Filename
stringlengths 22
64
| Paragraph
stringlengths 8
5.57k
|
|---|---|
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Strong emission from both H70α and H57α are detected towards core 2 in all the array configurations (Figure 2). Similar to the cm-continuum emission, the peak flux density of the H57α RRL in the more extended array configuration only recovers a small fraction of the flux density in the more compact configuration. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | To correct for this spatial filtering when creating an SED it is therefore necessary to sample the source emission at the same spatial frequencies. Figure 13 shows the SED for core 2 sampled between spatial frequencies of 5−10 kλ, the mutually overlapping range between all the 18.9 to 35 GHz observations. This shows that on spatial scales of ′′ 25-50 , the spectral index is almost flat – consistent with optically-thin free-free emission. It is not possible to unam- biguously compare this spectral index with the flux from the 92 & 93 GHz observations due to the smaller primary beam, much higher spatial frequencies and the potential contri- bution from thermal dust emission. However, the similarity between the 92 GHz H75 array configuration observations and the lower frequency emission suggests at least some of the 92 GHz emission may be due to free-free emission. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | The 93 GHz observations using the more extended H214 array configuration show a very different structure, with only a single, weak, unresolved detection directly in the middle of the two compact lower frequency knots. This source is also coincident with an N2H+ core (Longmore et al. in prep) trac- ing dense molecular gas, so we postulate this 93GHz emis- sion is likely to be from thermal dust. Although the emission from this source is probably distinct from that of core 2 at lower frequencies, they are spatially associated within the beam of the lower resolution data, and as such are both labelled as ‘core 2’. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Finally, there is also a strong 93 GHz continuum source at the position of the ammonia peak, core 1. The spectral index inferred from the upper limits of the lower frequency data at this position means this is also likely to be thermal dust emission. As this source is substantially outside of the primary beam, the flux measurement reported in Table 3 is highly uncertain. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 3 shows images of the continuum emission detected towards the region. The morphology of the 19 and 35 GHz continuum emission is very similar to that observed at 24 GHz by L07: a single source is seen peaking close to the methanol maser position with an extended tail towards the east. This continuum emission is offset to the south east from an L07 ammonia core which is extended north-east to south-west. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Table 2. Overview of the observing setup. For the H70α, H57α and H41α observations, the observing frequencies were centred on the respective RRL transitions and continuum emission was extracted from line-free channels. The 93.5 GHz observations were solely high spatial resolution continuum observations and no RRL was observed in this setup. Columns three and four give the bandwidth (BW) and number of channels for each of the correlator settings used. ∆V shows the corresponding velocity resolution per channel for each IF in kms−1. Column six lists the array configuration for each observation. The H75, H168 and H214 array configurations have baselines ranging from 31 - 89 m, 61 - 192 m and 82 - 247 m, respectively. Columns 7 and 8 show the theoretical spectral line RMS per channel and theoretical continuum brightness sensitivity (based on a one hour observation in average weather conditions using the ATCA sensitivity calculator – http://www.atnf.csiro.au). The final column gives a characteristic synthesised beam size (for a source at δ = −30◦). |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | report weak (∼3.5 mJy) continuum emission at 8 GHz, ex- tended east-west, with a similar morphology to that in Fig- ure 3. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | The H70α and H57α RRL emission detected towards the continuum (Figure 4) and spectral index of −0.07 de- rived from the SED (Figure 13) confirms the continuum be- tween 19 and 35 GHz as free-free emission. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | A compact continuum source is also detected at 92 and 93 GHz. This is offset from the peak of the lower frequency emission and is instead associated with the methanol maser emission, the peak of the L07 NH3(1,1) ammonia emission and the unresolved NH3(4,4) and (5,5) emission. Due to a combination of the lower sensitivity to extended emission of these observations and the lower optical depth of free-free emission at higher frequencies, the 92 & 93 GHz emission could be from the densest and brightest free-free component inside the larger region traced by the lower frequency emis- sion. However, given the similar synthesised beam sizes of the 35 GHz H168 and 92 GHz H75 observations, it is diffi- cult to understand the offset in the peak of the emission. We favour an alternative explanation in which the 92 & 93 GHz emission is dominated by thermal dust emission rather than free-free emission. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | emission. The extremely negative spectral index is biased by the low flux density of the 35 GHz H168 data point, which is probably due to missing flux. Removing this point before fitting results in a spectral index of −0.18 ± 0.09. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Re-inspection of the WBHR98 data shows this source is ′ ∼10 from the WBHR98 pointing centre, significantly out- ′ side their half-power beamwidth of 5.7 . Any emission would therefore have suffered from primary beam attenuation in their observations. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 5 also shows a second, unresolved source de- tected at 93 GHz, 5′′ south of the maser position, coincident with the unresolved NH3(1,1) → (5,5) core reported in L07 (core 4). The non-detection at frequencies <93 GHz makes it likely that the emission mechanism for this source is from dust rather than thermal free-free emission. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | In summary, G12.68-0.18 core 3 is an extended region of optically-thin ionised gas that was not detected by WBHR98 as it lies far outside their primary beam. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | In summary, G331.28-0.19 core 1 appears to be an opti- cally thin HII region. The 92 GHz emission and the ammonia emission are likely tracing a hot molecular core located at the edge of the HII region, similar to the case of G29.96- 0.02 (Cesaroni et al. 1998). The 8 GHz non-detection by WBHR98 can be attributed to their poorer sensitivity for this source compared to the rest of their sample. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 7 shows images of the continuum emission detected towards the region. The morphology of the 19 and 35 GHz continuum emission is similar to that observed at 24 GHz by L07: an unresolved continuum source, labelled core 2, lies ∼15′′ north-west of the methanol maser position. H57α and H70α RRL emission is detected towards the peak of the continuum emission (Figure 8), confirming the emission arises from ionised gas. The spectral index (Figure 13) is consistent with optically-thin free-free emission. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | No 8 GHz continuum emission was reported at this lo- cation by WBHR98. Re-examination of the WBHR98 data shows this region lies outside the primary beam so the con- tinuum sensitivity would have suffered significantly from pri- mary beam attenuation. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | A second, weaker source is seen only at 92 and 93 GHz within a few arc-seconds of the methanol maser position and unresolved NH3(1,1) → (5, 5) emission, designated core 1 in L07. At 35 GHz the 3σ upper limit is 7 mJy. This implies a spectral index between 35 and 92 GHz of α > 2, which rules out either optically-thick or thin bremsstrahlung emission. We conclude that the core 1 emission is most likely from warm dust. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Table 3. Continuum detections towards each of the regions. The frequency and array configurations are given in columns two and three. The listed positions, fluxes and angular sizes are taken from the fits to the images, as outlined in § 2. For extended sources, the angular sizes have been deconvolved with the synthesised beam. The errors shown in column seven are from the fit to the data and do not take into account the absolute error in the flux scale which is assumed to be 20% and 30% for the observations < 90 GHz and > 90 GHz, respectively. a the integrated flux for extended sources is shown in column seven in parentheses. b for integrated fluxes (in parentheses) the units are mJy rather than mJy/beam. c G316.81-0.06 Core 1 is considerably outside the primary beam of the 92 GHz H75 observations making this flux measurement highly uncertain. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Table 4. Detected radio recombination line emission towards each region. The second and third columns give the transition and array configuration. Columns four through seven list the velocity-integrated line flux, central velocity, full-width at half maximum and peak intensity with associated errors from fits to the spectra (see § 2), extracted from the position of peak continuum flux in Table 3. Column 8 gives the line to continuum ratio for each transition. a the reported flux is the velocity-integrated flux extracted from the peak spectra. The spectra are shown for each region separately in Figures 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 and overlayed with the fit to profile. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 9 shows images of the continuum emission detected towards the region. The morphology at 19 and 35 GHz is very similar to that observed at 24 GHz by L07: an unre- solved source at the methanol maser position (core 1) and a slightly extended source at the edge of the primary beam (core 3). Although, core 3 was not detected at 92 & 93 GHz, it lies outside the primary beam at >24 GHz making both detection more difficult and the flux determination more un- certain. Figure 10, shows H57α and H70α RRL emission is detected at the peak of the continuum emission towards core 3 and H57α is detected towards core 1, confirming both these sources contain ionised gas. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | WBHR98 reported a 1σ non-detection to 3mJy at both 24 GHz continuum positions. However, Forster & Caswell (2000) reported two 8.6 GHz continuum sources in the prox- imity of the methanol maser emission, with flux densities of 36 and 51 mJy. Re-examining the calibrated WBHR98 uv data shows residual phase errors in the data for this region. The image shows 8 GHz continuum emission in the region but its location is unclear, resulting in the reported non- detection. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Core 1 is well known in the literature as a hyper- compact HII region (e.g. Beltr´an et al. 2007). Figure 13 shows the SED at the frequencies observed in this work which are consistent with the source transitioning be- tween optically-thick and thin free-free emission. The single- component spectral index attributed to this source in Fig- ure 13 is therefore not a good representative of the true SED. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | compact HII region which was missed by WBHR98 due a combination of the steeply rising flux density between 8 and 24 GHz and calibration problems. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 11 shows images of the continuum emission detected towards the region. The morphology at 19 and 35 GHz is similar to that observed at 24 GHz by L07: a compact source is seen peaking ∼5′′ west of the methanol maser position, with a fainter tail extending towards the south-east. No emission was detected at 92 or 93 GHz. The detection of H57α (Figure 12) confirms the presence of free-free emission towards the source. Figure 13 shows the SED. The spectral index of 0.4 determined from the fit is not very robust due to the flux uncertainties and the narrow range of detected frequencies. Nevertheless, the spectral index is sufficient to rule out dust as the primary contributor to the emission. The spectral index of 0.4 is intermediate between the canonical values of +2 and −0.1, suggesting that the sampled frequen- cies are near the turn over region. Re-examination of the WBHR98 data shows a 3σ non-detection to 6mJy at 8 GHz. Extrapolating the WBHR98 upper limit assuming a spectral index of +2 results in a 19 GHz flux density well below the measured value (see Figure 13). From this, and the extended source size we assume the emission is optically thin. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Table 5. Nature of the L07A and newly detected continuum sources towards each of the regions derived from the spectral en- ergy distributions (see §3.7). |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | range of spatial frequencies probed between the different observations, the observations at <90 GHz were re-imaged selecting only visibilities in the mutually overlapping spatial frequency range. In practice this meant dropping the longest baselines at higher frequency, thus biasing the SED towards the large scale structure. As a result it was not possible to resolve G316.81-0.06 Core 2 into the two separate compo- nents, and only a composite SED is given. After re-imaging and re-fitting the emission to determine the flux density (as outlined in § 2), the spectral index was calculated using a weighted, linear least-squares fit. Uncertainties in the indi- vidual flux density measurements were calculated by adding in quadrature the formal error of the fit to the emission and the estimated uncertainty in absolute flux (see § 2). The absolute flux uncertainty was dominant in nearly all cases. As there were no overlapping spatial frequencies between the higher resolution observations at 92/93.5 GHz and the remaining data, it was not possible to re-image these data in the same way. As a result, the 92/93.5 GHz observations miss much of the flux seen towards extended sources at lower frequencies, potentially biasing the spectral index. The un- certainty to the spectral index is provided in each of the figures. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Table 5 shows the conclusions as to the nature of the 24 GHz continuum emission in L07 based on the SED fit- ting. Despite the sometimes large uncertainty in spectral in- dex, the SEDs are sufficient to rule out an optically-thick component as the dominant emission mechanism at this spatial scale in G316.81−0.02 core 2, G331.28−0.19 core 1, G12.68−0.18 core 3 and G19.47+0.17 core 2. This does not preclude the existence of compact ionised gas components at smaller spatial scales (indeed, density gradients may well exist), only that at this position and spatial scale diffuse, optically thin ionised gas is dominant. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | clearly fails for the remaining sources. We conclude the only other viable explanation is that WBHR98 observations must have missed the spatially extended optically-thin emission through either spatial filtering, reduced surface brightness sensitivity or a combination of the two. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Observations of cm-continuum emission towards regions of massive star formation provide a powerful indicator of the region’s age. Simplistically, detection of relatively weak (1- 5 mJy) emission from shock-ionised gas signals the existence of a powering source (that may be driving a thermal jet for example), while stronger emission from photo-ionised gas signals a young massive stellar object has evolved suffi- ciently to have begun ionising its surrounding environment. Conversely, lack of bright cm-continuum emission is often used to infer the region is at an evolutionary stage prior to the development of an UCHII region. As such, previous large, high-resolution, cm-continuum surveys have proven invaluable in helping to assess the relative ages of many massive star formation regions. However, from our original sample of 21 massive star formation regions, selected from such a survey to contain no cm-continuum emission, we have confirmed that 6 of these are in fact associated with cm- continuum emission. In § 4.1 we summarise the reasons for these discrepancies for the sources we have studied in this work and in § 4.2 discuss the implications this has on the implied evolutionary stage of the objects. We then assess how these results may affect the interpretation of the whole WBHR98 sample. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | In each of the three cases, the reason for the non- detection at 8 GHz is straightforward: (i) is due to the sen- sitivity limits of WBHR98; (ii) is due to the WBHR98 ob- servations resolving-out extended emission, and, (iii) is due to the significantly reduced sensitivity of the observations outside of the primary beam. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Based on the WBHR98 data, 15 of the 21 regions in the ini- tial L07 survey were selected as being methanol maser sites devoid of 8 GHz continuum emission and were thus assumed to be in an evolutionary stage prior to UCHII region forma- tion. The results from this work show that in fact only 9 of the original 21 regions contain no free-free emission and the remaining 12 are either at the HCHII region stage [case (i)] or in fact substantially older [cases (ii or iii)]. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | WBHR98 found ∼80% of their methanol maser sites were not associated with radio continuum emission and sug- gested methanol masers may form before an UCHII region develops. While this work does not contradict the conclu- sions of WBHR98 - methanol masers do trace very early stages of massive star formation - our results suggest a substantially larger fraction of methanol masers than de- termined by WBHR98 are associated with more evolved stages, UCHII regions and later. However, it is not possi- ble to rule out methanol masers as signposts of the pre-HII phase. Given the clustered mode of massive star formation, these youngest sources may simply be coincident with more evolved massive young stellar objects. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Our findings support the idea that methanol masers commonly occur in both a very early phase before a de- tectable UCHII region develops (this may include the hy- percompact HII region phase), and after the formation of a UCHII region where the ionised gas is expanding and becomes extended enough that it may be missed by ex- tended interferometer configurations, such as that used by WBHR98, due to spatial filtering/poor surface brightness sensitivity. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | In order to fully understand the relative occurrence of methanol maser sites in these three stages, we suggest a radio continuum survey that is sensitive to more extended radio continuum emission be undertaken. Such a survey should observe a large number of methanol maser sites with- out associated radio continuum emission, as identified by WBHR98. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Inadvertently ignoring a potentially substantial flux contri- bution (up to ∼0.5 Jy) from free-free emission has implica- tions for deriving dust masses from sub-mm flux densities. Given the sharply rising flux density of dust with frequency this overestimate will be most pronounced at lower frequen- cies. Comparison with sub-mm flux densities towards mas- sive star formation regions (e.g. Hill et al. 2005), shows that in the worse case scenario, missing a 0.5 Jy contribution from free-free emission will result in an over-estimate of dust mass by a factor of ∼2. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | that previous continuum surveys have missed several, some- times bright (∼0.5Jy) cm-continuum sources. If the original Longmore et al. (2007a) sample of 21 massive star formation regions are representative of the population as a whole, the evolutionary stage of a large number of regions have been mis-classified. Rather than being very young objects prior to UCHII region formation, they are, in fact, associated with free-free emission and thus significantly older. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | In addition, inadvertently ignoring a potentially sub- stantial flux contribution (up to ∼0.5 Jy) from free-free emis- sion has implications for dust masses derived from sub-mm flux densities, particularly the larger spatial scales probed by single-dish telescopes. Dust masses may be overestimated by a factor of ∼2. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | We note that cm-continuum data from observations si- multaneously studying masers are particularly susceptible to this missing flux problem, due to the extended array con- figurations needed to achieve sufficient angular resolution. The data in this work adds further evidence that high res- olution interferometric continuum data from such data may not be telling the whole picture. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | We thank Paul Ho and the referee, Stuart Lumsden, for instructive comments. The Australia Telescope is funded by the Commonwealth of Australia for operation as a National Facility managed by CSIRO. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 1. G316.81-0.06 maps. The top-left image shows the integrated NH3(1,1) emission as dashed contours and the 24GHz continuum emission as solid contours (taken from L07). The numbers show the labels given to each of the cores. The remaining images show the continuum emission at each frequency and array configuration. The peak flux shown at the top of each image corresponds to the maximum value in that image rather than the fits to the emission reported in Table 3. Contours are in 10% steps of the peak value with the maximum contour at 90%. The primary and synthesised beam sizes are shown as a circle and filled ellipse, respectively. The linear scale is illustrated by the line in each image. The position of the methanol maser emission and 8 GHz continuum from WBHR98 are shown as crosses and a box, respectively in all images and have the same angular size in each image. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 2. Radio recombination line spectra towards G316.81-0.06 in units of Jy/beam. The spectra are extracted from the peak of the emission for each of the cores and are labelled by core number & transition in the top right, and array configuration in the top left of each spectrum. Overlayed are the Gaussian fits to each spectrum outlined in § 2 and used to obtain the values in Table 4. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 3. G331.28-0.19 maps. The top-left image shows the integrated NH3(1,1) emission as dashed contours and the 24GHz continuum emission as solid contours (taken from L07). The remaining images show the continuum emission at each frequency and array configura- tion. The peak flux shown at the top of each image corresponds to the maximum value in that image rather than the fits to the emission reported in Table 3. Contours are in 10% steps of the peak value with the maximum contour at 90%. The primary and synthesised beam sizes are shown as a circle and filled ellipse, respectively. The linear scale is illustrated by the line in the lower left of each image. The position of the methanol maser emission is shown as crosses, with the same angular size in each image. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 4. Radio recombination line spectra towards G331.28-0.19 in units of Jy/beam. The spectra are extracted from the peak of the emission and are labelled by core number & transition in the top right, and array configuration in the top left of each spectrum. Overlayed are the Gaussian fits to each spectrum outlined in § 2 and used to obtain the values in Table 4. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 5. G12.68-0.18 maps. The top-left image shows the integrated NH3(1,1) emission as dashed contours and the 24GHz continuum emission as solid contours (taken from L07). The numbers show the labels given to each of the cores. The remaining images show the continuum emission at each frequency and array configuration. The peak flux shown at the top of each image corresponds to the maximum value in that image rather than the fits to the emission reported in Table 3. Contours are in 10% steps of the peak value with the maximum contour at 90%. The primary and synthesised beam sizes are shown as a circle and filled ellipse, respectively. The linear scale is illustrated by the line in the lower left of each image. The position of the methanol maser emission is shown as crosses, with the same angular size in each image. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 6. Radio recombination line spectra towards G12.68-0.18 in units of Jy/beam. The spectra are extracted from the peak of the emission and are labelled by core number & transition in the top right, and array configuration in the top left of each spectrum. Overlayed are the Gaussian fits to each spectrum outlined in § 2 and used to obtain the values in Table 4. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 7. G19.47+0.17 maps. The top-left image shows the integrated NH3(1,1) emission as dashed contours and the 24GHz continuum emission as solid contours (taken from L07). The numbers show the labels given to each of the cores. The remaining images show the continuum emission at each frequency and array configuration. The peak flux shown at the top of each image corresponds to the maximum value in that image rather than the fits to the emission reported in Table 3. Contours are in 10% steps of the peak value with the maximum contour at 90%. The primary and synthesised beam sizes are shown as a circle and filled ellipse, respectively. The linear scale is illustrated by the line in the lower left of each image. The position of the methanol maser emission is shown as a cross, with the same angular size in each image. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 8. Radio recombination line spectra towards G19.47+0.17 in units of Jy/beam. The spectra are extracted from the peak of the emission and are labelled by core number & transition in the top right, and array configuration in the top left of each spectrum. Overlayed are the Gaussian fits to each spectrum outlined in § 2 and used to obtain the values in Table 4. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 9. G24.79+0.08 maps. The top-left image shows the integrated NH3(1,1) emission as dashed contours and the 24GHz continuum emission as solid contours (taken from L07). The numbers show the labels given to each of the cores. The remaining images show the continuum emission at each frequency and array configuration. The peak flux shown at the top of each image corresponds to the maximum value in that image rather than the fits to the emission reported in Table 3. Contours are in 10% steps of the peak value with the maximum contour at 90%. The primary and synthesised beam sizes are shown as a circle and filled ellipse, respectively. The linear scale is illustrated by the line in the lower left of each image. The positions of the methanol maser spots are shown as crosses, with the same angular size in each image. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 10. Radio recombination line spectra towards G24.79+0.08 in units of Jy/beam. The spectra are extracted from the peak of the emission for each of the cores and are labelled by core number & transition in the top right, and array configuration in the top left of each spectrum. Overlayed are the Gaussian fits to each spectrum outlined in § 2 and used to obtain the values in Table 4. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 11. G24.85+0.09 maps. The top-left image shows the integrated NH3(1,1) emission as dashed contours and the 24GHz continuum emission as solid contours (taken from L07). The numbers show the labels given to each of the cores. The remaining images show the continuum emission at each frequency and array configuration. The peak flux shown at the top of each image corresponds to the maximum value in that image rather than the fits to the emission reported in Table 3. Contours are in 10% steps (except the bottom three contours in the bottom right image which are separated by 5%) of the peak value with the maximum contour at 90%. The primary and synthesised beam sizes are shown as a circle and filled ellipse, respectively. The linear scale is illustrated by the line in the lower left of each image. The position of the methanol maser emission is shown as crosses, with the same angular size in each image. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 12. Radio recombination line spectrum towards G24.85+0.09 in units of Jy/beam. The spectrum is extracted from the peak of the emission and labelled by core number & transition in the top right, and array configuration in the top left of the spectrum. Overlayed are the Gaussian fits to each spectrum outlined in § 2 and used to obtain the values in Table 4. |
Processed_Too_large_and_overlooked?_Extended_free-free_emiss.txt | Figure 13. Spectral energy distributions for each of the sources detected at 24 GHz and not 8 GHz in WBHR98. Crosses and error bars show the flux densities and their corresponding uncertainties measured in this work and L07A. To mitigate problems comparing fluxes of extended sources sampled at different spatial frequencies, extended sources were re-imaged only including visibilities in the mutually overlapping spatial frequency range. Fluxes extracted from these images therefore sample the sources over similar spatial scales. The solid line shows the weighted best-fit to the detections and the corresponding spectral index is given as text. The arrows show the detection limit at 8 GHz reported in WBHR98. The dashed line shows the SED between 8 to 19 GHz of a source with a flux density at 8 GHz equal to the lower limit reported by WBHR98 and spectral index of 2. The horizontal dotted line shows the expected 19GHz flux that would be expected for a source of optically thick free-free emission, which lies just below the detection threshold of WBHR98. The 8 GHz detection limit and dashed line are omitted for G19.47+0.17 as this was too far outside the WBHR98 primary beam to determine a reliable detection limit. The dashed lines in the remaining sources show that, with the exception of G24.79+0.08, the measured flux densities in this work can not have arisen solely from an optically thick source of free-free emission lying just below the WBHR98 detection limit. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Anand Menon1 and Chris Power1,2 1International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, Western Australia 6009, Australia 2ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D) Author for correspondence: Anand Menon, Email: [email protected]. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | The baryon mass content (i.e. stellar and gas mass) of dark matter halos in the early Universe depends on both global factors - e.g. ionising ultraviolet (UV) radiation background - and local factors - e.g. star formation efficiency and assembly history. We use a lightweight semi-analytical model to investigate how both local and global factors impact the halo baryon mass content at redshifts of z ≥ 5. Our model incorporates a time delay between when stars form and when they produce feedback of 0 ≤ td/Myr ≤ 30, which can drive bursts of star formation, and a mass and redshift dependent UV background, which captures the influence of cosmological reionization on gas accretion onto halos. We use statistically representative halo assembly histories and assume that the cosmological gas accretion rate is proportional to the halo mass accretion rate. Delayed (td>0) feedback leads to oscillations in gas mass with cosmic time, behaviour that cannot be captured with instantaneous feedback (td=0). Highly efficient star formation drives stronger oscillations, while strong feedback impacts when oscillations occur; in contrast, inefficient star formation and weak feedback produce similar long-term behaviour to that observed in instantaneous feedback models. If the delayed feedback timescale is too long, a halo retains its gas reservoir but the feedback suppresses star formation. Our model predicts that lower mass systems (halo masses mh ≤ 107M⊙) at z ≤ 10 should be strongly gas deficient (mg → 0), whereas higher mass systems retain their gas reservoirs because they are sufficiently massive to continue accreting gas through cosmological reionization. Interestingly, in higher mass halos, the median m⋆/(m⋆ + mg) ≃ 0.01 – 0.05, but is a factor of 3-5 smaller when feedback is delayed. Our model does not include seed supermassive black hole feedback, which is necessary to explain massive quenched galaxies in the early Universe. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Recent observations with the JWST have revealed a poten- tial overabundance of massive galaxies (M⋆ ∼ 1010.5–11M⊙) in the high redshift Universe (z ≳ 7) when compared to the predictions of theoretical models of galaxy formation (e.g. Finkelstein, Bagley, et al. 2023; Labbé et al. 2023). This has prompted questions about the validity of the standard cosmo- logical model and the early growth of dark matter halos (e.g. Boylan-Kolchin 2023, but see Kragh Jespersen et al. 2024), as well as questions about our understanding of the interplay between gas reservoirs, star formation, and feedback at early times (e.g. Dekel et al. 2023; Boyett et al. 2024). Whether or not there is an actual overabundance of massive galaxies when compared to theoretical model predictions (see discussion in, e.g., Finkelstein, Leung, et al. 2023), the questions these obser- vations have prompted highlight the fundamental time limit imposed by the age of the Universe at early cosmic times when assessing galaxy properties, given the rate at which the highest mass dark matter halos can grow and consequently the stellar masses of the galaxies that they contain. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | to note that the main sequence lifetimes of the high mass stars (M ≥ 8M⊙) that result in supernovae are relatively short - of order 107 yrs - which, at z ≳ 6, is an appreciable fraction - approximately 10% - of a dark matter halo’s dynamical time. This means that a common assumption of galaxy formation models - that the time between star formation and supernova feedback is short and be treated as instantaneous - should break down in the high redshift Universe. Instead, feedback is delayed, leading to episodic or bursty star formation (e.g. Scalo and Struck-Marcell 1986; Faucher-Giguère 2018; Orr, Hayward, and Hopkins 2019; Furlanetto and Mirocha 2022; Pallottini and Ferrara 2023; Shen et al. 2023; Sun et al. 2023). Faucher-Giguère (2018) modelled such bursty star forma- tion and showed that it can arise when the effective equilibrium between the self-gravity of gas in a galaxy and stellar feedback following star formation cannot be maintained. This should be commonplace in galaxies at high redshifts and in lower mass galaxies across cosmic time. Indeed, there is observational evidence for bursty star formation in galaxies at high redshifts (e.g. Faisst et al. 2019; Looser et al. 2023; Strait et al. 2023). Faisst et al. (2019) concluded from a statistical sample of z ∼4.5 galaxies that the significant scatter in UV and Hα luminosities and star formation rates implied episodes of bursty star forma- tion during the prior 50 Myr. Drawing on JWST/NIRSpec data, Strait et al. (2023) found star formation is in the process of being shut down in a z = 5.2 galaxy, while Looser et al. (2023) found star formation has been quenched in a z = 7.3 galaxy; both are consistent with galaxy formation model predictions that incorporate bursty star formation (Dome et al. 2023). Sim- ilarly, there is observational evidence for bursty star formation in dwarf galaxies (e.g. Weisz et al. 2012; Emami et al. 2019), based on the distributions of UV and Hα that probe their star formation histories. Such bursty star formation arises nat- urally in hydrodynamical galaxy formation simulations that can track resolved star formation and feedback (e.g. Hopkins et al. 2023), especially in lower mass galaxies (e.g. Oñorbe et al. 2015; Muratov et al. 2015; Sparre et al. 2017) and during the epoch probed by JWST (e.g. Pallottini and Ferrara 2023; Shen et al. 2023; Sun et al. 2023). |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | the suppression of cosmological gas accretion) influence the baryon content of halos at z ≥ 5. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | In the following sections, we describe the main features of our model (§ 2); we present our results for the baryon content of halos as a function of cosmic time and halo mass (§ 3.1), showing how they are sensitive to the assumptions of our model (instantaneous versus delayed feedback, absence or presence of UV background), model parameters (e.g. star formation efficiency, delayed feedback time interval), and vari- ations in dark matter halo assembly history; and we summarise our key findings and their implications for our understanding of galaxy formation and evolution in the low-mass halo regime (§ 4). We use the cosmological parameter values Ωb = 0.0484, Ωm = 0.308, ΩΛ = 0.692, h = 0.678, σ8 = 0.815, and ns = 0.968, which are consistent with the results obtained by the Planck Collaboration et al. (2020). |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | It is straightforward to convert between t and redshift z for our adopted cosmology, which is important for evaluating the contribution of the UV background. The various parameters are now described in the following subsections. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Here the quantities Ωb and Ωm refer to the total baryon and matter densities of the Universe, respectively, and the assump- tion is that the halo accretes a baryon mass equivalent to the cosmic fraction (Ωb/Ωm) per unit dark matter accreted. We also use a pre-factor 0 ≤ ϵin ≤ 1, such that ϵin = 1 cor- responds to the accretion of the cosmic baryon fraction and ϵin = 0 corresponds to complete suppression of baryon accre- tion. We discuss this further in the context of UV suppression of cosmological accretion below. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | where ϵfb parameterises feedback efficiency and corresponds to the momentum injected by the supernovae driving the wind, and πp is the total amount of momentum from each supernova. We follow Furlanetto and Mirocha (2022) in adopting ϵfb = 5 as our fiducial value, but we also consider values in the range 2 ≤ ϵfb ≤ 7. Following Furlanetto et al. 2017, we assume πp = 2 × 1033 g cm s–2. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | here zrei is the redshift of reionization. We adopt as our fiducial value zrei = 7 but have checked the sensitivity of our results to this choice. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | This has the effect of suppressing gas accretion at halo masses below the threshold mass Mc(z) at z < zrei, with Mc(z) in- creasing with decreasing z (i.e. accretion is suppressed onto progressively higher mass halos). For redshifts z > zrei, there is no suppression of gas accretion. We refer the interested reader to Figure 1 of Kravtsov and Manwadkar (2022) for an illustration of this behaviour. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | b. We note that Kravtsov and Manwadkar (2022) explored the general case in which gas accretion is suppressed by the presence of a UV background (ϵUV), the presence of a hot halo (ϵhot), and preventive feedback (ϵprev), such that ϵin = ϵUVϵhotϵprev. We argue that suppression by hot halos and by preventive feedback can be neglected at high redshifts (i.e. ϵhotϵprev = 1, and so we consider ϵin = ϵUV. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Figure 1. Mass assembly history of a sample of 100 dark matter halos with a halo mass of mh = 108M⊙ at z=5 generated using the Parkinson, Cole, and Helly (2008) Monte Carlo merger tree algorithm. The upper and lower panels show mh (in M⊙) and ˙mh (in M⊙/Gyr) against cosmic time (in Gyrs; lower horizontal axis) and redshift (upper horizontal axis); red solid and dotted curves indicate the median, 10th, and 90th percentiles of the distributions at a given time. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | In Figure 1, we show the mass assembly histories of a sample of dark matter halos that have masses of mh = 108M⊙ at z = 5. Each individual halo is represented by a light grey curve; the median, 10th, and 90th percentiles are indicated by the red solid and dotted curves. The upper panel shows the variation of mh with cosmic time (lower horizontal axis) and redshift (upper horizontal axis), starting at z=25, while the lower panel shows the corresponding values of ˙mh. This shows that our Monte Carlo merger trees produce a diversity of assembly histories and that halos that have the same value of mh at z=5 can differ by up to an order of magnitude in mh and ˙mh at earlier times. This allows us to explore how such variation in ˙mh and the corresponding influence on ˙mc,g and ˙m⋆ affect the halos’ baryon mass content. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Figure 2. Baryon mass assembly history of an example halo with mh = 107M⊙ at z=5. The upper and middle panels show mg and m⋆ (in M⊙) against cosmic time (in Gyrs); solid (dotted) curves correspond to instantaneous star formation and feedback without (with) UV suppression of accretion (instantaneous + No UV, instantaneous + UV), while dashed (dot-dashed) curves correspond to bursty star formation from delayed feedback without (with) UV suppression of accretion (delayed + No UV, delayed + UV). For comparison, we show also the growth of mh with cosmic time in the lower panel. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | bursty star formation and UV suppression on the growth of gas and stellar mass as a function of cosmic time, we consider the cases of instantaneous star formation and feedback and no UV suppression of accretion (hereafter instantaneous + No UV; solid curves); instantaneous star formation feedback and UV suppression of gas accretion with zrei = 7 (hereafter instantaneous + UV; dotted curves); bursty star formation from delayed feedback and no UV suppression of accretion (hereafter delayed + No UV; dashed curves); and bursty star formation and feedback and UV suppression of accretion with zrei = 7 (hereafter delayed + UV; dot-dashed curves). We adopt our fiducial parameters of ϵsf = 0.015 and ϵfb = 5. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | then declines with increasing time, while m⋆ plateaus. Because mg is linked to ˙mh and the magnitude of UV suppression is both halo mass and redshift dependent, we see that mg shows an initial sharp decline but plateaus after 1.5 Gyr. For the delayed + No UV case, we see the characteristic strong oscillations in mg - and to a lesser extent in m⋆ - evident during the initial 0.5 Gyr, but as the halo grows, these oscillations damp away, and both quantities are indistinguishable from the case with instantaneous star formation and feedback. Similarly, for the delayed + UV case, we see these oscillations in mg and m⋆ repeated. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Figure 3. Influence of halo mass assembly history: Baryon mass assembly history of a sample of 100 halos with mh = 107M⊙ at z=5. The upper and lower panels show the median values of mg and m⋆ (in M⊙) against cosmic time (in Gyrs); dotted curves correspond to the instantaneous + UV case, while dot-dashed curves correspond to the delayed + UV case. The coloured bands indicate the range of the 10th and 90th percentiles. |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | that the variations in m⋆ are similar in magnitude for both the instantaneous + UV and delayed + UV cases (∼ 0.5 dex at early times, ∼ 1 dex at later times). |
Processed_On_bursty_star_formation_during_cosmological_reion.txt | Figure 4. Influence of star formation efficiency: Baryon mass assembly history of a sample of 100 halos with mh = 107M⊙ at z=5. The upper and lower panels show the median values of mg and m⋆ (in M⊙) against cosmic time (in Gyrs) for ϵsf=0.0015 (inefficient) and ϵsf=0.1 (efficient) respectively. Dotted curves correspond to the instantaneous + UV case, while dot-dashed curves correspond to the delayed + UV case. The coloured bands indicate the range of the 10th and 90th percentiles. The greyed bands and curves correspond to the counterpart cases with the fiducial value of ϵsf=0.015. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | its International public health policies increasingly favor mandatory immunization. If there has been little short-term effects on vaccine coverage are well documented, consideration to its effects on public attitudes towards vaccines. In this paper, we examine Google searches related to vaccines in five countries (Australia, France, Germany, Italy, least one vaccine Serbia) and two American states (California) which experienced at mandate extension in the past decade. We found that the effects of a new mandate implementation heavily depends on the context in each specific country or state. We also the passing of new or extended mandates observed that attenuated public doubt towards vaccines. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Faced with the difficulties of reaching or persuading non-vaccinating parents, public health authorities are increasingly placing their hopes in mandates (Omer et al., 2019). Mandatory vaccination can take many forms (Attwell and Navin, 2019; Harmon et al., 2020). In the past years, several countries and American states have passed new legislation establishing mandatory vaccination or reinforcing pre-existing legislations (Omer et al., 2019). The most commented examples of this trend have been the decision made by the state of California in 2015 to repeal non-medical exemptions to vaccination requirements for school attendance and the announcement made in both France and Italy in 2017 that the list of vaccines required for school admission would be extended (Omer et al., 2019) (Ward, Peretti-Watel et al., 2019). Evidence suggests that mandates are effective in increasing vaccine coverage more often than not (Colgrove, 2016; Greyson et al., 2019; Omer et al., 2019). For instance, studies conducted in the United States have shown that childhood vaccination rates were lower in states in which vaccine exemptions were easier to obtain (Olive et al., 2018; Shaw et al., 2018) and that the states with the most strict mandates seem to be the only ones able to avoid clusters of non-compliance (Garnier et al., 2020). Recent to obtain studies attempting to assess the effect of reforms making it more difficult exemptions in Washington (Omer et al., 2018) and in California (Buttenheim et al., 2018) confirmed the expectation that such measures can help increase vaccine coverage. In France, early assessments of the extension of vaccine mandates show an increase in vaccine coverage even for vaccines not covered by the new mandate (Lévy-Brühl et al., 2019). Recent research on 29 European countries showed that those where vaccination against MMR was mandatory have better vaccine coverage than those without (Vaz et al., 2020). But the introduction or reinforcement of mandates are also known to sometimes backfire and amplify tensions surrounding vaccination (Colgrove, 2016; Omer et al., 2019). Famously, the great antivaccine movements of 19th century Great Britain and early 20th century Brasil emerged in reaction to such measures (Durbach, 2005; Meade, 1986). Historians of vaccination have underlined the fact the risk of alienating a large part of the public has always been taken into consideration by policymakers (Colgrove, 2006; McCoy, 2019). When negative attitudes towards vaccines are prevalent, is possible that mandates participate in radicalising hesitants who will resent being forced to vaccinate their children. While this might not appear in vaccine coverage, this can have long-lasting effects on trust in public health institutions and affect coverage of non-mandatory vaccines or new vaccines. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | where the internet has enabled a rapid sharing of arguments and experience. In Australia, a survey conducted over a year after the “No jab, no pay” reform suggested opposition to vaccines had remained very weak (Smith et al., 2017). In France, a comparison of surveys conducted before and after the mandate extension of 2018 suggests the proportion of vaccine hesitants has decreased but remained at a high level (Cohen et al., 2020; Larson et al., 2018). Research based on survey-type data is essential to assess the proportion of the population susceptible to vaccine hesitancy as well as the social geography of attitudes to vaccines. But the use of such data to assess the evolution of vaccine hesitancy is problematic as it is based on declarations, production cost make it a scarce resource, and the results of each wave of survey can be highly dependent on the short-term context in which it is conducted - i.e. whether vaccines are making the news in the week or month in which the survey was conducted. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | We collected data through the API of Google Trends (Google, 2021). For each country or state, values returned by the API are proportionate to the time and location of a query. Each actual number of searches is divided by the total number of searches in the country or state during the period studied, to get an idea of the relative popularity of the query. The resulting numbers are then scaled on a range of 0 to 100 (Google, 2021). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | controversy seems to have focused on the MMR vaccine and the use of mercury-based adjuvants which are wrongly accused of causing autism. In France, the main debate has been over the use of aluminium-based adjuvants. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | We monitored these queries for five countries: Australia, France, Germany, Italy and Serbia ; and two American States: California and Washington. In these six countries, Google is by far the search engine most widely used by Internet users. In our sample of jurisdiction, between 83% (USA) and 97% (Serbia) of queries on the internet were performed on Google in 2019 (Statista, 2019). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | We worked on a period ranging from January 1st, 2011 to November, 1st 2019. We have chosen this period which follows the aftermath of the H1N1 influenza crisis, and which precedes the onset of the covid-19 pandemic. Indeed, these two events generated a huge volume of internet queries concerning vaccination. Including these events would completely overshadow all variations observable in recent years. For each country, we highlighted the period between the month of the beginning of a debate around a new vaccine mandate policy (government official announcement, or rumors in a major national media) and its implementation. When no date clearly emerged, we highlighted the six-months period before the policy implementation. For each country or state included in our sample, we present below the context in which the policy change was announced, the nature of the policy change and the timeframe of its implementation. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | We detected abnormally high or low levels of Google searches by running a time series outlier detection algorithm (Chen and Liu, 1993). To that end, for each of our datasets, we run an automated search for the best Autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model - the widest class of models for forecasting a time series. The parameters (p,d,q) - where p is the number of autoregressive terms ; d the number of nonseasonal differences needed for stationarity ; q the number of lagged forecast errors in the prediction equation - are automatically selected to optimize the Akaike Information Criterion. These ARIMA models also help us assess the impact of vaccine mandate extensions on queries in the short and longer run. Detailed results for each of the 21 models are provided in the supplementary file. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | To understand which events could reasonably explain why such peaks have occurred, we search on Google the date at which the major peaks occur and the query monitored (e.g. “vaccine august 2011”). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | California On January 1st, 2012, California enforced Assembly Bill 2109, requiring parents to prove they consulted a medical professional about vaccines - a new policy which resulted in a reduction of non-medical exemption by 25% (Buttenheim et al., 2018). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | A new bill (Senate Bill 277) signed in July 2015 (Mello et al., 2015), and enforced from January 1st 2016 on, eliminated nonmedical exemptions for school entry. This raised concerns about medical exemptions being used instead of nonmedical exemptions (Mohanty, 2018). To prevent this trend from further developing, a new bill, (Senate Bill 276) was examined on April 24th, 2019, adopted in September 2019 and came into effect on January 1st, 2020. From then on, a state health official will have to review all medical exemptions at schools who did not share their vaccination rates, in which less than 95% of students are actually vaccinated, or from doctors who submit five or more exemptions within a year. In case of suspected fraud, physicians will be reported to California’s medical board, and exemptions reversed. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Washington At the beginning of the 2010s, Washington state had one of the highest rates of nonmedical exemptions in the USA (Constable et al., 2014). Faced with a pertussis outbreak the state changed its exemption law in July 2011, requiring parents looking for a in 2010, non-medical exemption to prove they discussed the risks and benefits of vaccines with a medical practitioner. After debates in 2015 about tightening these rules (Corte, 2015), a measles outbreak sickening 74 persons in the state in 2019 prompted a new reform, passed by the Washington senate in April 2019, abrogating philosophical exemptions for the MMR vaccine (Gutman, 2019). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | searches at the time of the H1N1 pandemic widely outnumber the peaks of the following ten years. Searches during this pandemic ranged from almost twice as many as during the peak of Google searches during a vaccine mandate extension in California or the Washington State, to more than 14 times as many in France. Other important peaks of interest are also linked to epidemic episodes. The most important peaks during the 2011-2019 period occurred during measles outbreaks (in Serbia, California and Washington State) or severe flu epidemics (in Australia). Only in Italy did the reinforcement of mandates have a greater impact on Google queries on vaccination than any epidemics. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Figure 2 shows the evolution of Google searches on vaccination and vaccination hazards in our seven geographical regions of interest. Figure 3 focuses only on queries related to the “dangers” of vaccines, for better readability. As we can see, some trends are common to all or most of the countries and states studied here. The seasonality of searches varies from country to country, but is almost always present. This shows the important impact of school calendars and flu season on the questions that Internet users ask themselves about vaccination. However, the amplitude of this seasonality differs greatly. It is extremely strong in a country such as Australia, for example. In fact, the flu season is sometimes a time when Google searches reach their peak over the 2011-2019 period, as in France or Germany (fig. 1). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Yet, each time a discussion about a new vaccine mandate takes place, the search volumes regarding both vaccination in general, and their alleged dangers, increase significantly, if not dramatically. The only exception is Serbia, where almost no impact is observed. But the discussion of a policy change does not seem to positively or negatively influence the trend in Google searches. The medium-term effects of these decisions on interest in vaccination, or concern about its alleged side effects, seem minor or imperceptible. An exception to this observation would appear to be Italy, where searches on these themes have even decreased after the decision to extend the vaccination obligation. There is also a temporary change in trend in California. For a year and a half, searches on vaccines stagnated rather than increased - but eventually the trend began to pick up again. Finally, in France, searches about the risks of aluminum in vaccines increased during the debates preceding the mandate extension, but decreased after it was passed. On the other hand, queries about the risks of vaccines slightly increased after the 2017 reform. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | We can also observe major differences between countries. It is striking to note how the proportion of vaccine related queries that focus on concerns about the risks of vaccines varies from country to country. In particular, the percentage of such queries in France and Germany is much greater than in any other country or state in our sample. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Figure 1 - Heatmap: extreme values of vaccine-related queries (as a global topic) on Google from January 2004 to November 2019 : peak of queries during the H1N1 pandemics ; peak of queries during the vaccine mandate extension generating the most searches during the period ; absolute peak of queries from January 2011 to November 2019. 100 denotes the most important value during the 2004-2019 period. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Figure 2 - Evolution of Google queries for vaccine-related keywords from January 2011 to November 2019: in blue, keywords related to the global vaccine topic ; in red, keywords related to the global “dangers” of vaccines ; in yellow, keywords related to specific vaccine controversies. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Figure 3 - Evolution of Google queries for vaccine-related keywords from January 2011 to November 2019: in red, keywords related to the global “dangers” of vaccines ; in yellow, keywords related to specific vaccine controversies ; in grey, period of discussion then enforcement of the new mandates. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Figure 4 - Synthesis of the Chen and Liu’s peak detection procedure results on the temporal series of Google searches: presence or absence of a statistically significant peak during a vaccine mandate extension (see supplementary material). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | We analysed the evolution of vaccine-related queries on google performed between January 2011 and November 2019 in seven countries or American States which passed new more strict legislation on vaccination during that period (Australia, France, Germany, Serbia, Italy, the State of California and the State of Washington). Our main finding is that the passing of these legislations was rarely associated with a decrease of hesitancy-driven queries. The only exceptions are Italy and, more marginally and for a limited period of time, California. On the other hand, in Australia and Serbia, the passing of new mandates was followed by an increase of queries on vaccination in general and side effects in particular. We the period between the announcement of the new legislation and its also found that application was associated with increased interest in vaccination, including more queries directly pertaining to the purported side effects of vaccines. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | theory about the dangers of vaccination might not really be worried about it, but simply want to know more about a theory they have heard but consider to be far-fetched, or want to criticize. It seems unlikely, however, that this would be the prevailing pattern. Cultural variations in the use of the Internet in general, and of the search engine Google in particular, could also bias our study, even if, as we have shown above, its use is extremely widespread in each of the countries studied. However, while vaccine controversies have been much studied on social networks, they have been much less studied in relation to queries on Google, even though this is one of the main ways people look for information on the Internet. Future studies could combine these two perspectives to better understand the evolution of attitudes towards vaccination. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Our results have several implications for public health. The main implication is that the effect of mandates on attitudes depends greatly on national contexts. Public authorities have historically been somewhat aware of the complex effects of mandates (Colgorove, 2006; McCoy, 2019). This is testified in the great variety of forms taken by mandatory vaccination around the globe which tend to be adapted to the precise issues faced at the moment of their design and the local institutional idiosyncrasies (Attwell and Navin, 2019; McCoy, 2019). But in the current context where public health authorities increasingly (rightly) rely on international academic publications and reports by trans-national organisations to devise their policy, there is a risk of relying too heavily on the experiences of a limited number of countries and adopt a “one size fits all” approach. For this reason, most specialists of vaccination behavior recommend great caution and attention to local contexts when deciding whether and how to mandate vaccines (Omer et al., 2019). |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | that policy changes do not seem to constitute the main driver of internet queries in our study. The announcement, discussion or application of new mandatory vaccination policies seem to be only one of several events susceptible to increase interest in vaccination and their purported side-effects in at least some countries. In our case studies, we found spikes in number of internet searches associated with epidemic outbreaks (such as the measles outbreak of 2015 but also the 2009 H1N1 influenza pandemic and the current COVID-19 outbreak), the launch of the seasonal flu vaccination campaign, and the annual procedure of school enrolment for children (in Australia). These very different types of events have in common the fact that they tend to be very widely covered by the media. Much like these other events, the passing of new legislation seems to put vaccines under the collective looking glass. This is important because experts in vaccination behaviours have emphasized the importance of integrating vaccination in the daily routine of people, and parents in particular. To reach wide coverage, vaccination must become a normal, almost automatic act, one that is not constantly questioned (Dubé et al., 2018). Indeed, belief in the safety and efficacy of recommended vaccines is regularly compromised by the irruption of vaccine-critical communication in the daily lives of people via multiple communication channels: relatives and friends, content recommendations on social media, media debates… Parents might not be directly convinced by such discourses, but they nonetheless can have the effect of foregrounding vaccines as an object of concern, investigation, which can in turn lead to more consultation of necessitating further vaccine-critical information easily accessible via a simple query on Google or elsewhere on the internet (Peretti‐Watel et al., 2019; Sobo et al., 2016). Specialists of the ethics of in a context where disinformation is vaccination have often underlined this paradox: everywhere and where people’s cognition can fall prey to a number of cognitive biases, the search for more information can be detrimental to adherence to vaccination (Navin, 2015). If the passing of new legislation leads to further interest in vaccines and their side effects, as we have found, the public and journalists can easily find reliable information on vaccines in the fewest number of clicks possible. Our data suggests this information must be available at the moment of the announcement of the upcoming change in legislation, not later, when it is finally put into effect. This means that communication efforts must not only accompany the passing of stricter mandates, it must precede it. The effectiveness of mandates paradoxically rests on the early application of the measures that can potentially render the recourse to mandates superfluous. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Whether the path leads to mandatory vaccination or not, such as in the case of a future the first step is always building trust and that COVID-19 vaccine, our results suggest providing people, healthcare providers and journalists with reliable and easily accessible information. |
Processed_Reinforcement_of_vaccine_mandates_and_public_attit.txt | Google, 2021. FAQ about Google Trends data - Trends Help [WWW Document]. URL https://support.google.com/trends/answer/4365533?hl=en (accessed 1.17.21). |
Processed_Large_N_QCD_--_Continuum_reduction.txt | Numerical evidence combined with Eguchi-Kawai reduction indicate that there are no finite volumes effects in the large N limit of QCD as long as the linear extent of the four-torus is bigger than a critical size. This is referred to as continuum reduction. Since fermions in the fundamental representation are naturally quenched in the large N limit, as long as we only have a finite number of flavors, continuum reduction provides us with the exciting possibility to numerically solve large N QCD using chiral fermions and present day computers. |
Processed_Large_N_QCD_--_Continuum_reduction.txt | Overlap fermions [1] enables one to compute quantities in the chiral limit of lattice QCD. But one has to work with ǫ(γ5Dw(−m)) where Dw(−m) is the Wilson-Dirac operator in the su- percritical region and ǫ is the sign function of the operator. This makes the algorithms on the lat- tice computationally intensive and the situation is further complicated by the presence of very small eigenvalues of γ5Dw(−m) [2]. In spite of these difficulties several results have been obtained in the quenched approximation [3] and dynamical simulations using overlap fermions have been ex- plored [4]. |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.