrad , h. , & hintzen , p. m. 1977 , , 216 , 757 , a. m. 2011 , proceedings of the national academy of science , 108 , 19142 , e. , israelian , g. , gonzlez hernndez , j. i. , et al . 2010 , , 725 , 2349 , c. l. , gil - pons , p. , lau , h. h. b. , lattanzio , j. c. , & siess , l. 2014 , , 437 , 195 , r. a. , margon , b. , anderson , s. f. , et al . 2004 , , 127 , 2838 , b. t. 2003 , , 41 , 241 . 2011 , physics of the interstellar and intergalactic medium , a. , israelian , g. , santos , n. c. , et al . 2004 , , 426 , 619 . 2006 , , 445 , 633 , b. , andersen , j. , gustafsson , b. , et al . 1993 , , 275 , 101 , s. , meyer , m. r. , & moore , b. 2012 , icarus , 221 , 859 , c. , garca - rojas , j. , carigi , l. , et al . 2014 , , 443 , 624 , d. , nissen , p. e. , asplund , m. , pettini , m. , & akerman , c. 2009 , , 500 , 1143 , b. , & palme , h. 1985 , earth and planetary science letters , 72 , 311 , d. a. , & valenti , j. 2005 , , 622 , 1102 , j. j. 2012 , , 747 , l27 , d. t. , & brown , r. l. 1997 , , 113 , 221 , e. , hartmann , l. , calvet , n. , et al . 2006 , , 165 , 568 , e. , mann , a. w. , lepine , s. , et al . 2014 , arxiv e - prints , arxiv:1406.7353 gaidos , e. j. 2000 , icarus , 145 , 637 , d. r. , skillman , e. d. , dufour , r. j. , et al . 1995 , , 443 , 64 , r. d. , truran , j. w. , williams , r. e. , & starrfield , s. 1998 , , 110 , 3 , j. e. 1997 , , 113 , 806 . 1998 , , 115 , 2053 , g. 1998 , , 334 , 221 , j. i. , delgado - mena , e. , sousa , s. g. , et al . 2013 , , 552 , a6 , p. 2013 , , 765 , 12 grossman , l. , beckett , j. r. , fedkin , a. v. , simon , s. b. , & ciesla , f. j. 2008 , reviews in mineralogy and geochemistry , 68 , 93 , y. , huss , g. r. , & leshin , l. a. 2007 , , 71 , 4082 , y. , huss , g. r. , macpherson , g. j. , & wasserburg , g. j. 2000 , science , 289 , 1330 , b. , karlsson , t. , olsson , e. , edvardsson , b. , & ryde , n. 1999 , , 342 , 426 , c. j. , schwartz , j. c. , & cowan , n. b. 2014 , , 444 , 3632 , p. , edwards , s. , & ghandour , l. 1995 , , 452 , 736 , l. , calvet , n. , gullbring , e. , & dalessio , p. 1998 , , 495 , 385 , d. c. , russell , s. s. , ross , a. j. , & kearsley , a. t. 2008 , meteoritics and planetary science , 43 , 1879 , t. , lazarian , a. , & schlickeiser , r. 2012 , , 747 , 54 , j. , nordstrm , b. , & andersen , j. 2007 , , 475 , 519 , g. r. , meshik , a. p. , smith , j. b. , & hohenberg , c. m. 2003 , , 67 , 4823 , m. , & ruzicka , a. 2000 , meteoritics and planetary science , 35 , 601 , w .- c . , henry , t. j. , beaulieu , t. d. , & subasavage , j. p. 2008 , , 136 , 840 , e. b. 2009 , , 700 , 1299 , a. p. 2009 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 414 , cosmic dust - near and far , ed . t. henning , e. grn , & j. steinacker , 473 , a. p. , fanciullo , l. , khler , m. , et al . 2013 , , 558 , a62 , a. i. 2010 , , 403 , 1413 , a. i. , & lattanzio , j. c. 2014 , arxiv e - prints , arxiv:1405.0062 , c. , karakas , a. i. , & umeda , h. 2011 , , 414 , 3231 , c. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , & ohkubo , t. 2006 , , 653 , 1145 , h. , & grn , e. 2009 , interstellar dust inside and outside the heliosphere , ed . j. l. linsky , v. v. izmodenov , e. mbius , & r. von steiger , 347 , s. , rich , r. m. , & shara , m. m. 2007 , , 669 , 1235 , q. , liang , s. l. , & li , a. 2014 , , 440 , l56 , m. r. , knutson , h. , wolf , a. s. , & yung , y. l. 2014 , , 783 , 70 , f. , asplund , m. , ramrez , i. , yong , d. , & melndez , j. 2014 , , 442 , l51 lodders , k. 2003 , sciences - new york , 1220 , l. s. 2013 , astrophysics , 56 , 472 , n. , harrington , j. , stevenson , k. b. , et al . 2011 , , 469 , 64 , a. 1992 , , 264 , 105 , g. w. , isaacson , h. , howard , a. w. , et al . 2014 , , 210 , 20 , l. 2010 , , 515 , a68 , j. , asplund , m. , gustafsson , b. , & yong , d. 2009 , , 704 , l66 , j. , madhusudhan , n. , & fischer , d. 2014 , , 787 , 81 , k. 2014 , , 100 , 51 , n. 2011 , , 729 , 133 , t. , & ostriker , j. p. 2006 , , 366 , 899 , m .- f . , & przybilla , n. 2012 , , 539 , a143 , p. e. 2013 , , 552 , a73 , p. e. , chen , y. q. , carigi , l. , schuster , w. j. , & zhao , g. 2014 , arxiv e - prints , arxiv:1406.5218 nomura , h. , & nakagawa , y. 2006 , the astrophysical journal , 640 , 1099 , k. i. , murray - clay , r. , & bergin , e. a. 2011 , , 743 , l16 , a. , gustafsson , b. , & korn , a. 2014 , , 562 , a102 , j. e. , clarke , c. j. , & ercolano , b. 2012 , , 422 , 1880 , p. , cambrsy , l. , juvela , m. , et al . 2006 , , 649 , 807 , i. , & sterzik , m. 2009 , , 702 , 724 , e. a. , howard , a. w. , & marcy , g. w. 2013 , proceedings of the national academy of science , 110 , 19273 , e. a. , & marcy , g. w. 2011 , , 735 , 41 , l. , chiosi , c. , & bressan , a. 1998 , , 334 , 505 prantzos , n. 2008 , sciences - new york , 1 , a. s. , reyl , c. , allard , f. , et al . 2014 , , 564 , a90 , i. , asplund , m. , baumann , p. , melndez , j. , & bensby , t. 2010 , , 521 , a33 , i. n. , hawley , s. l. , & gizis , j. e. 1995 , , 110 , 1838 , a. , & voli , m. 1981 , , 94 , 175 robinson , s. e. , laughlin , g. , bodenheimer , p. , & fischer , d. 2006 , astrophysical journal , 643 , 484 , b. , covey , k. r. , muirhead , p. s. , & lloyd , j. p. 2012 , , 748 , 93 , n. c. , israelian , g. , & mayor , m. 2004 , , 415 , 1153 , s. j. , wallerstein , g. , woolf , v. m. , & bean , j. l. 2009 , , 121 , 1083 , e. r. d. 2007 , annual review of earth and planetary sciences , 35 , 577 , y. m. , kim , j. , & hong , s. s. 2011 , , 728 , 140 , l. 2010 , , 512 , a10 , a. , gaidos , e. , & wu , y. 2014 , arxiv e - prints , arxiv:1406.6048 , u. j. , & parvathi , v. s. 2009 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 414 , cosmic dust - near and far , ed . t. henning , e. grn , & j. steinacker , 236 , k. b. , bean , j. l. , madhusudhan , n. , & harrington , j. 2014 , , 791 , 36 , m. , deroo , p. , tinetti , g. , et al . 2013 , icarus , 225 , 432 , h. , himeno , y. , & ida , s. 2005 , , 625 , 414 , a. d. , baggaley , w. j. , & steel , d. i. 1996 , , 380 , 323 , m. , huss , g. r. , ogliore , r. c. , nagashima , k. , & tachibana , s. 2012 , meteoritics and planetary science , 47 , 2013 , j. k. , cunha , k. , schuler , s. c. , griffith , c. a. , & smith , v. v. 2013 , , 778 , 132 , j. k. , cunha , k. , smith , v. v. , schuler , s. c. , & griffith , c. a. 2014 , , 788 , 39 , j. k. , schuler , s. c. , cunha , k. , smith , v. v. , & griffith , c. a. 2013 , , 768 , l12 , h. b. , & bally , j. 2008 , , 135 , 2380 , a. g. g. m. 1998 , , 499 , 267 , a. g. g. m. 2012 , in iau symposium , vol . 284 , iau symposium , ed . r. j. tuffs & c. c. popescu , 7281 , a. g. g. m. 2012 , in iau symposium , vol . 284 , iau symposium , ed . r. j. tuffs & c. c. popescu , 7281 , f. x. , woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 98 , 617 , b. m. 1980 , , 5 , 287 , a. , elliott , t. , ulfbeck , d. , et al . 2009 , science , 324 , 374 , m. , melendez , j. , & ramirez , i. 2014 , arxiv e - prints , arxiv:1407.4132 , m. , zinner , e. k. , & crozaz , g. 1997 , meteoritics and planetary science , 32 , 281 , a. a. , morgan , d. p. , bochanski , j. j. , et al . 2011 , , 141 , 97 , j. c. , sneden , c. , & truran , jr . , j. w. 1989 , , 27 , 279 , d. c. b. , goldsmith , p. f. , & pineda , j. l. 2010 , , 720 , 259 , a. p. , & bate , m. r. 2002 , , 333 , 679 williams , j. p. , & gaidos , e. 2007 , the astrophysical journal , 663 , l33 , m. g. , mckee , c. f. , hollenbach , d. , & tielens , a. g. g. m. 2003 , , 587 , 278 , v. m. , lpine , s. , & wallerstein , g. 2009 , , 121 , 117 , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 101 , 181 , h. 2009 , , 397 , 1093 , z. , luo , a. , song , y. , et al . 2014 , , 147 , 33 , q. 2005 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 341 , chondrites and the protoplanetary disk , ed . a. n. krot , e. r. d. scott , & b. reipurth , 632 , q .- z . , jacobsen , b. , moynier , f. , & hutcheon , i. d. 2007 , , 662 , l43 i computed changes in the abundance of five isotopes in the vicinity of the solar galactocetnric radius : @xmath87c , @xmath70c , @xmath88o , @xmath85o , and @xmath86o . the model accounts for the production of these isotopes and their release into the ism in sn explosions , winds from massive stars , and agb winds , incorporation of isotopes into long - lived low - mass stars , and dilution of the ism by the infall of metal - poor gas . the ism is described by a two - box model with a lower - density , warmer intercloud medium ( icm ) which spawns molecular clouds , and a giant molecular cloud ( gmc ) component that can form stars . the mean lifetime of molecular clouds is @xmath89 and the residence time of gas in the icm before condensing into a cloud is @xmath90 . the equations of motion for the mass surface density @xmath91 of the two components are : @xmath92 @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the infall rate , @xmath95 is the rate of formation rate of stars with @xmath96m@xmath12 , @xmath97 is the ratio of the total stellar mass to the mass in stars @xmath98m@xmath12 , @xmath99 is the flux of sn ejecta into the icm from progenitors that explode in time @xmath100 , @xmath101 is the flux of sn ejecta into the parent molecular cloud from progenitors that contribute to gmcs in time @xmath102 , and @xmath103 is the wind from agb stars , all contributing to the icm . the fluxes from agb winds and sn ejecta are given by : @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the mean mass of stars with @xmath106m@xmath12 , @xmath107 is the ejected mass in winds and/or explosions , @xmath108 is the fractional number of stars per unit mass in the imf , and @xmath109 and @xmath110 are the minimum and maximum masses contributing mass to the three different cases , and @xmath111 is the mass in the wind or ejecta from a progenitor of mass @xmath112 . the equations for the mass surface densities of stars ( @xmath113 ) and stellar remnants ( @xmath114 ) are @xmath115 and @xmath116 f(m _ * ) dm_*,\ ] ] where the limits of integation are over any stars that are moving off the main sequence . the star formation rate is related to the total mass surface density of gas using a schmidt - kennicut law : @xmath117 the equations governing the the mass fraction of the @xmath44th isotope is : @xmath118 @xmath119 @xmath120 are the isotopic abundances of the infalling gas , and @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the production ( equal to the nucleosynthetic yield plus the original mass of the isotope ) . the c / o ratio is calculated by summing the appropriate mass fractions divided by the atomic weights . an approximate metallicity is also calcated from the sum of all the isotopes relative to the abundances in the sun . i considered nucleosynthesis in the progenitors of agb stars ( 1 - 6.5m@xmath12 ) , `` super - agb '' stars ( 6.5 - 11m@xmath12 ) , and sn ( 11 - 120m@xmath12 ) . i used the agb yields from @xcite for agb progenitors up to 6.5m@xmath12 . for super - agb progenitors with masses between 7 and 11m@xmath12 i used the productions from @xcite , or @xcite otherwise . for sn yields i adopted the values in @xcite and @xcite for regular sn with energies of @xmath123 erg and their re - run calcalations for the cases of @xmath124m@xmath12 and @xmath125 , and @xmath126 and @xmath127 . these were supplemented with values from @xcite for progenitor masses of 12 , 60 , 100 , and 120m@xmath12 . in order to arrive at a solar c / o with reasonable choices of parameters i find it necessary to include yields from the _ winds _ of massive stars with @xmath128m@xmath12 estimated by @xcite ( table 3 in that work ) . the literature for sn and agb nucleosynthesis is very heterogeneous , with calculations performed for different ranges / values of progenitor masses and metallicities , and it was necessary to interpolate or extrapolate for some values . specifically , to estimate the production of 6.5m@xmath12 agb stars with sub - solar progenitor metallicities i scaled the @xcite values for sub - solar metallicity 6m@xmath12 progenitors by the ratio of the 6.5m@xmath12 to 6m@xmath12 production for solar - metallicity . for productions from super - agb stars with progenitor masses outside the caclulated range , i either used the production from the most massive progenitor with the same metallicity , or linearly interpolated between the values for the most massive agb and least massive super - agb progenitors with the same metallicity . for a review of the many parameters and uncertainties that enter these calculations see @xcite . i linearly interpolated the production onto a grid of 1000 masses over 1 - 120m@xmath12 with intervals chosen such that the imf has equal total mass in each bin . figure [ fig.yield ] shows the calculated yields ( production - initial incorporation ) for solar metallicity . these values were then used to evaluate eqns . [ eqn.production ] and [ eqn.iso_production ] . i searched for the parameter values that best reproduce the observational constraints using monte - carlo markov chain analysis . the constraints are the age of the sun , the present mass surface densities of stars , stellar remnants , and total gas at the solar galactocentric radius , solar c / o , the current metallicity of the ism ( taken to be + 0.14 based on the metallicities of m44 and the hyades ) , and the mean ( -0.05 ) and intrinsic standard - deviation ( 0.18 dex ) of the metallicity distribution in the solar neighborhood @xcite . i adopted standard errors of 0.12 in c / o @xcite , 1.5 , 1 , and 1 m@xmath12 pc@xmath129 for stars , remnants , and gas , 50 myr for the absolute age of the sun , and 0.01 and 0.02 dex in the mean and standard deviation of the present metallicity . i varied the exponential infall timescale , the metallicity of the infalling material , the age of the galactic disk in the solar annulus , the high - mass imf index @xmath14 , and the schmidt - kennicut index @xmath130 . the simulation is able to adequately reproduce the observed properties of the galactic disk in the solar neighborhood ( @xmath131 with @xmath132 ) . the most significant deviation is the over - prediction of the present ism gas mass and underprediction of the current metallicity . the adopted or fit values for the simulation are given in table [ tab.params ] . the predicted evolution of the sfr , mass surface densities , and the metallicity of the ism are plotted in fig . [ fig.gce ] . estimates of the current total star formation rate of the milky way cluster around @xmath133 m@xmath12 yr@xmath72 @xcite . presuming that star formation has an exponential radial distribution with scale length of 3.5 kpc @xcite then the rate at the solar radius will be about @xmath134 m@xmath12 myr@xmath72 pc@xmath129 . this compares favorably with the predicted value at the present ( fig . [ fig.gce ] ) . @lllll@ & & & & + + @xmath135 & solar oxygen & @xmath136 & & @xcite + @xmath137 & solar carbon & @xmath138 & & @xcite + + @xmath14 & imf index & 2.61 & & fit + @xmath97 & low mass / high - mass ratio & 2.00 & & fit + + @xmath139 & present stellar mass density & @xmath140 & m@xmath12 pc@xmath129 & @xcite + @xmath141 & present gas mass density & @xmath142 & m@xmath12 pc@xmath129 & @xcite + @xmath143 & present remnant mass density & @xmath144 & m@xmath12 pc@xmath129 & @xcite + @xmath89 & gmc gas residence time & 30 & myr & + @xmath145 & imc gas residence time & 150 & myr & + @xmath146 & age of disk & 9554 & myr & fit + @xmath147 & infall e - folding time & 2630 & myr & fit + @xmath148_0 $ ] & metallicity of infalling gas & -1.3 & & fit + @xmath130 & sfr rate index & 1.71 & & fit + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: living systems as far - from - equilibrium open systems , are essentially cognitive , and conversely , in order to grasp the essence of cognition , one may attempt to understand the ontology of the former processes . often this is viewed in the framework of a cell - like , structured , self - organizing system engaged in a two - way interaction between its functional mechanisms and that of its neighboring environment . there are several theories that revolve around this principle . readers may be familiar with a central relationship as explained by autopoiesis , a seemingly enduring theory as developed by maturana and varela ( 1980a , 1980b ) over several decades . though a much earlier and somewhat different hypothesis of bertalanffy ( 1972 ) had proposed that living systems are maintained in non - equilibrium states by a flow - like patterns when drawing matter and energy from their environment , and adjust accordingly in a `` flowing balance '' ( bertalanffy , 1972 ; capra , 1996 ) . further scientific rigor aimed at understanding this hypothesis was achieved by prigogine ( 1980 ) who formulated similar ideas cast within a theory of dissipative structures . whereas living systems are continuously maintained in - far - from equilibrium , dissipative structures do likewise while being capable of evolving . they are destabilized in the increase of information and energy , though as they remain self - organized and self - perpetuating , the complexity of their structure increases ; often this is simply for the sake of survival within the environment . elucidating a possible synthesis of these separate approaches , commencing from the bertalanffy hypothesis , is the main topic of capra ( 1996 ) . but cognition is also a function of a prevailing culture : by means of social and historical patterns of behavior traditions , etc . , human cognition feeds back into that culture through the course of social interaction , adaptive technologies , policies , memetic trends , etc . , and inevitably alters it in time ( see e.g. clark , 1997 ; hollan et al . , 2000 ; hutchins , 1994 ; richerson and boyd , 2004 ; wallace and fullilove , 2008 ) . there are several common factors at stake here , and in seeking to understand these , the ` immunology language ' viewpoint of atlan and cohen ( 1998 ) ( see also cohen , 2000 ) views human organizations at all levels as perceiving patterns of threat or opportunity , comparing those patterns with some internal , learned or inherited , picture of the world , and then choosing one or a small number of responses from a vastly larger repertory of that which is possible to them . putting it another way , consider a basic observation concerning the immune system : the latter incorporates its own system of options and responds cognitively at the level of information processing such that the _ meaning _ of an antigen is defined by the response of the immune system , somewhat reminiscent of earlier work of jerne ( 1974 ) who had postulated such ` meaning ' . the broader cognitive model that results from this can said to be a ` reactive ' system determined by contextual factors in cohen and harel ( 2007 ) as depicted in figure 1 . starting from this basic perspective , wallace ( 2005 ) has formulated a model of cognition that takes ` meaning ' in the sense of dretske s theory of semantic communication ( dretske , 1981 , 1988 ) claiming that the immune perception / response information networks of any cognitive system must be constrained by shannon s fundamental limit theorems of information theory ( see e.g. ash , 1990 ; berger , 1971 ; cover and thomas , 1991 ) . these networks comprising of cognitive modules interact within the framework of a kind of broadcasting system relaying within ` a theater of consciousness ' the basic operative hypothesis of the _ global ( neuronal ) workspace _ theory as developed in ( baars , 1988 ; baars and franklin , 2003 ) that forms an integral part of the model in ( wallace , 2005 ; wallace and fullilove , 2008 ) . here we take a further step forward that incorporates a number of related factors mainly following the ( generalized ) onsager relations of non - equilibrium thermodynamics combined with the principles of _ rate distortion _ theory which is one of the mainstays of shannon s pioneering work . one particular observation is that distortion in communication between interacting cognitive modules , is patently stochastic , in particular , it is manifestly a process of brownian motion . this observation is developed in several steps relative to a corresponding stochastic differential equation that eventually unfolds to a kind of master equation . by considering critical solutions for the distortion , we argue on a case - by - case basis that the ensuing brownian motion ( viz weiner process ) can be locally one of bounded variation . accordingly , we are motivated to introduce the necessary conditions that permit integration of these equations in order to obtain _ a multidimensional it process _ ; further we discuss those formal conditions that describe an associated stochastic solution flow . thus in a way we have recovered bertalanffy s perception of the `` flow '' of living systems , the kind of which information - tied epigenetic systems are certain representations . whereas such model conditions are mathematically stated for a flow in a smooth manifold geometry , we do not claim such ` smoothness ' in general . indeed , such epigenetic ` flow systems ' in living organisms and brain - environment interactions may be at best continuous over time and are most likely to be ` singular ' in some sense . the latter requires harder topological techniques and possible complications that detract from a more natural interpretation . eventually one seeks a workable common ground between various mathematical abstractions and the actual empirical properties of the systems themselves . another slant emerging from this cognitive paradigm goes towards epigenetic information sources as providing a _ tunable catalyst _ directed to gene expression by which the embedding of information sources can direct developmental pathways within the ontology of enveloped structures via the process of information ( wallace and wallace , 2008 ) . this leads to further developments of several cognitive paradigms for gene expression , in part furthering the scientific reason underlying that of jablonka and lamb ( 2005 ) who consider epigenetic inheritance systems in which information may be transmitted through generations , not just simply through the base sequence of dna , but also transmitted via cultural and behavioral means in higher animals , and by epigenetic means in cell lineages . this is initiated by memory systems that enable somatic cells of differing phenotype , but of identical genotype , to transmit their phenotypes to their descendants , even in the absence of the original stimuli that had engaged these phenotypes . conditional upon an individual s phenotype , environmental factors may trigger alterations in behavior and health , eventually impinging upon the nervous system with the likely consequence of mental disarray . in this respect moffitt et al . ( 2006 ) ( cf caspi and moffitt , 2006 ) make several observations : ( 1 ) a heritable versus environmental influence on phenotype variation across a given environment , ( 2 ) altered gene expressions via epigenetic programming geared in response to subsequent health - behavioral reactions towards the environment , ( 3 ) how an individual s phenotype determines a risk - level towards the environment , and ( 4 ) behavioral effects due to interdependence between specified variations in the dna sequence specific to a measured environment . indispensable to understanding and extending these findings is the parallel question of how gene - cultural interaction , two distinct but interacting hereditary systems , compares psychopathology across oriental and western cultures in basic perceptual processes , often an important piece missing from the larger picture ( nisbett , 2003 ; richerson and boyd , 2004 ; wallace , 2005 ; wallace , 2009 ) . as such distinct interacting systems of information influencing action and behavior , both kinds ( genes and culture ) are claimed in durham ( 1991 ) to create a real and unambiguous symmetry : between genes and phenotypes on the one hand , and culture and phenotypes on the other , whereby genes and culture may be reasonably viewed as two parallel lines of hereditary influence on phenotypes . from the perspective of ( wallace , 2005 ; wallace and wallace , 2008 ; wallace and wallace , 2009 ) both can be realized as generalized languages in the sense they have their own intrinsic recognizable grammar and syntax ( see [ meaningful ] ) . likewise , on reflecting upon the fundamental mechanisms of serial endosymbiotic theory ( see e.g. margulis , 2004 ) , witzany ( 2006 ) argues a case for extending the latter via biosemiotic cell - cell type interactions as ` signed ' language - communication processes subject to a range of syntactic , pragmatic and semantic rules as applied to protein coding dna , rna editing , dna splicing , transcription and other essential functions . a more general perspective is to consider those central relations characterizing the system and its various structural components , and how a state is altered under perturbations by the environment . an autopoietic system is organizationally closed and structurally determined . the system s autopoiesis is preserved within the living state , adaptable only to structural fluctuations for as long as the living entity survives within and is structurally coupled to its environment ; otherwise there is termination . the autopoiesis of the nervous system ( though itself is not strictly autopoietic ) functionally self-(creates ) replicates in order to engage in cognition . though structurally dependent , the nervous system affords an innate plasticity and with appropriate alterations , it is conducive to learning and can adapt itself towards broader interactions and human self - consciousness ( maturana and varela , 1980a , 1980b ) . such broader interpretations of this theory are addressed in mingers ( 1991 ) , such as the family nexus which via its idiosyncratic behavioral and linguistic interactions ( in relationship to hereditary factors , socioeconomic status , environment , culture , etc . ) , creates a peculiar structured reality that for the best part is only accessible to the members themselves , and through which a prospective psychotherapist must explore in order to fathom out those recurrent patterns of conversation and behavior influencing the cognitive malfunctioning of any concerned ( cf laing and esterson , 1964 ) . there are related theories with varying degrees of overlap to the overall concepts of maturana and varela ( 1980a , 1980b ) . one example is a biogenetic - structuralist theory ( laughlin and daquili , 1974 ) where connections within an evolutionary context are made between neural organization / brain functional activity and the environment . the result is `` acquired models of reality '' , again , a cognitive outcome of the response to and engagement with the environment , proposing a concept of ` neurognosis ' , a kind of ` holographic ' model based upon biogenetically induced rudimentary information embedded in various associated regions of the brain , as taken from birth towards the later stages of maturity . the neurognostic model depends upon ontogenetic feedback from an external reality according to which acquired components are continually engaged with sensory input . such modes are claimed to be represented in neural processes by probability expectations which we shall see , lie at the heart of information theory , and which encode the behavior of these process in relationship to the environment . thus it may be reasonable to suppose that enriched environments of some sort reciprocate to a greater advantage than others , and the structures governing the alignment of the self to the environment to an extent evolved in accordance to some degree of mastery over the latter . take for instance , the hypothalamic pituitary adrenal ( hpa ) axis ( as governing the neurophysiology of the `` flight or fight '' mechanism ) is cognitive in the sense of atlan and cohen ( 1998 ) . if there is an arousal of the individual s close environment , then mind , memory and emotional cognition engage , evaluate and select appropriate responses . the hpa accelerates this process and possible malfunctioning may induce hyper reactivity as observed in cases of post traumatic stress disorder . depression , as another example , may be partly viewed as the evolution of a structure conducive to a negative alignment of the self with an external reality . if we think of a child as gradually mastering its environment via a symbiotic relation with its mother , then take away the mother , the inability to further manage the environment activates a negative kind of ( neurognostic ) structure such as those that have been researched in the context of various evolutionary theories of depression that are founded upon the occurrence of attachment - defeat - loss , diminished opportunities , down - regulation of foraging capability , social / professional rank , etc . incurred with varying risk factors within a culturally influenced environment ( see e.g. gilbert , 2006 ; moffitt et al . , 2006 ; wallace , 2009 ) . another example is to consider the body s blood pressure control system consisting as a network of cognitive systems which compare a set of incoming signals with an internal reference structure in order to select a suitable level of blood pressure from possible levels ; hence as claimed in ( wallace and fullilove , 2008 ; wallace and wallace , 2009 ) an elaborate tumor control strategy must be at least as cognitive as the immune system itself . thus granted that most ( if not all ) given classes of cognitive modules interact within their cultural environment , we may proceed to consider what happens when the environment _ is _ the communication medium itself . for instance , in typical ai laboratory models where multi - agent , inter - sensing systems function in local coordinated tasks ( often with no explicit communication between agents ) , the eventual net effect may induce a ` shared memory ' ( cao et al . , 1997 ; krieger et al . , 2000 ) where , for instance , it was claimed that more energetic and efficient foraging tasks were typical of multi - agent ( robotic ) systems compared to individual agents , and the former tended to produce behavioral patterns similar to those of ` ant like ' decentralized control systems . on the other hand , biological regulatory networks besides being susceptible to alterations in the environment and/or intracellular conditions , may operate stochastically in varying degrees as seen along the pathways of neuronal signalling transduction ( manninen et al . , 2006 ) that provides an analogy motivating part of this paper ( see [ ito - process ] ) . a similar scenario is that of neuronal ` trail systems ' ( ts ) in glade et al . ( 2009 ) : single wire and logical gates in a self organized bioprocessor along which self propelled particles communicate via traces etched out in the environment , thus creating the ts . the claim of glade et al . ( 2009 ) is that such systems , although not precisely defined , are capable of programming and function on the basis of a turing machine . it suggests an evolutionary factor by which various living beings , by activating their respective nervous systems , have trained themselves to use models like the ts towards evolution within and possible mastery over their environment , by means of simulating ` trail ' signals . more from an information - theory viewpoint , wallace ( 2009b ) envisages similar ideas to trail systems as reminiscent of ` roman roads ' : decision making and tasking within small local communities , eventually creating ` roads ' , manifestly inter connected cognitive modules having different time constraints , but eventually creating extensions of ` local consciousness ' . a rate distortion argument applies here to account for the mutual crosstalk between different modules using the homology of the rate distortion function with free energy as will be described later . next we proceed with some specifics . as is well known , distortion arises when there is a fast relay of information through some channel which exceeds the latter s capacity . one of the principles of the shannon theory is that in order to reproduce a message transmitted from a source to a receiver , it is necessary to know what sort of information should be transmitted and how . for the purpose of engineering a communication system , one needs to figure out a suitable encoding / decoding system once the nature of the channel is specified . following berger ( 1971 ) , we briefly recall some of the basic principles involved . * source encoder * : we may consider some output @xmath0 emanating from the source as projected to a finite set of preselected images , namely , the space of possible source outputs is partitioned into a set of _ equivalence classes _ and the source encoder informs the channel encoder of that class containing the particular source output observed . once the channel encoder is informed that the source output belongs to say , the @xmath1-th equivalence class , it transforms the corresponding waveform @xmath2 across the channel . * source decoder * : within the system is a cascade of a channel encoder and a source decoder . the channel decoder receives a waveform @xmath3 of a corresponding function @xmath4 over some time interval and decides upon the nature of the message as transmitted . then it sends its approximation @xmath5 of the message number to the source decoder which in turn creates @xmath6 to register the system s estimate of @xmath0 over that time interval . initially , we may think of @xmath0 and @xmath4 as ` waveforms ' , but in our case , we consider these as consisting of a language with its own intrinsic grammar / syntax , as well as ` meaning ' to be made more specific in [ meaningful ] . analogous considerations apply to the channel signals @xmath7 and @xmath3 ( see figure 2 ) . one of shannon s notable results was that a communication system can be designed such that it achieves a level of fidelity @xmath8 once the _ rate distortion _ @xmath9 , where @xmath10 denotes the channel capacity . putting it another way , if the receiver can tolerate an average amount of distortion @xmath8 , the rate distortion @xmath11 is the effective rate at which the source can relay information with that level of tolerance . the rate at which a source produces information subject to insisting upon perfect reproduction , is the _ source entropy _ @xmath12 . given a distortion measure such that perfect reproduction is assigned zero distortion , then we have @xmath13 . as @xmath8 increases , @xmath11 becomes a monotonically decreasing ( convex ) function which eventually is zero , typically at a maximum value for @xmath8 ( see berger , 1971 , chapter 1 ) . this is a very basic observation , and typically in rate distortion theory one seeks a reduction of @xmath12 by either slowing down the emission of coding , or encoding the relevant languages at a lower rate . in view of shannon s theorem , as long as @xmath14 , we will obtain appropriate fidelity in transmission . inherent difficulties are clear , since the source rate may be corrupted due to low memory and coding congestion , hence the need for a communicating system to evolve so as recover the source data at the channel output satisfying the shannon estimate . having mentioned the rate distortion function @xmath11 we now follow berger ( 1971 ) to give its specific definition in terms of _ average mutual information _ ( an alternative , and equivalent definition of @xmath11 and a statement of the rate distortion theorem will be given in appendix [ appendix - b ] ) . firstly , for @xmath15 running over a suitable alphabet , let us write a given conditional probability assignment as @xmath16 such that in the usual way we have an associated joint distribution @xmath17 . we express _ the average distortion _ as @xmath18 where @xmath19 denotes the distortion measure . a conditional probability assignment @xmath20 is said to be _ @xmath8admissible _ if and only if @xmath21 . the set of all @xmath8admissible conditional probability assignments we denote by @xmath22 along with an average distortion @xmath23 , we also have an _ average mutual information _ @xmath24.\ ] ] then for fixed @xmath8 , the rate distortion function is defined as @xmath25 observe that if a parameter @xmath26 represents the slope of the function @xmath11 at a point @xmath27 generated parametrically , we have @xmath28 ( this is not exactly trivial : see berger , 1971 , theorem 2.5.1 ) . more formally , a pattern of sensory input is mixed in an unspecified but systematic algorithmic manner with a pattern of internal ongoing activity to create a path of combined signals @xmath29 . each @xmath30 thus represents some functional composition of internal and external signals . wallace ( 2005 ) provides some neural network examples . this path is fed into a highly nonlinear , but otherwise similarly unspecified , decision oscillator , @xmath31 , which generates an output @xmath32 that is an element of one of two disjoint sets @xmath33 and @xmath34 of possible system responses . let @xmath35 assume a graded response , supposing that if @xmath36 the pattern is not recognized , and if @xmath37 the pattern is recognized , and some action @xmath38 takes place . such oscillators may be influenced by ` forcing ' when a signal is subjected to some impulse such that its frequency , and hence the response , adjusts accordingly with respect to that applied impulse . more familiar oscillating physical models react to this by exhibiting ` beats ' and ` resonance ' for instance . the principal objects of formal interest are paths @xmath39 which , through information flow , trigger pattern recognition - and - response . that is , given a fixed initial state @xmath40 , we examine all possible subsequent paths @xmath39 beginning with @xmath40 and leading to the event @xmath41 . thus @xmath42 for all @xmath43 , but @xmath44 . for each positive integer @xmath45 , let @xmath46 be the number of high probability grammatical / syntactical paths of length @xmath45 which begin with some particular @xmath40 and further leading to the condition @xmath47 . these are paths of combined signals as above , that are structured to some language . for short , we call such paths ` meaningful ' , assuming , not unreasonably , that @xmath46 will be considerably less than the number of all possible paths of length @xmath45 leading from @xmath40 to the condition @xmath41 . one critical assumption which permits an inference on the necessary conditions constrained by the asymptotic limit theorems of information theory , is that the finite limit @xmath48}{n},\ ] ] ( the ` uncertainty ' ) both exists and is independent of the path @xmath39 . the rate distortion principle applies as follows ( wallace , 2005 ) : _ the restriction to meaningful sequences of symbols increases the rate at which information can be transmitted with arbitrary small error , and that the grammar / syntax of the path can be associated with a dual information source_. here we may assume a typical information source @xmath49 to be ` adiabatic ' , ` piece - wise stationary ' and ` ergodic ' ( apse ) , and that a system engaging in a cognitive process is describable as such . we list here the explanations : * ` adiabatic ' means that the changes are slow enough to allow the necessary limit theorems to function . * ` stationary ' means that between pieces the probabilities hardly change , and ` piecewise ' means that these properties hold between phase transitions which are described using renormalization methods ( see wallace , 2005 ) . * ` ergodic ' means that in the long term , correlated sequences of symbols are generated at an average rate equal to their ( joint ) probabilities . more specifically , the essence of ` adiabatic ' is that , when the information source is parametrized according to some appropriate scheme , within continuous ` pieces ' of that parametrization , alterations in parameter values occur slowly enough so that the information source @xmath49 remains as close to stationary and ergodic as needed to put to work the fundamental limit theorems of information theory . in view of , the shannon uncertainty of @xmath49 can be stated more specifically by ( see e.g. cover and thomas , 1991 ) : @xmath50= \lim_{n { { \longrightarrow}}\infty } \frac{\log[n(n)]}{n}.\ ] ] . we recall how the information source uncertainty was defined as in equation . this is quite analogous to the free energy density of a physical system , equation , and the relevance to a cognitive process can be explained by the following steps . for instance , feynman ( 1996 ) provides a series of physical examples ( based in part on the research of c. h. bennett into the thermodynamics of computing ( bennett , 1982 ) where this homology is , in fact , an identity , at least for very simple systems . bennett ( 1982 ) argues , in terms of idealized irreducibly elementary computing machines , that the information contained in a message can be viewed as the work saved by not needing to recompute what has been transmitted , or as feynman ( 1996 ) puts it : the information contained in a message is proportional to the amount of free energy density needed to erase it . the essential argument is that computing , in any form , takes work . thus the more complicated a cognitive process , measured by its information source uncertainty , the greater its energy consumption , and our ability to provide energy to the brain is limited : typically , a unit of brain tissue consumes an order of magnitude more energy than a unit of any other tissue . the less information available to us concerning an event , the higher is its entropy , and information retrieved is not without a cost in expenditure of energy , where ` cost ' may be interpreted as the necessary number of bits needed to encode a message . the thermodynamic minimum of energy in terms of bits of information is @xmath51 erg / bit ( @xmath52 erg / nat ) . so efficiency in an information system is essentially when there is the minimum amount of energy expended in retrieving information . specifically , if @xmath53 is taken to denote the free energy , then taking @xmath54 is to denote the minimum number of nats / sec , the efficiency of the system is given by @xmath55 ( see e.g. berger , 1971 ) . in a similar spirit to bennett s work , li and vitnyi ( 1992 ) consider the thermodynamic costs of computation and how certain thermodynamic considerations can give a recursively invariant notion of ` cognitive distance ' using a kind of billiard dynamics approach . in this case a minimal cognitive distance between two objects will correspond to the minimal amount of work expended for a given cognitive transformation of objects , either by some computational procedure or by some neurocognitive function of the brain . a higher descriptive level leading to more complex and protracted algorithms , then leads to greater kolmogorov complexity ( li and vitnyi , 1993 ) . as a particular application of the bennett / feynman ideas in the global workspace setting , wallace ( 2007 ) argues that the cognitive disorder of ` inattentional blindness ' emerges as a thermodynamic limit on processing capacity in a topologically - fixed global workspace , i.e. one which has been strongly configured about a particular task . institutional and machine generalizations seem clear . many cognitive processes exhibit the patterns of dynamical systems ( see e.g. glazebrook and wallace , 2009a ) . in such systems one aims to unify the internal and external symmetries , and to be able to reduce vast myriad like network configurations into manageable schemes involving the corresponding equivalence classes analogous to those already mentioned in source encoding / decoding , etc . in [ rd - function ] ( see also [ equiv - info ] below ) . a precise way of doing this lies within the categorical concept known as a _ groupoid _ ( see brown , 2006 ; connes , 1994 ; weinstein , 1996 ) . in essence a groupoid @xmath56 consists of both a set of objects @xmath57 and a set of morphisms , or ` arrows ' , each of which project to an object in @xmath57 , and all such morphisms admit an inverse . the most familiar example of a groupoid , as known to students of algebra , is that of a ` group ' where there is a single object ( ` the identity ' ) . hence groupoids can be viewed as extensions of the ` group ' concept to sets of _ multiple identities _ thus providing a wide scope of applications to the dynamics of neurocognitive and socio bioinformatic systems ( see e.g. baianu et al . , 2006 ; glazebrook and wallace , 2009a , 2009b ; golubitsky and stewart , 2006 ; stewart et al . , 2003 ; wallace 2005 ; wallace and fullilove , 2008 ) . a groupoid can be depicted by @xmath58^{{\alpha } } \ar[r]_{{\beta } } & x}\ ] ] where the groupoid morphisms @xmath59 onto objects , are called the _ range _ and _ source maps _ , respectively . informally , the groupoid represents a feature of built in reciprocity between its algebraic structures , internalizing and externalizing the prevailing symmetries . the morphisms @xmath60 satisfy certain algebraic relations of associativity , existence of two - sided identities , etc . ( details can be seen in e.g. brown , 2006 ; connes , 1994 ; weinstein , 1996 ) . a groupoid can here be understood in relationship to a linkage by a meaningful path of an information source dual to a cognitive process for which the underlying principle is that : _ states @xmath61 in a set @xmath62 are related by the groupoid morphism if and only if there exists a high probability grammatical path connecting them to the same base point , and the tuning across the various possible ways in which that can happen the different cognitive languages parametrizes the set of equivalence relations and creates the groupoid . _ [ ex2 ] since we have already mentioned equivalence classes in the context of source encoding / decoding , it seems appropriate to see how an equivalence relation @xmath63 defined on ( a set ) @xmath57 takes shape as a groupoid . here we have the two projections @xmath64 , and a product @xmath65 whenever @xmath66 together with an identity , namely @xmath67 , for each @xmath68 . moreover , the essential equivalence relations ( classes ) derived from a systems space ( network ) arise from the orbit equivalence relation of some groupoid @xmath56 acting on that space ( see e.g. weinstein , 1996 ) . in the context of connected ( sub)networks / graphs which can reduced to equivalence classes , natural groupoid structures come about in accordance with equivalence classes of relations @xmath69 , as above , that is simply interpreted as having an edge linking node @xmath39 to node @xmath70 . conversely , a groupoid ( of equivalence relations ) admits an underlying graph structure via its implicit scheme of objects and morphisms between objects ( for details , see e.g. brown , 2006 ) . thus we have the two - way associations whereby ` objects ' can be identified with ` nodes ' , and ` morphisms ' identified with ` edges ' in groupoids ( of equivalence relations ) and networks , respectively:@xmath71 an important observation about multi - tasking in institutional and distributed cognitive systems concerns how the various submodules interact . when a given subnetwork is represented in its groupoid form , then such interactions naturally can be realized in terms of _ groupoid actions _ , a topic that warrants further attention . then we would like to see the overall cognitive system in terms of such interacting groupoids and designed by an ` atlas ' of the latter , and one , as shown in glazebrook and wallace ( 2009a ) , containing the representation of several possible emergent ` giant components ' induced by the outcome of local group(oid ) actions within the workspace ( see figure 3 ) . a workable concept seems to be that of a _ groupoid atlas _ ( bak et al . , 2006 ) which provides a schematic representation for coupling interactions between multi - agent systems and uses a pasting together of the local dynamic groupoid actions with the net effect of a ` global ' groupoid . one commences from a family of dynamically interacting groupoids @xmath72 where each groupoid has the same set of objects ; this family is called a _ single domain _ or _ multiple groupoid_. _ a groupoid atlas _ is then defined as a set with a covering by patches each of which comprise a single domain with global action , representing the local processing which is then globalized across the atlas . this is a desirable effect and one particularly suited to logically inscribing processors or sensors ( the ` agents ' ) within the cognitive modules of the workspace . as a descriptive mechanism , this atlas has the advantage of admiting a weaker structure compared with that of a conventional manifold since no condition of compatibility between arbitrary overlaps of the patches is necessary . this is a key property relevant to the structure of cognitive modules that can be geared to equivalence class representations where flexibility in the structure is a natural characteristic . in this way , the atlas provides a convenient description of a web of complexity representing the dynamic reciprocity of tightly - knitted functional systems as was applied to small world networks ( glazebrook and wallace , 2009a ) . time and space does not permit including a mathematical outline of the construction ; for the technical details we refer the reader to bak et al . ( 2006 ) and del hoyo and minian ( 2009 ) . however , we intend to apply this concept with some essential details in [ info - atlas ] below . derived from the equivalence relations of their respective networks of multi - agent type cognitive modules . they are viewed as the components of a groupoid atlas . the groupoid actions are indicated by dotted arrows , in this case , between @xmath73 and @xmath74 , and may represent the formation of network linkages as the system is shifted via crosstalk , and for instance , how a ` giant component ' emerges ( see e.g. glazebrook and wallace , 2009a ) . this is a descriptive mechanism that could be seen , for instance , as enveloping the underlying networks of the ` reactive ' system in figure 1 , and is applicable to the content of [ info - atlas ] . , width=113 ] the information supported interactive cognitive modules we have in mind are assumed to possess their own internal metabolisms and mechanisms of self - organization as reflective of vital biochemical processes . just as for the latter , the evolution of these ` cognitive cells ' is characterized by reactive states of thermal nonequilibrium , in accord with the laws of thermodynamics , and the capability to assimilate information which we study in respect of source uncertainty . this we can achieve by applying the onsager relations of nonequilibrium thermodynamics ( kurzynski , 2006 ; landau and lifshitz , 2007 ) . the reasoning starts by observing how a fundamental homology between the information source uncertainty dual to a cognitive process and the free energy density of a physical system can arise mainly from the formal similarity between their definitions in the asymptotic limit . recall that for a thermodynamic state of a given system at fixed temperature @xmath75 with energy @xmath76 and entropy @xmath77 , the _ free energy density _ @xmath53 is defined to be @xmath78 in the hamiltonian formulism one takes the volume @xmath79 and the partition function @xmath80 derived from the system s hamiltonian at inverse temperature @xmath81 ( kurzynski , 2006 ; landau and lifshitz , 2007 ) . the free energy density is then defined to be @xmath82 & = \lim_{v { { \longrightarrow}}\infty } -\frac{1}{k } \frac{\log[z(k , v)]}{v } \\ & = \lim_{v { { \longrightarrow}}\infty } \frac{\log[{\widehat}{z}(k , v)]}{v } , ~ \text{where}~ { \widehat}{z}= z^{-\frac{1}{k}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] consider now an information source @xmath83 over a corresponding groupoid @xmath84 . the probability of @xmath83 is given by : @xmath85}{\sum_{\beta } \exp[-h_{{{\mathsf{g}}}_{\beta}}k]}~,\ ] ] where the normalizing sum is over all possible subgroupoids of the largest available symmetry groupoid . now let @xmath86.\ ] ] _ the groupoid free energy density ( gfe ) of the system @xmath87 at inverse normalized equivalent temperature @xmath81 _ is defined as @xmath88 = - \frac{1}{k } \log [ z_{{{\mathsf{g}}}}(k)].\ ] ] with each such groupoid @xmath84 of the ( large ) cognitive groupoid , we can associate a dual information source @xmath83 . we recall the rate distortion function between the message sent by the cognitive process and the observed impact , while noting that both @xmath83 and @xmath11 may be considered as free energy density measures . in a sense , @xmath11 constitutes a sort of ` thermal bath ' for the process of cognition . then the probability of the dual information source can be expressed by @xmath89}{\sum_{\beta } \exp[-h_{{{\mathsf{g}}}_{\beta}}/ \kappa r(d ) \tau]}~,\ ] ] where @xmath90 denotes a suitable dimensionless constant characteristic of the system in the context of a fixed machine response time @xmath91 . the sum is over all possible subgroupoids of the largest available symmetry groupoid . accordingly , the term @xmath92 represents a ` rate distortion energy ' , in this case , a kind of ` temperature analog ' . in the context of a fixed @xmath91 , a decline in @xmath11 ( on increase in average distortion ) , acts to ` lower the machine temperature ' , driving it to more simple and less less rich behaviors . the groupoids @xmath84 can indeed be taken to comprise a groupoid atlas @xmath93 on an appropriate set @xmath94 . in bak et al . ( 2006 ) this is motivated by considering a group @xmath95 in the standard algebraic sense , and a family @xmath96 of group actions ` @xmath97 ' on subsets @xmath98 , where the local groups @xmath99 and the corresponding subsets @xmath100 are indexed by an indexing set @xmath101 called _ the coordinate system of @xmath102 _ which is seen to satisfy certain conditions ( bak et al . , now the family of local groups can be replaced by a family of local groupoids @xmath103 defined with respective object sets @xmath100 , and with a coordinate systems @xmath104 that is equipped with a reflexive relation denoted by @xmath105 . this data is to satisfy the following conditions ( bak et al . , 2006 ) : * if @xmath106 in @xmath104 , then @xmath107 is a union of components of @xmath103 , that is , if @xmath108 and @xmath109 acts as @xmath110 , then @xmath111 . * if @xmath106 in @xmath104 , then there is a groupoid morphism defined between the restrictions of the local groupoids to intersections @xmath112 and which is the identity morphism on objects . thus each of the @xmath84 with its associated dual information source @xmath83 constitutes a component of an atlas which incorporates the dynamics of an ( inter)reactive system through information sources , by means of the intrinsic ( groupoid ) actions . for simplicity , let us refer to this atlas as @xmath102 . suppose we have another such atlas @xmath113 representing a separate system which can be related to @xmath102 via a suitable transformation . to make matters precise we consider then a morphism @xmath114 prescribed by a triple @xmath115 satisfying ( del hoyo and minian , 2009 ) : * @xmath116 is a set - theoretic function . * @xmath117 is a function that preserves the relation @xmath105 . * @xmath118 is a ( generalized ) natural transformation of groupoid diagrams over the function @xmath119 which restricts to @xmath120 on objects . these conditions can summarized in the following straightforward way . for each @xmath121 , a function @xmath122 is given , such that for objects @xmath123 , and if @xmath106 , the diagram @xmath124 is commutative . further motivation is provided by considering phases as chemically and thermodynamically homogeneous when formally compared with average mutual information such as applied to living systems that are capable of assimilating and using information reaped either from their environment or from information that is intrinsic to their particular system via genetic characteristics . here we reflect in part upon the theme of [ feynman ] in which we discussed certain physical means by which information runs at the cost of expending free energy . on course with the fundamental homology , it befits us to consider some physical equations that are homologous to the variational calculus of the rate distortion function , and follow to some extent berger ( 1971 , 6.4 ) . the idea is that when a living information system is confronted with an environment , it reacts towards it at an atomic - molecular level . given then some thermodynamic system , let @xmath125 be the number of atomic weights of substance @xmath126 that end up in phase @xmath127 , and let @xmath128 be the number of atomic weights that were introduced originally , so that @xmath129 . the multiphase ( chemical ) equilibrium problem involves determining the @xmath130 . to proceed , let us express the free energy as @xmath131 , where @xmath132 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath133 are _ the free energy constants _ , and where the term contained in the logarithm is the chemical potential of the reactant @xmath126 in phase @xmath127 . let now @xmath134 ( for some @xmath135 ) , @xmath136 and @xmath137 , then @xmath138 \big ] - n \sum_j p_j \log p_j.\ ] ] since in principle the @xmath45 and @xmath139 can be determined , the minimization of @xmath53 reduces to minimizing the double summation on the right side of . letting @xmath140 , then ` nature ' selects the @xmath130 so as to minimize the quantity @xmath141 -s d_{jk } \big].\ ] ] the crucial observation here is that is formally the same as @xmath142 in other words , the function to be minimized is the difference between the average mutual information and @xmath26 times the average distortion . this is minimized by an appropriate choice of @xmath143 such as to determine a point on the @xmath11 curve where , as in [ average ] , we have @xmath144 . the multiphase chemical equilibrium is a local process ; the overall system itself may in general remain in a state far - from - equilibrium . according to berger ( 1971 ) , ` nature ' then automatically performs the analogous minimization in multiphase chemical equilibrium , and when an information system encounters an environment , the reaction on the molecular level follows these principles . thus the free energy of the combined system and the environment is minimized , although this is at the cost of the system s free energy capacity where there will inevitably be some heat dissipation . eventually the system can fine - tune its coding mechanism and re - configures itself for the task of gaining more specialized knowledge about its environment , and thanks to newly acquired information , it may engage the latter to its advantage along with detecting other drifting cells of information . how such optimizing procedures can be realized in an evolutionary context , is of course one of the main tasks of applying rate distortion arguments ( cf wallace and wallace , 1998 , 1999 , 2008 , 2009 ) . for instance , a scenario studied in tlusty ( 2007 , 2008 ) concerns how the genetic code maps the 64 nucleotide triplets ( codons ) to 20 amino acids . in terms of this mapping , the code is viewed as a noisy information channel and the claim is that evolutionary characteristics determine the emergence of the code via appropriate selection of amino acids which minimise the risk of errors , and subsequently the code emerges at a ` supercritical ' phase transition once the mapping ceases to be random . understanding the time dynamics of cognitive systems away from phase transition critical points thus requires a phenomenology similar to the onsager relations . if the dual source uncertainty of a cognitive process is parametrized by some vector of quantities @xmath145 , then , in analogy with nonequilibrium thermodynamics , the gradients in the @xmath146 of the _ disorder _ , defined as @xmath147 become of central interest . equation is similar to the definition of entropy in terms of the free energy density of a physical system , as suggested by the homology between free energy density and information source uncertainty described above . pursuing the homology further , the generalized onsager relations defining temporal dynamics become @xmath148 where the ( kinetic coefficients ) @xmath149 are , in first order , constants interpreted as reflecting the nature of the underlying cognitive phenomena . the partial derivatives @xmath150 are analogous to thermodynamic forces in a chemical system , and may be subject to override by external physiological driving mechanisms as shown in ( wallace , 2005 ; wallace and fullilove , 2008 ) along with further extensions of these dynamical procedures . equation is ` general ' in the sense that we do not necessarily assume the symmetry condition @xmath151 which in this latter case expresses onsager s 4-th law of thermodynamics ( see e.g. ( 3.7 ) in kurzynski , 2006 ) . the matrix @xmath152 $ ] is to be viewed empirically , in the same spirit as the slope and intercept of a regression model , and may have a structure far different when compared to the more basic , more familiar chemical or physical processes . generally , information sources are notoriously one way in time , as exemplified by the patent linguistic scarcity of palindromic structures that do actually make some sense . equations and can be derived in a simple parameter - free covariant manner which relies on the underlying topology of the information source space implicit to a process . different cognitive phenomena have , according to our development , dual information sources , and we are interested in the local properties of the system near a particular reference state . we impose a topology on the system , so that , near a particular ` language ' @xmath62 , dual to an underlying cognitive process , there is ( in some sense ) an open set @xmath153 of closely similar languages @xmath154 , such that @xmath62 and @xmath154 are subsets of @xmath153 . note that it may be necessary to coarse - grain the system s responses to define these information sources . the problem is to proceed in such a way as to preserve the underlying essential topology , while eliminating ` high frequency noise ' . the formal tools for this can be found in e.g. burago et al . ( 2001 ) . since the information sources dual to the cognitive processes are similar , for all pairs of languages @xmath155 in @xmath153 , it is possible to make use of the following : * create an embedding alphabet which includes all symbols allowed to both of them . * define an information - theoretic distortion measure in that extended , joint alphabet between any meaningful ( i.e. high probability grammatical / syntactical ) paths in @xmath62 and @xmath154 , which we write as @xmath156 ( ash , 1990 ; cover and thomas , 1991 ) . note that these languages do not interact , in this approximation . * define a metric on @xmath153 , for example , @xmath157 using an appropriate integration limit argument over the high probability paths . the usual metric properties apply as in burago et al . ( 2001 ) . note that these conditions can be used to define equivalence classes of _ languages _ , where previously we defined equivalence classes of _ states _ which could be linked by meaningful paths to some base point . this led to the characterization of different information sources from which a formal topological manifold , _ which is an equivalence class of information sources _ , can be constructed . as a working hypothesis we may assume this to be a standard differentiable manifold in which the set of such equivalence classes generates the _ dynamical groupoid _ ( cf glazebrook and wallace , 2009a , 2009b ) , and then study those mechanisms , internal or external , which can break that groupoid symmetry . in particular , the imposition of a metric structure on this groupoid , and on its base set , would permit a nontrivial interaction between orbit equivalence relations and isotropy groups , leading to interesting algebraic structures . since @xmath12 and @xmath158 are both scalars , a ` covariant ' derivative can be defined directly as @xmath159 where @xmath160 is the source uncertainty of language @xmath62 . suppose the system is set in some reference configuration @xmath161 . to obtain the unperturbed dynamics of that state , impose a legendre transform using this derivative , defining another scalar @xmath162 the simplest possible onsager relation here seen as an empirical , fitted , equation like a regression model in this case becomes @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the time and @xmath165 represents an analog to the thermodynamic force in a chemical system ( cf [ multiphase ] ) . relevant here are patterns of oscillatory - like behavior where a weak signal is amplified by the presence of noise as result of some synchronized hopping around local extrema . the standard terminology for this phenomenon is _ stochastic resonance _ ( gammaitoni et al . , 1998 ) and we will proceed to give some idea of how this can be related to certain types of cognitive processes . since we are working with stochastic differential equations , the first step is to modify the equation of thermodynamic force accordingly . to this extent equation is rewritten as @xmath166 where @xmath167 is a constant and @xmath168 represents a white noise term . again , the quantity @xmath77 is seen as a function of the parameter @xmath158 . this leads directly to a family of classic stochastic differential equations expressed as differential 1-forms @xmath169 where @xmath170 and @xmath167 are appropriately regular functions of @xmath164 and @xmath158 , and @xmath171 represents the noise structure . such cognitive - epigenetic systems which are driven by stochastic and noise driven diffusion processes , may be suitably conditioned to admitting further noise perturbations that lead to a degree of stochastic resonance capable of amplifying a relatively weak signal or actually reducing the level of randomness in the system . such resonance may function as a catalyst towards the system s self - organization and complexity , in the same way as open systems far - from - equilibrium require internal amplification in order to reach a macroscopic dynamical structure ( gammaitoni et al . , 1998 ; prigogine , 1980 ; west et al . , 2005 ) . recall that the rate distortion function @xmath11 defines the minimum channel capacity necessary for the system to have an average distortion @xmath172 , thus imposing a limit on the information source uncertainty and suggesting how distortion measures can drive information system dynamics . in other words , @xmath11 affords a homological relation to free energy density , very much along the lines of the above relation between free energy density and information source uncertainty . accordingly , it is proposed that the dynamics of cognitive modules interacting in characteristic real time @xmath91 will be constrained by the system as described in terms of @xmath11 , but now we generalize matters as in wallace and wallace ( 2008 ) by producing a vector valued function @xmath173 where in the vector @xmath174 the first component is defined to be the average distortion , and then ( cf ) @xmath175 which leads to the deterministic and stochastic systems of equations analogous to the onsager relations of nonequilibrium thermodynamics @xmath176 together with @xmath177 where the @xmath178 represents often highly structured stochastic noise whose properties may be described in terms of brownian motion and quadratic variation ( see e.g. kunita , 1990 ; protter , 1995 ) . at this stage we introduce several examples for which part of the purpose will be to motivate introduction of the it principle which we will do so below . [ rdd - ex1 ] firstly , for a simple gaussian channel with noise having zero mean and variance @xmath179 , we have @xmath180 the simplest possible onsager relation becomes @xmath181 in which the term @xmath182 represents the force of an ` entropic wind ' which is a kind of internal dissipation inevitably driving the real time system of interacting cognitive information sources toward greater distortion . equation has a solution @xmath183 , showing in this case that the average distortion increases monotonically with time . following wallace ( 2009a , 7.2 ) , this example shows that such a system will inevitably succumb to a relentless entropic force , requiring _ a constant free energy expenditure for maintenance of some fixed average distortion within the system s communication between them_. the distortion in this case will , without free energy input , have a time dependence @xmath184 , with @xmath185 montonically increasing in @xmath164 , eventually leading to the punctuated failure of the system . further , in the einstein diffusion equation , a straightforward argument of wallace ( 2009a , 7.2)shows that the standard deviation of the particle position increases in proportion to @xmath186 . thus , whereas we do not expect the high correlations of an information source to exhibit typical brownian motion , it does seem to be the case that the _ distortion _ in communication between the interacting cognitive modules within the appropriate context of the onsager relations , does display brownian motion which may be of bounded variation in certain cases . here we consider different cognitive developmental subprocesses of gene expression characterized by information sources @xmath187 interacting through chemical or other signals , and assume _ that different processes become each other s principal environments _ which is a suitable hypothesis within a broad coevolutionary context . let @xmath188 where the @xmath189 represent other relevant parameters , and @xmath190 . we regard the dynamics of this system as driven by a recursive network of stochastic differential equations . letting the @xmath191 and @xmath187 all be represented as parameters @xmath192 ( with the caveat that @xmath187 does not depend on itself ) , we follow the generalized onsager formulation of wallace and wallace ( 2009 ) , in terms of the equation @xmath193 to obtain a recursive system of _ phenomenological onsager relations _ , in terms of a system of stochastic differential equations @xmath194,\ ] ] in which , for ease of notation , both the terms @xmath195 and the external @xmath191 s are expressed by the same symbol @xmath192 . as @xmath1 ranges over the @xmath187 we could allow different kinds of ` noise ' @xmath178 , having particular forms of quadratic variation which may represent a projection of environmental factors within the scope of a rate distortion manifold ( glazebrook and wallace , 2009b ) . the next step in extending is to bring in rate distortion functions for mutual crosstalk between a set of interacting cognitive modules by using the homology of @xmath11 itself . to this extent , consider different cognitive processes indexed @xmath196 , and take the mutual rate distortion functions @xmath197 characterizing communication ( and distortion ) between them . at the same time the essential parameters remain the characteristic time constants of each process , @xmath198 , for @xmath199 , together with an overall embedding free energy density @xmath53 . taking the @xmath200 to run over all the relevant parameters and mutual rate distortion functions ( along with the distortion measures @xmath201 ) , then now takes shape as @xmath202 and accordingly becomes @xmath203.\ ] ] this last equation generalizes the treatment in terms of crosstalk , its distortion , the inherent time constants of the different cognitive modules , and _ the overall available free energy density_. [ coev - ex1 ] for a gaussian channel and fixed embedded communication free energy density @xmath53 representing the richness of incoming information from the interacting cognitive modules , we extend to @xmath204 that represents the communication distortion between the modules . the equilibrium solution is @xmath205 . the difference between and is that whereas in the former case , the distortion grows directly as the square root of the elapsed time , equation reveals there is a finite , equilibrium , average distortion that is inversely proportional to the available environmental or informational free energy that the interacting systems can implement in order to navigate their actions . the above situation can be generalized to @xmath206 , where @xmath207 is monotonically increasing in @xmath53 . on introducing a characteristic response time variable @xmath91 , so that @xmath208 where @xmath209 is also monotonically increasing , leads to @xmath210 this example reveals that given a fixed rate of available information free energy , the increasing allowable response time _ decreases _ average distortion in the interaction . [ coev - ex2 ] suppose now that feedback is allowed so that the system actively seeks information in proportion to the distortion between intent and impact , then the onsager relation for a gaussian channel becomes @xmath211 and @xmath212 which is significantly smaller than , and is effectively the classic result for brownian motion in a harmonic central field ( e.g. equation ( 54 ) of wang and uhlenbeck , 1945 ) . together with the multiphase equilibrium problem of [ multiphase ] we have so far pursued a theme of how the stochastic simulation of biochemical systems closely parallels that of evolutionary genetic systems . an initial observation here , and one that will motivate further ideas , is that a stochastic differential equation of the type should in principle model the dynamics of large , intricate networks that are constrained by the costs of actual computational time , which seems relevant in certain senses to many epigenetic processes . the general setting for such processes often involves that of an it stochastic de ( viz _ it process _ ) and this is how we intend to view as a kind of ` master equation ' . for the readers sake , we remark why such a level of mathematical formality is necessary by recalling a basic difficulty : the sample paths @xmath213 of brownian motion are not in general functions of bounded variation , so that @xmath214 is not defined as for that of the usual riemann - stieltjes integral . one may start by supposing that for almost all samples , @xmath215 in is independent of future brownian motion @xmath216 ; otherwise said @xmath217 is an _ adapted _ stochastic process . putting it another way , the information available at a given time includes the history of the process at that time . more generally , the stochastic process may be taken to be _ predictable _ in order to define the it integral of the equation ( see e.g. 2.3 of kunita , 1990 and appendix [ appendix - a ] here ) . on the other hand , there is part justification for making assumptions of ( local ) boundedness of variation in the brownian motion incurred via distortion , and in particular , the adapted condition , points to those examples and observations already quoted that concern the dispensation of available free energy . firstly , in view of example [ rdd - ex1 ] we may expect a constant free energy expenditure for maintenance of some fixed average distortion in communication between the interacting cognitive modules . secondly , given a fixed rate of available information free energy , the increasing allowable response time _ decreases _ average distortion in the interaction ( example [ coev - ex1 ] ) , and thirdly , the possibility that finite , equilibrium , average distortion is actually inversely proportional to the available environmental or informational free energy that the interacting systems can utilize ( example [ coev - ex2 ] ) . however , to make matters precise , it is appropriate to consider the formalities of some filtered probability space @xmath218 , where @xmath219 ( see appendix [ appendix - a ] ) and postulate a multidimensional stochastic process given by the it integral of the master equation : @xmath220.\ ] ] in order to state the conditions for which this process is well - defined , we first express in the simplified form @xmath221 then following harrison ( 1985 , chapter 4 ) : * @xmath222 is measurable with respect to @xmath223 . * @xmath224 is an adapted stochastic process , and @xmath225 , for all @xmath226 . * the integral of ` drift ' , @xmath227 , is a continuous and adapted variation - finite ( vf ) process . granted that our observations about the local boundedness of the ( rate distortion ) brownian motion as essentially fulfilling these conditions , we now have an explicit stochastic model for the role of cross - talk , its distortion , the inherent time constraints of the different cognitive modules , as well as the overall available free energy density , where the @xmath228 parameter structure represents the full scale fragmentation of the system in the presence of some weiner noise . a further possible generalization of is to introduce into that expression a matrix valued function @xmath229 to describe the intrinsic reaction rates ( cf manninen et al . , 2006 ) : @xmath230.\ ] ] towards the possibility of a stochastic flow generated by ( such as a brownian flow of diffeomorphisms ) , we opt to simplify accordingly . following kunita ( 1990 ) we write in a simplified form as @xmath231 typically , we would seek a solution starting from some @xmath39 at some time @xmath26 ; let us call these solutions @xmath232 . then a stochastic flow can be represented as the solution of a stochastic differential equation of the type @xmath233 where in this case , brownian motion @xmath234 valued in vector fields , is given by @xmath235 the formal conditions for to produce a brownian flow of diffeomorphisms are ( kunita , 1990 ) : * @xmath236 is continuous in @xmath237 . * the map @xmath238 ( for suitable @xmath239 ) is a diffeomorphism for any @xmath240 . * @xmath241 , for any @xmath242 . note that conditions ( 1)-(3 ) are ` almost everywhere ( surely ) ' conditions . also , such a flow generates a _ holonomy _ or _ geometric phase ( transition ) _ which can be explained by the process of tracking internal states in relationship to a spatiotemporal orientation . in more precise differential - geometric terms , holonomy results from the parallel transport of vectors around a closed path , thus leading to a representation of the space of the latter into a group of global symmetries . the procedure for constructing a holonomy groupoid associated to this flow concerns some mathematical technicalities , but is nevertheless standard ( see e.g. connes , 1994 ; moerdijk and mrun , 2003 ) . whereas this case is fairly well tempered , we would in general expect ` singularities ' in the flow . the holonomy groupoid can be still be constructed , but this involves deeper mathematics outside of the scope of this paper ( see e.g. debord ( 2001 ) for details ) . we have given here a descriptive account of cognitive modules as components of epigenetic - evolutionary systems ( as far - from - equilibrium open systems ) embedded within the context of environment and culture . using dynamic groupoids of network equivalence classes we have put into atlas form the various constituent ( inter)reactive systems based on rate distortion principles of the shannon theorems and the groupoid free energy density . the rate distortion function @xmath11 determines a channel capacity that is measurable in an analogous way to a free energy that regulates many of the ( inter)reactive /reciprocating processes that have been described . rate distortion arguments suggest that if an external information source is pathogenic , then sufficient exposure to it within a developmental stage will likely result in a image inscribed on mind and body in a punctuated fashion , subsequently causing a developmental dysfunction . in this analogy , the reduction of the @xmath11 amounts to ` lower temperature ' which in turn directs the system to behavioral patterns which are less enriched and are less complex . further , accurate and efficient communicating systems require a greater channel capacity , and keeping in mind the analogy with free energy density , a higher rate of metabolism is necessary and further costs are incurred ( cf [ feynman ] ) . failure to provide such resources equates to a decline in processing , possibly to a point of disintegration . on the other hand , increased communication between the system s cognitive modules , depending on the availability of free energy , will usually be followed up by a phase transition ( in essence , this is what the holonomy groupoid encodes as shown in glazebrook and wallace ( 2009a ) ) inducing further complexity into the systems behavior . in principle one might envisage an associated _ holonomy groupoid atlas _ for interacting cognitive - dynamical systems based on synchronous ( geometric ) phase transitions of the various constituents . this would amount to a broad - scale descriptive artifact for the purpose of understanding the cumulative transitional mechanisms of living processes that may eventually uncover some even deeper conceptual issues . stochastic processes are perhaps more in keeping with what the world expects compared to a strictly deterministic approach , though the former are likely to entail higher computational costs and some neuroscientific work in this area is aimed at reducing such costs ( cf manninen et al . , 2006 ) . integration of the onsager stochastic differential equation towards a multidimensional it process , leads naturally to a stochastic flow which in our formulation diffuses across the atlas through mainly noisy channels ( cf [ multiphase ] ) . such evidence is provided by tlusty s rate - distortion analysis of the genetic coding map where it is shown that the evolution of the code unfolds as a smooth flow on the codon space as realized in tlusty ( 2007 ) . with such examples in mind , we have presented here a novel development , very much in tune with the `` flow '' nature of living systems as once envisaged by bertalanffy and prigogine , while at the same time our approach using rate distortion principles embraces many central features of related theories of cognition such as those proposed in atlan and cohen ( 1998 ) , baars ( 1988 ) , baars and franklin ( 2003 ) , cohen and harel ( 2007 ) and maturana and varela ( 1980a , 1980b ) . we state some basic details as to be found in harrison ( 1985 ) , kunita ( 1990 ) and protter ( 1985 ) . let @xmath243 be a set . a collection @xmath244 of subsets of @xmath243 is called a _ @xmath167-field _ if it contains an empty set and it is closed under the operations of countable unions and complements . it is customary to call @xmath245 a _ measurable space _ in which members of @xmath243 are called _ samples _ and those of @xmath244 are called _ events_. let @xmath246 be a @xmath167-additive measure on @xmath247 . it is called a _ probability _ if @xmath248 . the triple @xmath249 is then called a _ probability space_. let @xmath250 be a family of @xmath167-algebras on @xmath243 such that a ) @xmath251 , for all @xmath252 , and b ) @xmath253 , if @xmath254 . then @xmath255 is said to be a _ filtration _ ( an increasing sequence of sub-@xmath167-algebras ) of @xmath245 . the filtration @xmath255 characterizes how information arises ( how uncertainty is resolved ) and @xmath256 may be interpreted as the set of all events whose occurrence or nonoccurrence will be determined at time @xmath164 . in a filtered probability space it is usually understood that @xmath257 . a stochastic process @xmath258 , is said to be _ adapted _ ( relative to @xmath218 ) if @xmath259 is measurable with respect to @xmath256 , for all @xmath252 . loosely speaking , this means that the information available at time @xmath164 includes the history of @xmath260 up to that point . the _ predictable @xmath167-field _ is the least @xmath167-field in the product space @xmath261 \times \omega$ ] for which all continuous @xmath262-adapted processes are measurable . _ a predictable process _ is then defined as a process that is measurable with respect to the predictable @xmath167-field . an example is a continuous @xmath256-adapted process . recall that a process of random variables @xmath263 is brownian motion ( viz a weiner process ) if and only if * @xmath264 with probability @xmath265 . * for @xmath266 the increment @xmath267 is normally distributed @xmath268 . * for @xmath269 , the set of increments @xmath270 is a set of independent random variables ( that is , the increments are independent of the past ) . a process @xmath228 is called a _ @xmath271-brownian motion _ if it has the form @xmath272 where @xmath260 is a weiner process and @xmath273 is independent of @xmath260 . then we have @xmath274 . invoking the spirit of the shannon - mcmillan theorem , it is possible to define an apse information source @xmath49 associated with stochastic variates @xmath275 having joint and conditional probabilities @xmath276 and @xmath277 such that appropriate joint and conditional shannon uncertainties satisfy the classic relations @xmath278 & = \lim_{n { { \longrightarrow}}\infty } \frac{\log[n(n)]}{n } \\ & = \lim_{n { { \longrightarrow}}\infty}h(x_{n}|x_{0 } , \ldots , x_{n-1})\\ & = \lim_{n { { \longrightarrow}}\infty } \frac{h(x_{0},\ldots , x_{n})}{n}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] this information source is defined as _ dual _ to the underlying ergodic cognitive process ( wallace , 2005 ) . recall that the shannon uncertainties @xmath279 are cross - sectional law - of - large - numbers sums of the form @xmath280 $ ] , where the @xmath281 constitute a probability distribution ( for the basic details , see ash,1990 ; berger , 1971 ; cover and thomas , 1991 ; khinchin , 1957 ) . messages from an information source , seen as symbols @xmath282 from some alphabet , each having probabilities @xmath283 associated with a random variable @xmath57 , are ` encoded ' into the language of a ` transmission channel ' , a random variable @xmath284 with symbols @xmath285 , having probabilities @xmath281 , possibly with error . someone receiving the symbol @xmath285 then retranslates it ( without error ) into some @xmath286 , which may or may not be the same as the @xmath282 that was sent . more formally , the message sent along the channel is characterized by a random variable @xmath57 having the distribution @xmath287 the channel through which the message is sent is characterized by a second random variable @xmath284 having the distribution @xmath288 let the joint probability distribution of @xmath57 and @xmath284 be defined as @xmath289 and the conditional probability of @xmath284 given @xmath57 as @xmath290 then the shannon uncertainty of @xmath57 and @xmath284 independently and the joint uncertainty of @xmath57 and @xmath284 together are defined respectively as @xmath291 the _ conditional uncertainty _ of @xmath284 given @xmath57 is defined as @xmath292.\ ] ] for any two stochastic variates @xmath57 and @xmath284 , we have the inequality @xmath293 , as the knowledge of @xmath57 generally gives some knowledge of @xmath284 . equality occurs only in the case of stochastic independence . since @xmath294 , it is deduced @xmath295 the information transmitted by translating the variable @xmath57 into the channel transmission variable @xmath284 possibly with error and then retranslating without error the transmitted @xmath284 back into @xmath57 , is defined as @xmath296 where we refer to berger ( 1971 ) , cover and thomas ( 1991 ) and khinchin ( 1957 ) for details . the essential point is that if there is no uncertainty in @xmath57 given the channel @xmath284 , then there is no loss of information through transmission . in general this will not be true , and herein lies the essence of the theory . following wallace ( 2005 ) , suppose we have an ( ergodic ) information source @xmath284 with output from a particular alphabet generating sequences of the form @xmath297 ` digitalized ' in some sense , and induce a chain of ` digitalized ' values @xmath298 where the @xmath299alphabet is considered more restricted than the @xmath70alphabet . in this way , @xmath300 is deterministically retranslated into a reproduction of the signal @xmath301 . that is , each @xmath300 is mapped onto a unique @xmath45length @xmath70sequence in the alphabet of @xmath284 : @xmath302 we remark that many @xmath301 sequences may be mapped onto the same retranslation sequence @xmath303 , the set of which is denoted @xmath304 ; this may be interpreted as a loss of information . a distortion measure @xmath305 , between paths @xmath301 and @xmath303 is defined as @xmath306 for some suitable distance function @xmath307 ( such as the hamming distance ) . suppose that with each path @xmath308 and each @xmath300path retranslation @xmath309 into the @xmath70language , we consider the associated individual , joint , and conditional probability distributions @xmath310 the average distortion is then defined to be @xmath311 for the corresponding strings @xmath284 ( incoming ) , @xmath304 ( outgoing ) , applying the shannon uncertainty rule of gives @xmath312 the _ information rate distortion function _ @xmath11 for a source sequence @xmath284 , retranslated sequence @xmath304 with distortion measure @xmath313 , is defined as follows . let @xmath314 . then @xmath315 to explain this notation , the minimization is over all conditional distributions @xmath316 , for which the joint distribution @xmath317 satisfies average distortion less than or equal to @xmath8 . the rate distortion theorem ( see e.g. berger , 1971 ; cover and thomas , 1991 ) states that _ @xmath11 is the minimum necessary rate of information transmission ( effectively the channel capacity ) so that the average distortion does not exceed the distortion @xmath8_. ash , r. , 1990 , _ information theory _ , dover publications , new york . baianu , i. c. , brown , r. , georgescu , g. , and glazebrook , j. f. , 2006 , complex nonlinear biodynamics in categories , higher dimensional algebra and lukasiewicz moisil topos : transformations of neuronal , genetic and neoplastic networks , _ axiomathes _ , * 16 * nos . 12 , 65122 . glade , n. , ben amor , h. m. , and bastien , o. , 2009 , trail systems as fault tolerant wires and their use in bio processors . in amar , p. et al . , ( eds . ) _ modeling complex biological sytems in the context of genomics , proceedings of the spring school , nice 2009 _ , 85119 . moffitt , t. e. , caspi , a. , and rutter , m. , 2006 , measured gene - environment interactions in psychopathology : concepts , research strategies , and implications for research , intervention , and public understanding of genetics , _ perspectives on psychological science _ , * 1*(1 ) , 527 . wallace , r. , and wallace , d. , 2008 , punctuated equilibrium in statistical models of generalized coevolutionary resilience : how sudden ecosystem transitions can entrain both phennotype expression and darwinian selection , _ transactions on computational systems biology ix _ , lnbi 5121 : 23 85 . west , r. l. , stewart t. c. , lebiere c. , and chandrasekharan , s. ( 2005 ) , stochastic resonance in human cognition : act - r versus game theory , associative neural networks , recursive neural networks , q - learning and humans . in bara , b. , barsalou , l. , & bucciarelli , m. ( eds . ) , _ proceedings of the 27th annual conference of the cognitive science society - stresa , italy , 2005 _ 2353 - 2358 ) . mahwah , nj : lawrence erlbaum associates . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: cooperation and defection are the two strategies that are usually at the heart of every social dilemma @xcite . while cooperative individuals contribute to the collective welfare at a personal cost , defectors choose not to . due to the resulting lower individual fitness of cooperators the selection pressure acts in favor of the defectors , thus designating the evolution of cooperation as a dilemma standing on its own . established by @xcite , evolutionary game theory @xcite provides a competent theoretical framework to address the subtleties of cooperation among selfish and unrelated individuals . the prisoner s dilemma game in particular , is considered a paradigm for tackling the problem of cooperation @xcite . the game promises a defecting individual the highest fitness if facing a cooperator . at the same time , the exploited cooperator is worse off than a defector playing with another defector . according to the fundamental principles of darwinian selection , cooperation extinction is therefore inevitable . this unadorned scenario is actually realized in the well - mixed prisoner s dilemma game , where defectors reign supreme @xcite . relaxing the inevitability of a social downfall constituted by the well - mixed prisoner s dilemma is the snowdrift or hawk - dove game @xcite , where mutual defection is individually less favorable than a cooperation - defection pair - up . accordingly , the snowdrift game allows for stable coexistence of cooperators and defectors in well - mixed populations @xcite . completing the triplet is the stag - hunt game @xcite , which together with the prisoner s dilemma and the snowdrift game , forms the standard set of social dilemmas that is frequently explored in the current literature [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] . compared with the prisoner s dilemma , the stag - hunt game offers more support for cooperative individuals in that the reward for mutual cooperation is higher than the temptation to defect . still , cooperation in the stag - hunt game is compromised by the fact that mutual defection is individually more beneficial than being an exploited cooperator , as recently highlighted by @xcite . an important realization by the pursuit of cooperation in the context of social dilemmas was the fact that the outcome of evolutionary games in structured populations can be very different from the well - mixed case . in a pioneering work , @xcite showed that the introduction of spatial structure via nearest neighbor interactions enabled the cooperators to form clusters on the square lattice and so protect themselves against the exploitation by defectors . following this discovery , the impact of the spatial structure on the evolution of cooperation has been investigated in detail @xcite , and the subject has since been reviewed comprehensively on different occasions @xcite . notably , the theoretical conjecture that spatial structure may promote cooperation , or at least sustain a multitude of competing strategies has been confirmed experimentally @xcite , but there also exist evidences that spatial structure may not necessarily favor cooperation @xcite . since the impact of the spatial structure on the evolution of cooperation depends on the governing social dilemma , and due to the difficulties associated with the payoff rankings in experimental and field work @xcite , it is certainly good practice to test new mechanisms aimed at promoting cooperation on different evolutionary games . the recent shift from evolutionary games on regular grids to evolutionary games on complex networks [ for the latter see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] can be considered a step towards more realistic conditions . indeed , the shift is by no means trivial and bears fascinating results , as recently reviewed by @xcite . quite remarkably , scale - free networks @xcite turned out to sustain cooperation by all three above - described social dilemmas @xcite , owing predominantly to the heterogeneity that characterizes their degree distribution . following this seminal discovery , several studies have since elaborated on different aspects of cooperation on scale - free networks , as for example its dynamical organization @xcite , evolution under clustering @xcite , mixing patterns @xcite , memory @xcite and payoff normalization @xcite , as well as its robustness in general @xcite and under intentional attack and error @xcite . the body of literature devoted to the study of evolutionary games on complex network is extensive , aside from the scale - free architecture hosting the prisoner s dilemma @xcite and the snowdrift game @xcite , covering also small - world @xcite , social as well as other real - world networks @xcite . notably , the impact of different interaction topologies has also been studied for evolutionary games outside the realm of the above - described social dilemmas . examples include the rock - paper - scissors game @xcite , the ultimatum game @xcite or the public goods game @xcite , and indeed many more studies of the latter games on complex network are expected in the near future . besides the conditions generated by spatiality and complex interaction networks , many different mechanisms have been identified that can promote or otherwise affect the evolution of cooperation , and we mention them here briefly . aside from network reciprocity inherent to games on graphs and complex networks , other prominent rules promoting cooperative behavior are kin selection @xcite , direct reciprocity @xcite , indirect reciprocity @xcite and group selection @xcite , as recently reviewed in @xcite . moreover , voluntary participation @xcite , social diversity @xcite , asymmetric influence of links and partner selection @xcite , heterogeneous teaching activity @xcite , and the impact of long - term learning @xcite have been suggested as interesting possibilities that may emerge in real - life systems . the necessary overlap between interaction and replacement graphs @xcite has also been recognized as an important agonist in the evolution of cooperation . furthermore , the importance of time scales in evolutionary dynamics @xcite , the role of finite population size @xcite , and the impact of noise and uncertainties on evolution in general @xcite have been investigated as well . very recently , random explorations of strategies @xcite and simultaneous adoptions of different strategies depending on the opponents @xcite have also been identified as potent promoters of cooperation . some of these mechanisms will be described more accurately in the subsequent sections , but otherwise the reader is referred to the original works for details . in the focus of this mini review are evolutionary games with coevolutionary rules . initiated by @xcite and by @xcite , and in some sense motivated by then very vibrant advances in network growth and evolution @xcite , the subject has evolved into a mushrooming avenue of research that offers new ways of ensuring cooperation in situations constituting a social dilemma . coevolutionary rules constitute a natural upgrade of evolutionary games since in reality not only do the strategies evolve in time , but so does the environment , and indeed many other factors that in turn affect back the outcome of the evolution of strategies . coevolutionary rules can affect the links players make ( or brake ) @xcite ( see section [ interactions ] ) , the size of the network ( or population ) @xcite ( see section [ growth ] ) , the teaching activity ( or reproduction capability ) @xcite ( see section [ teaching ] ) and mobility of players @xcite ( see section [ mobility ] ) , their age @xcite ( see section [ aging ] ) , as well as several other factors @xcite ( see section [ related ] ) that eventually affect the outcome of the underlying evolutionary game . although the majority of coevolutionary rules studied so far affects the network architecture and size , it is important to distinguish these studies from previous , partially closely related works where networks also change or evolve in the course of time @xcite ; in particularly so , since the term ` coevolution ' has in the past been used quite frequently and for rather different processes . in the continuation of this paper we will review recent advances on evolutionary games with coevolutionary rules , affecting , as mentioned above , the interaction network , the reproduction capability of players , their reputation , mobility or age , more thoroughly . before that , however , we give in section [ games ] a more technical description of the evolutionary games and strategy adoption rules that we will encounter throughout the paper . following the main body of the review given in section [ rules ] , we conclude our work and give an outlook in section [ final ] . as noted in the first paragraph of section [ intro ] , the three main social dilemmas involving pairwise interactions are constituted by the prisoner s dilemma game , the snowdrift game and the stag - hunt game . at least one of these three games is employed in the majority of the works we will review below , and hence we give a more accurate description of them in what follows . irrespective of which game applies , players can choose either to cooperate or to defect . notably , other strategies , such as loners [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] or punishers [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] are also possible , but their inclusion to evolutionary games with coevolutionary rules has not yet been considered . in general , mutual cooperation yields the reward @xmath0 , mutual defection leads to punishment @xmath1 , and the mixed choice gives the cooperator the sucker s payoff @xmath2 and the defector the temptation @xmath3 . the standard scaled parametrization entails designating @xmath4 and @xmath5 as fixed , while the remaining two payoffs can occupy @xmath6 and @xmath7 . then , if @xmath8 we have the prisoner s dilemma game , @xmath9 yields the snowdrift game , and @xmath10 the stag - hunt game , as schematically depicted in fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] . without much loss of generality , this parametrization is often further simplified for the prisoner s dilemma game , so that @xmath11 is the only free parameter while @xmath4 and @xmath12 are left constant ( thick red line in fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) . however , since then the condition @xmath13 is not strictly fulfilled , this version is traditionally referred to as the weak prisoner s dilemma game @xcite . an option is also to use @xmath11 , @xmath14 , @xmath5 and @xmath15 , thus strictly adhering to the prisoner s dilemma payoff ranking @xmath8 while still having a single tunable parameter in the form of the ratio @xmath16 . for the snowdrift game one can , in a similar fashion , introduce @xmath17 $ ] such that @xmath18 and @xmath19 [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] , thereby again decreasing the effective dimensionality of the parameter space by one . note also that @xmath20 characterizes the cost - to - benefit ratio @xcite and in fact constitutes a diagonal in the snowdrift quadrant of the @xmath21 parameter plane , as shown in fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] by the dotted blue line . it is worth mentioning that other types of parametrization of two - strategy games are possible as well @xcite , but we focus on the one presented above since it is the most widely used , thus enabling an efficient comparison of different works . parameter plane encompassing the stag - hunt ( sh ) , the prisoner s dilemma ( pd ) and the snowdrift ( sd ) game . borders between games are denoted by dashed green lines . dotted blue diagonal depicts the @xmath20-parametrization of the snowdrift game , while the thick red line shows the span of the weak prisoner s dilemma game having @xmath11 as the only main parameter . the upper left quadrant represents the so - called harmony game ( hg ) . the latter , however , does not constitute a social dilemma because there cooperation is always the winning strategy.,width=283 ] the most frequently employed setup entails that initially each player @xmath22 is designated either as a cooperator @xmath23 or defector @xmath24 with equal probability , and is placed on one of the nodes of the network with degree @xmath25 . evolution of the two strategies is then performed in accordance with a pairwise comparison rule , during which players accumulate their payoffs @xmath26 by playing the game with their neighbors . subsequently , player @xmath22 tries to enforce its strategy @xmath27 on player @xmath28 in accordance with some probability @xmath29 to be specified below . during the simulation procedure the player @xmath22 and one of its neighbors @xmath28 are chosen randomly , whereby in accordance with the random sequential update each player is selected once on average during @xmath30 ( network size ) such elementary steps , together constituting one full monte carlo step @xcite . alternatively , players can be selected sequentially , albeit this may cause artificial effects . independently on whether synchronized or the random sequential update is used , however , the time evolution is always discrete . the probability of strategy adoption @xmath29 can be defined in several ways . if the degree @xmath25 of all players is the same and does not change in time , the fermi function @xmath31 } \label{fermi}\ ] ] is a viable option , as proposed by @xcite . in eq . [ fermi ] @xmath32 denotes the amplitude of noise @xcite , or equivalently its inverse ( @xmath33 ) the so - called intensity of selection @xcite . in the @xmath34 limit player @xmath22 always succeeds in enforcing its strategy to player @xmath28 if only @xmath35 but never otherwise . for @xmath36 , however , strategies performing worse may also be adopted based on unpredictable variations in payoffs @xcite or errors in the decision making , for example . importantly , if the degree distribution of the interaction network ( note that this is a property that may likely change due to a coevolutionary rule ) , at any instance of the game , deviates from the case where all players have the same degree , the application of the fermi function may introduce additional effects since then the impact of the same value of @xmath32 effectively varies from one player to the other . indeed , if the degree distribution characterizing the interaction network is heterogeneous , a more successful player ( _ i.e. _ having a larger payoff ) can pass its strategy with the probability @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the largest of the two degrees @xmath25 and @xmath39 , and @xmath40 for the prisoner s dilemma game , @xmath41 for the snowdrift game and @xmath42 for the stag - hunt game ( note that the ranking of payoff elements for each specific game ensures the positive sign of eq . [ pach ] . ) introduced by @xcite , it is still a popular choice surpassing the difficulties associated with the fermi function described above , albeit with the downside of being unable to adjust the level of uncertainty by strategy adoptions . finally , we mention another frequently used strategy adoption rule in coevolutionary models ; namely the so - called richest - following ( or ` learning from the best ' ) rule @xcite , where the focal player always imitates the strategy of its most successful neighbor @xcite . contrary to the preceding two strategy adoption rules , the richest - following is completely deterministic , in fact exercising the strongest selection between players . naturally , there also exist other microscopic strategy adoption rules , such as the win - stay - lose - shift rule where the focal player has restricted information on its neighbors , for which the reader is advised to consult the comprehensive review by @xcite for more details . we will use the notation introduced above throughout this work unless explicitly stated otherwise . also , any deviations with respect to the employed initial setup , simulation procedure or the definition of strategy adoption probability will be noted when applicable . while it is obvious that strategies of players engaging in evolutionary games evolve in time , the fact that other properties characterizing either their individual attributes or the environment in which the game is staged may simultaneously evolve as well gained foothold only in recent years . yet the preceding transitions from well - mixed populations to spatial grids and further to complex networks , and in particular their success in explaining the evolution of cooperation , are inviting to further extensions of the theoretical framework , and indeed , the introduction of coevolutionary rules seems like the logical next step . it should need little persuasion to acknowledge that links we make with others change in time , that all of us age , that our roles in life evolve , and that the society we are part of may itself be subject to transformations on a global scale . coevolutionary rules aim to integrate these processes into the framework of evolutionary games . perhaps the biggest challenge thereby is , how to do this without directly ( or obviously ) promoting cooperation . for example , if one introduces a rule that , in the course of time , cooperators should aim to link only with cooperators and defectors only with defectors , it should come as no surprise that such a coevolutionary rule will likely favor the evolution of cooperation . it is demanding , however , to explore and identify successful mechanisms that do not attribute special , not to say fictitious , cognitive skill to players , and do not use a discriminative set of rules for every participating strategy . thus , coming up with plausible coevolutionary rules is not straightforward , and care must be exercised in order to give both strategies equal credentials . simply because a strategy is bad for social welfare it should not be assumed that the individuals adopting it are less skilful or sly than their opponents . in fact , rather the opposite seems to apply . for example , defectors should be assumed being just as skilful by selecting appropriate partners as cooperators . in the following we will review coevolutionary rules affecting the interactions between players ( section [ interactions ] ) , population growth ( section [ growth ] ) , teaching activity ( section [ teaching ] ) , mobility ( section [ mobility ] ) and aging ( section [ aging ] ) of players , as well as related aspects ( section [ related ] ) of individual and global characteristics that may affect strategy dominance in evolutionary games . coevolutionary rules frequently affect how players link with one another and this section reviews examples thereof . as we have mentioned above , the result of a game with a partner may influence the durability of such a connection . in particular , an unsatisfied player can easily brake a link to look for a more beneficial interaction with another partner . notably , the network itself does thereby not shrink or grow in size ( for the latter see section [ growth ] ) . instead , our aim in this subsection is to explore possible rearrangements of an existing network that is driven by the success of players participating in the governing evolutionary game . since coevolutionary rules affecting the interactions between players were proposed first @xcite , the pertaining literature that has accumulated thus far is rather extensive . works can be partitioned into those that employed strategy independent rules for link adaptations @xcite and those that considered strategies or their performances as factors potentially affecting the rewiring @xcite . notably , the latter distinction is rather crude and sometimes not completely accurate since the rewiring can be performed based on a secondary player property , like reputation @xcite , attractiveness @xcite or satisfaction @xcite , which are typically related with strategy performance over time . it is indeed possible to further distinguish the proposed coevolutionary rules introducing dynamical interactions to those by which the change of the interaction network is driven by the urge to increase the payoff of the focal player directly @xcite , and those by which the rewiring serves also the increase of the payoff but on a global scale , _ i.e. _ independently of the payoff of the focal player that is affected by the link adaptation @xcite . in the latter case it is thus not necessary to calculate the players payoff prior to rewiring because solely its strategy determines the ` life ' of a link . [ ! ht ] summarizing the above , a simplified but useful classification of interaction - updating rules is presented in fig . [ fig : class_of_updates ] . as suggested in the works mentioned last in the preceding paragraph , the lifetime of a link may depend primarily on the strategies of the players that are connected with it ( type a ) . from this point of view it is straightforward to establish that defector - defector links are short - lived if compared to cooperator - cooperator links since the former are not beneficial for neither of the two involved players , while the later yield mutual gains for both . the second set of coevolutionary rules evaluates the payoffs originating from the investigated link prior to its potential deletion , while the actual removal takes place only if a new neighbor may yield higher benefits ( type b ) @xcite . and finally , the third set of coevolutionary rules considers the strategy adoption process as pivotal for deciding which links to delete and which to keep ( type c ) . an example thereof is that the invaded player looses all its links except the one with the donor of the new strategy @xcite , as depicted in fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](c ) . there are several real - life situations that can be modeled by the latter rule . from a biological viewpoint , the coevolutionary rule can be linked with an invasion of the subordinate species and the subsequent replacement by a newborn of the victor . a similar phenomenon can be observed in human societies when one changes a job . typically then the links to former coworkers fade and eventually brake , and new ties are formed primarily with the coworkers from the new working place . notably , it falls within the same logical set of rules if the player that has successfully passed its strategy is allowed to increase the number of neighbors that are directly connected to it , as was proposed by @xcite . it should not be overlooked , however , that the strategy adoption process , triggering the deletion and/or addition of links , is itself inherently routed in the payoff difference of the considered players . an important feature of coevolutionary rules molding the interactions among players is also the time scale separation between link and strategy adaptations , as reported in @xcite . as the cited works suggest , the time scale separation can drastically influence the final output of coevolutionary games . this effect will also be discussed in the present review . in what follows , we will review the coevolutionary rules presented in some of these works more accurately . in agreement with the actual time - line we start with the work of @xcite , who proposed a coevolutionary rule in which a randomly chosen player @xmath22 is connected to a new neighbor at random . if the new link increases the average payoff of the focal player the latter accepts it and disconnects from the neighbor it scores worst against . note that this coevolutionary rule indirectly favors the establishment of cooperator - cooperator links ( this pair - up yields the highest average payoff ) and at the same time facilitates the deletion of defector - defector links . the coevolutionary rule was paired up with strategy mutation @xcite , by which a mutation is accepted if it yields a higher payoff for player @xmath22 than the initial strategy [ type b ; see fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](b ) ] . starting from a random network with poissonian degree distribution , it was shown that this coevolutionary rule leads to cooperative nash equilibria in an iterative prisoner s dilemma game with the additional property that no agent can improve its payoff by changing its neighborhood . according to the authors , the later may be interpreted as a sort of ` network nash equilibrium ' @xcite . notably , this coevolutionary rule also affects the initial network structure in that the later evolves to a statistically stationary state with a broad degree distribution , suggesting scale - free behavior and giving rise to small - world properties , among others . following their preceding seminal contribution [ see @xcite ] , @xcite proposed a coevolutionary rule affecting only defector - defector pairs with the motivation that in this pair - up _ both _ players might be better off if searching for a new partner in the context of the prisoner s dilemma game [ type a ; see fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](a ) ] . it was shown that , starting from a random network with a given average degree and the richest - following strategy adoption rule , even a small probability @xmath43 of searching for a new partner from a defector - defector configuration may substantially promote cooperation . indeed , as low as @xmath44 were shown to uphold practically complete cooperator dominance across the whole span of the weak prisoner s dilemma game ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) . with respect to the network topology , it was reported that the coevolutionary rule facilitates the formation of a hierarchical interaction structure and may also introduce small - world properties if the search for new partners is constrained to the neighbors of the neighbors . however , unlike as shown by @xcite , the occasional ( depending on @xmath43 ) break - up of defector - defector pairs has not been found leading to broad or even scale - free degree distributions . these findings were subsequently extended @xcite , where it was elaborated on the spontaneous emergence of cooperators with extremely high payoffs and the important role of this so - called ` leaders ' for the global sustenance of cooperation . as such , these works can be considered as an important prelude to the realization of the fact that scale - free networks constitute an extremely favorable environment for the evolution of cooperation irrespective of the governing social dilemma @xcite . a simple but still plausible coevolutionary rule affecting links between players has been proposed by @xcite . exemplifying type a class of interaction updating [ see fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](a ) ] , players adopting either the strategy @xmath45 ( cooperate ) or @xmath46 ( defect ) were designated a propensity to form new links denoted by @xmath47 and @xmath48 , such that @xmath49 links were formed at rates @xmath50 , where @xmath51 $ ] . moreover , each link was assigned a specific lifetime depending on the strategy of the two connected players given by @xmath52 , where @xmath53 is the corresponding link death rate . with these definitions the authors were able to specify mean field equations governing the so - called active linking dynamics of the network . this coevolutionary rule has been tested on the prisoner s dilemma and the snowdrift game subject to the fermi function ( see eq . [ fermi ] ) governing the strategy adoption [ for additional set - ups see @xcite ] . it was shown that if the time scale associated with active linking is much smaller than the one associated with strategy updating the proposed coevolutionary rule leads to an effective rescaling of the governing payoff matrix , and thus a shift in the played evolutionary game . for example , the prisoner s dilemma game transforms to the coordination game , while the snowdrift game transforms to the harmony game [ for details on the coordination game see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] . in both cases the cooperation is promoted , in turn designating the proposed coevolutionary rule as a simple and analytically tractable means of understanding how selfish and unrelated individuals may be led to adopting the cooperative strategy . on the other hand , if the ratio between the time scales associated with active linking and strategy updating is not small , the interplay between these two dynamical processes leads to a progressive crossover between the analytic results obtained for very fast active linking and the evolutionary dynamics of strategies taking place on static graphs . the latter were found to exhibit different degrees of heterogeneity depending on the parameters determining active linking , yet in general complying well with real social networks having fast decaying tails in their degree distributions . notably , compared to the earlier works reviewed above , an important observation made in the two papers by @xcite was that the impact of coevolutionary rules may depend significantly on the time scales associated with the strategy and structure ( link ) evolution . for example , @xcite too commented on the time scale separation in their model , yet the promotion of cooperation was thereby not notably affected [ both slow ( @xmath54 ) and fast ( @xmath55 ) rewiring of @xmath56 links was found to be highly effective ] . active linking dynamics has also been investigated in repeated games incorporating direct reciprocity @xcite , where additionally the productivity of every link connecting two players was evaluated prior to potential rewiring . moreover , the active linking model proposed by @xcite was recently extended by @xcite to account for the impact of different reactions to adverse ties . in particular , @xcite additionally introduced individual behavioral types of players through different values of @xmath57 , separating those that tend to break their links frequently ( @xmath57 close to @xmath58 ) from those that tend to break them rarely ( @xmath57 close to @xmath59 ) . in this way both topology and strategy dynamics become interrelated it was shown that populations in which individuals are allowed to handle their social contacts diversely are more prone to cooperative behavior than those in which such diversity is absent . similarly as in @xcite , it was shown that by an appropriate time scale separation between strategy and network dynamics the diverse behavioral preferences can also introduce a transformation of the governing social dilemma , yet so that each individual perceives the same game differently . also building on the time scale separation between rewiring and strategy updating is another paper by @xcite , where players are able to decide which links they want to maintain and which they want to change based on local information about their neighbors [ type b ; see fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](b ) ] . a link change is initiated if player @xmath22 is dissatisfied with its connection to player @xmath28 , which is the case if the strategy of player @xmath28 is to defect . however , player @xmath28 also assesses the quality of its link to @xmath22 in the same fashion . if both @xmath22 and @xmath28 are satisfied ( which practically means that both are cooperators ) the link between them remains intact . if @xmath22 wants to remove the link and @xmath28 not ( @xmath60 and @xmath61 ) , the probability @xmath62 given by the fermi function ( see eq . [ fermi ] ) is invoked . if realized , player @xmath22 is allowed to redirect to a random neighbor of @xmath28 . if not , @xmath22 stays linked with @xmath28 . if both @xmath22 and @xmath28 are defectors , and thus both want to remove the link , then rewiring takes place such that the new link keeps attached to @xmath22 with probability @xmath62 or to @xmath28 with probability @xmath63 . finally , the authors introduce a ratio defined as the time scale associated with the evolution of strategies @xmath64 ( for simplicity equal to one ) divided by the time scale associated with the rewiring of the network @xmath65 , showing that there exists a critical value for this ratio above which cooperators wipe out defectors . moreover , the emerging networks exhibit an overall heterogeneity that is maximal at the critical value and can be compared well with diversity associated with realistic social networks . the coevolutionary rule proposed by @xcite was extended by allowing individuals to adjust their social ties @xcite , with the extension that each player was assigned an individual willingness @xmath66 to rewire unwanted social interactions . accordingly , players with small @xmath67 can be considered as loyal to their partners and resilient to change , while those with @xmath68 are swift in altering their links . it was shown that the highest cooperation levels can be achieved when the propensity to change links is highly strategy - dependent . more precisely , it was found very beneficial for the evolution of cooperation if defectors changed their partners frequently while cooperators behaved oppositely , _ i.e. _ kept their partners for as long as possible . this is indeed expect since defectors are unable to establish social ties under mutual agreement with their partners . on the other hand , cooperators are typically much more prone to establishing long - term relations and loyalty . ultimately , these two facts lead to the evolution of heterogeneous interactions networks where cooperators are known to prevail over defectors [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] . related to the work of @xcite is the recent paper by @xcite , the difference being that in the latter only cooperators are allowed to switch their partners if they act as defectors , and moreover , the new partner is sought randomly from the whole population . it is found that under such a coevolutionary rule there exists an optimal , rather than critical [ compare with @xcite ] , time scale separation between rewiring and strategy updating for which cooperation thrives best . also , the resulting interaction topology is different in that the network typically becomes divided into isolated communities of cooperators and defectors due to the selective coevolutionary rule targeting only mixed strategy pairs . notably , a preceding study by @xcite considered partner switching also with the aid of reputation , which was defined similar to image scoring proposed a decade earlier by @xcite . it was found that coevolutionary switching of partners based on the reputation of nearest and next - nearest neighbors , _ i.e. _ preferentially targeting players with a higher reputation , is significantly more effective in promoting cooperation than seeking a new partner randomly from the whole population . thus , these results underline the importance of indirect reciprocity @xcite also when individuals can adjust their social ties . links are beneficial for all involved ) , can pass its strategy to a defector that is weakened by neighboring defectors ( panel a ) . subsequently , the invaded player looses its links to other players , except the one with the donor of the new strategy ( panel b ) . due to random link additions , the successful invasion of cooperators will repeat itself sooner or later depending on @xmath69 ( panel c ) , ultimately resulting in the disintegration of the defector cluster ( panel d ) . note that this process can not work in the opposite direction , _ i.e. _ defectors can not invade a cluster of cooperators . the necessary condition for this mechanism to work is the emergence of quasi - homogeneous groups , which occur if strategy adoptions happen frequently between new link additions , _ i.e. _ if @xmath69 is large enough.,width=283 ] in addition to the studies reviewed above , similar coevolutionary rules were used to study how scale - free networks emerge in social systems @xcite , how cooperation in the prisoner s dilemma game can be established via the interplay between dynamical interactions and game dynamics @xcite or interaction stochasticity @xcite , how social dilemmas in general can thereby be resolved @xcite , as well as other sophisticated models @xcite were considered . we refer the interested reader to the original works for further details , while here we proceed with the review of some of the studies that employed strategy independent rules for link adaptations @xcite . belonging to the third type of interaction - updating coevolutionary rules [ type c ; see fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](c ) ] is the model proposed by @xcite , where whenever player @xmath22 adopts a new strategy all its links , except from the one with the donor of the new strategy , are deleted ( see fig . [ fig : multilevel_selection ] ) , and moreover , all individuals are allowed to form a new link with a randomly chosen player with which they are not yet connected after every @xmath69 full monte carlo steps . note that the random additions of links counteract the deletions following each strategy adoption , in turn largely preserving the initially random topology and the heterogeneity of the interaction network @xcite . it was shown that at a sufficiently large time scale separation between link deletions and additions , constituted by @xmath69 , this coevolutionary rules evokes the spontaneous emergence of a powerful multilevel selection mechanism , which despite the persistent random topology of the evolving network , maintains cooperation across a substantial portion of the @xmath21 parameter plane . importantly , the promotion of cooperation is thereby not realized by some final outcome of a coevolutionary rule , as is for example the case in @xcite , but is the consequence of a dynamical processes that affects the adoption of strategies on the macroscopic level of evolutionary game dynamics . as fig . [ fig : multilevel_selection ] illustrates , the latter manifests as multilevel selection @xcite that strongly promotes cooperation in all major types of social dilemmas . [ ! ht ] grid , obtained at an optimal ( @xmath70 ; top panel ) and a too large ( @xmath71 , bottom panel ) connectivity originating from the coevolutionary rule proposed by @xcite . full black ( open green ) boxes depict the positions of influential defectors ( cooperators ) while yellow ( white ) pixels depict the players who are within ( out of ) their range of influence . if the influential players are separated by large disjunct territories of influence ( bottom panel ) the network reciprocity is not functioning well.,width=264 ] conceptually fitting to the third type of interaction - updating coevolutionary rules [ type c ; see fig . [ fig : class_of_updates](c ) ] is also the model introduced by @xcite , where each player @xmath22 that successfully passes its strategy ( _ i.e. _ reproduces in a biological scenario ) is allowed to form a new link with one randomly selected neighbor from its current neighborhood , thereby increasing its degree @xmath25 by one . thus , successful players are allowed to grow compact large neighborhoods that are centered around their initial four nearest neighbors . as it is generally assumed , the payoff of any given player is accumulated from all the links with its neighbors . hence , without the normalization by degree , the more links a player has the higher its payoff is expected to be . for the sake of an easier depiction of player distributions , we start from an interaction graph that can be represented by a square lattice . evidently , the additions of new links will drive the initial topology away from two dimensions , yet still allowing us to capture relevant details of strategy distributions via a square lattice representation , as shown in fig . [ fig : coev_range ] . notably , the coevolutionary rule is independent on whether @xmath60 or @xmath46 , and can hence be considered as strategy independent . however , since the performance of the strategies is clearly definitive for who gets to make new links , the rule has at least conceptual similarities with some of the above - reviewed works that considered strategies as more directly decisive for the outcome of dynamical interactions . since the coevolutionary rule would eventually result in a fully connected graph ( the latter constitutes well - mixed conditions ) , the parameter @xmath72 was introduced as the maximal degree a player is allowed to obtain . accordingly , the process of making new connections is stopped as soon as the degree @xmath73 of a single player within the whole population reaches @xmath72 , whereby this limit prevents the formation of a homogeneous system and indeed constitutes the main parameter affecting the impact of the coevolutionary rule . starting from a square lattice , it was shown that intermediate values of @xmath74 substantially promote cooperation in the weak prisoner s dilemma game ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) governed by eq . [ pach ] , which was attributed to the formation of highly heterogeneous interactions networks ensuring optimal transfer of information between influential players , _ i.e. _ those that have the highest degree among any other players that can adopt the strategy from the influential player via an elementary process . the coevolutionary rule was also tested against robustness to time scale separation between neighborhood growth and strategy adoption via the introduction of a parameter @xmath75 , defining the probability of degree extension after a successful strategy pass . evidently , @xmath76 recovers the originally proposed model while decreasing values of @xmath75 result in increasingly separated time scales . although the impact of @xmath75 was found depending somewhat on the temptation to defect @xmath77 , in general values of @xmath78 yielded insignificantly different results if compared to the @xmath76 case . note that @xmath79 corresponds to the spatial model without coevolution , and hence it is natural that as @xmath80 the promotion of cooperation was found fading . the success of intermediate values of @xmath72 in promoting cooperation can be explained based on the emergence of heterogeneous interaction networks and the disassortative mixing of high - degree nodes @xcite . in particular , while intermediate values of @xmath72 result in a highly degree - diverse mixture of players , which generally promotes cooperation [ see also @xcite ] , too large values of @xmath72 yield just a few influential players with disjunct clouds of homogeneous regions surrounding them , as shown in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : coev_range ] . in the later case , the lack of information exchange between hubs ( influential players having large degree ) defectors can easily survive , thus resulting only in moderate cooperation levels . the top panel of fig . [ fig : coev_range ] , on the other hand , features an optimal distribution of influential players ( _ i.e. _ those having large degree ) , where high - degree cooperators can make cooperation prevail practically across the whole system . it is worth mentioning that the optimal level of cooperation observed for an intermediate value of @xmath72 in @xcite is conceptually similar to the case when an intermediate strength of information exchange between influential players yields the optimal environment for cooperation @xcite , as is illustrated in fig . [ fig : restricted ] . in the later case a fraction @xmath81 of players that are characterized with a larger teaching capability are allowed to temporarily link with distant opponents of the same kind with probability @xmath43 , thus introducing shortcut connections among the distinguished . these additional temporary connections are able to sustain cooperation throughout the whole range of the temptation to defect @xmath77 ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) . as fig . [ fig : restricted ] demonstrates , only minute values of @xmath43 , constituting a moderate intensity of information exchange between influential players , warrant the best promotion of cooperation . as a function of @xmath43 in the ` connected influential players ' model @xcite . parameter @xmath43 determines the intensity of the information exchange between influential players . the fraction of influential players is @xmath82 and the temptation to defect is @xmath83 . the line is just to guide the eye.,width=283 ] strategy - independent coevolutionary rules affecting the interactions between players have also been considered in the context of distinguished players populating a square lattice @xcite , in the context of dynamically changing random and scale - free networks @xcite , as well as in the context of random networks with different assortative mixing emerging due to links adaptations @xcite . again , the interested reader is referred to the original works for further details , while here we proceed with a new section devoted to the review of coevolutionary rules introducing network growth . first , it is worth noting that coevolutionary rules giving rise to population growth have been considered much less frequently than the above - reviewed rules affecting solely how players link with one another . indeed , only three works fit into this subsection , the latter being the arxiv contribution by @xcite and two recent papers by @xcite . closely related to the rather general and broad interest in network growth @xcite , the networks formed by the players participating in evolutionary games can be subject to growth as well , with motivations equivalent to those of the broader research field . although never officially published , the work by @xcite should be acknowledged as being pioneering in raising the question how the dynamics of an evolutionary game might affect network growth , and how in turn the latter affects back the prevalence of the competing strategies . for this purpose , the authors proposed a so - called payoff - based preferential attachment rule under the guidance of the @xmath20-parameterized snowdrift game ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) and the fermi strategy adoption rule given by eq . [ fermi ] . indeed , the preferential attachment rule by @xcite is practically identical to the seminal growth and preferential attachment model proposed by @xcite , only that in the former the probability of linking a new player to an existing player @xmath22 is not determined by its degree @xmath25 but rather by its accumulated payoff until that time . not surprisingly then ( note that in the absence of normalization , similarly as the degree of a player , its payoff will typically also increase by one during an update ) , the coevolutionary rule was found leading to the emergence of scale - free interaction networks that are characterized by the degree distribution @xmath84 ; the coefficient @xmath57 thereby depending on the scaling of the probability of linking a new player to an existing player . in accordance with an earlier study by @xcite , the emerging scale - free topology due to the coevolutionary rule was found highly beneficial for the evolution of cooperation in the snowdrift game . notably , the authors also investigated the average path length and the assortative mixing of the emerging networks , as well as the wealth distribution of players . the former two were found to be in agreement with observations from realistic social networks , while the latter was found consistent with the pareto law . the work by @xcite also introduces an evolutionary preferential attachment rule that is based on the payoffs of existing players , albeit the weak prisoner s dilemma is employed as the governing game and the strategy adoption probability is quantified according to eq . more precisely , the network growth starts with @xmath85 fully connected players and proceeds by adding a new player with @xmath86 links to the existing ones at equally spaced time intervals @xmath87 . the probability that any player @xmath22 , ( having payoff @xmath26 ) in the network receives one of the @xmath88 new links was defined as @xmath89 } \label{attach}\ ] ] where the sum runs over all the players forming the network at time @xmath90 . moreover , the parameter @xmath91 controls the weight of the payoffs during the network growth . for @xmath92 all nodes are equiprobable , corresponding to the weak selection limit [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite for recent works related to the latter ] , while for @xmath93 the players with the highest payoffs are much more likely to attract the newcomers . the authors also specified the time interval @xmath94 for payoff evaluations and potential strategy adoptions , focusing explicitly on @xmath95 ( typically @xmath96 , although smaller and larger values were also commented on ) , so that accordingly the network growth was considered to be faster than the evolutionary dynamics . it was shown that the weak selection limit results in networks having degree distributions with exponentially decaying tails , while the strong selection limit ( @xmath93 ) yields highly heterogeneous scale - free interaction networks . in agreement with the earlier findings obtained on static graphs @xcite , it was confirmed that higher levels of cooperation are attainable on heterogeneous rather than homogeneous topologies , albeit that the distribution of strategies with respect to the degree of nodes forming the network is different . more precisely , cooperators were not found occupying the main hubs as on static graphs , but rather the nodes with an intermediate degree , thus indicating that the interplay between the local structure of the network and the hierarchical organization of cooperation is guided by the competition between the network growth and the evolutionary dynamics . notably , similar differences in the microscopic organization of the steady state composition of strategies were found on static scale - free networks when the payoffs were subjected to normalization @xcite , although the discrepancies reported by @xcite were solely the consequence of the coevolutionary growth process . indeed , in a recent study @xcite this coevolutionary rule has been studied further to confirm that the reported promotion of cooperation hinges not only on the final heterogeneity of the resulting network but also vitally on the particularities of the growth process itself . in addition , it was shown that under strongly payoff dominated growth conditions so - called super - hubs can emerge , which attract most of the links from the other nodes . although under such conditions cooperation was found thriving even for high temptations to defect , it was also noted that the robustness of these findings may be compromised , or at least not so strong as on static scale - free networks @xcite , due to the extreme heterogeneity of the star - like structures that can be brought about by the coevolutionary network growth . with the above we conclude the review of coevolutionary rules affecting the interaction network , either in terms of links players form with one another ( see section [ interactions ] above ) or the actual number of players participating in the game and the related network size . we proceed with the review of coevolutionary rules affecting individual properties of players , such as their teaching activity ( see section [ teaching ] ) , mobility ( see section [ mobility ] ) or age ( see section [ aging ] ) . note , however , that some of the above - reviewed coevolutionary rules already incorporated and/or affected personal features of players , such as for example the loyalty to their partners @xcite or influence @xcite , albeit always in conjunction with the coevolution of the interaction network . in what follows , the links and the size of the network are not affected by the coevolutionary rules unless explicitly noted otherwise . heterogeneity of players has been explored as a beneficial condition for cooperation in several forms @xcite . it can be easily accepted that players are not perfectly identical within a population . some have higher reputation or stronger influence than others . these differences can be detected via a biased direction of strategy adoptions . more precisely , players with higher reputation can spread their strategy more easily than if having an average or low reputation . in other words , their activity to teach a neighbor a new strategy is higher . it turned out that one of the individual quantities that influences the evolution of cooperation most effectively is the teaching activity @xcite . notably , teaching activity can also be referred to as the influence or reproduction rate @xcite , with the logical assumption that influential individuals are much more likely to reproduce , _ i.e. _ have a higher teaching activity , than players with low influence . teaching activity ( or the synonyms we pointed out ) can be introduced into the framework of evolutionary game theory via a modified fermi strategy adoption rule @xmath97 } \label{teachfermi}\ ] ] where @xmath98 characterizes the strength of influence ( or teaching activity ) of player @xmath22 . obviously , @xmath99 for all @xmath22 returns eq . [ fermi ] , whereby it is important to acknowledge that even if @xmath100 but the same for all @xmath22 the evolutionary outcome of strategy abundance remains the same , only the relaxation times lengthen . quenched ( non - evolving ) distributions of @xmath98 may promote cooperation even on homogenous lattice - type interaction topologies @xcite , while their application on complex networks reveals further that players with large teaching activity play a similar role as hubs in highly degree heterogenous graphs , such as scale - free networks @xcite . we refer the reader to the original works for further details on models using quenched distributions of @xmath98 , while here we proceed with the review of the two papers by @xcite that thus far considered the teaching activity as an evolving property of individual players . ) , which were found beneficial for the evolution of cooperation irrespective of the underlying interaction network.,width=283 ] in a social context the strategy adoption can be considered as learning from the more successful player . accepting this point of view , it is straightforward to consider a player who has successfully passed a strategy as the one having a higher reputation , and thus a higher teaching activity than other players . implementing this idea into a coevolutionary rule , we proposed that whenever player @xmath22 successfully passes its strategy the influence @xmath98 increases by a constant positive value @xmath101 according to @xmath102 @xcite . this coevolutionary rule is illustrated in fig . [ fig : rule_evol_teach ] . it should be noted that in this model the term ` reputation ' does not necessarily have a positive meaning , and thus may be in contradiction with the same term used elsewhere @xcite , where players who cooperated were awarded a higher reputation , which expectedly yielded higher levels of cooperation . moreover , for the sake of simplicity it was assumed that the evolution of @xmath103 stops as soon as the highest @xmath98 reaches @xmath58 @xcite . starting from a nonpreferential setup , initially assigning @xmath104 to every player irrespective of its strategy , it was found that there exists an optimal intermediate value of @xmath105 for which cooperation in the weak prisoner s dilemma as well as the @xmath20-parameterized snowdrift game ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) is enhanced best . it is in fact understandable that only an intermediate value of the increment @xmath106 was found warranting the optimal heterogeneity of the distribution of @xmath98 . namely , if @xmath106 is small then the values of @xmath98 simply increase homogeneously for all the players , while large values of @xmath106 result in a very quick halt of the coevolutionary process , either way resulting in a rather homogeneous distribution of the teaching activity . indeed , for both considered evolutionary games it was found that using moderate @xmath106 the final distribution of @xmath103 is exponential , in turn attributing the promotion of cooperation to the spontaneously emerging highly heterogenous plethora of differently influential players , as shown in fig . [ fig : teaching_dist ] . it was also shown that the effectiveness of the coevolutionary rule increases with the increasing uncertainty by strategy adoptions @xmath32 , and that the rule is robust to variations of the updating scheme . for example , it was verified that an alternative coevolutionary rule , by which @xmath98 was allowed to grow also past @xmath58 only that then @xmath98 was normalized according to @xmath107 ( @xmath108 being the maximal out of all @xmath98 at any given time ) to ensure that the teaching activity remained bounded to the unit interval , yielded similar results as the halted version . as a result of the coevolutionary rule introduced by @xcite . results were obtained for the weak prisoner s dilemma game staged on a square lattice . parameter values were : @xmath109 , @xmath110 and @xmath111.,width=283 ] a two - fold extension of the above work was made in @xcite . first , the coevolutionary rule was no longer considered to be strategy independent . note that in the preceding work @xmath102 was executed irrespective of the strategy of player @xmath22 . conversely , in @xcite this rule was applied separately either only for @xmath60 ( cooperators ) or only for @xmath112 ( defectors ) . second , the evolution of cooperation was examined in all three major social dilemma types defined on the @xmath21 parameter plane ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) . it was shown that both versions of the coevolutionary rule promote cooperation irrespective of the underlying game . opposite to intuitive reasoning , however , it was revealed that the exclusive coevolutionary promotion of players spreading defection is more beneficial for cooperation than the likewise direct promotion of cooperators . this was attributed to the fact that the coevolutionary promotion of defectors results in a larger fraction of players that are at least once affected by the coevolution , ultimately leading to a stronger segregation of the population into active ( those having @xmath113 ; note that the latter is the initial teaching activity assigned to all ) and virtually ( or comparably ) inactive ( those having @xmath114 ) players than the coevolutionary rule affecting cooperators . according to previous findings on the impact of static distributions of heterogeneity @xcite , the stronger expressed segregation was found directly responsible for the better promotion of cooperation when defectors rather than cooperators were subjected to coevolution . as we have already mentioned ( see _ e.g. _ section [ interactions ] ) , the time scale separation of coevolutionary processes may decisively affect the final output of such models . this was observed for the coevolution of teaching activity as well . more precisely , the time scale separation between the coevolution of teaching activity and strategy adoption can be tuned via the introduction of a parameter @xmath75 , defining the probability of increasing @xmath98 after a successful strategy pass . evidently , @xmath76 recovers the two originally proposed models while decreasing values of @xmath75 result in increasingly separated time scales . although the impact of @xmath75 was found depending somewhat on the type of the considered coevolutionary rule , in general , values of @xmath115 yielded insignificantly different results if compared to the @xmath76 case , thus indicating that the findings are robust to this type of alterations [ note that , as in @xcite , @xmath79 corresponds to the model without coevolution , and hence it is natural that as @xmath80 the promotion of cooperation was found fading ] . more precisely , however , since the fraction of cooperators was found increasing rather steadily with increasing values of @xmath75 , especially for the coevolutionary rule affecting defectors , it is optimal to keep the coevolutionary process affecting the teaching activity of players paced similarly fast as the main evolution of strategies , _ i.e. _ @xmath116 . we thus emphasize , that the above - reviewed coevolutionary models affecting the teaching activity have revealed that a simple ` successful become more successful ' principle can result in a heterogenous hierarchy of individual properties of players , such that optimal conditions for the evolution of cooperation are warranted . a similarly positive impact of heterogeneity on the spread of the cooperative strategy was also detected on heterogenous interaction networks @xcite , hence conceptually linking these two seemingly disjoint promoters of cooperation . it was acknowledged already by @xcite that players finding themselves in an unprofitable or undesirable situation frequently choose moving in order to free themselves from the negative consequences of that situation . accordingly , mobility can be considered as being a coevolutionary process in the sense of strategy and/or position alterations that ultimately determine the environment of players . although we were unable to locate coevolutionary terminology associated with mobility , we review here advances on this topic made during the last decade , and indeed consider movements of players during the evolution of strategies as being guided by rules of coevolution . the impact of diffusion on the outcome of a spatial prisoner s dilemma game via empty sites was questioned first by @xcite . therein , weak quenched disorder introduced in the form of empty sites on a square lattice was found beneficial for cooperation in the prisoner s dilemma game subject to the richest - following strategy update rule . in a follow - up paper @xcite the approach was extended to allow diffusion of players to nearest - neighbor empty sites with a certain probability . in particular , two ways of implementing the mobility were considered . first , each player was allowed to make an attempt at moving only after payoff accumulation and potential strategy adaptations were executed in parallel , or second , the moving was attempted prior to the evolution of strategies . importantly , the moving of players was considered to be brownian random walk like , _ i.e. _ diffusive , not relying on any type of explicit , genotypic or phenotypic assortment , and also being strategy - independent . due to this minimalist set - up the study provided rather general insights into possible effects of mobility . it was shown that mobility may indeed promote cooperation since it increases the ability of cooperator clusters to invade and overtake isolated defectors . on the other hand , mobility may also allow defectors to escape retaliation from a former partner and lead to stronger mixing in a population due to increasing interaction ranges of players , both of which are known to damp the evolutionary success of cooperators . thus , the impact of mobility in the form introduced by @xcite is not clear cut . as noted by the authors , further work on this is in progress . importantly , it was also emphasized that mobility may be subject to more deliberate coevolutionary rules , taking into account personal preferences of players , their strategies , as well as aims . an example of the latter was studied by @xcite , who introduced success - driven migration as a possible mediator leading towards cooperation in populations of selfish and unrelated individuals even under noisy conditions . in particular , success - driven migration [ see also @xcite ] was implemented so that , before the strategy adoption , player @xmath22 was allowed to explore potential payoffs that it would receive if occupying one of the empty sites in the migration neighborhood . the latter was typically restrained to nearest and next - nearest neighbors of player @xmath22 . if the potential payoff was found to be higher than in the current location , player @xmath22 moved to the site offering the highest payoff and , in case of several sites with the same payoff , to the closest one . on the other hand , if the current location offered the highest payoff among all the empty sites within the migration neighborhood , player @xmath22 did not move . it was found that this fairly simple and very plausible migration rule promotes cooperation in the prisoner s dilemma game on a square lattice ( with a fraction of empty sites to accommodate moving ) irrespective of the noise introduced to the system . in fact , three types of noise were considered to attest to the robustness of cooperation facilitation due to the introduced mobility of players . first was the introduction of mutation with probability @xmath75 , second was the introduction of random movements not considering the expected success ( payoff ) with probability @xmath20 , while third was the combination of the two . additionally , different update rules , adding birth and death processes , as well as introducing a small fraction of individuals defecting unconditionally were considered as well . irrespective of all these factors cooperation was found prevailing in a large region of the parameter space defining the prisoner s dilemma game if only the players were allowed to execute success - driven migration . recently , mobility is getting increasing attention as a means to promote cooperation in social dilemmas @xcite . in the model of @xcite two types of players are introduced , and a random walk of the influential individuals is possible irrespective of their strategies . the mobility of influential cooperators can have two positive impacts on the evolution of cooperation . first , they can spread the cooperative strategy among the non - influential players having a lower teaching activity , and second , when two influential players with opposite strategies meet , the cooperator can prevail and thus ensure an effective information exchange between cooperating hubs . note that the importance of the latter has as already been emphasized in section [ interactions ] ( see _ e.g. _ fig . [ fig : restricted ] and the pertaining text ) . as expected based on preceding works considering mobility as a coevolutionary process , the final outcome of the competition between mobile , and thus influential , cooperators and defectors is highly sensitive to changes in the speed of moving . when the latter is too high the influential cooperators can not benefit from their cooperative neighborhoods because they abandon them too soon . similarly , influential defectors eschew the negative feedback effect originating from defecting neighbors ( note that @xmath56 links are nonprofitable for both players ) because they leave them too fast as well . indeed , high moving speeds generate conditions mimicking the well - mixed regime which is damning for cooperators . thus , only moderate mobility of influential players has been found effectively supporting the evolution of cooperation . we refer the reader to the original works for further details , noting that mobility seems a promising avenue of research for future explorations of coevolutionary rules . as the last coevolutionary process we consider aging . indeed , aging is always present , tailoring our interactions with others and postulating a finite lifespan during which we are able to exercise them . it thus seems natural to consider aging as an integral part of every evolutionary development , and certainly evolutionary games constitute a prime example thereof . nonetheless , studies taking aging explicitly into account within this realm of research are few . @xcite recently noted that lifespan might play an important role in the evolution of cooperation , albeit their study focused on the coevolution of choosiness ( see also section [ related ] ) rather than age . moreover , concepts similar to aging were recently introduced in the voter model @xcite , showing that age and memory - dependent transition rates can have a positive effect on consensus formation . a recent work focusing on aging within evolutionary games is due to @xcite , and in the following we present a summary of the proposed coevolutionary rules for aging as well as their main implications . the newborn is not supported by its ancestor ( the @xmath56 link is detrimental for both ) , and hence a neighboring cooperator with high age can conquer the site of the newborn defector . this procedure occurs repeatedly , ultimately resulting in a practically blocked ( more precisely an oscillating ) front between @xmath45 and @xmath46 regions ( left panel ) . importantly , a similar blocking is not present around old ( and thus influential ) cooperators because their cooperator - cooperator links help newborn cooperators to achieve higher age , in turn supporting the overall maintenance of cooperative behavior ( right panel ) . in both panels the size of players is proportional to their age ( _ i.e. _ their teaching activity ) . dashed ( solid ) arrows denote attempted ( successful ) strategy adoption processes.,width=283 ] since age is often associated with knowledge and wisdom an individual is able to accumulate over the years , it was introduced through a simple tunable function that maps age to teaching activity ( see section [ teaching ] ) of the corresponding player . more precisely , @xmath98 in eq . [ teachfermi ] was related to the integer age @xmath117 in accordance with the function @xmath118 , where @xmath119 , denoting the maximal possible age of a player , serves the bounding of @xmath98 to the unit interval , and @xmath120 determines the level of heterogeneity in the @xmath121 mapping . evidently , @xmath122 corresponds to the classical ( homogeneous ) spatial model with @xmath99 characterizing all players , @xmath123 ensures that @xmath98 and @xmath124 have the same distribution , whereas values of @xmath125 impose a power law distribution of strategy transfer capability . although different age distributions of players were considered also as quenched system states , the focus was on the study of aging as a coevolutionary process , entailing death and newborns . two rules were considered separately , both starting with @xmath124 being assigned randomly from a uniform distribution within the interval @xmath126 $ ] to all players , and subsequently increasing all @xmath124 by @xmath58 after each full monte carlo step . also inherent to both was that @xmath124 was set to zero for all players whose age exceeded @xmath127 ( effectively this means that a newborn follows the dead player ) . the difference was in the way age of players that have just adopted a new strategy from one of their neighbors was handled . in the coevolutionary model a their age was left unchanged , while in the coevolutionary model b they were considered as newborns , _ i.e. _ as soon as player @xmath22 adopted a new strategy its age was set to @xmath128 . notably , rules a and b can be interpreted rather differently . from a purely biological viewpoint the more successful player replaces the neighbor with its own offspring , who therefore initially has a limited strategy transfer capability , which corresponds to rule b. on the other hand , especially in social systems , strategy adoptions may not necessarily involve death and newborns , but may indicate solely a change of heart , preference , or way of thinking , whereby this situation corresponds to rule a. nevertheless , newborns in a social context can be considered those that changed their strategy recently , and therefore have a low reputation initially . interestingly , it was found that the small difference between coevolutionary rules a and b may have significant consequences for the evolution of cooperation . foremost , it was found that rule b promotes cooperation remarkably better than rule a. however , the difference could not be explained by the resulting heterogeneity of the distributions of @xmath98 , for example via a similar reasoning as introduced by @xcite , since both rules return power law distributed values with rather similar slopes ( @xmath129 for a and @xmath130 for b ) . in fact , it was shown that the coevolutionary rule b introduces a new powerful mechanism for promotion of cooperation acting solely on a microscopic player - to - player basis , and as such is thus virtually not detectable by statistical methods assessing the heterogeneity of the system . the mechanism was found relying on a highly selective promotion of cooperator - cooperator and defector - defector pairs , which hinders influential defectors ( those having @xmath124 close to @xmath127 ) to spread their strategy effectively across the spatial grid . in particular , rule b always leads to influential players being surrounded by newborns . thereby it is important to note that whenever an old defector , with a high strategy transfer capability @xmath98 , is imitated by one of the neighbors , further spreading of defection is blocked because the newborn defector has no chance to pass strategy @xmath46 further . at that time a neighboring cooperator with high age can strike back and conquer the site of the newborn defector . as a result the whole procedure starts again , which ultimately results in a practically blocked ( more precisely an oscillating ) front between @xmath45 and @xmath46 regions . crucially , a similar blocking mechanism is not present around old ( and thus influential ) cooperators because their cooperator - cooperator links help newborn cooperators to achieve higher age , in turn supporting the overall maintenance of cooperative behavior . the main differences in the propagation of different strategy pair - ups are summarized in fig . [ fig : blocked ] , while an example of the resulting spatial distribution of players is presented in fig . [ fig : aging_dist ] . in the latter a player is considered as influential if its age exceeds that of any of its neighbors by at least @xmath131 ( qualitatively similar snapshots can be obtained by choosing different thresholds as well ) . square lattice , obtained by considering players who have adopted a new strategy as newborns [ coevolutionary rule b in @xcite ] . full black ( open green ) boxes depict influential defectors ( cooperators ) while yellow and white are all other non - influential defectors and cooperators , respectively . the snapshot demonstrates clearly that the propagation of defectors is blocked in space as a consequence of age - related teaching activity.,width=264 ] in model a the situation is significantly different since cooperative domains , created around old players with high @xmath98 , can not prevail long . namely , the central cooperator who built up the cooperative domain eventually dies , and the arriving newborn with an accordingly low strategy transfer capability simply can not maintain this domain further , thus giving defectors an opportunity to win it over . as a consequence of the dynamical origin of the observed cooperation - promoting mechanism brought about by rule b , it is expected that it will work in other cases too , for example when the interaction graph is characterized by a different topology , by other evolutionary games , or by separated time scales between aging and strategy adaptations , as was shown already by @xcite . finally , it is important to note that the observed cooperation - promoting mechanism relying on a dynamical process is robust even if non - monotonous mappings between @xmath124 and @xmath98 are considered ( the oldest individuals may not necessarily be the most influential ) . indeed , the promotion of cooperation remains intact as long as the plausible assumption that very young players should have none or very little influence is adhered to . similarly as mobility reviewed in section [ mobility ] , we note that aging as a coevolutionary process seems very liable to further studies as well , and we hope this brief summary succeeded in wetting the appetite for them . aside from thus far reviewed coevolutionary rules , there exist examples @xcite we were unable to classify into the above subsections . without going into much details as it exceeds the scope of this mini review , we briefly describe some of these related approaches , but refer the reader to the original works for further details . @xcite , for example , studied the simultaneous evolution of learning rules and strategies , whereby the former were determined endogenously based on the success of strategies observed in the neighborhood of any given player . it was shown that endogenous learning rules put more weight on the proper understanding of each player s own experience rather than on the experience of an observed neighbor . coevolving learning rules were recently considered also by @xcite , showing that imitation is frequently displaced by replication , in turn leading to a rapid decrease of cooperation in the spatial prisoner s dilemma game . on the other hand , imitation was found to be superior to global but stochastic imitation , thereby facilitating cooperative behavior . the coevolutionary selection of strategy adoption rules was consider by @xcite as well , where the uncertainty in the fermi function ( see eq . [ fermi ] ) was subject to evolution as a player - specific property . in particular , instead of a single @xmath32 value authors introduced different @xmath132 values where @xmath133 , which were then assigned randomly to the players . as we have already noted in section [ games ] , the uncertainty by strategy adoptions can originate from different sources , ranging from unpredictable variations in payoffs to errors in the decision making @xcite . the parameter @xmath32 , however , can also be considered as characterizing the willingness of a player to risk a payoff quantity during a strategy change . therefore , by using different values of @xmath32 , not only the better strategy but also the way of strategy adoption can be the subject of an imitation process . values ( @xmath134 ) demonstrate the selection of the most appropriate strategy adoption uncertainty @xmath135 ( promoting cooperation best ) , as indicated by the red solid line . this directly implies the spontaneous selection of an optimal strategy adoption rule within the scope of the fermi function ( see eq . [ fermi ] ) , as reported by @xcite . dashed blue lines depicted the extinction of the other @xmath132 values . initially , @xmath136 different @xmath132 values were distributed on the square lattice of size @xmath137 . the temptation to defect was @xmath109.,width=283 ] accordingly , aside from the fact that player @xmath28 could adopt the strategy of player @xmath22 according to eq . [ fermi ] ( @xmath138 ) , an additional independent trail with the same probability was made also for the adoption of the imitation rule ( @xmath139 ) . it was shown that , if the system is seeded by random initial conditions , the proposed coevolutionary rule drives the system towards a state where a single @xmath135 value ( only one of the initial @xmath132 values ) prevails . this final strategy adoption uncertainty is closely related with the parameter value warranting the highest cooperation level if a given value of @xmath32 is used for all players at a certain value of the temptation to defect @xmath77 ( see fig . [ fig : schematic_games ] ) . naturally , the prevailing @xmath135 value thus depends also on the topology of the interaction network . the selection process is illustrated in fig . [ fig : n20_time ] , where @xmath136 different @xmath132 values were initially assigned to the players @xmath140 . summarizing the main observation , it was shown that a darwinian selection rule affecting a model parameter can spontaneously lead to the prevalence of the value that ensures an optimal level of cooperation in the system . for further details we refer the reader to the original work of @xcite . the evolution of altruistic behavior under coevolutionary rules was studied also in what can be considered more explicitly biologically or even humanly motivated settings @xcite . for example , internal norms , being a pattern of behavior enforced in part by internal sanctions , such as shame , guilt and loss of self - esteem , were found to provide support for the evolution of altruistic norms , and moreover , via a gene - culture coevolution argument an explanation was provided as to why individually fitness - reducing internal norms are likely to be prosocial rather than socially harmful @xcite . although mentioned already in section [ aging ] , the study of @xcite in fact focuses on the coevolution of choosiness , the later relying on cooperativeness being used by other individuals as a choice criterion . in such a setting competition to be more generous than others can emerge , and in this case the evolution of cooperation between unrelated individuals can be driven by a positive feedback between increasing levels of cooperativeness and choosiness . it was shown that , in situations where individuals have the opportunity to engage in repeated pairwise interactions , the evolution of cooperation depends critically on the amount of behavioral variation that is being maintained in the population by processes such as mutation . finally , we note that @xcite investigated the evolution of cooperation in a so - called nongrowth dynamic network model with a death - birth dynamics based on tournament selection , @xcite as well as @xcite studied the coevolution of group structure rather than graph structure in the context of generalized reciprocity , while @xcite considered evolving heterogeneous games as means to sustain cooperation . interestingly , in the later study the players had individual payoff elements assigned to them for calculating their final payoffs . accordingly , within the realm of the proposed coevolutionary rule a player could adopt not only the strategy of the neighbor but also its individual payoff matrix elements . it was found that if starting with a random heterogeneous distribution of payoffs , eventually only a small number of definite payoff matrices remained while the others went ` extinct ' . on the other hand , if the initial rank of individual payoff elements agreed with those constituting social dilemma games , the prevailing one was found to be the stag - hunt game . considering the latter result in the light of findings reported within the evolving adoption rules model by @xcite , it is possible to raise the question if coevolutionary rules as a selection mechanism can spontaneously drive the system into a state where mutual cooperation ensures the maximal average payoff . indeed , further studies are necessary to clarify this issue . in sum , there are few boundaries to imagination when considering what coevolutionary rules might affect , and certainly , it seems like all facets of existence can be brought into consideration . as we hope the above mini review on coevolutionary games clearly shows , coevolution is certainly a promising concept to follow , as it constitutes the most natural upgrade of evolutionary games in the sense that not only do the strategies evolve in time , but so does the environment , and indeed many other factors that in turn affect back the outcome of the evolution of strategies . some of these coevolutionary processes are of a finite duration , and thus on their own do not necessarily affect the outcome of evolutionary games but do this only indirectly due to the environment that they produce , while others are lasting , introducing dynamical alterations that affect the evolution of cooperation on a continuous basis . in the future , it should be of interest to further elaborate on the question whether coevolution itself may promote cooperation by introducing dynamical mechanisms , or if mainly the final outcome of a coevolutionary process , if it exists , is the one vital for the sustenance of cooperation . often , however , it is the interplay of both that facilitates the promotion of cooperation , as it was already shown in some of the works . it should also be considered which coevolutionary processes end sooner or later , and which are those that at least in principle should last forever . for example , the growth of a city can be considered something that has a finite duration due to environmental constrains , while aging , on the other hand , is a natural ingredient of every living organism , and as such it should only make sense to consider it evolving permanently . although social dilemmas may emerge at different levels of human and animal interactions , their occurrence is by no means limited to these examples . the applicability of the concept of evolutionary games extends across the whole of social and natural sciences , with examples ranging from the rna virus @xcite , atp - producing pathways @xcite and biochemical systems @xcite , to traffic congestion @xcite and climate change @xcite , to name but a few . in this sense coevolutionary rules should be applied to evolutionary games in the broadest possible sense , with specially adapted motivation fitting to the research avenue of the main evolutionary process . moreover , while focusing predominantly on resolving social dilemmas , coevolutionary rules have thus far not been considered for many other game types , as for example the public goods game , the ultimatum game or the rock - scissors - paper game . these gaps should be interesting to fill as well , in particular when striving towards universal concepts underlying cooperation in the broadest possible sense . the authors acknowledge support from the slovenian research agency ( grant z1 - 2032 ) , the hungarian national research fund ( grant k-73449 ) , the bolyai research grant , and the slovene - hungarian bilateral incentive ( grant bi - hu/09 - 10 - 001 ) . chen , y. , qin , s .- , yu , l. , zhang , s. , 2008 . emergence of synchronization induced by the interplay between two prisoner s dilemma games with volunteering in small - world networks . e 77 , 032103 . helbing , d. , schnhof , m. , stark , h .- u . , holyst , j. a. , 2005 . how individuals learn to take turns : emergence of alternating cooperation in a congestion game and the prisoner s dilemma . adv . complex syst . 8 , 87116 . holme , p. , trusina , a. , kim , b. j. , minnhagen , p. , 2003 . prisoner s dilemma in real - world acquaintance networks : spikes and quasiequilibria induced by the interplay between structure and dynamics . e 68 , 030901 . kim , b. j. , trusina , a. , holme , p. , minnhagen , p. , chung , j. s. , choi , m. y. , 2002 . dynamic instabilities induced by asymmetric influence : prisoner s dilemma game in small - world networks . e 66 , 021907 . milinski , m. , sommerfeld , r. d. , krambeck , h .- j . , reed , f. a. , marotzke , j. , 2008 . the collective - risk social dilemma and the prevention of simulated danderous climate change . natl . acad . usa 105 , 22912294 . pacheco , j. m. , santos , f. c. , 2005 . network dependence of the dilemmas of cooperation . in : mendes , j. f. f. ( ed . ) , science of complex networks : from biology to the intertnet and www , aip conf . aip , melville , ny , pp . 90100 . zimmermann , m. g. , eguluz , v. m. , miguel , m. s. , 2001 . cooperation , adaption and the emergence of leadership . in : zimmermann , j. b. , kirman , a. ( eds . ) , economics and heterogeneous interacting agents . springer , berlin , pp . 7386 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: for atomization energies and geometries , density functional theory ( dft ) constitutes a cost - effective alternative to wavefunction - based _ ab initio _ methods , being capable of accuracies on the order of a few kcal / mol and a few picometer , respectively , if basis sets of polarized triple zeta quality are employed@xcite . as a result of this astonishing success , especially considering the modest computational cost of dft methods , a variety of new applications are now being explored@xcite , including , very recently , the calculation of molecular anharmonic potential energy surfaces @xcite . anharmonic potential energy surfaces ( see refs.@xcite for initial pioneering studies at the scf and cisd level ) allow for the prediction of molecular vibration - rotation spectra that can be compared directly to experiment , obviating the need to make estimations or approximations for the effect of anharmonicity . ccsd(t)/@xmath0 anharmonic force fields can achieve accuracies on the order of 10 @xmath1 or better for fundamentals ( e.g. @xcite and references therein ) , and even greater accuracy is achievable if still larger basis sets and corrections for inner - shell correlation are considered@xcite . + dft anharmonic force fields for small molecules have recently been the subject of two validation studies@xcite . our own validation study@xcite suggested that , for fundamental frequencies , an rms accuracy of about 18 @xmath1 can be attained when using the b97 - 1 functional with sufficiently large basis sets . the question arises as to how capable dft is to treat medium - sized organic molecules in this fashion . particularly relevant here is the study the study of miani et al.@xcite on the fundamental frequencies of benzene , which employed the b3lyp@xcite functional with the tz2p ( triple - zeta plus double polarization ) basis set . this paper , as well as a more recent study of furan , pyrrole and thiophene@xcite , in fact yielded even more accurate results on these medium - sized organic systems than suggested by the small - molecule validation studies cited above . + the azabenzenes are obtained by systematically replacing ch moieties in benzene by nitrogen atoms . numerous experimental spectra of these compounds are available in the literature , ranging from mono - azabenzene ( pyridine ) to 1,2,4,5-tetraazabenzene ( s - tetrazine ) . pentazine is quite elusive@xcite ; the equally elusive n@xmath2 ( hexazine or hexaazabenzene ) molecule has been the subject of extensive theoretical studies@xcite : at the ccsd(t)/cc - pvtz level , the hexazine ( hexaazabenzene ) structure undergoes distortion from the idealized @xmath3 ring to a @xmath4 geometry , which is a local minimum situated some 23 kcal / mol above the @xmath5 diazide global minimum@xcite . straka recently made the interesting suggestion that cyclic n@xmath2 may form very stable m(@xmath6-n@xmath2 ) complexes with m = ti , zr , hf , th@xcite . in practice , nine molecules are relevant to the present study : the parent benzene molecule , pyridine , pyridazine , pyrimidine , pyrazine , 1,2,3-triazine , 1,2,4-triazine , 1,2,5-triazine ( _ sym_-triazine ) and 1,2,4,5-tetrazine ( s - tetrazine ) . all molecules are displayed in figure 1 . + azabenzene skeletons serve as building blocks in nature , e.g. , pyridine in pyridixol ( vitamin b@xmath2 ) , pyridazine and pyrimidine in pteridine , itself found in folic acid ( vitamin vitamin b@xmath7 ) and riboflavin ( vitamin b@xmath8 ) . moreover the four dna bases are derivates of pyrimidine ( c , t ) and of purine ( a , g ) itself a pyrimidine - imidazole fused ring system . for these reasons , azabenzene - like compounds figure in drug design , e.g. the reverse transcriptase inhibitors azt ( contains pyrimidine ) or nevirapine ( contains pyridine ) . derivatives of pyridazine have been found to have potential therapeutic or plant growth inhibitory effects . + quite different applications include melamine - based plastics ( melamine is a derivative of s - triazine ) and the potential use of s - tetrazine in molecular data storage applications ( one of the relaxation mechanisms of the @xmath9 state leads to 2 hcn+n@xmath8.@xcite ) . + innes , ross and moomaw ( irm throughout this paper ) published a compilation and critical review of experimental vibration spectroscopic data current to 1988@xcite . one of us ( with c. van alsenoy ) carried out a harmonic - only b3lyp / cc - pvtz study of the vibrational frequencies and geometries.@xcite the limitations of this approach are obvious . + in the present contribution , we will consider dft _ anharmonic _ force fields and anharmonic vibrational spectra which are directly comparable to experiment for the azabenzenes , and demonstrate their power as a spectroscopic assignment tool for medium - sized organic molecules . in our validation study@xcite , we considered a wide variety of exchange - correlation functionals , as well as convergence in terms of the basis set and the integration grids ( both kohn - sham , ks , and coupled perturbed kohn - sham ) . especially for organic molecules , we found the best performance to be delivered by the b97 - 1 functional , which is handy s reparametrization@xcite of becke s 1997 hybrid functional@xcite . satisfactory basis set convergence was generally found to be achieved with the tz2p basis set@xcite . this is therefore the functional / basis set combination employed for the present study . we found@xcite results for anharmonic force field calculations to be exceedingly dependent on the ks integration grid , much less so on the cpks grid . for the present study , we ended up using a ( 200,974 ) grid , that is , the direct product of a 200-point euler - maclaurin radial grid with a 974-point lebedev angular grid . for the cpks steps , we employed a ( 75,194 ) grid , which considerably reduced the overall computational cost . neither grid was pruned . the quartic force fields were calculated by numerical central differences ( in rectilinear normal coordinates ) of analytical second derivatives , using a stand - alone driver program adapted from the cadpac electronic structure program system@xcite . the actual dft second derivative calculations were done using the gaussian 98 rev . a11 program package@xcite . the step size in a numerical derivatives calculation always represents a compromise between discretization error and roundoff error . based on experience , we determined the step size as a functions of both the absolute value of the harmonic frequency associated with the normal coordinate involved , and the associated reduced mass ( @xmath10 ) : @xmath11 in order to reduce roundoff error as much as possible , the ks and cpks equations were basically converged to machine precision . to calculate this factor , both the reduced mass of the mode @xmath12 and the eigenvalues of the normalisation matrix @xmath13 are needed . the last part of equation 1 , depending on the harmonic frequencies @xmath14 , additionally ensures that each displaced geometry has approximately the same energy difference to the minimum geometry . + in this manner , we obtain a complete cubic force field , as well as all the diagonal and semidiagonal quartic force constants . these are sufficient for second - order rovibrational perturbation theory analyses@xcite , which were carried out using the spectro@xcite and polyad@xcite programs developed in the cambridge group and at weizmann , respectively . the parent molecule of our series , benzene ( figure 1a ) , has been the subject of a few previous anharmonic force field studies , two at the scf / dzp level@xcite , and a very recent one at the b3lyp / tz2p level@xcite . an extensive experimental literature exists on the subject ( see refs.@xcite for reviews ) : high resolution data are available for many of the fundamentals , and all the assignments can be regarded as conclusive . ( an analysis of the b3lyp / cc - pvtz normal modes of benzene and the azabenzenes in terms of pulay s redundant internal coordinates can be found in table 17 of ref.@xcite . ) experimentally obtaining harmonic frequencies for a molecule this large , even with such high symmetry , is a nearly impossible task . in table [ tab1 ] we compare computed harmonic frequencies with selected prior calculations ( in particular ccsd(t)/@xmath0 data@xcite ) , as well as several sets of experimentally derived data . the first such set are the ` @xmath15 ' estimates of handy , murray and amos ( hma)@xcite , themselves obtained as averages of an empirical estimate by goodman , ozkabak , and thakur ( got)@xcite and their own combination of experimental fundamentals with the scf / dzp computed anharmonicities of maslen et al.@xcite . the second set are derived from the experimental fundamentals and a new scf / dzp anharmonic analysis by handy and willetts ( hw)@xcite . the third set is derived from the experimental fundamentals and the b3lyp / tz2p anharmonicities@xcite , and is expected to be the most reliable . + both sets of dft numbers compare about equally well with the ccsd(t ) data . the c - h stretching frequencies are underestimated by about 20 @xmath1 , while all other frequencies are being reproduced very accurately . ( as an aside , we note that the c h underestimation problem also occurs@xcite at the mller - plesset perturbation theory ( mp2 ) level . ) although the c h stretches are reproduced marginally worse by the b97 - 1 functional ( 3 @xmath1 ) compared to the reference ccsd(t)/@xmath0 values , the overall performance is improved : the mean absolute error decreases from 9.3 ( b3lyp ) to 6.5 ( b97 - 1 ) @xmath1 , and the rms deviation from 10.6 ( b3lyp ) to 9.6 ( b97 - 1 ) . the smaller decrease for the rms error ( compared to the mean absolute error ) can be attributed to the greater proportional weight given to larger errors . when excluding the c - h stretching frequencies , the rms errors decrease to 8.4 ( b3lyp ) and 4.3 @xmath1 ( b97 - 1 ) . considering the computational cost of density functional theory , the b3lyp results are already of spectacular compared to the reference _ ab initio _ data . the b97 - 1 functional , however , reduces the rms error of the non c - h stretching frequencies by an additional 50% . + both functionals yield excellent agreement with experiment for the fundamental frequencies ( table [ tab2 ] ) . the experimental data were taken from the earlier compilation of got@xcite and from more recent gas - phase measurements@xcite . the two sets of experimental data agree very well with each other , except for @xmath16 and @xmath17 which are involved in strong fermi resonances . to obtain the b97 - 1/tz2p fundamentals , we had to take the following fermi resonances into consideration : @xmath18 and @xmath19 ( with the deperturbed frequency @xmath19 at 3018 @xmath1 and the combination at 2947 @xmath20 ) , @xmath21 and @xmath17 ( unperturbed @xmath22 at 3040 and the combination band at 3082 @xmath20 ) , @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( with the unperturbed frequencies at 3064 and 3020 @xmath20 ) , and @xmath25 and @xmath16 ( with @xmath16 ( unperturbed ) at 1600 , @xmath25 at 1603 @xmath20 ) . + interestingly , because of the small differences in the harmonic frequencies between the b3lyp / tz2p and the b97 - 1/tz2p calculations and the different force field , now new fermi resonances are predicted . furthermore , the fundamentals affected by these resonances are the ones which differ the most when using the b3lyp or b97 - 1 functional . because of the fermi resonances , the difference between different functionals and methods becomes more important than on the harmonic level of approximation . the results of both functionals compared to experiment are , however , very similar , with mean absolute errors ( compared to the latest experimental results of miani et al.@xcite ) of 9.4 ( b3lyp ) and 8.3 ( b97 - 1 ) @xmath1 and rms errors of 17.0 and 13.7 @xmath1 , respectively . again , all frequencies are very well described with the exception of the c - h stretches , which are underestimated by 1630 @xmath1 ( discounting @xmath24 which is severely perturbed by resonances ) . without the c - h stretches , the mean absolute errors are reduced to 3.7 ( b3lyp ) and 3.9 ( b97 - 1 ) @xmath1 and the rms errors to 4.8 ( b3lyp ) and 4.5 @xmath1 ( b97 - 1 ) . hence , while clearly better for harmonic frequencies , the b97 - 1 functional is only slightly better for predicting the fundamental frequencies of benzene . nevertheless , the accuracy obtained by density functional theory , which yields rms errors of less than 5 @xmath1 for non c - h stretching frequencies , is very good . + in the third column , we added the b97 - 1/tz2p anharmonic corrections to the ccsd(t)/ano4321 harmonic frequencies of ref.@xcite , in order to see how such a ` hybrid ' ab initio - dft approach would perform . the principal improvement seen is for the c h stretches , which are thus all bought into the range of the experimental values , except for @xmath26 , which is in resonance with @xmath23 as discussed above . when discounting c h stretching frequencies , the improvement compared to a pure b97 - 1/tz2p calculation is quite modest , to 3.1 @xmath1 for the mean absolute error and to 4.1 @xmath1 for the rms error . the corresponding error statistics including c h stretching frequencies change rather more significantly , to a mean absolute error of 4.0 @xmath1 and an rms error of 7.4 @xmath1 . + summarizing , b97 - 1/tz2p is likely to be a useful tool for analysis of vibrational spectra ( and verification of their assignments ) of aromatic organic molecules in general and of the azabenzene series in particular . pyridine being the simplest azabenzene ( figure 1b ) and the closest to the parent molecule , we may anticipate similar accuracy as for benzene . as expected for this chemically important species , many experimental spectra are available , in both liquid and gas phases . most of the experimental results and the latest experimental assignments are summarized by klots@xcite . the computed and observed vibrational frequencies are presented in table [ tab3 ] . as expected , the c - h stretching frequencies are not well described . here , they are also heavily perturbed , and , considering performance for the corresponding bands in benzene , our method may not be sufficiently accurate to assist in the experimental assignment . thus , although we will attempt to elaborate on the c - h stretching frequencies for most azabenzenes , the results are more tentative . additionally , a small change in the original unperturbed fundamental frequencies will cause large changes in the perturbed frequencies . nevertheless , the two asymmetric stretches @xmath27 and @xmath19 do not follow the general trend of being underestimated by 2040 @xmath1 . while the perturbed @xmath27 is close to the experimental value , @xmath19 differs by 70 @xmath1 . especially the latter appears too large to be accounted for merely by deficiencies in our dft calculation . here , the severe fermi resonance seems to be responsible for this assignment , as its deperturbed value is at 3021 @xmath1 . this mode is resonating with ( deperturbed frequencies given ) @xmath27 at 3053 @xmath1 , @xmath28 at 3015 @xmath1 and @xmath29 at 3054 @xmath1 , with the perturbed @xmath28 now appearing at 3023 @xmath1 . it appears that the latter value is more in line with experiment , and that perhaps this assignment might be more reasonable . nevertheless , some caution is appropriate as the c h harmonic stretching frequencies are not as well described by dft as the remaining modes . large basis set ccsd(t ) harmonic frequencies would be helpful here , but would require inordinate amounts of cpu time . + another picture emerges for the non c - h frequency modes . here , we primarily compare to the medium resolution raman vapor data of klots ( klots2)@xcite : their assignments seem to be in line with most other experiments , although they differ from the most recent data obtained by partal et al.@xcite . comparing to these latter inelastic neutron scattering ( ins ) data , however , amounts to comparing apples and oranges , as the ins data are based on further refinement of a dft computed _ harmonic _ force field by maximizing agreement between simulated and observed ins spectral . the pseudo - harmonic frequencies from the refined force field correspond neither to true harmonic nor to true fundamental frequencies in effect , they are neither fish nor fowl . + we can confirm the assignment of klots@xcite of @xmath30 to the lower value of 1053 @xmath1 . difficult assignments seem to result from the fermi resonances for both @xmath31 and @xmath32 , since these are the only fundamentals which give errors of 10 @xmath1 or larger . the deperturbed mode of @xmath31 at 1578 @xmath1 resonates with @xmath33 at 1593 @xmath1 resulting in perturbed modes at 1575 and 1596 @xmath1 . klots may have misassigned the latter band to @xmath31 rather than @xmath33 . @xmath32 , on the other hand , seems to be very difficult to assign from experimental data because of its depolarized character . the problem is further exacerbated as @xmath32 is located at the shoulder of @xmath34 . although @xmath32 is involved in a fermi resonance , it is probably not the source of the disagreement with , since its unperturbed frequency at 1241 @xmath1 resonates with @xmath35 at 1282 @xmath1 , resulting in bands at 1237 and 1289 @xmath1 . with the exception of these two strongly perturbed bands ( @xmath31 and @xmath32 ) , the agreement between experiment and theory can only be described as stunning for bands other than c - h stretches . for the latter , probably only a full ccsd(t ) force field can resolve the assignment . even when including @xmath31 and @xmath32 ( but excluding all c - h stretching frequencies ) , the mean absolute error for the computed values compared to the experimental data of klots@xcite is 3.6 @xmath1 and the rms error is 5.3 @xmath1 ; without @xmath31 and @xmath32 they are reduced to 2.7 and 3.8 @xmath1 , respectively . + the double - harmonic infrared intensities are in good agreement with the b3lyp / cc - pvtz values@xcite and in reasonable agreement with the experimental numbers . even here , the c - h stretches differ , probably not only because of anharmonic contributions and fermi resonances , but also because of the poor description of these modes by dft . still , the excellent performance seen for benzene results is repeated for pyridine . pyridazine ( figure 1c ) has been of particular interest in the last couple of years @xcite . a large body of experimental data is available , generally measured in the gas phase but when certain modes were unavailable , the authors of ref.@xcite substituted their own liquid or solid phase measurements in order to get a full complement of frequencies . all of the spectra have been assigned with the aid of scaled hartree - fock , mp2 , blyp or b3lyp harmonic force fields using small basis sets . some of them have their force fields fitted to match the experimental data . despite the large amount of data , huge discrepancies exist , as shown in table [ tab4 ] . this seems to be especially true for the out - of - plane modes where experimental assignments and values seem almost arbitrary . for @xmath36 , for example , the experimental numbers range from 765 to 949 @xmath1 , and even the two most recent numbers appear at opposite ends of this range . these assignments have been done using different methods and scaling techniques , since no reliable theoretical data were available at the time . + the same problem with the c - h stretches that was encountered for benzene and pyridine occurs for pyridazine as well ; the situation is further complicated since the experimental data differs and thus we can not assign the frequencies of the experiment . despite the discrepancies between various experimental numbers , all the c - h stretches appear plausible within the error range of our method . + as the ins data set dramatically varies from the remainder of the experimental data , and because it did not appear to be reliable for pyridine , it was excluded from our analysis , although it is reported in table [ tab4 ] for completeness . + since such a large amount of experimental data is available , it is best to discuss each mode separately , starting with the in - plane modes . * for @xmath37 , all experiments except the first of ref.@xcite agree on an assignment to the 1570 @xmath1 band . our results , however , would seem to indicate that the assignment around 1555 @xmath1 might be more plausible . * the same occurs for @xmath31 . experimental values of refs.@xcite cluster around 1440 @xmath1 , with refs . @xcite around 1415 @xmath1 . our calculation clearly favors the former assignment . * for @xmath24 , significant differences between experiments of refs.@xcite and the computed value of 1145 @xmath1 can be found . the experimental results are thus untenable in light of this huge discrepancy of more than a hundred @xmath1 , and only ref.@xcite proposes an assignment of 1160 @xmath1 , which still appears to be on the high side . * for @xmath34 , most experiments have assignments around the computed 1157 @xmath1 ; however , ref.@xcite assigned this mode to 1120 @xmath1 because of their previous assignment . our calculated @xmath24 and @xmath34 nearly coincide , * for @xmath38 , all experimental datasets are in agreement with each other and our calculations . considering the generally small anharmonicities for this type of vibrations , the discrepancy of 40 @xmath1 between the computed @xmath39 and the observed @xmath40 seems to be a bit on the large side . the experimental assignment may have been complicated by the band s position in an ir band envelope going from 960 to 980 @xmath1@xcite . * as with @xmath24 , the experimental assignment for @xmath41 of vazquez et al.@xcite differs from the other obtained fundamentals , and is the only one that can be confirmed by our calculations . * for @xmath16 , only refs.@xcite differ from the computed values , while for @xmath42 , the experimental assignment of stidham and tucci@xcite both in the ir and the raman phase appear doubtful . @xmath43 agrees nicely with all experiments . * for @xmath32 and @xmath22 , the same assignment problems that we experienced for @xmath24 and @xmath34 seem to have occurred ; while most experiments assign values above 1100 @xmath1 to @xmath32 , only vazquez et al.@xcite seem to give the correct assignment . this results , however , in the value of @xmath22 thus ending up a bit on the low side , and only the value of ref.@xcite ends up close to our calculated number . the same seems to have happened to @xmath30 , where only ref.@xcite is in line with our calculations . hence , for the in - plane modes , the data set of vazquez et al.@xcite appears to be most reliable , excluding @xmath37 and @xmath34 ( which appear to be dubious assignments ) and perhaps @xmath40 and @xmath22 . * for the out - of - plane modes , the experimental assignment appears to be even more problematic . for @xmath44 , all experiments differ by 20 @xmath1 , and are either found at 998 or 842 @xmath1 . both assignments appear to be unlikely , since the harmonic b97 - 1 frequency is at 981 @xmath1 , which would put the fundamental too low for 998 and definitely way too high for assignment to the 842 @xmath1 band . * for @xmath45 , all experimental assignments are around the computed 751 @xmath1 , while for @xmath46 , all the experiments appear to yield assignments higher than our computed fundamental of 362 @xmath1 . * based on our data , all the @xmath47 symmetry modes ( @xmath48 through @xmath49 ) should probably be re - examined , since several experimental results differ drastically from each other and from our calculations . a discussion of these modes is almost impossible , and with the exception of refs . @xcite for @xmath49 , all experimental assignments lie beyond the likely error bars of the theoretical values . on the whole , the pyridazine vibrational spectra definitely merit further investigation , as the many experimental and theoretical datasets available are considerably at variance with each other . thus , it is impossible to give an error estimate for the method used based on this molecule . however if our computational results prove to be as accurate as for benzene and pyridine , the experimental spectra have to be reexamined . based on this study , one might wonder whether the addition of more nitrogens or the n - n bond is causing the deterioration of the calculated values . pyrimidine ( figure 1d ) , has been studied less in recent years . notable are the ir experiments compiled by irm@xcite , the ir experiments of billes et al.@xcite , and the inelastic neutron scattering work of navarro et al.@xcite . here , we compare mainly to the ir experiments , since the ins data for neither pyridine nor pyridazine agree well with our computed values and the other experiments , for reasons outlined above . nevertheless , for pyrimidine the ins data seem a lot closer to the ir data than for the previous two azabenzenes ( table [ tab5 ] ) . the values for the @xmath50 c - h stretches are in agreement with experiment , although this seems fortuitous . otherwise , all in - plane modes are within 8 @xmath1 of experiment , with the sole exception of @xmath42 . interestingly , both @xmath38 and @xmath41 undergo strong fermi type 1 and 2 resonances ; their resonance matrices are displayed in table[tab6 ] with their respective eigensolutions . for @xmath38 , very small changes in the unperturbed fundamentals would result in the value ending up not at 1071 @xmath1 , but at the experimental assignment of 1065 @xmath1 . the assignment of the two resonating modes appears to be purely arbitrary . as for @xmath41 , the resonating overtone of @xmath46 matches the experimental number exactly . since both modes are in resonance , the overtone might have `` borrowed intensity '' ( as described in ref.@xcite ) from @xmath41 , and thus the assignment . + when looking at the out - of - plane modes in table [ tab5 ] , only @xmath48 and @xmath22 yield different results compared to the first set of experimental results . both discrepancies have been mentioned before by the harmonic - only study@xcite , and @xmath22 has a very small intensity . moreover , by using scaled hf frequencies , wiberg@xcite has suggested that the assignment for @xmath48 might also be incorrect . the irm@xcite assignments for modes 5 , 6 , 13 and 21 appear more plausible than from ref.@xcite . neglecting the problematic modes 10 and 20 and reassigning mode 9 to 677 @xmath1 , the errors , including the c - h stretches , are 6.3 ( mean absolute ) and 11.4 @xmath1 ( rms ) , and without them are 4.1 and 5.3 @xmath1 , respectively . thus this method again appears to be very reliable for predicting fundamental frequencies . as with pyrimidine , only few experiments have been done for pyrazine ( figure 1e ) . the vibrational assignments are displayed in table [ tab7 ] . in ref.@xcite , assignments were done in the gas phase for the ir active modes and in a melt for the raman spectrum . overall , the agreement is again very good for modes other than c - h stretches . if the previously mentioned tendency to underestimate the c - h stretches is taken into account , all assignments appear plausible , with the possible exception of the assignment of @xmath36 from ref.@xcite . it should be noted that all of the c - h stretches are perturbed by fermi resonances . for the in - plane modes , especially @xmath30 appears to lie beyond the error bars of our method . it has been mentioned by the harmonic - only study in ref.@xcite that this ` kekul mode ' is problematic and it was concluded that this mode has significant multireference character , since it corresponds to the dissociation into 2 hcn + c@xmath8h@xmath8 . however , hybrid density functionals are usually capable to describe nondynamical correlation to a certain extent , since for example the atomization energy of ozone is reasonably well reproduced . for this mode , the assignment of ref.@xcite appears to be out of question . + for all the other modes , most the experiments scatter only by about 5 @xmath1 , with this agreement suggesting that their assignments and values are pretty accurate . the out - of - plane modes are generally quite well described by theory . note that the two @xmath51 modes since they are neither ir nor raman active ; for this reason they are not assigned in ref.@xcite . the ins values are somewhat disappointing for both frequencies , since the chief advantage of this method is the ability to predict such bands . another discrepancy is the first @xmath52 mode ( @xmath41 ) , although the second experiment of ref.@xcite is closer to our values . + this leads to mean absolute and rms errors compared to ref.@xcite ( ref.@xcite ) of 7.8 ( 7.9 ) and 10.4 ( 11.1 ) @xmath1 including the c - h stretches , and of 5.4 ( 5.1 ) and 6.9 ( 6.5 ) @xmath1 when excluding them . if the problematic @xmath53 and @xmath41 are excluded , the mean absolute and rms errors for the non c - h stretches reduces to 4.1 ( 4.1 ) and 5.4 ( 5.5 ) @xmath1 , respectively . thus , the general rms discrepancy of 5 to 7 @xmath1 is obtained for pyrazine as well . + 1,3,5-triazine ( figure 1f ) is the only azabenzene with a degenerate point group symmetry ( @xmath54 ) . because of this , the @xmath55 modes ( @xmath31 and @xmath24 ) are both ir and raman inactive . the ins @xcite value for @xmath56 coincides exactly with our calculation ( table [ tab8 ] ) ; the discrepancy of 124 @xmath1 for @xmath24 is outlandish even for the ins data and this band is probably misassigned . the inelastic neutron scattering data@xcite are clearly inferior to the other experimental datasets . this is hardly surprising as this method relies on fitting and scaling a harmonic force field which is obtained from dft in small split - valence basis sets . already for the harmonics , this introduces errors on the order of about 50 @xmath1 . the error for the c - h stretches is expected to be even larger . it would be interesting to reanalyze their data based on the present anharmonic force fields , although this still would not resolve the problems associated with the c - h stretches , for which large basis set coupled cluster frequencies would be desirable . the experimental ir / raman data of daunt et al.@xcite and lancaster et al.@xcite are very similar to those of irm@xcite and are not listed in table [ tab8 ] . with the exception of the first @xmath57 @xmath17 and the c - h stretches , which are again underestimated , all computed values are within 11 @xmath1 of experiment again , the errors are similar to the other azabenzenes ; including the c - h stretches , the mean absolute error is 7.6 @xmath1 and the rms error 11 @xmath1 . excluding the stretches ( and @xmath17 ) , these numbers reduce to 5.1 ( 3.4 ) and 7.5 ( 5.0 ) @xmath1 , respectively . for 1,2,3-triazine ( figure 1 g ) , only one ir and raman spectrum in kbr has been experimentally determined@xcite : the assignment was assisted by scaled mp2/6 - 31 g * harmonic frequencies . the spectrum looks very similar to that of pyrimidine ; even the same fermi resonances are present . + at first glance at the spectra in table [ tab9 ] , the agreement between theory and experiment is disappointing . for very few of the modes is there agreement between the spectra . however , the authors did not consider _ any _ fermi resonances in the lower spectrum ( although they noted that one might exist , involving @xmath42 ) , and simply assumed the ordering of the fundamentals to be identical to that of the mp2/6 - 31 g * harmonics . this however leads to obvious misassignments . for example , @xmath34 and @xmath43 lie almost on top of each other , while @xmath58 borrows intensity from @xmath34 because of the fermi resonance , as can be seen in table [ tab10 ] . if the resonance were not as strong as computed specifically , if the unperturbed fundamental were shifted only a few @xmath1 towards higher values , the perturbed @xmath58 , presently calculated at 1056 @xmath1 , might easily correspond to the band at 1064 @xmath1 , assigned to @xmath34 in ref.@xcite . the same actually applies to @xmath22 , which has a strong fermi resonance with @xmath59 + @xmath49 , that has , however , been calculated at a lower value of 644 @xmath1 . we have also reassigned the first @xmath50 c - h stretch ( mode 1 ) , since the discrepancy between experiment and theory appears too high even for a c - h stretch . needless to say , this mode also has a strong fermi resonance with the @xmath60 overtone , which has its largest component for the eigenvector with associated eigenvalue at at 3100 @xmath1 , again explaining the experimental value perfectly . the only other value which is still in question would be a small peak at 1597 @xmath1 , which might correspond to an impurity ; a band was found that was assigned to acetylene , a fragmentation product of 1,2,3-triazine . the value of 318 @xmath1 , which has been reported for @xmath49 is actually just a scaled hartree - fock harmonic frequency . + therefore , a dramatic change in the errors is obtained by reassigning the experimental spectrum . including the c - h stretches in the error analysis , the mean absolute error decreases from 17.7 to 4.7 @xmath1 and the rms error from 27.9 to 6.1 @xmath1 . by excluding the c - h stretches , the mean absolute and rms errors improve from 14.6 and 22.1 @xmath1 , respectively , to 4.1 and 5.2 @xmath1 . thus , accuracy consistent with the preceding azabenzenes can be obtained following some reassignments in the experimental spectrum . this also corroborates our conclusion concerning pyridazine that neither substitution of c - h by n nor n - n bonds seem to be responsible for the discrepancies between experimental and computed vibrational spectra . because 1,2,4-triazine ( figure 1h ) is highly unstable , only one `` full '' experimental spectrum has been measured as a liquid film@xcite , although more recently two high - resolution ir spectra have been recorded for four frequencies@xcite . for the c - h stretches ( table [ tab11 ] ) , possibly @xmath61 and @xmath53 may have been swapped , since they both take part in a large resonance matrix block . overall , ten frequencies and combination bands interact forming this large resonance block that include modes 1 to 3 . hence , it is not surprising that a correct assignment based merely on experimental data would be problematic . with this swap , all three c - h stretches are underestimated by the usual 10 - 30 @xmath1 . only @xmath36 appears questionable in view of our results . however , @xmath41 has a fermi resonance with the combination of @xmath42 and @xmath30 , and the resonance , eigenvector and eigenvalue matrices are displayed in table [ tab12 ] . the fermi resonances displayed in these tables are similar to pyrimidine , 1,2,3-triazine and 1,2,4-triazine . assuming that both of the fermi resonances are slightly stronger than predicted , since @xmath30 is underestimated by 3 @xmath1 compared to the high - resolution ir data , the new @xmath42 + @xmath30 could well end up lower than the predicted 1143 @xmath1 , explaining the value of 1136 @xmath1 that would then not be assigned to any mode . the assignment of @xmath36 in the experiment would then correspond to @xmath48 , in agreement with the calculated spectrum . the assignment of @xmath49 also appears to be incorrect . + of the four modes obtained by high - resolution ir , the newer data for @xmath17 validates our computational value of 1044 @xmath1 rather than the 1050 @xmath1 predicted by the older experiment . on the other hand , the low - resolution ir value of 769 @xmath1 for mode 19 is closer to the hi - res data compared to our predicted 779 @xmath1 . these new experiments show the usefulness of the theoretical value , since its resolution is apparently even comparable to that obtained by low - resolution ir data . + without making any reassignments to the experimental spectrum , the mean absolute error from experiment is 13.6 @xmath1 , and the rms error is 19.2 @xmath1 including the c - h stretches . this appears to be quite large in comparison to the other azabenzenes . with the abovementioned suggested reassignments , these errors change to 7.5 @xmath1 and 10.0 @xmath1 , respectively . excluding the c - h stretches , we once again end up with a mean absolute error of 5.1 @xmath1 and an rms error of 5.8 @xmath1 . for 1,2,4,5-tetrazine ( figure 1i ) , ccsd(t ) harmonic frequencies are available in the literature@xcite . unfortunately , they were calculated with all electrons correlated in a basis set ( 6 - 311 g * * ) that is only minimal in the inner - shell orbitals . the resulting errors in harmonic frequencies can easily exceed 20 @xmath1 for small molecules@xcite , several times larger than the actual effect of neglecting core correlation ( typically less than 10 @xmath1 in hcnof systems@xcite ) . we have recomputed the ccsd(t)/6 - 311 g * * frequencies correlating only valence electrons ( table [ tab13 ] ) . for the in - plane modes , differences with the all - electron calculations are quite minor ( 6 @xmath1 or less ) . the out - of - plane modes , however , are drastically affected , up to 60 @xmath1 ( table [ tab13 ] , especially the @xmath62 and the second b@xmath63 frequencies ) . this adds yet another stanza to the long litany of rejoinders in the literature ( e.g.@xcite ) against the practice of correlating inner - shell electrons in basis sets unsuitable for the purpose . + we have recalculated the harmonic frequencies at the ccsd(t ) level ( frozen core ) with basis sets of @xmath0 quality , specifically dunning s popular cc - pvtz @xcite and the almlf - taylor atomic natural orbital@xcite basis set used in ref.@xcite for benzene . the ccsd(t)/cc - pvtz and ccsd(t)/ano4321 frequencies ( table [ tab13 ] ) are in excellent agreement with each other , the largest difference being 6 @xmath1 for the lowest frequency ( @xmath64 ) . ( this is very unlike the case of benzene@xcite , where the two @xmath52 modes are hypersensitive to the basis set and differ significantly even between cc - pvtz and ano4321 . ) . the two corresponding modes in s - tetrazine display appreciable differences between 6 - 311 g * and cc - pvtz but barely between cc - pvtz and ano4321 . ) in contrast , the ccsd(t)/6 - 311 g * * frequencies differs significantly from both data sets , particularly for the two @xmath52 modes ( 39 and 33 @xmath1 w.r.t . ano4321 ) , followed by the lowest @xmath65 mode ( a.k.a . ` kekul mode ' , 27 @xmath1 ) and the @xmath51 mode ( 25 @xmath1 , but a relative error of 7% ) . so even for a valence - only ccsd(t ) calculation , the 6 - 311 g * * basis set is insufficient , and the rms deviation from the ccsd(t)/ano4321 results , 16.4 @xmath1 ( 17.3 when excluding the c - h stretching frequencies ) , is comparable to that of the much more cost - effective b97 - 1 calculations , 18.1 ( 15.1 ) @xmath1 . turning now to the b97 - 1/tz2p harmonic frequencies , the most notable differences with the ccsd(t)/ano4321 data are for the ch stretches ( underestimates of 34 @xmath66 for both ) and the kekul mode ( overestimated by 37 @xmath66 ) . possibly , self - interaction error would adversely affect@xcite the presently used functional s description of the potential surface along the kekul mode , and it would be interesting how a self - interaction corrected functional would perform . unfortunately no implementation of such a functional is available to the authors , let alone an implementation including analytical derivatives . exclusive of this mode and the ch stretches , the rms deviation between the ccsd(t)/ano4321 and b97 - 1/tz2p frequencies is about 11 @xmath1 , compared to just 4 @xmath1 for benzene . as expect , agreement between b97 - 1/tz2p fundamentals and experiment is likewise compromised ( table [ tab14 ] ) . we note that s - tetrazine is both the least stable and the most ` inorganic ' molecule of the series , and that it has a low - lying excited state at less than 2 ev@xcite . if we combine the ccsd(t)/ano4321 harmonic frequencies with the b97 - 1/tz2p anharmonic corrections , the picture brightens somewhat . compared to the assignment of irm@xcite , the rms deviation amounts to 9.8 @xmath1 if the symmetric c h stretch is excluded . the peculiarly large splitting of 76 @xmath1 between irm s symmetric and asymmetric ch stretches is impossible to reconcile with any of our calculations , all of which suggest a very small splitting on the order of just 3 @xmath1 , in agreement with the earlier film ir and raman study of sigworth and pace ( sp)@xcite . ( their band origin of 3089 @xmath1 for the symmetric ch stretch is quite compatible with our calculations : irm s value of 3010 @xmath1 was taken from single - vibronic - level fluorescence spectra@xcite . an older gas - phase study by franks , merer , and innes ( fmi)@xcite found both ch stretches at 3090 @xmath1 ; the symmetric one in the ir , the antisymmetric one in the raman spectrum . ) our calculations do not reveal a resonance interaction affecting @xmath61 that is severe enough to make a large ch symmetric / antisymmetric spllitting plausible . we hence conclude that @xmath61 of irm is erroneous . one other irm assignment which is difficult to reconcile with our best calculations concerns the highest @xmath67 mode ( calculated : 902 , irm : 929 @xmath1 ) for which the franks , merer , and innes@xcite value of 904 @xmath1 nearly perfectly matches our calculation . it would appear that even the somewhat degraded performance , exhibited by our model for this molecule , still ought to be quite useful for resolving assignment issues or guiding high - resolution spectroscopic measurements . we have assessed the performance of modern density functional theory ( particularly , b97 - 1/tz2p ) for the anharmonic vibrational spectra of a series of related medium - sized molecules . the c - h stretching frequencies are consistently underestimated by about 20 - 30 @xmath1 ; disregarding them , the level of agreement with experiment that can be achieved is quite astonishing ( on the order of 6 @xmath1 rms deviation for fundamentals ) . somewhat poorer accuracy is achieved for pyridazine and particularly for s - tetrazine . for several systems ( particularly 1,2,3-triazine ) , our calculations strongly suggest revised assignments of the observed frequencies . for pyridazine , unfortunately , the experimental results are mutually contradictory and our analysis inconclusive . for s - tetrazine , basically all predicted fundamentals agree less well with experiment ; the more ` inorganic ' character of the molecule may have adversely affected the performance of our calculations . nevertheless , even here a rms deviation of about 15 @xmath1 for dft and 10 @xmath1 for the combined ccsd(t)/dft results is obtained . + overall , b97 - 1/tz2p quartic force fields combined with second - order rovibrational perturbation theory shows great promise for the assignment of vibrational spectra of medium - sized organic molecules . a. d. boese is grateful for financial support from the feinberg graduate school . this research was supported by the lise meitner - minerva center for computational quantum chemistry , of which j. m. l. martin is a member , and the helen and martin a. kimmel center for molecular design . b97 - 1/tz2p quartic force fields in normal coordinates of the molecules studied are available for download ( in spectro format ) at the url http://theochem.weizmann.ac.il/web/papers/azabenzenes.html . 99 boese , a. d. ; handy , n. c. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 114 * 5497 ( 2001 ) . boese , a. d. ; martin , j. m. l. ; handy , n. c. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 2003 * , _ 119 _ , 3005 . colwell , s. m. ; handy , n. c. ; lee , a. m. ; _ phys . * 1996 * , _ 53 _ , 1316 . jamorski , c. ; casida , m. e. ; salahub , d. r. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1996 * , _ 104 _ , 5134 . bauernschmitt , r. ; ahlrichs , r. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 1996 * , _ 256 _ , 454 . van caille , c. ; amos , r. d. ; _ chem . _ * 2000 * , _ 317 _ , 159 . amos , r. d. ; _ chem . * 2002 * , _ 364 _ , 612 . dressler , s. ; thiel , w.;_chem . lett . _ * 1997 * , _ 273 _ , 71 . clabo jr . , d. a. ; allen , w. d. ; remington , r. b. ; yamaguchi , y. ; schaefer iii , h. f. ; _ chem . _ * 1988 * , _ 123 _ , 117 . allen , w. d. ; yamaguchi , y. ; a. g. csszr , clabo , d. a. ; remington , r. b. ; schaefer iii , h. f. ; _ chem . phys . _ * 1990 * , _ 145 _ , 427 . martin , j. m. l. ; lee , t. j. ; taylor , p. r. ; franois , j. p. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1995 * , _ 103 _ , 2589 . martin , j. m. l. ; lee , t. j. ; and taylor , p. r. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1998 * , _ 108 _ , 676 . martin , j. m. l. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 1998 * , _ 292 _ , 411 . neugebauer , j. ; hess , b. a. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 2003 * , _ 118 _ , 7215 . boese , a. d. ; martin , j. m. l. ; submitted . miani , a. ; cane , e. ; palmieri , p. ; trombetti , a. ; handy , n. c. ; _ j. chem . _ * 2000 * , _ 112 _ , 248 . becke , a. d. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1993 * , _ 98 _ , 5648 . lee , c. ; yang , w. ; parr , r. g. ; _ phys . b _ * 37 * , 785 ( 1988 ) burcl , r. ; handy , n. c. ; carter , s.;_spectrochim . acta a _ * 2003 * , _ 59 _ , 1881 . politzer , p. ; murray , j. s. ; seminario , j. m. ; miller , r. s. ; _ j. mol . ( theochem ) _ * 1992 * , _ 94 _ , 155 . saxe , p. ; schaefer iii , h. f. ; _ j. am . soc . _ * 1983 * , _ 105 _ , 1760 . tobita , m. ; bartlett , r. j. ; _ j. phys . * 2001 * , _ 105 _ , 4107 and references therein ; see also http://www.qtp.ufl.edu/~bartlett/downloads/polynitrogen.pdf . straka , m. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 2002 * , _ 358 _ , 531 . scheiner , a. c. ; schaefer iii , h. f. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1987 * , _ 87 _ , 3539 m. schtz , hutter , j. ; lthi , h. p. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1995 * , _ 103 _ , 7048 . stanton , j. f. ; and gauss , j. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1996 * , _ 104 _ , 9859 . rubio , m. ; roos , b. o. ; _ mol . phys . _ * 1999 * , _ 96 _ , 603 . nooijen , m. ; _ j. phys . a _ * 2000 * , _ 104 _ , 4553 . innes , k. k. ; ross , i. g. ; moomaw , w. r. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1988 * , _ 132 _ , 492 . martin , j. m. l. ; van alsenoy , c. ; _ j. phys . chem . _ * 1996 * , _ 100 _ , 6973 . hamprecht , f. a. ; cohen , a. j. ; tozer , d. j. ; and handy , n. c. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1998 * , _ 109 _ , 6264 . becke , a. d. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1997 * , _ 107 _ , 8554 dunning , t. h. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1971 * , _ 55 _ , 716 . the cambridge analytic derivatives package ( cadpac ) , issue 6.5 , cambridge , 1998 ; developed by amos , r. d. , with contributions from alberts , i. l. ; andrews , j. s. ; colwell , s. m. ; handy , n. c. ; jayatikala , d. ; knowles , p.j . ; kobayashi , r.;laidig , k. e. ; laming , g. ; lee , a. m. ; maslen , p. e. ; murray , c. w. ; palmieri , p. ; rice , j. e. ; simandiras , e. d. ; stone , a. j. ; su , m .- d . ; tozer , d. j. frisch , m.j . ; trucks , g.w . ; schlegel , h.b . ; scuseria , g.e . ; robb , m.a . ; cheeseman , j.r . ; zakrzewski , v.g . ; j.a . montgomery jr . , stratmann , r. e. ; burant , j. c. ; dapprich , s. ; millam , j. m. ; daniels , a.d . ; kudin , k.n . ; strain , m.c . ; farkas , o. ; tomasi , j. ; barone , v. ; cossi , m. ; cammi , r. ; mennucci , b. ; pomelli , c. ; adamo , c. ; clifford , s. ; ochterski , j. ; petersson , g.a . ; ayala , p.y . ; cui , q. ; morokuma , k. ; malick , d.k . ; rabuckm , a.d . ; raghavachari , k. ; foresman , j.b . ; cioslowski , j. ; ortiz , j.v . ; baboul , a.g . ; stefanov , b.b . ; liu , g. ; liashenko , a. ; piskorz , p. ; komaromi , i. ; gomperts , r. ; martin , r.l . ; fox , d.j . ; keith , t. ; m.a . al - laham , peng , c.y . ; nanayakkara , a. ; gonzalez , c. ; challacombe , m. ; gill , p.m.w . ; johnson , b. ; chen , w. ; wong , m.w . ; andres , j.l . ; gonzalez , c. ; m. head - gordon , replogle , e.s . ; and pople , j.a . ; _ gaussian 98 , revision a. 11 _ ( gaussian , inc . , pittsburgh , pa , 1998 ) . mills , i. m. ; in : molecular spectroscopy : modern research , eds . k. narahari rao , c. w. mathews , vol . 1 , academic press , new york 1972 , pp . 115 - 140 . d. a. clabo jr . , allen , w. d. ; remington , r. b. ; yamaguchi , y. ; schaefer iii , h. f. ; _ chem . phys . _ * 1988 * , _ 123 _ , 187 . allen , w. d. ; yamaguchi , y. ; csaszar , a. g. ; clabo , d. a. ; remington , r. b. ; schaefer iii , h. f. ; _ chem . phys . _ * 1990 * , _ 145 _ , 427 . schneider , w. ; and thiel , w. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 1989 * , _ 157 _ , 367 . hoy , a. r. ; mills , i. m. ; and strey , g. ; _ mol . _ * 1972 * , _ 24 _ , 1265 . gaw , j. f. ; willets , a. ; green , w. h. ; handy , n. c. ; in _ advances in molecular vibration and collision dynamics _ ; bowman , j. m. , ed . ; jai : grennwich , ct , 1990 . martin , j. m. l. ; `` polyad : a vibrational perturbation theory program including arbitrary resonance matrices '' ( weizmann institute of science , reovot , 1997 ) . maslen , p. e. ; handy , n. c. ; amos , r. d. ; jayatilaka , d. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1992 * , _ 97 _ , 4233 . handy , n. c. ; willets , a. ; _ spectrochim . acta a _ * 1997 * , _ 53 _ , 1169 . goodman , l. ; ozkabak , a. g. ; thakur , s. n. ; _ j. phys . chem . _ * 1991 * , _ 95 _ , 9044 . martin , j. m. l. ; taylor , p. r. ; and lee , t. j. ; _ chem . _ * 1997 * , _ 275 _ , 414 . handy , n. c. ; murray , c. w. ; and amos , r. d. ; _ j. phys . chem . _ * 1993 * , _ 97 _ , 4392 . handy , n. c. ; maslen , p. e. ; amos , r. d. ; andrews , j. s. ; murray , c. w. ; and laming , g. j. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 1992 * , _ 197 _ , 506 . klots , t. d. ; _ spectrochim . acta a _ * 1998 * , _ 54 _ , 1481 . partal , f. ; fernandez gomez , m. ; lopez gonzalez , j. j. ; navarro , a. ; kearley , g. h. ; _ chem . _ * 2000 * , _ 261 _ , 239 . navarro , a. ; vazquez , j. ; montejo , m. ; lopez gonzalez , j. j. ; kearley , g. j. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 2002 * , _ 361 _ , 483 . billes , f. ; mikosch , h. ; and holly , s. ; _ j. mol . ( theochem ) _ * 1998 * , _ 423 _ , 225 . vazquez , j. ; lopez gozalez , j. j. ; marquez , f. ; boggs , j. e. ; _ j. raman spectrosc . _ * 1998 * , _ 29 _ , 547 . ozono , y. ; nibu , y. ; shimada , h. ; and shimada , r. ; _ bull . jpn . _ * 1986 * , _ 59 _ , 2997 . stidham , h. d. ; and tucci , j. v. ; _ spectrochim . acta a _ * 1967 * , _ 23 _ , 2233 . navarro , a. ; fernandez gomez , m. ; lopez gonzalez , j. j. ; fernandez liencres , m. p. ; martinez torres , e. m. ; tomkinson , j. ; kearley , g. j. ; _ j. phys . * 1999 * , _ 103 _ , 5833 . burcl , r. ; carter , s. ; and handy , n. c. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 2003 * , _ 380 _ , 237 . wiberg , k. b. ; _ j. mol . struct . _ * 1990 * , _ 244 _ , 61 . arenas , j. f. ; lopez navarrete , j. t. ; otero , j. c. ; marcos , j. i. ; _ j. chem . faraday trans . 2 _ * 1985 * , _ 81 _ , 405 . navarro , a. ; lopez gonzalez , j. j. ; kearley , g. j. ; tomkinson , j. ; parker , s. f. ; and sivia , d. s. ; _ chem . phys . _ * 1995 * , _ 200 _ , 395 . kearley , g. j. ; tomkinson , j. ; navarro , a. ; lopez gonzalez , j. j. ; fernandez gomez , m. ; _ chem . * 1997 * , _ 216 _ , 323 . daunt , s. j. ; shurvell , h. f. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1976 * , _ 62 _ , 373 . lancaster , j. e. ; stamm , r. f. ; colthup , n. b. ; _ spectrochim . acta _ * 1961 * , _ 17 _ , 155 . fischer , g. ; nwankwoala , a. u. ; olliff , m. p. ; scott , a. p. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1993 * , _ 161 _ , 388 . neunhoffer , h. ; hennig , h. ; _ chemische berichte _ * 1968 * , _ 101 _ , 3952 . palmer , m. h. ; maier , r. r. j. ; hegelund , f. ; newnham , d. a. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1998 * , _ 192 _ , 331 . hegelund , f. ; larsen , r. w. ; nelander , b. ; christen , d. ; palmer , m. h. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 2003 * , _ 217 _ , 9 . martin , j. m. l. ; schwenke , d. w. ; lee , t. j. ; taylor , p. r. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 1996 * , _ 104 _ , 4657 . martin , j. m. l. ; _ chem . lett . _ * 1995 * , _ 242 _ , 343 . little can be added to this statement : `` using valence - optimized basis sets and including core - correlation is not only a waste of computer time , but a potential source of problems , as it can substantially increase bsse . this point is not well appreciated : the prevailing view appears to be that no harm can come of correlating the core when the basis set is inadequate . this is not so . '' ( taylor , p. r. ; in _ lecture notes in quantum chemistry _ ; roos , b. o. , ed . ; springer : berling , 1992 ; p. 406 ) . dunning jr . , t. h. ; _ j. chem . _ * 90 * , 1007 ( 1989 ) almlf , j. ; taylor , p. r. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 86 * , 4070 ( 1987 ) patchkovskii , s. ; ziegler , t. ; _ j. chem . phys . _ * 116 * , 7806 ( 2002 ) sigworth , w. d. ; pace , e. l. ; _ spectrochim . acta a _ * 1971 * , _ 27 _ , 747 brumbaugh , d. v. ; innes , k. k. ; _ chem . phys . _ * 1981 * , _ 59 _ , 413 . franks , l. a. ; merer , a. j. ; innes , k. k. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1968 * , _ 26 _ , 458 . dilella , d. p. ; and stidham , h. d. ; _ j. raman spectrosc . _ * 1980 * , _ 9 _ , 90 . wiberg , k. b. ; walters , v. a. ; colson , s. d. ; _ j. phys . chem . _ * 1984 * , _ 88 _ , 6067 ; wong , k. n. ; colson , s. d. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1984 * , _ 104 _ , 129 ; walters , v. a. ; snavely , d. a. ; colson , d. a. ; wiberg , k. b. ; wong , k. n. ; _ j. phys . chem . _ * 1986 * , _ 90 _ , 592 . kakiuti , y. ; akiyama , m. ; saito , n. ; saito , h. ; _ j. mol . spectrosc . _ * 1976 * , _ 61 _ , 164 . califano , s. ; crawford jr . , b. _ spectrochim . acta _ * 1960 * , _ 16 _ , 900 . sverdlov , l. m. ; kovner , m. a. ; krainov , e. p. , eds . ; j. wiley and sons : new york , toronto , 1974 ; p. 533 ff . & b97 - 1 & b3lyp@xcite & ccsd(t)@xcite & hma@xmath68@xcite & hw@xmath69@xcite & mcpth@xmath70@xcite + + a@xmath71 & 3189 & 3192 & 3210 & 3198 & 3191 & 3218 + & 1008 & 1012 & 1003 & 1001 & 1008 & 1003 + a@xmath72 & 1380 & 1392 & 1380 & 1378 & 1367 & 1392 + b@xmath72 & 1012 & 1017 & 1009 & 1000 & 990 & 1012 + & 718 & 723 & 709 & 712 & 718 & 717 + e@xmath72 & 3165 & 3168 & 3183 & 3182 & 3174 & 3210 + & 1628 & 1635 & 1637 & 1623 & 1607 & 1645 + & 1195 & 1201 & 1194 & 1185 & 1178 & 1197 + & 617 & 624 & 611 & 610 & 613 & 617 + e@xmath71 & 863 & 864 & 865 & 856 & 847 & 861 + a@xmath73 & 686 & 686 & 687 & 680 & 686 & 683 + b@xmath74 & 3155 & 3159 & 3173 & 3173 & 3174 & + & 1022 & 1031 & 1020 & 1016 & 1024 & 1030 + + b@xmath73 & 1330 & 1333 & 1326 & 1313 & 1318 & 1338 + & 1170 & 1178 & 1163 & 1158 & 1167 & 1163 + e@xmath73 & 987 & 992 & 985 & 978 & 967 & 987 + & 408 & 412 & 406 & 402 & 1058 & 1056 + e@xmath74 & 3180 & 3183 & 3200 & 3186 & 3181 & 3212 + & 1509 & 1519 & 1509 & 1503 & 1494 & 1522 + & 1055 & 1060 & 1056 & 1048 & 1058 & 1057 + + + + & mode & b97 - 1/tz2p & b3lyp / tz2p & ccsd(t)/b97 - 1 & got@xcite & mcp@xcite + + a@xmath71 & 1 & 3048 & 3051 & 3069 & 3074 & 3073 + & 2 & 992 & 995 & 987 & 993 & 993 + a@xmath72 & 3 & 1348 & 1351@xmath75 & 1348 & 1350 & 1350 + b@xmath72 & 7 & 987 & 997 & 984 & 990 & 993 + & 8 & 707 & 708 & 698 & 707 & 702 + e@xmath72 & 15 & 3032@xmath75 & 3028 & 3050 & 3057 & 3057 + & 16 & 1611@xmath75 & 1613@xmath75 & 1620 & 1601 & 1610 + & 17 & 1178 & 1181 & 1177 & 1178 & 1178 + & 18 & 613 & 615@xmath75 & 607 & 608 & 608 + e@xmath71 & 11 & 841 & 846 & 843 & 847 & 847 + a@xmath73 & 4 & 672 & 677 & 673 & 674 & 674 + b@xmath74 & 5 & 3004@xmath75 & 2988@xmath75 & 3022 & 3057 & 3057 + & 6 & 1006 & 1015 & 1004 & 1010 & 1014 + + b@xmath73 & 9 & 1309 & 1305 & 1305 & 1309 & 1309 + & 10 & 1156 & 1163 & 1149 & 1150 & 1148 + e@xmath73 & 19 & 964 & 972 & 962 & 967 & 968 + & 20 & 400 & 403 & 398 & 398 & 398 + e@xmath74 & 12 & 3031@xmath75 & 3023@xmath75 & 3051 & 3064 & 3048 + & 13 & 1486 & 1484 & 1486 & 1484 & 1484 + & 14 & 1045 & 1038 & 1046 & 1038 & 1038 + & & 15.2 ( 4.2 ) & 17.0 ( 4.8 ) + & & 12.2 ( 2.8 ) & 13.7 ( 4.5 ) + & & 7.8 ( 4.5 ) & 7.4 ( 4.1 ) + + & & & & & ins + & mode & harmonic&fundamental & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite + + a@xmath76 & 1 & 3193 & 3061@xmath75 & 3068 & & 3082 & 3086 & 3064 & 3070 & 3086 + & 2 & 3166 & 3034@xmath75 & 3056 & & 3052 & 3071 & 3052 & 3053 & 3071 + & 3 & 1604 & 1558 & 1570 & 1555 & 1568 & 1570 & 1572 & 1570 & 1547 + & 4 & 1477 & 1446 & 1415 & 1440 & 1418 & 1444 & 1417 & 1441 & 1465 + & 5 & 1180 & 1145 & & 1340 & 1337 & 1160 & 1347 & 1352 & 1188 + & 6 & 1171 & 1157 & 1159 & 1153 & 1154 & 1119 & 1160 & 1150 & 1177 + & 7 & 1088 & 1064 & 1061 & 1055 & 1061 & 1061 & 1063 & 1063 & 1075 + & 8 & 1006 & 987 & 963 & 960 & 969 & 968 & 964 & 963 & 998 + & 9 & 676 & 669 & 629 & 622 & 622 & 668 & 630 & 632 & 670 + b@xmath8 & 14 & 3180 & 3056@xmath75 & 3085 & & 3082 & 3079 & 3083 & 3080 & 3079 + & 15 & 3162 & 3052@xmath75 & 3056 & & 3080 & 3057 & 3052 & 3041 & 3057 + & 16 & 1601 & 1556 & 1563 & 1540 & 1572 & 1563 & 1566 & 1564 & 1571 + & 17 & 1438 & 1406 & 1446 & 1408 & 1412 & 1413 & 1450 & 1401 & 1436 + & 18 & 1311 & 1284 & 1283 & 1283 & 1281 & 1281 & 1283 & 1287 & 1306 + & 19 & 1081 & 1058 & 1131 & 1112 & 1131 & 1049 & 1129 & 1113 & 1075 + & 20 & 1056 & 1039 & & 1058 & 1058 & 1027 & 1032 & 1052 & 1049 + & 21 & 629 & 622 & 664 & 663 & 673 & 622 & 667 & 660 & 628 + + b@xmath76 & 22 & 981 & 962 & & & 985 & 987 & 842 & 986 & 998 + & 23 & 762 & 751 & 760 & 760 & 745 & 745 & 759 & 755 & 782 + & 24 & 370 & 362 & 369 & 372 & 369 & 376 & 370 & 370 & 375 + a@xmath8 & 10 & 1019 & 1002 & & & 963 & 1025 & 938 & 970 & 1039 + & 11 & 943 & 926 & & & 765 & 945 & 861 & 786 & 949 + & 12 & 775 & 763 & & & 785 & 729 & 753 & 775 & 793 + & 13 & 372 & 365 & & & 377 & 367 & 410 & 363 & 372 + + & & & & ins + & mode & harmonic&fundamental & irm@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite + + a@xmath76 & 1 & 3194 & 3074@xmath75 & 3074 & 3082 & 3074 + & 2 & 3161 & 3045@xmath75 & 3052 & 3053 & 3052 + & 3 & 3147 & 3025@xmath75 & 3038 & 3053 & 3038 + & 4 & 1607 & 1565 & 1570 & 1572 & 1580 + & 5 & 1433 & 1404 & 1398 & 1465 & 1390 + & 6 & 1160 & 1139 & 1147 & 1155 & 1139 + & 7 & 1077 & 1071@xmath75 & 1065 & 1065 & 1080 + & 8 & 1004 & 989 & 991 & 969 & 972 + & 9 & 691 & 685@xmath75 & 678 & 679 & 665 + b@xmath8 & 12 & 3151 & 3040@xmath75 & 3086 & 3047 & 3086 + & 13 & 1605 & 1562 & 1568 & 1569 & 1565 + & 14 & 1494 & 1464 & 1466 & 1411 & 1470 + & 15 & 1393 & 1365 & 1370 & 1356 & 1376 + & 16 & 1252 & 1225 & 1225 & 1224 & 1225 + & 17 & 1211 & 1173 & 1159 & 1158 & 1136 + & 18 & 1091 & 1072 & 1071 & 1071 & 1021 + & 19 & 630 & 623 & 623 & 621 & 628 + + b@xmath76 & 20 & 1026 & 1006 & 980 & 1033 & 1070 + & 21 & 981 & 962 & 955 & 980 & 980 + & 22 & 822 & 809 & 811 & 804 & 826 + & 23 & 736 & 723 & 721 & 719 & 722 + & 24 & 347 & 340 & 344 & 347 & 344 + a@xmath8 & 10 & 1001 & 982 & [ 927 ] & 960 & 1020 + & 11 & 404 & 396 & 399 & 398 & 344 + & & 5.3 & 21.2 ( 9.9@xmath68 ) & + + + deperturbed & @xmath77 & @xmath45 + @xmath46 + & 1060.0 & + & -10.9 & 1060.1 + + deperturbed & @xmath59 & 2 @xmath46 + & 682.7 & + & 3.7 & 680.0 + + + + + perturbed & @xmath77 & @xmath45 + @xmath46 + coefficient of & 1049.2 & 1070.9 + @xmath77 & -0.7085 & -0.7057 + @xmath45 + @xmath46 & -0.7057 & -0.7085 + + perturbed & @xmath59 & 2 @xmath46 + coefficient of & 677.4 & 685.3 + @xmath59 & -0.5760 & 0.8175 + 2 @xmath46 & 0.8175 & -0.5760 + & & & & ins + & mode & harmonic&fundamental & irm@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite + + a@xmath78 & 1 & 3168 & 3043@xmath75 & 3055 & 3053 & 3054 & 3054 + & 2 & 1612 & 1567 & 1580 & 1579 & 1574 & 1571 + & 3 & 1251 & 1233 & 1233 & 1235 & 1230 & 1240 + & 4 & 1037 & 1020 & 1016 & 1015 & 1015 & 1015 + & 5 & 607 & 598 & 602 & 601 & 596 & 602 + b@xmath79 & 11 & 3147 & 3024@xmath75 & 3040 & 3062 & 3040 & 3040 + & 12 & 1576 & 1533 & 1525 & 1522 & 1529 & 1529 + & 13 & 1372 & 1342 & 1346 & 1353 & 1343 & 1359 + & 14 & 715 & 706 & 704 & 698 & 701 & 698 + b@xmath74 & 15 & 3148 & 2990@xmath75 & 3012 & 3017 & 3018 & 3018 + & 16 & 1513 & 1481 & 1483 & 1484 & 1482 & 1485 + & 17 & 1163 & 1136 & 1130 & 1135 & 1135 & 1062 + & 18 & 1030 & 1013 & 1018 & 1020 & 1020 & 1007 + b@xmath73 & 19 & 3162 & 3055@xmath75 & 3069 & 3069 & 3069 & 3069 + & 20 & 1440 & 1413 & 1411 & 1413 & 1416 & 1427 + & 21 & 1214 & 1174 & 1149 & 1337 & 1146 & 1146 + & 22 & 1084 & 1061 & 1063 & 1063 & 1062 & 1131 + + a@xmath80 & 6 & 1002 & 982 & [ 960 ] & & [ 997 ] & 1065 + & 7 & 347 & 338 & [ 350 ] & & [ 422 ] & 350 + b@xmath71 & 8 & 946 & 927 & 927 & 925 & 919 & 940 + b@xmath72 & 9 & 987 & 968 & 983 & 976 & 983 & 983 + & 10 & 775 & 762 & 756 & 755 & 754 & 754 + b@xmath63 & 23 & 804 & 791 & 785 & 785 & 786 & 818 + & 24 & 429 & 421 & 418 & 417 & 420 & 414 + & & 6.9 ( 5.3@xmath68 ) & 7.1 ( 6.7@xmath68 ) & 6.5 ( 5.5@xmath68 ) & + + + & & & & ins + & mode & harmonic&fundamental & ref.@xcite & irm@xcite & ref.@xcite + + a@xmath81 & 1 & 3164 & 3025@xmath75 & 3082 & 3042 & 3042 + & 2 & 1156 & 1137 & 1130 & 1137 & 1125 + & 3 & 1005 & 989 & 989 & 989 & 991 + a@xmath82 & 4 & 1400 & 1375 & [ 1556 ] & & 1375 + & 5 & 1168 & 1124 & [ 1381 ] & & 1000 + e & 8 & 3159 & 3034@xmath75 & 3081 & 3059 & 3056 + & 9 & 1594 & 1545 & 1560 & 1556 & 1555 + & 10 & 1439 & 1405 & 1404 & 1410 & 1414 + & 11 & 1194 & 1167 & 1168 & 1173 & 1165 + & 12 & 688 & 675 & 666 & 676 & 675 + + a@xmath83 & 6 & 947 & 932 & & 925 & 940 + & 7 & 755 & 740 & & 737 & 732 + e & 13 & 1043 & 1017 & & 1034 & 1030 + & 14 & 345 & 338 & & 339 & 333 + & & & 7.5 ( 5.0@xmath68 ) & + + + & & & ir & raman & ir reassigned + & mode & harmonic&fundamental & ref.@xcite & ref.@xcite & + + a@xmath76 & 1 & 3195 & 3032@xmath75 & 3107 & 3110 & 3046 + & 2 & 3165 & 3028 & & 3045 & + & 3 & 1589 & 1548 & 1597 & 1594 & 1546 + & 4 & 1384 & 1347 & 1336 & 1329 & 1336 + & 5 & 1136 & 1122 & 1080 & 1088 & 1124 + & 6 & 1092 & 1081@xmath75 & 1069 & 1064 & 1080 + & 7 & 1006 & 985 & 979 & 977 & 979 + & 8 & 675 & 667 & 660 & 660 & 660 + b@xmath8 & 14 & 3171 & 3042@xmath75 & 3046 & & 3046 + & 15 & 1584 & 1538 & 1545 & 1547 & 1545 + & 16 & 1438 & 1410 & 1410 & & 1410 + & 17 & 1219 & 1199 & 1195 & 1198 & 1195 + & 18 & 1101 & 1078 & 1124 & 1127 & 1080 + & 19 & 974 & 929 & 935 & & 935 + & 20 & 662 & 659@xmath75 & 653 & & 660 + + b@xmath76 & 10 & 1017 & 998 & & & + & 11 & 824 & 811 & 819 & & 819 + & 12 & 783 & 769 & 769 & & 769 + & 13 & 302 & 296 & [ 318 ] & & + a@xmath8 & 8 & 992 & 973 & & & + & 9 & 358 & 350 & & 365 & + & & 22.1 & & 5.2 + + deperturbed & @xmath84 & @xmath17 + @xmath49 + & 1074.5 & + & 10.6 & 1061.4 + + deperturbed & @xmath22 & @xmath41 + @xmath49 + & 655.1 & + & -6.3 & 647.6 + + + + + perturbed & @xmath84 & @xmath17 + @xmath49 + coefficient of & 1055.5 & 1080.7 + @xmath84 & -0.4804 & -0.8770 + @xmath17 + @xmath49 & 0.8770 & -0.4804 + + perturbes & @xmath22 & @xmath59 + @xmath49 + coefficient of & 644.0 & 658.7 + @xmath59 & 0.4939 & -0.8695 + @xmath59 + @xmath49 & 0.8175 & 0.4939 + & & & ir & hires - ir + & mode & harmonic&fundamental & ref.@xcite & refs.@xcite + + a & 1 & 3178 & 3051@xmath75 & 3090 & + & 2 & 3175 & 3075@xmath75 & 3060 & + & 3 & 3150 & 3007@xmath75 & 3035 & + & 4 & 1596 & 1556 & 1560 & + & 5 & 1563 & 1524 & 1529 & + & 6 & 1470 & 1438 & 1435 & + & 7 & 1401 & 1376 & 1380 & + & 8 & 1314 & 1286 & 1295 & + & 9 & 1179 & 1171@xmath75 & 1163 & + & 10 & 1139 & 1107 & 1136 & + & 11 & 1096 & 1067@xmath75 & 1113 & + & 12 & 1063 & 1044 & 1050 & 1043.5 + & 13 & 1011 & 989 & 955 & + & 14 & 726 & 717 & 713 & + & 15 & 632 & 629@xmath75 & & + + a & 16 & 1014 & 1001 & & + & 17 & 990 & 976 & & + & 18 & 862 & 853 & 851 & + & 19 & 791 & 779 & 768 & 768.7 + & 20 & 379 & 372 & & 367.9 + & 21 & 316 & 308 & & 311.3 + & & 16.1(5.8@xmath68 ) & + + + deperturbed & @xmath36 & @xmath42 + @xmath30 + & 1160.4 & + & -13.7 & 1153.4 + + deperturbed & @xmath19&2 @xmath30 + & 622.8 & + & 8.4 & 617.7 + + + + + perturbed & @xmath36 & @xmath42 + @xmath30 + coefficient of & 1142.7 & 1171.0 + @xmath36 & 0.6136 & -0.7896 + @xmath42 + @xmath30 & 0.7896 & 0.6136 + + perturbed & @xmath19&2 @xmath30 + coefficient of & 611.4 & 629.0 + @xmath59 & -0.5949 & 0.8038 + 2 @xmath30 & 0.8038 & -0.5949 + & & cc - pvtz & ano-4321 & cc - pvtz & tz2p + & @xcite & full@xcite & & @xcite & + + a@xmath85 & 3253 & 3223 & 3221 & 3223 & 3226 & 3196 & 3192 + & 1524 & 1456 & 1452 & 1455 & 1457 & 1472 & 1473 + & 1059 & 1018 & 1018 & 1025 & 1025 & 1050 & 1047 + & 758 & 741 & 740 & 747 & 745 & 756 & 751 + b@xmath74 & 3251 & 3222 & 3218 & 3222 & 3225 & 3199 & 3191 + & 1250 & 1212 & 1210 & 1218 & 1216 & 1232 & 1231 + & 1109 & 1088 & 1088 & 1096 & 1098 & 1099 & 1096 + b@xmath73 & 1505 & 1471 & 1465 & 1472 & 1470 & 1479 & 1478 + & 1167 & 1137 & 1134 & 1138 & 1137 & 1151 & 1147 + & 845 & 908 & 905 & 932 & 927 & 964 & 969 + b@xmath79 & 1611 & 1558 & 1552 & 1561 & 1561 & 1559 & 1560 + & 1345 & 1321 & 1319 & 1323 & 1323 & 1330 & 1325 + & 648 & 637 & 635 & 640 & 640 & 656 & 650 + + a@xmath86 & 344 & 257 & 319 & 344 & 346 & 354 & 344 + b@xmath72 & 985 & 947 & 957 & 998 & 996 & 1011 & 999 + & 803 & 772 & 783 & 816 & 816 & 837 & 829 + b@xmath63 & 930 & 896 & 904 & 919 & 921 & 940 & 930 + & 297 & 228 & 270 & 276 & 270 & 258 & 250 + & mode & b97 - 1 & ccsd(t)/b97 - 1 & irm@xcite & ref.@xcite & sp@xcite & fmi@xcite + + a@xmath85 & 1 & 3073 & 3107 & 3010 & 3040 & 3089 & 3090 + & 2 & 1424 & 1408 & 1415 & 1489 & 1417@xmath87 & 1418@xmath87 + & 3 & 1024 & 1000 & 1009 & 990 & 1015 & 1017 + & 4 & 741 & 735 & 736 & 737 & 734 & 736 + b@xmath74 & 11 & 3070 & 3104 & 3086 & 3070 & 3086 & 3090 + & 12 & 1204 & 1189 & 1204 & 1200 & 1204 & 1200 + & 13 & 1079 & 1081 & 1093 & 1106 & 1109@xmath70 & 1103@xmath70 + b@xmath73 & 14 & 1445 & 1437 & 1448 & 1434 & 1448 & 1440 + & 15 & 1112@xmath75 & 1102 & 1108 & 1187 & 1151 & + & 16 & 927 & 885 & 883 & 1085 & 893@xmath70 & 881@xmath70 + b@xmath79 & 8 & 1511 & 1511 & 1525 & 1543 & 1523@xmath87 & 1521@xmath87 + & 9 & 1294 & 1293 & 1290 & 1278 & 1302 & 1303 + & 10 & 645 & 638 & 640 & 679 & 649 & 651 + + a@xmath86 & 5 & 336 & 338 & 335 & 319 & 335 & 335 + b@xmath72 & 6 & 977 & 974 & 994 & 925 & 1015 & + & 7 & 814 & 801 & 801 & 775 & 799 & 800 + b@xmath63 & 17 & 911 & 902 & 929 & 890 & 929 & 904 + & 18 & 244 & 261 & 254 & 340 & 254 & 254 + & 15.2@xmath68(15.1,14.8@xmath69 ) & 54.8 ( 57.5 ) & 19.0 ( 19.4 ) & 16.0 ( 15.6 ) + & 12.2@xmath68(11.3,9.4@xmath69 ) & 63.5 ( 64.5 ) & 20.1 ( 20.3 ) & 11.0 ( 10.2 ) + + + + + + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: this paper is based on three lectures i gave at the conference on `` renormalization and galois theories '' that was held in luminy , at the centre international de rencontres mathmatiques ( cirm ) , on march 2006 . the purpose of these talks was to give an elementary overview on classical motives ( pure motives ) and to survey on some of the recent developments of this theory in noncommutative geometry , especially following the introduction of the notion of an _ endomotive_. it is likely to expect that the reader acquainted with the literature on motives theory will not fail to notice the allusion , in this title , to the paper @xcite in which p. deligne states that in spite of the lack of essential progresses on the problem of constructing `` relevant '' algebraic cycles , the techniques supplied by the theory of motives remain a powerful tool in algebraic geometry and arithmetic . the assertion on the lack of relevant progresses on algebraic cycles seems , unfortunately , still to apply at the present time , fifteen years after deligne wrote his paper . despite the general failure of testing the standard conjectures , it is also true that in these recent years the knowledge on motives has been substantially improved by several new results and also by some unexpected developments . motives were introduced by a. grothendieck with the aim to supply an intrinsic explanation for the analogies occurring among various cohomological theories in algebraic geometry . they are expected to play the role of a universal cohomological theory by also furnishing a linearization of the theory of algebraic varieties and in the original understanding they were expected to provide the correct framework for a successful approach to the weil s conjectures on the zeta - function of a variety over a finite field . even though the weil s conjectures have been proved by deligne without appealing to the theory of motives , an enlarged and in part still conjectural theory of mixed motives has in the meanwhile proved its usefulness in explaining conceptually , some intriguing phenomena arising in several areas of pure mathematics , such as hodge theory , @xmath0-theory , algebraic cycles , polylogarithms , @xmath1-functions , galois representations etc . very recently , some new developments of the theory of motives to number - theory and quantum field theory have been found or are about to be developed , with the support of techniques supplied by noncommutative geometry and the theory of operator algebras . in number - theory , a conceptual understanding of the main result of @xcite on the interpretation proposed by a. connes of the weil explicit formulae as a lefschetz trace formula over the noncommutative space of adle classes , requires the introduction of a generalized category of motives inclusive of spaces which are highly singular from a classical viewpoint . the problem of finding a suitable enlargement of the category of ( smooth projective ) algebraic varieties is combined with the even more compelling one of the definition of a generalized notion of correspondences . several questions arise already when one considers special types of zero - dimensional noncommutative spaces , such as the space underlying the quantum statistical dynamical system defined by j. b. bost and connes in @xcite ( the bc - system ) . this space is a simplified version of the adles class space of @xcite and it encodes in its group of symmetries , the arithmetic of the maximal abelian extension of @xmath2 . in this paper i give an overview on the theory of endomotives ( algebraic and analytic ) . this theory has been originally developed in the joint paper @xcite with a. connes and m. marcolli and has been applied already in our subsequent work @xcite . the category of endomotives is the minimal one that makes it possible to understand conceptually the role played by the absolute galois group in several dynamical systems that have been recently introduced in noncommutative geometry as generalizations of the bc - system , which was our motivating and prototype example . the category of endomotives is a natural enlargement of the category of artin motives : the objects are noncommutative spaces defined by semigroup actions on projective limits of artin motives . the morphisms generalize the notion of algebraic correspondences and are defined by means of tale groupoids to account for the presence of the semigroup actions . endomotives carry a natural galois action which is inherited from the artin motives and they have both an algebraic and an analytic description . the latter is particularly useful as it provides the data of a quantum statistical dynamical system , via the implementation of a _ canonical time evolution _ ( a one - parameter family of automorphisms ) which is associated by the theory of m. tomita ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) to an initial state ( probability measure ) assigned on an analytic endomotive . this is the crucial new development supplied by the theory of operator - algebras to a noncommutative @xmath3-algebra and in particular to the algebra of the bc - system . the implication in number - theory is striking : the time evolution implements on the dual system a scaling action which combines with the action of the galois group to determine on the cyclic homology of a suitable noncommutative motive associated to the original endomotive , a characteristic zero analog of the action of the weil group on the tale cohomology of an algebraic variety . when these techniques are applied to the endomotive of the bc - system or to the endomotive of the adles class space , the main implication is the spectral realization of the zeroes of the corresponding @xmath1-functions . these results supply a first answer to the question i raised in the title of this paper ( a quoi servent les endomotifs ? ) . an open and interesting problem is connected to the definition of a higher dimensional theory of noncommutative motives and in particular the introduction of a theory of noncommutative elliptic motives and modular forms . a related problem is of course connected to the definition of a higher dimensional theory of geometric correspondences . the comparison between algebraic correspondences for motives and geometric correspondences for noncommutative spaces is particularly easy in the zero - dimensional case , because the equivalence relations play no role . in noncommutative geometry , algebraic cycles are naturally replaced by bi - modules , or by classes in equivariant @xmath4-theory . naturally , the original problem of finding `` interesting '' cycles pops - up again in this topological framework : a satisfactory solution to this question seems to be one of the main steps to undertake for a further development of these ideas . the theory of motives in algebraic geometry was established by a. grothendieck in the 1960s : 1963 - 69 ( _ cf . _ @xcite,@xcite ) . the foundations are documented in the unpublished manuscript @xcite and were discussed in a seminar at the institut des hautes tudes scientifiques , in 1967 . this theory was conceived as a fundamental machine to develop grothendieck s `` long - run program '' focused on the theme of the connections between geometry and arithmetic . at the heart of the philosophy of motives sit grothendieck s speculations on the existence of a universal cohomological theory for algebraic varieties defined over a base field @xmath5 and taking values into an abelian , tensor category . the study of this problem originated as the consequence of a general dissatisfaction connected to an extensive use of topological methods in algebraic geometry , with the result of producing several but insufficiently related cohomological theories ( betti , de - rham , tale etc . ) . the typical example is furnished by a family of homomorphisms @xmath6 connecting the groups of tale cohomology of two ( smooth , projective ) varieties , as the prime number @xmath7 varies , which are not connected , in general , by any sort of ( canonical ) relation . the definition of a contravariant functor ( functor of motivic cohomology ) @xmath8 from the category @xmath9 of projective , smooth , irreducible algebraic varieties over @xmath5 to a semi - simple abelian category of pure motives @xmath10 is also tied up with the definition of a universal cohomological theory through which every other classical , cohomology @xmath11 ( here understood as contravariant functor ) should factor by means of the introduction of a fiber functor ( realization @xmath12-functor ) @xmath13 connecting @xmath10 to the abelian category of ( graded ) vector - spaces over @xmath2 v_k & ^h^ & grv ect _ + & _ h & ^ + & & m_k(v_k ) following grothendieck s original viewpoint , the functor @xmath14 should implement the sought for mechanism of compatibilities ( in tale cohomology ) and at the same time it should also describe a universal linearization of the theory of algebraic varieties . the definition of the category @xmath10 arised from a classical construction in algebraic geometry which is based on the idea of extending the collection of algebraic morphisms in @xmath9 by including the ( algebraic ) _ correspondences_. a correspondence between two objects @xmath15 and @xmath16 in @xmath9 is a multi - valued map which connects them . an algebraic correspondence is defined by means of an algebraic cycle in the cartesian product @xmath17 . the concept of ( algebraic ) correspondence in geometry is much older than that of a motive : it is in fact already present in several works of the italian school in algebraic geometry ( _ cf . _ severi s theory of correspondences on algebraic curves ) . grothendieck s new intuition was that the whole philosophy of motives is regulated by the theory of ( algebraic ) correspondences : `` _ ... jappelle motif sur @xmath5 quelque chose comme un groupe de cohomologie @xmath7-adique dun schema algbrique sur @xmath5 , mais considre comme indpendant de @xmath7 , et avec sa structure entire , ou disons pour linstant sur @xmath2 , dduite de la thorie des cycles algbriques ... _ '' ( _ cf . _ @xcite , lettre 16.8.1964 ) . motives were envisioned with the hope to explain the intrinsic relations between integrals of algebraic functions in one or more complex variables . their ultimate goal was to supply a machine that would guarantee a generalization of the main results of galois theory to systems of polynomials equations in several variables . here , we refer in particular to a higher - dimensional analog of the well - known result which describes the linearization of the galois - grothendieck correspondence for the category @xmath18 of tale , finite @xmath5-schemes @xmath19 by means of the equivalence between the category of artin motives and that of the representations of the absolute galois group . in the following section we shall describe how the fundamental notions of the theory of motives arose from the study of several classical problems in geometry and arithmetic . a classical problem in algebraic geometry is that of computing the solutions of a finite set of polynomial equations @xmath20 with coefficients in a finite field @xmath21 . this study is naturally formalized by introducing the generating series @xmath22 which is associated to the algebraic variety @xmath23 that is defined as the set of the common zeroes of the polynomials @xmath24 . under the assumption that @xmath15 is smooth and projective , the series encodes the complete information on the number of the rational points of the algebraic variety , through the coefficients @xmath25 . the integers @xmath26 supply the cardinality of the set of the rational points of @xmath15 , computed in successive finite field extensions @xmath27 of the base field @xmath21 . intersection theory furnishes a general way to determine the number @xmath26 as intersection number of two algebraic cycles on the cartesian product @xmath28 : namely the diagonal @xmath29 and the graph @xmath30 of the @xmath31-th iterated composite of the frobenius morphism on the scheme @xmath32 : @xmath33 the frobenius endomorphism is in fact an interesting example of _ correspondence _ , perhaps the most interesting one , for algebraic varieties defined over finite fields . as a correspondence it induces a commutative diagram @xmath34 in tale cohomology . through the commutativity of the above diagram one gets a way to express the action of the induced homomorphism in cohomology , by means of the formula @xmath35 where @xmath36 denote the two projection maps . here , ` algebraic ' refers to the algebraic cycle @xmath37 that performs such a correspondence . for particularly simple algebraic varieties , such as projective spaces @xmath38 , the computation of the integers @xmath26 can be done by applying an elementary combinatorial argument based on the set - theoretical description of the space @xmath39 ( @xmath40 any field ) . this has the effect to produce the interesting description @xmath41 this decomposition of the set of the rational points of a projective space was certainly a first source of inspiration in the process of formalizing the foundations of the theory of motives . in fact , one is naturally led to wonder on the casuality of the decomposition , possibly ascribing such a result to the presence of a cellular decomposition on the projective space which induces a related break - up on the set of the rational points . remarkably , a. weil proved that a similar formula holds also in the more general case of a smooth , projective algebraic curve @xmath42 of genus @xmath43 . in this case one shows that @xmath44 these results suggest that and are the manifestation of a deep and intrinsic structure that governs the geometry of algebraic varieties . the development of the theory of motives has in fact shown to us that this structure reveals itself in several contexts : topologically , manifests its presence in the decomposition of the cohomology @xmath45 , whereas arithmetically it turns out that it is the same structure that controls the decomposition of the series as a rational function of @xmath46 : @xmath47 this is in fact a consequence of the description of the integers @xmath26 supplied by the lefschetz - grothendieck trace formula ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) @xmath48 originally , grothendieck proposed a general framework for a so called category of _ numerically effective motives _ @xmath49 over a field @xmath5 and with rational coefficients . this category is defined by enlarging the category @xmath9 of smooth , projective algebraic varieties over @xmath5 ( and algebraic morphisms ) by following the so - called procedure of pseudo - abelian envelope . this construction is performed in two steps : at first one enlarges the set of morphisms of @xmath9 by including ( rational ) algebraic correspondences of degree zero , modulo numerical equivalence , then one performs a pseudo - abelian envelope by formally including among the objects , kernels of idempotent morphisms . let us assume for simplicity that the algebraic varieties are irreducible ( the general case is then deduced from this , by additivity ) . for any given @xmath50 , one works with correspondences @xmath51 which are elements of codimension equal to @xmath52 in the rational graded algebra @xmath53 of algebraic cycles modulo _ numerical equivalence_. we recall that two algebraic cycles on an algebraic variety @xmath15 are said to be numerically equivalent @xmath54 , if @xmath55 for any algebraic cycle @xmath56 on @xmath15 . here , by @xmath57 we mean the degree of the algebraic cycle @xmath58 . the degree defines a homomorphism from the free abelian group of algebraic cycles @xmath59 to the integers . on the components @xmath60 , the map is defined as follows @xmath61 the symbol ` @xmath62 ' in refers to the intersection product structure on @xmath63 , which is well - defined under the assumption of proper intersection . if @xmath64 is proper ( _ i.e. _ @xmath65 ) , then intersection theory supplies the definition of an intersection cycle @xmath66 . moreover , the intersection product is commutative and associative whenever is defined . passing from the free abelian group @xmath63 to the quotient @xmath67 , modulo a suitable equivalence relation on cycles , allows one to use classical results of algebraic geometry ( so called moving lemmas ) which lead to the definition of a ring structure . one then defines intersection cycle classes in general , even when cycles do not intersect properly , by intersecting equivalent cycles which fulfill the required geometric property of proper intersection . it is natural to guess that the use of the numerical equivalence in the original definition of the category of motives was motivated by the study of classical constructions in enumerative geometry , such as for example the computation of the number of the rational points of an algebraic variety defined over a finite field . one of the main original goals was to show that for a suitable definition of an equivalence relation on algebraic cycles , the corresponding category of motives is _ semi - simple_. this means that the objects @xmath68 in the category decompose , following the rules of a _ theory of weights _ ( _ cf . _ section [ fundstructures ] ) , into direct _ factors _ @xmath69 , with @xmath70 simple ( _ i.e. _ indecomposable ) motives associated to smooth , projective algebraic varieties . the importance of achieving such a result is quite evident if one seeks , for example , to understand categorically the decomposition @xmath71 in cohomology , or if one wants to recognize the role of motives in the factorization of zeta - functions of algebraic varieties . grothendieck concentrated his efforts on the numerical equivalence relation which is the coarsest among the equivalence relations on algebraic cycles . so doing , he attacked the problem of the semi - simplicity of the category of motives from the easiest side . however , despite a promising departing point , the statement on the semi - simplicity escaped all his efforts . in fact , the result he was able to reach at that time was dependent on the assumption of the _ standard conjectures _ , two strong topological statements on algebraic cycles . the proof of the semi - simplicity of the category of motives for numerical equivalence ( the only equivalence relation producing this result ) was achieved only much later on in the development of the theory ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) . the proof found by u. jannsen uses a fairly elementary but ingenious idea which mysteriously eluded grothendieck s intuition as well as all the mental grasps of several mathematicians after him . by looking at the construction of ( pure ) motives in perspective , one immediately recognizes the predominant role played by the morphisms over the objects , in the category @xmath49 . this was certainly a great intuition of grothendieck . this idea led to a systematic study of the properties of algebraic cycles and their decomposition by means of _ algebraic projectors _ , that is algebraic cycles classes @xmath72 satisfying the property @xmath73 notice that in order to make sense of the notion of a projector and more in general , in order to define a law of composition ` @xmath74 ' on algebraic correspondences , one needs to use the ring structure on the graded algebra @xmath75 . the operation ` @xmath74 ' is defined as follows . let us assume for simplicity , that the algebraic varieties are connected ( the general case can be easily deduced from this ) . then , two algebraic correspondences @xmath76 ( of degree @xmath77 ) and @xmath78 ( of degree @xmath79 ) compose accordingly to the following rule ( bi - linear , associative ) @xmath80 @xmath81 in the particular case of projectors @xmath82 , one is restricted , in order to make a sense of the condition @xmath83 , to use only particular types of algebraic correspondences : namely those of degree zero . these are the elements of the abelian group @xmath84 . the objects of the category @xmath49 are then pairs @xmath85 , with @xmath86 and @xmath87 a projector . this way , one attains the notion of a @xmath2-linear , pseudo - abelian , monoidal category ( the @xmath12-monoidal structure is deduced from the cartesian product of algebraic varieties ) , together with the definition of a contravariant functor @xmath88 here @xmath89 denotes the motive associated to @xmath15 and @xmath90 means the trivial ( _ i.e. _ identity ) projector associated to the diagonal @xmath29 . more in general , @xmath85 refers to the motive @xmath91 that is cut - off on @xmath92 by the ( range of the ) projector @xmath82 . notice that images of projectors are formally included among the objects of @xmath49 , by the procedure of the pseudo - abelian envelope . the cut - off performed by a projector @xmath87 on the space determines a corresponding operation in cohomology ( for any classical weil theory ) , by singling out the sub - vector space @xmath93 . the category @xmath49 has two important basic objects : @xmath94 and @xmath95 . @xmath96 is the _ unit motive _ @xmath97 this is defined by the zero - dimensional algebraic variety associated to a point , whereas @xmath98 is the so - called _ lefschetz motive_. this motive determines , jointly with @xmath96 , a decomposition of the motive associated to the projective line @xmath99 @xmath100 one can show that the algebraic cycles @xmath101 and @xmath102 on @xmath103 do not depend on the choice of the rational point @xmath104 and that their sum is a cycle equivalent to the diagonal . this fact implies that the decomposition is canonical . more in general , it follows from the knneth decomposition of the diagonal @xmath105 in @xmath106 by algebraic cycles @xmath107 , ( _ cf . _ @xcite and @xcite for the details ) that the motive of a projective space @xmath108 decomposes into pieces ( simple motives ) @xmath109 where @xmath110 , @xmath111 . it is precisely this decomposition which implies the decomposition on the rational points , when @xmath112 ! for ( irreducible ) curves , and in the presence of a rational point @xmath113 , one obtains a similar decomposition ( non canonical ) @xmath114 with @xmath115 , @xmath116 and @xmath117 . this decomposition is responsible for the formula . in fact , one can prove that these decompositions partially generalize to any object @xmath86 . in the presence of a rational point , or more in general by choosing a positive zero - cycle @xmath118 ( here @xmath15 is assumed irreducible for simplicity and @xmath119 ) , one constructs two rational algebraic cycles @xmath120 which determine two projectors @xmath121 in the chow group @xmath122 of rational algebraic cycles modulo rational equivalence . the corresponding classes in @xmath123 ( if not zero ) determine two motives @xmath124 and @xmath125 ( _ cf . _ _ e.g. _ @xcite ) . for the applications , it is convenient to enlarge the category of effective motives by formally adding the tensor product inverse @xmath126 of the lefschetz motive : one usually refers to it as to the _ tate motive_. it corresponds , from the more refined point of view of galois theory , to the cyclotomic characters . this enlargement of @xmath49 by the so - called `` virtual motives '' produces an abelian , semi - simple category @xmath127 of pure motives for numerical equivalence . the objects of this category are now triples @xmath128 , with @xmath129 . effective motives are of course objects of this category and they are described by triples @xmath130 . the lefschetz motive gains a new interpretation in this category as @xmath131 . the tate motive is defined by @xmath132 and is therefore reminissent of ( in fact induces ) the notion of tate structure @xmath133 in hodge theory . in the category @xmath127 , the set of morphisms connecting two motives @xmath128 and @xmath134 is defined by @xmath135 in particular , @xmath136 , one defines the two motives @xmath137 these determine a canonical decomposition of any virtual motive as @xmath138 , where the direct sum of two motives as the above ones is defined by the formula @xmath139 the general definition of the direct sum of two motives requires a bit more of formalism which escapes this short overview : we refer to _ op.cit . _ for the details . the tensor structure @xmath140 and the involution ( _ i.e. _ auto - duality ) which is defined , for @xmath15 irreducible and @xmath119 by the functor @xmath141 ( the general case follows from this by applying additivity ) , determine the structure of a _ rigid _ @xmath12-_category _ on @xmath142 . here , @xmath143 denotes the transpose correspondence associated to @xmath87 ( _ i.e. _ the transpose of the graph ) . one finds , for example , that @xmath144 . in the particular case of the effective motive @xmath92 , with @xmath15 irreducible and @xmath119 , this involution determines the notion of poincar duality @xmath145 that is an auto - duality which induces the poincar duality isomorphism in any classical cohomological theory . a category of pure motives over a field @xmath5 and with coefficients in a field @xmath0 ( of characteristic zero ) is supposed to satisfy , to be satisfactory , several basic properties and to be endowed with a few fundamental structures . in the previous section we have described the historically - first example of a category of pure motives and we have reviewed some of its basic properties ( in that case @xmath146 ) . one naturally wonders about the description of others categories of motives associated to finer ( than the numerical ) equivalence relations on algebraic cycles : namely the categories of motives for homological or rational or algebraic equivalence relations . however , if one seeks to work with a semi - simple category , the afore mentioned result of jannsen tells us that the numerical equivalence is the only adequate relation . the semi - simplicity property is also attaint if one assumes grothendieck s standard conjectures . following the report of grothendieck in @xcite , these conjectures arose from the hope to understand ( read prove ) the conjectures of weil on the zeta - function of an algebraic variety defined over a finite field . it was well - known to grothendieck that the standard conjectures imply the weil s conjectures . these latter statements became a theorem in the early seventies ( 1974 ) , only a few years later the time when grothendieck stated the standard conjectures ( 1968 - 69 ) . the proof by deligne of the weil s conjectures , however , does not make any use of the standard conjectures , these latter questions remain still unanswered at the present time . the moral lesson seems to be that geometric topology and the theory of algebraic cycles govern in many central aspects the foundations of algebraic geometry . the standard conjectures of `` lefschetz type '' and of `` hodge type '' are stated in terms of algebraic cycles modulo homological equivalence ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) . they imply two further important conjectures . one of these states the equality of the homological and the numerical equivalence relations , the other one , of `` knneth type '' claims that the knneth decomposition of the diagonal in cohomology , can be described by means of ( rational ) algebraic cycles . it is generally accepted , nowadays , to refer to the full set of the four conjectures , when one quotes the standard conjectures . in view of their expected consequences , one is naturally led to study a category of pure _ motives for homological equivalence_. in fact , there are several candidates for this category since the definition depends upon the choice of a weil cohomological theory ( _ i.e. _ betti , tale , de - rham , crystalline , etc ) with coefficients in a field @xmath0 of characteristic zero . let us fix a cohomological theory @xmath147 for algebraic varieties in the category @xmath9 . then , the construction of the corresponding category of motives @xmath148 for homological equivalence is given following a procedure similar to that we have explained earlier on in this paper for the category of motives for numerical equivalence and with rational coefficients . the only difference is that now morphisms in the category @xmath149 are defined by means of algebraic correspondences modulo homological equivalence . at this point , one makes explicit use of the axiom `` cycle map '' that characterizes ( together with finiteness , poincar duality , knneth formula , cycle map , weak and strong lefschetz theorems ) any weil cohomological theory ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) . the set of algebraic morphisms connecting objects in the category @xmath9 is enlarged by including multi - valued maps @xmath150 that are defined as a @xmath0-linear combination of elements of the vector spaces @xmath151 where @xmath152 is a subfield . two cycles @xmath153 are _ homologically equivalent _ @xmath154 if their image , by means of the cycle class map @xmath155 is the same . this leads naturally to the definition of a subvector - space @xmath156 generated by the image of the cycle class map @xmath157 . these spaces define the correspondences in the category @xmath148 . if @xmath15 is purely @xmath158-dimensional , then @xmath159 in general , if @xmath15 decomposes into several connected components @xmath160 , one sets @xmath161 . in direct analogy to the construction of correspondences for numerical equivalence , the ring structure ( `` cap - product '' ) in cohomology determines a composition law ` @xmath74 ' among correspondences . the category @xmath149 is then defined as follows : the objects are triples @xmath162 , where @xmath86 , @xmath129 and @xmath163 is an idempotent . the collection of morphisms between two motives @xmath162 , @xmath164 is given by the set @xmath165 this procedure determines a pseudo - abelian , @xmath0-linear tensor category . the tensor law is given by the formula @xmath166 the commutativity and associativity constraints are induced by the obvious isomorphisms @xmath167 , @xmath168 . the unit object in the category is given by @xmath169 . one shows that @xmath149 is a _ rigid _ category , as it is endowed with an auto - duality functor @xmath170 for any object @xmath68 , the functor @xmath171 is left - adjoint to @xmath172 and @xmath173 is right - adjoint to @xmath174 . in the case of an irreducible variety @xmath15 , the internal hom is defined by the motive @xmath175 the standard conjecture of knneth type ( which is assumed from now on in this section ) implies that the knneth components of the diagonal @xmath176 determine a complete system of orthogonal , central idempotents . this important statement implies that the motive @xmath177 has the expected direct sum decomposition ( unique ) @xmath178 the cohomology functor @xmath179 factors through the projection @xmath180 . more in general , one shows that every motive @xmath181 gets this way a @xmath182-_grading _ structure by setting @xmath183 this grading is respected by all morphisms in the category and defines the structure of a _ graduation by weights _ on the objects . on a motive @xmath184 in the category , one sets @xmath185 where @xmath186 is a pure motive of weight @xmath77 . one finds for example , that @xmath96 has weight zero , @xmath187 has weight @xmath188 and that @xmath189 has weight @xmath190 . more in general , the motive @xmath191 has weight @xmath192 . in order to achieve further important properties , one needs to modify the natural commutativity constraint @xmath193 , @xmath194 , by defining @xmath195 we shall denote by @xmath196 the category of motives for homological equivalence in which one has implemented the modification on the tensor product structure . an important structure on a category of pure motives ( for homological equivalence ) is given by assigning to an object @xmath197 a _ motivic cohomology _ @xmath198 . @xmath198 is a pure motive of weight @xmath77 . this way , one views pure motives as a universal cohomological theory for algebraic varieties . the main property of the motivic cohomology is that it defines a universal realization of any given weil cohomology theory @xmath199 . candidates for these motivic cohomology theories have been proposed by a. beilinson @xcite , in terms of eigenspaces of adams operations in algebraic @xmath0-theory _ @xmath200 and by s. bloch @xcite , in terms of higher chow groups _ i.e. _ @xmath201 . the assignment of a weil cohomological theory with coefficients in a field @xmath0 which contains an assigned field @xmath202 is equivalent to the definition of an exact _ realization @xmath12-functor _ of @xmath203 in the category of @xmath0-vector spaces @xmath204 in particular , one obtains the realization @xmath205 which defines the notion of the _ tate twist _ in cohomology . more precisely : in tale cohomology : @xmath206 , where @xmath207 is a @xmath208-vector space of dimension one endowed with the cyclotomic action of the absolute galois group @xmath209 . the `` twist '' ( or torsion ) @xmath210 in tale cohomology corresponds to the torsion in galois theory defined by the @xmath211-th power of the cyclotomic character ( tate twist ) in de - rham theory : @xmath212 , with the hodge filtration defined by @xmath213 , @xmath214 . here , the effect of the torsion @xmath210 is that of shifting the hodge filtration of @xmath215-steps ( to the right ) in betti theory : @xmath216 . the bi - graduation on @xmath217 is purely of type @xmath218 . the torsion @xmath210 is here identified with the composite of a homothety given by a multiplication by @xmath219 followed by a shifting by @xmath220 of the hodge bi - graduation . using the structure of rigid tensor - category one introduces the notion of _ rank _ associated to a motive @xmath221 in @xmath196 . the rank of @xmath68 is defined as the trace of @xmath222 _ i.e. _ the trace of the morphism @xmath223 , where @xmath224 are _ resp . _ the evaluation and co - evaluation morphisms satisfying @xmath225 , @xmath226 . in general , one sets @xmath227 under the assumption of the standard conjectures ( more precisely under the assumption that homological and numerical equivalence relations coincide ) and that @xmath228 ( @xmath229 ) , the tannakian formalism invented by grothendieck and developed by saavedra @xcite , and deligne @xcite implies that the abelian , rigid , semi - simple tensor category @xmath196 is endowed with an exact , faithful @xmath12-fibre functor to the category of graded @xmath0-vector spaces @xmath230 which is compatible with the realization functor . this formalism defines a _ tannakian _ ( _ neutral _ if @xmath231 ) structure on the category of motives . one then introduces the _ tannakian group _ @xmath232 as a @xmath0-scheme in affine groups . through the tannakian formalism one shows that the fibre functor @xmath13 realizes an equivalence of rigid tensor categories @xmath233 where @xmath234 denotes the rigid tensor category of finite dimensional , @xmath202 representations of the tannakian group @xmath235 . this way , one establishes a quite useful dictionary between categorical @xmath12-properties and properties of the associated groups . because we have assumed all along the standard conjectures , the semi - simplicity of the category @xmath236 implies that @xmath235 is an algebraic , pro - reductive group , that is @xmath235 is the projective limit of reductive @xmath202-algebraic groups . the tannakian theory is a linear analog of the theory of finite , tale coverings of a given connected scheme . this theory was developed by grothendieck in sga1 ( theory of the pro - finite @xmath237 ) . for this reason the group @xmath235 is usually referred to as the _ motivic galois group _ associated to @xmath9 and @xmath199 . in the case of algebraic varieties of dimension zero ( _ i.e. _ for artin motives ) the tannakian group @xmath235 is nothing but the ( absolute ) galois group @xmath238 . in any reasonable cohomological theory the functors @xmath239 are deduced by applying standard methods of homological algebra to the related derived functors @xmath240 which associate to an object in @xmath9 a bounded complex of @xmath5-vector spaces , in a suitable triangulated category @xmath241 of complexes of modules over @xmath5 , whose heart is the category of motives . this is the definition of cohomology as @xmath242 under the assumption that the functors @xmath243 are realizations of corresponding motivic functors _ @xmath244 , one expects the existence of a ( non - canonical ) isomorphism in @xmath245 @xmath246.\ ] ] moreover , the introduction of the motivic derived functors @xmath247 suggests the definition of the following groups of _ absolute cohomology _ @xmath248).\ ] ] for a general motive @xmath249 , one defines @xmath250 ) = \text{ext}^i({\bf 1},m).\ ] ] the motives @xmath198 and the groups of absolute motivic cohomology are related by a spectral sequence @xmath251 the first interesting examples of pure motives arise by considering the category @xmath18 of tale , finite @xmath5-schemes . an object in this category is a scheme @xmath252 , where @xmath253 is a commutative @xmath5-algebra of finite dimension which satisfies the following properties . let @xmath254 denote a fixed separable closure of @xmath5 1 . @xmath255}$ ] 2 . @xmath256 , for @xmath257 finite , separable field extensions 3 . @xmath258 $ ] . the corresponding rigid , tensor - category of motives with coefficients in a field @xmath0 is usually referred to as the category of _ artin motives _ : @xmath259 . the definition of this category is independent of the choice of the equivalence relation on cycles as the objects of @xmath18 are smooth , projective @xmath5-varieties of dimension zero . one also sees that passing from @xmath18 to @xmath260 requires adding new objects in order to attain the property that the category of motives is abelian . one can verify this already for @xmath261 , by considering the real quadratic extension @xmath262 and the one - dimensional non - trivial representation of @xmath263 that factors through the character of order two of @xmath264 . this representation does not correspond to any object in @xmath265 , but can be obtained as the image of the projector @xmath266 , where @xmath267 is the generator of @xmath264 . therefore , @xmath268 is a new object . the category of artin motives is a semi - simple , @xmath0-linear , monoidal @xmath12-category . when @xmath269 , the commutative diagram of functors @xmath270 where @xmath271 is the contravariant functor of linearization @xmath272 determines a linearization of the galois - grothendieck correspondence ( gg ) by means of the equivalence of categories @xmath273 . this is provided by the fiber functor @xmath274 and by applying the tannakian formalism . it follows that @xmath275 is @xmath12-equivalent to the category @xmath276 of representations of the absolute galois group @xmath209 . these results were the departing point for grothendieck s speculations on the definition of higher dimensional galois theories ( _ i.e. _ galois theories associated to system of polynomials in several variables ) and for the definition of the corresponding motivic galois groups . the notion of an _ endomotive _ in noncommutative geometry ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) is the natural generalization of the classical concept of an artin motive for the noncommutative spaces which are defined by semigroup actions on projective limits of zero - dimensional algebraic varieties , endowed with an action of the absolute galois group . this notion applies quite naturally for instance , to the study of several examples of quantum statistical dynamical systems whose time evolution describes important number - theoretic properties of a given field @xmath5 ( _ cf . _ _ op.cit_ , @xcite ) . there are two distinct definitions of an endomotive : one speaks of algebraic or analytic endomotives depending upon the context and the applications . when @xmath5 is a number field , there is a functor connecting the two related categories . moreover , the abelian category of artin motives embeds naturally as a full subcategory in the category of algebraic endomotives ( _ cf . _ theorem [ ncartinthm ] ) and this result motivates the statement that the theory of endomotives defines a natural generalization of the classical theory of ( zero - dimensional ) artin motives . in noncommutative geometry , where the properties of a space ( frequently highly singular from a classical viewpoint ) are analyzed in terms of the properties of the associated noncommutative algebra and its ( space of ) irreducible representations , it is quite natural to look for a suitable abelian category which enlarges the original , non - additive category of algebras and in which one may also apply the standard techniques of homological algebra . likewise in the construction of a theory of motives , one seeks to work within a triangulated category endowed with several structures . these include for instance , the definition of ( noncommutative ) motivic objects playing the role of motivic cohomology ( _ cf . _ ) , the construction of a universal ( co)homological theory representing in this context the absolute motivic cohomology ( _ cf . _ ) and possibly also the set - up of a noncommutative tannakian formalism to motivate in rigorous mathematical terms the presence of certain universal groups of symmetries associated to renormalizable quantum field theories ( _ cf . _ _ e.g. _ @xcite ) . a way to attack these problems is that of enlarging the original category of algebras and morphisms by introducing a `` derived '' category of modules enriched with a suitable notion of correspondences connecting the objects that should also account for the structure of morita equivalence which represents the noncommutative generalization of the notion of isomorphism for commutative algebras . the sought for enlargement of the category @xmath277 of ( unital ) @xmath5-algebras and ( unital ) algebra homomorphisms is defined by introducing a new category @xmath278 of cyclic @xmath279-modules . the objects of this category are modules over the _ cyclic category _ @xmath280 . this latter has the same objects as the simplicial category @xmath105 ( @xmath280 contains @xmath105 as sub - category ) . we recall that an object in @xmath105 is a totally ordered set @xmath281 = \{0<1<\ldots < n\}\ ] ] for each @xmath282 , and a morphism @xmath283 \to [ m]\ ] ] is described by an order - preserving map of sets @xmath284 . the set of morphisms in @xmath105 is generated by faces @xmath285 \to [ n]$ ] ( the injection that misses @xmath77 ) and degeneracies @xmath286 \to [ n]$ ] ( the surjection which identifies @xmath79 with @xmath287 ) which satisfy several standard simplicial identities ( _ cf . _ _ e.g. _ @xcite ) . the set of morphisms in @xmath280 is enriched by introducing a new collection of morphisms : the _ cyclic morphisms_. for each @xmath282 , one sets @xmath288 \to [ n]\ ] ] fulfilling the relations @xmath289 \tau_n \sigma_i = \sigma_{i-1 } \tau_{n+1 } & 1 \leq i \leq n , & \tau_n \sigma_0 = \sigma_n \tau_{n+1}^2 \\[3 mm ] \tau_n^{n+1 } = 1_n . & & \end{array}\ ] ] the objects of the category @xmath278 are @xmath5-modules over @xmath280 ( _ i.e. _ @xmath279-modules ) . in categorical language this means functors @xmath290 ( @xmath291 category of @xmath5-modules ) . morphisms of @xmath279-modules are therefore natural transformations between the corresponding functors . it is evident that @xmath278 is an abelian category , because of the interpretation of a morphism in @xmath278 as a collection of @xmath5-linear maps of @xmath5-modules @xmath292 ( @xmath293 ) compatible with faces , degeneracies and cyclic operators . kernels and cokernels of these morphisms define objects of the category @xmath278 , since their definition is given point - wise . to an algebra @xmath294 over a field @xmath5 , one associates the @xmath279-module @xmath295 . for each @xmath296 one sets @xmath297 the _ cyclic morphisms _ on @xmath298 correspond to the cyclic permutations of the tensors , while the face and the degeneracy maps correspond to the algebra product of consecutive tensors and the insertion of the unit . this construction determines a functor @xmath299 _ traces _ @xmath300 give rise naturally to morphisms @xmath301 in @xmath278 . the main result of this construction is the following canonical description of the cyclic cohomology of an algebra @xmath294 over a field @xmath5 as the derived functor of the functor which assigns to a @xmath279-module its space of traces @xmath302 ( _ cf . _ @xcite,@xcite ) . this formula is the analog of , that describes the absolute motivic cohomology group of a classical motive as an ext - group computed in a triangulated category of motives @xmath245 . in the present context , on the other hand , the derived groups @xmath303 are taken in the abelian category of @xmath278-modules . the description of the cyclic cohomology as a derived functor in the cyclic category determines a useful procedure to embed the nonadditive category of algebras and algebra homomorphisms in the `` derived '' abelian category of @xmath279-modules . this construction provides a natural framework for the definition of the objects of a category of noncommutative motives . likewise in the construction of the category of motives , one is faced with the problem of finding the `` motivated maps '' connecting cyclic modules . the natural strategy is that of enlarging the collection of cyclic morphisms which are functorially induced by homomorphisms between ( noncommutative ) algebras , by implementing an adequate definition of ( noncommutative ) correspondences . the notion of an algebraic correspondence in algebraic geometry , as a multi - valued map defined by an algebraic cycle modulo a suitable equivalence relation , has here an analog with the notion of kasparov s bimodule and the associated class in @xmath4-theory ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) . likewise in classical motive theory , one may prefer to work with ( compare ) several versions of correspondences . one may decide to retain the full information supplied by a group action on a given algebra ( _ i.e. _ a noncommutative space ) rather than partially loosing this information by moding out with the equivalence relation ( homotopy in @xmath4-theory ) . there is a natural way to associate a cyclic morphism to a ( virtual ) correspondence and hence to a class in @xmath4-theory . starting with the category of separable @xmath3-algebras and @xmath304-homomorphisms , one enlarges the collection of morphisms connecting two unital algebras @xmath294 and @xmath305 , by including correspondences defined by elements of kasparov s bivariant @xmath0-theory @xmath306 ( @xcite , _ cf . _ also 8 and 9.22 of @xcite ) . more precisely , correspondences are defined by kasparov s bimodules , that means by triples @xmath307 which satisfy the following conditions : @xmath308 is a countably generated hilbert module over @xmath309 @xmath310 is a @xmath304-homomorphism of @xmath311 to bounded linear operators on @xmath308 ( _ i.e. _ @xmath310 gives @xmath308 the structure of an @xmath311-@xmath309 bimodule ) @xmath202 is a bounded linear operator on @xmath308 such that the operators @xmath312 $ ] , @xmath313 , and @xmath314 are compact for all @xmath315 . a hilbert module @xmath308 over @xmath309 is a right @xmath309-module with a _ positive _ , @xmath309-valued inner product which satisfies @xmath316 , @xmath317 and @xmath318 , and with respect to which @xmath308 is complete ( _ i.e. _ complete in the norm @xmath319 ) . notice that kasparov bimodules are morita - type of correspondences . they generalize @xmath304-homomorphisms of @xmath3-algebras since the latter ones may be re - interpreted as kasparov bimodules of the form @xmath320 . given a kasparov s bimodule @xmath321 , that is a @xmath294-@xmath305 hilbert bimodule @xmath308 as defined above , one associates , under the assumption that @xmath308 is a projective @xmath305-module of finite type ( _ cf . _ @xcite , lemma 2.1 ) , a cyclic morphism @xmath322 this result allows one to define an enlargement of the collection of cyclic morphisms in the category @xmath278 of @xmath279-modules , by considering kasparov s projective bimodules of finite type , as correspondences . one then implements the _ homotopy equivalence relation _ on the collection of kasparov s bimodules . two kasparov s modules are said to be homotopy equivalent @xmath323 if there is an element @xmath324\to { { \mathcal}{b}}\,|\ , f \text { continuous } \}\ ] ] which performs a unitary homotopy deformation between the two modules . this means that @xmath325 is unitarily equivalent to @xmath326 or equivalently re - phrased , that there is a unitary in bounded operators from @xmath327 to @xmath328 intertwining the morphisms @xmath329 and @xmath330 and the operators @xmath331 and @xmath332 . here @xmath333 is the evaluation at the endpoints . there is a binary operation on the set of all kasparov @xmath334-@xmath305 bimodules , given by the direct sum . by definition , the group of kasparov s bivariant @xmath0-theory is the set of homotopy equivalence classes @xmath335 of kasparov s modules @xmath336 . this set has a natural structure of abelian group with addition induced by direct sum . this bivariant version of @xmath0-theory is reacher than both @xmath0-theory and @xmath0-homology , as it carries an intersection product . there is a natural bi - linear , associative composition ( intersection ) product @xmath337 for all @xmath338 and @xmath339 separable @xmath3-algebras . this product is compatible with composition of morphisms of @xmath3-algebras . @xmath4-theory is also endowed with a bi - linear , associative exterior product @xmath340 which is defined in terms on the composition product by @xmath341 a slightly different formulation of @xmath4-theory , which simplifies the definition of this external tensor product is obtained by replacing in the data @xmath342 the operator @xmath202 by an _ unbounded _ , regular self - adjoint operator @xmath343 . the corresponding @xmath202 is then given by @xmath344 ( _ cf . @xcite ) . the above construction which produces an enlargement of the category of separable @xmath3-algebras by introducing correspondences as morphisms determines an additive , although non abelian category @xmath345 ( _ cf . _ @xcite 9.22.1 ) . this category is also known to have a triangulated structure ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) and this result is in agreement with the construction of the triangulated category @xmath245 in motives theory , whose heart is expected to be the category of ( mixed ) motives ( _ cf . _ section [ fundstructures ] and @xcite ) . a more refined analysis based on the analogy with the construction of a category of motives suggests that one should probably perform a further enlargement by passing to the pseudo - abelian envelope of @xmath345 , that is by formally including among the objects also ranges of idempotents in @xmath4-theory . in section [ anendo ] we will review the category of analytic endomotives where maps are given in terms of tale correspondences described by spaces @xmath346 arising from locally compact tale groupoids @xmath347 associated to zero - dimensional , singular quotient spaces @xmath348 with associated @xmath3-algebras @xmath349 in view of what we have said in this section , it would be also possible to define a category where morphisms are given by classes @xmath350 which describe sets of equivalent triples @xmath342 , where @xmath351 is given in terms of a bimodule @xmath352 with the trivial grading @xmath353 and the zero endomorphism @xmath354 . the definition of the category of analytic endomotives is more refined because the definition of the maps in this category does not require to divide by homotopy equivalence . the comparison between correspondences for motives given by algebraic cycles and correspondences for noncommutative spaces given by bimodules ( or elements in @xmath4-theory ) is particularly easy in the zero - dimensional case because the equivalence relations play no role . of course , it would be quite interesting to investigate the higher dimensional cases , in view of a unified framework for motives and noncommutative spaces which is suggested for example , by the recent results on the lefschetz trace formula for archimedean local factors of @xmath1-functions of motives ( _ cf . _ @xcite , section 7 ) . a way to attack this problem is by comparing the notion of a correspondence given by an algebraic cycle with the notion of a geometric correspondence used in topology ( _ cf . _ @xcite , @xcite ) . for example , it is easy to see that the definition of an algebraic correspondence can be reformulated as a particular case of the topological ( geometrical ) correspondence and it is also known that one may associate to the latter a class in @xmath4-theory . in the following two sections , we shall review and comment on these ideas . in geometric topology , given two smooth manifolds @xmath15 and @xmath16 ( it is enough to assume that @xmath15 is a locally compact parameter space ) , a _ topological ( geometric ) correspondence _ is given by the datum @xmath355 where : @xmath356 is a smooth manifold @xmath308 is a complex vector bundle over @xmath356 @xmath357 and @xmath358 are continuous maps , with @xmath359 proper and @xmath360 @xmath0-oriented ( orientation in @xmath0-homology ) . unlike in the definition of an algebraic correspondence ( _ cf . _ section [ fundstructures ] ) one does not require that @xmath356 is a subset of the cartesian product @xmath17 . this flexibility is balanced by the implementation of the extra piece of datum given by the vector bundle @xmath308 . to any such correspondence @xmath361 one associates a class in kasparov s k - theory @xmath362 @xmath363 denotes the class of @xmath308 in @xmath364 and @xmath365 is the element in @xmath4-theory which fulfills the grothendieck riemann - roch formula . we recall that given two smooth manifolds @xmath366 and @xmath367 and a continuous oriented map @xmath368 , the element @xmath369 determines the grothendieck riemann roch formula @xmath370 for all @xmath371 , with @xmath372 the todd genus @xmath373 the composition of two correspondences @xmath374 and @xmath375 is given by taking the fibered product @xmath376 and the bundle @xmath377 , with @xmath378 the projections . this determines the composite correspondence @xmath379 . in fact , one also needs to assume a _ condition on the maps @xmath360 and @xmath380 in order to ensure that the fibered product @xmath356 is a smooth manifold . the homotopy invariance of both @xmath381 and @xmath382 show however that the assumption of transversality is ` generically ' satisfied . theorem 3.2 of @xcite shows that kasparov product in @xmath4-theory ` @xmath12 ' agrees with the composition of correspondences , namely @xmath383 in algebraic geometry , the notion of correspondence that comes closest to the definition of a geometric correspondence ( as an element in @xmath4-theory ) is obtained by considering classes of algebraic cycles in algebraic @xmath0-theory ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) . given two smooth and projective algebraic varieties @xmath15 and @xmath16 , we denote by @xmath384 and @xmath385 the projections of @xmath17 onto @xmath15 and @xmath16 respectively and we assume that they are _ proper_. let @xmath386 be an algebraic cycle . for simplicity , we shall assume that @xmath356 is irreducible ( the general case follows by linearity ) . we denote by @xmath387 and @xmath388 the restrictions of @xmath384 and @xmath385 to @xmath356 . to the irreducible subvariety @xmath389 one naturally associates the coherent @xmath390-module @xmath391 . for simplicity of notation we write it as @xmath392 . we use a similar notation for the coherent sheaf @xmath393 , associated to the irreducible subvariety @xmath394 . then , the sheaf pullback @xmath395 has a natural structure of @xmath396-module . the map on sheaves that corresponds to the cap product by @xmath356 on cocycles is given by @xmath397 since @xmath384 is proper , the resulting sheaf is coherent . using , we can write equivalently @xmath398 we recall that the functor @xmath399 is the right adjoint to @xmath400 ( _ i.e. _ @xmath401 ) and that @xmath399 satisfies the grothendieck riemann roch formula @xmath402 using this result , we can equally compute the intersection product of by first computing @xmath403 and then applying @xmath404 . using and we know that we can replace by @xmath405 with the same effect in @xmath0-theory . thus , to a correspondence in the sense of that is defined by the image in @xmath0-theory of an algebraic cycle @xmath406 we associate the geometric class @xmath407 with @xmath387 , @xmath408 and with the bundle @xmath409 . the composition of correspondences is given in terms of the intersection product of the associated cycles . given three smooth projective varieties @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath410 and ( virtual ) correspondences @xmath411 and @xmath412 , with @xmath413 and @xmath414 closed reduced irreducible subschemes , one defines @xmath415 @xmath416 , @xmath417 , and @xmath418 denote , as usual , the projection maps . under the assumption of ` general position ' which is the algebraic analog of the transversality requirement in topology , we obtain the following result [ corrcorr2 ] suppose given three smooth projective varieties @xmath15 , @xmath16 , and @xmath410 and algebraic correspondences @xmath419 given by @xmath420 and @xmath421 given by @xmath422 . assume that @xmath423 and @xmath424 are in general position in @xmath425 . then assigning to a cycle @xmath356 the topological correspondence @xmath426 satisfies @xmath427 where @xmath428 is the product of algebraic cycles and @xmath429 is the kasparov product of the topological correspondences . notice that , while in the topological ( smooth ) setting transversality can always be achieved by a small deformation ( _ cf . _ iii , @xcite ) , in the algebro - geometric framework one needs to modify the above construction if the cycles are not in general position . in this case the formula @xmath430\otimes [ { { \mathcal}{o}}_{t_2}]= [ { { \mathcal}{o}}_{t_1\circ t_2}]\ ] ] which describes the product in @xmath0-theory in terms of the intersection product of algebraic cycles must be modified by implementing tor - classes and one works with a product defined by the formula ( @xcite , theorem 2.7 ) @xmath431\otimes [ { { \mathcal}{o}}_{t_2}]= \sum_{i=0}^n ( -1)^i \left[{\rm tor}_i^{{{\mathcal}{o}}_x } ( { { \mathcal}{o}}_{t_1},{{\mathcal}{o}}_{t_2})\right].\ ] ] to define the category of _ algebraic endomotives _ one replaces the category @xmath432 of reduced , finite - dimensional commutative algebras ( and algebras homomorphisms ) over a field @xmath5 by the category of noncommutative algebras ( and algebras homomorphisms ) of the form @xmath433 @xmath434 denotes a unital algebra which is an inductive limit of commutative algebras @xmath435 . @xmath436 is a unital , _ abelian semigroup _ of algebra endomorphisms @xmath437 moreover , one imposes the condition that for @xmath438 , @xmath439 is an _ idempotent _ of the algebra and that @xmath440 is an isomorphism of @xmath434 with the compressed algebra @xmath441 . the crossed product algebra @xmath442 is defined by formally adjoining to @xmath434 new generators @xmath443 and @xmath444 , for @xmath438 , satisfying the algebraic rules @xmath445 since @xmath436 is abelian , these rules suffice to show that @xmath446 is the linear span of the monomials @xmath447 , for @xmath448 and @xmath449 . because @xmath450 , with @xmath451 reduced , finite - dimensional commutative algebras over @xmath5 , the construction of @xmath442 is in fact determined by assigning a _ projective system _ @xmath452 of varieties in @xmath432 ( @xmath453 is a countable indexing set ) , with @xmath454 morphisms in @xmath432 and with a suitably defined action of @xmath436 . here , we have implicitly used the equivalence between the category of finite dimensional commutative @xmath5-algebras and the category of affine algebraic varieties over @xmath5 . the graphs @xmath455 of the connecting morphisms of the system define @xmath209-invariant subsets of @xmath456 which in turn describe @xmath457 as algebraic correspondences . we denote by @xmath458 the associated _ pro - variety_. the compressed algebra @xmath441 associated to the idempotent @xmath459 determines a subvariety @xmath460 which is in fact isomorphic to @xmath15 , via the induced morphism @xmath461 . the noncommutative space defined by @xmath442 is the quotient of @xmath462 by the action of @xmath436 , _ i.e. _ of the action of the @xmath463 s . the galois group @xmath464 acts on @xmath462 by composition . by identifying the elements of @xmath462 with characters , _ i.e. _ with @xmath5-algebra homomorphisms @xmath465 , we write the action of @xmath464 on @xmath434 as @xmath466 this action commutes with the maps @xmath463 , _ i.e. _ @xmath467 . thus the whole construction of the system @xmath468 is @xmath464-equivariant . this fact does not mean however , that @xmath464 acts by automorphisms on @xmath442 ! moreover , notice that the algebraic construction of the crossed - product algebra @xmath442 endowed with the actions of @xmath464 and @xmath436 on @xmath462 makes sense also when @xmath469 . when @xmath470 , one defines the set of correspondences @xmath471 by using the notion of kasparov s bimodules @xmath472 which are projective and finite as right modules . this way , one obtains a first realization of the resulting category of noncommutative zero - dimensional motives in the abelian category of @xmath279-modules . in general , given @xmath468 , with @xmath452 a projective system of artin motives and @xmath436 a semigroup of endomorphisms of @xmath473 as above , the datum of the semigroup action is encoded naturally by the _ algebraic groupoid _ @xmath474 this is defined in the following way . one considers the grothendieck group @xmath475 of the abelian semigroup @xmath436 . by using the injectivity of the partial action of @xmath436 , one may also assume that @xmath436 embeds in @xmath475 . then , the action of @xmath436 on @xmath15 extends to define a _ partial action _ of @xmath475 . more precisely , for @xmath476 the two projections @xmath477 only depend on @xmath478 and the map @xmath479 defines an isomorphism of reduced algebras . it is immediate to verify that @xmath480 and that @xmath481 . the algebraic groupoid @xmath482 is defined as the disjoint union @xmath483 which corresponds to the commutative direct - sum of reduced algebras @xmath484 the range and the source maps in @xmath482 are given _ resp . _ by the natural projection from @xmath482 to @xmath15 and by its composition with the antipode @xmath485 which is defined , at the algebra level , by @xmath486 . the composition in the groupoid corresponds to the product of monomials @xmath487 . given two systems @xmath468 and @xmath488 , with associated crossed - product algebras @xmath442 and @xmath489 and groupoids @xmath490 and @xmath491 a _ geometric correspondence _ is given by a @xmath492-space @xmath493 , endowed with a right action of @xmath494 which fulfills the following _ tale _ condition . given a space such as @xmath494 , that is a disjoint union of zero - dimensional pro - varieties over @xmath5 , a right action of @xmath494 on @xmath356 is given by a map @xmath495 and a collection of partial isomorphisms @xmath496 fulfilling the following rules for partial action of the abelian group @xmath475 @xmath497 here @xmath498 denotes the partial action of @xmath475 on @xmath499 . one checks that such an action gives to the @xmath5-linear space @xmath500 a structure of right module over @xmath501 . the action of @xmath494 on @xmath356 is tale if the corresponding module @xmath500 is _ finite and projective _ over @xmath501 . given two systems @xmath468 and @xmath502 as above , an _ tale correspondence _ is therefore a @xmath503-space @xmath356 such that the right action of @xmath504 is tale . the @xmath2-linear space of _ ( virtual ) correspondences _ @xmath505 is the rational vector space of formal linear combinations @xmath506 of tale correspondences @xmath507 , modulo the relations arising from isomorphisms and equivalences : @xmath508 . the composition of correspondences is given by the fiber product over a groupoid . namely , for three systems @xmath468 , @xmath509 , @xmath510 joined by correspondences @xmath511 their composition is given by the rule @xmath512 that is the fiber product over the groupoid @xmath513 . finally , a system @xmath468 as above is said to be _ uniform _ if the normalized counting measures @xmath514 on @xmath515 satisfy @xmath516 the category @xmath517 of _ algebraic endomotives _ with coefficients in a fixed extension @xmath0 of @xmath2 is the ( pseudo)abelian category generated by the following objects and morphisms . the objects are uniform systems @xmath518 of artin motives over @xmath5 , as above . the set of morphisms in the category connecting two objects @xmath519 and @xmath520 is defined as @xmath521 the category @xmath259 of artin motives embeds as a full sub - category in the category of algebraic endomotives @xmath522 the functor @xmath523 maps an artin motive @xmath524 to the system @xmath468 with @xmath525 , @xmath526 and @xmath527 . the category of algebraic endomotives is inclusive of a large and general class of examples of noncommutative spaces @xmath528 which are described by semigroup actions on projective systems of artin motives . one may consider , for instance a pointed algebraic variety @xmath529 over a field @xmath5 and a countable , unital , abelian semigroup @xmath436 of _ finite _ endomorphisms of @xmath529 , _ unramified _ over @xmath530 . then , there is a system @xmath531 of artin motives over @xmath5 which is constructed from these data . more precisely , for @xmath532 , one sets @xmath533 for a pair @xmath534 , with @xmath535 , the connecting map @xmath536 is defined by @xmath537 this is an example of a system indexed by the semigroup @xmath436 itself , with partial order given by divisibility . one sets @xmath538 . since @xmath539 , the base point @xmath540 defines a component @xmath541 of @xmath542 for all @xmath532 . the pre - image @xmath543 in @xmath544 is a union of components of @xmath544 . this defines a projection @xmath545 onto an open and closed subset @xmath546 of the projective limit @xmath15 . it is easy to see that the semigroup @xmath436 acts on the projective limit @xmath15 by partial isomorphisms @xmath547 defined by the property @xmath548 the map @xmath549 is well - defined since the set @xmath550 is cofinal and @xmath551 , with @xmath552 . the image of @xmath549 is in @xmath546 , since by definition of @xmath549 : @xmath553 . for @xmath554 , we have @xmath555 . this shows that @xmath549 defines an isomorphism of @xmath15 with @xmath546 , whose inverse map is given by @xmath556 the corresponding algebra morphisms @xmath557 are then given by @xmath558 this class of examples also fulfill an _ equidistribution property _ , making the uniform normalized counting measures @xmath559 on @xmath542 compatible with the projective system and inducing a probability measure on the limit @xmath15 . namely , one has @xmath560 in this section we assume that @xmath5 is a number field . we fix an embedding @xmath561 and we denote by @xmath254 an algebraic closure of @xmath562 in @xmath563 . when taking points over @xmath254 , algebraic endomotives yield @xmath564-dimensional singular quotient spaces @xmath348 , which can be described by means of locally compact tale groupoids @xmath565 and the associated crossed product @xmath3-algebras @xmath566 . this construction gives rise to the category of _ analytic endomotives_. one starts off by considering a uniform system @xmath567 of artin motives over @xmath5 and the algebras @xmath568 the assignment @xmath569 defines an involutive embedding of algebras @xmath570 . the @xmath3-completion @xmath571 of @xmath572 is an abelian af @xmath3-algebra . one sets @xmath573 this is the @xmath3-completion of the algebraic crossed product @xmath574 . it is defined by the algebraic relations with the involution which is apparent in the formulae ( _ cf . _ @xcite,@xcite ) . in the applications that require to work with cyclic ( co)homology , it is important to be able to restrict from @xmath3-algebras such as @xmath575 to canonical dense subalgebras @xmath576 where @xmath577 is the algebra of locally constant functions . it is to this category of smooth algebras ( rather than to that of @xmath3-algebras ) that cyclic homology applies . the following result plays an important role in the theory of endomotives and their applications to examples arising from the study of the thermodynamical properties of certain quantum statistical dynamical systems . we shall refer to the following proposition , in section [ bcsystem ] of this paper for the description of the properties of the `` bc - system '' . the bc - system is a particularly relevant quantum statistical dynamical system which has been the prototype and the motivating example for the introduction of the notion of an endomotive . we refer to @xcite , 4.1 for the definition of the notion and the properties of a state on a ( unital ) involutive algebra . [ fab ] \1 ) the action of @xmath464 on @xmath462 defines a canonical action of @xmath464 by automorphisms of the @xmath3-algebra @xmath578 , preserving globally @xmath571 and such that , for any pure state @xmath579 of @xmath571 , @xmath580 \2 ) when the artin motives @xmath451 are abelian and normal , the subalgebras @xmath581 and @xmath582 are globally invariant under the action of @xmath464 and the states @xmath579 of @xmath575 induced by pure states of @xmath571 fulfill @xmath583\ ] ] on the totally disconnected compact space @xmath15 , the abelian semigroup @xmath436 of homeomorphisms acts , producing closed and open subsets @xmath584 , @xmath498 . the normalized counting measures @xmath514 on @xmath515 define a _ probability measure _ on @xmath15 with the property that the radon nikodym derivatives @xmath585 are locally constant functions on @xmath15 . one lets @xmath586 be the corresponding tale locally compact groupoid . the crossed product @xmath3-algebra @xmath587 coincides with the @xmath3-algebra @xmath349 of the groupoid @xmath482 . the notion of right ( or left ) action of @xmath588 on a totally disconnected locally compact space @xmath589 is defined as in the algebraic case by and . a right action of @xmath588 on @xmath589 gives on the space @xmath590 of continuous functions with compact support on @xmath589 a structure of right module over @xmath591 . when the fibers of the map @xmath592 are discrete ( countable ) subsets of @xmath589 one can define on @xmath590 an inner product with values in @xmath591 by @xmath593 a right action of @xmath588 on @xmath589 is _ tale _ if and only if the fibers of the map @xmath594 are discrete and the identity is a compact operator in the right @xmath3-module @xmath595 over @xmath349 given by . an _ tale correspondence _ is a @xmath596-space @xmath589 such that the right action of @xmath597 is tale . the @xmath2-vector space @xmath598 of linear combinations of tale correspondences @xmath589 modulo the equivalence relation @xmath599 for disjoint unions , defines the space of ( virtual ) correspondences . for @xmath600 , @xmath601 , and @xmath602 , the composition of correspondences @xmath603 is given following the same rule as for the algebraic case , that is by the fiber product over the groupoid @xmath604 . a correspondence gives rise to a bimodule @xmath352 over the algebras @xmath605 and @xmath606 and the composition of correspondences translates into the tensor product of bimodules . [ extartcalg ] the category @xmath607 of _ analytic endomotives _ is the ( pseudo)abelian category generated by objects of the form @xmath600 with the properties listed above and morphisms given as follows . for @xmath600 and @xmath601 objects in the category , one sets @xmath608 the following result establishes a precise relation between the categories of artin motives and ( noncommutative ) endomotives . [ ncartinthm ] the categories of artin motives and algebraic and analytic endomotives are related as follows . 1 . the map @xmath609 determines a tensor functor @xmath610 from algebraic to analytic endomotives . 2 . the galois group @xmath611 acts by natural transformations of @xmath612 . the category @xmath613 of artin motives embeds as a full subcategory of @xmath614 . the composite functor @xmath615 maps the full subcategory @xmath613 of artin motives faithfully to the category @xmath616 of @xmath464-equivariant @xmath4-theory with coefficients in @xmath0 . given two artin motives @xmath617 and @xmath618 and a component @xmath619 of the cartesian product @xmath620 , the two projections turn @xmath500 into a @xmath621-bimodule @xmath622 . if @xmath623 , @xmath624 defines a sum of bimodules in @xmath625 . the composition of correspondences in @xmath613 translates into the tensor product of bimodules in @xmath616 @xmath626 one composes the functor @xmath627 with the natural functor @xmath628 which associates to a @xmath621-bimodule @xmath629 the @xmath630-bimodule @xmath631 . the resulting functor @xmath632 is faithful since a correspondence such as @xmath419 is uniquely determined by the corresponding map of @xmath0-theory @xmath633 . the prototype example of the data which define an analytic endomotive is the system introduced by bost and connes in @xcite . the evolution of this @xmath3-dynamical system encodes in its group of symmetries the arithmetic of the maximal abelian extension of @xmath634 . this quantum statistical dynamical system is described by the datum given by a noncommutative @xmath3-algebra of _ observables _ @xmath635 and by the _ time evolution _ which is assigned in terms of a one - parameter family of automorphisms @xmath636 of the algebra . the action of the ( multiplicative ) semigroup @xmath637 on the commutative algebra @xmath638 is defined by @xmath639 for the definition of the associate endomotive , one considers the projective system @xmath640 of zero - dimensional algebraic varieties @xmath641 , where @xmath642 $ ] is the group ring of the abelian group @xmath643 . the inductive limit @xmath644 $ ] is the group ring of @xmath645 . the endomorphism @xmath646 associated to an element @xmath647 is given on the canonical basis @xmath648 $ ] , @xmath649 , by @xmath650 the artin motives @xmath651 are normal and abelian , so that proposition [ fab ] applies . the action of the galois group @xmath263 on @xmath641 is obtained by composing a character @xmath652 with the action of an element @xmath653 . since @xmath654 is determined by the @xmath655-th root of unity @xmath656 , this implies that the action of @xmath657 factorizes through the cyclotomic action and coincides with the _ symmetry group _ of the bc - system . the subalgebra @xmath658 coincides with the rational subalgebra defined in @xcite . there is an interesting description of this system in terms of a pointed algebraic variety @xmath529 ( _ cf . _ section [ genendo ] ) on which the abelian semigroup @xmath436 acts by finite endomorphisms . one considers the pointed affine group scheme @xmath659 ( the multiplicative group ) and lets @xmath436 be the semigroup of non - zero endomorphisms of @xmath660 . these endomorphisms correspond to maps of the form @xmath661 , for some @xmath282 . then , the general construction outlined in section [ genendo ] determines on @xmath662 the bc system . one considers the semigroup @xmath663 acting on @xmath664 as specified above . it follows from the definition that @xmath665 where @xmath666/(u_n^n-\,1).\ ] ] for @xmath667 the connecting morphism @xmath668 is defined by the algebra homomorphism @xmath669 , @xmath670 with @xmath671 . thus , one obtains an isomorphism of @xmath2-algebras @xmath672\,,\quad \iota(u_n)=\,e_{\frac{1}{n } } .\ ] ] the partial isomorphisms @xmath673 \to { \mathbb{q}}[{\mathbb{q}}/{\mathbb{z}}]$ ] of the group ring as described by the formula correspond under the isomorphism @xmath523 , to those given by on @xmath674 . one identifies @xmath15 with its space of characters @xmath675\to \bar { \mathbb{q}}$ ] . then , the projection @xmath676 is given by the restriction of ( the character associated to ) @xmath677 to the subalgebra @xmath678 . the projection of the composite of the endomorphism @xmath679 of with @xmath680 is given by @xmath681 this projection is non - zero if and only if the restriction @xmath682 is the trivial character , that is if and only if @xmath683 . moreover , in that case one has @xmath684 and in particular @xmath685 for @xmath686 the inclusion of algebraic spaces @xmath687 is given at the algebra level by the surjective homomorphism @xmath688 thus , one can rewrite as @xmath689 this means that @xmath690 by using the formula , one obtains the desired equality of the @xmath440 s of and . this construction continues to make sense for the affine algebraic variety @xmath691 for any field @xmath5 , including the case of a field of positive characteristic . in this case one obtains new systems , different from the bc system . the functor @xmath692 which connects the categories of algebraic and analytic endomotives establishes a significant bridge between the commutative world of artin motives and that of noncommutative geometry . when one moves from commutative to noncommutative algebras , important new tools of thermodynamical nature become available . one of the most relevant techniques ( for number - theoretical applications ) is supplied by the theory of tomita and takesaki for von neumann algebras ( @xcite ) which associates to a suitable state @xmath579 ( _ i.e. _ a faithful weight ) on a von neumann algebra @xmath68 , a one - parameter group of automorphisms of @xmath68 ( _ i.e. _ the modular automorphisms group ) @xmath693 @xmath694 is the modular operator which acts on the completion @xmath695 of @xmath696 , for the scalar product @xmath697 . this general theory applies in particular to the unital involutive algebras @xmath698 of and to the related @xmath3-algebras @xmath575 which are naturally associated to an endomotive . a remarkable result proved by connes in the theory and classifications of factors ( @xcite ) states that , modulo inner automorphisms of @xmath68 , the one - parameter family @xmath699 is _ independent _ of the choice of the state @xmath579 . this way , one obtains a _ canonically defined _ one parameter group of automorphisms classes @xmath700 in turn , this result implies that the crossed product dual algebra @xmath701 and the dual scaling action @xmath702 are _ independent _ of the choice of ( the weight ) @xmath579 . when these results are applied to the analytic endomotive @xmath703 associated to an algebraic endomotive @xmath518 , the above dual representation of @xmath704 combines with the representation of the absolute galois group @xmath464 . in the particular case of the endomotive associated to the bc - system ( _ cf . _ section [ bcsystem ] ) , the resulting representation of @xmath705 on the cyclic homology @xmath706 of a suitable @xmath707-module @xmath708 associated to the thermodynamical dynamics of the system @xmath709 determines the spectral realization of the zeroes of the riemann zeta - function and of the artin @xmath1-functions for abelian characters of @xmath464 ( _ cf . _ @xcite , theorem 4.16 ) . the action of the group @xmath710 on the cyclic homology @xmath711 of the noncommutative motive @xmath708 is analogous to the action of the weil group on the tale cohomology of an algebraic variety . in particular , the action of @xmath704 is the ` characteristic zero ' analog of the action of the ( geometric ) frobenius on tale cohomology . this construction determines a functor @xmath712 from the category of endomotives to the category of ( infinite - dimensional ) representations of the group @xmath410 . the analogy with the tannakian formalism of classical motive theory is striking . it is also important to underline the fact that the whole thermodynamical construction is non - trivial and relevant for number - theoretic applications only because of the particular nature of the factor @xmath68 ( type @xmath713 ) associated to the original datum @xmath714 of the bc - system . it is tempting to compare the original choice of the state @xmath579 ( weight ) on the algebra @xmath294 which singles out ( via the gelfand - naimark - segal construction ) the factor @xmath68 defined as the weak closure of the action of @xmath715 in the hilbert space @xmath716 , with the assignment of a factor @xmath717 ( @xmath718 ) on a pure motive @xmath719 : _ cf . _ . in classical motive theory , one knows that the assignment of a @xmath182-grading is canonical only for homological equivalence or under the assumption of the standard conjecture of knneth type . in fact , the definition of a weight structure depends upon the definition of a complete system of orthogonal central idempotents @xmath720 . passing from the factor @xmath68 to the canonical dual representation carries also the advantage to work in a setting where projectors are classified by their real dimension ( @xmath721 is of type @xmath722 ) , namely in a noncommutative framework of continuous geometry which generalizes and yet still retains some relevant properties of the algebraic correspondences ( _ i.e. _ degree or dimension ) . the process of dualization is in fact subsequent to a thermodynamical `` cooling procedure '' in order to work with a system whose algebra approaches and becomes in the limit , a commutative algebra ( _ i.e. _ @xmath723 ) . finally , one has also to implement a further step in which one filters ( _ i.e. _ `` distils '' ) the relevant noncommutative motive @xmath708 within the derived framework of cyclic modules ( _ cf . _ section [ cyclicmodules ] ) . this procedure is somewhat reminissent of the construction of the vanishing cohomology in algebraic geometry ( _ cf . _ @xcite ) . when the algebra of the bc - system gets replaced by the noncommutative algebra of coordinates @xmath724 of the adle class space @xmath725 of a number field @xmath5 , the cooling procedure is described by a restriction morphism of ( rapidly decaying ) functions on @xmath726 to functions on the `` cooled down '' subspace @xmath727 of idle classes ( _ cf . _ @xcite , section 5 ) . in this context , the representation of @xmath727 on the cyclic homology @xmath728 of a suitable noncommutative motive @xmath729 produces the spectral realization of the zeroes of hecke @xmath1-functions ( _ cf . _ _ op.cit_ , theorem 5.6 ) . the whole construction describes also a natural way to associate to a noncommutative space a canonical set of `` classical points '' which represents the analogue in characteristic zero , of the geometric points @xmath730 of a smooth , projective curve @xmath731 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: are concurrent computing machines equivalent to turing machines ? this question , which amounts to confront two fundamental notions like time and computation may be treated in a purely mathematical framework . practical consequences however can not be independent of concrete realizations , that is concrete machines performing actual computations in physical time . this remark may seem curious , if one aims at showing theorems , which can not depend on the physical properties of time or machines . but , even in a mathematical treatment of concurrent computation , one needs a representation of time . usually , time is modelized as a real parameter , shared by all parts of the computation . unfortunately , such a representation does not correspond to the observable time that can be obtained from physical systems like clocks , neither to the reference time that is defined by metrology , nor to the operational time that occurs in practical realizations of logical circuits . without questioning the validity of demonstrated theorems , difficulties may emerge when trying to find practical applications . the distinction just made between abstract and concrete machines raises related questions . when a machine @xmath0 can be simulated by a program @xmath1 running on another machine , how can one identify the concrete machine @xmath0 and the program @xmath1 ? and in case a machine can not be simulated on another one , indicating some greater expressive power , is the latter due to computation or to some fundamental physical property ? before entering such questions , one must first consider the sequential machines that are presently realized . these machines which we get from a constructor , which are made of matter , which transform electric energy into heat , which we communicate with through a keyboard and a screen , why do we need them ? let us note that all the features that make them concrete are inconveniences : we would prefer them lighter , smaller , less power consuming and less dissipating . it would be ideal to make all these parameters equal to zero . in fact , we need them for their logical function , their ability to compute . but then , since this function is mathematically known , modelized and even simulated , where is the need for a concrete machine , whose features are mainly inconveniences ? the natural answer is that these machines compute faster than humans can do , with just a pencil and paper . and yet , pencil and paper are already rudimentary elements of a concrete machine , using physical objects to memorize different steps of computations . the interest in concrete machines comes from their intimate relation with physical time . if computing machines go faster than humans , then one must be confident in their action , as in most cases one is unable to check their output . indeed , in very specific cases , one can verify the correctness of a result in much less time than is needed to obtain it . this is the case for instance of the prime factorization of integers . but few concrete applications have this property . in most cases , one can not check the result in much less time than the computation itself . if the result is important , and no other way is available to obtain it , then one must be confident in the machine . what can support such a confidence ? necessarily reasoning , founded on correct functioning of the machine at a given time on some particular computations , generalized to other times and other computations . a computing machine can not be tested for all computations it can do , at any time . even for a finite machine , the number of possible computations increases exponentially with the memory size , and a memory of one hundred bits already allows a number of configurations that can not be tested in less time than the age of the universe . to establish a reasoning leading to confidence , one must : - check that each elementary component effectively realizes the function it has been designed for ( physical validation ) . - prove in a deductive way that the particular composition of these elementary components building the machine effectively leads to the global function used ( logical validation ) . the first condition is ensured by choices in implementation design and by tests made by the constructor . the second condition is obtained from a mathematical representation of the machine and from the logics of computation . these two steps of validation require good representations of all components at the physical level , and of the global machine at the logical level . if the confidence one can put in a machine relies on good modelizations of both its physical and logical functioning , how could such a machine perform more than it has been designed for , more than our present theories can modelize ? even if the existence of a new type of calculus , still unknown today , can be envisaged , with machines performing this new type of calculus , how could one build such machines without having for them good modelizations ? in such a case , one could not ensure the two validation steps , and one could not say that these machines operate correctly neither be confident in their ouput . one consequence is that realistic models are necessary , both of the computational structure and of the physical implementation of logical operators . modelization is made easier when logical and physical constraints can be separated . this is the reason for developing sequential machines or synchronous concurrent machines . in that case , the logical validation of the machine can be made , whilst ignoring the implementation characteristics of its components . the latter will finally and mainly limit the performance of the machine through the value of the clock frequency . the machine can equivalently be simulated on another concrete machine with identical clock frequency , at the expense of slower performances . however , in the case of asynchronous concurrent machines , logical and physical constraints are more involved . although machines built with asynchronous circuits are less widely used , much effort has been devoted to their understanding and modelization @xcite . in fact , they may even appear as an unavoidable evolution of computing machines . on one hand , clock timed circuits are reaching limits where clock signal distribution consumes too many resources and progress in performances approaches saturation point . on the other hand , asynchronous circuits constitute the most general class of circuits , and thus allow one to express in the most general way the questions raised by the implementation of computation on physical systems , and the solutions that may be brought . in this article , we shall be concerned with the relation of concrete computing machines with physical time . after recalling the general characteristic properties of physical time and of computing machines which are presently realized , we shall compare the solutions provided by synchronous and asynchronous systems to the implementation of logical operations . we shall show that they give different implementations of causal relations , reflecting in that way different causal structures for space - time . the notion of time may be seen to follow from two necessities . from a logical point of view , time can be considered as the concept which allows one to make a distinction between two different types of propositions : general and universal propositions ( like mathematical ones ) which are eternal , and particular propositions which are related to changing reality ( like those describing physical systems ) . moreover , time is also rendered necessary by the formulation of physics : time is the concept which allows one to give a formal expression to movement , and hence to the laws of physics . properties of time are in fact imposed by the functions that this notion must fulfill . from the logical side , time allows one to conceive a same object by characterizing it by its different states , these states being asssociated with the object at different times . a time parameter can then be used not only to index the different states characterizing a same object , but also to organize the states of different objects into classes of simultaneity . the relation of order that can be introduced on the time parameter allows one to define a relation of logical causality between the state transitions affecting different objects . however , in order to be realized physically , for instance on real machines , the causal relation between states can not be independent of the real motions affecting physical systems . in particular , the simultaneity classes defined with the help of the time parameter must coincide with those that are associated with real events occuring in physical space , hence with the physical time . the notion of physical time is intimately related to the laws of physics . after having remarked that pendulum oscillations are isochronous , galileo galilei could give a mathematical representation of motion induced by free fall , by relating the undergone distance to the elapsed time , the latter being understood as a universal reference for all motions . the existence of such a reference is made possible by the existence of physical laws governing all movements , and in particular by the existence of regular movements like inertial motions . this introduction of time leaves an important conventional part in the definition of a time reference , even if a natural choice is provided by motions which appear as most regular , like the earth motion around the sun . this leads in fact to distinguish two types of time . thus , leibniz @xcite , relying on logical arguments , could consider that space and time are mere relations between objects or events , which are fixed by an observer in a conventional way , thus building subjective space and time . still , one is also bound to admit the existence of objective space and time , as the only way to understand how physical laws governing displacements of objects and time ordering of events can be formulated in a universal way , independently of the observer . the formulation of the universal law of gravitation led newton @xcite to fix the role played by time in physical laws , and to endow it with the mathematical representation that we still use nowadays : that of a real parameter which all physical quantities depend on . in fact , newton introduced two different notions of time , which he distinguished both in their conception and in their usage . the first one , which he called `` absolute and mathematical '' , allowed him to write mathematical equations for the laws of mechanics and gravitation . the second notion , which he called `` common and sensible '' , allowed him to relate the motions of different physical systems , including clocks . even if newton privileged the first notion , which he considered as representing absolute space and time , seeing clocks as systems to be improved in order to make them as close as possible to ideal space and time , he nevertheless made two distinct uses of these notions . the first one , which identifies with the curvilinear coordinate on the planet s trajectory , he used as a mathematical tool to deal with infinitesimals of different orders . the second one , which is the physical time as can be defined by kepler s area law , he used as a measure of inertial motions , which he compared planetary motions with . the theory of relativity @xcite has led to question the a priori and absolute character of physical space and time . according to relativity , the notion of time relies on clocks , the date of an event being defined by coincidence of this event with a top delivered by a clock located at the same place . but in order to be defined in whole space , the notion of time also relies on the exchange of light signals , which are necessary to compare and synchronize the indications of remote clocks . the universal and finite velocity of light propagation then leads to a definition of time simultaneity which depends on the observer s motion . in other words , time simultaneity is not given a priori but results from a construction , or clock synchronization . by exchanging light signals , on which time references provided by clocks are encoded , one can compare these references and synchronize clocks . then , time allows one to construct space . by comparing the light signals received from several remote clocks , one can , by quadrangulation , determine positions both in time and space . this relativistic definition of time and space is rendered necessary as soon as a high precision must be attained . this is the case for instance when corrections linked to the finite velocity of light , or relativistic effects , must be taken into account @xcite . hence , this relativistic definition is the one used in physics for high precision space - time measurements @xcite , and in metrology to define time and space standards @xcite and to construct the space - time reference systems required by physics @xcite . it is also the one used in modern practical positioning systems at the surface of the earth , like gps @xcite . finally , as it will appear in the following , it is also the notion of time which is implicitly used by asynchronous communicating and computing systems @xcite . the consequences of the theory of relativity on our conception of space and time have been remarkably discussed at the logical level by russell @xcite . our representation in terms of permanent material structures located in space and evolving according to a unique external time , must be replaced by that in terms of events which are located both in space and time . this conception of space - time not only affects the formulation of modern theories in a fundamental way @xcite , but also underlies present applications in physics and metrology @xcite . when refering to physical time , simultaneity classes can not be defined a priori any more , and rely on a physical implementation by means of propagating light signals . this constructive character of time has important consequences on the functioning of devices which rely on the physical exchange of information . causal relations between events can not be derived by simple comparison with an external , a priori given , parameter . for systems which are unlocalized in space , like communicating processors , this means that the time order relation of occuring events , even if it can be defined unambiguously at the local level of each processor , nevertheless requires a more complete representation to be defined over the whole system in a consistent way @xcite . in the following , we shall analyse how the functioning of actual devices depends on the causal structure of physical space - time . to discuss the intimate relation between time and computation , one must first recall some general principles which underly the physical implementation of computing systems , and which are applied in concrete machines realized with present technologies . * 3.1 implementation of logical operations * in cmos ( complementary mos ) technology , logical gates are implemented using two electrical networks @xmath2 and @xmath3 , as represented on figure 1 . @xmath4 describe input channels , and @xmath5 the output channel . @xmath2 and @xmath3 are built with electrical switches which are combined in series / parallel networks , thus allowing to implement the logics of propositions @xcite . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 1530,2808)(856,-2635 ) ( 2341,-1051)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711,-826)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1036,-1816)(0,0)[lb ] ( 856,-1276)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2386,-1276)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711,-1816)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1396,-151)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1036 , 29)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1036,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1396,-2581)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1036,-781)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 1 . a logical gate . each switch is implemented with a transistor . a function implemented by @xmath6 will be said to be true , for a particular set of values of @xmath4 , if and only if there is a path that connects extreme connections of @xmath6 . for instance , for the network represented by figure 1 : - when @xmath2 is _ true _ , output @xmath5 is forced to value _ true_. - when @xmath3 is _ true _ , output @xmath5 is forced to value _ false_. the possibility that ( @xmath7 ) for some values of @xmath4 must be excluded , otherwise current could flow both through @xmath2 and @xmath3 , resulting in a short circuit between voltage sources . in the following , we shall always impose that ( @xmath8 ) is verified for all configurations of variables @xmath4 ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 define as usual negation , logical disjunction and logical conjunction ) . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3117,2025)(1126,-2401 ) ( 2476,-1141)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1801,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1306,-1861)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4006,-781)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1306,-1501)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1126,-826)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1666,-826)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3151,-646)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1531,-511)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2026,-511)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3151,-1051)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 2 . nand gate . two cases must be considered . 1- @xmath2 and @xmath3 are always opposite , for all values of variables @xmath4 , ( @xmath12 ) . this case implements propositions of classical logic ( complementary mos ) . the simple example of the _ nand _ gate is represented on figure 2 ( a bubble represents negation ) : @xmath13 2- @xmath2 and @xmath3 can be simultaneously _ false _ , i.e. ( @xmath14 ) can be _ true_. in such configurations , the output @xmath5 is not connected to any voltage source . then , because of electrical capacities , @xmath5 memorizes its previous value . this allows one to realize memories , like the _ latch _ represented in figure 3 : @xmath15 ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 1620,1179)(631,-2761 ) ( 2251,-1951)(0,0)[lb ] ( 946,-1951)(0,0)[lb ] ( 946,-2536)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1981,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 721,-2761)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1576,-2131)(0,0)[lb ] ( 631,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 3 . transparent latch . in practice , in order to have memorization last for long enough , and quite generally for all memories , one must ensure memory stability by using some feed - back , by means of a looped amplifier . this feed - back can be permanent ( static ) or recurrent ( dynamic logic ) . one possibility of electrical feed - back is shown in figure 4 , where two looped amplifiers have been added on output @xmath5 , one of them being weak , in the sense that it can not create any serious short circuit when it conflicts with any of the two networks @xmath2 and @xmath3 . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 1992,2385)(1126,-2401 ) ( 1801,-151)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1126,-781)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711,-871)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711,-1816)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1801,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2566,-826)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1126,-1816)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2971,-1141)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 4 . electrical feed - back . another way to realize a stable memory is to implement a static feed - back on a logical gate corresponding to the first case . then , the quoted _ latch _ can be realized with a looped multiplexer ( _ mux _ ) , as shown in figure 5 : @xmath16 ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 1632,1497)(991,-2491 ) ( 2611,-1501)(0,0)[lb ] ( 991,-1681)(0,0)[lb ] ( 991,-2491)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711,-1186)(0,0)[lb ] fig . transparent latch with multiplexer . this exhibits a very general difficulty which characterizes looped systems : variable @xmath5 appears on both sides of its defining equation ( [ latchdef ] ) . this equation does not mean that an equality must be realized , for instance with electric voltages , but that the following assignment must be realized : @xmath17 @xmath18 in other words , two values of the variable @xmath5 must be distinguished , which correspond to successive times : @xmath19 ( after ) and @xmath20 ( before ) are linked by equation ( [ latche ] ) . it is required that the two values @xmath19 and @xmath20 do not interfere , and that variable @xmath5 change from @xmath20 to @xmath19 . the assignment represented by equation ( [ latcha ] ) expresses a causality requirement that must be implemented in order to realize computations . in the particular case of the _ latch _ just described , operation may only cause problem in case @xmath21 is falling . indeed , in other cases : - when @xmath21 is low , @xmath5 is memorized - when @xmath21 is high , @xmath5 copies @xmath22 - when @xmath21 rises , @xmath5 begins to copy @xmath22 so that the circuit operates correctly in these three cases . however , if @xmath21 falls down while @xmath22 changes , @xmath5 will hesitate between two values of @xmath22 . the whole circuit may enter a metastable state which is invalid ( electric voltage will stay in metastable balance at an intermediate level ) and which may last for an unbounded time . it may leave this state for any of the two possible values of @xmath5 , and this in an undeterministic way , which may not be eventually acceptable for the type of computation envisaged . let us note that the circuit of figure 4 shows the same defects , for it involves a feed - back , although this may be less apparent when treated at the electrical level . although chosen here as an example , the _ latch _ shows properties which are encountered quite generally in looped devices . this brief discussion shows that the correct operation of a circuit can not be analysed without taking its environment into account , in particular the time ordering relations of input and output signals . this is entailed by the existence of loops and must be dealt with quite generally , for computing machines are naturally looped systems . in all cases , time constraints must be implemented in order to ensure the causality relations which are necessary for computation . these constraints will take very different forms , according to the type of implementation chosen , whether by means of synchronous or asynchronous systems . before discussing separately these two classes of systems , we shall first recall one important property they share , as it is also imposed by implementation of complex computations , the property of modularity . * * there exist many various ways to organize electronic components into logical circuits , in order to realize machines performing computations . usually and quite generally , one defines complex circuits as hierarchies built with elementary circuits called primitives . this method , imposed by practical considerations , indeed hints at a logical necessity : one must be able to design and realize with the same rigour circuits of increasing complexity . more precisely , one must insure that circuits implementing logical functions of high complexity level behave as they should , and one must obtain this confidence in a rather short time . because of the exponential increase of the number of configurations to check , this requirement implies that a direct physical test of the circuit s behaviour soon becomes impossible when the complexity of the logical function increases . this aim can then only be attained with the help of modular implementations , by taking advantage both of their composite logical structure , and of the logical simplicity of chosen primitives @xcite . proofs relying on known properties of composition of primitives may be developed , which allow one to deduce the correct functioning of a whole modular complex from that of its constituent primitives . then , a test of the whole complex reduces to that of some of its constituents , which are logically simple . although efficient , such strategy may not reveal itself so straightforward . according to the type of physical implementation chosen for the primitives , problems may appear which prevent the systematic development of complex circuits operating correctly , and which do not occur when the choice of primitives is modified , or when pecular constraints are put on their composition . then , there results that logical and physical aspects of modular implementations must be analysed concurrently . time appears in computing systems very early , already in the definition of the electronic circuits which implement logical functions . most circuits which are known and used are synchronous . synchronous circuits may be defined as automata whose transitions between successive states are triggered by pulses delivered by a global clock . an alternative class of circuits is provided by asynchronous circuits . in this section , we introduce the strategies followed by these two main classes of circuits for making the implementation of computation effective , and , in particular , for dealing with problems of computation interferences . * 4.1 synchronous circuits * vlsi circuits which are produced nowadays are highly concurrent devices ( a microprocessor can contain up to @xmath23 transistors , i.e. @xmath24 logical gates ) , and yet most of them can be modelized as non concurrent devices and can be considered as single finite automata . this property comes from their synchronous character , which means that all operations on internal memories are simultaneously activated by a single pulse of a global clock shared by the whole circuit . synchronous implementations use a global clock to avoid the stability problem which has been discussed in previous section . more precisely , with same notations , all _ latches _ are systematically operated in such a way to ensure that logical variables @xmath22 be stable when variables @xmath21 are falling . there exist many different types of memories , but all present the same problem , reflecting the time character of logical assignment . for the sake of simplicity , we shall only discuss the case of the previous _ latch _ , and consider it as a generic example . a synchronous device using two items of this _ latch _ for each register bit ( master - slave _ flip - flop _ ) is sketched on figure 6 . the enabling signals @xmath25 and @xmath26 are mutually excluded in time , and are derived systematically from a common clock . the output is fed back under the form of input variables @xmath27 into a combinatorial operator . if the clock period is larger than the feedback time , then variables @xmath28 are always stable when @xmath25 is falling and the _ latches _ act as required , i.e. , they make the iteration of the combinatorial function effective . the global state @xmath29 is encoded by the state of all memory bits , and can only change at the arrival of a clock pulse . regarding specification and design , synchronous circuits may be considered as modular composites , where primitives , and other modules as well , are finite automata of the type described by figure 6 . the register encodes the state of the circuit , while the combinatorial operator represents the implementation of its transition function . all registers are activated by a single clock pulse . by connecting several automata of this type , one obtains another automaton of the same type , only with a larger memory and a more complex combinatorial function . in such a representation , and from a logical point of view , neither time nor space are involved . one only needs to consider the successive logical steps associated with successive clock periods . the logical time of a computation reduces to a mere integer , which one only relates to physical time by multiplying it by the mean clock period . in other words , time is discretized . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3072,5916)(946,-6010 ) ( 1711,-3031)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2926,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3331,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 946,-1951)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2746,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3241,-2176)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2746,-646)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2881,-2176)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1666,-1276)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1846,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3511,-1816)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-5281)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-4921)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3376,-5551)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1936,-5956)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3376,-3391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1261,-3391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1936,-3616)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2746,-3616)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2116,-4201)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2926,-4201)(0,0)[lb ] fig synchronous circuit . the only physical constraint one must impose is that the clock frequency be smaller than the limit value necessary for all internal propagations to be performed in less time than the clock period . space neither plays a role in the logical function . the whole circuit may be considered as local , i.e. propagation times need only to be taken into account when circuits are connected on large distances , that is when propagation times are large when compared to the clock period , as is the case when computers are connected . implementation on a silicon chip must take into account and control all propagation times within a circuit , so that to insure that all inputs become stable before the end of each clock period . the clock signal must be implemented so that it arrives simultaneously at all _ latches _ , that is with negligible delays when compared to the clock period . clearly , such properties can only be checked once the whole circuit has been specified . such type of circuit can not be implemented incrementally , i.e. by implementing a part without any knowledge on its connections with other parts and on the clock frequency of the whole circuit . in other words , all parts must be local at every scale , from primitives to the whole circuit . the synchronous approach is however questioned in present vlsi designs . this arises mainly because of difficulties which are encountered when distributing simultaneously a same clock signal to millions of _ latches _ , over several @xmath30 , and at a frequency of the order of a gigaherthz . clock distribution results in using an important part of the chip surface and in producing an important part of the overall dissipation . * 4.2 asynchronous circuits * asynchronous circuits may be defined in opposition to synchronous circuits , by the requirement of not using a global clock . but , rather than being complementary , the class they build includes synchronous circuits . usual models represent asynchronous circuits as general devices which are distributed and communicate along connecting channels , as shown on figure 7 . the activity of such circuits is not ruled by the pulses of a global clock , but proceeds with communications distributed between many concurrent parts . these devices can be simple logical gates ( a few transistors ) or , at the opposite , complex processors . communications can be realized through a single wire or through a complex network . clearly , concurrency can not be ignored any more . indeed , one can no more define a logical state which would be associated with the global circuit at a definite time . for each device can change its state following a communication , without being synchronized with most other devices . the notion of computing step itself must be revised , as it relies on a total ordering of all logical events . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 2319,1374)(1024,-2008 ) ( 2071,-916)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1081,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2971,-1141)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2206,-1861)(0,0)[lb ] fig . asynchronous circuit . problems of computation interference may then arise at two different levels . at lowest level , functioning of a single component may be endangered by computing interferences within the component itself , due to internal loops and instabilities of internal variables . at highest level , composition of asynchronous circuits may induce computation interferences due to exchanges between one module and its environment , the latter sending signals which conflict with the module operation . we shall discuss the second case only and shall assume that primitives may be defined which are free from internal computing interferences ( see for instance @xcite ) . we first briefly describe those that are most frequently used in asynchronous circuits . in some examples , logical functions are defined in a way which does not distinguish between rising and falling edges . these undistinguished transitions are called events , and the logical function operates on these events . but the events are still transitions between different levels ( or boolean variables ) , so that each primitive can be considered in both ways , either as an operation on boolean variables or as ( another ) operation on events . a most frequently used primitive is the _ join _ element , or muller s _ c - element_. it has two inputs @xmath31 and @xmath32 and one output @xmath5 , and its logical function can be described in the following way : - if @xmath33 , then @xmath34 - if inputs become different from one another , then @xmath5 keeps its previous value . then , ouput @xmath5 only changes after both inputs @xmath31 and @xmath32 have changed . this allows a rendez - vous to be realized between levels ( wait until two inputs acquire the same value ) or between events ( wait until two inputs have received the same number of rising or falling edges , after proper initialization ) . the primitive _ c - element _ can be realized using an electrical feed - back analogous to that of figure 4 . along this line , a frequent realization is represented on figure 8 . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 2352,2004)(451,-1738 ) ( 2656,-646)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711,-1681)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1711 , 74)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2161,-331)(0,0)[lb ] ( 451,-466)(0,0)[lb ] ( 451,-826)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 8 . simplified c - element . another primitive is the _ toggle _ , represented in figure 9 , which possesses one input @xmath22 and two ouputs @xmath35 and @xmath36 . successive events on the input are alternatively sent to outputs @xmath35 and @xmath36 . the first event after initialization is sent to the marked output @xmath35 . the _ or _ operation between events , also called _ merge _ , can be realized with a classical _ exclusive _ _ or _ gate ( _ xor _ between levels ) . the _ sequencer _ , represented in figure 9 , possesses three inputs @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath37 and two outputs @xmath35 and @xmath36 . its role is to grant a given resource to one of two different processes which can make requests on inputs @xmath31 and @xmath32 . when an event is received on @xmath37 , a granting event is produced either on @xmath35 or @xmath36 according to an existing request respectively on @xmath31 or @xmath32 . when two requests are present , the _ sequencer _ arbitrates between the two , and thus introduces some part of indeterminism . the _ sequencer _ may take an unbounded time to arbitrate , but it is required to realize the mutual exclusion of the two grant signals . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 1947,3435)(901,-3661 ) ( 1891,-1276)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2476,-3661)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2791,-2131)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2791,-1231)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2746,-2806)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2791,-1456)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2746,-3076)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1936,-1951)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1936,-2176)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1936,-2761)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1936,-3031)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2341,-691)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1891,-691)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1891,-421)(0,0)[lb ] ( 901,-691)(0,0)[lb ] ( 901,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 901,-2221)(0,0)[lb ] ( 901,-2986)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2791,-601)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 9 . some asynchronous primitives . in this section , we discuss the composition of asynchronous circuits , and some solutions which have been brought to the problem of computing interferences . compositions of asynchronous circuits correspond to distributed systems , where different parts communicate in a way which is not regularized by a global clock . then various and arbitrary time delays affect successive transitions at the input of a module . inputs may then conflict with the correct operation of the module itself . the approaches followed in circuit design to deal with computing interferences fall into two main classes . one practical approach to timing problems consists in working directly on the physical implementation , by keeping track of all the delays occuring in the logical circuit , together with all the constraints which must be satisfied by these delays in order to make the whole circuit operate correctly . then , programs are developed to find and optimize solutions in a systematic way @xcite . although practically very efficient , this strategy rapidly attains such a complexity that it becomes very difficult to distinguish fundamental issues from practical choices . in the other class of approaches , one attempts to separate as much as possible the logical issues related with timing from their physical manifestations , that is mainly from the values of time delays . this has led to different studies , focussing either on the determination of a best choice of logical primitives , satisfying criteria like speed - insensitivity or delay - insensitivity @xcite , or on a more restrictive definition of modular composition , like delay - insensitive compositions @xcite . in the following , we shall only briefly discuss approaches related with delay - insensitivity , and focus on the fundamental relation they tend to exhibit between the occurence of computing interferences and the causal structure of physical space - time . in order to make the analysis easier to follow , we shall introduce a graphic representation of the communications occuring between modules of a composition ( see figure 11 ) . these graphs are analogous to those that can be used in relativistic physics to represent the space - time evolution of localized physical systems , together with the light signals they exchange . as discussed in a previous section , an essential feature is the absence of an a priori given global and common time . only a local time ordering can be made between the successive events occuring on each module , reflecting the causal relations which can be made locally . although time is represented as the vertical axis , this only indicates the direction for increasing time on each module . different modules are displayed on the horizontal axis , which roughly corresponds to space . each module is then represented by a vertical line , indicating the causal succession of the local events occuring at its inputs or outputs . communications are then represented by inclined arrows leaving a module ( output ) to reach another module ( input ) . although they may vary , the slopes of theses arrows must always be greater than a strictly positive lower bound , which corresponds to light velocity . varying slopes indicate that varying speed and delays affect communications between modules . in the following , we shall denote by `` event '' each arrow corresponding to a communication , and shall call `` point '' the intersection of this event with the time evolution of a module ( following in that way the notation introduced by russell in his discussion of the causal structure of relativistic space - time @xcite ) . the logical specification of each module is translated into causal relations between the points which represent the occurence of events on the module . these local constraints may be given a precise expression using a formal language well suited to represent time ordered event structures @xcite . as propagation delays play an essential part , ordering constraints will be most conveniently visualized on graphic representations , which allow the analysis of global causal relations within distributed systems . * 5.1 delay - insensitivity * in order to discuss the role of delays in computation interferences , let us first analyse the illustrating example of the _ q - element _ @xcite , which is represented in figure 10 . the formal expression describing the logical function of the _ q - element _ can be written in a language which is derived from csp ( communicating sequential processes ) @xcite : @xmath38 ; y_o\uparrow ; [ y_i ] ; u\uparrow ; [ u ] ; y_o\downarrow ; [ \lnot y_i ] ; x_o\uparrow ; [ \lnot x_i ] ; u\downarrow ; [ \lnot u ] ; x_o\downarrow \right]\ ] ] each variable between brackets , which precedes a transition , represents a logical variable which must be true before the circuit can execute the transition which follows ( @xmath39 denotes time succession , and @xmath40 arbitrary repetition of the expresssion in brackets ) . thus , the circuit waits for @xmath4 to be true , then emits a rising edge on output @xmath41 , etc ... this logical function can be implemented as a composition of a _ c - element _ with two _ and _ gates , as represented in figure 10 . output @xmath42 of the _ c - element _ is followed by a fork , which relates @xmath42 to one input of each of the _ and _ gates . two other forks also dispatch the event produced by the environment @xmath4 ( resp . @xmath43 ) on two inputs denoted by @xmath31 and @xmath32 ( resp . @xmath44 and @xmath45 ) . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 2712,1872)(1216,-2773 ) ( 2251,-2581)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2476,-1996)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3826,-1186)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3016,-1096)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2251,-1591)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3061,-1546)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3736,-2581)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1216,-1096)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1216,-2491)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-2626)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3421,-1321)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2026,-2266)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2926,-2221)(0,0)[lb ] fig . q - element . the logical operation of the circuit may be represented using a space - time graph , as in figure 11 . left and right parts of the circuit environment are respectively represented as @xmath46 and @xmath47 . the series of points corresponding to the definition of the logical function of each module can be followed on each vertical line . situations which correspond to rendez - vous , i.e. intervals where a primitive is waiting for the arrival of two events in any order , have been represented by a thick line . this is systematically the case for the _ c - element _ , but also for the _ and _ gates , when they are waiting for their two inputs to be true . pairs of points which can not occur in reverse order without ruining computation , have been signalized by dashed lines . the two cases involve the internal variable @xmath42 and one event , @xmath48 or @xmath49 produced by the environment ( @xmath47 or @xmath46 ) . event @xmath48 must reach the _ and _ gate b before event @xmath50 , recalling that the latter has been produced by the arrival of event @xmath51 on the _ c - element_. then , the fork which dispatches both events @xmath48 and @xmath51 plays a crucial role in determining the order of points on _ and _ gate b. a few remarks are in order . concurrent computing is well illustrated by figure 11 . different computations proceed along paths involving vertical and propagation lines , each representing a causally ordered series of operations . causal order makes only sense either within each vertical line , where it is associated with the logical function of the module , or within propagating lines , where it connects the output of one module to the input of another module . but no a priori total order exists between all points of the graph . this is illustrated by the independence of computation on the order of some pairs of points . for instance , two events belonging to different branches of the fork on variable @xmath42 at the output of the _ c - element _ may have arbitrary relative order . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 2757,5487)(1384,-6418 ) ( 2071,-5416)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1891,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2971,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4051,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1441,-1096)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2431,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3511,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2026,-5956)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3241,-5956)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3151,-5506)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3736,-5281)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4141,-5056)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2566,-4966)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3151,-4381)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2656,-4381)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3736,-4291)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2566,-3796)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-3211)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3106,-2491)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2656,-2491)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2026,-2356)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-2041)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-5731)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2116,-2896)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3106,-3031)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2026,-3481)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3196,-3526)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4141,-3976)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3691,-4786)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 11 . space - time graph of the q - element . imposing a total ordering would amount to implement a global time , by means of clock distribution for instance , which would allow one to draw horizontal lines on the graph of figure 11 . but such condition is too restrictive , as computation only relies on causal relations imposed by vertical and propagation lines . the remaining freedom in the ordering of events , as the one related to the fork at the output of the _ c - element _ , is necessary for optimizing the circuit performance . for a definite implementation , event ordering will depend on the relative spatial localization of modules , so that the remaining freedom may be used to find an optimal arrangement of modules on the chip . the property of delay - insensitivity @xcite is easily seen on the graph . it corresponds to the independence of causal ordering of computation on delays occuring in responses of modules or in propagations of signals , i.e. on vertical or horizontal displacements of the modules . such property is made possible by using primitives which wait for the arrival of events at their input before producing other events at their output . but this condition appears to be unsufficient . in that respect , it is instructive to compare the two kinds of forks used by the previous composition implementing the _ q - element_. no constraint affects the events produced by the fork at the output of the _ c - element _ ( thick lines in figure 11 ) . however , forks dispatching the events produced by the environment must be implemented in such a way to respect the causal order of the events which they generate and which finally arrive at the same _ and _ gate ( dashed lines in figure 11 ) . such forks , which are called _ isochronic forks _ @xcite , must be isolated and given a special treatment at the implementation level , in order to satisfy the delay constraints which are necessary for preserving causal ordering . the property of delay - insensitivity ( di ) has been introduced and much developed as a simple condition one can impose on primitives and logical circuits , with the aim to design in a systematical way asynchronous circuits of arbitrary complexity , without having to take time scales into account . one approach consists in defining di circuits as compositions of stable primitives devoid of internal loops ( only electrical loops being used for memorization ) @xcite . a primitive is defined to be stable , by imposing that an input which changes the output can not change before the output has been established . it can then be shown that only compositions of _ c - elements _ can be di according to this definition . but , it can also be shown that compositions using _ c - elements _ ( and generalized _ c - elements _ with more inputs ) exclusively , strongly limit the type of allowed computations , excluding most circuits of interest @xcite . the _ isochronic fork _ may then be advocated as a weakest compromise to delay insensitivity . adding the _ isochronic fork _ and using this extended class of elements , called quasi delay - insensitive ( qdi ) , complex and efficient asynchronous circuits have been realized @xcite . however , as illustrated by the example of the _ q - element _ , _ isochronic forks _ need to be identified at the logical level and their implementation must be given a special treatment , which may reveal itself intricate for very complex circuits . * 5.2 delay insensitive composition * another approach for avoiding computation interferences @xcite , consists in defining a less restrictive set of di primitives , together with a notion of di composition of these primitives . circuits are represented in a formal language , called trace theory , similar to the one used in equation ( [ qelement ] ) , with further syntax rules on logical operations . computing interferences are avoided by imposing structural constraints under the form of simple rules . let us first recall definitions and some properties of trace structures @xcite . trace structures are defined as triples @xmath52 , where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are finite sets of symbols , respectively the input alphabet and the output alphabet , and @xmath55 is the set of traces , which is a subset of @xmath56 , the set of all finite - length sequences of symbols taken in the union set @xmath57 . trace structures are traditionally denoted by capital letters , while lower case letters @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 denote symbols and @xmath61 , @xmath62 traces . the following short notations are also frequently used : & & a ? < a , , a > + & & b ! operations of concatenation , union , repetition , prefix - closure , projection and weaving are defined on trace structures : [ operations ] & & r;s + & & r|s + & & * [ r ] + & & * pref*r + & & ra < * i*r a , * o*r a , ta| t r > + & & r||s where , for convenience , notation @xmath63 has been introduced for the total alphabet of @xmath64 , where @xmath65 denotes the projection of trace @xmath62 on alphabet @xmath66 and @xmath67 is the set of all finite - length concatenations of traces in @xmath55 ( symbols @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 denote as usual , existence , universality , set belonging , set intersection and set union ) . the @xmath73 operator constructs prefix - closed structures , while the projection operator hides internal symbols ; finally , the weave operator expresses instantaneous synchronization . a circuit is specified by a prefix - closed , non empty , trace structure @xmath64 with @xmath74 . the trace structure representing the environment of a circuit with trace structure @xmath64 is the reflection of the latter , and may also be given a compact notation : = < * o*r , * i*r , * t*r > a trace structure @xmath64 may be physically implemented by letting each symbol @xmath58 in the alphabets @xmath53 and @xmath54 correspond to a channel , and each occurence of this symbol in a trace of @xmath55 correspond to an event , i.e. a high or low transition , on the corresponding channel . symbols in @xmath53 or @xmath54 describe communication actions that are respectively produced by the environment or ( exclusive or ) by the circuit . in order to be able to ignore transmission delays while avoiding transmission and computing interferences , the following rules may be imposed @xcite . & & * r_0 * sr , ar s a a r + & & * r_1 * s , t r , ( a , br ) ( a , br ) + & & s a b t r s b a t r + & & * r_2 * s , t r , ( ar br ) ( ar br ) + & & ( s a b r s b a r ) ( s a b t r s b a t r ) rule @xmath75 excludes two consecutive transitions on the same wire , and hence transmission interferences that may result . rule @xmath76 expresses independence of computation on the order of signals travelling in the same direction , as this order may depend on suffered delays . the _ c - element _ is easily seen to satisfy this rule . however , the _ and _ gate only complies with the rule when it is waiting for a rising edge on its two inputs , and does not in all other cases . thus the _ and _ gate , and also the _ or _ gate are excluded by this rule , although the _ toggle _ , the _ merge _ and the _ sequencer _ are compatible . rule @xmath77 expresses the same property for signals travelling in opposite directions , in case their order does not change the result locally . note that due to the necessary symmetric treatment of a circuit and its environment , all rules are symmetric in the exchange of input and output symbols . one must exclude the possibility for a symbol of one type to disable a symbol of another type ( symbol @xmath58 is said to disable symbol @xmath59 in trace structure @xmath64 , if there is a trace @xmath61 with @xmath78 ) . such exclusion is necessary to prevent an admissible input symbol to get disabled by an output signal , depending on the delay the former has suffered on its way to the circuit ( by symmetry the same property must also hold for the environment and output signals ) . depending on the level of exclusion , this property leads to define three classes , with rules @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 : & & * r_3^ * s , a= br + & & ( s a r s b r ) s a b r & & * r_3^ * s , a= br ar br + & & ( s a r s b r ) s a b r & & * r_3^ * s , ( ar br ) ( ar br ) + & & ( s a r s b r ) s a b r these rules successively allow for more decision possibility . rule @xmath79 does not permit data transmission and is called synchronization class ( an example is provided by the _ c - element _ ) . rule @xmath80 allows for two inputs to disable each other and is called data communication class . with rule @xmath81 , a circuit may choose between two output symbols and belongs to the arbitration class . finally , rule @xmath77 appears on specific examples to be too restrictive @xcite . an alternative and more generally efficient rule is provided by : & & * r_2^ * s , t r , ( a , cr br ) ( a , cr br ) + & & ( s a b t cr s b a tr ) s b a t c r this rule , which is conveniently expressed on a space - time graph , as shown in figure 12 , concerns three events @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 connecting one module m and its environment @xmath82 . it stipulates that , if two time orders are allowed for the occurences of two events of different types ( i.e. one input and one output ) @xmath58 and @xmath59 , then if the event @xmath60 , of the same type as @xmath58 , is a consequence of the order `` @xmath58 then @xmath59 '' , it should also be a consequence of the other order `` @xmath59 then @xmath58 '' . this rule imposes that if an order on events is differently seen by a module and its environment , due to propagation time delays , then this order should have no consequence on the logical behavior of the module . as illustrated by figure 12 , this rule only affects the case on the left part of the figure , that is , only the case when propagation can change the order of events . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 2104,1932)(1159,-2368 ) ( 1216,-601)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1576,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2071,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2701,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3196,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1756,-1141)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2881,-1051)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1756,-1951)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1756,-1501)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2881,-1906)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2881,-1546)(0,0)[lb ] fig . space - time graph for rule @xmath83 . the set of di components is given by trace structures , defined according to definitions 1 and 2 , which satisfy the weakest form of the rules , i.e. @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 @xcite . a set of di primitive components for asynchronous circuits can thus be obtained with the following list of specifications in terms of trace structures ( see table 1 ) . .di primitive components [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] [ table1 ] the _ wire _ corresponds to a component which waits for an event to occur on its input , then sends an event on its output , and repeats this sequence indefinitely . the inverted wire ( _ iwire _ ) behaves similarly , but begins by sending an event on its output . the _ fork _ duplicates one input . as can be seen from definitions ( [ operations ] ) , weaving not only consists in putting in parallel , but also in synchronizing common output symbols . in the particular case of two _ wires _ with a common output , weaving leads to the _ c - element_. the other components correspond to the primitive circuits which have been previously introduced ( see figure 9 ) . the objective is to realize circuits corresponding to given complex specifications by combining simple di primitive circuits . this aim may be attained by making use of operations such as decomposition and substitution , together with two theorems setting the conditions for performing these operations . a component @xmath84 is said to be decomposed into components @xmath88 ( for @xmath89 if the following conditions are satisfied . letting @xmath90 [ decomposition ] & & ( i ) _ 0i < n ( * o*s_i ) = _ 0i < n ( * i*s_i ) + & & ( ii ) * o*s_i s_j = , 0i , j < n i= j + & & ( iii ) t , x , i ( 0i < n ) + & & tt xs_i txs_i s_i txt + & & ( iv)*t*ts_0 = * t*s_0 conditions in ( [ decomposition ] ) respectively describe a closed network ( each input is connected to an output and conversely ( i ) ) , absence of output interferences ( two outputs can not be connected ( ii ) ) , absence of computing interferences ( any event produced by a component is compatible with the behavior of the component which receives it ( iii ) ) and correct behavior at circuit boundary ( network behaves as prescribed ( iv ) ) . decomposition will be denoted by @xmath91 . let us now state two useful theorems ( proofs may be obtained in @xcite ) . for components @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 and @xmath94 & & r_0 ( r_1 , s ) s ( r_2 , r_3 ) + & & r_0 ( r_1 , r_2 , r_3)holds if ( * a*r_0 r_1 ) ( * a*r_2 r_3 ) = * a*s the latter condition stipulates that internal symbols of @xmath94 , i.e. symbols in @xmath95 , where @xmath96 means set deletion , should not appear in @xmath97 . it can be realized by an appropriate renaming of internal symbols of @xmath94 . [ theorem]separation theorem for components @xmath98 and @xmath99 ( @xmath100 ) & & r_0 ( r_i)_1i < n s_0 ( s_i)_1i < n + & & r_0||s_0 ( r_i||s_i)_1i < n holds if & & ( _ 1i < n(*a*r_i ) \*a*r_0 ) ( _ 1i < n(*a*s_i ) \*a*s_0 ) = [ sep1 ] + & & , 1i= j < n + & & ( * o*r_i s_i ) ( * o*r_j s_j ) = + & & ( * o*r_i s_i ) ( * o*|r_0 ) = [ sep2 ] condition ( [ sep1 ] ) stipulates that the internal symbols of the decompositions of @xmath84 and @xmath101 are disjoint ( this condition may be satisfied by renaming some of these symbols ) , and conditions ( [ sep2 ] ) stipulate that the outputs of any two components @xmath102 and @xmath103 are also disjoint when the components are different ( these conditions may also be satisfied by reordering the components ) . with the help of these two theorems , the previously defined di primitives may be combined to give modular compositions which are delay insensitive , hence circuits where computing interferences can not be introduced by delay modifications only . we briefly describe an example of a circuit which can be obtained with such a composition of di primitives , the _ token - ring _ interface @xcite . the _ token - ring _ interface is a device allowing to connect several machines , which must share a common resource ( like a memory , or a bus ) . one item @xmath104 of this device will be associated with each machine @xmath105 , all items being identical and realizing the same function , as shown by figure 13 . item @xmath104 of this device is connected to two environments , the machine @xmath105 on top of the figure , and , at bottom , the ring @xmath64 where a token circulates . the arrival of the token at @xmath104 corresponds to an event on @xmath59 , its departure to an event on @xmath106 . the machine @xmath105 can make a request under the form of an event on @xmath107 . @xmath104 grants the resource to the machine @xmath105 by an event on @xmath108 . the machine @xmath105 signals the end of its use of the resource by an event on @xmath109 , which is acknowledged by @xmath104 under the form of an event on @xmath110 . initially , the _ token - ring _ interface is specified by the following trace structure : & & * [ a1?;p1!;a0?;p0 ! ] + & & || * pref**[b?;(q!|p1!;a0?;q ! ) ] this specification results from weaving two trace structures which respectively describe the communications of the token - ring interface with the machine @xmath105 and with the ring @xmath64 . the two trace stuctures interact through their common dependence on two events @xmath111 and @xmath112 . each trace structure may be decomposed into primitive elements . substitution and separation theorems may be applied , finally leading to a possible decomposition , as shown by figure 13 in a graphic way : ( & & * [ a1?;p1 ! ] + & & || * pref**[rq1?;q1 ! ] + & & || * pref**[b?;(q1!|p1!)],@xmath113,\ ] ] @xmath114,\ ] ] @xmath115,\ ] ] * [ ( q1?|q0?);q ! ) ] ) [ token - dec ] the first component is a _ sequencer _ ( see table 1 ) , necessary for synchronizing the output @xmath111 shared by the two trace structures defining the _ token - ring_. the _ sequencer _ also arbitrates between corresponding inputs . other components describe an _ iwire _ , two _ wires _ and a _ merge_. although they do not appear explicitly in decomposition ( [ token - dec ] ) , two forks appear in figure 13 , as a consequence of double occurences of @xmath116 and @xmath117 in ( [ token - dec ] ) . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 2814,2953)(1564,-4169 ) ( 3646,-2536)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4186,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3241,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2341,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3151,-2536)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3556,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2161,-2356)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3691,-2986)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2341,-2896)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2521,-3886)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3961,-3886)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2116,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-3481)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2116,-2581)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2611,-2761)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1576,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2611,-3301)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2926,-4111)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2386,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 13 . token - ring interface . the di property of this implementation can be visualized on a space - time graph , as in figure 14 . two cases have been represented in figure 14 . in the first case , the request @xmath107 done by the machine @xmath118 is not granted , the token being sent back to the ring . when the token arrives a second time , the resource is granted to the machine @xmath105 which was waiting . this illustrates the undeterministic behavior of the module @xmath119 , which depends on arbitration performed by _ sequencer _ b. the figure also shows that the two forks , that on @xmath120 ( output of b ) and that defined by d can not create computation interferences , so that no particular constraints are necessary . this results from the function of _ sequencer _ b , which is not perturbed whatever the order of the events on its inputs . _ sequencer _ b waits for an event on @xmath59 to make a decision , and then arbitrates between the different requests it has received . as shown by the example of the _ token - ring _ interface , di primitives and di decomposition may be used to generate modular compositions which are delay insensitive , and , as shown with the help of space - time graphs , that remain free of computing interferences . delay - insensitivity appears as a simple criterion for escaping problems raised by computing interferences in a purely logically way , i.e. without recourse to a detailed analysis of the physical implementation of a circuit . the di criterion allows one to treat asynchronous circuits efficiently , like in the case of synchronous circuits , by allowing to represent them formally ( in terms of trace structures ) . although revealing a genuinely different underlying structure , the causal constraints on asynchronous circuits , as exhibited by space - time graphs , can nonetheless be embedded in a simple set of formal rules which limit the definition and composition of di circuits . in general , these rules allow di circuits to be decomposed into a number of di primitive components which increases linearly with the length of the circuit specification @xcite . ( 0,0 ) # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3082,5532)(1306,-6418 ) ( 2071,-4606)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3421,-2086)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2296,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4051,-2761)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2296,-3436)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1756,-4381)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3421,-5281)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1756,-5281)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2161,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3241,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3781,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4321,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2656,-6181)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1486,-1051)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2926,-2761)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3466,-2806)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2971,-3391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3421,-3931)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4006,-4561)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1891,-4741)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2341,-5731)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3376,-4561)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1606,-3706)(0,0)[lb ] fig . 14 . space - time graph of the token - ring interface . without giving definite answers to the problems raised in the introduction , we have nethertheless tried to provide some hints on the essential role played by physical time in computation . the necessary reference to physical time in physical implementations of logical circuits forces one to give an explicit treatment of computation interferences . these arise as obstructions when trying to make the causality underlying logical circuits coincide with the physical causality of their implementations . for synchronous circuits , these may be avoided by ruling the whole circuit with a single clock , which thus provides a global reference to a newtonian time . in general however , circuits must be considered as asynchronous and physical space - time as relativistic . in the latter , not all points are causally related , but only those such that one point falls within the light cone issued from the other . in that respect , asynchronous circuits and relativistic space - time share the same founding point of view . points derive from events and not the converse , propagating events being treated as primary entities and not as successions of points . the distinction between two classes of points can also be seen in a simple way : two points are causally related if and only if there exists a path between them using vertical or propagation lines ( in different spatial directions , but in the same time direction ) ; on another hand , points defined on two different events originating from the same point are not causally related @xcite . similarly for a concurrent computation , each computing path connects points which are causally related . avoiding computing interferences corresponds to impose that different computing paths respect a same time ordering , but only for pairs of causally related points . remedies to computing interferences in asynchronous circuits consist in recognizing paths which may conflict with a module specification , and in eventually delaying these paths , so that to respect a prescribed time ordering . this can be done either physically , at the implementation level by introducing explicit time delays , or at the logical level , by imposing specification rules which prevent the occurence of such conflicts . the latter solution , by imposing delay insensitivity both on circuits specification and decomposition in a consistent way , has the advantage of providing a purely logical characterization of the causal constraints . di circuits then build a class which may be seen as intermediate between synchronous circuits and general asynchronous circuits . they share with the former the possibility to be completely characterized by formal expressions and rules . but they rely on the same causal structure as the latter . synchronous circuits rely on time simultaneity classes , and thus on a causal structure which is typical of newtonian space - time . asynchronous circuits , on another hand , rely on a consistent treatment of propagation delays and time ordering , hence on a causal structure which characterizes relativistic space - time . delay - insensitivity provides an interesting transition between local properties , like those defining sequential processors , and global ones , like those exhibited by distributed systems . but di circuits hardly exhaust the computation potentialities brought by the introduction of asynchronous circuits . the critical consequences of delay sensitivity rather suggest to consider a further alternative when attempting to classify the different types of computations , i.e. those performed by synchronous , by di asynchronous and by ds ( delay - sensitive ) asynchronous circuits . similarly , in the same way as asynchronous computing machines may not always allow simulation by synchronous computing machines , one may infer that physical processes and physical laws , which intrinsically obey relativistic causality , may be simulated by synchronous machines in particular cases only . this hints at another advantage of computations based on asynchronous circuits , i.e. the ability to simulate in a universal way real physical processes . chakraborty , s. , yun , k.y . and dill , d.l . ( 1988 ) practical timing analysis of asynchronous circuits using time separation of events . _ proceedings of the ieee custom integrated circuits conference _ , 455458 . ieee computer society press ( may ) . davis , a. and nowick , s.m . ( 1995 ) asynchronous circuit design : motivation , background and methods . in g. birtwistle and a. davis ( editors ) , _ asynchronous digital circuit design , workshop in computing _ , 149 . bcs - springer . furber , s. ( 1995 ) computing without clocks : micropipelining the arm processor . in g. birtwistle and a. davis ( editors ) , _ asynchronous digital circuit design , workshop in computing _ , 211262 . bcs - springer . jaekel , m.t . and reynaud , s. ( 1998 ) quantum observables associated with einstein localisation . in e. zavattini , d. bakalov and c. rizzo ( editors ) , _ frontier tests of qed and physics of the vacuum ( sandansky , 1998 ) _ , 389404 . heron press . mallon , w.c . , udding , j.t . and verhoeff , t. ( 1999 ) analysis and applications of the xdi model . in async99 , proc . international symposium on advanced research in asynchronous circuits and systems _ , 231242 . ieee computer society press . martin , a.j . ( 1990b ) the limitations to delay - insensitivity in asynchronous circuits . in w. j. dally ( editor ) _ advanced research in vlsi : proceedings of the sixth mit conference _ , 263278 . mit press , cambridge , ma . martin , a.j . , lines , a. , manohar , r. , nystrm , m. , penzes , p. , southworth , r. , cummings , u. and tak - kwan - lee ( 1997 ) the design of an asynchronous mips r3000 microprocessor . in _ proceedings of the seventeenth conference on advanced research in vlsi _ , 164181 . ieee computer society press . matherat , p. and jaekel , m.t . ( 1996 ) dissipation logique des implmentations dautomates - dissipation du calcul . _ technique et science informatiques _ * 15*(8 ) , 10791104 . english translation at the url http://www.arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9805018 . mazurkiewicz , a. ( 1989 ) basic notions of trace theory . in j. w. de bakker , w. p. de roever , and g. rozenberg ( editors ) _ linear time , branching time , and partial order in logics and models for concurrency . lncs 354 _ , 285 . springer - verlag . school / workshop , noordwijkerhout , the nederlands , may - june 1988 . stevens , k. , ginosar , r. and rotem , s. ( 1999 ) relative timing . in _ async99 , proc . international symposium on advanced research in asynchronous circuits and systems _ , 208218 . ieee computer society press . winskel , g. ( 1989 ) an introduction to event structures . in j. w. de bakker , w. p. de roever , and g. rozenberg ( editors ) _ linear time , branching time , and partial order in logics and models for concurrency . lncs 354 _ , 364397 . springer - verlag . school / workshop , noordwijkerhout , the nederlands , may - june 1988 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: _ globally coupled maps _ are collections of individual discrete - time dynamical systems ( their _ units _ ) which act independently on their respective phase spaces , except for the influence ( the _ coupling _ ) of a common parameter that is updated , at each time step , as a function of the _ mean field _ of the whole system . systems of this type have received some attention through the work of kaneko @xcite in the early 1990s , who studied systems of @xmath0 quadratic maps acting on coordinates @xmath1 $ ] , and coupled by a parameter depending in a simple way on @xmath2 . his key observation , for huge _ system size _ @xmath0 , was the following : if @xmath3 denotes the time series of mean field values of the system started in a random configuration @xmath4 , then , for many parameters of the quadratic map , and even for very small coupling strength , pairs @xmath5 of consecutive values of the field showed complicated functional dependencies plus some noise of order @xmath6 , whereas for uncoupled systems of the same size the @xmath7 , after a while , are constant up to some noise of order @xmath6 . while the latter observation is not surprising for independent units , the complicated dependencies for weakly coupled systems , a phenomenon kaneko termed _ violation of the law of large numbers _ , called for closer investigation . the rich bifurcation structure of the family of individual quadratic maps may offer some explanations , but since a mathematically rigorous investigation of even a small number of coupled quadratic maps in the chaotic regime still is a formidable task , there seem to be no serious attempts to tackle this problem . a model which is mathematically much easier to treat is given by coupled tent maps . indeed , for tent maps with slope larger than @xmath8 and moderate coupling strength , a system of @xmath0 mean field coupled units has an ergodic invariant probability density with exponentially decreasing correlations @xcite . this is true for all @xmath0 and for coupling strengths that can be chosen to be the same for all @xmath0 . nevertheless , ershov and potapov @xcite showed numerically that ( albeit on a much smaller length scale than in the case of coupled quadratic maps ) also mean field coupled tent maps exhibit a violation of the law of large numbers in the aforementioned sense . they also provided a mathematical analysis which demonstrated that the discontinuities of the invariant density of a tent map are at the heart of the problem . their analysis was not completely rigorous , however , as chawanya and morita @xcite could show that there are indeed ( exceptional ) parameters of the system for which there is no violation of the law of large numbers - contrary to the predictions in @xcite . on the other hand , references @xcite contain further simulation results on systems violating the law of large numbers . ( but at present , a mathematically rigorous treatment of globally coupled tent maps that is capable of classifying and explaining the diverse dynamical effects that have been observed does not seem to be in sight either . ) these studies were complemented by papers by jrvenp @xcite and keller @xcite , showing ( among other things ) that globally coupled systems of smooth expanding circle maps do not display violation of the law of large numbers at small coupling strength , because their invariant densities are smooth . given this state of knowledge , the present paper investigates specific systems of globally coupled piecewise fractional linear maps on the interval @xmath9 $ ] , where each individual map has a smooth invariant density . for small coupling strength , theorem 4 in @xcite extends easily to this setup and proves the absence of a violation of the law of large numbers . for larger coupling strength , however , we are going to show that this phenomenon does occur in the following sense : bifurcation : : the nonlinear _ self - consistent perron - frobenius operator ( pfo ) _ @xmath10 on @xmath11 , which describes the dynamics of the system in its thermodynamic limit , undergoes a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation as the coupling strength increases . ( here and in the sequel @xmath12 denotes lebesgue measure . ) mixing : : at the same time , all corresponding finite - size systems have unique absolutely continuous invariant probability measures @xmath13@xmath14 on their @xmath0-dimensional state space , and exhibit exponential decay of correlations under this measure . stable behaviour : : in the _ stable regime _ , i.e. for fixed small coupling strength below the bifurcation point of the infinite - size system , the measures @xmath13@xmath14 converge weakly , as the system size @xmath15 , to an infinite product measure @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the unique fixed point of @xmath10 . bistable behaviour : : in the _ bistable regime _ , i.e. for fixed coupling strength above the bifurcation point of the infinite - size system , all possible weak limits of the measures @xmath13@xmath14 are convex combinations of the three infinite product measures @xmath18 , @xmath19 , where now @xmath17 is the unique unstable fixed point of @xmath10 and @xmath20 are its two stable fixed points . ( we conjecture that the measure @xmath16 is not charged in the limit . ) this scenario clearly bears some resemblance to the curie - weiss model from statistical mechanics and its dynamical variants . we also stress that a simple modification of our system leads to a variant where , instead of two stable fixed points , one stable two - cycle for @xmath10 is created at the bifurcation point . this may be viewed as the simplest possible scenario for a violation of the law of large numbers in kaneko s original sense . + in the next section we describe our model in detail , and formulate the main results . section [ sec : finite - sys - proofs ] contains the proofs for finite - size systems . in section [ sec : ifs ] we start the investigation of the infinite - size system via the self - consistent pfo @xmath10 . we observe that this operator preserves a class of probability densities which can be characterised as derivatives of herglotz - pick - nevanlinna functions . integral representations of these functions reveal a hidden order structure , which is respected by the operator @xmath10 , and allows us to describe the pitchfork bifurcation . in section [ sec : infinite - sys - proofs ] this dynamical picture for @xmath21 is extended to arbitrary densities . finally , in section [ sec : noisy ] , we discuss the situation when some noise is added to the dynamics . throughout , all measures are understood to be borel , and we let @xmath22probability measures on @xmath23 . lebesgue measure will be denoted by @xmath12 . we introduce a @xmath24-parameter family of piecewise fractional - linear transformations @xmath25 on @xmath26 $ ] , which will play the role of the local maps . to facilitate manipulation of such maps , we use their standard matrix representation , letting @xmath27{cc}a & b\\ c & d \end{array } \right ) \text{,}\ ] ] so that @xmath28 and @xmath29 . specifically , we consider the function @xmath30 , depending on a parameter @xmath31 , given by the coefficient matrix @xmath32{cc}r+4 & r+1\\ 2r & 2 \end{array } \right ) \text{.}\ ] ] one readily checks that @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 for @xmath36 , and that ( the infimum being attained on @xmath37 ) @xmath38 the latter shows that @xmath30 is uniformly expanding if and only if @xmath39 , and we define our _ single - site maps _ @xmath40 with parameter @xmath41 by letting @xmath42{ll}f_{m_{r}}(x ) & \text{on } [ -\frac{1}{2},\alpha_{r})\text{,}\\ f_{m_{r}}(x)-1=f_{n_{r}}(x ) & \text{on } ( \alpha_{r},\frac{1}{2}]\text{,}\end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath43 we thus obtain a family @xmath44 of uniformly expanding , piecewise invertible maps @xmath40 , each having two increasing covering branches . note also that this family is symmetric in that @xmath45 according to well - known folklore results , each map @xmath25 , @xmath41 , has a unique invariant probability density @xmath46 , and @xmath25 is exact ( hence ergodic ) w.r.t . the corresponding invariant measure . due to ( [ eq_symmetry ] ) , we have @xmath47 mod @xmath12 . we denote the _ perron - frobenius operator _ ( _ pfo_),w.r.t . lebesgue measure @xmath12 , of a map @xmath48 by @xmath49 , abbreviating @xmath50 . in our construction below we will exploit the fact that 2-to-1 fractional linear maps like @xmath25 in fact enable a fairly explicit analysis of their pfos on a suitable class of densities . in particular , the @xmath51 are known explicitly : let @xmath52 , @xmath53 . then @xmath54 is an integrable invariant density for @xmath55 , see @xcite . its normalised version @xmath56 is the unique @xmath55-invariant probability density . the key point in the choice of this family of maps is that for @xmath57 , @xmath55 is steeper in the positive part of @xmath58 than in its negative part , hence typical orbits spend more time on the negative part , which is confirmed by the invariant density ( see figure [ fig : trandhr ] ) . if @xmath59 , then @xmath55 favours the positive part . ( left ) , and @xmath51 ( right ) , for @xmath60 . ] ( left ) , and @xmath51 ( right ) , for @xmath60 . ] the heuristics of our construction is that for sufficiently strong coupling this effect of `` polarisation '' is reinforced and gives rise to bistable behaviour . for any probability measure @xmath61 , we denote its mean by @xmath62 and call this the _ field _ of @xmath63 . with a slight abuse of notation we also write , for @xmath64 , @xmath65 and , for @xmath66 @xmath67 to define the system of globally coupled maps ( both in the finite- and the infinite - size case ) we will , at each step of the iteration , determine the actual parameter as a function of the present field . this is done by means of a _ feedback function _ @xmath68 $ ] which we always assume to be real - analytic . everything else remains true if @xmath69 is merely of class @xmath70 . ] and _ s - shaped _ in that it satisfies @xmath71 and @xmath72 for all @xmath73 , while @xmath74 if @xmath75 . the most important single parameter in our model is going to be @xmath76 which quantifies the _ coupling strength_. [ remark : tanh ] the following will be our standard example of a suitable feedback function @xmath69 : @xmath77 where @xmath78 and @xmath79 . ( this requires some numerical effort . for @xmath80 and @xmath81 , elementary estimates suffice . ) for the results to follow we shall impose a few additional constraints on the feedback function @xmath69 , made precise in assumptions i and ii below . we consider a system @xmath82 of @xmath0 coupled copies of the parametrised map , defined by @xmath83 with @xmath84 . for the following theorem , which we prove in section [ sec : finite - sys - proofs ] , we need the following assumption ( satisfied by the example above ) : @xmath85{0.88\linewidth}\text{\textbf{assumption i:}}\quad\text { $ g'(x){\leqslant}25 - 50|g(x)|$ for all $ x\in x$. } \end{minipage}}}\ ] ] [ theo : finite - systems ] suppose the s - shaped function @xmath69 satisfies . then , for any @xmath86 , the map @xmath82 has a unique absolutely continuous invariant probability measure @xmath13@xmath14 . its density is strictly positive and real analytic . the systems @xmath87 @xmath13@xmath88 are exponentially mixing in various strong senses , in particular do hlder observables have exponentially decreasing correlations . the key to the proof is an estimate ensuring uniform expansion . after establishing the latter in section [ sec : finite - sys - proofs ] , the theorem follows from `` folklore '' results whose origins are not so easy to locate in the literature . in a @xmath89-setting , existence , uniqueness and exactness of an invariant density were proved essentially by krzyzewski and szlenk @xcite . exponential mixing follows from the compactness of the transfer operator first observed by ruelle @xcite . for a result which applies in our situation and entails theorem 1 , we refer to the main theorem of @xcite . since the coupling we defined is of mean - field type , we can adapt from the probabilistic literature ( see for example @xcite ) the classical method of taking the _ thermodynamic limit _ of our family of finite - size systems @xmath90 , as @xmath15 . to do so , consider the set @xmath91 of borel probability measures on @xmath58 , equipped with the topology of weak convergence and the resulting borel @xmath92-algebra on @xmath91 . define @xmath93 by @xmath94 we can then represent the evolution of any finite - size system using @xmath95 . indeed , if @xmath96 is the empirical measure of @xmath97 , then @xmath98 satisfies @xmath99 . furthermore , when restricted to the set of probability measures absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath12 , @xmath100 is represented by the _ self - consistent perron frobenius operator _ , which is the nonlinear positive operator @xmath101 defined as @xmath102 clearly , this map satisfies @xmath103 and preserves the set @xmath104 of probability densities . note , however , that it does not contract , i.e. there are @xmath105 such that @xmath106 . one may finally join these two aspects , the action of @xmath95 on means of dirac masses , or on absolutely continuous measures , via the following observation : [ pr : propchaos ] let @xmath107 , with @xmath108 . if @xmath109 is chosen according to @xmath110 , then , for any @xmath111 , the empirical measures @xmath112 converge weakly to @xmath113 as @xmath15 . this result confirms the point of view that the self - consistent pfo @xmath114 represents the infinite - size thermodynamic limit @xmath15 of the finite - size systems @xmath90 . its proof is reasonably simple ( easier than for stochastic evolutions ) . the only difficulty is that @xmath100 is not a continuous map on the whole of @xmath91 . this can be overcome with the following lemma , which proposition [ pr : propchaos ] is a direct consequence of , and whose proof is given in section [ se : conttil ] . [ le : contttil ] assume that a sequence @xmath115 in @xmath91 converges weakly to some non - atomic @xmath63 . then @xmath116 converges weakly to @xmath117 . here is an immediate consequence of this lemma that will be used below . [ coro : contttil ] assume that a sequence @xmath118 of @xmath95-invariant borel probability measures _ on _ @xmath91 converges weakly to some probability @xmath119 _ on _ @xmath91 . if there is a borel set @xmath120 with @xmath121 which only contains non - atomic measures , then @xmath119 is also @xmath95-invariant . our goal is to analyse the asymptotics of @xmath101 on @xmath104 . some basic features of @xmath101 can be understood considering the dynamics of @xmath122,}\ \quad { h}(r):=g(\phi(u_{r})),\ ] ] which governs the action of @xmath101 on the densities @xmath123 introduced in [ subsec : family - def ] , as @xmath124 in studying @xmath101 , we will always presuppose the following : @xmath125 this assumption can be checked numerically for specific feedback functions @xmath69 , like that of remark [ remark : tanh ] , cf . [ ssec : infinite - sys - proofs-1 ] below . by ( [ eq_symmetry ] ) , @xmath126 . note , however , that @xmath127 itself is not s - shaped ( see figure [ fig : plots-1 ] ) so that the s - shapedness of @xmath69 alone is not sufficient for that of @xmath128 . + assumption ii will enter our arguments only via the following dichotomy which it entails : either @xmath129 has a unique fixed point at @xmath130 + ( the * stable regime * with @xmath131 and @xmath130 stable ) , + or + @xmath129 has exactly three fixed points @xmath132 + ( the * bistable regime * with @xmath133 and @xmath134 stable ) . we will see that @xmath135 and @xmath136 , so that the stable regime corresponds to the condition @xmath137 . observe now that @xmath138 ( since @xmath139 for @xmath140 , and each @xmath25 is ergodic ) . we are going to show that the fixed points @xmath141 , and @xmath142 dominate the long - term behaviour of @xmath143 on @xmath104 completely , and that they inherit the stability properties of the corresponding parameters @xmath132 . therefore , the stable / bistable terminology for @xmath144 introduced above also provides an appropriate description of the asymptotic behaviour of @xmath101 . [ * long - term behaviour of * @xmath101 * * on * * @xmath104 ] [ theo : infinite - system ] consider @xmath145 , @xmath146 equipped with the metric inherited from @xmath11 . assuming ( i ) and ( ii ) , we have the following : 1 . [ theo2:item1 ] in the stable regime , @xmath17 is the unique fixed point of @xmath101 , and attracts all densities , that is , @xmath147 2 . in the bistable regime , @xmath148 are the only fixed points of @xmath101 . now @xmath17 is unstable , while @xmath149 and @xmath150 are stable . more precisely : a. @xmath142 are stable fixed points for @xmath101 in the sense that their respective basins of attraction are @xmath151-open . b. if @xmath152 is not attracted by @xmath149 or @xmath150 , then it is attracted by @xmath153 . c. @xmath153 is not stable . indeed , @xmath17 can be @xmath151-approximated by convex analytic densities from either basin . it is a hyperbolic fixed point of @xmath10 in the sense made precise in proposition [ prop : hyperbolic - fixed ] of section [ sec : infinite - sys - proofs ] . in case @xmath154 with @xmath78 and @xmath79 , both theorems apply . the infinite - size system is stable iff @xmath155 , and bistable otherwise , while all finite - size systems have a unique a.c.i.m . in this parameter region . the theorem summarises the contents of propositions [ prop : summary2 ] , [ prop : basin - boundary ] and [ prop : hyperbolic - fixed ] of section [ sec : infinite - sys - proofs ] ( which , in fact , provide more detailed information ) . the proofs rest on the fact that pfos of maps with full fractional - linear branches leave the class of herglotz - pick - nevanlinna functions invariant . this observation can be used to study the action of @xmath101 in terms of an iterated function system on the interval @xmath156 $ ] with two fractional - linear branches and place dependent probabilities . in the bistable regime the system is of course not contractive , but it has strong monotonicity properties and special geometric features which allow to prove the theorem . + our third theorem , which is essentially a corollary to the previous ones , describes the passage from finite - size systems to the infinite - size system . below , weak convergence of the @xmath13@xmath157 to some @xmath158@xmath159 means that @xmath160@xmath13@xmath161@xmath13 for all continuous @xmath162 which only depend on finitely many coordinates . ( so that @xmath163@xmath13@xmath14 is defined , in the obvious fashion , for @xmath0 large enough . ) [ theo : passage - to - infinity ] the @xmath90-invariant probability measures @xmath13@xmath14 of theorem [ theo : finite - systems ] correspond to the @xmath95-invariant probability measures @xmath13@xmath164 on @xmath91 . all weak accumulation points @xmath119 of the latter sequence are @xmath165-invariant probability measures concentrated on the set of measures absolutely continuous w.r.t . @xmath12 . furthermore : 1 . in the stable regime , the sequence @xmath166@xmath13@xmath167 converges weakly to the point mass @xmath168 . in other words , the sequence @xmath166@xmath13@xmath169 converges weakly to the pure product measure @xmath170 on @xmath171 . 2 . in the bistable regime , each weak accumulation point @xmath119 of the sequence @xmath166@xmath13@xmath167 is of the form @xmath172 for some @xmath173 $ ] . in other words , each weak accumulation point of the sequence @xmath166@xmath13@xmath169 is of the form @xmath174 . we can not prove , so far , that @xmath175 , which is to be expected because @xmath17 is an unstable fixed point of @xmath10 . in section [ sec : noisy ] we show that @xmath175 indeed , if some small noise is added to the system . as @xmath99 , the @xmath90-invariant probability measures @xmath13@xmath14 of theorem [ theo : finite - systems ] correspond to @xmath95-invariant probability measures @xmath13@xmath164 on @xmath176 . their possible weak accumulation points are all concentrated on sets of measures from @xmath176 with density w.r.t . @xmath12 , see theorem 3 in @xcite . ( the proof of that part of the theorem we refer to does not rely on the continuity of the local maps that is assumed in that paper . ) therefore corollary [ coro : contttil ] shows that all these accumulation points are @xmath165-invariant probability measures concentrated on measures with density w.r.t . @xmath12 . in other words , they can be interpreted as @xmath177-invariant probability measures on @xmath146 . now theorem [ theo : infinite - system ] implies that the sequence @xmath166@xmath13@xmath167 converges weakly to the point mass @xmath178 in the stable regime , whereas , in the bistable regime , each such limit measure is of the form @xmath172 for some @xmath173 $ ] ( observe the symmetry of the system ) . now the corresponding assertions on the measures @xmath13@xmath14 follow along known lines , for a reference see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * proposition 1 ) . we assume throughout this section that @xmath179 in order to apply the main theorem of mayer @xcite we must check his assumptions ( a1 ) ( a4 ) for the map @xmath180 . to that end define @xmath181^n$ ] by @xmath182 . obviously @xmath183 , and ( a1 ) ( a4 ) follow readily from the following facts that we are going to prove : [ lemma : homeo ] @xmath181^n$ ] is a homeomorphism which extends to a diffeomorphism between open neighbourhoods of @xmath184 and @xmath185^n$ ] . [ lemma : analytic - diffeo ] the inverse @xmath186 of @xmath187 is real analytic and can be continued to a holomorphic mapping on a complex @xmath188-neighbourhood @xmath189 of @xmath185^n$ ] such that @xmath190 is contained in a @xmath191-neighbourhood of @xmath184 for some @xmath192 . to verify these two lemmas we need the following uniform expansion estimate which we will prove at the end of this section . ( here @xmath193 denotes the euclidean norm . ) [ lemma : inv - contraction ] there is a constant @xmath194 such that @xmath195 for all @xmath196 and @xmath197 . obviously @xmath198^n$ ] . hence it is sufficient to prove the assertions of the lemma for the map @xmath199 . as each @xmath200 is differentiable on @xmath201 ( recall that @xmath202 ) , @xmath203 extends to an analytic mapping from @xmath204 . by lemma [ lemma : inv - contraction ] , it is locally invertible on @xmath205 for each sufficiently small @xmath206 . ( note that @xmath207 . ) all we need to show is that this implies global invertibility of @xmath208 , because then the possibility to extend @xmath203 diffeomorphically to a small open neighbourhood of @xmath184 in @xmath209 follows again from the local invertibility on @xmath210 for some @xmath211 . so we prove the global invertibility of @xmath208 . as each @xmath212 is a homeomorphism that leaves fixed the endpoints of the interval @xmath58 , we have @xmath213 and @xmath214 . observing the simple fact that @xmath215 is a paracompact connected smooth manifold without boundary and with trivial fundamental group , we only need to show that @xmath208 is proper in order to deduce from ( * ? ? ? * corollary 1 ) that @xmath216 is a diffeomorphism of @xmath215 . so let @xmath217 be a compact subset of @xmath215 . as @xmath216 extends to the continuous map @xmath218 and as @xmath213 , the set @xmath219 is closed and hence compact . therefore @xmath208 is indeed proper . as @xmath187 is real analytic on a real neighbourhood of @xmath184 , the real analyticity of @xmath186 on a real neighbourhood of @xmath185^n$ ] follows from the real analytic inverse function theorem ( * ? ? ? * theorem 18.1 ) . it extends to a holomorphic function on a complex @xmath188-neighbourhood @xmath189 of @xmath185^n$ ] see e.g. the discussion of complexifications of real analytic maps in@xcite . if @xmath220 is sufficiently small , lemma [ lemma : inv - contraction ] implies that @xmath186 is a uniform contraction on @xmath189 . hence the @xmath191 in the statement of the lemma can be chosen strictly smaller than @xmath188 . recall that @xmath221 where @xmath222 , @xmath223 and we write @xmath224 instead of @xmath200 . denote @xmath225 , @xmath226 and observe that @xmath227 simplifies to @xmath228 so that @xmath229 then the derivative of the coupled map @xmath230 is @xmath231 with @xmath232 denoting the identity matrix . letting @xmath233 and observing that @xmath234 so that @xmath235 , the inverse of @xmath236 is @xmath237 in order to check conditions under which @xmath187 is uniformly expanding in all directions , it is sufficient to find conditions under which @xmath238 _ uniformly _ in @xmath239 . observe first that @xmath240 for @xmath241 . from now on we fix a point @xmath239 and suppress it as an argument to all functions . then , if @xmath242 is any vector in @xmath243 , some scalar multiple of it can be decomposed in a unique way as @xmath244 where @xmath245 is perpendicular to @xmath246 . denote @xmath247 , @xmath248 , and observe that @xmath249 as @xmath246 has only nonnegative entries . we estimate the euclidian norm of @xmath250 : @xmath251 where @xmath252 . as @xmath253 and @xmath254 ( observe that all entries of @xmath246 are bounded by @xmath24 ) , we can continue the above estimate with @xmath255 to estimate this expression we abbreviate temporarily @xmath256 . then @xmath257 , and straightforward maximisation yields : @xmath258 so we can continue the above estimate by @xmath259 where @xmath260 hence @xmath261 and therefore @xmath262 observing @xmath263 one finds numerically that the norm is bounded by @xmath264 uniformly for all @xmath265 , if @xmath266 and @xmath267 . hence the map @xmath187 is uniformly expanding in all directions provided ( [ eq : finite - ass ] ) holds . the pfos @xmath268 allow a detailed analysis since their action on certain densities has a convenient explicit description : consider the family @xmath269 of probability densities on @xmath58 given by @xmath270 as pointed out in @xcite ( using different parametrisations ) , perron - frobenius operators @xmath271 of fractional - linear maps @xmath272 act on these densities via their _ duals _ @xmath273 , where @xmath274{cc}0 & 1\\ 1 & 0 \end{array } \right ) \cdot m\cdot\left ( \begin{array } [ c]{cc}0 & 1\\ 1 & 0 \end{array } \right ) = \left ( \begin{array } [ c]{cc}d & c\\ b & a \end{array } \right ) \text { \quad for } m=\left ( \begin{array } [ c]{cc}a & b\\ c & d \end{array } \right ) \text{,}\ ] ] in that @xmath275 for matrices @xmath276 and intervals @xmath277 for which @xmath278 . ( this can also be verified by direct calculation ) . since @xmath279 , one can compute the duals @xmath280 of the individual branches of @xmath25 , then express @xmath281 as the convex combination @xmath282}\cdot w_{y})\nonumber\\ & = p_{r}(y)\cdot w_{\sigma_{r}(y)}+(1-p_{r}(y))\cdot w_{\tau_{r}(y)}\text{,}\label{eq_pr_gy_in_terms_of_sigma_tau}\ ] ] with weights @xmath283 it is straightforward to check that for every @xmath31 the functions @xmath284 , @xmath285 are continuous and strictly increasing on @xmath156 $ ] with images @xmath286)=[-2,2/3]$ ] and @xmath287)=[-2/3,2]$ ] . from this remark and ( [ eq_pr_gy_in_terms_of_sigma_tau ] ) it is clear that the @xmath268 preserve the class of those @xmath288 which are convex combinations @xmath289 of the special densities @xmath290 for some _ representing measure _ @xmath13 from @xmath291 . we find that @xmath268 acts on representing measures according to @xmath292 where @xmath293 denotes the measure with density @xmath294 w.r.t . @xmath13 . to continue , we need to collect several facts about the dual maps @xmath284 and @xmath285 . we have @xmath295 showing that @xmath284 and @xmath285 are strictly concave , respectively convex , on @xmath156 $ ] . one next gets readily from that @xmath296 wherever defined , and @xmath297\diagdown\{-r\}\ ] ] while ( and this observation will be crucial later on ) @xmath298 and @xmath299 have a common zero @xmath300 and @xmath301 in the following , we restrict our parameter @xmath302 to the set @xmath303 $ ] . direct calculation proves that , letting @xmath304 $ ] , we have @xmath305 so that @xmath306 is an invariant set for all such @xmath284 and @xmath285 , and that @xmath307 which provides us with a common contraction rate on @xmath306 for the @xmath284 and @xmath285 from this parameter region . all these features of @xmath298 and @xmath299 are illustrated by figure [ fig : sigma - tau ] . and @xmath299 for @xmath308 . the small invariant box has endpoints @xmath309 and @xmath299 . ] we denote by @xmath310 the field of the density @xmath311 , and find by explicit integration that @xmath312 for @xmath313 . in particular , @xmath314 and @xmath315 , so the field depends monotonically on @xmath316 . note also that we have , for all @xmath317 , @xmath318 we focus on densities @xmath319 with representing measure @xmath13 supported on @xmath306 , i.e. on the class @xmath320 : @xmath321 . writing @xmath322 and recalling ( [ eq_pr_acting_on_representing_measures ] ) , we find that our nonlinear operator @xmath101 acts on the representing measures from @xmath323 via @xmath324 as @xmath325 , the support of @xmath326 , is contained in @xmath327 , it is immediate from ( [ eq_invariance_of_y ] ) that @xmath328 for @xmath329 $ ] we find that @xmath284 and @xmath285 each have a unique stable fixed point in @xmath306 , given by @xmath330 respectively . note that the interval @xmath331 $ ] of width @xmath332 between these stable fixed points is invariant under both @xmath284 and @xmath285 , see the small boxed region in figure [ fig : sigma - tau ] . furthermore , each of @xmath333 and @xmath334 is mapped to @xmath302 under the branch not fixing it , i.e. @xmath335 meaning that , restricted to @xmath336 , @xmath284 and @xmath285 are the inverse branches of some 2-to-1 piecewise fractional linear map @xmath337 . the explicit @xmath25-invariant densities @xmath51 from ( [ eq : inv - dens-2 ] ) can be represented as @xmath338 with @xmath339 given by @xmath340 our goal in this section is to study the asymptotic behaviour of @xmath101 on @xmath341 , using its representation by means of the ifs @xmath342 . we will prove [ * long - term behaviour of * @xmath101 * * on * * @xmath341 ] [ prop : summary ] take any @xmath343 , @xmath344 for some @xmath317 . the following is an exhaustive list of possibilities for the asymptotic behaviour of the sequence @xmath345 : 1 . @xmath346 for some @xmath111 . then @xmath345 converges to @xmath347 and hence @xmath348 converges to @xmath349 in @xmath350 . [ item : summary-2 ] the interval @xmath351 contains @xmath352 for all @xmath111 . then @xmath345 converges to @xmath353 and hence @xmath354 converges to @xmath17 in @xmath350 . in this case also the length of @xmath351 tends to @xmath352 3 . @xmath355 for some @xmath111 . then @xmath356 converges to @xmath357 and hence @xmath348 converges to @xmath358 in @xmath350 . in the stable regime , only scenario ( 2 ) is possible , so that we always have convergence of @xmath345 to @xmath353 . our arguments will rely on continuity and monotonicity properties of the ifs , that we detail below , before proving proposition [ prop : summary ] in section [ se : propro ] . _ convergence in _ @xmath323 , @xmath359 , will always mean weak convergence of measures , @xmath360 for bounded continuous @xmath361 . since @xmath306 is a bounded interval , this is equivalent to convergence in the _ wasserstein - metric _ @xmath362 on @xmath323 . if @xmath363 and @xmath364 are the distribution functions of @xmath13 and @xmath365 , then @xmath366 the kantorovich - rubinstein theorem ( e.g. ( * ? ? * ch.11 ) ) provides an additional characterisation : @xmath367{\leqslant}1}\int_{y}\psi\,d(\mu-\nu)\ ] ] for any @xmath368 . here , @xmath369 : = \sup_{y , y^{\prime}\in y;y\neq y^{\prime}}\left\vert \psi(y)-\psi(y^{\prime})\right\vert /\left\vert y - y^{\prime}\right\vert $ ] for any @xmath370 ( and analogously for functions on other domains ) . we now see that there is a constant @xmath371 ( the common lipschitz bound for the functions @xmath372 on @xmath306 , where @xmath73 ) such that @xmath373 this means that , for densities from @xmath341 , convergence of the representing measures implies @xmath151-convergence of the densities . we will also use the following estimate . [ lemma : stability ] there are constants @xmath374 such that @xmath375 for all @xmath368 and all @xmath376 . for lipschitz functions @xmath377 on @xmath306 we have @xmath378 \cdot{\mathsf{d}_w}(\mu,\nu)\nonumber\\ + \sup_{y\in y}\,\mathrm{lip}_{r}\left [ \psi(\sigma_{.}(y))\,p_{. } ( y)+\psi(\tau_{.}(y))(1-p_{.}(y))\right ] \cdot|r - s| \end{gathered}\ ] ] suppose that @xmath377 is @xmath379 , with @xmath380 . then the first lipschitz constant is bounded by @xmath381 } < \infty,\ ] ] and the second one by @xmath382 } < \infty,\ ] ] and the lemma follows from the kantorovich - rubinstein theorem , since these @xmath383 functions @xmath377 uniformly approximate the lipschitz functions appearing there . [ co : contifs ] the operators @xmath384 , @xmath385 , and @xmath342 are uniformly lipschitz - continuous on @xmath323 for the wasserstein metric . the lipschitz - continuity of @xmath384 is immediate from lemma [ lemma : stability ] . for @xmath342 , we recall from and that @xmath386 with @xmath387 so that @xmath388 which allows to conclude with lemma [ lemma : stability ] . rigorous numerical bounds give @xmath389 and @xmath390 . these estimates can be used to show that not only the individual @xmath384 are uniformly contracting on @xmath323 , but also ( under suitable restrictions on the function @xmath69 ) @xmath342 is a uniform contraction on @xmath391 where @xmath392 is a suitable neighbourhood of the support of @xmath347 , and @xmath347 is the representing measure of @xmath349 with @xmath393 the unique positive fixed point of the equation @xmath394 . our treatment of @xmath342 , however , does not rely on these estimates , because it is based on monotonicity properties explained below . on the space @xmath323 of probability measures @xmath395 representing densities from @xmath396 we introduce an order relation by defining @xmath397 the symbols @xmath398 , @xmath399 and @xmath400 designate the usual variants of @xmath401 . we collect a few elementary facts on this order relation : @xmath402{0.88\linewidth}$\mu\preceq\nu$ if and only if $ \textstyle{\int_y } u\,d\mu{\leqslant}\int_y u\,d\nu$ for each bounded and non - decreasing $ u : y\to{{\mathbb r}}$.\end{minipage}}}\ ] ] in particular , if @xmath403 , then @xmath404 , and hence @xmath405 as well . @xmath406{0.88\linewidth}if $ \mu\preceq\nu$ and if $ \rho_1,\rho_2:y\to y$ are non - decreasing and such that $ \rho_1(y){\leqslant}\rho_2(y)$ for all $ y$ , then $ \mu\circ\rho_1^{-1}\preceq\nu\circ\rho_2^{-1}$.\end{minipage}}}\ ] ] @xmath407{0.88\linewidth}if $ \mu\preceq\nu$ and if $ { \textstyle{\int_y } } u\,d\mu = { \textstyle{\int_y } } u\,d\nu$ for some strictly increasing\\ $ u : y\to{{\mathbb r}}$ , then $ \mu=\nu$.\end{minipage}}}\ ] ] @xmath408{0.88\linewidth}let $ z\in y$. then $ \delta_z\preceq\mu$ if and only if $ { \operatorname{supp}}(\mu)\subseteq[z,\infty)$.\end{minipage}}}\ ] ] we also observe that the representing measures @xmath409 of the @xmath55-invariant densities @xmath51 form a linearly ordered subset of @xmath323 . routine calculations based on ( [ eq : mu - r - density ] ) show that @xmath410 our analysis of the asymptotic behaviour of the ifs will crucially depend on the fact that the operators @xmath411 and @xmath412 respect this order relation on @xmath323 , as made precise in the next lemma : [ lemma : pre - monotonicity ] let @xmath368 and @xmath413 . a. [ item : pre - monotonicity - a ] if @xmath414 , then @xmath415 . b. [ item : pre - monotonicity - b ] if @xmath416 , then @xmath417 . c. [ item : pre - monotonicity - c ] if @xmath414 , then @xmath418 . let @xmath419 be bounded and non - decreasing and recall that @xmath420}\,d\mu.\end{gathered}\ ] ] [ item : pre - monotonicity - a ] ) let @xmath403 . in view of ( [ eq : mono - fact-1 ] ) we can prove @xmath421 by showing that the integrand on the right - hand side of is non - decreasing . for this we use the facts that @xmath298 and @xmath299 are strictly increasing with @xmath422 , and that @xmath423 is non - increasing , since @xmath424 . one gets then , for @xmath425 , @xmath426.}_{{\geqslant}0 } \end{split}\ ] ] hence @xmath403 implies @xmath427 . now , if @xmath319 is strictly increasing , then ( [ eq : monotonicity - estimate ] ) always is a strict inequality , i.e. the integrand on the right - hand side of is strictly increasing . therefore , @xmath414 implies @xmath428 by ( [ eq : mono - fact-2a ] ) . + [ item : pre - monotonicity - b ] ) we must show that is non - decreasing as a function of @xmath302 . to this end note first that @xmath429 hence , if @xmath430 , then @xmath431 and for strictly increasing @xmath319 we have indeed a strict inequality . + [ item : pre - monotonicity - c ] ) this follows from [ item : pre - monotonicity - a ] ) and [ item : pre - monotonicity - b ] ) : @xmath432 as @xmath433 by . in [ subsec : stablemfd ] below , we will also make use of a more precise quantitative version of statement a ) . it is natural to state and prove it at this point . [ lemma : gap - estimate ] suppose that @xmath434 are such that @xmath435 and @xmath436 . then , for @xmath403 , @xmath437 observing that @xmath438 and @xmath439 are @xmath440 , we find for the last expression in that @xmath441 { \geqslant}\alpha \beta y - \alpha \beta x.\ ] ] this turns into a chain of inequalities which shows that the function given by @xmath442 is non - decreasing . hence , by , @xmath403 entails @xmath443 , which is . we are now going to clarify the asymptotic behaviour of @xmath342 on @xmath323 . in view of ( [ eq : norm_w_estimate ] ) , this also determines the asymptotics of @xmath101 on @xmath341 , and hence proves proposition [ prop : summary ] . our argument depends on monotonicity properties which we can exploit since the topology of weak convergence on @xmath323 , conveniently given by the wasserstein metric , is consistent with the order relation introduced above . indeed , one easily checks : @xmath444{0.88\linewidth}if $ ( \nu_n)$ and $ ( \bar{\nu}_n)$ are weakly convergent sequences in $ \mathsf{p}(y)$ with $ \nu_n \preceq \bar{\nu}_n$ for all $ n$ , then $ \lim \nu_n \preceq \lim \bar{\nu}_n$.\end{minipage } } } } \ ] ] recall from [ subsec : infinite - sys ] that , in the bistable regime , @xmath393 is the unique positive fixed point of the equation @xmath394 . for convenience , we now let @xmath445 then , in either case , @xmath51 with representing measure @xmath409 is fixed by @xmath101 iff @xmath446 . by ( [ eq : mono - mu - r - family ] ) we have @xmath447 with strict inequalities in the bistable regime . [ lemma : monotonicity ] if @xmath448 , then @xmath449 , and the sequence @xmath345 converges weakly to a measure @xmath450 with @xmath446 . the same holds for @xmath399 instead of @xmath401 . the monotonicity of the sequence @xmath345 follows immediately from lemma [ lemma : pre - monotonicity][item : pre - monotonicity - c ] ) . because of ( [ eq : mono - cty - fact-1 ] ) , it implies that the sequence can have at most one weak accumulation point . compactness of @xmath323 and continuity of @xmath342 therefore ensure that @xmath345 converges to a fixed point of @xmath342 , i.e. to one of the measures @xmath409 with @xmath451 , and ( [ eq : mono - cty - fact-1 ] ) entails @xmath452 . the proof for decreasing sequences is the same . the following lemma strengthens the previous one considerably . it provides uniform control , in terms of the wasserstein distance , on the asymptotics of large families of representing measures . [ lemma : controlled - convergence ] we have the following : a. [ item : controlled - convergence - a ] in the stable regime , there exists a sequence @xmath453 of positive real numbers converging to zero such that @xmath454 b. [ item : controlled - convergence - b ] in the bistable regime , for every @xmath455 there exists a sequence @xmath453 of positive real numbers converging to zero such that @xmath456 an analogous assertion holds for measures @xmath457 . as @xmath458 $ ] , we trivially have @xmath459 for all @xmath460 . in particular , @xmath461 , and lemma [ lemma : monotonicity ] ensures that @xmath462 converges . due to lemma [ lemma : pre - monotonicity][item : pre - monotonicity - c ] ) , we have @xmath463 for all @xmath111 , showing , via ( [ eq : mono - cty - fact-1 ] ) , that @xmath464 . in the same way one proves that @xmath465 converges to @xmath357 . for the stable regime this means that both sequences converge to @xmath466 . + [ item : controlled - convergence - a ] ) assume we are in the stable regime . by the above discussion , @xmath467 tends to zero . for any @xmath13 , ( [ eq : mono - cty - fact-1 ] ) guarantees @xmath468 for all @xmath111 . hence @xmath469 for all @xmath316 , proving @xmath470 . + [ item : controlled - convergence - b ] ) now consider the bistable regime . note first that if there is a suitable sequence @xmath453 for some @xmath455 , then it also works for all @xmath471 . therefore , there is no loss of generality if we assume that @xmath455 is so small that @xmath472 ( use , and to see that this can be achieved . ) since @xmath473 and @xmath474 , we then have @xmath475 , recall lemma [ lemma : pre - monotonicity ] . lemma [ lemma : monotonicity ] then implies that @xmath476 converges to @xmath347 . in view of the initial discussion , @xmath462 converges to @xmath347 as well , so that @xmath477 defines a sequence of reals converging to zero . now take any @xmath317 with @xmath478 , then @xmath479 for all @xmath111 , and @xmath480 follows as in the proof of [ item : controlled - convergence - a ] ) above . this observation enables us to determine the asymptotics of @xmath481 for any @xmath460 which is completely supported on the positive half @xmath482 $ ] of @xmath306 ( meaning that @xmath483 , cf . ( [ eq : mono - fact-3 ] ) ) , or on its negative half @xmath484 . [ coro : monotone - convergence ] let @xmath317 . a. [ item : monotone - convergence - a ] in the stable regime , the sequence @xmath345 converges to @xmath353 . b. [ item : monotone - convergence - b ] in the bistable regime , if @xmath483 , then the sequence @xmath345 converges to @xmath347 . if @xmath485 , it converges to @xmath357 . [ item : monotone - convergence - a ] ) follows immediately from lemma [ lemma : controlled - convergence][item : controlled - convergence - a ] ) . we turn to [ item : monotone - convergence - b ] ) : let @xmath486 . then @xmath59 because @xmath487 on @xmath482 $ ] and @xmath483 . therefore @xmath488 . fix some @xmath489 as in lemma [ lemma : controlled - convergence][item : controlled - convergence - b ] ) , w.l.o.g . @xmath490 . then @xmath491 since @xmath284 and @xmath285 map @xmath492 into @xmath493 $ ] , so that indeed @xmath494 as @xmath495 by the lemma . it remains to investigate the convergence of sequences @xmath345 when none of these measures can be compared ( in the sense of @xmath398 ) to @xmath353 . to this end let @xmath496:=y$ ] . given a sequence of parameters @xmath497 define @xmath498 for @xmath499 , and , for any @xmath500 $ ] , consider the measures @xmath501 then @xmath502 @xmath503 ) \cup \tau_{r_{n } } ( [ a_{n-1},b_{n-1 } ] ) \subseteq$ ] @xmath504 $ ] by induction . write @xmath505_{\varepsilon}:=[a-\varepsilon , b+\varepsilon]$ ] , where @xmath506 . the next lemma exploits the crucial observation that the two branches @xmath298 and @xmath299 have tangential contact at their common zero @xmath507 , see figure [ fig : sigma - tau ] . [ lemma : crucial ] there exists some @xmath508 such that the following holds : suppose that @xmath509 is any given sequence in @xmath510 . if for some @xmath206 and @xmath511 we have @xmath512_{\varepsilon}\quad \text{for}\ n{\geqslant}\bar{n}(\varepsilon)\text{,}\tag{${\clubsuit}_\varepsilon$}\ ] ] then @xmath513 @xmath514 and , in case @xmath515 , @xmath516\quad \text{for}\ n{\geqslant}\bar{n}(0)+1 \text{.}\ ] ] let @xmath206 and assume ( @xmath517 ) . note that , for @xmath518 , @xmath519 the first implication holds because @xmath520 as @xmath521 increases strictly , and since by ( @xmath517 ) we have @xmath522 $ ] , whence @xmath523 due to ( [ eq : less3/4 ] ) . analogously for the second implication . the third is immediate from monotonicity . now , as @xmath284 and @xmath285 share a common zero @xmath507 , ( [ eq : less3/4 ] ) ensures @xmath524 in case @xmath525 $ ] . otherwise , note that @xmath507 is @xmath526-close to one of the endpoints , w.l.o.g . to @xmath527 . since @xmath284 and @xmath285 are tangent at @xmath528 , there is some @xmath529 s.t . @xmath530 in this case , while ( [ eq : less3/4 ] ) controls the rest of @xmath531 . in view of @xmath532 , we thus obtain , for @xmath533 , @xmath534 statement ( [ eq : club-1 ] ) follows immediately . for the asymptotic estimate ( [ eq : club-2 ] ) on @xmath535 , use the above inequality plus the observation that , by the first two implications stated in this proof , @xmath536 and @xmath537 never exceed @xmath538 . finally , if @xmath515 , ( [ eq : club-3 ] ) is straightforward from ( @xmath517 ) and the third implication above . while the full strength of this lemma will only be required in the next subsection , the @xmath515 case enables us to now conclude the the conclusions of ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) follow from corollary [ coro : monotone - convergence ] . if neither of these two cases applies , then the assumption of ( 2 ) must be satisfied , and so condition ( @xmath539 ) of lemma [ lemma : crucial ] is satisfied with @xmath540 . hence @xmath541 by ( [ eq : club-2 ] ) . as the @xmath481 are supported in @xmath542 $ ] , these measures must converge to @xmath353 . we are now going to clarify the asymptotics of the self - consistent pfo on the set @xmath104 of all densities , proving [ * long - term behaviour of * @xmath101 * * on * * @xmath104 ] [ prop : summary2 ] for every @xmath64 , the sequence @xmath543 converges in @xmath11 , and @xmath544 the basins @xmath545 of the stable fixed points @xmath20 are @xmath151-open . ( the set of densities attracted to @xmath17 in the bistable regime will be discussed in [ subsec : stablemfd ] below . ) + we begin with some notational preparations . throughout , we fix some @xmath288 . the iterates @xmath354 define parameters @xmath546 ( @xmath499 ) . with this notation , @xmath547 . we let @xmath548 , @xmath549 , denote the partition of @xmath58 into monotonicity intervals of @xmath550 . note that each branch of this map is a fractional linear bijection from a member of @xmath548 onto @xmath58 . since the @xmath55 , @xmath385 , have a common uniform expansion rate , we see that @xmath551 , and hence , by the standard martingale convergence theorem , @xmath552\rightarrow u$ ] in @xmath350 , that is , @xmath553-u\right\| _ { l_{1}({x},\lambda)}\longrightarrow0\quad \text { as } n\rightarrow\infty\text{.}\ ] ] write @xmath554\right)\quad \text{for}\ { k}{\geqslant}0\ \text{and}\ n{\geqslant}1 , \ ] ] and observe that @xmath555 because it is a weighted sum of images of the constant function @xmath24 under various fractional linear branches ( recall ( [ eq : transfer - by - fract - lin ] ) and ( [ eq_invariance_of_y ] ) ) . for @xmath556 we let @xmath557 and write , in analogy to the notation introduced for @xmath549 , @xmath558 and @xmath559 . obviously , @xmath560 for all @xmath561 . hence there are measures @xmath562 such that @xmath563 . observe also that @xmath564 as @xmath565 for all @xmath302 , so that in particular @xmath566 in addition , we need to understand the distances @xmath567 which , in fact , admit some control which is uniform in @xmath568 : [ lemma : shadow - estimate ] there is a non - decreasing sequence @xmath569 in @xmath570 , not depending on @xmath571 , such that @xmath572 let @xmath573 , and observe that entails @xmath574 applying lemma [ lemma : stability ] repeatedly , we therefore see that @xmath575 where the last inequality uses . ( recall that @xmath101 does not contract on @xmath576 , whence the need for the @xmath577-term . ) letting @xmath578 and @xmath579 , we thus obtain @xmath580 which proves our assertion . we can now complete the we begin with the easiest situation : + [ [ the - stable - regime ] ] * the stable regime * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we have to show that @xmath581 . take any @xmath582 . let @xmath453 be the sequence provided by lemma [ lemma : controlled - convergence][item : controlled - convergence - a ] ) , and @xmath217 the constant from ( [ eq : norm_w_estimate ] ) . there is some @xmath583 ( henceforth fixed ) for which @xmath584 . in view of ( [ eq : eta - n - cge-0 ] ) , there is some @xmath585 such that @xmath586 whenever @xmath587 . we then find , using ( [ eq : shadow - estimate ] ) , lemma [ lemma : shadow - estimate ] , and ( [ eq : norm_w_estimate ] ) together with lemma [ lemma : controlled - convergence][item : controlled - convergence - a ] ) that @xmath588 which completes the proof in this case . + [ [ the - bistable - regime ] ] * the bistable regime * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + given the sequence @xmath589 as before , we let @xmath542\subseteq y$ ] be the sequence of parameter intervals from lemma [ lemma : crucial ] . observe that the measures representing the @xmath590 satisfy @xmath591 $ ] for all @xmath583 and @xmath0 . we now distinguish two cases : + _ first case : _ for all @xmath211 we have ( @xmath592 ) from lemma [ lemma : crucial ] . then , for any @xmath211 , the lemma ensures that there is some @xmath583 ( henceforth fixed ) with @xmath593 , so that also @xmath594 , whatever @xmath0 . due to ( [ eq : eta - n - cge-0 ] ) , @xmath595 for @xmath587 , and we find , using ( [ eq : shadow - estimate ] ) and ( [ eq : norm_w_estimate ] ) , @xmath596 showing that indeed @xmath597 . + _ second case : _ there is some @xmath598 s.t . ( @xmath599 ) is violated in that , say , @xmath600 for infinitely many @xmath583 . we show that this implies @xmath601 . ( if ( @xmath599 ) is violated in the other direction , @xmath602 then follows by symmetry . ) + in view of ( [ eq : no - good - name ] ) , and since ( due to @xmath603 , ( [ eq : mono - fact-1 ] ) , and ( [ eq_mean_for_convex_combi ] ) ) @xmath604 , we have @xmath605 and hence , observing that @xmath606 and writing @xmath607 for @xmath313 , @xmath608 for all @xmath0 and @xmath568 . note that @xmath609 , see and . therefore , if we fix some @xmath610 , there exists some @xmath611 such that @xmath612 for all @xmath613}$ ] . without loss of generality , @xmath614 . + now fix @xmath0 such that @xmath615 , and let @xmath616 satisfy ( [ eq : exceptional : n ] ) . due to , we have @xmath617 now , if @xmath618 , then , by ( [ eq : sigma - tilde ] ) , @xmath619 otherwise , @xmath620 , and again @xmath621 it follows inductively that @xmath622 . more precisely : if @xmath623 and @xmath624 are integers such that @xmath625 and @xmath626 , then @xmath627 in particular , if the initial density @xmath319 is such that @xmath628 , then we can take @xmath629 . + next , fix @xmath630 , and choose a sequence @xmath453 according to lemma [ lemma : controlled - convergence][item : controlled - convergence - b ] ) . then @xmath631 and hence @xmath632 for @xmath633 so that the lemma implies @xmath634 . hence , by ( [ eq : norm_w_estimate ] ) , @xmath635 we then find , using ( [ eq : shadow - estimate ] ) and lemma [ lemma : shadow - estimate ] , @xmath636 for @xmath633 and all @xmath637 . now @xmath638 follows as in the stable case . + it remains to prove that the basin of attraction of @xmath349 is @xmath151-open . ( then , by symmetry , the same is true for @xmath358 . ) as @xmath10 is @xmath151-continuous , it suffices to show that this basin contains an open @xmath151-ball centered at @xmath349 . to check the latter condition , first notice that @xmath639 so that there is some @xmath640 such that @xmath641 . as we can assume w.l.o.g . that @xmath642 , we have @xmath643 , and as @xmath10 is @xmath151-continuous , there is some @xmath644 such that @xmath645 whenever @xmath646 . therefore we can continue to argue as in the previous paragraph ( using the present @xmath624 and @xmath629 ) to conclude that @xmath647 . we just proved a bit more than what is claimed in proposition [ prop : summary2 ] : another look at equation reveals that , in the bistable regime , the stable fixed point @xmath349 of @xmath10 is even lyapunov - stable ( and the same is true for @xmath358 ) . indeed , fix @xmath648 , @xmath649 and @xmath650 as in the preceding paragraph . that choice was completely independent of the particular initial densities investigated there , and the same is true of the choice of the constants @xmath217 , @xmath651 and @xmath652 occuring in estimate . now let @xmath220 . choose @xmath653 such that @xmath654 and then @xmath655 . then equation , applied with @xmath556 , shows that for each @xmath656 with @xmath657 and for each @xmath111 holds @xmath658 let @xmath659 denote the _ stable manifold _ of @xmath17 in the space of _ all _ probability densities on @xmath58 . clearly , all symmetric densities @xmath319 ( i.e. those satisfying @xmath660 ) belong to @xmath661 , because symmetric densities have field @xmath662 so that also the parameter @xmath663 , and symmetry is preserved under the operator @xmath664 . + however , @xmath661 is not a big set . in the present section we prove [ prop : basin - boundary ] each density in @xmath665 belongs to the boundaries of the basins of @xmath349 and of @xmath358 . we start by providing more information on the fields @xmath666 of orbits in @xmath665 . recall that for @xmath667 we have @xmath668 @xmath669 . given such a density , we denote by @xmath670 the `` radius '' of the support of @xmath481 , i.e. @xmath671\}$ ] , and let @xmath672 . [ lemma : roland ] in the bistable regime , for each @xmath673 there exists a constant @xmath674 such that @xmath675 in view of the explicit formula , we have @xmath676 and @xmath677 , and therefore see that there is some @xmath678 such that for every @xmath679 and all @xmath680 $ ] , @xmath681 where @xmath682 and @xmath683 , too , is a positive constant which only depends on the function @xmath69 . in addition , elementary calculations based on and show that letting @xmath684 , @xmath685 can be chosen such that , for every @xmath679 and @xmath686 , also @xmath687\text { , and}\\ 0>\tau_{r}(y ) & { \geqslant}\sigma_{r}(y){\geqslant}\left ( \frac{1}{2}+\varepsilon\right ) ( y+r)>- b \varepsilon\text { \quad for } y\in[-\varepsilon ,- r)\text{. } \end{split } \label{eq_estimate_tau_sigma_near_zero}\ ] ] ( recall that @xmath284 and @xmath285 share a zero at @xmath688 . ) finally , note that we can w.l.o.g . take @xmath685 so small that @xmath689 $ ] . ( due to assumption i we have @xmath690 . ) + consider some @xmath691 with @xmath692 . we claim that for @xmath693 @xmath694.\ ] ] denote @xmath695 which by s - shapedness of @xmath69 satisfies @xmath696 . in view of our system s symmetry , we may assume w.l.o.g . that @xmath697 . according to ( [ eq_mean_for_convex_combi ] ) and ( [ eq_p_tilda_acting_on_representing_measures ] ) we have @xmath698 so that , due to ( [ eq_estimate_f_near_zero ] ) and ( [ eq_estimate_tau_sigma_near_zero ] ) , @xmath699}\circ\sigma_{r}(y)}{6}\right ) \cdot \sigma_r(y)\,p_{r}(y)\,d\nu(y)\\ & { \geqslant}\int_{{y}}\left ( \frac{1_{[-\frac23,-r)}(y)}{6 - 6\varepsilon^2}\left ( \frac{1}{2 } + \varepsilon\right)+\frac{1_{[-r,\frac23]}(y)}{6}\left ( \frac{1}{2 } -\kappa\varepsilon\right)\right)\cdot ( y+r ) \,p_{r}(y)\,d\nu(y)\text{. } \end{aligned}\ ] ] combining this with the parallel estimate for @xmath700 , we get @xmath701}\frac{\left ( \frac{1}{2}-\kappa\varepsilon\right ) ( y+r)}{6}\,d\nu(y).\ ] ] continuing , we find that @xmath702}\frac{\frac{1}{2}-\kappa\varepsilon}{6}\cdot y\,d\nu(y)+\frac{\frac{1}{2}-\kappa\varepsilon}{6}\,\cdot r\\ & { \geqslant}\int_{[-\frac{2}{3},0)}\frac{\frac{1}{2}+\varepsilon}{6 - 6\varepsilon^2}\cdot y\,d\nu(y)+\int_{[0,\frac{2}{3}]}\frac{\frac{1}{2}-\kappa\varepsilon}{6}\cdot y\,d\nu(y)+\frac{\frac{1}{2}-\kappa\varepsilon}{6}\,\cdot r\\ & { \geqslant}\int_{[-\frac{2}{3},0)}k\cdot\overline{w}(y)\,d\nu(y ) + \int_{[0,\frac{2}{3}]}k^*\cdot\overline{w}(y)\,d\nu(y ) + \frac{\frac{1}{2 } -\kappa\varepsilon}{6}\,\cdot r\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath703 . as , because of ( [ eq_estimate_f_near_zero ] ) , @xmath704 , so that @xmath705 , we conclude @xmath706 since @xmath707 and @xmath708 whenever @xmath709 . this proves . + now take any @xmath673 . then @xmath710 , and the second alternative of proposition [ prop : summary ] applies , so that @xmath711 and @xmath712 for all @xmath583 larger than some @xmath713 . in particular , @xmath714 for these @xmath583 in view of . applying , for @xmath715 , the estimate to @xmath716 and @xmath717 , we obtain @xmath718 suppose for a contradiction that @xmath719 for some @xmath720 . then @xmath721 , and therefore @xmath722 . we can thus continue inductively to see that @xmath723 which contradicts @xmath710 . therefore @xmath724 for all @xmath720 , and the assertion of our lemma follows . [ lemma : stable - alternative ] in the bistable regime , if @xmath725 and @xmath691 are densities in @xmath726 with @xmath414 , then at most one of @xmath319 and @xmath727 can belong to @xmath661 . suppose that @xmath728 . we are going to show that @xmath729 , i.e. @xmath730 as @xmath495 . assume for a contradiction that also @xmath731 . we denote the parameters obtained from @xmath319 by @xmath732 , and define @xmath733 analogously . then our assumption implies that @xmath734 . in view of , @xmath735 , and one checks immediately that @xmath736 so that there is @xmath737 such that @xmath738 for all @xmath739 . because of the strict monotonicity of @xmath342 ( lemma [ lemma : pre - monotonicity ] ) we have @xmath740 , so that ( replacing @xmath13 and @xmath365 by these iterates ) we can assume w.l.o.g . that @xmath741 . denote @xmath742 so that @xmath743 and ( @xmath744 being non - decreasing ) @xmath745 for @xmath746 . therefore @xmath747 in view of the lower bounds for @xmath748 and @xmath749 , repeated application of the estimate from lemma [ lemma : gap - estimate ] yields @xmath750 observe that the last integral is strictly positive because @xmath414 , cf . . on the other hand , due to proposition [ prop : summary ] there are @xmath751 such that @xmath752 , \ ] ] and as @xmath753 and @xmath754 ( whence also @xmath755 ) , there exists a constant @xmath529 such that @xmath756 for @xmath757 . hence @xmath758 for @xmath757 by lemma [ lemma : roland ] , and as @xmath759 , this contradicts the previous estimate . we can now conclude this section with the suppose that @xmath760 . for @xmath761 let @xmath762 . then @xmath763 , hence @xmath764 by the previous proposition . therefore , due to proposition [ prop : summary ] and monotonicity of @xmath765 , for any @xmath766 , @xmath767 converges to @xmath768 as @xmath495 . on the other hand , @xmath769 , so @xmath319 is in the boundary of the basin of @xmath349 . replacing @xmath770 by @xmath771 yields the corresponding result for the basin of @xmath358 . as @xmath10 is based on a parametrised family of pfos where the _ branches _ of the underlying map ( and not only their weights ) depend on the parameter , it is nowhere differentiable , neither as an operator on @xmath11 nor as an operator on the space @xmath772 of ( much more regular ) functions of bounded variation on @xmath58 . on the other hand , as the branches of the map and their parametric dependence are analytic , one can show that @xmath10 is differentiable as an operator on the space of functions that can be extended holomorphically to some complex neighbourhood of @xmath773 . here we will focus on a more general but slightly weaker differentiability statement . [ lemma : differentiability ] let @xmath774 be a probability density w.r.t . @xmath12 and let @xmath775 have @xmath776 . then @xmath777 where @xmath778 , @xmath779 , and @xmath780 . if we consider @xmath10 as an operator from @xmath772 to @xmath11 , then @xmath10 is even differentiable at each probability density @xmath781 and @xmath782 in order to simplify the notation define a kind of transfer operator @xmath783 by @xmath784 and note that @xmath785 . observing that @xmath786 , we have @xmath787 . define @xmath788 for a function @xmath774 denote by @xmath789 the antiderivative of @xmath319 . then @xmath790 where @xmath791 as @xmath792 , we have @xmath793 together with this yields @xmath794 and @xmath795 with a constant that involves only the first two derivatives of @xmath319 . now let @xmath774 be a probability density , and let @xmath775 be such that @xmath796 . let @xmath797 and @xmath798 . then @xmath799 this implies at once formula for the directional derivative , and as @xmath800 ( @xmath801 ) uniformly for @xmath802 in the unit ball of @xmath772 , also follows at once . [ prop : hyperbolic - fixed ] in the bistable regime , @xmath803 is a hyperbolic fixed point of @xmath804 in the following sense : the derivative of @xmath805 at @xmath803 has a one - dimensional unstable subspace and a codimension @xmath24 stable subspace . let @xmath806 . as @xmath807 and @xmath808=[x]$ ] , it follows from that @xmath809\otimes\phi$ ] . ( here @xmath810 $ ] denotes the function @xmath811 , etc . ) observe now that @xmath812)=\frac1{12}$ ] . then @xmath813=p_0[x]+\frac b{12}\,[x]=(\frac12+\frac b{12})[x]$ ] so that , for @xmath814 , @xmath63 has the unstable eigendirection @xmath815 $ ] with eigenvalue @xmath816 . on the other hand , as @xmath817 , we have @xmath818 , so the constant density @xmath24 is a neutral eigendirection , and finally , for @xmath819 , we have @xmath820 , so @xmath821 . in theorem [ theo : passage - to - infinity ] we proved that , in the bistable regime , each weak accumulation point of the sequence @xmath166@xmath13@xmath167 is of the form @xmath172 for some @xmath173 $ ] , i.e. that the stationary states of the finite - size systems approach a mixture of the stationary states of the infinite - size system . it is natural to expect that actually @xmath175 , meaning that any limit state thus obtained is a mixture of _ stable _ stationary states of @xmath10 . while we could not prove this for the model discussed so far , we now argue that this conjecture can be verified if we add some noise to the systems . at each step of the dynamics we perturb the parameter of the single - site maps by a small amount . to make this idea more precise , let @xmath822 let @xmath823 be i.i.d . symmetric real valued random variables with common distribution @xmath824 and @xmath825 . for @xmath826 and @xmath197 let us define the @xmath184-valued markov process @xmath827 by @xmath828 and @xmath829 assume now that the distribution of @xmath830 has density @xmath831 w.r.t . lebesgue measure on @xmath184 . then routine calculations show that the distribution of @xmath832 has density @xmath833 where @xmath834 is the pfo of the map @xmath835 , @xmath836 . it is straightforward to check that , for sufficiently small @xmath526 , lemmas [ lemma : homeo ] [ lemma : inv - contraction ] from section [ sec : finite - sys - proofs ] carry over to all @xmath837 ( @xmath838 ) with uniform bounds , and that @xmath839 so that the perturbation theorem of @xcite guarantees that the process @xmath827 has a unique stationary probability @xmath13@xmath840 whose density w.r.t . @xmath841 tends , in @xmath842 , to the unique invariant density of @xmath90 as @xmath843 . this convergence is not uniform in @xmath0 , however . nevertheless , folklore arguments show that there is some @xmath844 such that , for all @xmath845 and all @xmath196 the absolutely continuous stationary measure @xmath13@xmath840 is unique so that the symmetry properties of the maps @xmath55 and the random variables @xmath846 guarantee that @xmath13@xmath840 is symmetric in the sense that its density @xmath847 satisfies @xmath848 . on the other hand , for each fixed @xmath211 , all weak limit points of the measures @xmath13@xmath849 as @xmath15 are stationary probabilities for the @xmath850-valued markov process @xmath851 defined by @xmath852 compare the definition of @xmath93 in . the proof is completely analogous to the corresponding one for the unperturbed case ( see lemma [ le : contttil ] and corollary [ coro : contttil ] ) . for @xmath845 the symmetry of the @xmath13@xmath840 carries over to these limit measures @xmath63 in the sense that @xmath853 for each borel measurable set @xmath854 where @xmath855 for all borel subsets @xmath856 . the following proposition then shows that , in the bistable regime and for small @xmath211 and large @xmath0 , the measures @xmath13@xmath840 are weakly close to the mixture @xmath857 of the stable states for @xmath10 ; compare also theorem [ theo : passage - to - infinity ] . suppose @xmath858 so that we are in the bistable regime and recall that the @xmath846 are symmetric random variables . then , for every @xmath220 there is @xmath859 such that for each @xmath860 the stationary distribution @xmath861 of @xmath862 on @xmath863 is supported on the set of measures @xmath864 which have density @xmath865 with representing measures @xmath866 satisfying @xmath867 . let @xmath63 be a stationary distribution of @xmath868 that occurs as a weak limit of the measures @xmath13@xmath840 . so @xmath63 is symmetric . just as in the proof of theorem [ theo : passage - to - infinity ] , where the `` zero noise limit '' , namely the transformation @xmath95 is treated , one argues that @xmath63 is supported by the set of measures @xmath869 , @xmath870 . arguing as in the derivation of one shows that densities in the support of @xmath63 can be approximated in @xmath11 by densities from @xmath726 , and the stationarity of @xmath63 implies that @xmath63 is indeed supported by measures with densities from @xmath726 . therefore the process @xmath871 can be described by the transfer operator @xmath872 of an iterated function system on @xmath306 just as the self - consistent pfo @xmath177 is described by the operator @xmath873 in equation . the only difference is that in this case one first chooses the parameter @xmath302 randomly , @xmath874 and then the branch @xmath298 or @xmath299 with respective probabilities @xmath875 and @xmath876 . let @xmath877 be such that @xmath878 . suppose now that for some realisation of the process @xmath871 the numbers @xmath879 satisfy condition ( @xmath880 ) of lemma [ lemma : crucial ] for all @xmath211 . then it follows , as in the proof of proposition [ prop : summary ] , that @xmath881 and the measures @xmath868 converge weakly to @xmath12 so that also @xmath882 . as @xmath883 for infinitely many @xmath583 almost surely , both limit can not be zero at the same time , and we conclude that almost surely there is some @xmath211 such that ( @xmath884 ) is not satisfied . in particular , there are @xmath885 and @xmath886 such that ( @xmath887 ) is violated for @xmath888 with some positive probability @xmath889 . let @xmath890 with @xmath891 . ( so @xmath831 and @xmath892 are random objects . ) as in we conclude that @xmath893 or @xmath894 in this case . without loss of generality we assume that the latter happens with probability at least @xmath895 . next , as in we may choose @xmath896 so small that @xmath897 . hence , for reasons of continuity , there is @xmath898 such that also @xmath899 if @xmath900 . therefore , in view of the monotonicity of the operator @xmath901 , we can conclude that @xmath902 for all @xmath903 with probability at least @xmath895 . now fix @xmath220 . by lemma [ lemma : controlled - convergence][item : controlled - convergence - b ] there is some ( non - random ) @xmath649 such that @xmath904 for all @xmath905 with probability at least @xmath895 . but then , by continuity reasons again , there is @xmath906 such that @xmath907 for all @xmath903 with probability at least @xmath895 . the claim of the proposition follows now , because @xmath908 is a markov process and because the stationary distribution @xmath63 is symmetric . it suffices to prove the convergence for evaluations of any lipschitz continuous function @xmath909 defined on @xmath58 . let us denote @xmath910 ( resp . @xmath911 ) , and @xmath912 ( resp . @xmath913 ) the discontinuity point of @xmath914 ( resp . @xmath55 ) . recall that @xmath915 ( resp . @xmath916 ) . let us fix @xmath211 . @xmath63 being non - atomic , there exists @xmath220 such that the interval @xmath917 $ ] is of @xmath63-measure smaller that @xmath526 . the weak convergence of @xmath918 to @xmath63 implies that @xmath919 tends to @xmath683 , and that @xmath920 . let us choose @xmath921 such that for all @xmath739 , @xmath922 and @xmath923 . one then has @xmath924 since the application @xmath925 as a single discontinuity point , which is of zero @xmath63-measure , the first term converges to zero . the second one also goes to zero since it measures the dependence of @xmath55 on its parameter away from the discontinuity point ( one can make an explicit computation ) . we start with some observations on the function @xmath926 that are based on symbolic computations and on numerical evaluations . one finds @xmath927 from this numerical evidence ( see figure [ fig : plots-1 ] for a plot ) it is clear that , for @xmath928 $ ] , @xmath929 hence @xmath930 . as @xmath931 @xmath932 follows provided @xmath933 . therefore , assumption is fulfilled , if @xmath934 for @xmath935 , in which case @xmath936 and @xmath937 this can be checked numerically . ( observe that @xmath938 and distinguish the cases @xmath939 and @xmath814 . ) for an illustration see the rightmost plot of @xmath940 in figure [ fig : plots-1 ] . o. bandtlow , o. jenkinson , _ invariant measures for real analytic expanding maps _ , j. london math . * 75 * ( 2007 ) , 343 - 368 . t. chawanya , s. morita , _ on the bifurcation structure of the mean - field fluctuation in the globally coupled tent map systems _ , physica d * 116 * ( 1998 ) , 44 - 70 . g. chichilnisky , _ topology and invertible maps _ , adv . mathematics * 21 * ( 1998 ) , 113 - 123 . d.a . dawson , j. grtner , _ large deviations from the mckean - vlasov limit for weakly interacting diffusions _ , stochastics , * 20 * ( 1987 ) , 247 - 308 . r. de la llave , _ invariant manifolds associaed to invariant subspaces without invariant complements : a graph transform approach , _ mathematical physics electronic journal * 9 * ( 2003 ) , paper 3 . ( http://www.ma.utexas.edu/mpej/vol/9/3.ps ) r. dudley , real analysis and probability , cambridge univ . press ( 2002 ) . ershov , a.b . potapov , _ on mean field fluctuations in globally coupled maps _ , physica d * 86 * ( 1995 ) , 523 - 558 . e. jrvenp , _ an srb - measure for globally coupled analytic expanding circle maps , _ nonlinearity * 10 * ( 1997 ) , 1435 - 1469 . k. kaneko , _ globally coupled chaos violates the law of large numbers but not the central limit theorem _ , phys . letters * 65 * ( 1990 ) , 1391 - 1394 . k. kaneko , _ remarks on the mean field dynamics of networks of chaotic elements _ , physica d * 86 * ( 1995 ) , 158 - 170 . g. keller , _ stochastic stability in some chaotic dynamical systems _ , monatshefte math . * 94 * ( 1982 ) , 313 - 333 . g. keller , _ an ergodic theoretic approach to mean field coupled maps _ , progress in probability , vol . * 46 * ( 2000 ) , 183 - 208 . g. keller , _ mixing for finite systems of coupled tent maps _ . math . * 216 * ( 1997 ) , 315 - 321 . krantz , h.r . parks , a primer of real analytic functions , sec . ed . , birkhuser ( 1992 ) . k. krzyzewski , w. szlenk , _ on invariant measures for expanding differentiable mappings _ , stud . math . * 33 * ( 1969 ) , 83 - 92 . d.h . mayer , _ approach to equilibrium for locally expanding maps in @xmath945 _ , commun . * 95 * ( 1984 ) , 1 - 15 . n. nakagawa , t.s . komatsu , _ dominant collective motion in globally coupled tent maps _ , phys . e * 57 * ( 1998 ) 1570 . n. nakagawa , t.s . komatsu , _ confined chaotic behavior in collective motion for populations of globally coupled chaotic elements _ , phys . rev e * 59 * ( 1999 ) , 1675 - 1682 . c. ptzsche , s. siegmund , _ @xmath946-smoothness of invariant fiber bundles , _ topol . methods nonlinear anal . * 24 * ( 2004 ) , 107 - 145 . ( http://www.math.uni-frankfurt.de/ siegmund / preprints/03hpoesie.ps ) d. ruelle , _ zeta - functions for expanding maps and anosov flows _ , inventiones math . * 34 * ( 1976 ) , 231 - 242 . f. schweiger , _ invariant measures for piecewise fractional linear maps_. j. austral . a * 34 * ( 1983 ) , 55 - 59 . sznitman , alain - sol , _ topics in propagation of chaos . ecole dete de probabilites de saint - flour xix1989 _ , lecture notes in math . , * 1464 * , 165251,springer , berlin , 1991 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: broad emission lines ( bels ) are a defining property of quasar spectra . nearly 25 years ago baldwin ( 1977 ) discovered an anti - correlation between the equivalent width in iv civ@xmath6 , @xmath7(iv civ ) , and the continuum luminosity , @xmath8(1450 ) , measured at 1450 in the quasar rest - frame . this result was based on a sample of 20 quasars spanning @xmath9 orders of magnitude in continuum luminosity in the redshift range @xmath10 . it has become known as the `` baldwin effect '' ( hereafter beff ) . the beff was subsequently confirmed in iv civ@xmath6 , as well as other bels such as ly@xmath11 and ovi@xmath1 ( vron - cetty , vron , & tarenghi 1983 ; baldwin , wampler , & gaskell 1989 ; kinney , rivolo , & koratkar 1990 ; osmer , porter , & green 1994 ; zheng , kriss , & davidsen 1995 ; green , forster , & kuraszkiewicz 2001 ; see osmer & shields 1999 for a recent review ) . a major impetus for studying the beff was that it might be useful for calibrating active galactic nuclei ( agns ) luminosities , e.g. based on @xmath7(iv civ ) . the agns could then be used as cosmological standard candles . but in the following years studies of bigger quasar samples revealed a large scatter in the anti - correlation of the continuum luminosity vs. emission line strength ( baldwin , wampler , & gaskell 1989 ; zamorani et al.1992 ) . the beff is nonetheless important as a diagnostic of agn structure and , perhaps , metal abundances ( korista , baldwin , & ferland 1998 ) . the relation between the continuum luminosity and the relative emission line strengths and ratios can be used to study the evolution and physics of the quasar phenomenon ( baldwin 1999 ) . in particular , this correlation can be used to test model predictions for the dependence of the shape of the continuum spectral energy distribution as a function of luminosity ( binette et al.1989 ; netzer , laor , & gondhalekar 1992 ; zheng & malkan 1993 ; wandel 1999a , b ) . the most fundamental problem , however , is that the physical cause of the beff remains unknown . it was suggested by mushotzky & ferland ( 1984 ) that the observed relation can be explained by an anti - correlation of the ionization parameter , u , and the continuum luminosity , with @xmath12 , where q(h ) is the number of hydrogen ionizing photons emitted per second by the central continuum source , r is the distance between the continuum source and the emission line region , and @xmath13 is the hydrogen density in the line - emitting cloud . assuming an additional relation of decreasing covering factor with increasing continuum strength , the observed beff could be well described for iv civ@xmath6 . however , this model does not naturally explain the beff in the full range of measured lines . it predicts , for example , a lack of a beff for ly@xmath11 even though it is clearly detected ( e.g. , kinney , rivolo , & koratkar 1990 ; osmer , porter , & green 1994 ; laor et al.1995 ; green 1996 ) . another important clue to the physical cause of the beff is that the strength of the relationship ( i.e. , the slope of the @xmath14 @xmath15 anti - correlation ) seems to depend on the ionization energy of the emission - line species ( zheng et al.1995 ; espey & andreadis 1999 ) . in particular , the equivalent widths of high - ionization lines like ovi@xmath1 decrease more dramatically with @xmath15 than lines with moderate ionization energies like iv civ@xmath6 or low ionization energies like mgii@xmath16 and balmer emission lines . our results in the present paper confirm this claim , and improve upon the overall empirical characterization of the beff correlations . the beff might result from a more fundamental correlation between the continuum luminosity , @xmath15 , and the shape of the ionizing ( euv soft x - ray ) continuum ( binette et al.1989 ; zheng & malkan 1993 ; zheng et al.1997 ; korista et al.1998 ) . netzer ( 1985 , 1987 ) and netzer et al.(1992 ) suggested accretion disc models to explain the observed continuum and emission line correlations . recently , wandel ( 1999a , b ) added to this the growth in black hole mass by accretion in the accretion disc model . his analysis predicts that the continuum luminosity increases towards higher black hole mass and that the shape of the ionizing continuum becomes softer . hence , it is suggested that the beff is driven by a softening of the ionizing continuum towards higher luminosities . this model is attractive because the uv x - ray spectral softening has been well documented by observations ( tananbaum et al.1986 ; wilkes et al.1994 ; green et al.1995 ) , and because the spectral softening provides a natural explanation for steeper beff slopes in higher ionization lines . an additional possibility is that the beff is driven , at least in part , by a trend for higher metallicities in more luminous agns . korista et al.(1998 ) presented theoretical results showing the dependence of the emission line equivalent widths on both the continuum shape and the metallicity of the gas . their proposal is based on evidence for higher metal abundances in more luminous quasars ( hamann & ferland 1993 , 1999 ; dietrich et al . 1999 ; dietrich & wilhelm - erkens 2000 ) , and on the suggestion that more luminous quasars reside in more massive host galaxies , which will naturally be more metal rich ( cen & ostriker 1999 ; pettini 1999 ; kauffmann & haehnelt 2000 ; granato et al.2001 ; see hamann & ferland 1999 for a review ) . our combination of ground - based and satellite data also provides the opportunity to study evolutionary aspects of the line strengths in detail e.g. by measuring the same rest - frame uv lines across a wide range of redshifts . one serious complication affecting previous work is that luminosity and redshift are often correlated in quasars samples , because the quasars are selected from magnitude - limited surveys . most studies have supported the original claim by baldwin ( 1977 ) , that w@xmath17 scales inversely with luminosity and that there is no significant trend with redshift @xmath18 ( e.g. , kinney , rivolo , & koratkar 1990 ; osmer et al.1994 ; francis & koratkar 1995 ; wilkes et al.1999 ) . however , some recent work based on the large bright quasar survey ( lbqs ) claims that the relationship to redshift is even stronger than with luminosity ( forster et al.2001 ; green , forster , & kuraszkiewicz 2001 ) . the present paper is the first in a series in which we examine the emission - line properties in a large sample of @xmath19 type 1 agns . the sample includes seyfert1 galaxies and both radio - loud and radio - quiet quasars spanning an unprecedented wide range in both redshift ( @xmath20 ) and intrinsic luminosity ( @xmath21 orders of magnitude ) . the database and data processing will be described in detail in a future paper . a major concern regarding beff studies is that selection effects in agn samples , e.g. pertaining to emission - line strengths , might bias some measurements of the beff . our sample has the advantage of being drawn from a variety of surveys , with objects selected based on radio properties , grism spectroscopy , or broad - band color criteria . hence , no specific selection criteria were applied for the data . another key advantage is that our sample includes a wide range of luminosities at various redshifts . we can therefore address the separate redshift and luminosity dependences in the emission line data . there are several interesting problems we wish to address . the most basic issue is to quantify the nature of empirical correlations with @xmath15 and/or @xmath18 . in an upcoming study we will further examine correlations with other agn properties such as radio - loudness ( baldwin 1977 ; sargent , steidel , & boksenberg 1989 ; steidel & sargent 1991 ; francis & koratkar 1995 ) . we will also report on trends with @xmath15 or @xmath18 among various emission - line metallicity indicators . here we present an initial analysis on the nature of the beff . our approach is to construct composite spectra for specific @xmath15 and @xmath18 intervals , thus providing high signal - to - noise spectra and allowing us to study trends in both weak and strong emission lines . the agn sample is described briefly in 2 and the calculation and analysis of the composite spectra in 3 and 4 . the main results appear in several figures in 5 . we compare our results with prior studies and discuss them in the context of suggested models in 6 . throughout this paper we use the cosmological parameters h@xmath22 kms@xmath23mpc@xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 ( carroll , press , & turner 1992 ) . introducing @xmath26 ( netterfield et al.2002 ) instead of @xmath27 , the luminosities at the highest redshifts would be @xmath28% smaller , while at low redshifts they would reach a maximum of @xmath29% larger at redshift @xmath30 . we have compiled a large sample of rest - frame visible and ultraviolet spectra for @xmath31 type 1 agns . a majority of the spectra were obtained by several groups for different studies over the last 20 years using ground - based instruments as well as _ international ultraviolet explorer ( iue ) _ and _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ ( bahcall et al.1993 ; baldwin et al.1989 ; chaffee et al.1991 ; corbin & boroson 1996 ; kinney et al.1991 ; lanzetta , turnshek , & sandoval 1993 ; laor et al.1995 ; sargent et al.1988,1989 ; schneider , schmidt , & gunn 1991a , b ; steidel 1990 ; steidel & sargent 1991 ; steidel unpublished ; storrie - lombardi et al.1996 ; weymann et al.1991,1998 ; wills et al.1995 ; zheng et al.1997 ) . in total , the sample contains 351 quasar spectra measured with _ hst_. furthermore , we observed a large number of the quasars in our sample at redshifts @xmath32 ( constantin et al.2002 ; dietrich et al.1999 ; dietrich & wilhelm - erkens 2000 ; dietrich et al.2002a , b ) . for this study we exclude broad - absorption line quasars ( balqsos ) , although there are indications that their emission line properties do not differ from non - bal quasars ( weymann et al.1991 ) . we also excluded several quasar spectra with extremely poor signal - to - noise ratios . the sample we investigate consists of @xmath19 type 1 agns . because this agn sample was compiled from many independent projects , it encompasses a wide range of selection criteria . most of the quasars especially at high redshifts were discovered by color selection techniques ( e.g. , storrie - lombardi et al.1996 ) or found by objective prism surveys ( e.g. , chaffee et al.1991 ; sargent et al.1988,1989 ; schneider at al.1991a , b ) . we used the radio flux densities given in vron - cetty & vron ( 2001 ) to determine the radio loudness for the quasars . following kellermann et al.(1989 ) we calculated the parameter @xmath33 with @xmath34 as the radio flux density at @xmath35ghz and @xmath36 as the b - band flux , each in the rest frame . our classifications of radio - loud quasars are consistent with classifications available in the literature ( wills et al.1995 ; bischof & becker 1997 ; wilkes et al.1999 ; stern et al.2000 ) . in total our sample contains @xmath37 radio - loud quasars and @xmath38 radio - quiet agns . kinney et al.(1990 ) and pogge & peterson ( 1992 ) pointed out that a significant fraction of the scatter in the beff in seyfert1 galaxies is caused by variability . they found that observations obtained at multiple epochs for individual sources display a beff - like correlation ( the _ intrinsic _ beff ) , but with a significantly steeper slope than the beff observed for an ensemble of agns . the physical mechanisms which drive each effect might be different , i.e. , the ensemble beff might be due primarily to variations in black hole mass while the intrinsic beff might be caused by changes of the accretion rate @xmath39 ( green 1999 ) . for @xmath40 of the @xmath41 low luminosity agns ( log@xmath42 , for @xmath43 in ergs@xmath23 ) , the spectra are means from intense monitoring campaigns ( crenshaw et al.1996 ; collier et al.1998,2001 ; dietrich et al.1993 ; goad et al.1999 ; kaspi et al.1996 ; korista et al.1995 ; peterson et al.1994 ; reichert et al.1994 ; santos - lle et al.2001 ; stirpe et al.1994 ; wanders et al.1997 ) . at the high luminosity end of the luminosity distribution , it has been shown that quasars vary on longer timescales and with smaller amplitudes ( e.g. , kaspi et al.2000 ) . for these reasons , the scatter caused by intrinsic variability is not expected to strongly influence our analysis of the present large quasar sample , particularly when comparisons of composite spectra are employed . we transformed each quasar spectrum to the rest - frame using a redshift measured from iv civ@xmath6 . to determine the redshift we fit a gaussian profile to the upper part of the iv civ@xmath6 emission line having @xmath44% of the peak intensity . we corrected each spectrum for galactic extinction ( seaton 1979 ) , based on the neutral hydrogen column density @xmath45 expressed in units of @xmath46@xmath47 , assuming @xmath48 ( dickey & lockman 1990 ) . the redshift distribution of the quasar sample is presented in figure 1 as a function of continuum luminosity , @xmath49 . the quasars cover a redshift range of @xmath0 and nearly @xmath50 orders of magnitude in luminosity . for most of the redshift range a reasonable coverage in luminosity is achieved , spanning at least @xmath51 orders of magnitude for @xmath52 . the radio - loud and radio - quiet quasars are displayed with different symbols in figure 1 . their distributions across luminosity and redshift are very similar within out sample , although the fraction of radio - loud quasars increases for redshifts @xmath53 . a common approach to study the beff is to measure the emission line properties of individual quasars . however , the results are often limited especially for the weaker emission lines by the low signal - to - noise ratio of individual spectra . there can also be significant problems introduced by including upper limits on weak lines in individual spectra . to avoid those problems , we computed composite spectra in different intervals of redshift and luminosity . the analysis of these spectra has the advantage of more clearly representing the average properties of the sample used to calculate each composite . figure 1 indicates the ranges in luminosity and redshift used to compute the composites . except for the low and high luminosity ends of our sample , each composite spectrum is based on more than @xmath54 individual quasar spectra . the scatter introduced by different individual spectra is taken into account by calculating a root - mean - square ( standard deviation ) spectrum for each composite , and using that to estimate the uncertainties in the measured equivalent widths ( 4 ) . before combining the individual quasar spectra , we normalized the flux densities to unity in a @xmath54 wide continuum range centered at @xmath55 by multiplying each spectrum with a suitable factor . we used these normalized quasar spectra to calculate the mean and rms spectrum for each composite , and the number of spectra contributing in each wavelength bin . to avoid the influence of strong narrow absorption lines , we developed a search routine to detect strong narrow absorption features and exclude them from the calculation of the composite spectrum . to search for strong absorption lines we applied the following method ( a more detailed description will be given in a subsequent paper on the properties of the entire quasar sample , dietrich et al.2002c ) . first , a preliminary mean spectrum is calculated for the sample of spectra under study . we then divided each individual spectrum by this preliminary mean to derive a ratio spectrum . each ratio spectrum is smoothed with a running boxcar function , which provides in addition to the mean also an rms value for each wavelength box . the resulting rms spectrum indicates the scatter in flux for each wavelength element in the immediate spectral region . a narrow absorption line will cause a sharp increase in the rms spectrum . the contaminated spectral regions of individual spectra , identified by these rms spikes , are excluded from the calculation of the final composite spectrum , and no interpolation has been applied . multiple tests with different agns and different sample sizes show that this technique sucessfully removes strong narrow absorption lines from our composite spectra ( see below ) without affecting the emission lines . significant effects of narrow absorption lines remain only in the ly@xmath56 forest ( @xmath57 ) for composites that include quasars with redshift @xmath52 . the resulting composite quasar spectrum for the entire sample is shown in figure 2 . a single power law fit to the continuum at @xmath58 is also displayed ; it has a slope of @xmath59 ( @xmath60 ) . this spectral index is consistent with the slope reported for other composite spectra ( brotherton et al.2001 ; vandenberk et al.2001 ; telfer et al.2002 ) . the bottom panel of figure 2 shows the number of quasars contributing to each individual wavelength element . for every wavelength @xmath61 this composite quasar spectrum is based on at least @xmath62 quasars . to measure the emission line fluxes we analyzed each composite spectrum with spectral fitting software provided by midas . we employed a powerlaw continuum , an ultraviolet and optical fe - emission template , a balmer continuum emission template , and multiple gaussian profiles for the broad emission lines in multi - component fits using @xmath63 minimization . for the ultraviolet wavelength range we used the fe emission template which vestergaard & wilkes ( 2001 ) carefully derived from hst spectra of izw1 ( kindly provided by m.vestergaard ) . the primary aim was to measure the broad and prominent feii - emission near mgii@xmath16 . however , we also used the uv template to correct for feii and feiii emission blended with iii ciii]@xmath64 and other lines across the wavelength range @xmath65 . for the optical wavelength region around h@xmath66 and h@xmath67 , we used the empirical feii emission template obtained from izw1 ( kindly provided by t.boroson ; boroson & green 1992 ) . we adjusted the line widths in these fe emission templates to match the measured widths of iv civ@xmath6 , mgii@xmath16 , or h@xmath3 . we calculated several bound - free balmer continuum emission spectra for @xmath68k , @xmath69@xmath70 , and @xmath71 following the formalism suggested by grandi ( 1982 ) . these balmer continuum emission templates were supplemented for @xmath72 with high order balmer emission lines with @xmath73 , i.e. h@xmath74 and higher ( storey & hummer 1995 ) . the individual high - order balmer lines were represented by gaussian profiles and coadded . the multi - component fit of a balmer continuum , two fe - emission templates , and a power law continuum yields independent measurements of the ultraviolet and optical fe - emission strengths . furthermore , the spectral index , @xmath56 , of the power law continuum does not include contributions from balmer continuum or from broad fe emission . the uncertainties associated with the fit of balmer continuum emission and fe emission templates were estimated from the @xmath63 distribution for each fit ( cf . , dietrich et al.2002a ) . the emission line fluxes were measured after subtracting the power law continuum , balmer continuum , and fe emission spectra . the line fluxes were determined by multi - component gaussian fits . in general , we fit the emission lines with a `` broad '' and a `` narrow '' gaussian component . for iv civ@xmath6 , however , it was necessary to introduce in addition a very broad component ( which turned out to have typically fwhm @xmath75 kms@xmath23 ) . to determine the fluxes of ly@xmath11 and nv@xmath5 , which are severely blended , we used the components obtained from the iv civ@xmath6 profile as templates ( preserving their widths and redshifts ) . please see figure 2 in dietrich & hamann ( 2002d ) for examples of fitted profiles . note that most of the ly@xmath11 forest absorption on the blue side of the ly@xmath11 profile is corrected by the methode we applied to calculated the composite spectra . the ovi@xmath1 emission line is subject to severe corruption by ly@xmath11 forest absorption . however , in composite spectra it can be assumed that the same fraction of the ovi@xmath1 emission line flux and the adjacent continuum flux is absorbed by the ly@xmath11 forest . hence , the equivalent width is not expected to be significantly altered by ly@xmath11 forest absorption . the ovi@xmath1 emission line is also contaminated by ly@xmath66 emission in the blue wing , whose relative strength shows a wide range , ly@xmath66/ovi@xmath76 ( laor et al.1995 ) . our fits to the ovi@xmath1 emission line profiles were achieved with a broad and narrow gaussian profile , and no additional component due to ly@xmath66 emission was necessary . the iii ciii]@xmath64 emission line complex was reconstructed with four gaussian profiles , corresponding to aliii@xmath77 , siiii]@xmath78 , and broad and narrow gaussian profiles for iii ciii]@xmath64 . the correction for fe emission allows a better measurement of mgii@xmath16 , heii@xmath79 , niii]@xmath80 , and the iii ciii ] emission line complex ( aliii@xmath77 , siiii]@xmath78 , iii ciii]@xmath64 ) . the measurement of the optical feii emission with an appropriate scaled template made it possible to measure the heii@xmath81 emission line which is otherwise severely blended with feii(37,38 ) multiplets . the cumulative errors in the emission line flux measurements and @xmath14 were calculated as the square root of the sum of i ) the uncertainties in the @xmath63 fitting and ii ) the rms scatter that is introduced by both the noise and distribution of the individual spectra contributing to that particular composite spectrum , squared . to search for a dependence of emission line properties , particularly @xmath7 , on cosmic time ( redshift ) , we selected a narrow luminosity range . the location of this luminosity range was also selected to achieve a comparable number of individual quasars contributing to each redshift bin in the @xmath18 @xmath49 plane . to cover a redshift range as large as possible for an almost constant luminosity , we selected a luminosity range of @xmath82 ( i.e. , @xmath83 ) . this range contains @xmath84 quasars with @xmath85 and an average luminosity of log@xmath86 . we computed composite spectra for redshift bins with @xmath87 centered on redshift @xmath88 , respectively ( fig.1 ) . figures 3a and 3b show the composite spectra for each redshift bin . these composite spectra are normalized by the power law continuum which we derived from the multi - component fits in 4 . as a first impression the relative line strengths in the normalized composite quasar spectra stay nearly constant with redshift @xmath18 . however , some emission lines show a marginal trend for increasing equivalent width at the highest redshifts . to quantify this result , we measured the equivalent width of most emission lines in the ultraviolet wavelength range ( @xmath89 ) and of the broad ultraviolet feii - emission feature ( @xmath90 ) . the results for @xmath14 as a function of redshift are displayed in figures 4a and 4b . in general , the equivalent widths of the lines remain constant within @xmath91% . the stronger emission lines , however , like ly@xmath11 , iv civ@xmath6 , and iii ciii]@xmath64 , show marginal trends for a relation of @xmath14 and redshift . @xmath14 stays nearly constant within less than @xmath92% for redshifts less than @xmath93 , but then for @xmath94 there are marginal indications for a slight increase of @xmath14 at constant luminosity . close inspection of figures 4a and 4b indicates that in particular the equivalent widths measured for the composites with @xmath95 are larger compared to lower redshifts . most of the quasar spectra in our sample with @xmath95 were obtained by constantin et al.(2002 ) . they found evidence that in spite of strong contamination by ly@xmath11-forest absorption , ly@xmath11 is stronger for quasars with @xmath96 than in their low-@xmath18 counterparts . next we divided the quasar sample into eleven subsets with respect to the luminosity @xmath97 . except for the lowest luminosity bin , each composite spectrum covers a range of @xmath98 in luminosity starting at log@xmath99 ergs@xmath23 ( fig.1 ) . the two lowest luminosity composite spectra consist of less than 10 objects . figures 5a and 5b show the composite spectra ordered by luminosity for the ultraviolet wavelength range ( @xmath100 ) , while figure 6 shows the longer wavelengths ( @xmath101 ) . each composite spectrum is normalized by the power law continuum fit we derived from the multi - component analysis ( 3 ) . these normalized spectra show very obviously a strong relation between the equivalent width , @xmath14 , and the continuum luminosity represented by @xmath49 , i.e. the baldwin effect , for most of the emission lines . figures 7a and 7b show the measured values of @xmath14 for each luminosity interval . the beff can be seen easily in strong lines such as iv civ@xmath6 , ovi@xmath1 , ly@xmath11@xmath102 , iii ciii]@xmath64 , and mgii@xmath16 ( figures 5a and 6 ) . taking advantage of the high signal - to - noise ratio of the composite spectra , we also detected this relation for weaker emission lines such as heii@xmath79 . furthermore , emission lines of the same ion but at different wavelengths ( oiii]@xmath103 , [ oiii]@xmath2 and heii@xmath79 , heii@xmath104 ) possess nearly identical slopes ( tab.1 ) . for the first time , we report on the beff for niv]@xmath105 , oiii]@xmath103 , and niii]@xmath80 . in spite of the large scatter , the broad fe emission features in the ultraviolet show some indications of a beff , while within the errors , the optical feii emission lacks a beff . in addition to the broad emission lines , we detect the baldwin effect also for the prominent forbidden emission line [ oiii]@xmath2 ( figure 6 ) , which is regarded as a typical narrow - line region ( nlr ) emission line . in contrast to the strong beff in most of the emission lines visible in figures 5a , 5b , and 6 , the balmer lines h@xmath67 and h@xmath66 show only weak indications of a baldwin effect , which might be restricted to the line center of the line profiles . close inspection of the nv@xmath5 emission line ( figures 5a and 8) also indicates that this line does not exhibit a beff like other high ionization lines . lines having the same equivalent widths in each individual spectrum will cancel out in difference spectra ( provided that their profiles are also the same ) , while lines whose equivalent widths are a function of luminosity will still be present in difference spectra . note that nv@xmath5 has on average cancelled out in the difference spectra as shown in figure 8 . hence , the difference spectra near nv and the careful deblending of the ly@xmath11-nv@xmath5 emission line complex both reveal that nv@xmath5 remains nearly constant in @xmath14 over @xmath21 orders of magnitude in continuum luminosity . zheng , fang , & binette ( 1992 ) , espey et al.(1993 ) , and espey & andreadis ( 1999 ) have suggested that there is a correlation between the ionization energy , @xmath106 , of a specific emission line and the strength ( slope ) of the beff . in contrast to espey & andreadis ( 1999 ) , we use the ionization energy necessary to create the ion for collisionally excited lines like iv civ@xmath107 and mgii@xmath16 , and the ionization energy needed to ionize the ion for recombination lines like ly@xmath11 and heii . the beff slope of the lines under study shows a relatively close linear correlation with @xmath106 ( figures 7a , b ) . we determined the slope @xmath3 , where log@xmath108 , of the beff from a linear least square fit to log@xmath14 vs. log@xmath109 . the fits were calculated taking into account the full uncertainties in log@xmath14 . first , we calculated the slopes across the entire luminosity range , shown by the dotted line in figures 7a and 7b . however , several of the emission lines indicate that the slope of the beff is flatter at lower luminosities ( @xmath110 ) . therefore , we calculated additional linear fits for the luminosity range log@xmath111 ( dashed - dotted lines ) . it is interesting to note that the lines showing a change in the beff slope have high ionization energies with @xmath112ev . the slopes of the log@xmath14 vs. log@xmath109 relations are listed in table 1 and plotted against @xmath106 in figure 9 for the entire range ( filled symbols ) and for log@xmath111 ( open symbols ) . notice , that the slope of the beff becomes steeper for increasing @xmath113 . however , as has already been shown by earlier studies , nv@xmath5 deviates significantly from this trend ( espey & andreadis 1999 ) . nv@xmath5 stays constant or shows a slightly decreasing w@xmath17 towards higher luminosity . the slope @xmath3 for ovi@xmath1 is of particular interest for testing the hypothesis of a steeper beff towards higher ionization energies since @xmath114 is more than twice @xmath115 and nearly @xmath116 times @xmath117 . assuming a constant ratio of ly@xmath66/ovi@xmath118 does not significantly change the slope of the beff for ovi@xmath1 however , @xmath3(ovi@xmath1 ) would become steeper by nearly @xmath119%if ly@xmath66 follows the same beff as ly@xmath11 and ly@xmath66/ly@xmath11=@xmath120 ( laor et al.1995 ) . to quantify the relationship of the beff slopes @xmath3 to @xmath106 , we calculated linear least square fits to the points in figure 9 excluding the outlying data point for nv@xmath5 . the resulting slope , @xmath121 , is the same with ( @xmath122 ) or without ( @xmath123 ) the ovi@xmath1 line included . this result indicates that ovi@xmath1 does not dominate the @xmath3 versus @xmath106 relation . in general , the slopes of the baldwin effect derived here are consistent with prior investigations . however , the large range in both luminosity and redshift that distinguishes our quasar sample reveals correlations which were missed in some other studies . in particular , we can more clearly separate the trends with @xmath124 and @xmath18 , and our use of composite spectra across a wide luminosity range more accurately probes the beff slopes , e.g. , for weaker lines . in the following we provide some more detailed comparisons with earlier work . the slopes we derived for ly@xmath11@xmath102 , iv civ@xmath6 , iii ciii]@xmath64 , and mgii@xmath16 , are in good agreement with prior studies ( kinney et al.1990 ; osmer et al.1994 ; laor et al.1995 ; green 1996 ; turnshek 1997 ; zamorani et al.1992 ; zheng et al.1995 ; wang et al.1998 ; espey & andreadis 1999 ) . the steeper slopes for iv civ@xmath6 in osmer et al.(1994 ) , laor et al.(1995 ) , and green ( 1996 ) , @xmath125 compared to @xmath126 here , might be caused by the luminosity range of their quasar samples , @xmath127 ergs@xmath23 . using only the @xmath7(iv civ ) measurements for @xmath127 ergs@xmath23 in our sample , we calculate a slope of the baldwin effect of @xmath128 for iv civ@xmath6 ( tab.1 ) . a lack of the baldwin effect for iv civ@xmath6 and iii ciii]@xmath64 is reported by wilkes et al.(1999 ) . they conclude that this is caused by the narrow - line - seyfert1 galaxies ( nlsy1s ) in their sample which decrease the strength of the baldwin effect ; a significant beff is found for both iv civ and iii ciii ] if the nlsy1s galaxies in their sample are omitted . we note that these nlsy1s are also low luminosity agn . as can be seen in figures 5a and 5b , the baldwin relation is significantly flatter for low luminosities than at higher luminosities . any agn sample favoring a narrow luminosity range can dilute or bias the derived beff . similarly , the steeper beff slopes reported by laor et al.(1995 ) , for oi@xmath129 , cii@xmath130 , siiv@xmath131 , and heii@xmath79 can be attributed to their smaller luminosity range ( @xmath132 ergs@xmath23 ) . the slope for the baldwin effect for the high ionization emission line ovi@xmath1 ( @xmath133ev ) is also consistent with prior investigations . the reported slope @xmath66(ovi@xmath1 ) varies between @xmath134 ( zheng et al.1995 ; turnshek 1997 ) and @xmath135 ( laor et al.1995 ) , with most recent studies favoring a less steep anti - correlation ( @xmath136 ; espey & andreadis 1999 ) . wilkes et al.(1999 ) found only a marginal anti - correlation of @xmath137ovi@xmath138 and continuum luminosity . however , they noted that this result is based on just ten objects . green ( 1996 ) and green et al.(2001 ) did not detect a significant baldwin effect for ovi@xmath1 in their analysis of the large bright qso survey ( lbqs ) data set , taking all quasar spectra into account , i.e. including upper limit measurements as well . however , using only those spectra with detected ovi@xmath1 the baldwin effect is clearly present . a possible reason for the missing baldwin effect for ovi@xmath1 in their study might be the very narrow luminosity range ( @xmath139 ) covered by lbqs quasars at these wavelengths . a comparison of our figure 7a with figure 2 in green et al.(2001 ) shows that we measure the same range of ovi@xmath1 equivalent widths for this luminosity , @xmath140(ovi@xmath141 . hence , we conclude that the non - detection of the baldwin effect for this high - ionization line in green et al.(2001 ) is predominatly caused by their very small luminosity range . in contrast to wills et al.(1999 ) , we detect a significant baldwin effect for the prominent nlr emission line [ oiii]@xmath2 ( fig.7b ) . the slope @xmath3 of the anti - correlation is nearly identical to the one which we derived for oiii]@xmath103 ( tab.1 , fig.9 ) . again , the lack of a beff for [ oiii]@xmath2 in wills et al.(1999 ) might be caused by the covered luminosity range of less than two orders of magnitude . in agreement with prior investigations , we found no significant baldwin effect for nv@xmath5 ( osmer et al.1994 ; laor et al.1995 ; turnshek 1997 ; espey & andreadis 1999 ) . instead of a decreasing equivalent width for increasing continuum strength , @xmath142 stays nearly constant , even though it has a high value of @xmath143ev . although much observational and theoretical effort has been spent to decipher the process which causes the baldwin effect , the mechanism is still unclear . several models have been suggested which emphasize different aspects , i.e. , contributions from optically thin clouds and luminosity - dependent ionization parameter , covering factor , ionizing continuum shape , and chemical composition of the gas . the dependence of the strength of the baldwin effect on the ionization energy indicates that a decreasing covering factor towards higher luminosities is not sufficient to explain the observed beff for each emission line . to explain the observed beff for iv civ@xmath6 , mushotzky & ferland ( 1984 ) presented model calculations suggesting that the beff is caused by a decrease of the ionization parameter , @xmath144 , as well as the covering factor towards higher luminosities . although this model predicts a weaker baldwin effect for lower luminosity agn , it also predicts that ly@xmath11 will lack a beff or show only a weak beff . a luminosity dependence of the covering factor might be indicated independently by measurements of x - ray absorption ( e.g. , lawrence & elvis 1982 ) . a variant of this picture was outlined by shields , ferland , & peterson ( 1995 ) , who suggested that the luminosity dependence could be caused by a luminosity - dependent covering factor of optically thin clouds which would emit preferentially high - ionization lines . the presence of this component in the blr is suggested from several aspects of variability in seyfert galaxies , as well as other arguments . while luminosity dependence of coverage by high - ionization clouds in the blr is apparently still a viable scenario for understanding the beff , this interpretation suffers from the lack of a strong physical basis for predicting this behavior ; explanations are ad hoc or phenomenological at best . several models have been advanced that focused primarily on the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of the ionizing continuum , and its consequences . this approach was motivated by increasing evidence that the sed of the continuum becomes softer for more luminous ( e.g. , sargent & malkan 1982 ; binette et al.1989 ; schulz 1992 ; netzer et al.1992 ; zheng et al.1992 ; zheng & malkan 1993 ; green 1996 , 1998 ; wang et al.1998 ) . empirical models have been suggested which combine a powerlaw continuum and a thermal uv bump . detailed investigations of x - ray and ultraviolet continuum observations , i.e. , the overall ionizing continuum shape , yield indications that the sed becomes softer for increasing luminosity . in particular , it has been shown that @xmath145 , the two - point power index which connects the ultraviolet at 2500 to the x - ray continuum at 2kev , increases significantly with luminosity ( tananbaum et al.1986 ; wilkes et al.1994 ; green et al.1995 ) . this softening can be understood by a shift of the thermal uv - bump towards longer wavelengths in more luminous quasars , i.e. , @xmath146 increases more than @xmath147 for increasing luminosity resulting in a greater @xmath145 ( cf . , binette et al.1989 ; zheng & malkan 1993 ) . early models of geometrically thin and optically thick accretion discs focused on the consequences of the disc inclination and the location of gas relative to the disc ( netzer 1985 , 1987 ) . although these models can not explain the beff for several orders of magnitude in luminosity they provide an explanation for scatter in the @xmath15 vs. @xmath14 relation at a given luminosity . the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of the accretion disc continuum depends on the luminosity which is in turn related to the mass of the black hole and the accretion rate . these dependencies were suggested as the primary mechanism to cause the baldwin effect . recently , wandel ( 1999a , b ) presented an evolutionary scenario which connects the growth of the black hole mass , the accretion rate and the continuum luminosity . as the mass of the black hole increases and consequently also the luminosity , the peak temperature of the uv bump decreases . this results in a shift of the peak of the thermal uv bump to longer wavelengths , i.e. , the continuum becomes softer . netzer et al.(1992 ) calculated the log@xmath148 vs. log@xmath149 relation for a wide range of black hole masses , accretion rates , and inclination angles in geometrically thin accretion disc models . the spread of the calculated @xmath148 at a given luminosity is mainly caused by the different inclination angles of the accretion disc . assuming that our composite spectra represent an average over a variety of disc inclinations , the beff which we measured for ly@xmath11 is consistent with their model predictions . the observed ionization dependence of the baldwin effect provides strong evidence for a luminosity dependent sed of the ionizing continuum and thus favors accretion disc models . however , the detailed models discussed by wandel ( 1999b ) show that the seds of accretion discs depend in a complex way on the mass of the black hole and the accretion scenario . in particular , the cutoff energy of the thermal uv - bump is expected to depend on the black hole mass . these models also predict that luminous quasars with massive black holes should show low cutoff energies , while seyfert1 galaxies with intermediate massive black holes should display high cutoff energies . the low luminosity nlsy1 galaxies with low mass black holes should also exhibit high cutoff energies . different accretion scenarios would introduce additional scatter to this relation . in summary , accretion disc models provide a reasonable explanation of the baldwin effect , in particular for the ionization energy @xmath106 dependent strength . although these models indicate that the luminosity - dependent sed is a major mechanism which drives the beff , the large possible parameter space allows for additional effects . evidence for effects in addition to variations of the spectral energy distribution is given by the failure to explain the lack of a baldwin effect for another high ionization emission line , nv@xmath5 . baldwin et al.(1995 ) and korista et al.(1997 , 1998 ) introduced the `` locally optimally - emitting cloud '' ( loc ) model , which assumes that the blr cloud ensemble covers a wide range of internal densities and occurs over a wide range in distance from the central continuum source . under these conditions the emitted spectrum is controlled by powerful selection effects and the typical observed quasar spectrum can be naturally produced ( korista et al.1997 , 1998 ) . korista et al.(1998 ) computed for a wide range of different continuum slopes ( @xmath150 ) , densities ( @xmath151@xmath70 ) , and metallicities ( 0.2 to 10 times solar ) the resulting emission line spectra . in recent years there has been growing evidence that the chemical composition of quasar gas can reach several times solar metallicity with a trend of higher metallicities in more luminous quasars ( hamann & ferland 1993 , 1999 ; ferland et al.1996 , dietrich et al.1999 ; dietrich & wilhelm - erkens 2000 ) . the emission lines studied by korista et al.(1998 ) follow the general trend for @xmath14 diminishing with softer continuum shapes . assuming the softer continua are related to higher luminosities , this yields the baldwin effect . however , in contrast to those emission lines , nv@xmath5 lacks a baldwin effect even though its high ionization energy @xmath143ev suggests that the decrease of @xmath14(nv ) should be strong . korista et al.(1998 ) introduced metallicity as an additional parameter to provide a possible explanation for the lack of a baldwin effect in nv@xmath5 . they found in their calculations that the equivalent width of ly@xmath11 , iv civ@xmath6 , or ovi@xmath1 show only a weak dependence on the gas metallicity , but nv@xmath5 strongly depends on it . in particular , they assume that nitrogen scales like a secondary element , so that its abundance relative to the other metals increases linearly with the overall metallicity ( e.g. , n / o @xmath152 o / h , see hamann et al.2002 ) . korista et al.(1998 ) assume that the metallicity increases with increasing agn luminosity ( hamann & ferland 1999 ) . with this abundance behavior , korista et al.(1998 ) showed that the equivalent width of nv@xmath5 is not expected to display a beff . therefore , the decreasing equivalent width that should occur in nv@xmath5 as part of the normal beff is approximately compensated by the increasing relative abundance of nitrogen . the net result is that nv@xmath5 shows essentially no beff . overall , the beff slopes that we derived for the emission lines in our quasar sample are in good agreement with the predictions by korista et al . ( table 1 ) . the observed slopes of iv civ@xmath153 and heii@xmath79 are smaller than expected , while the slope in niii]@xmath80 is steeper . however , if only measurements with @xmath154 ergs@xmath23 are taken into account , the observations yield a comparable steep anti - correlation as predicted by korista et al.(1998 ) . we will discuss these comparisons further in a forthcoming paper on the trends in metallicity in this dataset ( see also 6.4 below ) . a common prediction of models that involve a softer continuum sed towards higher luminosities is a steeper slope of the baldwin effect for lines with increasing ionization energy @xmath106 ( zheng et al.1992 ; zheng & malkan 1993 ; korista et al.1998 ; wandel 1999a ) . figures 7a , b and 9 provide clear evidence for this prediction . high ionization lines like iv civ@xmath6 , heii@xmath79 , and heii@xmath104 , and especially ovi@xmath1 are particularly valuable . these emission lines respond to photoionizing energies of @xmath155ev , @xmath156ev , and @xmath157ev , respectively . hence , they can be used to probe the location of the cutoff energy of the thermal uv - bump . the strong beff in these high - ionization lines is expected if the ionizing continuum becomes softer with increasing continuum luminosity . in this case the relative number of ionizing photons with @xmath158ev decreases as the uv bump is moving towards longer wavelengths . while there is only a marginal trend for a slightly steeper baldwin effect for heii than for iv civ , the higher ionization ovi@xmath1 line displays a significantly stronger beff ( fig.9 ) . the decrease of the relative number of ionizing photons with a softer continuum , caused by the shift of the uv bump to longer wavelengths , results in weaker high - ionization lines compared to lower ionization ones . the shift of the uv bump to longer wavelengths will affect emission lines at higher ionization energy first . in addition , the relative continuum strength beneath the emission lines will be enhanced , starting at short ultraviolet wavelengths . both effects together result in smaller @xmath14 for higher luminosities . in addition to the general trend of steeper beff for higher @xmath106 , the curvature or flattening of the beff towards lower luminosities can be accommodated in the framework of some of the luminosity - dependent sed models ( e.g. , netzer et al . 1992 ; wandel 1999a ) . the flattening at low luminosities has led to suggestions that seyfert1 nuclei do not participate in the baldwin effect but have instead equivalent widths independent of luminosity ( e.g. , wampler et al.1984 ) . a close inspection of figures 7a , b provides some evidence for the tendency of a flatter slope @xmath3 of the beff at low luminosities in comparison to higher luminosities , as can be seen for several emission lines ( siiv@xmath131 , niv]@xmath105 , iv civ@xmath6 , heii@xmath79 , oiii]@xmath103 , niii]@xmath80 , heii@xmath104 ) . the turnover appears to occur near @xmath159 , in quite good agreement with predictions ( wandel 1999a ) . within this context it is interesting to note that the steepening of the baldwin effect for @xmath160 , is observed for emission lines with @xmath161ev . for several elements we have measured more than one emission line strength . the comparison of the strength of the baldwin effect may provide information about the emission line region and the mechanism which causes the observed anti - correlation of @xmath14 and continuum luminosity . for hydrogen we have measured two balmer emission lines ( h@xmath162 , h@xmath3 ) and ly@xmath11 . the slope of the baldwin effect of h@xmath162 and h@xmath3 is very similar and within the uncertainties consistent with zero , i.e. no baldwin effect for balmer lines . the missing baldwin effect for these lines provide some argument against a luminosity dependent covering factor , at least for the gas component which is the dominant contributor to these emission lines . while the equivalent width @xmath7(h@xmath66 ) remains nearly constant , the flux ratio ly@xmath11/h@xmath66 decreases by a factor @xmath163 from low to high luminosities ( @xmath164 to @xmath165 ) . the different behaviour of the balmer lines and ly@xmath11 might be also related to the complex physical processes of ly@xmath11 and h@xmath3 emission ( netzer et al.1995 ) . the prominent beff of ly@xmath11 and the lack of a beff for h@xmath66 may be caused in part by a relative stronger increase of the local continuum beneath ly@xmath56 compared to the optical wavelength range of h@xmath66 . however , ly@xmath11 shows a significant beff which fits well in the slope @xmath3 vs. @xmath106 relation ( fig.7a,9 ) . ly@xmath11 might be blended with heii@xmath102 and ov]@xmath166 ( ferland et al.1992 ; shields et al.1995 ) . for standard blr conditions the contribution of heii@xmath102 and ov]@xmath166 are negligible ( less than @xmath28% , priv.comm.k.korista ) . but for higher densities and higher ionization parameter u , particularly for optically thin conditions , these emission lines can be quite strong compared to ly@xmath11 ( shields et al.1995 ) . because ov]@xmath166 has an ionization energy of @xmath167ev , this emission line might show a strong beff . if optically thin gas is a significant fraction of the blr gas , it might be possible that the moderate beff of ly@xmath11 might be caused at least in part by ov]@xmath166 . however , if ov]@xmath166 is a significant contamination of ly@xmath11 it is expected from the results in shields et al.(1995 ) that heii@xmath79 and iv civ@xmath6 should be stronger than observed . in addition , variability behavior in some objects suggests that the optically thin gas may contribute most strongly to the line wings ( e.g. , ferland et al.1990 ; peterson et al.1993 ) , but the part of the emission lines that changes the most with luminosity has a narrow fwhm ( e.g. , osmer et al.1994 ) . although we can not exclude that ov]@xmath166 provides some contribution to ly@xmath11 , it does appear that ly@xmath11 itself shows a moderate baldwin effect in contrast to the balmer emission lines . the two emission lines of he@xmath168 which we measured , heii@xmath79 and heii@xmath104 , show very similar slopes for the baldwin effect . this behavior is expected for heii@xmath79 and heii@xmath104 as typical recombination lines . the similar slope of the beff provides also some evidence that luminosity - dependent radiative transfer effects , collisional effects or dust effects can not affect these emission lines . another line pair we measured is oiii]@xmath103 and [ oiii]@xmath169 . while the ionization energy necessary to create o@xmath170 is @xmath171ev , the excitation energies of these lines differ by a factor of @xmath172 . if the ionizing continuum becomes softer for increasing luminosity , the temperature in the emission line region should drop and hence oiii]@xmath103 should be more affected than [ oiii]@xmath169 . therefore , we might expect oiii]@xmath103 to have a steeper beff than [ oiii]@xmath169 . observationally their beffs are the same . however , the comparison of these two lines is very complicated because they differ in critical density by several orders of magnitudes ( @xmath173@xmath70 for [ oiii]@xmath169 and @xmath174@xmath70 for oiii]@xmath103 ) . in particular , [ oiii]@xmath169 forms in the narrow line region ( nlr ) , which might be heated and ionized additionally by shocks , and is , in any case , spatially distinct from the blr . the different kinematics of the oiii emitting gas is also given by the significantly different profiles we used to measure the emission line flux and equivalent width . the oiii]@xmath103 emission line was fit with a broad and narrow gaussian profile ( with an average fwhm of @xmath175kms@xmath23 and @xmath176kms@xmath23 , respectively ) . the two gaussian components we used to fit [ oiii]@xmath169 result in a profile different compared to oiii]@xmath103 , with average fwhms of @xmath177kms@xmath23 and @xmath178kms@xmath23 . the overall average fwhm of the fitted oiii]@xmath103 and [ oiii]@xmath169 lines are @xmath179 kms@xmath23 and @xmath180 kms@xmath23 , respectively . we have studied three emission lines of nitrogen . nv@xmath5 lacks within the errors a beff . in contrast , the intercombination lines niv]@xmath105 and niii]@xmath80 exhibit a baldwin effect that is consistent with the overall trend of @xmath3 vs. @xmath106 ( fig.9 ) . it might be possible that additional effects influence the emission properties of these nitrogen intercombination lines at higher luminosities . we will discuss these issues in our forthcoming paper on elemental abundances . we have investigated a large sample of @xmath19 type1 agn covering the redshift range from @xmath181 and nearly 6 orders of magnitude in continuum luminosity . to enhance the signal - to - noise ratio , minimize the influence of peculiarities of individual quasars , and investigate weak as well as strong emission lines , we computed composite spectra representing narrow intervals in redshift and luminosity . the emission line fluxes were derived using multi - component gaussian fits after removing a powerlaw continuum fit , a balmer continuum emission template , and a uv and optical iron emission template from the composite spectra . our main results are the following . * in composite spectra spanning the full redshift range at nearly constant luminosity we detect no strong trend in the line @xmath14 with redshift i.e. , with cosmic time . however , there is a marginal tendency for the highest redshift quasars ( @xmath95 ) to show slightly stronger emission lines than their counterparts at lower redshift . * in the composite spectra ranked by luminosity we find a significant baldwin effect in nearly all emission lines in the ultraviolet to optical domain . the only exceptions are nv@xmath5 , h@xmath3 , h@xmath162 , and optical feii which remain constant in @xmath14 within the uncertanties . the lack of a beff for the high - ionization feature nv@xmath5 suggests that the chemical composition of the gas is an additional parameter that can strongly influence the equivalent width of this and possibly other lines . * we detect a strong baldwin effect for the prominent nlr emission line [ oiii]@xmath169 . the strength of the beff for [ oiii]@xmath182 is very similar to the beff measured in oiii]@xmath103 . * the slope @xmath3 of the baldwin effect , where log@xmath183log@xmath184 , shows a significant correlation with the ionization energy , @xmath106 , needed to produce the lines . * the slope of the baldwin effect , @xmath3 , tends to be steeper at higher luminosities , @xmath185ergs@xmath23 , compared to the lower luminosity regime . * the baldwin effect , its steepening towards higher luminosities , and the correlation of the slope @xmath3 with @xmath113 can all be well explained in the context of a luminosity dependent spectral energy distribution of the ionizing continuum . assuming that the sed can be described as a combination of a powerlaw continuum and a thermal uv bump , the ionizing continuum becomes softer for increasing luminosity as the uv bump is shifted to longer wavelengths . this behaviour can be explained with accretion disc models as suggested by netzer et al.(1992 ) and wandel ( 1999a , b ) . we are grateful to numerous colleagues for providing many of these spectra in digital form , in particular j.a.baldwin , t.a.boroson , m.r.corbin , a.laor , w.l.w.sargent , d.p.schneider , c.c.steidel , r.j.weymann , and w.zheng . we also thank desika narayanan for reducing the spectra obtained at lick observatory . md and fh have benefited from support from nasa grant nag 5 - 3234 and nsf through ast-99 - 84040 . mv greatfully acknowledges financial support from the columbus fellowship . bahcall , j.n . , bergeron , j. , boksenberg , a. , et al . 1993 , , 87 , 1 baldwin , j.a . 1977 , , 214 , 679 baldwin , j.a . , wampler , e.j . , & gaskell , c.m . 1989 , , 338 , 630 baldwin , j.a . , ferland , g.j . , korista , k. , & verner , d. 1995 , , 455 , l119 baldwin , j.a . 1999 , in `` quasars and cosmology '' , aspconf.ser.162 , eds . g.ferland & j.a.baldwin , p.475 binette , l. , prieto , a. , szuszkiewicz , e. , & zheng , w. 1989 , , 343 , 135 bischof , o.b . & becker , r.h . 1997 , , 113 , 2000 boroson , t.a . & green , r.f . 1992 , , 80 , 109 brotherton , m.s . , et al . 2001 , , 546 , 775 carroll , s.m . , press , w.h . , & turner , e.l . 1992 , , 30 , 499 cen , r. & ostriker , j.p . 1999 , , 519 , l109 chaffee , f.h . , foltz , c.b . , hewett , p.c . , et al . 1991 , , 102 , 461 collier , s. , et al . 1998 , , 500 , 162 collier , s. , et al . 2001 , , 561 , 146 constantin , a. , shields , j.c . , hamann , f. , foltz , c.b . , & chaffee , f.h . 2002 , , 565 , 50 corbin , m.r . & boroson , t.a . 1996 , , 107 , 69 crenshaw , d.m . , 1996 , , 470 , 322 dickey , j.m . & lockman , f.j . 1990 , , 28 , 215 dietrich , m. , et al . 1993 , , 408 , 416 dietrich , m. , et al . 1999 , , 352 , l1 dietrich , m. & wilhelm - erkens , u. 2000 , , 354 , 17 dietrich , m. , appenzeller , i. , vestergaard , m. , & wagner , s. 2002a , , 564 , 581 dietrich m. , hamann f. , appenzeller i. , vestergaard m. , & wagner s.j . 2002b , in eso astrophysics symposia `` lighthouses of the universe : the most luminous celestial objects and their use for cosmology '' , eds . r.sunyaev , et al . , in press dietrich , m. & hamann , f. 2002c , in prep . dietrich , m. & hamann , f. 2002d , in prep . espey , b.r . , lanzetta , k.m . , turnshek , d.a . 1993 , baas , 25 , 1448 espey , b.r . & andreadis , s.j . 1999 , in `` quasars and cosmology '' , aspconf.ser.162 , eds . g.ferland & j.a.baldwin , p.351 ferland , g.j . , korista , k.t . , & peterson , b.m . 1990 , , 363 , l21 ferland , g.j . , peterson , b.m . , horne , k. , welsh , w.f . , & nahar , s.n . 1992 , , 387 , 95 ferland , g.j . , baldwin , j.a . , korista , k.t . , et al . 1996 , , 461 , 683 forster , k. , green , p.j . , aldroft , t. , vestergaard , m. , foltz , c.b . , & hewett , p.c . 2001 , , 134 , 35 francis , p.j . & koratkar , a.p . 1995 , , 274 , 504 goad , m. , et al . 1999 , , 524 , 707 granato , g.l . , silva , l. , monaco , p. , et al . 2001 , , 324 , 757 grandi , s.a . 1982 , , 255 , 25 green , p.j . , schartel , n. , anderson , s.f . , 1995 , , 450 , 51 green , p.j . 1996 , , 467 , 61 green , p.j . 1998 , , 498 , 170 green , p.j . 1999 , in `` quasars and cosmology '' , aspconf.ser.162 , eds . g.ferland & j.a.baldwin , p.265 green , p.j . , forster , k. , & kuraszkiewicz , j. 2001 , , 556 , 727 hamann , f. & ferland , g.j . 1993 , , 418 , 11 hamann , f. & ferland , g.j . 1999 , , 37 , 487 hamann , f. , korista , k.t . , ferland , g.j . , warner , c. , & baldwin , j.a . 2002 , , 564 , 592 kaspi , s. , et al . 1996 , , 470 , 336 kaspi , s. , smith , p.s . , netzer , h. , et al . 2000 , , 533 , 631 kauffmann , g. & haehnelt , m.g . 2000 , , 311 , 576 kellermann , k.i . , sramek , r. , schmidt , m. , shaffer , d.b . , & green , r. 1989 , , 98 , 1195 kinney , a.l . , rivolo , a.r . , & koratkar , a.p . 1990 , , 357 , 338 kinney , a.l . , bohlin , r.c . , blades , j.c . , & york , d.g . 1991 , , 75 , 645 korista , k.t . , et al . 1995 , , 97 , 285 korista , k.t . , baldwin , j.a . , & ferland , g.j . 1997 , , 108 , 401 korista , k.t . , baldwin , j.a . , & ferland , g.j . 1998 , , 507 , 24 lanzetta , k.m . , turnshek , d.,a . , & sandoval , j. 1993 , , 84 , 109 laor , a. , bahcall , j.n . , jannuzi , b.t . , schneider , d.p . , & green , r.f . 1995 , , 99 , 1 lawrence , a. & elvis , m. 1982 , , 256 , 410 mushotzky , r. & ferland , g.j . 1984 , , 278 , 558 netterfield , c.b . , 2002 , , 571 , 604 netzer , h. 1985 , , 216 , 63 netzer , h. 1987 , , 225 , 55 netzer , h. , et al . 1995 , , 448 , 27 netzer , h. , laor , a. , & gondhalekar , p.m. 1992 , , 254 , 15 osmer , p.s . , porter , a.c . , & green , r.f . 1994 , , 436 , 678 osmer , p.s . & shields , j.c . 1999 , in `` quasars and cosmology '' , aspconf.ser.162 , eds . g.ferland & j.a.baldwin , p.235 peterson , b.m . , 1993 , , 402 , 469 peterson , b.m . , et al . 1994 , , 425 , 622 pettini , m. 1999 , in proc.of eso workshop `` chemical evolution from zero to high redshift '' , ed.j.walsh & m.rosa , lnp , p.233 pogge , r.w . & peterson , b.m . 1992 , , 103 , 1084 reichert , g.a . , et al . 1994 , , 425 , 582 santos - lle , m. , et al . 2001 , , 369 , 57 sargent , w.l.w . & malkan , m.a . 1982 , , 254 , 22 sargent , w.l.w . , boksenberg , a. , & steidel , c.c . 1988 , , 68 , 539 sargent , w.l.w . , steidel , c.c . , & boksenberg , a. 1989 , , 69 , 703 schneider , d.p . , schmidt , m. , & gunn , j.e . 1991a , , 101 , 2004 schneider , d.p . , schmidt , m. , & gunn , j.e . 1991b , , 102 , 837 schulz , h. 1992 , in `` physics of active galactic nuclei '' , eds . w.j.duschl & s.j.wagner ( berlin : springer ) , p.235 seaton , m.j . 1979 , , 187 , 73 shields , j.c . , ferland , g.j . , & peterson , b.m . 1995 , , 441 507 steidel , c.c . 1990 , , 74 , 37 steidel , c.c . & sargent , w.l.w . 1991 , , 382 , 433 stern , d. , djorgovski , s.g . , perley , r.a . , de carvalho , r.r . , & wall , j.v . 2000 , , 119 , 1526 stirpe , g.m . , et al . 1994 , , 425 , 609 storey , p.j . & hummer , d.g . 1995 , , 272 , 41 storrie - lombardi , l.j . , mcmahon , r.g . , irwin , m.j . , & hazard , c. 1996 , , 468 , 121 tananbaum , h. , avni , y. , green , r.f . , schmidt , m. , & zamorani , g. 1986 , , 305 , 57 telfer , r.c . , zheng , w. , kriss , g.a . , & davidsen , a.f . 2002 , , 565 , 773 turnshek , d.a . 1997 , in asp conf.ser.128 , `` mass ejection from agn '' , eds . n.arav , i.shlosman , & r.j.weymann ( san francisco : asp ) , p.52 vanden berk , d.e . , et al . 2001 , , 122 , 549 vron - cetty , m .- p . , vron , p. , & tarenghi , m. 1983 , , 119 , 69 vron - cetty , m .- & vron , p. 2001 , `` a catalogue of quasars and active nuclei '' , 10th edition vestergaard , m. & wilkes , b.j . 2001 , , 134 , 1 wampler , e.j . , gaskell , c.m . , burke , w.l . , & baldwin , j.a . 1984 , , 276 , 403 wandel , a. 1999a , , 527 , 649 wandel , a. 1999b , , 527 , 657 wanders , i. , et al . 1997 , , 113 , 69 wang , t .- g . , lu , y .- j . , & zhou , y .- y . 1998 , , 493 , 1 weymann , r.j . , morris , s.l . , foltz , c.b . , & hewett , p.c . 1991 , , 373 , 23 weymann , r.j . , jannuzi , b.t . , lu , l. , et al . 1998 , , 506 , 1 wilkes , b.j . , tananbaum , h. , worrall , d.m . , et al . 1994 , , 92 , 53 wilkes , b.j . , kuraszkiewicz , j. , green , p.j . , mathur , s. , & mcdowell , j.c . 1999 , , 513 , 76 wills , b.j . , thompson , k.l . , han , m. , et al . 1995 , , 447 , 139 wills , b.j . , laor , a. , brotherton , m.s . , et al . 1999 , , 515 , l53 zamorani , g. , marano , b. , mignoli , m. , zitelli , v. , & boyle , b.j . 1992 , , 256 , 238 zheng , w. , fang , l .- z . , & binette , l. 1992 , , 392 , 74 zheng , w. & malkan , m.a . 1993 , , 415 , 517 zheng , w. , kriss , g.a . , & davidsen , a.f . 1995 , , 440 , 606 zheng , w. , kriss , g.a . , telfer , r.c . , 1997 , , 475 , 469 fig.1 redshift distribution of the agn sample as a function of intrinsic luminosity at @xmath55 . the open symbols represent radio - loud quasars and the filled symbols radio - quiet quasars . the dashed horizontal ( vertical ) lines indicate the luminosity ( redshift ) ranges which were used to calculate composite spectra . at the left side ( top ) of the figure is the number of the individual spectra contributing to each composite spectrum . for the luminosity range @xmath186 composite spectra were calculated for the redshift intervals marked by the vertical dashed lines . fig.2 composite spectrum of the entire agn sample ( top panel ) . the dashed line shows a power law fit to the continuum ( @xmath187 ) yielding @xmath59 @xmath188 . the bottom panel displays the number of agn contributing to each wavelength element . fig.3 ( a ) normalized composite spectra are shown for redshift bins of @xmath87 , starting at @xmath189 ( cf . , fig.1 ) and nearly constant luminosity ( @xmath186 ) . the spectra were normalized by a power law continuum fit . the horizontal dashed lines indicate the continuum level for the individual normalized composite spectra which were vertically shifted for better display . the normalized continuum strength is shown for the spectrum at the bottom of the figure . this same scale applies to all other spectra . \(b ) same as fig.3a , but with an expanded vertical scale to display the dependence of the relative strength of weaker emission lines as a function of redshift . strong emission lines with flat tops are truncated for easier display . fig.5 ( a ) normalized composite spectra are shown for the luminosity bins ( @xmath190 ) as displayed in fig.1 . the spectra were normalized with the corresponding power law continuum fit . the horizontal dashed lines indicate the continuum - level for the individual normalized composite spectra which were vertically shifted for better display . the normalized continuum strength is shown for the spectrum at the bottom of the figure and it applies for the other spectra too . \(b ) same as fig.5a , but with an expanded vertical scale to display the dependence of the relative strength of weaker emission lines as a function of luminosity . strong emission lines with flat tops are truncated for easier display . fig.7 ( a ) line equivalent widths , @xmath7 , as a function of increasing continuum luminosity @xmath109 . we calculated linear fits to @xmath14(l ) for the entire luminosity range ( dashed line ) , as well as a luminosities log@xmath191 ( dashed - dotted line ) . fig.8 difference spectra with respect to the composite spectrum log@xmath192 ergs@xmath23 are displayed to illustrate that @xmath7(nv@xmath5 ) is nearly constant , regardless how @xmath14(nv ) is measured , while the other emission lines display a prominant beff . the dotted line indicates the location of nv@xmath5 . fig.9 the slope of the baldwin effect as displayed in fig.7a and 7b as a function of the ionization energy @xmath106 needed to create the specific ions . different lines of the same ion ( heii@xmath79 , heii@xmath104 and oiii]@xmath103 , [ oiii]@xmath2 ) show nearly identical slopes . the filled symbols represent the slopes based on the entire luminosity range , corresponding to the dashed lines in figures 7a , b . the slopes of the baldwin effect for higher luminosities only ( log@xmath111 ) are plotted as open symbols . lrccc line & @xmath106&entire @xmath109-range & log@xmath193 & korista et al.(1998 ) + & [ ev]&@xmath3&@xmath66&@xmath3 + ovi@xmath1 & @xmath194&@xmath195&@xmath195&@xmath196 + nv@xmath5 & @xmath197&@xmath198&@xmath199&@xmath200 + heii@xmath79 & @xmath201&@xmath202&@xmath203&@xmath204 + heii@xmath104 & @xmath201&@xmath205&@xmath206 & + iv civ@xmath6 & @xmath207&@xmath208&@xmath209&@xmath210 + niv]@xmath105 & @xmath211&@xmath212&@xmath213&@xmath214 + oiii]@xmath103 & @xmath215&@xmath216&@xmath217&@xmath218 + [ oiii]@xmath2&@xmath215&@xmath219 & & + siiv@xmath131 & @xmath220&@xmath221&@xmath219&@xmath222 + niii]@xmath80 & @xmath223&@xmath224&@xmath225&@xmath226 + aliii@xmath77 & @xmath227&@xmath228&@xmath228&@xmath229 + iii ciii]@xmath64 & @xmath230&@xmath221&@xmath231&@xmath232 + siiii]@xmath78&@xmath233&@xmath202&@xmath234&@xmath235 + ly@xmath11@xmath102 & @xmath236&@xmath237&@xmath208&@xmath238 + h@xmath67@xmath239&@xmath236&@xmath240&@xmath240 & + h@xmath66@xmath241 & @xmath236&@xmath242&@xmath243 & + cii@xmath130 & @xmath244&@xmath245&@xmath246&@xmath247 + siii@xmath248 & @xmath249&@xmath250&@xmath246 & + feiiuv & @xmath251&@xmath252 & & + feiiopt & @xmath251&@xmath240 & & + mgii@xmath16 & @xmath253&@xmath221&@xmath221&@xmath254 + oi@xmath129 & @xmath255&@xmath256&@xmath257&@xmath200 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: since its prediction in 1954 @xcite , the effect of superradiance has attracted a lot of theoretical and experimental attention @xcite . its basic principle the fact that a coherent interaction of an unexcited gas with the vacuum of a common field can create a spontaneous macroscopic excitation of both matter and field subsystems appears in various incarnations in diverse branches of physics @xcite . the dicke model @xcite of superradiance resorts to a maximal simplification of the problem to capture the main features of the superradiant transition in the most transparent way . the model shows a thermal phase transition , analyzed and discussed in refs.@xcite , as well as a zero - temperature ( ground - state ) quantum phase transition ( qpt ) , which was realized experimentally with the aid of a superfluid gas in a cavity @xcite . recent theoretical analyses showed that the model exhibits also a novel type of criticality the one observed in the spectrum of excited states @xcite . these so - called excited - state quantum phase transitions ( esqpts ) affect both the density of quantum levels as a function of energy and their flow with varying control parameters , and are present in a wide variety of quantum models with low numbers of degrees of freedom @xcite . in this work , we analyze properties of a simple superradiance model interpolating between the familiar dicke @xcite and tavis - cummings @xcite hamiltonians . a smooth crossover between both limiting cases is achieved by a continuous variation of a model parameter , which allows one to observe the system s metamorphosis on the way from the fully integrable ( hence at least partly understandable ) to a prevailingly chaotic ( so entirely numerical ) regime . one of the aims of our work is to survey the phase - transitional properties of the extended model and to investigate the nature of its _ quantum phases_the domains of the excited spectrum in between the esqpt critical borderlines . a usual approach to characterize different phases related to the ground state of a quantum system makes use of suitable order parameters , i.e. , expectation values of some observables . we show that an unmistakable characterization of phases involving excited states is not achieved through the expectation values alone but rather through their different smoothed energy dependences ( trends ) . the main emphasis of our analysis is nevertheless put on the entanglement properties of excited states across the whole spectrum and their potential links to esqpts and quantum phases of the model . it is known that a continuous ground - state qpt in many models ( including the present one ) is characterized by a singular growth of entanglement within the system , which can be seen as a quantum counterpart of the diverging correlation length in continuous thermal phase transitions @xcite . a question therefore appears whether there exist any entanglement - related signatures of esqpts . the extended dicke model is rather suitable for a case study of this type since it allows one to analyze at once various types of entanglement that between the field and all atoms , and that between individual atoms . it should be stressed that robust , systematic studies of entanglement in excited spectra of any systems are rather scarce . we hope that results of our analysis , which is unavoidably model - specific , will initiate similar studies in other relevant systems . the plan of the paper is as follows : basic quantum and classical features of the model are described in sec.[edm ] . thermal and quantum critical properties and a classification of thermodynamic and quantum phases are presented in sec.[pt ] . the atom field and atom atom entanglement properties are investigated in sec.[ent ] . conclusions come in sec.[sum ] . consider single - mode electromagnetic field with photon energy @xmath0 ( polarization neglected ) interacting with an ensemble of @xmath1 two - level atoms , all with the same level energies @xmath2 . the free hamiltonian reads as @xmath3 where the first term describes the field of photons , created and annihilated by bosonic operators @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively , and the second term represents the ensemble of atoms , with @xmath6 standing for the third pauli matrix acting in the space of the @xmath7th atom . in the following we use all pauli matrices @xmath8 with the subscripts @xmath9 or @xmath10 . the interaction term is taken in the dipole approximation , with the dipole operator for the @xmath7th atom proportional to @xmath11 . the size of the atomic ensemble is assumed to be much smaller than the wavelength of photons ( cavity size ) . then @xmath12 where the coupling parameter ( in units of energy ) can be written as @xmath13 , with @xmath14 standing for the electric dipole moment matrix element , @xmath15 for the vacuum permitivity , and @xmath16 for the cavity volume . the hamiltonian @xmath17 represents the well known dicke model @xcite . it is commonly invoked to explain basic features of the transition of matter to superradiant phase @xcite . indeed , as shown below , if the coupling strength @xmath18 is sufficiently increased , the superradiant phase with @xmath19 and @xmath20 is created at low temperatures . note that the diamagnetic term @xmath21 is neglected here though it turns out to be very important in the discussion of superradiance in realistic situations connected to cavity electrodynamics @xcite . we emphasize that recent experimental realizations of the dicke hamiltonian @xcite do not implement the above electrodynamic content , nevertheless in this presentation we keep this original formulation as a widely comprehensible background . introducing collective quasi - spin operators for the whole atomic ensemble ( which is possible due to the long wavelength approximation ) , @xmath22 one immediately sees that the dicke hamiltonian conserves the squared quasi - spin @xmath23 with eigenvalues @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is integer for @xmath1 even or half - integer for @xmath1 odd . the full atomic hilbert space is the span of all @xmath26 possible configurations of atoms , thus @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the space of the @xmath7th atom . however , due to the conservation of @xmath29 , the dynamics can be investigated separately in any of the single-@xmath25 subspaces @xmath30 with dimension @xmath31 . the decomposition reads as follows @xcite : @xmath32 where @xmath33 enumerates replicas ( their number is @xmath34 ) of the space with given @xmath25 differing by the exchange symmetry of atomic components . in the following , we will investigate thermodynamic properties of the model in the full atomic space @xmath35 , as well as quantum properties in a single-@xmath25 space @xmath36 . the most natural choice in the latter case is the unique ( @xmath34=1 ) subspace with maximal value @xmath37 , which is fully symmetric under the exchange of atoms and therefore emphasizes the collective character of the superradiance phenomenon . a general-@xmath25 subspace has a mixed exchange symmetry such that only a number of @xmath38 atoms can be excited independently , while excitations of the remaining @xmath39 atoms have to compensate each other ( in ref.@xcite the quantum number @xmath25 is called a cooperation number of the atomic gas ) @xcite . the reduced single-@xmath25 model has only two effective degrees of freedom , one associated with the bosonic field , the other with the su(2 ) algebra of collective quasi - spin operators ( [ jbul ] ) , hence @xmath40 . in contrast , in the full ( all-@xmath25 ) model each su(2)@xmath41 algebra of atom @xmath7 brings an independent degree of freedom , so the whole atom field system has @xmath42 . the dicke model is sometimes simplified by omitting the terms @xmath43 and @xmath44 , that for @xmath45 and very small @xmath18 yield negligible contributions to the transition amplitudes @xcite . the reduced model , in case of @xmath46 atoms called the tavis - cummings model @xcite , has an advantage of being completely integrable because of the existence of an additional integral of motion : @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the number of bosons and @xmath49 the number of excited atoms ( taking values @xmath50 $ ] , where @xmath51 is the @xmath52 quantum number ) . this conservation law follows from a u(1 ) symmetry under gauge transformations consisting of a phase shift @xmath53 and a simultaneous rotation @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is the rotation matrix by angle @xmath56 around axis @xmath57 . the quantity ( [ m ] ) is not conserved in the dicke model , although the full hamiltonian has a discrete z(2 ) symmetry with conserved parity @xmath58 . in this work , we analyze properties of the single - mode superradiance model across the transition between the tavis - cummings and dicke regimes . following refs.@xcite , we introduce a second interaction hamiltonian , @xmath59 where @xmath60 $ ] is an additional control parameter , and compose the total hamiltonian as @xmath61 , so : @xmath62 the tavis - cummings and dicke limits of the model are obtained for @xmath63 and 1 , respectively . we see that an increase of @xmath64 from zero breaks the u(1 ) symmetry while preserving the z(2 ) symmetry of the @xmath65 model . extended dicke model as a function of @xmath18 for @xmath66 and @xmath67 . the panels correspond to ( a ) the tavis - cummings limit @xmath68 , ( b ) intermediate regime @xmath69 and ( c ) the dicke limit @xmath70 . ] figure [ f_spe ] shows quantum spectra of hamiltonian with @xmath37 depending on the interaction parameter @xmath18 for three different values of @xmath64 . the evolution of the ground state , namely its sudden drop to lower energies above a certain value of @xmath18 , indicates the superradiant transition at zero temperature . we note that the eigensolutions of the model for a given @xmath25 are in general obtained by a numerical diagonalization of hamiltonian in the tensor product of atomic and field hilbert spaces , @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is the finite atomic space from eq . spanned by basis vectors @xmath73 with quasi - spin projections @xmath74 and @xmath75 is the infinite - dimensional space of the boson field spanned by vectors @xmath76 with boson numbers @xmath77 . since the diagonalization procedure requires a truncation of @xmath75 , the eigensolutions must be carefully checked for convergence . a general state vector of the model for any fixed @xmath25 is expressed as @xmath78 where @xmath79 are expansion coefficients satisfying the normalization condition @xmath80 . note that for even- and odd - parity states , respectively , the sums in eq . go either over even or odd values of @xmath81 . any vector can be visualized as a wave function @xmath82 , where the angle @xmath83 comes from the quasi - spin representation of the atomic subsystem and variable @xmath84 from the oscillator representation of the bosonic field . for integer @xmath25 ( even @xmath1 ) , the wave function can be obtained by substitutions ( up to normalization constants ) @xmath85 and @xmath86 , with @xmath87 standing for the hermite polynomial . for half - integer @xmath25 ( odd @xmath1 ) , however , the wave function @xmath82 acquires a spinorial character . a possible representation can be obtained by coupling an integer angular momentum @xmath88 ( the even core of @xmath89 atoms ) with @xmath90 ( the odd atom ) to the total @xmath25 as in the case of spinor spherical harmonics . this leads to a mapping of @xmath73 to a 2-valued function @xmath91 , which is @xmath92-periodic , with @xmath93 denoting the corresponding clebsch - gordan coefficients . examples of squared wave functions of the @xmath37 hamiltonian eigenstates for an even @xmath1 in the medium-@xmath64 regime are depicted in fig.[f_wav ] . they are taken at the parameter and energy values indicated by dots in fig.[f_qpd]d ( @xmath94 ) . all eigenstates have a good parity , which means that their wave functions are symmetric or antisymmetric under the transformation @xmath95 and @xmath96 . of selected eigenvectors of the hamiltonian with @xmath97 , @xmath66 for @xmath69 taken at the @xmath98 values indicated by dots in fig.[f_qpd]d . panels ( a)(f ) , respectively , correspond to the vertical row of points at the right of fig.[f_qpd]d from bottom to top [ panel ( a ) shows the ground state ] , panels ( g),(h ) to the left pair of points . note that variable @xmath99 is @xmath92 periodic . ] finding eigensolutions of the model is much simpler in the @xmath63 limit . in that case , the conserved quantity from eq . splits the hilbert space into a sum @xmath100 of dynamically invariant subspaces @xmath101 with different values of quantum number @xmath102 . each of these subspaces is spanned by states @xmath103 where @xmath51 goes from @xmath104 to @xmath105 and @xmath106 takes values from @xmath107 to @xmath108 , so its dimension is : @xmath109 note that the saturation of the @xmath101 dimension at @xmath110 for @xmath111 results from the finiteness of the atomic space @xmath36 . the full spectrum for @xmath63 is comprised of a number of mutually non - interacting spectra with different values of @xmath108 , each of them being obtained by truncation - free diagonalization in a finite dimension . as seen in panel ( a ) of fig.[f_spe ] , the @xmath63 spectrum indeed shows numerous crossings of levels with different @xmath108 . in contrast , an increase of @xmath64 in panels ( b ) and ( c ) leads to strengthening of level repulsion , which is a quantum signature of chaos . spectrum ( for @xmath97 ) in the @xmath112 subspace for the @xmath68 model with @xmath66 ( panel a ) , @xmath113 ( panel b ) and @xmath114 ( panel c ) . the wave - function entropies @xmath115 of individual eigenstates in the unperturbed basis @xmath103 are encoded in the varying shade of the corresponding lines . ] the structure of the spectrum for @xmath63 can be further elucidated by considering the hamiltonian with @xmath116 ( the tuned case ) . in a single-@xmath108 subspace it reads as @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the energy in absence of interaction and @xmath119 are the interaction matrix elements in the unperturbed basis @xmath120 enumerated by @xmath121 . a simple calculation yields : @xmath122 . the eigenvectors of this hamiltonian obviously do not depend on @xmath18 since both terms in eq . the eigenvalues have the form @xmath123 , where @xmath124 are eigenvalues of the matrix in the second term including the @xmath125 factor . since the characteristic polynomial of this matrix contains either even ( for @xmath126 even ) or odd ( for @xmath126 odd ) powers of @xmath127 , the eigenvalues come in pairs with opposite signs . for @xmath126 odd , there is an additional unpaired eigenvalue @xmath128 . therefore , the spectrum linearly expands with increasing @xmath18 around the non - interacting energy @xmath118 , while the eigenvectors remain unchanged . both these conclusions concerning the tuned system with @xmath63 are verified in panel ( a ) of fig.[f_cary ] , which besides the energy spectrum of a single-@xmath108 subspace ( the linearly diverging bundle of levels ) shows also the wave - function entropy @xmath129 of individual eigenstates ( encoded in the shade of the respective line ) . this quantity measures the localization of instantaneous eigenstates in the unperturbed basis @xmath103 , ranging from @xmath130 for any unperturbed state to @xmath131 for a uniformly distributed superposition @xcite . in sec.[ent ] we will see that for @xmath63 the wave - function entropy quantifies the atom field entanglement contained in the given state , but here we use it just as an indicator of structural evolution of eigenstates with varying @xmath18 . in fig.[f_cary ] we see in accord with the above analysis that the wave - function entropies of all states remain constant . it is clear that the full spectrum in fig.[f_spe]a results just from a pile up of the trivial spectra similar to that in fig.[f_cary]a with all values of @xmath108 . in contrast , the spectrum of a detuned hamiltonian ( with @xmath132 ) is less trivial . examples of level dynamics in a single-@xmath108 subspace and the corresponding wave - function entropies for @xmath133 and @xmath134 are shown in panels ( b ) and ( c ) of fig.[f_cary ] , where we see that the eigenvalues are no more straight lines and that the eigenvectors change with @xmath18 . the peculiar shapes of these spectra will be subject of our interest in sec.[qpt ] . here we only point out that the tuned situation is restored in an approximate sense for very large @xmath18 , when the last term in the detuned hamiltonian @xmath135 , with @xmath136 , becomes negligible . therefore , investigating properties of the model for large coupling strengths , one can make an assumption that @xmath45 . this conclusion , which holds independently of @xmath64 , will be seen in action in sec.[afe ] . a straightforward way to the classical limit of the extended dicke model leads via the following operator to c - number mappings : @xmath137 the spherical angles @xmath138 and @xmath139 $ ] determine the orientation of the classical quasi - spin vector @xmath140 . note that angle @xmath141 is measured here from the south to the north pole , thus a fully de - excited state of atoms ( @xmath142 ) corresponds to @xmath143 while a maximally excited state of atoms ( @xmath144 ) is associated with @xmath145 . it can be shown that the pair of variables @xmath99 and @xmath146 , respectively , represents canonically conjugate coordinate and momentum associated with the collective states of the atomic subsystem . similarly , quantities @xmath147 and @xmath148 in eq.([map2 ] ) are suitable coordinate and momentum of the field subsystem . let us point out that while the atomic phase space for each @xmath1 is finite ( it is a ball with radius @xmath25 ) , the field phase space covers the whole plane , expressing the fact that the number of bosons is unlimited . the classical hamiltonian resulting from substitution of eqs.([map1 ] ) and ( [ map2 ] ) to reads as ( see also ref.@xcite ) : @xmath149 \label{hcl } \,,\ ] ] since the classical limit of the model is reached in the limit @xmath150 , the above expression needs an appropriate scaling . it is achieved by introducing quantities @xmath151 , @xmath152 , @xmath153 and @xmath154 that for any value of the size parameter take values of order @xmath155 . this leads to the following size - invariant expression : @xmath156 \label{hclscal } \,.\ ] ] note that eq . contains an effective frequency @xmath157 and an effective coupling strength @xmath158 , which both increase linearly with @xmath25 and reach values of the bare parameters @xmath159 and @xmath18 for the maximal @xmath160 . stationary points of the classical hamiltonian will be analyzed below to determine critical values of control parameters and energy separating distinct quantum phases of the model . we know that for @xmath63 the hamiltonian is integrable as it preserves the quantity @xmath108 from eq .. this introduces a specific correlation between the degrees of freedom associated with both atomic and field subsystems . as a consequence , the system with @xmath40 degrees of freedom is for any fixed value of @xmath108 reduced to a system with just a single effective degree of freedom . to make this explicit , we employ a transformation : @xmath161 where @xmath162 is conserved . it can be checked that this transformation is canonical , so @xmath163 and @xmath164 are new pairs of conjugate coordinates and momenta . the @xmath163 variables for each @xmath165 satisfy a constraint @xmath166 $ ] , so they form a disc ( for @xmath167 ) or an annulus ( for @xmath168 ) . the classical tavis - cummings ( @xmath63 ) hamiltonian in terms of the new variables becomes : @xmath169 } \ x ' \label{hcl1d } \,,\ ] ] which for a constant @xmath165 depends only on @xmath163 , so has effectively @xmath170 degree of freedom . this not only guarantees the full integrability of the @xmath63 model , but also results in some emergent critical phenomena which will be discussed below . maps of the single-@xmath25 model with @xmath66 for six values of parameter @xmath171 $ ] . the tones of blue indicate the classical regular fraction . the curves correspond the ground state energy @xmath172 ( full line ) and the critical esqpt energies @xmath173 ( dotted ) , @xmath174 ( dashed ) , and @xmath175 ( dash - dotted ) from eqs.([ec1])([ec3 ] ) . acronyms d ( dicke ) , tc ( tavis - cummings ) , n ( normal ) and s ( saturated ) indicate different quantum phases of the model ( see sec.[qpt ] ) . dots in panel ( d ) mark places where wave functions in fig.[f_wav ] are taken . ] variation of parameter @xmath64 from 0 to 1 breaks the integrability of hamiltonian and leads to increasingly chaotic dynamics . the evolution of a classical measure of chaos with @xmath64 is demonstrated in fig.[f_qpd ] . it displays maps of so - called regular fraction @xmath176 in the plane @xmath98 for various @xmath64 . the regular fraction is defined as the volume of the phase space domain filled with regular trajectories relative to the total phase space volume available at given energy @xmath177 : @xmath178 here , @xmath179 stands for a characteristic function defining the regular part of the phase space , i.e. , the domain where classical dynamics is regular in the sense of vanishing lyapunov exponents ( @xmath180 in the regular part and @xmath181 in the chaotic part ) . the way how the regular fraction is obtained from numerical simulation of classical dynamics is described in ref.@xcite . the value of the regular fraction in fig.[f_qpd ] is encoded into the tones of blue : the full color indicates perfectly regular areas ( @xmath182 ) and white completely chaotic ones ( @xmath183 ) . we observe that the degree of chaos exhibits an overall increase with @xmath64 . however , even in the dicke limit the model is not entirely chaotic . the most chaotic domain in all @xmath184 panels is that with parameter @xmath18 above the superradiant transition and energy @xmath177 exceeding a certain value above the ground - state @xmath172 . besides the main trends in the dependence of @xmath176 we also observe some surprising fine structures for instance the ribs in panels ( d)(f ) . note that various aspects of chaos in the extended dicke model were recently studied in refs.@xcite . the extended dicke hamiltonian ( [ h ] ) has a complex phase structure @xcite . in this section , we analyze thermal phase transition of the full model with atomic hilbert space ( [ hil ] ) and the number of degrees of freedom @xmath42 . following the standard approach described in ref.@xcite , we use the glauber coherent states @xmath185 , where @xmath186 is an eigenvalue of the @xmath5 operator , @xmath187 is a normalization factor , and @xmath188 denotes the field vacuum . an average number of bosons @xmath189 in the state @xmath190 represents an indicator of the phase transition from normal to superradiant phase : it is zero in the normal phase , while in the superradiant phase we expect @xmath191 . on the way to the thermodynamic limit @xmath192 , it is convenient to perform the scaling transformation @xmath193 ( cf.sec.[cl ] ) , so that the scaled coherent - state variable @xmath194 taking values between 0 and @xmath195 becomes a suitable complex order parameter of the superradiant phase transition . we start by introducing two special values of the atom field coupling strength : @xmath196 while the first one will be shown to represent a critical strength for the occurrence of the superradiant phase , the second value will turn out to be a strength at which a specific form of the superradiant phase occurs for @xmath197 . to get an equilibrium field configuration at a given temperature @xmath198 ( measured in energy units ) , we minimize in variable @xmath199 a scaled free energy @xmath200 , where @xmath201 is the partition function , calculated for a given @xmath199 from a partial trace of the hamiltonian exponential over the full atomic hilbert space ( [ hil ] ) . for hamiltonian ( [ h ] ) this procedure yields : @xmath202 \\ \lambda\left[(1\+\delta){\bar\alpha'}\!\-i(1\-\delta){\bar\alpha''}\right ] & \frac{1}{2}\omega_0 \end{array}\right ) \right\ } \label{z } \,.\ ] ] the two eigenvalues of the matrix in the exponential are : @xmath203}\equiv\pm e_{{\bar\alpha } } \label{e } \,,\ ] ] which leads to a simple expression of the scaled free energy : @xmath204 stationary points of @xmath205 can be obtained from a simple analysis . the first derivative in variable @xmath206 or @xmath207 , respectively , vanishes at the points satisfying the first or second line of the following array : @xmath208 the point @xmath199=0 is always a trivial solution of both lines , but additional solutions appear for @xmath209 . this coupling strength represents a critical point where the normal phase @xmath210 becomes unstable at the lowest temperatures and a new , superradiant equilibrium is created at some non - zero values of @xmath199 . the critical temperature for the superradiant transition , i.e. , the upper temperature limit for the existence of the @xmath211 solution in the region @xmath209 , is : @xmath212 for @xmath213 , the stable equilibrium of the system is again only the normal solution @xmath210 . model ( @xmath66 , @xmath69 ) and sample landscapes of the scaled free energy at the @xmath214 cut of the phase diagram ( vertical line ) . the full curve in the phase diagram marks the critical temperature @xmath215 for the transition to the normal ( n ) phase , while the dotted curve indicates the temperature @xmath216 separating the tc and d superradiant phases ( with or without saddles of free energy ) . the free energy landscapes in the complex-@xmath217 plane are , for selected temperatures , visualized by contour - shade plots ( darker areas indicate lower values ) and by the cuts along real and imaginary axes . ] for @xmath63 ( the tavis - cummings limit ) , both right - side conditions in eqs.([con1 ] ) and ( [ con2 ] ) become identical and yield a solution @xmath218 that grows from zero with increasing difference @xmath219 . therefore , the superradiant minimum of the free energy forms a circle around @xmath210 . for @xmath184 , however , a simultaneous solution of both right - side conditions in ( [ con1 ] ) and ( [ con2 ] ) is no more possible . the superradiant equilibrium is then represented by a pair of points on the real axis , @xmath220 , where @xmath221 solves the right - side equation in ( [ con1 ] ) . if @xmath222 and @xmath223 , a pair of saddle points appears for low temperatures on the imaginary axis , @xmath224 , where @xmath225 solves the right - side equation in ( [ con2 ] ) . these unstable solutions exist for temperatures below @xmath226 a possibility of thermodynamic quasi - equilibrium states associated with the saddle points of free energy was recently discussed in ref.@xcite . a thermal phase diagram in the @xmath227 plane for @xmath94 is shown in fig.[f_tpd ] along with samples of the free energy landscapes in various phases and at @xmath228 . the critical temperature @xmath215 from eq.([tc ] ) determines the phase transition between the superradiant and normal ( acronym n ) phases of the model . the superradiant phase exists in two forms : the tavis - cummings phase ( acronym tc ) with the saddles in the free energy landscape and the dicke phase ( acronym d ) without the saddles . while the tc phase is the only type of superradiant phase in the tavis - cummings limit ( where @xmath229 and @xmath230 ) , the d phase is exclusive in the dicke limit ( in which @xmath231 ) . for intermediate @xmath64 both phases coexist , being separated by temperature @xmath216 from eq.([t0 ] ) . let us stress that the tc@xmath232d transition ( in contrast to d@xmath232n ) is not a phase transition in the standard sense since it does not affect the global minimum of the free energy . we return now to the analysis of the extended dicke model with the restriction to a single-@xmath25 collective subspace of atomic states . we assume in particular @xmath37 , but in the following we keep @xmath25 as a changeable parameter . the number of relevant degrees of freedom of the single-@xmath25 model is @xmath40 , independently of the size parameter @xmath1 , which implies that the infinite - size limit , @xmath192 , coincides with the classical limit @xcite . both ground - state and excited - state quantum phase transitions can be predicted from the classical version of the model , namely from the behavior of stationary points of the classical hamiltonian . in particular , the esqpts result from singularities ( non - analyticities ) in the semiclassical density of states @xmath233 where @xmath234 is the step function ( @xmath235 for @xmath236 and @xmath237 for @xmath238 ) , that appear at the points satisfying @xmath239 ( with @xmath240 standing for the gradient in the phase space ) . it has been shown @xcite that the esqpts caused by non - degenerate stationary points those which are locally quadratic as their hessian matrix of second derivatives has only non - zero eigenvalues can be classified by a pair of numbers @xmath241 , where a so - called index of the stationary point @xmath242 is a number of negative eigenvalues of the hessian matrix . in particular , for @xmath243 , the first derivative of the level density in a vicinity of a stationary - point energy @xmath244 behaves as : @xmath245 hence exhibits either a jump ( for @xmath242 even ) or a logarithmic divergence ( for @xmath242 odd ) at the critical energy @xmath244 . from eq.([trans ] ) in the phase space of the atomic subsystem defined by spherical angles @xmath141 and @xmath99 for @xmath66 and @xmath69 . various panels correspond to the indicated values of the coupling strength @xmath18 . each contour - shade polar plot ( with @xmath246angle and @xmath247radius ) is accompanied by the corresponding horizontal and vertical cuts . ] in the present case , the evaluation of the level density according to eq . can be simplified with the aid of the volume - preserving substitution @xmath248 which transforms the classical hamiltonian to the form @xmath249 with fully separated variables of the field and atomic subsystems . although the mapping does _ not _ represent a canonical transformation ( so @xmath250 is not a new coordinate - momentum pair otherwise the model would be separable and thus fully integrable for any @xmath64 ) , it simplifies the analysis of the level density . in particular , the integration in eq . over variables @xmath250 , on which the transformed hamiltonian depends quadratically , can be performed explicitly ( cf . ref.@xcite , where an analogous calculation is performed for a hamiltonian with a quadratic kinetic term ) . the result is a simplified expression @xmath251 in which the integration , involving function @xmath252 defined in eq . , goes only over the 2-dimensional collective phase space of the atomic subsystem a ball with radius @xmath25 . eq . is proportional to an area of the ball region where @xmath253 takes values less than ( or equal to ) the chosen energy @xmath177 , hence it can be visualized as flooding of a landscape with profile @xmath253 on a globe . in analogy to eq . , the @xmath253 function can be expressed in a scaled form , @xmath254 , with parameters @xmath159 and @xmath18 replaced by their effective values @xmath255 and @xmath256 depending on @xmath25 . the @xmath253 function is for selected values of control parameters @xmath18 and @xmath64 depicted in fig.[f_impo ] . , for the single-@xmath25 model with @xmath66 and @xmath69 as a function of @xmath18 and @xmath257 . the shade diagram in the left panel was obtained from eq . ; darker areas represent larger values and vice versa . panels ( a ) and ( b ) show cuts ( full curves ) at ( a ) @xmath258 and ( b ) @xmath214 in comparison with finite - size results ( dashed curves ) based on numerical diagonalization of the hamiltonian for @xmath97 and gaussian smoothening of the spectrum ( @xmath259 and @xmath260 for @xmath258 and @xmath261 , respectively ) . scales in panels ( a),(b ) are arbitrary and not the same . ] it is clear from the expression that the stationary points of @xmath262 in all four variables correspond to @xmath263 and @xmath264 determined as stationary points of the function @xmath253 . since the quadratic minimum in variables @xmath250 has a null index , any stationary point of @xmath262 has an index @xmath242 equal to that of the corresponding stationary point of @xmath253 . for the determination of esqpts it is therefore sufficient to find and classify stationary points of the function @xmath253 on a ball . non - degenerate stationary points of @xmath253 with index @xmath265 , @xmath266 , and @xmath267 cause , respectively , an upward jump , logarithmic divergence and a downward jump of @xmath268 . inserting the effective parameters @xmath256 and @xmath255 from the scaled hamiltonian into eq . , we obtain the following @xmath25-dependent values of the critical couplings : @xmath269 these will play the roles of @xmath270 and @xmath271 in individual subspaces of states with fixed values of @xmath25 . note that in the highest subspace with @xmath160 both expressions in eq . yield the bare values of critical couplings . a straightforward analysis leads to the following conclusions : \(i ) stationary points with @xmath265 represent the global minimum of both @xmath253 and @xmath262 functions , demarcating the ground state of the @xmath192 system . the minimum appears at @xmath272 ( @xmath99 arbitrary ) for @xmath273 , and at @xmath274 , @xmath275 and @xmath276 ( a pair of degenerate minima ) for @xmath277 . the ground - state energy is given by the following formula : @xmath278 & { \rm for\ } \lambda\in[\lambda'_c,\infty)\ , , \end{array } \right . \label{e0}\ ] ] which exhibits a second - order qpt from normal to superradiant ground - state phase at the critical coupling @xmath279 , where @xmath280 has a discontinuity . \(ii ) stationary points with @xmath281 represent saddles of @xmath253 . they are located at @xmath272 ( @xmath99 arbitrary ) for @xmath282 , and at @xmath283 , @xmath284 and @xmath285 for @xmath286 . these stationary points correspond to an esqpt ( a logarithmic divergence of @xmath268 ) at energy : @xmath287 & { \rm for\ } \lambda\in[\lambda'_0,\infty)\ , . \end{array } \right . \label{ec1}\ ] ] for @xmath288 we have @xmath289 and eq.([ec1 ] ) is reduced to its first line . \(iii ) stationary points with @xmath290 are maxima of @xmath253 at @xmath272 ( @xmath99 arbitrary ) for @xmath286 and at @xmath291 ( @xmath99 arbitrary ) for @xmath292 . related esqpts ( downward jumps of @xmath268 ) appear at energies @xmath293 the second maximum of @xmath253 at energy is the global one , so for @xmath294 the formula yields a constant ( saturated ) value of the level density equal to @xmath295 . subspace of the @xmath296 tavis - cummings model ( @xmath68 ) with @xmath113 as a function of @xmath18 and @xmath297 ( shade plot on the left , with dark areas indicating larger values and vice versa ) and three dependences of the corresponding hamiltonian function on @xmath298 for @xmath299 ( on the right ) . an esqpt due to an inflection point of the classical hamiltonian above the qpt critical point results in a logarithmic divergence of the semiclassical level density ( the dark band in the shade plot ) , cf.fig.[f_cary]b . ] all esqpt critical borderlines @xmath173 , @xmath174 and @xmath175 from eqs. for various values of @xmath64 are demarcated in fig.[f_qpd ] above . their existence is numerically verified in fig.[f_dender ] , which depicts the @xmath98 dependence of @xmath300 for @xmath37 somewhere in between the dicke and tavis - cummings limits . the shade plot was obtained through the phase - space integration in eq . and a comparison with results obtained by a numerical diagonalization is shown in the two panels on the right . we stress that due to the @xmath40 character of our model , the esqpt singularities occur in the _ first derivative _ of the level density with respect to energy . however , the conservation of quantity in the @xmath63 limit and the corresponding reduction of the number of effective degrees of freedom to @xmath170 ( see sec.[cl ] ) leads to a possibility to generate an esqpt singularity in the level density itself . such an effect can really be identified within a particular _ single @xmath108-subspace _ of the full model . the lowest - energy state of any of such subspaces for @xmath192 coincides with the global minimum of classical hamiltonian within the available ( for a given @xmath108 ) domain of the phase space . it turns out that the most interesting @xmath108-subspace is the one with @xmath301 . this particular subset of states exhibits for @xmath133 a second - order ground - state qpt at the coupling strength @xmath18 equal to a critical value : @xmath302 at this coupling , the main minimum of function moves from @xmath303 away to @xmath304 while @xmath305 becomes an inflection point . the inflection point is present for @xmath306 and generates an esqpt ( a logarithmic divergence of the level density in the @xmath301 subspace ) at energy @xmath175 from eq .. note that for @xmath134 the esqpt appears for @xmath307 at the upper energy of the unperturbed spectrum . this effect , described already in ref.@xcite , is demonstrated in fig.[f_tcdens ] . it displays a shade plot of the semiclassical density of levels with @xmath301 ( obtained by the @xmath170 phase space integration ) and the underlying forms of the hamiltonian . a finite - size sample of the predicted singularity in the level density was seen in panel ( b ) of fig.[f_cary ] above . a more detailed analysis of eq . shows that the present type of criticality is absent in the @xmath308 subspaces . this can be intuitively understood from the evaluation of matrix elements @xmath309 of the interaction hamiltonian @xmath310 with @xmath63 in the unperturbed basis ; see eq . and the text below it . the interaction matrix elements quantify the mixing induced by @xmath310 in the unperturbed eigenbasis of @xmath311 . neglecting the trivial state with @xmath312 which does not mix at all , the matrix elements @xmath309 are particularly small in the @xmath313 subspace ( dimension 2 ) and for the @xmath314 state of the @xmath301 subspace ( dimension @xmath31 ) . only the latter state can develop a singularity in the @xmath150 limit . it is the state @xmath315 , which for @xmath133 represents the lowest state of the @xmath301 subspace , while for @xmath134 it is the highest state ; cf.panels ( b ) and ( c ) of fig.[f_cary ] . although the @xmath308 subspaces show no quantum critical effects , it is interesting to realize that a pile up of all @xmath108-subspaces produces the downward jump of @xmath300 ( with @xmath316 standing for the total semiclassical level density ) , as observed in the @xmath317 esqpt of the @xmath63 system . the critical borderlines @xmath173 , @xmath174 and @xmath175 in the @xmath98 plane separate spectral domains that we consider to constitute different quantum phases of the model ( in analogy to thermodynamic phases ) . they are denoted by acronyms d ( dicke ) , tc ( tavis - cummings ) , n ( normal ) and s ( saturated ) , see fig.[f_qpd ] . both phases d and tc , which coexist for @xmath64 in between 0 and 1 , contain quantum states of a superradiant nature because their energy is lowered with respect to the minimal non - radiant value @xmath318 . in the limits of @xmath64 , the model shows only one type of the superradiant phase : tc for the tavis - cummings limit @xmath63 and d for the dicke limit @xmath319 . in contrast , both phases n and s contain states that resemble excitations in the fully non - radiant regime at @xmath320 . the s phase above @xmath321 yields a constant , saturated value of level density @xmath316 . ( panel a ) and @xmath322 ( panel b ) in individual eigenstates of the @xmath296 hamiltonian ( [ h ] ) for @xmath97 , @xmath66 , @xmath214 . the upper panels depict lattices for the limiting values of @xmath68 and 1 , whereas the lower panels correspond to @xmath69 . the insets of the @xmath69 panels show smoothed dependences of both observables on energy ( averages over 20 neighboring eigenstates and their piecewise fits in various quantum phases ) . ] while the definition of esqpts is obvious from the behavior of quantities like level density at the critical energies , the meaning of quantum phases in between the critical energies is not a priori clear . it should be looked for in the structure of the energy eigenstates in the corresponding energy domains . however , sample wave functions in fig.[f_wav ] [ where panels ( a ) , ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) and ( h ) correspond to phases d , d , tc , n and n , respectively ] indicate that individual eigenstates do not show sufficient clues for the identification of phases . we have to resort to a more efficient visualization tool allowing us a bulk inspection of the eigenstate properties . the approach employed in this work is based on the method of so - called _ peres lattices _ @xcite . it was proven useful in various models ( see ref.@xcite and references therein ) including the dicke model @xcite . a general peres lattice shows expectation values @xmath323 of a selected observable @xmath324 in individual energy eigenstates @xmath325 ( enumerated by integer @xmath326 ) arranged into lattices with energy @xmath327 on one of the axes . examples of peres lattices for observables ( a ) @xmath328 and ( b ) @xmath329 are shown in the respective panels of fig.[f_pere ] . a comparison of both @xmath94 lattices ( in the main panels ) with the map of chaos in fig.[f_qpd]d ( for @xmath18 demarcated by the second vertical line ) yields an overall agreement with the original conjecture concerning the correlation of orderly arranged domains of a generic lattice with more regular regions of classical dynamics and vice versa @xcite . also the limiting @xmath63 lattices in the upper panels of fig.[f_pere ] are perfectly regular , while those for @xmath319 above a certain energy are almost fully chaotic . the @xmath94 peres lattices in fig.[f_pere ] cross all four quantum phases of the model . there exist apparent similarities between parts of both @xmath94 lattices located in the tc and d phases , respectively , and the corresponding tavis - cummings and dicke lattices displayed in the @xmath63 and 1 upper panels . however , a more specific distinction of quantum phases results from an averaging of both lattices over the neighboring eigenstates , as shown in the insets of both lower panels of fig.[f_pere ] . points in these _ smoothed lattices _ represent averages @xmath330 and @xmath331 of the respective expectation values @xmath332 and @xmath333 over 20 neighboring eigenstates . smoothed dependences of the averaged quantities on energy are given by lines , resulting from piecewise fits within the four quantum phases . we observe that various quantum phases are recognized by different characters of the energy dependences , namely : ( i ) the phase d by slowly descending dependences of both @xmath330 and @xmath331 averages , ( ii ) the phase tc by roughly constant dependences , ( iii ) the phase n by linearly increasing dependences , and ( iv ) the phase s by saturated @xmath334 and linearly increasing @xmath331 . hamiltonian ( [ h ] ) with @xmath97 , @xmath66 and @xmath69 at @xmath214 . quantum phases d , tc , n and s are distinguished by different smoothed energy dependences of the average slopes see the piecewise fits indicated by full black lines . ] peres lattices for both quantities @xmath52 and @xmath322 are connected with the lattice of the interaction hamiltonian @xmath335 via the energy conservation relation . using the hellmann - feynman formula , @xmath336 , one derives the following expression for the slope of individual energy levels : @xmath337 the slopes averaged over bunches of neighboring 20 levels , as in the insets of fig.[f_pere ] , are presented in fig.[f_slo ] for the same values of control parameters . piecewise fits of the energy dependences in individual quantum phases are again indicated by lines . we see that any of the d , tc , n and s quantum phases is characterized by a specific , roughly invariant energy dependence of the averaged level slope @xmath338 within the corresponding energy domain . abrupt changes of the character of these dependences coincide with critical esqpt energies . this is in accord with a general relation between the density and flow signatures of esqpts , namely with the fact that a typical esqpt generates the same type of non - analyticity in the energy dependences of both quantities @xmath316 and @xmath338 @xcite . indeed , the discontinuities of @xmath339 at the critical energies @xmath174 and @xmath175 , as observed in fig.[f_slo ] , are consistent with the analogous behavior of the @xmath300 ( fig.[f_dender ] ) . on the other hand , the anticipated point of a singular growth of the level slope ( logarithmic divergence of its energy derivative ) at @xmath173 is smoothed out in the finite spectrum for a moderate system s size . we turn to the study of quantum entanglement properties of individual eigenstate of the model hamiltonian and their links to the esqpts . our analysis includes two types of bipartite entanglement : ( a ) that between the bosonic field and the set of all atoms ( atom field entanglement ) , and ( b ) that between any pair of individual atoms ( atom atom entanglement ) . the entanglement of type ( a ) is an important ingredient of superradiance since the interaction term of the hamiltonian carries a direct coupling between the atomic and field subsystems . in contrast , the entanglement of type ( b ) appears only due to an indirect coupling of individual atoms via the bosonic field , so it may be expected to be just a higher - order effect . we start with a brief description of the measures used to quantify both types of entanglement . in the following , the atom field and atom atom entanglement will be evaluated in individual eigenstates @xmath340 of hamiltonian . some examples of the eigenstate wave functions were shown in fig.[f_wav ] . since the wave - function arguments @xmath99 and @xmath341 , respectively , correspond directly to the atomic and field coordinates , a compound state @xmath342 is factorized with respect to the atom field partitioning of the system if it has a product wave function @xmath343 , where @xmath344 and @xmath345 are arbitrary atomic and field wave functions . the method to quantify a departure of a given pure state @xmath342 from exact factorization , i.e. , an amount of atom field entanglement involved in @xmath342 , makes use of the von neumann entropy corresponding to the reduced density operators @xmath346 and @xmath347 of the atomic and field subsystem , respectively . these operators are obtained by partial tracing of the total density operator @xmath348 over the irrelevant part of the total hilbert space , that is @xmath349 ( trace goes over @xmath350 ) for the atomic subsystem and @xmath351 ( trace goes over @xmath352 ) for the field subsystem . von neumann entropy of the pure compound state @xmath353 is by definition zero , but entropies of both reduced density operators @xmath346 and @xmath347 satisfy : @xmath354 . the case @xmath355 implies a separable compound state , while the case @xmath356 indicates that the reduction of @xmath353 to a single subsystem leads to a loss of information on mutual entanglement between subsystems . a maximally entangled state yields @xmath357 , where @xmath31 is a dimension of @xmath358 , the smaller of both subspaces . we therefore define a normalized atom field entanglement entropy in a compound state @xmath342 as : @xmath359}{\ln(2j+1 ) } = -\frac{\textnormal{tr}\left[\rho_{\textnormal{f}}\,\textnormal{ln}\rho_{\textnormal{f}}\right]}{\ln(2j+1 ) } \label{s } \,.\ ] ] it changes between @xmath360 for separable states and @xmath361 for maximally entangled states . quantifying the atom atom entanglement , i.e. , quantum correlations between a randomly chosen pair @xmath362 of atoms , is a more complex problem . the use of the above entropic approach is disabled by the fact that for any state @xmath342 of the whole atom field system , an arbitrary pair of atoms generically occurs in a _ mixed _ quantum state . it is known that mutual entanglement of a pair of objects in a mixed compound state can not be recognized by a non - zero entropy of the reduced density operators @xcite . indeed , a mixed compound state of the pair generates mixed reduced states of the objects even in absence of entanglement . in such cases , the evaluation of an entropy - based measure of entanglement ( so - called entanglement of formation ) has to be performed with respect to all possible decompositions of the compound density operator into statistical mixtures of pure states @xcite , which is from the computational viewpoint a difficult task . a way to bypass this obstacle for two - qubit systems was proposed in refs.@xcite in terms of a quantity called concurrence . the idea was applied and further elaborated @xcite for multi - qubit systems in fully symmetric states , like our ensemble of @xmath1 two - level atoms with @xmath160 . the atom atom entanglement in this case is characterized by a scaled concurrence : @xmath363 where @xmath364 are eigenvalues ( real and non - negative ) of a non - hermitian matrix @xmath365 , with @xmath366 denoting a reduced density matrix of the pair of atoms @xmath362 and @xmath367 the corresponding spin - flipped ( conjugate under the time reversal ) state ( with @xmath368 denoting the tensor product of operators for the selected atoms and @xmath369 a complex conjugated density matrix in the @xmath370 eigenbasis ) . the argument @xmath371 in the definition again reminds the compound state @xmath342 in which the concurrence is calculated . it has to be stressed that the full symmetry of @xmath342 under the exchange of atoms , which is guaranteed in the @xmath160 subspace , ensures that the reduced density matrix @xmath366 , as well as @xmath372 and @xmath373 , are the same for _ any _ pair of atoms , hence do not in fact depend on @xmath374 . model in the plane of control parameters @xmath18 and @xmath64 ( for @xmath66 , @xmath375 ) . the red curve indicates the qpt critical coupling @xmath279 . left : atom field entanglement measured by the entropy . right : atom atom entanglement measured by the concurrence . the darker areas indicated larger entanglement . ] matrix elements of the reduced two - atom density matrix @xmath366 for any symmetric state of an @xmath1-qubit system can be expressed through expectation values @xmath376 , @xmath377 and @xmath378 of collective quasi - spin operators in a given state see formulas ( 4 ) and ( 11 ) in ref.@xcite . this makes it possible to perform a straightforward numerical computation of @xmath373 in the @xmath160 subspace of our model . moreover , as shown in ref.@xcite , the scaled concurrence in this subspace is related to the so - called kitagawa ueda spin - squeezing parameter @xmath379 though the relation @xmath380 , so it varies between @xmath381 for separable states and @xmath382 for the states that exhibit the maximal entanglement allowed for a given @xmath1 . an entropy corresponding to the entanglement of formation of a single atomic pair reads as @xcite : @xmath383 \label{saa } \,.\ ] ] for @xmath381 we have @xmath384 , while for @xmath382 we obtain @xmath385 , which decreases from @xmath386 for @xmath387 to zero in the classical limit @xmath388 . with @xmath389 , the maximal entropy behaves as @xmath390 . note that the @xmath389 maximal atom field entanglement entropy _ per atom _ decreases as @xmath391 , see eq . , so it exceeds the atom atom entanglement entropy about @xmath1 times . these scaling properties are verified theoretically and by large-@xmath1 numerical calculations @xcite . the atom field and atom atom entanglement properties have been studied for the ground state of the dicke model @xcite . as in other models of similar nature , see e.g. refs.@xcite , the second - order qpt was shown to induce a singularity in both entanglement measures and . figure [ f_eng ] verifies this conclusion in our extended model with variable parameter @xmath64 . we observe that both @xmath392 and @xmath373 measures exhibit an increase at about the critical coupling @xmath279 from eq .. for @xmath184 , the atom atom entanglement drops back to nearly zero values with @xmath393 . the atom field entanglement saturates at a value @xmath394 for @xmath395 , which is due to an irreducible atom field coupling in the lowest positive parity state in the strong coupling limit @xcite . in the @xmath396 region , close to the integrable tavis - cummings limit , both entanglement measures show roughly a step - like increase at @xmath279 . this is due to a specific mechanism , in which the ground state at each @xmath18 is formed via unavoided crossings of levels with different values of the conserved quantum number @xmath108 , see fig.[f_spe]a . we will analyze the integrable case in more detail below . in the following , we present results of a numerical study of the atom field entanglement in individual eigenstates of hamiltonian with @xmath37 . we start by analyzing the integrable tavis - cummings limit @xmath63 . this simple setting will allow us to obtain some insight into the entanglement properties from quasi - analytic solutions , which will serve as a useful reference for the less trivial @xmath184 case . we know that for @xmath63 the hilbert space splits into the subspaces @xmath101 with fixed values of quantum number @xmath108 , see eq . , with the corresponding dimensions @xmath126 given by . the reduced density matrix of the atomic subsystem within each @xmath101 reads as @xmath397 where @xmath398 is a number of bosons associated with quasi - spin projection @xmath51 for a given value of @xmath108 . this expression implies that for @xmath63 the entanglement entropy of any eigenstate is equal to the wave - function entropy corresponding to its expansion in the non - interacting basis . model with @xmath66 for @xmath296 and @xmath97 ( left panel ) , and the atom field entanglement entropies @xmath392 in individual eigenstates corresponding to @xmath399 cut of the spectrum ( right panel ) . the lowest v - shaped chain of points ( connected by the green curve ) in the entropic spectrum corresponds to the lowest states from various @xmath108-subspaces , the second chain to the second states etc . the points corresponding to two selected @xmath108-subspaces ( @xmath400 and 8) are highlighted . ] let us focus first on the tuned case @xmath116 . the wave - function entropies for the @xmath301 spectrum of a tuned @xmath63 hamiltonian were shown in panel ( a ) of fig.[f_cary ] . we notice that the entropy of individual eigenstates does not change with @xmath18 and that it has an apparent symmetry with respect to the vertical reflection of the spectrum around the centroid energy @xmath118 . the former feature was explained by constancy of eigenstates of the simple hamiltonian , the latter follows from a recursive relation for the eigenstate components in eq . which yields the same distributions @xmath401 , hence the same entropies , for the pair of levels with opposite slopes . the full spectrum of the tavis - cummings model is obtained by combining the spectra for all values of @xmath108 . this is for @xmath116 seen in fig.[f_pileup ] . it shows the energy spectrum as a function of @xmath18 ( in the left panel ) and the atom field entanglement entropy of individual eigenstates for one particular value of the coupling strength ( the right panel ) . as follows from the above theoretical analysis , the energy spectrum in the left panel of fig.[f_pileup ] is formed by straight lines . the qpt critical coupling @xmath402 coincides with the point where the energy of the @xmath312 ground state is crossed by the lower state from the @xmath313 space . a further increase of @xmath18 above @xmath402 leads to a sequence of consecutive level crossings in which the lowest states from subspaces with increasing @xmath108 become instantaneous ground states of the system . a similar mechanism applies also in the spectrum of excited states , where we observe a sequence of separated caustic structures formed by states with increasing ordinal numbers within each @xmath108-subspace ( the @xmath322th caustic structure in the vertical direction represents an envelope of lines corresponding to the @xmath322th states from individual @xmath108-subspaces ) . the entropic spectrum on the right of fig.[f_pileup ] arises in a similar way . it is composed of several mutually shifted v - shaped chains of points , each of them containing a collection of states from different @xmath108-subspaces . for example , the lowest v - chain of points is formed by the lowest - energy states from all @xmath108-subspaces , the second lowest chain by second lowest - energy states and so on . to indicate a contribution of a single @xmath108-subspace to the entropic spectrum , we highlighted the points corresponding to two values of @xmath108 . for @xmath403 , the contribution has a seagull - like form ( see the @xmath404 example in the figure ) , whose reflection symmetry around @xmath118 results from the above - discussed properties of eq .. the instantaneous ground state at the given @xmath405 , which is well above the critical point @xmath402 , has a high value of @xmath108 and therefore carries a considerable amount atom field entanglement ( as in general expected in superradiance ) . on the other hand , the trivial one - dimensional subspace with @xmath312 formed by the state @xmath406 , which was the ground state of the @xmath63 hamiltonian at @xmath407 and becomes an excited state with energy @xmath408 for @xmath409 , has apparently zero atom field entanglement . we will see below that some remnants of this state remain present in entropic spectra also in the non - integrable @xmath184 regime . model with @xmath296 and @xmath97 in the detuned case ( @xmath113 ) for several values of the coupling strength @xmath18 . ] let us consider now the detuned case @xmath132 . field entropic spectra of a hamiltonian with @xmath63 and @xmath410 are displayed in fig.[f_detun ] for increasing values of the coupling strength @xmath18 ( the critical coupling is @xmath411 ) . we know ( see sec.[ha ] ) that in the strong coupling limit , @xmath412 , the detuned situation becomes very similar to the tuned one . this is obvious from a comparison of the @xmath413 entropic spectrum in fig.[f_detun ] with that in fig.[f_pileup ] . on the other hand , for small coupling strengths , @xmath414 , the detuning @xmath415 plays an important role . a detuned system shows generally lower values of the atom field entanglement than the tuned one , which can be attributed to a smaller perturbation efficiency of the interaction hamiltonian @xmath310 due to larger energy gaps between the unperturbed ( factorized ) states ( the energy spread of a single-@xmath108 spectrum at @xmath320 increases with @xmath415 ) . this overall lowering of entanglement entropies at small @xmath18 ( more apparent for @xmath133 than @xmath134 ) can be verified by simple numerical calculations , which we do not present here . it is clear that the factorized state @xmath406 with @xmath312 at critical energy @xmath416 is an invariant eigenstates of any @xmath63 hamiltonian , irrespective of @xmath18 and @xmath0 s . so the @xmath360 point at the place of the unperturbed ground state is present in all entropic spectra of fig.[f_detun ] . however , for an @xmath132 system , a local decrease ( converging to @xmath360 with @xmath150 ) of the atom field entanglement is present also at the highest critical energy @xmath417 . this is due to quantum critical properties of the @xmath301 subspace discussed in sec.[qpt ] . we consider here the @xmath133 case ( see fig.[f_cary]b ) , but the same phenomenon takes place also in the reversed detuning hierarchy @xmath134 ( fig.[f_cary]c ) . for @xmath418 , where @xmath419 is the critical coupling , the lowest state of the @xmath301 subspace at energy @xmath175 keeps the factorized form @xmath315 ( mind the sign difference in @xmath51 from the other factorized state , which means that now a maximal possible , for a given @xmath25 , number of atoms is in the _ upper _ level ) . distinct lowering of the atom field entanglement entropy at @xmath317 is observed in the @xmath420 and 0.4 panels of fig.[f_detun ] ( in which @xmath421 ) . this qpt - related effect becomes sharper with increasing @xmath1 and @xmath25 , and in the @xmath422 limit it results in a similar @xmath360 cusp as that at energy @xmath174 . for @xmath134 , the above factorized state , causing the same effect , is the highest state of the @xmath301 subspace at @xmath320 . subspace of the @xmath68 detuned ( @xmath113 ) model with @xmath296 : the ground state ( panel a ) and excited states which at @xmath423 have 15% ( panel b ) and 24% ( panel c ) of the maximal excitation energy . the dashed curves are for @xmath97 , the full ones for @xmath424 . the energy of the corresponding level ( for @xmath97 ) is shown at the bottom of each panel . the log - log plot in panel ( b ) inset shows the minimum value of @xmath392 in the dip as a function of @xmath25 for the level at 15% of the spectrum ( for this level , the dependence is roughly @xmath425 ) . ] an analogous lowering of the atom field entanglement entropy at the upper critical energy @xmath175 appears also for the coupling strengths _ above _ the qpt critical value @xmath419 . the effect in this domain is caused by the @xmath170 type of esqpt in the @xmath301 subspace . indeed , when excited states within this subspace cross the critical energy , they get temporarily localized in the coordinate region around the point @xmath426 , i.e. , at the position of the factorized state . this is due to dwelling of the @xmath317 classical trajectory and a semiclassical wave function at an inflection point of the classical hamiltonian . an analogous phenomenon was observed also in other quasi @xmath170 models , see e.g. ref.@xcite . the lowering of the eigenstate entropy in the @xmath427 domain was visible already in panels ( b ) and ( c ) of fig.[f_cary ] , but it is not apparent in fig.[f_detun ] . to see the effect in the pile up of all-@xmath108 spectra , one would have to go to higher values of @xmath1 and @xmath25 , when the localization becomes stronger and the entropy decreases to its lower limit @xmath360 . entropic spectra of the atom field entanglement with increasing parameter @xmath60 $ ] at @xmath214 , @xmath428 , @xmath97 . the esqpt energies are indicated by vertical lines . the spectrum contains @xmath429 well converged eigenstates . ] the esqpt - based localization effect is nevertheless well documented in fig.[f_entrotc ] , which depicts the evolution of the atom field entanglement for three selected levels ( ground state and two excited states ) from the @xmath430 subspace for @xmath431 and 1000 . we see that the passage of the selected excited states through the esqpt energy @xmath175 is correlated with a local decrease of the entanglement entropy [ sharp dips in the dependences in panels ( b ) and ( c ) ] . as demonstrated by the curves for two values of @xmath1 , the drop of entropy becomes sharper and deeper with increasing size of the system . the decrease of @xmath392 at the lowest point of the dip with @xmath37 for one of the excited states is shown in the inset of fig.[f_entrotc]b . the depicted log - log plot indicates a very slow power - low decrease according to @xmath432 . the exponent @xmath433 is rather small and depends on the selected level ( e.g. , for the displayed level at 15% of the spectrum we obtain @xmath434 , while for the level at 20% we would have @xmath435 ) note that the entanglement entropy for excited states for large @xmath18 saturates at a value close to @xmath436 , where @xmath437 is the dimension for @xmath301 . this expression follows from the use of the random matrix theory for estimating an average wave - function entropy for @xmath126 orthonormal states in the limit of strong mixing @xcite . note also that the critical coupling @xmath419 of the ground - state qpt coincides with the sharpest increase of the ground - state entanglement entropy ( fig.[f_entrotc]a ) . now we are ready to turn our attention to the non - integrable @xmath184 model . figure [ f_sdelta ] shows the evolution of the entropic spectrum with parameter @xmath171 $ ] for @xmath116 and @xmath438 , well above the critical coupling @xmath402 for any @xmath64 . the vertical lines demarcate the esqpt energies , the zones between them corresponding to the d , tc , n and s quantum phases . one can see that the departure from integrability ( an increase of @xmath64 ) gradually destroys regular patterns in the entropic spectra , in analogy with peres lattices . orderly patterns in the entropic spectrum occur in the domains of regular dynamics , while disorderly scattered points indicate chaotic domains . note that the accumulation of points in a narrow band close to ( slightly below ) the maximal entropy @xmath439 for high energies is a consequence of ergodicity of chaotic dynamics @xcite : a common eigenstate in the chaotic part of the spectrum contains virtually all atom field configurations , whose dominant part is strongly entangled . on the other hand , the regular low - energy part of the entropic spectrum tends to a minimal value @xmath440 , corresponding to states with a good parity quantum number @xcite . , @xmath69 ( cf.fig.[f_wav]e ) and ( b ) the factorized @xmath441 eigenstate for @xmath68 . the other parameters are the same as in fig.[f_sdelta ] . ] an interesting aspect of the entropic spectra in fig.[f_sdelta ] is the evolution of the atom field entanglement in transition between the superradiant and normal phases at the critical energy @xmath318 . for @xmath184 , this energy corresponds to @xmath173 for @xmath442 $ ] and to @xmath174 for @xmath443 . we know that in the @xmath63 limit , there always exists the fully factorized trivial eigenstate with @xmath444 located right at this energy and a group of weakly entangled eigenstates with low values of @xmath108 located nearby ( see figs.[f_pileup ] and [ f_detun ] ) . to what extent do these structures survive an increase of parameter @xmath64 ? the answer can be read out from fig.[f_sdelta ] . we see that the eigenstates with lowered entropy and even a single state with @xmath445 are preserved in the entropic spectra as far as the tc phase is present for the chosen value of the coupling strength @xmath18 . this is so if @xmath446 , hence @xmath447 , see eq .. if @xmath448 $ ] , that is for @xmath64 large enough to avoid the existence of the tc phase for a given @xmath18 , the decrease of entropy no longer takes place . these observations allow us to say that the occurrence of states with lowered atom field entanglement entropy is a signature of the esqpt between the n and tc phases , but not of that between the n and d phases . the wave function corresponding to the @xmath449 eigenstate with the lowest entanglement entropy for @xmath94 can be seen in panel ( e ) of fig.[f_wav ] . its detail is depicted in panel ( a ) of fig.[f_wavdet ] , in comparison with the fully factorized state with @xmath312 shown in panel ( b ) . although the fine structures of the wave function for @xmath184 ( panel a ) apparently disable its full factorization ( in contrast to the @xmath63 case ) , a distant view in fig.[f_wav]e makes clear that this state is indeed very similar to the @xmath312 state . following our findings for @xmath63 , one might expect an analogous decrease of the atom field entanglement entropy also at the critical energy @xmath175 ( in transition between the s and n phases ) in a detuned ( @xmath132 ) system with @xmath184 . a numerical evidence of this phenomenon is however hindered by the above - presented ( cf . the inset in fig.[f_entrotc]b ) slowness of the decrease of the entanglement entropy dip to zero . to see an effect in the @xmath184 system , one would have to perform a truncated - space diagonalization of the hamiltonian for a very large value of @xmath1 , which is computationally demanding . model with @xmath66 , @xmath214 , @xmath296 , @xmath97 . the contribution of selected @xmath108-subspaces ( the u - shaped chains of points ) is highlighted . ] for @xmath214 , @xmath66 , @xmath296 , @xmath97 . the concurrence spectra contain 5000 well converged states . ] we turn now to a brief numerical analysis of the atom atom entanglement , which is limited to the symmetric @xmath37 subspace of the atomic hilbert space . as in the previous case , we focus at first on the integrable tavis - cummings model . the scaled concurrence for individual eigenstates ( the concurrence spectrum ) of the tuned hamiltonian with @xmath63 and @xmath409 is plotted in fig.[f_concint ] . the highlighted points denote states belonging to selected @xmath108-subspaces . like in the entropic spectrum ( fig.[f_pileup ] ) , the states corresponding the same @xmath108-subspace form a pattern which is always symmetric with respect to the reflection around the central energy @xmath118 . trivially , the @xmath312 state @xmath406 has zero concurrence as the atomic state with minimal quasi - spin projection is fully factorized ( all atoms in the lower level ) . so this state shows no entanglement in either atom field or atom atom sense . in contrast , some states with low values of @xmath108 , which all have only weak ( increasing with @xmath108 ) atom field entanglement , show relatively large ( decreasing with @xmath108 ) atom atom entanglement . consider as an example a doublet of states with @xmath313 . the scaled concurrence for these states is @xmath450 , which changes between @xmath451 for @xmath387 and the maximal value @xmath382 for @xmath192 ( see the upper pair of points in fig.[f_concint ] ) . as follows from eq . , the @xmath313 eigenstates are expressed by the superpositions @xmath452 , whose first term is fully factorized in the atomic subspace ( as in the @xmath312 case ) while the second term is maximally entangled ( a symmetric state with one atom in the upper level and the rest of atoms in the lower level ) . it turns out that for increasing @xmath453 , only the states with the largest positive and negative slopes within the given @xmath108-subspace yield a non - vanishing atom atom entanglement . these states form the feelers of the u - shaped dependences of @xmath373 in each @xmath108-subspace . the scaled concurrence of these states decreases with @xmath108 , forming together the left and right chains of @xmath454 points in fig.[f_concint ] . the rest of the @xmath63 eigenstates has @xmath381 . figure [ f_cdelta ] shows an evolution of the concurrence spectrum with increasing @xmath64 for a fixed @xmath455 . apparently , an overall trend of the atom atom entanglement in individual eigenstates is a decrease with increasing @xmath64 . we stress that the concurrence of an absolute majority of states for any @xmath64 is zero ( the spectrum contains 5000 states ) and both the number of states with @xmath454 and the values of @xmath373 in these states further decrease with @xmath64 . the only states in which the atom atom entanglement remains significant even for a relatively large values of @xmath64 appear in a narrow energy interval around the esqpt critical energy @xmath174 demarcating the transition between the tc and n phases . these states partly coincide with those in which we previously observed a reduced atom field entanglement , see fig.[f_sdelta ] . for @xmath64 large enough to avoid the existence of the tc phase , the atom atom entanglement of all states vanishes . model with @xmath456 for two values of @xmath64 . the number of principal components of an actual eigenstate in the unperturbed basis is encoded in the shades of gray of the respective line ( black means perfect localization , @xmath457 , white complete delocalization , @xmath458 ) . revival of some @xmath459 eigenstates at @xmath460 is seen in both spectra . ] we analyzed properties of a generalized dicke model of single - mode superradiance allowing for a continuous ( governed by parameter @xmath64 ) crossover between the integrable tavis - cummings limit and the prevailingly chaotic dicke limit . we considered three constraints on the model hilbert space @xmath461 , namely : ( i ) the all-@xmath25 model with the full @xmath462 containing the complete @xmath26-dimensional atomic hilbert space @xmath35 , ( ii ) a single-@xmath25 model whose atomic hilbert space is restricted to a subspace @xmath463 with fixed quasi - spin quantum number @xmath25 ( usually @xmath37 ) and ( iii ) a single-@xmath464 model with only a single subspace @xmath465 of quantity @xmath108 , which is conserved in the integrable limit @xmath63 . we determined the classical limit and critical properties of the model . the all-@xmath25 model has @xmath42 degrees of freedom , the single-@xmath25 model @xmath40 and the single-@xmath464 model @xmath170 . the thermal phase diagram of the all-@xmath25 model for @xmath197 shows a coexistence of the tc and d types of superradiant phase ( with and without saddles in the free energy landscape ) , which contract to a single type tc or d in the limits @xmath63 or 1 , respectively . the quantum phase diagram of a single-@xmath25 model contains the ground - state superradiant quantum phase transition and three types of excited - state quantum phase transitions , characterized by singularities ( jumps and a logarithmic divergence ) in the first derivative of the semiclassical level density as a function of energy . the quantum phase diagram of a critical single-@xmath464 model with @xmath301 shows in the detuned case ( @xmath132 ) an excited - state quantum phase transition characterized by a singularity ( logarithmic divergence ) directly in the level density . we defined the spectral domains in between the esqpt critical borderlines of the single-@xmath25 model as the tc , d , n and s quantum phases . these phases were characterized by different shapes of a smoothed energy dependence of some expectation values , which show abrupt changes at the esqpt energies . a natural choice of the phase - defining quantity is the interaction hamiltonian , whose expectation value @xmath466 determines the slope @xmath467 of the given level @xmath326 . according to the density flow relation of the esqpt signatures @xcite , a smoothed level slope should exhibit the same type of non - analyticity as the semiclassical level density . therefore , quantum phases of systems with @xmath40 ( like our single-@xmath25 model ) are distinguished by @xmath468 , while phases in other systems are expected to differ in the @xmath469th energy derivative of @xmath470 . we analyzed entanglement properties of the single-@xmath25 and single-@xmath464 models . in general , an absolute majority of eigenstates in the spectrum for any choice of model parameters has large atom field entanglement but vanishing atom atom entanglement . exceptional in this sense for @xmath63 are the eigenstates with low values of @xmath108 , which yield a weak atom field entanglement and simultaneously an increased atom atom entanglement . we showed that remnants of these states exist relatively far in the non - integrable regime with @xmath184 . this concerns also the @xmath63 state with @xmath312 located at the esqpt energy @xmath174 , which has zero atom field entanglement . for @xmath132 , a state with reduced atom field entanglement entropy , originating in the critical @xmath301 subspace , exists also at the esqpt energy @xmath175 . a numerical evidence of its partial survival for @xmath184 is however difficult because of the observed slow decrease of the entropy dip with the size parameter @xmath1 . it needs to be stressed that the above states with exceptional entanglement properties form only a small subset of all states ( its relative size goes to zero in the @xmath388 limit ) . even so is their occurrence a significant phenomenon . the remnants of the @xmath63 states with low @xmath108 s appear in the range of parameter @xmath64 where the tc quantum phase still exists in the spectrum . so if @xmath64 is fixed at a non - zero value and the coupling strength @xmath18 increases from 0 to values above @xmath402 and @xmath471 , these states exhibit a surprising evolution . they first ( not later than at @xmath402 ) disappear from the spectrum , but later above the critical coupling ( somewhere in the @xmath472 region ) some of them reappear again . indeed , a systematic analysis of the spectrum discloses approximate revivals of a number of weak - coupling ( @xmath414 ) eigenstates in the strong - coupling ( @xmath473 ) regime . this is illustrated in fig.[f_fog ] where we again show spectra of the tuned model with @xmath37 for two values of @xmath64 . the fullness ( shade of gray ) of each level encodes the number of principal components @xmath474 of the corresponding hamiltonian eigenstate @xmath475 in the eigenbasis @xmath476 taken at @xmath477 infinitesimally displaced from the degeneracy point @xmath320 . the number of principal components varies from @xmath478 for a perfectly localized state ( identical with one of the @xmath479 eigenstates ) to @xmath480 for totally delocalized states . the revival of several @xmath479 eigenstates is clearly observed in fig.[f_fog ] as reappearance of certain dark lines in the spectrum for large @xmath18 in the tc and n phases . one can only speculate that the mechanism responsible for this surprising phenomenon can be perhaps related to a specific partial dynamical symmetry @xcite . the authors thank to t.brandes , n.lambert , j.hirsch and m.a.bastarrachea-magnani for illuminating discussions . this work was supported by the czech science foundation under the project no.p203 - 13 - 07117s . dicke , phys . rev . * 93 * , 99 ( 1954 ) . m. gross and s. haroche , phys . rep . * 93 * , 301 ( 1982 ) . benedict ( ed . ) , _ super - radiance : multiatomic coherent emission _ , taylor & francis , new york , 1996 . t. brandes , phys . rep . * 408 * , 315 ( 2005 ) . bekenstein and m. schiffer , phys . d * 58 * , 064014 ( 1998 ) . n. auerbach and v. zelevinsky , _ rev . phys . _ * 74 * 106301 ( 2011 ) . jaynes and f.w . cummings , proc . ieee * 51 * , 89 ( 1963 ) . m. tavis and f.w . cummings , phys . rev . * 170 * , 379 ( 1968 ) . wang and f.t . hioe , phys . rev . a * 7 * , 831 ( 1973 ) . k. hepp and e.h . lieb , phys . rev . a * 8 * , 2517 ( 1973 ) . k. hepp and e.h . lieb , ann . * 76 * , 360 ( 1973 ) . k. rzazewski , k. wodkiewicz and w. zakowicz , phys . 35 * , 432 ( 1975 ) . k. baumann , c. guerlin , f. brennecke and t. esslinger , nature * 464 * , 1301 ( 2010 ) k. baumann , r. mottl , f. brennecke and t. esslinger , phys . lett . * 107 * , 140402 ( 2011 ) p. prez - fernndez , p. cejnar , j.m . arias , j. dukelsky , j. e. garca - ramos and a. relao , phys . rev . a * 83 * , 033802 ( 2011 ) . p. prez - fernndez , a. relao , j.m . arias , p. cejnar , j. dukelsky and j. e. garca - ramos , phys . e * 83 * , 046208 ( 2011 ) . t. brandes , phys . e * 88 * , 032133 ( 2013 ) . bastarrachea - magnani , s. lerma - hernndez and j.g . hirsch , phys . rev . a * 89 * , 032101 , 032102 ( 2014 ) . p. cejnar , m. macek , s. heinze , j. jolie and j. dobe , j. phys . a * 39 * , l515 ( 2006 ) . caprio , p. cejnar and f. iachello , ann . ( n.y . ) * 323*,1106 ( 2008 ) . p. cejnar and p. strnsk , phys . e * 78 * , 031130 ( 2008 ) . p. strnsk , m. macek and p. cejnar , ann . phys . * 345 * , 73 ( 2014 ) . p. strnsk , m. macek , a. leviatan and p. cejnar , ann . phys . * 356 * , 57 ( 2015 ) . p. strnsk and p. cejnar , phys . a * 380 * , 2637 ( 2016 ) . p. cejnar and p. strnsk , phys . * 91 * ( 2016 ) 083006 . a. osterloh , l. amico , g. falci and r. fazio , nature * 416 * , 608 ( 2002 ) . j. vidal , g. palacois and r. mosseri , phys . a * 69 * , 022107 ( 2004 ) . j. vidal , r. mosseri and j. dukelsky , phys . a * 69 * , 054101 ( 2004 ) . n. lambert , c. emary and t. brandes , phys . lett . * 92 * , 073602 ( 2004 ) . n. lambert , c. emary , and t. brandes , phys . a * 71 * , 053804 ( 2005 ) . p. cejnar and j. jolie , phys . e * 58 * , 387 ( 1998 ) . p. cejnar and p. strnsk , aip conf . proc . * 1575 * , 23 ( 2014 ) . m.a . bastarrachea - magnani , b. lpez - del - carpio , s. lerma - hernndez and j.g . hirsch , phys . a * 90 * , 068015 ( 2015 ) . bastarrachea - magnani , b. lpez - del - carpio , j. chvez - carlos , s. lerma - hernndez and j.g . hirsch , phys . e * 93 * , 022215 ( 2016 ) . j. chvez - carlos , m.a . bastarrachea - magnani , s. lerma - hernndez and j.g . hirsch ( to be published ) ; see arxiv:1604.00725 [ nlin.cd ] ( 2016 ) . bastarrachea - magnani , s. lerma - hernndez and j.g . hirsch ( to be published ) ; see arxiv:1605.05357 [ quant - ph ] ( 2016 ) . a. peres , phys . rev . lett . * 53 * , 1711 ( 1984 ) . p. strnsk , p. hruka and p. cejnar , phys . e * 79 * , 066201 ( 2009 ) . a. peres , phys . * 77 * , 1413 ( 1996 ) . bennett , d. divincenzo , j. smolin and w.k . wooters , phys . a * 53 * , 3824 ( 1996 ) . s. hill and w.k . wootters , phys . * 78 * ( 1997 ) 5022 . wootters , phys . * 80 * ( 1998 ) 2245 . x. wang and k. mlmer , eur . j. d * 18 * 385 ( 2002 ) , x. wang and b.c . sanders , phys . a * 68 * , 012101 ( 2003 ) . s. heinze , p. cejnar , j. jolie and m. macek , phys . c * 73 * 014306 ( 2006 ) . y. alhassid and a. leviatan , j. phys . a : math . gen . * 25 * , l1265 ( 1992 ) . a. leviatan , prog . . phys . * 66 * , 93 ( 2011 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: [ sec : intro ] an impressive amount of data on backward hadron production in p+c interactions has been collected over the past four decades . a literature survey reveals no less than 19 experiments which have contributed a total amount of more than 3500 data points covering wide areas in projectile momentum , lab angle and lab momentum . looking at the physics motivation and at the distribution in time of these efforts , two distinct classes of experimental approaches become evident . 15 experiments cluster in a first period during the two decades between 1970 and 1990 . all these measurements have been motivated by the nuclear part of proton - nucleus collisions , in particular by the width of the momentum distributions in the nuclear rest system which reach far beyond the narrow limits expected from nuclear binding alone . these studies have ceased in the late 1980 s with the advent of relativistic heavy ion collisions and their promise of `` new '' phenomena beyond the realm of classic nuclear physics . a second class of very recent measurements has appeared and is being pursued after the turn of the century , with publications starting about 2008 . here the motivation is totally different . it is driven by the necessity of obtaining hadronic reference data for the study of systematic effects in cosmic ray and neutrino physics , in particular concerning atmospheric and long base line experiments as well as eventual novel neutrino factories . the main aim of these studies is the comparison to and the improvement of hadronic production models models which are to be considered as multi - parameter descriptions of the non - calculable sector of the strong interaction , with very limited predictive power . this new and exclusive aim has led to the strange situation that if all recent publications contain detailed comparisons to available production models , no comparison to existing data is attempted . it remains therefore unclear how these new results compare to the wealth of already available data and whether they in fact may over - ride and replace the existing results . in this environment the studies conducted since 15 years by the na49 experiment at the cern sps have a completely different aim . here it is attempted to trace a model - independent way from the basic hadron - nucleon interaction via hadron - nucleus to nucleus - nucleus collisions . this aim needs precision data from a large variety of projectile and target combinations as well as a maximum phase space coverage . as the acceptance of the na49 detector is limited to lab angles below 45 degrees , it is indicated to use existing backward data in the sps energy range in order to extend the acceptance coverage for the asymmetric proton - nucleus interactions . this requires a careful study of the dependence on cms energy and of the reliability of the results to be used . in the course of this work it appeared useful and even mandatory to provide a survey of all available data over the full scale of interaction energies , the more so as no overview of the experimental situation is available to date . this means that the present study deals with projectile momenta from 1 to 400 gev / c , for a lab angle range from 10 to 180 degrees , and for lab momenta from 0.2 to 1.2 gev / c . [ sec : var_kin ] most available data have been obtained as a function of the lab momentum @xmath8 ( or kinetic energy @xmath9 ) at constant lab angle @xmath10 . in this publication all given yields are transformed to the double differential invariant cross section @xmath11 in this context the term `` backward '' needs a precise definition . one possibility would be to define as `` backward '' the region of lab angles @xmath12 90 degrees . the present paper uses instead a definition which refers to the cms frame with the basic variables feynman @xmath13 and transverse momentum @xmath14 , defining as `` backward '' the particle yields at @xmath15 0 . this allows a clear separation of the projectile fragmentation region at positive @xmath13 with a limited feed - over into negative @xmath13 and the target fragmentation region at negative @xmath13 with a limited feed - over into positive @xmath13 . at the same time the notion of `` kinematic limit '' in participant fragmentation is clearly brought out at @xmath13 = @xmath16 1 and the contributions from intranuclear cascading may be clearly visualized and eventually separated . and @xmath10 in the cms frame spanned by feynman @xmath13 and @xmath14 for protons and pions at two different projectile momenta , a ) protons at 158 gev / c , b ) protons at 3 gev / c , c ) pions at 158 gev / c and d ) pions at 3 gev / c , width=510 ] the correlation between the two pairs of variables is presented in fig . [ fig : kinematics ] which shows lines of constant @xmath8 and @xmath10 in the coordinate frame of @xmath13 and @xmath14 for protons and pions for the two values of projectile momentum at 158 and 3 gev / c which are representative of the typical range of interaction energies discussed in this paper . several comments are due in this context . the definition of feynman @xmath13 has been modified from the standard one , @xmath17 to @xmath18 with @xmath19 the proton mass . this takes care of baryon number conservation and regularises the kinematic borders at low interaction energies . the @xmath20 dependence in fig . [ fig : kinematics ] is small to negligible for lab angles above about 50 degrees both for pions and protons but becomes noticeable at small @xmath10 . if at sps energy the full range of lab momenta up to 1.4 gev / c and angles above 10 degrees is confined to the backward region both for protons and pions , the coverage for pions extends to positive @xmath13 at low lab angles and low beam momenta . another remark concerns the overlap between target fragmentation and nuclear cascading . for protons , at all lab angles above about 70 degrees the kinematic limit for fragmentation of a target nucleon at rest in the lab system is exceeded . for pions on the other hand this is not the case as their @xmath13 value for @xmath8 = 0 is at @xmath21 this means that over the full range of lab angles and up to large @xmath8 values the contribution from target participants mixes with the nuclear component . the separation of the two processes therefore becomes an important task , see sect . [ sec : separation ] of this paper . a last remark is due to the limits of experimental coverage . all existing experiments run out of statistics at cross section levels of about 10 @xmath22b , that is about 4 orders of magnitude below the maximum yields . as visible from the momentum ranges indicated in tables 1 and 2 , this corresponds to a typical upper momentum cut - off in the region of 1 gev / c . [ sec : exp_sit ] the backward phase space coverage in p+c interactions is surprisingly complete if compared with the forward direction and even with the available data in the elementary p+p collisions . this is apparent from the list of experiments given in tables [ tab : prot_data ] and [ tab : pion_data ] with their ranges in beam momentum , lab angle , and lab momentum . although some effort has been spent to pick up all published results , this list is not claimed to be exhaustive as some results given as `` private communication '' , in conference proceedings or unpublished internal reports might have escaped attention . .data sets for proton production in p+c and n+c collisions from seven experiments giving the ranges covered in projectile momentum , lab angle , and lab momentum , the number of measured data points and errors [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] for secondary protons , table [ tab : prot_data ] , the important amount of low energy n+c data by franz et al . @xcite has been added to the survey as the isospin factors for the transformation into p+c results have been studied and determined with some precision , see sect . [ sec : prot ] . for secondary pions , table [ tab : pion_data ] , the situation is somewhat complicated by the fact that two independent sets of results have been published by the harp - cdp @xcite and the harp @xcite groups , based on identical input data obtained with the same detector . an attempt to clarify this partially contradictory situation is presented in sect . [ sec : harp ] of this paper . unfortunately , no commonly agreed scale in the three basic variables @xmath10 , @xmath8 and @xmath23 of the double - differential cross sections has been defined by the different collaborations providing the data contained in tables [ tab : prot_data ] and [ tab : pion_data ] . this leads to the fact that not a single couple out of the more than 3500 data points contained in these tables may be directly compared . the application of an interpolation scheme as described in sect . [ sec : comp ] is therefore an absolute necessity . ideally the thus obtained interpolated cross sections would form an internally consistent sample of results which would be coherent within the given experimental errors . as will become apparent in the following data comparison , this assumption is surprisingly well fulfilled for the majority of the experiments . only four of the 20 quoted groups of results fall significantly out of this comparison ; those will be discussed in sect . [ sec : dev_exp ] of this paper . in this sense the overall survey of the backward proton and pion production results in a powerful constraint for the comparison with any new data sample . [ sec : comp ] as stated above the main problem in bringing the wealth of available data into a consistent picture is given by the generally disparate position in phase space and interaction energy of the different experiments . the triplet of lab variables given by the beam momentum @xmath23 , the lab momentum @xmath8 and the lab angle @xmath10 has been used for the establishment of the following interpolation scheme . in addition and of course , the statistical and systematic errors have to be taken into account in the data comparison . [ sec : errors ] the last columns of tables [ tab : prot_data ] and [ tab : pion_data ] contain some information about the statistical and systematic errors of the different experiments . the given numbers are to be regarded as mean values excluding some upward tails as they are inevitable at the limits of the covered phase space in particular for the statistical uncertainties . in some cases only rudimentary information about the systematic errors is available or the systematic and statistical errors are even combined into one quantity . in the latter cases these values are given in between the respective columns of table [ tab : pion_data ] . inspection of these approximate error levels reveals a rather broad band of uncertainties ranging from about 4% to about 20% , the latter limit being generally defined by overall normalization errors . the presence of extensive data sets well below the 10% range of both statistical and systematic errors gives however some hope that a resulting overall consistency on this level might become attainable by the extensive use of data interpolation . the term `` interpolation '' is to be regarded in this context as a smooth interconnection of the data points in any of the three phase space variables defined above . this interconnection is generally done by eyeball fits which offer , within the error limits shown above , sufficient accuracy . if the distributions in @xmath10 and interaction energy are anyway not describable by straight - forward arithmetic parametrization , the @xmath8 dependences are , as discussed in sect . [ sec : pldep ] below , in a majority of cases approximately exponential . in these cases exponential fits have been used if applicable . as additional constraint physics asks of course for smoothness and continuity in all three variables simultaneously . therefore the resulting overall data interpolation has to attempt a three - dimensional consistency . if the data interpolation helps , by the inter - correlation of data points , to reduce the local statistical fluctuations , it does of course not reduce the systematic uncertainties . it is rather on the level of systematic deviations that the consistency of different experimental results is to be judged . it will become apparent from the detailed discussion described below that the majority of the quoted experiments allows for the establishment of a surprisingly consistent overall description in all three variables . [ sec : sdep ] as the data discussed here span an extremely wide range of cms energy from close to production threshold to the upper range of fermilab energies , a suitable compression of the energy scale has been introduced in order to be able to present the results in a close - to - equidistant fashion against energy . the form chosen here is the variable @xmath24 . this choice is suggested by the considerable amount of work invested in studying the approach of hadronic cross sections to the scaling limit at high energy in the 1970 s @xcite . in fact the regge parametrization suggested a smooth dependence of the cross sections as @xmath25 , with @xmath26 = 0.250.5 depending on the choice of trajectories involved . such behaviour was indeed found experimentally . in the present study the cross sections turn out to have only a mild @xmath24 dependence for @xmath27 5 gev , a dependence which is however different for pions and protons . this dependence is strongly modified below @xmath28 2.5 gev due to threshold effects . [ sec : thdep ] a convenient and often used scale for the lab angle dependence is given by @xmath29 . this scale has the advantage of producing shapes that are again to zero order exponential . of course , continuity through @xmath10 = 180 degrees imposes an approach to 180 degrees with tangent zero . as the data samples are generally not measured at common values of @xmath10 , a fixed grid of angles has been defined based on the @xmath10 values of the harp - cdp experiment @xcite dominating the range from 25 to 112 degrees . measured values down to 10 degrees and in the higher angular range at 137 , 160 , and 180 degrees have been added . measurements not corresponding to these grid values are interpolated using the @xmath29 distributions specified below . [ sec : pldep ] all data discussed here have been transformed into invariant cross sections ( [ eq : ddcs ] ) . this facilitates the presentation in different coordinate systems and eliminates the trivial approach of the phase space element to zero with decreasing momentum . in addition , most of the invariant @xmath8 distributions are close to exponential within the measured @xmath8 range . there are notable deviations mostly at low momentum and in the lower ( higher ) range of lab angles for pions and protons , respectively , as well as in the approach to threshold . in these cases an eyeball fit has been used which can be reliably performed within the error margins indicated above . at low lab momenta physics requires a deviation from the exponential shape as the invariant cross sections must approach @xmath8 = 0 with tangent zero . this limit appears in general at @xmath30 0.2 gev / c for pions and @xmath30 0.5 gev / c for protons . the data presented here fall practically all above these momentum limits . only the harp experiment @xcite gives results at @xmath8 = 0.125 gev / c for pions where indeed a substantial deviation from the exponential shape is visible . this is shown in fig . [ fig : first_point ] where the deviation from exponential fits at this @xmath8 is given in percent for all angles and beam momenta together with similar deviations observed in p+p interactions @xcite . = 0.125 gev / c from the exponential fits for @xmath31 and @xmath32 at all angles and beam momenta , b ) deviation of @xmath31 cross sections at @xmath14 = 0.125 gev / c from exponential fits to the higher @xmath14 region in p+p interactions as a function of @xmath13,width=453 ] a number of examples of momentum distributions for protons and pions is given in the following figs . [ fig : pldist_harpcdp ] and [ fig : plabex ] which show the invariant cross sections as a function of @xmath8 and the corresponding exponential fits @xmath33 which are , whenever necessary , supplemented by hand interpolations into the non - exponential regions . a first group of distributions in the medium angular range at 45 and 97 degrees is presented in fig . [ fig : pldist_harpcdp ] for the harp - cdp data concerning protons and pions , including exponential fits . and @xmath32 as a function of @xmath8 at @xmath10 = 45 and 97 degrees . full lines : exponential fits . broken line : hand - interpolation into the non - exponential region , width=529 ] evidently the exponential shape is within errors in general a good approximation to the momentum dependence . more quantitative information is contained in the normalized residual distributions of the data points , @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the difference between data and fit and sigma the statistical error of the given data point . should the fit describe the physics and should systematic effects be negligible , the distribution of @xmath36 is expected to be gaussian with rms equal to unity . the @xmath36 distributions are given for the totality of the harp - cdp data in fig . [ fig : diff_dist ] . these distributions are well described by centred gaussians . the resulting rms values are however somewhat bigger than one signalling systematic experimental effects or a deviation of physics from the simple exponential parametrization . in view of the statistical errors of 4% to 6% given by harp - cdp ( tables [ tab : prot_data ] and [ tab : pion_data ] ) these deviations are on the level of a few percent which is below the error margin to be anyway expected from the present general data survey . further examples of @xmath8 distributions from other experiments are given in fig . [ fig : plabex ] for a selection of particle type , beam momenta and angles . for a variety of particle type , lab angle and beam momenta including exponential fits ( full lines ) and , when necessary , eyeball fits into the non - exponential regions of @xmath8 ( broken lines).,width=529 ] again the basically exponential shape of these distributions is evident . characterizing the exponential fits by their inverse slopes @xmath37 a smooth and distinct dependence on lab angle and beam momentum becomes visible as shown in fig . [ fig : inverse ] . as a function of @xmath10 for four beam momenta from 3 to 158 gev / c , a ) for protons , b ) for @xmath31 and c ) for @xmath32 . the full lines are drawn to guide the eye ] compared to the strong dependence of b on @xmath10 which ranges from 0.3 to 0.05 gev / c , the only modest dependence on @xmath23 of @xmath380.03 gev / c for beam momenta from 3 to 158 gev / c is noticeable . following the above data parametrization a generalized grid of @xmath8 values between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c , in steps of 0.1 gev / c , may now be established . concerning the lower and upper limits of this grid , an extrapolation beyond the limits given by the experimental values has been performed in some cases . this extrapolation does not exceed the bin width of the respective data lists and is therefore defendable in view of the generally smooth , gentle and well - defined @xmath8 dependences . [ sec : ph ] in the absence of theoretical predictability in the soft sector of the strong interaction , any attempt at bringing a multitude of experimental results into a common and consistent picture has to rely on a minimal set of model - independent physics constraints . in fact a `` democratic '' averaging of eventually contradictory data sets would only add confusion instead of clarity . [ sec : ph1 ] two examples of the continuity constraint have already been mentioned above : invariant @xmath8 distributions have to approach zero momentum horizontally that is with tangent zero . the same is true for angular distributions in their approach to 180 degrees . [ sec : ph2 ] it is a matter of experimental experience in the realm of soft hadronic interactions that in general distributions in any kind of kinematic variable tend to be `` smooth '' in the sense of absence of abrupt local upwards or downwards variations . the widespread use of simple algebraic parametrizations has its origin in this fact , specifically in the absence of local maxima and minima , with the eventual exception of threshold behaviour of which some examples will become visible below . [ sec : ph3 ] charge conservation has of course to be fulfilled by any type of experimental result . this means for instance that for the interaction of a positively charged projectile ( proton ) with an isoscalar nucleus ( carbon ) the @xmath39 ratio has to be greater or equal to unity over the full phase space invoking isospin symmetry ( and of course the experience from a wide range of experimental results ) . the presence of data with @xmath40 1 therefore immediately indicates experimental problems . the inspection of @xmath39 ratios has the further advantage that a large part of the systematic uncertainties , notably the overall normalization errors , cancel in this ratio . [ sec : ph4 ] it has been shown that in proton induced nuclear collisions the yields of the secondary protons and neutrons are related by a constant factor of about 2 which is in turn related to the ratio of the basic nucleon - nucleon interaction @xcite . similarly , when rotating the projectile isospin from proton to neutron , it has been predicted that the yield ratio of secondary protons from proton and neutron projectiles @xmath41 should be constant and equal to 2.5 for light nuclei @xcite . the extensive and precise low - energy data set of franz et al . @xcite from n+c interactions has therefore been included in the present survey . these data present a welcome extension of the @xmath24 scale into the region 0.47 to 0.49 which is not covered for most of the angular range with proton projectiles . as shown below , these data fit indeed very well , after re - normalization , into the general @xmath24 dependence of secondary protons where the low energy data by frankel et al . @xcite and komarov et al . @xcite at angles between 112 and 180 degrees provide an independent control of the normalization . [ sec : ph5 ] with these constraints in mind , and having established the parametrization and interpolation of the @xmath8 distributions as discussed above , one may now proceed to the attempt at sorting the 19 available experiments into a consistent global data set . it would of course be rather surprising if all experiments would fit into this global picture within their respective error limits . in fact it turns out that this procedure establishes a very strong constraint for possible deviations , as a large majority of results is creating a perfectly consistent picture both for protons and for pions . only four of the 19 data sets can not be brought into consistency with all other experiments without gravely affecting and contradicting the above constraints . these data are not included in the following global interpolation scheme . they will be discussed separately in sect . [ sec : dev_exp ] below . [ sec : prot ] [ sec : prot_sdep ] the invariant proton cross sections are shown in fig . [ fig : oneoversq ] as a function of @xmath24 for a grid of ten lab angles between 25 and 180 degrees and constant lab momenta between 0.3 and 1.2 gev / c . the interpolated data points in each panel are identified by symbols corresponding to the different experiments . at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath10 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the interpolation of the data , width=268 ] at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath10 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the interpolation of the data , width=268 ] the solid lines are eyeball interpolations through the data points . a first remark concerning this figure concerns the smoothness and continuity of the @xmath24 dependences . the achieved overall consistency of all data is rather impressive even if single points are deviating in some areas of phase space . the salient features of the physics contained in these plots may be summarized as follows : * a strong yield suppression between 1/@xmath28 0.45 and the elastic limit at @xmath24 = 0.53 is evident . * the n+c data @xcite are well consistent with the p+c results in the overlap regions ; they define a broad maximum of the cross sections at 1/@xmath28 0.46 at medium angles and low @xmath8 . * there is a well - defined asymptotic behaviour of the cross sections for @xmath24 below about 0.2 or beam momenta above about 12 gev / c . * for the lower @xmath10 region and/or low @xmath8 the asymptotic region is approached from above . the latter point is reminiscent of the behaviour of the proton yields in p+p interactions , as shown in fig . [ fig : oneoversq_pp ] . for p+p interactions at the four lab angles a ) 25 , b ) 35 , c ) 45 and d ) 55 degrees for @xmath8 values from 0.4 to 1 gev / c . the data are interpolated from blobel @xcite and na49 @xcite . the lines are drawn to guide the eye ] another feature of fig . [ fig : oneoversq ] is the systematic droop of the cross sections from harp - cdp at their highest beam momentum of 15 gev / c or @xmath24 = 0.18 , demonstrating the discriminative power of the approach . this decrease is quantified in fig . [ fig : harp15_prot ] where the ratio @xmath43 between the measured invariant cross sections and the data interpolation is shown as a function of @xmath8 for the complete angular range from 25 to 97 degrees . here deviations of up to 50% are visible . between the interpolated invariant proton cross sections from harp - cdp @xcite and the global interpolation as a function of @xmath8 for the angular range 25 @xmath44 97 degrees ] the abruptness of this decrease would necessitate a rather violent variation of the cross sections with increasing energy including a minimum between ps and sps energies . a final clarification of this situation is given by the proton data from serpukhov @xcite which , although suffering from a different and independent problem , at least exclude such variations in the region between 17 and 67 gev / c beam momentum , see sect . [ sec : belyaev ] below . [ sec : prot_thdep ] in addition to the description of the energy dependence , the global interpolation has of course also to result in a smooth and continuous verification of the angular dependence presenting the third dimension of the present study . this constraint has to be fulfilled at any value of @xmath24 . in a first example the situation at @xmath24 = 0.05 is shown in fig . [ fig : pc_prot_theta ] . this value lies in between the fermilab @xcite and na49 @xcite data in the region of negligible @xmath20-dependence . it therefore allows for the direct comparison of the two experiments in their respective angular regions which have no overlap . = 0.05 as a function of @xmath46 combining the fermilab and na49 data for @xmath8 between 0.2 and 1.4 gev / c . the global interpolation is shown as full lines . the measured cross sections in the angular ranges from 70 to 160 degrees @xcite and from 10 to 40 degrees @xcite are given on the vertical broken lines , width=472 ] several observations are in place here : * the two experimental results connect perfectly through the gap between the na49 ( @xmath47 40 degrees ) and the fermilab ( @xmath48 70 degrees ) data . * there is at most a few percent variation of the cross sections between the angles of 160 and 180 degrees taking into account the constraint of continuity through 180 degrees discussed in sect . [ sec : comp ] above . this allows the combination of results in this angular region as it is applied in the determination of the @xmath24 dependence , fig . [ fig : oneoversq ] . * the angular distributions are smooth and close to exponential in shape . in particular , no instability in the region around 90 degrees is visible where an eventual diffractive peak from target fragmentation would appear , see also @xcite . further angular distributions at four @xmath24 values between 0.1 and 0.4 gev@xmath49 are given in fig . [ fig : costheta ] . in fact such distributions at arbitrary values of @xmath24 may be obtained from the global interpolation as it is presented in numerical form at the na49 web page @xcite . for four values of @xmath24 : a ) 0.1 , b ) 0.2 , c ) 0.3 , d ) 0.4 gev@xmath49 and for @xmath8 values between 0.4 and 1.2 gev / c . the standard grid of 10 angles , fig . [ fig : oneoversq ] , is indicated by the vertical broken lines ] evidently the angular distributions maintain their smooth and continuous shape , specifically through 90 degrees , at all interaction energies . with the approach to low beam momenta however , a progressive rounding of the shape towards higher lab angles manifests itself . [ sec : pip ] the global interpolation of the @xmath31 data is presented in this section in close analogy to the preceding section for protons . [ sec : pip_sdep ] the invariant @xmath31 cross sections are shown in fig . [ fig : sqs_pip ] as a function of @xmath24 for the standard grid of ten lab angles between 25 and 180 degrees and for constant lab momenta between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . the interpolated data points in each panel are identified by symbols corresponding to the different experiments . in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=257 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=257 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=257 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=257 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=257 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=257 ] the solid lines represent the global interpolation by eyeball fits of both the energy and the angular dependences . again the @xmath24 dependence is in general smooth and continuous , with an impressive overall consistency of all data with only few exceptions discussed below . there are some general trends to be pointed out : * at the lowest lab momentum , the pion cross sections are practically @xmath20-independent , with variations of only 1020% in the range from 1 to 400 gev / c beam momentum . * this fact suggests @xmath31 production at low momentum transfer in the nuclear cascade . * for all lab momenta , the approach to high energies is very flat for @xmath51 0.2 or beam momenta above 12 gev / c . * the high energy cross sections are approached for all angles and beam momenta from below . there are two areas of deviation from the global interpolation which are both connected to the harp - cdp data @xcite . at their lowest angle of 25 degrees , the cross sections are systematically low by up to a factor of two below @xmath52 0.5 gev / c and @xmath24 above 0.2 . this is in contradiction to the available low energy data from other experiments also shown in fig . [ fig : sqs_pip ] . the second area concerns , as for the protons , the data at 15 gev / c beam momentum where a characteristic pattern of deviations is visible : at low angles and low @xmath8 , the data tend to overshoot the interpolation , whereas at angles above 45 degrees a progressive droop with increasing lab momentum is evident . this is quantified by the ratio @xmath43 between the harp - cdp data and the global interpolation shown in fig . [ fig : harp15_pip ] . between the interpolated invariant @xmath31 cross sections from harp - cdp @xcite and the global interpolation as a function of @xmath8 for the angular range 25 @xmath53 112 degrees ] these deviations are rather consistent with the ones found for protons . also in this case a rapid variation of the cross sections with increasing beam momentum can be excluded by the comparison with the pion data from the serpukhov experiment @xcite between 17 and 67 gev / c beam momentum , see sect . [ sec : belyaev ] below . [ sec : pip_thdep ] as already shown in sect . [ sec : prot_thdep ] for protons , the angular distributions at @xmath24 = 0.05 , in between the fermilab @xcite and na49 @xcite energies , are presented in fig . [ fig : pc_pip_theta ] . this allows the comparison of the two data sets and their connection across the gap in lab angles between 40 and 70 degrees which represent the upper and lower limit of the respective experiment . cross sections at @xmath24 = 0.05 as a function of @xmath46 combining the fermilab @xcite and na49 @xcite data for @xmath8 between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . the global interpolation is shown as full lines . the measured cross sections in the angular ranges from 70 to 160 degrees ( @xcite ) and from 10 to 40 degrees ( @xcite ) are given on the vertical broken lines , width=472 ] further angular distributions at four @xmath24 values between 0.1 and 0.4 gev@xmath49 are given in fig . [ fig : costheta_pip ] . cross sections as a function of @xmath46 for four values of @xmath24 : a ) 0.1 , b ) 0.2 , c ) 0.3 , d ) 0.4 gev@xmath49 and for @xmath8 values between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . the standard grid of 10 angles , fig . [ fig : oneoversq ] , is indicated by the vertical broken lines ] the angular distributions are characterized by a smooth , close to exponential shape . at backward angles , the @xmath8 dependence is very steep with four orders of magnitude already between @xmath8 = 0.2 and 0.8 gev / c . in forward direction this dependence is much reduced with less than one order of magnitude between @xmath8 = 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . this is due to the prevailance of target fragmentation in this region , see sect . [ sec : separation ] for a quantitative study of this phenomenology . [ sec : pin ] this section follows closely the discussion of the @xmath31 cross sections in the preceding section . [ sec : pin_sdep ] the invariant @xmath32 cross sections are shown in fig . [ fig : sqs_pin ] as a function of @xmath24 for the standard grid of ten lab angles between 25 and 180 degrees and for constant lab momenta between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . the interpolated data points in each panel are identified by symbols corresponding to the different experiments . in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=268 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=268 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=268 ] in p+c collisions as a function of @xmath24 at fixed @xmath8 and @xmath50 . the interpolated data points are indicated by symbols corresponding to the respective experiments in each panel . the solid lines represent the global data interpolation , width=268 ] the solid lines represent the global interpolation by eyeball fits to the data , with several features which are worth noticing : * all the different data sets form a consistent ensemble without the systematic deviations visible in some regions of the proton and @xmath31 results . * the approach to large beam momenta happens from below for all @xmath8 . * the @xmath20-dependence is in general stronger than for @xmath31 , fig . [ fig : sqs_pip ] . if it is again flat up to @xmath54 0.2 at low @xmath8 , it becomes more pronounced both towards higher @xmath8 and in the approach to the production threshold at large @xmath24 indicating a marked increase of the @xmath39 ratio . * this effect has as physics origin the progressive change of the production mechanism from pion exchange at low energy to gluon or pomeron exchange at sps energy . this will be discussed in relation to the charge ratios in sect . [ sec : p2n ] . it is again interesting to compare the energy dependence to the one observed in p+p interactions as presented in fig . [ fig : oneoversq_pp_piminus ] . cross sections as a function of @xmath24 for p+p interactions at the two lab angles a ) 45 , and b ) 55 degrees for @xmath8 values from 0.2 to 1.2 gev / c . the data are interpolated from blobel @xcite and na49 @xcite . the lines are drawn to guide the eye ] although for both reactions the asymptotic high energy region is approached from below , this comparison shows a stronger @xmath20-dependence , at the same lab angle , in p+c than in p+p collisions . this is due to the component of nuclear cascading which contributes , in the given angular range , with equal strength than the target fragmentation to the total yield ( see sect . [ sec : separation ] below ) . [ sec : pin_thdep ] as for protons and @xmath31 in figs . [ fig : pc_prot_theta ] and [ fig : pc_pip_theta ] , the @xmath32 cross sections from the fermilab @xcite and na49 @xcite experiments are compared and combined as a function of @xmath46 in fig . [ fig : pc_pin_theta ] . cross sections at @xmath24= 0.05 as a function of @xmath46 combining the fermilab @xcite and na49 @xcite data for @xmath8 between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . the global interpolation is shown as full lines . the measured cross sections in the angular ranges from 70 to 160 degrees ( @xcite ) and from 10 to 40 degrees ( @xcite ) are given on the vertical broken lines , width=415 ] further angular distributions at four @xmath24 values between 0.1 and 0.4 gev@xmath49 are given in fig . [ fig : costheta_pin ] . cross sections as a function of @xmath46 for four values of @xmath24 : a ) 0.1 , b ) 0.2 , c ) 0.3 , d ) 0.4 gev@xmath49 and for @xmath8 values between 0.2 and 1.2 gev / c . the standard grid of 10 angles , fig . [ fig : oneoversq ] , is indicated by the vertical broken lines , width=529 ] concerning smoothness and continuity these distributions are similar to the @xmath31 data , including the large asymmetry between the forward and backward directions . the reduction of the cross sections for @xmath32 with respect to @xmath31 with increasing @xmath24 is however very apparent . this will be quantified in the following section on @xmath39 ratios . [ sec : p2n ] as already evoked in sect . [ sec : ph3 ] above , the study of @xmath39 ratios has two main advantages . firstly , in this ratio a major fraction of the experimental systematic uncertainties cancels . secondly , the ratio is constrained by very fundamental and model - independent physics arguments like charge conservation and isospin symmetry . in addition , its @xmath20-dependence is governed by the hadronic meson exchange process which leads to a power - law behaviour that will be shown to be common to a wide range of interactions . in the following argumentation the ratio between the global data interpolation for @xmath31 and @xmath32 as described in the preceding sects . [ sec : pip ] and [ sec : pin ] will be used : @xmath56 as a by - product , the fluctuation of this ratio as a function of angle and interaction energy will allow for the estimation of the local precision of the interpolation procedure . [ sec : p2n_high ] it has been established by numerous experimental results that at collision energies in the sps / fermilab range and above the hadronic interactions are characterized by the absence of charge and flavour exchange . it has also been shown that the feed - over of pions from the projectile hemisphere into the backward region of @xmath13 is sharply limited to the range of @xmath57 -0.05 , see @xcite for a detailed discussion . this range is outside the coverage in @xmath10 and @xmath8 considered in this publication . it is therefore to be expected that the backward production of pions off an isoscalar nucleus should be charge - symmetric at high energy . this is indeed verified by the results on pion production shown in the preceding sections . it is quantified in fig . [ fig : costheta_pin ] which shows the @xmath39 ratio at @xmath24 = 0.04 or 330 gev / c beam momentum for all lab angles and lab momenta treated in this publication . this number distribution has a mean value of 1.0125 with an rms deviation of 3.2% . this rms value may be seen as a first estimate of the local precision of the three - dimensional interpolation scheme at this energy which has been established independently for both pion charges . /@xmath32 ratio @xmath58 at @xmath24 = 0.04 gev@xmath49 for 25 @xmath59 162 degrees and 0.2 @xmath60 1.2 gev / c ] [ sec : p2n_endep ] with decreasing interaction energy or increasing @xmath24 the @xmath39 ratio develops a strong increase at all lab momenta and lab angles . this is shown in fig . [ fig : rpm_plab ] which gives @xmath61 as a function of @xmath24 for four lab momenta . the ratio of the global data interpolation is given in steps of 0.02 in @xmath24 . at each value of @xmath24 the number of points corresponds to the standard grid of angles available at this energy . as a function of @xmath24 for four values of @xmath8 . the dots represent the ratio of the global data interpolation for @xmath31 and @xmath32 in steps of 0.02 in @xmath24 and for the chosen grid of 10 angles . a ) @xmath8 = 0.2 , b ) @xmath8 = 0.4 , c ) @xmath8 = 0.6 , d ) @xmath8 = 0.8 gev / c ] several features of fig . [ fig : rpm_plab ] are noteworthy : * considering the wide range of lab angles , @xmath61 is at each value of @xmath24 confined to a narrow band indicating an approximative angle independence . * large @xmath61 values in excess of 5 are reached at the upper limit of the available scale in @xmath24 . * there is a systematic increase of @xmath61 with @xmath8 . [ sec : p2n_high1 ] the features pointed out above may be quantified and at the same time the local systematic fluctuations of the interpolation may be estimated by establishing the mean values @xmath62 averaged over the angular range at each @xmath24 . these mean values are well defined as shown in fig . [ fig : p2n_angdiff ] which presents the normalized distribution of the point - by - point deviations from the mean in percent , @xmath63 for four values of @xmath24 , summing the four @xmath8 values used in fig . [ fig : rpm_plab ] . from the mean over the angular range , a ) @xmath24 = 0.1 , b ) @xmath24 = 0.2 , c ) @xmath24 = 0.3 , d)@xmath24 = 0.4 . the four @xmath8 values shown in fig . [ fig : rpm_plab ] are summed up , width=283 ] these distributions are of gaussian shape with an rms which increases with @xmath24 as indicated in fig . [ fig : sigsqs ] . as a function of @xmath24 . the full line represents a hand interpolation . broken line : corresponding error margin of the mean values @xmath62 . dotted lines : corresponding errors for @xmath31 and @xmath32 separately ] the observed energy dependence of the rms deviations is due to the fact that the invariant pion cross sections decrease , after a relatively flat behaviour up to @xmath54 0.15 , progressively steeper towards the production threshold , see figs . [ fig : sqs_pip ] and [ fig : sqs_pin ] . this leads inevitably to larger variations in the corresponding energy interpolation . from the rms values given in fig . [ fig : sigsqs ] the error of @xmath62 may be derived which varies between 1% and 5% for the highest and lowest interaction energy , respectively ( broken line ) . also the corresponding error margins for the mean pion yields may be extracted as indicated by the dotted lines in fig . [ fig : sigsqs ] . from these plots it appears that the global interpolation induces fluctuations which increase from a few percent in the high @xmath20 region to about 10% in the approach to the pion threshold . [ sec : p2n_high2 ] the dependence of @xmath61 on @xmath10 is shown in fig . [ fig : angdep ] for four values of @xmath24 and four values of @xmath8 . as a function of @xmath10 for four values of @xmath24 , a ) @xmath8 = 0.2 , b ) @xmath8 = 0.4 , c ) @xmath8 = 0.6 , and d ) @xmath8 = 0.8 gev / c . the mean values @xmath62 are indicated as the horizontal broken lines in each panel , width=510 ] evidently no systematic @xmath10 dependence is visible over the complete angular range within the quoted errors . [ sec : p2n_high3 ] in the absence of angular dependence of @xmath61 as shown above , the mean values @xmath62 may now be used in order to establish a precise view of the @xmath24 dependence for different @xmath8 values . this dependence is presented in fig . [ fig : p2n_meanang ] . as a function of @xmath24 for five values of @xmath8 between 0.2 and 1.0 gev / c . the full lines are hand interpolations through the data points ] within the errors of @xmath62 extracted above , a clear @xmath8 dependence is evident superposing itself to the strong common increase of @xmath62 with @xmath24 . this increase may be parametrized up to @xmath54 0.3 by the functional from @xmath64 which is , as discussed below , typical of meson exchange processes . indeed the exponent beta varies from 2 to 1.2 for @xmath8 increasing from 0.2 to 0.8 gev / c . [ sec : p2n_epdep ] the strong increase of @xmath61 with @xmath24 merits a detailed study as it is directly connected to the basic hadronic production mechanisms in p+a interactions . the fact that the pion yields in the complete backward fragmentation region of an isoscalar nucleus remember the isospin of the projectile is clearly incompatible with charge and flavour independent exchange processes . instead a meson exchange mechanism may be invoked which has indeed been used successfully in a wide range of work at low projectile momenta , see for instance @xcite and references therein . close to the pion production threshold in the nuclear hemisphere , single excitation processes via pion exchange of the type @xmath65 only allow @xmath31 and @xmath66 production , whereas @xmath32 production needs double excitation like @xmath67 with in general an additional penalty for @xmath32 due to the isospin clebsch gordan coefficients . all meson exchange mechanisms are characterized by a strong decrease with projectile energy . this energy dependence and its interplay with processes governing the high energy sector is studied here for the first time in p+a collisions using the @xmath39 ratio . in this context it seems mandatory to first refer to the study of exclusive charge exchange reactions in elementary nucleon - nucleon collisions as the complete energy range discussed here has been covered there by a number of experiments @xcite . [ sec : p2n_epdep1 ] charge exchange processes may be cleanly isolated experimentally in nucleon - nucleon interactions by studying the following exclusive channels : * charge exchange scattering of the elastic type + & + + & * single dissociation with pion production + [ eq : single ] & + + ^++ + ( + ^+ ) & * double dissociation with pion production + [ eq : double ] & + ( + ^- ) + ( + ^+ ) & these channels are characterized by a very steep energy dependence . this is to be confronted with non - charge - exchange exclusive channels like : * elastic scattering + & + + & * single dissociation + [ eq : single0 ] & + + ( + ^+ + ^- ) & * double dissociation + [ eq : double0 ] & + ( + ^+ + ^- ) + ( + ^+ + ^- ) & which show a constant or logarithmically increasing @xmath20-dependence . charge exchange scattering has been measured by five experiments in the range of neutron beam momenta from 3 to 300 gev / c . this is exactly covering the energy range discussed in this paper . the single and double dissociation has been studied at the cern isr by two experiments @xcite extending the energy scale to @xmath20 = 3700 gev@xmath68 . the two isr experiments may be directly compared to the charge exchange measurements after appropriate re - normalization of the cross sections in the overlap region at the lowest isr energy . the resulting @xmath20-dependence at a momentum transfer @xmath69 = 0.032 gev@xmath68 is presented in fig . [ fig : chargeexch ] . at a momentum transfer @xmath69 = 0.032 gev@xmath68 . the full line represents an interpolation of the data points . the insert gives the local slope @xmath70 in the parametrization @xmath71 as a function of @xmath20,width=491 ] several features of fig . [ fig : chargeexch ] are of interest : * there is a decrease of about 4 orders of magnitude in cross section between the lowest and highest @xmath20 value . this decrease is to be compared to the constant or logarithmically increasing elastic and nucleon diffraction cross sections . the charge exchange contribution is therefore negligible compared to the inclusive baryon yields already at sps energy . * there is a steady decrease of the local slope @xmath72 with energy , from about 3.6 at 3 gev / c to about 1.1 above 80 gev / c beam momentum . * a characteristic change of slope manifests itself at around 30 gev / c beam momentum . these features have been interpreted in the 1970 s when the relevant experiments were performed , in the framework of regge theory which predicts an @xmath20-dependence of the form @xmath73 where @xmath26 is the intercept of the leading trajectory . this should in the case of one - meson exchange at low energy be given by the pion trajectory with zero intercept . the actual beta values above 3 at low @xmath20 seem to contradict however this expectation . here threshold effects may play a role which are not included in the parametrization ( [ eq : regge ] ) . with increasing energy the slopes move through the region of pion exchange with @xmath74 2 down to values of about 1.1 at high energy which could be connected to @xmath75 and a@xmath76 exchange with correspondingly higher intercepts @xmath26 in the region of 0.5 . at isr energy the ratio of @xmath77 contributions has indeed been estimated to be about 2 @xcite . anyway the simple parametrization given by ( [ eq : regge ] ) should not be expected to hold over the full energy scale . what is interesting here is rather the strong decline of the charge exchange cross sections with energy and the experimentally rather precisely determined slope variation . [ sec : p2n_epdep2 ] the single ( [ eq : single ] ) and double ( [ eq : double ] ) dissociation processes defined above are determined by the formation of @xmath35 resonances in the final states . they therefore constitute a source of direct @xmath35 production in nucleon - nucleon interactions . these channel cross sections decrease rapidly to the @xmath22barn level at sps energies . in contrast , the non - charge exchange channels like ( [ eq : single0 ] ) and ( [ eq : double0 ] ) have no @xmath20-dependence and stay on the mb level of cross sections . their final states have been shown to be governed by n@xmath78 resonances @xcite which may be excited by pomeron exchange . moreover , the p+@xmath31 combination of the p+@xmath31+@xmath32 final states has been shown to be dominated by @xmath79 @xcite . this is an indirect source of @xmath35 resonances as a decay product of n@xmath78 states which have large decay branching fractions into @xmath35+@xmath80 and @xmath35+@xmath75 . it is therefore questionable if , at sps energies and above , any direct @xmath35 production is persisting . this is an interesting question for the majority of microscopic models which produce final states by string fragmentation . in the baryonic sector , diquark fragmentation is generally invoked with a prevailing direct production of @xmath35 resonances which by isospin counting will dominate over n@xmath78 . indeed in practically all such models there is no or only negligible n@xmath78 production . as shown below , the decrease of charge exchange processes can be traced well into the non - diffractive , inelastic region of particle production . the multi - step , cascading decay of primordial n@xmath78 resonances into @xmath35 resonances and final state baryons should therefore be seriously considered , in particular also concerning the consequences for the evolution of final state energy densities with time . [ sec : p2n_epdep3 ] the very characteristic decrease of @xmath62 with increasing @xmath20 derived from the global data interpolation , fig . [ fig : p2n_meanang ] , offers a tempting possibility of comparison to the phenomenology discussed above for the elementary nucleon - nucleon sector . indeed , two components should contribute to the observed @xmath39 ratios : at high energy this ratio should approach unity due to the absence of charge and flavour exchange in this region . at low energy on the contrary it should be governed by meson exchange with its strong @xmath20-dependence . these two components may be tentatively separated by using instead of @xmath62 the quantity @xmath81 in order to extract the meson exchange contribution . this quantity is plotted in fig . [ fig : p2n_meanang1 ] as a function of @xmath20 for four @xmath8 values from 0.2 to 0.8 gev / c . as a function of @xmath20 for different values of @xmath8 , a ) @xmath8 = 0.2 , b ) @xmath8 = 0.4 , c ) @xmath8 = 0.6 , and d ) @xmath8 = 0.8 gev / c . the elastic limit is indicated by the arrows ] a very characteristic pattern emerges which resembles the @xmath20-dependence for the charge exchange in elementary interactions described above , see fig . [ fig : chargeexch ] . in general @xmath82 follows a power law dependence on @xmath20 @xmath83 with local slopes @xmath84 which are in turn a function of @xmath20 . three different regions with distinct local slopes can be identified in fig . [ fig : p2n_meanang1 ] : * a first region with large slopes is located at @xmath20 below about 6 gev@xmath68 . this region is strongly influenced by threshold effects as the threshold for inelastic production is placed at the elastic limit @xmath85 indicated in fig . [ fig : p2n_meanang1 ] . in the approach to pion threshold the @xmath39 ratio has to diverge as @xmath32 is progressively suppressed , see above . with increasing @xmath8 this suppression will of course be more pronounced . * an intermediate region between about 8 and 40 gev@xmath68 with an @xmath20 dependence decreasing with increasing @xmath8 . * a third region with flattening @xmath20-dependence above about 40 gev@xmath68 . at the lowest @xmath8 value of 0.2 gev / c corresponding to the lowest momentum transfer , the similarity to the charge exchange process in nucleon - nucleon interactions , fig . [ fig : chargeexch ] , is absolutely striking . this concerns both the detailed shape and the overall suppression factors . with increasing @xmath8 , the @xmath20 dependence is modified in a systematic way by a general reduction of slopes , with the exception of the threshold enhancement this is quantified in fig . [ fig : beta ] which shows the local slopes as a function of @xmath20 for @xmath8 values between 0.2 and 1 gev / c . of the @xmath20-dependence of @xmath82 as a function of s : a ) @xmath8 = 0.2 , b ) @xmath8 = 0.4 , c ) @xmath8 = 0.6 , d ) @xmath8 = 0.8 , and e ) @xmath8 = 1.0 gev / c . the shaded regions mark the error margins ] with the exception of the threshold region , the slopes are confined to the region between 2 and 1 typical of meson exchange processes . the dependence on @xmath8 is given in fig . [ fig : beta_pldep ] where the slopes in the three regions of @xmath20 specified above are presented . 6 gev@xmath68 ( broken line ) , 6 @xmath86 40 gev@xmath68 ( full line ) and @xmath87 40 gev@xmath68 ( dotted line ) as a function of @xmath8 between 0.2 and 1 gev / c ] this figure shows clearly the different nature of the low @xmath20 enhancement where the slopes increase strongly with @xmath8 . the two other regions , full and dotted lines , are compatible with a regge parametrization with trajectory intercepts which increase with @xmath8 . this is insofar interesting as the region of measurements regarded here covers the complete backward angular range and the corresponding interactions are by no means confined to diffractive or low momentum transfer collisions . it is shown in sect . [ sec : separation ] of this paper that in the backward hemisphere the pion yields from nuclear cascading and target fragmentation are comparable . if the nuclear component is characterized by low momentum transfer reactions @xcite the target fragmentation is manifestly inelastic and non - diffractive . it governs the total yield at all angles below about 70 degrees . in conclusion of this study of @xmath39 ratios in p+c interactions the following points should be stressed : * the global data interpolation leads to a precise and consistent description of the behaviour of the @xmath39 ratios in the full backward hemisphere , thus offering an additional tool for the discrimination of experimental deviations . * the inspection of the detailed @xmath20-dependence of the ratios opens a new window on the underlying exchange processes . * in particular the comparison to the elementary nucleon - nucleon collisions establishes a close relation between apparently disjoint sectors of the different hadronic interactions . [ sec : dev_exp ] as mentioned in sect . [ sec : ph ] four of the 19 investigated data sets are incompatible with the attempt at generating an overall consistent description of the experimental situation . these data will be shortly discussed below . [ sec : geaga ] these data have been obtained at the bevalac using beam momenta of 1.75 , 2.89 and 5.89 gev / c , spanning a lab momentum range from 0.3 to 0.9 gev / c at a lab angle of 180 degrees . the resulting cross sections trace the shape of the @xmath24 dependence rather precisely but are consistently about a factor of two below the global interpolation as shown in fig . [ fig : bevalac ] . here the full lines correspond to the global interpolation and the broken lines give the interpolation divided by a factor of two . for three values of @xmath24 ; a ) 0.427 , b ) 0.366 and c ) 0.281 gev@xmath49 . the full lines give the global data interpolation , the open circles the data from @xcite , width=585 ] as the angular bin from 160 to 180 degrees is mostly covered by data around 160162 degrees , a steep angular dependence in this region can not a priori be excluded . the smooth and gentle angular dependence of the interpolated data shown in fig . [ fig : geaga ] for the angular range from 82 to 180 degrees and for the three @xmath24 values of ref . @xcite , together with the constraint of the approach to 180 degrees with tangent zero , excludes however a drop of the cross sections by a factor of two between 160 and 180 degrees . [ sec : belyaev ] a sizeable set of data on proton @xcite and pion @xcite production has been obtained at the serpukhov accelerator spanning the range of beam momenta between 17 and 57 gev / c . this fills the gap between the ps and sps energies where no other data are available . the data cover the @xmath8 range from 0.25 to 1.2 gev / c at @xmath10 = 159 degrees . they are presented in fig . [ fig : serp_sdep ] in comparison to the global data interpolation . at @xmath10 = 159 degrees ( open circles ) in comparison to the global data interpolation at 160 degrees ( full lines),width=604 ] several features of this comparison are noteworthy : * the shape of the @xmath24 dependences complies precisely with the global interpolation . this is compatible with the absence of rapid variations of the cross sections with energy in the region between ps and sps . * there is a pronounced suppression of these data with respect to the interpolation with increasing @xmath8 reaching factors of three at the upper ranges for protons and pions . * the @xmath31 and @xmath32 data show an identical behaviour . * the proton data are tracing the interpolation up to @xmath8 = 0.4 gev / c whereas the pion data are already suppressed in this @xmath8 range . * the suppression factors are generally bigger for the pions at equal @xmath8 . * these features might be compatible with a momentum scale error . in addition to the reproduction of the shape of the @xmath24 dependence , also the @xmath39 ratio complies exactly with the one extracted from the global interpolation , fig . [ fig : serp_p2n ] , up to @xmath8 = 0.7 gev / c . above this value there is a sharp drop of @xmath61 reaching unphysical values at the upper limit of @xmath8 . this drop of about 20% has however to be compared to a drop of 300% of the invariant cross sections at this limit . from @xcite as a function of @xmath8 averaged over beam momentum between 17 and 57 gev / c . the full line gives the result of the global interpolation averaged over the same beam momentum scale , sect . [ sec : p2n],width=340 ] [ sec : harp ] these results cover a range from 3 to 12 gev / c beam momentum at @xmath10 between 25 and 117 degrees and 0.125 @xmath60 0.75 gev / c . they are thus directly comparable to the ones from @xcite which are part of the global data interpolation . their differences to this interpolation are presented in fig . [ fig : harpdiffdist ] for all beam momenta and the standard grid of @xmath8 and @xmath10 values . , panel b ) @xmath31 ] if the mean values of the differences are close to zero , their number distributions show wide spreads especially for @xmath31 . this is exemplified in fig . [ fig : pion_sdep ] where a typical comparison to the global interpolation ( full lines ) is given as a function of @xmath24 at @xmath10 = 67 degrees for four @xmath8 values . = 67 degrees and four @xmath8 values as a function of @xmath24 , ( open circles ) in comparison to the global data interpolation ( full lines ) . panel a ) @xmath31 , panel b ) @xmath32,width=585 ] a comparison of @xmath39 ratios is given in fig . [ fig : harp_p2n_5 ] as a function of @xmath8 for four values of @xmath10 at @xmath23 = 5 gev / c . from @xcite as a function of @xmath8 for four lab angles and a beam momentum of 5 gev / c . the full lines give the results of the data interpolation from @xcite , the full circles correspond to the ratios of the measured cross sections . the broken lines give the result of the global interpolation ] this figure demonstrates the importance of using , in addition to the invariant cross section proper , the particle ratios which are strongly constrained by physical arguments , see sect . [ sec : p2n ] . [ sec : shine ] these data have been obtained at a beam momentum of 31 gev / c in a @xmath10 range from 0.6 to 22.3 degrees and @xmath8 from 0.2 to 18 gev / c . if a large part of the given angular and momentum coverage falls outside the backward region regarded here , the low momentum range up to @xmath52 0.5 gev / c for all angles and the range 0.6 @xmath60 1 gev / c for angles above about 9 degrees corresponds to negative @xmath13 and can therefore be considered here . the complete @xmath24 dependence established in the preceding sections has a lower angular limit at 25 degrees corresponding to the lowest value of the standard grid of angles . this angle is close to the highest angle of @xcite at 22.3 degrees allowing for a safe interpolation . this is shown in fig . [ fig : na61 ] where the global interpolation is compared to the data of @xcite at their highest angles between 12 and 22 degrees for two @xmath8 values both for @xmath31 and for @xmath32 . at @xmath24 = 0.13 gev@xmath49 in the @xmath10 region from 12 to 35 degrees for @xmath8 = 0.4 and 0.6 full lines : global data interpolation . full dots and broken lines : data from @xcite ] as the global interpolation is limited to @xmath12 25 degrees , another way of comparison is offered by the combined na49 and fermilab results at 158/400 gev / c where the former data cover the complete angular range of @xcite . the ratio of the available high energy data to the results at 31 gev / c beam momentum is shown , as a function of @xmath10 , in fig . [ fig : na61_ratio ] . for @xmath8 = 0.4 and 0.6 gev / c . the full circles correspond to the global data interpolation , the open circles to the direct ratio @xcite/@xcite . the broken lines give the mean ratio over the complete range of the global data interpolation ] apparently this cross section ratio is within errors angle independent over the full range of the global data survey , with well defined averages below 1.05 for @xmath31 and 1.1 for @xmath32 . in contrast , the cross section ratio between na49 and ref . @xcite shows values in the region of 1.4 increasing with decreasing @xmath10 . in conclusion to this section it may be stated that the global data interpolation between 15 different experiments attempted in this paper proves to be a useful tool for the detection of deviating data sets . further details concerning the above comparisons can be found in an internal report on ref . [ sec : separation ] hadronic production in the backward direction of p+a collisions has two components : the fragmentation of the target nucleons which have been hit by the projectile proton , and the propagation of momentum transfer into the nucleus by secondary nucleon - nucleon interaction which follow , on a longer time scale , the initial excitation process . both processes are governed by the mean number of collisions @xmath89 suffered by the projectile on his trajectory through the nucleus . as only the sum of these two separate mechanisms is experimentally accessible , a minimum assumption about the fragmentation of the target nucleons is needed in order to allow the separation of the components in an otherwise model - independent fashion . this minimal assumption consists in assuming that the fragmentation process of the hit nucleons is equal to the basic nucleon - nucleon interaction , taking full account of course of isospin symmetry . in addition and only valid for the relatively small value of @xmath89 in the carbon nucleus , it will be assumed that successive collisions result in hadronization at full interaction energy of the corresponding elementary interactions . as far as the value of @xmath89 is concerned , this has been determined for pion production in some detail in @xcite using the forward and the backward region at @xmath90 -0.1 where no intra - nuclear cascading is present , see below . this determination used three independent approaches : * a monte - carlo calculation using the measured nuclear density distributions . * the relation between the inelastic cross sections of p+p and p+c interactions . * the approach to @xmath13 = -0.1 of the ratio of pion densities in p+c and p+p collisions . the two former methods have to make the assumption that the inelastic interaction cross sections are independent of the number of subsequent collisions @xmath91 . in @xcite a similar approach is used concerning the production of protons and anti - protons , again in the regions where there is no contribution from nuclear cascading as well as in the full backward hemisphere . all methods mentioned above result in a consistent estimate of @xmath89 = 1.6 in p+c collisions , with a relative systematic uncertainty of the order of a few percent . in the following argumentation a prediction of the mean pion density of target fragmentation in the backward hemisphere at @xmath92 = 17.2 gev will be used which is relying on the published pion data from na49 @xcite and the estimated mean number of collisions , @xmath89 . the invariant pion cross sections are divided by the inelastic cross section to yield the quantity @xmath93 per inelastic event which establishes isospin symmetry , and @xmath94 this prediction is transformed into the appropriate coordinates @xmath8 and @xmath10 and divided by the measured invariant p+c cross sections @xmath95 per inelastic event yielding the ratio @xmath96 this ratio is shown in fig . [ fig : rpred_plab ] as a function of @xmath8 for the lab angles 10 , 20 , 30 , 40 and 45 degrees . as a function of @xmath8 for the five angles 10 , 20 , 30 , 40 and 45 degrees ] it is evident that the ratio is close to one for the three lowest angles at all @xmath8 and for the region below 0.8 gev / c for 40 and 45 degrees . this is quantified in fig . [ fig : rpred_hist ] which gives the distribution of the ratio for the mentioned @xmath8 ranges . for the lab angles 10 , 20 , 30 degrees and 40 and 45 degrees at @xmath30 0.8 gev / c . full line : gauss fit to the distribution with a mean value at 1.01 and a relative rms of 4.3% ] the results show that indeed the measured pion cross sections correspond for lab angles up to 45 degrees precisely to the prediction from elementary collisions . this indicates that there is no contribution from intra - nuclear cascading in this region , in accordance with the results of @xcite . a drop of the ratio becomes however visible in the higher @xmath8 range at 40 and 45 degrees . this marks the onset of a nuclear component which becomes clearly visible in the ratios at larger angles shown in fig . [ fig : rpred_plab_high ] . as a function of @xmath8 for the angles of 45 , 55 , 70 , 90 , 112 , 137 and 160 the full lines are local interpolations , width=396 ] it is interesting to note that the target fragmentation governs the pion density up to the highest lab angles at low @xmath8 , with @xmath97 values of more than 50% . the ratio decreases however steadily with increasing @xmath8 and reaches zero at distinct momentum values indicating the approach to @xmath13 = -1 in the plots of fig . [ fig : kinematics ] . this kinematic effect is more clearly brought out in fig . [ fig : rpred_kin ] showing that the fraction of target fragmentation is essentially a function of @xmath13 and rather independent on lab angle . and @xmath10 for constant values of @xmath98 between 0.1 and 0.9 , b ) correlation between @xmath8 and @xmath10 for fixed values of @xmath13 between -0.1 and -1.0 and c ) @xmath98 as a function of @xmath13 ] the correlation between @xmath8 and @xmath10 for fixed values of @xmath97 shown in panel a traces rather exactly the kinematic correlation between the same variables for fixed values of @xmath13 , panel b. this allows to establish a direct dependence of @xmath97 on @xmath13 which is to first order angle - independent , panel c. the invariant densities @xmath100 per inelastic event as predicted from the fragmentation of the participant target nucleons is presented in fig . [ fig : fpred_theta ] . per inelastic event as a function of @xmath29 for fixed values of @xmath8 between 0.1 and 1.2 gev / c . the full lines represent data interpolations , width=415 ] this density may be subtracted from the pion density @xmath101 measured in p+c interactions which is within errors equal for @xmath31 and @xmath32 , see figs . [ fig : pc_pip_theta ] and [ fig : pc_pin_theta ] . the resulting invariant density @xmath102 is shown in fig . [ fig : nucl_theta ] . from intra - nuclear cascading as a function of @xmath29 for fixed values of @xmath8 between 0.1 and 1.2 gev / c . the full lines represent data interpolations , width=415 ] this subtraction procedure becomes of course uncertain in the small angle region where the nuclear component is on the few percent level and below with respect to the target fragmentation , see figs . [ fig : rpred_plab ] and [ fig : rpred_plab_high ] . the invariant angular distributions shown in figs . [ fig : fpred_theta ] and [ fig : nucl_theta ] may be converted into number distributions following : @xmath103 and @xmath104 integrating these distributions over @xmath8 , the number distributions @xmath105 and @xmath106 are obtained which are shown in fig . [ fig : dndcostheta ] together with the ratio @xmath107 as a function of @xmath108 ( full line ) , @xmath109 as a function of @xmath108 ( broken line ) , b ) the ratio @xmath110 as a function of @xmath108,width=453 ] evidently the nuclear component of pion production stays comparable to the target fragmentation in the full backward hemisphere of @xmath10 . it decreases rapidly for @xmath10 below about 60 degrees and vanishes below @xmath10 25 degrees . integration of @xmath111 over @xmath108 results in the total single pion yield from nuclear cascading @xmath112 per inelastic event . the predicted integrated yield from target fragmentation is @xmath113 with @xmath114 and @xmath115 from p+p interactions as measured by na49 , @xcite . this means that for p+c interactions the nuclear component of pion production amounts to 4.9% of the pions originating from the fragmentation of the hit target nucleons . applying isospin symmetry on the isoscalar c nucleus with @xmath116 the total pion yields are 6.45 from target fragmentation and 0.315 from nuclear cascading . making use of the kinematic relation between the coordinate pairs @xmath8 , @xmath10 and @xmath13 , @xmath14 , see fig . [ fig : kinematics]c , the double differential yields for the nuclear component as functions of @xmath13 and @xmath14 @xmath117 may be obtained where @xmath118 , ( [ eq : xf ] ) , and @xmath119 are cms quantities . the resulting pion density distributions are shown in fig . [ fig : dndxfdpt ] as a function of @xmath13 for @xmath14 values from 0.05 to 0.7 gev / c . as a function of @xmath13 for a ) 0.05 @xmath120 0.3 gev / c and b ) 0.4 @xmath120 0.7 gev / c , width=453 ] a peak at low @xmath14 and @xmath13 = -0.15 is apparent which corresponds to the location of pions with small lab momentum , see fig . [ fig : kinematics ] . with increasing @xmath14 the maximum density decreases and shifts in @xmath13 to lower values which is again in accordance with the kinematic correlation visible in fig . [ fig : kinematics ] . integration over @xmath14 results in the single differential density @xmath121 shown in fig . [ fig : dndxf ] together with the predicted density distribution @xmath122 from target fragmentation and with the ratio of the two densities . as a function of @xmath13 ( full line ) . the predicted density distribution from target fragmentation @xmath123 is shown as the broken line ; b ) ratio @xmath124 as a function of @xmath13,width=453 ] the @xmath14 integrated pion density @xmath121 shows a peak at @xmath125 -0.2 and vanishes at @xmath125 -0.08 . as shown by the density ratio with the predicted target fragmentation @xmath122 in fig . [ fig : dndxf]b , the nuclear component reaches 10% of the target fragmentation at @xmath13 = -0.15 and exceeds this contribution for @xmath15 -0.55 . the nuclear pion component extracted above is used in @xcite in conjunction with the complementary nuclear proton component to obtain the percentage of cascading protons which are accompanied by pion emission . [ sec : conclusion ] this paper presents a survey of available data concerning backward proton and pion production in minimum bias p+c interactions , including new and extensive data sets obtained at the cern ps and sps . the backward direction being defined as the complete phase space at negative feynman @xmath13 , the data cover , for projectile momenta from 1 to 400 gev / c , the ranges from 0.2 to 1.2 gev / c in lab momentum @xmath8 and from 10 to 180 degrees in lab angle @xmath10 . the paper attempts an interconnection of the different data sets by a detailed three - dimensional interpolation scheme in the variables @xmath24 , @xmath8 , and @xmath108 . this attempt allows a precise control of the internal data consistency as well as the study of the evolution of the invariant inclusive cross sections in all three variables . a literature search has provided a set of 19 different experiments with a total of more than 3500 data points . these measurements were obtained over 40 years of experimentation by collaborations employing widely different experimental techniques . in this respect it may be stated as a first positive result that the majority of the data may be combined into a surprisingly self - consistent ensemble . this global interpolation scheme results in a considerable discriminative power against the systematic deviation of particular data sets . only 4 of the 19 quoted experiments show in fact deviations which clearly mark them as systematically diverging . these experiments are inspected in detail one by one in an attempt to clearly bring out the discrepancies . in some of the cases , possible experimental error sources are pointed out . the underlying physics provides for additional constraints concerning basic quantities like charge conservation and isospin symmetry as well as the necessity of smoothness and continuity of the observed cross sections . whenever possible , contact to the complementary elementary nucleon - nucleon interactions is established . this concerns in particular the evocation of mesonic exchange processes for the description of @xmath39 ratios and the prediction of the target fragmentation from elementary interactions and its separation from the component of nuclear cascading . as far as the dependences of the invariant cross sections on the three basic variables @xmath8 , @xmath10 and @xmath24 is concerned , a well constrained phenomenology emerges . the @xmath8 dependences are exponential or close to exponential over a major part of the phase space with some exceptions mostly towards low interaction energies . this fact results in an important constraint for the data interpolation . the @xmath108 dependences are not far from exponential and smooth and continuous through all lab angles . in particular there is no indication of an instability around 90 degrees for the proton yields . the @xmath24 dependences converge , after strong variations close to production threshold , smoothly to asymptotic behaviour in the sps energy range . this region is approached from above by the protons and from below for the pions . this convergence is confirmed by the @xmath39 ratios which show , being governed by meson exchange at low @xmath92 with large values marked by the projectile isospin , a smooth decline with energy towards unity as expected from the underlying elementary exchange processes . this work was supported by the polish state committee for scientific research ( p03b00630 ) , the polish national science centre ( on the basis of decision no . dec-2011/03/b / st2/02634 ) the bulgarian national science fund ( ph-09/05 ) , the eu fp6 hrm marie curie intra - european fellowship program , the hungarian scientific research fund otka ( t68506 ) and the hungarian otka / nkth a08 - 77719 and a08 - 77815 grants . [ 20 ] y. d. bayukov et al . , phys . rev . * c20 * , ( 1979 ) 764 b. baatar et al . , arxiv:1207.6520v1 [ hep - ex ] i. m. belyaev et al . , * jinr - p1 - 90 - 551 * ( 1990 ) ( in russian ) a. bolshakova et al . , j. * c70 * ( 2010 ) 573 n. a. burgov et al . phys . * 30 * ( 1979 ) 371 , yad . fiz . * 30 * ( 1979 ) 720 y. d. bayukov et al . . phys . * 18 * ( 1974 ) 639 + y. d. bayukov et al . * 19 * ( 1974 ) 648 j. v. geaga et al . * 45 * ( 1980 ) 1993 s. frankel et al . lett . * 36 * ( 1976 ) 642 v. i. komarov et al . , phys . lett . * 69b * ( 1977 ) 37 j. franz et al . , nucl . phys . * a472 * ( 1987 ) 733 n. a. nikiforov et al . , phys . rev . * c22 * ( 1980 ) 700 c. alt et al . j. * c49 * ( 2007 ) 897 i. m. belyaev et al . , sov . * 49 * ( 1989 ) 295 n. abgrall et al . , phys . rev . * c84 * ( 2011 ) 034604 m. g. catanesi er al . , phys . rev . * c77 * ( 2008 ) 055207 n. a. burgov et al . * 32 * ( 1980 ) 219 , yad * 32 * ( 1980 ) 423 a. m. baldin et al . , * 20 * ( 1975 ) 629 d. r. f. cochran , phys * d6 * ( 1972 ) 3085 j. f. crawford , phys . rev . * c22 * ( 1980 ) 1184 j. whitmore et al . , phys . lett * 60b * ( 1976 ) 211 + t. ferbel , phys . * 29 * ( 1972 ) 448 + a. h. mueller , phys d2 * ( 1970 ) 2963 c. alt et al . j. * c45 * ( 2006 ) 343 b. d. anderson et al . lett . * 46 * ( 1981 ) 226 d. h. boal , phys . rev . * c25 * ( 1982 ) 3068 v. blobel et al . , nucl .phys . * b135 * ( 1978 ) 379 t. anticic et al . j. * c65 * ( 2010 ) 9 http://cern.ch/spshadrons v. blobel et al . , nucl . phys . * b69 * ( 1974 ) 454 g. barr et al . j. * c49 * ( 2007 ) 919 e. l. miller et al . * 26 * ( 1971 ) 984 m. n. kreisler et al . , nucl . phys . * b84 * ( 1975 ) 3 v. bhmer et al . * b110 * ( 1976 ) 205 a. babaev et al . , nucl . phys . * b110 * ( 1976 ) 189 h. r. barton et al . , phys . * 37 * ( 1976 ) 1656 h. de kerret et al . * 69b * ( 1977 ) 372 g. goggi et al . , phys . lett . * 72b * ( 1977 ) 265 g. goggi et al . , phys . lett . * 79b * ( 1978 ) 165 c. conta et al . , nucl . phys . * b175 * ( 1980 ) 97 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the formation mechanism of the thick disk is one of the most noticeable grey points of our current understanding of the galactic formation and evolution process . this uncertainty is particularly unfortunate because , being the thick disk a ubiquitous feature among spiral galaxies @xcite , its formation must be a common stage in the early evolution of late - type galaxies . during the nearly three decades since its discovery @xcite , many models have been proposed . the merging scenario , in which the early merging of a small satellite galaxy heats a primordial galactic disk producing an old , thick , and kinematically hot disk population @xcite , has been the most favored model in the last decade , following the evidence that the thin and thick disks are chemically distinct @xcite . nevertheless , even this scenario is not free of problems ( see , for example , * ? ? ? * ) , and alternative models have recently been drawn to attention ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? it is clear that the general properties of the galactic thick disk , such as its mean metallicity or mean kinematics , are not enough to distinguish between the models proposed for its formation . moreover , the merging scenario has many free parameters , such as the mass of the merging satellite and the inclination of its orbit with respect to the galactic disk , and the observations must constrain them if the quality of the model is to be finally assessed . in the last few years , theoretical simulations have started to cast predictions of the stellar distribution of stars in the multi - dimensional spatial - kinematical - chemical space ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? for example , @xcite have shown that , within the merging scenario , the time of impact , and the mass and orbit of the infalling satellite can be deduced from the distribution of the expected kinematical clumps in the @xmath7@xmath8 plane , while @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite find that the @xmath4/@xmath5 ratio and its variation with galactocentric distance are excellent indicators of the inclination angle of the merging event . @xcite and @xcite have also shown that the observed decrease of rotation velocity with distance from the plane points to a low - latitude merging . at the same time , the observations are gathering information about the spatial variations of the chemical composition and velocity distribution ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . detailed results of this kind are strongly needed because , through comparison with the expectations from the different models , they can be key to solve the puzzle of the galactic thick disk formation . we are undertaking an extensive survey aimed to reveal the kinematical and chemical vertical structure of the galactic thick disk @xcite . preliminary kinematical results were presented by @xcite and @xcite , while the sample was also used to investigate the galactic dark disk @xcite , and lithium - rich stars in the galactic thick disk @xcite . in this paper , we focus on the kinematical results , studying the trend of kinematical quantities as a function of distance from the galactic plane . in later papers of this series , the collected spectra will be used to measure the metallicity and chemical abundances of the sample , to study the variation of the thick disk chemistry with galactic height . our investigation is based on the sample of @xmath61200 red giants defined by @xcite , vertically distributed with respect to the galactic plane in a cone of fifteen degrees radius centered on the south galactic pole . the sample covers a large range of galactic heights , from the plane to @xmath95 kpc , and it is volume - complete up to @xmath10=3 kpc . all the objects have 2mass photometry @xcite , and absolute proper motions from the spm3 catalog @xcite . the sample was defined by the color cut [email protected] , to isolate intermediate - metallicity stars . main sequence ( ms ) dwarfs were excluded both by a sloped cut at fainter magnitudes , parallel to the ms , which excludes all but the nearest ( d@xmath1263 pc ) dwarfs , and by conservative kinematical criteria imposing a stellar velocity lower than the local escape velocity ( see * ? ? ? * for more details ) . l l c l c run & date & n. nights & instrument & n. stars + coralie1 & 2005 , september & 4 & coralie@euler & 39 + feros1 & 2005 , september & 6 & [email protected] & 183 + dupont1 & 2005 , october & 6 & echelle@dupont & 168 + coralie2 & 2005 , october & 3 & coralie@euler & 25 + feros2 & 2006 , august & 6 & [email protected] & 161 + dupont2 & 2006 , september & 6 & echelle@dupont & 119 + mike1 & 2006 , aug.nov . & 5x0.5 & mike@magellan & 77 + mike2 & 2007 , october & 2 & mike@magellan & 52 + we collected high - resolution echelle spectra for two - thirds of the girard et al.s sample ( 824 stars ) . all the stars in the brighter half of the sample were spectroscopically observed , while the completeness decreases with magnitude for fainter objects . we found a high contamination ( @xmath635% ) by nearby dwarf in the faintest end of the distribution , hence stars with @xmath13 were given lower priority after the first observations . the distribution of proper motions and colors of the observed sub - sample is shown in figure [ f_sample ] . the comparison with the complete sample reveals that no selection effect was introduced : the slight overabundance of red stars in the observed sample is due to the higher completeness at brighter magnitudes , where stars are on average redder . as discussed later , we will restrict our investigation to stars with galactic height @xmath141.3 kpc , to avoid a strong thin disk contamination . this reduced the sample under study to 514 stars . we visually inspected all the spectra , identifying 46 probable dwarf stars . as expected , they show on average low radial velocities but high u and v components , and only one is found at @xmath159 . we also found 22 stars with [ fe / h]@xmath161.5 , as deduced from comparisons with synthetic spectra . they were considered probable halo contaminants and were excluded from further analysis . we note that the metal - poor tail of the thick disk extends to much lower metallicities @xcite , but below this limit thick disk stars are outnumbered by halo members by a factor of nearly ten @xcite . finally , we also excluded from analysis 34 stars that , in the galactic cylindrical coordinate system , had velocity components ( defined in section [ s_disp ] ) outside the range @xmath17u@xmath18300 km s@xmath3 , @xmath19v@xmath12300 km s@xmath3 , and @xmath17w@xmath18150 km s@xmath3 . the cut in @xmath20 was aimed to remove the residual halo contamination , while the other components were restricted to exclude stars with wrong distance or bad proper motion . the cut in @xmath8 was offset toward negative values to take into account the vertical shear ( see section [ s_resmean ] ) . our final sample thus comprised 412 stars . the interstellar reddening e(@xmath21 ) was derived for each target from the @xcite maps , and the @xmath22 magnitude and ( @xmath23 ) color were de - reddened by means of the transformations of @xcite . the distance to each star was then estimated through a color - absolute magnitude relation calibrated on 47tucanae , a disk globular cluster @xcite whose stellar population is very similar to the galactic thick disk both in age and metallicity @xcite . the fit of the cluster red giant branch yields the relation ( l. miller 2008 , priv . comm . ) : @xmath24 which were translated into absolute magnitude and de - reddened color assuming @[email protected] and e(@xmath21)[email protected] for the cluster distance modulus and reddening , respectively @xcite . inspecting the 2mass photometric data of 47tuc used to derive equation ( [ eq_dist ] ) , we found that the uncertainty on @xmath27 is of the order of @xmath60.2 magnitudes . this is only a marginal contribution to the final error in distance , because the main source of uncertainty is the relatively wide range of age and metallicity covered by thick disk stars . indeed , the 2mass photometric errors have only negligible impact , because they do not exceed 0.03 magnitudes for our fainter targets ( @xmath2810.6 ) . we estimated the effect of the age and metallicity distribution on the derived absolute magnitudes by means of yale - yonsei isochrones @xcite . we assumed a scatter of 0.3 dex in metallicity , that should include the bulk of thick disk stars @xcite when excluding the scarcely - populated low- and high- metallicity tails @xcite , and a scatter of 2 gyr in age @xcite . they were considered uncorrelated , because the age - metallicity relation for the thick disk is very weak @xcite . we finally estimated the error on distance to be @xmath620% , quadratically summing all the relevant contributions . thin disk stars do not follow the age and metallicity distribution assumed to derive equation ( [ eq_dist ] ) , and their distances should be systematically biased . indeed , younger , more metal - rich red giants are intrinsically fainter than our estimate . comparing the absolute magnitudes calculated from equation ( [ eq_dist ] ) with yale - yonsei isochrones between 2 and 8 gyr , and metallicity following the age - metallicity relation of @xcite and @xcite , we found that the distance of thin disk stars would be overestimated by 1020% . this systematic error is small , but it has a relevant consequence on the contamination of the sample , which is artificially stretched to larger heights from the plane . our sample is contaminated by the thin disk , because the targets were selected through a color cut that efficiently eliminates low - metallicity stars , but which excludes only a small fraction of metal - rich objects , as it can be deduced from figure 1 of @xcite . in figure [ f_contam ] we plot an estimate of the fraction of thin disk stars in the sample , assuming 300 and 900 pc as thin and thick disk scale height , respectively , and a thick disk local normalization of 12% @xcite . we also calculated the contamination in the case of a distance overestimate of 15% for thin disk objects . the curves can be considered an upper limit , because the color cut , unaccounted for in the calculation , could have removed part of the contamination . in the same figure we indicate the results of a rough empirical estimate , obtained fitting a double gaussian to the distribution of the vertical velocity component ( @xmath20 ) in five bins of 50 stars . the dispersions of the two gaussian components were kept fixed , and the only free parameter of the fit was the number of thin disk stars in the bin . the error bars show the results when varying @xmath5 in the range 14 - 16 and 35 - 40 km s@xmath3 for the thin and the thick disk , respectively . this test was performed only for @xmath291 - 2 kpc , where both populations contribute by more than 20% of the objects , i.e. 10 stars in each bin . the empirical errorbars agree well with the curve obtained when the distance bias is considered , although the observed contamination fall - off with @xmath1 seems steeper than the modeled one . in conclusion , our sample is contaminated by thin disk stars , whose distances are overestimated . this affects even the estimate of their kinematics , which is also biased . therefore , we will not analyze the results for the thin disk , and we will limit our study to @xmath141.3 kpc , to avoid the strong contamination ( @xmath3050% ) of the nearest subsample . @xcite estimated that the halo contamination in the sample should be about 8% , hence we would expect 41 halo members among the 514 targets with @xmath141.3 kpc . the cut in @xmath20 removed 10 probable halo contaminants and , according to the statistics of @xcite , 18 of the excluded low - metallicity targets are expected to be halo stars . the cuts in @xmath7 and @xmath8 could also have removed some halo objects , but the effect of this cut is harder to quantify , because an unknown fraction of the outliers are probably objects with problematic proper motion or wrong distance . the residual halo contamination in our sample of 412 targets should therefore be lower than @xmath63% ( 13 stars ) , and it can be safely neglected . the spectra were collected during six observing runs between 2005 and 2007 , at la silla and las campanas observatories . the details of the observations and data reduction were presented in @xcite , and we will outline here only the most relevant points . four different telescopes were used , because the stars span a wide range in magnitude ( @xmath8=516 ) , but the instruments had similar characteristics . the basic information of the runs is given in table [ t_obs ] . the spectra covered the whole visual range from the atmospheric cutoff on the blue side to @xmath69000 , except for coralie data which only reached 6800 on the red edge . we did not reduce the spectra collected with the mike blue arm because of too low stellar flux , and mike data were thus limited to 4850 on the blue end . the spectral resolution varied between 32000 and 50000 , depending on the spectrograph . in particular , the 0@xmath317 slit was always used for mike runs ( r=32000 ) , while at dupont both the 0@xmath3175 and 1@xmath32 slits were used ( r=40000 and 30000 , respectively ) , depending on weather conditions . during each run we secured the spectra of up to seventeen bright stars with accurate parameters from the literature ( radial and rotational velocities , temperature , gravity , metallicity ) . exposure times were chosen according to weather conditions , to reach s / n=70100 for all the targets . comparison lamp arcs were acquired only during daytime calibrations for the fiber spectrographs coralie and feros . the second fiber of these two instruments was allocated to the sky background , because the spectra were usually collected next to full moon . lamp arcs were collected at intervals of about 2 hours during dupont and mike runs , and each spectrum was calibrated with the average of the two lamps temporally enclosing it , linearly weighted by the temporal distance between science and calibration frames . spectra were reduced with standard iraf[multiblock footnote omitted ] tasks , and we kept the procedures as much as possible identical for all the data . we a posteriori verified that the reduced feros and coralie spectra were of the same quality as the products of their dedicated pipelines . we analyzed the dark frames collected for all the runs , but we always found a negligible instrumental dark current and no clear 2d pattern , hence no dark correction was applied . the wavelength calibration lamp spectra were extracted in the same position on the ccd as science targets , to avoid systematics introduced by the curvature of the orders . the spectrum of a bright , well - exposed star was used to trace the orders on the ccd in each observing night , allowing only for rigid shifts among the frames . then , the spectra were extracted with an optimum extraction algorithm @xcite , normalized , and finally merged . the radial velocity ( rv ) for all the targets was measured with a cross - correlation ( cc ) technique @xcite as implemented in the iraf _ fxcor _ task . the procedure was described in detail in @xcite , and we give only a brief summary here . the spectrum of each star was cross - correlated with three template stars observed in the same run , namely hd180540 , hd223559 , and hd213893 ( this last replaced by hd224834 for coralie data ) , encompassing the temperature range of the targets . their rv was fixed by a cc with a synthetic spectrum generated with the spectrum code @xcite , because we found poor agreement between the available literature sources . the analysis of the seventeen standard stars acquired during observations , and of the solar spectra collected each night , revealed that the rv zero - point thus defined was biased by 0.3 - 0.7 km s@xmath3 , depending on the instrument , and this offset was removed . the three measurements were averaged , although they never differed by more than 0.2 km s@xmath3 . the cc was restricted to the range 4600 - 6800 ( 5000 - 6800 for mike data ) , to avoid the poor - quality blue section and the telluric bands at longer wavelengths . all rvs were corrected to heliocentric velocities , then the position of the telluric band at 6875 was used to correct the rvs for instrumental effects , mainly caused by a displacement on ccd between the lamp and science spectra , and an off - center position of the star inside the slit ( see , for example , the analysis of * ? ? ? corrections of up to 2 km s@xmath3 were applied , but with little scatter ( @xmath60.5 km s@xmath3 ) within each observing night . the final rv errors were estimated as the quadratic sum of the five relevant uncertainties introduced in the procedure : the cc and wavelength calibration error , the uncertainty on the zero - point and its offset , and the error on the estimate of the correction for instrumental effects . the resulting errors were typically in the range 0.4 - 0.7 km s@xmath3 . the final rvs of all the 824 stars will be made available at the cds website . l c c reference & n. stars & @xmath33 + & & km s@xmath3 + @xcite & 145 & [email protected] + @xcite & 9 & @xmath341.5 + @xcite & 9 & [email protected] + @xcite & 8 & @xmath352.1 + @xcite & 6 & @xmath363.8 + @xcite & 6 & @xmath370.9 + @xcite & 6 & [email protected] + we found 211 previous rv measurements for the stars in our sample . our results agree excellently with literature sources : the mean difference ( in the sense ours@xmath38literature ) is [email protected] km s@xmath3 , where the uncertainty is the rms of the differences . the comparison with the works that share with us more than five stars in common is given in table [ t_lit ] . the mean rv difference is always of the order of 1 km s@xmath3 , except for @xcite , whose rvs are higher than ours by a non - negligible amount ( @xmath65 km s@xmath3 ) . however , the number of stars in common is too small to conclude that this offset is significant . the proper motion , radial velocity , and distance of each target were combined to derive its ( @xmath39 ) velocity components in the galactic cylindrical reference frame , where @xmath7 is positive toward the galactic center , @xmath8 is directed in the sense of galactic rotation , and @xmath20 points toward the north galactic pole . the error on these velocities was derived propagating the uncertainty on the observed quantities . we assumed a proper motion error of 3 mas yr@xmath3 for all the stars , as this value is more realistic than the uncertainties quoted in the spm3 catalog ( t. girard , 2009 , priv . see also @xcite ) . the velocities were corrected subtracting the solar peculiar motion ( @xmath40)=(10.0 , 5.1 , 7.2 ) km s@xmath3 @xcite . @xcite recently proposed the revised values ( @xmath40)=(11.0 , 12.2 , 7.3 ) km s@xmath3 , but we preferred to adopt the older ones , for sake of continuity with previous works . in any case , the definition of the solar motion does not affect the velocity dispersions nor the off - diagonal terms of the dispersion matrix ( equation [ e_cross ] ) , while the effects on the mean values are discussed in section [ s_resmean ] . the sample was then divided into several bins , in which we calculated the mean velocities , the dispersions ( @xmath41 ) , and the non - diagonal terms of the dispersion matrix @xmath42 where the sum is extended to all the stars in the bin , and @xmath43 . the results are given in table [ t_res ] . the bins were defined by the requirement that their centers were equally spaced by 0.1 kpc from @xmath1=1.5 to 4.5 kpc , to uniformly sample the variation with @xmath1 of the kinematical quantities , while the width was imposed by the fixed number of stars per bin ( see below ) . this implied a partial overlap of the bins , increasing with distance from the plane due to the decreasing density of observed stars . however , @xcite have shown that the binning definition does not alter the results , and in fact our results are very similar to that work , despite the very different binning schemes . the bins with @xmath442.4 kpc comprised 50 stars each , while at lower heights , where the number of observed stars is larger , the bin size was increased to 80 targets for [email protected] kpc , and 100 targets for @xmath462.1 kpc . we thus ensured a good statistic of thick disk stars in bins contaminated by the thin disk . in each bin , the mean value and dispersion of each velocity component were measured by means of the analysis of the corresponding probability plot @xcite . this powerful tool is highly insensitive to outliers , and it can be employed even in case of poorly populated bins . the data are first ordered with increasing value of the velocity . each point @xmath47 is then assigned a value @xmath48 , equal to the deviation from the mean expected for the @xmath49 point of a normal distribution , in units of the standard deviation . when the underlying distribution is gaussian , the data follow a linear relation in the @xmath48-velocity plane , whose intercept and slope are given by the mean value and the dispersion , respectively . the probability plots were fitted with a straight line , weighting each data point by its error , two examples are shown in figure [ f_probplot ] . the intrinsic velocity dispersions were then obtained quadratically subtracting the mean velocity error in the bin . the wings of the distribution showing any deviation from linearity were excluded from the fit , suspected to be affected by objects with wrong distance or problematic proper motion , or by residual halo members . the analysis of artificial data samples , generated through monte - carlo simulations and analyzed as the real data , indicated that the velocity dispersion is underestimated by 1 - 2 km s@xmath3 when the thin disk contamination approaches 10% . the contamination was therefore neglected for @xmath442.5 kpc , where it is expected to be lower than 5% ( i.e. two stars per bin , see figure [ f_contam ] ) . following @xcite , in the presence of a non - negligible thin disk contamination ( @xmath462.5 kpc ) we derived the mean velocity and the dispersion of thick disk stars fitting only the wings of the probability plot , and only the negative one for @xmath8 . the cut excluded the ranges @xmath17u@xmath1850 km s@xmath3 , @xmath17w@xmath1830 km s@xmath3 , and @xmath5060 km s@xmath3 , approximatively 1.5 times the expected thin disk dispersion , thus removing about 90% of the contaminants . the two wings of the probability plot should have the same slope but a different intercept , and the mean velocity was obtained averaging the two intercepts obtained from the fit . although the mean values thus derived agree well with the trends observed in the contamination - free bins at higher @xmath1 , we regard them as less reliable . the formal errors of the least - square procedure used to obtain the intercept and the slope in the probability plots mainly indicate the deviations from gaussianity of the observed distribution . hence , they are not a good estimate of the real uncertainties . the errors were therefore derived by means of monte - carlo simulations . for each bin , we generated one thousand artificial samples of 50 stars , changing the proper motion , distance , and rv of each star assuming a gaussian random noise with dispersion equal to the estimated errors ( 3 mas yr@xmath3 , 20% , and 0.4 - 0.7 km s@xmath3 , respectively ) . the measurements were repeated in each artificial bin as done for the real data , and the dispersion of these artificial measurements was assumed as an estimate of the observational errors . the final errors are given in table [ t_res ] . the non - diagonal terms of the dispersion matrix , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 , were calculated by means of equation [ e_cross ] . the errors were estimated from monte - carlo simulations , as done for the velocity dispersions . for each bin , one thousand artificial data sets of 50 values were simulated , drawn from a distribution characterized by the same dispersion matrix as the real data . in each simulation , a gaussian random noise with a dispersion equal to the observational errors was added , and the non - diagonal terms were estimated by means of equation [ e_cross ] . the errors were defined by the scatter of these simulated measurements . with the same simulations we also evaluated the systematic error introduced by the observational uncertainties ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , comparing the results when the random noise was considered or not . we found that the expected systematic thus introduced is negligible , being about one order of magnitude lower than the uncertainties on the measured values . therefore , we did not correct the observed non - diagonal terms for observational errors . c r r r r r r r r r @xmath1 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath4 & @xmath57 & @xmath5 & @xmath52 & @xmath51 & @xmath53 + kpc & km s@xmath3 & km s@xmath3 & km s@xmath3 & km s@xmath3 & km s@xmath3 & km s@xmath3 & km@xmath58 s@xmath59 & km@xmath58 s@xmath59 & km@xmath58 s@xmath59 + 1.5 & @xmath3831@xmath264 & @xmath3846@xmath264 & 17@xmath261 & 81@xmath265 & 57@xmath265 & 38@xmath261 & 570@xmath26310 & 400@xmath26470 & 10@xmath26210 + 1.6 & @xmath3820@xmath264 & @xmath3855@xmath264 & 5@xmath261 & 77@xmath265 & 59@xmath265 & 37@xmath261 & 840@xmath26290 & @xmath38180@xmath26460 & @xmath3820@xmath26220 + 1.7 & @xmath3828@xmath264 & @xmath3861@xmath265 & 3@xmath261 & 79@xmath265 & 64@xmath265 & 38@xmath261 & 930@xmath26310 & @xmath38130@xmath26510 & @xmath3840@xmath26250 + 1.8 & @xmath3824@xmath264 & @xmath3869@xmath265 & 8@xmath261 & 79@xmath265 & 61@xmath266 & 40@xmath261 & 810@xmath26330 & @xmath38760@xmath26500 & @xmath3880@xmath26240 + 1.9 & @xmath3816@xmath264 & @xmath3877@xmath265 & 3@xmath261 & 78@xmath265 & 60@xmath265 & 40@xmath261 & 850@xmath26330 & @xmath381060@xmath26500 & @xmath38120@xmath26240 + 2.0 & @xmath3810@xmath265 & @xmath3885@xmath264 & 4@xmath261 & 83@xmath266 & 55@xmath266 & 39@xmath261 & 940@xmath26340 & 30@xmath26460 & @xmath3890@xmath26210 + 2.1 & @xmath3822@xmath265 & @xmath3878@xmath265 & 3@xmath261 & 80@xmath266 & 58@xmath266 & 38@xmath261 & 1060@xmath26320 & 470@xmath26470 & @xmath38130@xmath26220 + 2.2 & @xmath3816@xmath265 & @xmath3876@xmath267 & @xmath3813@xmath261 & 77@xmath266 & 63@xmath267 & 42@xmath261 & 690@xmath26330 & 0@xmath26550 & 230@xmath26260 + 2.3 & @xmath381@xmath266 & @xmath3881@xmath265 & @xmath389@xmath261 & 81@xmath267 & 58@xmath266 & 40@xmath261 & 750@xmath26340 & @xmath38500@xmath26470 & 10@xmath26230 + 2.4 & @xmath3812@xmath265 & @xmath3885@xmath266 & @xmath3812@xmath261 & 80@xmath266 & 59@xmath266 & 40@xmath261 & 410@xmath26330 & @xmath38710@xmath26480 & 180@xmath26240 + 2.5 & @xmath3818@xmath266 & @xmath3885@xmath266 & @xmath382@xmath261 & 78@xmath267 & 63@xmath267 & 42@xmath261 & 630@xmath26330 & @xmath381870@xmath26600 & @xmath3840@xmath26270 + 2.6 & @xmath3825@xmath266 & @xmath3890@xmath266 & 1@xmath261 & 71@xmath267 & 66@xmath267 & 42@xmath261 & 530@xmath26310 & @xmath382390@xmath26660 & @xmath38460@xmath26290 + 2.7 & @xmath3823@xmath266 & @xmath3898@xmath266 & 7@xmath261 & 72@xmath267 & 62@xmath267 & 39@xmath261 & 870@xmath26290 & @xmath381150@xmath26520 & @xmath381360@xmath26300 + 2.8 & @xmath3829@xmath266 & @xmath3895@xmath267 & @xmath382@xmath261 & 76@xmath267 & 62@xmath267 & 41@xmath261 & 880@xmath26320 & @xmath381740@xmath26580 & @xmath381310@xmath26300 + 2.9 & @xmath3817@xmath266 & @xmath38115@xmath267 & 5@xmath261 & 83@xmath267 & 68@xmath267 & 40@xmath261 & 840@xmath26340 & @xmath38820@xmath26590 & @xmath381230@xmath26300 + 3.0 & @xmath387@xmath266 & @xmath38126@xmath267 & 8@xmath261 & 90@xmath267 & 67@xmath268 & 42@xmath261 & 1440@xmath26410 & @xmath3850@xmath26610 & @xmath38460@xmath26280 + 3.1 & @xmath386@xmath267 & @xmath38129@xmath268 & 1@xmath261 & 101@xmath268 & 67@xmath268 & 43@xmath261 & 1610@xmath26450 & @xmath381150@xmath26690 & @xmath38650@xmath26290 + 3.2 & 2@xmath266 & @xmath38131@xmath268 & @xmath381@xmath261 & 99@xmath268 & 63@xmath268 & 42@xmath261 & 1470@xmath26440 & @xmath381820@xmath26650 & @xmath38440@xmath26280 + 3.3 & 8@xmath267 & @xmath38140@xmath268 & 0@xmath261 & 101@xmath268 & 66@xmath268 & 44@xmath262 & 2180@xmath26490 & @xmath382610@xmath26740 & @xmath38310@xmath26300 + 3.4 & 12@xmath267 & @xmath38140@xmath268 & 1@xmath261 & 98@xmath268 & 63@xmath269 & 43@xmath262 & 2100@xmath26480 & @xmath381880@xmath26660 & 260@xmath26280 + 3.5 & 18@xmath267 & @xmath38135@xmath269 & 5@xmath261 & 95@xmath269 & 63@xmath269 & 44@xmath262 & 1950@xmath26460 & @xmath383390@xmath26740 & 260@xmath26280 + 3.6 & 29@xmath267 & @xmath38137@xmath268 & 9@xmath261 & 101@xmath269 & 64@xmath269 & 44@xmath262 & 2290@xmath26510 & @xmath382170@xmath26700 & 360@xmath26290 + 3.7 & 7@xmath267 & @xmath38132@xmath269 & 0@xmath262 & 91@xmath269 & 61@xmath2610 & 44@xmath262 & 2180@xmath26460 & @xmath382150@xmath26610 & 610@xmath26280 + 3.8 & 15@xmath267 & @xmath38134@xmath2610 & 1@xmath262 & 92@xmath269 & 68@xmath2610 & 43@xmath262 & 1990@xmath26450 & @xmath382120@xmath26700 & @xmath3830@xmath26300 + 3.9 & 5@xmath268 & @xmath38139@xmath269 & @xmath386@xmath262 & 94@xmath2610 & 66@xmath2610 & 43@xmath262 & 1540@xmath26430 & @xmath38520@xmath26620 & 210@xmath26280 + 4.0 & 7@xmath268 & @xmath38143@xmath2610 & @xmath381@xmath262 & 93@xmath269 & 66@xmath2611 & 41@xmath262 & 1910@xmath26420 & @xmath38100@xmath26610 & 10@xmath26280 + 4.1 & 17@xmath268 & @xmath38145@xmath2610 & 1@xmath262 & 92@xmath2610 & 68@xmath2610 & 44@xmath262 & 1570@xmath26440 & 720@xmath26640 & @xmath3830@xmath26300 + 4.2 & 22@xmath268 & @xmath38142@xmath2611 & 2@xmath262 & 95@xmath2610 & 72@xmath2611 & 45@xmath262 & 1480@xmath26460 & 880@xmath26710 & 10@xmath26320 + 4.3 & 12@xmath269 & @xmath38148@xmath2610 & @xmath382@xmath262 & 94@xmath2610 & 69@xmath2611 & 48@xmath262 & 2320@xmath26510 & 1170@xmath26680 & 180@xmath26330 + 4.4 & 17@xmath269 & @xmath38152@xmath2611 & 0@xmath262 & 96@xmath2610 & 72@xmath2611 & 46@xmath262 & 2330@xmath26500 & 1370@xmath26710 & @xmath3850@xmath26330 + 4.5 & 19@xmath2610 & @xmath38158@xmath2611 & @xmath382@xmath262 & 93@xmath2611 & 76@xmath2611 & 46@xmath262 & 2180@xmath26480 & 3960@xmath26930 & 240@xmath26360 + the trend of the mean velocities with distance from the plane is shown in figure [ f_resmean ] . @xmath56 is consistent with no significant departure from zero in the whole range . some deviations are observed for @xmath602.5 kpc , but in this range the results are affected by large errors and , as already commented , not very trustworthy . this result agrees with previous studies , that found no net vertical motion up to various kpc from the galactic plane @xcite . on the contrary , @xmath61 has a more complex behavior : between @xmath1=1.5 and 3 kpc we detect a non - null mean velocity directed toward the galactic anticenter , with an average value @xmath54=@xmath623 km s@xmath3 . beyond 3 kpc from the plane @xmath54 abruptly increases and changes sign , and the net velocity between 3.5 and 4.5 kpc is 15@xmath262 km s@xmath3 toward the galactic center . another possible interpretation of the results is that @xmath54 linearly increases with @xmath1 , and a s - shaped feature is superimposed to this trend between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc , as observed for @xmath4 and other kinematical quantities ( see section [ s_comove ] ) . after the exclusion of this range , the fit returns a vertical increase of 15@xmath63 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 . adopting the new values of @xcite for the solar peculiar motion causes not a relevant change on the results , as @xmath54 would be higher by about 1 km s@xmath3 only . previous studies have shown evidence that stars more distant than 1 kpc from the plane show a non - null net radial motion of the order of @xmath69 km s@xmath3 toward the galactic anticenter @xcite . our results between @xmath1=1.5 and 3 kpc agree with their conclusion , although our mean value is larger by about a factor of two . the sign flip observed at larger @xmath1 , on the contrary , has never been reported in the literature . nevertheless , @xcite analyze halo stars , @xcite do not reach these heights above the plane , and @xcite have too few stars in this range . very interestingly , @xcite detect a small positive mean radial component out to @xmath64 kpc , and a negative value in their more distant bins , although the authors conclude that these results are consistent , within errors , with a null net motion . @xcite proposed that an inward motion of the local standard of rest ( lsr ) of the order of 10 km s@xmath3 is responsible for the observed non - null mean value of @xmath54 , as suggested by the fact that this is observed among both disk and halo stars more distant than 1 kpc from the sun . this hypothesis can not account for any vertical trend of @xmath54 other than a constant non - zero value at any @xmath1 . thus , while it is not contradicted by our results , at least another effect must be invoked . for example , an outward motion of @xmath625 km s@xmath3 of the stars between 3.5 and 4.5 kpc , coupled with the mentioned lsr motion , could explain our results . this clumpy kinematical distribution would not be surprising , because perturbations produced by the bar and the spiral arms are expected to form groups of stars with velocity offset as large as 50 km s@xmath3 @xcite . @xcite studied the proper motions of our same stellar sample , and their results for @xmath61 are overplotted to ours in the upper panel of figure [ f_resmean ] , after correcting for the solar peculiar motion and changing the sign of @xmath7 to account for the different direction of the reference axis . the agreement with our results is poor : while their nearly flat profile roughly coincides with our mean value ( @xmath387.7 km s@xmath3 ) , they did not detect any change of sign , nor a steep positive gradient . the different approach to the same data must have caused the different results . for example the features observed by us could have been masked in @xcite by their smoothed , statistical distance determination , or by dwarf stars and halo contaminants , removed in our work . in the middle panel of figure [ f_resmean ] we show the measured trend of @xmath65 , compared to other results from the literature . the mean rotational velocity of thick disk stars decreases with distance from the plane , due to the well - known vertical shear first detected by @xcite . the fit of the data , after the exclusion of the less reliable bins at @xmath602.5 kpc , yields @xmath66 ( km s@xmath3 ) . as can be seen in figure [ f_resmean ] , this solution excellently matches the results of @xcite , and even the data points of @xcite , at @xmath67 kpc , are well aligned with the derived linear relation . both these investigations measure a vertical shear of @xmath3830 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 , as also recently found by @xcite , and @xcite . had we fitted all the data points down to @xmath1=1.5 kpc , we would have found a steeper slope ( @xmath68 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 ) , at the upper limit of the range spanned by literature values , which vary from @xmath694 @xcite to @xmath701 km s@xmath3 @xcite . the revised values for the solar peculiar motion proposed by @xcite cause an upward revision of the results by 7.1 km s@xmath3 . @xcite and @xcite measured a shallower slope ( @xmath712.1 and @xmath622 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 , respectively ) between 0.7 and 2.8 kpc . while our results are compatible with theirs in our nearest bins , we find a lower mean rotational velocity beyond @xmath1=2 kpc . nevertheless , the different vertical rotational gradient found by these studies is not necessarily a disagreement , because they sample a different @xmath1-range , and the underlying shear is not required to be strictly linear . in fact , @xcite have proposed the non - linear relation @xmath72 km s@xmath3 from the analysis of sdss data . the combined data points of @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and of the present work , closely follow this equation ( see figure [ f_vall ] ) , and a fit in the form @xmath73 km s@xmath3 returns a very similar solution , with @xmath74 km s@xmath3 , @xmath75 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 , and @xmath761.23 . very noticeably , the results of four surveys finding a different linear relation are all well reproduced by a single non - linear curve proposed by an independent work . the underlying vertical trend of the thick disk rotational velocity is therefore most probably close to but not exactly linear , and better represented by a low - order power law . the vertical profile of the velocity dispersions is shown in figure [ f_disp ] , compared to other works from the literature . we excluded from comparison the results of @xcite , because they do not distinguish between different disk components , thus finding steeper gradients as a result of the mix of thin and thick disk stars . caution must also be taken when comparing the results obtained in different ranges of @xmath1 , because the underlying trend of the dispersions is not necessarily linear , and the gradient can assume different values . for example , the models of @xcite indicate that the vertical profile should be progressively flatter at increasing @xmath1 . the linear fit of the trends with @xmath1 yields : @xmath77 @xmath78 @xmath79 where @xmath1 is in kpc . the quoted errors were obtained restricting the fit to a subset of eight non - overlapping bins , to avoid the underestimate induced by the correlation between the data points . the results are identical to those of @xcite , despite the different binning scheme , except for @xmath57 for which we derive a slightly smaller gradient , but the difference is not significant ( 0.4 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 ) . the gradients are small , and the three dispersions increase by only @xmath67% between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc . this explains why the change of the thick disk kinematics with distance from the plane has not been clearly detected for about two decades after its discovery . the results for @xmath5 are the most precise and reliable , because @xmath690% of the information on @xmath20 comes from rvs , whose errors are an order of magnitude smaller than those in proper motions . @xmath80 shows a small but clear and constant increase , with small scatter around the derived linear relation . the vertical gradient is smaller than the one found by @xcite by about a factor of two , but the results are consistent at the 1@xmath48 level . @xcite propose an even steeper profile ( @xmath610 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 ) in the range @xmath1=02 kpc , but the same authors suspect that this could be due to contamination by halo stars increasing with galactic height . the dispersion of the rotational velocity component , @xmath57 , also shows a clear increase with @xmath1 , although the data points are affected by larger errors and are more scattered . the vertical gradient is smaller than the results of both @xcite and @xcite , by a factor of three and two , respectively , and the difference is at the 2@xmath48 level in both cases . the vertical profile of @xmath4 shows a very peculiar behavior , with large deviations from linearity between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc . this feature will be discussed in section [ s_comove ] . outside this range , the data points closely follow a linear relation , and the solution given in equation [ e_su ] was obtained excluding this interval from the fit . the derived vertical gradient of @xmath4 is very similar to that found by @xcite , but their solution is offset toward higher values by about 10 km s@xmath3 , while the gradient measured by @xcite is 4@xmath48 times higher than ours . in conclusion , we confirm that the velocity dispersions of the galactic thick disk increase with distance from the plane , as suggested by previous investigations @xcite , but we derive vertical gradients that are in general smaller than other studies . the differences with @xcite can be at least in part due to the aforementioned expected decrease of the gradient with distance from the plane , because the results for @xmath5 are consistent , and the solutions proposed for the other two components overlap in the @xmath0-range in common ( 1.52.2 kpc ) . on the contrary , @xcite studied our same sample , and the different data analysis must be the cause of the disagreement . since they measured both higher dispersions and steeper vertical gradients than us , their results could have been affected by the dwarf stars and halo contaminators removed by us , and/or the thin disk contamination , that they did not take into account . the three dispersions increase with distance from the plane proportionally , and the anisotropy is approximatively constant at all @xmath1 . in figure [ f_ratio ] the vertical profile of the ratios @xmath4/@xmath5 and @xmath4/@xmath57 is shown , where the errors come from propagation of the uncertainties on the dispersions . the mean value of @xmath4/@xmath5 is [email protected] , where the error was estimated from the statistical error on the mean for eight uncorrelated bins , as before . the linear fit of the data points returns a negligible gradient ( [email protected] kpc@xmath3 ) , and the data are consistent with a flat profile . literature values for @xmath4/@xmath5 span a wide range from 1.1 @xcite to 1.9 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , and our results are at the upper end of this distribution . as shown in the upper panel of figure [ f_ratio ] , the results of @xcite agree with our measurements in the z - range in common , but they deviate from our measurements if extrapolated to higher distance from the plane . the results for @xmath4/@xmath57 also show no significant gradient ( [email protected] kpc@xmath3 ) and a mean value of [email protected] . this is lower than the value predicted by the epicyclic approximation ( 1.49 , cfr . equation 3 - 76 of * ? ? ? * ) , indicating that the population under analysis can not be assumed in nearly circular orbits . our results are well within the range spanned by literature values , which vary from @xmath811 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , to @xmath811.6 @xcite . as in the case of @xmath4/@xmath5 , the results of @xcite overlap with our data points in the range in common , but their extrapolation to higher @xmath1 do not . the analytical expressions given by @xcite for @xmath4 and @xmath57 , on the contrary , return a value of their ratio much lower than our data points at any galactic height . this is probably due to their much higher @xmath57 , as shown in the middle panel of figure [ f_disp ] . the non - diagonal term of the dispersion matrix @xmath82 gives a measurement of the correlation between the @xmath47-th and @xmath83-th velocity components . in fact , if two principal axis of the dispersion ellipsoid are aligned with the @xmath47-th and @xmath83-th axis , we have @xmath82=0 , and the two velocity components are uncorrelated . the orientation of the dispersion ellipsoid of an old , dynamically relaxed population is related to the shape of the galactic potential @xcite , and can indicate the presence of non - axisymmetric structures in the disk @xcite . moreover , @xcite and @xcite have shown that the vertical tilt of the ellipsoid allows to estimate the flattening of the dark halo . however , calculating the expectation of a specific halo model through integration of orbits is beyond the scope of the paper , and here we will only present the observational results , for use of future works . our results for the three cross - terms are shown in figure [ f_cross ] . the profile of @xmath51 closely follows a decreasing linear relation up to @xmath1=4 kpc , but abruptly jumps to positive values at larger heights . this is probably due to the sign flip of @xmath54 analyzed in section [ s_comove ] . in any case , the results indicate that the @xmath7 and @xmath8 velocity components are correlated , and the velocity ellipsoid is titled in the radial - longitudinal plane . the rotation angle , i.e. the vertex deviation @xmath84 , was calculated in each bin by means of the relation : @xmath85 @xcite . the results are shown in the upper panel of figure [ f_angles ] . we measure a non - negligible vertex deviation , increasing from nearly zero at @xmath1=1.5 kpc to @xmath86 at 3.5 kpc . the linear fit in the range 1.54 kpc yields the relation @xmath87 . our results agree with @xcite , who measured @xmath88 at @xmath0=1.1 kpc . previous investigations evidenced that the vertex deviation decreases from @xmath89 for young populations to nearly zero for old , metal - poor disk stars @xcite . our results are not at variance with this conclusion if the vertex deviation increases with @xmath1 , as suggested by our observations , because previous studies were limited to small galactic heights . @xmath53 shows no significant deviation from zero in the whole range of @xmath1 , except between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc , as discussed in section [ s_comove ] . this indicates that the @xmath8 and @xmath20 velocity components are not correlated . on the contrary , @xmath52 is significantly different from zero , and steadily increases with @xmath1 . proposing a reliable linear expression for @xmath90 is not straightforward , because it shows irregular fluctuations . as expected by @xcite and @xcite , @xmath52 is always bound between zero and @xmath91 , the value assumed when the velocity ellipsoid is aligned with the spherical coordinate system , because we find that @xmath92 km@xmath93 s@xmath59 at any galactic height . we also find that the expression proposed by @xcite , obtained under the assumption that the ellipsoid points toward the galactic center and its axis ratio is constant in the spherical coordinate system , is a relatively good approximation of the measured value up to about 3 kpc from the plane , but the predicted slope is too shallow and the agreement with observations degrades with @xmath1 ( see figure [ f_cross ] ) . the tilt angle in the @xmath7-@xmath20 plane can be calculated , analogously to the vertex deviation , from the equation : @xmath94 and the results are shown in figure [ f_angles ] . we measure a slight increase of @xmath95 with @xmath1 , and the linear fit of the data , after the exclusion of two deviating points , yields the relation @xmath96 $ ] . the results agree with previous works at @xmath1=11.5 kpc @xcite , but not with the measurements of @xcite at @xmath971 kpc , whose sample is most probably dominated by thin disk stars . the dashed curve in figure [ f_angles ] indicates the value of @xmath95 when the dispersion ellipsoid points toward the galactic center , assuming r@xmath98=8 kpc . the tilt angle is constantly lower than this in the range 1.54.5 kpc , and the ellipsoid thus is directed toward a point located behind the galactic center , at a galactocentric distance increasing with @xmath1 from r@xmath99=2.3 to 9 kpc . orbit integration studies indeed predict this result @xcite , but the inclination is noticeably higher than the expectations , because theoretical calculations return r@xmath99=510 kpc at @xmath1=1.1 kpc . this could indicate that the galactic potential used in these studies needs to be refined to match the observations . on the contrary , the increase of @xmath100 modeled by @xcite is too steep , and their expectation @xmath95(3.5 kpc)=26@xmath101 is at variance with our results . @xcite showed that the vertical trend of the tilt angle is an excellent observational signature of the underlying gravity law , and it can be used as a test for the modified newtonian dynamics theory ( mond , * ? ? ? * ) , because its expectation diverges from that of the newtonian dynamics with distance from the plane . unfortunately , the calculations of @xcite are limited to @xmath972 kpc , and the range of overlap with our data is very narrow . the value of @xmath95 expected by @xcite at @xmath1=2 kpc is 12@xmath101 for newtonian dynamics and 10@xmath101 for mond . we find @xmath95(2 kpc)=@xmath102 and the mean of the five measurements in the range 1.8 - 2.2 kpc is @xmath103 , in excellent agreement with mond expectations . the linear fit presented in section [ s_resangles ] also implies @xmath95(2 kpc)=@xmath104 . however , we derive a vertical gradient ( @xmath105 kpc@xmath3 ) much shallower than the predictions of @xcite for both mond ( 5@xmath101 kpc@xmath3 ) and newtonian dynamics ( 6@xmath101 kpc@xmath3 ) . in conclusion , our observations agree better with the models that @xcite derived for mond than with those from newtonian dynamics , but the extension of @xcite calculations to higher @xmath1 , and to specific initial conditions for the thick disk , are required to perform a reliable test of the gravitational law . the vertical profile of @xmath106 shows a puzzling behavior between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc from the galactic plane ( top panel , figure [ f_disp ] ) , where the dispersion deviates from the linear trend . a similar feature is clearly observable in the trend of other quantities related to the radial velocity component @xmath7 , like @xmath54 and @xmath52 ( as already noted by * ? ? ? * ) , but deviations from the linear trend in the range @xmath1=2.53 kpc could be present even in other profiles , such as @xmath65 , @xmath107 , @xmath80 , and @xmath108 . the origin of this behavior is unclear . it is possible that a group of comoving stars , forming a sub - structure in the galactic thick disk , is affecting the measured kinematics between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc from the plane . in particular , the similarity of the profile of two totally unrelated quantity such as @xmath108 and @xmath106 is instructive , because it excludes the possibility that this behavior is only due to some bad measurements . in any case , the existence of a kinematical substructure among our stars can not be claimed on the basis of these results only . our targets are distributed in a very narrow range of @xmath109 , and the data do not provide any direct information about the radial behavior of the kinematical quantities . nevertheless , some indirect indication can be derived . manipulating the radial jeans equation in cylindrical coordinates in steady state , with the radial component of the force expressed as f@xmath110 , we obtain : @xmath111 where we also assumed that @xmath112 , @xmath113/@xmath114=0 , and that the density decays exponentially with both @xmath109 and @xmath0 , with scale length @xmath115 and scale height @xmath116 . inserting the observed quantities in the right hand side of equation [ e_jeans ] we can thus estimate , as an exercise , the radial behavior of @xmath4 . the large uncertainties involved prevent a precise measurement , but the comparison with the expectations provides a consistency check for the kinematical data here presented , because an unphysical result could indicate a problem with them . the results are shown in figure [ f_jeans ] , where we assumed @xmath115=3.6 kpc and @xmath116=0.9 kpc @xcite , r@xmath98=8 kpc , and @xmath117=220 km s@xmath3 . the data points are scattered around the mean value @xmath118 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 , following the behavior of @xmath106 discussed in section [ s_comove ] , with no clear vertical trend . in the nearest bins the results are partially consistent , but more negative , than what found by @xcite and ( * ? ? ? * @xmath119 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 ) , although neese & yoss refer to the thin disk . the observations show @xcite that @xmath5 should exponentially decay in the radial direction , with the same scale length of the mass density . this is often considered valid even for @xmath4 , under the assumption of a constant anisotropy , and @xcite found that this should be the best approximation at the solar position . the results also roughly agree with the expectation of this model , as shown in figure [ f_jeans ] . in conclusion , the presented kinematics implies a radial behavior of @xmath4 consistent with both previous observations and with the expectations of theoretical predictions . the presence of kinematical gradients in the galactic thick disk is a powerful diagnostic to discriminate between the various models of its formation @xcite , but unfortunately the model expectations concerning the vertical gradient have not been investigated so far . it would be interesting to compare , in the near future , the predictions of the various models with the observed trend with @xmath0 of the velocity dispersions . on the contrary , the radial gradient of the dispersions has been modeled in the context of thick disk formation through disk heating by the merging of minor satellites @xcite . the observations of @xcite agree with the results of these simulations , provided that a low inclination orbit of the merging satellite is assumed . a similar conclusion is drawn comparing our measurements of @xmath4/@xmath5 with the theoretical expectations of the merging scenario . in fact , the simulations showed that this ratio is strongly linked to the inclination angle of the orbit @xcite , and our result ( @xmath4/@xmath5=2.08 ) favors a small inclination angle , @xmath120030@xmath101 ( see figure 15 of * ? ? ? * ) . a low inclination orbit of the infalling satellite is also required to reproduce the rather large vertical gradient of the rotational velocity , found in this work as in previous investigations @xcite . on the contrary , the radial migration model predicts a much shallower gradient ( @xmath3817 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 , * ? ? ? * ) , incompatible with the observations . in conclusion , the models of thick disk formation have so far provided only fragmentary predictions about its kinematical properties , and our observations can not still be used to fully discriminate between them . however , we find that our results are consistent with the scenario where the thick disk formed through dynamical heating of a pre - existing galactic disk , induced by the merging of a minor satellite . moreover , all the kinematical evidence shows that , if this is the correct model , a low - latitude ( @xmath121 ) merging event is strongly preferred . we have analyzed a sample of @xmath6400 thick disk stars , measuring the variation of their kinematical properties as a function of distance from the galactic plane , from @xmath1=1.5 to 4.5 kpc . our results can be summarized as follows : * while the mean vertical velocity component @xmath56 shows no significant deviation from zero in the whole range , between 1.5 and 3 kpc , we find a net radial motion of about 20 km s@xmath3 directed toward the galactic anticenter . other authors have recently found evidence for a similar behavior , proposing an inward motion of the lsr , although our mean velocity is larger than their proposed value by a factor of two . however , we find that @xmath54 changes sign for @xmath1223 kpc , and that a radial motion of the lsr , although not excluded , can not alone explain this behavior . * the mean rotational velocity of the thick disk decreases with distance from the galactic plane , as found by many previous investigations . the linear fit of our data returns a gradient of @xmath2 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 , our data points and the results of three other previous works are globally better represented by a power - law with index 1.25 , very similar to what has recently been proposed by @xcite . * all the velocity dispersions steadily increase with distance from the galactic plane , closely following a linear relation . the gradients we found are , however , smaller than those proposed by previous works . * while the velocity dispersions increase with @xmath1 , the ratios @xmath123 and @xmath124 show no significant vertical trend . the observations thus indicate a substantial constancy with @xmath1 of the anisotropy . * we find a non - negligible vertex deviation , increasing with @xmath1 from values close to zero to @xmath86 at @xmath1=3.5 kpc . this is consistent with previous investigations , which found a very small vertex deviation of old stellar population close to the galactic plane . * the tilt angle steadily increases with distance from the galactic plane . as expected , the orientation of the velocity ellipsoid in the @xmath7-@xmath20 plane results , at any @xmath1 , intermediate between alignment with the cylindrical and spherical coordinate systems . according to calculations by @xcite , the tilt angle at @xmath1=2 kpc coincides with the expectation of mond , although the extension of their models to higher galactic heights is required to perform a conclusive test of the underlying gravitational law . * the vertical trend of many kinematical quantities show deviations from linearity between 2.5 and 3.5 kpc . the origin of these features is unknown , but it could indicate the presence of a sub - structure at this galactic height , such as a comoving group of stars . * the results are fully consistent with the model of thick disk formation through dynamical heating of a pre - existing galactic disk . if this is the correct scenario , a low inclination angle of the merging event is strongly preferred . however , not all the models proposed so far could be tested by our observations , and more simulations are required to obtain a detailed comparison able to discriminate between them . c.m.b . and r.a.m . acknowledge support from the chilean centro de astrofsica fondap no . 15010003 , and the chilean centro de excelencia en astrofsica y tecnologas afines ( cata ) basal pfb/06 . c.m.b . also thanks f. mauro for useful discussions . all authors acknowledge partial support from the yale university / universidad de chile collaboration . the spm3 catalog was funded in part by grants from the us national science foundation , yale university and the universidad nacional de san juan , argentina . we warmly thank w. f. van altena , v. i. korchagin , t. m. girard , and d. i. casetti - dinescu for their help and suggestions . allende prieto , c. , beers , t. c. , wilhelm , r. , et al . 2006 , apj , 636 , 804 amendt , p. , & cuddeford , p. 1991 , apj , 368 , 79 assmann , p. , fellhauer , m. , kroupa , p. , brns , r. c. , & smith , r. 2011 , mnras , 415 , 1280 beers , t. c. , & sommer - larsen , j. 1995 , apjs , 96 , 175 bekki , k. , & tsujimoto , t. 2011 , apj , 738 , 4 bensby , t. , feltzing , s. , & lundstrm , i. 2003 , a&a , 410 , 527 bensby , t. , zenn , a. r. , oey , m. s. , & feltzing , s. , 2007 , apj , 663 , l13 bienaym , o. 1999 , a&a , 341 , 86 bienaym , o. 2009 , a&a , 500 , 781 bienaym , o. , famaey , b. , wu , x. , zhao , h. s. , & aubert , d. 2009 , a&a , 500 , 801 binney , j. , & merrifield , m. 1998 , galactic astronomy ( princeton , nj : princeton university press ) , 1998 binney , j. , & spergel , d. 1983 , the nearby stars and the stellar luminosity , ed . philip , & u. schenectady ( n.y . : davis press ) , iau col . , 76 , 259 bochanski , j. j. , munn , j. a. , hawley , s. l. , et al . 2007 , aj , 134 , 2418 bond , n. a. , ivezi , z. , sesar , b. , et al . 2010 , apj , 716 , 1 bournaud , f. , elmegreen , b. g. , & martig , m. 2009 , apj , 707 , l1 brown , w. r. , beers , t. c. , wilhelm , r. , et al . 2008 , aj , 135 , 564 cardelli , j. a. , geoffrey , c. c. , & mathis , j. s. 1989 , apj , 345 , 245 carney , b. w. , latham , d. w. , & laird , j. b. 1989 , aj , 97 , 423 carollo , d. , beers , t. c. , chiba , m. , et al . 2010 , apj , 712 , 692 carraro , g. , van altena , w. f. , moni bidin , c. , et al . 2005 , aas , 37 , 1378 casetti - dinescu , d. i. , girard , t. m. , korchagin , v. i. , & van altena , w. f. 2011 , apj , 728 , 7 chiba , m. , & beers , t. c. 2000 , aj , 119 , 2843 cuddeford , p. , & amendt , p. 1992 , mnras , 256 , 166 dalcanton , j. j. , & bernstein , r. a. 2002 , aj , 124 , 1328 dehnen , w. , & binney , j. 1998 , mnras , 298 , 387 duflot , m. , figon , p. , & meyssonnier , n. 1995 , a&as , 114 , 269 evans , l. t. 1970 , mnras , 149 , 311 feltzing , s. , bensby , t. , & lundstrm , i. 2003 , a&a , 397 , l1 fuchs , b. , dettbarn , c. , rix , h .- w . , et al . 2009 , aj , 137 , 4149 fuhrmann , k. 1998 , a&a , 338 , 161 flynn , c. , & freeman , k. c. 1993 , a&as , 97 , 835 gilmore , g. , & reid , n. 1983 , mnras , 202 , 1025 girard , t. m. , dinescu , d. i. , van altena , w. f. , et al . 2004 , aj , 127 , 3060 girard , t. m. , korchagin , v. i. , casetti - dinescu , d. i. , et al . 2006 aj , 132 , 1768 gmez , f. a. , minchev , i. , villalobos , a. , oshea , b. w. , & williams , m. e. k. 2011 ( arxiv:1105.4231 ) gratton , r. g. , bragaglia , a. , carretta , e. , et al . 2003 , a&a , 408 , 529 gratton , r. g. , carretta , e. , matteucci , f. , & sneden , c. 2001 , a&a , 358 , 671 gray , r. o. , & corbally , c. j. 1994 , aj , 107 , 742 hamaker , h. c. 1978 , appl . stat . , 27 , 7 haywood , m. 2001 , mnras , 325 , 1365 hori , l. , & liu , t. 1963 , pasj , 15 , 100 horne , k. 1986 , pasp , 98 , 609 ivezi , z. , sesar , b. , juri , m. , et al . 2008 , apj , 684 , 287 jones , d. h. p. 1972 , apj , 178 , 467 juri , m. , ivezi , z. , brooks , a. , et al . 2008 , apj , 673 , 864 kent , s. , & de zeew , t. 1991 , aj , 102 , 1994 kobayashi , c. , & nakasato , n. 2011 , apj , 729 , 16 kuijken , k. , & gilmore , g. 1989 , mnras , 239 , 571 kuijken , k. , & tremaine , s. 1991 , in dynamics of disc galaxies , varberg castle , sweden , 71 loebman , s. r. , roskar , r. , debattista , v. p. , et al . 2011 , apj , 737 , 8 lutz , t. e. , & hanson , r. b. 1992 , asp conf . series , 25 , 257 lynden - bell , d. 1962 , mnras , 124 , 95 majewski , s. r. 1992 , apjs , 78 , 87 majewski , s. r. 1993 , ara&a , 31 , 575 majewski , s. r. , kunkel , w. e. , law , d. r. , et al . 2004 , aj , 128 , 245 milgrom , m. 1983 , apj , 270 , 371 monaco , l. , villanova , s. , moni bidin , c. , et al . 2011 , a&a , 529 , a90 moni bidin , c. , moehler , s. , piotto , g. , et al . 2006 , a&a , 451 , 499 moni bidin , c. , girard , t. m. , carraro , g. , et al . 2009 , rmxac , 35 , 109 moni bidin , c. 2009 , phd thesis , univ . de chile , 1 moni bidin , c. , carraro , g. , mndez , r. a. , & van altena , w. f. 2010 , apj , 724 , l122 neese , c. l. , & yoss , k. m. 1988 , aj , 95 , 463 ollongren , a. 1962 , baas , 16 , 561 purcell , c. w. , bullock , j. s. , & kaplinghat , m. 2009 , apj , 703 , 2275 quillen , a. c. , doughery , j. , bagley , m. b. , minchev , i. , & comparetta , j. 2010 , mnras , submitted ( arxiv:1010.5745 ) quinn , p. j. , hernquist , l. , & fullagar , d. p. 1993 , apj , 403 , 74 reddy , b. e. , lambert , d. l. , & allende prieto , c. 2006 , mnras , 367 , 1329 rocha - pinto , h. j. , maciel , w. j. , scalo , j. & flynn , c. 2000 , a&a , 358 , 850 roskar , r. , debattista , v. p. , stinson , g. s. , et al . 2008 , apj , 675 , l65 rybka , s. p. , & yatsenko , a. i. 2010 , kpcb , 25 , 309 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 schnrich , r. , & binney , j. 2009 , mnras , 396 , 203 schnrich , r. , binney , j. , & dehnen , w. 2010 , mnras , 403 , 1829 seth , a. c. , dalcanton , j. j. , & de jong , r. s. 2005 , aj , 130 , 1574 shapiro , k. , gerssen , j. , & van der marel , r. 2003 , apj , 126 , 2707 siebert , a. , bienaym , o. , binney , j. , et al . 2008 , mnras , 391 , 793 soubiran , c. , bienaym , o. , & siebert , a. 2003 , a&a , 398 , 141 spagna , a. , lattanzi , m. g. , re fiorentin , p. , & smart , r. l. 2010 , a&a , 510 , 4 skrutskie , m. f. , cutri , r. m. , stiening , r. , et al . 2006 , aj , 131 , 1163 smith , m. c. , evans , n. w. , belokurov , v. et al . 2009 , mnras , 399 , 1223 tonry , j. & davis , m. 1979 , aj , 84 , 1511 vallenari , a. , pasetto , s. , bertelli , g. , et al . 2006 , a&a , 451 , 125 van der kruit , p. c. , & searle , l. 1981 , a&a , 95 , 105 van der kruit , p. c. , & searle , l. 1982 , a&a , 110 , 61 veltz , l. , bienaym , o. , freeman , k. c. , et al . 2008 , a&a , 2008 , 480 , 753 villalobos , a. , & helmi , a. 2008 , mnras , 391 , 1806 villalobos , a. , & helmi , a. 2009 , mnras , 399 , 166 villalobos , a. , kazantzidis , s. , & helmi , a. 2010 , apj , 718 , 314 wyse , r. f. g. & gilmore , g. 2005 , astro - ph/0510025 yi , s. k. , kim , y .- c . , & demarque , p. 2003 , apjs , 144 , 259 yoss , k. m. , neese , c. l. , & hartkopf , w. i. 1987 , aj , 94 , 1600 yoss , k. m. , & griffin , r. f. 1997 , japa , 18 , 161 walker , i. r. , mihos , j. c. , & hernquist , l. 1996 , apj , 460 , 121 zinn , r. 1985 , apj , 293 , 424 zwitter , t. , siebert , a. , munari , u. , et al . 2008 , aj , 136 , 421 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in this article we revisit the notion of _ state _ : when it is preceded by the adjective _ pure _ it is commonly understood within _ quantum _ formalism as a unit ray in an hilbert space . we revisit the way a state is transformed through the action of an operator named _ quantum observable _ , and the way it evolves with the introduction in the formalism of an evolution parameter , i.e. a _ time_. hilbert spaces in quantum physics are usually vector spaces on complex numbers , and are infinite - dimensional for many of them . here , our approach is utterly minimalist , not only for pedagogical purposes , but also to show that quantum formalism applies as well to unexpected situations , far beyond our modelling of the microscopical world . it is minimalist in the sense that our departure point is the two - dimensional hilbert space on the real numbers , i.e. the euclidean plane , denoted @xmath5 , so familiar to us since , say , the kindergarden - grade 12 . think about the following quote extracted from common core state standards initiative @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ although there are many types of geometry , school mathematics is devoted primarily to plane euclidean geometry , studied both synthetically ( without coordinates ) and analytically ( with coordinates ) . euclidean geometry is characterized most importantly by the parallel postulate , that through a point not on a given line there is exactly one parallel line . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ besides parallel lines , _ vector _ is also a central concept of euclidean geometry , and the terminology associated to it can be a source of confusions , as exemplified by the following question asked on march 23 2013 at 22:15 on the site _ math.stackexchange.com_ , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i m trying to understand the difference between the sense , orientation , and direction of a vector . according to this , sense is specified by two points on a line parallel to a vector . orientation is specified by the relationship between the vector and given reference lines ( which i m interpreting to be some basis ) . _ _ however , these two definitions seem to be synonymous with direction . how do these 3 terms differ ? _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the most clear , detailed , correct in our sense , answer was given on january 1 2014 , at 9:44 , as _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ here is how i think of it , let s construct a vector from scratch using just two points in space @xmath6 , @xmath7 . draw a line segment between the two points @xmath6 , @xmath7 . the magnitude of the line segment is the `` length '' of the vector . the `` orientation '' of the line segment we can define as the angle that the line segment makes with the horizontal axis . to be clear this angle is measured counterclockwise from the positive @xmath8 axis and is an angle between @xmath9 and @xmath10 . ok so far we just have a line segment that is situated on the plane somewhere and we know how it is oriented , but there is no arrowhead yet . now the last thing you need is the `` sense '' , that basically tells you where to put the arrowhead and implies an order . we can define this vector as @xmath11 with an arrow over it , where you read it as the vector starting from @xmath6 and ending at @xmath7 . _ _ more generally you can define a vector by defining its magnitude ( length ) , its orientation , and then its sense . but keeping in mind , technically a vector is an equivalence class . so there are an infinite number of vectors which are parallel to each other ( have the same orientation ) and have the same sense or same choice of where to put the arrowhead ( there are only two possible senses , since the arrowhead can be placed on @xmath6 or on @xmath7 ) . but i do nt want to confuse you . usually we discuss vectors that are situated at the origin so we do nt concern ourselves over other equivalent vectors . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hence , a unit ray in the euclidean plane is an orientation associated to an angle @xmath12 , equivalently to a point of the upper unit semi - circle deleted of its left boundary point . it is the unit circle @xmath13 where diametrically opposed points are made identical , i.e. @xmath14 as a physical realization of this set , we immediately think of the compass without considering the sense , i.e , by identifying north with south , east with west , .... , or even better , to the familiar protractor shown in figure [ protractor ] . is clearly apparent on the picture , with @xmath15 , @xmath16 , etc , sign minus being attributed to the internal graduation.,width=480 ] the true compass orientations @xmath17 senses are described by the unit circle itself . in order to avoid notational complications , we consider in this paper states as elements of the latter , keeping in mind the possibility to view as equivalent two diametrically opposed points . now , multiplying a unit vector or a ray by a real number has a deep signification both in euclidean geometry as in quantum formalism , since it lies at the heart of the superposition principle , which states that any linear combination of two vectors is a vector , and that a new unit vector or ray is built from this vector , if it is not zero , by dividing it by its length . an appreciable part of the material presented here is borrowed from references @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . the article is organized as follows . in section [ r2dirac ] we briefly recall the definition of hilbert space before rewriting the language of euclidean geometry by using _ bra _ and _ ket _ dirac notations . we then describe _ pure _ or _ mixed _ states , and symmetric @xmath18 matrices as observables in these real hilbert spaces . in section [ intquant ] we proceed with the integral quantization of the circle , after a rapid survey of the method . this method allows us to give in a straightforward way the quantum counterparts of classical models such as functions ( and even distributions ) defined on the circle . some probabilistic aspects of the obtained quantum objects and of their _ semi - classical _ portraits are examined in great details . section [ evolution ] is devoted to the description of a quantum dynamics adapted to our model . indeed , an adaptation is necessary since we are supposed to use real numbers , vectors and matrices in our quantum formalism , and the latter can not be derived from the quantization of some phase space . such a classical object does not exist in our formalism , and so our quantum dynamics can not be derived from an hamiltonian system . if we want to use quantum dynamics _ la _ dirac , we are forced to introduce at a certain stage pure imaginary numbers . hence , the most general hamiltonian compatible with the equation ruling the quantum evolution of symmetric @xmath18 real matrices must be a symmetric complex matrix . on the other hand , we can deal with a formalism using real numbers only and leading to a kind of majorana evolution equation . then unitary evolution operators are just @xmath18 rotation matrices , as expected in two - dimensional euclidean geometry . in section [ entanglement ] , we address the question of entanglement of two systems with states in the euclidean plane . states of such objects are elements of the tensor product @xmath19 . now , because of the elementary identity @xmath20 , this tensor product is isomorphic to @xmath21 ( and also to @xmath22 ) . since the plane @xmath5 can be also viewed as the complex plane @xmath23 , we get the possibility of understanding initial entangled objects either as elements of the more elementary complex hilbert spaces @xmath2 , e.g. , the space of quantum one - half spins , or as elements of the quaternion field @xmath3 . this set of possibilities sheds an interesting light on entangled objects viewed as cat states in @xmath2 . the purpose of section [ magnint ] is to give a physical exemple of the quantum hamiltonian appearing in euclidean plane quantum dynamics . this is done by considering for instance a charged spin one half particle , e.g. , an electron , interacting with a magnetic field with constant direction in the plane . the demonstration rests upon an integral quantization of the 2-sphere @xmath24 viewed as the phase space with canonical coordinates @xmath25 , where @xmath26 has the meaning of an angular momentum and @xmath27 is the azimutal angle . in section [ conclu ] we present some interesting perpectives of generalisations of the content of our work , centred on the continuation of the game @xmath28 ( as vector spaces ) with @xmath29 ( as vector spaces ) , the latter cartesian product being given an octonionic structure . in appendix [ pararho ] we describe different parametrizations of real @xmath30 density matrices together with interesting properties . quaternions in different languages and their basic properties are described in appendix [ allsu2 ] , by insisting on their @xmath31 representation . in appendix [ unitsphere ] we present the integral quantization of the @xmath0-sphere which is needed to establish our result in section [ magnint ] . we first recall that a finite - dimensional hilbert space is a finite - dimensional real or complex vector space @xmath32 equipped with a scalar ( or dot or inner ) product @xmath33 or @xmath23 , between any pair of vectors @xmath34 , @xmath35 , with the following properties @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath38 , in are arbitrary complex or real numbers , and encodes the _ semi - definiteness _ of the scalar product . in the case of real vector space , the scalar product is fully symmetric and bilinear . hence , it is clear that the two - dimensional real vector space equipped with the usual dot product , i.e. the euclidean plane @xmath5 , is the simplest non - trivial hilbert space . we now adopt the dirac notations for vectors in @xmath5 after restoring the familiar arrow or hat superscripts and boldface symbols . given the orthonormal basis of @xmath5 defined by the two familiar unit vectors @xmath39 and @xmath40 , as is shown in figure [ r2fig ] , any vector @xmath41 in the plane decomposes as @xmath42 we also use in the sequel the column vector notation to designate @xmath41 with implicit mention of orthonormal basis , @xmath43 in such a way that the dirac _ ket _ and _ bra _ notations become transparent , @xmath44 hence , elementary matrix calculus allows to formulate scalar product and ( orthogonal ) projector in _ bra ket _ ( respectively in _ ket bra _ ) notations : @xmath45 since we view the euclidean plane as a space of quantum states , pure states are identified with unit vectors , discarding , as announced in the introduction , the imposed equivalence between opposed senses along the orientation support . hence , the unit circle @xmath13 in the plane is the natural set of parameters which distinguish these states . to each @xmath46 , polar angle of the unit vector @xmath47 , corresponds the pure state @xmath48 . in particular , with these notations and associated quantum terminology , the horizontal orientation " or _ spin up _ state is @xmath49 , @xmath50 is the vertical orientation " or _ spin down _ state . their quality to form an orthonormal basis is encoded in the relations @xmath51 together with the fact that the sum of their corresponding orthogonal projectors _ resolves the unity _ @xmath52 ( 60,60 ) ( 10,20)(1,0)30 ( 10,20)(0,1)30 ( 43 , 24)(0,0)@xmath53 ( 29 , 52)(0,0)@xmath54 ( 45 , 41)(0,0)(quantum ) state in `` spin representation '' ( 10 , 16.5)(0,0)@xmath55 ( 30 , 10)(0,0)@xmath56 ( 30 , 1)(0,0)@xmath57 ( 8 , 52)(0,0)@xmath58 ( 16 , 38)(0,0)@xmath59 ( 20 , 26)(0,0)@xmath27 ( 14,20)(10,15)[tr ] ( 10,20)(1,2)14 pursuing with our quantum terminology , the spin representation of a pure state lies in the form of the expansion or decomposition @xmath60 there exists another representation which could be abusively named `` phase space '' , as will become clearer in the next section . it is the `` unit circle '' representation given by the trigonometric function @xmath61 however , we should be aware that in our model there is no quantum observable underlying localisation on the whole unit circle , at the difference of ordinary quantum mechanics for which there exists a position operator , @xmath62 , underlying configuration representation , or a momentum operator , @xmath63 , underlying momentum representation . on the other hand , we know that in ordinary quantum mechanics there is no sharp localisation in the corresponding phase space @xmath64 due to the non commutativity of these two operators ( heisenberg ! ) . a similar situation is encountered here with the fuzzy localisation exemplified by the probability distribution families on the unit circle derived from , @xmath65 to the pure state @xmath66 corresponds the orthogonal projector @xmath67 given by : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the matrix of rotation in the plane by the angle @xmath27 , @xmath70 in quantum formalism , the projector @xmath71 is also called pure state . this designation is consistent with the fact that the projector ignores orientation , @xmath72 . then , _ mixed states _ or _ density matrices _ are unit trace and non - negative matrices of the form @xmath73 with @xmath74 the conditions express the non - negativeness of @xmath75 , i.e. @xmath76 for all @xmath77 . pure states are rank - one such matrices corresponding to @xmath78 , i.e. @xmath79 . more details are given in subsection [ ssecqcirc ] and in appendix [ pararho ] . a more enlightening parametrisation is given in terms of the highest eigenvalue @xmath80 , @xmath81 given in and polar angle @xmath27 , @xmath82 of the corresponding pure eigenstate @xmath77 pointing toward the upper half - plane . introducing the parameter @xmath83 , @xmath84 , the most general form of a real density matrix can be given , as a @xmath85-periodic matrix , in terms of the polar coordinates @xmath86 of a point in the upper half unit disk : @xmath87 this expression epitomizes the map from the closed unit disk to the set of density matrices . more precisely , each @xmath88 is univocally ( but not biunivocally ) determined by a point in the unit disk @xmath89 , with polar coordinates @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 . we check that for @xmath93 the density matrix is just the orthogonal projector on the unit vector @xmath77 with polar angle @xmath27 , i.e. @xmath94 . the parameter @xmath95 can be viewed as a measure of the distance of @xmath75 to the pure state @xmath67 while @xmath96 measures the degree of mixing " . a statistical interpretation is made possible through the von neumann entropy@xcite defined as @xmath97 as a function of @xmath98 $ ] @xmath99 is nonnegative , concave and symmetric with respect to its maximum value @xmath100 at @xmath101 , which corresponds to @xmath102 . the graph of @xmath99 as a function of @xmath95 is presented in figure [ srho1 ] . in fact , this function is the basic boltzmann - gibbs or shannon entropy in the case of two possibilities with probabilities @xmath80 and @xmath103 . as a function of parameter @xmath104$].,width=288 ] according to the canons of quantum formalism , a quantum observable is a self - adjoint operator in the hilbert space of quantum states , because self - adjointness is essential in the copenhagen - dirac - von neumann interpretation of quantum physics @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . indeed , the spectral theorem for bounded or unbounded self - adjoint operators is the key for ( sharp ) quantum measurement , as it was mentioned above . in our case , a self - adjoint operator @xmath6 is represented by a @xmath30 real symmetric matrix and its spectral decomposition reads in terms of the two orthogonal projectors corresponding to its real eigenvalues : @xmath105 an immediate example is provided by the spin representation , which is also understood through the superposition of the two basic projectors @xmath106 in terms of quantum measurement , this decomposition means that the observable `` orientation '' assumes two values only : @xmath107 , associated to the projector on the horizontal or spin up state @xmath108 and the other one , @xmath109 , associated to the projector on the vertical or spin down @xmath110 . those measurements of orientation with only two issues are sharp in the sense that the corresponding projectors are orthogonal . at this point , we understand why no angular sharp localisation can be established on the unit circle . by sharp localisation we mean the existence of an angle operator @xmath6 acting as a multiplication operator in `` angle '' representation @xmath111 . such an operator does not existe because no @xmath30 real symmetric matrix @xmath6 can satisfy the equation @xmath112 , for all @xmath113 . three basic matrices generate the jordan algebra @xcite of all real symmetric @xmath18 matrices . they are the identity matrix and the two real pauli matrices , @xmath114 any element @xmath6 of the algebra decomposes as : @xmath115 the product in this algebra is defined by @xmath116 which entails on the level of components @xmath117 , the relations : @xmath118 in this context , a pure state @xmath77 in the plane can be viewed as the eigenstate of a system , e.g. a spin @xmath119 , for the eigenvalue @xmath120 of the following operator @xmath121 whereas it is eigenstate of @xmath122 for the eigenvalue @xmath123 . it is interesting to notice that the density operator can be expressed in terms of @xmath124 as @xmath125 any quantization of functions defined on a set @xmath126 ( e.g. a phase space or something else ) should reasonably meet four basic requirements @xcite : it is a linear map @xmath127 : @xmath128 where * @xmath129 is a vector space of complex or real - valued functions @xmath130 on a set @xmath126 , i.e. a `` classical '' mathematical model , * @xmath131 is a vector space of linear operators in some real or complex hilbert space @xmath132 , i.e , a `` quantum '' mathematical model . the map is such that the function @xmath133 is mapped to the identity operator @xmath134 on @xmath132 , a real @xmath135 is mapped to a self - adjoint operator @xmath136 in @xmath132 or , at least , a symmetric operator ( in the infinite dimensional case ) if @xmath126 is acted on by a symmetry group @xmath137 , i.e. for @xmath138 , @xmath139 , then there exists a unitary representation @xmath140 of the group such that @xmath141 , with @xmath142 . in our case , @xmath132 is finite - dimensional and the operators @xmath143 can be viewed as matrices . of course , further requirements are necessarily added , depending on the mathematical structures equipping @xmath126 and @xmath129 and their respective physical relevance . an easy way to achieve the above minimal programme is to use resources offered by some adapted integral calculus . suppose that the set @xmath126 is equipped with a measure @xmath144 allowing to deal with integrals like @xmath145 , in which the functions @xmath146 are matrix valued , the integral being performed on each matrix element . now , suppose that there exists an @xmath126-labeled family of matrices @xmath147 resolving the identity @xmath134 in the following sense : @xmath148 the case we are specially interested in occurs when the @xmath149 s are unit trace and non - negative , i.e. are density matrices , @xmath150 because of their possible probabilistic content ( see below ) . with this material at hand , the integral quantization of functions @xmath130 on @xmath126 is the linear map @xmath151 which fulfills at least our quantization requirements ( i ) and ( ii ) and it takes the classical function @xmath130 to the operator @xmath143 . if the matrices @xmath149 are real symmetric , then ( iii ) is also satisfied . to get ( iv ) , i.e. covariance , we need to add more structure on the measure space @xmath152 . such structures will appear in a natural way in the examples we consider in this paper , namely the circle , @xmath153 , and the sphere , @xmath154 . any quantization map should be complemented by a dequantization " map , associating to @xmath143 a function @xmath155 , more or less similar to the original @xmath130 , and giving a semi - classical portrait " of @xmath143 . in quantum mechanics , examples are provided by the husimi function or the wigner function@xcite , more generally by lower ( lieb ) @xcite or contravariant ( berezin ) @xcite symbols . the terminology _ lower _ , which will appear below together with _ upper _ , is justified by the two berezin - lieb inequalities which follow from the symbol formalism . as a matter of fact , some properties of the operator @xmath136 , may be derived or at least well grasped from functional properties of its lower symbol , which is defined in the present context by : @xmath156 when @xmath157 ( density matrix ) for all @xmath8 , this new function is the local average of the original @xmath135 with respect to the probability distribution @xmath158 with respect the measure @xmath159 : @xmath160 in many cases , this generalisation of convolution has a regularising effect on the original @xmath135 . for instance , if @xmath161 is a dirac peaked at @xmath162 , @xmath163 for any test function @xmath164 , then @xmath165 , a function which is expected to be more regular around @xmath166 . here , the measure space @xmath167 is the unit circle equipped with its uniform ( lebesgue ) measure : @xmath168 the hilbert space is the euclidean plane @xmath169 . note that @xmath13 is also a group , isomorphic to the abelian group so@xmath4 of rotations in the plane . thus , we can expect that rotational covariance mentioned in point ( iv ) plays a central role here . it is indeed the case since the covariance property described in appendix [ pararho ] allows one to define the family of density operators obtained from rotational transport of the initial density operator introduced in , @xmath170 where the rotation matrix @xmath171 is defined by . it is straightforward to prove that this family resolves the identity @xmath172 the proof can be made by hand , integrating each matrix element . actually it is the direct consequence of a famous result in group representation theory , named schur s lemma @xcite . it follows the @xmath13-labelled family of probability distributions on @xmath173 @xmath174 such an expression reminds us of the cardioid distribution ( see @xcite , page 51 ) . at @xmath175 we get the uniform probability on the circle whereas at @xmath93 we get the simplified resolution of the identity @xmath176 and the pure state probability distribution @xmath177 previously introduced in . at given @xmath95 and @xmath178 a distance @xmath179 on the circle is defined as @xmath180 where the subscript @xmath181 refers to the hilbertian norm @xmath182 defined on matrices @xmath6 @xcite . the quantization of a function ( or distribution ) @xmath183 on the circle based on leads to the 2@xmath1842 matrix operator @xmath185 where @xmath186 is the average of @xmath135 on the unit circle and @xmath187 . the symbols @xmath188 and @xmath189 are for the cosine and sine doubled angle fourier coefficients of @xmath135 , @xmath190 the simplest function to be quantized is the angle function @xmath191 , i.e. the @xmath192-periodic extension of @xmath193 for @xmath46 , @xmath194 its eigenvalues are @xmath195 with corresponding eigenvectors @xmath196 . its lower symbol is given by the smooth function @xmath197 the existence of the set @xmath198 as the particular case @xmath93 and @xmath199 of the density matrices permits to proceed with the simplified coherent state " integral quantization @xmath200 the quantized version of the angle function @xmath201 introduced above becomes : @xmath202 with eigenvalues @xmath203 . thus , a localisation measurement on the circle would yield those two values only , along the spectral decomposition @xmath204 with @xmath205 the family of pure states @xmath206 allows one to carry out the symbol calculus _ la _ berezin - lieb mentioned above . to any _ self - adjoint _ operator @xmath6 one associates the two types of _ symbol _ , functions @xmath207 et @xmath208 respectively defined on the unit circle by @xmath209 and @xmath210 where @xmath208 is named upper or contravariant symbol of @xmath6 , besides the fact that it is also the classical counterpart of @xmath6 in the context of integral quantization . the simplest upper symbols and the lower symbols of non - trivial basic elements are respectively given by : @xmath211 for the symmetric matrix ( [ msym13 ] ) there follows the two symbols : @xmath212 for instance , the lower symbol of the quantum angle ( [ qangle13 ] ) is equal to @xmath213 a @xmath85-periodic function that smoothly varies between the two eigenvalues of @xmath214 , as is shown in figure [ quantangle13 ] . -periodic function @xmath215 that varies between the two eigenvalues of @xmath214.,width=384 ] one should notice that all the symbols defined above belong to the subspace @xmath216 of real fourier series that is the linear span of the three functions @xmath59 , @xmath217 , @xmath218 . hence @xmath208 is highly non unique since it is defined up to the addition of any function @xmath219 lying in the orthogonal complement of @xmath216 , i.e. such that @xmath220 . let us make explicit the berezin - lieb inequalities in the present context . let @xmath221 be a convex function . denoting by @xmath222 the eigenvalues of the symmetric matrix @xmath6 , we have @xmath223 this double inequality is not trivial . independently of the euclidean context it reads as : @xmath224 where @xmath225 and @xmath226 denotes the mean value on a period . if one applies ( [ berlieb13 ] ) to the exponential function @xmath227 , we get an intertwining of inequalities involving bessel functions of the second kind and the hyperbolic cosine : @xmath228 behind the resolution of the identity lies an interesting interpretation in terms of geometrical probability . let us consider a borel@xcite subset @xmath229 of the interval @xmath230 and the restriction to @xmath229 of the integral : @xmath231 one easily verifies the following properties : @xmath232 the application @xmath233 defines a normalized measure on the @xmath234-algebra @xcite of the borel sets in the interval @xmath230 , assuming its values in the set of positive or null @xmath30 matrices ( povm ) . let us now put into evidence the probabilistic nature of the measure @xmath235 . let @xmath236 be a unit vector . the application @xmath237 is clearly a probability measure , since it involves precisely the distribution @xmath238 introduced in . for instance , for @xmath239 $ ] and @xmath240 , we have @xmath241\right)= \frac{\theta_2-\theta_1}{2\pi } - \frac{1}{\pi}\sin\left(\theta_2-\theta_1\right ) \sin\left(\theta_2+\theta_1\right)\ , .\ ] ] now , the quantity @xmath242 means that direction @xmath243 is examined from the point of view of the family of vectors @xmath244 . as a matter of fact , it has a _ geometrical probability _ interpretation in the plane @xcite . with no loss of generality let us choose @xmath240 . recall here the canonical equation describing a straight line @xmath245 in the plane : @xmath246 where @xmath247 is the direction normal to @xmath245 and the parameter @xmath248 is equal to the distance of @xmath245 to the origin . there follows that @xmath249 is the ( non - normalized ) probability measure element on the set @xmath250 of the lines randomly chosen in the plane . picking a certain @xmath27 , consider the set @xmath251 of the lines normal to @xmath252 that intersect the segment with origin @xmath55 and length @xmath253 equal to the projection of @xmath252 onto @xmath254 as shown in figure [ probge13 ] ( 8,6 ) ( 5.1,4.9)(0,-1)3.9 ( 2.8,.6)o ( 7.5,1.3)@xmath254 ( 5.2,5)@xmath255 ( 3.1,1)(1,2)2 ( 3.1,1)(1,0)4.67 ( 2.1,1.5)(.1,.2)5(2,-1)2.7 ( 3.1,.1)@xmath256 0.5 cm the measure of this set is equal to : @xmath257 integrating ( [ measline13 ] ) over all directions @xmath252 gives the area of the unit circle . hence we can construct @xmath258 as the probability for a straight line in the plane to belong to the set of secants of segments that are projections @xmath259 of the unit vectors @xmath252 , @xmath260 , onto the unit vector @xmath243 . one could think in terms of _ polarizer _ @xmath261 and _ analyzer _ `` sandwiching '' the directional signal @xmath236 . as was asserted in the introduction , from a strictly quantum point of view , we should have made equivalent any vector @xmath263 of the euclidean plane with its symmetric @xmath264 , which amounts to deal with the half - plane viewed as the coset @xmath265 . following the same procedure as above , we start from the hilbert space @xmath266 and we choose the subset @xmath267 that is orthonormal . note that @xmath268 and @xmath269 are now exactly wigner semicircle distributions @xcite . we then consider the continuous family of pure states or coherent states @xmath270 . they are normalized and they solve the identity ( just change the factor @xmath271 into @xmath272 ) . the previous material can be repeated _ in extenso _ but with the restriction that @xmath12 . we now deal with the question of the existence of a quantum dynamics compatible with the simplicity of our model . let us introduce into the game a time ( or evolution ) parameter @xmath273 . can we associate with it a self - adjoint hamiltonian or energy operator @xmath274 , i.e. a @xmath18 real symmetric matrix @xmath274 ? a first problem concerns the construction of @xmath274 without the existence of a classical phase space as a guidance . let us circumvent this difficulty by simply postulating its existence . then , another issue makes our effort totally pointless . indeed , if we rely on the copenhagen - dirac - von neumann canons @xcite , the evolution of a time - dependent quantum observable or state is ruled by the equation @xmath275 + \ii \hbar\frac{\partial a}{\partial t}\ , .\ ] ] the presence of the imaginary unit @xmath276 in is unavoidable since the latter has to be a relation between symmetric operators acting in complex hilbert spaces . on the other hand , we want to keep the reality of our euclidean plane and of the matrices acting on it . thus , this number @xmath276 should be canceled because of its appearance somewhere on the right - hand side of . the only place where it can stand lies in the expression of @xmath274 as a @xmath18 complex symmetric matrix , and we easily check that the most general allowed matrix form of @xmath274 is @xmath277 actually the diagonal hamiltonian parameter @xmath278 does not play any role . moreover @xmath279 can be time - dependent . hence , no real symmetric matrix , except the trivial multiple of the identity , can represent an hamiltonian in the context of our approach . if we wish to keep real our matrices , we have to abandon the requirement of being symmetric . instead , let us introduce the real `` pseudo - hamiltonian '' @xmath280 then , by dividing by @xmath276 the evolution equation , one obtains an equation involving only real quantities , our _ baby majorana equation _ @xcite , @xmath281 + \hbar\frac{\partial a}{\partial t } \ , .\ ] ] the price to pay with our manipulation is that the eigenvalues @xmath282 of @xmath283 are real only in the trivial case @xmath284 : no physical energy comes out from our formalism . on the other hand , if @xmath279 is constant , the pseudo - hamiltonian @xmath283 may generate unitary time evolution . more precisely , in the case of time explicit independence of @xmath6 , the integration of is straightforward : @xmath285 i.e. the appearance of the @xmath30 proper rotation matrix in the plane as the solely possible continuous unitary operator in the plane is unescapable . in the case of the time evolution of a pure state @xmath286 , this solution corresponds to a uniform rotation , with frequency @xmath287 , of the unit vector @xmath288 . on the algebraic side , we note that our real quantum dynamics involves the antisymmetric matrix @xmath289 . together with @xmath290 and @xmath291 these 3 matrices generate the lie algebra @xmath292 of the group sl@xmath293 @xmath294= 2\sigma_3\ , , \quad [ \tau_2,\sigma_3]= 2\sigma_1\ , , \quad [ \sigma_3,\sigma_1]= -2\tau_2= 2\tau_2\,.\ ] ] if we had sticked to the complex formalism imposed by , we would have to introduce the third pauli matrix @xmath295 , which was missing in . then the self - adjointness of @xmath274 is preserved , and quantum evolution restores the full real lie algebra of su@xmath4 generated by the @xmath296 s , @xmath297 . actually , we will use in section [ magnint ] the equation for presenting a physical example of . the possible entanglement property of quantum states appears with the construction of tensor products @xcite of hilbert spaces for describing quantum states of composite systems . in the present case , we are in presence of a remarkable sequence of vector space isomorphisms due to the fact that @xmath298 : @xmath299 where @xmath3 is the field of quaternions ( see appendix [ allsu2 ] for definition and properties of these objects ) . let us first write the ( canonical ) orthonormal basis of the tensor product @xmath300 , the first factor being for system `` @xmath6 '' and the other for system `` @xmath7 '' , as latexmath:[\[\label{tensbas } these factors @xmath108 , @xmath302 pertaining to @xmath6 or to @xmath7 , are termed `` @xmath303-bit '' or qubit " in standard language of quantum information . they can be associated to a pointer measuring the horizontal ( resp . vertical ) direction or polarisation described by the state @xmath108 ( resp . @xmath302 ) . we now introduce the celebrated bell pure states @xcite in @xmath300 as special linear superpositions of the above basis elements @xmath304 or in matrix form , @xmath305 they form an orthonormal basis of @xmath300 . they are four specific _ maximally entangled _ quantum states of two qubits . `` maximally '' refers to the degree to which a state in a quantum system consisting of two entities is entangled . this degree is measured by the von neumann entropy @xcite of either of the two reduced density operators of the state , i.e. , obtained by tracing out one of the partners in the composite systems . they exhibit perfect correlation . consider for instance the state @xmath306 . if the pointer associated to @xmath6 measures its qubit in the standard basis the outcome would be perfectly random , either possibility having probability 1/2 . but if the pointer associated to @xmath7 then measures its qubit , the outcome , although random for it alone , is the same as the one @xmath6 gets . there is quantum correlation . let us now turn our attention to the complex two - dimensional hilbert space @xmath2 , one of the most familiar mathematical objects in our initiation to quantum formalism , after having been so nicely popularised by feynman @xcite with examples like two - level atom or spin one - half objects . now , as a complex vector space , @xmath2 , with canonical basis @xmath307 , @xmath308 , has a real structure . the latter is isomorphic to the real vector space @xmath309 , itself isomorphic to @xmath19 , from the above . a standard real structure is obtained by considering the vector expansion @xmath310 i.e. , by writing @xmath311 , @xmath312 , and considering the set of vectors @xmath313 as forming a basis of @xmath309 . now , we need to define a map from this @xmath309 to @xmath19 , forgetting about the superfluous subscripts @xmath6 and @xmath7 . for this , we use the map euclidean plane @xmath5 @xmath314 complex `` plane '' @xmath23 determined by @xmath315 or , in matrix form , @xmath316 interpreting @xmath2 as the space of quantum states of a two - level system , e.g. spin one - half with notations @xmath317 the correspondances and might be interpreted as giving a real composite nature to `` up '' and down " complex objects . note that the @xmath318-matrix on the right of is its own inverse . finally , we get the matrix map from the bell basis and the basis @xmath319 in terms of components of vectors in their respective spaces , @xmath320 equivalently , in complex notations , with @xmath321 , @xmath322 where we have introduced the conjugation operator @xmath323 , i.e. the mirror symmetry with respect to the real axis , @xmath324 being the mirror symmetry with respect to the imaginary axis . note that the operator @xmath325 can be expressed in the quaternionic language for su@xmath4 , as introduced in , by @xmath326 therefore , with the above choice of isomorphisms , bell entanglement in @xmath327 is represented by a linear superposition in @xmath2 . it involves also the two mirror symmetries @xmath328 . interpreting @xmath2 as in , we see that the operator @xmath329 is a kind of `` flip '' whereas `` cat '' operator @xmath325 builds from the _ up _ and _ down _ basic states the two elementary schrdinger cats @xmath330 we can now understand better the real bell state nature of these elementary cat superpositions if we remember the identification between composite real states and complex _ up _ and _ down _ basic states . interesting too is the appearance of the flip @xmath329 in the construction of the spin one - half coherent state defined in terms of spherical coordinates @xmath331 by @xmath332 indeed , they result from the action on the up state by the operator @xmath333 given in . this operator represents the element @xmath334 in su@xmath4 , quaternionic conjugate or inverse of @xmath335 . the latter corresponds through the homomorphism so@xmath336 @xmath314 su@xmath4 to the specific rotation @xmath337 that maps the unit vector pointing to the north pole , @xmath338 , to @xmath339 , as is shown in figure [ rotkton ] and explained at length in appendix [ allsu2 ] : @xmath340 now we notice that the second column of @xmath333 is precisely the flip of the first one , @xmath341 actually , this feature is the key for grasping the isomorphisms @xmath342 . with the notations of appendix [ allsu2 ] and using quaternionic algebra , e.g. , @xmath343 @xmath17 even permutations , @xmath344 after identifying @xmath345 , as both are roots of @xmath123 . then the flip appears naturally in the final identification @xmath346 as @xmath347 the fact that the sole acceptable form the hamiltonian may assume in our model is might suggest a kind of magnetic field interacting with some one - half spin magnetic moment . how can we integrate this physics in our toy model ? the ( potential ) energy of a magnetic moment @xmath348 ( whatever the origin of the latter ) submitted to a magnetic field @xmath349 is given by @xmath350 in the case of a moving charge , the magnetic moment is proportional to the angular momentum of the latter . here we consider a magnetic moment as a physical system on its own , without any consideration of space location or something else , and proportional to an angular momentum or classical spin denoted by @xmath351 : @xmath352 the factor @xmath353 is usually named gyromagnetic factor . now , the energy of a magnetic moment submitted to a constant magnetic field alone is conserved . choosing the direction of the unit vector @xmath354 , part of the orthonormal basis in space @xmath355 , as the same as @xmath349 , we have for the hamiltonian @xmath356 and so the polar angle @xmath357 is conserved : the magnetic moment experiences a precession about the @xmath354-axis at constant azimuthal velocity @xmath358 in such a way that @xmath359 is also conserved . actually , this precession motion which takes place on the surface of a sphere @xmath360 of radius @xmath361 has to be viewed as a phase trajectory in @xmath360 , the latter being as the classical phase space for the magnetic moment . the canonical conjugate coordinates are in the present case action - angle variables , the angle variable being the azimuthal angle @xmath27 whereas the action variable @xmath362 is precisely @xmath363 . indeed , from the expression @xmath364 of the rotational invariant measure on @xmath360 , one infers that @xmath363 is canonically conjugate to @xmath27 , and the action variable defined as @xmath365 is identical to @xmath363 in the case of a constant external magnetic field . note that the pair @xmath366 are a part of the cylindrical coordinates of the sphere @xmath360 with radius @xmath361 . let us turn our attention to the quantum model of a magnetic moment interacting with a constant magnetic field . following the integral quantization procedure of the two - sphere @xmath24 and of functions ( or distributions on it , as is explained in details in appendix [ unitsphere ] , and yielding the expression ) , the quantum version of the classical hamiltonian with @xmath367 reads as @xmath368 where the parameter @xmath369 plays the same rle as in . now , contrarily to our previous choice , we take the direction of the magnetic field along the unit vector @xmath370 , , @xmath371 . this new choice gives a quantum hamiltonian of the form , @xmath372 this formula leaves to us the freedom to choose @xmath95 and @xmath361 in order to comply with observations , for instance for the electron . we just remind that , in its quantum description , the electron _ total _ spin magnetic moment is given by the formula @xcite : @xmath373 where @xmath374 is the charge of the electron , @xmath221 is the land @xmath221-factor , and by the quantization equation along the direction determined by @xmath339 : @xmath375 where @xmath376 is the bohr magneton . basic aspects of quantum formalism have been presented in this paper , taking the euclidean plane as the simplest mathematical model to be considered in a pedagogical approach . the corresponding quantum dynamics has been given a physical flavour at the price of increasing the dimension from 2 to three in order to implement what we call integral quantization , and a simple illustration is presented in terms of magnetic moment . we have shown that entanglement , a central notion of modern developments in quantum physics , allows to follow an interesting path from the euclidean plane to the quantum one - half spin formalism and to the quaternionic language as well . now , this path can be extended in order to include entanglement of two @xmath119 spins and to give an interesting description of the latter in an octonionic language . indeed , like @xmath28 ( as vector spaces ) , we can continue with @xmath29 ( as vector spaces ) , the cartesian product of two quaternion field being given an octonionic structure _ la _ cayley dickson . this is the content of a work in progress . there are various expressions for a density matrix acting on the euclidean plane , i.e. a @xmath18 real positive matrix with trace equal to @xmath59 . the most immediate one is the following with parameters @xmath377 and @xmath378 : @xmath379 the above inequalities imply the following ones @xmath380 let @xmath381 be the highest eigenvalue of @xmath75 ( the lowest one is @xmath382 ) . the spectral decomposition of @xmath75 reads as @xmath383 where @xmath384 is the corresponding unit eigenvector , chosen as pointing toward the right half - plane . we could have as well chosen the opposite @xmath385 pointing in the left half - plane since @xmath386 . our choice corresponds to the most immediate one in terms of orthonormal basis of the plane issued from the canonical one @xmath387 through the rotation by @xmath27 . let us make explicit the decomposition , @xmath388 we derive from this expression the polar parametrization of the @xmath389 parameters of @xmath75 : @xmath390 in return , we have the angle @xmath391 $ ] in function of @xmath377 and @xmath378 @xmath392 in this way , each @xmath75 is univocally ( but not biunivocally ) determined by a point in the unit disk , with polar coordinates @xmath393 , @xmath91 , @xmath394 . also note the alternative expression issued from : @xmath395 where @xmath396 is the rotation matrix in the plane @xmath397 and @xmath291 is the diagonal pauli matrix @xmath398 in order to get the second equality in we used the important property @xmath399 therefore the expression of a matrix density to which we refer mostly often through the paper reads @xmath400 from and we derive the interesting multiplication formula @xmath401 and the resulting ( non - closed ! ) `` algebra '' of real density matrices , @xmath402= -irr'\sin(\phi -\phi^{\prime } ) \sigma_2\ , , \quad \{\rho,\rho'\ } = \rho + \rho ' + ( \cos(\phi - \phi^{\prime})- 1/2)i\ , .\ ] ] the expression is convenient to examine the way a density matrix transforms under a rotation @xmath403 in the plane . we have , @xmath404 the computation of the three following integrals is straightforward : @xmath405 @xmath406 @xmath407 @xmath408 where @xmath89 is the unit disk and @xmath409 . a convenient representation of rotations in space is possible thanks to quaternion calculus . we recall that the quaternion field as a multiplicative group is @xmath411su@xmath4 . the correspondence between the canonical basis of @xmath412 , @xmath413 , and the pauli matrices is @xmath414 , with @xmath415 . hence , the @xmath18 matrix representation of these basis elements is the following : @xmath416 any quaternion decomposes as @xmath417 ( resp . @xmath418 ) in scalar - vector notation ( resp . in euclidean metric notation ) . we also recall that the multiplication law explicitly reads in scalar - vector notation : @xmath419 . the ( quaternionic ) conjugate of @xmath420 is @xmath421 , the squared norm is @xmath422 , and the inverse of a nonzero quaternion is @xmath423 . unit quaternions , i.e. , quaternions with norm @xmath59 , which form the multiplicative subgroup isomorphic to su@xmath4 , constitute the three - sphere @xmath424 . on the other hand , any proper rotation in space is determined by a unit vector @xmath339 defining the rotation axis and a rotation angle @xmath425 about the axis , as illustrated in figure [ rotation ] . ( 40,40 ) ( 20,10)(2,1)30 ( 18,6)@xmath55 ( 35,12)@xmath426 ( 20,10)(-4,1)30 ( 16,20)@xmath427 ( 18,18)@xmath428 ( 17,26)@xmath339 ( 20,10)(-1,4)5 ( 0,10)@xmath429 the action of such a rotation , @xmath430 , on a vector @xmath429 is given by : @xmath431 the latter is expressed in scalar - vector quaternionic form as @xmath432 where @xmath433 or , in matrix form resulting from the identification , @xmath434 in which case quaternionic conjugation corresponds to the transposed conjugate of the corresponding matrix , @xmath435 in particular , for a given unit vector @xmath436 one considers the specific rotation @xmath437 that maps the unit vector pointing to the north pole , @xmath338 , to @xmath339 , as is shown in figure [ rotkton ] , @xmath438 with , in quaternionic matrix notations , @xmath439 @xmath440 ( 50,30 ) ( 20,10)(4,3)20 ( 20,10)(4,1)15 ( 18,6)@xmath55 ( 40,21)@xmath339 ( 33,9)@xmath441 ( 20,12.5)@xmath442 ( 27,11.5)@xmath442 ( 22,16)@xmath357 ( 17,28)@xmath354 ( 20,10)(0,4)23 the unitary irreducible representations @xmath443 of su@xmath4 are labelled by half - integers @xmath444 . for a given @xmath444 , the corresponding complex hilbert space is finite - dimensional , with dimension @xmath445 . the matrix elements of the linear operator @xmath446 in the basis @xmath447 are given by @xmath448 in agreement with talman @xcite . in the lowest non trivial dimensional case we are concerned with in this paper , @xmath449 , these matrix elements are given by @xmath450 hence , we have to be careful when we work with matrix representations of quaternions , due to the choice of basis . consequently , besides the `` canonical '' one , we use preferably ( and safely ! ) the notation @xmath451 for the @xmath30 matrix given by in the `` up '' and `` down '' spin basis , @xmath452 precisely , we have @xmath453 and for the particular case @xmath454 , essential in the construction of spin @xmath119 coherent states , @xmath455 we consider the unit sphere equipped with its rotationally invariant measure : @xmath456\ , , \quad \phi\in [ 0,2\pi)\ , .\ ] ] the hilbert space is @xmath457 . the unit ball @xmath458 in @xmath410 parametrizes the set of @xmath18 complex density matrices @xmath75 . indeed , given a 3-vector @xmath459 , viewed as a pure quaternion @xmath460 , and such that @xmath461 , a general density matrix @xmath75 can be written as @xmath462 where @xmath463 ( resp . @xmath464 ) are the cartesian ( resp . spherical ) coordinates of vector @xmath429 . we have used the representation @xmath465 defined by in order to avoid any ambiguity about the basis in which is expressed the density matrix @xmath75 . if @xmath93 , with spherical coordinates @xmath466 , then @xmath75 is the pure state @xmath467 where the column vector @xmath468 is the spin @xmath449 coherent state introduced in . let us now transport the density matrix @xmath75 by using the two - dimensional complex representation of rotations in space , namely the matrix su@xmath4 representation . for @xmath469 , one defines the family of density matrices labelled by @xmath470 : @xmath471 in order to get a one - to - one correspondence with the points of the 2-sphere , we restrict the elements of su@xmath4 to those corresponding to the rotation @xmath472 bringing the unit vector @xmath354 pointing to the north pole to the vector @xmath473 with spherical coordinates @xmath474 , as described in and but with an opposed sign for @xmath27 in order to get for @xmath93 . @xmath475 the value of the integral @xmath476 shows that the resolution of the unity is achieved with @xmath477 only . then , it is clear that @xmath478 it is with this strong restriction and the simplified notation @xmath479 that we go forward to the next calculations with the resolution of the unity @xmath480 note that the resolution of the identity with the su@xmath4 transport of a generic density operator is possible only if we integrate on the whole group , as it was done in @xcite . the @xmath24-labelled family of probability distributions on @xmath481 @xmath482 at @xmath175 we get the uniform probability on the sphere whereas at @xmath93 we get the probability distribution corresponding to the spin 1/2 cs , @xmath483 the quantization of a function ( or distribution ) @xmath484 on the sphere based on leads to the 2@xmath1842 matrix operator @xmath485 where @xmath486 is the average of @xmath135 on the unit sphere and @xmath487 and @xmath488 are fourier coefficients of @xmath135 on the sphere defined as @xmath489 since the sphere is a phase space with canonical coordinates @xmath490 , @xmath491 , and @xmath492 , the latter may be thought as the simplest functions to be quantized . we find for the quantization of @xmath303 @xmath493 its eigenvalues are @xmath494 with corresponding eigenvectors @xmath495 . its lower symbol is given by the smooth function @xmath496 the quantization of @xmath248 yields the diagonal matrix @xmath497 with immediate eigenvalues @xmath498 and lower symbol @xmath499 we note the commutation rule @xmath500 now , applying the quantization formula of the three components of the generic unit vector provides , as expected , the three pauli matrices , up to a common factor in agreement with general results given in @xcite , @xmath501 j.p . gazeau thanks cbpf and cnpq for financial support and cbpf for hospitality . curado acknowledges cnpq and faperj for financial support . the authors are grateful to pierre martin - dussaud ( ens lyon ) for helpful comments . for a quantum - mechanical system described by a density matrix @xmath503 , the von neumann entropy is @xmath504 , the last expression being actually its shannon form . it is zero if and only if @xmath75 is a pure state , i.e. , a projector . j. von neumann , mathematische grundlagen der quantenmechanik , springer , berlin ( 1932 ) . english translation by r. t. beyer , mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics , princeton university press ( 1955 ) . a borel set is any set in a topological space that can be formed from open sets ( or , equivalently , from closed sets ) through the operations of countable union , countable intersection , and relative complement . a very pedagogical explanation of the semi - circle law is given in the junior research seminar on probability , y. sinai , s. miller , l. silberman , @xmath505-functions , random matrix theory and ramanujan graphs , online at https://web.williams.edu/mathematics/sjmiller/public_html/mathlab/public_html/jr02spring/plfrmt.pdf ( 2003 ) . see the answer to the question _ what is the difference between cartesian and tensor product of two vector spaces ? _ at http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/710481/what-is-the-difference-between-cartesian-and-tensor-product-of-two-vector-spaces Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the last decade and a half have seen enormous progress in the description of light nuclei as collections of interacting nucleons with the same properties as in vacuum @xcite . after the formulation of potentials that fit nucleon - nucleon scattering data with high accuracy , _ ab initio _ calculations of nuclear structure demonstrated that the energy spectra of nuclei small enough for converged calculations ( mass number @xmath3 ) can be understood as arising from the vacuum nucleon - nucleon interaction @xcite . the addition of a three - nucleon interaction with only two to four parameters produces quantitative agreement with experiment for the nuclear binding energies and spin - orbit splittings , including the correct ground state ( @xmath4 instead of @xmath5 ) for @xmath6b @xcite . for nuclei with @xmath7 , methods using correlated hyperspherical harmonic bases or faddeev and similar formulations have solved bound - state , scattering , and reaction problems quite successfully @xcite . the _ ab initio _ methods that have been developed for @xmath8 nuclei are suited mainly to treatment of bound states , but there has been significant progress on unbound states in recent years . the green s function monte carlo ( gfmc ) method has been formulated as a particle - in - a - box method and used to compute phase shifts in the @xmath9he system with a full realistic hamiltonian @xcite . the no - core shell model ( ncsm ) has been merged with the resonating group method ( rgm ) to produce phase shifts and reaction cross sections in several systems using effective two - body forces without explicit three - body terms @xcite . the coupled - cluster method has been combined with a gamow shell model basis to compute complex energies @xmath10 of resonances and thus their excitation energies @xmath11 and total widths @xmath12 . it has been applied to resonances of he isotopes and @xmath13 nuclei , but it has not been used to produce cross sections @xcite . all of these approaches to scattering are computationally challenging , and significant human and computer effort is required for each individual system . even before the development of true scattering / reaction calculations in @xmath8 nuclei , there were accurate energy calculations for many unbound resonance states @xcite , produced by approximating them with bound ( i.e. , square - integrable ) wave functions and real energies . this approach is successful for states sufficiently narrow that important features of their structure can be accommodated within the model space . one way to understand these calculations is as approximations to gamow s decaying complex - energy states @xcite with energies near the real axis ( i.e. , small widths ) . quantum monte carlo ( qmc ) calculations of square - integrable `` pseudobound '' states begin with a variational monte carlo ( vmc ) calculation , in which a complicated but closed - form wave function containing large amounts of correlation is produced by minimizing the energy expectation value with respect to many variational parameters @xcite . the computational effort in the vmc method lies in computing energy expectation values by monte carlo integration over all particle coordinates , and a square - integrable wave function is necessary for both energy and normalization integrals to converge . the variational ansatz incorporates square integrability through particle correlations that decay exponentially at large separation , and reasonable energies result because the long - range tails of the true resonant wave function have small amplitudes relative to the `` interaction region '' where all nucleons interact . the second step in application of the qmc method to nuclei is a gfmc calculation . this step also requires square - integrable wave functions for evaluation of matrix elements . gfmc takes the vmc wave function as a starting point and evolves the schrdinger equation for imaginary values of the time @xmath14 through a series of small steps . this evolution filters high - energy contamination out of the wave function and for large @xmath15 leaves behind the lowest - energy eigenstate contained in the vmc starting point . for bound or narrow states , this procedure `` converges '' at large @xmath15 to a unique energy @xcite . for broad states the gfmc propagation drifts slowly toward the lowest available threshold ; even in very long gfmc propagations , the curve of energy _ versus _ @xmath15 for such states fails to flatten out at a `` converged '' energy . presumably this also occurs for the narrow states , but with a decline too slow to have been noticed in calculations so far . because the calculated energies of narrow resonances in the qmc methods are believed to be accurate , it is natural to ask whether widths could be extracted from these calculations , avoiding the considerable effort of explicit scattering / reaction calculations . attempts to correlate the width with the rate of decline of the energy , @xmath16 , in the late - time gfmc propagation failed , so the rate may depend more on the starting wave function than on the physical width @xcite . even in explicit scattering calculations , some widths are effectively too narrow to resolve by qmc methods . direct qmc calculations of widths so far consist of energy calculations for a series of specified boundary conditions @xcite , so the smallest width that can be computed must be larger than the energy resolution of the method . as an extreme example , the ground state of @xmath2b has a total energy of @xmath17 mev and a width of 0.5 kev , roughly 0.01% of the total . since the typical precision claimed for gfmc energy calculations is 1% , this width will not be amenable to calculation in this way . here i present a method to extract approximate widths from qmc wave functions . the basis of this approach is a relation between the partial width in a specified breakup channel and an integral over the `` interaction region '' where all of the nucleons are close to each other . this relation has been used in the literature , though not ( to my knowledge ) in explicit application to many - body wave functions . it has been used particularly in models of alpha @xcite and proton @xcite decays of heavy nuclei in order to avoid direct integration of the schrdinger equation to impractically large radii . it is also closely related to green s function formulations of scattering theory . there has been considerable interest in applying such formulations to _ ab initio _ calculations in the recent literature : they have been used to extract asymptotic normalization coefficients ( ancs ) from many - body bound states computed in various approximations @xcite and are coming into wider use for scattering problems @xcite . preparation for future reaction calculations of that kind is a primary motivation of the present work . although the integral relation can be used to compute the partial width in any two - body decay channel if wave functions of the parent and daughter nuclei are known , i confine my consideration in the present study to nucleon emission . i compute widths for all narrow ( @xmath18 mev ) one - nucleon decays to bound states in @xmath19 nuclei . i also present results for several specific broad states for which better theoretical information concerning widths would be useful and for some with unbound final states that are well - represented by pseudobound wave functions . the integral relation applied here can be used with either gfmc or vmc wave functions , extending even to use of the same computer routines . application to gfmc requires more computation and additional bookkeeping , so i have chosen in this initial study to use only vmc wave functions . this work represents the extension to unbound states of the methods presented in ref . the integral relation used here may be used with other many - body methods , but it is particularly well - suited to qmc wave functions because of its formulation as a short - range integral and because of the transparent treatment of fermion antisymmetry in the qmc methods . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : in sec . [ sec : derivation ] i motivate and define the integral method , and i discuss its accuracy and its connection to overlap calculations . in sec . [ sec : vmc ] i describe the application of the integral method to vmc wave functions . in sec . [ sec : results ] i present the results of calculations for specific states , compare computed and experimental widths , and consider how accurately widths may be computed from spectroscopic factors . along the way i present new ( and likely improved ) overlap calculations of vmc wave functions that may prove useful for treatment of transfer reactions . finally in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] i summarize my results and briefly mention future directions for this work . consider a many - body wave function @xmath20 at energy @xmath21 above the threshold for breakup into clusters 1 and 2 that have wave functions @xmath22 and @xmath23 respectively and no internal angular momentum . assume also for the moment that only this breakup channel is open . since @xmath22 and @xmath23 are spinless , the orbital angular momentum @xmath24 of their motion is equal to the total angular momentum @xmath25 of @xmath20 . given appropriate boundary conditions , @xmath20 at large separations @xmath26 of the clusters is a linear combination of an incoming wave proportional to @xmath27 and an outgoing wave proportional to @xmath28 , each normalized to probability flux @xmath29 in its appropriate direction at @xmath30 . ( for all special functions , i follow the conventions of refs . @xcite and @xcite . ) these functions depend on the energy @xmath21 through the wavenumber @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is the reduced mass of the clusters , and through the sommerfeld parameter @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the charge numbers of the clusters . @xmath36 and @xmath37 solve the radial coulomb - schrdinger equation @xmath38 with @xmath39 and outward and inward flux , respectively , at @xmath30 . in terms of @xmath37 and @xmath36 , @xmath20 ( assumed to have angular - momentum projection @xmath40 , omitted from subsequent expressions ) is , @xmath41/r_{12}.\ ] ] where @xmath42 is a spherical harmonic . in this single - channel case with both incoming and outgoing waves , the normalization @xmath43 is arbitrary . if @xmath44 and @xmath45 are real , conservation of probability guarantees that the effect of scattering is to multiply the outgoing wave @xmath36 by a complex phase factor relative to the incoming wave @xmath37 , so that the function @xmath46 may be written in terms of a real phase shift @xmath47 as @xmath48 . the function @xmath46 is the single - channel case of the @xmath49-matrix , which gives the amplitude and phase of outgoing waves in terms of specified ingoing amplitudes , and it determines the cross section uniquely . resonances in the scattering of clusters 1 and 2 occur at real energies near poles of @xmath46 and produce peaks in the scattering cross section where @xmath50 around some resonance with energy @xmath11 and width @xmath12 . @xmath49-matrix poles in general occur at complex @xmath44 ( and thus complex @xmath21 ) . it is evident from eq . ( [ eq : inandout ] ) that at such a pole the wave function takes the form @xmath51 with only outgoing flux . this is the same sort of decaying complex - energy state originally formulated in gamow s treatment of alpha decay @xcite . the probability flux out of this state is @xmath52 , so the normalization constant is no longer arbitrary but carries information about the size of the outgoing flux relative to the total wave function . if @xmath20 has been normalized to unit total probability in some finite region , its lifetime is inversely proportional to the outward probability flux . by writing @xmath20 in the form @xmath53^{-1 } i_l - o_l\right]/r_{12},\ ] ] and defining @xmath20 to have unit norm in some regularization scheme , it can be shown that the residue of the @xmath49-matrix pole is proportional both to the squared normalization constant @xmath54 and to the imaginary part of the pole energy @xcite . the relations among @xmath54 , the lifetime , and the pole location imply that the width @xmath55 . ( derivations that deal rigorously with the normalization of @xmath20 may be found in refs . @xcite . ) the width may thus be computed from the normalization constant @xmath56 . physically realized systems have real energies , so formulation of the width in terms of complex - energy gamow states is often inconvenient . for the qmc methods , not only is the energy real , but the wave functions are stationary waves , sums of incoming and outgoing waves with zero total flux in each channel . again assuming a single open channel of given angular momentum , a standing - wave solution is asymptotically @xmath57/r_{12},\ ] ] for some different @xmath43 than before . @xmath58 is the regular coulomb function that satisfies @xmath59 , @xmath60 satisfies the wronskian relation @xmath61 and the two are related to @xmath36 and @xmath37 by @xmath62 the function @xmath63 is the single - channel case of the @xmath64-matrix . ( [ eq : inandout ] ) , ( [ eq : outgoing ] ) , and ( [ eq : incoming ] ) combine to give @xmath65 so that @xmath66 . ( [ eq : standing - wave ] ) may then be written as @xmath67/r_{12}\ ] ] for some @xmath68 determined by an appropriate normalization of @xmath20 . at a resonance , @xmath69 and @xmath70 . this corresponds to a pole of @xmath63 on the positive real axis , so that @xmath71/r_{12}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the standing - wave solution at resonance is thus the sum of equal inward and outward fluxes , each of magnitude @xmath72 . this is the rate at which @xmath20 decays through the outgoing wave and is replenished by the ingoing wave . in analogy with the complex - energy case , it can be shown that the residue of the @xmath64-matrix at the resonance pole is proportional to @xmath73 for a wave function normalized to unity in a finite region @xcite , up to corrections arising from the choice of normalization volume . these corrections are small as long as the wave function has a much smaller amplitude in the asymptotic region than in the interaction region @xcite , as is expected for a long - lived resonance state . comparing eqs . ( [ eq : s - matrix - pole ] ) and ( [ eq : gl - norm ] ) , it is unsurprising that the result of a rigorous derivation is @xmath74 . i have sketched the considerations that lead to the connection between resonance width and wave function asymptotic normalization for the case of a single open channel and spinless daughter nuclei . these considerations carry over directly to _ ab initio _ wave functions , but it is necessary to account for complications absent from the toy model . most complications of the _ ab initio _ case amount to additional bookkeeping implied by multiple final - state channels , antisymmetry of the wave function , and daughters with nonzero angular momenta . multiple types of decay products may be emitted , and their non - zero internal angular momenta may couple in multiple ways . the simple right - hand sides of eqs . ( [ eq : inandout ] ) and ( [ eq : standing - wave ] ) are replaced by sums over all breakup and @xmath24 channels of a given total angular momentum @xmath25 and parity @xmath75 . the formalism to describe multi - channel wave functions in this case may be found in many treatments of reaction theory ( e.g. refs . the coefficient @xmath46 in eq . ( [ eq : inandout ] ) is replaced by a matrix @xmath76 that gives the outgoing flux in channel @xmath77 produced by unit incoming flux in channel @xmath78 , and @xmath63 in eq . ( [ eq : standing - wave ] ) is similarly replaced by a matrix @xmath79 that gives the irregular - function amplitude in channel @xmath77 produced by unit regular - function amplitude in channel @xmath78 . if the initial state in a reaction problem has amplitude @xmath80 in channel @xmath77 , then @xmath81_{j_a}\right]_{j } \left\{x_{a}f_{l_a}(\eta_a , k_ar_a ) + y_a g_{l_a}(\eta_a , k_ar_a)\right\}/r_a\ .\ ] ] in this expression , channel @xmath77 is characterized by daughter nuclei with wave functions @xmath82 and @xmath83 , wave number @xmath84 , sommerfeld parameter @xmath85 , and daughter separation @xmath86 . the orbital angular momentum of this channel is @xmath87 , and the square brackets denote coupling of the daughter angular momenta @xmath88 and @xmath87 first to `` @xmath89-coupled '' angular momentum @xmath90 and then with @xmath88 to form total angular momentum @xmath25 . ( the use of this coupling anticipates its later utility in defining channels in qmc wave functions . ) the antisymmetrization operator @xmath91 carries out an antisymmetric sum over all partitions of nucleons into daughters @xmath92 and @xmath93 with mass numbers @xmath94 and @xmath95 and multiplies by the normalization @xmath96 . the index @xmath77 is taken to specify the daughter nuclei as well as the channel quantum numbers @xmath90 , @xmath97 , @xmath88 , @xmath87 , and @xmath98 . away from resonance , the irregular - function amplitudes are given by @xmath99 . at a pole of @xmath79 , all asymptotic channels that are coupled to the resonance have wave functions proportional to @xmath100 . then the corresponding @xmath80 are irrelevant and may be set to zero . if @xmath20 at a pole is normalized to unit probability within some finite volume that includes the whole interaction region , the residue of @xmath101 is proportional to @xmath102 @xcite . the partial width of the resonance in channel @xmath77 is proportional to this residue , just as it was in the single - channel case discussed above @xcite . it can be shown that the imaginary part of the corresponding @xmath49-matrix pole energy is proportional to the sum of these partial widths @xcite , so the pole residues give the partial widths , whereas the @xmath49-matrix pole location gives only the total width . the channel radial functions defined by the summed terms in eq . ( [ eq : kmatrix - multichannel ] ) can be isolated from @xmath20 by projecting it onto the channel functions @xmath103 where the channel function in a given partition @xmath104 of the nucleons into clusters is @xmath105_{j_a}\right]_{j}\ , \\ { \bm\xi}_{ai } & = & { \bm\xi}_{ai}^p \equiv \left\{\mathbf{r}_j - \mathbf{r}_{ai}\right\},~j\in~ai\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath106 are the internal coordinates of @xmath107 , written in terms of nucleon coordinates in the specified partition @xmath104 as differences @xmath108 of the coordinates @xmath109 of nucleons within daughter @xmath110 and the center of mass of daughter @xmath110 . the daughter centers of mass @xmath111 are related to their separation @xmath112 by @xmath113 using bracket notation to indicate inner product in nucleon spin - isospin space and integration over all nucleon coordinates @xmath114 , @xmath115_{j_a}\right]_{j}^\dag \frac{\delta(r_a - r)}{r_a^2}\psi d^{3a}r,\ ] ] which for an exact solution of the hamiltonian gives the overlap function @xmath116 it is this function that multiplies the daughter wave functions in eq . ( [ eq : kmatrix - multichannel ] ) . ( formally the integral extends over only @xmath117 coordinates , because center - of - mass motion is irrelevant . the wave functions used in nuclear qmc calculations are translationally invariant , allowing the integral to be written as extending over all coordinates ; the effect of center - of - mass motion cancels out when dividing computed quantities by the wave function normalization . ) ( [ eq : gl - norm ] ) suggests that the partial width of a real - energy resonance state may be found by first computing @xmath20 at resonance and then projecting onto the desired channel and dividing by @xmath118 to obtain the partial width @xmath119 this approach is useful when @xmath20 can be computed accurately in the large-@xmath120 region ( as in ref . however , it often happens that @xmath20 is computed accurately in the interaction region , but computation in the asymptotic region described by eq . ( [ eq : kmatrix - multichannel ] ) is difficult or inconvenient . a more robust approach proceeds through a green s function formalism . one begins with the schrdinger equation , @xmath121 with @xmath122 the hamiltonian operator and @xmath21 the energy . to isolate a particular channel @xmath77 , as defined above , it is useful to choose a partition @xmath104 of nucleons into the daughter nuclei in that channel and write @xmath122 as a sum of parts internal to the daughters and parts that depend on their relative motion . working in the center - of - mass frame , @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the kinetic energy of relative motion of the daughters . the operator @xmath125 is the part of the hamiltonian ( kinetic plus potential ) involving only the coordinates @xmath126 within daughter @xmath110 . @xmath127 contains the remaining terms of the potential , consisting of interactions between nucleons in daughter 1 and nucleons in daughter 2 : @xmath128 this is _ not _ an effective interaction but rather the sum of all terms of the many - body potential ( with two - body terms @xmath129 and three - body terms @xmath130 ) linking the two daughters . the point - coulomb interaction between daughters , @xmath131 , is added and subtracted for reasons that will become apparent later ; it is zero if one of the daughters is a neutron . the energy @xmath21 may be similarly broken up into the sum of the daughter internal energies @xmath132 and the channel energy @xmath133 : @xmath134 then eq . ( [ eq : schroedinger ] ) becomes @xmath135 rearranging terms and multiplying by the operator @xmath136^{-1}$ ] , we find @xmath137^{-1 } \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\\ & & - \left[t_{a , p } + v^a_c - e_a\right]^{-1 } \left(h_1^{a , p } + h_2^{a , p } - e_{a1 } - e_{a2}\right)\psi\ . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the next step is to project @xmath20 onto channel @xmath77 , as in eq . ( [ eq : projection ] ) . projection of eq . ( [ eq : broken - up ] ) onto a channel function @xmath138 of eq . ( [ eq : channel - single - partition ] ) gives @xmath139^\dag\psi & = & -\left[\tilde{\phi}_{a , p}(\mathbf{r}_a^\prime)\right]^\dag \left[t_{a , p } + v^a_c - e_a\right]^{-1 } \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\\ & & - \left[\tilde\phi_{a , p}(\mathbf{r}_a^\prime)\right]^\dag \left[t_{a , p } + v^a_c - e_a\right]^{-1 } \left(h^{a , p}_1 + h^{a , p}_2 - e_{a1 } - e_{a2}\right)\psi \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( abbreviating @xmath140 on the right side by omitting the cluster internal coordinates ) , but since @xmath141 the second line of eq . ( [ eq : channel - projection ] ) is zero , and @xmath142^\dag\psi = -\left[\tilde\phi_{a , p}(\mathbf{r}_a^\prime)\right]^\dag \left[t_{a , p } + v^a_c - e_a\right]^{-1 } \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\ .\ ] ] now , the operator @xmath143^{-1}$ ] takes functions of nucleon coordinates @xmath144 to functions of nucleon coordinates @xmath145 with different values of the separation @xmath112 but with the @xmath108 untouched . its application to a function @xmath146 and projection onto a second function @xmath147 may be written as an integral over a green s function that contains a product of coulomb wave functions : @xmath148^{-1}\phi_1(\mathbf{r } ) = \frac{2\mu}{\hbar^2k_a}\phi_2^\dag(\mathbf{r}^\prime ) \int d^3 r_a\ \frac{f_{l_a}\!(\eta_a , k_ar_<)g_{l_a}\!(\eta_a , k_ar_>)}{r _ < r _ > } y_{l_a}(\mathbf{\hat{r}}_a^\prime)y_{l_a}^\ast(\mathbf{\hat{r}}_a ) \phi_1(\mathbf{r}),\ ] ] following the usual notation that @xmath149 denotes the smaller of @xmath86 ( a jacobi coordinate specified for partition @xmath104 by @xmath144 ) and @xmath150 ( specified by @xmath104 and @xmath145 ) , while @xmath151 denotes the larger of @xmath86 and @xmath150 . rewriting eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) in terms of eq . ( [ eq : better - channel - projection ] ) and applying eq . ( [ eq : greens - function ] ) , the result of integration over @xmath152 and antisymmetrization over partitions @xmath104 is @xmath153^\dag \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\ , d^{3a}r \right.\\\nonumber & & \left . + \frac{f_{l_a}\!(\eta_a , k_ar)}{r } \left\{b_{a,\infty } + \mathcal{a}_a\int_{r_a > r } \frac{g_{l_a}\!(\eta_a , k_ar_a)}{r_a } \left[\tilde\phi_{a , p}(\mathbf{r}_a)\right]^\dag \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\ , d^{3a}r \right\ } \right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constant of integration @xmath154 can be determined from @xmath20 as in ref . @xcite ; as discussed below , @xmath155 at resonance . finally , i denote the integrals in eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) by @xmath156^\dag \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\ , d^{3a}r\\ \label{eq : g - norm - integral } c_a(r ) & = & \frac{2\mu}{\hbar^2k_a } \mathcal{a}_a\int_{r_a < r } \frac{f_{l_a}\!(\eta_a , k_ar_a)}{r_a } \left[\tilde\phi_{a , p}(\mathbf{r}_a)\right]^\dag \left({\ensuremath{u_\mathrm{rel}}}^{a , p } - v^a_c\right)\psi\ , d^{3a}r\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that @xmath157f_l(\eta_a , k_ar ) + c_a(r)g_l(\eta_a , k_ar)\right\}/r.\ ] ] many derivations of eq . ( [ eq : integral - schematic ] ) and equivalent ( through analytic continuation ) bound - state expressions may be found in the literature ( e.g. refs . @xcite ) . several observations may be made at this point . the choice to add and subtract the point - coulomb interaction @xmath158 in eq . ( [ eq : h - breakdown ] ) has two important consequences . first , it guarantees that the overlap @xmath159 computed from eq . ( [ eq : integral - schematic ] ) is a linear combination of @xmath160 and @xmath161 , as required for solutions of the schrdinger equation governing @xmath20 . second , the nuclear interaction is short ranged , so that at large separations , the interaction between daughter nuclei is dominated by the monopole term of their coulomb interaction . since this is just equal to @xmath158 , the difference @xmath162 goes rapidly to zero for @xmath120 beyond the range of the nuclear interaction . for the interactions and wave functions discussed below , this typically happens at @xmath163 fm . thus , @xmath164 , and @xmath165 takes on approximately its asymptotic value for all @xmath166 fm . these two properties make eq . ( [ eq : integral - schematic ] ) especially useful for computing asymptotic properties of @xmath20 . indeed , similar integrals tend to appear in scattering theory for exactly this reason . comparison of eqs . ( [ eq : integral - schematic ] ) and ( [ eq : standing - wave - trig ] ) shows that since @xmath167 , @xmath168 as discussed in many places in the literature ( e.g. @xcite ) . in fact , eq . ( [ eq : kmatrix - integral ] ) may be improved upon significantly to yield estimates of @xmath101 that are second - order variational in approximations to @xmath20 @xcite . ( these improvements require considerably more computation , so i do not pursue them here . ) from the discussion in sec . [ sec : plausibility - and - channel - setup ] , at resonance there is no contribution from the regular function so that @xmath155 and @xmath101 has a pole . the residue of @xmath101 at this pole ( for @xmath20 normalized to unity within some radius @xmath169 that contains the interaction region ) is @xmath170 up to corrections of order @xmath171\ , , \ ] ] discussed in refs . it is easy to show from eq . ( [ eq : k - from - s ] ) that the residue of the @xmath49-matrix pole is twice the residue of the corresponding @xmath64-matrix pole , and thus the partial width of the resonance in channel @xmath77 is given by @xmath172 again up to corrections of order @xmath173 . since the integral defining @xmath174 ( eq . ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) ) is short - ranged , eq . ( [ eq : gamma - from - c ] ) for the partial width may be formulated as the square of a straightforward integral over all nucleon coordinates without specifying a boundary . this result for the width is easily generalized to include bound states . these occur at negative energy , @xmath175 , so that @xmath176 and @xmath177 . since they must be square - integrable , their overlap functions are asymptotically @xmath178 for purely imaginary @xmath84 , @xmath36 is proportional to the whittaker function , @xmath179 . working with analytic continuations of the linearly - independent pair of functions @xmath160 and @xmath36 instead of @xmath160 and @xmath161 , an integral relation analogous to eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) may be derived . it yields a result for @xmath180 that is guaranteed to have the correct form ( eq . ( [ eq : bound - as - outgoing - wf ] ) ) at large @xmath120 even if it is generated from an approximate @xmath20 that does not solve the schrdinger equation exactly . in fact , an early use of integral relations of the form considered here was to produce overlaps with the correct asymptotic behavior from asymptotically - incorrect hartree - fock wave functions @xcite . they have been used more recently to compute the asymptotic normalizations @xmath181 defined by @xmath182 from shell - model and _ ab initio _ wave functions @xcite . it is evident from the discussion above that a variational approximation to the wave function @xmath20 allows two calculations of @xmath180 : one from the definition in eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) and one from the integral relation of eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) . if @xmath20 , @xmath183 , and @xmath184 are all eigenstates of their respective hamiltonians , both methods yield the same result . in a typical application of many - body methods , @xmath20 is quite accurate in the interaction region but inaccurate where the daughter nuclei are widely separated . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) yields @xmath180 that is only as accurate as @xmath20 is at @xmath120 and is not guaranteed to have the correct form at large @xmath120 . if @xmath185 is computed from eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) , its value at any radius depends only on the values of @xmath20 within the interaction region ( apart from the integration constant @xmath154 , which is nonzero only for nonresonant open channels ) . at large radius the correct asymptotic shape is guaranteed . it seems likely that since eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) incorporates the hamiltonian directly ( through @xmath186 ) and not just through the approximate @xmath20 , it is also more accurate at smaller @xmath120 than the directly - computed @xmath180 @xcite . in the following calculations i use variational wave functions that were computed by the vmc method . they are approximate solutions for a hamiltonian consisting of the sum of the argonne @xmath187 ( av18 ) two - body @xcite and urbana ix ( uix ) three - body @xcite interactions , which appear both in the computation of the wave functions and in the operator @xmath186 used in the integral relation . in this section i describe enough of the structure of the vmc @xmath104-shell wave functions to discuss their asymptotic properties , i explain the implementation of the integral relation , and i finally comment on the asymptotics of the wave functions . the wave functions are described in detail in ref . @xcite . the vmc wave functions begin with the spin - isospin function @xmath188 , in which the spins and isospins of the first four particles are organized into a slater determinant like those of a filled , @xmath189-particle - like @xmath190 shell . ( the zeroes denote the total angular momentum @xmath25 , its projection @xmath191 , the total isospin @xmath192 , and its projection @xmath193 ; this notation follows conventions in previous qmc work and should not be confused with the channel function @xmath194 ) . the addition of further particles while retaining antisymmetry requires spatial dependence in the wave function , i.e. , placing particles into the @xmath104-shell . this is done using orbitals @xmath195}(r_{\alpha i})$ ] defined in terms of the separation @xmath196 of particle @xmath110 from the center of mass of the `` alpha core . '' the orbitals are derived from woods - saxon potential wells and coupled to form states of definite angular momentum , parity , spatial symmetry , and isospin in an @xmath197-coupled basis , and they fall off exponentially at large @xmath196 . the effects of pairwise interactions between nucleons ( through the av18 potential ) are then accounted for using two - body scalar correlations @xmath198 that mainly account for particles avoidance of the repulsive core of the potential and are functions of the separation @xmath199 of particles @xmath110 and @xmath200 . it has been found advantageous to allow different scalar correlations depending on whether particles @xmath110 and @xmath200 are both in the @xmath201-shell ( @xmath202 ) , both in the @xmath104-shell ( @xmath203 ) , or one in each ( @xmath204 ) . finally , there are analogous three - body scalar correlations ( @xmath205 , @xmath206 ) due to both two- and three - body interactions . all of these elements ( @xmath189 core , @xmath197 coupled orbitals , and scalar correlations ) are antisymmetrized among particle permutations to make up the jastrow wave function : @xmath207 } \big ( \beta_{ls[n ] } \phi_a(ls[n]jmtt_{z})_{p } \big ) \right\ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the index @xmath208 denotes a specific permutation of the particles into @xmath201- and @xmath104-shells ( subsequently antisymmetrized by the operator @xmath209 ) and the amplitudes @xmath210}$ ] specify the admixtures of @xmath104-shell @xmath197 states of young diagram @xmath211 $ ] . in turn , the configuration of good @xmath212 , j , m , t,$ ] and @xmath193 is given by @xmath213tt_{z})_p & = & \phi_{\alpha}(0 0 0 0)_{1234 } \prod_{5\leq i\leq a } \phi^{ls[n]}_{p}(r_{\alpha i } ) \nonumber \\ & & \times \left [ \left[\prod_{5\leq j\leq a}y_{1m_j}(\hat{r}_{\alpha j } ) \right]_{lm_l } \otimes \left[\prod_{5\leq k \leq a}\chi_k ( \frac{1}{2}m_k)\right]_{sm_s } \right]_{jm } \nonumber \\ & & \times \left[\prod_{5\leq l\leq a}\nu_{l}(\frac{1}{2}t_z)\right]_{tt_z } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the spinors @xmath214 and @xmath215 specify the angular momentum and isospin states of particle @xmath110 . because the hamiltonian includes operator as well as scalar terms ( i.e. , it acts on particle spins and isospins ) , there are operator correlations in addition to central correlations . these are accounted for by writing the variational trial function as @xmath216 where @xmath217 and @xmath218 are two- and three - body operators , and @xmath219 is a symmetrization operator , needed to preserve the antisymmetry of @xmath220 because the @xmath217 and @xmath218 do not commute amongst themselves . the operator correlations are of the form @xmath221 u_q(r_{ij } ) o^q_{ij } \ , \ ] ] where @xmath222 is an operator - independent three - body correlation , and the operators @xmath223 , @xmath224 , @xmath225 , @xmath226 , and @xmath227 ( where @xmath228 are nucleon spin operators , @xmath229 , are isospin operators , and @xmath226 is the tensor operator ) , appear in the largest operator terms in the av18 potential . the @xmath230 , together with the scalar correlation @xmath231 , solve a set of coupled euler - lagrange equations with coefficients that serve as variational parameters , discussed in ref . the central correlation @xmath202 falls off exponentially to reflect the strong binding of the @xmath201-shell particles , as do the @xmath232 functions . the @xmath233 and @xmath234 correlations are constructed to approximate @xmath231 at small @xmath199 but to approach constant values at large @xmath199 . this guarantees that where particles approach each other closely the wave function is governed by the nucleon - nucleon interaction , but that the correlation between widely - separated particles is dominated by binding to a `` mean field '' accounted for in the @xmath195}$ ] orbitals . thus , the asymptotic region of @xmath235 is dominated by the @xmath195}$ ] , which have much longer tails than the @xmath202 . all of the functions appearing so far in this section are specified as functions of variational parameters , either explicitly or in the differential equations solved to compute correlations . the optimum values of those parameters are found by searching the parameter space to minimize the energy expectation value , @xmath236 with both numerator and denominator computed by monte carlo integrals over the particle coordinates . as a final step , the hamiltonian is diagonalized with respect to the @xmath104-shell configurations labeled by @xmath237 $ ] to find the coefficients @xmath210}$ ] . diagonalization both improves the variational energy of the ground state of given @xmath238 and @xmath192 and provides access to excited states . energies of unbound @xmath104-shell states can almost always be lowered by making their wave functions more diffuse ( closer to threshold ) . this is also often true of bound states , where variational energies ( but not gfmc energies ) can lie artificially above breakup thresholds because of shortcomings of the variational ansatz . for both bound and resonance states , this problem is addressed by constraining variational parameter searches to keep charge radii close to experimentally known ground - state charge radii . the values of the variational parameters for all states used in the present calculations were provided by r. b. wiringa @xcite . they are the results of calculations in bases of good isospin in which individual nucleons typically can not have definite charges . for convenience in defining the integral relations for neutron or proton decays , i carry out the calculations below in a basis of good nucleon charge ( essentially an @xmath40-scheme in the particle isospins ) so that the emitted nucleon is definitely either a neutron or a proton . for given variational parameters , this is only a change of representation and does not alter observables . the variational minimization has in all cases been carried out for the state of lowest @xmath193 in each isomultiplet . i compute widths of the isobaric analogues of these states by using isospin rotations of the minimized states rather than carrying out independent variational minimizations . calculations of explicit overlap functions @xmath180 ( eq . ( [ eq : projection ] ) ) and integral relations ( eqs . ( [ eq : f - norm - integral ] ) and ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) ) involve several common elements . while integral relations are much more time - consuming because they contain the operator @xmath186 , most of the computational tasks in organizing the calculation amount to constructing the channel vector @xmath239 given by eq . ( [ eq : channel - definition ] ) and then contracting either @xmath235 or @xmath240 against it . for nucleon emission , i take @xmath82 to be the wave function of the daughter nucleus and @xmath83 to be the spinor of the emitted nucleon . the integrals of eqs . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) and ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) are computed by monte carlo integration over the particle coordinates , using the same sampling algorithm that has long been used to compute the energy expectation value , eq . ( [ eq : variational - energy ] ) . sampling follows the metropolis algorithm , using the weight function @xmath241 where @xmath242 is the variational wave function for the @xmath243-body parent nucleus at particle coordinates @xmath144 . the delta function in eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) is accounted for by sampling all particle coordinates and sorting the samples into narrow bins of specified channel radius ; this builds up the entire function @xmath180 from a single monte carlo walk . the normalization integral needed to give @xmath82 unit norm is computed in the same monte carlo walk by which the overlap or integral relation is computed . only relative coordinates are used in the definitions of @xmath235 and @xmath140 , so the results of the calculations are all explicitly translation invariant , and for operator @xmath244 the quantity computed is @xmath245 the routines used to compute the integral relations were written as modified versions of existing spectroscopic - overlap routines @xcite . the integral - relation routines were used previously to compute bound - state ancs @xcite , and only very minor modification ( replacing regular whittaker functions with regular scattering functions ) was necessary for width calculations . finally , the operator @xmath186 must be considered . it is just the potential - energy operator of the av18+uix hamiltonian , but with the restriction that only terms involving the @xmath246 ( emitted ) nucleon are considered so that eq . ( [ eq : urel - definition ] ) becomes : @xmath247 its action on @xmath235 is evaluated by calling the potential - energy routines with instructions to omit all terms purely internal to @xmath82 for the given permutation . it is then straightforward to contract @xmath248 with @xmath249^\dag$ ] for a given configuration @xmath144 . it is instructive to examine the integrand of eq . ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) by inserting a delta function @xmath250 into the integral . this is evaluated just like the delta function in eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) , by carrying out the monte carlo walk for the full integral and binning the monte carlo samples according to the channel radius instead of summing them all together . a typical result is shown in fig . [ fig : integrand ] , and nearly all cases that i have computed appear similar to this graph apart from an overall scaling . it is evident that the largest contribution comes from @xmath251 fm . it is also evident that the form of the vmc wave function beyond @xmath252 fm is irrelevant for the width , because the factor @xmath162 is zero there . this limits the integral to smaller radii and guarantees convergence of the integral regardless of what lies in the tails of the variational wave function . ) in two @xmath90 channels is shown as a function of channel radius @xmath120 after integrating over all other coordinates . the case shown is the @xmath253 overlap onto @xmath254 + neutron , but the shapes of the curves are similar in nearly all calculations from vmc wave functions . discrete points show the integrand @xmath255 . the solid curve shows its cumulative integral , @xmath165 , which at large radius is equal to the wave function asymptotic normalization . the integrand goes to zero at small radius because it contains the regular function @xmath256 and at @xmath257 fm because @xmath258 there . the light dotted curve indicates the distribution of samples in the monte carlo integration ( with zero at the bottom of the graph).,width=336 ] the motivation presented above for the integral relations assumes that @xmath235 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 are all energy eigenstates . to the extent that the vmc wave functions approximate these states , the integral relations approximate the overlaps and widths _ of the hamiltonian for which they are approximate solutions_. two difficulties then present themselves in applying the integral relations to vmc wave functions : 1 ) comparison of the results to other calculations using the av18+uix hamiltonian is not possible because ( except for @xmath9he ) no such calculations have been done by other methods , and 2 ) comparison to experiment is complicated because experimental resonance energies are not reproduced exactly by the hamiltonian . the mismatch of resonance energies from experiment can be dealt with straightforwardly . the integral relations of eqs . ( [ eq : f - norm - integral ] ) and ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) require an assumed channel energy @xmath133 , from which @xmath84 and @xmath85 are computed . formally @xmath133 should be the channel energy of the av18+uix hamiltonian ( known from gfmc ) , but the mismatch between this and the experimental @xmath133 is often @xmath259 mev . since the potential energy in the @xmath104-shell is much larger ( @xmath260 to @xmath261 mev ) , the experimental @xmath133 is close enough to the av18+uix channel energy that it can plausibly be used in the integrals . ( see sec . [ sec : psky ] . ) this choice accounts for most of the well - known strong dependence of the width on the resonance energy so that comparison with experiment is possible . it was found previously that using the experimental separation energy in integral - relation calculations of bound - state ancs produces results in generally good agreement with experiment @xcite . similarly , the results below indicate that using the experimentally - measured resonance energy as @xmath133 allows prediction of experimental widths . i present the results of using both experimental and gfmc values of @xmath133 in the integral relations . more consistent calculations will require hamiltonians that more precisely reproduce thresholds and resonance energies . such hamiltonians exist in the form of the illinois three - body potentials @xcite , but they have not yet been incorporated into the vmc code used here , and @xmath186 for these interactions requires considerably more computation than for the uix interaction . consider configurations in which particle @xmath243 ( before antisymmetrization ) is far from the first @xmath262 particles . because @xmath203 and @xmath204 approach constants and @xmath202 decays rapidly at large @xmath199 , the shape of @xmath235 in this part of the wave function is dominated by the shapes of the single - particle functions @xmath195}$ ] . this might be expected to give @xmath263 } \gamma_{ls[n ] } \phi_n^{ls[n]}(\omega_{ls[n]}r)\ ] ] for some amplitudes @xmath264}$ ] and jacobian - like factors @xmath265}$ ] that emerge from the correlations of eqs . ( [ eq : jastrow])-([eq : trial - wf ] ) when the overlap integral is computed . the factors @xmath265}$ ] account for the distinction between the channel radius @xmath120 and the distance @xmath196 of a @xmath104-shell particle from the center of mass of the @xmath201-shell core ; these only coincide when @xmath266 and otherwise differ by the mean difference between nucleon - core and nucleon - daughter distances . in general , the @xmath195}$ ] that emerge from the variational procedure do not yield the correct long - range asymptotic shapes for the overlaps @xmath185 . this is most readily seen for open channels , where solutions that should oscillate at large channel radius instead fall off with an assumed exponential dependence . in closed channels , the condition of square integrability gives zero for the analogue of @xmath154 in eqs . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) and ( [ eq : integral - schematic ] ) , so that eq . ( [ eq : whittaker - asymptotic ] ) holds for the true wave function . because no single @xmath237 $ ] term typically dominates a given @xmath180 , it is in general difficult to construct @xmath195}$ ] to satisfy eq . ( [ eq : whittaker - asymptotic ] ) for all possible channels at once . this difficulty is compounded by the problem that the energy expectation value driving the variational minimization receives very little contribution from the wave function tails , so the variational principle does not constrain the low - probability tails of the wave function very strongly . the application of the integral approach to bound state ancs in ref . @xcite avoided these difficulties and effectively matched the correct asymptotic form onto the better - computed interior of the wave function . pseudobound vmc wave functions approximate resonance states with square - integrable wave functions , in which the @xmath202 and @xmath195}$ ] functions cut off the wave function tails exponentially . this exponential cutoff can be understood at `` medium '' range ( 48 fm ) as forcing a resonance form on the wave function and beyond this range as providing a regularization to normalize the unbound state despite its formally nonzero amplitude at large radius . such a regularization is important for quantities like electromagnetic transition strengths ( e.g. @xcite ) and for the approximate relation between the asymptotic normalization and the partial width given in eq . ( [ eq : gamma - from - c ] ) @xcite . as long as the resonance wave function is computed reasonably accurately within the region where the integral of eq . ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) is nonzero , and it is normalized to unity over the region where @xmath235 is larger in amplitude than in the asymptotic region , the integral approximates the asymptotic normalization of @xmath161 and thus the partial width . the cutoff of @xmath235 at large nucleon separation is illustrated with overlap functions in fig . [ fig : fixing - asymptotics ] . of the unbound @xmath267 state of @xmath1b onto @xmath268 proton , computed directly from eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) ( discrete points with monte carlo error bars ) and from the integral relation of eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) ( solid curves ) . at large radius , the directly - computed overlap falls off exponentially because the @xmath195}$ ] in the vmc wave function fall off exponentially . however , the integral - relation overlap ( with @xmath155 ) gives the exact proportionality to @xmath161 expected at resonance . the absolute normalization @xmath269 multiplying @xmath161 gives the partial width of @xmath270 in each @xmath271 channel ; the normalized asymptotic is shown as a dashed curve for each channel and manifestly merges with the full overlap at @xmath272 fm.,width=336 ] i now apply the integral relation of eqs . ( [ eq : gamma - from - c ] ) and ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) to compute widths of several unbound energy levels in nuclei of mass numbers @xmath0 , from vmc wave functions . i mostly choose energy levels that empirically have small width ( under 1 mev ) and are dominated by nucleon emission . the integral relation is valid for decay channels in which all three wave functions ( one parent and two daughters ) are known , but i limit this first examination to nucleon - emission channels , where one `` daughter nucleus '' is a neutron or proton . i concentrate on two - body final states , but i also model some three - body decays as sequential processes , e.g. the @xmath2b ground state decaying to a proton and the unbound ground state of @xmath1be . the subsequent decay of @xmath1be to two alpha particles can be neglected because of its small width . ( in principle the widths of unbound daughter states should be integrated over , but i find that in all cases considered this correction is much smaller than either the experimental errors or the widths of omitted decay channels . ) the results of the width calculations are shown in table [ tab : big - width - table ] . each calculation was carried out twice : once assuming the channel energy @xmath133 from the av18+uix hamiltonian ( known from gfmc calculations ) and once using the experimentally - known resonance energy . ( for the second @xmath273 states in @xmath1b and @xmath1li and the @xmath274 states in @xmath2be and @xmath2b , av18+uix energies have never been computed with gfmc ) . where the experimental channel energy is unknown or uncertain , i have used instead the gfmc energy for the av18+il7 hamiltonian , which gives a better overall fit to experimental energies than av18+uix . i have taken the experimental energies and widths in table [ tab : big - width - table ] mainly from data compilations @xcite . nearly all of the widths in the compilations are `` observed '' widths , which coincide with the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of cross section peaks and are proportional to the sum of the @xmath64-matrix pole residues . the integral - relation widths should correspond to these quantities . in two cases ( @xmath275 and @xmath276 ) , examination of the source literature indicated that the available experimental widths are `` formal '' widths of the @xmath277-matrix formalism . i have converted the experimental widths listed for those states to `` observed '' widths by the usual relation @xmath278 where @xmath78 ( taken to be 4 fm ) is a matching radius , @xmath279 is the shift function of @xmath277-matrix theory @xcite , prime denotes its derivative , and @xmath280 is defined by the formal width @xmath281 and the penetrability function @xmath282 . ( see the section `` definitions of resonance parameters '' in ref . @xcite . ) the sources of the experimental widths are indicated in table [ tab : big - width - table ] . the widths presented in the table are sums over all @xmath104- and @xmath283-wave decay channels . the predicted @xmath283-wave contributions are less than 1% of the total in all cases except the decay of @xmath284 to @xmath285 , where it is computed to be 23% of the total . the @xmath104-wave decays are in most cases sums of @xmath286 and @xmath287 contributions . the decompositions into @xmath286 and @xmath287 ( or into a channel - spin coupling scheme ) are available on request to the author . the table only includes cases for which established experimental or gfmc energies are available . i have also computed widths of several states of @xmath2he with varying assumptions about resonance energies as described below , but i have not included these numbers in table [ tab : big - width - table ] . .the results of integral - relation calculations of widths . results are shown from calculations in which the channel energy was assumed equal to its experimental value ( `` from expt energy '' ) and to the av18+uix channel energy known from gfmc ( `` from av18+uix energy '' ) . error estimates are quadrature sums of monte carlo sampling errors and uncertainties from the input energies . where no experimental energy is available , the results in the `` experiment '' columns were computed using the gfmc energy with the av18+il7 hamiltonian , and they are indicated by square brackets . the column `` matches @xmath288 ? '' indicates whether the overlap function appears consistent with a resonance state , as discussed in sec . [ sec : psky ] . see sec . [ sec : psky ] and eq . ( [ eq : zeta ] ) for the definition of @xmath289 . energies are relative to the decay threshold in the center - of - mass frame . experimental energies are taken from data compilations @xcite unless otherwise noted . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<,^ , < " , ] the computed widths of those states and channels for which experimental data are available are shown graphically in fig . [ fig : width - width ] . only for those states where partial widths are available from experiment do i show partial widths in the graphs otherwise total widths are shown . [ fig : width - width ] demonstrates the wide dynamic range of the integral method , extending from 0.0005 to roughly 1 mev . with the exception only of the very broad @xmath290 states , which present problems discussed below , all computed widths are within a factor of three of experiment within a factor of two if states with uncomputed alpha and direct three - body width are omitted . the error - weighted mean ratio @xmath291 of the integral - method width to the experimental width is @xmath292 , and the @xmath293 statistic for the difference between computed and experimental widths is 5.9 per degree of freedom ( omitting @xmath9he for a total of 19 states ) . restricting consideration to those states with no omitted channels gives @xmath294 and @xmath295 with @xmath296 . the errors used to compute these statistics are mainly in the measured width @xmath297 . setting aside the resonance energies , the main sources of uncertainty in the theoretical calculation are in the accuracy of the variational wave function and of the potential . because it is unclear how to estimate these errors , the theoretical errors reported in table [ tab : big - width - table ] are the quadrature sums of monte carlo sampling errors with errors propagated from the input resonance energies . errors propagated from experimental energies are typically small compared with the other errors . however , each gfmc channel energy is the difference of a resonance energy and a threshold energy from separate calculations . the error on this difference is often large compared with the channel energy , and this propagates to a large error on the predicted width . for those cases included in the averages . the vertical axis shows the ratio @xmath298 of the integral - relation width to the measured width , and the horizontal axis shows the measured width @xmath297 . the horizontal dotted line shows @xmath299 as a guide to the eye . the errors shown are dominated by those on the experimental widths . experimental errors have been added in quadrature to smaller monte carlo statistical errors and errors propagated from the energy used in computing @xmath300 . states for which important alpha or 3-body decays have been neglected are indicated with asterisks next to the state labels , and large ( red ) circles indicate overlaps that seem inconsistent with @xmath288 phase shift . the outlying @xmath301 states of @xmath302be and @xmath302li are complicated by the need to include the small alpha decay channel in multichannel @xmath277-matrix fits when extracting widths from data ; this introduces a considerable spread in reported nucleon widths @xcite.,width=336 ] the results presented in table [ tab : big - width - table ] and fig . [ fig : width - width ] vary in the degree to which they match the experimental widths . some , like the first @xmath303 state of @xmath1li , are close matches . others , like the two low - lying states of @xmath9he , are very far from agreement with experiment . the @xmath9he cases are particularly interesting , because they are the only ones for which the correct widths for the av18+uix hamiltonian are known from explicit scattering calculations @xcite . the known av18+uix widths are 1.5 mev for the @xmath304 state and 5.0 mev for the @xmath305 state , while applying the integral relation to the pseudobound vmc wave functions gives 0.68 and 0.71 mev , respectively . the @xmath305 state lies above the centrifugal barrier and is so broad that its phase shift does not pass through @xmath288 , so it is unsurprising that the integral method fails for this case . the @xmath304 state does not present these difficulties , so its difference from both experiment and theory is clearly not a shortcoming of the potential but rather of the computational methods . there are several reasons that the application of the integral relation to a pseudobound variational wave function could fail to yield the correct width for the potential . i begin by noting that for the states examined , the function @xmath306 typically does not deviate far from its leading - order dependence on @xmath307 over the range of @xmath86 where @xmath308 differs significantly from zero . the main effect of changing the assumed resonance energy is therefore to change the overall scale of the integrand in eq . ( [ eq : g - norm - integral ] ) without changing its shape much . thus , simply using the experimental channel energy in the integral relation should correct rather accurately for the mismatch between experimental and theoretical channel energies without introducing significant distortions in the integrand . it is possible that the variational minimization with constrained charge radius fails to produce good approximations to some resonance states . it could happen that the variational ansatz is a poor match to a particular resonant wave function or that the vmc wave function , being only approximate , contains `` contamination '' from nonresonant continuum states . contamination more energetic than the desired state is precisely what the gfmc method is intended to remove , and much of the success of the qmc methods lies in the exclusion of low - energy excitations from the variational wave function . any off - resonance contamination produces contributions to the integral relation that do not correspond to the pole residue . the danger of contamination would seem to grow with the resonance width , because a less - peaked density of states implies a wider range of states that are similar to the resonance and difficult to eliminate by variational minimization . the presence of nearby resonances in the same channel may compound this problem by contributing contamination with rather different structure from the resonant wave function being sought . yet another kind of difficulty lies in the normalization of the wave function . the relationship between the width and the asymptotic normalization of standing - wave states found in refs . @xcite depends on the wave function being normalized in a finite volume and its amplitude being small at the boundary of that finite volume as expressed in eq . ( [ eq : humblet - correction ] ) . i have assumed that the normalization volume is effectively defined by the exponential fall - off of the @xmath202 and @xmath195}$ ] correlations in the tails of the variational wave function . if either the true or the computed wave function fails to fall off rapidly enough , the normalization is problematic in ways that can be viewed either as the lack of an effective cutoff or as neglect of a large surface - amplitude correction . the normalization problem is perhaps the most straightforward to examine . the final column of table [ tab : big - width - table ] displays a parameter @xmath309 where @xmath310 is the location of the maximum @xmath311 , and @xmath180 is computed directly from eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) . this ratio measures the amplitude of the variational wave function just outside the interaction region relative to that in the interior ( accounting for the @xmath312 dependence of the volume of a spherical shell ) . we may expect to encounter difficulties when @xmath313 , and this occurs for four states : the two @xmath9he states and the @xmath305 and @xmath314 states of @xmath302he . the relevance of @xmath289 may also be viewed in light of eq . ( [ eq : humblet - correction ] ) . if i adopt 8 fm as the effective boundary of the normalization volume and assume ( cf . [ fig : psky ] below ) that typically @xmath315 , then eq . ( [ eq : humblet - correction ] ) gives @xmath316 for all but a very few of the widths computed here . much larger values of @xmath173 occur for @xmath317 , @xmath318 , and minor decay channels of a few other states . the overlap functions may also be tested for consistency with expectations for a resonance . the integral relation for the width is the @xmath319 limit of @xmath185 as computed from eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) . given a wave function , it is possible to compute the overlap function at all radii using eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) given @xmath154 , and the result is likely more accurate than that from direct calculation of @xmath185 . determining @xmath154 from a variational wave function is a tractable problem @xcite , but i do not pursue it here . since i have tacitly _ assumed _ in computing widths that @xmath155 as required for a resonance state ( cf . ( [ eq : kmatrix - integral ] ) ) , i can compute the full overlap function from the integral relation ( eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) ) with @xmath155 and check that it matches the overlap function computed directly from ( eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) ) . if the two overlaps are in rough agreement in the interaction region , then the vmc wave function is consistent with a resonance wave function and may validly be used to compute a width . as a test of the approach , i apply it to bound states , since their integration constant corresponding to @xmath154 is zero by definition . results are shown for several states in fig . [ fig : bound - overlaps ] , and i have computed them for all of the channels considered in ref . the agreement between the two calculations , especially for @xmath201-shell nuclei where the vmc method is more accurate , is excellent . the deviations of the integral - relation overlap from the direct overlap are likely to be improvements : the integral relation contains more information about the potential than does the vmc wave function by itself , and it guarantees the correct @xmath319 asymptotics . for some nuclei with @xmath320 , 4 , and 7 , gfmc calculations of overlaps exist ( albeit for the av18+il7 hamiltonian , not av18+uix ) @xcite . the results of the gfmc calculations ( dashed curves of fig . [ fig : bound - overlaps ] ) are not severely different from those of applying the integral method to vmc wave functions , and they deviate from the vmc overlaps by similar amounts . this experience with bound states indicates that overlaps computed from integral relations are at least as accurate as directly - computed overlaps of vmc wave functions and are not in conflict with gfmc results . they may therefore be very useful for calculations of spectroscopic factors and transfer and knockout cross sections . ) ( solid curves ) and from the definition in eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) ( squares with monte carlo error bars . ) the @xmath87 and @xmath90 quantum numbers of the `` virtually emitted '' nucleon are indicated by labels near the appropriate curves ( and distinguished by color ) . where they exist , overlaps computed directly from gfmc wave functions @xcite are shown as ( black ) dashed curves.,width=528 ] overlap functions are shown for @xmath270 in fig . [ fig : fixing - asymptotics ] and for several other resonance states in fig . [ fig : psky ] . these were computed both directly and by integral relations with @xmath155 . in all cases , the integral relation replaces the artificial exponential fall - off of the vmc wave function with the oscillatory behavior of @xmath321 . based on experience with bound states , the two overlaps should agree at @xmath322 fm . in some cases ( e.g. @xmath323 ) the match there is quite good , while in others ( e.g. @xmath324 ) overlaps from the two methods seem to have little to do with each other . i conclude that when results of the two methods are qualitatively very different inside 4 fm , there is an inconsistency with the assumption of @xmath288 phase shift so that the pseudobound vmc wave function may not allow accurate width calculations . the penultimate column of table [ tab : big - width - table ] indicates for each width a qualitative judgment of whether the two methods of computing overlaps agree , and cases where they do not are indicated in fig . [ fig : width - width ] by large ( red ) circles . examination of the table reveals that with the exception of the @xmath325 state in @xmath1b , failures of the `` @xmath326 assumption '' occur only in a few neutron emission channels and in no proton emission channels . considering only states consistent with @xmath327 , i find @xmath328 and @xmath329 , this time for @xmath330 instead of 18 . further restriction to states in which all decay channels are computed gives @xmath331 and @xmath332 for 8 degrees of freedom . these are essentially the same results as for the entire data set . it appears that the best predictor of whether a calculated width will match experiment is simply whether the calculation includes all channels contributing to the measured width . ) ; points with monte carlo errors ) and from the integral relation of eq . ( [ eq : full - integral - relation ] ) with @xmath155 ( or @xmath333 ; solid curves ) . where more than one angular momentum channel is available , the channels are labeled . the four cases on the left show good agreement between the two methods at small separation ( @xmath322 fm ) , and the corresponding widths agree with experiment . the two states on the right are inconsistent with the @xmath334 assumption since the two types of overlap calculations disagree at @xmath335 fm . computed widths of these two states also disagree with experiment.,width=528 ] a difficulty presents itself in considering the pair of @xmath4 states of @xmath1be at @xmath337 mev and the pair of @xmath5 states at @xmath338 mev . each of these doublets consists of one @xmath339 and one @xmath340 state that have mixed , with the lower state of each pair predominantly @xmath340 . the vmc wave functions have definite isospin , so incorporating the mixing into calculations of their widths presents ambiguities . simply ignoring the mixing and assigning the @xmath340 widths to the lower states and @xmath339 widths to the higher states does not work . for example , in the @xmath303 doublet , the lower state has measured width @xmath341 kev and the upper has @xmath342 kev ; the unmixed widths from the integral method are 177 kev and 364 kev , respectively . there exist preliminary gfmc calculations of the mixing matrix element of the hamiltonian for each of these doublets @xcite , and this matrix element can be combined with the splitting of the doublet to determine its mixing angle ( e.g. @xcite ) . the splittings of the doublets are small enough that they are not resolved by the existing gfmc calculations , so the experimental splittings must be used to compute mixing angles . since the recommended @xcite 165 kev splitting of the @xmath303 doublet is less than twice the gfmc mixing energy , these two numbers can not be combined to yield a real mixing angle . ( adopting a splitting of 310 kev @xcite produces good agreement with the experimental widths . ) in the @xmath5 doublet , combining the gfmc mixing matrix element with the experimental splitting produces a poor match to the data ( widths of 14.2 and 105 kev _ versus _ @xmath343 and @xmath344 kev from experiment ) . for each doublet , a mixing angle can be computed by @xmath293 minimization of the difference between theoretical and experimental widths . this produces good agreement with the measured widths , which was not guaranteed . the resulting mixing angle for the @xmath303 doublet has @xmath345 , which is small relative to literature values @xcite . the mixing angle from minimizing @xmath293 for the @xmath5 doublet has @xmath346 , much smaller than both the value of @xmath347 from the gfmc mixing energy and the literature value of @xmath348 @xcite . thus , attempts to compute separate widths for the upper and lower states in each doublet run aground on the problem of finding mixing angles consistent with all available information . for each doublet , the quantity most independent of the mixing angle is the sum of the two widths . the sum is less sensitive to @xmath349 than are the underlying pole residues , but it is not quite independent of @xmath349 because the doublet states are not degenerate . it is the sum for each doublet that is shown in table [ tab : big - width - table ] and fig . [ fig : width - width ] , with the @xmath340 width computed in each case using the lower energy and the @xmath339 width the higher . these sums are in good agreement with experiment . an important use of theoretical estimates of widths is in the identification of observed states . most of the states considered here ( @xmath350 , @xmath18 mev , dominated by nucleon decays ) were found experimentally , and their spins and parities identified , long ago . some exceptions are the first @xmath325 and second @xmath351 states of @xmath1b and the entire low - lying spectra of @xmath2he and @xmath2li . here i attempt to shed light on these systems by calculating widths from vmc wave functions . several theoretical models predict low - lying states of @xmath1b that have not been observed , as discussed in ref . it is possible that the states are simply too broad to be seen easily in experiments , and evidence was recently found for a @xmath325 state at 1.9 mev above the @xmath1b ground state @xcite . an @xmath277-matrix fit to both elastic and inelastic scattering of @xmath302be on protons indicated a @xmath325 state with partial width @xmath353 mev for decay to the @xmath302be ground state and @xmath354 mev to the first excited state . since these widths are within @xmath355 of zero , i have not shown them in table [ tab : big - width - table ] . this state has some support from the calculation of ref . @xcite , where it was found in computed phase shifts at the same energy using the merged no - core shell model and resonating group method . that calculation also indicates reason for caution in applying the integral relation : the phase shift does not approach @xmath288 , and indeed the vmc @xmath325 state fails the @xmath288 consistency test discussed above . i show in table [ tab : big - width - table ] the predicted partial widths of the @xmath325 state at its energies for the av18+uix and av18+il7 hamiltonians . [ fig : b8_0 ] shows the dependence of this prediction on the assumed resonance energy . the claimed experimental widths are consistent with my results , though inconsistency of the overlaps with @xmath326 phase shift makes the significance of this consistency doubtful . i also include in table [ tab : big - width - table ] the av18+il7 energies and vmc - computed partial widths of the unobserved isobaric - analogue state in @xmath1li . the @xmath1li and @xmath302li vmc wave functions are explicitly isospin rotations of the @xmath1b and @xmath302be wave functions , and the @xmath356 decays also fail the @xmath288 condition on the overlaps . the authors of ref . @xcite also find a @xmath351 state at 2.55 mev excitation . because this result has not been confirmed , i omit this state from goodness - of - fit statistics , but i have computed its partial widths to the @xmath302be ground and first - excited states and included the results in table [ tab : big - width - table ] . the overlap functions for these states are compatible with @xmath288 phase shift . however , the computed partial widths do not match those claimed in ref . @xcite : i find @xmath357 mev to the @xmath302be ground state _ versus _ @xmath358 mev measured , and @xmath359 mev to the @xmath302be excited state _ versus _ @xmath360 mev measured . the origin of these differences is not clear . be ground state threshold ) for the first @xmath325 state in @xmath1b . the thicknesses of the bands indicate the errors from monte carlo sampling . the band bounded by solid curves indicates the partial width to the ground state of @xmath302be , and that bounded by dashed curves shows the partial width to the first excited state . the boxes ( offset from each other slightly in the horizontal direction for visibility ) show the experimental results of ref . @xcite without a correction from @xmath277-matrix formal width to observed width . ( this can amount to a @xmath361 reduction at the high end of the allowed width . ) also indicated is the best estimate of the resonance energy from gfmc calculations using the av18+il7 hamiltonian.,width=288 ] the spectroscopy of @xmath2he remains unclear despite several experimental studies @xcite . the ground state was originally thought to be a @xmath305 resonance state @xcite . subsequently , strong @xmath201-wave @xmath363-@xmath1he interaction was seen near threshold and argued to reflect a @xmath364 virtual state @xcite . more recent experiments have found a smaller scattering length and thus less support for a virtual state @xcite . because @xmath201-wave neutrons do not have true resonances passing through @xmath288 phase shift , i do not present a width for this state . several other observations of resonances within a few mev of the @xmath1he+@xmath363 `` threshold '' have been claimed . ( see ref . @xcite for a summary . ) spin and parity assignments for all of these states are uncertain , and matching them to theoretical expectations has proven difficult @xcite . width estimates based on _ ab initio _ calculations could provide useful guidance , so i explore this possibility here . there have been four claims of a state around 1.2 mev above the @xmath1he+@xmath363 `` threshold '' @xcite , and it has additional support from a study of possible analogue states @xcite . this is generally assumed to be the lowest - lying @xmath104-shell state , with @xmath365 , and there is conflicting information concerning its width . @xcite found it to be narrower than their 0.42 mev resolution ; other experiments found 1 mev @xcite , @xmath366 mev @xcite , and 2 mev @xcite . as pointed out particularly by barker @xcite , it is difficult to reconcile widths considerably narrower than 1 mev with the expected strong single - particle character of the @xmath305 resonance . theoretical calculations also place the @xmath305 state a few mev higher ( e.g. at 3 and 4 mev in gfmc calculations with illinois-6 and illinois-2 three - body forces , respectively ) . one possibility is reduction of the @xmath305 energy by an @xmath367-shell component that is missing in the calculations @xcite . additional resonances have been found at higher energies , one around 2.3 mev @xcite with claimed width @xmath368 mev , one around 4 mev @xcite , and another around 5 mev @xcite . in addition to the @xmath305 state , a @xmath304 state is expected theoretically , though also at higher energy . it is also likely that @xmath367-shell intruder states with @xmath369 and @xmath370 are present in the low - lying spectrum . i computed widths of @xmath104-shell states with @xmath365 and @xmath304 , but the results proved difficult to match with experimental data . the short - range overlaps of the @xmath305 state computed directly and by the integral method are in nice agreement . since it is unclear what resonance energy should be used in the calculation , i have computed widths from the vmc wave function using a range of channel energies in the integral relation . [ fig:9he ] shows these results . they mainly demonstrate the argument of barker @xcite that there is a mismatch between the narrow width of the @xmath305 state claimed by bohlen _ et al . _ @xcite and theoretical expectations of a strongly single - particle state . the resonances claimed by belozerov _ et al . _ @xcite and golovkov _ et al . _ @xcite are consistent with the computed @xmath305 width , but that assignment makes interpretation of the 1.3 and 2.4 mev states of bohlen _ et al . _ @xcite difficult : at least one would have to be an @xmath367-shell state . all channel energies below 6 mev for the @xmath304 state yield computed widths of less than 5 kev . this could match either of the states at 4.3 and 5.3 mev in ref . @xcite , which were found to be narrower than the 100-kev experimental resolution , but the vmc overlaps of this state are inconsistent with @xmath288 phase shift . for this reason , the integral - relation results are probably not reliable predictions of the width . vmc wave functions also exist for states with @xmath371 and @xmath372 , but these wave functions with @xmath367-shell components have not reached the same level of development as the vmc @xmath104-shell states and have not been published . as mentioned above , the @xmath364 state should not be observable as a resonance . the vmc wave functions for the @xmath370 and @xmath372 states indicate that they are mainly made by coupling the @xmath351 state of @xmath1he to an @xmath201-wave neutron and therefore also not true @xmath373 resonances . i did not attempt calculations of partial widths for decay to the @xmath374 state . calculations of the partial widths for decay from positive - parity states to the @xmath1he ground state by emission of a @xmath375-wave neutron yielded partial widths of less than 60 kev and overlaps inconsistent with @xmath288 phase shift . he resonances that have reported widths . the band labeled `` vmc '' shows the predicted width of the @xmath305 state as a function of the resonance energy assumed in the integral relation , and its width reflects the statistical error of the monte carlo integration . where no error was reported for a width ( for example , ref . @xcite has `` @xmath376 mev '' for the width of the state at 2.0 mev ) , i have assigned an error of 0.5 mev and indicated this with broken lines at the upper and lower limits . i have omitted some very broad states with missing or lower - limit errors : a state with @xmath377 mev and @xmath378 mev from ref . @xcite and one with @xmath379 mev and @xmath380 mev from ref . @xcite . see ref . @xcite for additional reports of states without measured widths . the displayed widths are from seth _ et al . _ @xcite , belozerov _ et al . _ @xcite , bohlen _ et al . _ @xcite , and golovkov _ et al . downward arrows indicate widths that include @xmath381 kev instrumental resolution.,width=288 ] the most recent data compilation for @xmath383 lists five low - lying states of @xmath2li and only assigns firm spins and parities to the lowest two @xcite . a more recent paper @xcite identifies the third state as @xmath384 by comparing spectroscopic factors of vmc wave functions ( older versions of those used here ) with measured @xmath385 cross sections . those authors also assigned @xmath386 and @xmath387 , respectively , to the next two states . this assignment was based partly on the ordering of states in theoretical calculations and partly on the assumption that widths should correlate with computed spectroscopic factors . the results presented in table [ tab : big - width - table ] and fig . [ fig : width - width ] support these assignments by reproducing the widths of all three unbound states . i conclude by considering other ways to estimate widths from vmc wave functions and comparing them with the integral method . in the absence of integral relations or explicit scattering calculations , widths must be estimated from spectroscopic factors . in applications of the shell model , one often assumes that the width is the product of the spectroscopic factor , @xmath388 ^ 2r^2\,dr\,,\ ] ] and the single - particle width . vmc spectroscopic factors might in fact be more suited to this procedure than those from a shell model , because shell models are typically confined to a single value of the principal quantum number , while the large amount of correlation in vmc wave functions guarantees that eq . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) picks up contributions from all major shells . the crudest estimate of the single - particle width is the `` wigner limit '' @xcite . on the basis of a causality argument , the width of a resonance can be shown to have an approximate upper limit of @xmath389 where @xmath78 is a `` matching radius '' ( typically @xmath390 fm ) defining the edge of the interaction region , and @xmath391 is the penetration factor of ref . @xcite . since @xmath392 is ( approximately ) an upper limit on the width that a resonance can have , it might approximate a single - particle width . some authors define @xmath392 to include an additional numerical factor multiplying eq . ( [ eq : wigner ] ) , reflecting assumptions about the wave function inside the interaction region . teichmann and wigner @xcite assumed a constant wave function to arrive at a factor of @xmath393 . other authors make more elaborate assumptions and arrive at a factor of @xmath394 for @xmath395 @xcite . i take eq . ( [ eq : wigner ] ) to define @xmath392 . in fig . [ fig : wigner ] i use the wigner limit to estimate widths of the states under consideration . in each case , i multiply @xmath392 for a 4 fm radius by the vmc spectroscopic factor from eqs . ( [ eq : direct - overlap ] ) and ( [ eq : spectroscopic - factor ] ) . these estimates plainly do not reproduce measured widths as well as the integral relation . the weighted mean ratio of `` theoretical '' to experimental width for this method , restricted to states consistent with @xmath288 phase shift and purely nucleon - emission decay , is @xmath396 ; the reduced @xmath293 is 1845 for eight degrees of freedom . ( recall that @xmath397 with @xmath398 for the same set of states . ) the mismatch between @xmath399 and @xmath297 can be reduced by choosing a smaller numerical factor to define the wigner limit , but that does not remove the large scatter in @xmath400 . better agreement with experiment is likewise achieved with a smaller radius , but good agreement requires an unphysically small radius in the neighborhood of 2 fm , which again does not remove the large scatter in the ratio @xmath401 . estimates from @xmath392 are typically @xmath402 smaller if they are estimated as `` observed widths '' from eq . ( [ eq : observed - width ] ) , using @xmath403 this helps significantly with neither the overall scale nor the large scatter of the predicted widths . , and the labels from that figure may be used to identify states here . comparison with fig . [ fig : width - width ] indicates that the integral relation is a significantly better predictor of widths than @xmath399 . note the different vertical scale from fig . [ fig : width - width].,width=336 ] a better estimate of the single - particle width , and one perhaps more widespread in shell - model studies , is based on woods - saxon potentials . one assumes a potential well of `` standard '' radius and diffuseness and adjusts its depth to produce a resonance at the correct energy . the width @xmath404 of this resonance is then taken as an estimate of the single - particle width . a range of geometric parameters for the potential is usually considered , because the most appropriate values are not known _ a priori_. i computed estimates of this kind , using diffuseness 0.65 fm and woods - saxon radius @xmath405 , with @xmath243 the mass number of the resonance state ( the defaults in a code provided by b. a. brown @xcite ) . i neglected variation of these parameters and estimated the single - particle width @xmath406 from the fwhm of the peak in the computed cross section for the given woods - saxon well . the comparison of @xmath407 with @xmath297 is shown in fig . [ fig : woods - saxon ] . the woods - saxon estimates are systematically low , with a weighted mean @xmath408 for the same eight cases considered above and @xmath409 for eight degrees of freedom . i conclude from this exercise and the similar exercise using wigner limits that vmc widths computed by the integral method are more useful predictors of experimental widths than are the vmc spectroscopic factors . , divided by experimental widths . symbols are as in fig . [ fig : width - width ] , and the labels from that figure may be used to identify states here . comparison with figs . [ fig : width - width ] and [ fig : wigner ] indicates that this approach predicts experimental widths more accurately than the wigner - limit approach but still not as well as the integral relation.,width=336 ] i have presented plausibility arguments , supported by detailed derivations in the literature , that widths of resonant states can be estimated by evaluating an integral over pseudobound _ ab initio _ wave functions . this approach is approximate , but it avoids a great deal of computation and human labor that would be needed in full - on scattering calculations and would often be complicated by coupled channels . it is nicely suited to quantum monte carlo calculations in that it is insensitive to the difficult - to - compute tails of the many - body wave functions , it involves a short - range integral amenable to monte carlo integration , it uses more information about the hamiltonian than is encoded in the variational wave function , and it can be applied to resonances narrower than the practical energy resolution of the gfmc technique . related integrals yield overlap functions for bound states , and these overlaps are guaranteed to have the correct shapes in their long - range asymptotics even when the variational wave function does not . these may be useful for calculations of spectroscopic factors and of transfer and knockout cross sections . i have implemented integral - method width calculations for one - nucleon emission from wave functions computed by the variational monte carlo method . it yields widths in good agreement with experiment for several states in the @xmath410 mass range . cases of disagreement always involve either open channels for which i have not accounted or a resonant wave function that is not strongly peaked in the interaction region . i have shown that widths predicted in this way are closer matches to experiment than are nave combinations of _ ab initio _ spectroscopic factors with wigner - limit or woods - saxon estimates of single - particle widths . the integral method is thus a useful tool for estimating widths from _ ab initio _ methods that produce pseudobound wave functions . for the longer term , the calculations presented here represent a learning problem for application of integrals of the type in eqs . ( [ eq : f - norm - integral])-([eq : g - norm - integral ] ) to qmc wave functions . application to gfmc wave functions of the methods used here will be straightforward and mainly involve additional bookkeeping similar to that used in ref . @xcite for direct overlap calculations . integrals of the kind considered here are likely to find their most extensive use in _ ab initio _ calculations of coupled - channel scattering and reactions , and a major goal of the work presented here is to prepare the way for such calculations . i acknowledge useful discussions with c. a. bertulani , i. brida , b. a. brown , c. r. brune , h. esbensen , a. m. mukhamedzhanov , s. c. pieper , and j. p. schiffer . i thank r. b. wiringa for providing variational wave functions and much guidance in their use . this work was supported by the u.s . department of energy , office of nuclear physics , under contract no . de - ac02 - 06ch11357 . calculations were performed on the fusion computing cluster operated by the laboratory computing resource center at argonne . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: as the number of online resources and web documents continues to increase , the need for better organizational structures that guide readers towards the information they seek increases . hierarchies and taxonomies are invaluable tools for this purpose . taxonomies are widely used in libraries via the library of congress system or the dewey decimal system , and hierarchies were a fixture of the early world wide web ; perhaps the most famous example being the yahoo search engine , which originally was a taxonomic - collection of hyperlinks organized by topic . these systems were developed because their effectiveness at topical organization and their logarithmic depth allowed users to quickly find the relevant documents for which they were searching . unfortunately , taxonomy curation of documents , articles , books , etc . is mostly a manual process , which is only possible when the number of curated documents is relatively small . this process becomes increasingly impractical as the number of documents grows to web - scale , and has motivated research towards the automatic inference of taxonomies @xcite . most document repositories contain linkages between the documents creating a _ document - graph_. these links provide , among other things , proper context to the terms and topics in each document . document - graphs are especially common in nonfiction and scientific literature , where citations are viewed as inter - document links . similarly , the world wide web ( www ) can be considered to be a single , very large document - graph , where web pages represent documents and hyperlinks link documents . web sites on the www could also be considered document graphs because a web site is simply a subgraph of the www . web site subgraphs , in particular , are a collection of documents with a specific and purposeful organizational structure , which are often carefully designed to guide the user from the entry page , _ i.e. _ , a homepage , to progressively more specific web pages . similarly , scientific literature can be categorized into a hierarchy of increasingly specific scientific topics by their citation links , and encyclopedia articles can be categorized into a hierarchy of increasingly specific articles by their cross references . thus , we assert that most document - graphs , or , more generally , information networks , contain hidden node hierarchies . in this paper we draw specific distinctions between a _ hierarchy _ and a _ taxonomy_. a taxonomy is defined to be a classification of objects into increasingly finer granularities , where each non - leaf node is a conceptual combination of its children . a biological taxonomy is a canonical example of this definition because a classified species , say ( _ i.e. _ , humans ) , can only be placed at a leaf in the taxonomy ; the inner nodes , _ e.g. _ , , , , do not declare new species , rather they are conceptual agglomerations of species . furthermore , each species is described by its path through the taxonomy . for example , s , can be more generally described as s , s and as s ( among others ) . a hierarchy , on the other hand , is an arrangement of objects where some objects are considered to be _ above _ , _ below _ or _ at the same level as _ others . this necessarily means that objects of a hierarchy live at the internal nodes . for example , a business , government or military chain of command is a hierarchy because the is a specific object that is above the s , which are above the s , and so on . in this case , high - level nodes like are not agglomerations of s just as the is not an aggregation of s or s. in the similar studies , `` document hierarchies '' were not actually hierarchies of documents in the literal sense . for example , hierarchical lda ( hlda ) @xcite , topicblock @xcite , and the tree structured stick breaking ( tssb ) model @xcite learn a conceptual taxonomy in which the non - leaf topics are a combination of words and does not represent a real document in the corpus ; the hierarchical pachinko allocation model ( hpam ) @xcite constructs a tree - like conceptual taxonomy like hlda , but where each topic can have multiple parents . in these related models , only the leaves contained the actual , literal documents . contrary to our perspective , the internal nodes of existing models contain ephemeral word - topic distributions , rather than actual documents . see figure [ fig : inh_relatedwork ] for a brief comparison of model outputs . the hdtm model introduced in this paper requires that inner nodes , which in previous work are made of ephemeral distributions , be literal documents . this requirement asserts that _ some documents are more general than others_. here we explore this assertion through examples and a review of similar assertions made in previous research . a web site @xmath0 can be viewed as a directed graph with web pages as vertices @xmath1 and hyperlinks as directed edges @xmath2 between web pages @xmath3 excluding inter - site hyperlinks . in most cases , designating the web site entry page as the root @xmath4 allows for a web site to be viewed as a rooted directed graph . web site creators and curators purposefully organize the hyperlinks between documents in a topically meaningful manner . as a result , web documents further away from the root document typically contain more specific topics than web documents graphically close to the root document . for example , the web site at the university of notre dame , shown in figure [ fig : inh_webtree ] contains a root web document ( the entry page ) , and dozens of children web documents . even with a very small subset of documents and edges , the corresponding web graph can be quite complicated and messy . a breadth first traversal of the web graph starting with the root node is a simple way to distill a document hierarchy from the web graph . unfortunately , a fixed breadth - first hierarchy can not account for many of the intricacies of real world web graphs . for explanation purposes , let s assume there are four types of hyperlink edges in a web site : ( 1 ) parent - to - child links , ( 2 ) upward links , ( 3 ) shortcuts , and ( 4 ) cross - topic links . parent - to - child links direct the user from one web page to a more topically specific web page ; _ e.g. _ , a hyperlink from engineering.nd.edu to cse.nd.edu is a parent - to - child hyperlink because computer science is topically more specific than engineering . upward links are hyperlinks that reference a more general document ; _ e.g. _ , there may exist a hyperlink from engineering.nd.edu to /the - arts because the engineering college would like to reference artistic happenings at the university . shortcut links are hyperlinks that skip from very general web documents to very specific web documents as a way of featuring some specific topic ; _ e.g. _ , if a computer science professor wins a prestigious award or grant , the professor s web page may be linked to from the news section of the root web page . cross topic links are hyperlinks that move across topical subtrees ; _ e.g. _ , the college of science may reference some working relationship with the college of engineering by creating a hyperlink between the two web pages . because the goal is to infer the document hierarchy , the hdtm model is , in a sense , trying to find parent - to - child links . in the event that there is more than one parent - to - child link to a particular web page , the goal is to find the best topically - relevant parent for each web document in the inferred hierarchy ( except the root ) . web researchers and practitioners have used hyperlink structures to organize web documents for many years . the pagerank and hits algorithms are two of the most famous examples of information propagation through links . pagerank , for instance , uses the model of a random web surfer ( _ i.e. _ random walker ) , who randomly follows hyperlinks over the web ; a current measure of a web page s authority corresponds to the probability that a random surfer lands upon that web page the pagerank score . in the hdtm model , pagerank s notion of authority loosely corresponds to topical generality , that is , web pages with a high random surfer probability are likely to be topically more general than others . the document - graph structure is also used to enrich the document description by adding features to improve retrieval performance . some of the intuition behind these previous works are helpful in framing the generative model . a limitation of the random walker model is that it only looks at the graphical structure of the network . the word distributions found in each document are clearly an important factor to consider when generating document hierarchies . previous work by song , _ et al . _ @xcite and qin , _ et al . _ @xcite show that a given web page can be enriched by propagating information from its children . their relevance propagation model modifies the language distribution of a web page to be a mixture of itself and its children according to the formula : @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the frequency of term @xmath7 in a document @xmath8 before propagation , @xmath9 is the frequency of term @xmath7 in document @xmath8 after propagation , @xmath10 is a child page of @xmath8 in the sitemap @xmath11 , and @xmath12 is a parameter to control the mixing factor of the children . this propagation algorithm assumes that the sitemap , @xmath11 , is constructed ahead of time . for the purposes of web information retrieval language models are often used to normalize and smooth word distributions . for illustration purposes , we apply a dirichlet prior smoothing function @xcite to smooth the term distribution where the @xmath9 from above is used in place of the usual @xmath13 from the original dirichlet prior smoothing function yielding : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the distribution over all terms in @xmath1 , @xmath16 is the smoothing parameter , and the length is modified by the propagation algorithm to be @xmath17 . as a result of the upward propagation @xmath18 function , the root document ( web site entry page ) will contain all of the words from all of the web pages in the web site with different non - zero probabilities . the most probable words are those that occur most frequently and most generally across all documents , and are thus propagated the most . as a small , preliminary example , table [ tab : inh_lm ] shows the top six most probable words in the top document ( via text propagation ) and in root topics of hlda and hdtm of the computer science department s web site at the university of notre dame . this small example reinforces the intuition that certain web sites have a hidden hierarchical topical structure . in the previous term propagation work , web site sitemaps were constructed ahead of time using url heuristics or manually . the goal of hdtm is to learn the document hierarchy automatically and in conjunction with the topical hierarchy . documents from many different collections exist in hidden hierarchies . while technically a web site , wikipedia documents and categories form a unique document graph . wikipedia categories are especially interesting because they provide a type of ontology wherein categories have more specific sub - categories and more general parent - categories . most wikipedia articles are are represented by at least one category description ; this allows for users to drill down to relevant articles in a very few number of clicks by browsing the category graph . a partial example of the wikipedia category graph is shown in figure [ fig : inh_wikicat ] . this figure illustrates how a document graph can be construed into a document hierarchy . specifically , the wikipedia community has hand - crafted a category hierarchy , represented by colored circles and edges , on top of the article - graph , represented by grey squares and grey edges . although the category graph is imperfect and incomplete , wikipedia browsers can get a sense of the granularity , topic and fit simply by viewing the article s placement in the category hierarchy . with the wikipedia construction in mind , our goal can be loosely interpreted as automatically inferring the wikipedia category hierarchy from the wikipedia article graph ; this inference is tried and evaluated in section [ sec : inh_experiments ] . bibliographical networks may also be hierarchically structured . in a bibliographic network , papers or authors ( wherein each author could be a collection of documents ) are represented by nodes and each citation is represented by an edge in the graph . apart from web and citation graphs , bioinformatics networks , for example protein networks , can also be hierarchically organized for protein fold prediction @xcite . the nodes in such network are proteins and two proteins are connected if they have structural or evolutionary relationships @xcite . the goal of this work is to construct node hierarchies from an information network using the node features ( _ e.g. _ , text ) and inter - node edges . for these purposes a node which appears _ above _ , _ below _ or _ at the same level as _ another node refers to the conceptual granularity of the nodes . in other words , given an information network with an explicitly identified root , such as a web site homepage , we aim to learn a node - hierarchy that best captures the conceptual hierarchy of the document - graph . this problem poses three technical challenges : 1 . * document - topic inference*. in document hierarchies the parent documents consist of topics that are more general than their children . this requires that the parent documents are viewed as a mixture of the topics contained within its children , and children documents should topically fit underneath their selected parent . in this paper we introduce the _ hierarchical document - topic model _ ( hdtm ) which generates a course - to - fine representation of the text information , wherein high - level documents live near the top of the hierarchy , and low - level , more specific documents live at or near the leaves . 2 . * selecting document placement*. placement of a document within the hierarchy drives the topic mixing during inference . because links between edges hint at the context of the relationship between documents , the document placement in the inferred hierarchy is constrained by their edges within the original document - graph . in other words , if an edge exists in the final , inferred hierarchy , then it must also exist in original document - graph ( not vice versa ) . unlike existing models , such as hlda @xcite , that select topic paths using the nested chinese restaurant process ( ncrp ) , hdtm performs document placement based on a stochastic process resembling random walks with restart ( rwr ) over the original document - graph . the use of a stochastic process over the document - graph frees the algorithm from rigid parameters ; perhaps most importantly the adoption of the rwr stochastic process instead of ncrp allows documents to live at non - leaf nodes , and frees the algorithm from the depth parameter of hlda . * analysis at web site - scale*. in many document - graph collections , the number of edges grows quadratically with the number of nodes . this limits the scalability of many topic diffusion algorithms @xcite . an important side - effect of the rwr process is the ability to adapt the hdtm model inference algorithm into a distributed graph processing system that is capable of processing billion - node graphs . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : after reviewing the related work we introduce the hdtm model and show how inference is performed . next we show how the inference can be adapted to a large scale graph processing system in order to run on web - scale data sets . the experiments section describes a myriad of tests that were run on various data sets and the quantitative and qualitative evaluations that were performed . we conclude with a examples of real - world use cases , discuss avenues for future research , and provide a link to hdtm s source code . initial efforts in hierarchical clustering used greedy heuristics such as single - link or complete - link agglomoration rules to infer dendrograms @xcite , in which the root node is split into a series of branches that terminate with a single document at each leaf . ho , _ et al . _ , point out that manually - curated web hierarchies like the open directory project are typically flatter and contain fewer inner nodes than agglomerative clustering techniques produce @xcite . other hierarchical clustering algorithms include top - down processes which iteratively partition the data @xcite , incremental methods like cobweb @xcite , classit @xcite , and other algorithms optimized for hierarchical text clustering . the processes that typically defines most hierarchical clustering algorithms can be made to fit in a probabilistic setting that build bottom - up hierarchies based on bayesian hypothesis testing @xcite . on the other hand , a lot of recent work uses bayesian generative models to find the most likely explanation of observed text and links . the first of these hierarchical generative models was hierarchical latent dirichlet allocation ( hlda ) . in hlda each document sits at a leaf in a tree of fixed depth @xmath19 as illustrated in figure [ fig : rwhlda ] . note that all non - leave nodes in figure [ fig : rwhlda ] are conceptual topics containing word distribution instead of a document . each document is represented by a mixture of multinomials along the path through the taxonomy from the document to the root . documents are placed at their respective leaf nodes stochasically using the nested chinese restaurant process ( ncrp ) along side an lda - style word sampling process . ncrp is a recursive version of the standard chinese restaurant process ( crp ) , which progresses according to the following analogy : an empty chinese restaurant has an infinite number of tables , and each table has an infinite number of chairs . when the first customer arrives he sits in the first chair at the first table with probability of 1 . the second customer can then chose to sit at an occupied table with probability of @xmath20 or sit at a new , unoccupied table with probability of @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the current customer , @xmath23 is the number of customers currently sitting at table @xmath24 , and @xmath25 is a parameter that defines the affinity to sit at a previously occupied table . the nested version of the crp extends the original analogy as follows : at each table in the chinese restaurant are cards with the name of another chinese restaurant . when a customer sits at a given table , he reads the card , gets up and goes to that restaurant , where he is reseated according to the crp . each customer visits @xmath19 restaurants until he is finally seated and is able to eat . this process creates a tree with a depth of @xmath19 and a width determined by the @xmath25 parameter . this process has also been called the chinese restaurant franchise because of this analogy @xcite . adams , _ et al . _ proposed a hierarchical topic model called tree structured stick breaking ( tssb ) , illustrated in figure [ fig : rwtssb ] , wherein documents can live at internal nodes , rather than exclusively at leaf nodes@xcite . however , this process involves chaining together conjugate priors which makes inference more complicated , and it also does not make use of link data . other work along this line include hierarchical labeled lda ( hllda ) by petinot _ et al . _ @xcite hllda , as well as fixed structure lda ( fslda ) by reisinger and pasca @xcite which modify hlda by fixing the hierarchical structure and learning hierarchical topic distributions . the hierarchical pachinko allocation model(hpam ) , shown in figure [ fig : rwhpam ] , produces a directed acyclic graph ( dag ) of a fixed depth allowing for each internal ( non - document ) node to be represented a mixture of more abstract , _ i.e. _ , higher level , topics @xcite . in network - only data , community discovery is the process of finding self - similar group , or clusters . the shrink algorithm creates hierarchical clusters by identifying tightly - knit communities and by finding disparate clusters by looking for hubs and other heuristics @xcite . clauset , _ et al _ , discover dendrograms by monte carlo sampling @xcite ; however , dendrograms poorly represent the manually curated hierarchies and taxonomies that we are pursuing . stochastic block models ( sbm ) are an alternative line of network clustering research that partitions nodes into communities in order to generatively infer link probabilities @xcite . several extensions to the original sbm have since been proposed ( for a survey see @xcite ) . one downside to block - model processes is that they assign probabilities to every possible edge requiring @xmath26 complexity in every sampling iteration . furthermore , sbm methods typically are not concerned with topical / conceptual properties of the nodes . because hdtm merges document text and inter - document links into a single model , we assume that the words and their latent topics fit within the link structure of the graph , and that the graph structure explains topical relationships between interlinked documents . topic modeling with network structure ( tmn ) is similar in this regard because it regularizes a statistical topic model with a harmonic regularizer based on the graph structure in the data ; the result is that topic proportions of linked documents are similar to each other @xcite . however , hierarchical information is not discovered nor can be easily inferred from this model . topic - sensitive pagerank combines document topics with the pagerank algorithm , by arguing that the pagerank score of a document ought to be influenced by its topical connection to the referring document @xcite . like tmn model , topic - senstive pagerank does not construct any type of information network hierarchy . other work on generative models that combine text and links include : a probabilistic model for document connectivity @xcite , the link - plsa - lda and pairwise - link - lda methods @xcite , the latent topic model for hypertext ( lthm ) method @xcite , role discovery in social networks @xcite , the author - topic - model @xcite , and others . the above models operate by encoding link probability as a discrete random variable or a bernoulli trial that is parameterized by the topics of the documents . the relational topic model ( rtm ) builds links between topics , where observed links are given a very high likelihood @xcite . the topicblock model combines the non - parametric hlda and stochastic block models @xcite to generate document taxonomies from text and links @xcite ; however , topicblock , like hlda , does not permit documents to reside at non - leaf nodes of the resulting tree . to apply topic modeling algorithms on web - scale data , several parallel algorithms have been introduced . newman , _ et al _ proposed an exact distributed gibbs sampling algorithm as well as an approximate distributed gibbs sampling algorithm that uses local gibbs sampling and global synchronization @xcite . smyth , _ et al _ introduced an asynchronous distributed algorithm that was capable of learning lda - style topics @xcite ; and ahmed , _ et al _ recently released yahoo lda , which is a scalable approximate inference framework on large - scale streaming data @xcite . these parallel approaches use the conventional , procedural programming paradigms , and as a result can not guarantee statistically sound samples from their gibbs iterations . although conventional parallel and distributed algorithms indeed divide the document set into smaller groups , the maximum number of subgroups is subject to the number of processors . in contrast , the vertex - programming paradigm , _ e.g. _ , pregel , graphlab and graphx @xcite , can distribute sampling operations at a much finer granularity by treating each graph - node as an independent computing unit . although the distributed variants of topic inference have made significant contributions in large scale topic models on the one hand , and large scale graph processing on the other hand , we are unaware of any parallel algorithm capable of joining these two subjects to infer topical hierarchies on large scale information networks . in contrast to the previous work , hdtm builds a hierarchy of documents from text and inter - document links . in this model , each node in the hierarchy contains a single document , and the hierarchy s width and depth is not fixed . the distributed version of proposed algorithm has the ability to handle graph with millions of nodes and billions of tokens . the problem of inferring the document hierarchy is a learning problem akin to finding the single , best parent for each document - node . unlike previous algorithms , which discover latent topic taxonomies , the hierarchical document - topic model ( hdtm ) finds hidden hierarchies by selecting edges in the document graph . this section presents a detailed description of the model . beginning with a document graph @xmath27 of documents @xmath1 and edges @xmath2 . each document is a collection of words , where a word @xmath7 is an item in a vocabulary . the basic assumption of hdtm and similar models is that each document can be generated by probabilistically mixing words from among topics . distributions over topics are represented by @xmath28 , which is a multinomial variable with an associated set of distributions over words @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is a dirichlet hyper - parameter . document - specific mixing proportions are denoted by the vector @xmath31 . parametric - bayes topic models also include a @xmath32 parameter that denotes the number of topics , wherein @xmath28 is one of @xmath32 possible values and @xmath31 is a @xmath32-d vector . hdtm , and other non - parametric bayesian models , do not require a @xmath32 parameter as input . instead , in hdtm there exist @xmath33 topics , one for each graph node , and each document is a mixture of the topics on the path between itself and the root document . in the original lda model , a single document mixture distribution is @xmath34 . the process for generating a document is ( 1 ) choose a @xmath31 of topic proportions from a distribution @xmath35 , where @xmath35 is a dirichlet distribution ; ( 2 ) sample words from the mixture distribution @xmath36 for the @xmath31 chosen in step 1 . hlda is an extension of lda in which the topics are situated in a taxonomy @xmath37 of fixed depth @xmath19 . the hierarchy is generated by the nested chinese restaurant process ( ncrp ) which represents @xmath31 as an @xmath19-dimensional vector , defining an @xmath19-level path through @xmath37 from root to document . because of the ncrp process , every document lives at a leaf and the words in each document are a mixture of the topic - words on the path from it to the root . the ncrp stochastic process could not be used to infer document hierarchies because the ncrp process forces documents to the leaves in the tree . hdtm replaces ncrp with random walk with restart ( rwr ) ( which is also known as personalized pagerank ( ppr ) ) @xcite . in contrast , random walk with teleportation ( aka pagerank ) random walks by selecting a random starting point , and , with probability @xmath38 , the walker randomly walks to a new , connected location or chooses to jump to a random location with probability @xmath25 , where @xmath25 is called the jumping probability , however , this would be ambiguous with the dirichlet hyper - parameter @xmath12 . ] . in hdtm , the root node is fixed , either as the entry page of a web site , by some other heuristic or manually . therefore , for the purposes of hierarchy inference , the random walker is forced to start and restart at the root node . [ alg : rwr ] ( ) @xmath39 ( ) @xmath40 @xmath41 say we wish to find the rwr - probability between some node @xmath42 and some target node @xmath43 . we model this by a random walker visiting document @xmath42 at time @xmath44 . in the next time step , the walker chooses a document @xmath45 from among @xmath42 s outgoing neighbors @xmath46 in the hierarchy @xmath37 uniformly at random . in other words , at time @xmath47 , the walker lands at node @xmath48 with probability @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the outdegree of some document @xmath51 . if at any time , there exists an edge to @xmath52 , _ i.e _ , an edge between the current node @xmath42 and the target node @xmath43 in the original graph @xmath0 , then we record the probability of that new path possibility for later sampling . alg . [ alg : rwr ] describes this process algorithmically . this procedure allows for new paths from the root @xmath53 to be probabilistically generated based on the current hierarchy effectively allowing for documents to migrate up , down and through the hierarchy during sampling . because a document hierarchy is a tree , each document - node can only have one parent . selecting a path for a document @xmath8 in the graph @xmath0 is akin to selecting a parent @xmath54 ( and grandparents , etc . ) from @xmath55 in the document graph @xmath0 . hdtm creates and samples from a probability distribution over each documents parent , where the probability of document @xmath42 being the parent of @xmath8 is defined as : @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the walkers current position at time @xmath44 , @xmath58 is the depth of @xmath8 in @xmath37 , and @xmath59 is the outdegree of @xmath57 in the hierarchy @xmath37 . in other words , the probability of landing at @xmath8 is the product of the emission probabilities from each document in the path through @xmath37 from @xmath4 to @xmath8 . this random walker function assigns higher probabilities to parents that are at a shallower depth than those at deeper positions . this is in line with the intuition that flatter hierarchies are easier for human understanding than deep hierarchies @xcite . simply put , the restart probability @xmath25 controls how much resistance there is to placing a document at successive depths . algorithmically , hdtm infers document hierarchies by drawing paths @xmath60 from the @xmath4 to the document @xmath8 . thus , the documents are drawn from the following generative process : 1 . each document @xmath61 is assigned a topic @xmath62 dir(@xmath63 ) : 2 . for each document @xmath61 : 1 . draw a path @xmath64 rwr(@xmath25 ) 2 . draw an @xmath19-dim topic proportion vector @xmath31 from dir(@xmath12 ) , where @xmath65len@xmath66 . 3 . for each word @xmath67 : 1 . choose topic @xmath68 mult(@xmath69 ) . choose word @xmath70 mult(@xmath71 ) , where @xmath72 is the topic in the @xmath28th position in @xmath60 . in this generative process hierarchical nodes represent documents _ and _ topics , where internal nodes contain the shared terminology of its descendants . the illustration in figure [ fig : topicdocuments ] shows the two potential outputs from a three - node graph of the wikipedia articles : , and . clearly , data mining and machine learning could both be regarded as children of computer science , but there is indeed a wiki - link from to in the graph . there are two key ideas conveyed in this illustration . the first is that the hierarchy on the left picks edges so as to ignore the to wiki - link ( denoted as a thin - grey line ) , whereas the hierarchy on the right picks edges so as to ignore the to wiki - link . thus , in this toy example , there are two possible hierarchy outcomes presented : the one on the left and the one on the right in figure [ fig : topicdocuments ] . the second idea conveyed in this illustration is that the word - topic distributions ( in colored circles ) are stored along with documents words ( in black squares ) at the same position in the hierarchy . the word distribution within each topic is constrained such that a document may only propagate terms upwards through the currently selected / sampled hierarchical topology . thus , it is impossible , in the hierarchy on the left , for the topic distribution at to contain a word unique to or . it is similarly impossible , in the hierarchy on the right , for the topic distribution in to contain a word unique to even though this is indeed possible in the hierarchical topology on the left . like in earlier models , there is statistical pressure to have more general terms in topics towards the root of the hierarchy . this is because every path in the hierarchy includes the root node and there are more paths through nodes at higher levels than through nodes at lower levels . moving down the tree , the topics , and therefore the documents , become more specific . hyperparameters also play an important role in the shape and character of the hierarchy . the @xmath12 parameter affects the smoothing on topic distributions , and the @xmath63 parameter affects the smoothing on word distributions . the @xmath25 parameter is perhaps the most important parameter because it affects the depth of the hierarchy . specifically , if @xmath25 is set to be large ( _ e.g. _ , @xmath73 ) then resulting hierarchy is shallow . low values ( _ e.g. _ , @xmath74 ) may result in deep hierarchies , because there is a smaller probabilistic penalty for each step that the random walker takes . exact inference on this model is intractable , so an approximation technique for posterior inference is used . the gibbs sampling algorithm is ideal in this situation because it simultaneously allows exploration of topic distributions and potential graphical hierarchies . the variables needed by the gibbs sampler are : @xmath75 , the @xmath22th word in document @xmath8 ; @xmath76 , the assignment of the @xmath22th word in document @xmath8 ; and @xmath77 , the topic corresponding to document at the @xmath28th level . the @xmath31 and @xmath30 variables are integrated out forming a collapsed gibbs sampler . the sampling is performed in two parts : ( 1 ) given the current level allocations of each word @xmath76 sample the path @xmath77 , ( 2 ) given the current state of the hierarchy , sample @xmath76 . in other words , we use the topic distributions to inform the path selections that make up the hierarchy , and the hierarchy topology to inform the topic distributions . the first gibbs sampling step is to draw a path from each document to the root through the graph . the sampling distribution for a path @xmath78 is @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the count of terms in document @xmath8 , and @xmath81 are the words without document @xmath8 . this equation is an expression of bayes theorem where the first term represents the probability of data given some choice of path from the root , and the second term represents the probability of selecting some path . specifically , the second term represents the probability of drawing the path @xmath82 to document @xmath8 at depth @xmath43 from the rwr process . recall that each node has an emission probability of @xmath83 , and a restart probability of @xmath25 . the probability is defined recursively : @xmath84 in other words , the probability of reaching @xmath8 is equal to the probability of a random walker with restart probability @xmath25 being at document @xmath8 at time @xmath43 . the first term in eq . [ eq : pathsample ] is the probability of a given word based on the current path @xmath85 and topic assignment @xmath86 : @xmath87 + w\eta } ) } { \prod_w { \gamma ( \#[\mathbf{c}_{-d , k } = c_{d , k } , \mathbf{w}_{-d } = w ] + \eta } ) } } \times \\ & \quad\hspace{1.1 cm } \frac { \prod_w{\gamma ( \#[\mathbf{z } = k , \mathbf{c}_{k } = c_{d , k } , \mathbf{w } = w ] + \eta ) } } { \gamma ( \sum { \#[\mathbf{z } = k , \mathbf{c}_{k } = c_{d , k } , \mathbf{w } = w ] } + w\eta ) } , \label{eq : pwgivenc } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath88 $ ] counts the elements of an array that satisfy the given condition , and @xmath89 is the maximum depth of the current hierarchy state . the expression @xmath90 $ ] counts : ( ii ) @xmath91 , _ i.e. _ , the number of words @xmath7 that do not appear in @xmath8 , for each ( i ) @xmath92 , _ i.e. _ , the number of paths to the current document @xmath8 except those where the path length is @xmath43 . the expression @xmath93 counts : ( iii ) @xmath94 , _ i.e. _ , the number of words @xmath7 such that , ( ii ) @xmath95 , _ i.e. _ , the words appear in document @xmath8 and are situated at the end of a path of length @xmath43 , where ( i ) @xmath96 , _ i.e. _ , @xmath43 is one of the topics in @xmath86 . @xmath97 is the size of the vocabulary . [ eq : pwgivenc ] is adapted from the standard ratio of normalizing constants for the dirichlet distribution @xcite . given the current state of all the variables , the word sampler must first pick an assignment @xmath28 for word @xmath22 in document @xmath8 . the sampling distribution of @xmath76 is @xmath98 where @xmath99 and @xmath100 . the first term is a distribution over word assignments : @xmath101 + \eta \end{split}\ ] ] which is the @xmath63-smoothed frequency of seeing word @xmath75 in the topic at level @xmath76 in the path @xmath78 . the second term is the distribution over levels @xmath102}{\#[\mathbf{z}_{d ,- n } \ge j ] } } \right ) \times \\ & \frac{1-\gamma}{\mathrm{deg}_t(d_{k-1 } ) } \frac{\#[\mathbf{z}_{d ,- n } = k]}{\#[\mathbf{z}_{d ,- n } \ge k ] } , \end{split } \label{eq : abuse}\ ] ] where @xmath88 $ ] is the number of elements in the vector which satisfy the given condition . [ eq : abuse ] abuses notation so that the product from @xmath103 to @xmath104 combines terms representing nodes at the @xmath105th level in the path @xmath85 down to the parent of @xmath106 , and the second set of terms represents document @xmath106 at level @xmath43 . the @xmath107 symbol in eq . [ eq : abuse ] refers to terms representing all ancestors of a particular node , and @xmath108 refers to the ancestors of a node including itself . a common complaint among data science practitioners is that graphical models , especially , non - parametric bayesian graphical models , do not perform well at scale . with this in mind , we also implemented the hdtm inference algorithm in the scalable , distributed vertex - programming paradigm . the mechanism behind gibbs sampling , and other markov chain monte carlo methods , requires sequential sampling steps , and execution of each step depends on the results of the previous step making gibbs samplers , and mcmc method in general , difficult to parallelize . approximate distributed lda ( ad - lda ) is one attempt to find approximate , distributed solutions to the serial inference problem by dividing documents into @xmath109 parts where @xmath109 is the number of processors and initializes the topic distribution @xmath28 globally . then , for every gibbs iteration , each processor samples @xmath110 of the dataset using the @xmath111 from last gibbs sampling iteration . when all processors are finished , a global synchronization is performed and @xmath28 is updated @xcite . following the distribution lessons from ad - lda we sought to also implement a scalable , distributed version of hdtm . however , a major difference between the lda / hlda and hdtm is that hlda uses the ncrp stochastic process to assign terms to topics , while hdtm samples paths from a graph of documents using graph - based random walk with restart method . the process of random walks over the network topology combined with the term sampling process described above is a good candidate for the vertex - programming paradigm using frameworks like pregel @xcite or graphlab @xcite . although mapreduce is a widely used , general purpose parallel scheme that can easily deal with scalable data , it is not optimized for _ iterative _ computational tasks such as statistical inference or logistic regression @xcite . this is because mapreduce materializes all intermediate results and to disk in order to tolerate task failures . mapreduce , therefore , has relatively high i / o costs compared to other designs that keep data in memory across iterations @xcite . apart from mapreduce , another scalable solution is to build a custom distributed system using message passing interface ( mpi ) . custom approaches are usually closer to optimal because developers can tune the code based on their own needs and minimize the unnecessary overhead . however , the drawbacks are also significant : because mpi is a barebone communication specification developers need to write their own code for job dispatching , load balancing , and dealing with node failure @xcite . after evaluating aforementioned approaches , we decided to use an emerging computational paradigm called vertex programming . vertex programming aims to improve the performance of graph / network computing by automatically distributing in - memory computation and with vertex - centric scheduling . unlike the mapreduce paradigm , which writes every intermediate result to disk , vertex programming keeps data up - to - date , in - memory and reduces i / o overhead by only materializing data to disk through periodic checkpoints . vertex - centric scheduling views every graph - vertex as an elementary computing unit and uses mpi ( or some other message passing system ) to transfer data over graph - edges . typically , vertex - programs are rather easy to implement , can be distributed easily , and are much more computationally efficient than conventional , procedural programming when working with iterative computational tasks @xcite . several vertex programming frameworks , including spark - graphx , hama , graphlab , graphlab create and graphlab 2.0 ( powergraph ) , were evaluated , and the powergraph framework was ultimately chosen . the decision was based , in part , from insurmountable troubles experienced during several months of implementation attempts on spark s graphx framework . ultimately , we concluded that c++ and mpi based powergraph was faster , more scalable and had a much smaller memory footprint than other frameworks . [ alg : dist_rwr ] ( ) vertex @xmath112 [ alg : dist_upate ] ( ) vertex @xmath112 the distributed hdtm inference algorithm is similar to procedural hdtm . we do not detail the entire distributed hdtm inference algorithm in this paper ; however , the source code is referenced in the section [ sec : conclusions ] . to fit hdtm to the vertex - programming model , changes in sampling sequence and attention to global synchronization were required . firstly , random walk with restart must be executed during each gibbs iteration so that every visited node can have a random walk probability . next , every node gathers @xmath81 , @xmath86 , and @xmath85 separately and decides their new path @xmath85 according to eq [ eq : pathsample ] and shown in alg [ alg : dist_rwr ] . after a path is sampled , each node will pick sample assignments @xmath28 for each word @xmath22 across all documents / nodes @xmath8 in parallel according to eq [ eq : wordsample ] . a global synchronization step is required so that each document / node can update the number of words @xmath22 and the topic assignments @xmath28 globally ; fortunately , because the topics and words are sampled according to the information provided in the _ path _ from root @xmath4 to the each document @xmath106 ( document @xmath8 at level @xmath43 ) , it suffices to update the nodes on the path from @xmath4 to @xmath106 instead of an actual global update to all nodes in @xmath1 . this vertex - programming based path - global update function is shown in alg [ alg : dist_upate ] . furthermore , this update is executed during the _ synchronization barrier _ , which is built - in to most vertex - programming frameworks , is highly optimized , and does not lock the global system any more than the synchronization barrier already does . this section describes the method and results for evaluating the hdtm model . a quantitative and qualitative analysis of the hierarchical document - topic model s ability to learn accurate and interpretable hierarchies of document graphs is shown . the main evaluations explore the empirical likelihood of the data and a very large case study wherein human judges are asked to evaluate the constructed hierarchies . hdtm is evaluated on four corpora : the wikipedia category graph , the wikipedia document graph , a computer science web site from the university of illinois , and a bibliographic network of all cikm and sigir conferences . the wikipedia data set has been used several times in the past for topic modeling purpose . however , because of the computational resources needed to infer topic models , prior studies have severely constricted the dataset size . , crawled 105 pages starting with the article on the nips conference finding 799 links @xcite . ho _ et al . _ performed a larger evaluation of their topicblock model using 14,675 document with 152,674 links ; however , they truncated each article to only the first 100 terms and limited the vocabulary to the 10,000 most popular words @xcite . the wikipedia category data set is a crawl of the _ category _ graph of wikipedia , beginning at the category as shown in figure [ fig : inh_wikicat ] . in wikipedia each category has a collection of articles and a set of links to other categories ; however , categories do nt typically have text associated with them , so the text of each article associated with a particular category is associated to the category s text . for example , the category includes articles : , etc . in total the crawled category graph consisted of 609 categories with text from 6,745 articles . the category graph is rather sparse with only 2,014 edges between categories , but has vocabulary size of 146,624 with 5,570,868 total tokens . we did not perform any text preprocessing procedure , including stop word removal and stemming , in any of the experiments due to empirical findings that these models are robust to the presents of stop words , etc @xcite . such settings can also explore hdtm s robustness in presence of a large and noisy corpus . a computer science department web site from the university of illinois urbana - champaign was chosen as the second data set because it represents a rooted web graph with familiar topics . by inferring the document hierarchy , the goal is to find the organizational structure of the computer science department . the intuition is that web sites reflect the business organization of the underlying entity ; thus it is expected that subtrees consisting of courses , faculty , news , research areas , etc . are found at high levels , and specific web pages are found at lower levels in the hierarchy . web site was crawled starting at the entry page and captured 1,078 web pages and 63,052 hyperlinks . in total there were 15,101 unique terms from 771,309 tokens . the bibliographic network consists of documents and titles from 4,713 articles from the sigir and cikm conferences . there exist 3,908 terms across 43,345 tokens in the document collection . in this collection , links include citations between papers within the cikm and sigir conferences . due to different citation styles , vendor abbreviations , and ambiguous names , without human interference most bibliographical meta - data extraction algorithms can only extract a portion of correct data @xcite . here we choose to use the most complete citation data set available from by the authors of the arnetminer project @xcite , however the citation graph is not guaranteed to be complete . a sigir 1998 paper by ponte and croft @xcite was chosen to be the root document because , in the data set , it had the most in - collection citations . to construct a larger data set with finer granularity , the english wikipedia article graph is used . in wikipedia , every wiki - article has two different link types : 1 ) category links , which point from the article to its categories , and 2 ) wiki - links , which point from the article to other wiki - articles . the category links are important because they hint at some encoded hierarchical structure that was codified on top of wikipedia after the article - graph was largely developed . for example , the wiki - article has a category link to and wiki - links to and among others . in later experiments we infer a document hierarchy from wikipedia and compare it to the crowd - encoded wikipedia category hierarchy . our wikipedia snapshot has 4,606,884 documents with 1,878,158,318 tokens , 44,739,242 links , and a vocabulary of 6,064,216 words . because the document graph is not a single connected component , we picked the largest component in that graph as data set . this giant component contains 1,957,268 documents and 44,673,134 document to document links ; 42.49% of nodes and 70% of edges are in this component . additionally , 1,316,879,537 terms with 4,225,765 unique tokens appear in this component , which is approximately 70% of the total number of terms . as a graph - preprocessing step , we replaced all edges pointing to redirection pages with edges that point directly to the actual wiki - article . using either the traditional inference model from sec . [ sec : inference ] or the high - throughput distributed sampling algorithm from sec . [ sec : distinference ] we basically sample a full hierarchy @xmath113 by sampling paths for each node @xmath78 except the root and the words in the document @xmath76 . given the state of the sampler at some time @xmath44 , _ i.e. _ , @xmath114 and @xmath115 , we iteratively sample each variable conditioned on the others as illustrated in [ sec : generating ] . the conditional distribution of the latent variables in hdtm model the given document - network . after running the markov chain a sufficient number of times we approach the stationary distribution ; the process of approaching the stationary distribution is called the `` burn - in '' period . after the burn - in we collect samples at a selected interval , _ i.e. _ , the sampling lag . the collected `` samples '' from the markov chain are full hierarchies constructed from the selection of a path for each node @xmath78 and a word for each document @xmath76 . therefore each sampled hierarchy contains one estimation about position of each document in the hierarchy and the position of each word in a document . for a given sampled hierarchy , we can assess the goodness of the hierarchy by measuring the log probability of that hierarchy and the observed words conditioned on the hyperparameters : @xmath116 using this log likelihood function it is possible to pick the most sampled hierarchy that maximizes the log likelihood as the final result . later , we will relax this assumption and use a more robust measurement that computes the mode of the sampled hierarchies and determines the _ certainty _ of the result . hdtm has some distinct qualities that make apples to apples comparison difficult . because hdtm is the first model to generate document hierarchies based on graphs , there is nothing to _ directly _ compare against . however , some of the models in the related work perform similar tasks , and so comparisons were performed when applicable . the related models typically perform quantitative evaluation by measuring the log likelihood on held out data or by performing some other task like link prediction . log likelihood analysis looks at the goodness of fit on held out data . unfortunately , the creation of a `` hold out '' data set is not possible , because each document , especially documents on the first or second level document , is very important to the resulting hierarchy . removing certain documents might even cause the graph to separate , which would make hierarchy inference impossible . instead , for the first quantitative evaluation , we compare the highest log likelihood generated from each model s sampler . quantitative experiments were performed on many of the aforementioned algorithms including : hlda @xcite , topicblock @xcite , tssb @xcite , and fslda @xcite . the fixed structure in fslda is determined by a breadth first iteration over the document graph because url heuristics used in the original paper do not exist in most of our data sets . the depth of hlda and topicblock is 4 . in all cases , a gibbs sampler was run for 5,000 iterations ; with a burn - in of 2,000 and a sampling lag of 20 . figure [ fig : lliterations ] shows the log likelihood for each sample on the computer science web site ; the other data sets showed similarly - shaped results . interestingly , figure [ fig : llavgdepth ] shows that higher likelihood values are strongly correlated with hierarchies of deeper average depth . lower @xmath25 values result in deeper hierarchies . ] the gibbs sampling algorithm was run on hdtm for various values of @xmath25 , and figure [ fig : bestcumll ] shows the best cumulative log likelihood for each of the tested values of @xmath25 . we observe that hdtm with @xmath74 achieved the best likelihood score . likelihood scores decreased steadily for increasing @xmath25 values , and hdtm with @xmath73 achieved the worst likelihood score . table [ tab : llresults ] shows the results of the different algorithms on the three smaller data sets . the topicblock and tssb clearly infer models with the best likelihood . the remaining algorithms , including hdtm , have mixed results . although these log likelihood results initially seem as if hdtm performs poorly , we demonstrate in section [ subsec : discussion ] that these likelihood results are expected and preferred . recall that the goal of hdtm is to generate document hierarchies from some original document - graph . thus , a positive result should somehow demonstrate that hdtm demonstrates hierarchies that are similar to the hierarchy that a human ( or many humans ) would create given the same document graph . with this in mind we performed a large scale experiment on the full english wikipedia article graph . also recall that the wikipedia category graph establishes a hierarchy that was human - built on top of wikipedia that maintains a pseudo - hierarchical classification of almost every document . the structure of categories is described to be a _ tree _ rooted by or ; however , we find that 87.01% of categories have an in - degree larger than 1 indicating the actual category is more complex . we find that although the wikipedia category graph _ mostly _ resembles a top - down ( coarse to fine ) hierarchy , it is technically an undirected loopy graph . as for wiki - articles , they almost always belong to more than one category because the idea or object described in each article can rightfully have multiple classification perspectives . for example , the wiki - article belongs to a category of the same name , but it also belongs to and among others . for a large scale evaluation our task is to infer a hierarchy from the full wikipedia article graph and see how well it matches the category graph . unfortunately , it is difficult to measure similarity between category graph and hdtm - hierarchies using conventional evaluation methods like the log likelihood . consider , for example , the category , which contains wiki - articles of faculty members from vastly different topical fields . in such cases , the bond is described primarily by the links rather than the content ; nevertheless , the log likelihood score judges models based on the goodness of fit of words . thus it is unreasonable to measure hierarchy quality by likelihood scores alone ; indeed , the hierarchy with the best possible likelihood score may be very different from actual , human created hierarchy . in order to perform a more thorough evaluation we should also compare the the graph structure . graph topologies can be compared in many different ways . among many options we chose deltacon @xcite to measure the similarity between hdtm s hierarchy and the wikipedia category hierarchy three reasons : 1 ) deltacon can calculate the similarity between two graphs with nodes that partially overlap , as observed in the messy wikipedia category graph , 2 ) the underlying metric in deltacon is the affinity score calculated by fast belief propagation ( fabp ) , which models the connectivity of nodes , and 3 ) deltacon can process millions of nodes in only a few hours . the deltacon metric returns a similarity score between the two compared graphs ranging between 0 and 1 inclusive where 0 is completely dissimilar and 1 is completely similar . although comparing with hlda and its variants is important , all existing hierarchical topic models are incapable of processing on data sets at this scale . we attempted to use the hlda implementation in the mallet package @xcite , but 130 hours was needed in order to compute a single gibbs sampling iteration . fortunately , we were able to use graphlab s implementation of lda which is based on models developed by ahmed _ et al . _ @xcite and smyth _ et al . _ although lda does not directly generate a graph , we are able to compare it with the category hierarchy by connecting the documents within a single lda - cluster to a made - up root node to simulate a hierarchy . the large scale models were inferred using 400 gibbs sampling iterations with a burn - in of 100 and a lag of 10 . in addition to hdtm and lda , we also use deltacon to compare the original wikipedia article graph and a randomly generated article - hierarchy as baselines . in the case of wikipedia article graph , we expect the wikipedia article graph ( the full graph , not a hierarchy ) to perform reasonably well because the category hierarchy is largely built on top of the article graph topology and they currently coexist and coevolve . in the case of the randomly generated article hierarchy , we randomly select a single parent for each node in the original article graph . .comparison of the wikipedia category graph to other generated hierarchies . deltacon scoring means higher is better . the random article hierarchy is generated by randomly picking one parent among all possible parents , _ i.e. _ , references , for each article . the differences in deltacon scores show that hdtm can preserve crucial connectivity information when constructing a new hierarchical structure from the original graph . [ cols=">,^ " , ] table [ tab : deltacon ] shows that the hierarchy inferred by hdtm is indeed most similar to the wikipedia category graph , followed by the random article hierarchy . recall that deltacon looks at graph topology similarity , thus the hdtm hierarchy is expected to more topologically similar to another hierarchy ( even if random ) than the article graph . these results demonstrate that hdtm can identify and preserve critical topological features when inferring a hierarchy from the graph . as usual , an increase in the number of lda topics increases the goodness of fit score ( in this case measured by deltacon instead of likelihood ) . interestingly , the @xmath25 parameter and the selection of different roots did not significantly influence deltacon score . to understand why this is , recall that different root - nodes and @xmath25 values result in different classification perspectives , but the different perspectives are still subsets of the same category graph with similar topological properties . hence they should have similar scores using the deltacon metric . recall that the hdtm , in its most basic form , generates a hierarchy by picking the best parent for each node / document ( except the root ) . in the iterative gibbs sampling process it is an almost certainty that a given node will pick different parents during different iterations . for example , say node @xmath8 has two parents @xmath117 and @xmath118 , it is possible that during iterations 15 node @xmath8 samples node @xmath117 as its parent , but then in iterations 620 node @xmath8 samples node @xmath118 to be its parent . two questions come to mind : 1 ) which parent should be ultimately picked for node @xmath8 in the final output graph ? and 2 ) what can the distribution of samples say about the certainty of our inferred graph ? in classic gibbs sampling , maximum a posteriori estimation is determined by the the mode of the samples . for some node @xmath8 , this translates to choosing the parent that appeared in the most samples as the final parent ; in the above case node @xmath8 would chose node @xmath118 as its parent because node @xmath118 was sampled 15 times compared to only 5 samples of node @xmath117 . to answer the second question , and therefore model the certainty of an inferred hierarchy , we calculate the number of times some node @xmath8 picks its final parent over the total number of samples normalized by the number of possible choices , _ i.e. _ , parents , node @xmath8 has . this results in a certainty score for node @xmath8 : @xmath119 where @xmath22 represents the total number of samples , @xmath120 is the number of times the final parent @xmath121 is sampled , and @xmath122 is the indegree of node @xmath8 representing the total number of parents that node @xmath8 could pick from . in the certainty score the outside fraction is used to measure the normalized difference between the raw probability and probability of random guess . applying this function to the above example we would calculate that the certainty score of node @xmath8 would be @xmath123 . figure [ fig : wiki_certainty_density ] shows the probability density functions for the certainties in hdtms parent sampling process . in the figures on both left and right we find that the probability densities appear to be polynomial distributions with interesting plateaus that end just before the 50% , 66% , and 75% certainty scores corresponding to the near - certain ( but not perfectly - certain ) scores for nodes with indegree values of 2 , 3 , and 4 respectively . in these results , and others not displayed in this paper , we find that when the root is a general document like , then changing @xmath25 does not affect the certainty distribution . given a relatively specific root like , larger @xmath25 values increase certainty overall . as discussed earlier , measuring topical similarity in hierarchies can be precarious because , in many cases , documents that are correctly situated under a topically unrelated parent may still have a strong contextual association with the parent document that outweighs the topical / language - oriented similarity as determined by the @xmath25 parameter . as an example , consider the wiki - articles and : even though these two articles are topically dissimilar , hdtm parameterized with a high @xmath25 value is likely to place both articles as children of the hierarchy s root because the high @xmath25 values weigh the topological link as more important that the documents inferred topicality . if , on the other hand , hdtm was parameterized with a very low @xmath25 value , then is more likely to be situated with other state senators , and the is more likely to be situated with other legislation . to quantitatively evaluate the topical and topological fitness of hierarchy together , we compare the similarily among the sets of parents and children in the inferred hierarchy against sets of wiki - articles and their wikipedia categories . because we are comparing sets of items we use the jaccard coefficient for this task . specifically , the jaccard coefficient is calculated by @xmath124 for each document @xmath8 that belongs to a set of categories @xmath125 , and where @xmath126 is the union of the corresponding categories of the nodes in @xmath8 s ancestors @xmath60 . the jaccard coefficient is useful here because it gives an quantitative measure describing how well the inferred hierarchical structure matches with the human - annotated categorical structure of wikipedia . figure [ fig : wiki_jaccard ] shows the relationship between jaccard coefficients of the hierarchies . for illustration clarity , in this figure all jaccard coefficients are binned into 10 equal intervals . we observe a clear correlation between the node s certainty function and its jaccard coefficient . this means that decisions that hdtm is most certain about tend to be the most similar to the human - created hierarchies . recall that hdtm uses the @xmath25 parameter to balance the weight of topological links and topical similarities . hence when specific nodes like are chosen as the root , higher @xmath25 will reduce jaccard coefficient for high certainty nodes . this is because higher @xmath25 values favor topology rather than content during the path and parent selection process . these results also underscore the importance of the selection of the root node . when provided a root node , which can be any node in the document graph , the inferred hierarchy is created from the perspective of that root . the hierarchy rooted at would therefore organize , say , congressional legislation differently than a hierarchy generated by the wiki - article on . yet , as we ve seen , the graph similarity metrics views the drastically different document - topic hierarchies as topologically similar . in order to properly understand the results captured in table [ tab : llresults ] from above , recall that log likelihood is a metric on the _ fit _ of the observations on the configuration of the model . the original work on lda @xcite found that likelihood increases as the number of topics increases . along those lines , chang , _ et al . _ demonstrated that more fine grained topics , which appear in models with a larger number of topics have a lower interpretability , despite having higher likelihood scores @xcite . simply put , there exists a negative correlation between likelihood scores and human interpretability in lda and similar topic models . applying those lessons to our experiments , recall that hdtm has as many topics as there are documents , and non - root document topics are mixtures of the topics on the path to the root . also recall that hlda , topicblock and tssb all generate a large number of latent topics . in hlda and topicblock , there are infinitely many topics / tables in the ncrp ; and practically speaking , the number of topics in the final model is much larger than the number of documents ( conditioned on the @xmath25 parameter ) . in tssb , the topic generation is said to be an interleaving of two stick breaking processes ; practically , this generates even larger topic hierarchies . the fslda algorithm has as many topics as there are in hlda , however , the fslda hierarchy is not redrawn during gibbs iterations to fit the word distributions resulting in a lower likelihood . simply put , the number of topics in hdtm and fslda @xmath127 @xmath128 hpam , hlda and topicblock @xmath128 tssb . similarly , figure [ fig : llavgdepth ] shows that deeper hierarchies have higher likelihood scores . this is because long document - to - root paths , found in deep hierarchies , are able to provide a more fine grained fit for the words in the document resulting in a higher likelihood . therefore , the better likelihood values of hlda , topicblock and tssb are due to the larger number of topics that these models infer and not necessarily due to better model outputs . in this case , a better way to evaluate model accuracy is by some external task or by manually judging the coherence of the topics . to measure the coherence of the inferred groupings , the _ word intrusion _ task developed by chang _ et al _ @xcite is slightly modified to create the _ document intrusion _ task . in this task , a human subject is presented with a randomly ordered set of eight document titles . the task for the human judge is to find the intruder , that is , the judge is asked to find which document is out of place or does not belong . if the set of documents without the intruder document all make sense together , then the human judge should easily be able to find the intruder . for example , given a set of computer science documents with titles \ { } , most people , even non - computer scientists , would pick as the intruder because the remaining words make sense together they are all computer science disciplines . for the set \ { } , identifying a single intruder is more difficult . human judges , when forced to make a choice , will choose an intruder at random , indicating that the grouping has poor coherence . to construct a set of document titles to present to the human judge , a grouping from the hierarchy is selected at random , and select seven documents are further selected at random from the grouping . if the there are fewer than 7 documents available in the selected grouping , then we select all of the documents available ; groupings of size less than 4 are thrown out . in addition to these documents , an intruder document is selected at random from among the entire collection of documents minus the documents in the test group . titles are then shuffled and presented to the human judges . extracting document groupings for evaluation is slightly different for each model . hdtm and fslda store a document at each node in the hierarchy . a grouping is selected by first picking a document at random , and then choosing its siblings . topicblock and hlda store documents at the leaves of the taxonomy , which often include several documents . a grouping is selected from these models by first picking a document at random , and then choosing the other documents in the leaf - topic . the hierarchies that the tssb model constructed allowed multiple documents to live at inner nodes . attempts to evaluate groupings on inner nodes with more than 4 documents were unsuccessful . nodes with 4 or more siblings were also difficult to find because the hierarchies that were generated were too sparse to find practical groupings . thus human judges with tssb groupings could not be found . each document - graph collection had different types of labels presented to the judges . the compsci web site collection was labeled by the web page title and url ; the wikipedia collection was labeled by the category title as shown in figure [ fig : intruder ] ; the bibliography network was labeled by the title of the paper . the intruder detection tasks described above were offered on amazon mechanical turk . no specialized training is expected of the judges . 50 tasks were created for each data set and model combination ; each user was presented with 5 tasks at a time at a cost of $ 0.07 per task . each task was evaluated by 15 separate judges . in order to measure the trustworthiness of a judge , 5 easy tasks were selected , _ i.e. _ , groupings with clear intruders , and gold - standard answers were created . judges who did not answer 80% of the gold - standard answers correctly are thrown out and not paid . in total the solicitation attracted 31,494 judgments , across 14 models of 50 tasks each . of these , 13,165 judgments were found to be from trustworthy judges . the _ model precision _ is measured based on how well the intruders were detected by the judges . specifically , if the intruder word @xmath129 is from model @xmath130 and task @xmath43 , and @xmath131 is the intruder selected by the human judge @xmath105 on task @xmath43 in model @xmath130 then @xmath132 where @xmath133 is the indicator function and @xmath134 is the number of judges . the model precision is basically the fraction of judges agreeing with the model . figure [ fig : turks ] shows boxplots of the precision for the four models on three corpora . in most cases , hdtm performs the best . as in @xcite , the likelihood scores do not necessarily correspond to human judgments . paired , two - tailed t - tests of statistical significants ( @xmath135 ) performed between hdtm @xmath136 and @xmath137 and the other models are represented by @xmath138 and @xmath139 in figure [ fig : turks ] respectively . . words at the root document represent the most probable words in the root topic . most probable words for other documents are not shown due to space constraints . ] the bibliography network data had relatively low precision scores . this is almost certainly because it was more difficult for the judges , who were probably not computer scientists , to differentiate between the topics in research paper titles . figure [ fig : dblphierarchy ] shows a small portion of the document hierarchy for the bibliographic network data set constructed with hdtm @xmath140 . the root document has 20 children in the hierarchy despite having 145 in - collection links . the remaining 120 documents live deeper in the hierarchy because hdtm has determined that they are too specific to warrant a first level position , and have a better fit in one of the subtrees . recall that each document is associated with the topics from itself to the root , where the root is a single , general topic . the seven most probable terms at the root level are also shown adjacent to the root s title in figure [ fig : dblphierarchy ] . these terms , like in hlda and topicblock , are terms that are general to the entire collection . similar sets of words exist at each node in the hierarchy , but are not shown in this illustration to maintain clarity . hdtm source code , analysis code and the scripts which generated the results found in this paper can be downloaded from https://github.com/nddsg/hdtm/releases/tag/kais . the wikipedia , web site and bibliographical data are all publicly available and free to download and are replicated in our own data repository . hierarchical document - topic model ( hdtm ) , is a bayesian generative model that creates document and topic hierarchies from rooted document graphs . the initial hypothesis was that document graphs , such as web sites , wikipedia and bibliographic networks contain a hidden hierarchy . unlike most previous work , hdtm allows documents to live at non - leaf nodes in the hierarchy , which requires the random walk with restart path sampling technique . an interesting side - effect of the random walker adaptation is that the path sampling step , eq . [ eq : pathsample ] , is much faster and easier to scale than the ncrp because rwr only creates a sampling distribution for the parents of a document , whereas the ncrp process creates a sampling distribution over all possible paths in the taxonomy . several quantitative experiments comparing hdtm with related models were performed . however , the results show that likelihood scores are a poor indicator of hierarchy interpretability , especially when the number of topics are different between comparison models . a large qualitative case study was also performed which showed that the cohesiveness of the document groupings generated by hdtm were statistically better than many of the comparison models despite the poor likelihood scores . 55ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/nips/nips2010.html#adamsgj10[__ ] ( ) pp . http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=944919.944937 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1145/2187836.2187936 [ _ _ ] ( , ) p. in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/nips/nips2010.html#chambersss10[__ ] ( ) pp . http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/journals/jmlr/jmlrp5.html#changb09 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1145/1273496.1273576 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/trec/trec2004.html#songwsxlqzzxm04[__ ] ( ) in link:\doibase 10.1145/1076034.1076105 [ _ _ ] ( , ) p. link:\doibase 10.1145/984321.984322 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/journals/jmlr/jmlrp15.html#nallapatimm11[__ ] , vol . ( ) pp . in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/icwsm/icwsm2008.html#furukawamoui08[__ ] ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/0306 - 4573(88)90027 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10618 - 005 - 0361 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase 10.1023/a:1022852608280 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0004 - 3702(89)90046 - 5 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1145/1102351.1102389 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . in http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2002736.2002866[__ ] ( ) pp . http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1690219.1690233 [ ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1145/1871437.1871469 [ _ _ ] ( , ) p. link:\doibase 10.1038/nature06830 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0378 - 8733(83)90021 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] http://arxiv.org/abs/0912.5410 [ , * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1145/1367497.1367512 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . in link:\doibase 10.1145/511446.511513 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/nips/nips2000.html#cohnh00[__ ] ( ) pp . in link:\doibase 10.1145/1401890.1401957 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/uai/uai2008.html#gruberrw08[__ ] ( ) pp . in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/ijcai/ijcai2005.html#mccallumcw05[__ ] ( ) pp . in http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/conf/uai/uai2004.html#rosen-zvigss04[__ ] ( ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop ( ) http://dblp.uni-trier.de/db/journals/pvldb/pvldb4.html#bahmanicg10 [ * * , ( ) ] in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . in @noop _ _ , vol . ( ) p. link:\doibase 10.1145/2094114.2094118 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) @noop ( ) in @noop _ _ ( ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . in link:\doibase 10.1145/1401890.1402008 [ _ _ ] ( , ) p. in link:\doibase 10.1145/290941.291008 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . @noop ( ) @noop ( ) in @noop _ _ ( ) pp . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: since its discovery in 1974 @xcite , the charmonium system has become the prototypical ` hydrogen atom ' of meson spectroscopy @xcite . the experimentally clear spectrum of relatively narrow states below the open - charm dd threshold of 3.73 gev can be identified with the 1s , 1p and 2s levels predicted by potential models , which incorporate a color coulomb term at short distances and a linear scalar confining term at large distances . spin - dependent interquark forces are evident in the splittings of states within these multiplets , and the observed splittings are consistent with the predictions of a one gluon exchange ( oge ) breit - fermi hamiltonian , combined with a linear scalar confining interaction . discussions of the theoretical importance and experimental status of heavy quarkonium , including recent experimental results for charmonium , have been given by quigg @xcite , galik @xcite , the cern quarkonium working group @xcite , seth @xcite and swarnicki @xcite . recently there has been a resurgence of interest in charmonium , due to the realization that b factories can contribute to the study of the missing states @xcite , and to high - statistics experiments at bes @xcite and cleo @xcite and the planned gsi @xmath3 facility @xcite . the possibility of contributions from b factories was dramatically illustrated by the recent discovery of the long missing @xmath4 @xmath5 state by the belle collaboration @xcite , which has since been confirmed by babar @xcite , and has also been observed by cleo in @xmath6 collisions @xcite . additional interest in spectroscopy has followed the discovery of the remarkable x@xmath7 by belle @xcite and cdf @xcite in b decays to @xmath8 ; assuming that this is a real resonance rather than a threshold effect , the x@xmath7 is presumably either a dd@xmath9 charmed meson molecule @xcite or a narrow @xmath10 d - wave state @xcite . very recent observations of the x@xmath7 in @xmath11 and @xmath12 by belle support a @xmath13 dd@xmath9 molecule assignment @xcite . there has also been experimental activity in the spin - singlet p - wave sector , with recent reports of the observation of the elusive @xmath14 @xmath15 state by cleo @xcite . finally , the surprisingly large cross sections for double charmonium production in @xmath16 reported by belle @xcite suggest that it may be possible to study c @xmath17 @xmath0 states in @xmath16 without using the higher - order @xmath18 two - photon annihilation process . one open topic of great current interest in spectroscopy is the search for the @xmath19 and @xmath20 states , which are expected to be quite narrow due to the absence of open - charm decay modes . a second topic is the lorentz nature of confinement ; in pure models this is tested by the multiplet splittings of orbitally - excited states . for example , with pure scalar confinement as is normally assumed there is no spin - spin hyperfine interaction at o@xmath21 , so the masses of spin - singlets ( such as the @xmath22 @xmath15 ) are degenerate with the corresponding triplet c.o.g . ( center of gravity ) ; here this is the @xmath1p@xmath23 c.o.g . , at 3525 mev . in the original cornell model @xcite it was assumed that confinement acts as the time component of a lorentz vector , which lifts the degeneracy of the @xmath15 and the @xmath1p@xmath23 c.o.g . another possibility is that confinement may be a more complicated mix of scalar and timelike vector @xcite . of course these simple potential model considerations may be complicated by mass shifts due to other effects , such as couplings to open - flavor channels @xcite . a third topic is the search for exotica such as hybrids ; the level of mixing between conventional quarkonium and hybrid basis states falls rapidly with increasing quark mass , which suggests that nonexotic hybrids may be more easily distinguished from conventional quarkonia in charmonium than in the light quark sectors . since lgt ( lattice gauge theory ) predicts that the lightest hybrids lie near 4.4 gev @xcite , there is a strong incentive to establish the background " spectrum of conventional states up to and somewhat beyond this mass . a final topic of current interest is the importance of mixing between quark model @xmath24 basis states and two - meson continua , which has been cited as a possible reason for the low masses of the recently discovered d@xmath25 states @xcite . the effects of unquenching the quark model " by including meson loops can presumably be studied effectively in the system , in which the experimental spectrum of states is relatively unambiguous . the success of the @xmath24 quark model is surprising , in view of the probable importance of corrections to the valence approximation ; the range of validity of the naive quenched " @xmath24 quark model is an interesting and open question @xcite . motivated by this revived interest in spectroscopy , we have carried out a theoretical study of the expected properties of charmonium states , notably the poorly understood higher - mass levels above dd threshold . two variants of potential models are used in this study , a conventional nonrelativistic model based on the schrdinger equation with a coulomb plus linear potential , and the godfrey - isgur relativized potential model . we give results for all states in the multiplets 1 - 4s , 1 - 3p , 1 - 2d , 1 - 2f and 1 g , comprising 40 resonances in total . predictions are given for quantities which are likely to be of greatest experimental interest , which are the spectrum of states , e1 ( and some m1 ) electromagnetic transition rates , and strong partial and total widths of states above open - charm threshold . similar results for many of the electromagnetic transition rates have recently been reported by ebert _ the @xmath26 leptonic and two - photon widths are not discussed in detail here , as they have been considered extensively elsewhere ; see for example @xcite and @xcite and references cited therein . as a minimal model of the charmonium system we use a nonrelativistic potential model , with wavefunctions determined by the schrdinger equation with a conventional quarkonium potential . we use the standard color coulomb plus linear scalar form , and also include a gaussian - smeared contact hyperfine interaction in the zeroth - order potential . the central potential is v_0^(c|c)(r ) = - + br + _ ( r ) _ c _ |c where @xmath27 . the four parameters @xmath28 are determined by fitting the spectrum . the spin - spin contact hyperfine interaction is one of the spin - dependent terms predicted by one gluon exchange ( oge ) forces . the contact form @xmath29 is actually an artifact of an o@xmath30 expansion of the t - matrix @xcite , so replacing it by an interaction with a range @xmath31 comparable to @xmath32 is not an unwarranted modification . we treat the remaining spin - dependent terms as mass shifts using leading - order perturbation theory . these are the oge spin - orbit and tensor and a longer - ranged inverted spin - orbit term , which arises from the assumed lorentz scalar confinement . these are explicitly v_spin - dep = . the spin - orbit operator is diagonal in a @xmath33 basis , with the matrix elements @xmath34/2 $ ] . the tensor operator t has nonvanishing diagonal matrix elements only between @xmath35 spin - triplet states , which are ^3l _ | | ^3l _ = . for experimental input we use the masses of the 11 reasonably well established @xmath0 states , which are given in table [ table_spectrum ] ( rounded to 1 mev ) . the parameters that follow from fitting these masses are @xmath36 . given these values , we can predict the masses and matrix elements of the currently unknown states ; table [ table_spectrum ] and fig . [ spectrum ] show the predicted spectrum . the godfrey - isgur model is a `` relativized '' extension of the nonrelativistic model of the previous section . this model assumes a relativistic dispersion relation for the quark kinetic energy , a qcd - motivated running coupling @xmath37 , a flavor - dependent potential smearing parameter @xmath38 , and replaces factors of quark mass with quark kinetic energy . details of the model and the method of solution may be found in ref.@xcite . the hamiltonian consists of a relativistic kinetic term and a generalized quark - antiquark potential , = h_0 + _ q|q ( , ) where _ 0 = + . just as in the nonrelativistic model , the quark - antiquark potential v@xmath39 assumed here incorporates the lorentz vector one gluon exchange interaction at short distances and a lorentz scalar linear confining interaction . to first order in @xmath40 , v@xmath41 reduces to the standard non - relativistic result given by eqns.(1 ) and ( 2 ) ( with @xmath42 replaced by a running coupling constant , @xmath37 ) . the full set of model parameters is given in ref.@xcite . note that the string tension and quark mass ( @xmath43 gev@xmath44 and @xmath45 gev ) are significantly larger than the values used in our nonrelativistic model . one important aspect of this model is that it gives reasonably accurate results for the spectrum and matrix elements of quarkonia of all @xmath46 quark flavors , whereas the nonrelativistic model of the previous section is only fitted to the system . the spectra predicted by the nr and gi models ( table [ table_spectrum ] and fig . [ spectrum ] ) are quite similar for s- and p - wave states , largely because of the constraints provided by the experimental candidates for these multiplets . we note in passing that these potential model results are very similar to the most recent predictions of the charmonium spectrum from lgt @xcite . at higher l we have only the l=2 @xmath47d@xmath48 and @xmath49d@xmath48 states @xmath50 and @xmath51 to constrain the models , and the predicted mean d - wave multiplet masses differ by _ ca . _ 50 mev . for @xmath52 the absence of experimental states allows a relatively large scatter of predicted mean masses , which differ by as much as @xmath53 mev in the 1 g multiplet . ( the splittings within higher l multiplets in contrast are rather similar . ) the mean multiplet masses predicted by the two models differ largely because of the values assumed for the string tension @xmath54 , which is @xmath55 gev@xmath44 in the gi model but is a rather smaller @xmath56 gev@xmath44 in the nr model . identification of any l=3 or l=4 state would be very useful as a constraint on the spectrum of higher - l states generally . this is unfortunately a difficult problem , since these states are not easily accessible experimentally . as we shall see , one possibility is to produce the @xmath1f@xmath57 @xmath58 state , which is formed in e1 radiative transitions from the @xmath51 and decays dominantly to dd and dd@xmath9 . ( for simplicity in this paper we abbreviate the final state d@xmath59 as dd " , the state d@xmath60d@xmath9 as dd@xmath9 " , and so forth . ) 1.0 cm ) . the solid lines are experiment , and the broken lines are theory ( nr model left , gi right ) . spin triplet levels are dashed , and spin singlets are dotted . the dd open - charm threshold at 3.73 gev is also shown.,width=321 ] radiative transitions of higher - mass charmonium states are of interest largely because they provide one of the few pathways between states with different quantum numbers . since typical e1 radiative partial widths of charmonia are 10s to 100s of kev , corresponding to significant branching fractions of @xmath61 to @xmath62 , large event samples of radially excited s - wave states produced in @xmath16 annihilation could be used to identify radially excited p - wave states , which are not otherwise easily produced . similarly , the e1 radiative transition of the nominally 2@xmath1d@xmath48 @xmath51 can be used to produce an f - wave state ; this multiplet would likely be very difficult to reach using other mechanisms . we evaluate these e1 radiative partial widths using _ e1 ( n ^2+1l _ ^2+1l_ + ) = c_fi _ e_c^2 |_f | r | _ i |^2 e_^3 , where @xmath63 is the @xmath64-quark charge in units of @xmath65 , @xmath66 is the fine - structure constant , e@xmath67 is the final photon energy , @xmath68 is the total energy of the final state , @xmath69 is the mass of the initial state , the spatial matrix element @xmath70 involves the initial and final radial wavefunctions , and the angular matrix element @xmath71 is c_fi=(, ) ( 2 + 1 ) \ { 1 } ^2 . this is the result of ref.@xcite , except for our inclusion of the relativistic phase space factor of @xmath72 , which is usually not far from unity . ( the gi results do not include this phase space factor . ) we evaluate these radiative partial widths in both the nr and gi models . for the nr model the matrix elements latexmath:[$\langle { n'}^{2{\s}'+1}{\l}'_{{\j } ' } |\ ; r \ ; linear plus smeared hyperfine wavefunctions of the potential model described in sec.iia , and for the gi model they were evaluated using the wavefunctions of ref.@xcite . since the masses predicted for unknown states differ in the two models , the assumed photon energy e@xmath67 differs as well ; these photon energies are given in the e1 and m1 transition tables ( tables [ e1rad_stop]-[m1rad ] ) together with the radiative partial widths . some e1 transitions that are of special importance for the study of higher charmonium states are discussed in the text . transitions from initial @xmath74 states are of greatest interest in this regard , since these can be studied with high statistics at @xmath16 machines . these can provide access to the spin - triplet members of the 2p and 3p multiplets in particular , starting from the @xmath75 and @xmath76 . e1 radiative transitions may also be useful in identifying the narrow 1d @xmath77 and @xmath78 states , since they are all predicted to have large partial widths ( _ ca . _ 300 kev ) to the 1p @xmath79 and @xmath15 states . although m1 rates are typically rather weaker than e1 rates , they are nonetheless interesting because they may allow access to spin - singlet states that are very difficult to produce otherwise . it is also interesting that the known m1 rates show serious disagreement between theory and experiment . this is in part due to the fact that m1 transitions between different spatial multiplets , such as @xmath80 ( 2s @xmath81 1s ) , are nonzero only due to small relativistic corrections to a vanishing lowest - order m1 matrix element . the m1 radiative partial widths are evaluated using _ m1 ( n ^2+1l _ ^2+1l_ + ) = 2j+12l+1 _ _ , 1 e_c^2 |_f | _ i ( see the previous e1 formula for definitions . ) the gi m1 radiative rates do not incorporate the @xmath72 phase space factor , but do include a @xmath82 recoil factor . we quote nr results both with and without this recoil factor . the photon energies e@xmath67 depend on the model in most cases , since we have assumed theoretical masses for unknown states . as with the e1 rates , we quote m1 radiative widths in both the nr potential model of sec.iia and the gi model @xcite of sec.iib . although the m1 decay rates involve a relatively simple off - diagonal matrix element of the magnetic moment operator , we note that our predicted rates show considerable variation with the model assumptions , and agreement with the two known m1 rates is not good . in the off - diagonal ( 2s @xmath81 1s ) transition @xmath80 this is because the zeroth - order m1 matrix element vanishes due to orthogonality of the spatial wavefunctions , and the nonzero predicted rate results from rather model - dependent corrections to the wavefunctions and recoil effects . evidently the corrections we have included do not accurately predict the observed partial width ; for this reason the other predicted m1 rates between different spatial multiplets are suspect , and in any case are evidently strongly dependent on recoil factors . better experimental data will be very important for improving our description of these apparently simple but evidently poorly understood m1 radiative transitions . -0.2 cm -0.2 cm the dominant strong decays ( when allowed by phase space ) are transitions to open - flavor final states . in these open - flavor decays the initial meson decays through production of a light @xmath24 quark - antiquark pair @xmath83 , followed by separation into two open - charm mesons . remarkably , the qcd mechanism underlying this dominant decay process is still poorly understood . in quark model calculations this decay process is modelled by a simple phenomenological pair production amplitude . the pair is usually assumed to be produced with vacuum @xmath84 quantum numbers , and variants of the decay model make different assumptions regarding the spatial dependence of the pair production amplitude relative to the initial pair . the simplest of these models is the @xmath1p@xmath2 model , originally introduced by micu @xcite , which assumes that the new @xmath24 pair is produced with vacuum quantum numbers ( @xmath1p@xmath2 ) by a spatially constant pair - production amplitude @xmath85 . leyaouanc _ et al . _ subsequently applied the @xmath1p@xmath2 model to meson @xcite and baryon @xcite open flavor strong decays in a series of publications in the 1970s . they also evaluated strong decay partial widths of the three states @xmath50 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model @xcite ; the relation between this early work and our contribution will be discussed . this decay model , which has since been applied extensively to the decays of light mesons and baryons , was originally adopted largely because of the success in predicting the d / s amplitude ratio in the decay @xmath86 @xcite . another stringent test of strong decay models is provided by the very tight limit on the spin singlet to spin singlets transition @xmath87 from the ves collaboration @xcite , @xmath88 this branching fraction is predicted to be zero in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model , but would not necessarily be negligible in a different decay model or if final state interactions are important . ( final state interactions combined with the @xmath1p@xmath2 model allow two - stage transitions such as @xmath89 , although the direct decay @xmath90 is forbidden in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model . ) recent variants of the @xmath1p@xmath2 model modify the pair production vertex @xcite or modulate the spatial dependence of the pair production amplitude to simulate a gluonic flux tube @xcite . ( the latter is the flux - tube decay model " , which gives very similar predictions to the @xmath1p@xmath2 model in practice . ) another class of decay models assumes that the pair production amplitude transforms as the time component of a lorentz vector . the cornell group used a decay model of this type for charmonium @xcite . this model appears to describe the partial and total widths of some charmonium states reasonably well , although it is known to disagree with experimental amplitude ratios in the light quark sector @xcite . in this work we employ a formalism that is equivalent to the original constant - amplitude version of the @xmath1p@xmath2 decay model , although we have simplified the calculations by deriving momentum - space feynman rules @xcite instead of using the real - space convolution integrals of leyaouanc _ et al . _ @xcite . in our formalism the @xmath1p@xmath2 model describes decay matrix elements using a pair production hamiltonian which is the nonrelativistic limit of h_decay = _ q 2 m_q d^ 3 x |_q _ q . here @xmath91 is a dirac quark field , @xmath92 is the constituent quark mass , and @xmath85 is the dimensionless pair production amplitude , which is fitted to data . the decay arises from the matrix element of this model hamiltonian between an initial meson state @xmath93 and a final meson pair @xmath94 , which is nonzero due to the @xmath95 term . here we will use sho ( simple harmonic oscillator ) wavefunctions for the mesons , with a universal width parameter @xmath96 . the pair - production strength parameter @xmath85 is found to be roughly flavor - independent in light meson decays involving pair production of @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 pairs . in our recent extensive studies of light ( @xmath100 ) meson decays @xcite we found that the value = 0.4 gives a reasonably accurate description of the overall scale of decay widths . the open - flavor decay amplitudes of the three states @xmath50 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 were evaluated in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model by leyaouanc _ et al . _ in the late 1970s @xcite . their calculations are generally quite similar to the approach used here , although we note three important differences : 0.2 cm 1 ) leyaouanc _ et al . _ fitted the pair production strength @xmath85 and wavefunction length scale @xmath101 to the charmonium decay data , whereas we used the same pair production amplitude @xmath85 as in light meson decays , and our sho wavefunction length scale @xmath102 is taken from potential models . 0.2 cm 2 ) we use the correct reduced mass coordinates for the unsymmetric open - charm meson wavefunctions , whereas leyaouanc _ et al . _ assumed symmetric sho wavefunctions for all mesons . this approximation proves to be quite important numerically , since @xmath103 . 0.2 cm 3 ) we consider all energetically allowed open - flavor decay modes . leyaouanc _ et al . _ did not consider some s+p decays of the @xmath76 , nor did they consider the important j@xmath104 d meson singlet - triplet mixing angle . ( the masses of the p - wave charmed mesons were unknown at that time . ) 0.2 cm although we have improved on the earlier calculations of leyaouanc _ et al . _ , and evaluate a much more extensive set of decay amplitudes , we do concur with their important conclusion that the dd mode of the @xmath75 is naturally suppressed given a @xmath105s@xmath48 assignment , and also that s+p modes are important for the @xmath76 . other more recent applications of the @xmath1p@xmath2 decay model to charmonium include a study of the strong decays of various @xmath0 x(3872 ) candidates to dd @xcite , and an examination of the hypothesis that the @xmath75 and @xmath106 are linear superpositions of a hybrid and a conventional @xmath107 state @xcite . the only other detailed studies of the open - flavor strong decays of charmonia of which we are aware are the early work by the cornell group @xcite , and recent more detailed applications of this model to other charmonium states @xcite . the decay model of the cornell group assumes a pair creation operator which is the time component of a lorentz vector ( @xmath108 ) , rather than the lorentz scalar assumed by the @xmath1p@xmath2 model . as we noted previously , this @xmath108 model does not agree well with some light meson decay amplitude ratios . in the original cornell model decay calculations only the combined channel contributions to @xmath101 were derived , and only channels containing pairs of s - wave open - charm mesons were included . the very interesting relative amplitudes in the d@xmath9d@xmath9 channel have not been evaluated in this model . tables [ strong_3s4s]-[strong_1 g ] present the partial widths and strong decay amplitudes we find for all kinematically allowed open - flavor decay modes of all the charmonium states listed in table [ table_spectrum ] . we have evaluated these in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model , assuming sho wavefunctions with a width parameter of @xmath109 gev and a pair production amplitude of @xmath110 . sho wavefunctions have the advantage that the decay amplitudes can be determined analytically , and we have found that the numerical results are usually not strongly dependent on the details of the spatial wavefunctions @xcite , unless they are near a node . this width parameter was chosen by comparing the overlap of nr and gi potential model wavefunctions with sho wavefunctions , which was found to be largest for both charmonium and open - charm mesons for a @xmath96 near 0.5 gev . as a test of the accuracy of these parameters , especially the value assumed for the pair production amplitude @xmath85 ( which is taken from light meson decays ) , in fig . [ gamma ] we compare the predicted total widths for @xmath109 gev and variable @xmath85 to the values observed for the four known states above open - charm threshold , @xmath50 , @xmath75 , @xmath51 and @xmath76 . although there is some scatter in the value of @xmath85 specified by these widths , a choice of @xmath111 is evidently near optimum , and yields an average error of only 29% , which is very reasonable for this phenomenological model . in the decay tables we will quote numerical results for our standard light - meson value of @xmath110 , which is rather close to this value . a subsequent change in @xmath85 will simply scale the widths as @xmath112 . for this paper the strong decay amplitudes were first evaluated analytically , following which numerical values were determined given our parameters @xmath109 gev , @xmath110 , and our constituent quark masses @xmath113 gev , @xmath114 gev and @xmath115 gev . ( quark mass _ ratios _ are required to specify the final open - charm meson wavefunctions . ) we determine the decay kinematics using external meson masses taken from the particle data group @xcite ( charge averaged where appropriate ) and from recent belle results @xcite . these masses are m@xmath116 gev , m@xmath117 gev , m@xmath118 gev @xcite , m@xmath119(narrow)@xmath120 gev , m@xmath121(broad)@xmath122 gev @xcite , m@xmath123 gev , m@xmath124 gev , m@xmath125 gev , m@xmath126 gev , m@xmath127 gev . the focus collaboration @xcite estimate a somewhat higher mass for the scalar @xmath128 , however their result is complicated by the presence of both scalar and broad axial vector ( @xmath129 ) contributions @xcite . the @xmath130 axial vector @xmath131 and @xmath132 mesons @xmath133 and @xmath129 are assumed to be coherent superpositions of quark model spin - singlet and spin - triplet states , @xmath134 we define this singlet - triplet mixing angle in the ls coupling scheme , in accord with the conventions of ref.@xcite . this reference also discusses other conventions for this mixing angle that have appeared in the literature . in the heavy - quark limit we expect to find a magic " mixing angle , due to the quark mass dependence of the spin - orbit and tensor terms , which is @xmath135 if the expectation of the heavy - quark spin - orbit interaction is negative ( positive ) @xcite . in the following we assume the first case , which is supported by the reported widths of the @xmath136 p - wave @xmath131 mesons . we note however that finite quark mass effects and mixing induced by higher - order fock states can substantially modify this mixing angle , so it should more generally be treated as a free parameter . we will discuss the dependence of our strong decay amplitudes on this mixing angle for a few sensitive cases . the four known states above dd threshold , @xmath50 , @xmath75 , @xmath51 and @xmath76 are of special interest because they are easily produced at @xmath16 machines . accordingly we will first discuss our predicted strong decay amplitudes and widths for these states . this will be followed by a more general discussion of strong decays by multiplet . the @xmath50 is generally assumed to be the @xmath1d@xmath48 state , perhaps with a significant @xmath49s@xmath48 component @xcite . ( this additional component can explain the leptonic width , which is much larger than expected for a pure @xmath1d@xmath48 state @xcite . ) for a pure @xmath1d@xmath48 state at the @xmath50 mass we predict a dd width of 43 mev with our parameters , which is rather larger than the experimental value of @xmath137 mev . the partial width of a mixed 2s - d state function of the mixing angle @xmath138 . in this simple model , fitting the experimental @xmath50 width requires a mixing angle of @xmath139 @xmath140 @xmath141 . assuming that the leptonic widths scale as the s - wave component squared , this mixing angle predicts an @xmath16 partial width ratio of |_thy . = 0.10 0.03 . it is interesting that this is consistent with experiment , |_expt . = 0.12 0.02 , so the small @xmath50 total width may indeed be an effect of @xmath1d@xmath48 - 2@xmath1s@xmath48 mixing . as a function of the @xmath1d@xmath48 - 2@xmath1s@xmath48 mixing angle @xmath138 . the experimental @xmath142 limits are shown as horizontal dashed lines.,width=302 ] next in mass is the @xmath75 , which is a very interesting case for the study of strong decays . four open - charm modes are energetically allowed , dd , dd@xmath9 , d@xmath9d@xmath9 and d@xmath143d@xmath143 , although d@xmath9d@xmath9 has little phase space . there is some experimental evidence for the three nonstrange modes from mark i at slac @xcite . remarkably , the reported relative branching fractions ( scaled by @xmath144 ) show a very strong preference for d@xmath9 final states , @xmath145 . this motivated suggestions that the @xmath75 might be a @xmath146 molecule @xcite . the mark i results were ( ^*0^*0 : ^0^*0 : ^0 ^ 0 ) = -0.8 cm 12840 : 4.0 0.8 : 0.20.1 . 1.0 cm this is much less striking once the @xmath144 factors are restored , which gives ( ^*0^*0 : ^0^*0 : ^0 ^ 0 ) = -0.8 cm 10.31 : 0.95 0.19 : 0.120.06 , 0.8 cm where we have used the @xmath147 mode to set the scale . these relative branching fractions should be compared to our theoretical @xmath75 branching fractions , not the more often quoted @xmath148 ratios . comparison with table [ strong_3s4s ] shows that the predicted @xmath1p@xmath2 model partial and total widths for a 3@xmath1s@xmath48 @xmath75 state are actually in accord with the mark i results . the total width is predicted to be 74 mev , which is reasonably close to the pdg experimental average of @xmath149 mev . seth @xcite estimates a rather larger width of @xmath150 mev for this state from crystal ball and new bes data , which is closer to our predicted width . the @xmath151 and @xmath146 branching fractions are predicted to be approximately equal , consistent with mark i. the dd mode is predicted to be much smaller , despite its larger phase space , as it is accidentally near a node in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model decay amplitude . ( this was previously noted by leyaouanc _ _ @xcite . ) this set of predictions constitutes a very nontrivial success of the @xmath1p@xmath2 decay model . the actual width to the suppressed dd mode is probably a few mev ; the 0.1 mev quoted in the table depends strongly on the location of the node , and varying the sho width parameter @xmath96 by @xmath152 suggests that a dd partial width of a few mev is plausible . this is again consistent with the mark i result . the @xmath146 mode is especially interesting for strong decay studies , since there are three independent decay amplitudes for @xmath153 , @xmath154p@xmath48 , @xmath155p@xmath48 and @xmath155f@xmath48 . if the @xmath75 is a pure s - wave state , we predict a zero @xmath155f@xmath48 @xmath146 decay amplitude , and the ratio of the nonzero amplitudes is @xmath155p@xmath156p@xmath157 ( independent of the radial wavefunction ) . as we shall see when we discuss the @xmath51 , very different @xmath146 amplitude ratios are predicted for a @xmath1d@xmath48 initial state . the unobserved mode d@xmath143d@xmath143 is predicted to have a branching fraction of about @xmath158 ; this prediction is fortunately not especially sensitive to the location of the decay amplitude node for @xmath75 to two pseudoscalars . this branching fraction is of special interest because it determines the event rates available for studies of @xmath159 weak decays at @xmath16 colliders such as cleo . finally , we note that a large sample of @xmath75 events might be used to access the 2p multiplet , since the e1 radiative branching fractions for @xmath160 are expected to be _ ca . _ @xmath161 ( table [ e1rad_stop ] ) . comparison of the mass of the @xmath74 @xmath51 with potential model predictions ( fig . [ spectrum ] ) immediately suggests a 2@xmath1d@xmath48 assignment . there may also be a significant s - wave component , since the @xmath51 has a much larger @xmath16 width than one would expect for a pure d - wave state @xcite . ( this was also the case for the @xmath50 . ) there are five open - flavor decay modes available to a @xmath74 vector at this mass , dd , dd@xmath9 , d@xmath9d@xmath9 , d@xmath143d@xmath143 and d@xmath162d@xmath163 . the predicted decay amplitudes and partial widths for a 2@xmath1d@xmath48 @xmath51 are given in table [ strong_1d2d ] . the theoretical total width of 74 mev is in good agreement with the experimental value of @xmath164 mev . seth @xcite quotes a similar width of @xmath165 mev for this state from crystal ball and recent bes data . the leading mode is predicted to be d@xmath9d@xmath9 with a branching fraction of @xmath166 , followed by comparable dd and d@xmath162d@xmath163 modes ( both @xmath167 ) , and a somewhat weaker d@xmath143d@xmath143 ( @xmath168 ) . the dd@xmath9 branching fraction is predicted to be very small , since it is suppressed by a decay amplitude node near the physical point . the mode d@xmath9d@xmath9 is again especially interesting , due to the three decay amplitudes allowed for this final state . ( the other modes have only single amplitudes . ) for a pure d - wave assignment the ratio of the two @xmath146 p - wave amplitudes is independent of the radial wavefunction , and is @xmath155p@xmath156p@xmath169 . the @xmath155f@xmath48 amplitude is predicted to be the largest given this 2@xmath1d@xmath48 assignment , whereas it is zero for an s - wave state . clearly , a determination of these d@xmath9d@xmath9 decay amplitude ratios would be an extremely interesting test of decay models . experimentally , to date nothing has been reported regarding the exclusive hadronic decay modes of the @xmath51 . the final resonance known above dd threshold is the @xmath74 @xmath76 . again , the mass of this resonance relative to potential model predictions suggests a assignment , in this case 4@xmath1s@xmath48 . of course this identification requires independent confirmation , since hybrids are predicted to first appear near this mass by lgt simulations @xcite , and the lightest hybrid multiplet in the flux tube model includes a @xmath74 state @xcite . ten open - charm strong decay modes are allowed for the @xmath76 , seven with @xmath131 meson final states ( @xmath170 ) , and three with @xmath132 . the predicted branching fractions of a 4@xmath1s@xmath48 state at this mass are quite characteristic , and ( if the @xmath1p@xmath2 decay model is accurate ) may be useful in confirming this assignment . as a note of caution , a 4s state has three radial nodes , and some of the smaller predicted branching fractions are sensitive to the locations of the nodes . the predicted total width of a 4@xmath1s@xmath48 meson at this mass with our parameters is 77 mev , somewhat larger than the experimental pdg average width of @xmath171 mev . seth @xcite notes however that the width of this state in crystal ball and recent bes data is rather larger , and quotes an average of @xmath172 mev , on the opposite side of the @xmath1p@xmath2 decay model prediction . the largest exclusive mode is predicted to be the s+p combination dd@xmath48 , where d@xmath48 is the narrower of the two @xmath136 @xmath131 axial mesons near 2.42 - 2.43 gev . since the d@xmath48 is rather narrow ( @xmath173-@xmath174 mev ) and decays dominantly to d@xmath175 , there should be a strong @xmath76 signal in dd@xmath175 final states . although both s - wave and d - wave dd@xmath48 final states are allowed , in the @xmath1p@xmath2 model the hqet ( heavy quark effective theory ) d@xmath48 mixing angle @xmath138 is just the value needed to give a zero s - wave @xmath176 amplitude . thus we have the striking prediction that the dominant @xmath76 decay mode is dd@xmath48 , in d - wave rather than s - wave . the second - largest @xmath76 branching fraction is predicted to be another s+p mode , dd@xmath177 . the d@xmath177 is also moderately narrow , so this isobar can also be isolated from the observed final state . ( the pdg quotes a neutral d@xmath177 total width of @xmath178 mev , but belle @xcite and focus @xcite find somewhat broader values of @xmath179 mev and @xmath180 mev respectively ; see @xcite for a recent discussion . the d@xmath177 has significant branching fractions to both d@xmath175 and d@xmath181 , so the dd@xmath177 mode of the @xmath76 should be observable in both dd@xmath181 and dd@xmath175 . a final important @xmath76 mode is predicted to be d@xmath9d@xmath9 , which should be comparable in strength to dd@xmath177 . as noted in the previous discussions of @xmath75 and @xmath51 decays , d@xmath9d@xmath9 is an especially interesting decay mode because it has three amplitudes , and the @xmath155p@xmath48/@xmath154p@xmath48 amplitude ratio is independent of the radial wavefunction for pure s - wave or d - wave states . if the @xmath76 is indeed an s - wave ( 4@xmath1s@xmath48 ) state to a good approximation , we expect this ratio to be @xmath155p@xmath48/@xmath154p@xmath157 , and the @xmath155f@xmath48 amplitude should be zero . it is interesting to note that @xmath76 decays may provide access to the recently discovered d@xmath182 . although the channel d@xmath183d@xmath184 has a threshold of 4429 mev , 14 mev above the nominal mass of the @xmath76 , the width of the @xmath76 and the fact that the decay @xmath185d@xmath183d@xmath184 is purely s - wave implies that one may observe significant d@xmath184 production just above threshold , near e@xmath186 mev . this is illustrated in fig . [ 4415_scan ] , in which we show theoretical @xmath187 decay model partial widths to d@xmath188d@xmath189 and d@xmath143d@xmath190 as functions of the @xmath191s@xmath48 mass . ( this calculation assumes pure @xmath132 d@xmath189 and d@xmath190 states , and should be modified accordingly if they have significant non-@xmath132 components . ) unfortunately , @xmath76 decays are not expected to be similarly effective in producing the d@xmath190 , because the assumed magic - mixed " hqet state @xmath192 predicts a vanishing @xmath193 s - wave decay amplitude . and @xmath194 as a function of the assumed @xmath195 mass . , width=321 ] the two unknown states in the 3s and 4s multiplets are the 3@xmath154s@xmath2 and 4@xmath154s@xmath2 pseudoscalars . to evaluate their strong decays we have assigned potential model masses to these states , specifically 4043 mev and 4384 mev . the resulting total widths are predicted to be moderate , 80 mev and 61 mev respectively , and both states should be observable in dd@xmath9 and d@xmath9d@xmath9 ( see table [ strong_3s4s ] ) . no other open - charm strong decay modes are allowed for a 3@xmath154s@xmath2 @xmath196 . although these modes are also important for the 4@xmath154s@xmath2 @xmath197 , its largest branching fraction is predicted to be to the s+p combination dd@xmath177 ( @xmath198 ) . these states may be observable in @xmath6 and hadronic production ( through @xmath199 fusion ) , analogous to the @xmath200 and @xmath5 . m1 transitions from the higher vectors to these states are unfortunately predicted to be rather weak , since they are either hindered or have little phase space . ( see table [ m1rad ] . ) the mean 2p multiplet mass is predicted to be near 3.95 gev . there is an interesting disagreement between the nr and gi models regarding the scale of mass splittings within this multiplet , as well as in the 3p states . ( see table [ table_spectrum ] and fig . [ spectrum ] . ) there are few open - flavor strong modes available to the 2p states ( table [ strong_2p3p ] ) . one result of this restricted phase space is the prediction of a fairly narrow 2@xmath1p@xmath2 @xmath201 ( assuming the nr model mass ) that decays only to dd , with a total width of just 30 mev . this small width is due in part to a decay amplitude node , and a variation of the total width by a factor of two could easily be accommodated . the two axial states 2@xmath1p@xmath48 @xmath202 and 2@xmath154p@xmath48 @xmath203 can only decay to dd@xmath9 , and both have nonzero s- and d - wave decay amplitudes ; their d / s ratios are @xmath204 and @xmath205 respectively . observation of the d / s ratio in a dd@xmath9 enhancement could be a useful check of the assumption of a resonant @xmath136 contribution . the relatively narrow 2@xmath1p@xmath2 state @xmath201 can be produced in @xmath6 , as can its somewhat wider 2@xmath1p@xmath57 @xmath206 partner . additional possible production mechanisms include @xmath199 fusion ( for the 2@xmath1p@xmath2 and 2@xmath1p@xmath57 ) , e1 radiative transitions from higher @xmath74 states ( to all 2p @xmath79 states ) , and b decays . the e1 branching fractions of the @xmath75 and @xmath51 to 2p @xmath79 states are predicted to be sufficiently large ( _ ca . _ @xmath161 , see tables [ e1rad_stop],[e1rad_1d2d ] ) to allow identification of these states at bes and cleo . although no 2p @xmath0 state has been clearly established experimentally , there are two recent reports of enhancements which may be due to states in this multiplet . the belle collaboration has reported evidence of an enhancement in @xmath12 with a mass and width of @xmath207 mev and @xmath208 mev @xcite ; this is compatible with expectations for 2p @xmath79 @xmath0 states . ( although 2p @xmath0 states should strongly favor open - charm strong decay modes , inelastic fsis ( final state interactions ) will allow weaker transitions to closed - charm final states such as @xmath12 . these fsis should be most important in s - wave , as in the virtual second - order processes @xmath209 . ) a search for evidence of this state in open - charm final states , with much larger branching fractions than to @xmath12 , will be a crucial test of a charmonium assignment . assuming that the enhancement is indeed due to a 2p @xmath79 state , if it is the @xmath210 state it will populate only dd , if @xmath13 only dd@xmath9 , and if @xmath211 comparable branching fractions to dd and dd@xmath9 are expected . there is a second report of a possible 2p state , also from the belle collaboration @xcite , in double charmonium production . an enhancement is seen in @xmath212 at a mass of @xmath213 mev , with a limit on the total width of @xmath214 mev ( @xmath215 ) . as this enhancement is not seen in @xmath12 , it has been suggested @xcite that it is distinct from the 3940 mev signal discussed above . consideration of possible 2p candidates ( table [ strong_2p3p ] ) suggests that this enhancement may be due to the @xmath216p@xmath217 , which is predicted to have a similar mass of 3925 mev . ( the predicted total width however is a somewhat larger 165 mev . ) the 3p states have an expected mean multiplet mass of about 4.3 gev . as with the 2p states there is a significant difference between the nr and gi models in the scale of mass splittings predicted within the multiplet . this leads for example to a 90 mev difference between the models for the predicted mass of the 3@xmath1p@xmath2 scalar . many open - charm strong decay channels are open at the 3p mass scale . the individual decay amplitudes however are typically somewhat smaller than for the 2p states , due in part to nodes in the decay amplitudes . this has the interesting result that the predicted mean total width of 3p states is smaller than for 2p states ( 58 mev for 3p versus 91 mev for 2p ) . the predicted branching fraction to the mode d@xmath9d@xmath9 is large for all four 3p states , and is the largest for all except the spin - singlet 3@xmath154p@xmath48 @xmath218 ; in this case the leading mode is dd@xmath219 . for all 3p states except the 3@xmath1p@xmath48 the d@xmath9d@xmath9 decay mode has multiple amplitudes , which are predicted to be comparable in strength . an experimental determination of any of these amplitude ratios would provide an interesting test of decay models . the decays of the tensor 3@xmath1p@xmath57 @xmath220 to dd@xmath48 and dd@xmath221 are also interesting , in that the prediction that the broad d@xmath221 mode dominates is a test of the axial - d mixing angle . as with the 2p states , the most important experimental problem is to find an effective production mechanism . again , @xmath6 and @xmath199 fusion can produce the @xmath211 and @xmath210 states ( here 3@xmath1p@xmath57 and 3@xmath1p@xmath2 ) , although there should be moderate suppression of the production amplitudes relative to the 1p ground states due to the higher masses and smaller short - distance wavefunctions . e1 transitions from the @xmath76 could lead to the identification of the 3p states , since radiative partial widths of 50 - 100 kev are expected to the 3@xmath1p@xmath57 and 3@xmath1p@xmath48 ; these correspond to branching fractions of _ ca . _ @xmath161 . production of the 3@xmath1p@xmath2 state however is expected to be suppressed , due to a radiative decay amplitude node . since the @xmath1d@xmath57 and @xmath154d@xmath57 states do not have allowed open - flavor decay modes , and we have already considered @xmath1d@xmath48 decays in the section on the @xmath50 , we restrict our discussion to the @xmath1d@xmath222 . this currently unknown state is predicted to have a mass of 3806 mev in the nr potential model . it is expected to be quite narrow simply because it has little phase space to the only open - flavor mode dd , which has an f - wave centrifugal barrier ; with our parameters the predicted total strong width is just 0.5 mev . the radiative width for the e1 transition @xmath223 is predicted to be about 0.3 mev ( table [ e1rad_1d2d ] ) , so the total width of this @xmath1d@xmath222 state should be near 1 mev , with comparable strong and radiative branching fractions . finding an effective production mechanism for this interesting state is again a crucial problem . as it has c @xmath224 , it can not be made in @xmath225 or @xmath199 fusion . one possibility is that the @xmath1d@xmath222 may be observable in e1 transitions from the radial @xmath49p@xmath57 tensor , since the radiative partial width is predicted to be a relatively large @xmath53 kev . similarly , the narrow @xmath1d@xmath57 and @xmath154d@xmath57 states may be observable in e1 transitions from 2p states , assuming that a production mechanism can be found for 2p states . all three of these states can also be produced in b - decays @xcite . the states in the 2d multiplet are predicted to be essentially degenerate in both the nr and gi potential models . the @xmath49d@xmath48 candidate @xmath51 suggests a 2d multiplet mass near 4.16 gev , which is consistent with potential model expectations . since the @xmath51 was discussed previously , here we will consider only the unknown states @xmath49d@xmath222 , @xmath49d@xmath57 and @xmath226d@xmath57 . these states are predicted to be rather broad , with theoretical total widths ranging from 78 mev for the @xmath49d@xmath48 ( consistent with the @xmath51 ) to 148 mev for the @xmath49d@xmath222 . the energetically allowed open - flavor modes are all of s+s type , since the first s+p mode is dd@xmath227 , at a nominal mass of 4175 mev . the decays of 2d states are dominated by dd , dd@xmath9 and d@xmath9d@xmath9 , with smaller contributions from the charm - strange final states d@xmath143d@xmath143 and d@xmath162d@xmath163 . if these states ( besides the @xmath51 ) can be produced , there are several interesting tests of their strong decay amplitudes . the @xmath49d@xmath222 @xmath228 , for example , is predicted to have d@xmath9d@xmath9 as the dominant mode , with both @xmath154f@xmath222 and @xmath155f@xmath222 amplitudes present , in the ratio @xmath155f@xmath222/@xmath154f@xmath229 . the remaining 2d states have many multiamplitude decays , in which the higher - l partial waves have large or dominant amplitudes . ( compare the p- and f - waves in the decays in table [ strong_1d2d ] . ) the four states in the 1f multiplet are predicted to be almost degenerate in both the nr and gi models , although the models disagree somewhat regarding this mass . in the nr potential model the states are expected near 4025 mev , whereas in the gi model the expected mass is near 4095 mev . this discrepancy is mainly due to the different values assumed for the string tension . it is unfortunate that production amplitudes for these higher - l states are expected to be quite weak , since the 1f multiplet is predicted to contain a rather narrow state , the @xmath1f@xmath230 @xmath231 ( table [ strong_1f ] ) . assuming our nr model @xmath1f@xmath230 mass of 4021 mev , we predict a strong width for this state of just 8.3 mev . this is partly a result of the centrifugal barrier ( both open modes , dd and dd@xmath9 , are g - waves ) , and is also because there is essentially no phase space for d@xmath9d@xmath9 . if the gi masses are more accurate we would no longer expect a very narrow @xmath1f@xmath230 state , since the d@xmath9d@xmath9 partial width increases rapidly above threshold . at the gi mass of 4095 mev the @xmath1f@xmath230 is predicted to have a partial width to d@xmath9d@xmath9 of 38 mev , and a total width of 60 mev . the single well - established mechanism that might be exploited to produce a 1f state is an e1 radiative transition from the @xmath51 to the @xmath1f@xmath57 @xmath232 . this transition however has a rather weak , model - dependent partial width of 20 - 50 kev ( table [ e1rad_1d2d ] ) , and the @xmath1f@xmath57 is predicted to be the broadest 1f state , with a total width of about 160 mev . if an effective production mechanism for 1f states is identified , the e1 decays of these states can be used to populate the narrow 1d states ; the e1 transitions @xmath1f@xmath233d@xmath222 , @xmath1f@xmath234d@xmath57 and @xmath154f@xmath235d@xmath57 are predicted to have rather large radiative widths of _ ca . _ 300 - 400 kev ( see table [ e1rad_1f ] ) . to complete our study we have evaluated the spectrum and decays of all states in the 2f and 1 g multiplets ( tables [ strong_2fa ] and [ strong_1 g ] ) , although the lack of a clear experimental route to these states suggests that it may be quite difficult to test these predictions . the multiplets are again predicted to be nearly degenerate in both the nr and gi potential models , with somewhat lower masses predicted by the nr model . the mean 2f and 1 g masses are approximately 4350 mev and 4225 mev respectively in the nr model , and 4425 mev and 4320 mev in the gi model . assuming nr model masses , these states are predicted to have total widths that range from a minimum of 58 mev for the @xmath1g@xmath236 @xmath237 to a maximum of 180 mev for the @xmath49f@xmath57 @xmath238 . the individual decay modes do show some interesting features ; although the dominant modes are usually of s+s type , some s+p modes are important in 2f decays . for example , the largest decay modes of the @xmath49f@xmath222 @xmath239 and @xmath49f@xmath57 @xmath238 are both s+p , with branching fractions of b(@xmath240 dd@xmath241 and b(@xmath242 dd@xmath243 respectively . we have computed the spectrum , all allowed e1 and some m1 electromagnetic partial widths , and all allowed open - charm strong decay amplitudes of the 40 charmonium states expected to _ ca . _ 4.4 gev . these were evaluated using two potential models , the quark model formulation of electromagnetic transition amplitudes , and the @xmath187 strong decay model . the predictions of the spectrum should be useful in the identification of new states , and in tests of the lorentz structure of confinement and the nature of spin - dependent forces . the transition amplitudes will be useful in searches for new higher - mass states , as they suggest which final states should be populated preferentially by the decays of a given initial state , as well as predicting the often characteristic strong decay amplitude ratios within a given final state . these predictions may also be useful in distinguishing between conventional charmonia and exotica such as charmed meson molecules ( perhaps including the x(3872 ) ) and hybrids . these results all implicitly test the accuracy of the pure - assumption made in these models , and can serve as benchmarks for calculations that relax this assumption . future experimental measurements of strong partial widths and decay amplitude ratios can provide very important tests of strong decay models , the @xmath1p@xmath2 model in particular . we have discussed many specific examples of these tests in the previous sections ; here we will summarize some of our most important observations . the @xmath50 is the lightest known state above open - charm threshold . we noted that the relatively large @xmath16 width of the @xmath50 is difficult to understand if it is assumed to be a pure @xmath1d@xmath48 state , but this problem is solved if the @xmath50 has a significant admixture of the @xmath244 @xmath0 basis state . this mixing also solves the @xmath50 total width problem , since the mixing angle required to fit the @xmath16 width is consistent with the value required to fit the @xmath1p@xmath2 model dd strong width to experiment . this mixing angle has been discussed in earlier references ( see for example refs.@xcite ) , although the observation that the same mixing angle resolves both the @xmath16 and total width discrepancies has not been noted previously . the relative branching fractions of the @xmath75 to dd , dd@xmath9 and d@xmath9d@xmath9 , although often cited as anomalous , are naturally explained in the @xmath187 model by a node in the dd decay amplitude . a very important test of this strong decay model and the nature of the @xmath75 follows from a simple measurement of the ratios of the three independent d@xmath9d@xmath9 decay amplitudes . the @xmath187 model predicts that the @xmath245 amplitude is zero , and the ratio of the two p - wave amplitudes is @xmath246 , independent of the radial wavefunction , provided that the @xmath75 is a pure s - wave state . similarly , the d@xmath9d@xmath9 amplitude ratios in @xmath51 decays test the decay model and the assumed @xmath247 assignment for this state . the @xmath245 d@xmath9d@xmath9 amplitude is predicted to be the largest for a pure @xmath247 @xmath51 , and the p - wave amplitude ratio is predicted to be @xmath248 , again independent of the radial wavefunction . finally , we noted that it may be possible to identify a higher - l state ( the @xmath249 @xmath232 member of the f - wave multiplet ) in e1 radiative @xmath51 decays . the @xmath76 has ten open - flavor modes , and their branching fractions have never been determined . we predict that the largest is the unusual s+p combination dd@xmath48 . it is especially notable that strong decays of the @xmath76 may provide a novel production mechanism for the enigmatic @xmath250 , through the above - threshold decay @xmath251 , as shown in fig . [ 4415_scan ] . one may also produce higher - mass charmonium states from the @xmath76 through electromagnetic transitions . for example , @xmath76 e1 decays are predicted to produce 3p states with branching fractions at the per mil level . these states could then be identified through their subsequent open - charm strong decays . as discussed in section v.c , two new states near 3940 mev have recently been reported by belle . 2p @xmath79 states are natural assignments , as they have theoretical quark model masses ranging from 3852 to 3972 mev and widths of 50 - 100 mev , similar to the reported values . a measurement of the relative branching fractions to @xmath252 , @xmath151 and @xmath146 and comparisons to our @xmath1p@xmath2 decay model predictions should allow the determination of the quantum numbers of these states , and will show whether they are indeed consistent with 2p @xmath0 assignments . a better determination of the properties of conventional charmonium states at higher masses is important not only because of the improved understanding of qcd that will follow ( especially aspects of confinement and strong decays ) , but also because qualitatively different types of resonances are expected at these masses . these new states include charmed meson molecules and charmonium hybrids , and the identification of these novel excitations will obviously be easier if the conventional charmonium spectrum is well established . the recent results from b factories and new programs at bes , cleo and gsi have led to a resurgence of interest in the physics of charmonium . we argue that a detailed experimental investigation of the spectrum of excited charmonium states and their decay properties will considerably improve our understanding of the nonperturbative aspects of qcd . this research was supported in part by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , the u.s . national science foundation through grant nsf - phy-0244786 at the university of tennessee , and the u.s . department of energy under contracts de - ac05 - 00or22725 at oak ridge national laboratory and de - fg02 - 00er41135 at the university of pittsburgh , and by pparc grant pp / b500607 . j. j. aubert _ et al . _ [ e598 collaboration ] , phys . rev . * 33 * , 1404 ( 1974 ) . j. e. augustin _ et al . _ [ slac - sp-017 collaboration ] , phys . * 33 * , 1406 ( 1974 ) . t. appelquist and h. d. politzer , phys . lett . * 34 * , 43 ( 1975 ) . a. de rujula and s. l. glashow , phys . * 34 * , 46 ( 1975 ) . t. appelquist , a. de rujula , h. d. politzer and s. l. glashow , phys . lett . * 34 * , 365 ( 1975 ) . e. eichten , k. gottfried , t. kinoshita , j. b. kogut , k. d. lane and t. m. yan , phys . lett . * 34 * , 369 ( 1975 ) [ erratum - ibid . * 36 * , 1276 ( 1976 ) ] . c. quigg , arxiv : hep - ph/0403187 . r. s. galik , arxiv : hep - ph/0408190 . n. brambilla _ et al . _ , arxiv : hep - ph/0412158 . k. k. seth , arxiv : hep - ex/0501022 . this reference in effect quotes a combined average mass for the @xmath15 of @xmath253 mev from new cleo measurements . k. k. seth , arxiv : hep - ex/0504050 . k. k. seth , arxiv : hep - ex/0504052 . t. skwarnicki , arxiv : hep - ex/0505050 . e.j.eichten , k.lane and c.quigg , phys . 89 , 162002 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206018 ] . the besiii detector . preliminary design report , ihep - bepch - sb-13 ( jan . 2004 ) . s .- k.choi _ et al . _ ( belle collaboration ) , phys . 89 , 102001 ( 2002 ) , err . 89 , 129901 ( 2002 ) . [ arxiv : hep - ex/0206002 ] . b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys . 92 , 142002 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0311038 ] . ( cleo collaboration ) , phys . lett.92 , 142001 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0312058 ] . s. k. choi _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys . 91 , 262001 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0309032 ] . d. acosta _ et al . _ [ cdf ii collaboration ] , phys . rev . 93 , 072001 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0312021 ] . f. e. close and p. r. page , phys . lett . b578 , 119 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309253 ] . e. s. swanson , phys . b588 , 189 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0311229 ] . n. a. tornqvist , phys . b * 590 * , 209 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0402237 ] . t. barnes and s. godfrey , phys . d69 , 054008 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0311162 ] . e. j. eichten , k. lane and c. quigg , phys . d69 , 094019 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0401210 ] . k. abe , arxiv : hep - ex/0505037 . k. abe , arxiv : hep - ex/0505038 . a. tomaradze , j. phys . * 9 * , 119 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0410090 ] . the reported @xmath15 signal is in the decay chain @xmath254 , @xmath255 . the masses found in two different inclusive analyses were @xmath256 mev and @xmath256 mev ( with an estimated systematic error of @xmath257 mev , and @xmath258 mev in exclusive decays ( with six different identified @xmath200 final states ) . k. abe _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys . 89 , 142001 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0205104 ] . k. abe _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys . d70 , 071102 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0407009 ] . p. pakhlov , [ arxiv : hep - ex/0412041 ] . p. pakhlov ( private communication ) . e. eichten , k. gottfried , t. kinoshita , k. d. lane and t. m. yan , phys . d * 17 * , 3090 ( 1978 ) [ erratum - ibid . d * 21 * , 313 ( 1980 ) ] . d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , arxiv : hep - ph/0503012 . c. w. bernard _ et al . _ [ milc collaboration ] , phys . d * 56 * , 7039 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/9707008 ] . x.liao and t.manke , [ arxiv : hep - lat/0210030 ] . z. h. mei and x. q. luo , int . j. mod . phys . a * 18 * , 5713 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0206012 ] . g. s. bali , eur . j. a * 19 * , 1 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0308015 ] . b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys . 90 , 242001 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0304021 ] . d. besson _ et al . _ [ cleo collaboration ] , aip conf . 698 , 497 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0305017 ] . e. s. swanson , phys . b * 582 * , 167 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309296 ] . d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , phys . d * 67 * , 014027 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210381 ] . t. barnes , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406327 ] . li , f. e. close and t. barnes , phys . d * 43 * , 2161 ( 1991 ) . e. s. ackleh and t. barnes , phys . d * 45 * , 232 ( 1992 ) . e. s. ackleh , t. barnes and f. e. close , phys . rev . d * 46 * , 2257 ( 1992 ) . t. barnes and g. i. ghandour , phys . lett . b118 , 411 ( 1982 ) . s.godfrey and n.isgur , phys . d32 , 189 ( 1985 ) . m. okamoto _ et al . _ [ cp - pacs collaboration ] , phys . d * 65 * , 094508 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0112020 ] . s. hashimoto and t. onogi , ann . rev . nucl . part . sci . * 54 * , 451 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407221 ] . w.kwong and j.l.rosner , phys . d38 , 279 ( 1988 ) . l. micu , nucl . b10 , 521 ( 1969 ) . a. le yaouanc , l. oliver , o. pne and j .- c . raynal , phys . d8 , ( 1973 ) 2223 . a. le yaouanc , l. oliver , o. pne and j .- c . raynal , phys . d9 , 1415 ( 1974 ) . a. le yaouanc , o. pne , j .- c . raynal and l. oliver , nucl . b149 , 321 ( 1979 ) . a. le yaouanc , l. oliver , o. pne and j .- c . raynal , phys . b71 , 397 ( 1977 ) . le yaouanc , l. oliver , o. pne and j .- c . raynal , phys . b72 , 57 ( 1977 ) . r. kokoski and n. isgur , phys . d35 , 907 ( 1987 ) . e.s.ackleh , t.barnes and e.s . swanson , phys . d54 , 6811 ( 1996 ) . [ arxiv : hep - ph/9604355 ] . m. nozar _ et al . _ [ e852 collaboration ] , phys . lett . b541 , 35 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0206026 ] . d. v. amelin _ et al . _ [ ves collaboration ] , [ arxiv : hep - ex/9810013 ] . ( particle data group ) , phys . b592 , 1 ( 2004 ) . w.roberts and b.silvestre-brac , phys . d57 , 1694 ( 1998 ) . [ arxiv : hep - ph/9708235 ] . t.barnes , f.e.close , p.r.page and e.s.swanson , phys . d55 , 4157 ( 1997 ) . [ arxiv : hep - ph/9609339 ] . t.barnes , n.black and p.r.page , phys . d68 , 054014 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0208072 ] . f. e. close and p. r. page , phys . b * 366 * , 323 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9507407 ] . p. geiger and e. s. swanson , phys . d50 , 6855 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9405238 ] . h. g. blundell and s. godfrey , phys . d53 , 3700 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9508264 ] . et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys . d69 , 112002 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0307021 ] . e. w. vaandering [ focus collaboration ] , [ arxiv : hep - ex/0406044 ] . r.kutschke , private communication . s.godfrey and r.kokoski , phys . d43 , 1679 ( 1991 ) . j. l. rosner , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0411003 ] . j. l. rosner , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0405196 ] . et al . _ , b69 , 503 ( 1977 ) . m.b.voloshin and l.b.okun , jetp lett . 23 , 333 ( 1976 ) [ pisma zh . fiz . 3 , 369 ( 1976 ) ] . a.derjula , h.georgi and s.l.glashow , phys . 38 , 317 ( 1977 ) . s.iwao , lett . nuovo cim . 28 , 305 ( 1980 ) . k. k. seth , [ arxiv : hep - ex/0405007 ] . n.isgur , r.kokoski and j.paton , phys . 54 , 869 ( 1985 ) . j. m. link _ et al . _ [ focus collaboration ] , phys . b586 , 11 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0312060 ] . p.s.cooper , new results in charm meson spectroscopy from focus and selex " , presented at ghp2004 ( fermilab , 24 - 26 oct 2004 ) . k. abe _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , [ arxiv : hep - ex/0408126 ] . t. skwarnicki , int j. mod . a * 19 * , 1030 ( 2004 ) . y.zhu , ph.d . thesis , california institute of technology , 1988 , caltech report calt-68 - 1513 ( unpublished ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: minimizers of a submodular function form a distributive lattice , and are compactly represented by a poset ( partially ordered set ) via birkhoff representation theorem . this fact reveals a useful hierarchical structure of the minimizers , and is applied to the dm - decomposition of matrices and further refined block - triangular decompositions @xcite . in this paper , we address such a birkhoff - type representation for minimizers of a _ @xmath0-submodular function_. here @xmath0-submodular functions , introduced by huber kolmogorov @xcite , are functions on @xmath2 defined by submodular - type inequalities . this generalization of ( bi)submodular functions has recently gained attention for algorithm design and modeling @xcite . our main result is to establish a compact representation for minimizers of a @xmath0-submodular function . this can be viewed as a generalization of the above poset representation for submodular functions and ando fujishige s signed - poset representation for bisubmodular functions @xcite . a feature of our representation is to utilize a _ poset with inconsistent pairs ( pip ) _ @xcite , which is a discrete structure having a stronger power of expression than that of a signed - poset . actually a pip is a poset endowed with an additional binary relation ( _ inconsistent relation _ ) , and is viewed as a poset reformulation of 2-cnf . this concept , also known as an _ event structure _ , was first introduced by nielsen plotkin winskel @xcite as a model of concurrency in theoretical computer science , and was independently considered by barthelemy constantin @xcite to establish a birkhoff - type representation theorem for a _ median semilattice_a semilattice generalization of a distributive lattice . a pip was recently rediscovered by ardila sullivant @xcite to represent nonpositively - curved cube complexes ; the term `` pip '' is due to them . our results consist of structural and algorithmic ones , summarized as follows : [ [ structural - results . ] ] structural results . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we show that minimizers of a @xmath0-submodular function form a median semilattice ( lemma 3 ) . by a birkhoff - type representation theorem @xcite for median semilattices , the minimizer set is represented by a pip , where minimizers are encoded into special ideals in the pip , called _ consistent ideals_. pips arising from @xmath0-submodular functions are rather special . we completely characterize such pips ( theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ) , which we call _ elementary_. this representation is actually compact . we show that the size of the elementary pip for a @xmath0-submodular function of @xmath3 variables is @xmath4 ( proposition [ prop : number_of_irreducibles ] ) . [ [ algorithmic - results . ] ] algorithmic results . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we present algorithms to construct the elementary pip of the minimizers of a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath1 under the following three situations : * a minimizing oracle of @xmath1 is given . * @xmath1 is network - representable . * @xmath1 arises from a potts energy function . for ( i ) , we show that the pip is obtained by calling the minimizing oracle @xmath5 time ( theorem [ thm : alg_oracle ] ) . notice that a polynomial time algorithm to minimize @xmath0-submodular functions is not known for the value - oracle model but is known for the valued - csp model @xcite . our result for ( i ) is applicable to such a case . for ( ii ) ( and ( iii ) ) , we consider an efficiently minimizable class of @xmath0-submodular functions considered in @xcite , where a @xmath0-submodular function in this class is represented by the cut function in a network of @xmath4 vertices and can be minimized by a minimum - cut computation . we show that the pip is naturally obtained from the residual graph of a maximum flow in the network ( theorems [ thm : network_algo ] and [ thm : network_time ] ) . for ( iii ) , we deal with a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath6 obtained from a @xmath0-label potts energy function @xmath7 by adding the @xmath8-label ( meaning `` non - labeled '' ) . such a @xmath0-submodular function , called _ potts @xmath0-submodular _ , is particularly useful in vision applications . indeed , via the _ persistency property _ @xcite , a minimizer of @xmath9 ( an optimal labeling ) is partly recovered from a minimizer of the relaxation @xmath10 . kolmogorov @xcite showed that a minimizer of a potts @xmath0-submodular function can be obtained by @xmath11 calls of a max - flow algorithm performed on a network of @xmath12 vertices . we show that the pip is also obtained in the same time complexity ( theorem [ thm : potts ] ) . in showing this result , we reveal an intriguing structure of the pip for a potts @xmath0-submodular function ( theorem [ thm : pip_potts ] ) , and utilize results @xcite from undirected multiflow theory . we also discuss enumeration aspects for minimizers . maximal minimizers , which are minimizers with a maximal number of nonzero components , are of particular interest from the view of partial optimal labeling . for a potts @xmath0-submodular function , we show that the problem of enumerating all maximal minimizers reduces to the problem of enumerating all ideals of a single poset ( theorem [ thm : enumeration_potts ] ) . this enables us to use an existing fast enumeration algorithm , and leads to a practical algorithm enumerating all maximal partial optimal labeling in actual computer vision problems . we present experimental results for real instances of stereo matching problems . [ [ organization . ] ] organization . + + + + + + + + + + + + + the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : preliminaries ] , we give preliminaries including a birkhoff - type representation theorem between pips and median semilattices . in section [ sec : structure ] , we prove the above structural results . in section [ sec : algorithms ] , we prove the algorithmic results . finally , in section [ sec : application ] , we describe applications and present experimental results . for a nonnegative integer @xmath3 , we denote @xmath13 by @xmath14}}$ ] ( with @xmath15 } } \defeq \varnothing$ ] ) . for a subset @xmath16 of an ordered set , let @xmath17 denote the minimum element in @xmath16 ( if it exists ) . let @xmath18 be the set of real numbers and @xmath19 . for a function @xmath1 from a set @xmath20 to @xmath21 , a _ minimizer _ of @xmath1 is an element @xmath22 that satisfies @xmath23 for all @xmath24 . the set of minimizers of @xmath1 is simply called the _ minimizer set _ of @xmath1 . we assume that posets are always finite , and assume the standard notions of lattice theory , such as join @xmath25 and meet @xmath26 . let @xmath0 be a positive integer . let @xmath27 denote @xmath28 . the partial order @xmath29 on @xmath27 is defined by @xmath30 if and only if @xmath31 for each @xmath32 . consider the @xmath3-product @xmath33 of @xmath27 , where the partial order on @xmath33 is defined as the direct product of @xmath29 and is also denoted by @xmath29 . in this way , @xmath33 and its subsets are regarded as posets . for @xmath34 , the _ support _ of @xmath35 is the subset of indices @xmath36}}$ ] with nonzero @xmath37 , and is denoted by @xmath38 : @xmath39}}}\mathrel{}\middle|\mathrel{}{x_i \neq 0}\right\}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] a _ @xmath0-submodular function _ @xcite is a function @xmath40 satisfying the following inequality @xmath41 for all @xmath42 . here the binary operation @xmath43 on @xmath33 is given by @xmath44 for every @xmath42 and @xmath36}}$ ] . the operation @xmath45 in is dually defined by changing @xmath46 to @xmath47 in . besides its recent introduction , a @xmath0-submodular function seems to be recognized when bouchet @xcite introduced _ multimatroids_. indeed , a @xmath0-submodular function is a direct generalization of the rank function of a multimatroid , and was suggested by fujishige @xcite in 1995 as a _ multisubmodular function_. it is not known whether @xmath0-submodular functions for @xmath48 can be minimized in polynomial time on the standard oracle model . however , some special classes of @xmath0-submodular functions are efficiently minimizable . for example , kolmogorov thapper ivn @xcite showed that a sum of low - arity @xmath0-submodular functions can be minimized in polynomial time , where the _ arity _ of a function is the number of variables . a nonnegative combination of binary _ basic @xmath0-submodular functions _ , introduced by iwata wahlstrm yoshida @xcite , can be minimized by computing a minimum @xmath49-cut on a directed network ; see section [ sec : network ] . a nonempty subset of @xmath33 is said to be _ @xmath50-closed _ if it is closed under the operations @xmath43 and @xmath45 . from , the following obviously holds . the minimizer set of a @xmath0-submodular function is @xmath50-closed . a key tool for providing a compact representation for @xmath50-closed sets is a correspondence between median semilattices and pips , which was established by barthlemy constantin @xcite . a recent paper @xcite also contains an exposition of this correspondence . a _ median semilattice _ @xcite is a meet - semilattice @xmath51 satisfying following conditions : ms every principal ideal is a distributive lattice . for all @xmath52 , if @xmath53 and @xmath54 exist , then @xmath55 exists in @xmath56 . note that every distributive lattice is a median semilattice . an element of @xmath56 is said to be _ join - irreducible _ if it is not minimum and is not represented as the join of other elements . let @xmath57 denote the set of join - irreducible elements of @xmath56 . next we introduce a _ poset with inconsistent pairs ( pip)_. a pip @xcite is a poset @xmath58 endowed with an additional symmetric relation @xmath59 satisfying the following conditions : ic for all @xmath60 with @xmath61 , there is no @xmath62 with @xmath63 and @xmath64 . for all @xmath65 , if @xmath66 and @xmath67 , then @xmath61 . a pip is also denoted by a triple @xmath68 . the relation @xmath59 is called an _ inconsistent relation_. each unordered pair @xmath69 of @xmath70 is called _ inconsistent _ if @xmath61 . note that every inconsistent pair of @xmath70 is incomparable and has no common upper bound in @xmath70 . an inconsistent pair @xmath69 of @xmath70 is said to be _ minimally inconsistent _ if @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath67 imply @xmath73 and @xmath74 for all @xmath75 . if @xmath69 is minimally inconsistent , the @xmath61 is particularly denoted by @xmath76 . we can easily check the following properties of the minimally inconsistent relation : mic for all @xmath60 with @xmath76 , there is no @xmath62 with @xmath63 and @xmath64 . for all @xmath65 with @xmath71 and @xmath72 , if @xmath77 and @xmath76 , then @xmath78 and @xmath79 . actually , pips can also be defined as a triplet @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is a binary symmetric relation on a poset @xmath58 satisfying the conditions ( mic1 ) and ( mic2 ) . in this definition , the inconsistent relation @xmath59 on @xmath70 is obtained by @xmath82 for every @xmath60 . since both definitions of pips are equivalent , we will use a convenient one . for a pip @xmath70 , an ideal of @xmath70 is said to be _ consistent _ if it contains no ( minimally ) inconsistent pair . let @xmath83 denote the family of consistent ideals of @xmath70 . regard @xmath83 as a poset with respect to the inclusion order @xmath84 . \(a ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( c ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( p ) at ( 0.4 , 1 ) @xmath85 ; ( d ) at ( 4 , 0 ) ; ( e ) at ( 4 , 1 ) ; ( q ) at ( 4.6 , 1 ) @xmath86 ; ( f ) at ( 0 , 2 ) ; ( g ) at ( 2.5 , 2 ) ; ( r ) at ( 2.5 , 2.4 ) @xmath87 ; / n a / c , b / c , d / e , c / f , c / g , e / g ( ) ( ) ; ( c ) to ( e ) ; ( e ) to ( f ) ; \(a ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( c ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( d ) at ( 4 , 0 ) ; ( p ) at ( 4.6 , 0 ) @xmath85 ; ( e ) at ( 4 , 1 ) ; ( qr ) at ( 5.1 , 1 ) @xmath88 ; ( f ) at ( 0 , 2 ) ; / n a / c , b / c , d / e , c / f ( ) ( ) ; ( c ) to ( e ) ; ( d ) to [ bend right=40 ] ( e ) ; ( e ) to ( f ) ; \(a ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( c ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( d ) at ( 4 , 0 ) ; ( e ) at ( 4 , 1 ) ; ( f ) at ( 0 , 2 ) ; / n a / c , b / c , d / e , c / f ( ) ( ) ; ( c ) to ( e ) ; ( e ) to ( f ) ; \(a ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( p ) at ( 1.4 , 0 ) @xmath89 ; ( c ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( p ) at ( 0.4 , 1 ) @xmath85 ; ( d ) at ( 4 , 0 ) ; ( p ) at ( 4.65 , 0 ) @xmath90 ; ( e ) at ( 4 , 1 ) ; ( p ) at ( 4.65 , 1 ) @xmath86 ; ( f ) at ( 0 , 2 ) ; / n a / c , b / c , d / e , c / f ( ) ( ) ; ( b ) to ( d ) ; \(a ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( c ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( d ) at ( 4 , 0 ) ; ( e ) at ( 4 , 1 ) ; ( f ) at ( 0 , 2 ) ; / n a / c , b / c , d / e , c / f ( ) ( ) ; / n b / e , d / c , d / f , c / e , e / f ( ) ( ) ; ( b ) to ( d ) ; figure [ fig : pip ] shows examples of pips and non - pip structures . solid arrows indicate the orders between elements ( drawn from higher elements to lowers ) . dotted lines and dashed lines indicate the inconsistent relations . in ( a ) , ( b ) and ( d ) , labeled elements indicate where the violations of ( ic1 ) and ( ic2 ) are . in ( c ) and ( e ) , the minimally inconsistent relations are drawn by dashed lines . the following theorem establishes a one - to - one correspondence between median semilattices and pips . [ thm : median_semilattice_and_pip ] 1 . let @xmath51 be a median semilattice and @xmath59 a symmetric binary relation on @xmath56 defined by @xmath91 for every @xmath92 . then @xmath93 forms a pip with inconsistent relation @xmath59 . the consistent ideal family @xmath94 is isomorphic to @xmath56 , and an isomorphism is given by @xmath95 . 2 . let @xmath70 be a pip . the consistent ideal family @xmath83 forms a median semilattice . the pip @xmath96 obtained in the same way as ( 1 ) is isomorphic to @xmath70 . the latter part of theorem [ thm : median_semilattice_and_pip ] ( 2 ) is implicit in @xcite , and follows from theorem [ thm : median_semilattice_and_pip ] ( 1 ) and the fact that for pips @xmath70 and @xmath97 , if @xmath83 and @xmath98 are isomorphic , then @xmath70 and @xmath97 are also isomorphic @xcite . [ lem : pip_and_cnf ] a pip is an alternative expression of a satisfiable boolean 2-cnf , where consistent ideals correspond to true assignments . indeed , for a pip @xmath68 with @xmath99}}$ ] , consider the following 2-cnf of boolean variables @xmath100 : @xmath101 then an assignment @xmath102 is true if and only if the set of elements @xmath103 with @xmath104 is a consistent ideal . the reverse construction of a pip from a 2-cnf satisfiable at @xmath105 is also easily verified . the starting point for a compact representation for @xmath50-closed sets is the following . [ lem : closed_set_is_median_semilattice ] every @xmath50-closed set is a median semilattice . let @xmath106 be a @xmath50-closed set . then @xmath107 is a semilattice since @xmath33 is a semilattice with minimum element @xmath108 , and the operator @xmath43 coincides with @xmath26 on @xmath33 . we show that @xmath107 satisfies the conditions ( ms1 ) and ( ms2 ) . let @xmath109 be the principal ideal of @xmath110 . for all @xmath111 and @xmath36}}$ ] , @xmath112 is equal to either 0 or @xmath37 . therefore , for all @xmath113 , the join @xmath114 exists and it holds @xmath115 . next let @xmath116}}}}$ ] be an injection defined by @xmath117 for every @xmath111 . one can easily see that @xmath118 and @xmath119 for every @xmath113 . in other words , @xmath120 is an isomorphism from @xmath121 to @xmath122 . since any nonempty subset of @xmath123}}}$ ] closed under @xmath124 and @xmath125 is a distributive lattice ordered by inclusion , @xmath109 is also distributive . let @xmath126 be such that the join of any two of them exists in @xmath107 . since @xmath127 and @xmath128 are comparable for any @xmath36}}$ ] , the join @xmath55 exists in @xmath33 , and coincides with @xmath129 . finally since @xmath107 is closed under @xmath45 , the join @xmath55 belongs to @xmath107 . let @xmath59 be a symmetric binary relation on @xmath33 defined by @xmath130 for every @xmath42 . note that if @xmath131 then @xmath132 is equal to @xmath133 for every @xmath134 . from theorem [ thm : median_semilattice_and_pip ] ( 1 ) and lemma [ lem : closed_set_is_median_semilattice ] , we obtain the following . [ thm : closed_set_and_pip ] let @xmath107 be a @xmath50-closed set . then @xmath135 forms a pip with inconsistent relation @xmath59 . the consistent ideal family @xmath136 is isomorphic to @xmath107 , and the isomorphism is given by @xmath137 . \(000 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) 00002 ; ( 100 ) at ( -1 , 1 ) 13002 ; ( 001 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) 00012 ; ( 110 ) at ( -1.5 , 2 ) 13102 ; ( 101 ) at ( -0.5 , 2 ) 13012 ; ( 120 ) at ( 0.5 , 2 ) 13202 ; ( 031 ) at ( 1.5 , 2 ) 00312 ; ( 111 ) at ( -1.5 , 3 ) 13112 ; ( 121 ) at ( -0.5 , 3 ) 13212 ; ( 131 ) at ( 0.5 , 3 ) 13312 ; ( 231 ) at ( 1.5 , 3 ) 22312 ; / n 000/100 , 000/001 , 100/110 , 100/101 , 100/120 , 001/101 , 001/031 , 110/111 , 101/111 , 101/121 , 101/131 , 120/121 , 031/131 , 031/231 ( ) ( ) ; \(100 ) at ( -1 , 0.5 ) 13002 ; ( 110 ) at ( -1.5 , 1.5 ) 13102 ; ( 120 ) at ( -0.5 , 1.5 ) 13202 ; ( 001 ) at ( 1 , 0 ) 00012 ; ( 031 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) 00312 ; ( 231 ) at ( 1 , 2 ) 22312 ; / n 100/110 , 100/120 , 001/031 , 031/231 ( ) ( ) ; / n 110/120 , 120/031 , 100/231 ( ) ( ) ; ( 110 ) to [ bend right=17 ] ( 031 ) ; figure [ fig : example_of_closed_set_and_pip ] shows an example of a @xmath138-closed set and the corresponding pip . in ( a ) , elements surrounded by double - lined frames are join - irreducible . in ( b ) , only minimally inconsistent relations are drawn . from theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_pip ] , it will turn out that the set @xmath139 of join - irreducible elements of every @xmath50-closed set @xmath107 does not lose any information about the structure of @xmath107 . that is , non - minimum elements in @xmath107 can be obtained as the join of one or more join - irreducible elements of @xmath107 ( notice that we can not obtain the minimum element of @xmath107 in this way ) . therefore we call @xmath135 a _ pip - representation _ of @xmath107 . furthermore , the following proposition , which will be proved in section [ sec : proof_of_theorem_1 ] , says that this representation is actually compact . [ prop : number_of_irreducibles ] let @xmath107 be a @xmath50-closed set on @xmath33 . the number of join - irreducible elements of @xmath107 is at most @xmath140 . theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_pip ] states that any @xmath50-closed set can be represented by a pip . however , not all pips correspond to some @xmath50-closed sets . a natural question then arises : _ what class of pips represents @xmath50-closed sets ? _ the main result ( theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ) of this section answers this question . [ def : elementary ] a pip @xmath58 is called _ elementary _ if it satisfies the following conditions : ep @xmath70 is the disjoint union of @xmath141 such that every pair @xmath142 of distinct elements is minimally inconsistent if and only if @xmath143 for some @xmath36}}$ ] . for any distinct @xmath144}}$ ] , if @xmath145 and @xmath146 , there is no element @xmath147 with @xmath148 . for any distinct @xmath144}}$ ] , if @xmath145 and @xmath149 , either of the following holds : ep every pair of @xmath147 and @xmath150 is not comparable . there exist @xmath151 and @xmath152 such that @xmath153 and @xmath154 for all @xmath155 and @xmath156 . \(01 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( 02 ) at ( 1 , 0 ) ; ( 03 ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( 10 ) at ( 0 , 1 ) ; ( 10 ) ( 01 ) ; ( 01 ) ( 02 ) ; ( 02 ) ( 03 ) ; ( 01.south east ) to [ bend right=25 ] ( 03.south west ) ; \(01 ) at ( 0 , 1 ) ; ( 02 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( 03 ) at ( 2 , 1 ) ; ( 10 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( 01 ) ( 10 ) ; ( 01 ) ( 02 ) ; ( 02 ) ( 03 ) ; ( 01.north east ) to [ bend left=25 ] ( 03.north west ) ; \(10 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( 20 ) at ( 1 , 0 ) ; ( 30 ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( 01 ) at ( 0 , 1 ) ; ( 02 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) ; ( 03 ) at ( 2 , 1 ) ; ( 01 ) ( 10 ) ; ( 02 ) ( 20 ) ; ( 03 ) ( 30 ) ; ( 01 ) ( 02 ) ; ( 02 ) ( 03 ) ; ( 01.north east ) to [ bend left=25 ] ( 03.north west ) ; ( 10 ) ( 20 ) ; ( 20 ) ( 30 ) ; ( 10.south east ) to [ bend right=25 ] ( 30.south west ) ; \(10 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) ; ( x ) at ( -0.5 , 0.05 ) @xmath157 ; ( 02 ) at ( -0.5 , 1 ) ; ( 03 ) at ( 0.5 , 1 ) ; ( 01 ) at ( 2 , 0 ) ; ( x ) at ( 2.5 , 0.05 ) @xmath158 ; ( 20 ) at ( 1.5 , 1 ) ; ( 30 ) at ( 2.5 , 1 ) ; ( 02 ) ( 10 ) ; ( 03 ) ( 10 ) ; ( 20 ) ( 01 ) ; ( 30 ) ( 01 ) ; ( 01 ) ( 03 ) ; ( 02 ) ( 03 ) ; ( 02 ) to [ bend right=10 ] ( 01 ) ; ( 10 ) ( 20 ) ; ( 20 ) ( 30 ) ; ( 10 ) to [ bend right=10 ] ( 30 ) ; figure [ fig : example_of_elementary_pip ] shows examples of elementary pips and non - elementary pips . in all diagrams , the drawn pips satisfy the condition ( ep0 ) with @xmath159 . each element is colored black or white according to the corresponding part @xmath160 . non - minimally inconsistent relations are not drawn in each diagram . [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] 1 . for every @xmath50-closed set @xmath107 , the pip @xmath135 is elementary . 2 . for every elementary pip @xmath70 , there is a @xmath50-closed set @xmath107 isomorphic to @xmath83 . in case of @xmath161 , since the condition ( ep2 ) in definition [ def : elementary ] is equivalent to the skew - symmetricity of the corresponding hasse diagram , the pip - representation for @xmath50-closed sets coincides with the one by ando fujishige @xcite . the following corollary of theorem [ thm : median_semilattice_and_pip ] ( 2 ) and theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ( 1 ) will be used in section [ sec : algorithms ] . [ cor : elementary_pip ] let @xmath70 be a pip . if @xmath83 is isomorphic to some @xmath50-closed set , then @xmath70 is elementary . the remaining part of this section is devoted to proving theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] . the proof of theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ( 1 ) is outlined as follows : 1 . first we define the _ differential _ of a join - irreducible element @xmath35 as the difference between @xmath35 and the unique lower cover @xmath157 of @xmath35 . next we introduce a _ @xmath50-closed set , which is a @xmath50-closed set such that every differential has exactly one nonzero component . we show that every @xmath50-closed set is isomorphic to some normalized @xmath50-closed set . this set gives us a natural partition of join - irreducible elements . finally we construct an elementary pip from the partition . a @xmath50-closed set @xmath107 is said to be _ simple _ if @xmath162 . any @xmath50-closed set can be converted to a simple @xmath50-closed set without any structural change . [ def : differential ] let @xmath106 be a simple @xmath50-closed set . for @xmath134 , we say that @xmath163 is a _ lower cover _ of @xmath35 , or _ @xmath35 covers @xmath163 _ , if @xmath164 and there is no @xmath165 such that @xmath166 . for a join - irreducible element @xmath167 , there uniquely exists @xmath168 covered by @xmath35 . the _ differential _ @xmath169 of @xmath35 is defined by @xmath170 if @xmath171 and @xmath172 if @xmath173 for each @xmath36}}$ ] . \(000 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) 0000 ; ( 100 ) at ( -1 , 1 ) 1300 ; ( 001 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) 0001 ; ( 110 ) at ( -1.5 , 2 ) 1310 ; ( 101 ) at ( -0.5 , 2 ) 1301 ; ( 120 ) at ( 0.5 , 2 ) 1320 ; ( 031 ) at ( 1.5 , 2 ) 0031 ; ( 111 ) at ( -1.5 , 3 ) 1311 ; ( 121 ) at ( -0.5 , 3 ) 1321 ; ( 131 ) at ( 0.5 , 3 ) 1331 ; ( 231 ) at ( 1.5 , 3 ) 2231 ; / n 000/100 , 000/001 , 100/110 , 100/101 , 100/120 , 001/101 , 001/031 , 110/111 , 101/111 , 101/121 , 101/131 , 120/121 , 031/131 , 031/231 ( ) ( ) ; \(100 ) at ( -1 , 0.5 ) 1300 + _ 1300 _ ; ( 110 ) at ( -1.5 , 1.5 ) 1310 + _ 0010 _ ; ( 120 ) at ( -0.5 , 1.5 ) 1320 + _ 0020 _ ; ( 001 ) at ( 1 , 0 ) 0001 + _ 0001 _ ; ( 031 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) 0031 + _ 0030 _ ; ( 231 ) at ( 1 , 2 ) 2231 + _ 2200 _ ; / n 100/110 , 100/120 , 001/031 , 031/231 ( ) ( ) ; / n 110/120 , 120/031 , 100/231 ( ) ( ) ; ( 110 ) to [ bend right=20 ] ( 031 ) ; \(000 ) at ( 0 , 0 ) 000 ; ( 100 ) at ( -1 , 1 ) 100 ; ( 001 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) 001 ; ( 110 ) at ( -1.5 , 2 ) 110 ; ( 101 ) at ( -0.5 , 2 ) 101 ; ( 120 ) at ( 0.5 , 2 ) 120 ; ( 031 ) at ( 1.5 , 2 ) 031 ; ( 111 ) at ( -1.5 , 3 ) 111 ; ( 121 ) at ( -0.5 , 3 ) 121 ; ( 131 ) at ( 0.5 , 3 ) 131 ; ( 231 ) at ( 1.5 , 3 ) 231 ; / n 000/100 , 000/001 , 100/110 , 100/101 , 100/120 , 001/101 , 001/031 , 110/111 , 101/111 , 101/121 , 101/131 , 120/121 , 031/131 , 031/231 ( ) ( ) ; \(100 ) at ( -1 , 0.5 ) 100 + _ 100 _ ; ( 110 ) at ( -1.5 , 1.5 ) 110 + _ 010 _ ; ( 120 ) at ( -0.5 , 1.5 ) 120 + _ 020 _ ; ( 001 ) at ( 1 , 0 ) 001 + _ 001 _ ; ( 031 ) at ( 1 , 1 ) 031 + _ 030 _ ; ( 231 ) at ( 1 , 2 ) 231 + _ 200 _ ; / n 100/110 , 100/120 , 001/031 , 031/231 ( ) ( ) ; / n 110/120 , 120/031 , 100/231 ( ) ( ) ; ( 110 ) to [ bend right=20 ] ( 031 ) ; figure [ fig : example_of_differential_and_normalizing ] ( a ) and ( b ) show examples of a simple @xmath50-closed set and the corresponding pip , respectively . in ( b ) , the differential of each join - irreducible element is written in italics . we show some properties about differentials . in what follows , we denote the subset @xmath174 by @xmath175 for @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath176}}$ ] . note that @xmath175 also forms a @xmath50-closed set if @xmath177 . [ lem : differential ] let @xmath106 be a simple @xmath50-closed set . the following hold : 1 . for every @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath176}}$ ] with @xmath177 , @xmath178 is join - irreducible in @xmath107 and @xmath179 holds . 2 . for every @xmath167 and @xmath36}}$ ] with @xmath180 , it holds @xmath181 . 3 . for every @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath176}}$ ] , there is at most one join - irreducible element @xmath167 such that @xmath179 . 4 . for every @xmath167 , the differential @xmath182 of @xmath35 has at least one nonzero components . the map @xmath183 is an injection from @xmath139 to @xmath33 . let @xmath36 } } { , \;}\alpha \in { { \left[{k}\right]}}$ ] and @xmath178 . suppose to the contrary that @xmath184 . then there exist @xmath185 such that @xmath186 and @xmath187 . since @xmath188 , either @xmath112 or @xmath128 is equal to @xmath189 . this contradicts the assumption that @xmath181 and @xmath186 . hence @xmath35 is join - irreducible . moreover , from definition [ def : differential ] , it holds @xmath179 . let @xmath167 and @xmath36}}$ ] such that @xmath180 . then @xmath190 . let @xmath163 be the minimum element of @xmath175 . if @xmath191 , definition [ def : differential ] contradicts @xmath192 . hence we have @xmath193 . suppose that @xmath107 has a join - irreducible element @xmath167 such that @xmath179 . from ( 2 ) , it holds @xmath181 . this lemma follows from the uniqueness of the minimum element of @xmath175 . assume that @xmath107 has a join - irreducible element @xmath35 such that @xmath194 . then for every @xmath195 , there exists @xmath196 such that @xmath197 . thus the join of @xmath198 is equal to @xmath35 . this contradicts the assumption that @xmath35 is join - irreducible . let @xmath199 such that @xmath200 . since @xmath201 from ( 4 ) , there exists @xmath36}}$ ] such that @xmath202 . then @xmath203 follows from ( 3 ) . now proposition [ prop : number_of_irreducibles ] is a consequence of lemma [ lem : differential ] . it suffices to consider the case where @xmath107 is simple . from lemmas [ lem : differential ] ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) , it holds @xmath204 . furthermore , since the map @xmath205 is injective , we have @xmath206 . hence @xmath207 is at most @xmath140 . a simple @xmath50-closed set @xmath107 is said to be _ normalized _ if it satisfies @xmath208 for all @xmath167 . examples of a normalized @xmath50-closed set and the corresponding pip are shown in figure [ fig : example_of_differential_and_normalizing ] ( c ) and ( d ) , respectively . [ lem : normalized_is_general ] for any @xmath50-closed set @xmath107 , there exists a normalized @xmath50-closed set that is isomorphic to @xmath107 . we can suppose that @xmath107 is simple . we first show : 1 . for @xmath199 , it holds that @xmath209 or @xmath210 . assume that @xmath107 has a join - irreducible element @xmath35 such that @xmath211 and @xmath212 for distinct @xmath144}}$ ] . if there exists @xmath213 such that @xmath214 and @xmath215 , it holds @xmath216 from lemma [ lem : differential ] ( 3 ) . hence we have @xmath217 since @xmath218 . however , @xmath35 and @xmath133 belong to @xmath219 since @xmath220 , thus it holds @xmath221 from lemma [ lem : differential ] ( 2 ) . this is a contradiction . by ( 1 ) , we can define an equivalence relation @xmath222 over the index set @xmath223}}}\mathrel{}\middle|\mathrel{}{\text{there exists $ x \in { { m}^\mathrm{ir}}$ such that $ x_i \neq 0$}}\right\ } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] as follows : @xmath224 then each equivalence class can be `` contracted '' into a single index without any structural change of @xmath107 as follows . let @xmath225 be the set of equivalence classes . for @xmath226}}$ ] , let @xmath227 be the set of join - irreducible elements having nonzero support @xmath228 . then , by lemma [ lem : differential ] , 1 . for every @xmath110 and @xmath229}}$ ] , either @xmath230 for all @xmath231 or there uniquely exists @xmath232}}$ ] such that @xmath233 for all @xmath231 . let @xmath234 } k_j$ ] . define @xmath235 by @xmath236 if @xmath230 for @xmath231 , and @xmath237 if @xmath238 for @xmath231 . it is easily verified ( from lemma [ lem : differential ] ) that the map @xmath120 is injective and preserves @xmath29 . an irreducible element of @xmath239 is the image of an irreducible element of @xmath107 , and , by construction , has the differential of a singleton support . thus @xmath239 is a normalized @xmath50-closed set . now we are ready to prove theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ( 1 ) . by lemma [ lem : normalized_is_general ] , it suffices to consider the case where @xmath107 is normalized . for every @xmath36}}$ ] , let @xmath240 . from the definition of normalized @xmath50-closed sets , @xmath241 forms a partition of @xmath139 ( note that @xmath242 may be empty ) . we show that the pip @xmath243 satisfies the axiom of elementary pips with @xmath244 for every @xmath36}}$ ] . ( ep0 , `` only if '' part ) . let @xmath245 be a minimally inconsistent pair . then there exists @xmath36}}$ ] such that @xmath246 . we show @xmath247 . suppose that @xmath248 . from definition [ def : differential ] , there exists @xmath249 such that @xmath250 and @xmath251 . now we have @xmath250 and @xmath252 , which contradict the assumption that @xmath35 and @xmath163 are minimally inconsistent . therefore @xmath211 holds , and we can show @xmath214 in the same way . thus @xmath253 holds . ( ep1 ) is an immediate consequence of the following property : * let @xmath144}}$ ] be distinct . if there exist @xmath254 and @xmath255 such that @xmath256 , then for all @xmath257 , there exists @xmath258 such that @xmath259 ; in particular @xmath260 if @xmath261 . we show ( @xmath262 ) . let @xmath254 and @xmath255 such that @xmath256 . now it holds @xmath263 and @xmath264 . let @xmath257 . we have @xmath265 since @xmath266 . thus @xmath267 does not hold . we show that @xmath268 . if not , @xmath269 is equal to @xmath270 , hence @xmath133 belongs to @xmath271 . therefore it holds @xmath267 since @xmath163 is the minimum element of @xmath271 from lemma [ lem : differential ] ( 2 ) . we have a contradiction here . let @xmath272 . this @xmath158 belongs to @xmath273 from lemma [ lem : differential ] ( 1 ) , and it holds @xmath274 . let @xmath144}}$ ] be distinct indices such that @xmath275 and @xmath276 . we can assume that ( ep2 - 1 ) does not hold , i.e. , there exist @xmath254 and @xmath255 such that @xmath256 . consider @xmath277 . by ( @xmath262 ) , there exist @xmath278 such that @xmath279 and @xmath280 . we show @xmath281 . suppose not . since @xmath279 and @xmath282 , we can take @xmath283 such that @xmath284 by ( @xmath262 ) with changing the role of @xmath285 and @xmath286 . now we have @xmath287 , which contradicts @xmath288 . therefore @xmath158 and @xmath289 are same elements . consequently , the required element @xmath290 in ( ep2 - 2 ) is given by @xmath158 . by changing the role of @xmath285 and @xmath286 , we see that @xmath291 is given by @xmath157 . ( ep0 , `` if '' part ) . let @xmath292 be distinct with @xmath36}}$ ] . now since @xmath293 , there exists a minimally inconsistent pair @xmath294 such that @xmath295 and @xmath296 . from the `` only if '' part of ( ep0 ) , @xmath157 and @xmath158 belong to @xmath273 for some @xmath297}}$ ] . if @xmath298 , then we have @xmath292 , @xmath299 , @xmath250 and @xmath300 , which contradict ( ep2 ) . hence @xmath301 and it must hold @xmath302 . let @xmath68 be an elementary pip with partition @xmath303 of condition ( ep0 ) . for every @xmath36}}$ ] , let @xmath304 , where @xmath305 . let @xmath306 } } } k_i$ ] . for a consistent ideal @xmath109 , let @xmath307 be defined by @xmath308}}}\right)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now @xmath309 is well - defined since every consistent ideal @xmath109 of @xmath70 has at most one element in each @xmath160 by ( ep0 ) . . then @xmath83 and @xmath107 are clearly isomorphic . therefore the rest of the proof of theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ( 2 ) is to show that @xmath107 forms a @xmath50-closed set . we define binary operations @xmath43 and @xmath45 on @xmath83 as @xmath311 and @xmath312 for every @xmath313 . theorem [ thm : closed_set_and_elementary_pip ] ( 2 ) follows immediately from : [ lem : consistent_ideal_family_of_p_is_closed ] for every @xmath313 , it holds @xmath314 , @xmath315 and @xmath316 . let @xmath313 . since the consistent ideal family of a pip is closed under the intersection , @xmath317 also forms a consistent ideal of @xmath70 . in addition , we can easily check that @xmath315 holds . next we consider @xmath318 . we show that @xmath318 is a consistent ideal . suppose that @xmath318 is not an ideal of @xmath70 . there exist @xmath319 and @xmath320 such that @xmath321 . without loss of generality , we assume @xmath322 . now @xmath109 also contains @xmath85 since @xmath109 is an ideal . let @xmath144}}$ ] such that @xmath323 and @xmath324 . we can take @xmath325 since @xmath326 . thus @xmath327 is greater than 1 , and @xmath328 is also greater than 1 since @xmath321 contradicts the condition ( ep1 ) if @xmath329 . from ( ep2 - 2 ) , there exists @xmath330 such that @xmath331 . it holds @xmath332 since @xmath333 . now we have @xmath334 , @xmath322 , @xmath332 and @xmath335 . this contradicts @xmath319 . therefore @xmath318 is an ideal . finally suppose that @xmath318 includes an inconsistent pair @xmath69 . since @xmath318 is an ideal , it also includes the minimally inconsistent pair @xmath336 with @xmath71 and @xmath72 . from ( ep0 ) , @xmath89 and @xmath90 belong to the same part @xmath160 of the partition . this contradicts the fact that @xmath337 , and thus @xmath318 is a consistent ideal . @xmath316 follows from the definitions of @xmath45 on @xmath33 and on @xmath83 . in this section , we study algorithmic aspects of constructing pip - representations for the minimizer sets of @xmath0-submodular functions . let @xmath338 denote the minimizer set of a function @xmath1 . let @xmath339 denote the time complexity of an algorithm of a maximum flow ( and a minimum cut ) in a network of @xmath3 vertices and @xmath340 edges . we assume a standard max - flow algorithm , such as preflow - push algorithm , and hence assume that @xmath339 is not less than @xmath341 ; notice that the current fastest one is an @xmath341 algorithm by orlin @xcite . we also assume @xmath342 for dealing with @xmath0-submodular functions on @xmath33 . we can obtain the pip - representation for the minimizer set of a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath40 by using a minimizing oracle @xmath0-sfm , which returns a minimizer of @xmath1 and its restrictions . let @xmath343 be the minimum value of @xmath1 . for @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath344 , we define a new @xmath0-submodular function @xmath345 from @xmath1 by @xmath346 namely , @xmath347 is a function obtained by fixing the @xmath285-th variable of @xmath1 to @xmath348 . before describing the main part of our algorithm , we present a subroutine in algorithm [ alg : get_minimum_minimizer ] . this subroutine returns the minimum minimizer of a @xmath0-submodular function . the validity of this subroutine can be checked by the fact that @xmath349 is equal to @xmath343 if @xmath350 and otherwise it holds @xmath351 . this subroutine calls @xmath0-sfm at most @xmath352 times . a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath40 the minimum minimizer @xmath353 of @xmath1 algorithm [ alg : get_irreducibles_minimizers ] shows a procedure to collect all join - irreducible minimizers of a @xmath0-submodular function . let @xmath35 be the minimum minimizer of @xmath1 . the function @xmath354 in algorithm [ alg : get_irreducibles_minimizers ] is defined as @xmath355 for every @xmath356 . since @xmath357 is equal to @xmath112 if @xmath230 and to @xmath37 if @xmath358 , we can regard @xmath359 as a @xmath0-submodular function obtained by fixing each @xmath285-th variable of @xmath1 to @xmath37 if @xmath358 . note that the minimum values of @xmath1 and @xmath359 are the same . the correctness of this algorithm is based on lemma [ lem : differential ] ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) . namely , the set of join - irreducible minimizers of @xmath1 coincides with the set @xmath360 } } \setminus { \mathop{\mathrm{supp}}}{x } { , \;}\alpha \in { { \left[{k}\right ] } } { , \;}\min { { \tilde{f}}_{{i},{\alpha } } } = \min f}\right\}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the algorithm collects each join - irreducible minimizer according to by calling at most @xmath361 times . consequently , if a minimizing oracle is available , the minimizer set can also be obtained in polynomial time . [ thm : alg_oracle ] the pip - representation for the minimizer set of a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath40 is obtained by @xmath5 calls of @xmath0-sfm . a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath40 the set @xmath362 of all join - irreducible minimizers of @xmath1 iwata wahlstrm yoshida @xcite introduced _ basic @xmath0-submodular functions _ , which form a special class of @xmath0-submodular functions . they showed a reduction of the minimization problem of a nonnegative combination of binary basic @xmath0-submodular functions to the minimum cut problem on a directed network . we describe their method and present an algorithm to obtain the pip - representation for the minimizer set . let @xmath3 and @xmath0 be positive integers . we consider a directed network @xmath363 with vertex set @xmath364 , edge set @xmath365 and nonnegative edge capacity @xmath366 . suppose that @xmath364 consists of source @xmath367 , sink @xmath368 and other vertices @xmath369 , where @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath176}}$ ] . let @xmath370 for @xmath36}}$ ] . an @xmath49-cut of @xmath371 is a subset @xmath16 of @xmath364 such that @xmath372 and @xmath373 . we call an @xmath49-cut @xmath16 _ legal _ if @xmath374 for every @xmath36}}$ ] . there is a natural bijection @xmath375 from @xmath33 to the set of legal @xmath49-cuts of @xmath371 defined by @xmath376 for an @xmath49-cut @xmath16 of @xmath371 , let @xmath377 denote the legal @xmath49-cut obtained by removing vertices in @xmath378 from @xmath16 for every @xmath36}}$ ] with @xmath379 . the _ capacity _ @xmath380 of @xmath16 is defined as sum of capacities @xmath381 of all edges @xmath382 from @xmath16 to @xmath383 . we say that a network @xmath371 _ represents _ a function @xmath40 if it satisfies the following conditions : nr there exists a constant @xmath384 such that @xmath385 for all @xmath386 . it holds @xmath387 for all @xmath49-cuts @xmath16 of @xmath371 . from ( nr1 ) , the minimum value of @xmath388 is equal to the capacity of a minimum @xmath49-cut of @xmath371 . for every minimum @xmath49-cut @xmath16 of @xmath371 , @xmath377 is also a minimum @xmath49-cut since @xmath371 satisfies the condition ( nr2 ) . therefore @xmath389 is a minimizer of @xmath1 , and a minimum @xmath49-cut can be computed by maximum flow algorithms . indeed , wahlstrm yoshida @xcite showed that nonnegative combinations of basic @xmath0-submodular functions are representable by such networks . now we shall consider obtaining the pip - representation for the minimizer set of a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath40 represented by a network @xmath371 . the minimizer set of @xmath1 is isomorphic to the family of legal minimum @xmath49-cuts of @xmath371 ordered by inclusion , where the isomorphism is @xmath375 . it is well - known that the family of ( not necessarily legal ) minimum @xmath49-cuts forms a distributive lattice . thus , by birkhoff representation theorem , the family is efficiently representable by a poset . queyranne @xcite showed an algorithm to obtain the poset from the residual graph corresponding to a maximum @xmath49-flow of @xmath371 . we describe their theorem briefly . for an @xmath49-flow @xmath120 of @xmath371 , the _ residual graph _ corresponding to @xmath120 is a directed graph @xmath390 , where @xmath391 [ thm : picard ] let @xmath363 be a directed network with @xmath392 and @xmath393 the residual graph corresponding to a maximum @xmath394-flow of @xmath371 . let @xmath395 be the set of strongly connected components ( sccs ) of @xmath393 other than the following : sccs reachable from @xmath367 . sccs reachable to @xmath368 . let @xmath396 be a partial order on @xmath395 defined by @xmath397 for every @xmath398 . the ideal family of the poset @xmath399 is isomorphic to the family of minimum @xmath49-cuts of @xmath371 ordered by inclusion . the isomorphism @xmath400 is given by @xmath401 , where @xmath402 is the set of vertices reachable from @xmath367 . our result is the following . [ thm : network_algo ] let @xmath371 be a network representing a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath40 and @xmath393 the residual graph corresponding to a maximum @xmath394-flow of @xmath371 . let @xmath395 be the set of sccs of @xmath393 other than the following : sccs reachable from @xmath367 . sccs reachable to @xmath368 . sccs reachable to an scc containing two or more elements in @xmath403 for some @xmath36}}$ ] . sccs reachable to sccs @xmath16 and @xmath404 such that @xmath405 and @xmath406 for some @xmath36}}$ ] . a partial order @xmath396 on @xmath395 is defined in the same way as theorem [ thm : picard ] . let @xmath59 be a symmetric binary relation on @xmath395 defined as @xmath407}}$}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] then @xmath395 forms an elementary pip with inconsistent relation @xmath59 . the consistent ideal family of @xmath395 is isomorphic to the minimizer set of @xmath1 , where the isomorphism is @xmath408 . first we prove that @xmath395 is a pip . we can see that @xmath59 satisfies the condition ( ic1 ) since for every @xmath398 with @xmath409 , an scc @xmath410 reachable to @xmath16 and @xmath404 does not belong to @xmath395 according to the above exclusion rule ( 4 ) . the condition ( ic2 ) is also satisfied from the definition of the relation @xmath59 . thus @xmath395 forms a pip . next we show @xmath411 for every consistent ideal @xmath109 of @xmath395 . let @xmath412 be the poset given in theorem [ thm : picard ] . note that @xmath395 is a subposet of @xmath412 . we show that @xmath109 is an ideal of @xmath412 . suppose not . then there exist @xmath413 and @xmath414 such that @xmath404 is reachable from @xmath16 and meets the above exclusion rules ( 3 ) or ( 4 ) . now since @xmath16 also satisfies the same exclusion rule , @xmath16 does not belong to @xmath395 . this is a contradiction . hence @xmath109 is an ideal of @xmath412 , and @xmath415 is a minimum @xmath49-cut ( theorem [ thm : picard ] ) . moreover , from the exclusion rule ( 3 ) and the definition of @xmath59 , we can see that @xmath415 is legal . therefore @xmath416 is a minimizer of @xmath1 . conversely , let @xmath386 be a minimizer of @xmath1 . since @xmath417 is a minimum @xmath49-cut , @xmath418 is an ideal of @xmath412 ( theorem [ thm : picard ] ) . suppose that @xmath419 . then there exists @xmath420 which meets the exclusion rule ( 3 ) or ( 4 ) . suppose that @xmath16 meets the rule ( 3 ) . then @xmath16 is reachable to an scc @xmath404 such that @xmath421 for some @xmath36}}$ ] . now @xmath404 is not reachable to @xmath368 since @xmath16 is not reachable to @xmath368 . thus @xmath404 meets the rule ( 1 ) or belongs to @xmath109 otherwise . in either case it holds @xmath422 . this contradicts the fact that @xmath417 is legal . a similar argument can also be applied in the case where @xmath16 meets the rule ( 4 ) . therefore @xmath423 holds , and @xmath109 is an ideal of @xmath395 since @xmath395 is a subposet of @xmath412 . the consistency of @xmath109 is an immediate consequence of the fact that @xmath417 is legal . now we have shown that @xmath408 is a bijection from @xmath424 to @xmath338 . in addition , @xmath408 clearly preserves the orders , hence it is an isomorphism . finally from corollary [ cor : elementary_pip ] , @xmath395 is elementary . consider the time complexity to obtain @xmath395 from the residual graph @xmath393 . first we can obtain the sccs of @xmath393 in @xmath425 time , where @xmath426 . additionally , the exclusion rules ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) can be applied to the sccs in the same time complexity . hence it is only the exclusion rule ( 4 ) that we should carefully take account of . an efficient algorithm is as follows : for each remaining scc @xmath16 , memorize the union of sccs reachable from @xmath16 , and if the union set has two or more elements in @xmath403 for some @xmath36}}$ ] , remove all sccs reachable to @xmath16 . by executing this process in reverse topological order , it can be done in @xmath427 time since the size of each memorized set is at most @xmath3 . therefore the time complexity for obtaining @xmath395 from @xmath393 is much less than the one for computing @xmath393 from the network @xmath371 . consequently , we obtain the following theorem : [ thm : network_time ] let @xmath40 be a @xmath0-submodular function represented by a network @xmath371 with @xmath428 edges . the pip - representation for the minimizer set of @xmath1 is obtained in @xmath429 time . let @xmath430 be a connected undirected graph on vertex set @xmath431}}$ ] with @xmath432 , where each edge @xmath433 has a positive edge weight @xmath434 . let @xmath435}}$ ] be the set of labels . potts @xmath0-submodular function _ is a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath436 of the following form : @xmath437 where @xmath438 is any @xmath0-submodular function on @xmath27 for each @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath439 is a @xmath0-submodular function on @xmath440 defined by @xmath441 for each @xmath442 . a potts @xmath0-submodular function is naturally associated with a _ potts energy function _ @xmath443}}^n}{\setr}$ ] : @xmath444}}^n}\right)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath438 is any function on @xmath435}}$ ] for each @xmath36}}$ ] and @xmath445}}^2}{\setr}$ ] is defined by @xmath446 if @xmath447 and @xmath448 if @xmath449 . finding a labeling @xmath450}}^n$ ] of the minimum potts energy is np - hard for @xmath48 but particularly important in computer vision applications . useful information of optimal labelings of the potts energy can be extracted from a minimizer of a potts @xmath0-submodular function with appropriate @xmath0-submodular functions @xmath451 . define each @xmath451 by @xmath452 for @xmath176}}$ ] and @xmath453}}}\::\:{\beta \neq \gamma } } } { \left({{{g_i}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}({\beta}{\aftergroup\egroup\right } ) } } + { { g_i}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}({\gamma}{\aftergroup\egroup\right})}}}\right)}/2 $ ] . in this case , @xmath10 is a _ @xmath0-submodular relaxation _ of @xmath9 , and an optimal labeling of @xmath9 is a partially recovered from a minimizer of @xmath9 ; see the next section . another choice of @xmath454 is : @xmath455 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\ } } } { { g_i}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}({\beta}{\aftergroup\egroup\right})}}}\right)}/2 $ ] for @xmath176}}$ ] and @xmath456 . also in this case , a part of an optimal labeling is obtained from a minimizer of @xmath10 , and coincides with kovtun s partial labeling @xcite . the goal of this section is to develop a fast algorithm to construct the pip of a potts @xmath0-submodular function @xmath10 . notice that @xmath10 is network - representable with @xmath457 edges @xcite . therefore we can obtain a minimizer as well as the pip - representation for @xmath10 in @xmath458 time by the network construction in the previous section . however it is hard to apply this algorithm to the vision application with large @xmath459 in @xcite . kolmogorov @xcite developed an @xmath460-time algorithm to find a minimizer of @xmath10 . the main theorem in this section is a stronger result that the pip - representation is also obtained in the same time complexity . [ thm : potts ] the pip - representation for the minimizer set of @xmath10 is obtained in + @xmath460 time . the rest of this subsection is devoted to proving this theorem . first we construct a network @xmath371 , different from the one in the previous section . for each @xmath36}}$ ] , decompose @xmath451 as follows . let @xmath461 be defined by @xmath462 if @xmath463 and @xmath464 otherwise . choose a minimizer @xmath465 of @xmath451 . then @xmath451 is represented as @xmath466 } } } \sigma_{i , \alpha } { { 1_{=}}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}({\alpha , x_i}{\aftergroup\egroup\right})}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath467 and @xmath468 for @xmath176}}$ ] . we remark that @xmath469 is nonnegative by @xmath0-submodularity , and that @xmath470 implies @xmath471 . let us construct @xmath371 . starting from @xmath430 , define the edge - capacity @xmath472 of each edge @xmath433 by @xmath434 . next add new vertices @xmath473 , called _ terminals_. for each @xmath36}}$ ] , if @xmath470 with @xmath474}}$ ] , add a new edge @xmath475 of capacity @xmath476 . an edge @xmath475 is called a _ terminal edge_. for each @xmath176}}$ ] with @xmath477 , add a new vertices @xmath478 and new edge @xmath479 of capacity @xmath480 . a vertex @xmath478 is called the _ @xmath189-fringe _ of @xmath285 . let @xmath481 . let @xmath482 be the set of all fringes , @xmath483 the set of all edges incident to fringes , and @xmath484 the set of all terminal edges . let @xmath485 and @xmath486 . let @xmath487 be the resulting network . second we show that @xmath10 is represented as a certain multicut function in @xmath371 . for a vertex subset @xmath16 , the cut capacity @xmath380 of @xmath16 is the sum of @xmath381 of all edges @xmath382 between @xmath16 and @xmath383 . for @xmath176}}$ ] , a vertex subset @xmath16 is called an _ @xmath488-isolating cut _ or _ @xmath189-cut _ if @xmath489 , @xmath490 for @xmath491 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] , and @xmath16 contains no @xmath189-fringe . semi - multicut _ is an ordered partition @xmath492 of @xmath493 such that @xmath494 is an @xmath189-cut for each @xmath176}}$ ] . the _ capacity _ @xmath495 of a semi - multicut @xmath496 is defined by @xmath497 } } } { { c}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}({x_\alpha}{\aftergroup\egroup\right})}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] an _ admissible _ semi - multicut is a semi - multicut @xmath498 such that for each @xmath176}}$ ] , each @xmath189-fringe @xmath478 belongs to @xmath402 if @xmath499 and belongs to @xmath500 if @xmath501 for @xmath491 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] . observe that the part to which a fringe of @xmath36}}$ ] belongs is uniquely determined from the part which @xmath285 belongs . for an admissible semi - multicut @xmath496 , define @xmath502 by @xmath503 if and only if @xmath504 . this map @xmath505 is a bijection from the family of all admissible semi - multicuts to @xmath33 . the next lemma says that a @xmath0-submodular function @xmath10 is actually represented by capacities of admissible semi - multicuts . for any admissible multicut @xmath506 , it holds @xmath507 } } } { { \tilde{g}_i}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}({\gamma_i}{\aftergroup\egroup\right})}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath508 . the capacity @xmath509 of a fringe edge @xmath479 contributes to @xmath495 by @xmath469 if @xmath510 and by @xmath8 otherwise . thus the contribution is equal to @xmath511 . the capacity @xmath512 of a terminal edge @xmath475 contributes to @xmath495 by @xmath8 if @xmath510 and by @xmath513 if @xmath514 , and by @xmath512 if @xmath501 with @xmath515 . thus the contribution is equal to @xmath516 . similarly , we verify that the contribution of the capacity @xmath434 of @xmath433 is equal to @xmath517 . thus the claimed equality holds . third we show that a minimum admissible semi - multicut is easily obtained by @xmath0 max - flow computations , where `` minimum '' is with regard to the cut capacity . an _ admissible _ @xmath189-cut is an @xmath189-cut @xmath16 such that for each @xmath491 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] , each @xmath518-fringe @xmath519 belongs to @xmath16 if @xmath520 and @xmath521 otherwise . then an admissible semi - multicut @xmath498 is exactly a partition of @xmath493 such that @xmath494 is an admissible @xmath189-cut for each @xmath176}}$ ] . [ lem : minimum_semimultiway_cut ] 1 . any minimum @xmath189-cut is admissible . 2 . for @xmath176}}$ ] , let @xmath522 be the inclusion - minimal minimum @xmath189-cut . then @xmath523 is a minimum admissible semi - multicut . in particular , a minimum admissible semi - multicut is exactly a partition @xmath524 of @xmath493 such that @xmath494 is a minimum @xmath189-cut for each @xmath176}}$ ] . let @xmath16 be an @xmath189-cut . for @xmath491 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] , if the @xmath518-fringe @xmath519 of @xmath520 is outside of @xmath16 , then include @xmath519 into @xmath16 to decrease the cut capacity . similarly , for @xmath491 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] , if the @xmath518-fringe @xmath519 of @xmath525 belongs to @xmath16 , then remove @xmath519 from @xmath16 to decrease the cut capacity . ( 2 ) is immediate from the standard uncrossing argument ; see the proof of lemma [ lem : uncrossing ] . in particular , a minimum admissible multicut is obtained by computing a minimal minimum @xmath189-cut for each @xmath176}}$ ] . the network @xmath371 has at most @xmath526 vertices and @xmath527 edges . when computing a minimum @xmath189-cut , all @xmath518-fringes with @xmath515 can be removed , and a max - flow algorithm is performed on a network of @xmath528 vertices and @xmath529 edges ( after combining @xmath530 for @xmath515 and all @xmath189-fringes into a single vertex ) . thus we obtain the following , which was essentially shown in @xcite . a minimizer of @xmath10 can be obtained in @xmath531 time . fourth we explain how to obtain the pip representation from maximum @xmath189-flows for @xmath176}}$ ] , where by an _ @xmath189-flow _ we mean a flow from @xmath488 to the union of @xmath532 and @xmath189-fringes . to construct the pip , we use the following intersecting properties of minimum isolating cuts . here a minimum @xmath189-cut is simply called an _ @xmath189-mincut_. [ lem : uncrossing ] 1 . for distinct @xmath533}}$ ] , if @xmath16 is an @xmath189-mincut and @xmath404 is a @xmath518-mincut , then @xmath534 is an @xmath189-mincut and @xmath535 is a @xmath518-mincut . 2 . for distinct @xmath536}}$ ] , if @xmath16 is an @xmath189-mincut , @xmath404 is a @xmath518-mincut and @xmath410 is a @xmath537-mincut , then @xmath538 . in the theory of minimum cuts on undirected networks , the following inequalities are well - known : @xmath539 for every @xmath540 . then ( 1 ) is an immediate consequence of the first inequality and the fact that any subset of an @xmath189-cut containing @xmath488 is again an @xmath189-cut . ( 2 ) is also immediate from the second inequality and the condition that @xmath430 is connected and each edge of @xmath371 has a positive capacity . by lemma [ lem : uncrossing ] ( 2 ) , each vertex belongs to at most two minimum isolating cuts . let @xmath541 denote the directed network obtained from @xmath371 by replacing each undirected edge @xmath542 by two directed edge @xmath543 and @xmath544 of capacity @xmath545 . for each @xmath176}}$ ] , consider the network obtained from @xmath541 by removing all @xmath518-fringes with @xmath515 and contracting terminals @xmath530 with @xmath515 and @xmath189-fringes into a single terminal @xmath546 , and consider the residual graph @xmath547 corresponding to a maximum @xmath548-flow in this network . let @xmath549 be the poset obtained from @xmath547 in the same way as defined in theorem [ thm : picard ] . here each element in @xmath550 is a subset of @xmath364 ( not including terminals and fringes ) . the ideal family of each @xmath550 is isomorphic to the family of minimum @xmath189-cuts . the intersecting part in @xmath550 and @xmath551 is described as follows . [ lem : intersection_of_isolating_cuts ] let @xmath533}}$ ] with @xmath447 . the following hold : 1 . for every @xmath552 and @xmath553 , it holds either @xmath554 or @xmath555 . 2 . for every @xmath556 , if @xmath557 , then it holds @xmath558 . assume that @xmath559 and @xmath560 . we can assume @xmath561 . consider an @xmath189-mincut @xmath16 with @xmath562 and consider a @xmath518-mincut @xmath404 with @xmath563 . take @xmath404 minimal . then every scc of @xmath564 included in @xmath404 is less than or equal to @xmath565 with respect to @xmath566 . suppose that @xmath404 contains @xmath365 . there is a @xmath518-mincut @xmath410 containing @xmath567 and disjoint from @xmath565 . by lemma [ lem : uncrossing ] ( 1 ) , @xmath568 is an @xmath189-mincut and properly intersects @xmath365 . however this is impossible since the set of non - fringe vertices in each @xmath189-mincut is a disjoint union of sccs of @xmath547 . suppose that @xmath404 does not contain @xmath365 . then @xmath534 is an @xmath189-mincut and properly intersects @xmath365 again . this is a contradiction . assume that @xmath557 and @xmath569 . there is a @xmath518-mincut @xmath404 containing @xmath365 and disjoint with @xmath565 . consider an @xmath189-mincut @xmath16 containing @xmath565 . then @xmath534 is an @xmath189-mincut , contains @xmath565 , and does not contain @xmath365 . however this contradicts the assumption that @xmath557 . by lemma [ lem : intersection_of_isolating_cuts ] , we obtain the elementary pip representing minimum admissible cuts just by `` gluing '' @xmath570 along the intersections . let @xmath571 } } } \sigma_\alpha \times { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] and @xmath396 a partial order on @xmath70 defined by @xmath572 for every @xmath573 . in addition , let @xmath81 be a symmetric binary relation on @xmath70 defined by @xmath574 for every @xmath575 . [ thm : pip_potts ] the triplet @xmath576 is an elementary pip with minimally inconsistent relation @xmath81 . the consistent ideal family @xmath83 and the family of minimum admissible semi - multicuts of @xmath371 are in one - to - one correspondence by the map @xmath577 where , for each @xmath176}}$ ] , @xmath578 is the admissible @xmath189-cut containing all vertices @xmath579 such that @xmath285 is reachable from @xmath488 in @xmath547 or belongs to @xmath16 for some @xmath580 . it is easy to see from lemma [ lem : intersection_of_isolating_cuts ] ( 2 ) that @xmath70 is a pip with minimally inconsistent relation @xmath81 . we next show that @xmath83 represents the family of minimum semi - multiway cuts . let @xmath581 . then @xmath578 is a minimum @xmath488-isolating cut ( by theorem [ thm : picard ] ) . by consistency , it necessarily holds @xmath582 for @xmath447 . thus @xmath583 is a minimum semi - multiway cut . conversely , let @xmath498 be a minimum semi - multiway cut . each @xmath494 is a minimum @xmath488-isolating cut , and is represented by an ideal @xmath584 of @xmath550 . now @xmath585 } } } i_\alpha \times { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] is a consistent ideal of @xmath70 since @xmath586 are pairwise disjoint . then it holds @xmath587 for @xmath176}}$ ] . now @xmath70 represents a @xmath588-closed set in @xmath33 , and is necessarily elementary by corollary [ cor : elementary_pip ] . therefore the pip - representation is obtained by computing a maximum @xmath189-flow for each @xmath176}}$ ] . the pip - representation for the minimizer set of @xmath10 is obtained in @xmath589 time . finally we present an improved algorithm of time complexity @xmath460 . the key is the existence of a single `` multiflow '' that includes all maximum @xmath189-flows . let @xmath590 denote the set of @xmath189-paths over all @xmath176}}$ ] , where an _ @xmath189-path _ is a path connecting @xmath488 and an @xmath189-fringe or a terminal @xmath530 with @xmath515 . a _ multiflow _ is a nonnegative - valued function @xmath1 on @xmath590 satisfying the capacity constraint : @xmath591 let @xmath592 denote the total - flow value of @xmath1 : @xmath593 for @xmath176}}$ ] , let @xmath594 be the submultiflow of @xmath1 defined by @xmath595 if @xmath596 is an @xmath189-path and @xmath597 otherwise . although the set @xmath590 is exponential , we can efficiently handle multiflow @xmath1 by keeping @xmath1 as @xmath0 flows of node - arc form in @xmath541 , as in @xcite . the following is a special case of ( * ? ? ? * theorem 1.2 ) ( a version of _ multiflow locking theorem _ ) . there exists a multiflow @xmath1 such that @xmath598 is equal to the minimum capacity of an @xmath189-cut for each @xmath176}}$ ] . thus the submultiflow @xmath594 of @xmath1 turns into a maximum @xmath189-flow in @xmath541 . we call such a multiflow _ locking_. our goal is to show that a locking multiflow @xmath1 is obtained in @xmath460 time . this , consequently , yields @xmath460-time algorithm to obtain posets @xmath570 and the desired pip @xmath599 } } } \sigma_\alpha \times { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] . in the case where there are no fringes , the problem of finding a locking multiflow is nothing but the _ maximum free multiflow problem _ , which is a well - studied problem in multiflow theory . karzanov nagamochi developed a divide - and - conquer @xmath600-time algorithm ( _ ikn - algorithm _ ) to obtain a locking multiflow . we remark that gridchyn algorithm @xcite is also designed by a similar divide - and - conquer idea in `` cut side . '' we adapt ikn - algorithm to the case where fringes exist . the pseudo code is shown in algorithm [ alg : locking ] . a network @xmath371 with terminal set @xmath601 a locking multiflow in @xmath371 let us explain the detail of the algorithm . consider the case @xmath602 . as in ikn - algorithm , our algorithm divides terminal set @xmath601 into two sets @xmath603 and @xmath604 such that @xmath605 and @xmath606 , and find a minimum cut @xmath16 with @xmath607 and @xmath608 , where fringes are removed in computation . two networks @xmath609 and @xmath610 are constructed as follows . the network @xmath609 is obtained from @xmath371 by contracting @xmath521 into a single terminal @xmath546 and by removing all @xmath189-fringes for @xmath611 . similarly , the network @xmath610 is obtained from @xmath371 by contracting @xmath16 into a single terminal @xmath612 and by removing all @xmath189-fringes for @xmath613 . suppose that we have a locking multiflow @xmath614 in @xmath609 and locking multiflow @xmath615 in @xmath610 . then a locking multiflow @xmath1 in @xmath371 is obtained by `` aggregating '' @xmath614 and @xmath615 as follows . an @xmath189-path @xmath596 in @xmath609 not connecting @xmath546 is regarded as an @xmath189-path in @xmath371 . set @xmath616 for such a path @xmath596 . similarly , set @xmath617 for each @xmath189-path @xmath596 in @xmath610 not connecting @xmath612 . next consider paths connecting @xmath546 in @xmath609 and @xmath612 in @xmath610 . observe that @xmath618 is a minimum @xmath546-cut in @xmath609 and @xmath619 is a minimum @xmath612-cut in @xmath610 . an edge @xmath382 in @xmath371 joining @xmath16 and @xmath620 becomes an edge connecting @xmath546 in @xmath609 and an edge connecting @xmath612 in @xmath610 . then @xmath621 necessarily holds . consider an @xmath546-path @xmath622 in @xmath609 and @xmath612-path @xmath623 in @xmath610 containing @xmath382 . the two paths @xmath622 and @xmath623 are concatenated along @xmath382 into an @xmath624-path @xmath596 in @xmath371 for @xmath625 , and set @xmath626 . decrease @xmath614 by @xmath627 on @xmath622 ( no @xmath612-flows in @xmath610 ) , and decrease @xmath615 by @xmath627 on @xmath623 . repeating this process until there are no @xmath546-flows in @xmath609 , we obtain a multiflow @xmath1 in @xmath371 . here @xmath1 is a locking in @xmath371 . this follows from the fact ( obtained from uncrossing ) that for @xmath176}}$ ] with @xmath628 ( resp . @xmath604 ) , a minimum @xmath189-cut in @xmath609 ( resp . @xmath610 ) is a minimum @xmath189-cut in @xmath371 . multiflows are kept as node - arc forms . this procedure , called the _ aggregation _ , can be done in @xmath341 time as in ( * ? ? ? * section 2.2 ) . suppose that @xmath629 . suppose that there is an @xmath189-fringe . compute a minimum @xmath189-cut @xmath16 . construct @xmath609 and @xmath610 as above , find locking multiflows @xmath614 in @xmath609 and @xmath615 in @xmath610 , and aggregate @xmath614 and @xmath615 into a locking multiflow @xmath1 in @xmath371 . in @xmath609 , there are two terminals , and a locking multiflow is obtained by a maximum flow . in @xmath610 , there are ( at most ) three terminals but no @xmath189-fringes . after recursing at most three times , we arrive at the situation that there are no fringes . this situation is precisely the same as ( * ? ? ? * section 2.1 ) . then a locking multiflow is obtained in at most three max - flow computations . the time complexity of this algorithm is analyzed in precisely the same way as ( * ? ? ? * section 2.3 ) , sketched as follows . for simplicity of analysis , we use orlin s @xmath341-time algorithm @xcite to find a maximum flow and minimum cut . let @xmath630 denote the time complexity of the algorithm applied to potts @xmath0-submodular functions on graph @xmath430 with @xmath631 , and @xmath632 . suppose that the time complexity of the max - flow algorithm and the aggregation procedure are bounded by @xmath633 and by @xmath634 for constants @xmath20 and @xmath635 , respectively . we show by induction that @xmath636 for a constant @xmath637 ( to be determined later ) . for @xmath638 , it holds @xmath639 . suppose that @xmath640 . then @xmath641 with @xmath642 . by induction , we have @xmath643 where we use @xmath342 and @xmath644 . for @xmath645 , it holds @xmath636 as required . this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : potts ] . the compact representation for @xmath50-closed sets by an elementary pip is kind of a data compression . hence it is natural to consider an efficient way to extract elements of the original @xmath50-closed set . this corresponds to the enumeration of consistent ideals of an elementary pip . as seen in remark [ lem : pip_and_cnf ] , consistent ideals correspond to true assignments of a boolean 2-cnf . thus we can enumerate all consistent ideals in output - polynomial time @xcite ( i.e. , the algorithm stops in time polynomial in the length of the input and output ) . maximal consistent ideals are of special interest , as described in section [ sec : relaxation ] . for a pip @xmath70 , let @xmath646 denote the family of maximal consistent ideals . now we consider the enumeration of @xmath646 . this can also be done in output - polynomial time by using the algorithm of @xcite in @xmath647 time per output . we here develop a considerably faster algorithm for the elementary pip of a potts @xmath0-submodular function @xmath10 . our algorithm utilizes its amalgamated structure by posets ( theorem [ thm : pip_potts ] ) . in fact , the structure of @xmath646 is quite simple , which we now explain . let @xmath570 be the posets , and @xmath571 } } } \sigma_\alpha \times { \left\{{\alpha}\right\}}$ ] the pip defined in the previous section . for distinct @xmath533}}$ ] , let @xmath648 be the subposet of @xmath550 . in particular , @xmath649 is equal to @xmath650 as a set , and the partial order of @xmath649 is the reverse of that of @xmath650 . let @xmath651 } } \setminus { \left\{{\alpha}\right\ } } } \sigma_{\alpha , \beta}$ ] . define the poset @xmath652 by disjoint sum @xmath653 where partial order @xmath396 on @xmath652 is defined as : the relation on @xmath649 is the same as the partial order of @xmath649 and there is no relation between @xmath649 and @xmath654 for @xmath655 . for a subset @xmath656 of @xmath550 , let @xmath657 . for an ideal @xmath658 of @xmath652 , let @xmath659 be defined by @xmath660 [ thm : enumeration_potts ] the map @xmath661 is a bijection from the ideal family of @xmath652 to @xmath646 . let @xmath658 be an ideal of @xmath652 . we first show that @xmath659 is a consistent ideal . consider @xmath662 . if @xmath663 , then @xmath664 since @xmath665 is an ideal by ( ep1 ) . suppose that @xmath666 . then @xmath667 . since @xmath658 is an ideal in @xmath649 , @xmath668 is an ideal in @xmath550 . consequently @xmath669 , and @xmath670 . suppose that @xmath671 . then @xmath672 . observe that @xmath673 is an ideal in @xmath674 . from this , we obtain @xmath670 , as above . since @xmath659 contains exactly one of @xmath675 with @xmath447 , the image @xmath659 is consistent and maximal . let @xmath109 be a maximal consistent ideal of @xmath395 . necessarily @xmath109 contains @xmath665 for all @xmath176}}$ ] . consider @xmath675 with @xmath447 . then @xmath109 contains exactly one of @xmath676 . otherwise , consider the principal ideal @xmath677 of @xmath678 , and the ideal @xmath679 . by maximality , @xmath679 is inconsistent . then there are @xmath680 and @xmath681 with @xmath682 . by ( ep1 ) , ( ep2 ) and lemma [ lem : intersection_of_isolating_cuts ] , there is @xmath683 with @xmath684 . since @xmath109 is an ideal , it holds @xmath685 . necessarily @xmath686 and @xmath687 . this is a contradiction . for distinct @xmath533}}$ ] let @xmath688 . then @xmath649 is the disjoint union of @xmath689 and @xmath690 ( as a set ) . thus , letting @xmath691 , we have @xmath692 . therefore our problem of enumerating all maximal minimizers of @xmath693 is reduced to the enumeration of all ideals of poset @xmath652 . this is a well - studied enumeration problem . one of the current best algorithms is squire s algorithm @xcite that enumerates all ideals of an @xmath3-element poset in amortized @xmath694 time per output . from the elementary pip for the minimizer set of potts @xmath0-submodular function @xmath436 , all maximal minimizers of @xmath10 can be enumerated in amortized @xmath694 time per output . the above poset @xmath652 may be viewed as a `` compact representation '' of maximal minimizers of potts @xmath0-submodular function @xmath10 . in a general elementary pip @xmath70 ( for the minimizer set of a general @xmath0-submodular function ) , such a compact representation is still possible if @xmath70 has a maximal consistent ideal @xmath637 satisfying the following property : * @xmath637 contains exactly one of @xmath291 and @xmath290 for each @xmath695 of the case ( ep2 - 1 ) . in this case , as in @xmath661 , there is a bijection between @xmath696 and @xmath646 . one can see that the pip @xmath697 has a simple structure similar to the above poset @xmath652 ( though it is not elementary ) . we developed an algorithm to enumerate consistent ideals of @xmath697 in @xmath12 time per output , and announced in the conference version of this paper @xcite that such a fast enumeration is possible for maximal consistent ideals of pip @xmath70 . however we found an elementary pip that having no maximal consistent ideal with the property ( p ) ; consider pip @xmath698 with @xmath699 , @xmath700 , @xmath701 , @xmath702 , @xmath703 , and @xmath704 . therefore ( * ? ? ? * theorem 14 ) is not true for such a pip . a _ @xmath0-submodular relaxation _ @xmath359 of a function @xmath705}}^n}{{\overline{\setr}}}$ ] is a @xmath0-submodular function on @xmath33 such that @xmath706 for all @xmath450}}^n { \left({\subseteq { s_k}^n}\right)}$ ] . yoshida @xcite investigated @xmath0-submodular relaxations as a key tool for designing efficient fpt algorithms . kolmogorov @xcite applied @xmath0-submodular relaxations to labeling problems on computer vision , which we describe below . a label assignment is a process of assigning a label to each pixel of a given image . for example , in the object extraction , each pixel is labeled as `` foreground '' or `` background '' . in stereo matching , the disparity of each pixel is computed from the given two photos taken from slightly different positions , and the pixel is labeled according to the estimated depth . we consider the labels to be numbered from 1 to @xmath0 . such a labeling problem is formulated as the problem of minimizing an _ energy function_. a potts energy function is simple but widely used energy function . however the exact minimization of a potts energy function is computationally intractable . gridchyn kolmogorov @xcite applied the @xmath0-submodular relaxation , that is , the energy function is relaxed to a @xmath0-submodular function by allowing some pixels to have 0 ( meaning `` non - labeled '' ) . the following property , called _ persistency _ @xcite , is the reason why they introduced the relaxation . [ thm : persistency ] let @xmath705}}^n}{{\overline{\setr}}}$ ] be a function and @xmath354 a @xmath0-submodular relaxation of @xmath1 . for every minimizer @xmath386 of @xmath359 , there exists a minimizer @xmath707}}^n$ ] of @xmath1 such that @xmath358 implies @xmath173 for each @xmath36}}$ ] . namely , each minimizer of @xmath359 gives us partial information about a minimizer of @xmath1 . an efficient algorithm for minimizing @xmath0-submodular relaxations of potts functions was also proposed in @xcite . hence we can obtain a partial labeling extensible to an optimal labeling , which we call a _ persistent labeling_. in section [ sec : potts ] we gave an efficient algorithm to construct the elementary pip representing all the minimizers of a potts @xmath0-submodular function . since minimizers that contain more nonzero elements have more information , we want to find a minimizer whose support is largest . in fact , such minimizers are precisely maximal minimizers . let @xmath107 be a @xmath50-closed set on @xmath33 . the supports of maximal elements in @xmath107 are the same . let @xmath134 be maximal and @xmath708 . for each @xmath36}}$ ] , it holds @xmath709 if @xmath710 and @xmath711 if @xmath712 . in particular , @xmath713 and @xmath714 hold . since @xmath163 is maximal , we obtain @xmath715 and @xmath716 . by changing the role of @xmath35 and @xmath163 , we also have @xmath717 . thus @xmath209 . from this lemma , it turns out that all maximal minimizers of @xmath359 have the same and largest amount of information about minimizers of @xmath1 . in labeling problem with potts energy , all maximal persistent labelings ( with respect to a @xmath0-submodular relaxation ) can be efficiently generated by the algorithm in section [ sec : enumeration ] . we implemented our algorithm on the stereo matching problem with potts energy function . this has an aspect of the replication of the experiment in @xcite , but we computed not only one of the persistent labelings but also its pip - representation . we used `` tsukuba '' and `` cones '' in the middlebury data @xcite as input images . [ [ problem - setting - and - formulation . ] ] problem setting and formulation . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we are given photo images @xmath56 and @xmath652 taken from left and right positions , respectively . the images @xmath56 and @xmath652 are @xmath718 arrays such that entries @xmath719}}$ ] and @xmath720}}$ ] are rgb vectors @xmath721 of the intensity at pixel @xmath722 , where each pixel is represented by a pair @xmath722 of its horizontal coordinate @xmath723 and vertical coordinate @xmath724 . the goal of the stereo matching problem is to assign to each pixel the `` disparity label '' @xmath725}}$ ] that represents the depth of the object on the pixel . we model this problem as a minimization of a potts energy function on diagonal grid graph @xmath430 , where @xmath364 is the set of pixels , and two pixels @xmath722 and @xmath726 have an edge in @xmath727 if and only if @xmath728 and @xmath729 . the first and the second term of are called `` data term '' and `` smoothness term '' @xcite , respectively . for each pixel @xmath579 , the data term @xmath438 measures how well the estimated disparity of pixel @xmath285 agrees with the pair of given images . we employed the traditional averaged ssd ( sum of squared difference ) costs as in @xcite : @xmath730 } } - { { r}{{\mathopen{}\mathclose\bgroup\left}[{x + d_\alpha , y}{\aftergroup\egroup\right}]}}}\right\rvert}^2 $ } \quad { \left({\alpha \in { { \left[{k}\right]}}}\right)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath731 is the @xmath732 window centered at @xmath733 ( i.e. , the set of pixels @xmath726 with @xmath734 and @xmath735 ) , @xmath736 is the 2-norm , @xmath737 is the disparity corresponding to the label @xmath189 . we simply set @xmath738 for each @xmath176}}$ ] . for each pair of adjacent pixels @xmath433 , the smoothness term increases the energy by @xmath434 if @xmath285 and @xmath286 have different labels . we set every @xmath434 to be the same value @xmath739 as in @xcite , and conducted experiments with @xmath740 and 20 to see the effect of @xmath739 . [ [ experimental - results . ] ] experimental results . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + and `` cones '' ( bottom row ) with @xmath741 and `` cones '' ( bottom row ) with @xmath741 and `` cones '' ( bottom row ) with @xmath741 and `` cones '' ( bottom row ) with @xmath741 and `` cones '' ( bottom row ) with @xmath741 and `` cones '' ( bottom row ) with @xmath741 figure [ fig : result_image ] and table [ tbl : result ] show the results of our experiment . the pixels labeled in the minimum persistent labeling are colored in gray of the brightness corresponding to each label . the blue pixels are unlabeled even in maximal persistent labelings . the red pixels are the difference between the minimum persistent labeling and maximal ones , i.e. , the pixel was labeled in ( any of ) maximal persistent labelings but not in the minimum one . we can observe that there are few red pixels as mentioned in @xcite , and they are mainly located on the boundary of two regions with different labels . a possible reason is the following : consider a simple 1-dimensional case where a pixel @xmath285 is adjacent only to pixels @xmath286 and @xmath742 . let @xmath386 be the minimum persistent labeling and assume @xmath743 . then the increment of the energy is the same ( @xmath744 ) even if @xmath37 is set to any of @xmath745 . therefore the pixel @xmath285 will be red if @xmath746 , and thus we think that this will occur in boundaries more frequently than inside of regions . with regard to the effect of @xmath739 , the larger @xmath739 decreases the percentages of gray and red pixels on both tsukuba and cones , and increases the blue pixels to the contrary . this result agrees with the experiments in @xcite . we consider that this is due to the fact that the value of each @xmath747 is moderately lower in @xmath451 since @xmath747 is the average of the minimum and the second minimum values of @xmath438 as described in section [ sec : potts ] . hence if @xmath739 is large , the energy will be lower just by letting all @xmath748 than by tuning each @xmath37 finely according to the values of the corresponding data term @xmath451 . .experimental result [ cols="<,>,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tbl : result ] [ [ the - structure - of - the - pip . ] ] the structure of the pip . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ] figure [ fig : result_pip ] shows the pip - representation for the partial labelings on tsukuba with @xmath740 . the pip consists of many small connected pips , which correspond to each of connected red regions in figure [ fig : result_image ] . thus we can easily calculate the number of maximal persistent labelings by multiplying the number of maximal consistent ideals of each connected pip ( notice that an ideal of the pip is maximal and consistent if and only if it contains all elements having no inconsistent pair and one element of each minimally inconsistent pairs ) . the right most column of table [ tbl : result ] shows the number of maximal persistent labelings in each experiment . we discovered the fact that there are plenty of maximal persistent labelings even though the percentages of red pixels are little . we thank kazuo murota for helpful comments . this work was partially supported by jsps kakenhi grant numbers 25280004 , 26330023 , 26280004 , and by jst , erato , kawarabayashi large graph project . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: string duality is a recently discovered symmetry of string theory . string theory itself is over twenty - five years old , and has been under intensive development since 1984 as the leading candidate for a unified theory of particle physics and gravity . the reason that some of its symmetry has been overlooked until now is simple , and important : string duality is not manifest in the weak - coupling perturbation expansion by which the theory is usually studied , but it is a property of the exact theory . as a result , string duality gives information about the behavior of string theory at strong coupling . in a period of a little over a year , we have gone from near - complete ignorance of the behavior of strongly - coupled strings to a rather detailed understanding of the intricate dynamics which occurs , at least in vacua having enough supersymmetry , and the subject continues to develop at a rapid pace . the central idea of string duality is that the strongly coupled limit of any string theory is equivalent to the weakly coupled limit of some other theory . all string theories are connected in this way , as well as something new and surprising : an eleven - dimensional theory known provisionally as ` m - theory . ' besides the ordinary vibrating strings which are the basic quanta of string theory , the multiplets of string duality include smooth classical objects ( solitons ) , singular classical objects ( black holes ) , and a new type of topological defect which is unique to string theory ( d - branes ) . with the improved understanding of string dynamics it has become possible to address one of the long - standing problems of quantum gravity to count the number of states of certain black holes in a controlled way , giving for the first time a statistical mechanical interpretation to the bekenstein - hawking entropy . beyond these specific results , string duality has greatly changed the way string theorists think about the fundamental principles of the theory . many ideas which once seemed to be central are now seen as technicalities , while other ideas which were neglected are now central . in this colloquium i would like to try to explain these developments and to put them in the context of the search for the unified theory of particle physics and gravity . i will use units in which @xmath0 . the gravitational coupling @xmath1 is then a length - squared , @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the planck length , @xmath4 cm . this is the natural length scale for the effects of quantum gravity to become important and so for the unification of gravity with the other interactions . it is far shorter than the length scales which can be probed directly ; the corresponding energy scale is @xmath5 far beyond the reach of accelerators . thus , to construct a unified theory one must rely heavily on theoretical reasoning such as the internal consistency of the theory , and any experimental tests will be indirect . fortunately , consistency is a very restrictive guide . general relativity is a nonrenormalizable field theory , meaning that its quantum mechanical perturbation theory has uncontrollable divergences . to see the significance of this , let us recall the four - fermi theory of the weak interaction . the weak interaction was originally described as an interaction of four fermionic fields at a spacetime point as depicted in figure 1a . the weak coupling constant @xmath6 also has units of length - squared , or inverse energy - squared . in a process with a characteristic energy @xmath7 the effective dimensionless coupling is then @xmath8 . it follows that at sufficiently high energy the coupling becomes arbitrarily strong , and this also implies divergences in the perturbation theory . a second order weak amplitude is dimensionally of the form @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the energy of the virtual state in the second order process , and this diverges at large energy . in position space the divergence comes when the two weak interactions occur at the same spacetime point ( high energy = short distance ) . the divergences become worse at each higher order of perturbation theory and so can not be controlled even with renormalization . the natural interpretation of such divergences is that the theory one is working with is only valid up to some energy scale , beyond which new physics appears . the new physics should have the effect of smearing out the interaction in spacetime and so soften the high energy behavior . one might imagine that this could be done in many ways , but in fact the combined constraints of lorentz invariance and causality are very restrictive . this is because lorentz invariance requires that if the interaction is spread out in space it is also spread out in time . in fact , for the weak interaction there is only one known way to solve the short - distance problem . this is depicted in figure 1b , where the four - fermi interaction is resolved into the exchange of a vector boson . moreover , this vector boson must be of a very specific kind , coming from a spontaneously broken gauge invariance . this is the only known solution , and in fact it is the one that nature chooses . for gravity the discussion is much the same . the gravitational interaction is depicted in figure 2a . as we have noted already , the gravitational coupling @xmath1 has units of length - squared and so the dimensionless coupling is @xmath11 . this grows large at high energy and signifies a nonrenormalizable perturbation theory . again the natural suspicion is that short - distance physics smears out the interaction , and again there is only one known way to do this , shown in figure 2b . it involves a bigger step than in the case of the weak interaction : it requires that at the planck length the graviton and other particles turn out to be not points but one - dimensional objects , loops of ` string . ' it is certainly not obvious that this should be the right thing to do , but if one tries to make a consistent lorentz - invariant quantum theory of one - dimensional objects , one finds that it is possible but that the theory is highly constrained . in particular , one of the states of the string is massless and has spin two . consistency requires that such a particle be a graviton , that its long - wavelength interactions be described by general relativity , and indeed this is what is found from the sum - over - histories depicted in figure 2b ( yoneya , 1974 ; scherk and schwarz , 1974 , 1975 ) . in a sense string theory predicts gravity , in that every consistent string theory includes general relativity , even though the theory initially seems to be formulated in flat space . further , calculation of the quantum corrections to amplitudes shows that they are finite . it is also not obvious why _ only _ this idea should work . many others have been tried without success . one natural question is , why one - dimensional objects and not two - dimensional or higher ? for this at least there is a simple answer . extended objects have an infinite number of internal degrees of freedom ( the fourier modes describing their shape ) . spreading out point particles into extended objects softens the spacetime divergences but introduces potential new divergences from the internal degrees of freedom . the latter grow worse as the dimension of the object increases , and the one - dimensional case is the only one for which both the spacetime and internal behavior is under control . it could be that we suffer from a failure of imagination , and that there are other solutions . however , we see from the example of the weak interaction that if we can find even one solution to a short - distance problem we should take it very seriously and see where it leads . the result here is quite striking . besides the graviton , other states of the string with different internal oscillators excited behave as gauge bosons ( neveu and scherk , 1972 ) , and yet others are fermions ( ramond , 1971 ) . in fact , string theory automatically incorporates ( and in some ways generalizes ) three earlier ideas for explaining the patterns in the standard model , namely grand unification , supersymmetry ( gliozzi , scherk and olive , 1977 ) , and kaluza - klein theory . some of the simplest string theories , the calabi - yau models , closely resemble unified versions of the supersymmetric standard model . as a particle physicist i usually emphasize these particle physics motivations for string theory , but many of those educated in general relativity and in mathematics find string theory compelling for reasons that are not entirely the same . from newton s gravity to einstein s , from quantum mechanics to non - abelian gauge theory , new physical theories have often required new mathematics , or least mathematics that had not previously been used in physics . if one searches for higher symmetries or other more mathematical structures that might be useful in physics , one finds many connections to string theory . one reason i emphasize this now is that in the recent work on string duality , all of these different points of view have had a role to play . it is worthwhile to note that these three kinds of motivation solving the divergence problem , the connection with geometry , and explaining the broad patterns in the standard model , were also present in the weak interaction . weinberg ( 1980 ) emphasized the divergence problem as i have done . salam ( 1980 ) was more guided by the idea that non - abelian gauge theory was a beautiful structure that should be incorporated in physics . experiment gave no direct indication that the weak interaction was anything but the pointlike interaction of figure 1a , and no direct clue as to the new physics that smears it out , just as today it gives no direct indication of what lies beyond the standard model . but it did show certain broad patterns universality and the @xmath12 structure , which were telltale signs of a gauge interaction . it appears that nature is kind to us , in providing many trails to a correct theory . the key question is , how do we go from explaining broad patterns to making precise predictions ? to understand the situation , it is useful to look again to history , to the state of quantum field theory in the early 60 s . at that time there was a good technical control of the weak - coupling perturbation theory , the feynman graph expansion , but little else . important dynamical ideas were missing , such as the higgs mechanism , dynamical symmetry breaking , and confinement . these have largely to do with the fact that the vacuum , the ground state of quantum field theory , is generally a more interesting and less symmetric object than one might naively expect from the hamiltonian . without understanding these ideas one can not make sense of the standard model : it would seem to predict fractionally charged particles and a long - ranged force coupled to isospin . beyond these dynamical ideas , it remained to discover the defining principle of the theory that one should organize the physics not _ graph by graph _ but rather _ length scale by length scale _ with the shortest distances first . this realization not only made it possible to define the theory beyond perturbation theory , but also provided a framework for understanding the dynamics , both analytically and numerically . the situation is similar in string theory . there has been a good technical control of the perturbation theory , but little else , at least up until the recent developments . the need to understand the dynamics is even more acute than in the case of the standard model for two reasons . the first is that because the planck energy is so large , there is no hope to explore a ` partonic ' regime where the stringy behavior is directly visible rather , we see only the extreme low energy limit of string theory , filtered through all the dynamics at intervening scales . the second reason has to do with one of the very attractive features of string theory , that it has no free dimensionless parameters at all . instead it has , in perturbation theory , many degenerate ground states parameterized by the values of various scalar fields ( moduli ) . the parameters of the standard model come ultimately from the values of these scalars , so it is necessary to understand the dynamics which selects one of the many ground states . string theory contains quantum field theory as its low energy limit , so all of the familiar dynamics of the latter is still present , but because string theory has many more degrees of freedom it is likely to have interesting new dynamics of its own . beyond this , the central defining principle of string theory is not known . we are trying to answer the question ` what is string theory ? ' , just as wilson and others addressed the question ` what is field theory ? ' . the various properties that make string theory an attractive unifying idea also imply that the theory exists as something more than an asymptotic weak - coupling expansion . so there is good reason to expect that we will find a central principle as powerful as that in field theory , which will again enable us to better understand the dynamics . with this background i can summarize what has been learned from string duality . we have learned a number of new dynamical ideas though certainly not yet all we need . we have not yet found the central principle but we have many new clues , some of which are surprising and have taken us in unexpected directions . string duality involves an interplay of many different ideas from quantum field theory and string theory . in this part i would like to explain some of the central principles . here are two ways to think about the meaning of the coupling constant @xmath13 of a quantum field theory . the first is in terms of the weak - coupling perturbation expansion . the amplitude @xmath14 for any process can be expanded @xmath15 where @xmath13 is the amplitude for a single interaction to occur . , or only odd , contribute to a given amplitude . ] the coefficient @xmath16 is given by the sum over feynman graphs with @xmath17 interaction vertices . interpreted with sufficient care this is an asymptotic series , meaning that it gives an approximation of any desired accuracy by taking @xmath13 to be sufficiently small . thus it is also a good qualitative guide to the small-@xmath13 physics . but for @xmath13 of order @xmath18 or larger it is of limited usefulness and can miss important aspects of the physics . another way to think about the meaning of @xmath13 is in terms of the quantum fluctuation of the fields . for the purpose of this discussion it is useful to keep explicit factors of @xmath19 ; we will return to @xmath20 units after section 3.2 . when @xmath13 is small the fluctuations are small and their equations of motion can be approximated by linear equations in other words , small @xmath13 is approximately free field theory . for larger @xmath13 the fluctuations of the fields , and the nonlinearities , become larger . and the size of the quantum fluctuations is in terms of the path integral , the sum over field histories weighted by @xmath21 with @xmath22 the classical action . the fields can be rescaled in such a way that @xmath13 appears in the action only as an overall factor @xmath23 , so @xmath13 and @xmath19 appear only in the combination @xmath24 . it is then clear that small @xmath13 and small @xmath19 are equivalent with this scaling of the fields . to relate this to the familiar example of qed , one must note that the electric charges of individual quanta are related to the charge in the classical field action by @xmath25 , so the familiar expansion parameter @xmath26 is indeed @xmath27 . ] in qcd , for example , the coupling is very strong at long distance , and correspondingly the color magnetic fields undergo large fluctuations in the vacuum this is the source of confinement . weak / strong duality ( in field theory or string theory ) means that as the string coupling @xmath13 becomes large , one can find new ` dual ' fields whose fluctuations become _ small_they are characterized by a new coupling @xmath28 which is something like @xmath29 . this is similar to a fourier transform , where a function which becomes spread out in position space can become very narrow in momentum space . here though , the fourier transform is in a complicated nonlinear field space . string theory includes gravity , and so one of the fields is the spacetime metric . one might therefore have expected strongly coupled string theory to have new and very exotic physics , including large fluctuations of the spacetime geometry and all other fields . this might correspond to some sort of confined phase of gravity . one of the surprises of string duality is that this is not so . as @xmath30 , @xmath31 and so the metric of the dual theory behaves more and more classically . it is quite likely that in nature the string coupling is close to 1 rather than to 0 or @xmath32 , so that string duality does not allow one to relate the theory directly to a weakly coupled theory in which one can calculate accurately . but having an understanding of both limits , large and small coupling , constrains the kinds of qualitative physics that can occur at intermediate coupling . even more important , duality gives a great deal of information about the exact theory and its symmetries , information that is not contained in the perturbation expansion , and so new clues to the answer to ` what is string theory ? ' . another perspective on the meaning of duality starts with maxwell s equations , @xmath33 the symmetry between @xmath34 and @xmath35 in these equations is striking . if one ignores the sources , or adds magnetic sources , the equations are invariant under @xmath36 , @xmath37 . this curious fact was made more interesting by dirac s study ( 1931 ) of the quantum mechanics of a charge moving in a magnetic monopole field . he found that the wavefunction could be consistently defined only if the electric charge @xmath38 and magnetic charge @xmath39 satisfy a quantization condition @xmath40 note that if a monopole of some charge @xmath39 exists , then all electric charges must be multiples of the unit @xmath41 . this would ` explain ' why the magnitudes of the electron and proton charges should be _ exactly _ equal , a fact known to hold to one part in @xmath42 . the subject took another step forward when t hooft ( 1974 ) and polyakov ( 1974 ) showed that in any grand unified theory , magnetic monopoles actually do exist . they are classical solutions , with a nonsingular core whose size is set by the scale of spontaneous symmetry breaking . at weak coupling , the electrically and magnetically charged objects look very different . the electrically charged objects are weakly coupled and have pointlike interactions . the magnetically charged objects are strongly coupled by the dirac condition ( [ dirac ] ) , the magnetic fine structure constant @xmath43 is roughly the reciprocal of the usual one and as noted above they have cores of finite size . montonen and olive ( 1977 ) were led by various evidence to conjecture that at strong coupling the situation would be reversed : the electrically charged objects would be strongly coupled and have nonsingular cores , while the magnetically charged objects would become weakly coupled and pointlike . the strongly coupled theory would be equivalent to weakly coupled theory in which the basic quanta carried magnetic rather than electric charges . in subsequent work this conjecture was refined ( witten and olive , 1978 ; osborn , 1979 ) . it was argued to hold specifically in supersymmetric gauge theories , in particular @xmath44 theories ( @xmath45 is the number of conserved supersymmetries ) . relating this discussion to the previous section , the weakly coupled dual fields described there would be the fields corresponding to the magnetic quanta . these conjectures were greeted with wide skepticism because the evidence for them was rather circumstantial , while attempts to construct the dual fields directly in terms of the original ones did not succeed . this skepticism is now largely gone , not because the dual fields have been found ( they have not ) , but because of a substantial strengthening of the circumstantial evidence . this evidence , based on supersymmetry , will be described in the next section . the reader should notice that this whole section has been concerned with duality in field theory , not string theory . the extension to string theory will be discussed in section 3.5 . to test the duality conjectures we need to be able to say something about the physics of the strongly coupled theories . the methods available for this are very limited , but in supersymmetric theories it is possible . supersymmetry is of interest for a number of reasons . it is likely that it is associated with the breaking of the electroweak symmetry . if so , it should be discovered by the lhc if not before , and it is the one piece of new physics associated with string theory that might be accessible at accelerators . beyond this , it is an appealing mathematical structure that extends general coordinate invariance and unifies fermions and bosons . any consistent string theory must have supersymmetry , at least at the planck scale . finally , supersymmetric field theories , and string theories with unbroken supersymmetry below the planck scale , have various nice properties that make them easier to study . it is difficult to give an intuitive picture of supersymmetry . one way to think about it is that in addition to the usual spacetime dimensions , whose coordinates are real numbers @xmath46 ( and so their multiplication commutes ) , there are additional ` fermionic ' coordinates @xmath47 which anticommute , @xmath48 . these extra dimensions have no size ; the anticommuting property means that they are essentially infinitesimal . one can make sensible field theories on this space . in fact , they can be thought of as quantum field theories on ordinary spacetime but with fields that have both fermionic and bosonic components , with a symmetry relating the masses and charges of the particles with different statistics . to see why supersymmetry is valuable in studying strong coupling we need the algebra of the quantum mechanical generators of the symmetry . for an ordinary internal symmetry , such as baryon number , the generator @xmath49 commutes with the hamiltonian @xmath50 , @xmath51 = 0.\ ] ] this is the definition of a symmetry . for supersymmetry , with generator @xmath52 , there is an additional relation ( see , for example , haag , lopuszansky , and sohnius , 1975 ) @xmath53 = 0 \qquad \{q , q\ } = h + g. \label{susy}\ ] ] in the second , anticommutation , relation , both the hamiltonian and various internal generators appear on the right - hand side . for clarity we have omitted the indices which would distinguish the various supersymmetry and internal symmetry generators and various associated constants , so this anticommutation relation is schematic . the anticommutation relation has the hamiltonian on the right - hand side , and as a result supersymmetry gives much more information about the dynamics than ordinary internal symmetries . to see one example of this ( witten and olive , 1978 ) , consider a one - particle state @xmath54 which has the special property that is invariant under part of the supersymmetry algebra ; in other words , @xmath55 for some of the @xmath52 s . this is known as a _ bogomolnyi - prasad - sommerfeld ( bps ) state_. take the expectation value of the anticommutator in eq . ( [ susy ] ) , @xmath56 for those @xmath52 s which annihilate @xmath57 , the left hand side is zero . the two terms on the right are just the mass of the particle and its @xmath49-charge . thus , the mass of any bps particle is determined entirely by its charge . this is a consequence of symmetry and does not depend on dynamics at all ; in particular it remains true even if the coupling is large . further analysis puts strong constraints on the interactions and on the phase diagram . for example , any bps state with zero charge has zero energy . the anticommutation relations imply that no other state can have lower energy , so any such state will be the ground state . a typical supersymmetric theory has many such states , which are characterized by the expectation values of some scalar fields . all these states must be degenerate . this is similar to spontaneous symmetry breaking , but with spontaneous symmetry breaking the degenerate vacua all have the same physics while here they are physically inequivalent they are not related to one another directly by any symmetry , rather the degeneracy follows indirectly from the bps argument . the scalar fields which label these vacua , known as moduli , must be massless for the same reason that goldstone bosons are massless . the low energy physics , the phase structure , is determined by the physics of the moduli , which is strongly constrained by supersymmetry . applying these methods to test the @xmath44 duality conjecture , one first finds that the bps mass formula is duality symmetric . that is , electrically charged bps states at coupling @xmath13 have the same masses as magnetically charged states at coupling @xmath29 . secondly , one can compare the degeneracies of bps states with different charges and spins . the degeneracy of magnetic monopoles can be determined by semiclassical methods when @xmath13 is small . in @xmath44 theories there can not be a phase transition as the coupling is varied and the supersymmetry algebra prevents the number of bps states from changing , so this also determines the degeneracy at strong coupling . for @xmath44 theories it is the same as that of the electrically charged states in the dual theory . as another test , the effective low energy physics of the moduli is duality invariant . this evidence was widely regarded as unconvincing , an accidental consequence of supersymmetry , until seiberg ( 1994 ) and others began to apply these methods systematically to determine the phase structures of theories with less supersymmetry , @xmath58 and @xmath59 . the arguments in these cases are more intricate , the physics is richer , and there are more consistency checks . many more examples of duality were found ( reviewed in seiberg , 1995 , and intriligator and seiberg , 1995 ) , as well as convincing evidence for various associated phenomena such as composite gauge bosons . , the duality holds at all energies . in many others it is holds only in the low energy theory . ] duality in supersymmetric gauge theory is now well - established . it is important to note , though , that the dual fields still have not been constructed . it is believed that to make duality manifest one may need a new formulation of these quantum field theories , something more intrinsically quantum - mechanical than the path integral over classical histories . it is also suspected that an understanding of the dualities in field theory will ultimately come from string theory . we will need one more idea in order to fully understand string duality . this is that spacetime may have more than four dimensions . the three spatial dimensions we see are expanding , and once were highly curved . it is a logical possibility that there are other dimensions which did not expand but remain small and highly curved . moreover , this is an attractive idea for a number of reasons . a good model for physics in such a spacetime is a waveguide , a cavity which has some finite cross section in the @xmath60-@xmath61 plane and is very long in the @xmath62 dimension . seen from far away , or with low resolution , this looks one - dimensional . an infinite number of different fields ( functions of @xmath62 and @xmath63 ) with different dispersion relations ( masses ) move along the waveguide . seen up close , the three - dimensional structure is evident and one sees that there is only one field , the electromagnetic field , and that the different dispersion relations come from modes with different @xmath60 , @xmath61 dependence . physics is much the same in a spacetime with three large spatial dimensions and additional ones which are small and compact . in nature , the additional dimensions would be quite small , close to the planck scale , so we would have seen only the very lowest modes . one reason this is attractive is that it unifies gravitational and gauge interactions . depending on whether its polarization is aligned along the long or compact directions , a higher - dimensional graviton can look like a graviton , photon , or scalar from the lower - dimensional point of view . this is the kaluza - klein mechanism . in addition , the dirac equation on such a space typically gives rise to multiple copies of the same set of quantum numbers ( that is , generations ) in the lower - dimensional spectrum . consistent weakly - coupled string theories necessarily live in ten spacetime dimensions . the origin of this condition is difficult to explain in simple terms , but it can be understood in various ways . calculation of quantum effects shows that they spoil essential symmetries unless the dimension is ten . also , the properties of fermions depend in an essential way on the number of dimensions and ten is special here for a number of reasons related to supersymmetry . for example , ten is the highest dimension in which the number of states of a massless vector ( eight : the spacetime dimension minus the timelike and longitudinal polarizations ) can be equal to the number of states of a massless fermion in higher dimensions the spinor representations are too large . the field equations of ten - dimensional string theory are consistent with four - dimensional physics that looks very much like what we have . some of the simplest solutions give rise to the same gauge groups and matter representations found in grand unification ( candelas , horowitz , strominger , and witten , 1985 ) . it is notable that the four - dimensional gauge couplings can be chiral , meaning that the right- and left - handed fermions have different gauge interactions . this was impossible for a number of previously considered unifying ideas including standard kaluza - klein theory ( witten , 1981 ) . for future reference it is useful to look at a simple example . this is a massless scalar field in five spacetime dimensions , with one dimension periodic with period @xmath64 . let @xmath46 with @xmath65 be the coordinates for the large dimensions , and @xmath66 be the periodic coordinate ; the index @xmath67 runs over all five values . the wave equation is @xmath68 as in the waveguide , separate variables and expand the @xmath66 dependence in a complete set of modes , @xmath69 then the @xmath17th mode satisfies @xmath70 which is the klein - gordon equation for a scalar field of mass @xmath71 . at low energies only the @xmath72 mode is detectable , but at energies above @xmath73 one sees a characteristic infinite tower of states . for this simple geometry the states are spaced evenly in mass . more complicated compact spaces would of course give a more complicated spectrum , but the average density of states depends only on the number of additional dimensions . from another point of view , consider how the spectrum behaves as @xmath74 : the infinite tower comes down in mass and forms the continuum characteristic of a noncompact dimension . string theory includes gauge theory . weak / strong duality in gauge theory is thus necessary if the same is to be true in string theory , but it is not sufficient . after the work of seiberg , it was still possible that duality was a property only of the low energy limit of string theory , not of the full massive spectrum . there were a number of early duality conjectures in string theory . a partial list includes the self - duality of @xmath58 heterotic string theories in four dimensions ( font , ibanez , lust , and quevedo , 1990 ) , self - duality of @xmath44 heterotic strings in four dimensions ( font , ibanez , lust , and quevedo , 1990 ; sen , 1994 ) , self - duality of the heterotic string in six dimensions ( duff,1995 ) , duality of certain string theories with theories of five - dimensional objects ( five - branes ) in ten dimensions ( duff , 1988 ; strominger , 1990 ) , and a relation not specifically duality of other string theories in ten dimensions to theories of membranes ( two - branes ) in eleven dimensions ( duff , howe , inami , and stelle , 1987 ) . these conjectures did not attract broad attention , due to their rather scattered nature and the limited evidence for any of them . the subject took a major step forward with the papers of hull and townsend ( 1995 ) , townsend ( 1995 ) , and witten ( 1995a ) . these authors proposed a nearly complete set of duals for all known string theories with at least @xmath44 supersymmetry . these new proposals elevated duality from a set of isolated conjectures to a general principle applying to any string theory in any dimension . the structure is quite rigid for each string theory the spectrum and symmetries determine a unique candidate for its dual , and the entire pattern fits together in an intricate way as dimensions are compactified and decompactified . some of the earlier conjectures , such as the @xmath44 conjecture , were incorporated whole , while others were incorporated in a modified or limited form ; we will return to the membrane idea in section 4.2 . these systematic conjectures made possible many new tests , and evidence for weak / strong duality in string theory accumulated rapidly . this led also to the discovery of various new dynamical ideas , some of which will be described in part 4 . there is now an integrated picture of the strongly coupled dynamics , at least for string theories with enough supersymmetry , and the methods are being extended to theories with less supersymmetry . figure 3 is a schematic picture of the space of string vacua . the parameters are the string coupling and the sizes and shapes of the compact dimensions ; in string theory these are not fixed but are determined by the expectation values of the moduli . over most of the space , the string coupling @xmath13 is of order 1 . in various limits , there is an effective description in terms of one or another weakly coupled string theory . the different string theories are characterized by the number and kind of supersymmetries and by the world - sheet topologies allowed ( oriented vs. unoriented and closed vs. open ) . in some limits new theories are encountered ; the most interesting of these , m - theory , will be described in section 4.1 . figure 3 is actually an oversimplification , in that the different limits are characterized not only by different string theories but by different topologies for the compact dimensions . it has been known for some time that even in weakly coupled string theory spacetime topology is not invariant ( aspinwall , greene , and morrison , 1993 ) , and string duality has provided many more examples ( greene , morrison , and strominger , 1995 ) . also , a more accurate picture would have many pieces resembling figure 3 , touching one another at points or along curves . in field theory the duality multiplets included the elementary quanta plus smooth classical configurations ( magnetic monopoles ) . the string duality multiplets include these ( though the elementary quanta are now loops rather than points ) , plus singular classical configurations ( black holes ) and also a new type of object unique to string theory , the d - brane . d - branes are topological defects on which the ends of a string can be trapped , as shown in figure 4 . they can be pointlike , one - dimensional , two - dimensional , and so on . these were discovered in the study of perturbative dualities of string theories , dualities that relate different weakly coupled theories ( dai , leigh , and polchinski , 1989 ; polchinski , chaudhuri , and johnson , 1996 ) . their relevance to weak / strong duality was noticed more recently ( polchinski , 1995 ) . let me illustrate one of the methods by which the strongly coupled limits are determined . in addition to the fundamental strings , various string theories have in their spectra one - dimensional objects which are either smooth solitons or d - branes . at weak coupling these are much heavier than the fundamental strings , but at strong coupling they are much lighter ( again this is guaranteed by the bps formula ) . in this limit it is natural to reinterpret the theory with the soliton or d - brane being the fundamental string . which string theory one gets depends on the degrees of freedom of the object , which can be determined by a weak - coupling calculation . this has been applied to determine , or confirm , the strongly coupled limits of various string theories ( sen , 1995a ; harvey and strominger , 1995 ; dabholkar , 1995 ; hull , 1995 ; schwarz , 1995 ; witten , 1996a ; polchinski and witten , 1996 ) . i have described the principal methods and general results of string duality . in this final part i would like to focus on some specific highlights , some of the discoveries that have most greatly changed our understanding . as described in section 3.4 , weakly coupled string theory requires specifically ten dimensions . one of the striking consequences of string duality is the existence of an eleventh dimension , not visible in weakly coupled string theory . how does one discover a new dimension ? the experimental signature was discussed in section 3.4 , a tower of new states above the energy @xmath73 . the theoretical signature is the same . a certain string theory , the iia theory in ten dimensions , has zero - dimensional d - branes , d - particles . these are heavy , with a mass @xmath75 at weak coupling ( @xmath76 is the string mass scale ) . for a pair of d - particles , the supersymmetric bound state problem can be solved and there is a single bound state with mass @xmath77 ( witten , 1996a ; sen , 1995b ) . similarly , @xmath17 d - particles have a single bound state of mass @xmath78 . this bound state spectrum was actually inferred from lower - dimensional duality symmetries before the explicit construction of the bound states . at strong coupling all of these become light , and in the @xmath79 limit form a continuum . we have seen just such a spectrum before , in section 3.4 . it is the signature of a new , eleventh , dimension with @xmath80 ( townsend , 1995 , witten , 1995a ) . this makes it clear why this dimension is invisible in string perturbation theory : the latter is an expansion in @xmath81 , so an expansion around the zero - radius limit . eleven dimensions is an interesting number . this is the maximum in which supersymmetry is possible beyond eleven the massless multiplets would contain spins higher than two , something which seems to be impossible in a consistent theory . eleven - dimensional supergravity is therefore the most symmetric theory based on supersymmetry ( cremmer , julia , and scherk , 1978 ) , and was considered as a possible unifying idea before string theory . the principal problems were that it is nonrenormalizable and that it is not possible to obtain a chiral spectrum . string theorists generally regarded eleven - dimensional supergravity as an irrelevant curiosity because of its difficulties and because strings seemed to live in ten , though some supergravity experts retained an interest in the theory because of its high degree of symmetry . now it develops that strings have an eleven - dimensional limit whose low energy physics is determined by symmetry considerations to be eleven - dimensional supergravity and whose short distance physics is not understood . this has been given the provisional name ` m - theory . ' the following exercise gives an interesting insight into m - theory . consider a long iia string in ten dimensions , shown in figure 5a . follow this state as the coupling is increased . we now know that a new orthogonal dimension will appear , but there are two possibilities for the form of the resulting state : in eleven dimensions it could look like a string as in figure 5b , or it could turn out to be a membrane wrapped around the eleventh dimension as shown in figure 5c . the answer can be determined in various ways from the conserved charges carries by the various objects , from the scaling of the string tension with coupling , from symmetry and it is figure 5c , the wrapped membrane . this is a puzzle . it seems to say that string theory is really the quantum mechanics of membranes , but in section 2.1 we have said that theories of fundamental membranes do not seem to exist . it is possible that the problems of quantizing membranes will be overcome and string theory will become membrane theory this was one of the origins of the name m - theory . it is likely , though , that the resolution lies in a different direction , that strings and membranes will turn out to be composites of something else . this has long been suspected in the case of string theory . some of the reasons for this are reviewed in polchinski ( 1994 ) . they include the general lack of success of string field theory and the fact that string perturbation theory diverges more rapidly than in field theory ( shenker , 1991 ) . string duality seems to give further support for this . in figure 3 , asymptotic _ behaviors in various limits are generated by different string theories , but there is no sign that the string descriptions do more than this . sums over string or membrane world - sheets are directly analogous to the feynman graph expansion and so are intrinsically perturbative . as for duality in field theory , we need a more quantum - mechanical description , one in which @xmath19 is not a free parameter ( witten , 1996c ) . incidentally , the membrane can also be oriented perpendicular to the eleventh dimension , so that in ten dimensions it still looks like a membrane . in string theory it appears as a d - brane . from the eleven - dimensional point of view one sees a symmetry in which a @xmath82 rotation takes the eleventh dimension into one of the others . from the string theory point of view this is a nonperturbative symmetry , mixing radii and couplings and relating strings to d - branes . in this section i would like to explain how all this business of extra dimensions might enter into an important piece of physics , the unification of the couplings . figure 6a shows the three gauge couplings and the dimensionless gravitational coupling @xmath83 as a function of energy . the logarithmic running of the gauge couplings is familiar ( amaldi , de boer , and furstenau , 1991 ) , as is the fact that they meet within experimental errors in the minimal supersymmetric model . it is also striking that the gravitational coupling nearly meets the other three , missing by a little over one order of magnitude out of fourteen.s and other factors reduces this to a factor of 20 ( kaplunovsky , 1988 ) . ] this is a near miss , less than ten percent in scale , but it is larger than the experimental error and so must be understood . there are many ways that the four couplings might turn out to unify . additional particles at an intermediate scale would change the running of the gauge couplings and can cause them to meet at a higher energy . enough extra states near the unification scale can have the same effect . or , the three gauge couplings may actually unify at the lower energy and a grand unified field theory with a single gauge coupling describe the physics from there until the string scale . all of these ideas modify the behavior of the gauge couplings . since the gauge couplings already meet , it would seem more economical to find instead a mechanism to change the running of the gravitational coupling . but this seems impossible because the running of the gauge coupling is just dimensional , as @xmath84 ; gravity is still classical at these scales . it is interesting to consider the effect of a new dimension below the unification scale . this changes the dimensional analysis . both the gauge and gravitational couplings grow more rapidly as shown in figure 6b , but they do not meet any sooner . in the @xmath85 heterotic string , the strong coupling limit leads to a new dimension which is slightly different from that considered before . instead of being periodic , a circle , it is a segment ( horava and witten , 1996 ) . the gauge fields and matter live at the endpoints only , while gravity propagates in the bulk . suppose that a fifth dimension of this type exists below the unification scale . that is , spacetime is a narrow five - dimensional layer bounded by four - dimensional walls . since the gauge fields and matter live in the walls , the evolution of the gauge couplings is the same as in four dimensions , but since gravity propagates in the full five dimensions the gravitational coupling behaves as in figure 6b . the result is shown in figure 6c : for a fifth dimension of appropriate size , the kink in the gravitational coupling makes it meet the others at the unification scale ( witten , 1996b ) . this is no more predictive than the idea of a unified theory : it adds one new parameter , the size of the fifth dimension . nevertheless it is an economical solution to the problem of the unification of all couplings , as likely to be true as any other . with only the data of the four couplings , there is not enough to distinguish among the possibilities . if supersymmetry is found and the masses of the superpartners measured with precision , many new renormalization group analyses become possible and it may be possible to determine the physics at the unification scale . local symmetries gauge invariance and coordinate invariance are a key ingredient in physics , appearing in the strong , weak , electromagnetic , and gravitational interactions . yet as has often been noted , these are not really symmetries in the usual sense . rather , they are _ redundancies _ : different vector potentials or coordinate systems describe the same physical state . why redundancy should be so important is puzzling , but it seems to be , and most attempts to unify are based on embedding the local symmetries at low energy into larger groups such as @xmath86 . in weakly coupled four dimensional theories , the size of the gauge group can only get larger at higher energies . there have been various arguments made that at strong coupling the reverse could be true , but convincing examples have only come with the understanding of strongly coupled dynamics in supersymmetric gauge and string theories . there are now many examples of composite gauge fields in the low energy theory , gauge fields not among the original short - distance fields ( intriligator and seiberg , 1995 ) . the interpretation of gauge symmetry is reversed : gauge symmetry is ubiquitous not because it is present in the underlying ultraviolet theory , but because it is infrared stable . that is , it is one of the few kinds of interesting long - distance dynamics which is _ natural _ , which does nt disappear when small changes are made in the short - distance parameters . in the early 1970 s it was found that classical black holes obey laws directly analogous to the laws of thermodynamics . this analogy was made sharper by hawking s discovery ( 1975 ) that black holes radiate as black bodies at the corresponding temperature . under this analogy , the entropy of a black hole ( the bekenstein - hawking entropy ) is the area of its horizon divided by @xmath87 . it has long been a goal to find a statistical mechanical theory associated with this thermodynamics , and in particular to associate the entropy with the density of states of the black hole . many arguments ( too many to review here ) have been put forward in this direction . while it may develop that some of the principles behind these are correct , until recently there was no example where the states of a black hole could be counted in a controlled way . the idea is to count supersymmetric ( bps ) black hole states . such black holes always carry gauge charges and have the maximum allowed charge to mass ratio they are extremal . as discussed in section 2.2 , the number of bps states can not change as we vary the string coupling constant . as the coupling is reduced and so the gravitational interaction weakened , certain black holes will at sufficiently weak coupling no longer look like black holes . rather , they look like a collection of d - particles as depicted in figure 7 ; this has the same charge - to - mass ratio as the black hole . the d - particles are a weakly coupled quantum system whose spectrum is explicitly known from d - brane methods . the density of bps states is just that given by the bekenstein - hawking entropy ( strominger and vafa , 1996 , and much subsequent work ; for a review see horowitz , 1996 ) . closely associated with all this is the black hole information paradox . a black hole of given mass and charge can be formed in a very large number of ways . it will then evaporate , and the final state is black body radiation that does not depend on how the black hole formed . thus , many initial states evolve to a single final state . this violates the usual laws of quantum mechanics . there are various schools of thought here ( reviewed in page , 1993 ) . the proposal of hawking ( 1976 ) is that this is just the way things are : the laws of quantum mechanics need to be changed . there is also strong opposition to this view . the problem is not that theorists believe that the laws of quantum mechanics are in their final form they may be , though most of us would like to see a less mysterious structure . rather , it is that the specific modification required here , the replacement of wavefunctions with density matrices , seems ugly and very possibly inconsistent . the principal alternative , that the initial state is encoded in subtle correlations in the hawking radiation , sounds plausible but in fact is even more radical . the problem is that hawking radiation emerges from the region of the horizon , where the geometry is smooth and so ordinary low energy field theory should be valid . one can follow the hawking radiation and see correlations develop between the fields inside and outside the black hole ; the superposition principle then forbids the necessary correlations to exist strictly among the fields outside . to evade this requires that the locality principle in quantum field theory break down in some long - ranged but subtle way . there is a proposal for how this might occur in string theory ( susskind , 1993 , 1995 ; lowe , polchinski , susskind , thorlacius , and uglum , 1995 ) , but it is controversial . the recent progress in string duality suggests that black holes do obey the ordinary rules of quantum mechanics . the multiplets include black holes along with various nonsingular states , and in figure 7 we have continuously deformed a black hole into a system which obeys ordinary quantum mechanics , at least to high accuracy . this is certainly not decisive , however . the problem is that dynamical properties are not like the counting of bps states ; they are not invariant under changes in parameters . it could be that as the coupling constant is increased , a critical coupling is reached where the d - particles collapse into a black hole . at this coupling there could be a discontinuous change ( or a smooth crossover ) from ordinary quantum behavior to information loss . it is an open question whether d - branes will give insight into the dynamical behavior of black holes ; there are hints that it may be so . so when will string theory make sharp predictions ? probably not until the vacuum is understood , as we discussed in section 2.3 . an important problem remains in our understanding of the vacuum , when we try to calculate the vacuum energy density , the cosmological constant . the vacuum is a complicated place , and there are many different contributions to the energy density the zero point energies of the quantum fields , the potential energy of the higgs field , the energy of the strongly fluctuating qcd fields . the total of the separate densities is at least @xmath88 gev@xmath89 , and there is no reason known that they should cancel to any degree of accuracy . yet the experimental bound on the cosmological constant is 55 orders of magnitude smaller than this ( see weinberg , 1989 , for a review ) . this is just as much problem in quantum field theory as in string theory but field theory can still make precise predictions because it is less ambitious . one can ignore gravity , or add a free parameter and adjust it to cancel the other contributions to the cosmological constant . in string theory , neither of these is possible . does string duality help here ? possibly . it is an interesting fact that in supersymmetric theories the energy density can cancel naturally . for example the zero point energies of bosons and their fermionic partners are equal and opposite . one can see this in the discussion of bps states : a supersymmetric vacuum has zero energy ( though the inclusion of supergravity makes things a bit more subtle ) . in nature , though , supersymmetry must be spontaneously broken there is no charged boson degenerate with the electron and spontaneous breaking spoils the cancellation of the cosmological constant . we need some new phase of supersymmetric theories , in which the boson / fermion degeneracy is removed while the vacuum energy remains zero . witten ( 1995b ) has suggested how such a phase might appear in strongly coupled string theory . from another point of view , the cosmological constant and black hole information problems both seem to require subtle nonlocalities in spacetime . for the information problem we have discussed this ; for the cosmological constant , the point is that the low energy value of this constant must somehow feed back into the short - distance physics that determines it . for example , it was argued that spacetime wormholes could accomplish this ( coleman , 1988 ) . this proposal was the subject of intense and skeptical scrutiny , but the subject ground to a halt because a nonperturbative formulation of quantum gravity was lacking . it may then be that it will return , possibly in some transmuted form , when we know what string theory is . in closing , let me say that there is a sense among those working in string theory that we are dealing with a unique and remarkable structure , one which has many points of contact with the physics we know and with earlier attempts to unify it quantum mechanics , gravity , gauge symmetry , chirality , grand unification , supersymmetry , and kaluza - klein theory . there is also a sense that we are discovering this structure , not inventing it . the distinction is illustrated , for example , by the question of the nature of spacetime . there have been many previous attempts to modify spacetime in a way that would look the same at long distance but would solve the problems of quantum gravity . this approach has often been sterile it is not a problem that seems to yield to direct effort . string theory , on the other hand , starts with a flat spacetime . one discovers first that the spacetime is dynamical , that the theory contains gravity . later one finds , as mentioned in section 3.5 , that spacetime topology is not a physical invariant but can change in specific and controlled ways . there is still more to be learned . in perturbation theory it seems that the shortest sensible distance is the string length scale , the typical radius of zero point vibrations of the string ( gross and mende , 1987 ; amati , ciafaloni , and veneziano , 1989 ; reviewed in witten , 1996c ) . this works out to be the planck length divided by a power of the string coupling . there is evidence for a somewhat shorter scale in the exact theory ( shenker , 1995 ) , and that d - branes may probe it ( bachas , 1995 ; danielsson , ferretti and sundborg , 1995 ; kabat and pouliot , 1995 ) . moreover , there is a sense in which the spacetime coordinates for d - branes are elevated from numbers to matrices ( witten , 1996a ) ; only at low energy the matrices are diagonal and an ordinary spacetime picture holds . it may turn that this is a curiosity , or it may signal a new uncertainty principle relating to a minimum distance . exploring the connection between d - branes and black holes is a likely way to learn which . in effect , string theory is smarter than we are . it knows what spacetime is , and we do nt , and we have to figure out how to ask it . we are very fortunate that this remarkable structure exists and that it seems to be within our power to understand it . i would like to thank gary horowitz , clifford johnson , and andy strominger for their suggestions on the manuscript . this work is supported by nsf grants phy91 - 16964 and phy94 - 07194 . u. amaldi , w. de boer , and h. furstenau , 1991 , `` comparison of grand unified theories with electroweak and strong coupling constants measured at lep , '' phys . lett . * b260 , * 447 . + d. amati , m. ciafaloni , and g. veneziano , 1989 , `` can spacetime be probed below the string scale ? '' phys . lett . * b216 , * 41 . + p. s. aspinwall , b. r. greene , and d. r. morrison , 1993 , `` multiple mirror manifolds and topology change in string theory , '' phys . lett . * b303 , * 249 , e - print hep - th/9301043 . + c. bachas , 1996 , `` d - brane dynamics , '' phys . * b374 , * 37 , e - print hep - th/9511043 . + e. bergshoeff , e. sezgin , and p.k . townsend , 1987 , `` supermembranes and eleven dimensional supergravity , '' phys . lett . * b189 , * 75 . + p. candelas , g. horowitz , a. strominger , and e. witten , 1985 , `` vacuum configurations for superstrings , '' nucl . phys . * b258 , * 46 . + b. carter , 1979 , `` the general theory of the mechanical , electromagnetic , and thermodynamic properties of black holes , '' in _ general relativity . an einstein centennial survey , _ ed . s. w. hawking and w. israel ( cambridge , cambridge ) . + s. coleman , 1988 , `` why there is nothing rather than something : a theory of the cosmological constant , '' nucl . phys . * b310 , * 643 . + e. d. commins and p. h. bucksbaum , 1983 , _ weak interactions of leptons and quarks _ ( cambridge , new york ) . + e. cremmer , b. julia , and j. scherk , 1978 , `` supergravity theory in eleven dimensions , '' phys . lett . * 76b , * 409 . + a. dabholkar , 1995 , `` ten - dimensional heterotic string as a soliton , '' phys . * b357 , * 307 , e - print hep - th/9506160 . + j. dai , r. g. leigh , and j. polchinski , 1989 , `` new connections between string theories , '' mod . . lett . * a4 , * 2073 . + u. h. danielsson , g. ferretti , and b. sundborg , 1996 , `` d - particle dynamics and bound states , '' preprint usitp-96 - 03 , e - print hep - th/9603081 . + p. a. m. dirac , 1931 , `` quantized singularities in the electromagnetic field , '' proc . * a133 , * 60 . + m. j. duff , p.s . howe , t. inami , and k.s . stelle , 1987 , `` superstrings in @xmath90 from supermembranes in @xmath91 , '' phys * 191b , * 70 . + m. j. duff , 1988 , `` supermembranes : the first fifteen weeks , '' class . * 5 , * 189 . + m. j. duff , 1995 , `` strong / weak duality from the dual string , '' nucl . * b442 , * 47 , e - print hep - th/9506057 . + a. font , l. ibanez , d. lust , and f. quevedo , 1990 , `` strong - weak coupling duality and nonperturbative effects in string theory , '' phys . * b249 , * 35 . + f. gliozzi , j. scherk , and d. olive , 1977 , `` supersymmetry , supergravity theories , and the dual spinor model , '' nucl . phys . * b122 , * 253 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 300 . + m. b. green and j. h. schwarz , 1984 , `` anomaly cancellations in supersymmetric @xmath90 gauge theory and superstring theory , '' phys . lett . * 136b , * 367 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 2 , 1007 . + m. b. green , j. h. schwarz , and e. witten , 1987 , _ superstring theory , vols . 1 and 2 _ ( cambridge , cambridge ) . + b. r. greene , d. r. morrison , and a. strominger , 1995 , `` black hole condensation and the unification of string vacua , '' nucl . * b451 , * 109 , e - print hep - th/9504145 . + d. j. gross , j. a. harvey , e. martinec , and r. rohm , 1985 , `` heterotic string , '' phys . * 54 , * 502 . + r. haag , j. t. lopuszanski , and m sohnius , 1975 , `` all possible generators of supersymmetries of the s matrix , '' nucl . phys . * b88 , * 257 . + j. a. harvey and a. strominger , 1995 , `` the heterotic string is a soliton , '' nucl . * b449 , * 535 , ( e ) * b458 , * 456 , e - print hep - th/9504047 . + j. a. harvey , 1996 , `` magnetic monopoles , duality , and supersymmetry , '' chicago preprint efi-96 - 06 , e - print hep - th/9603086 . + s. w. hawking , 1975 , `` particle creation by black holes , '' comm . * 43 , * 199 . + s. w. hawking , 1976 , `` breakdown of predictability in gravitational collapse , '' phys . rev . * d14 , * 2460 . + p. horava and e. witten , 1996 , `` heterotic and type i string dynamics from eleven dimensions , '' nucl . * b460 , * 506 , e - print hep - th/9510209 . + g. t. horowitz , 1996 , `` the origin of black hole entropy in string theory , '' ucsb preprint ucsbth-96 - 07 , e - print gr - qc/9604051 . + c. m. hull and p. k. townsend , 1995 , `` unity of superstring dualities , '' nucl . * b438 , * 109 , e - print hep - th/9410167 . + c. m. hull , 1995 , `` string - string duality in ten - dimensions , '' phys . * b357 , * 545 , e - print hep - th/9506194 . + k. intriligator and n. seiberg , 1995 , `` lectures on supersymmetric gauge theories and electric - magnetic duality , '' presented at tasi 95 , boulder , colo . , trieste summer school , trieste , italy , and cargese summer school , cargese , france , rutgers preprint ru-95 - 48 , e - print hep - th/9509066 . + d. kabat and p. pouliot , `` a comment on zero - brane quantum mechanics , '' rutgers preprint ru-96 - 17 , e - print hep - th/9603127 . + v. s. kaplunovsky , 1988 , `` one loop effects in string unification , '' nucl . phys . * b307 , * 145 , ( e ) * b382 , * 436 ( 1992 ) , e - print hep - th/9205070 . + d. a. lowe , j. polchinski , l. susskind , l. thorlacius , and j. uglum , 1995 , `` black hole complementarity versus locality , '' phys . rev . * d52 , * 6997 , e - print hep - th/9506138 . + c. montonen and d. olive , 1977 , `` magnetic monopoles as gauge particles ? '' phys . * 72b , * 117 . + a. neveu and j. scherk , 1972 , `` connection between yang - mills fields and dual models , '' nucl . phys . * b36 , * 155 . + h. osborn , 1979 , `` topological charges for @xmath44 supersymmetric gauge theories and monopoles of spin 1 , '' phys . * 83b , * 321 . + d. n. page , 1993 , `` black hole information , '' canadian gen . rel . * 1993 , * 1 , e - print hep - th/9305040 . + j. polchinski , 1994 , `` what is string theory ? '' les houches summer school , session 62 : fluctuating geometries in statistical mechanics and field theory , 1994 , e - print hep - th/9411028 + j. polchinski , 1995 , `` dirichlet - branes and ramond - ramond charges , '' phys . * 75 , * 4724 , e - print hep - th/9510017 . + j. polchinski and e. witten , 1996 , `` evidence for heterotic - type i string duality , '' nucl . phys . * b460 , * 525 , e - print hep - th/9510169 . + j. polchinski , s. chaudhuri , and c. v. johnson , 1996 , `` notes on d - branes , '' itp preprint nsf - itp-96 - 003 , e - print hep - th/9602052 . + p. ramond , 1971 , `` dual theory for free fermions , '' phys . * d3 , * 2415 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 53 . + a. salam , 1980 , `` grand unification of fundamental forces , '' rev . * 52 , * 525 . + j. scherk and j. h. schwarz , 1974 , `` dual models for non - hadrons , '' nucl . * b81 , * 118 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 191 . + j. scherk and j. h. schwarz , 1975 , `` dual model approach to a renormalizable theory of gravitation , '' caltech preprint calt-58 - 488 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 218 . + j. h. schwarz , 1985 , _ superstrings . the first 15 years of superstring theory , vols . 1 and 2 _ ( world scientific , singapore ) . + j. h. schwarz , 1995 , `` an @xmath92 multiplet of type iib superstrings , '' phys . * b360 , * 13 , ( e ) * b364 , * 252 , e - print hep - th/9508143 . + n. seiberg , 1994 , `` exact results on the space of vacua of four - dimensional susy gauge theories , '' phys * d49 , * 6857 , e - print hep - th/9402044 . + n. seiberg , 1995 , `` the power of duality : exact results in 4-d susy field theory , '' rutgers preprint ru-95 - 37 , e - print hep - th/9506077 . + a. sen , 1994 , `` strong - weak coupling duality in four - dimensional string theory , '' int . * a9 , * 3707 , e - print hep - th/9402002 . + a. sen , 1995a , `` string string duality conjecture in six - dimensions and charged solitonic strings , '' nucl . * b450 , * 103 , e - print hep - th/9504027 . + a. sen , 1995b , `` a note on marginally stable bound states in type ii string theory , '' mehta preprint mri - phy-23 - 95 , e - print hep - th/9510229 . + s. h. shenker , 1991 , `` the strength of nonperturbative effects in string theory , '' in _ random surfaces and quantum gravity _ , eds . o. alvarez , e. marinari , and p. windey ( plenum , 1991 ) . + s. h. shenker , 1995 , `` another length scale in string theory ? '' rutgers preprint ru-95 - 53 , e - print hep - th/9509132 . + a. strominger , 1990 , `` heterotic solitons , '' nucl . * b343 , * 167 , ( e ) * b353 , * 565 . + a. strominger and c. vafa , 1996 , `` microscopic origin of the bekenstein - hawking entropy , '' preprint hutp-96-a002 , e - print hep - th/9601029 . + l. susskind , 1993 , `` string theory and the principles of black hole complementarity , '' phys . * 71 , * 2367 , e - print hep - th/9307168 + l. susskind , 1995 , `` the world as a hologram , '' j. math . phys . * 36 , * 6377 , e - print hep - th/9409089 . + p. k. townsend , 1995 , `` the eleven - dimensional supermembrane revisited , '' phys . * b350 , * 184 , e - print hep - th/9501068 . + s. weinberg , 1980 , `` conceptual foundations of the unified theory of weak and electromagnetic interactions , '' rev . * 52 , * 515 . + s. weinberg , 1989 , `` the cosmological constant problem , '' rev . * 61 , * 1 . + k. wilson , 1983 , `` the renormalization group and critical phenomena , '' rev . mod . * 55 , * 515 . + e. witten and d. olive , 1978 , `` supersymmetry algebras that include topological charges , '' phys . lett . * 78b , * 97 . + e. witten , 1981 , `` search for a realistic kaluza - klein theory , '' nucl . * b186 , * 412 . + e. witten , 1995a , `` string theory dynamics in various dimensions , '' nucl . * b443 , * 85 , e - print hep - th/9503124 . + e. witten , 1995b , `` strong coupling and the cosmological constant , '' mod . * a10 , * 2153 , e - print hep - th/9506101 . + e. witten , 1996a , `` bound states of strings and @xmath93-branes , '' nucl . * b460 , * 335 , e - print hep - th/9510135 . + e. witten , 1996b , `` strong - coupling expansion of calabi - yau compactification , '' ias preprint iassns - hep-96 - 08 , e - print hep - th/9602070 . + e. witten , 1996c , `` reflections on the fate of spacetime , '' phys . today * 49 , * 4 , 5 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: linear regression is one of the most common statistical techniques used in astronomical data analysis . in general , linear regression in astronomy is characterized by intrinsic scatter about the regression line , and measurement errors in both the independent and dependent variables . the source of intrinsic scatter is variations in the physical properties of astronomical sources that are not completely captured by the variables included in the regression . it is important to correctly account for both measurement error and intrinsic scatter , as both aspects can have a non - negligible effect on the regression results . in particular , ignoring the intrinsic scatter and weighting the data points solely by the measurement errors can result in the higher - precision measurements being given disproportionate influence on the regression results . furthermore , when the independent variable is measured with error , the ordinary least squares ( ols ) estimate of the regression slope is biased toward zero ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? when there are multiple independent variables , measurement error can have an even stronger and more unpredictable effect @xcite . in addition , the existence of non - detections , referred to as ` censored data ' , in the data set will result in additional complications ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . therefore , when performing regression , it is essential to correctly account for the measurement errors and intrinsic scatter in order to ensure that the data analysis , and thus the scientific conclusions based on it , are trustworthy . many methods have been proposed for performing linear regression when intrinsic scatter is present and both variables are measured with error . these include methods that correct the observed moments of the data ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , minimize an ` effective ' @xmath1 statistic ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , assume a probability distribution for the true independent variable values ( so - called structural equation models , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) ; bayesian approaches to these models have also been developed ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? in addition , methods have been proposed to account for measurement error in censored regression ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the most commonly used methods in astronomy are the bces estimator @xcite and the ` fitexy ' estimator @xcite . both methods have their advantages and disadvantages , some of which have been pointed out by @xcite . however , neither method is applicable when the data contain non - detections . in this work i describe a bayesian method for handling measurement errors in astronomical data analysis . my approach starts by computing the likelihood function of the complete data , i.e. , the likelihood function of both the unobserved true values of the data and the measured values of the data . the measured data likelihood is then found by integrating the likelihood function for the complete data over the unobserved true values ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this approach is known as ` structural equation modelling ' of measurement error problems , and has been studied from both a frequentist approach ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) and a bayesian approach ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in this work , i extend the statistical model of @xcite to allow for measurement errors of different magnitudes ( i.e. , ` heteroscedastic ' errors ) , non - detections , and selection effects , so long as the selection function can be modelled mathematically . our method models the distribution of independent variables as a weighted sum of gaussians . the mixture of gaussians model allows flexibility when estimating the distribution of the true values of the independent variable , thus increasing its robustness against model mispecification ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the basic idea is that one can use a suitably large enough number of gaussians to accurately approximate the true distribution of independent variables , even though in general the individual gaussians have no physical meaning . the paper is organized as follows . in [ s - notation ] we summarize some notation , and in [ s - measerr ] i review the effects of measurement error on the estimates for the regression slope and correlation coefficient . in [ s - statmod ] i describe the statistical model and derive the likelihood functions , and in [ s - dcissues ] i describe how to incorporate knowledge of the selection effects and account for non - detections . in [ s - prior ] i describe the prior distribution for this model , and in [ s - markov ] i describe a gibbs sampler for sampling from the posterior distributions . in [ s - sims ] i use simulation to illustrate the effectiveness of this structural model and compare with the ols , bces(@xmath2 ) , and fitexy estimators . finally , in [ s - data ] i illustrate the method using astronomical data by performing a regression of the x - ray photon index , @xmath3 , on the eddington ratio using a sample of 39 @xmath4 radio - quiet quasars . sections [ s - statmod ] , [ s - dcissues ] , and [ s - compmeth ] are somewhat technical , and the reader who is uninterested in the mathematical and computational details may skip to them . i will use the common statistical notation that an estimate of a quantity is denoted by placing a ` hat ' above it ; e.g. , @xmath5 is an estimate of the true value of the parameter @xmath6 . in general , greek letters will denote the true value of a quantity , while roman letters will denote the contaminated measured value . i will frequently refer to the ` bias ' of an estimator . the bias of an estimator is @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the expectation value of the estimator @xmath5 , and @xmath9 is the true value of @xmath6 . an unbiased estimator is one such that @xmath10 . i will denote a normal density with mean @xmath11 and variance @xmath12 as @xmath13 , and i will denote as @xmath14 a multivariate normal density with @xmath15-element mean vector @xmath11 and @xmath16 covariance matrix @xmath17 . if i want to explicitly identify the argument of the gaussian function , i will use the notation @xmath18 , which should be understood to be a gaussian with mean @xmath11 and variance @xmath12 as a function of @xmath19 . following @xcite , i denote the scaled inverse-@xmath1 density as inv-@xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the degrees of freedom and @xmath22 is the scale parameter , and we denote the inverse - wishart as inv-@xmath23 , where @xmath21 is the degrees of freedom and @xmath24 is the scale matrix . the inverse - wishart distribution can be thought of as a multivariate generalization of the scaled inverse-@xmath1 distribution . i will often use the common statistical notation where `` @xmath25 '' means `` is drawn from '' or `` is distributed as '' . for example , @xmath26 states that @xmath19 is drawn from a normal density with mean @xmath11 and variance @xmath12 . it is well known that measurement error can attenuate the estimate of the regression slope and correlation coefficient ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . for completeness , i give a brief review of the effect of measurement error on correlation and regression analysis for the case of one independent variable . denote the independent variable as @xmath27 and the dependent variable as @xmath28 ; @xmath27 and @xmath28 are also referred to as the ` covariate ' and the ` response ' , respectively . i assume that @xmath27 is a random vector of @xmath29 data points drawn from some probability distribution . the dependent variable , @xmath28 , depends on @xmath27 according to the usual additive model : @xmath30 here , @xmath31 is a random variable representing the intrinsic scatter in @xmath32 about the regression relationship , and @xmath33 are the regression coefficients . the mean of @xmath34 is assumed to be zero , and the variance of @xmath34 is assumed to be constant and is denoted as @xmath12 . we do not observe the actual values of @xmath35 , but instead observe values @xmath36 which are measured with error . the measured values are assumed to be related to the actual values as @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the random measurement errors on @xmath40 and @xmath41 , respectively . in general , the errors are normally distributed with known variances @xmath42 and @xmath43 , and covariance @xmath44 . for simplicity , throughout the rest of this section i assume that @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the same for each data point . when the data are measured without error , the least - squares estimate of the regression slope , @xmath47 , and the estimated correlation coefficient , @xmath48 , are @xmath49 here , @xmath50 is the sample covariance between @xmath27 and @xmath28 , and @xmath51 is the sample variance of @xmath27 . when the data are measured with error , the least - squares estimate of the regression slope , @xmath52 , and the estimated correlation coefficient , @xmath53 , become @xmath54 from these equations it is apparent that the estimated slope and correlation are biased when the data are measured with error . it is informative to assess the effect of measurement error in terms of the ratios @xmath55 , as these quantities can be calculated from the data . the fractional bias in the estimated slope and correlation may then be expressed as @xmath56 from equations ( [ eq - frac_bbias ] ) and ( [ eq - frac_rbias ] ) it is apparent that measurement errors have the following effects . first , covariate measurement error reduces the magnitude of the observed correlation between the independent variable and the response , as well as biasing the estimate of the slope towards zero . second , measurement error in the response also reduces the magnitude of the observed correlation between the variables . third , if the measurement errors are correlated the effects depend on the sign of this correlation . if the measurement error correlation has the same sign as the intrinsic correlation between @xmath27 and @xmath28 , then the measurement errors cause a spurious increase in the observed correlation ; otherwise the measurement errors cause a spurious decrease in the observed correlation . the magnitude of these effects depend on how large the measurement errors are compared to the observed variance in @xmath19 and @xmath57 . in figure [ f - bias ] i plot the fractional bias in the correlation coefficient , @xmath58 , as a function of @xmath59 and @xmath60 when the errors are uncorrelated . as can be seen , measurement error can have a significant effect on the estimation of the linear correlation coefficient . for example , when @xmath61 and @xmath62 , the estimated correlation is @xmath63% lower than the true correlation . therefore , interpretation of correlation coefficients and regression slopes must be approached with caution when the data have been contaminated by measurement error . to ensure accurate results , it is necessary to employ statistical methods that correct for the measurement errors . i assume that the independent variable , @xmath27 , is drawn from a probability distribution @xmath64 , where @xmath65 denotes the parameters for this distribution . the dependent variable is then drawn from the conditional distribution of @xmath28 given @xmath27 , denoted as @xmath66 ; @xmath6 denotes the parameters for this distribution . the joint distribution of @xmath27 and @xmath28 is then @xmath67 . in this work i assume the normal linear regression model given by equation ( [ eq - adderr ] ) , and thus @xmath66 is a normal density with mean @xmath68 and variance @xmath12 , and @xmath69 . since the data are a randomly observed sample , we can derive the likelihood function for the measured data . the likelihood function of the measured data , @xmath70 , is obtained by integrating the complete data likelihood over the missing data , @xmath27 and @xmath28 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) : @xmath71 here , @xmath72 is the complete data likelihood function . because of the hierarchical structure inherent in the measurement error model , it is helpful to decompose the complete data likelihood into conditional probability densities : @xmath73 the density @xmath74 describes the joint distribution of the measured values @xmath19 and @xmath57 at a given @xmath27 and @xmath28 , and depends on the assumed distribution of the measurement errors , @xmath75 and @xmath76 . in this work i assume gaussian measurement error , and thus @xmath77 is a multivariate normal density with mean @xmath78 and covariance matrix @xmath79 , where @xmath80 and @xmath81 . the statistical model may then be conveniently expressed hierarchically as @xmath82,\sigma_i ) \label{eq - hierxy } \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that if @xmath40 is measured without error , then @xmath83 is a dirac delta function , and @xmath84 . an equivalent result holds if @xmath41 is measured without error . equation ( [ eq - obslik2 ] ) may be used to obtain the observed data likelihood function for any assumed distribution of @xmath27 . in this work , i model @xmath64 as a mixture of @xmath85 gaussians , @xmath86 where @xmath87 . note that , @xmath88 may be interpreted as the probability of drawing a data point from the @xmath89 gaussian . i will use the convenient notation @xmath90 and @xmath91 ; note that @xmath92 . it is useful to model @xmath64 using this form because it is flexible enough to adapt to a wide variety of distributions , but is also conjugate for the regression relationship ( eq.[[eq - adderr ] ] ) and the measurement error distribution , thus simplifying the mathematics . assuming the gaussian mixture model for @xmath64 , the measured data likelihood for the @xmath93 data point can be directly calculated using equation ( [ eq - obslik2 ] ) . denoting the measured data as @xmath94 , the measured data likelihood function for the @xmath93 data point is then a mixture of bivariate normal distributions with weights @xmath95 , means @xmath96 , and covariance matrices @xmath97 . because the data points are statistically independent , the full measured data likelihood is then the product of the likelihood functions for the individual data points : @xmath98 here , @xmath99 denotes the transpose of @xmath100 . equation ( [ eq - bobslik ] ) may be maximized to compute the maximum - likelihood estimate ( mle ) . when @xmath101 , the expectation - maximization ( em ) algorithm @xcite is probably the most efficient tool for calculating the mle . @xcite describe an em algorithm when @xmath102 is assumed to be a mixture of normals and the measurement error distribution is multivariate @xmath103 , and their results can be extended to the statistical model described in this work . it is informative to decompose the measured data likelihood , @xmath104 , as this representation is useful when the data contain non - detections ( cf . , [ s - nondet ] ) . the marginal distribution of @xmath40 is @xmath105 and the conditional distribution of @xmath41 given @xmath40 is @xmath106 ^ 2}{var(y_i|x_i , k ) } \right\ } \label{eq - cdensyx } \\ \gamma_k & = & \frac{\pi_k n(x_i|\mu_k , \tau^2_k + \sigma^2_{x , i } ) } { \sum_{j=1}^k \pi_j n(x_i|\mu_j , \tau^2_j + \sigma^2_{x , i } ) } \label{eq - cdenskx } \\ e(y_i|x_i , k ) & = & \alpha + \left ( \frac{\beta \tau^2_k + \sigma_{xy , i } } { \tau^2_k + \sigma^2_{x , i } } \right ) x_i + \left ( \frac{\beta \sigma^2_{x , i } - \sigma_{xy , i } } { \tau_k^2 + \sigma^2_{x , i } } \right ) \mu_k \label{eq - cmeanyx } \\ var(y_i|x_i , k ) & = & \beta^2 \tau^2_k + \sigma^2 + \sigma^2_{y , i } - \frac{(\beta \tau^2_k - \sigma_{xy , i})^2}{\tau^2_k + \sigma^2_{x , i } } \label{eq - cvary}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath107 can be interpreted as the probability that the @xmath93 data point was drawn from the @xmath89 gaussian given @xmath40 , @xmath108 gives the expectation value of @xmath41 at @xmath40 , given that the data point was drawn from the @xmath89 gaussian , and @xmath109 gives the variance in @xmath41 at @xmath40 , given that the data point was drawn from the @xmath89 gaussian . it is informative to investigate the case where the distribution of @xmath27 is assumed to be uniform , @xmath110 . interpreting @xmath102 as a ` prior ' on @xmath27 , one may be tempted to consider assuming @xmath110 as a more objective alternative to the normal distribution . a uniform distribution for @xmath27 may be obtained as the limit @xmath111 , and thus the likelihood function for @xmath110 can be calculated from equation ( [ eq - cdensyx ] ) by taking @xmath111 and @xmath112 . when the measurement errors are uncorrelated , the likelihood for uniform @xmath102 is @xmath113 the argument of the exponential is the fitexy goodness of fit statistic , @xmath114 , as modified by @xcite to account for intrinsic scatter ; this fact has also been recognized by @xcite . despite this connection , minimizing @xmath114 is not the same as maximizing the conditional likelihood of @xmath57 given @xmath19 , as both @xmath115 and @xmath12 appear in the normalization of the likelihood function as well . for a given value of @xmath12 , minimizing @xmath114 can be interpreted as minimizing a weighted sum of squared errors , where the weights are given by the variances in @xmath41 at a given @xmath40 , and one assumes a uniform distribution for @xmath27 . unfortunately , this is only valid for a fixed value of @xmath12 . moreover , little is known about the statistical properties of the fitexy estimator , such as its bias and variance , although bootstrapping ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) may be used to estimate them . furthermore , it is ambiguous how to calculate the fitexy estimates when there is an intrinsic scatter term . the fitexy goodness - of - fit statistic , @xmath114 , can not be simultaneously minimized with respect to @xmath116 and @xmath12 , as @xmath114 is a strictly decreasing function of @xmath12 . as such , it is unclear how to proceed in the optimization beyond an _ ad hoc _ approach . many authors have followed the approach adopted by @xcite and increase @xmath12 until @xmath117 , or assume @xmath118 if @xmath119 . despite the fact that minimizing @xmath120 is not the same as maximizing equation ( [ eq - uniflik ] ) , one may still be tempted to calculate a mle based on equation ( [ eq - uniflik ] ) . however , it can be shown that if one assumes @xmath110 , and if all of the @xmath19 and @xmath57 have the same respective measurement error variances , @xmath121 and @xmath122 , the mle estimates for @xmath123 and @xmath115 are just the ordinary least squares estimates @xcite . while this is not necessarily true when the magnitudes of the measurement errors vary between data points , one might expect that the mle will behave similarly to the ols estimate . i confirm this fact using simulation in [ s - sims1 ] . unfortunately , this implies that the mle for @xmath110 inherits the bias in the ols estimate , and thus nothing is gained . furthermore , as argued by @xcite , one can easily be convinced that assuming @xmath110 is incorrect by examining a histogram of @xmath19 . the formalism developed in [ s - normreg ] can easily be generalized to multiple independent variables . in this case equation ( [ eq - adderr ] ) becomes @xmath124 where @xmath115 is now a @xmath15-element vector and @xmath125 is a @xmath15-element vector containing the values of the independent variables for the @xmath93 data point . similar to before , we assume that the distribution of @xmath125 can be approximated using a mixture of @xmath85 multivariate normal densities with @xmath15-element mean vectors @xmath126 , @xmath16 covariance matrices @xmath127 , and weights @xmath128 . the measured value of @xmath125 is the @xmath15-element vector @xmath129 , and the gaussian measurement errors on @xmath130 have @xmath131 covariance matrix @xmath79 . the statistical model is then @xmath132 , \sigma_i ) . \label{eq - mhierxy } \\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] denoting @xmath133 , the measured data likelihood is @xmath134 here , @xmath135 is the @xmath136-element mean vector of @xmath137 for gaussian @xmath138 , @xmath139 is the @xmath140 covariance matrix of @xmath137 for gaussian @xmath138 , @xmath43 is the variance in the measurement error on @xmath41 , @xmath44 is the @xmath15-element vector of covariances between the measurement errors on @xmath41 and @xmath129 , and @xmath141 is the @xmath16 covariance matrix of the measurement errors on @xmath129 . similar to the case for one independent variable , the measured data likelihood can be decomposed as @xmath142 , where @xmath143 and @xmath144 ^ 2}{var(y_i|{\bf x}_i , k ) } \right\ } \label{eq - mcdensyx } \\ \gamma_k & = & \frac{\pi_k n({\bf x}_i|\mu_k , t_k + \sigma_{x , i } ) } { \sum_{j=1}^k \pi_j n({\bf x}_i|\mu_j , t_j + \sigma_{x , i } ) } \label{eq - mcdenskx } \\ e(y_i|{\bf x}_i , k ) & = & \alpha + \beta^t \mu_k + ( \beta^t t_k + \sigma^t_{xy , i } ) ( t_k + \sigma_{x , i})^{-1 } ( { \bf x}_i - \mu_k ) \label{eq - mxihati } \\ var(y_i|{\bf x}_i , k ) & = & \beta^t t_k \beta + \sigma^2 + \sigma^2_{y , i } - ( \beta^t t_k + \sigma^t_{xy , i } ) ( t_k + \sigma_{x , i})^{-1 } ( t_k \beta + \sigma_{xy , i } ) \label{eq - mcvary}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] there are several issues common in the collection of astronomical data that violate the simple assumptions made in [ s - statmod ] . astronomical data collection consists almost entirely of passive observations , and thus selection effects are a common concern . instrumental detection limits often result in the placement of upper or lower limits on quantities , and astronomical surveys are frequently flux - limited . in this section i modify the likelihood functions described in [ s - statmod ] to include the effects of data collection . general methods for dealing with missing data are described in @xcite and @xcite , and i apply the methodology described in these references to the measurement error model developed here . although in this work i focus on linear regression , many of these results can be applied to more general statistical models , such as estimating luminosity functions . suppose that one collects a sample of @xmath29 sources out of a possible @xmath145 sources . one is interested in understanding how the observable properties of these sources are related , but is concerned about the effects of the selection procedure on the data analysis . for example , one may perform a survey that probes some area of the sky . there are @xmath145 sources located within this solid angle , where @xmath145 is unknown . because of the survey s selection method , the sample only includes @xmath29 sources . in this case the astronomer is interested in how measurement error and the survey s selection method affect statistical inference . i investigate selection effects within the framework of our statistical model by introducing an indicator variable , @xmath146 , which denotes whether a source is included in the sample . if the @xmath147 source is included in the sample , then @xmath148 , otherwise @xmath149 . in addition , i assume that the selection function only depends on the measured values , @xmath19 and @xmath57 . under this assumption , the selection function of the sample is the probability of including a source with a given @xmath19 and @xmath57 , @xmath150 . this is commonly the case in astronomy , where sources are collected based on their measured properties . for example , one may select sources for a sample based on their measured properties as reported in the literature . in addition , if one performs a flux - limited survey then a source will only be considered detected if its measured flux falls above some set flux limit . if a sample is from a survey with a simple flux limit , then @xmath151 if the measured source flux @xmath41 is above the flux limit , and @xmath152 if the measured source flux is below the flux limit . since the selection function depends on the measured flux value , and not the true flux value , sources with true flux values above the flux limit can be missed by the survey , and sources with true flux below the limit can be detected by the survey . this effect is well - known in astronomy and is commonly referred to as malmquist bias ( e.g. , * ? ? ? including the variable @xmath146 , the complete data likelihood can be written as @xmath153 equation ( [ eq - complik ] ) is valid for any number of independent variables , and thus @xmath40 and @xmath125 may be either scalar or vector . integrating equation ( [ eq - complik ] ) over the missing data , the observed data likelihood is @xmath154 here , @xmath155 is the binomial coefficient , @xmath156 denotes the set of @xmath29 included sources , @xmath157 and @xmath158 denote the values of @xmath19 and @xmath57 for the included sources , and @xmath159 denotes the set of @xmath160 missing sources . in addition , i have omitted terms that do not depend on @xmath161 , or @xmath145 . note that @xmath145 is unknown and is thus also a parameter of the statistical model . the binomial coefficient is necessary because it gives the number of possible ways to select a sample of @xmath29 sources from a set of @xmath145 sources . it is apparent from equation ( [ eq - mislik ] ) that statistical inference on the regression parameters is unaffected if the selection function is independent of @xmath57 and @xmath19 . ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in this case the selection function may be ignored . it is commonly the case that a sample is selected based only on the measured independent variables . for example , suppose one performs a survey in which all sources with measured optical flux greater than some threshold are included . then , these optically selected sources are used to fit a regression in order to understand how the x - ray luminosity of these objects depends on their optical luminosity and redshift . in this case , the probability of including a source only depends on the measured values of the optical luminosity and redshift , and is thus independent of the x - ray luminosity . when the sample selection function is independent of @xmath57 , given @xmath19 , then @xmath162 . because we are primarily interested in the regression parameters , @xmath6 , i model the distributions of @xmath27 for the included and missing sources seperately , with the parameters for the distribution of included sources denoted as @xmath163 . in addition , i assume that the measurement errors between @xmath57 and @xmath19 are statistically independent . then the @xmath160 integrals over @xmath57 and @xmath28 for the missing sources in equation ( [ eq - mislik ] ) are equal to unity , and we can write the observed data likelihood as @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the distribution of those @xmath27 included in one s sample . here i have omitted terms depending on @xmath145 because one is primarily interested in inference on the regression parameters , @xmath6 . equation ( [ eq - indlik ] ) is identical to equation ( [ eq - obslik2 ] ) , with the exception that @xmath64 now only models the distribution of those @xmath27 that have been included in one s sample , and i have now assumed that the measurement errors on @xmath57 and @xmath19 are independent . in particular , for the gaussian mixture models described in [ s - normreg ] and [ s - multreg ] , the observed data likelihood is given by equations ( [ eq - bobslik ] ) and ( [ eq - mobslik ] ) , where @xmath95 , @xmath11 , and @xmath166 ( or @xmath167 ) should be understood as referring to the parameters for the distribution of the observed @xmath27 . as is evident from the similarity between equations ( [ eq - indlik ] ) and ( [ eq - obslik2 ] ) , _ if the sample is selected based on the measured independent variables , and if the measurement errors on the dependent and independent variables are statistically independent , then inference on the regression parameters , @xmath6 , is unaffected by selection effects_. if the method in which a sample is selected depends on the measured dependent variable , @xmath57 , or if the measurement error in @xmath19 and @xmath57 are correlated , the observed data likelihood becomes more complicated . as an example , one might encounter this situation if one uses an x - ray selected sample to investigate the dependence of x - ray luminosity on optical luminosity and redshift . in this case , the selection function of the sample depends on both the x - ray luminosity and redshift , and is thus no longer independent of the dependent variable . such data sets are said to be ` truncated ' . if the selection function depends on @xmath57 , or if the measurement errors on @xmath57 and @xmath19 are not independent , one can not simply ignore the terms depending on @xmath145 , since the @xmath168 integrals in equation ( [ eq - mislik ] ) depend on @xmath6 . however , we can eliminate the dependence of equation ( [ eq - mislik ] ) on the unknown @xmath145 by applying a bayesian approach . the posterior distribution of @xmath169 and @xmath145 is related to the observed data likelihood function as @xmath170 , where @xmath171 is the prior distribution of @xmath172 . if we assume a uniform prior on @xmath173 and @xmath174 , then one can show ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) that the posterior distribution of @xmath6 and @xmath65 is @xmath175^{-n } \prod_{i=1}^n p(x_i , y_i|\theta , \psi ) . \label{eq - trunclik}\ ] ] here , @xmath176 is given by equation ( [ eq - obslik2 ] ) , and @xmath177 is the probability of including a source in one s sample , given the model parameters , @xmath6 and @xmath65 : @xmath178 i have left off the subscripts for the data points in equation ( [ eq - detprob ] ) because the integrals are the same for each @xmath179 . if one assumes the gaussian mixture model of sections [ s - normreg ] and [ s - multreg ] , then @xmath176 is given by equations ( [ eq - bobslik ] ) or ( [ eq - mobslik ] ) . the posterior mode can then be used as an estimate of @xmath6 and @xmath65 , which is found by maximizing equation ( [ eq - trunclik ] ) . in addition to issues related to the sample selection method , it is common in astronomical data to have non - detections . such non - detections are referred to as ` censored ' data , and the standard procedure is to place an upper and/or lower limit on the censored data point . methods of data analysis for censored data have been reviewed and proposed in the astronomical literature , ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and @xcite describe censored regression when the variables are measured without error . see @xcite for a review of censored data in astronomy . to facilitate the inclusion of censored data , i introduce an additional indicator variable , @xmath180 , indicating whether a data point is censored or not on the dependent variable . if @xmath41 is detected , then @xmath181 , else if @xmath41 is censored then @xmath182 . it is commonly the case that a source is considered ` detected ' if its measured flux falls above some multiple of the background noise level , say @xmath183 . then , in this case , the probability of detecting the source given the measured source flux @xmath41 is @xmath184 if @xmath185 , and @xmath186 if @xmath187 . since source detection depends on the measured flux , some sources with intrinsic flux @xmath28 above the flux limit will have a measured flux @xmath57 that falls below the flux limit . similarly , some sources with intrinsic flux below the flux limit will have a measured flux above the flux limit . i assume that a sample is selected based on the independent variables , i.e. , @xmath162 . it is difficult to imagine obtaining a censored sample if the sample is selected based on its dependent variable , as some of the values of @xmath57 are censored and thus unknown . therefore , i only investigate the effects of censoring on @xmath57 when the probability that a source is included in the sample is independent of @xmath57 , given @xmath19 . in addition , i do not address the issue of censoring on the independent variable . although such methods can be developed , it is probably simpler to just omit such data as inference on the regression parameters is unaffected when a sample is selected based only on the independent variables ( cf . , [ s - seffects_x ] ) . the observed data likelihood for an @xmath19-selected sample is given by equation ( [ eq - indlik ] ) . we can modify this likelihood to account for censored @xmath57 by including the indicator variable @xmath180 and again integrating over the missing data : @xmath188 here , the first product is over the set of data points with detections , @xmath189 , and the second product is over the set of data points with non - detections , @xmath190 . the conditional distribution @xmath191 and the marginal distribution @xmath192 for the gaussian mixture model are both given in [ s - normreg ] and [ s - multreg ] . if the data points are measured without error and one assumes the normal regression model , @xmath193 , then equation [ eq - censlik ] becomes the censored data likelihood function described in @xcite . a mle for censored regression with measurement errors is then obtained by maximizing equation ( [ eq - censlik ] ) . in this section i describe a bayesian method for computing estimates of the regression parameters , @xmath6 , and their uncertainties . the bayesian approach calculates the posterior probability distribution of the model parameters , given the observed data , and therefore is accurate for both small and large sample sizes . the posterior distribution follows from baye s formula as @xmath194 , where @xmath195 is the prior distribution of the parameters . i describe some markov chain methods for drawing random variables from the posterior , which can then be used to estimate quantities such as standard errors and confidence intervals on @xmath6 and @xmath65 . @xcite is a good reference on bayesian methods , and @xcite gives a review of bayesian methods intended for astronomers . further details of markov chain simulation , including methods for making the simulations more efficient , can be found in @xcite . in order to ensure a proper posterior for the gaussian mixture model , it is necessary to invoke a proper prior density on the mixture parameters @xcite . i adopt a uniform prior on the regression parameters @xmath196 , and take @xmath197 . the dirichlet density is a multivariate extension of the beta density , and the @xmath198 prior adopted in this work is equivalent to a uniform prior on @xmath95 , under the constraint @xmath199 . the prior on @xmath11 and @xmath166 ( or @xmath167 ) adopted in this work is very similar to that advocated by @xcite and @xcite . i adopt a normal prior on the individual @xmath200 with mean @xmath201 and variance @xmath202 ( or covariance matrix @xmath203 ) . this reflects our prior belief that the distribution of @xmath27 is more likely to be fairly unimodal , and thus that we expect it to be more likely that the individual gaussians will be close together than far apart . if there is only one covariate , then i adopt a scaled inverse-@xmath1 prior on the individual @xmath204 with scale parameter @xmath205 and one degree of freedom , otherwise if there are @xmath206 covariates i adopt an inverse - wishart prior on the individual @xmath207 with scale matrix @xmath208 and @xmath15 degrees of freedom . this reflects our prior expectation that the variances for the individual gaussian components should be similar , but the low number of degrees of freedom accomodates a large range of scales . both the gaussian means and variances are assumed to be independent in their prior distribution , and the ` hyper - parameters ' @xmath209 ( or @xmath203 ) , and @xmath205 ( or @xmath208 ) are left unspecified . by leaving the parameters for the prior distribution unspecified , they becomes additional parameters in the statistical model , and therefore are able to adapt to the data . since the hyper - parameters are left as free parameters they also require a prior density . i assume a uniform prior on @xmath201 and @xmath205 ( or @xmath208 ) . if there is one covariate , then i assume a scaled inverse-@xmath1 prior for @xmath202 with scale parameter @xmath205 and one degree of freedom , otherwise if there are multiple covariate we assume a inverse - wishart prior for @xmath203 with scale matrix @xmath208 and @xmath15 degrees of freedom . the prior on @xmath202 ( or @xmath203 ) reflects the prior expectation that the dispersion of the gaussian components about their mean @xmath201 should be on the order of the typical dispersion of each individual gaussian . the prior density for one covariate is then @xmath210 and is summarized hierarchically as @xmath211 the prior density for multiple covariates is just the multivariate extension of equations ( [ eq - coefprior])([eq - wsqrprior ] ) . the posterior distribution summarizes our knowledge about the parameters in the statistical model , given the observed data and the priors . direct computation of the posterior distribution is too computationally intensive for the model described in this work . however , we can obtain any number of random draws from the posterior using markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) methods . in mcmc methods , we simulate a markov chain that performs a random walk through the parameter space , saving the locations of the walk at each iteration . eventually , the markov chain converges to the posterior distribution , and the saved parameter values can be treated as a random draw from the posterior . the random draws can then be used to estimate posterior medians , standard errors , of plot histogram estimates of the posterior . the easiest method for sampling from the posterior is to construct a gibbs sampler . the basic idea behind the gibbs sampler is to construct a markov chain , where new values of the model parameters and missing data are simulated at each iteration , conditional on the values of the observed data and the current values of the model parameters and the missing data . within the context of the measurement error model considered in this work , the gibbs sampler undergoes four different stages . the first stage of the gibbs sampler simulates values of the missing data , given the measured data and current parameter values , a process known as data augmentation . in this work the missing data are @xmath212 and any non - detections . in addition , i introduce an additional latent variable , @xmath213 , which gives the class membership for the @xmath93 data point . the vector @xmath213 has @xmath85 elements , where @xmath214 if the @xmath93 data point comes from the @xmath89 gaussian , and @xmath215 if @xmath216 . i will use @xmath217 to refer to the set of @xmath29 vectors @xmath218 . noting that @xmath88 gives the probability of drawing a data point from the @xmath89 gaussian , the mixture model for @xmath27 may then be expressed hierarchically as @xmath219 here , @xmath220 is a multinomial distribution with @xmath221 trials , where @xmath222 is the probability of success for the @xmath89 class on any particular trial . the vector @xmath213 is also considered to be missing data , and is introduced to simplify construction of the gibbs sampler . the new values of the missing data simulated in the data augmentation step are then used to simulate new values of the regression and gaussian mixture parameters . the second stage of the gibbs sampler simulates values of the regression parameters , @xmath6 , given the current values of @xmath223 and @xmath28 . the third stage simulates values of the mixture parameters , @xmath65 , given the current values of @xmath27 and @xmath28 . the fourth stage uses the new values of @xmath6 and @xmath65 to update the parameters of the prior density . the values of the parameters are saved , and the process is repeated , creating a markov chain . after a large number of iterations , the markov chain converges , and the saved values of @xmath6 and @xmath65 from the latter part of the algorithm may then be treated as a random draw from the posterior distribution , @xmath224 . methods for simulating random variables from the distributions used for this gibbs sampler are described in various works ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? a gibbs sampler for the gaussian mixture model is 1 . [ i - gstart ] start with initial guesses for @xmath225 and the prior parameters [ i - ycens ] if there are any non - detections , then draw @xmath41 for the censored data points from @xmath226 . this may be done by first drawing @xmath41 from @xmath227 : @xmath228 one then draws a random variable @xmath229 , uniformly - distributed on @xmath230 $ ] . if @xmath231 then the value of @xmath41 is kept , otherwise one draws a new value of @xmath41 and @xmath229 until @xmath232 . [ i - xi ] draw values of @xmath27 from @xmath233 . the distribution @xmath233 can be derived from equations ( [ eq - hierxi])([eq - hierxy ] ) or ( [ eq - mhierxi])([eq - mhierxy ] ) and the properties of the multivariate normal distribution : 1 . [ i - xi1 ] if there is only one independent variable then @xmath125 is updated as : @xmath234 \label{eq - gxihatk } \\ \hat{\xi}_{xy , i } & = & x_i + \frac{\sigma_{xy , i}}{\sigma^2_{y , i } } ( \eta_i - y_i ) \label{eq - gxixy } \\ \sigma^2_{\hat{\xi},i } & = & \sum_{k=1}^{k } g_{ik } \sigma^2_{\hat{\xi},ik } \label{eq - gxihvark } \\ \sigma^2_{\hat{\xi},ik } & = & \left [ \frac{1}{\sigma^2_{x , i}(1 - \rho^2_{xy , i } ) } + \frac{\beta^2}{\sigma^2 } + \frac{1}{\tau_k^2 } \right]^{-1}. \label{eq - gxihvar } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath235 is the correlation between the measurement errors on @xmath40 and @xmath41 . note that @xmath125 is updated using only information from the @xmath89 gaussian , since @xmath236 only for @xmath237 and @xmath215 otherwise . [ i - xi2 ] if there are multiple independent variables , i have found it easier and computationally faster to update the values of @xmath125 using a scalar gibbs sampler . in this case , the @xmath15 elements of @xmath125 are updated individually . i denote @xmath238 to be the value of the @xmath239 independent variable for the @xmath93 data point , and @xmath240 to be the measured value of @xmath238 . in addition , i denote @xmath241 to be the @xmath242-element vector obtained by removing @xmath238 from @xmath125 , i.e. , @xmath243 . similarly , @xmath244 denotes the @xmath242-element vector of regression coefficients obtained after removing @xmath245 from @xmath115 . then , @xmath238 is updated as @xmath246^{-1}. \label{eq - gmxihvark } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath247 is a @xmath136-element vector obtained by subtracting @xmath248 from @xmath249 , with the exception of the @xmath239 element of @xmath125 ; instead , the @xmath250 element of @xmath251 is just @xmath240 . the @xmath15-element vector @xmath252 is obtained in an equivalent manner . the @xmath140 matrix @xmath79 is the covariance matrix of the measurement errors on @xmath253 . the term @xmath254 denotes the @xmath250 element of the vector @xmath255 , and likewise for @xmath256 . the terms @xmath257 and @xmath258 denote the @xmath250 and @xmath239 elements of the diagonals of @xmath259 and @xmath260 , respectively . this step is repeated until all @xmath15 independent variables have been updated for each data point . + if any of the @xmath125 are measured without error , then one simply sets @xmath261 for those data points . 4 . [ i - eta ] draw values of @xmath28 from @xmath262 . similar to @xmath27 , the distribution @xmath262 can be derived from equations ( [ eq - hierxi])([eq - hierxy ] ) or ( [ eq - mhierxi])([eq - mhierxy ] ) and the properties of the multivariate normal distribution . 1 . [ i - eta1 ] if there is only one covariate then @xmath28 is updated as @xmath263 \label{eq - gmetahat } \\ \sigma^2_{\hat{\eta},i } & = & \left [ \frac{1}{\sigma^2_{y , i}(1 - \rho^2_{xy , i } ) } + \frac{1}{\sigma^2 } \right]^{-1}. \label{eq - gmetahvar } \end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . [ i - eta2 ] if there are multiple covariates then @xmath28 is updated as @xmath264^{-1 } \label{eq - gmetahvar2 } \\ { \bf z}^*_i & = & ( y_i , { \bf x}_i - \xi_i ) . \label{eq - zstar } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath265 is the first element of the vector @xmath266 , @xmath247 is a @xmath136-element vector whose first element is @xmath41 and remaining elements are @xmath267 , and @xmath268 is the first diagonal element of @xmath259 . + if any of the @xmath28 are measured without error , then one sets @xmath269 for those data points . 5 . [ i - glabel ] draw new values of the gaussian labels , @xmath217 . the conditional distribution of @xmath213 is multinomial with number of trials @xmath270 and group probabilities @xmath271 : @xmath272 note that if there is only one covariate then @xmath273 and @xmath274 . [ i - coef ] draw @xmath275 from @xmath276 . given @xmath277 and @xmath12 , the distribution of @xmath123 and @xmath115 is obtained by ordinary regression : @xmath278 here , @xmath279 is a @xmath280 matrix , where the first column is a column of ones , the second column contains the @xmath29 values of @xmath125 for the first independent variable , the third column contains the @xmath29 values of @xmath125 for the second independent variable , etc . 7 . [ i - sigsqr ] draw a new value of @xmath12 from @xmath281 . the distribution @xmath281 is derived by noting that given @xmath282 and @xmath125 , @xmath32 is normally distributed with mean @xmath283 and variance @xmath12 . re - expressing this distribution in terms of @xmath12 instead of @xmath28 , and taking the product of the distributions for each data point , it follows that @xmath12 has a scaled inverse-@xmath1 distribution : @xmath284 8 . [ i - pi ] draw new values of the group proportions , @xmath95 . given @xmath217 , @xmath95 follows a dirichlet distribution : @xmath285 note that @xmath286 is the number of data points that belong to the @xmath89 gaussian . [ i - mu ] draw a new value of @xmath200 from @xmath287 . if there is only one independent variable , then @xmath288 and @xmath289 . the new value of @xmath200 is simulated as @xmath290 10 . [ i - tausqr ] draw a new value of @xmath204 or @xmath207 . the distribution of @xmath291 or @xmath292 is derived in a manner similar to @xmath293 , and noting that the prior is conjugate for this likelihood . the distribution of @xmath294 is a scaled inverse-@xmath1 distribution , and the distribution of @xmath292 is an inverse - wishart distribution : 1 . [ i - tsqr ] if there is only one independent variable then draw @xmath295 . \label{eq - tsqr } \end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . [ i - tcovar ] if there are multiple independent variables then draw @xmath296 11 . [ i - mu0 ] draw a new value for @xmath297 . noting that conditional on @xmath201 and @xmath203 , @xmath298 are independently distributed as @xmath299 , it is straight - forward to show that @xmath300 if there is only one covariate then @xmath301 and @xmath289 . 12 . [ i - usqr0 ] draw a new value for @xmath202 or @xmath203 , given @xmath302 and @xmath205 ( or @xmath208 ) . similar to the case for @xmath303 or @xmath207 , the conditional distribution of @xmath202 or @xmath203 is scaled inverse-@xmath1 or inverse - wishart [ i - usqr ] if there is only one covariate then @xmath304 . \label{eq - usqrhat } \end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . [ i - umat ] if there are multiple covariates then @xmath305 13 . [ i - wsqr0 ] finally , draw a new value of @xmath306 or @xmath307 : 1 . [ i - wsqr ] if there is only one covariate then @xmath306 is drawn from a gamma distribution . this can be derived by noting that @xmath308 has the form of a gamma distribution as a function of @xmath205 . the new value of @xmath205 is then simulated as @xmath309 . \label{eq - b } \end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . [ i - wmat ] if there are multiple covariates then @xmath307 is drawn from a wishart distribution . this can be derived by noting that @xmath310 has the form of a wishart distribution as a function of @xmath208 . the new value of @xmath208 is then simulated as @xmath311 after completing steps [ i - ycens][i - wsqr0 ] above , an iteration of the gibbs sampler is complete . one then uses the new simulated values of @xmath312 and the prior parameters , and repeats steps [ i - ycens][i - wsqr0 ] . the algorithm is repeated until convergence , and the values of @xmath6 and @xmath65 at each iteration are saved . upon reaching convergence , one discards the values of @xmath6 and @xmath65 from the beginning of the simulation , and the remaining values of @xmath313 and @xmath166 ( or @xmath167 ) may be treated as a random draw from the posterior distribution , @xmath224 . one can then use these values to calculate estimates of the parameters , and their corresponding variances and confidence intervals . the posterior distribution of the parameters can also be estimated from these values of @xmath6 and @xmath65 using histogram techniques . techniques for monitering convergence of the markov chains can be found in @xcite . the output from the gibbs sampler may be used to perform bayesian inference on other quantities of interest . in particular , the pearson linear correlation coefficient , @xmath314 , is often used in assessing the strength of a relationship between the @xmath19 and @xmath57 . a random draw from the posterior distribution for the correlation between @xmath28 and @xmath315 , denoted as @xmath316 , can be calculated from equation ( [ eq - rho ] ) for each draw from the gibbs sampler . for the gaussian mixture model , the variance @xmath317 and covariance matrix @xmath318 are @xmath319 and @xmath320 is the @xmath239 diagonal element of @xmath321 . the simplification for one covariate is self - evident . if there is considerable posterior probability near @xmath322 or @xmath323 , then the gibbs sampler can get ` stuck ' . for example , if @xmath323 , then step [ i - xi1 ] of the gibbs sampler will draw values of @xmath324 . then , step [ i - mu ] will produce a new value of @xmath200 that is almost identical to the previous iteration , step [ i - tsqr ] will produce a new value of @xmath323 , and so on . the gibbs sampler will eventually get ` unstuck ' , but this can take a long time and result in very slow convergence . in particular , it is very easy for the gibbs sampler to get stuck if the measurement errors are large relative to @xmath12 or @xmath204 , or if the number of data points is small . in this situation i have found it useful to use the metropolis - hastings algorithm instead . if the selection function is not independent of @xmath57 , given the independent variables ( cf . eq.[[eq - trunclik ] ] ) , or if the selection function depends on @xmath19 and the measurement errors are correlated , then posterior simulation based on the gibbs sampler is more complicated . in addition , if the measurement errors are large compared to the intrinsic dispersion in the data , or if the sample size is small , then the gibbs sampler can become stuck and extremely inefficient . in both of these cases one can use the metropolis - hastings algorithm @xcite to sample from the posterior distribution , as the metropolis - hasting algorithm can avoid constructing markov chains for @xmath27 and @xmath28 . for a description of the metropolis - hastings algorithm , we refer the reader to @xcite or @xcite . in this section i perform simulations to illustrate the effectiveness of the gaussian structural model for estimating the regression parameters , even in the presence of severe measurement error and censoring . in addition , i compare the ols , bces(@xmath2 ) , and fitexy estimators with a maximum - likelihood estimator based on the gaussian mixture model with @xmath112 gaussian . the first simulation i performed is for a simple regression with one independent variable . i generated @xmath325 data sets by first drawing @xmath29 values of the independent variable , @xmath27 , from a distribution of the form @xmath326 the distribution of @xmath27 is shown in figure [ f - xidist ] , along with the best - fitting one and two gaussian approximations . in this case the two gaussian mixture is nearly indistinguishable from the actual distribution of @xmath27 , and thus should provide an excellent approximation to @xmath102 . the values for @xmath27 had a mean of @xmath327 and a dispersion of @xmath328 . i varied the number of data points in the simulated data sets as @xmath329 and @xmath330 . i then simulated values of @xmath28 according to equation ( [ eq - adderr ] ) , with @xmath331 and @xmath332 . the intrinsic scatter , @xmath34 , had a normal distribution with mean zero and standard deviation @xmath333 , and the correlation between @xmath28 and @xmath27 was @xmath334 . the joint distribution of @xmath27 and @xmath28 for one simulated data set with @xmath335 is shown in figure [ f - simdist1 ] . measured values for @xmath27 and @xmath28 were simulated according to equations ( [ eq - xerr ] ) and ( [ eq - yerr ] ) . the measurement errors had a zero mean normal distribution of varying dispersion and were independent for @xmath19 and @xmath57 . the variances in the measurement errors , @xmath336 and @xmath43 , were different for each data point and drawn from a scaled inverse-@xmath1 distribution . the degrees of freedom for the inverse-@xmath1 distribution was @xmath337 , and the scale parameters are denoted as @xmath103 and @xmath338 for the @xmath19 and @xmath57 measurement error variances , respectively . the scale parameters dictate the typical size of the measurements errors , and were varied as @xmath339 and @xmath340 . these values corresponded to values of @xmath341 and @xmath342 respectively . i simulated @xmath343 data sets for each grid point of @xmath344 and @xmath29 , giving a total of @xmath325 simulated data sets . the joint distributions of @xmath19 and @xmath57 for varying values of @xmath345 and @xmath346 are also shown in figure [ f - simdist1 ] . these values of @xmath19 and @xmath57 are the ` measured ' values of the simulated data set shown in the plot of @xmath28 as a function of @xmath27 . for each simulated data set , i calculated the maximum - likelihood estimate , found by maximizing equation ( [ eq - bobslik ] ) . for simplicity , i only use @xmath112 gaussian . i also calculated the ols , bces(@xmath2 ) , and fitexy estimates for comparison . i calculated a ols estimate of @xmath12 by subtracting the average @xmath122 from the variance in the regression residuals . if the ols estimate of @xmath12 was negative , i set @xmath347 . following @xcite , i estimate @xmath12 for a bces(@xmath2)-type estimator as @xmath348 , where @xmath349 is the average measurement error variance in @xmath57 , and @xmath350 is the bces(@xmath2 ) estimate of the slope . if @xmath351 is negative , i set @xmath352 . following @xcite , i compute a fitexy estimate of @xmath353 by increasing @xmath12 until @xmath117 , or assume @xmath118 if @xmath119 . the sampling distributions of the slope and intrinsic scatter estimators for @xmath354 are shown in figures [ f - sampdist1 ] and [ f - sampdist2 ] as a function of @xmath355 , and the results of the simulations are summarized in table [ t - univest ] . the bias of the ols estimate is apparent , becoming more severe as the measurement errors in the independent variable increase . in addition , the variance in the ols slope estimate decreases as the measurement errors in @xmath27 increase , giving one the false impression that one s estimate of the slope is more precise when the measurement errors are large . this has the effect of concentrating the ols estimate of @xmath115 around @xmath356 , thus effectively erasing any evidence of a relationship between the two variables . when the measurement errors are large , the ols estimate of the intrinsic scatter , @xmath357 , is occasionally zero . the bces(@xmath2 ) estimator performs better than the ols and fitexy estimators , being approximately unbiased when the measurement errors are @xmath358 . however , the bces estimate of the slope , @xmath359 , suffers some bias when the measurement errors are large and/or the sample size is small . in addition , the variance in @xmath360 is larger than the mle , and @xmath360 becomes considerably unstable when the measurement errors on @xmath27 are large . this instability results because the denominator in the equation for @xmath350 is @xmath361 . if @xmath362 , then the denominator is @xmath363 , and @xmath364 can become very large . similar to the ols and fitexy estimates , the estimate of the intrinsic variance for the bces - type estimator is often zero when the measurement errors are large , suggesting the false conclusion that there is no intrinsic scatter about the regression line . the fitexy estimator performed poorly in the simulations , being both biased and highly variable . the bias of the fitexy estimator is such that @xmath365 tends to overestimate @xmath115 , the severity of which tends to increase as @xmath60 decreases . this upward bias in @xmath365 has been noted by @xcite , who also performed simulations comparing @xmath365 with @xmath360 . they note that when one minimizes @xmath114 alternatively with respect to @xmath115 and @xmath12 , and iterates until convergence , then the bias in @xmath365 can be improved . i have tested this and also find that the bias in @xmath365 is reduced , but at the cost of a considerable increase in variance in @xmath365 . in general , our simulations imply that the variance of the fitexy estimator is comparable to that of the bces(@xmath2 ) estimator if one does not iterate the minimization of @xmath114 , and the variance of @xmath365 is larger if one does iterate . however , since @xmath360 is approximately unbiased when @xmath59 is not too large , @xmath360 should be preferred over @xmath365 . in addition , when the measurement errors are large the fitexy estimate of @xmath353 is commonly @xmath366 , similar to the bces - type estimate of the intrinsic dispersion . the maximum - likelihood estimator based on the gaussian structural model performs better than the ols , bces , and fitexy estimators , and gives fairly consistent estimates even in the presence of severe measurement error and low sample size . the mle is approximately unbiased , in spite of the fact that the mle incorrectly assumes that the independent variables are normally distributed . the variance in the mle of the slope , @xmath367 , is smaller than that of @xmath360 and @xmath365 , particularly when @xmath59 is large . in contrast to the ols estimate of the slope , the dispersion in @xmath367 increases as the measurement errors increases , reflecting the additional uncertainty in @xmath367 caused by the measurement errors . finally , in contrast to the other estimators , the mle of the intrinsic variance is always positive , and the probability of obtaining @xmath368 is negligible for these simulations . i argued in [ s - normreg ] that assuming a uniform distribution on @xmath27 does not lead to better estimates than the usual ols case . i also used these simulations to estimate the sampling density of the mle assuming @xmath110 . the results were nearly indistinguishable from the ols estimator , supporting our conjecture that assuming @xmath110 does not offer an improvement over ols . while it is informative to compare the sampling distribution of our proposed maximum - likelihood estimator with those of the ols , bces(@xmath2 ) , and fitexy estimators , i do not derive the uncertainties in the regression parameters from the sampling distribution of the mle . as described in [ s - markov ] , we derive the uncertainties in the regression parameters by simulating draws from the posterior distribution , @xmath224 . this allows a straight - forward method of interpreting the parameter uncertainties that does not rely on large - sample approximations , as the posterior distribution is the probability distribution of the parameters , given the observed data . the posterior distributions of @xmath369 and @xmath353 for a simulated data set with @xmath370 and @xmath371 is shown in figure [ f - post1d ] . when estimating these posteriors , i used @xmath372 gaussians in the mixture model . as can be seen from figure [ f - post1d ] , the true values of @xmath369 and @xmath353 are contained within the regions of non - negligible posterior probability . i have estimated posteriors for other simulated data sets , varying the number of data points and the degree of measurement error . as one would expect , the uncertainties in the regression parameters , represented by the widths of the posterior distributions , increase as the size of the measurement errors increase and the sample size decreases . a common frequentist approach is to compute the covariance matrix of the mle by inverting the estimated fisher information matrix , evaluated at the mle . then , under certain regularity conditions , the mle of the parameters is asympotically normally distributed with mean equal to the true value of the parameters and covariance matrix equal to the inverse of the fisher information matrix . furthermore , under these regularity conditions the posterior distribution and sampling distribution of the mle are asymptotically the same . figure [ f - fbcompare ] compares the posterior distribution of the slope for a simulated data set with that inferred from the mle . the posterior and mle was calculated assuming @xmath112 gaussian . as can be seen , the posterior distribution for @xmath115 is considerably different from the approximation based on the mle of @xmath115 , and thus the two have not converged for this sample . in particular , the posterior is more skewed and heavy - tailed , placing more probability on values of @xmath373 than does the distribution approximated by the mle . therefore , uncertainties in the mle should be interpreted with caution if using the asymptotic approximation to the sampling distribution of the mle . to assess the effectiveness of the gaussian structural model in dealing with censored data sets with measurement error , i introduced non - detections into the simulations . the simulations were performed in an identical manner as that described in [ s - sims1 ] , but now i only consider sources to be ` detected ' if @xmath374 . for those sources that were ` censored ' ( @xmath375 ) , i placed an upper limit on them of @xmath376 . i focus on the results for a simulated data set with @xmath377 data points and measurement errors similar to the intrinsic dispersion in the data , @xmath371 and @xmath378 . the detection threshold of @xmath374 resulted in a detection fraction of @xmath379 . this simulation represents a rather extreme case of large measurement errors and low detection fraction , and provides an interesting test of the method . in figure [ f - cens_reg ] i show the distribution of @xmath27 and @xmath28 , as well as the distribution of their measured values , for one of the simulated data sets . for this particular data set , there were 29 detections and 71 non - detections . as can be seen , the significant censoring and large measurement errors have effectively erased any visual evidence for a relationship between the two variables . i estimated the posterior distribution of the regression parameters for this data set using the gibbs sampler ( cf , [ s - gibbs ] ) with @xmath372 gaussians . the posterior median of the regression line , as well as the @xmath380 pointwise confidence intervals of the posterior probability . while the difference between confidence intervals and credibility intervals is not purely semantical , i do not find the difference to be significant within the context of my work , so i use the more familiar term ` confidence interval ' . ] on the regression line are shown in figure [ f - cens_reg ] . the posterior distributions for @xmath369 and @xmath353 are shown in figure [ f - censpost ] . as can be seen , the true value of the parameters is contained within the @xmath381 probability regions , although the uncertainty is large . for this particular data set , we can put limits on the value of the correlation coefficient as @xmath382 and the slope as @xmath383 . for comparison , the usual maximum - likelihood estimate that ignores the measurement error ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) concludes @xmath384 . this estimate is biased and differs from the true value of @xmath115 at a level of @xmath385 . the posterior constraints on the regression parameters are broad , reflecting our considerable uncertainty in the slope , but they are sufficient for finding a positive correlation between the two variables , @xmath27 and @xmath28 . therefore , despite the high level of censoring and measurement error in this data set , we would still be able to conclude that @xmath28 increases as @xmath27 increases . to further illustrate the effectiveness of the method , i apply it to a data set drawn from my work on investigating the x - ray properties of radio - quiet quasars ( rqqs ) . recent work has suggested a correlation between quasar x - ray spectral slope , @xmath387 and quasar eddington ratio , @xmath386 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in this section i apply the regression method to a sample of 39 @xmath4 rqqs and confirm the @xmath3@xmath386 correlation . because the purpose of this section is to illustrate the use of this regression method on real astronomical data , i defer a more in - depth analysis to a future paper . estimation of the eddington luminosity , @xmath388 , requires an estimate of the black hole mass , @xmath389 . black hole virial masses may be estimated as @xmath390 , where @xmath391 is the broad line region size , and @xmath392 is the velocity dispersion of the gas emitting the broad emission lines . a correlation has been found between the luminosity of a source and the size of it s broad line region ( the @xmath391@xmath393 relationship , e.g. , * ? ? ? one can then exploit this relationship , and use the broad line @xmath394 as an estimate for @xmath392 , obtaining virial mass estimates @xmath395 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , where the exponent is @xmath396 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? unfortunately , the uncertainty on the broad line estimates of @xmath389 can be considerable , having a standard deviation of @xmath397 dex ( e.g. , * ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . for ease of comparison with previous work , i estimate @xmath389 using only the h@xmath115 emission line . the logarithm of the virial mass estimates were calculated using the h@xmath115 luminosity and @xmath394 according to the relationship given by @xcite . my sample consists of a subset of the sample of @xcite . these sources have measurements of the x - ray photon index , @xmath398 , obtained from _ chandra _ observations , and measurements of the optical / uv luminosity at @xmath399 , denoted as @xmath400 , obtained from sdss spectra . the h@xmath115 profile was modeled as a sum of gaussians and extracted from the sdss spectra according to the procedure described in @xcite . i estimated the h@xmath115 @xmath394 and luminosity from the line profile fits . i estimate the bolometric luminosity , @xmath401 , from the luminosity at @xmath399 , assuming a constant bolometric correction @xmath402 @xcite . the standard deviation in this bolometric correction reported by @xcite is 3.1 , implying an uncertainty in @xmath403 of @xmath404 dex . combining this with the @xmath405 dex uncertainty on @xmath406 , the total ` measurement error ' on @xmath407 becomes @xmath408 dex . the distribution of @xmath3 as a function of @xmath409 is shown in figure [ f - gamx_eddrat ] . as can be seen , the measurement errors on both @xmath3 and @xmath409 are large and make a considerable contribution to the observed scatter in both variables , where @xmath410 and @xmath411 . therefore , we expect the measurement errors to have a significant effect on the correlation and regression analysis . i performed the regression assuming the linear form @xmath412 , and modelleling the intrinsic distribution of @xmath413 using @xmath372 gaussians . draws from the posterior were obtained using the gibbs sampler . the marginal posterior distributions for @xmath414 , and the correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath413 , @xmath314 , are shown in figure [ f - posthb ] , and the posterior median and @xmath381 ( @xmath415 ) pointwise intervals on the regression line are shown in figure [ f - gamx_eddrat ] . the posterior median estimate of the parameters are @xmath416 for the constant , @xmath417 for the slope , @xmath418 for the intrinsic scatter about the regression line , @xmath419 for the mean of @xmath409 , and @xmath420 dex for the dispersion in @xmath413 . here , i have used a robust estimate of the posterior standard deviation as an ` error bar ' on the parameters . these results imply that the observed scatter in @xmath409 is dominated by measurement error , @xmath421 , as expected from the large value of @xmath59 . for comparison , the bces(@xmath2 ) estimate of the slope is @xmath422 , the fitexy estimate is @xmath423 , and the ols estimate is @xmath424 ; the standard error on @xmath365 was estimated using bootstrapping . figure [ f - gamx_eddrat ] also compares the ols , bces , and fitexy best - fit lines with the posterior median estimate . the @xmath381 confidence region on the slope implied by the posterior draws is @xmath425 , whereas the approximate @xmath381 confidence region implied by the bces , fitexy , and ols standard errors are @xmath426 , @xmath427 , and @xmath428 , respectively . the ols and fitexy estimates and the bayesian approach give ` statistically significant ' evidence for a correlation between @xmath409 and @xmath3 ; however the bces estimate is too variable to rule out the null hypothesis of no correlation . as noted before , the large measurement errors on @xmath429 bias the ols estimate of @xmath115 toward shallower values and the fitexy estimate of @xmath115 toward steeper values . because of this bias , confidence regions based on @xmath47 and @xmath365 are not valid because they are not centered on the true value of @xmath115 , and thus do not contain the true value with the stated probability ( e.g. , @xmath381 ) . on the other hand , confidence regions based on the bces estimate are likely to be approximately valid ; however , in this example the large measurement errors have caused @xmath360 to be too variable to give meaningful constraints on the regression slope . the bces - type estimate of the intrinsic dispersion was @xmath430 and the ols estimate of the intrinsic dispersion was @xmath431 , where both were calculated in the same manner as in [ s - sims1 ] . the fitexy estimate of the intrinsic dispersion was @xmath366 , as @xmath119 . the bces - type estimate of @xmath353 is similar to the bayesian posterior median estimate , while @xmath432 overestimates the scatter compared to the bayesian estimate by @xmath433 . in contrast , the fitexy estimator does not find any evidence for intrinsic scatter in the regression , which is inconsistent with the posterior distribution of @xmath353 . from the posterior distribution , we can constrain the correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath409 to be @xmath434 with @xmath435 probability , confirming the positive correlation between @xmath3 and eddington ratio seen previously . the posterior median estimate of the correlation is @xmath436 , compared with an estimate of @xmath437 if one naively calculates the correlation directly from the measured data . the large measurement errors significantly attenuate the observed correlation , making the observed correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath413 appear weaker than if one does not correct for the measurement errors . in this work i have derived a likelihood function for handling measurement errors in linear regression of astronomical data . our probability model assumes that the measurement errors are gaussian with zero mean and known variance , that the intrinsic scatter in the dependent variable about the regression line is gaussian , and that the intrinsic distribution of the independent variables can be well approximated as a mixture of gaussians . i extend this model to enable the inclusion of non - detections , and describe how to incorporate the data selection process . a gibbs sampler is described to enable simulating random draws from the posterior distribution . i illustrated the effectiveness of structural gaussian mixture model using simulation . for the specific simulations performed , a maximum - likelihood estimator based on the gaussian structural model performed better than the ols , bces(@xmath2 ) , and fitexy estimators , especially when the measurement errors were large . in addition , our method also performed well when the measurement errors were large and the detection fraction was small , with the posterior distributions giving reasonable bounds on the regression parameters . these results were in spite of the fact that the intrinsic distribution of the independent variable was not a sum of gaussians for the simulations , suggesting that approximating the distribution of the independent variable as a mixture of gaussians does not lead to a significant bias in the results . finally , i concluded by using the method to fit the radio - quiet quasar x - ray photon index as a function of @xmath409 , using a sample of 39 @xmath4 sources . the posterior distribution for this data set constrained the slope to be @xmath438 and the linear correlation coefficient to be @xmath439 , confirming the correlation between x - ray spectral slope and eddington ratio seen by other authors . although i have focused on linear regression in this work , the approach that i have taken is quite general and can be applied to other applications . in particular , equations ( [ eq - obslik2 ] ) , ( [ eq - trunclik ] ) , and ( [ eq - censlik ] ) are derived under general conditions and are not limited to regression . in this work , i assume forms for the respective probability densities that are appropriate for linear regression ; however , these equation provide a framework for constructing more general probability models of one s data , as in , for example , nonlinear fitting * ? ? ? * or estimation of luminosity functions . this work was supported in part by nsf grant ast-0307384 . the author would like to thank the referee for comments that contributed to the improvement of this paper , and for providing some of the references to the statistics literature . the author would also like to thank jill bechtold , eric feigelson , and aneta siemiginowska for looking over and offering helpful comments on an early version of this paper . aitken , m. , & rocci , r. , 2002 , statistics and computing , 12 , 163 akritas , m. g. , & bershady , m. a. 1996 , , 470 , 706 akritas , m. g. , & siebert , j. 1996 , , 278 , 919 barker , d. r. , & diana , l. m. 1974 , am . j. phys . , 42 , 224 carroll , r. j. , roeder , k. , & wasserman , l. , 1999 , biometrics , 55 , 44 carroll , r. j. , ruppert , d. , & stefanski , l. a. , 1995 , measurement error in nonlinear models ( london : chapman & hall ) chib , s. , & greenberg , e. 1995 , amer . stat . , 49 , 327 clutton - brock , m. 1967 , technometrics , 9 , 261 davison , a. c. , & hinkley , d. v. 1997 , bootstrap methods and their application ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) dellaportas , p. , stephens , d. a. , 1995 , biometrics , 51 , 1085 dempster , a. , laird , n. , & rubin , d. 1977 , j. r. statist . b. , 39 , 1 efron , b. 1979 , ann . , 7 , 1 elvis , m. , et al . 1994 , , 95 , 1 feigelson , e. d. , & nelson , p. i. 1985 , , 293 , 192 feigelson , e. d. , 1992 , in statistical challenges in modern astronomy , ed . e. feigelson & g. babu , ( new york : springer - verlag ) fox , j. 1997 , applied regression analysis , linear models , and related methods ( thousand oaks : sage publications , inc . ) freedman , l. s. , fainberg , v. , kipnis , v. , midthune , d. , & carrol , r. j. , 2004 , biometrics , 60 , 172 fuller , w. a. 1987 , measurement error models ( new york : john wiley & sons ) gelman , a. , carlin , j. b. , stern , h. s. , & rubin , d. b. 2004 , bayesian data analysis ( 2nd ed . ; boca raton : chapman & hall / crc ) gull , s. f. 1989 , in maximum entropy and bayesian methods , ed . j. skilling , ( dordrecht : kluwer academic publishers ) 511 hastings , w. k. 1970 , biometrika , 57 , 97 huang , x. , stefanski , l. a. , & davidian , m. 2006 , biometrika , 93 , 53 isobe , t. , feigelson , e. d. , & nelson , p. i. 1986 , , 306 , 490 isobe , t. , feigelson , e. d. , akritas , m. g. , & babu , g. j. 1990 , , 364 , 104 kaspi , s. , maoz , d. , netzer , h. , peterson , b. m. , vestergaard , m. , & jannuzi , b. t. 2005 , , 629 , 61 kelly , b. c. , bechtold , j. , siemiginowska , a. , aldcroft , t. , & sobolewska , m. 2007 , , 657 , 116 kelly , b. c. , & bechtold , j. 2007 , , 168 , 1 landy , s. d. , & szalay , a. s. 1992 , , 391 , 494 little , r. j. a. , & rubin , d. b. 2002 , statistical analysis with missing data ( 2nd ed . ; hoboken : john wiley & sons ) loredo , t. j. , 1992 , in statistical challenges in modern astronomy , ed . e. feigelson & g. babu , ( new york : springer - verlag ) marshall , h. l. , 1992 , in statistical challenges in modern astronomy , ed . e. feigelson & g. babu , ( new york : springer - verlag ) mclure , r. j. , & jarvis , m. j. 2002 , , 337 , 109 metropolis , n. , & ulam , s. 1949 , j. amer . assoc . , 44 , 335 metropolis , n. , rosenbluth , a. w. , rosenbluth , m. n. , teller , a. h. , & teller , e. 1953 , j. chem . phys . , 21 , 1087 mller , p. , & roeder , k. , 1997 , biometrika , 84 , 523 piconcelli , e. , jimenez - bailn , e. , guainazzi , m. , schartel , n. , rodrguez - pascual , p. m. , & santos - lle , m. 2005 , , 432 , 15 porquet , d. , reeves , j. n. , obrien , p. , & brinkmann , w. 2004 , , 422 , 85 press , w. h. , teukolsky , s. a. , vetterling , w. t. , & flannery , b. p. 1992 , numerical recipes ( second ed . ; cambridge : cambridge unv . press ) richardson , s. , & leblond , l. , 1997 , statistics in medicine , 16 , 203 richardson , s. , leblond , l. , jaussent , i. , & green , p. j. , 2002 , j. r. statist . a , 165 , 549 ripley , b. d. 1987 , stochastic simulation ( new york : john wiley & sons ) roeder , k. , & wasserman , l. 1997 , j. amer . assoc . , 92 , 894 roy , s. , banerjee , t. , 2006 , ann . instit . statist . math . , 58 , 153 schafer , d. w. , 1987 , 74 , 385 schafer , d. w. , 2001 , biometrics , 57 , 53 scheines , r. , hoijtink , h. , boomsma , a. , 1999 , psychometrika , 64 , 37 schmitt , j. h. m. m. 1985 , , 293 , 178 shemmer , o. , brandt , w. n. , netzer , h. , maiolino , r. , & kaspi , s. 2006 , , 646 , l29 stapleton , d. c. & young , d. j. 1984 , econometrica , 52 , 737 tremaine , s. , et al . 2002 , , 574 , 740 vestergaard , m. , & peterson , b. m. 2006 , , 641 , 689 wandel , a. , peterson , b. m. , & malkan , m. a. 1999 , , 526 , 579 weiner , b. j. , et al . 2006 , , 653 , 1049 weiss , a. a. , 1993 , j. econometrics . , 56 , 169 . zellner , a. 1971 , an introduction to bayesian inference in econometrics ( new york : john wiley & sons ) and @xmath27 ( left ) , and the measured values of @xmath57 and @xmath19 ( right ) , from a simulated censored data set of @xmath354 data points , @xmath378 , and @xmath371 ( cf . , [ s - sims2 ] ) . in the plot of @xmath28 and @xmath27 , the solid squares denote the values of @xmath27 and @xmath28 for the detected data points , and the hollow squares denote the values of @xmath27 and @xmath28 for the undetected data points . the solid line in both plots is the true regression line . in the plot of @xmath57 and @xmath19 , the squares denote the measured values of @xmath19 and @xmath57 for the detected data points , and the arrows denote the ` upper limits ' on @xmath57 for the undetected data points . the fictitious data point with error bars illustrates the median values of the error bars . the dashed - dotted line shows the best fit regression line , as calculated from the posterior median of @xmath123 and @xmath115 , and the filled region defines the approximate @xmath381 @xmath440 pointwise confidence intervals on the regression line . the true values of the regression line are contained within the @xmath381 confidence intervals.[f - cens_reg],title="fig : " ] and @xmath27 ( left ) , and the measured values of @xmath57 and @xmath19 ( right ) , from a simulated censored data set of @xmath354 data points , @xmath378 , and @xmath371 ( cf . , [ s - sims2 ] ) . in the plot of @xmath28 and @xmath27 , the solid squares denote the values of @xmath27 and @xmath28 for the detected data points , and the hollow squares denote the values of @xmath27 and @xmath28 for the undetected data points . the solid line in both plots is the true regression line . in the plot of @xmath57 and @xmath19 , the squares denote the measured values of @xmath19 and @xmath57 for the detected data points , and the arrows denote the ` upper limits ' on @xmath57 for the undetected data points . the fictitious data point with error bars illustrates the median values of the error bars . the dashed - dotted line shows the best fit regression line , as calculated from the posterior median of @xmath123 and @xmath115 , and the filled region defines the approximate @xmath381 @xmath440 pointwise confidence intervals on the regression line . the true values of the regression line are contained within the @xmath381 confidence intervals.[f - cens_reg],title="fig : " ] , as a function of @xmath409 for 39 @xmath0 radio - quiet quasars . in both plots the thick solid line shows the posterior median estimate ( pme ) of the regression line . in the left plot , the filled region denotes the @xmath381 @xmath440 pointwise confidence intervals on the regression line . in the right plot , the thin solid line shows the ols estimate , the dashed line shows the fitexy estimate , and the dot - dashed line shows the bces(@xmath2 ) estimate ; the error bars have been omitted for clarity . a significant positive trend is implied by the data.[f - gamx_eddrat],title="fig : " ] , as a function of @xmath409 for 39 @xmath0 radio - quiet quasars . in both plots the thick solid line shows the posterior median estimate ( pme ) of the regression line . in the left plot , the filled region denotes the @xmath381 @xmath440 pointwise confidence intervals on the regression line . in the right plot , the thin solid line shows the ols estimate , the dashed line shows the fitexy estimate , and the dot - dashed line shows the bces(@xmath2 ) estimate ; the error bars have been omitted for clarity . a significant positive trend is implied by the data.[f - gamx_eddrat],title="fig : " ] cccccccccc 0.5 & 25 & @xmath441 & @xmath442 & @xmath443 & @xmath444 & @xmath445 & @xmath446 & @xmath447 & @xmath448 + & 50 & @xmath449 & @xmath450 & @xmath451 & @xmath452 & @xmath453 & @xmath454 & @xmath455 & @xmath456 + & 100 & @xmath457 & @xmath458 & @xmath459 & @xmath460 & @xmath461 & @xmath462 & @xmath463 & @xmath464 + 1.0 & 25 & @xmath465 & @xmath466 & @xmath467 & @xmath468 & @xmath469 & @xmath470 & @xmath471 & @xmath472 + & 50 & @xmath473 & @xmath474 & @xmath475 & @xmath476 & @xmath477 & @xmath478 & @xmath479 & @xmath480 + & 100 & @xmath481 & @xmath482 & @xmath483 & @xmath484 & @xmath485 & @xmath486 & @xmath487 & @xmath488 + 2.0 & 25 & @xmath489 & @xmath490 & @xmath491 & @xmath492 & @xmath493 & @xmath494 & @xmath495 & @xmath496 + & 50 & @xmath497 & @xmath498 & @xmath499 & @xmath500 & @xmath501 & @xmath502 & @xmath503 & @xmath504 + & 100 & @xmath505 & @xmath506 & @xmath507 & @xmath508 & @xmath509 & @xmath510 & @xmath511 & @xmath512 + Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: solutions of highly - charged polyelectrolytes , such as biopolymers ( dna , proteins , _ etc . _ ) and many synthetic polyelectrolytes , exhibit striking phenomena while multivalent salts or charged molecules are added into the solutions @xcite . if the concentration of the added salt lies within a window of concentration , the solution is separated in two phases : one is a viscous phase containing condensed or precipitated polyelectrolytes , and the other is a dilute phase in which polyelectrolytes are dissolved . if it lies outside the window , the solution is in a homogeneous phase . these phenomena are called `` reentrant condensation '' @xcite , or commonly referred as `` dna condensation '' in the fields of biology and medicine @xcite . this topic has attracted much attention recently due to its potential application in developing nonviral vectors of dna for the purpose of gene therapy @xcite . the amount of salt which results in the phase separation is determined by many factors , such as valence of salt , temperature , chain structure , and concentration of polyelectrolytes @xcite . it is known that the lower boundary of the window depends linearly on the concentration of polyelectrolytes but the upper one of the window is insensitive to it and roughly a constant . both flexible polyelectrolytes and stiff polyelectrolytes display similar phase diagrams @xcite . despite decades of effort , our understanding on polyelectrolytes is still limited and many issues , including the reentrant condensation , are far from being resolved @xcite . the aim of this paper is to investigate the properties of polyelectrolytes in salt solutions by means of computer simulations . there have been many simulations devoted to the study of polyelectrolytes @xcite . however , most of them investigated the properties in salt - free solutions @xcite . only recently , due to the progress of computing power , large - scale simulations for systems with added salt can be realized . the works included , for example , flexible chains in monovalent or multivalent salt solutions @xcite , semiflexible chains with multivalent salt or charged molecules @xcite , and rigid chains in the presence of multivalent salts @xcite . but the salt concentration or the salt valence was not large enough to observe any significant evidence being able to connect to the redissolution of polyelectrolytes . therefore , the reentrant condensation could not be discussed thoroughly in these works . et al . _ @xcite recently studied the effective interaction between two immobile dnas in the presence of tetravalent counterions . they have found that the effective interaction yields an attractive minimum at short distances which then disappears in favor of a shallow minimum at large separations , indicating the occurrence of dna condensation and redissolution and a novel stable mesocrystal . in a more recent study @xcite , we have investigated the properties of mobile polyelectrolytes in tetravalent salt solutions and demonstrated that following a collapsed transition , polyelectrolytes undergo reexpanding transition upon addition of the salt . this phenomenon is just a single - chain version of the condensation and the redissolution of polyelectrolytes . moreover , by varying the ion size , we have shown that the excluded volume of ions plays a decisive role on the reentrant condensation . however , to well understand the phenomena , there is still a far way to go . for example , is it possible to obtain any information related to the phase boundary of reentrant condensation from simulations ? there exist theories to explain the phase boundary @xcite but it has never been studied in simulations . concerning the size of polyelectrolyte in multivalent salts , muthukumar and coworkers have applied single and double screening theories to explain the collapsed transition of chains @xcite . however , no existing theory can predict chain reexpansion in the region of high salt concentration . moreover , chain morphology is essential to understand the properties of polyelectrolytes . it can be described by many quantities , such as asphericity and prolateness parameter @xcite . to our knowledge , no such study has been reported yet for strongly - charged polyelectrolytes . an alternative way to understand polymers is to study scaling behavior . although the concept of scaling has been successfully applied to neutral polymers @xcite , application of this concept to polyelectrolytes @xcite has encountered many difficulties owing to the long - range nature of coulomb interaction . in this paper , we compute the single - chain structure factor . the swelling exponent is then calculated by studying the power - law - like regime of the structure factor . since properties of polyelectrolytes depend strongly on ion size , we investigate in this paper the effect of ion size too . in our previous work @xcite , the sizes of ions were set to identical and varied simultaneously . as a consequence , bjerrum association @xcite was strongly intervened , particularly when ions were small . this setup has a disadvantage that the system was easily jammed by large ions , leading to the impossibility of investigation of the cases of big ions . therefore , in this study we vary only the size of the multivalent counterions and fix unchanged the one of the other ions , so that the ion size effect is restrictedly investigated . in the study of polyelectrolytes , it is tempting to discuss the long range nature of coulomb interaction using the concept of electrostatic persistence length . odijk @xcite , skolnick and fixman @xcite predicted that the electrostatic persistence length is proportional to the square of the screening length @xmath0 . the deduction was based upon debye - hckel theory . consequently , the effective intramolecular interaction is always repulsive , resulting in a positive electrostatic persistence length @xcite . however , experiments have shown that electrostatic persistence length can be negative under certain condition so that electrostatics gives a reversed contribution to chain flexibility @xcite . simulations on this issue @xcite were mainly performed within debye - hckel approximation using a screened coulomb potential @xmath1 to describe the screening effect of salt without involving explicitly salt ions . a negative electrostatic persistence length , hence , has never been reproduced in the simulations . noticeably , it is known that linear screening theory is valid only for a weakly - charged system and breaks down for a highly - charged one , such as dna and many biopolymers , due to strong ion correlations @xcite . recently , by employing a loop expansion method which goes beyond mean field , ariel and andelman were able to predict the negative regime of the electrostatic persistence length for a strongly - charged rodlike polyelectrolyte @xcite . therefore , we expect that to observe a negative electrostatic persistence length , one should incorporate salt ions explicitly and use the bare coulomb potential in simulations . our study fulfills this requirement and hence offer a good chance to verify the above phenomenon and theory . charge inversion is a universal phenomenon , occurred when a strongly charged macroion binds so many counterions that its net charge alters sign @xcite . _ intended to link charge inversion with the reentrant condensation of polyelectrolytes @xcite . the idea was based upon that counterions form strongly correlated liquid on the surface of polyelectrolytes . in an intermediate salt region , the bare charges of the chains are almost neutralized by the condensed counterions ; the correlation - induced attraction results in the condensation of polyelectrolytes . in a high - salt region , the counterions overcompensate the chain bare charges ; coulomb repulsion between chains dominates the attraction and , in consequence , the condensates are redissolved into the solution . solis and olvera de la cruz gave a different point of view using a theory called `` two - state model '' @xcite . they predicted that charge inversion is not necessarily occurred with redissolution of polyelectrolytes . although overcompensated by counterions , the redissolved polyelectrolytes can have either sign due to the association of coions @xcite . this association depends strongly on the ion size which was not considered in the study of nguyen _ et al . _ @xcite . therefore , solis and olvera de la cruz predicted a charge distribution which oscillates from a polyelectrolyte , in accordance with the profile observed in our previous work @xcite . in this paper , we investigate more extreme cases , including much smaller and much larger ions . we also study like - charge attraction between chains by calculating the potential of mean force and determine the conditions under which the attraction takes place . the rest of the article is organized as follows . model and simulation details are given in sec . [ sec_model_method ] . results are discussed in sec . [ sec_result_discussion ] . it is divided into five subsections . the first subsection ( sec . [ sec_rg2_cm ] ) is devoted to the study of the radius of gyration of a polyelectrolyte where salt concentration and polyelectrolyte concentration are varied . the results provide information helpful in understanding the boundaries of the condensation window . [ sec_shape ] studies the morphology of multiple polyelectrolytes in salt solutions . we compute several quantities , including shape factors , asphericity , and prolateness parameter . the effect of size of multivalent ions is discussed . single - chain structure factor is , then , calculated in sec . [ sec_sf ] . by least - square fitting the power - law - like regime , we compute the swelling exponent of a polyelectrolyte , which provides a fundamental vision how strongly - charged polyelectrolytes scale in salt solutions . sec . [ sec_lp ] deals with persistence length . the negative regime of the electrostatic persistence length is successfully reproduced in the simulations . comparison of the results with theoretical predictions is made . [ sec_pmf ] provides a general picture of the effective interaction between polyelectrolytes by computing the potential of mean force . as long as knowing the condition to appear like - charge attraction between chains and the integrated charge distribution around a chain ( sec . [ sec_iondist ] ) , we are able to arbitrate if the phenomena of charge inversion and the redissolution of polyelectrolytes are related . we give our conclusions in sec . [ sec_conclusion ] . we employed a coarse - grained model to simulate a polyelectrolyte system . the system contains four bead - spring chains , one of which is composed of 48 beads ( monomers ) . each monomer dissociates a monovalent cation ( counterion ) into a solution and carries a negative unit charge . there are totally 192 monovalent cations in the solution . solvent molecules are not modeled explicitly . their effect is taken into account implicitly by considering them as a medium of constant dielectric constant . the geometry of the medium is cubic and periodic boundary condition is applied to simulate bulk environment . salt molecules are added into the system . in the solution , they are dissociated into cations ( counterions ) and anions ( coions ) . we assume that the cations are tetravalent and the anions are monovalent . the amount of the cations and anions obeys the condition of charge neutrality . three types of interactions are included in our simulations . the first one is the excluded volume interaction described by a purely repulsive lennard - jones ( lj ) potential , @xmath2 + \varepsilon_{\rm lj } & \mbox{\ for $ r \le \root 6 \of 2 \sigma$\;}\\ 0 & \mbox{\ for $ r > \root 6 \of 2 \sigma$\ ; } \end{array } \right.,\ ] ] where @xmath3 is the distance between two particles , @xmath4 is the interaction strength , and @xmath5 is the collision diameter . we assume that all the particles have identical @xmath4 but the collision diameter may be different . the collision diameters for monomer , monovalent cation , tetravalent cation , and anion are denoted by @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 , respectively . lorentz - berthelot mixing rule @xcite is applied for the interaction between different kinds of particles . the second interaction is called finitely extensible nonlinear elastic ( fene ) potential @xcite and used to describe the bond connection between adjacent monomers on a chain . it reads as @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the spring constant , @xmath12 is bond length , and @xmath13 is the maximum extension of a bond . all particles interact via the third interaction , coulomb interaction , which is written as @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the charge of the @xmath16th particle , @xmath17 is the temperature , @xmath18 is the boltzmann constant , and @xmath19 is the bjerrum length defined as the separation distance at which the coulomb potential between two unit charges @xmath20 equals to the thermal energy @xmath21 . @xmath19 is equal to @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the dielectric constant and @xmath24 is the vacuum permittivity . we perform molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations in this study sjplimp / lammps.html . ] . we set @xmath7 and @xmath9 equal to @xmath6 and vary the size of tetravalent cation @xmath8 from @xmath25 to @xmath26 to investigate the effect of ion size on properties of the polyelectrolyte solution . simulation parameters are chosen as follows : @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 . the bjerrum length is set to @xmath30 . similar systems in salt - free solutions have been investigated by stevens and kremer @xcite . we assume that the masses of all the particles are identical and equal to @xmath31 , and choose @xmath6 and @xmath32 to be the length unit and the energy unit , respectively . therefore , the natural time unit is @xmath33 . the system is studied in canonical ensemble where the temperature is controlled using nos - hoover thermostat with the frequency of heat transfer with thermostat equal to @xmath34 . coulomb interaction is calculated by the technique of ewald sum . except in sec . [ sec_rg2_cm ] , the monomer concentration is fixed at @xmath35 which corresponds to a box size @xmath36 , whereas the salt concentration is varied . the amount of salt is controlled such that the volume fraction of total particles is smaller than @xmath37 . equations of motion are integrated applying verlet algorithm where time step is set to @xmath38 . each simulation starts with an equilibration phase of @xmath39 md steps and is followed by a production run of @xmath40 md steps in which data are collected every 1000 steps . in order to shorten the notation , we will use @xmath6 as the length unit , @xmath41 as the concentration unit , and @xmath20 as the charge unit in the following text . we started our study by simulating a single polyelectrolyte with added tetravalent salt at various monomer concentrations . the chain consists of 48 monomers and the size of the tetravalent cations is set to be identical to the one of the monomers . we used the radius of gyration to characterize the chain size . the radius of gyration @xmath42 is calculated by the equation @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the number of monomers on the chain , @xmath45 is the position vector of the @xmath16th monomer , and @xmath46 the center of mass of the chain . the results are presented in fig . [ cm_p1n48_rg2.eps ] where the mean square radius of gyration @xmath47 is plotted as a function of salt concentration @xmath48 at four monomer concentrations , @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 . as a function of @xmath48 at four monomer concentrations , @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . the symbols used to represent the four @xmath53 are indicated at the left - bottom side of the figure . the value of @xmath47 in a salt - free solution ( @xmath48=0.0 ) is depicted near the left vertical axis . the four curves in the regime @xmath54 can overlap each other ( shown in the inset ) under a suitable transformation described in the text . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] the angular bracket @xmath55 means averaging over chain configurations . two behaviors were observed . the first one is that each curve displays a similar trend of behavior against salt concentration . upon addition of salt , the chain undergoes two structural transitions : a collapsed transition and a followed reexpanding transition , as having been observed in the previous work @xcite . the first transition results from the screening of the coulomb interaction by the added salt . the second transition is still not well understood although it is a result of the competition between energetic gain and entropic loose in counterion condensation and in shape transformation of polyelectrolytes to minimize the free energy . we observed that the minimum of @xmath47 appears near the salt concentration @xmath56 and the more dilute the monomer concentration , the smaller value the minimum of @xmath47 will be . @xmath57 is the equivalence point at which the amount of charges of the tetravalent counterions exactly neutralizes the charges on polyelectrolytes as if the salts and the polyelectrolytes are in the stoichiometric reaction . we will call @xmath57 the equivalence concentration . in a salt - free solution ( @xmath58 ) , we found that the chain size increases with decreasing monomer concentration ( refer to the four data points near the left vertical axis of the figure ) . this effect has been discussed in literatures @xcite and our results are in accordance with them . and the second behavior is that @xmath47 for different @xmath53 attains approximately the same value while the salt concentration is larger than the equivalence concentration . therefore , the curves approximately overlap each other . we noticed , furthermore , that in the region @xmath54 , the @xmath47 curves for different @xmath53 can also lie over each other under an appropriate transformation . we demonstrate this overlap in the inset of fig . [ cm_p1n48_rg2.eps ] where the abscissa is @xmath59 and the ordinate is @xmath60 with @xmath61 the minimum value of @xmath47 . @xmath62 depends smoothly on @xmath53 and , in the figure , is equal to @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 for @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 , respectively . the size of polyelectrolytes in multivalent salt solutions has been studied by small - angle scattering experiments @xcite . the results showed that it diminishes with increasing or decreasing @xmath48 toward the region where the condensation of polyelectrolytes occurs ( cf . table 2 of ref . the results of our simulations are in accordance with the experiments . we make a hypothesis that chain size can be served as a qualitative condition to distinguish between a monophasic solution of polyelectrolyte and a diphasic one . more precisely , if the chain size is larger than some value , the chains are dissolved in the solution and the system is in a homogeneous phase ; if it is smaller , the chains are precipitated from the solution and a phase separation occurs . under this hypothesis , polyelectrolyte solutions of different @xmath53 become monophasic as @xmath67 is increased over a concentration in the high - salt region , since the chain size exceeds the some value nearly at the same @xmath48 due to the similarity of the @xmath47 curves against @xmath48 in this region . therefore , the upper boundary of the salt concentration window for the condensation of polyelectrolyte is independent of @xmath53 . similarly , the lower boundary of the window approximately depends linearly on @xmath53 , owing to the similarity of the @xmath60 curves against @xmath59 in the low - salt region ; the weak dependence of @xmath62 and @xmath61 on @xmath53 ensures that the chain size surpasses the some value roughly at the same @xmath59 . therefore , fig . [ cm_p1n48_rg2.eps ] provides an essential information to understand the boundaries of reentrant condensation . the aim of this article is to understand the properties of multiple flexible polyelectrolytes with added salt in an aqueous solution . it is known that the bjerrum length @xmath19 in water is equal to 7.14 at room temperature . our simulation setup , hence , corresponds to a collision diameter @xmath6 of monomer equal to 2.38 . this model represents a polyelectrolyte system with linear charge density equal to a unit charge per @xmath68 . ] , and can be employed to simulate a strongly - charged system such as sodium polystyrene sulfonate . the four monomer concentrations studied in this section , while converted to real unit , are equal to 0.039 m , 0.246 m , 0.986 m , and 1.971 m , respectively . even the largest @xmath53 is still smaller than the overlap threshold @xmath69 estimated by @xmath70 . therefore , our systems are dilute polymer solutions . readers should be aware that the value up to nearly 2 m is a very high monomer concentration for a real polymer system , and our systems are _ dilute _ only in the formal meaning of the world since the chains are very short . in the following sections , we fix @xmath53 at 0.008 and simulate a system comprising multiple chains . this monomer concentration is one or two order of magnitude higher than a typical monomer concentration used in experiments @xcite . however , based on the fact that systems at different monomer concentrations reveal similar evolution of chain size against salt concentration , the results obtained at @xmath71 can be used to understand a system at more dilute @xmath53 . we mention that this @xmath53 is a choice so that the simulation box is not so big . therefore , the amount of the added salt is controllable under limited computing resources . consequently , to study the behavior of polyelectrolytes in salt solutions , covering a broad range of salt concentration , becomes numerically feasible . in this section and in the followings , the studied system contains four polyelectrolytes and the monomer concentration is fixed at @xmath71 . this section is devoted to the study of chain conformation in tetravalent salt solutions . the effects of salt concentration and size of tetravalent counterions are investigated . we vary the size of tetravalent counterion , @xmath8 , from 0.0 to 4.0 and fix the size of the other ions at 1.0 . a large @xmath8 can represent a large cation , a large ion group , or a large charged colloid . it can be also a result of the hydration of a small ion . a small @xmath8 may be less representative for real systems but theorists are generally interested in it because many models are established on the base of vanishing ion size . morphology of a polymer can be quantified by many quantities . the first quantity that we studied is the shape factor @xmath72 , defined as the ratio of the mean - square end - to - end distance , @xmath73 , to the mean - square radius of gyration @xmath47 . @xmath72 attains a value 12 for a rodlike polymer , 6.3 for a flexible chain in a good solvent , and 6 for an ideal chain @xcite . for a compact structure , the value of @xmath72 is small . for example , if the chain has a spherical morphology and the two ends are randomly positioned , @xmath72 is equal to 2 . in fig.[shapep4n48_eta1&xi1.eps](a ) , we show how the shape factor @xmath72 varies with @xmath48 at different @xmath8 . as a function of @xmath48 , and ( b ) @xmath74 as a function of @xmath48 , for the cases of different size @xmath8 of the tetravalent counterions . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figures . the error bars are smaller than the size of the symbols . the result for neutral polymers is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ( a ) as a function of @xmath48 , and ( b ) @xmath74 as a function of @xmath48 , for the cases of different size @xmath8 of the tetravalent counterions . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figures . the error bars are smaller than the size of the symbols . the result for neutral polymers is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ( b ) in the figure , a reference curve , marked by `` neutral '' , is depicted . it represents a system composed of four neutral polymers of 48 monomers in tetravalent salt ( @xmath75 ) solutions . focus firstly on the polyelectrolyte solutions with @xmath76 , 1.4 and 2.0 . we witnessed that @xmath72 decreases at first and then increases upon addition of salt , in analogy of the radius of gyration studied in the previous section , and shows a v - shaped curve against @xmath48 in the semilog plot . in the low - salt region or in the high - salt region , @xmath72 is larger than or close to the value 6.3 , indicating that the chains have elongated or coil - like structures . in between , it appears a minimum near the equivalence concentration @xmath77 . the value of @xmath72 tells us that the chains possess compact structures but not so compact as spheres . for the cases with larger @xmath8 ( @xmath78 and @xmath79 ) , @xmath72 shows a shallow minimum and the whole curve stays basically above the value 6.3 . in these cases , the chains are in an extended state . it is worth to notice that for @xmath80 , @xmath72 , in principle , increases with @xmath8 at a given @xmath48 . now pay attention to the cases with @xmath81 . @xmath72 displays a similar v - shaped curve against @xmath48 but opposite to the previous cases , its value increases with decreasing @xmath8 . moreover , the degree of chain reexpansion in the high - salt region is weakened while @xmath8 is decreased . noticeably , for the case @xmath82 , @xmath72 displays a sharp transition from a value 7.2 in the low - salt solution to a value 6.5 in the vicinity of @xmath57 . in the latter region , the chains behave similarly to neutral polymers . the second quantity that we studied is @xmath83 , which is the ratio of the radius of gyration @xmath84 to the hydrodynamic radius @xmath85 computed by @xmath86 . @xmath83 is equal to @xmath87 for a hard sphere and attains a value 2.25 for a rodlike chain @xcite . renormalization group theory has predicted @xmath88 in a good solvent and @xmath89 at @xmath90 point @xcite , both of which have been shown in agreement with experiments @xcite . we present in fig . [ shapep4n48_eta1&xi1.eps](b ) the variation of @xmath83 against @xmath48 . the referenced curve for the system of neutral polymers is depicted . the curve was found very close to the value 1.24 , which seems to indicate an ideal - chain behavior . however , the neutral chains should behave as random coils and the value of @xmath83 would be larger than 1.24 . the deviation of @xmath83 from the value of a coil is probably due to the short chain length used in our simulations . _ have studied the finite size effect and shown that the dependence of @xmath83 on chain length is not negligible @xcite . therefore , @xmath83 reported here departs slightly from the asymptotic value of an infinite chain length . nonetheless , the results are still indicative and useful to understand how @xmath83 varies with salt concentration . in the small @xmath48 region , the polyelectrolytes are more extended than the neutral polymers . in the middle region of @xmath48 , the chains attain compact structures when @xmath91 . the dependence of @xmath83 upon @xmath8 resembles to that of @xmath72 . for large @xmath8 ( @xmath92 , the chains are elongated . for vanishing @xmath8 , we observed that following a sharp decrease , @xmath83 reattains approximately a constant value , close to that for the neutral polymers . a more fundamental way to study the shape of a polymer is to investigate the tensor of radius of gyration @xmath93 @xcite , defined by : @xmath94 where @xmath95 , @xmath96 denote the three cartesian components and @xmath97 is the @xmath95 component of the position of the @xmath16th monomer . let @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath100 be the three eigenvalues of @xmath101 . a quantity called `` asphericity '' @xcite , which measures the deformation from a spherical geometry , is defined by @xmath102 it takes a value between 0 ( sphere ) and 1 ( rod ) . for a coil polymer , it is 0.431 obtained from simulations @xcite . another quantity describing the degree of prolateness is defined by @xmath103 where @xmath104 @xcite . it is ranged from @xmath105 to @xmath106 and can be used to distinguish between a prolate shape ( @xmath107 ) and an oblate one ( @xmath108 ) . for neutral polymers in the dilute limit , simulations predict a prolate chain with @xmath109 @xcite . we present in figs . [ shapep4n48_asph&sp.eps](a ) and [ shapep4n48_asph&sp.eps](b ) the asphericity @xmath110 and the prolateness parameter @xmath111 as a function of @xmath48 . as a function of @xmath48 , and ( b ) @xmath111 as a function of @xmath48 , for different @xmath8 . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figures . the error bars are smaller than the size of the symbols . the result for neutral polymers is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ( a ) as a function of @xmath48 , and ( b ) @xmath111 as a function of @xmath48 , for different @xmath8 . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figures . the error bars are smaller than the size of the symbols . the result for neutral polymers is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ( b ) resembling to the behaviors of @xmath72 and @xmath83 , @xmath110 and @xmath111 show a minimum value in the vicinity of @xmath57 . the curve associated to @xmath75 roughly separates two different behaviors of evolution : @xmath110 and @xmath111 increase with increasing and with decreasing @xmath8 from 1.0 . the value of @xmath110 lies between 0.275 and 0.55 . therefore , even in a compact structure ( where @xmath48 is near @xmath57 ) , the chain shape is asymmetric . in a low - salt solution , the chains show extended morphology but are not as elongated as rods . on the other hand , @xmath111 is larger than zero for all of the studied cases , indicating that the polyelectrolytes display prolate conformation . at a high salt concentration , @xmath110 is close to 0.45 and @xmath111 is close to 0.54 , suggesting once more that the polyelectrolytes behave as the neutral polymers in the high - salt region . for the case with null @xmath8 , chain reexpansion does not occur ; @xmath110 and @xmath111 stay at a constant value when @xmath48 goes beyond @xmath57 . the results obtained in this section strongly suggest that @xmath75 is the optimal condition to pack polyelectrolytes into the smallest volume . in this section , we investigate the single - chain structure factor . this quantity is experimentally accessible and provides an essential information to theoretical analysis . the single - chain structure factor is defined by @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the scattering wavevector , @xmath114 is the number of polymer chains , @xmath115 is the number of monomers on a chain , and @xmath116 is the position of the @xmath117th monomer on the @xmath118th chain . suppose that the system has spherical symmetry . the dependence of the structure factor on the orientation of @xmath113 can be therefore integrated out : @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the norm of @xmath113 and @xmath121 is the solid angle . this integration was performed numerically by sampling over a set of randomly - oriented @xmath113 vectors . we present , in fig . [ sfp4n48_sxxx&txxx](a ) , @xmath122 at several salt concentrations for the case of @xmath75 . for the reason of clarity , the curves in the figure have been multiplied by @xmath123 with @xmath124 being increased by one for each curve from the bottom to the top . @xmath122 for the neutral polymers is depicted as reference with @xmath125 . for @xmath75 at different @xmath48 and ( b ) @xmath122 at @xmath126 for different @xmath8 . the value of @xmath48 or @xmath8 , at which the simulations were running , is indicated at the left side of each corresponding curve . @xmath122 for the neutral polymers at @xmath126 is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . for clarity , the curves , from bottom to top , have been multiplied by a factor @xmath127 with @xmath124 started from zero and increased by one for every curve . the dotted curve , near each @xmath122 and terminated at @xmath128 , is the guinier function @xmath129 . two dashed lines , which represent two power - law dependences , @xmath130 and @xmath131 ( marked by `` -1 '' and `` -2 '' , respectively ) , are drawn in the plots.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + ( a ) + for @xmath75 at different @xmath48 and ( b ) @xmath122 at @xmath126 for different @xmath8 . the value of @xmath48 or @xmath8 , at which the simulations were running , is indicated at the left side of each corresponding curve . @xmath122 for the neutral polymers at @xmath126 is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . for clarity , the curves , from bottom to top , have been multiplied by a factor @xmath127 with @xmath124 started from zero and increased by one for every curve . the dotted curve , near each @xmath122 and terminated at @xmath128 , is the guinier function @xmath129 . two dashed lines , which represent two power - law dependences , @xmath130 and @xmath131 ( marked by `` -1 '' and `` -2 '' , respectively ) , are drawn in the plots.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + ( b ) + we witnessed that @xmath122 shows typical behavior . in the guinier regime ( @xmath132 ) , @xmath122 behaves similarly to @xmath129 . it is demonstrated by plotting @xmath129 ( in dotted curve ) near the corresponding @xmath122 with the value of @xmath133 adopted from sec . [ sec_shape ] . the dotted curve terminates at @xmath128 in order to indicate the boundary of the guinier regime . in the regime @xmath134 , @xmath122 shows power - law - like behavior , manifested by a linear dependence of @xmath135 on @xmath136 . the slope @xmath137 of the linear dependence is related to the swelling exponent @xmath138 by the relation @xmath139 , which describes the size extension of a polymer : @xmath140 . in the regime @xmath141 , @xmath122 displays non - universal behavior . however , while @xmath142 , self - scattering of monomer is the only contribution , leading , therefore , @xmath122 to a universal value @xmath63 . we mention that the krathy regime , in which @xmath143 , is not observed in our study because the system is a dilute solution and the chain length is not long enough @xcite . for @xmath8 other than 1.0 , we observed analogous trends of behavior . for example , the variation of @xmath122 for different @xmath8 at the equivalence concentration is presented in fig . [ sfp4n48_sxxx&txxx](b ) , in which we rediscovered the three regimes : the guinier regime , the power - law - like regime and the non - universal regime . we noticed that in the last regime , a small bounce appears on the curve and , with increasing the size of tetravalent ions , gradually moves toward small @xmath120 . the swelling exponent @xmath138 of the polyelectrolytes was calculated by performing least - square fits in the log - log plot of @xmath122 in the power - law - like regime . the fitting region was chosen to be @xmath144 and the fitting reliability has been verified to be excellent . we present the results of the swelling exponent @xmath138 in fig . [ nup4n48.eps ] . as a function of @xmath48 for different @xmath8 . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figure . @xmath138 for the referenced neutral - polymer system is depicted and marked by `` neutral '' . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] @xmath138 for the referenced neutral polymers was verified at first and found to attain a value close to the flory s one , @xmath145 . next , we focused on the swelling exponent for the polyelectrolytes . we observed that @xmath138 exceeds the value for the neutral polymers at a low salt concentration . it indicates a strong extension of chain size due to coulomb repulsion between monomers . for the cases with @xmath146 , 1,0 , 1,4 , and 2.0 , the swelling exponent shows a v - shaped curve against @xmath48 : @xmath138 decreases and then increases with increasing salt concentration . a minimum occurs near the equivalence concentration @xmath147 and , at this moment , the chains show compact structures but are less compact than spheres because a spherical structure scales as @xmath148 . we remark that the swelling exponent obtained here for @xmath75 is consistent with that obtained by direct variation of the chain length of a system containing a single polyelectrolyte @xcite except in the mid - salt region where @xmath138 in the latter study is slightly smaller and acquires a value @xmath149 at @xmath147 . this deviation is due to multi - chain aggregation occurred in our system , which deforms the chain shape from a sphere and , consequently , increases @xmath138 . for the case with vanishing @xmath8 , following a drastic decrease , @xmath138 retains roughly a value 0.6 in the high - salt region and the chains , hence , scale like the neutral polymers . for the cases with large @xmath8 ( @xmath78 and 4.0 ) , @xmath138 is greater than 0.6 but still less than 1.0 . the chains , hence , do not reveal rigid rod - like structures . in principle , @xmath75 separates two behaviors of evolution at a salt concentration : @xmath138 increases with increasing and with decreasing @xmath8 from 1.0 . the results demonstrate again that the polyelectrolytes are mostly condensed while the size of the tetravalent counterions is compatible with the one of the monomers . there is a considerable interest to understand the variation of the persistence length of a polyelectrolyte against salt concentration . persistence length is a local property , which measures the stiffness of a polymer , and is distinguished from global conformational quantities . there are many ways to define the persistence length @xcite . in this section , we adopt a microscopic definition to calculate it : @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the @xmath117th bond vector and @xmath152 is the root - mean - square bond length . in this definition , the contribution of the finite bond length , which corresponds to the @xmath153 term in eq . [ persist_lp ] , is considered . the obtaining @xmath154 as a function of @xmath48 for different @xmath8 is plotted in fig . [ lpp4n48.eps ] . as a function of @xmath48 for different @xmath8 . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figure . the error bars are smaller than the size of the symbols . the bare persistence length @xmath155 is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] resembling to the quantities of chain conformation , @xmath154 decreases in the chain collapse region and increases in the chain reexpansion region . a minimum value appears in the vicinity of @xmath57 . the degree of increase diminishes with decreasing @xmath8 . for vanishing @xmath8 , it is so weak that @xmath154 is roughly a constant as @xmath156 . similar to the results in the previous sections , @xmath154 increases with both increasing and decreasing @xmath8 from 1.0 . @xmath75 , therefore , denotes a condition to separate the two behaviors of evolution of @xmath154 . the persistence length has generally two contributions : the bare persistence length @xmath155 ( in the absence of electrostatic force ) and the electrostatic persistence length @xmath157 ( owing to the coulomb interaction ) @xcite . in this study , the bare persistence length @xmath155 was calculated by performing simulations on the referenced system where four neutral chains and 192 neutral particles are placed in salt solutions . the result is depicted in fig . [ lpp4n48.eps ] and the curve is marked by `` neutral '' . we found that @xmath155 is not sensitive to the salt concentration and roughly attains a value 2.3 . it slightly decreases in the high - salt region , probably due to the jamming effect by the salt ions . for the polyelectrolyte solutions with large @xmath8 ( @xmath78 and 4.0 ) , the @xmath154 curve thoroughly lies above the @xmath155 curve , indicating a more rigid flexibility than a neutral polymer . the electrostatic persistence length is , hence , positive . on the other hand , for the polyelectrolyte solutions with @xmath158 , @xmath154 is smaller than @xmath155 in the mid - salt region and shows one or two intersections with the @xmath155 curve . therefore , @xmath159 is positive in a salt - free solution and becomes eventually negative upon addition of salt . it increases in the high - salt region and reattains a positive value for @xmath160 or @xmath161 . the negative contribution of electrostatics to the persistence length has been experimentally observed @xcite . recently ariel and andelman ( aa ) pointed out that a negative @xmath157 indicates a mechanical instability ( collapse ) of polyelectrolytes due to the presence of multivalent counterions @xcite . by taking into account the thermal fluctuations and correlations between bound counterions , they derived an expression of @xmath157 for an intrinsically - rigid charged polymer in ( @xmath162:1)-salt solutions in the limit of @xmath163 : @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the coulomb strength parameter between a monomer and a @xmath162-valent counterion , @xmath166 is the inverse debye - hckel screening length , and @xmath167 is the electrostatic persistence length deduced by odijk - skolnick - fixman ( osf ) theory @xcite . in the derivation , they have assumed point - like charges for the ions . we present , in fig . [ lep4n48.eps ] , @xmath157 obtained from the simulations and that predicted by eq . ( [ le_ariel ] ) as a function of @xmath168 . as a function of @xmath168 for different @xmath8 . the symbol used for each @xmath8 is indicated at the left - bottom side of the figure . the error bars are smaller than the size of the symbols . the dashed curve depicts @xmath169 predicted by eq . ( [ le_ariel ] ) . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] we witnessed that @xmath157 depends strongly on the size of the tetravalent ions . the negative regime of @xmath157 has been successfully captured in the simulations . to make a comparison with the theoretical prediction , we focused on the case with vanishing @xmath8 . please notice that this case does not exactly fulfill the assumption of the theory because in the simulations , the monovalent counterions and coions are not point charge - like and , also , the chains are not rigid . however , according to our experiences @xcite , ions other than multivalent counterions do not play a decisive role on the properties of polyelectrolytes . this comparison , therefore , makes sense if the effect of chain rigidness is negligible . we emphasize that the electrostatic correlations are fully taken into account in the simulations . in our study , the region in which eq . ( [ le_ariel ] ) is valid is @xmath170 because @xmath171 , @xmath172 , and @xmath173 is about 1.1 . notice that eq . ( [ le_ariel ] ) has a singularity at @xmath174 and , hence , the curve is divided into two branches . the left branch is located in the valid region but fails to predict @xmath157 . it gives not only a wrong value but also a wrong trend of variation of @xmath157 against @xmath168 . we noticed that eq . ( [ le_ariel ] ) is a modification of @xmath175 multiplied by a factor but the valid region given by aa theory @xcite is incompatible with that of osf theory . osf theory is held when the screening length @xmath176 is much smaller than the bare persistence length @xcite . therefore , aa theory may be true in the region @xmath177 . as shown in the figure , @xmath157 for vanishing @xmath8 is well described by the right branch of the curve of eq . ( [ le_ariel ] ) , which seems to support this conjecture . this topic deserves a further analysis in the future . experiments and simulations have shown that like - charged macroions can attract each other in a solution @xcite . it is hence relevant to know under which conditions the like - charge attraction takes place between polyelectrolytes . to answer this question , we investigate `` potential of mean force '' in this section . potential of mean force describes the effective interaction between two particles ( molecules ) in a medium , which includes two contributions : the direct interaction between two particles ( molecules ) and the indirect interaction via other particles ( molecules ) and the medium . this quantity can be calculated by simulations : @xmath178 where @xmath179 is the radial distribution function between particles of species @xmath95 and @xmath180 . @xmath179 is computed by @xmath181 where @xmath182 and @xmath183 are the number of @xmath95-particles and that of @xmath180-particles , respectively , @xmath184 is the volume of the simulation box , and @xmath185 with @xmath186 denoting the number of @xmath180-particles lying in a spherical shell , centered at the @xmath95-particle @xmath16 , of radius @xmath3 and shell thickness @xmath187 . because our system is composed of only four chains , it is not easy to reduce statistical error if we directly calculate the potential of mean force between chains . we , therefore , calculated the potential of mean force between monomers on different chains , which also provides the information about the chain interaction . we denote this quantity @xmath188 and the results are presented in fig . [ pmf11p4n48txxx ] which contains six plots , from top to bottom and from left to right , corresponding , in orders , to the cases @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 . @xmath188 for the referenced neutral polymers is also depicted in the figure . for @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six plots . each plot includes several @xmath188 at different @xmath48 . the value of @xmath48 is indicated in the plot or near the corresponding curve . @xmath188 for the neutral polymer system is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . the unit of ordinate axis is @xmath21.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six plots . each plot includes several @xmath188 at different @xmath48 . the value of @xmath48 is indicated in the plot or near the corresponding curve . @xmath188 for the neutral polymer system is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . the unit of ordinate axis is @xmath21.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six plots . each plot includes several @xmath188 at different @xmath48 . the value of @xmath48 is indicated in the plot or near the corresponding curve . @xmath188 for the neutral polymer system is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . the unit of ordinate axis is @xmath21.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six plots . each plot includes several @xmath188 at different @xmath48 . the value of @xmath48 is indicated in the plot or near the corresponding curve . @xmath188 for the neutral polymer system is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . the unit of ordinate axis is @xmath21.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six plots . each plot includes several @xmath188 at different @xmath48 . the value of @xmath48 is indicated in the plot or near the corresponding curve . @xmath188 for the neutral polymer system is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . the unit of ordinate axis is @xmath21.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath82 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six plots . each plot includes several @xmath188 at different @xmath48 . the value of @xmath48 is indicated in the plot or near the corresponding curve . @xmath188 for the neutral polymer system is depicted as reference and marked by `` neutral '' . the unit of ordinate axis is @xmath21.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] in a salt - free solution , @xmath188 displays a repulsive interaction , and is stronger than that for the neutral polymers owing to the electrostatic repulsion between monomers . this can be seen by comparing the range of repulsion estimated by equaling @xmath188 to the thermal energy @xmath21 . the range of repulsion is at @xmath189 for the polyelectrolytes and at @xmath190 for the neutral polymers . upon addition of salt , @xmath188 responses in two distinct ways , which depends on the ion size . the first one is applied for small or large tetravalent counterions , such as @xmath82 , 0.5 , or 4.0 . in these cases , @xmath188 is purely repulsive in the course of addition of salt . hence , the monomers on different chains repel between themselves and the system exhibits no like - charge attraction . the second way is happened for an intermediate size such as @xmath75 , 2.0 , or 3.0 . at this moment , @xmath188 displays an attractive well in a mid - salt region . therefore , it appears like - charge attraction between chains . in the first case , the range of repulsion of @xmath188 decreases to a minimum value nearly at @xmath126 . further increase of @xmath48 either leaves @xmath188 unchanged ( for vanishing @xmath8 and for @xmath191 ) or increases the range of repulsion of @xmath188 ( for @xmath146 ) . we will call @xmath188 at @xmath126 `` the curve at equivalence '' , which separates two behaviors of evolution of @xmath188 as @xmath48 is increased or decreased from @xmath57 . we noticed that @xmath188 tends toward the referenced curve of the neutral polymers at high salt concentrations except for the deviation happened at small @xmath3 due to the excluded volume of large ions . for vanishing @xmath8 , the curve at equivalence is very close to the reference curve and @xmath188 is roughly unchanged while @xmath192 . for @xmath146 , the curve at equivalence lies below the referenced curve ; @xmath188 is bounded between the two curves and increases with @xmath48 . and in the second case , @xmath188 displays a potential well located near @xmath193 . it suggests an attraction mediated by a tetravalent counterion . the depth of the well can be more profound than @xmath21 . therefore , a stable bound state can be formed between monomers on different chains and it is a prerequisite to occur salt - induced phase separation . the maximum depth of the well is happened while @xmath48 is @xmath57 . in general , we found that @xmath188 is bounded between the salt - free curve and the curve at equivalence while @xmath194 , and between the latter curve and the referenced neutral curve while @xmath192 . we have shown that the occurrence of the like - charge attraction depends on both salt concentration and ion size . in fig . [ pmf11p4n48_boundary.eps ] we present , in the variable space , the region where @xmath188 shows an attractive well . , @xmath8)-variable space . in region ( i ) , @xmath188 shows an attractive well and in region ( ii ) , it is purely repulsive.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in the figure , the data points ( symbolized by star ) denote the salt concentrations for a given @xmath8 , at which a purely repulsive @xmath188 turns to show an attractive well and _ vice versa _ , and the closed solid curve is sketched to help readers to separate the two regions . it clearly shows that an effective attraction appears only when @xmath8 is neither too small nor too big and salt concentration is intermediate around the equivalence concentration . we mention that the occurrence of an attractive region in the potential of mean force is not sufficient to have a phase separation of the system . phase transitions in charged colloid systems have been largely discussed in literatures but there have been relatively few studies of phase transitions in charged chain systems ( see refs . @xcite and @xcite and references therein ) . fig . [ snapshots ] shows snapshots of the simulations for @xmath146 , 1.0 and 4.0 at two salt concentrations @xmath126 and @xmath195 . , ( b ) @xmath75 , and ( c ) @xmath191 , at @xmath126 ( left ) and @xmath195 ( right ) . in the pictures , the bead - spring chains are represented in gray color ( red color online ) and the monovalent counterions in light one ( white color online ) . the tetravalent counterions are represented in dark - colored ( blue - colored online ) particles whereas the coions are not plotted for the clarity of the pictures . in the snapshots , a chain may appear more than one fragment because of periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , ( b ) @xmath75 , and ( c ) @xmath191 , at @xmath126 ( left ) and @xmath195 ( right ) . in the pictures , the bead - spring chains are represented in gray color ( red color online ) and the monovalent counterions in light one ( white color online ) . the tetravalent counterions are represented in dark - colored ( blue - colored online ) particles whereas the coions are not plotted for the clarity of the pictures . in the snapshots , a chain may appear more than one fragment because of periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , ( b ) @xmath75 , and ( c ) @xmath191 , at @xmath126 ( left ) and @xmath195 ( right ) . in the pictures , the bead - spring chains are represented in gray color ( red color online ) and the monovalent counterions in light one ( white color online ) . the tetravalent counterions are represented in dark - colored ( blue - colored online ) particles whereas the coions are not plotted for the clarity of the pictures . in the snapshots , a chain may appear more than one fragment because of periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , ( b ) @xmath75 , and ( c ) @xmath191 , at @xmath126 ( left ) and @xmath195 ( right ) . in the pictures , the bead - spring chains are represented in gray color ( red color online ) and the monovalent counterions in light one ( white color online ) . the tetravalent counterions are represented in dark - colored ( blue - colored online ) particles whereas the coions are not plotted for the clarity of the pictures . in the snapshots , a chain may appear more than one fragment because of periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , ( b ) @xmath75 , and ( c ) @xmath191 , at @xmath126 ( left ) and @xmath195 ( right ) . in the pictures , the bead - spring chains are represented in gray color ( red color online ) and the monovalent counterions in light one ( white color online ) . the tetravalent counterions are represented in dark - colored ( blue - colored online ) particles whereas the coions are not plotted for the clarity of the pictures . in the snapshots , a chain may appear more than one fragment because of periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , ( b ) @xmath75 , and ( c ) @xmath191 , at @xmath126 ( left ) and @xmath195 ( right ) . in the pictures , the bead - spring chains are represented in gray color ( red color online ) and the monovalent counterions in light one ( white color online ) . the tetravalent counterions are represented in dark - colored ( blue - colored online ) particles whereas the coions are not plotted for the clarity of the pictures . in the snapshots , a chain may appear more than one fragment because of periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] at @xmath126 , we saw that the polyelectrolytes favor to be apart from each other for both of the cases @xmath146 and @xmath191 . however , delicate difference was witnessed that the previous case displays a single - chain collapse but the latter one does not . for @xmath75 , the chains favor to aggregate together , in accordance with the results of fig . [ pmf11p4n48txxx ] which show the occurrence of an attraction between the negatively - charged polymers . this attraction is mediated by counterions , mainly the tetravalent counterions , since almost all the tetravalent counterions are condensed on the polyelectrolytes . we point out that the condensation of tetravalent counterion is not a sufficient condition to occur chain aggregation . it can be seen from the case @xmath146 in which most of the tetravalent counterions are condensed but the chains does not aggregate . at the high salt concentration @xmath195 , the attraction between chains is reduced , in comparison with the cases at @xmath126 . the chains segregate or show tendency of segregation from each other . in the simulations , we observed that while @xmath192 , only part of the tetravalent counterions can condense onto the chains . in this section , we investigate the charge distribution around a polyelectrolyte . it enables to understand how ions distribute around a chain and provides useful information for theorists to develop models . we define a worm - like tube of radius @xmath3 around a chain to be a union of @xmath44 spheres of radius @xmath3 centered at each monomer on the chain . we calculated the averaged total charge inside a worm - like tube , including the charge of the ions and the one of the monomers . this quantity is called `` the integrated charge distribution '' and is denoted by @xmath196 . we show in fig . [ iondist ] @xmath196 at various @xmath48 for @xmath8 ranged between 0.0 and 4.0 . at different @xmath48 for @xmath8=0.0 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six figures . the line arts used for different @xmath48 are indicated at the right - bottom side of each figure . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] at different @xmath48 for @xmath8=0.0 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six figures . the line arts used for different @xmath48 are indicated at the right - bottom side of each figure . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] at different @xmath48 for @xmath8=0.0 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six figures . the line arts used for different @xmath48 are indicated at the right - bottom side of each figure . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] at different @xmath48 for @xmath8=0.0 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six figures . the line arts used for different @xmath48 are indicated at the right - bottom side of each figure . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] at different @xmath48 for @xmath8=0.0 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six figures . the line arts used for different @xmath48 are indicated at the right - bottom side of each figure . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] at different @xmath48 for @xmath8=0.0 , 0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 and 4.0 , shown , in orders , from top to bottom and from left to right , in six figures . the line arts used for different @xmath48 are indicated at the right - bottom side of each figure . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] focus firstly on the case with vanishing @xmath8 . in the region @xmath197 , @xmath196 attains a value equal to the bare charge of a chain , @xmath198 . a stair - like behavior then appears for @xmath196 in the region @xmath199 while @xmath200 . outside the region , @xmath196 monotonically increases and tends toward zero at large @xmath3 due to electroneutrality . since @xmath201 is the depletion zone for the particles other than tetravalent counterions , the behavior of @xmath196 in this region is completely determined by the condensation of tetravalent counterions . the stair - like behavior indicates a _ perfect _ condensation on the surface of the chain , owing to the vanishing size of the tetravalent counterions . for instance , at @xmath202 , we have 24 tetravalent counterions in the simulation box and , therefore , 6 condensed tetravalent counterions on a chain , in average . a perfect condensation will lead to a value @xmath203 for @xmath196 and this is exactly what we have observed in the figure . at the equivalence concentration , @xmath196 is zero while @xmath204 . if @xmath48 is further increased ( @xmath192 ) , @xmath196 reveals a positive peak in the region @xmath205 , which indicates an overcharging , and , then , rapidly decays to zero as @xmath206 . the hight of the peak suggests that only a portion of the tetravalent counterions are condensed on the chain . for the case @xmath146 , the region in which only the tetravalent counterions can intervene is narrowed to @xmath207 . in the region , the step of the stair - like @xmath196 becomes tilted while @xmath194 . if @xmath192 , @xmath196 displays a positive peak , which is more pronounced than that for vanishing @xmath8 . for the case @xmath75 , an oscillatory behavior occurs at high @xmath48 . similar phenomena have been observed in other systems such as charged plate @xcite , colloid system @xcite , and rigid polyelectrolyte @xcite . this oscillatory behavior indicates a multi - layer organization of ions : in the close neighborhood of a polyelectrolyte , tetravalent counterions condense and form a positively - charged layer which overcharges the chain ; exterior to this layer , anionic particles intervene and form a negatively - charged layer which overcompensates the charge inside and , hence , the integrated charge becomes negative , and so forth . notice that the depletion zone around a chain for tetravalent counterions is @xmath208 . it becomes larger than that for the other ions while @xmath209 . in these cases , @xmath196 decreases with increasing @xmath48 in the depletion zone , but shows completely opposed behavior just outside the zone apparently due to the condensation of tetravalent counterions . at very high @xmath48 ( for instance , at @xmath210 for @xmath211 ) , @xmath196 in the zone can even attain a value smaller than the chain bare charge . in this case , negative particles are the major composition of the first ion layer around a chain , which is counterintuitive . the following three observations are worth to be noticed . ( 1 ) the salt concentration at which @xmath196 becomes ( roughly ) zero in the region @xmath212 decreases with increasing @xmath8 . ( 2 ) the oscillatory behavior appears more markedly for large @xmath8 than for small one . ( 3 ) at a given @xmath48 , the larger the @xmath8 , the higher the maximum peak of @xmath196 will be . it is tempting to consider that a polyelectrolyte and the ions condensed on the chain form a complex object . under some conditions , the effective charge of the complex object reverses its sign . this phenomenon is called charge inversion @xcite . _ intended to link the phenomenon of charge inversion with the reentrant condensation @xcite . they proposed that zero effective charge and charge inversion of chains are , respectively , the cause for the condensation and for the redissolution of polyelectrolytes . their theory necessitates further verification either by experiments or by simulations . in the rest of this section , we try to calculate the effective charge of a polyelectrolyte , in hope of being able to clarify the relationship between the charge inversion and the reentrant condensation . we simply define the complex to be the set of particles lying within a worm - like tube of radius @xmath213 around the chain . this definition has been utilized in many places , for example , in refs . @xcite and @xcite . usually , @xmath213 is chosen to be the distance at which the electrostatic attraction between a monovalent counterion and a monomer is equal to the kinetic energy @xmath214 ; in consequence , the counterion inside the tube of radius @xmath213 can not escape from the chain . we , thus , consider the total charge @xmath215 inside the tube as the effective charge of a chain . in our study , @xmath213 is equal to 2 . the results are presented in fig . [ iondist_p4n48_rc200.eps](a ) . as a function of @xmath48 with @xmath216 , and ( b ) @xmath217 as a function of @xmath48 , for different @xmath8 . the symbol used to denote each @xmath8 is indicated in the figures . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + ( a ) + as a function of @xmath48 with @xmath216 , and ( b ) @xmath217 as a function of @xmath48 , for different @xmath8 . the symbol used to denote each @xmath8 is indicated in the figures . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] + ( b ) two behaviors were observed : ( 1 ) for @xmath78 and 4.0 , @xmath215 decreases with increasing @xmath48 , ( 2 ) for @xmath218 , @xmath215 increases basically with @xmath48 . notice that @xmath215 for @xmath160 or 2.0 attains a large positive value in the mid - salt region . hence , @xmath188 should show strong repulsion in this region , according to the theory of nguyen _ et al_. but , in fact , we observed a strong attractive well for @xmath188 and the chains were observed to aggregate together . therefore , the results do not support the theory . we notice that it is too simple to regard @xmath215 as the effective chain charge , because ion valence is not considered in the definition . for example , the suitable @xmath213 for tetravalent counterions should be 8.0 , based upon the same argument to choice @xmath213 for monovalent counterions . in addition , @xmath216 becomes too small while @xmath219 , since the depletion zone around a chain for the tetravalent counterions is bigger than the tube . therefore , we redefine @xmath220 as the novel condensation region for tetravalent counterions , whereas keeping @xmath216 for monovalent counterions and for monomers on the other chains . considering that the condensation of coions is mainly mediated by tetravalent counterions , we choose @xmath220 for coions . the charges inside the different tubs are computed and their sum @xmath217 is then regarded as an alternative definition for the effective chain charge . the results are presented in fig . [ iondist_p4n48_rc200.eps](b ) . we remark that @xmath217 looks quite differently from @xmath215 . it shows a positive peak in the mid - salt region for @xmath75 , 1.4 , and 2.0 but retains negative value for the other @xmath8 . the obtained results suggest a disconnection between neutralization of chain charge and condensation of polyelectrolytes . our simulating system in the high - salt region reveals a picture more close to the one described by solis @xcite : although _ locally _ overcompensated by condensed counterions , the net charge of a redissolved chain can be positive or negative due to the association of coions . we must point out that the effective chain charge interpreted by @xmath215 or by @xmath217 in this section can be only served as a reference because both @xmath215 and @xmath217 are sensitive to the choice of @xmath213 . a rigorous way to study it , which can circumvent the ambiguity , is to study the electrophoretic mobility of polyelectrolytes in salt solutions . this part of research is currently undergoing . we have performed molecular dynamics simulations in canonical ensemble to investigate the properties of highly - charged polyelectrolytes in tetravalent salt solutions , including chain morphology , single - chain structure factor , swelling exponent , persistence length , like - charge attraction between chains and integrated charge distribution around a polyelectrolyte . we have explored a wide range of salt concentration and studied the effect of size of tetravalent counterions on the above properties . we have found that a polyelectrolyte exhibits , in turns , two conformational transitions upon addition of salt : a collapsed transition and a reexpanding transition , manifested by a v - shaped curve of the square of radius of gyration @xmath47 against salt concentration @xmath48 . the systems at different monomer concentration @xmath53 show similar curves . the curves overlap each other in the chain - reexpansion region . in the chain - collapsed region , we have also observed that @xmath60 against @xmath59 lie over each other for different @xmath53 , where @xmath62 and @xmath221 weakly depends on @xmath53 . these findings are useful in understanding the phase boundaries of the condensation of polyelectrolytes : on the upper boundary , @xmath48 is roughly independent of @xmath53 and on the lower one , @xmath48 depends linearly on @xmath53 . the study of chain morphology shows that for the cases with @xmath8 ( the size of the tetravalent counterions ) around 1.0 , the chains reveal compact and prolate structures in the vicinity of the equivalence concentration @xmath57 . in a low - salt region and in a high - salt region , the chains show extended structures . at a very high salt concentration , the chains behave similarly to neutral polymers . for the cases with large @xmath8 , the chains are elongated and do not display a collapsed - transition in the mid - salt region . for the case with vanishing @xmath8 , the behavior of the chains is analogous to that of neutral polymers as @xmath222 . noticeably , our results show that @xmath75 is the optimal condition to pack polyelectrolytes into the smallest volume . we have shown that the single - chain structure factor @xmath122 of the multi - chain system in salt solutions follows the guinier function @xmath129 while @xmath223 . @xmath122 then exhibits a power - law - like behavior @xmath224 in the region @xmath134 , suggesting that the scaling law , @xmath225 , is held for polyelectrolytes in salt solutions . the swelling exponent @xmath139 attains a minimum value near @xmath57 and behaves in analogy of the morphological quantities . it shows once more that the chains are mostly collapsed while @xmath8 is compatible with 1.0 . our simulations incorporated explicitly the salt ions and , therefore , were able to study the negative regime of the electrostatic persistence length @xmath157 . this regime appears simultaneously with the mechanical instability of the polyelectrolytes induced by salt . we have examined the theory of ariel and andelman @xcite and found that it fails to predict @xmath157 in the _ so - claimed _ valid region @xmath226 but describes @xmath157 well in the unexpected region @xmath227 . since the osf theory is valid in the latter region , we conjectured that the theory of ariel and andelman is applicable in the latter region . this part deserves a detail investigation in the future . we have studied like - charge attraction between polyelectrolytes by calculating the potential of mean force @xmath188 between monomers on different chains . the results show that it depends strongly on salt concentration and ion size . an attractive region appears in @xmath188 only when the salt concentration is intermediate and the tetravalent counterions possess a size compatible with the monomers . the most profound attractive well is happened while @xmath75 and @xmath228 . in the final part , the integrated charge distribution @xmath196 around a polyelectrolyte was investigated . we have found that the chain charge can be locally overcompensated by condensed ions . @xmath196 displays an oscillatory behavior at high salt concentrations while @xmath80 . the oscillatory behavior results from a multi - layer organization of ions around the chain , which is in agreement with the picture predicted by solis @xcite . we have used two different definitions to calculate the effective chain charge . the results suggest that charge inversion is not a necessary condition to occur reentrant condensation . recently wen and tang have provided evidence against the connection between charge inversion and resolubilization of polyelectrolyte bundles @xcite . a more rigorous study by electrophoresis performed by molecular dynamics simulations is undergoing . the author acknowledges c .- l . lee , y .- f . wei , and n. pardillos for their comments . this material is based upon work supported by the national science council , the republic of china , under the contract no . nsc 94 - 2112-m-007 - 023 . most of the simulations were running at the national center for high - performance computing . the author expresses his gratitude to the members and the staffs of the council and the center . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: tree - shaped objects are fundamental in nature , where they appear , e.g. , as delivery systems for gases and fluids @xcite , as skeletal structures , or describing hierarchies . examples encountered in image analysis and computational biology are airway trees @xcite , vascular systems @xcite , shock graphs @xcite , scale space hierarchies @xcite and phylogenetic trees @xcite . statistical methods for tree - structured data would have endless applications . for instance , one could make more consistent studies of changes in airway geometry and structure related to airway disease @xcite to improve tools for computer aided diagnosis and prognosis . due to the wide range of applications , extensive work has been done in the past @xmath0 years on comparison of trees and graphs in terms of matching @xcite , object recognition @xcite and machine learning @xcite based on inter - tree distances . however , the existing tree - distance frameworks are algorithmic rather than geometric . very few attempts @xcite have been made to build analogues of the theory for landmark point shape spaces using manifold statistics and riemannian submersions @xcite . there exists no principled approach to studying the space of tree - structured data , and as a consequence , the standard statistical properties are not well - defined . as we shall see , difficulties appear even in the basic problem of finding the average of two tree - shapes . this paper fills the gap by introducing a shape - theoretical framework for geometric trees , which is suitable for statistical analysis . most statistical measurements are based on a concept of distance . the most fundamental statistic is the _ mean _ ( or prototype ) @xmath1 for a dataset @xmath2 , which can be defined as the minimizer of the sum of squared distances to the data points : @xmath3 this definition of the mean , called _ frchet mean _ , assumes a space of tree - shapes endowed with a distance @xmath4 , and is closely connected to geodesics , or shortest paths , between tree - shapes . for example , the midpoint of a geodesic from @xmath5 to @xmath6 is a mean for the two - point dataset @xmath7 . hence , if there are multiple geodesics connecting @xmath5 to @xmath6 , with different midpoints , then there will also be multiple means . _ as a consequence , without ( local , generic ) uniqueness of geodesics , statistical properties are fundamentally ill - posed ! _ thus , geometry enters the picture , and the idea of a geodesic tree - space gives a constraint on the possible geometric structure of tree - space . in a shape space where distances are given by path length , we must be able to continuously deform any given tree - shape into any other by traveling along the shortest path that connects the two shapes . the deformation - paths are easy to describe when only branch shape is changed , while tree topology ( branch connectivity ) is fixed . such deformations take place in portions of tree - space where all trees have the same topological structure . it is more challenging to describe deformation - paths in which the tree - topological structure is changed , for instance through a collapsed internal branch as in fig . [ treetopologyviolationgeodesic ] . we model topologically intermediate trees as collapsed versions of trees with differing tree topology , and glue the portions of tree - space together along subspaces that correspond to collapsed trees , as in fig . [ tree_space_components ] . as a consequence , tree - space has self intersections and is not smooth , but has singularities ! the main theoretical contributions of this paper are the construction of a mathematical tree - shape framework along with a geometric analysis of two natural metrics on the shape space . one of these metrics is the classical tree edit distance ( ted ) , into which we gain new insight . the second metric , called quotient euclidean distance ( qed ) , is induced from a euclidean metric . using gromov s approach to metric geometry @xcite , we show that qed generically gives locally unique geodesics and means , whereas finding geodesics and means for ted is ill - posed even locally . we explain why using ted for computing average trees must always be accompanied by a carefully engineered choice of edit paths in order to give well - defined results ; choices which can yield average trees which are substantially different from the trees in the dataset @xcite . the qed approach , on the contrary , allows us to investigate statistical methods for tree - like structures which have previously not been possible , like different well - defined concepts of average tree . _ this is our motivation for studying the qed metric ! _ the paper is organized as follows : in section [ background ] we discuss related work . the tree - space is defined in section [ geometrysection ] , and the statistical properties of tree - space are analyzed in section [ curvaturesection ] . in section [ complexitysection ] , we discuss how to overcome the computational complexity of both metrics , and present a simple qed approximation . in section [ experimentalsection ] , we illustrate the properties of qed by computing geodesics and different types of average tree for synthetic planar data trees as well as by computing qed means for sets of @xmath8 airway trees from human lungs . metrics on sets of tree - structured data have been studied by different research communities for the past 20 years . the best - known approach is perhaps tree edit distance ( ted ) , which has been used extensively for shape matching and recognition based on medial axes and shock graphs @xcite . ted and , more generally , graph edit distance ( ged ) , are also popular in the pattern recognition community , and are still used for distance - based pattern recognition approaches to trees and graphs @xcite . the ted and ged metrics will nearly always have infinitely many shortest edit paths , or geodesics , between two given trees , since edit operations can be performed in different orders and increments . as a result , even the problem of finding the average of two trees is not well posed . with no kind of uniqueness of geodesics , it becomes hard to meaningfully define and compute average shapes or modes of variation . this problem can be solved to some extent by choosing a preferred edit path @xcite , but there will always be a risk that the choice has negative consequences in a given setting . trinh and kimia @xcite face this problem when they use ted for computing average medial axes using the simplest possible edit paths , leading to average shapes which can be substantially different from most of the dataset shapes . statistics on tree - shaped objects receive growing interest in the statistical community . wang and marron @xcite study metric spaces of trees and define a notion of average tree called the median - mean as well as a version of pca , which finds modes of variation in terms of _ tree - lines _ , encoding the maximum amount of structural and attributal variation . aydin et al . @xcite extend this work by finding efficient algorithms for pca . this is applied to analysis of brain blood vessels . the metric defined by wang and marron does not give a natural geodesic structure on the space of trees , as it places a large emphasis on the tree - topological structure of the trees . the metric has discontinuities in the sense that a sequence of trees with a shrinking branch will not converge to a tree that does not have that branch . such a metric is not suitable for studying trees with continuous topological variations and noise , such as anatomical tree - structures extracted from medical images , since the emphasis on topology makes the metric sensitive to structural noise . a different approach is that of jain and obermayer @xcite , who study metrics on attributed graphs , represented as incidence matrices . the space of graphs is defined as a quotient of the euclidean space of incidence matrices by the group of vertex permutations . the graph - space inherits the euclidean metric , giving it the structure of an orbifold . this graph - space construction is similar to the tree - space presented in this paper in the sense that both spaces are constructed as quotients of a euclidean space . the graph - space framework does not , however , give continuous transitions in internal graph - topological structure , which leads to large differences between the geometries of the tree- and graph - spaces . trees also appear in genetics . hillis et al . @xcite visualize large sets of phylogenetic trees using multidimensional scaling . billera et al . @xcite have invented a phylogenetic tree - space suitable for geodesic analysis of phylogenetic trees , and owen and provan @xcite have developed fast algorithms for computing geodesics in phylogenetic tree - space . nye @xcite has developed a notion of pca in phylogenetic tree - space , but is forced to make strict assumptions on possible principle components being simple lines for the sake of computability . phylogenetic trees are not geometric , and have fixed , labeled leaf sets , making the space of phylogenetic trees much simpler than the space of tree - like shapes . we have previously @xcite studied geodesics between small tree - shapes in the same type of singular shape space as studied here , but most proofs have been left out . in @xcite , we study different algorithms for computing average trees based on the qed metric . this paper extends and continues @xcite , giving proofs , in - depth explanations and more extensive examples illustrating the potential of the qed metric . let us discuss which properties are desirable for a tree - shape model . as previously discussed , we require , at the very least , local existence and uniqueness for geodesics in order to compute average trees and analyze variation in datasets . when geodesics exist , we want the topological structure of the intermediate trees along the geodesic to reflect the resemblance in structure of the trees being compared . in particular , _ a geodesic passing through the trivial one - vertex tree should indicate that the trees being compared are maximally different . _ perhaps more importantly , we would like to compare trees where the desired edge matching is inconsistent with tree topology , as in fig . [ treetopologyviolation ] . specifically , we would like to find geodesic deformations in which the tree topology changes when we have such edge matchings , for instance as in fig . [ treetopologyviolationgeodesic ] . in this paper we shall work with two different tree - spaces : a tree - space @xmath9 , which is the space of all trees of a certain size , and a subspace @xmath10 , which is a restricted space of trees , whose exact definition is flexible ( see definition [ subspacedef ] ) . the large tree - space @xmath9 is the natural space for geometric trees . however , the available mathematical tools only allow us to prove our results locally , where the locality assumptions become very strict in @xmath9 . using a set of natural assumptions , we can restrict to a tree - space @xmath11 where our results hold in larger regions of tree - space . this is discussed in detail in section [ injectivity ] . we also believe that our results hold in @xmath9 , as described in conjecture [ conjecture ] . in this paper , a tree - shape is an embedded tree in @xmath12 or @xmath13 , and consists of a series of edge embeddings , glued together according to a rooted combinatorial tree . tree - shapes are invariant to translation , but our definition of tree - shape does not remove scale and rotation . however , tree - shapes can always be aligned with respect to scale and rotation prior to comparison , if this is important . any tree - like shape is represented as a pair @xmath14 consisting of a rooted , planar tree @xmath15 with edge attributes @xmath16 . in @xmath17 , @xmath18 is the vertex set , @xmath19 is the edge set , and @xmath20 is the root vertex . the tree @xmath15 describes the tree - shape topology , and the attributes describe edge shape , as illustrated in fig . [ pickapart ] . the shape attributes , represented by a point @xmath21 in the product space @xmath22 , is a concatenation of edgewise attributes from an attribute space @xmath23 . the attributes could , e.g. , be edge length , landmark points or edge parametrizations . in this work , we mostly use open curves translated to start at the origin , described by a fixed number of landmark points along the edge . thus , throughout the paper , the attribute space @xmath23 is @xmath24 where @xmath25 or @xmath26 and @xmath27 is the number of landmark points per edge . collapsed edges are represented by a sequence of origin points . in some illustrations , we shall use scalar attributes for the sake of visualization , in which case @xmath28 . in order to compare trees of different sizes and structures , we need to represent them in a unified way . we describe all shapes using the _ same _ tree @xmath15 to encode tree topology . by choosing a sufficiently large @xmath15 , we can represent all the trees in our dataset by filling out with empty ( collapsed ) edges . we call @xmath15 _ the maximal tree_. we model tree - shapes using _ binary _ maximal trees @xmath15 . tree - shapes which are not binary are represented by the binary tree @xmath15 in a natural way by allowing constant , or collapsed , edges , represented by the zero scalar or vector attribute . in this way _ an arbitrary attributed tree can be represented as an attributed * binary * tree _ , see fig . [ constedge ] . this is geometrically very natural . binary trees are geometrically _ stable _ in the sense that small perturbations of a binary tree - shape do not change the tree - topological structure of the shape . conversely , a trifurcation or higher - order vertex can always be turned into a series of bifurcations sitting close together by an arbitrarily small perturbation . in our representation , thus , trifurcations are represented as two bifurcations sitting infinitely close together , etc . trees embedded in the plane have a natural edge order induced by the left - right order on the children of any edge . we say that a tree is _ ordered _ whenever each set of sibling edges in the tree is endowed with such a total order . conversely , an ordered combinatorial tree always has a unique , implicit embedding in the plane where siblings are ordered from left to right . for this reason we use the terms planar tree and ordered tree interchangingly . we initially study metrics on the set of ordered binary trees ; later we use them to induce distances between unordered trees by considering all possible orders . this allows us to model trees in @xmath13 . considering all orders leads to potential computational challenges , which are discussed in section [ complexitysection ] . - and @xmath29-axes are trees with a single branch . for each real number @xmath30 , the tree - shape found at @xmath31 is also represented at @xmath32 . we build the tree - shape space by gluing the different representations of the same tree - shapes ( e.g. , @xmath33 and @xmath34 ) together , obtaining the shape space shown on the right . note the path from @xmath35 to @xmath36 through @xmath37 in @xmath38 on the right ; the corresponding path in the pre - shape space @xmath9 involves a teleportation between the representations @xmath33 and @xmath39 of @xmath37 . ] in order to build a space of tree - shapes , fix an ordered maximal binary tree @xmath15 with edges @xmath40 , which encodes the connectivity of all our trees . any attributed tree @xmath33 is now represented by a point @xmath41 in @xmath42 , where the coordinate @xmath43 describes the shape of the edge @xmath44 . since we allow zero - attributed edges , as discussed above , some tree - shapes will be represented by several points in @xmath9 ( fig . [ constedge ] ) . as a result , some natural tree - deformations are not found as continuous paths in @xmath9 . in figs . [ tedmoves4 ] and [ folding ] , the paths in @xmath9 corresponding to the indicated deformations require a teleportation between two representations of the intermediate tree - shape . we tackle this by using a refined tree - shape space @xmath38 , where different representations are identified as being the same point . the original space @xmath9 is called the tree pre - shape space , analogous to kendall s terminology @xcite . we go from pre - shapes to shapes by identifying those pre - shapes which define the same shape . consider two ordered tree - shapes with collapsed edges . replace their binary representations by collapsed representations , where the zero attributed edges have been removed . the orders of the original trees induce well - defined orders on the collapsed trees . we say that two ordered tree - shapes are _ the same _ when their collapsed ordered , attributed versions are identical , as in fig . [ constedge ] . tree identifications come with an inherent bijection of subsets of the edge set @xmath40 : if we identify @xmath45 , denote by @xmath46 the sets of non - collapsed edges with non - zero attributes . the identification of @xmath16 and @xmath29 is equivalent to an order preserving bijection @xmath47 , identifying those edges that correspond to the same edge in the collapsed tree - shape . varying the attributes @xmath43 , @xmath48 spans a family of tree - shapes with fixed topology and several representatives . thus , the edge sets @xmath49 and @xmath50 induce linear subspaces @xmath51 of @xmath9 where , except for on the axes , the topological tree structure is constant . the tree - shapes represented in @xmath52 are exactly the same as those represented in @xmath53 . the bijection @xmath48 induces a bijection @xmath54 given by @xmath55 , which connects each representation @xmath56 to the representation @xmath57 of the same shape . note that the @xmath58 are spanned by axes in @xmath9 . define a map @xmath59 for each pair of identified tree - structures , and form an equivalence on @xmath9 by setting @xmath60 for all @xmath16 and @xmath59 . for each @xmath61 , @xmath62 is the equivalence class @xmath63 . the quotient space @xmath64 of equivalence classes @xmath62 is the space of ordered tree - like shapes . quotient spaces are standard constructions from topology and geometry , where they are used to glue spaces together @xcite . the geometric interpretation of the identification in the tree - space quotient is that we fold and glue the pre - shape space space along the identified subspaces ; i.e. , when @xmath65 , we glue the two points @xmath5 and @xmath6 together . see fig . [ folding ] for an illustration . given a metric @xmath4 on the euclidean pre - shape - space @xmath42 , we induce the standard quotient pseudometric @xcite @xmath66 on the quotient space @xmath67 by setting @xmath68 this corresponds to finding the optimal path from @xmath62 to @xmath69 , consisting of any number @xmath70 of concatenated euclidean lines , passing through @xmath71 identified subspaces , as shown in fig . [ folding ] . it is clear from the definition that the distance function @xmath66 is symmetric and transitive . it is , however , an infimum , giving a risk that the distance between two distinct tree - shapes is zero , as occurs with some intuitive shape distance functions @xcite . this is why @xmath66 is called a _ _ pseudo__metric , and it remains to prove that it actually is a metric ; i.e. , that @xmath72 implies @xmath73 . we prove this for two specific metrics on @xmath9 , which come from two different ways of combining individual edge distances : the metrics @xmath74 and @xmath75 on @xmath42 are the norms @xmath76 from now on , @xmath4 and @xmath66 will denote either the distance functions @xmath74 and @xmath77 , or @xmath75 and @xmath78 . we prove the following theorem in section [ theoremproof ] : [ orderedthm ] the distance function @xmath66 is a metric on @xmath38 , which is a contractible , complete , proper geodesic space . thus , given any two trees , we can always find a geodesic between them in both metrics @xmath77 and @xmath78 . on @xmath9 , the induced pseudometric @xmath66 on @xmath38 is a metric . ] we may often want to restrict to a subset of the large tree - space . [ subspacedef ] consider a subset @xmath10 , which only contains all representations of trees of certain restricted topologies , defined by collapsed subtrees of the maximal tree @xmath15 . the @xmath79 collapsed subtree of @xmath15 is characterized by a subset @xmath80 consisting of the edges in the maximal tree @xmath15 which are not collapsed . associated to it is a linear subspace @xmath81 containing representations of all the trees of this particular topology . we include all representations of each tree topology , and obtain a restricted preshape space @xmath82 containing all the trees that have of one of the considered topologies . the equivalence relation @xmath83 on @xmath9 restricts to an equivalence relation @xmath84 on @xmath11 , from which we obtain a restricted tree - shape space @xmath85 . the metric @xmath4 on @xmath9 induces a metric @xmath86 on @xmath11 which induces a quotient pseudometric @xmath87 on @xmath88 . denote by @xmath11 the space of all trees in @xmath9 with @xmath27 leaves , now @xmath88 is the space of tree - shapes with @xmath27 leaves . note that the space of tree - shapes on @xmath27 leaves in _ i ) _ is different from the billera - holmes - vogtmann ( bhv ) space @xcite of trees with vector attributes , because in the bhv space , geodesics will always deform leaves onto leaves , whereas in @xmath88 , leaves can be transformed to non - leaf branches by a geodesic . even in the restricted tree - shape space , we obtain an induced metric : [ subspacemetric ] the pseudometric @xmath89 on @xmath88 is a metric , and @xmath90 a contractible , complete , proper metric space . first , we show that the pseudometric is a metric . the pseudometric in equation defines the distance @xmath91 as the infimum of lengths of paths in @xmath38 connecting @xmath62 and @xmath69 . any path in @xmath88 is also a path in @xmath38 , so if @xmath92 , then @xmath72 as well , so @xmath73 . the proofs of the other claims follow the proof of theorem [ orderedthm ] as in section [ theoremproof ] . the world is not two - dimensional , and for most applications it is necessary to study embedded trees in @xmath13 . the main difference from the ordered case is that trees in @xmath13 have no canonical edge order . the left - right order on children of planar trees gives an implicit preference for edge matchings , and hence reduces the number of possible matches . when we no longer have this preference , we consider all orderings of the same tree and choose orders which minimize the distance . we define the space of ( unordered ) tree - like shapes in @xmath8 as the quotient @xmath93 , where @xmath94 is the group of reorderings of the maximal binary tree @xmath15 . the metric @xmath66 on @xmath38 induces a quotient pseudometric @xmath95 on @xmath96 . again , we can prove : [ unorderedthm ] for @xmath95 induced by either @xmath77 or @xmath78 , the function @xmath95 is a metric and the space @xmath97 is a contractible , complete , proper geodesic space . the same result holds for restricted tree - spaces with several restricted tree topologies : let @xmath10 be a subspace containing only trees of certain restricted topologies , as in definition [ subspacedef ] , which is saturated with respect to the reordering group is saturated if , for each tree topology appearing in @xmath11 , all reorderings of the same tree topology also appear in @xmath11 . equivalently , @xmath98 , where @xmath99 @xmath94 . for the corresponding restricted tree - space @xmath100 , the quotient pseudometric @xmath101 is a metric and the space @xmath102 is a contractible , complete , proper geodesic space . note that @xmath94 is a finite group , which means that @xmath96 is locally well - behaved almost everywhere . in particular , off fixed - points for the action of reorderings @xmath103 on @xmath38 , the projection @xmath104 is a local isometry , i.e. , it is distance preserving within a neighborhood . hence , the geometry from @xmath38 is preserved off the fixed points . geometrically , a fixed point in @xmath38 is an ordered tree - shape where a reordering @xmath105 of certain branches does not change the ordered tree - shape ; that is , some pair of sibling edges must have the same shape attributes . in particular , the fixed points are non - generic because they belong to the lower - dimensional subset of @xmath38 where two sibling edges have identical shape . theorem [ unorderedthm ] can be proved using standard results on compact transformation groups along with similar techniques as for theorem [ orderedthm ] . while considering all different possible orderings of the tree is easy from the point of view of geometric analysis , in reality this becomes a computationally impossible task when the size of the trees grow beyond a few generations . in real applications we can , however , efficiently reduce complexity using heuristics and approximations , as discussed in section [ complexitysection ] . it follows from the definition that the metrics @xmath77 and @xmath106 coincide with the classical tree edit distance ( ted ) metric for ordered and unordered trees , respectively . in this way the abstract , geometric construction of tree - space gives a new way of viewing the intuitive ted algorithm . the metrics @xmath78 and @xmath107 are descents of the euclidean metric on @xmath38 , and geodesics in this metric are concatenations of straight lines in flat regions . in section [ fundamental ] we compare the two metrics using examples . we now pass to the proof of theorem [ orderedthm ] . the rest of the article is independent of this section , and during the first read , the impatient reader may skip to section [ curvaturesection ] . however , while the proof is technical , theorem [ orderedthm ] is a fundamental building block for the shape space framework . we shall assume that the reader has a good knowledge of metric geometry or general topology @xcite . it is crucial for the proof that we are only identifying subspaces of the euclidean space @xmath9 which are spanned by euclidean axes , and these are finite in number . this induces a well - behaved projection @xmath108 , which carries many properties from @xmath9 to @xmath38 . we say that ordered tree - shapes whose ( collapsed ) ordered structure is the same , belong to the same _ combinatorial tree - shape type_. for each combinatorial type of ordered tree - shape @xmath109 ( @xmath110 ) which can be represented by collapsing edges in the maximal tree @xmath111 , there is a family @xmath112 of subsets of @xmath40 , which induce that particular type @xmath109 when we endow the edges in @xmath112 ( @xmath113 ) with nonzero attributes and leave all other edges with zero attributes . these subsets are characterized by the properties * the cardinality @xmath114 for all @xmath115 , @xmath110 . * there is a depth - first order on each @xmath112 induced by the depth - first order on @xmath40 , such that the ordered , combinatorial structure defined by any @xmath112 coincides with that defined by @xmath116 . that is , the subset @xmath112 for any @xmath117 lists the set of edges in @xmath15 which have nonzero attributes for the @xmath79 representation of any shape of type @xmath109 . corresponding to each @xmath112 is the linear subspace @xmath118 of @xmath9 given by @xmath119 and by condition b ) we can define isometries @xmath120 by forgetting the zero entries in @xmath118 and keeping the depth - first coordinate order . we generate the equivalence @xmath83 on @xmath9 by asking that @xmath121 whenever @xmath122 for some @xmath123 . we now define the space of ordered tree - like shapes as the quotient @xmath67 , and define the quotient map @xmath108 . it is clear from the definition that the distance function @xmath66 defined in is symmetric and satisfies the triangle inequality , which makes it a _ pseudometric_. [ pseudometricismetric ] let @xmath4 denote @xmath74 or @xmath75 . the pseudometric @xmath66 is a metric on @xmath38 . it suffices to show that @xmath124 implies @xmath73 ( @xmath125 ) . moreover , it is also easy to show that @xmath126 for any @xmath127 , so it suffices to show that @xmath128 implies @xmath73 . hence , from now on , write @xmath66 for @xmath78 , and assume that @xmath72 for two tree - shapes @xmath62 and @xmath69 . choose @xmath129 such that @xmath130 that is , @xmath131 is smaller than the size of any of the non - zero edges in @xmath62 and @xmath69 . we may assume that @xmath132 since otherwise we may assume by symmetry that @xmath133 and @xmath134 . denote by @xmath135 the image of @xmath118 under the quotient projection @xmath108 for any @xmath117 . we may assume that @xmath62 and @xmath69 belong to the same identified subspace ; that is , there exist @xmath136 such that @xmath137 since otherwise , @xmath138 since @xmath69 is a finite set , and @xmath139 is a closed set , ( [ emptyint ] ) implies @xmath140 in this case , the path will have to go through some @xmath141 which does not contain points equivalent to @xmath29 , and @xmath142 since in order to reach @xmath143 , we need to remove edge attributes which are nonzero in @xmath69 , and @xmath144 for all @xmath145 . thus , eq . [ inthesame ] holds , and in fact , it holds for all the intermediate path points @xmath146 from eq . [ metricdefn ] . but if the path points stay in @xmath135 , then the path consists of shifting and changing the nonzero edge attributes of the trees in question . this will only give a sum @xmath147 if the trees are identical and the path is constant . here , we prove the rest of theorem [ orderedthm ] , namely that the tree - shape space @xmath148 is a complete , proper geodesic space , and @xmath38 is contractible . first , we note that although @xmath38 is not a vector space , there is a well - defined notion of size for elements of @xmath38 , induced by the norm on @xmath9 : [ sizelemma ] note that if @xmath149 , we must have @xmath150 ; hence we can define @xmath151 . the equivalence is generated recursively from the conditions @xmath149 whenever either @xmath152 , indicating @xmath153 ; or @xmath154 , indicating @xmath155 since the @xmath156 are isometries . hence , the lemma holds by recursion . we will prove that @xmath148 is a proper geodesic space using the hopf - rinow theorem for metric spaces @xcite , which states that every complete locally compact length space is a proper geodesic space . a length space is a metric space in which the distance between two points can always be realized as the infimum of lengths of paths joining the two points . note that this is a weaker property than being a geodesic space , as the geodesic joining two points does not have to exist ; it is enough to have paths that are arbitrarily close to being a geodesic . it follows from ( * ? ? ? * lemma 5.20 ) that @xmath148 is a length space for _ any _ metric @xmath4 on @xmath9 where @xmath66 is a metric . to see that the tree - shape space is locally compact , note that the projection @xmath108 is finite - to - one , so any open subset @xmath157 of @xmath38 has as pre - image a finite union @xmath158 of open subsets of @xmath9 , such that @xmath159 and @xmath160 is compact whenever @xmath157 is bounded . we also need to prove that @xmath148 is complete : [ completenessdescends ] let @xmath66 denote either of the metrics @xmath77 and @xmath78 . the shape space @xmath148 is complete . the proof needs a lemma from general topology : _ ( * ? ? ? * , theorem 2.3 ) _ [ duglemma ] let @xmath161 be a metric space and assume that the metric @xmath4 has the following property : _ there exists @xmath129 such that for all @xmath162 the closed ball @xmath163 is compact . _ then @xmath66 is complete . using the projection @xmath108 , we can prove : [ closedandbounded ] bounded closed subsets of @xmath38 are compact . since lemma [ sizelemma ] defines a notion of size in @xmath38 , any closed , bounded subspace @xmath164 in @xmath38 is contained in a closed ball @xmath165 in @xmath38 for some @xmath166 , where @xmath167 is the image @xmath168 . since @xmath169 , it follows that @xmath170 , which is a closed and bounded ball in @xmath9 . since closed , bounded subsets of @xmath9 are compact @xmath171 is compact . by continuity of @xmath172 , @xmath173 is compact . then @xmath164 is compact too . it is now very easy to prove proposition [ completenessdescends ] : by lemma [ closedandbounded ] , all closed and bounded subsets of @xmath38 are compact , but then by lemma [ duglemma ] the metric @xmath66 must be complete . using the hopf - rinow theorem ( * , proposition 3.7 ) we thus prove that @xmath148 is a complete , proper geodesic space . we still miss contractibility : [ contractible ] let @xmath174 be a normed vector space and let @xmath83 be an equivalence on @xmath174 such that @xmath175 implies @xmath176 for all @xmath177 . then @xmath178 is contractible . define a map @xmath179 \to \bar{b}$ ] by setting @xmath180 . now @xmath181 is well defined because of the condition on @xmath83 , and @xmath182 so @xmath181 is a homotopy from @xmath183 to the constant zero map . combining the results of section [ theoremproof ] , we see that the proof of theorem [ orderedthm ] is complete . having proved theorem [ orderedthm ] , we may now pass to studying the geometry of the tree - shape space through its geodesics . uniqueness of geodesics and means is closely connected to the geometric notion of _ curvature _ , a concept which fundamentally depends on the underlying metric . using methods from metric geometry @xcite we shall investigate the curvature of the tree - shape space with the qed and ted metrics . using curvature , we obtain well - posed statistical methods for qed . the next theorem states that in the tree - shape space endowed with the qed metric , any randomly selected point has a corresponding neighborhood within which the tree - space has non - positive curvature . we shall use this fact to show that datasets within that same neighborhood have unique averages . [ qedcurv ] * endow @xmath38 with the qed metric @xmath78 . a generic point @xmath184 has a neighborhood @xmath185 in which the curvature is non - positive . at non - generic points , the curvature of @xmath186 is @xmath187 , or unbounded from above . * endow @xmath38 with the ted metric @xmath77 . the metric space @xmath188 does not have locally unique geodesics anywhere , and the curvature of @xmath188 is @xmath187 everywhere . claims i ) and ii ) also hold in the subspace @xmath189 containing only trees of certain restricted topologies , as defined in definition [ subspacedef ] . here , local uniqueness is defined as uniqueness within a sufficiently small neighborhood . _ genericity _ is a key concept in this paper . many of our results , e.g. , uniqueness of means , do not hold in general , but they do hold for a randomly chosen dataset with respect to natural probability measures . a _ generic property _ in a metric space @xmath190 is a property which holds on an open , dense subset of @xmath9 . in the tree - spaces @xmath191 and @xmath192 , one interpretation is that generic properties hold almost surely , or with probability one , with respect to natural probability measures . thus , for a random tree - shape , we can safely assume that it satisfies generic properties , e.g. , that the tree - shape is a binary tree . non - generic property _ is a property whose not happening is generic . this is similarly interpreted as a property that may _ not _ hold for randomly selected tree - shapes . a detailed discussion of the relation between genericity and probability is found in appendix a. one common misconception is that the term generic tree refers to a particular class of trees with a particular generic property . it is important to note that many different properties , which do not necessarily happen on the same subsets of tree - space , may all be generic at the same time . however , any finite set of generic properties _ will _ all happen on an open , dense subset . [ generic ] tree - shapes that are truly binary ( i.e. their internal edges are not collapsed ) are generic in the space of all tree - like shapes . let @xmath193 be a tree - shape in @xmath38 or @xmath96 which is not truly binary , represented by a maximal binary tree @xmath15 . by adding arbitrarily small noise to the zero attributes on edges of @xmath15 , we obtain truly binary tree - shapes @xmath194 which are arbitrarily close to @xmath193 . thus , the set of full truly binary tree - shapes in @xmath38 or @xmath96 is open and dense . hence , truly binary tree - shapes are generic both in @xmath38 and in @xmath96 . goes through a tree with a trifurcation , while geodesic @xmath195 does not have internal structural transitions . ] the essence of the proposition is that binary tree - shapes are generic , but that does not mean that non - binary trees do not need to be considered ! while non - binary trees may not appear as randomly selected trees , they _ do _ appear in geodesics between randomly selected pairs of trees , as in fig . [ fundamentalfigure ] . non - binary tree - like shapes also appear as samples in real - life applications , e.g. , when studying airway trees . however , we interpret this as an artifact of resolution rather than true higher - degree vertices . for instance , airway extraction algorithms record trifurcations when the lengths of internal edges are below certain threshold values . in order to understand and prove theorem [ qedcurv ] , we need a definition of curvature in metric spaces . in spite of its simplicity and elegance , this concept from metric geometry is novel in computer vision . we shall spend a little time introducing it before proceeding to prove theorem [ qedcurv ] in section [ qedcurvproof ] . since general metric spaces can have all kinds of anomalies , the concept of curvature in such spaces is defined through a comparison with spaces that are well understood . more precisely , the metric spaces are studied using _ geodesic triangles _ , which are compared with corresponding _ comparison triangles _ in model spaces with a fixed curvature @xmath196 . the model spaces are spheres ( @xmath197 ) , the plane @xmath12 ( @xmath198 ) and hyperbolic spaces ( @xmath199 ) , and through comparison with these spaces , we can bound the curvature of the metric space by @xmath196 . in this paper we shall use comparison with planar triangles , which gives us curvature bounded from above by @xmath200 . space if , for a geodesic triangle @xmath201 and for any point @xmath16 on the triangle , the distance from @xmath16 to the opposite vertex is not longer than the corresponding distance in the planar comparison triangle @xmath202 . ] given a geodesic metric space @xmath203 , a _ geodesic triangle _ @xmath201 in @xmath203 consists of three points @xmath204 and geodesic segments joining them . a planar _ comparison triangle _ @xmath205 for the triangle @xmath201 consists of three points @xmath206 in the plane , such that the lengths of the sides in @xmath202 are the same as the lengths of the sides in @xmath201 , see fig . [ cat0 ] . a @xmath207 space is a metric space in which geodesic triangles are thinner than for their comparison triangles in the plane . that is , @xmath208 for any @xmath16 on the edge @xmath209 where @xmath210 is the unique point on the edge @xmath211 such that @xmath212 and @xmath213 . if the planar comparison triangle is replaced by a comparison triangle in the sphere or hyperbolic space of fixed curvature @xmath196 , we get a @xmath214 space . a space @xmath203 has non - positive curvature if it is locally @xmath207 , i.e. , if any point @xmath215 has a radius @xmath20 such that the ball @xmath216 is @xmath207 . similarly , define curvature bounded by @xmath196 as being locally @xmath214 . [ negcurvex ] * the space @xmath157 obtained by gluing a family euclidean spaces @xmath217 together along isomorphic affine subspaces @xmath218 is a @xmath207 space . at any point in @xmath157 which is not a glued point , the local curvature is @xmath200 , since the space is locally isomorphic to the corresponding @xmath217 . at any glued point , it can be shown that the local curvature is @xmath219 . * the gpca construction by vidal et al . @xcite defines a @xmath207 space , giving a potential use of @xmath207 spaces and metric geometry in machine learning . * the space of phylogenetic trees is a @xmath207 space @xcite . * as we are about to see , the space of tree - like shapes is locally a @xmath207 space almost everywhere . one of the main reasons why @xmath214 spaces ( and @xmath207 in particular ) are attractive , is due to the following result on existence and uniqueness of geodesics . _ * proposition ii 1.4 ) _ [ bhprop ] let @xmath220 be a @xmath214 space . if @xmath221 , then all pairs of points have a unique geodesic joining them . for @xmath197 , the same holds for pairs of points at a distance less than @xmath222 . more results on curvature in metric spaces can be found in the book by bridson and haefliger @xcite . in this section we study the curvature of tree - shape space using the theory of @xmath207 spaces . we show that at a generic tree , the shape space has bounded curvature . the results rest on the following theorem : [ unique_geo ] at a generic point @xmath184 , the shape space is locally @xmath207 , and thus , @xmath38 has locally unique geodesics in a neighborhood of @xmath62 . recall from section [ singularspace ] how @xmath38 was formed by identifying subspaces @xmath223 , defined in eq . [ vdef1 ] and [ vdef2 ] . these identified subspaces corresponded to different representations in @xmath9 of the same shape @xmath184 . the points in @xmath38 can now be divided into three categories : * points @xmath224 which do not belong to the image of an identified subspace because they only have one representative in @xmath9 , and two classes of points in @xmath38 which have more than one representative in @xmath38 . * the first class contains points @xmath225 at which the space @xmath38 is locally homeomorphic to an intersection of linear spaces , as in example [ negcurvex ] a ) . these points are images of points @xmath226 which belong to one single identified subspace @xmath58 . * the second class contains points @xmath227 whose preimages @xmath228 in @xmath9 are at the intersection of identified subspaces @xmath229 . an example of such points is the image of the origin in fig . [ folding ] . these points correspond to trees where , infinitely close to the same tree , we can find pairs of trees in @xmath38 between which geodesics are not unique . these three classes of points correspond to local curvature @xmath200 , @xmath219 and @xmath187 . that is , the space is locally @xmath207 at points in categories _ i ) _ ; at points from _ ii ) _ it is @xmath214 for every @xmath230 , so has curvature @xmath219 ; and at points from _ iii ) _ it is not @xmath214 for any @xmath230 ; hence the curvature is @xmath187 . it thus suffices to show that the points in category _ iii ) _ are non - generic , which follows easily from the fact that these must necessarily sit in a lower - dimensional subspace of @xmath38 . the proof carries over to the subspace @xmath88 . we call a @xmath207 neighborhood @xmath231 of a point @xmath184 an _ injectivity neighborhood _ of @xmath62 . based on the above , we are now ready to prove : * the qed case : since @xmath38 is locally @xmath207 at generic points @xmath62 , the curvature of @xmath38 is non - positive in a neighborhood @xmath157 of @xmath62 . at points @xmath232 , however , we will always find pairs of points @xmath233 arbitrarily close to @xmath16 with two geodesics joining them , just as in fig . [ folding ] . * the ted case : consider a tree - shape @xmath234 , represented by a point @xmath61 . induce a second tree - shape @xmath194 represented by @xmath235 , where @xmath236 such that @xmath237 and @xmath238 have one non - zero coordinate , found in different edges , which are both nonzero edges in @xmath16 . the topology of @xmath194 is the same as of @xmath193 . for any @xmath239 , we can find @xmath27 ted geodesics @xmath240 from @xmath193 to @xmath194 , where @xmath241 can be decomposed as @xmath242 . thus , there are infinitely many ted geodesics from @xmath193 to @xmath194 , and @xmath188 does not have locally unique geodesics anywhere . as a consequence , its curvature is unbounded everywhere ( * ? ? ? * proposition ii 1.4 ) . the practical meaning of theorem [ qedcurv ] is that a ) we can use techniques from metric geometry to search for qed averages , b ) as we are about to see , for datasets contained in an injectivity neighborhood , there exist unique means , centroids and circumcenters for the qed metric , and c ) the same techniques can not be used to prove existence or uniqueness of prototypes for the ted metric , even if they were to exist . in fact , any geometric method which requires bounded curvature @xcite will fail for the ted metric . _ this motivates our study of the qed metric . _ it is easy to prove that the same results also hold for unordered tree - shapes : [ unordered_curvature ] the space @xmath243 of unordered trees with the qed metric is generically non - positively curved . with the ted metric @xmath106 , however , @xmath96 has everywhere unbounded curvature , geodesics are nowhere locally unique and neither are any of the types of average tree discussed in this paper . the same holds in the subspace @xmath244 , defined in theorem [ unorderedthm ] . in this section we use what we learned in the previous section to show that , given the qed metric on a space of tree - like shapes , we can find various forms of average shape in the space of ordered tree - like shapes , assuming that the data lie within an injectivity neighborhood . there are many competing ways of defining central elements given a subset of a metric space . we discuss several : the _ circumcenter _ considered in @xcite , the _ centroid _ considered , among other places , in @xcite , and the _ mean _ @xcite . the problem of existence and uniqueness of averages can be attacked using convex functions . recall that a function @xmath245 \to { \mathbb{r}}$ ] is convex if @xmath246 for all @xmath247 $ ] and @xmath248 $ ] . if we can replace @xmath249 with @xmath250 whenever @xmath2510 , 1[$ ] , then @xmath252 is _ strictly _ convex . convex functions have minimizers , which are unique for strictly convex functions . hence , existence and uniqueness of averages can be proven by expressing them as minimizers of strictly convex functions . we say that a function @xmath253 on a geodesic metric space @xmath9 is ( strictly ) convex if for any two points @xmath254 and any geodesic @xmath255 \to x$ ] from @xmath16 to @xmath29 , the function @xmath256 is ( strictly ) convex . we shall make use of the following standard properties of convex functions : [ convexlemma ] * if @xmath257 and @xmath258 are both convex , @xmath105 is monotonous and increasing , and @xmath105 is strictly convex , then @xmath259 is strictly convex . * if @xmath257 and @xmath258 are both convex , then @xmath260 is also convex . if either @xmath252 or @xmath105 is strictly convex , then @xmath261 is strictly convex as well . the _ mean _ of a finite subset @xmath262 in a metric space @xmath190 is defined as in eq . [ meandef ] , and is called the _ frchet mean_. local minimizers of eq . [ meandef ] are called _ karcher means_. the following result follows from a more general theorem by sturm ( * ? ? ? * proposition 4.3 ) ; we include the basic version of the proof here for completeness . [ existencemeans ] means exist and are unique in @xmath207-spaces . the function @xmath263 given by @xmath264 is convex for any fixed @xmath162 by ( * ? ? ? * proposition ii.2.2 ) , so the function @xmath265 is _ strictly _ convex by lemma [ convexlemma ] i ) . but then @xmath266 is strictly convex by lemma [ convexlemma ] _ ii ) _ , and a mean is just a minimizer of the function @xmath267 . the function @xmath267 is coercive , so the minimizer exists . since @xmath267 is strictly convex , the minimizer is unique . we also consider two other types of statistical prototypes for a dataset , namely _ circumcenters _ and _ centroids_. these are both well - known in the context of metric geometry and @xmath214 spaces . * * circumcenters . * consider a metric space @xmath220 and a bounded subset @xmath268 . there exists a unique smallest closed ball @xmath269 in @xmath203 which contains @xmath11 ; the center @xmath270 of this ball is the _ circumcenter _ of @xmath11 . * * the centroid of a finite set . * let @xmath9 be a uniquely geodesic metric space ( a metric space where any two points are joined by a unique geodesic ) . the centroid of a set @xmath271 of @xmath27 elements is defined recursively as a function of the centroids of subsets with @xmath272 elements as follows : denote the elements of @xmath273 by @xmath274 . if @xmath273 contains two elements , @xmath275 , the centroid @xmath276 of @xmath273 is the midpoint of the geodesic joining @xmath277 and @xmath278 . if @xmath279 , define @xmath280 , which is a set with @xmath27 elements . similarly , for larger @xmath70 , @xmath281 . all these sets have @xmath27 elements . if the elements of @xmath282 converge to a point @xmath283 as @xmath284 , then we say that @xmath285 is the _ centroid _ of @xmath273 in @xmath9 . based on the theory of @xmath214 spaces and our results for means , we have for the set of tree - like shapes : [ all_averages ] endow @xmath38 with the qed metric @xmath78 . a generic point @xmath184 has a neighborhood @xmath157 such that sets contained in @xmath157 have unique means , centroids and circumcenters . _ the same statistical properties also hold for the qed metric on unordered tree - shapes : _ generic points in the space of unordered tree - shapes with the qed metric @xmath243 have neighborhoods within which means , circumcenters and centroids exist and are unique . for the ted metric , these are not unique . the same results hold in the restricted tree - spaces @xmath88 and @xmath192 , defined in definition [ subspacedef ] and theorem [ unorderedthm ] . first consider @xmath38 and @xmath96 with the qed metric . by theorems [ qedcurv ] and [ unordered_curvature ] , @xmath38 and @xmath96 are both locally @xmath207 spaces , and by theorems [ orderedthm ] and [ unorderedthm ] they are both complete metric spaces . we have seen in theorem [ existencemeans ] that means exist and are unique in @xmath207 spaces , so the statement holds for means . by ( * proposition 2.7 ) , any subset @xmath203 of a complete @xmath207 space has a unique circumcenter . hence , the statement holds for circumcenters . similarly , by ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.1 ) , finite subsets of @xmath207 spaces @xmath9 have centroids ( unique by definition ) , so the statement holds for centroids . we turn to the ted metric . by definition , for any @xmath195-point dataset , all these notions of mean reduce to finding the midpoint of a geodesic connecting the two points . we know that geodesics and midpoints are not unique in the ted metric . this ends the proof . we have shown that the local curvature is nonpositive almost everywhere in @xmath38 , which makes @xmath38 well suited for geometric definitions of statistical properties . however , our notion of almost everywhere is strongly tied to ( maximal ) dimensionality , which again is strongly tied to the topological structure of the maximal tree @xmath15 . one consequence is that the injectivity neighborhoods in @xmath38 are rather small , as we are about to see through examples . in this section we impose natural constraints on tree - space that allow us to increase the size of the injectivity neighborhoods , and make a conjecture for future expansion beyond the use of @xmath207-spaces . consider the following two examples ; we thank the anonymous reviewer for the first ! * consider the tree - shapes @xmath286 and @xmath287 shown in fig . [ ref_ex_1 ] , left . these two tree - shapes are joined by two geodesics , and thus @xmath286 and @xmath287 are not contained in the same injectivity neighborhood in @xmath38 . however , in a suitably chosen @xmath88 , they can be . * consider the tree - shape @xmath193 in the space of unordered tree - shapes with attributes in @xmath12 , spanned by the maximal tree @xmath15 as in fig . [ ref_ex_2 ] , right . arbitrarily close to @xmath193 we will find two trees @xmath286 and @xmath287 which are joined by two geodesics , as shown in the figure . . ] are two other trees @xmath286 and @xmath287 who can not be joined by a unique geodesic . ] as a illustrated by these examples , the @xmath207 injectivity neighborhoods in the shape - space @xmath38 can be very small , mainly containing trees whose topology is the same as @xmath15 . however , we can obtain much larger injectivity neighborhoods by restricting to the natural subspaces @xmath189 and @xmath244 as in definition [ subspacedef ] . as shown in theorem [ all_averages ] , @xmath88 and @xmath192 have the same nice geometric properties as @xmath38 and @xmath96 , and @xmath11 can be chosen so that the injectivity neighborhoods are bigger than in @xmath38 and @xmath96 by avoiding situations as in the examples above . radius is not a good measure for the size of an injectivity neighborhood , as a tree may contain both small branches , which do not have much room to vary , as well as large branches , which will be allowed to move more throughout such a neighborhood . however , any convex neighborhood which does not contain points of curvature @xmath288 , will be an injectivity neighborhood . all the results from section [ meansection ] hold at generic points , within an injectivity neighborhood where the @xmath207 property holds . we have seen examples of points where local @xmath207-property must fail , illustrating the limitaitons of @xmath207 techniques for analyzing general trees . however , most of the situations where the @xmath207 property fails are highly non - generic , and we conjecture that more general results can be proven : [ conjecture ] for a generic set of points @xmath289 in @xmath38 , @xmath96 , @xmath88 or @xmath192 , means exist and are unique . as we have seen in theorems [ qedcurv ] , the qed metric gives locally non - positive curvature at generic points , while the ted metric gives unbounded curvature everywhere on @xmath191 and @xmath192 . equivalently , geodesics are locally unique almost everywhere in the qed metric , while nowhere locally unique in the ted metric . as emphasized by theorem [ all_averages ] , this means that we can not imitate the classical statistical procedures on shape spaces using the ted metric , while for the qed metric , we can . note , moreover , that the qed metric is the quotient metric induced from the euclidean metric on the pre - shape space @xmath9 , making it the natural choice of metric seen from the shape space point of view . from a computational point of view , the ted metric has nice local - to - global properties . if the trees @xmath286 and @xmath287 are decomposed into subtrees @xmath290 and @xmath291 as in fig . [ tedsplitting ] , such that the geodesic from @xmath286 to @xmath287 restricts to geodesics between @xmath292 and @xmath293 as well as @xmath294 and @xmath295 , then @xmath296 . many dynamic programming algorithms for ted use this property , and the same does not hold for the qed metric , due to the square root . for a qualitative comparison of qed and ted , we compare the geodesics defined by the ted and qed metrics between small , simple trees . consider the two tree - paths in fig . [ tedqedcomparison ] , where the edges are endowed with scalar attributes @xmath297 describing edge length . computing the costs of the two different paths in both metrics , we find the shortest ( geodesic ) path . path @xmath298 indicates a matching left and right side edges @xmath299 and @xmath4 , while path @xmath195 does not make the match . the cost of path @xmath298 is @xmath300 in both metrics , while the cost of path @xmath195 is @xmath301 in the qed metric and @xmath302 in the ted metric . thus , ted will identify the @xmath299 and @xmath4 edges whenever @xmath303 , while qed makes the identification whenever @xmath304 . thus , ted will be more prone to internal structural change than qed . the same occurs in the comparison of ted and qed matching in figs . [ qedmatching ] and [ tedmatching ] . although the ted is more prone to matching trees with different tree - topological structures , the edge matching results are similar , as is expected , since the metrics are closely related . in general , computational complexity is a problem for both ted and qed . computing ted distances between unordered trees is np - complete @xcite , and we conjecture that the qed metric is np - complete as well . we can , however , often use geometry and prior knowledge ( e.g. , anatomy ) to find efficient approximations . _ trees appearing in applications are often not completely unordered , but are semi - labeled_. [ semilabel ] most airway trees have similar , but not necessarily identical , topological structure , where several branches have names and can be identified by experts . the top generations of the airway tree serve very clear purposes in terms of anatomy . the root edge is the trachea ; the second generation edges are the left and right main bronchi ; the third generation edges lead to the lung lobes . as these are easily identified , we find a semi - labeling of the airway tree , and use it to simplify computations of inter - airway geodesics in section [ pulmonarysection ] . since the decomposition strategy used for dynamic programming in ted is not available for qed , an approximation of qed is used in our experiments . many anatomical trees have a somewhat fixed overall structure . for these , it is safe to assume that the number of internal structural transitions found in a geodesic deformation is low , and that the geodesics pass through identified subspaces of low codimension . the latter assumption is equivalent to assuming that the trees appearing throughout the geodesic deformation have nodes of low degree . for instance , for the airway trees studied in section [ pulmonarysection ] below , we find empirically that it is enough to allow for one structural change in each lobar subtree , which has at most a trifurcation . recall the definition of the metric from eq . [ metricdefn ] ; the approximation consists of imposing upper bounds @xmath305 on the number @xmath70 and @xmath267 on the degrees of internal vertices appearing in eq . [ metricdefn ] , respectively , giving : @xmath306 where all @xmath307 and @xmath308 have vertex degrees at most @xmath267 . geometrically , @xmath70 is the number of euclidean segments concatenated to form the geodesic . bounding @xmath70 is equivalent to bounding the number of internal topological transitions throughout the geodesic . in fact , @xmath309 _ the number of internal topological transitions in the geodesic_. all edges are translated to start at @xmath310 , and represented by a fixed number of landmark points ( in our case @xmath311 ) evenly distributed along the edge , the first at the origin . the distance between two edge attributes @xmath312 is the euclidean distance @xmath313 . we approximate of the qed metric using algorithm [ planaralg ] ; see appendix b in the supplemental material for details . the complexity of algorithm 1 is @xmath314 where @xmath27 is the number of internal vertices , @xmath305 is the bound on @xmath70 , @xmath267 is the bound on vertex degree and @xmath315 is the optimization in line @xmath316 . for the unordered airway trees in section [ pulmonarysection ] , we combine algorithm 1 with a complete search through the set of branch orderings . computing qed distances through a complete search is not optimal , and finding more exact and efficient algorithms is a nontrivial research problem . @xmath16 , @xmath29 planar rooted depth @xmath27 binary trees @xmath317 set of ordered identified pairs @xmath318 of subspaces of @xmath9 corresponding to internal topological changes through trees of order at most @xmath267 , corresponding to a subspace @xmath273 of @xmath38 , s.t . if @xmath319 , then also @xmath320 . @xmath321 @xmath322 @xmath323 @xmath324 @xmath325 @xmath326 geodesic @xmath327 [ planaralg ] the qed metric is new , whereas the properties of the ted metric are well known @xcite . our experimental results on real and synthetic data illustrate the geometric properties of the qed metric . the experiments on airway trees in section [ pulmonarysection ] show , in particular , that it is feasible to compute geodesics between real , @xmath8 data trees . movies illustrating geodesics between planar depth @xmath26 trees , as well as a table illustrating a tree - shape matching experiment for a set of synthetic planar depth @xmath26 trees , are found on the web page http://image.diku.dk/aasa/tree_shape/planar.html . the movies and matchings show the geometrically intuitive behavior of the geodesic deformations . we see that the intermediate structures resemble the geodesic endpoint trees in a reasonable manner , and show the ability of the geodesics to handle internal topological differences . these are among the wanted properties from the model listed in the beginning of section [ geometrysection ] . moreover , computed mean and centroid trees are shown in fig . [ dataset_means ] ; these are presented in greater detail in @xcite . the qed average trees clearly represent the main common properties of the dataset trees . as proof - of - concept experiments on real data we compute means for sets of pulmonary airway trees from the exact09 airway segmentation competition @xcite . the airway trees were first segmented from low dose screening computed tomography ( ct ) scans of the chest using a voxel classification based airway tree segmentation algorithm @xcite . the centerlines were extracted from the segmented airway trees using a modified fast marching algorithm based on @xcite . the method gives a tree structure directly through connectivity of parent and children branches . for simplicity , we only consider the upper airway tree down to the lobe branches . means are computed using both the qed metric ( details found in @xcite ) and using the ted method proposed by trinh and kimia @xcite . the dataset is shown in fig . [ airway_dataset ] , and the results are seen in fig . [ airway_means ] . we clearly see how the choice of ted geodesic makes the ted mean vulnerable to noise in the form of missing branches among the dataset trees , giving a mean shape whose structure is too simple . the qed mean , on the other hand , represents the data well . airway trees from the exact09 test set . @xcite ] th data tree misses these . ] starting from a purely geometric point of view , we define a shape space for tree - like shapes . this intuitive geometric framework allows us to simultaneously take both global tree - topological structure and local edgewise geometry into account . we study two metrics on this shape space , ted and qed , which both give the shape space a geodesic structure ( theorems [ orderedthm ] and [ unorderedthm ] ) . the framework is developed for tree - shapes , but carries over to other geometric trees with vector attributes . qed is the geometrically most natural metric , and turns out to have properties which are essential for statistical shape analysis . through a geometric analysis of the tree - shape framework , we show that the qed metric gives local uniqueness of geodesics and local existence and uniqueness for three versions of average shape , namely the mean , the circumcentre and the centroid ( theorem [ all_averages ] ) . our analysis gives new insight into the metric space defined by ted , and explains why the problem of finding ted - averages is ill - posed . both metrics are generally np complete to compute for @xmath8 trees . we explain how semi - labeling schemes can be used to handle complexity problems , and illustrate this by computing qed means for sets of trees extracted from pulmonary airway trees as well as synthetic planar data trees . the qed lacks an obvious decomposition strategy for dynamic programming , and involves an optimization term which makes it more time consuming to compute than the ted metric . the two metrics have similar matching properties , and thus , for applications which do not require a unique geodesic ( e.g. , clustering ) the ted metric is just as suitable as the qed metric . however , for statistical computations , the qed metric is the only suitable metric . this is emphasized by our experiments , where computed qed and ted means illustrate that the ted means are missing important structure . future research will be centered around two points : development of nonlinear statistical methods for the singular tree - shape spaces , and finding more efficient approximations and heuristics for the qed metric using both the tree geometry and the tree - space geometry . the latter will pave the road for computing averages and modes of variation for large , real @xmath8 data trees . this is by no means trivial , due to the non - smooth structure of the tree - shape space and the complexity of computing exact distances and geodesics . the purpose of this appendix is to explain the connection between genericity , defined as a topological property , and probability . in particular , we explain why a generic property can be assumed to hold with probability one , or almost everywhere , with respect to natural probability measures . the main point of the appendix is the contents of theorem [ mainthm ] . a property in a topological space @xmath9 is said to be _ generic _ if it holds on a dense , open subset of @xmath9 . a collection @xmath328 of subsets of some set @xmath9 is a _ @xmath329-algebra _ if @xmath23 has the following properties : * @xmath330 . * if @xmath331 , then its complement is also an element : @xmath332 . * if @xmath333 for a family @xmath334 , then the union is also an element : @xmath335 . a _ measure _ on a @xmath329-algebra @xmath23 is a function @xmath336 satisfying the @xmath329-additivity property : if @xmath337 is a countable family of pairwise disjoint subsets in @xmath23 , then @xmath338 . a property is said to hold _ almost everywhere _ with respect to a probability measure @xmath339 on a space @xmath9 if it holds on a subset @xmath340 such that @xmath341 . this corresponds to holding with probability one , or _ almost surely_. assume given a metric space @xmath190 , and @xmath329-algebra @xmath23 which contains the topology induced by @xmath4 , and measure @xmath339 on the sigma - algebra @xmath23 . assume also given an equivalence class @xmath83 on @xmath9 , and denote by @xmath67 the quotient of @xmath9 with respect to the equivalence . denote by @xmath342 the projection onto the quotient . the set @xmath343 is a @xmath329-algebra on @xmath38 . * @xmath344 so @xmath345 . * if @xmath346 then @xmath347 so @xmath348 , so @xmath349 . * if @xmath350 for @xmath334 then @xmath351 for all @xmath117 , so @xmath352 so @xmath353 . the function @xmath354 given by @xmath355 is a measure on @xmath356 . if @xmath357 is a countable family of pairwise disjoint subsets in @xmath356 , then @xmath358 is a countable family of pairwise disjoint subsets in @xmath23 , and @xmath359 . there are lebesgue induced measures @xmath360 and @xmath361 on the tree - spaces @xmath38 and @xmath96 , coming from the lebesgue measure @xmath362 on @xmath9 . for these measures , subsets of positive codimension have measure zero . in particular , generic properties hold almost everywhere with respect to the lebesgue induced measure . @xmath363 recall that we also work on a restricted subspace @xmath10 which consists of trees of certain fixed topologies that are collapsed versions of the maximal tree @xmath15 . the subspace @xmath11 is a finite union @xmath364 where each @xmath365 is a @xmath4-dimensional linear subspace of @xmath9 corresponding to a certain fixed collapsed version of @xmath15 described by its nonzero edge set @xmath80 . we assume , moreover , that @xmath366 whenever @xmath367 . each @xmath365 now has a lebesgue measure @xmath368 of its own , and we obtain a lebesgue induced measure @xmath369 on @xmath11 defined as @xmath370 the measure @xmath369 gives rise to lebesgue induced measures on @xmath88 and @xmath192 as explained above . there are lebesgue induced measures @xmath371 and @xmath372 on the tree - spaces @xmath88 and @xmath192 , coming from the lebesgue induced measure @xmath369 on @xmath11 . if all @xmath365 have equal dimension , subsets of positive codimension have measure zero . in particular , generic properties hold almost everywhere with respect to the lebesgue induced measure . @xmath363 @xcite let @xmath339 and @xmath373 be two measures on a @xmath329-algebra @xmath23 . the measure @xmath373 is _ absolutely continuous _ with respect to @xmath339 if and only if @xmath374 for each @xmath375 with @xmath376 . [ mainthm ] let @xmath373 be a probability measure which is absolutely continuous with respect to the lebesgue induced measure @xmath377 on one of the tree - space @xmath38 or @xmath96 , or of @xmath88 or @xmath192 under the assumption that all @xmath365 have equal dimension . now any subset of positive codimension has zero measure with respect to @xmath373 . in particular , generic properties hold almost surely , or with probability @xmath298 , with respect to @xmath373 . @xmath363 note that the converse is not necessarily true : properties which hold almost surely are not necessarily generic . in this appendix , we extend the explanation of how the approximate qed distance and geodesic computation specified in section 4.2 in the main paper can be made in practice . we shall consider computation of distances in the space of ordered trees @xmath38 , as the complete search reduction from ordered trees to the unordered tree - space @xmath96 is not hard to implement . recall that the tree - space @xmath38 is constructed from the euclidean space @xmath378 consisting of all trees spanned by a certain maximal combinatorial tree @xmath17 . the construction is made by identifying different representations of the same tree , with the help of an equivalence relation @xmath83 . denote by @xmath62 the equivalence class of a point @xmath61 . as discussed in the article , there is a standard way of defining a distance function on @xmath67 , given by the quotient pseudometric @xmath379 which is shown to be an actual metric . the quotient space construction is extremely useful for understanding the geometry of tree - space and proving statistical properties of tree - space based on geometry . however , it is less intuitive how one should proceed in order to actually compute distances in tree - space . in this section , we shall explain how the tree - space gluings are related to the trees themselves . recall that two points in @xmath9 are equivalent under @xmath83 and glued together in the formation of @xmath38 if they represent _ the same _ ordered tree - shape . how can we determine whether two points in tree - space represent the same ordered tree - shape ? this reduces to a tree isomorphism problem . more precisely : * assume given two points @xmath381 . * these points correspond to two combinatorial trees @xmath382 , equal to or derived from @xmath15 , where some of the edges in @xmath383 may be endowed with zero attributes in @xmath307 . * create two new combinatorial trees @xmath384 by deleting the edges in @xmath385 and @xmath386 with zero attributes in @xmath5 and @xmath6 , and using the induced orders on siblings from @xmath385 , @xmath386 to induce total orders on siblings in @xmath387 , @xmath388 . * the question of whether @xmath5 and @xmath6 end up in the same identified subspace is now equivalent to the question of whether @xmath387 and @xmath388 are isomorphic as ordered , combinatorial trees . the question of whether @xmath5 and @xmath6 represent the same tree - shape , is equivalent to the question of whether a ) @xmath387 and @xmath388 are topologically isomorphic , and b ) if yes , whether their ordered sets of attributes are identical . * the observations above give us a way to judge whether two points in @xmath9 are equivalent under the equivalence relation @xmath83 on @xmath9 ; equivalently , whether they are identified in @xmath38 . this realization can be used to reformulate algorithm 1 from the main paper in terms of the trees rather than in terms of the tree - space . * a geodesic in @xmath38 is composed of a set of linear stretches in @xmath9 between equivalence classes that belong to lower - dimensional identified subspaces . each such stretch can change one endpoint tree to the other endpoint tree by i ) gradually shrinking and removing edges , ii ) adding and gradually extending edges , or iii ) gradually changing edges which are present in both trees . all these changes are made simultaneously at constant speed throughout the linear stretch . * given two points @xmath389 and @xmath390 in @xmath38 , how can we find the shortest path joining them which consists of two euclidean stretches ? the length of the shortest such path is @xmath391 . we shall look at this problem in section [ twostretches ] below . * let @xmath389 , @xmath390 be tree - shapes in @xmath38 . let @xmath69 be some tree - shape whose topological structure can be obtained as a collapsed version of both @xmath389 and @xmath390 . * the topology of the tree @xmath69 is obtained from @xmath389 ( and similarly from @xmath390 ) by collapsing two types of edges : * * internal edges ( that is , there is some edge in the tree which is further from the root in @xmath389 ( or @xmath390 ) , which is not being collapsed ) , or * * external edges ( that is , all the edges in @xmath389 ( or @xmath390 ) which are farther from the root are also collapsed ) . * denote the sets of such edges as @xmath393 , @xmath394 , @xmath395 , @xmath396 , respectively . * we are looking for a point @xmath397 which contains some such @xmath69 as a subtree , such that the shortest two - stretch path from @xmath389 to @xmath390 passes through @xmath398 , and consists of the following types of deformations : * * deformation of all edges that collapse to an edge in @xmath69 ; throughout the whole path . * * gradually deforming all external collapsing edges in @xmath389 so that when we reach @xmath6 , their attributes have become zero ; throughout the whole path . * * gradually growing all external collapsing edges in @xmath390 from zero attributes when the deformation starts in @xmath5 ; throughout the whole path * * gradually deforming all internal collapsing edges in @xmath389 so that when we reach @xmath398 , their attributes are zero ; throughout the first stretch . * * from @xmath398 , gradually grow all internal collapsing edges in @xmath390 ; throughout the second stretch . * * thus , @xmath398 contains the edges from @xmath399 as well as the edges from @xmath394 and @xmath396 . + now the distance from @xmath389 to @xmath390 via @xmath398 is : @xmath400 where @xmath401 in case @xmath44 is not an edge in @xmath146 , @xmath402 . * this is illustrated in figure [ algorithm ] . * now we can define @xmath392 : @xmath403 where @xmath398 loops through the set of all trees generated from some tree @xmath69 which is a collapsed version of both @xmath389 and @xmath390 . the simplest possible path between two tree - shapes does not visit any identified subspaces , and has length @xmath404 . we have not in an obvious way taken into account that this might in fact be the shortest path . in order to see that this is part of the computation , let us start out as above : * let @xmath389 , @xmath390 be tree - shapes in @xmath38 . let @xmath69 be some tree - shape whose topological structure can be obtained as a collapsed version of both @xmath389 and @xmath390 . * the topology of the tree @xmath69 is obtained from @xmath389 ( and similarly from @xmath390 ) by collapsing two types of edges : * * internal edges ( that is , there is some edge in the tree which is further from the root in @xmath389 ( or @xmath390 ) , which is not being collapsed ) , or * * external edges ( that is , all the edges in @xmath389 ( or @xmath390 ) which are farther from the root are also collapsed ) . * assume that it is possible to find some tree @xmath69 which is obtained by only collapsing external edges . * the shortest path passing through the corresponding @xmath398 will be a single euclidean stretch , which can be obtained as described above . * hence , the option that @xmath404 might give the optimal path is part of the computation of @xmath392 . there is a chance that the intermediate trees appearing in this algorithm are too large for @xmath38 ( for example as in fig . [ algorithm ] . we have chosen to disregard this , and cut the intermediate trees off in iterative algorithms if they are too large . this can also be controlled by cutting @xmath398 off by default . * in order to compute @xmath391 , we need to search through all different collapsed versions @xmath69 of @xmath389 and @xmath390 . * in order to reduce computation time , we approximate this by setting a bound @xmath267 on the degree of vertices of the collapsed versions . * for @xmath405 , the number of such subtrees is @xmath406 , where @xmath27 is the number of edges in the tree . for @xmath407 , the number of such subtrees is @xmath408 . in our experiments we use @xmath405 . note that if we can answer the question in vii ) in the beginning of section [ reformulation ] , then we can compute @xmath409 as well : @xmath410 where @xmath398 goes through a family of trees derived from all possible collapsed trees @xmath69 obtained from @xmath389 . t. schlathlter , c. lorenz , i. c. carlsen , s. renisch , and t. deschamps . simultaneous segmentation and tree reconstruction of the airways for virtual bronchoscopy . in _ _ , volume 4684 , pages 103113 , 2002 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the analysis of cosmic large - scale structure in the distribution of galaxies contributed significantly to establish the current cosmological concordance model . with the increasing degree of perfection of the standard two - point correlation analysis , the related measurements reached unprecedented precision . however , the available and upcoming galaxy redshift survey data @xcite can not merely be characterized by its two - point correlation properties . already the filamentary structure that we see in those surveys indicates that the higher - order correlations play an important role . there have been different approaches to use this information for improving our knowledge about the constituents and evolution of the universe . the most direct approach of course is to simply measure the higher - order correlations directly . this has been done for both simulated and observed data starting for early catalogs with @xcite and @xcite . especially measurements of the three - point function have been standard for recent surveys @xcite and provide useful complimentary information @xcite . for higher orders , however , there are computational and conceptual challenges . on the computational side , increasing the order of the correlation function measured unleashes the curse of combinatorics . measuring all pairs in current surveys is feasible , for all triangles there are methods to do it @xcite , but beyond that it becomes increasingly hard . and then , from the conceptual side , even if measuring the full @xmath7-point function was possible , it would require modeling and covariances for a large number of data bins . already for a modest number of bins for each parameter of the @xmath7-point function this is a challenge . therefore , it is worthwhile to consider other approaches that contain information on certain aspects of the higher - order clustering without referring to the full correlation functions . since the beginning of large - scale structure analysis , a large number of such methods have been used , including moments of counts in cells , void probability @xcite , structure functions on minimal spanning trees , wavelet methods , the genus , etc . recently also approaches that attempt to bring the higher - order information back into the two - point correlation function through non - linear transforms were used like a logarithmic transformation @xcite . the method ( re-)considered in this paper is using minkowski functionals . they also also fall into the category of methods that provide condensed access to higher - order information . this information is encoded in the morphology of the density field . minkowski functionals access it by quantifying extended regions of the field through their geometrical properties like volume and surface ( see sec . [ sub : minkowski - functionals ] ) . for the construction of these extended regions , two different methods have been widely used in the past : in the first application of minkowski functionals for analyzing large - scale structure in the galaxy distribution in ( see @xcite for a short motivation and @xcite for a brief overview ) , the regions considered were defined by the union of balls around every galaxy location . we shall use the same method , referred to as germ - grain model , here and explain the details in sec . [ sub : germ grain ] . after a couple of applications in the analysis of galaxy and cluster catalogs , the germ - grain model has been less used in recent years . the second and most popular form of the application of minkowski functionals works with extended regions that are defined by iso - contours of the field under investigation . it has been used for the higher - order contributions to the dark matter overdensity field @xcite , for the weak lensing shear field @xcite , for local morphology of cosmic structure and for the morphology of reionization bubbles @xcite . another very active field of recent application is the study of iso - temperature contour maps of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) , where minkowski functionals helped to establish stringent bounds on the non - gaussianity of the cmb . so the iso - contour minkowski functionals are a well established tool in various domains of cosmology . however , as we shall discuss in sec . [ sub : germ grain ] , the germ - grain model accesses different aspects of the higher - order distribution and can be better suited for the analysis of galaxy redshift surveys . we have demonstrated some of these advantages already in the analysis of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) data release seven ( dr7 ) luminous red galaxies ( lrgs ) in @xcite . in the present paper , we concentrate more explicitly on the higher - order aspects of the minkowski functionals . to this end , we exploit the analytically known connection to the integrals over higher - order correlation functions . using direct measurements of the two - point correlation function , we can isolate the contribution of higher - order correlation functions to the minkowski functionals . this allows us to quantify the evidence for non - gaussianity of the galaxy distribution ( see @xcite and @xcite for related recent studies of non - gaussianity with isodensity contour functionals ) . the analysis is demonstrated with the final data from the baryon oscillation spectroscopic survey ( boss ) @xcite that is now publicly available within the dr12 of sdss - iii . being the largest spectroscopic galaxy redshift data set yet observed , it provides an ideal testbed for the analysis and reveals the strong presence of higher - order correlations already at redshifts of @xmath8 . we proceed as follows : sec . [ sec : minkowski - functionals - in - the ] recalls the properties of minkowski functionals in general and the germ - grain model in particular . we write out the connection of the functionals to higher - order correlations explicitly in [ sub : densdef ] and lay out in [ sub : density - dependence ] , how knowing the concrete form allows us to isolate the part of the functionals that is only dependent on higher - orders . we explain the subtleties of a gaussian reference model in the discrete case in [ sub : gauss - poisson ] and recall the basic properties of our minkowski code in [ sub : samplingcode ] . in sec . [ sec : data ] we turn to the description of the sdss dr12 data used . [ sub : cmass ] summarizes the data and mocks we are using . in [ sub : ceometry ] , we address issues related to the imperfections in the data , constructing a custom angular mask that defines a high quality region . in [ sub : radial ] we turn to the radial distribution of the data and choose the analysis volume and the radial grid . in [ sub : weights ] we finally discuss the effect of the regions that can not be accounted for by our custom mask . sec . [ sec : higherorders ] then turns to the core of the analysis . in [ sub : mfdensities ] we present the minkowski functionals of the mocks and the data and explain how we transform the data to be able to isolate the higher - order only part . this part is then examined in [ sub : highsubtract ] . in [ sub : seriescoefficients ] we demonstrate that the contributions to this higher - order part range at least up to the @xmath9-point function . to wrap up we discuss in [ sub : voidfraction ] an interesting aspects about the galaxy distribution using the base minkowski functional to study the volume in extreme voids in the observed field . we conclude in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] . in this section , we shall provide the basic notions necessary for understanding the quantities we used in our analysis . we summarize some key points already covered in the dr7 analysis paper @xcite , but with an emphasis on the crucial points that are the source for common misconceptions . minkowski functionals ( often called mfs later on ) quantify the morphology of extended bodies . they are defined as scalar functionals that map the shape of a body to a set of real numbers . a quite surprising result of integral geometry @xcite is that any such scalar functional , defined for bodies in euclidean @xmath10-dimensional space , that fulfills some basic requirements ( motion invariance , additivity and conditional continuity ) can be expressed as a linear combination of @xmath11 base functionals . there are different choices for the normalization of the base functionals . we will use one where the four mfs that exist for @xmath12 are denoted @xmath13 and related to geometrical properties of the body as follows : @xmath14 here , @xmath15 is the volume of the body , @xmath16 is its surface area , @xmath17 the integral mean curvature of the surface , and @xmath18 the euler characteristic ( the integral gaussian curvature of the surface ) . instead of using the functionals @xmath19 directly , we will mainly work with the mf densities @xmath20 : @xmath21 here @xmath22 is the volume within the survey boundary . in the practical calculation of the @xmath20 discussed in sec . [ sub : samplingcode ] , @xmath22 is the volume of the region that is more than two ball radii away from our custom angular mask of fig . [ fig : custommask ] . as mentioned , mfs are only defined for extended bodies . for the analysis of large - scale structure , however , the galaxies are usually treated as points . for points , all quantities in eq . ( [ eq : minkrelgeo ] ) are , a priori , trivial . for a meaningful analysis of large - scale structure , one therefore has to smooth the point distribution in some manner to define extended regions . the two most popular choices for defining extended regions are : 1 . isodensity contours 2 . the germ - grain model the first approach attempts to reconstruct the underlying density field from the observed galaxies and to define the extended bodies as the interior of the surfaces of constant density . the value of this density threshold can then be varied and the functionals are studied as a function of this parameter . in the second approach , the extended bodies are constructed by surrounding every galaxy ( the germ ) by an extended body ( the grain ) , which in our case is a ball of a certain radius , and calculating the functionals for the union of all these balls . the diagnostic parameter in this case is the common radius of the balls . [ fig : boolean ] shows how a structured body emerges with increasing radius . are surrounded by balls of a common radius @xmath23 . then the mfs of the body formed by the union of all the balls are studied as a function of @xmath23 . the parts of the body outside of the survey region are not taken into account . with increasing @xmath23 , more and more balls intersect and a complex structure develops . through the single and multiple intersections of neighboring balls , it encodes information about the @xmath7-point correlation hierarchy . plot from @xcite.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] only those parts of the structure are taken into account that lie within the survey boundaries , in fig . [ fig : boolean ] illustrated as a cube . even though the basic analysis tool is the same in both cases , the properties of the two approaches are quite different . the isodensity contours , at least in theory , are more directly linked the underlying physical density field , whereas the germ - grain radii are purely diagnostic parameters that merely specify the scale at which the correlations are probed . regarding the temporal evolution , the mfs for isodensity contours turn out to be relatively independent of the ( linear ) growth of the density field , if the value of the threshold density is adjusted accordingly . on the germ - grain side , there is no corresponding relabeling and , therefore , as we also shall see below , they depend significantly on the amplitude of the power spectrum . besides these conceptual differences , there are some technical advantages to the calculation of germ - grain mfs : 1 . the evaluation directly uses the point distribution and does not use a smoothing procedure that is an art by itself . the use of balls does not introduce additional ( smoothing ) parameters . the construction of smooth surfaces can be noisy if the density is low . the rougher smoothing procedure in the germ - grain model on the other hand always constructs some well defined surface . for both smoothing methods there have been detailed analysis how the values of the measured functionals are related to the parameters of the underlying density distribution . for the germ - grain case we recall this relation in the following section . due to the simplicity of the geometrical construction as a union of intersecting balls , it is relatively straightforward to relate the germ - grain mfs to correlation properties of the analyzed point distribution . for the case of a poisson distribution this has been achieved in @xcite , with the only relevant parameter being the density of the random sample . in the presence of structure , the dependence on higher order correlations has first been demonstrated in . in the following , we shall use the form derived in @xcite and detailed in the appendix of @xcite . in these works it has been shown that the ensemble average of the germ - grain mf densities defined in eq . ( [ eq : minkdens ] ) , for the case of balls as grains , can be expressed in an analytic manner as a function of the quantities @xmath24 and @xmath25 . @xmath24 is the ensemble average density of the point distribution studied , and the @xmath25 are the unnormalized modified mfs from the dr7 paper @xcite . the analytic relation reads @xmath26 and provides the implicit definition of the @xmath25 . in the rest of the paper we will drop the explicit ensemble averaging brackets and use @xmath27 as a shorthand , as we never refer to the mf density of one individual realization . we discuss this aspect in more detail in sec . [ sub : samplingcode ] . for a poisson distribution , the @xmath25 are simply the mfs @xmath28 of the balls of common radius @xmath23 that we use to obtain extended bodies : @xmath29 in the poisson case eq . ( [ eq : minkdensdef ] ) reduces to the result of @xcite . for a point distribution with structure , the @xmath25 are modified by weighted integrals of the dimensionless higher - order connected correlation functions @xmath30 . this modification is what we are interested in in this paper . it is convenient to define it as a multiplicative dimensionless correction to the poisson value , i.e. to study the quantities @xmath31 we will refer to @xmath32 as the modified mfs . they can be easily obtained from the quantities we measure , i.e. the average densities @xmath20 , by inverting eqs . ( [ eq : minkdensdef ] ) : @xmath33 in the analysis below , we will mainly use these modified mfs instead of the densities @xmath20 , as they are more directly related to the correlation properties of the point distribution via ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) . from @xcite the relation of @xmath32 to the correlations of order @xmath34 , @xmath35 , is of the form @xmath36 with @xmath37 being simply the mfs of the _ intersection _ of @xmath34 balls . @xmath38 denotes a ball around the origin and @xmath39 a ball around the point @xmath40 . in our model all intersecting balls have the same radius @xmath23 . for general germ - grain models , this is not a necessary requirement . one could imagine to increase the weight of some points by assigning them larger radii than other points . using elliptic or even more irregular grains would also be possible . however , this would complicate the interpretation as we expect that it would lead to a more complicated relation of the functionals to the correlation hierarchy than the one of eq . ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) . the advantage of the @xmath32 of being more directly related to the correlation properties is counterbalanced by an increase in the error . in @xcite we found weaker constraints when using the @xmath25 as compared to the @xmath20 . the main reason for this is the additional error that is introduced by removing the exponential suppression @xmath41 from @xmath42 in ( [ eq : minkdensdef ] ) . for @xmath43 , for example , @xmath44 so the relative error for the fraction of the volume not covered by any ball enters also for the higher functionals . this spoils to some extent the good precision that can be obtained for @xmath42 , because @xmath45 has to be measured in the full volume and @xmath42 only on the surface . especially for small @xmath46 it becomes costly to determine @xmath45 well enough . we will therefore restrict our analysis of the @xmath32 to parameter regions where @xmath46 is larger than @xmath47 . the modified mfs @xmath32 of eq . ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) not only depend on our diagnostic parameter , i.e. the radius @xmath23 of the balls that we are using to smooth the galaxy distribution , but also on the sample density . the rather complicated @xmath23 dependence is entirely encoded in the weight functions @xmath48 in the integrals over correlation functions . the dependence on the mean density of the galaxy sample @xmath24 , however , is of an easier form . it is a simple power series in @xmath24 @xmath49 with coefficients @xmath50 and @xmath51 that contain all of the radius and correlation function dependence . @xmath52 is the volume of a ball @xmath53 of radius @xmath23 . we choose to define the second index of @xmath54 such that it directly corresponds to the order of the integrated correlation function . the formal split into @xmath24 dependence and correlation function dependence in eq . ( [ eq : powerseriesdecomp ] ) allows us two things : first , we can remove the poisson part and the part that depends on the two - point correlation function , if we measure the sample density and the two - point correlations independently . this leaves us with a quantity @xmath55 that only includes higher - order contributions . this will prove the significance of their contribution to the mfs in sec . [ sub : highsubtract ] . second , we can extract the integrals over correlation functions by fitting a polynomial to the density evolution of @xmath56 . this allows to define a fitting formula for the form of the mfs in the sdss by giving the values and covariances of the coefficients @xmath57 . we shall use this in sec . [ sub : seriescoefficients ] . we close with the remark that , in general , a finite number of coefficients is not sufficient to describe the full shape of a power series of the sort ( [ eq : powerseriesdecomp ] ) . for cooked up point distributions with small @xmath30 , but a single large @xmath58 at some higher @xmath59 , giving only the lower coefficients will not determine @xmath32 well . for the assumed structure of the universe as the product of standard structure formation , however , we find that the coefficients @xmath60 are well behaved and the series @xmath32 converges reasonably well ( see sec . [ sub : seriescoefficients ] ) . in order to illustrate the relations ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) , let us consider the simplest non - trivial case . in analogy with the continuous case , one can define a gaussian point distribution by the absence of all higher - order connected correlation functions . in this case the hierarchy of correlations in ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) is truncated after the linear term and we have @xmath61 the weight functions @xmath62 are non - zero only for the range of @xmath63-values for which the balls intersect . for a coordinate system centered around the origin , i.e. the center of @xmath53 , the @xmath40-values therefore lie in a sphere of radius @xmath64 . a configuration of balls of radius @xmath23 therefore probes the correlation function up to a scale @xmath64 . we shall therefore plot the radial dependence as a function of the diameter @xmath65 instead of the radius . for isotropic correlations ( [ eq : minkgaussexp ] ) becomes @xmath66 the shape of the weights @xmath67 is shown in fig . [ fig : integrationwindow ] . and their fourier transforms can be found in @xcite ( in the fourier form of @xmath68 in eq . ( 16 ) there is a typo : the prefactor of the integral should be @xmath69 instead of @xmath70 ) . ] of eq . ( [ eq : minkgaussexp-1 ] ) , for a ball radius of @xmath71 . all functions have been normalized to their maximal value . the functionals of higher index @xmath72 probe the correlation function at larger distances . ( same plot already in @xcite ) [ fig : integrationwindow],scaledwidth=45.0% ] let us just recall that the weights are such that @xmath73 and @xmath74 have a particularly interesting form . @xmath73 directly contains the amplitude of fluctuations on the scale of the balls @xmath75 , @xmath76 and @xmath74 is a simple integral over the two - point function @xmath77 which could therefore be recovered from the derivative of @xmath74 . let us pause here and elaborate a bit on the gauss - poisson process as such ( see @xcite for a more complete discussion of what follows ) . it is tempting to think of the truncated quantities ( [ eq : minkgaussexp-1 ] ) as being the mfs of a point distribution that represents the gaussian limit of an actual point distribution that has higher - order correlations . however , in general there will not be a gauss - poisson point process that actually realizes these mfs , as in order for a gauss - poisson process to exist , @xmath78 and @xmath24 have to fulfill certain conditions . already in the continuum case , the clustering amplitude is limited by the fact that the matter density can only be positive . the density distribution , therefore , is in any case only approximated by a gaussian . this approximation of course is , excellent for early times and large scales , but when matter fluctuations @xmath75 grow too large it breaks down . this is also the point where higher - order correlations become important . in the same manner , the clustering amplitude of a gauss - poisson point process is limited . in this case , however , also the mean density of the point sample @xmath24 plays a role . for low enough density a thinning of the point distribution goes to an approximated poisson distribution . this effect can compensate larger fluctuations and it can be shown @xcite that the corresponding constraint is @xmath79 where @xmath80 are the fluctuations in the number density of cells @xmath81 stemming from structure ( @xmath82 are the full fluctuations including the poisson term ) , @xmath83 is the volume of one of these cells , and @xmath84 the mean number of particles in such a cell . this constraint has two interesting implications : first , we can already tell from the amplitude of the two - point function if the field will have a significant amount of higher order clustering . when we evaluate ( [ eq : fluctconstraint ] ) for the structure that we measure in the boss galaxies , we find that the constraint actually is violated . second , to study the gaussian limit on large scales it is not sufficient to simply increase the domain size ( the ball size in our case ) . in some cases , where the fluctuations on a region decay faster than its volume the constraint indicates that the structure for larger cells becomes more gaussian . in general , however , one will have to reduce the number density . in the continuous case , by smoothing over larger and larger regions , the amplitude of the fluctuations between these regions decreases and the gaussian approximation becomes better and better . in the discrete case , the analogous coarse graining procedure involves a subsampling of the density field . in the same way that the number of regions is reduced in the continuous case when averaging the density over larger cells , individual points of the downsampled point distribution represent larger regions . we will demonstrate this effect in sec . [ sub : mfdensities ] where we show the mfs for a couple of densities . the lower this density becomes , the better the gaussian model fits . in addition to the requirement ( [ eq : fluctconstraint ] ) , @xcite also showed that the correlation function of a gauss - poisson point process has to satisfy @xmath85 and can not be negative @xmath86 any violation of ( [ eq : fluctconstraint ] ) ( [ eq : xiconst ] ) already implies the existence of higher - order correlations @xmath30 with @xmath87 . we note finally that the condition ( [ eq : fluctconstraint ] ) prevents ( [ eq : v0-sigma ] ) and therefore the volume fraction @xmath45 in ( [ eq : minkdensdef ] ) from becoming negative . so we could have derived a similar constraint on a gauss - poisson process from the requirement that @xmath88 . the procedure we use to measure the functionals is the same as in the dr7 analysis @xcite . as the quantities that are related to the hierarchy of correlation functions via ( [ eq : minkdensdef ] ) are , strictly speaking , the ensemble averages of the mf densities @xmath20 , we approximate these averages by creating randomly subsampled realizations of the point distribution and averaging over their mf densities . mathematically speaking there is no guarantee that these averages should converge to those of an ensemble of independent realizations ( see also @xcite ) , but practically the procedure is working quite well . for studies on small scales one could in principle use subfields of the full survey as independent realizations and perform an average that is then more likely to converge ( even though it also requires the assumption of ergodicity and is only valid approximately as neighboring regions are not completely independent ) . for the scales that we are interested in , however , there is only one realization of the survey and therefore we use the subsampling . for details on how we generate the samples see the end of sec . [ sub : radial ] . the calculation of the @xmath20 for a given downsampled realization is performed by chipmink ( code for high speed investigation of partial minkowski functionals ) , introduced in the dr7 paper @xcite . in a first step , it generates neighbor lists for every galaxy in the sample . galaxies are considered as neighbors if they are closer than twice the maximal radius of the balls . to determine @xmath89-@xmath90 , the code considers galaxies that are more than @xmath64 away from the boundary . using the list of neighbors the code calculates the uncovered surface , integrated mean curvature and euler characteristic of the ball put around the galaxy . these partial functionals are then summed to give the global @xmath20 . the volume used for obtaining the densities from the summed @xmath91 is the effective part that is more than @xmath64 away from the boundary . for the volume functional @xmath45 another set of neighbor lists is generated that contains all galaxies within @xmath92 around points from a random sample filling the same volume as the data , but also eventual holes in the data that are not treated as internal boundaries . around each primary random point we generate @xmath4 random points in spheres of increasing radius @xmath93 . the volume fraction covered by the balls is then estimated by counting the fraction of the secondary randoms that have a distance of less than @xmath23 to any of the galaxies in the neighbor list of the primary random point . as compared to the dr7 code , we made a couple of enhancements . besides improved memory management , the code can now handle boundaries of arbitrary shape in ra - dec . it can use data with non - constant density , uses a larger fraction of points for radii smaller than @xmath94 , and samples the @xmath95-plane more efficiently than the earlier version . we plan to make also the current version publicly available . having completed the discussion of the methods , we now turn to a description of the data . the galaxy sample we are analyzing was observed by the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite using the 2.5-meter sloan telescope @xcite . photometric data used for target selection was obtained using a drift - scanning mosaic ccd camera @xcite and information on the camera , photometry and photometric pipeline can be found in @xcite . all the photometry was re - processed and released in the eighth data release @xcite . based on the so obtained target catalog , the spectroscopic redshifts are taken by the spectrographs described in @xcite . the final step of spectroscopic data reduction and redshift determination is presented in @xcite . the data analyzed here is contained in the twelfth data release ( dr12 ) @xcite of sdss data and was obtained during the third stage of sdss @xcite within the baryon oscillation spectroscopic survey ( boss ) @xcite . it is described in detail in @xcite . the full data set consists of the spectroscopic redshifts of 836,347 galaxies . the area probed is divided in a northern and a southern part and two different target redshift ranges . for our analysis we use the largest contiguous part of the survey , which is the northern cmass sample . given the technical progress in the boundary treatment of our code , mentioned in sec . [ sub : samplingcode ] , it would now also be possible to use it for the combined sample analyzed in @xcite . the mock catalogs we are using for estimating errors and covariances were constructed using two different methods . one is based on the quick particle mesh technique ( qpm ) described in @xcite and the other one is a hybrid method @xcite which employs what the authors call `` augmented '' second - order lagrangian perturbation theory . it was used for generating the multidark(md)-patchy mocks @xcite . we shall work with both mock catalogs in our analysis , but concentrate on the md - patchy mocks . , @xmath96 and @xmath97 away from the nearest boundary.[fig : custommask],scaledwidth=45.0% ] for taking the data of the northern cmass sample , @xmath98 objects were targeted over an area of @xmath99 . out of these , @xmath100 turned out to be galaxies and obtained redshifts from good boss spectra @xcite . they are distributed over @xmath101 . their redshifts range approximately from @xmath102 to @xmath103 . the central region of redshift @xmath104-@xmath105 that is used in most of the cmass analysis ( see e.g. @xcite ) contains @xmath106 galaxies . the md - patchy and qpm mock catalogs are constructed such that they trace the number density of the data . they are available for the central range of @xmath104-@xmath105 . their angular distribution fills the full survey geometry . for matching the angular distribution of the data as well , regions of bad data quality or missing observations can be masked out . the qpm mocks contain on average @xmath107 galaxies . after application of the full veto mask the average number is @xmath108 . for the md - patchy mocks , the unmasked number of galaxies is @xmath109 and the masked one @xmath110 . our custom radial selection of a redshift range of @xmath111 , explained in section [ sub : radial ] , reduces the number of galaxies that we use to @xmath0 . in order to compare the data to the galaxy samples created in the mock catalogs , it would be sufficient to calculate the mfs for the masked mocks and the data . however , ideally we would like to derive quantities that are independent of effects of the survey boundary . this is not necessary for the direct comparison , but desirable for later comparison of the data with other simulations without having to apply the survey mask to them . when estimating the correlation function , the effect of boundaries ( inner boundaries such as holes as well as the outer boundary ) can be taken into account by using random samples with the exact same boundaries as the data . the excess of data over random pairs in a given bin is then solely due to structure . in the case of the mfs , unfortunately there is no simple analogue to this approach . we tried to correct the mfs of the masked mocks with the mfs of a random distribution and the same mask . a comparison with the unmasked mocks showed that this correction is not effective in the mf case . in order to minimize the influence of boundaries , we therefore choose to restrict our analysis to regions with good data quality . this is achieved by using only galaxies that are more than @xmath64 away from the closest boundary , where @xmath23 is the common radius of the balls around every galaxy ( see sec . [ sub : germ grain ] ) . of course , especially for large @xmath23 , this reduces the volume probed and so the number of galaxies that can be used . we therefore have to find a compromise as to which boundaries we include and which we can ignore without affecting the result too much . as discussed in detail in @xcite , there are at least seven different effects that lead to bad or missing data . for each effect there is a veto mask that can be used in the correlation function analysis . the effects are : * the central bolt obscures the center of the plate * ly@xmath112 targets are given priority in fiber assignment * no observations around bright stars * no observations around bright objects * non - photometric conditions * spectra with bad seeing * spectra degraded by extinction the regions obscured by the first three effects are quite small individually , but relatively evenly distributed over the sky . including them , and especially the @xmath64 region around them , would reduce the usable area by a large amount , so we can not correct for their effect . the fourth effect is also present all over the sky , however , the obscured regions have a wide range of sizes . therefore we can exclude the largest ones . . the points indicate the minimal value of the density of the 1000 qpm mocks in the respective bin . the reference density with respect to which we define our downsampling is @xmath113 . this combination of reference density and redshift range maximizes the number of downsampled galaxies in the boxed blue shaded region . we also use the points above the reference density by downsampling always from the full density.[fig : radialselection],scaledwidth=45.0% ] the combination of the lower four masks is shown as the black regions in fig . [ fig : custommask ] . of those regions we select those with an area on the sky of more than about @xmath114 . we densely sample these regions and their boundaries with points that are shown in blue . these are used to determine the distance of a galaxy from the nearest boundary . the projected holes created by ball diameters @xmath64 of @xmath115 , @xmath96 and @xmath116 are shown as the regions not filled by orange , blue and yellow color . at these diameters the effective volume left is @xmath117 , @xmath118 and @xmath119 , respectively . for the largest scales probed of @xmath120 , only @xmath121 remains . as the mask we constructed does not take into account all imperfections , we have to test the extent to which the result still depends on the survey boundaries . in order to study this , we removed the galaxies from the mocks that fall into one of the seven masks described above . then we determined the distance of the remaining galaxies from our boundaries that are shown in fig . [ fig : custommask ] . we calculated their germ - grain mfs and those of the galaxy in the corresponding cubic mocks periodically wrapped to remove any boundary . the resulting comparison is shown in fig . [ fig : maskcorrection ] . it also contains the case where we use the full veto mask to remove the unobserved galaxies , but only take the outer boundaries into account in the calculation of the mfs . we find that our custom mask greatly improves the match with the boundaryless case as compared to not taking inner boundaries into account . after the correction the periodic mfs are now within the error bars of the sky mfs . the sky values of @xmath73 in fig . [ fig : maskcorrection ] have been corrected for a systematic @xmath122 offset from the periodic case . we shall apply the same correction throughout the rest of the paper . as the offset has been derived from a comparison of the sky mocks to the periodic mocks , one could think of using the deviations of fig . [ fig : maskcorrection ] to apply density and scale dependent corrections to both the sky mocks and the data , to empirically remove the effect of the boundary . we decided not to apply this correction as it would make the results for the mfs of the data completely dependent on this particular set of mocks . from fig . [ fig : maskcorrection ] , we also see that our correction is largest for the fourth functional @xmath74 and least important for @xmath73 . this reflects the property of the integration kernel of fig . [ fig : integrationwindow ] . with increasing index @xmath72 , the functionals probe larger and larger scales and are hence more sensitive to the large scale boundary effects we removed . in addition to the angular selection , we also apply some radial cuts . as described in sec . [ sub : density - dependence ] we want to study the mfs of the galaxy distribution as a function of ball radius , but also sample density . a controlled variation of sample density requires a roughly constant density throughout the sample . otherwise the summation of partial mfs ( see sec . [ sub : samplingcode ] ) from different regions of the survey would combine @xmath20 values effectively measured at different densities , removing the clear distinction between the @xmath24 and the @xmath30 dependence in eq . ( [ eq : minkdensdef ] ) . to generate a homogeneous sample we downsample the density to a common value for all radial shells . the concept is shown in fig . [ fig : radialselection ] . -@xmath24-space . for the smaller diameters there are @xmath123 density points , for the largest diameter used in the analysis @xmath124 , there are @xmath125 . the lines of constant @xmath45 are calculated for a poisson point process and correspond to \{0.99 , 0.95 , 0.75 , 0.55 , 0.35 , 0.15 , 0.05 , 0.01 } from top to bottom.[fig : densitygrid],scaledwidth=45.0% ] there , we plot the binned density distribution of the qpm mocks . for each bin we show the minimum of the 1000 qpm mocks . using this density distribution , we choose a reference density such that the number of points in the constant density region of the considered redshift range is maximal . this density is @xmath126 and corresponds to @xmath127 galaxies . the total number of galaxies in this redshift range is @xmath0 . as we used the minimum of all mocks , we can be sure that we can downsample from this reference density and obtain the same constant density for every single mock realization . the sampling points in radius and density that we used are shown in fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] . for ball diameters up to @xmath128 , there are @xmath123 density points ranging from @xmath129 to @xmath130 of the reference density . for diameters above @xmath128 we decrease the maximal density and therefore the number of density points . the reason for this is two - fold : first , as discussed in sec . [ sub : densdef ] , for very small fractions of uncovered volume ( i.e. large radius and/or high density ) , the precision of the determination of @xmath45 is no longer high enough to give reasonable error bars for the derived quantities @xmath32 . second , the runtime is much worse if the galaxies have a large numbers of neighbors . the density cutoff in fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] is therefore roughly chosen along the lines of constant @xmath45 . [ fig : densitygrid ] includes these lines for the poisson case , which we used for a first estimate of reasonable density ranges . from the range of diameters shown in fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] , we choose @xmath131 to @xmath132 for our analysis . for smaller scales than @xmath131 we expect to pick up too much effects from the ignored holes in the survey and for larger scales than @xmath132 , the volume far enough from the boundary becomes too small . for our independent measurement of the correlation functions of the data and the mocks , we chose to use those regions that are more than @xmath133 away from the closest boundary that we treat . the structure that we measured for these regions is shown in fig . [ fig : meancorrfun ] . the concrete monte carlo procedure we use is then to randomly select galaxies from the full number of galaxies in our redshift range ( and _ not _ a pre - downsampled reference density as in the dr7 paper ) for each @xmath134-point of the grid in fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] , to obtain a sample with the constant target density in each radial bin . we then calculate the mfs for this configuration . we repeat the random selection and average the resulting mfs over these different realizations of the subsampled point distribution . the number of realizations is largest for the smallest densities and ranges from @xmath135 for a fraction of @xmath129 to @xmath136 for a fraction of @xmath130 . scatter of the mocks.[fig : meancorrfun],scaledwidth=45.0% ] in addition to the regions that could not be observed or had bad data quality and that therefore had to be masked out , there are also imperfections in the rest of the observed survey volume . even though the completeness of the survey is high , see @xcite , there are still galaxies that have not obtained robust redshifts ( no - z ) . in addition due to the physical size of the fibers of the spectrograph , galaxies separated by less than @xmath137 can not be observed simultaneously ( close pairs ) . in the correlation function analysis , these holes are accounted for by upweighting nearby galaxies . in our case this can not be done as easily . in principle one could use imaging data for the angular position and the redshift of nearby galaxies to mimic the procedure in the correlation function case and fill in the holes . however , as we are already ignoring a large number of holes and looking at relatively large scales , we decided not to take these holes into account and to mask them in the mocks consistently . however , we include another class of weights correcting for spurious density fluctuations due to stellar density and seeing . for the correlation function analysis , these have been combined into a systematic weight ( see @xcite ) . we use this systematic weight to adjust the probability of selecting a galaxy when we downsample to a given target density . as the modifications are below @xmath138 and not factors of @xmath139 to @xmath125 as in the case of the no - z and close pairs weights , the fluctuations can be accounted for relatively easily by this procedure . in this section we first present the measured values for the observables @xmath20 introduced in sec . [ sub : densdef ] . we study their radial and density dependence based on the md - patchy mocks . then we turn to the analysis of the higher - order contributions . for this analysis , we need the @xmath32 that are obtained from the measured @xmath20 through eqs . ( [ eq : inverse - mink ] ) . from the @xmath32 we can then simply subtract the two - point part of the expansion ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) to extract the @xmath140 part ( [ eq : defmodminkhigher ] ) that only depends on higher orders . we will see that it contributes significantly to the full @xmath32 . finally we analyze the coefficients @xmath60 of ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) order by order and compare them to correlation function integrals . as mentioned in sec . [ sub : samplingcode ] , the quantities calculated by chipmink are the the mf densities @xmath20 . their dependence on the ball diameter is shown in fig . [ fig : minfundens ] and based on the mean of @xmath141 md - patchy realizations . we only used @xmath141 mocks in this case because fig . [ fig : minfundens ] is mainly for illustration and the large range of diameters is not optimal for the evaluation of the @xmath32 as discussed at the end of sec . [ sub : densdef ] . in order to illustrate also the density dependence , we plot @xmath142 different densities ranging from @xmath129 to @xmath130 of our reference density of @xmath126 ( the same density points as in fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] , however with an increased maximal radius ) . for the most extreme cases of @xmath129 and @xmath130 , we also plot the mfs of a poisson point process as dashed lines . for the high density case , the functionals for the mocks are clearly non - poissonian , whereas in the low density case the downsampling erased already a lot of the structure and the difference to a poisson sample is less important . let us qualitatively describe the difference for the euler characteristic @xmath90 ( @xmath143 ) . the faster drop of the functional with structure indicates that the individual balls aggregate earlier , which reduces the number of independent components @xmath144 faster than for the poisson case . then the holes @xmath17 in the union of multiple balls prevail up to larger radii and in the end there are less cavities @xmath145 but at larger radii . for our quantitative analysis in sec . [ sec : higherorders ] we will mainly use the modified mfs @xmath32 , eq . ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) . therefore , we use eqs . ( [ eq : inverse - mink ] ) to transform from the initial observables @xmath146 to @xmath147 . fig . [ fig : modminkfun ] shows the dependence of the @xmath32 on the ball diameter for the same densities as in fig . [ fig : minfundens ] , but now for 900 md - patchy mocks . in these plots the convergence of the functionals to those of the poisson point process with decreasing sample density is more visible than in fig . [ fig : minfundens ] . however , given the small error bars , even for the lowest density of @xmath148 the structure is well detected . the differing number of radial points for different densities illustrates our grid of points sampling the @xmath134 plane of fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] . for the highest density , @xmath125 radial bins of @xmath149 are possible until the survey volume is significantly filled , for the lowest density there are @xmath150 bins ( of which only the first @xmath151 are shown here ) . ccccccccc + & & & & & + + & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & & @xmath152 & @xmath154 & & @xmath152 & @xmath154 + @xmath155 & 1810 & 41.1 & & 171 & 10.1 & & 29.8 & 1.31 + @xmath156 & 1120 & 31.7 & & 88.1 & 5.93 & & 32.1 & 1.54 + @xmath157 & 454 & 19.1 & & 46.9 & 2.93 & & 29.6 & 1.28 + @xmath158 & 182 & 10.6 & & 29.7 & 1.30 & & 23.5 & 0.694 + we will now turn to the comparison of the density dependence of the modified mfs @xmath32 in the mocks and in the sdss data . instead of probing the grid of fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] for a fixed density as in fig . [ fig : modminkfun ] , we show in fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] the @xmath32 as a function of the sampling density for a ball diameter of @xmath133 . the form of @xmath32 in this direction of parameter space is easier to describe than in the @xmath159 direction , due to the power series form of the @xmath24-dependence , see eq . ( [ eq : powerseriesdecomp ] ) . in the plots of fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] , the poisson - case corresponds to the horizontal line at @xmath160 , thanks to the normalization of the @xmath32 in eq . ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) . the data are clearly different from @xmath160 , showing that there is structure in the galaxy distribution . the straight lines that depart from the poisson case at zero density show the @xmath32 truncated after the term linear in @xmath24 , see eq . ( [ eq : minkgaussexp ] ) . they have been calculated by measuring the two - point correlation functions for each of the @xmath161 qpm and @xmath162 md - patchy mocks and integrating them with the corresponding weight functions @xmath163 of eq . ( [ eq : minkgaussexp-1 ] ) . the plot shows the average and the @xmath164 fluctuations between the different mock realizations . the average of the correlation functions that formed the basis of these lines is shown in fig . [ fig : meancorrfun ] . the clear deviation of the full @xmath32 of the data and the mocks from these lines shows that the integrals over higher - order correlation functions in the series expansion of @xmath32 actually do play a significant role for the structure in the sdss galaxies . this becomes even more apparent in the plots of fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] . cccccc + & & & + + & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & & @xmath152 & @xmath154 + @xmath155 & 10300 & 97.3 & & 290 & 5.50 + @xmath156 & 11600 & 104 & & 282 & 5.22 + @xmath157 & 12300 & 107 & & 221 & 2.76 + @xmath158 & 12500 & 108 & & 252 & 4.04 + for these we use the integrated two - point correlations and subtract them off the corresponding @xmath32 for each mock individually . from these subtracted quantities @xmath140 ( eq . ( [ eq : defmodminkhigher ] ) ) we calculate the mean of the mocks and the covariances of the density points . the plots of the residuals show , that the higher - order contributions to the modified mfs are quite well described by the structure in the md - patchy mocks . the data happens to lie close to the @xmath164 line of the fluctuations between the @xmath162 mocks for all four mfs . it is quite encouraging that the mocks that were constructed to match the two- and three - point correlations only also capture what is going on in the higher orders quite well . as the data points in both fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] and fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] are strongly correlated , we need to take into account the full covariance matrix in order to estimate the significance of the remaining difference . the results of this calculation are shown in tab . [ tab : chisqmockdat ] . for the curves of fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] and fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] with @xmath123 density points , we first evaluate the @xmath3 values and then convert their @xmath165-values into those of a two sided deviation for a gaussian , which we express as multiples of one standard deviation . we inflate the error bars by multiplying the inverse covariance matrix by a factor of @xmath166 , in order to account for the finite number of mocks we use for estimating the covariance matrix @xcite . we find that the md - patchy mocks are a much better match of the data than the qpm mocks which are about @xmath167 away from the data in this case . for the higher components only , i.e. the central column of tab . [ tab : chisqmockdat ] , the agreement is even better and does not exceed @xmath168 for any of the functionals . so also quantitatively with covariances included the impression from the residual plots of fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] that the typical deviation is around @xmath169 is correct . when we combine all the information of the relevant @xmath170 points in our sampling grid of fig . [ fig : densitygrid ] , i.e. ball diameters from @xmath131 to @xmath132 and their complete density dependence , we find in tab . [ tab : chisqradcomb ] that the deviation of the higher - order md - patchy modified mfs is at most @xmath171 . for some diameters as in tab . [ tab : chisqmockdat ] the agreement is nearly perfect . this is very encouraging , as the mocks have only been generated to match the two- and three - pt . given the combined values of tab . [ tab : chisqradcomb ] , it is clear that there is still some room for improvement in the construction of realistic mocks to match the higher orders even better . regarding the deviation of the @xmath140 from the case of vanishing higher - order correlations ( the zero line in fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] ) , the conclusion is clear . there is strong evidence for higher - order correlations in the mocks and the data as seen by the mfs . even though this is not surprising , as at least the three - point function of the sdss data is well known ( see e.g. @xcite and @xcite ) , it is still interesting to see the statistical power that we have at hand for testing models with different higher - order correlations . for all of the quantities of tabs . [ tab : chisqmockdat ] and [ tab : chisqradcomb ] , one should keep in mind that the different mfs are not independent . so in order to derive one single value that would quantify the mismatch between mocks and data , one would also here have to take the covariances into account . for a single radius this is possible . for the full data set , we are limited by the number of mocks that we analyzed as an estimate of the @xmath172 covariance matrix would be noisy . finally , let us illustrate the scale dependence of the higher order contributions . [ fig : modminksubtractrad ] shows the deviation of the full @xmath32 ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) from the two - point part ( [ eq : minkgaussexp ] ) , i.e. @xmath140 of ( [ eq : defmodminkhigher ] ) . so it is the same quantities as in fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] , but now as a function of ball diameter for four fixed densities @xmath173 . the higher the density , the larger is the deviation from the two - point part , because the higher - order contributions play a more important role in the @xmath24-power series . in the radial direction , the functionals probe the higher - order correlations at different scales . for the two - point part we have seen in fig . [ fig : integrationwindow ] that the integration kernel picks up correlations at larger scales for increasing functional index @xmath72 . this is most probably also the case for the higher - order correlations ( we explicitly checked it for the three - point integrals ) and so @xmath174 probes the largest scales that we accessed in this analysis . the decreasing slope of the radial dependence reflects a similar behavior in the three point integral of @xmath175 . for even larger scales , the latter integral becomes negative and the difference to the two - point case decreases again . having found a significant contribution of higher - order correlations to the mfs , we now want to study which orders actually contribute . using the relation in eq . ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) we can decompose the functionals in different contributions from higher orders by fitting a polynomial of order @xmath7 to the density dependence of the @xmath32 as described in sec . [ sub : density - dependence ] . this decomposition is not necessary for using the higher - order mf information in the comparison of the model to the data , as we have shown in the previous section , but it illustrates the convergence properties of the @xmath32 series . in fig . [ fig : higherfit ] we evaluate the convergence of the fit for increasing polynomial order @xmath7 . of eq . ( [ eq : minkintegr ] ) . to the @xmath24-dependence of @xmath43 at a diameter of @xmath176 we fit polynomials in @xmath24 of increasing order taking the full correlations of the points into account and extract the @xmath177 from the best fit coefficients . the linear to third order polynomials in the large panel give a terrible fit already visually . the fourth and fifth order in the `` residual '' part of the plot indicate convergence at 5.-order . the corresponding @xmath3 values can be found in tab . [ tab : higherfitchi ] and confirm this fact.[fig : higherfit],scaledwidth=45.0% ] the deviations of the fitted model from the data are quantified in tab . [ tab : higherfitchi ] . from both presentations it is clear that the linear term that only includes the two - point coefficient @xmath178 is a very bad fit to the density evolution . the table indicates that only after the inclusion of the fifth term , which corresponds to integrals over the six - point function , the polynomial fit captures the shape of the modified mfs well . however , this only means that we have some sensitivity of the mfs of the mocks to contributions from up to the six - point function . it does not mean that these contributions are also significantly different from the ones in the data . in fact , as we have found in sec . [ sub : highsubtract ] the higher - order contributions of the mocks and the data actually agree relatively well . in order to evaluate how strongly the coefficients @xmath60 of eq . ( [ eq : powerseriesdecomp ] ) are biased by truncating the power series at a finite @xmath7 , we plot in fig . [ fig : evwithfitorder ] the dependence of the mean of the best fit values of @xmath179 , @xmath180 and @xmath181 of the @xmath162 md - patchy mocks on the polynomial order @xmath7 for a fit at a diameter of @xmath133 . as high values of @xmath7 also increase the chance of picking up spurious fluctuations , we decided to put a prior on the higher order coefficients . to this end we fit a three - parameter pad model to the density evolution of the mean mfs extracted from @xmath6 periodic md - patchy cubes . taylor expanding this model provides some model for the higher - order coefficients . we choose a gaussian prior around the so obtained values with a standard deviation corresponding to the value of the mean @xmath182 . we only apply this prior to coefficients beyond the four - point function coefficient @xmath183 . the first two coefficients @xmath178 and @xmath184 are already well measured without any prior , and for @xmath183 it is sufficient to regularize the higher orders . fig . [ fig : evwithfitorder ] shows that the value of the first coefficient @xmath178 is independent of @xmath7 as soon as @xmath7 is high enough that we have a good fit , i.e. @xmath185 from fig . [ fig : higherfit ] . the second coefficient @xmath184 is also largely independent of fit order , but needs a higher fit order @xmath7 than @xmath178 to be unbiased . for @xmath183 there is still some remaining uncertainty from the fit order , which is , however , still much smaller than the error from the scatter of the mocks . [ fig : errorellipse ] shows evolution of the mean value together with the @xmath164 contours of the parameters @xmath180 and @xmath181 for different @xmath7 starting at @xmath186 , to include also the covariances between the parameters . and @xmath181 of the fit to @xmath187 of fig . [ fig : higherfit ] for a diameter of @xmath176 . the leftmost point is for a third order polynomial and the order is increasing from left to right with a maximum order of @xmath188 . the error bars indicate @xmath164 intervals . starting from the ninth order , error bars include all higher order points.[fig : errorellipse],scaledwidth=45.0% ] below the order @xmath189 that provides the first good fit in tab . [ tab : higherfitchi ] , the best fit values are strongly dependent on fit order . for orders starting at @xmath190 the shift becomes much smaller than the scatter of the mocks . for the following plots , we will use polynomials of order @xmath191 for the @xmath43 fit at @xmath192 . to determine the fit order for the radii with a smaller number of density points , i.e. beyond @xmath128 , we constructed and analyzed test data . these were created from a pad model fit to the cut sky mocks and provide a model with known coefficients . then we applied the fitting procedure to these test data and found that for high enough @xmath7 , the coefficients we put in were recovered within the errors estimated by the fluctuations from the mocks . from the results of these test data fits , we determined for every diameter the minimum @xmath7 needed . for the larger diameters this value is lower due to the decreasing contribution of higher orders . the reason for this decrease is the steep scale dependence for the higher - order coefficients , an example of which we will see in fig . [ fig : threeptcoeffs ] for the three - point term ( see also fig . 14 of @xcite for the scale dependence of the coefficients of @xmath73 for a log - normal model ) . the decomposition into @xmath7-point components also allows us to test to which extent the deviation of the data from the mocks in fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] could be simply the result of a misnormalization of the power spectrum . the green line in fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] therefore shows the mean of the md - patchy mocks for a reduction in the power of @xmath193 . it has been obtained by taking the coefficients of the @xmath9-th order fit of fig . [ fig : higherfit ] and multiplying the integrated correlation functions with the power of the reduction factor that corresponds to the number of power spectra involved , i.e. @xmath194 for @xmath35 . of course this is only a very simplified model , given that the fit is not unbiased , especially for higher orders , but it should still provide a useful approximation . from the result in fig . [ fig : higherfit ] we see that at least approximately it removes the offset of the data from the mocks and makes them agree even better . this seems to be consistent with the analysis of the power spectrum in @xcite . our redshift range roughly corresponds to their second redshift bin , for which their fig . 1 indicates that the data also is slightly lower than the mean of the md - patchy mocks . cccc + fit order & coeff . & @xmath152 & p - value + @xmath160 & @xmath179 & 7859 & @xmath195 + @xmath139 & @xmath180 & 1509 & @xmath196 + @xmath197 & @xmath181 & 306 & @xmath198 + @xmath199 & @xmath200 & 47 & @xmath201 + @xmath189 & @xmath202 & 11.6 & @xmath203 + for the two cases @xmath178 and @xmath184 where the convergence in fig . [ fig : evwithfitorder ] is convincing , we compare in figs . [ fig : twoptcoeffs ] and [ fig : threeptcoeffs ] the extracted coefficients to reference models . [ fig : twoptcoeffs ] shows the two - point coefficients @xmath178 . for those , @xmath204 coincides with @xmath205 ( see eq . ( [ eq : v0-sigma ] ) ) and @xmath206 corresponds to the volume averaged correlation function ( see eq . ( [ eq : v3-xi ] ) ) . in addition to the average of the coefficients extracted from the md - patchy mocks , we show the coefficients of the data and the expected coefficients derived from integrals over the average two - point correlation function that we measured independently . the overall agreement of the two independent determinations is reassuring . it provides a confirmation that the fit to @xmath56 can extract individual terms from the power series ( [ eq : minkcorrcon ] ) . there is , however , for some of the functionals a relatively large offset . it is not clear if this offset is due to residual bias in the fitting method , or if our method to estimate the correlation function of a mock does not include the boundaries in the same way than the mfs . [ fig : threeptcoeffs ] then shows the @xmath184 . the connection to other known quantities is not as apparent as in the two - point case and we did not obtain an independent estimate of the three - point correlation integrals . what is shown in fig . [ fig : threeptcoeffs ] instead is the three - point function model of @xcite . it is based on leading - order perturbation theory and includes redshift space distortions . for the plots in fig . [ fig : threeptcoeffs ] we fixed the three bias parameters to @xmath207 , @xmath208 and @xmath209 . the @xmath210-value is the one we used in fig . [ fig : twoptcoeffs ] and the @xmath211-value is obtained from eq . ( 23 ) in @xcite and based on local lagrangian biasing @xcite . we did not attempt to fit for @xmath212 and so the lines in fig . [ fig : threeptcoeffs ] do not contain any free parameter . given that , the match of the model with the extracted coefficients is encouraging . in addition to being related to the hierarchy of @xmath7-point correlation functions , the mfs also contain information about the cosmic web . for example , the partial functionals probe the local morphology around the galaxy sites , and for an isodensity contour smoothing `` shapefinders '' have been defined to quantify the amount of filamentary vs. planarity of the local density field @xcite . for the global germ - grain mf densities that we study here , there are different quantities that can be extracted . the euler characteristic @xmath213 , for example , indicates for large balls how many extreme voids ( i.e. regions that are further away from any galaxy than @xmath92 ) there are in the galaxy distribution . the area functional @xmath89 gives an idea of their area and @xmath45 their volume . more generally , the comparison of the void fraction @xmath46 to the one of a poisson distribution of the same density indicates how inhomogeneously these void regions are distributed . in fig . [ fig : freevolumefraction ] , we therefore show @xmath46 as a function of the ball diameter and compare it to the corresponding poisson case . for a ball of diameter @xmath159 , where the first values correspond to the lower ( blue ) points and the values restarting at @xmath197 to the upper ( red ) points . the densities are @xmath214 and @xmath215 . especially for the higher density the solid poisson lines lie way below the values for the data , so the structure leads to a significantly higher void fraction than we would expect in an unclustered field.[fig : freevolumefraction],scaledwidth=45.0% ] especially for the higher density of @xmath216 the difference is quite remarkable . for a diameter of @xmath128 , the volume is a factor of @xmath217 larger than in the poisson case . for the most extreme case of @xmath132 , it is nearly @xmath218 . in this latter case the expected number of galaxies in a ball of diameter @xmath132 would be @xmath219 . with the standard poisson fluctuation one would expect a fraction of @xmath220 to be uncovered . including the observed structure however , there is @xmath221 of the @xmath222 in our analyzed region that remain uncovered . of course one has to make sure that this conclusion is not significantly affected by the holes in the survey . we tested this using the periodic cubic md - patchy mocks and plot the resulting void fractions as purple and green points in fig . [ fig : freevolumefraction ] . for the region that we evaluated , the cubic mocks for the difference is small , below @xmath223 for @xmath224 and below @xmath225 for @xmath226 . however , for the more extreme diameters the deviations will grow , but we do not expect that this affects the general picture . in this paper , we perform a new analysis that combines minkowski functionals with the standard two - point correlation function to measure the amount of non - gaussianity of the density field . we find in sec . [ sub : highsubtract ] that the significance of the higher - order contribution to the mfs is of the order of @xmath227 ( see tab . [ tab : chisqradcomb ] and fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] ) . this demonstrates that this part of the mfs can be well enough measured to give meaningful constraints on the higher - order properties of the galaxy distribution . given this constraining power it is reassuring that we find from fig . [ fig : modminksubtract ] and tab . [ tab : chisqmockdat ] that the md - patchy mocks , that were constructed to match the two- and three - point properties of the measured galaxy distribution , match fairly well to the higher - order mfs . this indicates that as far as the higher - orders accessible by the mfs are concerned , the mock galaxy catalogs are quite good . there is still some room for improvement as the combined deviation is as large as @xmath228 for some functionals ( see tab . [ tab : chisqradcomb ] ) , but this might be addressed by a @xmath193 shift in the normalization of the mock power spectrum ( see fig . [ fig : modminkdensdep ] ) . on the technical side , our careful boundary treatment minimizes the effects of the survey geometry on our measurement of the modified mfs ( see fig . [ fig : maskcorrection ] ) . the corrected values lie within the error bars of a boundaryless periodic box . for the qpm mocks , we find a much larger deviation ( beyond @xmath229 ) from the data than for md - patchy ( see tab . [ tab : chisqmockdat ] ) . as in this case already the two - point correlations are overnormalized in the range of scales that we are interested in ( see fig . [ fig : meancorrfun ] ) , a reduction of the amplitude of the initial gaussian field could also help in this case . we show that in the the higher - order part of the mfs calculated for the sdss dr12 cmass galaxies contains at least information up to the integrated @xmath9-point function ( see tab . [ tab : higherfitchi ] ) . this underlines the power of the mfs to bring condensed higher - order information into a simple functional form . aw thanks antonio cuesta for providing support with the qpm correlation functions . we thank graziano rossi and thomas buchert for valuable comments on the manuscript . the work of aw was supported by the german research organization dfg , grant no . wi 4501/1 - 1 . dje is supported by u.s . department of energy grant de - sc0013718 and as a simons foundation investigator . funding for sdss - iii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s . department of energy office of science . the sdss - iii web site is http://www.sdss3.org/. sdss - iii is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions of the sdss - iii collaboration including the university of arizona , the brazilian participation group , brookhaven national laboratory , carnegie mellon university , university of florida , the french participation group , the german participation group , harvard university , the instituto de astrofisica de canarias , the michigan state / notre dame / jina participation group , johns hopkins university , lawrence berkeley national laboratory , max planck institute for astrophysics , max planck institute for extraterrestrial physics , new mexico state university , new york university , ohio state university , pennsylvania state university , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the spanish participation group , university of tokyo , university of utah , vanderbilt university , university of virginia , university of washington , and yale university . t. , 1995 , in mcket j. p. , gottlber s. , mller v. , eds , large scale structure in the universe robust morphological measures for large scale structure . p. 156 , http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9412061[astro-ph/9412061 ] , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1995lssu.conf..156b[ads ] hadwiger h. , 1957 , vorlesungen ber inhalt , oberflche und isoperimetrie . die grundlehren der mathematischen wissenschaften in einzeldarstellungen mit besonderer bercksichtigung der anwendungsgebiete ; 93 , springer , http://cosmologist.info/isbn/3-540-02151-5 , [ isbn : 3 - 540 - 02151 - 5 , ] m. , schmalzing j. , buchert t. , wagner h. 1996 , in weiss a. , raffelt g. , hillebrandt w. , von feilitzsch f. , buchert t. , eds , astro - particle physics the significance of the fluctuations in the iras 1.2 jy galaxy catalogue .. pp 8398 , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1996app..conf...83k[ads ] r. et al . , 2001 , in harnden jr . f. r. , primini f. a. , payne h. e. , eds , astronomical data analysis software and systems x vol . 238 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , the sdss imaging pipelines . p. 269 , http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0101420[astro-ph/0101420 ] , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2001aspc..238..269l[ads ] m. c. et al . , 2011 , in american astronomical society meeting abstracts # 218 the log - density as a better cosmological density variable . p. # 233.04 , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2011aas...21823304n[ads ] m. , buchert t. 1996 , in weiss a. , raffelt g. , hillebrandt w. , von feilitzsch f. , buchert t. , eds , astro - particle physics applications of minkowski - functionals to the statistical analysis of dark matter models . , http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9509014[astro-ph/9509014 ] , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1996app..conf..251p[ads ] j. , kerscher m. , buchert t. 1996 , in bonometto s. , primack j. r. , provenzale a. , eds , dark matter in the universe minkowski functionals in cosmology . p. 281 , http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9508154[astro-ph/9508154 ] , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1996dmu..conf..281s[ads ] Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: labelled transition systems are a fundamental modelling formalism in many areas of computer science and one often needs to compare two or more such systems in applications . for example , in doing state compression prior to model checking one wants to ensure that the compressed system yields the same model checks as the uncompressed one . similarly , if one system is a specification and another one its implementation , then program correctness can be established by proving these systems to be equivalent . by the same token , if two systems are not equivalent , one may want to know to what degree this is so , e.g. in a risk analysis of a safety - critical system . this paper chooses bisimulation as the notion of equivalence of labelled transition systems . bisimulation is an established , sufficiently fine - grained notion of equivalence between labelled transition systems @xcite so any approximative notions , e.g. testing @xcite , have bisimulation as a well accepted point of reference . since quantitative aspects ought to be invariant under bisimulation , we stipulate that the quotient of all labelled transition systems with respect to bisimulation is the right conceptual space for reasoning about and comparing quantitative aspects of labelled transition systems . if two labelled transition systems are not bisimilar , one may require a quantitative measure of such differences and such a measure has many applications . we mention security protocols @xcite , where one system is the specification and the other is an implementation and where we may wish to quantify illicit information flow @xcite or the effort needed to expose implementation flaws ; modal specifications @xcite , where a specification captures a possibly infinite set of mutually non - bisimilar labelled transition systems ; and requirements engineering @xcite , where each system may be the modal specification of a particular viewpoint and _ consistency measures on modal specifications _ are sought . one principal aim of this paper is to unify several strands of established work in one integrated framework : metric semantics of processes la bakker & zucker @xcite ; use of hennessy - milner logic , domain theory and transition systems la abramsky @xcite ; means of under - specifying and refining processes la larsen & thomsen @xcite ; and representations of classical topological spaces as maximal - point spaces of domains la lawson @xcite . to that end , we use a domain @xmath0 , defined in @xcite and shown to be a universal model for finitely - branching modal transition systems and fully abstract for their refinement in loc . specifically , we discover that the metric induced by the lawson topology on @xmath0 is a generalization of the one in @xcite to modal transition systems ; that the subspace of maximal elements of @xmath0 is a stone space with respect to the lawson ( or scott ) topology ; and that this stone space is an isomorphic representation of the quotient of all labelled transition systems modulo bisimulation , so the topology and metric carry over to that quotient . since a stone space has a _ complete _ ultra - metric , our model has labelled transition systems that are not image - finite , allowing the modelling of continuous state spaces , but all labelled transition systems can be approximated by image - finite ones to any degree of precision . the compactness of this quotient space then makes it possible to study the topological structure of sets of implementations for modal transition systems , the second principal aim of this paper . in particular , our topological analysis shows that 3-valued model checking @xcite reasons about compact sets of labelled transition systems , namely the set of all 2-valued refinements of a given 3-valued system . we propose two measures , a pessimistic and an optimistic one , for how close any refining labelled transition systems of two such 3-valued systems can be . using compactness , we prove that the optimistic measure is zero iff the two 3-valued systems in question have a common refinement . our concepts and results are also _ robust under a change of representation _ , e.g. in moving from event - based to state - based systems or those that combine state and event information . it would be of interest to see whether results similar to the ones of this paper are obtainable for systems that explicitly represent time , probability ( e.g. as done in @xcite ) or other quantitative information . in section [ section : domain ] we review modal transition systems , their refinement , and a fully abstract domain model for these notions . section [ section : stone ] establishes the central result of this paper , showing that the maximal - points space of the fully abstract domain of section [ section : domain ] is a stone space and the quotient of all labelled transition systems with respect to bisimulation . in section [ section : applications ] we give three applications of the compactness of this maximal - points space : a compactness theorem for hennessy - milner logic on compact sets of implementations , an abstract interpretation of compact sets of implementations as scott - closed sets of modal transition systems , and a robust consistency measure for modal transition systems . section [ section : related ] states related work , and section [ section : conclude ] concludes . modal transition systems @xcite are defined like labelled transition systems , except that transitions come in two modes that specify whether such transitions must or may be implemented . a refinement relation between modal transition systems therefore associates to a modal transition system those refining labelled transition systems in which all implementation choices have been resolved . in this section we formalize these notions and present the domain of @xcite as a faithful mathematical model of the model - checking framework of modal transition systems . we define larsen & thomsen s modal transition systems @xcite , their refinement and other key concepts formally and present the domain @xmath0 which is a fully abstract model of such systems and their refinement @xcite . our results are shown within that domain . in this paper , let @xmath1 be a fixed finite set of events and @xmath2 the set of finite words over @xmath3 with @xmath4 denoting the word of length zero . the labelled transition systems considered here have events from @xmath3 only . the structural properties of our domain model require that we also define dams more general notion of mixed transition systems @xcite . a modal transition system @xmath5 has two transition relations @xmath6 on a set of states @xmath7 . the sets @xmath8 and @xmath9 specify _ contractual promises or expectations _ about the reactive capacity and incapacity of implementations , respectively . these guarantees are to be understood with respect to the refinement of states . we write `` _ a _ '' in @xmath10 to denote * a*sserted behavior and `` _ c _ '' in @xmath11 to denote * c*onsistent behavior and use these annotations in judgments @xmath12 and @xmath13 below with the same meaning . in figure [ fig : ref ] we see a contractual guarantee that any state refining @xmath14 can not have a transition labelled with @xmath15 to a state refining @xmath16 as the triple @xmath17 is not in @xmath18 . there is a contractual guarantee that any state refining @xmath19 has a @xmath8-transition labelled with @xmath15 to all states that refine @xmath14 or @xmath20 . 1 . * a _ mixed transition system _ @xcite is a triple @xmath21 such that , for every _ mode _ @xmath22 , the pair @xmath23 is a _ labelled transition system _ , i.e. @xmath24 . * if @xmath25 , then @xmath5 is a _ modal _ transition system @xcite . * we call @xmath5 _ image - finite _ iff for all @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 the set @xmath29 is finite . * a mixed transition system @xmath5 with a designated initial state @xmath30 is _ pointed _ , written @xmath31 . * we call elements of @xmath8 _ must - transitions _ and elements of @xmath32 _ may - transitions_. 2 . let @xmath33 be a mixed transition system . * a relation @xmath34 is a _ refinement within @xmath5 _ @xcite iff @xmath35 implies , for all @xmath27 , 1 . if @xmath36 , there exists some @xmath37 such that @xmath38 ; and 2 . if @xmath39 , there exists some @xmath40 such that @xmath38 . * we write @xmath41 or @xmath42 if there is some refinement @xmath43 with @xmath35 . in that case , @xmath44 _ refines _ ( _ is abstracted by _ ) @xmath45 . * states @xmath45 and @xmath44 are _ refinement - equivalent _ iff ( @xmath46 and @xmath47 ) . * let @xmath48 mean that @xmath49 refines @xmath30 in the mixed transition system that is the disjoint union of @xmath5 and @xmath50 ; @xmath31 and @xmath51 are refinement - equivalent iff @xmath30 and @xmath49 are refinement - equivalent in that union . * the _ implementations _ of @xmath31 are those pointed modal transition systems without may - transitions that refine @xmath31 . as the union @xmath52 of all refinements within @xmath5 is also a refinement within @xmath5 , @xmath52 is the greatest refinement relation within @xmath5 . please note that we use the relational inverse of the @xmath43 in @xcite , as done in @xcite , so our @xmath53 is written as @xmath54 in @xcite . larsen & thomsen s modal transition systems and their refinement @xcite are partial versions of labelled transition systems and bisimulation @xcite . a modal transition system represents those labelled transition systems that refine it , the implementations of @xmath5 . this representation is sound , for if a modal transition system @xmath5 refines a modal transition system @xmath50 , all labelled transition systems that refine @xmath5 also refine @xmath50 as @xmath55 is transitive . 1 . figures [ fig : ref ] and [ fig : reftwo ] depict modal transition systems , where dashed and solid lines depict may - transitions and must - transitions , respectively . the refinement @xmath43 identifies states with the same activity ; e.g. drinks with tomdrinks and bobdrinks etc . the mixed transition system on the left of figure [ fig : mixed ] is not a modal transition system but is refinement - equivalent to the modal transition system on the right of figure [ fig : mixed ] . # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3471,2056)(0,-10 ) ( 957,1129)(2982,1129 ) ( 2862.000,1099.000)(2982.000,1129.000)(2862.000,1159.000)(2898.000,1129.000)(2862.000,1099.000 ) ( 597,1039)(1542,364 ) ( 1426.915,409.337)(1542.000,364.000)(1461.789,458.161)(1473.646,412.824)(1426.915,409.337 ) ( 3297,994)(2037,364 ) ( 2130.915,444.498)(2037.000,364.000)(2157.748,390.833)(2112.132,401.566)(2130.915,444.498 ) ( 3207,1309)(1722,1759)(822,1309 ) ( 915.915,1389.498)(822.000,1309.000)(942.748,1335.833)(897.132,1346.566)(915.915,1389.498 ) ( 462,1309)(12,1579)(372,2029)(597,1354 ) ( 530.592,1458.355)(597.000,1354.000)(587.513,1477.329)(570.437,1433.689)(530.592,1458.355 ) ( 1632,274)(597,274)(597,859 ) ( 627.000,739.000)(597.000,859.000)(567.000,739.000)(597.000,775.000)(627.000,739.000 ) ( 2172,274)(3297,274)(3297,814 ) ( 3327.000,694.000)(3297.000,814.000)(3267.000,694.000)(3297.000,730.000)(3327.000,694.000 ) ( 1677,184)(0,0)[lb ] ( 372,1084)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3072,1084)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1677,1219)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1092,769)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2217,769)(0,0)[lb ] ( 687,49)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2352,49)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2397,1669)(0,0)[lb ] ( 552,1804)(0,0)[lb ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3855,4494)(0,-10 ) ( 777,912)(1722,1992 ) ( 1665.557,1881.936)(1722.000,1992.000)(1620.402,1921.446)(1666.686,1928.784)(1665.557,1881.936 ) ( 732,597)(372,237)(867,12)(867,507 ) ( 897.000,387.000)(867.000,507.000)(837.000,387.000)(867.000,423.000)(897.000,387.000 ) ( 3432,3612)(1992,4062)(867,3612 ) ( 967.275,3684.421)(867.000,3612.000)(989.559,3628.713)(944.992,3643.197)(967.275,3684.421 ) ( 867,3297)(1767,2262 ) ( 1665.620,2332.867)(1767.000,2262.000)(1710.897,2372.238)(1711.881,2325.387)(1665.620,2332.867 ) ( 1677,2127)(642,2127)(642,3207 ) ( 672.000,3087.000)(642.000,3207.000)(612.000,3087.000)(642.000,3123.000)(672.000,3087.000 ) ( 552,3612)(12,3972)(642,4467)(642,3792 ) ( 612.000,3912.000)(642.000,3792.000)(672.000,3912.000)(642.000,3876.000)(612.000,3912.000 ) ( 3432,3297)(2082,2262 ) ( 2158.980,2358.820)(2082.000,2262.000)(2195.486,2311.204)(2148.663,2313.108)(2158.980,2358.820 ) ( 2217,2127)(3567,2127)(3567,3207 ) ( 3597.000,3087.000)(3567.000,3207.000)(3537.000,3087.000)(3567.000,3123.000)(3597.000,3087.000 ) ( 1857,1947)(1857,1137)(1182,867 ) ( 1282.275,939.421)(1182.000,867.000)(1304.559,883.713)(1259.992,898.197)(1282.275,939.421 ) ( 1992,1947)(1992,1137)(3027,822 ) ( 2903.464,828.239)(3027.000,822.000)(2920.934,885.640)(2946.639,846.458)(2903.464,828.239 ) ( 1407,732)(2982,732 ) ( 2862.000,702.000)(2982.000,732.000)(2862.000,762.000)(2898.000,732.000)(2862.000,702.000 ) ( 1362,3432)(3072,3432 ) ( 2952.000,3402.000)(3072.000,3432.000)(2952.000,3462.000)(2988.000,3432.000)(2952.000,3402.000 ) ( 1767,2037)(0,0)[lb ] ( 417,3387)(0,0)[lb ] ( 417,687)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3117,3387)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3117,687)(0,0)[lb ] ( 777,4197)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2532,3972)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2577,2217)(0,0)[lb ] ( 867,2217)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1362,2847)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1767,3522)(0,0)[lb ] ( 642,1452)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1092,102)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1767,552)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2082,1182)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2307,2847)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1137,1182)(0,0)[lb ] we may identify modal transition systems @xmath56 with labelled transition systems @xmath57 and refinement between such modal transition systems with bisimulation @xcite and will freely move between these two representations of labelled transition systems and bisimulation subsequently . before we present the domain model for refinement of modal transition systems we use scott s interval domain @xcite as a motivating example that features most of the desirable properties of our domain model . figure [ fig : idom ] shows the interval domain and its ordering : @xmath58\leq [ r',s']$ ] iff ( @xmath59 and @xmath60 ) . in that case we say that @xmath61 $ ] refines @xmath58 $ ] . # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 5175,4860)(0,-10 ) ( 3015,4545 ) ( 3015,4545 ) ( 540,4545)(5040,4545)(2790,270)(540,4545 ) ( 2565,3420)(2340,4545 ) ( 2565,3420)(3690,4545 ) ( 2790,2475)(1215,4545 ) ( 2790,2475)(4455,4545 ) ( 2790,2475)(2792,2477)(2795,2481 ) ( 2801,2488)(2809,2498)(2820,2512 ) ( 2833,2528)(2847,2546)(2862,2566 ) ( 2876,2588)(2890,2610)(2902,2633 ) ( 2913,2656)(2921,2681)(2928,2707 ) ( 2931,2734)(2930,2762)(2925,2790 ) ( 2915,2816)(2903,2839)(2889,2858 ) ( 2875,2872)(2862,2882)(2850,2888 ) ( 2838,2892)(2827,2894)(2816,2895 ) ( 2805,2896)(2793,2897)(2780,2900 ) ( 2765,2905)(2747,2913)(2727,2923 ) ( 2705,2937)(2680,2953)(2655,2970 ) ( 2628,2989)(2604,3005)(2585,3017 ) ( 2569,3024)(2557,3028)(2548,3029 ) ( 2541,3028)(2535,3026)(2529,3024 ) ( 2524,3024)(2517,3026)(2510,3031 ) ( 2501,3042)(2492,3057)(2482,3079 ) ( 2475,3105)(2472,3131)(2471,3156 ) ( 2472,3178)(2474,3197)(2477,3213 ) ( 2481,3226)(2485,3236)(2489,3244 ) ( 2494,3251)(2498,3259)(2504,3268 ) ( 2509,3278)(2516,3292)(2523,3310 ) ( 2532,3331)(2542,3358)(2553,3388 ) ( 2565,3420)(2579,3456)(2593,3487 ) ( 2605,3512)(2616,3531)(2625,3544 ) ( 2634,3553)(2641,3558)(2648,3562 ) ( 2654,3566)(2661,3572)(2667,3580 ) ( 2675,3592)(2682,3609)(2689,3632 ) ( 2696,3659)(2700,3690)(2701,3724 ) ( 2699,3753)(2695,3774)(2690,3789 ) ( 2685,3798)(2680,3803)(2674,3806 ) ( 2668,3809)(2661,3814)(2653,3823 ) ( 2645,3837)(2634,3857)(2623,3884 ) ( 2610,3915)(2597,3946)(2586,3974 ) ( 2575,3996)(2567,4013)(2559,4026 ) ( 2552,4035)(2546,4043)(2540,4050 ) ( 2535,4058)(2530,4069)(2525,4082 ) ( 2521,4100)(2519,4120)(2520,4140 ) ( 2524,4155)(2530,4167)(2536,4176 ) ( 2542,4181)(2547,4184)(2551,4186 ) ( 2554,4186)(2558,4185)(2561,4184 ) ( 2566,4183)(2573,4182)(2582,4182 ) ( 2594,4183)(2611,4183)(2631,4184 ) ( 2655,4185)(2681,4184)(2706,4182 ) ( 2728,4179)(2746,4175)(2761,4171 ) ( 2774,4166)(2784,4160)(2794,4155 ) ( 2803,4150)(2813,4145)(2825,4140 ) ( 2840,4137)(2858,4135)(2879,4134 ) ( 2902,4136)(2925,4140)(2946,4147 ) ( 2963,4154)(2975,4162)(2984,4168 ) ( 2989,4174)(2992,4178)(2993,4182 ) ( 2993,4185)(2992,4189)(2992,4193 ) ( 2993,4200)(2995,4208)(2998,4220 ) ( 3003,4235)(3009,4254)(3015,4275 ) ( 3020,4301)(3024,4327)(3026,4351 ) ( 3027,4374)(3026,4395)(3025,4416 ) ( 3023,4435)(3021,4453)(3019,4469 ) ( 3018,4482)(3016,4492)(3015,4497)(3015,4500 ) ( 0,4545)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5175,4545)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2700,0)(0,0)[lb ] ( 990,4680)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2745,4635)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2070,4635)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3465,4635)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4320,4635)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2565,3195)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2700,2295)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3240,630)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3600,1215)(0,0)[lb ] the interval domain nicely illustrates some of the properties we expect our domain model @xmath0 to have . 1 . * refinement is complete for implementations : * real numbers @xmath62 $ ] represented as intervals @xmath63 $ ] are the `` implementations '' of intervals , so @xmath58 $ ] has all @xmath63 $ ] with @xmath64 $ ] as implementations . one can easily see that @xmath58 $ ] is refined by @xmath61 $ ] iff all implementations of @xmath61 $ ] are also implementations of @xmath58 $ ] . * universality : * the interval domain @xmath65 is universal for worst / best - case abstractions of subsets of @xmath66 $ ] . if we abstract @xmath67 $ ] by the interval @xmath68\in{{\mathbb i}}$ ] , any element of @xmath65 is the abstraction of at least one such @xmath69 . in fact , there is a galois connection @xmath70})}^{\rm op}\to { { \mathbb i}}$ ] and @xmath71})}^{\rm op}$ ] where @xmath72 $ ] is the monotone abstraction function , @xmath73 ) = [ r , s]$ ] is the monotone `` concretization '' function , and @xmath74 and @xmath75})}^{\rm op}}$ ] . * full abstraction : * the order on @xmath65 coincides with the refinement relation as the latter means reverse containment of implementations by item ( 1 ) above . 4 . * classical space as maximal - points space : * the set @xmath66 $ ] equipped with the compact euclidean topology is isomorphic as a topological space to the set of maximal elements of @xmath65 in the topology induced by the scott- or lawson - topology of @xmath65 . * denseness of computable structures : * intervals with rational endpoints approximate intervals to any degree of precision . * consistency measure : * the map @xmath76 defined by @xmath77,[r',s ' ] ) = [ \max(r , r'),\min(s , s')]$ ] , where @xmath78 $ ] is understood to be @xmath79 if @xmath80 , tells us whether its inputs are consistent with each other by checking whether its output is different from @xmath79 . non - overlapping intervals can not possibly approximate the same real number . the domain model @xmath0 for refinement of modal transition systems @xcite has similar properties which we discuss briefly here prior to their technical development in this paper . the completeness proof for implementations for refinement of modal transition systems does not depend on the compactness of @xmath81 , is non - trivial , and presented elsewhere @xcite . universality amounts to showing that every modal transition system has a refinement - equivalent embedding in the domain @xmath0 . full abstraction means that the order on @xmath0 equals the greatest refinement relation on @xmath0 interpreted as a modal transition system . the maximal - points space @xmath81 of @xmath0 gives us a precise model of labelled transition systems and their notion of `` nearness . '' this space turns out to be the quotient of labelled transition systems with respect to bisimulation such that the familiar metric based on tests expressed in hennessy - milner logic @xcite induces the topology on that space . finite - state labelled transition systems are shown to be dense in this space . finally , the compactness of this space is proved and a monotone consistency measure @xmath82 between two modal transition systems is then derived thereof . said compactness then renders a galois connection between compact sets of implementations and scott - closed sets of modal transition systems as shown in theorem [ theorem : gc ] below . apart from these similarities with @xmath65 , a key difference is that @xmath0 is algebraic and that the maximal - points space is therefore zero - dimensional . the reader familiar with domain theory @xcite may safely skip the next definition . 1 . * a _ topological space _ @xmath83 consists of a set @xmath69 and a family @xmath84 of subsets of @xmath69 such that @xmath85 and @xmath69 are in @xmath84 , and @xmath84 is closed under finite intersections and arbitrary unions . * elements @xmath86 are _ _ , complements @xmath87 with @xmath88 are _ @xmath84-closed _ , and sets that are @xmath84-open and @xmath84-closed are _ @xmath84-clopen_. 2 . * a subset @xmath89 of a partial order @xmath90 is _ directed _ iff ( for all @xmath91 there is some @xmath92 with @xmath93 ) . * a partial order @xmath90 is a _ iff all its directed subsets @xmath89 have a least upper bound @xmath94 . * we write @xmath95 for the set of _ upper bounds _ of @xmath89 . * we denote by @xmath96 the set of _ minimal upper bounds _ of @xmath89 . * an element @xmath97 is _ compact _ in a dcpo @xmath98 iff ( for all directed sets @xmath89 of @xmath98 with @xmath99 there is some @xmath100 with @xmath101 ) . we write @xmath102 for the set of compact elements of @xmath98 . * a dcpo @xmath98 is _ algebraic _ iff for all @xmath103 the set @xmath104 is directed with least upper bound @xmath105 . * for a finite subset @xmath106 of @xmath98 define , for all @xmath107 + @xmath108 * a _ bifinite domain _ , also known as an _ sfp_-domain , is an algebraic dcpo @xmath98 such that for every finite subset @xmath109 the set @xmath110 is finite , contained in @xmath102 , and @xmath111 where for any @xmath112 we write + @xmath113 * we call @xmath69 _ upper _ iff @xmath114 ; _ lower _ iff @xmath115 . 3 . for a bifinite domain @xmath98 , we define * the _ scott - topology _ @xmath116 to consist of all subsets @xmath117 of @xmath98 satisfying @xmath118 * the _ lawson - topology _ @xmath119 to consist of all subsets @xmath120 of @xmath98 such that @xmath121 implies the existence of some @xmath122 with @xmath123 ; and * the _ @xmath116-compact saturated _ subsets of @xmath98 to be the @xmath119-closed upper subsets of @xmath98 . the definitions of item ( 3 ) above are really characterizations @xcite . we use the _ initial _ solution @xmath0 of a domain equation , presented in @xcite and denoted by @xmath124 in loc . , as the domain whose set of maximal points we prove to be the stone space of pointed labelled transition systems modulo bisimulation . the items ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) of definition [ def : mtsd ] below are definition 8 and 9 of @xcite , respectively . [ def : mtsd ] 1 . the _ mixed powerdomain _ @xmath125}$ ] @xcite of a bifinite domain @xmath98 has as elements all pairs @xmath126 where @xmath127 is @xmath116-closed and @xmath117 is @xmath116-compact saturated such that @xmath127 and @xmath117 satisfy the mix condition + @xmath128 + the order on @xmath125}$ ] is defined by + @xmath129 2 . since @xmath125}$ ] is a bifinite domain whenever @xmath98 is bifinite and since the functors @xmath130 and @xmath131 are locally continuous @xcite , we can solve the domain equation + @xmath132}\ ] ] + over bifinite domains where @xmath133 denotes the product functor over all events in @xmath3 , and write @xmath0 for the _ initial solution _ of that equation . 3 . the domain @xmath0 may be _ interpreted as a pointed mixed transition system _ + @xmath134 + where the recursion @xmath135 of the equation ( [ equ : recursion ] ) for @xmath0 specifies that all elements @xmath136 in the set @xmath137 ( @xmath138 ) are exactly the @xmath139-successors ( @xmath140-successors ) of @xmath105 for @xmath141 in @xmath124 ( respectively ) . thus , the @xmath127 and @xmath117 in ( [ equ : mix ] ) model @xmath139- and @xmath140-transitions within @xmath124 , respectively . the order - theoretic mix condition ( [ equ : mix ] ) has an equivalent version for mixed transition systems . a mixed transition system @xmath33 satisfies the _ mix condition ( mc ) _ iff ( for all @xmath36 there is some @xmath142 such that @xmath143 ) . as shown in proposition 3 in @xcite , ( [ equ : mix ] ) ensures that @xmath124 satisfies the mix condition ( mc ) since the order on @xmath0 is a refinement within @xmath0 : for all @xmath144 there is some @xmath145 such that @xmath146 . [ example : mix ] figure [ fig : mixed ] demonstrates that mixed transition systems @xmath147 ) that satisfy the mix condition ( mc ) are refinement - equivalent to modal transition systems @xmath148 . therefore , such mixed transition systems are merely modal transition systems in disguise @xcite . # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 5488,2457)(0,-10 ) ( 1362,180 ) ( 462,1530 ) ( 2262,1530 ) ( 4512,180 ) ( 5412,1508 ) ( 3612,1530 ) ( 1317,225)(507,1440 ) ( 598.526,1356.795)(507.000,1440.000)(548.603,1323.513)(553.595,1370.108)(598.526,1356.795 ) ( 1473,287)(2238,1367 ) ( 2193.119,1251.737)(2238.000,1367.000)(2144.157,1286.418)(2189.447,1298.454)(2193.119,1251.737 ) ( 1362,360)(2127,1440 ) ( 2082.119,1324.737)(2127.000,1440.000)(2033.157,1359.418)(2078.447,1371.454)(2082.119,1324.737 ) ( 417,1575)(12,1980)(462,2430)(462,1755 ) ( 432.000,1875.000)(462.000,1755.000)(492.000,1875.000)(462.000,1839.000)(432.000,1875.000 ) ( 2172,1530)(597,1530 ) ( 717.000,1560.000)(597.000,1530.000)(717.000,1500.000)(681.000,1530.000)(717.000,1560.000 ) ( 4546,278)(5311,1358 ) ( 5266.119,1242.737)(5311.000,1358.000)(5217.157,1277.418)(5262.447,1289.454)(5266.119,1242.737 ) ( 5277,1530)(3702,1530 ) ( 3822.000,1560.000)(3702.000,1530.000)(3822.000,1500.000)(3786.000,1530.000)(3822.000,1560.000 ) ( 3522,1530)(3117,1935)(3567,2385)(3567,1710 ) ( 3537.000,1830.000)(3567.000,1710.000)(3597.000,1830.000)(3567.000,1794.000)(3537.000,1830.000 ) ( 192,1305)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2307,1305)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1182,1620)(0,0)[lb ] ( 552,2025)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1857,585)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1092,0)(0,0)[lb ] ( 687,630)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1452,900)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4152,1575)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4872,630)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3612,1980)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3297,1350)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4242,45)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5367,1260)(0,0)[lb ] by proposition 1 in @xcite and as seen in the previous example , the mix condition ( mc ) guarantees that the _ mixed _ transition system @xmath149 is refinement - equivalent to the _ modal _ transition system @xmath150 . therefore all reasoning that is invariant under refinement equivalence , as is the case in this paper , may be done with the latter modal transition system and we abuse notation to refer to that modal transition system as @xmath124 as well . the domain model @xmath0 is _ universal _ : there is an embedding @xmath151 from the class of image - finite pointed mixed transition system satisfying the mix - condition ( mc ) to elements of @xmath0 such that @xmath31 and @xmath152 are refinement - equivalent ( theorem 6.1 in @xcite ) . the domain model @xmath0 is _ fully abstract _ : for all @xmath153 , we have @xmath154 iff @xmath155 ( theorem 5 in @xcite ) . for sake of completeness , we sketch the construction of this embedding and needed aspects of the full abstraction proof in the next section . we show that the maximal elements of @xmath0 are precisely the representations of pointed labelled transition systems modulo bisimulation ; and that this quotient is a stone space and therefore determined by a complete ultra metric . we define the required notions from topology . [ def : ultra ] 1 . a topological space @xmath83 is 1 . _ compact _ iff for all @xmath156 with @xmath157 there is a finite subset @xmath158 with @xmath159 ; 2 . _ hausdorff _ iff for all @xmath160 in @xmath69 there are @xmath161 with @xmath162 , @xmath163 and @xmath164 ; 3 . _ zero - dimensional _ iff every @xmath84-open set is the union of @xmath84-clopens ; and 4 . a _ stone space _ iff it is zero - dimensional , compact , and hausdorff . 2 . a subset @xmath165 of @xmath83 is _ @xmath84-compact _ iff the topological space @xmath166 is compact . a subset @xmath89 of @xmath69 is _ dense _ in @xmath83 iff @xmath167 is non - empty for all non - empty @xmath168 . [ item : fourd ] an _ ultra - metric _ on @xmath69 is a function @xmath169 $ ] such that for all @xmath170 1 . @xmath171 iff @xmath172 ; 2 . @xmath173 ; and 3 . 5 . an ultra - metric @xmath169 $ ] _ determines a topology @xmath175 _ on @xmath69 whose elements are all those @xmath176 that are unions of sets of the form @xmath177 for @xmath178 and rational @xmath179 . a topological space @xmath83 is _ ultra - metrizable _ iff there is an ultra - metric @xmath169 $ ] such that @xmath180 . we denote by @xmath181 the set of _ maximal elements _ of @xmath0 . the set + @xmath182 + has a _ maximal - points space topology _ @xcite + @xmath183 8 . for @xmath184 , we write + @xmath185 since @xmath0 is a bifinite domain , the lawson condition @xcite holds for @xmath0 , namely that the topology @xmath186 is also induced by the @xmath187-topology : @xmath188 we remark that not all bifinite domains @xmath98 enjoy the property that @xmath189 is compact in the topology induced by @xmath116 or @xmath119 . we first record that @xmath190 is hausdorff and zero - dimensional . proposition [ prop : zero ] below holds for any algebraic domain satisfying the lawson condition @xcite . we state and prove that proposition for @xmath0 for sake of completeness . [ prop : zero ] the topological space @xmath191 is zero - dimensional and hausdorff . * every @xmath192 is the union of @xmath193-opens @xmath194 , @xmath195 , as @xmath0 is algebraic . but each @xmath194 is @xmath187-clopen as @xmath196 and @xmath194 is @xmath187-closed . from the lawson condition for @xmath0 , ( [ equ : lawsoncondition ] ) , we infer that @xmath197 is @xmath190-clopen and so @xmath186 is zero - dimensional as every @xmath198 is the union of such sets . * to show that @xmath186 is hausdorff , let @xmath199 . since @xmath0 is a partial order we may assume @xmath80 without loss of generality . since @xmath0 is algebraic , @xmath80 implies @xmath200 and @xmath201 for some @xmath195 . but @xmath197 is @xmath186-open and contains @xmath202 whereas @xmath203 is in @xmath204 which is @xmath190-open since @xmath197 is also @xmath190-closed . we use tools from temporal logic to develop a sufficient criterion for membership in @xmath205 . [ def : weak ] 1 . the set of formulas of _ hennessy - milner logic _ @xcite is generated by the grammar + @xmath206 + where @xmath141 ranges over the finite set of events @xmath3 . 2 . let @xmath207 be a pointed modal transition system . larsen s semantics , denoted by @xmath208 in @xcite for hennessy - milner logic in negation normal form , is depicted in figure [ fig : hml ] . 3 . we write @xmath209}}$ ] for @xmath210 and @xmath211 for @xmath212 subsequently for all @xmath27 and all @xmath213 and @xmath214 of hennessy - milner logic . @xmath215 for each @xmath28 we have @xmath216}}\phi & \mbox{iff } & \mbox{for all $ ( i,\alpha , i')\in{{r } ^{\it { \it \neg m}}}$ , $ ( n , i'){{\models } ^{\it { m}}}\phi$}\\ ( n , i){{\models } ^{\it { m}}}\phi\lor\psi & \mbox{iff } & \mbox{$((n , i){{\models } ^{\it { m}}}\phi$ or $ ( n , i){{\models } ^{\it { m}}}\psi)$\ , .}\end{array}\ ] ] please note that @xmath217}}\phi$ ] universally quantifies over transitions in the _ dual _ mode @xmath218 . [ example : two ] consider the modal transition system @xmath50 in figure [ fig : ref ] . 1 . [ item : one ] we have @xmath219 because of the @xmath18-transition @xmath220 . by the semantics of negation , this implies @xmath221 . we also infer @xmath222 as there is no state @xmath45 with @xmath223 . by the semantics of disjunction , these two judgments render @xmath224 . this judgment says that we ca nt determine that @xmath225 is asserted in state @xmath16 in @xmath50 . as that formula is a tautology over labelled transition systems we see that judgments @xmath226 under - approximate validity judgments `` all refinements of @xmath227 satisfy @xmath213 . '' as we show below , it turns out that the ability to capture these validity judgments for certain tautologies over labelled transition systems via @xmath12 is what characterizes modal transition systems that are refinement - equivalent to labelled transition systems . [ item : two ] we have @xmath228}}{{[{\rm talks}]}}({{\langle { \rm drinks}\rangle } } { { \it t\!t}}\lor\neg{{\langle { \rm drinks}\rangle } } { { \it t\!t}})$ ] as there is an @xmath18-path @xmath229 for the word @xmath230 and @xmath231 by item ( 1 ) . therefore , the check @xmath232}}{{[{\rm talks}]}}({{\langle { \rm drinks}\rangle } } { { \it t\!t}}\lor\neg{{\langle { \rm drinks}\rangle } } { { \it t\!t}})$ ] is unable to validate a tautology over labelled transition systems at state waits in @xmath50 . we sketch the definition of the embedding @xmath233 for an image - finite modal transition system @xmath31 such that @xmath31 and @xmath152 are refinement - equivalent @xcite . this construction follows ideas from algebraic semantics la nivat - courcelle - guessarian @xcite or la goguen - thatcher - wagner - wright @xcite in that we unfold pointed modal transition systems as finite trees for a fixed depth , adding a may - stub to all leaves of that tree for which there are still outgoing transitions in the pointed modal transition system . this unfolding is presented here via a simple process algebra . 1 . the grammar for the _ process algebra @xmath234 _ is + @xmath235 + where @xmath141 ranges over the finite set of events @xmath3 and no @xmath236 in @xmath237 is allowed to be @xmath238 or @xmath239 . 2 . for each @xmath240 let @xmath241 be as in figure [ fig : pad ] . 3 . for all @xmath240 , the structural operational semantics in figure [ fig : sos ] defines a pointed modal transition system @xmath242 _ { } } } , p)$ ] . l @xmath243 + + @xmath244 + + @xmath245 + + @xmath246 + + @xmath247 + + @xmath248 + + @xmath249 + + let @xmath240 be @xmath250 . then @xmath242_{}}},p)$ ] is refinement - equivalent to the image - finite pointed modal transition system in figure [ fig : app ] . we record that the denotational semantics of @xmath234 in @xmath0 matches the structural operational semantics . this proof is straightforward and amounts to showing that the saturations with @xmath251 and @xmath252 in @xmath0 do not break refinement equivalence as they always occur in the right direction . [ lemma : match ] for all @xmath240 , the modal transition system @xmath242_{}}},p)$ ] is refinement - equivalent to the mixed transition system @xmath253 . to define the embedding @xmath254 for an image - finite pointed modal transition system @xmath31 consider @xmath255 , unwind @xmath5 from @xmath30 as a tree @xmath256 $ ] such that all , and only , paths of length @xmath257 of @xmath5 are present . if a leaf of that tree has some @xmath18-successor in @xmath5 , create @xmath18-loops on that leaf for _ all _ events in @xmath3 ( a _ may - stub _ ) ; otherwise , leave it as is ( deadlock ) . by construction , this image - finite pointed modal transition system @xmath258,i)$ ] is the operational meaning @xmath259 _ { } } } , p_m)$ ] of a term @xmath260 so @xmath261 and lemma [ lemma : match ] imply that @xmath262 . thus @xmath263 is directed and we can set @xmath264 and note , shown in @xcite for bifinite domains without reference to a process algebra , that @xmath265 we may thus represent all @xmath195 in the form @xmath266 for some @xmath240 subsequently . ll & @xmath267 + + @xmath268 & @xmath269 + + @xmath270 & @xmath271 + + figure [ fig : app ] illustrates the construction of a finite approximation and depicts @xmath272,{\rm tomdrinks})$ ] for the pointed modal transition system @xmath273 of figure [ fig : reftwo ] . # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3900,2634)(0,-10 ) ( 2037,225)(2037,1215 ) ( 2067.000,1095.000)(2037.000,1215.000)(2007.000,1095.000)(2037.000,1131.000)(2067.000,1095.000 ) ( 1722,225)(912,1215 ) ( 1011.207,1141.122)(912.000,1215.000)(964.770,1103.128)(965.192,1149.988)(1011.207,1141.122 ) ( 597,1575)(12,2070)(687,2340)(687,1755 ) ( 657.000,1875.000)(687.000,1755.000)(717.000,1875.000)(687.000,1839.000)(657.000,1875.000 ) ( 1992,1575)(1407,2070)(2082,2340)(2082,1755 ) ( 2052.000,1875.000)(2082.000,1755.000)(2112.000,1875.000)(2082.000,1839.000)(2052.000,1875.000 ) ( 2307,225)(3432,1215 ) ( 3361.733,1113.203)(3432.000,1215.000)(3322.096,1158.246)(3368.940,1159.507)(3361.733,1113.203 ) ( 1812,0)(0,0)[lb ] ( 462,1350)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1812,1350)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3162,1350)(0,0)[lb ] ( 822,495)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2307,720)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1407,990)(0,0)[lb ] ( 12,2475)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1632,2475)(0,0)[lb ] we define the characteristic formulas for terms @xmath236 of the process algebra @xmath234 , which will also be the characteristic formulas of the compact elements @xmath266 of @xmath0 . for each @xmath240 , we define the formula @xmath274 of hennessy - milner logic in figure [ fig : phip ] . l @xmath275 + + @xmath276 + + @xmath277}}\phi _ p\land\bigwedge _ { \beta\not=\alpha } \neg{{\langle { \beta}\rangle } } { { \it t\!t}}$ ] + + @xmath278}}\phi _ p\land \bigwedge _ { \beta\not=\alpha } \neg{{\langle { \beta}\rangle } } { { \it t\!t}}$ ] + + @xmath279 + + @xmath280 } } ( \bigvee _ { v\in \{\bot,{{\it t\!t}}\ } } \ { \phi _ { r'}\mid p+q\longrightarrow ^\alpha_v r'\})$ ] these formulas characterize their terms , for one can interchange refinement checks @xmath281 with model checks @xmath282 for all @xmath283 . [ lemma : psip ] for all @xmath283 we have @xmath284 we prove this by structural induction on @xmath240 . * we have @xmath285 iff ( there are no @xmath140-transitions out of @xmath105 ) iff @xmath286 . * we have @xmath287 for all @xmath283 , but also @xmath288 for all @xmath283 . * using induction on @xmath236 , we have @xmath289 iff ( there is a @xmath139-transition @xmath290 in @xmath0 with @xmath291 ; all @xmath140-transitions @xmath292 in @xmath0 satisfy @xmath293 ; and there are no @xmath140-transitions out of @xmath105 in @xmath0 for other events ) . this exactly captures @xmath294 . * by induction on @xmath236 , we have @xmath295 iff ( there are no @xmath140-transitions out of @xmath105 for events other than @xmath141 , and all @xmath140-transitions @xmath290 satisfy @xmath291 ) . but this captures @xmath296 . * let @xmath297 . then @xmath298 and induction express that all @xmath139-transitions out of @xmath299 to some @xmath300 can be answered by corresponding @xmath301 with @xmath302 ; whereas @xmath303 } } \bigl ( \bigvee \ { \psi _ { r'}\mid\exists v\in \{\bot,{{\it t\!t}}\}\colon p+q\longrightarrow ^\alpha_v r'\}\bigr ) $ ] states that all @xmath304 can be answered in @xmath305 by corresponding @xmath140-transitions to some @xmath300 such that @xmath306 by induction . so @xmath307 . this characterization is the key to proving that @xmath0 is fully abstract and that refinement is characterized by the semantics for hennessy - milner logic . [ cor : hjs04 ] 1 . the order on @xmath0 is the greatest refinement relation within @xmath124 . 2 . for all pointed modal transition systems @xmath31 and @xmath51 the following are equivalent : 1 . @xmath48 2 . for all @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic , @xmath308 implies @xmath309 3 . for all @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic , @xmath310 implies @xmath311 . 1 . that the order of @xmath0 is a refinement follows directly from the definition of @xmath124 . for the converse , we show `` @xmath312 implies that @xmath313 does not refine @xmath314 : '' first note that @xmath315 order - generates @xmath0 so @xmath312 implies @xmath316 and @xmath317 for some @xmath195 . then there is @xmath240 with @xmath318 so that , by lemma [ lemma : psip ] , for all @xmath319 : @xmath320 iff @xmath321 . thus , @xmath322 and @xmath323 imply that @xmath324 does not refine @xmath105 in @xmath124 . 2 . since @xmath325 and @xmath326 are dual with respect to negation , ( b ) and ( c ) are equivalent . the proof that ( a ) implies ( b ) is a straightforward structural induction on @xmath213 @xcite . that ( b ) implies ( a ) follows from item ( 1 ) , lemma [ lemma : psip ] , and the fact that @xmath0 is algebraic . we demonstrate that embeddings of pointed image - finite labelled transition systems are dense in @xmath327 , which we subsequently show to be the quotient space of all pointed labelled transition systems with respect to bisimulation . the denseness argument rests on the fact that embeddings of implementations are maximal elements of @xmath0 . [ lemma : aremax ] let @xmath283 be such that , for all @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic , @xmath328 implies @xmath329 . then @xmath330 . consider such a @xmath105 and let @xmath154 in @xmath0 . since @xmath331 is a partial order and since @xmath0 is algebraic it suffices to show that @xmath332 . so let @xmath333 with @xmath334 . for @xmath335 of ( [ equ : phip ] ) , @xmath334 implies @xmath336 which implies @xmath337 by corollary [ cor : hjs04 ] as @xmath0 is fully abstract . but @xmath154 means @xmath338 as @xmath0 is fully abstract , and so @xmath339 by corollary [ cor : hjs04 ] as @xmath337 . by assumption on @xmath105 , this renders @xmath322 and so @xmath340 by ( [ equ : phip ] ) . [ prop : dense ] the set of all embeddings of pointed image - finite labelled transition systems is dense in @xmath341 . as any pointed image - finite labelled transition system @xmath342 is refinement - equivalent to @xmath343 @xcite , the embedding @xmath344 is in @xmath345 since it satisfies the assumptions of lemma [ lemma : aremax ] . let @xmath198 be non - empty , so @xmath346 for some @xmath192 and there is some @xmath347 with @xmath348 since @xmath349 is non - empty and @xmath0 is algebraic . let @xmath350 be obtained by replacing all @xmath79 in @xmath236 with @xmath239 and , for all @xmath351 , all prefixes @xmath352 with @xmath353 . then @xmath354 _ { } } } , q)$ ] refines @xmath242 _ { } } } , p)$ ] . since @xmath354_{}}},q)$ ] is a pointed _ labelled _ transition system and @xmath355 _ { } } } , r)$ ] is refinement - equivalent to @xmath356 for all @xmath357 by lemma [ lemma : match ] , we conclude @xmath358 by lemma [ lemma : aremax ] and @xmath359 is the embedding of a pointed image - finite labelled transition system . we show that @xmath191 is compact by proving , indirectly , that @xmath360 is @xmath187-closed . using results from @xcite one could show that @xmath360 is @xmath187-closed by finding a subset @xmath361 of @xmath315 that is a finitely branching tree and co - final in @xmath315 . given a candidate of such a @xmath361 , the property that is difficult to ascertain is that any two elements of @xmath361 that have an upper bound in @xmath315 are comparable . for example , consider the compact elements @xmath362 and @xmath363 , both of which have the compact element @xmath364 as an upper bound yet neither of them refines the other . faced with these difficulties , we therefore take a different route and realize @xmath360 as the set of those elements @xmath105 of @xmath0 that pass a set of judgments @xmath365 where @xmath366 are formulas of hennessy - milner logic . 1 . let @xmath367 , @xmath27 , and @xmath240 . then we define the hennessy - milner logic formula + @xmath368}}{{[{\delta _ 2}]}}\dots { { [ { \delta _ n}]}}({{\langle { \alpha}\rangle } } \phi _ p\lor \neg { { \langle { \alpha}\rangle } } \phi _ p)\ ] ] + with @xmath274 as in figure [ fig : phip ] . 2 . let @xmath369 be the set of all hennessy - milner logic formulas @xmath366 where @xmath370 , @xmath27 , and @xmath240 . 3 . for @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic and all @xmath371 we define + @xmath372^{{\it m } } } } = \ { d\in { { \mathbb d}}\mid ( { { \mathcal { d}}},d){{\models } ^{\it { m}}}\phi \}\ , .\ ] ] 4 . let @xmath373^{{\it a}}}}$ ] . for each formula @xmath213 in @xmath369 , the test @xmath374 checks whether there is a certain @xmath140-reachable state from @xmath105 with a certain outgoing may - transition that can not be matched with a corresponding outgoing must - transition . accordingly , @xmath375 consists of those elements whose reachable states always find such a match . intuitively , those should be the elements that represent labelled transition systems . the formulas in items ( [ item : one ] ) and ( [ item : two ] ) of example [ example : two ] are in @xmath369 as @xmath376 is @xmath377 , @xmath378 , and @xmath379 . rather than proving directly that @xmath360 is @xmath187-closed , we first establish that @xmath375 is @xmath187-closed and then prove @xmath380 . whence maximal elements in @xmath0 are exactly those elements whose reachable may - transitions have matching must - transitions . as @xmath375 is the intersection of sets of the form @xmath381^{{\it a}}}}$ ] , we can show that the former is @xmath187-closed by proving that all latter sets are @xmath187-closed . we do this by structural induction on @xmath213 which requires a stronger induction hypothesis . [ lemma : denoteclosed ] for each @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic , the sets @xmath381^{{\it a}}}}$ ] and @xmath381^{{\it c}}}}$ ] are @xmath187-clopen . in particular , @xmath375 is @xmath187-closed . we proceed with the first claim by structural induction on @xmath213 . this is evident for the clauses @xmath376 , negation , and conjunction since @xmath382^{{\it m } } } } = { { \mathbb d}}$ ] is @xmath187-clopen and clopens are closed under set complement ( @xmath383^{{\it a } } } } = { { \mathbb d}}\setminus { { [ \!\mid { \phi}\mid \!]^{{\it c}}}}$ ] and @xmath383^{{\it c } } } } = { { \mathbb d}}\setminus { { [ \!\mid { \phi}\mid \!]^{{\it a}}}}$ ] ) and finite intersections . we still require proofs for @xmath384 , where for each @xmath28 we have @xmath385^{{\it m } } } } = \{d\in { { \mathbb d}}\mid { { d } ^{\it { m}}}_\alpha \cap { { [ \!\mid { \phi}\mid \!]^{{\it m}}}}\not={\{\}}\}\ , .\ ] ] * let @xmath386 . by theorem 4.2 in @xcite , @xmath387^{{\it a}}}}$ ] is @xmath193-open for all @xmath214 of hennessy - milner logic , so @xmath388^{{\it a}}}}\in{{\sigma _ { { { \mathbb d}}}}}{\subseteq}{{\lambda _ { { { \mathbb d}}}}}$ ] and it suffices to show that @xmath388^{{\it a}}}}$ ] is @xmath187-closed , i.e. @xmath193-compact as an upper set . by induction , @xmath381^{{\it a}}}}$ ] is @xmath187-clopen ; it is also @xmath193-open so @xmath381^{{\it a } } } } = { { \uparrow \!\ ! _ { } \!{f_\phi}}}$ ] for a finite subset @xmath389 as @xmath0 is algebraic . by the definition of @xmath388^{{\it a}}}}$ ] , we have @xmath390^{{\it a}}}}$ ] iff @xmath391 iff @xmath392 ( as @xmath393 is a lower set ) . for each @xmath394 define @xmath395 by @xmath396 for all @xmath397 ; and @xmath398 . then @xmath399 is finite and @xmath400 . since @xmath401 for all @xmath402 , we get @xmath403^{{\it a}}}}$ ] as the latter set is upper . note that for each @xmath394 we have @xmath404 in @xmath0 iff @xmath405 . therefore , @xmath390^{{\it a}}}}$ ] implies @xmath406 . thus , @xmath388^{{\it a}}}}$ ] equals @xmath407 for the finite subset @xmath165 of @xmath315 . * let @xmath408 . from theorem 4.2 in @xcite we already know that @xmath388^{{\it c}}}}$ ] is @xmath193-closed and therefore @xmath187-closed . thus , it suffices to show that @xmath388^{{\it c}}}}$ ] is @xmath187-open . by induction , @xmath381^{{\it c}}}}$ ] is @xmath187-open and therefore @xmath409^{{\it c } } } } = { { [ \!\mid { \neg\phi}\mid \!]^{{\it a}}}}$ ] is @xmath187-closed ( and @xmath193-open ) , i.e. @xmath193-compact upper . since @xmath0 is algebraic , @xmath383^{{\it a } } } } = { { \uparrow \!\ ! _ { } \!{f_{\neg\phi}}}}$ ] for a finite subset @xmath410 of @xmath315 . thus , @xmath381^{{\it c } } } } = { { \mathbb d}}\setminus { { \uparrow \!\ ! _ { } \!{f_{\neg\phi}}}}$ ] . inspecting the definition of @xmath388^{{\it c}}}}$ ] , we infer @xmath390^{{\it c}}}}$ ] iff there is some @xmath411 such that @xmath412 . now let @xmath413^{{\it c}}}}$ ] . we claim that there are compact elements @xmath414 and @xmath415 with @xmath416^{{\it c}}}}$ ] , which concludes the proof since @xmath417 is @xmath187-open . choose any @xmath418 . as for @xmath419 , set @xmath420 for all @xmath397 ; and @xmath421 ; in particular , @xmath422 . note that @xmath423 in @xmath0 iff @xmath424 iff ( for some @xmath425 , @xmath426 ) . therefore , @xmath427^{{\it c}}}}$ ] . so @xmath375 is @xmath187-closed as the intersection of @xmath187-closed sets . in @xcite open sets are thought of as observable properties , so the denotations of hennessy - milner logic formulas in @xmath0 ( and in @xmath428 ) are closed under negation as observations . if we extend these denotations to the modal mu - calculus @xcite , we expect observable properties to correspond to sets in the borel algebra generated by @xmath193 . using the denseness of embeddings of image - finite labelled transition systems in @xmath428 , we can prove the inclusion @xmath429 . [ lemma : minc ] the set @xmath360 is contained in @xmath430 . let @xmath89 be the set of all embeddings @xmath344 of pointed image - finite labelled transition systems @xmath342 . then @xmath431 follows as * @xmath432 is refinement - equivalent to @xmath342 , * @xmath433 is valid over labelled transition systems for all @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic , * @xmath434}}\phi$ ] is valid over labelled transition systems whenever @xmath213 is , and * @xmath325 is the standard semantics of hennessy - milner logic over labelled transition systems . by proposition [ prop : dense ] , @xmath89 is a dense subset of @xmath341 and so its superset @xmath435 is also dense in @xmath341 and is @xmath436-closed by the lawson condition for @xmath0 since @xmath437 is @xmath187-closed by lemma [ lemma : denoteclosed ] . but the only dense @xmath186-closed subset of @xmath438 is @xmath428 itself and so @xmath439 follows which implies @xmath440 . for a proof of the reverse inclusion @xmath441 we need to clarify the structure of elements in @xmath375 . [ lemma : aboutc ] let @xmath442 . then : 1 . all @xmath443 that are reachable from @xmath105 in the labelled transition system @xmath444 are in @xmath375 as well . 2 . for all @xmath27 we have @xmath445 . 3 . for all @xmath213 of hennessy - milner logic , @xmath446 implies @xmath329 . 1 . let @xmath136 be reachable from @xmath105 in @xmath447 and let @xmath448 be the word obtained by travelling from @xmath105 to @xmath136 on such a path . given @xmath449 , the concatenation @xmath450 is in @xmath451 and so @xmath452 . thus the path for @xmath453 above and @xmath454 ensure @xmath455 and so @xmath456 . 2 . let @xmath27 . since @xmath457 , it suffices to show @xmath458 . proof by contradiction : let @xmath459 . then @xmath460 and @xmath461 imply @xmath462 and so @xmath463 . as @xmath0 is algebraic and @xmath464 , there is some @xmath465 with @xmath466 and @xmath467 and so @xmath468 as @xmath137 is a lower set . but @xmath454 implies @xmath469 , as @xmath470 is @xmath471 , and so @xmath472 implies @xmath473 by the definition of @xmath388^{{\it m}}}}$ ] in ( [ equ : diauniv ] ) , contradicting @xmath474 . we use structural induction on @xmath213 . the cases for @xmath376 , negation , and conjunction are straightforward . let @xmath475 , so @xmath476 for some @xmath477 . by item ( 2 ) , there is some @xmath478 with @xmath479 . but then @xmath476 and @xmath479 imply @xmath480 by corollary [ cor : hjs04 ] . since @xmath481 is reachable from @xmath105 in @xmath447 it is in @xmath375 by item ( 1 ) . thus , we can apply induction on @xmath482 and get @xmath483 . since @xmath484 , this renders @xmath485 . we have now all the machinery at our disposal for stating and proving our main results in the next two theorems . [ theorem : one ] the set @xmath360 equals @xmath375 . in particular , @xmath205 is @xmath187-closed and @xmath191 is a stone space in which the set of embeddings of pointed image - finite labelled transition systems is dense . from item ( 3 ) of lemma [ lemma : aboutc ] and lemma [ lemma : aremax ] we infer @xmath486 . lemma [ lemma : minc ] then renders @xmath380 . by lemma [ lemma : denoteclosed ] , this means that @xmath360 is @xmath187-closed . by propositions [ prop : zero ] and [ prop : dense ] , it suffices to show that @xmath487 is compact . let @xmath488 for @xmath489 . by the definition of @xmath436 , each @xmath490 is of the form @xmath491 for some @xmath492 . since @xmath0 is a bifinite domain , @xmath493 is compact @xcite . since @xmath360 is @xmath187-closed it is @xmath187-compact as a @xmath187-closed subset of the compact space @xmath493 . from @xmath494 and @xmath196 we infer that @xmath495 . the @xmath187-compactness of @xmath81 therefore implies the existence of a finite set @xmath158 with @xmath496 . but then @xmath497 follows . theorem [ theorem : one ] is of interest in its own right since @xmath189 is not @xmath119-closed for bifinite domains @xmath98 in general . but we also have to demonstrate that @xmath428 is the desired quotient space of labelled transition systems modulo bisimulation . given a topological space @xmath83 let @xmath498}$ ] be the _ poset of all @xmath84-compact subsets of @xmath69 _ , ordered by reverse inclusion : @xmath499 iff @xmath500 . [ theorem : two ] 1 . the embedding @xmath151 for pointed image - finite modal transition systems given in @xcite extends to pointed modal transition systems such that labelled transition systems are embedded into @xmath81 . conversely , for any @xmath501 the pointed mixed transition system @xmath314 is refinement - equivalent to a labelled transition system . ( it does nt `` type check '' to ask whether @xmath502 is _ bisimilar _ to a labelled transition system ; but @xmath503 and @xmath504 are merely saturation artifacts of the model . ) we have the isomorphism + @xmath505}\ ] ] + of sets where @xmath506 models the @xmath141-successors of @xmath203 as the @xmath186-compact set @xmath507 , for each @xmath27 . 1 . whenever a state @xmath45 has infinitely many states @xmath508 as @xmath141-successors for @xmath18 , choose a finite subset @xmath106 of @xmath509 , retain transitions @xmath510 and their must / may status for all @xmath511 , discard all @xmath510 with @xmath512 , and create a _ may - stub _ @xmath513 ( @xmath514 ) and a may - transition @xmath515 . doing this for all events while , at the same time , unfolding @xmath31 as a tree ensures that all approximations are image - finite with limit @xmath254 such that @xmath516 is refinement - equivalent to @xmath31 . in particular , @xmath517 by lemma [ lemma : aremax ] whenever @xmath31 is a labelled transition system . 2 . let @xmath330 and @xmath27 . the set @xmath518 is in @xmath430 , which equals @xmath360 , and @xmath445 by lemma [ lemma : aboutc ] and theorem [ theorem : one ] . combining this with ( [ equ : mix ] ) , we infer @xmath519 . but since @xmath375 is closed under states reachable in @xmath444 , we may assume this representation for all elements @xmath324 reachable from @xmath105 in @xmath444 . therefore , @xmath502 is refinement - equivalent to the modal transition system with no may - transitions that replaces @xmath520 with @xmath521 for all @xmath27 and all @xmath324 reachable from @xmath105 in @xmath444 . the isomorphism follows from the equation for @xmath0 and lemmas 34.5 and 25 of @xcite ; the latter is stated for @xmath522-domains @xmath98 , which are bifinite , but its proof only requires that @xmath189 is @xmath119-closed . an immediate consequence of these two main theorems is that sets of implementations of modal transition systems are compact in the quotient space modulo bisimulation . [ cor : cl ] for each pointed modal transition system @xmath523 , its set of implementations is compact in the quotient space of labelled transition systems modulo bisimulation . the set of implementations of @xmath523 in @xmath428 is @xmath524 which is @xmath187-closed as the intersection of two @xmath187-closed sets and so it is @xmath190-compact . we now discuss some of the consequences of the compactness of @xmath190 : a compactness theorem for hennessy - milner logic on compact sets of implementations , an abstract interpretation of compact sets of implementations as scott - closed sets of modal transition systems , and a robust consistency measure for modal transition systems . compactness of @xmath525 , stated in terms of hennessy - milner logic , is familiar from first - order logic but here secured without appeal to a complete proof system . such semantic techniques for proving compactness are not new , we mention model - theoretic techniques based on ultra - filters . a compactness theorem for hennessy - milner logic alone already follows from its standard encoding in first - order logic . however , we prove a compactness result that goes beyond hennessy - milner logic as it applies to compact sets of labelled transition systems , in particular to the set of common implementations of finitely - many pointed modal transition systems . for a single such system , @xmath526 , we then regain the familiar compactness theorem for hennessy - milner logic . our result is stronger than this familiar theorem as the sets of implementations of pointed modal transition systems are not expressible through hennessy - milner logic . in theorem [ theorem : mc](2 ) below we see that these sets are expressible in hennessy - milner logic extended with greatest fixed points for finite - state modal transition systems . [ coro : one ] 1 . let @xmath527 be a set of formulas of hennessy - milner logic and @xmath165 a @xmath190-compact set such that for all finite subsets @xmath528 of @xmath527 there is some @xmath529 that satisfies @xmath530 . then there is some @xmath531 that satisfies all formulas of @xmath527 . 2 . in particular , let @xmath527 be a set of formulas of hennessy - milner logic and @xmath532 a finite set of pointed modal transition systems such that for all finite subsets @xmath528 of @xmath527 there is a pointed labelled transition system that refines all @xmath533 and satisfies @xmath530 . then there is a pointed labelled transition system that refines all @xmath533 and satisfies all formulas of @xmath527 . by corollary [ cor : cl ] it suffices to prove item ( 1 ) . by duality of consistency ( i.e. satisfiability ) and validity , it suffices to prove the dual statement of item ( 1 ) : assume that every @xmath534 satisfies as least one @xmath535 and show that there is a finite set @xmath536 such that @xmath537 is valid over the set @xmath165 . by this assumption , we have @xmath538 where @xmath539^{{\it a}}}}\cap \max ( { { \mathbb d}})\mid \phi\in \gamma\}$ ] is a subset of @xmath190 as all @xmath381^{{\it a}}}}$ ] are in @xmath193 by theorem 4.2 in @xcite . as @xmath165 is @xmath190-compact , there is a finite @xmath158 with @xmath540 , i.e. @xmath541^{{\it a } } } } = { { [ \!\mid { \bigvee \delta}\mid \!]^{{\it a}}}}$ ] for a finite set @xmath536 . thus all @xmath534 satisfy @xmath542 . figure [ fig : cr ] depicts schematically the set of common implementations of two pointed modal transition systems @xmath314 and @xmath543 , the intersection of the implementations of @xmath105 and @xmath324 . this is a compact subset of @xmath428 and so we get a compactness theorem for hennessy - milner logic on that set . cousot & cousot s abstract interpretation framework @xcite approximates concrete objects and their transformations by abstract objects and transformations such that reasoning on abstract objects is sound for their concretizations . in a simple setting , one has given a set @xmath165 of concrete objects ( e.g. computer programs ) and a partial order @xmath544 of abstract objects , a monotone abstraction function @xmath545 , and a monotone concretization function @xmath546 . the value @xmath547 should represent the best approximation of @xmath548 within the partial order @xmath544 and @xmath549 should represent the set of those concrete objects that are abstracted by @xmath550 . one can encode these intuitions by making @xmath141 and @xmath551 a galois connection @xcite , a notion we define below . let @xmath165 be the set of natural numbers and @xmath552 where @xmath553 is the top element and @xmath349 and @xmath554 are incomparable . define @xmath555 to be @xmath349 if all elements of @xmath69 are odd ; @xmath554 if all elements of @xmath69 are even ; and @xmath553 otherwise . then @xmath556 and @xmath557 etc . define @xmath558 , @xmath559 , and @xmath560 . then @xmath561 says that @xmath349 is the least element that soundly represents the set @xmath562 . the equation @xmath563 shows that the abstract value of @xmath562 has a larger set of concrete objects . we want to apply this framework in our setting . from the compactness of @xmath190 corollary [ cor : cl ] infers that the set @xmath564 is @xmath190-compact for all pointed modal transition systems @xmath523 . said @xmath190-compact set comprises all the implementations of @xmath31 . conversely , a @xmath190-compact set @xmath165 of labelled transition system can be approximated by any pointed modal transition system @xmath523 satisfying @xmath565 . ideally , one wants an _ optimal _ such @xmath523 , one for which the difference @xmath566 is minimal . of course , this optimality is ensured for any @xmath165 of the form @xmath564 . the next example shows that there is no optimal @xmath523 in general . consider two pointed modal transition trees @xmath567 and @xmath568 that have a common refinement but do not refine each other . in general , there will be more than one minimal upper bound of the set @xmath569 in @xmath0 so there can not be a @xmath283 such that @xmath570 equals the @xmath190-compact set @xmath571 . the fact that modal transition systems can not be such optimal abstractions of @xmath190-compact sets seems to be related to the incompleteness of modal transition systems for abstraction - based model checking @xcite since @xmath0 is not bounded complete . but there is a galois connection between @xmath190-compact subsets of @xmath428 and @xmath193-closed subsets of @xmath0 . for a @xmath190-compact set @xmath165 its set of concretizations is the scott - closed set of all @xmath523 for which @xmath565 . conversely , a scott - closed subset @xmath127 of pointed modal transition systems is abstracted as the set of those pointed labelled transition systems that implement all elements of @xmath127 . 1 . let @xmath572 } = \{l\mid l\ \mbox{${{\sigma _ { { { \mathbb d}}}}}$-closed}\}$ ] be the set of @xmath193-closed subsets of @xmath0 , ordered by set inclusion : @xmath127 is less than or equal to @xmath573 iff @xmath574 . 2 . let @xmath575 and @xmath576 be complete lattices . a _ galois connection _ @xcite is a pair of monotone maps @xmath577 and @xmath578 such that for all @xmath579 we have @xmath580 and for all @xmath581 we have @xmath582 . in that case , @xmath141 is the _ upper adjoint _ of @xmath551 . [ theorem : gc ] the maps @xmath583}\to { { \mathcal l } [ { { { \mathbb d}}}]}$ ] and @xmath584}\to { { \mathcal c}[{{{\mathbb x}}},{\tau_{{\mathbb x}}}]}$ ] defined by @xmath585 form a galois connection , where @xmath141 is the upper adjoint of @xmath551 . * the map @xmath551 is well defined . first @xmath154 implies @xmath586 and so @xmath587 is a lower set . second let @xmath588 be directed in @xmath589 . then @xmath590 and the latter equals @xmath591 , so @xmath587 is @xmath193-closed . * the map @xmath141 is well defined . for if @xmath127 is empty , then @xmath592 is @xmath190-compact ; and if @xmath127 is non - empty , @xmath593 is the intersection of @xmath187-closed elements and so @xmath187-closed whence @xmath190-compact . * the map @xmath551 is monotone . let @xmath499 , i.e.@xmath500 . then @xmath594 means @xmath595 and so @xmath596 follows . therefore @xmath597 and so @xmath598 . * the map @xmath141 is monotone . let @xmath574 . then @xmath599 and so @xmath600 . * to see @xmath601}}$ ] let @xmath602}$ ] . then @xmath603 clearly contains @xmath127 . * to see @xmath604}}$ ] let @xmath605}$ ] . then @xmath606 obviously contains @xmath165 . theorem [ theorem : gc ] remains to be valid if we reverse the orders on the domains @xmath607}$ ] and @xmath572}$ ] and swap the names @xmath141 and @xmath608 throughout the theorem and its proof . in that case , a @xmath609-compact set @xmath165 is abstracted by a set @xmath127 of pointed modal transition systems and any such @xmath127 has a set of pointed labelled transition systems as concretizations . this view is perhaps more natural . we explicitly state the metrics @xmath610 for pointed modal transition systems and @xmath611 for pointed labelled transition systems . the latter is then used to define a consistency measure on modal transition systems as an alternative to the metric @xmath610 . fix an enumeration @xmath612 of @xmath234 and set @xmath613 then the topology determined by @xmath614 and @xmath615 is @xmath187 and @xmath186 , respectively . for practical purposes we wish to enumerate @xmath240 in increasing modal depth of @xmath274 in ( [ equ : phip ] ) , corresponding to the iterative unfolding of the functional for bisimulation @xcite . in that case , @xmath611 is essentially the metric in @xcite . these metrics are standard and well understood but result in consistency measures if lifted to compact sets of implementations . we define the _ consistency measure _ @xmath616\colon { { \mathbb d}}\times{{\mathbb d}}\to{{\mathbb i}}$ ] by @xmath617 and use this as an alternative to the metric @xmath610 for comparing the pointed modal transition systems @xmath314 and @xmath543 . note that @xmath618 and @xmath619 are optimistic and pessimistic measures ( respectively ) from the point of view of an implementor . figure [ fig : cr ] shows a scenario where two pointed modal transition systems @xmath314 and @xmath543 have a common refinement , and so @xmath620 . # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 6222,3783)(0,-10 ) ( 3240,3240 ) ( 3240,3240 ) ( 1620,3240 ) ( 1620,3240 ) ( 5040,3240 ) ( 5040,3240 ) ( 810,3240)(6210,3240)(3510,90)(810,3240 ) ( 1575,3240)(2610,2115)(3780,3240 ) ( 2565,3240)(4500,2475)(5040,3240 ) ( 1575,3465)(3735,3465 ) ( 3735,3465)(3735,3375 ) ( 1575,3465)(1575,3375 ) ( 4500,2475)(4501,2477)(4503,2481 ) ( 4507,2489)(4513,2501)(4521,2515 ) ( 4530,2533)(4540,2553)(4551,2575 ) ( 4562,2597)(4572,2621)(4583,2644 ) ( 4594,2668)(4603,2692)(4613,2717 ) ( 4621,2742)(4629,2766)(4635,2790 ) ( 4638,2807)(4641,2822)(4642,2835 ) ( 4642,2844)(4642,2851)(4641,2857 ) ( 4640,2860)(4639,2861)(4638,2862 ) ( 4637,2862)(4635,2861)(4633,2860 ) ( 4631,2860)(4629,2859)(4627,2859 ) ( 4624,2860)(4620,2861)(4616,2864 ) ( 4611,2867)(4605,2871)(4598,2876 ) ( 4590,2880)(4571,2887)(4555,2891 ) ( 4544,2892)(4536,2892)(4530,2891 ) ( 4524,2890)(4515,2888)(4501,2886 ) ( 4481,2884)(4455,2880)(4429,2875 ) ( 4409,2869)(4396,2864)(4389,2859 ) ( 4384,2854)(4379,2849)(4372,2844 ) ( 4360,2840)(4342,2837)(4320,2835 ) ( 4305,2836)(4292,2837)(4282,2839 ) ( 4275,2840)(4270,2841)(4266,2842 ) ( 4264,2843)(4261,2843)(4259,2845 ) ( 4255,2848)(4250,2852)(4244,2859 ) ( 4237,2868)(4230,2880)(4223,2899 ) ( 4221,2916)(4223,2929)(4228,2939 ) ( 4234,2948)(4240,2956)(4244,2966 ) ( 4245,2979)(4241,2996)(4230,3015 ) ( 4218,3029)(4206,3039)(4196,3045 ) ( 4189,3049)(4185,3051)(4181,3053 ) ( 4177,3053)(4171,3054)(4161,3055 ) ( 4145,3057)(4123,3059)(4095,3060 ) ( 4069,3059)(4046,3057)(4026,3054 ) ( 4011,3051)(4001,3048)(3993,3045 ) ( 3986,3041)(3980,3038)(3972,3034 ) ( 3960,3031)(3945,3027)(3924,3023 ) ( 3899,3019)(3870,3015)(3838,3012 ) ( 3813,3009)(3796,3006)(3786,3003 ) ( 3782,3000)(3780,2996)(3778,2993 ) ( 3774,2992)(3764,2992)(3747,2995 ) ( 3722,3003)(3690,3015)(3665,3027 ) ( 3642,3041)(3622,3054)(3607,3066 ) ( 3595,3077)(3586,3087)(3579,3096 ) ( 3574,3105)(3568,3114)(3562,3123 ) ( 3553,3133)(3542,3144)(3527,3156 ) ( 3509,3169)(3488,3183)(3465,3195 ) ( 3441,3206)(3419,3213)(3402,3217 ) ( 3387,3218)(3375,3218)(3364,3215 ) ( 3355,3212)(3348,3208)(3341,3204 ) ( 3336,3200)(3333,3198)(3331,3196)(3330,3195 ) ( 2610,2115)(2608,2117)(2604,2121 ) ( 2598,2127)(2589,2137)(2578,2149 ) ( 2566,2164)(2554,2180)(2542,2197 ) ( 2530,2215)(2521,2233)(2514,2253 ) ( 2509,2273)(2508,2295)(2512,2317 ) ( 2520,2340)(2534,2361)(2550,2380 ) ( 2567,2393)(2584,2403)(2600,2410 ) ( 2616,2413)(2630,2414)(2644,2415 ) ( 2658,2415)(2673,2417)(2689,2419 ) ( 2706,2424)(2726,2433)(2747,2444 ) ( 2769,2459)(2790,2475)(2806,2490 ) ( 2819,2503)(2829,2514)(2837,2523 ) ( 2843,2529)(2847,2533)(2850,2536 ) ( 2852,2538)(2854,2539)(2855,2540 ) ( 2855,2542)(2856,2544)(2856,2549 ) ( 2855,2556)(2853,2566)(2849,2578 ) ( 2843,2593)(2835,2610)(2822,2630 ) ( 2807,2648)(2791,2664)(2775,2677 ) ( 2760,2687)(2746,2695)(2732,2702 ) ( 2719,2707)(2705,2713)(2692,2719 ) ( 2678,2727)(2663,2736)(2649,2747 ) ( 2634,2761)(2621,2775)(2610,2790 ) ( 2603,2809)(2608,2820)(2622,2823 ) ( 2641,2821)(2663,2816)(2684,2811 ) ( 2702,2809)(2714,2811)(2714,2820 ) ( 2700,2835)(2685,2845)(2667,2856 ) ( 2648,2865)(2627,2874)(2607,2881 ) ( 2586,2888)(2566,2893)(2547,2898 ) ( 2527,2903)(2508,2907)(2489,2912 ) ( 2470,2917)(2452,2924)(2434,2931 ) ( 2417,2940)(2402,2949)(2391,2960 ) ( 2385,2970)(2386,2980)(2394,2989 ) ( 2407,2994)(2423,2998)(2439,2999 ) ( 2457,2999)(2475,2998)(2494,2996 ) ( 2513,2995)(2532,2993)(2552,2993 ) ( 2573,2994)(2594,2996)(2616,3001 ) ( 2636,3007)(2655,3015)(2669,3024 ) ( 2678,3032)(2681,3038)(2678,3043 ) ( 2670,3047)(2660,3050)(2647,3051 ) ( 2633,3052)(2619,3054)(2607,3056 ) ( 2598,3059)(2594,3064)(2596,3071 ) ( 2606,3080)(2626,3092)(2655,3105 ) ( 2681,3115)(2711,3126)(2742,3136 ) ( 2774,3145)(2807,3154)(2840,3163 ) ( 2874,3171)(2908,3179)(2942,3187 ) ( 2976,3195)(3009,3202)(3042,3209 ) ( 3073,3215)(3102,3221)(3127,3227 ) ( 3149,3231)(3167,3234)(3179,3237 ) ( 3188,3239)(3193,3240)(3195,3240 ) ( 855,1170)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3735,0)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4365,2250)(0,0)[lb ] ( 0,810)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2520,1890)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3285,3060)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1350,3015)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1710,3600)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4635,3060)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4230,585)(0,0)[lb ] since @xmath621 is @xmath186-compact for all @xmath622 by corollary [ cor : cl ] , @xmath623 and @xmath624 are the metric analogue of symmetric @xmath625 and @xmath626 lifts of relations from elements to subsets , here of @xmath627 to @xmath186-compact subsets , respectively . the standard metric @xmath628 between compact subsets @xmath570 and @xmath629 , the hausdorff distance , is the symmetric @xmath630-lift of @xmath611 to @xmath186-compact subsets and so @xmath631 such consistency measures are of particular interest if @xmath105 and @xmath324 represent different viewpoints @xcite of the same system such that the degree of consistency between these descriptions needs to be explored . we prove that @xmath618 is a robust measure in that its kernel consists of those pairs of pointed modal transition systems that have a common refinement . [ theorem : mc ] 1 . for all @xmath153 , we have @xmath620 iff @xmath314 and @xmath313 have a common refinement . 2 . deciding whether two finite - state modal transition systems have a common refinement is reducible to checking the satisfiability of a modal mu - calculus formula with greatest fixed points only . 1 . we use theorems [ theorem : one ] and [ theorem : two ] repeatedly . if @xmath314 and @xmath313 have a common refinement , there is some @xmath632 and so @xmath633 as @xmath634 . conversely , let @xmath620 . then for each @xmath635 there are @xmath636 and @xmath637 with @xmath638 . since @xmath341 is compact , there is a convergent subsequence @xmath639 of @xmath640 with limit @xmath641 and so @xmath642 as the latter is @xmath186-closed . since @xmath643 for each @xmath644 , this implies @xmath645 and so @xmath641 is in all @xmath186-closed sets that contain @xmath646 . therefore , @xmath641 is in @xmath629 and so @xmath647 is a common refinement of @xmath314 and @xmath313 . if @xmath31 and @xmath51 are finite - state , we show that there are formulas @xmath648 and @xmath649 of the modal mu - calculus with greatest fixed points only such that the modal mu - calculus formula @xmath650 is satisfiable over labelled transition systems iff @xmath31 and @xmath51 have a common refinement . larsen & thomsen implicitly define these formulas in the system of recursive equations ( 3 ) of @xcite where , for each state @xmath45 in @xmath651 , + @xmath652 } } ( \bigvee _ { ( s,\alpha , s')\in{{r } ^{\it { c } } } } x_{(m , s')}))\ ] ] + as a greatest fixed point . if @xmath45 has finitely many reachable states in @xmath5 , then @xmath653 is expressible in the modal mu - calculus , using a `` calling context '' on the set of states @xmath44 that are @xmath18-reachable from @xmath45 and static scoping of the greatest fixed - point operators @xmath654 . now for all pointed labelled transition systems @xmath342 we have @xmath655 iff @xmath656 where we can use the proof of ( 3 ) in @xcite which works in our setting as conjunctions and disjunctions need not be finite . let @xmath5 be the modal transition system from figure [ fig : ref ] . we write @xmath657 as a formula of the modal mu - calculus with greatest fixed points only . let @xmath658 } } z_{\rm dr } \land { { [ { \rm talks } ] } } x^{\rm dr}_{(m,{\rm ta})}\land { { [ { \rm orders } ] } } x^{\rm dr}_{(m,{\rm wa})}\\ x^{\rm dr}_{(m,{\rm ta } ) } & = & \nu z_{\rm ta}. { { [ { \rm drinks } ] } } z_{\rm dr } \land { { [ { \rm orders } ] } } x^{\rm dr\ , ta}_{(m,{\rm wa})}\nonumber\\ x^{\rm dr}_{(m,{\rm wa } ) } & = & \nu z_{\rm wa}. { { \langle { \rm newpint}\rangle } } z_{\rm dr } \land { { \langle { \rm newpint}\rangle } } x^{\rm dr}_{(m,{\rm ta})}\land { { [ { \rm newpint}]}}(z_{\rm dr}\lor x^{\rm dr\ , wa}_{(m,{\rm ta})})\nonumber\\ x^{\rm dr\ , wa}_{(m,{\rm ta } ) } & = & \nu z_{\rm ta}. { { [ { \rm drinks } ] } } z_{\rm dr } \land { { [ { \rm orders } ] } } z_{\rm wa}\nonumber\\ x^{\rm dr\ , ta}_{(m,{\rm wa } ) } & = & \nu z_{\rm wa}. { { \langle { \rm newpint}\rangle } } z_{\rm dr } \land { { \langle { \rm newpint}\rangle } } z_{\rm ta}\land { { [ { \rm newpint}]}}(z_{\rm dr}\lor z_{\rm ta})\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the superscripts in @xmath653 record the `` calling context '' of the recursions . so @xmath623 measures the _ degree of inconsistency _ of @xmath502 and @xmath313 , a lower bound on the difference between their implementations , @xmath624 is an upper bound on such a difference , and none of them is a metric : from item ( [ item : fourd ] ) of definition [ def : ultra ] , @xmath618 satisfies only ( b ) and @xmath619 satisfies only ( b ) and ( c ) . the reducibility of common refinement checks to satisfiability checks in the modal mu - calculus yields exptime as a weak upper bound on its complexity . since the formulas are defined in terms of greatest fixed points only , one can indeed show a stronger result : the decision problem of common refinements is in ptime @xcite . our results also apply to 3-valued model checking frameworks in which system observables are state propositions or a combination of state propositions and events . this is so since godefroid & jagadeesan s translation between modal transition systems ( events only ) , partial kripke structures @xcite ( state propositions only ) , and kripke modal transition systems @xcite ( events and state propositions ) and their translations of the respective temporal logic formulas is shown to preserve and reflect refinement and the meaning of model checks @xcite . bakker & zucker use domain equations and metric completions for a metric and denotational treatment of concurrency in @xcite . lawson proposes the notion of a maximal - point space to represent classical topological spaces as maximal points of a domain in the topology induced by the domain s lawson- and scott - topology @xcite . abramsky @xcite provides a fully abstract domain of synchronization trees for _ partial _ bisimulation between labelled transition systems that have a divergence predicate . the domain equation of loc . cit . uses a sum construction on the convex powerdomain . maximal points are not part of that paper s agenda and are therefore not discussed therein . labelled transition systems with a divergence predicate and partial bisimulation are recognized as certain modal transition systems and their refinement in @xcite . mislove et al . present a fully abstract domain model , which combines the probabilistic power domain with a convex variant of the plotkin powerdomain , for finite - state processes with non - deterministic and probabilistic choice @xcite . alessi et al . @xcite introduce a category of @xmath659-domains with a compositional maximal - points space functor to stone spaces . they show that all bifinite domains @xmath98 for which @xmath189 is a stone space are scott - continuous retracts of @xmath659-domains . in particular , @xmath0 is such a retract by theorem [ theorem : one ] . we suspect that @xmath0 is not an @xmath659-domain since @xmath660}$ ] is not an @xmath522-domain for the @xmath522-domain @xmath661 @xcite , although @xmath660}$ ] is the second iteration of the domain equation ( [ equ : recursion ] ) for @xmath0 when @xmath662 . the paper @xcite presents the domain @xmath0 and its modal transition system @xmath124 , both denoted as @xmath124 in loc.cit . , and proves full abstraction and a characterization of @xmath0 s compact elements in terms of formulas of hennessy - milner logic . in @xcite it is shown that the co - inductive refinement of modal transition systems has an extensional description : a pointed modal transition system @xmath31 refines a pointed modal transition system @xmath51 if , and only if , the set of implementations of @xmath31 is a subset of the implementations of @xmath51 . dams & namjoshi @xcite show that finite - state modal transition systems are incomplete as abstractions of infinite - state modal transition systems for modal mu - calculus checking . they propose focused transition systems as a generalization of modal transition systems , show completeness for this class of models , and define a game semantics for refinement of focused transition systems and a game semantics for model checks of alternating tree automata on focused transition systems . it is straightforward to write down a domain equation for focused transition systems but a programme of maximal - points spaces wo nt directly render pointed kripke structures since , as noted in @xcite , focused transition systems can have maximal refinements that have inconsistent constraints on propositions at states . in @xcite consistency , satisfiability , and validity problems are studied for collectively model checking a set of views endowed with labelled transitions , hybrid constraints on states , and atomic propositions . a ptime algorithm for deciding whether a set of views has a common refinement ( consistency ) it is proved that deciding whether a common refinement satisfies a formula of the hybrid mu - calculus @xcite ( satisfiability ) , and its dual ( validity ) , are exptime - complete . two generically generated `` summary '' views are defined that constitute informative and consistent common refinements and abstractions of a set of views ( respectively ) . di pierro et al . @xcite develop a quantitative notion of process equivalence as the basis for an approximative version of non - interference and precise quantifications of information leakage . they present two semantics - based analyzes for approximative non - interference where one soundly abstracts the other . desharnais et al . @xcite show that each continuous - state labelled markov process has a sequence of finite acyclic labelled markov processes as abstractions which is precise for a probabilistic modal logic ; an equivalence between the category of markov processes and simulation morphisms and a recursively defined domain , viewed as a category , is given . desharnais et al . @xcite define a pseudo metric between labelled concurrent markov chains where zero distance means weak bisimilarity . the metric is characterized in a real - valued modal logic and shown to allow for compositional quantitative reasoning . we presented the fully abstract and universal domain model @xmath0 for pointed modal transition systems and refinement of @xcite . using techniques from concurrency theory and topology , we demonstrated that @xmath0 is the right fully abstract and universal model for labelled transition systems and bisimulation since the quotient space of all pointed labelled transition systems with respect to bisimulation , @xmath191 , is obtained as the maximal - points space of @xmath0 . we furthermore revealed the fine - structure of @xmath428 , notably we proved that its topology @xmath186 inherited from the scott- and lawson - topology of @xmath0 is compact , zero - dimensional , and hausdorff ( a stone space ) . in particular , @xmath186 is determined by a computationally meaningful , complete ultra - metric @xmath615 for which image - finite labelled transition systems approximate labelled transition systems to any degree of precision . modulo refinement , @xmath663 is image - finite for all @xmath195 , so this denseness also applies to modal transition systems for the lawson - topology and its metric @xmath610 . thus our results unify denotational , operational , and metric semantics of labelled and modal transition systems . we finally derived consequences of this compact representation : a compactness theorem for hennessy - milner logic on compact sets of implementations , an abstract interpretation of compact sets of implementations as scott - closed sets of modal transition systems , and a robust consistency measure for modal transition systems . radha jagadeesan suggested working with the mixed powerdomain in @xcite . glenn bruns , alessandra di pierro , patrice godefroid , dimitar guelev , chris hankin , radha jagadeesan , achim jung , ralph kopperman , david schmidt , and herbert wiklicky are thanked for helpful comments and discussions . this paper is an extended journal version of @xcite and reflects the thorough and thoughtful comments made by the anonymous referees of the lics 2004 conference and the journal logical methods in computer science . f. alessi , p. baldan , and f. honsell . partializing stone spaces using sfp domains . in m. bidoit and m. dauchet , editors , _ tapsoft97 conference proceedings _ , volume 1214 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 478489 , lille , france , 14 - 18 april 1997 . springer verlag . g. bruns and p. model checking partial state spaces with @xmath664-valued temporal logics . in _ proc . of the 11th international conference on computer aided verification _ , volume 1633 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 274287 . springer verlag , july 1999 . g. bruns and p. godefroid . generalized model checking : reasoning about partial state spaces . in _ proc . of the 11th international conference on concurrency theory _ , volume 1877 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 168182 . springer verlag , august 2000 . p. cousot and r. cousot . abstract interpretation : a unified lattice model for static analysis of programs . in _ proc . of the 4th acm symposium on principles of programming languages _ , pages 238252 , los angeles , california . acm press , 1977 . d. dams and k. namjoshi . the existence of finite abstractions for branching time model checking . in _ proc . of the nineteenth annual ieee symposium on logic in computer science _ , pages 335344 , 13 - 17 july , turku , finland . ieee computer society press , 2004 . j. desharnais , v. gupta , r. jagadeesan , and p. panangaden . approximating labeled markov processes . in _ proc . of the 15th annual ieee symposium on logic in computer science _ , pages 95106 , santa barbara , california , 26 - 29 june 2000 . ieee computer society press . j. desharnais , v. gupta , r. jagadeesan , and p. panangaden . the metric analogue of weak bisimulation for probabilistic processes . in _ proc . of the 17th annual ieee symposium on logic in computer science _ , pages 413422 , copenhagen , denmark , july 2002 . ieee computer society . godefroid , m. huth , and r. jagadeesan . abstraction - based model checking using modal transition systems . in _ proc . of the 12th international conference on theory and practice of concurrency _ , volume 2154 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 426440 . springer verlag , august 2001 . p. godefroid and r. jagadeesan . automatic abstraction using generalized model checking . in e. brinksma and k. g. larsen , editors , _ proc . of the 14th international conference on computer aided verification _ , volume 2404 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 137150 , copenhagen , denmark , july 2002 . springer verlag . p. godefroid and r. jagadeesan . on the expressiveness of 3-valued models . in l. d. zuck , p. c. attie , a. cortesi , and s. mukhopadhyay , editors , _ proc . of the 4th international conference on verification , model checking and abstract interpretation _ , volume 2575 of _ lncs _ , pages 206222 , new york , january 2003 . springer verlag . m. huth , r. jagadeesan , and d. a. schmidt . modal transition systems : a foundation for three - valued program analysis . in d. sands , editor , _ proc . of esop2001 _ , pages 155169 . springer verlag , april 2001 . m. huth . beyond image - finiteness : labelled transition systems as a stone space . in : _ proc . of the nineteenth annual ieee symposium on logic in computer science _ , pages 222231 , 13 - 17 july , turku , finland , ieee computer society press , 2004 . k. g. larsen . modal specifications . in j. sifakis , editor , _ automatic verification methods for finite state systems _ , number 407 in lecture notes in computer science , pages 232246 . springer verlag , june 1214 1989 . international workshop , grenoble , france . u. sattler and m. vardi . the hybrid @xmath667-calculus . in r. gor ' e , a. leitsch , and t. nipkov _ proc . of the first international joint conference on automated reasoning_. lecture notes in computer science 2083 , pages 7691 , siena , italy , 18 - 23 june , springer verlag , 2001 . i. sommerville , p. sawyer , and s. viller . viewpoints for requirements elicitation : a practical approach . in _ proc . of the 1998 international conference on requirements engineering _ , colorado springs , colorado , april 6 - 10 1998 . ieee computer society press . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in 2007 rob spekkens proposed a toy theory @xcite with the aim of showing that many of the characteristic features of quantum mechanics could result from a restriction on our knowledge of the state of an essentially classical system . the theory describes a simple type of system which mimics many of the features of a quantum qubit . the success of the toy theory in replicating characteristic quantum behaviour is , in one sense , quite puzzling , since the mathematical structures employed by the two theories are quite different . quantum mechanics represents states of systems by vectors in a hilbert space , while processes undergone by systems are represented by linear maps . in contrast , the toy theory represents states by subsets and processes by relations . this ` incomparability ' means that the mathematical origins of the similarities ( and differences ) between the two theories are not easy to pinpoint . in this paper we consider the toy theory from a new perspective - by looking at the ` algebra ' of how the processes of the theory combine . the mathematical structure formed by the composition of processes in any physical theory is a _ symmetric monoidal category _ @xcite , with the objects of the category representing systems , and the morphisms representing processes undergone by these systems - we term this the _ process category _ of the theory . work initiated by abramsky and coecke @xcite , and continued by many other authors @xcite has investigated the structure of the process category of quantum mechanics . mathematical structures of this category have been identified which correspond directly to key physical features of the theory . in principle , any theory whose processes form a category with these mathematical features should exhibit these quantum - like physical features . it will be gratifying then to note that the process category of the toy theory shares many of these features , thus ` accounting for ' the similarities which this theory has with quantum mechanics . the main aim of this paper is to characterise the process category of the toy theory . this turns out to be less straightforward than one might have hoped ! in the case of quantum mechanics it is straightforward to see that the states of a system correspond exactly with the vectors of the hilbert space describing that system , and that processes correspond exactly with linear maps ; thus we can immediately conclude that the process category of quantum mechanics is * hilb * , whose objects are hilbert spaces and whose morphisms are linear maps . such a quick and easy statement of the process category for the toy theory is not possible . this is due largely to the way that the valid states and processes of the theory are defined : this is via an inductive procedure where the valid states and transformations for a collection of @xmath0 systems must be known before those for a collection of @xmath1 systems can be deduced . there is also a certain degree of ambiguity in the way in which the theory was originally stated , and , since the toy theory was never fully constructed ( until now ) , its consistency was not even guaranteed . another feature which was not addressed in the theory is _ compositional closure _ _ , that is : _ if we compose two valid processes , either in parallel or sequentially ( when types match ) , do we again obtain a valid process ? _ obviously , this is a natural operational requirement , and as indicated above , this notion of compositional closure is the operational cornerstone to modelling physical processes in a symmetric monoidal category . in this paper , it is exactly the compositional closure assumption which allows us to formulate the toy theory in terms of no more than a few generators , with clear operational meanings . _ _ _ _ _ the structure of the paper is as follows . we begin with a very brief summary of the toy bit theory , and a discussion of the ambiguities in its definition . we then define a categories * spek * and * mspek * which we claim is the process category for the toy theory . this is a sub - category of * rel * , whose objects are sets and whose morphisms are relations . the next section is devoted to showing the general form of the relations which constitute the morphisms of * mspek*. we then go on to argue that these relations are exactly those which describe the processes of the toy theory , thus demonstrating that * mspek * is the process category of the toy theory . finally we note some of the key categorical features of * mspek * and link these to the characteristically quantum behaviour exhibited by the toy bit theory . the category * spek * was first proposed by us in @xcite , and we provide some explicit pointers to useful information therein throughout this text . for full details of spekkens s toy bit theory , the reader is referred to the original paper @xcite . here we provide a very brief summary of the key points . there is just one type of elementary system in the theory , which can exist in one of four states . we will denote the set of these four states , the _ ontic state space _ by @xmath2 . alternatively we can depict it graphically as : @xmath3 the ontic states are to be distinguished from the _ epistemic _ states , which describe the extent of our knowledge about which ontic state the system occupies . for example we might know that the system is either in ontic state 1 or 2 . we would depict such an epistemic state in the following fashion : @xmath4 the epistemic state is intended to be the analogue of the quantum state . note that an epistemic state is simply a subset of the ontic state space . given a composite system of @xmath1 elementary systems , its ontic state space is simply the cartesian product of the ontic state spaces of the composite systems , @xmath5 . thus such a system has @xmath6 ontic states . the key premise of the theory is that our knowledge of the ontic state is restricted in a specific way so that only certain epistemic states are allowed . we refer the reader to the original paper for the full statement of this epistemic restriction , which spekkens refers to as the _ knowledge balance principle_. it suffices here to say that , given an @xmath1-component system , an epistemic state is a @xmath7 or @xmath8 element subset of the ontic state space , the @xmath9 case being the situation of maximal knowledge and the @xmath8 case being the situation of total ignorance . for a single system this means that there are six epistemic states of maximal knowledge : @xmath10 and one of non - maximal knowledge : @xmath11 a consequence of the knowledge balance principle is that any measurement on a system inevitably results in a probabilistic disturbance of that system s ontic state . a measurement in the toy theory essentially corresponds to asking which of a collection of subsets of the ontic state space contains the ontic state . an example would be a measurement on a single system corresponding to the question `` is the ontic state in the subset @xmath12 or the subset @xmath13 ? '' . if the initial epistemic state of the system was the subset @xmath14 then answering this question would allow us to pin down the ontic state precisely , to 1 if we get the first answer or 3 if we get the second , in violation of the knowledge balance principle . thus we hypothesise that if , for example , we get the first answer to our question , then the ontic state undergoes a random disturbance , either remaining in state 1 or moving into state 2 , with equal probability . the epistemic state following the measurement then would be @xmath12 . the effect of such a probabilistic disturbance on the _ epistemic _ state is best modelled by viewing it as a _ relation _ on the ontic state space , defined by @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , where the notation denotes that the element 1 in the domain relates to both the elements 1 and 2 in the codomain , the element 2 in the domain , while the elements 3 and 4 in the domain relate to no elements in the codomain . below we will omit specification of those elements in the domain that relate to no elements in the codomain . thus in general the transformations of the theory are described by _ relations_. in his original paper spekkens derives the states and transformations allowed in the theory , apparently appealing only to the following three principles : 1 . the epistemic state of any system must satisfy the knowledge balance principle globally i.e. it should be a @xmath7 or @xmath8 element subset of the ontic state space . 2 . when considering a composite system , the ` marginal ' epistemic state of any subsystem should also satisfy the knowledge balance principle . by the marginal epistemic state we mean the following . suppose the whole system has @xmath1 components , and we are interested in an @xmath19-component subsystem . the epistemic state of the whole system will be some set of @xmath1-tuples : to get the marginal state on the @xmath19-component system we simply delete the @xmath20 entries from each tuple which correspond to the subsystems which are not of interest to us . 3 . applying a valid transformation to a valid state should result in a valid state . the second principle is used , for example , to rule this out as an epistemic state for a two - component system : @xmath21 the third principle is used extensively . it is invoked to show that the transformations on a single element system constitute permutations on the set of ontic states , since any other function on @xmath22 would lead to some valid epistemic state being transformed into an invalid state . another illuminating example of the third principle in action is the elimination of this state as a valid epistemic state : @xmath23 this state would be allowed by the first and second principles , but upon making a certain measurement on one of the systems , the resulting measurement disturbance would transform it into this state : @xmath24 which clearly fails to satisfy the first principle . the mode of definition of the theory , via the three principles stated earlier , raises some interesting issues . firstly , this approach seems to be necessarily iterative . compare it , for example , to how we would describe the form of valid states in quantum mechanics - in one line we can say that they are the normalised vectors of the system s state space . secondly , do these rules actually uniquely define the toy theory ? there does seem to be a problem with the third rule . when we use it to rule out the state in diagram [ ruledoutby3 ] , our argument is that we already know what the valid measurement disturbance transformations on a single elementary system are , and when we apply one of them to this state we obtain a state which clearly violates the knowledge balance principle . however , it is not clear that we could not have made the alternative choice - that this state should be valid , and therefore that the transformation which we had previously thought was valid could no longer be considered as such . it seems that considerations other than the three rules above come into deciding which should be the valid states of the theory , but it is nowhere clearly stated exactly what they are . the second point touched slightly on our final issue : is the theory as spekkens presents it consistent ? he derives valid states and transformations for systems with up to three elementary components . however , can we be sure that these states and transformations , when combined in more complex situations involving four or more elementary systems , wo nt yield a state which clearly violates the knowledge balance principle ? currently there seems to be no such proof of consistency . in fact , in the process of re - expressing the theory in categorical terms , we will develop such a proof . we briefly review the key structural features of the process categories of quantum - like theories . a physicist - friendly tutorial of the category theoretic preliminaries is in @xcite . a survey on the recent applications of these to quantum theory and quantum information is in @xcite . [ smcdef ] a _ symmetric monoidal category _ @xmath25 is a category equipped with the following extra structure : a bifunctor @xmath26 ; a _ unit object _ @xmath27 ; and four natural isomorphisms , left and right unit : @xmath28 , @xmath29 , associative : @xmath30 and commutative : @xmath31 . furthermore these objects and natural isomorphisms obey a series of _ coherence conditions _ @xcite . as argued in @xcite , the process category of any physical theory is a smc . the bifunctor @xmath32 is interpreted as adjoining two systems to make a larger compound system . * hilb * becomes a smc with the tensor product as the bifunctor , and @xmath33 as the unit object . * rel * is a smc with the cartesian product as the bifunctor and the single element set as the unit object . there is a very useful graphical language for describing smcs , due to joyal and street @xcite , which we will make extensive use of . it traces back to penrose s earlier diagrammatic notation for abstract tensors @xcite . in this language we represent a morphism @xmath34 by a box : @xmath35 @xmath36 , the composition of morphisms @xmath37 and @xmath38 is depicted as : @xmath39 the identity morphism @xmath40 is actually just written as a straight line this makes sense if you imagine composing it with another morphism . turning to the symmetric monoidal structure , a morphism @xmath41 is depicted : @xmath42 and if @xmath34 and @xmath43 then @xmath44 is depicted as : @xmath45 the identity object @xmath27 is not actually depicted in the graphical language . morphisms @xmath46 and @xmath47 are written as : @xmath48 the associativity and left and right unit natural isomorphisms are also implicit in the language . the symmetry natural isomorphism is depicted as : @xmath49 in fact the graphical language is more than just a useful tool ; it enables one to derive all equational statements that follow from the axioms of a smc : two morphisms in a symmetric monoidal category can be shown to be equal using the axioms of a smc iff the diagrams corresponding to these morphisms in the graphical language are isomorphic , where by diagram isomorphism we mean that the boxes and wires of the first are in bijective correspondence with the second , preserving the connections between boxes and wires . the categories described by the graphical language are in fact _ strict smcs , that is , those for which @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 are equalities . mac lane s _ strictification theorem @xcite , which establishes an equivalence of any smc with a strict one , enables one to apply the diagrammatic notation to any smc . _ _ we will often refer to morphisms of type @xmath46 as _ states _ , since in a process category they represent the preparation of a system @xmath53 in a given state . in * hilb * such morphisms are in bijection with the vectors of the hilbert space @xmath53 ; in * rel * they correspond to subsets of the set @xmath53 . the process categories of _ quantum - like _ theories possess a range of additional structures . a _ dagger category _ is a category equipped with a contravariant involutive identity - on - objects functor @xmath54 . dagger symmetric monoidal category _ ( @xmath55-smc ) is a symmetric monoidal category with a dagger functor such that : @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , and @xmath60 . * hilb * is a @xmath55-smc with the _ adjoint _ playing the role of the dagger functor . * rel * is a @xmath55-smc with _ relational converse _ as the dagger functor . [ csdef ] in a smc @xmath61 a _ compact structure _ on an object @xmath53 is a tuple @xmath62 where @xmath63 is a dual object to @xmath53 which may or may not be equal to @xmath53 , and @xmath64 and @xmath65 satisfy the conditions : @xmath66 and the dual diagram for @xmath67 . a _ compact closed _ category @xmath61 is a smc in which all @xmath68 have compact structures . * hilb * is a compact closed category , where for each object @xmath53 the _ bell - state _ ket @xmath69 ( with @xmath70 a basis for the hilbert space @xmath53 ) familiar from quantum mechanics provides the morphism @xmath64 , and the corresponding bra acts as @xmath65 . perhaps unsurprisingly , given this example , abramsky and coecke in @xcite showed that this structure underlies the capacity of any quantum - like theory to exhibit information processing protocols such as _ teleportation _ and _ entanglement swapping_. furthermore abramsky has shown @xcite that any theory whose process category is compact closed will obey a generalised version of the no - cloning theorem . for the compact structures of interest in this paper @xmath71 is always equal to @xmath53 see proposition [ inducedcsprop ] below . hence , from here on we wo nt distinguish these two objects . this simplifies the graphical language , which can be extended by introducing special elements to represent the morphisms of the compact structure @xmath64 and @xmath65 : @xmath72 equation [ cccomdiag ] and its dual are then depicted as : @xmath73 this extension of the graphical language now renders it completely equivalent to the axioms of a compact closed category ; for a detailed discussion we refer to @xcite . two morphisms in a compact closed category can be shown to be equal using the axioms of compact closure iff the diagrams corresponding to these morphisms in the graphical language are isotopic . compact closure is of particular importance to us since in any compact closed category there will be _ map - state duality _ : a bijection between the hom - sets @xmath74 and @xmath75 ( in fact both these will further be in bijection with @xmath76 ) : @xmath77 and @xmath78 that this is a bijection follows from equation [ yanking ] . if we have a morphism with larger composite domain and codomain the number of hom - sets in bijection increases dramatically . for example the morphisms of the hom - sets @xmath79 and @xmath80 are in bijection : explicitly the conversion between morphisms from the two sets can be depicted as : @xmath81 clearly manoeuvres like this can convert any ` input ' line into an ` output ' line , by using the unit and co - unit morphisms to ` bend lines around ' . [ decdef ] a _ _ diagram equivalence class _ _ ( dec ) is a set of morphisms in a compact closed category which can be inter - converted by composition with the units and co - units of the factors of their domains and codomains . the final structure of interest is the _ basis structure _ , which can be seen as the ` dagger - variant ' of carboni and walters s frobenius algebras @xcite . this structure is discussed at length in @xcite . [ bsdef ] in a @xmath55-smc a _ basis structure _ @xmath82 on an object @xmath53 is a commutative isometric dagger frobenius comonoid @xmath83 . for more details on this definition see section 4 of @xcite where basis structures are referred to as ` observable structures ' . we represent the morphisms @xmath84 and @xmath85 graphically as : @xmath86 basis structures are so named because in * hilb * they are in bijection with orthonormal bases , via the correspondence : @xmath87 where @xmath88 is an orthonormal basis for @xmath89 . this is proved in @xcite . [ sepbsprop ] two basis structures @xmath90 and @xmath91 induce a third basis structure @xmath92 , with : @xmath93 [ inducedcsprop ] any basis structure induces a self - dual dagger compact structure , with @xmath94 and @xmath95 . basis structures are identified in @xcite as a key structure underlying a variety of quantum - like features , for example the existence of incompatible observables , and information processing tasks such as the quantum fourier transform . in the section we give the definitions of two key categories . the first definition is a convenient stepping stone to the second : [ defspek ] the category * spek * is a subcategory of * rel * , defined inductively , as follows : * the objects of * spek * are the single - element set @xmath96 , the four element set @xmath97 , and its @xmath1-fold cartesian products @xmath5 . * the morphisms of * spek * are all those relations generated by composition , cartesian product and relational converse from the following generating relations : 1 . all permutations @xmath98 of the four element set , represented diagrammatically by : @xmath99 there are 24 such permutations and they form a group , @xmath100 . 2 . a relation @xmath101 defined by : @xmath102 represented diagrammatically by : @xmath103 3 . a relation @xmath104 defined by @xmath105 and represented diagrammatically by : @xmath106 4 . the relevant unit , associativity and symmetry natural isomorphisms . @xcite[spek : basisstruc ] @xmath107 is a basis structure in * frel * and hence also in * spek*. this category turns out to be the process category for the fragment of the toy theory containing only epistemic states of maximal knowledge . in particular , as discussed in detail in @xcite , the interaction of the basis structure @xmath107 and the permutations of @xmath108 results in three basis structures , analogous to the @xmath109- , the @xmath110- and the @xmath111-bases of a qubit . furthermore , as also discussed in @xcite4 , * spek * also contains operations which in quantum theory correspond with projection operators , while these are not included in the toy theory . indeed , compact closure of * spek * implies _ map - state duality _ _ : operations and bipartite states are in bijective correspondence . _ _ _ the process category for the full toy theory has a similar definition : the category * mspek * is a sub - category of * rel * , with the same objects as * spek*. its morphisms are all those relations generated by composition , cartesian product and relational converse from the generators of * spek * plus an additional generator : @xmath112 by construction , both * spek * and * mspek * inherit dagger symmetric monoidal structure from * rel * , with cartesian product being the monoidal product , and relational converse acting as the dagger functor . * spek * and * mspek * are both compact closed . by propositions [ spek : basisstruc ] and [ sepbsprop ] it follows that each object in these categories has a basis structure , and hence by proposition [ inducedcsprop ] they both are compact closed . the primary task of the remainder of this paper is to demonstrate that * mspek * is indeed the process category of spekkens s toy theory . we first make some preliminary observations . a _ * spek * diagram _ is any valid diagram in the graphical language introduced in section [ seccategories ] which can be formed by linking together the diagrams of the * spek * generators , as described in definition [ defspek ] . there is clearly a bijection between the possible compositions of * spek * generators , and * spek * diagrams . a * spek * diagram with @xmath19 inputs and @xmath1 outputs represents a morphism of type @xmath113 : a relation between sets @xmath114 and @xmath5 . the number of relations between two finite sets @xmath53 and @xmath115 is clearly finite itself : it is the power set of @xmath116 . thus the hom - set * frel*(a , b ) is finite . since @xmath117 we can be sure that the hom - sets of * spek * are finite . on the other hand , there is clearly an infinite number of * spek * diagrams which have @xmath19 inputs and @xmath1 inputs - we can add more and more internal loops to the diagrams . thus many diagrams represent the same morphism . however the morphisms of * spek * are , by definition , all those relations resulting from arbitrary compositions of the generating relations , i.e. any relation that corresponds to one of the infinity of * spek * diagrams . hence any proof about the form of the morphisms in * spek * is going to have to be a result about the relations corresponding to each possible * spek * diagram , even though in general many diagrams correspond to a single morphism . if we know the relation corresponding to one diagram in one of * spek * s diagram equivalence classes ( recall definition [ decdef ] ) , then it is straightforward to determine the relations corresponding to all of the other diagrams . [ bendlinelemma ] given a * spek * diagram and corresponding relation : @xmath118 then the relation corresponding to the following diagram : @xmath119 is given by , for all @xmath120 : @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the subset of @xmath123 which is related by @xmath124 to @xmath125 . every diagram equivalence class in * spek * has at least one diagram of type @xmath126 , representing a state , where we make every external line an output . relations of this type can be viewed as subsets of the set @xmath5 and it will be convenient for us to concentrate on characterising these morphisms . via lemma [ bendlinelemma ] any results on the general form of states will translate into results on the general form of all morphisms . in what follows we will therefore make no distinction between the inputs and outputs of a * spek*-diagram : a diagram with @xmath19 inputs and @xmath1 outputs will simply be referred to as a @xmath127-legged diagram . our proof will involve building up * spek * diagrams by connecting together the generating morphisms . here we show what various diagram manipulations mean in concrete terms for the corresponding relations . henceforth , remembering that we only have to consider states , we will assume that the relation corresponding to any @xmath1-legged diagram is of type @xmath126 . first we introduce some terminology . the _ composite _ of an @xmath19-tuple @xmath128 and an @xmath1-tuple @xmath129 is the @xmath127-tuple @xmath130 from @xmath131 . by the @xmath132__-remnant _ _ of an @xmath1-tuple we mean the @xmath133-tuple obtained by deleting its @xmath134 component . by the @xmath135__-remnant _ _ of an @xmath1-tuple ( where @xmath136 ) we mean the @xmath137-tuple obtained by deleting the @xmath138 component of its @xmath132-remnant ( or equivalently , deleting the @xmath139 component of its @xmath140-remnant ) . _ [ relationtree ] consider linking two diagrams , the first representing the relation @xmath141 the second representing the relation @xmath142 via a permutation @xmath143 , to form a new diagram as shown : @xmath144 the relation corresponding to this diagram is given by @xmath145 or , in less formal language , for every pair of a tuple from @xmath124 and a tuple from @xmath146 obeying the condition @xmath147 , we form composite of the @xmath134 remnant of the tuple from @xmath124 , and the @xmath138 remnant of the tuple from @xmath146 . _ _ [ relationloop ] given a diagram representing the relation @xmath141 , consider forming a new diagram by linking the @xmath134 and @xmath138 legs of the original diagram via a permutation @xmath143 . @xmath148 the relation corresponding to this diagram is given by : @xmath149 or , in less formal language , we take the @xmath135-remnant of every tuple for which @xmath150 . _ _ [ relationcapping ] consider linking two diagrams , the first representing the relation @xmath151 the second representing the relation @xmath152 via a permutation @xmath143 , to form a new diagram as shown : @xmath153 the relation corresponding to this diagram is given by : @xmath154 or , in less formal language , we take the @xmath134 remnant of every tuple for which @xmath155 . _ it is convenient to single out a particular sub - group of the @xmath108 permutation sub - group . this consists of the four permutations which do nt mix between the sets @xmath12 and @xmath13 : ( 1)(2)(3)(4 ) ( the identity ) , ( 12)(3)(4 ) , ( 1)(2)(34 ) and ( 12)(34 ) . we term these the _ phased _ permutations . all other permutations are termed _ unphased_. we single out this sub - group because the relations corresponding to * spek * diagrams generated from @xmath156 , @xmath157 , and the four phased permutations have a significantly simpler general form . we term such diagrams _ phased diagrams_. all other diagrams are termed _ unphased diagrams_. a morphism which corresponds to a phased diagram is termed a _ phased morphism _ , all other morphisms being _ unphased morphisms_. it is straightforward to see that any unphased * spek * diagram can be viewed as a collection of phased sub - diagrams linked together via unphased permutations . we refer to these sub - diagrams as _ zones_. furthermore , note that any permutation in @xmath108 can be written as a product of phased permutations and the unphased permutation ( 1)(3)(24 ) ( which we denote by @xmath158 ) . since a single phased permutation constitutes a phased zone with two legs , we can in fact view an unphased diagram as a collection of phased zones linked together by the permutation @xmath158 : @xmath159 here @xmath160 represents a phased sub - diagram and a square box represents an unphased permutations . note that such a diagram is not necessarily planar , i.e. it may involve crossing wires . we distinguish between _ external zones _ which have external legs ( e.g. @xmath161 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 in diagram [ generalunphasedeq ] ) , and _ internal zones _ all of whose legs are connected to other legs within the diagram ( e.g. @xmath164 and @xmath165 ) . to the external legs we associate an enumeration , such that legs from the same external zone appear consecutively . in the first stage of the proof we determine the general form of the relation corresponding to a _ phased diagram_. this stage itself splits into two phases : first we determine the general form of the morphisms of a new category * halfspek * , and then we show how to use this result to prove our main result in * spek*. in the second stage we draw on the results of the first to determine the general form of the relation corresponding to _ any _ * spek * diagram . we build up to the full theorem via a simplified case . for this we need a new category . [ defhalfspek ] the category * halfspek * is a subcategory of * frel*. it is defined inductively , as follows : * the objects of * halfspek * are the single - element set @xmath96 , the two element set @xmath166 , and its @xmath1-fold cartesian products @xmath167 . * the morphisms of * halfspek * are all those relations generated by composition , cartesian product and relational converse from the following generating relations : 1 . all permutations @xmath168 of the two element set . there are 2 such permutations , the identity and the operation @xmath169 which swaps the elements of @xmath170 . together they form the group @xmath171 . a relation @xmath172 defined by : @xmath173 3 . a relation @xmath174 @xcite @xmath175 is a basis structure in * frel * and hence also in * halfspek*. _ the existence of this basis structure came as a surprise to the authors . naively one might think ( as many working in the area of categorical quantum mechanics initially did ) that on a set @xmath110 in * frel * there is a single basis structure with @xmath84 given by @xmath176 for all @xmath177 . the ` basis vectors ' ( or copyable points in the language of @xcite ) are then the elements of this set . but this is not the case . there are many ` non - well - pointed ' basis structures such as @xmath175 for which the number of copyable points is less than the number of elements of the set . in related work , pavlovic has classified all basis structures in * frel * and evans et al . have identified the pairs of complementary basis structures ( in the sense of @xcite ) among these @xcite . _ next we determine the general form of the relations which constitute the morphisms of * halfspek * , to which the considerations made at the beginning of section [ aboutdiagsandstates ] also apply . we say that an element of @xmath167 has _ odd _ parity if it has an odd number of ` 1 ' elements , and that it has _ even _ parity if it has an even number of ` 1 ' elements . we will use @xmath143 to represent a particular parity , odd or even , and @xmath178 will represent the opposite parity . whether an odd - parity @xmath1-tuple has an odd or even number of ` 0 ' elements clearly depends on whether @xmath1 itself is odd or even . we could have chosen either 0 or 1 to play the role of labelling the parity ; we have chosen 1 since it will turn out to be more convenient later on . _ [ halfspekmorphisms ] the relation in * halfspek * corresponding to an @xmath1-legged * halfspek*-diagram is a subset of @xmath167 , consisting of all @xmath179 @xmath1-tuples of a certain parity , which depending on the diagram may either be even or odd : if the product of all the permutations appearing in the diagram is the identity , then parity is even , and if it is @xmath169 , then the parity is odd . _ we prove this result by induction on the number of generators @xmath180 required to construct the diagram . remember that we need only consider those diagrams whose corresponding relations are states . there is just one possible base case ( @xmath181 ) , a diagram composed purely of the generator @xmath182 for which @xmath183 : the corresponding state consists of the single 1-tuple ( 0 ) , which is indeed the unique 1-tuple of even parity . now consider a diagram @xmath184 built from @xmath180 generators with a corresponding state @xmath185 consisting all @xmath179 @xmath1-tuples of parity @xmath143 . it is easily seen that composing @xmath184 with either @xmath186 , @xmath187 or @xmath188 respectively yields a diagram whose corresponding state consists of all @xmath189 @xmath0-tuples , all @xmath190 @xmath191-tuples , and all @xmath189 @xmath0-tuples of parity @xmath143 ; and that composing with @xmath169 yields all @xmath179 @xmath1-tuples of parity @xmath178 . finally consider producing a disconnected diagram by laying the @xmath182 diagram alongside @xmath184 : it is easily seen that the corresponding state consists of @xmath190 @xmath191-tuples of parity @xmath143 . we want to apply our results on * halfspek * to the category of real interest , * spek*. to do this we first need to digress to discuss some structural features of relations . the category * rel * has another symmetric monoidal structure , namely the _ disjoint union _ or _ direct sum _ _ , denoted by @xmath192 . concretely , if we can partition a set @xmath53 into @xmath19 subsets @xmath193 , then we have @xmath194 , and recalling that a relation @xmath195 is a subset of @xmath116 , we can decompose @xmath124 into @xmath196 components of the form @xmath197 , such that @xmath198 . the relations @xmath197 are termed the _ components _ of @xmath124 _ with respect to partitions _ @xmath194 , @xmath199 . in category theoretic terms , this is _ biproduct _ _ , and there is a _ distributive law _ with respect to the cartesian product : @xmath200 for sets @xmath201 and relations @xmath202 . for @xmath194 , @xmath199 , @xmath203 and @xmath204 , and relations @xmath195 , @xmath205 and @xmath206 , we then have : @xmath207 for @xmath208 by distributivity we have : @xmath209 if for @xmath210 and @xmath211 the only non - empty components are @xmath212 and @xmath213 we call it _ parallel_. given parallel relations @xmath214 , @xmath215 and @xmath216 with respect to the partition @xmath208 , the relations : @xmath217 are all also easily seen to be parallel with respect to the same partition of @xmath53 . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we can use these insights to make a connection between * halfspek * and * spek*. the generators of the phased morphisms of * spek * , i.e. @xmath218 , @xmath219 and the phased permutations on @xmath22 , are all parallel with respect to the following partition of @xmath220 . we conclude that all phased morphisms of * spek * are also parallel with respect to this partition . we refer to the two components of a phased * spek * morphism as its @xmath12-component and @xmath13-component . [ halfspekgenarespekgen ] the @xmath12-components of the generators of the phased morphisms of * spek * are simply the generators of * halfspek * with the elements of @xmath221 re - labelled according to @xmath222 , @xmath223 . similarly the @xmath13-components of the generators of the phased morphisms of * spek * are simply the generators of * halfspek * with the elements of @xmath221 re - labelled according to @xmath224 , @xmath225 . [ spekdis2halfspekd ] a state @xmath226 corresponding to a phased * spek * diagram @xmath184 is equal to the union of two states @xmath227 and @xmath228 . @xmath229 and @xmath230 are obtained by the following procedure . form a * halfspek * diagram @xmath231 by replacing every occurence of @xmath218 and @xmath219 in @xmath184 with @xmath232 and @xmath233 , and replacing every occurence of a permutation with its @xmath12 component , re - labelled as a @xmath234 permutation as described in proposition [ halfspekgenarespekgen ] . form a second * halfspek * diagram @xmath235 in the obvious analogous fashion using @xmath13 components of permutations . @xmath229 and @xmath230 are the states corresponding to @xmath231 and @xmath235 , once again under the re - labelling described in proposition [ halfspekgenarespekgen ] . note that @xmath231 and @xmath235 will appear identical as graphs , both to each other and to @xmath184 , but the labels on some of their permutations will differ . from proposition [ spekdis2halfspekd ] and theorem [ halfspekmorphisms ] now follows : [ phasedmorphisms ] a phased morphism in * spek * of type @xmath126 is a subset of @xmath5 , consisting of @xmath9 @xmath1-tuples , divided into two classes of equal number : * the first class consists of tuples of 1s and 2s , all of either odd or even parity . * the second class consists of tuples of 3s and 4s , again all of either odd or even parity . note that we are adopting the convention that tuples of the first class have odd parity if they have an odd number of 2s , even parity if they have an even number of 2s . tuples of the first class have odd parity if they have an odd number of 4s , even parity if they have an even number of 4s . recall from section [ proofstructuresec ] that any unphased diagram can be viewed as a collection of phased zones linked together by the permutation @xmath158 , ( 1)(3)(24 ) . we also enumerated the external legs . [ externalnonphasedth ] the relation in * spek * corresponding to an @xmath1-legged * spek*-diagram with @xmath19 zones , none of which is internal , is a subset @xmath185 of @xmath5 with the following form : 1 . it contains @xmath9 @xmath1-tuples ; each entry corresponding to an external leg . all those entries corresponding to a given zone of the diagram are termed a _ zone _ of the tuple ( whether we are referring to a zone of a diagram , or zone of a tuple should be clear from the context ) . each zone of the tuple has a well - defined _ type _ ( components either all 1 or 2 , or all 3 or 4 ) and _ parity _ ( as defined for phased relations ) . 3 . a _ block _ @xmath115 is a subset of @xmath185 such that the @xmath134 zone of all @xmath1-tuples in @xmath115 has the same parity and type . the sequence of types and parities of each zone is called the _ signature _ of the block . the @xmath9 tuples of @xmath185 are partitioned into @xmath236 equally sized blocks each with a unique signature . each of the @xmath236 blocks has a different type signature - these exhaust all possible type signatures . the parity signature of a block is the following simple function of its type signature : @xmath237 here @xmath238 and @xmath239 are boolean variables representing the parity and type of the @xmath134 zone . we adopt the convention that an odd parity is represented by 0 and an even parity by 1 , whilst the type @xmath12 is represented by 0 and the type @xmath13 by 1 . the set adj(@xmath240 ) consists of the zones directly adjacent to the @xmath134 zone . @xmath241 denotes the parity of the type @xmath239 tuples in the relation corresponding to the @xmath134 zone seen as an independent phased diagram ( recall theorem [ phasedmorphisms ] ) . [ internalnonphasedth ] the relation in * spek * corresponding to an @xmath1-legged * spek*-diagram with @xmath19 zones , of which @xmath242 are external is either : * a subset , @xmath185 of @xmath5 which satisfies conditions ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) of theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] and which is partitioned into @xmath243 blocks . the signatures of these blocks are determined as follows : 1 . begin with the state corresponding to the diagram obtained by adding an external leg to every internal zone ( i.e. we will have @xmath236 blocks , each with @xmath19 zones , exhausting all possible type signatures ) . 2 . eliminate all blocks whose type signatures do not satisfy the following constraints , one for each internal zone : @xmath244 where @xmath240 is the label of the internal zone , and @xmath245 labels its adjacent zones . 3 . finally from each block delete the zones corresponding to internal zones . * _ or _ it is equal to the empty set , @xmath246 . this second possibility occurs iff the constraints in equation [ typeconstrainteq ] are inconsistent . a simple counting argument shows that within each block , every tuple with the correct type and parity signature occurs . theorems [ externalnonphasedth ] and [ internalnonphasedth ] thus completely characterise the state corresponding to any * spek*-diagram . the input data is the shape of the diagram , which determines _ adj(i ) _ , and the ` intrinsic parities ' @xmath241 of each zone . futhermore , note from theorem [ phasedmorphisms ] that , as we would expect , the general form of phased morphisms is a special case of the form described above , with @xmath247 . _ we now give an example of theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] in action . consider the following schematic**spek**-diagram ( circles simply denote zones ) , which has three zones , all external ( @xmath248 ) and five external legs ( @xmath249 ) : @xmath250 where the labels by each zone denote the intrinsic parities of that zone ( i.e. the parity of the type-12 tuples and the parity of the type-34 tuples , recall theorem [ phasedmorphisms ] ) . we conclude from theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] that the state corresponding to this diagram will consist of @xmath251 5-tuples each with 3 zones , and that these will be partitioned into @xmath252 equally sized blocks . every combination of types appears exactly once amongst these blocks , and the parity signatures are easily determined from equation [ typeparityeq ] as follows . first we note , from the intrinsic parities that @xmath253 , @xmath254 and @xmath255 . we then see that equation [ typeparityeq ] here is essentially three equations : @xmath256 from this we can establish the signatures of the eight blocks : @xmath257 the first zone will have two elements , the second zone one element and the third zone two elements . within each block every possible collection of tuples consistent with the signature will appear meaning that each block will consist of four tuples . _ _ we go on to give an example of theorem [ internalnonphasedth ] . consider the following diagram : it is identical to the diagram in the previous example except that the second zone has been internalised . @xmath258 this diagram has two external zones @xmath259 and four external legs @xmath260 ; thus we expect the corresponding state to consist of @xmath261 4-tuples , each with 2 zones , partitioned into @xmath262 blocks . we now determine the signatures of the blocks applying theorem [ internalnonphasedth ] . according to step ( 1 ) we begin with the blocks from the previous example . step ( 2 ) requires that we eliminate all blocks whose types do not satisfy the constraint @xmath263 . this leaves : @xmath264 finally we delete the second zone from each block , leaving : @xmath265 _ the proofs of theorems [ externalnonphasedth ] and [ internalnonphasedth ] proceed as inductions over the process of building up a diagram by linking together phased zones via the permutation @xmath158 . in the course of this process it is clearly possible for an external zone to become an internal zone , as its last external leg is linked to some other zone - we refer to this as _ internalising _ a zone . it turns out that internalisation of a zone complicates the inductive proof . to get around this we do the induction in two stages . in the first stage we build up a diagram identical to the one we are aiming for , _ except _ that every zone that should be internal is given a single external leg in the following fashion . suppose we need to link together two zones via a permutation , and this will result in the internalisation of the left hand zone : @xmath266 we instead link the left hand zone to the permutation via a @xmath218 morphism . the @xmath218 morphism becomes part of the original zone , and provides it with an external leg : @xmath267 in the second stage we cap off all these extra external legs with the @xmath219 morphism . since @xmath218 and @xmath219 constitute a basis structure the result is the diagram which we are aiming for : @xmath268 we now prove theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] . the proof uses an induction over the process of building up a diagram . this building up can be split into two phases : firstly we connect all of the zones which will appear in the final diagram into a ` tree - like ' structure with no closed loops , secondly we close up any loops necessary to yield the desired diagram . henceforth we will represent the signature of a tuple with @xmath19 zones as @xmath269 where @xmath238 is the parity of the @xmath134 zone , and @xmath239 is its type . again , if @xmath143 is a parity , @xmath178 indicates the opposite parity , and likewise if @xmath270 is a type , @xmath271 represents the other type . [ unphasedtreelemma ] consider an @xmath1-legged non - phased diagram @xmath161 with @xmath19 zones . suppose the corresponding state @xmath272 satisfies the conditions in theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] . now consider linking the @xmath134 leg of @xmath161 to the @xmath138 leg of an @xmath273-legged phased diagram @xmath162 ( with corresponding state @xmath274 ) , via @xmath158 , to create an @xmath275-legged diagram @xmath164 with @xmath276 external zones . we will assume that the @xmath134 leg of @xmath161 lies within its @xmath277 external zone . the state @xmath278 corresponding to @xmath164 also satisfies the conditions in theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] . by the 1-@xmath134-remnants of @xmath279 we mean the @xmath134-remnants of those tuples in @xmath279 with a 1 in the @xmath134 position . we define the 2- , 3- , and 4-@xmath134-remnants similarly . by proposition [ relationtree ] the elements of @xmath280 comprise all the possible composites of the @xmath281-@xmath134-remnants of @xmath279 and the @xmath282-@xmath138-remnants of @xmath274 , where @xmath283 . it is clear that the zone structure of the tuples of @xmath279 is inherited by these composites , and that the @xmath282-@xmath138-remnants of @xmath274 constitute an additional zone within the composites - we conventionally consider this to be the @xmath284 zone . thus the tuples of @xmath280 satisfy condition ( 2 ) . consider a block @xmath285 , with signature @xmath286 , in which for definiteness we assume that @xmath287 ( the argument runs entirely analogously if @xmath288 ) . the composites of the 1-@xmath134-remnants of @xmath115 and the @xmath289-@xmath138-remnants of @xmath274 all have the same signature , @xmath290 , and constitute a block @xmath291 . likewise the composites of the 2-@xmath134-remnants of @xmath115 and the @xmath292-@xmath138-remnants of @xmath274 constitute a block @xmath293 of signature @xmath294 @xmath295 . thus each ` parent ' block in @xmath279 gives rise to two ` progeny ' blocks in @xmath280 . by hypothesis , each block @xmath296 has a unique type signature , thus the progeny blocks derived from different parent blocks are distinct . thus @xmath280 is partitioned into @xmath297 blocks , thus satisfying condition ( 3 ) . it is also clear that if all possible type signatures are represented by the @xmath236 blocks of @xmath279 then this is also true for the @xmath297 blocks of @xmath280 , and thus that @xmath280 satisfies condition ( 1 ) . note that @xmath115 consists of @xmath298 @xmath1-tuples , and will have @xmath299 1-@xmath134-remnants and a similar number of 2-@xmath134-remnants , all of which will be distinct . similarly @xmath274 will have @xmath300 @xmath289-@xmath134-remnants and a similar number of 4-@xmath134-remnants , again all distinct . thus , both @xmath301 and @xmath302 will consist of @xmath303 tuples . this holds for all blocks @xmath285 , of which there are @xmath236 . thus in total @xmath280 consists of @xmath304 tuples , and so satisfies condition ( 4 ) . finally we turn to condition ( 5 ) . recall from above that a parent block of signature @xmath305 @xmath306 yields two progeny blocks , of signatures @xmath307 @xmath308 and @xmath309 . note that those progeny blocks for which the @xmath277 zone and its new adjacent zone have different types exhibit a parity flip on the @xmath277 zone , relative to the parent block , and on the new adjacent zone , relative to its ` intrinsic parity ' . no such flip occurs if the zones have the same type . note that the term @xmath310 is equal to 0 if @xmath311 and 1 if @xmath312 . if condition ( 2 ) holds for @xmath279 then the correct parity signature for the blocks of @xmath280 can be obtained simply by adding the term @xmath313 to the @xmath314 and @xmath315 equations ( equation [ typeparityeq ] ) . thus we conclude that condition ( 5 ) will hold for @xmath280 as well . [ unphasedlooplemma ] consider an @xmath1-legged diagram @xmath184 with @xmath19 external zones . suppose the corresponding state @xmath185 satisfies the conditions in theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] . now consider forming a new @xmath137-legged diagram @xmath316 , with corresponding state @xmath317 , by linking the @xmath134 leg of @xmath184 ( in the @xmath277 zone of @xmath184 ) , to the @xmath138 leg ( in the @xmath318 zone ) , via @xmath158 . @xmath317 also satisfies the conditions in theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] . by the @xmath319-@xmath320__-remnants _ _ of a set of tuples we mean the @xmath320-remnants of all those tuples with @xmath281 in the @xmath134 position and @xmath321 in the @xmath138 position . from proposition [ relationloop ] , @xmath317 consists of the @xmath322-@xmath320-remnants of @xmath185 . the zone structure of @xmath185 is clearly inherited by these remnants , thus the tuples of @xmath317 satisfy condition ( 2 ) . consider a block @xmath323 with signature @xmath324 @xmath325 . it is straightforward to see that only one quarter of the tuples in this block have @xmath320-remnants which are @xmath322-@xmath320-remnants . all the @xmath322-@xmath320-remnants have the same signature : @xmath326 if @xmath327 and @xmath328 @xmath329 if @xmath330 . thus each ` parent ' block in @xmath185 gives rise to one ` progeny ' block in @xmath317 , with one quarter as many tuples . the type signatures of the progeny blocks are identical to those of the parent blocks ; by hypothesis each parent block had a different type signature and so the progeny blocks deriving from different parent blocks are all distinct . thus @xmath317 is partitioned into @xmath236 blocks , each containing @xmath331 tuples , and so satisfies conditions ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) . since the type signatures of progeny and parent blocks are identical , if @xmath185 satisfies condition ( 4 ) , so will @xmath317 . we now turn to condition ( 5 ) . closing a loop between the @xmath277 and @xmath318 zones means that they now become adjacent to each other . in the previous paragraph we saw that a progeny block for which the @xmath277 and @xmath318 zones have different types exhibits a parity flip on both these zones . using similar reasoning as in the previous lemma we conclude that , if condition ( 2 ) holds for @xmath185 , the correct parity signature for the blocks of @xmath317 can be obtained simply by adding the term @xmath332 to the @xmath314 and @xmath333 equations ( equation [ typeparityeq ] ) . thus we conclude that condition ( 5 ) will hold for @xmath317 as well . we can now prove * theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] * : by induction . the base case is a diagram consisting of a single zone , and it is clear from theorem [ phasedmorphisms ] that this satisfies all the conditions . any other diagram is built up via two inductive steps : linking a new phased zone onto the existing diagram and closing up internal loops within the diagram . lemmas [ unphasedtreelemma ] and [ unphasedlooplemma ] respectively show that if a diagram satisfied the conditions prior to either of these steps , the resulting new diagram will also satisfy the conditions . we now address the issue of internalising zones . recall that this step involves capping off external legs with the @xmath219 relation . throughout this section @xmath184 will denote a diagram with no internal zones , and @xmath316 will denote the diagram obtained by internalising some of @xmath184 s zones . the corresponding states will be @xmath185 and @xmath317 . suppose we obtain @xmath316 by capping the @xmath277 external leg of @xmath184 with the @xmath219 morphism . from lemma [ relationcapping ] we conclude that @xmath317 consists of the 1-@xmath277- and 3-@xmath277-remnants of @xmath185 . suppose that in going from @xmath184 to @xmath316 we internalised the @xmath134 zone of @xmath184 . from the proposition above we deduce that each block @xmath323 for which @xmath334 will give rise to one progeny block @xmath335 with the same number of tuples as @xmath115 , while all those blocks for which @xmath336 will give rise to no progeny blocks . from this we can conclude that those blocks which do give rise to progeny blocks satisfy a constraint on their type signatures , derived from setting @xmath334 in equation [ typeparityeq ] . depending on the form of @xmath241 , and whether the number of zones adjacent to the @xmath134 is odd or even , this constraint takes one of four forms : @xmath337 @xmath338 we describe the constraints in ( [ type0eq ] ) as _ type-0 constraints _ , and those in ( [ type1eq ] ) as _ type-1 constraints_. suppose @xmath184 has @xmath1 external legs and @xmath19 external zones . suppose that in going to @xmath316 we internalise @xmath339 of its zones . _ each internalisation gives rise to a corresponding constraint . _ there are now two possibilities : 1 . not all of the constraints are consistent . in this case none of the blocks in @xmath185 satisfy all of the constraints , and none of them will give rise to progeny blocks . thus @xmath340 . all @xmath339 constraints are consistent , and of these @xmath341 are linearly independent ( this essentially means that @xmath342 of the constraints can be derived from the remaining @xmath341 ) . each independent constraint reduces the number of blocks which can give rise to progeny by one half . thus only @xmath343 of the blocks in @xmath185 give rise to progeny blocks in @xmath317 , and @xmath317 can have at most @xmath343 blocks - this maximum is attained if all of the progeny blocks are distinct . [ duplicationlemma ] the following are equivalent : 1 . the constraints are consistent and there are @xmath341 linearly independent constraints . the @xmath343 blocks in @xmath185 which can give rise to progeny blocks in @xmath317 are partitioned into @xmath344 sets , each consisting of @xmath345 blocks which all yield identical progeny blocks . thus in total there are @xmath344 distinct progeny blocks . for brevity we will describe this as @xmath346-_fold duplication _ of progeny blocks . the proof of this lemma requires a number of preliminary definitions . the _ iz - set _ is the set of zones which are internalised in going from @xmath184 to @xmath316 . the _ non - internalised adjacent zones ( niazs ) _ of an internalised zone are all the zones adjacent to it which are not themselves members of the iz - set adjacency closure set ( acs ) _ is a subset of the iz - set with the minimal number of elements such that the disjoint union of the niazs of each element contains each niaz an even number of times . _ consider the following seven zone diagram ( external legs are suppressed for clarity ) . the filled - in zones are those which we internalise . @xmath347 the iz - set is @xmath348 . the niazs for 1 are @xmath349 for 3 are @xmath350 , for 6 are @xmath351 and for 7 are @xmath352 . zones 3 , 6 and 7 together constitute an acs . zone 1 is not part of any acs . _ given a set @xmath146 of zones in @xmath184 , and a block @xmath323 , the _ @xmath146-mirror of @xmath115 _ , @xmath353 is the block with the same type signature as @xmath115 except on the zones in @xmath146 , where the types are opposite . [ dupmirrorprop ] suppose @xmath184 has an acs @xmath124 . now , so long as the blocks @xmath354 ( i.e. a block and its @xmath124-mirror ) both yield progeny blocks in @xmath317 , these progeny blocks will be identical . conversely , if any two blocks @xmath355 yield identical progeny blocks in @xmath317 , they must be mirrored with respect to some acs in @xmath184 . for two blocks in @xmath185 to give identical progeny blocks in @xmath317 they must have identical type and parity on every zone which is not internalised . note from equation [ typeparityeq ] that two blocks in @xmath185 which are type mirrored on a single zone will otherwise differ only in parities on all the zones adjacent to this zone . now consider two blocks which are type - mirrored on a set of zones @xmath124 : in the case where @xmath124 constitutes an acs all the parity flips predicted by equation [ typeparityeq ] cancel one another out on the zones which will still be visible in @xmath317 . [ mirrorconstraintprop ] suppose @xmath184 has an acs @xmath124 whose member zones have corresponding constraints which satisfy the following condition : those zones with an odd number of adjacent zones within the iz - set have type-1 constraints , while those zones with an even number of adjacent zones within the iz - set have type-0 constraints . then if a block @xmath323 satisfies the constraints and gives rise to progeny blocks in @xmath317 , so does its @xmath124-mirror . conversely , if a block @xmath323 and its mirror with respect to some acs @xmath124 in @xmath184 both give rise to progeny blocks , the constraints corresponding to the zones of @xmath124 must satisfy the condition above . if a constraint contains an even number of terms relating to zones from a set @xmath124 then given a block @xmath323 either ( i ) both @xmath115 and @xmath356 satisfy the constraint ( ii ) neither @xmath115 nor @xmath356 satisfy the constraint . conversely , if both @xmath115 and @xmath356 satisfy a constraint , it must contain an even number of terms relating to zones from @xmath124 . [ constraintlindepprop ] suppose @xmath184 has an acs @xmath124 whose member zones have corresponding constraints which satisfy the condition in the previous proposition . then the constraints together form a linearly dependent set . the converse is also true . if @xmath124 is an acs and the condition on constraints is satisfied then each term appears in the constraints an even number of times altogether . summing all the constraints together then results in all the terms cancelling out , yielding the single equation 0=0 . this is a necessary and sufficient condition for the constraints to be linearly dependent . we can now prove lemma [ duplicationlemma ] . from propositions [ dupmirrorprop ] and [ mirrorconstraintprop ] we conclude that for @xmath1-fold duplication to take place the iz - set must contain @xmath1 acss and that the constraints must satisfy the condition in proposition [ mirrorconstraintprop ] . the converse is also clearly true . every linearly dependent set amongst the constraints corresponding to the internalised zones reduces the total number of linearly independent constraints by one . from proposition [ constraintlindepprop ] we conclude that for there to be @xmath1 linearly dependent sets the iz - set must contain @xmath1 acss and that the constraints must satisfy the condition in proposition [ mirrorconstraintprop ] . the converse is also clearly true . thus we conclude that both statements in the lemma are equivalent to a third statement : the iz - set contains @xmath342 acss , and the constraints corresponding to the internalised zones satisfy the condition of proposition [ mirrorconstraintprop ] . given a diagram @xmath184 without internal zones which satisfies the conditions in theorem [ externalnonphasedth ] , a diagram @xmath316 with internal zones formed by capping off external legs of @xmath184 with @xmath219 morphisms will satisfy the conditions in theorem [ internalnonphasedth ] . * theorem [ internalnonphasedth ] * follows as a straightforward corollary . _ [ mspeknumbers ] all * mspek * morphisms of type @xmath126 are subsets of @xmath5 containing @xmath357 or @xmath8 @xmath1-tuples . _ any * mspek * diagram @xmath316 can be obtained from a * spek * diagram @xmath184 simply by capping one or more legs of @xmath184 with the morphism @xmath358 . suppose we obtain @xmath316 by capping a single external leg of @xmath184 ( the @xmath134 , say ) with @xmath358 . the state @xmath317 corresponding to @xmath316 consists of the @xmath134-remnants of @xmath185 , the state corresponding to @xmath184 . suppose @xmath184 has @xmath1 external legs : since @xmath184 is a * spek*-diagram @xmath185 consists of @xmath9 tuples . then , unless some of the @xmath134-remnants of @xmath185 are identical , @xmath317 will also consist of @xmath9 tuples , despite only having @xmath359 external legs . furthermore it is clear that either all the @xmath134-remnants of @xmath185 are distinct , or @xmath185 is partitioned into pairs , the elements of which yield identical @xmath134-remnants , meaning that the addition of each @xmath358 cap either halves the number of tuples or leaves it unchanged . we know that the epistemic states of the toy theory are subsets of the sets @xmath5 , and that the transformations on these states are relations between these sets . thus we can see immediately that the toy theory s process category must be some sub - category of * frel * , restricted to the objects @xmath5 . furthermore we know that it can not be the full sub - category restricted to these objects , since some subsets of @xmath5 clearly violate the knowledge balance principle . we will show now that ( a strong candidate for ) the process category for the toy theory in its entirety is * mspek * , while if we restrict the toy theory to states of maximal knowledge ( consistent with the knowledge balance principle ) , the process category is * spek*. the morphisms of the process category of the toy theory are closed under composition , cartesian product and relational converse . there is no feature of the toy theory which would put any restrictions on which operations could be composed , so we expect the states and transformations to be closed under composition . since the cartesian product is used by the toy theory to represent composite systems we also expect the states and transformations to be closed under cartesian product . every epistemic state corresponds to an outcome for at least one measurement ( measurements correspond to asking as many questions as possible from canonical sets , epistemic states correspond to the answers ) . recalling the discussion of measurement in section 2 , we see that given a state @xmath226 the disturbance resulting from the corresponding measurement outcome can be decomposed as @xmath360 , where @xmath361 is the relational converse of @xmath185 . thus we expect the relational converse of each state also to feature in the physical category of the theory . the toy theory state corresponding to the subset @xmath362 along with its relational converse are then easily seen to constitute a compact structure on @xmath22 . we thus have map - state duality , and it is straightforward then to show that if states are closed under relational converse , so is any morphism in the physical category . note that this point sharpens our discussion about the consistency of the toy theory , in section 2 . if the states and transformations which spekkens has derived for up to three systems , under the operations of composition , cartesian product and relational converse , yield states which violate the knowledge balance principle , then the theory as presented is inconsistent . all of the generating morphisms of * mspek * are states or transformations of the toy theory , or can be derived from them by composition , cartesian product or relational converse . the only generator for which this is less than obvious is @xmath218 . this is formed by composing spekkens s ghz - like state ( see section v of @xcite ) with the relational converse of the state @xmath363 defined in the proof above . all of the states and transformations derived by spekkens in his original paper @xcite are morphisms of * mspek*. when we restrict to states of maximal knowledge all of the states and transformations are morphisms of * spek*. by inspection of @xcite . [ spekisclosure ] * mspek * is the minimal closure under composition , cartesian product and relational converse of the states and transformations described in @xcite . * spek * is the minimal closure under these operations of the states of @xcite corresponding to maximal knowledge and the transformations which preserve them . [ spekmspekarekbp ] all states @xmath364 of * mspek * and * spek * satisfy the knowledge balance principle on the system corresponding to @xmath5 viewed as one complete system . all those of * spek * satisfy the principle maximally . recall that the knowledge balance principle requires that we can know the answer to at most half of a canonical question set . a system with @xmath1 elementary components has @xmath8 ontic states . a canonical set for such a system consists of @xmath365 questions , each answer to a question halving the number of possibilities for the ontic state . thus , we know the answer to @xmath19 such questions ( @xmath366 ) , iff our epistemic state is a subset of @xmath5 with @xmath367 elements . we conclude from theorem [ mspeknumbers ] that all states of * mspek * satisfy the knowledge balance principle on the system as a whole . we conclude that all states of * spek * correspond to the maximum knowledge about the system as a whole consistent with the knowledge balance principle . [ subsysarekbptoo ] all states @xmath364 of * mspek * and * spek * satisfy the knowledge balance principle on every subsystem of the system corresponding to @xmath5 . given an epistemic state @xmath226 of a composite system with @xmath1 elementary components , the ` marginal ' state on some subsystem is obtained from @xmath185 by deleting from the tuples of @xmath185 the components corresponding to the elementary systems which are not part of the subsystem of interest . suppose this epistemic state corresponds to a * spek * or * mspek * diagram , @xmath184 . the elementary systems which are not part of the subsystem correspond to a certain collection of external legs of @xmath184 , and , by lemma [ relationcapping ] , if we cap these with the * mspek * generator @xmath358 , the effect on the state @xmath185 is exactly as just described . composing a * spek * or * mspek * morphism with @xmath358 yields some morphism of * mspek * , which by proposition [ spekmspekarekbp ] satisfies the knowledge balance principle . from corollary [ spekisclosure ] and propositions [ spekmspekarekbp ] and [ subsysarekbptoo ] we reach two key conclusions : * the states and transformations derived by spekkens in @xcite for systems of up to three components are all consistent with the knowledge balance principle . * the process category of the toy theory must , at least , contain all of the morphisms of * mspek*. the second conclusion begs the question , could * mspek * be a strict sub - category of the process category of the toy theory i.e. could the toy theory contain operations not contained in * mspek * ? it is difficult to answer this question , since , as discussed at the end of section 2 it is not clear what the rigorous definition of the toy theory is , or whether there is an unambiguous way to extend it beyond three systems . certainly , * mspek * is the process category of a theory which coincides with spekkens s theory up to the case of three qubits , and whose states and transformations are bound to satisfy the three rules of section 2 ( the first two rules by propositions [ spekmspekarekbp ] and [ subsysarekbptoo ] , and the third simply by its definition as the closure under composition of a set of generators ) . it is in this sense that we earlier remarked that * mspek * is a strong candidate for the process category of the toy theory . we achieved our goal stated in the abstract , that is , to provide a rigorous mathematical description of spekkens toy theory , which proves its consistency . this was established both in terms of generators for a dagger symmetric monoidal subcategory of * frel * , consisting of symmetries for the elementary system and a basis structure ( and nothing more ! ) , as well as in terms of an explicit description of these relations as in theorems [ internalnonphasedth ] , [ externalnonphasedth ] and [ mspeknumbers ] . this description meanwhile already has proved to be of great use , for example , in pinpointing what the essential structural difference is between the toy theory and the relevant fragment of quantum theory . in joint work with spekkens in @xcite we showed that the key difference between the toy theory and relevant fragment of quantum theory is the _ phase group _ _ , a group that by pure abstract nonsense can be attributed to each basis structure . in the case of the toy theory this phase group is @xmath368 while in the case of the relevant fragment of quantum theory it is @xmath369 . one can then show that it is this difference that causes the toy theory to be local , while the relevant fragment of quantum theory is non - local . _ _ _ in this context , one may wonder wether there is a general categorical construction which would turn a ` local theory ' like * spek * into a non - local one . we also expect that the construction in this paper can be fairly straightforwardly extended beyond qubit theories , for example to qutrits @xcite . s. abramsky ( 2009 ) _ no - cloning in categorical quantum mechanics__. in : semantic techniques for quantum computation , i. mackie and s. gay ( eds ) , pages 128 , cambridge university press . _ s. abramsky and b. coecke ( 2004 ) _ a categorical semantics of quantum protocols__. in : proceedings of 19th ieee conference on logic in computer science , pages 415425 . ieee press . arxiv : quant - ph/0402130 . revised version ( 2009 ) : _ categorical quantum mechanics__. in : handbook of quantum logic and quantum structures , k. engesser , d. m. gabbay and d. lehmann ( eds ) , pages 261323 . _ _ _ _ _ b. coecke and r. duncan ( 2008 ) _ interacting quantum observables__. in : proceedings of the 35th international colloquium on automata , languages and programming ( icalp ) , pages 298310 , lecture notes in computer science 5126 , springer - verlag . extended version ( 2011 ) : _ interacting quantum observables : categorical algebra and diagrammatics__. new journal of physics * 13 * , 043016 . arxiv:0906.4725 _ _ _ _ _ _ b. coecke and e. o. paquette ( 2011 ) _ categories for the practicing physicist__. in : new structures for physics , b. coecke ( ed ) , pages 167271 . lecture notes in physics , springer - verlag . _ b. coecke and d. pavlovic ( 2007 ) _ quantum measurements without sums__. in : mathematics of quantum computing and technology , g. chen , l. kauffman and s. lamonaco ( eds ) , pages 567604 . taylor and francis . arxiv : quant - ph/0608035 . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: by studying variable stars in the small magellanic cloud ( smc ) , henrietta leavitt discovered a linear relation between the pulsation period and magnitudes of @xmath2 cepheids , in the sense of that the brightest cepheids have longer periods @xcite . this correlation , commonly called period - luminosity ( pl ) relation , was lately renamed as the leavitt law ( ll ) in honor to its discoverer @xcite . this linear statistical correlation is a cornerstone in the measurement of the extragalactic distances using stellar standard candles . however , in order to obtain an accurate calibration of this relation , it is important to establish the effects of non - linearities , metallicity and companions on it , as it is mentioned by @xcite ; as well as other effects such as cepheids showing the hertzsprung progression and cepheids exhibiting changes in period . a brief literature review of these issues is presented below . * i ) the non - linearity effect : * the first works in this direction began twenty five years after the discovery by henrietta leavitt . in a study of the shape of the pl relation of nearby galaxies , kukarkin found that this relation has a break around @xmath3 d ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . three decades later , sandage & tammann ( 1968 , 1969 ) found evidence of curvature in the pl relation , and afterward , @xcite confirmed the break of the pl relation in @xmath3 d. @xcite confirmed again this result based on the statistical @xmath4-test . in the last years , the following studies have confirmed the non - linearity of the ll without proposing an explanation for it : the testimator method @xcite , the approaches of linear regression residuals and additive models @xcite , the multi - phase pl relations @xcite and the multiple least - squares regression @xcite . * ii ) the metallicity effect : * by using non - linear convective pulsating models , @xcite and @xcite studied synthetic multiband pl relations of populations of cepheids of different chemical compositions , uniformly distributed over the instability strip . the masses of these stars follow the law @xmath5 , and are distributed in the range of @xmath6 @xmath7 . for a wide range of log @xmath8 , those authors found clear evidence that the optical ll is better represented by a quadratic relationship than by a linear one , showing a dependence with the metallicity and the intrinsic width of the instability strip . for ir bands they showed that the ll is better fitted by a linear function showing a slightly dependence on the metallicity . @xcite and @xcite found strong evidence in favor of the universality of the optical pl relation , in the metallicity range from @xmath9 dex to @xmath10 dex . @xcite and @xcite found that the slopes of the pl relations in _ vi@xmath11 _ do not change significantly between the environments of the milky way and the lmc . * iii ) the companion effects : * physically bound companions to cepheids are difficult to detect at distances of tens of kpc . to produce a detectable effect on the light curve , the eclipses should be deep enough and a significant number of points associated with the eclipses should be observed . the first condition is reached with an adequate combination of radius , luminosity and effective temperature of the primary and secondary stars , jointly with the appropriate inclination and mass ratio of the system . these eclipsing systems exhibit light curves similar to those of cepheids , showing besides dispersed points below them , which are a signal of the eclipses ( @xcite , fig . 7 ) . when the cepheid light curve is subtracted , it emerges a typical eclipsing signal ( soszyski et al . 2008 , fig . @xcite claim to detect a few cepheids in eclipsing systems in the galactic bulge and the magellanic clouds , using a random forest supervised algorithm over the macho catalog of variable stars . however , due to these variables do not show a clear period of eclipses , it is difficult to affirm that they are binaries . it is very likely that these stars are blended with near neighbors . @xcite reported few magellanic clouds cepheids that could be blended , and also others that could be members of binary systems . detection of cepheid systems whose light curves exhibit eclipsing variations is too important : if the cepheid is a member of a physical binary system , it is possible to determine dynamical masses , radii and distance with a very high accuracy . until now , spectroscopic studies of double - lined eclipsing binary systems in the lmc have been made by the optical gravitational lensing experiment ( ogle ) in the systems : ogle - lmc - cep-@xmath12 @xcite , ogle - lmc - cep-@xmath13 @xcite , ogle - lmc - cep-@xmath14 @xcite , ogle - lmc - cep-@xmath15 @xcite and ogle - lmc@xmath16 ( @xcite , @xcite ) a system detected in the ogle gaia south ecliptic pole field . * iv ) the hertzsprung progression effect : * inspecting light curves of @xmath17 cepheids , @xcite found a relation between the position of a bump feature in the light curve and the pulsation period . later studies confirmed that this bump feature is present in the light and radial curves of fundamental - mode classical cepheids whose periods are in the range of @xmath18 d @xcite . this feature is present in the descending branch for pulsations in the range of @xmath19 d. for longer periods , this feature is observed in the ascending branch and disappears for periods longer than @xmath20 d ( @xcite , @xcite ) . the amplitude bump grows when the period increases , reaching its maximum value for periods near to the maximum light around @xmath21 d. for longer periods , the amplitude bump decreases until it vanishes @xcite . + there are two models that explain some of the properties of the observed bump feature . the first one , called the echo mechanism , proposes radial - pressure waves generated in the he ii ionization region @xcite . the traveling inward wave is reflected in the core and reaches the surface one period later , leading to the formation of the bump @xcite . however , this model has two points to solve : the contradiction with the acoustic - ray formalism ( @xcite ; aikawa & whitney 1984 , 1985 ) and the difficulty of predicting adequately the christy wave velocity near to the stellar surface ( @xcite , @xcite ) . the second model , known as the resonance mechanism , proposes that the feature bump arises from a resonance between the fundamental mode and the second overtone @xcite . by using numerical simulations @xcite studied the nonlinear saturation of the acoustic modes excited by the @xmath22mechanism . they found that this @xmath23:@xmath24 resonance causes that the bump appears in the ascending branch for @xmath25 . * v ) the changing period effect : * the long - term observations detect several thousand oscillation cycles for short period cepheids . this allows to determine , with very high accuracy , changing periods . for the long period cepheids , it is no possible to reach this accuracy , because the data have in the worse cases of sampling , tens of cycles . there are three scenarios explaining different characteristics of the period change rates . the first one proposes that the evolutionary changes on the stellar structure of cepheids crossing the instability strip are responsible of the period change rates ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the second one proposes that the presence of magnetic fields is a possible explanation for the random changing periods exhibited by some cepheids . the last one suggests that the amplitude and phase variations of cepheids are caused by an analogous to the blazhko effect , exhibited by rr lyr stars @xcite . @xcite reported a few cepheids that could be exhibit this blazhko effect , being the number of these cepheids larger in the lmc than in the smc . + the period changes should produce a shift of the phase in the light curve , and as a consequence , a higher scatter in the light curve , detectable on years of observations . a study of @xmath26 lmc cepheids found period changes in @xmath27 of the fundamental mode , and in @xmath28 of the first overtone ( @xcite , table 3 ) . a visual inspection of the light curves of these ogle cepheids shows , for the most of them , a strong scatter of the points as a consequence of the shift phase . + since there are a few studies about magnetic fields on cool radial pulsating stars , it is not clear if the nature of these magnetic fields are fossil or are produced as a consequence of the stellar pulsation @xcite . based on a solar - like magneto - convective cycle , @xcite could explain the observed period change rates of two short period cepheids : polaris and v473 lyr . as the existence of local magnetic fields on the surface of late - type stars causes spots @xcite , @xcite proposed that convective hot spots can be a possible explanation to the random changes in the pulsation period detected in the single cepheid observed by the kepler mission , v1154 cyg . + the first detection of magnetic fields in variable stars was made on rr lyr @xcite . measurements of magnetic fields for cepheid stars began later on . in particular , for @xmath29 car and @xmath30 cyg there were reported values of @xmath31 g @xcite , and from @xmath32 g to @xmath33 g ( @xcite ; @xcite ) , respectively . the spectropolarimetric works over the bright bump cepheid @xmath34 aql ( @xmath35 , @xmath36 d ) reported controversial results . while @xcite and @xcite measured periodic variations of the longitudinal magnetic field with an amplitude of tens of gauss , @xcite found a non - significant detection of the longitudinal magnetic field at a level of @xmath3 g. + in order to establish whether or not the effects previously described are influential on the ll , we make a study using statistical techniques . we start - off , in the second section , with a brief description of the lmc ll and the ogle - ii and ogle - iv cepheid data . the third section is dedicated to review the statistical theory of the linear regression analysis , relevant for this work . the fourth section presents the results of applying statistical models in order to obtain optical ll of the lmc and smc . finally , our main conclusions are given in the fifth section . ogle - ii and ogle - iv observations of cepheid variables of the lmc and smc galaxies were collected with the @xmath37-m warsaw telescope , at las campanas observatory , chile ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . while ogle - ii fundamental mode cepheid catalogs contain 771 and 1319 stars for the lmc and smc , respectively , ogle - iv has a nearly complete collection ( 2429 and 2739 for the lmc and smc , respectively ) , covering practically the whole magellanic system area with the time baseline , a little more than five years . @xcite . the slope and zero point of the lmc ll in optical _ vi_-bands were computed by @xcite using ordinary least - squares ( ols ) regression , on ogle - ii fundamental - mode cepheids . points deviating by more than @xmath38 ( outliers ) were removed by applying the sigma - clipping algorithm @xcite . udalski realized that standard deviation of residuals of the lmc data was almost two times smaller than that of the smc . this greater dispersion is caused mainly by the spatial distribution of cepheids in the smc bar , whose thickness is placed along the line - of - sight with a typical depth of @xmath39 mag @xcite . these facts , and the manner in which the ll of the lmc is much better populated for periods longer than @xmath40 d , suggested udalski to adopt as the universal slope value the one obtained for the lmc , notwithstanding that the number of cepheids in the smc was around twice that of lmc . for ogle - iv lmc cepheids the slope and zero point of the ll were determined in analogous approach , but the smc slope was obtained independently , using only cepheids of this galaxy @xcite . + with the aim to establish a possible statistical cause of the non - linearity of the ll , we use the dereddened sample of ogle - ii . fundamental mode cepheids belonging to the lmc and smc galaxies reported by @xcite and @xcite , as well as the nearly complete collection of ogle - iv magellanic clouds cepheids reported by @xcite . in this section we summarize the topics of the statistical theory of linear regression analysis , most relevant to this paper . we start explaining what the outliers and influential points are . then , we present the theory of ordinary least square method and the conditions to apply it . next , we describe the statistics tools to identify influential points . then , we present the specification test , which verifies if all variables involved in a statistical problem are adequately included and represented by a proposed model . following , we present the structural break test , which looks for unstable parameters . finally , we present the robust @xmath0-regression that allows to do a linear regression of data with no - gaussian error distribution . the @xmath1-regression is applied in order to get a high breakdown point and fit the models in presence of influential points that are outliers at the same time . an extended statistical discussion of these topics can be found in @xcite . some applications in the astronomy context can be found in @xcite . the most common method to estimate parameters in a linear regression model is ols , based on the gauss - markov theorem . the model is ( in matrix notation ) : @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the dependent variable vector , @xmath43 is the independent variables matrix , @xmath44 is the parameters vector and @xmath45 is the errors vector . this theorem states that the ols estimators are the best linear unbiased estimators if the expected value of the errors vector is zero ( @xmath46 ) , the variance of the errors is constant ( @xmath47 ) and the errors are uncorrelated . it can be shown @xcite that ols estimators ( @xmath48 ) are obtained from : @xmath49 notice that : @xmath50 is the nule vector , @xmath51 the identity matrix and @xmath52 indicates @xmath53 matrix is transposed . once the model is fitted the adequacy must be checked . that is : i ) the error term @xmath45 has a constant variance @xmath54 . ii ) the errors are uncorrelated . these items are the gauss - markov theorem assumptions . iii ) the errors are normally distributed . this is very important for making hypothesis testing and estimating confidence intervals . iv ) all the observations have approximately the same weight . it refers to the fact that it is not desirable that model estimators depend more on few observations than on the majority of them . this could happen if some observations , called influential points , have a disproportional impact in the ols estimations . v ) there is no specification problems in the model and there is not a structural break , i.e. the parameters are stable . it refers to the correct functional form of the model . after fitting the model , a residual analysis is made to verify its adequacy . since the residuals are the difference between the original observed values and their fits , they also measure the variability of the dependent variable which is not explained by the model . therefore , any violations to the assumptions can be detected by analyzing model residuals . mainly the analysis on residuals is looking for evidence of : i ) errors come from a distribution with heavier tails than normal . large departures from normality in the error distribution mean that the _ f- _ and _ t- _ test are not longer valid as well as the confidence interval estimations . ii ) heteroskedasticity , meaning that the errors do not have constant variance . iii ) influential points . iv ) specification problems . v ) autocorrelated errors . in this study it is not necessary to check if errors are correlated because the data are not time dependent , i.e. they come from a cross - section in the statistical sense . + for checking the error distribution a normal probability quantil - quantil ( @xmath55 ) plot is used . if all the residuals lie along a line , it means that they come from a normal distribution . for more details see @xcite . this plot shows if the distribution has heavier or lighter tails or if it is skewed compared to the normal distribution . for checking the assumption that errors have constant variance ( homoskedasticity ) the white s test @xcite is used in the following equation : @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the residual from the linear regression defined as : @xmath58 this test does not make the assumption that errors come from a normal distribution . its null hypothesis is that @xmath59 for all @xmath60 . since the pl relation can be modeled as a simple linear regression , the test uses the auxiliary model given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the error term and @xmath63 is the number of stars . it can be shown that white s statistic @xmath64 is asymptotic distributed as @xmath65 with g-1 degrees of freedom , where @xmath63 is the number of observations and @xmath66 is the regression coefficient of determination of the equation ( [ eq5 ] ) . because the auxiliary model ( equation [ eq5 ] ) has three parameters ( @xmath67 ) the @xmath65 has @xmath23 degrees of freedom . + outliers are points that have an unusual behavior . let us imagine a scatter plot , outliers are data points that unusually are located out of the pattern or far from the data cloud . on the other hand , influential points are those data that have a disproportional impact on ols estimators ( slope and zero point ) . as a result , the model estimators depend more on them than on the majority of data . let us imagine the scatter plot again , a regression line is fitted with all points . then we delete a point and fit the regression line once more . if the regression line obtained after removing the point changes a lot ; the deleted observation is an influential point . what is a lot ? statistics helps us in this decision , as we shall describe later . now , let us imagine the scatter diagram with a far point from the cloud of data points , but located along the regression line . if we delete it , the regression line will not change . therefore , the point is an outlier but not an influential point , because it affects the @xmath68 coefficient and the ols estimator standard errors , but not the ols regression estimators . on the contrary , if the outlier affects the regression coefficient estimators it is also an influential point . finally , let us imagine that the point is not an outlier ; however , after deleting it , the new regression fitted - line is very different from the obtained with it . this means that it is an influential point . in general , influential points can or can not be outliers . + * detection of influential points : * in order to look for influential points cook s distance , _ dffits , dfbetas , covratio _ statistics are commonly used @xcite . the first of them is defined as follows : @xmath69 basically , it measures the square distance between the ols @xmath44 estimate , based on all observations and ols @xmath70 estimate obtained after deleting the @xmath71 observation , where @xmath72 in equation ( [ eq6 ] ) is the number of parameters in equation ( [ eq3 ] ) , i.e. the number of independent variables plus the zero point . moreover , @xmath73 is an estimate of the mean square error , defined as follows : @xmath74 observations with large cook s distance affect ols estimates of @xmath44 . to know what is a large cook s distance , @xmath75 is compared to the @xmath76 distribution @xcite . if the @xmath71 observation has a @xmath77 , it is considered an influential point . _ dffits _ measures how large is the influence of the @xmath71 observation on its own estimated @xmath78 . in other words , it shows how many standard deviations @xmath78 change due to delete the @xmath71 observation . it is defined as follows : @xmath79 @xmath80 and @xmath81 are the fitted values and the standard deviation respectively , obtained without the @xmath71 observation . the term @xmath82 is the @xmath71 diagonal element of the matrix @xmath83 that is defined as follows : @xmath84 the term @xmath85 is the amount of leverage that the @xmath71 observation has on the @xmath86 fitted value . a point is considerate influential when @xmath87 . for complementary explanations and references about _ dffits _ and the @xmath88 matrix see @xcite and @xcite . other statistics that detects influential points is _ dfbetas_. it indicates how much effect has the @xmath71 observation on each @xmath89 , measured in standard deviation units . in order to apply it , the coefficient estimators of @xmath89 obtained using all observations are compared with the coefficient estimators computed excluding the @xmath71 observation ( @xmath90 ) . as a result , a measure for each @xmath89 is obtained . the _ dfbetas _ statistics is defined as follows : @xmath91 where @xmath92 , so that @xmath93 is the @xmath86 diagonal element of the matrix @xmath94 and @xmath95 is the square root of the regression mean square error fitted without the @xmath71 observation . an observation is considered an influential point if @xmath96 . + the last statistics used to detect influential points is _ covratio _ , that measures how the covariance matrix is affected by the @xmath71 observation . it compares the generalized variance of the parameters estimators , obtained without the @xmath71 observation , with that obtained using all observations . + the variance - covariance matrix of parameters estimators with all observations is : @xmath97 the generalized variance is the determinant of the equation ( [ eq11 ] ) : @xmath98 given this , _ covratio _ is defined as follows : @xmath99 the @xmath71 observation is considered influential if its _ covratio _ lies out of the following interval @xmath100 , where @xmath72 is the number of parameters in the equation ( [ eq3 ] ) and @xmath63 is the total number of observations . the reported ll in this work are obtained by rejecting from the sample the influential points , and cepheids exhibiting the communalities , explained later . however , two questions arise that require detailed answers : why is it important to identify these influential points and give them an statistical treatment ? why is it necessary to apply robust techniques to make a linear regression instead of applying a well - known algorithm as sigma - clipping ? in the next paragraphs , we answer these questions , illustrating the associated statistical problem . outliers are observations with anomalous behavior . when they are caused by human errors or instrumental failures , they can be recognized and excluded from the analysis . moreover , they can be rejected from the analysis only if there are strong non - statistical reasons that support such decision . in this work it is possible to reject them based on astronomical reasons . however , the usual practice of deleting outliers without making a further analysis looking for reasons that could explain their behavior , could imply serious consequences in the estimators precision , because they are adjusted artificially @xcite . as a result , when there are not astronomical reasons that support excluding those points and/or there are influential points , robust estimation methods are needed . to validate that there is no evidence of specification errors in the model , we use tests to look if a non - linear combination of the fitted values are significant to explain the response variable . one of them is the ramsey s test given by the equations ( [ eq15 ] ) to ( [ eq17 ] ) @xcite . the other one , is a variant proposed by godfrey and orme that uses only the model given by equation ( [ eq15 ] ) @xcite . these auxiliary models and their respectively hypotheses used in this work are the following : @xmath101 the null and alternative hypothesis are @xmath102 and @xmath103 @xmath104 the null and alternative hypothesis are @xmath105 and @xmath106 @xmath107 the null and alternative hypothesis are @xmath108 and @xmath109 : at least one @xmath110 ; @xmath111 . + if any of these tests are significant because there is evidence to reject the null hypothesis @xmath112 , then there is enough evidence of misspecification . in fact , it means that a non - linear combination of the fitted values are significant to explain the variability in the dependent variable , i.e the functional form is incorrect . + to verify if there are structural breaks , dummy variables are used . before explaining what a dummy variable is , it is necessary to give a brief explanation about qualitative variables . qualitative or categorical variables are those that do not have a natural scale of measurement . in this study two categorical variables are used . the first variable indicates which data set the observation belongs to when data are divided in two sets , to make structural tests to the models . this variable has two categories : data set @xmath24 and data set @xmath23 . the second variable is the galaxy name where the cepheid is located , which also has two categories : lmc and smc . + dummy variables are used to indicate which category from a qualitative variable the observations belong to . each dummy variable takes two possible values : @xmath24 if the observation belongs to the category that the dummy variable is representing , and @xmath113 if not . if a qualitative variable has @xmath114 categories , it can be represented by @xmath114 dummy variables , one for each category . however , only @xmath115 dummy variables are used in the regression model . besides , it does not matter which @xmath115 dummy variables are used since @xmath116 matrix is the same , independently of which dummy variable is taken out to fit the model . in fact , dummy variables representing the categories of a qualitative variable are linked between each other because when one of them takes a value of @xmath24 for an observation , the others take @xmath113 for the same observation . therefore , when all the @xmath115 dummy variables in the model take a value of @xmath113 , they are representing the dummy variable that is no present in the model . for more details see @xcite . + the process of verifying the existence of structural breaks is made as follows : the data are divided in two data sets by dummy variables . then , a model that includes the dummy variables is estimated to verify if the estimated parameters associated with dummies are significant or not . if they are significant , the parameters are unstable , thus there are structural breaks . + to contrast hypothesis the @xmath117value is used . it means the lowest level of significance that leads to reject null hypothesis when it is true . therefore , if @xmath117value is greater than the significance level , there is not enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis . on the contrary , if the @xmath117value is less than or equal to the significance level there is enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis and accept the alternative one , which means the test is significant . sometimes ols assumptions are not accomplished ; for example , errors have a distribution with heavier tails than normal distribution and/or there are influential points . an alternative to fit a linear model in these kinds of scenarios is a robust regression , in which the residuals can be defined as follows : @xmath118 it is convenient to scale the residuals by using median absolute deviation : @xmath119 therefore the scaled residuals @xmath120 can be expressed as follows : @xmath121 if scaled residuals are not dependent between them , and all of them have the same distribution @xmath122 , the maximum likelihood @xmath44 estimators are those that maximize the likelihood function : @xmath123 in @xcite is shown that this condition is equivalent to minimize the equation ( [ eq22 ] ) . therefore , a class of robust estimator that minimizes this equation is called @xmath0-estimator and the regression based on it is called @xmath0-regression . @xmath0 comes from maximum - likelihood since function @xmath124 is related to equation ( [ eq21 ] ) for a proper choice of the error distribution . besides , @xmath124 weights the scaled residuals @xmath62 in the sum : @xmath125 there are more than one suggestion for @xmath124 in the literature , the function used in this work is the tukey s bi - square , with parameter equal to @xmath126 @xcite . for further information about this function and other choices see @xcite . to minimize the equation ( [ eq22 ] ) the first partial derivative of @xmath124 must be calculated : @xmath127 as a result , the following equation is obtained : @xmath128 @xmath72 is the number of parameters in the model . multiplying the equation ( [ eq24 ] ) by @xmath129 , it is obtained : @xmath130 where @xmath131 @xmath132 @xmath133 , otherwise is @xmath24 . + the determination of @xmath0-estimator is an iterative process , thus , the @xmath0-estimator for @xmath44 is : @xmath134 this iterative process stops when a convergence criteria is reached , i.e. when the estimators change less than a preselected amount in the @xmath135 iteration . notice that the equation ( [ eq27 ] ) is the weighted least square estimator where @xmath136 is a diagonal @xmath137 matrix of weights whose elements are @xmath138 . see @xcite and @xcite for a wider discussion . in the context of @xmath0-regression it is important to check that there are no bad influential points , i.e. observations that are outliers in the * x * space and influential points at the same time . in this scenario the @xmath1-estimator @xcite should be used because it has a high breakdown point ( bdp ) . in a finite - sample the bdp is the smallest fraction of contaminated data causing a divergence of the estimator from the value that it would take if data were not contaminated @xcite . + the @xmath1-estimator combines the asymptotic efficiency of @xmath0-estimator with the high bdp estimators such as @xmath139estimators and least treammed squares . @xmath1-regression is obtained in three steps . first , a high bdp parameter estimators model is calculated to compute the residuals of the model . second , based on residual computed in the previous step , a @xmath0-estimate of scale with high bdp is calculated . finally , the model parameters are estimated using @xmath0-estimators and the scale estimation computed in the previous step . + neither normal errors nor homoskedasticity are assumptions in @xmath0-regression and @xmath1-regression . however , these regressions assume that errors are uncorrelated , which is not an issue when data come from a cross - section , meaning that data are not time dependent . + robust regressions are based on asymptotic results . this means they could lead to wrong results when they are used with small data sets . @xcite say that small to moderate sample size could be less than @xmath140 points . in our case , the smallest data set has about @xmath141 observations . hence , we have enough data to apply these techniques without problems . in particular , ogle - iv has around two and three times of observations for the smc and the lmc than ogle - ii , respectively . the statistical theory explained previously are applied for each one of the lmc and smc galaxies . the following models are fitted by ols : @xmath142 @xmath143 @xmath144 @xmath145 is @xmath146 and @xmath8 is the pulsation period of a cepheid . in general , these models have violations to the ols assumptions , as it will be shown below . influential points are data that truly affect the linear regression results , although they can or can not be outliers . it is very important that the studies of the ll make an appropriate treatment of those points . deleting a subset of influential points does not prevent the appearance of new influential points , as will be shown below . + the sigma - clipping algorithm is an iterative procedure commonly used in astronomy in order to reject the outliers in ols regression . however , to apply the ols regression its assumptions must be accomplished . in order to investigate if the ogle - ii data do not fulfill these conditions , we make an experiment in v - band using the whole sample of @xmath147 ogle - ii lmc fundamental mode cepheids . we apply the sigma - clipping algorithm using five iterations and an optimum threshold of @xmath148 . these values are the same used in the studies of the ll made by @xcite and @xcite . simultaneously , we apply the white s test to check if the assumption of homoskedasticity is fulfilled . + before the first sigma - clipping iteration , the white s test finds enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis of homoskedasticity with a _ _ p-__value of @xmath149 at @xmath150 of significance . a number of @xmath151 influential points are detected using some of the cook s distance , _ dffits , dfbetas , _ and _ covratio_. on the other hand , by applying the criteria of the sigma - clipping algorithm , @xmath152 points are rejected in the first iteration , not all of them identified as influential points . during second iteration , the white s test finds again enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis of homoskedasticity with a _ _ p-__value of @xmath153 at @xmath150 of significance and @xmath154 influential points are identified . by using sigma - clipping algorithm @xmath155 points are rejected . in the following three iterations influential points are detected again . taking into account these facts , we notice that the main problems of applying the sigma - clipping algorithm in the context of the ll are : \i ) ols estimators obtained by using this procedure are not adequate since their precision are adjusted artificially @xcite . \ii ) in the two initial iterations , the models have no a constant error variance , i.e. , they show heteroskedasticity . in the remaining iterations , the models show homoskedasticity , as a result of deleting points using the sigma - clipping criterium . \iii ) the residuals in each iteration have distributions with heavier tails than the normal distribution . \iv ) influential points are detected on each iteration . _ summarizing , rejecting outliers using the sigma - clipping algorithm is not adequate in this case , since there are violations of ols assumptions . without strong reasons to support the rejection of points , this method is invalid in the ll linear regression context . _ as we mentioned before , models ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) have violations to the ols assumptions : for cepheids belonging to the lmc galaxy , white s test ( explained in 3.1 ) finds enough evidence of heteroskedasticity with @xmath117values of @xmath149 and @xmath156 for models ( [ eq28 ] ) and ( [ eq29 ] ) at @xmath157 of significance . on the contrary , for model ( [ eq30 ] ) , white s test does not find enough evidence to reject its null hypothesis because of its @xmath117value of @xmath158 , that is greater than the same fixed level of significance . for cepheids belonging to the smc galaxy , white s test does not find enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis of homoskedasticity with @xmath117values of @xmath159 , @xmath160 and @xmath161 for models ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) respectively , at @xmath150 of significance . + another problem is the influential points that are found in all models in both galaxies . as we have mentioned above , this fact makes necessary to search for communalities in the influential points to understand the causes of this behavior . to do that , the @xmath162-band light curves of all cepheids in the lmc and smc are visually inspected many times . as a result , we identify two main morphological characteristics in them : the dispersion and the shape . using these communalities we perform a bi - dimensional classification of the cepheids in some of the following groups : light curves with small ( 1 ) , moderate ( 2 ) , or large ( 3 ) dispersion . and light curves whose morphological shapes are sinusoidal - like ( a ) , sawtooth - like ( b ) or exhibit bumps , i.e. showing the hertzsprung progression ( c ) . dispersion of light curves of cepheids classified as 2 and 3 seem to be caused in several cases by blending , since a visual inspection of the finding charts of these cepheids , shows neighbors near to the stars . representative examples of this classification are shown in figure [ fig1 ] . the bi - dimensional classification of all ogle - ii lmc and smc fundamental mode cepheids is given in table [ tab1 ] . the last column reports our bi - dimensional classification : morphological shape is given by a , b or c , and the grade of dispersion is measured by the discrete scale : @xmath24 , @xmath23 or @xmath163 , the last one being the corresponding to light curves with larger dispersion . an appended i letter indicates that this star is detected as influential point by at least one of the dffits , dfbetas or covratio statistics , computed from @xmath164 data . in table [ tab0 ] , the number of cepheids belonging to each sub - class is reported . .**morphological classification of ogle - ii cepheids * * [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] when the influential points are correlated with our bi - dimensional classification , an interesting fact arises : around one third of the lmc cepheids and one fifth of the smc cepheids , classified with a grade of dispersion moderate and large are influential points . taking this fact into account , and in order to avoid violations of ols assumptions , we propose the following hypothesis : if cepheids with light curves of moderate and large dispersion , exhibiting characteristics suggesting blending , bumps , eclipses and period changes , are excluded from the ols linear regression , and the remaining data do not present violations of ols assumptions , it is possible to affirm that a cause of non - linearities of the ll is due to the inclusion of a fraction of these stars , that despite to be cepheids are influential points . + for testing this hypothesis , we fit the models given by equations ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) by ols using only cepheids with small dispersion . the results confirm the hypothesis , as it will be described below . for this reason , we consider appropriate to summarize here the communalities of these influential cepheids : \i ) the scatter exhibited by light curves of some cepheids classified as a2 or a3 can be associated with phase shifts , suggesting changes in the pulsational period . this effect produces a dispersion of the mean magnitudes , which moves the locus cepheid in the pl relation . \ii ) the b2 light curves exhibit a behavior that could be explained by period changes or blending effects . the dispersion of these light curves do not allow to directly establish which of these effects could be present in these types of cepheids . in this work it is not clear which of them is more likely to be the best explanation . however , this point is out of the scope of this paper . this interesting fact could be investigated in more detail in future works . a small fraction of the light curves classified as b3 have characteristics suggesting eclipses or blending . in the first case , the main effect of the companion on the pl relation is to move the cepheid locus . due to that , the total mean brightness out - of - eclipse includes the companion contribution , adding scatter in some cases up to @xmath165 mag . , as it was reported by @xcite and @xcite . the second case is more probable to occur , since a visual inspection of the finding charts of the b3 cepheids , shows that most of them are blended . \iii ) light curves classified as c1 or c2 are bump cepheids , i.e. they exhibit the hertzsprung progression . the amplitude bump affects the cepheid mean magnitude . this effect is stronger for periods near to the maximum light , shifting the cepheid position in the pl relation . in order to use the ols regression , the white s test is applied . this test does not find enough evidence to reject its null hypothesis of homoskedasticity , with a @xmath150 of significance , since the @xmath117values associated with each model test are @xmath166 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 for the lmc , and @xmath169 , @xmath170 and @xmath171 for the smc , respectively . however , two issues are noted : the first one is again the presence of influential points . the second fact is that the residual distributions for @xmath164 lmc data ( and only for the @xmath11 smc data ) have heavier tails with respect to the normal distribution . + since there is neither an astronomical nor statistical reason to delete those influential points or a fraction of them , a new approach to estimate the parameters given in the models ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) is needed instead of ols . besides , if these influential points were deleted , new ones may appear . + we fit the models by using the @xmath0-regression . the @xmath172 function used is the bi - square . since no evidence of bad influential points is found , we check each model beginning with the slope test , which is a robust version equivalent to the @xmath173-test in ols . the null and alternative hypotheses are : @xmath174 and @xmath175 . + for each model fitted in both galaxies , the robust slope test has a @xmath8-value less than @xmath176 , so at @xmath150 of significance they are significant . the lmc @xmath177-band fitted model ( [ eq28 ] ) has a @xmath66 value ( the coefficient of determination ) of @xmath178 , meaning that the model explains about the @xmath179 of the variability of @xmath177 . for the lmc @xmath162-band model ( [ eq29 ] ) and the lmc @xmath11 model ( [ eq30 ] ) , they explain about @xmath180 and @xmath181 respectively of the observed variability . we also use the robust ramsey s test @xcite , given by the following equations : @xmath182 the null ( @xmath112 ) and alternative ( @xmath109 ) hypotheses are @xmath102 and @xmath103 . @xmath183 the null and alternative hypotheses are @xmath184 and @xmath185 at least one @xmath186 . @xmath187 the null and alternative hypotheses are @xmath108 and @xmath185 at least one @xmath188 . in equations ( [ eq31 ] ) to ( [ eq33 ] ) , @xmath189 is any of the magnitude vectors @xmath177 , @xmath162 or the @xmath11 index . moreover , values of @xmath190 and @xmath191 are different for each photometric band . this test shows that there is not enough evidence to reject @xmath112 due to its @xmath117values at @xmath150 of significance . this implies that there is no evidence of specification problems in the lmc models . on the contrary , for the smc models there is enough evidence to reject @xmath112 due to @xmath117values obtained by the test at the same level of significance . in particular , when equation ( [ eq31 ] ) is used , the lmc ( smc ) @xmath117values are @xmath192 ( @xmath193 ) for @xmath177-band , @xmath194 ( @xmath195 ) for @xmath162-band and @xmath196 ( @xmath197 ) for the @xmath11 index . by using equation ( [ eq32 ] ) , the lmc ( smc ) @xmath117values are @xmath198 ( @xmath199 ) for @xmath177-band , @xmath200 ( @xmath195 ) for @xmath162-band and @xmath201 ( @xmath202 ) for the @xmath11 index . finally , when equation ( [ eq33 ] ) is used , the lmc ( smc ) @xmath117values are @xmath203 ( @xmath197 ) for @xmath177-band , @xmath204 ( @xmath205 ) for @xmath162-band and @xmath206 ( @xmath207 ) for the @xmath11 index . in order to verify if there are structural breaks ( explained in 3.4 ) in model equations ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) , we fit the following model : @xmath208 each data set is split in two parts using a dummy variable represented by @xmath209 , where @xmath210 the lmc ( smc ) data are split around @xmath211 @xmath212 d , in order to secure that each data set has enough observations to avoid problems due to asymptotic results in robust regressions . as a result , each data set has @xmath213 ( @xmath214 ) and @xmath215 ( @xmath216 ) points . the hypotheses to contrast are : @xmath217 and @xmath185 some @xmath218 . the @xmath219 and @xmath220 parameters are associated with @xmath209 in order to detect structural breaks in the zero point @xmath221 and/or the slope @xmath222 of the ll , if these parameters are not significant there is not enough evidence of structural breaks . on the contrary , if both or some of them are significant there is enough evidence of structural breaks . + the obtained lmc @xmath117values are @xmath223 for @xmath224band , @xmath225 for @xmath226band , and @xmath227 for the @xmath11 index . whereby , no evidence of structural breaks is found , hence the parameters obtained using @xmath0-estimators are stable at @xmath150 of significance . we use the @xmath0-regression to estimate the lmc ll throughout the following equations : @xmath228 @xmath229 @xmath230 models explain about @xmath179 , @xmath180 and @xmath181 of the variability in @xmath177-band , @xmath162-band and @xmath11 , respectively . the confidence interval at @xmath231 for each @xmath0-estimator for the lmc zero point @xmath232 and slope @xmath221 are reported in table [ tab2 ] . it is worth to say that the estimators for zero point and slope obtained by ols are included between the confidence intervals obtained by @xmath0-regression . + _ to summarize , the robust tests have shown that there is no evidence to have doubts about lmc models adequacy ; as a result they are acceptable . _ @ccccc + & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & zp & @xmath34 + @xmath235 & 17.005 @xmath236 0.064 & -2.683 @xmath236 0.108 & 17.066 @xmath236 0.021 & -2.775 @xmath236 0.031 + @xmath237 & 16.549 @xmath236 0.044 & -2.930 @xmath236 0.074 & 16.593 @xmath236 0.014 & -2.977 @xmath236 0.021 + @xmath11 & 15.839 @xmath236 0.029 & -3.315 @xmath236 0.049 & 15.868 @xmath236 0.008 & -3.300 @xmath236 0.011 + @ccccc + & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & @xmath238 & zp + @xmath235 & 17.444 @xmath236 0.097 & 0.135 @xmath236 0.069 & -2.551 @xmath236 0.147 & 17.635 @xmath236 0.031 + @xmath237 & 17.019 @xmath236 0.074 & 0.107 @xmath236 0.053 & -2.869 @xmath236 0.110 & 17.149 @xmath236 0.025 + @xmath11 & 16.353 @xmath236 0.052 & 0.063 @xmath236 0.037 & -3.342 @xmath236 0.079 & 16.381 @xmath236 0.016 + @cccc + & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & @xmath238 + @xmath235 & 17.037 @xmath236 0.047 & 0.554 @xmath236 0.030 & -2.732 @xmath236 0.074 + @xmath237 & 16.590 @xmath236 0.034 & 0.540 @xmath236 0.022 & -2.995 @xmath236 0.054 + for the smc model the @xmath8-value obtained by the test of structural breaks is less than @xmath239 for all bands , implying enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis and accept @xmath109 at @xmath150 of significance ; i.e. there are structural breaks . because of the problems already detected in model equations ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) for smc , further models analysis is needed using equation ( [ eq34 ] ) . therefore the individual significance of the parameters is analyzed . to do that , the following hypotheses are contrasted : @xmath240 and @xmath241 . the individual robust test for @xmath219 shows it is significant at @xmath150 of significance , due to @xmath117values of @xmath242 in @xmath224band , @xmath199 in @xmath226band and @xmath243 in the @xmath11 index . on the contrary , the same test for @xmath220 is not significant at @xmath150 of significance since associated @xmath117values are @xmath244 in @xmath224band , @xmath245 in @xmath226band and @xmath246 in the @xmath11 index . there is not enough evidence to reject @xmath112 , i.e. @xmath247 . it means that the model has different zero point for each data set but the same slope . taking into account the specification problems and structural breaks detected in models ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) , we fit the following model for smc based on the previous individual significance analysis using ( [ eq34 ] ) : @xmath248 using ogle - iii cepheids , @xcite determined the inclination of the smc galaxy s disk in @xmath249 . the geometrical distribution of the cepheids across this disk could explain the behavior of the ll in the smc , observed in equation ( [ eq50a ] ) : linear regressions with the same slope and different zero points for each data set . + model ( [ eq50a ] ) is fitted by @xmath0-regression and no evidence of bad influential points is found . robust ramsey s test is applied again to check if there are specification problems in model ( [ eq50a ] ) . the equations and hypotheses of the test are : @xmath250 the null and alternative hypothesis are : @xmath102 and @xmath103 . @xmath251 the null and alternative hypothesis are : @xmath184 and @xmath252 . @xmath253 the null and alternative hypothesis are : @xmath108 and @xmath254 . the test does not find enough evidence of specification problems because the @xmath117values obtained at @xmath255 of significance . in particular , for model ( [ eq51a ] ) the smc @xmath117values are @xmath256 for @xmath177-band , @xmath257 for @xmath162-band and @xmath258 for the @xmath11 index . for model ( [ eq52a ] ) , smc @xmath117values are @xmath259 for @xmath224band , @xmath260 for @xmath226band and @xmath261 for the @xmath11 index . for equation ( [ eq53a ] ) , smc @xmath117values are @xmath262 for @xmath177-band , @xmath263 for @xmath162-band and @xmath264 for the @xmath11 index . @xmath0-regression estimations for the smc ll are shown in the following equations : @xmath265 @xmath266 @xmath267 these models explain about @xmath180 , @xmath268 and @xmath181 of the variability in @xmath177 , @xmath162 and the @xmath11 index , respectively . the confidence intervals at @xmath231 for each @xmath0-estimator in the equations ( [ eq54a ] ) to ( [ eq56a ] ) are reported in table [ tab3 ] . besides , it is interesting that the confidence intervals for @xmath0-estimators include the values obtained by ols , although there are slightly differences . + _ to summarize , robust tests show specification problems and structural break points in the smc models ( [ eq28 ] ) to ( [ eq30 ] ) ; therefore , analysis leads to model ( [ eq50a ] ) as a better choice . _ the universality hypothesis of the ll implies that the slope of the linear regression observed in the same filter in different galaxies has the same value , and shows a negligible dependence with the metallicity ( @xcite , and references therein . ) in order to test the universality of the ll , a linear model to fit simultaneously the data from the lmc and smc is proposed . this model is given by : @xmath269 that is fitted in @xmath177 , @xmath162 and the @xmath11 index after deleting the points previously discussed . the dummy variable @xmath209 indicates if the observation is from the lmc or the smc : @xmath270 if a cepheid is from the smc and @xmath271 otherwise . a number of @xmath272 cepheids from the smc and 487 from the lmc are used to fit this model . + the model ( [ eq73 ] ) is fitted by ols . white s test finds enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis of homoskedasticity , at @xmath150 of significance , since the @xmath8-value is @xmath273 in @xmath177 , less than @xmath239 in @xmath162 and less than @xmath176 in the @xmath11 index . as happened before , ols regression is not adequate due to heteroskedasticity problems and the presence of influential points . besides , the residuals distribution has a heavier tail than the normal distribution . therefore , model ( [ eq73 ] ) is fitted by @xmath0-regression using bi - square function . no evidence of bad influential points is found ; thus , the process to check the adequacy of the model continues . + the @xmath117values of the slope test are less than @xmath176 in @xmath177 , @xmath162 and for the @xmath11 index , so the models are significant at @xmath150 of significance . the hypotheses contrasted are : @xmath274 and @xmath275 . to test if both galaxies have the same zero point and slope the following hypotheses are contrasted : @xmath276 and @xmath185 some @xmath218 . + the @xmath117values obtained by the robust test are less than @xmath176 in @xmath177 , @xmath162 and for the @xmath11 index ; therefore , there is enough evidence to reject the null hypothesis at @xmath150 of significance . hence , the individual significance of each parameter must be analyzed . to do that , the following hypotheses are contrasted again : @xmath277 and @xmath241 . + the individual significance robust test for @xmath219 , shows it is significant at @xmath150 of significance , since its associated @xmath117values are less than @xmath176 in @xmath278 and the @xmath11 index . the same test for @xmath220 is not significant at @xmath150 of significance because its associated @xmath117values are @xmath279 and @xmath280 in @xmath177 and @xmath162 , respectively . this means that the model has different zero points , as we expect due to the galaxies are at different distances , but it has the same slope . as a result , the final equations fitted by the @xmath0-regression in @xmath177 and @xmath162 bands , after deleting @xmath220 are : @xmath281 @xmath282 confidence radius are reported in table [ tab4 ] . models ( [ eq76 ] ) and ( [ eq77a ] ) make an adjustment to the zero point when cepheids are from the smc but have the same slope for both galaxies at @xmath150 of significance . moreover , they explain about the @xmath283 and @xmath284 of the variability in @xmath177 and @xmath162 , respectively . the individual significance robust test for @xmath220 in the @xmath11 index is significant at @xmath150 of significance because its associated @xmath8-value is @xmath285 . it implies that each galaxy has its own regression line with different zero point and slope . it explains about @xmath181 of the @xmath11 variability . following equation gives the model fitted for the @xmath11 index : + @xmath286 the confidence intervals at @xmath231 for estimated parameters in equation ( [ eq78a ] ) are : @xmath287 for zero point , @xmath288 for zero point adjustment when cepheids are from smc , @xmath289 for slope , and @xmath290 for slope adjustment when cepheids are from smc . + _ as a general result of this work , robust tests have shown that the ll of the lmc and smc are universal in @xmath177 and @xmath162 bands . there are enough evidence of two parallel egression lines , with the same slope at @xmath150 of significance but different zero points , as it is shown by models ( [ eq76 ] ) and ( [ eq77a ] ) . however , for the @xmath11 index , it has been shown that there are not a universal ll : the lmc and smc have two completely different regression lines , as it is shown by equation ( [ eq78a ] ) . _ based on the experience obtained by fitting the models ( [ eq28 ] ) and ( [ eq29 ] ) , they are fitted for all @xmath278 mean magnitudes of fundamental mode cepheids observed by the ogle - ii project . we also fit these models using the ogle - iv fundamental mode cepheids , reported by @xcite . it is worthy to say that the published ogle - iv mean magnitudes are not corrected for extinction . all following models are fitted with the @xmath1-regression because of its high bdp of @xmath291 . the least treammed squares and tukey function are used . + as no evidence is found of skewness in the models for both galaxies , we proceed with the analysis . beginning with the lmc , model slope tests are significant , as it can be seen in the @xmath117values obtained : less than @xmath176 in @xmath224 and @xmath226band ( ogle - ii , ogle - iv ) . then , the test proposed by @xcite is performed obtaining @xmath117values of @xmath292 ( ogle - ii ) and @xmath293 ( ogle - iv ) in @xmath224band and @xmath294 ( ogle - ii ) and @xmath295 ( ogle - iv ) in @xmath226band ; therefore , there is evidence of specification problems in ogle - iv @xmath226band model at @xmath255 of significance . this could be due to blending problems and also to the lack of extinction correction in ogle - iv data . to perform stability tests , the data are split in two data sets around @xmath296 d ( ogle - ii ) and @xmath297 d ( ogle - iv ) , to have about half of observations in each set , by dummy variables . no evidence of structural breaks is found , because the @xmath117values obtained , by testing @xmath298 vs the hypothesis that at least one of them is not @xmath113 in equation ( [ eq34 ] ) , are @xmath299 ( ogle - ii ) and @xmath300 ( ogle - iv ) in @xmath224band , and @xmath301 ( ogle - ii ) and @xmath302 ( ogle - iv ) in @xmath226band . models explain about @xmath303 and @xmath304 of variability in @xmath224 and @xmath226bands respectively ( ogle - ii ) ; and @xmath305 and @xmath306 of variability in @xmath224 and @xmath226bands respectively ( ogle - iv ) . the estimated parameters of the models and their confidence intervals are reported in table [ tab6 ] . results for @xmath226band are shown only for information purposes because of their specification problems . the ogle - iv lmc data were also split in around @xmath307 d by equation ( [ eq34 ] ) . no evidence of structural break is found in the slope , because the @xmath8-value obtained is @xmath308 . however , the zero point adjustment is significative . as a result , there is evidence of two parallel regression lines . + the smc slope tests for models ( [ eq28 ] ) and ( [ eq29 ] ) are significant because the @xmath117values obtained are less than @xmath176 for @xmath224 and @xmath226bands ( ogle - ii , ogle - iv ) . however , these models show problems . godfrey and orme test finds enough evidence of specification problems because of @xmath309values obtained are less than @xmath176 for @xmath224 and @xmath226bands ( ogle - ii , ogle - iv ) . to perform stability tests , data are split around @xmath310 d ( ogle - ii ) and @xmath311 d ( ogle - iv ) to have about half of observations in each data set . enough evidence of structural breaks is found : @xmath117values are less than @xmath176 in both bands ( ogle - ii ) , for testing @xmath298 vs the hypothesis that at least one of them is not @xmath113 in equation ( [ eq34 ] ) . besides , when individual significance tests are performed for @xmath219 and @xmath220 , @xmath117values obtained are less than @xmath176 for @xmath219 in both bands ; @xmath312 and @xmath313 for @xmath220 in @xmath224band and @xmath226band respectively . as a result , in both bands there are two regression lines at @xmath150 of significance ( ogle - ii ) . + unlike smc ogle - ii models , there is not enough evidence to support that ogle - iv slope model parameters are unstable with @xmath117values @xmath314 and @xmath315 in @xmath224 and @xmath226bands respectively , while zero point adjustment , @xmath219 ( equation ( [ eq34 ] ) ) , is still significant with @xmath117value less than @xmath176 in both bands . as a result , stability tests show that there are two parallel regression lines in both bands . based on the individual significance analysis using model ( [ eq34 ] ) for @xmath224 and @xmath226bands , new models are fitted . however , godfrey and orme test shows that specification problems persist . nevertheless , only for information purposes , we report the slope estimated values at @xmath231 confidence intervals for the ogle - iv data:@xmath316 for @xmath224band and @xmath317 for @xmath226band . + _ summarizing , the lmc models fitted with ogle - ii and ogle - iv data are adequate except for the @xmath226band model ( ogle - iv ) . the ogle - ii models adequacy could be explained because only @xmath318 of cepheids in the lmc has intermediate and large dispersion . therefore , as cepheids with small dispersion are the largest fraction , excluding intermediate and large dispersion cepheids has no significant impact on the estimated slope value , because confidence interval for slope ( @xmath234 ) , showed in table [ tab6 ] , includes the slope estimation ( @xmath234 ) showed in table [ tab2 ] . moreover , lmc fitted models with all ogle - iv data have confidence intervals for slope that contain estimation obtained by using the models fitted with all ogle - ii data ( see @xmath234 values in table [ tab6 ] ) _ . + _ on the other hand , there is enough evidence showing that smc models are not adequate . unlike lmc , the largest fraction of ogle - ii smc data @xmath319 are intermediate and large dispersion cepheids ; as a result , when models are fitted with all data , those cepheids are majority in the sample . the presence of a large fraction of intermediate and large dispersion cepheids in the smc galaxy can be explained by the geometry of this galaxy , as it was discussed in the section @xmath320 . it is interesting that smc models improve when they are fitted with ogle - iv data because , despite of specification problems , there is not enough evidence of unstability of the slope parameter in both bands . _ our main conclusions can be summarized as follows : by applying the traditional ols and robust statistical linear regression models to optical ogle - ii and ogle - iv data , it is possible to affirm that the problems of break and non - linearity of the ll disappear for the lmc when @xmath0- or @xmath1-regressions are used . in that case , the ll is obtained without slope breaks , as it is shown in equations ( [ eq76 ] ) and ( [ eq77a ] ) , and it is not needed to exclude or reject points from the data sample . the models in this case are adequate and do not present specification problems or structural breaks , except in the ogle - iv @xmath162-band , probably due to the lack of extinction correction among others causes . these facts allow to conclude that the non - linearity of the lmc ll is a consequence of using a non - adequate statistical method . + for the smc , despite to use the robust regressions , specification , structural breaks and adequacy problems are found . this could be caused in part by blending problems due to the geometry of this galaxy , that could be generating a large fraction of intermediate and large dispersion cepheids , as it was discussed in section @xmath320 . this astronomical reason seems to imply that cepheid variables in galaxies with elongated structures like this of the smc are not appropriate to fit a reliable ll . in particular , for the smc , we found that excluding the intermediate and large dispersion cepheids , i.e. stars that exhibit the communalities of influential cepheids , leads to avoid the adequacy and specification problems . this could be indicating that this kind of cepheids really has influence in the fitting of the ll for galaxies with similar geometry to this of the smc . however , from a statistical point of view , there is no reason to exclude these stars from the analysis . + the ols method has violations to its assumptions for the lmc and smc galaxies , with ogle - ii and ogle - iv data , as it was discussed at the beginning of section @xmath321 . in particular , two important problems are worthy of mentioning here . the first one is the fact that rejecting outliers using the sigma - clipping algorithm is not adequate because the precision of the parameters is adjusted artificially , besides there are violations of ols assumptions . without strong non - statistical reasons to support the rejection of points , this method is invalid in the ll linear regression context . the second problem is the presence of influential points , that implies the necessity to find communalities in them . in this work we found that a fraction of cepheids with a grade of moderate and large dispersion are influential points . the communalities exhibited by them suggest in their light curves bumps , i.e. cepheids showing the hertzsprung progression , or eclipsing variations , or evidence of period changes . the exclusion of these influential cepheids from the sample using ols regression was made to solve adequacy problems ; however , new influential points appear that imply again violations to the ols assumptions . + although the obtained @xmath0-estimators ( slope and zero point ) and their respective confidence intervals include the ols estimators reported by @xcite , the relevance of using the @xmath0-estimators is that they allow to make a reliable statistical inference , since none of their assumptions are violated , unlike the ols estimations . + when cepheids from the lmc and smc are combined to fit a single model , in each one of the @xmath224 and @xmath226bands , the linear relations remain to be valid , after deleting the cepheids already discussed . the @xmath0-model shows that each galaxy has its own regression line differing only in the zero point . this implies that the ogle - ii leavitt law is universal in the range of metallicities of the magellanic clouds . on the contrary , the combined model for @xmath11 shows that each galaxy has its own linear regression with the expected difference in zero point , but with unexpected difference in slope . this result has already been reported in the literature , but its causes are not yet clear . lmc models fitted by using all ogle - ii and ogle - iv data by @xmath1-regression are adequate , but ogle - iv @xmath226band has specification problems . these problems could be due to blending and the lack of extinction correction in these data . there is no evidence of unstability in their zero point and slope parameters . on the other hand , despite of the specification problems in smc models for ogle - ii and ogle - iv data , there is not enough evidence of unstability in the slope parameters when they are fitted with ogle - iv data that have more observations compared to ogle - ii . however , when ogle - iv data are split in @xmath307 d , there is evidence of two parallel regression lines . + it is clear from our results that influential cepheids do not have an important effect on the ll for the lmc . however , they could have impact in the case of galaxies with similar geometry to this of the smc . the effect of these cepheids in the measurement of distances to these galaxies , will be studied in a forthcoming paper . + finally , based on the results of this work , we suggest to use the ll relations given by equations ( [ eq76 ] ) and ( [ eq77a ] ) as a universal law for the smc and lmc galaxies . we also suggest to use the slope and zero point for @xmath177-band , obtained for lmc using ogle - iv data , shown in table [ tab6 ] . for the smc using ogle - ii without the influential cepheids , we suggest to use the equations ( [ eq54a ] ) and ( [ eq55a ] ) . + authors thank the referee , dr . pawel pietrukowicz , for his important recommendations and suggestions that have improved this manuscript . agv , bes and jrm acknowledge support from facultad de ciencias , universidad de los andes , through proyecto semilla . svd acknowledges the physics department , universidad de los andes , for the fellowship supporting the postdoctoral position held within the astronomy group . aikawa , t. , & whitney , c. , 1984 , apj , 282 , 527 aikawa , t. , & whitney , c. , 1985 , apj , 296 , 165 alcock , c. , allsman , r. , alves , d. , et al . , 2002 , apj , 573 , 338 babcock , h. , 1958 , apjs , 3 , 141 bono , g. , marconi m. , & stellingwerf , r. , 2000 , a&a , 360 , 245 butkovskaya , v. , plachinda , s. , baklanova , d. , & butkovskyi , v. , 2014 , iaus , 301 , 393 caputo , f. , marconi , m. , & musella , m. , 2000 , a&a , 354 , 610 christy , r. , 1968 , quarterly journal of the royal astronomical society , 9 , 13 drapper , n. , & smith , h. , 1998 , applied regression analysis ( 3th ed . ; john wiley & sons publication ) fadeyev , y. , 2013 , astronomy letters , 39 , 746 fernie , j. d. , 1969 , pasp , 81 , 707 fouqu , p. , arriagada , p. , storm , j. , et al . , 2007 , a&a , 476 , 73f freedman , w. , & madore , b. , 2010 , ara&a , 48 , 673 feigelson , e. d. , & babu , g. j. , 2012 , modern statistical methods for astronomy with r applications ( 1st ed . ; cambridge ; cambridge university press ) garca - varela , a. , sabogal , b. , & ramrez - tannus , m. , 2013 , mnras , 431 , 2278 gastine , t. , & dintrans , b. , 2008 , a&a , 490 , 743 gieren , w. , storm , j. , barnes , t. , et al . , 2005 , apj , 627 , 224 g gieren , w. , pilecki , b. , pietrzyski , g. , et al . , 2014 , apj , 786 , 80 gieren , w. , pilecki , b. , pietrzyski , g. , et al . , 2015 , apj , 815 , 28 g godfrey , l. g. , & orme , c. d. , 1994 , international economic review , 48 , 489 harris , j. , & zaritsky , d. , 2006 , aj , 131 , 2514 hertzsprung , e. , 1926 , bulletin of the astronomical institutes of the netherlands , 3 , 115 kafadar , k. , 1983 , journal of reseach of the national bureau of standards , 88 , 105 kanbur , s. m. , & ngeow , c - c . , 2004 , mnras , 350 , 962k kanbur , s. m. , ngeow , c - c . , nanthakumar , a. , & stevens , r. , 2007 , pasp , 119 , 512 karp , a. , 1975 , apj 199 , 448 keller , s. , & wood , p. , 2006 , apj , 642 , 834 koen , c. , kanbur , s. m. , & ngeow c - c . , 2007 , mnras , 380 , 1440 kukarkin , b. , 1937 , astr . zhurnal u.s.s.r . , 14 , 125 leavitt , h. s. , & pickering , e. c. , 1912 , harvard college observatory circular , 173 , 1 madore , b. , & freedman , w. , 1991 , pasp , 103 , 933 marconi , m. , musella , m. , & fiorentino , g. , 2005 , apj , 632 , 590 molnr , l. , & szabados , l. , 2014 , mnras , 442 , 3222 montgomery , d. c. , peck , e. e. , & vining , g.g . , 2012 , introduction to linear regression analysis ( 5th ed . ; john wiley & sons publication ) neilson , h. , & ignace , r. , 2014 , a&a , 563 , l4 ngeow , c - c . , kanbur , s. m. , bellinger , e. p. , et al . , 2012 , ap&ss , 341 , 105 nun , i. , pichara , k. , protopapas , p. , et al . , 2014 , apj , 793 , 23 pietrzyski , g. , gieren , w. , udalski , a. , et al . , 2004 , aj , 128 , 2815p pietrzyski , g. , thompson , i. , gieren , w. , et al . , 2010 , nature , 468 , 542 pietrzyski , g. , thompson , i. , graczyk , d. , et al . , 2011 , apj , 742 , 20 pilecki , b. , graczyk , d. , gieren , w. , apj , 2015 , 809 , 29 plachinda , s. , 1990 , krymskaia astrofizicheskaia observatoriia , 81 , 112 plachinda , s. , 2000 , a&a , 360 , 642 poleski , r. , 2008 , acta astron . , 58 , 313 ramsey , j. b. , 1969 , journal of the royal statistical society series b , 31(2 ) , 350 ramsey , j. b. , 1974 . frontiers in econometrics . p. zarembka . nueva york ; academic press ) sandage , a. , & tammann , g. , 1968 , apj , 151 , 531 sandage , a. , & tammann , g. , 1969 , apj , 157 , 683 schwarzenberg - czerny , a. , 1989 , mnras , 241 , 153 severny , a. , kuvshinov , v. , & nikulin , n. , 1974 , krymskaia astrofizicheskaia observatoriia , izvestiia obs . 50 , 3 simon , n. , & schmidt , e. , 1976 , apj , 205 , 162 soszyski , i. , poleski , r. , udalski , a. , et al . , 2008 , acta astron . , 58 , 163 soszyski , i. , udalski , a. , poleski , r. , et al . , 2012 , acta astron . , 62 , 219 soszyski , i. , udalski , a. , szymaski m. , et al . , 2015 , acta astron . , 65 , 279 strassmeier , k. , 2009 , a&arv , 17 , 251 stothers , r. , 2009 , apj , 696 , l37 submramanian , s. , & subramanaiam , a. , 2015 , a&a , 573 , a135 tammann , g. a. , sandage , a. , & reindl , b. , 2003 , a&a , 404 , 423 turner , d. , abdel - sabour abdel - latif , m. , & berdnikov , l. , 2006 , pasp , 118 , 410 udalski , a. , soszyski , i. , szymaski , m. , et al . , 1999a , acta astron . , 49 , 223 udalski , a. , soszyski , i. , szymaski , m. , et al . , 1999b , acta astron . , 49 , 437 udalski , a. , szymaski , m. , kubiak , m. , et al . , 1999c , acta astron . , 49 , 201 udalski , a. , 2000 , acta astron . , 50 , 279 udalski , a. , wyrzykowski , . , pietrzyski , g. , et al . , 2001 , acta astron . , 51 , 221 udalski , a. , szymaski , m. , & szymaski , g. , 2015 , acta astron . , 65 , 1 wade , g. , chadid , m. , shorlin , s. , et al . , 2002 , a&a , 392 , l17 weiss , w. , 1986 , a&a , 160 , 243 white , h. , 1980 , econometrica , 48 , 817 whitney , c. , 1983 , apj , 274 , 830 yohai , v. , 1987 , the annals of statistics , 15 , 642 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in classical statistical mechanics , particles with shapes are ubiquitous . their prominence in granular matter @xcite , soft condensed matter @xcite , and , more specifically , biological matter @xcite , is well established . their shapes vary from the highly complex such as folded proteins to the most elementary such as hard spheres . their equilibrium and nonequilibrium properties are investigated by a broad array of experimental and computational probes . analytic approaches in this area of research see their predictive power restricted to fairly simple scenarios regarding shapes , environment , and dimensionality . for rigorous calculations the domains of applicability are further narrowed . this limitation finds ample compensation in their usefulness as benchmarks and anchor points for approximations and simulations . the work reported in the following is motivated by this chain of reasoning . it deals with hard rods in one dimension at thermal equilibrium in external potentials . we consider monodisperse rods of size @xmath1 , @xmath2 on a lattice ( linear array of cells with volume @xmath0 ) . hard rods of size @xmath5 populating a continuum emerge from the limit @xmath3 , @xmath4 with @xmath6 . there are several approaches that facilitate an exact derivation of thermodynamic and structural properties for a homogeneous one - dimensional hard rod system ( tonks gas ) with first - neighbor takahashi - type interactions @xcite . one rather elegant method uses convolution relations between boltzmann factors to determine partition functions @xcite . it produces the free enthalpy and the equation of state ( eos ) for first - neighbor interactions of arbitrary range . many - body - density distribution functions can be calculated by an extension of this approach @xcite . an alternative method of similar scope has recently been developed . it uses statistically interacting vacancy particles ( sivp ) as quasiparticles @xcite . this method also yields the size distribution of vacancies between rods . on the basis of these approaches for homogeneous systems , it is possible to treat inhomogeneous systems by assuming that the eos is valid on a coarse - grained local scale . from the requirement of mechanical equilibrium , spatial variations of pressure and density can then be calculated from the spatial variations of the external potential . this provides a simple and common thermodynamic route for calculating density and pressure profiles @xcite , which generally is a difficult task for an interacting many - particle system . we will refer to this thermodynamic route as the eos method in the following . because the eos method relies on the assumption of the existence of a local eos , it is interesting to gain insight into how far this assumption is justified and whether the method gives useful information even if the underlying assumption does not hold . to tackle this question analytically , exact results for inhomogeneous systems are required . for hard rods with first - neighbor interactions in one dimension , exact treatments are possible via recursion relations for partition functions @xcite or density functional theory ( dft ) @xcite . these methods allow for the exact derivation of density profiles as well as many - body distribution functions . given exact density profiles , pressure profiles can be obtained by resorting to the requirement of mechanical equilibrium as in the eos method , but without assuming a local eos . the exact calculation of local pressures is a more subtle task . generally , the local pressure can be defined via the trace of the local stress tensor , which governs the time evolution of the momentum density in a coarse - grained continuum description @xcite . in case of pair interaction forces , thermodynamic averaging over the corresponding local stress tensor allows for the determination of pressure profiles from the density profiles and pair distribution function . our calculations here will employ two approaches . the dft for lattice fluids @xcite is used to determine exact density profiles in external fields and the sivp approach @xcite is used as a realization of the eos method . the dft and sivp approaches have domains that partially overlap and strengths that complement each other . in the dft , the operational degrees of freedom are the rods themselves . in the sivp approach , the operational degrees of freedom are the vacancies between the rods . we begin by describing the general methodology and background ( sec . [ sec : meth ] ) and then proceed with applications to rods in a uniform gravitational field ( sec . [ sec : grav ] ) and in a power - law trap ( sec . [ sec : powe ] ) . the subtleties regarding average microscopic pressure are addressed in the context of the first application . steric wall effects in lattice systems and their relations to known continuum results are discussed in sec . [ sec : ster ] . in sec . [ sec : conc ] we summarize the main conclusions and outline projected extensions to polydisperse rods . appendices [ sec : appa ] and [ sec : appc ] summarize outlying background materials for use in the main text . appendix [ sec : appb ] presents a highly practical method of calculating exact density profiles within the dft framework for arbitrary external potentials . consider rods on a linear chain @xmath7 of lattice sites , represented in fig . [ fig : sketch - dft ] as an array of cells . each cell has volume @xmath0 . rods of size @xmath8 occupy that many adjacent cells . hard walls at both ends of the chain define the boundary conditions . assuming that cells ( and rods ) have unit cross section we can conveniently use @xmath0 as a microscopic scale for both volume and length . microstates of this system are encoded in a sequence of occupation numbers , @xmath9 , @xmath10 . to a rod that occupies sites @xmath11 , we assign the occupation number @xmath12 . hardcore exclusion imposes the conditions @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and the hard walls imply @xmath15 for @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively . at positions @xmath18 on a lattice of size @xmath19 . the relevant external potentials @xmath20 and interaction potentials @xmath21 are stated . one is a contact potential and the other represents an interaction of maximum range @xmath22.,width=321 ] the model system analyzed in this work is specified by the hamiltonian , @xmath23 where @xmath20 is an external potential and @xmath21 an interaction potential restricted to first - neighbor rods . the first - neighbor restriction is naturally ascertained by interactions @xmath21 with a range limited to @xmath24 , where @xmath25 , but an extended range between first - neighbor rods is permitted . in this work we mainly examine the effects of hardcore repulsion in combination with external potentials . contact forces are included in one application ( secs . [ sec : grav - sivp - cont ] and [ sec : grav - dft - cont ] ) . the effects of long - range forces are being analyzed in a separate study @xcite . the analysis carried out in @xcite is based on former work @xcite and expresses the grand potential as a density functional , i.e. a functional of the mean occupation numbers of rods @xmath26 ) , but with @xmath20 replaced by @xmath27 , where @xmath27 is the unique external ` mermin potential ' that ( for given interaction @xmath21 ) would generate the @xmath28 as the mean occupation numbers in equilibrium . ] @xmath29=f[\tilde n_1,\ldots,\tilde n_l]+ \sum_{i=1}^{l}(\mathcal{u}_i-\mu)\tilde n_i\,,\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the chemical potential . the intrinsic free - energy functional in eq . ( [ eq : omega ] ) can be written in the form @xmath31&=\sum_{i=1}^l f_i[\tilde{\mathbf{n } } ] = \sum_{i=1}^l ( e_i[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]-ts_i[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}])\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath32 is the temperature , and @xmath33=e_i[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]-ts_i[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]$ ] , @xmath34 $ ] , and @xmath35 $ ] are local functionals of the intrinsic free energy , internal interaction energy , and entropy . the latter are given by @xmath36=\sum_{j = i+\sigma}^{i+\xi } \mathcal{v}_{i , j}c_{i , j}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath37=&-k_\mathrm{b}\bigl\{\phi(a_i[\tilde{\mathbf{n } } ] ) + \phi(b_{i , i}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}])-\phi(b_{i-1,i}[\tilde{\mathbf{n } } ] ) + \nonumber\\ & \hspace*{-2em}{}+ \sum_{j = i-\xi}^{i-\sigma}\bigl[\phi(c_{i , j}[\tilde{\mathbf{n } } ] ) + \phi(d_{i , j}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}])- \phi(d_{i-1,j}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}])\bigr ] \bigr\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with pair correlators @xmath38=\langle n_in_j\rangle , \label{eq : correlators}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath39 , and , @xmath40 and @xmath41 refer to the probabilities to have zero or one rod in ` one - particle cavities ' , i.e. in intervals , where at most one rod can be placed . ] [ eq : abc ] @xmath42=\tilde n_i -\sum_{j = i-\xi}^{i-\sigma}c_{i , j}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]\,,\ ] ] @xmath43= 1-\sum_{k = j-\xi}^i\tilde n_k + \sum_{k = j-\xi+\sigma}^{i}\sum_{l = j-\xi}^{k-\sigma } c_{k , l}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]\,,\ ] ] @xmath44=\tilde n_j -\sum_{k = j+\sigma}^ic_{k , j}[\tilde{\mathbf{n}}]\,.\ ] ] the pair correlators ( [ eq : correlators ] ) have their dependence on @xmath45 encoded in the implicit relations , @xmath46 the equilibrium density profile of rods follows from the extremum condition , @xmath47=0 , \quad i=1,\ldots , l.\ ] ] with the solution @xmath48 of ( [ eq : structure - equations ] ) , the functions @xmath49 $ ] , @xmath50 $ ] and @xmath51 $ ] become the intrinsic free energy , internal interaction energy , and entropy per site . the equilibrium density profile @xmath48 and the profiles of the thermodynamic potentials depend on temperature , crowding , interaction , and environment via @xmath52 , @xmath30 , @xmath21 , and @xmath20 , respectively . the cell occupancy ( mass density ) is obtained from the rod occupancy ( number density ) via @xmath53 in homogeneous systems the pressure @xmath54 follows rigorously from the free - energy density @xmath55 via @xmath56 . a natural extension of this relation to systems with external potential has the form @xmath57+\sum_{j = i-\sigma+1}^i \bar{n}_j\frac{\partial f_i[\bar{\mathbf{n}}]}{\partial \bar{n}_j}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] and produces pressure profiles on a microscopic length scale . however , there is no guarantee that the pressure thus derived coincides with the average microscopic pressure as commonly defined via the pair - distribution function . more on this question follows in secs . [ sec : meth - loca ] and [ sec : grav - micro ] . exact profiles for @xmath58 and @xmath59 for arbitrary external potentials and interactions limited to hardcore repulsion on the lattice are calculated by the method introduced in appendix [ sec : appb ] . for this comparative study of methods we need a continuum description for rod positions on a microscopic length scale used in the dft approach ( sec . [ sec : meth - exac ] ) that carries over naturally to the mesoscopic length scale used in any of the eos methods , specifically the sivp approach ( sec . [ sec : meth - eosm ] ) . this continuum description of the lattice system is unrelated to the continuum limit . we replace each lattice site @xmath60 with the interval @xmath61 across one cell ( of unit cross section ) , and we define the interaction potential @xmath62 and external potential @xmath63 by setting @xmath64 and @xmath65 . the first - neighbor restriction for the interaction potential becomes @xmath66 for @xmath67 . the local coverage at equilibrium of this interval allows us to define a number density by the piecewise continuous function @xmath68 for a homogeneous situation we have @xmath69 . from any density profile @xmath70 we can calculate the associated pressure profiles @xmath71 by invoking the balance between internal and external forces at thermodynamic equilibrium @xcite , @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the external force field . in ( [ eq : pressure - density - relation ] ) makes @xmath70 dimensionless , consistent with ( [ eq : rho - dft ] ) . ] integration of this differential equation yields @xmath74 in some applications the reference pressure @xmath75 is known , e.g. via the weight of the rods in a uniform gravitational field . in other cases it can be determined from the average number @xmath76 of rods , which we know from summing @xmath77 over all sites , by using the normalization relation @xmath78 if @xmath79 then we can use @xmath80/\partial { x_0}$ ] . if the rods are only subject to hardcore repulsion we can use the fact that at the system boundaries we have kinematic pressure @xmath81 ( sec . [ sec : meth - loca ] ) . in sec . [ sec : grav - dft ] we compare profiles inferred from ( [ eq : pressure - dft - direct2 ] ) with profiles calculated from eq . ( [ eq : pressure - profile - dft ] ) . if one assumes that the eos of a homogeneous system remains valid in a corresponding inhomogeneous system on a coarse - grained local scale in the presence of external potentials , the balance equation ( [ eq : pressure - density - relation ] ) is sufficient to determine density and pressure profiles . depending on the circumstances we use ( [ eq : pressure - density - relation ] ) to calculate the functions @xmath71 and @xmath82 or the functions @xmath70 and @xmath83 . in the former case we have an eos in the form @xmath84 and solve ( [ eq : pressure - density - relation ] ) by separating variables @xmath54 and @xmath85 : @xmath86 where @xmath87 is determined by one of the conditions stated in sec . [ sec : meth - coar ] . in the latter case we proceed analogously via separation of variables @xmath88 and @xmath85 . the eos method is particularly useful if long - range interactions are present . for such cases an exact dft calculation of density profiles tends to be be impracticable and calculations based on recursion relation for partition functions @xcite are cumbersome . for long - range first - neighbor interactions , the sivp method @xcite provides a user - friendly way to derive the eos . the microstates are encoded in a sequence of @xmath89 vacancies of size @xmath90 @xmath91 between consecutive rods , @xmath76 in number . summing over all microstates means summing over all size combinations of @xmath89 vacancies . this sum is free of constraints . the interaction energy of first - neighbor rods at distance @xmath90 is equivalent to part of the excitation energy @xmath92 of the vacancies , @xmath93 where @xmath94 . the vacancies themselves are free of interaction energies and form a set of polydisperse quasiparticles with generalized exclusion statistics . their statistical mechanics has been worked out in @xcite building on a host of foundational work @xcite . this treatment produces exact results for any thermodynamic quantity of interest for spatially homogeneous situations . the free enthalpy @xmath95 per site is given by @xmath96 from which other thermodynamic quantities are inferred via the auxiliary quantities @xcite @xmath97^\gamma e^{-\beta\epsilon_m(p)}.\ ] ] this includes the mean size @xmath98 of vacant cells @xmath99 from which the eos is obtained in the form @xmath100 in continuum mechanics , the ` microscopic ' pressure is defined as one third of the ( negative ) trace of the microscopic stress tensor and the divergence of this tensor determines the time evolution of the momentum density caused by the internal interaction forces . in one - dimension , the local stress tensor reduces to the microscopic pressure @xmath101 and the equation of motion for the momentum density @xmath102 becomes @xmath103 how statistical mechanical expressions for the local pressure @xmath104 in thermodynamic equilibrium ( or the equilibrium - averaged microscopic stress tensor ) are obtained when starting with these euler equations of continuum mechanics was first studied by irving and kirkwood in 1950 @xcite . in appendix [ sec : appa ] we have adapted the elegant derivation by lutsko @xcite to one dimension , which for pair interactions yields @xmath105 here @xmath106 is the pair distribution function and @xmath107 the force of a particle at position @xmath108 on a particle at position @xmath109 . the first term represents the kinematic pressure and the second the interaction pressure . we set @xmath110 throughout sec . [ sec : meth - loca ] . for hard rod systems , the interaction potential @xmath111 is infinite for @xmath112 . this singularity can be accounted for in eq . ( [ eq : p - rho2 ] ) by considering a modified continuous potential @xmath113 , which agrees with @xmath114 for @xmath115 while for @xmath116 it is given by @xmath117 for @xmath118 and @xmath119(r-\sigma)$ ] for @xmath120 . after inserting the corresponding force in eq . ( [ eq : p - rho2 ] ) the pressure is obtained by taking the limit @xmath121 , @xmath122 . for non - interacting hard rods ( @xmath123 for @xmath115 ) in particular , this procedure yields @xmath124 because @xmath125 for @xmath126 or @xmath127 , the range of integration in the second term extends from zero to @xmath85 for @xmath128 , and from @xmath129 to @xmath130 for @xmath131 . this means that the interaction pressure at @xmath132 and @xmath133 ( the effective system boundary ) vanishes . accordingly , the local pressure at these boundary points is just given by the kinematic pressure , as earlier pointed out by ibsen _ @xcite , who derived eqs . ( [ eq : p - rho2 ] ) and ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) based on the approach in @xcite . for interacting hard rods ( @xmath134 for @xmath115 ) , the interaction pressure generally does not vanish at the system boundaries . it is interesting to note that equating the expressions for the local pressure in eqs . ( [ eq : pressure - profile - dft ] ) and ( [ eq : p - rho2 ] ) [ or eq . ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) ] yields an integral equation connecting the pair distribution with the density . this could in principle be used to determine @xmath135 . alternatively , the pair distribution can be obtained by solving the inhomogeneous ornstein - zernike relation with the direct correlation function given by the second order derivatives of the density functional . for hard rods with first - neighbor interactions , many - particle - density distribution functions are most conveniently obtained by employing recursion relations for partition functions , both for continuum @xcite and for lattice systems @xcite . we note that for the latter , the integrals for the interaction pressure in eqs . ( [ eq : p - rho2 ] ) and ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) can be replaced by corresponding sums ( appendix [ sec : appc ] ) . consider a semi - infinite vertical column of cells numbered @xmath136 from the bottom up . a uniform gravitational field @xmath137 acts on rods of mass @xmath138 . we use it here to represent any linear potential . we begin with non - interacting rods of size @xmath8 on a lattice and then take the continuum limit . results from sivp operating on a mesoscopic length scale are compared with those from dft operating on a microscopic length scale . pressure profiles on a microscopic length scale obtained from dft via ( [ eq : pressure - dft - direct2 ] ) are then compared with average microscopic pressure profiles inferred via ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) . finally , we discuss some effects of repulsive contact interaction as made manifest in one or the other method . for the sake of brevity we limit the discussion to one simple case study of each approach . they can both be adapted to different applications . the gravitational potential to be used in ( [ eq : pressure - density - relation ] ) is @xmath139 convenient scaled variables for position , pressure , and temperature in this application are @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the length of all @xmath76 rods stacked up in a solid column . the pressure at @xmath142 is @xmath143 , independent of @xmath32 . the thermal energy @xmath144 is measured in units of the work @xmath145 required to lift this weight a distance equal to the size of one rod . the sivp analysis ( sec . [ sec : meth - eosm ] ) starts from the expression for the density of vacant cells , @xmath146^{-1},\ ] ] derived in @xcite from ( [ eq : m - sivp ] ) . the scaled mass density ( volume fraction ) inferred from ( [ eq : eos - sivp ] ) then reads @xmath147 performing the integral ( [ eq : p - from - eos - method ] ) with ( [ eq:10 ] ) and ( [ eq:22 ] ) yields the following equation for the pressure profile @xmath148 the density profile follows from ( [ eq:22 ] ) by substitution . on a lattice and the dashed lines rods ( of any size ) in a continuum.,title="fig:",width=162 ] on a lattice and the dashed lines rods ( of any size ) in a continuum.,title="fig:",width=162 ] the solid curves in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] show the profiles @xmath149 and @xmath150 at various values of @xmath151 for rods of size @xmath152 . the variation of pressure with height crosses over from hydrostatic to atmospheric with increasing temperature . the density profile is rectangular in the low - temperature limit and varies like @xmath153 at @xmath154 . these profiles do not vary much with the rod size @xmath8 when expressed by the scaled quantities ( [ eq:1 ] ) . in the limit @xmath4 , @xmath3 with @xmath6 fixed , we have a system of rods of size @xmath5 and mass @xmath138 in a continuum . the continuum versions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) read @xmath155 respectively . the pressure and mass density profiles in the continuum are shown as dashed curves in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] . on the length scale of single rods additional features , not resolved by any eos method including sivp , emerge in the profiles for @xmath156 when analyzed via dft . we write @xmath157 where @xmath158 is the position of the center of the lowest cell occupied by a rod . the free energy functional ( [ eq : freeenergy - dft ] ) with no interaction except hardcore repulsion acquires the form ( [ eq : b1 ] ) and the density profile of rods for any given @xmath20 are the solutions of the coupled equations ( [ eq : b2 ] ) . here , for the linear potential ( [ eq:102 ] ) , we set @xmath159 in all expressions imported from appendix [ sec : appb ] . we first examine the case @xmath152 . the solution ( [ eq : b4 ] ) is constructed from an exponential function as follows : @xmath160 where @xmath161 and the average number @xmath162 of rods is controlled by the fugacity @xmath163 , where @xmath164 is the scaled chemical potential . this dft result exactly reproduces the functional dependence of @xmath165 on @xmath166 obtained via sivp and given by ( [ eq:22 ] ) with ( [ eq:23 ] ) for @xmath152 if we use ( [ eq:101 ] ) and set @xmath167 the results from both methods are fully consistent . the sivp solution remains exact even for small numbers of rods . there exist no microscopic features in the density profile that sivp does not resolve . now we turn to the case @xmath168 , where the microscopic length scale does indeed reveal additional structures in the various profiles . these structures are encoded in eqs . ( [ eq : b5 ] ) , which for slowly varying profiles we expand into the form , @xmath169,\ ] ] and note that the first correction is of second order . the leading term alone leads to the density profile , @xmath170 which coincides with ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) for @xmath168 if we set @xmath171 thus full consistency between the two approaches is established on the mesoscopic length scale . finding the microscopic structures in the density profiles of rods and mass requires that we solve eqs . ( [ eq : b5 ] ) and then use ( [ eq:101 ] ) instead of eq . ( [ eq:34 ] ) . the solution as derived in appendix [ sec : appb ] reads @xmath172 with the @xmath173 determined recursively from @xmath174 in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] in a uniform gravitational field at different temperatures . the solid curves represent solutions of ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) as predicted by sivp for a system with @xmath175 . the @xmath58-data on the left ( circles ) originate from ( [ eq:113 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:35 ] ) and @xmath177 from ( [ eq:19 ] ) with @xmath178 . these data are transcribed into the circles on the right via ( [ eq:101 ] ) and into the circles of panel ( g ) via ( [ eq:305]).,title="fig:",width=162 ] the circles in the panels on the left in fig . [ fig : fig9 ] are derived from ( [ eq:113 ] ) . the probability @xmath58 that a rod occupies cells @xmath60 and @xmath179 varies with index @xmath60 in a manner that reflects the combined effects of the hardcore exclusion interaction between rods and the presence of a hard floor @xmath180 . the spatial oscillations are mild at high @xmath32 and discernible only very close to the floor . as @xmath32 is lowered , the amplitude becomes stronger and the range wider . in the limit @xmath181 the @xmath58 strictly alternate between one and zero , reflecting a compact stack of rods . when transcribed via ( [ eq:101 ] ) to the mass density , the wall effect is not nearly as strong . the evidence is represented by the circles in the panels on the right , where we set @xmath182 for the discrete data and @xmath166 from ( [ eq:1 ] ) for the curves . at high @xmath32 the effect is still strongest in the immediate vicinity of the floor but that is no longer the case at the lowest @xmath32 used in fig . [ fig : fig9 ] . at @xmath183 the effect disappears altogether . the local pressure predicted by dft as inferred from ( [ eq : pressure - dft - direct2 ] ) with the @xmath58 from ( [ eq : b2 ] ) substituted into the free - energy functional ( [ eq : b1 ] ) becomes @xmath184 with @xmath59 from ( [ eq:101 ] ) . in panel ( g ) of fig . [ fig : fig9 ] we show the pressure profiles thus obtained from the density data of panels ( a)-(f ) . the profiles are monotonically decreasing from @xmath185 . remarkably , the wild oscillations of the @xmath58 are almost completely smoothed by ( [ eq:305 ] ) . however , there does exist a systematic albeit small deviation between the dft and sivp pressure profiles . the dft pressure profile is closer to but not identical with the true microscopic pressure as will be further discussed in sec . [ sec : grav - micro ] . the agreement of the dft and sivp approaches on the mesoscopic length scale defined earlier is underlined by expressions ( [ eq:19 ] ) and ( [ eq:32 ] ) for @xmath152 and by expressions ( [ eq:34 ] ) and ( [ eq:35 ] ) for @xmath168 . it can further be shown that for any @xmath8 the density @xmath150 determined by ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:23 ] ) is the solution of a polynomial equation of order @xmath8 . likewise , the probabilities @xmath58 at @xmath186 inferred from ( [ eq : b2 ] ) with all @xmath77 within the square brackets set equal to each other is also the solution of a polynomial equation of order @xmath8 . the control variables are @xmath151 , @xmath76 in the first polynomial equation ( canonical ensemble ) whereas they are @xmath151 and @xmath176 in the second polynomial equation ( grandcanonical ensemble ) . the two polynomial equations are equivalent if we set @xmath187 the agreement between dft and sivp on the mesoscopic length scale also extends to the pressure profiles . from ( [ eq:305 ] ) with @xmath188 we infer @xmath189 which is equivalent to ( [ eq:22 ] ) . the microscopic features in the density profile remain conspicuous for @xmath190 . the oscillations that are superimposed on profile predicted by sivp are characterized by a ` wavelength ' proportional to @xmath8 . such profiles are readily produced from ( [ eq : b15 ] ) and ( [ eq : b16 ] ) . the exact hard - wall effects for rods of arbitrary size @xmath8 will be investigated in sec . [ sec : ster ] . soft walls as realized in power - law traps also produce structures on a microscopic length scale . some examples will be investigated in sec . [ sec : powe ] . the average local microscopic pressure @xmath191 as inferred via ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) from the pair distribution function by the method presented in appendix [ sec : appc ] has two parts : a kinematic pressure and an interaction pressure ( in a formal sense ) . in fig . [ fig : microscopic_pres ] we show the profiles of both parts and their sum for rods of size @xmath192 at low temperature @xmath193 . both parts show strong oscillations that are somewhat out of phase . these oscillations are strongly attenuated with distance from the hard floor . they quickly become imperceptible with rising @xmath32 ( see fig . [ fig : microscpic_dft_pres ] ) . the non - monotonic features of @xmath191 remain totally unresolved in the eos pressure profiles discussed earlier but are partially resolved by the dft pressure profiles as illustrated in fig . [ fig : microscpic_dft_pres ] . at high @xmath151 the two profiles are virtually identical and equal to the sivp profile . at low @xmath151 , the additional @xmath191 oscillations are reproduced by dft with remarkable accuracy albeit not exactly . is not equal the total weight of the rods but it has the form @xmath194 , as can be shown from ( [ eq : part_fct_explicit ] ) , where @xmath195 is the pressure at the top of the system . with increasing system size @xmath195 approaches zero . ] for rods of size @xmath192 at low @xmath151 as inferred from ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) and the pair distribution function as derived in appendix [ sec : appc].,width=264 ] ) in conjunction with ( [ eq : micscopic_pressure ] ) ( circles connected by dashed lines ) and calculated from ( [ eq : pressure - dft - direct2 ] ) ( solid lines ) for high @xmath151 ( left ) and low @xmath151 ( right).,title="fig:",width=158 ] ) in conjunction with ( [ eq : micscopic_pressure ] ) ( circles connected by dashed lines ) and calculated from ( [ eq : pressure - dft - direct2 ] ) ( solid lines ) for high @xmath151 ( left ) and low @xmath151 ( right).,title="fig:",width=158 ] consider a contact interaction potential @xmath196 that is attractive for @xmath197 and repulsive for @xmath198 . as inferred from @xcite , the contact interaction changes the local density of vacant cells from ( [ eq:21 ] ) to @xmath199},\ ] ] where we have introduced the variable @xmath200 and the scaled interaction @xmath201 in addition to the scaled variables ( [ eq:1 ] ) . the mass density @xmath165 is inferred from ( [ eq : eos - sivp ] ) . the integral ( [ eq : p - from - eos - method ] ) can still be evaluated exactly and yields the pressure profile , @xmath202 in generalization of ( [ eq:23 ] ) . an attractive contact interaction affects the profiles in a way similar to what a drop in temperature does ( see fig . [ fig : fig1 ] ) . no significant additional features make their appearance . repulsion is more interesting in that respect as documented in fig . [ fig : fig5 ] for @xmath152 . ) in a uniform gravitational field at temperatures @xmath203 and for ( repulsive ) contact interaction @xmath204 . panel ( c ) shows the @xmath205 versus @xmath166 data near @xmath180 . the dashed line has slope @xmath206.,title="fig:",width=162 ] ) in a uniform gravitational field at temperatures @xmath203 and for ( repulsive ) contact interaction @xmath204 . panel ( c ) shows the @xmath205 versus @xmath166 data near @xmath180 . the dashed line has slope @xmath206.,title="fig:",width=162 ] ) in a uniform gravitational field at temperatures @xmath203 and for ( repulsive ) contact interaction @xmath204 . panel ( c ) shows the @xmath205 versus @xmath166 data near @xmath180 . the dashed line has slope @xmath206.,title="fig:",width=162 ] the configuration of rods becomes stratified at low temperature . the density profile now exhibits an additional layer of intermediate density . the width of that layer increases with the strength of the repulsion . the ( largely hydrostatic ) pressure profile acquires different slopes inside different layers . these profiles depend systematically on @xmath8 without producing any additional features . from @xcite we know that the effects of attractive or repulsive contact interactions of finite strength fade away completely in the continuum limit . one subtle feature of note concerns the initial slope of the hydrostatic pressure as presented in panel ( a ) of fig . [ fig : fig1 ] and then again in panel ( c ) on a much expanded scale . what in panel ( a ) looks like a clean change between slope @xmath207 for interaction strengths @xmath208 and slope @xmath209 for stronger contact repulsion , @xmath210 is , at very small @xmath166 , a two - step change with slope @xmath206 at @xmath211 in the middle . this asymptotic slope is evident in the expansion of ( [ eq:38 ] ) : @xmath212+\mathrm{o}(\hat{z}^{2}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we wish to demonstrate how a repulsive contact force of infinite strength effectively increases the size of rods . the inclusion of a scaled contact potential @xmath213 generalizes ( [ eq : b1 ] ) to @xmath214 as shown in @xcite , where the contact interaction @xmath215 is contained in the correlators , @xmath216 @xmath217 that appear in the first three terms of ( [ eq:43 ] ) . the last two terms reflect the hardcore repulsion . the metamorphosis of hard rods of one size into hard rods of a bigger size is most transparent if we consider the case @xmath152 and compare the limits @xmath218 and @xmath219 . the extremum condition ( [ eq : structure - equations ] ) applied to ( [ eq:43 ] ) leads to the following set of relations that determine the density profile @xmath220 for external potential @xmath20 and fugacity @xmath176 : @xmath221[\bar{n}_i - c_{i-1,i}][\bar{n}_i - c_{i , i+1}]}{\bar{n}_i[1-\bar{n}_{i-1}-\bar{n}_{i } + c_{i-1,i}][1-\bar{n}_i-\bar{n}_{i+1 } + c_{i , i+1}]},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath222 where @xmath223 and @xmath224 . for @xmath225 we have @xmath226 and ( [ eq:46 ] ) reduces to @xmath227 whereas for @xmath228 we have @xmath229 and ( [ eq:46 ] ) becomes @xmath230 representing rods of size @xmath168 with only hardcore repulsion . in the application to a uniform gravitational field , ( [ eq:48 ] ) is equivalent to ( [ eq:19 ] ) and ( [ eq:49 ] ) is equivalent to ( [ eq : b5 ] ) . the sivp approach of sec . [ sec : grav - sivp - cont ] describes the same crossover from rods of size @xmath8 to rods of size @xmath231 under a repulsive contact interaction of increasing strength . the pressure profile ( [ eq:38 ] ) evaluated for @xmath232 and any @xmath8 reproduces ( [ eq:23 ] ) . when the same expression is evaluated for @xmath233 it connects again with ( [ eq:23 ] ) but now for @xmath231 provided the scaled variables are properly adjusted . optical or magnetic traps of several different designs for atomic or molecular gases produce wells with a range of profiles . how does the pressure at the center of the trap vary with temperature ? how does the shape of the trap potential affect the profiles of density and pressure ? power - law traps are well - suited for our two approaches and can illuminate these questions with answers from an exact analysis . in this application we consider an infinite row of cells numbered @xmath234 at positions @xmath235 . the rods are confined to a region centered at @xmath132 by the symmetric power - law potential @xmath236 with @xmath237 representing a depth and @xmath238 representing ( at least for @xmath239 ) a width of the trap . the analysis proceeds as in sec . [ sec : grav - sivp ] . expression ( [ eq:22 ] ) remains unchanged . however , the pressure profile is now determined by the relation @xmath240 where , in addition to @xmath205 and @xmath151 from ( [ eq:1 ] ) , we use the scaled variables @xmath241 a solid stack of rods extends out to @xmath242 and the pressure at the center becomes @xmath243 . in the continuum limit , @xmath4 , @xmath3 with @xmath6 , eqs . ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:27 ] ) turn into @xmath244 one additional relation is needed to bring closure to ( [ eq:22 ] ) and ( [ eq:27 ] ) , namely @xmath245 reflecting mass conservation . the pressure @xmath246 at @xmath247 can be determined from this relation . for the two extreme rod sizes we thus obtain @xmath248 @xmath249^{\frac{1-\alpha}{\alpha}}\!\!\!=1\quad ( \sigma=\infty),\ ] ] where @xmath250 is the fermi - dirac function . the rods remain confined at any finite temperature : we have @xmath251 if @xmath252 for any @xmath253 . the limit @xmath254 , representing a trap of width @xmath255 with rigid walls , is subtle . relation ( [ eq:303 ] ) reduces to @xmath256 we then have @xmath257 inside the trap , with a uniform density , @xmath258 . we thus recover the familiar eos @xmath259 of the ideal lattice gas . the limit @xmath260 yields @xmath261 and the profiles for pressure and density are @xmath262 respectively . if @xmath239 @xmath263 the pressure @xmath246 at the center of the trap increases ( decreases ) with @xmath151 rising from zero . for the linear potential @xmath264 , which is equivalent to the case of the uniform gravitational field ( sec . [ sec : grav - sivp ] ) , we have @xmath261 for all @xmath151 . in fig . [ fig : fig3 ] we show pressure and density profiles for the two extreme rod sizes in two different power - law potentials . the shape of one potential @xmath265 is concave and that of the other @xmath266 convex . corresponding profiles for a linear potential @xmath264 have already been shown in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] albeit on a somewhat different scale . ( top ) and @xmath267 ( bottom ) at temperatures @xmath268 for rods of sizes @xmath152 ( solid curves ) and @xmath269 ( dashed curves).,title="fig:",width=162 ] ( top ) and @xmath267 ( bottom ) at temperatures @xmath268 for rods of sizes @xmath152 ( solid curves ) and @xmath269 ( dashed curves).,title="fig:",width=162 ] ( top ) and @xmath267 ( bottom ) at temperatures @xmath268 for rods of sizes @xmath152 ( solid curves ) and @xmath269 ( dashed curves).,title="fig:",width=162 ] ( top ) and @xmath267 ( bottom ) at temperatures @xmath268 for rods of sizes @xmath152 ( solid curves ) and @xmath269 ( dashed curves).,title="fig:",width=162 ] the opposite @xmath151-dependence of the pressure near the center of the trap is evident . the curves at the lowest temperature are close to the @xmath270 profiles ( [ eq:50 ] ) . naturally , the pressure decrease with rising @xmath151 in for @xmath271 has a much larger effect on the density than does the pressure increase for @xmath267 . another noteworthy feature is that the difference in profile between the lattice system and the continuum system is much more pronounced for the convex potential than for the concave potential . in sec . [ sec : grav - dft ] we have already identified some hard - floor effects in the form of spatially attenuated oscillations in the density profiles @xmath58 and @xmath59 of rods and mass , respectively . we found ( in fig . [ fig : fig9 ] ) that the effect is very conspicuous in the former and partially averaged out in the latter . a more systematic analysis of hard - wall effects for rods of various sizes on the lattice and for rods in a continuum will be presented in sec . [ sec : ster ] . and mass @xmath59 for rods of size @xmath168 in a harmonic trap @xmath266 and in a power - law trap with firmer walls @xmath272 . in both traps we use @xmath273 . all data are for @xmath274 . the chemical potential @xmath275 has the values ( a ) 1.0 , ( b ) 1.55 , ( c ) 0.3 , ( d ) 0.5.,title="fig:",width=162 ] and mass @xmath59 for rods of size @xmath168 in a harmonic trap @xmath266 and in a power - law trap with firmer walls @xmath272 . in both traps we use @xmath273 . all data are for @xmath274 . the chemical potential @xmath275 has the values ( a ) 1.0 , ( b ) 1.55 , ( c ) 0.3 , ( d ) 0.5.,title="fig:",width=162 ] and mass @xmath59 for rods of size @xmath168 in a harmonic trap @xmath266 and in a power - law trap with firmer walls @xmath272 . in both traps we use @xmath273 . all data are for @xmath274 . the chemical potential @xmath275 has the values ( a ) 1.0 , ( b ) 1.55 , ( c ) 0.3 , ( d ) 0.5.,title="fig:",width=162 ] and mass @xmath59 for rods of size @xmath168 in a harmonic trap @xmath266 and in a power - law trap with firmer walls @xmath272 . in both traps we use @xmath273 . all data are for @xmath274 . the chemical potential @xmath275 has the values ( a ) 1.0 , ( b ) 1.55 , ( c ) 0.3 , ( d ) 0.5.,title="fig:",width=162 ] here we briefly examine the question whether the soft walls of power - law traps also produce patterns of spatial density oscillations . we begin with rods of size @xmath168 . in fig . [ fig : fig15 ] we compare data for traps with walls of two different degrees of softness . these data are produced by using the potential ( [ eq:26 ] ) with @xmath276 and calculating the profiles from ( [ eq : b10 ] ) and ( [ eq:101 ] ) . we use @xmath277 with @xmath278 and a shift that positions the rod with index @xmath279 at the center of the trap . the harmonic trap is , in some sense , the smoothest form of confinement . we see in panels ( a ) and ( b ) that oscillations do make their appearance in the @xmath58-profiles . the amplitudes of these oscillations tend to be rather uniform across the region where the rod population is significant . the general trend is that the amplitudes increase with increasing chemical potential @xmath280 or decreasing temperature @xmath281 . superimposed on this systematic trend is an oscillatory dependence on @xmath275 . the data in the panels ( a ) and ( b ) are for two successive values near maximum and minimum amplitude of @xmath58-oscillations . the minimum amplitude is almost imperceptible . we also note that in the @xmath59-profiles these oscillations are almost completely averaged out . increasing the stiffness of the trap walls produces no dramatic changes . the dependence on @xmath275 of the spatial oscillations remains qualitatively similar . the amplitudes still oscillate as @xmath275 is varied . the data in the panels ( c ) and ( d ) are for @xmath282 and for values of @xmath275 near successive maximum and minimum amplitude . one systematic trend as the trap wall becomes increasingly firm is that the spatial oscillations become weaker near the center of the trap and stronger near the walls . this trend is visible between the data in panels ( a ) and ( c ) , for example . we shall see in sec . [ sec : ster ] that the oscillatory dependence of the amplitudes on @xmath275 disappears when the walls become hard @xmath283 . in fig . [ fig : fig16 ] we show some data for rods of size @xmath284 in a trap with relatively stiff walls @xmath272 and twice the width of the one used before . the calculations are based on eqs . ( [ eq : b15 ] ) and ( [ eq : b16 ] ) . here we only show data of the @xmath58-profiles for two conditions . for rods of size @xmath284 in a power - law trap with @xmath282 . we use @xmath285 . all data are for @xmath274 . the scaled chemical potentials are ( a ) @xmath286 and ( b ) @xmath287 . in each plot the second and third data sets are vertically displaced by 0.2 and 0.4 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=162 ] for rods of size @xmath284 in a power - law trap with @xmath282 . we use @xmath285 . all data are for @xmath274 . the scaled chemical potentials are ( a ) @xmath286 and ( b ) @xmath287 . in each plot the second and third data sets are vertically displaced by 0.2 and 0.4 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=162 ] the average numbers of rods in the data of panel ( a ) are such that the rods easily fit into the space at low potential energy . we observe significant oscillations with a period near but not exactly three . a small change in chemical potential produces shifts in the oscillatory patterns and variations in the average amplitude . we also observe slightly larger amplitudes near the wall compared to the center of the trap . at significantly smaller values of @xmath162 the oscillations are much weaker . the data in panel ( b ) are for circumstances where the rods are squeezed into the trap . here the rod positions are more correlated . the oscillations are closer to period three . we also observe the oscillatory dependence of the amplitude on @xmath275 . for some values there are one or two dominant configurations , producing high amplitude . for other values , there are three configuration that have very similar statistical weight , producing low amplitude . microscopic density profiles of rods or other particles with shapes near hard walls are relevant in the contexts of granular matter , porous solids , and zeolites among others . robledo and rowlinson @xcite studied the effects of confinement on hard rods in a continuum . davis @xcite extended that study to include first - neighbor interactions between rods . more recently , ibsen _ et al _ @xcite reported a general and exact solution for hard rods confined by a gravitational field and a hard floor . a computer simulation study of mehrotra _ et al _ @xcite of hard spheres under the same confinement in 3d produces similar results . here we pick up threads from secs . [ sec : grav - dft ] and [ sec : powe - soft - wall ] to investigate steric wall effects of hard rods on a lattice . one goal is to showcase the versatility of the method of analysis presented in appendix [ sec : appb ] and to establish how it connects to the continuum analysis familiar from previous work . we consider a box with rigid walls and investigate the oscillations in the density profiles produced by the steric interactions between rods of size @xmath156 . the effects of a single wall , relevant in sufficiently wide boxes , can be determined analytically for rods of any size on the lattice and for rods in the continuum . two walls within the distance of a certain coherence length affect the density profile from opposite sides . that coherence length is shown to grow with average density . we combine exact analytic results with results from a rigorous recursive scheme . we begin with the case of a semi - infinite box with one wall at @xmath288 and the other at @xmath289 populated by rods of size @xmath168 to an average mass density @xmath290 . later we move the second wall to @xmath291 . for the semi - infinite box we have found an analytic solution . the result ( with @xmath292 in the present context ) turns out to have a simple structure : @xmath293,\quad j=0,1,2,\ldots\ ] ] the relation between the fugacity and the average mass density is @xmath294.\ ] ] we have derived @xmath295 in ( [ eq:103 ] ) directly from ( [ eq : b11 ] ) with @xmath296 in the form of an infinite continued fraction that is readily evaluated . the @xmath58 for @xmath297 then follow directly from ( [ eq : b5 ] ) . the oscillations in the probability distribution @xmath58 of rod positions thus decay exponentially with distance from the wall . the boundary coherence length , @xmath298 vanishes for @xmath299 and diverges for @xmath300 . next we examine how the oscillations near the wall at @xmath288 are affected by the presence of a second wall at @xmath291 . for that purpose we have solved ( [ eq : b10 ] ) with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:104 ] ) for comparison with the analytic solution ( [ eq:103 ] ) . the results , shown in fig . [ fig : fig12 ] , are almost indistinguishable for @xmath301 . here the coherence length ( [ eq:106 ] ) is much smaller than the distance between the walls . at larger mass density the two sets of results begin to deviate from each other as @xmath302 grows and reaches about half the wall - to - wall distance at @xmath303 . with center at coordinate @xmath304 in a box of width @xmath305 . full circles connected by lines : solution of ( [ eq : b10 ] ) . open circles : result ( [ eq:103 ] ) for a box of infinite width with one wall at @xmath306.,title="fig:",width=162 ] with center at coordinate @xmath304 in a box of width @xmath305 . full circles connected by lines : solution of ( [ eq : b10 ] ) . open circles : result ( [ eq:103 ] ) for a box of infinite width with one wall at @xmath306.,title="fig:",width=162 ] with center at coordinate @xmath304 in a box of width @xmath305 . full circles connected by lines : solution of ( [ eq : b10 ] ) . open circles : result ( [ eq:103 ] ) for a box of infinite width with one wall at @xmath306.,title="fig:",width=162 ] with center at coordinate @xmath304 in a box of width @xmath305 . full circles connected by lines : solution of ( [ eq : b10 ] ) . open circles : result ( [ eq:103 ] ) for a box of infinite width with one wall at @xmath306.,title="fig:",width=162 ] the signature wall effect for @xmath168 manifests itself in the form of attenuated , period-2 spatial oscillations in the @xmath58 . the exponential attenuation is governed by a coherence length that grows with the density of rods in the box . in the limit @xmath300 the oscillations persist across the box as expected . we continue with the analysis of a system of rods of size @xmath307 subject to the potential @xmath308{0mm}{5 mm } \\ 0 & : ~ i>0 , \rule[-2mm]{0mm}{5 mm } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] representing a single rigid wall at @xmath279 . we present the exact solution of eqs . ( [ eq : b2 ] ) adapted to this case , @xmath309 \prod\limits_{k = i}^{i+\sigma-1}\left[1-\!\!\!\sum\limits_{j = k-\sigma+1}^{k}\bar{n}_{j}\right]^{-1}\!\!\!.\ ] ] we have @xmath310 for @xmath311 and assume that far from the wall @xmath312 the @xmath58 approach uniformity , @xmath313 where @xmath290 is the mass density in the bulk ( average cell occupancy ) . the fugacity , the only control variable aside from @xmath8 , depends on the asymptotic solution ( [ eq:116 ] ) as follows : @xmath314^{\sigma-1 } } { \big[1-\sigma \bar{n}^{(\mathrm{mes})}\big]^\sigma } , \quad 0<\bar{n}^{(\mathrm{mes})}<\frac{1}{\sigma}.\ ] ] next we convert ( [ eq:115 ] ) into a recursion relation that expresses the solution at a given site as a function of the solutions at the @xmath315 sites immediately to its left : @xmath316,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath317 and with @xmath176 from ( [ eq:117 ] ) . this recursion relation depends on the @xmath315 parameters @xmath318 . assuming that the solution with asymptotics ( [ eq:116 ] ) is unique , these parameters can be found with a little guidance from ( [ eq:103 ] ) for the case @xmath168 . they are @xmath319^{i-1 } } { \big[1-(\sigma-1)\bar{n}^{(\mathrm{mes})}\big]^i},\quad i=1,\ldots,\sigma-1.\ ] ] ( big circles ) and @xmath320 ( small circles ) with first cell at position @xmath321 near a rigid wall at @xmath279.,title="fig:",width=162 ] ( big circles ) and @xmath320 ( small circles ) with first cell at position @xmath321 near a rigid wall at @xmath279.,title="fig:",width=162 ] in fig . [ fig : figa1 ] we show data generated recursively from ( [ eq:118 ] ) for the scaled density @xmath322 versus the scaled position @xmath323 for rods of sizes @xmath324 and @xmath320 . the latter size is meant to generate an impression of what to expect in the continuum limit . the data suggest that the dominant wall effect manifests itself again in an attenuated spatial oscillation . successive minima are approximately spaced by @xmath8 . only in the limit @xmath325 , when the attenuation disappears , are the oscillations locked into the wavelength @xmath8 . this raises the interesting question , best analyzed in the continuum limit , what the spectrum of the wall oscillations is and how it depends on @xmath165 . the continuum limit carried out for @xmath326 produces an exponential function as follows : @xmath327 this result can now be extended to @xmath328 by using a continuum version of the fugacity ( [ eq:117 ] ) , @xmath329 and a continuum version of ( [ eq:115 ] ) , @xmath330 where @xmath331 as derived percus @xcite . following vanderlick et al . @xcite , we convert ( [ eq:122 ] ) and ( [ eq : a123 ] ) into difference - differential equation , @xmath332,\ ] ] @xmath333=\bar{\nu}(x)-\bar{\nu}(x+1),\ ] ] respectively . next we integrate ( [ eq:124 ] ) and ( [ eq:125 ] ) in alternating sequence over intervals of unit length , using ( [ eq:120 ] ) and @xmath334 for @xmath126 . we thus obtain the following exact , continuous , and piecewise analytic expression for @xmath335 on successive intervals @xmath336 : @xmath337 with asymptotic value , @xmath338far from the wall , approached more and more slowly with increasing average mass density @xmath165 . the lattice dft analysis thus connects neatly with known results @xcite for monodisperse rods in a continuum . in fig . [ fig : figa2 ] we graphically compare this analytic solution ( [ eq:126 ] ) for the continuum model with the iterative solution ( [ eq:118 ] ) for the lattice model with @xmath339 . the dominant feature of the curves is an attenuated spatial oscillation . the singularities at @xmath340 become progressively weaker with increasing @xmath90 : @xmath341 is continuous at @xmath340 for @xmath342 . except for @xmath343 , the singularities do not coincide with the minima of @xmath344 . on a lattice ( big circles ) and rods of ( scaled ) unit size in a continuum ( solid lines).,title="fig:",width=162 ] on a lattice ( big circles ) and rods of ( scaled ) unit size in a continuum ( solid lines).,title="fig:",width=162 ] . ( b ) spectrum ( [ eq:152 ] ) of the attenuated oscillation ( [ eq:126 ] ) at three values of @xmath165,title="fig:",width=162 ] . ( b ) spectrum ( [ eq:152 ] ) of the attenuated oscillation ( [ eq:126 ] ) at three values of @xmath165,title="fig:",width=162 ] the limit @xmath300 @xmath345 is subtle . as the population of rods becomes more crowded , they begin to line up with increasing probability near the integer positions as illustrated in fig . [ fig : fig17](a ) . in the limit @xmath300 , maxima and minima approach the singularity values @xmath340 in pairs from opposite sides . the maxima diverge and the minima approach zero . the area under the curve between successive singularities approaches unity . the shape of the curve approaches an of infinite height and unit width , effectively the function @xmath346 in fig . [ fig : fig17](b ) we show the spectrum of the attenuated oscillation ( [ eq:126 ] ) , @xmath347\cos(qx).\ ] ] this quantity features a peak at wave number @xmath348 emerging from a broad and flat background . the fourier transform ( [ eq:152 ] ) and the limit @xmath349 are not interchangeable operations . with increasing @xmath165 the peak becomes taller and sharper as it moves toward commensurability at @xmath350 . the dft mass density in the continuum , calculated from ( [ eq:126 ] ) via a continuum version of ( [ eq:101 ] ) , @xmath351 becomes @xmath352 on successive intervals @xmath336 . in fig . [ fig : fig18 ] we show profiles of @xmath353 for the corresponding to the profiles of @xmath344 shown in figs . [ fig : figa2 ] and [ fig : fig17 ] . the oscillatory wall effects are somewhat milder in @xmath353 than in @xmath344 but still fairly conspicuous . in the limit @xmath349 the oscillations in @xmath344 diverge as in ( [ eq:151 ] ) but disappear in @xmath353 , which becomes constant . .,title="fig:",width=162 ] .,title="fig:",width=162 ] in this work we have investigated the equilibrium statistical mechanics of monodisperse hard rods confined by external potentials , producing characteristic spatial profiles of density and pressure . the rods occupy @xmath8 consecutive cells of volume @xmath0 in a linear array . the continuum limit is implemented as @xmath4 , @xmath3 with @xmath1 kept finite and nonzero . the rods interact via hardcore exclusion forces . contact forces have also been considered . we have been employing two distinct methods of analysis , density functionals and generalized exclusion statistics , with partially overlapping domains of applicability and somewhat complementary strengths . the usefulness , soundness , and consistency of the two approaches has been demonstrated in a series of applications that include confinement by rigid walls , gravity , and power - law traps . we have shown that profiles of density , for example , exhibit characteristic features on a mesoscopic length scale that are reproduced identically by both approaches and , for @xmath156 , additional features on a microscopic length scale that are only resolved in the dft analysis . the dft pressure profiles are also compared with profiles of average microscopic pressure inferred from pair distribution functions in the context of one application . finally , we have established contact between our results for the lattice system and prior results for corresponding continuum systems , demonstrating full consistency the statistical mechanical analysis of hard rods of mixed sizes presents itself as a natural and promising extension of this work . significant ground has already been broken via both calculational tools used in this work . the mathematical structure of exact density functionals for hard - rod mixtures has recently been established @xcite and is awaiting analysis in specific applications . hard rod ensembles of mixed sizes on a lattice are mathematically equivalent to magnetic domains in ising chains . the combinatorics and statistical mechanics of such domains analyzed via generalized exclusion statistics have been in place for some time @xcite and is awaiting extensions to heterogeneous environments and new applications of current interest . the completion of the work reported here has paved the way for projects along these lines @xcite . in terms of the particle ( hard rod ) momenta @xmath354 and positions @xmath355 , the microscopic momentum density in eq . ( [ eq : momentum - flow ] ) is given by @xmath356 . the time derivative of its fourier transform @xmath357 reads ( with @xmath138 the mass of the rods , and assuming only pair interaction forces to be present ) @xmath358 here @xmath359 is the force of the @xmath90th on the @xmath360th particle ( @xmath361 ) , @xmath362 the external force on the @xmath360th particle , and we have used @xmath363 and newton s equations @xmath364 . for interaction forces obeying the principle of action and reaction , @xmath365 , the second term on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq : dpidt ] ) can be written in the form @xmath366 $ ] , where @xmath367 and @xmath368 . comparing eq . ( [ eq : dpidt ] ) with the fourier - transformed right hand side of eq . ( [ eq : momentum - flow ] ) , the microscopic pressure in fourier space becomes @xmath369 to obtain the corresponding expression in real space , we calculate @xmath370 where @xmath371\,,\\[1ex ] 0\ , , & \textrm{else}\,.\end{array}\right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] accordingly , @xmath372 using @xmath373 and eq . ( [ eq : g - function ] ) , the double sum can be written as @xmath374 , and the equilibrium average of eq . ( [ eq : pmic ] ) then yields eq . ( [ eq : p - rho2 ] ) . consider a system of rods of size @xmath8 confined to a finite array of cells numbered @xmath375 . the hardcore repulsion is the only interaction between rods . the external potential @xmath20 is arbitrary . the free energy functional ( [ eq : freeenergy - dft ] ) simplifies into @xmath376 where @xmath377 are the ( yet undetermined ) probabilities of rods at the allowed positions . the minimization ( [ eq : structure - equations ] ) then leads to the following relations that determine the exact density profile of rods , @xmath220 , for an any given external potential @xmath20 at given temperature @xmath32 and chemical potential @xmath30 : @xmath378}{\prod\limits_{k = i}^{i+\sigma-1}\left[1-\sum\limits_{j = k-\sigma+1}^{k}\bar{n}_{j}\right]},\ ] ] for @xmath379 with @xmath310 for @xmath16 and @xmath380 implied . in some applications we use a semi - infinite array @xmath381 with the second boundary condition replaced by a prescribed ( zero or nonzero ) limit @xmath382 . in the following we use the control variables , @xmath383 with the implication that @xmath384 for @xmath16 and @xmath380 . for rods of size @xmath152 the hardcore repulsion does not produce any interference between the @xmath58 at different positions . equations ( [ eq : b2 ] ) remain uncoupled . the density profile @xmath58 of rods , which , in this case , coincides with the mass density profile @xmath59 , reads @xmath385 its only structure is that imposed by the potential @xmath20 . in the case @xmath168 a rod at position @xmath60 obstructs the placement of a rod positions @xmath386 and @xmath179 . this interference is reflected in eqs . ( [ eq : b2 ] ) , which now read @xmath387 with @xmath388 implied . we solve the coupled eqs . ( [ eq : b5 ] ) by a strategy that also works for @xmath190 as we shall see . we reduce the set of nonlinear equations into two sets of recursion relations to be solved in sequence . this method has the benefit of isolating the physical solution . we begin by introducing the auxiliary quantities , @xmath389 we thus convert ( [ eq : b5 ] ) into @xmath390 from which we determine the @xmath173 recursively : @xmath391 the @xmath58 are then , in turn , determined recursively via ( [ eq : b6 ] ) : @xmath392 producing the explicit form @xmath393 a different rendition of that solution is derived from ( [ eq : b9 ] ) with use of ( [ eq : b8 ] ) : @xmath394 where the @xmath395 are generated recursively : @xmath396 if the external potential is symmetric under under reflection , as in power - law traps or boxes with rigid walls , we have @xmath397 , @xmath379 . the density profile of rods must then also exhibit that symmetry . to make this symmetry transparent we recognize that we have @xmath398 , @xmath379 , under these circumstances . we can then transform @xmath399 into @xmath58 as follows : @xmath400 now we generalize this method to rods of unrestricted size on the lattice : @xmath2 . a rod of size @xmath8 at position @xmath60 obstructs the placement of rods at positions @xmath401 . the right - hand side of ( [ eq : b2 ] ) contains @xmath58 at @xmath402 consecutive positions . the coupled equations now involve polynomials of order @xmath8 . the boundary conditions require that we set @xmath310 for @xmath403 and @xmath404 in these @xmath405 coupled equations . the auxiliary quantities @xmath406^{-1},\quad i=1,\ldots , m \ ] ] then convert ( [ eq : b2 ] ) into the set of recursion relations @xmath407 for given @xmath173 the @xmath58 then follow recursively from ( [ eq : b14 ] ) : @xmath408 consider a system of @xmath76 hard rods of size @xmath8 at positions @xmath409 , @xmath410 on a 1d lattice of @xmath411 sites . the system is confined by hard walls at positions @xmath412 and @xmath413 . the lattice partition function @xmath414 with variable change @xmath415 and excess volume defined as @xmath416 becomes @xmath417 and , after summation over @xmath418 , @xmath419 the density and pair distribution functions are then expressible as follows in terms of partial partition functions @xmath420 representing systems of @xmath421 rods confined by hard walls at positions @xmath422 and @xmath90 @xcite : @xmath423 @xmath424 a lattice version of expression ( [ eq : p - rho2-non - interacting ] ) for the average microscopic pressure to be used in sec . [ sec : grav - micro ] for comparison with the dft pressure profiles thus reads @xmath425 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: the cms experiment at the large hadron collider ( lhc ) announced @xcite recently that , for standard model ( sm ) with four quark generations ( 4 g ) , the higgs boson in the mass range of 120 to 600 gev is excluded at the 95% c.l . " . the atlas experiment is in agreement @xcite . a common inference is that the 4 g itself is practically ruled out . afterall , cms also reported the most stringent bounds on the @xmath2 and @xmath3 quarks to date : @xmath20 gev @xcite and @xmath21 gev @xcite , both at 95% c.l . , which are rather close to the unitarity bound ( ub ) of 500550 gev @xcite . however , in as much as 4 g may not exist , an intriguing possibility @xcite is that electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) itself might be triggered by , or related to , the strong yukawa couplings of the @xmath2 and @xmath3 quarks . can the ub violation of strong @xmath22 scattering @xcite be related to the ub violation of strong @xmath23 and @xmath24 scattering ? to pursue such questions is a major purpose of the lhc , and is well within its abilities . if a relatively light higgs particle emerges soon at the lhc with sm cross sections , then 4 g would truly be in trouble @xcite . but , the exclusion statement of sm/4 g higgs might well get extended to the sm higgs itself with 2011 - 2012 lhc data . for higgs particle beyond 600 gev or so , one enters the strong @xmath22 scattering domain , and the higgs " becomes a broad object @xcite , which requires both high energy ( 14 tev ) and high luminosity to explore . for such a heavy higgs boson , if the @xmath2 or @xmath3 quarks were however found below 500550 gev or so , then the yukawa sector may not be strongly coupled enough to link with the strongly coupled higgs sector " . thus , we have in mind the scenario where neither the ( sm - like ) higgs boson , nor the 4 g quarks , are found below 600 gev and 500550 gev , respectively . it is important to remember that new @xmath25 violating phases associated with 4 g quarks may link to @xcite the baryon asymmetry of the universe ( bau ) . thus , the existence of a very heavy 4 g may touch both ewsb and bau , which are two of the greatest problems in particle physics . this provides strong motivation for continuing the pursuit of 4 g in this volatile time . if the higgs boson is heavy ( and fat " ) , while the 4 g quarks are above the ub , then whether the large yukawa coupling induces @xmath23 condensation @xcite or not , it would be important to explore possible _ bound states _ of this strong coupling . this is not just about potentially interesting lhc phenomenology , but may be necessary to provide a guide for the search of ultraheavy chiral quarks beyond ub . the main purpose of this paper is to explore lower lying bound states of strong yukawa coupling , and the associated properties . however , by venturing above the ub , one immediately encounters the perils of the breaking down of perturbation theory . thus , in lieu of genuine nonperturbative approaches , such as @xcite lattice field theory ( lft ) , our work is only of an illustrative kind . one aid to the study is a new , heavy isospin . if 4 g quarks exist , by which we mean a sequential left - handed doublet and a pair of right - handed singlets under the weak interaction , the @xmath26 , @xmath27 variables @xcite or electroweak precision tests ( ewprt ) require the @xmath2 and @xmath3 to be nearly degenerate ( and here , independently , a heavier higgs is also required @xcite ) . of course , some small splitting is needed to satisfy @xmath27 , but in this paper we will treat the @xmath2 and @xmath3 as degenerate , hence one has a new isospin " . this isospin , in contrast to the chiral limit of @xmath28 and @xmath29 quarks under qcd , is in the opposite limit of degenerate _ we thus borrow the notation of isovector @xmath30 , @xmath31 ( or @xmath32 $ ] ) and isoscalar @xmath33 , @xmath34 ( or @xmath35 ) etc . , for the heavy @xmath36 mesons " . as we will see , unlike technicolor , the @xmath31 " meson does not play a major role for yukawa bound states , nor does the @xmath33 . another interesting point is that , if the yukawa interaction is the dominant binding mechanism , since it is color blind , the @xmath36 mesons , unlike the qcd situation , come not only in color singlets , but color octets as well @xcite . we find the states @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath10 and @xmath39 , where the subscript indicates the color representation , to be of phenomenological interest . in particular , @xmath37 and @xmath10 may be accessible in the near future . in sec . ii , we bring forth the issues of strongly coupled relativistic bound states . we contrast the necessarily relativistic @xmath40 coupling of weak nambu goldstone boson ( ng ) , or longitudinal vector boson exchange , to the coulombic qcd bound state , as well as scalar exchange . because the higgs scalar should be treated as heavy now , its effect is less prominent than ng exchange . we compare the traditional relativistic expansion @xcite with a relativistic bethe - salpeter approach @xcite , and illustrate why the yukawa bound state involves highly relativistic motion of its constituents . an issue appears regarding the treatment of @xmath41-channel ng exchange , towards strong yukawa binding . this , plus other issues , forces us to compromise in the study of the possible spectrum at this stage , and we restrict ourselves to @xmath42 in the range of 500700 gev , i.e. not far above the ub . in this way , the relativistic expansion provides a partial guide , while we offer a peek beyond and consider binding energies of order @xmath43 gev or more , for the possible spectrum around and above the tev scale . this leads us to focus on , from the production point of view , an @xmath37 state ( effectively a @xmath44 " , or gluon - prime ) , as well as possibly the @xmath10 and @xmath38 states in its decay final state . in sec . iii we turn to exploring the production and decay properties . we survey the key parameters needed : the binding energy , the vector pseudoscalar and octet singlet mass splittings , the vector meson decay constant @xmath45 , and the quark mixing element @xmath13 . production is mostly through @xmath46 and depend only on @xmath45 , but the annihilation , transition , and free quark decays involve all these parameters , where the numerical values we use are only illustrative . we find , in general , that the @xmath37 is relatively narrow , but has a host of decay final states , which might therefore elude early detection . we offer some discussion of the phenomenology at lhc in sec . iv , touching briefly on _ deep _ bound states , i.e. the possibility of binding energy approaching @xmath42 itself , for @xmath42 beyond 700 gev . we end with a conclusion and outlook . when the unitarity bound is reached for very heavy chiral quarks , it means that some _ tree level _ @xmath23 and @xmath24 scattering cross sections will violate unitarity , or conservation of probability , in the high energy limit . pointed out over 30 years ago @xcite , it is remarkable that we are now at the doorsteps to probe whether such new heavy chiral quarks exist . many , if not most people , tacitly take the ub as a kind of ceiling for sm - like chiral quarks to make sense . but in reality , crossing the ub just implies that the yukawa couplings are becoming so strong , they are turning nonperturbative . we have seen how the remarkable theory of qcd turns nonperturbative in the infrared , resulting in the rich phenomena of hadrons . we will not dwell on deeper short - distance ( uv ) gauge theories like technicolor , but just take the large yukawa couplings @xcite at face value : if chiral quarks @xmath47 ( a left - handed doublet of @xmath2 and @xmath3 in our case ) exist at or above the ub , what could be the emergent phenomena ? consider first heavy quarkonia bound by qcd . since qcd is perturbative at short distance , we have the familiar coulombic bound states with a @xmath48 enhancement factor , where @xmath49 is the velocity . this is the domain of non - relativistic qcd ( nrqcd ) , where one expands in velocity , which is of order @xmath50 . the nr nature makes good contact with the familiar atomic systems . exchanging higgs bosons brings in the yukawa couplings , which has been considered in the literature . for our case , we will treat the higgs boson as above @xcite 600 gev and heavy , which suppresses the binding effect due to higgs exchange . however , ng or longitudinal vector boson exchange ( transverse gauge boson exchange has coupling constant @xmath51 or @xmath52 , hence subdominant and largely ignored by us ) also couples with the yukawa coupling strength , but it involves the @xmath40 , which couples the upper and lower components of the massive dirac quark . since the lower component vanishes when the heavy quark is at rest , ng exchange is suppressed in the nr limit . conversely , the coupling to high momentum heavy quarks is large , the more so the heavier the quark . this reflects the derivative coupling nature of longitudinal vector bosons . the upshot is that , yukawa interactions between very heavy quarks are large when these quarks are in relativistic relative motion , i.e. with momentum @xmath53 . with this insight , and ignoring the higgs exchange for the moment , if the bound state formation is dominated by qcd , then the nr nature of the bound state ( @xmath54 ) actually suppresses the effect of yukawa coupling . however , as the yukawa coupling increases with @xmath42 , although the qcd - bound system becomes even more nonrelativistic , at some point ng exchange would ( perhaps suddenly ) take over , and one would find the bound state system turns ultrarelativistic . we shall illustrate with two different perspectives , one a traditional relativistic expansion @xcite , the other a relativistic bethe - salpeter approach @xcite . a standard approach in considering bound state phenomena is to make a relativistic expansion around the leading potential . the higgs potential for very heavy quarks , in the context of forming bound states , was considered a long time ago @xcite . the relativistic corrections were recently calculated in ref . the scattering amplitudes for @xmath17-channel higgs , neutral and charged ng ( called fictitious scalar in ref . @xcite ) , and gluon exchange , as well as @xmath41-channel ng exchange , were computed . @xcite , however , did not put in @xmath41-channel higgs and gluon exchange , even though both color singlet and octet @xmath23 configurations were discussed . touching both @xmath55 gev and @xmath56 cases , a variational approach was used to estimate the size @xmath57 ( equivalent to wavefunction ) and binding energy for @xmath58 , @xmath59 , color singlet and octet states . we will not repeat what was already done here , but just give some salient features . as a control on validity of the relativistic ( @xmath60 or @xmath61 ) expansion , the authors of ref . @xcite required @xmath62 ( @xmath63 is the relative momentum ) , which translates into @xmath64 . since @xmath17-channel gluon exchange gives the coulomb potential , it is clear that one has a coulombic qcd bound state when @xmath42 is not yet too large , with bohr radius @xmath65 . the low mass higgs case is no longer tenable with 4 g , both by direct search @xcite , and indirectly @xcite from ewprt due to the heaviness of 4 g quarks . for the heavy higgs case illustrated with @xmath56 , as one can see from fig . 8 of ref . @xcite , the radii @xmath57 of the @xmath38 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 ( the subscript @xmath68 stands for color singlet ) states decrease rather slowly below @xmath65 as @xmath42 increases . the @xmath39 radius rises slowly above @xmath65 due to the extra repulsion it receives from @xmath41-channel ng exchange . the yukawa effect is subdominant compared with qcd , where inspection of the binding energies offer further support : they rise slowly from @xmath69 gev around @xmath70 gev , to @xmath71 gev at @xmath72 gev , with @xmath39 only slightly lower . however , just before @xmath42 reaches 400 gev , radius @xmath57 for @xmath38 drops precipitously , while the binding energy rises sharply from around @xmath73 gev , to around @xmath43 gev at @xmath74 gev . the condition @xmath64 is violated shortly above @xmath75 gev . the kink " around 400 gev is the point where the ng exchange has wrestled the mechanism for binding away from the usual nr qcd binding . the sudden drop of the size of the bound state is due to tapping the large attraction at large momentum @xmath76 for the bound quark ( besides the @xmath40 coupling of the ng bosons , the heavy higgs also defines a very short range for the strong yukawa coupling to be effective ) . the resulting larger binding energy overcomes the much increased kinetic energy . for @xmath66 , the onset is delayed until @xmath77 gev or so , with binding energy of @xmath78 gev at @xmath79 gev . for color octet states , which are not bound by qcd , the binding energy for @xmath37 , due purely to yukawa coupling , turns on sharply around @xmath80 gev , rising to @xmath81 gev for @xmath79 gev . the @xmath82 state turns on much later , around @xmath83 gev . but , unlike @xmath39 , because there is no @xmath41-channel repulsion , @xmath10 is degenerate with @xmath37 . it should be noted that the yukawa effects of neutral and charged ng exchange is weaker but constructive for @xmath37 , while the converse is true for @xmath10 , so this degeneracy could be accidental . furthermore , this degeneracy should be lifted by @xmath41-channel gluon annihilation , which would raise @xmath84 but was not considered by the authors of ref . @xcite . as we shall soon see , the vector channel also has @xmath26- and @xmath85-wave mixing . although identifying the @xmath38 as the lightest color singlet , and @xmath37 ( and @xmath10 ) as the lightest color octet , it is ironic that the relativistic expansion breaks down almost immediately after the strong yukawa binding becomes potent . but it does illustrate that one needs a genuine relativistic approach in treating strong yukawa binding . we turn to such an approach that is in principle nonperturbative , but carrying its own dubious features : the bethe - salpeter ( bs ) equation . a long time ago , around the time the ssc ( superconducting super collider ) was under construction but then unfortunately canceled , the authors of ref . @xcite pursued the bs equation approach to the relativistic bound states of very heavy sequential 4th generation quarks . it consists of a ladder sum of the scattering amplitudes that appear in the relativistic expansion . in the heavy isospin limit and treating @xmath86 , a clear isospin reorganization separates into @xmath87 and @xmath88 mesons " . for @xmath36 meson with total momentum @xmath89 and relative momentum @xmath76 , one has a set of integral equations , with loop momentum @xmath90 , where @xmath91 is the momentum exchange in @xmath17-channel . however , for @xmath41-channel annihilation contribution , the annihilation momentum is @xmath89 itself , and the integral over loop momentum @xmath90 carries no @xmath76 dependence , giving a possibly divergent constant . to remedy this , ref . @xcite took a fixed @xmath76 subtraction at @xmath92 . in this way , all the @xmath41-channel diagram contributions were eliminated from the bs equation . this includes even the @xmath41-channel gluon exchange for the octet , isosinglet vector channel , which was not considered in ref . @xcite , as the authors concerned themselves with color singlet states only . in terms of mathematical physics , to set up integral equations to be solved in a self - consistent way , the subtraction at constant @xmath76 seems reasonable . however , as admitted by the authors of ref . @xcite in a footnote , the @xmath41-channel ng exchange leads to repulsion . thus , in discussing bound state solutions , there is the issue of the physical correspondence , and therefore the range of validity ( in @xmath42 ) for implementing the subtraction . in the relativistic expansion , one clearly would not drop the @xmath41-channel diagrams . our purpose here is not to make a full treatment of the bs equation , as it is only a ladder sum of @xmath17-channel exchange diagrams , with higher order corrections ignored . furthermore , while the bs equation is relativistic , its solution depends very much on the approximations and ansatz made . ref . @xcite illustrated with covariant gauge ( but employing a weak coupling relation between spatial and temporal spinor components ) , the instantaneous approximation with positive frequency potential only , as well as keeping both positive and negative frequency potentials . although the numerical solutions share common features , the bound state mass ( @xmath93 ) values differ . starting all from @xmath94 for low @xmath42 , they decrease smoothly as @xmath42 increases , without exhibiting the kink seen in the relativistic expansion . as such , the bs approach is an improvement . but , as a common feature , once the binding energy @xmath95 becomes significant ( e.g. @xmath43 gev or so ) , at high enough @xmath42 , the low lying mesons collapse . that is , the binding energy becomes so large such that the total mass drops to zero . ( solid ) and @xmath96 ( dashed ) potentials in eq . ( 1 ) for the @xmath39 state , for @xmath97 gev , and @xmath98 gev , plotted along @xmath99 . both vanish for @xmath92 , or zero relative motion , but go to rather large values for large @xmath76 , with @xmath96 turning on rather sharply for @xmath100 gev . , title="fig:",width=302 ] having bound state solutions numerically turning tachyonic for a strongly coupled system is not particularly astounding . for qcd ( and likewise for qed ) , quarkonium masses calculated at fixed order could also vanish at large enough coupling strength . the system has turned fully relativistic with strong coupling , and the familiar bohr - schrdinger solution is no longer valid . for the bs equation , however , it is already relativistic . the collapse of the meson state may be related to the symmetry breaking itself @xcite , but because of the approximate nature of the bs equation , as well as the numerical approximations made in its solution , we refrain from dwelling further on this . rather , we wish to use the bs equation and its numerical study to compare and contrast with the previously discussed relativistic expansion , to project what may really happen for relativistic , strong yukawa bound states , before any collapse " , such as illustrated in ref . @xcite , could occur . for this purpose , we note that with the _ subtracted _ bs equation , hence with the @xmath41-channel repulsion removed , the @xmath39 turns out to be the most attractive system , i.e. the lightest bound state : the ng , gluon and higgs exchange are all attractive , as can be seen also from ref . the behavior for @xmath38 is indeed similar , but the formalism is more complicated for the @xmath101 system , where the @xmath26- and @xmath85-wave channels are coupled . note that ref . @xcite used ( sometimes tacitly ) a higgs mass around 100 gev , which is no longer valid . in our mind , we are interested in the bound state dominated by yukawa coupling , i.e. by ng exchange , hence we will view gluonic exchange as correction , with higgs exchange perhaps even milder . this matches to what one finds in the relativistic expansion , that the yukawa binding suddenly turns on , bringing on a rapid rise in binding energy . in effect , we use the bs equation approach to check , and probe beyond , the kink " seen in the relativistic expansion . the equation for @xmath39 is the most compact . in the impulse approximation , integrating over @xmath102 gives the amplitude @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is the relative momentum . keeping both positive and negative frequency amplitudes @xmath105 , one has the coupled equations , @xmath106 , \label{bspi1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath93 is the eigenvalue , and @xmath107 . the potentials @xmath108 , where we have absorbed a factor of @xmath109 into its definition as compared to ref . @xcite , arise from @xmath17-channel diagrams as described earlier . let us understand the @xmath110 and @xmath111 potentials . the less familiar one is @xmath111 , which couples @xmath112 to @xmath113 , while @xmath110 is diagonal " . in the limit that @xmath114 , one simply has @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is analogous to the expectation value of the potential ( @xmath117 is like @xmath118 ) of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics . on the other hand , if @xmath119 , then @xmath120 , hence the @xmath111 contribution is more suppressed than the corresponding @xmath110 contribution when it is weak . the potentials @xmath121 are symmetric in @xmath76 and @xmath90 , and is steepest along @xmath99 . we plot @xmath122 in fig . [ vpm ] , for heavy @xmath98 gev , and for @xmath75 , 500 , 600 , 700 gev . we have checked that the @xmath123 potential drops by a factor of two or more as @xmath124 moves from 100 to 700 gev , but @xmath96 is rather insensitive to @xmath124 . we see from fig . [ vpm ] that both the @xmath123 and @xmath96 potentials are suppressed for low relative momentum @xmath76 , agreeing with the relativistic expansion view . as @xmath76 increases , @xmath123 increases relatively slowly , reaching @xmath125 at @xmath126 ( 700 ) gev for @xmath74 ( 700 ) gev . but @xmath96 turns on more sharply , reaching beyond @xmath127 at @xmath128 gev , and @xmath129 at @xmath130 gev . so what does the strength of @xmath131 mean ? take the @xmath132 equation , the binding energy @xmath133 is equal to @xmath134 , the kinetic energy due to motion , plus the right hand side of eq . ( [ bspi1 ] ) , which should be the potential " . let us normalize @xmath90 by @xmath42 . since @xmath135 is steepest for @xmath99 , we see that @xmath136 for @xmath137 means the potential " is comparable to @xmath42 in strength when the momentum is comparable to the rest mass , and the kinetic energy due to motion is @xmath138 . we can now sense why there is a tendency for the @xmath39 state to collapse already for @xmath42 not far above 500 gev in the numerics of ref . @xcite . we have illustrated how the binding energy for the ( heavy ) isovector , color singlet @xmath140 state , which we call @xmath39 , could be already moving towards collapse for @xmath42 as low as 500 gev ( this number from ref . @xcite contains the attraction due to light higgs exchange ) , if the bs approach of eq . ( [ bspi1 ] ) holds true . however , this state receives a repulsive @xmath41-channel ng annihilation contribution . furthermore , as the tendency towards collapse approaches , the ladder sum bs equation may no longer be sufficient . even within the bs approach , where eq . ( [ bspi1 ] ) gives rise to the earliest collapse , if one drops the negative frequency amplitude , the collapse is delayed @xcite by almost a factor of two in @xmath42 . in the covariant gauge but using a weak coupling relation between temporal and spatial spinor components , the collapse of @xmath39 occurs slightly before the positive frequency only case . it is not clear at what @xmath42 the collapse truly occurs numerically . in any case , we would not touch the collapse here , as it is not yet well understood . it seems prudent , then , to consider binding energies of @xmath43 to @xmath141 gev , but not more , to make a preliminary study of possible phenomena at lhc , running at @xmath142 tev . a similar equation as eq . ( [ bspi1 ] ) holds for the isosinglet , color singlet @xmath140 state , the @xmath67 . although gluon and higgs exchange are attractive , ng exchange turns repulsive @xcite . thus , @xmath67 is much heavier than @xmath39 , and can not be a low - lying state . turning to vector mesons , ref . @xcite found , similar to the relativistic expansion of ref . @xcite , that the isoscalar @xmath38 has the tightest binding , though it is weaker than ( @xmath41-channel subtracted ) @xmath39 . this concurs with our earlier observation that yukawa effects are weaker but constructive for vector , while stronger but destructive for pseudoscalar . however , there is no repulsive @xmath41-channel effect for @xmath38 . on the other hand , checking the formalism , we find that there is @xmath143-@xmath144 mixing , resulting in a set of more complicated coupled bs equations . from the numerics of ref . @xcite , we expect that for @xmath42 in the range of 500700 gev , binding energies of order @xmath43 to @xmath141 gev is reasonable for @xmath38 . the @xmath66 state , analogous to @xmath67 in receiving the repulsive ng exchange , is far less binding , which is also seen from the relativistic expansion . turning to color octet counterparts , one can treat gluon exchange as a perturbation when binding energies are much large than qcd bound states . given that the bound state should be rather small , the repulsion due to gluon exchange should be larger than typical qcd binding . but without fully solving for the bound state , octet - singlet splitting is uncertain . however , there should be no doubt that @xmath10 and @xmath37 would be the low - lying octet states , in agreement with the relativistic expansion . the octet @xmath145 and @xmath82 are likely not ( or at best weakly ) bound , hence we do not consider these . to summarize , the states to keep in mind are @xmath39 , @xmath38 , @xmath10 and @xmath37 . there are possibly other states with different quantum numbers , but in general they would not be lighter , while likely possessing more complicated properties . the absence of @xmath31 states is distinct from qcd - like gauge theories such as technicolor . for @xmath42 in the range of 500 to 700 gev , staying short of very tight binding , these states would probably populate the 1 to 1.4 tev range , with binding energies of order @xmath43 to @xmath141 gev . the ordering of the spectra , according to ref . @xcite ( which did not actually consider octet states ) , would be @xmath146 . since we are concerned with lhc phenomenology and the heavy quark search program in the near future , we should consider briefly issues regarding production : * @xmath39 and @xmath38 can not be produced via @xmath147 fusion , but can be produced via weak drell - yan processes , hence have a weak production cross section ; * @xmath10 can be pair produced by @xmath147 and @xmath7 scattering @xcite , but it is heavier and less efficient at 7 tev . this leaves @xmath37 , which has the same quantum numbers as the gluon , that is the most attractive in the near future in terms of production cross section . it can not be produced by @xmath147 fusion , as two massless vectors can not forge a massive vector ( yang s theorem ) particle , hence the production is limited to @xmath7 fusion . in the next section , we turn to the production and decay properties of the @xmath37 meson . note that if an @xmath145 or @xmath67 state existed , such as for qcd binding , it could tap @xmath147 production @xcite . in this section , we discuss the production and decay of the @xmath148 meson , which we have portrayed as the likely leading harbinger of 4 g bound - states in our scenario , where a very heavy quark _ isospin _ symmetry prevents the production of some mesons directly at hadron colliders . for the numerical study of the production cross - sections and decay rates , the following parameters are needed as input : the decay constant @xmath149 , the 4 g quark masses @xmath150 ( we assume degeneracy of @xmath2 and @xmath3 as a simplifying approximation , hence an isospin symmetry ) , the mass of resonances , _ i.e. _ the binding energy of resonances , and finally the quark mixing elements @xmath151 . once the constituents as well as their interactions are fixed , the decay constant and binding energy are the consequence of the dynamics of the system . as we stressed previously , in the range of strong yukawa couplings we consider , their estimation has to be done by lft approach @xcite for more quantitative understanding . however , such an endeavor is beyond the scope of this paper . instead we parameterize them in our phenomenological study . the decay constant of @xmath148 is defined through @xmath152 which we parameterize by a dimensionless parameter @xmath153 . the mass @xmath84 is the most important , as we discuss the production and decay of @xmath148 . we also assume @xmath154 is the dominant quark mixing element , and ignore mixings with lighter generations . at hadron colliders.,width=113 ] the dominant production mechanism for @xmath148 is , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : prod ] , via @xmath155 annihilation . because one can not fuse two massless gluons into a massive vector boson , gluon - gluon fusion is not operative . we have also computed the higher order @xmath156 process as a check . at the parton level , the total cross section is @xmath157 convolving with the parton luminosity @xmath158 we get the hadronic cross section , @xmath159 we plot on the left - hand side of fig . [ fig : pro ] the cross section for inclusive @xmath148 production at the lhc with @xmath160 tev . we use cteq6l @xcite parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) , and set the renormalization and factorization scales to @xmath161 . we use three values of @xmath162 , 0.03 and 0.01 for illustration . although we do not have any suggestive estimation for the decay constant , since the yukawa bound state is highly relativistic , we expect the larger ( smaller ) value of @xmath163 corresponds to a stronger ( weaker ) bound meson . we note that the decay constant divided by meson mass for usual @xmath31 , @xmath164 and @xmath165 are @xmath166 . however , we are not dealing with usual qcd - bound meson production @xcite , so we leave @xmath163 as a parameter . the cross section is proportional to @xmath167 and decreases with increasing @xmath84 . because of our ignorance of the decay constant @xmath149 , the cross section @xmath168 ranges from pb to fb , for @xmath84 ranging from 900 to 1400 tev . the plot extends to 2 tev , since it depends only on @xmath163 , which we view should be experimentally determined . as the gluon density at the lhc is large , we have checked the higher order @xmath156 scattering process , and find the contributions to be quite small for the region of our interest , @xmath169 tev . for comparison , we also plot the open @xmath23 pair production cross section at lo and nlo @xcite , as a function of @xmath170 , matching ( approximately ) to @xmath171 on the same plot . the cross section should be multiplied by two to take into account the production of the degenerate 4 g doublet . in nlo calculation , we use cteq6 m pdfs @xcite . to see the uncertainty of the cross section , as well as the size of nlo correction , we vary the scales in each calculation from @xmath172 to @xmath173 . the uncertainty for lo ( nlo ) prediction is expressed as the dotted ( hatched ) band . at the lhc running at 7 tev ( left ) and 14 tev ( right ) for various @xmath153 values . the open @xmath23 cross sections at lo and nlo are also plotted for comparison.,width=306 ] at the lhc running at 7 tev , the @xmath148 production cross section with @xmath174 is about the same order as twice the open @xmath175 production cross section in the lower mass region , but exceeds the latter in the higher mass region . on the other hand , when @xmath163 is smaller , the cross section could be well below the open production cross section . thus , @xmath148 production can be interesting if @xmath163 is sizable , such as of @xmath176 order . note that @xmath37 is produced through @xmath7 , while open @xmath23 is produced dominantly through @xmath147 fusion . we plot on the right - hand side of fig . [ fig : pro ] the @xmath148 cross section for lhc at @xmath177 tev , which is an order of magnitude larger than those for lhc at 7 tev . the open production cross section grows relatively larger than the @xmath148 production because of increase in gluon luminosities . the decay channels of @xmath148 we consider are * annihilation decay : @xmath178 , @xmath179 ; @xmath180 , @xmath181 ; * free - quark decay : @xmath182 , @xmath183 ; * meson transition : @xmath184 ; @xmath185 . in the following , we discuss each decay mode separately . first , @xmath148 can decay into dijets or @xmath179 by the co - annihilation of the 4 g quarks inside the bound state through qcd , as shown in fig . [ fig : anni ] . these are the reverse processes of the production mechanism , therefore the existence of these decay modes is robust . into light quark pair ( dijets ) or @xmath179 . , width=113 ] the decay partial width in this mode is proportional to @xmath167 . the two - body decay width is calculated at born level to be @xmath186 where @xmath187 is the number of light quark flavors , and @xmath188 is the velocity of the top quark in the @xmath148 rest - frame . due to the number of light quark flavors , the decay partial width into dijets is larger than that into @xmath179 by @xmath189 . analogous to @xmath190 production , we have also estimated the three - body @xmath191 decay rate , following the tree - level calculation of ref . @xcite , and found that it can be ignored . another type of annihilation decay channel is caused by weak boson exchange , where an off - diagonal quark mixing element acts on one of the bound quarks , as shown in fig . [ fig : weak](a ) . this is rather similar to the binding mechanism , where the quark mixing elements are always within 4 g . once the cross - generation interaction occurs , the recoil due to the energy release from the mass difference between the 4 g quarks and lower generations would eject the lighter quark and destroy the bound state , followed by subsequent decay of the leftover 4 g quark . the lower generation quark mass is too light such that it can not bind with the heavy 4 g quark by yukawa coupling . the decay width is calculated in terms of the decay constant in eq . ( [ eq : dec ] ) using the fierz identity for the current products , giving ( @xmath192 ) @xmath193 where @xmath194.\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath195 . the charge conjugate decays have the same partial width as above . we have actually performed a full calculation , but set @xmath196 , or weak coupling @xmath51 , to zero at the end , as we are concerned with longitudinal vector boson exchange . we have also not distinguished between @xmath197 and @xmath84 , where the latter provides the scale parameter . the decay rate depends on both the off - diagonal quark mixing element @xmath154 as well as @xmath163 . in this mode , @xmath148 decays into on - shell @xmath8 or @xmath9 ( and conjugate ) . if we restrict to @xmath198 and @xmath199 for the decay of 4 g quarks , the final state all end up as @xmath200 . the signal is similar to @xmath179 production , but the kinematical distribution differs from the standard model counterpart . a second type of decay mode is induced by the decay of the constituent quarks , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : weak](b ) . it is similar to the weak boson exchange decay discussed just before , and quantum mechanically speaking , the exchanged boson escapes the system as an on - shell particle . we call this the free " quark decay mode , even though the decaying quark is bound . the decay partial width in this mode depends crucially on @xmath13 and @xmath12 , but not strongly on the structure of @xmath148 . this last statement would no longer hold when one enters the realm of deeply bound states , where binding energy is much larger than the @xmath43 gev adopted here . inside the bound state system , the decay of the constituents is suppressed by phase - space and time dilatation effects @xcite . that is , the decaying quark constituent is off - shell . however , for simplicity , we ignore these effects in our rate calculation , and use @xmath201 = \gamma_{t'}+\gamma_{b'},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath202 , @xmath203 are given at born level as @xmath204 with @xmath205 or @xmath206 , and @xmath207 with @xmath208 as defined earlier . note that we have kept @xmath196 here , since the decay process is quite similar to the familiar top quark decay . the decay width of the 4 g quarks is suppressed by the small @xmath13 and @xmath12 , but grows rapidly with the 4 g quark mass . if @xmath148 decays through @xmath2 , the final state would be @xmath200 , and @xmath209 if decay is through @xmath3 . the search of these signal can be along the standard 4 g quark search strategy @xcite , except that , if heavy quark mass could be reconstructed , then for example one @xmath210 pair has a lower mass ( due to binding energy ) than the other @xmath210 pair from on - shell @xmath2 decay @xcite . , and @xmath211 . , title="fig:",width=132 ] , and @xmath211 . , title="fig:",width=132 ] finally , a third class of decay is for @xmath148 to turn into other resonances . we consider the two channels of @xmath212 and @xmath184 . the other possible channel @xmath213 is forbidden by the heavy isospin . the partial width for these decays depend on the mass difference as well as the transition amplitude of these resonances . the meson transition to @xmath185 would open only if @xmath214 . for @xmath215 , @xmath148 can decay into @xmath216 or @xmath217 through the off - shell @xmath15 boson . however , the partial width would be negligibly small . we can write down a general vector to pseudoscalar transition amplitude via ( color singlet ) vector or axial - vector currents as , @xmath218,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath219 , @xmath220 are 4-momentum of @xmath148 , @xmath221 respectively , @xmath222 is the polarization vector of @xmath148 , and @xmath223 and @xmath224 are form factors in @xmath225 a straightforward calculation gives ( @xmath192 ) @xmath226 with @xmath227x(1-x^2+y^2)\lambda^3 { \nonumber}\\ & \ ; + \frac{1}{4}|a_2+a_3|^2\lambda^5 + 2|v^2| \ , y^2\lambda^3 , \label{eq : hpw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath228 as already defined . here , @xmath196 has to be kept , since transverse @xmath15 emission has a @xmath61 phase space factor , while longitudinal @xmath15 emission has a @xmath229 factor and more suppressed . using the assumption that a free quark inside a meson interacts with currents , the form factors are reduced to @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 and @xmath233 . for simplicity , we use this limit in our numerical calculation , and eq . ( [ eq : hpw ] ) reduces to @xmath234 where @xmath235 . a vector to vector transition amplitude via color octet vector current is parameterized as @xmath236,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath222 , @xmath237 are the polarization vectors of @xmath148 , @xmath238 , respectively , and @xmath239 are form factors in @xmath240 . a straightforward calculation gives ( @xmath192 ) @xmath241 where we take the scale of the strong coupling constant to be at the mass of @xmath148 , and @xmath242 the second step follows from taking the free - quark limit as described above , which reduces the form factors to @xmath243 and @xmath244 . we use this result , which is highly suppressed by phase space , for our numerical estimation . to perform numerical studies of the branching ratios and decay widths , we finally have to specify the numerical values of the following parameters : @xmath163 , @xmath13 ( @xmath245 ) and @xmath246 for @xmath247 ( @xmath248 for @xmath249 ) . without a full solution to the relativistic strong coupling bound state problem , however , it is difficult to ascertain the values for @xmath153 as well as the mass splittings , and @xmath84 itself . we therefore examine four sets of parameters as a survey , * case 1 : @xmath174 , @xmath250 gev , @xmath251 ; * case 2 : @xmath252 , @xmath250 gev , @xmath251 ; * case 3 : @xmath174 , @xmath253 gev , @xmath251 ; * case 4 : @xmath174 , @xmath250 gev , @xmath254 . these are chosen simply to emphasize large variety of possible dominant decay channels . in all the cases we set the binding energy of @xmath148 to @xmath255 gev , which is much larger than qcd binding . a different choice of the @xmath148 binding energy changes our results only modestly . for the choices specified in case 1 , we assume the larger decay constant , @xmath256 gev mass difference in the meson spectrum , and @xmath13 is set to the nominal current upper limit @xcite . in case 2 , we examine the smaller decay constant . case 3 is for larger mass difference , and case 4 is when @xmath13 is more suppressed . we will discuss the two different mass differences ( vector pseudoscalar and octet singlet ) as variations . we plot in fig . [ fig : br ] the branching ratio of various @xmath148 decays as a function of @xmath84 for cases 1 to 4 . in case 1 , the dominant decay modes are the transition decay into @xmath185 , especially for lighter mass region , and free quark decay , i.e. via the decay of 4 g constituent quark for heavier mass region . the branching ratios of free quark decay and the @xmath13-dependent annihilation ( @xmath15 boson exchange ) decay increase with @xmath84 , because @xmath257 reflects a larger yukawa coupling . the @xmath7 is of order 10% and drops slightly at higher @xmath84 , with @xmath179 branching ratio a factor of 5 lower , at the percent level . the transition decay into @xmath258 is at the percent level or less . in case 2 , because of the small decay constant , the annihilation decay channels @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath7 and @xmath259 are suppressed . in this case , free quark decay and transition decay into @xmath185 are the two predominant modes . in case 3 , the large mass differences enhance the branching ratio of the transition decays , and the @xmath185 mode dominates . the other transition decay into @xmath258 can also be enhanced , especially in the lighter mass region . it could be that the mass difference of only @xmath260 is large , i.e. when the mass spectrum is like @xmath261 . if so , @xmath185 could be considerably suppressed , and @xmath258 would be more prominent , especially for low @xmath84 . in case 4 , the free quark decay and the @xmath13 induced annihilation decay are suppressed , due to small @xmath13 . the decay width of 4 g quarks is also suppressed for the same reason . in this case , the transition decay into @xmath185 dominates , and the annihilation decay into dijets can be sub - dominant with branching ratio at ten percent order . however , this sensitively depends on the @xmath262 mass difference , as well as the decay constant . if @xmath185 becomes kinematically suppressed , dijets would be dominant . let us summarize some general features regarding branching ratios . basically , the transition decay into @xmath185 is large , because of the large yukawa coupling and no suppression effect by bound state deformation . this decay mode can be more enhanced if the mass difference is large , but much suppressed if the mass difference is small , especially if less than @xmath196 , as we have seen . free quark decay has sizable contribution for the heavier mass region , if @xmath13 is close to the current upper limit of 0.1 . 0.13 cm and @xmath221 for the four parameter sets . the upper curves are for @xmath148 , where case 3 is enhanced by a larger @xmath262 mass difference . the lower curves , plotted 100 gev less in mass , are for @xmath221 , where cases 1 and 2 are barely distinguishable.,title="fig:",width=283 ] in fig . [ fig : wid ] , we show the total decay width of @xmath148 as a function of @xmath84 for the four parameter sets . the decay width increases with @xmath84 , from a few gev to around 10 gev . for case 3 , due to the rapid decay into @xmath185 from a relatively large @xmath262 mass difference , the width is at 20 gev range , and increases mildly with @xmath84 . still , compared with its tev scale mass , @xmath148 is a heavy but narrow meson resonance . we see that the binding energy , therefore strong yukawa dynamics , and flavor structure through @xmath13 all play crucial role for the eventual phenomenology one expects at lhc . to be able to address lhc phenomenology , we need to treat @xmath38 and @xmath10 further , as they may appear in @xmath37 decay final state . from fig . [ fig : br ] we see that in general @xmath263 is the leading decay . note , however , that we have assumed @xmath264 gev . the rate would drop sharply as this vector scalar splitting diminishes , and becomes practically negligible when @xmath15 turns virtual . on the other hand , if the strong binding found by ref . @xcite in the bethe salpeter approach with @xmath41-channel subtracted has any bearing , then @xmath10 may be deeper bound than @xmath37 . for this situation , case 3 stands as an illustration , where @xmath265 decay would be preeminent . in contrast , the process @xmath266 is never more than 10% , and more typically at @xmath267 order or smaller . the exception would be if @xmath268 is of order @xmath196 or less , but @xmath269 is sizable ( plot of case 3 in fig . [ fig : br ] , but with @xmath265 removed ) . viewing this exception as unlikely , we relegate the discussion of @xmath38 to a concurrent discussion of weak drell yan production . but we need to address how @xmath10 decays . it is interesting that @xmath270 vanishes because it is a @xmath271 transition , which we have verified by direct computation . the @xmath272 exchange diagram of fig . [ fig : weak](a ) is absent for charged @xmath273 ( i.e. @xmath274 and @xmath275 mesons ) because of isospin , while the @xmath41-channel annihilation is absent by the octet / isovector nature . the upshot is that we are left with only two decay processes : the familiar free quark decay , and a new type of decay , @xmath276 , where the @xmath15 is transverse . the latter is an inverse process of @xmath265 , with @xmath51 replacing @xmath148 . however , the annihilation rather than transition nature implies that @xmath276 is relatively suppressed . for the four parameter sets , ranging from predominance ( case 4 ) , to below @xmath267 ( case 2).,width=272 ] direct computation gives @xmath277 where @xmath278 is the @xmath10 decay constant normalized by @xmath10 mass . the rate of @xmath279 is suppressed by @xmath280 compared to the rate of @xmath281 of eq . we have checked explicitly that longitudinal @xmath15 emission again vanishes . we plot the @xmath10 width in fig . [ fig : wid ] , and the @xmath282 branching fraction , in fig . [ fig : pi8 ] . the width is at gev order , narrower than @xmath37 , but could be much smaller if a small @xmath13 suppresses the free quark decay widths . thus , @xmath279 decay branching fraction is below 10% , and much smaller for case 2 ( suppressed by a smaller decay constant ) . for case 4 , the small @xmath13 case , @xmath279 could dominate . into dijets , for the four parameter sets at the lhc 7 tev . cms upper limit @xcite for the cross section of dijet resonance production is also plotted.,width=264 ] we now discuss the possible phenomenology , as well as other issues . let us first comment on the dijet decay of @xmath148 , which could appear as a dijet resonance . absence of dijet features in tevatron and lhc searches constrains or rules out any model with particles in tev range . in fig . [ fig : jj ] , we plot the total cross section times dijet branching ratio for @xmath148 production at the lhc 7 running at tev , as a function of @xmath84 for the four parameter sets . we compare with the cms dijet resonance search @xcite with @xmath283 fb@xmath284 data at @xmath160 tev . we note that the data includes acceptance cuts for dijets , but our model numbers do not , which makes the comparison conservative . we find the cross section times dijet branching ratio are at least an order of magnitude lower than the current upper limit for all four cases , with case 4 the largest . even with @xmath285 channel removed making @xmath281 the leading decay , one is still below the cms limit . let us call this special situation case @xmath286 . our results show that , while a narrow resonance signal might start to show up with a considerably larger data set , it could show up soon for case @xmath286 . that is , if @xmath285 decay is forbidden , while free quark and exchange decays are suppressed by small @xmath13 . the need for these two conditions to be met , however , makes this possibility not particularly likely . in general , the @xmath285 decay is the dominant @xmath148 decay mode , unless it is kinematically suppressed by @xmath262 being too close to , or smaller than , @xmath196 . we have investigated the decay of @xmath10 itself , and found that it is dominated by free quark decay , with @xmath287 subdominant for cases 13 . it is important now to spell out the isospin nature : isosinglet @xmath288 , @xmath289 with a @xmath290 ratio , where the subscript @xmath41 indicates a relatively soft vector boson , and @xmath291 stands for the @xmath292 boson , as we have ignored heavy isospin breaking . thus , the signature for @xmath293 leads to @xmath294 , @xmath295 , and @xmath296 , plus c.c . except for the last case with presence of a @xmath292 boson ( the identification via dileptons would be costly in branching fraction ) , the additional @xmath297 which is relatively soft makes it an even more complicated signature than direct open @xmath23 production . the same sign dilepton approach @xcite remains a good one , but more jets would be present . note that the @xmath292 is usually vetoed against in same sign dilepton studies . however , if boosted @xmath15 and top jets can be exploited to isolate the @xmath298 and @xmath299 ( both in @xmath300 final state ) , then the associated soft @xmath301 could be an extra tag for @xmath5 production . besides the relatively low @xmath302 @xmath15 , the 7-jet system has rich imbeddings of @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 jets . it can be part of the @xmath303 search program , which would in any case be a background . but the multi - jet system is of rather high mass , and with different signature content , that one may be able to separate . if the total jet mass resolution is good , one may discover both the @xmath273 in multijets with a soft @xmath15 tag , with the @xmath273 and the @xmath304 reconstructing to @xmath37 . the lhc experiments should also look for a @xmath292 boson associated with high jet multiplicity , perhaps with a hint of unusual @xmath305 plus multijets as backdrop . given that @xmath221 is very narrow , one could look for a relatively soft @xmath292 recoiling from 6 or 8 hadronic jets with very high , but relatively specific mass , containing substructures of multiple boosted @xmath15 jets or boosted top jets . the whole event , @xmath306 6 or 8 jets , would also reconstruct to a narrow resonant mass . one might think that @xmath307 multijets can be similarly pursued . however , eq . ( [ eq : opw ] ) does not apply to @xmath308 : the @xmath309 term vanishes with @xmath310 . the photonic decay involves heavy quark spin flip , hence suppressed by @xmath311 . treating @xmath312 , since we allow @xmath313 gev at best , the radiative rate is @xmath314 . since a larger @xmath315 ( case 3 ) gives a larger total @xmath148 width , we find that @xmath316 is always below the percent level . however , photon detection does not suffer from the factor of 0.06 as for @xmath317 detection . hence , the lhc experiments might also consider @xmath307 multijet studies . case 4 offers yet again an intriguing signature , assuming @xmath285 decay dominance . from fig . [ fig : pi8 ] we see that @xmath287 is dominant , as free quark decay is suppressed by a small @xmath13 . one therefore has a unique signature of @xmath318 ( @xmath319 and @xmath320 ) . here , one @xmath15 is soft , and the other hard , with @xmath302 greater than 500 gev , accompanied by a similarly hard gluon . both @xmath15 s tend to be transverse , but the hard @xmath15-jet and the gluon jet would form a rather narrow resonance ! this case offers dramatic signature and should be quickly searched for . the production cross section , of course , is modulated by @xmath149 ( see fig . [ fig : pro ] ) . case 4 , which is the limiting case of small @xmath13 , has better likelihood than the even more special case 4@xmath321 discussed earlier . leaving case 4 , i.e. if @xmath13 is closer to 0.1 , the next prominent decay compared with @xmath285 in general is free " quark decay , i.e. one of the bound @xmath2 or @xmath3 quarks decays , dissolving the bound state system . this could be practically the only other decay mode , if the exchange and annihilation decays are suppressed by a small decay constant ( case 2 ) . the signature is @xmath322 , @xmath323 ( plus c.c . ) , where the notation implies the associated @xmath324 or @xmath325 decays on - shell , but the @xmath210 and @xmath326 are decay products of a bound , somewhat off - shell @xmath2 or @xmath3 quark , which is not too different from open @xmath23 production . unless the on - shell nature is used in the direct search , the search limits would not be affected . however , once 4 g quarks are discovered , one should check whether , for some fraction of the events ( depending on resonance vs open @xmath23 production ratio ) , one of the heavy quarks is in fact off - shell , which would be an indication for bound state phenomena . we remark that open @xmath23 production at the lhc is dominantly through @xmath147 fusion , while the @xmath148 resonance production is through @xmath7 fusion . there is little resonance phenomena in @xmath327 via yukawa effects . in fact , in the @xmath328 channels , it is even repulsive . thus , even above the unitarity bound , standard search can continue , except that there may be some anomalies " as we have discussed , if any thing is found at all . we have already dealt with the special case of dijet resonance for case 4 . dijets from @xmath329 tend to be subdominant in all other cases ( i.e. 13 ) , but it could be at 10% level . it would provide a spectacular dijet resonance signal , and definite measurement @xcite of resonance mass , and spin if there is good signal over background . if the branching ratio could be measured in some way , one could access the important decay constant . in general , a resonance would also appear in @xmath259 ( boosted top jets ) , with cross section 1/5 the dijet resonance . finally , there is also the exchange decay to @xmath8 and @xmath9 , which is a subdominant channel typically below 10% . it mimics single @xmath2 ( @xmath3 ) " production , and can be studied that way . but an associated boosted top , or a high @xmath302 @xmath16-jet that tags a resonant @xmath326 , could be quite distinct . we offer some remarks on the @xmath330 @xcite and @xmath331 @xcite anomalies at the tevatron . naively , one might think that the presence of resonance production of @xmath259 could be relevant for @xmath330 . but @xmath148 has same quantum numbers as the gluon , i.e. the coupling to @xmath259 is fully vector . thus , it can not generate @xmath330 suggested by tevatron data . for the @xmath331 anomaly , the yukawa bound resonances are so massive , they can have nothing to do with it . this brings us to comparing with technicolor ( tc ) models . low scale tc has been invoked @xcite for the @xmath331 anomaly suggested by cdf . our @xmath148 and @xmath221 are yukawa bound @xmath23 mesons with an operative heavy isospin , from degenerate chiral quark doublet @xmath47 not too far above the unitarity bound . thus , our @xmath148 and @xmath221 mesons are much heavier than those in low scale tc . for more generic tc models @xcite , since walking " is generally required , the technipion @xmath332 tends to be closer to the technirho @xmath333 in mass such that @xmath334 is absent , while ( near ) degeneracy of @xmath335 and @xmath336 with @xmath333 is also often invoked . the signature for these technimesons are typically @xmath337 , @xmath338 and @xmath339 . thus , not only the spectrum is rather different absence of @xmath31 and @xmath340 mesons the decay signature is also in strong contrast . the bound states due to strong yukawa coupling , which follow simply from the existence of new heavy chiral quarks without assuming new dynamics , should be easily distinguished from technicolor . the yukawa - bound ultraheavy mesons are also quite distinct from qcd bound states . not only there is the absence of @xmath33 ( where @xmath147 fusion would be possible ) and @xmath31 type mesons , they have a much larger binding energy , and are much smaller in size . this is brought about by not only a strong coupling constant , but facilitated by a @xmath40 coupling due to goldstone or longitudinal vector bosons ; the @xmath341 higgs boson , being heavy , would in fact be subdominant . thus , the tight bound states involve ultrarelativistic motion of its very heavy constituents , hence somewhat counterintuitive . by far we have not attempted any actual solution of the bound state problem here . we therefore chose to remain close to the unitarity bound , considering bound state masses not more than 1.5 tev . we have chose to parameterize with a few key parameters . our numerics , and associated phenomenology , should be viewed as only illustrative , with the _ key parameters to be determined by experiment_. what mass scale would nature actually choose , if she so chooses to offer an extra chiral doublet above the existing three generations ? it may be related to the electroweak symmetry breaking through @xmath36 condensation . it could in principle lead to very deeply bound states , with binding energy approaching @xmath42 order or more . we have only scratched the surface of yukawa - bound heavy mesons , the treatment of which would require genuine nonperturbative methods , such as @xcite lattice field theory . paradoxically , it is not impossible that heavier quark masses than considered here could result in lower heavy meson masses . again , experiment might take the lead here . with the experimental limits on sequential chiral 4th generation already at 500 gev , i.e. at the doorsteps of the unitarity bound , we have considered the possibility of new @xmath36 mesons bound by strong yukawa couplings . comparing a relativistic expansion approach ( which indicated nonapplicability ) , versus a relativistic bethe salpeter equation approach , we chose to illustrate what might appear in early data of lhc running , i.e. bound states just above the tev scale , but with relatively complicated decay final states . electroweak precision tests suggest a new ( heavy ) isospin symmetry , such that the leading production would be a color octet , isosinglet vector meson , which we call @xmath148 . it can be produced via @xmath4 fusion , through an unknown decay constant , @xmath149 . for decay , the key parameters besides @xmath149 are the quark mixing element @xmath13 , and the mass differences @xmath262 and @xmath269 where @xmath221 is a heavy color octet pion " and @xmath238 a color singlet we find the leading decay is likely @xmath285 , while the other transition channel into @xmath258 is relatively suppressed . the other leading decay is free " , or constituent , quark decay . illustrating with four cases for large / small decay constant , nominal / suppressed mass differences or @xmath13 , together with the two decay channels of free quark decay and @xmath11 decay of @xmath221 , we considered the possible lhc phenomenology . we find in general the @xmath37 to be narrow compared to its mass . the special case of small @xmath13 leads to two possible spectacular signatures . one is @xmath342 , where a massive back - to - back @xmath11 system is accompanied by a relatively soft @xmath15 . this mode could become suppressed if @xmath262 is close to or less than @xmath196 . then , one could have a dijet resonance close to current lhc limits , and a narrow dijet resonance could appear soon . in the general case , dijet signal is suppressed by a decay branching ratio . other than the above two ( perhaps unlikely ) spectacular signals , the generic leading decay is @xmath343 , @xmath344 , followed by free quark decay of @xmath221 ( @xmath287 is typically subdominant ) . this leads to possible multijet signals with an associated relatively soft @xmath15 or @xmath292 tag , where the multijet system is very massive , and with multiple @xmath16 , @xmath15 and @xmath17 jet substructures . if such massive multijet systems can be studied , one could possibly reconstruct both the @xmath221 and @xmath148 resonances . assuming single channel dominance , one can measure the meson decay constant by the total cross section . if @xmath285 is suppressed by kinematics , however , the likely leading decay would be by the constituent heavy quark decay , which is very similar to standard @xmath23 signal , except one heavy quark decays somewhat off - shell . since in any case the leading @xmath327 fusion does not exhibit resonance phenomena , _ the current 4th generation @xmath18 and @xmath19 search can continue beyond the unitarity bound_. but if 4 g quarks are discovered , then some good fraction of the events would have one quark decaying below threshold , indicating bound state phenomena . one , of course , would have to disentangle also @xmath285 , as already discussed . we have provide some definite signatures for yukawa - bound heavy @xmath23 mesons in the 1 to 1.5 tev range . but our study is only of precursory nature . as lhc energy increases , and with higher luminosity , it could uncover new chiral quarks above the unitarity bound , with new unusual bound states . one could probe into the truly nonperturbative regime , which our results only offer a glimpse of what might happen . there may be a host of new heavy mesons awaiting us beyond the horizon . 0.3 cm * acknowledgement*. we thank k .- f . chen , a. djouadi , k. ishiwata , b. kniel , t. kugo , m.b . wise , b .- young and c .- p . yuan for discussions , and k. hagiwara for encouraging comments . wsh thanks the national science council for academic summit grant nsc 99 - 2745-m-002 - 002-asp , and te and hy are supported under nsc 100 - 2811-m-002 - 061 and nsc 100 - 2119-m-002 - 001 . this has been explored , in the context of the nambu jona - lasinio model , by w.a . bardeen , c.t . hill and m. lindner , phys . d * 41 * , 1647 ( 1990 ) . the authors credit the idea to y. nambu , bootstrap symmetry breaking in electroweak unification " , efi preprint 89 - 08 ( 1989 ) . for a recent brief review on the 4th generation , see b. holdom _ et al . _ , pmc phys . a * 3 * , 4 ( 2009 ) . b.w . lee , c. quigg and h.b . thacker , phys . rev . lett . * 38 * , 883 ( 1977 ) ; phys . d * 16 * , 1519 ( 1977 ) . kribs , t. plehn , m. spannowsky and t.m.p . tait , phys . d * 76 * , 075016 ( 2007 ) ; h .- j . he , n. polonsky and s .- f . su , phys . d * 64 * , 053004 ( 2001 ) ; v.a . novikov , l.b . okun , a.n . rozanov and m.i . vysotsky , jetp lett . * 76 * , 127 ( 2002 ) [ pisma zh . fiz . * 76 * , 158 ( 2002 ) ] . j. pumplin _ et al . _ , jhep * 0207 * , 012 ( 2002 ) . r. baier and r. rckl , z. phys . c * 19 * , 251 ( 1983 ) . et al . _ , d * 35 * , 3366 ( 1987 ) [ erratum - ibid . d * 38 * , 1632 ( 1988 ) ] . p. nason , s. dawson and r.k . ellis , nucl . b * 303 * , 607 ( 1988 ) . a. petrelli _ et al . _ , nucl . b * 514 * , 245 ( 1998 ) . y. sumino _ et al . _ , phys . d * 47 * , 56 ( 1993 ) . m. jezabek , j.h . khn and t. teubner , z. phys . c * 56 * , 653 ( 1992 ) . s. chatrchyan _ et al . _ [ cms collaboration ] , phys . b * 701 * , 204 ( 2011 ) . this effect is examined for the top quark case in the @xmath345 resonance region , in y. sumino and h. yokoya , jhep * 1009 * , 034 ( 2010 ) . t. aaltonen _ et al . _ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . lett . * 106 * , 171801 ( 2011 ) . note that this has been refuted by the d0 collaboration , v.m . abazov _ et al . _ [ d0 collaboration ] , _ ibid . _ * 107 * , 011804 ( 2011 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: since the discovery of superconductivity in the copper oxide ceramics ( cuprates ) @xcite , both theoretical and experimental efforts have been made to investigate the physical mechanism responsible for superconductivity with an unprecedented high transition temperature @xmath0 ( for recent reviews see refs . @xcite ) . despite this , an understanding of the superconducting pairing of the high - temperature superconductors is still lacking . + very soon after the discovery of the high temperature superconductors , it was realized @xcite that superconductivity were intimately related to the square planar @xmath1 lattice . moreover , the physics of the @xmath1 planes were well described by the nearly half - filled hubbard model with moderately on - site coulomb repulsion . + the microscopic model for the description of electrons in the @xmath1 layers is believed to be the effective single - band hubbard model : @xmath2 \ , + \ , u \ , \sum_{i } \hat{n}_{i,\uparrow } \ , \hat{n}_{i,\downarrow } \ ; \ ; , \ ; \ ; \hat{n}_{i,\sigma } \ , = \ , \hat{c}^{\dagger}_{i,\sigma } \ , \hat{c}_{i,\sigma } \ ; , % \ ] ] where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are creation and annihilation operators for electrons with spin @xmath5 , @xmath6 is the onsite coulomb repulsion for electrons of opposite spin at the same atomic orbital , and @xmath7 is the hopping parameter . as is well known @xcite , the superexchange mechanism yields a heisenberg antiferromagnetic exchange interaction with @xmath8 between spins on the @xmath9 atoms . since @xmath10 , at half - filling the onsite coulomb repulsion gives an insulator where the electron spins are antiferromagnetically ordered . + the phase diagram resulting from tuning the doping of @xmath1 planes with holes is shown schematically in fig . [ fig-1 ] . at half - filling , corresponding to @xmath11 , we have a mott insulator with long range antiferromagnetic order which disappears for temperatures above the critical nel temperature @xmath12 ( not shown in fig . [ fig-1 ] ) . schematic phase diagram of hole - doped cuprate high - temperature superconductors . carrier concentrations @xmath13 near to the maximum critical temperature @xmath14 locate the optimal doped region . regions with lower and larger hole concentration are called underdoped and overdoped , respectively . the temperature @xmath15 is the pseudogap temperature . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] by adding holes into the @xmath1 planes ( @xmath16 ) the long range antiferromagnetic order is rapidly destroyed . superconductivity occurs beyond a minimal hole content @xmath17 where there is no long - range antiferromagnetic order . nevertheless , signs of magnetism persist @xcite in the hole - doped materials with @xmath18 as local order on a short length scale @xmath19 , as observed in muon spin relaxation @xcite and neutron scattering @xcite measurements . + the superconducting critical temperature @xmath0 rises with increasing hole doping through the underdoped region ( @xmath20 ) , reaches a peak at optimal doping @xmath21 , falls away at higher doping @xmath22 ( overdoped region ) , and then vanishes at the maximal doping @xmath23 . this peculiar doping dependence of the critical temperature @xmath0 is a generic feature of the hole - doped copper oxides . another generic feature of the high - temperature cuprate superconductors is the presence of a pseudogap @xmath24 ( @xmath25 being the boltzmann s constant ) in the underdoped region @xmath26 . the pseudogap was first detected in the temperature dependence of the spin - lattice relaxation , knight shift , and magnetic susceptibility studies . the pseudogap temperature @xmath15 is much larger than the superconducting critical temperature @xmath0 in the underdoped region . moreover , @xmath27 decreases upon increasing the doping and seems to merge with @xmath28 for @xmath21 . in the overdoped region , however , the coexistence of the superconducting gap with the pseudogap is still subject to an intense debate . + the challenge is to find a theory that is rooted in the microscopic physics of the copper oxides which is able to account for the physics of the pseudogap and the superconductivity . one of the problem in constructing a satisfactory microscopic theory of the high - temperature superconductivity is to isolate that part of the interaction which is responsible for both the pseudogap and the superconductivity in cuprates . the purpose of this paper is to present an approach which , according to the spirit of the conventional superconductivity theory of bardeen , cooper , and schrieffer @xcite ( bcs ) , allows to isolate an effective hamiltonian governing the dynamics of the electrons or holes injected into the undoped copper - oxide planes . we shall assume that the superconductivity originates into the @xmath1 planes , and thereby we shall neglect the motion along the direction perpendicular to the planes . we further assume that electron dynamics in the @xmath1 planes is described by the single - band effective hubbard model with hamiltonian given by eq . ( [ 1.1 ] ) . since the majority of high - temperature cuprate superconductors are hole - doped , we shall focus mainly on hole - doped cuprates . nevertheless , in section [ 6 ] we briefly discuss also the electron - doped cuprates ( for a recent review , see ref . @xcite ) . + the plan of the paper is as follows . in sect . [ 2 ] we set up the effective interaction between two holes in an antiferromagnetic background and we discuss the main assumptions of the paper . section [ 3 ] is devoted to a general discussion of the physical structure of the superconducting ground state . in sect . [ 3 - 1 ] we discuss the real - space d - wave bound states of two holes ; in sect . [ 3 - 2 ] we address the problem of the superconductivity and pseudogap in the underdoped region . in sect . [ 3 - 3 ] we discuss the d - wave bcs ground state and argue that it is relevant in the overdoped region . in sect . [ 3 - 4 ] we present our understanding of the phase diagram of hole - doped cuprates . the physics of the underdoped region is presented in sect . [ 4 ] where we discuss the real - space bound states in an external magnetic field ( sect . [ 4 - 1 ] ) , the upper critical magnetic field ( sect . [ 4 - 2 ] ) , the vortex region ( sect . [ 4 - 3 ] ) , the physics of fermi arcs and quantum oscillations ( sect . [ 4 - 4 ] ) . section [ 5 ] is devoted to the discussion of the physics in the overdoped and optimal doped regions together with the crossover between the underdoped region and the overdoped region . in sect . [ 6 ] we briefly address the problem of superconductivity and pseudogap in the electron - doped cuprates . finally , in section [ 7 ] we summarize the main achievements of the paper and we draw our conclusions in this section we set up our effective hamiltonian for the dynamics of holes in the nearly half - filled single - band hubbard model . as discussed in the introduction , we are assuming that the superconductivity in cuprates is related to the square planar @xmath1 lattice . the single - band hamiltonian is given by eq . ( [ 1.1 ] ) , where @xmath29 denotes a pair of nearest - neighbor sites of a square lattice with lattice constant @xmath30 ( see fig . [ fig-2 ] ) . let @xmath31 be the number of sites of the copper lattice and @xmath32 the number of electrons . in the half filled lattice @xmath33 , i.e. there is exactly one electron per site . in the underfilled case @xmath34 there are holes with doping fraction ( number of holes per site ) : @xmath35 in the subspace of the state space of avoided double occupancies of @xmath9 sites , the one - band hubbard model may be canonically transformed into the so - called @xmath36 hamiltonian : @xmath37 \ , + \ , j \ , \sum_{<i , j > } \left [ { \vec{s}}_i \cdot { \vec{s}}_j \ ; - \ ; \frac{1}{4 } \ ; \hat{n}_{i } \ , \hat{n}_{j } \right ] \ ; \ ; , % \ ] ] where @xmath38 and @xmath39 is the spin-@xmath40 operator at site @xmath41 . the idealized square copper plane with lattice spacing @xmath30 . the dashed ellipses represent two holes in an antiferromagnetic background . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] since at half - filling @xmath42 , the @xmath36 hamiltonian eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) reduces to the square lattice heisenberg hamiltonian : @xmath43 the ground state of the latter hamiltonian is known to be the antiferromagnetic nel state . when the system is doped with holes away from half filling ( @xmath16 ) , the dynamics is no longer described by the heisenberg hamiltonian eq . ( [ 2.4 ] ) , but one must use the @xmath36 hamiltonian eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) with the supplementary constraint of no double occupied lattice sites . it is easy to see that the motion of dilute holes in the antiferromagnetic nel background is strongly frustrate . indeed , when a hole hops from one site to its nearest neighbor , a spin is also moved onto one lattice site with the wrong spin orientation with respect to the antiferromagnetic background . on the other hand , a pair of holes with nearest - neighbor distance ( see fig . [ fig-2 ] ) can move almost freely without destroying the antiferromagnetic background . the effective hamiltonian for the propagation of the holes in the antiferromagnetic background can be written as @xcite : @xmath44 where @xmath45 , @xmath46 are creation and annihilation operators for holes at the lattice site @xmath47 and the sum over the direction vectors @xmath48 and @xmath49 is restricted to next - nearest neighbor lattice sites . note that in the effective hamiltonian @xmath50 we do not display the spin of the holes since the antiferromagnetic background forces the two holes to have antiparallel spins . in other words , the motion of a hole must not disturb the antiferromagnetic background . moreover , in this antiferromagnetic background approximation , it turns out that there is an effective attractive two - body potential between nearest - neighbor holes @xcite . however , it has been pointed out @xcite that the motion of a pair of holes , which naively should be mobile , is frustrated due to fermionic nature of the background spins . indeed , for states with two holes as nearest neighbors in an antiferromagnetic background it is easy to see @xcite that there are configurations that differ by the exchange of two electrons . the destructive interference of these configurations leads to holes with very large effective mass . this problem can be avoided if we consider pairs of hole with distance much greater than the lattice spacing . accordingly , we shall suppose that two holes with distance @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the antiferromagnetic local order length scale , are subject to an effective attractive two - body potential . our proposal is quite similar to the spin - bag theory @xcite where the pairing is due to a local reduction of the antiferromagnetic order ( bag ) shared by two holes . + thus , we are lead to consider the following reduced interaction hamiltonian : @xmath53 the simplest choice for the two - body potential @xmath54 is : @xmath55 where the hard - core at the origin is imposed to avoid configurations where two holes are on the same site . moreover , since we are considering the limit of low carriers , @xmath56 , the hard - core potential does not allow two holes to come too close , thereby implementing the no - double occupation constraint . as concern the range of our potential @xmath57 , it is natural to choice @xmath57 of the order of the coherence length @xmath58 . so that we assume : @xmath59 the peculiar dependence on the doping fraction @xmath13 arises as follows . the attractive two - body potential originates from the interaction of two holes in the antiferromagnetic background which extends over a distance of order @xmath52 . since the injected holes tend to destruct the antiferromagnetic order , the area of the antiferromagnetic islands should decrease with increasing @xmath13 . in addition , as discussed in the introduction ( see fig . [ fig-1 ] ) , the superconducting instability disappears at the maximal doping @xmath60 . the simplest parameterization which takes care of these effects leads to our eq . ( [ 2.8 ] ) . regarding the parameter @xmath61 in eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) , we have fixed this parameter such that there is at least one real space d - wave bound state . to this end it suffices to assume : @xmath62 in the following we will use the numerical values : @xmath63 that are appropriate for a typical cuprate . note that the resulting nel temperature : @xmath64 is of the order of the observed nel temperatures in cuprates . + before concluding this section , we would like to rewrite the hamiltonian @xmath50 eq . ( [ 2.5 ] ) in the limit of low - lying excitations . observing that @xmath50 can be diagonalized by writing : @xmath65 so that : @xmath66 we get : @xmath67 where : @xmath68 \ ; .\ ] ] we now take the small - k limit : @xmath69 with : @xmath70 so that we may write for the effective hamiltonian : @xmath71 where we make explicit the spin degrees of freedom . using the numerical values of the parameters we obtain : @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the electron mass . to summarize , our effective hamiltonian for low - lying excitations may be described by : @xmath74 with @xmath50 and @xmath75 given by eqs . ( [ 2.18 ] ) and ( [ 2.6 ] ) respectively . it is worthwhile to stress that the arguments developed in this section can not be considered as a truly microscopic derivation of the effective hamiltonian eq . ( [ 2.20 ] ) . for later convenience it is useful to think about the wave function of the superconducting ground state within the bcs theory . let @xmath76 be the wavefunction of a cooper pair @xcite , thus the superconducting ground state may be expressed as an antisymmetrized product of identical pair functions : @xmath77 in which the sum is over all permutations p of the n particles . the expression eq . ( [ 3.1 ] ) may be used to point out the analogies and differences between the superconducting ground state and that of a bose - einstein condensation of pairs @xcite . indeed , a bose - einstein condensate of pairs would also be given as a product of identical pair wavefunctions . the process of antisymmetrizing would not change the character of the state very much if the size of the pair wavefunction , @xmath78 , were small compared with the average spacing between pairs . in this case , wavefunctions in the sum differing by the exchange of single members of two or more pairs would not overlap very much , and the system would behave qualitatively like a condensed bose - einstein gas . however , antisymmetrization makes a major difference if the size of the pair wavefunction is large compared with the spacing between pairs . in this case , it is convenient to rewrite the superconducting ground - state wavefunction eq . ( [ 3.1 ] ) in the second quantization formalism . to this end , we introduce the creation operator of a pair at rest : @xmath79 then , the wavefunction eq . ( [ 3.1 ] ) can be written as : @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the vacuum , and @xmath82 is the number of pairs . now , from the identity @xcite : @xmath83 } \ ; | 0 > \ ; , \ ] ] we argue that the state : @xmath84 } \ ; | 0 > \ ] ] is the superconducting ground state for a system with varying number of particles . obviously , in that case the relevant hamiltonian is @xmath85 , where @xmath86 is the chemical potential . from eq . ( [ 3.2 ] ) we obtain : @xmath87 where : @xmath88 } \ ; \varphi(\vec{q } ) \ ; .\ ] ] using eq . ( [ 3.6 ] ) it is easy to find : @xmath89\ ; |0 > \ ; , \ ] ] with the normalization factor @xmath90 . indeed , eq . ( [ 3.8 ] ) agrees with the well - known bcs variational ground state : @xmath91\ ; |0 > \ ; , \ ] ] with the normalization : @xmath92 as we discuss later on , the superconducting ground - state wave function in the form of eq . ( [ 3.1 ] ) will be of relevance in the underdoped region , while in the overdoped region the bcs variational ground state eq . ( [ 3.9 ] ) would be more appropriate . [ [ 3 - 1 ] ] we are interested in the problem of two holes in interaction with the effective two - body potential eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) . the resulting schrdinger equation is : @xmath93 \ ; \phi ( \vec{r}_1 - \vec{r}_2 ) = \ ; e \ ; \phi ( \vec{r}_1 - \vec{r}_2 ) \ ; .\ ] ] according to the reduced interaction hamiltonian eq . ( [ 2.6 ] ) the holes have antiparallel spins , so that the wavefunction @xmath94 must be symmetric under hole interchange . introducing : we rewrite eq . ( [ 3.11 ] ) as : @xmath96 \ ; \phi ( \vec{r } , \vec{r } ) = \ ; e \ ; \phi ( \vec{r } , \vec{r } ) \ ; , \ ] ] whereupon : @xmath97 @xmath98 @xmath99 \ ; \varphi ( \vec{r } ) = - \ ; \delta \ ; \varphi ( \vec{r } ) \ ; .\ ] ] without loss in generality , we may assume that the center of mass of the pair is at rest , @xmath100 . since the potential is central we may adopt polar coordinates . we have : @xmath101 inserting into eq . ( [ 3.16 ] ) and using eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) we get : @xmath102 @xmath103 \ ; \varphi_m ( r ) = \ ; 0 \ ; \ ; , \ ; \ ; 0 \ ; < \ ; r \ ; < \ ; r_0(\delta ) \ ; , \ ] ] @xmath104 \ ; \varphi_m ( r ) = \ ; 0 \ ; \ ; , \ ; \ ; r_0(\delta ) \ ; < \ ; r \ ; \ ; .\ ] ] since @xmath105 is even and must satisfy eq . ( [ 3.18 ] ) , we have @xmath106 . with our choice of the parameters , ( [ 2.8 ] ) , ( [ 2.9 ] ) and ( [ 2.10 ] ) , it is straightforward to check that there are bound states ( @xmath107 ) only for @xmath108 ( d - wave ) . in this case we get : @xmath109 where @xmath110 and @xmath111 are bessel functions , @xmath112 and @xmath113 with the further definitions : @xmath114 one can rewrite eq . ( [ 3.23 ] ) as : @xmath115 it is not too hard to see that eq . ( [ 3.25 ] ) allows non trivial solutions if the _ effective _ wall - depth @xmath116 satisfies : @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the solution of : @xmath119 the gap @xmath120 versus the hole doping fraction @xmath13 . according to eq . ( [ 3.28 ] ) @xmath121 . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] from eq ( [ 3.26 ] ) it follows that there are non trivial solutions for hole doping such that : @xmath122 in fact , in fig [ fig-3 ] we display @xmath120 versus the hole doping fraction @xmath13 . we see that the gap @xmath120 decreases rapidly with @xmath13 and vanishes at @xmath123 according to eq . ( [ 3.28 ] ) . note that , with our parameters , we have @xmath124 which should be compared with @xmath125 . the normalized d - wave wavefunction @xmath126 for @xmath127 . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] from figure [ fig-4 ] , where we display the normalized wavefunction @xmath128 , eq . ( [ 3.21 ] ) , for a typical value of @xmath13 , we see that our bound - state wavefunction extends up to distance @xmath129 . + since the eigenvalue equations eqs . ( [ 3.19 ] ) and ( [ 3.20 ] ) depend on @xmath130 , the general d - wave wavefunction is a linear combination of @xmath128 and @xmath131 . from the geometry of the @xmath1 planes we are lead to assume : @xmath132 where the coordinate axis are directed along the @xmath133 bond directions as in fig . [ fig-2 ] . this is the most natural choice since the wavefunction is sizable along the @xmath133 bonds and vanishes at @xmath134 . for later convenience , we need to evaluate the fourier transform of the wavefunction eq . ( [ 3.29 ] ) . we have : @xmath135 assuming that the @xmath136 , @xmath137 axis are oriented along the copper - oxygen bond directions , and using the expansion : @xmath138 } \ ; j_m ( kr ) \ ; , \ ] ] we readily obtain : @xmath139 where : @xmath140 remarkably , we see that the fourier transform of the wavefunction vanishes along the _ nodal _ directions : @xmath141 while it is sizable along the _ antinodal _ directions : @xmath142 these features are reminiscent of the observed pseudogap in the underdoped region . therefore , we are lead to identify @xmath120 with the pseudogap and to introduce the pseudogap temperature according to : @xmath143 [ [ 3 - 2 ] ] we have shown in the previous section that , as long as @xmath144 , it is energetically favored to pair two holes into a d - wave bound state with wavefunction given by eq . ( [ 3.29 ] ) . then , we may construct the superconducting ground state according to eq . ( [ 3.1 ] ) with @xmath145 . however , although the formation of cooper pairs is essential in forming the superconducting state , its remarkable properties , i.e. zero resistance and perfect diamagnetism , require phase coherence among the pairs . in the underdoped region @xmath146 we infer from fig . [ fig-4 ] that the size of the pair is small with respect to the average distance between holes . so that the ground state wavefunction eq . ( [ 3.1 ] ) reduces to the ground state of a bose - einstein gas of paired holes . in this case the required phase coherence is established by the condensation of pairs . however , in two spatial dimensions it is well known that there is no bose - einstein condensation . thus we are lead to conclude that in the extremely underdoped region @xmath146 there is a pseudogap @xmath120 but not superconductivity . however , by increasing @xmath13 it will be a certain minimal value of the hole doping fraction @xmath147 where the pairs become to overlap . to estimate @xmath147 , we observe that the pair wavefunction @xmath148 extends up to distance @xmath149 . thus , to have overlap between different hole pairs we need at least two holes in a square of size @xmath150 . thereby we estimate : @xmath151 which agrees , remarkably , with the observed value @xmath17 for the onset of the superconductivity in the hole - doped cuprates . once the pairs begin to overlap , the phases of the pairs are locked to a constant value . indeed , it is well known that a condensate with varying phase @xmath152 contribute to the ground state energy with : @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the so - called phase stiffness . in our case we have : @xmath155 with the superfluid density given by : @xmath156 the pseudogap and berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless temperatures ( in kelvin ) versus @xmath157 . we assume @xmath158.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] as is well known @xcite , the phase coherence of the condensate survives up to the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( b - k - t ) critical temperature : @xmath159 for temperatures above @xmath160 the phase coherence and the superconductivity is lost due to the thermal activation of vortex excitations . if we neglect the temperature dependence of the phase stiffness , we obtain : @xmath161 using our numerical values for @xmath7 and @xmath6 we get : @xmath162 in figure [ fig-5 ] we display the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless critical temperature together with the pseudogap temperature @xmath15 versus the hole doping fraction by assuming @xmath158 . we see that in our approach the superconductivity transition in the underdoped region is described by the @xmath163 transition at @xmath164 , which coexists with the much higher pseudogap temperature @xmath15 . this picture is supported by a large amounts of observational data which , however , will be discussed in details in sect . [ 4 ] . [ [ 3 - 3 ] ] to complete the phase diagram of the hole - doped cuprate superconductors we must address the problem of the ground state for @xmath165 . since the pseudogap @xmath120 vanishes at @xmath166 , we do not have real - space paired holes and , whence , the @xmath163 critical temperature can not be defined . on the other hand , as long as @xmath167 , the attractive two - body potential eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) is short - range and can be considered as a small perturbation . as a consequence , in the overdoped region @xmath165 the normal state is described by the hamiltonian @xmath50 , eq . ( [ 2.18 ] ) . in other words , the normal state properties are those of ordinary fermi liquid metals that is characterized by hole quasiparticles with effective mass given by eq . ( [ 2.17 ] ) and density : @xmath168 in fact , in the overdoped side of the superconducting phase diagram , experiments strongly suggest that above the critical temperature the full fermi surface is restored with well - defined quasiparticles . thereby this confirms the applicability of a fermi liquid picture . moreover , quantum oscillation experiments @xcite in an overdoped high - temperature superconductor are consistent with hole quasiparticles with density given by eq . ( [ 3.44 ] ) and effective mass : @xmath169 in fair agreement with our estimate , eq . ( [ 2.19 ] ) . + the superconductive instability is driven by the short - range attractive interaction between the quasiparticles . we see , then , that the pairing is in momentum space , so that the relevant superconducting ground state is the bcs variational ground state eq . ( [ 3.9 ] ) with hamiltonian @xmath170 , where the chemical potential is essentially the fermi energy : @xmath171 the relevant gap equation has been discussed since long time @xcite : @xmath172 where : @xmath173 and @xmath174 } \ ; v(r ) \ ; .\ ] ] using the expansion eq . ( [ 3.31 ] ) we may recast eq . ( [ 3.47 ] ) into : @xmath175 with : @xmath176 equation ( [ 3.50 ] ) suggests that : @xmath177 in the weak coupling limit one expects that the mixing of different partial wave @xmath178 will be small @xcite . therefore eq . ( [ 3.50 ] ) reduces to : @xmath179 since the bcs gap in the limit of localized pairs is proportional to the bound - state wave function in momentum space , we conclude that eq . ( [ 3.53 ] ) admits non trivial solutions for the d - wave gap ( @xmath180 ) . moreover , from eq . ( [ 3.32 ] ) we infer that : @xmath181 thus , we obtain the following gap equation : @xmath182 ^ 2 } \ ; \ ; \frac { v_2(k , k ' ) \delta_{bcs}(k ' ) } { \sqrt { \xi^2_{\vec{k } ' } + [ \delta_{bcs}(k ' ) \cos{(2 \theta_{k'})}]^2 } } \ ; .\ ] ] since the gap is sizable on the fermi surface , we may further simplify eq . ( [ 3.55 ] ) as : @xmath183 ^ 2 } { \sqrt { \xi^2_{\vec{k } ' } + [ \delta_{bcs } \cos{(2 \theta_{k'})}]^2 } } \ ] ] where @xmath184 and @xmath185 . a standard calculation gives : @xmath186 ^ 2 } { \sqrt { \xi^2 + [ \delta_{bcs } \cos{(2 \theta)}]^2 } } \ ] ] where @xmath187 is an energy cut - off much smaller than the fermi energy . performing the integrals and using the approximation : @xmath188 \ ; \simeq \ ; \ln { \left [ \frac{2 \varepsilon_c } { \delta_{bcs } |\cos{(2 \theta)| } } \right ] } \ ; , \ ] ] we get : @xmath189 } \ ; , \ ] ] where : @xmath190 ^ 2 \ ; .\ ] ] the pseudogap and bcs critical temperatures ( in kelvin ) versus the hole doping fraction . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] to obtain the critical temperature , we note that @xcite : @xmath191 @xmath192 being the euler s constant . as concern the high - energy cut - off , it is natural to identify @xmath187 with @xmath193 which , indeed , is much smaller than the fermi energy in the range of hole doping fraction of interest . in summary , we obtain for the critical temperature @xmath194 : @xmath195 } \ ; .\ ] ] equation ( [ 3.62 ] ) shows that the bcs critical temperature depends on the hole doping fraction . in fact , in fig . [ fig-6 ] we compare @xmath196 with the pseudogap temperature @xmath27 . it is evident that for @xmath197 we have a non - zero bcs d - wave gap . note that the undulations on the critical temperature curve is an artifact of the sharp cut - off of the effective interaction potential at @xmath198 . [ [ 3 - 4 ] ] we are , now , in position of discuss the phase diagram of the hole - doped cuprates . in fig . [ fig-7 ] we display the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( @xmath160 ) , the pseudogap ( @xmath15 ) , and the bcs ( @xmath199 ) temperatures versus the hole doping fraction @xmath13 . the pseudogap , berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless , and bcs critical temperatures ( in kelvin ) versus the hole doping fraction @xmath157 . the region enclosed by the ellipse where the three temperatures are comparable is the optimal doped region . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] in our approach the superconducting dome - shaped region of the phase diagram of oxide cuprates is determined by the region enclosed by the two critical temperatures @xmath160 and @xmath199 . the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless temperature increases with the doping @xmath13 , while the bcs critical temperature decreases with increasing hole doping . these temperatures are comparable for @xmath200 . accordingly , we individuate three regions in the phase diagram : * the underdoped region @xmath201 ; * the optimal doped region @xmath202 ; * the overdoped region @xmath203 . in fig . [ fig-7 ] we have also displayed the pseudogap temperature @xmath27 which decreases rapidly with increasing doping , meets the superconducting dome in the optimal doped region , and vanishes beyond a critical doping level @xmath204 within the optimal doped region . in the following sections we shall discuss the physical properties which characterize the three regions and compare with selected experimental observations supporting our proposal the underdoped region in all hole - doped high - temperature superconductors is characterized by the presence of the pseudogap . in general it is assumed that the pseudogap has a d - wave structure . moreover , there is a general agreement on the doping dependence of the pseudogap . for instance , recently the authors of ref . @xcite used angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy to probe the electronic excitations in underdoped @xmath205 . these authors find evidence of a nodal liquid whose excitation gap vanishes only at points in momentum space which are consistent with the gap structure of a d - wave superconductors . in particular , these authors show that the measured gap in momentum space is consistent with : @xmath206 where @xmath207 monotonically increase with underdoping . in fact , eq . ( [ 4.1 ] ) is consistent with our eq . ( [ 3.32 ] ) and the doping dependence of the pseudogap ( see fig . [ fig-3 ] ) . however , it should be stressed that many experiments report a gap that deviates from the simple relation in eq . ( [ 4.1 ] ) @xcite . in fact , several experimental studies are consistent with the presence of two gaps , namely the pseudogap and a peculiar nodal gap . we believe that this nodal gap is related to the dynamics of the nodal fermi liquid discussed in sect . [ 4 - 4 ] . then , we see that the nodal gap has naturally a d - wave symmetry with gapless nodes . on the other hand , the pseudogap being defined as the energy needed to break the real - space two - hole bound state , does not need to depend on the geometry of the fermi surface . however , a full account on this subject lies beyond the aim of the present paper . we plan to present a detailed discussion of this point in a separate paper . + as concern the pseudogap temperature , in fig . [ fig-8 ] , where we plot @xmath208 versus @xmath209 for various cuprates @xcite , we compare the experimental data with our relation eq . ( [ 3.36 ] ) which can be rewritten as : @xmath210 @xmath208 versus @xmath211 for various cuprates compared to our relation @xmath212 ( dashed line ) and the d - wave bcs relation @xmath213 ( dotted line ) . the data have been extracted from fig . 5 of ref . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] indeed , we see that the data are consistent with eq . ( [ 4.2 ] ) . we also plot in fig . [ fig-8 ] the d - wave bcs relation . ] : @xmath214 since eq . ( [ 4.3 ] ) is quite close to our eq . ( [ 4.2 ] ) , the data are consistent with both relations . in our opinion , this unfortunate circumstance is the origin of confusion and several misinterpretations in the literature . + in conclusion , according to our previous discussion , the observed gap opening in the density of states ( the pseudogap ) marks the onset of the hole pairing at rather high temperatures @xmath215 , but the critical temperature is set by the onset of phase coherence at lower temperatures @xmath216 . the above point of view is supported by several experiments . we believe that the most convincing evidence comes from ref . in fact , by using ultrathin films of ca - substituted @xmath217 , the authors of ref . @xcite found a clear evidence of the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless transition . in particular , they observe a remarkable scaling of the critical temperature with @xmath218 in accordance with eqs . ( [ 3.39 ] ) and ( [ 3.41 ] ) . further support on this picture comes from measurements of the high - frequency conductivity reported in ref . + to summarize , we may conclude that the key features of the underdoped side of the phase diagram are controlled by very strong hole pairing that is phase - disordered by fluctuations @xcite . in the following subsections , from a wealth of possible material , we have chosen to discuss some selected topics that we think well illustrate the physics of the underdoped region of hole - doped high - temperature superconductors . [ [ 4 - 1 ] ] we are interested in the dynamics of hole pairs in presence of an external magnetic field perpendicular to the copper - oxide plane : @xmath219 in this case the schrdinger equation eq . ( [ 3.11 ] ) becomes : @xmath220 \phi ( \vec{r}_1 , \vec{r}_2 ) % \nonumber \\ % + \ ; v(\vec{r}_1 - \vec{r}_2 ) \ ; \phi ( \vec{r}_1 , \vec{r}_2 ) \ ; = \ ; e \phi ( \vec{r}_1 , \vec{r}_2 ) \ ; \ ; . \end{aligned}\ ] ] it is useful to work in the symmetric gauge : @xmath221 where the angular momentum is conserved . using eq . ( [ 3.12 ] ) we recast eq . ( [ 4.5 ] ) into : @xmath222 \phi ( \vec{r } , \vec{r } ) % \nonumber \\ % + \ ; v(\vec{r } ) \ ; \phi ( \vec{r } , \vec{r } ) \ ; = \ ; e \phi ( \vec{r } , \vec{r } ) \ ; \ ; . \end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we can write : @xmath223 and @xmath224 such that : @xmath225 ^ 2 \psi ( \vec{r } ) % \ ; = \ ; e_{cond } \ ; \psi ( \vec{r } ) \ ; , \ ] ] @xmath226 \varphi ( \vec{r } ) % \ ; = \ ; - \ ; \delta \ ; \varphi ( \vec{r } ) \ ; .\ ] ] the wavefunction @xmath227 describes the condensate . in fact , @xmath228 is obtained from @xmath229 after averaging over the internal degree of freedom . moreover , if we write : @xmath230 } \ ; , \ ] ] we see that in presence of an external magnetic field the condensate acquires a non - uniform phase . for an almost uniform condensate we have : @xmath231 and @xmath152 is a slowly varying function . in this case we obtain : @xmath232 where the supercurrent velocity is given by the well - known relation @xcite : @xmath233 let us , now , consider eq . ( [ 4.11 ] ) in polar coordinates : @xmath234 \varphi(r,\theta ) = - \delta \varphi(r,\theta ) \ ; .\ ] ] again , after writing : @xmath235 we have : @xmath236 \varphi_m(r ) = - ( \delta_m(h ) + \frac { e \hbar m h}{2 m^*_h c } ) \ ; \varphi_m(r ) % \ ] ] this last equation shows that , as expected , the external magnetic field lifts the degeneracy @xmath237 . [ [ 4 - 2 ] ] we have already seen that for @xmath238 two holes give rise to a d - wave bound state . in presence of an external magnetic field the d - wave bound states are the solutions of our pervious eq . ( [ 4.18 ] ) specialized to @xmath239 : @xmath240 \varphi_{\pm 2}(r ) = - ( \delta_{\pm 2}(h ) \pm \frac { e \hbar h } { m^*_h c } ) \ ; \varphi_{\pm 2}(r ) \ ; . % \ ] ] we may , now , introduce the pair - breaking critical filed @xmath241 such that : @xmath242 to estimate the pair - breaking critical magnetic field we note that : @xmath243 where the pseudogap @xmath244 , already discussed in sect . [ 3 - 1 ] , can be approximated quite accurately by : @xmath245 \ ; \ ; , \ ; \ ; \delta _ { 2}(0 ) \ ; \simeq \ ; 41.91 \ ; mev \ ; .\ ] ] moreover , it is easy to see that the zeeman term can be neglected . in fact , using eq . ( [ 2.19 ] ) we find : @xmath246 where @xmath247 means that the strength of the magnetic field is measured in tesla . even though we are using cgs units , it is customary in the literature to express the applied magnetic field in tesla . ] . accordingly , we get from eq . ( [ 4.19 ] ) : @xmath248 since @xmath249 , we obtain : @xmath250 which leads to : @xmath251 the upper critical field @xmath252 versus the hole doping fraction @xmath13 according to eq . ( [ 4.31 ] ) assuming @xmath253 . the data have been extracted from fig . 18 of ref . @xcite ( full squares ) and fig . 4 of ref . @xcite ( full circles ) . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] equation ( [ 4.26 ] ) shows that the pair - breaking critical field is very high . this means that the pseudogap is not affected by applied magnetic fields @xmath254 in accordance with several experimental observations . + in conventional superconductors the pair - breaking critical filed is of the same order of the depairing critical field . in our case , it turns out that the depairing critical field is much smaller than the pair - breaking critical field . as a consequence , the upper critical field @xmath255 is determined by the depairing field . it is worthwhile to recall that in type - ii superconductors in the mixed state ( schubnikov phase ) between the lower critical field @xmath256 and the upper critical field @xmath255 , the magnetic flux penetrates in a regular array of flux tubes , each carrying a quantum flux : @xmath257 within each unit cell of the array there is a vortex of supercurrent concentrating the flux toward the vortex center . to estimate the critical velocity @xmath258 we use eqs . ( [ 4.9 ] ) and ( [ 4.14 ] ) to get : @xmath259 accordingly , the critical supercurrent is : @xmath260 from the maxwell equation @xmath261 we easily get the following estimate : @xmath262 since the magnetic field can be considered almost uniform over distance of order of the london penetration length @xmath263 , and considering that there are @xmath264 vortices in a region of area @xmath265 , we obtain our final estimate of the upper critical field : @xmath266 in fig . [ fig-9 ] we display our estimate of the upper critical field eq . ( [ 4.31 ] ) in the underdoped region @xmath144 . we see that in the deep underdoped region the upper critical field decreases with underdoping in accordance with recent measurements @xcite . in fig . [ fig-9 ] we also display the depairing critical field as determined from the nernst signal in refs . it is known that the cuprate superconductors have a large ginzburg - landau parameter @xmath267 and are , therefore , extreme type - ii superconductors . in fact , to compare quantitatively eq . ( [ 4.31 ] ) with experimental data we choose @xmath268 . it is gratifying to see that the doping dependence of our critical magnetic field as implied by eq . ( [ 4.31 ] ) seems to follows quite closely the experimental data . [ [ 4 - 3 ] ] in the underdoped region of the high - temperature cuprate superconductors there is convincing evidence for vortices at temperatures significantly above the critical temperature @xcite . indeed , our previous determination of the upper critical magnetic field shows that @xmath269 is different from zero even for @xmath270 , i.e. outside the superconducting dome in the phase diagram . to strengthen this point , following ref . @xcite , we define a critical vortex temperature @xmath271 by the phenomenological relation : @xmath272 where @xmath273 is the bohr magneton . the meaning of @xmath271 is that vortices are absent for @xmath274 . the pseudogap , berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless , and vortex temperatures ( in kelvin ) versus @xmath157 . the vortex region lies in between @xmath275 and @xmath160.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in fig . [ fig-10 ] we compare the vortex temperature to the critical berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless and pseudogap temperatures . for temperatures @xmath276 ( the so - called nernst region ) one should observe a large nernst signal well above the superconducting critical temperature , in accordance with observations . + we would like to conclude this section by addressing the puzzling observations of discrete core bound states in isolated vortices . in a classical paper @xcite , it was predicted the existence of electronic states bound to the core of an isolated vortex at energies below the superconducting gap in the case of s - wave bcs superconductors . since the spacing of the discrete spectrum turns out to be very small , these bound states lead to a continuum which manifests itself as a zero - bias conductance peak in scanning tunneling spectroscopy measurements . in high - temperature superconductors the scanning tunneling spectroscopy of isolated vortices revealed striking electronic signatures which can not be understood within the conventional bcs s - wave or d - wave theory . indeed , the vortex cores give evidence of a pair of states with energy which scales with the superconducting gap and do not depend on the applied magnetic field . if we denote with @xmath277 the energy of the vortex core states measured with respect to the zero - bias voltage , then there is a simple relation between the state energy and the superconducting gap @xcite : @xmath278 where the slope were obtained by a linear fit to all data points , and @xmath279 is the superconducting gap . we have already noted that the data are consistent with the relation ( see fig . [ fig-8 ] ) : @xmath280 so that , using eq . ( [ 4.2 ] ) , we may rewrite eq . ( [ 4.33 ] ) in terms of the pseudogap : @xmath281 to interpret this last remarkable relation , we refer to the schrdinger equation for the d - wave hole bound states in presence of an external magnetic field , eq . ( [ 4.18 ] ) with @xmath239 . we have shown that , neglecting the zeeman splitting , @xmath282 . thus , we infer that the pseudogap without the external magnetic field fixes the zero - bias voltage in the core of an isolated vortex . moreover , from eq . ( [ 4.18 ] ) it follows that there are two states whose energies measured with respect to the pseudogap are given by : @xmath283 where @xmath284 is the magnetic field inside the vortex core . to estimate @xmath284 , we note that the size of the isolated vortex can be determined by : @xmath285 where @xmath286 is the hole reduced mass . thus , the magnetic field in the vortex core can be obtained from : @xmath287 i.e. @xmath288 inserting eqs . ( [ 4.39 ] ) and eq . ( [ 4.37 ] ) into eq . ( [ 4.36 ] ) , we get : @xmath289 which is in satisfying agreement with eq . ( [ 4.35 ] ) . [ [ 4 - 4 ] ] the normal - state properties in the underdoped region of high - temperature cuprates are highly anomalous . it is now well - established by many angle - resolved photoemission studies that low - energy excitations are characterized by fermi arcs , namely truncate segments of a fermi surface . the resistivity obeys @xmath290 over a wide range of temperatures in striking contrast to a fermi - liquid law @xmath291 , expected for a conventional metals . moreover , several recent studies @xcite report unambiguous identification of quantum oscillations in high magnetic fields . interestingly enough , the measured low oscillation frequencies reveals a fermi surface made of small pockets . in fact , from the luttinger s theorem and the onsanger relation @xcite between the frequency and the cross - sectional area of the orbit , it turns out that the area of the pocket correspond to about @xmath292 of the first brillouin zone area in sharp contrast to that of overdoped cuprates where the frequency corresponds to a large hole fermi surface @xcite . in addition , the authors of ref . @xcite reported the observation of a negative hall resistance in the magnetic - field -induced normal state , which reveals that these pockets are electron - like rather than hole - like . more recently @xcite , experiments on the second harmonic quantum oscillations in underdoped high - temperature cuprates lead to the conclusion that there exists only a single underlying quasi - two dimensional fermi surface pocket . moreover , it turns out that the pocket is most likely associated with states near the nodal region of the brillouin zone . this nodal pocket comprises quasielectron carrier to explain both the high field quantum oscillations with negative hall and seebeck @xcite effect . finally , the recent studies of @xmath293 at very high magnetic fields indicate that the specific heat exhibits the conventional temperature dependence and quantum oscillations expected for a fermi liquid . moreover , the magnetic field dependence of the quasiparticle density of states follows the @xmath294 behavior pointing to a d - wave superconducting gap . thus , the specific heat data demonstrate the surprising coexistence of the signature of a fermi liquid and a d - wave superconducting gap over the entire magnetic field range measured . + in the present section we show that in our approach these features can be accounted for as a consequence of the pseudogap @xmath120 . we have already seen that , in the underdoped region @xmath144 , the holes are bound into pairs with k - space wavefunction given by eq . ( [ 3.32 ] ) . even though the pair wavefunction vanishes along the nodal directions @xmath295 ( @xmath296 ) , there are not nodal low - lying hole excitations . this is due to the fact that the pairing of the holes is in the real space and not in momentum space . on the other hand , due to the rotational symmetry , we may freely perform rigid rotations of the pairs without spending energy . the rigid rotations of pairs is equivalent to hopping of electrons according to the hopping term in the hamiltonian eq . ( [ 1.1 ] ) : @xmath297 \ ; . % \ ] ] we may diagonalize this hamiltonian by writing : @xmath298 to get : @xmath299 @xmath300 \ ; .\ ] ] in the small - k limit we have : @xmath301 where : @xmath302 since there are @xmath303 electrons per @xmath9 atoms , from the hamiltonian eq . ( [ 4.45 ] ) we may determine the electron fermi energy : @xmath304 at first glance , one expects that the quasielectrons fill in momentum space the circle with radius @xmath305 ( the electron fermi circle ) . however , one should keep in mind that the hopping of electrons is possible thanks to the paired holes . since in momentum space the wavefunction of a given pair is spread over a region around @xmath306 , we see that the wavefunction of quasielectrons is likewise localized on a region in k - space around @xmath307 . thus , the quasielectrons do not have the needed coherence to propagate over large distances with a well defined momentum . however , this argument does not apply along the nodal directions where the momentum space hole - pair wavefunction vanishes . therefore we are led to the conclusions that there are coherent quasielectrons that fill small circular sectors of the electron fermi circle around the nodal directions @xmath295 . thanks to the rotational symmetry , we have four circular sectors with the same area . since the number of coherent quasielectrons is determined by the doping fraction of holes ( assuming that all the holes are paired ) , we obtain ( see fig . [ fig-11 ] ) : @xmath308 i.e. @xmath309 the fermi sector and fermi arc in the first quadrant of the brillouin zone.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] we see , thus , that the fermi surface is made by four fermi arcs in agreement with the angle - resolved photoemission data . moreover , the area of the fermi sector with respect to the area of the fermi circle in overdoped region turns out to be : @xmath310 for the typical value of hole doping fraction @xmath311 , we infer from eq . ( [ 4.50 ] ) that @xmath312 is about @xmath313 of the first brillouin zone area in the overdoped region , in satisfying agreement with quantum oscillation experimental results . note that the effective quasielectron mass measured in quantum oscillation experiments lies in the range @xmath314 , in agreement with our estimate eq . ( [ 4.46 ] ) . + the drastic reduction of the available states in momentum space leads to a peculiar quasielectron conductivity . to see this , we may employ the simple drude model @xcite for the frequency - dependent conductivity : @xmath315 where , according to eq . ( [ 4.48 ] ) , @xmath316 . since the nodal quasielectrons suffer almost unidimensional scatterings , we get for the relaxation time the quite general estimate : @xmath317 and eq . ( [ 4.51 ] ) becomes : @xmath318 for @xmath319 we obtain the conductivity : @xmath320 on the other hand , if @xmath321 we get : @xmath322 these relations are in qualitative agreement with several observations . in particular eq . ( [ 4.54 ] ) should be valid up to temperatures of the order of the pseudogap temperature @xmath15 . + let us conclude this section by discussing the peculiar dependence of the specific heat on the applied magnetic field reported in ref . @xcite . firstly , we evaluate the sommerfeld coefficient for @xmath238 . a standard calculation gives : @xmath323 where @xmath324 is the avogadro s number . the authors of ref . @xcite found that at very high magnetic fields the specific heat in an underdoped high - temperature superconductors exhibits both the conventional temperature dependence and quantum oscillations expected for a fermi liquid . the oscillatory component of the specific heat is given by the lifshitz - kosevich formula @xcite . on the other hand , for the sommerfeld coefficient they report : @xmath325 with @xmath326 to compare our eq . ( [ 4.56 ] ) with eq . ( [ 4.58 ] ) one should keep in mind that there are two @xmath1 planes per formula unit in @xmath327 . moreover , the planar @xmath1 densities in high - temperature cuprates are difficult to estimate . assuming @xmath311 and using the effective electron mass eq . ( [ 4.46 ] ) , we find ( in mks units ) : @xmath328 which differs from measured value in eq . ( [ 4.58 ] ) by about a factor of @xmath329 . as far as field - induced sommerfeld coefficient is concerned , the behavior @xmath330 is interpreted as evidence of the presence of a d - wave superconducting gap . in fact , it was pointed out @xcite that the increase of the sommerfeld coefficient with the external magnetic field is due to the line nodes of the superconducting gap . the evidence of quantum oscillations and field - induced sommerfeld coefficient in the electronic specific heat points to the surprising coexistence of a fermi liquid and a d - wave superconductor . in our approach , we now show that the quasielectron nodal fermi liquid leads naturally to the observed sommerfeld coefficient @xmath330 . in the mixed state , according to ref . @xcite the energies of the low - lying excitations circulating around a vortex are shifted by doppler effect . since it results that @xmath331 , we may employ the semiclassical approach which considers the momentum and position of quasiparticles as commuting variables . the effects of the supercurrent circulating around a vortex is accounted for by a doppler shift of the quasiparticle energy . thus , for the quasielectrons we have : @xmath332 where @xmath333 is the supervelocity that , according to eq . ( [ 4.15 ] ) , is given by : @xmath334 the doppler shift eq . ( [ 4.60 ] ) has a sizable effect on the density of state . to see this , we need to evaluate the density of state at the fermi surface averaged over the vortex : @xmath335 \ ; \frac{1}{\pi r^2 } \ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath336 is the average distance between vortices . we obtain : @xmath337\ ] ] where the angular integration on @xmath338 is performed over the four fermi arcs ( @xmath339 ) . the integration over @xmath340 can be done easily . one obtains : @xmath341 finally the angular integrations give : @xmath342 or , using eqs . ( [ 4.63 ] ) and ( [ 4.49 ] ) : @xmath343 since the high - temperature superconductors are extreme type - ii superconductors , one should average the density of state over the vortex distribution . however , from eq . ( [ 4.67 ] ) it is evident that the quasiparticle energy doppler shift induced by vortices leads to the expected field - induced sommerfeld coefficient @xmath330 . in the overdoped region we have already stressed that the normal state properties can be described reasonably well by the fermi liquid picture , although still with some electronic correlations , with a hole density corresponding to @xmath344 holes per @xmath9 atom . indeed , as long as @xmath165 , the effective two - body potential eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) can be dealt with as a small perturbation . therefore , the dynamics of the copper - oxide layers is governed essentially by our effective hamiltonian @xmath50 , eq . ( [ 2.18 ] ) . note that the correlation effects due to the on - site repulsion @xmath6 are built into @xmath50 by means of the effective hole mass @xmath345 . it is interesting to note that : @xmath346 in fact , several quantum oscillation experiments give consistently an effective quasiparticle mass of carrier in the overdoped region which is approximately twice the effective quasiparticle mass of carriers in the underdoped region . + it is interesting to compare the low - temperature linear term in the electronic specific heat of the quasiholes with the one of the nodal quasielectrons evaluated in sect . [ 4 - 4 ] . since the quasiholes behave like a two - dimensional normal fermi liquid , we obtain instead of eq . ( [ 4.56 ] ) : @xmath347 in fact , it is easy to check that the sommerfeld coefficient given by eq . ( [ 5.2 ] ) exceeds by about an order of magnitude the quasielectron sommerfeld coefficient . using our hole effective mass we obtain ( mks units ) : @xmath348 our determination of @xmath349 compares quite well with the observed value : @xmath350 as obtained from direct measurements in polycrystalline @xmath351 @xcite , independently on @xmath13 , and also from indirect determination through the effective hole mass @xmath352 in ref . + concerning the superconducting phase in the overdoped region , we already argued that this can be described within the conventional bcs framework . in fact , there is a large body of evidence that the weak - coupling d - wave bcs approach accounts for many of the low - energy and low - temperature properties of overdoped copper oxides . here , we restrict ourself to the discussion of a clear signature of d - wave bcs pairing in momentum space , namely the ratio of the bcs gap to the critical temperature anticipated in eq . ( [ 3.61 ] ) : @xmath353 to derive eq . ( [ 5.5 ] ) , we observe that the gap equation eq . ( [ 3.47 ] ) at finite temperature reads : @xmath354 } \ ; .\ ] ] thus , instead of eq . ( [ 3.56 ] ) we have : @xmath355 ^ 2 } { \sqrt { \xi^2_{\vec{k } ' } + [ \delta_{bcs } \cos{(2 \theta_{k'})}]^2 } } \tanh { \left [ \frac{\sqrt { \xi^2_{\vec{k } ' } + [ \delta_{bcs } \cos{(2 \theta_{k'})}]^2 } } { 2 \ ; k_b \ ; t } \right ] } \ ; .\ ] ] since the critical temperature is defined by @xmath356 , we obtain : @xmath357 ^ 2 } { | \xi | } \ ; \tanh { \left [ \frac { | \xi | } { 2 \ ; k_b \ ; t_c } \right ] } \ ; , \ ] ] i.e. @xmath358 } \ ; .\ ] ] upon using eq . ( [ 3.60 ] ) we may rewrite eq . ( [ 5.9 ] ) as : @xmath359 } \ ; \simeq \ ; \lambda_2 \ ; \left [ \ln{(\frac{\varepsilon_c}{2k_bt_c } ) } \ ; - \ ; \ln{(\frac{\pi}{4 } ) } \ ; + \ ; \gamma \right ] \ ; , % \ ] ] which leads to : @xmath360 } \ ; .\ ] ] combining eq . ( [ 5.11 ] ) with eq . ( [ 3.59 ] ) one obtains eq . ( [ 5.5 ] ) . doping dependence of the ratio of superconducting gap @xmath361 over the critical temperature @xmath0 . the data has been extracted from fig . 4 of ref . the dashed line is the weak coupling d - wave bcs value @xmath362 . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] in figure [ fig-12 ] we display the doping dependence of the ratio eq . ( [ 5.5 ] ) using the data reported in fig . 4 of ref . it is evident that in the overdoped region @xmath363 the gap values approach closely onto the theoretical prediction of the weak - coupling d - wave bcs superconductivity . + let us now discuss the optimal doped region @xmath200 . according to our picture , the low - doping region is characterized by a large pseudogap @xmath120 which decreases rapidly with increasing doping , while the superconductivity is driven by the finite - temperature berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless transition with a critical temperature that increases with doping . on the other hand , in the overdoped region the superconducting transition is well described by the conventional weak - coupling d - wave bcs pairing in momentum space . the decrease of the critical temperature with increasing doping level originates from the underlying reduction in the pairing strength due to the disturbing of the antiferromagnetic correlations with overdoping . from our fig . [ fig-7 ] we see that the two critical temperatures meet in the optimal doped region @xmath200 , explaining in a natural way why the critical superconducting temperature reaches here the maximum value . since the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless temperature is comparable to the bcs critical temperature , this makes fluctuations much more important . even more , fig . [ fig-7 ] suggests that also the pseudogap temperature @xmath15 becomes comparable to both @xmath160 and @xmath199 . we conclude , thus , that in this region of the phase diagram there are competing phases and it is quite difficult to precisely pin down the underlying physics . on the other hand , as our fig . [ fig-7 ] is suggesting , there is a large body of evidence that pseudogap energy scale does not extend into the heavily overdoped region of the phase diagram , but rather collapse at a well defined critical concentration around @xmath364 . we would like to stress that the presence of an expanded phase - fluctuation regime in the optimal doped region may explain why certain spectroscopic probes , like angle - resolved photoemissions , tend to advocate scenarios in which the pseudogap temperature tracks the superconducting dome rather than vanishing inside it . the scenario advanced in this paper is supported by the results presented in ref . @xcite . by means of a systematic electronic raman scattering study of a mercury - based single layer cuprate as a function of doping level , the authors of ref . @xcite revealed the existence of a breakpoint close to optimal doping , below which the antinodal gap ( the pseudogap ) is gradually disconnected from superconductivity . the nature of both the superconducting and normal state is distinctly different on each site of this breakpoint . this is consistent also with electronic specific heat measurements . in fact , it turns out that @xcite in optimally and overdoped samples the sommerfeld coefficient is almost constant for @xmath365 , in accord with our eq . ( [ 5.2 ] ) , while for underdoped samples there is considerable drop in the sommerfeld coefficient for @xmath366 ( see our eq . ( [ 4.56 ] ) ) . moreover , there is evidence for carrier density which decreases smoothly from @xmath367 in the overdoped phase to @xmath368 in the underdoped phase . in fact , in refs . @xcite it is shown that it exists a critical point @xmath204 where the pseudogap temperature @xmath15 goes to zero and which lies in the superconducting dome . just below @xmath204 there is a crossover from a metal with large hole - like fermi surface , consistent with @xmath369 , to a metal with low density of charge carrier , which from hall and seebeck effect measurements are quasielectrons , with @xmath316 . + before concluding this section , we would like to remark that the optimal doped region of hole - doped cuprates is the most difficult to precisely characterize . in fact , according to our current theoretical understanding , in this region there is competition between the bcs gap and the pseudogap , and the presence of sizable phase fluctuations strongly limit our mean - field treatment . nevertheless , it is worthwhile to disciss the dependentce of the maximum critical temperature @xmath370 on the microscopic parameters of the model . as already discussed we have : @xmath371 now , from eqs . ( [ 2.5 ] ) , ( [ 2.9 ] ) , ( [ 2.17 ] ) , ( [ 3.46 ] ) and ( [ 3.60 ] ) we obtain : @xmath372}\ ] ] where we recall that @xmath204 is the hole doping fraction where the pseudogap @xmath373 vanishes . apparently eq . ( [ 5.13 ] ) suggests that one can increase @xmath370 by increasing @xmath374 and/or decreasing @xmath204 . however , it turns out that the increase of @xmath374 leads also to an increase of @xmath204 and vice versa , such that the two effects compensate in eq . ( [ 5.13 ] ) . this explains why the optimal hole doping fraction is very close to @xmath204 and attains the universal value : @xmath375 in the whole family of cuprates . the vast majority of high - temperature superconductors are hole - doped . nevertheless , in this section we will touch upon high - temperature electron - doped cuprates ( see ref . @xcite for a review ) . the most evident difference between electron and hole doped cuprates is that the antiferromagnetic phase at @xmath376 is much more robust in the electron - doped material and it persists to much higher doping levels . if we adopt the effective single - band hubbard model of sect . [ 1 ] for the microscopic description of the @xmath1 layers , then we see that the electrons injected into the copper - oxide plane would behave like the holes in the overdoped region of the hole - doped cuprates . however , due to the stronger antiferromagnetic correlations in the ground state for @xmath16 , the electron carrier density is : @xmath377 since one electron of the @xmath378 electrons per cu atom is frozen in the half - filled hubbard band antiferromagnetic configuration . in our approach the effective hamiltonian for the injected electrons should be given by eqs . ( [ 2.18 ] ) and ( [ 2.6 ] ) . in particular , the electron effective mass agrees with eq . ( [ 2.17 ] ) : @xmath379 with the previously stated values of the model parameters . however , due to the increased role played by the fermion correlations in the antiferromagnetic background , we expect that the effective two - body potential in the interaction hamiltonian eq . ( [ 2.6 ] ) is reduced to some extent . to take into account this effect , we shall assume that the effective potential @xmath380 has the same form as in eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) but with a somewhat reduced interaction length : @xmath381 we now show that this small variation in the range of the effective two - body interaction potential leads to a dramatic change in the phase diagram of the electron - doped cuprates . in fact , by solving the real - space d - wave bound state schrdinger equation eq . ( [ 3.11 ] ) we find a drastically reduced pseudogap ( see fig . [ fig-13 ] ) : @xmath382 the pseudogap and bcs critical temperatures ( in kelvin ) versus the doping fraction for the electron - doped cuprates . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] this means that , according to the discussion in sect . [ 3 - 2 ] , the pseudogap superconducting phase of the underdoped region of hole - doped cuprates is absent . therefore , the superconducting transition in electron - doped cuprates is driven by the weak - coupling d - wave bcs pairing in momentum space . in this case the critical bcs temperature is given by eq . ( [ 3.62 ] ) : @xmath383}\ ] ] with @xmath384 given by eq . ( [ 6.4 ] ) , @xmath385 ^ 2 \ ; , \ ] ] and @xmath386 the bcs critical temperature eq . ( [ 6.5 ] ) as a function of the electron doping level is displayed in fig . [ fig-13 ] . from the schematic phase diagram we infer that the maximal critical temperature is strongly reduced with respect to the hole - doped cuprates . moreover , the superconducting phase manifests itself in a rather narrow interval of doping around @xmath387 . these general aspects of our phase diagram seem to be in qualitative agreement with observations . however , a thorough understanding of the superconductivity in electron doped cuprates must await more detailed experimental informations . the driving principle of the approach presented in this paper has been that the high - temperature superconductivity can be understood within some framework along the line of the microscopic theory of bardeen , cooper , and schrieffer . the results presented in this paper summarize our attempts over the last years to construct a comprehensive model that gives all aspects of the unusual behavior seen in the various regions of the phase diagram of the cuprates . it is obvious that we must rely heavily on some assumptions . first , we assumed that the physics of the high - temperature cuprates is deeply rooted in the copper - oxide planes . this allowed us to completely neglect the motion along the direction perpendicular to the @xmath1 planes . our second main assumption has been that the single - band effective hubbard model is sufficient to account for all the essential physics of the copper - oxide planes . both assumptions are well accepted and superbly illustrated in the anderson s book @xcite . accordingly , we have proposed an effective hamiltonian that is able to govern the dynamics of the electrons or holes injected into the undoped copper - oxide planes . we arrived at our effective hamiltonian by using arguments well - known in the literature on the motion of charge carriers in an antiferromagnetic background . notwithstanding , we were unable to offer a truly microscopic derivation of the effective hamiltonian . so that our arguments to determine the effective hamiltonian , albeit suggestive , can not be considered a first principle derivation . in spite of that , we showed that the effective hamiltonian offers us a consistent picture of the high transition temperature cuprate superconductors . due to the reduced dimensionality the two - body attractive potential admits real - space d - wave bound states . the binding energy of these bound states , which plays the role of the pseudogap , decreases with increasing doping until it vanishes at a certain critical doping @xmath166 . this allows us to reach the conclusion that the key features of the underdoped side of the phase diagram are controlled by very strong pairing that is phase - disordered by thermal fluctuations . we also were able to estimate the upper critical magnetic field whose strength and doping dependence are in good agreement with observations . we obtain a clear explanation for the so - called vortex region and for the puzzling discrete states bounded to the core of isolated vortices . we have discussed how the presence of the pseudogap is responsible for the formation of the quasielectron nodal fermi liquid which , in turn , leads to the fermi arcs observed in angle - resolved photoemission studies and to the fermi pockets in quantum oscillation experiments . we have found a natural explanation for the peculiar dependence of the specific heat on the applied magnetic field observed in underdoped cuprates . however , we would like to stress that we did not attempt a complete discussion of the strange behavior of the cuprates in this region . in particular , as already pointed out in sect . [ 4 ] , we did not discuss the so - called nodal gap . in fact , we plan to present in a separate paper a detailed discussion on the origin and temperature dependence of the nodal gap , on the thermal conductivity , on the departure from the wiedemann - franz law and on the london penetration depth . + in our model the overdoped region is realized for hole doping in excess of the critical doping @xmath204 where the pseudogap vanishes . in this region the conventional d - wave bcs framework account for many of the low - energy and low - temperature properties of the copper oxides , in agreement with several observations . finally , we explain naturally why the superconducting critical temperature reaches its maximum in the optimal doped region . we pointed out that in this region the competition between the pseudogap and the d - wave bcs gap together with the enhanced role of the phase fluctuations makes questionable the usually adopted mean - field approximation . we have also briefly discussed the comparatively less - studied electron - doped cuprates . we suggest that the dome - shaped superconducting region in electron - doped copper - oxides can be described by the conventional weak - coupling d - wave pairing in momentum space . + in conclusion , the fact that a relatively simple model for the effective hamiltonian allowed to recover several observational features of the high - temperature copper oxides , suggests that the approach presented in this paper could be considered a significative step toward a microscopic explanation of the high - temperature superconductivity in cuprates . 99 j. g. bednorz and k. a. mller , z. phys . b * 64 * ( 1986 ) 189 a. damascelli , z. hussain and z. x. shen , rev . * 75 * ( 2003 ) 473 g. deutscher , rev . * 77 * ( 2005 ) 109 d. n. besov and t. timusk , , rev . phys . * 77 * ( 2005 ) 721 p. a. lee , n. nagaosa , and x. -g . wen , rev . * 78 * ( 2006 ) 17 . fischer , h. kugler , i. maggio - aprile and c. berthod , rev . * 79 * ( 2007 ) 353 p. a. lee , rep . * 71 * ( 2008 ) 012501 s. hfner , m. a. hossain , a. damascelli and g. a. sarvatzky , rep . * 71 * ( 2008 ) 062501 s. e. sebastian , n. harrison and g. g. lonzarich , rep . * 75 * ( 2012 ) 102501 p. w. anderson , science * 235 * ( 1987 ) 1196 p. w. anderson , _ the theory of superconductivity in the high-@xmath0 cuprates _ , princeton university press , princeton , new jersey ( 1997 ) p. w. anderson , phys . rev . * 115 * ( 1959 ) 2 d. a. bonn , nature physics * 2 * ( 2006 ) 159 ch . * 80 * ( 1998 ) 3843 s. -w . et al . _ , * 67 * ( 1991 ) 1791 t. e. mason , g. aeppli and h. a. mook , phys . * 68 * ( 1982 ) 1414 a. n. lavrov , l. p. kozeeva , m. r. trunin and v. n. zverev , phys . b * 79 * ( 2009 ) 214523 j. bardeen , l. n. cooper and j. r. schrieffer , phys . rev . * 106 * ( 1957 ) 162 ; phys . rev . * 108 * ( 1957 ) 1175 n. p. armitage , p. fournier and r. l. greene , rev . * 82 * ( 2010 ) 2421 a. p. balachandran , e. ercolessi , and g. morandi , _ hubbard model and anyon superconductivity _ , world scientific publishing co. inc . ( 1990 ) k. huang and e. manousakis , phys . b * 36 * ( 1987 ) 8302 j. e. hirsch , phys . rev . * 59 * ( 1987 ) 228 s. a. trugman , phys . b * 37 * ( 1988 ) 1597 e. w. carlson , v. j. emery , s. a. kivelson and d. orgad , _ concepts in high temperature superconductivity _ , cond - mat/0206217 j. r. schrieffer , x. -g . wen , and s. -c . zhang , phys . lett . * 60 * ( 1988 ) 944 ; phys . b * 39 * ( 1989 ) 11663 l. n. cooper , phys . rev . * 104 * ( 1956 ) 1189 m. r. schafroth , phys * 100 * ( 1955 ) 463 j. m. blatt and s. t. butler , phys * 100 * ( 1955 ) 476 p. w. anderson , rev . * 38 * ( 1966 ) 298 a. j. legget , _ quantum liquids _ , oxford university press , oxford , uk ( 2008 ) v. l. berezinskii , sov . jetp * 32 * ( 1971 ) 493 ; sov . jetp * 34 * ( 1972 ) 610 j. m. kosterlitz and d. j. thouless , j. phys . c * 6 * ( 1973 ) 1181 b. vignolle _ et al . _ , nature * 455 * ( 2008 ) 952 p. w. anderson and p. morel , phys . * 123 * ( 1961 ) 1911 h. won and k. maki , phys b * 49 * ( 1994 ) 1397 t. timusk and b. statt , rep . * 62 * ( 1999 ) 61 j. l. tallon and j. w. loran , physica c * 349 * ( 2001 ) 53 u. chatterjee _ et al . _ , nature physics * 6 * ( 2010 ) 99 k. tanaka _ et al . _ , science * 314 * ( 2006 ) 1910 r .- h . _ , nature physics * 5 * ( 2009 ) 119 a. pushp _ et al . _ , science * 324 * ( 2009 ) 1689 m. hashimoto _ et al . _ , nature physics * 6 * ( 2010 ) 414 t. j. reber _ et al . _ , nature physics * 8 * ( 2012 ) 606 s. sakai _ _ , _ exploring the dark side of cuprate superconductors : s - wave symmetry of the pseudogap _ , arxiv:1207.5070 t. yoshida _ _ , _ coexisting pseudo - gap and superconducting gap in the high - t@xmath388 superconductor la@xmath389sr@xmath390cuo@xmath391 _ , arxiv:1208.2903 m. hashimoto _ et al . _ , b * 86 * ( 2012 ) 094504 m. kugler _ et al . * 86 * ( 2001 ) 4911 i. hetel , t. r. lemberger and m. randeira , nature physics * 3 * ( 2007 ) 700 j. corson _ _ , nature * 398 * ( 1999 ) 221 v. j. emery and s. a. kilvelson , nature * 374 * ( 1985 ) 434 m. tinkham , _ introduction to superconductivity _ , second edition , mc graw - hill , inc . , new york ( 1996 ) y. wang , l. li and n. p. ong , phys . b * 73 * ( 2006 ) 024510 l. li _ et al . _ , nature physics * 3 * ( 2007 ) 311 j. chang _ et al . _ , nature physics * 8 * ( 2012 ) 751 z. a. xu _ et al . _ , nature * 406 * ( 2000 ) 486 c. capan _ et al . _ , * 88 * ( 2002 ) 056601 l. li , y. wang , j. g. checkelsky and m. j. naughton , physica c * 460 - 462 * ( 2007 ) 48 c. caroli , p. g. de gennes and j. matricon , phys . lett . * 9 * ( 1964 ) 307 n. doiron - leyrand _ et al . _ , nature * 447 * ( 2007 ) 565 e. a. yelland _ et al . _ , * 100 * ( 2008 ) 047003 a. f. bangura _ et al . _ , * 100 * ( 2008 ) 047004 c. jaudet _ et al . _ , physica b * 404 * ( 2009 ) 354 a. f. bangura _ _ , phys . rev . b * 82 * ( 2010 ) 140501 a. a. abrikosov , _ introduction to theory of normal metal _ , academic press , new york and london ( 1972 ) d. shoenberg , _ magnetic oscillations in metals _ , cambridge university press , cambridge ( 1984 ) d. le boeuf _ et al . _ , nature * 450 * ( 2007 ) 533 s. sebastian _ et al . _ , nature communications * 2 * ( 2011 ) 471 f. laliberte _ et al . _ , nature communications * 2 * ( 2011 ) 432 s. c. riggs _ et al . _ , nature physics * 7 * ( 2011 ) 332 n. w. ashcroft and n. d. mermin , _ solid state physics _ , harcourt college publishers ( 1976 ) g. e. volovik , sov . jetp * 58 * ( 1993 ) 469 j. m. wade _ et al . _ , j. supercond . * 7 * ( 1994 ) 261 y. wang _ et al . b * 76 * ( 2007 ) 064512 w. guyard _ et al . _ , b * 77 * ( 2008 ) 024524 j. w. loram , k. a. mirza , j. r. cooper and j. l. tallon , physica c * 282 - 287 * ( 1997 ) 1405 j. w. loram , j. luo , j. r. cooper and j. l. tallon , j. phys . * 62 * ( 2001 ) 59 r. daou _ et al . _ , nature physics * 5 * ( 2009 ) 31 r. daou _ et al . _ , phys . rev . b * 79 * ( 2009 ) 180505 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: one of the major long - term goals of astronomy is to place the solar system within a greater context , finding for example whether habitable planets like the earth are typical , and whether these earth analogues have conditions suitable for alien life . such goals are ambitious and many obstacles must be overcome for them to come to fruition . for the particular case of directly imaging earth - like planets around other stars , a major unknown is the level of photon noise from the dust that resides in the target system itself , specifically dust located in the `` habitable zone '' ( hz , e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . such dust populations are generically referred to as `` exo - zodi '' by analogy with the solar system s zodiacal cloud , though they may have different origins . to be clear , we consider the dust populations seen around 10 - 25% of nearby stars with near - infrared ( ir ) interferometry to be a largely unrelated phenomenon , based on their small grain size and hot temperatures , and lack of correlation with both mid - ir detections of hz dust ( mennesson et al . , apj , in press ) and far - ir detections of cool dust . if hz dust levels an order of magnitude or so greater than the solar system level are typical , this noise source could seriously hinder an earth analogue - imaging and characterisation mission ( which we will refer to as earth - imaging for brevity , e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . currently , the brightness distribution ( which we also call the luminosity function ) of exo - zodi is largely unknown . limits have been set by the keck interferometer nuller ( kin , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * mennesson et al . , apj , in press ) , but the distribution has only been characterised at levels 3 - 4 orders of magnitude above the solar system by photometric methods @xcite . enter the large binocular telescope interferometer ( lbti ) , a mid - ir instrument specifically designed to characterise exo - zodi at dust levels just a few times greater than the solar system s zodiacal cloud . for a brief description of the instrument see defrre et al . ( submitted ) . by observing of order 50 nearby stars at this level of sensitivity ( weinberger et al . , submitted ) , the lbti will identify specific targets with low dust levels that are suitable for future earth - imaging , and moreover will characterise the exo - zodi luminosity function with sufficient detail to provide new information on the dust origin and evolution . this latter point is important because the lbti will observe a limited number of stars and can not access the entire sky , and population - level information such as correlations with other system properties will be needed to assess the suitability of targets that are not observed with the lbti . of course the results will also be scientifically valuable and interesting , particularly when combined with existing and future observations ( e.g. defrre et al . submitted ) . mid and far - ir imaging using telescopes such as _ spitzer , herschel _ , and jwst will provide important information on the existence , location , and structure of cooler dust belts that lie outside the hz . interferometric observations with longer baselines ( e.g. vlti / matisse ) and/or at different wavelengths ( e.g. chara / fluor , vlti / pionier ) will provide information that complements the lbti to help build a complete picture of the inner regions of individual systems . the goal of this paper is to outline a modelling framework for interpreting lbti observations . such models are needed because lbti observations yield limited information on the spatial structure of any disk that is detected . it is therefore important that the model used to interpret the observations is thoroughly characterised so that the constraints placed on its various parameters can be understood in terms of their implications for the disk structure and surface brightness . the primary goal is to use the model to make a useful statement about the level of dust in a system , or the limits on undetected dust , in the habitable zone where earth - imaging will be attempted in the future . in what follows , we outline a parameterised dust model that can be used to approximate the solar system s zodiacal dust cloud . we show how this model can be used to derive the distribution of dust levels given an lbti observation of thermal dust emission . we then determine the corresponding implications for scattered light levels at visible wavelengths . we finally show the expected levels of dust that could be detected by the hunt for observable signatures of terrestrial planetary systems ( hosts ) survey and the corresponding scattered light levels . for a detailed description of the lbti sample we refer the reader to weinberger et al . ( submitted ) , and for discussion of the instrument and the first scientific results to defrre et al . ( submitted ) . the primary goal of our exo - zodiacal cloud model is to allow easy comparison of the results among survey stars , which span a range of distances and luminosities . in general we expect that detections will be near the sensitivity limits , and that there will be little information about any warm dust detected ( or not detected ) other than from lbti . therefore , while warm dust may arise from various different processes , for example _ in situ _ asteroid - belt like evolution , stochastic collisions , delivery of comets from elsewhere , or some combination of all three ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , we will have little power to distinguish among them . some scenarios could result in clumpy non - axisymmetric structures , but there again is little hope of distinguishing these from axisymmetric structures in all but the dustiest systems where lbti detections will be relatively easy and at high signal to noise ratios . therefore , the models considered here are axisymmetric . for specific stars , the stellar luminosity @xmath1 ( in solar units ) is easily derived by fitting stellar atmosphere models to photometry , and the flux density @xmath2 at any wavelength can be inferred from these models . given a distance @xmath3 , the stellar radius can be estimated from the same model , though in some cases it may have been directly observed . in any case , the contribution of the resolved stellar disk to an lbti observation will generally be negligible . here we use the stellar fluxes for hosts survey stars derived by weinberger et al . ( submitted ) . lbti observations are sensitive to the surface brightness distribution @xmath4 in the n band at 11@xmath5 m ( the bandpass spans 9.81 - 12.41 @xmath5 m ) . our model can be considered a means of parameterising this surface brightness distribution using parameters that have some physical relevance . unless stated otherwise , in what follows our calculations are made at 11 @xmath5 m . the surface brightness profile of the disk , if viewed face - on , is modelled as @xmath6 here @xmath7 is the temperature of disk material that behaves like a black body @xmath8 where the distance to the star , @xmath9 , is in au . the numerical factor in eq . [ eq : sb ] is a conversion ( 1au@xmath10/1pc@xmath10 ) so that the surface brightness is in units of jy arcsec@xmath11 . the parameter @xmath12 is representative of the disk s face - on surface density of cross - sectional area ( in au@xmath10/au@xmath10 ) , so is analogous to optical depth and is assumed to have a power law distribution @xmath13 between radii @xmath14 and @xmath15 ( both in au ) . the normalisation @xmath16 is to be set at some @xmath17 ( in au ) such that the surface density is in units of zodis @xmath18 ( see section [ ss : zodi ] ) . for generality we include an inclination @xmath19 , which is half the total opening angle of the disk , and represents the maximum inclination of the parent bodies ( whose nodes would be assumed to be randomised ) . here we assume that our disks have negligible opening angles so @xmath19 is not used , but that @xmath19 is always sufficiently large that the disk is radially optically thin . if all of the disk particles behave like black bodies , the parameter @xmath12 can be interpreted as the disk s surface density of cross - sectional area . its interpretation becomes more complicated for disks with more realistic particle optical properties because the observed dust can be several times hotter than the black body temperature , and not all radiation incident on a particle is absorbed and thermally re - emitted . however , as the surface brightness is typically assumed to exhibit a power law dependence across the relevant radius range , we have not lost any generality by expressing the disk surface brightness in this way , even if the disk s temperature profile differs from that of a black body . these issues will be discussed in more detail in sections [ ss : other ] and [ ss : scat ] . the final parameters , which specify the direction to the observer relative to the disk , are the disk inclination @xmath20 and the position angle @xmath21 . the inclination is defined such that @xmath22 is face - on and the position angle is measured anticlockwise ( i.e. east ) from north . the range of inclinations is 0 to @xmath23 and the range of position angles 0 to @xmath24 , ) means that if the disks are not spatially resolved we in fact only need to consider angles between 0 and 90@xmath25 . we retain the larger range because we may wish to set @xmath21 based on the position angle of the star or an outer disk component . ] with these ranges set because we can not distinguish between the near and far side of a disk . that is , the faint disks considered here are optically thin viewed from any direction , and in thermal emission look the same mirrored in the sky plane or for 180@xmath25 rotations . the model parameters and their meanings are summarised in table [ tab : params ] . .model parameters [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] ` zodipic ` is an implementation of the @xcite zodiacal cloud model . this parametric model has many parameters , whose values were derived via fitting to cobe / dirbe observations . ` zodipic ` produces two - dimensional images of the solar system s zodiacal dust cloud as might be seen by an external observer , and has been used as a reference model for calculating the limits set by kin observations @xcite . though it is a complex model and can include dust components such as the earth s resonant ring and trailing blob , only the main smooth axisymmetric component is normally used . because this main component is simply a radial power law , with an approximately gaussian vertical density distribution , it is possible to reproduce the ` zodipic ` surface brightness using our parameterised model . the vertical dust distribution is the main difference between the @xcite model and ours . the @xcite model assumes that the radial and vertical components of the cloud are separable @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 and @xmath29 is the height above the disk midplane in au . the best fit values for the cobe data were @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 . the units of the normalisation are au@xmath10/au@xmath35 ( i.e. a volume density of surface area ) , and the integrated length of the vertical term is not constant with radius , so their exponent @xmath36 is not the same as our exponent @xmath37 . numerically integrating equation ( [ eq : zodipic2 ] ) over @xmath38 yields 0.63 , so the surface density at 1 au is @xmath39 ( au@xmath10/au@xmath10 ) . assuming for mathematical simplicity that @xmath40 , the integral of the exponential term in equation ( [ eq : zodipic ] ) is @xmath41 for both cases of @xmath42 , and hence @xmath43 and @xmath44 . therefore , the ` zodipic ` model can be reasonably expressed in terms of our model with @xmath45 au @xmath46 , and @xmath47 . there remain a few small differences in the surface brightness of our model relative to ` zodipic ` , as shown in the right panel of fig . [ fig : mod ] . the main difference is that the ` zodipic ` model is slightly brighter at larger radii because the radial temperature profile is flatter . setting the ` zodipic ` temperature profile to equal our black body prescription leads to nearly indistinguishable face - on surface brightness profiles . some minor differences arise because the @xcite model defines radius as @xmath48 , whereas our narrow opening angle means that our model is effectively cylindrical . here we introduce a reference disk model , the parameters of which are summarised in table [ tab : params ] and based on the @xcite solar system model described above . the model extends from 0.034 - 10 au with a power - law index @xmath49 , and is scaled to @xmath50 at @xmath45 au ( the location where @xmath51 k ) . the inner edge is set by a black body temperature of 1500k , approximately the sublimation temperature of silicates , though we show in section [ ss : other ] that this choice is irrelevant for our model as long as the inner disk edge is inside the iwa of 40 mas . the outer edge of 10 au is chosen to be sufficiently large that it does not affect the model at the lbti wavelength of 11 @xmath5 m . as noted above we treat the disk as two dimensional so the opening angle is small . our reference model is based on the solar system so the star is sun - like , but as described in section [ ss : zodi ] the reference parameters are later varied to model disks around different stars . figure [ fig : mod ] shows the distribution of temperature , surface density and surface brightness at 11@xmath5 m in this reference model , where we have assumed a distance of 10 pc . survey targets are chosen so that the lbti is sensitive to dust in their habitable zone ( weinberger et al . , submitted ) , so the dotted lines show the range of radii implied by a temperature range of 210 - 320k , a rough indication of the habitable zone location for the sun ( e.g. * ? ? ? the right panel shows that the surface brightness of our model closely matches ` zodipic ` , and as noted above this difference only arises due to different assumptions about the radial temperature profile . therefore , for the same assumptions and aside from the differences in scale height our model yields the same results as ` zodipic ` for a sun - like star . the disk normalisation ( i.e. brightness ) is set by the parameter @xmath16 , which is the disk surface density at @xmath17 . the goal here is to set what @xmath52 and @xmath17 are so that they scale sensibly with stellar spectral type , and so that our disk model is somehow sensibly related to zodi units , and therefore the solar system dust level . these parameters , along with @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath37 , and @xmath19 define our reference disk model . in making this definition , it is important to remember the ultimate goal of the lbti , which is to constrain the level of dust in the habitable zone around nearby stars . that is , disk surface brightness is the most important measure of the impact of exo - zodi on future earth - imaging missions . a desirable definition might be one of `` constant hindrance '' for an earth - imaging mission , where @xmath16 is set such that a @xmath53 disk impacts all observations in search of exo - earths at the same level . however , for this imaging any exo - earths will be unresolved , whereas the exo - zodi that accompany them will be resolved , so the same physical disk has the same surface brightness regardless of distance , but the brightness of the unresolved planet decreases with distance . therefore , any zodi definition that attempts to provide constant hindrance will be distance dependent , which is an undesirable property since it is unrelated to the physical disk structure . to set @xmath16 therefore requires a choice between using either the total disk brightness , or the surface brightness at @xmath17 . both approaches have their merits . for example , using the total disk brightness allows comparison with photometric observations and therefore easy construction of the warm dust luminosity function ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . however , as we show below in fig . [ fig : fnutvsr ] , lbti observations are not necessarily sensitive to total disk brightness ( e.g. when a significant fraction of the disk emission lies inside the first transmission peak ) . we therefore prefer a zodi definition linked to the disk surface density in the habitable zone . for the spectral type scaling , it then makes sense for @xmath17 to scale with @xmath54 , so that the surface brightness expressed by @xmath16 corresponds to the radial distance where the equilibrium temperature is the same as at earth ( i.e. an `` earth - equivalent '' distance ) , therefore @xmath55 au . scaling @xmath14 and @xmath15 by @xmath56 is also appropriate , since this results in a common temperature at the inner and outer edges of the disk , and maintains the disk inner edge at the sublimation radius . the disk edges are of relatively little importance here because as we show below the lbti is relatively insensitive to their location . with this definition , @xmath16 is fixed at the surface density of the solar system s zodiacal cloud at 1 au , but the location where this surface density applies depends on the stellar luminosity . this definition is different to ` zodipic ` , which fixes @xmath17 at 1 au for all stars and fixes @xmath14 at the sublimation radius . because the dust temperature at @xmath17 is the same for all spectral types , the thermal surface brightness at @xmath17 ( i.e. in the habitable zone ) for a 1 zodi disk is also the same . because it is based on surface brightness , this zodi definition is well suited for use as an important metric for future earth - imaging missions . an lbti observation is not necessarily sensitive to the radial extent of a disk , so the derived zodi level depends on what is assumed for @xmath14 and @xmath15 , particularly if the disk is relatively narrow . for example , below we consider a `` worst case '' scenario where the dust emission only originates in the habitable zone , in which case the derived dust surface density ( and hence @xmath18 ) is higher for a given null depth . to avoid confusion we recommend that zodi levels primarily use our reference model to allow consistent comparisons . the original concept for nulling interferometry was put forward by @xcite , and for a reasonably non - technical description of the instrument we refer the reader to defrre et al . ( submitted ) . basically speaking , the lbti combines the beams from the two lbt mirrors , with one beam having a half - wavelength phase shift . light in the viewing direction , and along lines perpendicular to the mirror baseline vector , is therefore suppressed . light from off axis sources at odd multiples of the angular distance @xmath57 is transmitted ( @xmath58 is the baseline length ) . similarly , light from sources at even multiples of this angular distance is suppressed . the transmission ( or `` fringe '' ) pattern is therefore a @xmath59 function parallel to the baseline vector , and is constant perpendicular to this vector . a model disk , the transmission pattern , and the transmitted disk image are illustrated in fig . [ fig : trx ] . this illustration is for an object at transit ; at other times the fringe pattern is not aligned with north . the key measurement from an lbti observation is the ratio of the transmitted flux to the total photometric flux . because the transmission pattern is designed to suppress light from the star , leaving light from a much fainter disk , this ratio is approximately the ratio of the transmitted disk flux to the stellar flux . deriving the transmitted disk flux is not straightforward however , as some on - axis ( i.e. stellar ) flux is always transmitted because the instrument is not perfect and the star has a finite angular size . removal of these effects is an integral part of the data analysis ( see defrre et al , submitted ) , so the quantity derived from a given observation is the `` calibrated null depth '' or `` source null depth '' . in what follows we generally refer to this measurement and the same quantity derived from our models as simply the `` null depth '' . because the total flux is almost exactly the stellar flux and dominates over any disk emission , we therefore compute the null depth for our models as the transmission for a starless model divided by the stellar flux density . our disk model is radially extended , but to illustrate how surface brightness is transmitted through the lbti transmission pattern as a function of angular scale we first consider a series of discrete annuli of angular radii @xmath60 . we later combine these annuli to model the transmission for our disk models . the angular distance to the first transmission peak is @xmath61 ; for the lbti @xmath62 @xmath5 m and @xmath63 m , so the distance is 79 mas . the transmission function perpendicular to the fringes @xmath64 is @xmath65)$ ] , and is shown as the grey line in figure [ fig : trvsr ] , where the x axis is the distance from the annulus center in units of the distance to the first transmission peak ( i.e. @xmath66 ) . a common definition for the inner working angle of an instrument is where the sensitivity first reaches half of the peak value , which for lbti is therefore at @xmath67 mas . ) . the grey line is the projected transmission function parallel to the lbti baseline , the blue dashed line is the fraction of emission for face - on ( @xmath22 ) annuli after summing around the azimuthal angle . dots show a population of annuli with random inclinations and position angles , and the red line shows the average transmission of these dots.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] to calculate the transmission for a point at some azimuth around the annulus requires finding the sky - plane component of this vector point ( relative to the star ) that is perpendicular to the fringe pattern . this component can be calculated using three rotations , and is @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the angle from the sky plane around the annulus to the point of interest , and @xmath70 is the position angle of the annulus relative to the lbti fringe pattern . the angle @xmath70 varies with hour angle , and because the lbti baseline is always perpendicular to the local vertical ( i.e. a great circle through the target and zenith ) , is equal to @xmath21 for an object at transit . the transmission from a point in the annulus is then \right)/2\ ] ] where @xmath71 are the sky offsets from the null center and @xmath72 the corresponding spatial frequencies ( i.e. @xmath73 ) . lbti transmission is simpler to compute because the length of the sky - projected baseline is always the same due to the common mount for the mirrors . ] @xmath74 ) \ , .\ ] ] for a face - on ( @xmath22 ) annulus at radius @xmath75 , the transmission is clearly a function of azimuth around the annulus . averaging around an annulus yields the total transmission for that annulus , and repeating this calculation for annuli of different angular sizes gives the blue dashed line in figure [ fig : trvsr ] . this exercise is finally repeated for a large number of annuli with random orientations , so that @xmath76 is distributed evenly from 0 to 1 , and @xmath70 is evenly distributed from 0 to 180@xmath25 . again , the transmission around each annulus is azimuthally averaged , which results in the dots shown in figure [ fig : trvsr ] . averaging these points yields the average transmission as a function of annulus radius for a population of disks with random orientations , shown as the red line . as can be surmised from the decreasing amplitude , the average transmission tends to 0.5 at large separations ( i.e. the average of @xmath59 is 0.5 ) . the minimum separation at which this transmission is achieved is @xmath77 , twice the inner working angle . the origin of the dot distribution can be understood by considering how annuli of different orientations are transmitted through a given transmission peak . for example , the upper envelope of dots at about 70% transmission are all transmitted through the first transmission peak , and those at higher @xmath66 are nearer to edge - on with position angles closer to @xmath78 ( i.e. perpendicular to the baseline and parallel to the fringes ) . this effect is relatively common because the average inclination is about 60@xmath25 ( i.e. biased towards edge - on ) . by comparing the phase of the grey line with the red line , it is clear that the peak average transmission is actually about a quarter of the way beyond a transmission peak , and that the peak transmission for face - on annuli lies somewhere in between . the phase shift of the face - on transmission can be understood by realising that an annulus with a radius @xmath75 that is slightly greater than @xmath77 has more emission in the peak transmission region than an annulus with @xmath79 . the average transmission for random orientations is phase shifted slightly further because most disks are inclined , and therefore on average appear somewhat smaller on the sky than they actually are . . flux is lost at all radii due to the transmission pattern , but most is lost from inside the habitable zone . the total and transmitted disk fluxes are 0.11 and 0.031 mjy.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] using the reference model of section [ sss : ref ] , fig . [ fig : fnutvsr ] shows the total and transmitted disk flux as a function of radius for a face - on geometry and a distance of 10 pc . that is , the figure is a histogram showing where the total and transmitted flux originates , so the solid line is an azimuthally summed radial profile created from the right panel of fig . [ fig : trx ] . much of the total disk emission originates from the inner regions , and since the disk inner edge is well inside the first transmission peak significant flux from these inner regions is not transmitted . some flux is also lost at larger radii , and in total only about 30% of the disk flux is transmitted . overall therefore , the radial distance over which the disk emits strongly in the mid - ir and can be detected is not particularly large ; emission is strongly reduced inside the inner working angle , and the faint wien side of cooler emission means that the surface brightness drops steeply at larger radii . given the spacing of the transmission peaks and the distance to nearby stars , the transmitted flux detected by the lbti is constrained to come from near the hz , even if it can not be certain that it originates within it . ) and randomly distributed orientations . the dotted line shows the average transmitted flux derived in figure [ fig : fnutvsr ] . the disk will sometimes appear fainter than average , but is often a little bit brighter . the mean level is 0.026 mjy , and the medial level 0.029 mjy.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] figure [ fig : ftrhist ] shows how the total transmitted flux is distributed for a random distribution of disk orientations . the concentration of transmitted fluxes near the maximum arises because any disk with a position angle perpendicular to the transmission pattern has the same transmitted flux , regardless of inclination ( and any disk near to face - on also has the same transmitted flux ) . the low transmitted flux tail arises from disks that have a position angle parallel to the transmission pattern and are sufficiently near to edge on such that almost the entire disk lies in the central null transmission region . such a geometry is relatively unlikely , as can be seen by the lack of dots with low transmission in fig . [ fig : trvsr ] . these relatively rare low transmitted fluxes are allowed because we assume disks with negligible scale height . this distribution therefore represents a pessimistic ( but possible ) case , and becomes tighter as the disk scale height increases . the width of the distribution also depends on the range of hour angles over which a target is observed , as discussed in section [ ss : ha ] . the point here is that the transmitted flux depends on the orientation , and since this is expected to be unconstrained for lbti targets ( unless we use stellar inclination or the orientation of a resolved outer disk as an estimate , which will be possible for some of the hosts sample ) , there will be a corresponding uncertainty in any disk parameters that are derived from the observations . since the transmitted flux scales linearly with @xmath16 , the distribution of @xmath16 , and hence @xmath18 , required to reproduce a given transmitted flux is directly related to that in figure [ fig : ftrhist ] . the distribution of possible null depths for our reference model at 10 pc is therefore calculated by dividing the distribution of transmitted fluxes in fig . [ fig : ftrhist ] by the stellar flux . the distribution of zodi levels @xmath18 implied for a given observed null depth ( or upper limit ) is found by dividing the observed null depth by the distribution of model null depths for @xmath53 . this was the method employed by @xcite in modelling kin observations with ` zodipic ` . any real lbti observation takes a finite amount of time , during which any disk will rotate relative to the transmission pattern on the sky . thus , even a vertically thin edge - on disk , which can be instantaneously invisible to the lbti , will be visible when the length of the observation is taken into account . to compute how the disk transmission changes for an observation of a given object requires computing the position angle of the lbti fringe pattern on the sky at a given hour angle . the common mirror mount for the lbt means that this angle is the difference between the vector in the direction of the local vertical and a vector pointing towards equatorial north along a line of constant right ascension through the object in question ( i.e. the hour circle ) . this angle is commonly called the parallactic angle . is not instantaneously detected , but is only about 50% fainter than a face - on disk for a 4 hour observation.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the null depth is then computed as the average null depth over the range of observed hour angles . for modelling purposes here , these are spaced evenly in hour angle , but future models will use the true distribution for each specific observation . [ fig : orient ] shows the difference between the instantaneous sensitivity for a transiting target ( left panel ) and a 4 hour observation ( right panel ) , for a target at @xmath80 declination over the parameter space of different disk orientations . this calculation is purely related to the changing position angle of the disk , and does not represent the time needed to reach a given s / n . here , as before , we have assumed a vertically thin disk . the dark region in the upper middle of the left panel shows that an edge on disk is not instantaneously detectable when the disk is aligned with the lbti fringe pattern . in the right panel , the rotation of the fringe pattern with respect to north over a four hour observation means that the sensitivity relative to a face - on disk is reduced by about 50% for the worst case disk orientation . , relative to a face - on disk . each line shows the transmission for a different disk inclination . the top axis shows the disk position angle relative to the fringe pattern , which is 180@xmath25 at transit because the lbt is facing north at that time . the curves at transit ( ha=0 ) yield the transmission - inclination relation shown in the left panel of fig . [ fig : orient ] at @xmath81 , while the average value of each curve yields the transmission - inclination relation shown in the right panel . the curve average is always greater than the transmission at transit , so observations over a wider range of hour angles can detect disks with less favourable orientations.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] to understand the origin of this increased sensitivity , fig . [ fig : orient_ha ] again shows the transmission relative to a face - on disk , but now for @xmath81 at each point in the range of hour angles from -2 to 2h . each curve shows how the transmission for a different disk inclination varies with hour angle ( or @xmath70 ) . at ha=0 , the curves correspond to a cut at @xmath81 in the left panel of fig . [ fig : orient ] . the average of each line over the hour angle range corresponds to the same cut , but in the right panel . because the average of each curve is greater than the minimum value at ha=0 , the disk sensitivity is greater . of course , the inclination and position angle dependence in figs . [ fig : orient ] and [ fig : orient_ha ] shows that it would be highly desirable to discern how the transmitted disk flux changes as a function of hour angle in order to learn about the disk geometry and the possibility of non - axisymmetric structure . for axisymmetric disks there is also a potential degeneracy between the disk geometry and the vertical scale height ; an edge - on disk with sufficient vertical extent will vary much less than the curves in fig . [ fig : orient_ha ] , and may be indistinguishable from a less inclined disk that is oriented such that the transmission variation is small . if a large variation in transmission is seen , the disk may be vertically thin , but could alternatively be non - axisymmetric . the detection of such effects will certainly be sought , but given that we expect most lbti detections to be near the sensitivity limits and therefore at low s / n we assume for now that lbti observations can be modelled by simply averaging over the hour angle . the lbti is well suited to observing dust levels in the habitable regions around nearby stars , both in terms of baseline length and observing wavelength . lbti results will therefore broadly address the goal of characterising warm dust levels without requiring additional information from other observations . however , the specific location and radial extent of the dust will be poorly constrained , and as illustrated by fig . [ fig : fnutvsr ] , significant disk emission can arise from regions both inside and outside the habitable zone and still be detected with the lbti . in general , such degeneracy in disk models will be hard to break because the goal of the lbti is to detect disks that are fainter than current detection limits ( hence the need for the modelling framework outlined in this paper ) . in some cases however , lbti results will be compared to other observations , most likely ( spectro)photometric detections or limits for the total disk flux density at the same wavelength , and in some cases limits on disk size from high - resolution imaging or interferometry . detections and/or upper limits from near - ir interferometry will provide constraints on dust levels inside the lbti iwa . lbti will similarly provide very strong constraints on the emission spectrum and location of hot dust detections .0.9 ) , non - detection with high quality mid - ir photometry is already sufficient to restrict this dust to lie well inside the habitable zone ( kennedy et al . , in prep ) . ] mid - ir photometric data will come from _ _ infrared spectrograph ( irs , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , wise observations @xcite , or in the future the spectrometers on the mid - infrared instrument ( miri ) on the jwst , which cover the same wavelength range as the lbti . such photometry will provide the most useful constraints on the disk location , so we now briefly outline how the total and lbti - transmitted disk fluxes vary with model parameters , in particular the disk inner and outer radii . and @xmath15 , or for two different values of @xmath37 ( the defaults are @xmath82 au , @xmath83 au , @xmath49 ) . the lbti n band is shown as a grey stripe.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] to illustrate the flux density distribution , fig . [ fig : spec ] shows disk spectra for our reference model with @xmath53 , with examples for both sun - like and a - type host stars at 10 pc . because our standard model has the same temperature range all disk spectra have the same shape , but are brighter or fainter depending on the zodi level , the distance to the host star , and the host star spectral type ( which changes the area of the disk and hence total brightness ) . the a5v star has @xmath84 , so the disk around this star is 14 times brighter than for the sun - like star . however , the a - star is only about 5 times brighter at 11 @xmath5 m ( 10 vs. 2 jy ) , so the disk / star flux ratio has increased by a factor of about 3 . [ fig : spec ] also shows how the spectrum varies when @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath37 are changed from their standard values , and what the effect is at the lbti wavelength of 11 @xmath5 m . larger values of @xmath37 concentrate the disk emission closer to the star and hence shift the spectrum towards warmer temperatures . changing @xmath85 and @xmath15 remove emission from the inner and outer disk regions , leading to a spectrum that is closer to a single - temperature black body spectrum . as noted above and shown by the curve for @xmath86 au , the outer disk radius is large enough that the exact value matters little for the level of emission at 11 @xmath5 m . while our model gives a reasonable idea of the true disk spectrum , and could in principle be used to constrain disk structure based on observations at other wavelengths , it is inaccurate on a detailed level because grains do not emit like black bodies . three important differences are that i ) the disk will be fainter than our model at long wavelengths because grains emit inefficiently at wavelengths longer than their size , ii ) the spectrum may also be shifted to shorter wavelengths due to the presence of small grains with temperatures greater than that of a black body , and iii ) the spectrum may show non - continuum spectral features . these differences pose problems for extrapolating our model to other wavelengths , or at least mean that additional parameters such as grain properties would need to be considered . + such differences are of minor importance here however , as important comparisons with other observations can be made at the lbti wavelength , so are largely independent of the disk spectrum . the most important comparison is between the total and transmitted disk fluxes , or equally the total disk to star flux ratio and the null depth . to illustrate why combining such measurements is important , fig . [ fig : rin ] shows how the total and transmitted model disk flux changes at 11 @xmath5 m as the disk inner and outer radii change . as @xmath14 is increased the total disk flux decreases because hot emission is being removed . however , the lbti - transmitted flux changes little while @xmath14 remains small , because these changes occur behind the central transmission minimum and are invisible . when @xmath14 is outside the first transmission peak ( at about 0.7 au here ) both the total and transmitted fluxes decrease in the same way . as @xmath15 is decreased there is initially little difference in the total and transmitted fluxes because the outer disk is faint at 11 @xmath5 m , but when @xmath15 moves behind the central transmission minimum the flux drops much more steeply than the total flux . as noted earlier , fig . [ fig : rin ] shows that the lbti transmission is insensitive to our choice of disk inner and outer radii , as long as the disk is much wider than the habitable zone . given such relations between the total and transmitted disk fluxes , it is clear that observations of both may constrain the disk location . however , the transmitted disk flux is a function of both the disk size and the orientation , so the best constraints on the disk size require the orientation to be known ( or take some assumed value ) . it is unlikely that the position angle will be inferred from lbti measurements in many cases , so the disk orientation would probably be assumed based on other system information , such as coplanarity with a resolved outer cool disk component , the known inclination and/or position angle of the host star s rotation axis , or of planet orbits , or a combination of all three @xcite . see defrre et al . ( submitted ) for an application of this assumption to @xmath87 crv . currently nasa is focussed on developing concepts for three optical ( 0.4 - 1 @xmath5 m ) exoplanet - imaging missions , exo - c ( a coronagraph ) , exo - s ( a starshade ) , as well as an ambitious precursor , the coronagraph on wfirst - afta . therefore , the thermal dust emission information from the lbti must be converted to predict the impact on scattered light imaging . we now derive a simple prescription for converting the dust levels in the above model into scattered light surface brightness estimates . scattered light predictions are in general difficult , and have largely proven unsuccessful to date ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , with debris disks imaged in scattered light generally seen to be much fainter than predicted based on theoretical grain models that match observed thermal emission . the typical minimum grain size in debris disks is thought to 1 - 10 @xmath5 m for sun - like stars ( e.g. * * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and the steepness of the size distribution means that these grains dominate the surface area . such grains are expected to scatter optical light fairly isotropically , and have fairly large albedoes of @xmath880.5 . the scattered light faintness of debris disks , where albedoes of 0.05 - 0.1 are seen ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , likely arise from incorrect assumptions about grain properties and sizes , and how these grains scatter starlight . the properties of exo - zodi are not sufficiently well known that considering physically motivated possibilities for different grain sizes and properties would make predictions for their scattered light brightness more certain . therefore , regardless of the physical reason , we will assume that the @xmath890.1 effective albedoes seen for scattered light disks around nearby stars are representative , and assume isotropic scattering . it may be that the properties of warm dust are different to those inferred from scattered light detections , since for example hot dust detected with near - ir interferometry is generally inferred to originate in much smaller grains . for higher / lower albedoes , our scattered light predictions would be higher / lower by the same factor . while the model surface density @xmath12 is connected to the true optical depth and the surface area of grains from which the emission arises , the model surface density is the true optical depth only if the grains behave like black bodies . that is , real grains reflect starlight , so the true total surface area in the disk is always higher than @xmath12 . to be more realistic , and to allow for the possibility of scattered light , the grain absorption and scattering properties need to be considered . consider a disk with particles with a range of sizes @xmath90 , and @xmath91 the true cross - sectional area per unit area of particles in the size range @xmath90 to @xmath92 . using the absorption efficiency as a function of size and wavelength @xmath93 , the thermal emission is @xmath94 ) dd.\ ] ] though the dependence is not included explicitly here for simplicity , all quantities in this equation also vary with location in the disk due for example to the disk structure and changing composition . using the scattering efficiency @xmath95 the scattered light emission can be written in various ways , but a convenient form is @xmath96 which we could also express in terms of albedo @xmath97 by substituting @xmath98 . if we assume the albedo @xmath99 is the empirical value of 0.1 , independent of grain size and wavelength , then because @xmath100 the surface density @xmath101 is approximately the true optical depth , but is underestimated by a factor of @xmath102 ( i.e. @xmath103 $ ] ) . that is , with these assumptions the thermal surface brightness could be written @xmath104 the scattered light brightness is therefore calculated using the dust surface density and the empirical effective albedo . with these assumptions , the predicted scattered light emission from the model of section [ ss : model ] would be @xmath105 for simplicity we use the value of @xmath12 derived from our modelling , and thus include an extra factor of @xmath106 . therefore , with our model the scattered light surface brightness relative to the stellar flux in the habitable zone ( i.e. @xmath107 ) of a 1 zodi disk decreases as @xmath108 , as the habitable zone is pushed farther from the star by the increased luminosity . this is the approach we use below to estimate the limiting scattered light surface brightnesses for hosts , and for the lbti @xmath87 crv detection . an extension to this approach would be to add a phase function that accounts for forward scattering properly . the albedo could then be derived theoretically and calibrated with observations . while in the above case the scattered light can be calculated simply along the radial direction , and for a given orientation turned into an image , use of a phase function @xmath109 requires a three - dimensional calculation that includes the star - particle - observer scattering angle @xmath69 at each location in the disk . given that we expect relatively large uncertainties in disk parameters , even in the case of a detection , use of a detailed three - dimensional calculation including ( assumed ) grain properties and a phase function will in general be unwarranted . to convert the simple scattered light prediction of equation ( [ eq : ssca ] ) to an observable for an arbitrary disk inclination a three dimensional calculation must be made to account for brighter disk ansae . however , the disk inclination will in general be unknown , so a simple approximation for deriving a representative scattered light surface brightness would be to assume an average inclination of @xmath110 , and for a vertically thin disk an increase of @xmath111 . we now show two examples using the model described above . we first use the lbti commissioning measurement for @xmath87 crv to illustrate how zodi levels are derived , and then derive zodi limits for the hosts survey . these levels assume that the disk orientation is not known , but in some cases coplanarity with a resolved outer disk could be assumed to further constrain the disk brightness . this assumption can be made for @xmath87 crv , and we refer the reader to defrre et al . ( submitted ) for an in - depth discussion of these results for this system . using @xmath87 crv with a null depth of @xmath112% as an example , we first show how the distribution of zodi levels is derived assuming an unknown disk orientation . this procedure is generic in that it can be applied to any lbti observation , whether a significant detection or an upper limit was found . the lbti is still in commissioning so the zodi sensitivity derived here is not illustrative of the expected performance . [ fig : etacrvlim ] shows the @xmath113-plane coverage of the lbti observation relative to the disk position angle , and the distribution of zodi levels calculated using our reference model . we include the rotation of the disk relative to the fringe pattern during the observation to compute the average null depth for each disk orientation . as described at the end of section [ ss : trx ] the distribution is essentially the inverse of that shown in fig . [ fig : ftrhist ] . the distribution is strongly peaked at about @xmath114 , with a tail of larger values due to unfavourable disk orientations . the 1@xmath115 zodi uncertainty due purely to the calibrated null depth measurement is given by the width of the `` median @xmath116 null uncertainty '' error bar in the right panel of fig . [ fig : etacrvlim ] . similarly , the 16 and 84% levels from the cumulative distribution give a representative 1@xmath115 range due to the orientation distribution . the upper uncertainty on the zodi level is therefore set by the orientation distribution , while the lower uncertainty is set by the null depth measurement . the median zodi level for @xmath87 crv is @xmath117 if the uncertainty is set by the lbti null depth measurement . including the 1@xmath115 range from the orientation distribution in quadrature , the range covered on either side of the median value is @xmath118 . in general , we expect that the null depth uncertainty will dominate the lower bound on the zodi level , and the orientation distribution will dominate the upper bound . for comparison , based on a kin detection and using the ` zodipic ` model mennesson et al . ( in press ) found @xmath119 for @xmath87 crv at 8.5 @xmath5 m with no assumptions about the disk orientation . our derived zodi level is different for two reasons : i ) @xmath87 crv is hotter than the sun ( 6900k ) , so our luminosity - dependent zodi definition will lead to a zodi level about 1.7 times smaller than ` zodipic ` , and ii ) the mid - ir spectrum of the @xmath87 crv disk increases more steeply with wavelength than a black body ( i.e. has a silicate spectral feature ) , so although our model has nearly the same temperature profile as ` zodipic ` , our derived zodi level will be slightly larger because lbti observes at 11 @xmath5 m . therefore , direct comparisons between our zodi levels and those using ` zodipic ` should not be made . using the simple prescription for the scattered light surface brightness described in section [ ss : scat ] , we can convert the zodi levels shown in fig . [ fig : etacrvlim ] into a prediction for the face - on scattered light surface brightness . here , the value of interest is the surface brightness in the habitable zone , as this is where planets would be sought . the level is then calculated using equation ( [ eq : ssca ] ) , with @xmath120 because @xmath16 is the value at the radial distance where the equilibrium temperature is the same as earth s . adopting @xmath121 , and using @xmath122 jy in v band , @xmath123 pc , @xmath124 au , and @xmath125 yields a scattered light surface brightness of @xmath126 mjy / arcsec@xmath10 , or about 15 mag / arcsec@xmath10 . as noted above , this habitable zone estimate may be increased by a factor of a few to account for the inclination of the disk . given a prediction for the sensitivity of the lbti and a sample of stars that will be observed , we can make predictions for the sensitivity of the hosts survey . in what follows we assume a 1@xmath115 uncertainty on the lbti calibrated null depth of @xmath127 , and hence the limits presented are also at 1@xmath115 . limits are calculated as above , using the median of the distribution of zodi levels over the random distribution of orientations . though we do not account for it here , there is some uncertainty in the stellar flux densities and luminosities used , which we estimate to contribute at about the 5% level . here we calculate the sensitivity assuming an observation at a single hour angle , but when the model is applied to real observations in the future the calculations will account for sky rotation as described in section [ ss : ha ] . these calculations are carried out for both our reference disk model , and a `` worst - case '' scenario where the dust is restricted to lie only within the habitable zone , which we assume to lie between temperatures of 320 and 210k . as shown in figs . [ fig : fnutvsr ] and [ fig : rin ] , the lbti is sensitive to emission that lies interior and exterior to the habitable zone , so the dust surface density must be higher in the latter case for an lbti detection at the same sensitivity . as noted above in section [ ss : zodi ] , the `` zodi levels '' derived with this different radial structure are also different and should really be considered as enhancements over the surface density derived for the solar zodiacal cloud , rather than zodi levels to be compared with other values . the hosts survey sample is described by weinberger et al . ( submitted ) , the key aspect being that targets are chosen such that their habitable zones have larger angular sizes than the first lbti transmission peak , so observations directly probe the levels of habitable zone dust . the sample is split by @xmath128 colour at 0.42 into `` sun - like '' and `` sensitivity '' sub - samples , which simply reflects the levels of dust that can be detected . ) .,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] + ) .,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] + ) .,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] figure [ fig : leak ] shows the predicted disk to star flux ratios , null depths , and sensitivity in zodi units for the hosts sample using our reference model ( red and blue symbols ) and our worst case scenario ( grey symbols , which we discuss below ) . the top and middle panels show the flux ratios and null depths expected for a 1 zodi model around these stars , and the bottom panel shows the sensitivity in zodis for the predicted lbti sensitivity . there are clear trends with stellar luminosity , which can be understood as follows . with our model the disk flux density at fixed wavelength scales with the angular area , i.e. , @xmath129 ( with our zodi definition @xmath16 is constant , but we include it to consider other zodi definitions below ) . the stellar flux , on the other hand , scales @xmath130 in the rayleigh - jeans regime so the total disk to star flux ratio only depends on the star , and is higher for earlier spectral types @xmath131 this dependence in the top panel of fig . [ fig : leak ] arises due to the stronger scaling of stellar luminosity with temperature than flux density at 11 @xmath5 m , with the variations from a perfect correlation arising due to variation in @xmath1 at fixed @xmath132 ( i.e. different stellar radii ) . at fixed distance , as the stellar temperature and luminosity increase the habitable zone is pushed outwards ( @xmath133 ) and its area and brightness increase more rapidly than the stellar flux . alternatively , for a fixed disk angular size ( and hence fixed disk brightness ) , increasing the stellar temperature and luminosity pushes the system to greater distances and the star becomes fainter due to increasing distance faster than it becomes brighter due to an increased temperature . the null depths for a 1 zodi disk are shown in the middle panel , and the trend has a similar origin as the disk to star flux ratio . at fixed distance , increasing stellar luminosity increases the disk surface brightness at fixed angular radius because @xmath17 increases ( i.e. increases if @xmath37 is positive ) . assuming that most of the transmitted disk flux originates from a constant angular scale ( i.e. near the first transmission peak ) , the transmitted disk flux therefore increases as @xmath134 ( assuming that the effect of the changing disk temperature in the first transmission peak is small ) . combining this expression with the stellar flux yields a null depth @xmath135 \ , .\ ] ] hosts stars are chosen to have habitable zones with similar angular sizes and for our reference model @xmath49 , so the term in square parentheses varies relatively little and the null depth almost entirely depends on the stellar temperature . the absolute null depth level of course also varies linearly with the zodi level , so the zodi limits can be derived by dividing the expected sensitivity of @xmath127 by the null depth values in the middle panel ( i.e. by solving equation ( [ eq : leakmod ] ) for @xmath18 ) @xmath136 \ , .\ ] ] the resulting sensitivities show that what we define as solar system levels of zodiacal dust are at the predicted 1@xmath115 noise level for early - type stars , as are 3 - 10 zodi disks around sun - like stars . this discussion of scalings applies equally to the narrow worst case scenario , shown as grey symbols in fig . [ fig : leak ] . as expected for a narrower disk that emits over a smaller total physical area , the disk to star flux ratios are lower than for our reference model , as are the null depths . while the difference between the two models is about a factor of five in disk / star flux ratio , the difference in null depths is only a factor of two to three because most of the flux removed from the disk in the narrower model is hidden behind the central transmission minimum ( e.g. fig . [ fig : rin ] ) . similarly , the difference in zodi levels is a factor two to three higher in this case compared to our reference model . therefore , the effect of this pessimistic scenario in terms of habitable zone dust levels is relatively minor . because our zodi definition is based on constant surface density in the habitable zone , the @xmath18 dependence on luminosity directly shows that the lbti can truly detect lower surface densities of dust in the habitable zones of earlier type stars . this conclusion does not depend on our zodi definition because the lbti is sensitive to @xmath137 . a different definition , for example @xmath138 , makes the zodi limit approximately constant ( @xmath139^\alpha$ ] ) , but also implies @xmath140 ( and the sensitivity to habitable zone surface density is the same as with our definition ) . ) for the reference disk model for hosts survey stars , split into `` sun - like '' and `` sensitivity '' sub - samples ( red circles and blue squares ) . these limits use equation ( [ eq : ssca ] ) and the zodi limits from fig . [ fig : leak ] . grey symbols show a pessimistic narrow - disk scenario where disks only cover the habitable zone ( from 320 to 210k).,scaledwidth=50.0% ] given the detection limits in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : leak ] , we can also derive the face - on habitable zone ( @xmath141 au ) scattered light surface brightness of disks at the hosts survey detection limits . these limits are shown in fig . [ fig : ssca ] for @xmath121 as defined in section [ ss : scat ] . red and blue symbols show limits for our standard disk model , which again depend on the stellar luminosity . the origin of the dependence on stellar luminosity can be understood by rewriting equation ( [ eq : ssca ] ) using the zodi limit scaling above @xmath142 like the zodi limits , the scattered light levels in the habitable zone at these limits decrease with stellar luminosity . the squared distance and luminosity dependence is simply the geometric effect that accounts for @xmath143 dilution of light and that surface brightness is an angular measure . the extra @xmath37 dependence is because the habitable zone is not at the first transmission peak for all targets . if the lbti observation is dominated by emission near the first transmission peak , but the habitable zone is slightly farther out ( i.e. @xmath144 ) , the @xmath37 dependence represents a model - dependent extrapolation that is relatively unimportant while @xmath37 is small . as with the lbti sensitivity to habitable zone surface density , our zodi definition has no effect on the scattered light predictions and is merely an intermediate step for deriving the true quantity of interest . that is , as described above the lbti sensitivity to @xmath12 in the habitable zone ( i.e. @xmath145 ) , which sets the limits on @xmath146 , will always be the same . for the example of a constant @xmath147 zodi definition therefore , @xmath18 is constant but @xmath148 and equation ( [ eq : scamod ] ) is the same . because the hosts sample is explicitly chosen such that the lbti is sensitive to thermal emission from dust in the region of interest for earth - imaging , the scattered light predictions do not strongly depend on the choice of our disk model parameters ( but of course depends on albedo ) . the predictions are not totally independent of our disk model however , since for example changing the steepness of the radial profile makes the dust in the model more or less concentrated relative to the lbti transmission pattern , thus changing the derived zodi level . varying @xmath37 between -1 and 1 yields changes of @xmath1491 mag in the scattered light predictions , meaning that the model dependent uncertainty is similar to the variation expected from the unknown disk inclination . for solar - type stars , the scattered light levels in fig . [ fig : ssca ] for our face - on reference model at the @xmath894 zodi detection limit is 20 - 21 mag arcsec@xmath11 . for comparison , using a 4 zodi disk the ` zodipic ` model predicts 21.2 mag arcsec@xmath11 at 1 au with default parameters ( a solar analogue with @xmath150 and use of a phase function ) , and 21.6 mag arcsec@xmath11 for @xmath121 and isotropic scattering . our simple model therefore compares well with the more complex calculation made by ` zodipic ` . for a 60@xmath25 inclined disk , ` zodipic ` gives 21.1 mag arcsec@xmath11 , and for 90@xmath25 gives 20.6 mag arcsec@xmath11 , and therefore the increase from face - on to edge - on is about 1 magnitude . our model has smaller vertical extent than ` zodipic ` , so the increase in surface brightness for inclined disks will be larger , roughly a factor of three for a 60@xmath25 inclined disk . the grey symbols in fig . [ fig : ssca ] show the scattered light surface brightness for narrower disks that only lie in the habitable zone . these limits are about 1 magnitude brighter than our reference model , so similar to the variation in brightness with the ( unknown ) disk orientation . therefore , the scattered light limits from lbti observations are fairly robust to disk width . we have outlined a parameterised disk model to be used for modelling and interpreting mid - ir exo - zodi observations with the lbti . using this model , we have illustrated how to derive dust limits and levels for exo - zodiacal clouds , and how these can be converted to scattered light surface brightnesses needed for planning future missions that will image extrasolar earth - analogues . using the hosts sample that the lbti will observe , we illustrate the survey detection limits both in terms of zodi units and the expected scattered light levels at these limits . these limits are around ten times the solar system level for solar - type stars , and thus the lbti is expected to provide stringent limits with key information that will help plan future earth - imaging efforts . the large binocular telescope interferometer is funded by the national aeronautics and space administration as part of its exoplanet exploration program . this work was supported by the european union through erc grant number 279973 ( gmk , op , abs & mcw ) . we thank the reviewer for valuable comments . , o. , defrre , d. , coud du foresto , v. , di folco , e. , mrand , a. , augereau , j .- c . , ertel , s. , hanot , c. , kervella , p. , mollier , b. , scott , n. , che , x. , monnier , j. d. , thureau , n. , tuthill , p. g. , ten brummelaar , t. a. , mcalister , h. a. , sturmann , j. , sturmann , l. , & turner , n. 2013 , , 555 , a104 , d. , absil , o. , augereau , j .- c . , di folco , e. , berger , j .- p . , coud du foresto , v. , kervella , p. , le bouquin , j .- b . , lebreton , j. , millan - gabet , r. , monnier , j. d. , olofsson , j. , & traub , w. 2011 , , 534 , a5 , j. , van lieshout , r. , augereau , j .- c . , absil , o. , mennesson , b. , kama , m. , dominik , c. , bonsor , a. , vandeportal , j. , beust , h. , defrre , d. , ertel , s. , faramaz , v. , hinz , p. , kral , q. , lagrange , a .- m . , liu , w. , & thbault , p. 2013 , , 555 , a146 , r. , serabyn , e. , mennesson , b. , traub , w. a. , barry , r. k. , danchi , w. c. , kuchner , m. , stark , c. c. , ragland , s. , hrynevych , m. , woillez , j. , stapelfeldt , k. , bryden , g. , colavita , m. m. , & booth , a. j. 2011 , , 734 , 67 Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: multilayers built from ferromagnetic layers with various spacer layers include a wide variety of magnetic film systems that have been intensively studied during last years . due to remarkable phenomena as giant magnetoresistance , exchange - spring behaviour and/or exchange bias , and surface enhanced magnetic anisotropy , such nanostructures have already found a number of applications and are considered as promising candidates for nonvolatile magnetic recording media.@xcite on the other hand , nanoscale superlattices and similar structures provide convenient model systems to study different aspects of surface magnetism and magnetic ordering in confining geometry . in particular , much attention has been given to multilayers composed of antiferromagnetically coupled ferromagnetic nanolayers . @xcite such layered synthetic antiferromagnets can be separated into two classes according to the symmetries ruling their magnetic properties : superlattices with relatively strong uniaxial anisotropies include low - symmetry multilayers with effective uniaxial magnetic anisotropy in the layer planes , e.g. epitaxial systems deposited on ( 110 ) , ( 211 ) faces of cubic substrates.@xcite also multilayer systems with perpendicular anisotropy belong to this class.@xcite magnetization processes in these nanostructures are strongly influenced by the uniaxial anisotropy which is responsible for specific phenomena such as `` surface spin - flop '' @xcite or field - induced metamagnetic jumps.@xcite on the other hand , the uniaxial anisotropy may be absent in layered systems with higher symmetry . these represent another large and intensively investigated class of synthetic antiferromagnetic nanostructures . superlattices with planar magnetization grown on ( 001 ) faces of cubic substrates , e.g. multilayers from materials combinations as co / cu @xcite , fe / si @xcite co / cr , @xcite or fe / cr , @xcite belong to this class . in the case of weak four - fold anisotropy , their magnetic properties are mostly determined by the interlayer exchange interactions which may include an important _ biquadratic _ contribution . @xcite evidence of strong biquadratic exchange interaction has been given in a number of experimental papers for fe / cr two - layers and multilayers @xcite , for fe / si(001 ) multilayers @xcite ) . strong effective four - fold anisotropies have been found in systems such as co / cr(001 ) or fe / cr(001 ) . @xcite the competition between magnetic anisotropy , applied fields and exchange energies may cause complicated magnetic effects and processes . in fact , a great number of novel magnetic configurations and remarkable reorientational effects in external fields have been found in such superlattices . @xcite in particular , recent experimental results using modern depth - resolving techniques reveal spatially inhomogeneous magnetic structures , e.g. in fe / cr(001 ) superlattices,@xcite and specific reorientation effects imposed by four - fold planar ( tetragonal ) anisotropy.@xcite the understanding and interpretation of the complex magnetization processes found in such systems @xcite requires a theoretical underpinning . theoretical activity in this field is largely based on analytical and numerical calculations mostly within phenomenological approaches . @xcite these studies have demonstrated the general validity of the phenomenological models to describe the magnetization processes in antiferromagnetic nanostructures . @xcite for the system under discussion the phenomenological theory has been developed to describe effects of 90 degree couplings and a concomitant complex evolution of domain structures in fe / cr / fe layers.@xcite four - fold anisotropy effects have been theoretically investigated in ref . for sandwich structures with @xmath2=2 ferromagnetic layers coupled through a spacer . multilayer systems provide also experimental models to study effects of the confining surfaces on antiferromagnetic structures.@xcite in this context , specific inhomogeneous magnetic states described for theoretical models in ref . , have recently been observed in fe / cr superlattices.@xcite the existing theoretical results , however , are restricted to special cases and are not sufficient for an exhaustive description of the magnetic states and field - induced reorientional effects observed in recent experiment . @xcite in this paper we provide a theoretical analysis of magnetic states and magnetization processes in planar antiferromagnetic superlattices with and without four - fold anisotropy in magnetic fields applied within the multilayer plane . in such magnetic superlattices the exchange interlayer coupling is an oscillatory function of the spacer thickness.@xcite depending on the spacer thickness an alternating sequence of ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interlayer couplings is realized , and , by adjusting the spacer thicknesses , very different strengths of antiferromagnetic coupling can be realized . on the other hand , the four - fold anisotropy includes interface - induced contributions which implies a strong dependency of the effective average anisotropy of each ferromagnetic layer on the layer thickness.@xcite thus , the effective magnetic interactions can vary in extremely broad ranges for such multilayers in dependence on the chosen materials combinations and thicknesses , see e.g. ref . , where for a co / cu(001 ) two - layer system with a wedged spacer layer the ratio between four - fold anisotropy energy and the exchange coupling is changed by orders of magnitude . in contrast to bulk planar antiferromagnets , where an essentially fixed hierarchy for the strengths of the magnetic interactions holds,@xcite in these artificial antiferromagnetic systems the ratios between different magnetic energies , respectively the phenomenological parameters in the magnetic free - energy , may assume practically arbitrary values . moreover , as the interlayer exchange is weak compared to direct exchange interactions , the fields to induce spin - reorientation phenomena are similarly weak and experimentally accessible . the rich phase diagrams for these systems precludes an analysis in all details . the phase space in terms of the phenomenological parameters includes a large variety of different magnetic states with a corresponding multitude of spontaneous and field - induced phase - transformations . in a first step to such an analysis , all laterally homogeneous states in such multilayers must be found . they are the building blocks for a domain theory.@xcite for the case of laterally homogeneous states of each ferromagnetic sublayer one has a system that behaves like an antiferromagnetically coupled chain of stoner - wohlfarth particles . this simplified one - dimensional model for the behaviour across the multilayer stack also yields the limiting case for the magnetization processes with maximum hystereses . again , a direct analysis of all magnetic states even for these one - dimensional models yields an intricate succession of phase diagrams and magnetization curves.@xcite in this paper , we avoid the cumbersome task of listing and classifying _ all _ solutions and transitions . instead , we provide a broad physically intuitive picture of the physical effects due to the different exchange or anisotropic forces , and those imposed by the confining geometry of the system . to this end , we study limiting cases of the model . this includes the case of strictly zero anisotropy with and without biquadratic exchange , and the case of infinite anisotropy with fixed four - fold orientation of the magnetizations in each layer . for the antiferromagnetic two - layer systems ( @xmath2=2 ) , i.e. the sandwich structures ( experimentally realized as ferromagnetic / spacer / ferromagnetic trilayers ) , we provide a detailed investigation of the magnetic phase - diagram for arbitrary orientation of fields in the layer planes . based on this , we can understand the _ basic _ magnetic configurations in the multilayers , and we can give a map of the _ topologically different types _ of magnetic phase diagrams . we use standard methods to analyse magnetic phases and transitions within the phenomenological approach and the theory of phase transitions.@xcite the one - dimensional chain models are considered as composite order - parameters with many components ( @xmath2 components in a multilayer stack composed of @xmath2 ferromagnetic / spacer bilayers ) and a characteristic structure of couplings between the components defined by interlayer exchange and the surfaces . from this point of view , the very rich phase - diagrams and correspondingly complex sequences of magnetic configurations can be understood . for the general cases of the model , the equations for equilibrium and phase stability can be solved only by numerical methods . with the methods and results expounded below , one can extend the analysis to specific experimental cases in all detail . the solutions for the one - dimensional chain models include various field - induced canted and inhomogeneous states with a net magnetization . based on the phase diagrams of these models , the evolution of laterally inhomogeneous ( domain ) states and magnetization processes can be discussed.@xcite in this connection , the coexistence regions of different phases in the vicinity of discontinuous ( first - order ) magnetic phase transitions are important . in external fields , thermodynamically stable domain - configuration from these competing phases can be established in extended multilayers this is crucial for an understanding of the hysteretic magnetization processes under coercivity mechanisms . the paper is organized as follows . after introducing the model and mathematical tools ( sec . ii ) we consider the effects of the bilinear and biquadratic exchange interactions in the next section ( sec . iii ) . in sec . iv we investigate in detail four - fold anisotropy effects in antiferromagnetically coupled two - layers and then discuss the generalization of these finding to the case of multilayers . in sec . iv we discuss domain states and magnetization processes by using qualitative arguments . in the concluding part we discuss possible extensions of the theory , and we suggest some useful experiments to enhance our understanding of magnetization processes in antiferromagnetic superlattices . let us consider a stack of @xmath2 ferromagnetic plates infinite in @xmath3- and @xmath4-directions and with finite thickness along @xmath5-axis . the magnetization of the layers is @xmath6 , and there are indirect interlayer - exchange couplings through spaces between them . the phenomenological energy of the system can be written in the following form @xmath7 -\mathbf{h}\cdot \sum_{i=1}^{n}\zeta_i \mathbf{m}_i - \frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{n } k_i\left ( \mathbf{m}_x^4 + \mathbf{m}_y^4 \right ) \label{energy1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) are unity vectors along the @xmath10-th layer magnetization . @xmath11 designate deviations of the magnetization in the @xmath10-th layer from the averaged value @xmath12 . we assume that @xmath13=0 , i.e. the layer magnetizations are restricted to the layer plane . @xmath14 and @xmath15 are constants of bilinear and biquadratic exchange interactions , respectively ; @xmath16 are constants of the in - plane four - fold anisotropy . the functional ( [ energy1 ] ) generalizes similar models considered earlier in a number of studies on exchange @xcite and anisotropy @xcite effects in planar antiferromagnetic systems . within this approach the ferromagnetic layers are considered as homogeneously magnetized blocks with constant values of the magnetic interactions . this assumption deserves some comment . it is well - established that in magnetic nanostructures surface / interface exchange and relativistic interactions strongly modify electronic and magnetic properties within all volume of the magnetic constituents @xcite . this means that the values of the exchange or anisotropy parameters , and the magnetizations include large interface / surface - induced components which may strongly vary across the thickness of the individual layers.@xcite however , the hypothesis of magnetic homogeneity in the ferromagnetic nanolayers in the models of type ( [ energy1 ] ) has a solid physical basis and is justified by successful applications of these models to describe magnetization processes in layered ferro- and antiferromagnetic nanostructures.@xcite this relies on the fact that in ferromagnetic nanolayers the intrinsic ( direct ) exchange coupling are usually very strong and overcome surface / interface induced interactions . thus , they play the dominating role to determine the magnetic order _ within _ the layers , which reacts also very stiffly on all external and induced magnetic forces . furthermore , in these planar systems the stray field forces confine the magnetization of the layers into their plane . as a result , in most of these systems the ferromagnetic layers preserve essentially homogeneous in - plane magnetized states even under the influence of strongly inhomogeneous induced interactions.@xcite in this connection it is important to stress here that the materials parameters in the phenomenological model ( [ energy1 ] ) should be treated as averages over a multilayer _ period_. they comprise ( in integral form ) all intrinsic and induced energy contributions of the magnetic states in the ferromagnetic layers . in particular , for the systems under consideration they may also include a contribution from magnetism of the spacer layers . thus , in contrast to their bulk counterparts which are considered as constants of the magnetic material , in nanoscale multilayer systems the phenomenological parameters strongly depend on many physical and geometrical factors and may considerably vary from sample to sample . parity of @xmath2 also plays an important role . the model ( [ energy1 ] ) with _ even _ number of ferromagnetic layers represents systems with fully compensated magnetization . such superlattices can be treated as analogues to bulk collinear antiferromagnets . superlattices with odd numbers of layers or with unequal thicknesses of layers own a noncompensated magnetization which strongly determines their global magnetic properties . in their response to an applied field , these structures are similar to bulk ferrimagnets . they could be studied by similar methods as used below , but have to be considered as separate class of systems . concentrating on the properties of systems with fully compensated total magnetization , we consider only superlattices with even @xmath2 and equal magnetization in all layers ( @xmath17 ) . in this contribution dedicated to general properties of these antiferromagnetic superlattices , we avoid secondary effects which are related to their micro - structure and interface properties , such as strains , chemical intermixing etc . with that in view we will study the model ( [ energy1 ] ) mainly for the case of _ identical _ ferromagnetic layers assuming that the exchange and anisotropy constants are equal for all the layers , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 . some of the analytical results can be generalized to the isotropic ( i. e. with @xmath21 ) system with mirror symmetry about the center of the layer stack , i.e. @xmath22 and @xmath23 . in our problem the magnetization of the _ i_th layer is confined in planar orientations and can be described by the angle @xmath24 between the vector @xmath25 and @xmath3-axis . thus , calculations of the magnetic states for the model ( [ energy1 ] ) can be reduced to the optimization of the function @xmath26 . following the theory of bulk antiferromagnetism it is convenient to introduce here the vectors of the _ total magnetization _ @xmath27 and the _ staggered _ ( or _ antiferromagnetism _ ) vector @xmath28 @xmath29 the energy ( [ energy1 ] ) is invariant under transformation @xmath30 , and , therefore , all magnetic states in this model are degenerate with respect to the sign of the staggered vectors . in the following only solutions with a definite sign of the staggered vector will be discussed . however , one should keep in mind that the full set of solutions includes also those with opposite sign of @xmath28 . the magnetic states with opposite sign of @xmath28 behave identically in an applied magnetic field . thus , for the magnetization processes there is no need to distinguish these solutions . for the particular case of a two - layer ( @xmath0 ) the energy ( [ energy1 ] ) can be transformed to the following form @xmath31 where @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 is the angle between the @xmath35 and the @xmath3-axis . this case of a two - layer is of special interest . the energy ( [ energy2 ] ) functionally coincides with that of a bulk two - sublattice antiferromagnet . this offers the opportunity for useful physical relations and analogies with bulk antiferromagnetism . on the other hand , the two - layers represent the simplest model of antiferromagnetically coupled layered nanostructures . the equations minimizing the function @xmath26 have strongly nonlinear character and no analytical solution are available generally . the body of our results have been obtained by numerical methods . we solve the coupled equations for equilibria @xmath36 by an efficient conjugate gradient minimization.@xcite for systems with large anisotropy the configurations with the magnetizations oriented in the four - fold easy - axis directions are close to mostly metastable minima of the energy . these configurations have been systematically searched for global absolute stability and checked for stability . numerically , this is feasible for @xmath2 not too large with present day computers . stability limits and phase - transitions are determined from the evolution of the smallest eigenvalue @xmath37 of the stability matrix @xmath38 under changing parameters in ( [ energy1 ] ) , i.e. ratios @xmath39 , @xmath40 , or the applied magnetic field . basic spin - configurations in isotropic antiferromagnetically coupled two - layers ( @xmath2=2 ) . at zero field ( a ) the magnetization vectors @xmath25 are antiparallel in adjacent layers but the structure has no fixed orientation in the plane ( infinite degeneracy ) . an in - plane magnetic field lifts the degeneracy and stabilizes states with * l * perpendicular to the field and with * m * along the field - this is a spin - flop ( sf ) phase ( b ) . in a sufficiently strong magnetic field the sf phases transform into the saturated ( _ flip _ ) phase ( c),width=321 ] we start the investigations of the static configurations minimizing energy ( [ energy1 ] ) from the isotropic case ( i.e. with @xmath16 = 0 ) . depending on relations between bilinear and biquadratic constants different collinear and noncollinear configurations are stable.@xcite ) the equations @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 determine the region in the parameter space where a collinear _ antiferromagnetic _ ( af ) phase is the zero - field ground - state consisting of blocks of adjacent layers with antiparallel orientation of the magnetization ( fig . we restrict our analysis to this practically important case . the af phase is infinitely degenerate with respect to orientations of the staggered vector * l * in planar directions . the magnetic states for the isotropic two - layer ( @xmath0 ) in the applied field can be obtained by minimization of the energy ( [ energy2 ] ) with @xmath44 . the solutions ( @xmath45 , @xmath46 ) describe the states with the staggered vector perpendicular to the applied field ( so called _ spin - flop _ ( sf ) phase ) . in an increasing magnetic field the magnetization vectors rotate into the field direction ( fig . 1 ( b ) ) , and finally a continuous transition into the ferromagnetic ( _ flip _ ) phase with @xmath47 . this ( _ spin - flip _ transition ) occurs at the exchange - field @xmath48 ( fig . 1 ( c ) ) , which is lower than the corresponding spin - flip field @xmath49 for a bulk system . in superlattices with @xmath1 the magnetic field applied in the plane also lifts the degeneracy and stabilizes the sf phase ( the state with @xmath50 and @xmath51 ) ( figs . however , the magnetic configurations in these sf states and their evolution in the applied field are markedly different from those in bulk antiferromagnets or in the two - layer systems . it turns out that magnetic structures of the multilayers with @xmath2 divisible by four ( @xmath52 called here _ even - even _ ) differ from _ even - odd _ systems with @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) . in low fields ( @xmath55 ) the solutions for the sf phase are given by a set of linear equations @xmath56 where @xmath57 for even - even and @xmath58 even - odd systems . it is clear that for the isotropic model the direction of the magnetic field in the film plane plays no role . following the definition of the angles @xmath24 we assume here that the magnetic field is applied along the @xmath3-axis . the solutions ( [ sol1 ] ) describe small deviations of the magnetization vectors , from the directions perpendicular to the easy axis ( see the magnetization profiles in figs . 2 , 4 and the configuration in fig . 3 ( b ) ) . in all internal layers ( @xmath59 ) neighbouring pairs retain antiparallel orientations ( e.g. , ( @xmath60 ) and ( @xmath61 ) in fig . 3b ) . for even - even systems the magnetization vectors of the central layers ( @xmath62 , @xmath63 ) preserve perpendicular orientation even in finite ( but weak ) fields ( see layers 6 and 7 in fig . 3 ) . for even - odd systems the magnetization vectors of all layers have finite deviations from perpendicular orientation . towards top and bottom layer @xmath64 or @xmath2 in the stack , these deviations increase . due to antiparallel orientation the pairs have zero net magnetization . the total magnetization arises only due to the top and bottom layers @xmath64 and @xmath2 . note that in these configurations a number of layers rotates against the applied field ( in fig . 2 - 4 the layers with @xmath10 = 2 , 4 and their symmetric counterparts with @xmath10 = 11 , 9 ) . this occurs because , in weak fields , the exchange interactions favouring antiparallel magnetizations in adjacent layers play the dominant role . an increasing magnetic field counteracts and slows down this reverse rotation , when the non - linear evolution for the magnetization structure is reached , and finally the sense of rotation is changed at characteristic fields @xmath65 where @xmath66 . with increasing @xmath2 the number of layers increases which display this reverse rotation , the deviations from orientations perpendicular to the applied low field become larger near the surface layers , and the fields @xmath65 are reached at lower fields ( see inset in fig . 2 for @xmath67 ) . a further set of characteristic fields @xmath68 defines the points where the projection of @xmath69 on the field directions changes the sign ( the field @xmath70 and @xmath71 are indicated in fig . 2 . ) in increasing field these characteristic fields initially are reached for the central layers and at higher fields for those closer to the boundaries . for fields @xmath72 the magnetization directions of all layers have positive projections onto the field direction . in the model with equal exchange constant there is another special field @xmath73 ( independent of @xmath2 ) , where all inner layers have the same projection onto the field direction ( @xmath74 , @xmath75 ) . the parameters of this `` knot '' point are determined from a set of equations @xmath76 the functions @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 are plotted in fig . [ knotpoint ] . in particular for superlattices with zero biquadratic exchange @xmath80 one has @xmath81 and @xmath82 . near saturation , the sf phase has only positive projections of the magnetization on the direction of the magnetic field which decreases towards the center similarly to spin configurations obtained numerically in ref . . evolution of spin - states in multilayers with a field @xmath83 applied in the plane of the layers and for zero anisotropy @xmath84 and biquadratic exchange @xmath80 , hence @xmath85 . main figure : rotation angles of the layers in the plane @xmath24 @xmath86 for superlattice with @xmath87 . at point labeled `` r '' the sense of rotation changes for the magnetization direction @xmath24 ( here , @xmath88 ) ; at point `` @xmath89 '' the magnetization of this layer is perpendicular to the applied field again . point `` @xmath90 '' is the `` knot - point '' ( eq . ( [ knot ] ) ) . inset : @xmath67 only @xmath24 for even @xmath88 and @xmath91 shown . , width=321 ] spin - states in multilayers with @xmath87 for zero anisotropy @xmath84 and field @xmath83 applied in the plane : ( a ) @xmath92 ( b ) @xmath93 ( c ) @xmath94 ( d ) @xmath95 ( e ) @xmath96 , and ( f ) @xmath97 , i.e. below the transition to the flip - phase ( cf . [ evolutionkzero ] ) . all states have mirror - symmetry about the center of the multilayer stack ( marked by the dashed line ) . , width=321 ] the spatial inhomogeneity of the sf phases in the multilayers and their remarkable evolution in the applied field are due to the particular _ finite - size _ effects in this type of magnetic nanostructures . in such layered nanostructures all internal layers interact with two adjacent layers but the top and bottom layer have only one neighbouring layer . thus , their exchange coupling is weakened compared to internal layers within the multilayer stack . this strong disbalance of the exchange forces at the boundaries affects the magnetic ordering within the entire multilayer and causes the reorientational processes in the sf phases . this mechanism is also responsible for the occurrence of inhomogeneous states in other noncollinear structures in the multilayers ( see iv.c and v.a ) . note , this important role of the cut exchange - couplings is specific to antiferromagnetic confined systems with noncompensated moments at surfaces . in contrast , the cutting of exchange couplings does not affect _ ferromagnetically _ coupled nanostructures where relative orientation of the magnetization in the layers essentially depend only on magnetic anisotropy , applied fields , and the demagnetizing stray - fields . evolution of spin - flop profiles for the multilayer with finite biquadratic exchange is plotted in fig . 4 . for the systems with collinear ground - states the biquadratic exchange does not induce reorientional transitions but it has rather strong influence on the distribution of the magnetization in the multilayers ( see insets in fig . 4 ) and the value of the characteristic fields ( fig . 5 ) . the effects of a biquadratic exchange @xmath98 , if present in multilayers with collinear antiferromagnetic ground - state , can be easily understood . for magnetic configurations close to the antiparallel orientation of neighbouring layers , it softens the linear exchange forces ; for nearly parallel orientation the system becomes stiffer instead . the evolution of the magnetic states in the external field is distorted accordingly by the presence of the biquadratic exchange @xmath98 ( fig . [ evolutionkappa ] ) . in low fields close to the antiferromagnetic ground - state , the system reacts more strongly on the external field . thus , the fields @xmath99 , where the rotation of the ithe layer reverses , and the field @xmath68 , where perpendicular orientation with respect to field is regained , respectively , are reached at relatively lower fields ( labels `` r '' and `` @xmath89 '' in fig . [ evolutionkappa ] ) . conversely , the ferromagnetic state is reached only close to the enhanced exchange fields @xmath100 reflecting the stiffening of the effective exchange couplings in nearly ferromagnetic configurations . thus , the magnetization curves acquire a nonlinear character with increasing @xmath98 ( inset ( a ) in fig . [ evolutionkappa ] ) . experimental observation of the fields @xmath99 and the special field @xmath101 ( fig . [ knotpoint ] ) could be used to determine the relative strength of @xmath98 . for large values of @xmath102 the reversal of the rotation of the magnetizations of individual layers takes place at very low fields ( see , inset ( b ) in fig . [ evolutionkappa ] ) . evolution of magnetic states in antiferromagnetic multilayer @xmath87 with zero anisotropy @xmath84 and biquadratic exchange @xmath103 , i.e. with enhanced @xmath49 ( compare with fig . [ evolutionkzero ] for @xmath104 ) . @xmath83 is applied in the layer plane . insets ( a ) : magnetization curves in the range of values of @xmath105 with antiferromagnetic ground - state in zero field . ( b ) : evolution of states ( only shown for layers with even numbers ) in small fields for @xmath106 . , width=321 ] dependence of `` knot '' point @xmath107 ( eq . ( [ knot ] ) on strength of biquadratic exchange @xmath105 . inset shows the two angles @xmath108 , @xmath109 which characterise this special configuration independent on @xmath2 . , width=321 ] spin - flip fields for antiferromagnetic multilayers ( zero anisotropy @xmath84 ) in dependence on number of layers @xmath2 . , width=321 ] near the spin - flip transition from the sf - phase to the ferromagnetic states , the deviations of @xmath25 from the field directions are small ( @xmath110 ) , and the energy of the system ( [ energy1 ] ) can be expressed by the quadratic form @xmath111 , where the matrix @xmath112 has a tridiagonal band structure with nonzero elements only in the main diagonal @xmath113 and with the side diagonal elements @xmath114 . the spin - flip field @xmath115 is determined as the largest root of the equation @xmath116 . in particular for the model with equal parameters these solutions are plotted in fig . the spin - flip field gradually increases from @xmath117 for the two - layer to the `` bulk '' value @xmath118 in the limit of infinite @xmath2 ( fig . this dependence reflects the increase of the average number of exchange bonds from the value 1 for the two - layer and approaching 2 as @xmath2 tends to infinity . effects of the four - fold magnetic anisotropy on the states in the antiferromagnetic superlattices are revealed in detail by applying fields in arbitrary directions . we approach the general case by a detailed investigation on the case of the two - layer . to set the stage , we discuss the highly symmetric phase - diagrams with fields in direction of easy and hard - axes in the plane . this completes earlier work by dieny et al . @xcite on the @xmath2=2 systems . then , we present phase diagrams for arbitrary field directions in the layer plane . as we have seen in the last section , the primary effect of biquadratic exchange is a distortion of phase diagrams in various regions . thus , here we consider only models with @xmath119 to avoid such quantitative effects which will not affect the general topological features of the phase diagrams . optimization of the function @xmath120 eq . ( [ energy2 ] ) yields solutions for the magnetic states and their stability limits . in zero field the tetragonal anisotropy lifts the rotational degeneracy of the af phase and stabilizes two different states with perpendicular orientations of @xmath28 ( fig . 7 ( a ) ) . magnetic configurations in planar antiferromagnetically coupled two - layers with four - fold anisotropy . easy directions are indicated by thin continuous lines , hard directions by dashed lines . in zero field two antiferromagnetic configurations ( i ) ( a ) and ( ii ) ( b ) with the staggered vectors along the easy directions correspond to the ground - state . a magnetic field along the hard directions distorts them into the canted phases ( c ) , ( d ) which transform into the spin - flop state ( e ) . corresponding configurations of net magnetization and staggered vectors are shown for the two canted phases ( c ) ( d ) , and for the spin - flop phase ( e ) . , width=287 ] magnetic phase diagram of the two - layer system in magnetic fields along _ hard _ directions . the tricritical point ( @xmath121 , @xmath122 ) separates the continuous ( dotted line ) and discontinuous ( thick line ) transitions between the canted and sf phases . a further dotted line gives the critical field of the second - order transition between the sf and flip phases @xmath123 ( [ tran2 ] ) . thin lines give the lower stability limit @xmath124 of the sf phases and the upper limit @xmath125 of the canted phases . the grey area is the region of the phase equilibrium between the two canted phases ( see fig . [ tetragonconfigs ] ( c),(c ) and ( d),(d ) ) . magnetization curves for low and high anisotropy , as indicated in the main panel , are plotted in ( a ) and ( b ) . , width=287 ] in a field applied along one of the hard axes , the af configurations of the ground - state ( fig . 7(a),(b ) ) are distorted into low symmetry configurations ( so called _ canted _ phases - fig . 7(c),(d ) ) . both these magnetic configurations preserve mirror symmetry with respect to the field direction and have the same energy . the total magnetizations * m * of these canted states deviate from the field directions to different sides at equal angles ( fig . 7(c),(d ) ) . an oblique magnetic field deviating from the hard direction to one or the other side violates the phase balance between these two canted states . it favours the canted phase with the larger projection of * m * onto the field direction . this is the typical situation of a first - order ( or discontinuous ) transition . in an increasing field the vectors * m * in both canted phases rotate into the field direction and reach it at a certain critical field @xmath126 . at this point both phases transform into the common configuration corresponding to the sf phase ( fig . 7(d ) ) , i.e. a second - order ( or continuous ) phase transition from low symmetry canted phases into the high - symmetry sf - phase occurs in this field . standard analysis yields the following expression for the parameters of the critical point @xmath127 where @xmath128 determines the equilibrium sf configuration at the critical field . the two canted phases are competing phases related by a first - order transition . at the field @xmath124 the discontinuity between these phases disappears , i.e. this is a _ critical end - point _ of the first - order transition . after the transition into the sf phase , the system further evolves by rotation of the magnetizations @xmath25 into the direction of the field . this process is terminated at another critical field @xmath129 ( fig . the transition between the canted and sf phases is continuous only below a certain anisotropy strength , @xmath130 , and becomes discontinuous at higher anisotropy . the parameters of the corresponding tricritical point @xmath121 , @xmath122 have been calculated numerically from the equation @xmath131 together with eqs . ( [ tran2 ] ) . numerically calculated transition fields @xmath132 and the upper stability fields of the canted phases @xmath125 are plotted in fig . 8 . in this picture the grey area describes the region of the first - order transition , respectively the region of phase - coexistence between the canted phases . a magnetic field applied in one of the easy directions violates the energy balance between the two af states . the state af(i ) with staggered vector parallel to the field does not change its configuration and exists as a metastable collinear state up to the critical field @xmath133 . the phase af(ii ) with the staggered vector perpendicular to the magnetic field transforms into a sf phase which corresponds to the global energy minimum of the system . in an increasing magnetic field this phase evolves similarly to the sf phase along the hard directions , and continuously transforms into the flip states at the critical fields @xmath134 for low anisotropy . the transition between the sf and flip phases changes the order in another tricritical point ( @xmath135 ) . at a critical field @xmath136 ( [ stab1 ] ) the sf phase becomes unstable with respect to flipping distortions , i.e. modes that redirect the magnetization vectors into the field direction but preserve the symmetry of the sf phase . the parameters of the tricritical point ( @xmath137 ) . and the stability limits @xmath138 have been calculated in @xcite . after some algebra the first - order transition field @xmath139 also can be derived in analytical form @xmath140\ , , \label{tran1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] at the transitional field we have @xmath141 . magnetic phase diagram of the two - layer system in magnetic fields along _ easy _ directions . the tricritical point ( @xmath142 , @xmath143 ) separates the continuous @xmath134 ( [ stab1 ] ) ( dashed line ) and discontinuous @xmath134 ( [ tran1])(thick line ) transitions between sf and flip phases . the tricritical point ( @xmath144 , @xmath145 ) separates the continuous @xmath134 ( [ stab1 ] ) ( dashed line ) and discontinuous @xmath134 ( [ tran1])(thick line ) transitions between sf and flip phases . thin lines indicate the lability lines of the individual phases ( [ stab1 ] ) . the grey area designates the stability region of the canted phases . for the anisotropy @xmath146 = 0.47596 ( point @xmath147 ) , the critical field of the sf phase switches from an instability against symmetric `` flipping '' at the line @xmath136 to an instability against canting at @xmath148 given by the two branches @xmath149 from eq . ( [ stabsf2 ] ) . ( inset in main figure shows the details of this process ; see text following eq . ( [ stabsf2 ] ) for further explanation . ) small panels ( a ) and ( b ) show magnetization curves for low and high anisotropies as indicated in the main figure . full thick lines are for the evolution of the equilibrium ground - states , in ( a ) from sf phase to a continuous spin - flip transition into saturation . dotted lines are the evolution starting from the metastable af - phase . in ( b ) the evolution of the saturated state in decreasing fields is given by a thin line . the inner small hysteresis loop shows the transitions from and into the metastable canted phase . , width=287 ] the ( k , h)-phase diagram for this cases is plotted in fig . 9 . with increasing strength of the anisotropy , the `` landscape '' described by the energy function @xmath120 acquires additional folds . in particular , metastable canted phases arise in a certain region of the magnetic fields along the easy directions . ( this region is indicated by grey colour in fig . [ kheasy ] ) . for @xmath150 with @xmath151 = 0.28 + 0.08@xmath152 = 0.47596 the sf phase undergoes an instability with respect to a transition into the canted phases . this instability occurs at lability fields which are given by the two branches of the following parametric equation @xmath153 where @xmath154 is given by the the configuration in the sf - state , @xmath155 . both branches of the lability field ( [ stabsf2 ] ) start at the point @xmath156 ( point @xmath147 in fig . [ kheasy ] ) ; @xmath157 meets the lability line @xmath136 of eq . ( [ stab1 ] ) at the `` beak '' ( @xmath158 ) ( point @xmath159 in fig . [ kheasy ] ) . the transition between the metastable sf phase and the metastable canted phases along @xmath160 is continuous between the points @xmath159 and a further tricritical point @xmath161 . for stronger anisotropy the transition between these metastable phases is discontinuous at a first - order transition field @xmath162 . this transition line along with the stability limits of the canted phases have been numerically determined as given in fig . [ kheasy ] . note that such processes between metastable phases may be realized only in systems with high coercivity where the transition into the thermodynamically stable flip phase is suppressed at the field @xmath139 ( [ tran1 ] ) . now we consider the magnetic states in applied fields deviating from the symmetric directions and construct ( @xmath163)-phase diagrams for different values of the parameter @xmath164 . for the ( @xmath163)-diagrams in figs . [ hxhyweak ] to 14 it is assumed that the easy directions coincide with the @xmath3- and @xmath4-axis . ( a ) schematic ( @xmath163)-phase diagram of the two - layer for @xmath165 . the astroid ( continuous line ) gives the stability limit of the canted metastable phases . thick lines in diagonal directions ( hard axis ) are first order transitions between canted phases . the line for the ( continuous ) transition into the saturated spin - flip state is given by the dotted line . note that the real size of the astroid in the ( @xmath163)-diagram is much smaller than shown here . ( b ) evolution of spin - flip field , respectively lower stability limits of the saturated ( ferromagnetic ) phase ( fm ) . phase fm is stable outside the closed curves for the various values of anisotropy @xmath166 . for @xmath167 the fm - phases are ( meta)stable even in reverse fields and the existence regions overlap for states saturated in different easy directions . , title="fig:",width=287 ] ( a ) schematic ( @xmath163)-phase diagram of the two - layer for @xmath165 . the astroid ( continuous line ) gives the stability limit of the canted metastable phases . thick lines in diagonal directions ( hard axis ) are first order transitions between canted phases . the line for the ( continuous ) transition into the saturated spin - flip state is given by the dotted line . note that the real size of the astroid in the ( @xmath163)-diagram is much smaller than shown here . ( b ) evolution of spin - flip field , respectively lower stability limits of the saturated ( ferromagnetic ) phase ( fm ) . phase fm is stable outside the closed curves for the various values of anisotropy @xmath166 . for @xmath167 the fm - phases are ( meta)stable even in reverse fields and the existence regions overlap for states saturated in different easy directions . , title="fig:",width=287 ] this corresponds @xmath168 in the energy eq . ( [ energy2 ] ) . diagrams for @xmath169 can be obtained by rotation of those for @xmath168 through an angle @xmath170 . in the limit of weak anisotropy , @xmath171 , independent minimization with respect to the angle @xmath172 yields @xmath173 and the energy ( [ energy2 ] ) is simplified to the following form @xmath174 \ , . \label{energy3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the set of equations for the stability limits of solutions , @xmath175 and @xmath176 , yield two closed lines of critical fields in the ( @xmath177)-phase diagram ( fig . [ hxhyweak ] ) . one of them @xmath178 describes the second - order transition into the flip phase with @xmath179 . the other closed curve can be written in a parametric form @xmath180 where @xmath181 , @xmath182 . it describes an astroid with eight - cusps that confines the region of the canted metastable states ( fig . [ hxhyweak](a ) ) . first quadrant of the ( @xmath163)-phase diagram for antiferromagnetic two - layers with ( a ) @xmath183 ( b ) @xmath184 . easy axes of magnetic anisotropy are along the axes of the diagrams . inset in ( a ) magnifies the region of the `` swallow tail '' for the discontinuous transitions in magnetic fields oriented close to the hard axes . thick lines are lines of first - order transitions . the dotted lines @xmath185 @xmath186 are continuous spin - flips from spin - flop phase to the saturated ( spin - flip ) state . thinner lines are the limits of stability , defining the coexistence regions for the corresponding phases . , title="fig:",width=287 ] first quadrant of the ( @xmath163)-phase diagram for antiferromagnetic two - layers with ( a ) @xmath183 ( b ) @xmath184 . easy axes of magnetic anisotropy are along the axes of the diagrams . inset in ( a ) magnifies the region of the `` swallow tail '' for the discontinuous transitions in magnetic fields oriented close to the hard axes . thick lines are lines of first - order transitions . the dotted lines @xmath185 @xmath186 are continuous spin - flips from spin - flop phase to the saturated ( spin - flip ) state . thinner lines are the limits of stability , defining the coexistence regions for the corresponding phases . , title="fig:",width=287 ] the cusps along the easy directions coincide with the stability field of the af phase @xmath133 eq . ( [ stab1 ] ) , and those along the hard directions with @xmath187 eq . ( [ tran2 ] ) . thick black lines within the astroid and along the hard directions indicate the first - order transitions between the canted phases from fig . [ tetragonconfigs ] . this topology of the ( @xmath163)-phase diagram fig . [ hxhyweak](a ) is preserved up to the first tricritical point @xmath188 . for @xmath189 a first - order transition between sf phase and two canted phases arises along the hard directions ( point @xmath190 in fig . [ hxhyo3](a ) ) . for stronger anisotropies , @xmath191 , discontinuous phase transitions exist also for finite deviations of the field direction from the hard axes . the corresponding line of these first - order transitions have critical end - points , where the difference between the competing phases disappears ( analogously to the end - point of a coexistence - line in gas - liquid phase diagrams ) . for @xmath192 and for fields along the easy directions , the spin - flip into the saturated ( induced ) ferromagnetic state occurs discontinuously . thus , another line of first - order transitions develops for @xmath193 also in oblique fields . correspondingly , the transition lines for spin - flips in ( @xmath163)-phase diagrams consist of continuous and discontinuous sections joined by the tricritical points @xmath185 , @xmath186 . the calculated ( @xmath163)-phase diagrams for @xmath194 in fig . [ hxhyo3 ] ( a ) and for @xmath195 in fig . [ hxhyo3 ] ( b ) represent the main topological features of these phase diagrams . point ` @xmath190 ' indicates the field of phase equilibrium between the sf phase and two canted phases and corresponds to the critical field @xmath132 from fig . 8 ; points @xmath196 , @xmath197 are the end - points of the first - order transitions between one of the canted phases and the sf phase . points @xmath198 @xmath199 correspond to the transition field @xmath139 from fig . 9 ; points @xmath185 , @xmath186 are the tricritical points , where the discontinuous transition between the flip phase and the distorted sf phase ends . the lability lines in the vicinity of the transition field @xmath132 have the shape of a `` swallow tail '' . similar phase diagrams arise in uniaxial ferromagnets with strong fourth - order anisotropy.@xcite as the anisotropy constant increases in the region @xmath193 the lines of the first - order transitions extend and near the special value @xmath200=@xmath201 the points @xmath196 , @xmath197 reach the easy directions . for larger @xmath202 canted phases exist as metastable state also for fields in easy directions ( compare fig . however , for increasing fields close to this direction , the discontinuous transition from the spin - flop state into the spin - flip state occurs before the transition into such a canted phase can take place , i.e. the two first - order lines @xmath190 @xmath196 and @xmath185 @xmath198 cross each other close to the easy axis directions in fig . brhl et al . @xcite reported evidence of an intermediate canted state in a co / cu / co / cu(001 ) system with field in an easy direction , following the theoretical prediction of such states by dieny et al . @xcite however , the state was found at lower fields than expected . this may be due to a misorientation of the external field and/or a mosaic of the epitaxial layer system because then the canted state becomes stable already at lower fields , as can be seen from line @xmath190 @xmath196 in phase diagram fig . generally , it is not sufficient to investigate only magnetization behaviour in hard and easy axes directions for a thorough understanding of the magnetization phases in these multilayer systems . to understand the transformation of ( @xmath163)-diagrams with increasing tetragonal anisotropy the limiting case is useful where @xmath25 are strictly oriented along the easy axes . in this case with _ infinite _ anisotropy , i.e. @xmath203 , our model can be considered as a chain of an antiferromagnetic four - state clock - model or planar potts - model@xcite in a transverse external field . recently , such four - state - clock models were employed to analyse the spin configurations of bulk tetragonal metamagnets with large four - fold anisotropies , such as rare - earth nickel - borocarbides @xcite or rare - earth silver - antimonides.@xcite rich experimental ( @xmath163)-phase diagrams have been obtained and analysed in terms of four - state - clock models , e.g. for honi@xmath204b@xmath204c @xcite or dyagsb@xmath204.@xcite the values of the angles @xmath205 0 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 , or @xmath208 in these four - fold states for @xmath209 are symbolically given by @xmath210 , @xmath211 , @xmath212 , and @xmath213 , e.g. the af and sf phases are ( @xmath210@xmath212 ) and ( @xmath213@xmath211 ) for @xmath0 . in addition to the collinear af and flip states there are phases with perpendicular orientation of the magnetization , or `` 90 degree - folded '' phases ( fig . [ hxhyinfinite ] ) . the states created by all combinations of these four angles @xmath24 for the magnetization in the multilayer stack exist as metastable states in arbitrary magnetic fields because the energy wells corresponding to these solutions are separated by infinitely high potential barriers . the regions of the absolute stability of these phases are separated by first - order transitions lines shown in fig . [ hxhyinfinite ] . in the first quadrant the transition between the af states and the canted phase ( @xmath214 ) occurs at the line @xmath215 ; the transitions lines from the canted phase ( @xmath214 ) into the flip states ( @xmath216 ) and ( @xmath217 ) are @xmath218 and @xmath219 , correspondingly ( fig . 12 ) . in the points ( 1,0 ) and ( 0,1 ) four phases coexist . thus , under increasing strength of the anisotropy ( @xmath220 ) the ( @xmath163)-phase diagram evolves from that plotted in fig . [ hxhyweak](a ) for @xmath221 to that in fig . [ hxhyinfinite ] for infinitely large values of @xmath222 . ( @xmath163)-phase diagram of the @xmath0-layer system in the limit of an infinite positive four - fold anisotropy . , width=321 ] the equilibrium magnetic configurations in two - layer systems arise as a results of the competition between the interlayer exchange coupling and tetragonal anisotropy . for multilayers the disbalance of the exchange forces at the boundaries ( sec . ii ) additionally influences the magnetic states . we first describe the structure of the one - dimensional solutions for laterally homogeneous states in finite antiferromagnetic superlattices . these magnetic states are determined by the interplay between cut exchange at the surfaces and the four - fold anisotropy . then we discuss some consequences for multidomain states and magnetization processes , and we discuss the physical nature of other effects which may play a role for the magnetic behaviour of real experimental systems . first , we investigate the ( @xmath163)-diagrams of magnetic states of multilayers with @xmath1 in the limit of infinite four - fold anisotropy . ( @xmath163)-phase diagram of the multilayer in the limit of infinite positive four - fold anisotropy . the phase - region of the l@xmath223x@xmath223-phases coincides with that of the collinear ferrimagnetic f@xmath223 , not shown here . ( for details see text . ) , width=287 ] the zero - field ground - states are the af phases @xmath224 and @xmath225 we may restrict the field to be oriented in directions @xmath34 in the interval @xmath2260,@xmath207/4@xmath227 $ ] . the configurations for other values of @xmath34 follow from symmetry . then , we may distinguish the four ground - state ( zero - field ) domains ( af1)@xmath228= @xmath229 , ( af2)@xmath228= @xmath230 , ( sf1)@xmath228= @xmath231 , and ( sf2)@xmath228= @xmath232 , where @xmath233 signifies the number of repetitions of the pair in a domain . in external fields @xmath234 configurations with net magnetization will be stabilized . these configurations must have pairs of adjacent moments flipped by 90 degree l=@xmath235 or x=@xmath236 , and by 180 degree f=@xmath237 . the 90-degree - folded configuration `` x '' is less favourable than `` l '' for field orientations in the chosen range , except for fields in easy - axis direction @xmath238 . thus , the magnetized configurations with lowest magnetization and smallest expense of exchange energy are those with only one pair of type `` l '' . in a short - hand , we write l@xmath223 for these configurations of type ( af1)@xmath239l@xmath240(sf2)@xmath241 ( with @xmath242 . ) next , we may form configurations with higher magnetization and smallest expense of exchange energy using one `` l '' and one `` x''-pair : l@xmath223x@xmath223= ( af1)@xmath239l@xmath240(sf2)@xmath243x@xmath240(af1)@xmath244 , ( @xmath245 ) . these configurations have the same energy and , therefore , are degenerate with configurations containing only one `` f''-pair : f@xmath223=(af1)@xmath239f@xmath240(af2)@xmath241 . note that these states are highly degenerate because the `` l''- , `` x''-pair , or `` f''-pair may be placed at arbitrary positions in the stack of @xmath2 layers . in higher fields configurations with various combinations of `` l''- , `` x''- , and `` f''-pairs may be stabilized by an external field . however , the structures with lowest energy , i.e. the absolutely stable states , are rather simple because of the following considerations . if , in external fields , more than one `` l''-pair can be formed starting from the l@xmath223 structure , the formation of the maximum number of l - pairs gives the most favourable configuration . in particular , the structure l@xmath246=(@xmath214)@xmath246 is the lowest energy structure for fields pointing in hard axis - directions @xmath247 in the limit of infinite h. the state with higher magnetization than l@xmath246 for fields pointing closer to the easy axis direction , @xmath248 , and with the smallest expense of exchange energy is in our notation l@xmath249f . the saturated state fm@xmath250f@xmath246 is the most favourable state which is reached whenever energy can be gained in external fields by flipping more moments into position @xmath210 in the states l@xmath249f , f@xmath223 , or l@xmath223x@xmath223 . thus , for general @xmath2 we have only the following phases for infinite positive four - fold anisotropy : af or sf as zero - field ground - states ; for fields with orientation close to the hard direction @xmath247 l@xmath223 and l@xmath246 ; otherwise in intermediate fields two degenerate phases f@xmath223 and l@xmath223x@xmath223 ; at high fields an asymmetric l@xmath249f - phase and the fully saturated ferromagnetic phase fm . we did numerical checks to ascertain that no further energetically stable phases do exist in external fields of arbitrary strength and direction , indeed . thus , we searched for the states of lowest energy by sampling all possible configurations for models with @xmath2=4 , @xmath251 , 12 corroborating our arguments . based on this set of magnetic configurations the resulting ( @xmath163)-phase diagram for general @xmath252 can be calculated analytically ( fig . [ hxhyinfinite2 ] ) . as in the simpler case of fig . [ hxhyinfinite ] for the two - layer system all these states are separated by infinitely high potential barriers and remain metastable for arbitrary fields . the first - order transitions between different phases occur along straight lines as shown in fig . [ hxhyinfinite2 ] . for finite strength of the four - fold anisotropy and under the influence of the exchange interactions , the basic structures are derived from the phases in fig . [ hxhyinfinite2 ] . under the influence of the field , they are elastically distorted into spatially _ inhomogeneous _ configurations . we have numerically investigated models for such cases with @xmath253 and various values of anisotropy @xmath222 . [ mvshn8 ] displays the general features for the example @xmath254 . the numerically calculated magnetization curves corresponding to the lowest energy states for sufficiently high anisotropies show the sequence of phases present in the infinite - anisotropy phase diagram fig . [ hxhyinfinite2 ] . however , the degeneracy of these phases is lifted because the distortions possible at finite anisotropy yield different gains of energy for the different configurations of the phases l@xmath223 , f@xmath223 , and l@xmath223x@xmath223 . generally , depending on field - orientation , large domains with nearly spin - flop - like configurations @xmath50 are favoured because these configurations can be more easily distorted by the fields yielding a corresponding gain of energy . in particular , phases derived from the ferrimagnetic collinear f@xmath223-phase are disfavoured compared to the l@xmath223x@xmath223-type phases . the nearly collinear ferrimagnetic configurations seem to exist only as metastable states . for fields closer to the hard - axis direction the phases with either one l - pair or @xmath255 l - pairs occur . under the influence of an applied field further discontinuous transitions occur at intermediate anisotropies , as seen e.g. in fig . [ mvshn8 ] ( a ) for @xmath256 . these transitions are jumps from one energy basin to another which are formed by distorting degenerate configurations mainly of the type l@xmath223 and l@xmath223x@xmath223 . examples of magnetization in an antiferromagnetic multilayer with @xmath254 . curves corresponding to the evolution of lowest energy states and for various values of anisotropy are shown with field oriented in directions of an easy axis ( a ) , in an oblique field ( b ) and in hard - axis direction ( c ) . @xmath34 is angle between magnetic field and easy axis direction . in each case , various magnetic configurations are shown for the discontinuous evolution of the magnetization curves with highest anisotropy . , title="fig:",width=287 ] examples of magnetization in an antiferromagnetic multilayer with @xmath254 . curves corresponding to the evolution of lowest energy states and for various values of anisotropy are shown with field oriented in directions of an easy axis ( a ) , in an oblique field ( b ) and in hard - axis direction ( c ) . @xmath34 is angle between magnetic field and easy axis direction . in each case , various magnetic configurations are shown for the discontinuous evolution of the magnetization curves with highest anisotropy . , title="fig:",width=287 ] examples of magnetization in an antiferromagnetic multilayer with @xmath254 . curves corresponding to the evolution of lowest energy states and for various values of anisotropy are shown with field oriented in directions of an easy axis ( a ) , in an oblique field ( b ) and in hard - axis direction ( c ) . @xmath34 is angle between magnetic field and easy axis direction . in each case , various magnetic configurations are shown for the discontinuous evolution of the magnetization curves with highest anisotropy . , title="fig:",width=287 ] at low anisotropies the phase diagram attains the behaviour discussed for zero anisotropies in section iii . here the magnetic states are only influenced by the cuts of exchange bonds at the surfaces and spatially inhomogeneous spin - flop states slightly distorted by four - fold anisotropy are realized ( see figs . ( @xmath163)-diagrams for this isotropic case consist of the region of the inhomogeneous sf phase ( fig . 2 , 3 ) separated from the saturated flip state by the critical line @xmath115 ( fig . these global features of the phase - diagrams are similar to the case of antiferromagnetic multilayers with uniaxial anisotropy.@xcite up to now we have discussed the effects of the competition between the bilinear exchange and four - fold anisotropy . it is clear that finite _ biquadratic coupling _ may substantially change the critical fields and stability regions of the various phases as it affects the elastic stiffness of the system . we note further , that the simple structure of the phase - diagram ruled by the phases present in the infinite anisotropy limit of fig . [ hxhyinfinite2 ] is valid only for the case of equal exchange constants @xmath257 in the multilayer stack . for arbitrary sets of values for @xmath14 in energy ( [ energy1 ] ) the phase diagrams may become considerably more complex and may contain further phases with different combinations of flipped 90 and 180 degree spin - pairs . even in such cases , the outline of the magnetic phase - diagrams , described here for finite equal - constant superlattices , should generally hold : ( i ) the high anisotropy limit is comparably simple with few phases determined by the competing lowest - energy basins of the anisotropy . non - equal constants may lift some degeneracies that are present in superlattices . ( ii ) in intermediate anisotropy range many elastically distorted phases appear , which are derived from stable and metastable high - anisotropy phases . ( iii ) for vanishing anisotropy the phase - diagrams become simple again as only inhomogeneous spin - flop - like phases and the saturated ferromagnetic phase remain in external fields . so far , we have analyzed single domain magnetic configurations . magnetization processes in real systems , however , are usually accompanied by complex reconstruction of the multidomain patterns as those recently observed in fe / cr multilayers.@xcite there are two main physical mechanism for multidomain states in the systems under discussion . four - fold degeneracy of the ground - state leads to creation of _ antiferromagnetic multidomain structures _ with 90 degree domain walls . unlike the case of magnetic materials with nonzero total magnetization , where multidomain states are caused by demagnetization effects , in antiferromagnets such domains are _ metastable _ and arise during the formation of the ordering state , i.e. they have a kinetic origin.@xcite hence , multidomain patterns observed in antiferromagnetic coupled two - layers and multilayers have irregular morphologies and depend on thermal and magnetic - field histories.@xcite however , another type of multidomain structures arises in the vicinity of field - induced discontinuous transitions.@xcite such thermodynamically stable _ transitional domain structures _ are formed by domains from states corresponding to the coexisting phases at first - order transitions . these domains are analogous to the domains of a demagnetized ferromagnet . in principle , the equilibrium parameters of such multidomain structures and their boundaries can be calculated by standard methods.@xcite in @xcite such calculations have been carried out for bulk easy - plane tetragonal antiferromagnets . _ magnetoelastic interactions _ lead to modification of the inhomogeneous states and decrease the regions of the multidomain states up to their complete suppression.@xcite this and other coercivity mechanism partly block the development of the equilibrium states . as a result , in real systems the evolution of multidomain states @xcite is accompanied by rather strong hystereses.@xcite for experiments , there are two important consequences related to the starting states and history dependence of magnetization processes . the `` texture '' of a real antiferromagnetic state in zero - field depends on the detailed kinetics imposed by e.g. cooling rates or deposition conditions . on the other hand , field cycling by inner loops for an antiferromagnetic multilayer may yield various metastable configurations and multidomain structures owing to the very wide coexistence region of the domains whenever sizable magnetic anisotropies are present in the multilayer stack within a phenomenological approach we develop the theory of reorientation transition in antiferromagnetically coupled superlattices with in - plane magnetization . detailed investigations of the surface effects in the isotropic multilayers ( sec . iii ) and four - fold anisotropy effects in two - layer systems ( sec . iv ) reveal the most important features of the system : ( i ) complex evolution of the inhomogeneous states ( figs . 2 - 4 ) is imposed by the strong disbalance of the exchange coupling , i.e. by the _ cut of the exchange bonds_. ( ii ) remarkable field - induced reorientational processes occur due to enhanced four - fold anisotropy ( figs . 8 to [ mvshn8 ] ) . the model used here , corresponding solutions and phase - diagrams include as special cases earlier theoretical studies on surface @xcite and four - fold anisotropy @xcite effects . the results are in essential accordance with existing experimental observations on inhomogeneous distribution in the spin - flop phase near the saturation field @xcite , and some effects of four - fold anisotropy in co / cu(001 ) wedged two - layers @xcite and fe / cr superlattices.@xcite our approach and results enable a _ qualitative _ analysis of the magnetization processes in the multilayered systems ( sec . v ) . in spite of the rather complex phase - diagrams of these systems , the analysis can be extended towards a quantitative description of real systems belonging to the class of artificial layered antiferromagnets described by eq . ( [ energy1 ] ) . so far most experimental work is carried out only for special conditions , often data are collected only with fields along easy - axes . these results only cover small regions of the ( @xmath258,@xmath259)-phase diagrams ( figs . [ hxhyweak ] to [ hxhyinfinite2 ] ) and do not capture the rich varieties of magnetizations processes in such systems . it is remarkable that many interesting effects , such as 90-degree folded phases , transitions into asymmetric canted phases etc . , are present already in antiferromagnetically coupled two - layers.@xcite as we have seen , phase diagrams for multilayer systems with @xmath260 become very complex . hence , systems with few layers are probably a better starting point for detailed investigations on magnetization processes . such experiments could be used to assess magnetic parameters and quality of such systems . generally , magnetization processes and checks for their dependence on magnetic and thermal pre - history should be made by applying fields in oblique directions and/or under rotating fields . only then , the behaviour of the ( @xmath258,@xmath259)-phase diagrams can be usefully compared with detailed theoretical investigations . further theoretical work may address models with non - equal constants . also effectively ferrimagnetic systems with odd numbers @xmath2 of layers and with different layer thicknesses may be interesting . some experimental data for magnetization processes in such systems exist , e.g. for co / cr two - layers with different ferromagnetic layers thicknesses,@xcite and for odd - numbered multilayers.@xcite interesting reorientational effects should arise also in magnetic fields , which are applied perpendicular or under arbitrary angle to the layer plane . antiferromagnetically coupled superlattices may also undergo transitions into perpendicularly magnetized states for certain thicknesses of the individual ferromagnetic layers , as observed for co / cr(001).@xcite in such cases the stray field must be taken into account already for laterally homogeneous states . concluding we state that the magnetic effects and phenomena discussed in this paper can be used for detailed investigations on such aspects of nanomagnetism as interlayer - exchange interactions , reorientational , and multidomain processes . g. j. strijkers , s. m. zhou , f. y. yang , and c. l. chien , phys . b * 62 * , 13896 ( 2000 ) ; k. y. kim , s. h. jang , k. h. shin , h. j. kim , and t. kang , j. appl . phys . * 89 * , 7612 ( 2001 ) ; a. moser _ et al . _ , j. phys . d * 35 * , r157 ( 2002 ) . m. a. howson _ et al . _ , b * 49 * , 9560 ( 1994 ) . r. w. wang , d. l. mills , e. e. fullerton , j. e. mattson , and s. d. bader , phys . lett . * 72 * , 920 ( 1994 ) ; s. g. e. te velthuis , j. s. jiang , s. d. bader , and g.p . felcher , phys . lett . * 89 * , 127203 ( 2002 ) . p. steadman _ et al . _ , lett . * 89 * , 077201 ( 2002 ) ; s. g. e. te velthuis , j. s. jiang , g. p. felcher , appl . . lett . * 77 * , 2222 ( 2000 ) . o. hellwig , t. l. kirk , j. b. kortright , a. berger , and e. e. fullerton , nature materials * 2 * , 112 ( 2003 ) . k. ounadjela _ _ , phys . b * 45 * , 7768 ( 1992 ) ; s. hamada , k. himi , t. okuno , and k. takanashi , j. magn . magn . * 240 * , 539 ( 2002 ) . h. itoh , h. yanagihara , k. suzuki , and e. kita , j. magn . mater . * 257 * , 184 ( 2003 ) . a. n. bogdanov and u. k. rler , phys . b * 68 * , 012407 ( 2003 ) ; u. k. rler and a. n. bogdanov , cond - mat/0307494 ( unpublished ) . k. brhl , s. di nunzio , f. schreiber , th . zeidler , and h. zabel , j. appl . * 75 * , 6184 ( 1994 ) ; k. brhl , th . zeidler , f. schreiber , a. schreyer , and h. zabel , j. magn . mater . * 130 * , l1 ( 1994 ) . a. van der graaf , m. valkier , j. kohlhepp , and f. j. a. den broeder , j. magn . * 165 * , 157 ( 1997 ) . r. w. e. van de kruijs _ et al . _ , phys . b * 65 * , 064440 ( 2002 ) . t. zeidler , f. schreiber , and h. zabel , j. appl . phys . * 79 * , 4793 ( 1996 ) . j. j. picconatto , m. j. pechan , and e. e. fullerton , j. appl . phys . * 81 * , 5058 ( 1997 ) . j. z. hilt , j. j. picconatto , a. obrien , m. j. pechan , and e. e. fullerton , j. magn . magn . mater . * 198 * -*1999 * , 387 ( 1999 ) . v. v. ustinov , m. a. milyaev , l. n. romashev , t. p. krinitsina , e. a. kravtsov , j. magn . * 226 * -*230 * , 1811 ( 2001 ) . c. chesman _ _ , phys . rev . b * 58 * , 101 ( 1998 ) . v. lauter - pasyuk , h. j. lauter , b. p. toperverg , l. romashev , and v. ustinov , phys . 89 * , 167203 ( 2002 ) ; v. lauter - pasyuk _ et al . _ , j. magn . magn . mater . * 258 * -*259 * , 382 ( 2003 ) . k. temst , physica b * 276 - 278 * , 684 ( 2000 ) . d. l. nagy _ et al . _ , lett . * 88 * , 157202 ( 2002 ) ; l. bottan _ et al . _ , j. magn . mater . * 240 * , 514 ( 2002 ) . h. lauter _ et al . _ , j. magn . * 258 * -*259 * , 338 ( 2003 ) . s. o. demokritov , j. phys . d : appl . * 31 * , 925 ( 1998 ) . b. dieny , j. p. gavigan , and j. p. rebouillat , j. phys . : condens . matter * 2 * , 159 ( 1990 ) ; b. dieny and j. p. gavigan , j. phys . : condens . matter * 2 * , 187 ( 1990 ) . f. c. nrtemann , r. l. stamps , a. s. carrio , and r. e. camley , phys . b * 46 * , 10847 ( 1992 ) ; a. l. dantas and a. s. carrio , phys . rev . b * 59 * , 1223 ( 1999 ) . a. hubert , r. schfer , _ magnetic domains _ ( springer - verlag , berlin , 1998 ) . d. l. mills , j. magn . mater . * 198 * -*199 * , 334 ( 1999 ) . p. grnberg , r. schreiber , y. pang , m. b. brodsky , and h. sowers , phys . lett . * 57 * , 2442 ( 1986 ) ; s. s. p. parkin , n. more , and k. p. roche , phys . rev . lett . * 64 * , 2304 ( 1990 ) . m. d. stiles , j. magn . mater . * 200 * , 322(1999 ) . v. g. baryakhtar , a. n. bogdanov , and d. a. yablonskii , usp . * 156 * , 47 ( 1988 ) [ sov . usp . * 31 * , 810 ( 1988 ) ] . l. d. landau , e. m. lifshitz , _ statistical physics _ part i. course of theoretical physics ; v. 5 ( butterworth - heinemann , oxford 1980 ) . f. y. wu , rev . mod . phys . * 54 * , 235 ( 1982 ) . mller and v. n. narozhnyi , rep . phys . * 64 * , 943 ( 2001 ) ; p. c. canfield and s. l. budko , j. alloys compd . * 262 * , 169 ( 1997 ) ; g. andr _ et al . _ , physica b * 292 * , 176 ( 2000 ) . p. c. canfield _ et al . _ , b * 55 * , 970 ( 1997 ) ; v. a. kalatsky and v. l. pokrovsky , phys . b * 57 * , 5485 ( 1998 ) . k. d. myers , p. c. canfield , v. a. kalatsky , and v. l. pokrovsky , phys . b * 59 * , 1121 ( 1999 ) . a. hubert , _ theorie der domnenwnde in geordneten medien _ ( springer , berlin , 1974 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: in view of various applications such as the study of two dimensional melting @xcite , investigations of mesoscale structure formation @xcite or engineering of colloidal crystals on spherical surfaces @xcite , the self assembly of sub-@xmath0 m colloidal particles at water air or water oil interfaces has gained much interest in recent years . these particles are trapped at the interface if the colloid is only partially wetted by both the water and the oil . this configuration is stable against thermal fluctuations and appears to be the global equilibrium state , as it is observed experimentally that the colloids immersed in the bulk phases are attracted to the interface @xcite ( see also sec . [ sec:1coll ] ) . the mutual interaction between the trapped colloids at distances close to contact , i.e. , within the range of molecular forces , is dominated by strong van der waals attraction . in order to avoid coagulation due to this attraction , the colloids can be stabilized sterically with polymers or with charges such that the colloids repel each other . variants of charge stabilization may include the coverage with ionizable molecules which dissociate in water , or the labeling of colloids with charged fluorescent markers . for charge stabilized colloids at large distances , the resulting repulsive force at water interfaces stems from a dipole dipole interaction as shown theoretically for point charges on surfaces @xcite and verified experimentally for polystyrene ( ps ) spheres on water oil interfaces @xcite . nonetheless , charged colloids at interfaces also show attractions far beyond the range of van der waals forces . the corresponding experimental evidence can be roughly classified as follows . ( i ) according to refs . @xcite , ps spheres ( radii @xmath1 @xmath0 m ) on flat water air interfaces using highly deionized water exhibit spontaneous formation of complicated metastable mesostructures . they are consistent with the presence of an attractive , secondary minimum in the intercolloidal potential at distances @xmath2 with a depth of a few @xmath3 . the use of water slightly contaminated by ions seems to move the minimum further out and to reduce its depth @xcite . ( ii ) in ref . @xcite , pmma spheres with radius @xmath4 @xmath0 m were trapped at the interface of water droplets immersed in oil . here , the secondary minimum has been measured at a distance @xmath5 and is reported to be surprisingly steep . the tentative explanation of these findings given in ref . @xcite invokes an analogue of long ranged flotation or capillary forces which decay @xmath6 . this interpretation was criticized in ref . @xcite ( with which the authors of ref . @xcite agreed @xcite ) and in ref . @xcite which both concluded that possible capillary forces in this system are much shorter ranged , i.e. , @xmath7 , but the authors of these references disagree with respect to the sign of this shorter ranged force . in yet another twist of the story , after completion of our work we encountered the very recent ref . @xcite in which the authors claim that long ranged capillary forces @xmath6 caused by the colloidal charges persist for sub-@xmath0 m particles . this conclusion is based on measurements of the meniscus shape around single glass spheres with radii 200 300 @xmath0 m floating at water oil and water air interfaces . motivated by the experimental data summarized above and the still incomplete theoretical understanding , here we undertake a quite general analysis of capillary interactions between two spherical colloids trapped at fluid interfaces . we characterize the system by a general stress field which acts on the interface , e.g. , due to a discontinuous electrostatic field at the interface , and by forces on the colloid of gravitational and/or electrostatic origin . special attention will be given to the role of a restoring force fixing the interface , e.g. , due to gravity or interface pinning . in sec . [ sec:1coll ] we present a free energy model for a single colloid trapped at an interface in the limit of small stresses and forces . the general solution for the interface deformation will be used in sec . [ sec:2coll ] in order to determine the effective potential between two colloids within the superposition approximation . in view of the differing theoretical results in the literature , the derivation of the interface deformation and the resulting effective potential is presented in detail in order to reveal properly the subtleties involved . in sec . [ sec : discussion ] we apply the results to the case of charged polymeric spheres on water interfaces . it turns out that the constraint of approximate mechanical isolation of the experimental systems renders the capillary interaction basically short ranged . long ranged attractive forces @xmath6 only arise through a restoring force acting on the interface ( which is , however , weak ) or in the presence of an external electric field . we shall discuss the relation to previous theoretical results , especially in view of the experimental results reported in refs . directions for further research will be pointed out . in sec . [ sec : summary ] we summarize our results . in this section we consider as a first step the equilibrium state of a single colloid of radius @xmath8 at the interface between two fluid phases denoted as 1 and 2 . the contact angle formed by the interface and the colloid surface is given by young s law , @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the surface tension between phases 1 and 2 , and @xmath11 is the surface tension between the colloid and phase @xmath12 . as a reference state , with respect to which changes in free energy will be measured , we take a planar meniscus configuration with the colloid at such a height @xmath13 that young s law is satisfied ( fig . [ fig : ref ] ) . this corresponds to the equilibrium configuration of an uncharged colloid at the interface if its weight can be neglected which for generic cases is a safe approximation for @xmath14 @xmath0 m @xcite ( see also sec . [ sec : discussion ] ) . we model the colloid as a smooth sphere so that the system is invariant under rotations around the colloid axis perpendicular to the reference planar meniscus . the presence of charges induces a shift of the system ( colloid and interface ) with respect to the reference state . here we neglect corresponding changes in the surface tensions @xmath10 and @xmath11 ; this approximation is expected to be valid provided the concentration of charges is sufficiently small . this shift is characterized by the meniscus profile @xmath15 relative to the planar configuration and by the height @xmath16 of the colloid center . in the reference configuration , the charge distribution is assumed to be already in equilibrium . in the following we do not consider the degree of freedom `` charge density field '' explicitly but take it to be fixed to that of the reference configuration . this amounts to neglecting the feedback of the interface displacement on the charge distribution . it turns out to be useful to introduce the radius @xmath17 of the three phase contact line and the angle @xmath18 as auxiliary variables ( see fig . [ fig : pert ] ) . in this subsection we formulate a free energy functional for the degrees of freedom @xmath15 and @xmath16 . as shown later , for the cases of interest here the deviations from the reference configuration are small enough to justify a perturbative treatment , and the free energy can be expanded up to quadratic order in @xmath19 and @xmath15 . we denote with @xmath20 the vertical force per unit area acting on the meniscus surface in the reference configuration . in the case of a charged colloid , @xmath20 is given by the @xmath21component of the difference of the maxwell stress tensor right above and below the meniscus , plus the pressure difference acting across the meniscus ( incluiding an imbalance in osmotic pressure due to the different concentration of ions just above and below the meniscus ) @xcite . we introduce the following dimensionless parameter to measure the relative strength of this force : @xmath22 where the integral extends over the flat meniscus @xmath23 ( the plane @xmath24 with a circular hole of radius @xmath25 ) . we assume @xmath26 with @xmath27 , so that the integral converges . in the same spirit we introduce the total vertical force @xmath28 acting on the charged colloid in the flat reference configuration , which includes gravity , the electrostatic force , and the total ( i.e. , hydrostatic and osmotic ) pressure exerted by the fluids . this leads to the definition @xmath29 these two dimensionless parameters will appear naturally in the course of the calculations . if @xmath30 and @xmath31 vanish , the reference configuration _ is _ the equilibrium state ; it is the global minimum of the free energy functional given in eqs . ( [ eq : fdef ] ) and ( [ eq : f ] ) below if @xmath32 , @xmath33 . the aforementioned perturbative expansion of the free energy can be rephrased as an expansion in terms of the small parameters @xmath30 and @xmath31 . the free energy @xmath34 of the colloid expressed relative to the aforementioned reference configuration consists of five terms : @xmath35 in the following we discuss each contribution : * _ fluid contact of the colloid_. with @xmath36 denoting the surface area of the colloid which is in contact with phase @xmath12 , the surface free energy of the colloid due to its exposure to the phases 1 and 2 is @xmath37 in appendix [ sec : fcont ] we express this contribution as a function of @xmath38 and @xmath15 . the final result , valid up to corrections of at least third order in @xmath30 or @xmath31 , reads @xmath39 ^ 2 + \pi \gamma ( r_0 ^ 2 - r_{0,\rm ref}^2 ) . \ ] ] * _ change of the meniscus area_. the free energy contribution due to variations in the meniscus area relative to the reference state reads @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the surface of the fluid interface projected onto the plane @xmath24 ( in which the reference interface is located ) , and @xmath42 is the gradient operator on the flat reference interface . for small slopes ( @xmath43 ) one obtains : @xmath44 since the @xmath45dependent term is of second order in @xmath45 , we have approximated the integration domain @xmath41 by @xmath46 ; the corrections are at least of third order in the small parameters @xmath30 or @xmath31 . the first term in this expression represents the change in the area of the meniscus which is cut out by the colloid , and in eq . ( [ eq : fdef ] ) it cancels the second term of eq . ( [ eq : fcont_iso ] ) . * _ volume forces on the fluids_. we consider the case that the only volume force acting on the fluid phases is gravity . the electrostatic forces are active only at the surfaces , where a net charge can accumulate . if the spherical colloid is replaced by a long cylinder of radius @xmath25 ( fig . [ fig : cylinder ] ) the change in gravitational potential energy relative to the reference state due to the displacements of volumes of the fluid phases can be calculated easily : @xmath47 assuming that the mass density of phase 2 is larger than the one of phase 1 , i.e. , @xmath48 ; @xmath49 denotes the capillary length @xmath50 in terms of the acceleration @xmath51 of gravity . for a spherical colloid @xmath52 in eq . ( [ eq : fvol ] ) has to be corrected to account for the specific dependence of the displaced fluid volume on the colloid height @xmath16 , yielding a slightly cumbersome expression @xcite . this correction is usually numerically small and we neglect it for reasons of simplicity . as it will be shown in subsec . [ sec : lambda ] this is justified because the results of interest here are insensitive to the precise form of @xmath53 in the limit @xmath54 ( @xmath55 mm , which is much larger than any other relevant length scale of the system ) . * _ force on the fluid interface_. the aforementioned surface force density @xmath20 acts on the fluid interface between phase 1 and phase 2 . the free energy change due to the ensuing displacements of the meniscus is @xmath56 here @xmath20 is the surface force in the _ reference _ configuration ( @xmath57 corresponds to a force pointing upward ) . changes in the force induced by meniscus deformations and colloidal displacements contribute terms of higher orders in @xmath30 or @xmath31 in eq . ( [ eq : finter ] ) . the replacement of @xmath58 by @xmath23 in eq . ( [ eq : finter ] ) introduces terms of higher order , too . * _ contribution from the colloid_. the free energy change due to a vertical displacement of the colloid is @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the vertical force on the colloid in the _ reference _ configuration . like for @xmath61 , changes of @xmath60 due to deviations from the reference configuration contribute to higher order terms . in conclusion , by adding eqs . ( [ eq : fcont_iso ] ) , ( [ eq : fmen ] ) , ( [ eq : fvol ] ) , ( [ eq : finter ] ) , and ( [ eq : fcoll ] ) we obtain the following approximate expression for the total free energy , which is correct up to second order in @xmath30 or @xmath31 , and which is a function of @xmath38 and a functional of @xmath15 : @xmath62 + \pi \gamma [ u_0 - \delta h ] ^2 - f \delta h , \ ] ] where @xmath63 . the equilibrium configuration of the system minimizes the free energy expression ( [ eq : f ] ) . the minimization proceeds in two stages . first we seek the minimum with respect to @xmath38 at fixed @xmath15 : @xmath64 where we have used the definition ( [ eq : epsf ] ) . using repeatedly the definitions of @xmath16 and @xmath17 in terms of the auxiliary angle @xmath18 ( fig . [ fig : pert ] ) we can compute the change of the contact radius : @xmath65 plus corrections of second order in @xmath30 , @xmath31 . in the second step , we minimize eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) with respect to @xmath15 at fixed @xmath38 . this is a problem of variations with a free boundary condition at @xmath66 @xcite . variation with respect to @xmath67 yields a second order ordinary differential equation , @xmath68 while variation with respect to @xmath69 provides a boundary condition : @xmath70 where the last equality follows from eq . ( [ eq : h_eq ] ) . the second boundary condition one has to impose on eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) follows from the requirement that the meniscus is asymptotically flat far from the colloid ( assuming that @xmath71 ) : @xmath72 equation ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) describes mechanical equilibrium of the interface such that the laplace pressure balances the forces acting on the interface . the boundary condition ( [ eq : u0 ] ) expresses mechanical equilibrium of the colloidal particle : at the contact line ( i.e. , the circle with radius @xmath17 at @xmath73 ) the interface exerts a force onto the colloid which has a non vanishing contribution only in @xmath74direction with the magnitude @xmath75 \approx 2 \pi \gamma r_{0,\rm ref } u'_0 $ ] . this contact line force is balanced by the total force @xmath60 . the solution of eqs . ( [ eq : younglaplace][eq : u_infty ] ) can be written in terms of the modified bessel functions of zeroth order : @xmath76 , \ ] ] where the integration constant @xmath77 is determined by the boundary condition ( [ eq : u0 ] ) . for typical values of the parameters , @xmath49 is of the order of millimeters and therefore much larger than any other length scale occurring for experiments with sub - micrometer colloids . in order to study the intermediate asymptotics ( @xmath79 ) of @xmath15 as given by eq . ( [ eq : solbessel ] ) , we insert the asymptotic expansions of the bessel functions @xcite as @xmath78 and retain those terms which do not vanish in this limit . assuming that @xmath80 decays sufficiently fast , eq . ( [ eq : solbessel ] ) reduces to @xmath81 where @xmath82 and @xmath83 is euler s constant . in eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) , we have expressed the integration constant @xmath77 appearing in eq . ( [ eq : solbessel ] ) in terms of @xmath31 by using the boundary condition ( [ eq : u0 ] ) . the first term in eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) is a solution of the homogeneous part of eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) ( with @xmath84 in the equation ) , demonstrating that the limit @xmath78 is singular as long as @xmath85 . the second term corresponds to a particular solution of the inhomogeneous differential equation . if the surface force @xmath20 decays algebraically , @xmath86 , this term decays like @xmath87 ( since we have assumed @xmath27 ) , so that the logarithmic contribution is dominant . if @xmath88 , the asymptotic behavior is no longer given by eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) but a different dependence on @xmath49 arises . at distances @xmath89 of the order of @xmath49 , the expression ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) is not valid and a crossover to the exact solution ( [ eq : solbessel ] ) takes place in order to satisfy the boundary condition at infinity ( eq . ( [ eq : u_infty ] ) ) . figure [ fig : u(r ) ] sketches the behavior of the meniscus profile @xmath15 . as can be checked directly in the differential equation ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) , one has @xmath90 asymptotically as @xmath91 , which expresses the balance between the surface force @xmath20 on the meniscus and the gravitational force . there is , however , another intermediate regime @xmath92 but not too large , in which @xmath15 decays @xmath93 and which corresponds to the solution of eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) with @xmath94 set to zero , i.e. , when gravity is balanced by the laplace pressure induced by the meniscus curvature . these conclusions , as well as the functional dependence of @xmath15 on @xmath20 , are robust and independent of the details of the boundary condition at @xmath95 . in order to support this statement , we consider two cases which implement the distant boundary condition differently : * _ pinned interface_. in the absence of gravity the interface is assumed to be pinned at a finite distance @xmath96 from the colloid . this corresponds to setting @xmath84 in eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) and replacing eq . ( [ eq : u_infty ] ) by the new boundary condition @xmath97 . in this case the solution of eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) is given by @xmath98 where @xmath99 in analogy to eq . ( [ eq : epspi ] ) . in the intermediate asymptotic regime ( @xmath100 ) , the meniscus profile is then given by @xmath101 assuming that @xmath20 decays sufficiently fast so that the integrals in eqs . ( [ eq : sol_pin ] ) and ( [ eq : epspi_pin ] ) converge as @xmath102 . equation ( [ eq : sol2 ] ) resembles eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) with @xmath103 replaced by @xmath96 . * _ pinned curved reference interface_. in some experiments the interface between phases 1 and 2 is in fact closed , so that the colloidal particle lies at the surface of a large nonvolatile spherical droplet of phase 2 which is immersed in phase 1 @xcite ( fig . [ fig : droplet ] ) and fixed by certain means ( e.g. by a glass plate ) . + the free energy functional ( [ eq : f ] ) has to be modified to account for the curvature of the reference interface as well as of the constraint that the droplet volume remains unchanged under deformation . to determine the interface deformation , we minimize the functional and employ the boundary condition that the droplet is fixed at some point far from the colloid . the mathematical details and the corresponding solution for @xmath15 are presented in appendix [ sec : droplet ] . here we quote only the intermediate asymptotic behavior ( @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is the radius of the undeformed droplet ) : @xmath106 with @xmath107 a numerical constant given by eq . ( [ eq : tildec ] ) . again eq . ( [ eq : sol3 ] ) closely resembles eqs . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) and ( [ eq : sol2 ] ) . the physical reason for the occurrence of the singularity in the limit @xmath108 is that a `` restoring force '' far from the particle is required to yield a well defined unperturbed interface which allows one to determine the deformation @xmath15 unambiguously . for example , if one takes the limit @xmath109 in the young laplace eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) , it is inconsistent to impose the boundary condition @xmath110 in the corresponding solution . the special case @xmath111 , however , is not singular ; this will be discussed in sec . [ sec : discussion ] . furthermore , the comparison of eqs . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) , ( [ eq : sol2 ] ) , and ( [ eq : sol3 ] ) demonstrates that the functional form of the intermediate asymptotic behavior is independent of how the restoring force is implemented . this corresponds to the so called intermediate asymptotic behavior of the second kind @xcite , characterized by the following features : 1 . there is a length scale ( @xmath49 , @xmath96 , or @xmath105 ) which is much larger than the other length scales of the system under consideration and which seems at first sight to be irrelevant . 2 . nevertheless , this length scale determines the dominant logarithmic ( or more generally , the power law ) dependence . 3 . the detailed physical origin of this length scale ( in the examples we have considered , gravity , pinning of a reference flat or curved interface ) does not matter . well known examples of this kind of asymptotic behavior are critical phenomena in phase transitions @xcite . in that case , it is the microscopic length scale given by the amplitude of the correlation length which can not be set to zero although it is much smaller than the correlation length itself . this microscopic length scale is required to formulate the power law behavior of certain properties of the system , but its detailed physical origin is unimportant for the universal decay exponents of the power laws . in this section we consider the equilibrium state of two identical colloids floating at the interface at a fixed lateral distance @xmath112 and compute the effective interaction potential @xmath113 generated by the meniscus . the free energy can be derived along the same lines leading to eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) , but with due account for the fact that in the presence of two colloids the meniscus slope no longer exhibits rotational symmetry . nonetheless @xmath114 depends only on the distance @xmath112 between the centers of the two spheres . the reference configuration is that of two colloids floating on a planar interface with the corresponding reference free energy being independent of @xmath112 . in this case one has for the free energy relative to that of the reference configuration a contribution @xmath115 from the meniscus and a contribution of the form @xmath116 from each colloid . ( the total free energy includes also the direct interaction between the colloids ; this contribution will be considered in subsec . [ sec : elec ] . ) from eqs . ( [ eq : fcont_aniso ] ) , ( [ eq : fmen ] ) , ( [ eq : fvol ] ) , ( [ eq : finter ] ) , and ( [ eq : fcoll ] ) one obtains : @xmath117 + \sum_{\alpha=1,2 } \left\ { \frac{\gamma}{2 r_{0 , \rm ref } } \oint_{\partial s_\alpha } \!\!\ ! d\ell \ ; [ \delta \hat{h}_\alpha - \hat{u}]^2 - \hat{f } \delta \hat{h}_\alpha \right\ } .\ ] ] here , @xmath118 is the meniscus profile in the presence of two colloids , @xmath119 are the corresponding heights , @xmath120 is the vertical force per unit area on the meniscus in the reference configuration , and @xmath121 is the force on each colloid . by symmetry , one has @xmath122 and @xmath123 . @xmath124 are the circular disks delimited by the contact lines of the colloids in the reference configuration , @xmath125 are the contact lines , with the convention that we trace them counterclockwise , and @xmath126 ( see fig . [ fig:2coll_top ] ) . the equilibrium configuration is the minimum of the free energy given by eq . ( [ eq : f2 ] ) . the minimization procedure follows closely subsec . [ sec : minf ] . first , minimizing with respect to @xmath127 at fixed meniscus height @xmath118 leads to the height of the colloids , @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the mean height of the contact line . in the next step , we minimize with respect to @xmath118 at fixed @xmath119 . variation in the interior of the domain @xmath130 provides a second order partial differential equation , @xmath131 while variation at the boundary @xmath132 provides the following _ transversality conditions _ @xcite : @xmath133 where the last equality follows from eq . ( [ eq : h_eq2 ] ) . in this expression , @xmath134 is the derivative in the outward normal direction of @xmath125 . ( in this way , the triad ( @xmath135 ) is right - handed , where @xmath136 is the unit vector in the outward normal direction , @xmath137 is the unit vector in the counterclockwise tangent direction , and @xmath138 is the unit vector in the positive @xmath74direction . ) when applying the transversality condition , in the context of gauss theorem one must keep in mind that the boundary of the region @xmath130 consists of the contours @xmath125 traced in _ clockwise direction _ with the normals directed towards the interior of @xmath124 . ( the boundary at @xmath139 does not contribute due to eq . ( [ eq : u_infty2 ] ) . ) in the special case of a single colloid , rotational invariance reduces eq . ( [ eq : trans ] ) to eq . ( [ eq : u0 ] ) . finally , one has the additional boundary condition @xmath140 the solution of eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace2 ] ) with the boundary conditions given by eqs . ( [ eq : trans ] ) and ( [ eq : u_infty2 ] ) is a difficult task . ( we are only aware of the already very involved solution of the homogeneous eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace2 ] ) , i.e. , @xmath141 , with the simplified boundary condition @xmath142 @xcite . ) for the present purpose , one can use the so - called _ superposition approximation _ @xcite , which yields the correct solution in the asymptotic limit of large separation @xmath143 between the colloids . let @xmath144 denote the equilibrium meniscus profile as if colloid @xmath145 was alone , with @xmath146 and @xmath147 denoting the corresponding forces . the superposition approximation then reads : @xmath148 notice that the fields @xmath149 and @xmath150 are defined in the domain @xmath151 , while the fields @xmath152 and @xmath153 are defined in the smaller domain @xmath130 . equations ( [ eq : younglaplace2 ] ) and ( [ eq : u_infty2 ] ) are fulfilled by this approximate solution , but the boundary condition ( [ eq : trans ] ) is violated : using eqs . ( [ eq : superposition ] ) and the boundary condition in eq . ( [ eq : u0 ] ) for the single colloid solution , one obtains @xmath154_{{\bf r } \in \partial s_1 } \simeq \left [ \frac{\partial { u}_2 ( { \bf r})}{\partial n_1 } - \frac{1}{r_{0 , \rm ref } } \left\ { { u}_2 ( { \bf r})- \frac{1}{2 \pi r_{0 , \rm ref } } \oint_{\partial s_1 } \!\!\ ! d\ell \ ; { u}_2 \right\ } \right]_{{\bf r } \in \partial s_1 } , \ ] ] and a similar expression for the other colloid with the indices 1 and 2 interchanged . in general , this expression does not vanish as required by eq . ( [ eq : trans ] ) . if @xmath112 is large , eq . ( [ eq : trans1 ] ) can be evaluated by expanding @xmath155 into a taylor series around the center of colloid 1 , yielding to lowest order ( @xmath156 is the outward directed normal unit vector of @xmath157 ) @xmath158_{{\bf r } \in \partial s_1 } \simeq \frac{1}{4 } r_{0 , \rm ref } [ { \bf e}_1 { \bf e}_1 : \nabla \nabla { u}_2 ( d ) + \nabla^2 { u}_2 ( d ) ] \ ] ] in dyadic notation . inserting the single colloid solution given in eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) , one finds that this expression decays like @xmath159 if @xmath160 , and like @xmath161 if @xmath162 . the superposition solution can be used to determine the vertical displacement according to eq . ( [ eq : h_eq2 ] ) : @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the relative vertical displacement of an isolated colloid ( eq . ( [ eq : h_eq ] ) ) and @xmath165 is the average of the single colloid meniscus height at the contact line of the other colloid . the meniscus induced effective potential between the two colloids ( without their direct interaction ) is defined as @xmath166 where @xmath167 is the free energy of the two colloid equilibrium configuration ( eq . ( [ eq : f2 ] ) ) while @xmath168 is the single colloid equilibrium free energy ( eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) ) . as noted before the energy of the reference configuration is independent of the separation @xmath112 and drops out from eq . ( [ eq : veff_a ] ) . we insert eqs . ( [ eq : superposition ] ) , ( [ eq : z_superposition ] ) , and ( [ eq : meanu ] ) into eq . ( [ eq : veff_a ] ) and exploit the invariance of the free energy under exchange of the colloids , i.e. , the symmetry under exchanging indices @xmath169 . after carrying out some analytic manipulations one finds the following expression for the effective potential : @xmath170 \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } - \int_{s_1 } \!\!\ ! da \ ; \left [ \gamma |\nabla { u}_2|^2 + \frac{\gamma}{\lambda^2 } { u}_2 ^ 2 - 2 { \pi}_2 { u}_2 \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } + \frac{\gamma}{r_{0 , \rm ref } } \oint_{\partial s_1 } \!\!\ ! d\ell \ ; [ \bar{{u } } - { u}_2]^2 - 2 f \bar{{u}}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first integral accounts for the change in surface energy , gravitational potential energy , and surface stress potential energy of the meniscus due to the overlap of the meniscus deformations caused by the two colloids . the second integral is the corresponding change due to the fact that the interface is reduced by an amount @xmath171 compared to the single colloid case because of the presence of the second colloid . the third integral is the change in surface free energy of one colloid due to the extra meniscus deformation induced by the second colloid . the last term is the change in energy due to the vertical displacement of one colloid by this extra meniscus deformation . for the mathematical manipulations to follow , it is suitable to rewrite eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) by applying gauss theorem to the integrals involving @xmath172 and by using the fact that the functions @xmath173 fulfill eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace ] ) individually , e.g. , @xmath174 = \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } - \gamma \oint_{\partial s_1 } \!\!\ ! d\ell \ ; \frac{\partial ( { u}_1 { u}_2)}{\partial n_1 } + \int_{\mathbb{r}^2\backslash(s_1 \bigcup s_2 ) } \!\!\!\!\!\ ! da \ ; \left [ { \pi}_1 { u}_2 - \frac{\gamma}{\lambda^2 } { u}_1 { u}_2 \right ] . \nonumber \\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] thus one obtains from eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) @xmath175 ^ 2 - 2 f \bar{{u } } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this form all the integrals , except the first one , are performed over bounded domains . this allows one to carry out a taylor expansion which yields a uniformly valid asymptotic expansions of the terms as @xmath176 . in the following calculations , the integrals are evaluated in polar coordinates with the origin at the center of @xmath124 and @xmath177 is the position vector with respect to this origin . in particular , @xmath178 is the center of colloid 1 with respect to the center of colloid 2 , and @xmath179 is the center of colloid 2 with respect to the center of colloid 1 ( fig . [ fig:2coll_top ] ) so that , e.g. , @xmath180 . 1 . in order to compute the leading asymptotic behavior of the first term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) as @xmath176 we distinguish two cases : 1 . @xmath85 : in this case , @xmath181 ( eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) ) while @xmath182 ( @xmath27 ) as @xmath183 . asymptotically the main contribution stems from the region near @xmath171 and @xmath184 employing the definition ( [ eq : epspi ] ) . it will turn out that there is no need to compute also the next to leading term in order to obtain @xmath185 as the leading term will be part of the leading contribution to @xmath114 and it will not be cancelled by other contributions . @xmath186 : in this case @xmath187 if @xmath188 . the regions contributing mainly to the integral are the neighborhoods of @xmath171 and @xmath189 . we employ the taylor expansion of the integrand ( which is valid up to a maximum order depending on how fast @xmath94 decays ) to evaluate the leading and the next to leading contributions if @xmath190 ( using dyadic notation ) : @xmath191_{{\bf r}_2 = d { \bf e}_x } \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } + \int_{\mathbb{r}^2\backslash s_2 } \!\!\!\!\!\ ! da \ ; { u}_2 \left[{\pi}_1 + \dots \right]_{{\bf r}_1 = - d { \bf e}_x } \nonumber \\ & \simeq & 2 \pi \gamma r_{0 , \rm ref}\ ; \varepsilon_\pi \;{u}(d ) + \frac{1}{2 } \pi \nabla^2 { u } ( d ) \int_{r_{0,\rm ref}}^\infty dr\ ; r^3\,\pi(r ) \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } + { \pi}(d ) \int_{\mathbb{r}^2\backslash s_2 } \!\!\!\!\!\ ! da \ ; { u}_2 + \dots \ ; . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we can simplify the result further by evaluating the last integral by repeated partial integration with the explicit solution for @xmath192 given in eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) : @xmath193 .\ ] ] one finally obtains @xmath194 { \pi } ( d ) + \dots \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have employed eq . ( [ eq : younglaplace2 ] ) ( with @xmath195 for simplicity ) . convergence of the integral of @xmath192 imposes the more stringent constraint @xmath190 on the decay of @xmath196 ( see eq . ( [ eq : int_uda ] ) ) . + the validity of formulae ( [ eq : pi1u2_a ] ) and ( [ eq : pi1u2_b ] ) has been checked explicitly by comparing their predictions with the numerical evaluation of the integral for a surface stress of the form @xmath197 with @xmath190 . 2 . the second term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) can be estimated in the limit @xmath176 by expanding the integrand into a taylor series , which is uniformly valid in the integration domain : @xmath198_{{\bf r}_2 = d { \bf e}_x } \simeq \pi r_{0 , \rm ref}^2 \ , { \pi } ( d ) \ , { u } ( d ) + \dots \ ; . \end{aligned}\ ] ] 3 . the third term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) reads : @xmath199_{r_1=r_{0 , \rm ref } } \\ & \simeq & \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\ ! d\varphi \ ; \left\ { ( { \bf r}_1 \cdot \nabla ) \left [ { u}_1 \left ( \phantom { \frac{1}{2 } } \!\!\ ! { u}_2 + { \bf r}_1 \cdot ( \nabla { u})_2 + \right.\right.\right.\nonumber \\ & & \qquad \qquad \left . \left . \left . \frac{1}{2 } { \bf r}_1 { \bf r}_1 : ( \nabla \nabla { u})_2 + \dots \right)_{{\bf r}_2=d { \bf e}_x } \right ] \right\}_{r_1=r_{0 , \rm ref } } \nonumber \\ & \simeq & 2 \pi r_{0 , \rm ref } { u}(d ) \left . \frac{d { u}}{d r } \right|_{r = r_{0 , \rm ref } } + \frac{\pi}{2 } r_{0 , \rm ref } \nabla^2 { u}(d ) \left . \frac{d ( r^2 { u})}{d r } \right|_{r = r_{0 , \rm ref } } + \dots \nonumber \\ & \simeq & 2 \pi r_{0 , \rm ref } \varepsilon_f { u}(d ) - \frac{\pi}{2\gamma } r_{0 , \rm ref}^3 \left(\varepsilon_f + \frac{2{u}_0}{r_{0 , \rm ref } } \right ) { \pi}(d ) + \dots \end{aligned}\ ] ] using the boundary condition for @xmath192 in eq . ( [ eq : u0 ] ) . 4 . the fourth term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) is evaluated analogously : @xmath200_{r_1=r_{0 , \rm ref } } \\ & \simeq & \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\ ! d\varphi \ ; \left\ { { \bf r}_1 \cdot \left [ ( \nabla { u}^2)_2 + { \bf r}_1 \cdot ( \nabla \nabla { u}^2)_2 + \dots \right]_{{\bf r}_2=d { \bf e}_x } \right\}_{r_1=r_{0 , \rm ref } } \nonumber \\ & \simeq & \pi r_{0 , \rm ref}^2 \nabla^2 { u}^2 ( d ) + \dots \ ; . \end{aligned}\ ] ] 5 . the fifth term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) is given by @xmath201 ^ 2 & = & \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\ ! d\varphi \ ; { u}_2 ^ 2 - 2 \pi \bar{{u}}^2 \nonumber \\ & \simeq & \frac{1}{2 } \pi r_{0 , \rm ref}^2 \left [ \nabla^2 { u}^2 ( d ) - 2 { u } \nabla^2 { u } ( d ) \right ] + \dots \nonumber \\ & \simeq & \frac{1}{2 } \pi r_{0 , \rm ref}^2 \left [ \nabla^2 { u}^2 ( d ) + \frac{2}{\gamma } { \pi } ( d ) \ , { u } ( d ) \right ] + \dots \;. \end{aligned}\ ] ] 6 . in order to evaluate the sixth term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) , we expand @xmath202 in the definition given by eq . ( [ eq : meanu ] ) : @xmath203 the asymptotic behavior of the effective potential is finally obtained from eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) by collecting all terms . there are two qualitatively different cases : * : the limit @xmath204 is singular and the single colloid meniscus profile exhibits a logarithmic dependence . one finds that the leading contribution is provided by the terms proportional to @xmath205 : @xmath206 which represents a long - ranged attractive effective potential , irrespective of the sign of the forces @xmath60 and @xmath94 acting on the system . * : the single colloid meniscus profile decays like @xmath207 if @xmath161 . the leading contribution is proportional to @xmath208 , because the terms proportional to @xmath205 cancel each other : @xmath209 this correspond to a shorter ranged effective interaction , which in principle can be either attractive or repulsive depending on the precise form of the function @xmath210 . in the particular case that @xmath210 decays monotonically to zero , e.g. , @xmath211 , it is easy to check that @xmath114 amounts to a repulsive force , because the sign of @xmath192 is opposite to the sign of @xmath196 . we have seen that the error committed by the superposition approximation in satisfying one of the boundary conditions , eq . ( [ eq : correction_sup ] ) , decays like @xmath208 , too . this suggests that the corrections to the superposition approximation could modify the precise value of the constant factor acting as an amplitude in eq . ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) , and _ a priori _ it can not be excluded that there are cancellations leading to a vanishing amplitude , and therefore to an even faster decay for large @xmath112 . thus the superposition approximation might not be reliable enough for calculating @xmath114 if @xmath186 . if one traces back the origin of the dominant contributions to @xmath212 , one finds that in both cases only the first , third , and sixth term in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) are relevant . they correspond physically to the effect of the overlap of the two single colloid meniscus profiles and the change of the colloid height ( first integral and the term @xmath213 in eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) , respectively ) . equations ( [ eq : logv ] ) and ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) describe the asymptotic behavior of the meniscus induced effective intercolloidal potential and thus represent a central result of our analysis . they provide the explicit functional dependence on an arbitrary stress field @xmath20 which decays sufficiently fast . the assumptions entering their derivation are ( i ) that the deviations of the meniscus profile from the reference configuration are small , allowing one to confine the analysis to a free energy expression which is quadratic in the deviations , and ( ii ) the superposition approximation , which expresses the two colloid equilibrium state in terms of the single colloid state . the analysis shows that the limit @xmath214 is non singular only in the case @xmath162 . equation ( [ eq : logv ] ) can be used to determine the flotation force . there are no stresses acting at the meniscus , @xmath215 , while the force @xmath60 on the colloids is due to their weight corrected by the buoyancy force . accordingly , eq . ( [ eq : logv ] ) reduces to the flotation potential @xmath216 where @xmath217 is known as the capillary charge @xcite , by analogy with two dimensional electrostatics . the asymptotic form for @xmath218 originates from a potential proportional to the modified bessel function @xmath219 ( see eq . ( [ eq : solbessel ] ) ) @xcite . the order of magnitude of the capillary charge is @xmath220 . for a typical value at room temperature and for colloids with a mass density of the order of , the prefactor of the logarithm can be estimated as @xmath221 therefore , compared with the thermal energy , the flotation force is negligible for submicrometer sized colloids . another application is the case of electrically charged colloids . if one of the liquid phases is water , the charge of the colloid is screened ( the debye length of pure water is @xmath222 @xmath0 m and smaller in the presence of an electrolyte ) , and the effective electric field is that of a dipole oriented perpendicularly to the fluid interface @xcite . the electrostatic field decays as @xmath223 and the stress on the meniscus as @xmath224 . both the electrostatic stress and the osmotic ionic pressure decay in the same manner @xcite . thus the total intercolloidal potential at intermediate distances is @xmath225 if gravity is neglected both as a force on the colloid and as a restoring force for the interface @xmath226 , then one can indeed show that the ensuing condition of mechanical isolation ( no net force on the system ) leads to @xmath186 , i.e. , precisely the situation for which the limit @xmath78 is non singular . to see this , we consider the total stress tensor @xmath227 which consists of the maxwell stress tensor ( due to the electrostatic field ) and a diagonal osmotic pressure tensor ( due to the electrolytes ) @xcite . at interfaces @xmath227 can be discontinuous . the total volume @xmath228 of the system is divided into volumes @xmath229 , @xmath230 , and @xmath231 ( see fig . [ fig : forcebalance ] for the explanation of the notation in the following equation ) . the total force reads ( the superscript @xmath232 denotes evaluation on the positive(negative ) side of the oriented surface , i.e. , the side the arrows in fig . [ fig : forcebalance ] point to ( do not point to ) ) @xmath233 \nonumber \\ & = & \int_{s_{\rm men , ref } } \!\!\!\!\!\ ! da \ ; \pi \ , { \bf e}_z + f { \bf e}_z \ ; . \ ] ] in the first line , we have applied gauss theorem with due account of the possible discontinuities of the tensor @xmath227 accross the interfaces . in the second line , @xmath234 in the fluid phases @xmath229 and @xmath230 , because the counterion distribution of the present reference configuration is the equilibrium distribution and thus locally force free . this distribution is considered to be fixed . the second term in the second line is the total force on the meniscus ( which can have only a normal component ) , while the terms in square brackets sum up to the force @xmath60 acting on the colloid . thus the vertical component of the total force is @xmath235 if it vanishes , as it is the case for an isolated system , then @xmath236 . according to eq . ( [ eq : logv ] ) this implies that the long ranged logarithmic contribution to @xmath114 is absent and thus the limit @xmath78 is regular . physically this means that there is no need for a restoring force acting on the fluid fluid interface when the deformation is created by localized internal stresses . instead , according to eq . ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) , one obtains a potential @xmath237 for the present case of a dipolar electric field ( see above ) . this shorter ranged potential can not counterbalance the direct electrostatic dipolar repulsion @xmath238 . such a counterbalance would be needed for a straightforward explanation of the aforementioned experimentally observed attractions . the line of argument to explain the absence of the logarithm contribution to @xmath114 was already put forward in refs . @xcite and @xcite , where exclusively the case @xmath239 has been addressed . our detailed analysis complements and generalizes these contributions . in ref . @xcite , @xmath240 is estimated by taking into account only the degree of freedom `` meniscus profile '' , @xmath241 , and considering only the change in meniscus area due to the superposition of the dimples . this corresponds to retaining only the term @xmath242 in expression ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) . although the type of @xmath112dependence obtained that way is correct , the sign of the force turns out to be wrong ( attraction instead of repulsion ) . the reason is that the contributions @xmath243 and @xmath244 in eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) are equally important as the retained term . this is taken into account in the more detailed analysis of ref . @xcite , where the limiting case @xmath245 ( point particle ) is considered from the outset , so that `` height of the colloid '' is not an independent degree of freedom , i.e. , @xmath246 . correspondingly , @xmath60 is set to zero ( @xmath247 ) , and its effect is modelled by a dirac delta contribution to the stress @xmath20 such that @xmath248 . the potential @xmath249 calculated this way corresponds to keeping the three terms mentioned above which are relevant ( the first and third term in the first integral of eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) and the last term of eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) ) and to setting @xmath250 , since this limit is regular when @xmath251 . our analysis has shown that the terms which are dropped in the limit @xmath252 ( second and third integral in eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) , second , fourth , and fifth terms in eq . ( [ eq : vmen2 ] ) ) yield indeed a subdominant contribution to eq . ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) . however , the integral appearing as a prefactor in eq . ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) is divergent for @xmath252 , so that in ref . @xcite a short distance cutoff @xmath253 has been introduced which is expected to be of the order of @xmath8 . the precise value of @xmath253 depends on the details of the implementation of this cutoff ; for the example used in ref . @xcite , the application of eq . ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) yields @xmath254 . in the presence of gravity mechanical isolation is violated and as we have shown @xmath255 . ( the force balance argument ( eq . ( [ eq : forcebalance ] ) ) can be easily generalized to include the effect of the gravitational volume force . ) in the case of a curved reference interface ( corresponding to the experiment reported in ref . @xcite using colloids trapped at the interface of water droplets in oil ) , eq . ( [ eq : forcebalance ] ) is replaced by @xmath256 where @xmath257 is the radial unit vector of the unperturbed spherical droplet . force balance in the vertical direction yields a factor @xmath258 ( see fig . [ fig : droplet ] ) in the integral , which can be expanded for small angles in the limit @xmath259 . this leads to a curvature induced correction @xmath260 even for mechanical isolation . thus we see that independently of the details of the implementation of the distant boundary conditions the logarithmic term in the potential @xmath114 ( eq . ( [ eq : logv ] ) ) has a strength which is proportional to ( colloid size / system length)@xmath261 , which is nevertheless too weak to explain the reported attractive total interaction . mechanical isolation is violated in the presence of an external homogeneous electric field @xmath262 . for the experimental setup used in ref . @xcite it can not be ruled out that such an external field may have distorted the measurements @xcite . since this is the only experiment which provides quantitative information about the secondary minimum in @xmath263 , we discuss the case of an external field in more detail . in this experiment position recording measurements were performed on a hexagonal configuration of seven trapped colloids on a water droplet immersed in oil @xmath264 m ) . the latter was confined between two glass plates and the droplet stuck on the upper glass plate with a contact angle close to @xmath265 . residual charges might have resided on the upper plate @xcite . the measurements yielded the position of the secondary minimum , @xmath266 , and the curvature at the minimum , @xmath267 . with regard to the latter value we remark that systematic corrections can be estimated to lower @xmath268 by a factor 2 to 3 . these systematic corrections include ( i ) multiparticle effects and ( ii ) center of - mass movement of the droplet . we have estimated the effect of ( i ) by carrying out langevin simulations of the seven particle system using the intercolloidal potential eq . ( [ eq : vtot1 ] ) below . as for the effect of ( ii ) , any shape deformation induced by the moving colloids changes the center of mass position of the droplet since the droplet is fixed to the upper glass plate . the corresponding change in the gravitational energy of the droplet translates into a weak confining potential for the colloids which limits the stochastic movement of the center of mass of the seven colloids . this effect might be part of an explanation for the absence of center of mass movement observed in ref . @xcite . according to eqs . ( [ eq : logv ] ) and ( [ eq : vtot ] ) , the total intercolloidal potential in an external field is @xmath269 using the aforementioned experimental data for @xmath270 and @xmath271 , one obtains from eq . ( [ eq : vtot1 ] ) @xmath272 , @xmath273 and @xmath274 which is surprisingly deep , even if reduced by a factor 2 to 3 due to the systematic corrections mentioned above . furthermore , from eq . ( [ eq : logv ] ) we deduce @xmath275 and with @xmath276 n / m we find @xmath277 . the long ranged meniscus deformation ( see eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) ) is on the scale of nanometers . the short ranged meniscus deformation near the colloid can only be evaluated with a specific microscopic model for @xmath20 . for a rough estimate of @xmath30 , we consider the colloid charge to be concentrated on the surface . the asymptotic behavior of the stress tensor in this case is given by @xmath278 @xcite . if we assume this form of the stress tensor to hold for all @xmath89 , we find @xmath279 for the values of @xmath10 and @xmath253 given above . for not too small contact angles , this _ a posteriori _ justifies the perturbative approach which we have adopted . if the system has a net charge @xmath280 , then @xmath281 ) and ( [ eq : logv ] ) ) . using the values for @xmath282 and @xmath10 as given above we find @xmath283 for the value @xmath284 quoted in ref . @xcite , this yields a relatively small electric field @xmath285 , indicating how sensitive the system can be to spurious external fields . alternatively , an electric field @xmath286 is sufficient for the meniscus induced logarithmic potential to have a depth of the order @xmath287 . thus the external field offers the possibility to tune easily the capillary long ranged attraction and to manipulate the structures formed by the colloids at the interface . in ref . @xcite , experimental results for the meniscus deformation around glass particles of radii 200 300 @xmath0 m trapped at water air or water oil interfaces are reported . the data for the meniscus slope @xmath288 at the contact circle imply ( eq . ( [ eq : u0 ] ) ) @xmath289 ( water oil interface ) , about fifteen times larger than the corresponding @xmath290 caused by gravity alone . furthermore , the reported meniscus shape for one sample contains a logarithmic part which is consistent with @xmath291 ( see eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) ) . as in the experiment analyzed in the previous subsection , the experimental observations could be understood within the framework of the theoretical model we have developed in terms of an external electric field violating mechanical isolation . yet independently of us , the authors of ref . @xcite have developed a theoretical model based on the same physical hypotheses as our approach which , they claim , explains the observed long ranged meniscus deformation . here we would like to note two important errors which flaw their analysis : 1 . ( 3.15 ) in ref . @xcite , in terms of which they interpret their observations , can be obtained by inserting the large distance ( @xmath292 ) asymptotic behavior of @xmath20 in our eq . ( [ eq : sol1 ] ) ( equivalent to their eq . ( 3.14 ) up to an additive constant ) both into the integral term _ and into the definition of @xmath30 _ ( eq . ( [ eq : epspi ] ) ) . since the dominant contribution to the integral defining @xmath30 stems from points @xmath293 , this procedure is clearly inadmissible . as a consequence , they obtain a wrong , nonvanishing prefactor of the logarithm , in spite of their explicit consideration of mechanical isolation ( see their eq . ( 6.6 ) ) . 2 . in order to calculate the intercolloidal effective potential within the superposition approximation , the formula relating @xmath294 to the meniscus deformation @xmath295 _ in the presence of gravity alone _ ( i.e. , eq . ( [ eq : flotv ] ) ) is applied even though @xmath296 . thus , an additional term contributing to the leading logarithm is not included ( compare their eq . ( 3.16 ) and our eq . ( [ eq : logv ] ) ) . in ref . @xcite also a numerical analysis is carried out . a detailed study of the relation between the results of this numerical analysis and our theoretical predictions will be published elsewhere @xcite . it may be possible that the presence of an external field is consistent with the data from refs . @xcite , as well as with the presence of the secondary potential minimum observed in the experiments using planar troughs , in particular in the cases @xmath297 , which fall into the intermediate asymptotic regime considered here . but this still remains as an open problem . given that already nanometer distortions of the meniscus produce noticeable attractions , the surface topography of colloids might be relevant . in ref . @xcite , colloidal surface roughness is proposed as an explanation of the attraction . the meniscus contact line is assumed to be pinned at defects on the colloid surface caused by surface roughness . this imposes a different boundary condition for the meniscus at contact , which is then deformed even in the absence of electrostatic forces . the corresponding analysis in ref . @xcite is concerned only with the term @xmath242 in the expression ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) , leading to the conclusion that @xmath113 decays as @xmath298 and corresponds to an attractive potential with a strength of @xmath299 for meniscus deformations of the order of @xmath300 . this conclusion , however , can not be simply carried over to the case of charged colloids . as we have shown the contributions of the terms @xmath301 and @xmath244 in eq . ( [ eq : vmen1 ] ) are relevant and can change the qualitative behavior of @xmath113 even in the limit of point colloids . it would be worthwhile to generalize the analysis of ref . @xcite along the line of arguments presented here in order to assess the importance of surface roughness . this should be complemented by more precise experimental information about the actual colloidal topography . recently , an explanation based on a contaminated interface has been advocated @xcite . the air water interface would be actually a two dimensional emulsion consisting of hydrophylic ( water ) patches and hydrophobic ( silicon oil ) patches . the colloidal particles ( hydrophobic in character according to ref . @xcite ) would cluster in the hydrophobic patches . thus , confinement of the colloids by finite size hydrophobic patches would give the impression of an effective intercolloidal attraction . at present , this explanation is only of qualitative nature . thermal fluctuations of the interface position around its mean value @xmath302 also induce an effective interaction between the colloids which confine these fluctuations ( casimir like force ) . using a gaussian model of the fluctuating interface in analogy to the procedure employed in ref . @xcite for calculating fluctuation induced forces between rods in a membrane , one finds for uncharged colloids a fluctuation induced potential @xmath303 , which is too small and falls off more rapidly than the intercolloidal dipole repulsion . here , the generalization to the charged case might give hints for the effective attractions between _ very _ small particles trapped at interfaces . concerning particle sizes well below the debye length , one should modify our analysis to account for the overlap of the screening ionic clouds ( this would affect , e.g. , the superposition approximation for the stress field @xmath94 , eq . ( [ eq : superposition ] ) ) . finally , in ref . @xcite the attraction of particles trapped at a nematic air interface is reported and an explanation in terms of a logarithmic meniscus deformation is proposed which parallels the explanation given in ref . @xcite : in this case , the deformation would be caused by the elastic distortion induced by the particles on the nematic phase @xcite . our detailed theoretical treatment shows that no long range ( logarithmic ) meniscus distortion can arise on an interface if the system is mechanically isolated and the excess free energy of the perturbed interface is correctly described by an expression like eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) . thus it appears that the simple explanation of the observed colloidal attractions given in ref . @xcite is not correct . however , it is not clear whether the free energy of a distorted nematic air interface is equivalent to that of a simple fluid interface due to the long ranged interactions in the nematic bulk caused by defects . thus , a generalization of our theory to interfaces involving nematic phases would be desirable in order to assess the possibility of long ranged colloidal attractions in more detail . we have analyzed the effective force induced by capillary deformation between two smooth spherical colloids floating at a fluid interface . the relevant degrees of freedom are the meniscus deformation and the height of the colloids ( fig . [ fig : pert ] ) , whose equilibrium values are given by minimization of a free energy functional . this functional was derived assuming small deviations from a reference configuration ( fig . [ fig : ref ] ) . it incorporates the surface tensions of the three interfaces involved ( `` colloid fluid phase 1 '' , `` colloid fluid phase 2 '' , and `` fluid phase 1 fluid phase 2 '' ) , the potential energy of the colloids under the action of a force @xmath60 , the potential energy of the fluid interface in an arbitrary surface stress field @xmath304 , and the potential energy due to a restoring force acting on the interface ( eqs . ( [ eq : fdef])([eq : f ] ) ) . the effective intercolloidal potential ( eq . ( [ eq : veff_a ] ) ) was calculated in the limit of large separations by using the superposition approximation ( eq . ( [ eq : superposition ] ) ) . we have shown in this limit that the contribution to the effective potential by the interfaces `` colloid fluid phases '' is subdominant . if the total force acting on the system , consisting of the two colloids and the meniscus , does not vanish , the presence of the restoring force acting on the fluid interface is essential although its precise form does not matter ( subsec . [ sec : lambda ] ) . in this case , the effective interaction is long ranged and attractive ( eq . ( [ eq : logv ] ) ) . if the total force vanishes , the restoring force is irrelevant altogether , the effective interaction is shorter ranged ( eq . ( [ eq : shortrangev ] ) ) , and it can not be computed reliably within the superposition approximation . as an application , we have considered the case of like charged , micrometer sized particles when the capillary deformation is due to the ensuing electrostatic field . we have discussed how one can tune the long ranged attractive interaction by an external electric field , but we conclude that the experimentally observed attraction in an isolated system can not be explained within the present model . possible directions for future research such as colloidal surface roughness and fluctuations of the interface have been discussed . we kindly acknowledge helpful discussions on the subject of the manuscript with m. nikolaides , a. bausch , k. danov , and p. kralchevsky . in this appendix we determine the contribution to the free energy due to the exposure of the colloid to the two fluid phases . here we consider the general case of no rotational invariance , so that the meniscus height @xmath305 depends on the distance @xmath89 from the axis through the colloid center and on the angle of revolution @xmath306 around this axis ( fig . [ fig : contactline ] ) . accordingly , the auxiliary variables @xmath307 and @xmath308 also depend on the revolution angle and one has @xmath309 and @xmath310 where @xmath311 is the meniscus height at contact . the surface areas of the colloid in contact with phase 1 and phase 2 are @xmath312\ ] ] and @xmath313 respectively . the expression for the free energy in eq . ( [ eq : fcont ] ) is based on these formulae for the special case @xmath314 ( fig . [ fig : ref ] ) and on young s law ( eq . ( [ eq : young ] ) ) : @xmath315 = \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{2 } \gamma r^2 \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\!\ ! d \varphi \ , [ \cos \xi(\varphi ) - \cos \theta]^2 + \frac{1}{2 } \gamma r^2 \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\!\ ! d \varphi \ , [ \cos^2 \theta - \cos^2 \xi(\varphi ) ] \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{2 } \gamma \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\!\ ! d \varphi \ , [ u(r_0(\varphi ) , \varphi ) - \delta h]^2 + \frac{1}{2 } \gamma \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\!\ ! d \varphi \ , [ r_0 ^ 2 ( \varphi ) - r_{0,\rm ref}^2 ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second term , which arises upon completing the square , represents the change of the meniscus area which is cut out by the colloid . since @xmath45 and @xmath38 are already of first order in @xmath30 or @xmath31 , one can replace @xmath307 by @xmath25 in the first term and obtains @xmath316 ^ 2 + \frac{1}{2 } \gamma \int_0^{2 \pi } \!\!\!\ ! d \varphi \ , [ r_0 ^ 2 ( \varphi ) - r_{0,\rm ref}^2 ] , \ ] ] plus corrections of at least third order in @xmath30 or @xmath31 . in the special case of rotational invariance , this expression reduces to eq . ( [ eq : fcont_iso ] ) . for the purpose of sec . [ sec:2coll ] one can rewrite eq . ( [ eq : almostfcont_aniso ] ) as the line integral @xmath317 ^ 2 + [ r_0 ^ 2 - r_{0,\rm ref}^2 ] \right\ } , \ ] ] where @xmath318 is a circular disk of radius @xmath319 , here centered at the origin , and @xmath320 denotes its circumference . in this appendix we calculate the deformation of the interface of a spherical droplet due to a floating colloidal particle . the reference configuration corresponds to a colloid floating at the surface of the spherical droplet such that eq . ( [ eq : young ] ) is fulfilled . here we will consider only axially symmetric configurations ( see fig . [ fig : droplet ] ) . in terms of the polar angle @xmath321 $ ] , the distance @xmath89 measured along the unperturbed spherical droplet surface is @xmath322 . ( note that in this appendix we consider @xmath323 and @xmath324 as functions of @xmath325 instead of @xmath89 . ) we define @xmath326 and we introduce the angle @xmath327 with @xmath328 at which another boundary condition ( to be specified below ) holds reflecting the fact that the droplet is fixed in space . with this additional boundary condition we model closely the actual experimental setup of ref . @xcite , where the droplet was attached to a glass plate with a contact angle less than @xmath265 @xcite . * in spherical coordinates , @xmath329 reads @xmath330 where @xmath331 is the differential of the solid angle , and @xmath332 is the gradient operator on the unit sphere . as before , this functional is now expanded for small deviations from the reference configuration , and we obtain @xmath333 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have neglected terms evaluated at @xmath334 which vanish in the limit @xmath259 . * the term @xmath61 in eq . ( [ eq : finter ] ) has to be amended by the extra work upon deformation which is caused by the pressure difference in the reference configuration between the interior and the exterior of the droplet , @xmath335 : @xmath336 \nonumber \\ \label{eq : finter1 } & \simeq & - 2 \pi \gamma \int_{\psi_{0}}^{\psi_1 } \!\!\ ! d\psi \ ; \sin\psi \ , \left [ \frac{r_{\rm drop}^2}{\gamma } \pi \ , u + ( 2 r_{\rm drop } u + 2 u^2)\right ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath337 is of order @xmath338 , we have to keep also terms @xmath339 in this expression for consistency . for simplicity we have neglected the contribution due to the change of @xmath41 during the deformation . such a term would affect the behavior of the meniscus only near @xmath334 and vanishes in the limit @xmath259 . * the change in volume of the perturbed droplet reads @xmath340 where @xmath341 is a contribution due to the spherical shape of the colloid ; it depends on @xmath38 and @xmath342 but can be safely neglected . ( this is the same kind of term encountered in calculating @xmath53 , see eq . ( [ eq : fvol ] ) . ) expanding @xmath343 for small deformations @xmath45 up to linear order yields @xmath344 physically , the deformation of the interface occurs under the constraint that the droplet volume remains unchanged . this constraint ( @xmath345 ) will be implemented in the free energy functional by means of a lagrange multiplier @xmath0 which itself turns out to be linear in the parameters @xmath30 and @xmath31 . this justifies keeping only the linear term in eq . ( [ eq : deltav ] ) . the contribution @xmath346 ( see eq . ( [ eq : fcont_iso ] ) ) is concerned only with quantities at @xmath334 , the colloid surface , and thus in the limit of large droplet radii this contribution are the same as in the planar case . the free energy related to the work done upon moving the colloid , @xmath347 ( see eq . ( [ eq : fcoll ] ) ) , remains also unchanged . for simplicity we also neglect gravity and set @xmath84 . in conclusion , the free energy functional to be minimized is the sum @xmath348 plus the constraint term @xmath349 ( where @xmath0 is a dimensionless lagrange multiplier ) : @xmath350 + \pi \gamma [ u_0 - \delta h ] ^2 - f \delta h .\ ] ] the quantity @xmath351 can be interpreted as a homogeneous pressure field enforcing the constant volume constraint . we note that the terms linear in @xmath45 present in eqs . ( [ eq : fmen1 ] ) and ( [ eq : finter1 ] ) have cancelled in the total free energy . minimization with respect to @xmath38 yields the same result as in eq . ( [ eq : h_eq ] ) . subsequent minimization with respect to @xmath352 leads to @xmath353 and ( compare with eq . ( [ eq : u0 ] ) ) @xmath354 the solution must satisfy the constant volume constraint @xmath355 finally , the second boundary condition mentioned at the beginning expresses the physical requirement that the droplet is fixed in space . ( otherwise , the application of a localized force at the interface would shift the droplet as a whole without deforming it . ) as an example , we assume that the droplet interface is pinned at @xmath327 ( another example , force balance by suitable localized counterstresses , is studied in ref . @xcite ) : @xmath356 the general solution of the inhomogeneous legendre equation ( [ eq : spheryl ] ) is @xmath357 \pi(\sigma ) , \ ] ] where @xmath77 and @xmath358 are integration constants and @xmath359 are solutions of the homogeneous legendre equation . for notational simplicity , evaluation of a function at @xmath334(@xmath327 ) will be denoted by the subscript @xmath360 . from eq . ( [ eq : u_1 ] ) one obtains @xmath361 from the other boundary condition ( [ eq : u_0 ] ) it follows that @xmath362 where we have defined the auxiliary function @xmath363 .\ ] ] finally , in order to impose the integral constraint ( [ eq : constraint ] ) we employ the following identities : @xmath364 \pi(\sigma ) = \\ \int_{\psi_0}^{\psi_1 } \!\!\!\ ! d\sigma \ , \sin \sigma \ ; \pi(\sigma ) \ ; \int_{\psi_0}^{\sigma } \!\!\!\ ! d\psi \ ; \sin \psi \ , [ p(\sigma ) q(\psi ) - p(\psi ) q(\sigma ) ] = \nonumber \\ \mbox { } - \int_{\psi_0}^{\psi_1 } \!\!\!\ ! d\sigma \ , \sin \sigma \ ; \pi(\sigma ) \ ; \frac{1}{2 } \left[1-\frac{w(\sigma)}{w_0}\right ] \;. \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] the first equality follows from interchanging the order of integration . the last equality follows most easily by noticing ( i ) that the @xmath325integral in the second line is , as a function of @xmath365 , a solution of the differential equation ( [ eq : spheryl ] ) with @xmath45 replaced by this integral , @xmath366 replaced by @xmath367 , @xmath368 , and the analogues of the boundary conditions @xmath369 , and ( ii ) that the function @xmath370 is the solution to the same differential equation with the same boundary conditions . with these identities eq . ( [ eq : constraint ] ) turns into @xmath371 \;,\ ] ] where we have introduced the numerical constants @xmath372 \nonumber \\ { \cal q } & : = & \int_{\psi_0}^{\psi_1 } \!\!\!\ ! d\psi \ , \sin \psi \ ; [ q(\psi ) - q_1 ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that the constants @xmath77 and @xmath358 are determined by the two linear eqs . ( [ eq : ab1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ab2 ] ) . these results permit us to study the intermediate asymptotic regime @xmath373 . in the expressions derived above , we have to take the limit @xmath259 while keeping fixed @xmath327 , @xmath374 and @xmath375 ( so that @xmath376 ) . in this limit , the constants @xmath377 and @xmath378 are finite , while @xmath379 and @xmath380 . the integral over @xmath94 in eq . ( [ eq : ab1 ] ) simplifies as follows ( provided that the stress field @xmath381 decays sufficiently fast ) : @xmath382 where we have used @xmath383 . the integrals over @xmath94 in eqs . ( [ eq : ab2 ] ) and ( [ eq : sol_drop ] ) can be simplified in the same manner . from eq . ( [ eq : ab1 ] ) we obtain @xmath384 and eq . ( [ eq : ab2 ] ) yields @xmath385 one finds indeed that the lagrange multiplier @xmath0 determined by eq . ( [ eq : mu ] ) is linear in @xmath386 . finally , the general solution ( [ eq : sol_drop ] ) simplifies to @xmath387 which renders eq . ( [ eq : sol3 ] ) with the constant @xmath388 } .\ ] ] this constant is finite and non vanishing provided @xmath327 is not close to @xmath265 . the case @xmath389 is pathological because @xmath390 for a smooth profile , so that the boundary condition ( [ eq : u_1 ] ) would overdetermine the problem . r. aveyard , b. p. binks , j. h. clint , p. d. i. fletcher , t. s. horozov , b. neumann , v. n. paunov , j. annesley , s. w. botchway , d. nees , a. w. parker , a. d. ward , and a. n. burgess , phys . lett . * 88 * , 246102 ( 2002 ) . Abstract:

Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered . Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video . Paper: ion pressure anisotropies are ubiquitous in heliospheric and astrophysical plasmas . in the absence of coulomb collisions , the magnetic moment of ions , @xmath4 ( @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the ion velocity perpendicular to the local magnetic field @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) is an adiabatic invariant . thus , if ion collisions are infrequent , the ion velocity distributions parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field decouple , making @xmath9 ( where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the pressure components of ions perpendicular and parallel to @xmath7 ) . examples of systems where ion pressure anisotropies are important are low - luminosity accretion disks around compact objects @xcite , the intracluster medium ( icm ) @xcite , and the heliosphere ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in these systems the ion pressure anisotropy is expected to play a key role in the large scale dynamics of the plasma . for instance , @xcite pointed out that pressure anisotropies can give rise to an anisotropic stress that can contribute to angular momentum transport and plasma heating in low - luminosity accretion disks . this physics is not included in standard mhd models of accretion disks . velocity space instabilities limit the growth of the pressure anisotropy and give rise to small scale fluctuations in the magnetic field . these fluctuations can , in turn , affect the large scale transport properties of the plasma by modifying the mean free path of particles . magnetic field amplification in a collisionless system generically drives @xmath12 . there are two ion - scale instabilities that can be excited in this regime : the mirror and the ion - cyclotron ( ic ) instabilities @xcite . the mirror instability consists of non - propagating , strongly compressional modes . their fastest growing wave vectors @xmath13 are oblique to @xmath7 , with the magnetic variations parallel to @xmath7 being much larger than the perpendicular fluctuations , @xmath14 . for a bi - maxwellian distribution of ions , and assuming cold electrons , the threshold condition for mirror instability growth is given by @xmath15 , where @xmath16 ( @xmath17 ) is the ion temperature perpendicular ( parallel ) to @xmath7 , and @xmath18 @xcite . the ic instability , on the other hand , consists of transverse electromagnetic waves , with the fastest growing @xmath13 being preferentially parallel to @xmath7 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? whether the ic or mirror instability sets in first depends on how fast these instabilities grow for a given set of plasma conditions . @xcite showed that for @xmath19 , the growth rate of the ic instability is @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the cyclotron frequency of the ions . in addition , for @xmath22 , the threshold anisotropy depends very weakly on @xmath23 . in the linear regime , the dominant instability will be determined by which threshold is reached first as @xmath7 is amplified . these estimates for the threshold conditions imply that , in the linear regime , the ic instability should dominate for @xmath24 , while the mirror instability should dominate for @xmath25 . although both the mirror and ic instabilities have been extensively studied in the linear regime , a complete theory of their nonlinear evolution and saturation is still lacking . in this paper , we are particularly interested in the question of how the mirror and ic modes behave after the initial phase of exponential growth . indeed , in most astrophysical scenarios where the magnetic field is amplified , the growth of the field occurs on time scales much longer than the growth time of the relevant kinetic instabilities . therefore , most of the evolution of the velocity space instabilities happens in a nonlinear regime , where the conditions typically assumed in linear studies , such as a homogeneous plasma or a bi - maxwellian distribution of particle velocities , are not necessarily satisfied . moreover , if the field is amplified by order unity or more , a quasi - linear analysis is not applicable . one of the key questions we are interested in addressing in this case is whether the mirror instability saturates via pitch - angle scattering that violates magnetic moment conservation @xcite or via a nearly @xmath4-conserving rearrangement of the magnetic field , with fluctuations @xmath26 @xcite . we shall see that both of these saturation processes can in fact be important . the nonlinear regime of the ic and mirror instabilities has been studied both theoretically ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) and numerically @xcite . in most numerical studies , however , the pressure anisotropy is treated as an initial condition , which decreases as the instabilities grow and saturate . thus , in these approaches the nonlinear saturation can not be followed for a time much longer than that of the initial exponential growth . moreover , many of the previous numerical studies have focused on one - dimensional simulations . in this paper we study the long term , nonlinear evolution of the mirror and ic instabilities using two - dimensional particle - in - cell ( pic ) simulations in driven systems . in order to self - consistently explore a time much longer than the initial exponential growth , we continuously induce the growth of @xmath27 by amplifying the mean field @xmath28 during the simulation . we concentrate on amplification by incompressible plasma motions . thus , our simulations impose a shear velocity on the plasma , which sustains the growth of the magnetic field and maintains an overall positive pressure anisotropy . this growth is intended to mimic magnetic field fluctuations in a turbulent plasma and mhd - scale instabilities that amplify the magnetic field , like the magnetorotational instability ( mri ; * ? ? ? * ) or convective instabilities driven by anisotropic thermal conduction in dilute plasmas @xcite . we suspect that our results are also relevant to cases in which perpendicular heating or parallel cooling drives a plasma mirror and/or ic unstable , as in , e.g. , the solar wind . @xcite conducted an analogous study to ours using hybrid simulations . in their study , expansion of the simulation box decreased the mean magnetic field , so that on average @xmath29 . this in turn led to the growth and nonlinear saturation of the firehose instability . also , @xcite conducted a similar hybrid simulation study where the simulation box is expanded along the directions parallel and perpendicular to @xmath7 . with this setup , @xmath10 becomes larger than @xmath11 on average , and both the mirror and ic instabilities can grow and reach saturation . our work is complementary to these hybrid simulation studies and focuses on the process in which the condition @xmath12 is achieved by field amplification due to shearing plasmas . we also consider higher values of @xmath30 @xmath31 , relevant to accretion disks , the icm , and the near - earth solar wind . our calculations are less directly applicable to heliospheric measurements of mirror modes driven unstable by rapid heating through the earth s bow shock ( e.g. , * ? ? ? this is because we assume that the pressure anisotropy is generated on a timescale long compared to the ion cyclotron timescale , which is probably not true at collisionless shocks . our paper is organized as follows . in [ sec : numsetup ] we describe the simulation set up , emphasizing the key physical and numerical parameters . [ sec : results ] shows our results and [ sec : conclu ] presents our conclusions . throughout the paper we compare some of our simulation results with linear theory predictions appropriate to our pic simulations . these have artificially low ion to electron mass ratios ( @xmath32 . the linear theory results are based on the linear vlasov solver developed in @xcite . during the completion of this work , @xcite presented calculations of firehose and mirror saturation in shearing plasmas with very similar results to those that we present here . we use the electromagnetic , relativistic pic code tristan - mp @xcite in two dimensions . the simulation box consists of a square box in the @xmath33 plane , containing plasma with a homogeneous magnetic field @xmath34 initially pointing along the @xmath35 axis . since we want to simulate a magnetic field that is being amplified in an incompressible way , we impose a shear motion of the plasma so that the mean particle velocity is @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is a shear parameter with units of frequency and @xmath38 is the distance along @xmath35 . from flux conservation , the @xmath39-component of the mean field evolves as @xmath40 , implying a net growth of @xmath41 . although we present simulations resolving the @xmath33 plane only , we also tried runs where the @xmath42 plane was resolved . in those cases the isotropization efficiency was substantially lower this is because , if the @xmath42 plane is resolved , the growing component of @xmath7 is perpendicular to the plane of the simulation . this way the angle between the relevant wave vectors , @xmath13 , and @xmath7 can not be 0 . this over - constrains the wave vectors that are allowed to exist , artificially reducing the isotropization efficiency . an important physical parameter in our simulations will be the ratio of the initial ion cyclotron frequency to the shear frequency , @xmath43 . we refer to this as the magnetization . in typical astrophysical environments @xmath44 . due to computational constraints , however , we will use values of @xmath43 much smaller than expected in reality , although still satisfying @xmath45 . the dependence of our results on the ratio @xmath43 will be carefully assessed . ccccccccc beta6mag93 & 1 & 6 & - & 93 & 0.05 & 14 & 30 & 12 + beta6mag670a & 1 & 6 & - & 670 & 0.15 & 14 & 10 & 18 + beta6mag670b & 1 & 6 & - & 670 & 0.15 & 14 & 10 & 24 + beta20mag93a & 1 & 20 & - & 93 & 0.05 & 10 & 60 & 35 + beta20mag93b & 1 & 20 & - & 93 & 0.05 & 10 & 30 & 35 + beta20mag670a & 1 & 20 & - & 670 & 0.05 & 7 & 30 & 36 + beta20mag670b & 1 & 20 & - & 670 & 0.05 & 7 & 30 & 48 + beta20mag2000 & 1 & 20 & - & 2000 & 0.05 & 7 & 50 & 55 + beta80mag670 & 1 & 80 & - & 670 & 0.05 & 5 & 30 & 24 + beta80mag1340 & 1 & 80 & - & 1340 & 0.05 & 5 & 30 & 24 + betai20magi240mass10 & 10 & - & 20 & 240 & 0.05 & 5 & 20 & 25 [ table:1d ] in standard mhd simulations where shear plasma motions are imposed , shearing periodic boundary conditions would be used along the @xmath38 direction ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? in that case , the flow velocities at the @xmath38-boundaries of the box are matched using galilean transformations of the fluid velocity . in the case of relativistic pic simulations this can not be done in a self - consistent way . the reason is that , under a relativistic change of reference frame , the current @xmath46 transforms in a way that is inconsistent with simply transforming the particle velocities . we instead implement _ shearing coordinates _ , in which the grid moves with the shearing velocity @xmath47 . in this new frame the average plasma velocity vanishes everywhere in the box and simple periodic boundary conditions are allowed both in the @xmath38 and @xmath39 axes . in these shearing coordinates , maxwell s equations gain additional terms ( see appendix a of * ? ? ? * ) , becoming @xmath48 @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the speed of light , and @xmath51 is the electric field . in addition to the modifications to maxwell s equations , the forces on the particles also acquire an extra term : @xmath52 where @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 are the particle s momentum , velocity , and charge , respectively . the third term on the right hand side of equation [ eq : ind ] and the fourth term on the right hand side of equation [ eq : amp ] are proportional to time and arise from the motion of the shearing coordinate grid points with respect to those of the non - shearing coordinates . indeed , as time goes on , the @xmath38 axis of the shearing coordinates is gradually tilted ( as seen from the non - shearing frame ) ; therefore the @xmath56derivatives of the fields ( @xmath57 ) in the shearing coordinates must include a time dependent term that accounts for the evolution of the @xmath38 axis . the last terms in equations [ eq : ind ] and [ eq : amp ] , which are proportional to the coordinate @xmath39 , will be neglected for the following reasons . in our simulations the box size will typically be a few times the larmor radius of the ions , @xmath58 . thus , @xmath59 ( where @xmath60 is the thermal velocity of the ions ) , which is much smaller than unity since we are interested in the regime @xmath61 and @xmath62 . as a result , the last term in equation [ eq : ind ] will be much smaller than the term on the left hand side , especially since @xmath63 . the last term of equation [ eq : amp ] , on the other hand , is not necessarily much smaller than the displacement current ( left hand side term ) , mainly because we expect @xmath64 . however , if the characteristic timescale for the mirror and ic modes is close to @xmath65 ( below we will check that this is indeed the case ) , the last term in equation [ eq : amp ] will be much smaller than the first term on the right hand side ( the ratio between these terms scales as @xmath66 ) , so we choose to neglect it in the limit @xmath67 . the fact that the neglected term can still be comparable to the displacement current implies that we may be excluding a relevant contribution to the charge density in gauss law . however , the physics of interest in this paper is non - relativistic and charge separation does not play a role . as a result , @xmath68 ( equivalent to @xmath69 in the _ non - shearing _ coordinate system ) . neglecting the terms proportional to @xmath39 is also required by the periodic boundary conditions in the y - direction . the existence of these terms at all is a consequence of the incompatibility of the galilean invariance of the shearing box and the lorentz invariance of the pic calculations . for consistency we will also neglect the term @xmath70 in equation [ eq : amp ] , which is also comparable to the displacement current ( in the case where @xmath51 evolves on a timescale close to @xmath65 ) can be integrated using simple time and space interpolations of @xmath71 . this way , after this modification is implemented , the numerical algorithm used by tristan - mp continues to be second order accurate in time and space . ] our set of simulations are summarized in table 1 . the physical setup is defined by the magnetization parameter , @xmath43 ( the ratio of the initial cyclotron frequency to the shear rate ) , the ratio between the initial particle and magnetic pressures , @xmath72 , the mass ratio between ions and electrons , @xmath73 , and the initial alfvn velocity of the plasma @xmath74 , relative to the speed of light @xmath50 , where @xmath75 and @xmath76 is the mass density . the numerical parameters of our runs are defined by the spatial resolution ( @xmath77 ) , box size relative to the ion larmor radius ( @xmath78 ) , and number of particles per cell ( @xmath79 ) , where @xmath80 is the plasma frequency of the electrons and @xmath81 is the spacial separation of the grid points . the simulations shown in this paper are described in table 1 . these simulations are a subset of a higher number of runs , where we used different combinations of numerical and physical parameters , which confirmed numerical convergence . we want to explore the regime @xmath82 . in order to do so , most of our runs use the mass ratio @xmath83 . since for @xmath83 both species will be essentially indistinguishable , we initially give ions and electrons maxwellian energy distributions with the same temperature , and use the parameters @xmath84 and @xmath85 to quantify the pressure of the plasma perpendicular and parallel to @xmath7 . simulations with @xmath83 of course do not allow us to study the physics of electron isotropization . however , in [ sec : compmime ] we use an example of our @xmath86 runs to show that @xmath83 calculations reproduce the ion - related phenomena fairly well , with @xmath87 and @xmath88 playing the same role of @xmath89 and @xmath90 in the @xmath86 runs . we defer a detailed study of electron scale pressure isotropization to future work . we divide our runs into cases with three different initial betas : @xmath91 , 20 , and 80 . our analysis focuses on the nonlinear structure of the ic / mirror generated fluctuations , the evolution of the pressure anisotropy @xmath92 , and the conservation of the ion magnetic moment . runs . panels @xmath93 and @xmath94 show the evolution of @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ; solid ) and @xmath97 ( @xmath98 ; dotted ) for runs beta6mag93 and beta6mag670a , respectively ( @xmath99 and @xmath100 correspond to black , red , and green , respectively ) . for the same runs , panels @xmath50 and @xmath101 show @xmath102 ( @xmath103 ; black - solid ) , compared with the linear mirror and ic thresholds ( @xmath104 and @xmath105 , in red and green , respectively ) for pair plasma and growth rates @xmath106 and @xmath107 , respectively . panels @xmath108 and @xmath109 show @xmath110 and @xmath111 , where the subscripts @xmath112 and @xmath113 denote the components parallel and perpendicular to @xmath28 , respectively . after the plasma pressure anisotropy exceeds the mirror and ic thresholds , there is an initial phase of exponential growth followed by a secular phase . the pressure anisotropy initially grows but saturates at the linear threshold for the mirror / ic instabilities.,width=340 ] runs with @xmath114 and @xmath115 ( beta6mag93 and beta6mag670a in table [ table:1d ] ) . we show the evolution of the true average magnetic moment @xmath116 @xmath117 ( black line ) and an effective global magnetic moment , @xmath118 @xmath119 ( red line ) , where the subscript @xmath120 denotes an average over all particles . the ion magnetic moment @xmath116 is conserved until @xmath121 , at which point it decreases on the same timescale as the mean magnetic field ( see fig . [ fig : muderivs ] ) . the close similarity between @xmath116 and @xmath118 shows that there are not strong correlations between the particle velocity @xmath122 and magnetic field @xmath123 ; such correlations are more prominent at higher @xmath124 where the ic instability is subdominant ( see fig . [ fig : mubeta20]).,width=340 ] , for different @xmath124 , compared to the growth rate of the mean magnetic field @xmath125 ( black line ; this quantity is the same for the different @xmath124 runs ) . @xmath126 is shown for our simulations with @xmath127 and 80 ( beta6mag670a , beta20mag670a , and beta80mag1340 , respectively ) . the vertical - dotted lines mark the beginning of the saturated state for each run based on when the growth of the fluctuations becomes roughly secular . in the saturated state , the magnetic moment changes on a timescale comparable to that of the mean magnetic field ( to within @xmath128 ) . at earlier times , however , the magnetic moment is reasonably well conserved.,width=283 ] as discussed above , the expectation is that the ic instability should play an important role in the @xmath91 case , and it should become significantly less important in the @xmath129 and 80 cases . the contributions from the ic and mirror modes can be seen from figure [ fig : fieldsbeta6 ] . this figure shows 2d images of the field fluctuations @xmath130 ( @xmath131 ; @xmath132 stands for volume average " ) and the plasma density fluctuations @xmath133 for run beta6mag670@xmath50 ( @xmath134 " stands for the component @xmath38 , @xmath39 , or @xmath100 of @xmath135 ) at two different times : @xmath136 ( upper panels ) and @xmath137 ( lower panels ) . we can see that at the earlier time ( @xmath136 ) the three components of @xmath135 have about the same amplitude ( see figures [ fig : fieldsbeta6]@xmath93 , [ fig : fieldsbeta6]@xmath94 , and [ fig : fieldsbeta6]@xmath50 ) , but appear to be dominated by different mode orientations , indicating the simultaneous presence of ic and mirror modes . the mirror modes are expected to have @xmath135 mainly in the plane of the simulation ( the plane of @xmath13 and @xmath28 ; * ? ? ? on the other hand , the ic modes have the three components of @xmath135 of comparable magnitude , so their presence can be most clearly revealed by @xmath138 ( figure [ fig : fieldsbeta6]@xmath50 ) . indeed , while @xmath139 and @xmath140 are dominated by a combination of oblique ( mirror ) and quasi - parallel ( ic ) modes , @xmath138 appears to be dominated by only quasi - parallel modes . thus , initially the mirror and ic instabilities contribute comparably to @xmath135 . at the later time ( @xmath137 ) , however , the fluctuations become dominated by an oblique wave vector , with the ic instability playing a subdominant role . the density fluctuations at all times are @xmath141 , and seem to correlate primarily with the mirror modes . the relative contribution of the mirror and ic instabilities can also be seen from figure [ fig : beta6 ] , which shows the time evolution of different volume - averaged quantities for runs with @xmath142 ( first column ; run beta6mag93@xmath93 ) and @xmath143 ( second column ; run beta6mag670@xmath93 ) . in figures [ fig : beta6]@xmath93 and [ fig : beta6]@xmath94 we plot @xmath95 for the two magnetizations . in both cases there is an initially exponential growth of @xmath144 until @xmath145 . both instabilities have about the same growth rates , which are @xmath146 . note that the dominant growth rate of the mirror / ic modes is nearly the same in the two simulations with different values of @xmath21 . the growth rate is thus set by the background shear rate @xmath37 instead of @xmath21 . this can be understood by noting that the smaller growth rate modes have a smaller anisotropy threshold . therefore , as @xmath123 and @xmath147 grow , modes with smaller growth rate will begin to grow first . this implies that the dominant modes will be those that can reach a significant amplitude to stop the growth of @xmath147 on the shear timescale @xmath65 . after the exponential phase , the growth becomes dominated by the mirror modes and is secular ( as predicted by * ? ? ? this transition from exponential to secular is clearly seen at @xmath148 for @xmath149 in figure [ fig : beta6 ] . despite the similar exponential growth rate for the mirror and ic instabilities in the linear regime , the mirror modes are more robust and dominate in the nonlinear regime . this dominance of the mirror modes is remarkable because it occurs even for @xmath24 , where the linear analysis predicts an important contribution of the ic instability ( in the nonlinear regime the mean magnetic energy has been amplified by about one order of magnitude , so that @xmath24 ) . we suggest below ( fig . [ fig : spectrabeta6 ] ) that departure from the bi - maxwellian energy distribution assumed in the linear instability analysis is likely playing an important role in this sub - dominance of the ic instability . run beta6mag670a at two different times . _ top : _ energy spectra as a function of the energies perpendicular and parallel to the magnetic field , @xmath150 ( black - dotted line ) and @xmath151 ( black - solid line ) . _ bottom : _ energy spectra as a function of @xmath152 . bi - maxwellian fits are shown in red . there is a clear deviation from the bi - maxwellian at the highest energies , which grows in time . there is , however , little deviation from a maxwellian at @xmath153 , in contrast to some of the 1d runs discussed in the appendix . comparison with figure [ fig : spectrabeta20 ] suggests that the high energy deviation from maxwellian is due to the ic instability , since it is less prominent at higher @xmath154 when the ic instability is sub - dominant.,width=340 ] one difference in the evolution of @xmath135 for the two different magnetizations is that the end of the exponential phase occurs at somewhat higher amplitude in the @xmath142 case . this difference implies that , for smaller values of @xmath43 , the mirror and ic fluctuations are less efficient in suppressing the pressure anisotropy , requiring larger values of @xmath144 . at the end of this section , we will explain in further detail this dependence of @xmath144 on magnetization by focusing on the mechanism by which the isotropization occurs . one consequence of the difference in @xmath144 is that the lower magnetization runs take longer to reach the point when @xmath102 ( @xmath103 ) saturates . thus in the @xmath142 run the anisotropy @xmath102 has more time to grow , reaching larger values before saturating . this can be seen in the evolution of @xmath102 , shown in black lines in figures [ fig : beta6]@xmath50 and [ fig : beta6]@xmath101 for runs beta6mag93@xmath93 and beta6mag670@xmath93 , respectively . for both magnetizations , there is an initial overshoot in @xmath102 , whose amplitude is larger for the @xmath142 run . after the overshoot , @xmath102 evolves in a similar way for both magnetizations . since in the nonlinear regime @xmath135 is dominated by mirror modes , after the saturation one would expect the pressure anisotropies to behave according to the marginal stability conditions of the mirror instability . since in our simulations both the ic and mirror modes grow at @xmath155 , we calculated the ic and mirror thresholds for equivalent growth rates in the pair plasma case with magnetizations @xmath142 and @xmath143 . thus , figures [ fig : beta6]@xmath50 and [ fig : beta6]@xmath101 show that the threshold for mirror ( red ) and ic instability ( green ) in the cases @xmath156 and @xmath157 , respectively . we see that the mirror threshold coincides fairly well with the saturated @xmath102 for both magnetizations . these results imply that the linear marginal stability condition for the mirror instability is fairly accurate in determining @xmath102 in the nonlinear regime . in realistic astrophysical setups , where @xmath21 can be many orders of magnitude larger than @xmath37 , the expectation is that @xmath102 will follow the @xmath158 mirror threshold , given by @xmath159 . this differs from the results shown in figure [ fig : beta6 ] , which are only appropriate for pair plasmas and modest magnetization . ( red ) for @xmath160 and @xmath149 ( run beta6mag670a ) . the good agreement between the two results implies that the anisotropic stress coupling to the background shear is the primary mechanism for particle heating.,width=283 ] as discussed in the introduction , it is not known whether the mirror instability saturates via pitch - angle scattering ( see , for instance , * ? ? ? * ) or whether it cancels the appearance of a pressure anisotropy by substantially modifying the structure of the magnetic field @xcite . in the latter case @xmath135 should grow secularly until @xmath161 , with the breaking of @xmath162invariance not necessary for the regulation of @xmath163 . figures [ fig : beta6]@xmath108 and [ fig : beta6]@xmath109 show the evolution of @xmath111 and @xmath110 for @xmath114 and @xmath115 , respectively , where @xmath164 and @xmath165 refer to the magnetic field component perpendicular and parallel to the mean field @xmath28 . we see that @xmath166 @xmath167 dominates in the nonlinear regime , as expected from the larger amplitude of the oblique mirror modes , and @xmath168 the saturation amplitude is @xmath169 , which favors the scenario where the non - conservation of @xmath116 is the key mechanism for the isotropization of the plasma pressure , at least if the background field has been amplified significantly . to quantify the time variation of the average ion magnetic moment we define @xmath170 where @xmath171 stands for average over all the particles . @xmath116 corresponds to the actual average of the magnetic moment . thus if a nearly @xmath162conserving process dominates the mirror saturation , @xmath116 should remain fairly constant . @xmath118 , on the other hand , can be thought as an _ effective _ global magnetic moment that ignores the fluctuations in @xmath172 or the correlation between @xmath122 and @xmath123 due to particles collecting in mirrors . @xmath118 necessarily decreases since the mirror and ic instabilities suppress the growth that @xmath173 would have if the particles were only affected by the mean field @xmath28 . thus , if @xmath116 is nearly conserved , @xmath116 and @xmath118 should evolve quite differently , with @xmath174 . on the other hand , if there is significant pitch angle scattering @xmath175 and both should decrease on the same timescale that @xmath176 increases . figures [ fig : beta6b]@xmath93 and [ fig : beta6b]@xmath94 show @xmath116 and @xmath118 for our @xmath160 runs with magnetizations @xmath142 and @xmath143 , respectively . we see that for both magnetizations the difference between @xmath116 and @xmath118 is very small ( only @xmath177 a few @xmath178 difference ) . this implies that there is little spatial correlation between @xmath122 and @xmath123 . we shall see below that @xmath116 and @xmath118 differ somewhat more at higher @xmath154 where the mirror instability dominates over the ic instability . figure [ fig : muderivs ] compares the rate of change of the ion magnetic moment with that of the mean magnetic field for runs with @xmath1796 , 20 , and 80 . this comparison is important since it is the evolution of the mean field that is driving the velocity space instabilities in our calculations . if the total thermal energy varies on a timescale long compared to the mean magnetic field , maintaining marginal stability to the mirror instability via pitch - angle scattering implies @xmath180 $ ] . the term @xmath181 is exactly @xmath182 for the canonical high magnetization mirror instability threshold but is somewhat different in our pair plasma , modest magnetization simulations ( hence the use of @xmath183 ) . this expression for @xmath184 implies that pitch - angle scattering should lead to the magnetic moment varying at a rate slightly less than that of the mean magnetic field . this is consistent with our numerical results in figure [ fig : muderivs ] in the saturated state where the magnetic field grows secularly in time . at earlier times , when the magnetic field fluctuations due to the mirror and ic instability are smaller , @xmath116 is approximately conserved even though the mirror and ic are present and grow exponentially . in particular , there is a temporal lag of @xmath185 between the onset of the exponential growth of the mirror and ic instabilities and the onset of pitch angle scattering that decreases @xmath116 . our interpretation of this result is that the mirror / ic fluctuations must reach a sufficient amplitude , roughly @xmath186 , in order for pitch angle scattering to be effective . for the mirror instability , this violation of @xmath116 conservation by finite amplitude fluctuations is likely due to the stochasticity of particle orbits that sets in for large amplitude ( albeit low frequency ) fluctuations ( e.g. , @xcite ) . for the ion cyclotron instability , the need for finite amplitudes before significant scattering sets in is a consequence of the well - known result that the scattering rate for cyclotron - frequency fluctuations is @xmath187 . the breaking of local @xmath116-invariance for this calculation ( @xmath87 , @xmath188 ) might be affected by the subdominant ( but still significant ) contribution of the ic modes to the magnetic fluctuations . however , figure [ fig : muderivs ] shows that the magnetic moment varies at the same rate as the mean magnetic field for all of the @xmath124 we have simulated . we will discuss the higher @xmath124 results in more detail in the next two subsections . at @xmath189 for @xmath190 and magnetization @xmath114 ( panel @xmath93 ; run beta20mag93b ) and @xmath149 ( panel @xmath94 ; run beta20mag670b ) . panels @xmath50 and @xmath101 show the same quantities at @xmath191 . the black arrows show the direction of @xmath28 . the higher magnetization run produces mirror modes whose wavevectors are more perpendicular to @xmath28 and with longer wavelengths . a migration to larger wavelengths in time can also be seen.,width=340 ] an interesting question is whether the non - linear evolution of the velocity space instabilities makes the energy distribution of the particles substantially different from a bi - maxwellian spectrum . this question is particularly relevant in terms of understanding the suppression of the ic modes in the nonlinear regime as @xmath87 goes from 6 to @xmath192 . indeed , it has been shown@xcite that a significant departure from a bi - maxwellian distribution can increase the anisotropy threshold for the growth of the ic modes and that a change of this kind is expected given the resonant character of the ic instability . figure [ fig : spectrabeta6 ] shows that the particle spectrum does differ somewhat from a bi - maxwellian for our @xmath160 run , mainly due to a significant excess of particles at the highest energies . in future work , we will study whether or not the spectral variation in figure [ fig : spectrabeta6 ] can completely account for the decrease in the amplitude of the ic modes in the saturated state . figure [ fig : spectrabeta6 ] also shows that the ion velocity distribution does not deviate significantly from a bi - maxwellian at low @xmath152 , as has been found in some 1d studies of the saturation of the mirror instability ( e.g. , @xcite ) . we discuss this in more detail in the appendix . finally , figure [ fig : anistress ] shows the evolution of the total heating rate of the particles as a function of time ( black line ) . for comparison , in the red line we plot the particle heating rate by the anisotropic stress , @xmath193 @xcite . we see a reasonable agreement between the two results , implying that the anisotropic stress plays the dominant role in particle heating . other mechanisms , like wave - particle interaction , must play a secondary role in the total particle energization . this is true for all of the @xmath124 we have simulated . we now consider a somewhat weaker magnetic field case with @xmath129 . in this case , the field fluctuations are dominated by the mirror instability at all times . this can be seen in figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath93-@xmath50 which show the evolution of the three components of @xmath194 for @xmath190 runs with magnetizations @xmath43=93 , 670 , and 2000 , respectively ( runs beta20mag93@xmath93 , beta20mag670@xmath93 and beta20mag2000@xmath93 in table 1 ) . in all three cases @xmath195 is small compared to @xmath194 , showing the subdominant role of the ic instability . figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath93-@xmath50 also show the characteristic transition between exponential growth ( with @xmath196 ) and secular growth ( with @xmath197 ) for the mirror modes . as in the @xmath91 case , the transition between the exponential and secular regimes occurs at smaller amplitudes and in a smoother way in the more strongly magnetized runs . figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath101-@xmath109 also show that , as in the case of @xmath91 , after the overshoot the pressure anisotropy follows the marginal stability condition for the mirror modes reasonably well , particularly at higher magnetization . figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath198-@xmath199 show @xmath200 and @xmath201 as a function of time . while @xmath200 is about the same for the three magnetizations , @xmath201 is significantly smaller in the higher magnetization runs . the relative magnitude of @xmath202 and @xmath203 is a measure of the orientation of the mirror s dominant wave vector , @xmath13 , with respect to @xmath28 : a large @xmath204 ratio implies that @xmath13 and @xmath28 are nearly perpendicular . the results of figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath198-@xmath199 imply that for larger magnetization , @xmath13 and @xmath28 are more perpendicular , which is consistent with linear calculations @xcite . and @xmath94 show the evolution of the ion magnetic moment @xmath116 for @xmath190 runs with @xmath114 ( beta20mag93a ; panel @xmath93 ) and @xmath149 and @xmath205 ( beta20mag670a and beta20mag2000 ; panel @xmath94 ) . panels @xmath50 and @xmath101 compare the corresponding rate of change of @xmath116 with that of the mean magnetic field for runs beta20mag93a and beta20mag670a , respectively . all plots show the evolution of the true average magnetic moment @xmath116 @xmath117 ( black line ) and an effective global magnetic moment , @xmath118 @xmath119 ( red line ) , where the subscript @xmath120 denotes an average over all particles . the magnetic moment begins to decrease when the fluctuations reach @xmath206 ( see fig . [ fig : beta20b2s ] ) . the difference between @xmath116 and @xmath118 is more significant than for @xmath160 ( cf fig . [ fig : beta6b ] ) . this is a consequence of particles bunching in mirrors , which leads to a correlation between @xmath122 and @xmath123 . nonetheless , the ion magnetic moment changes at about the same rate as the background magnetic field after saturation at @xmath207 , indicating that pitch angle scattering regulates the nonlinear saturation on sufficiently long timescales.,width=340 ] the orientation of the modes in the nonlinear stage can also be seen directly in figure [ fig : fieldsbeta20 ] , which shows the spatial distribution of @xmath208 at two different times for the runs with @xmath142 and @xmath143 . figures [ fig : fieldsbeta20]@xmath93 and [ fig : fieldsbeta20]@xmath94 correspond to the time @xmath136 , while figures [ fig : fieldsbeta20]@xmath50 and [ fig : fieldsbeta20]@xmath101 correspond to @xmath137 . for each magnetization , the mirror fluctuations are dominated by two modes that are symmetric with respect to the magnetic field , and that are more oblique at higher magnetization . note also that the wavelength of the dominant modes ( in units of the larmor radius of the particles , @xmath58 ) is larger for larger magnetization and that the modes tend to grow in wavelength as time goes on . figure [ fig : mubeta20 ] shows the evolution of the ion magnetic moment @xmath116 and the rate of change of @xmath116 relative to that of the mean magnetic field for our @xmath190 calculations . a comparison of figures [ fig : mubeta20 ] & [ fig : beta20b2s ] shows that the magnetic moment is reasonably conserved until the magnetic fluctuation amplitude is close to ( though somewhat less than ) its saturated value . as in our @xmath160 calculations , this implies that there is a time lag of @xmath209 between the onset of the mirror instability and the onset of significant pitch - angle scattering ( and its associated decrease in @xmath116 ) . note , however , that for @xmath129 the saturated amplitude of the fluctuations in the secular regime , @xmath210 , is larger than in the @xmath91 case , for which @xmath211 . this implies that when _ only _ the mirror instability plays a significant role , a somewhat larger fluctuation amplitude is necessary for efficient pitch - angle scattering . we will see below that @xmath210 continues even for @xmath212 ; the saturated amplitude of the mirror modes is thus fairly independent of the beta of the plasma as long as the ic instability is not significant ( @xmath213 6 ) . figure [ fig : mubeta20 ] also shows that for @xmath190 , the true ion magnetic moment @xmath116 decreases somewhat more slowly than the effective global magnetic moment @xmath118 ( by @xmath214 ) . this was not seen in our @xmath160 calculations ( figs . [ fig : beta6b ] ) . the modest difference between @xmath116 and @xmath118 indicates that the nonlinear saturation of the mirror instability involves correlations between @xmath122 and @xmath123 , i.e. , particles bunching in mirrors . this effect is independent of magnetization , as can be seen from the solid and dotted lines in figure [ fig : mubeta20]@xmath94 ( corresponding to @xmath215 670 and 2000 , respectively ) . run beta20mag670a at two different times during the nonlinear regime . _ top : _ energy spectra as a function of the energies perpendicular and parallel to the magnetic field , @xmath150 ( black - dotted line ) and @xmath151 ( black - solid line ) . _ bottom : _ energy spectra as a function of @xmath152 . in all cases , a bi - maxwellian energy spectrum ( red ) provides a good approximation to the numerical simulations.,width=340 ] figure [ fig : spectrabeta20 ] shows that the particle energy spectrum stays fairly close to bi - maxwellian in our @xmath190 runs , regardless of the magnetization . since these simulations are almost purely mirror dominated , this suggests that the mirror modes provide rather momentum - independent pitch - angle scattering to the particles . as a result , it is likely that ic modes produce the deviations from a bi - maxwellian distribution seen in figure [ fig : spectrabeta6 ] . figure [ fig : spectrabeta20 ] also shows that the parallel velocity spectrum @xmath216 remains nearly maxwellian during most of the saturated regime ( with only a transient @xmath217 decrease for @xmath218 especially at the end of the exponential growth regime ) . the lack of significant flattening of @xmath216 ( which contrasts with the prediction of * ? ? ? * ) is analyzed in further detail in the appendix . for @xmath212 we focus on simulations with @xmath143 and 1340 , respectively ( runs beta80mag670 and beta80mag1340 in table 1 ) . the results are essentially the same as for the @xmath129 case so we do not discuss them in detail . figure [ fig : beta80b2s ] shows that the mirror instability dominates the fluctuations in @xmath7 . the evolution of the pressure anisotropy @xmath102 contains the initial overshoot followed by a rather flat behavior . the amplitude of the overshoot is controlled by the magnetization , while the subsequent evolution is fairly well described by the threshold condition for mirror modes . runs with @xmath149 ( beta80mag670 ; left column ) and @xmath219 ( beta80mag1340 ; right column ) . panels @xmath93 and @xmath94 show the evolution of @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ; solid ) and @xmath97 ( @xmath98 ; dotted ) , respectively ( @xmath99 and @xmath100 correspond to black , red , and green , respectively ) . for the same runs , panels @xmath50 and @xmath101 show @xmath102 ( @xmath103 ; black - solid ) , compared with the linear mirror threshold in red ( @xmath104 ) for a pair plasma and growth rates @xmath107 and @xmath220 , respectively . panels @xmath108 and @xmath109 show @xmath110 and @xmath111 . the results shown here are very similar to the analogous @xmath129 results in figure [ fig : beta20b2s ] , consistent with the dominance of the mirror instability at high @xmath154.,width=340 ] as in the @xmath129 case , the saturation @xmath221 is @xmath222 . figure [ fig : mubeta80 ] shows the evolution of the ion magnetic moment for the @xmath223 simulations . the evolutions of @xmath116 and @xmath224 are the same for the two magnetizations presented ( @xmath149 and @xmath219 ) , and show the same behavior seen in the @xmath129 case , which is discussed in detail in the previous subsection . and @xmath94 show the evolution of the ion magnetic moment @xmath116 for our @xmath223 runs with @xmath149 and @xmath219 ( runs beta80mag670 and beta80mag1340 , respectively ) . panels @xmath50 and @xmath101 compare the rate of change of @xmath116 with that of the mean magnetic field . in all panels , we show the evolution of the true average magnetic moment @xmath116 @xmath117 ( black line ) and an effective global magnetic moment , @xmath118 @xmath119 ( red line ) , where the subscript @xmath120 denotes an average over all particles . the magnetic moment begins to decrease when the fluctuations reach @xmath206 ( see fig . [ fig : beta80b2s ] ) . all of the key results here are very similar to the @xmath129 results shown in figure [ fig : mubeta20].,width=340 ] , @xmath225 , and @xmath226 ( run betai20magi240mass10 ) . the ion results here are similar to the corresponding @xmath227 results in figures [ fig : beta20b2s ] and [ fig : mubeta20 ] , indicating that the pair plasma results capture most of the key ion physics . panel @xmath93 shows the evolution of @xmath228 and @xmath229 , in solid and dotted lines , respectively . the small contribution of @xmath195 implies the dominance of mirror modes . panel @xmath94 shows the evolution of @xmath111 ( red ) and @xmath110 ( black ) with @xmath230 , implying that the mirror modes have @xmath231 . panel @xmath50 shows the evolution of the ion pressure anisotropy @xmath232 ( black - solid ) . the linear mirror threshold for mirror modes with @xmath233 in a @xmath234 , @xmath235 plasma is also shown ( red line ) along with the analogous threshold for @xmath236 for comparison ( red dotted line ) . panel @xmath101 shows the evolution of @xmath116 ( @xmath237 , black - solid ) and @xmath118 ( @xmath238 , red - solid ) ; see eq . [ eq : mu ] and associated text for details.,width=340 ] in this section we show that our use of @xmath83 in the previous sections does not have a significant effect on the evolution of the ion pressure anisotropy under the influence of the ic and mirror instabilities . in figure [ fig : beta20b2smime4 ] we present the results for a simulation with @xmath235 , @xmath225 , and @xmath226 ( run betai20magi240mass10c ) , which is analogous to the previous @xmath83 simulations that use @xmath239 . a comparison of figure [ fig : beta20b2smime4]@xmath93 with figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath93 , [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath94 , and [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath50 shows that for both mass ratios the evolution of @xmath135 is dominated by the mirror instability , with the initial exponential regime being followed by secular growth . figure [ fig : beta20b2smime4]@xmath94 shows the evolution of @xmath111 and @xmath110 . as in the @xmath83 case ( see figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath198 , [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath240 , and [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath199 ) , @xmath230 in the secular stage , implying that mirror modes with @xmath231 are dominant . the maximum amplitude of @xmath241 is also in good agreement with the @xmath83 simulations . the evolution of the ion pressure anisotropy @xmath232 is shown in figure [ fig : beta20b2smime4]@xmath50 . as in the @xmath83 runs ( see figures [ fig : beta20b2s]@xmath242 ) , @xmath243 follows the linear threshold of the mirror instability fairly closely . this is seen in figure [ fig : beta20b2smime4]@xmath50 , which shows the linear mirror threshold expected for modes with @xmath233 , @xmath225 , and @xmath235 and 1836 ( red and dotted - red lines , respectively ) . the small difference between our results and the @xmath235 and 1836 thresholds strongly suggests that the use of @xmath83 for most of our study captures reasonably well the key physics of the mirror and ic instabilities in a real electron - ion plasma . finally , figure [ fig : beta20b2smime4]@xmath101 shows the evolution of @xmath116 ( black solid line ) and @xmath118 ( red solid line ) . the results are quantitatively similar to the @xmath227 results in figures [ fig : mubeta20]@xmath93 and [ fig : mubeta20]@xmath94 . this shows that the role played by pitch - angle scattering in the saturation of the mirror instability is well captured by our @xmath83 simulations . we have used pic simulations to study the nonlinear , long - term evolution of ion velocity space instabilities in collisionless plasmas . we have focused on instabilities driven by pressure anisotropy with @xmath244 : the ion cyclotron ( ic ) and mirror instabilities . these instabilities are expected to arise when turbulence and/or mhd instabilities amplify @xmath7 , rendering @xmath244 due to conservation of the ion magnetic moment @xmath4 . alternatively , in the solar wind @xmath245 can increase due to perpendicular heating and/or parallel cooling of the plasma . in contrast to previous studies , we do not consider the initial value problem of the evolution of a given initial ion pressure anisotropy . instead , we self - consistently induce the growth of an ion pressure anisotropy by continuously amplifying the mean magnetic field in our computational domain . this setup allows us to study the long - term , saturated state of the plasma , rather than the ( much shorter ) initial , exponential stage . the former is of most interest for the heliospheric and astrophysical applications of our work . we have focused on the regime @xmath246 and plasma magnetizations @xmath43 in the range @xmath247 ( the magnetization is the ratio of the initial ion cyclotron frequency to the background shear frequency ) . most of our simulations used @xmath83 , but we showed that our results for the ion scale physics are fairly independent of the mass ratio ( see [ sec : compmime ] ) . so long as @xmath45 , our results are also relatively independent of the precise value of the magnetization ( see , in particular , figs . [ fig : beta20b2s ] & [ fig : mubeta20 ] ) . thus we believe that our basic conclusions about the saturation of the mirror and ic instabilities in continuously driven systems can be applied to physical problems where @xmath21 is many orders of magnitude larger than @xmath37 . our primary results are as follows : * for the @xmath246 regime we have studied , the turbulent fluctuations in the saturated state are dominated by mirror modes . this is despite the fact that ic and mirror instabilities are both present at early phases ( and have similar linear instability thresholds ) when @xmath248 a few . a plausible explanation for this dominance of the mirror instability in the saturated state even at @xmath249 a few is that the ion velocity distribution departs from a bi - maxwellian spectrum in the presence of the ic instability . this can in turn increase the threshold for the ic instability @xcite making it less important than the mirror instability in the nonlinear regime . we indeed see more significant departures from a bi - maxwellian in the low @xmath30 regime where the ic instability is present ( figs . [ fig : spectrabeta6 ] & [ fig : spectrabeta20 ] ) . by contrast , the ion distribution function remains relatively bi - maxwellian in the high @xmath30 regime in which the mirror instability dominates over the ic instability at all times ( fig . [ fig : spectrabeta20 ] ) . the dominance of the mirror instability at @xmath248 a few is consistent with the nonlinear study of @xcite , which makes use of hybrid simulations of an expanding box . * small - scale fluctuations driven by the mirror instability initially grow exponentially but saturate in a secular phase in which @xmath250 ( figures [ fig : beta6 ] & [ fig : beta20b2s ] ) . the fluctuations in the saturated state have @xmath231 ( see , e.g. , figure [ fig : fieldsbeta6 ] ) consistent with linear theory expectations for mirror modes . * the ion pressure anisotropy @xmath232 in the saturated state is reasonably well described by the marginal stability condition for the mirror instability ( e.g. , figs [ fig : beta6 ] & [ fig : beta20b2s ] ) . note , however , that the marginal stability state of the mirror mode in our simulations is not the same as in real systems because of the comparable ion and electron masses and the smaller @xmath43 used in our calculations . this is important to bear in mind when comparing our results to heliospheric measurements . * the total thermal energy of the plasma increases in time at the theoretically predicted rate given the background shear in the plasma and the anisotropic stress associated with the pressure anisotropy ( fig . [ fig : anistress ] ) . this is consistent with the idea that the `` viscous '' heating rate in a collisionless plasma is set by how velocity space instabilities regulate the pressure anisotropy @xcite . * when the growth time of the mirror instability is long compared to the ion cyclotron period as is the case in our simulations where the shear slowly amplifies the mean magnetic field the ion magnetic moment is initially reasonably well conserved . this is fundamentally because there is no mechanism to violate magnetic moment conservation during the linear phase of mirror growth . so the modes continue to grow to larger and larger amplitudes , given the sustained free energy source created by the background velocity shear amplifying the magnetic field and continuously generating pressure anisotropy . this regime lasts until @xmath3 and @xmath251 , and is consistent with the secular regime " found by @xcite where @xmath116 is nearly conserved . * saturation of the mirror modes starts to happen once the fluctuations attain @xmath3 . in this stage the variation in magnetic field on the scale of the larmor radius is sufficiently large that the ion magnetic moment is no longer conserved . this is consistent with theories of stochastic ion motion in large amplitude turbulent fluctuations ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? in this phase the ion magnetic moment changes on nearly the same timescale as the mean magnetic field ( fig . [ fig : muderivs ] ) , which is consistent with pitch angle scattering maintaining marginal stability . in this stage the magnetic fluctuations only experience a modest additional growth , reaching a maximum amplitude of @xmath252 . * the need for finite amplitude fluctuations with @xmath3 in order to stop magnetic moment conservation implies the existence of a the temporal delay of @xmath185 between the onset of the ic and mirror instabilities and the onset of efficient pitch angle scattering ( @xmath37 is the rate at which the mean magnetic field is growing ) . our results have a number of consequences for modeling the large scale dynamics of nearly collisionless astrophysical plasmas and for interpreting heliospheric measurements . we briefly mention a few of these applications but defer a more detailed analysis to future work . our results are consistent with a number of in situ heliospheric measurements . for instance , our maximum saturated value of @xmath253 is in reasonable agreement with mirror modes observations in different environments like planetary magnetosheaths ( where large amplitude mirror modes are frequently found . see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , the solar wind ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and the heliosheath ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? . corresponds to @xmath254 , where @xmath132 stands for volume average . this means that our results still allow for _ local _ magnetic fluctuations of even larger amplitude . it is also important to stress that if a plasma is rapidly driven to have a temperature anisotropy well in excess of the mirror threshold ( e.g. , at the earth s bow shock ; * ? ? ? * ) then the resulting amplitude of the mirror modes could significantly exceed what we find in our calculations . in this case , a standard initial value calculation of the mirror evolution is likely to better capture the resulting dynamics than our model in which the anisotropy slowly increases in time . ] our results also show that the dominant wavelength is initially close to a few ion larmor radii , with a subsequent migration to longer wavelengths through a coalescence process . this wavelength growth is consistent with observations ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) and with theoretical models that predict the growth of mirror mode wavelengths due to magnetic diffusion @xcite . the fact that our @xmath255 calculations find that the mirror instability dominates the nonlinear state of the fluctuations ( even though the ic and mirror instabilities have comparable linear thresholds and growth rates for a bi - maxwellian distribution ) is also consistent with heliospheric observations . in particular , solar wind measurements at @xmath256 show that @xmath257 is limited by the linear threshold of the mirror instability ( instead of the ic instability . see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the observations of @xcite also show enhanced magnetic fluctuations and magnetic compressibility that follow the linear mirror threshold fairly well . it is important to emphasize , however , that the observations presented by @xcite and @xcite showing dominance of the mirror instability also include the regime @xmath258 , which is not considered in our study . also , the dominance of the mirror instability could be affected by properties of the solar wind that are usually not included in calculations of instability thresholds . these include the presence of @xmath259 of alpha particles ( see , e.g. , figure 7 of * ? ? ? * ) , the drift of alpha particles with respect to protons @xcite , and the frequent presence of a proton beam @xcite . we interpret the dominance of the mirror modes in our simulations as being due to the suppression of the ic waves , which is caused by the ion velocity distribution function departing from bi - maxwellian @xcite . this interpretation also requires the ic modes to have finite amplitudes ( although smaller than the one of the mirror modes ) so that they can maintain , via pitch - angle scattering , an ion distribution function that is marginally stable to the growth of ic waves . to the best of our knowledge , these ic modes have not been found by in - situ heliospheric measurements during mirror dominated events . this is consistent with the fact that in our simulations the mirror and ic modes only have comparable amplitudes during the initial , exponential regime ( fig . [ fig : beta6]@xmath93 and @xmath94 ) . in the saturated regime ( which is likely to be more representative of the observed state of the plasma in the heliospheric and astrophysical systems ) , we find that the mirror modes have significantly larger amplitudes . moreover , this dominance increases with the magnetization @xmath43 , as can be seen by comparing figures [ fig : beta6]@xmath93 and @xmath94 . can be accounted for by the fact that the scattering rate of cyclotron - frequency fluctuations is expected to be @xmath187 . if we equate this to the shear parameter @xmath37 ( which is , roughly , the rate at which pitch - angle scattering takes place , as can be seen from the changing rate of @xmath116 in fig . [ fig : muderivs ] ) , one obtains that @xmath260 . ] thus , for realistic values of @xmath43 , we do not anticipate easily detectable ic waves by in - situ measurements in cases where the mirror modes dominate . the departure from the bi - maxwellian ion distribution function has not been confirmed by in - situ heliospheric measurements of mirror - dominated events either . we believe that this is due to the high sensitivity of resonant instabilities to gradients in the velocity distribution function . thus , in cases where ic and mirror modes can have similar growth rates , only small deviations from the bi - maxwellian distribution can significantly reduce the importance of the ic modes and give way to the dominance of the mirror modes . we , therefore , do not anticipate easily detectable departures from bi - maxwellian associated to this effect . nevertheless , future careful observations comparing the nature of the fluctuations and the ion distribution functions in the solar wind can help to unveil these effects . a second application of our results is to low - collisionality accretion flows onto black holes . in these systems pressure anisotropies can produce an anisotropic stress that can increase the transport of angular momentum and the heating of the plasma @xcite . our results are consistent with @xcite s hypothesis that the mirror and/or ic instabilities would provide enhanced pitch angle scattering and regulate the evolution of the plasma pressure tensor . axisymmetric kinetic simulations have also demonstrated this directly @xcite though the restriction to axisymmetry limits the quantitative applicability of these initial simulations to real disks . one of the key conclusions of our study in this paper is that even modest plasma magnetization is sufficient to quantitatively capture the nonlinear saturation of the mirror instability . for example , our @xmath261 results in figures [ fig : beta20b2s ] & [ fig : mubeta20 ] show that the evolution of the ion pressure anisotropy , ion magnetic moment , and turbulent fluctuations are quite similar for @xmath114 and @xmath149 . the primary difference is that in the lower magnetization run the plasma has a larger `` overshoot '' of the saturation pressure anisotropy set by the linear mirror instability threshold . this weak dependence on magnetization is encouraging because it is computationally infeasible to reach @xmath149 in three - dimensional kinetic simulations of astrophysical plasmas ( e.g. , accretion disks ) . one of the interesting questions not fully addressed by our work is the saturation of velocity space instabilities in turbulent low - collisionality plasmas where the shear rate of the mean magnetic field itself fluctuates in time and the magnitude of the large - scale turbulent fluctuations satisfies @xmath262 . our calculations in this paper have focused on the case where an imposed velocity shear amplifies a background magnetic field by order unity or more . if , on the other hand , the shear acts for less time such that the background field is amplified by significantly less , the plasma may never become mirror / ic unstable ( depending on @xmath30 and @xmath221 ) or the background shear may reverse sign before the mirror / ic fluctuations have reached sufficiently large amplitudes for pitch angle scattering to set in . this regime will be explored in future work . another key question not addressed by our study is isotropization of the electron pressure anisotropy . in future work we will study how fast electrons interact with the large - scale mirrors generated by the ion pressure anisotropy , and whether there are separate electron - scale fluctuations that produce significant electron pitch - angle scattering ( e.g. , the whistler instability ) . we thank tobi heinemann , ben chandran , phil isenberg and , in particular , matt kunz for fruitful discussions . eq is supported in part by nasa htp grant nnx11aj37 g , nsf grant ast-1333682 , a simons investigator award from the simons foundation , the david and lucile packard foundation , and the thomas alison schneider chair in physics . mr thanks support from the chilean comisin nacional de investigacin cientfica y tecnolgica ( conicyt ; proyecto fondecyt iniciacin n@xmath263 11121145 ) . dv is supported in part by nasa htp grant nnx11aj37 g and nasa grant nnx12ab27 g . 99 anderson , b. j. , fuselier , s. a. , & murr , d. 1991 , geophysical research letter , 18 , 1955 balbus , s. a. , hawley , j. f. 1991 , , 376 , 214 balbus , s. a. 2001 , , 562 , 909 bale , s. d. , kasper , j. c. , howes , g. g. , quataert , e. , salem , c. , & sundkvist , d. 2009 , phys . 103 , 211101 baumgartel , k. , sauer , k. , & dubinin , e. 2003 , geophys . , 30 , 1761 califano , f. , hellinger , p. , kuznetzov , e. a. , passot , t. , sulem , p. l. , & travnicek , p. m. 2008 , j. geophys . res . , 113 , a08219 chen , l. , lin , z. , & white , r. 2001 , phys . of plasma , 8 4713 johnson , j. r. , & cheng , c. z. 2001 , geophys . lett . , 28 , 4421 buneman , o. 1993 , `` computer space plasma physics '' , terra scientific , tokyo , 67 enriquez - rivera , o. , blanco - cano , x. , russell , c. t. , jian , l. k. , & luhmann , j. g. 2010 , aip conf . proc . , 1216 , 276 gary , s. p. 1992 , j. geophys . res . , 97 , 8519 gary , s. p. & lee , m. a. 1994 , j. geophys . res . , 99 , 11297 guo , j. , yang , z. , lu , q. , & wang , s. 2009 , plasma sci . technol . , 11 , 274 hasegawa , a. 1969 , phys . fluids , 12 , 2642 hasegawa , a. & tsurutani , b. t. 2011 , , 107 , 245005 hawley , j. f. , gammie , c. f. , & balbus , s. a. 1995 , , 440 , 742 hellinger , p. , travnicek , p. , kasper , j. c. , & lazarus , a. j. 2006 , geophys . lett . , 33 , 9 hellinger , p. & travnicek , p. m. 2008 , j. geophys . res . , 113 , a10109 hellinger , p. , kuznetzov , e. a. , passot , t. , sulem , p. l. , & travnicek , p. m. 2009 , geophys . res . lett . , 36 , l06103 heuer , m. & marsch , e. 2007 , , 112 , a03102 horbury , t. s. & lucek , e. a. 2009 , , 114 , a05217 isenberg , p. a. 2012 , phys . plasmas 19 , 032116 isenberg , p. a. , maruca , b. a. , & kasper , j. c. 2013 , , 773 , 164 joy , s. p. , kivelson , m. g. , walker , r. j. , khurana , k. k. , russell , c. t. , & paterson , w. r. 2006 , j. geophys . res . , 111 , a12212 kunz , m. , schekochihin , a. a. , & stone , j. m. 2014 , phys . rev 112 , 205003 liu , y. , richardson , j. d. , belcher , j. w. , kasper , j. c. , & skoug , r. m. 2006 , j. geophys . res . , 111 , a09108 lyutikov , m. 2007 , , 668 , l1 marsch , e. , muhlhauser , k. -h . , rosenbauer , h. , schewnn , r. , & neubauer , f. m. 1982 , j. geophys . res . , 87 , 35 marsch , e. , muhlhauser , k. -h . , schewnn , r. , rosenbauer , h. , pilipp , w. & neubauer , f. m. 1982 , j. geophys . res . , 87 , 52 maruca , b. a. , kasper , j. c. & bale , s. d. 2011 , phys . 107 , 201101 matteini , l. , landi , s. , hellinger , p. , pantellini , f. , maksimovic , m. , velli , m. , goldstein , b. , & marsch , e. 2007 , geophys . lett . , 34 , l20105 matteini , l. , hellinger , p. , landi , s. , travnicek , p. m. , & velli , m. 2007 , space sci . 172 , 373 narayan , r. , mahadevan , r. , & quataert , e. 1998 , theory of black holes acretion disks pokhotelov , o. a. , sagdeev , r. z. , balikhin , m. a. , & treuman , r. a. 2004 , j. geophys . , 109 , a09213 quataert , e. 2008 , , 673 , 758 remya , b. , reddy , r. v. , tsurutani , b. t. , lakhina , g. s. , & echer , e. 2013 , jgra , 118 , 785 riquelme , m. a. , quataert , e. , sharma , p. , & spitkovsky , a. 2012 , , nn , nn russell , c. t. , blanco - cano , x. , jian , l. k. , & luhmann , j. g. 2009 , geophys . lett . , 36 , l05106 schekochihin , a. a. , cowley , s. c. , kulsrud , r. m. , hammett , g. w. , & sharma , p. 2005 , , 629 , 139 schekochihin , a. a. , cowley , s. c. , kulsrud , r. m. , rosin , m. s. , & heinemann , t. 2008 , phys . lett . , 100 , 081301 schmid , d. , volwerk , m. , plaschke , f. , voros , z. , zhang , t.l . , baumjohann , w. , & narita , y. 2014 , ann . geophys . , 32 , 651 schwartz , s. j. , burgess , d. , & moses , j. j. , 1996 , ann . , 14 , 1134 sharma , p. , hammett , g. w. , quataert , e. , & stone , j. 2006 , , 637 , 952 shoji , m. , omura , y. , tsurutani , b. t. , verkhoglyadova , o. p. , & lembege , b. 2009 , , 114 , a10203 soucek , j. , lucek , e. , & dandouras , i. 2008 , j. geophys . res . , 113 , a04203 southwood , d. j. , & kivelson , m. g. 1993 , , 98 , 9181 spitkovsky , a. 2005 , aip conf . proc , 801 , 345 , astro - ph/0603211 travnicek , p. , hellinger , p. , taylor , m. , escoubet , c. , dandouras , i. , & lucek , e. 2007 , geophys . lett . , 34 , l15104 tu , c .- y . & marsch , e. 2002 , , 107 , a9 tsurutani , b. t. , smith , e. j. , anderson , r. r. , ogilvie , k. w. , scudder , j. d. , baker , d. n. , & bame , s. j. 1982 , , 87 , 6060 tsurutani , b. t. , lakhina , g. s. , verkhoglyadova , o. p. , echer , e. , guarnieri , f. l. , narita , y. , constantinescu , d. o. 2011 , , 116 , a02103 tsurutani , b. t. , echer , e. , verkhoglyadova , o. p. , lakhina , g. s. , guarnieri , f. l. 2011 , journal of atmospheric and solar - terrestrial physics , 73 , 1398 verscharen , d. , bourouaine , s. , chandran , b. d. g. , & maruca , b. a. 2013 , , 773 , 8 volwerk , m. , zhang , t. l. , delva , m. , voros , z. , baumjohann , w. , & glassmeier , k.h . 2008 , geophys . lett . , 35 , previous 1d studies of the mirror instability suggest that its growth and saturation are dominated by the resonant " scattering of @xmath218 particles ( where @xmath264 is the particle velocity component parallel to the magnetic field ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , leading to a flattening of the distribution function near @xmath218 . in contrast , our 2d runs discussed in the main text show that scattering by mirror modes is fairly momentum independent , with no significant flattening of @xmath265 . to compare our results more directly to the previous literature , in this appendix we compare the mirror saturation in 1d and 2d for different values of @xmath154 , paying especial attention to the behavior of @xmath218 particles . we show that , compared with the 1d case , 2d runs significantly change the way pitch - angle scattering occurs , modifying the saturation mechanism . to best compare with the previous literature , we use initial - value simulations in this appendix , where a linearly unstable pressure anisotropy is imposed as an initial condition . figure [ fig:1d2d2.3 ] compares simulations with @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 in 1d and 2d . in the 1d simulation , the initial magnetic field @xmath34 forms an angle of @xmath269 with the resolved dimension of the simulation . apart from the different number of dimensions , these simulations also have the same numerical parameters . panels [ fig:1d2d2.3]@xmath93 and [ fig:1d2d2.3]@xmath94 show @xmath116 and @xmath224 as a function of time for the 1d and 2d cases , respectively . in 1d , @xmath116 decreases significantly slower than @xmath224 , which means that there is a significant correlation between @xmath163 and @xmath123 ( as expected for the mirror instability ) . in 2d , on the other hand , the difference between @xmath116 and @xmath224 is very small , implying that pitch - angle scattering occurs more efficiently in 2d . this difference in the scattering efficiency can be explained considering the modes that grow in the 1d and 2d simulations . indeed , in the 1d case , mirror modes with wave vectors pointing in only one direction can grow . in the 2d case , on the other hand , both ic and mirror modes appear ( with the mirror modes forming both positive and negative angles with respect to @xmath34 ) . this can be seen from panels [ fig:1d2d2.3]@xmath50 and [ fig:1d2d2.3]@xmath101 , which show the evolution of the magnetic energy contained in fluctuations parallel ( @xmath167 ) and perpendicular ( @xmath270 ) to @xmath34 for the 1d and 2d cases . whereas the 1d case is dominated by @xmath167 ( characteristic of mirror modes ) , the 2d case is dominated by @xmath270 , showing the dominant presence of the ic modes . panels [ fig:1d2d2.3]@xmath108 and [ fig:1d2d2.3]@xmath109 show snapshots of the parallel velocity distribution @xmath265 for the 1d and 2d runs at the saturated state @xmath271 ( black lines ) , and compare them with a bi - maxwellian distribution ( red line ) . in the 1d case , we can see flattening of @xmath265 for @xmath218 . this flattening is consistent with the results of @xcite , who argue that it is due to the resonant interaction of @xmath218 particles with the mirror modes . the 2d run , however , does not have this flattening , implying that the saturation process in two dimensions is quite different . this is indeed expected from the dominant role of the ic instability . since at higher @xmath272 the ic instability is expected to play a subdominant role , we also explored the case where initially @xmath273 . figure [ fig:1d2d20 ] compares simulations with @xmath266 , @xmath274 , and @xmath275 in 1d and 2d , with both cases having the same numerical parameters . panels [ fig:1d2d20]@xmath93 and [ fig:1d2d20]@xmath94 show the evolution of @xmath116 and @xmath224 for both cases . in the 1d case these two quantities differ significantly , implying an important correlation between @xmath123 and @xmath163 . this correlation almost disappears in the 2d case , which shows the presence of more efficient pitch - angle scattering in the 2d case . since for @xmath273 the ic instability plays a subdominant role , this is likely a property of the mirror instability itself rather than the presence of the ic instability as was the case for the lower @xmath154 results shown in figure [ fig:1d2d2.3 ] . the higher rate of scattering in 2d also affects the maximum amplitude of the fluctuations , which are shown in panels [ fig:1d2d20]@xmath50 and [ fig:1d2d20]@xmath101 for the 1d and 2d cases . although in both cases @xmath276 ( implying that mirror dominates ) , in 2d the amplitude of the modes is smaller , which means that field rearrangement plays a less important role in the approach to marginal stability . finally , figure [ fig:1d2d20 ] also compares @xmath265 at the saturated state ( @xmath277 ) in the 1d and 2d cases . there is very little flattening for @xmath218 in both cases . this confirms our result from the main text that the pitch - angle scattering in the mirror dominated case is fairly independent of particle momentum . it is interesting , however , that we do not see flattening even in 1d . since @xcite reported the appearance of flattening only near the threshold of the mirror instability ( and only for certain box sizes ) , we tested simulations with the same plasma parameters having anisotropies as low as @xmath278 and found similar results . Abstract: