instruction
stringlengths
147
1.1k
output
stringclasses
2 values
generator
stringclasses
3 values
<question> A collision occurs between two trains, and the total damage exceeds the reporting threshold. However, the damage to each railroad involved is below the threshold. Is this accident reportable to the FRA? If so, which railroad is responsible for reporting it? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the event of an accident in a remote or hard-to-access location, what specific considerations should be made when recording and reporting casualties to ensure accuracy and compliance with safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Is the injury in Scenario 3 considered work-related and reportable? What factors should be considered in making this determination? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the FRA-mandated forms contribute to effective incident reporting and investigation, and what are the potential consequences of non-compliance for railroads? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the requirement for posting a listing of all injuries and occupational illnesses at an establishment, and what are the exceptions to this requirement? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Which railroads are exempt from the recordkeeping requirements regarding accountable injuries and illnesses? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How might the 250-character limit impact the railroad's ability to report on incidents involving multiple parties, and what strategies can be employed to ensure a comprehensive and accurate report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do the reporting requirements for rail equipment accidents/incidents differ from those for injuries and illnesses to railroad employees, and what are the key forms used for each type of report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A railroad cites an employee’s failure to follow procedures as a contributing cause to a rail equipment accident. The Employee Human Factor Attachment is completed, and the Notice to Railroad Employee (Form FRA F 6180.78) is prepared. However, the employee has been on medical leave and is not expected to return to work for several weeks. Can the railroad defer sending the notice to the employee on medical grounds, and if so, what documentation is required to support this deferral? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA's guidance on reporting accident/incident days impact the overall safety culture in the railroad industry? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a railroad contacts a highway user who was involved in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident and the user refuses to provide any information, is the railroad still required to make a determination on whether the user suffered a reportable injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can railroads ensure the consistent and accurate use of the case/incident number across different forms and records, especially in the event of a reportable incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What information should be included in the narrative sections (15(b) and 16(b)) of the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form (Form FRA F 6180.150) to ensure that the report is comprehensive and meets FRA requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Are all injuries to railroad employees, regardless of their nature or location, reportable under FRA guidelines? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the definition of a 'passenger station platform gap incident' and what are some examples and non-examples of such an incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad discovers a math error in their submitted Railroad Injury and Illness Summary (Form FRA F 6180.55), what is the correct procedure for amending the report and ensuring compliance with FRA regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How should a railroad address instances where employees are intimidated or harassed to prevent them from reporting injuries or illnesses, and what measures should be included in the Internal Control Plan (ICP) to ensure accurate and complete reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In what circumstances would a railroad use an alternative record-keeping system for injuries and incidents, and what are the potential implications for safety and incident management? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Can you explain the significance of the Notice to Railroad Employee (Part I of Form FRA F 6180.78) and its role in the reporting procedure for railroad accidents and incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How should railroads handle a Group III accident/incident, and what forms are required for reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How can the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) effectively ensure consistent safety standards and develop comprehensive safety programs when certain railroad operations are exempt from reporting requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do I decide if an injury or illness involved a transfer to another job? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> What is the difference between Form FRA F 6180.55 and Form FRA 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of 'Type of Equipment Consist' and how is it reported on FRA Form F 6180.54 and FRA Form F 6180.57? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A pedestrian was struck by a train at a highway-rail grade crossing that is not protected by gates or other similar barriers. The pedestrian was not attempting to pass over, under, or between cars or locomotives. Is the pedestrian classified as a trespasser or a nontrespasser? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific conditions must be met for an incident to be classified as a 'Highway-Rail Grade Crossing Accident/Incident'? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A railroad employee was exposed to a hazardous material during the course of their work. The employee experienced symptoms severe enough to require medical treatment beyond first aid. Is this case reportable under FRA regulations, and if so, under what criteria? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What information should be included in the narrative sections of the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form (Form FRA F 6180.150) to ensure that the railroad provides the FRA with accurate and comprehensive details about the accident or incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential legal and operational risks associated with railroads designing their own record-keeping systems, and how can these be mitigated to ensure compliance and data integrity? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the exposure to hazardous materials (Hazmat) influence the reporting requirements for injuries and illnesses in railroad operations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In cases of multi-jurisdictional accidents, how can railroads ensure accurate and timely reporting while adhering to local time requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the penalties for a railroad that fails to report a work-related injury or illness in a timely and accurate manner, and how do they differ for willful violations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What qualifies as 'significant injury' or 'significant illness' for the purposes of reporting under Group III? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the recent amendments to FRA's accident/incident reporting regulations address the reporting of suicides, and what specific requirements are there for obtaining and reporting documentation related to the cause of death for suicides and trespasser casualties? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential legal implications for railroads if they fail to accurately report incidents using the designated codes, and how can they ensure compliance with these regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a railroad submits a Form FRA F 6180.54 and cites an employee human factor as a contributing cause of the accident, but later determines that another employee was actually responsible, what steps must the railroad take to correct the report and notify the implicated employees? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA's review process impact a railroad's safety culture and incident reporting practices? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A freight train derailed, and during the cleanup, additional damage was caused to the track and roadbed. How should the costs of the additional damage be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A highway user was struck by a train at a grade crossing and was transported to a hospital by ambulance. The hospital later informed the railroad that the injury did not require medical treatment beyond first aid. Is the injury still reportable to FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad chooses to submit its required reports electronically, what are the specific requirements for the format and submission process, and what are the consequences of not adhering to these requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was injured on the job and received a recommendation from a PLHCP to take three days off to recover, but the employee chose to return to work on the second day. How should the days away from work be reported in this scenario? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In a scenario where a passenger railroad contracts track maintenance, what steps can the contracting railroad take to ensure timely and accurate notifications of reportable injuries to its contracted employees, and what challenges might they face in this process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a PLHCP recommends that an employee take two days off due to a work-related injury but the employee only takes one day off, how should the railroad report the days away from work? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the consequences of submitting a report with missing or contradictory information, and how should such errors be corrected? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a contractor is hired to repair a section of track damaged in a derailment, and the railroad cannot determine the exact equivalent craft for the contractor's labor hours, how should the railroad calculate the direct labor costs for reporting purposes? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a yard switching train-mile be calculated if the actual mileage is not known? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps must a railroad take to determine the nature and severity of injuries sustained by highway users in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can railroads leverage state-wise employee hours and casualty data to effectively identify regional safety trends and design location-specific safety interventions, considering the potential biases and limitations of this data? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a formal investigation is still in progress, can the railroad defer naming implicated employees on Form FRA F 6180.81, and if so, what information should be provided in the 'Description' area of the form? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the exceptions to the presumption of work-relatedness, and how might these exceptions influence the design and implementation of safety procedures in railroad operations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How might the failure to record and report suicide data accurately impact the railroad's ability to track and address potential safety hazards? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A pedestrian was struck by a train at a grade crossing and suffered significant injuries. The pedestrian was not immediately identifiable, and the railroad was unable to contact the individual or their representative. What steps should the railroad take to fulfill its reporting responsibilities for the injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the presumption of work-relatedness impact the reporting of injuries and illnesses that are caused by pre-existing conditions or long-term exposures in the work environment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> During transport to the hospital, the Emergency Medical Team may perform some precautionary procedures that could be considered beyond first aid. Is this reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing accident involves a train striking a vehicle transporting hazardous materials, what specific information must be recorded in the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What constitutes a passenger station platform gap incident, and what types of events are excluded from this definition? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In what circumstances is a highway user presumed to have sustained an FRA reportable injury, and what are the implications for railroad safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the use of supplement forms (Part II of Form FRA F 6180.78) ensure the employee's statement is properly placed and reviewed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the potential legal and ethical implications for a railroad company if they fail to report casualties accurately, particularly in cases of suicide or attempted suicide? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If an employee trips while walking on a level surface at work and sustains an injury, is the injury considered work-related even if the cause of the trip is unknown? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user is struck by a train at a grade crossing but the impact is minor and there are no injuries or property damage, is the case reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad discovers in January of the following year that it failed to report an injury that occurred in November of the previous year, what steps should the railroad take to correct this omission? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing accident occurs and the crossing was equipped with flashing lights and gates, but the gates were not activated due to a signal system failure, what codes should be entered in Items 32 and 33, and what additional information should be included in the narrative description? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is it mandatory for a highway user to complete and return the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form after receiving it from the railroad? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the legal implications for railroads if they fail to provide the required notification and information to employees within the specified timeframe, and how might this impact railroad safety culture and incident management? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In what circumstances might a volunteer be considered a safety-sensitive function for the railroad, and what are the reporting requirements in such cases? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> During a derailment, a non-employee (a passenger) was injured, and the railroad tested several crew members for alcohol and drugs. The tests were positive for alcohol for one crew member, but the investigation concluded that impairment was not a cause of the accident. How should the railroad report this incident, and what additional information should be included in the narrative to explain the positive test result? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a train strikes a pedestrian at a highway-rail grade crossing, but the pedestrian is not killed or seriously injured, and only requires first aid, is this incident reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of 'employee' for the purposes of the Employee Human Factor Attachment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific information should be included in the narrative section of the alternative railroad-designed record to ensure that it meets the FRA's requirements for describing the sequence of events leading to the injury or illness? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of a 'musculoskeletal disorder (MSD)' in the context of railroad safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user is involved in a grade crossing accident and the railroad sends the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form (Form FRA F 6180.150), is the highway user required to complete and return the form? What are the potential consequences if the form is not returned? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad determines that a highway user has suffered a reportable injury based on the circumstances, but the user later provides additional information indicating otherwise, how should the railroad amend their records and reports? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the primary purpose of Form FRA F 6180.56, and how does it contribute to the overall railroad safety reporting framework? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a derailment incident, the primary cause was determined to be a broken rail, but there was also a contributing factor of insufficient maintenance checks. How should the cause codes be reported on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad employee dies as a result of a work-related injury, and the initial report did not include the death, what is the penalty for failing to submit a corrected report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the procedure for notifying implicated employees if a railroad is conducting a formal investigation into a rail equipment accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the 'general railroad system of transportation' and how does it differ from operations that are not part of it? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA Guide's definition of a "new case" impact the railroad's responsibility to provide a safe work environment, and what steps can be taken to ensure accurate reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the purpose of the "Alternative Railroad-Designed Record," and how does it enhance the documentation and investigation of accident/incident reports in railroad safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the difference between a 'collision' and an 'other impact' in the context of rail equipment accidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential legal and ethical considerations when balancing employee privacy with the need for transparent safety record-keeping? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the difference between 'hazardous material cargo' and 'diesel fuel used by the locomotive' in the context of reporting an accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if a rail equipment accident or incident is reportable based on the damage threshold? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train accident occurred on a single main track that is classified as Track Class 3. The consist included 2 locomotives and 15 cars. The train was traveling at an estimated speed of 35 mph in the northbound direction. At the highway-rail grade crossing, there was a flashing light signal (FLS) that provided a warning of less than 20 seconds. What codes should be entered for Items 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, and 33 on Form FRA F 6180.57 and how should these be consistent with Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of 'employee' for the purposes of completing Form FRA F 6180.81? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can railroads ensure accurate and consistent damage reporting when using multiple forms for different equipment consists, to avoid overestimation or underestimation of costs? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What information must be included in the alternative record for a claimed occupational illness that lacks sufficient details to determine work-relatedness? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should positive drug or alcohol test results be reported if they are not deemed to have caused the accident or injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What should the railroad do if a highway user refuses to provide information about their injuries after being involved in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident, and the railroad is unable to determine if the injuries are reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What criteria must be met for a railroad to require telephonic notification of an accident or incident according to Appendix M? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the reporting requirements for days away from work and days of restriction vary for railroad employees compared to non-railroad employees, and what are the implications for safety and data collection? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the purpose of Form FRA F 6180.150, and who is responsible for completing Part II of this form? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific criteria define an "accountable" rail equipment accident/incident, and how do these criteria influence the reporting and response procedures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do the "Type of Equipment Consist" codes impact the overall analysis and investigation of an accident, and what specific information do they provide to investigators? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the purpose of the Employee Human Factor Attachment form, and when must it be completed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is an injury sustained by an employee while walking from their car to the office on company-owned property, but before their scheduled start time, considered work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A railroad employee, while on duty, was exposed to a hazardous material that caused a skin irritation. The employee visited a PLHCP, who prescribed a topical cream to treat the irritation. The employee was able to return to work with no restrictions. Is this case reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the U.S. DOT Grade Crossing Identification Number contribute to the accuracy and efficiency of accident/incident reporting, and what potential safety benefits does it offer? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How should I code an injury that occurred when a passenger was stepping down from a passenger car at a high-level platform? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b