Filename
stringlengths 22
64
| Paragraph
stringlengths 8
5.57k
|
|---|---|
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | scaling relationship between the SZE and X-ary derived properties (Huang et al. 2008), and the baryonic frac- tion when our SZE data are jointly analyzed with the Subaru lensing data (Umetsu et al. 2008). Brief conclu- sions are given in Section 7. We have other companion papers investigating the system performance (Lin et al. 2008), the foreground (Liu et al. 2008), and data in- tegrity (Nishioka et al. 2008). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 1.— (a) Left: the measured primary beam of one of the 60-cm antennas. (b) Right: azimuthally averaged beam shape (solid) and a Gaussian fit (dashed); the dotted lines indicate the FWHM. In both plots the intensity is in units of db normalized to the peak value. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 2.— The u-v coverage of a typical observation by seven- element AMiBA (left) and its corresponding noise-weighted synthesized beam (the dirty beam; right). In the left plot, the color scale indicates the relative sensitivity in u-v space, while the dots mark the u-v modes sampled by the typical AMiBA observation. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | line operates at two frequency channels centered at each with a band width f = 90 and 98 GHz, of 8 GHz. Thus the three baseline lengths corre- spond to six multipole bands ℓ = 2π√u2 + v2 = 2πLbf /c = [1092, 1193], [1891, 2067], [2067, 2243], [2184, 2387], [2387, 2590]. These baselines have a six-fold symmetry (Ho et al. 2008a). To achieve better u-v coverage and thus a better imaging capabil- ity, we observe each target at eight different polariza- tion angles of the platform with an angular step of 7.5 degrees, uniformly covering azimuthal angles in the u-v plane with 48 discrete samples for each of the three differ- ent baseline lengths at each of the two frequency bands. This makes a total of 288 discrete u-v samples. Figure 2 shows such typical u-v coverage, with the correspond- ing noise-weighted point spread function from a typical observation, the so-called ‘dirty beam’. The FWHM of the dirty beam is about 6 arcminutes, defining the syn- thesized resolution of the seven-element AMiBA. When using an equal-weighted (rather than the current noise- weighted) scheme to construct the dirty beam, we still obtain a similar resolution of about 6 arcminutes because the noise level for each baseline is about the same. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 3.— Modulation between the target (left) and the blank sky (center) successfully removes the strong contribu- tions from ground pickup and electronic offset. The difference map (right) clearly reveals the signal from cluster A2142. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | greater than the RA of the target. Since it takes 10 sec- onds for the telescope to slew between the fields, the two patches are observed over identical azimuth and eleva- tion tracks. During both tracks the platform polariza- tion angle is controlled so that each baseline corresponds to a fixed u-v mode. The recorded data during the two tracks should then contain the same contribution from ground pickup, which is removed by a subsequent differ- encing of the two tracks. This strategy requires that both the electronic offset and the ground emission are stable within 6 minutes, which is far shorter as compared with the measured time dependence (Lin et al. 2008). The penalty for adopting such a two-patch strategy is the loss of efficiency by a factor of 4, where a factor of 2 comes from doubling the observing time and the other factor of 2 from doubling the noise variance when dif- ferencing the two patches. We also note that there is a CMB component as well as possible combinations from Galactic foreground and extragalactic point sources in the differencing map though at a level much lower than the expected SZE of massive clusters (Liu et al. 2008). Nevertheless before observations we did check our fields for such contaminations. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Figure 3 demonstrates the application of the two-patch observing strategy for SZE mapping. The left panel is an image constructed from the leading patch, contain- ing cluster Abell 2142 (see Sec. 4 for the formalism and procedure of data analysis). The middle panel shows the corresponding image from the trailing patch of blank sky. It is clear that both patches are contaminated by signals much stronger than the SZE (mainly from the ground pickup), and that the images are closely similar. The difference of the two patches reveals the cluster signal (right panel), whose signal strength is only about 1% of the contamination signal in individual patches. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 4.— Dirty images of Saturn (left) and the quasar J0325+2224 (right), both calibrated by Jupiter using the for- malism presented in Sec. 4. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | ibration error to be within 5% in gain and 0.1 radian in phase (Lin et al. 2008). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | To test the overall performance of our observing, cal- ibration, and analysis strategy, we first used the Sun to successfully phase-calibrate an observation of Jupiter, and then Jupiter to phase and amplitude calibrate an observation of Saturn. The left plot of Figure 4 shows a dirty image of Saturn calibrated by an observation of Jupiter made four hours later. The FWHM of this im- age is identical to that of the dirty beam shown in Fig- ure 2, and the index of asymmetry (Wu et al. 2001) of the cleaned image is well below 5%. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | After further fine tuning of the system, in April 2007 we detected our first SZE cluster, Abell 2142 with a central SZE decrement of around -320 mJy per beam. During 2007 we observed a total of six S-Z clusters with 0.091 0.322: A1689, A1995, A2142, A2163, A2261, ≤ ≤ and A2390. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Note. — Observing log for the AMiBA observations of six clusters of galaxies, including the pointing directions, the observing (tobs) and integration (tint) times per baseline, and the synthesized resolution (syn. res.; the FWHM of the azimuthally averaged dirty beam). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | servations at other frequencies, and the existence of ex- tensive published X-ray data. The observational con- venience requires that the targets can be seen at the Mauna-Loa latitude of 19.54◦ N, at the night time when the system is stable (between about 8pm and 8am), and during the main observing period between April and August in 2007. Several cluster catalogs are compiled and studied for the expected SZE flux at AMiBA fre- quency, including OVRO (30 GHz; Mason et al. 2001), OVRO/BIMA (30 GHz; Grego et al. 2001; Reese et al. Lancaster et al. 2005), and 2002), VSA (34 GHz; SuZIE II (145, 221, and 355 GHz; Benson et al. 2004). 0.3 is so chosen that massive The redshift range of z < ∼ clusters of a typical virial radius of few Mpc is resolvable by AMiBA, whose resolution (6′) corresponds to a physi- cal scale of 1.6 Mpc at z = 0.3 in a flat ΛCDM cosmology with matter density parameter Ωm = 0.3, cosmological constant density parameter ΩΛ = 0.7, and Hubble con- stant H0 = 70 km s−1Mpc−1. Among these six clusters, only A1689 and A2390 are known to have relaxed with a nearly isothermal profile. A1689 has a regular mor- phology in X-ray while A2390 is elongated. A2163, by contrast, is a merger with shocks and high-temperature regions, and A2142 is a merger with a strong frontal structure. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Due to the missing-flux problem, most studies for the scientific implications of our results require the assis- tance of X-ray derived properties of the clusters. In Table 2, we summarize the critical X-ray derived pa- rameters for the AMiBA clusters, which will be used by our companion science papers (Huang et al. 2008; Koch et al. 2008b; Liu et al. 2008; Umetsu et al. 2008). The X-ray temperatures are from Reese et al. (2002) for A2163, A2261, A1689, and A1995, Markevitch et al. (1998) for A2142, and Allen (2000) for A2390. The power-law index β in the isothermal β-model and the core radius θc are from Reese et al. (2002) for A2163, A2261, A1689, and A1995, Sanderson & Ponman (2003) for A2142, and Bohringer et al. (1998) for A2390. The X-ray core radii are mostly below one arcminute except for A2142 and A2163. These parameters are mostly X- emission weighted but not corrected for any cooling flows, which we further discuss in some science analyses such as the estimation of the Hubble constant H0 (Koch et al. 2008b). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | We describe the formalism that we use to analyze AMiBA data from their raw format to the calibrated visibilities, images, and cluster profiles. AMiBA oper- ates with a bandwidth of 16 GHz centered at 94 GHz. Its four-lag correlators provide two pass-bands of 8 GHz processing dual linear polarizations. The challenge for the analysis of such data arises because the measured output of the instrument is not visibilities and because there are only two channels of wide bands causing con- siderable band-smearing effect in frequency. With the formalism presented here we successfully used the Sun to calibrate the image of Jupiter, and then used several planets (Jupiter, Saturn, Mars, Venus) to cross-calibrate. Jupiter was chosen as the primary calibrator for our sci- ence results. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | After this flagging, we difference the tracking data cb(τm; t) in the two-patch observation in order to remove ground pickup and the electronic DC offset. 4σ outliers in the temporal domain are clipped before the differenced tracking data are integrated over the 3-minute (4-minute for the calibration) tracking period to yield the lag data cb(τm) cb(τm; t) t. Thus each two-patch observation i yields a set of four lags cb(τm) (m = 1–4). We carefully verified that the noise of the lag data is white within the time scale of 10 minutes, assuring the scaling of the noise level with the two-patch integration time (Nishioka et al. 2008). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | where τm (m = 1–4) is the time delay for each of the four lags, Rb(f ) and φb(f ) are the instrumental frequency- dependent gain- and phase-responses respectively, f0 is the frequency of the Local Oscillator (86 GHz), and f1 and f2 indicate the upper and lower ends of the response frequency range i.e. [f1, f2] = [86, 102] GHz for AMiBA. Our analysis must invert Equation (5) to obtain the cal- ibrated visibilities vb(f ). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Figure 5 shows our first-light lag data cb(τm) of a drift scan on Jupiter. The fringing rate is determined by the angle between a baseline and the drift direction. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Further flagging of 4σ outliers is applied in the visibil- ity space (see Sec. 4.3). Table 3 shows the percentages of data that are flagged out by each step. On average the fraction of good data is about 60%. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 5.— First-light lag data cb(τm) of a drift scan on Jupiter in September 2006. Each panel represents one baseline, with an ‘XY ’ label at the bottom-right corner indicating the correlation between the antennae X and Y . X = 1 represents the central antenna, with the other six close-packed around it. In each panel, the four black curves and four red curves correspond to the lag outputs of the LL and RR cross-polarization modes respectively (see Sec. 2). Here a low-pass filtering at 0.05 Hz is used to remove high-frequency noise. The horizontal time axis is the offset relative to the transit time. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Since the involved operations are linear, there must exist a calibration matrix Cb that corrects this discrepancy, i.e. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | where #t is the number of temporal data in the time in- tegration. Then (σb c)2 constitute the diagonal elements of the lag-lag noise correlation matrix Nb . i The off-diagonal elements are found to be less than 10% of the diagonal elements (Nishioka et al. 2008) so we ap- proximate them as zeros. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | v ≡ h 4.5. Image Making and Cleaning We construct the ‘dirty’ image of a cluster by making a continuous inverse Fourier transform of all the band- visibilities from all days and all baselines, with noise weighting based on the noise variance. The instanta- neous u-v coverage is improved in AMiBA operation by rotating the platform to eight polarization angles, giving a uniform angular interval of 7◦.5 between sampled u-v modes k (see Sec. 3.2). Figure 6 shows the dirty images of these clusters. The flux decrement at the center of each target is evident, as expected for the SZE signal at the AMiBA center frequency of 94 GHz (see Sec. 2). The left part of Table 4 summarizes the angular sizes (az- imuthally averaged FWHM) and the peak fluxes directly measured from these images. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | cleaned images are summarized in the right part of Ta- ble 4. The apparent angular sizes, as compared with the synthesized resolution of about 6′, indicate that we have partially resolved clusters A2142, A2163, and A2390, while A1689, A1995, and A2261 appear unresolved in these images. The SZE signals observed here are at the level of few hundred mJy, indeed consistent with the the- 200 mJy as discussed in oretical expectation ∆ISZE ∼ − Sec. 2. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | In Table 4, the S/N ratios are computed as the peak flux of the cleaned model (uncorrected for the primary- beam attenuation) divided by the RMS of the noise resid- ual map. We note that the noise level in these results are dominated by the instrumental noise, leading to the fact that the scaling among the peak flux, S/N ratios, and integration time is consistent with the noise equiv- alent flux (point-source sensitivity) of 63 mJy√hr. for the on-source integration time in a 2-patch observation (Lin et al. 2008), i.e. for a 2-hour observation, one hour per patch, the noise RMS is 63 mJy. Simulations also show that our analysis method (described in Sec. 4.2–4.4) does not bias the SZE amplitude but induces a statisti- cal error at the few-percent level. The calibration error is controlled within 5 % (Lin et al. 2008). The systematic effect from CMB anisotropy is estimated to be at a sim- ilar level as the instrumental noise, and the point-source contamination causes an underestimate of the SZE am- plitude by about 10 % (Liu et al. 2008). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | kn 2 − where x0 is the SZE cluster center, x1 is the pointing direction, B(x) is the primary beam, and the integration accounts for the frequency band-smearing effect. These are equivalent to the band-visibilities at x1 = x0 vp { and therefore are real numbers. They indicate the cluster profile in the visibility space. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Markov Chain Monte-Carlo (MCMC) approach with Metropolis-Hastings sampling is used for this eight- dimensional likelihood analysis. For each cluster three MCMC chains of 200,000 samples are used. The results are given in Table 5 and Figure 8. For all clusters the ex- pected SZE decrement in flux density is evident. We note that although the primary CMB makes a non-negligible contribution to our observed visibilities (Liu et al. 2008), it appears with random phase in u-v space and thus will not bias our analysis here but rather contribute as part of the error bars. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 6.— Dirty images of the six SZE clusters observed by AMiBA. The white circles indicate the half-maximum contour of the primary beam (the field of view; 23′), while the blue regions at the bottom-right corners indicate the half-maximum regions of the noise-weighted synthesized beams (∼ 6′). The central decrements in flux density within the field of view provide strong evidence for the detections of SZE clusters. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Note. — The maximum-likelihood results for the coordinates of SZE cluster centers x0 and band-visibility profiles {vp}. The values v1–v6 correspond to the multipole bands of ℓ = [1092, 1193], [1193, 1295], [1891, 2067], [2067, 2243], [2184, 2387], [2387, 2590] respectively (see Sec. 3.2, Sec. 4.6). v1, v3, v5 correspond to the frequency band of [86, 94] GHz, and v2, v4, v6 correspond to [94, 102] GHz. The three baseline lengths Lb are 0.606 m (for v1, v2), 1.05 m (for v3, v4), and 1.212 m (for v5, v6). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 7.— Cleaned SZE images of clusters observed by seven-element AMiBA. The white circles indicate the half-maximum contour of the primary beam (the field of view; 23′), and the blue patches at the bottom-right corners show the half-maximum regions of the dirty beams (∼ 6′). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 8.— Visibility profiles {vp} of AMiBA SZE clusters. The data for the crosses are summarized in Table 5, while the boxes are the noise weighted average of the two frequency bands at each baseline length. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | and x0 are independent of cluster model. They can be further com- pared or combined with other experimental results, or fit- ted with a specific cluster model, for further study. The approach here is different from that in Liu et al. (2008), where an isothermal β-model is directly fitted with the visibilities to estimate the central brightness I0, with the core radius θc and the power index β taken from X-ray analysis. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Fig. 9.— Both dirty images (left and middle) of A2142 analyzed from two equally divided sub datasets show a clear SZE signal of flux decrement, while their difference (right) indicates no recognizable signal but noise. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | We carried out several other tests for systematics. Long-duration (12-hour) observations of planets were used to check the stability of the system; an indepen- dent analysis path produced results for A2142 consistent to high accuracy with those presented here; and several two-patch blank-sky observations showed no signal above the expected CMB confusion (Lin et al. 2008). The noise properties of the lag data were investigated in detail indi- cating no systematics and no significant non-Gaussianity (Nishioka et al. 2008). The asymmetry of the antenna beams (Wu et al. 2001) was shown to be negligible. The pointing error is small enough that it has negligible ef- fects on our results (Koch et al. 2008a), and the radio alignment was tuned to improve efficiency and tested for stability (Wu et al. 2008b). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | Note. — The integrated Compton parameter Y2500 measured by AMiBA (86–102 GHz; Huang et al. 2008) as compared with re- sults from OVRO/BIMA (30 GHz; deduced from Morandi et al. 2008, relativistic correction considered) and SuZIE II (145 GHz; deduced from Benson et al. 2004, relativistic correction consid- ered). |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | on data from other observations, and provide comple- mentary information at the same time. A number of tests show that the system performs as expected from its design, and we anticipate that the current expansion to a 13-element system (Ho et al. 2008b; Wu et al. 2008a) will boost its capability for the study of CMB cosmology. |
Processed_AMiBA_Observations,_Data_Analysis_and_Results_for_.txt | We thank the Ministry of Education, the National Sci- ence Council, the Academia Sinica, and National Taiwan University for their support of this project. We thank the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory for hosting the AMiBA project staff at the SMA Hilo Base Facility. We thank the NOAA for locating the AMiBA project on their site on Mauna Loa. We thank the Hawaiian people for allowing astronomers to work on their mountains in order to study the Universe. This work is also supported by National Center for Theoretical Science, and Center for Theoretical Sciences, National Taiwan University for J.H.P. Wu. We are grateful for computing support from the National Center for High-Performance Computing, Taiwan. Support from the STFC for M. Birkinshaw and K. Lancaster is also acknowledged. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | Abstract — An analytical approach to a search process is a mathematical prerequisite for digital synchronization and acquisition optimization. A search is performed for an arbitrary set of sequences within random but not equiprobable L-ary data. This paper derives in detail an expression for probability distribution function, from which other statistical parameters - expected value and variance – can be obtained. The probabilistic nature of (cross-) bifix indicators is shown and application examples are outlined, ranging beyond the usual telecommunication fiel d. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | The next section introduces the basic elements necessary for derivation. Within the third section the statistical parameters for M=1 case are derived, extended to M>1 case within the section IV. The possible application and topics for further research are outlined within the concluding remarks. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | An objective of the search process is to find one of the M predefined sequences of length N while performing the tests along a stream of random L- ary data. The pro cess itself is simple, but the statistics describing it were not, so the first ones were obtained by simulation study. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | Further research, by this author, added the probability distribution function and variance to already known expected value [3]. The results were later extended to the case of set of M sequences [4]. Since the applications that have followed [5, 6 and 7] were related to digital transmission assuming scrambled data, at equiprobable level were considered complete. A motivation to switch to non-equiprobable case was initiated by a suggestion of anonymous reviewer of [6]. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | Starting at the random point, a search is performed, stopping at the moment when the first N-symbols long sequence , out of the set of M predefined sequences, is observed. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | A cross-bifix is a subsequence of length n, n£ N , that is a suffix of one sequence and a prefix of is denoted hij(n), where another. subscripts i and j denote respectively sequences which suffix and prefix are observed, and superscript (n) denote the cross-bifix length. The default values are hii(N)=1 (a sequence is equal to itself), hij(N )=0, i„j (no two sequences out of M ones are the same) and hij(0)=1 (for the reasons that would be clear after the next section), i,j £ M. |
Processed_Search_Process_and_Probabilistic_Bifix_Approach.txt | E{k} = T – expected duration of a search; - E{k2} – second moment; - s 2 = E{k2} - E2{k} – variance. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | InfraRed Array Camera (IRAC) data we define the IR colors of PNe and demon- strate good isolation between these colors and those of many other types of as- tronomical object. The only substantive contamination of PNe in the color-color plane we illustrate is due to YSOs. However, this ambiguity is readily resolved by the unique optical characteristics of PNe and their environs. We also examine the relationships between optical and MIR morphologies from 3.6 to 8.0 µm, and explore the ratio of mid-infrared (MIR) to radio nebular fluxes, which is a valu- able discriminant between thermal and nonthermal emission. MASH emphasizes late evolutionary stages of PNe compared with previous catalogs, enabling study of the changes in MIR and radio flux that attend the aging process. Spatially in- tegrated MIR energy distributions were constructed for all MASH PNe observed by the GLIMPSE Legacy Project, using the Hα morphologies to establish the di- mensions for the calculations of the Midcourse Space Experiment (MSX), IRAC, and radio continuum (from the Molonglo Observatory Synthesis Telescope and the Very Large Array) flux densities. The ratio of IRAC 8.0-µm to MSX 8.3-µm flux densities provides a measure of the absolute diffuse calibration of IRAC at 8.0 µm. We independently confirm the aperture correction factor to be applied to IRAC at 8.0 µm to align it with the diffuse calibration of MSX. The result is in accord with the recommendations of the Spitzer Science Center, and with our results from a parallel study of Hii regions in the MIR and radio. However, these PNe probe the diffuse calibration of IRAC on a spatial scale of 9′′ − 77′′, as opposed to the many arcmin scale from the study of Hii regions. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | objects for which Spitzer Space Telescope (Werner et al. 2004: hereafter SST) observations are available between 3.6 and 8.0 µm from the GLIMPSE survey of portions of the Galactic Plane (Benjamin et al. 2003; Churchwell et al. 2004). We compare multiwavelength images of PNe in Hα, the 8.3-µm band of the Midcourse Space Experiment (MSX: Price et al. 2001), the four InfraRed Array Camera (IRAC: Fazio et al. 2004) bands, and radio continuum from either the Molonglo Galactic Plane Survey in the south (MGPS2: Green 2002) or the NVSS in the north (Condon et al. 1998). |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MASH PNe lie within Galactic latitudes of |b| 10◦ − 13◦. MSX imaged the entire Galac- tic Plane within ±5◦ while GLIMPSE is confined to ±1◦. For the present multiwavelength study of PNe we investigated both regions of the GLIMPSE survey, covering the longitudes from 10◦ to 65◦ and 295◦ to 350◦. As part of the final culling of MASH candidates prior to publication, various multiwavelength comparisons were made between MASH PN candi- dates and other extant data from MSX, 2MASS and, for the area of overlap, GLIMPSE. There were 85 PNe candidates in the MASH/GLIMPSE overlap zone to begin with. Mid- infrared (MIR) data are valuable to study the properties of these objects as well as to remove misidentifications from the MASH (Cohen & Parker 2003). Parker et al. (2006) discuss in detail how non-PN contaminants were eliminated from the MASH catalog. An environment with the indicators of active star-formation or heavy dust obscuration, or an optical mor- phology showing multiple patches of nebulosity, possibly linked, suffice to remove many Hii regions. Any object that lacks Hα emission will appear the same in the narrowband Hα and accompanying broadband red continuum exposures, precluding reflection nebulae and normal galaxies. Compact Hii regions were eliminated by optical spectroscopy based on the weakness of [Nii](6548+6584) relative to Hα emission (hereafter [Nii]/Hα). Additional emission-line objects that are not PNe were rejected by optical spectroscopy if they lacked the characteristic PN lines (e.g. [Oiii] in the blue; [Oi], [Nii], and [Sii] in the red) or showed a continuum. MIR morphology is often sufficient to discriminate between PNe and Hii regions. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MASH PNe are generally distinguishable from previously known nebulae by their larger size and faintness. This distinction translates to large proportions of highly evolved objects of large apparent size and low surface brightness that have almost dissolved into the interstellar medium (ISM), and of compact faint PNe. This complementarity between the MASH and old PN catalogs is important because only a small fraction of the estimated ∼30,000 Galactic PNe (e.g. Frew & Parker 2005) is known. To understand PNe it is vital to identify more of this population and to have access to a broad representation of different evolutionary stages. This helps to gauge the relationship between morphology and age and to quantify the gradual chemical enrichment of the Galaxy. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MASH PN candidates resulted in the rejection of a total of 27 candidates: 4 objects were found to correspond to portions of known supernova remnants; 4 are inconclusive identifi- cations following consideration of the available optical and IR data; one is a symbiotic star; 2 are “likely” PNe; and the remaining 16 are probably Hii regions and were anyway never classified as more than “possible” PNe. Fifty-eight nebulae survived this cull, composed of 28 true, 16 likely, and 14 possible PNe (from the classification categories of Parker et al. 2006). Objects inconclusive in nature have been placed in the MASH Miscellaneous Emis- sion Nebulae (MEN) catalog until their true character can be revealed. Some of these may later turn out to be PNe and will return to MASH. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | In this paper we present the sample of PNe and summarize their multiwavelength char- acteristics (§2); describe the tools we use to confirm true MIR counterparts of the 58 objects (§3); compare the ratio of IRAC 8.0-µm to MSX 8.3-µm fluxes to investigate further the accuracy of IRAC’s absolute diffuse calibration on smaller spatial scales than probed by (2006) in their study of Hii regions (§4); compare the IRAC colors of the Cohen et al. MASH PNe with those found by Hora et al. (2004) to provide a diagnostic color-color plot which distinguishes PNe from other sources in the GLIMPSE data (§5); examine the ratio of spatially-integrated MIR/radio flux density for PNe (§6); and compare MIR and optical morphologies of PNe (§7). §8 gives our conclusions. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Fig. 1 compares the Hα appearance with the IRAC morphology of a PN candidate that has now been reclassified as an Hii region. It was initially considered a PN candidate because of its plausible optical morphology and its reasonable optical red spectrum (Fig. 2, with [Nii]/Hα) of 0.60, close to the cut-off value for Hii regions, of 0.70 (Kennicutt et al. 2000). High extinction precluded blue spectroscopy that might have revealed the absence of PN lines. However, the relative locations of Hα and 8-µm emission (see Fig. 1), and what appear to be possible secondary star formation regions (several compact Hii regions on the north-western rim) are much more consistent with an Hii region. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MIR image is a 3-band false color image as described in §3.2.) The nebular spectrum (Fig. 4) is PN-like with [Oiii]/Hβ≈10, [Nii]/Hα≈0.1, but with an obvious blue, and a weaker red, continuum. The CS is not blue but is bright in the near-infrared (NIR) with 2MASS photometry yielding J − H∼1.43 and H − K∼1.41. Combining these with a magnitude at 3.6 µm of 7.35, and K−[3.6] of 2.87 indicates that the stellar photosphere is overwhelmed by thermal emission from ∼700 K dust (see Allen & Glass 1974, their Fig. 2). The optical outflows coincide exactly with a strong elongated emission ridge of a much more extensive underlying MIR structure which extends in filamentary form for several arcminutes from NE-SW. These structures are clearly related and certainly atypical of PNe, as are the rising continua. In its Hα structure and the shape of its MIR core, this nebula is strongly redolent of the highly collimated, high-density nebulae discussed by Corradi (1995). He linked these systems to interacting binaries containing a symbiotic star. Among the usual nebular lines, and those from H and Hei, one sees four [Feii] lines that are associated with symbiotic spectra. Hence a more likely identification would be a highly collimated bipolar outflow, perhaps from a symbiotic nucleus. Characterizing PHR1253−6350 as a bipolar symbiotic outflow does not explain the relationship between this object and its environment. Does the geometry of the extended MIR emission indicate the passage of this star through the ISM, represented by the filaments? Or was the object born within the material traced by the halo of MIR emission that surrounds it and that is excited by the bright bipolar nebula inside? This intriguing object is the subject of a separate paper (Parker, Cohen & Frew, in preparation). Although we regard it as a non-PN, the influence of environment on the evolution of PNe is still a relevant issue, as shown by the work of Villaver et al. (2006) on the potential contribution of the ISM to PN morphology. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | offset from the center of the MIR ridge were significant then one might argue for the ridge to represent a photodissociation region (PDR) created by ionizing radiation from some star(s) to the west of the sinuous bright 8.0-µm filament. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Table 1 contains the following information: Column (1) – source name; Column (2) – status of the PN as true (T), likely (L), or possible (P); Columns (3-4) – Galactic coordinates in degrees; Columns (5-6) – J2000 Equatorial coordinates with units shown; Column (7) – optical dimensions in arcsec; Column (8) – optical morphology code, described in §2.4 and in Parker et al. (2006); Column (9) – shows the presence (“y”) or absence (“n”) of a clear MIR false-color counterpart (from IRAC) to the PN; Column (10) – indicates if an IRAC counterpart (in any or all of the 4 bands) is linked morphologically to the Hα nebular image; Columns (11-13) – list any MSX 8.3-µm or radio continuum counterparts, with the presence (“y”) or absence (“n”) of detections listed and “...” indicating that no image from MGPS2 or NVSS was available; Column (14) – notes if the likely central star of the PN is detected, with “o” implying an optically identified CS candidate in an appropriate position (for three PNe that candidate is optically blue and is footnoted), “i” signifying a CS candidate found in 2MASS images, “m” indicating a possible stellar candidate in at least one IRAC band, and “N” denoting nebular emission seen in 2MASS. One of the MASH PNe, PHR1815-1457, designated as a likely PN, lies so close to the upper limit of latitude in the GLIMPSE coverage that it was unobserved at 3.6 and 5.8 µm, although images are available in the other band pair (4.5 and 8.0 µm) because of the different fields of view observed through IRAC’s two dichroic beamsplitters. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | When looking for the MIR counterpart morphologically, one may see a resolved source exactly matching the ionized gas as traced by the Hα image. If this occurred in the two short IRAC wavelengths (3.6 and 4.5 µm) it would suggest that recombination lines dominated the emission in these two filters (e.g. Pfγ at 3.3 µm and Brα at 4.05 µm, respectively). Alterna- tively, if there is 5.8 and 8.0-µm emission that follows the form of the ionized gas but with a greater extent, then we would attribute the MIR emission in these two bands to radiation from fluorescing PAHs in a PDR that wraps around the PN. Only five nebulae are detected by 2MASS as extended NIR objects: PHR1457−5812, PHR1831−0805, PHR1843−0325, PHR1857+0207, and PHR1619−4914 (PM 5, the only known Galactic [WN] central star of a planetary nebula (Morgan, Parker & Cohen 2003)). |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | nebulae the relevant location would be the center of curvature of the arc. Ten of the PNe, or 17% of the sample, show optical CS candidates; 12% NIR; and 24% MIR. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Unlike with the MSX images, we have worked from GLIMPSE “residual images”. These are 3.1◦×2.4◦ images with 1.2′′ pixels from which all GLIMPSE point sources have been removed. The residual images are ideal for enhancing the recognition of diffuse nebulosity in regions of high point source density and enable a far more reliable photometry of such emission. The residual images use our adaptation of daophot ii (Stetson 2000) for all GLIMPSE sources detected down to 2σ, deeper than the publicly released Catalog and Archive point source lists that are required to meet higher reliability criteria by sources being detected multiple times at a 5σ level in one or more channels. No measurements less than 3σ are ever listed in either the GLIMPSE Catalogs or Archives. Thus there are faint 2−3σ point sources that are subtracted from the residual images but which are not listed in GLIMPSE enhanced products. Residual images may contain sources not extracted by daophot, such as saturated sources and sources that peak beyond the non-linearity limit for each band. These objects were analysed individually and their integrated flux densities were subtracted. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | The correlation between highly bipolar PNe and strongly enhanced He and N abun- dances is now well-known (e.g. Corradi & Schwarz 1995) but the linkage between chemistry and morphology was first noted by Greig (1967, 1971). Subsequently Peimbert (1978) and Peimbert & Serrano (1980) defined Type I PNe in terms of threshold values of He or N abundance. Most Type I PNe were found to be bipolar (Peimbert 1978; Peimbert & Torres- Peimbert 1983), while surveys of bipolar PNe (Corradi & Schwarz 1995) confirmed their chemical peculiarities and added enhanced Ne abundance to these. As a class, Type I PNe have larger than average diameters and expansion velocities (Corradi & Schwarz 1995), hot- ter and more massive CS (Tylenda 1989), smaller scale heights (e.g. Stanghellini 2000), and deviate from the circular rotation of the Galaxy. Their association with more massive progenitors than typical PNe is widely acknowledged on theoretical grounds too (e.g. Becker & Iben 1980; Kingsburgh & Barlow 1994). This is consistent with the high proportion of new Type I PNe found by the MASH, with its low-latitude coverage. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | To find the PAH emission commonly associated with carbon-rich PNe (e.g. Cohen et al. 1989) we searched for MIR counterparts at 8 µm. Hence, as part of the rigorous checking of all MASH candidate PNe prior to finalization of the catalog, an initial check against available MIR data from MSX was made. This was later supplemented at the lowest latitudes, by the new GLIMPSE data. As a consequence of this combined effort a significant number of Hii contaminants were culled from the MASH database before its publication. However, there are also a significant number of obviously spatially extended 8.0-µm counterparts of PNe. Fig. 6 illustrates two such objects, both classified as true PNe: PHR1246−6324 and PHR1457−5812. Both were detected by MSX but no morphology could be discerned. The figure compares MIR structures (upper images) with their corresponding Hα images (lower images). PHR1246−6324 has a clear, tight, bipolar morphology while PHR1457−5812 is compact but asymmetric. Yet the similarities between the MIR and optical are clear. The angular sizes of the MIR and Hα images are in close agreement, with identical position angles of the main axis of symmetry. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MIR spectra of PNe are not always dominated by PAH emission bands. To eliminate the potential bias against any PN for which thermal emission from dust or ionic fine-structure lines might be the major contributor to radiation in the IRAC bands we made a second comparison. False-color images were produced using IRAC’s 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0-µm bands shown in blue, green, and red, respectively. This particular trio avoids the clutter due to the high stellar density in the 3.6-µm band. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | The MSX data at 8.3 and 12.1 µm also measure PAH emission, but 12.1-µm was gener- ally not sensitive enough to provide a confirming detection. By contrast, the IRAC results offer three sensitive bands capable of sampling PAH emission (3.6, 5.8 and 8.0-µm). The 3.3-µm PAH band lies within IRAC’s 3.6-µm band but its strength is typically only 10% of that of the 7.7-µm PAH band, while the 6.2-µm PAH feature attains 56% of the 7.7-µm band in PNe, reflection nebulae, and Hii regions (Cohen et al. 1986; their Table 5). Therefore, 3.6-µm imagery is not a sensitive tracer of PAHs, and we looked for similar morphologies in the 5.8 and 8.0-µm bands to confirm the existence of PAHs, that are often the dominant spectral features in PNe. Furthermore, it is well-known that PNe also produce emission from lines of H2 (ro-vibrational and pure rotational lines; e.g. Cox et al. 1998). H2 lines can contribute to emission in several IRAC bands. They are chiefly seen at 8.0 µm (Hora et al. 2004) but can be responsible for over 90% of the flux detected in IRAC’s 3.6, 4.5, and 5.8- µm bands (Hora et al. 2006). This molecular emission in PNe can arise either in the warm molecular zone of a PDR or in shocks. In NGC 6302 the molecular gas is photo-dissociated (Bernard-Salas & Tielens 2005) while, in the main ring of the Helix, 90% of the H2 emission is in shocks and only 10% in PDRs (Hora et al. 2006). Such PNe could appear red but might have different morphologies at 5.8 and 8.0 µm, rather than identical structures as with pure PAH emission. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | We intended the 3-color image to be a simple pragmatic tool that treats every PN’s trio of images identically. We used SAOImage ds9 in its RGB mode. Each of the three color images for a given PN was displayed with the same stretch: linear and zscale. These images were examined for evidence of an extended counterpart to each PN, that had a distinctive color compared with its surroundings. Clearly, MIR-bright PNe will stand out against a dark sky background, whatever their false color (typically red). Fig. 7 displays 10 PNe that are recognizable by this technique. Six are very obvious examples demonstrating the power of this identification technique, while 4 others illustrate its capability for robustness in the presence of complicated MIR background emission. Indeed, we are investigating the prospects for discovering new PNe, too obscured to be visible in the SHS, by using GLIMPSE 3-color imaging alone. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1844−0503 (top image of second column of MIR composite images in Fig. 7), whose position is indicated by the small green circle based on the optical position, epitomizes the obvious matches, despite confusion with a diffraction spike from a bright source at the northern edge of the image. The orange periphery and yellow core distinguish the PN from artifacts and from the many stars seen in the field. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1157−6312 (top image of first column in Fig. 7) lies in a field that is relatively sparse in stars but suffers from bright MIR “cirrus” emission that permeates almost the entire 4×4 arcmin field that we show. The PN is the scarlet diffuse patch just below the field center, strongly contrasting with the widespread orange diffuse emission and predominantly green noise. Twenty one nebulae (36% of the 58) have definite, resolved, counterparts that are distinguishable from their environs by false color imaging. The dominant colors associated with these 21 MIR counterparts separate into three groups: 8 are red; 10 are violet; and 3 are orange. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Red most likely represents dominant 7.7 and 8.7-µm PAH band emission. Orange could imply either of two explanations: PAH emission with strong 6.2-µm emission (comparable intensities in the 5.8 and 8.0-µm bands would lead to orange or yellow in false color) or H2 emission lines which are strongest in IRAC’s 8.0-µm band but also contribute to the 5.8-µm band chiefly through the 0−0 S(7) line (e.g. Hora et al. 2006). Violet objects could also represent two types of PN. In high-excitation PNe, ionic lines of heavy elements such as [Mgiv] (4.485 µm) and [Arvi] (4.530 µm) are very strong and fall in IRAC’s 4.5-µm band. However, such an object would also emit strongly in the 8.99-µm [Ariii], 7.90-µm [Arv], and 7.65-µm [Nevi] lines in the 8.0-µm band. A combination of high-excitation lines would increase emission in both the 4.5-µm and 8.0-µm bands, leading to violet in the false-color image. As a second scenario we suggest another possibility, namely low-excitation PNe in which the H recombination lines are the dominant spectral features. The combination of Brα and Pfβ (in the 4.5-µm band) would overwhelm Pfα and lines such as Hi 6−8 (in the 5.8-µm band). Flux density ratios 4.5-µm/8.0-µm in typical PNe are very small except when H lines are dominant. Ratios of 5.8-µm/8.0-µm emission without substantial extinction, for PNe dominated by (i) PAH bands, or (ii) H2 lines, or (iii) H recombination would be about 0.5 (Cohen & Barlow 2005, Tables 2,3), 0.3 (Hora et al. 2006, Table 2), and 0.1 (using the H recombination lines in IC 418: Pottasch et al. 2004), respectively. Bernard-Salas & Pottasch 2001), respectively. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | color combination of IRAC bands 2, 3 and 4 can differentiate between PNe of high and low [Nii]/Hα. Thus we propose the following model to explain the MIR false colors and optical excitations of PNe. “Red” PNe are PAH-dominated and of modest excitation, “orange” objects are dominated by H2 or high-excitation fine-structure lines and “violet” nebulae are dominated by H recombination lines and are of low or very low excitation. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | For the 22 PNe with [Nii]/Hα ≥3, 9 objects (41%) have a bipolar morphology, suggesting that this line ratio may be a valuable proxy for selecting Type I PNe (see also Parker et al., in preparation). No such patterns emerge in the smaller sample of PNe with measured ratios of [Oiii]/Hβ intensities. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | To locate the MIR counterparts the Hα images were regridded to Galactic coordinates with the same projections as the GLIMPSE maps and each of the four IRAC images was overlaid as contours on the Hα image. “Quartets” of these overlays were inspected. Most of these IRAC counterparts are clearly resolved and many have similar morphologies to that shown by the PNe in Hα, at least at the shorter IRAC wavelengths. The lowest contours displayed in all quartets were set as the mean off-source level of emission plus 3 standard deviations. Filaments of PAH emission (in the 5.8 and 8.0-µm bands) that might represent limb-brightened PDRs will appear displaced from the periphery of a PN. In addition, one can readily recognize potential MIR counterparts to the PN central stars. For 9 of the 58 PNe (16%) we could identify a candidate central star in one or more IRAC bands. Generally these are blue; i.e. they become monotonically fainter with increasing IRAC wavelength. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | To illustrate how the quartets were used to determine the MIR counterparts to PNe, we present four such quartets, chosen to highlight different features in the nebulae, their probable MIR emission processes, and their central stars. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | The first quartet, presented in Fig.8, shows the small nebula PHR1857+0207 that ap- pears in an otherwise empty field. Note the progressive increase in size of this likely PN with increasing wavelength, and the change in its morphology from the asymmetric enhanced brightness of the southern limb in the three shortest bands to the large circular appearance at 8.0 µm. We identify the 8.0-µm structure and the increase in size at 5.8 µm as due to a substantial PDR that envelops the entire ionized zone. Ionic fine structure lines probably account for the changing size from 3.6 to 5.8 µm. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PN’s center, which seems to be unrelated to the nebula. The number of stars detected falls with increasing wavelength (as expected for random stars in their Rayleigh-Jeans domain) and only the brightest one is still detected at 8.0 µm. The PN is bipolar and the bright Hα axis is filled across the pinched waist. This elongation is also seen in the MIR. Unlike in Fig. 8, the 3.6 and 4.5-µm bands are almost identical in appearance and dimensions, which closely match the distribution of ionized gas traced by Hα. This is due either to recombination lines in these two short bands (e.g. Pfγ and Brα, respectively) or to thermal emission from dust grains, close to the central star, which are heated by direct starlight. In both the longer bands the PN is markedly larger in latitude extent, reflecting the contribution by PAHs in the PDR in the outer portions of the nebula. The inner contours suggest thermal emission by cooler grains in a somewhat tilted dust disk. This dust emission must be optically thin to produce the two peaks, presumably from limb-brightening along the line-of-sight to the circumstellar dust disk. The U-shaped curvature of the second highest 8.0-µm contours strongly suggests that IRAC has resolved a tilted dusty disk. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Fig. 10 presents PHR1457−5812, in the third quartet; a true PN with a very different MIR structure, also shown in Fig. 6 and in Fig. 7 (left column, third image down). One must ignore the two unrelated point sources projected against the western edge of the PN. It is a compact but asymmetric PN with a strongly enhanced eastern edge. The curving eastern portion with the bright Hα emission coincides with the peaks of MIR counterparts in the three longer IRAC bands. These MIR peaks shift slightly with wavelength but the spatial extent of the resolved structure is remarkably similar at 3.6 and 5.8 µm where it lies inside the Hα image, and again at 4.5 and 8.0 µm, where it is slightly more extensive with a boundary very well-matched to that of the ionized gas. Despite the redness (Fig. 7) this pattern does not suggest the presence of PAHs. It seems more indicative of strong emission by the pure (ν=0-0) rotational lines of H2 within the IRAC bands. These lines dominate the MIR emission of the Helix Nebula (Cox et al. (1998); Hora et al. (2006)) and are strong in high-excitation PNe (Bernard-Salas & Tielens 2005). This would also account for the nebular detection by 2MASS, which is brightest in the Ks band that includes H2 from the strong S(1) 1-0 line. Optical spectra available from MASH for this object show [Nii]/Hα ∼4 but only weak [Oiii] in the blue due to high extinction. There is also weak [Ariii] at 7136˚A but no evidence of higher excitation Heii. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | by a small diffuse patch. This becomes more prominent at 8.0 µm. We interpret this, and its fainter eastern counterpart, as PDRs lying just outside the bright ionized edges of the central disk. The peak of the eastern PDR is clearly displaced from the Hα emission. The PN has a size in Hα of 82′′×46′′. Large PNe lack PAHs, perhaps because these lower density nebulae are optically thin to ionizing radiation and have no PDRs. The only large PNe in which PAHs have been detected are bipolar, high-excitation PNe in which PAHs are found in a high-density central circumstellar disk. We note that PHR1408−6229 has [Nii]/Hα of 8, and shows [Oiii] > Hβ so it may well be another high-excitation bipolar PN. It is fortunate that a blue spectrum of this object exists to support this conclusion. Often the MASH PNe have lower quality blue spectra because the heavy extinction so close to the Plane requires extremely long integrations to detect a useful result. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Firstly, the previously known PNe catalogued by Acker and colleagues and indepen- dently by the various compilations of Perek and Kohoutek (e.g. Kohoutek 2000), were largely detected originally in the optical from broadband, narrow-band, or objective-prism photography. Unsurprisingly, these samples represent the bright end of the PN luminosity function and those nearest the sun which are less extinguished. It is only recently, with the advent of new surveys in the infrared and optical using, for example, combinations of selected narrow-band filters and CCD imaging, that more extinguished, lower surface brightness and more evolved PNe have been detected in significant numbers. A brief summary of these small-scale projects appears in the main MASH paper of Parker et al. (2006) but it is the MASH survey itself that has changed the situation most dramatically (see later). |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | the IR-bright nebulae amongst the known optical PNe. For example, at 10 µm Cohen & Barlow (1974,1980) detected 52% of their combined total of 145 of the optically best-known PNe with apparent diameters ≤30′′. Consequently, a large fraction would be expected to have MIR counterparts. Cohen & Barlow (1974) also noted that those PNe whose central star showed an optical emission-line spectrum were more likely to have MIR detections. Other programs have made use of the specific IRAS colors of PN candidates through the far-infrared (60 and 100 µm) excess associated with the cool dust in the nebulae. Ratag & Pottasch (1991) and van de Steene & Pottasch (1995) identified 63 new PNe and 67 possible PNe. There is always a question mark over such candidates until confirmatory spectroscopy and high resolution optical, NIR, or radio imaging are obtained. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Young compact PNe are dense, surrounded by dust grains that are heated dominantly by direct starlight. Most of these were already known from early optical searches. Ma- ture PNe that have expanded significantly derive most of their MIR thermal emission by absorbing resonantly trapped Ly-α photons (Cohen & Barlow 1974). This mechanism acts as a thermostat so that all grains in the ionized zone of a PN see approximately the same intensity of UV radiation and attain the same temperature, typically around 120 K. At this temperature, the bulk of the thermal dust emission is radiated at wavelengths longer than 25 µm and does not lead to bright emission near 8 µm from PNe. The dominant emission processes that can be observed in PNe by IRAC are fluorescent PAH bands from the PDR, fine structure lines from the ionized zone, stratified outward in the nebula according to de- creasing excitation level, and H2 lines that arise chiefly in the warm regions of the PDR. Forbidden atomic lines also emit in the PDR but these radiate principally between 35 and 158 µm, outside the range of the IRAC. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MASH has greatly increased the number of the most highly evolved optical PNe known. Indeed, it has discovered even more extreme examples of the phenomenon of PNe that are dissolving into the interstellar medium, e.g. Pierce et al. (2004). Such PNe are inherently of low surface brightness, except at possible shock fronts, and so become undetectable at increasing distance from the sun and as the interstellar extinction levels become significant. MASH PNe span a broader evolutionary range than the previously published PNe and are generally more evolved, obscured, of lower surface brightness and greater angular extent than those of most other PN catalogs. These combined properties naturally lead to lower levels of MIR detectability with current survey sensitivities including GLIMPSE, though the success rate here is higher than for the same region covered by MSX. These characteristics and the implications for MIR detectability are explored in more detail below. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | As a PN ages many factors affect its MIR-detectability. When the density drops below Ne∼1000 cm−3, Ly-α photons are no longer trapped in the ionized zone and dust grains can absorb only dilute starlight that provides little thermal heating, particularly as the central star descends the white dwarf cooling track. Lower density nebulae are optically thin to ionizing radiation and have no PDRs unless they are also bipolar and surrounded by dense circumstellar disks (Cohen & Barlow 2005). Extensive neutral and molecular material resides outside many PNe from previous mass lost while the star was on the asymptotic giant branch (AGB). Indeed, the bulk of the stellar ejecta in PNe must occupy extensive, but optically- faint, AGB halos that are created by slow AGB winds and are either neutral or only weakly ionized. Advancing age also increases the fraction of total PN mass in the form of ionic gas, while decreasing the atomic and molecular gas masses (Bernard-Salas & Tielens 2005), reducing PAH and H2 emission and lessening nebular detectability by IRAC. While these authors emphasize the importance of the PDRs around PNe they state explicitly that these regions are thin compared with the ionized zones. Therefore, they do not treat extended halos in their analysis so their “total mass” excludes AGB halo material. However, their overall results are robust as regards the PDRs and the ionized regions of these nebulae to which the MASH, IRAC, and radio continuum are sensitive. As a nebula ages and expands, the radiation field at large radii is more dilute even as the nebula itself becomes optically thin. Those PAHs that still survive are bathed in a diminishing far-UV radiation field, which can be quantified by plotting incident far-UV flux against PN diameter (Bernard-Salas & Tielens 2005: their Fig. 3). Recombination occurs if denser clumps remain in the inner nebula and previously neutral gas continues to expand slowly outwards. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Not every PN is carbon-rich, containing PAHs. Oxygen-rich PNe also have dust grains, identified by their silicate spectral features, which peak near 10 µm. These contribute rela- tively little to the IRAC 8.0-µm band, whose relative spectral response curve drops abruptly beyond 9 µm. Furthermore, for a PN with a low gas-phase ratio of C/O, the fraction of total nebular IR luminosity emitted in PAHs is correspondingly decreased (Cohen & Barlow 2005: their Fig. 3). Therefore, fewer 8-µm counterparts should be found among PNe that are highly evolved, or physically large, or of low C/O abundance ratio, and among those for which the central stars exhibit no stellar winds (seen via Wolf-Rayet or Of emission lines). Of our 58 PNe, only PM 5 has a known emission-line central star. Consequently, a much smaller proportion of MASH PNe are expected to have MIR counterparts, as has been found. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1813−1543: the radio counterpart appears to be a double source, perhaps a background radio galaxy. There is no MIR counterpart within the PN nor around its periphery. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1826−0953: The radio source is located exactly at the Hα centroid of the PN. The MSX counterpart of a bright star fills much of the area of the PN. In the IRAC mosaic image the stellar diffraction vanes make accurate analysis impossible. However, the GLIMPSE residual images indicate that the star is not associated with the PN because it lies far from the optical centroid of this oval bipolar nebula. Bright diffuse emission lies across the PN so that it is difficult to provide a useful upper limit with MSX (<160 mJy at 8.3 µm is given in Table 2). There is clearly an excess of MIR emission within the PN and this can be measured using the residual images to give an IRAC 8.0-µm detection of 170 mJy. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1843−0232: The NVSS radio source in this vicinity is not associated with the PN. There are clear indications of a surrounding PDR that wraps around 270◦ of the PN’s outer rim at 8.0 µm. However, the region is suffused by bright streamers and extended 8.0- µm emission so that an estimate of the MIR emission from the PDR is impossible. This situation occurs frequently and emphasizes the impossibility of undertaking any uniformly flux-limited survey within the Galactic plane. The problem is illustrated for this PN in the final panel of the montage of 3-band false-color images in Fig. 7 (bottom right corner). The 8-µm sky brightness in the immediate vicinity of the PN is about 70 MJy sr−1. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | only an upper limit at 8.3 µm of <110 mJy, consistent with our detection of a spatial integral of 78 mJy above local background in a region encompassing the PN’s Hα extent. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1619−4914: This object is “PM 5”, the only PN known in the Galaxy to have a central Wolf-Rayet star of type [WN] (Morgan, Parker, & Cohen 2003). Although the MSX PSC2.3 lists a value of 600 mJy at 8.3 µm this is not of the entire PN, which is substantially larger than the MSX point spread function (PSF), nor does it reflect an accurate estimate of the CS which lies in bright PN nebulosity. An estimate using the IRAC images suggests that the CS contributes about 25% of the PN’s total integrated flux at 8.0 µm. A more detailed examination of this PN with Spitzer will be presented by Cohen, Shupe, & Parker (in preparation). |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1223−6236: This object shows weak evidence for an association between the PN and diffuse patches of 5.8 and 8.0-µm emission on the NE and SW rims. A bright star is projected against the NE rim making it difficult to distinguish between artifacts of this point source and MIR extended emission. However, the residual image definitively shows diffuse 8.0-µm emission distinct from the stellar PSF. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | RCW 69 (PHR1244−6231) is a relatively nearby, evolved Type I bipolar PN (Frew, Parker, & Russeil 2006), viewed through the Coalsack. RCW 69 is one of the closest PNe in the GLIMPSE sample (1.3±0.2 kpc) and it is also intrinsically large (1.6×1.5 pc2). It has an elongated central bar in optical images which likely represents a thick edge-on torus similar to the ring seen in the Helix nebula (O’Dell, McCullough, & Meixner 2004), but it is much fainter in Hα surface brightness than the Helix and is more evolved. Frew et al. (2006) identify the B=18.4 CS and demonstrate that it is on the white dwarf cooling track. This star is undetected in GLIMPSE images. Fig. 12 overlays 8.0-µm contours on an Hα greyscale image of the PN. The location of the CS is marked by a cross. There is evidence for a PDR in the form of a bar of 8.0-µm emission displaced to the east of the obvious nebular bar, making RCW 69 another example of a large bipolar PN associated with PAH emission. Frew et al. (2006) discuss the possible detection of CO (1-0) and CO (2-1) emission which indicates the presence of molecular material in the PN although its location is unknown. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | PHR1250−6346: The association (in Table 1) between MIR emission and this moderately large PN seems likely because there are indications of a peripheral PDR around the western rim in the form of diffuse emission at 5.8 and especially at 8.0 µm. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | The MASH PNe have been used to check the absolute diffuse calibration of IRAC at 8.0 µm on smaller spatial scales than in our study of Hii regions, spanning the range from PNe only slightly larger then the IRAC PSFs (but smaller than the MSX PSFs) to a scale of a few arcmin. Details of the method adopted to calculate directly comparable integrated fluxes from the MSX images of the PNe and the GLIMPSE residual images are given by Cohen et al. (2006). To represent the PNe we utilized the Hα images from the SHS (Parker et al. 2005). The outer Hα contours of each PN were overlaid on its quartet of IRAC images and the flux density integrated over the identical area for all bands, while including any peripheral PDR apparent at 8.0 µm. The same approach was used with MSX 8.3-µm images. Multiple estimates were made of the sky background for each PN. For the measurements of sky background for each PN, specific areas were selected from the IRAC 8.0-µm residual images. The same areas were used for the three other bands. It must be emphasized that it is critical to understand the contribution of the interstellar medium at 8.0 µm in defining what is sky emission and what is a MIR counterpart of a PN. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | The largest PN in our sample of 58 MASH objects (PHR1408−6106) encompasses an area of 18 arcmin2. Within the Hα boundary there are two unresolved 8.3-µm sources from the MSX PSC2.3 catalog above the 5σ level and none listed in the corresponding Reject Catalog. The background emission would permit detection of an 8.3-µm source at magnitude 7.5 (60 mJy). SKY predicts that an additional 2% of the sky background surface brightness should be subtracted from the integrated PN flux to account for the sources (to a magnitude of 8.0) that were removed in producing the GLIMPSE residual image in this field. Such a small adjustment is well within the uncertainties of our MIR flux measurements. The remainder of the MASH sample have smaller areas and correspondingly smaller corrections to their observed 8.3-µm integrated fluxes. Consequently, we have subtracted only those point sources listed in the PSC2.3 and the Reject catalog to ensure equivalence of the PN fluxes estimated from the MSX and GLIMPSE residual images. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | We also estimated upper limits for PNe undetected by MSX and/or IRAC as three times the root-sum-squared 1σ uncertainties in the fluxes measured for both PN and sky background locations at each wavelength. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Table 2 summarizes the MIR integrated fluxes for 19 PNe. Objects listed first have MIR detections from MSX and IRAC, together with a radio detection. Later entries are PNe without radio detections but with both MSX and IRAC data. PNe with fewer than two detections among MSX, IRAC, and the radio continuum are excluded. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | A total of fourteen PNe have both MSX and IRAC MIR detections. This sample spans a dynamic range at 8 µm from below 30 mJy to about 1000 mJy. Fig. 13 compares these results and plots a formal linear least squares regression line (with uncertainties in both variables). The slope of this logarithmic plot is 0.9±0.1, consistent with a linear proportionality between IRAC and MSX fluxes. The offset is poorly defined as 0.4±0.2, corresponding to a ratio of IRAC/MSX of 2.9±1.5. More accurate determinations come from the unweighted mean of the ratios of IRAC/MSX (1.3±0.2) and the median of the sample of fourteen PNe (1.2±0.2), which are consistent with the factor of 1.55 found for this ratio from Hii regions (Cohen et al. 2007). |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | MSX PSF and several are smaller in the MIR than in Hα even when resolved by IRAC. A plot of the ratio of IRAC/MSX against nebular radius will reveal if the calibration of IRAC diverges with increasing PN radius from the expectation of a ratio of 1.0 at small scale (the point source calibration of IRAC is good to ∼3% absolute) to a value close to 1.55 for the largest scale at which we can probe the diffuse calibration. Fig. 14 illustrates this comparison. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Three lines are overlaid on the plotted points: the formal regression line (solid) and the ±1σ limiting relationships that couple the mean+1σ slope with the mean−1σ offset, and vice versa (dashed lines). The regression was derived by assigning 10% uncertainties to the diameters of the PNe, and using the 1σ errors in the ratios of MIR fluxes determined from the root-sum-squared errors in both IRAC and MSX flux integrals. The slope is 0.005±0.005, with an offset of 1.1±0.1. The results are, therefore, marginal but would accommodate a gradual change between a point source calibration factor of 1.0 at small nebular size to a diffuse factor ≥ 1.4 by 77′′. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Table 3 summarizes the six color indices in Vega-based magnitudes derived from 41 of the 58 MASH PNe for which spatially integrated fluxes were estimated. Not every band was measureable above the sky for every nebula. The median colors and the standard errors of the median (sem) are given after applying the SSC recommended aperture correction factors in each IRAC band. The color offsets that these cause are given by Cohen et al. (2007: their Table 5, col.4). For comparison we have synthesized the same six colors for a set of 26 optically well-known PNe taken from Acker et al. (1992), based on low-resolution spectra obtained with the Short Wavelength Spectrometer (SWS) of the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO). There is excellent agreement within the ∼1σ joint uncertainties. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Can we distinguish PNe from the plethora of other MIR sources using this color-color plane? Only a single category among the 87 compact MIR sources in SKY is expected to contaminate any of the three color zones observed for planetaries, shown by the cross near (1.7,0.4) in Fig. 15. That category corresponds to one type of reflection nebula. This contaminant is easily removed by comparing Hα and red continuum exposures. Compact Hii regions (small filled circle in the figure) cannot be confused with PNe but some extended Hii regions do overlap the lower right portion of the solid box for MASH PNe (see Cohen et al. 2007; their Fig. 8). We attribute this similarity of colors to PAHs that dominate the MIR spectra of many Hii regions and of some PNe. However, these two classes can be readily separated by MIR morphology and/or by optical spectroscopy. Spiral galaxies (both normal and interacting), ellipticals, and irregulars all show minimal overlap with MASH PNe and none with the other PN samples, while QSOs do not overlap any PN color-color zone. (Smith et al. 2007). |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Young stellar objects (YSOs) span a very wide range of GLIMPSE colors. From a large grid of pre-computed models (Robitaille et al. 2006) one finds that some younger YSOs would overlap with PN colors. The energy distributions of bona fide PNe are never even quasi-continua. This can lead to real ambiguity when model energy distributions are com- pared with solely broadband measurements of spectra that contain strong emission lines, and broad emission or absorption bands. Consider a confirmed PN whose MIR spectral energy distribution is well-matched in the IRAC range by that of a YSO from this grid (Robitaille et al. 2007). Currently, a true PN must be optically detected, suffer no unusual reddening, be isolated from obvious star-forming regions, emit the appropriate optical forbidden lines with the correct intensities, and have a morphology plausible for a PN. Thus, no MASH PN is actually a YSO. Conversely, one could discriminate between a true PN and a YSO, whose IRAC photometry places it within the color-color domain that we have identified for MASH PNe, by the application of these additional criteria. Perhaps the simplest test is to examine the extinction required to match a YSO model to the IRAC photometry. Good fits of YSO models to PN energy distributions often involve high reddening (AV ≥5) and the existence of an optical counterpart makes it less likely that one has found such a YSO. Colors alone cannot uniquely identify new IR-discovered PNe. The goal is simply to isolate plausible candidates for future follow-on spectroscopy. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | Radio flux densities were obtained from the MGPS2 (Green 2002, Murphy et al. 2007) and NVSS (Condon et al. 1998) surveys. MGPS2 covers the sky south of −30◦ Dec. at 843 MHz and NVSS covers the sky north of −40◦ Dec. at 1.4 GHz. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | For MGPS2, flux densities were calculated using the using the miriad imfit task to fit elliptical Gaussians above a planar background. For the NVSS the source catalog was queried and imfit was also run on the survey images as confirmation. The images were inspected to reject multiple source detections and unrelated chance alignments. Mauch et al. (2003) and Murphy et al. (2007) determined that the flux density calibration of NVSS and MGPS2 agreed to within 2%, based on a comparison of ∼7000 sources in the overlap zone between these two surveys. |
Processed_Spitzer_IRAC_observations_of_newly-discovered_plan.txt | All MGPS2 detections of our PN sample were unresolved (as defined in Mauch et al. 2003) and hence the fitted peak flux density is used as a good measure of the integrated radio fluxes. NVSS detections were treated identically. |
Subsets and Splits