question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I have a table in which the multiple linear regression results is provided. If I have unstandardized coefficients and standard error for each independent variable, is it possible to calculate standardized coefficient (Beta) and coefficient of determination ($R^2$) from these data. </p> <p>My friend provided $R^2=0.41$ for these data, but I doubt if the results are reliable. I brought the table in the following, would you please compute Beta and R-squared for me to compare with the original table?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/LJGFb.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>the descriptive statistics is the following table:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/re6g2.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
49,927
[ -0.050037235021591187, 0.0353698693215847, -0.009119781665503979, 0.011676832102239132, 0.0384674146771431, 0.019158294424414635, -0.034455493092536926, -0.02335195615887642, 0.04205329716205597, -0.050070442259311676, 0.03417579457163811, 0.01421107817441225, 0.07809203118085861, 0.008904152549803257, 0.03220458701252937, -0.002663375809788704, -0.016763856634497643, 0.0330301895737648, -0.003094614250585437, -0.0022091984283179045, -0.0028021992184221745, 0.011863695457577705, 0.021489514037966728, -0.005013735499233007, -0.030665317550301552, 0.06946594268083572, 0.009839619509875774, -0.005779628176242113, -0.007788950577378273, 0.03297209367156029, -0.009414412081241608, -0.018536224961280823, 0.025610750541090965, 0.010176638141274452, 0.011540034785866737, 0.022185882553458214, -0.05900944024324417, -0.020103586837649345, -0.03640875965356827, 0.046708013862371445, 0.017350289970636368, -0.04313908889889717, 0.0012953119585290551, 0.042006801813840866, 0.014772295951843262, 0.008214902132749557, 0.00424346374347806, -0.027707992121577263, 0.033540114760398865, -0.0241427980363369, 0.09418202191591263, 0.007337253075093031, 0.05938011407852173, 0.04267897084355354, -0.04586676135659218, 0.006314466241747141, 0.02986232563853264, 0.06002192571759224, 0.009515363723039627, -0.041666723787784576, 0.02209005318582058, -0.0014462241670116782, 0.022802285850048065, -0.0024985538329929113, -0.031839240342378616, 0.009057142771780491, -0.018831495195627213, 0.022610193118453026, 0.03544743359088898, -0.010362268425524235, 0.05765272676944733, 0.015223984606564045, 0.010892982594668865, 0.001272551016882062, -0.023063521832227707, -0.015410536900162697, 0.013926618732511997, 0.003232648130506277, 0.0013441373594105244, 0.013757412321865559, 0.028553273528814316, 0.022539429366588593, 0.062300387769937515, 0.04130852594971657, 0.041326794773340225, -0.008526927791535854, 0.04449257254600525, -0.03327867388725281, 0.0404827706515789, 0.018225660547614098, -0.004573579411953688, -0.008700517006218433, 0.03851933032274246, 0.014527606777846813, -0.046598419547080994, 0.01953195035457611, -0.008052447810769081, 0.059989798814058304, 0.03273608908057213, -0.004520644433796406, 0.021618837490677834, -0.028589405119419098, -0.0007315387483686209, 0.05437187850475311, -0.003768641734495759, -0.02570384368300438, -0.01308945007622242, 0.03364638239145279, 0.01033046841621399, -0.05353180319070816, -0.028362631797790527, -0.006090386305004358, 0.0030315129552036524, -0.018173106014728546, 0.04224858433008194, -0.029353221878409386, -0.023107759654521942, 0.03121308609843254, 0.055710334330797195, 0.051603589206933975, 0.027925098314881325, -0.04639866203069687, -0.011996560730040073, 0.010984599590301514, -0.0034584172535687685, 0.05638788267970085, 0.0028087764512747526, -0.015092579647898674, -0.042705584317445755, 0.021914038807153702, -0.014728742651641369, 0.00017676566494628787, 0.013700499199330807, -0.003926632460206747, 0.00038474667235277593, 0.01776788756251335, -0.06776855140924454, -0.06988099962472916, 0.026074910536408424, -0.013123812153935432, -0.0013159043155610561, -0.03949958458542824, -0.01834116131067276, 0.01925964094698429, 0.04113033413887024, 0.019829099997878075, 0.02449105679988861, 0.04409003630280495, 0.047596514225006104, 0.01115505862981081, -0.016613056883215904, -0.007636435329914093, -0.04075910896062851, -0.04401247575879097, 0.000324635038850829, -0.10162894427776337, -0.00790092721581459, -0.0017754018772393465, 0.010686960071325302, 0.01257566548883915, 0.017074843868613243, 0.037279170006513596, -0.04341430589556694, 0.04430898651480675, 0.026141636073589325, -0.0443069189786911, 0.06451138854026794, -0.021122699603438377, 0.028798704966902733, -0.006209457293152809, -0.023987792432308197, 0.010828503407537937, 0.005624679382890463, 0.04707380011677742, 0.056006379425525665, 0.01576371118426323, -0.013148907572031021, -0.014536304399371147, 0.033304180949926376, 0.005075858440250158, -0.12115425616502762, -0.006713956594467163, -0.03127150982618332, -0.02744266949594021, 0.02662254311144352, 0.07226473838090897, 0.015549090690910816, -0.045721497386693954, 0.016922106966376305, -0.04874936491250992, -0.029116475954651833, -0.05991329252719879, -0.010233958251774311, -0.0033400009851902723, -0.029739340767264366, 0.009333153255283833, 0.03398135304450989, 0.010526985861361027, -0.019529540091753006, -0.0368013009428978, -0.03715823218226433, 0.000081688653153833, 0.04556361585855484, -0.029429966583848, 0.02379462867975235, 0.034918155521154404, 0.06983587145805359, -0.004550701938569546, 0.025507774204015732, -0.04047923535108566, -0.0329788476228714, 0.044584646821022034, -0.040895093232393265, 0.011995888315141201, -0.02015805058181286, -0.011225301772356033, 0.024030761793255806, 0.02465764433145523, -0.02643701061606407, 0.03846296668052673, -0.04398554563522339, 0.04041943699121475, 0.054001856595277786, 0.03794505447149277, 0.0006499852170236409, 0.01657629944384098, 0.01702655479311943, 0.03550095483660698, -0.06308536231517792, -0.018719172105193138, -0.04807955399155617, -0.044457439333200455, 0.014371708035469055, 0.01109606958925724, -0.05450553819537163, 0.03239447996020317, 0.05350799486041069, 0.021807914599776268, 0.024129744619131088, -0.0030743784736841917, -0.004791247192770243, -0.02353750728070736, -0.03296913579106331, -0.022561579942703247, -0.008182319812476635, 0.03122975304722786, -0.026376476511359215, 0.011509912088513374, 0.03073200210928917, -0.013961531221866608, 0.04524558410048485, 0.03178154677152634, -0.02360144443809986, -0.021133968606591225, -0.018830783665180206, -0.02349672093987465, 0.05799846351146698, -0.008328115567564964, 0.022862689569592476, 0.05281337350606918, 0.03874176740646362, -0.002507205819711089, 0.03166135400533676, 0.015620785765349865, 0.035742029547691345, 0.010116363875567913, -0.03037700057029724, 0.004552093800157309, 0.014374165795743465, -0.040077414363622665, 0.004475628957152367, -0.03402866795659065, -0.019579336047172546, -0.0033607985824346542, -0.008353724144399166, 0.027731312438845634, -0.0026158408727496862, -0.006222098600119352, -0.00903056375682354, 0.008373651653528214, -0.01333935372531414, -0.02501792646944523, 0.009943174198269844, -0.009598573669791222, -0.039749857038259506, 0.0006526103243231773, -0.03265291824936867, 0.011125992983579636, 0.02058389224112034, 0.0007575854542665184, -0.043217528611421585, 0.053832706063985825, 0.01515006460249424, -0.07072725147008896, -0.04857120290398598, -0.032882582396268845, 0.01026933640241623, -0.05721001327037811, -0.030269548296928406, 0.016193937510252, -0.017622660845518112, -0.04461127147078514, 0.029982352629303932, -0.0801648274064064, -0.030591551214456558, -0.023237790912389755, -0.001971492078155279, 0.02965894713997841, 0.018870970234274864, 0.013791787438094616, -0.019174186512827873, -0.019738998264074326, 0.00420660013332963, -0.0586337074637413, -0.04900432378053665, 0.019915297627449036, 0.018725743517279625, 0.05175628885626793, 0.02735734172165394, -0.07023343443870544, 0.05356356501579285, 0.034629255533218384, -0.058264415711164474, -0.041659511625766754, 0.03409178555011749, -0.03301399573683739, -0.03240134194493294, 0.008410423062741756, -0.006197571754455566, 0.006956411525607109, 0.003491653362289071, -0.03449282795190811, -0.013170894235372543, 0.04586959257721901, -0.02411755360662937, 0.030463315546512604, 0.019514724612236023, 0.023564526811242104, -0.0003150559205096215, 0.05377398803830147, -0.01250679511576891, -0.00239944807253778, -0.0033710969146341085, 0.007355094887316227, 0.048036955296993256, 0.035685840994119644, -0.04037915915250778, 0.006584545131772757, 0.005270938854664564, 0.007927634753286839, -0.03010760061442852, 0.0053627509623765945, 0.04479946196079254, -0.004136241041123867, -0.0032326928339898586, -0.01606055349111557, 0.026133904233574867, -0.011875146068632603, 0.02569105103611946, 0.06095702201128006, 0.026605648919939995, 0.02709585800766945, -0.02633204311132431, -0.003842220874503255, 0.01071876846253872, 0.050085291266441345, -0.01901581510901451, -0.034536343067884445, 0.04667183756828308, 0.02749001793563366, 0.0028939887415617704, -0.003986959811300039, -0.056321218609809875, 0.014465845189988613, -0.03519744798541069, -0.005763204302638769, -0.05449561029672623, 0.042015090584754944, 0.0043693967163562775, 0.014871249906718731, -0.0024701557122170925, -0.0536712147295475, 0.030108701437711716, -0.011082707904279232, -0.059929076582193375, 0.041768308728933334, 0.0004988206783309579, -0.03738951310515404, 0.029780130833387375, -0.042779818177223206, 0.030233066529035568, -0.006452818866819143, 0.012048821896314621, 0.025252459570765495, 0.008301923982799053, -0.044255923479795456, -0.0007380844908766448, -0.006501741707324982, -0.0067134578712284565, -0.005030164960771799, 0.03975094482302666, -0.005043662618845701, -0.031935952603816986, -0.01838100701570511, 0.03728657588362694, -0.034664615988731384, 0.01617708057165146, -0.0592283196747303, 0.0023326866794377565, 0.0024772395845502615, 0.025166979059576988, 0.007864157669246197, 0.025523394346237183, -0.01775220036506653, -0.010721730999648571, 0.021177120506763458, 0.027469316497445107, 0.03817366808652878, 0.026502670720219612, -0.04409435763955116, -0.019305255264043808, -0.01103304699063301, 0.0039110914804041386, 0.030974220484495163, 0.01669556461274624, 0.024596290662884712, 0.06345666944980621, 0.027327576652169228, -0.03185372054576874, 0.05122292786836624, 0.030867289751768112, 0.01943276822566986, -0.02565082162618637, -0.028097957372665405, -0.010533799417316914, 0.007804286200553179, -0.025498704984784126, 0.023619215935468674, 0.037346988916397095, -0.010926050134003162, -0.013099388219416142, 0.03509257733821869, -0.018341178074479103, -0.023684967309236526, 0.008604786358773708, 0.014458389952778816, 0.05386417359113693, -0.007974505424499512, -0.0536201037466526, 0.011903006583452225, 0.03249592334032059, 0.05049271509051323, -0.0036184079945087433, -0.016089634969830513, -0.05197242647409439, 0.011974312365055084, 0.008940285071730614, 0.048421550542116165, -0.027842944487929344, 0.0025388700887560844, -0.003690412500873208, -0.0076866792514920235, 0.051367998123168945, -0.022639334201812744, 0.018960652872920036, 0.00844613742083311, 0.011855312623083591, -0.0007671643979847431, 0.0014803378144279122, -0.04955017939209938, -0.026325300335884094, -0.009385766461491585, 0.02730388753116131, -0.029658429324626923, -0.030130581930279732, -0.0252105463296175, -0.0010688587790355086, -0.0058896723203361034, 0.0743199959397316, 0.001491141621954739, -0.017818491905927658, 0.015032259747385979, 0.017921293154358864, -0.019141722470521927, -0.050220418721437454, -0.0008634371915832162, 0.0037491426337510347, -0.007576609030365944, 0.04943154752254486, 0.00035798587487079203, -0.026258710771799088, 0.027720540761947632, 0.04836685210466385, 0.013067773543298244, 0.0036718628834933043, -0.011043569073081017, 0.03916894271969795, 0.04755408689379692, 0.007160655222833157, 0.0808197557926178, 0.013942603021860123, -0.033615123480558395, -0.003174469107761979, -0.013598672114312649, 0.004445748869329691, -0.024404149502515793, -0.04238829016685486, -0.04738973453640938, -0.0013795654522255063, -0.01584031619131565, 0.00618521124124527, -0.02854553610086441, 0.03734765201807022, -0.003485072636976838, 0.010271614417433739, 0.04033174738287926, 0.014982347376644611, -0.011352659203112125, 0.01287917885929346, -0.01178149227052927, 0.019958024844527245, -0.03634131699800491, -0.06310128420591354, 0.020958667621016502, -0.011213979683816433, 0.01576099917292595, 0.00495938491076231, -0.04189304634928703, 0.04612903296947479, -0.005343628115952015, -0.030980288982391357, -0.014172474853694439, -0.053981322795152664, 0.030430560931563377, -0.0022508404217660427, 0.04575851559638977, -0.018648335710167885, -0.05569211021065712, -0.04332299157977104, 0.04400661215186119, -0.002020421903580427, 0.021226312965154648, -0.027569759637117386, 0.04249672591686249, -0.01069934293627739, -0.04247742146253586, -0.0459202416241169, -0.014273315668106079, 0.004967781715095043, -0.0013289430644363165, -0.0014232455287128687, -0.0071890526451170444, -0.013635480776429176, -0.025552671402692795, -0.010798517614603043, -0.01929202862083912, 0.041006576269865036, 0.003893303917720914, -0.017936060205101967, 0.02986668236553669, -0.00789603777229786, 0.07018155604600906, 0.000610776711255312, -0.010638403706252575, 0.019846772775053978, 0.005774747580289841, -0.023947829380631447, 0.024058997631072998, -0.0011150249047204852, -0.014580942690372467, -0.027091003954410553, -0.057448893785476685, -0.004403629340231419, 0.04854363948106766, -0.014675783924758434, -0.02359827607870102, 0.032429128885269165, 0.019229955971240997, -0.015553148463368416, -0.028794731944799423, 0.017406446859240532, 0.0034393647219985723, 0.02204071916639805, -0.01701950654387474, -0.00985743384808302, -0.03787126764655113, -0.001575430273078382, 0.020569797605276108, -0.041132569313049316, -0.015886468812823296, 0.007778432220220566, 0.0906783789396286, -0.015454634092748165, 0.036081574857234955, -0.027339231222867966, -0.012507007457315922, 0.03377974405884743, 0.024555498734116554, 0.009340610355138779, -0.006662649568170309, 0.04950692504644394, -0.05107744038105011, -0.03222046419978142, -0.03206894174218178, 0.023218940943479538, 0.08012373745441437, -0.015798505395650864, 0.011828025802969933, 0.07956752926111221, 0.003850158303976059, -0.003597480012103915, -0.05435417219996452, -0.0010076190810650587, 0.0016929942648857832, 0.04644693434238434, 0.05790926516056061, 0.009718911722302437, -0.03639926016330719, 0.005253951530903578, -0.011134525761008263, -0.008467732928693295, 0.05942579731345177, -0.006843941751867533, 0.022036921232938766, -0.005533968564122915, -0.005628278478980064, -0.059371642768383026, 0.010875544510781765, -0.021804366260766983, 0.0033659813925623894, -0.05841713026165962, -0.027582325041294098, 0.017468364909291267, 0.041088882833719254, 0.030875930562615395, -0.03970757871866226, -0.006457698997110128, -0.05071129649877548, 0.026708563789725304, 0.0035051077138632536, -0.00011064188583986834, -0.005160761531442404, -0.006651591509580612, 0.03292059898376465, -0.01942678913474083, 0.0653732642531395, -0.04494833946228027, -0.06870342791080475, 0.0025667245499789715, -0.027899188920855522, -0.003781670704483986, 0.023128950968384743, -0.031615763902664185, -0.03111044503748417, 0.004866167437285185, -0.051343027502298355, 0.006963176652789116, 0.020472442731261253, 0.0497334823012352, -0.028573935851454735, 0.05399058759212494, -0.017409563064575195, 0.010781555436551571, 0.010764026083052158, -0.013844314031302929, 0.10353051871061325, 0.08808410167694092, 0.016137780621647835, -0.04201074689626694, -0.0010786689817905426, -0.02016405761241913, -0.010928246192634106, -0.002592179924249649, 0.004215152934193611, -0.04545336961746216, -0.01926094852387905, 0.05979925021529198, 0.07755830138921738, -0.005928135477006435, -0.007357175927609205, 0.00756129901856184, 0.018511001020669937, -0.030094724148511887, 0.000030631967092631385, 0.02373591624200344, -0.0018754993798211217, 0.024873288348317146, -0.019074704498052597, 0.013879784382879734, -0.017346736043691635, -0.02575334534049034, -0.03461433947086334, 0.03912907466292381, -0.00940943043678999, -0.003215258475393057, -0.05360852926969528, 0.01197320781648159, 0.017910869792103767, 0.035817548632621765, -0.05181712657213211, 0.004434600472450256, 0.054039366543293, -0.04260170832276344, 0.011220070533454418, 0.0358344204723835, -0.02417217567563057, -0.009547402150928974, 0.015824276953935623, 0.006023216061294079, -0.07921043038368225, -0.004223228897899389, -0.028465086594223976, 0.039840687066316605, -0.029091255739331245, -0.05713900551199913, -0.01943519338965416, 0.017595788463950157, -0.020037570968270302, -0.04262654483318329, -0.006883060559630394, 0.035649970173835754, 0.011163345538079739, -0.06027255579829216, -0.01679019257426262, -0.03438752517104149, -0.0008325177477672696, 0.010648087598383427, -0.012189115397632122, -0.011572381481528282, -0.021733783185482025, -0.02820322848856449, -0.005802889820188284, 0.05171894654631615, -0.006628631614148617, 0.033706579357385635, -0.034976448863744736, -0.01508194487541914, 0.007292138412594795, 0.01151688490062952, 0.035574741661548615, 0.041430484503507614, -0.005357850342988968, 0.025050466880202293, 0.008317414671182632, 0.002671330003067851, -0.053452860563993454, 0.023326678201556206, -0.029882365837693214, 0.016493195667862892, -0.06571446359157562, -0.001967631746083498, 0.018917230889201164, 0.03962411731481552, -0.014819182455539703, -0.006482462398707867, 0.002865686547011137, 0.03925498574972153, 0.01502382941544056, -0.0705571323633194, 0.009144900366663933, -0.0048585613258183, -0.04784223809838295, 0.03014318272471428, -0.029931189492344856, 0.03151538968086243, 0.031202394515275955, 0.03156966716051102, -0.021095285192131996, 0.007431810721755028, 0.019652336835861206, -0.007853350602090359, 0.009824247099459171, -0.06900718808174133, 0.037851713597774506, 0.008884420618414879, 0.020213544368743896, 0.005500590894371271, 0.037466078996658325, -0.050625234842300415, -0.04131099581718445, -0.016961347311735153, -0.022142983973026276, -0.034137971699237823, 0.00616867933422327, -0.018620865419507027, -0.0017372131114825606, -0.03661022707819939, -0.0011799850035458803, -0.02023426443338394, -0.015061010606586933, 0.030839545652270317, 0.003667823038995266, 0.0007307476480491459, 0.020047971978783607, -0.023284638300538063, 0.0260348878800869, 0.056512266397476196, 0.01708824560046196, 0.01574665866792202, -0.007362159434705973, -0.0012376464437693357, 0.02848253957927227, 0.05278464034199715, -0.009736518375575542, -0.0036770671140402555, 0.012048361822962761, -0.01799420639872551, -0.009695678018033504, 0.013819188810884953, 0.005258582066744566, 0.04542652145028114, 0.009342643432319164, 0.019173581153154373, -0.042294733226299286, 0.058126091957092285, -0.04656226187944412, -0.003548160893842578, -0.018927177414298058, -0.01876511238515377, 0.035979144275188446, 0.0248899906873703, 0.011253143660724163, 0.010165846906602383, -0.005964246578514576, 0.032074540853500366, 0.04781187325716019, -0.011886227875947952, 0.002795930253341794, -0.003906568046659231, 0.0022819468285888433, 0.0033115774858742952, -0.001479922910220921, -0.005268505774438381, 0.02102404646575451, 0.037461962550878525, -0.029204005375504494, 0.0558319166302681, 0.006525532808154821, 0.021944601088762283, -0.09903585910797119, -0.04863089323043823, 0.0033082568552345037, 0.029579520225524902, 0.045490920543670654, -0.05398976802825928, 0.002976322313770652, 0.014318208210170269, -0.0417167954146862, -0.036554113030433655, -0.009687796235084534, -0.015425324440002441, -0.04071702063083649, -0.003120606765151024, -0.010064271278679371, 0.015790432691574097, 0.007187651004642248, 0.057016827166080475, 0.018665557727217674, 0.05681530013680458, -0.005742216017097235, 0.013420246541500092, -0.03579678758978844, 0.004689326044172049, 0.011321826837956905, -0.05422127619385719, -0.001174428965896368, -0.033241502940654755, -0.014283459633588791, 0.02234439179301262, -0.03176259621977806, 0.04938087612390518, 0.00045859423698857427, 0.012007142417132854, 0.009210996329784393, 0.05110926553606987, 0.002058704849332571, -0.03486274555325508, -0.015440260991454124, -0.008854168467223644, -0.00793946348130703, 0.022045576944947243, -0.03503866493701935, 0.011334840208292007, 0.010911911725997925, -0.002672995673492551, -0.02807571180164814, 0.005869179964065552, -0.03509336709976196, -0.005739498883485794, -0.016157593578100204, -0.0014616933185607195, 0.029132096096873283, -0.03573254495859146, -0.00789838656783104, -0.050511669367551804, 0.0024999503511935472, 0.03741064667701721, 0.053571537137031555, -0.031842753291130066, 0.039248570799827576, -0.0038676243275403976, -0.06644942611455917, 0.005908840335905552, -0.0048983776941895485, -0.00024289479188155383, -0.08496877551078796, 0.013393801636993885, 0.02704465761780739, -0.023442836478352547, -0.012869777157902718, -0.006288610398769379, -0.026353776454925537, 0.018887965008616447, 0.0034477391745895147, -0.023397047072649002, 0.033354081213474274, -0.02087722346186638, 0.0011808023555204272, -0.06733202934265137, 0.04203006252646446, 0.01327715627849102, -0.022816548123955727, -0.029709547758102417, -0.01049340981990099, -0.02322053350508213, -0.017060020938515663, 0.06610618531703949, 0.005202445667237043, 0.013874929398298264, 0.01168752834200859, 0.03592110052704811, -0.0074323685839772224, -0.04508647695183754, 0.0433003306388855, 0.025571517646312714, -0.00255963415838778, -0.02755083702504635, -0.02062784880399704, 0.0337144210934639, 0.002969632390886545, 0.013066855259239674, -0.03434105962514877, 0.012344799004495144, 0.02314591221511364, -0.012719309888780117, 0.04456786811351776, -0.009901965036988258, -0.039579007774591446, 0.05563206225633621, 0.003164806868880987, 0.017839932814240456, 0.04621640220284462, 0.011930374428629875, -0.030265459790825844, 0.046114061027765274, -0.004588223993778229, -0.048574239015579224, 0.0041631245985627174, -0.0306718647480011, -0.048017654567956924, -0.03850734606385231, 0.016232840716838837, 0.02376117929816246, -0.003822443773970008, -0.0005167286726646125, 0.034537240862846375, 0.013214319944381714, 0.04771805554628372, -0.009849810041487217, 0.010906938463449478, 0.00914997048676014, -0.057535137981176376, 0.020159384235739708, 0.0029612104408442974, 0.025893045589327812, 0.031227469444274902, -0.02126745693385601, 0.03339357674121857, -0.02303726226091385, 0.006976953707635403, -0.002201793249696493, 0.017028987407684326, -0.04915120452642441, -0.01527819037437439, 0.011252152733504772, -0.010416033677756786, 0.04237503930926323, -0.01879219524562359, -0.026312267407774925, 0.05198877304792404, -0.03833839297294617, 0.002977216150611639, -0.02658412791788578, 0.004491426050662994, -0.061520349234342575, 0.010910247452557087, 0.003213150193914771, 0.0017565845046192408, -0.0036342046223580837, 0.023051517084240913, -0.01667475886642933, 0.01307640504091978, 0.03889184817671776, 0.014436189085245132, 0.013058566488325596, -0.002501585753634572, 0.00162366998847574, -0.013297956436872482, -0.03427337855100632, -0.012047274969518185, -0.018174462020397186, 0.04406517744064331, 0.04133071377873421, -0.018251562491059303, -0.025731783360242844, -0.02831813506782055, 0.0030443575233221054, 0.07389971613883972, -0.06829877942800522, -0.009914321824908257, -0.036585211753845215, 0.017568128183484077, -0.012482340447604656, -0.021437181159853935 ]
<p>Let's say I have 7 urns filled with random numbers of colourful marbles. An example dataset is as below:</p> <pre><code>data &lt;- matrix (c(5,3,4,4,4,2,1,1,1,1,1,2,2,1,2,2,1,1,2,1,4,1,1,2,4,1,3,1,7,1,1,2,1,3,3), ncol = 5); rownames(data) &lt;- as.character(seq(1,7)); colnames(data) &lt;- c("red", "blue", "yellow", "green", "pink"); </code></pre> <p>I assume the count-based colour distribution to be multinomial. I want to test whether the contents of Urn 1 follow the colour distribution of Urns 2-7. </p> <p>I get the MLEs for Urns 2-7 as:</p> <pre><code>p_sample &lt;- colSums(data[2:7,])/ sum(colSums(data[2:7,])) </code></pre> <p><strong>1)</strong> When I run a $\chi^2$ test as below, R displays a warning message since the expected counts (EC)&lt;5. </p> <pre><code>obs &lt;- data["1",] chisq.test(obs,p=p_sample) # Chi-squared test for given probabilities # data: obs # X-squared = 8.0578, df = 4, p-value = 0.08948 # # Warning message: # In chisq.test(obs, p = p_sample) : # Chi-squared approximation may be incorrect </code></pre> <p>One of the answers to this <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/14226/given-the-power-of-computers-these-days-is-there-ever-a-reason-to-do-a-chi-squa">question</a> states that $\chi^2$ test would nevertheless return accurate results as long as ECs exceed 1.0 if a very simple $\frac{N-1}{N}$ correction is applied to the test statistic. Is the correction implemented simply like this: $\chi^2 = (\sum_i \frac{(O_i - E_i)^2}{E_i} )* \frac{N-1}{N} $ ?</p> <p>This <a href="https://sites.google.com/a/lakeheadu.ca/bweaver/Home/statistics/notes/chisqr_assumptions" rel="nofollow">link</a> suggests so but I am not sure about its reliability:</p> <blockquote> <p>If one has the regular Pearson chi-square (e.g., in the output from statistical software), it can be converted to the 'N - 1' chi-square as follows:</p> <pre><code> 'N -1' chi-square = Pearson chi-square x (N -1) / N </code></pre> </blockquote> <p><strong>2)</strong> Alternative to $\chi^2$, since the number of counts is low, I ran a Fisher's exact test and got the results below. Is how I call the fisher.test below correct? The result I get makes me think: "No". I am confused since the R help document only refers to use cases for contingency tables.</p> <pre><code>fisher.test(obs, sum(obs)*p_sample) # Fisher's Exact Test for Count Data # # data: obs and sum(obs) * p_sample # p-value = 1 # alternative hypothesis: two.sided </code></pre>
74,183
[ -0.046435777097940445, -0.0627143457531929, 0.030796028673648834, -0.03722793608903885, 0.03448955714702606, 0.03243044763803482, 0.030560435727238655, -0.026795074343681335, -0.007160866633057594, -0.0071049961261451244, 0.06397717446088791, 0.0421217642724514, 0.023943636566400528, 0.0349145233631134, 0.04116039350628853, 0.020936140790581703, -0.014963148161768913, 0.028877289965748787, -0.008944162167608738, 0.027068473398685455, 0.0408896878361702, 0.009528007358312607, -0.002673929324373603, -0.0081856157630682, -0.043736781924963, 0.02086397260427475, 0.044963523745536804, -0.03440074995160103, 0.0006802877178415656, 0.06335395574569702, -0.07098197191953659, 0.009085296653211117, 0.04709799215197563, 0.025294138118624687, -0.003797483164817095, 0.005996460560709238, -0.0038609718903899193, -0.015477458946406841, -0.028069397434592247, -0.005726172123104334, 0.02700461819767952, 0.0034407926723361015, 0.00911540724337101, 0.02762349508702755, 0.007109419442713261, 0.009971406310796738, -0.006384928245097399, -0.025461601093411446, 0.050322119146585464, -0.04368125647306442, 0.1018558219075203, -0.04165792092680931, 0.033719923347234726, 0.00995541736483574, -0.048100803047418594, -0.014262768439948559, 0.03173254430294037, 0.052816152572631836, 0.0006229333812370896, -0.055162131786346436, -0.007134600076824427, -0.012417593970894814, 0.03696584329009056, -0.0279815886169672, -0.0368376225233078, -0.0017901500687003136, 0.017440898343920708, -0.016920214518904686, 0.044499341398477554, -0.013453570194542408, 0.005274916533380747, 0.034281983971595764, 0.03694634512066841, -0.004722713027149439, 0.010570939630270004, -0.009257136844098568, 0.018207434564828873, 0.027037091553211212, 0.017053689807653427, -0.004714026581496, -0.02267446368932724, 0.003483900334686041, -0.006490163039416075, 0.028149044141173363, 0.045712657272815704, -0.005690965801477432, -0.0027561362367123365, -0.04987945780158043, -0.012026935815811157, 0.014322224073112011, -0.013888509944081306, -0.02023838832974434, 0.04786456376314163, 0.038881734013557434, -0.0369536429643631, 0.011477768421173096, -0.03460363298654556, 0.029596932232379913, -0.029635753482580185, -0.006320556625723839, -0.024442052468657494, -0.038974910974502563, 0.014429451897740364, 0.03663768991827965, -0.05640070140361786, -0.018411431461572647, -0.01362791657447815, -0.029039178043603897, -0.003196654375642538, -0.03143758326768875, -0.010518648661673069, 0.028227536007761955, 0.01277329120784998, 0.0023315157741308212, 0.004538505803793669, -0.04377696290612221, -0.021310044452548027, -0.012771346606314182, 0.02492739073932171, 0.06344042718410492, 0.03699152544140816, 0.005841396749019623, -0.004061288665980101, -0.06680221110582352, -0.028750455006957054, 0.029315369203686714, 0.016166847199201584, -0.0054613929241895676, -0.06308228522539139, 0.04604142904281616, -0.009716550819575787, -0.01159616932272911, 0.040032267570495605, 0.02941642887890339, 0.02695619687438011, -0.018022771924734116, -0.08054306358098984, -0.052450213581323624, 0.01810377836227417, -0.017832644283771515, -0.00675790524110198, -0.04268971085548401, -0.021020960062742233, 0.06661425530910492, 0.0578913539648056, 0.0015892547089606524, 0.06616813689470291, 0.007319100201129913, 0.009338386356830597, 0.017510339617729187, -0.03916050121188164, -0.01539397332817316, -0.03116803988814354, -0.013213559053838253, 0.011790158227086067, -0.06244002282619476, 0.04496137797832489, 0.011713511310517788, 0.004869302734732628, 0.007045679725706577, 0.013314967975020409, 0.0037547422107309103, 0.010639442130923271, -0.03999485448002815, -0.015174616128206253, -0.013122943229973316, 0.06451241672039032, 0.030858684331178665, 0.007333459332585335, 0.025555893778800964, -0.0387217178940773, -0.007210058160126209, -0.01519348006695509, 0.049360889941453934, 0.060474131256341934, 0.01515210885554552, 0.03544524312019348, 0.003171502612531185, 0.03765144199132919, 0.03200975060462952, -0.050369758158922195, -0.022564874961972237, -0.03900938108563423, -0.022467784583568573, 0.04228755831718445, 0.025651387870311737, 0.027438204735517502, -0.06154283508658409, 0.06386282294988632, -0.06176362186670303, -0.060869112610816956, -0.04173944517970085, -0.005207622889429331, -0.008467678911983967, -0.07279860228300095, 0.011918148957192898, 0.0238419771194458, -0.004887638613581657, 0.024664193391799927, 0.005193294957280159, -0.038638219237327576, -0.013296757824718952, 0.04042491689324379, -0.05170299485325813, -0.04050079360604286, 0.0019193795742467046, 0.028641561046242714, 0.0062424116767942905, 0.040895648300647736, -0.030516358092427254, -0.006364353466778994, 0.013929257169365883, -0.01894262805581093, -0.008197151124477386, 0.03914390504360199, 0.016575006768107414, 0.021422477439045906, -0.003240167396143079, -0.018592629581689835, 0.0415322482585907, -0.07161013782024384, 0.03126510605216026, 0.05517315864562988, -0.012702303938567638, -0.0005511877243407071, -0.02510741725564003, -0.002501159440726042, 0.04489974305033684, -0.01426954846829176, 0.024655794724822044, -0.03536135330796242, -0.00016228239110205323, -0.014986677095293999, 0.031764041632413864, -0.052099063992500305, 0.0021713138557970524, 0.03048582375049591, -0.0019739142153412104, -0.006647788919508457, 0.03291847184300423, -0.03798467665910721, -0.029522033408284187, 0.037360530346632004, 0.015377562493085861, -0.02423602156341076, 0.02606133185327053, 0.03292306885123253, -0.0021110251545906067, 0.009626663289964199, -0.01563487946987152, -0.012109557166695595, -0.0002832514001056552, -0.03831460326910019, -0.011993232183158398, -0.041355233639478683, -0.02244897186756134, 0.04162153601646423, -0.005127774551510811, -0.02282562479376793, 0.038881976157426834, 0.02367265895009041, -0.016859259456396103, -0.018753400072455406, -0.038954924792051315, -0.0015510240336880088, 0.03149842470884323, -0.07964474707841873, -0.023588892072439194, 0.01730860210955143, -0.019368452951312065, 0.013595975935459137, -0.01768157258629799, -0.03447277843952179, -0.048108939081430435, 0.036392685025930405, 0.012193172238767147, -0.019823873415589333, -0.0008859141962602735, -0.019401177763938904, -0.022484755143523216, -0.02473200485110283, -0.023734427988529205, 0.024805283173918724, -0.002480019349604845, -0.04730632156133652, -0.015265585854649544, -0.029283076524734497, -0.011947273276746273, -0.00811779499053955, 0.008338689804077148, -0.049960412085056305, 0.05437026545405388, 0.023781461641192436, -0.00033638038439676166, -0.022146809846162796, 0.007784165907651186, -0.020360207185149193, -0.037997644394636154, -0.0004855224397033453, 0.02699217014014721, 0.019632792100310326, -0.05951022729277611, 0.035112299025058746, -0.06281498074531555, 0.006068401038646698, -0.028146326541900635, -0.005904293619096279, -0.02830655872821808, -0.020996518433094025, 0.022404862567782402, 0.026085294783115387, 0.020867696031928062, -0.022036787122488022, -0.06524156779050827, -0.02887418493628502, -0.017225218936800957, -0.0009279592195525765, 0.03751217946410179, 0.03054174594581127, 0.011165894567966461, 0.06214147061109543, 0.031040586531162262, -0.028178445994853973, -0.03392823785543442, -0.004856890998780727, -0.03873559087514877, -0.06113002821803093, 0.020625079050660133, 0.009642479009926319, 0.009980428032577038, 0.016910258680582047, -0.01634139008820057, 0.02719859778881073, 0.0402996651828289, -0.019290417432785034, 0.014369772747159004, 0.015000926330685616, -0.04560456797480583, -0.0282187070697546, 0.030044538900256157, 0.04379089176654816, -0.029684346169233322, 0.022440176457166672, -0.0008271762635558844, 0.01738196797668934, -0.022155027836561203, -0.025508904829621315, 0.005209296476095915, -0.007773799821734428, 0.06415363401174545, -0.020646005868911743, 0.06942471861839294, 0.012762629427015781, -0.05675201490521431, 0.011596295982599258, 0.023655127733945847, 0.024778328835964203, -0.04110118746757507, -0.0034908244851976633, 0.060207799077034, 0.05082940682768822, -0.017925914376974106, 0.025067362934350967, -0.024893729016184807, -0.004164346493780613, 0.03832974657416344, -0.04292343556880951, 0.0072587947361171246, 0.028535155579447746, 0.050813402980566025, 0.03654484450817108, 0.029910612851381302, 0.014432924799621105, 0.010412488132715225, -0.015386811457574368, -0.020922895520925522, -0.02571362815797329, 0.05172724276781082, 0.016398144885897636, 0.0642540231347084, 0.025385068729519844, -0.05970088392496109, -0.0016627745935693383, -0.019189544022083282, -0.0698196291923523, 0.0239428523927927, 0.03730688989162445, -0.012917332351207733, -0.0090159447863698, -0.056177351623773575, 0.0160396546125412, -0.0492132268846035, 0.023864366114139557, 0.039484746754169464, 0.019092455506324768, -0.03280787169933319, 0.062001731246709824, -0.0002424218546366319, 0.041227757930755615, 0.008263013325631618, 0.031586773693561554, 0.031003013253211975, 0.007360578048974276, 0.030986584722995758, -0.0021753935143351555, -0.026501549407839775, 0.001060732640326023, -0.017004411667585373, 0.05917932465672493, 0.0042684320360422134, 0.0447850376367569, 0.007333796937018633, 0.05086987838149071, -0.03254915773868561, -0.011304020881652832, -0.012253028340637684, 0.02759043499827385, 0.05298163369297981, -0.004267562180757523, 0.03408585861325264, -0.026546847075223923, -0.0009649343555793166, 0.025664126500487328, 0.01915176957845688, 0.00490589952096343, -0.029165975749492645, 0.03531631454825401, 0.007285129278898239, -0.03494730219244957, 0.032799430191516876, 0.07152649760246277, 0.017081785947084427, -0.02530040219426155, 0.012928787618875504, 0.020912999287247658, -0.0213626641780138, 0.017758341506123543, -0.015273555181920528, 0.038178469985723495, 0.007498085033148527, 0.015138058923184872, 0.03464138135313988, -0.02861104905605316, -0.05716901272535324, -0.02377333864569664, 0.026916222646832466, 0.004576512146741152, -0.02097637765109539, -0.013925300911068916, -0.013464197516441345, 0.0595083087682724, 0.01773221231997013, -0.014893263578414917, -0.02609262801706791, -0.10123766958713531, 0.00459090992808342, 0.04076322540640831, 0.04661192372441292, -0.015308166854083538, -0.013746822252869606, -0.056205447763204575, 0.009145798161625862, 0.017623215913772583, -0.04055828973650932, 0.024298924952745438, -0.016918517649173737, 0.034116193652153015, -0.01683826744556427, -0.014633283950388432, -0.05295681580901146, 0.021191643550992012, -0.05074147880077362, 0.03971928730607033, -0.036295901983976364, -0.020210901275277138, -0.0717630609869957, -0.007343069650232792, 0.042152635753154755, 0.02987672947347164, -0.08783812075853348, -0.04289849475026131, 0.011181148700416088, 0.006711215246468782, -0.011797991581261158, -0.03195924311876297, 0.04955224692821503, -0.04270000010728836, 0.0390387661755085, 0.06909625232219696, 0.009415296837687492, 0.01567121595144272, 0.006358915939927101, 0.03550859913229942, -0.01864311657845974, -0.0016633898485451937, -0.035787761211395264, 0.015685800462961197, 0.0016144521068781614, -0.00820181705057621, 0.0402817539870739, 0.02278319001197815, 0.002774246037006378, 0.034827280789613724, -0.09144989401102066, 0.013314390555024147, -0.0034006177447736263, -0.02135874517261982, -0.049247000366449356, -0.002805489581078291, -0.0038739319425076246, 0.012256837449967861, 0.008012774400413036, 0.007949997670948505, -0.0017829795833677053, -0.023998994380235672, 0.047718364745378494, 0.025692163035273552, 0.003154166042804718, 0.02752668224275112, 0.009085786528885365, 0.015961112454533577, 0.000753565866034478, 0.03255833312869072, 0.05862531438469887, -0.01484367623925209, -0.0051172226667404175, 0.04204066842794418, -0.03078671172261238, 0.02406494691967964, -0.04722774028778076, -0.012828822247684002, 0.01279673632234335, 0.0006687839049845934, 0.017900481820106506, -0.00891690980643034, 0.048091646283864975, -0.009022310376167297, 0.0018496669363230467, 0.006980422418564558, 0.031186005100607872, -0.03004441410303116, -0.0010016941232606769, -0.005135111976414919, 0.04721124470233917, 0.018765786662697792, -0.010089711286127567, -0.05063304677605629, -0.03508691117167473, -0.03302042558789253, -0.01028304360806942, -0.028729746118187904, -0.03846103325486183, -0.0715477243065834, -0.016483349725604057, -0.0007346295169554651, -0.0013482717331498861, 0.0225264523178339, -0.018587786704301834, -0.009147774428129196, -0.013592420145869255, -0.03087623417377472, 0.06933579593896866, 0.010140465572476387, -0.02971200831234455, 0.026003248989582062, -0.021915249526500702, 0.01742917113006115, -0.005336403846740723, -0.005309239961206913, -0.05831054225564003, -0.022110488265752792, -0.007451269775629044, 0.022957157343626022, 0.03694043681025505, -0.021430743858218193, -0.06691678613424301, -0.01829390786588192, -0.012146704830229282, 0.004297902807593346, -0.0430707223713398, 0.0008741030469536781, -0.03439214080572128, -0.018144024536013603, -0.021562518551945686, -0.02024799957871437, -0.0007606364670209587, 0.029922977089881897, 0.019292516633868217, -0.016921577975153923, 0.0060123540461063385, 0.05407384783029556, 0.08784730732440948, 0.003623558674007654, -0.021204641088843346, -0.0349702462553978, 0.007234734483063221, 0.033771757036447525, 0.01474779099225998, -0.01216074451804161, -0.013983270153403282, 0.012628370895981789, 0.0027915602549910545, 0.007649715524166822, -0.0448291189968586, 0.006967312190681696, 0.04044603183865547, -0.0057762907817959785, 0.03147049993276596, 0.01862967759370804, 0.0006488155340775847, -0.011234017089009285, -0.0043318611569702625, -0.02297240123152733, -0.02031310647726059, 0.044715531170368195, 0.06163906306028366, 0.0043764072470366955, 0.0033217640593647957, 0.020338842645287514, 0.0014117681421339512, 0.003531479509547353, 0.034214191138744354, 0.028777694329619408, -0.005662053823471069, 0.03138706833124161, -0.05311449617147446, -0.007356414571404457, 0.05373150482773781, -0.01273586880415678, 0.027507765218615532, -0.0358123816549778, -0.01070345751941204, 0.03246358036994934, 0.05969926714897156, -0.02276463620364666, -0.0028649610467255116, -0.029366666451096535, -0.012624336406588554, 0.00004040267231175676, 0.035542555153369904, -0.005052307620644569, 0.012471577152609825, -0.021222172304987907, 0.032086487859487534, 0.015992633998394012, 0.03487292677164078, -0.024086255580186844, -0.06692245602607727, 0.0005020081298425794, -0.0007593633490614593, -0.04987214133143425, 0.027825338765978813, 0.02505502663552761, -0.014990659430623055, -0.001097363419830799, -0.004336279816925526, 0.041948940604925156, 0.01665685512125492, 0.04304380714893341, -0.026024293154478073, 0.02913903072476387, -0.024735238403081894, 0.012589304707944393, -0.011149990372359753, -0.03663571923971176, 0.11773286759853363, 0.07062826305627823, 0.025679007172584534, -0.06994634866714478, 0.01361986342817545, 0.034051477909088135, -0.01935228519141674, -0.027157094329595566, -0.03103572130203247, 0.011657638475298882, 0.018702689558267593, 0.05173260346055031, 0.07706764340400696, 0.03485575690865517, 0.025377754122018814, 0.038733262568712234, -0.014638230204582214, -0.032172754406929016, 0.01695672981441021, 0.03252864629030228, -0.015722213312983513, 0.0029388470575213432, -0.04827244207262993, -0.0035226810723543167, 0.037135228514671326, -0.0026464906986802816, -0.0464179590344429, -0.02027767337858677, -0.01218836847692728, 0.011251182295382023, -0.027663100510835648, 0.02966163493692875, 0.019942548125982285, 0.012624138966202736, -0.005716581828892231, -0.01077003963291645, 0.01953749544918537, -0.03398963436484337, 0.0626378208398819, 0.03939669579267502, 0.015574666671454906, -0.027315441519021988, 0.02098710834980011, 0.04645829647779465, -0.0354057215154171, -0.032208167016506195, -0.06500717252492905, 0.04188133403658867, -0.00816556066274643, -0.03549065440893173, 0.0005771828000433743, -0.010430537164211273, -0.024585247039794922, -0.0672934502363205, 0.0009895235998556018, 0.006272288970649242, 0.02299303002655506, -0.014816001057624817, -0.01825796067714691, -0.01223227009177208, 0.026360733434557915, 0.007675573695451021, 0.01464965008199215, 0.051598142832517624, -0.013165343552827835, -0.028347240760922432, -0.032133474946022034, 0.027049046009778976, -0.00549636734649539, 0.003170155454427004, 0.008958506397902966, -0.03039940632879734, -0.008067473769187927, 0.018972236663103104, 0.013242263346910477, 0.006455984432250261, -0.008436919189989567, -0.007645808160305023, -0.04007668420672417, -0.011910485103726387, -0.02167721837759018, 0.026812970638275146, -0.01837356761097908, -0.06654055416584015, -0.03544038534164429, -0.01460498571395874, 0.041370440274477005, 0.017401553690433502, 0.013943232595920563, 0.009741895832121372, -0.020900502800941467, 0.09673865139484406, 0.006756745278835297, -0.015680944547057152, -0.024035749956965446, -0.013758613727986813, -0.02584826573729515, -0.008686359971761703, -0.0017169220373034477, 0.04382684826850891, 0.015840226784348488, 0.0012837080284953117, 0.013660188764333725, 0.007505753077566624, 0.006008689757436514, -0.010719042271375656, 0.020681986585259438, -0.02920469455420971, -0.004098616074770689, -0.009676306508481503, -0.0192496869713068, -0.017578748986124992, -0.024762166664004326, -0.02909596636891365, -0.09061352908611298, 0.026030244305729866, -0.040099259465932846, -0.04348769411444664, -0.03345666080713272, -0.02136373706161976, -0.020954273641109467, 0.00968956295400858, -0.018510576337575912, -0.018997101113200188, -0.003762453095987439, -0.015407824888825417, -0.037662435322999954, -0.020597342401742935, 0.02842073142528534, -0.032623693346977234, 0.01855388656258583, 0.031069748103618622, 0.003080831142142415, 0.029140934348106384, -0.0035922599490731955, 0.02365167811512947, 0.02061622217297554, 0.04672571271657944, 0.02427631802856922, -0.01199472974985838, 0.05150405317544937, -0.055122967809438705, -0.047592394053936005, 0.01871434412896633, -0.03488536551594734, 0.04555382952094078, 0.0035889733117073774, -0.005499348510056734, 0.0058589172549545765, 0.011957007460296154, -0.0532275028526783, 0.0005805932451039553, 0.004612510558217764, 0.008565896190702915, 0.02881135791540146, -0.010819287039339542, 0.0255231112241745, -0.006752774119377136, -0.008886548690497875, 0.007579298224300146, 0.05135111138224602, -0.0005707837408408523, -0.012646125629544258, -0.014330927282571793, -0.05101991817355156, 0.007099742069840431, -0.0022799961734563112, -0.0039974297396838665, -0.010268277488648891, 0.021755358204245567, -0.04945680871605873, 0.008110838010907173, -0.015037420205771923, 0.0051688263192772865, -0.10581338405609131, -0.03570365905761719, 0.025635382160544395, 0.0045652552507817745, 0.03241204097867012, -0.05898861959576607, 0.05573808029294014, 0.056486546993255615, -0.049937598407268524, -0.022355280816555023, -0.0010659098625183105, -0.008990895003080368, -0.03239409998059273, 0.05333659052848816, -0.021743960678577423, 0.017502671107649803, 0.05975699424743652, 0.011684880591928959, 0.05940777063369751, -0.014716858975589275, -0.03202909603714943, -0.02857161872088909, 0.0008907227893359959, 0.00923036690801382, 0.01651543192565441, -0.030760403722524643, 0.04129628464579582, 0.0010670938063412905, -0.020689165219664574, 0.019220223650336266, -0.0014892072649672627, 0.030163872987031937, 0.012934418395161629, 0.040831372141838074, 0.04121088236570358, 0.04292470961809158, -0.012424048036336899, -0.022245673462748528, -0.01828397996723652, 0.0025320190470665693, 0.02406112477183342, 0.03605205938220024, -0.035939693450927734, 0.019796011969447136, 0.03263576701283455, 0.0020571015775203705, -0.006625058129429817, 0.0431276336312294, -0.0037955993320792913, -0.020355865359306335, -0.014616086147725582, 0.0021015338134020567, 0.007915031164884567, -0.01563332788646221, 0.05162375047802925, -0.06995970755815506, 0.03952982276678085, 0.026755061000585556, 0.08753480762243271, -0.0020294098649173975, 0.03512236103415489, 0.0006615045131184161, -0.028698747977614403, 0.0037800678983330727, 0.010945908725261688, -0.006394652649760246, -0.010909048840403557, -0.020834313705563545, -0.01674015447497368, 0.040045157074928284, 0.003296027658507228, 0.010183635167777538, -0.026342693716287613, 0.036332037299871445, 0.013330789282917976, -0.002358470344915986, 0.013576140627264977, 0.01563420332968235, 0.04386996477842331, -0.0837010070681572, 0.00744310999289155, 0.009931907057762146, 0.011830450966954231, -0.047348860651254654, 0.02729707956314087, -0.054911911487579346, 0.021805444732308388, 0.02712351083755493, 0.027491113170981407, -0.012493868358433247, 0.027965638786554337, 0.031580887734889984, 0.0005329038831405342, -0.036837682127952576, 0.01452280580997467, -0.03229692578315735, 0.006182826589792967, -0.06343957781791687, 0.020254308357834816, 0.026426708325743675, 0.02597622759640217, -0.016543986275792122, -0.0033758264034986496, -0.04580342024564743, 0.011446909047663212, -0.03304579108953476, 0.04461406543850899, 0.011678049340844154, -0.002100299345329404, 0.009598496370017529, -0.02949625253677368, 0.014811701141297817, 0.050749145448207855, 0.01201644167304039, -0.040587425231933594, 0.03570827841758728, -0.02717563323676586, -0.011396652087569237, 0.04638572409749031, -0.005801640450954437, -0.04005419462919235, -0.01610592007637024, 0.009849181398749352, 0.006243813782930374, -0.025781432166695595, -0.021194688975811005, 0.01321934163570404, 0.024233058094978333, 0.022397218272089958, 0.006694876588881016, 0.008442755788564682, -0.01016008760780096, -0.016238057985901833, 0.014429448172450066, 0.004800616763532162, -0.004180927760899067, -0.0366322286427021, -0.020622316747903824, 0.0204840749502182, -0.0024705424439162016, -0.017063820734620094, 0.00593883590772748, 0.05659914016723633, 0.010220845229923725, -0.013247672468423843, 0.010165520012378693, -0.032923124730587006, 0.013596591539680958, -0.007332971785217524, -0.011496184393763542, 0.019072556868195534, -0.02532288245856762, 0.03012275882065296, -0.030816009268164635, -0.033084675669670105, -0.019442284479737282, -0.005761608015745878, -0.009705320000648499, 0.035211775451898575, -0.014958100393414497, 0.04858748987317085, 0.02684316225349903, -0.00021361676044762135, 0.021515313535928726, -0.03333127498626709, 0.013313215225934982, 0.03738948702812195, -0.01492547057569027, 0.018838275223970413, -0.020788123831152916, 0.021210238337516785, 0.009575028903782368, 0.030988598242402077, 0.019626596942543983, -0.001076816231943667, -0.04336796700954437, 0.005722570698708296, 0.020263826474547386, 0.011824850924313068, -0.013180568814277649, 0.0031308582983911037, -0.01940317451953888, 0.029348917305469513, 0.0030015488155186176, -0.05239817500114441 ]
<p>Apologies if this is a very basic question.</p> <p>If we have data that are not normally distributed (e.g. skewed, Shapiro-Wilk test is significant) and we resort to rank-based methods (e.g. Wilcoxon Signed Rank test), then do we need to be concerned with outliers?</p> <p>Imagine, for example, we plot the data using a boxplot and a minority of data points are marked as outliers. Should we transform those points? Or remove them? It seems to me that many textbooks talk about dealing with outliers, but only because they exert a major influence on the parameters such as mean and standard deviation. However, when we use a rank-based test they will already be 'transformed' to be the next value in the rank, and would therefore not exert a major influence on the test. I have not seen this stated explicitly in a statistics book so far, so I thought I would ask the question here.</p> <p>Do we need to worry about outliers when using rank-based tests?</p>
279
[ -0.015351077541708946, 0.0026366999372839928, -0.014223779551684856, -0.019147248938679695, 0.04049897938966751, 0.023882245644927025, 0.004848878365010023, -0.006192245054990053, 0.045491866767406464, -0.03971416503190994, 0.019582659006118774, -0.0007072659791447222, 0.04154793918132782, -0.01740245148539543, -0.004783157259225845, -0.01778525672852993, -0.04917529970407486, 0.010563497431576252, -0.004679796751588583, 0.0034322477877140045, 0.0013786643976345658, 0.03719688206911087, 0.03526643291115761, -0.0025477753952145576, -0.04815534129738808, 0.028437845408916473, 0.0033424552530050278, -0.020035525783896446, 0.028760598972439766, 0.038351621478796005, -0.0529739074409008, 0.001261831377632916, 0.03239061310887337, 0.03173404186964035, 0.027168037369847298, 0.004423368722200394, -0.004427047912031412, -0.028371799737215042, -0.007482606917619705, 0.01756969280540943, -0.0070291245356202126, -0.03880668058991432, 0.02403377555310726, 0.0027602987829595804, -0.010683500207960606, 0.04667513445019722, 0.014942526817321777, -0.06560249626636505, 0.011285450309515, -0.04592575877904892, 0.047879453748464584, 0.00671427883207798, -0.0023563967552036047, 0.03286992013454437, -0.025940537452697754, -0.004765485879033804, 0.05918359011411667, 0.03905133530497551, -0.03119533509016037, -0.038193751126527786, -0.01228339597582817, -0.027953285723924637, -0.021046223118901253, -0.018279103562235832, -0.04125726595520973, 0.027673665434122086, -0.020116755738854408, -0.017129702493548393, 0.0614902563393116, -0.008249611593782902, -0.017104564234614372, 0.04008803144097328, 0.014425688423216343, -0.02404889091849327, -0.008769071660935879, -0.0184004008769989, 0.03233083337545395, 0.004090688191354275, 0.04673386737704277, 0.03669710457324982, 0.022368038073182106, 0.010120819322764874, 0.014389945194125175, 0.02980157732963562, 0.026051754131913185, -0.0036793146282434464, 0.0546996109187603, -0.05544916167855263, 0.017625944688916206, 0.05225621536374092, -0.0004481735231820494, -0.032428137958049774, 0.040335096418857574, -0.015491124242544174, -0.05161212012171745, -0.010865014977753162, -0.054725438356399536, 0.012517904862761497, -0.03925802558660507, -0.020785007625818253, -0.007049292791634798, -0.038451846688985825, 0.03713464364409447, 0.02804083377122879, -0.02898436039686203, -0.01292465440928936, -0.02388288453221321, 0.019958840683102608, -0.014223032630980015, -0.057773079723119736, -0.031135862693190575, 0.006985248997807503, -0.014197556301951408, 0.018941370770335197, 0.04942724108695984, 0.019156591966748238, 0.02564302273094654, 0.004528919700533152, 0.04927792772650719, 0.02428918331861496, 0.04580965265631676, -0.0014147342881187797, 0.017405547201633453, -0.024728434160351753, -0.027209710329771042, 0.014310155063867569, 0.02613612823188305, 0.012558951042592525, -0.03642168268561363, 0.034264858812093735, 0.01314953900873661, 0.0215107761323452, 0.0433819517493248, 0.012489574030041695, 0.055405955761671066, -0.023809315636754036, -0.09673979133367538, -0.048753540962934494, 0.040121667087078094, 0.0006816898821853101, -0.019032679498195648, -0.07047772407531738, -0.021104879677295685, 0.04275456815958023, 0.007494061253964901, 0.022828303277492523, 0.030821604654192924, 0.012861202470958233, 0.02751551941037178, -0.0027645984664559364, -0.017626065760850906, -0.0073789265006780624, -0.028594905510544777, -0.03862251713871956, -0.005739795044064522, -0.09620431065559387, 0.0259946770966053, 0.028611183166503906, 0.001595672219991684, -0.0312996469438076, 0.019368506968021393, 0.003072427585721016, 0.011844410561025143, -0.03295120969414711, 0.004803193733096123, 0.02240925095975399, 0.05804076045751572, -0.003999672830104828, 0.04249903932213783, 0.02487451583147049, 0.007990999147295952, 0.025977158918976784, 0.037504907697439194, 0.05256719887256622, 0.05376345291733742, -0.024468112736940384, -0.0026970028411597013, -0.06599870324134827, 0.047114014625549316, 0.0003195141616743058, -0.044543344527482986, -0.020387500524520874, -0.009924937039613724, 0.009786425158381462, -0.00014836211630608886, 0.036595407873392105, -0.0004068191337864846, -0.0226481631398201, 0.07880759984254837, -0.04852656275033951, -0.03017207235097885, -0.07402081042528152, 0.01285282988101244, 0.008089549839496613, -0.04553419351577759, 0.026698976755142212, 0.02761217951774597, 0.013439221307635307, -0.029827717691659927, 0.0026934887282550335, -0.0010697075631469488, 0.010839165188372135, 0.027362601831555367, -0.06950227916240692, -0.00799952819943428, 0.02457154169678688, 0.02326982654631138, -0.019265146926045418, 0.006356109399348497, -0.051054779440164566, -0.043768174946308136, 0.016657326370477676, -0.047067273408174515, 0.0212584026157856, 0.003083890536800027, -0.013787980191409588, 0.02092425711452961, -0.0021461688447743654, -0.025716694071888924, 0.032197173684835434, -0.03396881744265556, 0.056099142879247665, 0.040893636643886566, -0.01606404036283493, -0.011043325997889042, -0.027665087953209877, 0.009850847534835339, -0.013147124089300632, -0.0202132910490036, -0.006213443353772163, -0.04445936158299446, -0.000862350279930979, 0.01610754057765007, 0.008252421393990517, -0.04520495608448982, 0.007687749341130257, 0.07471466809511185, 0.014133674092590809, 0.01068799290806055, 0.03735039755702019, -0.009840207174420357, -0.03911392018198967, -0.001576507231220603, 0.02465551532804966, 0.014195645228028297, 0.010288023389875889, 0.013925953768193722, 0.009213344193994999, 0.022460073232650757, 0.019769473001360893, 0.032860931009054184, 0.028067924082279205, 0.01253815833479166, 0.03142182528972626, -0.007818908430635929, 0.022157814353704453, 0.03087947890162468, -0.025455741211771965, -0.012732389383018017, 0.03504065424203873, -0.003465456422418356, 0.009855881333351135, 0.005016923416405916, -0.00014838596689514816, 0.02538200654089451, 0.038788408041000366, -0.05738481879234314, 0.01927359588444233, 0.010507892817258835, -0.053880102932453156, -0.018390582874417305, -0.03956935182213783, -0.04796309769153595, -0.03426162526011467, -0.001046225312165916, 0.04800914227962494, 0.008812816813588142, 0.047203488647937775, 0.00925100315362215, -0.018478428944945335, -0.022625979036092758, -0.025772826746106148, -0.01658516190946102, -0.0018595285946503282, -0.06565555185079575, 0.014259137213230133, -0.03377607837319374, -0.019066205248236656, -0.006269759498536587, -0.025738533586263657, 0.03822772204875946, 0.0023904074914753437, -0.0002175364934373647, -0.02576439455151558, -0.03063131868839264, -0.04827301949262619, 0.029904473572969437, -0.017458077520132065, -0.04769108444452286, 0.07001721858978271, -0.016312653198838234, -0.00553171755746007, 0.018193142488598824, -0.005008025094866753, -0.028675908222794533, -0.02325933799147606, 0.020844517275691032, 0.0294098649173975, 0.0012215649476274848, 0.0070600081235170364, -0.006339340470731258, -0.029743345454335213, -0.01284162886440754, -0.02209576778113842, -0.04964005574584007, 0.022067926824092865, 0.017428603023290634, 0.04606251046061516, 0.0062929922714829445, -0.05147046595811844, 0.07653647661209106, 0.04850050434470177, -0.039465732872486115, -0.01866140589118004, -0.027750499546527863, -0.05140037462115288, 0.0022092037834227085, 0.010199738666415215, 0.01175904180854559, 0.04789763316512108, 0.029517747461795807, 0.005785950925201178, 0.03407337889075279, 0.017620336264371872, 0.004216648172587156, -0.03194233402609825, -0.00013613967166747898, 0.045121677219867706, -0.004495400004088879, 0.025051262229681015, 0.03633539006114006, -0.03440296649932861, -0.005934176500886679, 0.027264170348644257, 0.01074992585927248, 0.028266172856092453, -0.02374541573226452, 0.023710448294878006, -0.028346894308924675, 0.005120495799928904, -0.020228184759616852, 0.03556990623474121, 0.03842361271381378, 0.005446328315883875, -0.02452274225652218, -0.0020279029849916697, 0.004790313076227903, -0.00685149198397994, 0.030219756066799164, 0.05038498342037201, 0.03380116447806358, -0.010427439585328102, 0.012951720505952835, 0.010659421794116497, -0.021775970235466957, 0.041564010083675385, -0.01627178303897381, -0.014178555458784103, 0.03536156564950943, 0.03197619691491127, 0.00554052134975791, -0.01908239535987377, -0.057984359562397, 0.004657980985939503, -0.02873699553310871, -0.013527337461709976, 0.0038056380581110716, 0.05042232200503349, -0.0034412641543895006, 0.025163205340504646, 0.05315510556101799, -0.012330913916230202, -0.030670903623104095, -0.018927207216620445, -0.03397306427359581, 0.019258862361311913, -0.04671479016542435, 0.004472562111914158, -0.004960527177900076, -0.004792677238583565, 0.018735934048891068, -0.022989576682448387, 0.016244158148765564, -0.0030465691816061735, 0.04508332163095474, -0.026385877281427383, 0.007460367865860462, -0.0492568165063858, -0.004465068690478802, 0.020840423181653023, 0.014475022442638874, -0.004514477681368589, -0.04423760622739792, 0.019402028992772102, 0.04866644740104675, 0.004416652023792267, -0.024390364065766335, -0.024672767147421837, 0.018689492717385292, 0.04774787276983261, 0.051508959382772446, 0.02514711394906044, 0.004516801796853542, -0.06759495288133621, 0.055079251527786255, 0.009606216102838516, 0.045442450791597366, 0.0015677101910114288, -0.020963607355952263, -0.01952289044857025, -0.03060334175825119, -0.04903487488627434, -0.019932571798563004, 0.004622702021151781, 0.025780832394957542, -0.01099962368607521, 0.04911672696471214, -0.0024485145695507526, -0.05447464808821678, 0.02327715791761875, 0.0558738149702549, 0.053419873118400574, 0.019941234961152077, -0.0175464004278183, 0.006350760813802481, 0.01298655103892088, -0.031852491199970245, 0.02464067004621029, -0.0063830106519162655, 0.008472143672406673, 0.02103823982179165, 0.023794202134013176, -0.004238335881382227, -0.02819831110537052, 0.018464725464582443, 0.0492715947329998, 0.062218960374593735, -0.0022283599246293306, -0.006169217173010111, 0.03312595561146736, -0.015172370709478855, 0.048628758639097214, 0.039138954132795334, -0.018781421706080437, -0.07186338305473328, 0.022499915212392807, 0.06353344768285751, 0.0425611175596714, -0.01985197328031063, 0.019862230867147446, -0.014671947807073593, 0.03362792357802391, 0.03484605625271797, -0.04431962966918945, -0.008192508481442928, -0.0032034784089773893, -0.011812785640358925, -0.03426653519272804, -0.02961777336895466, -0.05221095308661461, 0.006275990977883339, -0.010120055638253689, -0.007081256713718176, -0.04363581910729408, -0.04411914199590683, -0.03078550659120083, 0.009834391996264458, -0.021454283967614174, 0.07313791662454605, -0.012172692455351353, -0.0032116633374243975, -0.003606592770665884, 0.03533351421356201, -0.017069373279809952, -0.06479617208242416, 0.0024641018826514482, 0.017496559768915176, -0.007942600175738335, 0.07702518999576569, 0.003944121766835451, -0.0734693855047226, 0.004032919183373451, 0.020123805850744247, -0.018274039030075073, 0.008545154705643654, 0.001148729701526463, 0.04019986465573311, 0.026709912344813347, 0.012881271541118622, 0.03535984084010124, 0.016630925238132477, 0.010354158468544483, -0.023939646780490875, -0.021685903891921043, 0.03357406705617905, -0.0564129464328289, -0.0030883520375937223, -0.06386198848485947, -0.023658698424696922, -0.014429261907935143, 0.05094727501273155, -0.017062529921531677, 0.03240871801972389, -0.02775626629590988, 0.0011018969817087054, 0.032346200197935104, 0.03360336646437645, 0.021200085058808327, 0.02093273214995861, -0.016617080196738243, 0.032883454114198685, -0.010927189141511917, -0.017933782190084457, -0.007815600372850895, -0.015093258582055569, 0.019240397959947586, 0.010207301937043667, -0.05424436554312706, 0.009021729230880737, -0.03689951449632645, -0.014082551933825016, 0.024053798988461494, -0.008251729421317577, 0.05827023833990097, 0.008181627839803696, -0.02075296826660633, 0.022714102640748024, -0.02663729339838028, -0.002015328500419855, 0.026906970888376236, -0.016869770362973213, 0.036259058862924576, -0.04759592190384865, 0.023992985486984253, 0.01572573184967041, 0.02300443686544895, -0.07771611213684082, -0.05502459779381752, 0.003871987806633115, 0.0006522685871459544, 0.008561445400118828, -0.004487394820898771, 0.0041373902931809425, -0.01031939685344696, -0.015436380170285702, -0.030346207320690155, 0.0599701814353466, -0.025553550571203232, -0.043473754078149796, -0.004418640397489071, 0.01571059599518776, 0.09350747615098953, -0.0372513048350811, -0.02031680755317211, 0.010593869723379612, -0.0003897639107890427, -0.01959369145333767, 0.015252954326570034, 0.054259274154901505, -0.019682591781020164, -0.014929474331438541, -0.05196218565106392, -0.026116961613297462, 0.01862913742661476, -0.015160312876105309, -0.0046735056675970554, 0.009293212555348873, 0.007301196921616793, 0.0370638370513916, 0.005162840709090233, -0.024898894131183624, 0.018782977014780045, 0.024657748639583588, 0.021883754059672356, 0.002303827553987503, -0.006410143803805113, -0.018333643674850464, 0.027505524456501007, 0.003266583662480116, 0.005815950222313404, 0.02207089401781559, 0.06346457451581955, -0.022385677322745323, 0.03043069690465927, -0.044218920171260834, -0.08299071341753006, 0.05511057749390602, 0.003069277387112379, 0.008821279741823673, -0.015440966002643108, 0.022645948454737663, -0.024687353521585464, -0.034473054111003876, -0.044084176421165466, -0.006534423213452101, 0.0677628368139267, -0.008429287001490593, 0.015007928013801575, 0.036516036838293076, 0.0033851764164865017, -0.004175329115241766, -0.040860485285520554, -0.026394270360469818, -0.018782608211040497, -0.011106545105576515, 0.01867656409740448, 0.003148397197946906, 0.04853663593530655, 0.01401110552251339, 0.004644129890948534, 0.0027729985304176807, 0.04310975968837738, 0.01691863127052784, 0.030562318861484528, 0.027252135798335075, 0.011419333517551422, -0.03387996554374695, 0.027128510177135468, -0.05996051803231239, 0.04162165895104408, -0.02305024303495884, -0.012989741750061512, 0.04291967302560806, 0.029469454661011696, 0.02565653808414936, -0.03694763407111168, -0.035148169845342636, -0.06941916793584824, 0.02557276003062725, -0.02441658452153206, -0.01777859590947628, -0.00948525220155716, 0.006438551936298609, 0.05149545893073082, -0.011241928674280643, 0.027887815609574318, -0.02851949632167816, -0.08174502104520798, -0.0705125704407692, -0.00519602233543992, -0.028058793395757675, -0.0004362344043329358, -0.030638983473181725, -0.02838020958006382, 0.01858319714665413, -0.06921619921922684, 0.024843228980898857, -0.0010949368588626385, 0.055623091757297516, -0.03181200101971626, 0.0821332111954689, -0.00012677944323513657, 0.004443129058927298, 0.0038101577665656805, 0.017211265861988068, 0.11089980602264404, 0.07881733775138855, 0.014457798562943935, -0.09447149187326431, 0.020109359174966812, -0.0072778696194291115, 0.008612964302301407, -0.003718850901350379, 0.001962101086974144, 0.010050836019217968, 0.020193636417388916, 0.03076545149087906, 0.03640762344002724, 0.002376590622588992, -0.011684074066579342, 0.06624257564544678, -0.02064068801701069, -0.04460453242063522, -0.012416960671544075, 0.04667479544878006, -0.011445141397416592, 0.0076971338130533695, -0.06656907498836517, 0.007160328794270754, 0.004447968676686287, -0.021720856428146362, 0.017590485513210297, 0.0025385161861777306, -0.026286330074071884, 0.007859361357986927, -0.015441508032381535, 0.0004067542031407356, 0.044575851410627365, -0.0381929837167263, -0.055167876183986664, 0.012142227962613106, -0.011564381420612335, -0.04527943208813667, 0.027546599507331848, 0.03023267537355423, -0.0031666916329413652, -0.004421096760779619, 0.033685944974422455, 0.010693172924220562, -0.05049266666173935, -0.0022370759397745132, -0.02428171969950199, 0.009945571422576904, -0.02202508971095085, 0.02548367902636528, -0.01656401716172695, -0.016409898176789284, -0.008686370216310024, -0.06033426895737648, -0.031017258763313293, 0.01667589507997036, 0.018234463408589363, -0.0038107058499008417, 0.0015788323944434524, -0.03225640580058098, 0.0015612418064847589, -0.009224255569279194, 0.028492510318756104, 0.047354087233543396, -0.033853303641080856, -0.014150386676192284, -0.008456146344542503, 0.029591450467705727, 0.0027955491095781326, 0.02657249942421913, -0.013633986003696918, -0.006817050743848085, -0.013971365988254547, 0.011743050068616867, 0.024455372244119644, 0.006967821158468723, 0.04654612019658089, -0.01844421774148941, 0.019704528152942657, -0.03359328582882881, -0.08346838504076004, 0.05171164125204086, -0.03151528909802437, -0.02636447176337242, -0.042362410575151443, 0.03558088839054108, 0.02888740785419941, 0.05720745027065277, 0.03433195501565933, -0.028635380789637566, -0.007043893914669752, 0.027129990980029106, 0.02960743010044098, -0.06589693576097488, 0.023659395053982735, 0.03428269177675247, 0.010188682936131954, -0.02018335647881031, 0.003953046631067991, 0.06622425466775894, 0.0402180552482605, 0.019021587446331978, -0.025458896532654762, 0.03661996126174927, 0.031382374465465546, 0.02026144228875637, 0.023240435868501663, -0.06453222036361694, 0.017088500782847404, 0.01107088103890419, -0.0026958531234413385, -0.03120121918618679, -0.04745917022228241, -0.015213048085570335, -0.006212905514985323, -0.006714358925819397, -0.03128849342465401, -0.020526902750134468, -0.020412009209394455, -0.005497663281857967, 0.04104449227452278, -0.022657819092273712, -0.032069459557533264, -0.03219206631183624, -0.00557903666049242, 0.014170614071190357, -0.007441840134561062, -0.004206258337944746, -0.00940715242177248, -0.00013658036186825484, 0.026552723720669746, 0.008733749389648438, 0.03930380567908287, 0.029423220083117485, 0.004265309777110815, -0.022209474816918373, -0.015015712007880211, 0.04425567388534546, -0.01990688405930996, 0.010071229189634323, 0.050643760710954666, -0.022752054035663605, -0.05024178698658943, 0.03397122770547867, -0.004321829881519079, 0.010947822593152523, -0.0006994647555984557, 0.015880363062024117, -0.02226671203970909, 0.011656887829303741, -0.02196795679628849, -0.01559789851307869, -0.014618146233260632, -0.006973011884838343, -0.02208346500992775, 0.005584786180406809, 0.012301008217036724, -0.013987304642796516, -0.03442229703068733, 0.04503408074378967, 0.08119061589241028, 0.012610981240868568, 0.003335275687277317, 0.02005765028297901, 0.01316757407039404, 0.051283642649650574, -0.030702343210577965, 0.011706894263625145, 0.06221850588917732, 0.052191391587257385, -0.03735174238681793, 0.02008916810154915, -0.011564431712031364, 0.01023080013692379, -0.08673197776079178, -0.032531097531318665, 0.032366957515478134, 0.0009019661229103804, 0.019400764256715775, -0.045422401279211044, -0.031045246869325638, 0.053111761808395386, -0.05978298932313919, 0.06756766140460968, -0.01650763861835003, -0.023164380341768265, -0.031138388440012932, 0.003873064648360014, -0.007870432920753956, 0.045735497027635574, 0.018955610692501068, -0.005979650188237429, 0.02693445049226284, 0.02043655328452587, 0.008829840458929539, 0.008371616713702679, -0.011531613767147064, 0.04664745181798935, 0.013385104015469551, -0.09018466621637344, 0.03445354849100113, -0.015790138393640518, -0.01808859221637249, 0.03600407391786575, -0.010007383301854134, 0.006602764129638672, 0.03001290000975132, 0.001592751475982368, 0.006608149968087673, 0.03619566559791565, 0.03156523033976555, -0.013830004259943962, -0.05201970785856247, -0.016120988875627518, 0.030996471643447876, 0.021904360502958298, -0.0340333990752697, 0.040974605828523636, 0.012440639548003674, -0.06170305982232094, 0.006357067264616489, -0.019416214898228645, -0.04468246549367905, -0.001988865900784731, -0.010745539329946041, 0.02398390881717205, -0.006000852677971125, 0.0003529010573402047, 0.026229284703731537, -0.04265100881457329, 0.004397398792207241, 0.0070861754938960075, 0.038277216255664825, 0.002053796546533704, 0.01346910372376442, -0.007778664119541645, -0.027268005535006523, 0.0036406072322279215, 0.014869275502860546, -0.023745989426970482, -0.08529312163591385, -0.018176501616835594, -0.013349064625799656, -0.029321255162358284, -0.044227130711078644, -0.019883787259459496, -0.015047213062644005, 0.053326066583395004, -0.030689051374793053, 0.03129066526889801, 0.009576097130775452, -0.020358704030513763, -0.03346024826169014, -0.07999643683433533, 0.07226625829935074, 0.02533181756734848, -0.02144872583448887, -0.03201298043131828, 0.0011701261391863227, -0.036653030663728714, -0.013341098092496395, 0.02769514173269272, 0.03199455514550209, 0.03332146257162094, -0.006654839031398296, -0.0010166418505832553, -0.018890121951699257, -0.03519792854785919, 0.0037284218706190586, 0.005486318375915289, 0.005472464952617884, -0.025516580790281296, -0.015540105290710926, 0.019577261060476303, 0.010343358851969242, 0.0009249855647794902, -0.038382381200790405, 0.038136616349220276, 0.02761899121105671, 0.002729949541389942, 0.042385637760162354, 0.025359801948070526, -0.03435955196619034, 0.02021396905183792, 0.011134001426398754, 0.036893535405397415, 0.018986854702234268, -0.011605645529925823, -0.04938054829835892, 0.02083352766931057, -0.015206384472548962, -0.037755273282527924, -0.011490050703287125, 0.022645587101578712, -0.02531401999294758, -0.05098501965403557, -0.008382398635149002, 0.011734561994671822, -0.046014539897441864, 0.019520509988069534, 0.006151946261525154, 0.025392333045601845, 0.007658352609723806, 0.0015080409357324243, -0.01696752943098545, 0.056710269302129745, -0.02539297752082348, 0.02009420469403267, 0.01585099846124649, -0.010380635969340801, 0.0453377440571785, 0.005956846754997969, 0.022114461287856102, 0.0003777545935008675, 0.05557827651500702, -0.003741899970918894, 0.05897267907857895, -0.051514558494091034, -0.02567133679986, 0.00735986465588212, -0.002069308189675212, 0.04103908687829971, -0.011441025882959366, 0.0009452963713556528, 0.02614006958901882, 0.010695284232497215, 0.004547809716314077, -0.04109176993370056, -0.004575738683342934, -0.0191354900598526, -0.01534306164830923, -0.0043392782099545, 0.013270862400531769, -0.040412258356809616, -0.002360883867368102, -0.0009161736816167831, -0.003555391216650605, 0.04369192197918892, -0.02667045406997204, 0.033198487013578415, -0.04244048893451691, 0.012912371195852757, -0.019823990762233734, -0.03798257187008858, -0.03745563328266144, 0.015191987156867981, 0.007006998173892498, 0.037868399173021317, 0.03845806419849396, -0.02189779467880726, -0.0014607060002163053, -0.004533253610134125, 0.06002628430724144, -0.04743851721286774, -0.02646620199084282, -0.033451274037361145, 0.005704100243747234, -0.0046062287874519825, -0.01774822361767292 ]
<p>I'm taking a class on R and I cannot get the professors code to work. I am trying to do a simple linear model and I run this code:</p> <blockquote> <p>ozone&lt;-read.table("<a href="http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/r/faq/ozone.csv" rel="nofollow">http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/r/faq/ozone.csv</a>", sep=",", header=T)</p> <p>fit = lm(ozone~.,data=ozone)</p> <p>summary(fit)</p> </blockquote> <p>Which keeps giving me the following error:</p> <blockquote> <p>Error in model.frame.default(formula = ozone ~ ., data = ozone, drop.unused.levels = TRUE) : invalid type (list) for variable 'ozone</p> </blockquote> <p>It's really depressing as they are the first two lines of code in his lecture notes. I have also found several other forum posts on this topic (it's even listed as a common r mistake), but I am too...special to figure out how to change it.</p> <p>I tried reading it as.numeric, and as a data.frame, which is what most other threads suggested, but neither worked.</p>
74,184
[ -0.030230151489377022, -0.0038074166513979435, 0.00040281255496665835, 0.018394241109490395, 0.01633385196328163, -0.0061286198906600475, -0.003611094318330288, -0.004187447018921375, 0.04553348571062088, 0.018026627600193024, 0.05598989129066467, 0.055195923894643784, 0.08397752791643143, 0.01944298855960369, 0.036640796810388565, 0.00653427466750145, 0.005632027983665466, 0.013121281750500202, -0.03140298277139664, -0.000778555404394865, -0.018585901707410812, 0.007604964077472687, -0.02583909034729004, -0.02476060576736927, 0.025166243314743042, 0.053225718438625336, 0.029214704409241676, 0.020847922191023827, 0.011317790485918522, 0.025325370952486992, -0.037955496460199356, -0.04349031299352646, 0.038331177085638046, 0.011497228406369686, 0.033422086387872696, 0.032645273953676224, -0.025174785405397415, -0.01317271962761879, -0.013075258582830429, 0.0290999636054039, 0.013472473248839378, 0.008703986182808876, 0.04591388627886772, 0.05596373230218887, -0.020891359075903893, 0.027644621208310127, 0.0003831381618510932, -0.0025107786059379578, 0.053020115941762924, -0.03222595900297165, 0.07835176587104797, -0.011924726888537407, 0.019974661991000175, 0.057303447276353836, -0.015836821869015694, 0.0009069781517609954, 0.06194951757788658, 0.03075183555483818, -0.026038534939289093, -0.025609422475099564, 0.00046381482388824224, -0.024890385568141937, -0.0108073391020298, -0.014021582901477814, -0.052496813237667084, -0.03620479628443718, 0.0011863947147503495, -0.021476784721016884, 0.053672581911087036, -0.024615541100502014, 0.031855009496212006, -0.00006413782830350101, 0.004661749117076397, -0.02477538399398327, 0.0455985926091671, 0.005063903518021107, 0.018323589116334915, -0.014826983213424683, 0.007628235965967178, 0.029046213254332542, -0.01385534554719925, 0.02529311552643776, 0.008058879524469376, 0.009907170198857784, -0.003071566578000784, -0.024397503584623337, 0.05357368662953377, -0.0003887590137310326, -0.01126361358910799, 0.025643151253461838, -0.009803462773561478, -0.01399662159383297, 0.05025578290224075, 0.007540429476648569, -0.004940214101225138, 0.04854065179824829, 0.01767575368285179, 0.0610145665705204, 0.010996237397193909, 0.0004040647472720593, 0.013151715509593487, -0.024804724380373955, 0.018764372915029526, 0.013227651827037334, -0.03588453307747841, -0.029581809416413307, -0.03774635121226311, 0.01663464494049549, -0.008586779236793518, -0.054710980504751205, -0.006213465705513954, 0.04941564053297043, 0.005319538526237011, -0.02954227663576603, -0.00503642437979579, -0.012874696403741837, -0.01722482405602932, 0.019776655361056328, 0.05713275074958801, 0.04352967068552971, 0.07237356901168823, -0.039201077073812485, 0.05045083165168762, -0.02453521639108658, -0.04877857863903046, -0.0042116655968129635, 0.02163805440068245, 0.009933617897331715, -0.05919770523905754, 0.025879330933094025, -0.029565725475549698, -0.022968001663684845, 0.02115488611161709, 0.009471981786191463, 0.05055712163448334, -0.055513281375169754, -0.08542925119400024, -0.07069438695907593, -0.0002105358144035563, 0.0063446294516325, -0.02161196805536747, -0.035624828189611435, -0.023819001391530037, -0.008938707411289215, 0.054244764149188995, 0.03691882640123367, -0.0008590951329097152, 0.0008836795459501445, 0.016067206859588623, 0.01588313840329647, -0.007416528183966875, 0.017678551375865936, -0.03348252922296524, -0.05351975932717323, 0.012179750017821789, -0.08154337853193283, 0.02139652706682682, 0.017936544492840767, 0.020115403458476067, -0.01650100387632847, 0.04569920897483826, -0.020018508657813072, 0.004279531072825193, -0.007999364286661148, -0.02913128398358822, -0.033967699855566025, 0.05435781553387642, 0.0015866197645664215, 0.03131014481186867, 0.033299725502729416, -0.03193941339850426, 0.024748390540480614, -0.03533651679754257, 0.039599187672138214, 0.045621950179338455, -0.01291029155254364, -0.006772099994122982, -0.05365395173430443, 0.0037463572807610035, 0.057639431208372116, -0.056692566722631454, -0.028747132048010826, 0.04630642011761665, -0.010560913942754269, 0.013909154571592808, 0.04153980687260628, -0.005633647553622723, -0.00296511291526258, 0.016430677846074104, -0.05894438922405243, -0.05220532417297363, -0.05083084851503372, 0.01865924336016178, -0.033026374876499176, -0.006273992359638214, -0.0020283274352550507, -0.004598936531692743, 0.02779260091483593, -0.0023494185879826546, 0.0013799609150737524, -0.020776238292455673, -0.009123406372964382, 0.06784463673830032, -0.009568597190082073, -0.0097415242344141, 0.06260926276445389, 0.05696890875697136, -0.02632254920899868, 0.03511018678545952, -0.030897343531250954, -0.017390955239534378, 0.0011296962620690465, -0.02292788214981556, 0.012761072255671024, -0.010489767417311668, 0.0019290943164378405, -0.016111906617879868, 0.01886974833905697, -0.008221645839512348, 0.06460808962583542, -0.04527616500854492, 0.03840629756450653, 0.08228813111782074, 0.043562330305576324, 0.00882707629352808, -0.009999101050198078, 0.005741978995501995, 0.013387341052293777, 0.00791558250784874, -0.002868147101253271, -0.019430335611104965, 0.001851953798905015, 0.07044169306755066, -0.015430954284965992, -0.030219754204154015, -0.008519668132066727, 0.04031166806817055, 0.007938610389828682, 0.023038582876324654, 0.04049339145421982, -0.01962977834045887, -0.028218362480401993, -0.004457996226847172, -0.018254848197102547, 0.032932478934526443, -0.011250092647969723, 0.024302523583173752, 0.013046321459114552, 0.055917300283908844, -0.009920340962707996, -0.015741214156150818, 0.04013168811798096, 0.00020274713460821658, -0.023322083055973053, -0.019757788628339767, 0.015743261203169823, 0.05458585545420647, -0.037177443504333496, 0.020922096446156502, 0.06883629411458969, -0.010802644304931164, -0.02592994086444378, -0.026726843789219856, -0.007595463190227747, -0.02535613439977169, 0.052180398255586624, -0.020945895463228226, -0.007064931560307741, 0.01929323934018612, -0.03303448110818863, -0.005729013588279486, -0.011939658783376217, -0.038090843707323074, -0.02830425836145878, 0.023950867354869843, 0.009132110513746738, 0.025252636522054672, 0.031018823385238647, -0.0015906521584838629, -0.040109701454639435, -0.022231576964259148, -0.03902401030063629, 0.032744839787483215, 0.004410716705024242, -0.014253472909331322, -0.023714115843176842, 0.003178304759785533, -0.026095855981111526, 0.031779903918504715, 0.013542176224291325, -0.02898108772933483, 0.03762952610850334, -0.015993108972907066, -0.03931242600083351, -0.055132754147052765, -0.001436319900676608, 0.03119681030511856, 0.0029397099278867245, -0.045073702931404114, 0.011982847936451435, -0.015187337063252926, -0.045784760266542435, 0.014765026979148388, -0.06513785570859909, -0.04524872452020645, -0.037584807723760605, -0.02226785570383072, 0.006959589198231697, -0.011744947172701359, -0.015483113937079906, -0.000978310825303197, -0.00017606138135306537, -0.013275554403662682, -0.06314260512590408, -0.03655780106782913, -0.012235376983880997, 0.02679184265434742, 0.012057436630129814, 0.03134269639849663, -0.007252571173012257, 0.09884747117757797, 0.020471608266234398, -0.03133659064769745, -0.06624976545572281, 0.008490712381899357, -0.04288990795612335, -0.057632770389318466, 0.025145668536424637, 0.0009315393399447203, 0.012334764935076237, 0.014041148126125336, -0.03331456333398819, 0.022348644211888313, 0.036188755184412, -0.029234271496534348, 0.0044907196424901485, 0.009471835568547249, -0.02941119857132435, -0.03365669772028923, 0.06043744087219238, 0.0039007849991321564, -0.006451926194131374, 0.018282897770404816, -0.029610728845000267, 0.0248302910476923, -0.02473331056535244, -0.054135214537382126, 0.025541657581925392, 0.01547786220908165, 0.04436744004487991, -0.035789500921964645, 0.010307741351425648, -0.010080722160637379, -0.021802477538585663, 0.028647184371948242, 0.019141817465424538, 0.032335128635168076, -0.01068531908094883, -0.02068285644054413, 0.040450092405080795, 0.05364532768726349, -0.036940816789865494, 0.008851935155689716, 0.013307008892297745, -0.025636889040470123, 0.004547875840216875, 0.000556146027520299, -0.006324044428765774, 0.057411644607782364, 0.049480848014354706, 0.001466470304876566, 0.03437409549951553, -0.01895136386156082, 0.031338393688201904, -0.04016202688217163, 0.0009315398056060076, 0.004929542075842619, 0.027568403631448746, 0.03914164751768112, 0.060175973922014236, 0.021426206454634666, -0.00802378635853529, 0.050342053174972534, -0.02680519036948681, -0.041440967470407486, 0.05548138543963432, 0.009790441021323204, -0.034605249762535095, -0.014347908087074757, -0.0033505132887512445, 0.01840570569038391, 0.020426003262400627, -0.00448477640748024, -0.01654631830751896, -0.010868427343666553, -0.035087816417217255, 0.003882344113662839, -0.010607191361486912, -0.02584630809724331, -0.020803213119506836, 0.038823213428258896, 0.011909113265573978, 0.0016227576415985823, -0.0076413871720433235, 0.06665484607219696, -0.04334710165858269, 0.00433132890611887, -0.04512810707092285, -0.0012801027623936534, 0.02813667617738247, 0.03688336908817291, 0.02086588554084301, 0.029751809313893318, -0.01814764365553856, 0.07892485707998276, -0.0056159161031246185, 0.020771892741322517, 0.05580641329288483, 0.006271012593060732, -0.0314420610666275, -0.03690238669514656, 0.01211710087954998, 0.018908889964222908, 0.007423027418553829, 0.021779745817184448, 0.00840359553694725, 0.0663321316242218, 0.03755026310682297, -0.02859494648873806, 0.02694505639374256, 0.05905676260590553, -0.00791893806308508, 0.010361555963754654, -0.031331200152635574, 0.0015751061728224158, -0.015397865325212479, 0.005139780696481466, 0.031165624037384987, 0.031246431171894073, 0.04111003503203392, -0.006532894913107157, 0.014163811691105366, -0.00708695687353611, -0.021038983017206192, 0.015312607400119305, 0.0034333907533437014, -0.002477232599630952, -0.06132940948009491, -0.04660957306623459, 0.01068165898323059, 0.04128415882587433, 0.037146177142858505, -0.006502611096948385, 0.00041384424548596144, -0.09102636575698853, -0.01270032487809658, 0.04550992324948311, 0.03843970224261284, -0.03249751403927803, -0.018149998039007187, -0.04029400274157524, -0.030524108558893204, 0.06454484909772873, -0.02073219232261181, 0.04183853417634964, -0.04044926166534424, 0.026241321116685867, 0.0007150588207878172, -0.030336473137140274, -0.03190752491354942, -0.018262723460793495, -0.03380114585161209, 0.03320581465959549, 0.0070498306304216385, -0.02727283537387848, -0.04488087445497513, 0.015897177159786224, -0.014085948467254639, 0.032100189477205276, -0.019889643415808678, -0.025093602016568184, 0.01733197644352913, -0.007222414948046207, -0.0313139408826828, -0.05180423706769943, -0.008331656455993652, 0.020066775381565094, 0.023413991555571556, 0.005992342717945576, 0.010136918164789677, -0.035968538373708725, 0.023723160848021507, 0.04441902041435242, -0.0001997763174585998, -0.02393198199570179, -0.05265485495328903, -0.0019637010991573334, 0.0025520327035337687, 0.008113878779113293, 0.08770646899938583, 0.035953644663095474, -0.02128574438393116, 0.006295996718108654, -0.05318580940365791, 0.028252799063920975, -0.004115852527320385, -0.03360844403505325, -0.05381479486823082, -0.0011575043899938464, -0.0024597118608653545, -0.00240133423358202, 0.04426351189613342, 0.016834508627653122, -0.03595820441842079, -0.01568259298801422, 0.04842032119631767, -0.0005328815896064043, -0.025695154443383217, -0.023620788007974625, -0.013104740530252457, 0.013384146615862846, -0.0008896688814274967, -0.035180073231458664, 0.000056673070503165945, -0.03440671041607857, -0.002763445023447275, 0.014940842054784298, -0.01531271357089281, 0.0026003620587289333, -0.03318782150745392, -0.04292930290102959, 0.0037483491469174623, -0.020659711211919785, 0.0073477961122989655, -0.02388269640505314, 0.035492319613695145, -0.008241767063736916, -0.04332994297146797, -0.03130337595939636, 0.013252395205199718, 0.006740786600857973, -0.024015434086322784, -0.029484577476978302, 0.05600489303469658, -0.03641101345419884, -0.0217166505753994, -0.040717482566833496, -0.0676247850060463, 0.028809795156121254, 0.016429275274276733, -0.030953509733080864, -0.04924652352929115, -0.010876983404159546, -0.02314010076224804, 0.003296192968264222, -0.014024297706782818, 0.04779292643070221, -0.038873281329870224, 0.002360048471018672, -0.006144362036138773, 0.0026984955184161663, 0.061480194330215454, 0.013793465681374073, -0.005122056696563959, 0.016125546768307686, -0.0024179734755307436, -0.040497008711099625, -0.011781584471464157, -0.0006694459589198232, -0.044846292585134506, -0.009100640192627907, -0.028413372114300728, -0.010897520929574966, 0.07066697627305984, -0.022485459223389626, -0.009479294531047344, 0.04077063873410225, -0.030021505430340767, 0.011667006649076939, -0.0532895103096962, 0.04335739091038704, -0.03421202301979065, 0.013110136613249779, -0.03848482668399811, 0.011206081137061119, -0.013014757074415684, -0.01463277731090784, 0.00458740396425128, -0.01736472360789776, 0.011300232261419296, 0.05119333043694496, 0.060688845813274384, -0.014579158276319504, 0.004391637165099382, -0.007045809179544449, -0.02719125710427761, 0.026135478168725967, 0.05417453870177269, -0.0201456006616354, 0.003494915086776018, 0.06290049850940704, -0.03102213703095913, -0.01956077106297016, -0.02449893206357956, 0.01558398175984621, 0.04457896947860718, 0.02053998038172722, 0.00656704930588603, 0.05224209651350975, 0.0024902611039578915, -0.014303331263363361, -0.04727787524461746, -0.019808797165751457, -0.0043753343634307384, 0.030556695535779, 0.07584937661886215, 0.019794128835201263, 0.005175075028091669, 0.045418158173561096, 0.013657775707542896, 0.040481094270944595, 0.01851757988333702, 0.016792092472314835, -0.009242397733032703, -0.0025847351644188166, 0.034998610615730286, -0.023554468527436256, 0.05726054310798645, -0.006696766708046198, 0.04400140047073364, -0.0038226675242185593, -0.008767979219555855, 0.015742162242531776, 0.026743009686470032, 0.03464597091078758, -0.035274770110845566, -0.020123636350035667, -0.039918314665555954, 0.02927028387784958, 0.028247512876987457, -0.029954850673675537, 0.03049028478562832, 0.0026537799276411533, 0.05277571082115173, -0.01613333821296692, 0.020722899585962296, -0.028142016381025314, -0.06454402208328247, -0.024108843877911568, -0.03280358016490936, -0.05231473967432976, 0.04154977574944496, 0.01355239748954773, -0.008027414791285992, 0.008791559375822544, -0.028776468709111214, 0.014099408872425556, 0.014499370940029621, 0.04165424033999443, 0.025509431958198547, 0.04829255864024162, -0.007824450731277466, -0.004970913287252188, -0.012614883482456207, -0.029671940952539444, 0.10642896592617035, 0.05484981834888458, 0.034149959683418274, -0.060308054089546204, 0.013723869808018208, 0.01900992915034294, 0.00744978990405798, 0.016966156661510468, 0.017733613029122353, -0.02266344428062439, 0.016365930438041687, 0.023797040805220604, 0.0580935925245285, 0.034990619868040085, 0.030287092551589012, -0.00973908044397831, -0.04085669293999672, -0.03834836557507515, 0.002451998880133033, -0.01217759121209383, -0.025895152240991592, -0.025306882336735725, -0.055357519537210464, 0.018675832077860832, 0.0009514762205071747, -0.025266209617257118, 0.003976723179221153, 0.0025073180440813303, 0.023599494248628616, -0.01139143481850624, -0.033516623079776764, 0.02071286365389824, 0.005966592114418745, 0.013802414759993553, 0.0015758844092488289, 0.02280285209417343, 0.03827532008290291, -0.01150400098413229, 0.027150627225637436, 0.046937327831983566, 0.02557755820453167, 0.015043403953313828, -0.04319052770733833, 0.019721930846571922, -0.019252503290772438, -0.01701829954981804, -0.013295241631567478, 0.04469184949994087, 0.004256997257471085, -0.00700402120128274, -0.001053876243531704, 0.03503226488828659, -0.01651686429977417, -0.055623650550842285, -0.024825433269143105, 0.02380000427365303, 0.019701601937413216, -0.009954218752682209, -0.01565026119351387, -0.01848965510725975, -0.013388773426413536, -0.03198862075805664, 0.02033356949687004, 0.06202806904911995, -0.03459024429321289, 0.01295834593474865, -0.04277857765555382, 0.026907073333859444, -0.02502223290503025, 0.03695003688335419, -0.0029658263083547354, -0.022600866854190826, -0.02379954420030117, -0.014381231740117073, 0.015783200040459633, 0.017648624256253242, 0.032988715916872025, -0.026462716981768608, 0.01172939594835043, -0.028269952163100243, -0.07430661469697952, 0.022156372666358948, -0.0013058912009000778, -0.06676405668258667, 0.013536750338971615, 0.0036804010160267353, 0.002842928748577833, 0.01748458482325077, -0.0071625495329499245, -0.02652726136147976, 0.01556045189499855, 0.011669390834867954, -0.008684753440320492, -0.051169417798519135, -0.023022709414362907, 0.03109820932149887, 0.0014438824728131294, -0.008354267105460167, -0.0035040632355958223, 0.051765963435173035, 0.0039412654004991055, 0.030668344348669052, -0.026450838893651962, -0.0016444077482447028, -0.014251159504055977, -0.006743513513356447, 0.027702704071998596, -0.041027966886758804, 0.03833331912755966, 0.008486525155603886, 0.009910203516483307, -0.06920909136533737, -0.02756359800696373, -0.05643046647310257, -0.06621945649385452, 0.014713365584611893, -0.011305846273899078, -0.0488697849214077, 0.031122535467147827, -0.010697506368160248, -0.02672111801803112, -0.00022233289200812578, -0.02403760887682438, -0.03434696048498154, -0.017795270308852196, -0.0006783317658118904, -0.011627460829913616, -0.03262181207537651, 0.01979580894112587, -0.035757992416620255, 0.02376217395067215, 0.02066660299897194, 0.03612900525331497, 0.012874584645032883, -0.0010902028298005462, 0.0032600078266113997, 0.02779102325439453, 0.06912695616483688, -0.012344974093139172, -0.01840749941766262, 0.03204702213406563, -0.00023789910483174026, -0.0310367401689291, -0.004120661877095699, -0.047874417155981064, 0.02703748643398285, 0.02051650919020176, -0.021010417491197586, -0.01935686357319355, 0.08440598100423813, -0.042908936738967896, 0.011485867202281952, -0.023643143475055695, 0.010010113008320332, -0.005004514008760452, 0.010148759931325912, 0.030025694519281387, 0.01383474562317133, -0.041943833231925964, 0.02120089717209339, 0.06155190244317055, -0.01566356047987938, 0.027942193672060966, -0.034087616950273514, -0.030944811180233955, 0.0019781924784183502, -0.01077472697943449, 0.0014122548745945096, 0.024295488372445107, 0.045216720551252365, -0.03721555322408676, 0.044287387281656265, -0.04006638750433922, 0.017560847103595734, -0.11436200141906738, -0.01870630867779255, 0.01671546697616577, 0.01323494128882885, 0.04111985117197037, -0.06576452404260635, -0.010480551980435848, 0.012343807145953178, -0.0565146878361702, -0.051173560321331024, 0.00539651233702898, -0.003902705619111657, -0.012000028975307941, 0.011790581047534943, -0.009488009847700596, 0.0049887471832334995, 0.03914584964513779, 0.03794239088892937, 0.04181920364499092, 0.01383964903652668, 0.008473707363009453, -0.02369105815887451, -0.020835842937231064, 0.01190851628780365, 0.007425431162118912, -0.030633632093667984, 0.011987035162746906, -0.00641645397990942, 0.010500196367502213, 0.0023087160661816597, -0.010673888027668, 0.04340626299381256, 0.029774490743875504, 0.04128126800060272, 0.028125837445259094, 0.051016900688409805, 0.0060299416072666645, 0.019652437418699265, -0.03688108175992966, 0.0033836946822702885, 0.03014974482357502, 0.015190345235168934, -0.010920772328972816, 0.015519409440457821, -0.00021135849237907678, -0.007685087155550718, -0.05987073481082916, 0.006058649159967899, -0.02376287616789341, 0.0058533926494419575, -0.032886166125535965, -0.015418795868754387, 0.01027179416269064, -0.06291501224040985, 0.015446310862898827, -0.007883863523602486, -0.011894709430634975, 0.04475812241435051, -0.009894543327391148, -0.005963177420198917, 0.008444715291261673, -0.043546922504901886, -0.024951651692390442, -0.0016224855789914727, 0.01061326451599598, -0.014194048009812832, -0.05191056430339813, 0.020246582105755806, -0.0010873711435124278, -0.058181293308734894, 0.007467254064977169, 0.006917521823197603, -0.05641671270132065, 0.012468966655433178, -0.015326063148677349, 0.020180489867925644, 0.017875313758850098, -0.00760754756629467, 0.02978135272860527, -0.11634010076522827, 0.051306918263435364, 0.012050813995301723, 0.040343210101127625, -0.050974491983652115, 0.003917731810361147, -0.0009023912134580314, 0.0199813824146986, 0.051993176341056824, -0.0012380435364320874, 0.0013407227816060185, -0.026235906407237053, 0.020559163764119148, -0.005483535584062338, -0.0020692371763288975, 0.0282814372330904, 0.029989635571837425, -0.0551239475607872, 0.008292464539408684, -0.007105085067451, 0.010738973505795002, 0.0036780936643481255, 0.036018479615449905, 0.0030725570395588875, 0.017159219831228256, -0.02504373900592327, -0.048975225538015366, 0.01733895018696785, -0.03427638113498688, -0.017050020396709442, 0.006713191047310829, 0.004681346006691456, 0.025209009647369385, 0.07032950222492218, 0.015113869681954384, -0.05458686128258705, 0.045777469873428345, -0.08315317332744598, 0.0022070761770009995, -0.000828267598990351, -0.032819412648677826, 0.0043029324151575565, -0.04119967296719551, 0.0359029583632946, 0.022677864879369736, 0.001861280994489789, 0.002618297003209591, 0.0028113427106291056, -0.008065177127718925, 0.038001228123903275, 0.026998834684491158, -0.01634693332016468, -0.0008853015024214983, -0.03058215044438839, 0.0023136313538998365, 0.011869029141962528, 0.017446784302592278, -0.010901043191552162, -0.0040109651163220406, 0.053622983396053314, -0.001445947797037661, 0.005545219872146845, 0.008740812540054321, 0.06551539152860641, 0.016674557700753212, -0.019450344145298004, -0.01635267399251461, -0.005248390603810549, 0.004126036539673805, 0.024837210774421692, -0.012675019912421703, 0.049599774181842804, -0.03033488802611828, 0.03332875296473503, -0.031851012259721756, -0.031071558594703674, -0.07010503113269806, 0.0371255949139595, 0.016375327482819557, -0.004337774123996496, -0.016820168122649193, 0.010062789544463158, -0.004246718715876341, -0.003489308524876833, 0.05185778811573982, -0.010060303844511509, -0.00228365371003747, -0.003949269652366638, -0.02974902093410492, 0.01306084543466568, 0.014631413854658604, -0.0011747503885999322, -0.014432866126298904, 0.017105067148804665, 0.02381332591176033, 0.006191269960254431, -0.044214483350515366, -0.0029779046308249235, -0.019782401621341705, 0.06827662140130997, -0.06905112415552139, -0.011094790883362293, -0.03436633199453354, 0.012482897378504276, -0.01012126449495554, -0.0326850488781929 ]
<p>I am seeking a statistic measuring an estimate's reliability or stability as an alternative to the coefficient of variation (CV), also known as the relative standard error. The CV is the standard error of an estimate (proportion, mean, regression coefficient, etc.) divided by the estimate itself, usually expressed as a percentage. For example, if a survey finds 15% unemployment with a 6% standard error, the CV is .06/.15 = .4 = 40%. </p> <p>Some US government agencies flag or suppress as unreliable any estimate with a CV over a certain threshold such as 30% or 50%. But this standard can be arbitrary (for example, 85% employment would have a much lower CV of .06/.85 = 7%) and has other limitations (such as when the estimate is zero).</p> <p>Can anyone suggest an alternative measure of stability or reliability?</p>
74,185
[ -0.037832774221897125, 0.004866792354732752, 0.023565692827105522, -0.0213798675686121, 0.011473027989268303, -0.007290704175829887, 0.024060694500803947, -0.015559595078229904, 0.04103226214647293, -0.037395887076854706, 0.016857188194990158, 0.04016955569386482, 0.06508038938045502, 0.012103605084121227, -0.003802116261795163, 0.013015511445701122, 0.003947605844587088, 0.01019289344549179, -0.03399871289730072, -0.02911258488893509, -0.011996753513813019, 0.01755361258983612, 0.01485446747392416, -0.004055903758853674, -0.01997176557779312, 0.04188184812664986, 0.02209620736539364, -0.006840401329100132, 0.006349213887006044, 0.07991542667150497, -0.07155271619558334, -0.03673099726438522, -0.00843280553817749, 0.04302358254790306, -0.0015997139271348715, 0.014780724421143532, -0.014360837638378143, -0.018468910828232765, -0.04651721566915512, 0.06879997998476028, -0.05328334867954254, 0.010046099312603474, -0.02748848684132099, 0.03413895517587662, -0.018413180485367775, -0.012577291578054428, -0.02373017929494381, -0.030984913930296898, 0.051204923540353775, -0.011641516350209713, 0.10278622061014175, -0.0005191995878703892, 0.03342247009277344, 0.03616611659526825, -0.006847310345619917, -0.018681466579437256, 0.05118168145418167, 0.07030633836984634, -0.029263997450470924, -0.04536088928580284, -0.061544813215732574, -0.03239545226097107, 0.006915197242051363, -0.018534773960709572, -0.038551464676856995, 0.03154365345835686, -0.02348807454109192, -0.020180799067020416, 0.0523756742477417, -0.006835279520601034, 0.00268213520757854, 0.02091590128839016, 0.030749404802918434, 0.0060651870444417, 0.0003928964724764228, -0.06958870589733124, -0.03082461468875408, 0.019672563299536705, 0.008854588493704796, 0.03294855356216431, -0.0026767512317746878, -0.021572940051555634, -0.00033851555781438947, 0.05337171629071236, 0.01995452679693699, -0.037434544414281845, 0.08337050676345825, -0.0337594598531723, 0.05469735339283943, 0.04179808497428894, -0.017553694546222687, -0.02758580818772316, 0.049575261771678925, -0.0023929341696202755, -0.07132359594106674, 0.01892068050801754, -0.02473018877208233, 0.06368587911128998, 0.022787773981690407, -0.0009414158412255347, 0.02380690723657608, -0.015396030619740486, 0.0004690779896918684, 0.07191649079322815, -0.0409792922437191, -0.03012179024517536, -0.02795104682445526, -0.021469157189130783, 0.0004962950479239225, -0.001976017840206623, -0.0027609795797616243, -0.0038393947761505842, 0.006351644638925791, 0.02118978276848793, 0.008955741301178932, 0.000048500511184101924, 0.0030973784159868956, -0.022467169910669327, 0.06059704348444939, 0.018510987982153893, 0.047886770218610764, -0.03581497445702553, 0.017203429713845253, -0.03984551876783371, -0.03833943232893944, 0.01774756982922554, 0.04680291563272476, -0.02752223238348961, -0.022570207715034485, 0.056147944182157516, -0.009913304820656776, -0.02266746573150158, 0.04423872008919716, -0.02438156120479107, 0.023640763014554977, 0.011563491076231003, -0.06231032684445381, -0.062294863164424896, 0.011799169704318047, 0.014071473851799965, -0.005110470112413168, -0.06844083219766617, 0.020629076287150383, 0.03698262572288513, 0.013643038459122181, 0.02020418643951416, 0.05472299084067345, 0.00771997170522809, 0.02931221015751362, -0.006903361063450575, -0.043689534068107605, -0.049403004348278046, 0.04089808091521263, -0.04806678369641304, -0.03580542281270027, -0.07384399324655533, -0.016439292579889297, 0.013859517872333527, -0.001253696158528328, -0.024180730804800987, 0.0014573456719517708, 0.027705073356628418, -0.022552816197276115, -0.00654947105795145, 0.0546388104557991, -0.04223412275314331, 0.06054867058992386, -0.022091541439294815, 0.020523175597190857, -0.02110806107521057, 0.014652888290584087, -0.0019592521712183952, 0.04207540675997734, 0.013830253854393959, 0.04961015656590462, -0.029058093205094337, 0.009129781275987625, -0.012294276617467403, 0.0020859912037849426, -0.01678343117237091, -0.0562751330435276, -0.00983232818543911, 0.018105870112776756, -0.021961679682135582, 0.022265326231718063, 0.020179972052574158, -0.03352772071957588, -0.008701842278242111, 0.043425533920526505, -0.021269405260682106, -0.008594945073127747, -0.030053121969103813, 0.024419685825705528, 0.006462691817432642, -0.023990992456674576, 0.02128724940121174, 0.02222977578639984, 0.020901016891002655, -0.043343596160411835, -0.004590312018990517, -0.015140888281166553, -0.008144516497850418, 0.00008404540130868554, -0.05491131916642189, 0.010640242137014866, 0.022029319778084755, 0.04514896497130394, -0.0107415821403265, 0.062318354845047, -0.030066749081015587, -0.06560398638248444, -0.03405965864658356, -0.009479003958404064, 0.04427574574947357, -0.02177070453763008, -0.009592512622475624, 0.023593049496412277, -0.010677575133740902, -0.009202206507325172, 0.035207349807024, -0.041417088359594345, 0.06429769843816757, 0.028845198452472687, 0.028692670166492462, 0.005584040656685829, 0.026428693905472755, -0.001751117641106248, 0.006832260172814131, -0.03253057599067688, -0.016959022730588913, -0.035573139786720276, 0.004821760579943657, 0.0277736596763134, 0.009877942502498627, -0.054360147565603256, 0.014376804232597351, 0.08903554081916809, 0.04991825670003891, 0.030504923313856125, 0.01968003809452057, -0.014047547243535519, -0.03051922656595707, 0.013518585823476315, -0.01646289974451065, 0.007526305504143238, 0.04016891121864319, 0.013080891221761703, 0.03272032365202904, 0.010232223197817802, 0.031651925295591354, 0.019924571737647057, 0.04744773730635643, -0.0009841668652370572, -0.028914080932736397, -0.017537258565425873, -0.008282597176730633, 0.04032137244939804, -0.04233022779226303, 0.03880270943045616, 0.04437161237001419, -0.023019203916192055, 0.017609450966119766, 0.030691664665937424, -0.014714286662638187, 0.0606854222714901, 0.006998016498982906, -0.031819891184568405, 0.01496901735663414, 0.023623118177056313, -0.002465810626745224, -0.001505186315625906, -0.05799536406993866, -0.037692490965127945, -0.0020918380469083786, 0.00039598075090907514, 0.06855253875255585, 0.02774778939783573, 0.026589488610625267, 0.020548224449157715, -0.008127210661768913, 0.0002180403535021469, -0.019281204789876938, 0.019942577928304672, 0.00014604437456000596, -0.0390138253569603, -0.00121590169146657, 0.04546722397208214, -0.022019244730472565, 0.029797330498695374, -0.011092333123087883, -0.003316920017823577, 0.038013942539691925, 0.03175949677824974, -0.04147836193442345, 0.03258303552865982, -0.027124840766191483, 0.0034132262226194143, -0.03043237514793873, -0.040477070957422256, 0.02130129560828209, -0.02761497162282467, -0.027135709300637245, 0.06650674343109131, -0.03202810883522034, -0.039209116250276566, -0.03138263151049614, 0.02507946640253067, 0.013421342708170414, -0.012163637205958366, 0.04994914308190346, 0.021462809294462204, 0.00008296607848023996, -0.03057924285531044, -0.06034555286169052, -0.11161316931247711, 0.02109457552433014, -0.0292162224650383, 0.01775084249675274, 0.012670752592384815, -0.03578030318021774, 0.08126724511384964, 0.0022706177551299334, -0.021458767354488373, -0.010809686966240406, 0.02276414819061756, -0.024987386539578438, 0.005453457590192556, 0.008971627801656723, -0.00834877323359251, 0.02201789803802967, 0.007289735134691, -0.013246718794107437, 0.004175807349383831, 0.03108927421271801, -0.0016835039714351296, 0.008857238106429577, 0.026419783011078835, -0.02041199617087841, -0.0126516567543149, 0.022381357848644257, 0.016436947509646416, -0.04688291624188423, -0.01568542793393135, 0.0203715693205595, 0.018000606447458267, 0.021164659410715103, -0.028378669172525406, 0.0019374174298718572, -0.016825178638100624, -0.013128424994647503, -0.018960554152727127, 0.008138134144246578, -0.028964022174477577, 0.0028421038296073675, -0.030771268531680107, 0.009662560187280178, 0.015838680788874626, -0.014264198020100594, -0.006050065625458956, 0.05101410299539566, 0.04926862195134163, 0.020722245797514915, -0.0024118975270539522, -0.02724101021885872, 0.008677440695464611, -0.007590265478938818, -0.012579460628330708, -0.047380365431308746, 0.046950336545705795, 0.0365079864859581, 0.04666721820831299, -0.03746812418103218, -0.055858537554740906, 0.014022110030055046, -0.06448053568601608, 0.026899967342615128, -0.013728848658502102, 0.03099558874964714, -0.004058565944433212, 0.012793613597750664, 0.026384267956018448, 0.005546499043703079, 0.0023231245577335358, 0.013074149377644062, -0.06888602674007416, 0.028969373553991318, -0.023490585386753082, -0.029134050011634827, 0.011609293520450592, 0.0015394019428640604, 0.018017226830124855, 0.019917823374271393, -0.008160484954714775, -0.014433341100811958, 0.016176432371139526, -0.01096266321837902, 0.010453205555677414, 0.0013906883541494608, -0.009064658544957638, 0.011376479640603065, -0.02202143706381321, -0.002233644714578986, -0.031242821365594864, 0.03352827951312065, 0.026335671544075012, 0.008847667835652828, -0.015426825731992722, -0.03919396921992302, -0.000593910226598382, 0.018946081399917603, 0.03522539138793945, 0.015504783019423485, 0.01424755435436964, -0.03067617490887642, 0.042437974363565445, 0.010993755422532558, 0.04754677042365074, 0.033098578453063965, 0.014023878611624241, -0.04765933007001877, -0.026036009192466736, -0.032121460884809494, 0.008322810754179955, 0.005540213081985712, -0.00742576876655221, 0.013302357867360115, 0.056280091404914856, -0.006807331461459398, -0.08057907968759537, 0.034058909863233566, 0.05029398575425148, 0.018434086814522743, 0.009188506752252579, -0.00253686448559165, -0.008915523067116737, 0.002092501614242792, -0.02367139607667923, 0.010316981002688408, 0.008707224391400814, -0.002612615469843149, -0.011824867688119411, 0.03368913382291794, -0.02263663522899151, -0.053077343851327896, -0.02231716923415661, -0.0036991729866713285, 0.010372895747423172, -0.0006847039912827313, -0.01995554193854332, 0.004501435440033674, 0.021928709000349045, 0.04920903220772743, 0.05058808997273445, 0.012279102578759193, -0.08213616907596588, 0.017064908519387245, 0.03321744129061699, 0.02966441959142685, -0.07087413221597672, -0.06050817295908928, -0.031935807317495346, -0.030035091564059258, 0.04094896838068962, -0.053803522139787674, 0.002640360966324806, -0.0056997123174369335, -0.0026114981155842543, -0.0007898194016888738, -0.0030355751514434814, -0.029674392193555832, -0.017515499144792557, 0.013566006906330585, 0.024150816723704338, -0.006699167657643557, 0.0021532399114221334, -0.017756788060069084, 0.008556910790503025, 0.03410501033067703, 0.0761389508843422, 0.03843282535672188, -0.0624985508620739, 0.017168743535876274, 0.03119329735636711, -0.018603801727294922, -0.04346266761422157, -0.01291313860565424, 0.004646101035177708, -0.005428951699286699, 0.023394959047436714, 0.013767649419605732, -0.014119768515229225, 0.009915524162352085, -0.007061564829200506, -0.0018235035240650177, -0.004376335069537163, 0.02725440450012684, 0.045117344707250595, 0.03156192600727081, 0.05256865918636322, 0.07251191139221191, 0.0417504645884037, 0.013590451329946518, 0.008117713034152985, -0.003447874216362834, 0.01309877634048462, -0.0459069199860096, -0.04914480075240135, 0.007399065885692835, -0.011219678446650505, -0.058572981506586075, 0.05611053854227066, -0.008312197402119637, 0.03350355476140976, -0.02289074845612049, 0.012972946278750896, -0.008131155744194984, -0.0028111678548157215, 0.0096986573189497, -0.021985774859786034, 0.01237110048532486, 0.023391542956233025, 0.008637168444693089, -0.0217027198523283, 0.03488099202513695, -0.002469890983775258, -0.038888681679964066, 0.013751735910773277, -0.03976226970553398, 0.014201495796442032, -0.056554097682237625, -0.020898934453725815, 0.024401457980275154, -0.02661641500890255, 0.02842000126838684, -0.008817455731332302, 0.04721301048994064, -0.014894514344632626, -0.0588313564658165, -0.03171166032552719, 0.024572432041168213, 0.005783646367490292, 0.07578244060277939, -0.03734196349978447, 0.037069596350193024, 0.0011409370927140117, 0.012346731498837471, -0.08952871710062027, -0.031979646533727646, 0.024659760296344757, 0.014815627597272396, -0.03616355359554291, -0.033687423914670944, 0.015358374454081059, 0.014679878018796444, -0.02839099057018757, -0.015246442519128323, 0.050446171313524246, -0.004869784694164991, -0.004941093269735575, -0.015767056494951248, 0.005080633796751499, 0.06605472415685654, -0.004517822992056608, -0.020656926557421684, 0.011572633869946003, -0.02443421445786953, 0.005592177622020245, 0.023760704323649406, 0.024148229509592056, -0.033371008932590485, -0.022538110613822937, -0.00966697372496128, -0.0086803138256073, 0.015123149380087852, -0.009599377401173115, -0.032391175627708435, 0.011529379524290562, 0.0012664921814575791, 0.013705609366297722, 0.013259775936603546, 0.0216666329652071, -0.024209704250097275, -0.008826691657304764, -0.02520156465470791, 0.002652048133313656, -0.014142610132694244, -0.020349640399217606, 0.022040022537112236, 0.005520710255950689, -0.03201353922486305, 0.0024981587193906307, 0.08151134848594666, 0.00122365343850106, 0.011212502606213093, 0.014214897528290749, -0.015855055302381516, 0.030108267441391945, 0.03768949583172798, -0.0003951950347982347, 0.003305230289697647, 0.026642223820090294, -0.0415862612426281, -0.06374737620353699, -0.006986815948039293, 0.0169366504997015, 0.018977347761392593, -0.012474780902266502, 0.058300115168094635, 0.056376952677965164, 0.006707336753606796, 0.004313141107559204, 0.008847194723784924, -0.013681930489838123, 0.025011098012328148, 0.01062215305864811, 0.027463335543870926, -0.007431114092469215, 0.010206888429820538, -0.0029835489112883806, 0.03347089886665344, 0.012529715895652771, 0.04594453051686287, -0.021303720772266388, 0.05121815577149391, 0.03358292952179909, -0.01237220037728548, -0.07851842045783997, 0.057317402213811874, -0.021596016362309456, 0.01949498988687992, -0.015561518259346485, -0.027324270457029343, 0.003766045905649662, -0.010997184552252293, 0.01546270027756691, -0.004801994189620018, -0.047945812344551086, -0.031027918681502342, 0.026092519983649254, -0.001402657013386488, -0.041274651885032654, -0.005738924257457256, -0.030694441869854927, -0.000566860951948911, 0.0005894175264984369, 0.04526582732796669, -0.042239993810653687, -0.09784471243619919, -0.014636917039752007, -0.011200742796063423, -0.027262186631560326, 0.0458502359688282, 0.019648293033242226, -0.006937336176633835, 0.024416502565145493, -0.03483124077320099, -0.017528755590319633, 0.025483326986432076, 0.010355915874242783, -0.00019114359747618437, 0.04840901121497154, -0.010687078349292278, 0.014108321629464626, -0.03597129136323929, -0.012328612618148327, 0.1043018028140068, 0.08039575815200806, 0.03701997175812721, -0.017703518271446228, 0.014730352908372879, -0.02417040430009365, 0.0019662240520119667, -0.00932876206934452, 0.022922463715076447, 0.020830200985074043, -0.016780966892838478, 0.0640445351600647, 0.05464822053909302, 0.004584621172398329, 0.021302804350852966, 0.05606062337756157, -0.014778556302189827, -0.007099704816937447, 0.01590927504003048, 0.012365692295134068, 0.0006462319288402796, -0.02225665934383869, -0.010504685342311859, 0.01800321787595749, 0.005944015923887491, -0.05281570181250572, -0.02173793502151966, 0.005051447078585625, -0.00450739823281765, 0.00911284051835537, -0.018338404595851898, 0.005980027839541435, -0.0030385323334485292, 0.02683037333190441, -0.03883121907711029, -0.003616397036239505, -0.012244060635566711, -0.01240550633519888, -0.0011279695900157094, 0.0597953237593174, 0.008227294310927391, -0.0011056221555918455, 0.01368824765086174, 0.0070116338320076466, -0.048634227365255356, -0.0007499350467696786, -0.06183065101504326, 0.007865548133850098, -0.02419091947376728, 0.02716277725994587, -0.04009971395134926, -0.0018239313503727317, -0.006406052969396114, -0.02290039137005806, -0.016337890177965164, -0.003183143213391304, -0.0004834198916796595, -0.042643334716558456, -0.042870134115219116, -0.03581491857767105, 0.006264407653361559, -0.010030083358287811, 0.03614187240600586, 0.04980528727173805, -0.0518152192234993, -0.05173509940505028, -0.010136695578694344, 0.06293471902608871, -0.014508266933262348, -0.026982661336660385, 0.043805304914712906, -0.02959374152123928, -0.045119378715753555, 0.006092716474086046, -0.00979671161621809, -0.008885582908987999, 0.02037673071026802, 0.005338282324373722, -0.003482941072434187, 0.014712932519614697, -0.05483795702457428, 0.02438211441040039, -0.04007817804813385, 0.009489655494689941, -0.08290083706378937, -0.001212695031426847, 0.04303987696766853, -0.007089085876941681, 0.005366481840610504, 0.025499973446130753, -0.0029036265332251787, 0.010487668216228485, 0.019060740247368813, -0.0730002298951149, 0.01604059711098671, 0.011358929798007011, -0.019009103998541832, 0.004300412256270647, -0.009594558738172054, 0.052582997828722, 0.007682659663259983, 0.01408408023416996, -0.02936585620045662, 0.04848195239901543, -0.025229129940271378, 0.029527926817536354, 0.012949647381901741, -0.04700810834765434, -0.05449778214097023, 0.0016604370903223753, 0.011870242655277252, -0.00664700660854578, 0.00340891070663929, -0.06603886932134628, -0.00894180592149496, -0.003574216039851308, -0.008448092266917229, -0.03270783647894859, 0.02018587663769722, 0.005703244358301163, -0.0014989004703238606, -0.02111891098320484, 0.012046735733747482, -0.019263463094830513, -0.018021665513515472, 0.002637406811118126, -0.002091754227876663, -0.019013220444321632, -0.01191194262355566, 0.021164607256650925, -0.019488465040922165, 0.020675064995884895, -0.004943173378705978, 0.019879058003425598, 0.010146064683794975, 0.004785965662449598, 0.0566631555557251, 0.060012396425008774, -0.05127258971333504, -0.004588587675243616, 0.06378916651010513, -0.05841156467795372, -0.06819970905780792, 0.026278458535671234, -0.020739374682307243, 0.02885603904724121, 0.022775158286094666, 0.002579842461273074, 0.03221617639064789, 0.031302038580179214, -0.001610507839359343, -0.005153239239007235, -0.019756492227315903, -0.0046076527796685696, -0.001432844903320074, 0.013542979955673218, -0.0017579587874934077, 0.001109917531721294, -0.01057722419500351, 0.006989454850554466, 0.06842191517353058, -0.028035182505846024, -0.013144812546670437, 0.023745350539684296, -0.025114944204688072, -0.017399346455931664, 0.01512996293604374, 0.021683113649487495, 0.024008696898818016, 0.014451069757342339, -0.049674853682518005, 0.00936743151396513, 0.01700180396437645, 0.025884702801704407, -0.08280472457408905, -0.017116842791438103, -0.007217556703835726, 0.00649811839684844, 0.006519689690321684, -0.03721221536397934, 0.0004887530230917037, 0.036283962428569794, -0.03357962891459465, 0.029906103387475014, -0.03893505781888962, -0.003031870350241661, -0.045048221945762634, -0.007193454075604677, 0.0013728247722610831, 0.024350320920348167, -0.005597555544227362, 0.0005847697611898184, 0.02439739741384983, 0.035018716007471085, -0.019466271623969078, -0.021074669435620308, -0.008018228225409985, 0.014958162792026997, 0.031556833535432816, -0.04934024438261986, 0.029376186430454254, -0.03952670097351074, -0.024526504799723625, 0.07440046966075897, 0.013746233657002449, 0.03882159665226936, -0.010973040945827961, 0.03931867703795433, 0.004887508228421211, 0.04745589569211006, 0.03777135908603668, 0.004310644697397947, -0.046148356050252914, -0.01189188752323389, 0.013628910295665264, 0.045978814363479614, 0.0011345575330778956, -0.009055987000465393, 0.01959284208714962, -0.0024427215103060007, -0.05349016934633255, 0.016430078074336052, 0.005761875305324793, -0.0050059594213962555, 0.01153088454157114, -0.028571980074048042, 0.03316813334822655, -0.027718158438801765, 0.04285719618201256, -0.06690963357686996, 0.006460788194090128, 0.03718695417046547, 0.022722413763403893, -0.01810561493039131, 0.020185209810733795, -0.010121744126081467, -0.008051086217164993, 0.03653356805443764, -0.006206555757671595, -0.028914690017700195, -0.07011226564645767, -0.005071228835731745, -0.01392338890582323, -0.01522025652229786, -0.0002690093533601612, 0.01097598485648632, -0.007284247782081366, 0.06256667524576187, 0.005851472727954388, -0.02369244210422039, 0.02600523643195629, -0.028986727818846703, -0.005136142019182444, -0.0616452693939209, 0.07332815229892731, 0.02702726423740387, -0.011190653778612614, -0.006260923109948635, -0.029269715771079063, -0.023122265934944153, -0.0024379370734095573, 0.06957630068063736, -0.013418534770607948, -0.02013106644153595, -0.0005203409818932414, -0.012984481640160084, -0.009415007196366787, -0.07082576304674149, 0.009586401283740997, -0.013864033855497837, -0.0611073262989521, -0.029185986146330833, -0.008560369722545147, -0.00026150408666580915, -0.03141177073121071, 0.010260780341923237, -0.007839042693376541, 0.0012556141009554267, -0.014813716523349285, 0.016573680564761162, 0.023164989426732063, 0.02946084924042225, -0.05215200409293175, 0.05945907160639763, -0.014385722577571869, 0.031672921031713486, 0.01768486574292183, -0.007728154305368662, -0.062300797551870346, 0.0308796726167202, 0.011933988891541958, -0.049381695687770844, 0.008291867561638355, 0.024693235754966736, -0.01758568361401558, -0.041361622512340546, -0.03131013363599777, 0.022899694740772247, -0.032871462404727936, 0.019693151116371155, 0.02527127042412758, 0.03154253959655762, 0.06315487623214722, -0.012514769099652767, 0.014574616216123104, 0.015024487860500813, -0.004905182868242264, 0.0029969920869916677, 0.0335347056388855, 0.06464536488056183, 0.020539162680506706, 0.02950746938586235, 0.0046737114898860455, -0.041847847402095795, 0.02966455928981304, 0.012227742932736874, 0.04458589851856232, -0.029622523114085197, -0.027009297162294388, 0.0252319797873497, -0.0061409506015479565, -0.013629045337438583, 0.0013081574579700828, -0.0220088679343462, 0.0346369668841362, 0.014596924185752869, 0.0008989854832179844, -0.03637964278459549, 0.026844289153814316, -0.04120762646198273, -0.046621277928352356, 0.02081224136054516, 0.0103332893922925, -0.015982413664460182, 0.026583397760987282, 0.025612711906433105, 0.01793551631271839, 0.008706266060471535, -0.008191130124032497, 0.024884594604372978, -0.03167325630784035, 0.014443567022681236, -0.053583621978759766, 0.03734811767935753, -0.030347494408488274, -0.0009597874595783651, 0.011956572532653809, 0.04225165396928787, 0.03736059367656708, 0.008844099007546902, -0.041783321648836136, 0.011008746922016144, 0.04434455558657646, -0.04645238071680069, -0.006106186658143997, -0.04148779809474945, 0.03252401575446129, -0.027946438640356064, -0.04218995198607445 ]
<p>I use <code>escalc()</code> function from <code>metafor</code> package to calculate various effect sizes or outcome measures (and the corresponding sampling variances) that are commonly used in meta-analyses.</p> <p>In most of articles are tables of <em>mean</em> and <em>standard deviation</em> which can be easily used by <code>escalc()</code>.</p> <pre><code># for example: # group A == mean=7; sd=1.8; n=13 # group B == mean=3.5; sd=3; n=179 escalc(m1i=7, sd1i=1.8, n1i=13, m2i=3.5, sd2i=3, n2i=179, measure="MD") yi vi 1 3.5000 0.2995 </code></pre> <p>...unfortunately, in some articles are tables consisting of <em>mean</em> and <em>confidence intervals</em>.</p> <p><strong>Is there any way how to compute effect size by using confidence intervals instead of standard deviation?</strong></p> <pre><code># for example # group A == mean=19.25; CI=17.1-20.1; n=28 # group B == mean=8; CI=6.8-9.2; n=72 </code></pre> <p><strong>P.S.</strong> or if not from CI than maybe from <em>range</em> (probably impossible).</p>
36,904
[ -0.041333217173814774, -0.013697578571736813, -0.02339644730091095, -0.007108051795512438, 0.013473238795995712, 0.047420524060726166, -0.03625348210334778, -0.05458834394812584, 0.018127206712961197, 0.016300657764077187, 0.06598002463579178, 0.02413860522210598, 0.07024276256561279, 0.010859303176403046, 0.00415042182430625, 0.0068784309551119804, 0.013444211333990097, 0.01577163301408291, 0.01301402598619461, -0.030695360153913498, -0.006585284601897001, -0.006639943923801184, -0.004980416968464851, -0.017839694395661354, 0.0038731812965124846, 0.03672342002391815, 0.016789428889751434, -0.006624703295528889, -0.013125821948051453, 0.0398387648165226, -0.028078678995370865, -0.025809425860643387, 0.024722620844841003, 0.0023437358904629946, -0.03280171379446983, -0.009931538254022598, -0.016349729150533676, -0.032136596739292145, 0.017299054190516472, 0.01437370479106903, -0.03191289305686951, 0.028561260551214218, 0.0008356884936802089, 0.0381467342376709, -0.007249194197356701, 0.044909100979566574, -0.0462011955678463, -0.029118148609995842, 0.011770336888730526, -0.024655282497406006, 0.06399431079626083, 0.007166566327214241, 0.05241060629487038, 0.013986052945256233, -0.0327366478741169, 0.0007899964693933725, 0.03741387650370598, 0.0506947822868824, -0.015786008909344673, -0.059540893882513046, -0.01230047270655632, -0.057509198784828186, 0.039374321699142456, -0.003469668561592698, -0.020094871520996094, 0.0133742056787014, -0.0163619052618742, -0.0015057130949571729, 0.03169996663928032, -0.009066448546946049, 0.04669109731912613, 0.015462464652955532, 0.01790926605463028, -0.01931758038699627, 0.019062865525484085, -0.019693652167916298, 0.05673879384994507, 0.007185949943959713, 0.04768873006105423, 0.0711720660328865, -0.018939264118671417, 0.01891147531569004, 0.04200798645615578, -0.005057528614997864, 0.010818946175277233, -0.003178295912221074, 0.0662398636341095, -0.0013122577220201492, 0.027646971866488457, -0.004264610819518566, -0.008468572050333023, -0.009099333547055721, 0.06028633192181587, 0.02636829949915409, -0.0338173508644104, 0.021437907591462135, -0.003902744734659791, 0.058117713779211044, -0.015893273055553436, 0.00100798811763525, -0.03611055761575699, -0.046154335141181946, 0.023812657222151756, 0.02759234979748726, -0.01892346702516079, -0.011054275557398796, -0.04151441156864166, -0.02079024538397789, -0.010098696686327457, -0.004750004503875971, 0.007700180169194937, -0.009787770919501781, -0.02036301977932453, 0.02062997594475746, 0.03693167865276337, -0.030245207250118256, -0.000023557879103464074, -0.002414607210084796, 0.05833856016397476, 0.07554714381694794, 0.062046248465776443, -0.014264747500419617, 0.022294873371720314, -0.042204245924949646, -0.04792767018079758, 0.017636580392718315, 0.0027389507740736008, -0.0021534287370741367, -0.0444459468126297, 0.020251475274562836, -0.01296193990856409, -0.018010390922427177, 0.03689020872116089, 0.013034992851316929, 0.025325927883386612, 0.002923054853454232, -0.06295330822467804, -0.060120441019535065, 0.041640505194664, -0.0028787527699023485, 0.0017364464001730084, -0.051223769783973694, 0.004899378400295973, -0.0031824647448956966, 0.026062507182359695, 0.03964122757315636, 0.057950474321842194, 0.009434833191335201, 0.0341920480132103, 0.03231009095907211, -0.04443524032831192, 0.01916106417775154, -0.03678878769278526, -0.010969647206366062, -0.010431952774524689, -0.09518718719482422, 0.05157605558633804, -0.005976162850856781, 0.014348828233778477, -0.010728796012699604, 0.04385725036263466, -0.013982327654957771, -0.022646842524409294, -0.03565989434719086, 0.005208859220147133, 0.02166113443672657, 0.07941173762083054, 0.01728188991546631, -0.01872149109840393, 0.00032490998273715377, -0.001121646724641323, 0.024867648258805275, 0.025599366053938866, 0.025083327665925026, 0.05463482812047005, -0.016065280884504318, 0.0035114006604999304, -0.012645415961742401, 0.023424528539180756, 0.022069092839956284, -0.03625302389264107, -0.0411478728055954, -0.01571640931069851, -0.022643918171525, 0.026613963767886162, 0.03019777126610279, -0.0148311173543334, -0.025127839297056198, 0.010253066197037697, -0.04488139599561691, -0.05718564614653587, -0.09209258109331131, 0.025554904714226723, 0.04077029600739479, -0.02488742582499981, 0.012851192615926266, 0.015962768346071243, 0.023479241877794266, 0.010973834432661533, -0.046290431171655655, -0.02432955615222454, -0.010602650232613087, 0.045608390122652054, -0.019041981548070908, -0.008160876110196114, 0.028140442445874214, 0.038267020136117935, -0.04759072884917259, 0.056273166090250015, -0.02054903656244278, -0.06930399686098099, 0.003735919715836644, -0.04325141757726669, -0.02494264394044876, -0.01672937162220478, -0.06661903113126755, -0.017384065315127373, 0.021981321275234222, -0.028471563011407852, 0.04630140960216522, -0.05140339210629463, 0.061106353998184204, 0.08822978287935257, 0.023908287286758423, 0.0038433740846812725, 0.005707015749067068, 0.03160935640335083, 0.0061788917519152164, -0.01273143757134676, -0.02607535384595394, -0.08814527094364166, -0.008352193050086498, 0.033526185899972916, -0.006565590854734182, -0.04488706216216087, 0.009855384938418865, 0.039252035319805145, -0.025169378146529198, 0.002343161730095744, 0.045574869960546494, -0.016731996089220047, -0.03429507836699486, -0.011348294094204903, 0.017052657902240753, 0.0568053275346756, 0.011806841939687729, -0.01254604198038578, 0.056276835501194, -0.003919661045074463, 0.051026612520217896, 0.007369478233158588, 0.030781617388129234, 0.013764791190624237, -0.019503870978951454, -0.00865047238767147, -0.05406084656715393, 0.04735986888408661, -0.020545314997434616, 0.025060098618268967, 0.012624419294297695, 0.006571700796484947, 0.0013954550959169865, 0.013112879358232021, 0.0020195047836750746, 0.007961621508002281, 0.0222930870950222, -0.02327042445540428, 0.020579323172569275, 0.002211826154962182, -0.00810957234352827, -0.017016444355249405, -0.03685664385557175, -0.02017834410071373, -0.06434375792741776, 0.015485157258808613, -0.005643011536449194, -0.024830589070916176, 0.028501279652118683, -0.03210323676466942, 0.0031292063649743795, 0.002929345704615116, -0.01591838151216507, 0.007840954698622227, -0.013060236349701881, -0.03407454490661621, -0.015040676109492779, 0.009729745797812939, -0.027961108833551407, 0.032528020441532135, -0.0415203720331192, -0.02847222611308098, 0.01921784318983555, 0.015880323946475983, -0.04088909178972244, 0.0038013539742678404, -0.002582679269835353, -0.009297956712543964, -0.0059827594086527824, -0.03846752271056175, 0.01899692974984646, -0.006372053176164627, -0.05755358934402466, 0.049540549516677856, -0.0019015492871403694, 0.005644154269248247, -0.013520278967916965, 0.03260589390993118, -0.007086351979523897, -0.020828258246183395, -0.021890981122851372, 0.035184096544981, -0.011973757296800613, -0.023333419114351273, -0.0472017303109169, -0.00717333797365427, 0.017231477424502373, 0.01142914965748787, 0.041029587388038635, -0.0030499862041324377, -0.029628196731209755, 0.08240214735269547, 0.010609213262796402, -0.0443241260945797, -0.040155813097953796, -0.008885035291314125, -0.013366421684622765, 0.00919361226260662, -0.0012582519557327032, 0.004955057054758072, 0.007368738297373056, 0.0052833277732133865, -0.025108125060796738, 0.005228786263614893, 0.043966684490442276, -0.010117468424141407, -0.004734620917588472, -0.003813253715634346, -0.01540877390652895, -0.0352809838950634, 0.02420613169670105, 0.015119964256882668, 0.01786617934703827, 0.010114290751516819, -0.0007885144441388547, 0.03674493357539177, -0.029599038884043694, -0.06223288178443909, 0.021745800971984863, 0.0055173528380692005, 0.013073713518679142, -0.055553779006004333, 0.035237863659858704, 0.005885649472475052, 0.0037265161518007517, 0.009398567490279675, 0.04104181379079819, 0.030214160680770874, -0.030202724039554596, -0.040427856147289276, 0.03589748591184616, 0.05913006141781807, 0.012001614086329937, -0.01170345488935709, -0.02588222175836563, -0.016471825540065765, -0.02828628569841385, -0.04638427868485451, -0.021168982610106468, 0.053908806294202805, 0.04323134198784828, 0.012197839096188545, -0.0003639135684352368, -0.030622661113739014, 0.03421744704246521, -0.059405211359262466, 0.015427461825311184, -0.047905273735523224, 0.028148116543889046, 0.036487821489572525, 0.05282857269048691, -0.000179090493475087, -0.02040167897939682, -0.0012226044200360775, -0.04160819202661514, -0.07899512350559235, 0.03309674933552742, -0.04814384877681732, -0.011915551498532295, 0.011671863496303558, -0.011447963304817677, 0.038729652762413025, 0.012643135152757168, 0.010281110182404518, 0.008887791074812412, 0.026005981490015984, 0.01516855787485838, 0.010594964027404785, 0.016358498483896255, 0.0009107433725148439, -0.013869124464690685, 0.017893698066473007, -0.005690420046448708, -0.006917854771018028, 0.011245383881032467, 0.04035442695021629, -0.020284121856093407, -0.03165528550744057, 0.006892860401421785, 0.01977904886007309, -0.0030641239136457443, 0.009007404558360577, 0.05375450849533081, 0.02585696615278721, -0.038022324442863464, 0.04701058939099312, -0.017734281718730927, 0.015077662654221058, 0.05090626701712608, -0.023018155246973038, 0.010911311954259872, -0.017873594537377357, 0.026133768260478973, 0.0420411191880703, 0.01794131100177765, -0.0050149643793702126, -0.012273226864635944, 0.06950683891773224, 0.0145950336009264, -0.05083555355668068, 0.02359817549586296, 0.05653386190533638, 0.017694301903247833, 0.003634818596765399, -0.07103726267814636, 0.01496155560016632, 0.0027699298225343227, -0.03160105645656586, 0.030963268131017685, 0.030351411551237106, 0.042873039841651917, 0.005831979215145111, 0.037832554429769516, -0.030076200142502785, -0.05852410942316055, 0.006768380757421255, -0.003862903919070959, 0.03668203204870224, 0.027119671925902367, -0.030709929764270782, 0.002574669662863016, 0.037489138543605804, 0.027670927345752716, 0.007717067841440439, -0.018158255144953728, -0.08725625276565552, 0.017988204956054688, 0.06395181268453598, 0.08174746483564377, -0.02422722615301609, -0.01366965752094984, -0.015044920146465302, 0.001435683574527502, 0.04919711872935295, -0.032128289341926575, 0.009443217888474464, -0.061961572617292404, 0.011636639013886452, -0.04044065624475479, -0.017042607069015503, -0.0179301667958498, 0.01555059477686882, -0.009738666005432606, 0.007894553244113922, -0.02478000521659851, -0.01903928630053997, 0.018506985157728195, 0.010448543354868889, 0.011777388863265514, 0.04954184219241142, -0.06602299958467484, -0.017094779759645462, 0.0019265312002971768, 0.037646327167749405, -0.03867586702108383, -0.061510778963565826, -0.0089028999209404, -0.0025235244538635015, 0.009753507561981678, 0.04490702971816063, -0.03241248056292534, -0.011401892639696598, 0.05505593493580818, 0.022273479029536247, -0.023032210767269135, -0.018432267010211945, -0.018328027799725533, 0.03478960320353508, 0.03724777698516846, -0.0004240877751726657, 0.04279053211212158, -0.005857111420482397, -0.022807469591498375, 0.0193957332521677, -0.022398656234145164, -0.016903631389141083, -0.025301596149802208, -0.000267824245383963, -0.06809859722852707, -0.008536801673471928, -0.012197154574096203, 0.01972513273358345, 0.030804887413978577, 0.011228353716433048, -0.01753239892423153, 0.01619475521147251, 0.0029020023066550493, 0.02849404327571392, 0.005057156551629305, 0.008067453280091286, 0.016205402091145515, -0.005039941053837538, 0.0042853993363678455, -0.011169375851750374, 0.026217805221676826, 0.0010431002592667937, 0.022388141602277756, 0.024898121133446693, -0.07615572214126587, 0.0034346661996096373, -0.02458363026380539, -0.029312461614608765, 0.01992076076567173, -0.06262386590242386, 0.010895643383264542, -0.03194699063897133, -0.0066055855713784695, -0.008296947926282883, -0.029491787776350975, -0.022029682993888855, 0.031253326684236526, -0.007152134086936712, -0.008243083022534847, -0.048221126198768616, 0.04819689318537712, 0.01703023910522461, -0.011392658576369286, -0.07961363345384598, -0.009995336644351482, 0.023542290553450584, -0.00942431204020977, -0.013123003765940666, -0.055571042001247406, -0.03269457072019577, -0.011518562212586403, -0.007609190884977579, -0.03133215755224228, 0.02949526160955429, -0.011796585284173489, 0.012332499958574772, -0.0043053035624325275, 0.014359421096742153, 0.06901605427265167, 0.0033722082152962685, -0.02041769027709961, 0.017253905534744263, -0.021510742604732513, -0.028517795726656914, 0.025564588606357574, -0.02079787291586399, -0.03403827175498009, -0.014427882619202137, -0.04393498972058296, -0.01570625603199005, 0.054210979491472244, -0.004335344769060612, -0.03354913368821144, 0.00855476874858141, -0.0001881258503999561, 0.026900984346866608, -0.056049883365631104, -0.0065345438197255135, -0.033492282032966614, 0.04900630936026573, -0.04072998836636543, 0.0460604690015316, -0.01355045847594738, 0.03961827978491783, 0.00288629112765193, 0.010418089106678963, -0.034503694623708725, -0.005900934804230928, 0.07118260115385056, -0.026760661974549294, 0.05484149977564812, 0.0007238771650008857, -0.02503247745335102, 0.022168470546603203, 0.029461825266480446, 0.029013974592089653, 0.015348098240792751, -0.0017538764514029026, -0.028251586481928825, -0.04158251732587814, -0.01427300926297903, 0.011105548590421677, 0.029924223199486732, -0.02268759161233902, 0.023346377536654472, 0.05977111682295799, -0.020446186885237694, 0.009485524147748947, 0.00011391311272745952, -0.007364777848124504, -0.01603483222424984, 0.006905146408826113, 0.05929949879646301, -0.003819277510046959, -0.02025279588997364, 0.04503065347671509, 0.0258022453635931, 0.009514959529042244, 0.060747068375349045, 0.020059093832969666, -0.0017007067799568176, -0.009336987510323524, -0.0245758518576622, -0.02451304718852043, 0.050722233951091766, -0.06867377460002899, 0.006444388534873724, -0.052413906902074814, -0.01407644897699356, 0.009596803225576878, 0.012814362533390522, 0.02493736520409584, -0.029457198455929756, -0.02653414011001587, -0.04036437347531319, -0.001764171989634633, 0.027094334363937378, -0.043854743242263794, 0.020416265353560448, 0.012233738787472248, -0.009060361422598362, -0.04449601098895073, 0.062075164169073105, -0.024364208802580833, -0.07898201793432236, -0.017007926478981972, -0.04026629775762558, -0.03287287428975105, 0.04780177026987076, 0.006772791966795921, -0.026122570037841797, 0.021097421646118164, -0.03561616688966751, 0.022389637306332588, 0.011375615373253822, 0.03322387859225273, 0.019260546192526817, 0.06399483978748322, 0.006437197793275118, 0.019344406202435493, 0.009731240570545197, -0.04100634157657623, 0.132716566324234, 0.07594118267297745, 0.018094437196850777, -0.06058058515191078, 0.07497446984052658, 0.03202658146619797, 0.004727167543023825, 0.024149974808096886, -0.02581886388361454, -0.011685188859701157, -0.02142598107457161, 0.03879357501864433, 0.08041323721408844, 0.03777617588639259, -0.016692159697413445, 0.03283429518342018, -0.049439359456300735, -0.032093748450279236, 0.01820114441215992, 0.0016941064968705177, -0.013032248243689537, -0.06452290713787079, -0.042961485683918, 0.005748591385781765, 0.04044877365231514, -0.0011158944107592106, -0.02141272835433483, 0.003891624975949526, -0.01595754735171795, 0.026435524225234985, -0.015135611407458782, 0.0006710966699756682, -0.013292535208165646, 0.015768256038427353, 0.0010132505558431149, -0.036315008997917175, 0.06016130372881889, -0.019974268972873688, -0.010400149039924145, 0.05322607606649399, -0.0007990957819856703, 0.0159131046384573, -0.02453172393143177, 0.0358920656144619, -0.033310066908597946, -0.028248073533177376, -0.00974242202937603, 0.028577476739883423, 0.012316725216805935, 0.018708201125264168, -0.005823069252073765, 0.0020526426378637552, -0.021510504186153412, -0.02340064011514187, -0.01830381155014038, 0.015299403108656406, 0.006623846013098955, -0.026441756635904312, 0.013804899528622627, -0.0032200701534748077, 0.009237907826900482, -0.0398707278072834, 0.037343382835388184, 0.054472699761390686, -0.027450861409306526, -0.03502564877271652, -0.026006095111370087, 0.004953809082508087, 0.013669678010046482, 0.009988738223910332, 0.004277964122593403, -0.013565624132752419, -0.021214736625552177, -0.005573715548962355, -0.0060394201427698135, 0.027195334434509277, 0.045333825051784515, -0.013580174185335636, 0.010196094401180744, -0.020306706428527832, -0.022588839754462242, 0.018599076196551323, -0.03342161700129509, -0.015963157638907433, -0.003091181628406048, 0.012033790349960327, 0.02735656313598156, -0.009344300255179405, 0.012769673950970173, 0.03125710040330887, -0.016160771250724792, 0.03512154892086983, 0.018348827958106995, -0.05377720668911934, -0.030801251530647278, 0.0012689086142927408, -0.02063390426337719, -0.00606181425973773, 0.004663574509322643, 0.05709633231163025, -0.01919153332710266, 0.017333026975393295, 0.0300334133207798, 0.009735344909131527, 0.005531044211238623, -0.019126037135720253, 0.025246646255254745, -0.051003243774175644, -0.0015537835424765944, 0.012229264713823795, -0.0025273067876696587, -0.02261991798877716, 0.029700404033064842, -0.046104688197374344, -0.05067375674843788, 0.03723273426294327, -0.0017843018285930157, -0.040131207555532455, 0.045732758939266205, -0.009371606633067131, -0.021541208028793335, -0.020404238253831863, -0.021431060507893562, -0.03783547505736351, -0.04597887769341469, -0.010418931022286415, 0.005899445153772831, -0.0024758614599704742, 0.02825178951025009, -0.036559540778398514, -0.0006381585844792426, 0.002503449097275734, 0.006402385886758566, -0.0031551115680485964, 0.024026712402701378, -0.0027999719604849815, 0.003635537112131715, 0.02052322030067444, -0.041034746915102005, 0.0019538963679224253, 0.04040880873799324, -0.05615241080522537, -0.039651159197092056, -0.005929439328610897, -0.009777660481631756, 0.027713103219866753, 0.0406516008079052, -0.0070546153001487255, -0.013103175908327103, 0.05411861836910248, -0.030317476019263268, -0.02001161500811577, -0.01667335443198681, -0.0247079748660326, -0.009013249538838863, -0.008656279183924198, -0.007002491969615221, 0.00884809996932745, -0.0015579102328047156, 0.05565035343170166, 0.053165435791015625, 0.027665790170431137, -0.008854550309479237, 0.020358465611934662, 0.01886620745062828, 0.021154610440135002, 0.011952687054872513, -0.019978312775492668, 0.030642298981547356, 0.03555402532219887, -0.02962520718574524, 0.017708670347929, -0.033407289534807205, 0.04216599091887474, -0.11591515690088272, -0.007559144403785467, -0.027542904019355774, 0.039337776601314545, 0.030692528933286667, -0.06060972437262535, 0.007072646636515856, -0.01125682145357132, -0.0406816229224205, 0.014931874349713326, -0.0321044959127903, 0.0065737515687942505, -0.003008910221979022, 0.026306763291358948, -0.019938893616199493, -0.0040427204221487045, 0.026700587943196297, 0.026217076927423477, 0.018746938556432724, 0.030548810958862305, 0.01959543116390705, -0.05284596234560013, -0.022604502737522125, 0.011872773990035057, 0.022244196385145187, -0.061908330768346786, 0.03462646156549454, -0.0159401074051857, -0.033537570387125015, 0.011856394819915295, -0.00394747918471694, 0.05187947303056717, 0.012027561664581299, 0.035403959453105927, -0.00515069579705596, 0.057557303458452225, 0.016922684386372566, -0.01017808262258768, -0.03654561936855316, -0.032309893518686295, -0.005639994516968727, -0.0019402630859985948, -0.0211420226842165, 0.012973735108971596, 0.024291571229696274, -0.010300392284989357, 0.010691411793231964, 0.024091139435768127, -0.04619536176323891, -0.040921494364738464, -0.04939151555299759, -0.021360160782933235, 0.016103019937872887, -0.026991548016667366, 0.01892772503197193, -0.03439630568027496, -0.016217969357967377, 0.0413300059735775, 0.03432755544781685, -0.01344345137476921, 0.0068918680772185326, 0.0071417177096009254, -0.004873068071901798, -0.007755664177238941, 0.004055608995258808, 0.008709363639354706, -0.0713336318731308, 0.03458886221051216, -0.014123978093266487, 0.001783324289135635, -0.011734901927411556, 0.0002354356984142214, -0.04327337443828583, 0.025602979585528374, -0.02344006672501564, -0.015482972376048565, 0.009421201422810555, 0.004729739855974913, 0.08192463219165802, -0.07805505394935608, 0.05042571201920509, 0.01609806902706623, -0.011392246000468731, -0.06856772303581238, -0.0027630648110061884, -0.02374497428536415, 0.015407133847475052, 0.04978005588054657, 0.04481837525963783, 0.007176661863923073, -0.00601170351728797, 0.04204945266246796, -0.0005620220908895135, -0.043405238538980484, 0.030855335295200348, -0.01265697181224823, 0.005568021442741156, -0.02392798475921154, -0.026341762393712997, 0.009812362492084503, 0.025416463613510132, 0.02225140668451786, 0.007265998516231775, 0.007045023608952761, 0.02132251299917698, -0.02310647815465927, 0.058232489973306656, 0.0017888532020151615, -0.007749695330858231, 0.02961142547428608, 0.008684806525707245, 0.018641486763954163, 0.026308666914701462, 0.0519048236310482, -0.021591968834400177, 0.0204002782702446, -0.03923052176833153, -0.03382452577352524, 0.010287576355040073, -0.006792654283344746, -0.009034701623022556, -0.051689647138118744, 0.025664668530225754, 0.02644592709839344, -0.04161766171455383, -0.0105100367218256, 0.018330639228224754, 0.02235470339655876, 0.014584152959287167, 0.025840487331151962, -0.0007488054106943309, 0.03188133239746094, -0.018716910853981972, -0.001886832294985652, -0.005038779694586992, -0.007797654718160629, -0.01144547201693058, -0.01341858971863985, 0.038986850529909134, -0.023030351847410202, 0.023430904373526573, 0.03058958612382412, 0.05707092955708504, 0.014168460853397846, -0.029349802061915398, -0.011794846504926682, -0.0025801239535212517, 0.014948606491088867, -0.004391224589198828, -0.01190211996436119, 0.046779584139585495, -0.028166474774479866, 0.05155268684029579, -0.03750540688633919, -0.02363668754696846, -0.015305557288229465, 0.019630789756774902, 0.0005439306842163205, 0.01695229299366474, 0.03406523913145065, 0.044102657586336136, -0.0035723221953958273, -0.024010833352804184, 0.023593226447701454, -0.01768852397799492, 0.03819674998521805, -0.004101126920431852, 0.027590231969952583, -0.01545842457562685, 0.008404445834457874, -0.01590416207909584, -0.05403447523713112, 0.02997836098074913, 0.031044110655784607, 0.027981186285614967, -0.045167576521635056, -0.08206934481859207, 0.04065459594130516, 0.05004153400659561, -0.05379614233970642, -0.020149236544966698, 0.001407052855938673, -0.019147565588355064, 0.018914449959993362, -0.015977146103978157 ]
<p>I want to determine if there's a difference in mean p-values between two groups. In order to do this I perform a Wilcoxon's rank-sum test (the data is not normally distributed). So far, so good. Finally, I want to calculate the corresponding effect size. Unfortunately, R does not provide this. It also does not provide a z value with which the effect size can easily be calculated using: effect size = z / sqrt(N)</p> <p>here is some sample R code:</p> <pre><code>a=rep(0:1,each=20) #grouping variable b=c(rnorm(20, .03,.01), rnorm(20, .02, .009)) #vector of p-values d=cbind(a,b) test = wilcox.test(b ~ a, data = d) #perform Wilcoxon rank-sum test test </code></pre> <p>Does anybody know how to obtain the effect size?</p>
74,186
[ -0.040521059185266495, -0.015364835038781166, -0.026756679639220238, -0.018598297610878944, 0.007832304574549198, 0.04132550582289696, -0.032910916954278946, -0.04522434249520302, 0.02273261733353138, -0.011429855599999428, 0.029700033366680145, 0.05574733391404152, 0.07449028640985489, 0.01206670980900526, 0.028252538293600082, -0.010717135854065418, -0.002158860908821225, 0.0035369663964957, 0.0001779610029188916, -0.006781827658414841, 0.0042167482897639275, 0.0025147967971861362, 0.018811997026205063, 0.0015615841839462519, 0.004274446051567793, 0.06805824488401413, 0.03434906154870987, 0.006527601275593042, -0.020454879850149155, 0.05057529732584953, -0.042420923709869385, -0.054376017302274704, 0.04409405216574669, 0.0310607198625803, 0.028732582926750183, -0.019873052835464478, 0.0008483619894832373, -0.030410349369049072, -0.012768659740686417, 0.026223570108413696, -0.007369671482592821, -0.016927799209952354, 0.013695814646780491, 0.0239687729626894, -0.017918523401021957, 0.02217441238462925, -0.021105056628584862, -0.04495355114340782, 0.03706800192594528, -0.032310277223587036, 0.05885960906744003, 0.03845923766493797, 0.023674990981817245, 0.0026960738468915224, -0.027073418721556664, 0.011895348317921162, 0.030789732933044434, 0.059591058641672134, -0.02409985475242138, -0.0287737138569355, -0.006499909330159426, -0.059463758021593094, -0.0030091784428805113, -0.03913050517439842, -0.03818328678607941, -0.0002448402519803494, -0.029881596565246582, -0.03690081089735031, 0.03531092777848244, -0.021503321826457977, 0.02144317328929901, 0.029715798795223236, 0.030421653762459755, -0.0283940602093935, -0.019662704318761826, -0.03495452180504799, 0.033312052488327026, 0.0054262555204331875, 0.043590594083070755, 0.0594279021024704, -0.009664364159107208, 0.018791038542985916, 0.019365832209587097, 0.046524424105882645, 0.010931761004030704, -0.002572163473814726, 0.06912019103765488, -0.04042652249336243, 0.0011735140578821301, 0.04124562442302704, -0.043392181396484375, -0.017398180440068245, 0.05784938856959343, 0.007260330952703953, -0.0453198067843914, 0.040199290961027145, -0.02653069607913494, 0.04721072316169739, -0.019564911723136902, 0.003790979040786624, -0.012413229793310165, -0.05767539143562317, 0.004691677633672953, 0.04262186959385872, -0.02888290025293827, 0.0066595617681741714, -0.01846570335328579, 0.013759948313236237, -0.02564377151429653, -0.006143726408481598, 0.028883423656225204, 0.03870308771729469, -0.03215166553854942, -0.01712082512676716, 0.03040618635714054, -0.023725682869553566, -0.041460420936346054, 0.004819422960281372, 0.05568473041057587, 0.06090763583779335, 0.06973928213119507, 0.010625461116433144, 0.020246131345629692, -0.03770507872104645, -0.03833726793527603, -0.001531153917312622, 0.0002050246694125235, 0.015240153297781944, -0.027693167328834534, 0.06741524487733841, -0.023138370364904404, -0.026736564934253693, 0.02288435958325863, -0.017445610836148262, 0.014553824439644814, 0.014855174347758293, -0.07646315544843674, -0.014944767579436302, 0.028565648943185806, -0.008606594987213612, 0.011630858294665813, -0.06261077523231506, -0.00014057656517252326, 0.014823832549154758, 0.0249011367559433, 0.04893812537193298, 0.05257013067603111, -0.017413243651390076, 0.02405460551381111, 0.02393832802772522, -0.03300593048334122, -0.02064729668200016, -0.02547505311667919, -0.021229637786746025, -0.004251288250088692, -0.04492625221610069, 0.012211430817842484, 0.011810529977083206, -0.03677637502551079, 0.02539663016796112, 0.04479525610804558, 0.01227227970957756, -0.01509774662554264, -0.022408856078982353, 0.024040596559643745, 0.01020731870085001, 0.05344085395336151, 0.007968179881572723, -0.02186679281294346, 0.01479937694966793, -0.02537117898464203, -0.03239920735359192, 0.04143945500254631, 0.02447698451578617, 0.060664303600788116, -0.028753409162163734, 0.011793460696935654, -0.03145687282085419, 0.022193115204572678, 0.024168282747268677, -0.03531395271420479, 0.022156165912747383, -0.03213678300380707, -0.0026086641009896994, 0.013766750693321228, 0.03642735257744789, 0.02393580973148346, -0.022162670269608498, 0.01240230817347765, -0.0064939772710204124, -0.06699594855308533, -0.09211619198322296, 0.009487304836511612, 0.03821076452732086, -0.04011194407939911, -0.01237379852682352, 0.06032492220401764, 0.0470455028116703, -0.010440249927341938, -0.03987174108624458, -0.007615245413035154, -0.006931537762284279, 0.010226697660982609, -0.05138244107365608, -0.01285884715616703, 0.04217958077788353, 0.10041114687919617, -0.05326366797089577, 0.038062430918216705, -0.03657485544681549, -0.04316465184092522, 0.0018295027548447251, -0.04199400916695595, -0.017248371616005898, 0.004585096146911383, -0.028839146718382835, 0.02404889650642872, -0.004473221953958273, 0.00979782734066248, 0.03581809252500534, -0.05327031388878822, 0.04506903141736984, 0.08241068571805954, 0.027835354208946228, 0.030804533511400223, -0.03821778669953346, 0.026225466281175613, -0.02386998012661934, -0.04510632902383804, 0.012223674915730953, -0.04703785479068756, -0.015804139897227287, 0.07414022088050842, -0.021764589473605156, -0.05495539307594299, -0.014960040338337421, 0.08195403963327408, -0.010543697513639927, 0.017669443041086197, 0.06321300566196442, 0.010133032687008381, -0.03727033734321594, -0.007452351972460747, 0.04015295207500458, 0.021351022645831108, 0.014680728316307068, 0.02976939082145691, -0.004865936003625393, 0.06522028148174286, 0.022541148588061333, -0.023157712072134018, 0.027724819257855415, 0.018630776554346085, 0.002308763563632965, -0.012571512721478939, -0.04253587871789932, 0.033529412001371384, -0.018024785444140434, -0.0050019193440675735, 0.032940223813056946, 0.021684745326638222, 0.008637839928269386, 0.0018149534007534385, -0.021359754726290703, 0.02141072228550911, 0.04074826091527939, -0.02786569483578205, 0.04517865553498268, -0.007796215824782848, -0.018734972923994064, -0.006377292796969414, -0.0071672252379357815, 0.003438411746174097, -0.06927711516618729, -0.00768702570348978, -0.004691906273365021, 0.02363976277410984, 0.016593236476182938, -0.01844004914164543, -0.013321136124432087, -0.021655121818184853, -0.02172660641372204, 0.024057259783148766, -0.02112298272550106, -0.039148952811956406, 0.004526089411228895, 0.00254651322029531, -0.037308767437934875, 0.011531511321663857, -0.010610981844365597, -0.017242906615138054, 0.02111917920410633, 0.0051236823201179504, -0.030357038602232933, 0.00042142521124333143, -0.024470316246151924, 0.0011593784438446164, -0.018729286268353462, -0.028871357440948486, 0.023531900718808174, 0.0013625886058434844, -0.05507688224315643, 0.04480050504207611, -0.013876795768737793, -0.008218414150178432, -0.026698356494307518, 0.009084510616958141, 0.004522282630205154, -0.008603512309491634, -0.011248799972236156, 0.01460169441998005, -0.025239700451493263, -0.004384560976177454, -0.028391033411026, -0.028699789196252823, 0.02053040824830532, 0.007908814586699009, 0.019219744950532913, -0.0033323566894978285, -0.03044893406331539, 0.061454568058252335, 0.0181460902094841, -0.010454067029058933, -0.072132907807827, 0.006613411474972963, -0.02786538563668728, 0.027135418727993965, 0.030660277232527733, 0.02585919387638569, 0.012265496887266636, 0.02998857945203781, -0.014968274161219597, 0.009362746961414814, 0.03447941318154335, 0.016817664727568626, -0.02282038889825344, 0.011056150309741497, 0.012531605549156666, -0.0225759856402874, 0.04819914698600769, 0.014129366725683212, -0.029009360820055008, 0.022454913705587387, 0.018196914345026016, 0.01078670471906662, -0.035287585109472275, -0.031865596771240234, -0.004806221928447485, 0.01986328884959221, 0.026402568444609642, -0.029648886993527412, 0.05621441453695297, -0.0158754363656044, -0.029220249503850937, 0.00962903629988432, 0.026068363338708878, 0.031135832890868187, -0.005051816813647747, -0.008093473501503468, 0.03874213621020317, 0.045024022459983826, -0.023006858304142952, 0.014943259768188, 0.005253106355667114, -0.022050147876143456, 0.00009103570482693613, -0.038329970091581345, -0.04243744537234306, 0.060720425099134445, 0.04255177453160286, 0.02507205680012703, 0.00689655402675271, -0.04142005741596222, 0.034519825130701065, -0.03340553864836693, 0.014792758971452713, -0.04410915821790695, 0.05696761608123779, 0.0016306779580190778, 0.09049203246831894, 0.0015140024479478598, -0.003251081332564354, -0.013573495671153069, -0.046253547072410583, -0.06544826924800873, 0.060282278805971146, -0.028910787776112556, 0.001345935044810176, -0.004685445688664913, -0.013679844327270985, -0.0026574700605124235, 0.02843894064426422, 0.036703165620565414, 0.021379735320806503, 0.03536836802959442, -0.021853135898709297, -0.0014025612035766244, 0.009082747623324394, 0.014190126210451126, 0.010030458681285381, 0.029261695221066475, 0.01615450344979763, -0.010298549197614193, 0.02044062130153179, 0.03031826950609684, -0.0037660617381334305, -0.005033343564718962, -0.012409500777721405, 0.009290576912462711, -0.009153475984930992, 0.025206634774804115, 0.04265551641583443, 0.01689041033387184, -0.0316627100110054, 0.006091097369790077, -0.03769586607813835, 0.033260527998209, 0.03864055499434471, -0.0005819401703774929, 0.007724829483777285, -0.010549379512667656, 0.0011156286345794797, -0.032068151980638504, -0.002486937213689089, -0.024295393377542496, 0.0005289710243232548, 0.01694578491151333, 0.01720295660197735, -0.032496899366378784, 0.011589180678129196, 0.07763968408107758, 0.02478707954287529, -0.007686892990022898, -0.06876207143068314, 0.02290169522166252, -0.02208094671368599, -0.0336063914000988, 0.021183207631111145, 0.0031596769113093615, 0.03469115123152733, -0.0008168016211129725, 0.04330483824014664, -0.030979417264461517, -0.01787504181265831, -0.030040856450796127, 0.01718159019947052, 0.035693444311618805, -0.0007644542492926121, -0.012162751518189907, -0.031630147248506546, 0.026929330080747604, 0.022230710834264755, 0.0019373244140297174, -0.024056822061538696, -0.07295974344015121, 0.0175363477319479, 0.04396633431315422, 0.06642357259988785, -0.02030112035572529, -0.019642429426312447, -0.018728388473391533, -0.006339491344988346, 0.07665292173624039, -0.0619414858520031, 0.0015195328742265701, -0.03162454441189766, 0.00208074739202857, -0.051438428461551666, -0.012473211623728275, -0.06465842574834824, 0.026412153616547585, -0.04997379705309868, 0.023245302960276604, -0.0005279729375615716, -0.05456727743148804, -0.010404480621218681, 0.0370248444378376, 0.015185832977294922, 0.028362059965729713, -0.05057555064558983, -0.005286904983222485, 0.01139132585376501, 0.024449367076158524, -0.008903910405933857, -0.05433237552642822, -0.010058867745101452, 0.014197006821632385, 0.0017333442810922861, 0.06539712101221085, -0.00014079577522352338, 0.002200801158323884, 0.031016752123832703, 0.006512950174510479, -0.01956368423998356, -0.009762081317603588, -0.011280812323093414, 0.05297129973769188, 0.03901289775967598, 0.0058295223861932755, 0.07229979336261749, -0.02315645106136799, 0.004948602523654699, -0.017873093485832214, -0.025090092793107033, 0.015279419720172882, -0.025735504925251007, -0.030377784743905067, -0.06039652228355408, 0.003658814588561654, -0.0007610027678310871, 0.05051428824663162, -0.010445239022374153, 0.0061363764107227325, -0.057361848652362823, 0.015018684789538383, 0.025746995583176613, 0.009970124810934067, 0.0023353835567831993, -0.008712075650691986, 0.01615988463163376, -0.014333448372781277, 0.014263047836720943, -0.006261759903281927, 0.02412126213312149, -0.019446520134806633, -0.02755715325474739, -0.008063328452408314, -0.0380917526781559, 0.01776694878935814, 0.035074781626462936, -0.03172130882740021, 0.04476584121584892, -0.024064289405941963, 0.040372367948293686, -0.0513225793838501, 0.027173742651939392, 0.008435683324933052, -0.05629332736134529, 0.00968374777585268, 0.028012434020638466, -0.00686643598601222, 0.00805630348622799, -0.06458224356174469, 0.016194796189665794, 0.008885876275599003, -0.007507031317800283, -0.061783742159605026, -0.039065711200237274, 0.017427414655685425, -0.012493402697145939, 0.004336406011134386, -0.061553340405225754, -0.018777143210172653, -0.01691276952624321, -0.014135124161839485, -0.018846731632947922, 0.05622396990656853, -0.03281756862998009, 0.007352188695222139, -0.021593933925032616, 0.01266968809068203, 0.06520909816026688, 0.014677269384264946, -0.03286109119653702, -0.010307888500392437, -0.019865287467837334, -0.02193659357726574, 0.01658111996948719, -0.013540147803723812, -0.03667071834206581, -0.017145885154604912, -0.04062981158494949, -0.004665589891374111, 0.026965422555804253, 0.0017408609855920076, -0.02763034775853157, -0.008696561679244041, -0.0037134571466594934, 0.050190530717372894, -0.05427790805697441, -0.007688485085964203, -0.033781107515096664, 0.021419355645775795, -0.04790055379271507, 0.009860783815383911, -0.030894501134753227, 0.012129746377468109, -0.02071530930697918, 0.05298113450407982, -0.04361758753657341, -0.003800386795774102, 0.08811327815055847, 0.0069087534211575985, 0.04292283579707146, 0.002885836875066161, -0.031537141650915146, 0.025310952216386795, 0.014279461465775967, -0.011779814958572388, -0.0018639800837263465, -0.009930836968123913, -0.03653552010655403, 0.0013244517613202333, -0.025817690417170525, -0.01235034316778183, 0.04735918343067169, 0.0018842011922970414, 0.030773311853408813, 0.06178117170929909, 0.024770304560661316, -0.007634020410478115, -0.006404281593859196, 0.0014980039559304714, -0.005485421046614647, 0.008611981756985188, 0.07931531965732574, 0.0018680690554901958, -0.0010118890786543489, 0.07070869207382202, 0.028392747044563293, 0.0232029240578413, 0.062060609459877014, 0.010046867653727531, 0.01582426019012928, 0.03633640334010124, -0.05121033266186714, -0.02039436623454094, 0.008534044027328491, -0.04824568331241608, 0.0002883527195081115, -0.05709260329604149, -0.006410997826606035, 0.04495730996131897, 0.03588865324854851, -0.0216252189129591, -0.011782589368522167, -0.012263097800314426, -0.04720287397503853, -0.02117864042520523, 0.015480379574000835, -0.0361979641020298, 0.02359418198466301, 0.0030295324977487326, -0.005348026752471924, -0.033162206411361694, 0.04628884047269821, -0.01972675323486328, -0.057790808379650116, -0.03875732421875, -0.034091658890247345, -0.026551689952611923, 0.02587719075381756, -0.002463281387463212, -0.00957641564309597, 0.011705055832862854, -0.05602840334177017, 0.018568282946944237, 0.008559581823647022, 0.01644110679626465, 0.01569388620555401, 0.056944236159324646, -0.022581050172448158, 0.04275497794151306, 0.006319541018456221, -0.017172908410429955, 0.1285669207572937, 0.04445428401231766, 0.03358830511569977, -0.05835210531949997, 0.029273981228470802, 0.023656724020838737, 0.004603784065693617, -0.009954167529940605, 0.015836076810956, -0.022065041586756706, 0.008289504796266556, 0.045051295310258865, 0.06522558629512787, 0.0474761538207531, -0.0383387953042984, 0.05219597369432449, -0.01681012474000454, -0.02010873518884182, 0.008773584850132465, 0.029567422345280647, -0.013615463860332966, -0.045148734003305435, -0.06830313056707382, 0.0006600589258596301, 0.019429976120591164, -0.02458721585571766, -0.04545343667268753, 0.03144606202840805, -0.050705406814813614, -0.0103383120149374, -0.006427770014852285, 0.026552369818091393, 0.006503095384687185, 0.011384079232811928, -0.02296927571296692, -0.014861423522233963, 0.03970234468579292, -0.01302866730839014, -0.0006507270154543221, 0.058796610683202744, 0.0005049512255936861, 0.008260318078100681, -0.028275594115257263, 0.04662560671567917, -0.057146646082401276, -0.0020925449207425117, -0.01967117376625538, 0.05024399980902672, -0.003328086109831929, 0.026172051206231117, 0.009968970902264118, 0.008843470364809036, -0.02263123169541359, -0.03851836919784546, -0.03480401262640953, 0.01253027468919754, 0.013151784427464008, 0.011722643859684467, -0.0038940105587244034, -0.01506501529365778, 0.03219793364405632, -0.015944430604577065, 0.03991559520363808, 0.04994380474090576, -0.02038801833987236, -0.029409492388367653, -0.02823951281607151, 0.038638681173324585, -0.011585350148379803, 0.0001754977274686098, 0.019688621163368225, 0.007012464106082916, -0.008012344129383564, -0.006701427046209574, -0.01597660966217518, -0.006964182481169701, 0.045610710978507996, -0.01946353167295456, -0.01265004463493824, -0.02367984503507614, -0.012631981633603573, 0.019683929160237312, -0.028435589745640755, -0.02148469164967537, -0.018676333129405975, 0.03707724064588547, 0.04519033432006836, 0.00839405320584774, 0.001634074724279344, 0.003079272573813796, 0.025606321170926094, 0.0581011064350605, 0.03680456429719925, -0.037621963769197464, 0.0024574920535087585, 0.03189443424344063, -0.003139014355838299, -0.022464370355010033, -0.015264407731592655, 0.05318262055516243, 0.034795016050338745, -0.015599358826875687, -0.0011252050753682852, 0.015402872115373611, -0.039397601038217545, -0.002608989365398884, 0.023680072277784348, -0.04918231815099716, -0.024117305874824524, 0.004653420764952898, -0.032612599432468414, -0.023600641638040543, -0.0001259155833395198, -0.05467835068702698, -0.03903860226273537, 0.016105709597468376, -0.04381869360804558, -0.02540251798927784, -0.008552591316401958, -0.01320113055408001, -0.00498508894816041, 0.008434181101620197, -0.007534445729106665, -0.04011526703834534, -0.021579613909125328, -0.008168722502887249, 0.019672004505991936, -0.01910318247973919, 0.0312364399433136, -0.049965694546699524, 0.0055226595140993595, 0.019309325143694878, 0.032242029905319214, 0.025788025930523872, 0.02506481483578682, -0.010018485598266125, 0.01531821209937334, 0.04899686202406883, 0.0007147617288865149, -0.014134024269878864, 0.05107062682509422, -0.0874367207288742, -0.0520305410027504, 0.016386592760682106, -0.00853012502193451, 0.044759608805179596, 0.018280448392033577, -0.011842267587780952, -0.027939219027757645, 0.017597315832972527, -0.02216269262135029, -0.029675517231225967, -0.02615620754659176, -0.022165942937135696, -0.02433123253285885, -0.010875476524233818, 0.0059990608133375645, -0.006111985072493553, -0.0389392152428627, 0.025287427008152008, 0.023248683661222458, -0.011803951114416122, 0.008416686207056046, -0.001745459157973528, -0.007395769003778696, 0.0137498639523983, 0.003445568960160017, -0.033054549247026443, 0.022841405123472214, 0.04396694898605347, -0.046835578978061676, 0.00903596542775631, -0.031251341104507446, 0.04188808798789978, -0.11088012903928757, -0.006815100554376841, -0.015028475783765316, 0.02030772715806961, 0.015736810863018036, -0.06302779912948608, 0.018852360546588898, -0.004860793240368366, -0.06999780982732773, 0.04993162676692009, -0.02714027464389801, -0.004550490528345108, -0.015702087432146072, 0.021140333265066147, 0.003158728126436472, 0.04889889806509018, 0.02698742412030697, 0.05107811465859413, 0.07989329844713211, 0.029586883261799812, 0.014634375460445881, -0.0067235310561954975, -0.001563056604936719, 0.009716952219605446, 0.0028943850193172693, -0.07408849149942398, 0.024048717692494392, -0.022697705775499344, -0.022609589621424675, 0.03127157688140869, -0.027181187644600868, 0.04799444600939751, -0.008851587772369385, 0.034419748932123184, 0.008528124541044235, 0.07731207460165024, 0.0107490299269557, -0.01577548123896122, -0.03469010442495346, -0.00207502325065434, -0.013023044914007187, 0.009833895601332188, -0.0378589890897274, -0.0003988138341810554, 0.019180690869688988, 0.023100940510630608, -0.02660207822918892, 0.0036405024584382772, -0.015822749584913254, -0.016401106491684914, -0.032585833221673965, -0.006791100837290287, 0.012552008032798767, -0.021567489951848984, -0.010837476700544357, -0.008688164874911308, -0.01995919644832611, 0.04011521115899086, 0.03143547847867012, -0.013642060570418835, 0.04157373681664467, 0.011342781595885754, -0.01938604563474655, 0.0019980762153863907, -0.017638277262449265, 0.012836371548473835, -0.04506959021091461, -0.0019552698358893394, -0.009495113044977188, 0.020564328879117966, -0.009713732637465, 0.0033110480289906263, -0.0228672306984663, 0.018116261810064316, -0.04822130501270294, 0.001964070601388812, 0.003547772066667676, 0.013943707570433617, 0.06390726566314697, -0.08957655727863312, 0.054420650005340576, 0.010929981246590614, 0.015105796977877617, -0.03368578106164932, -0.005568023305386305, -0.040164392441511154, 0.006892943289130926, 0.0644560307264328, 0.02631979063153267, -0.009973250329494476, -0.02419067546725273, 0.02810886688530445, 0.0000021536416170420125, -0.07836104929447174, 0.017251787707209587, -0.020112110301852226, -0.009848937392234802, -0.04044647142291069, -0.0002884027489926666, 0.03329777345061302, 0.016699083149433136, 0.01506590936332941, 0.016874684020876884, 0.0033552569802850485, -0.0245562382042408, -0.012924063950777054, 0.047708287835121155, 0.010511577129364014, -0.014912263490259647, 0.028506651520729065, 0.01648491993546486, 0.04525972157716751, 0.04173985496163368, 0.04376085102558136, -0.03162926435470581, 0.030785148963332176, -0.039302658289670944, -0.008914659731090069, 0.01986796222627163, -0.014580653049051762, -0.001828214735724032, -0.04137667641043663, 0.008079495280981064, 0.009439762681722641, -0.04299619793891907, 0.007783420383930206, 0.0064949579536914825, 0.012922141700983047, 0.03529144823551178, -0.022031323984265327, 0.007326055783778429, -0.009668666869401932, -0.02137472853064537, 0.019838489592075348, -0.0003406312898732722, -0.008078384213149548, 0.011119682341814041, 0.0008626990020275116, 0.023066479712724686, -0.051999639719724655, 0.029920406639575958, -0.003489066381007433, 0.03543003275990486, -0.004716533701866865, -0.024799689650535583, 0.031911808997392654, -0.027267850935459137, 0.026177607476711273, -0.0065007940866053104, -0.005891573615372181, 0.042072441428899765, -0.009147049859166145, 0.008969778195023537, -0.03503090888261795, -0.019659142941236496, -0.021349497139453888, -0.013138076290488243, 0.012366514652967453, 0.0023649882059544325, -0.03184216096997261, 0.01955535262823105, 0.024230074137449265, -0.0364384762942791, 0.016341034322977066, 0.003974422346800566, 0.03882575407624245, -0.01601393334567547, 0.011804517358541489, -0.011655901558697224, 0.010000370442867279, -0.039981190115213394, -0.00391492061316967, 0.04700177162885666, 0.0210257600992918, 0.035647060722112656, -0.02832919731736183, -0.005095626227557659, 0.0054444181732833385, 0.035313598811626434, -0.04458991065621376, -0.041766900569200516, -0.04348745197057724, -0.0007990693557076156, 0.012724674306809902, -0.021603673696517944 ]
<p>Suppose we have a joint distribution on vector $[\mathbf{x}, y]$: $$ p([y, \mathbf{x}] ) = \mathcal{N}\left(\begin{pmatrix} y \\ \mathbf{x}\end{pmatrix}| 0, \begin{pmatrix} k&amp; \mathbf{v} \\ \mathbf{v}^T &amp; K\end{pmatrix}\right), $$ where $\mathbf{x} \in \mathbb{R}^N$, $y \in \mathbb{R}$. And also we know distribution of $\mathbf{x}$ conditioned on some data $D$: $$ q(\mathbf{x}| D) = \mathcal{N} (\mu, \sigma^2 I). $$ How does analytical expression for $p(y| D)$ look like (i.e. how to handle such an integral in the simplest way)?: $$ p(y| D) = \int p(y| \mathbf{x}) q(\mathbf{x}| D) d \mathbf{x} = ? $$</p> <p>So, I try to solve this, but all I obtain looks like a monster, which isn't appropriate for me, so I have to use this expression further through my research.</p>
74,187
[ 0.007655701600015163, -0.009091835469007492, -0.004507916979491711, -0.07064060866832733, 0.03338133171200752, 0.0449204295873642, -0.009831485338509083, -0.034703634679317474, 0.017813365906476974, -0.013587886467576027, 0.04113158956170082, 0.06984502822160721, 0.09216389805078506, 0.021695652976632118, 0.022580640390515327, 0.015426508150994778, -0.012145931832492352, -0.018657999113202095, -0.04090625047683716, -0.024531284347176552, 0.006161218974739313, 0.03171068802475929, 0.018833311274647713, -0.022221079096198082, 0.003034842200577259, 0.07847248762845993, 0.023012179881334305, -0.005761804524809122, 0.037382788956165314, 0.05179854482412338, -0.04064922034740448, -0.012485128827393055, 0.0467582605779171, 0.022729355841875076, -0.02644946426153183, 0.038414906710386276, -0.04805978760123253, -0.03265644982457161, -0.022257085889577866, 0.007159867789596319, -0.044419072568416595, -0.026115363463759422, 0.00403804425150156, 0.05197405442595482, -0.020337607711553574, 0.02274215780198574, 0.031721096485853195, -0.020431039854884148, 0.020865166559815407, -0.0298282690346241, 0.10322543233633041, 0.051452118903398514, 0.05120331421494484, 0.06309222429990768, -0.012465003877878189, 0.016618257388472557, 0.025393567979335785, 0.030169811099767685, 0.008714229799807072, -0.03500070795416832, -0.04265683516860008, -0.03482575714588165, -0.001038348418660462, -0.054542817175388336, 0.006746131461113691, -0.001780301914550364, 0.040326084941625595, -0.009146880358457565, -0.004327800124883652, -0.028611136600375175, 0.003745223395526409, 0.04578248783946037, 0.060442786663770676, -0.029550259932875633, 0.03700026869773865, 0.022456949576735497, 0.02583559975028038, 0.027627239003777504, 0.011106150224804878, -0.027860766276717186, -0.0139143792912364, 0.002039716113358736, 0.015480343252420425, 0.01594432443380356, 0.007626453414559364, -0.030845630913972855, 0.0677684098482132, -0.017680101096630096, 0.030196480453014374, -0.010029870085418224, -0.021780742332339287, 0.0036063443403691053, 0.07283750921487808, -0.00993379857391119, -0.0835244357585907, 0.021912619471549988, -0.014466659165918827, 0.03521576151251793, 0.0002864571870304644, -0.04441380873322487, -0.00730423117056489, -0.0405755452811718, 0.0016652938211336732, 0.04682765156030655, 0.01372627355158329, -0.0011449286248534918, -0.009629728272557259, -0.023455141112208366, -0.016079621389508247, -0.02897239662706852, -0.02876434661448002, 0.046924374997615814, -0.007005465682595968, -0.0067033590748906136, 0.008423680439591408, -0.009366493672132492, -0.02139056660234928, 0.0013867680681869388, 0.06449006497859955, 0.09146364033222198, 0.030312631279230118, 0.001966675743460655, 0.03578946739435196, -0.03544934466481209, -0.07071477919816971, 0.042851656675338745, 0.01654406078159809, -0.013033018447458744, -0.07594913989305496, 0.03749420866370201, 0.002120519056916237, -0.0019948615226894617, 0.0011073565110564232, -0.001361335627734661, 0.013610783964395523, -0.0378168523311615, -0.05991233512759209, -0.028042158111929893, 0.019711647182703018, -0.04822961241006851, 0.012604986317455769, -0.03982535004615784, -0.005147982854396105, 0.01996619813144207, 0.06630033254623413, -0.015814874321222305, 0.05203181132674217, -0.02150585502386093, 0.011805051937699318, 0.008287956938147545, -0.040330905467271805, -0.07127182930707932, -0.023319227620959282, 0.008396221324801445, -0.0005683449562638998, -0.06296133995056152, 0.030483437702059746, 0.0318991020321846, -0.009473515674471855, -0.025252174586057663, 0.0711435079574585, -0.0007567625725641847, -0.04293385148048401, 0.015072296373546124, 0.01621124893426895, -0.032594844698905945, 0.053654540330171585, 0.01287042535841465, 0.02285066805779934, 0.029624205082654953, -0.008134168572723866, 0.03315875679254532, 0.012609150260686874, 0.06121336296200752, 0.02140912413597107, -0.04591251537203789, 0.006975824479013681, -0.024095091968774796, 0.00881252996623516, 0.00826804805546999, -0.03169577196240425, -0.0316169373691082, -0.030468091368675232, -0.02495911344885826, -0.007872207090258598, 0.01892421767115593, 0.018685409799218178, -0.004696277901530266, 0.0151748675853014, -0.03109203651547432, 0.0049825748428702354, -0.04799853265285492, 0.025980619713664055, -0.007656282279640436, -0.043381042778491974, 0.008101197890937328, -0.006733870133757591, 0.025083577260375023, 0.04148485139012337, -0.02677028439939022, -0.006872636266052723, -0.004063994623720646, 0.008915268816053867, -0.030196940526366234, -0.020664412528276443, 0.028560170903801918, 0.04144006967544556, 0.02665887586772442, 0.027112847194075584, -0.04036732390522957, -0.01713506132364273, 0.007028899155557156, -0.022941498085856438, 0.027158522978425026, 0.02500428445637226, -0.01202350202947855, 0.029243625700473785, -0.03678150847554207, -0.006004203576594591, 0.006425823550671339, -0.04531954973936081, 0.02069895528256893, 0.08302056044340134, 0.0030255166348069906, -0.0187327079474926, 0.020639410242438316, -0.015871839597821236, 0.03689533844590187, -0.02505304291844368, -0.026784194633364677, -0.04640733078122139, 0.04420723766088486, 0.027589822188019753, 0.028476284816861153, -0.04161727428436279, 0.01861908659338951, 0.05651799589395523, 0.025516366586089134, 0.03320963308215141, 0.01643974892795086, -0.016735145822167397, -0.0033569454681128263, -0.0058219595812261105, 0.0028144719544798136, 0.017695562914013863, -0.021112587302923203, 0.005464336834847927, -0.004020781721919775, 0.03863881900906563, 0.022030433639883995, -0.047073137015104294, 0.051153868436813354, -0.03944902494549751, 0.02590494230389595, -0.017398234456777573, 0.0032397250179201365, 0.04057715833187103, 0.006396537646651268, -0.0075195855461061, 0.05234387516975403, -0.009033406153321266, 0.0007154318736866117, -0.004399598576128483, -0.052717503160238266, 0.009088574908673763, 0.045425623655319214, -0.018548905849456787, -0.012062544003129005, 0.005984774325042963, 0.026606984436511993, 0.006984017323702574, 0.01321222260594368, -0.00842129997909069, -0.008199279196560383, 0.009967586025595665, 0.018914634361863136, -0.009943357668817043, -0.02186371013522148, -0.025657743215560913, -0.04374905303120613, 0.00857633724808693, 0.008047366514801979, 0.022840937599539757, -0.019053950905799866, -0.06768061220645905, -0.014355570077896118, -0.04355015233159065, -0.021988563239574432, 0.03126321732997894, -0.013721168972551823, -0.013697979971766472, -0.015288927592337132, -0.02268652431666851, -0.03934037312865257, -0.006250462494790554, 0.02089739963412285, -0.008464105427265167, -0.048658911138772964, -0.0034927723463624716, 0.0429530069231987, -0.007564880419522524, -0.007826369255781174, -0.02001536451280117, -0.016879411414265633, -0.01924136094748974, -0.02557879313826561, -0.019587915390729904, 0.001080348971299827, 0.015536588616669178, 0.05305881053209305, 0.01517440378665924, -0.036472972482442856, -0.04105248674750328, -0.09305625408887863, -0.0571330226957798, 0.009252536110579967, -0.0006569261313416064, -0.012093540281057358, 0.033845942467451096, -0.0014590044738724828, 0.056163106113672256, 0.010500995442271233, -0.02012266218662262, 0.0011931295739486814, -0.006059115752577782, 0.006557036656886339, -0.0008396913763135672, 0.00984288565814495, 0.01836337149143219, -0.011228440329432487, 0.054153747856616974, 0.005818768870085478, -0.011987496167421341, 0.0669613629579544, -0.024864301085472107, -0.05535300448536873, 0.029842881485819817, -0.018001025542616844, 0.008057531900703907, 0.029935242608189583, -0.012752383947372437, -0.037754449993371964, 0.02282945066690445, 0.025594884529709816, -0.010366374626755714, 0.020003916695713997, -0.035656753927469254, 0.007981272414326668, -0.005460986867547035, -0.019353318959474564, -0.03691132739186287, 0.06835542619228363, 0.011746074073016644, -0.04521065577864647, 0.005572451278567314, 0.043731074780225754, 0.041340649127960205, -0.03151202201843262, -0.009774038568139076, 0.03976532444357872, 0.015422206372022629, -0.011192339472472668, -0.041586555540561676, 0.004207197111099958, 0.019139552488923073, -0.004541424103081226, -0.02307375706732273, -0.012747565284371376, -0.005868329666554928, 0.020964952185750008, 0.01456616260111332, -0.06436369568109512, 0.004788968712091446, -0.008719805628061295, -0.04532383009791374, 0.002970953704789281, 0.005180057138204575, 0.022439047694206238, 0.028116615489125252, 0.03173306584358215, 0.029264232143759727, 0.0018013945082202554, 0.0007734589162282646, -0.005853979382663965, -0.05708016827702522, 0.0030001534614712, -0.008046232163906097, -0.009145624935626984, -0.025403296574950218, -0.04592389613389969, 0.04076489433646202, -0.039810582995414734, -0.0029424785170704126, 0.009124962612986565, 0.021520789712667465, -0.03113529458642006, -0.02532861940562725, 0.0021953824907541275, -0.030327480286359787, -0.004192190244793892, 0.06378186494112015, 0.0340532623231411, -0.013744274154305458, -0.015474948100745678, 0.013974453322589397, -0.016955822706222534, -0.010995455086231232, -0.0025619047228246927, 0.01509035937488079, 0.007933714427053928, 0.03227351978421211, 0.004937149118632078, 0.032922353595495224, 0.0007656833040527999, 0.0380876250565052, 0.001952780527062714, 0.07092801481485367, 0.03385200724005699, -0.041906218975782394, -0.009220823645591736, -0.04612552374601364, 0.02763221226632595, -0.04898364096879959, 0.02333415113389492, 0.009209718555212021, -0.008313512429594994, 0.04444059357047081, 0.011979429051280022, -0.038827795535326004, 0.007151060272008181, 0.04756142571568489, -0.005613809917122126, -0.017507633194327354, -0.02464284561574459, 0.036208830773830414, -0.019574765115976334, -0.009342513047158718, 0.03962203487753868, -0.02245945669710636, -0.007302836515009403, -0.018210820853710175, 0.020287277176976204, -0.009383088909089565, -0.003123418428003788, -0.009689254686236382, 0.05482922121882439, 0.002369956811890006, 0.0067955744452774525, -0.03756404295563698, 0.04579663649201393, 0.06015026569366455, 0.010611017234623432, 0.015433080494403839, -0.023603202775120735, -0.04875098168849945, -0.012835146859288216, 0.02287858910858631, 0.03259875625371933, -0.01854609325528145, -0.014944654889404774, -0.04097815230488777, 0.0072541083209216595, 0.046173591166734695, 0.0032015801407396793, 0.04055199772119522, 0.013734942302107811, 0.00923120602965355, -0.002050291746854782, -0.017885934561491013, -0.035207316279411316, 0.004832321312278509, -0.058228179812431335, 0.05223310366272926, -0.012112272903323174, -0.022258145734667778, -0.006375967990607023, 0.0071780867874622345, 0.011232955381274223, 0.0537148155272007, -0.013384006917476654, -0.020939035341143608, 0.0032743585761636496, 0.019027085974812508, -0.011115998961031437, -0.09538362175226212, 0.021176766604185104, -0.009462904185056686, 0.00915093719959259, 0.07703270763158798, 0.0076937866397202015, -0.03483069688081741, 0.043836139142513275, 0.020197588950395584, 0.03132645785808563, 0.052428457885980606, -0.010226564481854439, 0.07232940942049026, 0.047216784209012985, 0.01955926977097988, 0.045750562101602554, 0.01071818545460701, 0.029363855719566345, -0.003912923391908407, -0.019658129662275314, 0.033496029675006866, -0.01080331765115261, -0.0021400453988462687, -0.03145359456539154, 0.01942209154367447, -0.01153353787958622, 0.06620768457651138, -0.011671023443341255, 0.019313333556056023, -0.011339399963617325, -0.02465076744556427, 0.023745229467749596, 0.015822524204850197, 0.008354369550943375, -0.017538083717226982, 0.014469892717897892, 0.025934480130672455, 0.039060551673173904, 0.0140090212225914, 0.021800579503178596, -0.03721771016716957, 0.019930165261030197, -0.001768584712408483, 0.006444093305617571, 0.014241513796150684, -0.005973903927952051, -0.04351487010717392, 0.020324580371379852, -0.028346572071313858, 0.02669246308505535, 0.0006748802261427045, 0.03379260003566742, -0.01531923282891512, -0.019823407754302025, -0.0060446662828326225, -0.03261799365282059, 0.01863539032638073, 0.03274421766400337, -0.031465284526348114, -0.006221185438334942, -0.029824087396264076, 0.020030329003930092, -0.11673077195882797, 0.009547557681798935, 0.008940289728343487, -0.011250928975641727, -0.03842403367161751, -0.04600725695490837, 0.028094617649912834, -0.015086659230291843, -0.05165917053818703, 0.020607857033610344, 0.056776415556669235, 0.008723913691937923, -0.034314025193452835, -0.035329483449459076, 0.05225062742829323, 0.02588639035820961, -0.027127820998430252, 0.012383181601762772, -0.008812961168587208, -0.015497017651796341, 0.029696384444832802, 0.0007683253497816622, 0.03924662247300148, -0.01730937324464321, 0.009291954338550568, -0.03597383573651314, -0.04233365133404732, 0.020201798528432846, -0.03795669227838516, -0.007819365710020065, -0.010780500248074532, 0.0032894087489694357, -0.013845250010490417, -0.013363583944737911, -0.02592081017792225, -0.018518051132559776, -0.024166272953152657, 0.003458192106336355, -0.016751784831285477, 0.006033998914062977, -0.006033407989889383, 0.023472420871257782, -0.00014188802742864937, 0.0053830016404390335, 0.008339240215718746, 0.07499799877405167, -0.019333194941282272, -0.004124073777347803, -0.01267708744853735, 0.003397255437448621, 0.01283944770693779, -0.0007454297738149762, -0.03898807615041733, 0.010327832773327827, 0.00045911403140053153, -0.012573104351758957, -0.05072839558124542, -0.06274197995662689, 0.06314880400896072, 0.061111193150281906, -0.004371962044388056, 0.0447731651365757, 0.019261283800005913, 0.021796606481075287, -0.018611468374729156, -0.023126870393753052, -0.030941089615225792, 0.02902415208518505, -0.019611669704318047, 0.05484919995069504, 0.028293875977396965, -0.020221978425979614, 0.05216832086443901, 0.03703756257891655, -0.007446926552802324, 0.0378996916115284, 0.04673917591571808, 0.03581942617893219, 0.027956176549196243, 0.0025481677148491144, -0.012422384694218636, 0.012479507364332676, -0.036576155573129654, -0.0027807645965367556, -0.02570122666656971, -0.013455452397465706, 0.024758238345384598, 0.07436708360910416, -0.019428502768278122, -0.02690569870173931, -0.017458772286772728, -0.05156828835606575, 0.023638131096959114, 0.03815288469195366, 0.005887633189558983, 0.054880015552043915, 0.015719007700681686, 0.010664936155080795, -0.02939870022237301, 0.009324753656983376, 0.025452744215726852, -0.03943321108818054, -0.012414642609655857, -0.019911006093025208, -0.059004053473472595, -0.032069094479084015, -0.0021465483587235212, -0.0009126572986133397, 0.042665351182222366, -0.01971430890262127, 0.031601324677467346, -0.006530954968184233, 0.00763006741181016, -0.029111819341778755, 0.09962078928947449, 0.002540891058743, 0.03682883456349373, -0.010548786260187626, -0.007485516835004091, 0.10546335577964783, 0.05318140611052513, 0.03831370174884796, -0.07450547069311142, -0.012389354407787323, -0.029803069308400154, -0.0458507239818573, -0.057358577847480774, 0.033656131476163864, 0.03846627101302147, -0.007757205981761217, 0.016076410189270973, 0.04663747549057007, 0.04656916856765747, -0.02519899047911167, 0.024818113073706627, -0.046189140528440475, -0.030397731810808182, 0.019969278946518898, -0.0034951483830809593, -0.056554488837718964, -0.03565509244799614, -0.05807241424918175, 0.02607150934636593, 0.018177570775151253, 0.006487666163593531, -0.041442375630140305, -0.022438909858465195, 0.007536103017628193, 0.0047287181951105595, 0.008503079414367676, -0.015149434097111225, -0.007599520962685347, 0.0025422796607017517, 0.025155678391456604, 0.0077124061062932014, 0.04702356085181236, -0.027834303677082062, 0.03216533735394478, 0.05049251392483711, -0.005026326514780521, 0.001069475430995226, -0.016813935711979866, -0.022381877526640892, -0.023373480886220932, -0.05237016826868057, -0.047104474157094955, 0.06585250049829483, -0.015188338235020638, 0.018866198137402534, -0.004596276208758354, 0.030145788565278053, 0.011304224841296673, -0.06776440143585205, 0.017733663320541382, 0.014185132458806038, 0.04895802214741707, -0.015820961445569992, -0.007768753916025162, 0.007479450665414333, 0.04594898968935013, 0.018162664026021957, 0.03360789269208908, 0.01790299452841282, -0.02663514018058777, -0.01909857615828514, 0.016527138650417328, 0.05805623531341553, -0.01456440519541502, -0.0069064488634467125, -0.03925073519349098, -0.038739077746868134, -0.026484806090593338, -0.05171065032482147, -0.017874768003821373, -0.006523406133055687, -0.016209879890084267, -0.024888234212994576, -0.02003263123333454, -0.017653418704867363, -0.06528797745704651, 0.02108635939657688, -0.04426063969731331, -0.00043143975199200213, -0.028371714055538177, -0.0059979744255542755, 0.022812141105532646, 0.03454125300049782, -0.008867247961461544, -0.009802218526601791, -0.00279632699675858, 0.07016216218471527, 0.0008265053038485348, -0.016240455210208893, -0.05422733724117279, 0.01167104858905077, -0.02576541341841221, 0.03130010887980461, -0.016047928482294083, 0.04154496267437935, -0.016023430973291397, 0.036642223596572876, -0.0015952523099258542, 0.04620344564318657, -0.016304276883602142, 0.008577915839850903, -0.011318803764879704, -0.05309412628412247, 0.022339584305882454, 0.005297139752656221, -0.008350527845323086, -0.016608906909823418, -0.004700723569840193, 0.006058818660676479, -0.01320805586874485, -0.0013150771846994758, -0.01863127574324608, -0.04120878130197525, -0.057638056576251984, 0.009083396755158901, -0.0035196261014789343, 0.043423864990472794, 0.006529494188725948, -0.012038081884384155, 0.009855495765805244, -0.011279052123427391, 0.0036560487933456898, -0.045837633311748505, -0.0019383978797122836, -0.0314984992146492, -0.030473079532384872, 0.028888670727610588, 0.019247623160481453, 0.00007834722782718018, 0.002138665411621332, -0.01037708017975092, -0.015519845299422741, 0.03852175176143646, -0.014933381229639053, -0.016422336921095848, 0.04380993917584419, -0.03579162061214447, -0.04055391624569893, 0.023920388892292976, 0.03563231602311134, 0.044392772018909454, -0.0012341660913079977, 0.03709600493311882, -0.03582717850804329, 0.04855513200163841, -0.007118362467736006, -0.02949138544499874, 0.015119178220629692, -0.04407370835542679, -0.03580417484045029, -0.007613786030560732, 0.005413006525486708, 0.010449361056089401, 0.02214624732732773, 0.031059645116329193, 0.022214967757463455, -0.035120442509651184, 0.015652751550078392, 0.06719490140676498, -0.011160883121192455, 0.04317157343029976, 0.006065004505217075, -0.023949334397912025, 0.008670789189636707, 0.07170065492391586, -0.019604943692684174, 0.006609281059354544, -0.04499126225709915, 0.02400277741253376, -0.09048076719045639, -0.006159211043268442, 0.04082394391298294, 0.003321039956063032, 0.06335047632455826, -0.0770818442106247, 0.0032199902925640345, 0.022944672033190727, -0.029342256486415863, -0.0036438426468521357, 0.018558766692876816, 0.009537865407764912, -0.011116264387965202, 0.036334481090307236, 0.0038852200377732515, 0.01811143010854721, 0.014843638055026531, 0.030690062791109085, 0.06644781678915024, 0.005483912769705057, 0.0060175200924277306, -0.019263722002506256, -0.021017974242568016, 0.007654239889234304, 0.01906530000269413, -0.0326572060585022, 0.09450139850378036, -0.05691571533679962, -0.0431024394929409, 0.03761661797761917, 0.0010269948979839683, 0.0004719396820291877, -0.006692604161798954, 0.04635070636868477, 0.0004504562821239233, 0.03769998252391815, 0.015142172574996948, -0.0068129366263747215, 0.04681580141186714, -0.014764513820409775, 0.010160083882510662, -0.01858273148536682, -0.026535972952842712, 0.02147560752928257, 0.005421941634267569, -0.0012060112785547972, -0.0074061062186956406, 0.035237137228250504, 0.008485415950417519, -0.040121499449014664, 0.023302119225263596, -0.04107999429106712, 0.012367833405733109, -0.022150954231619835, 0.046704065054655075, -0.052115943282842636, 0.01352809276431799, 0.03128533810377121, 0.04363173246383667, 0.015420503914356232, 0.012786935083568096, -0.04082094505429268, -0.08299894630908966, 0.012081041000783443, -0.005117746070027351, -0.04029072821140289, -0.05747143551707268, -0.030562177300453186, -0.03385638818144798, -0.00876773800700903, 0.02390669845044613, -0.029567215591669083, -0.039848338812589645, 0.0031254966743290424, -0.019630778580904007, 0.03337481617927551, 0.01710849069058895, -0.021643754094839096, -0.003760320832952857, -0.0608045719563961, 0.04417724907398224, 0.013532532379031181, -0.05550001189112663, -0.004478516057133675, 0.02830183133482933, 0.002617893274873495, -0.0017885759007185698, 0.025852330029010773, 0.02646254189312458, -0.02297919988632202, -0.00780223123729229, -0.004703063517808914, 0.01790792867541313, -0.07720047980546951, 0.010314138606190681, -0.01589183323085308, 0.00784716010093689, -0.029572132974863052, 0.03460806608200073, 0.03524719923734665, -0.0003289118758402765, 0.0021228212863206863, 0.031017092987895012, 0.0010419812751933932, 0.015656715258955956, -0.0194131787866354, 0.003939209971576929, -0.02262098900973797, -0.021689243614673615, 0.018428685143589973, -0.010672859847545624, 0.02363615296781063, -0.011175836436450481, 0.0006213563028723001, -0.017942853271961212, 0.028357144445180893, -0.0019851992838084698, -0.032511305063962936, -0.0007883963407948613, -0.015700433403253555, 0.019504152238368988, -0.06854710727930069, -0.05091991275548935, 0.003029347863048315, -0.04727877676486969, -0.02283717691898346, 0.021127304062247276, 0.04232315719127655, 0.04108039289712906, 0.003390413708984852, 0.020991168916225433, -0.006740179378539324, 0.008122621104121208, 0.012729255482554436, 0.0031366627663373947, 0.005745673552155495, 0.0045329309068620205, 0.011701828800141811, 0.020675484091043472, -0.038322195410728455, 0.01641571894288063, -0.005162903107702732, -0.0201020035892725, -0.015974048525094986, -0.01175179984420538, -0.007444447837769985, -0.010247724130749702, 0.009314464405179024, 0.01765589974820614, -0.00995699968189001, 0.06398610770702362, 0.0013087831903249025, 0.0019096361938863993, -0.028298668563365936, -0.03247949481010437, -0.018191561102867126, 0.018005117774009705, 0.03026082180440426, 0.04063788056373596, -0.014394386671483517, -0.010074727237224579, 0.016801543533802032, -0.02515965886414051, 0.013247670605778694, -0.016590196639299393, 0.0259874165058136, -0.02010081335902214, -0.01833784393966198, -0.004951905459165573, -0.02852771431207657, -0.0014336509630084038, -0.01877162605524063, -0.005926721263676882, 0.013969856314361095, 0.038600943982601166, -0.021814173087477684, -0.015287782996892929, -0.01596894860267639, 0.05291224643588066, -0.07784463465213776, -0.022346820682287216, -0.034032147377729416, 0.008428099565207958, 0.01734231226146221, -0.025227831676602364 ]
<p>I know that linear regression can be thought as <em>"the line that is vertically closest to all the points"</em>:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IXibx.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>But there is another way to see it, by visualizing the column space, as <em>"the projection at the space spanned by the columns of the coefficient matrix"</em>: </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/txk3G.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>My question is: in these two interpretations, what happens when we use the penalized linear regression, like <strong>ridge regression</strong> and <strong>LASSO</strong>? What happens with the line in the first interpretation? And what happens with the projection in the second interpretation?</p> <p><strong>UPDATE:</strong> @JohnSmith in the comments brought up the fact that the penalty occurs in the space of the coefficients. Can we come up with an interpretation in this space also?</p>
74,188
[ -0.03228175640106201, 0.0185711532831192, -0.0040326714515686035, -0.030825629830360413, 0.017249317839741707, 0.0354795977473259, 0.004044829402118921, -0.018270814791321754, 0.03952356055378914, -0.040118541568517685, 0.026406552642583847, 0.04198867082595825, 0.06587959825992584, 0.007474020589143038, 0.009509432129561901, 0.02289532870054245, -0.03321131691336632, -0.002364420099183917, -0.01796560361981392, 0.037993185222148895, 0.03182343766093254, 0.01226959377527237, -0.014020372182130814, 0.012269456870853901, -0.027403054758906364, 0.055116429924964905, 0.03313105180859566, 0.010182524099946022, 0.0022488445974886417, 0.040661733597517014, -0.008020997047424316, -0.01480040792375803, -0.016971195116639137, 0.011027947068214417, 0.009323667734861374, -0.007331955712288618, 0.001312356791459024, -0.03281198814511299, 0.004292459227144718, 0.06944789737462997, 0.020318368449807167, -0.057279203087091446, 0.006838917266577482, 0.0760880634188652, -0.033346641808748245, 0.03040221892297268, -0.006959571503102779, -0.015060266479849815, 0.03086087666451931, -0.02698633074760437, 0.06772375106811523, 0.009652524255216122, 0.04394746199250221, 0.052934661507606506, -0.04374029114842415, 0.009237582795321941, 0.049998559057712555, 0.04818136245012283, -0.0032431113068014383, -0.060462020337581635, -0.01778172329068184, -0.025057202205061913, 0.00292002665810287, -0.0034793338272720575, -0.03493468463420868, 0.008560442365705967, -0.01971476525068283, -0.02503623627126217, 0.025886164978146553, 0.0009302328107878566, -0.02963142842054367, 0.04234013706445694, 0.03255906701087952, -0.015950653702020645, 0.031187547370791435, -0.004103035666048527, -0.00010234048386337236, 0.024438614025712013, 0.06075063720345497, -0.004114877432584763, 0.05049055069684982, 0.03415895625948906, 0.03360646963119507, 0.046462565660476685, -0.006324396003037691, 0.018958231434226036, 0.06054128333926201, -0.030597757548093796, 0.045302461832761765, 0.03542434796690941, -0.008499616757035255, 0.019424812868237495, 0.0040955194272100925, 0.00535028288140893, -0.014049571938812733, 0.011793903075158596, -0.005909574683755636, 0.017535269260406494, 0.028845777735114098, 0.0016220881370827556, 0.005172619596123695, 0.001448981580324471, -0.03188558295369148, 0.02097264863550663, -0.009917140007019043, -0.002565757604315877, -0.019013799726963043, 0.025414694100618362, -0.014644209295511246, -0.03456134349107742, -0.05562945082783699, 0.02133563533425331, -0.001962937880307436, 0.0003063821350224316, 0.022643355652689934, -0.037794627249240875, 0.014407424256205559, -0.0021315659396350384, 0.05261147767305374, 0.08437131345272064, 0.031602319329977036, -0.025581831112504005, 0.03662089258432388, -0.007758606690913439, -0.06148522347211838, 0.031504519283771515, 0.02381483092904091, -0.01497997622936964, -0.05354921147227287, 0.04288413003087044, -0.012108871713280678, -0.004547493997961283, 0.019796617329120636, 0.011227579787373543, 0.011717618443071842, 0.0037286891601979733, -0.09540226310491562, -0.04697490483522415, 0.06348167359828949, 0.01668497361242771, -0.0069853514432907104, -0.03307276964187622, -0.016826875507831573, 0.04241861030459404, 0.07779411226511002, -0.0004602220142260194, 0.011631659232079983, -0.0008573997765779495, 0.006402068305760622, 0.00525241531431675, -0.015734242275357246, 0.007521591614931822, -0.043030884116888046, -0.038317468017339706, 0.0050760009326040745, -0.05836956202983856, -0.008060852065682411, 0.03877026215195656, 0.0013568381546065211, -0.010636094957590103, 0.06956392526626587, -0.0032018586061894894, -0.021010328084230423, 0.00530138099566102, -0.03533364459872246, -0.021682608872652054, 0.06764202564954758, 0.03219511732459068, 0.03069997951388359, 0.04394098371267319, -0.01179089117795229, 0.03605925664305687, 0.003065815195441246, 0.052847545593976974, 0.030083803460001945, -0.0263734869658947, -0.0019393465481698513, -0.019489239901304245, 0.01951408199965954, -0.0039611030369997025, -0.09308625757694244, -0.048858076333999634, -0.008317203260958195, -0.0064529068768024445, 0.025224316865205765, 0.06159841641783714, -0.0478493757545948, -0.0511472225189209, 0.02619972825050354, -0.029361793771386147, -0.058467015624046326, -0.07343605905771255, 0.01676265150308609, 0.01414033118635416, -0.03128845617175102, 0.025367144495248795, 0.01462618075311184, 0.008411575108766556, -0.03951708599925041, -0.02078660950064659, -0.004773125518113375, 0.0014973989455029368, 0.0011088083265349269, -0.01923217438161373, -0.009814983233809471, 0.048269711434841156, 0.020490149036049843, 0.0005450400058180094, 0.022913629189133644, -0.05191934481263161, -0.02932869829237461, 0.033070337027311325, -0.023611582815647125, 0.019325099885463715, 0.0003957506560254842, 0.005403266288340092, -0.009379531256854534, -0.029937725514173508, -0.01420209277421236, 0.015656525269150734, -0.06158852577209473, 0.05137130618095398, 0.06835238635540009, 0.016440868377685547, 0.012834866531193256, -0.006646258756518364, -0.026176072657108307, -0.0020350138656795025, -0.03193213790655136, -0.015369637869298458, -0.009493277408182621, -0.015374530106782913, 0.0187386441975832, 0.049717068672180176, -0.021291477605700493, -0.01645551808178425, 0.04473797231912613, 0.02129199355840683, 0.002724020043388009, 0.019218245521187782, -0.003960520029067993, -0.015588388778269291, -0.023591643199324608, -0.00993531383574009, -0.0070248618721961975, 0.005985596217215061, -0.04279593750834465, 0.008142596110701561, 0.025592049583792686, 0.00795266404747963, -0.012516614980995655, 0.05586231127381325, -0.039118923246860504, 0.021791763603687286, -0.021144166588783264, -0.015444292686879635, 0.027205394580960274, -0.03963225334882736, 0.03109637275338173, 0.027997279539704323, -0.004140534438192844, -0.0007337115821428597, -0.024305693805217743, 0.0075091891922056675, 0.012120496481657028, 0.029930099844932556, -0.009615551680326462, 0.02673567831516266, 0.022510657086968422, -0.04616714268922806, 0.032601356506347656, -0.029853153973817825, 0.0008919188403524458, -0.008588569238781929, -0.005702608730643988, 0.05184158682823181, -0.002258274471387267, -0.011594554409384727, -0.019803179427981377, -0.02540583349764347, 0.002268964657559991, -0.04017305374145508, 0.05977728217840195, 0.02112690359354019, -0.036867182701826096, -0.007433239370584488, -0.0960145965218544, -0.004249435383826494, 0.04819251596927643, 0.014407271519303322, -0.010617295280098915, 0.0019090235000476241, -0.029579738155007362, -0.06470290571451187, -0.07125899195671082, -0.019596457481384277, 0.02517296001315117, -0.012142014689743519, -0.016251130029559135, 0.0708790123462677, -0.015747828409075737, -0.04996129497885704, 0.009261054918169975, -0.01824156939983368, -0.0023731987457722425, -0.05341894552111626, -0.0030686217360198498, 0.02348441630601883, 0.029293296858668327, 0.02558073401451111, 0.04662822186946869, -0.03109743446111679, -0.006155060604214668, -0.08485013246536255, -0.023889359086751938, 0.03561914339661598, -0.01119325216859579, -0.00111386738717556, -0.021906457841396332, -0.03663267940282822, 0.08427412062883377, 0.02034398913383484, -0.01391544844955206, -0.07012965530157089, -0.004017014522105455, -0.05392204597592354, -0.03327910602092743, 0.015166474506258965, -0.011786448769271374, 0.016737716272473335, 0.051570866256952286, -0.021824751049280167, 0.04750392958521843, 0.05945539474487305, 0.007228652946650982, 0.013003673404455185, 0.00452451454475522, -0.021443504840135574, 0.00373590225353837, 0.012460893951356411, 0.003685408504679799, 0.0007613365305587649, -0.012385022826492786, -0.016643421724438667, 0.02357681281864643, 0.007837117649614811, -0.04200223833322525, -0.009840955026447773, -0.007423719856888056, 0.02788270078599453, -0.024243969470262527, 0.020427413284778595, 0.00880589708685875, -0.010304026305675507, 0.004191108979284763, 0.019954612478613853, 0.025207849219441414, -0.030033476650714874, 0.01345174852758646, 0.020342538133263588, 0.04277550429105759, -0.005806873086839914, -0.0053414166904985905, 0.010195741429924965, 0.0029134529177099466, 0.013006475754082203, -0.03516149893403053, -0.03044898621737957, 0.02257537841796875, 0.024207226932048798, -0.020594781264662743, -0.0012079832376912236, -0.0706128254532814, 0.021769387647509575, -0.03590334579348564, -0.012562179937958717, 0.016426317393779755, 0.03742041438817978, -0.0053550321608781815, 0.03625141829252243, 0.010303808376193047, 0.02330796606838703, 0.03929947689175606, 0.012326790951192379, -0.05553358048200607, -0.028821714222431183, 0.004810249898582697, -0.003962367307394743, 0.003640159033238888, -0.019128695130348206, 0.02701691724359989, -0.03554253652691841, -0.0070436629466712475, 0.00853443518280983, 0.03967665880918503, -0.0673023909330368, 0.012436766177415848, -0.00781430583447218, -0.02032318338751793, -0.03484952077269554, -0.01813281886279583, 0.035532765090465546, -0.022417349740862846, 0.01392591092735529, 0.05144936591386795, -0.03502490371465683, 0.0009378039976581931, -0.008934488520026207, 0.011527006514370441, 0.0769684836268425, 0.03230792284011841, 0.03795238211750984, -0.004739117808640003, -0.01855107955634594, 0.012636384926736355, -0.006943114567548037, 0.036060236394405365, 0.022036226466298103, -0.022987086325883865, 0.0042211757972836494, -0.04292875528335571, -0.02555978298187256, -0.02713833563029766, 0.020875785499811172, 0.00656908517703414, 0.014277301728725433, 0.035643454641103745, 0.05503809079527855, -0.04118460789322853, 0.0391344279050827, 0.033516641706228256, 0.045539580285549164, -0.020602231845259666, -0.022076230496168137, -0.016460679471492767, -0.001741143874824047, -0.00031138796475715935, 0.07144703716039658, -0.03781023249030113, 0.0015729567967355251, -0.006383143365383148, 0.04729623720049858, -0.035929255187511444, -0.0341344028711319, 0.004208787344396114, -0.009620723314583302, 0.02067948877811432, -0.012141551822423935, -0.02301856130361557, 0.022995535284280777, 0.03697943314909935, 0.028380125761032104, 0.05504221469163895, 0.008525918237864971, -0.0828586220741272, -0.03834231570363045, 0.0068178316578269005, 0.006233084946870804, -0.012600540183484554, -0.02809484302997589, -0.035115499049425125, -0.02382812649011612, 0.05679849162697792, -0.007915593683719635, 0.031161919236183167, 0.0023360897321254015, 0.01061395462602377, -0.03682767599821091, -0.011282418854534626, -0.032953787595033646, 0.010000010021030903, 0.006965196691453457, 0.06610984355211258, -0.004616182763129473, -0.027303680777549744, -0.055294618010520935, 0.027959121391177177, -0.013158655725419521, 0.04245363548398018, 0.009664013981819153, -0.004119296092540026, -0.02097809873521328, 0.04721434414386749, -0.01163181010633707, -0.06894420832395554, 0.013703346252441406, 0.03595335781574249, -0.034707121551036835, 0.09013797342777252, -0.02459104359149933, -0.04790962487459183, 0.007602154277265072, 0.032786380499601364, -0.02421466074883938, 0.005259805358946323, -0.015592921525239944, 0.025420216843485832, 0.04004029557108879, 0.01450610626488924, 0.06600029766559601, -0.00399054354056716, 0.010690459981560707, 0.006619567517191172, -0.03806829825043678, 0.03209879994392395, -0.014045808464288712, -0.049060940742492676, -0.06058843433856964, -0.030847027897834778, -0.008917518891394138, 0.01966990903019905, 0.02308247797191143, 0.00981177855283022, -0.03199813514947891, -0.05003567039966583, -0.010623065754771233, 0.025260109454393387, -0.007860432378947735, -0.019957823678851128, 0.009081531316041946, 0.04102138802409172, 0.03207864984869957, -0.03565302491188049, -0.006886883173137903, -0.024385204538702965, 0.02491704933345318, 0.014298719353973866, -0.03913173824548721, 0.006594195030629635, 0.02152916043996811, 0.0013535767793655396, 0.022521834820508957, -0.026246841996908188, 0.029074644669890404, -0.013981861062347889, 0.028500758111476898, -0.038132861256599426, -0.05031256750226021, -0.034569039940834045, 0.007039173040539026, -0.048052433878183365, -0.0014613829553127289, -0.01282520778477192, 0.031496524810791016, -0.004944689106196165, -0.014238575473427773, -0.0580892376601696, -0.06303790956735611, -0.002577367704361677, 0.03184976428747177, -0.03778373450040817, -0.008805552497506142, -0.01610744744539261, -0.016314616426825523, -0.057240478694438934, 0.03322833776473999, 0.03593286871910095, -0.040842801332473755, -0.03941616415977478, 0.0077207074500620365, -0.009468221105635166, 0.062020353972911835, 0.0052872877568006516, 0.012212974950671196, 0.013453226536512375, 0.003367133205756545, 0.011559302918612957, -0.025957586243748665, 0.017540045082569122, -0.018774280324578285, -0.02709982916712761, -0.07948341965675354, -0.0188759695738554, 0.011579356156289577, -0.002770055318251252, 0.009307026863098145, 0.01896894909441471, 0.012087654322385788, 0.02233698032796383, -0.023169370368123055, -0.023564418777823448, -0.00777182262390852, 0.012514940463006496, 0.0208590105175972, -0.00479933712631464, 0.02772599086165428, 0.004779005888849497, 0.04645242542028427, 0.023506587371230125, -0.0349138118326664, 0.010614016093313694, 0.03398613631725311, -0.0401998832821846, 0.02400211989879608, -0.005988691002130508, -0.008448326960206032, 0.061621226370334625, 0.023489175364375114, 0.017497025430202484, 0.03131759911775589, 0.03432995080947876, -0.06179114431142807, -0.046147096902132034, -0.0592743344604969, 0.046293459832668304, 0.03380380570888519, -0.032928694039583206, 0.04905286431312561, 0.04821726307272911, -0.043581582605838776, -0.008802797645330429, -0.053778912872076035, -0.002279462292790413, -0.005812854040414095, -0.028631988912820816, 0.04015998914837837, -0.027227625250816345, 0.0041153086349368095, 0.0701359361410141, 0.017881998792290688, -0.03155049681663513, 0.0058962320908904076, 0.0013604197883978486, 0.023975534364581108, 0.040473904460668564, 0.004632028751075268, -0.05275607854127884, 0.023088939487934113, -0.02750513143837452, -0.012831459753215313, 0.008581975474953651, 0.005270273890346289, 0.03981130197644234, 0.046658582985401154, 0.017530407756567, -0.04668348282575607, -0.013981974683701992, -0.05809100717306137, 0.016848986968398094, -0.000937039265409112, 0.009526997804641724, 0.027504771947860718, -0.017723137512803078, 0.03224024549126625, -0.03227100893855095, 0.01854534074664116, -0.013318507932126522, -0.05461350083351135, -0.042610205709934235, -0.0012257705675438046, 0.010339049622416496, 0.023795945569872856, 0.01845671236515045, -0.04013378173112869, 0.007238611578941345, -0.05732008442282677, -0.02299964614212513, 0.0469006784260273, 0.05013752728700638, -0.0037708920426666737, 0.07192973047494888, -0.0078212795779109, 0.0030179310124367476, 0.001844866550527513, -0.03982425853610039, 0.11399009078741074, 0.09636524319648743, 0.0218866728246212, -0.0917656421661377, 0.013745293952524662, 0.00021436804672703147, -0.012525398284196854, -0.006896234583109617, -0.013895542360842228, 0.0023050785530358553, 0.023169774562120438, 0.028097957372665405, 0.04115061089396477, 0.012177446857094765, -0.00589870847761631, 0.033291637897491455, -0.052122458815574646, 0.01104394905269146, 0.01788640022277832, -0.009750517085194588, 0.005075063556432724, 0.009924310259521008, -0.0588969923555851, 0.007145226001739502, -0.0024740600492805243, -0.01457514613866806, -0.021590780466794968, 0.013817984610795975, 0.014606539160013199, -0.03817889094352722, -0.028497818857431412, -0.015836864709854126, 0.02905336394906044, -0.013752533122897148, -0.01180222537368536, 0.026341261342167854, 0.02323288656771183, -0.0006252439925447106, -0.015984782949090004, 0.0028141429647803307, -0.014378800988197327, 0.013992361724376678, 0.0035253569949418306, 0.014044668525457382, -0.02080187201499939, -0.02594488486647606, -0.02518569305539131, 0.05898810178041458, -0.011532144621014595, -0.02323681116104126, -0.0034990431740880013, 0.029309310019016266, 0.013682304881513119, -0.05115552619099617, 0.004830017685890198, 0.011464725248515606, 0.03348083794116974, 0.008212857879698277, -0.003420585533604026, 0.002086714608594775, 0.0088774049654603, -0.002007200149819255, 0.01164910476654768, 0.041562508791685104, 0.003650151425972581, -0.00609313091263175, -0.031177563592791557, 0.039110515266656876, 0.009629668667912483, 0.020043767988681793, -0.036312662065029144, -0.001475922530516982, -0.010211661458015442, -0.021817287430167198, 0.01703706756234169, 0.028244007378816605, 0.007113767322152853, -0.00776860024780035, 0.0025981750804930925, -0.005589279346168041, -0.05692978948354721, 0.03701459616422653, -0.04948596656322479, -0.02336132898926735, -0.04198804870247841, 0.016934150829911232, 0.03044549748301506, 0.062375258654356, 0.002989964559674263, -0.001240366604179144, -0.015271377749741077, 0.05292917415499687, -0.012663080357015133, -0.035456325858831406, -0.029452987015247345, -0.01487693004310131, -0.021775558590888977, -0.02848544530570507, 0.0036323547828942537, 0.09357007592916489, 0.03605670854449272, 0.024524345993995667, -0.00037104537477716804, 0.037715889513492584, -0.000024125163690769114, -0.020793911069631577, 0.01662571169435978, -0.05880225822329521, 0.025476699694991112, 0.020546378567814827, -0.009663485921919346, -0.04394270107150078, 0.025356439873576164, -0.02647535875439644, -0.032345835119485855, 0.005712558981031179, 0.010061897337436676, -0.03459995239973068, 0.0056102280505001545, -0.007277016527950764, 0.05329355224967003, -0.021815400570631027, -0.032748911529779434, -0.05060325190424919, 0.027600934728980064, 0.018193891271948814, -0.05118569731712341, 0.0031235336791723967, -0.01153483334928751, -0.0317966490983963, -0.012800252996385098, 0.007925696671009064, 0.022136718034744263, 0.027390601113438606, -0.013746041804552078, 0.023885395377874374, -0.004776936024427414, 0.05612805858254433, -0.023233629763126373, -0.013557462953031063, 0.012028626166284084, -0.017113197594881058, -0.03661728650331497, 0.01718650758266449, -0.0193573497235775, 0.03626656532287598, 0.02348739095032215, 0.030653197318315506, -0.06620866805315018, 0.04334063455462456, 0.0012479518773034215, 0.01717768982052803, -0.0029587445314973593, -0.008920015767216682, -0.010185620747506618, -0.011960241012275219, 0.018685080111026764, -0.025292610749602318, -0.012404041364789009, -0.03579651564359665, 0.042778488248586655, -0.010292540304362774, -0.002462908858433366, 0.0017935707001015544, -0.02069476805627346, 0.025879479944705963, -0.014789250679314137, -0.025001151487231255, 0.023433927446603775, 0.03113095462322235, -0.03956050053238869, 0.011349749751389027, 0.03879060968756676, 0.03422573208808899, -0.10518883913755417, -0.03006890043616295, 0.003784380154684186, -0.012599279172718525, 0.02684013359248638, -0.05857599526643753, 0.010853291489183903, 0.05953984707593918, -0.04994554445147514, 0.010949638672173023, 0.015362902544438839, 0.036435358226299286, -0.041770484298467636, 0.002417035400867462, -0.0033065525349229574, 0.05329921841621399, 0.030213737860322, 0.034304648637771606, 0.019032543525099754, 0.02946992963552475, -0.0009364233701489866, -0.03453313186764717, -0.03335558995604515, 0.028797494247555733, 0.005813839845359325, -0.040139466524124146, 0.06951505690813065, -0.022266609594225883, -0.012727168388664722, 0.007606594357639551, -0.015477784909307957, 0.01895378716289997, 0.0605948343873024, 0.0005311525892466307, 0.00651652691885829, 0.01621299795806408, 0.014965345151722431, -0.030399387702345848, 0.001718283398076892, -0.008007676340639591, 0.004898610059171915, -0.03432893380522728, 0.00436368677765131, 0.04017011448740959, 0.02779422327876091, -0.040214430540800095, 0.006449256557971239, 0.026486137881875038, 0.00819126982241869, -0.014361939392983913, 0.004346746951341629, -0.019680827856063843, 0.02802273817360401, -0.030795257538557053, 0.024967966601252556, -0.02700413018465042, -0.006422013975679874, 0.026016322895884514, 0.031864017248153687, -0.030978089198470116, 0.006113489158451557, 0.012932108715176582, -0.05630572885274887, 0.0050646355375647545, -0.022252682596445084, -0.015497846528887749, -0.06947759538888931, -0.0004474564047995955, -0.0026793156284838915, -0.04083629325032234, -0.01935735158622265, 0.011132858693599701, -0.05611608177423477, 0.005944711621850729, 0.02630608342587948, 0.022515032440423965, 0.018303658813238144, -0.051289334893226624, 0.008408373221755028, -0.09516685456037521, 0.07294337451457977, 0.0063461801037192345, -0.05214869603514671, -0.021756663918495178, 0.007574731949716806, -0.010573059320449829, -0.0008924433495849371, 0.043452054262161255, 0.005560365971177816, -0.0036228690296411514, -0.010747640393674374, 0.03062007576227188, 0.011702795512974262, -0.024193208664655685, 0.01873207464814186, 0.04665927588939667, -0.02113422378897667, 0.008473405614495277, 0.0014396990882232785, -0.005602315533906221, 0.02508086897432804, 0.01300863828510046, -0.005834265146404505, 0.005042776465415955, 0.0026882262900471687, -0.007247129455208778, 0.03887642174959183, 0.0036259633488953114, -0.006022123619914055, 0.042137160897254944, 0.012281716801226139, -0.0009454155806452036, 0.023061150684952736, -0.026162663474678993, -0.011294263415038586, -0.005595662631094456, -0.031035298481583595, -0.004877923987805843, 0.013998212292790413, 0.005771661642938852, 0.002366978209465742, -0.053978435695171356, -0.02155856415629387, 0.006057505030184984, -0.020460886880755424, -0.039293188601732254, 0.04423895478248596, 0.016304006800055504, 0.016429059207439423, 0.017556866630911827, 0.04531118646264076, 0.024830244481563568, 0.00989120826125145, -0.004419565200805664, 0.004014530219137669, 0.08332661539316177, 0.006656755693256855, 0.03254937753081322, 0.004385681357234716, -0.014057517051696777, 0.019484758377075195, 0.004579530097544193, 0.01995616964995861, -0.07520193606615067, -0.01027153804898262, -0.010634834878146648, -0.008106496185064316, 0.00016397886793129146, -0.03589269891381264, 0.010080721229314804, 0.04727674275636673, -0.034975454211235046, -0.02547493204474449, -0.027724016457796097, 0.01359238475561142, -0.013186401687562466, 0.0123813571408391, -0.01086927205324173, 0.03628217801451683, -0.014630564488470554, 0.005038585513830185, 0.029334070160984993, 0.006900169886648655, 0.04221990332007408, -0.014057168737053871, 0.030382635071873665, -0.0158231183886528, -0.03072788007557392, -0.030898867174983025, -0.041584234684705734, 0.005229966714978218, 0.008260317146778107, 0.04863189905881882, 0.052806608378887177, 0.02111092023551464, -0.009300175122916698, -0.022254912182688713, -0.014368687756359577, 0.02343449555337429, -0.08451665937900543, -0.010336930863559246, -0.029330579563975334, 0.02158794365823269, 0.01084748562425375, -0.008991214446723461 ]
<p>I'm trying to build a model that would describe some process of payment and distribution of payments in time. I believe that time of payment has <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A9vy_distribution" rel="nofollow">Levy distribution</a> with probability density function:</p> <p>$ f(x,c)=\sqrt{\frac{c}{2\pi}}~~\frac{e^{ -\frac{c}{2x}}} {x^{3/2}} $</p> <p>This distribution depends on parameter <em>c</em> which actually defines the shape of distribution. My task is to build model that explains dependency of this parameter on some explaining variables. I'm trying linear dependency $c = \sum_i \beta_i x_i$ </p> <p>This is example of generalized linear model and is implemented in the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/VGAM/index.html" rel="nofollow">VGAM package</a> in R. Problem is that in a sample for building this model I have data only from some period at the beginning and this period is different for different groups of cases. And because of that I can not just to run the model in VGAM package on this data as the result will be incorrect significantly exaggerating probability of early payments.</p> <p>One possible solution I can think about is to change the likelihood function from which parameter is estimated. If we have information only from time up to <em>t</em> and as cumulative distribution function of Levy distribution is:</p> <p>$ F(x,c)=\textrm{erfc}\left(\sqrt{c/2x}\right) $</p> <p>the density of distribution up to time <em>t</em> is $ f_1(x,c,t)= \frac{f(x,c)}{F(t,c)} $ (where $f(x,c), F(t,c)$ defined as above). This new density functions can be used in estimating regression parameters with maximum likelyhood method. But can it be done in R using methods from VGAM package or usual <strong>glm</strong> function or some other packages? Or there are some better approaches to my problem? I'm interested in implementation in R.</p> <p>Thank you in advance for any help!</p>
38,194
[ 0.030832771211862564, -0.0046131545677781105, 0.050884801894426346, -0.015996478497982025, 0.017084170132875443, -0.030739951878786087, -0.009255488403141499, -0.01370394229888916, 0.02603699266910553, -0.05881504341959953, 0.03683494031429291, 0.040572863072156906, 0.046297136694192886, 0.005355224013328552, 0.02647797204554081, 0.003373187268152833, 0.015387559309601784, -0.0051079317927360535, -0.005446471739560366, -0.03445238247513771, 0.012645683251321316, 0.032169099897146225, 0.01186602283269167, 0.002535762032493949, -0.04687802866101265, 0.02828715555369854, 0.022344261407852173, -0.029629765078425407, -0.033794716000556946, 0.07087885588407516, -0.0323634073138237, -0.010850975289940834, -0.025793932378292084, -0.014186615124344826, 0.020760241895914078, 0.03219561651349068, -0.002877105725929141, -0.030911054462194443, 0.036564283072948456, 0.03489069268107414, -0.05600373446941376, 0.020240474492311478, 0.04469902068376541, 0.045674338936805725, 0.025857053697109222, 0.02915063314139843, 0.009685637429356575, -0.04465479031205177, 0.03507617115974426, -0.0026991700287908316, 0.04916710406541824, -0.017373811453580856, -0.007469938136637211, 0.005182140972465277, -0.01867782138288021, -0.041781846433877945, 0.00782890897244215, 0.11040166765451431, 0.018357858061790466, -0.032198868691921234, -0.01583617553114891, -0.013640272431075573, -0.006303511094301939, -0.045444585382938385, -0.027775466442108154, 0.014797513373196125, -0.000392080401070416, -0.02768072858452797, -0.003001619828864932, -0.04974515363574028, 0.03425232693552971, 0.0006405015592463315, 0.006566821131855249, 0.004218444228172302, 0.003676434513181448, 0.010187139734625816, -0.019363900646567345, 0.022136341780424118, -0.0008301069610752165, 0.002594799967482686, 0.00571843795478344, 0.018654968589544296, 0.0005268235108815134, 0.035798270255327225, 0.0026141065172851086, -0.021654604002833366, 0.055408090353012085, -0.027270132675766945, 0.03845658525824547, 0.011648205108940601, -0.05235695466399193, 0.04654461145401001, 0.09871049225330353, 0.0008814028697088361, -0.036994922906160355, 0.02093002200126648, -0.003969209734350443, 0.021846318617463112, 0.014586643315851688, -0.014443975873291492, 0.006002205424010754, -0.08181645721197128, -0.041008882224559784, 0.0604570247232914, -0.01834087446331978, -0.012454862706363201, -0.00819139089435339, -0.013965953141450882, -0.03560978174209595, -0.04770855978131294, -0.011689149774610996, 0.07490653544664383, -0.011239522136747837, 0.002465056022629142, -0.015875468030571938, 0.0027621362823992968, -0.021591607481241226, -0.06366951763629913, 0.04567074030637741, 0.030922669917345047, 0.05165562033653259, -0.008634159341454506, 0.027681129053235054, -0.01559504959732294, -0.043664783239364624, -0.0027016971725970507, 0.021751590073108673, -0.03025921992957592, -0.032011136412620544, 0.036079294979572296, 0.03051816299557686, -0.050965432077646255, 0.032894961535930634, 0.00965760089457035, 0.02840556390583515, 0.0023379286285489798, -0.06849353760480881, -0.0359664149582386, 0.052654117345809937, 0.01023448072373867, 0.04378807544708252, -0.025841007009148598, -0.006151932291686535, 0.02771965228021145, 0.03901226818561554, -0.010838440619409084, 0.055065665394067764, 0.029389163479208946, 0.026166515424847603, 0.016575241461396217, -0.011052188463509083, -0.004008932039141655, -0.03416498750448227, 0.00016607069119345397, 0.015680184587836266, -0.05993352830410004, 0.06759017705917358, 0.03115948662161827, -0.02623116225004196, -0.004509994760155678, 0.05904249846935272, 0.043568115681409836, -0.02170759066939354, -0.01645798049867153, 0.010019381530582905, -0.0020243851467967033, 0.09296528995037079, 0.015881063416600227, 0.00851202942430973, 0.017155371606349945, -0.023381134495139122, 0.033037927001714706, -0.00401142705231905, 0.05394652858376503, 0.04305817931890488, -0.017985964193940163, 0.009330536238849163, -0.020853139460086823, 0.010786890983581543, 0.021410027518868446, -0.02124696783721447, -0.009716984815895557, -0.00263741216622293, -0.030216021463274956, 0.011054705828428268, 0.030761172994971275, 0.004331896081566811, 0.00013559369836002588, 0.01153411716222763, -0.027425650507211685, -0.05462227761745453, -0.036536019295454025, -0.015122069045901299, -0.029648959636688232, -0.03092115931212902, 0.013815893791615963, -0.06341682374477386, 0.0365208238363266, 0.013181566260755062, 0.0035137017257511616, -0.021254604682326317, -0.001722865505144, 0.029384970664978027, -0.028929099440574646, 0.017924390733242035, 0.010751109570264816, 0.050457946956157684, 0.006563353817909956, 0.003486830275505781, -0.03080924041569233, 0.016293875873088837, 0.020658276975154877, -0.044725414365530014, 0.015281202271580696, -0.03277366980910301, -0.007587069645524025, -0.019607383757829666, 0.0315728560090065, 0.018789732828736305, 0.03891441226005554, -0.025874873623251915, 0.0003794139774981886, 0.09491755813360214, -0.001747514819726348, -0.006275656633079052, 0.030112529173493385, -0.023256994783878326, 0.03301791846752167, -0.041868895292282104, -0.039288416504859924, -0.04494021087884903, -0.04379305988550186, 0.03547867760062218, 0.039345864206552505, -0.005173239391297102, -0.021099701523780823, 0.08633898198604584, -0.013022882863879204, 0.010451956652104855, 0.016858158633112907, -0.007475512567907572, -0.02060048095881939, 0.026106834411621094, -0.004734835587441921, 0.012007690966129303, -0.018066223710775375, 0.031209778040647507, 0.023258831351995468, 0.02203981578350067, -0.03305680677294731, 0.013565492816269398, 0.024823790416121483, 0.011399864219129086, -0.015338398516178131, -0.021750150248408318, 0.022024426609277725, 0.041777051985263824, -0.024208901450037956, -0.007891970686614513, 0.01774488389492035, -0.019342806190252304, -0.02705364301800728, 0.00433068023994565, -0.02916068024933338, 0.04406530037522316, 0.05807807669043541, -0.00038850793498568237, 0.010850642807781696, 0.018715746700763702, -0.03398779779672623, -0.027911782264709473, 0.0011631875531747937, -0.07450994104146957, -0.009856068529188633, 0.045253027230501175, 0.03182892128825188, 0.02188889868557453, -0.03830377757549286, -0.028662441298365593, -0.0538286529481411, 0.008584022521972656, 0.014556031674146652, 0.008656076155602932, 0.010665243491530418, -0.03294835612177849, 0.013352718204259872, 0.034932658076286316, -0.013255908153951168, 0.022553037852048874, 0.032406825572252274, 0.0330628864467144, 0.044190797954797745, -0.00849128607660532, -0.04514375701546669, 0.004780784249305725, 0.011850944720208645, 0.0019625278655439615, -0.05471594259142876, -0.02783895656466484, 0.04508614540100098, 0.03362100571393967, -0.011647854931652546, 0.02618778683245182, -0.083724245429039, -0.002977986354380846, 0.0015742710093036294, 0.014100837521255016, 0.009247605688869953, 0.012179290875792503, 0.035517606884241104, 0.001619535032659769, 0.019588829949498177, -0.016236042603850365, -0.06483212858438492, -0.04676808416843414, 0.010215156711637974, -0.009634656831622124, 0.01994161307811737, -0.004141996614634991, -0.013789072632789612, 0.044085387140512466, 0.049454137682914734, 0.019490055739879608, -0.01761581189930439, -0.014172041788697243, -0.012468066066503525, -0.013650355860590935, 0.02709624543786049, -0.0021095031406730413, 0.0015799303073436022, 0.0014358090702444315, -0.03703473135828972, 0.003419813234359026, 0.023333512246608734, -0.006834434345364571, 0.03028831072151661, 0.017449451610445976, 0.012452836148440838, 0.01889178901910782, 0.01897531934082508, 0.02100692130625248, 0.028355872258543968, 0.013998009264469147, -0.014652405865490437, 0.018071677535772324, 0.02504674904048443, -0.05469818413257599, 0.006275571882724762, 0.01745530404150486, -0.03030630573630333, -0.024070683866739273, -0.0025149742141366005, -0.011108746752142906, -0.048843368887901306, 0.014802398160099983, -0.02609189599752426, 0.04744277894496918, -0.0060545895248651505, 0.019557669758796692, 0.023693565279245377, 0.05501379445195198, -0.003898853436112404, -0.013148711994290352, -0.022227272391319275, 0.001697127940133214, 0.05327477306127548, -0.04538040608167648, -0.004231159575283527, 0.01962127722799778, 0.036295995116233826, 0.01903935708105564, -0.007729359436780214, 0.0038048226851969957, 0.008311129175126553, -0.039643242955207825, 0.0019133115420117974, 0.003258161712437868, 0.061332784593105316, 0.0335480272769928, 0.004717452451586723, 0.028201403096318245, -0.045286573469638824, 0.01802651211619377, 0.004745539743453264, -0.12318971008062363, 0.02055814117193222, 0.020905975252389908, 0.01602705754339695, -0.024520955979824066, -0.037920188158750534, 0.0486503504216671, 0.017828933894634247, 0.013460717163980007, 0.0016224903520196676, 0.015076628886163235, -0.03618597239255905, 0.01897520385682583, 0.0024458239786326885, 0.007503055967390537, -0.04467866197228432, 0.01421288587152958, 0.022750074043869972, 0.011593252420425415, 0.031384825706481934, 0.03132137283682823, 0.006480826064944267, -0.002092228503897786, -0.026040049269795418, -0.0025892441626638174, 0.0513584278523922, 0.040648896247148514, -0.012956001795828342, 0.012760859914124012, -0.022129017859697342, 0.027409501373767853, 0.01920814998447895, 0.040322136133909225, 0.0874117761850357, 0.001679186592809856, -0.0092189135029912, -0.0593276172876358, -0.00818806141614914, 0.005093732848763466, 0.029049759730696678, 0.041310373693704605, -0.028533002361655235, 0.05144159123301506, 0.04496529698371887, 0.010419287718832493, 0.015478737652301788, 0.052266720682382584, 0.004888287279754877, 0.0056171114556491375, -0.017162764444947243, 0.000028427495635696687, -0.013582670129835606, -0.013159273192286491, 0.023737188428640366, 0.029717858880758286, 0.01040288619697094, -0.013607628643512726, 0.053690508008003235, 0.007652165833860636, -0.02225898578763008, 0.0008181178127415478, 0.0237746424973011, 0.0379294753074646, 0.0009564582142047584, -0.033972159028053284, 0.014597962610423565, 0.006867334246635437, 0.033721793442964554, 0.011068309657275677, 0.021010207012295723, -0.07558052241802216, -0.014917709864675999, 0.0477067232131958, 0.034573160111904144, -0.027429671958088875, -0.06400883197784424, -0.04361915588378906, -0.012031168676912785, 0.0188338290899992, -0.02408885397017002, 0.0019674513023346663, -0.011427665129303932, 0.008506189100444317, -0.001162787084467709, -0.09138941764831543, -0.07458055764436722, 0.014388557523488998, -0.040626417845487595, -0.013917881064116955, -0.0371696837246418, -0.033086489886045456, 0.009625378996133804, -0.019313670694828033, 0.03037063218653202, 0.04193881154060364, -0.027253486216068268, -0.002660562517121434, 0.02320242114365101, 0.01358757819980383, -0.05119374394416809, -0.054586976766586304, 0.023700939491391182, -0.04412119835615158, 0.04037392511963844, 0.00839269906282425, -0.0016372313257306814, -0.0003126657975371927, 0.027454731985926628, 0.028141094371676445, 0.0040295361541211605, -0.010164717212319374, -0.025586754083633423, 0.028276439756155014, 0.057280510663986206, -0.000919430807698518, 0.10174880176782608, 0.04782606661319733, -0.027651000767946243, 0.019348932430148125, -0.03930993378162384, 0.005123998504132032, -0.01906798779964447, -0.0008275494328700006, -0.06184067204594612, -0.0005011364119127393, -0.0016965543618425727, 0.03164061903953552, -0.01631700061261654, 0.03614967316389084, -0.012342493049800396, 0.014719957485795021, 0.014508096501231194, 0.016708487644791603, -0.0199874434620142, 0.01212352979928255, -0.03331248462200165, -0.0013418688904494047, -0.023621072992682457, 0.0314863845705986, 0.00035663830931298435, -0.04593073949217796, -0.0022062959615141153, -0.004616020247340202, 0.0023577974643558264, -0.002980354242026806, -0.01622915454208851, -0.007731746882200241, 0.004155763424932957, 0.008676856756210327, 0.036400049924850464, 0.01006353460252285, 0.005552608519792557, 0.0016525908140465617, -0.036442384123802185, -0.011747869662940502, 0.03037048690021038, -0.008661900646984577, 0.04976821318268776, -0.008579117245972157, -0.014571067877113819, 0.017815664410591125, -0.01809847541153431, -0.06195073947310448, -0.03335058316588402, 0.029943764209747314, -0.032358407974243164, -0.02132299728691578, -0.04657505452632904, -0.007620175834745169, 0.007847446948289871, 0.011650036089122295, 0.005144752096384764, 0.04549025744199753, 0.035941459238529205, 0.011208310723304749, -0.03281601518392563, 0.03183331713080406, 0.07338689267635345, 0.015917807817459106, -0.019659193232655525, 0.016510775312781334, -0.014740816317498684, -0.017626622691750526, -0.026317687705159187, -0.01630701869726181, -0.030159443616867065, 0.005666755139827728, -0.033903706818819046, 0.009492556564509869, 0.05770348012447357, -0.023158153519034386, -0.05749121680855751, -0.0020445073023438454, 0.027955636382102966, -0.01756858453154564, -0.0340970940887928, -0.024098342284560204, 0.0036251165438443422, -0.009025889448821545, -0.04989944025874138, -0.0069998460821807384, -0.04003650322556496, -0.0457441508769989, 0.013684097677469254, -0.026240205392241478, -0.008168690837919712, 0.031494710594415665, 0.04533221945166588, -0.028225328773260117, 0.002492095110937953, 0.005471984390169382, 0.008452905341982841, 0.022575270384550095, -0.0040216767229139805, -0.0013901276979595423, 0.004392507951706648, -0.002586025046184659, -0.013324754312634468, 0.010905373841524124, -0.07048022747039795, -0.01172610279172659, 0.04722585529088974, 0.012095008045434952, 0.04549434408545494, 0.008028160780668259, -0.014786839485168457, -0.013294419273734093, -0.027268309146165848, -0.04458307847380638, -0.012057686224579811, -0.005503231659531593, 0.0286235474050045, -0.054538946598768234, -0.05710691958665848, 0.04701606184244156, -0.006970884744077921, 0.02749289572238922, 0.047771356999874115, 0.008745541796088219, -0.015125248581171036, 0.006973973475396633, -0.012793623842298985, -0.06323256343603134, 0.03482313081622124, -0.007403072435408831, 0.020440399646759033, -0.06638487428426743, -0.013694771565496922, 0.04309407249093056, 0.02910798415541649, 0.016737595200538635, -0.05413849651813507, -0.030314689502120018, -0.07532711327075958, 0.011678268201649189, 0.05846213921904564, -0.015032948926091194, 0.08310536295175552, 0.02002953737974167, 0.048795778304338455, -0.036438290029764175, 0.04564649239182472, -0.016152307391166687, -0.08980632573366165, -0.011706788092851639, -0.010331179015338421, -0.016534559428691864, 0.03482545539736748, -0.0032925771083682775, -0.011721798218786716, 0.01831216737627983, -0.03031918965280056, 0.035521626472473145, 0.013923592865467072, 0.004178646951913834, -0.0036162850446999073, 0.07687204331159592, -0.03050200827419758, -0.0062411027029156685, -0.07842229306697845, -0.031086446717381477, 0.15483562648296356, 0.02824900858104229, 0.039761073887348175, -0.008092770352959633, 0.0034261727705597878, 0.013132918626070023, -0.015598720870912075, -0.041590362787246704, 0.0061248308047652245, 0.0037510988768190145, -0.04915890097618103, 0.059029385447502136, 0.031930968165397644, -0.035429470241069794, 0.0251165758818388, 0.019730236381292343, -0.026079993695020676, -0.016899636015295982, 0.010897471569478512, 0.0014220034936442971, 0.0015050803776830435, -0.00013756762200500816, -0.04482535272836685, 0.010207113809883595, -0.0029853058513253927, -0.02355039305984974, -0.03712835907936096, -0.01493367925286293, 0.015491076745092869, -0.02752727083861828, -0.026094047352671623, -0.01418210193514824, 0.03353411704301834, 0.021477336063981056, 0.038621146231889725, -0.03138168901205063, 0.015036465600132942, -0.03878775238990784, 0.03110838495194912, 0.012867593206465244, 0.009080431424081326, -0.008443671278655529, 0.007541603874415159, -0.0025560110807418823, -0.07608219981193542, -0.01907910592854023, -0.04893166199326515, 0.03318432718515396, -0.020108221098780632, -0.047809746116399765, -0.004532969556748867, 0.017388688400387764, -0.0030799396336078644, -0.04901372268795967, -0.025409720838069916, 0.04067515954375267, 0.017074668779969215, -0.030689343810081482, -0.0172348041087389, -0.05022918060421944, 0.005265745334327221, -0.011981234885752201, 0.02021108753979206, 0.029535654932260513, -0.0451766662299633, -0.033796876668930054, -0.05741652846336365, 0.04797256365418434, -0.03375077247619629, -0.005195609759539366, 0.03309096023440361, -0.019377024844288826, -0.004391164518892765, -0.016239391639828682, -0.018590867519378662, 0.007349664811044931, 0.018202153965830803, -0.04468221217393875, -0.0013638841919600964, -0.02823185734450817, -0.018272990360856056, -0.02486293949186802, 0.006102887447923422, 0.021135907620191574, -0.03904300183057785, 0.026559574529528618, 0.001291667460463941, 0.02594916895031929, 0.012560966424643993, 0.008278957568109035, -0.021787520498037338, 0.032857805490493774, 0.022321682423353195, -0.05303002893924713, -0.004632843658328056, -0.030053116381168365, -0.0238441601395607, 0.0021926681511104107, -0.03588683158159256, 0.03453761711716652, -0.014354965649545193, -0.01591886579990387, -0.012687326408922672, 0.035034939646720886, -0.00879176240414381, -0.01301527302712202, 0.0677592009305954, -0.022759029641747475, 0.03164923936128616, 0.0009343933779746294, 0.043519601225852966, 0.000503187533468008, -0.004023097455501556, 0.00952534843236208, -0.05635100230574608, -0.0028179495129734278, -0.011889753863215446, -0.03357061743736267, 0.0348343588411808, -0.040092308074235916, -0.014425649307668209, -0.010678920894861221, 0.0037220229860395193, 0.027671651914715767, 0.0012141566257923841, -0.04303368180990219, -0.009697921574115753, 0.010370093397796154, 0.012859968468546867, -0.01838938519358635, -0.03203587979078293, 0.006095751188695431, 0.015049723908305168, 0.014321365393698215, -0.025195466354489326, 0.05242115259170532, -0.0018005080055445433, 0.03233935683965683, -0.0063914163038134575, -0.003931338433176279, 0.02510860562324524, -0.041263822466135025, -0.03684336319565773, -0.003351889317855239, 0.04465928301215172, 0.01958480104804039, 0.012382812798023224, 0.02068942040205002, 0.010502527467906475, 0.044899214059114456, -0.015386155806481838, 0.0034316868986934423, -0.030385706573724747, 0.01627107337117195, 0.00365833705291152, 0.023025499656796455, -0.014243523590266705, -0.009283353574573994, 0.023401129990816116, 0.028289567679166794, 0.0368478000164032, -0.02106713503599167, -0.03472435846924782, 0.026166021823883057, -0.005232208874076605, -0.005407698918133974, -0.006902089808136225, 0.010264585725963116, 0.05716991424560547, 0.02797214686870575, -0.0032435874454677105, 0.03768650069832802, -0.010284604504704475, -0.018941162154078484, -0.06656752526760101, -0.052474796772003174, 0.023912770673632622, 0.031093470752239227, 0.03619346767663956, -0.001830866327509284, -0.044550854712724686, -0.008107016794383526, -0.015578730031847954, 0.011142362840473652, 0.03243504464626312, 0.026860971003770828, -0.0104006202891469, -0.016792086884379387, -0.050054073333740234, 0.017081383615732193, 0.011135932989418507, 0.017789658159017563, 0.03545447066426277, 0.022702276706695557, 0.021361680701375008, -0.024231713265180588, -0.004253652412444353, 0.010110828094184399, 0.016114970669150352, -0.041692104190588, 0.04793718457221985, -0.034356746822595596, 0.029582805931568146, 0.019688580185174942, 0.003347134916111827, 0.013305401429533958, -0.0025307859759777784, 0.02058831974864006, 0.0439777672290802, 0.053441278636455536, 0.029554281383752823, 0.004680384416133165, 0.00833994708955288, -0.002075752941891551, 0.03408254683017731, 0.021941296756267548, 0.007737663108855486, -0.005322359036654234, 0.019627289846539497, 0.011256841011345387, 0.0014234331902116537, -0.0059406389482319355, -0.021829985082149506, 0.006892488803714514, -0.015838077291846275, -0.011671844869852066, -0.011064669117331505, -0.025505127385258675, 0.025780724361538887, -0.021387189626693726, -0.010947597213089466, 0.03882051631808281, 0.0346960574388504, -0.02675660327076912, -0.0034143647644668818, -0.04011371731758118, -0.056260496377944946, 0.008699540048837662, -0.010500283911824226, -0.013477610424160957, -0.03655301779508591, -0.005554077681154013, -0.03349173814058304, -0.008874515071511269, -0.01084077823907137, 0.009497719816863537, -0.04916234686970711, 0.045788999646902084, -0.03784196823835373, -0.017226919531822205, 0.012085256166756153, 0.013307360000908375, 0.06882078945636749, -0.1039181798696518, 0.060645606368780136, 0.004195183515548706, -0.02380606345832348, 0.024133387953042984, -0.020063234493136406, -0.03773496299982071, 0.023868035525083542, 0.06845394521951675, -0.008382500149309635, -0.003118386957794428, -0.011539780534803867, 0.03275376185774803, 0.022460807114839554, -0.04482778534293175, 0.03083897940814495, -0.0377759225666523, 0.012334640137851238, 0.002396209631115198, 0.011523740366101265, -0.009041811339557171, 0.013402978889644146, -0.0005390295991674066, -0.011536925099790096, 0.03356466814875603, 0.005785088986158371, 0.006817157380282879, 0.017224114388227463, -0.0034777980763465166, -0.047412291169166565, 0.05366106703877449, -0.020961925387382507, -0.013262861408293247, 0.024343743920326233, 0.0065054865553975105, -0.06356308609247208, -0.006469670217484236, -0.05433773621916771, -0.046588752418756485, -0.0015702092787250876, -0.028850335627794266, -0.022046692669391632, -0.06450890749692917, -0.011481733992695808, 0.02829560823738575, -0.006763853132724762, 0.019336270168423653, 0.025264035910367966, -0.01569507271051407, 0.07095861434936523, 0.0074440473690629005, -0.015309561043977737, -0.04510587081313133, -0.027140457183122635, -0.014522489160299301, -0.03687361627817154, 0.028525853529572487, -0.017565468326210976, -0.004537210334092379, 0.03293130546808243, -0.005876973737031221, 0.023126989603042603, -0.036674365401268005, 0.022700242698192596, -0.023637680336833, -0.003885459853336215, 0.023515131324529648, 0.048959292471408844, -0.007688439451158047, -0.0435810461640358, -0.010909385047852993, 0.0745215117931366, -0.008769607171416283, 0.04320508986711502, -0.01605772227048874, -0.020817382261157036, -0.04915977641940117, 0.03424102067947388, 0.008656574413180351, 0.018028924241662025, 0.01200060360133648, 0.013109231367707253, -0.020348910242319107, 0.0026068154256790876, 0.0579364150762558, 0.01528727076947689, -0.02080296352505684, 0.01888527348637581, -0.020742712542414665, 0.023327209055423737, -0.0050886934623122215, -0.020275842398405075, -0.06237811967730522, 0.010630223900079727, 0.024314643815159798, 0.036066003143787384, -0.03191191703081131, 0.004488965030759573, 0.02726677991449833, 0.05813118815422058, -0.049126651138067245, -0.017345359548926353, -0.020276090130209923, 0.0024100630544126034, 0.006361975334584713, -0.057362016290426254 ]
<p>I am learning Gaussian kernel SVMs recently. I have to choose the parameter $\epsilon$ for Gaussian kernel, $$k(x,t)=e^{-\frac{\|x-y\|_2^2}{2\epsilon}}.$$</p> <p>I try to find the answer in literature. I found some to analyze the parameters like '<a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20221922" rel="nofollow">A User's Guide to Support Vector Machines</a>' (<a href="http://pyml.sourceforge.net/doc/howto.pdf" rel="nofollow">PDF</a>). I really want to analyze these by myself step by step. But I have work to finish, you know. I found a paper '<a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14690712" rel="nofollow">Practical Selection of SVM Parameters and Noise Estimation for SVM Regression</a>' (<a href="http://www.svms.org/parameters/CherkasskyMa2004.pdf" rel="nofollow">PDF</a>). </p>
74,189
[ -0.012866800650954247, -0.03713921830058098, 0.03540824353694916, -0.005112484097480774, -0.007176282349973917, -0.013067320920526981, -0.011848719790577888, -0.05068299546837807, 0.015952326357364655, -0.029445914551615715, 0.03204898163676262, 0.061365243047475815, 0.05986739322543144, 0.0421614944934845, 0.023105889558792114, -0.00008572368824388832, -0.030476253479719162, -0.02240476943552494, -0.01452337671071291, 0.005721311550587416, -0.003956461790949106, 0.014060399495065212, -0.014310470782220364, -0.0363265685737133, -0.029615197330713272, 0.034750837832689285, -0.006466348189860582, 0.004879613872617483, 0.031054863706231117, 0.04350034520030022, -0.057685233652591705, -0.050462834537029266, 0.011693146079778671, 0.0321325920522213, 0.0019338063430041075, 0.00426796218380332, -0.022483110427856445, -0.039489004760980606, -0.015704981982707977, 0.020878411829471588, -0.037606190890073776, 0.006979201454669237, 0.0043836720287799835, 0.052013199776411057, -0.01736990548670292, 0.018815502524375916, 0.030774615705013275, -0.073216013610363, 0.009739958681166172, -0.04920833557844162, 0.07890243828296661, -0.004654449410736561, 0.014693522825837135, 0.051212649792432785, 0.017926590517163277, 0.0022063234355300665, 0.029229016974568367, 0.059702929109334946, 0.015847880393266678, -0.02623780071735382, -0.003285146551206708, -0.0015501577872782946, -0.008705859072506428, -0.0254154521971941, -0.018961099907755852, 0.051808569580316544, 0.01631668582558632, -0.02292632684111595, 0.03226684033870697, 0.004194420296698809, 0.015528627671301365, -0.02111000195145607, 0.03624424338340759, -0.008265791460871696, 0.02193201147019863, -0.003218752099201083, -0.004874865058809519, 0.021642303094267845, 0.030786484479904175, 0.026209630072116852, 0.0247789416462183, 0.013944150879979134, 0.005874996073544025, -0.0053888955153524876, -0.01401540543884039, 0.02432394213974476, 0.05884290486574173, 0.015005472116172314, 0.016694702208042145, 0.035346560180187225, -0.015352470800280571, 0.02395947091281414, 0.027020908892154694, -0.008122176863253117, -0.0391470231115818, 0.043632108718156815, 0.004340081010013819, 0.023745976388454437, 0.003326953621581197, -0.037672363221645355, -0.018041688948869705, 0.006849892437458038, 0.009442686103284359, 0.08268693834543228, -0.06149796396493912, 0.009950844570994377, 0.008695123717188835, 0.006010305602103472, -0.055377047508955, -0.05074305459856987, -0.04139643907546997, -0.005891517736017704, 0.008644003421068192, -0.00262882630340755, 0.0422012023627758, 0.005848147440701723, -0.001475319848395884, -0.04447450488805771, 0.005420357454568148, 0.06310146301984787, 0.046193841844797134, 0.011163566261529922, 0.005073076114058495, -0.014202549122273922, -0.03062235377728939, 0.04039900749921799, 0.06185882166028023, 0.0010690728668123484, -0.039516597986221313, 0.04989713430404663, 0.00574824633076787, -0.006770062260329723, 0.044735584408044815, -0.0265848059207201, 0.04855608195066452, -0.0014560313429683447, -0.08874237537384033, -0.0405331552028656, 0.035757604986429214, -0.011116515845060349, 0.02914467640221119, -0.07225046306848526, 0.011238793842494488, 0.008983947336673737, 0.031725943088531494, 0.0007379036978818476, 0.025891916826367378, 0.02116578258574009, 0.04811796545982361, -0.00927184708416462, -0.04822327941656113, 0.004357560072094202, -0.03871437907218933, -0.005145304836332798, -0.028032101690769196, -0.04636825993657112, 0.004873392637819052, 0.01857151836156845, -0.013502570800483227, 0.0028313978109508753, 0.052283018827438354, -0.0037817733827978373, 0.002633195137605071, -0.0003434543905314058, 0.016644194722175598, -0.043184585869312286, 0.04027039557695389, 0.030396129935979843, 0.03576783090829849, 0.01537630520761013, -0.019970104098320007, 0.014980720356106758, 0.03101591020822525, 0.020989960059523582, 0.04562148079276085, -0.011199952103197575, -0.0021834848448634148, -0.02381127141416073, 0.01873188652098179, 0.019391823559999466, -0.07950132340192795, -0.046841952949762344, 0.01821434684097767, 0.050505757331848145, 0.015569375827908516, 0.06236386299133301, -0.0026567266322672367, -0.009994166903197765, 0.014902161434292793, -0.06913791596889496, -0.02311154268682003, -0.0442480631172657, 0.015034590847790241, -0.014658421277999878, -0.031002601608633995, 0.04496285691857338, -0.01234191283583641, -0.029137399047613144, -0.015401442535221577, -0.00473575945943594, -0.01971363089978695, 0.02094212733209133, 0.04857790097594261, -0.011304053477942944, 0.01593661680817604, 0.03708236292004585, 0.035712528973817825, -0.03568116948008537, 0.04616717994213104, -0.014620163477957249, -0.03283055126667023, 0.0060274237766861916, -0.016907157376408577, 0.02577270194888115, -0.0010238310787826777, -0.038849011063575745, 0.02140410989522934, 0.015618340112268925, -0.018972380086779594, 0.010671135038137436, -0.07489722222089767, 0.07016050070524216, 0.08359964936971664, 0.04140661284327507, 0.002090292051434517, 0.02343994379043579, -0.023983106017112732, 0.04179014265537262, -0.013975267298519611, 0.004115672316402197, -0.02807457186281681, -0.026231752708554268, 0.05910096317529678, 0.02191980555653572, -0.03251337260007858, 0.011645724065601826, 0.05582493916153908, 0.014987707138061523, 0.0017797347391024232, 0.0065423534251749516, -0.0412137508392334, -0.016735725104808807, 0.018504135310649872, -0.016012419015169144, -0.04567112401127815, 0.00039402273250743747, 0.024301676079630852, 0.004024212248623371, 0.05089089274406433, 0.01162870042026043, -0.021323805674910545, 0.08439981192350388, -0.022037703543901443, 0.00393516244366765, -0.00816874485462904, -0.008602154441177845, 0.03951207175850868, -0.02288283035159111, -0.008681802079081535, 0.03333315998315811, -0.00878640916198492, 0.014989732764661312, -0.011186706833541393, 0.007831308990716934, 0.022914212197065353, 0.015306167304515839, -0.04601277410984039, 0.0340278334915638, 0.028703076764941216, -0.05895302817225456, -0.005738007370382547, 0.004025316331535578, -0.03724979981780052, -0.05952749028801918, 0.0035640064161270857, 0.020289041101932526, 0.007727897260338068, 0.010746876709163189, 0.011637058109045029, -0.040884945541620255, 0.020965546369552612, 0.0015831958735361695, 0.0493469201028347, -0.0009498819708824158, -0.03746277838945389, -0.00500589981675148, -0.03834603354334831, 0.010415452532470226, 0.059006839990615845, -0.02307322435081005, 0.013614281080663204, -0.015772173181176186, -0.00016942553338594735, -0.05552670359611511, -0.02367975004017353, -0.0380704291164875, 0.014061780646443367, 0.0011166796321049333, -0.01223138440400362, 0.053149133920669556, -0.0030442574061453342, -0.03419225662946701, 0.04492490738630295, -0.044888999313116074, -0.055186670273542404, -0.00443106796592474, -0.013817104510962963, 0.02097398228943348, -0.014421887695789337, 0.003300045384094119, 0.031591229140758514, 0.007990346290171146, 0.029383035376667976, -0.06068408489227295, -0.04939179867506027, 0.023819731548428535, 0.017666416242718697, 0.059304799884557724, 0.003870791057124734, -0.024378309026360512, 0.1252313256263733, 0.05459412559866905, -0.04461796209216118, -0.032146431505680084, 0.001631427207030356, -0.05421872437000275, -0.0026467088609933853, 0.015557804144918919, 0.041208114475011826, 0.02427772432565689, 0.028658553957939148, -0.010840818285942078, -0.0013060704804956913, 0.05102261155843735, 0.0024287726264446974, -0.03450249880552292, 0.011531263589859009, -0.036641404032707214, -0.024123912677168846, 0.05841691046953201, 0.00909187737852335, -0.010732142254710197, 0.022514482960104942, -0.0007406279328279197, -0.024501051753759384, -0.01891709491610527, -0.04964783042669296, 0.008669845759868622, -0.04958080127835274, -0.014408069662749767, -0.037321776151657104, 0.005791058298200369, 0.040599461644887924, -0.05020337924361229, -0.018721874803304672, -0.0008350189309567213, -0.0045452602207660675, -0.03559228777885437, 0.013456507585942745, 0.02928130514919758, 0.03317839652299881, -0.018294163048267365, -0.013249693438410759, -0.010322675108909607, -0.014334496110677719, 0.02171989157795906, 0.013570687733590603, -0.026199420914053917, 0.030500371009111404, 0.024192895740270615, -0.01775062270462513, -0.0008492838824167848, -0.0035466195549815893, 0.00793258473277092, -0.07430402934551239, -0.041014935821294785, -0.022292250767350197, 0.04305985942482948, 0.014768899418413639, 0.0005232779076322913, 0.01244386937469244, -0.03686370328068733, 0.03051396831870079, -0.0018521224847063422, -0.05518335476517677, 0.0045112441293895245, -0.011875394731760025, -0.030232392251491547, 0.03975449502468109, -0.009361080825328827, 0.05116529017686844, -0.014076926745474339, 0.021141797304153442, -0.02227737195789814, 0.046713970601558685, -0.05983573570847511, 0.0023195042740553617, -0.014794078655540943, -0.020281370729207993, 0.0012767916778102517, 0.009084000252187252, 0.02359275333583355, -0.019198764115571976, -0.01006394624710083, 0.03217117115855217, -0.06125631183385849, -0.01136688981205225, 0.010768947191536427, 0.009796983562409878, 0.024729514494538307, 0.04737108573317528, 0.0017568073235452175, 0.02945733442902565, -0.00941700953990221, 0.01803283765912056, -0.004864968359470367, 0.0435989573597908, 0.07199334353208542, -0.01000673696398735, -0.02487979829311371, -0.047725826501846313, -0.026357363909482956, 0.003924984019249678, 0.04656246304512024, -0.0023150818888098, -0.011235052719712257, 0.07606682926416397, -0.01561503391712904, -0.05183176323771477, -0.012598318047821522, 0.014451311901211739, 0.004194245208054781, 0.034464407712221146, -0.0414399728178978, -0.018827231600880623, -0.02644975483417511, -0.003815281670540571, 0.01676267571747303, -0.01567784883081913, -0.04914618656039238, -0.01294376514852047, 0.02516673319041729, -0.010239326395094395, -0.000011016650205419865, 0.0037338773254305124, 0.06184815987944603, 0.033424653112888336, -0.02891646698117256, -0.00232480326667428, -0.0061113773845136166, 0.06030796840786934, 0.047326553612947464, -0.021058663725852966, -0.02765689790248871, -0.04585067182779312, -0.008761626668274403, 0.08602695912122726, 0.03397747501730919, -0.01951337791979313, 0.00010480618220753968, -0.05456889420747757, -0.03465454652905464, 0.015135611407458782, -0.004422568716108799, 0.023443732410669327, 0.010951190255582333, -0.028078267350792885, -0.020413585007190704, -0.007349821273237467, -0.03384600579738617, -0.0069769215770065784, -0.010068349540233612, 0.014518826268613338, -0.0363924466073513, -0.024477628991007805, -0.03403063118457794, -0.0003553825372364372, -0.013035492040216923, 0.07446189224720001, 0.00683644600212574, -0.02507304772734642, 0.01473967730998993, 0.021561797708272934, -0.021983828395605087, -0.05862738564610481, 0.007517545949667692, 0.02408040314912796, -0.00018388924945611507, 0.03748239949345589, 0.011443788185715675, -0.060346394777297974, 0.01597732864320278, 0.04750179499387741, -0.03136371448636055, -0.01056920737028122, -0.0046873572282493114, 0.024217655882239342, 0.03340872377157211, 0.04013573005795479, 0.06375565379858017, 0.04045125097036362, -0.021462079137563705, 0.011721570044755936, -0.05647173151373863, 0.010715232230722904, -0.025631995871663094, 0.003029618412256241, -0.03963889181613922, -0.0003959862806368619, -0.026885928586125374, 0.027688417583703995, 0.020294856280088425, 0.05351341888308525, -0.022308193147182465, -0.005165901035070419, 0.012446527369320393, 0.06077722832560539, 0.002961336402222514, -0.025690501555800438, 0.019033946096897125, 0.05394275486469269, -0.02511979080736637, 0.0024670963175594807, -0.013232355937361717, -0.024348963052034378, 0.035628847777843475, 0.031067771837115288, -0.050831347703933716, 0.015667513012886047, -0.04463522136211395, -0.021405642852187157, 0.013508712872862816, -0.03926098719239235, 0.05205513536930084, -0.0015514529077336192, 0.018670234829187393, 0.03529086336493492, -0.03031073324382305, -0.03413655608892441, -0.014777780510485172, -0.00941675715148449, 0.05820247530937195, -0.012603528797626495, 0.009771717712283134, 0.022904861718416214, -0.0013169310986995697, -0.06203271448612213, -0.00505015579983592, 0.015184374526143074, -0.039976008236408234, -0.02249111980199814, -0.06136631593108177, 0.03763262927532196, 0.01970248855650425, -0.03250141814351082, 0.04108671098947525, 0.05044548213481903, 0.006433830130845308, -0.00022431528486777097, -0.023870879784226418, 0.025342313572764397, 0.08333681523799896, 0.028395162895321846, 0.018583284690976143, 0.00956871546804905, -0.019543536007404327, -0.030101316049695015, 0.04018980264663696, 0.03145405650138855, -0.024186788126826286, 0.011928397230803967, -0.048454850912094116, 0.0025287808384746313, 0.030505947768688202, -0.002147153951227665, -0.008637540973722935, 0.028436429798603058, -0.0017154862871393561, 0.031911276280879974, -0.013918845914304256, 0.023026252165436745, -0.012897314503788948, -0.019360680133104324, 0.017233164981007576, -0.015469356440007687, -0.03263638913631439, -0.018995041027665138, 0.032818492501974106, 0.004333843477070332, 0.007410494610667229, 0.003466463414952159, 0.052629392594099045, -0.012473651207983494, 0.01212037168443203, 0.008652186021208763, -0.015519016422331333, 0.015856251120567322, -0.033286768943071365, 0.012680110521614552, 0.00272619491443038, 0.013696102425456047, -0.026612136512994766, -0.020634835585951805, -0.056679580360651016, -0.029106343165040016, 0.059016965329647064, -0.03604695573449135, 0.09256737679243088, 0.035874176770448685, -0.016787197440862656, 0.00019697322568390518, -0.035081647336483, 0.004783011041581631, -0.06139502301812172, -0.03174704313278198, 0.0036189695820212364, 0.0056771948002278805, 0.005387393292039633, 0.00990950409322977, -0.0071385945193469524, -0.004463482182472944, 0.012121862731873989, -0.0012707910500466824, 0.038618091493844986, 0.05068892613053322, -0.022210754454135895, -0.006300103385001421, 0.04874703288078308, -0.008021817542612553, 0.031439755111932755, -0.009812749922275543, -0.019270794466137886, 0.020087316632270813, 0.012867815792560577, 0.008393690921366215, -0.010695432312786579, -0.01547206286340952, -0.040554024279117584, 0.03632782772183418, 0.05798386037349701, -0.05503540858626366, 0.0363696925342083, 0.06444282084703445, 0.025810882449150085, 0.005864262115210295, 0.04593601077795029, -0.0395025871694088, -0.07098367065191269, -0.013123219832777977, -0.031693048775196075, -0.037459228187799454, 0.04336338862776756, 0.0075845192186534405, -0.08110897988080978, -0.008667975664138794, -0.04781137406826019, 0.031207507476210594, 0.02548827789723873, 0.029939770698547363, -0.034321095794439316, 0.05383749678730965, -0.0326261930167675, -0.02491096407175064, -0.0002425792918074876, -0.010761650279164314, 0.11235488951206207, 0.08548657596111298, 0.022363778203725815, -0.06385280936956406, -0.00003596068563638255, -0.004688813351094723, -0.017408257350325584, -0.027146384119987488, 0.02565283700823784, -0.020260613411664963, 0.0032725795172154903, 0.028766855597496033, 0.0026155433151870966, 0.01615103706717491, -0.027352871373295784, 0.03112207166850567, 0.0008933615172281861, -0.039992593228816986, 0.02087642438709736, -0.008791832253336906, -0.026477254927158356, -0.017373766750097275, -0.011900664307177067, 0.04254455119371414, -0.02648562379181385, -0.028094103559851646, -0.054945290088653564, -0.06694840639829636, 0.02245614305138588, -0.023517783731222153, 0.002587342169135809, -0.0030757226049900055, 0.02040042169392109, 0.012025982141494751, -0.004983710590749979, 0.009039470925927162, -0.017836591228842735, -0.00769734475761652, 0.01785440556704998, 0.0025668046437203884, 0.0067626978270709515, -0.0217256061732769, 0.02808300219476223, -0.022545266896486282, -0.01644449681043625, -0.04295583814382553, -0.020037708804011345, 0.0692560151219368, 0.025039270520210266, -0.006485269404947758, -0.0047490885481238365, 0.038757774978876114, 0.0064500467851758, -0.03497554734349251, 0.001582257216796279, 0.0034045919310301542, 0.048477012664079666, -0.041629161685705185, -0.02106742560863495, -0.024288812652230263, 0.030123500153422356, -0.033204805105924606, 0.041054945439100266, 0.022968312725424767, -0.07007510960102081, -0.008428824134171009, -0.035789892077445984, 0.015943452715873718, 0.02021990343928337, -0.011561835184693336, -0.011703208088874817, -0.05561838671565056, -0.011145476251840591, -0.008120839484035969, 0.007257332094013691, -0.003573611844331026, 0.02529328502714634, -0.03761254996061325, -0.030183915048837662, -0.030570678412914276, -0.07120058685541153, 0.009691176004707813, -0.005670325364917517, 0.02272826060652733, -0.0055192201398313046, 0.004071671515703201, -0.011225588619709015, 0.01270651537925005, 0.03717845305800438, 0.0052645243704319, 0.01940590888261795, 0.0012999849859625101, 0.018927181139588356, -0.058451712131500244, -0.00965713057667017, 0.0012885561445727944, -0.0369550883769989, 0.013925082050263882, 0.008737750351428986, 0.06221722811460495, -0.0019519225461408496, 0.01914522983133793, 0.024211199954152107, 0.013926554471254349, -0.00799797847867012, -0.03115534782409668, -0.008144937455654144, -0.036482226103544235, 0.01677301898598671, 0.00153173110447824, -0.0035525579005479813, -0.018163375556468964, -0.018136247992515564, -0.010849276557564735, 0.0049105556681752205, 0.0014449763111770153, 0.0034500048495829105, -0.018158668652176857, 0.037798989564180374, -0.024376152083277702, 0.026444850489497185, -0.01570715568959713, 0.00831392128020525, 0.01701342687010765, 0.0002190107188653201, -0.02042056992650032, 0.021427810192108154, 0.020830072462558746, -0.0336386039853096, 0.040190745145082474, 0.010064350441098213, 0.027798673138022423, 0.008977179415524006, 0.03066457062959671, 0.005412104073911905, 0.014176815748214722, -0.015527586452662945, 0.06036096438765526, -0.04090951755642891, -0.0076158298179507256, 0.04510815814137459, -0.0772319808602333, -0.04017122462391853, -0.008334082551300526, -0.025240793824195862, 0.015065713785588741, 0.0009243880049325526, 0.005454573780298233, -0.023463796824216843, 0.04086987301707268, -0.0012756612850353122, 0.024650806561112404, -0.02219935692846775, 0.008417326956987381, -0.0020112968049943447, -0.011411339975893497, 0.016563894227147102, -0.01226232759654522, 0.023429028689861298, 0.015735192224383354, 0.012124189175665379, -0.008102442137897015, -0.01842181198298931, 0.010937749408185482, -0.0047646695747971535, 0.004471469670534134, 0.003961928654462099, -0.007078344468027353, 0.07557366788387299, 0.024320131167769432, -0.0226732324808836, 0.03389914706349373, -0.009032896719872952, 0.028691357001662254, -0.11041814088821411, -0.0005747393588535488, -0.0027253006119281054, 0.040089961141347885, 0.04473400488495827, -0.0615222193300724, 0.012978590093553066, 0.04540403187274933, -0.03473780304193497, 0.014216423034667969, -0.0019657269585877657, -0.014224594458937645, -0.012719962745904922, 0.009473639540374279, -0.019871532917022705, 0.02417837642133236, 0.023408830165863037, 0.021374545991420746, 0.03712260723114014, 0.01807490736246109, 0.004076242912560701, -0.015281639993190765, -0.012543849647045135, 0.04804914817214012, -0.001522145583294332, -0.03714554384350777, 0.02972692996263504, -0.012655890546739101, -0.013691642321646214, 0.006006545387208462, 0.02040845900774002, 0.015344029292464256, 0.02776361256837845, 0.038888078182935715, 0.003031468018889427, 0.04836133494973183, 0.04587375000119209, 0.0313548743724823, -0.0033391385804861784, -0.01961934007704258, 0.006237216759473085, 0.011745240539312363, -0.0007166705909185112, 0.013132935389876366, 0.008723482489585876, -0.011531306430697441, -0.01756066270172596, 0.026927992701530457, -0.052340876311063766, -0.03403136134147644, 0.03349580615758896, 0.010300587862730026, -0.007815426215529442, -0.03450248762965202, 0.02123044990003109, -0.04398553445935249, -0.01368899829685688, 0.007835757918655872, 0.015281971544027328, -0.031983841210603714, 0.0020482921972870827, -0.013751907274127007, -0.0620528906583786, 0.008201271295547485, 0.003316215705126524, -0.02223391830921173, -0.05564117059111595, -0.0007658582762815058, 0.02345343306660652, -0.01853729970753193, -0.030538484454154968, -0.006875546183437109, -0.04289742186665535, 0.06082239747047424, -0.004359003156423569, 0.00914156623184681, -0.007752531208097935, -0.009393662214279175, 0.0014539029216393828, -0.06309536099433899, 0.04435085877776146, 0.03193021938204765, -0.02796662040054798, -0.014131659641861916, -0.02509438805282116, -0.006817752029746771, -0.006757820025086403, 0.0320872999727726, -0.009721011854708195, -0.0028724907897412777, -0.020513636991381645, -0.001536786905489862, 0.006942017935216427, -0.05295542627573013, 0.033047277480363846, 0.002733709057793021, -0.04953412339091301, -0.010427584871649742, -0.008045820519328117, 0.0015749308513477445, 0.04241975396871567, 0.03179209679365158, 0.02433038130402565, 0.01226559653878212, 0.017379438504576683, -0.02052523009479046, 0.013193275779485703, 0.03834264725446701, -0.007487913127988577, 0.08659890294075012, -0.018688609823584557, 0.001849619671702385, 0.008162814192473888, 0.007092676591128111, -0.0434705913066864, 0.0031232659239321947, 0.0026162192225456238, -0.04682265222072601, -0.028483236208558083, -0.011367346160113811, 0.02449263446033001, -0.03851107880473137, -0.009211190044879913, 0.06828206777572632, -0.0319342203438282, -0.003543225349858403, 0.02068348228931427, 0.005936960689723492, 0.011698901653289795, 0.021710995584726334, 0.021533768624067307, 0.01630273088812828, -0.03491555526852608, -0.013644610531628132, 0.007276695687323809, 0.010348895564675331, 0.01338067464530468, 0.004864849150180817, 0.034646689891815186, -0.032236333936452866, 0.042386360466480255, 0.0013132384046912193, 0.00433054706081748, -0.07519567757844925, -0.014990702271461487, 0.0012116548605263233, 0.01952086202800274, -0.04429265111684799, -0.04383593052625656, -0.04757577180862427, 0.06506379693746567, -0.06353113800287247, -0.0032876431941986084, -0.017368432134389877, -0.012622088193893433, -0.026376452296972275, 0.032275956124067307, 0.021946949884295464, 0.0024300175718963146, -0.009514753706753254, 0.023494333028793335, -0.018925227224826813, 0.02278936468064785, 0.03229463845491409, -0.04488692060112953, 0.03330380842089653, -0.003414181526750326, 0.002830892102792859, 0.011140747927129269, 0.006713127251714468, -0.000682884594425559, -0.04970754310488701, 0.007848136126995087, 0.04650908336043358, -0.014682097360491753, -0.040233585983514786, -0.02923228219151497, -0.005824399646371603, 0.05861682817339897, -0.07667176425457001, -0.0054786731489002705, -0.012355362996459007, 0.0009107995429076254, -0.02946769818663597, -0.030600514262914658 ]
<p>I am working on time series analysis. The book I am using ("Statistics for Long Memory Processes" by Jan Beran) uses a number of measures for process memory and one of them is to graph Sample Mean Variance against the sample size (In other words, for every n, the variance of the mean of $X_n$ is graphed).</p> <p>There is a graph of the famous Nile low water level dataset (page 21) and I have not been able to replicate it with the same dataset. I tried, for every n, to take many (100k) random samples, calculate average for each of them and graph their variance against n. My graph is significantly different, most importantly, while the log-log graph for me is fairly continuous and has a slop of 1, the graph in the book has a much different slope.</p> <p>Am I going the wrong way about this?</p> <p>EDIT: As per the request So here is the code:</p> <pre><code>sampleCount = 100000 def sampleMeanVariance(inputArray,sampleSizes): for sampleSize in sampleSizes: mean_set = [] for i in range(sampleCount): interarrivalTimesSample = random.sample(inputArray, sampleSize) mean_set.append(mean(interarrivalTimesSample)) print sampleSize,var(mean_set) </code></pre> <p>Here is <a href="http://postimg.org/image/kgpl3wjrx/" rel="nofollow">my plot</a>.</p> <p>Here is the <a href="http://books.google.de/books?id=jdzDYWtfPC0C&amp;lpg=PP1&amp;dq=Statistics%20for%20long%20range%20processes%20nile%20river&amp;hl=de&amp;pg=PA21#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">book plot</a> (pg 21):</p>
36,907
[ -0.036745425313711166, -0.017948515713214874, -0.004191784653812647, 0.00821765512228012, 0.02969910204410553, 0.02295093983411789, -0.04426005110144615, -0.029334554448723793, -0.007032592780888081, -0.0035250296350568533, 0.043498557060956955, 0.03480369970202446, 0.06607750803232193, 0.02886621654033661, 0.034207213670015335, 0.006520007271319628, 0.01747923344373703, 0.022129442542791367, 0.009772300720214844, -0.05273827537894249, -0.009509936906397343, 0.004464998375624418, 0.03815045580267906, -0.004925989545881748, -0.023176591843366623, 0.010154785588383675, 0.008276290260255337, -0.024011755362153053, 0.015093263238668442, 0.023800930008292198, -0.06395861506462097, -0.041475292295217514, 0.0159765537828207, 0.022336753085255623, 0.026696868240833282, 0.03237238898873329, -0.019613834097981453, -0.06858381628990173, 0.013756688684225082, 0.025306817144155502, -0.02346825785934925, 0.03959837183356285, 0.0026425763498991728, 0.044524338096380234, -0.031515978276729584, 0.04005406051874161, 0.011304523795843124, -0.014501800760626793, 0.04329453036189079, -0.022220643237233162, 0.06331072747707367, 0.009621718898415565, 0.05384653061628342, 0.03631846606731415, 0.003424256108701229, 0.014223262667655945, 0.013221601024270058, 0.01922135055065155, -0.03074963204562664, -0.03964890167117119, -0.020237812772393227, -0.009653925895690918, -0.013428237289190292, 0.035263705998659134, -0.031141886487603188, -0.01984104886651039, -0.00838532391935587, 0.0035260284785181284, 0.04766961932182312, 0.029203476384282112, 0.013113782741129398, 0.03161976858973503, 0.06819034367799759, -0.0013151458697393537, 0.01596946083009243, 0.01848672516644001, 0.012829429470002651, 0.030398808419704437, 0.05124733969569206, 0.02610156498849392, 0.000005287853127811104, 0.031601693481206894, 0.007209596689790487, 0.004267789423465729, 0.00024025396851357073, 0.013797827064990997, 0.07115260511636734, 0.006110865157097578, -0.01407927181571722, 0.036919038742780685, 0.00820939801633358, -0.0007135830237530172, 0.03682518005371094, 0.023246902972459793, -0.042532503604888916, 0.02776292897760868, 0.005253375507891178, 0.013340598903596401, -0.008921942673623562, 0.012147690169513226, -0.03069549985229969, -0.05059197545051575, 0.05214684456586838, 0.04418737068772316, -0.0010063881054520607, -0.0321480818092823, -0.0028669252060353756, 0.0043391333892941475, -0.01721620187163353, -0.02436983399093151, -0.041487567126750946, -0.0054353754967451096, 0.02005775086581707, 0.021348340436816216, 0.014068245887756348, 0.008466850966215134, 0.012552793137729168, 0.0346304252743721, 0.03292481601238251, 0.06661418825387955, 0.019159870222210884, -0.021950146183371544, 0.04495896399021149, -0.0404757484793663, -0.06381931900978088, 0.040930572897195816, 0.00857308879494667, -0.030228866264224052, -0.027818545699119568, 0.0445537269115448, -0.004980125464498997, 0.010973977856338024, 0.0504036620259285, -0.024893321096897125, 0.08874750882387161, 0.01946265436708927, -0.08467856794595718, -0.054477956146001816, 0.046592555940151215, -0.020163781940937042, 0.025278549641370773, -0.045508261770009995, 0.005405443720519543, 0.027514558285474777, 0.03295360133051872, 0.004521877504885197, 0.04212064668536186, 0.01665990613400936, -0.0021234850864857435, 0.02208917960524559, -0.04577165096998215, 0.00900560524314642, 0.013923203572630882, -0.03125301003456116, -0.005812793970108032, -0.0626339316368103, 0.016923874616622925, 0.023485751822590828, 0.00017479127564001828, -0.0045021530240774155, -0.02670741081237793, -0.01397832203656435, 0.008580604568123817, -0.02995445765554905, -0.007800746709108353, -0.05495253950357437, 0.07937570661306381, 0.021869082003831863, 0.06319671869277954, -0.03837156295776367, -0.02302166447043419, -0.017371907830238342, -0.005679110996425152, 0.006846155039966106, 0.04345356300473213, -0.008449668064713478, 0.04144368693232536, -0.0022014277055859566, 0.004088223446160555, 0.03307321295142174, 0.004989590961486101, -0.017301339656114578, -0.033764924854040146, 0.005126459989696741, 0.011783461086452007, 0.009361288510262966, 0.007385607343167067, -0.008045380003750324, -0.01196636725217104, -0.04620249941945076, -0.031850554049015045, -0.033012114465236664, -0.002788133453577757, -0.008669205009937286, -0.003383062547072768, 0.007500583305954933, -0.03392340615391731, 0.014491057023406029, -0.0016949818236753345, -0.05625484511256218, 0.022586816921830177, -0.03753942251205444, 0.010776945389807224, -0.04041752219200134, -0.009792834520339966, 0.020631231367588043, 0.008733360096812248, -0.008223696611821651, 0.035842686891555786, -0.027469493448734283, -0.02830052562057972, 0.023040711879730225, -0.02432418242096901, -0.028480762615799904, -0.015671057626605034, -0.026583943516016006, 0.021128658205270767, 0.050139907747507095, 0.019278794527053833, 0.015549859032034874, -0.026116248220205307, 0.04554804787039757, 0.06370051205158234, 0.002449994208291173, -0.017263175919651985, 0.002886380534619093, 0.03997340425848961, 0.031879886984825134, -0.01521463692188263, -0.009022540412843227, -0.034018032252788544, -0.0022631799802184105, -0.004557304549962282, 0.03568011522293091, 0.005176290404051542, -0.033977847546339035, 0.08028168976306915, 0.00701370881870389, 0.02810799516737461, 0.018649816513061523, -0.01586293615400791, -0.0011096253292635083, 0.020968426018953323, 0.05901860445737839, 0.039598461240530014, -0.016562016680836678, -0.01245415210723877, -0.02396463230252266, 0.023324813693761826, -0.011734752915799618, -0.0018149311654269695, -0.026147939264774323, 0.0004461773205548525, 0.014325544238090515, -0.03844485431909561, -0.0026660780422389507, 0.040874309837818146, -0.012682885862886906, -0.02321532927453518, 0.022235384210944176, 0.014553409069776535, -0.007184768095612526, -0.01793336309492588, -0.04021330922842026, 0.0310890544205904, 0.02389039844274521, -0.023480819538235664, -0.04981343820691109, 0.023326531052589417, -0.024388445541262627, 0.008095250464975834, -0.00479478994384408, -0.027804164215922356, -0.023678258061408997, 0.0315217450261116, 0.017503762617707253, 0.00960147101432085, 0.0026905701961368322, -0.023632057011127472, -0.003354395506903529, -0.012639295309782028, 0.022516625002026558, 0.0022406147327274084, -0.02109915390610695, -0.04222656413912773, 0.012371508404612541, -0.00795217789709568, -0.023644069209694862, -0.011018754914402962, -0.03473072499036789, 0.03668386861681938, 0.02819092385470867, 0.016135666519403458, -0.04884345829486847, -0.02587362378835678, -0.05171296373009682, 0.006410693284124136, 0.001107063959352672, 0.0006076073623262346, 0.04060422256588936, 0.024274475872516632, -0.022315753623843193, 0.03656971827149391, -0.014420642517507076, 0.005166678223758936, -0.041079115122556686, -0.0113791823387146, -0.014195696450769901, 0.004957340192049742, -0.0002586855844128877, 0.06025420129299164, -0.02239951491355896, -0.03070204332470894, -0.06744685769081116, -0.08570805937051773, -0.009953845292329788, 0.008207404054701328, 0.02931724674999714, -0.006461828015744686, 0.0028005335479974747, 0.05980189889669418, 0.02356528863310814, -0.035737667232751846, -0.022641751915216446, -0.006013877224177122, -0.0174795463681221, -0.06961209326982498, 0.03428944572806358, 0.006191092077642679, -0.05756353959441185, -0.0028737932443618774, -0.0008054160280153155, 0.045469608157873154, 0.03906136378645897, -0.018844889476895332, -0.0049404059536755085, 0.01754581183195114, -0.0018683593953028321, -0.013436355628073215, 0.053135503083467484, 0.026119163259863853, -0.03100753203034401, -0.004113377071917057, -0.027109380811452866, 0.009690215811133385, -0.0008180190343409777, -0.045949049293994904, 0.05011210963129997, 0.024968251585960388, 0.022506970912218094, -0.05908780172467232, 0.014447437599301338, 0.0010038799373432994, -0.0402488075196743, -0.02067265659570694, 0.046205099672079086, 0.03276710584759712, -0.025768650695681572, 0.01978549174964428, 0.04379718750715256, 0.08058806508779526, -0.011795297265052795, -0.004682295490056276, -0.05357160046696663, 0.009119016118347645, -0.003384241135790944, -0.011262519285082817, 0.0027533010579645634, 0.05403399094939232, 0.0380823016166687, 0.008538562804460526, -0.035233817994594574, -0.05731078237295151, 0.00716202100738883, -0.04222717881202698, 0.011484815739095211, -0.0427982397377491, 0.0389971099793911, 0.04579238221049309, 0.00315164215862751, 0.012805584818124771, 0.02349402755498886, -0.009890045039355755, 0.002625135937705636, -0.05854461342096329, 0.004522155970335007, -0.01625823602080345, -0.046942323446273804, -0.014718959107995033, -0.026168527081608772, 0.04312365502119064, -0.0039008331950753927, 0.05585780739784241, 0.0371045283973217, -0.0003627141413744539, -0.04010830447077751, 0.004898037761449814, -0.023108772933483124, 0.01533586997538805, -0.02175302989780903, 0.02150900848209858, 0.04669949784874916, -0.009297206066548824, 0.03400082513689995, -0.007728897966444492, 0.018732348456978798, -0.05672219395637512, 0.002235366962850094, 0.033534009009599686, 0.007831146009266376, 0.009160417132079601, 0.018535150215029716, 0.009588116779923439, -0.0546693280339241, 0.01230543851852417, 0.004007917363196611, 0.038876619189977646, 0.06126214936375618, 0.004269164055585861, 0.025052862241864204, -0.022225305438041687, 0.010130580514669418, 0.06754657626152039, -0.006573423743247986, 0.022980669513344765, 0.0017260190797969699, 0.01314531173557043, 0.03151838481426239, -0.0452064648270607, 0.04379668086767197, 0.04570154845714569, -0.026449155062437057, 0.0060784583911299706, 0.001539452001452446, -0.0007730305078439415, 0.03225235268473625, 0.0012275074841454625, 0.03487629443407059, 0.04728410765528679, -0.010965713299810886, 0.006265493109822273, 0.06630434095859528, -0.003914660774171352, -0.014680864289402962, 0.024543991312384605, 0.010451139882206917, 0.036410652101039886, 0.006901414133608341, -0.030032159760594368, 0.019086100161075592, -0.00214397837407887, -0.005147379823029041, 0.04038473963737488, -0.007663675583899021, -0.07381651550531387, -0.009903349913656712, 0.02011292241513729, 0.031482383608818054, -0.00855615921318531, 0.008590245619416237, -0.06892230361700058, -0.012401890940964222, 0.021987851709127426, -0.04864000156521797, 0.040005844086408615, 0.003651538398116827, 0.0425487719476223, -0.04833262413740158, -0.043362025171518326, -0.019080495461821556, -0.0002846050192601979, -0.03482583165168762, 0.040262430906295776, -0.043236806988716125, -0.043069228529930115, -0.01591377519071102, 0.030552463605999947, 0.003002121113240719, 0.07421490550041199, -0.04866985231637955, 0.020989198237657547, -0.0017411911394447088, 0.02187320776283741, -0.02307777851819992, -0.07057292759418488, 0.013183672912418842, -0.041735127568244934, 0.008701509796082973, 0.01579417660832405, 0.008694133721292019, -0.03280959278345108, 0.061383139342069626, 0.020923087373375893, -0.004921985790133476, -0.012899025343358517, -0.02125515602529049, 0.0296462569385767, 0.03422681987285614, -0.01026065181940794, 0.09097244590520859, 0.03507951647043228, 0.026617325842380524, -0.0052263145335018635, -0.00009799528925213963, 0.046492114663124084, -0.051349036395549774, -0.027150742709636688, -0.07135020196437836, -0.016040178015828133, -0.03557272627949715, 0.003024413250386715, 0.019234981387853622, 0.013654458336532116, -0.0274786576628685, -0.019214961677789688, 0.01274887565523386, 0.011116893962025642, 0.010617755353450775, 0.005378963891416788, 0.02088031731545925, 0.005372206214815378, -0.03154308348894119, 0.00034410119405947626, 0.04058739170432091, -0.020077215507626534, -0.023423336446285248, 0.03306391462683678, -0.012585362419486046, 0.013057202100753784, -0.05301442742347717, 0.013620801270008087, 0.002376168267801404, -0.005659701768308878, 0.006031376775354147, -0.007358388975262642, 0.039037708193063736, 0.013951889239251614, -0.011725308373570442, 0.04394003748893738, 0.037321850657463074, -0.022772962227463722, 0.013864212669432163, -0.03841002658009529, 0.018585216253995895, -0.009709896519780159, 0.019753381609916687, -0.08841610699892044, -0.06845641881227493, 0.053443487733602524, -0.02926257997751236, -0.024433523416519165, -0.013520010747015476, -0.060450516641139984, 0.00841706432402134, 0.03300277143716812, -0.004898276180028915, 0.03473256155848503, -0.05138852819800377, -0.00868934765458107, -0.0371115617454052, 0.02893460914492607, 0.09067743271589279, -0.0023025660775601864, -0.03773908317089081, 0.027357909828424454, 0.000676084600854665, -0.05009342357516289, -0.017360877245664597, 0.05296158045530319, -0.045597925782203674, -0.010011395439505577, -0.005572881083935499, 0.013123241253197193, 0.03258069232106209, -0.02588345855474472, -0.026568051427602768, 0.014309126883745193, 0.02812379226088524, 0.02868715301156044, -0.03271537646651268, -0.055968835949897766, -0.023473327979445457, -0.013752132654190063, -0.028077149763703346, 0.002724516438320279, 0.004887955728918314, 0.001891859108582139, -0.006640604231506586, 0.034762170165777206, -0.0027859278488904238, 0.02839711308479309, 0.06255818903446198, -0.013975397683680058, -0.047410834580659866, -0.0045884051360189915, -0.035316336899995804, 0.007918952964246273, -0.002749418141320348, 0.008597674779593945, -0.005999288521707058, -0.03137783333659172, -0.04468026012182236, -0.032607901841402054, -0.03496556729078293, 0.012689746916294098, 0.060043297708034515, 0.011682572774589062, 0.0464150570333004, 0.06268566101789474, -0.00010380787716712803, 0.019167708232998848, -0.029796183109283447, -0.0336063876748085, -0.006247114390134811, -0.004321437794715166, 0.0684472844004631, -0.02100554294884205, -0.013175005093216896, 0.01337809395045042, -0.0006809948245063424, 0.05914956331253052, 0.0349661223590374, 0.012822013348340988, -0.00217338465154171, 0.008286233060061932, -0.0013834707206115127, -0.04652908071875572, 0.0067399730905890465, -0.019952578470110893, 0.03861973434686661, -0.004105332773178816, -0.028895391151309013, 0.022459791973233223, 0.053325291723012924, 0.0149394441395998, -0.03070879355072975, -0.04189354181289673, -0.062151163816452026, -0.026638280600309372, 0.04361123591661453, 0.019377607852220535, 0.019690902903676033, 0.016556300222873688, 0.018064696341753006, -0.030050715431571007, 0.012505673803389072, -0.03155277296900749, -0.029827844351530075, -0.0224037803709507, -0.0006794811924919486, -0.01986926794052124, 0.04627297446131706, -0.019257748499512672, -0.06769700348377228, 0.0489063635468483, -0.03942460939288139, 0.042186420410871506, -0.0124704260379076, -0.0025473081041127443, 0.014107324182987213, 0.09192631393671036, 0.010537819936871529, 0.02529602311551571, -0.04854356497526169, -0.009064443409442902, 0.12983427941799164, 0.0453978069126606, 0.03496718406677246, -0.05298040807247162, 0.016713766381144524, 0.031090257689356804, -0.008007924072444439, -0.0565527081489563, -0.02032638154923916, 0.006199987139552832, -0.021333850920200348, 0.02102901041507721, 0.02353404089808464, 0.013356011360883713, 0.006977821700274944, 0.05872109532356262, -0.05845753848552704, 0.018899422138929367, 0.027628077194094658, -0.0117957079783082, 0.022795695811510086, -0.006487226579338312, -0.0848812460899353, 0.038098547607660294, -0.003551364177837968, -0.017376700416207314, -0.010540205053985119, 0.006746973376721144, -0.009297091513872147, 0.036201220005750656, 0.004563372582197189, 0.008339694701135159, 0.015432779677212238, -0.029580362141132355, 0.03281175717711449, 0.0038888126146048307, 0.006921981927007437, -0.000633984396699816, 0.03792166709899902, 0.03502091020345688, 0.0307370126247406, -0.003469833405688405, 0.018120452761650085, 0.006370068062096834, -0.014056441374123096, -0.07456576824188232, -0.021915731951594353, 0.0404292456805706, -0.0034475033171474934, -0.00696537084877491, -0.012507683597505093, 0.02401835098862648, 0.006743112578988075, -0.0337168425321579, 0.014644031412899494, -0.022554965689778328, 0.009082775563001633, -0.0033188285306096077, -0.010119469836354256, -0.009594233706593513, 0.02003224939107895, -0.0017756320303305984, 0.02005421184003353, 0.02081468515098095, -0.03517034649848938, -0.020609645172953606, -0.0505368635058403, 0.005911076907068491, -0.011900817975401878, 0.0027271141298115253, -0.016560157760977745, -0.038832660764455795, -0.05426105111837387, -0.022939134389162064, -0.007126406766474247, -0.010622093454003334, 0.03839476406574249, -0.03972399979829788, -0.021151019260287285, -0.020601000636816025, -0.024216394871473312, -0.02564604952931404, -0.005069747567176819, -0.03468921408057213, -0.014589453116059303, -0.019860807806253433, 0.0322798490524292, 0.016291972249746323, 0.020613033324480057, 0.003711956087499857, -0.017528297379612923, 0.04751964285969734, 0.03420328348875046, -0.06186049059033394, -0.0009557380108162761, -0.0042289551347494125, -0.03716406598687172, -0.011926162987947464, -0.00849513616412878, 0.06279338151216507, 0.029255148023366928, -0.011027393862605095, 0.02173352614045143, 0.024428382515907288, 0.011639824137091637, 0.01260522659868002, 0.010264996439218521, -0.05889663100242615, 0.036695901304483414, 0.015694359317421913, -0.028704620897769928, -0.06095456704497337, -0.010266103781759739, -0.010018964298069477, -0.05541687086224556, -0.0009925059275701642, -0.010510535910725594, -0.023540139198303223, 0.01114664040505886, -0.040728431195020676, 0.03427276760339737, -0.028395261615514755, 0.004403191152960062, -0.028503743931651115, -0.04352232441306114, -0.028046252205967903, 0.028910445049405098, -0.02909642457962036, 0.025569215416908264, -0.026914266869425774, -0.023366961628198624, 0.017535855993628502, 0.016459554433822632, 0.04228039085865021, -0.018029537051916122, -0.011710097081959248, 0.017993202432990074, -0.0036179996095597744, -0.06822685897350311, -0.04266823083162308, 0.08002210408449173, -0.04772544279694557, -0.04591182619333267, 0.0462469682097435, 0.02336188778281212, -0.0005586936022154987, -0.0034451582469046116, 0.0022457288578152657, -0.0635969266295433, 0.07628120481967926, -0.03196822479367256, 0.011266486719250679, -0.014367122203111649, -0.020463556051254272, 0.03889872878789902, 0.0018908510683104396, -0.012800736352801323, 0.016188571229577065, 0.04052424058318138, 0.03095192089676857, 0.060494985431432724, -0.013251730240881443, -0.010354580357670784, -0.022490523755550385, 0.005359492264688015, -0.0050209565088152885, -0.028715144842863083, -0.008460727520287037, 0.044268716126680374, 0.04397545009851456, -0.017481021583080292, -0.029322754591703415, -0.06365295499563217, -0.010375033132731915, -0.04721496254205704, -0.013638357631862164, -0.022186879068613052, 0.02107078768312931, 0.027055516839027405, -0.030573921278119087, -0.023815030232071877, 0.028070444241166115, -0.033887699246406555, -0.008155367337167263, 0.01644316129386425, -0.0040968540124595165, -0.06612484902143478, 0.021958813071250916, -0.02423708327114582, 0.010491627268493176, 0.03353763744235039, 0.04868261143565178, 0.058108508586883545, 0.024400385096669197, 0.05063294246792793, -0.03952545300126076, -0.02395046502351761, 0.033628594130277634, 0.024425622075796127, -0.026981238275766373, -0.004968077875673771, -0.032436370849609375, -0.056588105857372284, 0.0293453149497509, -0.02999715320765972, -0.0007224570726975799, -0.013408313505351543, 0.04193956032395363, 0.006173027213662863, 0.06853921711444855, 0.02622377686202526, -0.009775935672223568, 0.018698174506425858, -0.04414455592632294, 0.049521319568157196, 0.03604277968406677, 0.002749107778072357, 0.03244546428322792, 0.057803113013505936, -0.026491768658161163, -0.04019235447049141, -0.018445171415805817, 0.0076210168190300465, -0.03075842373073101, 0.01331457868218422, -0.019716890528798103, 0.035347722470760345, -0.037803780287504196, 0.014076834544539452, -0.02186254784464836, 0.002440085867419839, 0.041557230055332184, 0.009457698091864586, 0.003258987097069621, 0.0034151857253164053, 0.0019120877841487527, -0.015468067489564419, -0.04922238737344742, 0.026684394106268883, -0.0470484159886837, -0.03183537349104881, -0.02844814397394657, -0.011928843334317207, -0.012668450362980366, -0.0053461831994354725, -0.020522590726614, -0.04811571165919304, 0.006365612149238586, -0.01282638218253851, 0.006893789395689964, -0.029961759224534035, -0.0002809594734571874, 0.024325357750058174, -0.0704287588596344, 0.067703478038311, -0.0004190053732600063, -0.005352781619876623, -0.05959979444742203, -0.018927495926618576, 0.004585244692862034, 0.028742125257849693, 0.020177751779556274, -0.013916563242673874, 0.01601310633122921, -0.004816817585378885, 0.014861863106489182, 0.031134581193327904, -0.02178318239748478, 0.048252951353788376, -0.051345471292734146, -0.013273890130221844, 0.03732498362660408, -0.015675069764256477, 0.01134708896279335, 0.015313047915697098, 0.03677850216627121, -0.006863048300147057, 0.0034513352438807487, 0.004254568833857775, -0.056876104325056076, 0.023211676627397537, -0.03294101729989052, -0.04063130170106888, 0.016401227563619614, 0.011585251428186893, -0.024159589782357216, 0.03157651424407959, -0.008820484392344952, -0.037567172199487686, 0.013248584233224392, -0.0078238844871521, -0.030903588980436325, -0.01719966158270836, 0.007220642175525427, 0.04531411826610565, -0.030645892024040222, 0.007854240946471691, 0.022950006648898125, 0.011895013973116875, -0.008895437233150005, 0.045744556933641434, 0.009827611036598682, -0.015824120491743088, -0.00648625148460269, 0.004148906096816063, -0.02371671237051487, 0.018916772678494453, -0.0041855438612401485, -0.018190832808613777, 0.03509583696722984, -0.009143441915512085, -0.03497113659977913, 0.011976421810686588, -0.027164973318576813, 0.012716109864413738, 0.005608029663562775, 0.07562962174415588, -0.0071928719989955425, -0.029085850343108177, 0.04805593192577362, -0.0004989411681890488, -0.012115756049752235, 0.011781341396272182, 0.02094750665128231, 0.05697654187679291, -0.017244389280676842, 0.014746969565749168, -0.022566189989447594, -0.05067865923047066, -0.012707256712019444, 0.025402819737792015, 0.03203359991312027, 0.009410765953361988, 0.0064829266630113125, 0.00765268737450242, -0.04112205654382706, 0.016979126259684563, 0.019162720069289207, -0.04879634454846382, -0.001361392904073, 0.004743159748613834, 0.0023126639425754547, 0.008705907501280308, -0.0023737342562526464, 0.004130104091018438, -0.019859235733747482, 0.033514443784952164, 0.009075377136468887, 0.005079624708741903, 0.00955110415816307, -0.01292475312948227, 0.024472642689943314, 0.053545039147138596, -0.06671740114688873, -0.008633123710751534, -0.03817309811711311, 0.00790407694876194, 0.011777196079492569, -0.01456280704587698 ]
<p>In a normal distribution, the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/68-95-99.7_rule">68-95-99.7 rule</a> imparts standard deviation a lot of meaning. But what would standard deviation mean in a non-normal distribution (multimodal or skewed)? Would all data values still fall within 3 standard deviations? Do we have rules like the 68-95-99.7 one for non-normal distributions?</p>
20,350
[ -0.03611818701028824, -0.04711886867880821, 0.011553735472261906, -0.03286176919937134, 0.0392555296421051, 0.029649903997778893, -0.018703926354646683, -0.05058663710951805, 0.03189883753657341, -0.03953602910041809, 0.020623167976737022, -0.013567212969064713, 0.03743084892630577, 0.021487275138497353, 0.03815975785255432, -0.029471131041646004, 0.003876945935189724, -0.0007271254435181618, -0.024795465171337128, -0.04266376420855522, 0.025656837970018387, 0.009790265001356602, -0.03659564629197121, -0.01884937658905983, -0.029999839141964912, 0.05090471729636192, 0.014637026004493237, 0.020822636783123016, 0.0617787204682827, 0.031082717701792717, -0.01237853616476059, -0.028550082817673683, 0.0032888250425457954, 0.03119243122637272, 0.027836499735713005, -0.0072097862139344215, -0.009219146333634853, 0.005191737320274115, -0.019699865952134132, 0.041359610855579376, -0.049544814974069595, 0.015909718349575996, -0.005579362157732248, 0.01656341552734375, -0.05808604881167412, 0.025368867442011833, -0.006549248471856117, -0.049453362822532654, 0.025157811120152473, -0.03304295986890793, 0.0776301920413971, -0.010255269706249237, 0.027850443497300148, 0.058140091598033905, -0.003035291563719511, 0.01841088756918907, 0.07584681361913681, 0.03736138343811035, 0.0024355435743927956, -0.0666794553399086, 0.0008468370651826262, -0.0226995088160038, -0.003864270867779851, -0.019784623757004738, 0.004929991904646158, 0.017138933762907982, 0.00027453681104816496, -0.054704781621694565, 0.057897213846445084, -0.007687665987759829, 0.013903376646339893, 0.05119134485721588, 0.034008145332336426, -0.023667432367801666, 0.0006017075502313673, -0.022631138563156128, 0.04468471556901932, 0.002418199088424444, 0.03037436120212078, 0.014783383347094059, 0.04793450981378555, -0.017421353608369827, 0.04986611381173134, 0.027100061997771263, 0.015101639553904533, -0.01665395125746727, 0.09938321262598038, -0.03522583842277527, 0.02280520647764206, 0.008744915947318077, 0.005954331252723932, 0.029625536873936653, 0.0481388121843338, -0.03025522083044052, -0.048756226897239685, 0.040787987411022186, -0.03155975416302681, 0.01101947296410799, 0.005909292958676815, -0.02134234644472599, 0.001010957290418446, -0.03874910622835159, 0.04639917239546776, 0.0359315387904644, -0.006646911613643169, 0.00017071765614673495, -0.016386868432164192, 0.027703098952770233, -0.011757433414459229, -0.002726741833612323, -0.005434955004602671, 0.013471575453877449, -0.003726674010977149, -0.010830052196979523, 0.04413141682744026, 0.020766280591487885, -0.01127571053802967, -0.03127730265259743, 0.019237004220485687, 0.046394843608140945, 0.041691072285175323, -0.015293153934180737, 0.020925959572196007, -0.0014772365102544427, -0.057750821113586426, 0.03012852743268013, 0.010806528851389885, 0.025229284539818764, -0.05330461636185646, 0.04615233838558197, -0.018866583704948425, -0.004559442866593599, 0.03120058961212635, -0.00812522228807211, -0.002109984867274761, -0.027909042313694954, -0.06206558644771576, -0.053463686257600784, 0.0342409648001194, 0.002206997247412801, -0.03282035142183304, -0.06281790882349014, -0.03874583542346954, 0.03472105786204338, 0.03310934454202652, 0.0051055471412837505, 0.015093153342604637, -0.004405531100928783, 0.014727456495165825, 0.012313349172472954, -0.02297445945441723, 0.0031916967127472162, 0.0037679451052099466, -0.013630090281367302, 0.01929931715130806, -0.08878526836633682, 0.034815073013305664, 0.009829342365264893, 0.02342679537832737, -0.026667194440960884, -0.002885503228753805, -0.01205131970345974, 0.0035387875977903605, -0.007467952091246843, -0.002861154731363058, -0.02961949072778225, 0.05917716771364212, -0.008177706971764565, 0.007201729342341423, 0.0297092217952013, 0.021927328780293465, 0.021272094920277596, -0.04996249079704285, 0.08574334532022476, 0.07206264138221741, -0.017913030460476875, -0.0016835096757858992, -0.016269946470856667, 0.0030112294480204582, -0.008225574158132076, -0.06988854706287384, 0.016713954508304596, 0.020665081217885017, 0.037684760987758636, -0.003385337069630623, 0.044036924839019775, 0.0019260834669694304, -0.010427547618746758, 0.061616651713848114, -0.02514338493347168, -0.030133714899420738, -0.05096212774515152, 0.00017381356155965477, -0.024236377328634262, -0.06259366124868393, 0.03828170523047447, 0.04434299096465111, 0.049427539110183716, -0.028147857636213303, -0.0031998073682188988, 0.011249138042330742, 0.013907155953347683, 0.06161726638674736, -0.03588532283902168, 0.0100520309060812, 0.06719198822975159, 0.020002391189336777, -0.004518912639468908, 0.0023443137761205435, -0.043970346450805664, -0.07639192789793015, -0.003092097584158182, -0.046581294387578964, 0.031218374148011208, -0.001582526951096952, -0.004623734392225742, 0.013304521329700947, -0.0085613327100873, -0.011277874931693077, 0.027601417154073715, -0.03322509303689003, 0.03687211126089096, 0.02962852455675602, -0.021700240671634674, -0.008129782974720001, -0.004325248766690493, 0.015474994666874409, -0.004211011342704296, 0.0014894522028043866, -0.047069400548934937, -0.03618679940700531, -0.015505877323448658, 0.023433130234479904, -0.0005731969722546637, -0.04830560460686684, 0.006253505125641823, 0.044507697224617004, 0.006488991901278496, 0.0213047843426466, 0.017451539635658264, 0.0009965170174837112, -0.031127968803048134, -0.022479107603430748, -0.0026127442251890898, 0.01673213765025139, -0.0110315578058362, -0.0068379780277609825, 0.035944387316703796, 0.010289665311574936, 0.006533108651638031, 0.004882850218564272, 0.041058674454689026, -0.014471051283180714, 0.020306888967752457, 0.015138234943151474, 0.003030148334801197, 0.03563297167420387, -0.03547491505742073, 0.03096345253288746, 0.07582620531320572, -0.03168511390686035, -0.022428879514336586, -0.0069438740611076355, -0.002706781029701233, 0.012128517962992191, 0.06209876388311386, 0.00509925140067935, 0.014956620521843433, 0.021117014810442924, -0.061044223606586456, -0.02195250615477562, -0.047336775809526443, -0.003950335085391998, -0.00786090549081564, -0.0000433686473115813, 0.0310744047164917, -0.019225627183914185, 0.043809205293655396, -0.037501826882362366, -0.038580697029829025, -0.015763847157359123, 0.00968120712786913, -0.024770934134721756, -0.036690518260002136, -0.04781600087881088, -0.007808357011526823, 0.009822704829275608, -0.03531254827976227, -0.00007733067468507215, -0.032517384737730026, 0.043615520000457764, 0.02675316110253334, 0.00873502530157566, -0.03465086594223976, 0.020065903663635254, -0.016296429559588432, -0.003393752733245492, -0.027052203193306923, -0.047364819794893265, 0.0345606654882431, -0.016116846352815628, -0.049002885818481445, 0.0525515154004097, -0.05912386253476143, -0.10102304816246033, -0.0417005829513073, 0.04442835599184036, 0.014339061453938484, -0.004630982410162687, 0.031698863953351974, 0.038470420986413956, -0.06004321575164795, 0.013819949701428413, -0.06512119621038437, -0.04632614180445671, 0.015539729036390781, -0.0028632974717766047, 0.03103419579565525, 0.011195271275937557, -0.019022546708583832, 0.059296708554029465, 0.016808874905109406, -0.038987427949905396, -0.01046160701662302, -0.013047304935753345, -0.014745085500180721, -0.040271203964948654, 0.03964286670088768, 0.0041399854235351086, 0.038188062608242035, 0.014334120787680149, 0.029078438878059387, 0.04098653793334961, 0.05067625641822815, 0.014974581077694893, -0.00044468589476309717, -0.001351747428998351, -0.007079326547682285, -0.015591598115861416, 0.0542493611574173, 0.02189624309539795, 0.002320533851161599, 0.00046666801790706813, 0.0017808893462643027, 0.03972842916846275, 0.02500675804913044, -0.03365383669734001, 0.054878219962120056, 0.0013432045234367251, 0.006955527234822512, -0.050487492233514786, 0.01614215597510338, 0.004590908996760845, -0.001179595710709691, 0.00792685803025961, 0.010921579785645008, 0.03109908290207386, -0.01970425248146057, 0.026573842391371727, 0.03616121783852577, 0.0512721873819828, -0.004692797549068928, -0.027121763676404953, -0.01655796356499195, -0.009820781648159027, -0.0045103514567017555, 0.002857168670743704, -0.017051788046956062, 0.039080724120140076, 0.03914075344800949, 0.008981759659945965, 0.00029446359258145094, -0.019450092688202858, 0.010126227512955666, -0.08917538076639175, -0.014098696410655975, -0.037863388657569885, -0.013735798187553883, -0.01454210840165615, 0.03207813575863838, 0.023859959095716476, -0.021853214129805565, 0.014407175593078136, 0.0043825414031744, -0.039312463253736496, 0.034296613186597824, 0.0007476968457922339, -0.012022554874420166, -0.0033759991638362408, -0.017654329538345337, 0.005814976990222931, -0.03267427161335945, 0.052061256021261215, -0.014958294108510017, 0.026156334206461906, -0.015288542956113815, -0.017475036904215813, -0.022642241790890694, -0.031823985278606415, -0.023553788661956787, 0.0019179515074938536, 0.028152946382761, -0.027336515486240387, -0.005374895874410868, 0.019639281556010246, 0.008425034582614899, -0.014581003226339817, -0.031320929527282715, 0.00010325788025511429, -0.012338981963694096, 0.05224583297967911, 0.024183664470911026, 0.008213719353079796, -0.012690005823969841, 0.041839759796857834, 0.021076304838061333, 0.0702395886182785, 0.03854800760746002, -0.02742946892976761, -0.02302074432373047, -0.04102414473891258, -0.030154457315802574, 0.029144125059247017, -0.01763596013188362, 0.00998139102011919, 0.01389992143958807, 0.055510248988866806, 0.004666739143431187, -0.055861696600914, 0.02697782963514328, 0.06756920367479324, 0.01701751910150051, -0.01581512950360775, -0.05510333552956581, -0.006337215658277273, -0.0028331091161817312, -0.0154794342815876, 0.008620555512607098, 0.038723718374967575, 0.009288148023188114, 0.03071095421910286, 0.02880830504000187, -0.0010525110410526395, -0.030156070366501808, -0.03705722093582153, 0.03372237831354141, 0.031087694689631462, -0.027917128056287766, 0.006980168633162975, 0.01565675623714924, 0.030514735728502274, 0.060463979840278625, 0.013309251517057419, 0.005428353790193796, -0.09738826751708984, 0.008019519969820976, 0.059971150010824203, 0.055150460451841354, -0.009540689177811146, 0.00681528402492404, -0.026491772383451462, 0.024089956656098366, 0.022273041307926178, -0.011138307861983776, -0.000013867695088265464, -0.03042333945631981, 0.033030033111572266, -0.01969379372894764, -0.020286088809370995, -0.018858840689063072, 0.03143835812807083, 0.010478767566382885, 0.0041459714993834496, -0.005382215604186058, -0.010818026959896088, -0.03924091160297394, 0.01266434881836176, 0.031049909070134163, 0.05041221156716347, 0.014864602126181126, -0.023585544899106026, 0.005275216419249773, 0.03792900592088699, -0.01505174022167921, -0.0718558058142662, 0.004898897837847471, -0.0011736706364899874, -0.014735591597855091, 0.022831572219729424, 0.009538215585052967, -0.044787585735321045, 0.015072663314640522, 0.0344180092215538, -0.008670501410961151, 0.05215442180633545, 0.00038360364851541817, 0.056263770908117294, 0.024772632867097855, 0.040749434381723404, 0.016824871301651, 0.0018073995597660542, 0.011986560188233852, -0.036259058862924576, -0.031168073415756226, 0.07161752134561539, -0.022872282192111015, -0.04520532116293907, -0.041858091950416565, -0.050385985523462296, -0.01775861158967018, -0.0011734961299225688, -0.0005606350023299456, 0.03772132098674774, 0.02175140380859375, -0.01652207411825657, -0.022847488522529602, 0.00039090780774131417, 0.011558298952877522, 0.028045933693647385, 0.01696314848959446, -0.0020969929173588753, -0.012068996205925941, 0.003456033067777753, 0.04466117545962334, -0.03401307389140129, 0.026424746960401535, 0.03679759427905083, -0.025131555274128914, -0.01127716712653637, -0.0335153192281723, -0.05321834236383438, -0.006440248806029558, -0.023365383967757225, 0.04946402087807655, 0.015159014612436295, 0.028211701661348343, -0.0036144964396953583, -0.03639283776283264, 0.00845527183264494, 0.03424442559480667, -0.027688398957252502, 0.03111312724649906, -0.032832566648721695, 0.051591988652944565, -0.04130331426858902, 0.027800170704722404, -0.05115002021193504, -0.019415544345974922, 0.043104302138090134, 0.01873822510242462, -0.012277036905288696, -0.0005475269863381982, -0.019274652004241943, -0.02397407963871956, -0.028351500630378723, -0.014161333441734314, 0.03986860439181328, -0.016760118305683136, -0.018588382750749588, 0.00693912897258997, 0.010923669673502445, 0.09400616586208344, -0.027619391679763794, 0.008894984610378742, 0.025318168103694916, 0.0034865669440478086, -0.03859241306781769, -0.022068044170737267, 0.03519623726606369, -0.019954800605773926, 0.004944884218275547, -0.007240735925734043, -0.0239734947681427, 0.041002728044986725, -0.05206733196973801, -0.004434382542967796, -0.019533339887857437, -0.0016464634099975228, -0.004671105183660984, -0.0073950281366705894, 0.03149666264653206, -0.00007022963836789131, 0.01998741179704666, -0.023100506514310837, -0.0020376674365252256, -0.025933071970939636, -0.008079588413238525, 0.02662619948387146, 0.01599644124507904, -0.0029105860739946365, 0.056210339069366455, 0.016833676025271416, -0.011253642849624157, 0.0015679369680583477, -0.01743246614933014, 0.011862833984196186, 0.028658274561166763, 0.011200188659131527, -0.004740819334983826, -0.009950745850801468, 0.02796752005815506, -0.022514747455716133, -0.027686698362231255, -0.03708967566490173, -0.014573801308870316, 0.06880588829517365, -0.019088005647063255, 0.06090132147073746, 0.02900736965239048, -0.020936207845807076, -0.01802375353872776, -0.057886529713869095, -0.016759667545557022, -0.008541237562894821, 0.017502373084425926, 0.048043105751276016, -0.0016798399155959487, 0.027653634548187256, 0.02916785702109337, 0.025881733745336533, -0.03310921788215637, 0.04693492129445076, -0.00393730727955699, 0.003316049464046955, 0.014885769225656986, -0.02709440141916275, -0.0642470195889473, 0.05083955451846123, -0.020874403417110443, 0.01556604728102684, 0.001138933002948761, -0.011555527336895466, 0.015834247693419456, -0.0065798829309642315, -0.017383472993969917, -0.043447911739349365, 0.005229009781032801, -0.050089478492736816, -0.011924953199923038, 0.013895105570554733, -0.03136640787124634, 0.0035937586799263954, -0.009363091550767422, 0.04870627447962761, -0.04390910267829895, 0.010789423249661922, 0.0018538428703323007, -0.10961435735225677, -0.026466304436326027, -0.032733622938394547, -0.035305216908454895, 0.0227422546595335, -0.009430227801203728, -0.03693871945142746, -0.001199405174702406, -0.03342674672603607, 0.037396617233753204, -0.006320754066109657, 0.019065676257014275, -0.0014225231716409326, 0.06042104214429855, 0.013897170312702656, 0.015665072947740555, -0.004450589418411255, 0.0021424710284918547, 0.11213721334934235, 0.04934661462903023, 0.039880186319351196, -0.05198385939002037, -0.002760618692263961, -0.04741959646344185, 0.006338607985526323, 0.0175514817237854, 0.021408377215266228, 0.016685323789715767, 0.03298312425613403, 0.03603048250079155, 0.040460776537656784, -0.0016029406106099486, -0.03916958346962929, 0.055954255163669586, -0.015561580657958984, -0.01801992394030094, 0.00028578212368302047, 0.019118281081318855, 0.0022098636254668236, 0.008174213580787182, -0.06014826521277428, 0.011672014370560646, -0.0034045425709336996, 0.0025005533825606108, -0.023693209514021873, -0.016635434702038765, 0.010272642597556114, 0.007991043850779533, -0.016791095957159996, -0.04403385519981384, 0.02237352356314659, 0.009045133367180824, -0.06454651802778244, -0.0018958131549879909, 0.024575745686888695, -0.07537079602479935, -0.002840799279510975, 0.03098694607615471, 0.012107052840292454, 0.00745344627648592, 0.001934665022417903, 0.0017417833441868424, -0.03877047076821327, -0.026989607140421867, 0.0017754496075212955, 0.024601131677627563, 0.0012648723786696792, -0.03140696510672569, -0.03032897785305977, 0.015164188109338284, 0.011881562881171703, -0.0044072773307561874, 0.01139660645276308, -0.015136580914258957, -0.0032363140489906073, -0.03182706609368324, -0.013499217107892036, -0.004037158098071814, -0.015572854317724705, 0.012105540372431278, 0.042745236307382584, 0.018383437767624855, -0.009005513973534107, -0.007963658310472965, -0.034676842391490936, 0.050217386335134506, -0.007742665242403746, -0.021926499903202057, -0.01500944048166275, 0.013648067601025105, -0.027873678132891655, 0.01683410257101059, 0.012285750359296799, 0.017763279378414154, 0.005916676018387079, 0.016316380351781845, 0.005323076155036688, -0.010020286776125431, -0.0407559834420681, 0.04865295812487602, -0.04186083376407623, 0.029085705056786537, -0.03711036592721939, -0.0025489346589893103, 0.04044490307569504, 0.04527126997709274, 0.024677885696291924, 0.016352640464901924, 0.010313077829778194, 0.036768633872270584, 0.01350022666156292, -0.0505773201584816, 0.008859164081513882, 0.019369129091501236, -0.03160569816827774, -0.004298166837543249, -0.011155575513839722, 0.062157727777957916, 0.017553528770804405, 0.03615118935704231, -0.04805329442024231, 0.02026323229074478, 0.02357732690870762, -0.012808687053620815, 0.022952059283852577, -0.0736125260591507, 0.019830692559480667, 0.030892856419086456, 0.012536442838609219, -0.043191276490688324, -0.005257885903120041, -0.021642180159687996, -0.03203350678086281, 0.01587018184363842, 0.018898341804742813, -0.04077174514532089, -0.019941460341215134, -0.01162873674184084, 0.040867991745471954, -0.01870163530111313, 0.0222955122590065, -0.0009988995734602213, 0.016994604840874672, 0.0019496458116918802, -0.0009623343939892948, -0.012931440956890583, -0.009899905882775784, 0.0061134034767746925, 0.02464194782078266, 0.011864442378282547, 0.007493185810744762, 0.034867916256189346, -0.018085069954395294, -0.0025011315010488033, -0.030063938349485397, 0.02501973882317543, -0.007433397229760885, 0.0002914609503932297, 0.06911647319793701, -0.036084603518247604, -0.047847919166088104, 0.02373967505991459, 0.006034110207110643, 0.0021377871744334698, 0.014012038707733154, -0.005278817377984524, 0.00754729937762022, 0.06303720921278, -0.04647079110145569, -0.023447318002581596, -0.02080024592578411, -0.022767363116145134, 0.011541074141860008, 0.03203503414988518, 0.01936366781592369, 0.010345525108277798, -0.04101216048002243, 0.05868088826537132, 0.03531445935368538, -0.02158108726143837, -0.00826417375355959, 0.0382816419005394, -0.008545085787773132, -0.0027680688071995974, 0.009314635768532753, 0.021273789927363396, 0.051817797124385834, 0.042610522359609604, -0.026044275611639023, 0.048340924084186554, -0.0029757756274193525, 0.009611360728740692, -0.08593568950891495, -0.022211400792002678, 0.04222184419631958, -0.007243756204843521, 0.027583302929997444, -0.04909089207649231, -0.00012084589980076998, -0.004244745243340731, -0.06125153228640556, 0.012420100159943104, -0.027137910947203636, -0.05523858591914177, -0.029610414057970047, -0.008331882767379284, 0.004805197007954121, 0.06698118150234222, -0.013758533634245396, -0.015611004084348679, 0.0011998212430626154, 0.025101512670516968, -0.008426585234701633, -0.0038476765621453524, -0.04005252197384834, 0.03873246908187866, 0.013212446123361588, -0.05867056921124458, 0.018428442999720573, -0.038836464285850525, -0.061607517302036285, 0.01642969250679016, -0.007667250465601683, 0.02281372994184494, -0.011934202164411545, -0.008115301840007305, 0.013766053132712841, 0.03497883677482605, 0.01887880451977253, 0.009091079235076904, -0.01943393051624298, -0.009412848390638828, 0.02909468114376068, 0.02212229184806347, -0.04849475622177124, -0.009985278360545635, 0.008158612996339798, -0.04502975940704346, -0.018816785886883736, -0.0010794166009873152, -0.034425288438797, -0.05317908152937889, 0.00841093435883522, 0.012392906472086906, 0.0002747030812315643, -0.02637057565152645, 0.07636948674917221, -0.015588684007525444, 0.008220569230616093, 0.022704554721713066, 0.03999807685613632, -0.025707028806209564, 0.008535402826964855, -0.01207119319587946, -0.03709506615996361, -0.01911873370409012, 0.011541573330760002, -0.016437698155641556, -0.06100566312670708, -0.0057402318343520164, -0.03735147789120674, 0.0038927108980715275, -0.005438321735709906, -0.014082680456340313, -0.014600064605474472, 0.05323305353522301, -0.016924982890486717, 0.013431374914944172, 0.030609339475631714, -0.07249411195516586, -0.030176285654306412, -0.10746520757675171, 0.03546111285686493, 0.02272370271384716, 0.006271337158977985, -0.10405143350362778, -0.005392088554799557, -0.05867120251059532, -0.004648689180612564, 0.06563030928373337, 0.0387759692966938, 0.02166181430220604, -0.042225368320941925, 0.005844790022820234, -0.000997845665551722, -0.06963855028152466, 0.048985857516527176, -0.0020441338419914246, 0.00725321751087904, -0.03132925182580948, -0.01079902146011591, -0.00507506774738431, -0.017733678221702576, 0.022550547495484352, -0.009360854513943195, 0.019881755113601685, 0.025742869824171066, 0.0179445818066597, 0.03635526821017265, 0.028569281101226807, -0.048998862504959106, 0.018902353942394257, -0.029167095199227333, -0.013683648779988289, 0.04643673077225685, -0.0009699619258753955, -0.031791988760232925, -0.010411220602691174, 0.011005810461938381, -0.04305505007505417, -0.0073346165008842945, 0.02875748835504055, 0.012346829287707806, -0.05044173076748848, 0.01562623307108879, 0.03918685391545296, -0.03470435366034508, 0.005013713613152504, 0.04259346053004265, 0.04693487286567688, 0.02359277941286564, -0.0158699844032526, -0.005000198259949684, 0.0006917978753335774, -0.045087795704603195, 0.0382285974919796, -0.007673720829188824, 0.010719160549342632, -0.02359374240040779, -0.0033514618407934904, -0.014011455699801445, -0.03425247594714165, 0.0375075563788414, 0.019296368584036827, 0.08202597498893738, 0.013078497722744942, -0.01199104730039835, -0.015458757057785988, 0.02552877739071846, 0.04311860725283623, -0.02535363659262657, -0.02296065166592598, 0.07121330499649048, 0.0025677820667624474, -0.007962586358189583, -0.02117753215134144, -0.014423824846744537, -0.026203010231256485, 0.01141776330769062, -0.01501487661153078, 0.022804884240031242, -0.010037467814981937, -0.02725459635257721, 0.0056934054009616375, 0.02594088204205036, 0.04020565748214722, -0.01114049181342125, 0.04361951723694801, -0.020482800900936127, 0.02441415563225746, -0.0174820926040411, -0.024859491735696793, -0.016336292028427124, -0.002072973409667611, -0.009127553552389145, 0.05047134310007095, 0.03871004655957222, 0.006069398485124111, -0.019328324124217033, -0.013056485913693905, 0.02294060029089451, -0.05035121366381645, 0.0006876991828903556, -0.028000501915812492, 0.024140089750289917, 0.007501611951738596, -0.03563825786113739 ]
<p>I am using panel data and I would like to determine whether I can use the Random Effects (RE) model instead of Fixed Effects (FE) to estimate one coefficient of interest. When I use the Hausman test comparing FE and RE, I have to reject the null hypothesis (meaning that the RE model is not OK). However, the difference between the coefficient of interest estimated by FE and RE is not statistically significant. So my question is: Can I justify using the RE model only based on this fact? After all, the null hypothesis of the Hausman test must be rejected only because the estimation of some other covariates (control variables) significantly differ between the RE and FE approaches. But in my case, these variables are not of interest and I do not seek for consistent estimators.</p>
36,910
[ -0.03805803880095482, 0.0072351000271737576, -0.01032702811062336, -0.012777083553373814, 0.02187241241335869, 0.0389111265540123, -0.0055288830772042274, -0.032513100653886795, 0.028270559385418892, -0.0753893181681633, 0.006520254537463188, 0.04629238694906235, 0.06290441006422043, -0.028853630647063255, 0.021100671961903572, 0.02312110736966133, -0.001634896034374833, 0.011696559377014637, 0.00429051648825407, -0.0011066721053794026, -0.0538601316511631, 0.058516956865787506, 0.01407623291015625, -0.023183714598417282, -0.0256086066365242, 0.04203597456216812, 0.010653478093445301, 0.00008483202691422775, 0.007289975881576538, 0.017599398270249367, 0.00206837453879416, -0.0014021958922967315, -0.013375019654631615, 0.02921120636165142, -0.010124258697032928, -0.020293040201067924, -0.002721213735640049, 0.0011810087598860264, -0.002621494233608246, 0.026675846427679062, 0.011497958563268185, -0.018171871080994606, 0.009824019856750965, 0.04643590748310089, 0.012027275748550892, 0.024160105735063553, 0.028004581108689308, -0.042637553066015244, 0.04810680076479912, -0.037538252770900726, 0.0645124763250351, -0.00520645547658205, 0.044126708060503006, 0.05524224042892456, -0.017490912228822708, -0.017768628895282745, 0.030087973922491074, 0.07226526737213135, -0.03590621054172516, -0.02540699951350689, -0.02966330014169216, -0.03924417123198509, 0.007670160848647356, -0.010721046477556229, -0.041340459138154984, -0.025668803602457047, -0.0032048055436462164, -0.017810974270105362, 0.056763965636491776, -0.01102398056536913, 0.01320394966751337, 0.005263696424663067, 0.018321508541703224, -0.0032737436704337597, 0.006241696421056986, -0.05120769515633583, 0.014033247716724873, 0.004342708736658096, 0.019619710743427277, 0.06940438598394394, -0.02719103731215, 0.00455316249281168, 0.005744727328419685, 0.06778888404369354, 0.03725552186369896, 0.0021263707894831896, 0.023267891258001328, -0.028066229075193405, 0.04294899106025696, 0.0143464095890522, -0.0416250079870224, -0.018702641129493713, 0.059535738080739975, 0.04630276933312416, -0.044124215841293335, 0.045683812350034714, -0.01665485091507435, 0.04883338883519173, 0.0506962351500988, 0.0077681634575128555, -0.038462184369564056, -0.03573068231344223, 0.015065883286297321, 0.044649556279182434, -0.002895632293075323, -0.0022426387295126915, -0.029079142957925797, 0.04249725863337517, -0.03271586075425148, -0.027886081486940384, 0.015169229358434677, 0.020569246262311935, -0.018144812434911728, -0.0033890954218804836, 0.0841032862663269, 0.023936325684189796, -0.014512104913592339, -0.02622980996966362, 0.09104804694652557, 0.09460103511810303, 0.04567890614271164, -0.05010390654206276, 0.017555320635437965, -0.009586138650774956, -0.034785591065883636, 0.014138582162559032, 0.011089224368333817, -0.01750929281115532, -0.017053304240107536, 0.02279350534081459, 0.008343291468918324, 0.006287890020757914, 0.030053868889808655, -0.0028970970306545496, 0.0358303003013134, 0.0075980727560818195, -0.05105423182249069, -0.05242428183555603, 0.021129129454493523, -0.01669926568865776, -0.0033162953332066536, -0.08082476258277893, -0.007813974283635616, -0.02098042331635952, 0.06511250138282776, -0.00014124854351393878, 0.028091982007026672, 0.0044886525720357895, 0.04263179004192352, -0.0012463588500395417, -0.03645608201622963, -0.05755738914012909, -0.021525902673602104, -0.02854924276471138, -0.048217907547950745, -0.09972301870584488, 0.01159259770065546, -0.019809305667877197, -0.001150015159510076, 0.01791614666581154, 0.03548009693622589, 0.029781419783830643, -0.010729405097663403, 0.033900827169418335, 0.004726978950202465, -0.009654045104980469, 0.08918832987546921, -0.028264136984944344, 0.07913225889205933, 0.01967315748333931, -0.007250762544572353, 0.03293409198522568, 0.029941994696855545, 0.03798452019691467, 0.012795677408576012, -0.024240927770733833, 0.011407813057303429, 0.0055009364150464535, 0.0527462512254715, 0.008269383572041988, -0.06749033182859421, 0.009752178564667702, -0.00434525404125452, -0.06407731026411057, 0.01021826732903719, 0.03061009757220745, -0.020796142518520355, -0.0061377836391329765, 0.03601342812180519, -0.024917611852288246, -0.06080956757068634, -0.09300069510936737, 0.0031337467953562737, -0.0007442882051691413, -0.005445797927677631, 0.005436250474303961, 0.012175395153462887, 0.017074987292289734, -0.008543409407138824, 0.0066971792839467525, -0.025074254721403122, 0.010714794509112835, 0.008277065120637417, -0.049268484115600586, 0.043562792241573334, 0.007149114273488522, 0.0561385415494442, -0.008434390649199486, 0.0799027532339096, -0.037471186369657516, -0.07335851341485977, 0.017214559018611908, -0.046274494379758835, -0.007774596568197012, 0.013747729361057281, -0.03153908625245094, 0.013933531939983368, -0.0005657309084199369, -0.02664342150092125, 0.037398625165224075, -0.02936709299683571, 0.06024959310889244, 0.016231775283813477, -0.00926771480590105, 0.0014158253325149417, 0.005211315583437681, 0.016598492860794067, -0.004690620116889477, -0.0031874594278633595, -0.0022362449672073126, -0.023783892393112183, -0.029988981783390045, 0.05011181905865669, 0.01925080083310604, -0.05682588368654251, 0.017882879823446274, 0.09294236451387405, 0.016873324289917946, 0.011668876744806767, 0.028893863782286644, 0.03208329901099205, -0.04593075439333916, 0.01769128069281578, 0.01698516495525837, -0.008030214346945286, 0.02732735313475132, 0.02075125463306904, 0.009879179298877716, 0.03923836350440979, -0.012169284746050835, 0.034776125103235245, 0.04493176192045212, 0.022954117506742477, 0.0007713994127698243, 0.0002289795666001737, 0.0064811971969902515, 0.024248095229268074, 0.009388735517859459, 0.01132826879620552, 0.024136554449796677, 0.03042132593691349, 0.004378930199891329, 0.010756390169262886, -0.03033355437219143, 0.035794466733932495, -0.022309597581624985, -0.03406386077404022, 0.013714130036532879, 0.024141672998666763, -0.0005634856643155217, -0.01015050895512104, -0.027284111827611923, -0.008825581520795822, -0.03503190726041794, 0.007253739051520824, -0.00019130595319438726, -0.008343013934791088, 0.015141861513257027, 0.036246877163648605, 0.010159267112612724, 0.019149037078022957, 0.0014678831212222576, 0.02325986698269844, -0.0016735431272536516, -0.03053826093673706, 0.009201748296618462, -0.006863470189273357, -0.0012576257577165961, 0.0041788783855736256, -0.011622757650911808, -0.013309754431247711, 0.05058365687727928, 0.0054786065593361855, -0.046664778143167496, -0.002986972453072667, -0.0026304256170988083, 0.0008947734022513032, -0.021674955263733864, -0.06402565538883209, 0.038653671741485596, 0.001992207719013095, -0.019329197704792023, 0.049241118133068085, -0.041602618992328644, -0.049719519913196564, 0.01929471082985401, 0.0026020770892500877, 0.011484017595648766, -0.005590824410319328, 0.05329873040318489, -0.013906297273933887, -0.057588156312704086, -0.011846821755170822, -0.06291413307189941, -0.0639464408159256, 0.03115995228290558, -0.006021925248205662, 0.018362868577241898, -0.0033123469911515713, -0.04791146144270897, 0.0379437617957592, 0.04453741014003754, 0.006515756715089083, -0.015401456505060196, -0.008688550442457199, -0.02542785368859768, -0.008248590864241123, -0.007057409267872572, 0.02633245289325714, 0.008401686325669289, 0.03163409233093262, -0.015776077285408974, 0.03720218688249588, 0.0369395837187767, 0.009283543564379215, 0.0008641713648103178, -0.0009684709366410971, 0.02677791938185692, -0.020738612860441208, 0.02301247976720333, 0.011478379368782043, -0.006241729948669672, 0.015568932518362999, -0.003260009689256549, 0.02129169926047325, 0.02984980307519436, -0.04296907037496567, 0.022172072902321815, -0.025260455906391144, 0.0047956048510968685, -0.0034979211632162333, -0.0002535840612836182, 0.032194048166275024, -0.010533247143030167, -0.05048131197690964, -0.028630388900637627, 0.009670665487647057, -0.01789405755698681, 0.0016449502436444163, 0.03920435532927513, 0.017591658979654312, 0.04704679176211357, -0.007711929269134998, -0.0202126894146204, -0.013569585978984833, 0.03140311688184738, 0.0110945338383317, -0.036175135523080826, 0.045222263783216476, 0.03994542360305786, 0.01008620299398899, -0.028057120740413666, -0.042213037610054016, -0.024683097377419472, -0.055527180433273315, 0.00627319747582078, -0.0352628268301487, 0.035289257764816284, 0.000028738648325088434, 0.01613948494195938, 0.01663934253156185, -0.04194345325231552, -0.026323070749640465, -0.0021032891236245632, -0.06750689446926117, 0.02007305435836315, -0.03511040285229683, 0.019271738827228546, 0.013929691165685654, -0.024690086022019386, 0.03260479494929314, -0.009528500027954578, 0.008615227416157722, -0.024418067187070847, -0.007188009098172188, -0.02851002849638462, 0.013672667555510998, -0.023356007412075996, -0.021168207749724388, -0.008012243546545506, 0.01469145342707634, -0.007138790097087622, -0.024298781529068947, -0.027958858758211136, 0.01674494333565235, -0.01869123801589012, 0.019953543320298195, -0.02390555664896965, -0.02792051061987877, -0.010256399400532246, 0.021004367619752884, 0.04723485931754112, -0.005823716055601835, -0.028574366122484207, 0.022073494270443916, 0.03247857466340065, 0.03182806447148323, 0.017490629106760025, 0.021051958203315735, -0.036962635815143585, -0.012167559005320072, -0.031778398901224136, -0.0011705170618370175, 0.03485185652971268, 0.021657835692167282, 0.0006954974378459156, 0.06451170891523361, 0.031501803547143936, -0.03317062184214592, 0.009045200422406197, 0.03609922155737877, 0.06642097234725952, -0.008147385902702808, -0.06545566022396088, 0.012546618469059467, -0.010969390161335468, -0.019877783954143524, 0.022739285603165627, 0.01093493215739727, -0.032682064920663834, 0.0029848946724087, 0.04816634580492973, -0.010328222997486591, -0.05656222626566887, 0.027336742728948593, 0.017758212983608246, 0.015698391944169998, 0.04733011871576309, -0.03396562114357948, 0.008809935301542282, 0.035614654421806335, 0.002746232785284519, 0.034098848700523376, 0.01452647801488638, -0.0823768749833107, 0.023046333342790604, 0.03742286190390587, 0.012075577862560749, -0.08099693059921265, 0.0170329250395298, -0.020744778215885162, 0.03947914019227028, 0.01597711816430092, -0.04347565397620201, -0.03510431572794914, -0.03348817676305771, -0.007952789776027203, -0.02105940505862236, 0.006332480814307928, -0.06282083690166473, 0.01860935427248478, -0.0031143170781433582, 0.014962858520448208, -0.03345510736107826, -0.04448630288243294, -0.022351406514644623, 0.04168305918574333, 0.030242161825299263, 0.02598917856812477, 0.009833857417106628, 0.004500457551330328, 0.03798629716038704, 0.019840283319354057, -0.016529817134141922, -0.07472062855958939, 0.0166925135999918, 0.02868039533495903, 0.022195301949977875, 0.06161733716726303, -0.0026768448296934366, -0.014020135626196861, 0.004601535852998495, -0.023220837116241455, 0.006737513933330774, 0.015008951537311077, -0.061449386179447174, 0.04662393406033516, 0.01629948429763317, 0.038484856486320496, 0.06283985078334808, 0.02079828642308712, 0.018908187747001648, 0.0016278065741062164, 0.005355169530957937, 0.017778467386960983, -0.08406644314527512, -0.028283042833209038, -0.029412006959319115, -0.00794669147580862, 0.021175576373934746, 0.022058798000216484, -0.006090463139116764, 0.03979532793164253, -0.03056703507900238, -0.018180062994360924, -0.02105301432311535, 0.033155035227537155, -0.019302252680063248, -0.012204096652567387, -0.009749925695359707, 0.011027554981410503, -0.03566371276974678, -0.04562193900346756, -0.02498517371714115, -0.02870873175561428, 0.021908503025770187, -0.006939943414181471, -0.02272750437259674, 0.022765904664993286, 0.0029275096021592617, -0.0249498151242733, 0.015604259446263313, -0.019251447170972824, 0.011682884767651558, -0.028089744970202446, 0.029457394033670425, -0.038672011345624924, -0.056373730301856995, 0.00436865258961916, 0.014301777817308903, 0.011927084065973759, 0.04020415619015694, 0.0048232851549983025, 0.027696406468749046, 0.02988487295806408, -0.042048919945955276, -0.08698543161153793, -0.04584980756044388, -0.03390701487660408, -0.024046601727604866, 0.0032810501288622618, 0.0018244372913613915, -0.01650676131248474, -0.009573504328727722, -0.03355390951037407, -0.031980231404304504, 0.07296446710824966, -0.003698023734614253, -0.00654340535402298, 0.01382069569081068, 0.0076269349083304405, 0.08221673220396042, -0.027012011036276817, -0.004942478146404028, 0.027861589565873146, -0.05320211872458458, -0.014246554113924503, -0.026458371430635452, -0.01576291397213936, -0.014034377411007881, 0.017030252143740654, -0.03973506763577461, -0.011440626345574856, 0.05682503432035446, 0.0008698907331563532, 0.000018930486476165242, 0.06295651942491531, -0.005137622822076082, 0.004910180810838938, -0.03467405587434769, 0.02268218621611595, -0.038408663123846054, 0.007353469729423523, 0.015441943891346455, 0.037541162222623825, -0.025673391297459602, -0.03190609812736511, 0.07602861523628235, -0.059987470507621765, -0.03321985527873039, 0.03953015059232712, 0.08045884966850281, -0.01944804936647415, 0.0006114629213698208, -0.010806010104715824, 0.010043710470199585, 0.04785811901092529, 0.014044256880879402, 0.0104853305965662, 0.002919355873018503, 0.027711696922779083, -0.017643561586737633, -0.05015666037797928, -0.044803619384765625, -0.00378045835532248, 0.05092405900359154, -0.005325267557054758, 0.017838366329669952, 0.03233042359352112, 0.0034231217578053474, -0.021663101390004158, 0.014097068458795547, 0.014025119133293629, -0.013311352580785751, 0.01199603546410799, 0.037668999284505844, -0.020434213802218437, -0.038645271211862564, 0.030353708192706108, 0.013781384564936161, 0.014482121914625168, 0.03978097811341286, 0.02569543570280075, 0.06576991081237793, 0.029835673049092293, -0.011227292008697987, -0.023855019360780716, 0.03695300593972206, -0.04099659621715546, 0.029771575704216957, -0.046846162527799606, -0.03558085486292839, 0.017032163217663765, 0.06586670875549316, -0.0248671043664217, -0.040440578013658524, -0.025133606046438217, -0.023029882460832596, 0.02713881805539131, 0.032786011695861816, -0.019182847812771797, 0.021057816222310066, -0.024929752573370934, 0.029761841520667076, 0.01080392301082611, 0.03855819255113602, -0.03856871277093887, -0.07766292989253998, 0.0009200352360494435, -0.013785635121166706, -0.004232336301356554, 0.029915107414126396, -0.009366028010845184, -0.026912834495306015, 0.00622662203386426, -0.053796131163835526, -0.02415494993329048, -0.009659986943006516, 0.03534938395023346, 0.007233747746795416, 0.042621854692697525, -0.018029937520623207, 0.0013767075724899769, 0.015324082225561142, -0.009452138096094131, 0.0943748876452446, 0.0717172846198082, 0.007694106083363295, -0.046520691365003586, 0.019548416137695312, -0.0029212862718850374, -0.014525359496474266, -0.030872641131281853, 0.008309717290103436, 0.00653425045311451, -0.010085618123412132, 0.07011634111404419, 0.06697570532560349, 0.023480094969272614, 0.01804220676422119, 0.06324148178100586, -0.013678004033863544, -0.011510491371154785, -0.0013304963940754533, 0.009044020436704159, 0.034645721316337585, -0.04919781535863876, -0.005882604513317347, -0.03635291010141373, -0.015453360974788666, -0.00683265645056963, 0.0017119457479566336, 0.021100621670484543, -0.03452511876821518, 0.03990362957119942, -0.02163112908601761, -0.016482073813676834, 0.003488866612315178, 0.0007741950685158372, 0.0011979152914136648, -0.028101785108447075, 0.006472432520240545, -0.021351905539631844, 0.035391468554735184, 0.02787896990776062, -0.004209338687360287, -0.006122557446360588, 0.007776413578540087, 0.014257464557886124, -0.08438871055841446, 0.004810767248272896, -0.023009900003671646, -0.006854046601802111, -0.030839571729302406, -0.0032165548764169216, -0.012014565989375114, 0.0013329999055713415, -0.0034818598069250584, -0.022713754326105118, -0.02501327358186245, -0.003689886536449194, -0.0032959545496851206, -0.027953363955020905, -0.03751832991838455, -0.05765918642282486, 0.014986435882747173, -0.0031127301044762135, 0.04280507564544678, 0.015482023358345032, -0.06510831415653229, -0.0004909456474706531, 0.004937092773616314, 0.04170392453670502, -0.0159807950258255, -0.03667859733104706, 0.02374657802283764, -0.023872027173638344, -0.031420640647411346, -0.010919948108494282, 0.02712227590382099, 0.04041992872953415, 0.004346040543168783, -0.014136293902993202, 0.004931019619107246, -0.010368846356868744, -0.017277613282203674, -0.004940509796142578, -0.04141629859805107, -0.015406613238155842, -0.07189731299877167, 0.020857203751802444, 0.025059454143047333, 0.033437538892030716, -0.010453109629452229, 0.003764428896829486, 0.01941533572971821, 0.021146437153220177, 0.007900425232946873, -0.0716005191206932, -0.04879925400018692, -0.033172428607940674, -0.03526608645915985, 0.0013413538690656424, 0.014955898746848106, 0.029695795848965645, 0.024769257754087448, 0.004866270814090967, -0.02554989606142044, 0.03051413968205452, -0.029231315478682518, 0.019428271800279617, 0.015198985114693642, -0.06529679149389267, -0.0452159158885479, 0.03380068764090538, 0.012493032030761242, -0.02491133101284504, -0.01856148988008499, -0.04943985491991043, 0.003238060511648655, 0.008155408315360546, -0.014475014060735703, -0.03820504993200302, -0.021922878921031952, -0.0201492328196764, 0.016973888501524925, -0.02192656509578228, -0.002026317873969674, -0.055500052869319916, -0.009049403481185436, 0.042593300342559814, 0.004549864679574966, -0.014049358665943146, 0.03574198856949806, 0.005233313422650099, 0.03522151708602905, -0.003514357842504978, 0.0057011195458471775, -0.0009954646229743958, 0.01952427253127098, -0.011622470803558826, -0.03137096390128136, 0.064093679189682, -0.04668157920241356, 0.0032334632705897093, 0.061064086854457855, -0.06890002638101578, -0.020565498620271683, 0.00005301224155118689, 0.007677787449210882, 0.030825139954686165, 0.02700871229171753, 0.024600641801953316, 0.02336292155086994, 0.029638776555657387, -0.018092729151248932, 0.007568755187094212, -0.014925225637853146, 0.018174119293689728, -0.0026624868623912334, -0.022667324170470238, -0.003651583334431052, -0.002848972100764513, 0.00247666472569108, 0.03990675136446953, 0.061572249978780746, 0.010037191212177277, -0.00032238359563052654, 0.026672733947634697, -0.011316674761474133, -0.004096508026123047, 0.010424871928989887, -0.01810113899409771, -0.020050257444381714, 0.03052879124879837, -0.025171758607029915, 0.02997281402349472, 0.009714769199490547, 0.014787647873163223, -0.06255411356687546, -0.014855222776532173, -0.0043318565003573895, 0.03774001821875572, 0.013037406839430332, 0.01963100954890251, 0.0038072390016168356, -0.01445415522903204, -0.027115192264318466, 0.004544786177575588, -0.03718799352645874, -0.0216276403516531, -0.06250574439764023, 0.01591678336262703, -0.014920499175786972, -0.0061323679983615875, 0.024632809683680534, 0.021864240989089012, 0.03106514737010002, 0.005806084722280502, 0.008105358108878136, -0.004591660108417273, 0.011454879306256771, 0.015720726922154427, 0.011331756599247456, -0.060145072638988495, 0.04982571676373482, -0.051276832818984985, -0.011199629865586758, 0.01880321092903614, -0.006366743240505457, 0.02232409454882145, -0.0012270017759874463, 0.012106065638363361, 0.019346194341778755, 0.02436579391360283, 0.05773713067173958, 0.011566032655537128, -0.011809488758444786, -0.02088746428489685, -0.0002871032920666039, 0.033809080719947815, -0.02720123901963234, 0.0031274857465177774, -0.0166336540132761, -0.0230852160602808, 0.0008234073175117373, 0.0009707601857371628, -0.01465962827205658, -0.01874598115682602, 0.028549501672387123, -0.022848181426525116, 0.005829490255564451, -0.005501710344105959, 0.01730675995349884, -0.06891552358865738, 0.013349862769246101, 0.06032487377524376, 0.011476002633571625, -0.038240786641836166, 0.011182342655956745, -0.008297125808894634, -0.048868272453546524, -0.0035390995908528566, 0.01827174425125122, -0.02978048287332058, -0.06497018039226532, -0.02511920966207981, 0.007994542829692364, 0.024669259786605835, -0.0577586404979229, -0.0030483382288366556, 0.006841767113655806, 0.050143901258707047, -0.010517571121454239, -0.014933880418539047, 0.010366461239755154, -0.02017073519527912, 0.0054503693245351315, -0.07144015282392502, 0.06492874026298523, 0.026695439592003822, -0.018654504790902138, 0.004440745338797569, -0.013831309042870998, -0.048508089035749435, 0.021201256662607193, 0.0750332921743393, -0.016108766198158264, -0.014372349716722965, 0.016659343615174294, 0.03206877410411835, -0.016640927642583847, -0.04794955998659134, 0.05997545272111893, 0.003183990716934204, -0.025717193260788918, -0.0024359640665352345, -0.013656090945005417, 0.007002719212323427, -0.013555626384913921, 0.029707351699471474, -0.006709620356559753, -0.0033948211930692196, -0.014431875199079514, -0.028491144999861717, 0.02290496416389942, 0.021840276196599007, -0.0012259968789294362, 0.041884321719408035, -0.030251482501626015, 0.03871488943696022, 0.034007731825113297, 0.012571180239319801, -0.01700189895927906, 0.047174111008644104, -0.04418693855404854, -0.05335008352994919, 0.02105231210589409, 0.001891706488095224, -0.02093467488884926, -0.04917971044778824, 0.03296046331524849, 0.04759220778942108, -0.04420674219727516, 0.010764742270112038, 0.03243367373943329, 0.025063402950763702, 0.029411939904093742, 0.025217922404408455, 0.009338856674730778, 0.018637802451848984, -0.02901178039610386, 0.04389995336532593, 0.033030446618795395, 0.05389242619276047, 0.014243174344301224, -0.011370150372385979, 0.01484356913715601, -0.014261369593441486, 0.021534286439418793, -0.03393424302339554, 0.034181442111730576, -0.0520721860229969, -0.053772084414958954, 0.016516180709004402, -0.0038946252316236496, 0.015392178669571877, -0.009294544346630573, -0.002752042841166258, 0.057953786104917526, -0.023447509855031967, 0.00546493474394083, -0.03155641630291939, 0.009642078541219234, -0.02568514458835125, 0.0027334473561495543, 0.052911628037691116, 0.012547912076115608, 0.006334087811410427, 0.009496082551777363, 0.00350038125179708, -0.029003499075770378, -0.009860135614871979, 0.0020352459978312254, 0.0224964190274477, -0.026920562610030174, -0.014042992144823074, -0.05556494742631912, 0.0072903139516711235, -0.03266852721571922, -0.0014476265059784055, 0.006609622854739428, 0.021644987165927887, 0.024062665179371834, -0.00904256571084261, -0.03314145281910896, 0.012863148003816605, 0.06623957306146622, -0.07790977507829666, -0.025976480916142464, -0.021722450852394104, 0.010576550848782063, 0.004968810360878706, 0.011495276354253292 ]
<p><a href="http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/JCLI4253.1" rel="nofollow">Perkins et al. (2007)</a> introduce a "skill score" for measuring climate model output against observations. The score basically consists of measuring the overlap between probability density functions of the model (m), and the observations (o); for some variable (eg. maximum daily temperature). It is calculated as </p> <p>$$S_{score} = \int^\infty_{-\infty} min[pdf(m),\ pdf(o)]$$</p> <p>I'm trying to wrap my head around bayesian conditional distributions, and not getting far. This seems related, in that it's some measure of the likelihood of the model being a good estimate of the observations. However, I can't figure out if it's equivalent or not.</p> <p>Given $P(m|o) = \frac{P(o|m)P(m)}{P(o)}$, is it correct that $P(m)=\int^\infty_{-\infty} pdf(m)=1$, and the same for the obs? Or am I missing something big here?</p>
48,610
[ -0.016347594559192657, -0.028229357674717903, -0.0033649804536253214, 0.012513234280049801, 0.03466397523880005, 0.04286043718457222, -0.02160387858748436, -0.04049202427268028, 0.01142312865704298, -0.016490967944264412, 0.026322655379772186, 0.03581433743238449, 0.06020249053835869, 0.015120303258299828, 0.004919369705021381, 0.018220288679003716, -0.014860715717077255, 0.029415244236588478, -0.01819501630961895, -0.012795346789062023, -0.018844351172447205, 0.034624505788087845, 0.04517131298780441, -0.02178245596587658, -0.02683989517390728, 0.03501660376787186, 0.025063445791602135, -0.01401524804532528, 0.02292606048285961, 0.05371024087071419, -0.026653720065951347, -0.02818969078361988, 0.02619769424200058, 0.05952942743897438, 0.004885517060756683, -0.006975623778998852, 0.0008197809802368283, -0.02836688607931137, 0.010025217197835445, 0.03951968252658844, -0.030070265755057335, -0.00875627901405096, 0.0005209100781939924, 0.014794654212892056, -0.00448234798386693, 0.00742341810837388, 0.0051057832315564156, -0.029057642444968224, 0.0254493597894907, -0.03932913392782211, 0.03970487415790558, 0.03777752444148064, 0.018807627260684967, 0.0379449836909771, -0.0016826558858156204, -0.010834499262273312, 0.09048496931791306, 0.08258544653654099, 0.005886458791792393, -0.035799674689769745, -0.03875543922185898, -0.049193717539310455, 0.0045944564044475555, 0.011404452845454216, -0.02816772274672985, 0.02922838181257248, 0.0038373463321477175, -0.029510097578167915, 0.023630991578102112, 0.026342494413256645, -0.011291145347058773, 0.03355566784739494, 0.0012856109533458948, -0.0008503459976054728, 0.034061744809150696, -0.007225715555250645, 0.019520850852131844, 0.031199363991618156, 0.02056598663330078, 0.02674553543329239, 0.025792252272367477, 0.010875081643462181, 0.01310777012258768, 0.05027270317077637, 0.030698344111442566, -0.013494868762791157, 0.07361602783203125, -0.029327746480703354, 0.02054646983742714, -0.0016763125313445926, -0.05991422384977341, 0.013200943358242512, 0.016678061336278915, -0.0253991037607193, -0.05602448061108589, 0.03754907101392746, 0.007521061226725578, 0.027482684701681137, -0.010640053078532219, -0.0030584202613681555, -0.019062766805291176, -0.06346464157104492, 0.006239107344299555, 0.041148100048303604, -0.031805455684661865, -0.0013132093008607626, -0.008668371476233006, -0.008976994082331657, -0.032225172966718674, -0.031896792352199554, -0.02704462967813015, 0.019359858706593513, -0.0045067789033055305, 0.019260838627815247, 0.006567451637238264, -0.0472562201321125, 0.017140481621026993, -0.006186319515109062, 0.05095357447862625, 0.032317694276571274, 0.03960559517145157, 0.016192283481359482, 0.016267359256744385, -0.03920824080705643, -0.09066757559776306, 0.0065948739647865295, -0.001104526105336845, -0.01497223787009716, -0.037378035485744476, 0.03888462483882904, -0.001631100196391344, 0.00006979591125855222, 0.032224833965301514, 0.022444095462560654, 0.02025996521115303, -0.0131830470636487, -0.064415343105793, -0.010428243316709995, 0.04366747662425041, 0.016230078414082527, -0.0068636671639978886, -0.06698102504014969, 0.01063329167664051, 0.011041421443223953, 0.03954850882291794, -0.0005343080847524107, 0.06205107644200325, -0.016230786219239235, 0.05455844849348068, -0.02587839588522911, -0.025727545842528343, -0.013316926546394825, -0.022599879652261734, -0.02127433381974697, -0.019264254719018936, -0.0798659548163414, 0.013383514247834682, 0.03207549825310707, 0.004710063338279724, -0.010168291628360748, 0.06452865153551102, 0.007784742396324873, 0.02534562163054943, -0.03374946862459183, 0.01814230903983116, -0.05076879635453224, 0.05489426106214523, -0.008545788936316967, 0.04462902992963791, 0.012252498418092728, 0.0107621680945158, -0.03688584268093109, 0.0015955452108755708, 0.035742875188589096, 0.08516956865787506, -0.04311316832900047, -0.007964256219565868, -0.035713884979486465, -0.0030137680005282164, 0.011339441873133183, -0.028633514419198036, 0.02734082192182541, 0.004066983237862587, -0.029816728085279465, 0.022452497854828835, 0.03216221556067467, -0.012194781564176083, -0.011705220676958561, 0.003562521655112505, -0.08063582330942154, -0.054248929023742676, -0.07287930697202682, -0.020167358219623566, -0.01871679350733757, 0.008348491974174976, 0.045636486262083054, -0.002202817006036639, 0.040665626525878906, -0.008282136172056198, -0.0056761689484119415, -0.04025188833475113, -0.00557019654661417, 0.037556882947683334, -0.03305649012327194, 0.020265601575374603, 0.05498833954334259, 0.048564612865448, 0.022089052945375443, 0.006095469929277897, -0.0380418561398983, -0.08186397701501846, -0.013245235197246075, -0.047965098172426224, 0.036234382539987564, -0.012623083777725697, -0.017914127558469772, 0.03951355069875717, -0.02084987983107567, 0.0012520266463980079, -0.03498955816030502, -0.02832084149122238, 0.02663573995232582, 0.06661135703325272, 0.01504718977957964, -0.009991127997636795, 0.028719905763864517, -0.0005649165832437575, 0.04147733002901077, -0.011230957694351673, 0.026659218594431877, -0.025682050734758377, -0.01987687684595585, 0.05261017009615898, 0.026329899206757545, -0.03880682960152626, 0.02736375853419304, 0.053409747779369354, -0.012401716783642769, 0.030679717659950256, 0.009040525183081627, 0.021480601280927658, -0.0073599847964942455, 0.008283973671495914, 0.0174226313829422, 0.013251864351332188, 0.023956002667546272, 0.027864521369338036, -0.014215271919965744, 0.018084684386849403, 0.002984672551974654, -0.0100118862465024, 0.02239830419421196, -0.013532432727515697, 0.023833386600017548, -0.043964933604002, -0.003097779583185911, 0.03639102727174759, -0.028064601123332977, -0.024664290249347687, 0.04564789682626724, 0.029635492712259293, 0.01403799094259739, 0.00040506196091882885, -0.017696939408779144, 0.032429199665784836, 0.019120628014206886, -0.031469669193029404, -0.054098136723041534, 0.018962053582072258, -0.027889488264918327, 0.011079272255301476, 0.020431088283658028, -0.02459646202623844, -0.0487205944955349, 0.04644716531038284, 0.014953522942960262, -0.014712663367390633, 0.003971472382545471, -0.028297048062086105, -0.05564888194203377, -0.012682548724114895, 0.019490081816911697, 0.003896806389093399, 0.018759459257125854, -0.044776059687137604, -0.014066987670958042, -0.036781568080186844, -0.01570259965956211, 0.04939625412225723, -0.025018129497766495, -0.025826208293437958, -0.008674845099449158, -0.0012148339301347733, -0.005381553899496794, -0.031680960208177567, -0.033400148153305054, -0.005957304500043392, -0.0017589034978300333, -0.025913218036293983, 0.05003415793180466, 0.013070594519376755, -0.031098628416657448, 0.03983040153980255, -0.022392766550183296, -0.04884178191423416, -0.02125711552798748, -0.0069356560707092285, 0.001304826932027936, 0.014977709390223026, 0.0421447791159153, 0.01875798963010311, -0.043338846415281296, -0.012683830223977566, -0.05740023031830788, -0.07690112292766571, 0.023615920916199684, -0.017261061817407608, 0.019018888473510742, 0.015320844016969204, -0.042363520711660385, 0.07124428451061249, 0.01545602548867464, -0.005170376505702734, -0.02782950922846794, 0.0251071285456419, -0.0421786792576313, -0.00804775208234787, -0.04361255094408989, 0.008333588019013405, -0.012424396350979805, 0.04940352588891983, -0.027655640617012978, 0.012584609910845757, 0.006671753711998463, -0.006506956648081541, 0.01674036867916584, 0.010204088874161243, -0.025326354429125786, -0.006326812785118818, 0.007215442135930061, 0.010436614975333214, 0.022513525560498238, -0.000400644785258919, -0.033394705504179, 0.00990221742540598, 0.033100664615631104, -0.01153893955051899, 0.026904813945293427, -0.020952580496668816, 0.00672841677442193, -0.0677139088511467, 0.04727399721741676, -0.010519401170313358, -0.018077000975608826, 0.003767329966649413, 0.013052734546363354, 0.025774626061320305, 0.01625111512839794, 0.012481346726417542, 0.06254811584949493, 0.03304775059223175, 0.018068579956889153, -0.04752543196082115, -0.021875742822885513, 0.010654625482857227, -0.0010115740587934852, 0.010732773691415787, -0.030561430379748344, 0.058626964688301086, 0.019320104271173477, -0.0034393109381198883, -0.02431851252913475, -0.045148421078920364, -0.010939929634332657, -0.0509641133248806, -0.020766248926520348, -0.02542087808251381, 0.03710734471678734, 0.007378582842648029, 0.04775242507457733, 0.0023517629597336054, 0.014222491532564163, 0.014015529304742813, 0.011888253502547741, -0.05596790835261345, 0.048456449061632156, 0.012816477566957474, -0.05716138705611229, -0.02264329046010971, 0.002952979179099202, 0.06830862164497375, -0.02127896063029766, 0.015788983553647995, 0.011155459098517895, 0.049912434071302414, -0.011880419217050076, 0.008235776796936989, -0.049198780208826065, -0.03238016739487648, 0.003379839239642024, -0.009229681454598904, 0.024180684238672256, -0.0384117029607296, 0.04989081993699074, 0.0702328234910965, -0.024420706555247307, -0.03778634965419769, -0.013670426793396473, 0.0190593134611845, 0.0030077702831476927, -0.01295847725123167, 0.04675986245274544, 0.04403041675686836, -0.0544389933347702, 0.04997164383530617, 0.04204775020480156, 0.036406684666872025, 0.05324121192097664, -0.012759704142808914, -0.013929123058915138, -0.002996233059093356, -0.01584358885884285, 0.06877493113279343, 0.009332328103482723, -0.012040538713335991, -0.006847471464425325, 0.03824104368686676, 0.002033537719398737, -0.0503724068403244, 0.03329033777117729, 0.041167084127664566, -0.018210124224424362, 0.014162133447825909, -0.04808334633708, -0.018739739432930946, -0.052868083119392395, 0.008437459357082844, 0.01974538341164589, 0.04424187168478966, -0.025754734873771667, -0.019415564835071564, 0.024649158120155334, -0.03692038729786873, 0.00360455852933228, -0.022194014862179756, 0.027381276711821556, 0.05246414244174957, 0.01629464142024517, -0.01226547360420227, 0.037246353924274445, 0.06125413998961449, 0.019302131608128548, 0.0001787673099897802, -0.0051234751008450985, -0.09634149819612503, -0.011720342561602592, 0.03413432836532593, 0.011652165092527866, -0.02469799481332302, 0.01812220737338066, -0.07284650951623917, 0.004935161676257849, 0.027210915461182594, -0.0069633908569812775, 0.019463246688246727, 0.012021122500300407, 0.022912804037332535, 0.0051195500418543816, -0.004644538275897503, -0.03453453257679939, 0.0151517353951931, 0.011837421916425228, 0.017874162644147873, 0.0029823363292962313, -0.03700229898095131, -0.03493818640708923, 0.017266089096665382, -0.00740364333614707, 0.03856325522065163, -0.03031318262219429, -0.016395321115851402, 0.0014639851870015264, -0.014476862736046314, -0.009454176761209965, -0.06751125305891037, -0.014480245299637318, -0.003965754993259907, -0.03990582004189491, 0.024125004187226295, -0.02251025103032589, -0.04285259172320366, 0.025207221508026123, 0.010417288169264793, -0.023129235953092575, -0.013763661496341228, -0.028727425262331963, 0.058314401656389236, -0.008277688175439835, 0.022920818999409676, 0.044102009385824203, 0.036601584404706955, 0.0011911287438124418, 0.011274341493844986, -0.032109782099723816, 0.03254717215895653, -0.048114389181137085, -0.024478990584611893, -0.04582307115197182, -0.00741871353238821, -0.025618840008974075, 0.005672462750226259, 0.039752665907144547, 0.03726765140891075, -0.006288211327046156, -0.013202251866459846, -0.0020883935503661633, 0.0195540152490139, -0.0021515721455216408, -0.01904943585395813, -0.0028030986431986094, 0.03234625235199928, -0.0023627623450011015, -0.004069058690220118, 0.010336097329854965, -0.01708337850868702, -0.0008879326051101089, -0.030709562823176384, -0.039403222501277924, 0.056029871106147766, -0.03335893154144287, -0.012088987976312637, 0.024228332564234734, -0.0020694115664809942, -0.006958572193980217, -0.004617555066943169, 0.026681451126933098, 0.015311713330447674, -0.033077023923397064, -0.01961921527981758, 0.016318002715706825, 0.013649774715304375, 0.019182942807674408, -0.04989193379878998, 0.01644393801689148, 0.026021549478173256, 0.005742453970015049, -0.042153406888246536, -0.016928911209106445, 0.0035720528103411198, -0.015197847038507462, -0.03010047785937786, -0.05109423026442528, -0.009545041248202324, -0.0311140026897192, -0.00539123360067606, -0.021181663498282433, 0.029938383027911186, -0.07153693586587906, -0.000599510211031884, -0.020102910697460175, 0.02170734293758869, 0.051557641476392746, -0.0012972737895324826, 0.002406747080385685, 0.04115491360425949, -0.02714398130774498, -0.03512720763683319, -0.0004070003633387387, 0.017500372603535652, -0.027531981468200684, -0.0030020829290151596, -0.016462527215480804, 0.009533272124826908, 0.042311929166316986, 0.01733374409377575, -0.030269885435700417, 0.04114207625389099, 0.01563357189297676, 0.020226726308465004, 0.022834105417132378, -0.02126757800579071, -0.021474288776516914, 0.00867540668696165, -0.0609649196267128, 0.005294926464557648, 0.031516920775175095, -0.03848499059677124, 0.012631908059120178, -0.00491134962067008, 0.0002781572111416608, 0.026073133572936058, 0.07074057310819626, -0.001864049700088799, 0.017588777467608452, 0.02342170663177967, -0.004407818429172039, 0.049152716994285583, 0.030038122087717056, 0.018592946231365204, 0.02107270434498787, 0.01141223032027483, -0.02521737851202488, -0.04353199526667595, -0.054955095052719116, -0.027489198371767998, 0.0445040725171566, -0.01539005246013403, 0.051465824246406555, 0.017364762723445892, 0.0025697159580886364, 0.014620018191635609, -0.0430142804980278, 0.011504068970680237, 0.0016794925322756171, -0.0018274469766765833, 0.035645920783281326, -0.032094914466142654, -0.015265471301972866, 0.03719487413764, -0.02716033346951008, -0.00877336785197258, 0.04190147668123245, -0.01592322438955307, 0.036145564168691635, 0.03539030998945236, -0.034223392605781555, -0.03627033159136772, 0.08703409880399704, -0.03650294989347458, -0.010764623992145061, -0.01392656471580267, -0.0367727093398571, 0.04645422473549843, 0.04062496870756149, -0.0018729260191321373, -0.05401391163468361, -0.013019290752708912, -0.03481364995241165, 0.04322288557887077, 0.04206907004117966, -0.03056527115404606, 0.028696220368146896, -0.02595551125705242, 0.04533549025654793, 0.008486475795507431, 0.004355036653578281, -0.048409782350063324, -0.06646446883678436, -0.024438874796032906, -0.0194920152425766, -0.043026722967624664, 0.0070495205000042915, 0.001483085216023028, -0.002387974178418517, 0.023627473041415215, -0.01653459295630455, -0.005810119677335024, -0.002108403015881777, 0.015275509096682072, -0.024783527478575706, 0.08038567751646042, 0.007000645622611046, 0.016636066138744354, -0.046562645584344864, -0.008167997933924198, 0.12141111493110657, 0.0788259208202362, 0.04419476166367531, -0.059187013655900955, 0.026831129565835, -0.013580030761659145, 0.012978464365005493, -0.05065125226974487, 0.002592993201687932, 0.02908848598599434, -0.021327966824173927, -0.0058058262802660465, 0.07569345831871033, 0.011395208537578583, -0.01461501233279705, 0.028472306206822395, -0.01388326846063137, -0.005556138698011637, 0.011469644494354725, 0.015734663233160973, -0.025341281667351723, -0.03693734481930733, -0.017545651644468307, -0.012848792597651482, 0.0005790300783701241, -0.0206903088837862, 0.010757180862128735, -0.017176497727632523, -0.03256344422698021, 0.004421609919518232, -0.007144446950405836, -0.022885235026478767, 0.009306460618972778, 0.020105643197894096, 0.028879230841994286, -0.009383855387568474, 0.0036874450743198395, -0.0004884803202003241, 0.007710955571383238, 0.055049750953912735, -0.0038556258659809828, -0.011592724360525608, 0.023798005655407906, -0.024774106219410896, -0.039132364094257355, -0.05497276037931442, -0.029862087219953537, 0.039527468383312225, -0.025788838043808937, 0.007930898107588291, -0.031356390565633774, -0.004092022776603699, -0.01761971414089203, -0.026211027055978775, 0.004788815043866634, 0.018374381586909294, 0.053997259587049484, -0.039798520505428314, -0.04838194698095322, -0.03767123818397522, 0.00140454713255167, -0.016597794368863106, 0.017880592495203018, 0.012015295214951038, -0.020513704046607018, -0.03773137927055359, -0.0030844579450786114, 0.057214826345443726, 0.02948312647640705, -0.0049528577364981174, -0.0023463089019060135, 0.014943454414606094, -0.037758734077215195, -0.009554684162139893, 0.024746114388108253, -0.03862031176686287, 0.021563639864325523, 0.010788464918732643, 0.009093261323869228, 0.010524543933570385, -0.061150047928094864, -0.006225808523595333, -0.03581317886710167, -0.03396176919341087, -0.024569829925894737, 0.00645371014252305, 0.042926885187625885, 0.031135329976677895, 0.02046915329992771, 0.030578503385186195, 0.024323346093297005, 0.03183404356241226, 0.014494136907160282, -0.06915471702814102, -0.015912339091300964, 0.015380209311842918, -0.02756107971072197, -0.005828372668474913, 0.04201846197247505, 0.03395004943013191, 0.02995365485548973, 0.048630326986312866, -0.007243654225021601, 0.03426918014883995, -0.01872098259627819, 0.03858952969312668, 0.001679583452641964, -0.036393605172634125, -0.01666034199297428, 0.01952751912176609, -0.003990341443568468, -0.0269733015447855, -0.012768642976880074, -0.013224468566477299, -0.003114541759714484, 0.01540490984916687, -0.0340300127863884, -0.06508200615644455, 0.00436357269063592, 0.0029854702297598124, 0.015707965940237045, -0.036360159516334534, 0.010795420035719872, -0.005684708245098591, -0.01451096311211586, -0.006375032011419535, -0.004814480897039175, 0.007940011098980904, 0.0024796570651233196, -0.03397936001420021, -0.01278031338006258, 0.026219479739665985, 0.017594391480088234, -0.01616629958152771, -0.039212871342897415, 0.008078211918473244, 0.0393529050052166, 0.06561363488435745, -0.027613189071416855, -0.017678067088127136, 0.07133623212575912, -0.04252665489912033, -0.06700745224952698, 0.05091562867164612, 0.04223870858550072, 0.06767373532056808, 0.006603968795388937, -0.015363049693405628, -0.037453871220350266, 0.04479391500353813, -0.0037021709140390158, 0.018970025703310966, -0.002200922230258584, -0.0062301307916641235, 0.003614073619246483, -0.010521480813622475, 0.015454196371138096, -0.008020774461328983, 0.008732560090720654, 0.014722555875778198, 0.03418334200978279, -0.007067552302032709, 0.007876789197325706, 0.0002158431598218158, -0.04843483120203018, -0.021855175495147705, -0.03433029726147652, -0.007460125721991062, -0.016470767557621002, 0.056167393922805786, -0.01581374555826187, 0.026018954813480377, -0.0005276284646242857, 0.002597255166620016, -0.08787640184164047, -0.0015995396533980966, 0.009190664626657963, 0.039357349276542664, 0.056154847145080566, -0.06879785656929016, 0.014516117051243782, 0.028580674901604652, -0.009695729240775108, -0.02082997001707554, 0.01924489438533783, -0.005704192444682121, -0.03954252600669861, 0.005225543864071369, -0.040365807712078094, 0.057065922766923904, 0.022920265793800354, 0.008572681806981564, 0.035617727786302567, 0.03417319431900978, 0.0067472863011062145, -0.000004912662461720174, -0.02268461510539055, 0.07375810295343399, -0.0036060898564755917, -0.04869759827852249, 0.057461388409137726, -0.006851974409073591, -0.04358163848519325, 0.03793943673372269, -0.0024492533411830664, 0.04612170532345772, -0.03622681275010109, 0.06764747202396393, 0.014338240027427673, 0.031003503128886223, 0.019543714821338654, -0.007776463404297829, -0.0027109780348837376, -0.001799614168703556, 0.040154971182346344, -0.003972423728555441, -0.03806767240166664, 0.004544942639768124, 0.00270281033590436, -0.032749246805906296, -0.0731302872300148, 0.05296986550092697, -0.019349290058016777, -0.04635530337691307, 0.0056518735364079475, -0.008265607059001923, 0.015196170657873154, -0.044159941375255585, 0.0014288475504145026, -0.06687810271978378, 0.01013644877821207, 0.04295400530099869, -0.015360136516392231, -0.047449126839637756, -0.0019705744925886393, -0.003598466282710433, -0.05127926170825958, 0.07136204093694687, 0.01191613171249628, -0.00964132696390152, -0.045859262347221375, 0.01457162108272314, -0.008580510504543781, 0.03435560688376427, -0.030962303280830383, -0.001505162799730897, -0.05640695244073868, 0.029735282063484192, -0.010851986706256866, 0.023174162954092026, 0.017467308789491653, -0.01724505051970482, 0.0008271177648566663, -0.0939953550696373, 0.07761647552251816, -0.002009827643632889, 0.005882089026272297, -0.00801538210362196, -0.02634679153561592, -0.011713817715644836, -0.042071472853422165, 0.02443046122789383, 0.0060384939424693584, 0.0008740866906009614, 0.009954515844583511, 0.02656584046781063, 0.008232606574892998, -0.03301864489912987, 0.0343223474919796, 0.005231665447354317, 0.007260114420205355, -0.011002039536833763, -0.03289950639009476, 0.027768755331635475, -0.009782233275473118, 0.02852257527410984, -0.014216125011444092, 0.022762157022953033, 0.02496575564146042, 0.005522127263247967, 0.02608783356845379, 0.005626634228974581, 0.0007118461071513593, 0.04601743072271347, 0.0005447912262752652, 0.010843509808182716, 0.023278573527932167, -0.014625615440309048, -0.025774654000997543, 0.010423707775771618, -0.02213861420750618, -0.02499425783753395, 0.022915218025445938, 0.013874121010303497, -0.003643151605501771, -0.05319531634449959, -0.02081707864999771, 0.04569448158144951, -0.008999153040349483, -0.013227969408035278, 0.035619497299194336, 0.011348506435751915, 0.024332696571946144, -0.019852740690112114, 0.0293626319617033, 0.03370365500450134, -0.008168399333953857, -0.028272969648241997, 0.026779258623719215, 0.09532872587442398, -0.01644447073340416, 0.05198557674884796, 0.008315560407936573, -0.029922375455498695, 0.0004342730389907956, 0.016489950940012932, 0.019122201949357986, -0.01827613078057766, -0.02434566617012024, 0.03398701176047325, 0.00586595106869936, -0.013931500725448132, -0.01659846492111683, -0.013978729024529457, 0.034782662987709045, -0.008541565388441086, -0.003999842796474695, -0.04404037445783615, 0.012856479734182358, -0.06571348011493683, 0.008825176395475864, 0.010770058259367943, 0.015024509280920029, 0.037976205348968506, 0.021071884781122208, 0.0020018366631120443, 0.01770036108791828, 0.020502969622612, -0.05202643200755119, 0.026871459558606148, -0.037683479487895966, 0.003340998897328973, 0.004189380910247564, -0.003004202153533697, 0.004315965808928013, -0.027734853327274323, -0.0035179287660866976, 0.013254236429929733, 0.02940351702272892, -0.016730627045035362, -0.03076181933283806, -0.020652983337640762, 0.03904903307557106, -0.06844630092382431, 0.012838872149586678, -0.04867143556475639, 0.03270935267210007, 0.0018700152868404984, -0.03928947448730469 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/14500/how-can-a-regression-be-significant-yet-all-predictors-be-non-significant">How can a regression be significant yet all predictors be non-significant?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>X and Y are not correlated (-.01); however, when I place X in a multiple regression predicting Y, alongside three other (related) variables, X and two other variables are significant predictors of Y. Note that the two other variables are significantly correlated with Y.</p> <p>How should I interpret these findings? X predicts unique variance in Y, but since these are not correlated, it is somehow difficult to interpret. </p> <p>I know of opposite cases (i.e., two variables are correlated but regression is not significant) and those are relatively simpler to understand from a theoretical and statistical perspective. </p>
49,368
[ -0.04512994363903999, -0.0009553286945447326, -0.007054004818201065, -0.007716667838394642, 0.06273183971643448, 0.010498653165996075, -0.0039107236079871655, -0.02331084944307804, 0.04129248112440109, -0.0471196211874485, 0.02863638661801815, -0.007797596976161003, 0.035314008593559265, -0.01153430063277483, 0.00032039335928857327, 0.013661706820130348, -0.006050352938473225, 0.03133280575275421, 0.04521903395652771, 0.0036743527743965387, -0.0381450392305851, 0.034012679010629654, 0.012817371636629105, 0.019144505262374878, -0.024205103516578674, 0.05235021188855171, 0.02134222537279129, -0.00263946782797575, 0.024272888898849487, 0.030333850532770157, -0.017856905236840248, 0.008080736733973026, 0.009102602489292622, 0.05713018774986267, 0.011235092766582966, -0.0036714598536491394, -0.004890125710517168, 0.021440714597702026, 0.04705042392015457, 0.044453974813222885, -0.01210775412619114, -0.03956200182437897, 0.0034559976775199175, 0.04296361282467842, -0.032561030238866806, 0.009247702546417713, -0.003288130508735776, -0.017631318420171738, 0.041502099484205246, -0.017913587391376495, 0.080063097178936, -0.004817620851099491, 0.04450707137584686, 0.06487204879522324, -0.021689271554350853, -0.007557302713394165, 0.05091945827007294, 0.05620609223842621, -0.04818244278430939, -0.035360295325517654, -0.020712951198220253, -0.01592242904007435, 0.016218820586800575, 0.00024805060820654035, -0.026135288178920746, 0.020022571086883545, 0.020385917276144028, -0.003894340479746461, 0.05604131519794464, -0.005299627315253019, -0.001804863102734089, 0.013830036856234074, 0.020022990182042122, 0.00023486347345169634, -0.0005240702885203063, -0.009260168299078941, 0.01776314526796341, 0.004016051534563303, 0.04508198797702789, 0.06543968617916107, -0.021042972803115845, 0.009582207538187504, 0.00921622384339571, 0.010166998021304607, 0.018340446054935455, 0.001520406687632203, 0.05823253467679024, 0.011797798797488213, 0.024319738149642944, 0.017510022968053818, -0.008695338852703571, -0.011652782559394836, 0.03256916254758835, 0.015607411041855812, -0.042707525193691254, 0.02198784239590168, -0.030981825664639473, 0.02055828459560871, 0.04926082491874695, -0.005299852229654789, -0.02282961644232273, -0.033798445016145706, 0.029583457857370377, 0.02293611317873001, -0.03988578915596008, 0.004059630446135998, -0.01731150783598423, 0.03705409914255142, 0.00308156106621027, -0.014544613659381866, 0.002568461000919342, 0.02482088841497898, -0.013002286665141582, -0.03277698531746864, 0.018504906445741653, -0.01578313484787941, -0.011627464555203915, -0.02604304626584053, 0.05194700509309769, 0.06556250900030136, -0.0014066536678001285, -0.039748094975948334, 0.0006086878129281104, -0.006804712116718292, -0.04813600704073906, -0.002600723644718528, 0.021821146830916405, -0.016554338857531548, -0.005615763831883669, 0.043036751449108124, 0.011099354363977909, -0.010353190824389458, 0.010629578493535519, 0.010447492823004723, 0.016124023124575615, 0.005906379781663418, -0.1020544096827507, -0.04319371283054352, 0.052639465779066086, -0.0061700548976659775, -0.012715863063931465, -0.053010839968919754, -0.01505342498421669, 0.0026255245320498943, 0.0668884664773941, -0.00667224358767271, 0.0008855515043251216, 0.014926042407751083, 0.009983884170651436, 0.012143556959927082, -0.0069709662348032, 0.021289438009262085, -0.025245463475584984, -0.03433108702301979, -0.007959822192788124, -0.07144831120967865, 0.006701071280986071, 0.019006364047527313, 0.006714200600981712, -0.0030845256987959146, 0.015864532440900803, -0.009405860677361488, -0.01680801622569561, -0.01828129030764103, 0.011631988920271397, -0.002469890285283327, 0.07148052006959915, -0.0025256238877773285, 0.02168898656964302, 0.02991650626063347, -0.012069967575371265, 0.006278625689446926, -0.00501119764521718, 0.0849594697356224, 0.024494057521224022, -0.011300177313387394, -0.008335836231708527, -0.007509293500334024, 0.0011800125939771533, -0.002923165913671255, -0.09702454507350922, -0.03991751745343208, -0.029553405940532684, -0.012556352652609348, 0.019492296501994133, 0.06442306935787201, -0.013532870449125767, -0.009031353518366814, 0.03236760199069977, -0.05317920073866844, -0.030313434079289436, -0.06242319941520691, -0.0077554527670145035, -0.03412072733044624, -0.04510347917675972, 0.03378245607018471, 0.013986923731863499, 0.03247398883104324, -0.022055411711335182, 0.011043194681406021, -0.014500513672828674, 0.024484004825353622, 0.03218350559473038, -0.029937850311398506, 0.042244862765073776, 0.03672496974468231, 0.062002770602703094, -0.009100277908146381, 0.019374262541532516, -0.04328080266714096, -0.03446511924266815, 0.04045983776450157, -0.021100899204611778, 0.002789162565022707, -0.047703638672828674, -0.02241511456668377, 0.017490003257989883, -0.014668503776192665, -0.024957219138741493, 0.04109547287225723, -0.03579955920577049, 0.06351470202207565, 0.011699438095092773, -0.03074062056839466, -0.020315097644925117, 0.00911857932806015, 0.019394634291529655, 0.014746218919754028, -0.039003148674964905, -0.0122837508097291, -0.047848429530858994, -0.03320888802409172, 0.04684258997440338, 0.02687937766313553, -0.057774078100919724, 0.010534395463764668, 0.02163546346127987, 0.04271078109741211, 0.00457125436514616, 0.02561919391155243, -0.024616768583655357, -0.015378902666270733, 0.002336535369977355, -0.02057061903178692, 0.001807152759283781, -0.0018579366151243448, -0.004157821647822857, 0.026618098840117455, 0.06070409342646599, 0.013703390024602413, 0.014863829128444195, 0.10025828331708908, -0.0034506183583289385, -0.0025731574278324842, -0.013682258315384388, 0.002844365080818534, 0.04456646740436554, -0.019845668226480484, 0.0221166480332613, 0.04719504714012146, 0.021898604929447174, -0.0009498209110461175, 0.02755301631987095, -0.027579737827181816, 0.009082045406103134, 0.03610881045460701, -0.059203486889600754, 0.026883278042078018, 0.008155038580298424, -0.020708560943603516, 0.029034294188022614, -0.04579410329461098, -0.04009959101676941, -0.006713289301842451, -0.006013081409037113, 0.0267732422798872, 0.007512122392654419, 0.022219747304916382, -0.04344722628593445, -0.029526524245738983, -0.030225273221731186, -0.01741938665509224, 0.005201223772019148, -0.0337548553943634, -0.04247916862368584, -0.0020189026836305857, -0.03639023005962372, -0.03447309881448746, 0.020425448194146156, -0.03186874836683273, -0.020134402438998222, 0.017970116809010506, -0.04997587576508522, -0.09210780262947083, -0.022839117795228958, -0.051003146916627884, 0.017484797164797783, -0.041149865835905075, -0.059776656329631805, 0.05540778115391731, -0.03202322870492935, -0.04719683900475502, 0.008503725752234459, -0.002653182949870825, -0.015794556587934494, 0.004880520515143871, -0.021922927349805832, 0.02355375699698925, -0.01327499933540821, 0.027101214975118637, -0.014862414449453354, -0.07417019456624985, -0.008554339408874512, -0.03315054252743721, -0.06432158499956131, 0.02492557279765606, 0.005490537732839584, 0.022697927430272102, -0.009286779910326004, -0.03123069554567337, 0.04264736920595169, 0.0018904635217040777, -0.0007613541674800217, -0.038259606808423996, -0.016446221619844437, -0.02652043104171753, -0.05311310663819313, 0.0017830132273957133, 0.033712342381477356, 0.043642815202474594, 0.028988489881157875, 0.01166649628430605, 0.039989665150642395, 0.011754277162253857, 0.021109219640493393, -0.016897203400731087, -0.0007994722109287977, 0.013753168284893036, 0.010565132834017277, 0.010007553733885288, 0.0306389182806015, -0.03949674218893051, 0.01659809984266758, -0.00934003945440054, 0.015922268852591515, 0.017394816502928734, -0.02368267998099327, 0.03908136114478111, -0.004061106592416763, -0.007960760965943336, -0.05577147379517555, 0.00837923213839531, 0.016499733552336693, -0.010067194700241089, -0.022223761305212975, -0.012866846285760403, 0.028584463521838188, 0.006174555979669094, 0.025027045980095863, 0.029737170785665512, 0.019555648788809776, -0.02404060959815979, 0.008428881876170635, -0.02168881893157959, -0.014482621103525162, 0.021710403263568878, 0.0020633244421333075, -0.005890639964491129, 0.045803252607584, 0.012716269120573997, -0.01812923140823841, -0.036126185208559036, -0.049625784158706665, 0.0001907802652567625, -0.05107038840651512, 0.022015348076820374, -0.034466225653886795, 0.024658961221575737, -0.026857882738113403, 0.03515526279807091, 0.013793542981147766, -0.027688980102539062, -0.008741753175854683, -0.00015864887973293662, -0.04887327179312706, 0.044296059757471085, -0.030095167458057404, 0.01539582759141922, -0.008872903883457184, -0.01958521082997322, 0.03473975509405136, -0.05354759842157364, 0.0264155063778162, -0.03774771839380264, 0.041779886931180954, -0.004777070134878159, -0.006545940414071083, -0.021371759474277496, -0.02161332778632641, -0.012380065396428108, 0.036480702459812164, 0.01463690958917141, -0.020508917048573494, 0.049855418503284454, 0.04528290033340454, -0.02358306758105755, -0.02811642736196518, -0.027310919016599655, 0.003933110274374485, 0.03151964768767357, 0.045378632843494415, 0.031077511608600616, 0.00029956066282466054, -0.025249717757105827, 0.005427462048828602, 0.004044720437377691, 0.02516111172735691, 0.021396657451987267, -0.02184135653078556, -0.031824976205825806, -0.020295564085245132, -0.017346195876598358, 0.005150525365024805, 0.030540501698851585, 0.022342197597026825, 0.017938492819666862, 0.07435749471187592, 0.012251636013388634, -0.03963973745703697, 0.01965094543993473, 0.03511214256286621, 0.0427924282848835, 0.00874762237071991, -0.02537260763347149, 0.003142468398436904, 0.0011538970284163952, 0.0246947780251503, 0.022132249549031258, -0.0010133167961612344, 0.017147233709692955, -0.021689871326088905, 0.010446642525494099, -0.011227880604565144, -0.002248552395030856, -0.012569031678140163, 0.00665110070258379, 0.05375223979353905, -0.021277373656630516, -0.03313513100147247, -0.00021296305931173265, 0.023371824994683266, 0.012027601711452007, 0.036993902176618576, 0.011672154068946838, -0.09009113907814026, 0.013249125331640244, 0.034774597734212875, 0.04655880853533745, -0.04186249524354935, -0.0025089834816753864, -0.016315994784235954, -0.010861264541745186, 0.04002709314227104, -0.0330999493598938, 0.023624468594789505, -0.0019043807405978441, 0.006969379726797342, -0.003335218643769622, -0.02105427347123623, -0.06979293376207352, 0.01769394241273403, -0.02967185154557228, 0.02148166298866272, -0.026488088071346283, -0.04685886949300766, -0.04462350159883499, -0.012903342954814434, 0.00608711875975132, 0.06758138537406921, -0.015025055967271328, 0.012449152767658234, -0.020691970363259315, 0.036427516490221024, 0.01225581020116806, -0.06582275778055191, 0.04191284626722336, 0.04543989151716232, -0.01506233960390091, 0.040082868188619614, -0.03209097310900688, -0.07649391889572144, 0.022565409541130066, 0.0098483357578516, -0.02595432847738266, 0.011609598062932491, -0.04095325991511345, 0.03807639703154564, 0.02802317589521408, 0.006022597197443247, 0.07724162936210632, 0.014832618646323681, -0.004778319504112005, -0.02487175539135933, -0.016440851613879204, 0.0026888565625995398, -0.06174760311841965, -0.024560164660215378, -0.01647372357547283, 0.0057883975096046925, -0.024055587127804756, 0.031873755156993866, 0.004509254824370146, -0.022225065156817436, -0.025639573112130165, -0.0040704975835978985, 0.005947376601397991, 0.01586410403251648, 0.005236568860709667, 0.01583305560052395, -0.008082384243607521, 0.0032936222851276398, -0.010386516340076923, -0.024707676842808723, 0.019520167261362076, 0.0017828289419412613, -0.0146813178434968, 0.026503553614020348, -0.032672055065631866, -0.006408617366105318, -0.022244714200496674, 0.0014221792807802558, -0.009478642605245113, -0.033536192029714584, 0.016341792419552803, -0.007614667061716318, 0.01617267169058323, -0.01412679348140955, -0.041660308837890625, -0.020489035174250603, 0.027437742799520493, 0.017507294192910194, 0.0404980443418026, -0.009236338548362255, 0.028393657878041267, -0.019991502165794373, -0.01402193121612072, -0.054957471787929535, -0.02724301815032959, -0.0010762757156044245, 0.01942213624715805, -0.006828333716839552, -0.022399097681045532, 0.02829894609749317, -0.041213031858205795, -0.03585216775536537, -0.007195423822849989, 0.009911729022860527, -0.04259774461388588, -0.02238299325108528, 0.004674382042139769, 0.011107121594250202, 0.06655793637037277, -0.03328537568449974, -0.019198855385184288, 0.02411581575870514, -0.012553947977721691, -0.02945244126021862, 0.02091919258236885, -0.004118820186704397, -0.029828330501914024, -0.02580658160150051, -0.03621217608451843, -0.025797130540013313, 0.03620912507176399, -0.02656669355928898, -0.022086145356297493, -0.011094281449913979, -0.020496932789683342, 0.022198021411895752, -0.01685173436999321, 0.021636612713336945, 0.011281860992312431, 0.03551051393151283, -0.00948137417435646, 0.006197233684360981, -0.03249379247426987, -0.006936199497431517, 0.05811378359794617, -0.007495633326470852, -0.023055128753185272, 0.005586159881204367, 0.06070782616734505, -0.019642403349280357, 0.030993212014436722, -0.015878751873970032, -0.018537040799856186, 0.0628039687871933, 0.03494901955127716, 0.0031374976970255375, 0.011130609549582005, 0.038611095398664474, -0.04500988498330116, -0.03582664579153061, -0.04918597638607025, -0.023355448618531227, 0.05512351170182228, -0.0399940125644207, 0.05609559640288353, 0.06861913204193115, -0.03798125311732292, 0.009491465985774994, -0.052567847073078156, 0.0008615081897005439, -0.012156940996646881, 0.03338710218667984, 0.031938616186380386, -0.03181827813386917, -0.002550545148551464, 0.059214308857917786, 0.011010704562067986, 0.028541801497340202, 0.02171502262353897, 0.026435289531946182, 0.018625307828187943, 0.021413730457425117, -0.01147154439240694, -0.07508688420057297, 0.04396413266658783, -0.00046864882460795343, -0.008021202869713306, 0.0030346792191267014, -0.01344787236303091, 0.04672584682703018, 0.03587242215871811, 0.01828189007937908, -0.06511399894952774, -0.0329304039478302, -0.04268966615200043, 0.01332926657050848, 0.003926077391952276, -0.029365524649620056, 0.005618979688733816, -0.001256111660040915, 0.026954706758260727, -0.0330754891037941, 0.032597146928310394, -0.04146159440279007, -0.07857482880353928, -0.029919162392616272, -0.00024231593124568462, 0.022475602105259895, 0.03690223768353462, -0.019028188660740852, -0.05119454488158226, 0.014350751414895058, -0.06958802789449692, -0.006434009410440922, 0.0012558656744658947, 0.0338958315551281, -0.020895885303616524, 0.0572589747607708, -0.006969962734729052, 0.009482761844992638, 0.008956653997302055, -0.02257777377963066, 0.08972350507974625, 0.06359615921974182, 0.012399698607623577, -0.07475432753562927, 0.01786547526717186, 0.008194725960493088, 0.0043013677932322025, -0.007530458737164736, -0.0199513491243124, 0.010521442629396915, -0.003441441571339965, 0.04869759827852249, 0.03612791374325752, 0.032197222113609314, 0.012461477890610695, 0.059847794473171234, -0.041881583631038666, -0.02673405036330223, -0.019909430295228958, 0.01969030313193798, 0.01831439882516861, -0.0321587510406971, -0.026853688061237335, -0.0033465176820755005, -0.025493457913398743, -0.010476536117494106, -0.03282224386930466, -0.00489378347992897, -0.02582884393632412, 0.01468892116099596, -0.022219786420464516, -0.02654840610921383, 0.028318174183368683, -0.01589530147612095, -0.04857528209686279, 0.00395792443305254, 0.05839729309082031, -0.035284481942653656, 0.0058443848975002766, 0.029840650036931038, -0.00899120420217514, -0.015595023520290852, 0.021434225142002106, 0.0189898069947958, -0.06920240074396133, -0.02440171130001545, -0.021819980815052986, 0.040922798216342926, 0.015228127129375935, -0.029272235929965973, -0.032577719539403915, -0.002031106734648347, 0.0013443867210298777, -0.01303994469344616, -0.018787294626235962, 0.04456934705376625, 0.026163259521126747, -0.06665961444377899, -0.026332126930356026, -0.03221338242292404, -0.010166896507143974, -0.01630477048456669, 0.03193148970603943, 0.02348545752465725, -0.03846561536192894, -0.02456730231642723, -0.03935370221734047, 0.04046318680047989, 0.00909797940403223, 0.025784684345126152, 0.01543260645121336, -0.005820698570460081, -0.035853926092386246, 0.016579726710915565, 0.023472202941775322, 0.0017586441244930029, 0.027648458257317543, 0.02200922742486, 0.0033706342801451683, -0.03757967799901962, -0.0204558614641428, 0.037026964128017426, -0.02693764492869377, 0.0021569677628576756, -0.06345341354608536, -0.006124344654381275, 0.05049847066402435, 0.039204783737659454, 0.05184954032301903, 0.010336841456592083, -0.019963566213846207, 0.03170512244105339, 0.024502171203494072, -0.05468837544322014, -0.036755017936229706, 0.0064492910169065, -0.013340812176465988, -0.01737942546606064, 0.008248486556112766, 0.042246486991643906, 0.0446719229221344, 0.028686048462986946, 0.012767434120178223, 0.0311446413397789, -0.03733869642019272, -0.008376440033316612, 0.027774864807724953, -0.04613109678030014, 0.007861841470003128, 0.04551928490400314, 0.02848624624311924, 0.001071241102181375, -0.034414999186992645, -0.012938585132360458, -0.04282425343990326, 0.038225822150707245, -0.006353478878736496, -0.017913401126861572, -0.0010766945779323578, -0.01356407068669796, 0.050059735774993896, -0.05393282324075699, -0.05248582363128662, -0.06785669922828674, -0.014878583140671253, 0.025935214012861252, -0.014081798493862152, 0.011072124354541302, -0.006050951313227415, -0.022553572431206703, 0.015723206102848053, 0.0548936128616333, 0.020223623141646385, 0.023126354441046715, -0.00941039901226759, 0.019262978807091713, -0.017178498208522797, 0.049317046999931335, -0.02062665857374668, -0.02675434947013855, 0.05902395769953728, -0.012339968234300613, -0.023240363225340843, 0.029327545315027237, -0.019471360370516777, 0.031367186456918716, 0.02336580865085125, 0.011309070512652397, -0.02610233798623085, 0.047855865210294724, -0.024910105392336845, 0.028978904709219933, -0.019388239830732346, 0.023869827389717102, 0.009025009348988533, -0.010373896919190884, 0.005124072078615427, -0.0007131859310902655, -0.017521141096949577, 0.04430892691016197, 0.0756782591342926, 0.03331998735666275, -0.0037446923088282347, 0.033952392637729645, 0.04812762886285782, 0.010837982408702374, 0.0020670818630605936, 0.0077926358208060265, 0.020776592195034027, 0.05373397842049599, -0.039385199546813965, 0.07403511554002762, 0.0026468124706298113, 0.023500686511397362, -0.09774651378393173, -0.02310522459447384, -0.015120444819331169, 0.006522202864289284, 0.047111134976148605, -0.04873824492096901, -0.003822346217930317, 0.042347341775894165, -0.06258571892976761, 0.004259862005710602, -0.011179566383361816, -0.028457220643758774, -0.0196091178804636, -0.011723087169229984, -0.028673570603132248, 0.05552176013588905, 0.03074016235768795, 0.0466642864048481, -0.004334599245339632, 0.055089667439460754, -0.0000034061588394251885, -0.029445135965943336, -0.023415381088852882, -0.005792216397821903, -0.01629955880343914, -0.040945932269096375, 0.04033578932285309, -0.026154976338148117, -0.017988132312893867, 0.06087026000022888, -0.0045959544368088245, 0.038338225334882736, 0.05160292610526085, -0.009991815313696861, 0.014524994418025017, 0.040276750922203064, 0.04730445146560669, 0.0038550805766135454, -0.019694868475198746, 0.0010173121700063348, -0.007418645545840263, 0.06711310148239136, -0.002477090572938323, 0.017683882266283035, -0.007439904846251011, -0.019713256508111954, -0.013277637772262096, 0.01805201545357704, -0.03931865096092224, -0.015800829976797104, 0.007269035093486309, 0.005571279674768448, -0.01779654622077942, -0.02294902876019478, 0.02933586575090885, -0.04870482161641121, -0.020896172150969505, 0.047705646604299545, 0.05611621215939522, -0.04309093579649925, -0.004238319117575884, -0.01985265500843525, -0.02532464638352394, 0.013971993699669838, -0.017649158835411072, 0.007167760748416185, -0.04574014991521835, -0.010265584103763103, 0.017770979553461075, -0.010249066166579723, -0.03043961711227894, 0.00046804308658465743, -0.0817667692899704, 0.03863346949219704, -0.012384857051074505, 0.009596425108611584, 0.0016171917086467147, -0.050590258091688156, -0.018585586920380592, -0.08836588263511658, 0.052998170256614685, 0.04276929423213005, -0.01340869814157486, -0.054976753890514374, -0.005964873358607292, -0.03082890436053276, 0.021336931735277176, 0.053316496312618256, -0.011979780159890652, 0.05816924199461937, 0.02688736654818058, 0.03745511919260025, 0.0038640764541924, -0.04279996454715729, 0.054579153656959534, 0.02714916504919529, -0.018513847142457962, 0.00002483689968357794, -0.010404917411506176, 0.015078769065439701, 0.023066671565175056, 0.03588732331991196, -0.011941663920879364, 0.01508096233010292, 0.019968809559941292, 0.003315407084301114, 0.07029489427804947, 0.005764948669821024, -0.0065146759152412415, 0.03282550349831581, 0.03296101838350296, 0.024012170732021332, 0.054770663380622864, 0.0032187658362090588, -0.03526681661605835, -0.009792190045118332, -0.011686843819916248, -0.02396452985703945, 0.010953315533697605, 0.005021881312131882, 0.0055601634085178375, -0.049160294234752655, 0.001808665692806244, 0.012194611132144928, 0.011080591939389706, -0.0013581536477431655, 0.041646454483270645, 0.029583068564534187, 0.018764028325676918, 0.022197535261511803, -0.01061889436095953, 0.0064375209622085094, -0.027188237756490707, 0.022897541522979736, 0.010582176968455315, 0.04453000798821449, 0.009512314572930336, 0.010409276932477951, 0.03945170342922211, 0.012109833769500256, 0.03467513248324394, -0.015808062627911568, 0.03541873022913933, -0.044520121067762375, -0.02870822139084339, -0.0018196359742432833, -0.013485606759786606, 0.03584340214729309, 0.000505411415360868, 0.02194383181631565, 0.06564369052648544, -0.059368427842855453, -0.016623592004179955, 0.010722917504608631, 0.023264095187187195, -0.024985339492559433, -0.009623621590435505, -0.011911553330719471, 0.009895393624901772, 0.0017788854893296957, 0.00897661130875349, 0.010093499906361103, -0.034129589796066284, -0.016276700422167778, -0.0018341457471251488, 0.008507343009114265, -0.009383578784763813, -0.030801162123680115, -0.023655109107494354, -0.013422537595033646, -0.035261306911706924, -0.02207292430102825, 0.028618790209293365, 0.08226059377193451, 0.006417162716388702, -0.04978158697485924, -0.00857549998909235, -0.014088071882724762, 0.06327538937330246, -0.06995811313390732, -0.021579323336482048, -0.04696701094508171, 0.03328768163919449, 0.009354040957987309, -0.02803279273211956 ]
<p>Apologies for the almost text-book like question. </p> <p>I have a 2x2 design with fixed categories and a continuous response variable.</p> <p>If the variances are equal between groups (Bartlett test) and residuals are normally distributed (Shapiro test), ok I can do standard ANOVA. </p> <p>Otherwise: </p> <ol> <li><p>Try transforming the data (e.g: arcsin(sqrt), or log(), or even rank()). If transformed data is homoscedastic &amp; normal residues, do normal ANOVA. </p></li> <li><p>One option: Kruskal test (tells you whether any means differ between groups) followed by many pairs of wilcox tests (to identify which means differ). If all are significant, all factors (and interactions are significant). </p></li> <li><p>Another option: Use the bootstrap approach (permuting residuals) outlined here: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/12151/is-there-an-equivalent-to-kruskal-wallis-one-way-test-for-a-two-way-model">Is there an equivalent to Kruskal Wallis one-way test for a two-way model?</a></p></li> </ol> <p>Is this correct?</p>
34,294
[ -0.00806892104446888, 0.037485238164663315, -0.0009201153879985213, 0.015022192150354385, 0.050582047551870346, -0.033600762486457825, -0.013447548262774944, -0.024264754727482796, 0.030093902722001076, -0.01800950989127159, 0.05105701461434364, 0.0005293843569234014, 0.042721398174762726, 0.01060650683939457, 0.01903386600315571, -0.005075803957879543, -0.0113539332523942, -0.01796630024909973, 0.012247991748154163, 0.03141486272215843, -0.03741585835814476, 0.0006887330091558397, -0.00022514312877319753, 0.012648987583816051, -0.032837945967912674, 0.05649927258491516, 0.027803365141153336, -0.026198536157608032, 0.006053578108549118, 0.06097158417105675, -0.043197523802518845, -0.01831839419901371, -0.019565263763070107, 0.027155276387929916, -0.024072306230664253, -0.004870648495852947, 0.02681555598974228, -0.01011700090020895, 0.005613429006189108, 0.03450314700603485, -0.02584441378712654, -0.015187419950962067, -0.017880210652947426, 0.03919204697012901, 0.03289338946342468, 0.031501516699790955, -0.017607109621167183, -0.010572364553809166, 0.0413183718919754, -0.026524370536208153, 0.05813165009021759, 0.0042220354080200195, -0.005085272714495659, 0.019876908510923386, -0.018682288005948067, -0.021296894177794456, 0.0267119612544775, 0.017112841829657555, -0.0099533936008811, -0.040264565497636795, -0.04608702287077904, -0.01507955975830555, -0.0008297062013298273, 0.010347381234169006, -0.05836155265569687, -0.004170042462646961, 0.0010763156460598111, -0.020120378583669662, 0.05071113631129265, -0.016819197684526443, -0.005908623803406954, 0.00905958004295826, 0.027176329866051674, 0.005152037367224693, -0.005040602758526802, 0.008743534795939922, -0.0006856352556496859, 0.036510955542325974, 0.02981352061033249, 0.054580312222242355, -0.02017597295343876, 0.0012858151458203793, -0.007642711978405714, 0.05617934465408325, 0.04717579856514931, -0.03710578754544258, 0.05085179954767227, -0.03415386751294136, -0.020776158198714256, 0.024850456044077873, -0.02823629602789879, -0.010796151123940945, 0.05572187528014183, 0.03325372189283371, -0.04474935680627823, 0.020595360547304153, -0.01827816292643547, 0.0219047162681818, 0.008521447889506817, 0.0019275402883067727, 0.015966346487402916, -0.03609419986605644, 0.03418424353003502, 0.039015259593725204, -0.010877563618123531, -0.007484062109142542, -0.007388929836452007, 0.0061501204036176205, -0.0034938007593154907, -0.05245878919959068, -0.029220929369330406, 0.032029636204242706, 0.009865649044513702, 0.006723345257341862, 0.022850731387734413, -0.0011332377325743437, -0.02249092049896717, -0.035726647824048996, 0.07973793148994446, 0.05593978986144066, 0.08219209313392639, -0.02334863692522049, -0.010281525552272797, -0.009432407096028328, -0.036590952426195145, -0.01973017118871212, 0.036400239914655685, 0.004604686982929707, -0.010401942767202854, 0.07751626521348953, 0.027156518772244453, -0.016394244506955147, 0.03505617380142212, 0.01115700975060463, 0.04127541556954384, 0.006736338138580322, -0.10444611310958862, -0.07918386161327362, 0.010021512396633625, 0.021315891295671463, -0.04259920120239258, -0.034764986485242844, -0.001978896325454116, 0.021006355062127113, 0.05901933088898659, 0.03606489673256874, 0.027599185705184937, -0.01456079725176096, 0.020236771553754807, 0.03856690227985382, -0.018879050388932228, -0.0046181040816009045, -0.037837106734514236, -0.0003799644473474473, 0.014060952700674534, -0.06476432830095291, 0.013089627958834171, -0.012697615660727024, 0.019590485841035843, 0.03986341133713722, 0.026077523827552795, 0.02475830167531967, -0.018081482499837875, 0.01653987169265747, 0.026716288179159164, -0.011121521703898907, 0.06833167374134064, -0.04426656663417816, 0.0304257795214653, -0.024775734171271324, -0.013047199696302414, -0.011540157720446587, 0.002144885715097189, 0.048169881105422974, 0.014647051692008972, -0.006996862590312958, -0.023051157593727112, -0.04563251882791519, 0.02055807039141655, -0.010436427779495716, -0.024253448471426964, -0.014244752936065197, -0.02247457206249237, -0.024630911648273468, 0.014054013416171074, 0.011011955328285694, -0.020188089460134506, -0.011322717182338238, 0.0571494959294796, -0.043323714286088943, -0.03955533355474472, -0.04995447397232056, -0.0031590608414262533, -0.01055486872792244, -0.03942238166928291, 0.034031372517347336, 0.042614467442035675, 0.014956197701394558, -0.01269978005439043, -0.012235973961651325, -0.033361271023750305, 0.00005629530642181635, 0.017506828531622887, -0.01645399071276188, 0.00898931547999382, -0.00346802594140172, 0.06629655510187149, -0.059676315635442734, 0.02391744591295719, -0.0572720468044281, -0.054014213383197784, 0.007134565152227879, -0.06732166558504105, 0.01950673572719097, 0.00021962755999993533, -0.0002818592474795878, 0.002304030815139413, 0.028919722884893417, -0.005019239149987698, 0.061225298792123795, -0.06001582369208336, 0.047977104783058167, 0.05174694210290909, -0.01109758485108614, -0.023338746279478073, 0.02963661402463913, -0.015456304885447025, 0.0029264306649565697, -0.035001855343580246, 0.001154485042206943, -0.0012530166422948241, -0.032625291496515274, 0.059763189405202866, -0.017463158816099167, -0.034038152545690536, 0.030462168157100677, 0.05725715309381485, 0.043239958584308624, -0.0033602938055992126, 0.005126093979924917, -0.015008790418505669, -0.057075560092926025, 0.01842539757490158, 0.024892376735806465, 0.029943345114588737, 0.01283884234726429, 0.04127822071313858, 0.013653567060828209, 0.0250187236815691, 0.03493649885058403, 0.013014283031225204, 0.043797027319669724, 0.038035862147808075, -0.008974027819931507, -0.03802807256579399, -0.0064340317621827126, 0.06084848940372467, 0.01947835646569729, 0.017118696123361588, 0.0499233603477478, 0.01802544668316841, -0.011013342067599297, 0.008265684358775616, 0.00545246247202158, 0.025621049106121063, 0.00860653817653656, -0.021781114861369133, -0.006768899969756603, 0.013869368471205235, -0.03297297656536102, 0.02461894042789936, -0.01811106689274311, -0.014273061417043209, -0.013080026023089886, 0.021138930693268776, -0.01978178881108761, 0.005239757243543863, 0.007246632594615221, -0.015405039303004742, -0.021026864647865295, 0.001583081902936101, 0.007967930287122726, 0.019492998719215393, 0.0012413130607455969, -0.05591249465942383, -0.020151210948824883, -0.030714722350239754, -0.0007754258112981915, 0.014605851843953133, -0.013652831315994263, -0.01615406945347786, 0.0490812286734581, -0.027071107178926468, -0.0615118071436882, -0.029348528012633324, -0.05263374745845795, 0.0154203986749053, -0.03932001814246178, -0.023085342720150948, 0.011970513500273228, 0.043912921100854874, -0.02571769431233406, 0.020005354657769203, -0.022570421919226646, 0.011548644863069057, 0.015077806077897549, 0.02353058010339737, 0.01180948968976736, 0.0005851082387380302, 0.0066911992616951466, -0.0008748986874707043, -0.037842489778995514, 0.0013509312411770225, -0.09807237237691879, -0.03514353185892105, 0.02464885823428631, 0.004059996455907822, 0.028329305350780487, -0.0018046561162918806, -0.027478547766804695, 0.05110717937350273, 0.03060079738497734, -0.004204476717859507, -0.02439013682305813, 0.0017104395665228367, -0.024000748991966248, -0.03279542922973633, 0.022377898916602135, 0.012437968514859676, 0.0139932157471776, 0.0462600402534008, -0.03495118021965027, 0.0016908308025449514, 0.046397823840379715, 0.016743790358304977, -0.0004485456447582692, 0.043638404458761215, 0.024775274097919464, -0.010972167365252972, 0.02616625837981701, 0.026896314695477486, -0.034671440720558167, -0.016028625890612602, 0.009297736920416355, 0.025137847289443016, 0.04268176108598709, -0.04399854689836502, 0.027024948969483376, -0.03421506658196449, -0.007495809346437454, -0.030245574191212654, 0.015104396268725395, 0.0280554611235857, -0.018042348325252533, -0.012973111122846603, 0.025920653715729713, -0.0060103400610387325, 0.02077265828847885, 0.04199504107236862, 0.0471833311021328, 0.06325967609882355, 0.006475573405623436, -0.015026843175292015, -0.006177999544888735, -0.020290466025471687, 0.013021676801145077, -0.010730606503784657, 0.016135696321725845, 0.016002319753170013, 0.027578791603446007, 0.027685843408107758, -0.014410952106118202, -0.022576773539185524, 0.004435006994754076, -0.0431339256465435, 0.026088673621416092, -0.04531813785433769, 0.019732143729925156, 0.006958530750125647, 0.05733061581850052, 0.017328858375549316, -0.02741694450378418, -0.04004056379199028, -0.026284700259566307, -0.06686092913150787, 0.030746744945645332, -0.024105673655867577, 0.0033520350698381662, 0.03980641067028046, -0.02584664896130562, 0.011869977228343487, -0.00213761068880558, 0.0320025309920311, -0.005259525962173939, 0.0382348969578743, -0.03757466748356819, 0.016071556136012077, -0.007727936841547489, -0.049134332686662674, 0.009089209139347076, 0.025750847533345222, 0.008707696571946144, -0.04086841270327568, 0.03738498315215111, 0.007585454266518354, -0.00286121922545135, -0.006500680465251207, -0.02306649461388588, -0.01667925901710987, 0.017275499179959297, 0.06096335127949715, 0.028725426644086838, 0.018038302659988403, -0.02157471887767315, 0.024333110079169273, -0.007154162973165512, 0.019725434482097626, -0.0016088656848296523, 0.017586003988981247, 0.001975118648260832, -0.03569534048438072, -0.030087381601333618, -0.03351951017975807, 0.04428815469145775, 0.025191424414515495, 0.0042678555473685265, 0.032971352338790894, 0.03691290691494942, -0.04288173094391823, 0.030872682109475136, 0.06991303712129593, 0.0062579018995165825, -0.0484028086066246, 0.01620825007557869, -0.02126147598028183, 0.010613000020384789, -0.004638128913938999, 0.030498646199703217, -0.021974680945277214, 0.016273133456707, -0.0013853622367605567, 0.02562233991920948, 0.00872499868273735, 0.014804508537054062, 0.007568897679448128, -0.012321265414357185, -0.002375276293605566, -0.01654749922454357, -0.042797282338142395, 0.015499082393944263, 0.0146113820374012, 0.02316705323755741, -0.0059964582324028015, -0.002450685715302825, -0.08683392405509949, 0.031074484810233116, 0.043923430144786835, 0.05968642234802246, -0.05732119083404541, 0.023840751498937607, 0.009428627789020538, -0.04153287783265114, 0.03735154867172241, -0.02495884895324707, 0.012659971602261066, -0.004084667656570673, 0.03869404271245003, -0.04444832354784012, -0.0070473989471793175, -0.04267039895057678, 0.013293430209159851, 0.012610324658453465, -0.0355592705309391, 0.003714793361723423, -0.038300588726997375, -0.06910131126642227, -0.011624282225966454, 0.008898932486772537, 0.018154019489884377, -0.046507060527801514, -0.016981378197669983, 0.029478220269083977, 0.008727708831429482, -0.016952933743596077, -0.0504942424595356, 0.03864261135458946, -0.007183264009654522, -0.03107271157205105, 0.062417976558208466, 0.012553351931273937, -0.036623697727918625, 0.031287696212530136, -0.049218855798244476, -0.0005055537330918014, -0.008194059133529663, -0.009487081319093704, 0.04328557848930359, 0.011281994171440601, 0.015715405344963074, 0.06321725994348526, 0.026211556047201157, -0.04004411771893501, 0.0004437557072378695, -0.050740282982587814, 0.025436822324991226, -0.029529331251978874, -0.04765894636511803, -0.022419221699237823, -0.01291009783744812, -0.02720816060900688, 0.011510681360960007, 0.01413670927286148, 0.00872078537940979, -0.03630862385034561, 0.0012292666360735893, 0.006492237094789743, 0.022308705374598503, -0.0024886317551136017, 0.027594145387411118, 0.012904714792966843, 0.0006368221947923303, 0.0005804473184980452, -0.04052433744072914, 0.01144550833851099, -0.042890679091215134, -0.018959350883960724, -0.006048416718840599, -0.016283363103866577, 0.013607900589704514, -0.027103882282972336, -0.018647098913788795, -0.010690219700336456, -0.020659897476434708, 0.0418790727853775, -0.030362937599420547, 0.02890329249203205, -0.029207367449998856, -0.03955375403165817, -0.026759548112750053, 0.053080592304468155, 0.03321816772222519, 0.028631526976823807, 0.005317504517734051, 0.0363885723054409, -0.009957138448953629, -0.00832044892013073, -0.050518106669187546, -0.025872742757201195, 0.03253275528550148, 0.0047410475090146065, -0.003304611425846815, -0.011333751492202282, -0.026981253176927567, -0.03328408673405647, -0.008859751746058464, -0.037299785763025284, 0.07176376134157181, -0.009678944945335388, 0.0008317101746797562, 0.001335362670943141, 0.05230399966239929, 0.055249955505132675, 0.015029450878500938, -0.036688052117824554, -0.024439750239253044, -0.031221305951476097, -0.01962999813258648, 0.027842774987220764, 0.0013123687822371721, -0.045339737087488174, -0.01726347580552101, -0.024860870093107224, 0.0074922251515090466, 0.05943452939391136, -0.016855675727128983, -0.032842233777046204, 0.028252873569726944, -0.02044491656124592, -0.009254748933017254, -0.04082239046692848, 0.008290104568004608, 0.015369324944913387, 0.05308600142598152, -0.02138110063970089, -0.004645854234695435, -0.028017405420541763, 0.0001492329320171848, 0.0019528575940057635, 0.01349073275923729, -0.02198338508605957, 0.027589473873376846, 0.06916668266057968, -0.005802396684885025, 0.016662104055285454, 0.0038143410347402096, -0.019292550161480904, 0.0379352942109108, -0.011700253002345562, -0.014681930653750896, 0.025553472340106964, 0.017415862530469894, -0.03748120367527008, -0.018771449103951454, -0.0004209720646031201, -0.029047153890132904, 0.06107243150472641, -0.00023836038599256426, 0.03189803659915924, 0.056572429835796356, 0.037699125707149506, -0.003132561221718788, -0.021874597296118736, -0.015428473241627216, 0.00299843936227262, 0.033951759338378906, 0.06609553098678589, -0.0281330868601799, 0.01914415881037712, 0.02801620401442051, 0.011287211440503597, 0.0287600290030241, 0.03368137776851654, 0.01574154943227768, 0.049117542803287506, 0.03314892575144768, -0.023356281220912933, -0.055439457297325134, 0.035042669624090195, -0.06802301853895187, 0.014777911826968193, -0.02502339705824852, 0.020811166614294052, 0.06443218141794205, 0.056087952107191086, -0.006726114545017481, -0.05853551626205444, -0.03948608785867691, -0.0640469640493393, 0.025622623041272163, 0.0007160688401199877, 0.030736388638615608, -0.013980621472001076, 0.007811600808054209, 0.06868498772382736, -0.013763891533017159, 0.007653671316802502, -0.011350533924996853, -0.10009991377592087, -0.03482891991734505, 0.04773128032684326, -0.004755869507789612, 0.0091527309268713, -0.018848897889256477, -0.030193127691745758, 0.009038764052093029, -0.06027470901608467, 0.006607458461076021, 0.020401813089847565, 0.04070208966732025, 0.0015979508170858026, 0.029880838468670845, -0.016372695565223694, -0.003463165136054158, -0.024716906249523163, -0.014229844324290752, 0.11840032786130905, 0.05649735406041145, 0.05226210877299309, -0.05270230397582054, 0.04334813356399536, 0.00001034187062032288, -0.001361220609396696, -0.004604711197316647, 0.02377481758594513, -0.011649691499769688, -0.015128239057958126, 0.07441850751638412, 0.10493908077478409, 0.03199395537376404, -0.014397405087947845, 0.03911419212818146, -0.0042036729864776134, -0.024980278685688972, -0.013554924167692661, 0.005449901334941387, -0.006517901085317135, -0.030464695766568184, 0.0046296436339616776, 0.0013301015133038163, 0.0084278155118227, 0.0066145602613687515, -0.04287462309002876, -0.01595495268702507, -0.025925246998667717, -0.0029160073027014732, -0.029129410162568092, 0.02507667988538742, 0.0048109362833201885, 0.014581218361854553, -0.02506963536143303, 0.00011264240310993046, 0.02774566411972046, -0.030896339565515518, 0.03475403040647507, 0.03278151527047157, -0.014463376253843307, -0.006226738449186087, 0.025121184065937996, 0.0034277443774044514, -0.046456221491098404, -0.014421738684177399, -0.007993526756763458, 0.017117036506533623, 0.013143351301550865, -0.015650631859898567, -0.0465795062482357, -0.011646507307887077, -0.027728810906410217, 0.006295060273259878, -0.033106375485658646, 0.02393166907131672, 0.004887675400823355, -0.03319983184337616, -0.021794211119413376, -0.03065360337495804, 0.022685963660478592, -0.017978418618440628, 0.02023782953619957, 0.006205047480762005, -0.01057479903101921, 0.0023818351328372955, -0.045327078551054, 0.062140464782714844, 0.04793863371014595, 0.002840687520802021, 0.001634629676118493, -0.03149658814072609, -0.0318453423678875, 0.025285039097070694, -0.014819440431892872, 0.02568482607603073, 0.025546368211507797, -0.008262143470346928, -0.02588483691215515, -0.011375674046576023, -0.048353951424360275, 0.005466593895107508, -0.010934209451079369, 0.016175417229533195, -0.054037582129240036, -0.008013255894184113, 0.03314567729830742, -0.0003890721418429166, -0.008808622136712074, 0.024838818237185478, 0.012697734870016575, 0.07464738935232162, -0.0037068375386297703, -0.07329219579696655, -0.05045054852962494, -0.009370820596814156, -0.03700266033411026, -0.009330285713076591, -0.021268418058753014, 0.05866353586316109, 0.0352056547999382, 0.06933999806642532, -0.022450720891356468, 0.017924301326274872, -0.018238497897982597, 0.021056341007351875, 0.039386216551065445, -0.07665585726499557, 0.006399207282811403, 0.019337350502610207, 0.034350812435150146, 0.014118906110525131, -0.06026135012507439, -0.014349916949868202, -0.05247048661112785, 0.03062756173312664, -0.02042163722217083, -0.02315433882176876, -0.0031856223940849304, -0.03409207984805107, 0.028744107112288475, -0.06858112663030624, -0.029426008462905884, -0.04134286567568779, -0.01067481841892004, 0.025312526151537895, 0.020674167200922966, 0.01683271862566471, 0.03246694058179855, -0.005710090510547161, 0.029274411499500275, 0.04552967846393585, 0.006748981308192015, 0.004242425784468651, 0.02092665061354637, -0.005962847266346216, 0.013918022625148296, 0.038694482296705246, 0.021524084731936455, 0.007560696918517351, 0.046783123165369034, -0.023122021928429604, -0.026822296902537346, -0.006690191105008125, -0.023089248687028885, 0.03429478406906128, 0.020551882684230804, -0.016646819189190865, 0.001709235250018537, 0.03555002063512802, -0.022070828825235367, -0.006461912300437689, -0.027354029938578606, 0.00011373304732842371, -0.0071045695804059505, -0.010374083183705807, 0.0013538453495129943, -0.00044421240454539657, -0.05976681038737297, 0.05721166357398033, 0.054703328758478165, -0.006823546253144741, -0.01527696754783392, 0.0001952131133293733, -0.014303703792393208, -0.004654888994991779, 0.02576562762260437, 0.003199222031980753, -0.005392912309616804, 0.059604912996292114, -0.045994676649570465, 0.03287455067038536, -0.03808331489562988, -0.006885651499032974, -0.09859104454517365, -0.01788114383816719, -0.02044268138706684, 0.017939476296305656, 0.039976656436920166, -0.07168782502412796, 0.008770744316279888, 0.01700063794851303, -0.07288499921560287, -0.0011194664984941483, -0.02125062420964241, -0.0572354756295681, -0.047940485179424286, -0.029636412858963013, -0.01970685087144375, 0.04321778938174248, -0.01973484829068184, 0.0392313152551651, -0.014122111722826958, 0.0386066809296608, -0.0070419576950371265, -0.016910837963223457, 0.03203878179192543, 0.002923240652307868, 0.039895884692668915, -0.06896423548460007, -0.00079288927372545, 0.0003512051480356604, -0.025490516796708107, 0.012628411874175072, -0.03999201953411102, 0.04751046746969223, 0.0028854473493993282, 0.02263908088207245, 0.02763177454471588, 0.023556208238005638, 0.02220611646771431, 0.005679779686033726, -0.04109431803226471, 0.0013124624965712428, 0.0037106433883309364, 0.042156677693128586, -0.023573927581310272, 0.015212307684123516, 0.025188220664858818, -0.014299726113677025, -0.023866869509220123, 0.024741753935813904, -0.022870607674121857, -0.03069499507546425, -0.008399620652198792, -0.00848714541643858, 0.04012623429298401, 0.020698396489024162, 0.009041542187333107, -0.07166659086942673, 0.004877891857177019, 0.02402682974934578, 0.015344789251685143, 0.000053836702136322856, 0.028469327837228775, -0.0139035414904356, -0.020123539492487907, 0.03664180636405945, -0.005391549319028854, 0.029471425339579582, -0.05377552658319473, -0.05913449451327324, -0.019564872607588768, 0.017667504027485847, 0.007174637634307146, -0.03150489926338196, -0.019203072413802147, 0.03530476242303848, -0.03539805859327316, 0.003907486330717802, 0.029758935794234276, -0.002509916666895151, -0.013698688708245754, -0.08822319656610489, 0.06097528338432312, 0.028505967929959297, -0.010862622410058975, -0.04737656190991402, -0.021499669179320335, -0.046837273985147476, -0.017511937767267227, 0.07434368133544922, 0.022243278101086617, 0.021959565579891205, -0.02323795296251774, 0.02958347462117672, 0.005047592334449291, -0.048672329634428024, 0.033731430768966675, -0.019665991887450218, -0.014315859414637089, -0.012049614451825619, 0.027553338557481766, 0.018986307084560394, 0.0066010961309075356, 0.06416814029216766, -0.02174954116344452, -0.001840256154537201, -0.013076449744403362, -0.018657539039850235, 0.02789519913494587, 0.005742850713431835, 0.0012071732198819518, 0.031811319291591644, -0.010026529431343079, -0.0214510690420866, 0.053219396620988846, 0.003620120231062174, -0.0301514845341444, 0.03940214961767197, -0.01533171534538269, -0.038056835532188416, -0.011753453873097897, 0.02078150026500225, -0.009225754998624325, -0.05564364045858383, 0.021886486560106277, 0.028701459988951683, -0.02642274647951126, 0.03148786723613739, 0.02007110044360161, 0.038868363946676254, 0.0028063931968063116, 0.008429077453911304, -0.020832061767578125, -0.011707070283591747, -0.046958234161138535, 0.020955214276909828, 0.017639165744185448, 0.032045360654592514, 0.02666829153895378, -0.010496458038687706, 0.026769867166876793, -0.02696944773197174, 0.018283113837242126, -0.015150473453104496, 0.04003942757844925, 0.005376255139708519, -0.004440372809767723, 0.04116065055131912, 0.02093173749744892, -0.007566644344478846, -0.011022369377315044, -0.0014670015079900622, 0.042995989322662354, -0.05901496112346649, 0.03126809746026993, -0.016756132245063782, -0.014663547277450562, -0.04451528191566467, -0.010247375816106796, 0.022332999855279922, 0.0021800468675792217, 0.005683504045009613, -0.012676936574280262, -0.00927975308150053, -0.024443630129098892, -0.02565399743616581, 0.010144411586225033, 0.03505304455757141, -0.005625453311949968, -0.017615215852856636, -0.04144660383462906, -0.05270996317267418, -0.027898235246539116, -0.06687463819980621, 0.040462229400873184, 0.04104367643594742, 0.013631687499582767, -0.03779914975166321, -0.019547689706087112, 0.018154852092266083, 0.05844522640109062, -0.06571987271308899, -0.023580215871334076, -0.009070893749594688, 0.007640763185918331, 0.009620487689971924, -0.008208532817661762 ]
<p>Intervention analysis in Box-Jenkins framework crosspoinds to time-series regression with arma errors if the noise is stationary or arima errors if the noise is non-stationary. </p> <p>For a seasonal time series data with increasing trend, the noise model can be express as</p> <p>$$ N_t = \frac{\Theta(B)}{(1-B)(1-B^{12})\Phi(B)} \eta_t $$ </p> <p>If there is a step $S_t$ (0 before intervention and 1 after intervention) and a pulse $P_t$ (1 at intervention and 0 elsewhere) interventions, the model then can be expressed as</p> <p>$$ Y_t=\beta_1S_t+\beta_2P_t+\frac{\Theta(B)}{(1-B)(1-B^{12})\Phi(B)} \eta_t $$</p> <p>Also because there may different responses to the interventions, say graduate change in level is by $\frac{\omega S_t}{1-\delta B}$ or decayed responses $\frac{\omega P_t}{1-\delta B}$. </p> <p>$$ Y_t=\frac{\omega S_t}{1-\delta B}+\frac{\omega P_t}{1-\delta B}+\frac{\Theta(B)}{(1-B)(1-B^{12})\Phi(B)} \eta_t $$</p> <p>Therefore my question is:</p> <p>if the data is seasonal time series, then in the practice, does it mean we need to perform difference $(1-B)(1-B^{12})S_t$ and $(1-B)(1-B^{12})P_t$ along with $(1-B)(1-B^{12})Y_t$ anyways when consider those interventions?</p> <p>Thanks and Regards</p>
74,190
[ 0.00577171053737402, -0.030708853155374527, -0.004138311371207237, 0.010004058480262756, 0.0698608011007309, 0.06591370701789856, 0.007173116318881512, -0.021294552832841873, 0.06128407269716263, -0.023275822401046753, 0.025114620104432106, 0.0009414503583684564, 0.04669598117470741, -0.01764867454767227, 0.008295088075101376, -0.010345011949539185, -0.02026619389653206, -0.0019795678090304136, 0.007131015881896019, -0.009559888392686844, 0.017456624656915665, -0.0015951833920553327, -0.02079840376973152, 0.016072480008006096, -0.043309979140758514, 0.051460735499858856, -0.0065504866652190685, -0.01508221123367548, -0.02331276424229145, 0.02161557786166668, -0.009980511851608753, -0.016359083354473114, 0.0016211371403187513, 0.02282954938709736, -0.0007933147717267275, 0.01231742836534977, -0.025938386097550392, -0.08949591964483261, 0.03011368401348591, 0.030369941145181656, -0.030031027272343636, 0.01199238933622837, -0.0012503420002758503, 0.016831904649734497, -0.052720554172992706, 0.0013270791387185454, 0.015111671760678291, 0.010203564539551735, 0.03278536722064018, -0.0353979617357254, 0.036671027541160583, -0.025065885856747627, 0.0376414954662323, 0.02552640438079834, -0.050788260996341705, -0.05615674704313278, 0.06376606225967407, 0.03745112195611, -0.0337618812918663, -0.028903881087899208, -0.010478245094418526, -0.0007837734883651137, -0.01092561986297369, -0.00817619264125824, -0.013266016729176044, 0.022969504818320274, -0.016701336950063705, -0.0053722127340734005, 0.014389276504516602, -0.0254246573895216, 0.041024647653102875, -0.007731379009783268, 0.01473965123295784, -0.013938399963080883, 0.037133026868104935, -0.05600053444504738, -0.00046556396409869194, 0.027112500742077827, -0.0003889920189976692, 0.0529266856610775, -0.04192366078495979, -0.027560120448470116, 0.00620881374925375, 0.05118619278073311, 0.006846118718385696, 0.013167306780815125, 0.03750941529870033, -0.06922689080238342, 0.033704180270433426, 0.024518536403775215, 0.005305737257003784, 0.027236469089984894, 0.03550155833363533, -0.016964219510555267, -0.05526132136583328, 0.05511047691106796, -0.013586383312940598, 0.00892073567956686, 0.013961116783320904, -0.026036716997623444, -0.012988840229809284, -0.06487748771905899, 0.027215110138058662, 0.031955521553754807, -0.044315073639154434, 0.008112000301480293, -0.032071515917778015, -0.0046981507912278175, -0.03125094249844551, -0.038803987205028534, -0.06820344924926758, 0.01641715131700039, -0.026104802265763283, 0.007902896031737328, 0.038835830986499786, 0.011568387970328331, -0.04961089417338371, 0.015270575881004333, 0.0360436849296093, 0.025782564654946327, 0.07079452276229858, 0.01079012081027031, 0.026567667722702026, -0.013718776404857635, -0.06448347121477127, -0.001823512022383511, 0.0017894700868055224, -0.02270534448325634, -0.06255625188350677, 0.024738658219575882, 0.03365996479988098, -0.02473311685025692, 0.034240663051605225, 0.014966577291488647, 0.054632995277643204, -0.0070506492629647255, -0.0637872964143753, -0.06805254518985748, 0.025012806057929993, -0.003601240226998925, 0.02715367078781128, -0.06263912469148636, 0.008133823052048683, -0.016872573643922806, 0.04050690680742264, -0.006985971238464117, 0.0009341338882222772, 0.036570947617292404, 0.020869484171271324, 0.0032733147963881493, -0.0352306105196476, 0.026450302451848984, 0.022286945953965187, -0.019006265327334404, -0.008648054674267769, -0.10235198587179184, 0.04231613129377365, 0.012281829491257668, -0.03270744904875755, -0.023148709908127785, 0.07280400395393372, 0.0009894586401060224, -0.01826675795018673, 0.010332016274333, -0.01838892139494419, -0.03110859915614128, 0.031039295718073845, 0.015109863132238388, 0.03504830226302147, 0.027411287650465965, 0.010520867072045803, -0.00397651270031929, -0.007510527968406677, 0.07056698948144913, 0.04135708883404732, -0.030352521687746048, 0.017734253779053688, -0.01983685791492462, -0.016482608392834663, 0.006891549564898014, -0.05207829549908638, -0.02905764803290367, -0.07424028217792511, -0.0001905672688735649, -0.0026594114024192095, 0.0544794537127018, -0.007606845814734697, 0.01679663360118866, 0.050359033048152924, -0.06749098747968674, -0.026951661333441734, -0.08052882552146912, 0.02373138815164566, -0.0071096415631473064, -0.03652007505297661, 0.029643261805176735, -0.035358306020498276, -0.0014967195456847548, 0.009358563460409641, 0.007901851087808609, -0.0001135911516030319, 0.017368147149682045, 0.03944384679198265, -0.056666698306798935, -0.0020281593315303326, 0.04110340774059296, -0.005505771841853857, 0.0035335153806954622, 0.05790175125002861, -0.05069758743047714, -0.014124694280326366, -0.010743767954409122, -0.05525794252753258, 0.023514648899435997, -0.02903563156723976, -0.026822341606020927, 0.034020278602838516, -0.050218366086483, -0.03645019978284836, 0.03782809153199196, -0.09024093300104141, 0.038349878042936325, 0.09191469103097916, 0.0001495235919719562, 0.011431608349084854, 0.029925666749477386, 0.02311222441494465, 0.07356773316860199, -0.03372742235660553, -0.0474761463701725, -0.024561172351241112, -0.008396896533668041, 0.0116979805752635, -0.005854178220033646, -0.011554575525224209, 0.023349542170763016, 0.051062557846307755, -0.013696547597646713, 0.008675298653542995, 0.03780902177095413, 0.017055807635188103, 0.006507698446512222, 0.015790171921253204, 0.03360188379883766, -0.014895129017531872, 0.006523837335407734, -0.006449876353144646, -0.045875195413827896, 0.03912898525595665, 0.0032271454110741615, -0.0021176657173782587, 0.006682975217700005, 0.010899432934820652, 0.0010379398008808494, -0.01147723663598299, -0.011764015071094036, 0.05523000285029411, -0.03691673278808594, -0.007330357562750578, 0.02222496084868908, -0.004964333493262529, -0.018303869292140007, 0.012146049179136753, -0.010641570203006268, -0.0112128471955657, -0.012266730889678001, -0.007162733934819698, -0.007609671913087368, 0.02221927046775818, -0.017586257308721542, 0.00009014828538056463, -0.02760222554206848, -0.02160860411822796, -0.03221037611365318, -0.027962131425738335, 0.03104044869542122, 0.034868866205215454, 0.017283055931329727, -0.016635950654745102, -0.0007935098838061094, 0.003914047498255968, 0.0173450019210577, 0.02797446772456169, -0.03255461901426315, -0.043706949800252914, -0.007429029326885939, -0.02357494831085205, 0.021291963756084442, 0.02843591943383217, -0.0216260626912117, -0.038317084312438965, 0.014733134768903255, 0.018440483137965202, -0.011131885461509228, -0.05192996561527252, -0.03431699052453041, -0.010021774098277092, 0.016313519328832626, -0.018497345969080925, 0.034293487668037415, 0.021229678764939308, -0.01918978802859783, -0.0044834124855697155, -0.03033754974603653, -0.015193857252597809, -0.03613488748669624, 0.013709680177271366, -0.009822918102145195, 0.017288237810134888, 0.016615448519587517, 0.013352020643651485, -0.019919458776712418, -0.014310827478766441, -0.0731760561466217, -0.03348641097545624, 0.014017333276569843, 0.013731763698160648, 0.04416321963071823, 0.013720735907554626, -0.01771184429526329, 0.08139864355325699, 0.030656110495328903, 0.004448661580681801, -0.03698820620775223, -0.015182474628090858, -0.02398778311908245, -0.05226695537567139, -0.0010195965878665447, 0.053344786167144775, 0.010652191005647182, 0.031355537474155426, -0.029610300436615944, 0.03329212963581085, 0.027047479525208473, 0.0033611501567065716, -0.019937295466661453, 0.010031436569988728, -0.002929203910753131, -0.0009109396487474442, 0.0063291131518781185, 0.0027617118321359158, 0.02692817524075508, -0.015726353973150253, -0.01140108983963728, -0.014167391695082188, 0.04479663446545601, -0.028399186208844185, 0.01843409799039364, -0.022708512842655182, -0.008468398824334145, -0.011042091064155102, 0.008370064198970795, 0.015698503702878952, -0.01661977358162403, -0.045384641736745834, 0.02139604650437832, 0.0321672298014164, 0.0042945691384375095, -0.003085019299760461, 0.039346370846033096, 0.02104862593114376, -0.006897671148180962, -0.020275525748729706, 0.027679210528731346, -0.012163928709924221, 0.0313006192445755, -0.04398727044463158, -0.02624141424894333, 0.0056223999708890915, 0.0019017871236428618, 0.0032409310806542635, -0.014069883152842522, -0.05288379639387131, -0.03324226662516594, -0.08220871537923813, -0.00514830369502306, -0.054896723479032516, 0.06780992448329926, -0.027384283021092415, 0.016708992421627045, -0.007629673928022385, -0.030876174569129944, 0.030186930671334267, -0.012202400714159012, -0.04032544046640396, 0.057427071034908295, 0.02951180934906006, -0.018194276839494705, 0.0048375059850513935, 0.015170621685683727, 0.024277547374367714, -0.0259032491594553, 0.016127055510878563, -0.0021124938502907753, 0.014610127545893192, -0.010289410129189491, 0.023250294849276543, -0.058737777173519135, -0.04412305727601051, -0.017207525670528412, -0.006668880116194487, 0.02392825484275818, -0.02068299800157547, 0.012833045795559883, 0.023778798058629036, 0.000790978956501931, 0.00483144773170352, -0.017706243321299553, 0.019604574888944626, 0.01216018758714199, 0.04333873093128204, 0.05658929795026779, 0.024587450549006462, -0.08716756850481033, 0.05747558921575546, 0.03720591217279434, 0.0005503742140717804, 0.05105352774262428, -0.0010840501636266708, -0.035305313766002655, -0.03895150497555733, 0.025534553453326225, 0.0739801824092865, 0.021731898188591003, 0.03926639258861542, 0.01852322928607464, 0.061148691922426224, 0.004007225390523672, -0.03163279965519905, -0.003247087122872472, 0.06679235398769379, 0.0008271078113466501, 0.0278437789529562, -0.040824227035045624, -0.0074292998760938644, 0.027816804125905037, -0.009834738448262215, 0.028188075870275497, 0.021015901118516922, 0.016272075474262238, 0.024609055370092392, 0.02372725121676922, 0.028137588873505592, -0.027494892477989197, 0.026596160605549812, 0.02283136174082756, 0.015498451888561249, 0.028851494193077087, -0.01769552193582058, 0.034986790269613266, 0.045801497995853424, 0.05854305252432823, 0.026579292491078377, 0.01016087643802166, -0.0957440435886383, -0.0151474978774786, 0.017804203554987907, 0.03975658863782883, -0.026817284524440765, -0.016816643998026848, -0.04298624023795128, -0.022953543812036514, 0.06424631923437119, -0.014417911879718304, 0.028789691627025604, -0.033232398331165314, 0.02360481768846512, -0.00879931915551424, -0.0513625368475914, -0.027998853474855423, 0.04367779940366745, -0.012193967588245869, 0.03300660848617554, 0.003377074608579278, -0.01225200667977333, -0.005479473154991865, 0.006796103436499834, -0.014717682264745235, 0.062017474323511124, -0.08180255442857742, 0.0076057580299675465, -0.022497231140732765, 0.007708484306931496, 0.015665464103221893, -0.033176522701978683, 0.01904168725013733, 0.0031791350338608027, -0.0054792738519608974, 0.023877382278442383, 0.04892881214618683, -0.029114428907632828, 0.0057655153796076775, 0.035815443843603134, 0.009905455633997917, -0.01697724312543869, -0.015702232718467712, 0.05421525239944458, 0.016742626205086708, 0.027093954384326935, 0.06734804064035416, 0.056400563567876816, -0.006505096331238747, 0.018849890679121017, -0.009298116900026798, 0.017337113618850708, 0.014492841437458992, -0.0024534042458981276, -0.03590793535113335, 0.03206908702850342, -0.015970047563314438, 0.07586182653903961, 0.0030231198761612177, 0.02897440642118454, -0.025836432352662086, -0.012306997552514076, 0.012731141410768032, 0.04079039394855499, -0.04397062212228775, -0.04012652486562729, -0.009852791205048561, 0.023693246766924858, 0.023133769631385803, -0.03110460191965103, -0.013589402660727501, -0.040393222123384476, -0.0034978853072971106, 0.0033729004207998514, -0.01700851507484913, 0.03559150546789169, -0.021574197337031364, -0.0018573531415313482, 0.01850506104528904, -0.028147082775831223, 0.012721426784992218, 0.003573712659999728, 0.017326422035694122, -0.0026471398305147886, -0.0588361993432045, 0.0030694580636918545, 0.008832945488393307, 0.018200840801000595, -0.022381065413355827, -0.04169485345482826, -0.004134086426347494, 0.021643290296196938, -0.019717257469892502, -0.0703398585319519, -0.0636405423283577, 0.02032485045492649, -0.001329301274381578, -0.01264011301100254, -0.00790348555892706, 0.029590409249067307, -0.0009285492124035954, -0.06341385841369629, -0.02500452660024166, 0.057237736880779266, -0.047690704464912415, -0.0370938777923584, 0.006191330961883068, 0.051906242966651917, 0.04839981347322464, 0.04170609638094902, 0.010210823267698288, 0.010996109806001186, -0.03044000081717968, -0.0374198742210865, 0.009926099330186844, 0.01555892825126648, -0.01879902556538582, 0.008944220840930939, -0.03176281973719597, -0.041856732219457626, 0.04649261012673378, -0.02068900875747204, -0.02340676821768284, 0.05455891788005829, 0.027118848636746407, 0.012161952443420887, -0.0027422725688666105, 0.004401718266308308, 0.01160692423582077, 0.023137111216783524, -0.004057238809764385, -0.01640182174742222, -0.025685088708996773, -0.037580396980047226, 0.02437472715973854, 0.0055862185545265675, -0.036272622644901276, 0.017500095069408417, 0.04486537352204323, -0.04687095806002617, -0.01077199075371027, 0.024827517569065094, 0.00447034602984786, 0.04200451076030731, -0.0033978631254285574, 0.02476058341562748, -0.003928763326257467, -0.01060399878770113, 0.01418932992964983, -0.03365917131304741, -0.01010120753198862, -0.0019545641262084246, 0.054091326892375946, -0.009970767423510551, -0.0026377378962934017, 0.013090469874441624, -0.001811240566894412, 0.006381558254361153, -0.05734790116548538, 0.03880014270544052, 0.01848394051194191, -0.02416333369910717, 0.07514267414808273, -0.03497212752699852, -0.024335797876119614, 0.04026691988110542, 0.03642302751541138, -4.0906934373197146e-7, 0.02891869843006134, 0.03552689403295517, 0.025211112573742867, 0.015810297802090645, -0.01325523667037487, -0.052213069051504135, 0.05682773515582085, -0.021777959540486336, 0.03606288880109787, -0.03612852096557617, 0.0011103578144684434, 0.04142575338482857, 0.04648300260305405, -0.0017242933390662074, -0.037217725068330765, -0.002969510853290558, -0.07308375835418701, -0.00615381496027112, 0.04033749923110008, -0.02796284295618534, 0.015211029909551144, 0.010844630189239979, 0.06119535490870476, -0.011849474161863327, 0.011168308556079865, -0.02651435323059559, -0.08239851891994476, -0.014102277345955372, -0.009624878875911236, -0.04044231027364731, 0.048915453255176544, -0.0599563829600811, 0.005050810519605875, 0.015513032674789429, -0.02041976898908615, 0.020449280738830566, 0.03129211813211441, 0.0379897765815258, 0.02038675546646118, 0.06408212333917618, -0.02047821693122387, 0.020290881395339966, 0.014516502618789673, -0.01612664945423603, 0.12753163278102875, 0.07762667536735535, 0.017451710999011993, -0.04600302129983902, -0.013522092252969742, -0.02446114644408226, 0.0265162605792284, -0.004275091923773289, 0.025688255205750465, 0.032964058220386505, -0.030465589836239815, 0.014661216177046299, 0.04451429843902588, 0.046067848801612854, -0.03159262612462044, 0.03723950684070587, -0.030477315187454224, -0.036584414541721344, 0.04074444994330406, 0.042537327855825424, -0.0011083009885624051, -0.0169370174407959, -0.01267858687788248, -0.019196713343262672, -0.010783558711409569, -0.05182946100831032, 0.013612165115773678, -0.014993889257311821, 0.004970324691385031, 0.004119358025491238, -0.014533273875713348, 0.03974486514925957, 0.024806298315525055, 0.017077282071113586, -0.007446457166224718, -0.008466814644634724, -0.023562505841255188, -0.006786753423511982, 0.04522760957479477, 0.0593331940472126, 0.02807980589568615, -0.0012022900627925992, 0.010372702963650227, 0.01707715541124344, -0.046860918402671814, 0.00695415772497654, -0.03113049641251564, 0.044336359947919846, -0.02312190644443035, -0.007456734776496887, -0.035157158970832825, 0.008441325277090073, -0.019729264080524445, -0.019300708547234535, -0.022722607478499413, 0.02726953662931919, -0.005086441989988089, -0.06911810487508774, 0.002580560278147459, -0.02441897988319397, -0.034577492624521255, -0.002697252668440342, 0.010566435754299164, 0.031228281557559967, -0.05098310485482216, 0.010939679108560085, 0.009745420888066292, 0.03868645802140236, -0.03133385255932808, 0.002114679431542754, 0.005781035870313644, 0.02532794140279293, -0.050235815346241, -0.01255746465176344, 0.00014778519107494503, 0.02104618400335312, 0.004249020479619503, -0.007121805101633072, -0.00746941240504384, -0.005857932846993208, -0.043416786938905716, 0.04450426623225212, -0.03132043778896332, -0.01491507701575756, 0.015993136912584305, -0.00584044773131609, 0.006870341952890158, 0.03321598842740059, -0.0076679508201777935, -0.03599034622311592, 0.015300460159778595, 0.039984460920095444, 0.06571150571107864, -0.06184437498450279, -0.05913820117712021, -0.023562660440802574, 0.013745532371103764, 0.008526381105184555, -0.03272241726517677, 0.033569127321243286, 0.0007423615898005664, 0.026782335713505745, -0.06463879346847534, 0.024872178211808205, 0.005113510414958, 0.016702480614185333, -0.00197176868095994, -0.041439980268478394, 0.0059212916530668736, 0.045162491500377655, 0.024228956550359726, -0.00003784869477385655, 0.011602241545915604, -0.024309545755386353, 0.02621455118060112, -0.007748166564851999, -0.038557425141334534, -0.05502184107899666, -0.038396257907152176, -0.035491038113832474, 0.008371679112315178, -0.024514781311154366, 0.034966763108968735, -0.003479552222415805, 0.007741352077573538, -0.0031396623235195875, -0.010843519121408463, 0.021601153537631035, 0.024039333686232567, -0.009455492720007896, -0.009790540672838688, 0.008249664679169655, -0.015415227971971035, 0.025191927328705788, -0.0026082710828632116, 0.017554190009832382, 0.0013271721545606852, 0.037063706666231155, -0.008837705478072166, -0.06263817101716995, 0.011460935696959496, -0.024434199556708336, -0.06319853663444519, 0.05471784994006157, 0.006148104090243578, 0.01899397186934948, 0.006864611059427261, 0.012940892018377781, -0.0011357152834534645, 0.025394637137651443, -0.005682595074176788, 0.028110641986131668, 0.018463628366589546, -0.00047707444173283875, 0.009451193735003471, -0.05524227395653725, 0.019250720739364624, 0.028221743181347847, -0.00067396170925349, 0.03601542487740517, 0.02425496280193329, 0.014604940079152584, -0.042136967182159424, -0.009456857107579708, -0.012117400765419006, -0.0065228259190917015, -0.025463413447141647, 0.00785592757165432, 0.0395064651966095, 0.028317075222730637, 0.030790042132139206, -0.013913980685174465, 0.0005019726813770831, -0.0039148107171058655, -0.04130154475569725, -0.032643288373947144, -0.00799605157226324, 0.02101864293217659, 0.021112920716404915, -0.04571133106946945, 0.05135633051395416, 0.012284770607948303, -0.033438656479120255, 0.003796677803620696, 0.0016671253833919764, 0.01169369462877512, -0.003689468838274479, -0.0017372284783050418, -0.01660151779651642, 0.013503785245120525, 0.05504017695784569, 0.007368743419647217, -0.009052557870745659, 0.007212563417851925, 0.00008779398194747046, -0.040797337889671326, 0.00910844188183546, 0.012771381065249443, 0.030439473688602448, -0.08552248775959015, 0.038894958794116974, -0.039918310940265656, -0.03641311451792717, 0.025246869772672653, -0.03238731250166893, 0.0319715291261673, 0.021796973422169685, 0.014205203391611576, 0.0026923709083348513, 0.04017091542482376, 0.036973096430301666, -0.0005194953992031515, 0.0030247175600379705, -0.019281426444649696, 0.047088269144296646, 0.04051930084824562, -0.019362913444638252, -0.0070548346266150475, -0.024351544678211212, 0.005645282566547394, -0.011669733561575413, -0.028561346232891083, -0.015129825100302696, -0.012078088708221912, -0.012203029356896877, -0.015542772598564625, -0.01438959687948227, 0.0031737713143229485, 0.038548603653907776, -0.04061150178313255, 0.000543811940588057, 0.020157769322395325, 0.04378829523921013, -0.061004530638456345, -0.015090804547071457, -0.011907534673810005, -0.03841974958777428, 0.015367342159152031, 0.042819876223802567, 0.005010867491364479, -0.030216949060559273, -0.028138307854533195, -0.023231036961078644, -0.015833841636776924, -0.07457123696804047, 0.0011596799595281482, -0.06067504733800888, 0.024811048060655594, -0.026111965999007225, -0.006914203055202961, 0.04510684683918953, 0.03490011394023895, 0.012902872636914253, -0.06944713741540909, 0.04764029383659363, 0.05146114528179169, -0.020701028406620026, -0.017350846901535988, -0.006187622435390949, -0.05913296341896057, -0.000054845491831656545, 0.07972008734941483, 0.03351866081357002, 0.014063251204788685, 0.0444650873541832, -0.004704905673861504, -0.03108149953186512, -0.034522660076618195, 0.06126299872994423, -0.03304475173354149, -0.0008326389361172915, -0.014901095069944859, 0.016749104484915733, -0.022971361875534058, 0.013853872194886208, 0.010134096257388592, 0.007729358039796352, 0.015266533009707928, 0.027470482513308525, -0.0038822819478809834, -0.014968334697186947, -0.011815563775599003, 0.01761271432042122, 0.027630021795630455, 0.041425541043281555, 0.021498730406165123, 0.0402187779545784, 0.005617511924356222, -0.05079042166471481, 0.031104715541005135, -0.03846125677227974, -0.01171894371509552, -0.01614462584257126, 0.02461683377623558, -0.015292191877961159, -0.055124811828136444, -0.016965830698609352, 0.0165718887001276, -0.012791916728019714, -0.008773311041295528, 0.05400045961141586, -0.004616550635546446, -0.003754806937649846, -0.013199567794799805, 0.026481883600354195, 0.032593052834272385, 0.03280162811279297, 0.0008029892924241722, -0.004571060184389353, -0.00844875443726778, 0.010280204005539417, 0.021786540746688843, 0.013165577314794064, 0.013318621553480625, 0.036055583506822586, -0.010970299132168293, 0.036692023277282715, 0.0167272686958313, 0.0014919351087883115, 0.01690470241010189, 0.0008160177967511117, -0.01629548706114292, 0.03685477375984192, -0.006031810771673918, 0.03228975832462311, -0.032045867294073105, -0.0029599249828606844, 0.011025998741388321, -0.022114213556051254, -0.011917633935809135, -0.005574699956923723, 0.026790814474225044, -0.0019496595486998558, 0.010486123152077198, -0.0014207626227289438, 0.011457734741270542, -0.03509107977151871, 0.010921264998614788, -0.06137886270880699, -0.0089297816157341, 0.015290528535842896, -0.04003268480300903, -0.004384050611406565, -0.016587551683187485, -0.0365060418844223, -0.03018602356314659, 0.031014323234558105, 0.025914499536156654, 0.0001370905083604157, -0.03295503556728363, -0.02725154720246792, -0.005671883001923561, 0.06932764500379562, -0.036814700812101364, -0.011459290981292725, -0.005829359870404005, -0.027365602552890778, -0.021113624796271324, -0.012608530931174755 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/35510/why-does-including-latitude-and-longitude-in-a-gam-account-for-spatial-autocorre">Why does including latitude and longitude in a GAM account for spatial autocorrelation?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I am interested in the effect of a predictor vector $X_i$ on a binary outcome $Y_i$, with corresponding spatial location $s_i$, so I've considered the spatial random effects model, </p> <p>\begin{equation} logit(P(Y_i=1)) = X_i \beta + Z(s_i) \end{equation}</p> <p>where $Z(s_i)$ is a stationary mean zero random process whose covariance structure is known up to a number of parameters $\theta$. It appears that this model is usually fit using Bayesian sampling algorithms, which can take a very long time to run when $n$ is large, since you have to sample from the joint posterior distribution of $\beta, \theta$ and the random effects. To circumvent the computational complexity and the expert tuning required for the MCMC, I've instead fit the model </p> <p>\begin{equation} logit(P(Y_i=1)) = X_i \beta + f(s_i) \end{equation}</p> <p>where $f(s_i)$ is estimated by a 2-D spline, which can be fit with the gam package in R in a matter of seconds. I have found in simulation studies that this model is effective at removing the spatial autocorrelation from the residuals and gives reasonable estimates for $\beta$. This leaves me wondering why this approach is not prominent in the literature. Why do users often opt for the computationally intensive sampling algorithms? Is there some drawback or something systematically lacking in this approach? </p>
49,903
[ -0.0398201122879982, 0.0026200960855931044, 0.0042372155003249645, 0.003676031017675996, 0.03756324574351311, 0.00045623729238286614, -0.01768091879785061, -0.041107404977083206, 0.047954026609659195, -0.03140181675553322, 0.01436606328934431, 0.07775356620550156, 0.06582365185022354, 0.0437331460416317, 0.03039766475558281, -0.009271077811717987, 0.03415674343705177, 0.011109941639006138, -0.020422877743840218, -0.029508909210562706, -0.006093870382755995, 0.038212794810533524, 0.007383177522569895, -0.014692048542201519, -0.03922533616423607, 0.023149363696575165, 0.024109268561005592, -0.0029527635779231787, -0.03788800165057182, 0.07696537673473358, -0.025506993755698204, -0.00830890517681837, -0.007394260261207819, 0.03620969131588936, -0.026634573936462402, -0.021143747493624687, -0.030698345974087715, -0.038888610899448395, 0.057318367063999176, 0.01943071372807026, -0.019453465938568115, -0.011784209869801998, -0.0350189208984375, 0.010488342493772507, -0.0331280417740345, 0.03206725791096687, -0.016014518216252327, 0.010691992938518524, 0.049830298870801926, -0.005342673975974321, 0.02891119383275509, 0.012251063250005245, 0.017711250111460686, 0.043605737388134, 0.0007777869468554854, -0.026615245267748833, 0.04442008584737778, 0.06328707188367844, -0.00013941244105808437, -0.035149455070495605, -0.022988909855484962, -0.027402957901358604, 0.022816700860857964, -0.025662537664175034, -0.0018032044172286987, 0.017313901335000992, -0.0026025124825537205, -0.0182761549949646, 0.04045562446117401, -0.017551060765981674, 0.0302446112036705, 0.02079855091869831, -0.005361977033317089, 0.012236705049872398, 0.026844283565878868, -0.023022020235657692, -0.006451297085732222, 0.026189394295215607, 0.01905747875571251, 0.011528972536325455, -0.008127718232572079, -0.005760332103818655, 0.027068400755524635, -0.00343499262817204, -0.022618789225816727, 0.01169712096452713, 0.05714042857289314, -0.031215092167258263, 0.0028020264580845833, -0.0052663651295006275, -0.020386379212141037, 0.03870364651083946, 0.025711188092827797, 0.006679665297269821, -0.057749032974243164, 0.05377916246652603, -0.023821700364351273, 0.04184582084417343, 0.012292982079088688, 0.01551783550530672, -0.06208908185362816, -0.051438622176647186, 0.010231975466012955, 0.06247066706418991, -0.018996587023139, -0.01100757997483015, 0.006511455401778221, 0.011957459151744843, -0.04523070901632309, -0.03614243119955063, -0.025523371994495392, 0.00133526511490345, 0.007947290316224098, 0.00264090858399868, 0.027230679988861084, -0.0007316459086723626, 0.017751429229974747, -0.022167731076478958, 0.01871531270444393, 0.07824245095252991, 0.02686227113008499, -0.009993375279009342, -0.00506302947178483, -0.03412449359893799, -0.06157951056957245, 0.031071539968252182, 0.017581237480044365, -0.04917122423648834, -0.060762304812669754, 0.02337595820426941, -0.010620017535984516, -0.01215823832899332, 0.02929205447435379, 0.0223075058311224, 0.012317179702222347, 0.0309352558106184, -0.0773836225271225, -0.07488373667001724, 0.0466042198240757, 0.007744073402136564, 0.04813750833272934, -0.05001165717840195, 0.0009509128867648542, -0.030662719160318375, 0.025195792317390442, 0.0025259433314204216, 0.05350552499294281, 0.004479941446334124, 0.03249697387218475, 0.0036361641250550747, -0.0783684104681015, 0.006424164865165949, -0.04145123064517975, -0.027709122747182846, -0.04226092994213104, -0.0990506038069725, 0.018557634204626083, 0.02160828746855259, -0.004223975818604231, -0.022520562633872032, 0.07114364206790924, 0.010827234014868736, -0.020722929388284683, -0.039566345512866974, 0.010933528654277325, -0.027208393439650536, 0.06064668670296669, 0.01917843706905842, 0.049671467393636703, 0.036918289959430695, -0.02999952621757984, 0.006240482907742262, -0.0066138384863734245, 0.018419712781906128, 0.04945049434900284, -0.0384465791285038, 0.03118778020143509, 0.0020685140043497086, -0.013301786966621876, 0.006537367589771748, -0.03569018468260765, -0.000378728611394763, -0.039200231432914734, -0.018747659400105476, 0.001766468514688313, 0.04521932452917099, -0.01572556234896183, -0.016316169872879982, 0.03198941424489021, -0.01945810206234455, -0.03590180352330208, -0.06587228178977966, 0.022352809086441994, 0.027978498488664627, -0.007367975078523159, 0.05248266085982323, -0.01847977750003338, 0.030819186940789223, 0.019030725583434105, -0.029341578483581543, -0.01730302721261978, 0.0012331418693065643, 0.03779061138629913, -0.03774407505989075, 0.030433258041739464, 0.052889883518218994, 0.04227345809340477, -0.007092252839356661, 0.034505825489759445, -0.016406824812293053, -0.044605910778045654, -0.010777855291962624, -0.02568679116666317, 0.03637344017624855, -0.02691551484167576, -0.04395822808146477, -0.0026776620652526617, -0.006297421175986528, -0.029154503718018532, -0.004766253754496574, -0.07559861242771149, 0.06882867962121964, 0.09478013962507248, -0.02610684372484684, 0.001860921154730022, 0.055473800748586655, 0.030727682635188103, -0.00782863236963749, -0.014346740208566189, -0.026067670434713364, -0.07865646481513977, 0.005819236394017935, 0.06934171169996262, -0.00955402385443449, -0.0029855582397431135, 0.016169292852282524, 0.017480311915278435, 0.03842645511031151, 0.002575910184532404, 0.00754529470577836, -0.030499422922730446, -0.01979721337556839, 0.019663900136947632, 0.0010437170276418328, 0.01908387802541256, -0.012228721752762794, -0.00936336163431406, -0.008603169582784176, 0.02099263109266758, -0.013925292529165745, -0.004478336777538061, 0.02226388454437256, 0.006603837013244629, 0.006580832414329052, -0.024812640622258186, 0.01362645160406828, 0.0665278509259224, -0.01364425290375948, -0.031455427408218384, 0.04626106098294258, 0.031604450196027756, 0.002025660825893283, -0.011696545407176018, -0.02990625984966755, 0.02420700155198574, 0.04546936973929405, -0.008622043766081333, 0.020755382254719734, 0.024027910083532333, -0.02780725061893463, 0.03427010774612427, -0.03064892627298832, -0.01819673553109169, -0.010138456709682941, 0.021995000541210175, 0.02181978151202202, -0.0042132907547056675, 0.006517094559967518, -0.01341936644166708, 0.0018401739653199911, -0.012109183706343174, 0.051682502031326294, 0.00037052520201541483, 0.04057779908180237, -0.05966808646917343, -0.010602262802422047, -0.006276040803641081, 0.003947031684219837, -0.0012156227603554726, -0.007400603499263525, -0.010135720483958721, -0.008021729066967964, 0.005506931338459253, -0.08085191994905472, -0.034797001630067825, -0.03551666811108589, 0.013293527998030186, -0.03382206708192825, -0.07725081592798233, 0.05179722234606743, 0.051059529185295105, -0.04316322132945061, 0.05026068910956383, -0.02128504030406475, 0.017571765929460526, -0.01603340543806553, 0.008126465603709221, 0.02966601401567459, -0.027391571551561356, -0.0027893849182873964, 0.019969092682003975, -0.03246351704001427, -0.022058622911572456, -0.08390497416257858, -0.03058590553700924, 0.016168970614671707, -0.016011444851756096, 0.03146428242325783, -0.02099369652569294, 0.010243932716548443, 0.06187968701124191, 0.058162495493888855, 0.000963938538916409, -0.0438912957906723, 0.0049001784063875675, 0.007473831530660391, -0.043420374393463135, -0.020800352096557617, 0.00843577366322279, 0.03792022913694382, 0.024192756041884422, -0.027642078697681427, 0.018774336203932762, 0.05398191884160042, 0.029292747378349304, 0.024968428537249565, 0.012761566787958145, -0.0336136668920517, -0.016337133944034576, 0.036008596420288086, 0.04431562498211861, -0.01258847676217556, -0.011186358518898487, -0.006925390567630529, -0.00442881602793932, 0.006614654790610075, -0.07254446297883987, 0.005069090519100428, -0.034720808267593384, -0.019438641145825386, -0.04664064198732376, 0.03186659887433052, 0.020464902743697166, -0.052101463079452515, 0.012344347313046455, 0.00209046876989305, 0.025562738999724388, -0.005473816301673651, 0.0034896295983344316, 0.022731585428118706, 0.035414744168519974, -0.009573252871632576, 0.000368050328688696, -0.009829471819102764, 0.042423345148563385, 0.027620552107691765, -0.01634681597352028, 0.0010035564191639423, 0.013650651089847088, 0.028754757717251778, -0.006809613201767206, -0.026086630299687386, -0.02200944349169731, -0.009684770368039608, -0.07931851595640182, 0.016614267602562904, -0.05467284098267555, 0.03627505525946617, 0.004520856309682131, 0.010625628754496574, -0.005221082828938961, -0.024355070665478706, 0.006450369022786617, 0.03324355557560921, -0.07013297826051712, -0.00046121992636471987, -0.014975067228078842, -0.003397260792553425, 0.01756124570965767, -0.013668925501406193, 0.07434065639972687, 0.001917384215630591, 0.02445085532963276, -0.0217574555426836, 0.010044069029390812, -0.012838052585721016, 0.013684277422726154, -0.005100725684314966, -0.03706730157136917, 0.007063278462737799, 0.014164485968649387, 0.0218184906989336, -0.05414079874753952, -0.009067941457033157, 0.03652520850300789, -0.004008690360933542, -0.0123891057446599, -0.01833937130868435, 0.020041286945343018, -0.0034003928303718567, 0.009409887716174126, 0.03052450157701969, -0.004518467467278242, -0.00633477745577693, 0.005852510686963797, 0.01364425104111433, 0.029108891263604164, 0.04668978974223137, -0.019455721601843834, -0.029375972226262093, -0.022197404876351357, -0.014257793314754963, 0.0399935208261013, 0.001955633284524083, 0.006707510445266962, -0.0001607072481419891, 0.08530052751302719, 0.058988746255636215, -0.05243927240371704, 0.020437568426132202, 0.009658552706241608, -0.02016262896358967, 0.009755305014550686, -0.009765292517840862, -0.01808984950184822, -0.011968091130256653, -0.01445620134472847, 0.07064461708068848, -0.018790483474731445, -0.04391296207904816, -0.00010478071635589004, 0.03117409348487854, -0.02737647108733654, -0.025976886972784996, 0.009259574115276337, 0.03636728972196579, 0.04345891624689102, 0.04147513955831528, -0.027249814942479134, -0.008696786127984524, 0.024123944342136383, 0.030786052346229553, 0.03434073552489281, -0.009080815128982067, -0.07084968686103821, -0.005473433528095484, 0.04284263774752617, 0.0026506250724196434, -0.021209275349974632, 0.01640893891453743, -0.06211303547024727, -0.007302321959286928, 0.012139256112277508, -0.019468707963824272, -0.00863620638847351, -0.019923821091651917, 0.005661255680024624, -0.013939352706074715, -0.06337366253137589, -0.06846468150615692, 6.749516501258768e-7, -0.026794200763106346, 0.015080629847943783, -0.004450620152056217, -0.0411670058965683, -0.029477838426828384, 0.024366628378629684, -0.0012248028069734573, 0.0485326386988163, -0.011330295354127884, -0.0073801735416054726, -0.019651830196380615, 0.005494633689522743, -0.017189055681228638, -0.0597461499273777, 0.017510242760181427, 0.007359374314546585, -0.0380098856985569, 0.052869293838739395, -0.009199527092278004, -0.0758664458990097, 0.06750798970460892, -0.00883601326495409, 0.007436515763401985, 0.004680883139371872, -0.026391200721263885, 0.057001806795597076, 0.010375144891440868, 0.01174946315586567, 0.0427754782140255, -0.0224411990493536, -0.021437648683786392, -0.006152933929115534, -0.0043138861656188965, -0.013848809525370598, -0.02134617790579796, -0.0013808119110763073, -0.029500287026166916, -0.017908675596117973, -0.03880445286631584, 0.031117763370275497, 0.02307976223528385, 0.000540338282007724, -0.013350261375308037, -0.049688439816236496, -0.005200622137635946, 0.048650093376636505, -0.023421386256814003, 0.0161204282194376, -0.023696793243288994, 0.021325940266251564, 0.008185616694390774, -0.0072097983211278915, 0.018817860633134842, -0.012202154844999313, 0.005851247347891331, 0.005462515167891979, -0.05863747373223305, -0.007615636568516493, -0.02567461133003235, 0.014555034227669239, -0.007017027586698532, -0.04655871540307999, 0.03635178506374359, 0.0049117435701191425, 0.038645606487989426, -0.012356254272162914, -0.07347346097230911, -0.012998529709875584, 0.008225631900131702, 0.018260156735777855, 0.01771937496960163, 0.008898726664483547, -0.020571716129779816, -0.022229954600334167, -0.006856267806142569, -0.058651164174079895, -0.048015449196100235, 0.03049142099916935, -0.02408282645046711, -0.00260986783541739, -0.050559479743242264, 0.0037244039122015238, -0.035621680319309235, -0.025307418778538704, -0.012092367745935917, 0.05484386533498764, -0.005335978697985411, 0.010042545385658741, -0.008870531804859638, 0.059571243822574615, 0.06592001020908356, -0.008300616405904293, -0.02558455429971218, 0.047532469034194946, -0.03495057299733162, -0.022556759417057037, -0.026128459721803665, 0.02503085881471634, -0.03824681043624878, -0.027614008635282516, -0.030927548184990883, -0.002335659461095929, 0.008508083410561085, 0.008664163760840893, -0.02198663353919983, 0.06433350592851639, -0.026961402967572212, -0.0025110398419201374, -0.0036106931511312723, -0.0010702257277444005, 0.006168535444885492, 0.029229823499917984, -0.044895052909851074, 0.015721555799245834, 0.020350856706500053, 0.03827064856886864, 0.02460193820297718, -0.0059708948247134686, -0.02147834189236164, 0.04595116898417473, 0.060345690697431564, -0.01722053252160549, 0.04263635352253914, 0.009705252945423126, -0.004126970190554857, 0.06769249588251114, 0.03346675634384155, 0.005184262990951538, 0.0347876138985157, 0.03373710438609123, -0.05341697484254837, -0.02756640873849392, -0.028039390221238136, 0.014280452392995358, 0.048359215259552, -0.02596491388976574, 0.0201401449739933, 0.035720791667699814, -0.018406976014375687, 0.014799149706959724, -0.009861883707344532, 0.01927190274000168, -0.00993217620998621, -0.0409945584833622, 0.049001600593328476, -0.0046505979262292385, 0.0009217310580424964, 0.024921860545873642, -0.009895052760839462, 0.020697778090834618, -0.0036410789471119642, 0.014506794512271881, 0.03372674807906151, 0.040305785834789276, 0.008400598540902138, -0.062289755791425705, 0.039915766566991806, -0.014400798827409744, 0.0004772331449203193, 0.012281489558517933, -0.02860947698354721, 0.07145076245069504, 0.02867114543914795, 0.012874836102128029, -0.044329721480607986, -0.010786307975649834, -0.07169875502586365, -0.008663141168653965, 0.0173697080463171, -0.00858356710523367, 0.029321283102035522, -0.04362667724490166, 0.035853635519742966, -0.018576109781861305, -0.006184816360473633, -0.023634174838662148, -0.09950961172580719, -0.0010858150199055672, -0.008913056924939156, -0.014178217388689518, 0.05664462223649025, 0.019515199586749077, -0.039127036929130554, 0.0333026684820652, -0.07086921483278275, 0.021015023812651634, 0.012409217655658722, 0.025411123409867287, -0.024688510224223137, 0.0794246718287468, -0.010570121929049492, -0.015708982944488525, -0.019435860216617584, -0.040475957095623016, 0.11783962696790695, 0.05157056823372841, 0.053812239319086075, -0.07330780476331711, 0.009001162834465504, 0.010639475658535957, 0.004074435215443373, 0.0005928004393354058, -0.02475634776055813, 0.013107143342494965, -0.027696019038558006, 0.06100355461239815, 0.038266751915216446, 0.02139422856271267, -0.007841579616069794, 0.0336613729596138, -0.05840393155813217, 0.017595812678337097, 0.01117046270519495, -0.0147973308339715, -0.0035742390900850296, -0.03553736209869385, -0.021793439984321594, 0.004808243364095688, -0.039728399366140366, -0.023512914776802063, -0.03512581065297127, -0.01259914692491293, -0.00959519948810339, 0.00485270144417882, -0.024971185252070427, -0.023067347705364227, 0.005104849115014076, 0.006287400610744953, 0.01094595342874527, -0.006644596345722675, 0.007994021289050579, -0.024170199409127235, 0.005581119563430548, 0.0315900482237339, -0.03034539893269539, 0.03368963673710823, 0.011717150919139385, -0.02897435426712036, -0.023833028972148895, -0.04298444464802742, -0.023153048008680344, 0.08150067180395126, -0.020165598019957542, -0.019003190100193024, 0.000647537934128195, -0.0007012769929133356, -0.0018443866865709424, -0.004831528291106224, -0.01222475990653038, 0.03420834243297577, 0.02453695982694626, -0.015202532522380352, 0.009911983273923397, -0.012217667885124683, 0.03297281265258789, 0.004047326277941465, 0.0491160973906517, 0.04054974764585495, -0.039061352610588074, -0.016162076964974403, -0.003965175244957209, 0.056664757430553436, 0.02658613957464695, 0.015530898235738277, 0.006065755151212215, 0.01315532997250557, -0.0451970249414444, -0.00982703361660242, -0.0006390347261913121, -0.01201657671481371, 0.021897418424487114, -0.014420641586184502, 0.005137565545737743, -0.026548271998763084, -0.029420852661132812, -0.012774582020938396, -0.04652227833867073, 0.011989434249699116, -0.027545489370822906, 0.018666740506887436, 0.018388615921139717, 0.009041980840265751, 0.013740128837525845, -0.011832447722554207, -0.03464939445257187, 0.0645066425204277, -0.026119021698832512, -0.03564346209168434, -0.042998164892196655, -0.007066347170621157, -0.055818311870098114, -0.006655947770923376, 0.025771087035536766, 0.04067399725317955, -0.001095450366847217, 0.040545497089624405, 0.03039507195353508, 0.023519061505794525, -0.004722401965409517, -0.005518915597349405, -0.0009042384917847812, -0.048730067908763885, -0.026975015178322792, 0.0012477904092520475, -0.023756003007292747, -0.01359016727656126, 0.03862643986940384, 0.007076343055814505, 0.005103743635118008, 0.026684608310461044, -0.012302388437092304, -0.04425251483917236, 0.010142880491912365, 0.010630321688950062, 0.02878616191446781, -0.04956125095486641, 0.012791989371180534, -0.012142174877226353, -0.04267001897096634, -0.025532854720950127, -0.0047963340766727924, 0.04328165948390961, 0.04866775497794151, -0.040766485035419464, 0.015205122530460358, 0.04946563392877579, -0.012550657615065575, 0.02661069668829441, 0.017658907920122147, 0.00438314862549305, 0.031338635832071304, 0.0496075265109539, -0.02556788921356201, -0.02934923768043518, 0.013027304783463478, -0.031601712107658386, -0.03481176495552063, 0.0318596214056015, -0.04114688187837601, 0.0333552360534668, 0.022440433502197266, 0.005539173260331154, -0.02490815334022045, 0.03985299542546272, -0.008646364323794842, 0.016210807487368584, -0.0342860110104084, 0.048063650727272034, 0.028883380815386772, -0.005074264481663704, 0.024271370843052864, 0.01975191757082939, 0.02041115239262581, 0.021252818405628204, 0.015849556773900986, -0.009412397630512714, 0.020970117300748825, 0.008304981514811516, -0.012946444563567638, 0.018873663619160652, -0.015029042959213257, -0.006706657819449902, 0.016282513737678528, 0.04931919649243355, -0.012108049355447292, 0.02707967534661293, 0.006553401239216328, 0.015871122479438782, -0.10236377269029617, -0.011920076794922352, 0.03335370868444443, 0.029456814751029015, 0.038202885538339615, -0.05352242290973663, -0.0032892462331801653, 0.017596030607819557, -0.06042393296957016, 0.019249625504016876, 0.06125786900520325, 0.008592978119850159, -0.023085901513695717, -0.019238442182540894, -0.017680982127785683, -0.022469135001301765, 0.02208062820136547, 0.027648545801639557, 0.023546218872070312, 0.059273552149534225, 0.005476637277752161, -0.04042908549308777, 0.012234365567564964, 0.014163918793201447, -0.01583787612617016, -0.021502496674656868, 0.02742636762559414, -0.017928143963217735, -0.0049672722816467285, 0.018488654866814613, 0.0180842075496912, -0.002253575948998332, -0.009876706637442112, 0.045300621539354324, 0.004290508572012186, 0.035470206290483475, 0.04290296509861946, 0.020390568301081657, -0.0177770983427763, -0.01821007765829563, 0.013081332668662071, 0.025328509509563446, -0.04157065600156784, 0.0007206032169051468, -0.004019849468022585, -0.0012260004878044128, -0.01061950996518135, 0.020627662539482117, -0.012896062806248665, -0.023948585614562035, -0.003378442721441388, 0.002957122167572379, 0.00607606116682291, -0.029512109234929085, 0.011967401951551437, -0.04347173869609833, -0.007868370972573757, 0.06735748797655106, 0.025102660059928894, -0.025588804855942726, -0.030681034550070763, -0.028362996876239777, -0.015359638258814812, 0.009484334848821163, -0.011836265213787556, -0.019357185810804367, -0.031061748042702675, -0.010719867423176765, 0.025781674310564995, 0.005366286728531122, -0.034986142069101334, 0.02374989539384842, -0.03840110823512077, 0.03787585720419884, -0.02615697681903839, 0.017645003274083138, 0.021966800093650818, 0.025558656081557274, 0.021713385358452797, -0.06375771015882492, 0.06844224035739899, 0.004456117749214172, -0.026245146989822388, -0.03760496526956558, -0.022639606148004532, -0.0031882517505437136, 0.015567028895020485, 0.05750823765993118, 0.001293374109081924, 0.008580068126320839, 0.015486509539186954, 0.06464672088623047, -0.010160120204091072, -0.01571703888475895, 0.04833574220538139, -0.009576174430549145, -0.029738154262304306, 0.020482532680034637, -0.012756799347698689, -0.011385812424123287, 0.04235898330807686, 0.024613521993160248, -0.02847960963845253, -0.008462417870759964, -0.013832778669893742, 0.029500914737582207, 0.0226422231644392, -0.010083148255944252, 0.008017007261514664, 0.05411753058433533, -0.0031280354596674442, 0.03352300077676773, 0.013387522660195827, 0.014897260814905167, -0.05841517448425293, -0.012680239975452423, -0.05136983096599579, -0.07341117411851883, -0.02661363035440445, 0.0038503396790474653, -0.0028620059601962566, -0.030648423358798027, 0.026843490079045296, 0.015765054151415825, -0.020372090861201286, 0.02363789826631546, 0.04705512896180153, 0.005190282128751278, 0.04297780990600586, 0.02169080078601837, 0.014334244653582573, 0.03579699993133545, -0.0240206066519022, -0.011385861784219742, 0.03608918935060501, 0.06080418452620506, 0.004670293070375919, 0.0028401194140315056, 0.02327881194651127, 0.02114676684141159, 0.033235326409339905, -0.0015203141374513507, 0.05312906578183174, -0.0326557494699955, -0.03373580053448677, 0.027405599132180214, 0.008045347407460213, 0.004863728303462267, -0.020341480150818825, -0.005311673041433096, 0.06948861479759216, -0.023264000192284584, -0.022792907431721687, -0.01416313461959362, -0.012527604587376118, -0.025837590917944908, 0.018410377204418182, -0.016480613499879837, 0.017157038673758507, 0.024371130391955376, 0.020359564572572708, 0.04169329255819321, -0.020683132112026215, -0.007856723852455616, -0.0037695812061429024, -0.008975360542535782, 0.026163175702095032, 0.00784359686076641, -0.007994166575372219, -0.03573859483003616, -0.0015184007352218032, -0.044291380792856216, -0.001710002077743411, -0.009487519040703773, -0.00038433060399256647, -0.01666056551039219, 0.001624574651941657, 0.0010306970216333866, 0.0697656199336052, -0.0739021897315979, 0.002278477419167757, -0.03749311342835426, -0.016848793253302574, -0.015100700780749321, -0.03651119023561478 ]
<p>Based on real data (e.g. spot and futures prices of an index) if two series are correlated in the long run (e.g. strong positive significant correlation) it does not mean that they are cointegrated.</p> <p>What if two series are cointegrated: can we infer that they are also correlated in the long run? Can we find a case with real data that two series are cointegrated but they are not correlated in the long run?</p>
74,191
[ -0.027609504759311676, -0.02031978964805603, 0.0014814760070294142, 0.01593019999563694, 0.035141702741384506, 0.027108918875455856, -0.016090944409370422, -0.002619517268612981, 0.059364572167396545, -0.02321109175682068, 0.013401666656136513, -0.0043731271289289, 0.02294527366757393, 0.024171646684408188, 0.013769732788205147, 0.030208894982933998, -0.0029386936221271753, 0.009964581578969955, 0.017518071457743645, 0.00034154628519900143, -0.007593339774757624, 0.03584945946931839, 0.01893201470375061, 0.016540145501494408, -0.03231462091207504, 0.02408147044479847, 0.020845819264650345, -0.02992633543908596, 0.020925011485815048, 0.05878722295165062, -0.042595844715833664, 0.004216820001602173, 0.003057284979149699, 0.05144820362329483, 0.008784922771155834, -0.013698317110538483, -0.03300650790333748, -0.05281377211213112, 0.011973677203059196, 0.04038451239466667, -0.03214215859770775, -0.03218819946050644, 0.028542280197143555, 0.04676462709903717, -0.012058673426508904, 0.006452050060033798, -0.0048042782582342625, -0.03328995406627655, 0.01812223345041275, -0.03663494810461998, 0.04878994822502136, -0.019926883280277252, 0.037822041660547256, 0.029736310243606567, -0.03455635532736778, -0.017093118280172348, 0.052648309618234634, 0.06137901544570923, -0.006521215662360191, -0.055388908833265305, 0.004635249730199575, -0.01683754473924637, 0.030488857999444008, -0.0010944245150312781, -0.06442660093307495, 0.024870669469237328, -0.00535284960642457, -0.011064673773944378, 0.014534004963934422, -0.02462860383093357, 0.03334922716021538, -0.0004793263506144285, 0.03363518416881561, -0.016174722462892532, 0.04015126824378967, -0.01455176342278719, 0.009451247751712799, 0.04051608964800835, 0.038315918296575546, 0.060591064393520355, 0.0070351483300328255, 0.015490034595131874, 0.041160281747579575, 0.03832539916038513, 0.07163956761360168, 0.009439871646463871, 0.055161140859127045, -0.0181588064879179, 0.03552021086215973, 0.03935975581407547, 0.0020981987472623587, -0.03744238615036011, 0.06395457684993744, -0.016867326572537422, -0.048101186752319336, 0.01345589105039835, -0.03999554365873337, 0.012803304940462112, 0.026591965928673744, 0.0044540720991790295, 0.0013333074748516083, -0.029115945100784302, 0.024463292211294174, 0.03062894195318222, 0.008545055985450745, -0.00006239057256607339, -0.0009456069674342871, 0.00570979667827487, -0.015932269394397736, -0.02834721840918064, -0.009504035115242004, 0.006302819121629, 0.0038429973646998405, 0.018811265006661415, 0.0025678505189716816, 0.008919118903577328, -0.016674809157848358, -0.008678849786520004, 0.051206741482019424, 0.08307346701622009, 0.033339593559503555, -0.03550823777914047, -0.01731102727353573, -0.00328193511813879, -0.044564660638570786, -0.003315448760986328, 0.006661144085228443, -0.022633856162428856, -0.05654994025826454, 0.058016009628772736, 0.03202490136027336, -0.02222565934062004, 0.01017090119421482, -0.023346658796072006, 0.0597912035882473, 0.037295855581760406, -0.086675263941288, -0.05194663256406784, 0.06093033403158188, -0.030681787058711052, -0.016892896965146065, -0.05537886545062065, 0.044668324291706085, -0.0072109815664589405, 0.06765589118003845, -0.027066651731729507, 0.018156608566641808, 0.009432966820895672, 0.0109860273078084, 0.01825214922428131, 0.001958909211680293, -0.029845064505934715, -0.01421414315700531, -0.04566875100135803, 0.02271200530230999, -0.06094198301434517, -0.0015614180592820048, 0.044489238411188126, -0.004022372420877218, 0.01143370196223259, 0.04111040011048317, 0.019576730206608772, -0.020881300792098045, -0.01050658617168665, -0.0036611466202884912, -0.044749293476343155, 0.04888530820608139, -0.011766302399337292, 0.02595743164420128, 0.010202710516750813, -0.007522778119891882, 0.013286941684782505, 0.031469643115997314, 0.04675265774130821, -0.011067940853536129, -0.03129739314317703, -0.016494812443852425, 0.013066273182630539, 0.018888475373387337, -0.02475530095398426, -0.019855350255966187, -0.027925245463848114, -0.031963933259248734, -0.02095877192914486, 0.07254918664693832, 0.0685603991150856, 0.015022615902125835, -0.025515025481581688, 0.014555701054632664, -0.058924607932567596, -0.030297698453068733, -0.06762199848890305, 0.00403296435251832, -0.00924578309059143, -0.013702032156288624, 0.06452926248311996, -0.012092447839677334, 0.015321199782192707, -0.023102495819330215, -0.036051977425813675, -0.044133976101875305, 0.03480098396539688, -0.01018080860376358, -0.06516090780496597, 0.03759032115340233, 0.018112603574991226, 0.05203563719987869, -0.00018064088362734765, 0.02862299047410488, -0.018800878897309303, -0.06336725503206253, 0.030519966036081314, -0.030340095981955528, 0.028472833335399628, 0.004672757349908352, -0.007284261751919985, 0.03346056863665581, 0.00035462877713143826, -0.02879328466951847, 0.034588802605867386, -0.027040177956223488, 0.04210164025425911, 0.05940302833914757, -0.0253310464322567, -0.01202434953302145, 0.014045687392354012, 0.046579379588365555, 0.010403954423964024, -0.01426660269498825, -0.02650597132742405, -0.06590019166469574, -0.01360862236469984, 0.038282670080661774, 0.07506003230810165, -0.04082793369889259, 0.01686209999024868, 0.09110471606254578, 0.04855010658502579, -0.020707450807094574, 0.04656829684972763, 0.009414518252015114, -0.02427235245704651, 0.02135344035923481, -0.00992557778954506, -0.004913700744509697, -0.014789704233407974, 0.0180131234228611, -0.0034965858794748783, 0.017091818153858185, -0.0011295111617073417, -0.024283327162265778, 0.05155289173126221, 0.04164824262261391, 0.002739835064858198, -0.016303176060318947, -0.032259251922369, 0.054087333381175995, -0.03945968300104141, -0.0009130560792982578, -0.03441866487264633, 0.004423453938215971, 0.010807480663061142, 0.013046402484178543, -0.003303352277725935, 0.029174668714404106, -0.008102339692413807, -0.026855744421482086, -0.007854463532567024, 0.01511486154049635, -0.04884523153305054, -0.0009388704784214497, -0.021239422261714935, -0.02723771706223488, -0.02026713825762272, 0.00710376538336277, 0.02826451137661934, -0.005632994696497917, 0.02697746641933918, -0.005445532500743866, -0.03800472989678383, 0.0036383369006216526, -0.034678179770708084, -0.002990975510329008, 0.001495434669777751, -0.029161863029003143, 0.030611928552389145, -0.034077491611242294, -0.012937599793076515, -0.0035524198319762945, -0.007588384672999382, 0.043807581067085266, 0.04713509976863861, -0.029377136379480362, -0.03998885676264763, -0.026866823434829712, -0.03287924453616142, 0.007347282953560352, -0.02767336182296276, -0.03127889707684517, 0.048039473593235016, -0.026272812858223915, -0.03016308881342411, -0.030870582908391953, -0.005078128073364496, -0.010533422231674194, -0.035469286143779755, -0.0015094735426828265, 0.006590573582798243, -0.041929248720407486, 0.03515113517642021, -0.01691965013742447, -0.04615132883191109, -0.011826863512396812, -0.057148415595293045, -0.055403932929039, 0.02352387271821499, -0.024034708738327026, -0.0034891346003860235, -0.003373547689989209, -0.07460442930459976, 0.010306136682629585, -0.008230491541326046, -0.0015259619103744626, -0.016589364036917686, -0.00841884408146143, -0.016789132729172707, -0.03694625198841095, 0.014094647020101547, 0.007623493205755949, 0.020644256845116615, 0.0343242846429348, 0.03780839219689369, 0.037783972918987274, 0.01784711703658104, -0.00838484801352024, 0.02831517904996872, 0.016492897644639015, -0.007347049657255411, 0.017245303839445114, 0.0056180949322879314, 0.020116452127695084, -0.017999501898884773, -0.011877649463713169, 0.018922429531812668, -0.026654237881302834, 0.014597210101783276, -0.025922805070877075, 0.026627207174897194, -0.03474487364292145, 0.02129802480340004, -0.07569286972284317, 0.03861622512340546, 0.04015660658478737, -0.007422322873026133, -0.04330533742904663, 0.006617517676204443, 0.0024886764585971832, -0.005530236754566431, 0.02768598310649395, 0.03358668461441994, 0.014371052384376526, -0.024399757385253906, -0.029865987598896027, -0.006120111793279648, 0.00032066545099951327, 0.022840037941932678, -0.04481351375579834, -0.011021306738257408, 0.03677111491560936, 0.006601125467568636, 0.020938720554113388, -0.01252293772995472, -0.049057669937610626, -0.050392936915159225, -0.0624140128493309, 0.014583989977836609, -0.03391187638044357, 0.044999513775110245, -0.007996920496225357, 0.03537001833319664, 0.024584464728832245, 0.0020524710416793823, 0.005397135857492685, 0.018811076879501343, -0.05111238732933998, 0.02485615201294422, -0.0417228564620018, 0.018165308982133865, 0.004098150413483381, -0.042725954204797745, 0.003923497628420591, -0.047918107360601425, 0.0326005183160305, -0.03476940840482712, 0.0013277505058795214, -0.004941950552165508, 0.012216711416840553, 0.0016775797121226788, -0.03170245885848999, -0.0010733294766396284, -0.021618276834487915, 0.024018028751015663, -0.005690078716725111, 0.06262068450450897, 0.0794195681810379, 0.0062338137067854404, -0.0037557135801762342, -0.013546416535973549, 0.03588671237230301, 0.030177367851138115, 0.015201009809970856, 0.0319116972386837, -0.03460685908794403, -0.014833551831543446, 0.03089142218232155, 0.06350426375865936, 0.04406311735510826, 0.029132891446352005, -0.000045122840674594045, -0.024143099784851074, -0.04032277688384056, -0.015113461762666702, 0.020376870408654213, 0.01029219850897789, 0.03509462624788284, -0.02283359505236149, 0.05954061448574066, 0.011597227305173874, -0.04111962765455246, 0.032219525426626205, 0.05899691954255104, 0.0372622087597847, 0.01687917672097683, -0.00949749443680048, -0.05496326461434364, 0.0065629975870251656, -0.004648405127227306, 0.05284985154867172, 0.006713304203003645, -0.016500063240528107, -0.002764784498140216, 0.04277099668979645, 0.0008855944615788758, -0.011769510805606842, 0.005010172724723816, 0.012484024278819561, 0.06244227662682533, 0.0037648254074156284, -0.01608322374522686, 0.0697849914431572, 0.021988701075315475, 0.003936757333576679, 0.0414978563785553, -0.001394252059981227, -0.09315060079097748, 0.044009607285261154, 0.02641856111586094, 0.029990822076797485, -0.025266733020544052, -0.04140499606728554, -0.06506923586130142, -0.0150528559461236, 0.03184937313199043, -0.023569969460368156, 0.03430354595184326, -0.03439733386039734, 0.026650719344615936, -0.02237304300069809, -0.039091795682907104, -0.04676441103219986, 0.023919863626360893, 0.012831445783376694, 0.03483515605330467, -0.0298271793872118, -0.019657017663121223, -0.04437016695737839, -0.014982028864324093, 0.05246305465698242, 0.052341070026159286, -0.020697252824902534, 0.02155345492064953, -0.00927203893661499, 0.026236724108457565, 0.004623441491276026, -0.08572417497634888, 0.028597833588719368, -0.006146222352981567, -0.005915267858654261, 0.04303528368473053, -0.00040976121090352535, -0.03947024047374725, -0.0167295653373003, -0.03555576503276825, 0.010877298191189766, -0.010512796230614185, -0.012297652661800385, 0.0582427941262722, 0.02888229489326477, 0.008457837626338005, 0.05296621471643448, 0.007591544184833765, 0.0017823913367465138, 0.006637290585786104, -0.004250967875123024, 0.010609027929604053, -0.021941544488072395, 0.01768188178539276, -0.005343086086213589, -0.00807463750243187, -0.03999461978673935, 0.016195325180888176, 0.024780742824077606, 0.01719845086336136, -0.046457573771476746, 0.01989028975367546, -0.007562162354588509, 0.010472141206264496, -0.018807142972946167, -0.019071705639362335, -0.012725389562547207, 0.029371075332164764, -0.03806627169251442, -0.02851831167936325, 0.018028073012828827, -0.020373940467834473, -0.03415141627192497, 0.001620110822841525, -0.01315311435610056, 0.0040091946721076965, -0.009182527661323547, 0.005916443653404713, 0.005921630188822746, -0.010639277286827564, 0.035155389457941055, 0.021362796425819397, 0.016661113128066063, 0.0024755927734076977, -0.007911923341453075, 0.013367240317165852, 0.02304662950336933, 0.00765677634626627, 0.017337821424007416, -0.03361913934350014, 0.044220082461833954, 0.005695841740816832, -0.03626737743616104, -0.06349296122789383, -0.02362070232629776, 0.012286391109228134, 0.029378758743405342, -0.010099193081259727, -0.025664212182164192, 0.02825034223496914, -0.005962902680039406, -0.013400430791079998, -0.05993671715259552, 0.04022030159831047, -0.02540035918354988, -0.018457312136888504, -0.00457290094345808, 0.0038716730196028948, 0.09230726957321167, -0.021878819912672043, -0.05211411416530609, 0.03192443400621414, -0.020309289917349815, -0.029103746637701988, 0.0009412504150532186, 0.0336117260158062, 0.009329000487923622, 0.018961353227496147, -0.04039907827973366, -0.043337058275938034, 0.020177040249109268, -0.035438112914562225, -0.04235505312681198, 0.021852876991033554, -0.010010755620896816, 0.00452266214415431, -0.018804751336574554, 0.020035257562994957, -0.003573630005121231, 0.032770898193120956, -0.0264044888317585, -0.008463140577077866, 0.0022857561707496643, -0.019442809745669365, 0.021020522341132164, -0.020216327160596848, -0.047442954033613205, 0.018497630953788757, 0.05408622696995735, -0.024351900443434715, 0.005306465085595846, -0.01722808927297592, 0.003808689536526799, 0.05498170107603073, -0.023268064484000206, 0.020020943135023117, -0.003179144114255905, 0.007016713730990887, -0.04879334196448326, -0.05413227155804634, -0.010110649280250072, -0.030199425294995308, 0.06290006637573242, -0.004786103498190641, 0.044294778257608414, 0.027439704164862633, -0.018889518454670906, -0.009394089691340923, -0.01542646437883377, 0.01866336353123188, 0.01009690947830677, -0.02729007415473461, 0.045025259256362915, -0.051203954964876175, -0.0010311549995094538, 0.04309914633631706, -0.012421035207808018, 0.0030562577303498983, 0.02074555866420269, -0.012976208701729774, 0.014848088845610619, 0.0011282318737357855, 0.02234545722603798, -0.0649772584438324, 0.04355907812714577, -0.04611869528889656, 0.019418833777308464, -0.030879134312272072, -0.020208746194839478, 0.04593367874622345, 0.04472880810499191, -0.023186691105365753, -0.03354133293032646, -0.028986966237425804, -0.051137637346982956, -0.009393793530762196, 0.02339034341275692, -0.013622259721159935, 0.02133752591907978, 0.011237310245633125, 0.031225968152284622, 0.0014118249528110027, 0.010719817131757736, -0.030092589557170868, -0.0392160527408123, -0.0002713675203267485, -0.01599215343594551, 0.019979119300842285, 0.053519610315561295, -0.009845184162259102, -0.0018493188545107841, 0.01748288981616497, -0.023631606251001358, -0.01499529555439949, -0.016121508553624153, 0.02581598609685898, -0.038404952734708786, 0.058900345116853714, 0.021576644852757454, 0.04476679489016533, -0.03161175549030304, -0.010629851371049881, 0.10132350772619247, 0.06396433711051941, 0.027867648750543594, -0.06808685511350632, 0.014994839206337929, -0.0187034010887146, 0.03084120713174343, -0.042439647018909454, 0.01214740239083767, 0.002567995572462678, 0.019097357988357544, 0.03817295283079147, 0.04168429598212242, -0.022530365735292435, -0.0029038218781352043, 0.05088123679161072, -0.049553319811820984, 0.0022127835545688868, -0.007285382132977247, 0.027391424402594566, 0.000663659768179059, 0.02045600302517414, -0.026341235265135765, -0.013369100168347359, -0.04765809699892998, -0.0269156526774168, 0.00008209859515773132, -0.011835656128823757, -0.012201282195746899, -0.00022896805603522807, -0.04444395750761032, -0.005576094146817923, 0.07437819242477417, -0.008695883676409721, -0.013048643246293068, -0.01635223813354969, 0.02415277808904648, 0.004132749047130346, 0.025781121104955673, -0.0020458425860852003, 0.011729192920029163, -0.019578194245696068, -0.015994353219866753, 0.034083638340234756, -0.06567422300577164, -0.022012818604707718, -0.025454098358750343, 0.00394116947427392, -0.016475431621074677, 0.0018285172991454601, -0.0164556335657835, 0.00027889510965906084, 0.01124605443328619, -0.019095590338110924, -0.0023680448066443205, 0.0061176191084086895, 0.011531376279890537, -0.055669356137514114, -0.007256082259118557, -0.05537150800228119, 0.0015864179003983736, -0.0313180647790432, 0.07166855037212372, 0.034984707832336426, -0.04693004488945007, 0.018174009397625923, 0.006766507402062416, 0.05313154682517052, 0.0027977442368865013, -0.016259055584669113, -0.016457336023449898, 0.0023967260494828224, -0.02374320663511753, -0.011211305856704712, 0.03770199045538902, 0.004804002121090889, 0.059790417551994324, -0.021677659824490547, -0.0050038849003612995, -0.03427056223154068, -0.03105521760880947, 0.04782038927078247, -0.007053042761981487, -0.023015020415186882, -0.033317986875772476, 0.00869258213788271, 0.06089990958571434, 0.06257539242506027, -0.030437711626291275, 0.02159193344414234, -0.038785770535469055, 0.028669962659478188, 0.06713917851448059, -0.07407388091087341, 0.00022320941206999123, -0.03937990590929985, -0.032487791031599045, -0.035695403814315796, 0.00921821128576994, 0.05389044061303139, 0.05039164051413536, 0.047228727489709854, -0.003921177703887224, 0.002782507101073861, 0.0009119349997490644, 0.0318918451666832, 0.026851492002606392, -0.006711184978485107, -0.02266595885157585, 0.03695644065737724, 0.024271534755825996, -0.005418801214545965, -0.008375546894967556, -0.03900205343961716, 0.005718327593058348, 0.004551551770418882, -0.004761728458106518, -0.04510730132460594, 0.008254820480942726, -0.00915876217186451, 0.01375131867825985, -0.06080400198698044, -0.026961881667375565, -0.06980841606855392, -0.028697198256850243, 0.025661509484052658, -0.025704337283968925, -0.008280673995614052, 0.018991362303495407, -0.04325176775455475, -0.007064525969326496, 0.06372081488370895, 0.023376066237688065, -0.013943624682724476, -0.023810220882296562, 0.01439114660024643, -0.02440161444246769, 0.009819667786359787, -0.010890240781009197, -0.048987723886966705, 0.01725500077009201, 0.002539339940994978, -0.043105218559503555, 0.00419100234284997, -0.02310817688703537, 0.03729502484202385, 0.017184678465127945, -0.015529045835137367, -0.042566921561956406, 0.00584273599088192, -0.01683819852769375, 0.011840558610856533, -0.004390201065689325, 0.022706255316734314, 0.026646697893738747, -0.00820306409150362, 0.030008750036358833, -0.004364818800240755, -0.00039483222644776106, 0.010068774223327637, 0.0518270879983902, 0.03823608532547951, 0.02755190059542656, 0.0009329610620625317, 0.013082287274301052, 0.02856544777750969, 0.02374211512506008, -0.015760350972414017, 0.042226023972034454, 0.02244040183722973, 0.010118480771780014, -0.0020410381257534027, -0.0016000287141650915, 0.003202668623998761, -0.05486886203289032, -0.01850857399404049, -0.020648274570703506, -0.005766251590102911, 0.0330941267311573, -0.0006472151726484299, -0.018430761992931366, -0.004130697343498468, -0.04580022767186165, 0.03204780071973801, -0.030622202903032303, -0.018258200958371162, -0.029681947082281113, -0.016431357711553574, -0.02738046646118164, 0.04544367641210556, 0.03951503708958626, 0.05047670006752014, -0.005465016234666109, 0.015179745852947235, 0.015008308924734592, 0.014640635810792446, -0.0391593836247921, -0.03325032442808151, -0.01597786694765091, -0.05688275024294853, 0.047219932079315186, -0.0767008438706398, 0.005840089172124863, 0.008783794939517975, -0.03634824976325035, 0.017778798937797546, 0.001983275869861245, 0.033740557730197906, 0.00861559808254242, 0.013194533996284008, 0.028370097279548645, -0.015000379644334316, -0.006870636250823736, -0.02021568827331066, 0.022790631279349327, 0.01132157351821661, -0.031048979610204697, 0.019196394830942154, -0.018257765099406242, -0.028265517204999924, -0.001127608004026115, 0.001621175091713667, -0.006079657934606075, -0.024715451523661613, -0.011634483002126217, -0.012736323289573193, 0.0292564257979393, 0.0376545749604702, 0.04902512952685356, -0.014188017696142197, -0.022149566560983658, 0.05479626730084419, 0.05832015350461006, -0.04155052825808525, -0.000854815065395087, 0.014210826717317104, -0.017271248623728752, 0.050168994814157486, 0.0188192930072546, -0.0036941878497600555, -0.03939991816878319, -0.022726822644472122, 0.02351299114525318, 0.0023649008944630623, -0.03689870610833168, -0.018634624779224396, -0.017091354355216026, 0.03892216458916664, -0.0020160102285444736, 0.01892351545393467, 0.020630011335015297, -0.021161265671253204, -0.02403254061937332, -0.0590362511575222, 0.03970201686024666, 0.002981140511110425, -0.030241480097174644, -0.01567864418029785, -0.02533762902021408, -0.046189725399017334, -0.014489039778709412, 0.050882697105407715, -0.02871277555823326, 0.007271753158420324, 0.024774931371212006, 0.022759942337870598, 0.01440676860511303, -0.05300254002213478, 0.0391734354197979, -0.02183530293405056, -0.040974367409944534, 0.03398545831441879, -0.03269093483686447, 0.010424662381410599, 0.005613391753286123, 0.029834574088454247, -0.016027482226490974, 0.0022305019665509462, 0.031753070652484894, -0.03724662959575653, 0.05149364471435547, 0.028229190036654472, -0.021262936294078827, 0.06897123903036118, 0.029545102268457413, 0.029640382155776024, 0.02895609475672245, -0.024600666016340256, -0.06988867372274399, 0.018082160502672195, -0.019316596910357475, -0.017958989366889, 0.004068577662110329, 0.017063915729522705, -0.03448713943362236, -0.039597123861312866, -0.026742730289697647, 0.04290792718529701, -0.038131311535835266, 0.01324498001486063, 0.07084014266729355, 0.018230533227324486, 0.02191266231238842, 0.026517726480960846, 0.0340370312333107, 0.007041078060865402, 0.014943736605346203, 0.0019523627124726772, 0.011670712381601334, 0.06644754856824875, -0.013825269415974617, -0.005967775359749794, 0.013860996812582016, -0.012005642056465149, 0.0029453043825924397, -0.053608667105436325, 0.06853562593460083, -0.05601223558187485, -0.02107463777065277, -0.00262967636808753, -0.01237852405756712, 0.0423474982380867, 0.04919280856847763, -0.011480600573122501, 0.060748904943466187, -0.012334455735981464, -0.0018457159167155623, 0.01441451907157898, 0.03030598908662796, -0.04130542278289795, 0.005289429798722267, 0.02119152806699276, -0.00036022550193592906, 0.007182389032095671, -0.0016874877037480474, 0.0012385776499286294, -0.01291696447879076, -0.011838242411613464, -0.025858087465167046, -0.01799645647406578, -0.012889533303678036, -0.022355783730745316, -0.043580833822488785, 0.03947598114609718, -0.07061067223548889, -0.03448154032230377, 0.03981278836727142, 0.02480292320251465, 0.006510694976896048, -0.05112705007195473, -0.01202242262661457, 0.008143560960888863, 0.04144575446844101, -0.09124768525362015, 0.01965331844985485, -0.022747278213500977, 0.007386534009128809, 0.032561857253313065, -0.015510721132159233 ]
<p>I am trying to simulate a process of selection without replacement. The process is one in which the system places a set of items in a specific order, and then the user selects N items in whatever order they want. The order of the items will vary depending on an algorithm. </p> <p>The probability that each item will be picked by the user varies based on: the item, the position, and which draw the user is on (1st, 2nd, etc.). </p> <p>The full probability space is: 1 = Pr(Draw any item) + Pr(Draw no items and end selection)</p> <pre><code>+--------+----------+ | Item | Position | +--------+----------+ | Item A | 1 | | Item B | 2 | | Item C | 3 | | Item D | 4 | +--------+----------+ </code></pre> <p>My challenge is trying to figure out how to generate a conditional probability table that can be used in a simulation. I have one that is Pr(Click | Item, Position, Draw Number). But what I need is Pr(Click | Item, Position, Draw Number, {History of draws})</p> <pre><code>+--------+----------+------+-------------+ | Item | Position | Draw | Probability | +--------+----------+------+-------------+ | Item A | 1 | 1 | 0.33 | | Item B | 2 | 1 | 0.25 | | Item C | 3 | 1 | 0.2 | | Item D | 4 | 1 | 0.14 | | Item A | 1 | 2 | 0.1 | | Item B | 2 | 2 | 0.3 | | Item C | 3 | 2 | 0.18 | | Item D | 4 | 2 | 0.05 | +--------+----------+------+-------------+ </code></pre> <p>This table fails to take into account that the process is a draw without replacement. The probabilities for draw 2 do not take into account which item was selected in the first draw.</p> <p>If I simulate a series of draws, and simulate the user on Draw 1 selecting Item B, is there a way to modify the probabilities of Items A, C D for draw 2 to account for the fact that Item B is no longer eligible?</p> <p>I think there is an application of Bayes Theorem here, but I'm struggling with how to adapt bayes formula to account for the number of conditionals.</p>
74,192
[ -0.0018542548641562462, -0.05246000736951828, 0.03198301047086716, -0.00823386013507843, 0.027174832299351692, 0.0005060643889009953, 0.01951228640973568, 0.008550357073545456, 0.003956931177526712, -0.014000718481838703, 0.032596223056316376, -0.006191270425915718, 0.05564543977379799, 0.004549454897642136, 0.0029612109065055847, 0.04283791035413742, -0.002089893911033869, -0.03151344135403633, 0.00015555747086182237, -0.015937229618430138, 0.01260118093341589, -0.028737923130393028, 0.009572815150022507, -0.025727851316332817, 0.00589391216635704, 0.04036200791597366, -0.02181713655591011, -0.0317290723323822, 0.005565343424677849, 0.088625468313694, -0.06332569569349289, -0.038934413343667984, -0.017670758068561554, 0.039439547806978226, 0.038953810930252075, 0.039028599858284, 0.003096163272857666, -0.044893618673086166, -0.026688499376177788, -0.0016546413535252213, 0.011904047802090645, 0.018379762768745422, -0.014713374897837639, 0.05350643768906593, -0.011984914541244507, 0.026434557512402534, -0.035053741186857224, -0.009250055067241192, 0.037599898874759674, -0.0660686045885086, 0.09067477285861969, -0.024656010791659355, 0.06545014679431915, 0.024550385773181915, -0.049476176500320435, 0.007040419615805149, 0.03716158866882324, 0.07125765830278397, 0.0010323760798200965, -0.0346580408513546, 0.013589927926659584, -0.05869569629430771, 0.018101703375577927, -0.015358644537627697, -0.01999201625585556, -0.02016931213438511, -0.011506190523505211, 0.016505103558301926, 0.0065178838558495045, -0.013563742861151695, -0.01499488577246666, 0.020580248907208443, 0.039827704429626465, 0.006675466895103455, 0.03805526718497276, -0.01674964465200901, 0.03138027712702751, 0.0010333550162613392, 0.04528193548321724, 0.04197784513235092, -0.023196494206786156, 0.030901886522769928, 0.0022097842302173376, 0.029501687735319138, 0.029495416209101677, -0.040057189762592316, 0.023218028247356415, -0.024733060970902443, 0.0012010964564979076, 0.0006587310344912112, -0.016057396307587624, -0.01585579849779606, 0.050977084785699844, 0.03890310972929001, -0.016592415049672127, -0.004805923905223608, 0.004488538950681686, 0.022371040657162666, -0.015946010127663612, -0.014611724764108658, 0.004982844460755587, -0.030262216925621033, 0.01515259686857462, 0.01576334424316883, -0.014764479361474514, 0.01409715786576271, 0.010890855453908443, -0.020934641361236572, -0.029945071786642075, 0.0033896281383931637, 0.015397025272250175, 0.044335782527923584, -0.005688771605491638, 0.0027577525470405817, 0.00209610303863883, -0.025021662935614586, -0.03507867455482483, 0.0071480488404631615, 0.0336046926677227, 0.0377550907433033, 0.0023836051113903522, -0.04459024965763092, 0.03106462024152279, -0.0780031606554985, -0.04529887065291405, -0.03294782713055611, -0.008150771260261536, 0.015391719527542591, -0.010736308991909027, 0.050274692475795746, -0.053098395466804504, -0.02385268174111843, 0.06502941250801086, 0.010831305757164955, 0.01974250003695488, 0.03796456381678581, -0.045109204947948456, -0.022780459374189377, 0.04376615211367607, -0.03668074309825897, -0.04247669503092766, -0.045168738812208176, 0.03283097222447395, 0.011139108799397945, 0.023508407175540924, 0.005066359415650368, 0.03319069370627403, -0.014585900120437145, -0.01972173899412155, 0.02951967529952526, -0.016955936327576637, -0.0036056293174624443, -0.020364051684737206, -0.013987942598760128, -0.023823149502277374, -0.0409155935049057, 0.026816783472895622, 0.008686055429279804, 0.007396341301500797, 0.004112170543521643, 0.0008441107929684222, 0.02358102984726429, 0.011724919080734253, 0.012906493619084358, 0.021627765148878098, -0.025646911934018135, 0.08636031299829483, 0.02136746607720852, -0.013394839130342007, -0.033967941999435425, -0.002735922811552882, -0.0009342701523564756, -0.002519929315894842, -0.0002399594523012638, 0.07472694665193558, -0.018660198897123337, 0.008214668370783329, -0.008598302491009235, -0.033875416964292526, -0.006434429902583361, 0.0021969701629132032, -0.004348632413893938, -0.022805478423833847, -0.027796005830168724, 0.04013131931424141, 0.03526414558291435, 0.0003485565248411149, -0.008239084854722023, 0.019541244953870773, -0.02112720161676407, -0.028531238436698914, -0.08198019117116928, -0.009745508432388306, 0.0329095721244812, -0.007989748381078243, 0.010893195867538452, 0.024212686344981194, -0.005407252814620733, 0.028540465980768204, -0.04864979162812233, -0.098635733127594, -0.03812560439109802, -0.01879061758518219, -0.0533977709710598, -0.054913781583309174, 0.07329753786325455, 0.0314968042075634, -0.029514135792851448, 0.026890048757195473, -0.01606844551861286, -0.04743795469403267, -0.02704496681690216, -0.034737881273031235, 0.017234735190868378, 0.0034749920014292, -0.029747584834694862, 0.006127349566668272, 0.0011742395581677556, 0.0006125756190158427, -0.005942449904978275, -0.015056325122714043, 0.012866295874118805, 0.057847119867801666, -0.015115263871848583, 0.012442243285477161, 0.013807843439280987, -0.028144245967268944, 0.009375054389238358, 0.06029238924384117, -0.028536152094602585, -0.015010574832558632, 0.010634305886924267, 0.012234603986144066, -0.007887621410191059, -0.053664956241846085, 0.012653191573917866, 0.06849522888660431, -0.008627990260720253, 0.03575010597705841, 0.06184322014451027, -0.0031644010450690985, 0.030507102608680725, 0.005760636646300554, 0.02763848938047886, 0.06771765649318695, 0.0029989033937454224, 0.019650574773550034, -0.0010013136779889464, -0.01156561728566885, 0.005392525810748339, -0.01719197817146778, -0.01933104917407036, 0.003979521803557873, -0.009693879634141922, -0.030184835195541382, -0.038910165429115295, 0.044745929539203644, 0.023289425298571587, -0.02093645930290222, 0.054323263466358185, 0.013008556328713894, 0.003396102227270603, 0.007305643986910582, -0.0594228059053421, -0.014433547854423523, 0.02719103917479515, -0.05945265665650368, -0.00952882505953312, 0.04055391624569893, 0.013096047565340996, 0.02570209838449955, 0.020371902734041214, -0.01479983888566494, -0.0722082182765007, 0.009732655249536037, 0.00304766115732491, 0.012817799113690853, 0.009222367778420448, 0.002019510604441166, -0.0007685991004109383, -0.0285631250590086, 0.004378074314445257, -0.0008903659181669354, -0.0015107528306543827, -0.12151209264993668, -0.02538662776350975, 0.027021517977118492, -0.031446631997823715, 0.016506889835000038, 0.023004993796348572, -0.04680446907877922, 0.06444209069013596, -0.0268394872546196, -0.03726433217525482, -0.03147590160369873, -0.0359218455851078, -0.0024776177015155554, -0.018704837188124657, 0.02019333839416504, 0.050476059317588806, 0.026433203369379044, -0.051763635128736496, 0.05761471018195152, -0.0372554250061512, -0.02265041507780552, -0.014605605974793434, -0.03258732706308365, 0.0007486007525585592, -0.03668075427412987, 0.010682663880288601, 0.011999139562249184, 0.00762092275545001, 0.045471370220184326, -0.08844994008541107, -0.05413857474923134, -0.0022904775105416775, -0.011638264171779156, 0.0502622053027153, 0.011877540498971939, 0.0015151656698435545, 0.057123444974422455, -0.0029614046216011047, -0.018480908125638962, -0.04003326967358589, 0.016951778903603554, -0.010810778476297855, -0.04260583594441414, 0.0436154268682003, 0.00073696777690202, -0.03828001767396927, 0.010913161560893059, -0.013844056986272335, 0.02332042157649994, 0.05700736492872238, -0.03171170875430107, 0.02255997061729431, 0.03949202969670296, 0.015214682556688786, 0.004811638500541449, -0.004377581644803286, -0.0032701294403523207, -0.048863861709833145, 0.014789426699280739, -0.06819625943899155, -0.0015782566042616963, -0.00638373289257288, 0.0016247032908722758, 0.009944869205355644, 0.001411398989148438, 0.023715810850262642, 0.0053763906471431255, 0.04392295330762863, -0.026464339345693588, -0.03142555430531502, -0.007335209753364325, 0.019177736714482307, 0.05972805991768837, 0.006591069046407938, 0.024496542289853096, 0.05426768586039543, 0.03338192030787468, -0.005105226766318083, 0.010933750309050083, 0.024634838104248047, -0.001859129872173071, -0.03657517209649086, -0.02441876195371151, -0.012839904054999352, 0.010479909367859364, 0.029788700863718987, -0.015871740877628326, 0.02181832119822502, -0.009352091699838638, -0.055091701447963715, -0.0052131847478449345, -0.012673626653850079, -0.010809733532369137, 0.07068183273077011, -0.009803025983273983, 0.02201905846595764, 0.01569480262696743, -0.030659765005111694, -0.010857786983251572, 0.004469824023544788, -0.11212685704231262, 0.021119138225913048, 0.0061273216269910336, 0.0009491145610809326, -0.0019646615255624056, -0.003146677976474166, 0.010557505302131176, -0.04989137500524521, 0.009854225441813469, 0.028720462694764137, 0.004809216596186161, -0.036971066147089005, 0.003581893863156438, 0.00003801561251748353, 0.026117613539099693, -0.014790837652981281, 0.014702624641358852, 0.028205685317516327, 0.01760917715728283, 0.05462433770298958, 0.015609851107001305, -0.0010572089813649654, -0.01448348443955183, -0.004254637751728296, 0.02780190482735634, 0.0358954519033432, 0.03631332144141197, 0.057793837040662766, 0.042341675609350204, -0.06433628499507904, -0.002464954974129796, -0.016146766021847725, 0.059409454464912415, 0.0698896199464798, -0.032183099538087845, 0.020214423537254333, -0.04227403923869133, 0.006295640487223864, -0.0019200437236577272, 0.037430163472890854, 0.0003502820909488946, 0.03792976215481758, 0.008266158401966095, 0.0075719584710896015, -0.06259982287883759, 0.0006048703799024224, 0.06728734076023102, 0.011720628477633, -0.027832118794322014, -0.04413839057087898, 0.04822598025202751, 0.02650061435997486, -0.01612669974565506, -0.0052365814335644245, 0.038909755647182465, 0.005566853564232588, 0.00635748915374279, 0.012754409573972225, 0.0063269250094890594, -0.017771419137716293, 0.037745680660009384, 0.008859636262059212, 0.030658932402729988, 0.04167884960770607, -0.007976951077580452, 0.0207501333206892, -0.004521263763308525, -0.010546162724494934, 0.025402788072824478, 0.01681043580174446, -0.046793513000011444, -0.02113884687423706, 0.03883745148777962, 0.04877704754471779, -0.04151524230837822, 0.020076289772987366, -0.030135665088891983, -0.0054532908834517, 0.030406728386878967, -0.02823621779680252, 0.04496770352125168, -0.038443125784397125, 0.009802920743823051, -0.034285541623830795, -0.0303182490170002, -0.043823763728141785, 0.009046657010912895, -0.0629778504371643, 0.021696066483855247, -0.05489688739180565, -0.01222260296344757, -0.010641937144100666, 0.0036639997269958258, 0.00879630446434021, 0.06811866164207458, -0.050247061997652054, 0.0014517722884193063, 0.019950276240706444, -0.005256510339677334, -0.008256051689386368, -0.037628188729286194, 0.028652720153331757, -0.02077031135559082, 0.028661999851465225, 0.04667694866657257, 0.008069655857980251, -0.01472283061593771, 0.014844212681055069, -0.026586342602968216, 0.02819277159869671, 0.016848981380462646, -0.012638607062399387, 0.036741141229867935, 0.007794699631631374, -0.022961312904953957, 0.041435930877923965, 0.027793610468506813, 0.0021603170316666365, 0.013021524995565414, -0.015900779515504837, -0.0008482906268909574, 0.0018217999022454023, -0.006437651347368956, -0.08228884637355804, -0.0015124257188290358, -0.028318816795945168, 0.0277202557772398, 0.029842572286725044, -0.01723431795835495, 0.03304461017251015, 0.026233073323965073, -0.020054245367646217, 0.03446974232792854, 0.00593834463506937, -0.005884925834834576, -0.020675528794527054, 0.00033130787778645754, -0.026021244004368782, -0.00874484982341528, 0.018423205241560936, -0.043175436556339264, -0.025235606357455254, -0.013087672181427479, -0.016608405858278275, 0.02151215262711048, -0.032330844551324844, -0.015847433358430862, -0.01639152131974697, -0.04421398043632507, 0.008286196738481522, 0.013801288791000843, 0.059378672391176224, 0.02789883315563202, -0.04700406640768051, -0.04570966213941574, 0.002415810478851199, -0.017204483970999718, -0.02736072614789009, -0.03523659333586693, 0.03309645503759384, -0.004829934798181057, 0.0031626338604837656, -0.10371488332748413, -0.029115596786141396, 0.013856506906449795, -0.004465768113732338, -0.04045887291431427, -0.015547393821179867, -0.04718538001179695, -0.00328463246114552, -0.03846180811524391, -0.011634055525064468, -0.008522497490048409, 0.003529844107106328, 0.0049550835974514484, 0.03058861754834652, -0.021016821265220642, 0.07488130778074265, 0.05186699330806732, -0.009916221722960472, -0.004990573972463608, -0.031829506158828735, -0.04047910124063492, -0.0020956264343112707, -0.015490391291677952, -0.03680012747645378, 0.02006467990577221, -0.010520677082240582, 0.03274458646774292, 0.030453944578766823, 0.004407862201333046, 0.0043940735049545765, -0.025974171236157417, -0.03596216067671776, -0.010231439024209976, -0.014762288890779018, -0.018777435645461082, 0.010139888152480125, 0.01697572134435177, -0.009894032031297684, 0.044106148183345795, 0.012367094866931438, 0.012140628881752491, 0.015152753330767155, -0.0012630223063752055, -0.043537598103284836, 0.010197657160460949, 0.06247049570083618, 0.003484500804916024, -0.013285634107887745, 0.012111152522265911, -0.0389619916677475, 0.0770299881696701, -0.02038305625319481, -0.0034229743760079145, -0.006826113909482956, -0.013232186436653137, -0.05554598569869995, 0.016144951805472374, -0.02934342995285988, 0.005567700136452913, -0.013081502169370651, -0.011127409525215626, 0.028910916298627853, 0.051625389605760574, 0.014332546852529049, 0.008236016146838665, 0.024006545543670654, 0.005361646879464388, 0.004468945786356926, -0.005986311472952366, 0.04887951537966728, -0.02855576016008854, 0.017309002578258514, 0.033175915479660034, -0.005044488236308098, 0.018417900428175926, 0.02785658650100231, -0.022681698203086853, -0.0256461501121521, 0.06967795640230179, 0.0005299564218148589, 0.015283262357115746, -0.006672654766589403, -0.05936267599463463, 0.015440994873642921, -0.03477931022644043, -0.047196920961141586, 0.018720295280218124, 0.020174002274870872, -0.04131627082824707, -0.013158927671611309, -0.04683047533035278, -0.07790680229663849, 0.0023773612920194864, -0.001997688552364707, -0.004927580710500479, 0.02003473788499832, -0.014297515153884888, 0.008738420903682709, 0.004247399978339672, 0.04050830006599426, -0.04254646599292755, -0.02889033779501915, -0.004854370839893818, -0.0522792786359787, -0.017951007932424545, 0.02911199815571308, 0.02745969220995903, -0.03189913183450699, -0.01309522520750761, 0.00995294563472271, 0.027215108275413513, 0.04338238388299942, 0.03451291844248772, 0.006381114013493061, 0.07849178463220596, -0.008351433090865612, 0.0638444796204567, -0.06037741154432297, 0.011341165751218796, 0.16524618864059448, 0.0636383518576622, 0.04286877065896988, -0.04120124503970146, -0.03845785930752754, 0.024976549670100212, -0.02237570844590664, 0.001279731746762991, 0.04149600863456726, 0.0399215891957283, -0.03442808985710144, 0.03655138611793518, 0.01074996031820774, -0.005428931210190058, 0.02820650488138199, 0.030258547514677048, -0.05739736929535866, -0.03003847785294056, 0.03668181970715523, 0.011974186636507511, -0.010351579636335373, 0.012471074238419533, -0.033726975321769714, -0.05157255008816719, 0.04688737541437149, -0.0008359044441021979, -0.03735998272895813, -0.022733960300683975, -0.02754581905901432, 0.005095725413411856, -0.0009130880935117602, -0.008028801530599594, 0.011825405061244965, 0.014491735957562923, -0.014430886134505272, -0.011458883062005043, 0.011142767034471035, -0.011683035641908646, 0.0011594558600336313, 0.05207381397485733, 0.021547934040427208, -0.018882382661104202, -0.02676290273666382, 0.029697343707084656, -0.04768083989620209, 0.008573832921683788, -0.07719619572162628, 0.00606075394898653, -0.05834959074854851, 0.00801036972552538, -0.010600369423627853, -0.02092052437365055, -0.03581622987985611, -0.04770808666944504, -0.027775557711720467, 0.011573705822229385, 0.033755503594875336, -0.035148486495018005, -0.040842775255441666, -0.01367898378521204, 0.01062373910099268, -0.013927042484283447, 0.03528603911399841, 0.02038692682981491, -0.02896556630730629, -0.028792425990104675, -0.05248913913965225, 0.036340706050395966, 0.0024084490723907948, 0.0007600565440952778, 0.003921588882803917, -0.0016502408543601632, -0.014003431424498558, -0.029468020424246788, -0.007232411298900843, -0.0027441370766609907, -0.007972453720867634, -0.02842041850090027, -0.019079331308603287, 0.023724015802145004, 0.0068227206356823444, 0.0033994491677731276, -0.05466354638338089, 0.008466478437185287, -0.07563076168298721, 0.023034902289509773, 0.02311396785080433, 0.0287417434155941, 0.01136705745011568, -0.03739841654896736, -0.022403543815016747, 0.008546576835215092, 0.019106924533843994, -0.057304747402668, -0.023914551362395287, 0.023941369727253914, -0.028355836868286133, 0.022380055859684944, -0.03859705105423927, 0.061431750655174255, 0.0020519171375781298, 0.004055532161146402, -0.007946285419166088, 0.00835263729095459, 0.02381640113890171, 0.020411459729075432, -0.0010776290437206626, -0.06682881712913513, -0.022364381700754166, 0.009124994277954102, -0.018584702163934708, 0.003995469305664301, -0.006687636952847242, -0.010392121970653534, -0.0422324575483799, -0.013413962908089161, -0.015350386500358582, -0.01834740675985813, -0.004918775986880064, -0.0232569370418787, -0.025229772552847862, 0.038860734552145004, 0.04107437655329704, -0.013579433783888817, 0.007714168168604374, -0.0010259405244141817, 0.02083207294344902, -0.013404321856796741, 0.006144057027995586, 0.009050107561051846, 0.032135602086782455, -0.03300361707806587, 0.03099696896970272, -0.01099422574043274, 0.01794630102813244, 0.01775590144097805, 0.027154451236128807, 0.029391616582870483, -0.00879277940839529, -0.02468768134713173, 0.01851101592183113, -0.044483985751867294, -0.03150179982185364, 0.024508779868483543, 0.014921078458428383, 0.06142307445406914, 0.02861265279352665, 0.04132602736353874, 0.04077042266726494, 0.041912030428647995, -0.028986856341362, -0.015618795529007912, -0.005194328725337982, -0.0013447745004668832, 0.01898006722331047, 0.019856320694088936, -0.012633385136723518, 0.014027152210474014, -0.008807312697172165, 0.022244272753596306, 0.010865220800042152, -0.00472783949226141, -0.027480503544211388, 0.04929036274552345, -0.011600926518440247, 0.009987383149564266, 0.012838062830269337, -0.024909608066082, 0.0034773782826960087, 0.05193518102169037, 0.008896898478269577, 0.014066427014768124, 0.01780402846634388, -0.017043784260749817, -0.07588323205709457, -0.01578136533498764, 0.0030647425446659327, -0.023134853690862656, 0.048234157264232635, -0.04026525840163231, 0.011164631694555283, 0.046556778252124786, -0.016582291573286057, -0.006968438159674406, 0.036609258502721786, 0.027160873636603355, -0.07363329082727432, -0.003044036217033863, -0.03199191391468048, 0.025477152317762375, 0.016910919919610023, 0.023020170629024506, 0.04689565673470497, 0.02689993940293789, -0.03193945810198784, -0.01966455951333046, -0.01284346729516983, 0.032552506774663925, -0.046192068606615067, -0.03809761628508568, 0.016709527000784874, -0.002988827181980014, -0.013250182382762432, 0.0524592250585556, 0.012904862873256207, -0.01951519027352333, 0.01636412739753723, 0.040691785514354706, 0.0005821511149406433, 0.060482386499643326, 0.05690249055624008, -0.012843066826462746, -0.00029217719566076994, -0.0008558440604247153, 0.03469759598374367, 0.008867846801877022, -0.02171199396252632, 0.025394633412361145, 0.028709599748253822, -0.0259285569190979, -0.00848650373518467, 0.012211139313876629, -0.009512371383607388, -0.0021233404986560345, 0.022114869207143784, -0.019691022112965584, -0.006121139507740736, -0.0024702483788132668, -0.01259466353803873, -0.015455799177289009, 0.028667688369750977, -0.004300651140511036, -0.024746887385845184, -0.008151104673743248, -0.030998293310403824, -0.0021763008553534746, -0.03146125003695488, 0.013977603055536747, 0.019214864820241928, -0.04752302169799805, -0.04405587166547775, 0.012763671576976776, -0.016102224588394165, -0.007092499639838934, 0.0018382987473160028, -0.0029739204328507185, -0.028073959052562714, -0.01393680926412344, -0.005679923575371504, 0.02034272626042366, 0.02491469494998455, 0.044018976390361786, 0.031060840934515, -0.08299559354782104, 0.05981846898794174, 0.029406428337097168, -0.03185684606432915, -0.04444663226604462, 0.034189920872449875, -0.04465288668870926, 0.05975380167365074, 0.004128661472350359, -0.038729067891836166, -0.019740987569093704, -0.040912188589572906, 0.010448495857417583, 0.031623050570487976, -0.04936129227280617, 0.011267748661339283, -0.017704308032989502, -0.006972757633775473, 0.015021410770714283, 0.012797693721950054, 0.06546363979578018, 0.019815772771835327, 0.02195468358695507, -0.00644161319360137, -0.03822305426001549, -0.01840045303106308, -0.03395042568445206, 0.010104266926646233, 0.014545842073857784, 0.008573534898459911, 0.033580001443624496, -0.005567644722759724, 0.018916113302111626, -0.0008419699734076858, 0.018741855397820473, -0.0428834892809391, -0.0015757654327899218, -0.05040382593870163, -0.006692041642963886, 0.014252997003495693, -0.01030617393553257, 0.014717028476297855, -0.04713558405637741, 0.010880149900913239, -0.002485031960532069, -0.053608138114213943, -0.0075699384324252605, 0.005603926721960306, 0.024163540452718735, 0.03230364993214607, 0.004881675820797682, 0.023208629339933395, -0.03840809315443039, 0.0006292275502346456, 0.0042191362008452415, -0.005607266444712877, 0.013593284413218498, -0.022685833275318146, 0.033577993512153625, 0.04476933553814888, 0.02260519564151764, 0.023263011127710342, -0.010310359299182892, 0.05514459311962128, 0.03649652749300003, 0.0369146429002285, 0.05292084440588951, -0.011904704384505749, -0.003236347110942006, 0.03450218588113785, -0.007605775259435177, 0.06352894753217697, 0.028680818155407906, 0.028246212750673294, -0.01396210864186287, 0.00967457890510559, -0.016850782558321953, -0.02039184607565403, 0.022622140124440193, -0.0017980823758989573, -0.021140597760677338, 0.04553528502583504, 0.015560642816126347, 0.023869119584560394, 0.02516118437051773, 0.0018320895032957196, 0.04917905479669571, 0.03856905549764633, -0.020339235663414, 0.0068563437089324, 0.009383275173604488, 0.010378796607255936, -0.05058283358812332, 0.009089214727282524, -0.0036543968599289656, 0.03131238743662834, -0.0058981021866202354, 0.008206449449062347, -0.012043645605444908, 0.06785408407449722, -0.007053427863866091, -0.03683404624462128, -0.03976881131529808, 0.07476073503494263, 0.004885097499936819, 0.019247708842158318 ]
<p>I understand how best split is chosen for random forest for numerical predictors (features). </p> <p>Numerical predictors are sorted then for every value Gini impurity or entropy is calculated and a threshold is chosen which gives the best split. But how best split is chosen for categorical predictor as there is no specific ordering?</p>
49,622
[ -0.028604505583643913, 0.006798360496759415, -0.004411804024130106, -0.011892237700521946, 0.010156836360692978, -0.002281227381899953, 0.02894577756524086, -0.021653199568390846, 0.013317200355231762, -0.02175154536962509, 0.01710139587521553, 0.0045638433657586575, 0.009202706627547741, 0.03802790865302086, -0.003842536825686693, -0.0058150882832705975, -0.0030416660010814667, 0.0115294698625803, 0.022354518994688988, -0.013864335604012012, -0.04915725067257881, 0.024971019476652145, 0.03279292583465576, -0.0016237093368545175, -0.043130647391080856, 0.04378151521086693, 0.04760415852069855, 0.047938067466020584, -0.0018688510172069073, 0.009191200137138367, -0.020620843395590782, -0.04726219177246094, -0.007598612457513809, 0.05256516486406326, 0.005775350145995617, -0.005020681768655777, -0.043239060789346695, -0.03425726294517517, -0.04459739476442337, -0.002187545644119382, -0.020211637020111084, -0.020554127171635628, 0.0008904789574444294, 0.02097019925713539, -0.022846439853310585, 0.04861442744731903, -0.024529721587896347, -0.03478332236409187, 0.023957939818501472, -0.05637788027524948, 0.04772140458226204, -0.026984622702002525, 0.030826004222035408, 0.04181385412812233, -0.0013139999937266111, -0.016803991049528122, 0.03393211588263512, 0.05859896540641785, -0.04188813269138336, -0.006729327142238617, -0.0026266290806233883, -0.04146696254611015, 0.03176778554916382, 0.005467192269861698, -0.008400320075452328, 0.023698247969150543, 0.013331555761396885, -0.021320398896932602, 0.03261857479810715, 0.0060842037200927734, -0.0009676704648882151, -0.02722998708486557, 0.04469885677099228, -0.010867354460060596, 0.056612540036439896, 0.009656079113483429, -0.015533952042460442, 0.03349374234676361, 0.053888171911239624, 0.0004749522777274251, 0.024967564269900322, 0.009889551438391209, 0.0016906179953366518, 0.06094389781355858, -0.04093070700764656, -0.005671442952007055, 0.04221897944808006, -0.005461269989609718, 0.00368952052667737, 0.01892085000872612, -0.008447309955954552, -0.045059092342853546, 0.07055015116930008, -0.03231935575604439, -0.029545452445745468, 0.033791717141866684, -0.01457529328763485, -0.019922012463212013, 0.006112053524702787, -0.0007695627864450216, 0.03077356517314911, -0.029609479010105133, 0.016462303698062897, 0.07256665825843811, -0.050668828189373016, 0.00306901172734797, -0.07853236049413681, 0.02272936701774597, 0.008306862786412239, 0.0051112184301018715, -0.023128876462578773, 0.017732834443449974, -0.009469188749790192, -0.019452881067991257, 0.0046189287677407265, -0.024704083800315857, -0.01586013287305832, -0.031460508704185486, 0.022834572941064835, 0.05574421584606171, 0.005663514602929354, -0.02671537734568119, 0.016631489619612694, -0.0084374425932765, -0.029958117753267288, 0.009424972347915173, 0.018784049898386, -0.012921969406306744, -0.022550977766513824, 0.011318589560687542, -0.05578189343214035, -0.028476452454924583, 0.03825605288147926, 0.011764707043766975, 0.014903760515153408, 0.02963721565902233, -0.12733732163906097, -0.05268808454275131, 0.013375974260270596, -0.04038965702056885, 0.037376392632722855, -0.06296983361244202, 0.0194760300219059, 0.03855878487229347, 0.06298403441905975, 0.012575718574225903, 0.044518206268548965, 0.046682581305503845, 0.011251664720475674, 0.004659998696297407, -0.02330918051302433, -0.007482166402041912, -0.012187064625322819, 0.017565185204148293, -0.05147881060838699, -0.06925740838050842, 0.009784442372620106, 0.02321789227426052, -0.024882590398192406, -0.049585334956645966, -0.009937824681401253, -0.00415570056065917, 0.01122292410582304, 0.016753556206822395, -0.0015263757668435574, 0.0014815048780292273, 0.054840315133333206, 0.005207940936088562, 0.08465825021266937, 0.03413280099630356, 0.008244075812399387, -0.00844960194081068, 0.028859462589025497, 0.04932013526558876, 0.02233552560210228, 0.020566655322909355, -0.023349527269601822, -0.01741788163781166, 0.034200627356767654, -0.022242490202188492, -0.02558751031756401, -0.04724718630313873, -0.0073114014230668545, 0.012149233371019363, 0.025803735479712486, 0.008627641946077347, -0.02779453620314598, -0.008700818754732609, 0.04888179525732994, -0.0708344355225563, -0.024941155686974525, -0.01731433905661106, 0.012556331232190132, 0.011443723924458027, -0.004834855906665325, 0.03597160056233406, 0.008742897771298885, 0.01664024032652378, -0.01218047458678484, 0.01853860542178154, -0.05215015262365341, -0.031920839101076126, 0.018022609874606133, -0.036360133439302444, 0.02722923830151558, 0.07069749385118484, -0.010145840235054493, -0.023610595613718033, 0.04490247741341591, -0.023990225046873093, -0.07322990894317627, 0.052912306040525436, -0.02609146200120449, 0.02047165296971798, -0.045369721949100494, -0.03302063047885895, 0.0366675965487957, 0.03620680794119835, -0.026000147685408592, 0.011256741359829903, -0.055657513439655304, 0.06823262572288513, 0.06367293000221252, 0.0258407611399889, -0.013381170108914375, 0.005128995981067419, -0.030871396884322166, 0.003367344383150339, -0.004605797119438648, -0.020557207986712456, -0.061097994446754456, -0.06527704000473022, 0.0522657111287117, 0.03263698145747185, -0.026235055178403854, 0.004179288633167744, 0.05324942618608475, 0.024443425238132477, 0.0429464615881443, 0.0403570719063282, -0.0017740980256348848, 0.0005067904130555689, 0.030562594532966614, 0.0043240622617304325, 0.0034606140106916428, -0.0123285548761487, 0.027152657508850098, -0.0138235567137599, 0.04009794443845749, -0.00022752705262973905, -0.027871055528521538, 0.07378163933753967, 0.003391355276107788, 0.020600637421011925, 0.0008125646272674203, -0.046711280941963196, -0.0020806232932955027, -0.04821614921092987, 0.013054892420768738, 0.050336841493844986, 0.022845471277832985, -0.020497260615229607, -0.012566220946609974, 0.0159751046448946, 0.024073520675301552, 0.056101132184267044, -0.07153203338384628, 0.008748657070100307, 0.022787876427173615, -0.04383860155940056, 0.01398816704750061, -0.020992020145058632, -0.03313658758997917, -0.04987730458378792, 0.005676546134054661, 0.0665697231888771, -0.023041922599077225, 0.002590293763205409, 0.010201269760727882, 0.02015438675880432, -0.02771504782140255, -0.04373518005013466, 0.034467749297618866, 0.007529363036155701, -0.029327498748898506, -0.021052196621894836, -0.001920580747537315, -0.01412378903478384, 0.024226145818829536, -0.01864604651927948, -0.035785675048828125, 0.007099566049873829, -0.025287168100476265, -0.047554221004247665, -0.006316598504781723, -0.00006471568485721946, 0.021869858726859093, -0.0028392255771905184, -0.04395525902509689, 0.01616075076162815, -0.0039511993527412415, -0.02008635737001896, -0.014229407534003258, -0.01303086057305336, -0.004329059738665819, 0.003903007134795189, -0.03158338740468025, 0.028538987040519714, 0.009299375116825104, 0.0384097620844841, 0.01077735610306263, -0.022501736879348755, 0.010180947370827198, -0.05915107950568199, -0.03710294887423515, 0.01346723735332489, -0.027445849031209946, 0.022156482562422752, 0.0028835071716457605, -0.00316137564368546, 0.08607125282287598, 0.024231115356087685, -0.031218519434332848, -0.04731152579188347, -0.0047537838108837605, 0.011184879578649998, -0.008545422926545143, 0.022313807159662247, 0.0365959107875824, 0.02987646497786045, 0.03672470897436142, 0.005213132128119469, 0.05638911575078964, 0.038016822189092636, -0.03694296255707741, -0.033648744225502014, 0.04311167448759079, 0.031767837703228, -0.024851806461811066, 0.010274847038090229, 0.006686822976917028, -0.0411980077624321, 0.044013261795043945, -0.005533975083380938, -0.004507723264396191, 0.03209284320473671, -0.047743313014507294, 0.019568845629692078, -0.03289845585823059, 0.039097800850868225, -0.04886187985539436, 0.031838785856962204, 0.004421466961503029, -0.05338075011968613, -0.010018967092037201, 0.01001909002661705, 0.04733321815729141, -0.013019764795899391, -0.010163772851228714, 0.03813064470887184, 0.050151340663433075, 0.010660957545042038, 0.02546355500817299, 0.002172384411096573, -0.040678054094314575, 0.07328221946954727, -0.020296765491366386, 0.024343783035874367, 0.010876113548874855, 0.022389130666851997, 0.016379497945308685, -0.010201351717114449, -0.03874790295958519, 0.018130673095583916, -0.04081302881240845, 0.007933534681797028, -0.013263052329421043, 0.04258735105395317, 0.004624581895768642, 0.06544329226016998, 0.03168938681483269, 0.012138264253735542, 0.000863943831063807, 0.033029019832611084, -0.03172701597213745, -0.015690404921770096, 0.008836572989821434, -0.00016742493608035147, -0.02329758182168007, -0.02509974129498005, -0.0016950611025094986, -0.014990940690040588, -0.0064279139041900635, -0.01249766070395708, 0.021246282383799553, -0.05953206494450569, -0.002725821454077959, -0.0343802236020565, 0.002160722855478525, 0.002978375181555748, 0.022235864773392677, -0.005544943269342184, -0.010698291473090649, 0.029483094811439514, 0.050143659114837646, -0.0014099482214078307, 0.036511410027742386, 0.010505982674658298, 0.00799928605556488, 0.0049031865783035755, 0.0615396685898304, 0.022979052737355232, -0.01269375067204237, -0.04423321783542633, 0.006417568773031235, -0.016394373029470444, 0.03092225268483162, -0.009474496357142925, -0.02400701493024826, 0.008046474307775497, -0.013958880677819252, 0.01180614810436964, -0.038666196167469025, 0.004198180045932531, -0.004745921120047569, -0.0077504729852080345, 0.06245873123407364, 0.019962968304753304, -0.0651165246963501, -0.0021776158828288317, 0.07471541315317154, 0.0009085533674806356, -0.03905486315488815, -0.04182320088148117, -0.028726177290081978, 0.0072660320438444614, -0.020453397184610367, 0.03723989054560661, 0.010842774994671345, -0.02053556963801384, 0.011948809958994389, 0.036811549216508865, -0.03165918216109276, -0.05723249167203903, -0.02019616588950157, 0.04233015328645706, 0.038445621728897095, 0.009191544726490974, -0.026561912149190903, -0.01749406009912491, 0.006997258868068457, 0.022283270955085754, 0.036420129239559174, -0.0065849293023347855, -0.10538605600595474, -0.010741478763520718, 0.02066078595817089, 0.03402688354253769, -0.054735247045755386, -0.017792681232094765, -0.05581124499440193, -0.006003885064274073, 0.018709834665060043, -0.0116931376978755, 0.01717604510486126, -0.018346479162573814, 0.023031020537018776, -0.011620325036346912, -0.02916964888572693, -0.005829301197081804, 0.047732412815093994, 0.024075733497738838, 0.07374035567045212, 0.008654830045998096, -0.019665980711579323, -0.05398821085691452, -0.0073659708723425865, -0.01061314158141613, 0.04413735494017601, -0.014440834522247314, 0.03499804437160492, -0.01447306852787733, 0.031058941036462784, -0.0028114861343055964, -0.046582385897636414, 0.014265665784478188, 0.030834002420306206, 0.013339775614440441, 0.03866579383611679, -0.025479810312390327, -0.031185872852802277, -0.015408722683787346, 0.055138178169727325, -0.017912913113832474, 0.008376572281122208, -0.0036048777401447296, 0.05410618707537651, 0.0032029214780777693, -0.017540620639920235, 0.04343651607632637, 0.06423499435186386, -0.004804587922990322, -0.0041846842505037785, -0.027544725686311722, 0.01655474118888378, -0.01703621819615364, -0.04762895405292511, -0.030896678566932678, 0.00862933974713087, -0.0027310180012136698, 0.0023101666010916233, -0.008552364073693752, 0.04240191727876663, -0.013992980122566223, -0.03587517887353897, -0.013658900745213032, 0.026694556698203087, 0.004268778953701258, 0.007100529968738556, -0.03183132782578468, 0.02575807087123394, 0.02501862496137619, 0.02381373941898346, 0.033774785697460175, 0.007057239301502705, 0.051116541028022766, 0.03234277665615082, -0.003103859256953001, 0.0020879979711025953, -0.03840459883213043, -0.022579707205295563, 0.01498864870518446, -0.010541331954300404, 0.052687253803014755, -0.008187501691281796, -0.007922817021608353, -0.005333255976438522, -0.0564909353852272, -0.035735923796892166, 0.00812242180109024, -0.04005579650402069, 0.05702511593699455, -0.03905479237437248, 0.052473098039627075, 0.0026772026903927326, 0.01922084018588066, -0.0691557452082634, -0.020381353795528412, 0.011331189423799515, 0.004543365444988012, -0.054337795823812485, -0.03155192732810974, 0.03125748038291931, -0.024426888674497604, 0.009099356830120087, -0.008250728249549866, 0.047025203704833984, -0.010263373143970966, -0.022314641624689102, 0.007895567454397678, 0.010528983548283577, 0.03309179097414017, 0.018119066953659058, 0.013299105688929558, 0.0032177818939089775, 0.019477656111121178, 0.011929611675441265, 0.004596550948917866, -0.004367596935480833, -0.018063249066472054, 0.01667877659201622, -0.007230447139590979, 0.006407038774341345, 0.05032076686620712, 0.02176406793296337, 0.029901089146733284, -0.003804571460932493, -0.005382816307246685, 0.014999168924987316, -0.02441549301147461, -0.0006880327709950507, -0.027384327724575996, -0.0028379359282553196, -0.00131815648637712, 0.011612288653850555, -0.02245066501200199, -0.018862290307879448, -0.001983682857826352, 0.0003851580258924514, -0.011077206581830978, -0.02098562754690647, 0.05266166850924492, 0.00034836592385545373, 0.004170964006334543, -0.006500561721622944, -0.05239734798669815, 0.01210708450525999, 0.033651743084192276, 0.040189243853092194, 0.022575121372938156, 0.036683645099401474, 0.0074132345616817474, 0.008637653663754463, -0.05510108917951584, 0.0020453431643545628, 0.05157723277807236, -0.00414844136685133, 0.031643178313970566, 0.009912021458148956, 0.003029804676771164, 0.000050541417294880375, -0.07342647761106491, 0.010584425181150436, 0.010854415595531464, -0.005284145474433899, 0.07671554386615753, 0.04148879647254944, 0.01840539649128914, 0.01054938230663538, 0.027611570432782173, -0.007327837869524956, 0.036792825907468796, 0.02625567466020584, -0.0009152994025498629, 0.031472597271203995, -0.042370591312646866, -0.04178231954574585, 0.02099069394171238, -0.04449557512998581, 0.007938001304864883, -0.015589918941259384, -0.014418950304389, 0.048867471516132355, -0.0029236709233373404, 0.0005424294504337013, -0.07994595915079117, 0.008512944914400578, -0.044140711426734924, 0.01833483576774597, -0.006239322479814291, -0.02380126714706421, 0.03485774248838425, -0.00938096921890974, -0.02388654462993145, -0.0028009451925754547, -0.004589184653013945, 0.011322501115500927, -0.06966767460107803, -0.08459501713514328, -0.016329655423760414, -0.057753730565309525, -0.007761415559798479, 0.014269795268774033, -0.03219082951545715, 0.028546636924147606, -0.055585842579603195, 0.03202163428068161, -0.007756438106298447, 0.02560693770647049, 0.024818845093250275, 0.05939678102731705, 0.01829749532043934, 0.059209924191236496, 0.015503120608627796, 0.010939202271401882, 0.128312349319458, 0.07930386811494827, 0.06358242779970169, -0.09596677869558334, 0.024213209748268127, 0.05702371522784233, 0.015571306459605694, 0.010356897488236427, -0.006151440553367138, 0.008727970533072948, 0.015198423527181149, 0.0733037143945694, 0.0017646771157160401, 0.035458073019981384, -0.014024997130036354, 0.030752692371606827, -0.05848780646920204, 0.007489230949431658, 0.03516819328069687, 0.03180406987667084, 0.0028774752281606197, -0.00013324098836164922, -0.06282833963632584, 0.01242842897772789, 0.01961522549390793, 0.01337351556867361, -0.021544309332966805, -0.023231079801917076, 0.0068423207849264145, -0.004775737412273884, -0.007093116641044617, 0.0021573652047663927, 0.0042846365831792355, -0.009359132498502731, 0.009351681917905807, -0.014533686451613903, 0.016647573560476303, -0.008243088610470295, -0.002411322668194771, 0.027741799131035805, 0.017868850380182266, -0.003391688922420144, -0.010501094162464142, -0.007280657533556223, -0.05962100625038147, -0.021869182586669922, -0.03227468207478523, -0.02276339940726757, -0.03319515287876129, -0.04488491266965866, -0.00657586008310318, 0.010260709561407566, 0.006520529743283987, -0.02799425646662712, -0.01830807887017727, 0.03402569144964218, 0.04132730886340141, -0.00506854010745883, -0.053966812789440155, -0.004806987941265106, 0.009161547757685184, -0.043440334498882294, 0.010920041240751743, -0.02663809433579445, -0.04398166760802269, -0.0006276659551076591, -0.013073518872261047, 0.0024230799172073603, 0.013937178067862988, 0.02588844858109951, 0.005235365126281977, -0.009569653309881687, -0.03631092980504036, -0.037610460072755814, -0.013546204194426537, -0.00835328083485365, 0.0004992331378161907, -0.014877951703965664, -0.013201100751757622, -0.021702993661165237, -0.020206958055496216, -0.004651020746678114, -0.012289351783692837, 0.010050677694380283, -0.03078342229127884, 0.01057765819132328, -0.009807356633245945, 0.043010350316762924, 0.04298347234725952, 0.03540576621890068, 0.0061508845537900925, 0.015668313950300217, -0.004362102132290602, -0.04645322263240814, -0.01974548026919365, -0.0004246888856869191, -0.03973056375980377, 0.04303831234574318, -0.018401870504021645, 0.07805557548999786, 0.04067908599972725, 0.010877967812120914, 0.00991028267890215, 0.028221633285284042, -0.014061301946640015, 0.018981128931045532, 0.0016643648268654943, -0.04666944220662117, 0.0040320041589438915, 0.012420199811458588, -0.03046499378979206, -0.029004955664277077, -0.03225014731287956, -0.01847159117460251, -0.030850624665617943, 0.014866077341139317, -0.03142968565225601, -0.023896846920251846, -0.02301318570971489, 0.006639526225626469, 0.01658514142036438, -0.018182331696152687, -0.05616627633571625, -0.05097109451889992, 0.02788093127310276, 0.001108014490455389, -0.03074435144662857, -0.03507593646645546, 0.010944624431431293, 0.02531534992158413, -0.01358201913535595, 0.008025883696973324, 0.01336769200861454, 0.015186943113803864, -0.006083390209823847, 0.021563498303294182, -0.026044704020023346, 0.04051712155342102, -0.01642097346484661, -0.03292829543352127, -0.021795744076371193, -0.043501704931259155, -0.037691034376621246, 0.010735636577010155, -0.0025967122055590153, 0.004728410858660936, 0.022658171132206917, 0.02512936107814312, -0.007589310873299837, 0.08859405666589737, -0.02644861489534378, -0.027277324348688126, -0.002755270106717944, 0.01090877316892147, 0.011363642290234566, -0.015038792043924332, -0.01160633284598589, -0.012377157807350159, -0.02229972556233406, 0.015486426651477814, 0.033128585666418076, 0.028807075694203377, 0.004913749173283577, 0.02867749147117138, -0.018306255340576172, 0.04032410681247711, 0.03586231544613838, -0.004920066334307194, 0.013314313255250454, 0.03643069416284561, -0.009575171396136284, 0.03823569789528847, -0.007541273254901171, 0.03569406270980835, -0.04664257541298866, -0.035627011209726334, 0.031739987432956696, 0.0014063083799555898, 0.03291549161076546, -0.05207935348153114, 0.018901431933045387, 0.04152501001954079, -0.05413449928164482, 0.042048875242471695, 0.025426818057894707, -0.019292296841740608, -0.035152509808540344, 0.01502818800508976, -0.014452178962528706, 0.01606055162847042, 0.07179119437932968, -0.011937095783650875, 0.028420744463801384, 0.01443398091942072, -0.027154259383678436, -0.025931991636753082, -0.04180527478456497, 0.020739231258630753, -0.011560860089957714, -0.06732506304979324, 0.058063868433237076, -0.02692905254662037, -0.02407374233007431, 0.024632753804326057, -0.022282524034380913, -0.02227182872593403, 0.08265471458435059, 0.03526542708277702, 0.004785274621099234, 0.03191323205828667, -0.0017213256796821952, -0.022128470242023468, -0.0036831635516136885, 0.010948816314339638, 0.00688357837498188, -0.010669275186955929, 0.009838101454079151, 0.011003118939697742, 0.009315134957432747, -0.002139742486178875, -0.008443154394626617, 0.007548479828983545, -0.029687020927667618, -0.012957717292010784, 0.0080454982817173, 0.016706710681319237, 0.004101195372641087, -0.030421435832977295, -0.007540514227002859, -0.026518622413277626, 0.018206816166639328, 0.04146523028612137, -0.0008415355696342885, 0.006817803252488375, -0.014889555983245373, -0.04375246912240982, -0.06438121199607849, -0.003976742271333933, 0.02145470678806305, 0.018920212984085083, -0.04808773100376129, 0.016404110938310623, -0.01218086201697588, -0.01733819767832756, -0.024256449192762375, -0.04944977909326553, 0.0016442425549030304, 0.028612639755010605, 0.031072299927473068, 0.02896161936223507, -0.0010079025523737073, -0.06536627560853958, 0.0021988260559737682, -0.08842717856168747, 0.04361702874302864, 0.02821521833539009, -0.04203414171934128, -0.023970894515514374, 0.007776055950671434, -0.06367415934801102, -0.004674436990171671, 0.045577988028526306, 0.02677365392446518, 0.01691519096493721, -0.02856491506099701, 0.037580132484436035, 0.04377586394548416, -0.01779983565211296, -0.006316706072539091, -0.016172973439097404, -0.041960470378398895, -0.019350841641426086, -0.006693723611533642, 0.018573718145489693, 0.03080957755446434, -0.022167326882481575, -0.005969344172626734, -0.005813269875943661, -0.0039748926647007465, 0.04418276622891426, 0.00280933128669858, -0.023807723075151443, -0.005955611355602741, 0.03949635103344917, -0.013185497373342514, -0.011559819802641869, 0.008566649630665779, 0.004117377568036318, -0.043583206832408905, 0.0058566126972436905, -0.014358056709170341, 0.008854985237121582, -0.02196425199508667, 0.02748550847172737, 0.034832295030355453, -0.07788292318582535, -0.022299565374851227, 0.04188566282391548, -0.00626477412879467, 0.012853392399847507, 0.03811894729733467, 0.026549501344561577, 0.05702247843146324, 0.03417743742465973, 0.00847352109849453, 0.01963728666305542, -0.015288910828530788, 0.0259116031229496, 0.01468387246131897, 0.007745812181383371, 0.015432166866958141, 0.029700256884098053, 0.006097047124058008, -0.013228246942162514, 0.030551200732588768, 0.010975501500070095, 0.016050102189183235, -0.009389137849211693, -0.028856661170721054, 0.02104310877621174, -0.018642688170075417, 0.032278019934892654, 0.019049080088734627, -0.013646033592522144, 0.06782799959182739, -0.051604125648736954, 0.006464560981839895, -0.06640125811100006, -0.007117615547031164, -0.05004381760954857, -0.01902865245938301, -0.0015097527066245675, 0.03359760344028473, 0.004800282418727875, 0.006436771247535944, 0.01565050333738327, 0.0018331407336518168, 0.04129531607031822, -0.03702856972813606, 0.026253145188093185, -0.02592390775680542, -0.029093051329255104, 0.008769342675805092, -0.01934748888015747, -0.020374685525894165, -0.026397285982966423, 0.02276727557182312, 0.0675082877278328, 0.037480928003787994, 0.04572726786136627, -0.04939959943294525, -0.028661945834755898, 0.0015386570012196898, -0.05015572905540466, -0.015207143500447273, -0.053480952978134155, -0.003315890673547983, -0.02013413794338703, -0.036815837025642395 ]
<p>I am trying to fit a linear model (<code>lme4::lmer()</code>) to my data in R. I would like to look at a number of things, including "<strong>scrambling</strong>" of visual stimuli and "<strong>intensity</strong>" of the emotions portrayed therein. These things are stored the "<strong>scrambling</strong>" and "<strong>intensity</strong>" columns of my dataframe.</p> <p>To ease your comprehension you may see a graphic plot of my data in <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/76134/determining-best-approximator-based-on-repeated-measurements">this other thread</a>.</p> <p>I have been told that linear model results can be compromised if category names are parsed as integers instead of strings by accident. But since these measures (<strong>scrambling</strong> and <strong>intensity</strong>) are kind-of quantitative, I am thinking it may be better to leave them as integers - or maybe even use both approaches separately.</p> <p>I am however unsure how my interpretation of results should vary depending on whether or not my category IDs are passed as stings or ints.</p> <p>Could anyone explain this to me?</p> <p>Also would this differentiation still hold for when I use <code>stats::aov()</code> on the same data?</p>
74,193
[ -0.045667994767427444, -0.023503197357058525, -0.010776438750326633, -0.016912873834371567, -0.014688314869999886, 0.030375488102436066, -0.005560755729675293, 0.011916524730622768, 0.04503415897488594, -0.0060646506026387215, -0.009981070645153522, 0.016135387122631073, 0.07826830446720123, 0.04651259258389473, 0.01257213857024908, -0.0352909080684185, 0.007018678821623325, -0.011019792407751083, 0.009447979740798473, 0.025124112144112587, -0.01284869760274887, 0.03745128959417343, -0.03743583709001541, -0.014890743419528008, -0.045162007212638855, 0.09243622422218323, 0.017333459109067917, -0.014413725584745407, 0.0022566840052604675, 0.03630617633461952, -0.016815470531582832, -0.028227869421243668, 0.007013644091784954, 0.00928958784788847, 0.01107760239392519, -0.0056044552475214005, -0.02488134801387787, -0.010908292606472969, -0.028548244386911392, 0.038405053317546844, -0.024928104132413864, 0.0000035523819406080293, -0.020699869841337204, 0.02762967348098755, -0.008003137074410915, 0.028374819085001945, -0.01586204767227173, -0.011117104440927505, 0.035765331238508224, -0.01019982248544693, 0.053558122366666794, 0.004350341856479645, 0.01779957488179207, 0.032370422035455704, -0.04050993174314499, -0.01761995255947113, 0.05617775395512581, 0.06249095872044563, -0.0023026156704872847, -0.059277597814798355, 0.011530613526701927, -0.0362299419939518, 0.006908216048032045, -0.020487571135163307, -0.012715931981801987, 0.024053217843174934, 0.04485459253191948, -0.03437122330069542, 0.033764373511075974, -0.028383934870362282, 0.029058584943413734, 0.03777443245053291, 0.03088926523923874, -0.026998164132237434, 0.038848768919706345, -0.030068567022681236, 0.030992940068244934, -0.01518106646835804, 0.05667388439178467, 0.0304854866117239, 0.013202272355556488, 0.004431704059243202, 0.018505997955799103, 0.06678760051727295, 0.0198254082351923, -0.01375732570886612, 0.06066382676362991, -0.021440820768475533, 0.004514171276241541, 0.0444452129304409, 0.007983076386153698, -0.002715983660891652, 0.05865496024489403, 0.044387686997652054, -0.029866129159927368, 0.044151902198791504, -0.02035600133240223, 0.05606909096240997, -0.0030796986538916826, -0.0012558232992887497, -0.03928034380078316, -0.027237368747591972, 0.013170763850212097, 0.03098653070628643, -0.02357100509107113, -0.008883010596036911, -0.023525819182395935, -0.021201256662607193, 0.0009288163273595273, -0.02581525407731533, -0.011066258884966373, 0.02231528051197529, -0.016233233734965324, -0.024913573637604713, 0.022318661212921143, -0.06331831216812134, -0.026878882199525833, -0.013383550569415092, 0.046193454414606094, 0.07275468856096268, 0.0356612466275692, -0.02036508172750473, 0.02792893722653389, -0.021964063867926598, -0.015388797037303448, 0.03460273519158363, 0.041148439049720764, 0.004426055122166872, -0.06484346091747284, 0.057932689785957336, 0.004309080075472593, -0.028958704322576523, 0.04817074164748192, -0.035243839025497437, -0.013659480027854443, -0.0011535098310559988, -0.07349392771720886, -0.061641089618206024, -0.00931412260979414, -0.011013316921889782, -0.02050045318901539, -0.07491729408502579, -0.020989207550883293, -0.01708076521754265, 0.0521138459444046, 0.021439865231513977, 0.055846162140369415, 0.03050866164267063, -0.008100045844912529, 0.043194741010665894, -0.04604218155145645, 0.014901991002261639, -0.020434468984603882, -0.016787750646471977, -0.032386600971221924, -0.08417689055204391, 0.010763474740087986, 0.012069523334503174, 0.002379810670390725, 0.005777832120656967, 0.023114699870347977, 0.004300363827496767, 0.0034448241349309683, 0.025756070390343666, 0.037660375237464905, -0.0055444808676838875, 0.05165128782391548, -0.003249283879995346, 0.05456145480275154, -0.006628223694860935, -0.014155707322061062, 0.019259942695498466, 0.005237115081399679, 0.02896416187286377, 0.05324355140328407, -0.022569626569747925, 0.030142150819301605, -0.048853468149900436, 0.02152339741587639, 0.0217119213193655, -0.05689669027924538, -0.04848186671733856, -0.032281212508678436, -0.03823311626911163, -0.005687656346708536, 0.023545511066913605, -0.0018968208460137248, -0.029065251350402832, 0.04372265934944153, -0.03750920295715332, -0.0391412191092968, -0.08552618324756622, -0.005690213292837143, -0.03078392706811428, -0.05132331699132919, 0.029104197397828102, -0.017023589462041855, 0.04556293413043022, 0.009274911135435104, 0.0189373716711998, -0.0061486042104661465, -0.015244918875396252, 0.05998635292053223, -0.04195516183972359, -0.018487410619854927, 0.018390826880931854, 0.013585684821009636, -0.022372009232640266, 0.044128432869911194, -0.017331641167402267, -0.034610334783792496, 0.030303960666060448, -0.014344348572194576, 0.032359421253204346, 0.025440886616706848, 0.005313389003276825, 0.022764034569263458, 0.002805400639772415, -0.0381137989461422, 0.052803587168455124, -0.055244699120521545, 0.05508380010724068, 0.047658536583185196, 0.020745685324072838, 0.012518493458628654, 0.032693471759557724, -0.006388538051396608, -0.019164692610502243, -0.03855431452393532, 0.008557625114917755, -0.03584183752536774, -0.004668085370212793, 0.08287494629621506, 0.008188464678823948, -0.043037064373493195, 0.033547814935445786, 0.024775858968496323, -0.014399404637515545, 0.03481978178024292, -0.01461818628013134, 0.005044210236519575, -0.01498446799814701, 0.03061837889254093, -0.000339939579134807, 0.01514462474733591, 0.01383171509951353, 0.004070356022566557, -0.04161200299859047, 0.047617457807064056, 0.0041084010154008865, 0.02013157494366169, 0.05494892597198486, -0.010711738839745522, -0.006364384666085243, -0.04530907794833183, -0.014736492186784744, 0.05465662106871605, -0.029429875314235687, -0.008715878240764141, 0.06715317070484161, 0.013592987321317196, -0.03274470195174217, -0.01124847773462534, 0.012504846788942814, 0.003433292033150792, 0.04156406596302986, -0.026569725945591927, -0.00007006114174146205, 0.03102823533117771, -0.05208020657300949, 0.01137266680598259, -0.023294225335121155, -0.0344805009663105, -0.031861837953329086, 0.007518323138356209, 0.0007940102950669825, 0.037607382982969284, -0.007888886146247387, -0.03985200822353363, 0.019894475117325783, 0.0057143536396324635, -0.02890625409781933, 0.04113113135099411, 0.004329239949584007, -0.0358659103512764, -0.0055550760589540005, -0.0582934208214283, -0.04368383437395096, 0.04102005064487457, 0.013213614001870155, -0.01177702285349369, 0.014601635746657848, -0.024125611409544945, -0.03683727979660034, -0.02949732169508934, -0.01692080870270729, 0.012143452651798725, -0.021222660318017006, -0.04117433726787567, 0.023818353191018105, -0.01739288493990898, -0.040464527904987335, 0.007175159640610218, -0.03921835497021675, -0.004552062600851059, -0.01837042160332203, -0.01616865210235119, 0.010910731740295887, 0.007576067931950092, -0.003939715679734945, 0.02487494796514511, -0.007727156393229961, -0.007381596602499485, -0.07627753168344498, -0.0463545061647892, -0.0019004294881597161, 0.04571482539176941, 0.002819561865180731, 0.03962501510977745, -0.01450430043041706, 0.12068571895360947, 0.03760329633951187, -0.03987361863255501, -0.07035336643457413, -0.013817455619573593, -0.03767780959606171, -0.02126077376306057, 0.022451650351285934, 0.028119640424847603, 0.042625706642866135, -0.004543656017631292, -0.006406838074326515, 0.035316694527864456, 0.03846030309796333, -0.017193369567394257, -0.019358184188604355, 0.03873845562338829, -0.02167840115725994, -0.07544559985399246, 0.010284370742738247, 0.05168389901518822, -0.029864054173231125, 0.016129983589053154, -0.0035190621856600046, -0.019876260310411453, 0.02376040630042553, -0.04510284215211868, 0.013893493451178074, -0.011599362827837467, 0.05098334699869156, 0.01924283802509308, 0.02362830936908722, -0.028818253427743912, -0.041613779962062836, -0.019104333594441414, 0.013953777961432934, 0.021610071882605553, -0.03556112200021744, -0.011429921723902225, 0.026010267436504364, 0.03165363147854805, -0.011005731299519539, 0.019227415323257446, -0.005756165366619825, -0.02551686018705368, 0.014909407123923302, -0.027847951278090477, 0.008828823454678059, 0.029700325801968575, 0.018188579007983208, 0.0067451163195073605, 0.02113894373178482, -0.049248576164245605, 0.022072700783610344, -0.06958331912755966, -0.006144415121525526, -0.026696667075157166, 0.03023509494960308, 0.028381023555994034, 0.05581076443195343, 0.04008984565734863, -0.000023017366402200423, -0.012003792449831963, 0.015318545512855053, -0.0554065965116024, 0.00772334448993206, 0.03589655086398125, -0.02845359407365322, 0.017336510121822357, -0.03272504732012749, -0.017273634672164917, -0.016065550968050957, 0.021823987364768982, 0.018061986193060875, 0.00786624290049076, -0.03228292614221573, -0.028495296835899353, 0.00011921535769943148, -0.014217191375792027, -0.01605096086859703, 0.0335562601685524, 0.03231433033943176, 0.011597723700106144, 0.027430616319179535, 0.04041875898838043, 0.02274077571928501, -0.0017667541978880763, -0.03862934187054634, -0.006174169015139341, 0.030853018164634705, 0.052488356828689575, -0.0074246907606720924, -0.031517013907432556, 0.01570866070687771, 0.027076009660959244, 0.014643589965999126, 0.027799006551504135, 0.0297283586114645, 0.010129915550351143, -0.014312163926661015, -0.020794786512851715, -0.006335306912660599, 0.0076856776140630245, 0.026560654863715172, 0.00018510637164581567, -0.0038191264029592276, 0.03835288807749748, 0.05329136922955513, -0.006908341310918331, -0.019249893724918365, 0.07614412903785706, 0.021149974316358566, -0.0375586561858654, -0.041316136717796326, 0.019289012998342514, -0.004273462574928999, -0.0037577280309051275, 0.02930518053472042, 0.002489721402525902, 0.04356153681874275, 0.024322504177689552, 0.024199601262807846, -0.009109638631343842, -0.05168595910072327, 0.024212729185819626, 0.01140664517879486, 0.014576312154531479, -0.07829207181930542, -0.03261472284793854, 0.0020252149552106857, 0.06919966638088226, 0.044300906360149384, 0.013036717660725117, -0.005806804168969393, -0.08766692876815796, 0.023735178634524345, 0.019194811582565308, 0.07396876066923141, -0.043719954788684845, -0.018116574734449387, -0.010385530069470406, -0.010661042295396328, 0.016272127628326416, 0.007025671191513538, 0.016731739044189453, -0.03702056035399437, -0.015487568452954292, -0.0419028215110302, -0.007248010020703077, -0.039168208837509155, 0.025266030803322792, 0.003196579869836569, 0.04202020913362503, -0.011394436471164227, -0.002740823430940509, -0.04750630632042885, 0.04397913068532944, -0.017916806042194366, 0.011216952465474606, -0.039099086076021194, -0.041905518621206284, 0.002404124243184924, -0.010957642458379269, -0.04990847781300545, -0.022099491208791733, 0.03184833750128746, -0.0167122520506382, 0.014126286841928959, 0.04808221384882927, 0.02721606194972992, -0.008119914680719376, -0.004371387884020805, 0.044594425708055496, 0.015288149006664753, 0.004050308372825384, -0.012900091707706451, 0.029121989384293556, 0.02352217398583889, 0.024290507659316063, 0.06251472979784012, 0.04068031534552574, -0.014871148392558098, 0.03321363776922226, -0.016144931316375732, 0.04200558736920357, 0.001565561513416469, -0.07018230855464935, -0.04514828324317932, -0.005070956889539957, -0.0009787866147235036, 0.011801349930465221, 0.02096063271164894, 0.0434163473546505, -0.033483508974313736, -0.0357154905796051, 0.026705250144004822, 0.02567788027226925, -0.009904321283102036, -0.012020598165690899, -0.0038187799509614706, 0.03813454508781433, -0.013959260657429695, -0.00813993625342846, -0.021710779517889023, -0.0332045741379261, 0.028246097266674042, 0.03926302120089531, -0.05890984088182449, 0.018132269382476807, -0.019442133605480194, -0.005088260862976313, 0.05056042969226837, -0.01875712163746357, 0.0035889034625142813, -0.004644532687962055, 0.0003828428452834487, 0.009770304895937443, -0.05600318685173988, -0.010448482818901539, 0.02139967493712902, -0.05222885683178902, 0.04040820524096489, -0.04382165148854256, 0.05858344957232475, -0.040666162967681885, -0.008749494329094887, -0.04112488776445389, -0.04984307661652565, -0.0001883842924144119, -0.007553732953965664, -0.05126436799764633, 0.009070130065083504, -0.019826505333185196, -0.021841557696461678, -0.030772263184189796, -0.02770628035068512, 0.07002203911542892, -0.013689110986888409, 0.00494062015786767, -0.01475484948605299, 0.014931421726942062, 0.06509044766426086, 0.030879154801368713, 0.04373154416680336, 0.012336652725934982, 0.011080832220613956, 0.003942469600588083, -0.0047628977335989475, 0.007986699230968952, -0.049350399523973465, -0.0024469068739563227, -0.026273082941770554, 0.007958467118442059, 0.06586041301488876, 0.01728634163737297, -0.020540745928883553, -0.015834609046578407, -0.03968963772058487, 0.02847547084093094, -0.04328157752752304, 0.0006709501030854881, -0.030722279101610184, -0.0004208570171613246, -0.020544420927762985, 0.003710942342877388, 0.006848494056612253, 0.011334486305713654, 0.03297333046793938, -0.01776447333395481, -0.0018349664751440287, 0.019605059176683426, 0.04470640420913696, 0.018233899027109146, 0.034748587757349014, -0.014310713857412338, -0.023762809112668037, 0.05162728950381279, -0.001391717465594411, -0.013075907714664936, -0.003240972524508834, 0.058673977851867676, -0.027915237471461296, -0.014543748460710049, -0.010476617142558098, -0.0005253194831311703, 0.03509471192955971, 0.00862063653767109, 0.014691551215946674, 0.05296482890844345, -0.009786656126379967, -0.009681942872703075, -0.040499262511730194, -0.04681437462568283, -0.0029028088320046663, 0.017283201217651367, 0.08639610558748245, 0.007409066893160343, 0.005773178301751614, 0.03975687175989151, -0.010564342141151428, 0.015517919324338436, -0.013294849544763565, 0.01971062645316124, 0.009833313524723053, 0.026095570996403694, -0.017398731783032417, -0.05461138114333153, 0.03354005515575409, -0.038848407566547394, 0.0229498241096735, 0.011700975708663464, -0.05209390074014664, 0.03562043607234955, -0.0028018441516906023, -0.012440456077456474, -0.07505375146865845, -0.01923849619925022, -0.024466052651405334, 0.0009940124582499266, 0.031951408833265305, 0.0008150121429935098, -0.005544465966522694, 0.04791897535324097, 0.051523130387067795, -0.014961469918489456, 0.019369633868336678, 0.002759320428594947, -0.07604168355464935, -0.01705028861761093, -0.03214690089225769, -0.02817249856889248, 0.05157415568828583, -0.0032570764888077974, -0.0014047352597117424, 0.009075094945728779, -0.10582935810089111, 0.04159574955701828, 0.021121041849255562, 0.04152128845453262, 0.019644731655716896, 0.03335975110530853, -0.028224404901266098, -0.020532017573714256, -0.044832512736320496, -0.025989023968577385, 0.12669825553894043, 0.07545994967222214, 0.014844347722828388, -0.0618172362446785, 0.024191908538341522, 0.047960251569747925, -0.008130786009132862, 0.01693800278007984, -0.018995314836502075, 0.018756726756691933, 0.015061073936522007, 0.033174268901348114, 0.035586532205343246, 0.0179225355386734, 0.002725009573623538, 0.008900724351406097, -0.007880287244915962, 0.026574213057756424, 0.04577253758907318, 0.02372021973133087, 0.009918885305523872, -0.010708542540669441, -0.06678664684295654, 0.003599794814363122, 0.050368234515190125, -0.000986061175353825, -0.0033214474096894264, -0.005857590585947037, -0.00995540525764227, -0.02320670709013939, -0.02312564291059971, 0.013207560405135155, 0.005685559473931789, 0.008927657268941402, 0.018369639292359352, 0.004282868932932615, 0.007932022213935852, -0.026226965710520744, 0.02638891339302063, 0.048851124942302704, 0.007632683962583542, 0.0016334877582266927, -0.018016066402196884, 0.020392563194036484, -0.012826300226151943, -0.04726424813270569, -0.06682196259498596, 0.020950479432940483, 0.009527315385639668, -0.023227272555232048, 0.01682197116315365, 0.01696428284049034, -0.016136925667524338, -0.05539786070585251, -0.031961336731910706, 0.020323937758803368, 0.010823620483279228, -0.005470362026244402, -0.014472341164946556, -0.020757846534252167, 0.003102060640230775, -0.0023225785698741674, 0.0007974635809659958, -0.002143996302038431, -0.0340702123939991, -0.0004602751578204334, 0.004267886281013489, 0.03698067367076874, 0.030566789209842682, 0.015954989939928055, 0.030673371627926826, -0.020553139969706535, -0.0486028715968132, -0.028721250593662262, -0.021224969998002052, 0.021129658445715904, -0.010637834668159485, -0.012687892653048038, -0.0020522112026810646, -0.025355711579322815, -0.04467983916401863, 0.00731090409681201, -0.0057960678823292255, 0.012652372010052204, -0.03432703763246536, 0.00010230451152892783, 0.011091146618127823, -0.01934686303138733, 0.009458483196794987, -0.024886339902877808, 0.0007657992537133396, 0.059538546949625015, -0.018239565193653107, -0.03144195303320885, 0.009295406751334667, 0.023380303755402565, -0.013479280285537243, 0.0036544352769851685, -0.001899469643831253, 0.051025185734033585, -0.015207702293992043, 0.022369788959622383, -0.03064514882862568, 0.021411603316664696, 0.014128795824944973, 0.014999061822891235, 0.047450918704271317, -0.04663743078708649, -0.017220495268702507, -0.0013758919667452574, 0.02562490478157997, -0.03232055529952049, -0.04688100889325142, -0.0618390329182148, -0.05039287731051445, -0.020004674792289734, -0.02623312547802925, -0.022204941138625145, 0.016722654923796654, -0.005403770133852959, 0.00020297335868235677, -0.009216371923685074, 0.001954144798219204, -0.04055478051304817, -0.018641574308276176, -0.015002780593931675, -0.01813262701034546, 0.002193456282839179, 0.012456783093512058, -0.032413288950920105, -0.01946243643760681, 0.021142002195119858, -0.010339664295315742, 0.019595669582486153, 0.010432354174554348, 0.023243773728609085, -0.0028379964642226696, 0.03517910838127136, 0.02644571289420128, -0.043727342039346695, 0.004391906782984734, -0.016704648733139038, -0.06428813189268112, 0.011632691137492657, -0.04676450043916702, 0.004015748389065266, 0.03377150744199753, 0.008347571827471256, -0.015405882149934769, 0.062189072370529175, 0.0047972071915864944, -0.005411069840192795, -0.0016547967679798603, -0.012984609231352806, 0.023381495848298073, 0.019743433222174644, 0.025536414235830307, 0.021043822169303894, -0.014258095994591713, 0.023269006982445717, 0.005812206771224737, -0.002230592304840684, -0.0002707003732211888, -0.012088689021766186, -0.03516075760126114, 0.024910828098654747, -0.020246652886271477, 0.003589673899114132, 0.02694382704794407, 0.03037073463201523, -0.011634305119514465, 0.033354200422763824, -0.038464631885290146, 0.0211158599704504, -0.08178495615720749, -0.013268956914544106, 0.01795358397066593, 0.01645677536725998, 0.016325972974300385, -0.08670295774936676, 0.03310628607869148, 0.036677271127700806, -0.0866934284567833, -0.013060193508863449, -0.017268987372517586, 0.002710785483941436, -0.0313139408826828, 0.008101848885416985, -0.012303294613957405, -0.005569221917539835, 0.01352572999894619, -0.027503283694386482, 0.02246222272515297, 0.010115092620253563, 0.01905062422156334, 0.005331790540367365, -0.004673577845096588, 0.02734496258199215, 0.04741555079817772, -0.059110067784786224, 0.0570223331451416, -0.007274537347257137, -0.03605636581778526, 0.017279379069805145, -0.03154689446091652, 0.04349159449338913, 0.01606282778084278, 0.01642036996781826, 0.04521648958325386, 0.03868449851870537, -0.00969904288649559, -0.013411024585366249, -0.026729393750429153, -0.020684950053691864, 0.0005850789602845907, 0.020533816888928413, 0.0016000248724594712, -0.03354907035827637, 0.0027491161599755287, 0.012154302559792995, -0.0383295975625515, -0.009202844463288784, 0.0016464402433484793, -0.003455365775153041, -0.006103024818003178, 0.00018235042807646096, 0.012140671722590923, -0.05546380579471588, 0.033453360199928284, -0.02931705117225647, 0.03161996603012085, 0.02577570080757141, 0.014646059833467007, -0.013094787485897541, 0.02199368178844452, -0.026396075263619423, -0.04379674792289734, -0.03116757608950138, 0.010395271703600883, -0.017585044726729393, -0.04745174199342728, 0.018152756616473198, 0.017227038741111755, -0.02526901848614216, -0.009426132775843143, 0.0011261585168540478, -0.025458170101046562, 0.03558988496661186, -0.019665248692035675, 0.019265908747911453, 0.01518977340310812, -0.023857910186052322, 0.012903611175715923, -0.1205381229519844, 0.06117480620741844, 0.042241718620061874, 0.039984624832868576, -0.056470565497875214, 0.00752010103315115, -0.026438668370246887, 0.017038624733686447, 0.05223523825407028, 0.02190503664314747, -0.010606151074171066, 0.016685742884874344, 0.021747812628746033, -0.0006213981541804969, 0.0028934329748153687, -0.004331114701926708, -0.0008055944344960153, 0.009401155635714531, -0.005136339459568262, 0.03721870854496956, -0.0013574492186307907, 0.0013714540982618928, 0.005506948567926884, -0.014049896970391273, 0.007050157058984041, -0.00333671597763896, -0.028126364573836327, 0.02680990844964981, -0.021834958344697952, -0.013730227015912533, 0.02571699023246765, 0.014993971213698387, -0.003782127983868122, 0.018979812040925026, -0.010681086219847202, -0.03283261880278587, 0.04152560234069824, 0.007796131074428558, 0.0032263626344501972, -0.0015180624322965741, 0.008620554581284523, 0.03144828975200653, -0.06246556341648102, 0.028483247384428978, 0.008539527654647827, -0.00848902203142643, -0.002578840358182788, 0.033944811671972275, 0.005246913991868496, 0.013377110473811626, 0.03615787252783775, 0.02568429708480835, 0.0035826119128614664, -0.01583118364214897, -0.029203113168478012, 0.00909756775945425, 0.03391046077013016, 0.028946997597813606, -0.0033827736042439938, 0.030091119930148125, -0.005726901348680258, 0.005443740636110306, 0.02033684030175209, 0.0835149958729744, 0.0013118054484948516, -0.0029367152601480484, 0.01645684614777565, -0.008503708057105541, -0.004969385452568531, 0.00011362215445842594, -0.03403707593679428, 0.0643112063407898, -0.06863823533058167, 0.0024467380717396736, -0.013605356216430664, -0.024866100400686264, -0.052647825330495834, -0.005165298003703356, 0.030257657170295715, 0.033831704407930374, -0.008908037096261978, -0.011551852338016033, -0.012669640593230724, -0.027713041752576828, 0.04014661908149719, -0.058503974229097366, -0.025891762226819992, -0.002665968844667077, -0.02104734070599079, 0.000701317039784044, 0.01725158281624317, -0.03832489997148514, -0.004693887196481228, 0.056571461260318756, 0.010018671862781048, 0.02343611977994442, -0.032595958560705185, -0.0297610554844141, 0.006924849469214678, 0.03524760529398918, -0.054019082337617874, -0.0337301529943943, -0.010909992270171642, 0.014652110636234283, 0.031902287155389786, -0.02959630824625492 ]
<p>I am frequentist by training and practice, but I'd like to learn more about Bayesian statistics. I know the basics, but I would be at a loss if I had to, for example, replace my normal ANOVA hypothesis testing approach with a Bayesian alternative.</p> <p>What book would you recommend to learn practical Bayesian approaches? Preferably using R.</p>
36,918
[ -0.026391854509711266, -0.018741561099886894, 0.016866648569703102, -0.005696589592844248, 0.03779612109065056, 0.023145513609051704, 0.027537303045392036, -0.01345613319426775, 0.008399737067520618, -0.01606166735291481, 0.027177834883332253, 0.054728563874959946, 0.05886842682957649, 0.0013699393020942807, 0.029826004058122635, -0.01035078801214695, -0.0060605802573263645, -0.03903889283537865, -0.05510827898979187, 0.0024263071827590466, 0.0026473472826182842, 0.002891605719923973, 0.04312331601977348, -0.014611076563596725, -0.01360300462692976, 0.0367748960852623, 0.021673647686839104, -0.022600794211030006, -0.0026741879992187023, 0.06511718779802322, -0.04772590100765228, -0.006086012814193964, -0.006123075261712074, 0.043885450810194016, 0.006371547933667898, -0.00415105139836669, -0.0022111088037490845, -0.016595734283328056, -0.021680578589439392, 0.02269221842288971, -0.030652804300189018, -0.03199326619505882, -0.0021990302484482527, 0.03453204780817032, -0.018532074987888336, 0.0030793198384344578, 0.0036184771452099085, -0.03321859613060951, -0.0023483913391828537, -0.0598822683095932, 0.04303295910358429, 0.02003137581050396, 0.026226796209812164, 0.060426343232393265, 0.018990375101566315, -0.010052734054625034, 0.0517580583691597, 0.0569588728249073, -0.022003667429089546, -0.08546818792819977, -0.04376858472824097, -0.0442521907389164, 0.0029040889348834753, -0.02954399771988392, -0.05164842680096626, 0.021257488057017326, -0.011407480575144291, -0.03394388407468796, 0.03261540085077286, -0.015608529560267925, 0.010774754919111729, 0.0428597517311573, 0.03272552788257599, -0.00811038352549076, 0.013539807870984077, -0.023417456075549126, 0.00026600240380503237, 0.028234343975782394, 0.031227827072143555, 0.07088055461645126, 0.006866562645882368, -0.005085567478090525, 0.024191375821828842, 0.05763312801718712, 0.005329318810254335, -0.04292009398341179, 0.08563943207263947, 0.0027226002421230078, -0.03393607586622238, -0.01003840658813715, -0.05547633394598961, -0.0029061392415314913, 0.032513804733753204, 0.0037943872157484293, -0.05948455631732941, 0.05249902233481407, -0.021959953010082245, 0.07236982136964798, -0.00017146939353551716, -0.027646364644169807, 0.011757241562008858, -0.02026611566543579, 0.028655583038926125, 0.05537992715835571, -0.03360927850008011, -0.04985325038433075, -0.019990993663668633, 0.030223596841096878, -0.030080456286668777, -0.024708641692996025, -0.03480534255504608, 0.058224231004714966, -0.004470837768167257, 0.01539559941738844, 0.027083922177553177, -0.021994009613990784, 0.02359713800251484, -0.03442233055830002, 0.07726816087961197, 0.07995986193418503, 0.06158130615949631, -0.020531054586172104, 0.0514407679438591, -0.03950759395956993, -0.04772801697254181, -0.006934609729796648, 0.001658302848227322, -0.04957304522395134, -0.026723230257630348, 0.062058474868535995, -0.017611553892493248, -0.02737581916153431, 0.032979369163513184, 0.023004697635769844, 0.011062102392315865, 0.007705546449869871, -0.06882365792989731, -0.04483425244688988, 0.05713190883398056, -0.03833307325839996, -0.03448962792754173, -0.054868508130311966, 0.001903624041005969, 0.03310650214552879, 0.019267605617642403, -0.007791210897266865, 0.017330488190054893, 0.001618148642592132, 0.03321244567632675, -0.038718853145837784, -0.03283319249749184, -0.03917596861720085, -0.009658767841756344, -0.008940414525568485, -0.02562461793422699, -0.09285984188318253, 0.015614002011716366, -0.006581645924597979, 0.03433395177125931, -0.012504559941589832, 0.04991866275668144, -0.01066968496888876, -0.025520194321870804, -0.00821114145219326, -0.014868323691189289, 0.008583015762269497, 0.08417526632547379, 0.017066210508346558, 0.01801707036793232, 0.0108870267868042, -0.01029195822775364, 0.01916058175265789, 0.025191808119416237, 0.032627590000629425, 0.03960211202502251, -0.038444507867097855, 0.001881417236290872, -0.013231851160526276, 0.02300748974084854, 0.01505961362272501, 0.013097777031362057, 0.023688359186053276, -0.027473798021674156, -0.04644542187452316, -0.007697441149502993, 0.0212502870708704, 0.02300521917641163, -0.007228520233184099, 0.02587026171386242, -0.039037346839904785, -0.041725192219018936, -0.09898131340742111, -0.019236240535974503, -0.006451450753957033, -0.01470001507550478, 0.04937431216239929, 0.023247485980391502, 0.039710648357868195, -0.046549491584300995, -0.03694814443588257, -0.03899019584059715, -0.01866830699145794, 0.012973657809197903, -0.03553007170557976, 0.007927922531962395, 0.06654955446720123, 0.06331274658441544, -0.02500847354531288, 0.025185301899909973, -0.05017068609595299, -0.06606645882129669, -0.015006130561232567, -0.017549803480505943, 0.020140843465924263, -0.014531925320625305, -0.030197402462363243, 0.015080797486007214, -0.007576886564493179, -0.018038781359791756, 0.006526907440274954, -0.06676780432462692, 0.05484621599316597, 0.07507667690515518, 0.020886201411485672, -0.0002396819181740284, 0.017564920708537102, 0.011599493212997913, 0.006478007882833481, -0.016864271834492683, 0.016535332426428795, -0.031198633834719658, 0.0179621372371912, 0.06038026511669159, 0.0022133286111056805, -0.019533753395080566, 0.02001166343688965, 0.009690573439002037, 0.02994270622730255, 0.023839375004172325, 0.0584261529147625, -0.006737638730555773, -0.04556335508823395, 0.0013133945176377892, 0.010731401853263378, -0.001055888831615448, 0.027496960014104843, 0.038271814584732056, 0.008232343010604382, 0.048823416233062744, 0.003995586186647415, -0.03741370514035225, -0.0043889377266168594, -0.026097416877746582, 0.009326566942036152, -0.008989435620605946, -0.02818060852587223, 0.02335013635456562, -0.02306847833096981, -0.016948886215686798, -0.010674907825887203, 0.009742742404341698, -0.002525073243305087, 0.001752057345584035, -0.026319332420825958, 0.019806217402219772, 0.02423379383981228, -0.03475834056735039, 0.01240603905171156, 0.027004452422261238, -0.04356946423649788, 0.03817123547196388, -0.01857169345021248, -0.02230723947286606, -0.03486708924174309, 0.007988815195858479, -0.009907710365951061, 0.004493203479796648, 0.02674998715519905, -0.012946724891662598, -0.04480656981468201, 0.022555481642484665, -0.02448209375143051, 0.035032618790864944, -0.015618044883012772, -0.05765555426478386, 0.0008792000007815659, -0.035941172391176224, -0.019663376733660698, 0.016097115352749825, -0.02082321234047413, -0.0172883253544569, 0.0014481382677331567, 0.03365599364042282, -0.028422504663467407, -0.002317782025784254, 0.006289371754974127, -0.01123026106506586, -0.013709344901144505, -0.02059209905564785, 0.02767331339418888, 0.006148467306047678, 0.000310682225972414, 0.02247053012251854, -0.037570416927337646, -0.03050796315073967, -0.01814437098801136, -0.014541569165885448, 0.012654938735067844, 0.010719726793467999, -0.0032597847748547792, 0.036499928683042526, -0.07256381213665009, 0.01801380142569542, -0.04884039983153343, -0.04872555285692215, 0.005498966202139854, 0.01829724945127964, 0.015355940908193588, -0.003900674404576421, 0.0009381457348354161, 0.04396836832165718, 0.024474168196320534, -0.029702045023441315, 0.017625369131565094, 0.006297272630035877, -0.027909480035305023, -0.02585744485259056, 0.01636914536356926, 0.0019111575093120337, -0.009157011285424232, 0.0007721338188275695, -0.00334127782844007, 0.013604812324047089, 0.04249661788344383, 0.044257525354623795, 0.023529501631855965, 0.020997878164052963, -0.004665147513151169, 0.002031307201832533, 0.0035463301464915276, 0.0030333525501191616, -0.0241958349943161, 0.000752449850551784, -0.021200448274612427, 0.0243680402636528, 0.017621217295527458, -0.025024201720952988, 0.0076083592139184475, -0.005024326965212822, 0.017546579241752625, -0.06202332302927971, 0.0456436462700367, -0.00790410302579403, -0.0446440763771534, 0.02191573940217495, 0.0266746636480093, 0.011592517606914043, -0.02310439571738243, 0.022966766729950905, 0.03951311111450195, 0.0420110709965229, -0.02738320454955101, -0.03088715486228466, -0.0027083796449005604, 0.0021632788702845573, 0.005895237438380718, -0.0009733791812323034, 0.003015519119799137, 0.06398287415504456, 0.0205533467233181, 0.007196287624537945, -0.024089982733130455, -0.04867253080010414, 0.03252412751317024, -0.05944284051656723, -0.007762168999761343, -0.014190882444381714, 0.016776058822870255, 0.000029036484193056822, 0.021441539749503136, 0.0031345055904239416, 0.0017124091973528266, 0.024155987426638603, -0.009348351508378983, -0.09302382171154022, 0.020601680502295494, -0.029489312320947647, -0.01822141371667385, -0.022001484408974648, -0.0017253655241802335, 0.04573841020464897, 0.009623603895306587, -0.0071177054196596146, -0.025046315044164658, -0.00032623152947053313, -0.031182102859020233, 0.011405134573578835, -0.04822571203112602, -0.027902742847800255, 0.005928863771259785, -0.0045476388186216354, 0.026871833950281143, -0.025033187121152878, 0.008352644741535187, 0.01676214300096035, -0.016116073355078697, -0.025980373844504356, 0.008709478192031384, 0.017684021964669228, 0.015706190839409828, 0.009843258187174797, 0.03177232667803764, 0.04879346489906311, -0.032690443098545074, 0.05377031862735748, 0.021571088582277298, 0.04642266035079956, 0.022262293845415115, -0.04775786027312279, 0.007013530470430851, -0.0397290401160717, -0.005397804081439972, -0.004291738849133253, 0.0067078121937811375, 0.007010862696915865, 0.006315898150205612, 0.057724226266145706, 0.023182140663266182, -0.07211339473724365, 0.0368465781211853, 0.035016827285289764, -0.0035062297247350216, -0.008999217301607132, 0.0001299068972002715, -0.011332966387271881, -0.027600452303886414, -0.0026863545645028353, 0.04267379269003868, 0.02742893621325493, -0.0227971188724041, 0.012373746372759342, 0.016470255330204964, -0.0039024692960083485, -0.010836699977517128, -0.03230391815304756, 0.021888485178351402, 0.025328468531370163, 0.01989618130028248, -0.03848283737897873, 0.02729823626577854, 0.015284078195691109, 0.042783211916685104, 0.007669365964829922, -0.00833150465041399, -0.08065421879291534, 0.015644198283553123, 0.052242595702409744, 0.03555291146039963, -0.03052050620317459, 0.023158874362707138, -0.04324259236454964, -0.023534605279564857, 0.07427222281694412, -0.029404081404209137, -0.01448024157434702, -0.026309635490179062, -0.011991534382104874, -0.012484094128012657, -0.009162696078419685, -0.04811146482825279, -0.03210445120930672, -0.011536706238985062, 0.039504509419202805, 0.012926118448376656, -0.019720425829291344, -0.07333334535360336, -0.009076477959752083, 0.011335319839417934, 0.0517771914601326, -0.0007729146163910627, -0.02343153953552246, 0.03742576390504837, 0.005551370792090893, -0.002575963269919157, -0.046576518565416336, -0.000440837669884786, 0.00014322770584840328, -0.018909700214862823, 0.02315961755812168, -0.016828365623950958, -0.06408721953630447, 0.027496954426169395, -0.03859874978661537, -0.05985337495803833, -0.02191409282386303, -0.04042583331465721, 0.004330216906964779, 0.0007580013480037451, 0.01548186969012022, 0.07701611518859863, -0.01862229034304619, -0.0020966718439012766, 0.01097495574504137, -0.03718876093626022, 0.05241222307085991, -0.031166253611445427, -0.013548494316637516, -0.0550280399620533, -0.02772175893187523, -0.008520131930708885, 0.0428919643163681, 0.021967098116874695, 0.019705774262547493, -0.03461305797100067, -0.024723321199417114, 0.030479099601507187, 0.03727395087480545, 0.003741463180631399, -0.008554819040000439, 0.011215327307581902, -0.0024688206613063812, 0.004735852591693401, 0.009357165545225143, 0.04593084380030632, -0.008247565478086472, 0.011845280416309834, -0.028018910437822342, -0.02432442083954811, 0.04729057475924492, -0.05321989208459854, -0.04514722153544426, 0.055010467767715454, -0.04893200099468231, 0.056044802069664, 0.030864937230944633, 0.04346698895096779, -0.006919975392520428, -0.0618373267352581, -0.051596976816654205, -0.0005857437499798834, 0.014569609425961971, 0.04142254218459129, -0.05969744548201561, 0.013249928131699562, -0.04994475468993187, 0.005156556610018015, -0.05299334228038788, -0.041693877428770065, 0.003422608831897378, -0.0077833132818341255, -0.028726626187562943, -0.05843047425150871, 0.057627566158771515, -0.007739181164652109, -0.010028288699686527, -0.029638219624757767, 0.03892659395933151, -0.029796458780765533, 0.018248409032821655, -0.0066647897474467754, 0.00586652010679245, 0.07068037241697311, 0.029565338045358658, -0.012066858820617199, 0.016964683309197426, -0.009755120612680912, -0.0066285100765526295, -0.020978234708309174, 0.045129626989364624, -0.01771293394267559, 0.009498708881437778, -0.015072950161993504, 0.016180863603949547, 0.04379020631313324, -0.04142672196030617, 0.016708172857761383, 0.046384166926145554, 0.01620030216872692, -0.018802916631102562, -0.05410374328494072, -0.021652234718203545, -0.015877239406108856, 0.006553871091455221, -0.050221480429172516, -0.0035806347150355577, 0.023469598963856697, -0.01755794882774353, 0.04210282862186432, 0.0025738882832229137, 0.012800399214029312, 0.013149010017514229, 0.03450336307287216, -0.012954389676451683, 0.033353790640830994, -0.004375869873911142, -0.012224430218338966, -0.008544986136257648, 0.004817929584532976, 0.003838661825284362, 0.02639283798635006, -0.014520211145281792, -0.027625108137726784, -0.04672817885875702, -0.06152993440628052, -0.0054646022617816925, 0.04242480918765068, -0.0037185170222073793, 0.05553300678730011, 0.06467359513044357, 0.00947258248925209, 0.00800273660570383, -0.03175869211554527, -0.023938994854688644, -0.02545681595802307, 0.0540507435798645, 0.03448644280433655, -0.03458526358008385, 0.019299739971756935, 0.04166010767221451, -0.00959879532456398, 0.02611425891518593, 0.04078962653875351, 0.0077391029335558414, 0.05589352175593376, 0.042296990752220154, -0.010025089606642723, -0.041800159960985184, 0.050014298409223557, -0.03457474336028099, 0.03715145215392113, -0.05432359129190445, -0.029712889343500137, 0.03447318822145462, 0.044850584119558334, -0.010535139590501785, -0.023117337375879288, -0.03241816908121109, -0.04359813407063484, 0.04357059299945831, 0.03457743301987648, 0.022479116916656494, 0.019521087408065796, 0.013762817718088627, 0.030112074688076973, -0.04511385038495064, 0.023389218375086784, -0.013138814829289913, -0.07284800708293915, -0.057941533625125885, 0.006661401130259037, -0.002825625939294696, 0.028461510315537453, -0.008971214294433594, -0.024548716843128204, -0.011646104976534843, -0.036353714764118195, 0.016468476504087448, -0.009587089531123638, 0.036944709718227386, -0.02768731117248535, 0.07190559804439545, -0.04479499161243439, 0.01029243879020214, 0.00004937046833219938, -0.005655472166836262, 0.11761456727981567, 0.07519993185997009, 0.05784444510936737, -0.10188174247741699, 0.04911348596215248, -0.02373356558382511, 0.005482586566358805, -0.03133884444832802, 0.023197175934910774, 0.015149486251175404, -0.015492450445890427, 0.02501796744763851, 0.05455229431390762, 0.03019295260310173, -0.019563373178243637, 0.056860484182834625, -0.04235191270709038, -0.030640769749879837, -0.006364614237099886, 0.0075124092400074005, -0.025571200996637344, -0.01659056916832924, -0.038999732583761215, 0.002227744087576866, -0.02172795683145523, -0.03695223852992058, -0.025447789579629898, -0.017979497089982033, -0.013663365505635738, 0.014533672481775284, 0.02144945226609707, -0.03598899766802788, 0.0004821656330022961, -0.030665026977658272, 0.03290102258324623, -0.005187222734093666, 0.03225197643041611, -0.02144540473818779, 0.020947447046637535, 0.014263639226555824, 0.0011030808091163635, 0.004143294412642717, -0.0015341842081397772, 0.008914961479604244, -0.044572994112968445, -0.029568670317530632, 0.009923350065946579, 0.057672545313835144, -0.01854967139661312, 0.004481236916035414, -0.01262268889695406, 0.0074296859093010426, 0.008898063562810421, -0.03740245848894119, -0.0005438748048618436, 0.0347374752163887, 0.05070166289806366, -0.029268037527799606, -0.010644424706697464, -0.00707532512024045, 0.0323648564517498, -0.008584782481193542, 0.040644582360982895, 0.03710496425628662, -0.014783710241317749, -0.038281749933958054, -0.04032670333981514, 0.019445767626166344, -0.0019102846272289753, -0.002520305337384343, -0.008905245922505856, 0.009678727947175503, -0.03479652479290962, -0.012328441254794598, 0.010521539486944675, 0.004979773424565792, 0.021944941952824593, -0.030712759122252464, 0.004403619561344385, 0.01416611485183239, -0.017656240612268448, 0.009256976656615734, -0.0298934169113636, 0.00470883771777153, 0.00013462750939652324, -0.00396421505138278, 0.04954315349459648, 0.03209127113223076, 0.01933535560965538, 0.018720896914601326, -0.02123335748910904, 0.02022581920027733, 0.041818421334028244, -0.04441014304757118, 0.00613915640860796, -0.016678158193826675, -0.022383634001016617, -0.011278570629656315, -0.0016175102209672332, 0.031263504177331924, 0.04603448137640953, 0.012944872491061687, -0.0053521497175097466, 0.003029999788850546, -0.023761508986353874, 0.015865178778767586, -0.026827378198504448, -0.05177689716219902, -0.012961370870471, 0.02965109795331955, 0.025644315406680107, -0.029633693397045135, -0.041628703474998474, -0.0067895036190748215, 0.00384702836163342, 0.013351071625947952, -0.004878432955592871, -0.03303041681647301, 0.03413483127951622, 0.02454441413283348, 0.022485285997390747, -0.026844212785363197, 0.03031086176633835, -0.027265047654509544, -0.012277726083993912, -0.030280904844403267, -0.0005579658900387585, -0.002785577205941081, 0.0247392188757658, -0.015616483986377716, -0.01556427963078022, 0.02574932761490345, -0.020333433523774147, 0.03385661914944649, 0.00693483417853713, 0.0154495220631361, -0.023316506296396255, 0.04098297655582428, -0.010581864975392818, -0.014661379158496857, 0.05037149786949158, -0.027655212208628654, -0.0439724437892437, 0.006945949979126453, 0.01663764752447605, 0.02796795777976513, -0.011548557318747044, -0.006253782659769058, -0.02351485751569271, 0.03865645080804825, -0.004072139970958233, -0.03718256205320358, -0.0013578537618741393, 0.022133616730570793, -0.019639689475297928, -0.006101976614445448, 0.03147885948419571, 0.0154524901881814, -0.007261890918016434, 0.01802288554608822, 0.02863268181681633, 0.02331056259572506, 0.030065493658185005, 0.02802661992609501, -0.014448271133005619, 0.021416760981082916, -0.015564093366265297, -0.02929849736392498, 0.03560003638267517, 0.04353887960314751, 0.003386245807632804, 0.048747505992650986, -0.031146453693509102, -0.009133711457252502, -0.10052112489938736, -0.012247603386640549, -0.002330463146790862, 0.014972604811191559, 0.037892453372478485, -0.058293018490076065, -0.0043697659857571125, 0.04693979024887085, -0.0324188694357872, 0.03666809946298599, 0.010055262595415115, -0.03305954858660698, -0.012528207153081894, 0.0016431843396276236, 0.0051991078071296215, 0.037182461470365524, 0.0007137850043363869, 0.020794320851564407, 0.037894606590270996, 0.0016126458067446947, 0.03529214486479759, -0.013804508373141289, 0.015076003968715668, 0.04560388624668121, 0.017478635534644127, -0.06814789026975632, 0.018294276669621468, -0.016527846455574036, -0.03393431752920151, 0.020034154877066612, 0.031769491732120514, 0.02868419699370861, 0.013586423359811306, 0.031121594831347466, -0.0034646636340767145, 0.06592793017625809, 0.040280554443597794, -0.00793344434350729, -0.008808874525129795, 0.00040551566053181887, 0.0259564071893692, 0.033792320638895035, -0.03002854995429516, 0.019892748445272446, 0.014877927489578724, -0.05031184107065201, -0.04051182046532631, 0.026147469878196716, 0.014712870121002197, -0.023234697058796883, 0.03194623813033104, 0.007220627274364233, 0.009755734354257584, -0.003761349245905876, -0.0004927465924993157, -0.04385245963931084, 0.019954273477196693, 0.05297795683145523, -0.016719691455364227, 0.007708719931542873, 0.03244241327047348, -0.019412975758314133, -0.02595340833067894, 0.01634817011654377, 0.015393005684018135, -0.00012521905591711402, -0.06291451305150986, 0.0012738906079903245, 0.023782499134540558, -0.012218170799314976, -0.021279137581586838, -0.022472549229860306, -0.028006214648485184, 0.013789081946015358, -0.0008223128388635814, 0.01641038805246353, 0.019894331693649292, 0.01664380356669426, -0.001898210379295051, -0.04071453958749771, 0.10880060493946075, -0.0011889130109921098, -0.014053985476493835, -0.03815840929746628, 0.01618272066116333, -0.018113940954208374, -0.018594207242131233, 0.060277700424194336, -0.0008824887918308377, 0.011903779581189156, -0.03713245317339897, 0.01717538759112358, 0.0324241928756237, -0.05629619210958481, 0.03926783800125122, -0.0018029395723715425, -0.042732495814561844, -0.0053628371097147465, -0.023576434701681137, 0.026039190590381622, 0.023513739928603172, -0.008935341611504555, -0.00958807673305273, 0.03330320119857788, -0.0016986625269055367, -0.01075052097439766, 0.05820050463080406, 0.022637441754341125, 0.006678894627839327, 0.014864915981888771, -0.026631051674485207, 0.013906807638704777, 0.03540193662047386, -0.015889491885900497, -0.02421777881681919, 0.03998774290084839, -0.040398068726062775, -0.04399080201983452, 0.0262482687830925, -0.0009376787929795682, -0.01495748944580555, -0.048677392303943634, 0.02211632765829563, 0.04193512722849846, -0.041526392102241516, 0.023721493780612946, 0.0336264930665493, -0.0059035480953752995, 0.056978292763233185, 0.007802258711308241, -0.002822499256581068, 0.03557935357093811, 0.018036456778645515, -0.012777812778949738, -0.013191142119467258, 0.03595063090324402, -0.01595555990934372, 0.024248864501714706, 0.04430212453007698, -0.022738855332136154, 0.02950448915362358, -0.016610493883490562, 0.042823273688554764, -0.048363275825977325, 0.010437770746648312, -0.013501281850039959, -0.02545277029275894, 0.011666922830045223, -0.004977654665708542, -0.0020666755735874176, 0.055554673075675964, -0.035144783556461334, -0.014585464261472225, -0.006847376935184002, 0.009804787114262581, -0.024550028145313263, -0.02126549929380417, -0.017814908176660538, 0.03679962083697319, 0.01679336279630661, 0.026532763615250587, 0.0073703583329916, -0.0011259462917223573, 0.03431418165564537, -0.035024769604206085, 0.03756527602672577, -0.0030686892569065094, -0.01751459762454033, -0.022552642971277237, 0.007023320998996496, -0.035672396421432495, -0.023063909262418747, -0.029267290607094765, 0.03636203333735466, 0.030863510444760323, -0.014563624747097492, -0.016019398346543312, -0.003352798754349351, 0.01874988153576851, -0.07605050504207611, 0.028972938656806946, -0.06208378076553345, 0.013498526066541672, -0.025464722886681557, 0.016870303079485893 ]
<p>I have a dataset (data1.csv) that contains some missing data ** . ** (missing at random), I am creating a subset from this dataset (d1) such that only complete observations are retained in d2. I am using the <strong>ftable</strong> , <strong>as.data.frame</strong> function and creating a column <strong>p</strong> that represent the percentage of each combination.</p> <pre><code> d1 = read.csv("C:/Users/....../Data1.csv",header=T) d1[d1=='.'] &lt;- NA d2=na.omit(d1) d3= ftable(d2) d4=as.data.frame(d3) d4$p </code></pre> <p>The function <strong>ftable</strong> , <strong>as.data.frame</strong> works fine but the problem is I still see missing data in my results (d4). I thought I got rid of this when i did </p> <pre><code> d1[d1=='.'] &lt;- NA d2=na.omit(d1) </code></pre> <p>So need help getting rid of missing values and doing frequency table only with complete observations</p>
74,194
[ -0.00809334684163332, 0.014868780970573425, 0.00767789501696825, 0.016120033338665962, 0.011507674120366573, 0.007489530369639397, 0.013791478238999844, -0.02922692708671093, 0.007543059531599283, -0.0074615185149014, 0.008615834638476372, 0.06544426828622818, 0.03608408197760582, -0.001577645423822105, 0.04551900923252106, -0.023132698610424995, -0.005571945570409298, 0.004111148416996002, -0.021127501502633095, -0.004486027639359236, -0.022247502580285072, 0.017021432518959045, 0.014643126167356968, -0.02069823443889618, 0.007752988953143358, 0.028699908405542374, 0.006001312751322985, -0.02205670066177845, 0.02875901572406292, 0.04563578963279724, -0.0866023600101471, -0.04941849783062935, 0.01189827173948288, 0.011396561749279499, 0.015631839632987976, -0.0015950732631608844, -0.041567835956811905, 0.012598256580531597, -0.008414504118263721, 0.02435135282576084, -0.016653915867209435, -0.0038289588410407305, -0.015647701919078827, 0.03778136894106865, 0.012050101533532143, 0.03208998218178749, 0.01841508224606514, 0.04159817472100258, 0.03825296834111214, -0.04618409276008606, 0.055610377341508865, -0.02745813876390457, 0.06453099101781845, 0.02728230319917202, -0.03502931445837021, 0.01611093245446682, 0.041537705808877945, 0.08446596562862396, 0.005449394229799509, -0.06202287599444389, -0.008105766028165817, -0.05678360536694527, 0.022874103859066963, -0.035584188997745514, -0.046251583844423294, 0.03137223422527313, -0.043350283056497574, -0.03727336972951889, 0.03809858113527298, -0.023544585332274437, 0.018595077097415924, -0.021892046555876732, 0.035090040415525436, -0.026690706610679626, -0.0029967764858156443, -0.044983215630054474, 0.017875004559755325, 0.024548044428229332, 0.0174460057169199, 0.008125836960971355, -0.021178394556045532, -0.012818361632525921, 0.02903038263320923, 0.005353366024792194, 0.02858765609562397, -0.013761157169938087, 0.05070570483803749, -0.028057517483830452, 0.019111119210720062, 0.02477242611348629, -0.02726633846759796, -0.01242203637957573, 0.040653109550476074, 0.05444058030843735, -0.010038524866104126, 0.004259396344423294, -0.007073591463267803, 0.02918134443461895, -0.013226792216300964, -0.016695410013198853, 0.01001705601811409, -0.023749662563204765, 0.037816304713487625, 0.043786730617284775, -0.059213846921920776, -0.03196138143539429, -0.050730351358652115, -0.011143756099045277, -0.006444407626986504, -0.009579617530107498, 0.0009720016387291253, 0.03591052442789078, 0.010411196388304234, -0.034418947994709015, 0.03660859912633896, -0.03785013407468796, 0.009492481127381325, 0.026715848594903946, 0.03935700282454491, 0.06548798084259033, 0.04210254177451134, -0.041708026081323624, 0.01539209671318531, -0.017515072599053383, -0.002978289034217596, 0.007947664707899094, -0.01579727604985237, -0.02985747531056404, -0.004040517378598452, 0.039392080157995224, -0.06858781725168228, -0.01875564455986023, 0.0626945048570633, 0.023334268480539322, 0.026665546000003815, -0.030961113050580025, -0.06945735961198807, -0.023035485297441483, 0.02237597294151783, -0.07787191867828369, -0.007728539872914553, -0.07487461715936661, 0.025607235729694366, -0.0014770528068765998, 0.04068383947014809, 0.03217198699712753, 0.019863136112689972, 0.029090536758303642, 0.011657970026135445, 0.03715371713042259, -0.026372713968157768, -0.013714601285755634, -0.027754880487918854, 0.004986753687262535, -0.05575308948755264, -0.05118928104639053, 0.029620954766869545, 0.025157280266284943, -0.005914325825870037, -0.008963296189904213, 0.04363102838397026, -0.008610136806964874, -0.020546693354845047, -0.011322892270982265, 0.026744406670331955, -0.03432334214448929, 0.05259104445576668, 0.008494464680552483, 0.048076339066028595, 0.03917369991540909, -0.025993889197707176, 0.0046638380736112595, 0.018310073763132095, 0.03387809172272682, 0.012711339630186558, -0.018318558111786842, -0.046049050986766815, -0.02830229513347149, 0.014737910591065884, 0.01609507016837597, -0.0032843570224940777, -0.013910740613937378, -0.008510569110512733, -0.006704728119075298, 0.02843782678246498, 0.036394570022821426, 0.054552145302295685, -0.05860314145684242, 0.03176698833703995, -0.027885735034942627, -0.05264933034777641, -0.06798373907804489, 0.012007366865873337, -0.000723629433196038, -0.05738500505685806, -0.00228632683865726, 0.012486726976931095, 0.01086253672838211, 0.031999632716178894, 0.0037976447492837906, -0.04057593271136284, -0.02095133066177368, 0.038683947175741196, -0.050759002566337585, -0.02999700978398323, 0.041827600449323654, 0.0469193272292614, -0.01982511393725872, 0.04151350259780884, -0.020327504724264145, -0.03909555450081825, 0.00518093490973115, -0.016870908439159393, -0.0052068643271923065, -0.021732192486524582, -0.0005405991687439382, 0.014037741348147392, 0.005565452855080366, -0.0320112444460392, 0.03674301132559776, -0.05576154962182045, 0.06870284676551819, 0.05222387611865997, -0.0016136571066454053, 0.005545180756598711, -0.024041403084993362, 0.014597326517105103, 0.019669590517878532, -0.033215612173080444, 0.0024726693518459797, -0.05532202497124672, 0.033214032649993896, 0.03941581770777702, -0.014634259976446629, -0.029838671907782555, 0.00187544128857553, 0.03672504797577858, -0.03816976398229599, 0.03357145935297012, 0.04199550673365593, -0.016306625679135323, -0.01601463556289673, 0.019681409001350403, 0.009295592084527016, -0.004662002436816692, 0.004102099221199751, -0.012229090556502342, 0.027053695172071457, 0.03954465687274933, 0.02367812767624855, 0.012857590802013874, 0.016538597643375397, 0.01907379925251007, 0.026192007586359978, -0.00619845325127244, -0.032621707767248154, 0.05228090658783913, -0.015405946411192417, -0.017315732315182686, 0.04661845415830612, 0.008425888605415821, -0.0032322602346539497, 0.013098479248583317, -0.024551674723625183, 0.012598956003785133, 0.053674351423978806, -0.01808033138513565, 0.0018559903837740421, 0.006708654575049877, -0.023149309679865837, 0.006678430363535881, -0.0252989511936903, -0.022986460477113724, -0.06566005200147629, 0.04787478223443031, 0.05433257669210434, 0.01475865300744772, 0.051694706082344055, -0.020578429102897644, -0.010635709390044212, -0.006752020213752985, -0.041095420718193054, 0.0016987017588689923, 0.019724730402231216, -0.042602699249982834, -0.023913828656077385, 0.016958516091108322, -0.013006063178181648, 0.02243514358997345, -0.014039267785847187, 0.002320029539987445, 0.04326774924993515, -0.01566002517938614, -0.03720845654606819, -0.015088442713022232, -0.02898627333343029, 0.04260675236582756, -0.025567341595888138, 0.0009290347225032747, 0.027186889201402664, 0.018597818911075592, -0.030178310349583626, -0.011998004280030727, -0.05072156712412834, -0.004670288413763046, -0.031278133392333984, -0.02274460345506668, 0.03011079505085945, -0.014387940987944603, -0.007139198482036591, 0.02365742437541485, -0.007010835688561201, 0.036874786019325256, -0.08996701240539551, -0.04671080783009529, 0.0386965312063694, 0.023587848991155624, -0.013371377252042294, 0.004489568527787924, -0.015878895297646523, 0.03289841488003731, 0.02833985909819603, -0.04330305755138397, -0.019053515046834946, -0.010767255909740925, -0.041061434894800186, -0.02280000038444996, 0.04042056202888489, -0.02669219858944416, 0.023877834901213646, -0.009475378319621086, -0.019998127594590187, -0.0015438903355970979, 0.022654728963971138, 0.05005202069878578, 0.007691951002925634, 0.00530244130641222, -0.004397410899400711, -0.010915224440395832, 0.03952224180102348, 0.012823151424527168, -0.0207828301936388, 0.024134507402777672, 0.0027436362579464912, 0.057076409459114075, -0.004467179533094168, -0.031975287944078445, -0.04613111540675163, 0.010828941129148006, 0.042230989784002304, -0.02008962631225586, 0.022535154595971107, 0.01102000568062067, -0.013236286118626595, 0.015404999256134033, 0.013920748606324196, 0.07794585078954697, -0.023802511394023895, -0.027559882029891014, 0.0764135792851448, 0.0029034947510808706, -0.02314482256770134, 0.025473875924944878, -0.03226600959897041, -0.012407743372023106, 0.002882867818698287, -0.03467145562171936, -0.023461734876036644, 0.02676505222916603, 0.04887847602367401, 0.04247051849961281, 0.010884509421885014, -0.015356069430708885, 0.04276929795742035, -0.036770544946193695, 0.032079245895147324, -0.03985413536429405, 0.0605490580201149, 0.00565576134249568, 0.03468194976449013, 0.034606728702783585, 0.02838706225156784, -0.012045043520629406, 0.02453119494020939, -0.08636871725320816, 0.008124690502882004, 0.031692471355199814, -0.010212038643658161, -0.02422683872282505, -0.06119013950228691, 0.006471552420407534, -0.02799273654818535, -0.0033750045113265514, 0.0002021452528424561, -0.020913047716021538, -0.023858755826950073, 0.022212885320186615, 0.02180417627096176, 0.05188997834920883, -0.011554784141480923, 0.019156627357006073, 0.028240004554390907, 0.01882125250995159, 0.02154398523271084, 0.046543534845113754, -0.020846696570515633, 0.00636447174474597, -0.03715810179710388, -0.01793903112411499, 0.03334800899028778, 0.04686905816197395, 0.024726741015911102, 0.0435313954949379, 0.0071519529446959496, 0.020344410091638565, -0.008633601479232311, 0.057910896837711334, 0.02244507148861885, 0.016367755830287933, -0.025586256757378578, -0.010557539761066437, -0.006438810843974352, -0.03371613472700119, 0.01874283142387867, -0.015324831940233707, 0.021699372678995132, 0.039332516491413116, 0.04344021901488304, -0.040569864213466644, 0.03159836307168007, 0.05397605895996094, 0.0344478078186512, 0.0027605986688286066, -0.02776225656270981, 0.04320883750915527, -0.023269008845090866, -0.020999232307076454, 0.059090036898851395, 0.0027714893221855164, -0.010015872307121754, 0.008719966746866703, 0.013504067435860634, -0.010237496346235275, -0.02387828938663006, 0.01748989149928093, -0.03679491579532623, 0.03556905314326286, -0.010535177774727345, -0.03388623148202896, 0.01038119476288557, 0.051013387739658356, 0.017660198733210564, 0.0026600630953907967, 0.01991244964301586, -0.10925121605396271, -0.00960504449903965, 0.05342217534780502, 0.054600607603788376, -0.032077357172966, -0.01851232722401619, -0.04516270011663437, -0.024077394977211952, 0.027653221040964127, -0.051351532340049744, 0.0021457963157445192, -0.02661377191543579, 0.002440019976347685, -0.0213550366461277, -0.013002868741750717, -0.03874337300658226, -0.0029919256921857595, -0.04853513464331627, 0.04497543349862099, 0.012559637427330017, -0.02663586288690567, -0.038995411247015, 0.007681778632104397, 0.012931949459016323, 0.060741279274225235, -0.02973848208785057, -0.061839114874601364, -0.004112041089683771, 0.011421696282923222, -0.0088713513687253, -0.026518622413277626, 0.030662884935736656, -0.02990027703344822, -0.01717490889132023, 0.03527854382991791, -0.040242306888103485, -0.0014836766058579087, 0.049875106662511826, 0.035580992698669434, 0.008284446783363819, -0.03870208561420441, -0.02077084593474865, -0.0009281121310777962, 0.001813952811062336, -0.017620457336306572, 0.06163553148508072, 0.009401834569871426, -0.011385428719222546, 0.010778297670185566, -0.04505232721567154, -0.0008074718061834574, 0.0024346986319869757, -0.008311441168189049, -0.068112812936306, -0.014221617951989174, -0.02382338047027588, -0.018833976238965988, 0.005023374687880278, 0.024544568732380867, -0.014935160987079144, -0.018943488597869873, 0.027063751593232155, 0.0431261844933033, 0.026837782934308052, 0.012985536828637123, -0.01210191659629345, 0.015586143359541893, -0.018591763451695442, -0.03258007764816284, 0.02900024503469467, -0.020413663238286972, -0.05416972562670708, 0.00757326977327466, -0.040551215410232544, 0.023947954177856445, -0.00032051699236035347, -0.032671332359313965, 0.029920006170868874, 0.00280710868537426, -0.018037499859929085, -0.012587683275341988, 0.09217070043087006, -0.020886249840259552, -0.0310446135699749, -0.022218147292733192, 0.04321644455194473, -0.013995952904224396, 0.019487526267766953, -0.032276734709739685, 0.06597178429365158, 0.007647169288247824, -0.006411226931959391, -0.07544700801372528, -0.07963921129703522, 0.01417629700154066, 0.027996264398097992, -0.053750332444906235, -0.053699638694524765, -0.026215123012661934, -0.010397957637906075, 0.0029852637089788914, -0.028902573511004448, 0.013300330378115177, 0.007281942293047905, 0.009568401612341404, 0.03902708739042282, -0.0042161354795098305, 0.05530931055545807, -0.00334170158021152, -0.016944102942943573, 0.018881963565945625, -0.013912119902670383, -0.012815805152058601, 0.0076585253700613976, -0.022504793480038643, -0.04309781268239021, -0.02514861710369587, -0.020177923142910004, 0.008877086453139782, 0.019647691398859024, 0.0004782211035490036, 0.026297153905034065, -0.021065887063741684, 0.021322274580597878, 0.035756949335336685, -0.05222811549901962, -0.0042607649229466915, -0.006214822642505169, 0.022170642390847206, -0.0011259634047746658, 0.023060720413923264, -0.005913977976888418, -0.014920872636139393, 0.008480680175125599, -0.037132784724235535, 0.011331501416862011, 0.00631218496710062, 0.06272108852863312, -0.00022692084894515574, 0.015282641164958477, -0.012963920831680298, -0.009172845631837845, 0.06511862576007843, 0.037426676601171494, 0.0034791231155395508, -0.015282945707440376, 0.03712188079953194, -0.03842827305197716, -0.0239406730979681, -0.011693115346133709, 0.014586379751563072, 0.03486061468720436, -0.024067316204309464, 0.005082253832370043, 0.0241757333278656, 0.028875118121504784, 0.0011618481948971748, -0.0019177709473297, -0.02657431550323963, -0.011678501963615417, 0.003055666107684374, 0.05422788858413696, 0.030845733359456062, -0.0048621781170368195, 0.039358966052532196, 0.012917233631014824, 0.029259394854307175, 0.04920657351613045, 0.031395088881254196, -0.003915688488632441, 0.011265596374869347, 0.002628304762765765, -0.017696037888526917, 0.005356902256608009, -0.04282308742403984, 0.011694016866385937, 0.0036133218090981245, -0.06380683183670044, 0.031019998714327812, 0.018845664337277412, 0.014657904393970966, -0.0053345877677202225, -0.0654732882976532, -0.025463519617915154, 0.008225316181778908, 0.017099982127547264, -0.022926608100533485, 0.054488666355609894, 0.008847439661622047, 0.0350230373442173, 0.018472978845238686, 0.03460991010069847, -0.032806526869535446, -0.04357721284031868, -0.019231781363487244, -0.03784047067165375, -0.023523693904280663, 0.05693427473306656, 0.003201217157766223, -0.023216646164655685, 0.026791466400027275, -0.01929713785648346, 0.04818706959486008, 0.03883766010403633, 0.056782521307468414, 0.002385420724749565, -0.005015410482883453, 0.028705088421702385, 0.041586827486753464, 0.004914216231554747, -0.00931964349001646, 0.104859359562397, 0.07610106468200684, 0.04024183750152588, -0.06640590727329254, -0.003878496354445815, 0.02354460582137108, -0.007993968203663826, -0.024702060967683792, -0.017400134354829788, 0.03877831995487213, 0.012176492251455784, 0.056806858628988266, 0.04707411676645279, -0.008486099541187286, 0.06339900195598602, 0.02865092270076275, -0.05086900293827057, -0.015343321487307549, 0.004775548353791237, 0.010179959237575531, -0.034286484122276306, -0.04632841423153877, -0.07522915303707123, -0.013317595236003399, 0.06723126769065857, -0.06293995678424835, -0.01827239990234375, 0.009820195846259594, -0.020609175786376, 0.023754382506012917, -0.022842440754175186, 0.03258754685521126, 0.006620909087359905, 0.00030233358847908676, 0.006975786294788122, 0.011105615645647049, 0.011485646478831768, -0.040466904640197754, -0.021127820014953613, -0.0029885643161833286, -0.008009711280465126, -0.0017545713344588876, -0.006865824107080698, 0.03332967683672905, -0.021364087238907814, -0.018270673230290413, -0.029260745272040367, 0.049216289073228836, -0.01216265931725502, -0.009169691242277622, 0.0010626284638419747, 0.018329553306102753, -0.011751108802855015, -0.05120634660124779, -0.026008056476712227, 0.01543039083480835, 0.03663427755236626, -0.011355245485901833, -0.0343322716653347, -0.011297574266791344, -0.0029619704000651836, -0.018376678228378296, 0.017814816907048225, 0.01640268601477146, -0.008257292211055756, -0.019343305379152298, -0.02134747803211212, 0.03390158712863922, 0.0038942075334489346, 0.003877926617860794, 0.039267685264348984, -0.011634423397481441, -0.030469605699181557, -0.02173062041401863, 0.034016214311122894, -0.013848229311406612, 0.02952747605741024, -0.03430452570319176, -0.0036080472636967897, 0.013486046344041824, -0.056704696267843246, 0.04915359616279602, -0.007479394320398569, -0.028365498408675194, -0.0330684557557106, -0.003052549669519067, 0.023581910878419876, 0.013569844886660576, 0.012408207170665264, 0.015318342484533787, -0.014206714928150177, 0.05141686648130417, 0.015469927340745926, -0.02770138531923294, -0.03660281375050545, 0.0009374921792186797, -0.01697458326816559, 0.009755031205713749, -0.009782876819372177, 0.07561090588569641, 0.0322391651570797, 0.029260912910103798, -0.01886744424700737, -0.005649660248309374, -0.00882094819098711, 0.011697307229042053, 0.013290481641888618, -0.04652179405093193, 0.005447911564260721, 0.0074853189289569855, -0.015104773454368114, -0.06167573481798172, -0.002157069044187665, -0.0662851557135582, 0.0012581453192979097, 0.0001797184522729367, -0.020515091717243195, -0.04976056516170502, 0.03024357371032238, 0.017060672864317894, -0.0016788617940619588, 0.0038717854768037796, -0.008073217235505581, -0.07026633620262146, -0.04273395612835884, -0.022435668855905533, 0.004215362016111612, -0.03093547746539116, 0.014060460031032562, -0.0336715430021286, -0.001786123844794929, 0.012425052002072334, -0.0039010357577353716, 0.009951725602149963, 0.007640393916517496, 0.027565836906433105, 0.016911976039409637, 0.038108643144369125, -0.00998381245881319, -0.006931845564395189, 0.024737337604165077, -0.05679991468787193, -0.050918567925691605, 0.011975894682109356, -0.01903250627219677, 0.04171983152627945, -0.010591291822493076, -0.02665868028998375, -0.019644521176815033, 0.08229616284370422, -0.02283775433897972, -0.03264489024877548, -0.042443424463272095, 0.01768852211534977, 0.008271071128547192, 0.01762617938220501, -0.05768053978681564, 0.024951210245490074, -0.03781820461153984, 0.008602054789662361, 0.0770326554775238, 0.02744898572564125, -0.00732911704108119, 0.005708261858671904, 0.024966582655906677, 0.03030255064368248, 0.020463144406676292, 0.013579300604760647, 0.02313162386417389, 0.05728990584611893, 0.017077676951885223, 0.025674523785710335, -0.014596142806112766, 0.02850732021033764, -0.10103186964988708, -0.04776743799448013, -0.020511498674750328, 0.026566920801997185, -0.0021744482219219208, -0.03830082342028618, 0.006506820674985647, 0.02299489639699459, -0.018132852390408516, 0.011732393875718117, -0.0036495081149041653, 0.03805932775139809, -0.03174019977450371, 0.0445266030728817, -0.026204518973827362, 0.005296790972352028, 0.0354483500123024, -0.007334116380661726, 0.027646541595458984, 0.012571481987833977, 0.015136390924453735, -0.0364203006029129, -0.043252650648355484, 0.008548777550458908, 0.023395638912916183, -0.07585495710372925, 0.03215784206986427, -0.013609755784273148, -0.034869544208049774, 0.010462978854775429, -0.023280823603272438, -0.022840358316898346, 0.02353634499013424, 0.03812683746218681, 0.018999429419636726, 0.03548451140522957, -0.02218577265739441, 0.029412906616926193, -0.029983842745423317, 0.006437128875404596, 0.006204974837601185, -0.0065909456461668015, -0.030729210004210472, 0.023003414273262024, 0.05767185613512993, -0.013299358077347279, -0.011608341708779335, 0.019418692216277122, -0.011650768108665943, 0.04237387329339981, 0.004511737264692783, 0.009430483914911747, 0.03523075953125954, -0.07640717923641205, -0.006212431006133556, -0.0136701799929142, -0.005841265898197889, 0.06800705939531326, 0.011738649569451809, 0.01525680348277092, 0.03600788488984108, -0.005430988501757383, -0.01810402050614357, -0.0064980387687683105, 0.022414308041334152, -0.012659713625907898, -0.02652318775653839, -0.020599056035280228, 0.03061782568693161, 0.00023798664915375412, 0.009905455633997917, -0.005963530857115984, -0.056299839168787, 0.0448838546872139, -0.030723903328180313, -0.010950709693133831, -0.0012656032340601087, -0.0025407306384295225, 0.012525529600679874, -0.09385178983211517, 0.043908651918172836, -0.02157418802380562, 0.0005162438028492033, -0.04875028505921364, 0.007947681471705437, -0.04799390211701393, 0.05078187212347984, 0.017963234335184097, 0.0013748122146353126, -0.007920819334685802, -0.009933375753462315, 0.032672151923179626, 0.029165875166654587, -0.017965519800782204, 0.060996875166893005, -0.00245048594661057, -0.015796387568116188, 0.016638604924082756, -0.013303868472576141, 0.0030986065976321697, -0.01452240813523531, -0.03485241159796715, -0.016937220469117165, 0.010351750999689102, 0.015242885798215866, -0.010053117759525776, 0.04207276180386543, -0.005225585773587227, 0.007834289222955704, 0.030849639326334, -0.023549780249595642, 0.0224950909614563, 0.07030769437551498, 0.008148389868438244, -0.02603280358016491, 0.04568684101104736, -0.0396915078163147, -0.021994903683662415, 0.008895862847566605, 0.015447973273694515, -0.01619664393365383, -0.018786508589982986, 0.01425266545265913, 0.007552950643002987, -0.017170174047350883, 0.049055855721235275, 0.012120897881686687, -0.007338771130889654, 0.04750242456793785, -0.007162430323660374, 0.007232797332108021, -0.014407956972718239, -0.035066429525613785, 0.04005756601691246, 0.03936794772744179, -0.0465482734143734, 0.003427938325330615, 0.018295859917998314, 0.021514611318707466, -0.0045250700786709785, -0.024482781067490578, -0.020401492714881897, 0.05642429739236832, -0.041666723787784576, -0.016301652416586876, -0.013056199066340923, -0.0022435043938457966, 0.014391542412340641, 0.001718154875561595, 0.00989232026040554, 0.01671583019196987, -0.04006292670965195, 0.05423411354422569, -0.01786707155406475, -0.045936599373817444, -0.020685583353042603, 0.010453290306031704, -0.011637181043624878, 0.04262895882129669, -0.04950214922428131, 0.021105729043483734, 0.007182922679930925, -0.028814800083637238, 0.02373085357248783, -0.030015654861927032, -0.01995931565761566, -0.059411488473415375, -0.004568580538034439, -0.02119147963821888, 0.010882445611059666, 0.00757974199950695, -0.015713654458522797, 0.0010736961849033833, 0.05594167485833168, -0.009905843995511532, -0.05697764456272125, 0.0010659696999937296, 0.017237866297364235, 0.005598938092589378, -0.07259145379066467, -0.02927199937403202, -0.005780426319688559, 0.042760588228702545, -0.023335998877882957, -0.02398647367954254 ]
<p>Consider 10 values that follow a standard normal distribution. What would you expect to be the lowest value?</p> <p>I tried to simulate this problem in R. I basically just simulated 100000 standard normal distribution with 10 values and took the mean of the each lowest value.</p> <pre><code>&gt; mean(replicate(100000,min(rnorm(10)))) [1] -1.536875 </code></pre> <p>This corresponds to a probability to get a lower value of </p> <pre><code>&gt; pnorm(-1.536875) [1] 0.06216196 </code></pre> <p>I tried to reach these values analytically but I really have no idea how to approach this.</p> <p>I thought about it for quite some time now and also tried to look it up. But I can't find a solutions to this simple problem. Probably just overlooking something obvious. Someone that can help me?</p>
36,920
[ -0.036036089062690735, -0.041171759366989136, -0.024872353300452232, -0.005993183236569166, 0.01639373041689396, -0.008064820431172848, 0.0006896152626723051, -0.022444669157266617, -0.010805422440171242, -0.02556884102523327, 0.014123394154012203, 0.06744982302188873, 0.010037501342594624, 0.007987933233380318, 0.05383054167032242, 0.015942271798849106, -0.042495034635066986, -0.01977257803082466, -0.01965828239917755, -0.02226043865084648, 0.013792679645121098, 0.011395571753382683, 0.0028734926600009203, 0.001360977184958756, -0.039085518568754196, 0.018568113446235657, 0.04223603010177612, -0.016755538061261177, -0.011257972568273544, 0.06409133970737457, -0.048227328807115555, -0.035593606531620026, 0.004328033421188593, 0.04389306157827377, 0.0049171666614711285, 0.014660045504570007, -0.005855041556060314, -0.010651865042746067, -0.023539310321211815, 0.02633429318666458, -0.02894439361989498, 0.011993233114480972, -0.010508719831705093, 0.01894170604646206, 0.001412553945556283, 0.0037279946263879538, 0.013321759179234505, -0.027607230469584465, 0.03058536909520626, -0.049836114048957825, 0.05907028168439865, 0.03080558031797409, 0.013423808850347996, 0.01712796278297901, -0.006335761863738298, -0.044154439121484756, 0.07668354362249374, 0.052432186901569366, -0.013138451613485813, -0.07785172015428543, 0.002716830000281334, -0.05061058700084686, -0.018184693530201912, 0.015645187348127365, -0.007263336330652237, -0.018912235274910927, -0.0099050123244524, -0.001155528356321156, 0.018840216100215912, -0.0031339030247181654, 0.024449707940220833, 0.03552931174635887, 0.029925690963864326, -0.006674638018012047, 0.05319225415587425, -0.011736921966075897, 0.024530572816729546, -0.0023041758686304092, 0.033824384212493896, 0.05307091772556305, 0.015658412128686905, -0.003725416725501418, 0.030492518097162247, 0.06552094221115112, 0.00837330985814333, -0.021557342261075974, 0.07304762303829193, -0.027475707232952118, 0.030658461153507233, 0.04183031618595123, -0.01530721690505743, 0.005328385625034571, 0.04530571028590202, 0.01400932390242815, -0.0640234723687172, 0.057134974747896194, 0.00020876171765848994, 0.03523330017924309, -0.015799233689904213, -0.010061357170343399, -0.026317158713936806, -0.07050469517707825, 0.042364221066236496, 0.05182136967778206, -0.043494146317243576, 0.009005791507661343, -0.03451725095510483, 0.003991964738816023, 0.0026414927560836077, 0.017545634880661964, -0.030049249529838562, -0.0076637836173176765, 0.003519547637552023, -0.010038121603429317, 0.009116905741393566, -0.025528792291879654, 0.011046912521123886, -0.02313014306128025, 0.018440231680870056, -0.00790472887456417, 0.03057916834950447, 0.0052665346302092075, 0.03185969963669777, -0.02937617339193821, -0.02955806627869606, 0.02030918002128601, 0.006964048836380243, 0.003547138534486294, -0.03722357749938965, 0.033880677074193954, -0.04334467276930809, -0.0045561231672763824, 0.05171714350581169, 0.018346982076764107, 0.05956583842635155, -0.028113197535276413, -0.09273266792297363, -0.054268207401037216, 0.03449324518442154, -0.03483593463897705, 0.008914127014577389, -0.06156943365931511, -0.003240018617361784, 0.01458862517029047, -0.02886800467967987, 0.026767617091536522, 0.04873424395918846, -0.016516458243131638, -0.008027566596865654, 0.0035433329176157713, 0.015187007375061512, 0.014493755996227264, -0.019337328150868416, -0.027982961386442184, -0.009939372539520264, -0.08782092481851578, 0.010015001520514488, -0.004127518739551306, -0.010322066955268383, -0.020500965416431427, -0.018134530633687973, -0.059804774820804596, -0.01637217588722706, -0.032123979181051254, 0.016258081421256065, -0.041105035692453384, 0.08473186194896698, 0.015357526950538158, 0.017439354211091995, 0.008979237638413906, -0.02960294485092163, 0.01863250695168972, -0.022961368784308434, 0.019783349707722664, 0.041880641132593155, -0.0311269648373127, 0.010069100186228752, -0.01982695981860161, 0.04916609823703766, 0.046297285705804825, -0.019132088869810104, 0.043460629880428314, -0.008187400177121162, -0.0033618637826293707, 0.023776499554514885, 0.0029334044083952904, -0.02016739547252655, -0.020151637494564056, 0.04477297514677048, -0.030138270929455757, -0.034408312290906906, -0.06607209891080856, -0.00983736477792263, 0.0217044185847044, -0.029473472386598587, 0.009171556681394577, 0.01774503104388714, 0.07007507979869843, -0.028339006006717682, 0.024652237072587013, -0.035573430359363556, -0.03909726440906525, 0.046266764402389526, -0.05219743400812149, -0.0021428305190056562, 0.08574261516332626, 0.04718497395515442, -0.027573738247156143, 0.05397135019302368, -0.02551957592368126, -0.027431292459368706, -0.026885956525802612, -0.016671758145093918, 0.023993179202079773, 0.025937974452972412, -0.034027349203825, 0.049735553562641144, -0.03334568068385124, -0.0016544279642403126, 0.032526224851608276, -0.05348663032054901, 0.04644596204161644, 0.08742626756429672, 0.01995273120701313, -0.025399062782526016, -0.02075173333287239, 0.006901635322719812, 0.01699940674006939, -0.010341079905629158, 0.002695512492209673, -0.04746786504983902, -0.010636037215590477, 0.03275216370820999, 0.020342739298939705, -0.03842272236943245, 0.004404264036566019, 0.055382613092660904, -0.008475523442029953, 0.05414539948105812, 0.051916077733039856, -0.012460536323487759, -0.00627209572121501, 0.002749459818005562, 0.028066281229257584, 0.05124441906809807, 0.027690282091498375, 0.023083552718162537, 0.008859437890350819, 0.031515251845121384, 0.006500485353171825, -0.027471013367176056, 0.03325860574841499, 0.004160019103437662, 0.04592171311378479, -0.01974969170987606, -0.016979701817035675, 0.022036803886294365, -0.02365684323012829, -0.005447519477456808, 0.023414868861436844, -0.006648606155067682, -0.007342155557125807, 0.006240352056920528, -0.029459046199917793, 0.00986556988209486, 0.048248305916786194, -0.016127606853842735, -0.005197721999138594, -0.0026794211007654667, 0.0050865537486970425, 0.01110004261136055, -0.03267291933298111, -0.02777200937271118, -0.038947656750679016, -0.0008727460517548025, 0.06337719410657883, -0.01463906280696392, -0.0131929786875844, -0.05199902504682541, -0.015540234744548798, -0.03272230178117752, 0.002929797861725092, -0.019356967881321907, 0.005324346479028463, -0.0517510287463665, -0.00694848969578743, 0.0059592933394014835, -0.036225415766239166, 0.016570979729294777, -0.005382284987717867, -0.0008318774634972215, 0.03007635474205017, -0.019580360502004623, -0.02413446456193924, -0.01154907327145338, -0.027847807854413986, 0.0002862836990971118, -0.03714242950081825, -0.005883016623556614, 0.07505761831998825, 0.023764850571751595, -0.022752122953534126, 0.03818662464618683, -0.038677703589200974, -0.04813801497220993, -0.045032430440187454, -0.02111109532415867, 0.018687939271330833, -0.0176650732755661, -0.0064336820505559444, -0.006498291157186031, 0.0059254649095237255, 0.00553163792937994, -0.051077622920274734, -0.06724274903535843, 0.008741315454244614, -0.011958817951381207, 0.03246355056762695, 0.030598631128668785, -0.015878450125455856, 0.09598033130168915, 0.02450818568468094, -0.012872901745140553, -0.04397641867399216, -0.005978070665150881, 0.008172709494829178, -0.020622458308935165, 0.013382114470005035, 0.049932509660720825, -0.01465662382543087, 0.015578522346913815, -0.005413027945905924, 0.019651466980576515, 0.045877229422330856, 0.0009429101482965052, -0.02754719741642475, 0.03598756715655327, -0.029047278687357903, -0.007227363996207714, 0.06075125187635422, -0.004593417979776859, -0.00583101250231266, 0.03850770741701126, -0.01333534438163042, 0.04993947222828865, -0.020704833790659904, -0.03421857953071594, 0.05229635536670685, -0.0013241588603705168, 0.016113348305225372, -0.025218751281499863, 0.02244829200208187, 0.014602839946746826, -0.05005710572004318, 0.011868922039866447, 0.007291813381016254, 0.03072534315288067, -0.03138412535190582, -0.02783558890223503, 0.03528698906302452, 0.04574175924062729, -0.033548902720212936, 0.0014444396365433931, -0.013177221640944481, -0.011673296801745892, 0.014815161935985088, -0.015314381569623947, -0.011580098420381546, 0.0748792290687561, 0.053440291434526443, 0.03128352761268616, 0.015478190034627914, -0.044857680797576904, 0.036391910165548325, -0.053645048290491104, 0.001716591534204781, 0.0004315382393542677, 0.05176039785146713, 0.005549212452024221, 0.018118595704436302, 0.04356525093317032, -0.004725127015262842, 0.010844049975275993, 0.008157492615282536, -0.07100207358598709, 0.06055860221385956, 0.004136000294238329, 0.004929175600409508, -0.024302441626787186, -0.03595850244164467, 0.0252381581813097, -0.0073652733117341995, 0.049580298364162445, -0.007105913013219833, 0.044819507747888565, -0.016521533951163292, -0.014850626699626446, 0.004240446258336306, -0.0017114054644480348, -0.017688456922769547, 0.012468965724110603, 0.022652750834822655, 0.02070501446723938, 0.011448627337813377, -0.006396301090717316, -0.02468034438788891, -0.015827981755137444, -0.018814118579030037, -0.005115767475217581, -0.0034779971465468407, 0.0323890782892704, 0.01990303210914135, 0.03184989094734192, -0.03371720016002655, 0.01544542983174324, -0.015762202441692352, 0.049164045602083206, 0.05092371627688408, 0.003927778452634811, -0.018643422052264214, -0.03304952010512352, -0.014486203901469707, 0.010640565305948257, -0.023851562291383743, -0.030202016234397888, 0.030068837106227875, 0.058797236531972885, -0.011171821504831314, -0.06868899613618851, 0.03267520293593407, 0.04376032203435898, 0.009777317754924297, -0.0061821481212973595, -0.03417057916522026, -0.04435490071773529, -0.025808868929743767, 0.027357956394553185, 0.046007778495550156, 0.015811961144208908, 0.0021123767364770174, -0.00805598683655262, 0.05667855963110924, -0.023846078664064407, -0.028307346627116203, -0.015865914523601532, -0.020918559283018112, 0.0511452816426754, -0.027667058631777763, -0.004421430639922619, 0.03587732091546059, 0.02329178899526596, 0.02106357179582119, 0.004038642160594463, -0.0007018037722446024, -0.06291895359754562, 0.0023396320175379515, 0.060675568878650665, 0.04503409191966057, -0.012765500694513321, -0.012685510329902172, -0.054962191730737686, -0.011778965592384338, 0.014139662496745586, -0.06375256925821304, 0.00982504989951849, 0.004740118980407715, -0.002898761071264744, -0.008734332397580147, -0.027668913826346397, -0.022630583494901657, 0.029671762138605118, -0.023482367396354675, 0.041946105659008026, -0.014062128029763699, -0.010342334397137165, -0.058010268956422806, 0.011886844411492348, 0.01696511171758175, 0.09074470400810242, -0.03329583629965782, -0.0016908709658309817, 0.015538720414042473, -0.0033855969086289406, 0.012203002348542213, -0.07103316485881805, 0.025983773171901703, -0.018792064860463142, -0.019722504541277885, 0.054937947541475296, -0.0242703165858984, -0.03472895920276642, 0.034764230251312256, 0.03150612488389015, -0.013062722980976105, 0.0014629772631451488, -0.017324119806289673, 0.023228472098708153, 0.06156948581337929, -0.006214703433215618, 0.028121398761868477, -0.012142745777964592, -0.03371063992381096, -0.0433305948972702, -0.03043695166707039, 0.027395058423280716, -0.0064858440309762955, -0.016365734860301018, -0.06704744696617126, -0.020675325766205788, 0.01147379819303751, 0.06176353245973587, 0.01401614211499691, 0.025817573070526123, 0.008839031681418419, -0.007662027608603239, 0.0183874424546957, 0.013772149570286274, 0.031048167496919632, -0.007695270236581564, 0.0006201289361342788, 0.011109908111393452, -0.011003788560628891, -0.00015385349979624152, 0.0111579280346632, -0.010074292309582233, 0.014297042973339558, 0.025152113288640976, -0.05734239146113396, 0.0066848741844296455, -0.051103055477142334, -0.033367522060871124, 0.014073116704821587, -0.043803855776786804, 0.03977683186531067, 0.009653731249272823, 0.019840344786643982, 0.04079386219382286, -0.022142425179481506, -0.004696017596870661, 0.02879634127020836, -0.003427576506510377, 0.019081443548202515, -0.03554518148303032, 0.06767548620700836, 0.00987496878951788, 0.01367085799574852, -0.055926091969013214, -0.031069185584783554, 0.01622370444238186, 0.009821540676057339, -0.0071227941662073135, -0.042669620364904404, -0.04462355747818947, -0.009533767588436604, -0.011888970620930195, 0.0024058951530605555, 0.040650416165590286, -0.02167503349483013, 0.021550292149186134, -0.03785104677081108, -0.008778312243521214, 0.1000208631157875, -0.027780314907431602, -0.02720736898481846, 0.08365500718355179, -0.01300500612705946, -0.005754718091338873, -0.0018914720276370645, 0.05935308709740639, -0.04530753195285797, 0.010009008459746838, -0.013463271781802177, -0.00104330584872514, 0.06866389513015747, -0.013691281899809837, -0.019173158332705498, -0.005004448350518942, 0.01018266100436449, 0.017737416550517082, -0.039878636598587036, 0.005578794050961733, -0.016435040161013603, 0.017098551616072655, -0.015625324100255966, 0.0128758130595088, -0.017834654077887535, 0.00018499877478461713, 0.0362037792801857, 0.020672939717769623, 0.0030570202507078648, 0.011195898056030273, 0.09168927371501923, -0.027204276993870735, 0.008748925291001797, -0.026307418942451477, -0.01926846243441105, 0.004679171368479729, 0.03194409981369972, -0.025189371779561043, 0.02345779724419117, 0.013629117980599403, -0.03786502033472061, -0.027916450053453445, -0.056941647082567215, 0.001460753264836967, 0.013808648101985455, 0.007973168045282364, 0.04241235554218292, 0.02856380306184292, -0.016490565612912178, -0.004671627189964056, -0.021204622462391853, -0.002745887031778693, -0.015181423164904118, 0.030728593468666077, 0.03575301542878151, -0.01830957643687725, 0.01584066078066826, 0.04389461874961853, 0.009675411507487297, 0.04298260807991028, 0.055006250739097595, 0.043153222650289536, -0.001964368624612689, 0.00968101155012846, -0.04241158440709114, -0.007332599721848965, 0.00847314391285181, -0.03866942226886749, 0.040601640939712524, -0.014904575422406197, 0.0010063443332910538, 0.02758246846497059, -0.0066067068837583065, 0.03037220425903797, -0.014919990673661232, -0.015150847844779491, -0.01431681215763092, -0.0017626548651605844, 0.037965357303619385, -0.02594785951077938, 0.013887902721762657, 0.018105914816260338, 0.032254062592983246, 0.002215375890955329, 0.025498341768980026, -0.009134012274444103, -0.03933456167578697, -0.04277266934514046, -0.005193970166146755, -0.03536904230713844, 0.01615912839770317, 0.023142093792557716, -0.0046201832592487335, 0.02053997851908207, -0.05732712522149086, 0.012839589267969131, -0.016574863344430923, 0.025163261219859123, -0.02475922554731369, 0.0779334306716919, 0.05486183986067772, 0.029659602791070938, -0.0030488474294543266, -0.027624132111668587, 0.11747395247220993, 0.06108564883470535, 0.030725833028554916, -0.05336209759116173, -0.003930662292987108, -0.016075804829597473, 0.005174655932933092, 0.021601326763629913, -0.012127161026000977, 0.03266439586877823, 0.0045935832895338535, 0.03440816327929497, 0.016584407538175583, 0.008337547071278095, 0.003914474975317717, 0.029200203716754913, -0.05949977785348892, -0.03178413212299347, -0.02460665814578533, 0.015378992073237896, -0.011212858371436596, -0.046697184443473816, -0.0380387045443058, 0.07008254528045654, 0.0062864432111382484, -0.03132026642560959, -0.04748076945543289, -0.0018478368874639273, -0.010944873094558716, -0.02232440561056137, 0.003924074117094278, 0.02113671787083149, 0.01992497406899929, -0.0356135331094265, 0.01076832227408886, 0.018673846498131752, 0.02581527829170227, -0.013423520140349865, 0.01843436062335968, 0.016948435455560684, -0.019512351602315903, 0.007876168936491013, -0.00828968919813633, 0.008033767342567444, -0.024003740400075912, -0.04650764912366867, -0.021148785948753357, 0.05282774567604065, -0.025115616619586945, -0.013102566823363304, -0.011352982372045517, 0.010305210016667843, -0.02815215103328228, -0.03015880472958088, -0.010922259651124477, 0.04080607742071152, 0.050742533057928085, 0.0037310216575860977, -0.01183173805475235, 0.005590265616774559, 0.01748686470091343, -0.021131543442606926, 0.02787776291370392, 0.032797858119010925, -0.012716534547507763, -0.02892935276031494, -0.03680168464779854, 0.028205478563904762, -0.026913858950138092, 0.019109072163701057, -0.0011884199921041727, -0.0025026702787727118, -0.01730559766292572, -0.027190132066607475, 0.027974892407655716, -0.03245034068822861, 0.022436507046222687, 0.014217551797628403, 0.01231465581804514, -0.02756538987159729, -0.00843810010701418, 0.017658043652772903, -0.01259857788681984, 0.00613443274050951, -0.0073924437165260315, -0.024088608101010323, -0.021828535944223404, 0.05972547456622124, 0.028856223449110985, 0.009158391505479813, 0.015584277920424938, 0.05541703850030899, 0.008042761124670506, -0.005345765966922045, -0.010132770985364914, 0.037981923669576645, -0.026364991441369057, 0.018718574196100235, 0.030234113335609436, 0.07274940609931946, -0.00039849363383837044, -0.007996741682291031, 0.01398080587387085, 0.02751118876039982, -0.01949782855808735, -0.021091939881443977, -0.007315400987863541, -0.0625981017947197, 0.02045278623700142, 0.030017269775271416, 0.01151540782302618, -0.017884796485304832, -0.011573792435228825, 0.011375637724995613, -0.04038693383336067, 0.023977242410182953, 0.013226627372205257, 0.025180960074067116, 0.007172697689384222, -0.006237977650016546, -0.021291619166731834, 0.005739076994359493, -0.014918306842446327, -0.026989338919520378, -0.023206621408462524, -0.018380027264356613, -0.02014313079416752, -0.029820457100868225, 0.01638345792889595, 0.028212983161211014, 0.011009449139237404, 0.028414348140358925, -0.0020091552287340164, 0.01613832637667656, -0.02687455713748932, 0.024143319576978683, 0.011367376893758774, 0.025523614138364792, -0.04451415315270424, -0.06261338293552399, 0.024434836581349373, -0.05437778681516647, -0.04798799753189087, 0.016596520319581032, 0.02480228617787361, 0.01839023269712925, -0.0038403919897973537, -0.01947980932891369, -0.013857904821634293, 0.04644925147294998, -0.01657586731016636, -0.035128071904182434, -0.00779153686016798, 0.001593742286786437, 0.03944909945130348, -0.007994971238076687, 0.01099934708327055, -0.008786218240857124, 0.013889562338590622, 0.006780937314033508, 0.02732066996395588, -0.019541200250387192, -0.0069035692140460014, 0.027559146285057068, 0.034769851714372635, 0.010542003437876701, -0.013956560753285885, 0.013558141887187958, -0.022076120600104332, 0.018868396058678627, -0.019713249057531357, 0.0451493114233017, -0.07405619323253632, -0.008872454054653645, -0.09100686013698578, -0.036836765706539154, 0.027394426986575127, -0.06462089717388153, 0.058354657143354416, -0.07648125290870667, -0.023801440373063087, 0.03235722705721855, -0.02503702975809574, 0.02153288759291172, -0.015219462104141712, -0.018940672278404236, -0.01703590527176857, 0.014974773861467838, -0.03069884330034256, 0.04934938997030258, 0.007965104654431343, 0.039859589189291, 0.04552353546023369, 0.007642405107617378, 0.026133695617318153, -0.043351974338293076, -0.01182200014591217, 0.03730868175625801, 0.011948945932090282, -0.038032982498407364, 0.0266242828220129, -0.05258619412779808, -0.024490639567375183, 0.04044163599610329, -0.008257352747023106, -0.0035872962325811386, 0.003506012726575136, 0.004510920494794846, -0.013354668393731117, 0.08866576105356216, 0.029667934402823448, 0.011337004601955414, -0.022419467568397522, 0.03797075152397156, 0.02901022508740425, -0.0029241801239550114, -0.008700872771441936, 0.0010868767276406288, 0.023173950612545013, 0.005011021625250578, -0.02339840866625309, 0.025881433859467506, -0.01759466901421547, -0.011509952135384083, -0.0075022089295089245, -0.008176879957318306, 0.016933368518948555, -0.05843830853700638, -0.002730799373239279, 0.0027901206631213427, -0.006692672614008188, 0.06438974291086197, 0.037497423589229584, -0.020424077287316322, 0.008905786089599133, -0.05190986767411232, -0.030860992148518562, -0.007812353316694498, 0.023238247260451317, -0.007864432409405708, -0.046148329973220825, -0.022231075912714005, -0.033830009400844574, 0.007312342990189791, -0.008671823889017105, -0.006985143758356571, -0.06375569850206375, 0.023876633495092392, -0.010202020406723022, 0.03630420193076134, -0.00942730251699686, -0.021373074501752853, 0.015397627837955952, -0.08613156527280807, 0.03700364753603935, -0.018766725435853004, 0.01382987480610609, -0.042209379374980927, -0.02741817571222782, -0.04580771178007126, 0.008832095190882683, 0.04631646350026131, 0.03734637424349785, -0.026665372774004936, -0.017437634989619255, 0.017224540933966637, 0.023827629163861275, -0.07771747559309006, 0.02676522731781006, -0.025004396215081215, -0.04464426264166832, -0.021013563498854637, -0.005850521847605705, 0.02812746725976467, -0.022773535922169685, -0.024568526074290276, 0.003606613725423813, -0.037489548325538635, -0.007703056558966637, 0.03158075362443924, 0.04408111795783043, -0.006392409559339285, 0.004139814525842667, 0.04533964395523071, 0.0036768224090337753, -0.0031415086705237627, 0.008297893218696117, 0.0214509516954422, -0.026844291016459465, 0.0567607507109642, -0.05120997130870819, -0.05128975585103035, 0.007861971855163574, -0.006620011758059263, 0.03155583515763283, -0.047847576439380646, -0.0384918749332428, 0.0275940652936697, -0.03676891699433327, -0.01196579821407795, 0.02553677186369896, 0.013380656018853188, 0.03741108998656273, 0.021444274112582207, 0.018873803317546844, -0.04199203476309776, 0.006651376374065876, 0.0028206531424075365, -0.027018774300813675, -0.010724480263888836, -0.02734352834522724, 0.02184845320880413, 0.011706412769854069, -0.04622495546936989, 0.03923813998699188, -0.006156901828944683, 0.058417998254299164, -0.011669875122606754, -0.025600671768188477, 0.016756296157836914, 0.007742169313132763, -0.011276822537183762, -0.020328469574451447, 0.00511293625459075, 0.03794291615486145, -0.030978845432400703, 0.0016010539839044213, -0.053479474037885666, -0.0027526081539690495, -0.03598819300532341, 0.02027279883623123, 0.004124649800360203, 0.009462065063416958, -0.013058161363005638, 0.010082856751978397, 0.015776420012116432, 0.05147407948970795, 0.05120561644434929, 0.012174167670309544, 0.035674262791872025, -0.034774795174598694, -0.0011844562832266092, -0.009717711247503757, -0.020644260570406914, -0.036033760756254196, -0.02939520590007305, -0.005748348776251078, 0.020203717052936554, 0.032105401158332825, 0.01987253874540329, -0.02098485454916954, 0.011613667011260986, 0.03588243946433067, -0.04249226674437523, -0.026876607909798622, -0.08522157371044159, 0.01099722646176815, -0.030257554724812508, -0.026457512751221657 ]
<p>Training data with $p$ =11 predictors and $n$ =165 with 4-class problem was cross-validated (5 times repeated 10-fold CV) using the sparse LDA (aka SDA) using <code>caret</code> package. This model is a regularized version of LDA with two tuning parameters: <em>lasso</em> using $\ell_{1}$ penalty and ridge using the $\ell_{2}$ penalty. The former will eliminate unimportant predictors and hence provide <em>feature selection</em>, a desired effect, while ridge will shrink the discriminant coefficients towards zero.<br> In <code>caret</code> one can tune over the no of predictors to retain <em>instead</em> of defined values for $\ell_{1}$ penalty. The ridge can also be tuned in the model and given the name <code>lambda</code> in the figure below. When looking to the documentation of <code>sparseLDA</code> package, I found that ridge or <code>lambda</code> has a default value of 1e-6. I couldn't find any clue about how wide the tune range could be.<br> Anyway, empirical values were passed for <code>lambda</code> as in the code below between (0 to 100).<img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/GrStW.png" alt="enter image description here"> </p> <pre><code>ctrl &lt;- trainControl(method = "repeatedcv", repeats = 5, number = 10, verbose = TRUE, classProbs = TRUE) sparseLDAGridx &lt;- expand.grid(.NumVars = c(1:11), .lambda = c(0, 0.01, .1, 1, 10, 100)) set.seed(1) # to have reproducible results spldaFitvacRedx &lt;- train(Class ~ ., data = training, method = "sparseLDA", tuneGrid = sparseLDAGridx, trControl = ctrl, metric = "Accuracy", # not needed it is so by default importance=TRUE, preProc = c("center", "scale")) </code></pre> <p>As shown in the figure, the best ridge was 100 (I am sure it can take on higher values had been passed), and the important predictors are 8. I rant out of ways to know which 8 predictors of the 11 they were. For example: </p> <p>I ran this code on <code>$finalModel</code> I got this: </p> <pre><code>&gt; spldaFitvacRedx$finalModel Call: sda.default(x = x, y = y, lambda = param$lambda, stop = -param$NumVars, importance = TRUE) lambda = 100 stop = 8 variables classes = H, P, R, Q Top 5 predictors (out of 11): IL12A, EBI3, IL12RB1, IL23R, IL12B </code></pre> <p>If I run the <code>$bestTune</code>:</p> <pre><code>&gt; spldaFitvacRedx$bestTune NumVars lambda 48 8 100 </code></pre> <p>If I run <code>varImp()</code>: </p> <pre><code>&gt; varImp(spldaFitvacRedx) ROC curve variable importance variables are sorted by average importance across the classes H P R Q IL12RB1 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 IL23A 100.00 0.00 99.05 100.00 IL12RB2 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 IL12B 100.00 85.71 97.14 100.00 IL23R 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 EBI3 100.00 96.43 98.10 100.00 IL8 100.00 100.00 91.43 100.00 IL6ST 100.00 100.00 99.05 100.00 IL17A 100.00 73.48 97.14 100.00 IL12A 100.00 42.86 100.00 100.00 IL27RA 99.29 92.86 98.10 99.29 </code></pre> <p>The last output is puzzling, I didn't ask for ROC, so that's must be an irrelevant output. The 11 predictors if were really sorted as said in the output across the 4 classes then IL23A cannot be at any rate the second one while more average values other predictors have (e.g., IL12RB2 and IL23R). </p> <p><strong>Questions:</strong> </p> <ol> <li>How to interpret this figure which refers to more important number of predictors as the ridge would be increased. In other words, why do more important predictors appear as we increase the ridge penalty? </li> <li>What is our clue to the range of ridge values to be tuned? what is the highest limit? </li> <li>In <code>caret</code> package, how can one know <em>which are</em> the most important predictors here? </li> </ol> <p><strong>Note:</strong><br> The 11 predictors are gene expression data of 11 genes. They are by nature correlated $ r $ was not above 0.9. </p> <p><strong>Update</strong><br> According to the answer below, I couldn't get 8 but rather all of the 11 predictors so what to do now? really puzzled.</p> <pre><code>set.seed(1) # important to have reproducible results SDAobj &lt;- train(Class ~ ., data = training, method = "sparseLDA", tuneGrid = data.frame(NumVars = 8, lambda = 100), preProc = c("center", "scale"), trControl = trainControl(method = "cv")) &gt; SDAobj$finalModel$xNames[SDAobj$finalModel$varIndex] [1] "IL8" "IL17A" "IL23A" "IL23R" "EBI3" [6] "IL6ST" "IL12A" "IL12RB2" "IL12B" "IL12RB1" [11] "IL27RA" &gt; SDAobj$finalModel$varIndex [1] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 </code></pre> <p>I tried on iris data, the same problem it returned all the 4 variables instead of 3, no feature selection was obtained: </p> <pre><code>data(iris) set.seed(1) obj &lt;- train(iris[,-5], iris$Species, method = "sparseLDA", tuneGrid = data.frame(NumVars = 3, lambda = 1), preProc = c("center", "scale"), trControl = trainControl(method = "cv")) &gt; obj$finalModel$xNames[obj$finalModel$varIndex] [1] "Sepal.Length" "Sepal.Width" "Petal.Length" [4] "Petal.Width" </code></pre> <p>Now trying the <code>Sonar</code> data, it was successful (10 were selected out of 60 predictors): </p> <pre><code>library(mlbench) data(Sonar) set.seed(1) obj &lt;- train(Class~., data = Sonar, method = "sparseLDA", tuneGrid = data.frame(NumVars = 10, lambda = 1), preProc = c("center", "scale"), trControl = trainControl(method = "cv")) &gt; obj$finalModel$xNames[obj$finalModel$varIndex] [1] "V4" "V11" "V12" "V21" "V22" "V36" "V44" "V45" [9] "V49" "V52" </code></pre> <p><strong>Question:</strong><br> My data and <code>iris</code> are more than 2 classes, <code>mdrr</code> and <code>Sonar</code> are 2-class problems. Most likely the problem is there, can you please help to fix this phenomenon? really appreciate that. </p>
74,195
[ -0.018162338063120842, 0.004511160776019096, 0.033769816160202026, 0.008985877968370914, 0.018532397225499153, -0.014247125014662743, -0.05152470991015434, -0.034747008234262466, 0.02730657532811165, -0.03368035703897476, 0.04653673246502876, 0.022865138947963715, 0.03144275024533272, 0.04423961788415909, 0.0028279379475861788, 0.009787711314857006, -0.028953421860933304, 0.012553134001791477, -0.011135916225612164, -0.0016037673922255635, -0.005957125220447779, 0.0009798684623092413, -0.015887729823589325, -0.004064288921654224, 0.016141189262270927, 0.016766991466283798, 0.007844864390790462, -0.005984242539852858, -0.004108111374080181, 0.04844781383872032, -0.05679096654057503, -0.001799679477699101, -0.004676472395658493, 0.030232252553105354, 0.007040655706077814, 0.01805921085178852, -0.00005279770994093269, -0.0193183533847332, 0.0058777714148163795, 0.031849462538957596, 0.03695148974657059, -0.017631489783525467, -0.01732110232114792, 0.07486191391944885, 0.005009477958083153, 0.04657876864075661, -0.016139725223183632, -0.03414454311132431, 0.06411013752222061, -0.022582409903407097, 0.05973675847053528, 0.02009495347738266, 0.04618535190820694, 0.03677338734269142, -0.0076516252011060715, -0.010607085190713406, 0.02513789013028145, 0.06504595279693604, -0.0006790641928091645, -0.06184522062540054, -0.038606636226177216, -0.03637286648154259, 0.030916035175323486, -0.0017894222401082516, -0.021728843450546265, -0.003011605003848672, 0.02498214691877365, -0.0007418043096549809, 0.01554673071950674, -0.03221824765205383, 0.014333543367683887, -0.012145170010626316, 0.021167708560824394, -0.02415892668068409, 0.04008631408214569, -0.006106019020080566, -0.03749382495880127, 0.01674627885222435, 0.02782921865582466, 0.012803849764168262, 0.023665841668844223, 0.03793914243578911, -0.005901882890611887, 0.0035240205470472574, 0.024217955768108368, 0.015409433282911777, 0.05109084025025368, 0.0044348887167871, 0.03397069126367569, 0.014452677220106125, 0.014985756017267704, 0.01993795856833458, 0.02777051366865635, 0.021416058763861656, -0.017621280625462532, 0.04971201345324516, 0.02685457281768322, 0.007195456884801388, -0.0004812241531908512, -0.029434984549880028, -0.013994869776070118, -0.007705643307417631, -0.039999060332775116, 0.06474730372428894, -0.041152223944664, -0.020754743367433548, -0.03567865863442421, -0.02404152788221836, -0.025411879643797874, -0.006819295696914196, 0.002404524013400078, 0.006186811253428459, 0.017569292336702347, -0.054622896015644073, 0.00158996123354882, -0.00009523246990283951, -0.0014166884357109666, 0.0002641328901518136, 0.027683567255735397, 0.06864175945520401, 0.018154283985495567, -0.04505240544676781, 0.028857892379164696, -0.02011675387620926, -0.032002680003643036, 0.0024548389483243227, 0.054046403616666794, -0.005696328356862068, -0.01770186610519886, 0.05551401525735855, -0.016990214586257935, -0.02369169145822525, 0.05090774595737457, 0.017732681706547737, -0.009398536756634712, 0.004056605976074934, -0.0666053518652916, -0.03974281623959541, 0.040238428860902786, -0.007900295779109001, 0.013955563306808472, -0.04515288397669792, -0.03387163579463959, -0.0008099577389657497, 0.041479095816612244, 0.014014174230396748, 0.026437053456902504, 0.02642970159649849, 0.006744780112057924, -0.01227225735783577, -0.0006153648137114942, 0.00029848163831047714, -0.044237107038497925, -0.002066045068204403, -0.05537974834442139, -0.06174604222178459, -0.009916877374053001, -0.0002520240086596459, -0.0389273576438427, 0.01865883730351925, 0.030699143186211586, -0.009404750540852547, -0.014054879546165466, -0.005715276580303907, -0.014583722688257694, -0.013360579498112202, 0.012482528574764729, 0.030228421092033386, 0.012275119312107563, 0.0399816557765007, -0.06457886099815369, -0.0020690220408141613, 0.01421059388667345, 0.03067781776189804, 0.03996730223298073, 0.0179219339042902, 0.01705261692404747, -0.05367244780063629, 0.009878121316432953, 0.023700496181845665, -0.02641460672020912, -0.037730127573013306, -0.006483492441475391, 0.000961905054282397, 0.008035599254071712, 0.029781116172671318, -0.02669505774974823, -0.0007214475190266967, 0.026720300316810608, -0.001931395148858428, -0.06316015869379044, -0.008721322752535343, 0.009198802523314953, 0.03264699503779411, -0.044974226504564285, 0.014730858616530895, -0.006369829177856445, 0.002848472911864519, 0.02939535863697529, -0.02348671481013298, -0.02817385084927082, 0.005948444362729788, 0.03834211453795433, 0.009787247516214848, -0.0038663148880004883, 0.042010530829429626, 0.028080105781555176, -0.026451069861650467, 0.0706055760383606, -0.037234507501125336, -0.0531056672334671, 0.012058151885867119, -0.015780869871377945, 0.017314787954092026, -0.024383477866649628, -0.003933693747967482, 0.011354031972587109, 0.0008675832068547606, -0.023435527458786964, 0.05950833857059479, -0.059301916509866714, 0.01100834645330906, 0.047528691589832306, 0.005587252322584391, 0.02194518782198429, -0.004508347250521183, -0.023019354790449142, 0.03250986710190773, -0.07526571303606033, -0.02613089419901371, -0.03455252945423126, -0.055933643132448196, 0.05992870777845383, 0.04160996899008751, -0.019489383324980736, 0.019155416637659073, 0.0665254145860672, 0.03239137679338455, 0.05273981764912605, 0.030668415129184723, -0.015064372681081295, -0.038688577711582184, -0.0020071379840373993, 0.024626486003398895, -0.014397460967302322, -0.004230836872011423, 0.004679858684539795, 0.008126560598611832, 0.06948518753051758, 0.03673790022730827, -0.005669437814503908, 0.0402410626411438, 0.009028318338096142, -0.014116276986896992, -0.02623077481985092, -0.019555935636162758, 0.039329882711172104, 0.023138614371418953, 0.005187845788896084, 0.09102492034435272, 0.01074341218918562, 0.0340835303068161, -0.012443287298083305, -0.0030743172392249107, 0.011988596059381962, 0.04806869849562645, 0.010418912395834923, -0.0072476062923669815, 0.01667526364326477, -0.06622247397899628, 0.044554371386766434, -0.010242914780974388, -0.017014361917972565, -0.03937147557735443, 0.02148706652224064, 0.07217519730329514, 0.011407882906496525, -0.013338270597159863, -0.04357721284031868, -0.025457803159952164, 0.027007481083273888, -0.02095542475581169, 0.058810990303754807, -0.01610025018453598, -0.06097356602549553, -0.052839793264865875, -0.01656968891620636, -0.016976840794086456, 0.04102882370352745, 0.01065213605761528, -0.02168448269367218, 0.020759902894496918, -0.0012812939239665866, -0.04735695570707321, -0.04190272092819214, -0.04504241794347763, 0.02484813518822193, -0.02929656207561493, -0.03376660495996475, 0.06756673753261566, 0.06110411137342453, -0.09534219652414322, 0.008900037966668606, -0.01556005235761404, 0.007537363097071648, -0.04805821180343628, -0.011897418648004532, -0.014188379980623722, 0.01591574028134346, 0.00356458337046206, 0.05433599278330803, -0.0028568399138748646, 0.024906838312745094, -0.05633150786161423, -0.031884584575891495, 0.013194497674703598, -0.003494479926303029, 0.03933851048350334, -0.014839015901088715, 0.037424731999635696, 0.06788476556539536, 0.014955617487430573, -0.010787605307996273, -0.07662243396043777, 0.014908254146575928, -0.032261673361063004, -0.030031872913241386, 0.0012276200577616692, 0.021170271560549736, 0.05145038291811943, 0.014168608002364635, -0.04275770112872124, 0.028020104393363, 0.038611359894275665, -0.004598574247211218, -0.0026129302568733692, 0.06631498038768768, -0.010438316501677036, -0.025540539994835854, 0.02296617440879345, 0.0228620246052742, -0.00962461531162262, 0.01447075791656971, 0.0034075977746397257, -0.018545953556895256, -0.043243713676929474, -0.039313171058893204, -0.013234161771833897, 0.01857495680451393, 0.03673717379570007, -0.01115394290536642, -0.0033612456172704697, 0.017041301354765892, -0.048611246049404144, -0.03249657526612282, -0.026410311460494995, 0.06662095338106155, -0.015061404556035995, 0.010320904664695263, 0.022077947854995728, 0.010879102163016796, 0.04187852144241333, 0.01687149703502655, -0.00728424871340394, -0.019341355189681053, -0.007315437775105238, -0.009512403048574924, -0.02790864184498787, 0.03564652055501938, 0.051809899508953094, -0.000700349744874984, -0.01598561741411686, -0.039003774523735046, 0.054192159324884415, -0.05225424841046333, -0.0029847887344658375, -0.020162127912044525, 0.033550363034009933, 0.025446170940995216, 0.008068585768342018, 0.03519322723150253, -0.003578790230676532, 0.01388811320066452, 0.03359534218907356, -0.0473271943628788, 0.010732095688581467, 0.01370189432054758, -0.008705878630280495, 0.022102115675807, -0.013376529328525066, 0.015107137151062489, -0.015533930622041225, -0.014810777269303799, 0.03090095892548561, 0.026034371927380562, -0.03853227570652962, -0.0061308653093874454, 0.01092605385929346, -0.0018821012927219272, -0.05964060127735138, -0.01148557011038065, 0.031853385269641876, 0.007505679968744516, -0.0010861156042665243, 0.0032664951868355274, -0.0016459113685414195, -0.011902039870619774, -0.016129136085510254, -0.0009609558619558811, -0.004833776969462633, 0.04232306778430939, 0.006275577936321497, 0.01572301797568798, -0.04542502760887146, -0.0017336583696305752, -0.029919587075710297, 0.030363822355866432, 0.04407110437750816, 0.016757633537054062, -0.023999402299523354, -0.03220485895872116, -0.02787398174405098, 0.015661850571632385, 0.009486374445259571, -0.015369257889688015, -0.006536533124744892, 0.0420081652700901, 0.030213262885808945, -0.048037298023700714, 0.01539846695959568, 0.012208213098347187, 0.026252632960677147, -0.006870221346616745, -0.04369667172431946, 0.022267770022153854, 0.023999352008104324, -0.026478322222828865, 0.06438533216714859, -0.015500769950449467, 0.025106456130743027, -0.0039724139496684074, 0.030601751059293747, -0.05163539573550224, -0.0438842847943306, -0.03106878139078617, 0.007782765664160252, 0.06407743692398071, -0.02641943469643593, -0.014245199039578438, -0.014647726900875568, 0.01599295809864998, 0.05961175635457039, 0.009454088285565376, 0.012606925331056118, -0.10002011060714722, -0.05396736040711403, 0.02538430690765381, 0.08427461236715317, -0.03768618032336235, 0.01426280103623867, -0.03808979690074921, -0.04714474081993103, 0.0069093587808310986, -0.017537083476781845, 0.024110808968544006, -0.008751734159886837, 0.01298227533698082, -0.03219200298190117, -0.02170981653034687, -0.03559018298983574, -0.011966993100941181, -0.04329158738255501, 0.012685736641287804, -0.044579654932022095, -0.03904874995350838, -0.054266564548015594, 0.031153900548815727, -0.018282996490597725, 0.0316382460296154, -0.003407418029382825, -0.05239051207900047, 0.007895061746239662, 0.00410671578720212, -0.022174116224050522, -0.06491691619157791, 0.015173387713730335, -0.0055155265145003796, 0.009889469482004642, 0.04127998650074005, 0.026967661455273628, -0.01141374558210373, -0.002418623771518469, 0.03381418064236641, -0.010489976964890957, -0.012046532705426216, 0.01046659890562296, 0.014076648280024529, -0.015822187066078186, 0.017193982377648354, 0.06958922743797302, 0.023142321035265923, 0.006123067811131477, 0.01524239219725132, -0.02959119901061058, 0.015368649736046791, -0.013480140827596188, -0.0328422486782074, -0.03354254364967346, -0.011311564594507217, -0.020516397431492805, 0.052035871893167496, -0.03598588705062866, 0.05097118020057678, -0.022165313363075256, -0.0308943260461092, 0.010912501253187656, 0.05709705129265785, -0.02077903412282467, -0.029306022450327873, -0.006116039119660854, 0.04700327292084694, 0.008292075246572495, 0.02193874679505825, -0.008240409195423126, -0.0014220474986359477, 0.022422881796956062, -0.0039637209847569466, -0.036422308534383774, -0.011882171034812927, -0.012671456672251225, 0.010236344300210476, 0.007052094675600529, -0.01441114954650402, 0.053331408649683, 0.008782096207141876, 0.042900241911411285, -0.028526533395051956, -0.061940427869558334, 0.011308546178042889, 0.016694094985723495, -0.02563183195888996, 0.018033497035503387, 0.00761310663074255, 0.01202673651278019, -0.027336260303854942, -0.04044706001877785, -0.056285560131073, 0.0016553805908188224, -0.019934814423322678, 0.010240355506539345, -0.04099521040916443, -0.00205777189694345, -0.02962159551680088, -0.002631798619404435, -0.03585377708077431, 0.004300819709897041, 0.042502932250499725, -0.03885916993021965, 0.02567969635128975, -0.011952780187129974, -0.0053724502213299274, 0.055955227464437485, 0.01002456434071064, 0.019243018701672554, -0.018103359267115593, -0.013805028051137924, -0.03208937495946884, 0.006761664990335703, -0.009440860711038113, -0.0451509952545166, -0.0002804674149956554, -0.02998705767095089, 0.027844395488500595, 0.008637585677206516, -0.0035624403972178698, -0.010091032832860947, -0.012726173736155033, -0.013184268958866596, 0.018274690955877304, -0.013545808382332325, 0.006771424785256386, -0.002277534920722246, 0.0038852763827890158, 0.009591996669769287, -0.010764064267277718, -0.02860672026872635, -0.026763813570141792, 0.005463510286062956, -0.004980192519724369, 0.01263504195958376, 0.006663435138761997, 0.05638513341546059, 0.019105521962046623, 0.030252831056714058, -0.041726548224687576, -0.03545884042978287, 0.06428969651460648, 0.006682806182652712, 0.03697800636291504, 0.027148578315973282, 0.024081673473119736, -0.052518896758556366, 0.0012031017104163766, -0.0793561339378357, 0.0075494879856705666, 0.05410272255539894, 0.0249627772718668, 0.026643231511116028, 0.046422917395830154, -0.033883072435855865, 0.04019152745604515, -0.042036425322294235, -0.012102377600967884, 0.003933183383196592, 0.03311124071478844, 0.07225701957941055, 0.005827557761222124, -0.02445378340780735, 0.06426975131034851, 0.005572522059082985, 0.06443920731544495, 0.05818065255880356, -0.007690486963838339, 0.008491533808410168, 0.003224301151931286, -0.046680547297000885, -0.03758911415934563, 0.02163909189403057, -0.00927984993904829, -0.0049690851010382175, 0.035281162708997726, -0.041280243545770645, 0.049324482679367065, 0.044470805674791336, 0.009995652362704277, -0.005330345127731562, -0.007552914321422577, -0.08449002355337143, 0.04095654562115669, 0.02670319564640522, -0.03578154742717743, 0.03327189385890961, -0.009521983563899994, -0.017513634636998177, 0.0024919009301811457, 0.04424138739705086, -0.02383957803249359, -0.07950077205896378, 0.02029140666127205, 0.02008937858045101, -0.018356112763285637, 0.03128642588853836, 0.03878215700387955, -0.0351424366235733, -0.00859308335930109, -0.035612452775239944, 0.027395449578762054, 0.041061270982027054, 0.03528812527656555, -0.005925289820879698, 0.02108811028301716, -0.02887663058936596, 0.016668567433953285, -0.013112140819430351, -0.029430914670228958, 0.17513975501060486, 0.11052588373422623, 0.031023936346173286, -0.03284385800361633, -0.002949643414467573, 0.043896012008190155, -0.02582666277885437, -0.004222172778099775, -0.021180221810936928, 0.006487563252449036, -0.03290208429098129, 0.02954021655023098, 0.03395569324493408, 0.023942887783050537, 0.0030914463568478823, 0.007986650802195072, -0.02813839167356491, 0.002938647987321019, 0.04205435886979103, -0.01848709024488926, 0.022654814645648003, -0.004422325640916824, -0.027511456981301308, -0.007791122887283564, 0.011573596857488155, -0.033004362136125565, -0.04972038418054581, 0.0013569989241659641, 0.015604936517775059, -0.025190802291035652, -0.016489487141370773, -0.026938486844301224, 0.003600346390157938, -0.011153382249176502, 0.009678740985691547, 0.010981997475028038, 0.019706295803189278, 0.00734213599935174, -0.006281828973442316, 0.04296569526195526, -0.0073950327932834625, -0.013250957243144512, -0.008561325259506702, 0.009204726666212082, 0.0003803272556979209, -0.03623778000473976, -0.01749381609261036, 0.05828393995761871, -0.010682356543838978, 0.008146146312355995, 0.03336028754711151, -0.004279667045921087, 0.009486519731581211, -0.061036475002765656, 0.00014889817975927144, -0.0001653701619943604, 0.03770063444972038, -0.0186340119689703, -0.011508534662425518, -0.03054928034543991, -0.010994848795235157, 0.0007612020708620548, 0.029170209541916847, 0.024573659524321556, 0.01536362711340189, -0.02639409340918064, -0.056755099445581436, 0.053224820643663406, 0.028187068179249763, 0.05434140935540199, -0.008306168019771576, -0.010779363103210926, 0.0008712986600585282, -0.03539519011974335, 0.03755566105246544, 0.029389875009655952, 0.01613009162247181, -0.013817155733704567, -0.041538022458553314, -0.04556576535105705, -0.06273981928825378, 0.004824299365282059, -0.04977976158261299, 0.00012749490269925445, -0.03587158024311066, 0.015106361359357834, 0.033326130360364914, 0.04563610255718231, 0.011445723474025726, 0.012435308657586575, -0.006225199438631535, 0.06261968612670898, -0.020645128563046455, -0.038430940359830856, -0.02439418062567711, -0.0032027342822402716, -0.038614507764577866, 0.017111685127019882, 0.004821675829589367, 0.07617651671171188, 0.013627063482999802, 0.008995053358376026, -0.021890951320528984, 0.04831742122769356, -0.02183166891336441, -0.02319934405386448, 0.016647612676024437, -0.04599238932132721, 0.028251316398382187, -0.020137019455432892, 0.004413011018186808, -0.04546758532524109, -0.018410574644804, -0.02248239330947399, -0.07387685775756836, 0.00815350841730833, 0.014795067720115185, -0.027529042214155197, -0.009243519976735115, -0.002063891850411892, 0.023973781615495682, -0.03793676942586899, -0.05723972246050835, -0.0005489974282681942, 0.00124459364451468, -0.04139817878603935, -0.020176375284790993, -0.005767468828707933, -0.006332254968583584, -0.050157640129327774, 0.01369908731430769, 0.021575024351477623, -0.017926648259162903, 0.0028895484283566475, -0.023692389950156212, -0.020525885745882988, -0.006507744546979666, 0.06471669673919678, -0.00817573256790638, -0.05118934065103531, 0.02226337231695652, -0.05625170096755028, -0.023388639092445374, -0.009027838706970215, -0.03200675919651985, 0.018600448966026306, 0.05173811689019203, 0.021854963153600693, -0.024745265021920204, 0.05118446797132492, 0.020701607689261436, -0.016219288110733032, -0.021658506244421005, 0.0327557697892189, 0.021824203431606293, 0.01800089329481125, -0.004400992300361395, -0.0017121877754107118, -0.024516332894563675, -0.0044702948071062565, 0.01301498431712389, -0.030713917687535286, -0.029499147087335587, 0.0017457813955843449, -0.061550505459308624, 0.024135634303092957, 0.00013624809798784554, 0.018202677369117737, -0.002482377691194415, 0.012724591419100761, -0.02222435735166073, 0.036970991641283035, 0.018361609429121017, 0.0007943291566334665, -0.11614429205656052, -0.014845024794340134, -0.010380763560533524, 0.02696317806839943, 0.009949864819645882, -0.02415568195283413, 0.014900283887982368, 0.008424712345004082, -0.01830914057791233, 0.02629769966006279, 0.02360893040895462, 0.03159068897366524, -0.04350468888878822, 0.013055010698735714, 0.000811501988209784, -0.04192623496055603, 0.0393545962870121, 0.011704505421221256, 0.057300131767988205, 0.010467465966939926, 0.012927302159368992, 0.0157628171145916, -0.043358854949474335, 0.011211000382900238, -0.005800912156701088, -0.0406997874379158, -0.02271418087184429, 0.0020070448517799377, -0.002039752434939146, -0.004012502264231443, 0.007586358580738306, 0.020267803221940994, 0.024449201300740242, 0.026431357488036156, 0.020507199689745903, 0.05264704301953316, 0.046479832381010056, -0.006329661700874567, 0.009027481079101562, -0.015489999204874039, -0.006807355210185051, -0.017917634919285774, -0.013663618825376034, 0.020866410806775093, -0.004345699213445187, -0.026612283661961555, -0.03363453596830368, 0.03443436697125435, -0.024423940107226372, -0.011827260255813599, 0.018674388527870178, -0.020305221900343895, -0.004081623628735542, -0.04463435336947441, -0.009172257967293262, -0.013659206219017506, -0.012136438861489296, 0.03337976336479187, 0.03698807209730148, -0.008165882900357246, 0.051563944667577744, -0.02428370900452137, -0.02656695805490017, -0.022931989282369614, -0.01860152930021286, -0.02951805293560028, -0.07507390528917313, 0.030263902619481087, -0.013225866481661797, -0.037138551473617554, -0.03851984441280365, 0.010623065754771233, -0.01838209480047226, 0.037921663373708725, -0.037351105362176895, 0.03160899505019188, 0.017369752749800682, -0.027657248079776764, 0.01478180568665266, -0.08792048692703247, 0.06375907361507416, -0.013308225199580193, -0.022980118170380592, -0.003518048906698823, -0.007579621858894825, -0.002372562885284424, 0.04757855832576752, 0.05082600936293602, 0.0300711952149868, 0.011786207556724548, -0.03623504564166069, 0.0068642315454781055, 0.013492554426193237, -0.05406132712960243, 0.04647250100970268, 0.00493276584893465, 0.012182151898741722, -0.010857336223125458, 0.016109047457575798, -0.0003410518111195415, 0.006480740383267403, 0.02970331534743309, -0.005002324469387531, -0.028351478278636932, 0.024927346035838127, -0.045467786490917206, 0.04970112442970276, 0.0037886009085923433, 0.004854756407439709, 0.05272204428911209, 0.00014659510634373873, -0.0024529590737074614, 0.015262443572282791, 0.027491016313433647, -0.030622581019997597, -0.01330050639808178, -0.04842415824532509, 0.01025809533894062, 0.024896590039134026, 0.04432363063097, 0.0019535247702151537, -0.03202735632658005, 0.016905415803194046, 0.0035103086847811937, -0.022155195474624634, -0.013818866573274136, 0.023022763431072235, -0.004639665130525827, 0.04653782770037651, 0.009718630462884903, 0.029316071420907974, 0.011678649112582207, -0.009028184227645397, 0.007395424414426088, -0.01948622055351734, 0.008958514779806137, -0.04007288068532944, 0.006874131038784981, 0.02049487829208374, -0.014263837598264217, 0.05308905243873596, -0.018373187631368637, 0.052164822816848755, -0.04509267210960388, -0.035595037043094635, 0.003636664478108287, -0.04977940768003464, -0.011263198219239712, -0.042254816740751266, -0.02187686786055565, 0.03845205157995224, -0.017670990899205208, -0.030453896149992943, -0.01772172562777996, -0.04085550457239151, 0.011020696721971035, 0.03179793804883957, -0.021561456844210625, 0.04858429357409477, 0.01946275681257248, 0.03140999376773834, -0.0006333909695968032, -0.0246362816542387, 0.042911186814308167, -0.014940997585654259, 0.029525374993681908, 0.030533364042639732, 0.003291267203167081, -0.0003020291624125093, 0.012126273475587368, 0.00003672499951790087, -0.03505656123161316, -0.0069421082735061646, 0.03956175222992897, 0.016137132421135902, -0.014732496812939644, -0.015296452678740025, 0.021495051681995392, 0.028648657724261284, -0.04084692522883415, -0.045419033616781235, -0.007083190605044365, -0.009985929355025291, 0.006709054112434387, 0.010145559906959534 ]
<p>I'm reading the GPML book and in <a href="http://www.gaussianprocess.org/gpml/chapters/RW2.pdf" rel="nofollow">Chapter 2 (page 15)</a>, it tells how to do regression using Gaussian Process(GP), but I'm having a hard time figuring how it works.</p> <p>In Bayesian inference for parametric models, we first choose a prior on the model parameters $\theta$, that is $p(\theta)$; second, given the training data $D$, we compute the likelihood $p(D|\theta)$; and finally we have the posterior of $\theta$ as $p(\theta|D)$, which will be used in the <em>predictive distribution</em> $$p(y^*|x^*,D)=\int p(y^*|x^*,\theta)p(\theta|D)d\theta$$, and the above is what we do in Bayesian inference for parametric models, right?</p> <p>Well, as said in the book, GP is non-parametric, and so far as I understand it, after specifying the <em>mean function</em> $m(x)$ and the <em>covariance function</em> $k(x,x')$, we have a GP over function $f$, $$f \sim GP(m,k)$$, and this is the <strong>prior</strong> of $f$. Now I have a <strong>noise-free</strong> training data set $$D=\{(x_1,f_1),...,(x_n,f_n)\}$$, I thought I should compute the <strong>likelihood</strong> $p(D|f)$ and then the <strong>posterior</strong> $p(f|D)$, and finally use the posterior to make predictions.</p> <p>HOWEVER, that's not what the book does! I mean, after specifying the prior $p(f)$, it doesn't compute the likelihood and posterior, but just go straight forward to the predictive prediction.</p> <p>Question:</p> <p>1) Why not compute the likelihood and posterior? Just because GP is non-parametric, so we don't do that?</p> <p>2) As what is done in the book (page 15~16), it derives the <strong>predictive distribution</strong> via the joint distribution of training data set $\textbf f$ and test data set $\textbf f^*$, which is termed as <strong>joint prior</strong>. Alright, this confuses me badly, why joint them together?</p> <p>3) I saw some articles call $f$ the <strong>latent</strong> variable, why?</p>
36,921
[ 0.0051249004900455475, -0.003819085191935301, 0.05685970187187195, -0.0337812714278698, 0.02395593747496605, 0.047678012400865555, 0.003892353270202875, -0.06004314497113228, 0.011846810579299927, -0.018550673499703407, 0.03252110630273819, 0.05030190199613571, 0.0970785915851593, 0.02233925648033619, 0.018683165311813354, 0.020610282197594643, -0.034845273941755295, 0.004415806382894516, 0.010158542543649673, -0.02600373886525631, -0.01364724151790142, 0.05621339753270149, -0.007132713682949543, -0.032198287546634674, -0.00880336668342352, 0.028501875698566437, 0.011745212599635124, -0.009766644798219204, -0.013282210566103458, 0.047888580709695816, -0.04318956658244133, -0.02030174247920513, -0.017323967069387436, 0.02119610831141472, 0.011064190417528152, 0.021576274186372757, -0.030905794352293015, -0.031371213495731354, -0.01992696151137352, 0.04243440553545952, -0.01692688651382923, -0.03316916897892952, 0.024808980524539948, 0.04992900416254997, -0.04236133024096489, 0.005146264564245939, 0.005732149351388216, -0.04530608281493187, 0.026219859719276428, -0.038962651044130325, 0.036921776831150055, 0.011331839486956596, 0.03203955292701721, 0.06595855206251144, -0.004401905927807093, -0.009184107184410095, 0.06509245932102203, 0.06890446692705154, -0.012183581478893757, -0.07492252439260483, 0.003087362740188837, -0.0450858473777771, 0.007359218318015337, -0.009552047587931156, -0.022986844182014465, 0.0017785403179004788, 0.0018274266039952636, -0.024307353422045708, 0.03144490718841553, -0.015958495438098907, 0.018709374591708183, 0.018702661618590355, 0.02166525274515152, -0.02041078358888626, 0.03155101463198662, 0.018950456753373146, 0.0003535787982400507, 0.036695174872875214, 0.06089340150356293, 0.004708474967628717, 0.005937317851930857, -0.010072112083435059, -0.009835734963417053, 0.036923959851264954, -0.027783546596765518, 0.010606913827359676, 0.08076272904872894, 0.01303967647254467, 0.02490929886698723, 0.006937317084521055, -0.03609731048345566, 0.002347189001739025, 0.010676472447812557, -0.05426950380206108, -0.022865992039442062, 0.06165922060608864, -0.021519845351576805, 0.009853515774011612, -0.04047177731990814, -0.00754894083365798, -0.023829076439142227, -0.046784259378910065, -0.013382160104811192, 0.03926485776901245, -0.04519427567720413, -0.03394120931625366, 0.025227511301636696, -0.005602765362709761, -0.028283195570111275, -0.02067355066537857, -0.01862352527678013, 0.04453594237565994, 0.00912617426365614, -0.0007469092961400747, 0.019543636590242386, -0.0026433300226926804, -0.009521303698420525, -0.01731962524354458, 0.021482020616531372, 0.06641538441181183, 0.029599785804748535, -0.00903649628162384, 0.0301472507417202, -0.04500241577625275, -0.0428151972591877, 0.019507987424731255, 0.00698444526642561, 0.0015625644009560347, -0.02437964454293251, 0.045842137187719345, -0.0067903632298111916, -0.024063026532530785, 0.03714152052998543, 0.06456825137138367, -0.011519482359290123, 0.013605944812297821, -0.0539507120847702, -0.01944534108042717, 0.03053431399166584, -0.05488274618983269, 0.05093841627240181, -0.04814692214131355, -0.009663686156272888, 0.006580385845154524, 0.018491476774215698, -0.032332565635442734, 0.04746413603425026, 0.008395603857934475, 0.013614309020340443, -0.025568461045622826, -0.04041510075330734, -0.019616814330220222, -0.015695123001933098, 0.010732723399996758, -0.052803151309490204, -0.09411405026912689, 0.006991739384829998, 0.008519488386809826, -0.018555553629994392, -0.016248174011707306, 0.03785223886370659, -0.01588476076722145, -0.036478761583566666, -0.028373392298817635, 0.013350523076951504, -0.03854181244969368, 0.044095709919929504, 0.030266517773270607, 0.03428031876683235, 0.030510589480400085, -0.006115138065069914, -0.002372554736211896, -0.03350134938955307, 0.06447722762823105, 0.03810363635420799, -0.01808708906173706, -0.007143320050090551, -0.026640169322490692, 0.025412485003471375, 0.002124646445736289, -0.014175349846482277, -0.0034752902574837208, 0.012584351934492588, 0.0036757858470082283, -0.02091132663190365, 0.04251549392938614, 0.03682906553149223, 0.0012478934368118644, 0.013964906334877014, -0.03162753954529762, -0.024313220754265785, -0.04185299575328827, 0.020950205624103546, 0.014312293380498886, 0.009473614394664764, 0.0526118203997612, -0.03785938397049904, 0.007335839327424765, 0.01504706870764494, -0.03106861189007759, -0.01968621276319027, -0.008193368092179298, 0.0009667213307693601, -0.04395585134625435, 0.027604717761278152, 0.0828990638256073, 0.029560303315520287, 0.010693243704736233, 0.031927403062582016, -0.03182203322649002, -0.015395388938486576, 0.015234525315463543, -0.03260922059416771, -0.0008569189812988043, -0.02557379938662052, -0.05925620719790459, 0.025593651458621025, 0.00022559810895472765, 0.007085863035172224, -0.011707610450685024, -0.07470692694187164, 0.03411952033638954, 0.0951564759016037, -0.0019691959023475647, -0.007557787466794252, -0.012071670964360237, -0.020999005064368248, 0.0257357656955719, -0.002987704472616315, 0.0026541459374129772, -0.04570142552256584, -0.02184353955090046, 0.030774962157011032, -0.00010803113400470465, -0.02300702966749668, -0.009474764578044415, 0.04445294290781021, 0.030688507482409477, 0.014956830069422722, 0.04569583758711815, -0.010042126290500164, -0.0412462055683136, 0.05857617408037186, -0.0016286632744595408, -0.013462568633258343, -0.004872149787843227, -0.007192122749984264, 0.028643179684877396, 0.06827282905578613, 0.00244360463693738, -0.011726148426532745, 0.07679501175880432, 0.00879234541207552, 0.0011462911497801542, -0.03934358060359955, -0.016340015456080437, 0.015065453946590424, -0.008315792307257652, 0.006243652664124966, 0.02098902128636837, 0.02905738726258278, -0.022544139996170998, -0.047112587839365005, -0.01645323447883129, 0.013063552789390087, 0.04293544963002205, -0.026608673855662346, 0.024836337193846703, 0.019557073712348938, -0.03496445342898369, 0.016780078411102295, 0.013563559390604496, -0.03557443991303444, -0.010511819273233414, 0.014367295429110527, 0.002764109754934907, 0.0007562472019344568, -0.007256385404616594, -0.032230641692876816, -0.042463518679142, -0.010201117023825645, -0.00505112437531352, 0.04320567473769188, 0.0005331282154656947, -0.05468616634607315, -0.02819068729877472, -0.05201138183474541, -0.006342134438455105, 0.03592165932059288, -0.004728501196950674, -0.00003959838068112731, -0.0188040342181921, -0.043695345520973206, -0.06425787508487701, -0.02947785146534443, -0.020173540338873863, -0.02820548042654991, -0.024770023301243782, -0.02297545038163662, 0.03197538107633591, 0.02647818811237812, -0.00840470939874649, 0.011254816316068172, -0.036187391728162766, -0.03439643234014511, -0.04134557396173477, 0.009515803307294846, -0.009151223115622997, -0.009557672776281834, 0.0646040067076683, 0.02868441492319107, -0.029957709833979607, 0.02136356756091118, -0.06826053559780121, -0.022517463192343712, 0.018475806340575218, 0.0011834576725959778, 0.009694736450910568, 0.015324994921684265, -0.01508981641381979, 0.03256715461611748, 0.011098431423306465, -0.05394032597541809, -0.014162363484501839, 0.030100183561444283, -0.02514261193573475, -0.052279818803071976, 0.012720838189125061, 0.019670981913805008, 0.00030320946825668216, 0.01464158296585083, -0.003058352507650852, -0.011209482327103615, 0.042396098375320435, -0.011649818159639835, -0.0003232783928979188, 0.030114829540252686, -0.0018572689732536674, 0.005160205066204071, 0.01638086512684822, 0.03472280129790306, -0.01933286339044571, 0.017103632912039757, -0.018484828993678093, -0.01918809860944748, 0.016347665339708328, -0.030462175607681274, -0.0090152807533741, -0.0034742550924420357, -0.00401213439181447, -0.059343546628952026, 0.061778225004673004, 0.008919788524508476, -0.05256681516766548, 0.00407475046813488, -0.016296913847327232, 0.02754725143313408, -0.018888818100094795, -0.028721151873469353, 0.021046018227934837, 0.006703666411340237, 0.00007474072481272742, -0.018939102068543434, -0.007316726725548506, -0.013717638328671455, 0.014947290532290936, 0.011552398093044758, 0.016895264387130737, 0.016852159053087234, 0.0218926090747118, -0.012252746149897575, -0.006423745304346085, -0.0033320002257823944, 0.004007063340395689, -0.038424428552389145, 0.0090867904946208, 0.0026810122653841972, 0.02869594842195511, 0.0014269659295678139, 0.05656876042485237, 0.026541899889707565, -0.008761472068727016, 0.012579143978655338, -0.006362689193338156, -0.06628842651844025, 0.003439782653003931, -0.0016050664708018303, -0.029495786875486374, 0.01524671446532011, -0.03494590148329735, 0.051242612302303314, -0.019267668947577477, 0.02656794711947441, -0.010630757547914982, -0.0028277619276195765, -0.041018713265657425, -0.0021759632509201765, -0.040695976465940475, -0.026138104498386383, -0.013575074262917042, 0.01645723730325699, 0.028664715588092804, -0.017115453258156776, 0.02523111179471016, 0.05197865888476372, -0.013663949444890022, 0.004494406748563051, 0.0031545176170766354, 0.005778242833912373, 0.0012001266004517674, 0.031533461064100266, 0.030575817450881004, 0.04018579423427582, -0.027555977925658226, 0.037073247134685516, 0.019555576145648956, 0.07479845732450485, 0.09129706770181656, -0.0342864915728569, 0.00019142443488817662, -0.01586402766406536, -0.012295035645365715, 0.027813125401735306, 0.02331213839352131, -0.0029707502108067274, -0.039623506367206573, 0.05122104659676552, -0.021283747628331184, -0.027925195172429085, 0.01778620481491089, 0.037730149924755096, -0.01712031289935112, -0.0058513786643743515, -0.03182170167565346, -0.004462466575205326, -0.0102913286536932, -0.018859313800930977, 0.03005925379693508, -0.027695005759596825, -0.02228645049035549, -0.015229846350848675, 0.022803928703069687, -0.01729600504040718, -0.022079717367887497, -0.03854075446724892, 0.062523253262043, 0.00919712521135807, 0.011134197004139423, -0.04261244088411331, 0.014604756608605385, 0.05460908263921738, 0.023381147533655167, 0.015940243378281593, 0.02950662188231945, -0.052003104239702225, 0.006616426166146994, 0.030553743243217468, 0.026338255032896996, 0.008077018894255161, -0.0019604249391704798, -0.04296502470970154, -0.03103609010577202, 0.006431476678699255, 0.024823687970638275, 0.005560953635722399, -0.006672670133411884, 0.018699610605835915, -0.016029322519898415, -0.022384343668818474, -0.07043695449829102, -0.015858620405197144, -0.034271858632564545, 0.022716129198670387, -0.038609832525253296, -0.0008930070325732231, -0.0070662652142345905, -0.027096128091216087, -0.010885401628911495, 0.057998791337013245, -0.03144766762852669, -0.030060093849897385, 0.019865650683641434, 0.045082978904247284, 0.009340453892946243, -0.05837022513151169, 0.023404764011502266, 0.0030289292335510254, 0.0011498932726681232, 0.05237627401947975, -0.037592384964227676, -0.051377568393945694, 0.047008585184812546, 0.017300480976700783, -0.006653297692537308, 0.004671849776059389, -0.02460300922393799, 0.03846614435315132, 0.005734439007937908, 0.015429908409714699, 0.056628476828336716, 0.011681846342980862, -0.010371370241045952, -0.027657510712742805, -0.030920276418328285, 0.019514741376042366, -0.028070807456970215, -0.006512510124593973, -0.050010476261377335, -0.00630566943436861, 0.00574504816904664, 0.02019830420613289, 0.024844203144311905, 0.027780435979366302, -0.031189734116196632, -0.011820107698440552, 0.01257555652409792, 0.03426793962717056, -0.005575315095484257, 0.04106799513101578, -0.03654715418815613, 0.002898597624152899, 0.021965267136693, 0.002956586657091975, -0.002724973950535059, -0.018381454050540924, 0.04350486770272255, -0.012608255259692669, -0.0030585573986172676, -0.021201688796281815, -0.030645718798041344, -0.02873971126973629, 0.023678136989474297, -0.015680739656090736, 0.04194089397788048, 0.014689096249639988, 0.03162204474210739, 0.013401016592979431, -0.08199186623096466, -0.015321101993322372, 0.010498946532607079, -0.0185153279453516, 0.022191818803548813, -0.017816105857491493, -0.02291404828429222, -0.007435448933392763, 0.008120284415781498, -0.027887750416994095, 0.016576042398810387, 0.0027772020548582077, -0.05715632438659668, -0.040052782744169235, -0.005389121826738119, -0.0018546481151133776, -0.011439422145485878, -0.057168811559677124, -0.015647901222109795, 0.05060730502009392, 0.0008179550641216338, 0.0031156924087554216, 0.0149778351187706, 0.029910245910286903, 0.06484272330999374, 0.012735985219478607, -0.0325629860162735, 0.03643601015210152, 0.0049572172574698925, -0.03949267044663429, -0.010167374275624752, 0.005063350312411785, -0.0220845527946949, 0.021730398759245872, -0.036568786948919296, 0.0021775802597403526, 0.0186859592795372, -0.020331276580691338, -0.010327753610908985, 0.025873184204101562, 0.005330389831215143, -0.0073194969445466995, -0.05860539898276329, -0.051465462893247604, -0.020544249564409256, 0.003899884410202503, 0.010739930905401707, -0.012044361792504787, 0.01659475825726986, 0.00027611188124865294, 0.05891517549753189, -0.031154515221714973, 0.009547650814056396, 0.017849696800112724, 0.05005849525332451, -0.023914271965622902, 0.024182632565498352, 0.0005610131775029004, -0.010725026950240135, 0.038057178258895874, 0.0067920563742518425, 0.036418087780475616, 0.03963411971926689, 0.019145803526043892, -0.05620574206113815, 0.012884306721389294, -0.08106205612421036, -0.014386395923793316, 0.08445059508085251, -0.02367241680622101, 0.06919768452644348, -0.004988953471183777, -0.02117619663476944, -0.011431792750954628, -0.056101955473423004, -0.0322536900639534, -0.018024031072854996, -0.0018989202799275517, 0.030577562749385834, -0.014249970205128193, -0.002046434208750725, 0.04063853621482849, -0.02335551753640175, 0.02172841504216194, 0.019383560866117477, -0.010030049830675125, 0.040166035294532776, 0.02320103347301483, -0.03131764382123947, -0.040214087814092636, 0.054349347949028015, -0.027210883796215057, -0.01431369874626398, -0.04256177321076393, -0.0015190677950158715, 0.009225327521562576, 0.055833954364061356, 0.01456824317574501, -0.055371347814798355, -0.0015928809298202395, -0.05955549702048302, 0.009475087746977806, 0.044619347900152206, -0.017796237021684647, -0.01169134583324194, -0.023114871233701706, -0.0005672890692949295, 0.013235385529696941, 0.02103557623922825, -0.024397488683462143, -0.08981205523014069, -0.03843948245048523, -0.016073312610387802, 0.03026779182255268, 0.03289708122611046, 0.006449616514146328, -0.05664477497339249, 0.01906822994351387, -0.020032260566949844, 0.055191945284605026, 0.04168432950973511, 0.005325899925082922, -0.019803958013653755, 0.097005695104599, -0.012579253874719143, 0.03403608873486519, -0.04103787988424301, -0.04456031322479248, 0.13761094212532043, 0.0691523626446724, 0.05680502951145172, -0.03934859111905098, -0.005752641707658768, -0.03117874450981617, -0.015201025642454624, -0.019982965663075447, 0.002418884541839361, 0.015400259755551815, -0.024041395634412766, 0.005109064746648073, 0.020517420023679733, 0.01525751780718565, -0.004169492982327938, 0.044934242963790894, -0.03599204868078232, -0.039019521325826645, 0.01466184202581644, -0.011767158284783363, -0.032943956553936005, -0.005709247663617134, -0.007115890737622976, 0.017928041517734528, -0.01649024896323681, 0.009014622308313847, -0.023313917219638824, 0.0032187558244913816, 0.003466497641056776, 0.0332026481628418, 0.011224832385778427, -0.0158394668251276, -0.017162088304758072, -0.0008703292696736753, 0.008014462888240814, 0.012081327848136425, 0.012804625555872917, -0.011545662768185139, 0.015634682029485703, 0.05196579545736313, 0.010370411910116673, -0.002992395544424653, 0.004672541283071041, -0.017750974744558334, -0.017095379531383514, -0.03216904401779175, -0.024937821552157402, 0.07026935368776321, -0.008874847553670406, 0.011272821575403214, -0.0006733007612638175, 0.020822491496801376, -0.011404723860323429, -0.03337659314274788, 0.032277725636959076, 0.01273282803595066, 0.05554582178592682, -0.011466762982308865, -0.0035062942188233137, -0.008213161490857601, 0.0457988865673542, -0.020286958664655685, 0.05098925530910492, 0.008424275554716587, -0.054298724979162216, -0.0074666524305939674, -0.04590768367052078, 0.046175405383110046, -0.009713615290820599, 0.02689290978014469, 0.0029860592912882566, -0.011391041800379753, -0.030827924609184265, -0.06428894400596619, 0.040158797055482864, -0.01998862251639366, -0.00920754112303257, -0.0035737042780965567, -0.012456339783966541, -0.01324356347322464, -0.04135068878531456, 0.06332570314407349, -0.04582028090953827, 0.014591504819691181, -0.014369916170835495, -0.026335064321756363, 0.01073173712939024, 0.04200420901179314, 0.0367560088634491, 0.03814568370580673, 0.0004778457514476031, 0.028623515740036964, 0.01976294443011284, -0.03426842391490936, -0.05409207567572594, 0.006176766008138657, -0.041194599121809006, -0.011067179031670094, 0.01785617135465145, 0.03730662539601326, 0.045286279171705246, 0.07674598693847656, -0.03373022750020027, 0.009254608303308487, 0.0008819434442557395, 0.00015787970914971083, -0.04942356422543526, -0.044342946261167526, 0.024626579135656357, 0.016130605712532997, 0.013213256374001503, -0.011245323345065117, 0.016142182052135468, 0.0037782962899655104, 0.008491745218634605, 0.05102028325200081, -0.010982892476022243, -0.04949543997645378, 0.008307886309921741, 0.019389282912015915, 0.04026465117931366, 0.014851159416139126, 0.005250729154795408, 0.012283183634281158, 0.005342371761798859, 0.015338283032178879, 0.010041562840342522, -0.02531919814646244, 0.0013176382053643465, -0.009673348627984524, -0.024565011262893677, 0.03157167509198189, -0.013081067241728306, 0.018405377864837646, 0.017486462369561195, 0.02318628504872322, -0.05208906531333923, 0.03790690749883652, -0.011145692318677902, -0.027789853513240814, 0.021445222198963165, -0.06460415571928024, -0.04119027778506279, 0.03351188451051712, 0.03460365906357765, 0.04240455478429794, 0.011680054478347301, 0.0394982248544693, -0.059171997010707855, 0.03062923066318035, -0.03695837780833244, -0.013028805144131184, -0.036802683025598526, -0.002643313491716981, 0.01939219795167446, -0.006969376467168331, 0.02647113800048828, 0.015002606436610222, 0.05491705238819122, 0.02857239916920662, 0.004248418379575014, 0.015648026019334793, -0.016963958740234375, 0.02736332081258297, -0.03143706172704697, 0.00005876519935554825, 0.02506088837981224, 0.007544475607573986, 0.015089273452758789, 0.0514795184135437, 0.030127622187137604, 0.041751887649297714, -0.013710329309105873, -0.0074907331727445126, -0.1066816970705986, -0.017825499176979065, 0.04610040783882141, 0.01238541305065155, 0.05267757549881935, -0.05593015253543854, -0.0317203551530838, 0.04626771807670593, -0.04980011656880379, 0.016066068783402443, 0.04493745416402817, -0.01690009981393814, -0.015284317545592785, 0.020879264920949936, -0.028686806559562683, 0.05956262722611427, 0.02490054816007614, 0.02422766014933586, 0.058768678456544876, 0.016630958765745163, 0.0020805117674171925, -0.040177151560783386, -0.024873271584510803, 0.018684551119804382, 0.015923231840133667, -0.027204977348446846, 0.024635061621665955, -0.017435843124985695, -0.019017359241843224, 0.017741283401846886, 0.02627006731927395, -0.0060198260471224785, -0.030232137069106102, 0.02828151173889637, 0.011829602532088757, 0.021418295800685883, 0.06180012971162796, 0.012864312157034874, 0.03611866757273674, 0.004501537885516882, 0.007009453605860472, 0.031215116381645203, -0.02753056213259697, 0.02447022683918476, -0.022541135549545288, -0.024525295943021774, -0.02430790849030018, 0.002859815489500761, -0.0035173939540982246, -0.024206440895795822, 0.029530523344874382, 0.02467711828649044, -0.031775422394275665, -0.02643619105219841, -0.002156945178285241, -0.05042248219251633, 0.016983354464173317, 0.04496259614825249, 0.013389283791184425, 0.007946114055812359, 0.019513439387083054, -0.0306586641818285, -0.05650285258889198, -0.002796391025185585, -0.01217583566904068, -0.01482770498842001, -0.03289437294006348, 0.0027698238845914602, 0.026868252083659172, -0.051091767847537994, 0.0006460185395553708, 0.013446537777781487, -0.06934843957424164, 0.010336136445403099, -0.0179281085729599, 0.009225687943398952, -0.03225618973374367, -0.012311783619225025, 0.02437557280063629, -0.06760190427303314, 0.07729417830705643, 0.013511337339878082, -0.0578479990363121, -0.02777865342795849, -0.0018312670290470123, 0.0023349293041974306, 0.0025512846186757088, 0.024745838716626167, 0.014777496457099915, 0.017397591844201088, 0.0037620076909661293, 0.03436857834458351, 0.003467569360509515, -0.07884396612644196, 0.03013397753238678, 0.011449824087321758, -0.01630479469895363, -0.016055626794695854, 0.004442514386028051, 0.016191085800528526, 0.05911923199892044, 0.00779305025935173, -0.006856326945126057, 0.025952940806746483, 0.006123094819486141, 0.008168329484760761, 0.004560424946248531, 0.000027204259822610766, 0.016091862693428993, 0.04817494377493858, -0.04278835654258728, 0.019518522545695305, 0.032188910990953445, 0.0046873451210558414, -0.07520529627799988, 0.00594782829284668, -0.03591879829764366, -0.05227022245526314, 0.0062828510999679565, -0.0022153027821332216, 0.027158420532941818, -0.04745129868388176, -0.009795215912163258, 0.06933841854333878, -0.05350225046277046, 0.004132249858230352, 0.06425900012254715, 0.03166085109114647, 0.06562749296426773, 0.023202640935778618, -0.0067086853086948395, 0.010642187669873238, -0.026751695200800896, 0.01705903373658657, 0.019540837034583092, 0.055668823421001434, 0.0001723536115605384, 0.004031263757497072, 0.008087397553026676, -0.014642518013715744, 0.012346901930868626, 0.004616082645952702, 0.05700680613517761, -0.02784532681107521, -0.017951354384422302, -0.030546730384230614, -0.007829426787793636, 0.0026787228416651487, -0.014487475156784058, -0.020013274624943733, 0.0765264704823494, -0.06088388338685036, -0.04274648427963257, -0.023218484595417976, 0.019445935264229774, -0.041338369250297546, 0.003928810823708773, 0.01766171120107174, 0.025059416890144348, 0.0027251497376710176, 0.007118578534573317, 0.018695363774895668, -0.016946004703640938, 0.00149215804412961, -0.023709597066044807, 0.027403468266129494, 0.03911372274160385, -0.022245824337005615, -0.01678549125790596, -0.012456070631742477, -0.020188650116324425, -0.024804186075925827, -0.0030387453734874725, 0.011749395169317722, 0.02583000436425209, -0.04803675040602684, 0.0007260129787027836, -0.007059117779135704, 0.01925448514521122, -0.052408959716558456, 0.03743397817015648, -0.020948326215147972, -0.041222650557756424, 0.015088723972439766, -0.011245221830904484 ]
<p>I'm trying to differentiate two groups of patients using various machine learning algorithms, including support-vector machines (SVM). </p> <p>As far as the details of the analysis go, I would like to train the sample on a separate group and cross-validate on another. </p> <p>The problem is that patients are different in some categorical variables (gender for example) and continuous variables (age for example) none of which are of interest. In regression analysis using generalized linear models, it is easy to factor out nuisance variables. I'm wondering whether there is a way in machine learning as general, and SVM in particular to factor out the effect of nuisance variable. In some papers I have seen that authors include nuisance variable to somehow normalize them. </p>
36,922
[ -0.0376734584569931, -0.006351483520120382, 0.019826456904411316, -0.01815682090818882, 0.011719069443643093, -0.015227455645799637, -0.051049958914518356, 0.0079808896407485, 0.038507651537656784, -0.02987070381641388, 0.027683330699801445, 0.010734450072050095, 0.085759237408638, 0.025422677397727966, 0.016758890822529793, -0.0016550066648051143, -0.0009853864321485162, -0.03397580608725548, -0.018747076392173767, 0.011417361907660961, -0.006223953794687986, 0.0024194344878196716, -0.001206286484375596, -0.0200472641736269, 0.01782965660095215, 0.07503069937229156, -0.004527857527136803, -0.04279527813196182, -0.012397215701639652, 0.03578079119324684, -0.04186444357037544, -0.020813768729567528, 0.007771293632686138, 0.040471937507390976, -0.02158522978425026, 0.020280424505472183, -0.01061757281422615, -0.007806993089616299, -0.0157791618257761, 0.04976363107562065, -0.012097524479031563, 0.010146597400307655, 0.0005951783386990428, 0.06393281370401382, -0.04494279623031616, 0.038186538964509964, -0.0005064698052592576, -0.009570623748004436, 0.008696532808244228, -0.049155283719301224, 0.1043090894818306, 0.015889035537838936, 0.048099033534526825, 0.041617535054683685, -0.032021503895521164, 0.0023443452082574368, 0.037636540830135345, 0.0769919827580452, 0.012327919714152813, -0.019632138311862946, -0.03553512692451477, -0.03442663326859474, 0.006080383900552988, -0.03533155843615532, -0.030350668355822563, 0.024153342470526695, -0.01335128117352724, -0.03517116606235504, 0.01472590584307909, -0.016140524297952652, 0.025105617940425873, -0.015336346812546253, 0.013302046805620193, -0.00791880488395691, 0.0015056494157761335, -0.04154480993747711, 0.007863455452024937, 0.02197284996509552, 0.028508096933364868, 0.0013808258809149265, 0.013912941329181194, 0.004812362603843212, 0.02500634454190731, 0.019823910668492317, -0.010865839198231697, -0.013713061809539795, 0.04062238708138466, -0.01597040891647339, 0.013714171946048737, 0.05247858539223671, -0.022340955212712288, 0.04703189805150032, 0.0599508173763752, 0.005120332818478346, -0.05411863327026367, 0.029414741322398186, 0.0020122758578509092, 0.02223697490990162, 0.05630611628293991, -0.0007495765457861125, -0.04233791306614876, -0.04095569998025894, 0.046284422278404236, 0.050645262002944946, -0.05363551527261734, -0.02250165306031704, -0.03190053999423981, 0.00603233277797699, -0.014202596619725227, -0.018654076382517815, -0.037163469940423965, -0.02843344770371914, 0.007423060480505228, -0.023293036967515945, 0.035809747874736786, 0.00460146414116025, -0.052775438874959946, -0.05213967710733414, 0.055936481803655624, 0.06978616863489151, 0.028806231915950775, -0.036230601370334625, 0.03992483764886856, -0.024419620633125305, -0.05965416878461838, 0.0031893993727862835, 0.026094602420926094, 0.0133449025452137, -0.02205553650856018, 0.057975444942712784, 0.009005646221339703, -0.02123861014842987, 0.03093077428638935, -0.03040749579668045, 0.005159665364772081, 0.0011655362322926521, -0.04427872598171234, -0.030903901904821396, 0.01309937983751297, -0.008885222487151623, 0.02821849286556244, -0.01878119260072708, -0.011549320071935654, 0.027440523728728294, 0.06633839011192322, 0.02947254665195942, 0.015190795995295048, 0.029894931241869926, 0.02501208893954754, 0.008145838044583797, 0.008067283779382706, -0.03373510390520096, -0.023349374532699585, -0.011571535840630531, -0.015348639339208603, -0.0549890361726284, 0.01646663062274456, 0.012081358581781387, 0.004456883296370506, 0.0101925665512681, 0.03692985698580742, -0.020992668345570564, -0.0024633780121803284, 0.03451243415474892, 0.00791361927986145, -0.01752994768321514, 0.041892874985933304, -0.014402704313397408, 0.030944880098104477, 0.029011452570557594, 0.019791610538959503, 0.00689633097499609, 0.045857809484004974, 0.06934158504009247, 0.025069722905755043, 0.02970849722623825, -0.007008831016719341, -0.01276838593184948, 0.05656834691762924, 0.023328380659222603, -0.04801500216126442, -0.042863111943006516, -0.004168761894106865, 0.006440989673137665, 0.013466404750943184, 0.05421669781208038, 0.004319940228015184, -0.004241322632879019, 0.06918441504240036, -0.03546607494354248, -0.014826455153524876, -0.06729299575090408, 0.0009956832509487867, -0.037659961730241776, -0.027298089116811752, 0.03472926467657089, 0.011071398854255676, 0.01716483384370804, -0.02181253209710121, -0.018106214702129364, -0.05191291868686676, -0.004127867985516787, 0.03922058269381523, -0.060314323753118515, -0.02368074841797352, -0.0009954716078937054, 0.030845871195197105, -0.010744371451437473, 0.04236648976802826, -0.021149903535842896, -0.08274342864751816, 0.03535937890410423, -0.05226229131221771, 0.017463024705648422, -0.04473735764622688, -0.021027589216828346, 0.009955898858606815, 0.0113133629783988, -0.021533172577619553, 0.03407558798789978, -0.058084636926651, 0.06496480107307434, 0.06916261464357376, -0.0013674373039975762, -0.002316871890798211, -0.04312083125114441, 0.0394669771194458, 0.0051622213795781136, -0.004840061068534851, -0.03785935789346695, -0.042119693011045456, -0.038443826138973236, 0.05728381872177124, -0.007802845910191536, -0.02291780523955822, 0.009736183099448681, 0.041857555508613586, 0.01994815096259117, 0.02324647083878517, 0.011925818398594856, -0.027848146855831146, -0.006785423029214144, 0.022212544456124306, 0.022931557148694992, -0.004151857923716307, -0.028027893975377083, 0.03494217246770859, 0.006437792908400297, 0.014140327461063862, -0.00131417706143111, -0.022446824237704277, 0.060922689735889435, -0.00015479742432944477, 0.02653999999165535, -0.0276007242500782, -0.035698890686035156, 0.04093647748231888, 0.007997648790478706, 0.012678000144660473, 0.034323934465646744, -0.007189535535871983, -0.012508586049079895, 0.006128824781626463, -0.009784101508557796, 0.02528255060315132, 0.055475156754255295, -0.026900237426161766, 0.046279508620500565, 0.007054018322378397, -0.05896306782960892, 0.005240927916020155, 0.012647442519664764, -0.007547383196651936, -0.05010610446333885, 0.016285955905914307, 0.049118347465991974, 0.005012345500290394, 0.030250784009695053, -0.0010182515252381563, -0.030043724924325943, -0.0003425790346227586, -0.030941730365157127, -0.0069012148305773735, 0.03274937719106674, -0.03205979987978935, 0.001571491826325655, -0.03731357306241989, -0.02127346582710743, 0.04137694463133812, -0.0035132046323269606, 0.01098332367837429, 0.012023054994642735, 0.010414871387183666, -0.0768890231847763, -0.021338241174817085, -0.07277984917163849, -0.003239239798858762, 0.02699865587055683, -0.004151501692831516, 0.002440603217110038, 0.016504187136888504, -0.017779987305402756, 0.00992157869040966, -0.012601199559867382, -0.008839782327413559, -0.01893346942961216, -0.024244682863354683, 0.04310348257422447, -0.010455177165567875, -0.006651622708886862, 0.027989564463496208, -0.036464624106884, 0.017503883689641953, -0.07534785568714142, -0.05660047382116318, 0.0470416359603405, 0.024551400914788246, 0.009804255329072475, 0.019962577149271965, -0.005380582995712757, 0.09953688085079193, 0.0368155874311924, -0.030965283513069153, -0.050134219229221344, -0.01951528713107109, -0.04032154753804207, -0.011397898197174072, 0.007909199222922325, 0.026625357568264008, 0.046735137701034546, 0.03597470372915268, -0.005065201781690121, 0.013433922082185745, 0.04899049550294876, 0.031271133571863174, -0.02111467532813549, 0.04077235609292984, -0.0059901876375079155, 0.013883691281080246, 0.029078712686896324, 0.018004294484853745, -0.018322860822081566, -0.012349671684205532, 0.005357190500944853, 0.03705933317542076, 0.0035831036511808634, -0.02430310659110546, -0.00410740589722991, -0.048511601984500885, 0.01490651722997427, -0.04282403364777565, 0.005252365488559008, -0.0045760576613247395, -0.02679537795484066, 0.0017759623005986214, 0.014093231409788132, 0.02346472442150116, -0.036642562597990036, 0.03572133183479309, 0.07884075492620468, 0.045294299721717834, -0.02665197290480137, -0.017139077186584473, -0.004895775578916073, -0.0036097492557018995, 0.03508441895246506, -0.02948002703487873, -0.02309514582157135, 0.029569551348686218, 0.03956649824976921, 0.0064517841674387455, 0.02645385079085827, -0.0425427109003067, 0.013765919953584671, -0.07098695635795593, -0.01669665239751339, -0.024769918993115425, 0.05758177861571312, 0.01105546671897173, 0.011916200630366802, 0.03836388140916824, -0.01541703287512064, 0.010979359969496727, -0.02318255975842476, -0.05164957419037819, 0.0194011889398098, -0.006009963806718588, -0.02784726396203041, 0.04722728952765465, -0.020344818010926247, 0.0343666709959507, -0.01932591199874878, -0.009583561681210995, 0.022480271756649017, 0.01902751997113228, -0.06323405355215073, 0.013131070882081985, 0.005181248765438795, -0.033488161861896515, -0.016329048201441765, 0.0027913323137909174, -0.027739310637116432, -0.012769163586199284, -0.02857803925871849, 0.028633084148168564, -0.018387850373983383, -0.011599859222769737, -0.04196162521839142, 0.02830546535551548, -0.031100960448384285, 0.05477619916200638, 0.009587480686604977, 0.017287909984588623, -0.0732378363609314, 0.020474301651120186, -0.0027730478905141354, 0.02197270467877388, 0.04766177758574486, -0.001577331218868494, -0.04001310467720032, -0.06119813397526741, -0.027139874175190926, 0.026997767388820648, 0.038893479853868484, 0.00618113623932004, 0.018750518560409546, 0.035230085253715515, 0.021737590432167053, -0.07041240483522415, -0.015277151949703693, 0.046966567635536194, 0.03844625502824783, -0.0025574988685548306, -0.03647922724485397, -0.0011693739797919989, -0.0023563674185425043, -0.01345245260745287, 0.019684413447976112, 0.023261094465851784, -0.0037101523485034704, -0.02991230972111225, 0.03079122118651867, -0.027890494093298912, -0.03302960842847824, -0.0065346877090632915, 0.026129882782697678, 0.015996763482689857, 0.01509062759578228, -0.03243708983063698, 0.03595180809497833, 0.04222433269023895, 0.014886573888361454, -0.00568755529820919, -0.016811128705739975, -0.11397519707679749, 0.01392365526407957, 0.027458354830741882, 0.0464775450527668, -0.047945622354745865, -0.05911441147327423, -0.02276565320789814, 0.014398318715393543, 0.04244711622595787, 0.009485076181590557, -0.010848837904632092, 0.0008259988971985877, 0.0019626677967607975, -0.01824629306793213, -0.0057930899783968925, -0.04803771898150444, 0.03800656646490097, -0.016789359971880913, 0.023918017745018005, -0.003374034073203802, -0.05353831127285957, -0.04741997644305229, -0.024301793426275253, 0.014200100675225258, 0.05421358346939087, 0.006111964117735624, -0.03185553848743439, -0.009784991852939129, 0.04689541831612587, -0.006097544450312853, -0.07079023867845535, -0.003176875878125429, 0.032019685953855515, -0.017479395493865013, 0.07573238760232925, -0.019546469673514366, -0.056182123720645905, 0.01064302958548069, 0.036835573613643646, -0.020598452538251877, -0.01925060711801052, -0.027181901037693024, 0.03346148878335953, 0.012754298746585846, 0.01341952569782734, 0.0472945012152195, 0.02181587740778923, 0.00859101489186287, 0.0008062128908932209, -0.04608311876654625, -0.012569180689752102, -0.03163415938615799, -0.02943533845245838, -0.0474361926317215, -0.018037695437669754, 0.009365477599203587, 0.03237026184797287, 0.0020597102120518684, 0.049587588757276535, -0.011394097469747066, -0.024461990222334862, -0.013438773341476917, 0.030015714466571808, -0.0009891334921121597, -0.04422267898917198, 0.012220845557749271, 0.005559602752327919, -0.021463558077812195, -0.017626430839300156, 0.01974429003894329, -0.022754106670618057, 0.021246450021862984, 0.006616025697439909, -0.04674394056200981, 0.026093997061252594, -0.004293861798942089, -0.0034054976422339678, 0.0139601556584239, -0.0005696714506484568, 0.034116052091121674, 0.01125780213624239, 0.04083143174648285, -0.019057288765907288, -0.026099201291799545, 0.014217488467693329, 0.011701746843755245, 0.008664608933031559, 0.03521885350346565, -0.04887402802705765, 0.006619029212743044, -0.007404164411127567, -0.0021931668743491173, -0.07512009888887405, -0.02270612120628357, -0.02197900600731373, -0.012267234735190868, -0.0003322782868053764, -0.043776433914899826, 0.03317464515566826, -0.03064671717584133, -0.03993414714932442, 0.02568664588034153, 0.0714426040649414, -0.002919950056821108, -0.007367062382400036, -0.029674623161554337, -0.006104249507188797, 0.09370201081037521, 0.013148442842066288, 0.019476164132356644, -0.017851058393716812, -0.021333925426006317, -0.0031566948164254427, 0.02858736552298069, 0.011960710398852825, -0.013324079103767872, -0.028350582346320152, -0.03432910144329071, -0.012993531301617622, 0.024293135851621628, -0.009084360674023628, 0.0022320332936942577, 0.007747147232294083, -0.01652670092880726, 0.00971431564539671, -0.00842907465994358, 0.03171321749687195, 0.026654163375496864, -0.013104505836963654, -0.007522057741880417, 0.0077436333522200584, -0.022187644615769386, 0.003060488263145089, 0.04329388588666916, 0.00038830487756058574, -0.024786878377199173, -0.0070212222635746, 0.0537041500210762, -0.0010915760649368167, 0.01375087071210146, -0.015727682039141655, -0.022672919556498528, 0.04511108249425888, -0.02266990952193737, -0.0004890013951808214, -0.02362937480211258, 0.021226946264505386, -0.030622487887740135, -0.03270549699664116, -0.048409949988126755, -0.018128156661987305, 0.04758382961153984, 0.00350392353720963, 0.06780562549829483, 0.0670667290687561, 0.01776573620736599, -0.022537613287568092, -0.05948052555322647, 0.00558592239394784, 0.006405378691852093, -0.011460468173027039, 0.03831920400261879, 0.02428656630218029, 0.013159670867025852, 0.04942040890455246, 0.03029305674135685, -0.0033347164280712605, 0.040448740124702454, -0.0007723813178017735, 0.051406893879175186, 0.051223330199718475, -0.013494395650923252, -0.0364292748272419, 0.02873043529689312, -0.04191562160849571, -0.003241298720240593, -0.014795028604567051, 0.008527479134500027, 0.030907180160284042, 0.0207771435379982, 0.01043643243610859, -0.037778519093990326, -0.04807298630475998, -0.03565460816025734, 0.03219999000430107, 0.036921482533216476, -0.04767843708395958, 0.047351788729429245, 0.06094830110669136, 0.014183632098138332, -0.008031896315515041, 0.02819225564599037, -0.03422785922884941, -0.09553726017475128, -0.039512500166893005, -0.057738251984119415, 0.0006139496108517051, 0.035311128944158554, -0.0019222652772441506, -0.054502371698617935, 0.00844439398497343, -0.055036284029483795, 0.057235222309827805, -0.010525559075176716, 0.029422150924801826, 0.0048971353098750114, 0.04205543175339699, -0.022468486800789833, 0.0044722361490130424, -0.00200461782515049, 0.05410205200314522, 0.10359906405210495, 0.045713845640420914, 0.021480511873960495, -0.06626050919294357, 0.01116969808936119, -0.016715645790100098, -0.026160622015595436, -0.018211649730801582, 0.0012851461069658399, -0.00793515145778656, -0.035371895879507065, 0.02530570700764656, 0.0011051109759137034, 0.027867605909705162, 0.007909451611340046, 0.06679003685712814, -0.01576921157538891, 0.0126753905788064, 0.03204828128218651, 0.0070144664496183395, 0.01433106791228056, -0.01975090242922306, -0.023707902058959007, 0.028702378273010254, 0.002271851757541299, -0.051662378013134, -0.026856381446123123, 0.01654747687280178, 0.02293507382273674, -0.007406090851873159, -0.026535680517554283, 0.020561758428812027, 0.005463976878672838, 0.03805961459875107, -0.015828805044293404, 0.0003436136175878346, -0.006664448417723179, -0.029320739209651947, -0.0026578670367598534, 0.0026185361202806234, 0.02320658043026924, -0.03451455011963844, 0.00456871185451746, 0.006460277829319239, -0.043790340423583984, -0.032464005053043365, -0.013305448926985264, 0.06503908336162567, 0.028603149577975273, -0.016362318769097328, -0.006468174047768116, 0.03472413495182991, 0.0046132211573421955, -0.007345571648329496, -0.0016627872828394175, 0.013621542602777481, 0.024077916517853737, -0.012064489535987377, 0.007913494482636452, -0.008215631358325481, 0.03686925396323204, 0.006852870341390371, 0.04324978590011597, 0.01587224192917347, -0.05186416953802109, -0.021364079788327217, -0.009721238166093826, -0.016465337947010994, -0.01415941771119833, -0.02517220564186573, 0.024751335382461548, -0.02168983966112137, 0.004781210795044899, -0.007500818464905024, -0.0008136255783028901, 0.01080954261124134, 0.02119365520775318, -0.015772435814142227, -0.0009408782352693379, -0.033193353563547134, -0.049288880079984665, 0.007155833300203085, -0.017061550170183182, 0.0111490897834301, 0.0020330017432570457, 0.0077939764596521854, -0.017130963504314423, 0.019052334129810333, 0.012108986265957355, -0.006506842095404863, 0.019678514450788498, 0.038401901721954346, 0.005013910587877035, -0.04598696902394295, -0.04701906070113182, -0.01613686792552471, -0.020426157861948013, 0.0669177696108818, 0.015627680346369743, 0.04233831912279129, 0.014302014373242855, 0.0012051608646288514, 0.001746706198900938, 0.039854153990745544, -0.004387348424643278, -0.01669284701347351, -0.006344689056277275, -0.05230512097477913, 0.0024566047359257936, -0.003878191579133272, 0.0029881142545491457, 0.009591308422386646, -0.012973915785551071, -0.01487390510737896, -0.009593967348337173, 0.01381644606590271, -0.016446107998490334, -0.02109055407345295, 0.0029257009737193584, -0.01914285309612751, 0.017094625160098076, -0.03449917584657669, 0.005363090895116329, -0.024382619187235832, 0.012024441733956337, 0.010351108387112617, -0.06099225953221321, 0.02944527007639408, 0.003038574941456318, 0.013999365270137787, 0.013963445089757442, 0.00898532010614872, 0.01029158290475607, 0.02988322451710701, 0.00540028465911746, 0.038506198674440384, 0.004429456777870655, 0.06547916680574417, -0.03629318252205849, -0.011722588911652565, 0.0016876274021342397, -0.05136920511722565, -0.0033605284988880157, 0.015650520101189613, 0.005369116086512804, 0.016472384333610535, 0.028477786108851433, -0.0051462831906974316, -0.007687552832067013, 0.05482162907719612, -0.01966964825987816, -0.015659857541322708, -0.02493670955300331, 0.05090780556201935, -0.03174487128853798, 0.018381057307124138, 0.005071381106972694, -0.002514288993552327, -0.03094063140451908, 0.004390506073832512, 0.030162807554006577, 0.024329911917448044, -0.05440422147512436, 0.026504049077630043, 0.02224344201385975, 0.02362298220396042, -0.01633942313492298, 0.022047054022550583, 0.07715010643005371, 0.0394662581384182, -0.012209679000079632, 0.012646233662962914, 0.02195378765463829, 0.041444331407547, -0.14113107323646545, -0.020974168553948402, 0.01752629689872265, 0.04575178399682045, 0.02613433636724949, -0.053811535239219666, 0.027894770726561546, 0.023518795147538185, -0.04368472471833229, -0.018646547570824623, 0.004457228817045689, -0.005377792287617922, -0.04821183905005455, 0.007426869124174118, -0.014736395329236984, -0.006174385081976652, 0.03324512764811516, -0.008717397227883339, 0.0254695862531662, 0.01867273636162281, -0.0025372100062668324, -0.027999993413686752, -0.04177412763237953, 0.0076273707672953606, 0.01825902611017227, -0.06683143228292465, -0.004325149115175009, -0.029491979628801346, -0.05540928989648819, 0.01366058737039566, -0.0246622022241354, -0.005265497136861086, 0.048546869307756424, 0.04801575094461441, 0.020085712894797325, 0.02033962868154049, 0.035615891218185425, 0.01441735029220581, 0.007978629320859909, -0.012886805459856987, -0.009316534735262394, 0.042540598660707474, 0.015766765922307968, 0.0135341202840209, 0.018317105248570442, -0.026493189856410027, 0.0004044908273499459, 0.017382055521011353, -0.01910812221467495, -0.03886067122220993, -0.02268158085644245, -0.0221270639449358, -0.015400901436805725, -0.028627611696720123, 0.02924123778939247, -0.048935163766145706, 0.008136491291224957, 0.02344667911529541, -0.002467289799824357, -0.0062695760279893875, 0.016244927421212196, -0.011458558961749077, -0.058822862803936005, -0.0034725978039205074, 0.045962557196617126, -0.010135515592992306, -0.033700186759233475, 0.005311247892677784, -0.012026757001876831, -0.039549920707941055, -0.0484912171959877, 0.0013783550821244717, -0.027105357497930527, 0.0633603185415268, -0.037101294845342636, 0.035528190433979034, 0.010655119083821774, 0.025885609909892082, 0.011230643838644028, -0.07020249217748642, 0.047668877989053726, 0.035059891641139984, -0.019787315279245377, -0.032557833939790726, 0.03220280632376671, -0.05351363494992256, -0.004292039666324854, 0.018310172483325005, -0.01761142536997795, 0.026266945526003838, -0.016001829877495766, -0.0005392551538534462, -0.054373811930418015, -0.03746628761291504, 0.04151732474565506, -0.015926223248243332, -0.0186349768191576, -0.015676451846957207, 0.02399495057761669, 0.020929021760821342, -0.0004344362241681665, -0.009375038556754589, -0.006755237001925707, -0.027386104688048363, 0.019913259893655777, -0.006397381890565157, 0.019015243276953697, 0.04092951864004135, 0.01795119047164917, 0.0018296486232429743, 0.009042036719620228, 0.0032211116049438715, 0.035223908722400665, 0.0010668940376490355, -0.07547300308942795, 0.03251632675528526, -0.035330772399902344, -0.044675104320049286, -0.01563696749508381, 0.01125637348741293, 0.016375211998820305, -0.043221041560173035, 0.000010450320587551687, 0.053161703050136566, -0.009724639356136322, 0.025591565296053886, 0.011598300188779831, 0.02153617888689041, 0.028988104313611984, -0.009965247474610806, 0.008978317491710186, 0.02429034747183323, 0.0024032494984567165, 0.011475931853055954, -0.005285060498863459, -0.0030398794915527105, 0.04386502131819725, 0.002762189134955406, -0.005135666579008102, 0.0015504325274378061, 0.02587507665157318, 0.0093473419547081, 0.04538249596953392, -0.01655111089348793, 0.011460833251476288, -0.015326759777963161, -0.0017259260639548302, 0.021826691925525665, -0.01591351628303528, -0.012124980799853802, 0.041552748531103134, -0.025388922542333603, -0.03753722086548805, -0.07698614150285721, -0.010381788946688175, -0.012770048342645168, -0.0199725441634655, 0.042553141713142395, 0.04742530360817909, 0.00816547591239214, -0.002787400037050247, 0.017450353130698204, -0.03900701925158501, 0.005501515697687864, -0.05263153836131096, 0.03875114396214485, -0.00843925029039383, -0.008056139573454857, 0.009682158939540386, -0.02454771101474762, -0.012635369785130024, -0.028955772519111633, 0.031132908537983894, 0.05589970201253891, 0.04781855642795563, -0.03816132992506027, -0.00474679796025157, -0.00908647757023573, 0.02915417216718197, -0.0763382762670517, -0.027630150318145752, -0.005257155746221542, 0.02589145489037037, -0.008494770154356956, -0.005694000981748104 ]
<p>I have a collection of training documents with publication dates, where each document is labeled as belonging (or not) to some topic T. I want to train a model that will predict for a new document (with publication date) whether or not it belongs to T, where the publication date might be in the past or in the future. Assume that I have decomposed each training document's text into a set of features (e.g., TF-IDF of words or n-grams) suitable for analysis by an appropriate binary classification algorithm provided by a library like Weka (for instance, multinomial naive Bayes, random forests, or SVM). The concept to be learned exhibits multiple seasonality; i.e., the prior probability that an arbitrary document published on a given date belongs to T depends heavily on when the date falls in a 4-year cycle (due to elections), where it falls in an annual cycle (due to holidays), and on the day of the week.</p> <p>My research indicates that classification algorithms generally assume (as part of their statistical models) that training data is randomly sampled from the same pool of data that the model will ultimately be applied to. When the distribution of classes in the training data differs substantially from the known distribution in the wild, this leads to the so-called "class imbalance" problem. There are ways of compensating for this, including over-sampling underrepresented classes, under-sampling overrepresented classes, and using cost-sensitive classification. This allows a model creator to implicitly specify the prior probability that a new document will be positively classified, but importantly (and unfortunately for my purposes), this prior probability is assumed to be equal for all new documents.</p> <p>I require more flexibility in my model. Because of the concept's seasonality, when classifying a new document, the model must explicitly take the publication date into account when determining the prior probability that the document belongs to T, and when the model calculates the posterior probability of belonging to T in light of the document's features, this prior probability should be properly accounted for. I am looking for a classifier implementation that either (1) bakes sophisticated regression of prior probabilities based on dates into the classifier, or (2) can be extended with a user-specified regression function that takes a date as input and gives the prior probability as output.</p> <p>I am most familiar with the Weka library, but am open to using other tools if they are appropriate to the job. What is the most straightforward way of accomplishing this task?</p>
15,738
[ -0.013348083011806011, -0.025121774524450302, 0.019894914701581, -0.03873062506318092, 0.03480023890733719, 0.01864154264330864, 0.004150832071900368, 0.03498208895325661, 0.014268534258008003, -0.028673112392425537, 0.023785365745425224, 0.07720400393009186, 0.03875790908932686, 0.01689363270998001, -0.0347633920609951, -0.0045583429746329784, -0.009435877203941345, 0.009734432213008404, -0.017589738592505455, 0.00137777638155967, 0.025034986436367035, 0.035512033849954605, 0.020024312660098076, -0.0051072994247078896, -0.03798304498195648, 0.016117051243782043, 0.00036064229789189994, -0.017201628535985947, 0.012120865285396576, 0.050196029245853424, -0.05501103401184082, 0.008678383193910122, 0.010790791362524033, 0.04324722662568092, 0.012641815468668938, 0.02780207060277462, 0.01359335333108902, -0.04323071613907814, -0.03795139491558075, 0.008713342249393463, -0.007592862471938133, 0.02644839510321617, -0.019542375579476357, 0.03308986872434616, -0.03740351274609566, 0.02007840760052204, -0.009459848515689373, 0.005562464240938425, 0.056921400129795074, -0.012756897136569023, 0.05903713405132294, -0.018556781113147736, 0.023682311177253723, 0.04365293309092522, -0.04186097905039787, -0.03293052315711975, 0.02383837290108204, 0.095701202750206, 0.009336095303297043, -0.013370813801884651, -0.04288399592041969, -0.02236103266477585, 0.001466100220568478, -0.014345637522637844, -0.02802368812263012, 0.0063273427076637745, 0.018449651077389717, -0.02272290736436844, 0.018983079120516777, -0.04798036813735962, 0.0022018603049218655, -0.05039412900805473, 0.004167797975242138, 0.0004405906074680388, 0.018823524937033653, -0.03923901170492172, -0.00396861182525754, 0.05543867126107216, 0.005391967017203569, -0.0005976366810500622, 0.009573581628501415, -0.007115642540156841, -0.00369063438847661, 0.03832106664776802, 0.034104932099580765, -0.020633023232221603, 0.055684659630060196, -0.017790641635656357, 0.013408309780061245, 0.027714675292372704, -0.016660312190651894, 0.009709612466394901, 0.030680527910590172, -0.040935467928647995, -0.018340347334742546, 0.04709155485033989, 0.0175786092877388, -0.01217508316040039, -0.012555939145386219, 0.00786369014531374, -0.011702606454491615, -0.04502703994512558, -0.001076935208402574, 0.06334047019481659, -0.06385304778814316, -0.032514166086912155, -0.03883127495646477, -0.034046318382024765, -0.00983386393636465, 0.006893940269947052, -0.03904557228088379, 0.008064253255724907, 0.006786417681723833, -0.011820903047919273, 0.01416473276913166, -0.0021240722853690386, 0.00013365612539928406, -0.020656080916523933, 0.026394858956336975, 0.05931631848216057, 0.03507440909743309, -0.03796931728720665, 0.03995878994464874, -0.057477619498968124, -0.025885265320539474, -0.0019347063498571515, 0.002974666655063629, -0.0370117723941803, -0.007492908276617527, 0.0032375999726355076, 0.03135208413004875, -0.05088408291339874, 0.05324100703001022, -0.01846793107688427, 0.00692249508574605, 0.02299903891980648, -0.02717343345284462, -0.03951423615217209, 0.037807587534189224, 0.013489087112247944, 0.0075325267389416695, -0.05326290428638458, 0.0008492814376950264, 0.013595806434750557, 0.031126167625188828, 0.011930238455533981, 0.060992978513240814, 0.03188813105225563, 0.03283320739865303, 0.012120235711336136, -0.008603585883975029, 0.027456283569335938, -0.03036164678633213, 0.004175032954663038, -0.04689491540193558, -0.04862307757139206, 0.03305382281541824, 0.006846918724477291, 0.012474477291107178, 0.017708882689476013, 0.020401647314429283, 0.0091337775811553, -0.03237733617424965, 0.01077948696911335, 0.033533018082380295, -0.043514177203178406, 0.06041503697633743, 0.04240615293383598, 0.033691950142383575, -0.010820338502526283, 0.004681695252656937, 0.024631356820464134, 0.015054143033921719, 0.049535442143678665, 0.040390145033597946, -0.021461736410856247, 0.0016657866071909666, -0.020712019875645638, 0.013278728350996971, 0.00037964581861160696, -0.018348174169659615, -0.034398697316646576, -0.05017007514834404, -0.01790725626051426, 0.012811793945729733, 0.017801925539970398, 0.013200406916439533, 0.015794118866324425, 0.066655233502388, -0.05984703078866005, -0.04315514862537384, -0.03577136620879173, 0.015708420425653458, -0.048462219536304474, -0.037404000759124756, 0.0635378286242485, 0.008852017112076283, 0.0037369360215961933, -0.018553277477622032, -0.0460188090801239, -0.020255621522665024, -0.0026908768340945244, 0.055346712470054626, -0.05444849282503128, -0.012722129002213478, 0.04435477405786514, 0.0065887002274394035, 0.00872853584587574, 0.03593188524246216, -0.047485534101724625, -0.08620072901248932, -0.020347245037555695, -0.042901258915662766, 0.010969669558107853, -0.05063319951295853, -0.0343509167432785, 0.04554911330342293, -0.020527483895421028, -0.018811283633112907, 0.043097928166389465, -0.0411243736743927, 0.04309501126408577, 0.05620840936899185, -0.01378042995929718, 0.008981126360595226, 0.05635587498545647, 0.029855314642190933, 0.02965248003602028, -0.02748984843492508, 0.0032004774548113346, -0.02096632868051529, -0.01181863620877266, 0.052194658666849136, 0.0074785370379686356, -0.010967041365802288, 0.03638254478573799, 0.03504394739866257, 0.02239505760371685, 0.005555105861276388, 0.040594737976789474, -0.014488264918327332, 0.007090408820658922, 0.041820019483566284, -0.0139382965862751, 0.04250182956457138, -0.01815086230635643, 0.029591502621769905, -0.040080659091472626, -0.0005750516429543495, -0.012654762715101242, -0.022398896515369415, 0.0031356329564005136, 0.004893998149782419, -0.002096594078466296, -0.012141630984842777, -0.007071549538522959, 0.0360846221446991, -0.02932116948068142, -0.011276843957602978, 0.021277152001857758, 0.0019189186859875917, 0.03186935931444168, 0.018458357080817223, -0.042309995740652084, 0.013248518109321594, 0.04369111731648445, -0.03504883870482445, 0.001966088777408004, 0.02922496572136879, -0.0170879065990448, 0.01134964544326067, 0.014855366200208664, -0.041731514036655426, -0.009317276068031788, 0.03687175735831261, 0.012622897513210773, -0.0029654959216713905, 0.00494025181978941, 0.008491110987961292, 0.006766099948436022, 0.023333190008997917, 0.0337078794836998, 0.020517289638519287, -0.015198989771306515, -0.040809761732816696, 0.036692582070827484, -0.010572158731520176, -0.0554768331348896, 0.05495968461036682, 0.03112778253853321, -0.046496566385030746, -0.009734252467751503, 0.023447193205356598, -0.04134271666407585, -0.023887457326054573, -0.04666743054986, -0.02333313226699829, -0.05298377200961113, -0.012220424599945545, 0.04937157779932022, -0.0026213601231575012, -0.05832608416676521, 0.01621352508664131, -0.013471934013068676, -0.041744329035282135, -0.01630335859954357, -0.032055750489234924, -0.02190452814102173, -0.025121834129095078, 0.004157618619501591, 0.03755180537700653, 0.02423553727567196, -0.020174313336610794, -0.0597870871424675, -0.07116493582725525, 0.007858788594603539, -0.022836090996861458, 0.059540800750255585, 0.04376114159822464, 0.057451773434877396, 0.070034459233284, 0.05732440948486328, -0.0002349259302718565, -0.0005846277344971895, -0.001023481716401875, -0.0011896699434146285, -0.029396163299679756, 0.014858735725283623, -0.0011748395627364516, 0.006721437908709049, 0.011569463647902012, -0.007078452035784721, -0.029994115233421326, 0.06485895812511444, -0.00632958859205246, -0.04341112822294235, 0.03691478818655014, -0.0009101719479076564, 0.0048227556981146336, 0.03364226967096329, 0.019727535545825958, -0.02712666243314743, -0.01977996900677681, -0.03727879002690315, 0.019638368859887123, 0.04189778491854668, -0.024190841242671013, 0.011250875890254974, -0.02067163772881031, 0.00428417231887579, -0.031030183658003807, 0.04026761278510094, -0.024055935442447662, -0.05261467769742012, 0.0032875852193683386, 0.0025803532917052507, 0.039367131888866425, -0.014584595337510109, -0.009723001159727573, 0.04255474731326103, 0.045404769480228424, -0.01173446886241436, 0.002556791063398123, -0.06828644126653671, 0.004086571745574474, 0.03572454676032066, -0.030571067705750465, 0.023408235982060432, 0.0483805313706398, 0.023673947900533676, 0.0016974060563370585, 0.011741489171981812, -0.05212034657597542, -0.015138735063374043, -0.026682261377573013, -0.007097852416336536, -0.020761409774422646, 0.03498583287000656, -0.006291161756962538, -0.01143159344792366, -0.030504470691084862, -0.01122366450726986, 0.015177125111222267, 0.039628222584724426, -0.07105749845504761, -0.008179707452654839, 0.003058496629819274, 0.0017311226110905409, -0.018150364980101585, -0.020075559616088867, 0.04123730957508087, -0.011650346219539642, -0.02888484299182892, -0.02268843911588192, 0.008439318276941776, -0.033943306654691696, 0.021191008388996124, -0.021430304273962975, -0.030495742335915565, -0.006083827465772629, 0.004893279168754816, 0.03665052726864815, -0.006432449910789728, 0.0439847856760025, 0.004894086625427008, 0.04443483054637909, -0.015879252925515175, -0.02232634834945202, 0.05922507867217064, -0.005652460269629955, 0.017357148230075836, 0.021663939580321312, 0.05150199308991432, -0.06542885303497314, 0.02062791958451271, 0.016198191791772842, 0.03594108670949936, 0.047276366502046585, -0.0275349710136652, 0.004906565882265568, -0.07196927070617676, -0.03354543074965477, 0.058212775737047195, 0.02542746625840664, 0.005859034601598978, -0.01795649155974388, 0.012092280201613903, 0.010786389000713825, -0.072352334856987, -0.017904384061694145, 0.066766157746315, -0.01036426518112421, 0.002902233973145485, -0.013156013563275337, 0.015509932301938534, -0.003317611524835229, 0.030720984563231468, -0.007490036077797413, 0.028331689536571503, 0.024688659235835075, -0.005175136495381594, -0.017180724069476128, -0.008674049749970436, -0.03509874641895294, -0.0017949091270565987, -0.001280038384720683, 0.028787851333618164, -0.0009538966696709394, 0.0089481882750988, 0.03135594725608826, 0.06981099396944046, 0.023495571687817574, 0.030623219907283783, 0.04236218333244324, -0.12435168027877808, -0.025529056787490845, 0.05574343353509903, 0.04526561126112938, -0.019293729215860367, -0.020785875618457794, -0.03776625171303749, 0.010583415627479553, 0.029082009568810463, 0.014224156737327576, 0.01676139235496521, 0.019643761217594147, 0.007949242368340492, 0.006332340184599161, -0.03139929845929146, -0.003228937741369009, 0.045869529247283936, -0.01655443198978901, 0.05153495445847511, 0.009750875644385815, -0.02036634460091591, -0.05047602206468582, 0.001978451618924737, 0.018185380846261978, 0.04657648131251335, -0.031758297234773636, -0.039614904671907425, -0.009327362291514874, 0.009542460553348064, -0.007721500005573034, -0.0695309042930603, -0.0289240013808012, 0.0014507109299302101, 0.01813329942524433, -0.001464963424950838, -0.034778282046318054, -0.03303077071905136, 0.039455804973840714, 0.015742115676403046, -0.051447559148073196, 0.0019487503450363874, -0.01827014982700348, -0.007582590449601412, 0.0279687587171793, 0.017690686509013176, 0.053277771919965744, 0.046761129051446915, 0.02711351588368416, -0.00654078833758831, -0.02530161663889885, -0.0024267437402158976, -0.022366849705576897, -0.013895784504711628, -0.033613186329603195, 0.00020676490385085344, -0.019943224266171455, 0.015797004103660583, -0.008571267127990723, -0.005094368942081928, 0.011863669380545616, -0.028237659484148026, -0.022383155301213264, -0.020146556198596954, -0.019665731117129326, -0.03884955123066902, -0.016568636521697044, 0.024963121861219406, -0.047166068106889725, 0.05248270183801651, 0.0075424304232001305, -0.009115265682339668, 0.020061951130628586, 0.013448053039610386, -0.04123583436012268, 0.02129405178129673, -0.05027053877711296, -0.015246945433318615, 0.006149446126073599, 0.00901571661233902, 0.04313233494758606, 0.009422684088349342, 0.06270036846399307, 0.014252417720854282, -0.028181659057736397, -0.021209226921200752, 0.018308188766241074, 0.003217916237190366, 0.046147070825099945, -0.02295675501227379, -0.0044855098240077496, 0.002263476140797138, -0.032821230590343475, -0.04654986783862114, -0.007019737269729376, 0.017277970910072327, 0.00032530503813177347, -0.07540880143642426, -0.000018247914340463467, 0.031592387706041336, 0.020392127335071564, -0.026641543954610825, 0.012820982374250889, 0.06789771467447281, -0.021450025960803032, -0.016618069261312485, -0.03292026370763779, 0.030598977580666542, 0.05633220449090004, -0.047620560973882675, 0.03880084306001663, 0.014164573512971401, 0.001147718750871718, -0.004942801780998707, -0.006719795521348715, 0.00962105393409729, -0.04231701046228409, -0.010882665403187275, -0.01340689416974783, 0.013431522063910961, 0.0246280524879694, -0.017855329439044, -0.025462452322244644, 0.04025371000170708, -0.017858512699604034, 0.008412349969148636, -0.03734184429049492, 0.019754981622099876, 0.02885131724178791, -0.019929470494389534, -0.06835813075304031, -0.0015819711843505502, 0.035819604992866516, -0.01876131445169449, 0.006638634949922562, -0.021691318601369858, 0.0015916856937110424, 0.009699851274490356, 0.03396027535200119, -0.020467696711421013, 0.019486112520098686, 0.010322390124201775, -0.02052510716021061, 0.03947256878018379, 0.01605348289012909, -0.011468972079455853, 0.008318934589624405, -0.02887597307562828, -0.03619208186864853, -0.020309045910835266, -0.042411480098962784, -0.0013119191862642765, 0.05372682958841324, -0.009795892052352428, 0.05478261038661003, 0.04620034247636795, 0.00021052168449386954, 0.006715212482959032, -0.043601419776678085, -0.028879361227154732, -0.008109867572784424, -0.03665318340063095, 0.028504442423582077, -0.03261720389127731, -0.014462997205555439, 0.024292100220918655, -0.02379257045686245, 0.014507399871945381, 0.09331315010786057, -0.006744192913174629, 0.021069779992103577, 0.039638083428144455, -0.05207649990916252, -0.04663386568427086, 0.013058721087872982, -0.03877381980419159, 0.00894754659384489, -0.00949277076870203, -0.055287595838308334, 0.03421705216169357, 0.01800735481083393, -0.013008258305490017, -0.07027167826890945, -0.029896114021539688, -0.06302909553050995, 0.04567298665642738, 0.02092328667640686, -0.009780083782970905, 0.01703396812081337, 0.011909042485058308, 0.01554708369076252, -0.0012124639470130205, 0.019549613818526268, -0.020706679672002792, -0.05511712655425072, -0.03020399622619152, -0.04546161741018295, -0.04297168552875519, 0.008505314588546753, -0.006004005204886198, -0.006663838401436806, -0.00902791228145361, -0.013559370301663876, 0.03577806428074837, 0.01961568556725979, 0.06497293710708618, 0.001962902257218957, 0.04724110662937164, -0.009860389865934849, 0.022031983360648155, -0.029764462262392044, 0.0079592764377594, 0.16723623871803284, 0.08400609344244003, 0.08193711191415787, -0.03495323285460472, 0.0365385077893734, -0.010055809281766415, -0.0010343152098357677, -0.03420770540833473, 0.007673314306885004, 0.00317028327845037, -0.05232802405953407, 0.024130716919898987, 0.011062176898121834, 0.0074314819648861885, -0.02203691564500332, 0.04954199120402336, -0.04248553887009621, 0.030887486413121223, -0.005787890404462814, -0.00583264185115695, 0.06560219079256058, 0.014856934547424316, -0.05429458990693092, -0.004759522620588541, 0.021823115646839142, -0.015208367258310318, -0.026343362405896187, -0.05606250837445259, -0.03176082670688629, 0.011658606119453907, -0.003547833999618888, -0.006234488449990749, 0.02377139963209629, 0.029244739562273026, 0.04650839790701866, 0.0036765653640031815, -0.009683285839855671, -0.03704257681965828, 0.007639735005795956, 0.023486357182264328, 0.05863666906952858, -0.008662384003400803, 0.008150165900588036, 0.0202670618891716, -0.030432336032390594, 0.0023153992369771004, -0.05529145523905754, 0.037100665271282196, -0.015946971252560616, -0.015742434188723564, -0.016605058684945107, -0.035324592143297195, 0.022800812497735023, -0.009805706329643726, -0.029711786657571793, 0.02977277897298336, 0.029365403577685356, 0.021536190062761307, -0.014866099692881107, 0.0019824448972940445, 0.04092409834265709, 0.017394203692674637, 0.044035594910383224, 0.009847559034824371, -0.034886110574007034, -0.037787728011608124, -0.008616048842668533, 0.01214083842933178, 0.031704243272542953, -0.00036326644476503134, -0.007282956037670374, -0.002283818554133177, -0.046244245022535324, -0.04706695303320885, -0.018318012356758118, 0.005164457950741053, 0.01050070021301508, -0.02972318045794964, -0.013829555362462997, -0.013563347049057484, 0.009167886339128017, -0.011866092681884766, -0.013812797144055367, 0.019248731434345245, -0.046916067600250244, 0.0299700777977705, 0.010730826295912266, 0.01480709109455347, 0.03462570905685425, 0.018224366009235382, 0.017765924334526062, 0.06579702347517014, 0.019663821905851364, -0.03102889098227024, -0.003962996881455183, -0.04457061365246773, -0.0017335955053567886, 0.006611030548810959, 0.019076397642493248, 0.03738190233707428, 0.04807642847299576, 0.003991746809333563, -0.003320606891065836, 0.043691568076610565, 0.00853934045881033, 0.0025506936945021152, -0.005477431695908308, -0.06696465611457825, -0.015989389270544052, 0.0024220512714236975, -0.002125570783391595, -0.029466303065419197, -0.0338919498026371, -0.008742262609302998, -0.014378544874489307, 0.021011710166931152, -0.021561352536082268, -0.051578111946582794, 0.0026622628793120384, -0.014694779179990292, 0.03019760176539421, -0.0014158935518935323, -0.000195209271623753, -0.01493240986019373, -0.0022086019162088633, -0.03270958364009857, -0.015933727845549583, 0.01756925880908966, 0.03684619441628456, -0.023101676255464554, -0.017910629510879517, 0.049392104148864746, 0.009123889729380608, 0.011763439513742924, 0.02343033440411091, 0.035752471536397934, 0.013117795810103416, 0.014605598524212837, -0.007247264962643385, -0.017779456451535225, 0.008059129118919373, -0.011784631758928299, -0.012259681709110737, 0.026498012244701385, -0.028466721996665, 0.028058333322405815, 0.021287711337208748, 0.002586046000942588, -0.021303528919816017, 0.030007660388946533, -0.04148952662944794, -0.016633447259664536, -0.01809070073068142, 0.022591233253479004, 0.019811546429991722, -0.007546217180788517, 0.004827660042792559, 0.0007578750373795629, -0.008043229579925537, -0.0028733264189213514, 0.02706194669008255, 0.035925161093473434, -0.03668622672557831, 0.027465548366308212, -0.021176889538764954, -0.022259337827563286, -0.012647001072764397, -0.001198124373331666, 0.023562828078866005, 0.033824093639850616, -0.033673495054244995, 0.05449152737855911, 0.03037850186228752, 0.00317495153285563, -0.06564446538686752, -0.02893298678100109, 0.06309521943330765, 0.005147435702383518, 0.03752356395125389, -0.02832132577896118, 0.008926810696721077, 0.02442314475774765, -0.029193740338087082, 0.04399313032627106, -0.022123388946056366, -0.016189582645893097, -0.04014807939529419, 0.03531860187649727, -0.04896681010723114, -0.012448920868337154, -0.0005196008132770658, -0.008047370240092278, 0.02111182175576687, 0.05460347235202789, 0.0065286350436508656, -0.04414352774620056, -0.04525195434689522, -0.013067159801721573, 0.016937371343374252, -0.022452998906373978, 0.04896748065948486, -0.061443645507097244, -0.02202429622411728, 0.047790177166461945, 0.013525000773370266, 0.003620433621108532, 0.03998585045337677, 0.012120585888624191, 0.021704992279410362, 0.016354234889149666, 0.07136233150959015, -0.002472039544954896, 0.011197429150342941, 0.012376942671835423, 0.012532368302345276, 0.056837860494852066, 0.000037098161556059495, 0.03221212700009346, -0.01505302544683218, -0.031156597658991814, -0.003994917031377554, 0.022285791113972664, -0.024723447859287262, -0.003157722530886531, -0.0009314225753769279, 0.025105878710746765, -0.019557617604732513, 0.017902236431837082, 0.005692233331501484, -0.054442960768938065, 0.0014071043115109205, 0.033648815006017685, 0.026035049930214882, -0.024562522768974304, 0.006663447245955467, -0.054578039795160294, -0.056368108838796616, 0.031041156500577927, 0.004093991592526436, -0.00284781027585268, -0.03277817368507385, 0.0023765985388308764, 0.019640641286969185, -0.024020114913582802, -0.022160660475492477, -0.025676079094409943, -0.04407934471964836, 0.01367446593940258, -0.04594244435429573, 0.016392601653933525, -0.02770712412893772, 0.005250274669378996, 0.03652510046958923, -0.09082718193531036, 0.05374022200703621, -0.023015519604086876, 0.0025332828518003225, -0.02118021249771118, -0.015727180987596512, -0.04555072262883186, 0.0034738131798803806, 0.017093311995267868, -0.026065971702337265, 0.02963446080684662, -0.010543775744736195, -0.0014120170380920172, 0.010101507417857647, -0.04807599261403084, 0.036396272480487823, -0.00021957751596346498, -0.02001951076090336, -0.012898435816168785, -0.025466904044151306, -0.029293756932020187, -0.0024470093194395304, 0.01929357834160328, -0.0015135245630517602, 0.011911571025848389, 0.05307988077402115, -0.000439514551544562, 0.03284738212823868, 0.007314817514270544, 0.025079883635044098, 0.03129706159234047, 0.03950270637869835, 0.003541033947840333, -0.005839918740093708, 0.0016510994173586369, -0.06485947966575623, 0.027615610510110855, -0.03766355291008949, -0.06806659698486328, 0.00938408449292183, 0.05108151212334633, -0.017911149188876152, -0.0428725890815258, 0.010671119205653667, 0.027581550180912018, -0.021200936287641525, 0.03849126771092415, 0.03564804792404175, -0.02376306802034378, 0.07362011075019836, -0.012651839293539524, 0.039012596011161804, 0.012442546896636486, -0.01718785986304283, -0.019956348463892937, -0.03608417138457298, -0.00003026086778845638, 0.0027477778494358063, 0.040100354701280594, -0.00800950825214386, 0.006704546045511961, 0.05291769653558731, -0.011431315913796425, 0.03006329946219921, -0.037165310233831406, -0.030478646978735924, 0.03163427859544754, 0.03229393810033798, 0.03320735692977905, 0.0027625029906630516, 0.031070301309227943, 0.02962636388838291, 0.0035930692683905363, 0.0006734413327649236, -0.08109217137098312, -0.015344444662332535, -0.003791601862758398, 0.03608248755335808, -0.014960769563913345, 0.02376900054514408, -0.016474280506372452, 0.020386813208460808, 0.024361658841371536, 0.0021870683412998915, 0.008055632933974266, -0.028429457917809486, 0.04612857103347778, 0.005114929284900427, -0.0008499035029672086, -0.0029193791560828686, -0.030588552355766296, -0.0035941111855208874, -0.039115745574235916, -0.019289441406726837, 0.029469825327396393, 0.04118431732058525, 0.014993133023381233, -0.03341513127088547, -0.0034013076219707727, 0.0023106136359274387, -0.048180535435676575, 0.0033207584638148546, -0.07030177861452103, 0.04107600823044777, -0.0012205253588035703, -0.04682149738073349 ]
<p><strong>Question</strong></p> <p>In some bank, the time it takes from the moment a customer arrives until a clerk is available is distributed normally with $\mu=15,\sigma=2$</p> <p>a. What's the probability for the next client to wait more than 18 minutes?</p> <p>b. What's the prob. that the average waiting time of the next 100 customers will be greater than 15.1 minutes (assuming that the waiting times are independent)</p> <p>c. The bank management hired a new manager for customer service and he claims that since he arrived at this job, the time it takes to be treated by a clerk decreased. To check his claim he measured the waiting time of 30 random customers and got an average of 14.3 minutes. Assuming that the s.d. hasn't changed - Check if his claim is true, with confidence level of a=0.1.</p> <p><strong>My answer</strong></p> <p>a. P(X>18)=(normalizing) P(Z>1.5)=0.0668</p> <p>b. $P(\bar X&gt;15.1)=P(Z&gt;0.5)=0.3085$</p> <p>c. $H_0:\mu=15, H_A:\mu&lt;15$ so $CI=(-\infty,15-Z_0.99 \frac 2{\sqrt{30}}]=(-\infty,14.15]$ but 14.13&lt;14.15 so H_0 is true and not rejected. </p> <p>Also calculating the p-value: $P_{H_0}(\bar X&lt;14.3)=P(Z&lt;-1.91)=0.0281&gt;0.01 $therefore $H_0$ is not rejected.</p> <p>Since this is the first time I've been doing it on my own I'd love if someone take a look, and confirm that it's correct (or not?) </p>
74,196
[ -0.01922989822924137, -0.07794847339391708, 0.0351637564599514, -0.03596410155296326, 0.05163424462080002, -0.024886704981327057, -0.007581694517284632, -0.016690487042069435, -0.011851050890982151, 0.04428917542099953, 0.039831794798374176, 0.046626485884189606, 0.04874977841973305, 0.03308796510100365, -0.00786659587174654, 0.03192698583006859, 0.0022345036268234253, -0.01332599762827158, -0.0033030034974217415, 0.02009201981127262, 0.015902433544397354, -0.01829325035214424, 0.017558827996253967, -0.0370364673435688, -0.050453320145606995, -0.028228148818016052, -0.007616259157657623, -0.022024909034371376, -0.043620023876428604, 0.054557837545871735, -0.04585399478673935, -0.04335225373506546, 0.02438906766474247, 0.01087522879242897, 0.015706123784184456, 0.04781566560268402, -0.027816860005259514, -0.03258507326245308, -0.010954193770885468, 0.017687983810901642, -0.005001055542379618, -0.001137036713771522, 0.02319370210170746, 0.019066032022237778, -0.02692044898867607, 0.023793118074536324, -0.01523821521550417, -0.01938486471772194, 0.03591308370232582, -0.017524363473057747, 0.03547889366745949, -0.016604354605078697, 0.03275129944086075, -0.015403258614242077, -0.012056304141879082, -0.06613784283399582, 0.04143841564655304, 0.03521130979061127, -0.027996739372611046, -0.045123159885406494, 0.004173431545495987, -0.055649444460868835, -0.0129769342020154, -0.029469957575201988, 0.005684724543243647, -0.007210599724203348, 0.012841823510825634, 0.007758048363029957, 0.053922902792692184, -0.025289198383688927, 0.04518566653132439, 0.017978573217988014, 0.01796393282711506, -0.00930520985275507, 0.019579710438847542, -0.012009825557470322, 0.022893456742167473, 0.021937046200037003, 0.02378423698246479, 0.02927510067820549, 0.0013604052364826202, -0.015439075417816639, 0.009858032688498497, 0.043847158551216125, 0.029851870611310005, -0.044639863073825836, 0.10104403644800186, -0.005470707081258297, 0.042951181530952454, 0.012518049217760563, 0.023174094036221504, -0.019885729998350143, 0.005915026180446148, -0.03922397270798683, -0.02935774065554142, 0.08505622297525406, -0.016965817660093307, 0.03701264411211014, 0.010395209304988384, -0.005333535838872194, -0.027095342054963112, -0.046764813363552094, -0.003800205187872052, 0.052197057753801346, 0.001704938942566514, -0.00020875397603958845, -0.008539490401744843, 0.0023372601717710495, -0.008692105300724506, -0.01636360213160515, -0.06653536111116409, 0.03447645902633667, -0.0346224382519722, -0.0030375001952052116, -0.020664194598793983, -0.01083978358656168, -0.03644769266247749, -0.03683536872267723, 0.06523428857326508, 0.004801154602319002, 0.04201991483569145, 0.0010032497812062502, -0.03138120472431183, -0.01431966945528984, -0.03901994228363037, -0.006092241033911705, -0.007238002959638834, -0.02664715051651001, -0.046092689037323, 0.03937700763344765, 0.014829549938440323, 0.03463347628712654, 0.03051142208278179, 0.03758255019783974, -0.008273073472082615, 0.0019572493620216846, -0.060304947197437286, -0.040721770375967026, 0.0335339717566967, -0.005173642188310623, 0.030682213604450226, -0.04315667971968651, -0.036319550126791, 0.05086041986942291, 0.052146315574645996, -0.010624360293149948, 0.05348746106028557, -0.015676239505410194, -0.003860600059852004, 0.041051022708415985, -0.008233187720179558, -0.003349709091708064, -0.026024701073765755, -0.009233729913830757, 0.007207943592220545, -0.059738848358392715, 0.01063046045601368, 0.01205127127468586, -0.023931168019771576, -0.07366152852773666, 0.009120086207985878, 0.013831619173288345, 0.005779980216175318, -0.05163302272558212, 0.02234460972249508, -0.017218193039298058, 0.06756270676851273, 0.0009196144528687, 0.016184084117412567, 0.028698768466711044, 0.008808688260614872, 0.019515827298164368, -0.01885676197707653, 0.03133302927017212, 0.042442191392183304, -0.03699982538819313, 0.022027330473065376, 0.03457413613796234, -0.0005401912494562566, 0.023042835295200348, -0.023106781765818596, 0.02842392958700657, -0.055602043867111206, 0.014022168703377247, -0.0377015545964241, 0.008449935354292393, -0.014025560580193996, -0.023125506937503815, -0.0012678316561505198, -0.04229886829853058, -0.05132095143198967, -0.08590950071811676, 0.027007155120372772, 0.023645682260394096, 0.0026044375263154507, 0.040641967207193375, 0.00793466717004776, -0.036766067147254944, 0.0007841638871468604, 0.00679482938721776, -0.03328707814216614, 0.002796732122078538, 0.018583865836262703, -0.04911893978714943, 0.0009145140647888184, 0.060513854026794434, 0.038284819573163986, -0.0006558760651387274, 0.05157121270895004, -0.03683887794613838, -0.03272128105163574, -0.0062815239652991295, -0.053548652678728104, 0.0060137496329844, -0.016271518543362617, -0.011095003224909306, 0.004717786330729723, 0.006792527623474598, 0.01914913021028042, 0.035309650003910065, -0.04771453142166138, 0.009427797980606556, 0.07399622350931168, 0.007243146654218435, -0.00181392184458673, -0.021398652344942093, -0.009815891273319721, 0.022443385794758797, -0.0029973655473440886, -0.0594930462539196, -0.04540722817182541, -0.0401313379406929, 0.04512391611933708, -0.0038992776535451412, 0.0038350282702594995, -0.004610501695424318, 0.07253828644752502, 0.018003007397055626, 0.016436168923974037, 0.006675949785858393, 0.00468461075797677, -0.020057788118720055, 0.03673785552382469, 0.0404149554669857, 0.014630483463406563, 0.026929954066872597, 0.017905812710523605, -0.019380347803235054, 0.042007818818092346, 0.008386511355638504, 0.03530019521713257, 0.008932641707360744, -0.03340008482336998, 0.02081797644495964, -0.04075964540243149, -0.03066200576722622, 0.02362017333507538, 0.015510360710322857, -0.016886722296476364, 0.033341184258461, 0.008951136842370033, 0.0662396028637886, -0.009114689193665981, -0.041747115552425385, 0.005445071030408144, 0.026114048436284065, -0.024872880429029465, 0.017852939665317535, 0.03273020684719086, -0.01454021967947483, 0.010959157720208168, -0.033445876091718674, -0.01526561751961708, -0.016337063163518906, -0.0293844286352396, 0.021580729633569717, 0.03120303526520729, 0.026622403413057327, -0.04247476905584335, 0.0052940500900149345, -0.034655407071113586, 0.02444271743297577, 0.03332750126719475, -0.005845358595252037, -0.09154962003231049, -0.042949922382831573, 0.04979604110121727, -0.012169725261628628, 0.028928296640515327, 0.00277764187194407, 0.011080230586230755, 0.017270583659410477, 0.011161037720739841, 0.006660785060375929, -0.004060760606080294, -0.006259643938392401, 0.017981190234422684, -0.009703077375888824, -0.02737252041697502, 0.07760854065418243, 0.024679023772478104, -0.0443866066634655, 0.049355264753103256, -0.02044028416275978, -0.0255577452480793, -0.017109593376517296, -0.002975405426695943, -0.02544512040913105, -0.029371172189712524, 0.014416263438761234, 0.004689148627221584, 0.0031444979831576347, -0.002189928200095892, -0.058106884360313416, -0.05614675208926201, -0.006091659888625145, -0.014973449520766735, 0.020505381748080254, -0.01088672038167715, 0.014522576704621315, 0.10260644555091858, 0.05809253826737404, -0.029088089242577553, 0.018338218331336975, 0.005361654795706272, -0.06869490444660187, -0.022251196205615997, 0.014646374620497227, 0.03379464149475098, -0.02834068052470684, 0.0016782783204689622, -0.003818678902462125, 0.06253533065319061, 0.03246002271771431, -0.015045156702399254, -0.0025776412803679705, 0.012830033898353577, -0.0005122180446051061, 0.00248316559009254, 0.030724462121725082, 0.01143652480095625, -0.021043647080659866, -0.029261261224746704, -0.005409560166299343, 0.012804988771677017, 0.012904196977615356, -0.05919031798839569, 0.035426992923021317, -0.01656297594308853, 0.0028970579151064157, -0.04963351786136627, 0.04535013437271118, -0.016204528510570526, -0.030060600489377975, 0.004517754539847374, -0.052149053663015366, 0.05756682530045509, -0.039777446538209915, 0.03386623039841652, 0.060002606362104416, 0.03937295451760292, -0.0020403338130563498, -0.017089875414967537, -0.02431030012667179, -0.02180176042020321, 0.026726022362709045, -0.049214474856853485, -0.007404932752251625, 0.03376509249210358, 0.07061420381069183, -0.0010788668878376484, -0.013567796908318996, -0.012447046115994453, -0.028388846665620804, -0.07125874608755112, 0.04424414411187172, 0.004192660097032785, 0.026143549010157585, 0.01484236866235733, 0.0564882829785347, 0.0065752845257520676, -0.04102535545825958, -0.0011497093364596367, 0.00685269758105278, -0.05810778588056564, 0.011611482128500938, -0.011534323915839195, 0.01580728404223919, -0.02142130583524704, -0.03834058716893196, 0.039775457233190536, -0.026127329096198082, 0.027365537360310555, -0.014304779469966888, 0.013205157592892647, -0.03365366905927658, 0.012264191173017025, -0.022503798827528954, -0.033064115792512894, -0.027260372415184975, -0.04044155031442642, -0.0014071225887164474, -0.022977223619818687, 0.03548428788781166, 0.017320819199085236, 0.014525114558637142, -0.01613333262503147, -0.02451239340007305, -0.0068849013186991215, 0.07264997065067291, 0.057658784091472626, 0.029615240171551704, 0.0030886386521160603, -0.015310295857489109, 0.040175337344408035, 0.036831334233284, 0.03105963207781315, 0.048605915158987045, 0.004894453100860119, -0.016495702788233757, -0.05242312699556351, -0.039436470717191696, -0.015360831283032894, 0.008707406930625439, -0.00456984294578433, -0.025307022035121918, 0.054823052138090134, 0.002908351831138134, -0.046953361481428146, 0.04674728587269783, 0.05269531533122063, 0.013947990722954273, -0.009861640632152557, -0.02068798430263996, -0.029920369386672974, -0.031112702563405037, -0.019268523901700974, -0.002412360394373536, 0.026189783588051796, 0.01438045408576727, -0.01332692801952362, 0.054546505212783813, -0.013027559034526348, -0.010377424769103527, 0.021434282884001732, 0.05876004323363304, 0.00804377906024456, 0.04273157939314842, -0.014145877212285995, -0.0008798065828159451, 0.02756618708372116, 0.014370720833539963, -0.003360562492161989, -0.021791407838463783, -0.03647025302052498, 0.008338593877851963, 0.02914896048605442, 0.038175709545612335, 0.012266505509614944, -0.01776012033224106, -0.06241053342819214, -0.003319879062473774, 0.02373819425702095, -0.01727474480867386, 0.038305431604385376, -0.02455168589949608, -0.0086481012403965, 0.008771651424467564, -0.05096849799156189, -0.05700042471289635, -0.02221132256090641, 0.022716447710990906, 0.028279360383749008, 0.004989051725715399, -0.027353862300515175, -0.0038989894092082977, 0.019122490659356117, 0.06481348723173141, 0.0184327345341444, -0.04730527102947235, 0.01850786618888378, 0.0108898114413023, 0.029749056324362755, -0.002774974796921015, -0.06014373153448105, -0.001824943465180695, -0.004797325003892183, -0.005660205613821745, 0.04099603742361069, -0.020552687346935272, -0.03639170899987221, 0.062356408685445786, 0.018927862867712975, 0.005330396816134453, -0.008206648752093315, -0.04584153741598129, 0.020729897543787956, 0.037396710366010666, 0.03947097808122635, 0.040238119661808014, 0.014537839218974113, -0.04625518247485161, 0.007877531461417675, -0.0032152498606592417, -0.017717862501740456, -0.025938108563423157, -0.007250613998621702, -0.06202501431107521, 0.03537865728139877, 0.00607789121568203, 0.049917709082365036, 0.008020884357392788, 0.005446870345622301, -0.051133863627910614, -0.0269096028059721, -0.005560645833611488, -0.0013772689271718264, -0.03356926888227463, 0.01923372410237789, -0.017824258655309677, -0.05548088625073433, -0.012077882885932922, 0.029816197231411934, 0.0105209331959486, -0.023157646879553795, 0.03297210857272148, -0.016817117109894753, -0.036396048963069916, 0.0007168095908127725, -0.01414575707167387, -0.01378040760755539, 0.04067889228463173, -0.04792153090238571, 0.023410165682435036, 0.004941931460052729, 0.03585519641637802, -0.004918667022138834, 0.00659160828217864, -0.0005588672356680036, 0.03673664480447769, -0.0015571865951642394, -0.0010458079632371664, -0.030992941930890083, 0.043676432222127914, 0.016306420788168907, -0.0030776895582675934, -0.0963686853647232, -0.00006800708069931716, 0.04035243019461632, -0.005169067531824112, -0.03655624762177467, -0.02582833170890808, -0.019712133333086967, 0.019282635301351547, -0.04826130345463753, -0.03325769677758217, 0.04123052582144737, 0.023688238114118576, -0.02510794810950756, 0.003668425139039755, 0.014441528357565403, 0.06297454982995987, 0.019974004477262497, -0.004035463090986013, -0.004982238635420799, -0.01992908865213394, -0.03505915030837059, 0.0267998855561018, 0.015371897257864475, -0.012969090603291988, 0.008400875143706799, -0.019267182797193527, -0.0015283178072422743, 0.017760125920176506, 0.011575383134186268, -0.019901132211089134, -0.031316228210926056, -0.003150659380480647, -0.017351016402244568, 0.011324713006615639, -0.004472101107239723, 0.04851337894797325, 0.01150794979184866, -0.0023368755355477333, 0.006443795748054981, -0.00014755470328964293, 0.023810137063264847, 0.010088642127811909, 0.06284347176551819, -0.026300663128495216, 0.03274087980389595, 0.05694694072008133, -0.029142463579773903, -0.019869808107614517, -0.005792646668851376, 0.008651473559439182, 0.01880391128361225, -0.03882097080349922, -0.004647932946681976, -0.010656679980456829, -0.0034579625353217125, -0.03672315180301666, -0.022902561351656914, -0.04325445368885994, 0.028466880321502686, 0.011970841325819492, 0.0413491427898407, 0.020927220582962036, 0.014068333432078362, 0.007604673039168119, -0.021041076630353928, 0.0021592602133750916, -0.037245336920022964, 0.01405995711684227, -0.017303887754678726, 0.05588383600115776, 0.0035390646662563086, 0.03713174909353256, 0.03723980113863945, 0.004762464668601751, 0.03682016208767891, 0.0010676756501197815, 0.01531376875936985, -0.024621956050395966, 0.051510460674762726, -0.023987576365470886, -0.02674052119255066, 0.00597805343568325, -0.03355155512690544, 0.014974478632211685, -0.011822089552879333, -0.00584863917902112, 0.04260034114122391, 0.04750395193696022, -0.011049412190914154, -0.030422426760196686, -0.004593847319483757, -0.077454574406147, -0.0470675453543663, -0.007966991513967514, 0.016066787764430046, 0.04422278329730034, -0.008354642428457737, 0.04407135769724846, -0.004087943583726883, 0.03093765489757061, -0.029489587992429733, -0.11096739768981934, -0.04286221042275429, -0.03177344799041748, -0.02323855832219124, 0.06529976427555084, -0.02044002152979374, -0.010871130973100662, -0.010388776659965515, -0.06645245105028152, 0.028511201962828636, 0.014619271270930767, -0.009773503057658672, 0.008601321838796139, 0.07592680305242538, 0.003491586772724986, 0.044226739555597305, -0.007183902896940708, -0.028066135942935944, 0.1220698133111, 0.06811965256929398, 0.016968771815299988, -0.020089879631996155, 0.02618873119354248, -0.019559480249881744, 0.011787968687713146, -0.024121051654219627, 0.02611987479031086, 0.012894611805677414, -0.004563500639051199, 0.0583658367395401, 0.014613941311836243, -0.01680077239871025, -0.03836963698267937, 0.023614833131432533, -0.021399222314357758, -0.020548228174448013, -0.019385453313589096, 0.047202128916978836, -0.01898008957505226, -0.017844393849372864, -0.03354557976126671, -0.01040914561599493, -0.012353549711406231, 0.0008324998198077083, -0.0025622614193707705, 0.01784074306488037, -0.020870737731456757, -0.02758202888071537, -0.004016336984932423, 0.016337167471647263, 0.009901830926537514, -0.03332476317882538, 0.006243776064366102, -0.028827762231230736, 0.009192193858325481, -0.009177878499031067, 0.03411167114973068, 0.08321286737918854, -0.037914179265499115, -0.00933915562927723, 0.028764205053448677, 0.022702563554048538, -0.07031051069498062, -0.0074317785911262035, -0.04022454097867012, 0.015932150185108185, -0.01935529336333275, -0.026537664234638214, 0.025739088654518127, -0.04084324091672897, -0.0017836674815043807, -0.014265750534832478, 0.01288235280662775, 0.027446528896689415, -0.03504813835024834, -0.011096924543380737, -0.013055776245892048, -0.014078290201723576, 0.02629275806248188, 0.028869543224573135, 0.006448214873671532, 0.05581305921077728, -0.02835797145962715, -0.024084066972136497, -0.023849952965974808, 0.005771418567746878, -0.03825664892792702, 0.031753506511449814, -0.013209246098995209, 0.01148359663784504, -0.007740057073533535, 0.011796018108725548, -0.0167341697961092, -0.0252075158059597, 0.012463393621146679, -0.0013579572550952435, 0.02349049784243107, -0.05253957584500313, -0.015886317938566208, -0.00432867556810379, -0.030174976214766502, 0.014985433779656887, -0.032194994390010834, -0.03153926134109497, -0.02421420067548752, -0.003982069902122021, 0.04012296721339226, 0.0012971708783879876, -0.000028205246053403243, 0.09118550270795822, 0.016388699412345886, -0.06315594166517258, 0.019823869690299034, -0.03829481825232506, -0.07367730140686035, -0.004890873562544584, -0.012307287193834782, 0.07681521028280258, 0.0341043695807457, 0.011331595480442047, -0.003791963681578636, -0.010624105110764503, -0.014074057340621948, -0.01843794621527195, 0.06008990854024887, -0.04714926704764366, -0.01953134499490261, 0.03884216025471687, 0.016268018633127213, -0.014899041503667831, 0.003779587335884571, -0.005695161409676075, -0.034974366426467896, 0.016108660027384758, 0.01046412717550993, -0.034044209867715836, -0.013194280676543713, 0.003162231994792819, 0.007950661703944206, -0.011951316148042679, 0.015518402680754662, 0.0037085586227476597, -0.02634262852370739, 0.007162672001868486, 0.01773550920188427, 0.0019331661751493812, -0.007593343034386635, 0.010868006385862827, -0.012067095376551151, -0.003055115230381489, 0.019210081547498703, 0.003340324154123664, -0.025736140087246895, -0.01589857041835785, 0.040714818984270096, 0.003062837291508913, -0.0282290019094944, 0.0005643150070682168, 0.06361714750528336, -0.05253958702087402, -0.04080675169825554, 0.046724241226911545, 0.05112120509147644, 0.04386776313185692, 0.01604311726987362, -0.014823880977928638, -0.00544614577665925, 0.0007250881171785295, -0.04722058027982712, -0.0237821564078331, -0.048041678965091705, -0.008243914693593979, 0.02087296172976494, -0.009095346555113792, 0.010635649785399437, 0.050100523978471756, -0.018943801522254944, 0.01127889659255743, 0.030561786144971848, -0.026778673753142357, 0.023597555235028267, 0.00287383864633739, 0.007958972826600075, 0.004427804611623287, 0.008954248391091824, 0.000941338948905468, 0.02360435202717781, 0.023576870560646057, -0.0114615922793746, 0.012694444507360458, -0.03057069703936577, 0.016748396679759026, -0.10328876227140427, 0.008387850597500801, 0.04727156087756157, 0.0056575993075966835, 0.03360958397388458, -0.015884049236774445, -0.032470423728227615, 0.025463324040174484, -0.035667307674884796, 0.04310383275151253, 0.011545881628990173, -0.0030080359429121017, -0.018119443207979202, 0.030138621106743813, 0.014849253930151463, 0.00047919852659106255, 0.03314535692334175, 0.02812248468399048, 0.03312521427869797, 0.06052812561392784, 0.009098609909415245, -0.03343683481216431, 0.013270707800984383, 0.06125476211309433, -0.012365712784230709, -0.06277169287204742, 0.020932862535119057, -0.06718484312295914, 0.008010677061975002, 0.042139407247304916, -0.010616960003972054, 0.00000420741707785055, 0.0024157981388270855, 0.02017243020236492, 0.020317915827035904, 0.05252806842327118, 0.04718460142612457, 0.008867169730365276, 0.03449811413884163, 0.01272360235452652, 0.0406329408288002, 0.052504558116197586, 0.01576618105173111, -0.016625573858618736, 0.0245374608784914, 0.007382403127849102, -0.015878966078162193, 0.024035675451159477, -0.0045154038816690445, -0.03492221608757973, 0.023715442046523094, 0.00645813113078475, -0.02187022566795349, -0.003024037228897214, -0.012830077670514584, -0.023861652240157127, 0.018614431843161583, 0.0570635087788105, 0.02897757850587368, -0.008002279326319695, -0.0015712829772382975, -0.016954394057393074, -0.022914402186870575, 0.025496672838926315, -0.016371939331293106, 0.005960559472441673, -0.009978611022233963, -0.01942722126841545, -0.023555900901556015, 0.01025145873427391, -0.006849683355540037, 0.016587961465120316, -0.043860308825969696, 0.012076634913682938, -0.012201573699712753, -0.014169232919812202, 0.012641129083931446, 0.018130147829651833, 0.006787354126572609, -0.08666200935840607, 0.0441540889441967, -0.021884366869926453, 0.0005512026837095618, -0.05626887083053589, -0.022280652076005936, -0.035005535930395126, -0.008374463766813278, 0.07421090453863144, 0.021391702815890312, -0.030794916674494743, 0.01377339567989111, 0.014248032122850418, 0.016518810763955116, -0.0872291848063469, 0.020485280081629753, -0.02887122333049774, 0.007747691590338945, -0.018540574237704277, 0.019229603931307793, 0.045323435217142105, -0.03674398735165596, -0.000926692970097065, 0.015540508553385735, 0.006495543755590916, -0.005545660387724638, -0.03144117072224617, 0.022417515516281128, -0.0029267179779708385, -0.027148544788360596, 0.0347161628305912, 0.004386225249618292, 0.013774305582046509, 0.029902463778853416, -0.01641067862510681, -0.07732105255126953, 0.012523496523499489, -0.013558835722506046, 0.024072302505373955, -0.00519007770344615, 0.028824511915445328, -0.00033725262619554996, -0.09000295400619507, -0.020907055586576462, 0.03233826905488968, -0.024759754538536072, -0.00460114935413003, -0.011560550890862942, 0.025913169607520103, 0.006827296689152718, -0.002402382902801037, -0.006973618641495705, -0.0017598860431462526, -0.014182446524500847, -0.00274354568682611, 0.010982743464410305, 0.03337518498301506, -0.05620977282524109, 0.023662010207772255, 0.02116963267326355, -0.016389282420277596, 0.025126423686742783, 0.003698857268318534, 0.031196504831314087, 0.0005009137676097453, 0.003313000313937664, 0.048204291611909866, 0.015247088856995106, 0.0036915242671966553, 0.0009848885238170624, 0.003536343341693282, 0.06533320993185043, -0.03900128975510597, 0.019410928711295128, -0.028141865506768227, 0.0022216287907212973, -0.022459726780653, -0.004511902574449778, 0.03396905958652496, 0.027157898992300034, -0.013876162469387054, 0.014954651705920696, 0.01610352098941803, 0.03222480043768883, -0.0075068543665111065, -0.03912606090307236, -0.011613301001489162, 0.04745578020811081, -0.021521523594856262, -0.034255851060152054, -0.03244423121213913, 0.0076710074208676815, -0.03320837765932083, 0.027113325893878937, 0.04735663905739784, 0.018375486135482788, -0.021455571055412292, -0.03278420493006706, 0.0009401056449860334, 0.0673929899930954, -0.009512527845799923, -0.004482800606638193, -0.04609678313136101, 0.009924712590873241, -0.0093002337962389, -0.019927214831113815 ]
<p>I am looking for a working algorithm for find out optimal kernel bandwidth for density estimation. I need to write my own program in pascal instead of using R or Matlab. So far all algorithms I found failed. For example, this one looks simple and promising:</p> <p><a href="http://www.di.ubi.pt/~lfbaa/entnetsPubs/bandwidth.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.di.ubi.pt/~lfbaa/entnetsPubs/bandwidth.pdf</a></p> <p>I wrote the following program for it:</p> <pre><code>program test; {$mode objfpc}{$H+} function hopt(data: array of Double): Double; var h0, h1, k4, s: Double; i, j, n: Integer; begin n := Length(data); //Silverman's value to start with //stdev_p() simply calculate the population standard deviation h0 := 1.06*stdev_p(data)*power(n,-0.2); while True do begin //start of formula-17 k4 := 0; for i := 0 to n - 1 do begin for j := 0 to i - 1 do begin s := sqr(data[i] - data[j]); k4 += (sqr(s-6*h0*h0)-24*power(h0,4))*exp(-s/4/h0/h0); end; end; k4 := 3*n*h0+k4/2/power(h0,3); h1 := power(4*n*power(h0,6)/k4,0.2); //end of formula-17 h1 := (h0+h1)/2; if abs(h1-h0) &lt; 0.0001 then Break; h0 := h1; end; Result := h1; end; var a: array of Double; begin SetLength(a, 6); a[0] := -2.1; a[1] := -1.3; a[2] := -0.4; a[3] := 1.9; a[4] := 5.1; a[5] := 6.2; WriteLn('hopt=', hopt(a)); end. </code></pre> <p>Using this sample to test the above function: -2.1, -1.3, -0.4, 1.9, 5.1, 6.2</p> <p>The result it gives is 3.716, which is much worse than initial Silverman value 2.335. Using R's sm::hsj() on this data set, the optimal h value is around 1.9, which is rather close to wikipedia's 1.5.</p> <p>I have also tried cross-validation method suggested here:</p> <p><a href="http://www3.stat.sinica.edu.tw/statistica/oldpdf/A6n18.pdf?origin=publication_detail" rel="nofollow">http://www3.stat.sinica.edu.tw/statistica/oldpdf/A6n18.pdf?origin=publication_detail</a></p> <p>which does not converge at all.</p> <p>Could anyone explain a simple way, be it cross-validation, or plug-in method, using a small data set, rather than math formula or proprietary languages such as R or matlab?</p> <p>Thanks a lot!</p>
19,101
[ -0.01679587922990322, -0.0027271611616015434, 0.06405048817396164, -0.012979946099221706, 0.0062717050313949585, -0.009972521103918552, 0.030292969197034836, -0.013431750237941742, 0.006692219991236925, 0.0022214180789887905, 0.045576948672533035, 0.011938957497477531, 0.020981062203645706, 0.03140135481953621, 0.03910603001713753, -0.031377244740724564, -0.028202932327985764, -0.0035284205805510283, -0.03609227389097214, -0.03372585400938988, 0.006365420762449503, 0.023885507136583328, -0.027517044916749, 0.0031836607959121466, -0.0796031579375267, 0.04284470155835152, -0.025466693565249443, -0.03611381724476814, -0.03473018854856491, 0.04136229306459427, -0.033103372901678085, -0.03704392537474632, 0.03625990450382233, 0.001976081170141697, 0.03983258083462715, 0.021453898400068283, -0.02653469331562519, -0.0020809799898415804, 0.004587872885167599, 0.010749788023531437, -0.05268161743879318, 0.010681944899260998, -0.0035683128517121077, -0.007971692830324173, 0.009993557818233967, 0.03424892947077751, 0.03223242238163948, -0.02374458685517311, 0.03308079019188881, -0.05938027799129486, 0.05259661003947258, -0.014081685803830624, -0.011205911636352539, -0.006087323650717735, -0.030834274366497993, 0.019234037026762962, 0.025408411398530006, 0.07298807799816132, 0.021770529448986053, -0.054365385323762894, 0.049325428903102875, -0.015330865047872066, -0.026692232117056847, -0.01701769046485424, -0.019764678552746773, -0.013991237618029118, -0.036678019911050797, -0.0471489243209362, 0.04269065707921982, -0.018363304436206818, 0.01252424344420433, 0.016985071823000908, -0.005673862528055906, -0.0018803265411406755, 0.04901573061943054, -0.02468608133494854, -0.008808599784970284, 0.00021743173419963568, 0.04344408959150314, 0.029662854969501495, 0.01923607476055622, -0.020203199237585068, 0.011392169632017612, 0.03329282999038696, 0.02818671613931656, -0.0002895879151765257, 0.08529637008905411, 0.01689525879919529, 0.02209775522351265, 0.035357389599084854, -0.03177668899297714, -0.024879975244402885, 0.08031098544597626, 0.008490994572639465, -0.004480384755879641, 0.024391984567046165, -0.03415621817111969, 0.03328715264797211, -0.012864707969129086, -0.016915326938033104, -0.006162628065794706, -0.030031796544790268, 0.001934386440552771, 0.04287397488951683, -0.041907500475645065, -0.00014839813229627907, -0.01253517810255289, -0.019005227833986282, 0.008375175297260284, -0.01965480111539364, -0.0318845771253109, 0.04159318283200264, 0.00514907855540514, -0.015246662311255932, 0.028005177155137062, -0.03972066566348076, -0.032143812626600266, 0.03265153244137764, 0.018385250121355057, 0.03000393509864807, 0.025311199948191643, -0.031493935734033585, 0.00010460409976076335, -0.0370500385761261, -0.04608689621090889, 0.07213558256626129, -0.001496371696703136, -0.029793646186590195, -0.046018391847610474, 0.04756569117307663, 0.016945673152804375, -0.009486268274486065, 0.10052813589572906, -0.013738855719566345, 0.0009428337798453867, 0.007039314601570368, -0.06315810978412628, -0.051743727177381516, 0.02478797361254692, 0.006568621844053268, 0.027723707258701324, -0.03450682759284973, 0.032006438821554184, 0.03145119920372963, 0.07277768105268478, 0.011991417966783047, 0.04818252846598625, -0.013519559055566788, 0.02487769164144993, -0.012138891033828259, -0.013867435976862907, -0.002358795143663883, -0.02132437378168106, -0.025416366755962372, -0.0036270380951464176, -0.04401818662881851, -0.0038560014218091965, -0.013482468202710152, -0.031057467684149742, -0.029570823535323143, 0.043706014752388, 0.03331867605447769, 0.02072931081056595, -0.019484179094433784, -0.024003945291042328, -0.024454131722450256, 0.10006898641586304, 0.02545548789203167, 0.027635248377919197, -0.02913801558315754, -0.020861824974417686, 0.00776174571365118, -0.014886404387652874, -0.013968348503112793, 0.0664488822221756, -0.02727757766842842, -0.0015620384365320206, -0.058960992842912674, 0.02349662594497204, -0.0070537179708480835, -0.00267062708735466, -0.03821113705635071, 0.03613955155014992, 0.018394190818071365, 0.06503590941429138, 0.023000122979283333, 0.014087310060858727, 0.046756815165281296, 0.0408250167965889, -0.0307912640273571, -0.04446133226156235, -0.014758513309061527, -0.039249930530786514, 0.008802900090813637, -0.048165783286094666, 0.0016268979525193572, -0.027884790673851967, -0.012681839056313038, 0.015086591243743896, -0.019505465403199196, -0.017310770228505135, -0.0024167760275304317, 0.027967384085059166, -0.0223245769739151, 0.006630470976233482, 0.06797406822443008, 0.02481384016573429, -0.046438317745923996, 0.023028841242194176, -0.02228344976902008, 0.0067089325748384, -0.003967501223087311, -0.02574544958770275, -0.027844015508890152, 0.014255916699767113, -0.018414270132780075, 0.007496990729123354, 0.019769813865423203, 0.012805493548512459, -0.020085230469703674, -0.038986824452877045, 0.03689565137028694, 0.058303169906139374, 0.05265524610877037, 0.049607325345277786, 0.022126439958810806, -0.03377624973654747, 0.00021145639766473323, 0.005616762675344944, -0.010902490466833115, -0.04634101688861847, 0.026258477941155434, 0.03301902487874031, 0.011110745370388031, -0.053622741252183914, -0.043232209980487823, 0.07857686281204224, -0.0451032854616642, 0.02022683620452881, 0.02502088062465191, -0.01713554747402668, 0.00032182125141844153, 0.023783324286341667, 0.016748441383242607, 0.00806381180882454, 0.03338906913995743, 0.017706871032714844, 0.04484620690345764, 0.013207011856138706, 0.00043898989679291844, -0.012456906028091908, 0.04469772055745125, -0.010096061043441296, -0.011478303000330925, -0.00475928233936429, 0.005861734971404076, 0.02869572304189205, -0.007198424078524113, -0.02110259421169758, 0.047129157930612564, -0.030910849571228027, 0.031128399074077606, -0.004034232813864946, -0.038657400757074356, 0.0009663907694630325, 0.02374778874218464, 0.0042742290534079075, -0.020274415612220764, 0.03015744686126709, -0.04960930719971657, -0.00012019995483569801, -0.01646432653069496, -0.02954890951514244, -0.05999138578772545, -0.009395384229719639, 0.035160042345523834, 0.02611207775771618, 0.027953051030635834, -0.03846943750977516, 0.02745671756565571, -0.009613160975277424, -0.009149073623120785, 0.005575751420110464, -0.009623458608984947, -0.06161024048924446, -0.03098720870912075, 0.026591770350933075, -0.010844608768820763, 0.010435597971081734, -0.007407133933156729, -0.006075561046600342, 0.05211906507611275, 0.009957809932529926, -0.028285721316933632, 0.00476759672164917, -0.030506277456879616, -0.015439818613231182, -0.034488141536712646, -0.009809781797230244, 0.04437734931707382, -0.016433298587799072, -0.059184569865465164, 0.06358297914266586, -0.05267889425158501, -0.061131082475185394, -0.01332828775048256, 0.0005269930697977543, 0.0029645494651049376, 0.011413623578846455, 0.01626201719045639, 0.011880498379468918, 0.00846948567777872, -0.010762729682028294, -0.06849531829357147, -0.057387903332710266, 0.022665536031126976, 0.03864013031125069, 0.03978854417800903, 0.004714845679700375, -0.012746994383633137, 0.04218168929219246, -0.00584222050383687, -0.035922810435295105, -0.023858588188886642, 0.008103539235889912, -0.04731737822294235, 0.01786247082054615, 0.05361566320061684, 0.006227868143469095, 0.005815697368234396, -0.02117825672030449, -0.009378273971378803, 0.0009026722400449216, 0.0900934562087059, -0.008108850568532944, -0.0006058119470253587, -0.023104343563318253, -0.05404117330908775, -0.02457406558096409, 0.06599588692188263, 0.017407197505235672, -0.0118971336632967, 0.017724063247442245, 0.0005510026239790022, -0.006044699344784021, 0.03474260866641998, -0.03265347704291344, 0.00463700108230114, 0.009249239228665829, 0.03763629123568535, -0.041353318840265274, -0.016763124614953995, 0.0027943511959165335, -0.05730757117271423, -0.004748915322124958, 0.026779355481266975, 0.026597924530506134, -0.016123304143548012, -0.005533356685191393, 0.053090568631887436, 0.013460226356983185, 0.011679081246256828, -0.023279739543795586, 0.004581951070576906, -0.011660883203148842, 0.02302452363073826, -0.017548196017742157, -0.010225774720311165, 0.05850687623023987, 0.05279608070850372, -0.0057508861646056175, -0.022875184193253517, -0.021440414711833, 0.026412751525640488, -0.10000743716955185, -0.005341514945030212, -0.056507863104343414, 0.09828696399927139, -0.009708719328045845, 0.04477019980549812, 0.028262117877602577, 0.005969557911157608, 0.0005780790816061199, 0.0011055857175961137, -0.08484990894794464, 0.007832791656255722, 0.0033562835305929184, -0.031249139457941055, 0.008777269162237644, -0.01155424676835537, 0.012665591202676296, -0.030269665643572807, 0.03034798800945282, 0.01343914121389389, 0.010547149926424026, -0.05900651589035988, 0.007563321851193905, -0.01780533418059349, 0.006524450145661831, -0.05692673102021217, 0.02011410892009735, 0.027411125600337982, -0.02468295395374298, 0.003053235588595271, 0.05647770315408707, -0.005069931503385305, 0.018021192401647568, -0.015908746048808098, 0.02164768986403942, 0.0015135068679228425, 0.05818648263812065, 0.0025065462104976177, 0.04926051199436188, -0.04346681758761406, 0.020676106214523315, -0.019858848303556442, 0.04398087412118912, 0.04123404994606972, 0.017590487375855446, 0.02946033701300621, -0.0017736685695126653, -0.01874508336186409, -0.0209499541670084, 0.0003488075453788042, -0.024407291784882545, 0.03495751693844795, 0.016774125397205353, -0.023457011207938194, -0.030961791053414345, -0.01119778398424387, 0.07789761573076248, -0.00544865382835269, 0.015163393691182137, -0.07547472417354584, -0.007353850640356541, -0.013703344389796257, -0.011435674503445625, 0.011379064992070198, 0.026013975962996483, -0.014828618615865707, -0.016446102410554886, 0.04006761685013771, 0.011388542130589485, 0.02605077251791954, 0.02132519893348217, 0.03154037147760391, 0.0415923036634922, -0.018637007102370262, -0.024389687925577164, 0.01218830980360508, 0.016992149874567986, 0.04118255525827408, 0.007246697787195444, 0.018684757873415947, -0.07672221213579178, -0.029374901205301285, 0.029375772923231125, 0.023680180311203003, -0.0003795046068262309, 0.03264271467924118, -0.061808664351701736, -0.035437580198049545, -0.006736076902598143, -0.05634583160281181, 0.01396459061652422, -0.04749803990125656, 0.02494189515709877, -0.05383945629000664, -0.002946586348116398, -0.0540580078959465, 0.0012780572287738323, 0.011170141398906708, 0.005638966336846352, -0.026210376992821693, 0.00034118618350476027, -0.03429533168673515, 0.03236725181341171, 0.03428344801068306, 0.06556711345911026, -0.039905935525894165, -0.075371652841568, 0.02074139192700386, 0.020532026886940002, -0.03427322581410408, -0.04761326313018799, 0.003071130719035864, -0.0007162289693951607, 0.02176818624138832, 0.02365097589790821, -0.017230795696377754, -0.03343673795461655, 0.02142353728413582, 0.005529090296477079, -0.019669100642204285, 0.009398924186825752, -0.0014290468534454703, 0.024040864780545235, 0.009565488435328007, 0.01776205189526081, 0.05254187807440758, 0.061595525592565536, -0.007291102781891823, -0.00452900817617774, -0.03879483416676521, -0.035790953785181046, 0.0017749322578310966, -0.007808298338204622, -0.03118942864239216, -0.013717317953705788, -0.012275998480618, 0.02479865401983261, 0.011442323215305805, 0.026646466925740242, -0.027424480766057968, 0.027598904445767403, 0.012452645227313042, 0.039490312337875366, 0.002087088068947196, 0.005655521061271429, -0.015674537047743797, 0.031976114958524704, -0.0017386222025379539, -0.04521775618195534, 0.01071115117520094, -0.008814789354801178, -0.0019598098006099463, 0.022262416779994965, -0.05232040584087372, -0.008225124329328537, -0.03667055070400238, -0.032067518681287766, 0.024698995053768158, -0.05361638218164444, 0.059583939611911774, 0.004924090579152107, 0.032627224922180176, 0.044534243643283844, -0.024960892274975777, -0.012331926263868809, -0.009977609850466251, -0.0323299802839756, 0.04439954459667206, -0.04111076891422272, -0.015425914898514748, 0.01380051951855421, -0.014303724281489849, -0.07645124942064285, -0.0017430671723559499, 0.045474495738744736, 0.02143006958067417, -0.022916758432984352, -0.06099517643451691, -0.012049907818436623, 0.01583893783390522, -0.04565688967704773, -0.023938579484820366, 0.004352108109742403, 0.007948444224894047, 0.011357581242918968, 0.024180524051189423, -0.016560683026909828, 0.08747390657663345, -0.006143020000308752, 0.018498098477721214, 0.025377269834280014, 0.017195912078022957, -0.052644211798906326, -0.0015306121204048395, -0.015265603549778461, 0.014076262712478638, 0.028522349894046783, -0.04438965767621994, -0.0072392490692436695, 0.03482500836253166, 0.014385759830474854, -0.018519069999456406, -0.04407989978790283, -0.04276255518198013, 0.010264359414577484, -0.00558173144236207, 0.0002758902555797249, -0.04088011384010315, -0.013761856593191624, -0.01195377204567194, -0.010475720278918743, -0.0436912477016449, 0.010018606670200825, 0.006295064464211464, 0.006679867394268513, 0.025999033823609352, -0.014007938094437122, 0.03411787003278732, -0.003472753567621112, -0.02903067134320736, 0.02158454805612564, -0.015927869826555252, 0.022011958062648773, 0.029615875333547592, -0.011387892067432404, 0.011331789195537567, 0.012612172402441502, -0.0038470907602459192, -0.018931975588202477, -0.0287478007376194, -0.023453686386346817, 0.04570108279585838, -0.0078101493418216705, 0.032063934952020645, -0.009905369952321053, -0.01156317163258791, 0.01989244669675827, 0.022216545417904854, 0.00949047226458788, -0.0022151991724967957, -0.036208610981702805, 0.08396999537944794, 0.011508612893521786, -0.013102500699460506, 0.053077273070812225, 0.05045417323708534, 0.003027674974873662, 0.03685525804758072, 0.0007101058727130294, 0.036528002470731735, 0.0138040566816926, -0.05937984585762024, -0.039189811795949936, 0.032959260046482086, -0.03682418540120125, 0.03839823603630066, -0.01873474195599556, -0.014914331026375294, 0.026366697624325752, 0.0242338664829731, -0.000011987325706286356, -0.09677978605031967, 0.009697243571281433, 0.0010158666409552097, 0.010564448311924934, -0.007379178889095783, -0.04511919990181923, -0.01952662318944931, 0.01877470500767231, -0.008361518383026123, 0.016086485236883163, 0.048684414476156235, -0.021544648334383965, -0.013979680836200714, -0.02412465028464794, -0.06684237718582153, -0.04237750545144081, 0.06080975756049156, 0.013182738795876503, -0.040242861956357956, 0.03582857549190521, 0.01719200611114502, 0.05552581697702408, 0.030823901295661926, 0.0050352150574326515, 0.0597299188375473, 0.09710431843996048, -0.010193499736487865, 0.0033458813559263945, -0.017878549173474312, -0.007944258861243725, 0.1692763864994049, 0.07281837612390518, 0.04765454679727554, -0.05303582549095154, 0.0008465185528621078, 0.0021694586612284184, 0.018868817016482353, -0.027210203930735588, -0.010222529992461205, -0.009121733717620373, -0.0023841510992497206, 0.07520761340856552, 0.015706969425082207, 0.006432864349335432, 0.037522826343774796, 0.03368905559182167, -0.03417434170842171, 0.00009843556472333148, 0.05394352972507477, 0.018196651712059975, 0.03842899575829506, -0.010289693251252174, -0.04181051254272461, 0.023524919524788857, 0.01930367760360241, -0.037687234580516815, -0.035966161638498306, 0.0006180795026011765, 0.015596435405313969, 0.008046247996389866, -0.042989667505025864, 0.016608675941824913, 0.04366092011332512, 0.018636003136634827, 0.0007009828113950789, -0.03283929079771042, 0.01498216949403286, -0.027577849105000496, 0.013238130137324333, 0.010576869361102581, 0.019583536311984062, -0.0016451990231871605, 0.0029783067293465137, 0.011511427350342274, -0.001959611428901553, 0.01741265319287777, -0.020078660920262337, 0.029514910653233528, 0.011077262461185455, -0.0042536091059446335, 0.024820443242788315, 0.006881871726363897, 0.00895986519753933, -0.047584161162376404, -0.02988058514893055, -0.030319184064865112, 0.024782275781035423, -0.027092762291431427, -0.02723853662610054, 0.014893593266606331, -0.007851324044167995, -0.009959639981389046, 0.012942800298333168, -0.008282079361379147, -0.00260332552716136, -0.029529260471463203, -0.027111535891890526, 0.024014536291360855, -0.021075481548905373, -0.03342737630009651, 0.029608333483338356, -0.049179501831531525, -0.0241481252014637, -0.003804734442383051, -0.02583223767578602, -0.003518167184665799, -0.0029580446425825357, -0.022079268470406532, -0.04947621747851372, -0.03271988034248352, -0.004041996784508228, -0.007573998067528009, -0.03636486828327179, 0.005090712569653988, -0.0373636856675148, -0.004693011287599802, 0.04290153086185455, 0.017460905015468597, 0.00952750351279974, -0.01102437824010849, 0.01656387187540531, 0.06595084816217422, 0.009698454290628433, -0.08832316845655441, -0.028529968112707138, -0.013373066671192646, -0.015458544716238976, 0.002117869211360812, -0.020153094083070755, 0.02420687861740589, 0.007456386461853981, 0.02061389572918415, -0.027994683012366295, 0.024719152599573135, -0.005121205002069473, 0.01340122427791357, -0.027760811150074005, -0.017523420974612236, 0.000758668000344187, -0.028608672320842743, 0.041864633560180664, -0.044754836708307266, 0.03471622243523598, -0.036244772374629974, -0.029344908893108368, -0.019649608060717583, 0.0060519264079630375, -0.014222926460206509, -0.010000922717154026, -0.007812106050550938, -0.023610347881913185, 0.029149306938052177, 0.04178640618920326, 0.04041975736618042, 0.011186296120285988, -0.029978064820170403, 0.020608453080058098, -0.04238305985927582, -0.008584017865359783, -0.007170524913817644, 0.025352468714118004, 0.04462442919611931, 0.018367351964116096, 0.043530724942684174, 0.010090291500091553, 0.023694049566984177, 0.004712665919214487, 0.004671485163271427, -0.006634838413447142, 0.014088010415434837, 0.050936732441186905, -0.05888887122273445, -0.049711890518665314, -0.006696456111967564, 0.003513296600431204, -0.010680994018912315, 0.02279316820204258, 0.020182790234684944, -0.0006528375670313835, 0.03790746629238129, 0.010905958712100983, -0.026639962568879128, -0.012132333591580391, -0.023122532293200493, 0.002454119734466076, 0.02839489094913006, 0.01777198538184166, 0.01538075227290392, 0.00007302198355318978, 0.019449708983302116, 0.02003507874906063, -0.038143090903759, 0.01905520260334015, 0.028103657066822052, -0.01130054984241724, -0.01887289620935917, -0.0025672772899270058, -0.024521442130208015, 0.034528862684965134, 0.02054714411497116, -0.02166607230901718, 0.0037076862063258886, -0.03472856804728508, 0.007923801429569721, -0.05086382478475571, -0.006568050477653742, -0.019298402592539787, 0.002701440127566457, 0.029186444357037544, -0.015225165523588657, 0.024046557024121284, 0.003066122066229582, -0.0399177260696888, 0.047933824360370636, 0.02576793171465397, 0.00400008587166667, -0.05032271519303322, 0.02463848702609539, -0.04876372218132019, 0.030573761090636253, -0.0016369422664865851, 0.003443646477535367, 0.023578841239213943, 0.02450423687696457, -0.027894971892237663, 0.01031066570430994, -0.02287033386528492, -0.0024746335111558437, 0.02535312809050083, -0.04609335958957672, 0.03649087995290756, -0.025006204843521118, -0.00560951279476285, 0.03200899437069893, -0.039008643478155136, 0.014514544978737831, -0.022149743512272835, -0.014557098969817162, 0.0007799935410730541, 0.048466574400663376, 0.002930911723524332, -0.0227679330855608, -0.015039995312690735, -0.038654569536447525, 0.021882880479097366, -0.0004729586944449693, -0.02719636633992195, 0.04910273477435112, 0.053065355867147446, -0.00006774441135348752, -0.039652351289987564, -0.003451598109677434, 0.028632350265979767, -0.012795789167284966, -0.015454757027328014, 0.017207276076078415, -0.020753534510731697, -0.02756025455892086, 0.03013857640326023, -0.053343430161476135, 0.0096586924046278, -0.01911652460694313, 0.018976861611008644, -0.02225443162024021, -0.013854876160621643, -0.01499048713594675, -0.04465511068701744, 0.03392689302563667, 0.02637246437370777, -0.0036907647736370564, -0.022262459620833397, -0.03378556668758392, -0.012089044786989689, 0.03867468237876892, 0.0026713693514466286, -0.018713241443037987, -0.0020673973485827446, 0.046671830117702484, 0.036178503185510635, -0.015422969125211239, 0.00023843321832828224, -0.004111513029783964, 0.03298266977071762, -0.07749789208173752, 0.046563033014535904, 0.0027934235986322165, 0.0018446639878675342, -0.012400423176586628, -0.005693055223673582, -0.022557029500603676, 0.05395051836967468, 0.028048858046531677, 0.0002248491218779236, -0.0206373929977417, -0.01079465076327324, -0.006649847608059645, 0.004128092434257269, -0.05682721734046936, 0.01867307536303997, 0.005632324609905481, -0.027999743819236755, 0.02222542092204094, -0.011697924695909023, 0.01297424454241991, 0.006672993302345276, -0.03336913511157036, 0.024740906432271004, -0.0009552245028316975, 0.02162827178835869, -0.03355374559760094, -0.022796666249632835, 0.010205456055700779, -0.028438128530979156, 0.055023517459630966, -0.014401131309568882, -0.017135581001639366, 0.0019222013652324677, 0.009015710093080997, -0.04769274964928627, 0.001033367938362062, -0.037683408707380295, -0.03992200642824173, -0.02086533047258854, 0.01842748001217842, 0.026363758370280266, -0.025882862508296967, -0.017274081707000732, 0.023262303322553635, -0.05913270264863968, -0.009509844705462456, 0.026609322056174278, -0.02826758101582527, 0.028012078255414963, -0.013280564919114113, 0.04014841094613075, -0.042689982801675797, -0.029853958636522293, 0.007861638441681862, 0.0347309373319149, 0.004954047035425901, -0.0013114181347191334, 0.041910842061042786, 0.05552595853805542, 0.011913198046386242, 0.054819125682115555, 0.002924490487203002, 0.03208506479859352, 0.017114868387579918, -0.05252961814403534, 0.016667786985635757, 0.016192788258194923, -0.0459008514881134, 0.041200753301382065, -0.005377012304961681, 0.056770529597997665, 0.012300117872655392, 0.022727638483047485, 0.026749081909656525, -0.03461402282118797, 0.007839175872504711, -0.019942164421081543, -0.017839105799794197, 0.0028181711677461863, -0.013562388718128204, 0.029643693938851357, 0.018610138446092606, -0.028423603624105453, 0.05863839015364647, -0.03532684966921806, 0.01266863290220499, 0.05257060006260872, 0.004211722873151302, 0.003563226666301489, 0.0062699392437934875, -0.006291502621024847, -0.019871968775987625, 0.03752562031149864, 0.02254439890384674, 0.011265973560512066, 0.011869230307638645, -0.0438992939889431, -0.01822279579937458, 0.06371839344501495, -0.04711807891726494, -0.008359861560165882, 0.017808323726058006, -0.034281764179468155, -0.02313994988799095, 0.03016369417309761 ]
<p>I found that the probability of an event occurring is an algebraic function of all the probabilities that I want to find;</p> <p>$$P(v_1,v_2,v_3,...,v_n)=p_{collected}$$</p> <p>For small $n$, it would be easy to solve for all $v$ as a system of equations. However, as $n$ grows large (in the order of hundreds to several thousand), analyzing the data in this manner becomes infeasible. </p> <p>The majority of the variables may be zero (or very, very close) and are negligible. The function is not a polynomial so it might be hard to solve using basic linear algebra.</p> <p>Is there a way to estimate what these variables could be?</p>
36,927
[ -0.039378419518470764, -0.019612649455666542, -0.009636237286031246, -0.02007552608847618, 0.04031490162014961, -0.011210966855287552, -0.010789726860821247, -0.012705320492386818, 0.029612060636281967, -0.030243007466197014, -0.0007057992625050247, 0.06170988827943802, 0.0492805577814579, 0.0424446277320385, 0.02394329383969307, -0.000020054822016390972, -0.003408337477594614, -0.0015859098639339209, -0.0004949895082972944, -0.029870856553316116, -0.006032825447618961, 0.04700604826211929, 0.02797994203865528, -0.026776760816574097, -0.03096538409590721, 0.047793641686439514, 0.0027556964196264744, -0.04987185448408127, 0.015594190917909145, 0.05605483055114746, -0.031167853623628616, -0.024313533678650856, 0.02160148322582245, 0.06065228953957558, 0.022441217675805092, 0.015717489644885063, -0.022908788174390793, -0.04270576685667038, 0.007173512130975723, 0.028022661805152893, -0.05451403558254242, -0.038773179054260254, -0.04079737141728401, 0.04268212243914604, -0.023917246609926224, -0.0014909608289599419, 0.012871424667537212, -0.04790604114532471, 0.022968189790844917, -0.05263272300362587, 0.0736730769276619, 0.0028537006583064795, 0.07874573022127151, 0.02059544064104557, -0.03552623465657234, 0.003519035642966628, 0.045653797686100006, 0.08158261328935623, 0.010568990372121334, -0.04810798913240433, -0.009727776981890202, -0.012371311895549297, -0.030636146664619446, -0.022711047902703285, -0.03861835226416588, 0.01858038268983364, -0.017989177256822586, -0.02684635855257511, 0.025964004918932915, 0.0005146260955370963, 0.0074489908292889595, 0.011548584327101707, 0.025108259171247482, 0.008966868743300438, 0.008217777125537395, -0.009123948402702808, 0.03496414050459862, 0.006286218296736479, 0.030241938307881355, 0.008286930620670319, -0.004870888311415911, 0.006307713221758604, 0.0035259893629699945, 0.010141697712242603, 0.03575349971652031, -0.02326575107872486, 0.059898313134908676, -0.04613574966788292, 0.02602853812277317, -0.015270558185875416, -0.056129369884729385, 0.01173582673072815, 0.01752038300037384, 0.001913407351821661, -0.06152138486504555, 0.014288924634456635, -0.006555064115673304, 0.03654930740594864, 0.03011973202228546, -0.019385024905204773, -0.000798250490333885, -0.022460458800196648, -0.014885582029819489, 0.06307709217071533, -0.04907706007361412, 0.002982574747875333, -0.030812513083219528, 0.0004644147993531078, -0.003410282777622342, 0.004373482894152403, -0.019202452152967453, 0.020429223775863647, 0.04677823185920715, 0.0023642582818865776, 0.009259778074920177, -0.012234565801918507, -0.003249688306823373, -0.02993657998740673, 0.046623311936855316, 0.0981377512216568, 0.021234693005681038, -0.027716899290680885, 0.03696027770638466, -0.026614371687173843, -0.03631247952580452, 0.002904417458921671, 0.030285151675343513, 0.015538756735622883, -0.03831423446536064, 0.054826099425554276, -0.004861406050622463, -0.02822532132267952, 0.05863489955663681, -0.024150464683771133, 0.023769523948431015, -0.005475217942148447, -0.0795183926820755, -0.04954134672880173, 0.018210964277386665, -0.025965316221117973, -0.029471449553966522, -0.0598372146487236, -0.0022511042188853025, 0.04158887267112732, 0.05153846740722656, -0.009200536645948887, 0.048493705689907074, 0.03144606202840805, 0.023630253970623016, 0.04405348002910614, -0.03762084245681763, 0.007348957937210798, -0.02858065813779831, 0.0026410750579088926, -0.0198911614716053, -0.0727548897266388, 0.03893451392650604, 0.024730898439884186, -0.004927854053676128, 0.006167646963149309, 0.048171550035476685, 0.012280665338039398, -0.023656656965613365, 0.0056810639798641205, 0.030494166538119316, -0.020828047767281532, 0.07725328207015991, 0.02719653584063053, 0.011432761326432228, 0.026061803102493286, 0.027854125946760178, 0.045412689447402954, 0.05331314355134964, 0.04846638813614845, 0.05707429349422455, -0.03663153573870659, -0.010924061760306358, 0.025212664157152176, 0.030501117929816246, 0.003407204756513238, 0.00345161953009665, -0.014897411689162254, 0.012045451439917088, -0.004536192398518324, 0.020431065931916237, 0.03472663834691048, 0.025346318259835243, -0.0401257760822773, 0.019917434081435204, 0.008957075886428356, -0.013177111744880676, -0.06109907105565071, 0.008599339984357357, 0.0033064098097383976, 0.007554739713668823, 0.03148874640464783, 0.014360109344124794, 0.003053464228287339, -0.01350302342325449, -0.027750888839364052, -0.01117115467786789, 0.0015118117444217205, 0.027346225455403328, -0.057194940745830536, -0.03590269759297371, 0.026492414996027946, 0.04587855562567711, 0.002251183148473501, 0.031207183375954628, -0.013470899313688278, -0.048983629792928696, -0.02687143348157406, -0.06376945972442627, 0.018307317048311234, -0.02070396952331066, -0.033404041081666946, 0.01207184512168169, -0.0069873761385679245, 0.0365179181098938, 0.020519057288765907, -0.03474164754152298, 0.059250377118587494, 0.03942345455288887, 0.054725825786590576, -0.00016848916129674762, -0.0007977404166013002, 0.042953040450811386, -0.023202912881970406, 0.00017031132301781327, -0.013474981300532818, -0.07953829318284988, 0.01296528335660696, 0.024158431217074394, 0.024095823988318443, -0.03280965983867645, 0.010182159952819347, 0.08262379467487335, 0.0470132902264595, 0.016241027042269707, 0.010397475212812424, -0.028452103957533836, 0.012884916737675667, -0.005336778704077005, 0.03281863406300545, -0.004147595725953579, -0.006049705669283867, -0.0037445039488375187, 0.0389808751642704, 0.013829401694238186, -0.0110346470028162, -0.04758467525243759, 0.039999037981033325, -0.015330991707742214, 0.020686252042651176, -0.046357400715351105, -0.03812360018491745, 0.056928522884845734, -0.0317697636783123, 0.014778418466448784, 0.02942841500043869, 0.03012770414352417, -0.0028340539429336786, 0.014184131287038326, -0.033624399453401566, 0.0354856476187706, 0.012135230004787445, -0.0725545883178711, 0.013492689467966557, 0.019717782735824585, -0.026492321863770485, 0.022175263613462448, -0.018522022292017937, -0.04004810377955437, -0.028591422364115715, 0.04005081206560135, 0.002613763092085719, -0.016856079921126366, 0.014092993922531605, -0.005306079983711243, -0.03493012860417366, 0.030920911580324173, -0.0400565005838871, 0.014773068018257618, 0.04679037258028984, -0.0818137601017952, -0.004537052474915981, -0.026788437739014626, -0.022194240242242813, 0.00994863547384739, -0.026025664061307907, -0.015350471250712872, 0.03489343822002411, -0.021010393276810646, -0.04319886490702629, 0.0003497595025692135, -0.0103757930919528, -0.01361952442675829, -0.04251136630773544, -0.027218077331781387, 0.006307703442871571, -0.0027657451573759317, -0.019988099113106728, 0.01289624534547329, -0.03723344951868057, -0.042103029787540436, -0.04336953163146973, -0.003365688258782029, 0.0026306440122425556, -0.04308364912867546, 0.009006704203784466, 0.024328239262104034, 0.0012778042582795024, 0.00666330149397254, -0.0660274401307106, -0.08351662755012512, -0.008810929954051971, 0.008847152814269066, 0.04130164161324501, 0.011284621432423592, -0.022705312818288803, 0.047833941876888275, 0.030047999694943428, -0.043883197009563446, 0.006167513318359852, -0.0038071037270128727, -0.009122868068516254, 0.007082509808242321, 0.011589943431317806, -0.009461573325097561, -0.0024739718064665794, 0.026931095868349075, -0.007266419008374214, -0.026499316096305847, 0.04011375457048416, 0.00155486015137285, -0.017212072387337685, 0.04378318414092064, -0.02837265469133854, 0.005451211240142584, 0.04485082998871803, -0.005159849766641855, -0.02110355719923973, 0.015517610125243664, -0.0007381087634712458, -0.01766861416399479, 0.02344426140189171, -0.044981662184000015, 0.00654938630759716, 0.0009489304502494633, 0.01507177110761404, -0.017953237518668175, 0.016335291787981987, 0.0007692446815781295, -0.004065297544002533, 0.030166584998369217, 0.037686076015233994, 0.05768231302499771, -0.0363185741007328, 0.02682698331773281, 0.03243762627243996, 0.05125420168042183, -0.046018023043870926, -0.047541648149490356, -0.039381153881549835, -0.022201064974069595, -0.011404488235712051, -0.012900818139314651, 0.019100196659564972, 0.0554785318672657, 0.027003837749361992, 0.02789664827287197, -0.011277081444859505, 0.0022270428016781807, -0.006709051784127951, -0.04254484176635742, -0.02456982433795929, -0.009025374427437782, 0.012963331304490566, -0.008267647586762905, 0.03869318589568138, 0.00820935145020485, -0.012468218803405762, 0.010065820999443531, 0.016205549240112305, -0.0892689973115921, 0.024774538353085518, -0.043748874217271805, -0.020157072693109512, -0.01433731522411108, -0.010810349136590958, 0.05288911238312721, 0.005075186025351286, -0.01050885021686554, 0.009574702009558678, -0.0012609271798282862, -0.07582767307758331, 0.009130832739174366, -0.02600570023059845, -0.009276253171265125, 0.0051567344926297665, 0.011775442399084568, 0.04322021082043648, -0.0043411473743617535, 0.007870975881814957, 0.041777852922677994, -0.0033763477113097906, -0.038256317377090454, -0.004823863506317139, -0.003907135222107172, 0.02209109626710415, 0.042266570031642914, 0.008044826798141003, 0.027513304725289345, -0.02775266394019127, 0.013030629605054855, -0.009398536756634712, 0.039620574563741684, 0.07051711529493332, 0.02789122611284256, 0.0008330617565661669, -0.02542642131447792, -0.0022597000934183598, 0.006974987685680389, 0.0007281117723323405, 0.01218301523476839, 0.01820608787238598, 0.06208328530192375, 0.01613309048116207, -0.06797640025615692, -0.0033699506893754005, 0.06111307442188263, -0.0018371471669524908, -0.009147374890744686, -0.03256518766283989, 0.03246298059821129, -0.0022799824364483356, -0.010065586306154728, -0.012545219622552395, -0.007968753576278687, -0.02081654779613018, -0.013739719055593014, 0.060611940920352936, 0.0009300358942709863, -0.04659154638648033, -0.010233815759420395, -0.020076032727956772, 0.022296667098999023, 0.008520885370671749, -0.04851851612329483, 0.03363652154803276, 0.05669008940458298, 0.023059919476509094, 0.02469848468899727, -0.009398289024829865, -0.08693951368331909, 0.007473254110664129, 0.021165037527680397, 0.056939709931612015, -0.023787207901477814, -0.010861551389098167, -0.02944561280310154, -0.03896619752049446, 0.059021323919296265, -0.024936849251389503, 0.024549759924411774, 0.013244358822703362, 0.022424770519137383, -0.018786465749144554, -0.039644867181777954, -0.0415014922618866, -0.009564520791172981, -0.03307849541306496, 0.04165608435869217, -0.05031496658921242, 0.002259171102195978, -0.030297942459583282, 0.042840130627155304, 0.060927167534828186, 0.08496537059545517, 0.03401346132159233, -0.0009324271231889725, -0.05158574506640434, -0.007940714247524738, -0.016500182449817657, -0.0765819102525711, 0.02331591583788395, -0.0014944771537557244, -0.012337319552898407, 0.05160932242870331, -0.023769762367010117, -0.05303613469004631, 0.021907959133386612, -0.02533775381743908, 0.0077741737477481365, -0.0007010100525803864, -0.024888815358281136, 0.05181014537811279, 0.033604178577661514, 0.04248777776956558, 0.05802779644727707, 0.004724549595266581, 0.0036003589630126953, 0.011230682954192162, 0.004548349883407354, -0.011220628395676613, -0.012904033996164799, -0.016354314982891083, -0.02229238674044609, 0.018102101981639862, 0.007822506129741669, 0.04391910508275032, -0.008240872994065285, 0.011972534470260143, 0.006677971221506596, 0.0024592475965619087, -0.0326678641140461, 0.03388196602463722, 0.023794224485754967, -0.014623313210904598, -0.00424923887476325, 0.009539834223687649, 0.008734213188290596, -0.0061716982163488865, 0.03901642933487892, -0.022476792335510254, 0.016716567799448967, -0.005331686232239008, -0.018851278349757195, 0.008248008787631989, -0.06730315089225769, -0.020219584926962852, 0.048700686544179916, -0.02917577140033245, 0.057795796543359756, -0.023057512938976288, 0.029050378128886223, -0.003488830290734768, -0.07407672703266144, -0.027176404371857643, 0.012519769370555878, 0.011313671246170998, 0.052366647869348526, -0.02027626894414425, 0.00041935249464586377, -0.044838737696409225, 0.015532619319856167, -0.06610467284917831, -0.06207457184791565, 0.022361567243933678, 0.03944387286901474, -0.029848337173461914, -0.04367487132549286, 0.013158873654901981, -0.029072484001517296, 0.0029688598588109016, -0.004449526779353619, 0.04899013787508011, -0.03736133873462677, -0.004019599407911301, 0.014069237746298313, 0.0030540076550096273, 0.049942828714847565, -0.010310271754860878, -0.026271607726812363, 0.03957095742225647, -0.009553531184792519, 0.00469954451546073, 0.001428287010639906, 0.007662932854145765, -0.04061979055404663, -0.0026613916270434856, -0.013611541129648685, 0.005278141237795353, 0.045489050447940826, -0.028240183368325233, 0.014829558320343494, 0.006329967174679041, -0.004656998906284571, 0.007053743116557598, -0.009227689355611801, 0.0033904905430972576, 0.03260210156440735, 0.0023771452251821756, 0.01605127938091755, -0.023369785398244858, 0.00872834213078022, 0.0170198492705822, 0.018831634894013405, 0.011463326402008533, -0.014627866446971893, 0.016929367557168007, 0.025548364967107773, 0.010739313438534737, -0.008110574446618557, -0.0071329702623188496, -0.009712171740829945, 0.04519953206181526, 0.021606825292110443, -0.016393594443798065, 0.008451919071376324, 0.028680607676506042, -0.020849116146564484, -0.06577052175998688, -0.06143757328391075, -0.0009030369692482054, 0.07542802393436432, -0.016653770580887794, 0.05253636837005615, 0.04416966438293457, 0.030841946601867676, -0.011104745790362358, 0.00960833765566349, -0.004926970694214106, 0.019211437553167343, 0.018766488879919052, 0.007879139855504036, -0.014820517972111702, 0.0027476006653159857, 0.016714273020625114, 0.005084517411887646, 0.007918400689959526, 0.031943242996931076, -0.009984812699258327, 0.012864897958934307, 0.07640020549297333, -0.03711942955851555, -0.025500545278191566, 0.005075818859040737, -0.04662109166383743, 0.021593721583485603, -0.015151948668062687, -0.04909138008952141, 0.057642899453639984, 0.015094636939466, -0.019616128876805305, -0.029892439022660255, -0.03684432432055473, -0.029531104490160942, 0.006305209826678038, 0.03513357415795326, 0.026051361113786697, 0.012008007615804672, 0.007435004226863384, -0.00030956679256632924, 0.005349227227270603, 0.018688606098294258, 0.014072488993406296, -0.07755780220031738, 0.007889648899435997, -0.03557956963777542, -0.06803697347640991, 0.04511401802301407, 0.03289731591939926, -0.022642845287919044, 0.03429887816309929, -0.014375708065927029, 0.025784973055124283, 0.0034933469723910093, 0.06570889055728912, -0.008509889245033264, 0.06491898000240326, 0.0050263372249901295, 0.012404129840433598, -0.008830389939248562, 0.03585555776953697, 0.10367202758789062, 0.09059266000986099, 0.026834595948457718, -0.03847726434469223, 0.0029369646217674017, -0.006243502721190453, 0.0061659496277570724, -0.03383505344390869, 0.022952936589717865, -0.007849575020372868, -0.014601986855268478, 0.023977261036634445, 0.0500376895070076, -0.004953444004058838, -0.005458255298435688, 0.06296480447053909, -0.02854657918214798, -0.03766842931509018, -0.027909155935049057, 0.03139645606279373, 0.003572050714865327, -0.0038355260621756315, -0.03674066811800003, 0.041093483567237854, 0.025242378935217857, -0.053237322717905045, -0.03317432105541229, -0.01840336062014103, 0.007852254435420036, -0.027351630851626396, -0.036674633622169495, 0.005760046653449535, 0.053937289863824844, 0.005629989318549633, -0.017157286405563354, 0.027193227782845497, 0.03331939876079559, -0.018742414191365242, 0.017814014106988907, 0.012567008845508099, 0.00932442769408226, 0.0017576608806848526, -0.0008128590416163206, -0.004821827169507742, -0.07231447100639343, -0.034075312316417694, -0.044507768005132675, 0.036458373069763184, -0.021452445536851883, 0.01634214259684086, -0.04296131059527397, -0.03327392786741257, 0.02214694954454899, -0.018385013565421104, -0.026747938245534897, -0.005975197535008192, 0.007024356164038181, -0.04482248052954674, -0.006541058421134949, -0.01260762196034193, 0.006363970227539539, -0.00015122201875783503, 0.019567783921957016, 0.029933098703622818, -0.022486047819256783, 0.0069206575863063335, -0.009143318049609661, 0.0351995974779129, 0.006952060852199793, -0.007477263920009136, -0.014085509814321995, -0.03713901340961456, -0.028372617438435555, -0.03483490273356438, 0.0285567007958889, 0.01665365695953369, 0.015997324138879776, 0.005433487240225077, -0.0220908485352993, 0.021689044311642647, -0.03278030455112457, -0.006627700291574001, -0.04590006172657013, 0.004234622232615948, -0.050899799913167953, 0.024380037561058998, 0.002759194001555443, 0.01737136021256447, 0.00744046363979578, 0.026397010311484337, -0.0009735772619023919, 0.03798938915133476, 0.019808175042271614, -0.021250898018479347, -0.01393030397593975, -0.019521288573741913, -0.014366702176630497, 0.021091794595122337, -0.002379031153395772, 0.07477542012929916, -0.0010220551630482078, 0.00874011404812336, 0.02192484214901924, 0.05372653156518936, -0.014322313480079174, 0.0021667852997779846, 0.012623725458979607, -0.05864538624882698, 0.010189157910645008, -0.011816884391009808, 0.029129471629858017, -0.017190074548125267, -0.023512762039899826, 0.0032195919193327427, -0.002368062036111951, -0.005627117585390806, 0.0004959027282893658, -0.028793498873710632, 0.013476347550749779, -0.024434486404061317, 0.0007242313586175442, -0.011545997112989426, 0.01862533949315548, 0.00716434046626091, 0.02003055065870285, -0.01884082518517971, -0.011139153502881527, -0.044005293399095535, -0.006471904460340738, -0.007629793137311935, 0.006239504553377628, 0.013616984710097313, 0.011957614682614803, -0.001408494426868856, -0.023795878514647484, 0.028133822605013847, -0.01589887961745262, 0.05770658701658249, -0.03295666724443436, -0.017404040321707726, 0.052900899201631546, -0.06156129762530327, -0.019394634291529655, 0.03298167884349823, 0.003287979168817401, 0.041387010365724564, 0.04231466352939606, -0.01696988381445408, -0.023481709882616997, 0.02377791330218315, -0.05593416094779968, -0.01888233795762062, -0.0029831603169441223, 0.03559212386608124, -0.025880806148052216, 0.02255416288971901, 0.01030840165913105, 0.02588324435055256, -0.022921094670891762, 0.007801043801009655, 0.021690869703888893, 0.0029891852755099535, -0.002921062521636486, 0.024798663333058357, 0.012168853543698788, 0.005668504163622856, 0.06105754151940346, -0.00553840072825551, 0.006602461449801922, 0.07930505275726318, -0.025546206161379814, 0.04217270761728287, 0.0026872374583035707, 0.034478332847356796, -0.10542265325784683, -0.04416906088590622, 0.005397687666118145, 0.008765925653278828, 0.04672802984714508, -0.06378055363893509, 0.0031325321178883314, 0.04208901897072792, -0.05623643472790718, 0.020716065540909767, -0.002202605130150914, -0.005844439845532179, -0.03499797731637955, 0.043845076113939285, -0.02757037803530693, 0.0259344894438982, 0.017829209566116333, 0.0350651778280735, 0.05770142376422882, 0.02283487282693386, -0.004042705055326223, -0.02266165055334568, -0.007566417567431927, 0.0017060566460713744, 0.004162889439612627, -0.05619767680764198, 0.03522859141230583, -0.06724967807531357, -0.05617538467049599, 0.03426770493388176, -0.007231647148728371, 0.013845901936292648, 0.013756724074482918, 0.014248347841203213, -0.011094566434621811, 0.050712235271930695, 0.019603779539465904, -0.022596800699830055, 0.009517384693026543, -0.008836057037115097, 0.0030621427576988935, 0.041339706629514694, -0.017762010917067528, 0.015852337703108788, 0.04486231505870819, -0.013460468500852585, -0.03185384348034859, 0.005879446864128113, 0.010871242731809616, -0.008549168705940247, 0.022796230390667915, -0.026570355519652367, -0.011036083102226257, -0.044588226824998856, 0.036094944924116135, -0.05366942659020424, 0.011385087855160236, 0.012616215273737907, 0.008455337956547737, 0.006457112263888121, -0.00450019771233201, -0.02767299674451351, -0.0487828403711319, -0.002025777706876397, 0.021956680342555046, -0.018967678770422935, -0.08642598241567612, 0.005322417709976435, 0.013049552217125893, -0.044731784611940384, 0.006581631954759359, -0.0553961843252182, -0.018631495535373688, 0.01701613888144493, -0.023998824879527092, -0.010005190037190914, 0.034552156925201416, -0.019095316529273987, 0.028002746403217316, -0.08224765211343765, 0.021582460030913353, -0.0182778462767601, 0.024568114429712296, -0.031219104304909706, -0.016573967412114143, -0.014000852592289448, -0.018460558727383614, 0.02574813738465309, -0.02667689323425293, 0.006285387556999922, 0.0029966537840664387, 0.017214905470609665, 0.016295339912176132, -0.024825239554047585, 0.005726613570004702, -0.057813819497823715, -0.014560387469828129, -0.02149828150868416, -0.03868001326918602, 0.02275586873292923, -0.024823304265737534, 0.02006501331925392, -0.013069717213511467, -0.006196742877364159, -0.01908845826983452, -0.005382127594202757, 0.036621421575546265, -0.002314983634278178, -0.008355146273970604, 0.03616190701723099, -0.02837567776441574, 0.0067438771948218346, 0.03271134942770004, -0.0029172077775001526, -0.05068711191415787, 0.04519764706492424, -0.008518727496266365, -0.058812256902456284, 0.01782657951116562, 0.011549056507647038, 0.030573450028896332, -0.057183392345905304, 0.03285149484872818, 0.022186866030097008, -0.03721959888935089, 0.003247441491112113, 0.029746122658252716, -0.02039456181228161, 0.01708163134753704, -0.008668997325003147, 0.023263616487383842, 0.007109127007424831, -0.03962881863117218, -0.012771569192409515, 0.01326032355427742, 0.04636020213365555, -0.008835776709020138, 0.015714766457676888, 0.044242069125175476, -0.019899500533938408, 0.008470159955322742, 0.04657354950904846, -0.011551950126886368, -0.04562065377831459, -0.0104318056255579, -0.0129391523078084, 0.0063196332193911076, 0.02306322567164898, -0.02008410356938839, -0.019245754927396774, 0.0867115929722786, 0.01947585493326187, 0.01210390217602253, -0.055052004754543304, 0.00988872442394495, -0.022166112437844276, -0.00581979937851429, -0.01273464784026146, 0.020178640261292458, -0.038131773471832275, 0.013105159625411034, -0.008059817366302013, 0.0038595551159232855, 0.04746174067258835, -0.019952258095145226, 0.015492111444473267, -0.014313717372715473, 0.004471482243388891, -0.03529272601008415, -0.022468527778983116, -0.03162679448723793, -0.023562274873256683, 0.011627907864749432, 0.03562489524483681, 0.032879941165447235, 0.010544465854763985, -0.0043741436675190926, -0.02326367050409317, 0.042911872267723083, -0.04547079652547836, 0.009661303833127022, -0.067760169506073, 0.03451975807547569, 0.0010622680420055985, -0.02070462517440319 ]
<p>I have been having a hard time deciding which statistical test to choose for a dataset. The more a read on the web, the more I get confused since frequently there are different opinions when it comes to chose the right test.</p> <p>To this extent, when in doubt, I apply one parametric and one non-parametric tests, for example, an one-way ANOVA and a Kruskal-Wallis, or a two-sample t-test and a Mann-Whiteney, hoping that both tests give me the same output (generally $p &lt; 0.05$). If they do, I am done; if not, then I need to work harder.</p> <p>Is there some well recognized site out there that provides some kind of decision support tree for choosing statistical tests?</p> <p>Is there some tool that checks <em>as much as possible</em> the assumptions of a statistical test on a given dataset before applying it? For example, for one-way ANOVA it could check for normality and variance homogeneity automatically!</p> <p>I think such site or tool would help a lot, but probably I am asking too much ...</p> <p>Thanks</p>
74,197
[ -0.0379742756485939, -0.006082493346184492, -0.01086460705846548, 0.0017215498955920339, 0.013078947551548481, 0.03588198497891426, 0.013828826136887074, -0.018821770325303078, 0.004963441286236048, -0.003500603139400482, 0.07292059808969498, 0.040387704968452454, 0.02586180903017521, 0.032238077372312546, -0.0015262766974046826, 0.0002190347877331078, -0.025136448442935944, -0.030120497569441795, -0.021270692348480225, -0.012401054613292217, -0.008325750008225441, -0.008103284984827042, -0.0055802082642912865, -0.02093333750963211, -0.04343931004405022, 0.035126443952322006, 0.011141777038574219, -0.004909943323582411, 0.009042623452842236, 0.04015756770968437, -0.0684286430478096, -0.03381501883268356, -0.02865726314485073, 0.040749724954366684, 0.004478815011680126, -0.0038971451576799154, 0.01734454557299614, -0.0227209459990263, -0.016682453453540802, 0.027076514437794685, -0.02989095263183117, -0.002514033345505595, 0.0069705648347735405, 0.037533797323703766, -0.0034795980900526047, 0.007865379564464092, -0.01944243535399437, -0.007009152323007584, 0.01112364698201418, -0.06885652244091034, 0.06695784628391266, 0.03238651528954506, 0.041800934821367264, 0.039609432220458984, 0.0011051782639697194, -0.011820395477116108, 0.019668713212013245, 0.04562258720397949, -0.030243225395679474, -0.07171640545129776, -0.008927428163588047, -0.017805850133299828, 0.0014684951165691018, 0.002840423956513405, -0.07199835032224655, 0.04352487251162529, -0.009966544806957245, -0.01305407378822565, 0.03779188543558121, -0.009974710643291473, 0.0013338824501261115, -0.0053827897645533085, 0.04744601249694824, -0.005202976055443287, -0.010739374905824661, 0.015173383057117462, 0.013819129206240177, -0.004375125281512737, 0.05821729823946953, 0.03959595784544945, 0.01621812954545021, 0.008890587836503983, -0.00016056776803452522, 0.020466960966587067, 0.041806887835264206, -0.036693982779979706, 0.07745610922574997, -0.02522898279130459, -0.055412065237760544, 0.016655294224619865, -0.014664712361991405, -0.033223725855350494, 0.04925142601132393, -0.008734841831028461, -0.03468089923262596, -0.0011457119835540652, -0.0275886207818985, 0.013773909769952297, -0.00847547221928835, -0.009171182289719582, 0.0021117597352713346, -0.04669952392578125, 0.03612011671066284, 0.05314641445875168, -0.01350459922105074, -0.006633896380662918, 0.006842383649200201, 0.006640690844506025, -0.009367825463414192, -0.019573146477341652, 0.008037404157221317, 0.04448804631829262, -0.0031794372480362654, 0.01123893167823553, 0.017238160595297813, -0.0005314876907505095, 0.003747012000530958, -0.026620803400874138, 0.042990390211343765, 0.056158699095249176, 0.08274172991514206, -0.019495410844683647, 0.028558671474456787, -0.019631540402770042, -0.04385161027312279, 0.006601480767130852, 0.019614268094301224, -0.012516791932284832, -0.024021176621317863, 0.07882524281740189, -0.013438789173960686, -0.02128485031425953, 0.03295421227812767, 0.0029294348787516356, 0.0508548766374588, 0.007400091737508774, -0.08761958032846451, -0.0772603377699852, 0.022934745997190475, -0.005879248958081007, -0.0030209075193852186, -0.04548016935586929, -0.006264036055654287, 0.015719112008810043, 0.05464966595172882, -0.004717343486845493, 0.05004332587122917, -0.023153215646743774, 0.013624228537082672, -0.0015356827061623335, -0.040745943784713745, -0.008540235459804535, -0.019975310191512108, -0.012886838987469673, 0.00977000780403614, -0.06740539520978928, 0.024595459923148155, -0.007454859558492899, 0.0018512718379497528, 0.008398882113397121, 0.03159415349364281, 0.009776219725608826, -0.036099400371313095, 0.021084124222397804, 0.022591911256313324, -0.009266277775168419, 0.0692870244383812, -0.012650320306420326, 0.05731084942817688, 0.012065693736076355, -0.0016639543464407325, 0.025987347587943077, 0.029600774869322777, 0.050169285386800766, 0.04609740525484085, 0.0009380558039993048, -0.0007105086697265506, -0.007768220268189907, 0.035212237387895584, -0.017181454226374626, -0.03603383153676987, -0.019952790811657906, -0.021679190918803215, -0.005382576026022434, 0.024960044771432877, 0.034989483654499054, 0.004774125292897224, -0.041656143963336945, 0.04738358408212662, -0.06382496654987335, -0.056008659303188324, -0.04724733904004097, -0.015480401925742626, -0.04624084383249283, -0.06432744115591049, 0.031515005975961685, 0.03886954486370087, -0.0033829330932348967, -0.022192180156707764, -0.03882644698023796, -0.027967991307377815, 0.0012034160317853093, 0.0367044098675251, -0.03503131866455078, -0.002506062388420105, 0.009270585142076015, 0.02627239190042019, -0.05214877799153328, 0.02761266566812992, -0.04890761151909828, -0.06960532814264297, -0.004292320925742388, -0.05544966459274292, 0.004898166283965111, 0.007773466873914003, -0.015633584931492805, -0.025525163859128952, 0.011341407895088196, -0.010419284924864769, 0.04239753261208534, -0.049864526838064194, 0.06134024262428284, 0.014738460071384907, 0.02551805041730404, 0.008099582977592945, -0.004389466717839241, -0.006199438590556383, 0.002915206365287304, -0.032817840576171875, 0.012210620567202568, -0.031708359718322754, 0.0318254716694355, 0.040789809077978134, -0.020811745896935463, -0.038146983832120895, 0.03374044969677925, 0.046189047396183014, 0.009488598443567753, -0.01619723066687584, 0.029102109372615814, -0.015325131826102734, -0.04954798147082329, 0.0030118764843791723, 0.04330221936106682, 0.030164649710059166, 0.017165137454867363, 0.022418001666665077, 0.023050576448440552, 0.04287046566605568, 0.0315328873693943, -0.007255488075315952, 0.04143170267343521, -0.016883816570043564, -0.007048184052109718, -0.03157253563404083, -0.028840892016887665, 0.033794838935136795, -0.013655739836394787, 0.019172636792063713, 0.023339778184890747, 0.022531472146511078, -0.0026263941545039415, -0.004450930282473564, -0.03446361422538757, 0.04276488348841667, 0.006042515859007835, -0.03968520835042, 0.026487575843930244, 0.033153995871543884, -0.018955236300826073, 0.022034762427210808, -0.035139601677656174, -0.040712207555770874, -0.06542641669511795, 0.010647307150065899, -0.00908012967556715, 0.01647491194307804, 0.02910764515399933, -0.019777225330471992, 0.0038956019561737776, 0.008250748738646507, -0.032536763697862625, 0.022949138656258583, 0.0036683292128145695, -0.015092295594513416, -0.01903349906206131, -0.06411781162023544, 0.0008719683974049985, 0.057710565626621246, -0.002194337546825409, -0.011709255166351795, 0.03711056336760521, 0.041336540132761, -0.03577762469649315, -0.0426335334777832, -0.04451760649681091, 0.01834256760776043, -0.03516760095953941, -0.0427946113049984, 0.000878792954608798, -0.012436752207577229, -0.010848645120859146, 0.06023228168487549, -0.043330442160367966, -0.027681272476911545, 0.0157193373888731, 0.022051215171813965, 0.009181373752653599, -0.0016283865552395582, 0.0006090599345043302, 0.04538409039378166, -0.017973648384213448, -0.027603035792708397, -0.07725929468870163, -0.03905731439590454, 0.008917558006942272, -0.0038574591744691133, 0.049917303025722504, 0.042812738567590714, -0.025744473561644554, 0.06482838094234467, 0.04441048577427864, -0.02645207941532135, -0.04474322125315666, 0.0005815985496155918, -0.05563640967011452, -0.0359715074300766, 0.012339359149336815, 0.0045256963931024075, -0.02782713994383812, 0.021677110344171524, 0.02160179615020752, 0.0031171287409961224, 0.020015163347125053, 0.030143387615680695, -0.0062655117362737656, 0.026702802628278732, 0.022745603695511818, -0.034137822687625885, 0.025418171659111977, 0.01647460088133812, 0.008641197346150875, -0.001904114498756826, -0.0042021977715194225, -0.008038269355893135, 0.012313948012888432, -0.022031355649232864, 0.03293602541089058, -0.016118256375193596, 0.006007820833474398, -0.058582548052072525, -0.0036036071833223104, 0.0024239912163466215, -0.01714802347123623, 0.003507017157971859, 0.017673876136541367, -0.010207057930529118, -0.011950265616178513, 0.02275499701499939, 0.03730585798621178, 0.04621640220284462, -0.02509385533630848, -0.042143724858760834, -0.01178075186908245, -0.02741497941315174, 0.01720641739666462, -0.001827971893362701, -0.020884348079562187, 0.04415722191333771, 0.04598139598965645, 0.050537995994091034, -0.011708058416843414, -0.0493377186357975, 0.031150640919804573, -0.04060078784823418, 0.017332611605525017, -0.05151114612817764, 0.04678259789943695, 0.0034793028607964516, 0.04782429337501526, 0.021733922883868217, -0.012439720332622528, -0.005153412465006113, -0.0023766423109918833, -0.056382738053798676, 0.05103249475359917, -0.002639593556523323, -0.014399680308997631, 0.025682231411337852, -0.02733134664595127, 0.040512003004550934, -0.020613232627511024, 0.02781735733151436, 0.003305444261059165, 0.06774575263261795, -0.013946695253252983, 0.013737352564930916, -0.022299811244010925, -0.04909132048487663, 0.0033180778846144676, 0.01522702444344759, -0.029145166277885437, -0.030065368860960007, 0.03246774896979332, -0.00010122236562892795, -0.004875746089965105, -0.003505381755530834, 0.0018078986322507262, 0.028458353132009506, 0.01545186061412096, 0.03299221768975258, 0.04741356521844864, 0.025162074714899063, -0.02467852644622326, 0.008409376256167889, -0.027307478711009026, 0.042560506612062454, 0.015304970555007458, -0.004379450809210539, 0.004850017372518778, -0.026972102001309395, -0.032793037593364716, -0.020993240177631378, 0.009719714522361755, 0.01080454234033823, -0.01966211013495922, 0.04106743633747101, 0.017077041789889336, -0.03341507166624069, 0.031208312138915062, 0.06753494590520859, -0.015478314831852913, -0.0026985853910446167, -0.02355046384036541, -0.02360333688557148, -0.010316711850464344, 0.013150428421795368, 0.01667162775993347, 0.044861696660518646, 0.002364743035286665, -0.015905681997537613, 0.016710476949810982, -0.015346905216574669, -0.009408502839505672, 0.0015373462811112404, 0.02158551663160324, 0.06427715718746185, 0.0041331336833536625, -0.019292112439870834, 0.04874085262417793, 0.008331486955285072, 0.02861335314810276, 0.0308237262070179, -0.003949685953557491, -0.07917160540819168, 0.04332036152482033, 0.08351468294858932, 0.0369410403072834, -0.03505181148648262, -0.0016330924117937684, -0.02794705703854561, -0.019000200554728508, 0.05660784989595413, -0.029064128175377846, 0.023000219836831093, 0.007967174984514713, 0.015875274315476418, -0.05725860223174095, 0.009799244813621044, -0.0319761224091053, -0.012985999695956707, -0.014682049863040447, 0.02781609073281288, -0.018426885828375816, -0.017111526802182198, -0.06996436417102814, -0.014669670723378658, -0.005141125991940498, 0.04105662927031517, -0.027766147628426552, -0.020802317187190056, 0.024182118475437164, -0.001517260679975152, -0.0005964850424788892, -0.06408395618200302, -0.01646723598241806, 0.015503437258303165, -0.009307850152254105, 0.03812999278306961, 0.010882013477385044, -0.0261903814971447, 0.03831101208925247, -0.03700212016701698, -0.04652060568332672, 0.015224406495690346, 0.01310088112950325, 0.035946544259786606, 0.016795065253973007, 0.0416266992688179, 0.05697740614414215, 0.011532158590853214, 0.001873360830359161, 0.022153323516249657, -0.049897223711013794, 0.03263585641980171, -0.03134392574429512, 0.0019018846796825528, -0.06143350899219513, -0.051810216158628464, -0.04200687259435654, 0.02791384793817997, 0.015543549321591854, 0.0124655831605196, -0.018235769122838974, -0.005563449580222368, -0.01420794241130352, 0.03348727151751518, 0.026981718838214874, -0.01933424174785614, 0.021037451922893524, -0.013268541544675827, -0.026993395760655403, 0.009254103526473045, 0.045622725039720535, 0.007006329949945211, -0.0024732770398259163, -0.0008993162773549557, -0.05191672220826149, 0.0338326022028923, -0.039595700800418854, -0.04253044351935387, -0.00425090454518795, -0.02479708008468151, 0.050822917371988297, -0.000885218265466392, 0.08530620485544205, -0.017148954793810844, -0.029867298901081085, -0.010694341734051704, 0.04230473190546036, 0.014450675807893276, 0.05395466461777687, -0.04214194416999817, 0.04789968580007553, -0.05651174858212471, 0.01208326406776905, -0.05856866389513016, 0.0015810932964086533, 0.021559471264481544, 0.010387972928583622, -0.024989450350403786, -0.026295991614460945, 0.017922189086675644, -0.01719263195991516, -0.009195837192237377, -0.0049460469745099545, 0.06732499599456787, 0.004268970340490341, -0.0363299623131752, 0.01039207261055708, 0.06513693928718567, 0.06942830234766006, -0.0235150009393692, 0.019113007932901382, -0.016092348843812943, -0.020755520090460777, -0.017176132649183273, 0.03433731943368912, 0.00393423717468977, -0.03139299526810646, 0.004864571616053581, -0.04931451752781868, 0.014374298974871635, 0.03298259526491165, -0.02148963324725628, 0.007052809000015259, 0.03328271955251694, -0.017695492133498192, -0.015458800829946995, -0.037225790321826935, 0.022223401814699173, 0.0010796479182317853, 0.029776694253087044, -0.015149013139307499, 0.009534868411719799, -0.012159699574112892, 0.0021453695371747017, -0.018134387210011482, 0.0005405798438005149, -0.01921161636710167, 0.05593753978610039, 0.0748346820473671, 0.002221764298155904, 0.04637470841407776, -0.01919625513255596, -0.04015478119254112, 0.013796582818031311, -0.012337417341768742, -0.009353690780699253, 0.04233111813664436, 0.012044548988342285, -0.054721422493457794, -0.011851130984723568, -0.0038205827586352825, -0.007995945401489735, 0.01576767861843109, -0.007417391985654831, 0.08167895674705505, 0.09535285085439682, 0.02241428755223751, 0.009626827202737331, -0.0139271579682827, -0.015759987756609917, -0.006600688211619854, 0.03195091709494591, 0.06273093074560165, 0.00966395903378725, 0.010810337960720062, 0.028154751285910606, 0.01707109808921814, 0.022247668355703354, 0.03132045641541481, 0.01534014567732811, 0.028881564736366272, 0.06115845963358879, -0.03792283684015274, -0.041577745229005814, 0.033103469759225845, -0.05954001098871231, 0.002243868773803115, -0.023400217294692993, -0.002845712238922715, 0.05545499920845032, 0.06511162966489792, -0.0031542798969894648, -0.05086845904588699, -0.018216252326965332, -0.06774383038282394, 0.010432282462716103, 0.0011208478827029467, -0.02270761877298355, 0.009412921033799648, 0.01480959728360176, 0.016126839444041252, -0.007744782138615847, 0.02758415788412094, -0.008306600153446198, -0.06657174974679947, -0.04276026040315628, -0.00487471604719758, -0.03476067632436752, 0.027473481371998787, 0.011806899681687355, -0.04002575948834419, 0.01252930797636509, -0.035562604665756226, 0.026934731751680374, -0.001901106210425496, 0.019947966560721397, -0.024472612887620926, 0.041340421885252, -0.03345029056072235, 0.01573023945093155, 0.004713693168014288, -0.009862999431788921, 0.12634365260601044, 0.07350096106529236, 0.041317880153656006, -0.08158238232135773, 0.021485183387994766, -0.02165149711072445, 0.005254810675978661, -0.0038811068516224623, 0.02495194971561432, 0.0030141319148242474, 0.007075376808643341, 0.02515629306435585, 0.0748528465628624, 0.01136121153831482, -0.01785401441156864, 0.0828707218170166, -0.029087072238326073, -0.0234359223395586, 0.019121864810585976, 0.00734562985599041, 0.007221803534775972, -0.030776437371969223, -0.011113029904663563, 0.0029119302053004503, 0.005614141933619976, -0.0016276378883048892, -0.025491515174508095, -0.057929132133722305, 0.019021080806851387, -0.015672583132982254, -0.018171770498156548, 0.0017766528762876987, 0.019710058346390724, 0.023829244077205658, -0.04089740291237831, 0.004588717129081488, 0.0016150296432897449, -0.030054718255996704, 0.023649046197533607, 0.03593454509973526, 0.015613994561135769, -0.026030194014310837, 0.028629031032323837, 0.014884034171700478, -0.03471306711435318, 0.009657218120992184, -0.02651926316320896, 0.03921413794159889, 0.008049010299146175, -0.013657201081514359, -0.04944793879985809, 0.006551341153681278, 0.028124062344431877, -0.025738950818777084, -0.013078236021101475, -0.003357154317200184, 0.021286915987730026, -0.01033207681030035, -0.00677490932866931, -0.051824647933244705, 0.033683665096759796, -0.005804107058793306, 0.04546494036912918, 0.022509144619107246, -0.01038810983300209, -0.014166329987347126, -0.011923755519092083, 0.061427365988492966, 0.018323121592402458, -0.016062770038843155, 0.016963401809334755, -0.023160960525274277, -0.03899642825126648, 0.025237558409571648, -0.0037349737249314785, 0.01906016655266285, 0.026933155953884125, -0.007730824872851372, -0.013682646676898003, 0.00683232769370079, -0.06727230548858643, 0.013653239235281944, -0.05887703225016594, 0.0070058321580290794, -0.03765036165714264, -0.036485154181718826, 0.030428366735577583, 0.02896161936223507, 0.05049358680844307, 0.022430386394262314, 0.02010623924434185, 0.03107582777738571, 0.019806506112217903, -0.07924874871969223, -0.009067382663488388, -0.016347728669643402, -0.01781407743692398, 0.0058904546312987804, -0.04739762842655182, 0.050721317529678345, -0.010845213197171688, 0.041879862546920776, -0.027807051315903664, 0.02282988280057907, -0.016177130863070488, 0.008014250546693802, -0.03786980360746384, -0.05465655401349068, -0.02471068687736988, 0.016547635197639465, 0.02071990817785263, -0.026179881766438484, -0.03339289128780365, -0.030205171555280685, -0.03697363659739494, 0.033996473997831345, -0.014549857936799526, -0.0038315493147820234, 0.013793678022921085, 0.014149196445941925, 0.01904459111392498, -0.04599392041563988, -0.00924422312527895, -0.03855323791503906, -0.0443819984793663, 0.00531573873013258, 0.016112755984067917, 0.020764462649822235, -0.006591394077986479, 0.007687870413064957, -0.000994729227386415, 0.03067755326628685, 0.010911074467003345, 0.009568072855472565, 0.042452890425920486, -0.008650627918541431, -0.008207239210605621, 0.061332959681749344, -0.007007796783000231, 0.012016342021524906, 0.04059397429227829, -0.03913954272866249, -0.051295168697834015, 0.012147906236350536, -0.004405598621815443, 0.03119763918220997, -0.01017789263278246, -0.006246845703572035, -0.010990876704454422, 0.05132999271154404, -0.022484388202428818, -0.01933152787387371, -0.030755549669265747, -0.015229985117912292, 0.0001738120918162167, -0.012534351088106632, 0.0005137482658028603, -0.0064862617291510105, -0.0306612029671669, 0.05456673726439476, 0.03743710741400719, 0.020291155204176903, -0.01930762454867363, 0.0009702230454422534, -0.0039343261159956455, 0.009120360016822815, 0.027277901768684387, -0.029091645032167435, 0.03791763260960579, 0.05565321445465088, -0.04836319386959076, 0.029390724375844002, -0.007564017549157143, 0.0126192606985569, -0.07987891882658005, -0.013689576648175716, -0.004039029590785503, 0.014043688774108887, 0.031069671735167503, -0.05421435460448265, 0.03175409883260727, 0.013105889782309532, -0.00985014159232378, -0.007471979595720768, -0.01130409725010395, -0.031113773584365845, -0.01807894930243492, -0.028066543862223625, -0.0077163237147033215, 0.0238802470266819, -0.017387034371495247, 0.01896035484969616, 0.03002057410776615, 0.039013735949993134, 0.01651441492140293, -0.034651435911655426, 0.005067005287855864, 0.021982751786708832, 0.0020754309371113777, -0.0940861850976944, 0.011904575861990452, 0.0020574326626956463, -0.06954720616340637, 0.04175781458616257, -0.014918508939445019, 0.030164964497089386, 0.00834114570170641, 0.048169199377298355, -0.015941647812724113, 0.036986324936151505, 0.033771809190511703, 0.010019942186772823, -0.02938264049589634, -0.015973836183547974, 0.01659718155860901, 0.046847596764564514, -0.026195716112852097, 0.014874891377985477, 0.02919495850801468, -0.019917912781238556, -0.024015503004193306, 0.011973041109740734, -0.029371220618486404, -0.03524988517165184, -0.0053116511553525925, -0.012113342992961407, 0.014599582180380821, 0.005483739078044891, 0.006855106446892023, -0.05449232459068298, 0.028135688975453377, 0.017861967906355858, 0.03618669509887695, 0.02834106981754303, 0.03886481374502182, -0.010347994044423103, -0.03302760049700737, 0.003538402495905757, -0.0035362355411052704, 0.02893914468586445, -0.05031484365463257, -0.013560492545366287, -0.021751930937170982, -0.019144244492053986, -0.009016978554427624, -0.02305973507463932, -0.008150209672749043, 0.013879907317459583, -0.03443118557333946, -0.012389136478304863, 0.014597303234040737, -0.02195977047085762, 0.0035102872643619776, -0.09656000882387161, 0.08142901957035065, 0.018643908202648163, -0.00840586144477129, -0.04357985034584999, 0.0042391493916511536, -0.018100444227457047, -0.014507127925753593, 0.038472939282655716, -0.0018541524186730385, 0.029447587206959724, -0.03886912390589714, 0.005796290934085846, -0.007646200712770224, -0.07133211195468903, 0.04271349310874939, -0.034532930701971054, -0.0337965190410614, -0.014751878567039967, -0.020394165068864822, 0.03667481616139412, 0.011538173072040081, 0.03745489940047264, 0.012192795053124428, 0.015947455540299416, -0.011306099593639374, 0.01002313569188118, 0.03695426136255264, 0.011718839406967163, -0.017569206655025482, 0.026034511625766754, -0.04181160032749176, 0.012014475651085377, 0.015341284684836864, -0.010121751576662064, -0.012713227421045303, 0.055029623210430145, -0.0065168654546141624, -0.03804018720984459, -0.027371199801564217, 0.022304177284240723, -0.002335878787562251, -0.06231317296624184, 0.024473784491419792, -0.0012684115208685398, -0.010702134110033512, 0.0009804553119465709, 0.012468181550502777, 0.04519124701619148, 0.03796447440981865, -0.015352499671280384, 0.028533469885587692, 0.019234707579016685, -0.018261175602674484, 0.012595121748745441, -0.02129742130637169, 0.02354815974831581, 0.01714094914495945, -0.029027367010712624, 0.014963444322347641, -0.03204406052827835, 0.008251544088125229, -0.006077870726585388, 0.025939038023352623, -0.012508605606853962, -0.047077007591724396, 0.025618858635425568, 0.004928975366055965, 0.00839912984520197, -0.03555459529161453, -0.03085380047559738, 0.06125034764409065, -0.04671509936451912, -0.003469471586868167, -0.039039842784404755, -0.02407318539917469, 0.01426696591079235, 0.014836084097623825, -0.018402772024273872, 0.008218335919082165, -0.0063476464711129665, 0.03223410248756409, -0.01251176092773676, 0.020800234749913216, 0.026682358235120773, 0.007235235068947077, 0.037215061485767365, 0.003260883968323469, -0.02603742480278015, -0.02123742178082466, -0.037241943180561066, -0.011045187711715698, -0.013636910356581211, 0.02686239778995514, 0.03734596073627472, 0.006695822812616825, -0.039326056838035583, -0.02324780821800232, 0.020991655066609383, 0.015824902802705765, -0.0673971176147461, -0.023413047194480896, -0.03151882439851761, 0.006905129179358482, 0.010468647815287113, 0.001164340297691524 ]
<p>After doing k-means clustering on a set of observations, I would like to construct a discriminant function so as to classify new observations into the categories I found after k-means. Is this at all a good idea? What should I be careful with?</p>
36,928
[ -0.06270790845155716, 0.00543218944221735, -0.02364828623831272, -0.012877465225756168, 0.006307838950306177, -0.012643815018236637, -0.0248098187148571, -0.009309659712016582, 0.022547023370862007, -0.044646721333265305, 0.028176572173833847, 0.010115295648574829, 0.040745195001363754, 0.0286516472697258, 0.024027321487665176, 0.002679478144273162, -0.003301111748442054, -0.005212822929024696, -0.008691519498825073, 0.006733303423970938, -0.014784584753215313, 0.03774114325642586, 0.01849953830242157, -0.007516024634242058, -0.029864314943552017, 0.029682794585824013, -0.002169201150536537, 0.002081344136968255, 0.026977261528372765, 0.03835118189454079, -0.02602926269173622, -0.020872032269835472, 0.024227676913142204, 0.028324857354164124, 0.003185834502801299, -0.013261362910270691, -0.03078465722501278, -0.0675734207034111, -0.04017586261034012, 0.021420007571578026, -0.05837229639291763, 0.0015203934162855148, 0.015661899000406265, 0.06563954800367355, -0.0038276631385087967, 0.01696745865046978, -0.02673511765897274, -0.031019827350974083, 0.022489970549941063, -0.060003556311130524, 0.1035713404417038, 0.008415362797677517, 0.03707398101687431, 0.036827292293310165, -0.03872494399547577, 0.01793680340051651, 0.036048952490091324, 0.07438144087791443, -0.03509204089641571, -0.019297627732157707, -0.006859063170850277, -0.0228305421769619, 0.01623779535293579, -0.017626924440264702, -0.025245433673262596, 0.04906851798295975, 0.004946584347635508, -0.0014166950713843107, 0.03524540737271309, -0.008035882376134396, 0.0356825590133667, 0.0009069349616765976, 0.03833639249205589, -0.047444652765989304, 0.006039838306605816, -0.02474820241332054, 0.01310120802372694, 0.01343813817948103, 0.04203027859330177, -0.0066289156675338745, 0.034672811627388, 0.032049745321273804, -0.014652376063168049, 0.02622814290225506, 0.036661453545093536, 0.0016206407453864813, 0.06371568888425827, -0.04315471649169922, 0.034024011343717575, 0.06547603011131287, -0.03443966433405876, 0.0044492557644844055, 0.04446602612733841, 0.001590102561749518, -0.035938654094934464, 0.01907222531735897, 0.006152347661554813, 0.024727266281843185, -0.00301735638640821, 0.013399629853665829, 0.021103201434016228, -0.015881532803177834, -0.0005709840916097164, 0.04018673673272133, -0.04207463189959526, 0.009588286280632019, -0.06404470652341843, 0.01252299640327692, -0.001428527059033513, -0.011203806847333908, -0.00003263858161517419, 0.006179599091410637, 0.019784480333328247, -0.020370880141854286, 0.04663015156984329, -0.004144180100411177, -0.01739625260233879, -0.012996169738471508, 0.006033440586179495, 0.06755159795284271, 0.039276205003261566, -0.04026427119970322, 0.03585389256477356, -0.023877155035734177, -0.05597250908613205, -0.014079125598073006, 0.023314733058214188, -0.01098451018333435, -0.046392735093832016, 0.04325919225811958, -0.034952569752931595, -0.03750477358698845, 0.03695522993803024, -0.0142508614808321, -0.010038342326879501, -0.03665516525506973, -0.07035847753286362, -0.03022497519850731, -0.015906915068626404, -0.02172510139644146, -0.0056642526760697365, -0.06114031746983528, -0.00438737915828824, 0.01940542459487915, 0.03679928928613663, 0.03250151872634888, 0.009193428792059422, 0.014473384246230125, 0.045828644186258316, 0.0017480750102549791, -0.030433883890509605, -0.03928259387612343, -0.043550435453653336, -0.04595818743109703, -0.021759241819381714, -0.05190126225352287, -0.004491457249969244, -0.007697501685470343, -0.00798710621893406, -0.03370143473148346, 0.007004845421761274, 0.0008076319936662912, -0.020557118579745293, -0.0031982020009309053, 0.008111628703773022, 0.0009446717449463904, 0.07007387280464172, 0.014088449999690056, 0.05931625887751579, -0.011446645483374596, 0.011737613007426262, 0.018998155370354652, 0.04143345355987549, 0.04862125590443611, 0.03730693832039833, 0.00795963779091835, -0.028539948165416718, -0.026553338393568993, 0.06639499217271805, -0.04603162035346031, 0.002322191372513771, -0.027980348095297813, -0.0030698920600116253, -0.0037743826396763325, -0.0027418651152402163, 0.022185754030942917, 0.01899026334285736, -0.03622376546263695, 0.035575419664382935, -0.057449039071798325, -0.01748594455420971, -0.049673523753881454, 0.00812547281384468, -0.032056353986263275, 0.005921272095292807, 0.025963550433516502, 0.022822827100753784, 0.03337782993912697, -0.006691655609756708, -0.03279729187488556, -0.034305308014154434, -0.04036602005362511, 0.008361794985830784, -0.022810259833931923, -0.033299632370471954, 0.02378545142710209, 0.028469674289226532, -0.018862901255488396, 0.0870795026421547, -0.05320252850651741, -0.032819680869579315, -0.0024673882871866226, -0.02850966341793537, -0.009853210300207138, -0.045952558517456055, 0.032523903995752335, 0.05306853726506233, 0.0035259013529866934, -0.014639200642704964, 0.021581383422017097, -0.0580986887216568, 0.0927928239107132, 0.05280965566635132, 0.029975926503539085, 0.010524701327085495, 0.008713510818779469, 0.05488789454102516, 0.01479764562100172, 0.006823152769356966, -0.02365908771753311, -0.07505226135253906, 0.00824783369898796, 0.08503251522779465, 0.03448241576552391, -0.045832835137844086, 0.055749133229255676, 0.03288666531443596, -0.0027204144280403852, 0.009800530970096588, -0.013353319838643074, -0.002725524129346013, 0.013395559042692184, 0.0173161793500185, 0.020368652418255806, -0.014019537717103958, -0.0070632454007864, 0.03050331026315689, -0.02415611781179905, 0.030105527490377426, -0.01628689654171467, -0.011767847463488579, 0.03847680240869522, 0.010872517712414265, 0.0189887136220932, 0.010690350085496902, -0.06066753342747688, 0.03517412766814232, -0.025625556707382202, 0.013472753576934338, 0.03440306708216667, 0.023401618003845215, 0.008842059411108494, 0.014803080819547176, 0.0034458409063518047, 0.024711791425943375, 0.04459351301193237, -0.02765820547938347, 0.03462104871869087, 0.04220893606543541, -0.06632174551486969, 0.01983565464615822, 0.01262670662254095, -0.023032324388623238, -0.04726621136069298, 0.0162148829549551, -0.010365297086536884, -0.017392273992300034, 0.02293461747467518, -0.01478838361799717, -0.015793878585100174, -0.0005497988895513117, 0.01109448354691267, 0.028341513127088547, 0.018815558403730392, -0.05313603952527046, 0.0032646183390170336, -0.020549114793539047, -0.025967789813876152, 0.034943971782922745, 0.01304041501134634, -0.02491058222949505, -0.00964477937668562, -0.021632414311170578, -0.04430526867508888, -0.0041091167367994785, -0.01600375957787037, 0.03755990415811539, -0.03256068751215935, -0.02522999979555607, 0.019215498119592667, 0.017604516819119453, -0.036636002361774445, -0.00418222788721323, -0.03178829699754715, -0.022908508777618408, -0.03297276049852371, 0.023446517065167427, -0.004230151418596506, -0.025023598223924637, -0.01690647006034851, 0.026959901675581932, -0.031911034137010574, 0.03926518186926842, -0.0411067008972168, -0.07441795617341995, 0.012716444209218025, 0.011863172985613346, 0.016039961948990822, 0.013639718294143677, 0.00795411504805088, 0.07946591079235077, 0.026002177968621254, -0.03532787784934044, -0.03261646628379822, -0.0047462028451263905, -0.06411321461200714, -0.013435904867947102, 0.0010212009074166417, 0.010813398286700249, 0.0038667921908199787, -0.001264727208763361, 0.010653923265635967, -0.0036383739206939936, 0.06353149563074112, -0.041260745376348495, -0.028928136453032494, 0.04633454605937004, 0.006633695214986801, -0.0031823180615901947, 0.034234847873449326, 0.012832533568143845, -0.03689184412360191, 0.029864607378840446, -0.012169054709374905, 0.01279833260923624, 0.038619495928287506, -0.010809572413563728, 0.010862165130674839, 0.0057816398330032825, 0.012834623456001282, -0.024788595736026764, 0.017766786739230156, 0.01002493780106306, -0.009805825538933277, 0.0034961046185344458, -0.00020933746418450028, 0.008468993939459324, -0.01961659826338291, -0.017744984477758408, 0.06374786049127579, 0.03501308709383011, -0.00396155146881938, 0.02669607102870941, -0.041933298110961914, -0.012754150666296482, 0.029377302154898643, 0.010122433304786682, 0.003641946706920862, 0.026888592168688774, 0.00980416126549244, 0.027426715940237045, 0.03476770594716072, -0.01956012472510338, -0.0017657928401604295, -0.055120810866355896, 0.0011484044371172786, -0.002341217128559947, 0.043419450521469116, -0.006746853236109018, 0.0406273789703846, 0.025746824219822884, -0.03317869454622269, -0.01244281604886055, 0.02001016214489937, -0.05338184908032417, 0.034633077681064606, -0.03089788928627968, 0.01689194329082966, -0.0023579495027661324, -0.03195524215698242, 0.008345028385519981, -0.02930070459842682, 0.006506329867988825, 0.004246728960424662, 0.005054605659097433, -0.05908944085240364, -0.012653770856559277, -0.022557297721505165, -0.01645069196820259, -0.018283214420080185, 0.008924062363803387, 0.053792838007211685, 0.0260367002338171, 0.04865046963095665, 0.01376184169203043, 0.0157625749707222, -0.0029348554089665413, -0.025133298709988594, 0.008963432163000107, -0.003614591434597969, -0.010074456222355366, -0.040314238518476486, 0.01330522820353508, -0.03719161078333855, 0.029304439201951027, -0.022486407309770584, 0.058432437479496, 0.010904486291110516, -0.019571518525481224, -0.007965544238686562, -0.056840091943740845, -0.03304655849933624, -0.008230430074036121, 0.047947030514478683, 0.002954342635348439, -0.02614111639559269, 0.03146759048104286, 0.01865539140999317, -0.06127545237541199, -0.0024799921084195375, 0.07701137661933899, 0.03894227743148804, -0.056243330240249634, -0.007588264066725969, 0.024326380342245102, -0.00522423442453146, -0.0468791127204895, -0.015166976489126682, 0.005138353910297155, -0.008481346070766449, 0.0410519577562809, 0.023729735985398293, -0.004100893624126911, -0.030379243195056915, -0.034127481281757355, 0.015949377790093422, 0.029920656234025955, -0.018273424357175827, -0.02134934812784195, 0.018334219232201576, 0.05900762230157852, 0.05019950121641159, 0.01742122694849968, 0.013983197510242462, -0.11779246479272842, 0.00823059119284153, 0.058627400547266006, 0.04666544124484062, -0.06678514927625656, -0.02033573016524315, -0.041489582508802414, -0.006585943512618542, 0.055047646164894104, -0.027912097051739693, 0.04095904529094696, -0.031455300748348236, 0.009132325649261475, -0.0158564280718565, 0.013841662555932999, -0.05185651034116745, 0.0427088662981987, -0.01950191520154476, 0.03424027934670448, -0.024990981444716454, -0.007589268498122692, -0.07916177809238434, 0.03156903013586998, 0.03950845077633858, 0.0480320118367672, -0.007525842636823654, -0.061594247817993164, 0.014337071217596531, 0.023906201124191284, -0.014310491271317005, -0.04209074750542641, 0.0056327818892896175, 0.002995210699737072, -0.008699765428900719, 0.046190500259399414, -0.02818755991756916, -0.019094618037343025, 0.00963058415800333, 0.010488354600965977, -0.017113985493779182, 0.003808838315308094, -0.022936325520277023, 0.05827568098902702, 0.02834787219762802, 0.014190719462931156, 0.06171666085720062, 0.031660474836826324, 0.014456909149885178, 0.03924601897597313, -0.010153907351195812, 0.0448676235973835, -0.01679767481982708, -0.02004849724471569, 0.0032879607751965523, -0.006916183978319168, -0.03844722732901573, 0.012494307942688465, -0.0012610023841261864, 0.04962313175201416, -0.04592109099030495, -0.024249201640486717, -0.006993563380092382, 0.0366709865629673, -0.006760746240615845, -0.009773844853043556, 0.021474037319421768, 0.04752470925450325, 0.02898918092250824, -0.032442715018987656, 0.0007626426522620022, -0.006405714899301529, 0.029560338705778122, 0.032815057784318924, -0.02083938755095005, 0.021970098838210106, -0.04768504202365875, -0.02410941570997238, 0.02439372055232525, -0.023243330419063568, 0.05698553845286369, -0.01785365305840969, 0.031110821291804314, 0.0365004763007164, -0.04796662926673889, -0.005583814345300198, 0.04630323126912117, -0.007928034290671349, 0.027645906433463097, -0.06535135954618454, 0.040506668388843536, -0.010158561170101166, -0.00908489990979433, -0.07506433129310608, -0.0379253514111042, -0.008260990492999554, 0.004462204873561859, -0.031819380819797516, -0.037404224276542664, 0.024599669501185417, 0.004958608187735081, -0.04286273568868637, -0.015045282430946827, 0.07015035301446915, -0.0245091300457716, 0.003605643520131707, 0.005989763420075178, -0.011256412602961063, 0.07519946992397308, 0.009825793094933033, 0.011851479299366474, 0.000928727095015347, 0.0007528081769123673, 0.006015176419168711, 0.0042866915464401245, -0.013266881927847862, -0.02387869358062744, -0.008192307315766811, -0.03418559581041336, 0.035164546221494675, 0.0361759290099144, -0.028451215475797653, 0.0011178121203556657, 0.009842229075729847, 0.0015937330899760127, -0.003571554785594344, -0.04103449732065201, 0.008640345185995102, -0.03656688705086708, -0.020415769889950752, -0.013262317515909672, 0.015071127563714981, -0.010577100329101086, -0.0038059980142861605, 0.04054417461156845, -0.010018836706876755, 0.030157189816236496, 0.009961781091988087, 0.038250405341386795, -0.0220144372433424, -0.01247328706085682, 0.00227561523206532, -0.04189661890268326, 0.02157963626086712, 0.01536448672413826, -0.0035907626152038574, -0.022851599380373955, 0.05795279145240784, -0.05548324063420296, -0.007700053043663502, -0.015263257548213005, -0.04203017055988312, 0.0739055946469307, 0.04030657187104225, 0.02958139404654503, 0.03467835485935211, 0.012033472768962383, 0.009922999888658524, -0.019203174859285355, -0.0019954247400164604, -0.024999361485242844, -0.037044707685709, 0.053886014968156815, 0.02950292080640793, 0.029736803844571114, 0.007570565678179264, 0.021586881950497627, 0.0034321516286581755, 0.05382777005434036, 0.023918382823467255, 0.03229742497205734, 0.023760491982102394, -0.03144093602895737, -0.07157454639673233, 0.024734677746891975, -0.06203226000070572, 0.010106241330504417, -0.03641096130013466, -0.03894279897212982, 0.029501458629965782, 0.03132783621549606, 0.006024207454174757, -0.04307670518755913, -0.022311238572001457, -0.0377969853579998, 0.041813310235738754, 0.02326429821550846, 0.0020541767589747906, 0.020404599606990814, 0.018528221175074577, 0.03952614963054657, 0.01983005926012993, 0.017512278631329536, 0.020251097157597542, -0.06243168190121651, -0.04521436244249344, -0.06856916844844818, -0.032068729400634766, 0.003086279844865203, 0.019082624465227127, -0.05476505309343338, -0.005577773787081242, -0.004626288544386625, 0.03632887452840805, 0.0006212441367097199, 0.03328345715999603, 0.010395855642855167, 0.03203685209155083, -0.011554979719221592, 0.024073563516139984, 0.0025180280208587646, 0.0018237550975754857, 0.11918825656175613, 0.04769156500697136, 0.036723535507917404, -0.011151975020766258, 0.05393502116203308, 0.004028299357742071, -0.014657657593488693, -0.035086315125226974, 0.06271421909332275, -0.02255183272063732, 0.034314557909965515, -0.01164986938238144, 0.03242702782154083, -0.004399836529046297, 0.028414854779839516, 0.05599234998226166, -0.008468392305076122, -0.02540176548063755, 0.004895559512078762, -0.007013280410319567, 0.0014501844998449087, -0.0052194176241755486, -0.028228960931301117, 0.020766859874129295, 0.015968959778547287, -0.018966518342494965, -0.015505233779549599, -0.008634922094643116, 0.018720926716923714, -0.004587119910866022, -0.013365778140723705, 0.027389071881771088, 0.02503117360174656, 0.014456571079790592, -0.001921731629408896, -0.01695132441818714, 0.011100939474999905, -0.005062550771981478, 0.028061162680387497, 0.016236215829849243, 0.03321675583720207, -0.035247426480054855, -0.008043280802667141, -0.03157150372862816, -0.044339876621961594, -0.007533987984061241, -0.04489864408969879, 0.04791039228439331, -0.0051690684631466866, 0.01337139680981636, 0.01464131847023964, 0.015126662328839302, 0.0032409830018877983, -0.036290593445301056, -0.01408879179507494, -0.011935499496757984, 0.024632448330521584, -0.015437361784279346, -0.015353324823081493, -0.05848802626132965, 0.04709663987159729, -0.008968031965196133, 0.04361347854137421, -0.02667860873043537, -0.01027365680783987, 0.00787066575139761, -0.0011261667823418975, 0.03697063401341438, -0.006694116163998842, -0.02741544134914875, -0.008861614391207695, -0.024972880259156227, -0.018911518156528473, -0.012896868400275707, -0.03826940059661865, 0.006781387608498335, 0.052192322909832, -0.019019318744540215, -0.025807034224271774, -0.01412449311465025, -0.08223330974578857, 0.0031404022593051195, -0.01977030746638775, 0.013175341300666332, -0.04105387255549431, 0.019274719059467316, 0.0531088262796402, 0.027018913999199867, 0.029815709218382835, 0.0509539358317852, 0.02214747481048107, 0.044546131044626236, 0.021722067147493362, -0.037515390664339066, 0.03597759082913399, -0.012078963220119476, -0.03302554041147232, 0.03245345130562782, -0.008288752287626266, 0.04958886653184891, 0.02335805632174015, 0.004284849856048822, -0.010293561033904552, 0.04407268390059471, -0.019635966047644615, 0.05859149992465973, 0.01821836270391941, -0.06246279925107956, 0.020798014476895332, -0.02474592626094818, -0.002527121687307954, -0.04932430759072304, -0.07054587453603745, -0.02286478690803051, -0.0055313715711236, 0.01705036498606205, -0.019550345838069916, -0.028409864753484726, -0.026576446369290352, -0.015415463596582413, 0.028989380225539207, -0.023412907496094704, -0.02603854052722454, -0.024126609787344933, 0.01665773242712021, -0.03873232379555702, -0.004115814808756113, -0.003982657101005316, 0.02061501145362854, -0.005331738851964474, 0.033087607473134995, 0.042880166321992874, 0.01893731765449047, -0.017716772854328156, -0.007788402494043112, 0.0016709758201614022, -0.05656692385673523, 0.05354399234056473, -0.019829273223876953, 0.011701593175530434, 0.010242764838039875, -0.0575900673866272, -0.022055774927139282, -0.00038638911792077124, 0.0035276564303785563, 0.02835588902235031, 0.03037416934967041, 0.004614717792719603, 0.01821748912334442, 0.03997903689742088, 0.0023377116303890944, -0.04705924168229103, -0.0155032342299819, -0.01953701116144657, -0.0043829092755913734, 0.00151662970893085, 0.020938904955983162, 0.013572362251579762, -0.029254456982016563, 0.03681778907775879, 0.017229430377483368, 0.009624546393752098, -0.0492033027112484, 0.004816481377929449, 0.010833751410245895, -0.003356263507157564, -0.0048906076699495316, 0.003897495334967971, 0.04717705398797989, 0.0419720821082592, -0.05495743080973625, 0.03118129074573517, 0.0023044771514832973, 0.030300198122859, -0.06972860544919968, -0.027488812804222107, 0.009166263043880463, -0.018677687272429466, 0.057139329612255096, -0.07289765030145645, 0.005201677791774273, 0.01912492886185646, -0.03612847998738289, 0.02675784006714821, -0.0040994626469910145, -0.03526487201452255, -0.02520403079688549, 0.022113056853413582, -0.023506561294198036, -0.006075577344745398, 0.02111652120947838, 0.020151842385530472, 0.019385408610105515, 0.014838386327028275, 0.0057662720791995525, -0.018426336348056793, -0.017233360558748245, 0.0031593439634889364, 0.019041160121560097, -0.05631813406944275, 0.053062986582517624, -0.039006561040878296, -0.06098524481058121, 0.012172175571322441, -0.016348527744412422, -0.0010753922397270799, 0.07495592534542084, -0.0003049354418180883, 0.031444650143384933, 0.03728725016117096, 0.0310357715934515, -0.028756750747561455, -0.02353724278509617, 0.011658026836812496, 0.013683072291314602, 0.03833543136715889, -0.023834064602851868, 0.011107617057859898, 0.014751039445400238, -0.011499036103487015, -0.05906589701771736, 0.002453977009281516, -0.02359396405518055, -0.026257071644067764, 0.02089439146220684, 0.0025697732344269753, -0.03549324348568916, 0.004709790460765362, 0.006225593853741884, -0.03920073062181473, -0.0049118176102638245, 0.021560218185186386, -0.009579692035913467, -0.0014796082396060228, 0.03876226767897606, -0.05068107321858406, -0.06021064147353172, 0.031550195068120956, 0.010549788363277912, -0.01443723775446415, -0.05380493775010109, 0.01621619053184986, 0.013263891451060772, -0.023971645161509514, -0.024352245032787323, -0.017657672986388206, 0.024959634989500046, 0.06519625335931778, -0.04251343384385109, 0.013447106815874577, 0.05380803346633911, -0.03264228254556656, 0.0008582588634453714, -0.09180774539709091, 0.06748766452074051, 0.03012821264564991, -0.036384761333465576, -0.004309870768338442, -0.027022821828722954, -0.037279486656188965, 0.0011936757946386933, 0.03902888298034668, -0.005966340657323599, 0.0042917197570204735, -0.034180574119091034, 0.02723202295601368, 0.00970932375639677, -0.04897846654057503, 0.03725608065724373, 0.0058600702323019505, 0.013093126937747002, -0.00641970057040453, -0.015005788765847683, -0.0038988336455076933, -0.004827851429581642, -0.006492541171610355, 0.001285028993152082, -0.008517210371792316, -0.009089874103665352, -0.014096011407673359, 0.044790469110012054, -0.013514511287212372, -0.0029312539845705032, 0.03724553808569908, 0.0013580291997641325, 0.015271306037902832, 0.03558477759361267, -0.03036271408200264, -0.04687662050127983, 0.029949989169836044, -0.06348779797554016, -0.03598115220665932, 0.00969712808728218, 0.02233094535768032, 0.009406905621290207, -0.049855414777994156, -0.00505284545943141, 0.02198590524494648, -0.0091414675116539, 0.024757279083132744, 0.04059275984764099, 0.005209522321820259, 0.030465975403785706, 0.0030148085206747055, 0.0019343423191457987, 0.00215228577144444, -0.004267281387001276, 0.014123629778623581, 0.0054639591835439205, 0.019138958305120468, -0.0076987771317362785, 0.021617313846945763, 0.0030179149471223354, -0.011148631572723389, -0.008611143566668034, -0.002185625024139881, 0.05357509106397629, -0.025155577808618546, 0.02960973046720028, -0.0010541080264374614, -0.004767457488924265, 0.03811022266745567, 0.0128256781026721, -0.027915876358747482, 0.03832880035042763, -0.022816166281700134, -0.01816507801413536, -0.0373077392578125, -0.05240362510085106, -0.02500256337225437, 0.00012887494813185185, 0.03126158192753792, 0.04487871006131172, 0.008774355985224247, 0.030019130557775497, -0.005123419687151909, -0.004967025946825743, 0.04031221941113472, -0.020435335114598274, 0.03250036761164665, -0.00863897055387497, 0.01586095057427883, -0.0009085851488634944, 0.0028580829966813326, -0.02670135907828808, -0.04458363354206085, 0.010984688997268677, 0.06464928388595581, 0.016030894592404366, -0.00749503169208765, -0.021125800907611847, -0.015941904857754707, 0.029493190348148346, -0.049826644361019135, -0.023654090240597725, -0.04939917474985123, 0.0032105864956974983, 0.009083600714802742, -0.023301362991333008 ]
<p>These two functions exist in R but I don't know their differences. It seems that they only return the same p-values when calling <code>wilcox.test</code> with <code>correct=FALSE</code>, and <code>wilcox_test</code> (in the coin package) with <code>distribution="aymptotic"</code>. For other values they return different p-values. Also <code>wilcox.test</code> is always returning W=0 for my dataset, independently of the settings of its parameters: </p> <p><code>x = c(1, 1, 1, 3, 3, 3, 3)</code> and <code>y = c(4, 4, 6, 7, 7, 8, 10)</code></p> <p>Also, when I try using different tools other than R (some available online, others as Excel add-ons), sometimes they report different p-values.</p> <p>So how can I know which tool is giving the "correct" p-value? </p> <p>Is there a "correct" p-value, or if a few tools give a p-value &lt; 0.05 should I be happy? (Sometimes these tools do not offer so many parametrization possibilities like R.)</p> <p>What am I missing here? </p> <p>Thanks</p>
37,492
[ -0.027604781091213226, -0.006299348548054695, 0.004585336893796921, -0.009787253104150295, -0.013374486938118935, 0.006447989027947187, -0.033219289034605026, -0.009372194297611713, 0.029538001865148544, -0.023971959948539734, 0.04246329516172409, 0.05252807214856148, 0.038426291197538376, 0.026207907125353813, 0.0395130030810833, 0.025485912337899208, 0.003468303708359599, -0.003677819389849901, -0.004281323868781328, 0.012241343036293983, 0.006107119377702475, 0.024774378165602684, 0.0072055961936712265, -0.035051994025707245, -0.024259360507130623, 0.035534173250198364, 0.008709680289030075, -0.006534005980938673, 0.015757348388433456, 0.07459317892789841, -0.041816383600234985, -0.029884565621614456, 0.0011480965185910463, 0.023866187781095505, 0.03455140441656113, -0.006739849224686623, -0.005185758229345083, -0.044526126235723495, -0.02873123809695244, 0.043375272303819656, -0.04470452293753624, -0.02006947249174118, 0.017483314499258995, 0.03443819284439087, 0.025933891534805298, 0.012788275256752968, -0.015416919253766537, -0.03487829491496086, 0.013920586556196213, -0.02539423666894436, 0.05430609732866287, 0.04079636186361313, 0.01871887966990471, 0.03154683858156204, -0.008091612718999386, -0.0030584358610212803, 0.06896582245826721, 0.04751560464501381, -0.034865446388721466, -0.07014361768960953, -0.005354457069188356, -0.008711210452020168, -0.0038442816585302353, 0.004840823356062174, -0.03749915584921837, 0.025643950328230858, -0.013403515331447124, -0.04872329905629158, 0.024879226461052895, -0.007837960496544838, 0.03606291860342026, 0.02489684708416462, 0.05160390958189964, -0.020834174007177353, 0.02799062803387642, -0.006525630597025156, 0.007073894143104553, 0.010747050866484642, 0.06389639526605606, 0.04483886808156967, 0.019247157499194145, 0.029018620029091835, 0.0008406652486883104, 0.03375843167304993, 0.01361839473247528, -0.007620353251695633, 0.05299737676978111, -0.04240139201283455, -0.022018028423190117, 0.04297273978590965, -0.02205514721572399, -0.01408445741981268, 0.05444527417421341, -0.023046286776661873, -0.015107004903256893, 0.043841224163770676, -0.017461538314819336, 0.017714455723762512, -0.02005593478679657, -0.02011091634631157, 0.005714859813451767, -0.05225037410855293, -0.0067026037722826, 0.04929865896701813, -0.04807805269956589, -0.03407801687717438, 0.006278712302446365, -0.006345116533339024, -0.020893556997179985, -0.02463480643928051, 0.01998054049909115, 0.06335507333278656, -0.026806751266121864, -0.0052183810621500015, 0.020450370386242867, -0.005398936104029417, -0.015942752361297607, -0.021004747599363327, 0.05546759441494942, 0.053180254995822906, 0.05097468942403793, -0.00527979526668787, 0.015308520756661892, -0.023555375635623932, -0.06400497257709503, -0.03316354379057884, -0.009377679787576199, -0.013412919826805592, -0.03736480697989464, 0.04036515951156616, -0.0014942996203899384, -0.03034253604710102, 0.0954865887761116, -0.0021384675055742264, 0.04992836341261864, 0.017741519957780838, -0.08933987468481064, -0.048441432416439056, 0.019960157573223114, -0.003668526653200388, -0.007390944287180901, -0.052130647003650665, -0.006684806197881699, 0.0157442856580019, 0.04317601025104523, -0.01095452718436718, 0.02697763405740261, -0.012895860709249973, 0.03538272902369499, 0.01920141652226448, -0.04478893056511879, -0.00032517159706912935, -0.014144551940262318, -0.027290228754281998, -0.024842213839292526, -0.06961386650800705, 0.012564454227685928, 0.011205529794096947, -0.00017853484314400703, 0.010105409659445286, 0.05596828833222389, -0.020915517583489418, -0.011839066632091999, -0.038837920874357224, 0.019326698035001755, -0.018231533467769623, 0.06741245090961456, 0.023455394431948662, 0.03365958854556084, 0.029060320928692818, -0.040761955082416534, 0.028300419449806213, -0.005879705771803856, 0.030665647238492966, 0.03214928135275841, -0.04849807173013687, -0.00159193086437881, -0.047662973403930664, 0.02557753585278988, 0.027483465149998665, -0.04759778082370758, 0.028225025162100792, -0.013800100423395634, -0.023088542744517326, 0.002654855139553547, 0.017447011545300484, 0.009864386171102524, 0.001832344802096486, 0.04264353960752487, -0.06801190972328186, -0.07883628457784653, -0.06546532362699509, -0.004828501958400011, 0.002255671424791217, -0.02847791463136673, 0.04466456174850464, 0.03548990190029144, -0.012354808859527111, 0.009234030731022358, -0.007623386103659868, -0.0029716817662119865, 0.031694445759058, 0.0341612845659256, -0.046278148889541626, -0.02011920139193535, 0.07308363914489746, 0.04499318450689316, -0.03069010004401207, 0.053589820861816406, -0.03304076939821243, -0.04215642809867859, 0.006022104062139988, -0.04952362924814224, -0.016688931733369827, 0.010887335054576397, -0.04487329348921776, -0.011166243813931942, 0.008900235407054424, 0.007393208332359791, 0.05179909989237785, -0.042231861501932144, 0.0615742951631546, 0.0720471441745758, 0.010977963916957378, -0.0026236928533762693, -0.0056390222162008286, -0.005283885635435581, 0.027315475046634674, -0.05217768996953964, -0.0001338389265583828, -0.025497330352663994, 0.010085080750286579, 0.025047680363059044, 0.01973070576786995, -0.030579768121242523, 0.018321625888347626, 0.06476972997188568, -0.01099704671651125, 0.002606772119179368, 0.02534089796245098, 0.020878873765468597, -0.039116743952035904, 0.0014048910234123468, 0.03857346624135971, 0.022694634273648262, 0.04971838742494583, 0.028780847787857056, -0.02110128290951252, 0.061762068420648575, -0.012546931393444538, 0.0018246081890538335, 0.05963665992021561, 0.0013048029504716396, -0.048571161925792694, -0.036812227219343185, -0.008944116532802582, 0.02985347993671894, -0.03033396042883396, -0.028087349608540535, 0.019594307988882065, 0.022343095391988754, -0.021896935999393463, -0.005599520169198513, -0.012380445376038551, 0.05202240124344826, 0.008576806634664536, -0.02304544672369957, 0.013743188232183456, 0.0005400173831731081, -0.007201874163001776, -0.004258148837834597, -0.0524539090692997, 0.010796288959681988, -0.05021238327026367, 0.04097742587327957, 0.022800050675868988, 0.022036446258425713, 0.02098800614476204, -0.05024787411093712, -0.040234409272670746, 0.011321495287120342, -0.01917063072323799, 0.030706394463777542, -0.02996170148253441, -0.03596584498882294, 0.00887256395071745, -0.034561384469270706, -0.0024182589258998632, 0.03304818645119667, 0.0014237462310120463, -0.013738344423472881, 0.005833970382809639, -0.00673016719520092, 0.007644846569746733, 0.007541275583207607, -0.04319106042385101, 0.007283539045602083, -0.043963219970464706, -0.02913839742541313, 0.03413115814328194, -0.028076382353901863, -0.005782564170658588, 0.0522080697119236, -0.04241364076733589, 0.0035590725019574165, -0.03754124045372009, -0.014386364258825779, 0.002081705955788493, 0.0296227615326643, -0.01904420740902424, 0.05386020988225937, -0.02887866646051407, -0.019512351602315903, -0.07727059721946716, -0.03638587146997452, 0.013387670740485191, -0.018971668556332588, -0.010372258722782135, 0.01699485257267952, -0.018300265073776245, 0.051697470247745514, 0.03868473693728447, -0.015178769826889038, -0.05971790477633476, 0.031445421278476715, -0.05685364082455635, 0.0006526107317768037, 0.0007408895762637258, 0.030437825247645378, 0.016500795260071754, 0.007401701528578997, -0.038563236594200134, 0.022685715928673744, 0.01593378745019436, -0.0038924787659198046, -0.002606231952086091, 0.04864055663347244, 0.0266413576900959, -0.05462823435664177, 0.05825451388955116, 0.015547579154372215, 0.01913677714765072, 0.02076161466538906, -0.009550600312650204, -0.002483178162947297, -0.02130552940070629, -0.02756907045841217, -0.0056001474149525166, -0.007511060684919357, 0.023793894797563553, -0.013135021552443504, 0.02421002835035324, -0.0032816294115036726, -0.0510835163295269, -0.024731867015361786, 0.019616056233644485, 0.0380910187959671, 0.01473724003881216, 0.0037296076770871878, 0.02861599624156952, 0.02240028791129589, -0.04387753829360008, -0.007887669838964939, -0.013248270377516747, -0.0292047131806612, -0.005537689663469791, -0.025368129834532738, -0.029696401208639145, 0.06993478536605835, 0.039905913174152374, 0.0431898832321167, 0.001230071298778057, -0.04409332945942879, 0.030540648847818375, -0.06246526539325714, 0.03460301458835602, -0.0401010699570179, 0.05302058532834053, 0.003632724517956376, 0.05780121311545372, 0.033791448920965195, 0.01269855722784996, -0.019215846434235573, -0.011410092003643513, -0.045322418212890625, 0.056034691631793976, -0.009094491600990295, 0.001560125732794404, -0.02510184794664383, -0.007913663052022457, 0.014743234030902386, -0.0018404624424874783, 0.03917606920003891, 0.03848718851804733, 0.00268351286649704, -0.027898073196411133, -0.0044747693464159966, 0.0045349751599133015, -0.014145170338451862, 0.009490206837654114, 0.014049927704036236, 0.005527506582438946, -0.01081577967852354, 0.04293014854192734, 0.05110181123018265, -0.0013771654339507222, 0.007192455697804689, 0.020075062289834023, -0.012604706920683384, 0.04027196019887924, 0.020437752828001976, 0.05934106931090355, 0.02698449045419693, -0.06875758618116379, 0.014972957782447338, -0.004054140765219927, 0.024862881749868393, 0.0849190279841423, -0.03146142140030861, -0.03070009872317314, -0.02843661420047283, -0.0016608061268925667, -0.015468060970306396, -0.0025306844618171453, 0.014533892273902893, -0.007888786494731903, 0.04857264831662178, 0.03342064470052719, 0.002707258565351367, 0.008604422211647034, 0.05995938554406166, -0.011712334118783474, 0.012361754663288593, 0.00810226146131754, 0.0053454795852303505, -0.0160182174295187, -0.018114373087882996, 0.0044606467708945274, 0.02006264217197895, 0.013751219026744366, 0.0011448966106399894, 0.048388853669166565, -0.044547393918037415, -0.0025244932621717453, -0.025688758119940758, 0.021928120404481888, 0.02927185781300068, -0.013784753158688545, -0.014509657397866249, 0.018364766612648964, 0.0382317453622818, 0.0032321622129529715, 0.017089879140257835, -0.04035841301083565, -0.05996415391564369, 0.01775149628520012, 0.06730388849973679, 0.056453872472047806, -0.035150300711393356, -0.04044327884912491, -0.05724255368113518, 0.010635918006300926, 0.055919282138347626, -0.047301795333623886, 0.020382625982165337, 0.014656721614301205, 0.0115897748619318, -0.012576188892126083, 0.0011360859498381615, -0.03663375973701477, -0.01906711980700493, -0.03655530512332916, 0.019390903413295746, -0.025504041463136673, -0.054131682962179184, -0.05385778844356537, 0.030301231890916824, 0.008419888094067574, 0.034079961478710175, -0.05407314747571945, -0.023041484877467155, 0.007372859865427017, -0.012338340282440186, 0.017842229455709457, -0.06703612953424454, -0.0014344453811645508, -0.008904911577701569, 0.018552934750914574, 0.055859945714473724, 0.03223738819360733, -0.02585325762629509, 0.026459338143467903, -0.020333055406808853, -0.0224835816770792, 0.010901106521487236, 0.004709212109446526, 0.024183157831430435, 0.03012692742049694, 0.007760383654385805, 0.055383097380399704, 0.03479841724038124, -0.010403436608612537, -0.04274803772568703, -0.07933168858289719, 0.007707747630774975, 0.010836617089807987, -0.023808591067790985, -0.0737977847456932, -0.008271101862192154, -0.026273947209119797, -0.0011329820845276117, 0.033108990639448166, -0.0021337056532502174, -0.03894713521003723, 0.007860579527914524, 0.005894786678254604, 0.021955301985144615, 0.026164744049310684, 0.028596503660082817, 0.012178170494735241, -0.005449200980365276, 0.019446535035967827, 0.0187048502266407, 0.018081601709127426, -0.02954951673746109, -0.025848032906651497, 0.04819898679852486, -0.014473807998001575, 0.008716341108083725, 0.010962412692606449, -0.03631342574954033, 0.017018785700201988, -0.019218051806092262, 0.03380559757351875, -0.009250888600945473, 0.03277088701725006, 0.005592907778918743, -0.03608184680342674, -0.02434367500245571, 0.022147225216031075, -0.00378593523055315, 0.034024909138679504, -0.02615150809288025, 0.030565381050109863, -0.0206822007894516, 0.015877770259976387, -0.05531135946512222, -0.03194214403629303, -0.013761310838162899, 0.006736377254128456, -0.05236031860113144, -0.027811085805296898, 0.007082012947648764, -0.008888037875294685, -0.022473471239209175, 0.00566151924431324, 0.055988434702157974, -0.05177394300699234, -0.01458515040576458, -0.029721155762672424, 0.01864873804152012, 0.0613987073302269, -0.02051856368780136, -0.002353908494114876, -0.013678043149411678, -0.0038601013366132975, 0.001985937124118209, 0.03043566271662712, 0.01113620214164257, -0.03877375274896622, -0.012517754919826984, 0.005181453190743923, 0.004936008248478174, 0.0528269037604332, -0.005941655021160841, -0.00106514198705554, 0.01527593843638897, -0.02535409666597843, -0.016169656068086624, -0.016356252133846283, -0.008972080424427986, -0.028399240225553513, 0.020977340638637543, -0.033846642822027206, -0.013966916128993034, -0.012448480352759361, -0.025559913367033005, 0.011615491472184658, 0.00024379095702897757, -0.032019101083278656, 0.043252065777778625, 0.07580398768186569, -0.023389281705021858, 0.009106922894716263, -0.030818847939372063, -0.037169039249420166, 0.027538876980543137, 0.022174952551722527, -0.028574734926223755, -0.02211751416325569, 0.020571570843458176, -0.02951371669769287, -0.023041503503918648, -0.041715510189533234, -0.0030223773792386055, 0.035690583288669586, 0.009008596651256084, 0.061109017580747604, 0.04695860296487808, 0.0006463287863880396, -0.01080788392573595, -0.03662554547190666, -0.03523349389433861, -0.012992105446755886, 0.028085673227906227, 0.07317885011434555, 0.03205769881606102, -0.016699664294719696, 0.0664391964673996, 0.02122529223561287, 0.0069433110766112804, 0.03452298045158386, 0.013038578443229198, 0.006083585787564516, 0.013615505769848824, -0.030884014442563057, -0.04915889352560043, 0.03624328598380089, -0.031546931713819504, 0.03313351795077324, -0.0268386360257864, -0.052278924733400345, 0.03904120996594429, 0.024041797965765, -0.023040665313601494, -0.03458765894174576, 0.0017437590286135674, -0.053804051131010056, 0.002477033529430628, 0.02148173190653324, -0.010433332994580269, 0.011850466020405293, -0.0001993727928493172, 0.027155881747603416, 0.005726186092942953, 0.0327250212430954, -0.00078411033609882, -0.07706395536661148, -0.03184802830219269, -0.03193727508187294, -0.0460456907749176, 0.022806920111179352, 0.009067844599485397, -0.027909059077501297, 0.011843089014291763, -0.06580685824155807, 0.02467002533376217, -0.009972629137337208, 0.03720857948064804, -0.01706657186150551, 0.03969990834593773, -0.035934995859861374, -0.006095296237617731, -0.02183602936565876, -0.03599903732538223, 0.14588390290737152, 0.07133101671934128, 0.055441949516534805, -0.08526108413934708, 0.0006623113295063376, 0.0008441477548331022, 0.02983134612441063, -0.004743590485304594, 0.013718760572373867, 0.021310532465577126, 0.010327409952878952, 0.024210451170802116, 0.05086565762758255, 0.003391098463907838, 0.02271120250225067, 0.052032191306352615, -0.03869951516389847, -0.016039518639445305, 0.0049860794097185135, 0.028593910858035088, -0.002637560246512294, -0.01223424170166254, -0.01819802075624466, 0.004203089978545904, 0.030060168355703354, 0.0037516048178076744, -0.011542524211108685, -0.06050663813948631, 0.004990001674741507, -0.0005267790402285755, -0.014449253678321838, -0.015554998070001602, 0.028429411351680756, 0.0023241762537509203, 0.010391118936240673, 0.017855990678071976, 0.007179521955549717, -0.044884949922561646, -0.0016958924243226647, 0.058769676834344864, -0.016649330034852028, -0.011925559490919113, 0.00971580296754837, 0.02594589814543724, -0.0709155946969986, -0.016522858291864395, -0.009995563887059689, 0.01824893057346344, -0.014047740958631039, -0.01085110567510128, -0.008362388238310814, 0.00883707869797945, -0.01194455474615097, -0.033975183963775635, -0.03539322316646576, 0.004844064824283123, 0.016951322555541992, -0.004278067499399185, -0.03438481315970421, -0.03906317800283432, 0.010381468571722507, -0.0533035472035408, 0.04898273944854736, 0.04979436472058296, -0.05093501880764961, 0.0011275334982201457, -0.024660037830471992, 0.06165383383631706, -0.020752117037773132, 0.046809494495391846, 0.028633760288357735, -0.02514573000371456, -0.011604161001741886, -0.016895759850740433, -0.002409204840660095, -0.002075889613479376, 0.04345346614718437, -0.019705476239323616, -0.009758533909916878, -0.0255263764411211, -0.04163113981485367, 0.031247204169631004, -0.042211439460515976, -0.0001878574548754841, -0.052561599761247635, -0.046645697206258774, 0.046931397169828415, 0.020269695669412613, 0.022359522059559822, 0.02559029683470726, -0.013946116901934147, 0.0468098446726799, -0.00034029578091576695, -0.055059660226106644, -0.014392467215657234, 0.024234220385551453, -0.01495175901800394, -0.009891487658023834, -0.018260452896356583, 0.06630697846412659, 0.009882031939923763, 0.028571180999279022, -0.007644266821444035, -0.0026512802578508854, -0.014559602364897728, 0.006286964286118746, -0.005759746767580509, -0.03357258066534996, 0.0011638766154646873, 0.03798885643482208, -0.031106922775506973, -0.022994402796030045, -0.036650437861680984, -0.05350181460380554, -0.020274223759770393, 0.013153644278645515, -0.006929577328264713, -0.04401334747672081, 0.017796872183680534, -0.021052194759249687, 0.005662048235535622, -0.03934437036514282, 0.004999335389584303, -0.037434447556734085, -0.010073637589812279, -0.005057098343968391, -0.02190491370856762, 0.008090890944004059, 0.010265536606311798, -0.01332357432693243, 0.011816873215138912, 0.057280972599983215, 0.008046063594520092, 0.01676914282143116, 0.03776948153972626, 0.004761449992656708, 0.024543702602386475, 0.054781723767519, -0.0009336408693343401, -0.011477910913527012, 0.04605071619153023, -0.06341423094272614, -0.07755066454410553, 0.029779432341456413, 0.0002441734541207552, 0.026072276756167412, 0.008088918402791023, -0.004137075040489435, 0.009650971740484238, 0.03965150937438011, -0.04292669892311096, -0.0032031836453825235, -0.005291704088449478, 0.014823077246546745, 0.016451556235551834, 0.006521488539874554, 0.005374081898480654, -0.029676403850317, -0.01134477462619543, 0.0607418492436409, 0.034660521894693375, 0.020554158836603165, -0.010998979210853577, -0.00975540466606617, -0.03807971999049187, 0.015629218891263008, 0.01997426524758339, 0.003911112900823355, 0.0005035426001995802, 0.014193898998200893, -0.03536397963762283, 0.0601198710501194, -0.03181217238306999, 0.028621269389986992, -0.08272138983011246, -0.028287192806601524, 0.006276653613895178, 0.005724533926695585, 0.009990354999899864, -0.028426319360733032, 0.006072645541280508, 0.014153320342302322, -0.027844680473208427, 0.03239131346344948, 0.009688124060630798, -0.008118955418467522, -0.025542600080370903, 0.031990908086299896, 0.015843844041228294, 0.023706180974841118, 0.041578080505132675, 0.02733379229903221, 0.06079467758536339, 0.0005765607347711921, 0.0007446371018886566, -0.027160832658410072, -0.03624464571475983, 0.01815124601125717, -0.012202796526253223, -0.07331718504428864, 0.019314303994178772, -0.03631875663995743, -0.04638247936964035, 0.02737942524254322, 0.00740272318944335, 0.029729492962360382, 0.0004620168765541166, 0.039749786257743835, 0.00673667062073946, 0.05824929475784302, 0.054271429777145386, -0.022029932588338852, -0.02935100719332695, 0.024747898802161217, 0.02346036769449711, 0.026425406336784363, -0.03929711878299713, 0.007384053431451321, 0.019774433225393295, 0.0015495625557377934, -0.006301386747509241, 0.011451048776507378, -0.02581215091049671, -0.007844999432563782, 0.00718319695442915, 0.007597561925649643, 0.03209367021918297, -0.026380125433206558, 0.006824887823313475, -0.027936795726418495, 0.002512614941224456, 0.038171254098415375, 0.013027935288846493, -0.01624445617198944, 0.03259919211268425, -0.019079333171248436, -0.014178378507494926, -0.004312304314225912, 0.010599164292216301, 0.013527391478419304, -0.007282822858542204, 0.001297648879699409, 0.017767008394002914, 0.022790148854255676, 0.004801825620234013, 0.00669213617220521, -0.012462510727345943, 0.015639441087841988, -0.03580712899565697, -0.01884157955646515, 0.03748418018221855, 0.03927210345864296, 0.018446216359734535, -0.07487807422876358, 0.06202042102813721, -0.008872533217072487, -0.0011176947737112641, -0.01057529915124178, 0.004863020498305559, -0.04479127749800682, 0.013275939039885998, 0.05801473557949066, 0.008235922083258629, -0.007831077091395855, 0.0024689780548214912, 0.01961676776409149, -0.0016717890975996852, -0.08415407687425613, 0.02770679071545601, -0.006390489637851715, -0.008681084960699081, -0.02451152727007866, -0.01995142176747322, 0.02915065735578537, 0.028621399775147438, -0.008197737857699394, -0.021029887720942497, 0.014075945131480694, 0.009891598485410213, -0.0007361104362644255, 0.03703667223453522, -0.00011499347601784393, -0.02899942919611931, 0.0436185821890831, 0.0010259239934384823, 0.02115461975336075, 0.001731849741190672, 0.017481932416558266, -0.022424781695008278, 0.06891202181577682, -0.013553536497056484, -0.03478782996535301, 0.010073024779558182, 0.0032375419978052378, -0.0072313048876821995, -0.052478015422821045, -0.02873145416378975, 0.009057888761162758, -0.021847320720553398, -0.02597377821803093, 0.012124167755246162, 0.025155294686555862, 0.03663400933146477, -0.011922200210392475, 0.01788010448217392, 0.012812850996851921, -0.02780517376959324, 0.013134554028511047, -0.0013327216729521751, 0.030589431524276733, 0.0014446231070905924, 0.012776033952832222, 0.04187179356813431, -0.04766279086470604, 0.04452548176050186, -0.013931958004832268, 0.06034693866968155, -0.03408915176987648, -0.03680363669991493, 0.026448793709278107, -0.026510199531912804, 0.005080350674688816, -0.05347967520356178, -0.013312000781297684, 0.04322519525885582, -0.024484805762767792, 0.009856085292994976, -0.030307065695524216, -0.019387340173125267, 0.03825961425900459, -0.019761689007282257, -0.031050164252519608, -0.0038190449122339487, -0.02002088353037834, -0.0025451513938605785, -0.011317885480821133, -0.000593522097915411, 0.04718797281384468, -0.024969227612018585, -0.011947541497647762, -0.04343858361244202, 0.018197106197476387, -0.04038228839635849, 0.0027118816506117582, -0.023646775633096695, 0.006506334990262985, 0.00982921663671732, 0.03094329684972763, 0.0061357952654361725, -0.03449202701449394, -0.007615810260176659, 0.029828883707523346, 0.035191915929317474, -0.07129760831594467, -0.013979134149849415, -0.013654613867402077, -0.017963076010346413, 0.02519289031624794, -0.03945939242839813 ]
<p>Suppose I am doing some experimental procedure on two treatment groups. The procedure has several stages, each of which may fail. Failure at any stage halts the experiment. If all stages are passed then there is some useful result.</p> <p>Although I'm primarily interested in the final result, the treatments <strong>might</strong> also entail different failure rates along the way. I'd like to quantify this, and since we're looking at simple counts it seems like a chi square or Fisher exact test would be appropriate.</p> <p>If I want to use such a test as it were <em>recursively</em>, to the groups passing each stage, do I need to apply some correction for multiple comparisons?</p> <p>That is, supposing the groups progressed like this:</p> <pre><code> Group_A Group_B Start 100 100 Stage_1 90 95 Stage_2 80 85 Stage_3 60 75 Stage_4 55 30 Results ... ... </code></pre> <p>Does it make sense to do a sequence of 2x2 tests of the form:</p> <pre><code> Group_A Group_B Passed_N X Y Failed_N Started_N-X Started_N-Y </code></pre> <p>I feel like I should just <em>know</em> the answer, but I can't figure out whether this counts as doing repeated tests or not. The populations are <em>somewhat</em> distinct each time, but heavily overlapping.</p> <p>Also, would it make a difference if I had physical reasons to suppose that only stage 4 should be at all affected by the treatments? Could I just choose to ignore any differences in passage through the other stages in that case?</p> <p>(Feel free also to post answers like "ZOMG, don't use that sort of test here, use XXXX, in manner YYYY, for reasons ZZZZ.")</p>
74,198
[ -0.029965415596961975, -0.026023680344223976, -0.00641866447404027, -0.014870104379951954, 0.02471328340470791, 0.031487494707107544, 0.007710455916821957, -0.032821428030729294, 0.027576813474297523, 0.014382196590304375, 0.05206817761063576, 0.035404596477746964, 0.04375471919775009, -0.011250827461481094, 0.043348439037799835, 0.012946361675858498, -0.021904366090893745, -0.015879470854997635, -0.005800601094961166, 0.000073148803494405, -0.0011693784035742283, 0.00822207797318697, 0.020886661484837532, 0.00750559289008379, -0.02887735702097416, 0.034967031329870224, 0.019463296979665756, -0.0228611808270216, -0.001969468779861927, 0.041984617710113525, -0.036670852452516556, -0.021865693852305412, -0.017335306853055954, 0.04080008342862129, 0.026899436488747597, 0.021697886288166046, -0.021423853933811188, -0.020662419497966766, -0.01647435501217842, 0.02325170300900936, -0.05497736856341362, -0.0011746766977012157, -0.044602908194065094, 0.04546681419014931, 0.02287205122411251, 0.030024390667676926, -0.011460741981863976, 0.006948649417608976, 0.029750732704997063, -0.009080205112695694, 0.07747061550617218, -0.0027950373478233814, 0.0394076332449913, 0.0068368082866072655, -0.011347600258886814, -0.029204273596405983, 0.06913267821073532, 0.027766982093453407, -0.00804041512310505, -0.02443060651421547, -0.025970401242375374, -0.027105731889605522, 0.02091788314282894, -0.010268163867294788, -0.050078775733709335, 0.02202611044049263, -0.007850782945752144, -0.036186862736940384, 0.02604587748646736, -0.02058756723999977, 0.005704295355826616, 0.046257466077804565, 0.032631561160087585, -0.0018776332726702094, 0.012454397045075893, -0.036604009568691254, 0.03017311729490757, 0.016835998743772507, 0.04169352725148201, 0.05957440659403801, -0.050423674285411835, 0.007319184485822916, 0.02270686626434326, 0.06177438050508499, 0.03890719264745712, -0.012864847667515278, 0.06699524074792862, -0.028205417096614838, 0.006998166441917419, 0.020187055692076683, 0.005822048522531986, -0.014656835235655308, 0.029598455876111984, 0.030344447121024132, -0.056801699101924896, 0.03830918297171593, -0.01591341570019722, 0.027191169559955597, -0.017439868301153183, 0.0009922662284225225, -0.033140137791633606, -0.026332136243581772, 0.05868741497397423, 0.03779581934213638, -0.0432596355676651, -0.00021261459914967418, -0.0475747212767601, -0.003172546625137329, -0.003747710259631276, -0.02557794190943241, 0.019266869872808456, 0.036603350192308426, -0.00833211001008749, -0.004814278334379196, 0.028990861028432846, -0.01798609271645546, -0.027692414820194244, -0.005867650266736746, 0.04324594512581825, 0.05558866634964943, 0.049976639449596405, -0.004923033062368631, 0.03977247700095177, -0.02253854088485241, -0.06620237231254578, -0.019305145367980003, 0.03446785360574722, -0.020092016085982323, -0.04825824126601219, 0.0553889237344265, -0.001868190593086183, 0.012187143787741661, 0.04088493436574936, -0.036114200949668884, 0.05005395784974098, 0.012740465812385082, -0.05176630616188049, -0.06333301961421967, 0.024145737290382385, -0.0065293340012431145, -0.005912839435040951, -0.04016437008976936, 0.01688605174422264, 0.023223118856549263, 0.0753181055188179, -0.014269676059484482, 0.029632363468408585, -0.014274326153099537, 0.020869996398687363, 0.04120389744639397, -0.01963513344526291, 0.010794957168400288, 0.01672409474849701, -0.03201131522655487, -0.021223563700914383, -0.06282275915145874, 0.056241828948259354, 0.01312718354165554, -0.0032971245236694813, -0.017768125981092453, 0.039667461067438126, -0.0225385669618845, 0.010539333336055279, -0.01156334113329649, 0.042017824947834015, 0.009157043881714344, 0.08444466441869736, 0.033250920474529266, 0.038223765790462494, 0.019600730389356613, -0.018800344318151474, 0.030551334843039513, 0.006028522737324238, 0.03184568136930466, 0.050221893936395645, -0.05079242214560509, 0.008663837797939777, -0.017008978873491287, 0.00889844074845314, 0.004283007234334946, -0.05782889574766159, -0.03205012530088425, -0.016767367720603943, -0.007508471608161926, 0.028050603345036507, 0.013797024264931679, 0.015471105463802814, 0.005203098524361849, 0.04323948547244072, -0.030926110222935677, -0.030957859009504318, -0.09681951254606247, -0.01118254754692316, 0.0151065019890666, -0.038069214671850204, 0.01987426169216633, -0.006249960977584124, 0.007643114775419235, 0.0134214973077178, -0.053301043808460236, -0.01026551891118288, 0.005018720403313637, 0.01933886483311653, -0.02564840205013752, -0.015058985911309719, 0.04636726155877113, 0.025290658697485924, -0.020718516781926155, 0.09576141089200974, -0.038057729601860046, -0.03164622560143471, -0.005189074203372002, -0.0010690310737118125, 0.012613356113433838, -0.0066052149049937725, 0.002980868797749281, -0.003275024238973856, 0.009696988388895988, -0.028796862810850143, 0.038226474076509476, -0.09259903430938721, 0.08362255245447159, 0.09918080270290375, -0.007068202830851078, -0.011636679992079735, 0.0047851125709712505, 0.019148727878928185, 0.014836860820651054, -0.023112259805202484, -0.0019594670739024878, -0.05247771739959717, -0.006024395115673542, -0.017114680260419846, -0.01969398558139801, -0.0412260964512825, 0.05041171610355377, 0.034357596188783646, -0.005404782015830278, -0.004702495876699686, 0.06416081637144089, -0.004841791931539774, -0.018781078979372978, 0.007554974872618914, 0.04919373616576195, 0.016100360080599785, 0.04873964190483093, 0.033689018338918686, 0.009385197423398495, -0.01022748276591301, 0.018148938193917274, 0.0008984379819594324, 0.03649317845702171, -0.006253930274397135, -0.017491072416305542, -0.0005199940642341971, -0.07564187049865723, 0.016981402412056923, 0.001660470967181027, 0.023252930492162704, 0.023126645013689995, 0.02807648852467537, -0.01242897380143404, -0.038427453488111496, -0.014389295130968094, 0.023747362196445465, 0.0214731115847826, -0.014037569984793663, -0.004769529681652784, 0.013645652681589127, -0.004692623857408762, 0.004844397306442261, -0.056600529700517654, -0.006307539530098438, -0.04229947179555893, 0.03992071375250816, 0.026576491072773933, 0.005822555627673864, 0.04097621142864227, -0.06691445410251617, -0.028605351224541664, 0.005195288453251123, -0.018151430413126945, 0.042656708508729935, 0.008517070673406124, -0.0579083189368248, 0.0009057258139364421, 0.0017156742978841066, -0.01130740623921156, 0.03874373808503151, -0.0008978653931990266, -0.025222985073924065, 0.05883123353123665, 0.025403479114174843, -0.03540030121803284, -0.01838391087949276, -0.012824431993067265, 0.021931251510977745, -0.02699088305234909, -0.0075205541215837, 0.08810941129922867, 0.02733624167740345, -0.04377545043826103, 0.02655487135052681, -0.032320793718099594, -0.0075710671953856945, -0.008069398812949657, -0.015762915834784508, 0.005589182488620281, -0.013006743974983692, -0.022871999070048332, 0.03929860517382622, -0.05043145269155502, -0.026529325172305107, -0.051324278116226196, -0.060320962220430374, 0.006208681967109442, 0.0046924324706196785, 0.039795223623514175, 0.0336189940571785, 0.011352850124239922, 0.0958433672785759, 0.02188349887728691, -0.020049702376127243, -0.028520798310637474, -0.0025493709836155176, -0.018491586670279503, -0.005273193586617708, 0.01271689124405384, -0.009776606224477291, -0.028817998245358467, -0.01348431408405304, 0.03822655603289604, 0.042745623737573624, 0.056457288563251495, 0.01134522259235382, 0.015470650047063828, 0.015432716347277164, 0.061850134283304214, -0.048097431659698486, 0.00473478389903903, 0.006521969567984343, -0.032457657158374786, -0.00897048506885767, 0.004288438707590103, 0.017520932480692863, 0.012221688404679298, -0.03795068711042404, 0.014071911573410034, -0.029371825978159904, 0.010657583363354206, -0.003132937243208289, 0.029354697093367577, 0.018315864726901054, -0.0282897986471653, -0.010721074417233467, 0.026046987622976303, 0.056961625814437866, -0.03307477384805679, -0.035500552505254745, 0.0235211793333292, 0.07011163979768753, -0.0322260744869709, 0.006282417569309473, 0.007710019592195749, -0.0090045016258955, 0.028646359220147133, -0.02240377478301525, 0.015979178249835968, 0.011017783544957638, 0.04796268045902252, 0.03828568756580353, -0.015619554556906223, -0.03776514530181885, -0.0015819254331290722, -0.06659916788339615, -0.0033217452000826597, -0.04756039381027222, 0.06227844953536987, 0.027166100218892097, 0.059268176555633545, 0.018278365954756737, -0.03816215693950653, -0.016084181144833565, -0.005006003193557262, -0.09058214724063873, -0.0030018517281860113, 0.009316623210906982, -0.0171767920255661, 0.017451506108045578, -0.018495185300707817, 0.014967313036322594, -0.00011172348604304716, 0.014646277762949467, 0.012769730761647224, 0.014179247431457043, -0.01260776910930872, 0.004252040293067694, -0.021553441882133484, 0.003992016892880201, 0.0065565211698412895, 0.027257749810814857, 0.0041507575660943985, -0.016265766695141792, 0.04587104916572571, 0.021250149235129356, -0.0184100903570652, 0.020616035908460617, -0.012685646302998066, -0.014304683543741703, 0.013536548241972923, 0.035866737365722656, 0.021372919902205467, 0.0536758154630661, -0.05510622262954712, 0.012433161959052086, 0.02459091879427433, 0.024479780346155167, 0.03901415318250656, -0.0022434694692492485, -0.0018667931435629725, -0.004202879499644041, -0.03928590938448906, 0.018671752884984016, 0.02884046547114849, 0.03433099016547203, -0.013514812104403973, 0.010017980821430683, 0.025218170136213303, -0.05812908336520195, 0.017143843695521355, 0.05414315685629845, -0.005364833399653435, 0.00521828094497323, -0.011335459537804127, -0.008046386763453484, 0.012138940393924713, 0.02494913712143898, 0.00007007351814536378, 0.030308956280350685, -0.010827003978192806, 0.021282292902469635, 0.027598245069384575, -0.0035633407533168793, -0.03687366470694542, 0.028004642575979233, -0.0008039241656661034, 0.023287668824195862, 0.012745982967317104, -0.014276687055826187, 0.026046181097626686, 0.03699444234371185, 0.028134673833847046, 0.02010340802371502, -0.020227426663041115, -0.07287821173667908, 0.00012878028792329133, 0.04356839880347252, 0.06263017654418945, -0.05869791656732559, -0.01591455563902855, -0.00795325543731451, -0.010885889641940594, 0.02325483411550522, -0.041464533656835556, 0.01903911866247654, -0.03243459016084671, 0.012618687003850937, -0.06599574536085129, -0.04102745279669762, -0.03574828803539276, 0.02313450537621975, -0.016791556030511856, 0.014449517242610455, 0.017735091969370842, -0.0313321128487587, -0.036261655390262604, -0.00833355076611042, -0.005093708634376526, 0.0376703143119812, -0.04042424261569977, -0.044753216207027435, -0.014531983062624931, 0.006993555463850498, -0.016286911442875862, -0.04967007040977478, 0.016681795939803123, -0.016138294711709023, 0.009573433548212051, 0.052111800760030746, -0.025566622614860535, -0.020095760002732277, 0.04348987340927124, 0.005436519160866737, -0.01657029613852501, -0.0035445536486804485, 0.0003296435170341283, 0.06074558570981026, 0.032917942851781845, 0.010899767279624939, 0.05023957043886185, 0.022107336670160294, 0.00932214967906475, 0.02268736995756626, -0.025842387229204178, -0.016699200496077538, -0.028511200100183487, 0.01256287656724453, -0.047995686531066895, -0.009885131381452084, -0.008020398207008839, 0.06182963401079178, -0.004461850039660931, 0.0069270990788936615, -0.024796225130558014, -0.00541626987978816, 0.02376543916761875, 0.0030281164217740297, 0.009066134691238403, -0.013334127143025398, 0.004105808679014444, 0.0072205704636871815, -0.013694168999791145, -0.04474632069468498, 0.026017233729362488, -0.017228996381163597, 0.03093077428638935, 0.02239501103758812, -0.041651397943496704, 0.001373190782032907, -0.0451032780110836, -0.03312233090400696, 0.02438945323228836, -0.014897973276674747, 0.021933138370513916, -0.03610013425350189, 0.039448101073503494, -0.018890874460339546, -0.015122715383768082, -0.007962589152157307, 0.05798720568418503, -0.01967286877334118, -0.038069695234298706, -0.004738436080515385, 0.03304465487599373, -0.002327052876353264, 0.006661203224211931, -0.08733335882425308, -0.049311839044094086, 0.024283062666654587, 0.005113594233989716, -0.006974249612540007, -0.037089549005031586, -0.02756434865295887, -0.010331526398658752, -0.015646979212760925, -0.0016953838057816029, 0.0718374028801918, -0.02937694452702999, -0.034444570541381836, -0.0023001686204224825, 0.022585315629839897, 0.07485467195510864, 0.008844174444675446, -0.029615068808197975, 0.007689755409955978, -0.03459717333316803, 0.0031650345772504807, 0.023769322782754898, -0.047552626579999924, -0.032566484063863754, -0.039934467524290085, -0.004862561356276274, 0.01092554535716772, 0.04696323722600937, -0.01840154267847538, -0.021999085322022438, 0.03405452147126198, -0.033980730921030045, -0.018430152907967567, -0.06603259593248367, -0.009846000000834465, -0.04709860682487488, 0.004707686137408018, -0.0024922238662838936, 0.007536774035543203, -0.015605714172124863, 0.010811141692101955, 0.038696255534887314, 0.010345765389502048, -0.025231296196579933, 0.013537916354835033, 0.03984065353870392, -0.008490076288580894, -0.020090606063604355, -0.006723227445036173, -0.022134888917207718, 0.03014448657631874, 0.019688935950398445, -0.02215840481221676, 0.009305641986429691, 0.002781771356239915, 0.00960478838533163, -0.012454833835363388, -0.029933428391814232, -0.027693089097738266, 0.046446628868579865, -0.0028893533162772655, 0.025708215311169624, 0.024935612455010414, 0.0009192565339617431, 0.01202489249408245, 0.013969502411782742, 0.028098780661821365, -0.009332972578704357, 0.010316694155335426, 0.05483631789684296, 0.013169923797249794, -0.015363717451691628, 0.04510565847158432, 0.02825588546693325, 0.03945350646972656, 0.02696100063621998, 0.017735658213496208, -0.00525142066180706, 0.03781683370471001, -0.053989507257938385, -0.023815244436264038, 0.039320725947618484, -0.06319601833820343, -0.016239747405052185, -0.0606919601559639, -0.017929941415786743, 0.04015133157372475, 0.05442451685667038, -0.015027107670903206, -0.01989155448973179, -0.0064522153697907925, -0.08079361170530319, -0.0021566639188677073, -0.004024439956992865, -0.0006514659617096186, 0.04230237007141113, 0.012974456883966923, 0.025178149342536926, 0.021131083369255066, 0.05107627809047699, -0.008144150488078594, -0.08102865517139435, -0.047941043972969055, -0.006676307879388332, -0.044302187860012054, 0.0499638207256794, 0.022072311490774155, -0.02146182395517826, 0.006142539903521538, -0.032317012548446655, 0.04291747137904167, 0.0009343792917206883, 0.054495830088853836, -0.06491531431674957, 0.0124669149518013, 0.01941804215312004, 0.019255483523011208, -0.00206982484087348, -0.044308848679065704, 0.1208379790186882, 0.058589544147253036, 0.04443199560046196, -0.05410877987742424, 0.0401020273566246, 0.011900953948497772, -0.000713506480678916, 0.012609248980879784, -0.028753964230418205, 0.021327108144760132, -0.0114802410826087, 0.046522676944732666, 0.03610005974769592, 0.026432350277900696, 0.025182047858834267, 0.04072774946689606, -0.02949546091258526, -0.04693673923611641, -0.007088576443493366, 0.026659801602363586, 0.002600334817543626, -0.016812460497021675, -0.02109791524708271, 0.019889794290065765, 0.015179465524852276, -0.009464413858950138, -0.011832139454782009, -0.029128633439540863, 0.000929933215957135, -0.002717884723097086, -0.019534636288881302, 0.020446158945560455, 0.0327022559940815, -0.011274243704974651, -0.04169393330812454, -0.0037694680504500866, 0.007110359612852335, -0.021338514983654022, 0.041305433958768845, 0.06361070275306702, 0.012150171212852001, 0.011670802719891071, -0.009340425953269005, 0.05382106080651283, -0.03349258750677109, -0.03677154332399368, -0.012186693958938122, 0.060601819306612015, -0.013053803704679012, -0.030350999906659126, 0.000832286081276834, -0.01958283968269825, 0.02585046924650669, -0.029922349378466606, -0.027819104492664337, 0.031899601221084595, 0.032425690442323685, -0.027725864201784134, -0.0036480778362601995, -0.0015143533237278461, 0.022536272183060646, -0.008008209988474846, 0.0047581857070326805, 0.015109377913177013, -0.052643705159425735, -0.02646809257566929, -0.05813250690698624, 0.035527002066373825, -0.017091484740376472, 0.0042265914380550385, 0.016917062923312187, -0.0027288072742521763, -0.014013312757015228, 0.02632158063352108, -0.001369395526126027, 0.030424688011407852, 0.020685935392975807, -0.0062486850656569, -0.007324370089918375, -0.005589761771261692, -0.015547916293144226, 0.01589544303715229, -0.026721322908997536, 0.0053988732397556305, -0.05883929133415222, -0.012146079912781715, 0.04295594245195389, 0.05460284650325775, 0.016470422968268394, 0.011325456202030182, -0.014327200129628181, 0.07217510789632797, 0.008724156767129898, -0.049991682171821594, -0.0290372297167778, -0.0023826041724532843, -0.023400790989398956, -0.0066538481041789055, -0.043505072593688965, 0.07166621088981628, 0.015238156542181969, -0.01043973583728075, -0.022931886836886406, 0.0472571961581707, -0.0012614933075383306, -0.023438945412635803, 0.031198661774396896, -0.07127531617879868, -0.0429813489317894, 0.013075673021376133, 0.013640508987009525, -0.02272912673652172, -0.04692063853144646, -0.05405452847480774, -0.010541665367782116, -0.015268435701727867, -0.05181242525577545, -0.027197666466236115, 0.005212682764977217, -0.059518396854400635, -0.020615478977560997, -0.0347905196249485, 0.006088087800890207, -0.024551380425691605, -0.041591428220272064, -0.0249134860932827, -0.016883930191397667, -0.01954171434044838, -0.004216550383716822, -0.008810977451503277, 0.010615131817758083, 0.012206049636006355, 0.014627562835812569, 0.00805678591132164, 0.0071597532369196415, 0.009996912442147732, -0.00022538166376762092, 0.02956341952085495, 0.013519483618438244, -0.007435131818056107, -0.0019106846302747726, -0.05913916602730751, -0.03865232691168785, 0.01662321761250496, 0.0021390654146671295, 0.026805922389030457, -0.010930044576525688, -0.019965000450611115, 0.007765213958919048, 0.026825299486517906, -0.040955062955617905, -0.028393076732754707, -0.01596248149871826, -0.020151285454630852, -0.01147461961954832, 0.023692650720477104, 0.018096638843417168, -0.005239204037934542, -0.004175963811576366, 0.02050940878689289, 0.032785169780254364, 0.034538231790065765, -0.02101222798228264, 0.00031582446536049247, 0.0030378741212189198, 0.024554545059800148, -0.005995866376906633, -0.03178026154637337, 0.013583247549831867, 0.05549785494804382, -0.014557364396750927, 0.006445883307605982, -0.031395021826028824, 0.013693774119019508, -0.08863303810358047, 0.0037082387134432793, -0.0044945175759494305, 0.033709101378917694, 0.0220163706690073, -0.04435206204652786, 0.023076612502336502, 0.006512812338769436, -0.033965252339839935, 0.01506316103041172, -0.017236685380339622, 0.021110016852617264, -0.05233665555715561, 0.031440369784832, -0.034079503268003464, 0.030040400102734566, 0.024177443236112595, -0.014147959649562836, 0.018612992018461227, -0.013314715586602688, 0.01772666536271572, -0.0324426144361496, 0.010820609517395496, -0.009603388607501984, -0.00935977604240179, -0.061122991144657135, 0.03322871774435043, -0.020571108907461166, -0.052900537848472595, 0.003143299138173461, 0.0012824629666283727, 0.058167748153209686, 0.01567278616130352, 0.03196927160024643, 0.013767094351351261, 0.03921585530042648, 0.04056533798575401, 0.0007006872911006212, -0.02845032513141632, 0.0029320232570171356, 0.001588056213222444, 0.004561545792967081, -0.029653511941432953, 0.014167842455208302, 0.05024482309818268, 0.010267085395753384, -0.008853763341903687, 0.025162432342767715, -0.013571957126259804, -0.03332588076591492, -0.007865042425692081, -0.016810372471809387, 0.028583932667970657, -0.0170412790030241, -0.0008696908480487764, -0.03322552517056465, 0.0017981679411605, 0.02122831530869007, 0.029179861769080162, -0.028436798602342606, 0.009342508390545845, 0.009703797288239002, -0.032263193279504776, -0.006648990325629711, 0.0020525737199932337, 0.003935001324862242, -0.040411610156297684, 0.028952475637197495, -0.03836040571331978, -0.02153044566512108, -0.02782737836241722, -0.012276341207325459, -0.005510256160050631, 0.05600832775235176, -0.028981877490878105, -0.015008396469056606, 0.02708209492266178, 0.002437417395412922, 0.02979196421802044, -0.07792147994041443, 0.059231773018836975, -0.018313612788915634, -0.005581793840974569, -0.04691145941615105, 0.008017071522772312, -0.03635590896010399, -0.00020687596406787634, 0.07770382612943649, 0.012684191577136517, 0.0080594252794981, 0.023568907752633095, 0.0445324145257473, 0.017746085301041603, -0.06151625141501427, 0.035990212112665176, -0.045807454735040665, 0.00666934996843338, -0.055399928241968155, 0.017707480117678642, -0.021266071125864983, 0.0035667563788592815, -0.0019205112475901842, -0.018690364435315132, -0.008052060380578041, -0.019760912284255028, -0.007826880551874638, 0.05010189488530159, -0.01262875646352768, -0.01344079989939928, 0.030447782948613167, -0.017747417092323303, 0.01985963061451912, 0.078766368329525, -0.01370879728347063, -0.06336182355880737, 0.05279653146862984, -0.03492560610175133, -0.03373301774263382, -0.0014062889385968447, -0.01027670968323946, -0.011497072875499725, -0.04538814723491669, -0.0056077889166772366, -0.024190861731767654, -0.05336335673928261, -0.007329182233661413, -0.0011346929240971804, 0.03493719547986984, 0.03680197894573212, -0.005138230975717306, -0.003363183233886957, 0.022988002747297287, -0.011294038966298103, -0.005251413211226463, 0.020217658951878548, 0.034613411873579025, 0.02470008097589016, 0.01699095219373703, 0.008167773485183716, -0.017252469435334206, 0.0014327795943245292, -0.019084684550762177, 0.035829219967126846, -0.009908395819365978, 0.015966277569532394, 0.01690288819372654, -0.03294605389237404, -0.012429548427462578, -0.01103474386036396, -0.021203724667429924, 0.031179869547486305, -0.04851279780268669, 0.039485134184360504, -0.025893183425068855, -0.03354113548994064, -0.01835915632545948, 0.0022739639971405268, 0.03602886572480202, 0.024756325408816338, -0.001333884196355939, 0.01834500953555107, -0.030744709074497223, -0.021479371935129166, 0.03948873281478882, -0.016391174867749214, 0.04060904681682587, -0.03204721584916115, -0.011851298622786999, -0.003894519992172718, -0.024007529020309448, -0.059763722121715546, -0.036750759929418564, 0.05537472665309906, 0.05621921271085739, 0.027123214676976204, -0.04648284241557121, -0.02092522755265236, 0.012672673910856247, 0.039614446461200714, -0.03238510340452194, -0.021439334377646446, -0.03720322251319885, 0.017342573031783104, 0.01446516439318657, -0.004795709624886513 ]
<p>I have a dataset that has both continuous and categorical data. I am analyzing by using PCA and am wondering if it is fine to include the categorical variables as a part of the analysis. My understanding is that PCA can only be applied to continuous variables. Is that correct? If it cannot be used for categorical data, what alternatives exist for their analysis? </p>
48,631
[ -0.016383133828639984, 0.02966565452516079, 0.007528336718678474, 0.0053712851367890835, 0.051361940801143646, -0.006641573738306761, -0.015911856666207314, -0.00969579629600048, 0.020890163257718086, -0.01801273226737976, 0.025262491777539253, 0.03754417598247528, 0.028902165591716766, 0.010784683749079704, 0.01643640734255314, 0.0021484598983079195, -0.017854923382401466, -0.003168808063492179, -0.011350084096193314, 0.03301263973116875, -0.011557246558368206, 0.040697384625673294, 0.02768566459417343, -0.0073741283267736435, 0.007174372673034668, 0.06845136731863022, 0.018045496195554733, -0.011716334149241447, 0.01919049210846424, 0.005922993179410696, -0.014342151582241058, -0.0234315674751997, -0.0006230805884115398, 0.06303966790437698, 0.0030465018935501575, 0.007819674909114838, -0.04553186893463135, -0.019311729818582535, -0.014954390935599804, 0.01055176928639412, -0.03406117483973503, -0.012136291712522507, 0.026547377929091454, 0.02812449261546135, -0.008554650470614433, 0.022950101643800735, 0.003030641470104456, -0.033593930304050446, 0.004010452888906002, -0.039418093860149384, 0.08733761310577393, -0.027281934395432472, 0.04060472548007965, 0.042622752487659454, -0.006192638073116541, 0.016817525029182434, 0.05405043810606003, 0.03219124302268028, -0.010241562500596046, -0.048334114253520966, -0.01868690364062786, -0.004460577387362719, -0.016399702057242393, -0.03605041280388832, -0.014714809134602547, 0.041036300361156464, -0.001880571711808443, -0.014282209798693657, 0.028190165758132935, -0.010385711677372456, 0.03357364609837532, -0.0059751104563474655, 0.037537023425102234, -0.003925009164959192, -0.0018828067695721984, -0.013804897665977478, 0.023068677634000778, 0.01854395493865013, 0.034522660076618195, 0.005257865879684687, 0.01112810056656599, -0.003424653084948659, 0.019438251852989197, 0.021717499941587448, 0.009012996219098568, 0.005617863964289427, 0.04882093891501427, -0.042536236345767975, -0.0014153869124129415, -0.0029473036993294954, -0.027750574052333832, -0.015814075246453285, 0.043189529329538345, 0.04873790219426155, -0.04434942454099655, 0.027308527380228043, -0.005238764453679323, 0.04370243474841118, 0.006333271041512489, -0.019166117534041405, 0.02095770835876465, -0.02151578851044178, 0.027045104652643204, 0.04207484424114227, -0.022112233564257622, 0.004383340943604708, -0.024420741945505142, 0.01808040216565132, -0.011111901141703129, -0.06093275919556618, -0.03304566070437431, -0.0025478650350123644, 0.034378573298454285, -0.015750382095575333, 0.032839566469192505, -0.010544436983764172, 0.017601661384105682, -0.015620537102222443, 0.04552571102976799, 0.0831214115023613, 0.04777801036834717, -0.05614594742655754, 0.008075724355876446, -0.0020721254404634237, -0.04884888976812363, -0.01996510848402977, 0.005678357090801001, 0.00399815896525979, -0.021058008074760437, 0.040721993893384933, -0.018668044358491898, -0.031620439141988754, 0.025859981775283813, -0.02805222198367119, 0.04440436512231827, 0.0015099237207323313, -0.10286175459623337, -0.02054492197930813, 0.003016968024894595, -0.02943795546889305, 0.002421899465844035, -0.05310335382819176, 0.011977904476225376, 0.03392595797777176, 0.024413399398326874, -0.011479543522000313, -0.004897142294794321, 0.02487514354288578, 0.02720499038696289, 0.004088797606527805, -0.04455322399735451, -0.032840777188539505, -0.02934933267533779, -0.044841740280389786, -0.047332752496004105, -0.07818356901407242, 0.025531113147735596, 0.0157898161560297, 0.026830578222870827, -0.019596487283706665, 0.013943062163889408, 0.007518345955759287, -0.008365538902580738, -0.004050731658935547, -0.011579451151192188, -0.007231120485812426, 0.038645874708890915, -0.027665546163916588, 0.06509871035814285, 0.010555177927017212, 0.019303208217024803, 0.024608874693512917, 0.07298097759485245, 0.04494424909353256, 0.02542106993496418, 0.0013040456688031554, -0.016678359359502792, 0.005533318500965834, 0.04512394219636917, 0.02265940047800541, -0.04196023941040039, -0.03831883519887924, -0.010660992003977299, 0.01863887906074524, 0.029790418222546577, 0.05389118939638138, 0.01730506122112274, -0.06768890470266342, 0.03996047377586365, -0.03276154771447182, -0.016710190102458, -0.04928683862090111, 0.0444280244410038, -0.049337804317474365, -0.009357735514640808, 0.031610921025276184, 0.0295399259775877, 0.0030111244414001703, -0.0445922315120697, -0.02153940685093403, -0.030835162848234177, -0.01645907759666443, 0.022583909332752228, -0.05922985076904297, -0.018832851201295853, 0.0288376547396183, 0.025655271485447884, 0.0021440547425299883, 0.04196871817111969, -0.014876811765134335, -0.06248582899570465, -0.003462600987404585, -0.03185040131211281, 0.02411523088812828, -0.009238461963832378, 0.011546367779374123, 0.008125213906168938, 0.028668751940131187, -0.06986463814973831, 0.045018963515758514, -0.05330023914575577, 0.08079653233289719, 0.04341709986329079, -0.00333983451128006, -0.008915385231375694, -0.01327783614397049, 0.02107059396803379, -0.017159517854452133, 0.001300910022109747, -0.009900416247546673, -0.050528790801763535, 0.03533201664686203, 0.04672335088253021, 0.027837378904223442, -0.05713910982012749, -0.0002455089706927538, 0.052381597459316254, 0.041183292865753174, 0.045308668166399, 0.020604752004146576, 0.009661346673965454, -0.01065262220799923, 0.0043630762957036495, 0.015864050015807152, -0.0029110403265804052, -0.02713187225162983, 0.040932875126600266, -0.0238354429602623, 0.05294490233063698, -0.01161984819918871, -0.011486709117889404, 0.07184693962335587, -0.027060862630605698, 0.030812468379735947, 0.01244445238262415, -0.031849589198827744, 0.05166007578372955, -0.02578425034880638, 0.04197268560528755, 0.029533065855503082, 0.026535160839557648, -0.025342104956507683, 0.015530128963291645, -0.025505954399704933, -0.0021969180088490248, 0.05057099834084511, -0.09605132043361664, 0.021627651527523994, 0.01750371977686882, -0.026963474228978157, -0.007305370643734932, -0.03328116238117218, -0.04014761000871658, -0.03331676498055458, 0.009709969162940979, 0.0468018464744091, -0.0017169909551739693, 0.052326805889606476, 0.00037176822661422193, -0.015832822769880295, -0.013510389253497124, -0.038135599344968796, -0.0034999619238078594, 0.000142753662657924, -0.045092493295669556, -0.011381651274859905, -0.023693298920989037, 0.01583907939493656, 0.011324084363877773, -0.03028566762804985, -0.019820762798190117, 0.03414814546704292, -0.03243287652730942, -0.050215546041727066, 0.02066384255886078, -0.006108508445322514, 0.030960777774453163, -0.007359324023127556, -0.02654990367591381, 0.004350973293185234, 0.0425785593688488, -0.012452869676053524, -0.02018631622195244, -0.014286343939602375, -0.0366528145968914, 0.001488204812631011, -0.021108290180563927, 0.04575939476490021, 0.004790185485035181, -0.008642513304948807, 0.02053237520158291, -0.04457753896713257, 0.01796310395002365, -0.05797658488154411, -0.08310047537088394, 0.02787918783724308, -0.005868023261427879, 0.025488223880529404, -0.006133467424660921, 0.0005806466797366738, 0.07019314914941788, 0.03187515586614609, -0.05629055202007294, -0.02137930877506733, -0.017245419323444366, -0.07433302700519562, -0.016472501680254936, -0.009660910815000534, -0.018714018166065216, 0.038374438881874084, 0.008239537477493286, 0.0017751886043697596, 0.005382424220442772, 0.043850358575582504, 0.0205323975533247, -0.022200413048267365, 0.026645036414265633, 0.0179832074791193, -0.0005892348708584905, 0.00718116108328104, 0.0243807602673769, -0.035161830484867096, 0.020994964987039566, 0.008135376498103142, 0.021985875442624092, -0.0005066557205282152, 0.005359249655157328, -0.0020675298292189837, -0.05432308837771416, 0.025648871436715126, -0.054718099534511566, 0.009895422495901585, 0.0185532346367836, -0.012062743306159973, 0.002443769248202443, 0.04265383258461952, 0.026761403307318687, -0.03738204762339592, -0.008053412660956383, 0.07666964083909988, 0.04837741702795029, -0.00975708570331335, -0.019399596378207207, 0.033312927931547165, -0.01361740380525589, 0.0898449644446373, -0.01457427442073822, 0.017336741089820862, 0.037762440741062164, 0.027285868301987648, 0.035406023263931274, 0.016741152852773666, -0.049277413636446, 0.026931311935186386, -0.07490015774965286, 0.03306903690099716, -0.02064257301390171, 0.03467551991343498, 0.0074762385338544846, 0.05382383614778519, 0.03503419831395149, -0.006444039288908243, -0.015081490390002728, 0.008546613156795502, -0.05324384942650795, -0.02836373820900917, -0.009302671998739243, 0.0008784638484939933, -0.005995729006826878, -0.042173027992248535, 0.02947520650923252, 0.023141684010624886, -0.009866386651992798, -0.009465650655329227, -0.01814201846718788, -0.026338571682572365, -0.016198433935642242, -0.018678640946745872, -0.013098955154418945, -0.012750369496643543, -0.03004208393394947, 0.014258920215070248, -0.015838900581002235, 0.05329461768269539, 0.03390216827392578, -0.002218457404524088, -0.02937946654856205, -0.015390364453196526, -0.0085377162322402, 0.043118514120578766, 0.058991145342588425, 0.002054751617833972, 0.03758282959461212, 0.004944664426147938, 0.04109140858054161, -0.004488806240260601, 0.04346340894699097, 0.007095285691320896, -0.00836671981960535, -0.036260899156332016, -0.04657607153058052, -0.019445881247520447, -0.04444253817200661, 0.015700269490480423, -0.004254359286278486, -0.023402826860547066, 0.04068285599350929, 0.03280016407370567, -0.06325365602970123, 0.016971444711089134, 0.06444988399744034, 0.05423479899764061, -0.03119436278939247, -0.02465747855603695, -0.010492638684809208, -0.031597238034009933, -0.008527347818017006, 0.03705008327960968, 0.001777211669832468, -0.0021685210522264242, 0.005023673176765442, 0.05233162268996239, -0.021980633959174156, -0.05133948475122452, -0.007522930391132832, 0.04759545996785164, 0.014091468416154385, -0.01166173629462719, -0.0460403747856617, 0.051010098308324814, 0.04716401547193527, 0.015049770474433899, 0.010169069282710552, -0.0014256861759349704, -0.10955162346363068, 0.022962400689721107, 0.02892954833805561, 0.03371185064315796, -0.012879345566034317, -0.03726949542760849, -0.05429772660136223, -0.0023313823621720076, 0.04074765741825104, -0.021418645977973938, 0.0358460508286953, -0.038021642714738846, 0.03810583055019379, -0.022707868367433548, -0.004880284424871206, -0.018084319308400154, -0.008396908640861511, -0.009182427078485489, 0.011771081946790218, 0.00645646033808589, -0.028164558112621307, -0.03514694795012474, 0.03557794168591499, -0.00070560461608693, 0.04809030890464783, 0.01009728480130434, -0.01569509506225586, 0.024598805233836174, 0.014766418375074863, -0.012108382768929005, -0.07411982119083405, 0.009738139808177948, 0.023763515055179596, -0.004764239769428968, 0.06370468437671661, 0.023254547268152237, -0.01729455590248108, -0.014781271107494831, -0.012679790146648884, -0.007023754063993692, -0.014931827783584595, -0.014233958907425404, 0.04539913684129715, 0.0004866761155426502, -0.02871680073440075, 0.060648113489151, 0.02378121204674244, 0.014580659568309784, -0.019722817465662956, -0.04305198788642883, 0.02535432018339634, -0.0017468859441578388, -0.030213430523872375, -0.036483921110630035, -0.027699848636984825, -0.0024875716771930456, 0.005473867058753967, -0.01169444527477026, 0.00893646664917469, -0.007292684633284807, -0.012050646357238293, -0.00366386491805315, 0.031929194927215576, 0.02383657731115818, -0.012179839424788952, -0.03357023745775223, -0.010055133141577244, -0.009094003587961197, -0.019182967022061348, 0.03621309995651245, -0.007278068456798792, -0.0001398987224092707, 0.012247934937477112, -0.020154716446995735, 0.001089317025616765, -0.02221045270562172, -0.02877013199031353, 0.00264615542255342, -0.004772070329636335, 0.03702337667346001, -0.015515775419771671, 0.05794580280780792, -0.00738356402143836, -0.07054167985916138, -0.00039387212018482387, 0.03517257794737816, 0.00274781696498394, 0.06083106994628906, -0.06102336570620537, 0.06313157081604004, -0.02152780257165432, 0.00216138968244195, -0.07006311416625977, -0.07731414586305618, 0.0013866210356354713, 0.03012351505458355, -0.034071628004312515, -0.047361522912979126, 0.024604501202702522, -0.007862254045903683, -0.00937096681445837, -0.009269914589822292, 0.058794163167476654, -0.03415388613939285, -0.020945396274328232, 0.00048104923916980624, 0.010097300633788109, 0.09130389243364334, 0.02205696515738964, -0.002564747119322419, 0.02214708924293518, -0.02424502745270729, -0.012532456777989864, -0.006926851812750101, -0.0026818737387657166, -0.014726509340107441, 0.009872382506728172, -0.016957173123955727, -0.0009412609506398439, 0.022991381585597992, -0.01927684061229229, -0.01775248721241951, 0.032339513301849365, -0.011841123923659325, 0.027951737865805626, -0.030405674129724503, -0.013248628936707973, -0.02124430052936077, -0.018850699067115784, -0.025232983753085136, 0.0072812605649232864, -0.023479385301470757, 0.00988730788230896, 0.03960125893354416, -0.002111465437337756, -0.045086778700351715, 0.05089040845632553, 0.06807348132133484, 0.005757025443017483, 0.00688532367348671, -0.03275463730096817, -0.010770818218588829, 0.019878996536135674, -0.000658063217997551, -0.00647461274638772, -0.0024060921277850866, 0.028514275327324867, -0.021076753735542297, 0.006160297896713018, -0.023242179304361343, -0.03015151247382164, 0.037091903388500214, 0.020189909264445305, 0.05141695961356163, 0.05723945051431656, 0.026362145319581032, -0.002186037367209792, -0.03760161250829697, 0.01551598496735096, 0.016836460679769516, -0.01297412347048521, 0.03901281952857971, 0.016538573428988457, -0.006536140572279692, -0.003786903340369463, 0.022814765572547913, 0.01912810653448105, 0.02734481543302536, 0.015487408265471458, 0.039297282695770264, -0.00627174973487854, -0.00043326138984411955, -0.06533662974834442, -0.004741472192108631, -0.06390698254108429, 0.003830832662060857, -0.035538118332624435, -0.0656496062874794, 0.028182581067085266, 0.03159160166978836, -0.0069342018105089664, -0.0542902909219265, -0.028726940974593163, -0.04053343087434769, 0.023970050737261772, -0.002327513415366411, 0.03497853875160217, 0.042982373386621475, -0.038390763103961945, 0.03543132543563843, 0.0007833007839508355, 0.029392383992671967, -0.018898237496614456, -0.02046014368534088, -0.08865420520305634, -0.03738384693861008, -0.008156190626323223, 0.013282453641295433, -0.0006102786283008754, -0.037545640021562576, 0.021649496629834175, -0.04979705810546875, 0.02554331347346306, -0.0012410185299813747, 0.03856126219034195, 0.011338301002979279, 0.03835371136665344, -0.016349628567695618, 0.008816820569336414, -0.00267246225848794, 0.02229820378124714, 0.10652423650026321, 0.10004766285419464, 0.03713406249880791, -0.08569885790348053, 0.04315316677093506, 0.0013590746093541384, 0.019305376335978508, -0.046273645013570786, 0.01213756762444973, -0.002488418249413371, -0.022376280277967453, 0.05662686005234718, 0.026646483689546585, 0.032726842910051346, 0.01781047321856022, 0.07997395843267441, -0.008394976146519184, -0.010721547529101372, 0.022740783169865608, 0.0031614885665476322, -0.04068313539028168, 0.004915004596114159, -0.004113541916012764, 0.0023129815235733986, -0.00418746005743742, -0.04629463702440262, 0.005351037718355656, 0.0022191295865923166, 0.0045686205849051476, -0.017061280086636543, -0.03428933396935463, 0.012874389067292213, 0.021276704967021942, 0.020644092932343483, -0.029038848355412483, -0.04682688042521477, -0.003303240053355694, -0.018521569669246674, -0.012791527435183525, -0.007921424694359303, 0.0021148291416466236, -0.0037378149572759867, 0.0018771137110888958, 0.02085222490131855, -0.05125488340854645, -0.01777283102273941, -0.0336591862142086, 0.04238680750131607, -0.0018622378120198846, 0.013984397053718567, -0.016426553949713707, 0.021255552768707275, 0.0021994963753968477, -0.025625787675380707, -0.01992100663483143, 0.014944915659725666, 0.014097174629569054, 0.0013701260322704911, -0.010676462203264236, -0.04806317016482353, 0.01889517530798912, -0.002407277701422572, 0.015705686062574387, 0.021568873897194862, -0.032724689692258835, 0.01540584396570921, -0.00023336218146141618, 0.04110940173268318, -0.014826713129878044, -0.016377603635191917, -0.007911505177617073, -0.009699134156107903, -0.012770428322255611, 0.000589876261074096, 0.007360958494246006, 0.004714008420705795, 0.012088674120604992, -0.020116029307246208, -0.007367278914898634, -0.0052377586252987385, -0.047366686165332794, 0.010305036790668964, 0.015228486619889736, -0.009274406358599663, -0.03208256512880325, 0.020230168476700783, 0.030013317242264748, 0.03667465224862099, -0.00015482533490285277, 0.005946224555373192, -0.022968031466007233, 0.037532974034547806, 0.02404703199863434, -0.038382574915885925, -0.0006433105445466936, -0.007881227880716324, -0.02980571985244751, 0.006399334408342838, -0.020930549129843712, 0.07445312291383743, 0.03601783141493797, 0.011994432657957077, -0.010452407412230968, 0.025745665654540062, 0.02138453535735607, 0.029275279492139816, 0.021938053891062737, -0.06014908850193024, 0.009108654223382473, -0.0004981871461495757, -0.002509349025785923, -0.024876846000552177, -0.03903467208147049, -0.05399458110332489, -0.014245209284126759, -0.027152348309755325, -0.040708426386117935, -0.040303632616996765, -0.010639057494699955, -0.015576601959764957, 0.007315165363252163, -0.06036556512117386, -0.01378493383526802, -0.06366133689880371, 0.014889616519212723, -0.03313451632857323, -0.042029716074466705, 0.006379400379955769, 0.006643407512456179, 0.01351882703602314, 0.030659692361950874, 0.04612290859222412, 0.028455233201384544, 0.02480166405439377, -0.01048367004841566, 0.03210160881280899, 0.010757825337350368, 0.05572417750954628, -0.052594058215618134, -0.010090098716318607, 0.04512643814086914, -0.04215960577130318, 0.006115127820521593, -0.006100738421082497, -0.0030357874929904938, 0.055007874965667725, 0.021128175780177116, 0.005769416689872742, -0.007601974997669458, 0.04046256095170975, -0.00997489970177412, -0.011024284176528454, -0.011247317306697369, 0.016800548881292343, -0.019571581855416298, -0.007743909023702145, 0.011770573444664478, 0.024922840297222137, -0.006546319928020239, 0.04164760559797287, 0.04820416495203972, 0.022407472133636475, -0.03657086566090584, 0.021261919289827347, -0.010544881224632263, 0.01558871753513813, 0.033747196197509766, 0.0031155627220869064, 0.06562313437461853, 0.028803599998354912, -0.006514292676001787, 0.02410636469721794, 0.0069439597427845, 0.025435257703065872, -0.08252155035734177, -0.029466470703482628, 0.011128829792141914, 0.01646571047604084, 0.0352027490735054, -0.05076204612851143, 0.0178151186555624, 0.016493773087859154, -0.03566454350948334, 0.007993752136826515, -0.015141013078391552, -0.024961067363619804, -0.03093087486922741, 0.027167126536369324, 0.012715850956737995, 0.018319198861718178, 0.02667558379471302, 0.013106130063533783, 0.01776636764407158, 0.018312888219952583, 0.013191962614655495, -0.023109279572963715, -0.008138411678373814, -0.007263620384037495, -0.005560019984841347, -0.07691888511180878, 0.05909821391105652, -0.014959774911403656, -0.04405394196510315, 0.012880404479801655, -0.009984430857002735, 0.0027014005463570356, 0.0938115268945694, 0.033525146543979645, 0.013541778549551964, 0.012602780014276505, 0.037676695734262466, -0.021361198276281357, -0.04899323359131813, 0.02478916384279728, 0.024079661816358566, 0.05080731213092804, -0.025394346565008163, 0.011293207295238972, 0.014988432638347149, -0.04630860313773155, -0.035095326602458954, -0.013252757489681244, -0.02404387667775154, -0.012211689725518227, -0.012428835965692997, -0.0005459264502860606, -0.037134841084480286, 0.0005459301173686981, 0.057765714824199677, -0.030648088082671165, -0.005403961054980755, 0.029475346207618713, -0.007173572201281786, 0.0016525739338248968, -0.016946159303188324, 0.0002686434891074896, -0.06019449234008789, -0.004712665919214487, 0.018022337928414345, 0.00458516413345933, -0.04955939203500748, 0.015789993107318878, 0.018152080476284027, -0.04404592141509056, -0.060284752398729324, -0.033824801445007324, -0.027945388108491898, 0.070599265396595, -0.018325703218579292, 0.004665262997150421, 0.037418924272060394, -0.024660002440214157, 0.005888997111469507, -0.07006224244832993, 0.061106082051992416, -0.000924868683796376, -0.009114954620599747, -0.02302788943052292, 0.017771311104297638, -0.08737852424383163, 0.0014152098447084427, 0.01654975116252899, -0.028787285089492798, 0.015280093997716904, -0.025900298729538918, 0.02895832620561123, -0.0145230982452631, -0.026396242901682854, 0.026617761701345444, -0.032692160457372665, -0.03667595610022545, -0.039565738290548325, -0.04079202562570572, -0.006263878662139177, 0.008739576674997807, 0.004754328168928623, -0.0004760332521982491, 0.05480626970529556, 0.0073346784338355064, -0.026846732944250107, 0.05026343837380409, -0.0020224638283252716, -0.03419045731425285, 0.023222776129841805, 0.018159886822104454, 0.01868252083659172, 0.0268313679844141, -0.014852126128971577, -0.020991135388612747, 0.03888137638568878, -0.016582323238253593, -0.017673859372735023, 0.005822151433676481, 0.036272380501031876, -0.02545282430946827, -0.04588605836033821, 0.0008471712353639305, 0.04387352988123894, -0.06076551973819733, 0.019504213705658913, 0.0076111359521746635, 0.026641028001904488, 0.022699372842907906, -0.012522274628281593, 0.015462304465472698, 0.039894767105579376, -0.018567103892564774, 0.018376274034380913, 0.018567189574241638, 0.02169370837509632, -0.0029655948746949434, -0.015069509856402874, 0.04133831709623337, 0.007854759693145752, 0.008135716430842876, 0.007448799442499876, 0.05654733628034592, -0.04165329039096832, -0.003807480912655592, -0.018396489322185516, 0.027507973834872246, 0.03988563269376755, 0.006845678668469191, -0.02165123075246811, 0.03670232370495796, -0.026579294353723526, 0.0058722347021102905, -0.031862322241067886, -0.0033502031583338976, -0.013491924852132797, -0.01841515675187111, 0.02460489235818386, 0.049720648676157, 0.009235840290784836, -0.0032307012006640434, -0.025567686185240746, -0.018353356048464775, 0.019885720685124397, -0.03281635418534279, 0.013733269646763802, -0.029711149632930756, 0.014993061311542988, -0.020327840000391006, -0.019065257161855698, -0.018032509833574295, -0.03343721851706505, 0.036416683346033096, 0.04062424600124359, 0.03028683178126812, -0.009722878225147724, -0.018475722521543503, -0.010502677410840988, 0.02101716957986355, -0.058103710412979126, -0.0287779550999403, -0.029825886711478233, 0.02123956009745598, 0.01451067067682743, 0.0014331386191770434 ]
<p>There are 8 people playing poker.</p> <p>So, the odds of winning the entire round = 1/8</p> <p>2 rounds are played, and Bill wins both rounds.</p> <p>What are the odds this was random? (Hypothesis test?)</p> <p>NullH = Bill has no added skill. (Got lucky)</p> <p>AltH = Bill has skill.</p> <p>p = .13 = 1/8</p> <p>q = .87 = 7/8</p> <p>n = 2</p> <p>SD = sqrt(pq/n) = .23</p> <p>actual (p-hat) = 1</p> <p>z = 3.74</p> <p>p-value = 0%</p> <p>Conclusion: Odds of winning 2 out of 2 rounds randomly is unlikely.</p> <p>Reject null hypothesis. Bill has skill.</p> <p>Is this right? Thanks!!</p>
36,934
[ -0.01597202569246292, -0.059849243611097336, -0.03237337991595268, -0.022277822718024254, 0.02482730895280838, 0.009679848328232765, 0.006198537535965443, -0.027880186215043068, -0.015607383102178574, -0.01135244034230709, 0.04883984103798866, 0.04095112532377243, 0.017813533544540405, 0.051156509667634964, 0.007066016551107168, 0.043916307389736176, -0.023147564381361008, -0.00031849046354182065, 0.0007686523022130132, 0.014637070707976818, -0.02953425608575344, 0.005318314302712679, 0.024269601330161095, 0.001552434405311942, -0.047713011503219604, 0.025540409609675407, 0.05817859247326851, -0.01029155682772398, 0.0015852488577365875, 0.06240963935852051, -0.01358557678759098, -0.03795936703681946, 0.027409495785832405, 0.00221483432687819, 0.05086899921298027, 0.006338515318930149, -0.013238745741546154, -0.0203894954174757, -0.007747627329081297, 0.004005372989922762, 0.011795256286859512, 0.024418869987130165, 0.007986101321876049, 0.031210970133543015, -0.009984925389289856, 0.030019180849194527, -0.005131331738084555, -0.04353597015142441, 0.018308745697140694, -0.06321202218532562, 0.05853090435266495, -0.009865171276032925, 0.016849182546138763, 0.020312441512942314, 0.022669322788715363, -0.013549261726439, 0.025156725198030472, 0.0714692696928978, -0.024071674793958664, -0.05245750769972801, -0.0071960752829909325, -0.06054295226931572, -0.03714067116379738, 0.012015748769044876, -0.03343130648136139, 0.010473819449543953, 0.023275835439562798, -0.03250125050544739, 0.047928567975759506, -0.01528457086533308, 0.00315083097666502, 0.07539734244346619, 0.01420851144939661, 0.004689481109380722, 0.019383123144507408, -0.027314096689224243, 0.023914316669106483, 0.025225574150681496, 0.015399056486785412, 0.031134629622101784, 0.02821250818669796, -0.010402741841971874, 0.0202485304325819, 0.035079605877399445, 0.0600874125957489, -0.020561959594488144, 0.04257151111960411, -0.019925184547901154, 0.01143973134458065, 0.03746611624956131, -0.0033260085619986057, -0.020632445812225342, 0.038778822869062424, -0.01956225372850895, -0.03738109767436981, 0.022773608565330505, -0.021861905232071877, 0.05798788368701935, -0.0007412909180857241, -0.031410716474056244, 0.01075852569192648, -0.036953605711460114, 0.03613210842013359, 0.03630685433745384, -0.01431187242269516, -0.040822744369506836, -0.0068919663317501545, 0.028561213985085487, -0.007656777743250132, -0.0038436853792518377, -0.03973196819424629, 0.055118758231401443, -0.00397625844925642, 0.0326034277677536, 0.022318542003631592, -0.044436775147914886, -0.022282954305410385, 0.025644125416874886, 0.06280826777219772, 0.0628078281879425, 0.0023754986468702555, -0.021675726398825645, 0.012332242913544178, -0.013138549402356148, -0.034153327345848083, 0.046773761510849, 0.021573413163423538, -0.032347939908504486, -0.031387798488140106, 0.06068124622106552, -0.02225697599351406, 0.028600266203284264, 0.050102598965168, 0.03412657231092453, 0.05324195325374603, 0.0015179903712123632, -0.08484479784965515, -0.045289088040590286, 0.04707447439432144, -0.03659060597419739, 0.012970613315701485, -0.07823952287435532, -0.0051301829516887665, 0.04207358509302139, 0.036215752363204956, 0.001481287064962089, 0.07140561193227768, -0.01672097109258175, 0.002536779036745429, 0.03828206658363342, -0.011102142743766308, -0.003813526127487421, -0.022383669391274452, -0.03590613231062889, -0.005307584069669247, -0.05356678366661072, 0.03514035791158676, -0.008557064458727837, -0.007248487323522568, -0.03717569261789322, 0.014138869941234589, -0.012601770460605621, -0.003064669668674469, -0.0365128293633461, -0.010365575551986694, -0.028317714110016823, 0.09205123782157898, 0.03352963551878929, 0.010281594470143318, 0.017205670475959778, -0.00974480714648962, 0.01690906099975109, 0.008334405720233917, -0.007061464712023735, 0.04849977046251297, -0.04614478349685669, -0.006937868893146515, 0.023573847487568855, 0.03345581144094467, -0.001085203723050654, -0.04031681269407272, 0.028540611267089844, -0.0055175828747451305, -0.011530532501637936, 0.019531385973095894, 0.03509720787405968, 0.01662714220583439, -0.022332187741994858, 0.015627363696694374, -0.03150419518351555, -0.061229076236486435, -0.11238651722669601, -0.015408717095851898, -0.0037968961987644434, -0.015888502821326256, -0.012979703955352306, 0.03302241116762161, 0.03594242408871651, -0.02128017693758011, 0.005030341446399689, -0.023282483220100403, -0.00733439065515995, 0.015435551293194294, -0.07364395260810852, -0.02182396873831749, 0.05302949994802475, 0.027905210852622986, -0.05172343552112579, 0.04337063059210777, -0.04416486248373985, -0.011918356642127037, -0.005571660585701466, -0.032823193818330765, -0.0060112434439361095, 0.009390204213559628, 0.012991298921406269, 0.02534203603863716, 0.01667873188853264, 0.034319713711738586, 0.031463623046875, -0.03823292627930641, 0.0459497794508934, 0.04238445684313774, 0.0005947027239017189, -0.011076157912611961, -0.01407626736909151, 0.008970147930085659, 0.01761588640511036, 0.013687257654964924, 0.01782228611409664, -0.038261085748672485, 0.0010437231976538897, 0.04127921909093857, 0.03787928447127342, -0.029042446985840797, 0.0357489250600338, 0.06763114780187607, 0.0249062217772007, -0.015641633421182632, 0.052776169031858444, 0.0018849842017516494, 0.01861369051039219, -0.016811305657029152, 0.03455367684364319, 0.02976599894464016, 0.03128451481461525, 0.017356639727950096, -0.0053546070121228695, 0.01507857721298933, 0.02982034534215927, -0.027224242687225342, 0.01018462423235178, 0.0036554632242769003, 0.04713642969727516, -0.012962661683559418, -0.04048344865441322, 0.037533387541770935, 0.01873967796564102, 0.009804447181522846, 0.009877456352114677, 0.01880306750535965, -0.0026778746396303177, -0.022458426654338837, -0.018753526732325554, 0.01898737996816635, 0.01728656142950058, -0.011471062898635864, -0.007528949063271284, 0.039797116070985794, -0.01794165000319481, -0.034777719527482986, -0.017803914844989777, 0.025343647226691246, -0.04817177355289459, 0.009731254540383816, 0.010405536741018295, -0.014492394402623177, 0.04969232529401779, -0.02464667707681656, -0.026745062321424484, -0.030681608244776726, 0.005505446810275316, 0.010906672105193138, -0.027163170278072357, -0.08355710655450821, -0.00958165805786848, 0.01709907501935959, -0.011579195968806744, 0.035471148788928986, -0.0053563774563372135, 0.016133854165673256, 0.03386097401380539, -0.005724494345486164, -0.019887490198016167, -0.029493536800146103, -0.05766262859106064, 0.013859341852366924, -0.05093226581811905, -0.02545291930437088, 0.054053895175457, 0.05658440291881561, -0.031279586255550385, 0.08591020107269287, -0.012182964943349361, -0.051379211246967316, -0.02030959166586399, -0.0034953884314745665, 0.03690570592880249, 0.011580114252865314, 0.01906137727200985, 0.014275745488703251, -0.02223759889602661, 0.04755933955311775, -0.08458242565393448, -0.09077021479606628, 0.008991731330752373, 0.01649230346083641, 0.00953984446823597, -0.0313379168510437, -0.02398689091205597, 0.04555421322584152, 0.020814744755625725, -0.015674928203225136, -0.015031562186777592, 0.021687816828489304, -0.036696963012218475, -0.00927744060754776, 0.018840879201889038, 0.04482284188270569, -0.03707776591181755, 0.03639041259884834, -0.018527066335082054, 0.05030004307627678, 0.024286042898893356, 0.003700156696140766, -0.001541418838314712, -0.008316532708704472, -0.004368053749203682, -0.02895781584084034, 0.019631970673799515, 0.009667213074862957, -0.05374462157487869, 0.020870694890618324, -0.017480669543147087, 0.016759146004915237, 0.010225504636764526, -0.02297665737569332, 0.0034290982875972986, -0.009600467048585415, 0.016375252977013588, -0.047323353588581085, 0.05785774067044258, 0.007073589600622654, -0.035225171595811844, 0.002949254587292671, -0.01944931223988533, 0.04761883243918419, 0.006710303947329521, 0.03788997232913971, 0.056760918349027634, 0.007714366540312767, -0.021710913628339767, -0.0067059132270514965, 0.01690683513879776, 0.00012586380762513727, 0.012317800894379616, -0.042541101574897766, -0.03201303258538246, 0.06856641918420792, 0.04911838844418526, 0.03647417202591896, 0.0113590182736516, -0.034443199634552, 0.013402547687292099, -0.05090686306357384, 0.033691197633743286, -0.02068706974387169, 0.042973682284355164, -0.025908546522259712, 0.040854692459106445, -0.002222713315859437, -0.042428262531757355, 0.022641034796833992, 0.003004098078235984, -0.04705492779612541, 0.04110143706202507, 0.0018255169270560145, -0.016418222337961197, -0.012154101394116879, -0.012566618621349335, 0.005405435338616371, -0.04512102156877518, 0.025840817019343376, 0.03723379597067833, 0.01626475527882576, -0.020604807883501053, 0.02762787416577339, -0.01930132508277893, -0.0394061915576458, 0.017406219616532326, 0.005258945748209953, 0.020112620666623116, -0.02213939093053341, 0.018732825294137, 0.05437060073018074, -0.02595183067023754, -0.0018470038194209337, -0.016421468928456306, 0.014800922013819218, 0.028524819761514664, 0.03971334919333458, 0.03250209614634514, 0.03385519981384277, -0.03960423171520233, 0.001471217954531312, -0.00957732368260622, 0.030646871775388718, 0.047855135053396225, 0.022393349558115005, 0.016182085499167442, -0.0432930551469326, -0.01940688118338585, 0.003142956178635359, -0.020687159150838852, 0.0037659406661987305, 0.022024525329470634, 0.051896169781684875, 0.034206245094537735, -0.07105724513530731, 0.04056530445814133, 0.06965664029121399, -0.013548697344958782, -0.012701380997896194, -0.0477580800652504, 0.0005385318072512746, -0.009169279597699642, -0.028545189648866653, 0.03100014477968216, 0.012856614775955677, -0.0547107495367527, -0.014209163375198841, 0.02950359880924225, -0.016294119879603386, -0.005039636977016926, 0.03221769630908966, -0.0008325589005835354, 0.05826254189014435, 0.04840131849050522, -0.0006946880021132529, 0.041558437049388885, 0.025494610890746117, -0.0023990559857338667, 0.010147891007363796, -0.036805685609579086, -0.04902723804116249, 0.04414910078048706, 0.05776538699865341, 0.07333452999591827, -0.040625009685754776, -0.006169590167701244, -0.02748197317123413, 0.019003629684448242, 0.03117658942937851, -0.05459270626306534, -0.006076825316995382, -0.02115260623395443, 0.016594011336565018, -0.03324127569794655, -0.015492789447307587, -0.06316149234771729, 0.003174932673573494, -0.012489610351622105, 0.03724328801035881, -0.018135560676455498, -0.0443182997405529, -0.04281186684966087, -0.008131961338222027, 0.06500819325447083, 0.023428862914443016, -0.0562330037355423, -0.004705454688519239, -0.005551681388169527, 0.013305299915373325, -0.03515953570604324, -0.07117193192243576, 0.03562972694635391, -0.012870351783931255, 0.013102265074849129, 0.027515694499015808, -0.023602742701768875, -0.030498245730996132, 0.01950252614915371, 0.002524363109841943, -0.0527888759970665, 0.005694437772035599, -0.031453121453523636, 0.009229276329278946, 0.04686864838004112, 0.04423599690198898, 0.056380495429039, -0.013156052678823471, -0.020523564890027046, -0.015666190534830093, -0.021172065287828445, -0.006040947046130896, 0.0076697757467627525, 0.02398131601512432, -0.07989544421434402, 0.013527413830161095, 0.010027693584561348, 0.004876014310866594, 0.019846372306346893, 0.0534406341612339, -0.014576171524822712, 0.0032509882003068924, -0.041922517120838165, 0.01741471327841282, 0.018136190250515938, 0.003785985754802823, 0.010930036194622517, 0.0020341556519269943, -0.026137955486774445, -0.02142314985394478, 0.036450520157814026, -0.009576836600899696, -0.02069663256406784, -0.0070241903886199, -0.026276269927620888, 0.029781702905893326, 0.006537124048918486, -0.030488887801766396, -0.013705667108297348, -0.047606728971004486, 0.03082186169922352, -0.0231031384319067, 0.01826825924217701, -0.015086039900779724, -0.027980316430330276, -0.04558798298239708, 0.02048872411251068, 0.009753462858498096, 0.004712479189038277, -0.04462172091007233, 0.08441197127103806, 0.017032360658049583, 0.024436412379145622, -0.051405806094408035, -0.0217667855322361, 0.006234175991266966, -0.0015911185182631016, 0.0031811168882995844, 0.0003495568234939128, -0.03286844119429588, -0.008265802636742592, -0.010454223491251469, -0.026978667825460434, 0.02483682706952095, -0.00013924093218520284, -0.008602636866271496, 0.0017707429360598326, -0.004158336203545332, 0.06565496325492859, 0.04873450845479965, -0.017582008615136147, -0.007604511920362711, -0.0352303683757782, -0.014578340575098991, -0.020642172545194626, 0.02052592858672142, -0.026870356872677803, -0.024481656029820442, -0.029650943353772163, 0.006276373751461506, 0.03268788009881973, -0.0035711973905563354, 0.003858640557155013, -0.037533361464738846, 0.030147476121783257, -0.006572941783815622, -0.0258819367736578, -0.008072125725448132, -0.010999639518558979, 0.02335173264145851, 0.00518538523465395, 0.04540413245558739, -0.014164472930133343, 0.022122180089354515, 0.011877844110131264, 0.038376763463020325, -0.04230184108018875, 0.008350224234163761, 0.059974510222673416, -0.013341866433620453, 0.004402536898851395, 0.003914420027285814, -0.00982598029077053, 0.03370310738682747, 0.046163324266672134, -0.005851623136550188, -0.01322237029671669, 0.02861732244491577, -0.02716790698468685, 0.0074912686832249165, -0.01792874187231064, 0.005510872695595026, 0.02796229161322117, 0.007857287302613258, 0.06988521665334702, 0.05127374827861786, 0.026820626109838486, -0.001706159207969904, -0.017994029447436333, 0.0017936654621735215, -0.031321246176958084, 0.014377701096236706, 0.043180350214242935, 0.024188559502363205, 0.025824956595897675, 0.05861382931470871, 0.00894506461918354, 0.009869697503745556, 0.026592988520860672, 0.061327021569013596, 0.008269250392913818, 0.019898684695363045, -0.025392426177859306, -0.0255762729793787, 0.00963356252759695, -0.06104971095919609, 0.05702201649546623, -0.029091408476233482, -0.03154595196247101, 0.05373627319931984, -0.014461315236985683, -0.04059063643217087, -0.005262280814349651, -0.0037781696300953627, -0.029103590175509453, 0.0036632735282182693, -0.01774485968053341, -0.005124819464981556, 0.03962218761444092, -0.017303163185715675, 0.04624190926551819, -0.011529382318258286, 0.050254061818122864, -0.04748445004224777, -0.08404664695262909, -0.01986762136220932, 0.0031626117415726185, -0.02858736366033554, 0.0124032748863101, -0.0015733613399788737, -0.0346064418554306, 0.02981698513031006, -0.04234911873936653, -0.0005073462962172925, 0.0024229027330875397, 0.007152040489017963, -0.04224206134676933, 0.06091570481657982, 0.038209620863199234, -0.005349187180399895, -0.00019125209655612707, -0.03428534045815468, 0.12344388663768768, 0.04041947424411774, 0.012315277010202408, -0.059092868119478226, -0.0008649110095575452, -0.018362492322921753, 0.016842283308506012, 0.0008367343689315021, 0.010795896872878075, -0.0001769795926520601, 0.0011947776656597853, 0.03771515563130379, 0.038242362439632416, 0.0227561853826046, -0.0029030954465270042, 0.024122655391693115, -0.042441971600055695, -0.05125701427459717, -0.02223026566207409, 0.02784014120697975, -0.008652622811496258, -0.0037620156072080135, -0.015127907507121563, 0.003816659562289715, -0.004546725191175938, -0.009119611233472824, 0.0008025975548662245, -0.027708252891898155, -0.01388567965477705, 0.0017709393287077546, -0.005171448457986116, -0.04235585033893585, 0.022412730380892754, -0.030422618612647057, -0.007028680294752121, -0.02868817187845707, 0.029160328209400177, -0.0540926568210125, 0.010948841460049152, 0.031718458980321884, -0.009288912639021873, -0.019013497978448868, 0.02894396148622036, 0.005796643905341625, -0.04905204102396965, -0.012082370929419994, -0.026177722960710526, 0.027363460510969162, -0.021330472081899643, -0.012870623730123043, -0.021681418642401695, 0.0075904750265181065, -0.036874525249004364, -0.029943810775876045, -0.031178589910268784, 0.01531323790550232, 0.007202270440757275, -0.03708546608686447, -0.05657855048775673, -0.02974989451467991, 0.009078430011868477, -0.015200678259134293, 0.01944037154316902, 0.01578127220273018, 0.010629781521856785, -0.015546448528766632, -0.04401644319295883, 0.026392001658678055, -0.022236404940485954, 0.021762311458587646, 0.013634508475661278, -0.0069258371368050575, -0.05340852960944176, -0.006247620098292828, 0.015912985429167747, -0.005044668447226286, 0.016556520015001297, -0.024371525272727013, 0.0257802065461874, 0.005193404853343964, -0.021269358694553375, 0.022273613139986992, -0.024353180080652237, -0.019569549709558487, -0.017611583694815636, -0.006616977043449879, 0.015994995832443237, 0.007401153910905123, -0.051924001425504684, -0.014686698094010353, 0.02454385720193386, 0.04046044498682022, 0.000515662191901356, -0.0630803108215332, -0.05481096729636192, -0.02375931292772293, -0.056373629719018936, -0.021373601630330086, -0.003804990090429783, 0.06934551894664764, 0.009309212677180767, 0.015131637454032898, 0.016470616683363914, -0.011186630465090275, -0.019492296501994133, 0.021270737051963806, 0.008678603917360306, -0.04685679078102112, -0.04267387092113495, 0.05122815817594528, 0.005833153612911701, -0.016034230589866638, -0.021587997674942017, -0.0280588548630476, -0.025918226689100266, 0.002125924453139305, -0.015501091256737709, -0.0711175724864006, 0.016845347359776497, -0.015328209847211838, 0.012672404758632183, -0.014632472768425941, 0.016306893900036812, -0.02822001650929451, -0.04198097810149193, 0.03319739177823067, 0.03184790909290314, -0.003628810402005911, 0.004225115291774273, -0.02242247946560383, 0.01506776548922062, 0.0073911030776798725, -0.009411420673131943, 0.005385582335293293, -0.031315628439188004, -0.018440555781126022, -0.011407529935240746, -0.0036167807411402464, -0.047780659049749374, -0.02038075402379036, 0.045453619211912155, -0.0573464073240757, 0.004327415954321623, 0.03979713097214699, 0.036478690803050995, 0.06887198984622955, 0.01096932590007782, -0.012711499817669392, 0.010733488015830517, 0.03842563182115555, -0.04518390819430351, -0.05089027062058449, -0.021738538518548012, -0.0009722514660097659, 0.030549250543117523, 0.04429098963737488, -0.007807743735611439, 0.004406992346048355, -0.007026423700153828, 0.01938801445066929, 0.07655776292085648, 0.015481558628380299, 0.010070527903735638, -0.013791096396744251, 0.031485769897699356, 0.013974408619105816, 0.027149323374032974, -0.03221754729747772, -0.017698852345347404, 0.008948144502937794, -0.009940927848219872, 0.04841909930109978, -0.03394775465130806, -0.020609917119145393, -0.09549149125814438, -0.047252923250198364, 0.026424316689372063, 0.013183272443711758, 0.030429285019636154, -0.059406425803899765, -0.005639457609504461, 0.009349407628178596, -0.05335357040166855, 0.007943881675601006, 0.04026127979159355, -0.03385509178042412, -0.04393620416522026, 0.05470449849963188, 0.005001931916922331, 0.04477357119321823, 0.03363320976495743, 0.017098618671298027, 0.028985321521759033, -0.010994447395205498, 0.0021306800190359354, 0.017013555392622948, -0.012090897187590599, 0.017410220578312874, -0.0001589270104886964, -0.04848933219909668, -0.02819560095667839, -0.06448990851640701, -0.005293571390211582, 0.029729699715971947, 0.005656742956489325, 0.018804503604769707, 0.02568487636744976, 0.017055556178092957, -0.004298837389796972, 0.01149072591215372, 0.02923961542546749, -0.02566709741950035, -0.03390668332576752, 0.010177412070333958, 0.031024817377328873, 0.03918270021677017, 0.014980974607169628, -0.010705300606787205, 0.011304916813969612, 0.021335558965802193, -0.04189344868063927, 0.024300405755639076, -0.03396255522966385, 0.002418957185000181, 0.043436914682388306, 0.0064208912663161755, 0.006052487995475531, -0.034028489142656326, 0.008642220869660378, -0.03436652198433876, 0.02560686692595482, 0.03914477303624153, 0.01914391852915287, -0.011929769068956375, -0.031138364225625992, -0.007882479578256607, -0.03272055834531784, 0.0049075898714363575, 0.012026187032461166, -0.00512331398203969, -0.04169102758169174, -0.005442135967314243, 0.015408847481012344, 0.04341015964746475, 0.01984817534685135, -0.030407432466745377, -0.02125118486583233, 0.010470355860888958, -0.0016085868701338768, -0.005725340452045202, 0.010634462349116802, -0.005013984628021717, 0.0006676048506051302, -0.05456400290131569, 0.056941259652376175, 0.005418339744210243, -0.016982227563858032, -0.03878767043352127, 0.019665075466036797, -0.008214973844587803, 0.01146831177175045, 0.013615242205560207, -0.006408995948731899, -0.027387795969843864, -0.012212259694933891, -0.008621000684797764, 0.021151062101125717, -0.07379268854856491, 0.0647052675485611, -0.01759384758770466, -0.04700099304318428, 0.008191565982997417, -0.013485042378306389, 0.030158106237649918, -0.018886778503656387, 0.033468276262283325, -0.01742607355117798, 0.013440023176372051, -0.016088765114545822, -0.03750285506248474, 0.018970660865306854, 0.009149461053311825, -0.008460224606096745, 0.03319301828742027, -0.014951302669942379, -0.014710252173244953, 0.0020152742508798838, -0.006629813462495804, -0.010370212607085705, 0.047799382358789444, -0.021511713042855263, 0.005304953549057245, -0.001958340173587203, -0.015466773882508278, -0.005092507693916559, -0.042552489787340164, 0.0138799287378788, 0.005515286233276129, -0.022048359736800194, -0.04055512323975563, 0.022744737565517426, 0.058261558413505554, 0.024893855676054955, -0.053826943039894104, -0.002673483919352293, -0.04439225420355797, -0.039305657148361206, 0.03522198647260666, 0.008290381170809269, 0.036291129887104034, -0.00991580169647932, 0.0561891533434391, 0.03616702929139137, -0.01538597047328949, 0.013387685641646385, -0.003431082936003804, 0.024843653663992882, -0.03454199805855751, 0.025464225560426712, 0.027566086500883102, 0.005431262776255608, 0.014735935255885124, 0.009215408936142921, 0.011138897389173508, 0.05269559845328331, -0.007223909720778465, 0.011607468128204346, -0.01848503202199936, -0.025951338931918144, -0.054449066519737244, -0.0043822699226439, 0.014432013034820557, 0.015044501051306725, -0.008347311057150364, -0.02294004335999489, 0.0009885808685794473, 0.064241424202919, 0.04664043337106705, 0.00044351600809022784, 0.005211321171373129, -0.03287805989384651, -0.030560649931430817, -0.02323051542043686, 0.03123876452445984, 0.012096351012587547, -0.0011784909293055534, 0.015281829982995987, 0.04413158819079399, -0.0048268940299749374, -0.03942073881626129, -0.024905886501073837, 0.005320127587765455, 0.07413724064826965, -0.07260327786207199, -0.026955248787999153, -0.062008194625377655, 0.0371028296649456, -0.03513678163290024, -0.010234043933451176 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/6/the-two-cultures-statistics-vs-machine-learning">The Two Cultures: statistics vs. machine learning?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>What is the difference between data mining and statistical analysis?</p> <p>For some background, my statistical education has been, I think, rather traditional. A specific question is posited, research is designed, and data are collected and analyzed to offer some insight on that question. As a result, I've always been skeptical of what I considered "data dredging"--looking for patterns in a large dataset and using these patterns to draw conclusions. I tend to associate the latter with data-mining and have always considered this somewhat unprincipled--along with things like algorithmic variable selection routines.</p> <p>Nonetheless, there is a large and growing literature on data mining. Often I see this label referring to specific techniques--clustering, tree-based classification, etc. Yet, at least from my perspective, these techniques can be "set loose" on a set of data or used in a structured way to address a question. I'd call the former data mining and the latter statistical analysis.</p> <p>I work in academic administration and have been asked to do some "data mining" to identify issues and opportunities. Consistent with my background, my first questions were--what do you want to learn and what are the things that you think contribute to issue. From their response, it was clear that me and the person asking the question had different ideas on the nature and value of data mining.</p>
48,439
[ -0.06920627504587173, -0.020592141896486282, 0.012391122989356518, -0.032309018075466156, 0.043557703495025635, 0.024382587522268295, 0.021662263199687004, -0.0062653496861457825, 0.030422411859035492, 0.005622351076453924, 0.03302275389432907, 0.04803857207298279, 0.043835945427417755, 0.03558740019798279, 0.04144095256924629, 0.03000420704483986, 0.008463896811008453, 0.030742136761546135, -0.011934229172766209, 0.021448947489261627, 0.017142076045274734, 0.007579735945910215, 0.004005244467407465, 0.002649093745276332, -0.07477530092000961, 0.023347485810518265, 0.0020613204687833786, -0.015437335707247257, -0.02154061384499073, 0.05067398399114609, -0.016653720289468765, 0.008094032295048237, 0.013458107598125935, 0.02021303027868271, 0.03346594423055649, 0.012458599172532558, -0.005438089836388826, 0.0020363328512758017, -0.008161623030900955, 0.05590370297431946, -0.04642504081130028, -0.035652052611112595, -0.017287801951169968, 0.02329612523317337, -0.026816299185156822, 0.00003253863178542815, -0.04152294248342514, -0.04016044735908508, -0.006628134287893772, -0.026137685403227806, 0.03245541825890541, -0.04842318594455719, -0.00024280621437355876, 0.034462857991456985, -0.01894618384540081, -0.007553808391094208, 0.07483527064323425, 0.06749128550291061, -0.024521563202142715, -0.057109247893095016, -0.019533412531018257, 0.011352513916790485, 0.035583820194005966, 0.00966370664536953, -0.05429549887776375, 0.0308323185890913, -0.02043234370648861, 0.021058522164821625, 0.03113044798374176, -0.0008337305043824017, 0.012544720433652401, 0.03739120066165924, 0.016113651916384697, -0.02146022953093052, 0.0017472581239417195, -0.036810245364904404, -0.004296672064810991, 0.03340514749288559, 0.025179103016853333, 0.04645156487822533, 0.03154861927032471, 0.010349598713219166, 0.019470714032649994, 0.03192034363746643, 0.004918506368994713, -0.012952077202498913, 0.0772540494799614, -0.03212588280439377, -0.01795787364244461, -0.004811908584088087, 0.01614384911954403, 0.027929339557886124, 0.016587194055318832, -0.012813052162528038, -0.04348202794790268, 0.022666044533252716, -0.009923121891915798, 0.0666099488735199, 0.022713907063007355, -0.008171038702130318, -0.003651750972494483, -0.015099878422915936, 0.007635047193616629, 0.02883005514740944, -0.025649288669228554, -0.021446816623210907, -0.013618238270282745, 0.021242445334792137, -0.053452104330062866, -0.03217040374875069, -0.01965172216296196, 0.010337789542973042, 0.015812160447239876, -0.011312940157949924, 0.03741538152098656, 0.02003047987818718, -0.018508179113268852, 0.016314998269081116, 0.06237892434000969, 0.07183253020048141, 0.04677390307188034, -0.048671822994947433, 0.025219673290848732, -0.0393064059317112, -0.053386468440294266, -0.00865026842802763, 0.04156149923801422, -0.03705538064241409, -0.027052268385887146, 0.010462411679327488, -0.03807758539915085, 0.00807406846433878, 0.010385049507021904, 0.009284388273954391, -0.024965545162558556, 0.015238480642437935, -0.07331299036741257, -0.05448910966515541, 0.034720007330179214, 0.03376086801290512, -0.024756193161010742, -0.027678893879055977, -0.029615046456456184, -0.010900423862040043, 0.04004283249378204, 0.01367567665874958, 0.06667649745941162, 0.004696705378592014, 0.03174649551510811, 0.006986455991864204, -0.02641826495528221, -0.006047441158443689, -0.021143825724720955, -0.004812680650502443, -0.029444267973303795, -0.03292519971728325, 0.01895470730960369, 0.02801617607474327, -0.00861483532935381, -0.0052218190394341946, 0.031073687598109245, -0.01275814138352871, -0.01567693240940571, 0.004244474694132805, 0.01676524244248867, 0.026565758511424065, 0.06082610785961151, 0.005340102128684521, 0.08111932873725891, 0.03338285908102989, 0.0022581792436540127, 0.03281080350279808, 0.021518802270293236, 0.009642229415476322, 0.05845261365175247, -0.01961912214756012, -0.02404671348631382, 0.02125556580722332, 0.003326957579702139, -0.03515584394335747, -0.05372247099876404, -0.04857602342963219, -0.0027669973205775023, -0.01675465889275074, 0.008153525181114674, 0.08333760499954224, 0.05780979245901108, -0.025716397911310196, 0.03377457335591316, -0.06231117993593216, -0.05391794070601463, -0.08685290813446045, -0.024119365960359573, -0.07403802126646042, -0.006400702055543661, 0.007783507462590933, -0.01755368523299694, -0.006090725772082806, -0.04175820201635361, -0.019997140392661095, 0.025801466777920723, -0.009319719858467579, 0.0465376116335392, -0.016300460323691368, -0.026837777346372604, 0.039401762187480927, -0.015156768262386322, -0.02890530787408352, 0.015624284744262695, -0.06256772577762604, -0.09935421496629715, -0.013122210279107094, -0.032884832471609116, 0.029442325234413147, 0.007311955559998751, -0.00919251050800085, -0.005492071621119976, 0.004582093562930822, -0.06564338505268097, 0.012623436748981476, -0.01845778524875641, 0.08319969475269318, 0.05399101972579956, 0.0012777741067111492, 0.015189861878752708, 0.016977723687887192, -0.004057944752275944, 0.0018120775930583477, -0.01425917074084282, 0.005398582201451063, -0.06137824431061745, 0.035130735486745834, 0.05213571712374687, 0.013188546523451805, -0.0426274798810482, 0.018662339076399803, 0.02143903821706772, 0.0526406466960907, 0.012826669029891491, 0.026816437020897865, -0.062363121658563614, 0.007763557601720095, 0.026100173592567444, 0.0311298631131649, -0.02152819186449051, 0.009243466891348362, 0.012070337310433388, 0.02754042111337185, 0.011374074034392834, 0.006789127830415964, 0.008211459033191204, 0.07601363956928253, 0.012243000790476799, -0.011349223554134369, 0.023879265412688255, -0.01996639557182789, 0.018236501142382622, -0.041927095502614975, -0.039843808859586716, 0.013163628987967968, -0.002489953301846981, 0.012162736617028713, -0.029570771381258965, 0.011140894144773483, 0.013086830265820026, 0.03472592309117317, -0.009853195399045944, 0.02888333611190319, 0.026943542063236237, -0.011891346424818039, 0.04379462078213692, -0.01307092048227787, -0.04535055160522461, -0.009504511952400208, 0.028689175844192505, -0.024337882176041603, 0.029052628204226494, 0.03611389547586441, -0.03546538203954697, -0.0046638790518045425, -0.015268179588019848, -0.02052471600472927, -0.019724367186427116, 0.019978659227490425, -0.039313092827796936, 0.003826815402135253, -0.02313004806637764, -0.006794520653784275, 0.023671627044677734, 0.0012324318522587419, -0.010789779946208, 0.010260513052344322, 0.027496526017785072, -0.08370702713727951, -0.03666319698095322, 0.0022282127756625414, 0.017756370827555656, 0.018380913883447647, -0.03542492166161537, 0.02254035510122776, -0.012670382857322693, -0.014525754377245903, 0.0001639613474253565, -0.02051503024995327, -0.04508960247039795, -0.061044543981552124, -0.0014566159807145596, 0.042603522539138794, 0.008698442950844765, -0.013883313164114952, 0.015579192899167538, 0.0026320002507418394, 0.008703083731234074, -0.045491911470890045, -0.044876717031002045, 0.01787557080388069, -0.02681225910782814, -0.0007231055060401559, 0.024488314986228943, -0.000624223961494863, 0.05724421888589859, 0.019764693453907967, -0.04301462695002556, -0.03203625604510307, -0.030483512207865715, -0.03320232033729553, 0.03983086720108986, 0.028003526851534843, 0.0329115092754364, 0.009844849817454815, 0.0007613152265548706, -0.019405879080295563, 0.02384035475552082, 0.041203517466783524, 0.024103036150336266, -0.0021175749134272337, 0.007609900087118149, -0.020197389647364616, 0.01566021889448166, 0.03833438828587532, 0.01349638495594263, -0.02105189487338066, 0.010821332223713398, -0.03906845673918724, 0.015698494389653206, 0.03650793433189392, -0.0618111826479435, 0.013641525991261005, -0.01573014445602894, 0.029937930405139923, -0.0315818190574646, 0.029146414250135422, 0.022545568645000458, -0.03256829082965851, 0.0003468849172350019, -0.004477121401578188, 0.013867417350411415, -0.03473209589719772, -0.03672534599900246, 0.060366395860910416, 0.06217315420508385, -0.0070640952326357365, -0.0028339691925793886, -0.02849864959716797, 0.006667720153927803, 0.040303878486156464, -0.009794804267585278, 0.016824692487716675, 0.050254058092832565, 0.03480907529592514, 0.019730817526578903, -0.010649685747921467, -0.05270799249410629, 0.003792313626036048, -0.08541542291641235, 0.014693567529320717, -0.03607415035367012, 0.06489085406064987, -0.029193684458732605, 0.03313768655061722, 0.01428744662553072, -0.028033092617988586, -0.01403605192899704, -0.015053275972604752, -0.05933389067649841, 0.0021415837109088898, -0.019341357052326202, -0.002134080743417144, -0.007212574128061533, -0.01563425175845623, 0.006814855150878429, 0.009658430702984333, 0.011691397055983543, -0.02650306560099125, 0.027717461809515953, -0.032026518136262894, 0.045974913984537125, -0.043814871460199356, 0.014851266518235207, 0.042874157428741455, 0.011198037303984165, 0.05444610118865967, 0.0028866762295365334, 0.05668214336037636, -0.0004410996043588966, 0.024788308888673782, -0.037687476724386215, 0.006896581966429949, -0.016582734882831573, 0.02322252467274666, 0.027121009305119514, 0.000744886405300349, 0.022481055930256844, -0.05011314898729324, 0.03685032203793526, 0.02449108101427555, 0.023387499153614044, -0.003929635509848595, -0.03896275535225868, -0.004352382849901915, -0.024117086082696915, -0.025024984031915665, 0.01461184024810791, 0.037292491644620895, -0.005499927327036858, 0.0035414809826761484, 0.02690279297530651, 0.012189758010208607, -0.04409852251410484, 0.06275739520788193, 0.06380152702331543, 0.00683003943413496, 0.02477332204580307, -0.037536680698394775, 0.006526106037199497, -0.0006452305242419243, -0.014971572905778885, 0.04804176092147827, 0.012412745505571365, 0.006044311914592981, -0.019052991643548012, 0.04562046378850937, -0.00679656770080328, -0.04624186083674431, -0.0035491108428686857, 0.0032040749210864305, 0.018433645367622375, -0.015724632889032364, -0.007353337947279215, 0.00973240565508604, 0.03536543995141983, 0.045869067311286926, 0.0257088765501976, 0.0357513427734375, -0.10798782110214233, -0.028433704748749733, 0.05234493315219879, 0.026956554502248764, -0.04026984050869942, 0.019190220162272453, -0.034882400184869766, 0.004934985190629959, 0.03588026016950607, -0.04110623896121979, 0.03640417754650116, -0.042542438954114914, 0.028681645169854164, -0.012834228575229645, 0.022662466391921043, -0.0446351021528244, -0.006343628279864788, -0.00016024956130422652, 0.06394665688276291, 0.0016677242238074541, -0.02593357302248478, -0.09778669476509094, -0.012830132618546486, 0.0038553697522729635, 0.039109110832214355, -0.021685315296053886, -0.010878645814955235, -0.01579101011157036, 0.022544022649526596, -0.002354890573769808, -0.06399136036634445, -0.023392941802740097, 0.021837810054421425, -0.00597033416852355, 0.033697132021188736, -0.03899799659848213, -0.07217414677143097, 0.020655907690525055, -0.02436358854174614, -0.00007183689740486443, -0.010152315720915794, -0.016656596213579178, 0.026071492582559586, 0.012238578870892525, 0.024043504148721695, 0.04276119917631149, 0.021543782204389572, 0.015353294089436531, -0.015786034986376762, -0.022862859070301056, 0.02262737974524498, -0.023488089442253113, -0.046016912907361984, 0.0022851696703583, -0.025091502815485, -0.059218380600214005, 0.01996486634016037, 0.017654934898018837, 0.0029895449988543987, -0.07151343673467636, -0.039792969822883606, -0.007239657919853926, -0.005423298105597496, 0.017070766538381577, -0.020894819870591164, -0.00186487240716815, 0.030760519206523895, -0.02360690012574196, -0.027509039267897606, 0.031595539301633835, -0.016874082386493683, -0.011034862138330936, 0.03242393583059311, -0.04384985938668251, -0.015241319313645363, -0.024904031306505203, 0.0017270521493628621, 0.018040955066680908, -0.009005449712276459, 0.06216703727841377, 0.023456959053874016, 0.06830183416604996, 0.009979595430195332, -0.05778098106384277, -0.0065471576526761055, 0.009887750260531902, 0.03143497556447983, 0.015713771805167198, -0.019467025995254517, 0.03814632073044777, -0.035157445818185806, -0.03582831099629402, -0.05009445548057556, -0.05162959545850754, -0.007308041211217642, 0.0013254121877253056, -0.05871449038386345, -0.01811564527451992, 0.047665975987911224, -0.0041657425463199615, -0.026549624279141426, -0.005704977083951235, 0.04401719570159912, -0.04314793273806572, -0.02350267581641674, 0.012119392864406109, 0.0034984389785677195, 0.07571485638618469, -0.008038816973567009, -0.023825041949748993, -0.019140902906656265, -0.008513173088431358, 0.0421290285885334, -0.013412092812359333, 0.012014508247375488, -0.02557547204196453, -0.013347005471587181, -0.06491708010435104, 0.015165815129876137, 0.011755645275115967, -0.0010965804103761911, 0.001635727589018643, 0.024180741980671883, 0.012959638610482216, -0.0017350780544802547, -0.0015983241610229015, 0.011129592545330524, -0.020082570612430573, 0.019353896379470825, -0.015844762325286865, 0.0080330865457654, 0.03060232289135456, 0.03961370140314102, 0.017468450590968132, 0.014584971591830254, -0.020514270290732384, 0.04779092222452164, 0.006809399463236332, -0.044942907989025116, 0.027170101180672646, 0.004367089364677668, -0.03288984298706055, 0.03147602826356888, -0.006075747776776552, 0.0014000050723552704, -0.00023296586005017161, 0.03556668758392334, 0.0006254371255636215, -0.05760244280099869, -0.0015734971966594458, -0.01296633668243885, 0.0615212619304657, 0.022416554391384125, 0.07072250545024872, 0.0589432492852211, -0.00638590008020401, 0.011710208840668201, -0.048918552696704865, 0.015663694590330124, -0.023366820067167282, 0.022384891286492348, 0.031632840633392334, -0.01606115885078907, -0.008206674829125404, 0.0715455636382103, -0.0034592554438859224, 0.01392890140414238, 0.035620905458927155, 0.04544822499155998, 0.047886647284030914, 0.022826887667179108, -0.048179201781749725, -0.04286710545420647, 0.008972981944680214, -0.07082633674144745, 0.002710679778829217, 0.010780604556202888, -0.04125770553946495, 0.057655081152915955, 0.03208640217781067, 0.010713710449635983, -0.052670303732156754, 0.033184073865413666, -0.05878143385052681, -0.015007684007287025, 0.008107781410217285, 0.01143927313387394, 0.052795540541410446, -0.016746828332543373, -0.009217924438416958, -0.016486261039972305, -0.005701488349586725, -0.017296237871050835, -0.04673771560192108, -0.027173329144716263, -0.01993175409734249, -0.04403476417064667, 0.04954325035214424, 0.006851882673799992, -0.0577533058822155, 0.013954240828752518, -0.038090843707323074, 0.013763677328824997, 0.04764511063694954, 0.019016187638044357, -0.04659250006079674, 0.048678312450647354, -0.02603176049888134, 0.004972114227712154, -0.011828416958451271, -0.02854863554239273, 0.11954542249441147, 0.044837892055511475, 0.0783880427479744, -0.058585286140441895, 0.016787920147180557, -0.0066480934619903564, -0.018907425925135612, -0.012428263202309608, 0.0026773649733513594, -0.00212599104270339, -0.005371019709855318, 0.028272852301597595, 0.029709916561841965, 0.023768708109855652, 0.011207210831344128, 0.06107156351208687, -0.0114622563123703, -0.027238978073000908, 0.014525704085826874, 0.0004489548155106604, 0.02109784446656704, 0.004952336195856333, -0.017114631831645966, 0.0050489455461502075, 0.020286215469241142, -0.021596433594822884, -0.008553544990718365, -0.02057575434446335, 0.0034539038315415382, 0.011634968221187592, -0.03840814158320427, -0.012474801391363144, 0.03197279945015907, 0.03227553889155388, -0.05258287116885185, -0.026931365951895714, 0.011582164093852043, -0.0416596494615078, -0.0012533898698166013, 0.03106137178838253, 0.022434858605265617, -0.03967328369617462, 0.005922747775912285, 0.020597781985998154, -0.0769474133849144, -0.011804374866187572, -0.0078774718567729, 0.03353637084364891, 0.002452048473060131, -0.010380683466792107, -0.01287076622247696, -0.014110487885773182, 0.0011440787930041552, -0.026883471757173538, -0.000198914494831115, -0.008109019137918949, 0.05224922299385071, -0.03304850310087204, -0.01386553980410099, -0.01809614524245262, 0.027630725875496864, -0.02012566663324833, 0.03144434839487076, -0.0006121707847341895, 0.002693257760256529, -0.032305095344781876, -0.004586460068821907, 0.014179258607327938, -0.01068207435309887, 0.019558118656277657, -0.029055112972855568, 0.01506587490439415, -0.031171007081866264, 0.02827230654656887, -0.0057250261306762695, 0.037936873733997345, 0.025244878605008125, 0.004624469671398401, -0.018773915246129036, -0.007700852584093809, -0.016988346353173256, 0.02904505841434002, -0.029999352991580963, 0.013722260482609272, -0.02871003746986389, 0.032610803842544556, -0.02063908986747265, 0.02691030129790306, 0.022017598152160645, 0.030231283977627754, 0.034002870321273804, 0.0379633754491806, -0.012076632119715214, -0.019585246220231056, -0.0361880287528038, -0.019739359617233276, -0.05271930992603302, 0.012422171421349049, -0.0027047989424318075, 0.03486085310578346, 0.039726436138153076, 0.020789844915270805, -0.020026443526148796, 0.019452547654509544, 0.003502488601952791, 0.018034452572464943, 0.023421864956617355, -0.04112113639712334, -0.03047875128686428, 0.017252709716558456, -0.007121555507183075, -0.05078501999378204, -0.04724045470356941, -0.0014181091682985425, -0.01326821744441986, 0.020567407831549644, 0.019702071323990822, -0.025488732382655144, 0.03445162996649742, 0.008362424559891224, 0.005974953528493643, -0.03857233747839928, -0.025899339467287064, -0.0955256000161171, -0.033426206558942795, -0.016887864097952843, -0.012410943396389484, 0.008151842281222343, 0.024518057703971863, -0.024711497128009796, 0.0017462479881942272, 0.023708730936050415, 0.0261172354221344, -0.005485376808792353, 0.002811240730807185, 0.024211086332798004, -0.03246360272169113, 0.04227807745337486, -0.015001260675489902, -0.004933651071041822, 0.03840206190943718, -0.020905377343297005, -0.038345638662576675, 0.02194288931787014, -0.01792324334383011, 0.005712415557354689, 0.022414643317461014, 0.02300911396741867, 0.0017030051676556468, 0.03053596243262291, -0.035277072340250015, -0.03377809748053551, -0.021487366408109665, -0.003519263118505478, 0.004374828655272722, -0.008214634843170643, 0.017621612176299095, 0.01827239990234375, -0.0162670761346817, 0.0020504824351519346, 0.02174110896885395, 0.028049830347299576, -0.04779493808746338, -0.0033358591608703136, 0.015541487373411655, 0.01933104544878006, -0.029406793415546417, 0.0022774478420615196, 0.03435157239437103, 0.016748793423175812, -0.022496802732348442, 0.024945437908172607, 0.003998986445367336, 0.01837947964668274, -0.11132141947746277, 0.001803908497095108, 0.021171823143959045, -0.0015168004902079701, -0.0005103592993691564, -0.031099943444132805, -0.02624029852449894, 0.016714565455913544, -0.048709429800510406, -0.006447212304919958, -0.03725234419107437, 0.010611708275973797, -0.025208713486790657, 0.055830225348472595, -0.009403194300830364, 0.028222588822245598, -0.014234849251806736, 0.030916737392544746, 0.02634882740676403, 0.04375528544187546, -0.010119060985744, 0.012377262115478516, -0.007353412453085184, 0.0007518019410781562, -0.01441298145800829, -0.032953958958387375, 0.04324699193239212, -0.013302103616297245, -0.07361756265163422, 0.0405968502163887, 0.00788481067866087, 0.017429685220122337, 0.06720525026321411, -0.009953154250979424, 0.010699952021241188, 0.0014946699375286698, 0.05580606311559677, -0.020399082452058792, -0.0346858911216259, -0.0076830689795315266, 0.013951187022030354, 0.03425879031419754, 0.008949145674705505, 0.014820398762822151, 0.02773614600300789, -0.011967064812779427, 0.016559207811951637, 0.010034914128482342, -0.029703766107559204, -0.027773790061473846, -0.002779597183689475, 0.01637015864253044, 0.015654075890779495, -0.006701083853840828, 0.022318832576274872, -0.004067858215421438, 0.03129632771015167, 0.018419630825519562, 0.02598476968705654, -0.0037524837534874678, 0.04868041351437569, -0.0064490120857954025, -0.024544602259993553, -0.008233455009758472, -0.01345204096287489, -0.01703527756035328, -0.053098130971193314, -0.030491426587104797, 0.015894690528512, -0.04064362123608589, -0.0540195107460022, 0.015214107930660248, -0.03487759828567505, 0.05413609370589256, -0.021160606294870377, 0.0376897007226944, 0.039085641503334045, -0.06116239354014397, -0.002123618731275201, -0.06449377536773682, 0.0800681784749031, 0.00017031357856467366, 0.013807257637381554, -0.0435744971036911, -0.00818579364567995, -0.053890760987997055, -0.011487307958304882, 0.04715068265795708, 0.017744604498147964, 0.03022092953324318, -0.024491162970662117, -0.009797357022762299, 0.000747092068195343, -0.005982762202620506, 0.03308641165494919, -0.009972807951271534, -0.012074431404471397, 0.02113749086856842, -0.042057543992996216, 0.001401452929712832, 0.007243251893669367, 0.02292768284678459, 0.0034045286010950804, 0.021291343495249748, 0.04538233205676079, 0.01980036124587059, 0.03431301936507225, 0.014938200823962688, -0.0035305540077388287, 0.028961794450879097, -0.01785222999751568, 0.013007604517042637, 0.060084279626607895, -0.024212215095758438, -0.03284742310643196, 0.03695463016629219, -0.02949565090239048, -0.03072163835167885, 0.006561660673469305, -0.018504520878195763, 0.015527846291661263, -0.025889962911605835, -0.027258887887001038, 0.012306097894906998, -0.017689894884824753, 0.006515586283057928, 0.025946250185370445, 0.0329258032143116, 0.017058607190847397, -0.005974330008029938, -0.005498536862432957, 0.012086824513971806, -0.035424523055553436, -0.012531000189483166, 0.027112985029816628, 0.05107809603214264, 0.00656817527487874, 0.020981697365641594, 0.016070857644081116, 0.04252953827381134, 0.019297949969768524, -0.018847012892365456, 0.025754986330866814, -0.0020103224087506533, -0.030538683757185936, -0.01554081030189991, 0.020893847569823265, -0.018497824668884277, 0.02393331378698349, -0.00260921404697001, 0.059395719319581985, -0.002107765292748809, -0.03340989351272583, -0.04791973531246185, -0.0370120108127594, -0.003994120750576258, 0.0001325251505477354, -0.021987738087773323, 0.01996718719601631, 0.010262321680784225, -0.007350581232458353, 0.008752337656915188, 0.015707338228821754, 0.041146427392959595, 0.012917941436171532, 0.02502153255045414, -0.02622980810701847, 0.0024943368043750525, -0.02846229076385498, -0.013652855530381203, -0.05810961872339249, -0.0013691444182768464, 0.06043226644396782, 0.03573700785636902, 0.03292990103363991, -0.0012371636694297194, -0.012535146437585354, -0.024041542783379555, 0.03388381376862526, -0.042288556694984436, -0.006964302621781826, -0.07060379534959793, 0.010398675687611103, 0.008003824390470982, -0.039054036140441895 ]
<p>I have a ranking of books that is based on number of sales and I want to improve it to include how many countries the book was sold in and number of libraries that carries it</p> <pre><code>Book rating 1 = # sales Book rating 2 = # sales + # countries + # libraries </code></pre> <p>Can I say that Book rating 2 is "better" than book rating 1 ? What do "better" mean here? more comprehensive and more than one dimension?</p> <p>If I have a list of books that were ranked using these 2 equations , can I compare the 2 ratings to see if there a difference between them using t-test for example? or there is different test to use ?</p> <pre><code>Example - equation1 - equation2 Book 1 - 5000 - 5050 Book 2 - 300 - 320 Book 3 - 90 - 99 </code></pre> <p>Finally, forming a new equation and comparing it to existing ones is called modeling ?</p> <p>Many thanks </p>
74,199
[ -0.04069410264492035, -0.03388698399066925, -0.005225165747106075, 0.026309451088309288, 0.03200836479663849, 0.018634598702192307, -0.00969107635319233, 0.0015471228398382664, 0.05809471383690834, 0.00010532427404541522, 0.052679650485515594, 0.028475021943449974, 0.0462985523045063, 0.0034491366241127253, -0.0003695401828736067, 0.040229931473731995, -0.0047023966908454895, 0.02876570075750351, 0.005260086618363857, -0.0008114035590551794, -0.004263313487172127, 0.01783081330358982, 0.03032309003174305, 0.00259664049372077, 0.005031005013734102, 0.02803974784910679, 0.07161575555801392, -0.01910022832453251, -0.010100731626152992, 0.009791465476155281, -0.03852705657482147, -0.015309219248592854, 0.02145867422223091, 0.02979947440326214, 0.015245012007653713, 0.02079998329281807, -0.014679761603474617, -0.018327053636312485, 0.0026431004516780376, -0.0004560824600048363, -0.010294976644217968, -0.03274621069431305, 0.008892497979104519, 0.028545835986733437, -0.016025619581341743, 0.042077936232089996, -0.014705495908856392, -0.023088626563549042, -0.00013641637633554637, -0.03258464112877846, 0.05749751627445221, 0.013543086126446724, 0.045756589621305466, 0.04636693000793457, -0.023349031805992126, -0.005582040641456842, 0.04727236181497574, 0.07001763582229614, -0.000421892327722162, -0.05991331860423088, -0.0014032914768904448, -0.024428177624940872, 0.02195245772600174, -0.0025770554784685373, -0.029136117547750473, 0.04540732502937317, 0.010770728811621666, 0.014004716649651527, 0.021565444767475128, -0.018494294956326485, -0.012292771600186825, 0.0035043125972151756, 0.04913458228111267, -0.047945428639650345, 0.030213169753551483, -0.05954036861658096, 0.011479776352643967, 0.04195991903543472, 0.059193775057792664, 0.039405155926942825, -0.0254686176776886, 0.019920682534575462, -0.0021801448892802, 0.04470108821988106, -0.00048451582551933825, -0.02910248376429081, 0.07181859761476517, -0.017691200599074364, -0.014375841245055199, 0.020744143053889275, -0.0006013885722495615, 0.006893030367791653, 0.0033689928241074085, 0.008942285552620888, -0.017742780968546867, 0.03396906331181526, 0.00013193709310144186, 0.007086068857461214, 0.01309789065271616, -0.012530079111456871, 0.008550700731575489, -0.04958279803395271, -0.007347306236624718, 0.020108109340071678, -0.03775808960199356, -0.01524393167346716, -0.025930507108569145, -0.06443991512060165, 0.0073836734518408775, 0.012091022916138172, -0.04960183426737785, -0.003519711084663868, -0.00028238981030881405, -0.028196318075060844, 0.008388220332562923, -0.01526289340108633, 0.02798524685204029, -0.018650615587830544, 0.046782344579696655, 0.048876918852329254, 0.04257984459400177, -0.059079959988594055, 0.02781113237142563, 0.0011740474728867412, -0.06838415563106537, -0.02689688466489315, -0.011835494078695774, -0.012258895672857761, -0.025046899914741516, 0.03259970620274544, -0.03189455345273018, 0.04119081795215607, 0.023093651980161667, 0.01320879627019167, 0.03797556087374687, 0.023171506822109222, -0.08592380583286285, -0.04314669221639633, 0.02388547733426094, -0.021366950124502182, 0.04513680562376976, -0.02286769263446331, 0.04082633554935455, 0.01321625616401434, 0.04701230674982071, 0.0340605191886425, 0.029298068955540657, 0.027263211086392403, 0.030146833509206772, -0.006830707658082247, -0.035593222826719284, -0.04057256132364273, 0.006731114350259304, -0.037163201719522476, -0.03613686561584473, -0.09699466079473495, 0.006235629785805941, 0.008400536142289639, -0.03358441963791847, 0.014702966436743736, 0.026943938806653023, -0.03025784157216549, -0.024578066542744637, 0.011113088577985764, -0.0009522825130261481, -0.0001740622683428228, 0.034773267805576324, 0.0029448140412569046, 0.0664653331041336, 0.02362455055117607, 0.0002520052657928318, 0.031461529433727264, 0.007722950074821711, -0.029277073219418526, 0.031549811363220215, 0.014603342860937119, -0.02718907780945301, -0.025556016713380814, 0.009252328425645828, 0.003003535559400916, -0.05249821022152901, -0.047793276607990265, -0.012514231726527214, 0.02835465781390667, 0.04505601525306702, 0.006096032448112965, 0.007750118616968393, 0.00961779709905386, 0.04920204356312752, -0.04615853726863861, -0.026798030361533165, -0.07517684251070023, 0.012435821816325188, 0.01993727870285511, 0.0028227881994098425, -0.00007352004467975348, -0.021741174161434174, 0.004613582510501146, -0.004189526662230492, 0.005830366630107164, -0.04660875350236893, 0.011850631795823574, 0.027676818892359734, -0.004448582883924246, 0.03019537590444088, 0.07174915075302124, 0.06532423198223114, -0.027390819042921066, 0.06842704117298126, -0.06111309677362442, -0.036075737327337265, 0.010213212110102177, -0.04337028041481972, -0.015321909449994564, -0.005488772876560688, -0.05719010531902313, 0.023329202085733414, 0.007224577013403177, -0.005676422268152237, 0.03494573384523392, -0.06159490719437599, 0.028794562444090843, 0.0895700454711914, 0.0006311339675448835, 0.049806930124759674, -0.00860015768557787, 0.008223061449825764, 0.039504580199718475, 0.0030620992183685303, 0.006984126754105091, -0.05201949179172516, -0.014847289770841599, 0.025152502581477165, 0.0014842541422694921, -0.030649034306406975, -0.00770106166601181, 0.07838879525661469, -0.00413190433755517, 0.008467410691082478, -0.0010928440606221557, -0.025312570855021477, -0.042571116238832474, 0.022146213799715042, 0.038829538971185684, 0.03793647885322571, 0.021134275943040848, 0.019804611802101135, 0.0169233288615942, 0.021667780354619026, -0.019378842785954475, 0.040844693779945374, 0.05847374349832535, 0.005388992838561535, -0.009974068962037563, 0.000444282399257645, -0.0035700660664588213, 0.03622971475124359, -0.029494035989046097, -0.014273347333073616, 0.01603092812001705, -0.012628592550754547, -0.015218996442854404, 0.008756842464208603, 0.0015932166716083884, -0.0035497783683240414, 0.06977137923240662, -0.015721295028924942, -0.019880972802639008, 0.03222068399190903, -0.05277612432837486, 0.027698388323187828, -0.007127006538212299, -0.01739831641316414, -0.08532299101352692, 0.010973245836794376, 0.02680126018822193, -0.000878951686900109, 0.06269240379333496, -0.014072117395699024, -0.023476729169487953, -0.014767857268452644, -0.01937578245997429, 0.011833781376481056, -0.05602115020155907, -0.04490424692630768, 0.014931491576135159, -0.047962576150894165, 0.00590852415189147, 0.03140740841627121, -0.0075079272501170635, -0.01994927227497101, 0.030390042811632156, 0.007726394105702639, -0.021840926259756088, -0.06688514351844788, -0.040772028267383575, 0.057361409068107605, 0.008205519057810307, -0.02020946890115738, 0.03704638034105301, -0.02633596956729889, -0.008279068395495415, 0.025518378242850304, -0.0660952553153038, -0.03587489575147629, -0.028552275151014328, -0.023458536714315414, 0.003526733722537756, 0.005546633619815111, 0.008143936283886433, 0.010057227686047554, -0.00432503642514348, -0.007958530448377132, -0.07554581016302109, -0.03547331318259239, 0.03626096621155739, -0.016095561906695366, 0.035497963428497314, 0.00517249945551157, -0.0014823568053543568, 0.10091471672058105, 0.027404407039284706, -0.046847715973854065, -0.04442214220762253, -0.016390910372138023, -0.011591975577175617, -0.0479247123003006, -0.0022941480856388807, 0.029464302584528923, -0.007639346644282341, -0.002704903483390808, 0.0033339629881083965, 0.016379645094275475, 0.03891231492161751, -0.0020147606264799833, 0.000881374697200954, 0.015237931162118912, -0.00017969694454222918, -0.028261316940188408, 0.06273248046636581, 0.003871491178870201, -0.0636502131819725, 0.012693180702626705, -0.008480302058160305, 0.011590853333473206, 0.020739849656820297, -0.05876188352704048, 0.017502523958683014, 0.01163299661129713, -0.0058305272832512856, -0.04704591631889343, 0.03304651007056236, 0.015670016407966614, -0.032287705689668655, -0.021689150482416153, 0.034791599959135056, 0.013611572794616222, -0.02642541192471981, -0.0036088349297642708, 0.018634837120771408, 0.03940571844577789, -0.041168276220560074, 0.01074970979243517, -0.04842683672904968, -0.006976197473704815, 0.0031354420352727175, -0.01219136267900467, -0.0033172336407005787, 0.0493057519197464, 0.04771028459072113, 0.02806832641363144, 0.03903379663825035, -0.031065942719578743, -0.009802061133086681, -0.04483312740921974, -0.020262664183974266, -0.06526532024145126, 0.10182947665452957, 0.004920038394629955, 0.05385836958885193, -0.009184652008116245, 0.007406224496662617, 0.05744117125868797, -0.00169830908998847, -0.072611503303051, 0.03204631805419922, -0.01951318234205246, -0.017008544877171516, 0.04198117181658745, -0.00561033608391881, 0.02262866124510765, -0.03682428225874901, -0.01945277862250805, 0.006614476442337036, -0.013215060345828533, -0.04420154541730881, 0.014905421994626522, -0.015091939829289913, 0.013670919463038445, 0.0064095063135027885, 0.01718290150165558, 0.020767945796251297, -0.03919731453061104, 0.06331565231084824, 0.025288427248597145, -0.00962684117257595, 0.013754564337432384, -0.03648332878947258, 0.0021957927383482456, 0.05203256383538246, 0.02409953810274601, 0.03138524293899536, 0.02225021831691265, -0.06024353578686714, 0.04009838402271271, -0.00019830766541417688, 0.022754618898034096, 0.0462925098836422, 0.0041166432201862335, -0.034100331366062164, -0.04204022139310837, 0.0036888825707137585, 0.010634752921760082, -0.0018754060147330165, 0.018337545916438103, -0.0366181954741478, 0.00288283615373075, 0.029315104708075523, -0.04617476463317871, 0.017519667744636536, 0.0873224288225174, -0.012960433959960938, 0.0005563792074099183, 0.009364573284983635, -0.032372742891311646, -0.02471873164176941, -0.04355965554714203, 0.02697470225393772, 0.03463681414723396, -0.01374642364680767, 0.009794499725103378, 0.048159822821617126, 0.010571233928203583, -0.06164951249957085, 0.0048580532893538475, 0.028348011896014214, 0.013258530758321285, -0.006080633495002985, -0.032726213335990906, -0.002189293038100004, 0.05004654452204704, 0.02183806709945202, -0.02566458284854889, -0.013912264257669449, -0.11312755942344666, -0.016836104914546013, 0.027568113058805466, 0.03829125687479973, -0.0692896768450737, -0.02744228206574917, -0.04900155961513519, 0.011586868204176426, -0.014262307435274124, -0.04422774165868759, 0.03889010101556778, -0.019022975116968155, 0.0009368955506943166, -0.036733999848365784, -0.010145786218345165, -0.04077034443616867, 0.023070279508829117, 0.0018099513836205006, 0.0004500255745369941, 0.003344403114169836, -0.0025754498783499002, -0.03132812678813934, 0.016377132385969162, 0.019017256796360016, 0.03148455172777176, -0.04208281263709068, -0.03191255033016205, -0.0007403395138680935, -0.005278644151985645, -0.03484411537647247, -0.030520660802721977, 0.011804389767348766, -0.0067589241079986095, 0.013418729417026043, 0.017417436465620995, 0.018890073522925377, -0.04466208443045616, 0.017183806747198105, 0.013552021235227585, -0.04164180904626846, -0.021286290138959885, -0.01030415203422308, 0.014628210105001926, 0.05264630168676376, 0.001989081036299467, 0.04083302244544029, 0.04314997419714928, -0.004239239264279604, 0.007363941054791212, -0.03202986344695091, 0.035594359040260315, -0.011210463009774685, -0.020436083897948265, -0.060636088252067566, -0.029205217957496643, -0.05574333667755127, -0.0004238247638568282, -0.007014170754700899, 0.008180822245776653, -0.07858557254076004, 0.023467490449547768, -0.0006907592178322375, 0.03060787357389927, -0.004306785296648741, -0.026699941605329514, 0.032713234424591064, 0.009409110061824322, -0.001556526287458837, -0.025374703109264374, 0.023687850683927536, -0.016003886237740517, -0.024456849321722984, 0.022826729342341423, -0.0077646938152611256, 0.03838594630360603, -0.014593789353966713, 0.0002170508960261941, 0.002422309247776866, -0.015787934884428978, 0.03532429039478302, 0.013777095824480057, 0.007240843493491411, 0.00922973919659853, -0.01734473556280136, -0.04300074651837349, 0.03156035766005516, 0.029499437659978867, -0.02702219970524311, -0.02702864445745945, 0.04448145255446434, 0.011661645956337452, -0.03021235018968582, -0.03352340683341026, -0.02269972302019596, 0.05702275410294533, -0.05020010843873024, -0.013682244345545769, -0.015118136070668697, -0.010159914381802082, -0.016175465658307076, 0.002042163396254182, -0.011145773343741894, 0.024625537917017937, -0.05943334102630615, -0.036955565214157104, 0.022051451727747917, -0.013208637945353985, 0.024542292580008507, 0.04238542169332504, -0.047592174261808395, -0.006567880976945162, 0.03293214738368988, 0.0003327810554765165, 0.0052521913312375546, 0.04648980125784874, -0.04399951919913292, -0.011823245324194431, -0.04291564226150513, 0.03595106676220894, 0.04810849949717522, 0.006017528474330902, -0.01811106503009796, -0.018000813201069832, -0.014922847971320152, -0.013712153770029545, -0.02901804819703102, -0.002224148251116276, -0.03863760083913803, 0.008548279292881489, -0.03562608361244202, 0.02591744251549244, -0.015202569775283337, 0.004268106538802385, 0.014979026280343533, 0.007504203822463751, -0.01056736521422863, 0.0008155841496773064, 0.09100258350372314, -0.010544758290052414, 0.024675369262695312, 0.012950785458087921, -0.016158288344740868, 0.04751264676451683, 0.008308864198625088, 0.008084938861429691, 0.017682800069451332, 0.040025483816862106, -0.0346771664917469, -0.017959995195269585, -0.010089796967804432, -0.017482711002230644, 0.05494946986436844, -0.004290617071092129, 0.036641404032707214, 0.060045089572668076, 0.03509385511279106, 0.02282181940972805, -0.030359847471117973, -0.013144014403223991, 0.025494810193777084, 0.030621115118265152, 0.09105422347784042, -0.014413648284971714, -0.01905450038611889, 0.04098733142018318, 0.016462935134768486, 0.036205850541591644, 0.04117373749613762, 0.011872612871229649, 0.014733930118381977, -0.03421330079436302, -0.062044207006692886, -0.0269479863345623, 0.06849578768014908, -0.04452987015247345, 0.0037705886643379927, -0.032417237758636475, -0.014848814345896244, 0.018701791763305664, 0.030390990898013115, -0.008830009959638119, -0.05225545912981033, -0.0037958265747874975, -0.08135905861854553, 0.018497439101338387, 0.01159574743360281, 0.01680636964738369, 0.016048772260546684, -0.00285178329795599, 0.019869903102517128, -0.008338370360434055, 0.01857764460146427, -0.03327316790819168, -0.07457312941551208, -0.014681300148367882, -0.01734929159283638, -0.02609507367014885, 0.022093290463089943, -0.0049167112447321415, -0.017473846673965454, 0.009854171425104141, -0.024114757776260376, 0.02482706308364868, 0.03139674663543701, 0.04118070378899574, -0.028590569272637367, 0.0935613363981247, -0.017924468964338303, 0.007382113486528397, 0.02314629964530468, -0.013131367973983288, 0.10508154332637787, 0.03134211152791977, 0.023715779185295105, -0.04070509597659111, 0.003454340621829033, 0.03488178551197052, -0.009396926499903202, -0.02016746625304222, -0.012930524535477161, -0.02042938582599163, -0.0003462160821072757, 0.05669216811656952, 0.04886298254132271, 0.0029604765586555004, -0.010913804173469543, 0.03619266301393509, -0.04817875474691391, -0.038744714111089706, 0.009953401051461697, -0.022709818556904793, -0.02009712904691696, -0.0028557763434946537, -0.01188475452363491, 0.0231377724558115, 0.031465258449316025, 0.01298412773758173, -0.028439508751034737, 0.005597399547696114, 0.00032755424035713077, 0.03736729174852371, -0.04287604242563248, 0.004318044055253267, -0.003061038674786687, 0.043773166835308075, -0.01898963749408722, 0.010219014249742031, 0.010624222457408905, -0.041282519698143005, 0.011583421379327774, 0.04482433572411537, -0.010064564645290375, -0.01486875582486391, -0.0013885486405342817, 0.018753277137875557, -0.07147686928510666, -0.005184709560126066, -0.025662172585725784, -0.0111642275005579, -0.0177396759390831, -0.03412175923585892, -0.027898132801055908, 0.009450681507587433, -0.00543990358710289, -0.018980128690600395, -0.05249228700995445, 0.043817076832056046, 0.02742903120815754, -0.013085546903312206, -0.03277038782835007, -0.04742565378546715, 0.004397943150252104, -0.021883606910705566, 0.004423428792506456, 0.0177654679864645, -0.0030846083536744118, -0.010899334214627743, -0.05500922352075577, 0.07325457781553268, -0.032073378562927246, 0.02694650925695896, 0.01812434010207653, -0.011202900670468807, -0.025586441159248352, -0.021286772564053535, 0.0173069778829813, 0.0616629384458065, -0.014233840629458427, 0.0031942925415933132, -0.015336944721639156, -0.04389570653438568, 0.015968503430485725, 0.004920086823403835, -0.005411047954112291, 0.00048041119589470327, -0.053210824728012085, -0.004874526523053646, 0.014554918743669987, 0.007813135161995888, 0.037121061235666275, 0.028488395735621452, 0.02295316942036152, 0.012742341496050358, 0.04004765674471855, -0.049075331538915634, -0.034394748508930206, 0.01618671976029873, -0.04708894342184067, -0.0073274583555758, 0.003012751927599311, 0.0639796331524849, 0.06264742463827133, -0.017291385680437088, 0.0023630664218217134, 0.019716931506991386, -0.023391643539071083, 0.02068965695798397, 0.013048456981778145, -0.04883725941181183, 0.007428439799696207, -0.012263618409633636, 0.007641770876944065, 0.002940291306003928, 0.009469473734498024, -0.009493296034634113, -0.004909510724246502, 0.04336248338222504, -0.004490416031330824, -0.025980273261666298, 0.027423562481999397, -0.012043134309351444, 0.014680531807243824, -0.04927895963191986, 0.01627138815820217, -0.0430031418800354, 0.0030455312225967646, -0.011310689151287079, -0.012828420847654343, -0.0035536475479602814, -0.006509603001177311, -0.03690830618143082, 0.02419929951429367, 0.009251581504940987, -0.006808542180806398, 0.010945991612970829, -0.01663404330611229, 0.0019555503968149424, -0.009695964865386486, 0.0662737712264061, -0.028131375089287758, -0.040120065212249756, 0.039637740701436996, -0.027619963511824608, 0.007034053094685078, 0.005852965638041496, -0.015565415844321251, 0.05622144043445587, 0.0028267037123441696, -0.014170519076287746, -0.016041509807109833, 0.04931008815765381, -0.009305999614298344, -0.012372719123959541, 0.006770786829292774, -0.05309825390577316, 0.023898331448435783, -0.012428661808371544, 0.0017738366732373834, -0.006374340504407883, -0.015242280438542366, 0.026094047352671623, 0.08101797103881836, -0.018483465537428856, -0.017474863678216934, 0.026002388447523117, 0.01645570807158947, 0.006316922605037689, 0.023435069248080254, 0.003204595996066928, 0.02325534075498581, 0.01733044907450676, -0.02344479225575924, 0.03490392863750458, -0.00482932198792696, 0.04740750789642334, -0.05633288249373436, -0.014895474538207054, -0.03231421113014221, 0.02258177474141121, 0.011999210342764854, -0.06274101883172989, 0.007918189279735088, 0.007732309866696596, 0.00009092836990021169, 0.04416888579726219, -0.008837542496621609, 0.020198095589876175, -0.02643643133342266, 0.027624471113085747, -0.009707451798021793, 0.009998653084039688, 0.03149627149105072, 0.03237476572394371, 0.02635684236884117, 0.013193674385547638, 0.04097364842891693, -0.013282663188874722, -0.015469067730009556, 0.0004424382059369236, -0.0186773668974638, -0.030440056696534157, 0.01012971717864275, -0.03426579013466835, -0.024286990985274315, 0.03419653698801994, -0.0008504962315782905, 0.03910207748413086, 0.032155685126781464, -0.011806311085820198, 0.020913012325763702, 0.012065003626048565, 0.04254019632935524, -0.008892061188817024, -0.03939502686262131, 0.023592429235577583, 0.017973849549889565, 0.023521875962615013, 0.009175118990242481, 0.026172399520874023, 0.02439131774008274, -0.03505510464310646, -0.018026193603873253, 0.06766434013843536, -0.00408958550542593, 0.00758700305595994, -0.002449912717565894, -0.0014212786918506026, 0.0292072556912899, -0.015469217672944069, -0.02541368082165718, -0.02799694612622261, 0.008376030251383781, 0.0194967333227396, -0.015003942884504795, -0.0029660272412002087, -0.0034697912633419037, -0.0013475163141265512, -0.045210689306259155, 0.026453925296664238, -0.011233947239816189, 0.004623762797564268, -0.044136833399534225, -0.0025678365491330624, 0.019172465428709984, -0.0061589316464960575, -0.01658232882618904, 0.0009537061559967697, -0.045970115810632706, 0.03101014904677868, 0.007252890150994062, -0.0016819025622680783, 0.04389485716819763, -0.01243437547236681, -0.0062575857155025005, -0.08826147764921188, 0.06991853564977646, 0.010585560463368893, -0.031412433832883835, 0.009206426329910755, -0.01098879985511303, -0.05998845025897026, 0.019211530685424805, 0.05034184083342552, 0.04455144330859184, -0.02468014508485794, -0.029761578887701035, 0.011126679368317127, 0.01524551585316658, -0.038370031863451004, 0.00913276057690382, 0.020157795399427414, -0.008941602893173695, -0.029984531924128532, 0.01507721096277237, 0.006327656097710133, 0.01255551166832447, 0.01985214650630951, -0.016324013471603394, 0.0018159191822633147, -0.007261163089424372, -0.04128159210085869, 0.005495227407664061, 0.03305923938751221, 0.0006009733187966049, 0.07527150958776474, -0.012896185740828514, 0.018327787518501282, 0.02867722697556019, 0.02089841105043888, -0.03418542072176933, 0.036814942955970764, -0.03810670226812363, -0.005004406441003084, -0.017486529424786568, -0.032703835517168045, -0.021968873217701912, -0.032951559871435165, 0.011128653772175312, 0.037913672626018524, -0.02608799748122692, 0.019640116021037102, 0.022850869223475456, 0.040345460176467896, 0.04168190807104111, -0.06655418127775192, 0.024671658873558044, 0.019671114161610603, -0.011298896744847298, -0.0007949176360853016, 0.028745217248797417, 0.03509912267327309, 0.03848910704255104, 0.013252655044198036, 0.024692760780453682, 0.0008044927380979061, 0.005220883991569281, 0.0022260837722569704, 0.043410204350948334, -0.02629205211997032, -0.028196915984153748, 0.0319281704723835, 0.02985505200922489, 0.011134730651974678, 0.031505294144153595, -0.0007169590680859983, 0.02834317274391651, -0.03690529614686966, 0.003628242528066039, -0.06065751612186432, -0.0002805807744152844, -0.04514917731285095, -0.022977221757173538, -0.003978699445724487, 0.017577949911355972, -0.0007906941464170814, 0.018100779503583908, -0.011586670763790607, -0.0382300466299057, -0.027021968737244606, 0.004993201699107885, 0.015412754379212856, -0.0313400998711586, -0.02588523179292679, -0.002786034718155861, -0.026784192770719528, -0.01862124167382717, -0.0132697569206357, 0.05124109238386154, -0.005854867398738861, 0.0652088075876236, -0.035036686807870865, -0.030943429097533226, 0.008234445005655289, 0.013154773972928524, -0.03517511114478111, -0.05779185891151428, -0.021310653537511826, -0.0009894284885376692, 0.0017588152550160885, -0.05874381214380264 ]
<p>Let $f\left(x\right)$ be the probability density function of the random variable $X$. What is the joint probability distribution of $f_{X,Y}\left(x,y\right)$ if $Y=X$? </p> <p>Thanks for any helpful answer.</p>
74,200
[ -0.027904348447918892, 0.0025997385382652283, 0.029461020603775978, -0.025629455223679543, 0.006369066424667835, 0.016820959746837616, -0.01116276253014803, -0.033817142248153687, 0.03966381400823593, -0.015889503061771393, 0.06298051029443741, 0.046130869537591934, 0.07035040855407715, 0.008821644820272923, 0.04111667349934578, 0.009208510629832745, -0.026034101843833923, 0.01659407652914524, -0.009653582237660885, -0.00501072034239769, -0.0074012442491948605, 0.011979741044342518, 0.06879154592752457, -0.0059406873770058155, -0.020559653639793396, 0.04686018079519272, -0.002807343378663063, -0.015263720415532589, 0.05319428816437721, 0.08390885591506958, -0.05607758089900017, -0.04919559508562088, -0.00995061919093132, 0.0656546950340271, 0.0012616589665412903, 0.013429946266114712, -0.0331549309194088, -0.028805488720536232, -0.0013307846384122968, 0.0242067351937294, -0.06198325380682945, -0.03164844587445259, 0.03771396353840828, 0.02543036639690399, 0.003175147110596299, 0.023010658100247383, 0.022763242945075035, -0.038643285632133484, 0.04136300086975098, -0.03827320784330368, 0.11343416571617126, 0.0030428115278482437, 0.039686888456344604, 0.0183040052652359, -0.016002019867300987, -0.006671716924756765, 0.07147375494241714, 0.08274809271097183, 0.018025889992713928, -0.04405651241540909, -0.03844065219163895, -0.06839796900749207, -0.025662535801529884, -0.02994356118142605, -0.019184358417987823, 0.04207918792963028, -0.041454583406448364, -0.024565232917666435, -0.04083467274904251, 0.0031344727613031864, -0.020221775397658348, 0.05233991518616676, 0.07188446819782257, -0.02584698237478733, 0.027652502059936523, -0.0009215809986926615, 0.058304313570261, 0.020181985571980476, 0.026771221309900284, 0.0060831960290670395, 0.009891410358250141, 0.024500833824276924, 0.02982327900826931, -0.0013756626285612583, 0.014481505379080772, -0.014306847006082535, 0.08290635049343109, 0.00829312950372696, 0.019183222204446793, -0.012055279687047005, -0.01975097879767418, 0.001155436271801591, 0.03362317010760307, -0.0170469731092453, -0.03602065518498421, 0.04208343103528023, -0.02228381112217903, 0.021704083308577538, 0.0002566484035924077, -0.03352891653776169, 0.024438908323645592, -0.0483626127243042, 0.02348916046321392, 0.06555204838514328, -0.020858116447925568, 0.001186356064863503, -0.008851047605276108, 0.009516959078609943, -0.01107908133417368, 0.015845349058508873, -0.03329849988222122, 0.031253233551979065, -0.024380510672926903, -0.002274814760312438, 0.0677976980805397, 0.02798127755522728, 0.011928201653063297, -0.020805183798074722, 0.0524275116622448, 0.042472824454307556, 0.04703005030751228, -0.020873798057436943, 0.022757703438401222, -0.015313730575144291, -0.035298701375722885, 0.010673293843865395, 0.008720631711184978, 0.016235096380114555, -0.032406996935606, 0.049033667892217636, -0.03025933727622032, -0.028809785842895508, 0.014722559601068497, 0.014403141103684902, -0.017858557403087616, -0.01471948903053999, -0.054380424320697784, -0.0320855937898159, 0.02467893436551094, -0.01958097517490387, 0.009921146556735039, -0.07815524190664291, 0.015905456617474556, 0.021844111382961273, 0.0053811040706932545, -0.02910747565329075, 0.014282955788075924, -0.020515885204076767, 0.03189058601856232, -0.03254269063472748, -0.005285358987748623, -0.02461746335029602, 0.007850868627429008, -0.04942002147436142, 0.0104001360014081, -0.037197668105363846, 0.010766045190393925, 0.016917327418923378, -0.014581267721951008, -0.04540400207042694, 0.04635971784591675, 0.00042463885620236397, -0.02985784225165844, -0.015101678669452667, 0.024656519293785095, -0.05336092785000801, 0.05962425097823143, 0.030499299988150597, 0.03827128931879997, 0.035949889570474625, -0.01235147099941969, 0.029123831540346146, 0.032557521015405655, 0.055681195110082626, 0.0224885456264019, -0.04972610995173454, -0.048165373504161835, -0.016731658950448036, 0.020045025274157524, 0.006031029857695103, -0.01475669164210558, -0.000712161767296493, -0.04499903693795204, -0.0004937859484925866, 0.01810792088508606, 0.02541959658265114, 0.02723679132759571, -0.03234080225229263, -0.0032242031302303076, -0.0708760917186737, -0.01262202113866806, -0.05314638465642929, -0.014993011951446533, -0.03706960007548332, -0.03983847051858902, 0.018464118242263794, 0.04038272798061371, 0.020396031439304352, -0.03370921313762665, -0.011873586103320122, -0.031370583921670914, -0.007174808997660875, -0.01024316344410181, -0.014355362392961979, 0.012113898061215878, 0.04939964413642883, 0.06543751060962677, -0.004233050160109997, 0.03789154067635536, -0.03257917985320091, -0.03549947962164879, -0.0024978192523121834, -0.01140948198735714, 0.026009313762187958, -0.037080515176057816, -0.000906256667803973, 0.0049080271273851395, -0.005321364849805832, -0.0021271936129778624, -0.0018598431488499045, -0.05894475057721138, 0.018249191343784332, 0.0762571394443512, 0.007445451337844133, -0.0037957706954330206, 0.002940854523330927, 0.00500969123095274, 0.0026435123290866613, -0.018307438120245934, -0.024115506559610367, -0.060633715242147446, 0.013191407546401024, 0.023606278002262115, 0.033092349767684937, -0.021551160141825676, 0.031765107065439224, 0.03951183706521988, 0.020844653248786926, 0.01619572751224041, 0.0034360296558588743, -0.015988392755389214, -0.027082348242402077, -0.007302847225219011, 0.01683904603123665, 0.039286643266677856, 0.028103109449148178, 0.0008722516940906644, 0.01926751434803009, 0.038943465799093246, -0.011597596108913422, -0.046250928193330765, 0.06533689051866531, -0.02217680774629116, 0.03506573289632797, 0.024848010390996933, -0.027739061042666435, 0.00020544827566482127, -0.030135594308376312, -0.03178506717085838, 0.02622542902827263, 0.005105188582092524, -0.007986340671777725, 0.02860051766037941, -0.020773621276021004, 0.02168974094092846, 0.020447729155421257, -0.03483926132321358, -0.007820960134267807, 0.043896425515413284, -0.02864794246852398, 0.013875987380743027, 0.008072111755609512, -0.023671170696616173, 0.006335823331028223, -0.021835261955857277, 0.018567640334367752, -0.006707767955958843, 0.02637707069516182, -0.021300965920090675, -0.022538479417562485, -0.00809028372168541, -0.04312829673290253, 0.02378924749791622, -0.024195099249482155, -0.05054096505045891, 0.015247670002281666, -0.03846133500337601, -0.016837749630212784, 0.02546646259725094, -0.008245483972132206, -0.0024572843685746193, -0.011180027388036251, -0.04780028387904167, -0.07311016321182251, 0.005331707652658224, -0.035208798944950104, 0.029266487807035446, -0.052494458854198456, 0.01004686951637268, 0.044721297919750214, -0.010490148328244686, -0.031577218323946, -0.012367462739348412, -0.03145754709839821, -0.03326540067791939, -0.037101682275533676, 0.0043417587876319885, 0.03910684213042259, 0.015235720202326775, 0.02056290954351425, 0.02308345027267933, -0.03574351221323013, -0.004594651982188225, -0.060853131115436554, -0.046804528683423996, 0.0037056731525808573, 0.0027157729491591454, 0.030031457543373108, 0.0012086312053725123, -0.03473914414644241, 0.022828925400972366, 0.04726447910070419, -0.027449751272797585, 0.0013320090947672725, 0.014085808768868446, 0.023860182613134384, -0.008492403663694859, 0.029156049713492393, 0.011744248680770397, 0.018778014928102493, 0.03427349776029587, 0.02604886330664158, -0.012109436094760895, 0.04708462208509445, -0.021153826266527176, 0.014267505146563053, 0.026386786252260208, 0.015067298896610737, -0.01833929307758808, 0.018586156889796257, 0.004299678839743137, -0.013662142679095268, 0.01629604585468769, 0.0004444123478606343, 0.020949149504303932, -0.0004951253067702055, 0.024270182475447655, 0.04419473931193352, -0.0015230211429297924, -0.003940131980925798, -0.03724663332104683, 0.047502439469099045, 0.020400825887918472, -0.015441236086189747, -0.002473847707733512, -0.003946808632463217, 0.04853362590074539, -0.03032623790204525, 0.03916620463132858, 0.037438858300447464, 0.017836956307291985, -0.043745968490839005, -0.044662389904260635, -0.04177020490169525, 0.0024664881639182568, 0.057399895042181015, -0.015436354093253613, -0.04791943356394768, 0.018549436703324318, -0.0023558319080621004, 0.013795235194265842, -0.02932136133313179, -0.021148163825273514, 0.010664810426533222, -0.04732076823711395, -0.006888363044708967, 0.00526384124532342, 0.030845003202557564, 0.03078550286591053, 0.0691380426287651, 0.004966840613633394, 0.01018566731363535, 0.0017094463109970093, 0.007031640969216824, -0.07835589349269867, 0.011348797008395195, -0.02328992821276188, 0.023808971047401428, -0.03101412020623684, -0.02012438327074051, 0.03615957126021385, -0.006689343135803938, 0.011510636657476425, -0.0280276108533144, 0.004901187494397163, -0.0425717867910862, -0.0350581556558609, -0.02870331145823002, -0.05349452793598175, 0.0037130473647266626, 0.050293050706386566, 0.035672836005687714, -0.013302519917488098, 0.04460867494344711, 0.02653541974723339, -0.02009524218738079, -0.024240154772996902, -0.004757001996040344, -0.007729797158390284, 0.02648310549557209, 0.017720147967338562, -0.010179451666772366, 0.056317564100027084, -0.01773591712117195, 0.008007831871509552, -0.007396403234452009, 0.08085735142230988, 0.027555234730243683, -0.05368586257100105, -0.02076687477529049, -0.04632565751671791, -0.054658547043800354, -0.01867232657968998, 0.02259357087314129, -0.01646380126476288, 0.01916082575917244, 0.034315936267375946, 0.05503036081790924, -0.01594318449497223, 0.03547164797782898, 0.06171936169266701, 0.0396648645401001, -0.007668865844607353, -0.005048616789281368, 0.02282584086060524, -0.047305572777986526, 0.004927102942019701, 0.015408231876790524, 0.008774062618613243, -0.02215941622853279, -0.008349671959877014, 0.040517110377550125, 0.029266929253935814, -0.006957773584872484, -0.009778227657079697, -0.016573797911405563, 0.012687375769019127, 0.004203073214739561, -0.0404413565993309, 0.029524456709623337, 0.05593148618936539, 0.007246595341712236, 0.03119339793920517, -0.010043220594525337, -0.02042052522301674, 0.02769484557211399, 0.062820665538311, 0.002637081081047654, -0.036055974662303925, 0.008412372320890427, -0.019586047157645226, -0.017785338684916496, 0.039602186530828476, -0.010948274284601212, 0.007866502739489079, -0.0007413500570692122, 0.003494454314932227, 0.03508066385984421, -0.008866670541465282, -0.060691554099321365, 0.021567659452557564, 0.0008570791687816381, 0.019711587578058243, -0.007578930351883173, 0.0019388062646612525, -0.04932131990790367, 0.018166719004511833, 0.024523576721549034, 0.06112689897418022, -0.0017316710436716676, -0.03262494131922722, -0.0014712007250636816, 0.03089379332959652, 0.022630412131547928, -0.07869476824998856, 0.05198560655117035, 0.0008704247302375734, -0.01896955817937851, 0.03350533917546272, -0.020791100338101387, -0.049495842307806015, 0.01758773811161518, -0.0234410110861063, 0.00043071946129202843, 0.08114276826381683, -0.0012787329033017159, 0.01956951431930065, 0.044967107474803925, 0.01990913599729538, 0.03748608008027077, 0.0039922380819916725, -0.009579954668879509, -0.022700047120451927, -0.010735535062849522, 0.01876777783036232, -0.058291126042604446, -0.01570325531065464, -0.021547287702560425, 0.014890400692820549, -0.016349254176020622, 0.005115257576107979, -0.02358999475836754, 0.01039847917854786, -0.027123885229229927, -0.02045489102602005, -0.02094549871981144, 0.010272547602653503, 0.013446144759654999, 0.0200888030230999, -0.035655464977025986, 0.003506238106638193, 0.014570552855730057, -0.013417229056358337, 0.008176080882549286, -0.010051124729216099, -0.003940264228731394, 0.0023469924926757812, -0.01830069161951542, 0.013556544668972492, -0.04769562557339668, -0.02133648656308651, 0.015386542305350304, -0.00629619462415576, 0.03233383595943451, -0.016949854791164398, 0.02280854806303978, 0.028572965413331985, -0.06219286099076271, -0.02477071061730385, 0.03926056995987892, 0.04137475788593292, 0.05137278512120247, -0.02179119922220707, 0.02672717534005642, -0.018787577748298645, -0.027920296415686607, -0.08942469209432602, -0.05817948654294014, 0.007316725794225931, -0.0030416161753237247, -0.006830166094005108, -0.045251209288835526, 0.051606450229883194, -0.02395666390657425, -0.031383488327264786, -0.02407296746969223, 0.04307284206151962, -0.010431681759655476, -0.023075532168149948, -0.01394460815936327, -0.06014515459537506, 0.04866154491901398, 0.008569585159420967, 0.004463136661797762, 0.024877697229385376, -0.010138023644685745, 0.005400964990258217, -0.022850442677736282, 0.03468913957476616, -0.01941853016614914, 0.015537422150373459, 0.003177604405209422, -0.06577932834625244, 0.03384363651275635, -0.035511862486600876, 0.01110265962779522, 0.025050237774848938, 0.033370986580848694, -0.02690870873630047, 0.007255216594785452, 0.006685534026473761, -0.02242851071059704, -0.015235071070492268, -0.011051018722355366, -0.008714184165000916, -0.0034320196136832237, -0.021739963442087173, 0.02596265636384487, -0.0219944529235363, -0.022136297076940536, 0.029360756278038025, 0.09189414978027344, -0.00456016743555665, -0.017349673435091972, -0.007730979472398758, 0.009448717348277569, 0.037763383239507675, -0.008845742791891098, -0.02037634514272213, 0.026738904416561127, 0.02598710171878338, -0.04908157140016556, 0.00864969752728939, -0.06130289286375046, -0.02472935989499092, 0.06371907889842987, -0.04524284228682518, 0.05106126517057419, 0.04850699380040169, 0.02446766570210457, 0.028044743463397026, -0.00812053307890892, 0.001470794202759862, -0.009406904689967632, -0.013072432018816471, 0.02300381474196911, -0.010907596908509731, -0.007376146037131548, 0.05251399800181389, 0.006332787219434977, 0.007621551398187876, 0.041829850524663925, -0.011865438893437386, 0.021245447918772697, 0.040707703679800034, -0.02970650978386402, -0.06335841119289398, -0.0019197501242160797, -0.04363526403903961, 0.002861304674297571, -0.015510509721934795, -0.046508949249982834, 0.04941016063094139, 0.01548055186867714, 0.004055358003824949, -0.022367268800735474, -0.0074913352727890015, -0.007885178551077843, -0.002689302433282137, -0.0050796992145478725, 0.04369717463850975, 0.03126586601138115, 0.042390864342451096, 0.03317009285092354, -0.014652103185653687, 0.029135558754205704, -0.013693337328732014, -0.06049000844359398, -0.02916349470615387, -0.003407810116186738, -0.027819031849503517, 0.013443296775221825, -0.008367159403860569, -0.03777347505092621, 0.013132418505847454, -0.027313394472002983, -0.011799382977187634, -0.009663255885243416, 0.04590876027941704, -0.03191845118999481, 0.08488763123750687, -0.013285390101373196, 0.05380629375576973, -0.023941924795508385, 0.0073375883512198925, 0.0956805869936943, 0.03500834107398987, 0.048351455479860306, -0.05464882776141167, 0.009461342357099056, -0.04048841446638107, -0.04000860080122948, -0.04027121141552925, 0.02578669600188732, 0.043531183153390884, 0.030671026557683945, 0.05256272107362747, 0.020455986261367798, 0.012988967821002007, -0.01697591133415699, 0.03351110965013504, -0.018421117216348648, -0.02437598444521427, -0.004762010183185339, 0.016486477106809616, -0.016039066016674042, -0.00947221927344799, -0.048334430903196335, -0.029599864035844803, -0.014329247176647186, -0.009644433856010437, -0.028705021366477013, -0.04698822647333145, 0.016153773292899132, -0.006534944754093885, -0.01992623135447502, -0.009751065634191036, 0.04692098870873451, -0.020602788776159286, -0.02122100070118904, 0.008963853120803833, 0.010907881893217564, -0.02845948375761509, -0.020138410851359367, 0.05558764189481735, 0.0032294427510350943, 0.005972887389361858, 0.013329649344086647, -0.010444540530443192, -0.023939862847328186, -0.024769172072410583, -0.042501453310251236, 0.026239749044179916, 0.008355822414159775, 0.01700522191822529, -0.013893106952309608, 0.013152996078133583, -0.007534233387559652, -0.02951047196984291, 0.0009572949493303895, 0.021103788167238235, 0.051249101758003235, -0.01921895146369934, -0.018814431503415108, -0.045818399637937546, 0.04343008995056152, -0.03309294581413269, 0.018727147951722145, 0.03057035803794861, -0.034821752458810806, 0.012906767427921295, 0.01288947556167841, 0.052321068942546844, 0.03919495269656181, 0.004331366624683142, -0.024820880964398384, -0.030787575989961624, -0.0009663808159530163, -0.04680225998163223, 0.04465518146753311, -0.0017275300342589617, 0.030849827453494072, 0.022231807932257652, -0.0014196400297805667, -0.01499533373862505, -0.0692308098077774, 0.04012998566031456, 0.016067495569586754, -0.00038229991332627833, -0.03260231018066406, -0.01400809083133936, 0.03399255499243736, 0.03223107382655144, 0.017465952783823013, -0.014036551117897034, -0.03651439771056175, 0.027260376140475273, 0.02200760692358017, -0.031209589913487434, 0.003958703018724918, 0.020583895966410637, 0.007634242530912161, -0.01518124807626009, -0.04779710993170738, 0.04046805948019028, 0.03918086364865303, 0.052676063030958176, 0.008215067908167839, 0.01939137652516365, -0.007690319791436195, 0.031133968383073807, 0.005488406401127577, -0.041893817484378815, -0.005027550272643566, 0.009291043505072594, 0.013720011338591576, -0.017737768590450287, -0.02606980688869953, 0.004109455272555351, 0.0007603344274684787, 0.013274475000798702, -0.008362237364053726, -0.014490284025669098, -0.0506131686270237, -0.010655811987817287, 0.03218759223818779, 0.004313943907618523, -0.005780898034572601, -0.025285670533776283, -0.010437988676130772, 0.03907450661063194, -0.01851767487823963, -0.02965112403035164, 0.008806477300822735, 0.022686513140797615, -0.008764519356191158, 0.011336270719766617, -0.0075116525404155254, 0.028614087030291557, 0.0028301523998379707, 0.0409291610121727, -0.01606139726936817, 0.0336000993847847, -0.01882534846663475, 0.015871737152338028, 0.05777272582054138, -0.052793193608522415, -0.013219627551734447, 0.016613371670246124, 0.02809881418943405, 0.04630350321531296, 0.015995759516954422, 0.007198899053037167, -0.03703803941607475, 0.04574105143547058, -0.0422939658164978, 0.006036085542291403, -0.01649673469364643, 0.023730609565973282, 0.019806968048214912, 0.026323659345507622, -0.032565418630838394, -0.023734072223305702, 0.008319362066686153, 0.0071666045114398, 0.02605476602911949, -0.013616383075714111, -0.003456952515989542, 0.04615924507379532, 0.024927794933319092, -0.011277781799435616, -0.006047799717634916, 0.004994574002921581, 0.02478732354938984, 0.02940499223768711, -0.005791008472442627, 0.016854707151651382, -0.009865451604127884, 0.021127715706825256, -0.10028860718011856, -0.04326769709587097, 0.031038226559758186, -0.02213873714208603, 0.041190408170223236, -0.06169172376394272, -0.05253036320209503, 0.03338203951716423, -0.06273500621318817, 0.0033470450434833765, 0.03294963762164116, -0.004394081421196461, -0.029473328962922096, 0.006041035056114197, -0.01325824111700058, 0.08072614669799805, -0.012456538155674934, 0.05404125154018402, 0.021956462413072586, 0.0404757522046566, -0.020091069862246513, -0.000690820103045553, -0.01294779870659113, 0.013006011955440044, -0.003778396174311638, -0.030178913846611977, 0.08652117848396301, -0.02071085013449192, -0.029806550592184067, 0.038081977516412735, 0.04509839415550232, -0.008433636277914047, -0.024070288985967636, -0.0024691238068044186, 0.021276136860251427, 0.02725159376859665, 0.012673350982367992, -0.01877516880631447, -0.0051683527417480946, 0.03060954250395298, 0.002132726600393653, 0.03547190502285957, -0.04963201656937599, -0.016403278335928917, 0.018598657101392746, -0.03074324131011963, -0.06357507407665253, 0.01721680909395218, -0.00609816936776042, -0.041163623332977295, 0.0080874627456069, -0.026521380990743637, 0.02314949594438076, -0.02667522057890892, 0.033859383314847946, -0.0267619751393795, -0.02997017279267311, 0.009695909917354584, -0.008497008122503757, -0.004359476733952761, 0.023981207981705666, 0.010319920256733894, -0.04257453605532646, 0.02103220671415329, -0.022041693329811096, -0.0011643683537840843, -0.048587583005428314, -0.007274962496012449, 0.012369494885206223, 0.00899387989193201, 0.013838903047144413, -0.043594155460596085, -0.05705730617046356, 0.009942938573658466, -0.028150588274002075, -0.004111929330974817, 0.0336758978664875, -0.034984007477760315, -0.03985462337732315, -0.046993982046842575, 0.034830570220947266, 0.048164427280426025, -0.05506666749715805, -0.04275979846715927, 0.00540551170706749, -0.02447197027504444, -0.05310206487774849, 0.019462022930383682, 0.014830579981207848, -0.008169442415237427, -0.021612895652651787, 0.051170069724321365, 0.047479625791311264, -0.08169881999492645, 0.00020671187667176127, -0.028582856059074402, -0.016246745362877846, -0.02526831068098545, 0.003271934576332569, -0.0016027308302000165, 0.0035159543622285128, -0.0002991778892464936, -0.026302717626094818, 0.011444298550486565, 0.0002985685132443905, -0.0018260030774399638, 0.015320719219744205, 0.014355690218508244, 0.026864279061555862, 0.06411022692918777, 0.004905094392597675, 0.007056521251797676, 0.003637484973296523, -0.0018723062239587307, -0.05937465652823448, -0.009649205952882767, -0.03368881717324257, -0.02535644918680191, -0.014942328445613384, 0.015533323399722576, -0.009282389655709267, -0.05530909076333046, -0.015108326449990273, 0.03442474827170372, -0.07170368731021881, -0.016684668138623238, 0.029725132510066032, 0.04029029980301857, 0.048421524465084076, -0.007987909950315952, -0.005533309653401375, -0.0054153865203261375, -0.023424232378602028, 0.024007314816117287, -0.03193417191505432, 0.012856993824243546, -0.0251714289188385, 0.0031369200441986322, 0.016515037044882774, -0.02338172309100628, 0.06700761616230011, 0.008812001906335354, 0.039421599358320236, -0.022053251042962074, 0.0021928497590124607, 0.029622351750731468, 0.003694801591336727, 0.0033097926061600447, -0.0002463879354763776, -0.015367187559604645, 0.05045555159449577, -0.024527285248041153, -0.000599588907789439, -0.037575121968984604, -0.006580579560250044, -0.04713349789381027, -0.00869421660900116, 0.07223430275917053, 0.03932968154549599, -0.028810715302824974, -0.0025023685302585363, 0.007822680287063122, -0.030229762196540833, 0.02475735731422901, -0.02713744156062603, 0.0163609366863966, -0.020260484889149666, 0.008661762811243534, -0.014781196601688862, -0.0049892934039235115, -0.019526535645127296, -0.03211534023284912, 0.030567636713385582, 0.047637052834033966, 0.019530273973941803, -0.0055839261040091515, 0.007541307248175144, -0.013534534722566605, 0.07555168867111206, -0.06937208026647568, -0.005886573810130358, -0.04489820823073387, 0.023531459271907806, 0.042794208973646164, -0.01799333468079567 ]
<p>I have data for multiple people, where each person performs and is graded on a task an arbitrary number of times each year across multiple years. E.g. - </p> <pre><code> year 1 year 2 year 3 Person1 1 1 3 2 4 2 3 3 5 2 3 4 1 Person2 2 3 1 7 9 1 2 3 3 1 Person3 ... </code></pre> <p>So in year 1, person 1 does the task 5 times and gets scores 1 1 3 2 4. I take the mean for each person in each year: </p> <pre><code> year 1 year 2 year 3 Person1 2.2 2.7 3 Person2 2 4.75 2.3 Person3 ... </code></pre> <p>How do I test for a significant difference between people in the means for each year? I assume that I could do a repeated measures ANOVA on the means, but this ignores the number of measurements per person per year. For example, for person 1 in year1, there are 5 measurements compared to 3 for person2 in year1, making the former measurement more certain. In general, some people can have far more measurements than other people across all years. Thanks.</p>
36,938
[ -0.018924109637737274, -0.0012967803049832582, -0.03180563822388649, -0.004557634703814983, 0.03315786272287369, 0.02961207740008831, 0.0032666767947375774, -0.014944139868021011, -0.00006281081004999578, -0.005651968065649271, 0.07003478705883026, 0.008804858662188053, 0.04896833747625351, -0.0047250911593437195, 0.035085804760456085, -0.02810361422598362, -0.014649292454123497, -0.02403557114303112, -0.006881881505250931, 0.004450644366443157, -0.04922475293278694, 0.0070549482479691505, 0.024606499820947647, -0.05415165051817894, -0.03778534010052681, 0.020082077011466026, 0.024641793221235275, -0.02851187065243721, 0.0005364235257729888, 0.038972076028585434, -0.027384363114833832, -0.0238250233232975, 0.0021497190464287996, 0.01824170909821987, 0.022266920655965805, -0.019453026354312897, -0.035906028002500534, -0.019324742257595062, 0.035103682428598404, 0.03254103660583496, -0.01850622333586216, -0.0022244637366384268, -0.015616402961313725, 0.03417482599616051, -0.004293583799153566, 0.03148646280169487, -0.014804096892476082, 0.008101405575871468, 0.05480366200208664, -0.041247859597206116, 0.0781279057264328, 0.022011956200003624, 0.07842995971441269, 0.01694229245185852, -0.04160764813423157, -0.019396737217903137, 0.01856088452041149, 0.07553475350141525, 0.013357331976294518, -0.054963383823633194, -0.029423788189888, -0.031559158116579056, -0.0015658341581001878, 0.01650901325047016, -0.0436147004365921, 0.006349016912281513, -0.04117651283740997, -0.04562346637248993, 0.04912692680954933, -0.030930161476135254, 0.0031714204233139753, 0.0009082669275812805, 0.05103176832199097, -0.011721555143594742, -0.001609433558769524, -0.0008759887423366308, 0.022860132157802582, -0.030527101829648018, 0.06121641770005226, 0.05862196534872055, -0.028072716668248177, 0.011355588212609291, 0.02969217486679554, 0.014950640499591827, 0.034650012850761414, -0.05031055212020874, 0.05776266008615494, -0.04107068479061127, -0.03094824217259884, 0.04614809527993202, -0.021415889263153076, -0.013753821142017841, 0.036239366978406906, 0.03602718561887741, -0.025678634643554688, 0.025889350101351738, -0.012128069996833801, 0.007921842858195305, 0.0029963557608425617, 0.02274813875555992, -0.014061219058930874, -0.0431508868932724, 0.03486565127968788, 0.011685322038829327, -0.019825037568807602, 0.006375085096806288, -0.006008340511471033, -0.005568853113800287, -0.01350440178066492, 0.0024102525785565376, 0.007981102913618088, -0.0003196655889041722, 0.013697351329028606, -0.007558929268270731, 0.05285792052745819, -0.0198028776794672, -0.027839621528983116, -0.019345179200172424, 0.077570840716362, 0.05467779189348221, 0.027852607890963554, -0.01690136454999447, 0.010725600644946098, -0.04004358872771263, -0.008238371461629868, 0.0016170126618817449, -0.01679549179971218, -0.021600019186735153, 0.0032647144980728626, 0.06560561805963516, -0.01765567623078823, -0.0068632010370492935, 0.048457738012075424, -0.02207127958536148, 0.026845591142773628, 0.008659006096422672, -0.08782672882080078, -0.06697738170623779, 0.02872762456536293, -0.010874073952436447, -0.0047761243768036366, -0.054741766303777695, 0.016557669267058372, -0.010736304335296154, 0.05400862917304039, 0.04771406948566437, 0.019840160384774208, 0.0008895157370716333, 0.01753750629723072, 0.046489521861076355, -0.015981100499629974, -0.006361191160976887, -0.006354684941470623, -0.028599407523870468, -0.022353438660502434, -0.10156689584255219, 0.0017994947265833616, 0.003961123526096344, -0.0015691907610744238, 0.011265317909419537, 0.02407360076904297, 0.024140221998095512, -0.00957926269620657, 0.0056188455782830715, 0.01952008344233036, -0.03160487115383148, 0.08520427346229553, 0.007885688915848732, 0.048650745302438736, 0.039555829018354416, 0.003931939601898193, 0.036267511546611786, -0.01106960978358984, 0.033714715391397476, 0.048848673701286316, -0.019130263477563858, 0.01353712659329176, 0.02242438495159149, 0.00040610923315398395, 0.026778031140565872, -0.016782062128186226, -0.02972075715661049, -0.05305728688836098, -0.0073796105571091175, 0.030773043632507324, 0.030139746144413948, -0.016570700332522392, -0.006184353958815336, 0.03096073493361473, -0.03805338963866234, -0.040977220982313156, -0.08593491464853287, 0.007497888989746571, 0.026998206973075867, -0.03282012790441513, 0.025169972330331802, -0.015489877201616764, 0.026236597448587418, 0.00488482229411602, -0.02813713811337948, -0.01883728988468647, -0.010900996625423431, 0.04305271804332733, -0.04294730722904205, -0.0014886498684063554, 0.038677878677845, 0.09226041287183762, 0.012005853466689587, 0.1018410250544548, -0.05330578610301018, -0.012514591217041016, 0.024060584604740143, -0.04064982756972313, -0.0003942355397157371, 0.009097418747842312, 0.004474283196032047, -0.004817553795874119, -0.010358341969549656, -0.015932025387883186, 0.04395574703812599, -0.036274734884500504, 0.09394744038581848, 0.0627715140581131, -0.014565887860953808, -0.009889761917293072, -0.03347388654947281, 0.024137550964951515, 0.016254356130957603, -0.018264412879943848, -0.02612043172121048, -0.05652295798063278, -0.032096318900585175, 0.003356693312525749, 0.020069850608706474, -0.02316274121403694, 0.049328554421663284, 0.04681896045804024, 0.015570913441479206, -0.024087682366371155, 0.010279212146997452, 0.010754173621535301, 0.02927553839981556, 0.029607119038701057, 0.03080613538622856, 0.03521707281470299, 0.022337695583701134, 0.044085778295993805, 0.03095666505396366, 0.04381123557686806, 0.036683339625597, 0.034930016845464706, 0.011704388074576855, 0.002215203596279025, 0.01249290443956852, 0.0188291072845459, -0.024080906063318253, 0.01472481433302164, -0.004902377258986235, -0.025546811521053314, 0.05020786076784134, 0.0016605538548901677, -0.031604647636413574, 0.0006095308344811201, -0.038880541920661926, 0.0038331905379891396, 0.04154333472251892, -0.024678997695446014, -0.0011966839665547013, 0.011770347133278847, 0.002304689260199666, 0.04323221743106842, -0.02351108193397522, -0.006839382462203503, -0.035226013511419296, 0.027292586863040924, 0.0010865803342312574, -0.017273137345910072, 0.02068004012107849, -0.00955387856811285, -0.013984810560941696, 0.007680403999984264, -0.04793234169483185, 0.031226173043251038, -0.008028012700378895, -0.05818021297454834, -0.0008394831093028188, 0.01161187794059515, -0.0019159972434863448, 0.0453193224966526, -0.011199939996004105, -0.011561036109924316, 0.06502783298492432, -0.002439458854496479, -0.03420869633555412, -0.02551046572625637, -0.024259330704808235, 0.009634075686335564, 0.0029823535587638617, 0.005657005589455366, 0.06421121209859848, 0.023613521829247475, -0.024759845808148384, 0.001956403022632003, -0.03755642846226692, -0.010842755436897278, 0.0069764284417033195, -0.019692571833729744, 0.008116381242871284, 0.0005372312152758241, 0.013700808398425579, 0.027650782838463783, -0.02449345588684082, -0.020252831280231476, -0.05706304311752319, -0.051105767488479614, 0.024758560582995415, 0.017245890572667122, 0.02288231812417507, -0.011085545644164085, -0.006407599896192551, 0.04281364008784294, 0.0432572066783905, -0.014217552728950977, -0.054969098418951035, 0.019402481615543365, 0.008661575615406036, -0.01737719401717186, 0.02806319110095501, 0.021046632900834084, -0.036073192954063416, 0.02397521771490574, 0.031004127115011215, -0.01884853094816208, 0.04299785941839218, 0.023536643013358116, 0.010991109535098076, 0.0038196523673832417, 0.02961445041000843, -0.02487577497959137, 0.03984029218554497, 0.01432416494935751, -0.050199851393699646, -0.008324888534843922, 0.012937812134623528, 0.014904677867889404, -0.008154220879077911, -0.00856749713420868, 0.014045429416000843, -0.04805920273065567, 0.009264611639082432, -0.04331570863723755, 0.00970375444740057, 0.02813495695590973, -0.015774289146065712, -0.012212937697768211, 0.00529265683144331, -0.02253502607345581, -0.015915658324956894, -0.02498716488480568, 0.005216705147176981, 0.005961088463664055, 0.006472238339483738, 0.0063749621622264385, -0.040981587022542953, -0.01099303923547268, 0.0022346375044435263, -0.03794680908322334, -0.01999107375741005, 0.029614755883812904, 0.02843649871647358, 0.015862690284848213, 0.003229089779779315, -0.05300689861178398, 0.011877277866005898, -0.04649384319782257, 0.01814068853855133, -0.031284160912036896, 0.0652882307767868, 0.0008505069999955595, 0.015541233122348785, 0.02473163977265358, -0.023279890418052673, 0.0019666363950818777, -0.047431573271751404, -0.03913535550236702, 0.019858045503497124, 0.01158234104514122, -0.027230633422732353, 0.029842866584658623, -0.012803326360881329, 0.016773968935012817, -0.04407436400651932, 0.03778190165758133, 0.006870143581181765, 0.03245770186185837, -0.001327825360931456, -0.034448254853487015, -0.029930751770734787, -0.018519975244998932, -0.009918383322656155, 0.008989197202026844, 0.024297239258885384, -0.03977716341614723, 0.03702212870121002, -0.00665884418413043, -0.017265552654862404, -0.03300938010215759, -0.04694069176912308, 0.00005734910155297257, 0.00887556467205286, 0.035362087190151215, 0.011696229688823223, 0.045679692178964615, -0.020289897918701172, 0.034791115671396255, 0.019003411754965782, 0.01685531623661518, 0.040810294449329376, 0.016743727028369904, -0.02930266596376896, -0.00825774297118187, -0.014939343556761742, 0.03388997167348862, 0.030010785907506943, 0.028195494785904884, 0.008806898258626461, -0.006944667082279921, 0.05272802710533142, -0.0697174221277237, -0.0013474954757839441, 0.08292167633771896, -0.0029793977737426758, -0.014057432301342487, -0.02870798483490944, -0.006142029073089361, 0.005699809640645981, -0.01242957916110754, 0.00873552542179823, 0.04921631142497063, 0.012509041465818882, 0.02497471496462822, 0.030619753524661064, -0.0005815252079628408, -0.02642372064292431, 0.01087344903498888, -0.0019344546599313617, 0.04084280878305435, -0.011568475514650345, 0.0008955340017564595, 0.014601366594433784, 0.007482917048037052, 0.038232386112213135, 0.010629852302372456, 0.006673513446003199, -0.09710182994604111, 0.015274307690560818, 0.07114097476005554, 0.05877998471260071, -0.05379805713891983, 0.0035861493088304996, 0.0011449683224782348, 0.010635370388627052, 0.05678338184952736, -0.03694432973861694, 0.036289069801568985, -0.012915336526930332, 0.012256600894033909, -0.03804735466837883, -0.012631836347281933, -0.04778384789824486, 0.020501138642430305, -0.033267293125391006, 0.01702822372317314, 0.022554973140358925, -0.0375642403960228, -0.048758186399936676, -0.013158218935132027, 0.025271501392126083, 0.05998450517654419, -0.029525693506002426, -0.016980603337287903, 0.010158644989132881, 0.020599104464054108, -0.007242504041641951, -0.0387401208281517, 0.042959731072187424, -0.008597989566624165, -0.028145017102360725, 0.03301520273089409, -0.026821933686733246, -0.0214985441416502, 0.0206951554864645, -0.007273143157362938, -0.0013408591039478779, -0.01648249290883541, -0.007432241924107075, 0.05636116862297058, 0.009176219813525677, 0.0027689950075000525, 0.06185668334364891, 0.02400573529303074, 0.0033318570349365473, 0.043912969529628754, -0.055964015424251556, -0.005881621036678553, -0.011252696625888348, 0.002587704686447978, -0.012671994976699352, -0.023896336555480957, -0.008653509430587292, 0.022305067628622055, -0.0005477249505929649, 0.018785757943987846, -0.0262202937155962, -0.008135964162647724, 0.01481662131845951, 0.007786717731505632, 0.031008392572402954, -0.01218678429722786, 0.0416758693754673, 0.015276730991899967, 0.0010598594089969993, -0.011159011162817478, 0.013984874822199345, -0.0041350107640028, -0.015543687157332897, -0.03979780524969101, -0.03595093637704849, 0.02645852603018284, -0.021755503490567207, -0.03558409959077835, 0.005972274113446474, -0.03160625323653221, 0.014574122615158558, -0.03735194727778435, 0.04086693748831749, 0.0129087558016181, -0.019367821514606476, -0.01624932698905468, 0.02147391438484192, -0.03092237561941147, 0.021808676421642303, -0.032561853528022766, 0.03982456773519516, -0.03781379759311676, -0.007193917874246836, -0.03639523684978485, -0.024496275931596756, 0.028954658657312393, 0.030447261407971382, 0.02045767940580845, 0.0006061779567971826, -0.03449275717139244, -0.01679104007780552, 0.0008343578083440661, -0.039132095873355865, 0.06660962104797363, -0.01855413056910038, -0.012867980636656284, 0.0025225786957889795, 0.033540330827236176, 0.07938028872013092, 0.012500577606260777, 0.0037929005920886993, 0.0005768656264990568, -0.028636621311306953, -0.038071535527706146, -0.029996782541275024, -0.010144665837287903, -0.048785533756017685, -0.028718050569295883, -0.021526603028178215, 0.030852964147925377, 0.07542980462312698, -0.04913118854165077, -0.019607799127697945, -0.006325297523289919, -0.036817245185375214, 0.008552460931241512, -0.04277943819761276, 0.014558208175003529, -0.03477068245410919, 0.0070919860154390335, -0.053204089403152466, 0.01991559937596321, -0.00004093877214472741, -0.009575841017067432, 0.03888968005776405, 0.03139117732644081, -0.034746285527944565, -0.015741348266601562, 0.05487078055739403, -0.0225038081407547, -0.006995580159127712, 0.0025720372796058655, -0.010045760311186314, 0.03008796088397503, -0.0024131471291184425, -0.032196756452322006, -0.002142115728929639, 0.012573802843689919, -0.05253887549042702, 0.014407905749976635, -0.020166832953691483, -0.0375615619122982, 0.05198559910058975, 0.019647672772407532, 0.023516103625297546, 0.10110781341791153, -0.015613697469234467, 0.01894364319741726, -0.013911972753703594, -0.023695530369877815, -0.0017541092820465565, 0.010389193892478943, 0.06125733256340027, -0.026371309533715248, -0.008614650927484035, 0.030761385336518288, -0.006693028379231691, 0.0217447392642498, 0.04927341639995575, 0.0023466800339519978, 0.01900077983736992, 0.0385860800743103, -0.028887085616588593, -0.029422948136925697, 0.04045852646231651, -0.0406334362924099, -0.0004262325819581747, -0.03469602391123772, 0.016611240804195404, 0.015653317794203758, 0.052564069628715515, -0.03602878004312515, -0.053704384714365005, -0.05254393815994263, -0.06329834461212158, 0.019691675901412964, 0.04811654984951019, -0.02168256975710392, 0.019458506256341934, 0.001100504887290299, 0.041064951568841934, 0.010908964090049267, -0.011843254789710045, -0.05055580660700798, -0.040074363350868225, -0.033808182924985886, -0.026022830978035927, -0.034736521542072296, 0.04101190343499184, 0.01381444651633501, -0.021659165620803833, -0.009631520137190819, -0.034841492772102356, 0.011698158457875252, 0.021355627104640007, 0.04356849566102028, -0.00005094978405395523, 0.064662404358387, 0.001307029859162867, 0.025585440918803215, 0.010545925237238407, 0.009788076393306255, 0.1215766966342926, 0.07637622952461243, 0.028859969228506088, -0.04450695961713791, 0.03797765076160431, 0.027354316785931587, -0.016687769442796707, -0.01253441721200943, 0.0036175926215946674, -0.0028691894840449095, -0.009714284911751747, 0.0371624194085598, 0.05284636467695236, 0.019778095185756683, 0.015196245163679123, 0.07636123895645142, -0.01801110990345478, -0.0008615893311798573, 0.01913374848663807, -0.01202373206615448, -0.00473810825496912, -0.014730789698660374, -0.03533109650015831, 0.0034299425315111876, 0.029168421402573586, -0.0041587562300264835, -0.025289148092269897, -0.025311024859547615, -0.011750445701181889, 0.00824772659689188, -0.00883266981691122, 0.034340888261795044, 0.0015112165128812194, 0.01030639372766018, 0.0038887723349034786, -0.011362971737980843, 0.0266795065253973, -0.04180799052119255, 0.011951452121138573, 0.01752125658094883, 0.007604236714541912, -0.028634365648031235, -0.03017832525074482, 0.019660815596580505, -0.027707479894161224, -0.051073357462882996, -0.014186665415763855, 0.026362869888544083, -0.002093056682497263, -0.046899598091840744, -0.008449993096292019, -0.00496986648067832, -0.03244811296463013, -0.02926536276936531, -0.0471106581389904, 0.027759505435824394, 0.022440660744905472, -0.039445146918296814, 0.006331917364150286, 0.0017781073693186045, -0.024008164182305336, -0.02680378407239914, 0.02549772337079048, 0.01815708912909031, -0.013594180345535278, -0.01447436586022377, -0.058880627155303955, 0.02275984361767769, -0.008181474171578884, -0.033829472959041595, 0.02553228661417961, -0.01507099624723196, -0.013579505495727062, 0.0043954188004136086, 0.006464625243097544, 0.011166488751769066, 0.03373762592673302, -0.017257627099752426, -0.004376158583909273, -0.01751917600631714, -0.021759429946541786, 0.0006815793458372355, -0.014013377018272877, 0.0016855201683938503, -0.04440134018659592, -0.008965506218373775, 0.0506109818816185, 0.03259890154004097, 0.02216414362192154, -0.005522018764168024, 0.0030866223387420177, 0.05685708299279213, 0.039738286286592484, -0.05175883322954178, -0.014529259875416756, -0.0027046033646911383, -0.03910535201430321, -0.02359802834689617, -0.03806830570101738, 0.0804055854678154, 0.04941581189632416, -0.0048825861886143684, -0.0026126387529075146, 0.03300674632191658, -0.037232257425785065, 0.005033088382333517, 0.0026691292878240347, -0.05794136971235275, -0.02825333923101425, -0.022787468507885933, 0.01205118466168642, -0.02901320531964302, -0.021547822281718254, -0.07102195918560028, -0.023990977555513382, 0.02307770773768425, 0.002280679764226079, -0.002402297919616103, -0.005844608414918184, -0.001803610590286553, 0.002242735354229808, -0.06199151650071144, -0.013700651004910469, -0.0363457128405571, -0.011993473395705223, 0.01808270998299122, 0.017978157848119736, -0.02293890155851841, 0.007934601046144962, -0.02438739687204361, 0.008852842263877392, 0.040945760905742645, -0.0008355010650120676, 0.028333880007267, 0.010235952213406563, -0.01141529530286789, -0.009265626780688763, 0.04021681845188141, -0.010490922257304192, -0.041484080255031586, 0.05431510880589485, -0.04444202408194542, -0.05426857993006706, 0.013899463228881359, -0.026531485840678215, 0.04257256165146828, 0.004141514655202627, -0.03188188374042511, -0.01762688346207142, 0.03373398631811142, -0.02624540962278843, -0.02441955730319023, -0.06674116104841232, 0.011190742254257202, 0.022798579186201096, -0.00006452573870774359, -0.005608245264738798, 0.010957440361380577, -0.04444246366620064, 0.046918485313653946, 0.041779953986406326, 0.027157794684171677, -0.016433853656053543, -0.008641375228762627, 0.019513187929987907, -0.0049491869285702705, 0.02653748169541359, 0.009343328885734081, 0.04376088082790375, 0.05327702313661575, -0.03642098233103752, 0.009010965935885906, -0.0714937224984169, 0.0090645095333457, -0.0691898763179779, -0.03250517323613167, -0.029566161334514618, 0.008973177522420883, 0.021657316014170647, -0.0828743651509285, 0.015374635346233845, 0.029510900378227234, -0.04160205274820328, 0.04415411502122879, -0.02171361818909645, -0.02846931666135788, -0.03736281022429466, 0.02685004286468029, -0.01203368604183197, 0.019958648830652237, 0.016085224226117134, 0.028357207775115967, 0.01492730900645256, 0.03902449458837509, 0.030710672959685326, -0.07553993910551071, -0.03176845610141754, -0.013325209729373455, 0.026942241936922073, -0.08852684497833252, 0.01263988297432661, -0.03437936305999756, -0.02525203302502632, 0.019346753135323524, -0.04558302462100983, 0.01909690722823143, 0.026852751150727272, 0.024382079020142555, 0.03189082816243172, 0.09612562507390976, 0.03864716365933418, 0.009986323304474354, -0.02651469223201275, -0.03245659917593002, -0.02528991736471653, 0.030854905024170876, -0.032199010252952576, 0.014092771336436272, 0.02838323637843132, -0.0025904891081154346, -0.018644878640770912, -0.008136979304254055, -0.009660058654844761, -0.030554695054888725, -0.0013766270130872726, -0.025883572176098824, 0.023403018712997437, -0.002964094514027238, -0.02507079392671585, -0.027508486062288284, 0.014985473826527596, 0.03070756047964096, 0.019815074279904366, -0.012552359141409397, 0.010117089375853539, -0.006860777735710144, 0.0017657229909673333, -0.005064620170742273, 0.01637343131005764, 0.004767445847392082, -0.04102388396859169, -0.0009628505213186145, -0.011198997497558594, 0.018977344036102295, -0.020267315208911896, -0.021766364574432373, -0.0011292574927210808, 0.014162044040858746, -0.008831730112433434, -0.020588252693414688, -0.00830658245831728, -0.0054741366766393185, -0.0021963438484817743, -0.0994422435760498, 0.05099114775657654, 0.047692395746707916, -0.023026980459690094, -0.03413178771734238, -0.00223792577162385, -0.0659973993897438, 0.03419681265950203, 0.04186021536588669, -0.004279499873518944, -0.002017366699874401, -0.018500929698348045, 0.007852744311094284, 0.0015963284531608224, -0.09170552343130112, 0.04677991569042206, -0.0046344930306077, -0.012795611284673214, -0.013468301855027676, 0.0012305837590247393, 0.009684699587523937, -0.0023945074062794447, 0.019622962921857834, -0.017139306291937828, 0.0006088029476813972, 0.008182641118764877, -0.01739657111465931, 0.009181800298392773, 0.028767144307494164, -0.02150149829685688, -0.009772864170372486, -0.004725669045001268, 0.04675896093249321, 0.005522947758436203, 0.03178820013999939, -0.05924515426158905, 0.0248287171125412, -0.06614606082439423, -0.013640807010233402, 0.01945272460579872, 0.017583057284355164, -0.03981374204158783, -0.05198037624359131, 0.017642967402935028, 0.010449343360960484, -0.021598080173134804, -0.003612961620092392, 0.06788210570812225, 0.02629202790558338, 0.03286818414926529, 0.009811153635382652, 0.01458402257412672, -0.01518995314836502, -0.0013986454578116536, 0.007924869656562805, 0.014197355136275291, 0.00723501481115818, -0.00031798495911061764, 0.04271792620420456, 0.0360107384622097, -0.006608668714761734, 0.015782451257109642, -0.015626369044184685, 0.0749027281999588, 0.023845981806516647, 0.0027745477855205536, -0.010745597071945667, -0.019004246219992638, 0.037900544703006744, 0.055131375789642334, 0.017845667898654938, 0.040493398904800415, -0.03879757225513458, 0.013847598806023598, -0.00798893440514803, 0.005624691490083933, -0.016344411298632622, 0.011515247635543346, 0.02397134155035019, 0.00872018001973629, 0.012250824831426144, 0.02523726597428322, -0.009082609787583351, -0.008204738609492779, -0.002337314188480377, -0.021381104364991188, 0.05642038956284523, -0.003808720735833049, -0.010966189205646515, -0.004826298914849758, 0.0015819678083062172, -0.07440224289894104, -0.03032766655087471, 0.02060755528509617, 0.010209157131612301, 0.057192619889974594, -0.03208833187818527, -0.03798876330256462, 0.006150309927761555, 0.009753881953656673, -0.016830461099743843, -0.014815202914178371, -0.056815557181835175, 0.020914768800139427, -0.007881313562393188, -0.020299309864640236 ]
<p>Having looked at multiple online sources, I can't seem to get a straight answer. Could someone please clarify for me if ordinal data is sufficient to use for the WSRT and if not, is the sign test an appropriate alternative? Finally, this is for my dissertation project at university and so if any references/literature could be included in answers it would be much appreciated as I need to justify my choice of test either way and so far have only found answers from websites (which I can't reference!)</p>
36,939
[ -0.003967328928411007, -0.04498906061053276, -0.02531268261373043, 0.002738957293331623, 0.03205845132470131, 0.002877000020816922, 0.006930440664291382, -0.026899974793195724, 0.036264095455408096, 0.012294951826334, 0.004315654747188091, -0.017098117619752884, 0.030713405460119247, 0.012157213874161243, 0.028362857177853584, 0.01603490486741066, 0.021993350237607956, -0.029205165803432465, -0.017694121226668358, -0.004528991412371397, -0.005681738723069429, 0.0009528465452603996, 0.0009132588165812194, -0.025793399661779404, -0.020853571593761444, 0.04637443274259567, 0.018153931945562363, -0.028662540018558502, 0.06424971669912338, 0.012169702909886837, -0.021840229630470276, -0.0060113887302577496, -0.021126626059412956, 0.059748418629169464, 0.027329280972480774, 0.0015511809615418315, -0.011486290954053402, -0.007326413411647081, -0.018590625375509262, 0.02384224347770214, 0.005738654173910618, -0.003361497540026903, 0.011708351783454418, 0.015424254350364208, 0.009979207068681717, 0.01660607010126114, -0.023151645436882973, -0.017779385671019554, 0.016914943233132362, -0.04177223891019821, 0.05608610808849335, 0.0229257233440876, 0.0006327666342258453, -0.00041137871448881924, 0.0015667405677959323, 0.00939655676484108, 0.03353999927639961, 0.02414662018418312, 0.0001876709284260869, -0.0341382771730423, -0.027471814304590225, -0.03153843432664871, -0.013802512548863888, -0.02504798211157322, -0.022434663027524948, -0.013503565452992916, 0.03000027686357498, -0.0316622331738472, 0.0699862688779831, 0.035799749195575714, -0.0009445991599932313, 0.020006410777568817, 0.051322683691978455, -0.01768835075199604, 0.05195106193423271, -0.02197425067424774, 0.01725357584655285, -0.0032037566415965557, -0.007058639544993639, 0.016989830881357193, -0.03518938645720482, -0.0017870147712528706, 0.03383908420801163, 0.05870213732123375, 0.011673935689032078, -0.02889486402273178, 0.0462239608168602, 0.006100869737565517, -0.000349262059899047, 0.049380019307136536, 0.010412867181003094, -0.06558751314878464, 0.02976156957447529, 0.021675361320376396, -0.031376294791698456, 0.027487631887197495, -0.05922791361808777, -0.0026957341469824314, 0.03209633007645607, -0.0027547485660761595, -0.0037241377867758274, -0.025411566719412804, 0.062327127903699875, 0.06222248449921608, -0.0038188770413398743, 0.006192394532263279, -0.012626768089830875, -0.01539190486073494, -0.03068460151553154, -0.009297605603933334, -0.014986732974648476, 0.027312394231557846, 0.03398635983467102, 0.046395063400268555, 0.036349765956401825, 0.03160410374403, -0.019751543179154396, -0.012445432133972645, 0.03906320035457611, 0.0591474287211895, 0.07141759246587753, -0.03455644100904465, 0.02238098345696926, -0.029509931802749634, -0.051501061767339706, 0.037134356796741486, -0.005742912646383047, 0.020426791161298752, -0.0055515761487185955, 0.05333847552537918, 0.02980276383459568, 0.013114756904542446, 0.05686183273792267, 0.012388216331601143, 0.04848318174481392, 0.005069956183433533, -0.08705724030733109, -0.060743436217308044, 0.02089979313313961, 0.030606631189584732, 0.010196271352469921, -0.03838096186518669, 0.019132398068904877, 0.017353903502225876, 0.029259756207466125, 0.0011864794651046395, 0.06158960238099098, 0.011573405005037785, -0.017018135637044907, 0.021358810365200043, -0.05544554814696312, -0.019081510603427887, -0.003982235677540302, -0.05753496289253235, -0.010365203022956848, -0.06927651166915894, -0.01298259012401104, -0.016831599175930023, -0.014718693681061268, -0.04596775770187378, 0.015395364724099636, 0.02194935828447342, 0.017568636685609818, 0.012290213257074356, -0.0034735295921564102, 0.01287972740828991, 0.06414451450109482, -0.014579365961253643, 0.009128124453127384, -0.011677614413201809, 0.045177772641181946, 0.018051499500870705, 0.032172705978155136, 0.048048265278339386, 0.03942567855119705, -0.04028046876192093, 0.02352222055196762, -0.07132718712091446, 0.025409119203686714, -0.025292744860053062, -0.01864342764019966, -0.03388999029994011, -0.02507832646369934, -0.025452254340052605, -0.0005278303869999945, 0.047137998044490814, -0.030306067317724228, -0.013663697056472301, 0.027741355821490288, -0.04589495435357094, -0.04004720225930214, 0.007623961661010981, -0.0059199463576078415, 0.002950522117316723, -0.06782516837120056, 0.03319307044148445, -0.010688111186027527, 0.03410590440034866, -0.0051366835832595825, -0.0005188030772842467, -0.021445972844958305, -0.002474660286679864, -0.009228864684700966, -0.041219498962163925, 0.013439543545246124, 0.031319260597229004, 0.03498174995183945, -0.028990045189857483, 0.0091876070946455, -0.0608469657599926, -0.04584524780511856, 0.019024180248379707, -0.011825730092823505, 0.020015934482216835, 0.005832221824675798, -0.0251298937946558, 0.008710375055670738, 0.014518487267196178, -0.03486659750342369, 0.029815131798386574, -0.064603291451931, 0.06936049461364746, 0.02362709864974022, 0.028615768998861313, -0.008380582556128502, 0.0034991218708455563, -0.004947766195982695, -0.019438957795500755, -0.013122216798365116, 0.0059977928176522255, -0.03354504704475403, 0.004258358851075172, 0.008960974402725697, -0.015556019730865955, -0.03915056586265564, 0.028424549847841263, 0.046758659183979034, 0.03226563706994057, 0.010473673231899738, 0.022579871118068695, -0.005927917081862688, -0.056608036160469055, -0.04578007385134697, 0.012551735155284405, 0.05259842798113823, 0.01876930706202984, 0.004796035122126341, 0.02403929829597473, 0.035141874104738235, 0.03294546902179718, -0.02712268941104412, -0.011245439760386944, 0.006493309512734413, 0.018507584929466248, -0.027728935703635216, 0.0052291713654994965, 0.07453412562608719, -0.092864491045475, 0.013754644431173801, 0.0413815900683403, -0.008322055451571941, -0.04043896123766899, 0.011714950203895569, 0.005477567669004202, 0.019166044890880585, 0.013374671339988708, -0.023855872452259064, 0.013140675611793995, 0.046778254210948944, -0.060312751680612564, -0.00754959462210536, -0.03170233964920044, -0.03717439994215965, -0.033553093671798706, -0.018005620688199997, 0.05317170172929764, 0.024386709555983543, 0.019973358139395714, -0.012566396035254002, 0.0007294752285815775, -0.02560780756175518, -0.01667606085538864, 0.03421802818775177, -0.009624164551496506, -0.028765425086021423, 0.0003320980758871883, -0.019504571333527565, 0.01614968851208687, 0.03185627982020378, -0.03713260218501091, -0.05426259711384773, 0.027591373771429062, 0.04103277251124382, -0.03240424767136574, -0.034299641847610474, -0.0371830053627491, 0.007771081291139126, -0.014681982807815075, 0.0010953507153317332, 0.06785791367292404, 0.0077296714298427105, -0.02781771682202816, 0.023318829014897346, -0.09252456575632095, -0.03431233391165733, -0.014539428986608982, -0.01241703238338232, -0.004683482460677624, 0.002603854052722454, 0.017177890986204147, -0.004520576447248459, -0.038462571799755096, -0.01280018500983715, -0.06462916731834412, -0.06880529224872589, 0.0771089643239975, -0.04730274900794029, 0.02850605547428131, 0.029488710686564445, -0.04255910590291023, 0.047104403376579285, 0.008594665676355362, 0.00937768816947937, -0.025449851527810097, 0.03732842952013016, -0.03253428265452385, 0.0010169107699766755, -0.00046380056301131845, 0.016102634370326996, 0.01878081075847149, 0.013224868103861809, 0.003452554577961564, 0.044965710490942, 0.03385968878865242, -0.046441059559583664, -0.024657433852553368, 0.01621643453836441, -0.007936869747936726, -0.033738650381565094, 0.023329928517341614, 0.02478400431573391, -0.030081620439887047, -0.016534138470888138, -0.02734903246164322, -0.006390826776623726, 0.014916758053004742, -0.04135144129395485, -0.0065895793959498405, -0.013973996974527836, 0.033443231135606766, -0.021455084905028343, 0.04265410825610161, 0.01149421650916338, 0.0075949691236019135, -0.020837748423218727, 0.004779295064508915, 0.02671717293560505, -0.012053251266479492, 0.005026574246585369, 0.047469593584537506, 0.03885629400610924, 0.009283979423344135, 0.01786954514682293, 0.004547414369881153, -0.027300531044602394, 0.02102009207010269, 0.0014460564125329256, -0.029358895495533943, 0.031693004071712494, 0.06516693532466888, 0.04698876664042473, 0.018384089693427086, -0.034859295934438705, 0.0022362414747476578, -0.022556057199835777, -0.023918550461530685, -0.029190683737397194, 0.0455622561275959, 0.0036566504277288914, 0.02593679167330265, 0.034107595682144165, 0.034641560167074203, -0.019755300134420395, 0.010824625380337238, -0.03865114226937294, 0.013950725086033344, -0.04050745815038681, -0.013351520523428917, 0.029784223064780235, -0.04085112735629082, -0.012145452201366425, -0.029591990634799004, 0.00457752775400877, -0.004881983157247305, 0.009517304599285126, -0.03813957795500755, 0.020189296454191208, -0.02043253928422928, -0.020994767546653748, 0.007754510268568993, 0.023007404059171677, -0.006359529681503773, -0.04388675466179848, -0.00441318703815341, 0.04317259415984154, 0.012529964558780193, -0.02273782715201378, -0.04565177857875824, 0.02889219857752323, -0.01575193740427494, -0.004312644246965647, 0.04242092743515968, 0.011004884727299213, -0.08961717039346695, 0.056265927851200104, -0.008757974952459335, 0.01645485684275627, 0.012596470303833485, -0.027568276971578598, -0.009259168058633804, -0.019480591639876366, 0.01128272246569395, -0.021795229986310005, 0.018902486190199852, 0.03673931583762169, -0.003293422283604741, 0.02766076661646366, 0.010862622410058975, -0.037241626530885696, 0.01339560654014349, 0.06688372790813446, -0.029738960787653923, -0.029055582359433174, -0.012307461351156235, -0.028865672647953033, 0.026508083567023277, -0.01030438020825386, 0.05183108523488045, 0.029527446255087852, -0.04086332023143768, -0.0055535160936415195, 0.031545694917440414, 0.016495196148753166, -0.023714039474725723, 0.017110062763094902, -0.00943148322403431, 0.026186469942331314, -0.0011159705463796854, -0.04831135645508766, 0.024155298247933388, 0.015259758569300175, 0.05519462749361992, -0.004809177480638027, -0.010597446002066135, -0.08657345920801163, 0.025034479796886444, 0.0514957420527935, 0.07117483764886856, -0.02281218394637108, -0.01876719854772091, -0.02159310318529606, -0.0009030877845361829, 0.09318751096725464, 0.0017517890082672238, 0.0042258016765117645, 0.0025026716757565737, -0.008655146695673466, -0.060189906507730484, -0.025387579575181007, -0.0028726591262966394, 0.0042067477479577065, -0.015484629198908806, 0.022441497072577477, 0.027499087154865265, -0.035168956965208054, -0.035022422671318054, -0.002638427307829261, 0.014459921047091484, 0.038537267595529556, -0.004072115290910006, 0.022477926686406136, -0.011430557817220688, 0.008345636539161205, -0.061008814722299576, -0.031052282080054283, -0.0025885039940476418, 0.010920660570263863, 0.01815170608460903, 0.0897996723651886, 0.02785697765648365, -0.06189807131886482, 0.01485908031463623, -0.0049090818502008915, -0.015049233101308346, 0.014330266043543816, 0.01898127794265747, 0.0710652619600296, 0.02788044884800911, 0.03773600608110428, 0.04508521035313606, 0.051581479609012604, 0.014081996865570545, 0.008693190291523933, 0.02956857904791832, 0.018073413521051407, -0.054238300770521164, -0.00503210024908185, -0.028400294482707977, -0.008512072265148163, -0.05354113131761551, 0.01924857683479786, 0.016001729294657707, -0.018291475251317024, -0.020833276212215424, -0.013956421054899693, 0.0010364269837737083, -0.023797690868377686, -0.02932646870613098, -0.011797145940363407, 0.020020142197608948, 0.025069352239370346, -0.004758683033287525, -0.043837882578372955, 0.012917757965624332, -0.03572678565979004, -0.02406696416437626, 0.02812286466360092, -0.006483565550297499, 0.0082758953794837, -0.03738877922296524, -0.01528509333729744, 0.03574396297335625, -0.03408896550536156, 0.05251745134592056, 0.01524371188133955, 0.015980089083313942, 0.009433485567569733, -0.04230208694934845, -0.03557434305548668, 0.032464586198329926, -0.01799420453608036, 0.02315687946975231, -0.00723345996811986, 0.01641622744500637, 0.031168926507234573, 0.0001843062200350687, -0.08494032919406891, -0.07034196704626083, 0.021121617406606674, 0.022854352369904518, -0.041219815611839294, 0.02355656586587429, 0.051483940333127975, -0.0019213854102417827, -0.009094749577343464, -0.024099227041006088, 0.06550487875938416, -0.019552337005734444, 0.026247330009937286, -0.023555759340524673, -0.024254826828837395, 0.07446421682834625, 0.007025695405900478, -0.010982244275510311, 0.010512135922908783, -0.022391512989997864, 0.01094105839729309, 0.006573413033038378, 0.02290967106819153, -0.04575611650943756, -0.04298859462141991, -0.05285882577300072, -0.005558204837143421, 0.04880359396338463, -0.002313041826710105, -0.013411572203040123, 0.0063802930526435375, -0.038882557302713394, -0.005242443177849054, -0.03555233031511307, -0.022514784708619118, -0.02927541360259056, -0.019106904044747353, 0.0029127353336662054, 0.01582096330821514, -0.022875186055898666, 0.006451934576034546, 0.013036238960921764, 0.055688414722681046, -0.03854384273290634, 0.005029701162129641, 0.05768970400094986, -0.0026744238566607237, -0.020148850977420807, 0.01880289986729622, -0.01675475761294365, 0.02832317352294922, 0.028300048783421516, 0.006318747065961361, 0.004068027250468731, 0.035977553576231, -0.0472036711871624, -0.02186775580048561, -0.002614595927298069, 0.003385071409866214, 0.03341526538133621, 0.004770792089402676, 0.015865042805671692, 0.030399952083826065, -0.03834400698542595, -0.002945258282124996, -0.017749998718500137, -0.010356297716498375, 0.010513660497963428, -0.0077360644936561584, 0.018333517014980316, -0.02411242015659809, 0.011592209339141846, 0.036117225885391235, 0.011997118592262268, 0.0076681869104504585, 0.0014185719192028046, 0.05981217697262764, 0.005018388386815786, 0.045786306262016296, -0.0219375379383564, -0.026723023504018784, 0.00812385231256485, -0.047558121383190155, 0.033086229115724564, 0.01218701247125864, 0.0048159952275455, 0.025288475677371025, 0.006856534164398909, -0.007292081601917744, -0.05334837734699249, -0.04571748152375221, -0.05495456978678703, 0.013036130927503109, 0.022848842665553093, -0.026138268411159515, 0.02228984422981739, -0.00784949492663145, 0.05779477208852768, -0.014866262674331665, -0.00438934750854969, -0.0007843581261113286, -0.06884749978780746, -0.0016996306367218494, 0.021222233772277832, -0.06856155395507812, 0.0534769631922245, -0.02244601771235466, -0.007564209401607513, 0.024909608066082, -0.047379713505506516, -0.00383765809237957, 0.003362310817465186, 0.06523340940475464, -0.017781995236873627, 0.05648697540163994, 0.007915867492556572, 0.0028692823834717274, 0.023574987426400185, 0.0004468371334951371, 0.13165394961833954, 0.08209060877561569, 0.0656556561589241, -0.022798430174589157, 0.03658904507756233, 0.013809841126203537, 0.017009686678647995, 0.0017426853301003575, 0.026931749656796455, 0.004553209524601698, -0.02856137417256832, 0.027901802211999893, 0.03223467618227005, -0.0178420078009367, -0.02865304797887802, 0.030506188049912453, 0.004867864307016134, -0.04347016662359238, 0.05277268961071968, 0.019500235095620155, 0.01603175327181816, -0.011888714507222176, 0.02172136679291725, -0.026028679683804512, 0.04300699383020401, -0.0037731772754341364, 0.03220170736312866, 0.007035363465547562, 0.02150384709239006, 0.033352192491292953, -0.025892911478877068, 0.017466707155108452, 0.016877539455890656, 0.035929616540670395, -0.08524763584136963, 0.014333409257233143, 0.0017507855081930757, -0.030345864593982697, 0.04788123443722725, 0.03606308624148369, 0.0011453902116045356, -0.03765072301030159, -0.028554238379001617, 0.019369300454854965, -0.02824912965297699, -0.0051978575065732, -0.01552662905305624, -0.012750452384352684, 0.0024940241128206253, 0.007349255494773388, -0.005767000373452902, -0.005308319348841906, 0.0009611111599951982, -0.05863701552152634, 0.011315987445414066, 0.01019252184778452, 0.03562218323349953, -0.022923948243260384, -0.021354567259550095, -0.030424131080508232, 0.010045255534350872, -0.009503534995019436, 0.03759478032588959, -0.004054940305650234, -0.047139231115579605, -0.021195797249674797, -0.035230349749326706, 0.005932459607720375, 0.030811382457613945, -0.0003341051342431456, -0.011510415002703667, -0.007464508060365915, -0.01420535147190094, 0.0242101289331913, 0.031104473397135735, 0.005695636384189129, 0.02663884125649929, -0.011766832321882248, -0.004494651220738888, -0.025388965383172035, -0.021898306906223297, -0.02791004069149494, -0.03514494374394417, -0.05254090949892998, -0.024786245077848434, -0.06747964769601822, 0.007076381705701351, 0.01849002204835415, -0.02539379708468914, 0.026857512071728706, -0.006006881594657898, 0.07615315914154053, -0.007558147422969341, -0.05225783959031105, -0.04062597453594208, 0.024721646681427956, -0.008767961524426937, 0.011046069674193859, -0.008418251760303974, 0.03973573073744774, 0.010332977399230003, 0.01699529029428959, -0.0052748778834939, 0.007492250297218561, 0.0022426259238272905, 0.036351632326841354, 0.033610615879297256, -0.05778663605451584, -0.02067290060222149, -0.011302047409117222, -0.019794844090938568, -0.0010544261895120144, -0.009073813445866108, -0.046171557158231735, -0.029586561024188995, -0.012966678477823734, -0.03678101673722267, -0.018963932991027832, 0.007146335206925869, -0.03398805111646652, 0.020597165450453758, 0.0020133445505052805, 0.005793463904410601, -0.03397078439593315, -0.0025980432983487844, 0.02539144828915596, 0.006571873556822538, -0.03839294984936714, 0.012383891269564629, -0.009972378611564636, 0.03537711128592491, -0.004355890676379204, -0.0030696745961904526, -0.05131754279136658, -0.007868303917348385, -0.04298558831214905, 0.01820899359881878, 0.051887478679418564, 0.015262224711477757, -0.0011213450925424695, -0.014257829636335373, -0.02678893879055977, -0.010277006775140762, 0.040304917842149734, -0.014068849384784698, -0.0014830643776804209, -0.02848406508564949, 0.006768749561160803, -0.002130412496626377, 0.054670851677656174, -0.019044755026698112, -0.020355278626084328, -0.004684390965849161, 0.027456605806946754, -0.0037843273021280766, -0.014295573346316814, 0.006830213591456413, -0.0199704822152853, -0.010664190165698528, 0.011636955663561821, 0.02024700865149498, -0.032028067857027054, 0.03731684386730194, -0.00046594798914156854, -0.05952289700508118, -0.034315213561058044, 0.011478199623525143, -0.032656945288181305, -0.008851741440594196, 0.03219424560666084, -0.019445601850748062, 0.025974877178668976, -0.03377943113446236, 0.01346566528081894, -0.08134522289037704, -0.014820403419435024, 0.019699575379490852, -0.02584504708647728, 0.06340043246746063, -0.054655324667692184, 0.04012696072459221, 0.025606540963053703, -0.07186926901340485, 0.05076039955019951, 0.01492201630026102, -0.042758747935295105, -0.04503081738948822, -0.04511804133653641, -0.015209789387881756, 0.01454219501465559, 0.019160835072398186, 0.048957597464323044, -0.000553022138774395, 0.0038706858176738024, 0.02910773828625679, -0.031123729422688484, -0.01970900222659111, 0.025536848232150078, -0.0009758265223354101, -0.07245015352964401, 0.0019844339694827795, -0.06391649693250656, -0.022840771824121475, 0.06973834335803986, -0.024475760757923126, 0.04794678837060928, 0.0015510550001636147, 0.07566268742084503, -0.010781663469970226, 0.03853559494018555, 0.031546156853437424, -0.035980481654405594, -0.025492791086435318, 0.033899299800395966, 0.013472291640937328, 0.00047115972847677767, -0.003174499375745654, 0.003516210475936532, -0.00427671754732728, -0.04096357896924019, 0.000293139077257365, 0.009013212285935879, -0.025140361860394478, -0.018703307956457138, 0.005585163831710815, -0.03064250573515892, 0.011386102065443993, -0.018071113154292107, -0.010331062600016594, -0.0499468632042408, 0.03473464027047157, -0.03680587187409401, 0.023880869150161743, -0.021785257384181023, -0.0012464247411116958, 0.0002709346008487046, -0.003758144797757268, -0.006486813072115183, -0.003067672485485673, 0.017175234854221344, -0.016399357467889786, -0.00040725505095906556, -0.006312163081020117, 0.007551049813628197, -0.02056797966361046, 0.013198288157582283, 0.028313901275396347, 0.04642766714096069, -0.03250754624605179, 0.0036980535369366407, 0.03258734196424484, -0.036614324897527695, 0.04532751813530922, -0.06607307493686676, 0.04739924892783165, 0.07033459097146988, -0.023661255836486816, -0.0025265293661504984, -0.012825150042772293, -0.022767359390854836, -0.01513141393661499, 0.0603841170668602, 0.0035268680658191442, -0.023992858827114105, -0.016953665763139725, -0.024997320026159286, -0.00832957774400711, -0.057305097579956055, -0.0062324670143425465, -0.023717602714896202, -0.023136915639042854, -0.005472719203680754, -0.01239759474992752, 0.0611889511346817, -0.027888378128409386, 0.014369209297001362, 0.009545418433845043, 0.015197854489088058, -0.03551032394170761, 0.017472654581069946, 0.01824009232223034, 0.01162902731448412, 0.003742142114788294, 0.06502512842416763, 0.010814839042723179, -0.012623012065887451, 0.018820490688085556, -0.028794825077056885, -0.03681518882513046, 0.03631255030632019, 0.004505814053118229, 0.015496962703764439, 0.0021457362454384565, 0.0618850477039814, -0.04530177637934685, -0.05819792300462723, -0.02812066674232483, 0.04604276269674301, 0.00800313800573349, -0.023796839639544487, 0.022826747968792915, 0.05462890490889549, 0.015974808484315872, -0.02140711434185505, -0.025617027655243874, 0.009159955196082592, -0.05239587649703026, 0.03581371158361435, 0.008869515731930733, 0.014733411371707916, 0.04594720900058746, 0.008603250607848167, 0.00844025332480669, -0.03838915377855301, 0.022344183176755905, 0.01772378571331501, 0.008423227816820145, 0.06609312444925308, 0.010246198624372482, 0.027761919423937798, -0.01266474649310112, 0.03923571854829788, 0.010537846013903618, -0.009759493172168732, 0.06341355293989182, 0.022435050457715988, -0.0005976620595902205, -0.01901370845735073, -0.019122086465358734, -0.019160732626914978, 0.009829925373196602, 0.0918487012386322, -0.030880596488714218, -0.012930165976285934, -0.011374223046004772, -0.005717636551707983, 0.003032405162230134, 0.007061331998556852, -0.03380077704787254, 0.03544710949063301, -0.009302102960646152, -0.006469953339546919, 0.021528063341975212, -0.009101173840463161, -0.047205593436956406, 0.012492337264120579, 0.013173593208193779, -0.0010124979307875037, 0.013265043497085571, -0.03484258055686951, 0.030962176620960236, 0.010067268274724483, 0.05453735217452049, -0.030255498364567757, -0.025462662801146507, -0.052774276584386826, 0.0002638750011101365, 0.030360789969563484, -0.002472233260050416 ]
<p>Let's say the following is data for airplane accident death to total.</p> <pre><code>Country Sky Total death Total individual traveler A 30 10,000 B 60 15,000 C 3000 10,000,000 </code></pre> <p>Is it possible to calculate probability of air accident probability for any traveler in A, B, or C skies by simply dividing total deaths over total travelers ? If some countries have low flight and others have very high number of flights can this affect the estimates ? </p>
74,201
[ -0.022631412371993065, -0.026390675455331802, -0.004095894284546375, -0.017598336562514305, 0.07547298818826675, 0.026898127049207687, -0.04077547416090965, -0.033037759363651276, 0.04343489930033684, -0.03305291011929512, 0.036311566829681396, 0.05219833552837372, 0.03724803775548935, 0.009745311923325062, 0.04099587723612785, 0.009416922926902771, -0.013287927955389023, 0.012811192311346531, 0.017774060368537903, -0.015959003940224648, 0.007055453024804592, 0.025836410000920296, 0.02089650370180607, -0.042026035487651825, -0.022879652678966522, 0.05387569218873978, 0.019743697717785835, -0.03735588863492012, -0.0058599007315933704, 0.07535889744758606, -0.008570433594286442, -0.000555367732886225, 0.03660152107477188, 0.05491413548588753, 0.03847786784172058, 0.015632236376404762, -0.02205212228000164, -0.00006698739889543504, -0.026158533990383148, 0.018553350120782852, -0.0033150953240692616, -0.02999029867351055, -0.024614818394184113, 0.0580550953745842, -0.017502129077911377, 0.03235827386379242, -0.014115646481513977, -0.030177798122167587, 0.007040555123239756, -0.06874775141477585, 0.04201545938849449, -0.03748992830514908, 0.06424538791179657, 0.03956809639930725, -0.019325092434883118, -0.019065452739596367, 0.06796379387378693, 0.10651151090860367, 0.024103160947561264, -0.018906448036432266, -0.020642617717385292, -0.03703830763697624, 0.008168128319084644, -0.01411863137036562, -0.011286422610282898, 0.011251291260123253, -0.04822269827127457, -0.04880010709166527, 0.001644444651901722, -0.019014157354831696, 0.021877221763134003, 0.0018789810128509998, 0.014006705954670906, -0.009951253421604633, 0.03181557357311249, -0.027781501412391663, 0.025228869169950485, -0.02884303778409958, 0.0475989431142807, 0.06784247606992722, -0.004750591237097979, 0.016605982556939125, 0.018391208723187447, 0.020966505631804466, 0.04788024723529816, -0.012426616623997688, 0.08277260512113571, -0.02587718702852726, -0.0003729900054167956, -0.02375226840376854, -0.03298027440905571, -0.02611755020916462, 0.013719245791435242, 0.013350863941013813, -0.03875163197517395, 0.03443409875035286, -0.013278316706418991, 0.053971730172634125, -0.0015539685264229774, -0.026506736874580383, 0.010114970616996288, -0.02266904152929783, 0.017746545374393463, 0.033073507249355316, -0.033040959388017654, 0.013839825987815857, -0.0485401451587677, -0.01735306903719902, -0.008418342098593712, 0.007103521842509508, -0.037570640444755554, 0.03576088324189186, 0.0004864764050580561, -0.034472569823265076, -0.006145349238067865, 0.008144884370267391, -0.00045257515739649534, -0.03506872057914734, 0.028462015092372894, 0.029952894896268845, 0.07543287426233292, -0.008252821862697601, 0.016269614920020103, 0.003367957193404436, -0.016060931608080864, -0.014818942174315453, 0.019743528217077255, -0.02957155555486679, -0.033489275723695755, 0.02304372563958168, -0.024229973554611206, -0.0070967599749565125, 0.05136530101299286, 0.002291141077876091, 0.03022604249417782, 0.015042956918478012, -0.08349120616912842, -0.025446726009249687, 0.014253289438784122, -0.0035165799781680107, -0.011281750164926052, -0.046647317707538605, 0.020577343180775642, 0.016947781667113304, 0.0417787991464138, 0.023555302992463112, 0.0687544122338295, 0.008967963978648186, 0.009933318942785263, 0.017238330096006393, -0.025906071066856384, 0.03691874444484711, 0.002329185837879777, -0.042125899344682693, -0.015089787542819977, -0.1066170260310173, -0.004930347669869661, 0.03974835202097893, 0.0019905054941773415, -0.008021135814487934, 0.04515089467167854, -0.008500635623931885, 0.007424678187817335, -0.02064681425690651, 0.022444024682044983, -0.016650879755616188, 0.10374131798744202, 0.04137396439909935, 0.014741103164851665, 0.012809744104743004, 0.012792376801371574, 0.044834136962890625, -0.0009309026645496488, 0.006123916711658239, 0.09390333294868469, -0.009449932724237442, -0.0059015220031142235, -0.017739517614245415, 0.01336499024182558, 0.0019167308928444982, -0.04601480811834335, -0.003407029202207923, -0.01034238375723362, 0.0016824394697323442, 0.030562113970518112, 0.01578262634575367, 0.02968773804605007, -0.01744719222187996, 0.02727808989584446, -0.014803360216319561, -0.05901462584733963, -0.0622580386698246, -0.013152176514267921, -0.0057344138622283936, -0.00135051179677248, -0.011292668990790844, 0.007186136208474636, 0.021326944231987, -0.04701990261673927, -0.009401131421327591, -0.02801015041768551, -0.025618690997362137, -0.0008462948608212173, -0.022796323522925377, -0.020108940079808235, 0.035304956138134, 0.04478330910205841, -0.00768708810210228, 0.047927357256412506, -0.004737905226647854, -0.04505598172545433, -0.02780109830200672, -0.03379758074879646, 0.008672741241753101, -0.009548626840114594, -0.01837894506752491, 0.03630732744932175, 0.019953861832618713, -0.021296175196766853, 0.02652725763618946, -0.05090094357728958, 0.04539725184440613, 0.08991177380084991, 0.013808473013341427, 0.021807130426168442, -0.009349802508950233, 0.024394556879997253, -0.029416002333164215, 0.025310322642326355, -0.056717801839113235, -0.07196968048810959, -0.013047701679170132, 0.04697737842798233, -0.016621140763163567, -0.05584300681948662, 0.008425253443419933, 0.05290117859840393, 0.014203055761754513, 0.016939809545874596, 0.020462583750486374, -0.00045847363071516156, -0.01862812228500843, 0.00011277916200924665, -0.00011316630116198212, 0.005966856610029936, -0.006795269437134266, 0.010604746639728546, 0.006176644470542669, -0.01014510914683342, -0.04309790953993797, -0.04385753348469734, 0.013576269149780273, -0.03460760787129402, 0.030391136184334755, -0.01860697939991951, 0.005354328081011772, 0.038235653191804886, -0.025432009249925613, 0.03346562385559082, 0.011870059184730053, 0.005241739563643932, -0.023608775809407234, 0.004218880087137222, -0.03185045346617699, 0.02175009436905384, 0.06030426546931267, -0.06570959836244583, 0.024251282215118408, 0.02782735787332058, -0.014147445559501648, -0.003965925425291061, -0.01979578658938408, -0.003985346294939518, -0.03701542690396309, 0.03879662603139877, 0.04568535462021828, -0.009384202770888805, 0.062198903411626816, -0.011337785981595516, -0.03607727959752083, -0.01787918619811535, -0.02374209836125374, -0.040739160031080246, 0.0012897532433271408, -0.07000451534986496, 0.04196420684456825, -0.012269933708012104, -0.04732481390237808, 0.018295563757419586, -0.035407550632953644, -0.017686469480395317, 0.04124181345105171, -0.014145753346383572, -0.04187079519033432, 0.011234271340072155, -0.02789083682000637, 0.028702449053525925, -0.03551642969250679, -0.031101223081350327, 0.016520950943231583, 0.02707652747631073, -0.008411094546318054, 0.04523472487926483, -0.06478513032197952, -0.042241934686899185, -0.022567493841052055, -0.011896422132849693, 0.015562629327178001, -0.05678706243634224, 0.026009682565927505, -0.007124787662178278, -0.010732832364737988, 0.0023347269743680954, -0.031911592930555344, -0.05000884830951691, 0.024492720142006874, -0.011343348771333694, 0.012880896218121052, 0.014034540392458439, -0.01684403046965599, 0.047614820301532745, 0.020387331023812294, -0.054073162376880646, -0.008911470882594585, -0.029969193041324615, -0.010173832066357136, 0.029247211292386055, -0.01243508979678154, 0.012569122947752476, 0.011576724238693714, 0.025264842435717583, 0.01107352040708065, -0.010450147092342377, 0.0486820712685585, 0.029851078987121582, -0.03610643744468689, 0.0229216106235981, 0.0076942224986851215, 0.04482201114296913, 0.0604085810482502, 0.03276786953210831, -0.011339007876813412, 0.030421379953622818, -0.022494474425911903, 0.022511739283800125, 0.024005141109228134, -0.032904695719480515, 0.0228100772947073, -0.005143884569406509, 0.013004363514482975, -0.03472837805747986, 0.045724693685770035, 0.013415792025625706, 0.00019822295871563256, -0.00496801920235157, 0.01885918527841568, 0.02212880365550518, -0.021117182448506355, -0.0029147909954190254, 0.015336808748543262, 0.05046907439827919, -0.015398725867271423, -0.06503383815288544, -0.002659546909853816, -0.012829995714128017, 0.010681875981390476, -0.02153642289340496, -0.023478807881474495, 0.0269722118973732, 0.06075997278094292, 0.04358883574604988, 0.006378848571330309, -0.03319481387734413, 0.02251722663640976, -0.07219342887401581, -0.06339232623577118, -0.03836570307612419, 0.06396568566560745, 0.007448346819728613, 0.023732157424092293, -0.015108161605894566, -0.02009482868015766, 0.006869993172585964, 0.017952432855963707, -0.07858870923519135, 0.04021260887384415, -0.002377013675868511, -0.028944456949830055, -0.0038407279644161463, -0.02792643941938877, 0.03544094040989876, -0.02146855928003788, -0.01240625511854887, -0.02760225720703602, 0.01264371071010828, -0.03579661250114441, 0.015888867899775505, 0.011615549214184284, 0.004937834106385708, 0.014462815597653389, 0.034125760197639465, 0.02175481803715229, 0.024333251640200615, 0.04117614030838013, 0.05000080540776253, -0.020152708515524864, -0.04674672707915306, -0.029817767441272736, 0.006252198945730925, 0.024577012285590172, 0.02498790994286537, -0.0010165020357817411, 0.017580203711986542, -0.050754476338624954, 0.012266824021935463, 0.005375091917812824, 0.02431938238441944, 0.011560832150280476, 0.009362398646771908, -0.035445913672447205, -0.047931913286447525, -0.02490806393325329, 0.002378899371251464, -0.0005351821309886873, -0.012433499097824097, 0.0189785398542881, 0.04513087123632431, 0.014715896919369698, -0.06056762859225273, 0.026701530441641808, 0.04108544439077377, -0.0018431502394378185, 0.019869009032845497, -0.010184136219322681, -0.008666407316923141, -0.0183753352612257, -0.028202228248119354, 0.042130254209041595, 0.02106841653585434, -0.026989417150616646, 0.02320060133934021, 0.07632133364677429, 0.008088460192084312, -0.03697238862514496, 0.025845510885119438, -0.0017176965484395623, -0.007689265534281731, 0.03331151604652405, -0.03432828560471535, 0.011814012192189693, 0.010795769281685352, 0.01961064711213112, 0.016446037217974663, -0.01997753046452999, -0.08626583218574524, 0.011067851446568966, 0.043317221105098724, 0.042077887803316116, -0.027647776529192924, -0.004412162117660046, -0.02208486571907997, -0.013074507005512714, 0.04574832692742348, -0.028407497331500053, -0.009980528615415096, -0.027918102219700813, -0.0013566133566200733, 0.01678290031850338, -0.04134131222963333, -0.017670458182692528, 0.0498645044863224, 0.004591598641127348, -0.0010152611648663878, -0.003576981835067272, 0.009593329392373562, -0.028082476928830147, 0.0157327763736248, 0.05109403654932976, 0.045747339725494385, -0.0005076501984149218, -0.020794905722141266, -0.05858289822936058, 0.0060943420976400375, -0.001741844229400158, -0.047227077186107635, 0.01182725839316845, -0.021066922694444656, 0.004885467234998941, 0.055627595633268356, 0.022529752925038338, 0.00011447785800555721, 0.03576233983039856, 0.006363904569298029, -0.01342951413244009, -0.027468016371130943, -0.0004489279817789793, 0.06889984756708145, 0.03530145809054375, -0.01147045660763979, 0.021700233221054077, 0.022623777389526367, -0.023445989936590195, -0.0036115727853029966, -0.017986712977290154, 0.01691177673637867, -0.0150409871712327, -0.006700614001601934, -0.02035859227180481, -0.026083223521709442, 0.0026848665438592434, 0.0023836190812289715, -0.023407481610774994, 0.009871512651443481, -0.0612853541970253, -0.028615612536668777, -0.013399502262473106, 0.0068575856275856495, 0.0257621631026268, 0.027592213824391365, -0.03714875131845474, 0.02019057236611843, 0.018193377181887627, -0.007105672266334295, 0.032300107181072235, 0.007409199140965939, 0.016257427632808685, -0.03229941800236702, -0.05161553993821144, 0.018038587644696236, -0.06224499270319939, -0.009582110680639744, 0.008673794567584991, -0.056743983179330826, 0.06618622690439224, 0.024721216410398483, -0.01268339715898037, 0.03348294645547867, -0.06019619107246399, -0.026214875280857086, 0.00245942291803658, 0.023543640971183777, 0.02361132949590683, -0.057404324412345886, 0.04350639879703522, -0.007663909811526537, -0.0013911242131143808, -0.06213797256350517, -0.024403050541877747, 0.032500315457582474, 0.013741746544837952, -0.013411667197942734, -0.07100795209407806, 0.0020451918244361877, -0.03495899587869644, -0.04206087440252304, 0.004044840577989817, 0.043864086270332336, -0.02879263646900654, -0.014383369125425816, 0.015471251681447029, -0.021176261827349663, 0.05405435338616371, 0.010898377746343613, -0.03291238844394684, 0.021503610536456108, -0.026487622410058975, 0.013367921113967896, -0.03470402583479881, 0.03621196746826172, -0.02663758397102356, -0.035279031842947006, 0.002125226426869631, -0.00305547215975821, 0.017096983268857002, -0.020256588235497475, -0.0033097644336521626, -0.007880943827331066, -0.020617233589291573, 0.03163566440343857, 0.002277475781738758, 0.021152373403310776, 0.0036926656030118465, 0.01005647610872984, -0.04020275920629501, 0.024365169927477837, -0.022348592057824135, 0.005975722800940275, 0.005109226796776056, 0.002908990951254964, -0.023485934361815453, 0.023850848898291588, 0.055163051933050156, -0.01581433042883873, -0.010225645266473293, -0.04086213558912277, -0.02323330193758011, 0.026551585644483566, -0.011272686533629894, -0.03056694194674492, 0.06361488252878189, 0.018138879910111427, -0.0033482953440397978, -0.0291142575442791, -0.05231991037726402, -0.019467005506157875, 0.028364233672618866, -0.02196837030351162, 0.02868293598294258, 0.02917570248246193, 0.04354942589998245, 0.011333776637911797, 0.010365313850343227, 0.002872178563848138, 0.021898193284869194, 0.021338334307074547, 0.05539444088935852, -0.024554606527090073, -0.025988848879933357, 0.03815549984574318, 0.06045108661055565, 0.013108144514262676, 0.04274661839008331, 0.01064457930624485, 0.0014295162400230765, 0.015484295785427094, 0.009048755280673504, 0.007104191929101944, 0.039331480860710144, -0.03777309134602547, 0.01814681850373745, -0.024055115878582, -0.03068118914961815, 0.05693240836262703, 0.017044370993971825, -0.026114942505955696, -0.03784071281552315, 0.011015729047358036, -0.010083617642521858, 0.0340164415538311, -0.008784005418419838, 0.025005009025335312, 0.015628507360816002, -0.029698053374886513, 0.024517839774489403, -0.017507832497358322, 0.0007777658756822348, -0.004330718889832497, -0.06874125450849533, -0.05103188380599022, -0.03320753946900368, -0.0366121344268322, 0.019189702346920967, 0.009411169216036797, -0.02928961254656315, 0.011356179602444172, 0.000004408143922773888, 0.04352303966879845, 0.019552333280444145, 0.05163128674030304, -0.012168064713478088, 0.06919080764055252, 0.015001190826296806, 0.02804604545235634, 0.00900320801883936, -0.002342547057196498, 0.1295570731163025, 0.04670342057943344, 0.017763342708349228, -0.04843814671039581, -0.012568796053528786, 0.01510630827397108, 0.011036528274416924, -0.03872508555650711, -0.002349363174289465, 0.015341638587415218, -0.012362622655928135, 0.040082406252622604, 0.06828133016824722, 0.0011143827578052878, -0.007593720220029354, 0.07113781571388245, -0.06114325299859047, -0.04214416444301605, -0.01490764133632183, 0.04495834559202194, -0.016738561913371086, -0.02678483910858631, -0.03744463250041008, -0.007669652346521616, 0.010870533064007759, 0.010218176059424877, -0.05262675881385803, 0.003468214999884367, -0.022959502413868904, 0.013548139482736588, -0.06276563555002213, 0.00018463430751580745, 0.04713721573352814, 0.03169209882616997, -0.011251999996602535, -0.020237918943166733, 0.013185127638280392, -0.013731392100453377, -0.021880026906728745, 0.02990696020424366, -0.02322765253484249, 0.0025459860917180777, -0.008736252784729004, 0.02603890560567379, -0.05989689752459526, -0.02279268205165863, -0.029142115265130997, 0.005153132136911154, -0.02523781545460224, 0.008516810834407806, -0.06187523528933525, -0.015403278172016144, -0.015198531560599804, -0.0159926600754261, -0.027914779260754585, 0.015623759478330612, 0.011489593423902988, -0.033604059368371964, -0.0640566498041153, -0.019195526838302612, -0.004404901061207056, -0.01887696236371994, 0.0010824826313182712, 0.026860881596803665, -0.019287414848804474, -0.04292401298880577, -0.04129059612751007, 0.02299436740577221, -0.028433235362172127, 0.02132045477628708, -0.029966048896312714, -0.015612736344337463, -0.035839468240737915, -0.03195108845829964, 0.03879907727241516, 0.0011889077723026276, 0.05033094435930252, 0.02526256814599037, -0.020709527656435966, 0.019233057275414467, 0.01888519898056984, 0.0020331237465143204, -0.024977972730994225, -0.0009448444470763206, -0.020934412255883217, 0.00939003936946392, 0.016749748960137367, 0.04222019389271736, 0.004641007166355848, 0.032981473952531815, 0.009600942954421043, 0.05946989357471466, -0.002434435533359647, -0.036334920674562454, 0.001367256511002779, -0.002289021387696266, -0.04835129901766777, 0.023705502972006798, 0.010642912238836288, 0.0643276572227478, 0.0051865968853235245, 0.014530334621667862, -0.01941455900669098, 0.052893951535224915, 0.0020644867327064276, 0.002803201787173748, 0.003557422198355198, -0.08592606335878372, -0.0007308448548428714, 0.02474309504032135, 0.05299394205212593, -0.03241897001862526, -0.016943005844950676, 0.018380966037511826, 0.0053555928170681, 0.007118167355656624, -0.005106796510517597, 0.003064914373680949, 0.018381750211119652, -0.02446695975959301, -0.0214737206697464, -0.018474474549293518, 0.009908474050462246, -0.030687548220157623, -0.019494153559207916, -0.022941460832953453, -0.03374926373362541, -0.03064688667654991, 0.001528058317489922, -0.010379713959991932, 0.009504711255431175, 0.012955953367054462, 0.031254179775714874, 0.01993671990931034, -0.0013820264721289277, 0.03463364392518997, 0.00802483968436718, 0.04264463856816292, -0.03225059434771538, -0.03576979413628578, 0.03829381614923477, -0.04433266073465347, -0.05320218205451965, 0.05633994936943054, 0.025515539571642876, 0.10260945558547974, 0.04835093021392822, 0.012205553241074085, -0.01109351683408022, 0.06929253041744232, -0.0251455195248127, -0.03600651025772095, -0.022002030164003372, 0.00968124344944954, 0.014483480714261532, -0.031886134296655655, -0.024725373834371567, 0.024427346885204315, -0.034040190279483795, 0.002346423454582691, 0.035956140607595444, -0.006398126017302275, -0.017536384984850883, 0.03144216537475586, 0.021118979901075363, 0.01980234682559967, 0.008125580847263336, 0.02005295269191265, 0.03199417144060135, 0.02955499291419983, -0.02840249612927437, 0.04634150117635727, -0.00817124079912901, 0.014573118649423122, -0.10412949323654175, -0.023437609896063805, 0.033152736723423004, 0.004980036988854408, 0.04011627659201622, -0.023583145812153816, 0.03135460987687111, -0.0016449785325676203, -0.04557786136865616, 0.021998291835188866, 0.00684240972623229, -0.01742912083864212, -0.05609256029129028, 0.020216546952724457, -0.00742904981598258, 0.051850538700819016, 0.038992565125226974, 0.013637370429933071, 0.05252685025334358, 0.00927532184869051, -0.009931625798344612, -0.021926073357462883, -0.030490882694721222, 0.014390380121767521, 0.007048279978334904, -0.04854592680931091, 0.06336242705583572, -0.06259460002183914, -0.04150775447487831, 0.023266976699233055, -0.028111960738897324, 0.011865120381116867, -0.002175849163904786, -0.004234459716826677, 0.03423324599862099, 0.009277785196900368, 0.036091241985559464, 0.013472075574100018, -0.011155917309224606, 0.04530230164527893, 0.0030367011204361916, 0.006013082340359688, -0.027819624170660973, 0.0049310713075101376, 0.039074864238500595, 0.0003468883805908263, -0.04441840946674347, 0.023916998878121376, 0.020421521738171577, -0.012689727358520031, -0.007934467867016792, -0.012668888084590435, 0.02326945960521698, -0.0020866882987320423, 0.026309693232178688, -0.044231973588466644, 0.013243655674159527, 0.013382022269070148, 0.006046719383448362, -0.007200248539447784, 0.008617286570370197, -0.026953740045428276, -0.04684295877814293, -0.01132550835609436, -0.001874792156741023, -0.032514020800590515, -0.019736697897315025, 0.008706592954695225, -0.0036127932835370302, -0.0069376020692288876, -0.01484741736203432, -0.039606980979442596, -0.019497526809573174, 0.0025676835794001818, 0.012355550192296505, 0.016638172790408134, 0.025984611362218857, 0.020892411470413208, 0.002042002510279417, -0.0718635842204094, 0.020052356645464897, -0.014893929474055767, 0.023973042145371437, -0.05559815466403961, -0.016876613721251488, -0.047419920563697815, 0.007745183072984219, 0.03162182867527008, -0.0072572254575788975, 0.015615257434546947, -0.0332210548222065, 0.0301331989467144, -0.005208435468375683, -0.04634567350149155, -0.005866618826985359, -0.009365355595946312, -0.08040240406990051, -0.028982004150748253, -0.0003601041971705854, -0.004696419928222895, 0.004894167184829712, -0.019024448469281197, -0.04371349886059761, -0.0025478966999799013, 0.018390221521258354, 0.01530301384627819, 0.03582139313220978, -0.005957977380603552, 0.0149437440559268, 0.009765488095581532, 0.02116147242486477, 0.03550458326935768, 0.025076471269130707, 0.012848579324781895, -0.026103593409061432, 0.039645880460739136, -0.04021403566002846, -0.05672348663210869, 0.0068816933780908585, -0.010309282690286636, 0.008813098073005676, -0.03690820559859276, 0.02265854738652706, 0.0045027825981378555, -0.015372775495052338, 0.026177819818258286, 0.025012554600834846, 0.01775851473212242, 0.051413580775260925, -0.010355648584663868, 0.012420074082911015, 0.011225530877709389, -0.041065432131290436, -0.0030975709669291973, 0.013865672051906586, 0.008890369907021523, -0.0105381328612566, 0.04629477858543396, 0.011450249701738358, 0.02968563139438629, -0.003822888247668743, 0.001909829443320632, 0.0214594267308712, -0.0016400760505348444, -0.003517212113365531, 0.018259653821587563, 0.010954884812235832, 0.020329613238573074, 0.004027640447020531, 0.008429060690104961, 0.045068565756082535, 0.025059817358851433, 0.03220463916659355, -0.02877996675670147, -0.01925472728908062, -0.02407880313694477, -0.010201206430792809, 0.020846955478191376, 0.04772408306598663, -0.010571532882750034, -0.019188715144991875, -0.004836029373109341, 0.01799221709370613, 0.02572178654372692, -0.022511206567287445, 0.03036922961473465, -0.04443589970469475, 0.002727464074268937, -0.014794471673667431, -0.016536284238100052, 0.003037496469914913, -0.037022095173597336, 0.03622647747397423, 0.07155797630548477, 0.03233902156352997, -0.003709274111315608, -0.05926474556326866, -0.00551975192502141, 0.032365910708904266, -0.009452174417674541, -0.03348221629858017, -0.05993594229221344, 0.04244951903820038, -0.01873079314827919, -0.027115127071738243 ]
<p>Can somebody provide an intuitive difference between correlation and correlation coefficient? During learning of weights of neural network, I want to show how closely the estimated weights are to the known true weights. For this, I was thinking of using the correlation measure. If they are correlated then the value will be close to one. But I am not sure, if it should be the correlation or the correlation coefficient. </p> <p>Also, what is the difference between the two formula wise and physical meaning wise. Thank you</p>
74,202
[ -0.030569661408662796, -0.006196034140884876, -0.024715691804885864, 0.002035812009125948, 0.02814953587949276, 0.011330490931868553, 0.010458020493388176, -0.011312169022858143, 0.03593158721923828, -0.0186847522854805, 0.03311282768845558, 0.04995202273130417, 0.03993627801537514, 0.012583275325596333, 0.02345418743789196, 0.031439997255802155, -0.01908542774617672, 0.030761882662773132, 0.012497369199991226, -0.01179584302008152, -0.007229426875710487, 0.046294204890728, 0.041260976344347, 0.008899286389350891, 0.002585694193840027, 0.061286810785532, 0.012503352016210556, -0.03659640997648239, 0.037885624915361404, 0.054275333881378174, -0.04313243180513382, -0.05708520859479904, 0.00914477463811636, 0.052026621997356415, 0.0065569523721933365, -0.03333404287695885, -0.014858760870993137, -0.01889750175178051, -0.03432811051607132, 0.0142333609983325, -0.029947543516755104, -0.05672139301896095, 0.02929829992353916, 0.022222036495804787, 0.00885164923965931, 0.009856987744569778, 0.007462930865585804, -0.04203536733984947, 0.007954000495374203, -0.04147252440452576, 0.07110808789730072, 0.003082665614783764, 0.045649562031030655, 0.05870727077126503, 0.021043971180915833, 0.034749191254377365, 0.062443796545267105, 0.03793269023299217, -0.03939376398921013, -0.06282041221857071, -0.029645269736647606, -0.032451365143060684, 0.019764000549912453, -0.0032897950150072575, -0.019873928278684616, 0.037490904331207275, -0.006280013360083103, -0.013317597098648548, 0.043058790266513824, -0.0029665182810276747, 0.021303564310073853, 0.02839784510433674, 0.048874273896217346, -0.023103363811969757, -0.010731440037488937, -0.028199953958392143, -0.0050841160118579865, 0.005872564855962992, 0.05601619929075241, 0.04785816743969917, -0.00803754385560751, 0.04144340381026268, 0.026891425251960754, 0.01770717464387417, 0.04206543415784836, -0.031116386875510216, 0.08845554292201996, -0.02747122384607792, 0.04316270351409912, 0.008495798334479332, -0.029574325308203697, 0.006707242224365473, 0.03146737068891525, 0.01095401681959629, -0.008001693524420261, 0.016635160893201828, -0.0013542312663048506, 0.018991053104400635, 0.03183143958449364, -0.02921639196574688, -0.029115406796336174, -0.019944973289966583, -0.0034025677014142275, 0.05093134194612503, -0.013479904271662235, -0.018820594996213913, -0.014020880684256554, 0.023042859509587288, 0.007166742812842131, -0.020288478583097458, -0.01490525808185339, 0.0035038564819842577, 0.01684209145605564, 0.025484830141067505, 0.054590724408626556, 0.0018842376302927732, 0.030677856877446175, 0.015263201668858528, 0.05309295281767845, 0.0749148279428482, 0.03656844422221184, -0.0399942472577095, 0.0317658893764019, -0.006289022974669933, -0.03694823756814003, 0.01762355864048004, 0.03781009092926979, -0.021351097151637077, -0.012596742250025272, 0.06973408907651901, -0.0034729596227407455, -0.030482608824968338, 0.01952088251709938, -0.004486100282520056, 0.016629107296466827, 0.008422363549470901, -0.097434863448143, -0.015363382175564766, 0.04030720144510269, -0.052795104682445526, -0.010191578418016434, -0.034231994301080704, 0.025984419509768486, 0.023257778957486153, 0.07452855259180069, 0.05172784999012947, 0.017997659742832184, -0.019036324694752693, 0.015953917056322098, 0.006392768118530512, -0.034046344459056854, -0.019972769543528557, -0.001089080236852169, -0.009937649592757225, -0.029874717816710472, -0.041417233645915985, -0.011605952866375446, 0.023148680105805397, -0.01575239561498165, -0.04761476069688797, 0.0324862115085125, -0.0033340079244226217, -0.01236499659717083, 0.020660001784563065, 0.026807809248566628, -0.02963794581592083, 0.06029968336224556, -0.0187006164342165, 0.008778735063970089, 0.0439947172999382, -0.01014795247465372, -0.019189966842532158, 0.03894537687301636, 0.04379529505968094, 0.05714644119143486, -0.0017880561063066125, -0.031179513782262802, -0.024026891216635704, 0.025198226794600487, -0.017910337075591087, -0.02866358868777752, -0.04722278192639351, -0.00223813415504992, 0.004712892696261406, 0.007755618076771498, 0.04877627640962601, 0.008544934913516045, -0.04850390926003456, -0.00423708138987422, -0.0032817181199789047, -0.026639418676495552, -0.06846220046281815, 0.007170212455093861, -0.03049270063638687, -0.019355954602360725, 0.05554990842938423, 0.021764537319540977, 0.002598053775727749, -0.018320929259061813, -0.030347071588039398, -0.045927271246910095, 0.025257114320993423, -0.018424157053232193, -0.027957642450928688, 0.018994411453604698, 0.03440270572900772, 0.017567846924066544, -0.004575286526232958, 0.03268079459667206, -0.04325845465064049, -0.05025302991271019, 0.04025400057435036, -0.01971101015806198, 0.005769683979451656, -0.031030355021357536, -0.02801278606057167, 0.016062263399362564, -0.006247119978070259, -0.03080550581216812, 0.025508133694529533, -0.02014821767807007, 0.09439225494861603, 0.03717195987701416, 0.018558820709586143, -0.0028055389411747456, 0.03512268513441086, -0.005192671436816454, 0.005269120447337627, -0.04175984486937523, -0.022294150665402412, -0.023258665576577187, -0.009242696687579155, 0.022582823410630226, 0.036757998168468475, -0.05159102752804756, 0.0023771992418915033, 0.06690341234207153, 0.018248198553919792, 0.021642453968524933, 0.015122896060347557, -0.006031704600900412, -0.008298722095787525, 0.0060504646971821785, 0.012451793067157269, -0.01058355811983347, -0.016684094443917274, -0.005402777809649706, 0.04293656349182129, 0.04654287174344063, 0.009611331857740879, -0.04419483616948128, 0.06269726157188416, 0.014751003123819828, 0.00612017372623086, -0.01769576594233513, -0.01843077316880226, 0.007937878370285034, -0.023454267531633377, -0.006633745040744543, 0.02679714374244213, -0.012570904567837715, -0.0009548403322696686, -0.011821980588138103, -0.03436649590730667, 0.027937551960349083, 0.021822847425937653, -0.027788545936346054, -0.027266310527920723, -0.0004089611175004393, -0.04056268930435181, 0.01197134517133236, -0.009765010327100754, -0.0021899882704019547, -0.021000850945711136, 0.02519003115594387, 0.0557638481259346, 0.002006319584324956, 0.025330206379294395, -0.0010109171271324158, -0.04754581302404404, -0.006441290490329266, -0.015056528151035309, 0.0123558035120368, -0.0230454932898283, -0.07499775290489197, -0.011355414055287838, -0.04136354848742485, -0.021923448890447617, 0.04288836568593979, -0.04125788435339928, 0.0004088591376785189, 0.021148955449461937, -0.008459407836198807, -0.056316960602998734, -0.010213087312877178, -0.022031303495168686, 0.03608095645904541, 0.003243537386879325, -0.03517100587487221, 0.03907869756221771, -0.05559597164392471, -0.03833353519439697, 0.0070571694523096085, -0.003938199020922184, -0.041971925646066666, -0.02543492615222931, -0.010601341724395752, 0.002967827720567584, -0.02604317106306553, -0.0001354309933958575, 0.0349552147090435, -0.04783039912581444, -0.01993134431540966, -0.04757554456591606, -0.02789929322898388, 0.057178374379873276, -0.009953898377716541, 0.007535187061876059, 0.022298064082860947, -0.012803744524717331, 0.0727529227733612, -0.012014955282211304, -0.024064207449555397, -0.015509570948779583, 0.022977709770202637, -0.02843071147799492, 0.00624698493629694, 0.0020480474922806025, 0.02498653531074524, 0.04051537811756134, 0.03311536833643913, 0.020583244040608406, 0.0073762619867920876, 0.06491746753454208, 0.009637784212827682, 0.0483735129237175, 0.029208272695541382, 0.0032992816995829344, -0.038259316235780716, 0.03566577285528183, 0.01606065221130848, -0.0738641694188118, 0.021420208737254143, 0.02731417492032051, 0.001484141917899251, 0.0002782460651360452, -0.010930363088846207, 0.013667451217770576, -0.009044526144862175, 0.02154616080224514, -0.06025714427232742, 0.004984718281775713, -0.005076723638921976, 0.012168972752988338, -0.013628351502120495, 0.048327527940273285, 0.040543440729379654, -0.021674180403351784, -0.010073024779558182, 0.03330972045660019, 0.02911231480538845, -0.026808161288499832, -0.00567470071837306, -0.01784132421016693, -0.038187526166439056, 0.04613601788878441, -0.020795153453946114, -0.015945719555020332, 0.050375837832689285, 0.00582556938752532, -0.009710727259516716, -0.0069074472412467, -0.03918321058154106, -0.0166664719581604, -0.07069853693246841, -0.007868435233831406, -0.005713714752346277, 0.07245892286300659, 0.005053771194070578, 0.0661352202296257, 0.03687222674489021, 0.003456022357568145, 0.03162216767668724, 0.006052961107343435, -0.0818251520395279, 0.030514124780893326, -0.0021886525209993124, -0.030092677101492882, 0.023702096194028854, -0.04009557515382767, 0.008453771471977234, -0.04136158525943756, -0.003869356121867895, 0.0011641692835837603, 0.027692146599292755, -0.01762535236775875, 0.03157935291528702, -0.013315957970917225, 0.01816566288471222, -0.0018309653969481587, 0.004838384222239256, -0.021995529532432556, -0.03587311506271362, 0.045305006206035614, 0.0501718632876873, 0.01994422636926174, -0.0030278656631708145, -0.031800225377082825, 0.0006008390337228775, 0.034714601933956146, 0.02314177341759205, 0.04516935721039772, 0.009541330859065056, -0.03327034041285515, 0.001422853791154921, 0.03505301848053932, 0.03705857694149017, 0.033134546130895615, -0.030285563319921494, -0.025029268115758896, -0.04493607208132744, -0.001392488949932158, -0.02385261468589306, 0.03533860296010971, 0.0022524865344166756, 0.0240770410746336, 0.03201537951827049, 0.012799985706806183, -0.034111518412828445, 0.013171648606657982, 0.050789862871170044, 0.04552802816033363, -0.03467823565006256, -0.029018288478255272, 0.0014788736589252949, -0.021094312891364098, -0.004107999615371227, 0.041585370898246765, -0.0007212333148345351, -0.010513419285416603, -0.004781603347510099, 0.02234429121017456, -0.03139324113726616, -0.028675759211182594, -0.03195209056138992, 0.028711535036563873, 0.035492103546857834, -0.022086385637521744, -0.03849874064326286, -0.013218359090387821, 0.06449867784976959, 0.01413833536207676, 0.01006818376481533, -0.009312951005995274, -0.05486678704619408, -0.010104713961482048, 0.014523659832775593, -0.004863385576754808, -0.0552213229238987, -0.017982937395572662, -0.013733533211052418, -0.021033234894275665, 0.04621489346027374, -0.00982667226344347, 0.015654979273676872, -0.00759436609223485, 0.0014679317828267813, 0.0010311455698683858, 0.014394808560609818, -0.03263765946030617, 0.048224352300167084, -0.0005781598738394678, 0.016720900312066078, -0.03142445906996727, -0.011173956096172333, -0.0365401916205883, -0.026503102853894234, 0.011907167732715607, 0.08073176443576813, -0.03848382458090782, -0.0012198691256344318, 0.011766770854592323, 0.026881903409957886, 0.0366324819624424, -0.0818713828921318, -0.003422006731852889, -0.008980941958725452, -0.025935033336281776, 0.040757909417152405, -0.011866605840623379, -0.03180282935500145, 0.0010633491910994053, -0.004449694883078337, -0.032094210386276245, -0.013679075986146927, -0.023829327896237373, 0.08542250096797943, 0.0387423001229763, 0.0032796452287584543, 0.06693962216377258, -0.0018489661160856485, 0.0017674965783953667, -0.015515275299549103, -0.03789963573217392, 0.03422078490257263, -0.031560953706502914, -0.021444490179419518, -0.021703453734517097, 0.0060323928482830524, -0.050639808177948, 0.036362726241350174, -0.008695441298186779, 0.023604977875947952, -0.058782439678907394, 0.007044701371341944, -0.009974285028874874, 0.03202145919203758, 0.0009635864407755435, -0.021629517897963524, 0.02945587784051895, 0.004531331360340118, 0.016955306753516197, -0.03751854971051216, -0.023370040580630302, -0.0356740728020668, -0.015460910275578499, 0.02663528546690941, -0.029681487008929253, -0.018256796523928642, -0.035388339310884476, -0.008069868199527264, 0.047066569328308105, -0.012059330940246582, 0.023876599967479706, 0.022333446890115738, 0.02214730530977249, -0.007535463664680719, -0.05880912020802498, -0.008705999702215195, 0.012876235879957676, -0.028820142149925232, 0.04315739497542381, -0.040086690336465836, 0.015925003215670586, -0.0013964426470920444, -0.014321527443826199, -0.06536968797445297, -0.04518745094537735, -0.009728960692882538, 0.019242385402321815, -0.0018882994772866368, -0.0044507537968456745, 0.027924994006752968, -0.00023501989198848605, -0.04371025040745735, -0.027516692876815796, 0.05937492474913597, 0.004144467879086733, -0.024169644340872765, -0.004404846113175154, -0.00810631737112999, 0.07093334197998047, -0.0023586684837937355, -0.018778737634420395, -0.018578488379716873, -0.013312001712620258, -0.028991324827075005, 0.01928168348968029, 0.01538135576993227, -0.03026338294148445, -0.02477368339896202, -0.02199730835855007, -0.042366765439510345, 0.048199426382780075, -0.014558900147676468, -0.0035570149775594473, -0.011311057023704052, 0.00817238911986351, -0.026822073385119438, -0.013881114311516285, -0.0051787244156003, -0.017949366942048073, 0.02451247349381447, 0.011652238667011261, -0.010358799248933792, -0.04628781974315643, -0.017286423593759537, 0.03626280277967453, 0.02849751152098179, -0.009225049056112766, 3.709665747919644e-7, 0.0594550296664238, -0.008752097375690937, 0.017204781994223595, -0.037722066044807434, -0.021146543323993683, 0.030727054923772812, -0.008879336528480053, 0.018613582476973534, 0.024245640262961388, 0.019014889374375343, -0.03841057047247887, 0.00015856385289225727, -0.05229657515883446, -0.0030077749397605658, 0.08265663683414459, -0.030103469267487526, 0.08787746727466583, 0.03449948877096176, 0.0006636396865360439, 0.0025859051384031773, -0.008621394634246826, -0.01708609238266945, 0.03809288144111633, -0.018104009330272675, 0.023394528776407242, -0.022352203726768494, -0.02925730124115944, 0.0089584244415164, 0.001327820704318583, 0.022524399682879448, 0.037208545953035355, -0.017517821863293648, 0.0528392568230629, -0.011596019379794598, 0.007098713889718056, -0.03532106801867485, 0.03698214888572693, -0.0183033999055624, 0.002248839708045125, -0.018962692469358444, -0.018144311383366585, 0.046120524406433105, 0.03259573131799698, -0.02159426175057888, -0.06087249517440796, -0.037852562963962555, -0.02004908211529255, 0.0012470765504986048, 0.028958536684513092, -0.024222545325756073, 0.011545374989509583, 0.02005620487034321, 0.0015024258755147457, -0.007959284819662571, 0.025416001677513123, -0.013063376769423485, -0.07280643284320831, -0.03879062086343765, -0.027748867869377136, -0.03521574288606644, 0.03212086111307144, 0.03154855594038963, -0.05520587041974068, 0.025105267763137817, -0.015875963494181633, 0.01322509441524744, 0.03494776040315628, -0.001397730316966772, -0.04773799329996109, 0.06863118708133698, -0.00713512534275651, 0.00781954824924469, -0.002728900173678994, -0.006830716039985418, 0.09048230946063995, 0.08879788219928741, 0.021048562601208687, -0.07530516386032104, 0.006245083175599575, -0.0050422148779034615, -0.0072212484665215015, -0.05477948486804962, 0.00942958239465952, 0.03382297605276108, 0.044399555772542953, 0.03404615446925163, 0.028584200888872147, 0.03541805222630501, -0.0061597805470228195, 0.040451548993587494, -0.001480043400079012, -0.022462284192442894, 0.010166559368371964, 0.019350819289684296, 0.014563256874680519, -0.003068851074203849, -0.045731574296951294, -0.008605857379734516, -0.00711989589035511, 0.008533374406397343, -0.037572942674160004, -0.01910383068025112, 0.02811487205326557, -0.008447747677564621, -0.01197753008455038, -0.007585939019918442, 0.023999996483325958, -0.006152877118438482, 0.011183228343725204, 0.03155587613582611, 0.03885693848133087, -0.03716285899281502, -0.00019568021525628865, -0.011564637534320354, -0.006143597420305014, -0.015911052003502846, 0.01147110853344202, 0.00010951684816973284, -0.04727493226528168, -0.02954903244972229, -0.03552304208278656, 0.020574631169438362, -0.012490415014326572, 0.010214708745479584, 0.03208210691809654, 0.01692904345691204, 0.0007110250880941749, -0.04229927808046341, -0.010768108069896698, 0.03350909799337387, 0.017911367118358612, -0.02625022456049919, -0.012923052534461021, -0.06084747239947319, 0.013442332856357098, -0.033595651388168335, 0.051288310438394547, 0.018638240173459053, -0.03467068448662758, 0.031588759273290634, -0.016172653064131737, 0.053284723311662674, -0.005887349136173725, -0.00095215073088184, 0.009051663801074028, -0.00214439257979393, -0.05330077186226845, -0.024772342294454575, -0.0005749941919930279, -0.004087171051651239, 0.020126167684793472, -0.014132381416857243, -0.0005535289528779685, 0.0014875944470986724, -0.0434795618057251, 0.02291499637067318, 0.02380427159368992, -0.017964249476790428, -0.056535329669713974, 0.005130027886480093, 0.053653646260499954, 0.027931705117225647, 0.027067463845014572, 0.008484701626002789, -0.010608169250190258, 0.014497563242912292, 0.036929331719875336, -0.03700149804353714, 0.005761821288615465, 0.02490721456706524, -0.03609976917505264, 0.015970075502991676, -0.00671155983582139, 0.03584124520421028, 0.05015496537089348, -0.0067317127250134945, -0.039697278290987015, 0.0019057872705161572, -0.01213238574564457, 0.0019130184082314372, -0.010087313130497932, -0.0171348974108696, -0.011144857853651047, 0.01269633136689663, -0.0021824880968779325, -0.04552249237895012, -0.01707630045711994, -0.058207299560308456, -0.02234085649251938, 0.005747761577367783, 0.014772196300327778, -0.050946194678545, -0.02393466793000698, 0.012918392196297646, 0.038009271025657654, -0.01456898357719183, -0.029810382053256035, -0.055394746363162994, 0.040253423154354095, 0.01580706797540188, -0.012365424074232578, -0.02004755288362503, 0.028540048748254776, -0.011259390041232109, 0.003163625719025731, 0.0433342419564724, 0.026371832937002182, 0.026816628873348236, -0.0028433832339942455, -0.006648237816989422, -0.01645306684076786, 0.07802330702543259, -0.028420500457286835, -0.033417508006095886, 0.05326526612043381, -0.0084833400323987, -0.02357371337711811, 0.02823450230062008, -0.00682242214679718, 0.05009165778756142, 0.02801564335823059, 0.011957195587456226, -0.018528232350945473, 0.04624044522643089, -0.03732980042695999, 0.00020511614275164902, -0.03179405629634857, -0.014034283347427845, -0.03983576223254204, -0.0060094259679317474, -0.009987291879951954, -0.027966104447841644, -0.0213021133095026, -0.0012108779046684504, 0.05122070759534836, -0.0017930447356775403, -0.019555935636162758, 0.0029444326646625996, 0.012184455059468746, 0.014844642952084541, 0.01716640219092369, -0.024066822603344917, 0.00552296033129096, 0.04942810535430908, -0.03204118087887764, 0.03159881383180618, 0.008944603614509106, 0.018791448324918747, -0.0765366330742836, -0.015628810971975327, 0.01873166300356388, -0.0076134237460792065, 0.038475848734378815, -0.05181795731186867, 0.011121193878352642, 0.028142433613538742, -0.04702049121260643, 0.031580425798892975, -0.028292611241340637, -0.052218981087207794, 0.0019833450205624104, 0.01661745086312294, 0.008746946230530739, 0.05077814310789108, 0.03159641847014427, 0.02278011478483677, 0.007634373847395182, 0.014908583834767342, 0.0068472386337816715, 0.01713957078754902, -0.05344942584633827, 0.014989099465310574, 0.007692525628954172, -0.06366266310214996, 0.05475005879998207, -0.028420880436897278, -0.03950239717960358, 0.06892576813697815, -0.039547767490148544, -0.026282574981451035, 0.02784152887761593, 0.039337143301963806, -0.007483271416276693, 0.007538052275776863, 0.009290662594139576, -0.03176933899521828, -0.027602149173617363, 0.01492665708065033, 0.024402646347880363, 0.010013972409069538, -0.004904210101813078, 0.004175841808319092, 0.003390829311683774, 0.00794493593275547, -0.05166909098625183, 0.036701757460832596, -0.018895020708441734, -0.02233266271650791, -0.0023441999219357967, -0.0323350764811039, 0.01714434288442135, -0.032396409660577774, 0.03954094275832176, -0.051716484129428864, -0.004693781025707722, 0.023914530873298645, 0.03848928213119507, -0.031046733260154724, 0.0022288456093519926, 0.006102444604039192, -0.022194145247340202, 0.010319014079868793, 0.012349387630820274, -0.025526316836476326, -0.03919800743460655, -0.014180703088641167, 0.01873556151986122, -0.028275366872549057, 0.008517677895724773, -0.04514350742101669, -0.03131836652755737, 0.05770916864275932, 0.007387952413409948, 0.001692986930720508, 0.026655729860067368, -0.04297778010368347, -0.02531621977686882, -0.08665037900209427, 0.04194685071706772, -0.019752131775021553, -0.031530555337667465, -0.03474491089582443, 0.007331270258873701, -0.04436766356229782, -0.008587993681430817, 0.06898708641529083, -0.015857163816690445, -0.001643459196202457, -0.02619185671210289, 0.013164888136088848, 0.023070290684700012, -0.03655063360929489, 0.005531203467398882, -0.007895013317465782, -0.024278409779071808, 0.005791673436760902, -0.016788071021437645, 0.007192361168563366, 0.01175056304782629, 0.007466014940291643, -0.026570718735456467, 0.022248826920986176, -0.005807788576930761, 0.016705242916941643, 0.0653892308473587, 0.03069170005619526, 0.017493676394224167, 0.07860374450683594, -0.03288388252258301, 0.010318516753613949, 0.03694639354944229, -0.007782458793371916, -0.04164070636034012, 0.0309460312128067, 0.008681081235408783, -0.021187033504247665, 0.03156869485974312, 0.04887259006500244, 0.0023259734734892845, -0.0646287351846695, -0.034156683832407, 0.04583744332194328, -0.03743499889969826, -0.037637270987033844, 0.044467080384492874, 0.013544450514018536, 0.013311441987752914, -0.0036929408088326454, 0.033251479268074036, -0.010105523280799389, -0.004208361729979515, 0.008036293089389801, 0.05026931315660477, 0.06692086160182953, 0.0010094933677464724, 0.056345462799072266, 0.0027296943590044975, -0.009204139932990074, 0.01824633963406086, -0.05382408946752548, 0.03747573494911194, -0.060659535229206085, -0.036316413432359695, 0.015249000862240791, -0.015099072828888893, 0.04386203736066818, 0.007546822540462017, -0.019028760492801666, 0.055710867047309875, -0.07856209576129913, 0.00044230269850231707, -0.011842424049973488, -0.013444391079246998, -0.03514798358082771, -0.025654029101133347, 0.03474126383662224, 0.023858115077018738, 0.008437340147793293, -0.01749883033335209, 0.0019377896096557379, -0.044955622404813766, 0.01905965991318226, -0.03089725784957409, 0.010000450536608696, -0.03241432458162308, 0.0168737955391407, -0.0232816394418478, 0.009810931980609894, -0.03989493474364281, 0.006638869643211365, 0.05413276329636574, 0.057338014245033264, 0.018247755244374275, 0.012358816340565681, -0.016519056633114815, 0.016911963000893593, 0.06398771703243256, -0.07911328226327896, -0.024710921570658684, -0.032875556498765945, 0.03171153366565704, 0.018659371882677078, -0.009164593182504177 ]
<p>I need to be <em>neat</em> in measuring the success rate of a treatment. It is anyway pretty high. But as it is all about ecology, multpliying experiments is difficult.</p> <p>I have treated $N = 20$ individuals, $18$ succeded. This is a $\tau = .9$ success rate.</p> <p>I used the <em>Jeffrey's table</em> to get the uncertainty about this rate (<a href="http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/2676784?uid=3739328&amp;uid=2&amp;uid=4&amp;sid=21104010444151" rel="nofollow">Brown 2013</a>), which seems then to be $CI_{95\%} = [.716,.979]$.</p> <p>Now, to be really neat, I'd like to increase it a little, taking into account the fact that, in reality, $N = N_1 + N_2 + N_3 + N_4$ with all $N_i = 5$, for the treatments have been given at 4 different dates.</p> <p>How do I take this replication into account ? How do I integrate a random factor to a proportion estimation ?</p> <p>I am aware it might be too much for not much, and that the raw data for $N = 20$ will be pretty convincing anyway. :)</p> <p>[EDIT:]</p> <p>A more narrow question seems to arise from your comments : How do I estimate, in the first place, whether or not the date $i$ is likely to have an impact on the success rate? Put it another way: How do I assess the null hypothesis $H_0: \tau_1 = \tau_2 = \dots$ with this (rather poor) data?</p> <ul> <li>If this hypothesis was to be validated by the data, then I would use this $CI_{95\%}$ and everthing would be fine.</li> <li>If it was to be invalidated by the data then How much wider should it be? (it would then represent the confidence interval of an "overall success rate $\tau$" (?))</li> </ul> <p>(once again, GLMs do seem to be the immediate answer but I'm far below their asymptotic assumptions..)</p> <p>(and once again, at the end of the day, $N$ might actually turn out to be so low that <em>doing statistics</em> is not a relevant option anymore ;)</p>
74,203
[ -0.00866659451276064, -0.05921880528330803, -0.001156045706011355, -0.022793710231781006, 0.05628510192036629, 0.0015206621028482914, -0.0175599604845047, -0.024033112451434135, 0.007870354689657688, -0.030281275510787964, 0.05977534502744675, 0.058610182255506516, 0.04076586291193962, 0.050537385046482086, 0.0013000787002965808, 0.01927795074880123, -0.023050446063280106, 0.03903166204690933, -0.011080740951001644, 0.04034443572163582, 0.052135515958070755, 0.030214352533221245, -0.009623605757951736, -0.03416239470243454, -0.06120551377534866, 0.006311649922281504, 0.037363357841968536, -0.024336135014891624, -0.060321394354104996, 0.035817503929138184, -0.03794005140662193, -0.041331078857183456, 0.045970749109983444, 0.023650428280234337, -0.005208533722907305, -0.015745248645544052, -0.01388306450098753, -0.02146119624376297, 0.031416263431310654, 0.049124397337436676, -0.04283136501908302, -0.029372623190283775, 0.010663241147994995, 0.0070482585579156876, -0.0016038587782531977, 0.01885426789522171, -0.0182658601552248, -0.014712395146489143, 0.04518653452396393, -0.017820684239268303, 0.07589509338140488, 0.013400197960436344, 0.014086815528571606, -0.00402443390339613, -0.015725620090961456, -0.04462919756770134, 0.04243706911802292, 0.03979402408003807, 0.007490934804081917, -0.047101084142923355, -0.012912081554532051, -0.054925695061683655, -0.012081137858331203, -0.019571779295802116, -0.0056001958437263966, 0.011760696768760681, 0.001131584169343114, -0.028149902820587158, 0.027106788009405136, -0.043691545724868774, 0.008575730957090855, 0.004580008797347546, 0.0452147051692009, 0.02544764243066311, -0.013023399747908115, -0.004505657125264406, 0.026498468592762947, 0.021044371649622917, 0.02258642390370369, 0.028891349211335182, -0.023467203602194786, -0.004529735539108515, 0.026077164337038994, 0.062011681497097015, 0.031064216047525406, -0.02996896207332611, 0.03483403101563454, -0.03598583862185478, 0.03785615786910057, 0.027839554473757744, -0.006527530495077372, -0.009393563494086266, 0.055802784860134125, -0.015494748018682003, -0.038718655705451965, 0.009599732235074043, 0.009034509770572186, 0.01971515081822872, -0.02658243291079998, 0.02176257222890854, -0.023293346166610718, -0.02619040198624134, -0.002625060500577092, 0.0921475738286972, -0.030505096539855003, -0.02286786586046219, -0.02257300540804863, -0.0142749585211277, -0.014448410831391811, -0.054654791951179504, -0.016832243651151657, 0.04632525518536568, 0.00555373914539814, -0.013699585571885109, 0.002465135185047984, -0.02871803008019924, -0.021225662901997566, -0.03420340642333031, 0.10546361654996872, 0.03384595736861229, 0.0024036357644945383, -0.016319677233695984, 0.02103114128112793, -0.006502883043140173, -0.01550387591123581, 0.030193950980901718, 0.004053360782563686, -0.024594245478510857, 0.006033992860466242, 0.02724308706820011, 0.018493974581360817, -0.005275490693747997, 0.011837252415716648, 0.018880009651184082, 0.009004673920571804, -0.018012354150414467, -0.07737202942371368, -0.024141715839505196, 0.08196710050106049, -0.05027041584253311, -0.0010043428046628833, -0.0940174087882042, 0.009473430924117565, 0.02680002525448799, 0.03082403913140297, -0.0036515856627374887, 0.035951558500528336, -0.00282924878410995, 0.04409049451351166, 0.05947069451212883, 0.01915757544338703, -0.0009370024199597538, -0.028317730873823166, -0.0300509724766016, -0.07386749237775803, -0.07929812371730804, 0.030673742294311523, 0.004305354319512844, 0.007868540473282337, -0.024671386927366257, 0.06731703132390976, 0.019673848524689674, -0.012427310459315777, 0.02150207944214344, 0.04850827530026436, -0.010451198555529118, 0.05222563073039055, 0.03359018638730049, 0.019256889820098877, 0.011313658207654953, -0.044296666979789734, 0.015353528782725334, 0.011268948204815388, 0.04961176961660385, 0.02474687620997429, -0.04939810559153557, 0.024517374113202095, -0.01820879988372326, -0.029494740068912506, -0.0020327032543718815, -0.025431400164961815, 0.006576869171112776, -0.04404551163315773, -0.02949550747871399, 0.03381859511137009, -0.0016071837162598968, -0.018865082412958145, 0.009643517434597015, 0.009095900692045689, -0.038884688168764114, -0.029844436794519424, -0.07113848626613617, -0.010975024662911892, 0.019082175567746162, -0.04374949261546135, 0.012866826727986336, -0.015476608648896217, -0.002757174428552389, 0.03212546557188034, -0.0006922580068930984, 0.004059327766299248, -0.0014524967409670353, 0.062054116278886795, -0.01654054783284664, 0.010178648866713047, 0.04289229214191437, 0.040671348571777344, 0.013885295018553734, 0.06480752676725388, -0.04416628181934357, -0.05166575312614441, -0.049676164984703064, -0.038295697420835495, 0.0023628666531294584, -0.0022072456777095795, -0.022647984325885773, 0.02117397077381611, -0.0464019812643528, -0.0166658703237772, 0.03213534876704216, -0.032528966665267944, 0.06782935559749603, 0.04793728515505791, 0.0012788728345185518, 0.024492239579558372, 0.011878264136612415, 0.006283923052251339, 0.014303624629974365, 0.0034975723829120398, -0.01173189003020525, -0.061593007296323776, -0.0009043920435942709, 0.014560889452695847, 0.013866758905351162, -0.008560358546674252, 0.021025458350777626, 0.05464119464159012, 0.038990844041109085, 0.01447816751897335, 0.02758106403052807, 0.006718734744936228, -0.02206060290336609, 0.030477257445454597, 0.010341282933950424, 0.0012075371341779828, 0.016581296920776367, 0.009607063606381416, -0.014721100218594074, 0.04260946065187454, 0.012289735488593578, 0.0007483161170966923, 0.009299326688051224, 0.003659748937934637, -0.006863560993224382, -0.02695036679506302, 0.0024531104136258364, 0.028891248628497124, 0.0006237657507881522, 0.008033251389861107, 0.03708651661872864, 0.03469134867191315, -0.0013962029479444027, -0.023563243448734283, -0.03678182512521744, 0.014381890185177326, 0.01787271350622177, -0.028360610827803612, -0.0002482722920831293, 0.008917623199522495, 0.0062181586399674416, 0.017964312806725502, -0.05294656753540039, -0.013450740836560726, -0.013685783371329308, -0.03236400708556175, 0.010137938894331455, 0.004463887307792902, 0.026003651320934296, -0.023513415828347206, 0.018632229417562485, -0.009882609359920025, 0.028001980856060982, 0.011733975261449814, 0.01656297966837883, -0.05892269313335419, -0.019810685887932777, -0.009293360635638237, 0.009453917853534222, 0.022099345922470093, -0.00867417175322771, -0.005578710697591305, 0.04514190927147865, 0.014855827204883099, -0.04116020351648331, -0.0487792044878006, -0.030116872861981392, -0.0012189052067697048, -0.06246741861104965, -0.007122349925339222, 0.041904862970113754, 0.03579959645867348, -0.059325266629457474, 0.03424406796693802, -0.005440260749310255, -0.01887613534927368, 0.013915115967392921, 0.016312524676322937, -0.0025379792787134647, -0.025593169033527374, -0.009732471778988838, 0.014494308270514011, 0.022531092166900635, -0.04400356858968735, -0.09775194525718689, -0.045699771493673325, 0.003540160832926631, 0.009848354384303093, 0.04737500101327896, -0.005727551877498627, 0.009594321250915527, 0.06276983767747879, 0.04237616807222366, -0.008294059894979, -0.0320710763335228, -0.003669729456305504, -0.0068319677375257015, -0.0355321541428566, 0.03338395059108734, 0.032940056174993515, -0.0016034941654652357, 0.0185349490493536, -0.023636003956198692, -0.010330484248697758, 0.0530974343419075, 0.018092136830091476, 0.0035804463550448418, 0.0355985090136528, 0.019401466473937035, -0.007676667533814907, 0.0376693531870842, 0.013445129618048668, -0.035530757158994675, -0.005490467883646488, -0.025798289105296135, 0.01072174683213234, 0.0294143408536911, -0.09887734055519104, 0.03100575879216194, -0.01842786744236946, -0.01875894144177437, -0.020505471155047417, 0.03350939229130745, 0.008048242889344692, -0.03913692757487297, 0.00787026435136795, -0.0056333052925765514, 0.06271345168352127, -0.021537888795137405, 0.017407918348908424, 0.080439992249012, 0.04936729371547699, 0.015221570618450642, -0.007301668636500835, -0.02410776913166046, -0.00029193537193350494, -0.024293798953294754, -0.022881189361214638, 0.016164729371666908, 0.02889110893011093, 0.04849272966384888, 0.005793614313006401, -0.024051425978541374, -0.007744740694761276, -0.01710650511085987, -0.05699717998504639, 0.012558463960886002, -0.05308741703629494, 0.030213607475161552, 0.007948172278702259, 0.007354449015110731, -0.01073041558265686, -0.023308217525482178, -0.0005040420801378787, -0.017895860597491264, -0.03996453061699867, 0.02230302430689335, 0.006404093001037836, -0.020518746227025986, 0.021763890981674194, -0.059750333428382874, 0.031011000275611877, 0.016691621392965317, 0.021545618772506714, -0.025933729484677315, 0.03525137901306152, 0.008200140669941902, 0.017735661938786507, -0.002917650854215026, -0.03514378145337105, -0.010097833350300789, 0.020453041419386864, 0.02043522149324417, -0.010468907654285431, -0.0010351819219067693, 0.02030470222234726, 0.019909275695681572, -0.010161726735532284, -0.05461869016289711, -0.011081395670771599, 0.03862381726503372, 0.04182615503668785, 0.012201427482068539, 0.020909328013658524, -0.07479272037744522, 0.023597445338964462, 0.014358874410390854, 0.04989657551050186, 0.04848482459783554, 0.04222925752401352, -0.01241149753332138, 0.0038267357740551233, 0.03165837377309799, 0.018810875713825226, 0.009711998514831066, 0.0014104502042755485, 0.005535138305276632, 0.053004395216703415, 0.03407701477408409, -0.014951121062040329, 0.0037607289850711823, 0.027503035962581635, -0.026791971176862717, 0.036624033004045486, -0.051883287727832794, -0.04958977550268173, 0.017596399411559105, 0.01695353351533413, -0.002367079257965088, 0.029031902551651, 0.0021261314395815134, -0.016024580225348473, 0.051769983023405075, 0.012249739840626717, -0.03196506202220917, 0.03170588240027428, -0.01040155254304409, 0.05655156075954437, 0.006650425493717194, -0.02092609368264675, -0.025833236053586006, 0.04074219986796379, 0.04745998606085777, 0.03267578408122063, 0.021827571094036102, -0.052179429680109024, -0.046665653586387634, 0.009511779993772507, 0.03807422146201134, -0.04030352085828781, 0.02159964293241501, -0.06112895905971527, -0.017647158354520798, 0.003452941309660673, -0.01817341148853302, 0.01583935134112835, 0.0006453813402913511, 0.014372476376593113, -0.03792706876993179, -0.046687051653862, -0.03475657477974892, 0.010077805258333683, -0.015989143401384354, 0.02298656478524208, -0.006306689698249102, -0.00813321117311716, -0.026130083948373795, 0.014632006175816059, 0.03547678142786026, 0.05867701396346092, -0.019159769639372826, -0.011797037906944752, 0.025342348963022232, 0.0004242055583745241, -0.002304073888808489, -0.039860501885414124, 0.05346434935927391, 0.03130529448390007, 0.019901547580957413, 0.05687238276004791, -0.052356697618961334, -0.000872284232173115, 0.051990121603012085, -0.005246086977422237, -0.033879514783620834, -0.010245469398796558, -0.06498634815216064, 0.006166533101350069, -0.0046120332553982735, 0.0059175328351557255, 0.06400752067565918, 0.04081333056092262, -0.02128584496676922, 0.04129728674888611, -0.057271406054496765, 0.0016697522951290011, -0.021758873015642166, -0.010656489990651608, -0.033763062208890915, 0.022941116243600845, 0.002485461300238967, 0.019073842093348503, 0.0015235083410516381, 0.03735588490962982, -0.009835685603320599, -0.011119694449007511, 0.004286561626940966, 0.009849123656749725, -0.01917092874646187, -0.009654635563492775, 0.020213522017002106, -0.03030235320329666, 0.010965565219521523, -0.005886433646082878, -0.0004151132015977055, -0.031893838196992874, 0.023897657170891762, -0.002986133797094226, -0.03231615573167801, 0.009099841117858887, -0.03688140958547592, -0.025263044983148575, -0.0016004904173314571, 0.017495406791567802, 0.023266419768333435, -0.04133763909339905, 0.031002525240182877, -0.030760999768972397, -0.03951212018728256, -0.0087653873488307, 0.03642725571990013, 0.010537806898355484, 0.019841071218252182, 0.008754018694162369, -0.015656515955924988, 0.0007170634926296771, 0.02304091677069664, -0.05583987385034561, 0.019183380529284477, 0.022121071815490723, 0.018626302480697632, -0.0335492379963398, -0.03793342784047127, -0.047858599573373795, 0.013326006941497326, -0.04358941689133644, 0.0029474638868123293, 0.05072994902729988, -0.03023182973265648, -0.026073576882481575, -0.03713581711053848, 0.028818214312195778, 0.06978000700473785, -0.02508879452943802, -0.01399946678429842, 0.028000017628073692, -0.034574173390865326, -0.018004106357693672, 0.00983631331473589, -0.04649733379483223, -0.046965256333351135, -0.004149262327700853, -0.05644094944000244, -0.0016704635927453637, 0.02889232710003853, -0.014598441310226917, -0.030755233019590378, 0.011937719769775867, -0.010485579259693623, -0.006756540387868881, -0.03922324255108833, 0.005764276720583439, 0.012532118707895279, 0.005407419521361589, -0.0048010037280619144, 0.033036913722753525, 0.0159737728536129, -0.007060336880385876, 0.02755380980670452, -0.00955200381577015, -0.0160788856446743, 0.0026712610851973295, 0.06407272070646286, -0.03363381698727608, -0.022880593314766884, 0.008911393582820892, -0.021534297615289688, 0.008446679450571537, 0.024447359144687653, 0.011520227417349815, 0.014350525103509426, -0.0007233313517645001, -0.04166370630264282, -0.01988610439002514, -0.06355752795934677, 0.010020271874964237, 0.03792990744113922, -0.016997413709759712, 0.002510395832359791, 0.021063515916466713, 0.0026972852647304535, -0.014947304502129555, -0.012031213380396366, 0.03135782107710838, -0.007317291107028723, -0.002716412302106619, 0.034504733979701996, 0.0052512953989207745, -0.02940201573073864, 0.048941098153591156, 0.024092581123113632, 0.008905650116503239, 0.04586246982216835, 0.04147130623459816, 0.006859851069748402, 0.023992326110601425, -0.050222501158714294, -0.05284079909324646, 0.03147359564900398, -0.06555727124214172, 0.0271010585129261, -0.05688755214214325, -0.0319630391895771, 0.02033424563705921, 0.046180061995983124, 0.01389985904097557, -0.06060533598065376, -0.036393407732248306, -0.01255650632083416, -0.010952241718769073, 0.036253273487091064, -0.020727258175611496, 0.04060935601592064, 0.01086089201271534, 0.02757824771106243, -0.016981570050120354, 0.03512086346745491, -0.01785171963274479, -0.09676298499107361, -0.0056648957543075085, -0.00236516329459846, -0.03024958446621895, 0.05232783406972885, -0.014409149065613747, -0.015121309086680412, -0.0032494845800101757, -0.02013017050921917, -0.029503589496016502, 0.007532850373536348, 0.04544670879840851, -0.017741000279784203, 0.032916709780693054, 0.03428469970822334, -0.020617861300706863, -0.0016967233968898654, -0.02598257176578045, 0.13737298548221588, 0.06810365617275238, 0.03627368435263634, -0.021679239347577095, 0.0293947234749794, 0.024846792221069336, 0.01389752235263586, -0.012014168314635754, -0.03651932626962662, 0.02077646553516388, -0.0583796463906765, 0.036021895706653595, 0.0413375124335289, -0.004584021400660276, -0.03820858895778656, 0.050495464354753494, -0.004539504647254944, -0.03693154826760292, -0.011212566867470741, 0.0002977100375574082, 0.03864522650837898, -0.01832744851708412, -0.026338739320635796, 0.0022479789331555367, 0.007035731803625822, -0.021023958921432495, -0.015055143274366856, -0.010015334002673626, -0.013037831522524357, 0.003886642400175333, -0.021416248753666878, -0.018303802236914635, 0.01089986227452755, 0.003881352487951517, -0.016852719709277153, -0.02794516645371914, -0.0016079824417829514, -0.038877833634614944, 0.015650495886802673, 0.06167646497488022, 0.0072313291020691395, 0.0026304740458726883, 0.026267927139997482, 0.03767719864845276, -0.06243021786212921, -0.04140576720237732, -0.05326193571090698, 0.03058118186891079, -0.04101834446191788, -0.016132904216647148, -0.03554217889904976, 0.011780355125665665, 0.025901852175593376, -0.012614293023943901, -0.010686754249036312, 0.020421363413333893, 0.04770469292998314, -0.02665701135993004, -0.02886826917529106, 0.029434164986014366, -0.001552217872813344, -0.010576233267784119, 0.04753115028142929, 0.05486816167831421, -0.008644466288387775, -0.05300399288535118, -0.025859972462058067, -0.000575075566302985, 0.03704711049795151, -0.008148066699504852, -0.035021815448999405, -0.02722136676311493, -0.023386511951684952, 0.03985345736145973, -0.03473370894789696, 0.013791508972644806, 0.02942558564245701, -0.006230078637599945, -0.012301011011004448, -0.027324816212058067, -0.06257417052984238, 0.01088547334074974, -0.04204240441322327, 0.033129263669252396, -0.05941462144255638, -0.0074462429620325565, -0.0055471197701990604, 0.03527265042066574, -0.02039523236453533, 0.04882628470659256, -0.024573206901550293, 0.05291937664151192, 0.03902842104434967, -0.021825093775987625, -0.041046567261219025, -0.01894628256559372, -0.010495678521692753, -0.044648416340351105, -0.0254085473716259, 0.05290168151259422, 0.02425064705312252, 0.00430168304592371, 0.027348486706614494, 0.009584656916558743, 0.004878625739365816, -0.011107449419796467, 0.02045527659356594, -0.059417251497507095, 0.029645586386322975, 0.00795363262295723, 0.030312027782201767, -0.014564987272024155, -0.0044587585143744946, -0.014573887921869755, -0.028455941006541252, -0.021493421867489815, -0.05486077815294266, -0.031696613878011703, -0.016247296705842018, -0.018699636682868004, 0.022821826860308647, 0.0009814929217100143, -0.03233182057738304, -0.037578776478767395, -0.0066492389887571335, -0.007054897956550121, 0.020843133330345154, -0.02076730690896511, 0.02063506469130516, 0.011353608220815659, 0.005366760306060314, 0.0653591901063919, 0.008252907544374466, 0.006706393323838711, -0.03716827556490898, 0.0034855580888688564, 0.033968545496463776, 0.03211760148406029, 0.024734629318118095, 0.0015942222671583295, 0.04950997233390808, -0.05250097066164017, -0.049711924046278, 0.02824162133038044, 0.02873951569199562, 0.02697065845131874, 0.009271404705941677, 0.02601439505815506, -0.019896548241376877, 0.037110570818185806, -0.07139212638139725, -0.014910927973687649, -0.003474049735814333, 0.0029302574694156647, 0.0018067507771775126, -0.0047899456694722176, -0.01160354632884264, 0.05153721570968628, 0.02188309282064438, 0.030170060694217682, 0.035940080881118774, 0.023852979764342308, 0.011295781470835209, 0.005356678273528814, -0.01754120923578739, 0.013846968300640583, -0.006998472381383181, -0.029072806239128113, -0.006775625515729189, 0.0763280838727951, -0.035936858505010605, 0.03829579055309296, 0.002121011959388852, 0.026145296171307564, -0.08600570261478424, -0.017309114336967468, 0.02850588597357273, 0.05098073184490204, 0.04881212115287781, -0.03128466010093689, 0.019610466435551643, -0.005671971011906862, -0.004792587365955114, 0.044298190623521805, -0.007959235459566116, -0.005309061612933874, -0.03370652347803116, -0.013802113942801952, -0.005835673306137323, -0.001421912107616663, 0.05001329630613327, 0.02535238303244114, -0.0052640982903540134, 0.06774678826332092, -0.01665482111275196, -0.01224436704069376, 0.03467518091201782, 0.0025308565236628056, 0.0485355369746685, -0.042103447020053864, 0.024556200951337814, -0.0003958502784371376, -0.037029754370450974, 0.037556085735559464, 0.007214078679680824, 0.04797642305493355, 0.0019064114894717932, 0.028466183692216873, 0.022772876545786858, 0.04117059335112572, 0.023233497515320778, -0.005574233364313841, 0.014619954861700535, -0.01869063451886177, -0.0014441992389038205, 0.03229483589529991, -0.020653456449508667, -0.012068533338606358, 0.05210475996136665, -0.013493306934833527, -0.04943437874317169, -0.0006267110002227128, 0.018552178516983986, -0.01129965577274561, 0.001885337638668716, -0.048445459455251694, 0.013080386444926262, -0.006947333458811045, -0.0055459532886743546, -0.016462907195091248, 0.00008116762910503894, 0.03879644349217415, 0.017268091440200806, -0.025018978863954544, 0.008702904917299747, -0.04155201464891434, -0.005306820850819349, -0.018909607082605362, 0.0023881501983851194, 0.018214832991361618, -0.0761001855134964, -0.019146066159009933, -0.03699992224574089, 0.019757136702537537, -0.04044722020626068, 0.01994882896542549, -0.060745738446712494, 0.0396934449672699, -0.019861409440636635, -0.014602400362491608, 0.01152911875396967, 0.012072657234966755, 0.018804116174578667, -0.04240194708108902, 0.05000175163149834, 0.03862999752163887, 0.027592802420258522, -0.05380692705512047, 0.0073255631141364574, -0.005972682032734156, 0.0030619993340224028, 0.04390944540500641, 0.012000353075563908, 0.002435843925923109, 0.013595739379525185, 0.06738410145044327, 0.014821772463619709, -0.048313431441783905, 0.057373564690351486, -0.014774244278669357, 0.019103799015283585, -0.058374449610710144, -0.013043450191617012, 0.0004475693276617676, -0.022512298077344894, 0.03641578182578087, -0.01062955241650343, 0.019675174728035927, 0.005683054216206074, -0.028911514207720757, 0.019134391099214554, -0.005530955735594034, -0.033984456211328506, 0.02932378277182579, -0.015022211708128452, -0.0026596062816679478, 0.013301705941557884, -0.01021649595350027, -0.08240383863449097, 0.03689173236489296, -0.0347144678235054, -0.03532087802886963, -0.007507427595555782, 0.015750212594866753, -0.030020127072930336, -0.06490617245435715, -0.0025419415906071663, 0.036723289638757706, -0.008466369472444057, 0.008761724457144737, -0.004070740193128586, 0.01710803620517254, 0.03316045552492142, 0.009163080714643002, 0.02460957132279873, -0.011401663534343243, -0.0038817995227873325, -0.026458585634827614, 0.0013925052480772138, 0.011690624989569187, -0.031156368553638458, -0.012005116790533066, 0.016252603381872177, 0.03391323983669281, 0.004584719892591238, 0.012734995223581791, 0.011771396733820438, -0.04319421201944351, -0.012379332445561886, 0.057756055146455765, 0.01004201639443636, 0.004189472179859877, 0.00492011709138751, 0.02060345560312271, 0.0789438933134079, -0.008099927566945553, -0.002181337447836995, -0.02745974063873291, -0.027843281626701355, -0.012020003981888294, 0.019089307636022568, 0.005984353832900524, 0.02676396258175373, -0.03609559312462807, 0.03605320677161217, -0.023038409650325775, -0.0031895351130515337, 0.06469426304101944, -0.047332148998975754, 0.01778281480073929, 0.021186374127864838, 0.002316893544048071, -0.035439733415842056, -0.019441857933998108, -0.042523451149463654, -0.04877109080553055, -0.01487056165933609, 0.025445764884352684, 0.009158882312476635, -0.0015450832433998585, -0.027667256072163582, 0.032552968710660934, 0.0360320545732975, -0.030600139871239662, -0.017099061980843544, -0.02086608298122883, -0.004994496237486601, 0.018121689558029175, -0.017033247277140617 ]
<p>I have fitted a Poisson regression to my claim frequency.</p> <p>I have obtained the following result:</p> <pre><code> Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) -19.95861 1139.33678 -0.018 0.9860 make -0.10534 0.04116 -2.559 0.0105 * agevehO 0.05983 0.08580 0.697 0.4856 area1 20.68177 1139.33677 0.018 0.9855 area2 20.85866 1139.33677 0.018 0.9854 area3 20.76927 1139.33676 0.018 0.9855 --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Null deviance: 657.49 on 583 degrees of freedom Residual deviance: 150.62 on 578 degrees of freedom AIC: 1096. </code></pre> <p>My predictors area i have four levels (area 1,2,3,4) and agveh two (old and new), however for make i have four levels (make 1,2,3,4), how come it is not showing the three levels?? i am confused on how to interprete this result? Also my deviance table showed the following :</p> <pre><code> DF DEVIANCERESID DF RESIDDEV PR(&gt;CHI) make 1 13.61 582 643.88 0.0002251 *** ageveh 1 9.80 581 634.08 0.0017460 ** area 3 483.47 578 150.62 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** </code></pre> <p>Bases on this can i conclude that make ageveh and area are statistically significant in explaining my claim frequency? Thanks</p>
74,204
[ -0.005565074272453785, 0.005645156837999821, 0.0037364319432526827, 0.02346540056169033, 0.04132736101746559, -0.0011978700058534741, 0.02808264084160328, -0.026185238733887672, 0.03982225060462952, -0.03552499786019325, 0.015582837164402008, 0.029395809397101402, 0.07460810989141464, -0.012982512824237347, 0.06110183894634247, -0.00916968658566475, 0.019240161404013634, 0.008272145874798298, 0.03112156316637993, -0.05555637553334236, -0.016592802479863167, 0.04216979816555977, 0.014413515105843544, -0.03134014457464218, -0.0005260747857391834, 0.06568593531847, 0.03505663946270943, -0.002776694018393755, -0.007795081008225679, -0.012519092299044132, -0.046865422278642654, -0.04261862859129906, -0.015273578464984894, -0.01324919331818819, 0.04655490070581436, 0.031126124784350395, -0.016024364158511162, -0.018932240083813667, -0.0187982227653265, 0.05211079865694046, -0.019553128629922867, 0.007386340294033289, -0.01634211465716362, 0.018710946664214134, -0.007452179677784443, 0.008471785113215446, -0.0008835472399368882, 0.00348650268279016, 0.06750365346670151, -0.011339358054101467, 0.02463061362504959, -0.017138544470071793, 0.013901213183999062, 0.0314018651843071, -0.050052739679813385, -0.019628701731562614, 0.04508007690310478, 0.04649074003100395, -0.02578561194241047, -0.019039981067180634, 0.003478330560028553, -0.024694353342056274, 0.025850992649793625, -0.0489959679543972, -0.032461006194353104, 0.020347898826003075, -0.006045039277523756, -0.04986502230167389, 0.021589461714029312, -0.009950140491127968, 0.03647685423493385, 0.0022233950439840555, -0.01724560372531414, 0.0005951254279352725, 0.019475838169455528, -0.01324477605521679, 0.019753923639655113, 0.022707292810082436, 0.0120264096185565, 0.02456044964492321, -0.009022848680615425, 0.038361020386219025, 0.018828537315130234, 0.010251069441437721, -0.011322347447276115, 0.0269315168261528, 0.08015821874141693, -0.002425527200102806, 0.014315307140350342, 0.008665662258863449, -0.01261882297694683, 0.025882018730044365, 0.04825371876358986, 0.01887170970439911, -0.027925409376621246, 0.00860325526446104, -0.03564387187361717, 0.008416770026087761, -0.0069135925732553005, -0.001378568704240024, -0.03543462976813316, -0.04889416694641113, 0.01694484055042267, 0.013312675058841705, -0.02717558480799198, -0.008953818120062351, -0.03450854495167732, -0.04260791093111038, -0.036851126700639725, -0.035826425999403, 0.0033011147752404213, 0.019254270941019058, 0.0026794136501848698, -0.014483124949038029, -0.011504534631967545, 0.0013908026739954948, -0.0025643291883170605, 0.022712521255016327, 0.016145262867212296, 0.047425322234630585, 0.004874927457422018, -0.059765513986349106, 0.0429881326854229, -0.041719552129507065, -0.08244497328996658, 0.009188325144350529, 0.016002783551812172, -0.03144766762852669, -0.021262124180793762, 0.048261191695928574, 0.005950871855020523, -0.012486372143030167, 0.034023467451334, 0.014935906045138836, 0.017989400774240494, -0.02468940056860447, -0.06955162435770035, -0.019693711772561073, -0.003688964294269681, -0.004005432594567537, 0.024005359038710594, -0.04263017326593399, -0.006084918510168791, 0.03682068735361099, 0.04218282178044319, -0.003042456228286028, 0.01721709966659546, 0.0067826854065060616, -0.0051184482872486115, -0.0000043828699745063204, -0.04143930971622467, 0.01535695232450962, -0.04479914531111717, -0.02707003243267536, -0.0524367019534111, -0.06065977364778519, 0.015009716153144836, -0.016305899247527122, -0.005892937071621418, -0.03572876378893852, 0.036289431154727936, -0.00642437394708395, -0.0014132513897493482, 0.010856537148356438, -0.017324168235063553, -0.0077620274387300014, 0.043653011322021484, 0.018802015110850334, 0.002254999941214919, 0.030732251703739166, -0.000922116101719439, 0.003271625144407153, -0.014178937301039696, 0.06085730344057083, 0.027539871633052826, -0.00898867566138506, 0.0033402417320758104, -0.05323324352502823, 0.016827376559376717, -0.003206574125215411, -0.05907944217324257, -0.013427798636257648, -0.016161024570465088, -0.032061558216810226, 0.021654196083545685, -0.0012753007467836142, 0.0021477937698364258, -0.005678961053490639, 0.033138666301965714, -0.06024632230401039, -0.05062151700258255, -0.0415315218269825, -0.00170333799906075, -0.002854302991181612, -0.026712721213698387, -0.012173626571893692, 0.007034722715616226, 0.022244762629270554, 0.0009403589647263288, -0.000213153354707174, -0.019385576248168945, -0.027832133695483208, 0.011880225501954556, -0.05463563650846481, 0.029985401779413223, 0.04163746535778046, 0.001915785949677229, 0.013539976440370083, 0.0427698940038681, -0.0205431766808033, -0.013777748681604862, 0.05055810511112213, -0.01419891882687807, 0.0074390266090631485, -0.019170809537172318, -0.01741340197622776, 0.005376310087740421, 0.022922048345208168, -0.013129384256899357, 0.030437786132097244, -0.055046726018190384, 0.06086667999625206, 0.060055650770664215, 0.002118632197380066, -0.0021915670949965715, 0.018393831327557564, -0.016787545755505562, 0.03591457009315491, -0.0792836993932724, 0.008784526027739048, -0.047107670456171036, -0.042045921087265015, 0.01831863448023796, -0.004720350727438927, -0.01670556329190731, 0.014093446545302868, 0.07393606007099152, -0.0297161266207695, 0.024785486981272697, 0.026562675833702087, 0.020237673074007034, -0.022509055212140083, 0.05926515534520149, 0.027936439961194992, 0.015859831124544144, 0.017018036916851997, 0.016462428495287895, 0.028592344373464584, 0.02732515148818493, -0.04596633091568947, -0.02679884247481823, 0.0616057850420475, -0.053221575915813446, 0.008230638690292835, -0.04497597739100456, 0.014101643115282059, 0.05589998885989189, -0.023057233542203903, 0.036456674337387085, 0.057335015386343, 0.01008555293083191, -0.02488017827272415, -0.013112938962876797, -0.03931616246700287, 0.04092235490679741, 0.05700492113828659, -0.04435211047530174, -0.0151915792375803, 0.021841565147042274, -0.026698920875787735, 0.0351303294301033, -0.03188253939151764, -0.02182353287935257, -0.04419277608394623, 0.023972876369953156, 0.057371463626623154, 0.01325059775263071, 0.03365453705191612, -0.0025816953275352716, -0.0026396142784506083, -0.020107252523303032, 0.034467071294784546, 0.08193402737379074, -0.02132776938378811, -0.05899835377931595, -0.055488523095846176, -0.002540977904573083, -0.03943425416946411, 0.04579116031527519, 0.013169104233384132, -0.053817830979824066, 0.02981744147837162, -0.0021122924517840147, -0.022145934402942657, -0.020020365715026855, -0.021382177248597145, 0.012205304577946663, -0.02048191986978054, -0.0308097992092371, 0.03936135396361351, -0.002674727700650692, 0.007090169936418533, 0.008929265663027763, -0.02842894196510315, -0.013839049264788628, -0.018158257007598877, -0.011022749356925488, 0.005500167142599821, 0.011349168606102467, 0.024841899052262306, 0.058026302605867386, 0.004284525755792856, 0.013480971567332745, -0.024162182584404945, -0.056198179721832275, 0.019065139815211296, -0.026388386264443398, -0.017270037904381752, -0.017259348183870316, -0.027991607785224915, 0.03853921592235565, 0.03144235908985138, -0.03691756725311279, -0.02978748455643654, 0.013154609128832817, -0.056807320564985275, -0.04356839507818222, 0.02743670903146267, 0.007746987510472536, 0.014917857013642788, 0.018221868202090263, -0.045255836099386215, 0.060392800718545914, 0.05143982544541359, -0.015117351897060871, 0.023531729355454445, 0.018275225535035133, 0.02804584987461567, -0.047225408256053925, 0.033939238637685776, 0.0008487258455716074, -0.0026345110964030027, -0.014960323460400105, -0.0021511020604521036, 0.04909215122461319, 0.001183844287879765, -0.05341873690485954, -0.009426580742001534, -0.006792127620428801, 0.019043976441025734, -0.00869986042380333, 0.017169538885354996, 0.007532050833106041, -0.046546388417482376, 0.008748390711843967, 0.01999572664499283, 0.033702898770570755, -0.05028197541832924, -0.0021333496551960707, 0.05733083188533783, -0.01723037287592888, 0.026438474655151367, 0.020332979038357735, -0.0008336342871189117, -0.008142600767314434, -0.000031621155358152464, -0.02107843942940235, -0.027479926124215126, 0.026002485305070877, 0.01597723923623562, 0.015086371451616287, 0.013444887474179268, -0.02588113583624363, 0.022852834314107895, -0.05618032068014145, 0.002311491873115301, -0.01851121336221695, 0.045667704194784164, -0.008393612690269947, 0.02642563171684742, -0.01351983193308115, -0.0045317369513213634, -0.041915494948625565, -0.014030499383807182, -0.03418917581439018, 0.010200923308730125, 0.023889411240816116, 0.008144044317305088, -0.01729821041226387, -0.02085515670478344, 0.016213538125157356, -0.05316893011331558, 0.014916040003299713, 0.023337213322520256, 0.009143330156803131, -0.004315191879868507, 0.014079111628234386, 0.004944645334035158, 0.03912201523780823, 0.00047860509948804975, 0.014862277545034885, 0.027577491477131844, 0.04037413373589516, 0.0418127179145813, 0.07307464629411697, 0.004030135460197926, -0.03693484142422676, -0.06638570874929428, 0.006900756154209375, 0.012990537099540234, 0.02218562737107277, 0.06023041158914566, -0.02298772893846035, -0.02087601087987423, 0.01934928447008133, 0.010776854120194912, 0.02535472810268402, 0.03837113082408905, 0.03721858933568001, -0.02623101696372032, -0.03075219877064228, -0.029556037858128548, 0.011462808586657047, 0.011545413173735142, -0.0000053556254897557665, 0.027410486713051796, 0.03476954624056816, 0.016019092872738838, -0.05234852060675621, 0.042466651648283005, 0.06360936909914017, -0.030597321689128876, 0.03380875289440155, -0.03336440771818161, -0.03386234492063522, 0.004554920829832554, -0.02165287360548973, 0.037829022854566574, 0.030144937336444855, -0.020499268546700478, -0.00005055836300016381, 0.05251701921224594, -0.04085275158286095, -0.049032606184482574, -0.001119497581385076, 0.01397579163312912, -0.004764323588460684, -0.008402402512729168, -0.011827603913843632, 0.0043258690275251865, 0.010514543391764164, 0.014219311065971851, 0.02714727260172367, 0.008100098930299282, -0.09728649258613586, -0.038464825600385666, 0.02194768376648426, 0.02934934012591839, -0.03545626997947693, -0.03549481928348541, -0.06758861243724823, -0.027223840355873108, 0.0038333002012223005, -0.030613437294960022, 0.019079193472862244, -0.04835454374551773, 0.008144296705722809, 0.002274988451972604, -0.040337055921554565, -0.06014800816774368, -0.00525377644225955, -0.011390495114028454, 0.02475406415760517, -0.011612108908593655, -0.0047427015379071236, -0.0264251958578825, -0.006737242918461561, 0.0026658314745873213, 0.0016415108693763614, -0.015523373149335384, -0.025519317016005516, -0.01201753318309784, 0.024916069582104683, 0.0070168147794902325, -0.03212127462029457, 0.011117585934698582, -0.01893499493598938, 0.031070291996002197, 0.06420604139566422, -0.01663474179804325, -0.00879665371030569, -0.013542183674871922, 0.03791816160082817, -0.022943466901779175, -0.014476591721177101, -0.016762014478445053, 0.07333256304264069, 0.0028576066251844168, -0.006265432108193636, 0.07176031917333603, 0.01551148109138012, -0.004022853448987007, 0.025942808017134666, -0.05069615691900253, 0.0013791949022561312, -0.00034567058901302516, -0.036334000527858734, -0.05216705799102783, 0.013095084577798843, -0.006829126738011837, 0.027948180213570595, -0.006187891587615013, 0.018971599638462067, -0.0742901936173439, 0.00993366539478302, 0.030264154076576233, 0.040858037769794464, -0.011407673358917236, -0.033009592443704605, -0.008911734446883202, 0.01969519443809986, 0.02039402350783348, -0.023040710017085075, 0.001585360849276185, -0.016068289056420326, -0.010382519103586674, 0.013523525558412075, -0.015831198543310165, 0.016376113519072533, -0.0004427399835549295, -0.0036572946701198816, 0.004247754346579313, -0.05210554599761963, -0.005040377844125032, 0.022102706134319305, 0.02466934360563755, -0.021096305921673775, -0.007443009410053492, -0.015451324172317982, -0.0212653037160635, -0.011019854806363583, 0.05749652534723282, -0.02550537697970867, 0.037569500505924225, -0.0175300482660532, -0.014738135039806366, -0.07963317632675171, -0.048134975135326385, 0.034243300557136536, 0.033685263246297836, -0.0465049110352993, -0.007160964421927929, -0.039752546697854996, -0.0019541990477591753, -0.017590319737792015, -0.00007320012082345784, 0.03628411144018173, -0.05742662772536278, -0.018115520477294922, 0.04016408324241638, 0.018164169043302536, 0.06815487891435623, -0.013029493391513824, 0.016939740628004074, 0.025782648473978043, -0.027725093066692352, 0.01167970709502697, 0.010962584987282753, -0.013853794895112514, 0.00026791676646098495, -0.021861927583813667, -0.023494446650147438, 0.001122975256294012, 0.018141504377126694, -0.01326977089047432, -0.03784416243433952, -0.019541721791028976, 0.02113395743072033, 0.015536459162831306, -0.03921438381075859, -0.02591758966445923, -0.016567131504416466, 0.0003948677040170878, -0.014975772239267826, 0.042515650391578674, -0.0385747030377388, 0.021525392308831215, 0.06486193835735321, -0.052794475108385086, 0.029785148799419403, 0.01709967665374279, 0.07839639484882355, -0.006214711349457502, 0.012468034401535988, -0.00997699610888958, -0.004894617944955826, 0.052382007241249084, -0.01151824090629816, 0.0024355079513043165, 0.03638190031051636, 0.03270953893661499, -0.036210812628269196, -0.014625070616602898, -0.03170248866081238, 0.032110169529914856, 0.030544495210051537, -0.03169969841837883, 0.05710442364215851, 0.03600521758198738, -0.014184103347361088, -0.0010568758007138968, -0.058543361723423004, -0.056125737726688385, 0.020452668890357018, -0.017693810164928436, 0.035057634115219116, -0.05072754994034767, 0.014729959890246391, 0.05754790082573891, -0.008116981945931911, 0.005449890159070492, 0.029691528528928757, 0.017706960439682007, 0.01702067442238331, 0.0026454837061464787, 0.013027770444750786, 0.011151283979415894, 0.03691147267818451, 0.0400012731552124, 0.020090924575924873, -0.03628748282790184, -0.029578236863017082, 0.05251811444759369, 0.06418920308351517, 0.017872488126158714, -0.06047219783067703, -0.03808468580245972, -0.07718225568532944, 0.018916083499789238, 0.04444391652941704, -0.019533315673470497, 0.015481597743928432, 0.015465591102838516, 0.036774445325136185, -0.008801720105111599, 0.04404710978269577, -0.03540463000535965, -0.03997558727860451, -0.039161209017038345, 0.022088628262281418, 0.016301168128848076, 0.025182180106639862, -0.005423237103968859, -0.012756231240928173, 0.019069353118538857, -0.03241745010018349, 0.023340512067079544, -0.002197113586589694, 0.025429174304008484, -0.00337407598271966, 0.024766409769654274, 0.032052990049123764, -0.01715768128633499, -0.010088400915265083, -0.017267437651753426, 0.15400604903697968, 0.04336581006646156, 0.02146816998720169, -0.046563465148210526, 0.01466758269816637, 0.013661698438227177, -0.004688208922743797, -0.012477247975766659, -0.018490543588995934, 0.002168676583096385, -0.008858664892613888, 0.058864153921604156, 0.056370291858911514, 0.02856181003153324, 0.0030549296643584967, 0.035911429673433304, -0.009924204088747501, -0.007261666469275951, -0.027911482378840446, 0.046893686056137085, 0.021901259198784828, -0.03527591750025749, -0.06198783963918686, 0.003773020813241601, 0.035133227705955505, -0.014217173680663109, -0.018949178978800774, 0.027985883876681328, -0.04131973162293434, -0.017580216750502586, -0.028476450592279434, -0.018277598544955254, -0.00812076311558485, -0.005554753355681896, -0.021611075848340988, 0.000995259964838624, -0.02742687612771988, -0.0494905523955822, 0.015980863943696022, 0.05387452244758606, -0.0366438627243042, 0.00007569941226392984, 0.0031456626020371914, 0.03278789296746254, -0.02616453915834427, -0.037649065256118774, -0.02655637077987194, 0.040311191231012344, -0.016382044181227684, -0.032878242433071136, 0.017575396224856377, -0.01655636355280876, 0.03180396184325218, -0.030286166816949844, -0.003549678949639201, 0.0048735118471086025, 0.006671659182757139, -0.02648830972611904, -0.01337464153766632, 0.015577137470245361, 0.020735852420330048, -0.004584543406963348, 0.024063756689429283, 0.036086555570364, -0.025598861277103424, -0.03366795554757118, -0.07989659160375595, 0.057396866381168365, 0.004544817376881838, 0.010501584969460964, 0.008394775912165642, -0.037343669682741165, -0.019572582095861435, 0.00880017876625061, -0.01936907321214676, 0.016207756474614143, 0.02097259648144245, -0.024314474314451218, -0.032471250742673874, -0.002176921349018812, -0.020741496235132217, 0.03726185858249664, -0.033245205879211426, 0.011379776522517204, -0.05207047238945961, -0.016370372846722603, 0.002975494135171175, 0.009345305152237415, 0.012658967636525631, 0.0264279842376709, -0.002999582327902317, 0.05164829641580582, -0.04029404744505882, -0.07714169472455978, -0.009977594949305058, 0.0052651227451860905, -0.029951579868793488, 0.0025306078605353832, -0.028481779620051384, 0.054570335894823074, -0.004751213826239109, 0.019147856160998344, 0.0026054182089865208, 0.04223966225981712, -0.022264687344431877, -0.00397619791328907, -0.015637023374438286, -0.01995682343840599, -0.0024918795097619295, 0.018676159903407097, -0.006015120539814234, -0.011420654132962227, 0.003004139056429267, -0.04389999806880951, -0.058440256863832474, 0.006324933376163244, -0.0006637158803641796, -0.04863530397415161, 0.03273636847734451, -0.010146424174308777, -0.014964371919631958, 0.04120036959648132, 0.006314991042017937, -0.02142995037138462, 0.02374764159321785, 0.014880510047078133, -0.05326814204454422, -0.01766877807676792, -0.0024875167291611433, -0.009450347162783146, -0.012876932509243488, -0.004750734195113182, 0.005294937640428543, 0.02394179441034794, -0.013693164102733135, 0.05088885873556137, 0.018493356183171272, 0.0024161571636795998, 0.011980976909399033, -0.03728052228689194, -0.005808631889522076, -0.018402040004730225, -0.045890264213085175, 0.059677302837371826, 0.004167008213698864, 0.04552823677659035, -0.017771592363715172, 0.04834410548210144, -0.000221631649765186, 0.06711605191230774, -0.013576162047684193, 0.009553291834890842, -0.03084281086921692, 0.017190895974636078, 0.022625161334872246, -0.0239734947681427, -0.038928426802158356, 0.03714729845523834, 0.02005983144044876, 0.009287845343351364, 0.06570703536272049, 0.004120468162000179, 0.00013681962445843965, 0.020243166014552116, -0.035575300455093384, 0.008094148710370064, 0.05480366572737694, 0.029974089935421944, 0.03869657218456268, 0.050948891788721085, 0.02142447791993618, 0.025842295959591866, -0.027932150289416313, 0.041358135640621185, -0.08052140474319458, -0.04047846421599388, -0.006492386106401682, 0.025365980342030525, 0.009009787812829018, -0.04898447170853615, -0.0002591316879261285, -0.018235409632325172, -0.014449482783675194, 0.03319217264652252, -0.008674693293869495, 0.02172292023897171, -0.0304703488945961, -0.01113270502537489, -0.03805816173553467, 0.005958656780421734, 0.02191169001162052, -0.014412007294595242, 0.038159798830747604, 0.0010567139834165573, -0.01618206687271595, -0.06112820282578468, -0.023025380447506905, 0.04243794456124306, 0.014338554814457893, -0.10431726276874542, 0.0442984476685524, -0.06592079252004623, -0.005828503519296646, 0.014188643544912338, 0.0001182817286462523, -0.016787221655249596, 0.02566239982843399, 0.0014325135853141546, 0.021813707426190376, 0.0346907377243042, 0.039110489189624786, 0.02736518532037735, -0.002941239159554243, -0.0066395653411746025, -0.007937788963317871, -0.006558119785040617, -0.01714516058564186, 0.01941577158868313, 0.030333122238516808, 0.005420548841357231, -0.013460488989949226, 0.004629251081496477, -0.005152217578142881, 0.0251150019466877, -0.006415172945708036, 0.04362434893846512, 0.02040633000433445, -0.03650173544883728, 0.04122169688344002, -0.028800521045923233, 0.035370830446481705, 0.053598109632730484, 0.05601144954562187, -0.002144516445696354, -0.0009307211148552597, -0.04103327915072441, -0.03502393886446953, -0.010523846372961998, -0.02422315441071987, -0.02272615022957325, -0.027954449877142906, 0.009021827951073647, -0.008967448025941849, -0.022361312061548233, -0.006703469902276993, 0.04771739989519119, -0.0711364895105362, 0.022206272929906845, -0.03863595426082611, -0.02175186201930046, 0.018767276778817177, 0.010071149095892906, 0.03690008446574211, -0.08078507333993912, 0.03535301983356476, 0.028010934591293335, -0.06513529270887375, -0.06424105167388916, -0.031226517632603645, -0.045070089399814606, 0.051699042320251465, 0.07765857875347137, 0.020870178937911987, -0.010018196888267994, -0.007957394234836102, 0.019243232905864716, 0.023687053471803665, -0.0072090825997292995, 0.06897445023059845, 0.019014738500118256, -0.01411132700741291, -0.01699131913483143, 0.04014333710074425, 0.019069135189056396, -0.0012004097225144506, -0.013612587004899979, -0.012752063572406769, 0.013080657459795475, -0.03291083872318268, -0.023909326642751694, -0.02752365730702877, -0.004490424878895283, -0.01866888254880905, 0.058076512068510056, 0.014620916917920113, -0.004299466498196125, 0.054297808557748795, 0.03719945624470711, -0.00780249061062932, 0.06604136526584625, 0.042169757187366486, 0.00171253876760602, 0.005022850818932056, 0.014149753376841545, 0.028030257672071457, -0.06445485353469849, 0.004992054775357246, -0.00952894240617752, -0.028535379096865654, -0.0009513924596831203, 0.04783422499895096, 0.027219606563448906, 0.02220126800239086, -0.009247586131095886, 0.013490764424204826, -0.013860447332262993, -0.028132857754826546, 0.049464963376522064, 0.047938015311956406, 0.06312523782253265, -0.0050575402565300465, -0.009635966271162033, 0.04519175738096237, -0.005706331692636013, -0.0004187649174127728, -0.009490270167589188, 0.07789227366447449, 0.013154447078704834, 0.0214228592813015, 0.0005424620467238128, 0.019930163398385048, -0.003286233637481928, 0.028684118762612343, -0.019313642755150795, 0.029723962768912315, -0.030252227559685707, 0.03062456287443638, -0.0013196348445490003, -0.007149067707359791, -0.019382674247026443, -0.005080073606222868, 0.03779173642396927, 0.047047749161720276, -0.004279750864952803, -0.029596535488963127, 0.010280086658895016, -0.016733016818761826, 0.018292220309376717, -0.01683361455798149, -0.005206814501434565, -0.002941150451079011, 0.010016752406954765, -0.0028294208459556103, -0.017767757177352905, -0.012782488949596882, -0.03820658475160599, 0.021749412640929222, 0.0222366563975811, 0.01848755031824112, -0.05101732909679413, -0.0405069924890995, -0.00032626756001263857, 0.0331222228705883, -0.04032057896256447, -0.04351657256484032, -0.028506800532341003, 0.008611402474343777, 0.016402577981352806, -0.006765998899936676 ]
<p>I have two normal distributions, and I want to test whether they have the same standard deviation, I really don't care about the mean.</p> <p>My idea is: de-mean both of them and then use <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov%E2%80%93Smirnov_test" rel="nofollow">Kolmogorov-Smirnov</a> to test if the distributions are different, if they are then standard deviations also should be different. </p> <p>I am wondering if I am missing anything, and if there is a better way to do this.</p>
74,205
[ -0.04957573488354683, 0.0050650849007070065, -0.02117069438099861, 0.004108920693397522, 0.010297047905623913, 0.007277727127075195, 0.020040621981024742, -0.050545040518045425, 0.006719137076288462, -0.021631499752402306, 0.034148141741752625, 0.006635295692831278, 0.0523114912211895, 0.011551447212696075, 0.0417034775018692, -0.018384050577878952, -0.03942463546991348, 0.0011919077951461077, 0.0018446604954078794, -0.04584465175867081, -0.006104346364736557, 0.005347141996026039, 0.02411997690796852, -0.011615985073149204, -0.027584685012698174, 0.03374239802360535, 0.015457402914762497, -0.026204798370599747, 0.0374627411365509, 0.06979533284902573, -0.04514699801802635, -0.025856761261820793, -0.0020455308258533478, 0.050987180322408676, 0.009502368047833443, -0.029088743031024933, -0.0073509677313268185, -0.00791383720934391, -0.040165018290281296, 0.04662436991930008, -0.03402984142303467, 0.019872860983014107, -0.009729348123073578, 0.03108474612236023, -0.01449396088719368, 0.025995425879955292, -0.014847072772681713, -0.05289063975214958, 0.02706344798207283, -0.0442449189722538, 0.07363305985927582, -0.0036433383356779814, 0.057386353611946106, 0.035952355712652206, -0.0254815760999918, -0.0038717351853847504, 0.045534539967775345, 0.059397611767053604, -0.005377369932830334, -0.056915514171123505, 0.002375922631472349, -0.007918581366539001, -0.01739979162812233, 0.010039759799838066, -0.035403016954660416, 0.017107129096984863, 0.009331825189292431, -0.022206969559192657, 0.04255963861942291, -0.017963794991374016, 0.02020580694079399, 0.03721712529659271, 0.05228773131966591, -0.01273071113973856, 0.024974117055535316, -0.02661990374326706, 0.024032780900597572, 0.004015321843326092, 0.0015873967204242945, 0.034297842532396317, 0.00014814829046372324, -0.015588208101689816, 0.07405685633420944, 0.045514266937971115, 0.032885465770959854, -0.017754975706338882, 0.06230843439698219, -0.009157335385680199, -0.010262002237141132, 0.04406612738966942, -0.005271503236144781, -0.018023386597633362, 0.0741175189614296, -0.010842183604836464, -0.05147605761885643, 0.02986958436667919, -0.014446927234530449, 0.027292391285300255, -0.008499938994646072, -0.023123012855648994, -0.010036041960120201, -0.03751532360911369, 0.05110583081841469, 0.04579250514507294, -0.012504074722528458, -0.013000323437154293, 0.0164854247123003, 0.006857687141746283, -0.017757060006260872, -0.018542921170592308, -0.030384711921215057, 0.029409902170300484, -0.00705999368801713, -0.01305550616234541, 0.027480268850922585, 0.030063150450587273, -0.012856699526309967, -0.01608031801879406, 0.03717905655503273, 0.05001618713140488, 0.06975971162319183, -0.010859014466404915, 0.0023532076738774776, 0.0019596144556999207, -0.03750091791152954, 0.01487346738576889, 0.014751506969332695, 0.0020892058964818716, -0.028377782553434372, 0.057587482035160065, -0.03578124940395355, -0.01407239492982626, 0.012925905175507069, 0.0008684989297762513, 0.03691878542304039, -0.024255676195025444, -0.06536571681499481, -0.04620694741606712, 0.023570572957396507, -0.02442007325589657, -0.012592773884534836, -0.07191382348537445, -0.007714706938713789, -0.017248118296265602, 0.025345461443066597, 0.026822788640856743, 0.03796103224158287, -0.037852928042411804, 0.030297288671135902, 0.02565024606883526, 0.015609425492584705, -0.027083970606327057, -0.010466288775205612, -0.014029663056135178, -0.033350493758916855, -0.06340783834457397, 0.0007053118897601962, 0.006674060598015785, -0.024997388944029808, -0.02646300196647644, 0.02801704779267311, 0.005064232274889946, -0.016331586986780167, -0.01106214988976717, 0.05131209269165993, -0.05326903238892555, 0.08561766892671585, 0.0042246426455676556, 0.043242447078228, -0.013119302690029144, -0.001273315749131143, 0.03099152259528637, 0.0002171122032450512, 0.029366355389356613, 0.036293063312768936, -0.05865158885717392, -0.0063985008746385574, -0.02240671031177044, 0.0513915941119194, -0.012292481027543545, -0.01562972366809845, -0.01250569149851799, -0.038789041340351105, -0.014545585960149765, -0.013243191875517368, 0.06281734257936478, 0.017649130895733833, -0.0010687881149351597, 0.010243398137390614, -0.06239740923047066, -0.017846331000328064, -0.07158758491277695, -0.03210247680544853, -0.021110650151968002, -0.034221913665533066, 0.03195055574178696, 0.03777579218149185, 0.0673065036535263, -0.04613758623600006, -0.03494071587920189, 0.004640992730855942, -0.009569143876433372, 0.0406317412853241, -0.021682702004909515, 0.025756075978279114, 0.044073186814785004, 0.07414663583040237, -0.023189520463347435, 0.05334276333451271, -0.04128490015864372, -0.04750708490610123, 0.013457461260259151, -0.04701128974556923, -0.019766729325056076, 0.017980672419071198, 0.017769645899534225, 0.02284977398812771, 0.03625553846359253, 0.017783060669898987, 0.014187411405146122, -0.059988971799612045, 0.057851728051900864, 0.04016055911779404, -0.0056708152405917645, -0.009581305086612701, 0.0026640496216714382, 0.025482874363660812, 0.03694330155849457, -0.020313577726483345, -0.025671804323792458, -0.021245673298835754, 0.006253684870898724, 0.03410102427005768, 0.010739490389823914, -0.06410451978445053, 0.02428600564599037, 0.042924147099256516, -0.02099635824561119, 0.004293793812394142, 0.03693682327866554, 0.01608414202928543, -0.029583849012851715, -0.03122946433722973, 0.04489973187446594, 0.0009388990583829582, 0.02521672658622265, 0.014498736709356308, 0.010479622520506382, 0.03910351172089577, 0.0016465495573356748, -0.02539009414613247, 0.026463733986020088, -0.012280852533876896, 0.008770088665187359, 0.01013567391782999, -0.004960924852639437, 0.03110230714082718, 0.0068369172513484955, 0.022589221596717834, 0.03217257931828499, -0.011831138283014297, -0.0008317421306855977, 0.016148699447512627, -0.03287366032600403, 0.02947959490120411, 0.025023896247148514, 0.0019580251537263393, 0.0026568484026938677, 0.02539278194308281, -0.037734974175691605, -0.007161024957895279, -0.008788913488388062, -0.016792992129921913, -0.005509520880877972, 0.00906455609947443, -0.01467939093708992, 0.0030489193741232157, 0.022463960573077202, -0.012914597056806087, -0.021962977945804596, 0.0017277428414672613, -0.015346315689384937, 0.003579231910407543, 0.009859091602265835, -0.02390154078602791, 0.03025330975651741, 0.01614456996321678, -0.018861057236790657, 0.011425577104091644, -0.02340291067957878, 0.03813466057181358, 0.0452217236161232, 0.005105290096253157, -0.06365754455327988, -0.00783556792885065, -0.04630859196186066, 0.051504675298929214, -0.009074758738279343, -0.007886210456490517, 0.03660538047552109, 0.0037651772145181894, -0.058288995176553726, 0.01039551105350256, -0.057287536561489105, -0.056495849043130875, -0.059875696897506714, -0.027071572840213776, 0.019984789192676544, -0.0016649350291118026, 0.003625617129728198, 0.05773116275668144, -0.05838480964303017, -0.01947682350873947, -0.05275152996182442, -0.05400507524609566, 0.04315072298049927, 0.018164126202464104, 0.04557519033551216, 0.02174830436706543, -0.029687948524951935, 0.08213059604167938, 0.036173783242702484, -0.007699497975409031, -0.009819206781685352, 0.012796781957149506, -0.04215604439377785, -0.022625910118222237, 0.012005922384560108, -0.015121450647711754, -0.01042724959552288, 0.022259652614593506, 0.03740138188004494, 0.0011534332297742367, 0.04402733966708183, -0.015426244586706161, 0.008780884556472301, -0.0050281318835914135, 0.014960641041398048, -0.040974076837301254, 0.08217785507440567, 0.009602958336472511, -0.007936953566968441, -0.017561327666044235, 0.025974847376346588, 0.04453302547335625, 0.028719190508127213, -0.019350025802850723, 0.03333960473537445, -0.0014522550627589226, 0.028860896825790405, -0.03706349432468414, 0.013060622848570347, 0.035922255367040634, -0.028846362605690956, 0.004496688023209572, 0.040248285979032516, 0.016637954860925674, -0.02107928693294525, 0.025803720578551292, 0.06782657653093338, 0.03757822513580322, -0.027068831026554108, -0.03212405741214752, -0.0024755834601819515, -0.0045384373515844345, 0.0131734199821949, -0.005494976881891489, -0.04566020891070366, 0.047925159335136414, 0.039764586836099625, 0.029068436473608017, 0.006103305146098137, -0.03736184909939766, 0.016929849982261658, -0.08524658530950546, 0.02791762724518776, -0.00048337920452468097, 0.044474970549345016, 0.03230559453368187, 0.039752207696437836, 0.022879241034388542, 0.004828801844269037, -0.030832530930638313, -0.0013898871839046478, -0.1098894327878952, 0.037243179976940155, -0.03868863731622696, -0.035811688750982285, -0.006749895866960287, -0.045898810029029846, -0.013554063625633717, -0.010063868016004562, 0.045463696122169495, 0.007327498402446508, 0.016435882076621056, -0.06026555225253105, -0.004477059468626976, -0.03511637821793556, -0.038897521793842316, 0.01949269324541092, -0.003699861466884613, 0.00864177756011486, -0.021249067038297653, 0.04367630556225777, 0.0154280299320817, -0.024278439581394196, -0.013724975287914276, -0.05973387137055397, 0.02018614113330841, 0.0157251488417387, 0.04128503054380417, 0.006868558004498482, 0.028088176622986794, -0.026495574042201042, 0.014629585668444633, 0.0039466251619160175, 0.03778380900621414, 0.00994883943349123, -0.009837314486503601, -0.019925955682992935, -0.06844893097877502, -0.05273214355111122, -0.009538200683891773, 0.019039468839764595, 0.011081468313932419, -0.0009454351966269314, 0.03027973137795925, 0.03506369888782501, -0.0010938779450953007, 0.006417719181627035, 0.09603991359472275, -0.00584074854850769, 0.02499471604824066, 0.0059210979379713535, -0.021156180649995804, -0.036942847073078156, -0.019170785322785378, 0.02797122113406658, 0.030169110745191574, -0.013050655834376812, 0.002817532978951931, 0.025535229593515396, -0.013137121684849262, -0.011282511055469513, -0.01184083241969347, 0.006820834241807461, 0.043066155165433884, -0.018253283575177193, -0.010007602162659168, 0.041651446372270584, 0.020297463983297348, 0.010816745460033417, -0.006971723400056362, 0.008943460881710052, -0.04893825575709343, 0.0045586940832436085, 0.07181714475154877, 0.04274396598339081, -0.021682467311620712, 0.00749329524114728, -0.0438038595020771, -0.01098712719976902, 0.06523527950048447, -0.052010685205459595, 0.0012286356650292873, 0.0026940142270177603, 0.014622773975133896, -0.014697184786200523, -0.013907664455473423, -0.05828818306326866, 0.023958051577210426, -0.008809969760477543, 0.014020262286067009, -0.0029862921219319105, -0.04231976345181465, -0.04772639647126198, -0.01760643906891346, 0.022885669022798538, 0.07194413989782333, 0.018802372738718987, -0.019618907943367958, 0.007441526744514704, 0.031019246205687523, -0.0018628971884027123, -0.07667381316423416, -0.0055083660408854485, -0.02702268958091736, 0.011650828644633293, 0.04554508626461029, 0.009706866927444935, -0.05153144150972366, 0.03575004264712334, -0.007654545828700066, -0.026620682328939438, 0.00845281407237053, 0.001579810748808086, 0.024575870484113693, 0.0726744756102562, 0.024784544482827187, 0.03243223950266838, 0.018443813547492027, -0.008495412766933441, 0.005978571716696024, -0.03145725280046463, 0.01547438558191061, -0.04495592415332794, -0.028960878029465675, -0.03877538442611694, -0.040825340896844864, -0.048242244869470596, 0.015636306256055832, -0.02502155862748623, 0.025169603526592255, -0.011038419790565968, 0.007286982610821724, 0.02981914021074772, 0.014905339106917381, 0.02407713793218136, 0.014893843792378902, 0.01377274189144373, 0.010907867923378944, -0.025930048897862434, -0.012810688465833664, 0.02783314697444439, -0.015603545121848583, -0.016932837665081024, 0.009274263866245747, -0.07652857899665833, 0.02917672134935856, -0.04984373226761818, -0.04558204859495163, -0.02445177175104618, -0.037326641380786896, 0.023609468713402748, 0.015419524163007736, 0.05854106694459915, 0.031799256801605225, -0.016042634844779968, -0.007369804661720991, 0.04309414327144623, 0.015525090508162975, 0.017248334363102913, -0.049950484186410904, 0.05297039449214935, -0.0062081217765808105, -0.019466513767838478, -0.08664021641016006, -0.031669456511735916, -0.009121013805270195, -0.028531143441796303, 0.012497102841734886, -0.07092184573411942, 0.010097754187881947, 0.0010479161283001304, 0.004071811679750681, -0.009026209823787212, 0.05771126225590706, 0.009328157640993595, -0.029354145750403404, 0.0005373486201278865, 0.010763042606413364, 0.08572140336036682, -0.004880547057837248, -0.01351618580520153, -0.01742754690349102, -0.018549960106611252, -0.030482592061161995, 0.010911373421549797, 0.017956728115677834, -0.0206291601061821, -0.014193386770784855, -0.0321127213537693, -0.005687850061804056, 0.03322213888168335, -0.02241138368844986, -0.03231864422559738, -0.001367572695016861, 0.008050569333136082, 0.01137029379606247, -0.024026889353990555, 0.004917821381241083, -0.02551213838160038, -0.0025759823620319366, -0.01146757509559393, 0.01800869219005108, 0.007070265244692564, -0.01568790338933468, 0.023724984377622604, 0.028767379000782967, 0.009982304647564888, 0.0021662211511284113, 0.05972476303577423, -0.0020253914408385754, 0.013417514972388744, -0.0132925258949399, -0.014298949390649796, 0.011452063918113708, -0.028727401047945023, -0.01872379332780838, 0.010133658535778522, 0.029950549826025963, -0.037366945296525955, -0.007426928728818893, -0.026303885504603386, -0.017747851088643074, 0.044000811874866486, 0.0032290315721184015, 0.07753424346446991, 0.046551674604415894, 0.025719020515680313, 0.018282819539308548, -0.02601701393723488, 0.00014132838987279683, -0.03331366181373596, -0.001710341777652502, 0.06591124832630157, -0.00016055790183600038, 0.039238836616277695, 0.05542151629924774, 0.0340300127863884, 0.026045089587569237, 0.052537448704242706, 0.018364420160651207, 0.04533541575074196, 0.04111957922577858, -0.021135743707418442, -0.04121990501880646, 0.05631302297115326, -0.06904864311218262, 0.021944625303149223, -0.011613046750426292, -0.017007209360599518, 0.031564876437187195, 0.009078387171030045, -0.02786579355597496, -0.04408643767237663, -0.013132482767105103, -0.05879977345466614, 0.00670008547604084, -0.006030978634953499, -0.01782405376434326, 0.006634920369833708, -0.0017301355255767703, 0.05222411826252937, -0.006394760217517614, 0.02232401631772518, -0.04988687485456467, -0.07434282451868057, -0.013327496126294136, -0.02769925817847252, -0.005310288164764643, 0.04266814887523651, 0.0019396076677367091, -0.02780165895819664, 0.014434682205319405, -0.04594002664089203, 0.054568540304899216, 0.004720703698694706, -0.002773443702608347, -0.012854320928454399, 0.056314513087272644, -0.006000347435474396, 0.04769885167479515, 0.002450651256367564, -0.015207665041089058, 0.10951311886310577, 0.01566014066338539, 0.043397702276706696, -0.05796195939183235, 0.020767534151673317, -0.0004847330565098673, 0.006991971284151077, -0.006910999305546284, 0.027137907221913338, 0.006462232209742069, 0.0115499934181571, 0.04094606265425682, 0.04016842320561409, 0.01849859394133091, -0.03771119937300682, 0.040687646716833115, -0.01350798923522234, -0.013327034190297127, 0.020290745422244072, 0.014500821009278297, -0.01541613508015871, -0.03862813115119934, -0.023421060293912888, 0.060963165014982224, -0.03816602751612663, 0.028663115575909615, -0.017657531425356865, 0.011216730810701847, 0.008015979081392288, 0.016107838600873947, -0.017609089612960815, 0.01902058906853199, 0.04168006032705307, 0.0006112839328125119, -0.02387065254151821, 0.00786564126610756, 0.007247369736433029, -0.0080022681504488, 0.03525489196181297, 0.0009596250602044165, 0.023966997861862183, -0.015033434145152569, 0.022817667573690414, 0.0011512336786836386, -0.0294471587985754, -0.022074658423662186, -0.02890966646373272, 0.03950575739145279, -0.015466704964637756, -0.01874539442360401, 0.002823631977662444, -0.020114662125706673, -0.0003118433814961463, -0.04363049566745758, -0.012809901498258114, -0.006303479429334402, 0.02367510087788105, -0.03986595571041107, 0.010837098583579063, -0.04445534944534302, 0.03954556584358215, 0.0017076057847589254, 0.04314554110169411, -0.00821645651012659, 0.0024268226698040962, -0.012635337188839912, -0.012723502703011036, 0.06438896805047989, -0.005593313369899988, -0.04700140655040741, 0.017707793042063713, -0.023493435233831406, -0.013857058249413967, 0.027222396805882454, 0.0011795135214924812, 0.00046567805111408234, 0.03664363548159599, 0.01676030643284321, -0.0058076223358511925, 0.0007163927657529712, -0.043709658086299896, 0.017535528168082237, -0.020467637106776237, 0.0005718807224184275, -0.02824893593788147, -0.004023455549031496, 0.060335759073495865, 0.05849909782409668, 0.03955650329589844, 0.045304734259843826, 0.04924970492720604, 0.07249075919389725, 0.023978738114237785, -0.07009271532297134, -0.007925706915557384, 0.00570180919021368, -0.028160998597741127, -0.00013298416160978377, -0.0369730181992054, 0.03758572041988373, 0.027212824672460556, 0.03372414782643318, -0.03475271537899971, 0.016792431473731995, -0.025160077959299088, 0.020370811223983765, -0.01563682220876217, -0.042378176003694534, -0.002945470158010721, 0.009043055586516857, 0.016748545691370964, 0.00963823776692152, 0.0069002024829387665, -0.03306439146399498, -0.017814958468079567, 0.021990332752466202, -0.014792893081903458, -0.037364766001701355, -0.03590032085776329, -0.017483243718743324, 0.02629788964986801, -0.02312173880636692, 0.0014113460201770067, -0.02815047837793827, -0.021832406520843506, -0.003988080658018589, -0.004279762040823698, -0.026913201436400414, 0.028362544253468513, -0.001918562687933445, 0.012411659583449364, 0.05398278310894966, 0.01667417772114277, 0.0017277548322454095, 0.019071290269494057, 0.022279616445302963, 0.0016586189158260822, 0.04094168171286583, -0.0379101000726223, 0.01611657440662384, 0.05282124876976013, -0.03499676659703255, -0.018330054357647896, -0.0041953264735639095, 0.0204085111618042, 0.0171376820653677, -0.007218866143375635, -0.04041808471083641, -0.024418942630290985, 0.06163971126079559, -0.013230890035629272, -0.013557101599872112, -0.0591474287211895, -0.02559761516749859, 0.005872330628335476, 0.005474091041833162, 0.003314318833872676, 0.006006426177918911, -0.013122609816491604, 0.05670808255672455, 0.0338096059858799, -0.008997364901006222, 0.01273439172655344, -0.022710133343935013, 0.04547838121652603, 0.00067218515323475, 0.021759845316410065, -0.0000011160924486830481, 0.027374979108572006, 0.06400533020496368, -0.02055351249873638, 0.0030534351244568825, -0.04526551440358162, -0.007676501292735338, -0.09537217020988464, -0.01721605472266674, 0.017631303519010544, -0.013973996043205261, 0.030679862946271896, -0.04285114258527756, 0.014239870943129063, 0.03554369509220123, -0.020980851724743843, -0.001844335813075304, -0.016990218311548233, -0.036776620894670486, -0.040889445692300797, -0.00042929465416818857, -0.002065949607640505, 0.05551210045814514, -0.007094301749020815, 0.016247432678937912, 0.013694314286112785, 0.03382207080721855, 0.012885306030511856, 0.01588507741689682, -0.0462326854467392, -0.00946043711155653, -0.00033468453329987824, -0.05835788697004318, 0.003486253786832094, -0.023554310202598572, -0.03744816780090332, 0.028931999579072, -0.02355307899415493, 0.0006316171493381262, -0.008369620889425278, 0.024317262694239616, 0.02662672847509384, 0.03575776517391205, 0.034065961837768555, -0.0030168243683874607, -0.023289058357477188, -0.020233837887644768, 0.0064528873190283775, 0.024066505953669548, -0.03413058817386627, -0.017244700342416763, 0.051471076905727386, -0.030068721622228622, -0.022419922053813934, 0.004229647107422352, -0.00408648606389761, -0.03570900857448578, -0.015696510672569275, -0.010486711747944355, 0.02283773198723793, 0.0013011273695155978, 0.00224098889157176, -0.04173552244901657, 0.005710660945624113, 0.02377903461456299, 0.010675469413399696, -0.02989724650979042, 0.013640039600431919, -0.016655443236231804, -0.048455994576215744, 0.009348560124635696, 0.002798557048663497, -0.023307403549551964, -0.05421269312500954, 0.0035501185338944197, -0.04061082378029823, 0.014784546568989754, -0.02115774340927601, -0.05750146135687828, -0.026875723153352737, 0.048763252794742584, -0.02609911933541298, 0.02929810807108879, -0.0036598392762243748, 0.013949352316558361, 0.003912787884473801, -0.06283740699291229, 0.04994402453303337, 0.018687281757593155, -0.009467901661992073, -0.03958756849169731, 0.008058973588049412, -0.053688667714595795, -0.007452906109392643, 0.039595991373062134, 0.02631114237010479, 0.02330547384917736, -0.004521894734352827, 0.015052547678351402, 0.023235704749822617, -0.07267213612794876, 0.03773577883839607, -0.03700925409793854, -0.020286547020077705, 0.02592734433710575, -0.03520634025335312, 0.004189849365502596, 0.01216751430183649, 0.007811273448169231, -0.029032167047262192, -0.013715122826397419, 0.01037084311246872, -0.015413844026625156, 0.04147971048951149, -0.015284142456948757, -0.03287694603204727, 0.020310992375016212, -0.028816724196076393, 0.004622739274054766, 0.013069269247353077, 0.03131773695349693, -0.04078380763530731, 0.05058872327208519, -0.030168959870934486, -0.043503351509571075, -0.01973034255206585, 0.00891968421638012, 0.0020311695989221334, -0.032993901520967484, -0.021466614678502083, 0.02408756874501705, -0.06035931780934334, -0.0070382533594965935, 0.039254963397979736, 0.025429362431168556, 0.022092418745160103, -0.017495017498731613, 0.014225997030735016, 0.00016519817290827632, -0.0013503737282007933, 0.021906651556491852, -0.005710919853299856, 0.020588362589478493, -0.012040667235851288, -0.012569185346364975, 0.019903084263205528, -0.024029621854424477, 0.015314866788685322, -0.036178793758153915, 0.07161878794431686, -0.01617283560335636, -0.057986337691545486, 0.0063035693019628525, -0.005589728243649006, 0.024245884269475937, -0.009480035863816738, -0.013094568625092506, 0.03968831151723862, -0.032665055245161057, -0.027390889823436737, -0.010246183723211288, -0.047599390149116516, -0.0153073500841856, -0.0021385864820331335, 0.027022622525691986, -0.0022859189193695784, 0.001680344226770103, -0.0018190306145697832, 0.00165880611166358, -0.0014035601634532213, 0.03416956961154938, -0.014435003511607647, 0.03383222222328186, -0.019957007840275764, -0.021969402208924294, -0.021827545017004013, 0.015356757678091526, -0.02713289111852646, -0.015455159358680248, 0.020670846104621887, 0.07485442608594894, 0.01621429994702339, -0.005906109698116779, -0.060537464916706085, 0.0002023796841967851, 0.0402694046497345, -0.06364121288061142, -0.015294736251235008, -0.037971485406160355, -0.011047402396798134, 0.01881272718310356, -0.03992076963186264 ]
<p>The general disjunction rule for events $A_1$ and $A_2$ is $$P(A_1 \vee A_2) = P(A_1) + P(A_2) - P(A_1 \wedge A_2).$$ What about when there are $n$ events? What is $P(\bigvee_i^n A_i)$ where $A_i$ is the $i$th event?</p>
74,206
[ -0.023045985028147697, -0.03797155246138573, -0.02084372751414776, -0.008386525325477123, 0.04559875279664993, 0.022630134597420692, -0.019375082105398178, 0.0034129824489355087, 0.021024731919169426, -0.0164803434163332, 0.036640267819166183, 0.034079570323228836, 0.04926619678735733, 0.014517601579427719, 0.02313605695962906, 0.03307380527257919, 0.006023849826306105, 0.0043748957104980946, 0.012954826466739178, 0.014343857765197754, 0.0031523671932518482, 0.03729401156306267, 0.022161424160003662, -0.03957325220108032, -0.02345740795135498, 0.034310031682252884, 0.040149398148059845, 0.0034771186765283346, 0.023212378844618797, 0.0886356383562088, -0.010496326722204685, -0.027286408469080925, 0.020802056416869164, 0.06471247225999832, -0.003938002046197653, 0.0013691041385754943, -0.007110737729817629, -0.028967902064323425, -0.004116520285606384, -0.006148248445242643, -0.03352358192205429, -0.026425985619425774, -0.0330507755279541, 0.043999094516038895, -0.06736685335636139, 0.029471099376678467, -0.011512791737914085, -0.06703709065914154, 0.013005014508962631, -0.056374210864305496, 0.06164113059639931, -0.02095043659210205, 0.08652127534151077, 0.021523071452975273, -0.003559304866939783, -0.002630431903526187, 0.03264563903212547, 0.04474255442619324, 0.008179562166333199, -0.03884442523121834, -0.004008392803370953, -0.04306533560156822, 0.03672253340482712, -0.05087193474173546, -0.03906465321779251, 0.006705275271087885, -0.012640328146517277, -0.030429964885115623, -0.019322769716382027, -0.024703385308384895, 0.01886828988790512, 0.026700716465711594, 0.02434946782886982, -0.0011717212619259953, -0.00778099475428462, -0.009485538117587566, 0.05914253368973732, 0.01231437548995018, 0.04451974853873253, 0.023060716688632965, 0.02232755720615387, 0.033009208738803864, 0.030917737632989883, 0.03145525977015495, 0.03411070257425308, -0.052440088242292404, 0.05911191925406456, -0.009252358227968216, 0.005776307545602322, -0.01873227022588253, -0.02520550787448883, -0.011770831421017647, 0.01697235181927681, -0.05639917030930519, -0.025323089212179184, 0.006620630621910095, -0.06518618762493134, 0.017632998526096344, 0.00546659529209137, -0.002958123805001378, -0.021556401625275612, -0.02255869098007679, 0.03256424888968468, 0.05188365653157234, -0.0391521081328392, -0.014468396082520485, -0.01413238886743784, 0.021834447979927063, -0.0169619582593441, 0.004476293455809355, -0.033213160932064056, 0.04400326684117317, 0.004253521095961332, 0.054130345582962036, -0.019384128972887993, -0.016459783539175987, -0.017421334981918335, -0.007097934372723103, 0.06095060333609581, 0.07120535522699356, 0.05810415372252464, -0.01850482076406479, 0.027053115889430046, -0.023117730394005775, -0.050121091306209564, 0.01601077802479267, 0.03839549049735069, -0.005790971219539642, -0.06819538027048111, 0.029316700994968414, -0.011327439919114113, -0.016116119921207428, 0.009443167597055435, 0.011613784357905388, 0.02443249523639679, -0.0058216736651957035, -0.08763524144887924, -0.05077790468931198, 0.02797221764922142, -0.03351070359349251, -0.04302413389086723, -0.0613996684551239, 0.0313870795071125, 0.06250172108411789, 0.06508597731590271, 0.0015576803125441074, 0.05536834895610809, 0.015433709137141705, -0.011114275082945824, 0.027230512350797653, -0.0400390625, -0.03059469535946846, 0.006608373485505581, -0.0023431407753378153, -0.0042353360913693905, -0.0841563269495964, 0.05748605728149414, 0.021443655714392662, -0.00856749527156353, -0.031022250652313232, 0.07543403655290604, -0.027635740116238594, -0.007124071009457111, -0.03869791328907013, 0.03871715068817139, -0.043138954788446426, 0.08840232342481613, 0.004194869659841061, 0.028316592797636986, 0.02827988564968109, 0.040735118091106415, 0.04811089113354683, 0.01853756420314312, 0.07488757371902466, 0.04478864744305611, 0.005784456618130207, -0.023173313587903976, -0.037865716964006424, 0.018725072965025902, 0.01689327135682106, -0.017719684168696404, -0.007544338703155518, -0.021495545282959938, 0.014495128765702248, 0.0012444384628906846, -0.001045085722580552, -0.0035855197347700596, 0.0005152719095349312, 0.03384069725871086, -0.0326678603887558, 0.011089015752077103, -0.09440732002258301, 0.021599553525447845, 0.007822496816515923, -0.007295281160622835, 0.026636391878128052, 0.02954164519906044, 0.004677174612879753, -0.0046696593053638935, -0.006133649963885546, -0.02539823204278946, 0.016582055017352104, 0.013680207543075085, -0.052227869629859924, 0.0033892588689923286, 0.029037820175290108, 0.03650904446840286, -0.01394236832857132, 0.025339815765619278, -0.02579585649073124, -0.025246640667319298, 0.002826469950377941, -0.023017391562461853, 0.034982793033123016, -0.01806792989373207, -0.028884001076221466, 0.004942520055919886, 0.010068424977362156, 0.02491176873445511, 0.05727509781718254, -0.056765366345644, 0.07162892073392868, 0.07757794857025146, 0.023090621456503868, 0.014920216053724289, -0.016408178955316544, 0.035727471113204956, -0.03729396313428879, -0.020574962720274925, -0.0008913861820474267, -0.042145658284425735, -0.00007280159479705617, 0.016872374340891838, 0.036541711539030075, -0.002907136920839548, 0.028727157041430473, 0.026979390531778336, 0.03080747462809086, 0.0034431698732078075, 0.04217343404889107, -0.025470653548836708, 0.014063688926398754, 0.007491134572774172, 0.038057707250118256, 0.013548541814088821, 0.023328792303800583, -0.011902391910552979, -0.00048589418292976916, 0.013885551132261753, -0.019232256338000298, -0.05107032135128975, 0.06655577570199966, -0.020958978682756424, 0.013737984001636505, -0.028461305424571037, -0.04649565741419792, 0.035035111010074615, -0.0438537672162056, -0.0002296857419423759, 0.017348073422908783, 0.036310192197561264, -0.03520355001091957, -0.017509717494249344, -0.036420587450265884, 0.04561706632375717, -0.011451427824795246, -0.05262969061732292, 0.003083044197410345, 0.04197174683213234, -0.010379484854638577, 0.028616400435566902, -0.03442724794149399, -0.05674103647470474, -0.010339238680899143, -0.005332115106284618, 0.019875487312674522, -0.03893439471721649, 0.03796101734042168, -0.015007728710770607, -0.05056644603610039, -0.039758842438459396, -0.04515653848648071, 0.021787691861391068, 0.009068408980965614, -0.043550774455070496, 0.011666166596114635, -0.006048166658729315, -0.022653331980109215, 0.024810321629047394, -0.006765570491552353, -0.009673738852143288, 0.019904565066099167, 0.0008301872294396162, -0.028881460428237915, -0.02229665033519268, -0.021107757464051247, -0.0026300952304154634, -0.0714733824133873, -0.03674052283167839, 0.05315037816762924, -0.0007974319742061198, -0.05780819058418274, 0.006575422827154398, -0.026314185932278633, -0.01750991865992546, -0.03638424351811409, -0.010747071355581284, 0.018472392112016678, -0.04747162014245987, 0.02117043174803257, 0.048386335372924805, -0.03339463099837303, 0.00803658738732338, -0.057714883238077164, -0.07270742952823639, -0.0032569626346230507, -0.01618976704776287, 0.03354792296886444, 0.003354038577526808, -0.03280676528811455, 0.035377297550439835, 0.04333602637052536, 0.0075481003150343895, 0.017044877633452415, -0.005206841975450516, 0.0021436105016618967, -0.020746413618326187, 0.001330806640908122, -0.002428223844617605, 0.00976904109120369, 0.05993548780679703, 0.030150284990668297, 0.00790073350071907, 0.07334474474191666, 0.024706488475203514, 0.0005133546073921025, 0.003387647680938244, 0.013853046111762524, -0.014031155966222286, 0.04844311624765396, 0.021728526800870895, -0.02694268338382244, 0.020204368978738785, 0.004346500150859356, 0.028242237865924835, -0.015621897764503956, -0.0335979089140892, 0.05193424969911575, -0.025903208181262016, -0.004847779870033264, 0.008190941996872425, 0.062339529395103455, 0.014948142692446709, -0.008850195445120335, 0.025825927034020424, 0.006707006599754095, 0.02758527733385563, -0.06347840279340744, 0.004982649348676205, 0.021412430331110954, 0.039886631071567535, -0.057204678654670715, -0.04964659735560417, -0.04129369184374809, -0.003069535130634904, 0.02007364109158516, -0.0017191404476761818, 0.012068233452737331, 0.042841315269470215, 0.009461604058742523, 0.010230078361928463, -0.009957251138985157, -0.01923987828195095, -0.038973137736320496, -0.03056345134973526, -0.01767680235207081, 0.0048972126096487045, 0.013229762203991413, 0.0014683391200378537, 0.030846472829580307, 0.009146815165877342, -0.023796040564775467, 0.04208418354392052, 0.007163502275943756, -0.04833018779754639, 0.025846391916275024, -0.003687785705551505, -0.012052852660417557, -0.005513014737516642, -0.003776983357965946, 0.06021716073155403, -0.03173286095261574, 0.008163291960954666, -0.01596486009657383, 0.004297757521271706, -0.043827157467603683, 0.018847214058041573, -0.04323296993970871, -0.05894723907113075, 0.02832738682627678, 0.03163575381040573, 0.017455484718084335, 0.008976745419204235, 0.03001672402024269, 0.046010397374629974, -0.007283621933311224, -0.017928211018443108, 0.009094145148992538, 0.002787536010146141, 0.018353193998336792, 0.00663535762578249, 0.03928030654788017, 0.04295340180397034, -0.02849833481013775, 0.008515608496963978, 0.0033373634796589613, 0.05645870789885521, 0.05354274436831474, 0.001750376308336854, 0.008137182332575321, -0.06195874884724617, -0.0232547614723444, -0.030135348439216614, 0.026955509558320045, 0.032061100006103516, 0.01893143728375435, 0.056470002979040146, 0.030650442466139793, -0.04976169019937515, 0.014144295826554298, 0.07808919996023178, 0.00825577974319458, -0.041166722774505615, -0.010113119147717953, 0.03496827185153961, 0.008906837552785873, -0.004810309503227472, 0.003674101550132036, -0.00848984345793724, -0.018730266019701958, -0.008951240219175816, 0.044694989919662476, -0.03235721215605736, -0.038475897163152695, -0.02351679839193821, -0.010407567024230957, -0.0032762011978775263, 0.05757838487625122, -0.03444146737456322, 0.04069508984684944, 0.023376859724521637, -0.005326905287802219, 0.05330429971218109, -0.02438647300004959, -0.054796215146780014, 0.019012130796909332, 0.03644074127078056, 0.07513247430324554, -0.03321424499154091, -0.010358194820582867, -0.029397908598184586, -0.034257739782333374, 0.015868598595261574, -0.028099630028009415, 0.024900736287236214, -0.007394149899482727, -0.0025999394711107016, -0.014480008743703365, -0.019213562831282616, -0.0321834422647953, 0.009291551075875759, -0.005835849326103926, 0.03126789629459381, 0.006999282166361809, 0.011278033256530762, -0.042378246784210205, -0.014565016143023968, 0.05571944639086723, 0.04740805923938751, -0.03345993533730507, -0.012183097191154957, -0.062354158610105515, 0.016219859942793846, -0.021731335669755936, -0.048585742712020874, 0.022499261423945427, -0.003185032866895199, -0.013718538917601109, 0.04034658893942833, -0.0037330961786210537, -0.05953509733080864, 0.009443278424441814, 0.0012734642950817943, -0.024572907015681267, 0.032112330198287964, -0.029926728457212448, 0.04360201954841614, 0.027165906503796577, -0.00596029544249177, 0.036740053445100784, 0.004735860042273998, -0.01992296800017357, -0.010863122530281544, -0.00369541859254241, 0.00756110018119216, -0.005715442821383476, -0.0026531782932579517, -0.0014600693248212337, -0.00842469371855259, -0.009738260880112648, -0.00805696938186884, 0.014231622219085693, 0.021070634946227074, -0.0044916123151779175, -0.030899744480848312, -0.04703563079237938, 0.031226888298988342, 0.037500862032175064, 0.017602697014808655, 0.012442287988960743, 0.025664115324616432, 0.02901151031255722, 0.013500023633241653, 0.03180236741900444, -0.013560828752815723, 0.04454628750681877, -0.02113453857600689, -0.008121144957840443, 0.05713459104299545, -0.0542641282081604, 0.0010834198910742998, 0.02483239769935608, -0.018997149541974068, 0.04336538910865784, 0.002960585756227374, -0.017944322898983955, 0.015277496539056301, -0.03844417259097099, -0.03636879101395607, 0.03227586671710014, -0.01384663861244917, 0.01711469329893589, -0.039229851216077805, 0.02749488689005375, -0.009090874344110489, -0.0044021084904670715, -0.06304122507572174, -0.025393487885594368, 0.01565420813858509, -0.00034741993295028806, -0.03579891473054886, -0.016053615137934685, -0.02060304954648018, -0.02284412831068039, -0.014645871706306934, -0.046316392719745636, 0.08349648863077164, 0.00409719068557024, -0.01713346503674984, 0.028825819492340088, -0.0011951460037380457, 0.06035652011632919, 0.0010985874105244875, -0.029040537774562836, -0.003241032361984253, -0.03130963444709778, 0.014054941944777966, 0.014692275784909725, 0.03672189638018608, -0.04885973036289215, -0.0038316859863698483, -0.002655327320098877, -0.02878701128065586, 0.015579703263938427, -0.0400700569152832, -0.007927565835416317, -0.020543327555060387, 0.011997529305517673, -0.013208226300776005, -0.000515589548740536, -0.006973565556108952, -0.002059764927253127, 0.02632296457886696, 0.024244394153356552, -0.021712651476264, 0.04976551979780197, -0.01377868838608265, -0.0033043939620256424, 0.007106539327651262, 0.0004912596195936203, 0.03299642354249954, 0.043723709881305695, -0.022052157670259476, -0.00038801413029432297, 0.00454843370243907, -0.0153606366366148, 0.04655015841126442, 0.0005047588492743671, -0.007358623668551445, -0.0012682885862886906, -0.006737472023814917, -0.034075815230607986, -0.022739455103874207, -0.040727872401475906, 0.04050000384449959, 0.04835840314626694, -0.04598591849207878, 0.03416141867637634, 0.035665739327669144, 0.021347038447856903, -0.01763581670820713, -0.01311536319553852, 0.027531083673238754, -0.018672674894332886, -0.007808571215718985, 0.03772929310798645, -0.018867425620555878, 0.026059042662382126, 0.028888961300253868, 0.026510247960686684, -0.0047706374898552895, -0.007394943851977587, -0.006496709305793047, 0.00021460965217556804, 0.030411673709750175, -0.014494920149445534, -0.008879746310412884, 0.019861873239278793, -0.05176347866654396, -0.013074411079287529, -0.026537641882896423, -0.04132196679711342, 0.04731177166104317, -0.012330520898103714, 0.018896760419011116, -0.047044675797224045, -0.030593207105994225, -0.026158533990383148, 0.00855238176882267, 0.005547738634049892, 0.03393107280135155, 0.021483713760972023, 0.02779177576303482, 0.005303596146404743, 0.02119271270930767, 0.010432200506329536, 0.01091125886887312, -0.0903252586722374, -0.016307583078742027, -0.04584868624806404, -0.050185177475214005, -0.006682348437607288, 0.014357113279402256, -0.01987595483660698, -0.023520100861787796, -0.017568062990903854, 0.00017358870536554605, 0.018922191113233566, 0.0111282579600811, -0.0035149259492754936, 0.06680109351873398, 0.02521912194788456, 0.049676619470119476, 0.023525604978203773, -0.0223339032381773, 0.10225789994001389, 0.06414832919836044, 0.032051410526037216, -0.07143044471740723, 0.014327017590403557, -0.007860380224883556, -0.0006448749918490648, -0.03723553568124771, -0.0004589447344187647, 0.026847654953598976, 0.005768391769379377, 0.030547933652997017, 0.05706539750099182, -0.002235461724922061, -0.034999046474695206, 0.04433455318212509, -0.06604351848363876, -0.07056058943271637, -0.0037811482325196266, 0.01938268169760704, -0.02148570492863655, -0.002033836208283901, -0.013978961855173111, -0.0036504422314465046, 0.036818958818912506, 0.005285447929054499, -0.01955391839146614, -0.0029801882337778807, 0.03053012676537037, -0.0020588377956300974, -0.010935666039586067, -0.02286246046423912, 0.03543321043252945, -0.00324382446706295, -0.025290360674262047, 0.015482050366699696, 0.020101448521018028, -0.03606734797358513, 0.029920537024736404, 0.043054353445768356, 0.01886792853474617, 0.0016455105505883694, 0.024968843907117844, -0.011745154857635498, -0.06800271570682526, -0.0355231873691082, -0.01097274199128151, 0.0018217352917417884, -0.008844900876283646, 0.04703608155250549, -0.014961297623813152, -0.034612447023391724, 0.00035922907409258187, -0.02477746084332466, -0.02538537047803402, 0.03187200799584389, 0.015645915642380714, -0.05217297747731209, -0.03171645849943161, -0.009286622516810894, 0.03401621803641319, -0.02050088718533516, 0.06031075119972229, 0.018165728077292442, -0.012589427642524242, 0.005440573673695326, -0.019741183146834373, 0.0021641908679157495, 0.025088734924793243, 0.005785258952528238, -0.06743969023227692, 0.0023718958254903555, -0.022537052631378174, -0.01270984672009945, 0.015568173490464687, -0.010282058268785477, 0.028275158256292343, 0.012829053215682507, -0.006666573230177164, 0.014358635060489178, -0.039519939571619034, 0.004792708903551102, -0.08640279620885849, -0.02058195136487484, -0.03375841677188873, 0.02493314817547798, 0.034160397946834564, 0.02720601111650467, 0.0070371245965361595, 0.022285396233201027, 0.004784660413861275, 0.061571087688207626, 0.04840430989861488, -0.03846453130245209, -0.003998360130935907, -0.008797015994787216, -0.006139772944152355, -0.008953209035098553, -0.03780512139201164, 0.04153113812208176, 0.007937301881611347, 0.02712532877922058, 0.012299531139433384, -0.005534693598747253, -0.014664825052022934, 0.028174245730042458, 0.002623161533847451, -0.042615294456481934, 0.010192511603236198, 0.020361201837658882, 0.005409011151641607, -0.039679624140262604, -0.02448255568742752, 0.0016105202957987785, 0.01922028139233589, 0.04722052812576294, -0.0418870784342289, -0.04406895488500595, -0.007952462881803513, -0.025409763678908348, 0.05302203446626663, 0.01116923801600933, -0.026554357260465622, -0.0061497436836361885, -0.007375349290668964, 0.0356108658015728, -0.02225838601589203, -0.029511718079447746, 0.009607639163732529, -0.003258321899920702, -0.02403370663523674, 0.012631178833544254, 0.043137840926647186, 0.0022120531648397446, -0.008972943760454655, 0.02567216008901596, -0.010294599458575249, 0.04816056787967682, -0.03645472973585129, -0.05655234679579735, 0.05238068103790283, -0.04348955675959587, -0.022201398387551308, 0.023715179413557053, 0.02561228536069393, 0.036457933485507965, 0.016507670283317566, 0.011219050735235214, -0.014879634603857994, 0.02014230564236641, -0.08161873370409012, -0.024267293512821198, 0.004294871352612972, 0.01156606525182724, 0.0013097623595967889, 0.027748342603445053, 0.0008939796825870872, 0.036213867366313934, -0.025420887395739555, -0.0015081447781994939, 0.03133367747068405, -0.002733726054430008, -0.006928800139576197, 0.022727927193045616, 0.008357547223567963, 0.04233969748020172, 0.011798274703323841, -0.00946905929595232, 0.01314412709325552, 0.06364470720291138, -0.02978886477649212, 0.06385137140750885, -0.008713934570550919, 0.01513061486184597, -0.06638085842132568, -0.023459523916244507, 0.058238573372364044, 0.006373086478561163, 0.04577616602182388, -0.04165927320718765, 0.0002128729538526386, 0.005147245712578297, -0.04056864604353905, 0.02824576571583748, 0.01663460023701191, -0.004900687374174595, -0.04316148906946182, 0.027917463332414627, -0.011382292956113815, 0.062394846230745316, 0.004195831250399351, 0.028047451749444008, 0.04969417676329613, 0.0013570135924965143, 0.007354189176112413, -0.034468285739421844, -0.007598576135933399, 0.010260256007313728, -0.019505657255649567, -0.055171795189380646, 0.02112874947488308, -0.03644879534840584, -0.03295350819826126, 0.008919092826545238, 0.001153098070062697, -0.011624932289123535, 0.011197329498827457, 0.024315617978572845, 0.02978484332561493, 0.03472486138343811, -0.00629808334633708, -0.006076216232031584, 0.005747823975980282, 0.022898271679878235, 0.001749172923155129, 0.03877595439553261, -0.043917540460824966, -0.012506498955190182, 0.05358437821269035, -0.011437551118433475, -0.03999342396855354, 0.017728101462125778, 0.026013309136033058, -0.03868811950087547, 0.007385866716504097, -0.016254078596830368, -0.00908800307661295, -0.0105308648198843, 0.023154480382800102, -0.03683498501777649, -0.016746485605835915, 0.05049610137939453, 0.004492646548897028, 0.01685805805027485, -0.006863845977932215, -0.018466012552380562, -0.0556710883975029, 0.01193786971271038, 0.033157214522361755, -0.027120551094412804, -0.058891136199235916, 0.009579388424754143, -0.0059358663856983185, -0.003669177182018757, 0.004905674606561661, -0.05964745581150055, 0.0028406609781086445, 0.0031754241790622473, -0.011326112784445286, -0.00004560090746963397, 0.01141289621591568, -0.028583265841007233, 0.011814613826572895, -0.04331180825829506, 0.03610752895474434, -0.0037713637575507164, 0.01801961660385132, -0.05372488126158714, -0.010250695049762726, -0.009997463785111904, -0.02947319485247135, 0.035283442586660385, 0.013769436627626419, -0.0038294559344649315, -0.016414375975728035, 0.008187183178961277, 0.026922103017568588, -0.025396663695573807, -0.012111748568713665, -0.05358069762587547, 0.000609532929956913, -0.07020515203475952, -0.009097089059650898, -0.007136437110602856, 0.009864293038845062, 0.012654825113713741, -0.02333366684615612, -0.004322187043726444, -0.02617443911731243, 0.032354675233364105, 0.034391921013593674, 0.007109103724360466, 0.011818588711321354, 0.05946746841073036, -0.034822385758161545, 0.017973292618989944, -0.009470053017139435, -0.007885454222559929, -0.05823122709989548, 0.01525403093546629, -0.04513635113835335, -0.031279075890779495, 0.009472410194575787, 0.01322446670383215, 0.029567105695605278, -0.05989164486527443, -0.01730293594300747, -0.000717284856364131, -0.03826708346605301, -0.000476128829177469, 0.03783905506134033, 0.00931303296238184, 0.028328238055109978, -0.0005110549973323941, 0.016848649829626083, 0.011231508105993271, -0.010478079319000244, -0.0044572362676262856, 0.02687387354671955, 0.06689971685409546, -0.008665340021252632, 0.02660331130027771, 0.02221657522022724, 0.00248685572296381, 0.0488109290599823, 0.006486132275313139, 0.014239325188100338, 0.020793849602341652, -0.010271565057337284, -0.015579801984131336, -0.01791120134294033, 0.037086136639118195, -0.0015986993676051497, -0.0047844089567661285, 0.06280838698148727, -0.02834874764084816, 0.0363597571849823, -0.037895746529102325, -0.0299602672457695, -0.03182745352387428, -0.04720008000731468, 0.017286181449890137, -0.00007280833960976452, -0.03251074254512787, -0.025928955525159836, 0.03053892031311989, -0.006666501984000206, 0.043875377625226974, -0.04342532157897949, 0.02657526172697544, 0.010465690866112709, -0.023714840412139893, -0.054074034094810486, -0.034729570150375366, -0.03730253875255585, -0.0477127879858017, -0.005625298712402582, 0.04183943197131157, 0.0346277579665184, 0.03793177753686905, -0.03221758455038071, -0.008978155441582203, 0.024111513048410416, -0.0444946214556694, 0.0075136045925319195, -0.052986592054367065, 0.02641572244465351, -0.0001258549455087632, -0.04969140142202377 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/agsGZ.png" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/fgfjT.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I took the residual of a historical stock price $\hat e_t=r_t-\hat \mu_t$, where $r_t$ is the return of a stock and ran ACF and PACF. From the ACF I think that the residual does not follow AR or MA process, and the PACF shows slight MA. But I am new to this and I am not sure if my interpretation is correct.</p> <p>What do you think?</p> <p>The Ljung Box test gave Q-statistic of 87.5597</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/AJi7W.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>which rejects the null that the autocorrelation coefficients are all zero. I used 40 lags here to be consistent with the ACF and PACF. </p> <p>Does this contradict or confirm your intuition from visually inspecting ACF and PACF?</p>
74,207
[ 0.007493856828659773, 0.007328895851969719, 0.0003864608006551862, -0.005316094029694796, 0.05556594580411911, -0.011234648525714874, -0.0015460423892363906, 0.012708229944109917, 0.0014782806392759085, -0.05147510766983032, 0.02930980548262596, 0.02722681127488613, 0.019811177626252174, 0.009325876832008362, 0.008901792578399181, 0.006292223464697599, -0.013552285730838776, -0.033897265791893005, 0.05073264613747597, -0.02554459311068058, 0.0030435333028435707, 0.042188167572021484, -0.04547516256570816, -0.024491962045431137, -0.04428835213184357, 0.04472265765070915, 0.02918708696961403, 0.006878296844661236, -0.0006082732579670846, 0.07149044424295425, -0.015250295400619507, -0.007318253628909588, -0.033436328172683716, 0.012998457998037338, -0.016375193372368813, 0.014317817986011505, -0.0017272608820348978, -0.03676382452249527, 0.016385242342948914, 0.07277879118919373, -0.007768196053802967, -0.0015272600576281548, -0.014734911732375622, 0.007815886288881302, -0.011312928982079029, 0.0017458915244787931, 0.0255770031362772, -0.023108171299099922, 0.014475459232926369, -0.041792213916778564, 0.06584122776985168, 0.001850905828177929, -0.010458135977387428, 0.015611938200891018, -0.02673500031232834, -0.040189217776060104, 0.04264973849058151, 0.03663391247391701, -0.018836330622434616, -0.0644407868385315, 0.013018452562391758, -0.004950092639774084, -0.016025898978114128, -0.007729944307357073, -0.03876073285937309, 0.014696631580591202, 0.020563330501317978, -0.009954302571713924, 0.009471653029322624, -0.01505468413233757, 0.02298668399453163, 0.0227323267608881, 0.008928915485739708, 0.0027214735746383667, 0.04059987887740135, -0.025955509394407272, 0.021015852689743042, 0.03490728512406349, 0.03422700613737106, 0.04059785604476929, 0.04209686443209648, -0.0030154373962432146, 0.0335824079811573, 0.028599223122000694, 0.06391946226358414, 0.02314298041164875, 0.04733356833457947, -0.0434006005525589, 0.015504072420299053, 0.0427812784910202, -0.02687927708029747, -0.007631844375282526, 0.062868133187294, 0.0027993666008114815, -0.05667686089873314, 0.011841033585369587, -0.02395492047071457, 0.06399093568325043, 0.032727498561143875, -0.01800113171339035, -0.040110789239406586, -0.03962785378098488, 0.032147105783224106, 0.055951137095689774, 0.01086916122585535, 0.011374994181096554, 0.005289918277412653, 0.016730807721614838, -0.005355540197342634, -0.009150471538305283, -0.06626543402671814, 0.012243044562637806, -0.029964420944452286, 0.012832032516598701, 0.045737240463495255, 0.023066500201821327, -0.008040168322622776, -0.0018639081390574574, 0.07325666397809982, 0.0684165358543396, 0.009149705059826374, -0.020535090938210487, 0.020344920456409454, -0.018411248922348022, -0.026567086577415466, 0.013237393461167812, 0.014455331489443779, -0.02595413289964199, -0.05984732508659363, 0.06424460560083389, -0.0052479892037808895, -0.02320232056081295, 0.009487800300121307, 0.006037423852831125, 0.018172943964600563, -0.0032942993566393852, -0.08825495094060898, -0.061680905520915985, 0.06334072351455688, -0.026528287678956985, 0.018789691850543022, -0.084211565554142, -0.012587903998792171, 0.012839089147746563, 0.05932958051562309, 0.0059004295617341995, 0.034379661083221436, 0.004679220728576183, 0.07426364719867706, 0.008828516118228436, -0.051356829702854156, 0.00486482959240675, -0.034654539078474045, -0.03407661244273186, -0.03125894442200661, -0.1017378643155098, -0.024928929284214973, 0.03641584888100624, 0.016748851165175438, -0.019433511421084404, 0.024635719135403633, 0.014798599295318127, -0.027245432138442993, 0.000491111830342561, -0.019518284127116203, -0.05467363819479942, 0.04829014465212822, 0.01126413606107235, 0.001072501065209508, -0.005402725655585527, 0.003398987464606762, 0.027469845488667488, 0.014069744385778904, 0.01563360169529915, 0.0027791212778538465, -0.035485487431287766, 0.03980472311377525, -0.015644803643226624, -0.018542958423495293, 0.015155056491494179, -0.0495310015976429, -0.012333571910858154, -0.04887005314230919, -0.009282242506742477, 0.025193704292178154, 0.03106795996427536, -0.026423834264278412, 0.00013948623382020742, 0.06346064060926437, -0.06468135863542557, -0.045255646109580994, -0.07601939886808395, 0.022546112537384033, -0.036549728363752365, -0.019557274878025055, -0.004878218285739422, 0.003541248617693782, 0.005218526814132929, 0.011826976202428341, -0.02709989994764328, 0.021493252366781235, 0.008280056528747082, 0.042640142142772675, -0.03882641717791557, 0.023129232227802277, 0.0158830713480711, 0.019392434507608414, -0.007640792056918144, 0.014529732055962086, -0.016245197504758835, -0.06782455742359161, 0.021506093442440033, -0.01802418939769268, 0.032741010189056396, -0.014268449507653713, 0.008070000447332859, 0.048450812697410583, 0.009228642098605633, -0.02881268784403801, 0.0213104709982872, -0.04089070484042168, 0.04593052715063095, 0.05163266509771347, 0.008710592985153198, -0.02236296236515045, 0.019359828904271126, 0.015236901119351387, -0.0004676934622693807, -0.029192300513386726, 0.030589662492275238, -0.03850990906357765, -0.01597309298813343, 0.033456750214099884, 0.02964627742767334, -0.011293112300336361, 0.04120061174035072, 0.04888686537742615, -0.006021765526384115, 0.005060001276433468, 0.042755596339702606, 0.006356192287057638, -0.01895463466644287, -0.0027241285424679518, 0.024653146043419838, 0.013310016132891178, -0.0071616992354393005, 0.016318224370479584, -0.019366983324289322, 0.01772925816476345, -0.03320540860295296, -0.0023859457578510046, 0.05357231944799423, -0.016600696370005608, -0.006476475857198238, -0.05478611961007118, -0.025126520544290543, 0.040147121995687485, -0.041160713881254196, -0.023973373696208, -0.012258161790668964, 0.037004273384809494, -0.008834216743707657, -0.012007820419967175, -0.03215229511260986, -0.013247557915747166, -0.007973631843924522, -0.018279748037457466, -0.018233833834528923, -0.0019025781657546759, -0.027687476947903633, 0.014444354921579361, -0.05261841043829918, 0.014506649225950241, -0.010709390975534916, -0.0015841082204133272, 0.027978455647826195, 0.04622167348861694, 0.02501560188829899, -0.029624463990330696, -0.013139321468770504, 0.004134576302021742, -0.006809417624026537, 0.03431277349591255, 0.031298842281103134, -0.02781405672430992, -0.019903624430298805, -0.024938441812992096, 0.008193680085241795, 0.02706899121403694, -0.010341038927435875, 0.0016761895967647433, 0.01965276338160038, -0.008009430952370167, -0.05077922344207764, -0.041684042662382126, -0.05327937752008438, -0.011476323008537292, -0.06616225093603134, -0.025798015296459198, 0.05758503079414368, 0.03193112835288048, -0.04023119434714317, 0.03410568833351135, -0.032849475741386414, -0.002779897302389145, -0.019935164600610733, -0.028888432309031487, -0.008264060132205486, -0.04580249637365341, -0.028320321813225746, -0.0009029170614667237, -0.019439805299043655, -0.008244863711297512, -0.05742963030934334, -0.05646276846528053, 0.017295634374022484, -0.01890067756175995, 0.004458539187908173, 0.01053858082741499, -0.04421127960085869, 0.059478674083948135, 0.03768378123641014, 0.009634649381041527, -0.039158038794994354, -0.005048539023846388, -0.04315682500600815, -0.03769440948963165, -0.01126267109066248, 0.02607092075049877, 0.015900809317827225, 0.03861679509282112, -0.032276272773742676, 0.03986068814992905, 0.05875861272215843, 0.004523819778114557, 0.027211930602788925, 0.013550659641623497, -0.03243940323591232, 0.019425883889198303, 0.054522085934877396, 0.03693521022796631, -0.012577573768794537, -0.008830253034830093, -0.009863604791462421, 0.023829828947782516, -0.007632150314748287, -0.0735761970281601, 0.030719522386789322, -0.04475747421383858, -0.009448854252696037, -0.016964862123131752, 0.02622935175895691, -0.006888111587613821, -0.02114654704928398, -0.037800032645463943, -0.04556227847933769, -0.0022855259012430906, 0.02854151837527752, 0.005712530110031366, 0.07402171939611435, 0.020921116694808006, -0.019036179408431053, -0.009459841065108776, -0.020933305844664574, -0.013554942794144154, 0.06574400514364243, -0.04278062283992767, -0.020009947940707207, 0.026205215603113174, 0.015200521796941757, 0.04829450696706772, -0.009682146832346916, -0.0473138764500618, 0.0024477553088217974, -0.06516962498426437, 0.024261465296149254, -0.01599506288766861, 0.0648168995976448, -0.00003878971256199293, 0.052700746804475784, 0.014260378666222095, -0.025496620684862137, 0.0013681487180292606, -0.000770599115639925, -0.050602518022060394, 0.02586357295513153, 0.013259022496640682, -0.027439774945378304, -0.01526047382503748, -0.024407632648944855, 0.027528317645192146, -0.012460238300263882, 0.023754896596074104, -0.011469854041934013, 0.02786092832684517, -0.02590918354690075, -0.004726755432784557, -0.02780011296272278, 0.018152393400669098, -0.021505091339349747, -0.02235887572169304, 0.029826460406184196, -0.01976742222905159, 0.03360225632786751, 0.08721747249364853, -0.006952942349016666, 0.011224024929106236, 0.00424910057336092, 0.03282443434000015, 0.07723517715930939, 0.023359300568699837, 0.07041031122207642, -0.011870434507727623, -0.026218080893158913, 0.023489244282245636, 0.03683774173259735, 0.022842438891530037, 0.032865967601537704, 0.01940775103867054, 0.012049762532114983, -0.029389578849077225, -0.041458915919065475, 0.010434621945023537, 0.004955766722559929, 0.03093818947672844, 0.004906835500150919, 0.04034670069813728, 0.03959505259990692, -0.01668204367160797, 0.017965376377105713, 0.04686792194843292, 0.03691970929503441, 0.018178049474954605, -0.05494038015604019, 0.011146296747028828, 0.03585459664463997, -0.00964155700057745, 0.06430543214082718, -0.007213329430669546, -0.033139634877443314, -0.007502279244363308, 0.02854839526116848, -0.0011189086362719536, -0.02511879988014698, 0.007067436818033457, 0.005329389590770006, -0.004172095097601414, -0.009787507355213165, -0.015891248360276222, 0.034964997321367264, 0.0648515596985817, 0.008385571651160717, 0.03883756324648857, -0.01270059123635292, -0.09001395851373672, 0.022067217156291008, 0.034003596752882004, 0.03200140222907066, -0.012126443907618523, -0.028459811583161354, -0.06096474081277847, -0.032778698951005936, -0.0010704142041504383, -0.0034498851746320724, 0.04940665140748024, 0.00007400827598758042, 0.04138131067156792, -0.028795000165700912, -0.05204830318689346, 0.004133857320994139, 0.015341052785515785, -0.005619199015200138, 0.005135392304509878, -0.04501728340983391, -0.031286273151636124, 0.0013842949410900474, -0.01658821478486061, 0.009822512045502663, 0.032159604132175446, -0.031144224107265472, 0.032468751072883606, -0.02650526538491249, 0.016726462170481682, 0.020670434460043907, -0.08436118811368942, 0.012987468391656876, -0.018600959330797195, -0.005415366496890783, 0.05731706693768501, 0.005436071660369635, -0.010216751135885715, 0.011610956862568855, 0.0027827173471450806, 0.00962085835635662, -0.009952431544661522, -0.059302546083927155, 0.04103406146168709, 0.007523023523390293, -0.01837710291147232, 0.03912367299199104, 0.01150620635598898, 0.0020338869653642178, 0.005706048104912043, -0.012708581052720547, 0.018074573948979378, -0.007602211087942123, -0.0027087745256721973, -0.045704323798418045, 0.007225341629236937, -0.031170884147286415, 0.012542447075247765, -0.017436187714338303, 0.030661465600132942, -0.018192142248153687, 0.009249141439795494, 0.020000159740447998, -0.01044527254998684, -0.008990621194243431, -0.004637395963072777, 0.022481266409158707, -0.0033620898611843586, -0.05085195600986481, -0.023853762075304985, 0.006838526111096144, 0.0030657800380140543, -0.00473730219528079, 0.04265730828046799, -0.0035876291804015636, 0.01539436262100935, -0.008673951961100101, -0.005719804670661688, -0.04540504887700081, 0.0014552939683198929, 0.033034373074769974, 0.012937110848724842, 0.023961082100868225, 0.005782803986221552, 0.00028698131791315973, -0.04973346367478371, 0.013149311766028404, -0.009869752451777458, 0.05037127807736397, -0.026577362790703773, 0.034737441688776016, 0.0031452642288058996, -0.023710979148745537, -0.05288861319422722, -0.049275267869234085, 0.014765465632081032, 0.035278256982564926, -0.07243754714727402, -0.016968753188848495, -0.02879059873521328, -0.02195516973733902, 0.007918212562799454, -0.003412107937037945, 0.06130652129650116, -0.016153628006577492, -0.03271578252315521, 0.024032706394791603, 0.03841923177242279, 0.06067275628447533, -0.014033913612365723, -0.025426451116800308, -0.004389854148030281, -0.00018298957729712129, -0.017637958750128746, 0.0026747710071504116, 0.019810037687420845, -0.027493637055158615, -0.005761558655649424, -0.03571692481637001, -0.01296338438987732, 0.034786395728588104, -0.01715194620192051, -0.04153933376073837, 0.023378081619739532, 0.00006685583502985537, 0.01224549487233162, -0.025786101818084717, 0.005904140416532755, 0.009242436848580837, 0.023376019671559334, -0.0020600957795977592, -0.044622696936130524, 0.027250897139310837, 0.004430487751960754, 0.023758942261338234, -0.0008545358432456851, -0.042011015117168427, 0.0138782924041152, 0.06764841079711914, -0.0429670549929142, -0.028948264196515083, -0.040340106934309006, 0.007325763814151287, 0.03499613329768181, -0.013895268552005291, 0.01057986170053482, -0.020658627152442932, -0.010304206050932407, -0.04986342042684555, 0.01635449007153511, -0.06504163891077042, -0.0011954980436712503, 0.061628177762031555, 0.0027895946986973286, 0.05223365128040314, 0.0014676408609375358, 0.021297305822372437, 0.01597464457154274, -0.035883717238903046, 0.02355010062456131, -0.005126655101776123, -0.014281355775892735, 0.04229837656021118, -0.01158717181533575, 0.012924323789775372, 0.011132754385471344, -0.004687475040555, 0.0045637511648237705, 0.010770495049655437, 0.06271106749773026, 0.02772684395313263, 0.0027686019893735647, -0.009208893403410912, -0.042791448533535004, 0.03272753581404686, -0.028544792905449867, 0.04562383517622948, -0.02252131886780262, -0.0018006796017289162, 0.056335341185331345, 0.026008758693933487, -0.00423748604953289, -0.04385749623179436, -0.006539592985063791, -0.05620705336332321, 0.006922933738678694, 0.013191208243370056, -0.018384870141744614, 0.045695241540670395, 0.0009574630530551076, 0.08519481122493744, -0.027956178411841393, 0.05362933874130249, 0.03453650698065758, -0.041211407631635666, 0.020123934373259544, -0.006831799168139696, -0.01153851579874754, 0.03437675163149834, -0.050660427659749985, -0.008880289271473885, -0.01696324162185192, -0.06374811381101608, 0.015452560037374496, -0.01607881300151348, 0.0360724963247776, -0.019243957474827766, 0.06961309164762497, 0.02798372134566307, 0.020360508933663368, -0.026167957112193108, -0.03380458801984787, 0.1458233892917633, 0.05562882870435715, -0.002541173016652465, -0.05069515109062195, 0.007818029262125492, -0.01374912727624178, 0.02021058276295662, -0.03275369107723236, -0.01508859358727932, -0.05439433827996254, 0.007963115349411964, 0.05714738741517067, 0.04158475250005722, 0.016788093373179436, -0.015652572736144066, -0.005639448296278715, -0.05163835361599922, 0.005178666207939386, -0.0027543308679014444, 0.028421344235539436, -0.0026495486963540316, 0.016967879608273506, -0.03045709989964962, 0.012210270389914513, -0.005066697020083666, 0.005377656780183315, 0.0038597630336880684, -0.01614929363131523, -0.0018826016457751393, -0.006621119566261768, -0.048488643020391464, -0.02294333092868328, 0.04309950768947601, 0.013124235905706882, -0.02709794044494629, -0.027982736006379128, -0.0016863164491951466, -0.05480328947305679, 0.0017917283112183213, 0.02641698531806469, 0.025795508176088333, -0.019997041672468185, 0.006752571556717157, -0.028602102771401405, -0.028556879609823227, -0.00897256750613451, -0.03452721983194351, 0.03296612203121185, -0.006094044074416161, -0.007409949786961079, -0.06350231170654297, -0.02858571708202362, -0.025966480374336243, -0.039883993566036224, 0.004150317516177893, 0.020438412204384804, 0.009138545952737331, -0.05004362761974335, 0.026251021772623062, -0.04295461252331734, -0.017484543845057487, -0.004308593459427357, 0.023485589772462845, 0.001050814287737012, -0.019457131624221802, -0.023748451843857765, -0.020135074853897095, 0.051077745854854584, -0.06428650766611099, 0.01745675690472126, -0.007062301971018314, 0.0007912078290246427, -0.04810001328587532, 0.01740318164229393, 0.020764144137501717, 0.035540785640478134, 0.026114951819181442, 0.023526959121227264, -0.007827839814126492, -0.012453741393983364, -0.0639767050743103, 0.02773420326411724, -0.05515608191490173, -0.00677154678851366, -0.0504944808781147, 0.005319791845977306, 0.015481325797736645, 0.07355017960071564, -0.016660064458847046, -0.00732498150318861, -0.029828984290361404, 0.06631450355052948, 0.00863641407340765, -0.027669506147503853, -0.01322014257311821, 0.019240323454141617, -0.012417745776474476, -0.02046772465109825, -0.04586786776781082, 0.05157741159200668, 0.06130659207701683, 0.04707741737365723, -0.04369841143488884, -0.00530672911554575, 0.02537512220442295, -0.0010554277105256915, 0.016323229297995567, -0.031424228101968765, 0.027639761567115784, 0.056010082364082336, 0.007676054257899523, -0.02795153297483921, -0.031937576830387115, 0.0011288170935586095, -0.0127320047467947, -0.013069233857095242, 0.0236553605645895, -0.031185034662485123, 0.009969697333872318, -0.02226235531270504, 0.02931266836822033, -0.05706759914755821, -0.01630532741546631, -0.025950537994503975, -0.045530710369348526, 0.012553316541016102, -0.027677731588482857, -0.05456750467419624, 0.0335087925195694, -0.019590485841035843, 0.007560985628515482, 0.054903339594602585, 0.02489078976213932, 0.004340821877121925, -0.027275850996375084, 0.002068928210064769, 0.01675974205136299, 0.018793625757098198, 0.004769656807184219, -0.027643805369734764, -0.010555955581367016, -0.02949436753988266, -0.03416479378938675, 0.009564012289047241, 0.012554050423204899, 0.022521698847413063, 0.0014130549971014261, 0.020875800400972366, -0.026880132034420967, 0.023053620010614395, -0.022906702011823654, 0.01486937701702118, -0.011251592077314854, 0.004677570424973965, 0.05220451578497887, 0.005378722678869963, 0.02040984481573105, 0.029006335884332657, -0.01656653918325901, -0.010120299644768238, 0.030052270740270615, 0.003635919187217951, 0.0055535463616251945, 0.015374736860394478, -0.038005001842975616, -0.016943413764238358, -0.010631270706653595, -0.005918128415942192, -0.002450629835948348, 0.03653288632631302, 0.013340989127755165, 0.036088328808546066, -0.03134329989552498, 0.02374730072915554, -0.08670013397932053, 0.00889420136809349, 0.01344177033752203, 0.04084225371479988, 0.05245468392968178, -0.03657173365354538, 0.013380110263824463, 0.05255664139986038, -0.07016082853078842, 0.026054123416543007, 0.01378429215401411, 0.015192347578704357, -0.06119051203131676, -0.033465638756752014, -0.03775520622730255, 0.01934768073260784, 0.03229104354977608, 0.00004079585414729081, 0.005839771591126919, 0.04828142374753952, 0.009916428476572037, 0.014612513594329357, -0.002332442905753851, 0.015324047766625881, 0.01736239716410637, -0.01482360064983368, 0.059135738760232925, -0.009459096007049084, -0.01095636934041977, 0.04026171565055847, 0.01253165490925312, 0.02833777852356434, 0.023590276017785072, -0.012018074281513691, 0.022989923134446144, 0.0017746540252119303, 0.02895159274339676, -0.0025199302472174168, 0.02611619420349598, -0.0013668544124811888, 0.04049541801214218, 0.011780229397118092, 0.014530085027217865, 0.03423106297850609, 0.028447823598980904, -0.015593561343848705, -0.013501215726137161, 0.021175064146518707, -0.006481564603745937, -0.012328458949923515, 0.015946166589856148, -0.0007381667965091765, 0.012745555490255356, 0.013161581009626389, 0.021383870393037796, -0.027529986575245857, -0.023654727265238762, 0.046172745525836945, 0.04663405567407608, -0.0343329943716526, -0.008956347592175007, -0.03804745525121689, -0.0396108478307724, 0.030847938731312752, 0.04482894763350487, 0.01591389626264572, -0.051948923617601395, -0.03716485574841499, -0.007432583253830671, -0.008705287240445614, -0.019190272316336632, -0.034162573516368866, -0.0004959842772223055, 0.01432255282998085, -0.04692843183875084, -0.03888118267059326, 0.0446464940905571, -0.01214994303882122, -0.006321873981505632, -0.09829339385032654, 0.054695919156074524, -0.020509842783212662, -0.03937263414263725, 0.007688633166253567, -0.030128635466098785, -0.03621622920036316, -0.007037999574095011, 0.04272671043872833, -0.014741920866072178, 0.005898443050682545, 0.0038567790761590004, -0.025736279785633087, 0.016954384744167328, -0.015561467036604881, 0.048505641520023346, -0.05312115326523781, 0.005336219910532236, 0.02634301595389843, 0.012207730673253536, 0.007576697040349245, 0.015327833592891693, 0.023123901337385178, -0.004655861761420965, -0.032119330018758774, 0.0029203486628830433, -0.007919315248727798, 0.05408874526619911, -0.0029409152921289206, -0.018407458439469337, 0.05193323642015457, 0.06605392694473267, -0.008667385205626488, 0.043410323560237885, -0.012023183517158031, -0.05968451127409935, 0.04293294623494148, 0.013350466266274452, -0.014136005192995071, -0.013727178797125816, 0.013826383277773857, 0.008404134772717953, -0.04630374163389206, -0.007060272619128227, 0.020022686570882797, -0.011600387282669544, -0.024932662025094032, 0.035481493920087814, 0.015846645459532738, 0.009973007254302502, -0.02194642461836338, 0.03824436292052269, 0.013770810328423977, 0.001478864811360836, -0.01003773882985115, 0.0005598443676717579, 0.05184737592935562, 0.017393965274095535, 0.03297736868262291, 0.02182801067829132, -0.007485309150069952, -0.003649079706519842, -0.009894085116684437, 0.029656153172254562, -0.022866517305374146, -0.03743625804781914, 0.01939317025244236, 0.011509228497743607, 0.02040519379079342, -0.020124351605772972, 0.004601686727255583, 0.035434290766716, -0.04756768047809601, 0.0033443497959524393, 0.0011230558156967163, 0.01749461516737938, -0.04006808623671532, 0.007645594887435436, 0.012599747627973557, 0.0031677400693297386, -0.00210569822229445, -0.003765993984416127, -0.009890580549836159, 0.022099696099758148, 0.04094048961997032, -0.024499645456671715, -0.02306678146123886, -0.002501249313354492, -0.00806102342903614, 0.016348006203770638, -0.04381987452507019, -0.03418770432472229, -0.012248179875314236, 0.01582947187125683, 0.037370141595602036, 0.00503534683957696, -0.03585962951183319, -0.02630254626274109, 0.013723169453442097, 0.09815168380737305, -0.05120687559247017, 0.016712762415409088, -0.006981616839766502, -0.009206751361489296, 0.025211934000253677, -0.007883142679929733 ]
<p>I am interested in stochastically modeling whether the market is likely to go on in the same direction(trend), or reverse and head back. This is all for intraday purposes, next 1-2 ticks kind of strategy with 30sec - 3 mins holding times. How can I attack this problem? Where do I start? </p>
74,208
[ -0.005029224790632725, -0.054788921028375626, -0.004421102814376354, 0.010463177226483822, 0.028402624651789665, -0.012998932041227818, 0.027584683150053024, -0.0016778744757175446, 0.051725007593631744, -0.04555230960249901, 0.016714418306946754, 0.019654473289847374, 0.06399548798799515, 0.033136554062366486, 0.018757589161396027, 0.00496314000338316, -0.014155341312289238, -0.018654027953743935, -0.015700941905379295, -0.018383478745818138, 0.0010481795761734247, -0.02068360149860382, 0.03148474544286728, -0.007295168936252594, -0.05794304981827736, 0.007553241681307554, 0.056808192282915115, 0.0005287792882882059, 0.002459559589624405, 0.05127064883708954, -0.058794766664505005, -0.03589821234345436, 0.0030481209978461266, 0.06091546267271042, -0.0037783277221024036, 0.024254897609353065, -0.006168573163449764, -0.0750080794095993, -0.03261711075901985, 0.02384333685040474, -0.03196398913860321, 0.0042523411102592945, -0.004324969369918108, 0.03437680006027222, 0.009712149389088154, -0.006014267448335886, -0.036029938608407974, -0.01614212431013584, 0.058125466108322144, -0.07154805958271027, 0.10650959610939026, -0.030659645795822144, 0.029521148651838303, 0.03805918246507645, 0.021810488775372505, 0.003142448142170906, 0.06790190190076828, 0.0748061016201973, 0.003131006145849824, -0.067013680934906, -0.007943686097860336, 0.014359342865645885, -0.014743189327418804, -0.03122871182858944, -0.0576186329126358, 0.026232870295643806, 0.0037255443166941404, -0.026657776907086372, 0.030351709574460983, -0.01909361593425274, 0.010363763198256493, -0.0024126896169036627, 0.050156496465206146, 0.02256457693874836, 0.027644092217087746, -0.017763260751962662, 0.0011976880487054586, 0.05022246390581131, 0.028894534334540367, 0.04228326678276062, 0.014108328148722649, -0.00047236718819476664, 0.01244249939918518, 0.06726867705583572, 0.044988662004470825, -0.025518858805298805, 0.04236045107245445, -0.04182356968522072, 0.005691788624972105, 0.03344681113958359, -0.04826284199953079, -0.0007070449064485729, 0.038064904510974884, -0.014183289371430874, -0.06083652377128601, 0.023065436631441116, 0.016107972711324692, 0.025127483531832695, -0.02240639179944992, -0.008122680708765984, 0.0023986357264220715, -0.049698635935783386, -0.021494140848517418, 0.0332152359187603, -0.037605226039886475, 0.01604861579835415, -0.014975870959460735, -0.0007249760092236102, -0.02032581716775894, -0.020687757059931755, -0.04258591681718826, 0.027960047125816345, 0.020812034606933594, -0.01866178773343563, 0.007997899316251278, -0.009814493358135223, -0.038813021034002304, -0.031528178602457047, 0.013837827369570732, 0.05291028320789337, 0.02466442994773388, 0.0021187474485486746, 0.034447360783815384, -0.04425617307424545, -0.04043149948120117, -0.028573963791131973, 0.012510876171290874, -0.030778780579566956, -0.05631817504763603, 0.06932896375656128, -0.00008544777665520087, -0.05011540278792381, 0.02522842027246952, -0.048458281904459, 0.09112101048231125, -0.0042771706357598305, -0.07453596591949463, -0.0374915711581707, 0.0646611899137497, -0.04361162707209587, 0.007395958062261343, -0.07907261699438095, -0.03301616013050079, 0.05306922644376755, 0.01931513473391533, 0.017830707132816315, 0.0326184444129467, 0.005423279944807291, 0.03508288413286209, 0.028542309999465942, -0.043252989649772644, -0.018923137336969376, -0.018874213099479675, 0.03492153063416481, -0.0026195181999355555, -0.059508513659238815, 0.014161194674670696, 0.017634866759181023, -0.047437503933906555, -0.02470274455845356, 0.01125334668904543, 0.016057142987847328, -0.018675945699214935, 0.010911714285612106, -0.0013793548569083214, -0.03139882534742355, 0.09412220120429993, -0.016849251464009285, -0.004746770020574331, 0.015441786497831345, 0.024289600551128387, -0.0020965200383216143, 0.01770293340086937, 0.013178986497223377, 0.053151655942201614, -0.03252027556300163, 0.006046760827302933, 0.020048750564455986, -0.02577526681125164, 0.02532203122973442, 0.0028658530209213495, 0.019022760912775993, -0.026149483397603035, -0.016456851735711098, 0.00266412366181612, 0.01999293640255928, -0.011560207232832909, -0.020071962848305702, -0.010291782207787037, -0.05628436431288719, -0.01979360729455948, -0.05928361788392067, 0.018245136365294456, -0.03513502702116966, 0.004743669182062149, 0.04436657950282097, -0.00623631477355957, 0.017986556515097618, -0.035422250628471375, -0.04366038739681244, -0.019486183300614357, -0.014326122589409351, 0.040789999067783356, -0.017176596447825432, 0.018121274188160896, 0.05105064809322357, 0.019101087003946304, -0.03585859015583992, 0.006400010082870722, -0.022116772830486298, -0.054231077432632446, -0.018774336203932762, -0.04726025462150574, 0.021145610138773918, -0.0013322909362614155, -0.015385769307613373, 0.043186698108911514, -0.009219257161021233, 0.01073464099317789, 0.016908930614590645, -0.007705519441515207, 0.038161877542734146, 0.05174513906240463, 0.03132426366209984, -0.036722905933856964, -0.004326730500906706, 0.009267840534448624, 0.018865615129470825, 0.023147597908973694, -0.03339154273271561, -0.02425343729555607, 0.031995758414268494, 0.043112512677907944, 0.031540289521217346, -0.03112819790840149, 0.0030880060512572527, 0.08375424146652222, 0.02851204387843609, 0.009875616058707237, 0.05438041314482689, -0.00006335779471555725, 0.007284493185579777, 0.0016901541966944933, -0.0015777089865878224, 0.021314973011612892, -0.009515032172203064, 0.024861248210072517, -0.008365982212126255, 0.021720508113503456, 0.01274191029369831, -0.0648195743560791, 0.019859494641423225, 0.02335120365023613, 0.01096698734909296, -0.0010447879321873188, -0.048866190016269684, 0.01589834876358509, -0.02862633764743805, 0.013231492601335049, 0.021590156480669975, 0.020255066454410553, 0.0007079442148096859, 0.029384436085820198, -0.009870488196611404, -0.00435590511187911, 0.0332573801279068, 0.004524781834334135, 0.016569538041949272, 0.03981607034802437, -0.014416768215596676, 0.019857196137309074, 0.003975920844823122, -0.0071876696310937405, -0.02786150574684143, 0.0012078924337401986, 0.04277211055159569, -0.00024908894556574523, 0.014702025800943375, -0.006788585800677538, -0.03351987153291702, 0.01418641209602356, -0.0024266077671200037, 0.006489990744739771, -0.012241668999195099, -0.06299363076686859, 0.04256680980324745, 0.017762206494808197, -0.020466821268200874, 0.015075376257300377, -0.004635782912373543, 0.04867437854409218, 0.03448515012860298, 0.005167278926819563, -0.07122814655303955, -0.024123337119817734, -0.04346103593707085, 0.030009077861905098, 0.001977298641577363, -0.031422749161720276, 0.054615333676338196, 0.01685880683362484, -0.027860883623361588, 0.03305104374885559, -0.046021468937397, -0.006033250130712986, -0.05390838161110878, 0.018066639080643654, 0.005283738952130079, -0.02829347737133503, 0.0210354533046484, 0.02058347500860691, -0.036259714514017105, 0.01001010462641716, -0.0521799772977829, -0.060409411787986755, -0.03376231715083122, 0.019562842324376106, -0.005030176602303982, 0.012459173798561096, -0.02061472460627556, 0.0630052387714386, 0.023427603766322136, -0.031870659440755844, -0.033616770058870316, -0.017750270664691925, -0.03593439236283302, -0.07628726214170456, 0.012620488181710243, 0.0014017836656421423, -0.006791576277464628, -0.002142018871381879, -0.0002214298874605447, 0.026446733623743057, 0.05422384291887283, 0.0050015500746667385, -0.01405082456767559, 0.020466908812522888, -0.026775971055030823, 0.02436928264796734, 0.018831251189112663, -0.02196572534739971, -0.03022443875670433, -0.014974991790950298, 0.010961956344544888, 0.01938159018754959, 0.03631105273962021, -0.03431982174515724, 0.0517457015812397, -0.022871265187859535, -0.0001875553571153432, -0.01043789368122816, 0.021476969122886658, -0.020403549075126648, -0.0025110465940088034, -0.00713376235216856, 0.0033197090961039066, 0.018192108720541, 0.03167273476719856, 0.029328739270567894, 0.061981990933418274, 0.028865426778793335, -0.03314723074436188, -0.028479913249611855, -0.026823949068784714, -0.017819242551922798, 0.010370716452598572, -0.02112755924463272, -0.00837748683989048, 0.053222451359033585, 0.015408641658723354, 0.03146155923604965, 0.004504084121435881, -0.025643659755587578, -0.02464376576244831, -0.06474617123603821, 0.009573277086019516, -0.025524558499455452, 0.04744114726781845, -0.0023631080985069275, 0.03711467236280441, 0.018008200451731682, -0.017794417217373848, 0.030614886432886124, 0.00732377078384161, -0.06667189300060272, 0.08304749429225922, -0.017011938616633415, -0.002880000276491046, -0.029398053884506226, -0.005324138328433037, 0.006810271181166172, -0.009245202876627445, -0.016294322907924652, -0.0032384057994931936, 0.011789461597800255, -0.042162805795669556, 0.02700604870915413, -0.03839055076241493, 0.01089470274746418, -0.013111386448144913, 0.014534723944962025, 0.018804708495736122, -0.02849867381155491, 0.03807632997632027, 0.04490360617637634, -0.014347495511174202, -0.016581179574131966, -0.016586914658546448, 0.01183957327157259, 0.013570374809205532, 0.006679601967334747, 0.03522490710020065, 0.002003417583182454, -0.036719031631946564, 0.05015062913298607, 0.006818310357630253, 0.04586751386523247, 0.04358479008078575, 0.01254194788634777, -0.018726015463471413, -0.0741356909275055, -0.03658849745988846, 0.03672012314200401, 0.01909121498465538, 0.017903130501508713, 0.0023077463265508413, 0.06667971611022949, 0.0215955451130867, -0.04534457251429558, -0.001248336979188025, 0.0826193317770958, 0.0455678328871727, 0.0016342921881005168, -0.035377856343984604, -0.010054846294224262, 0.03267672657966614, 0.01010680291801691, 0.024033689871430397, -0.0042185103520751, -0.017099784687161446, 0.016912905499339104, 0.02990085631608963, -0.008327671326696873, 0.01223086565732956, 0.01616668701171875, -0.014949946664273739, 0.0598125085234642, 0.045497503131628036, -0.004272249527275562, 0.020145796239376068, 0.025331662967801094, 0.03444790840148926, 0.052747804671525955, 0.024062713608145714, -0.11844944208860397, -0.0027284238021820784, 0.018691938370466232, 0.012113118544220924, -0.031519658863544464, -0.006931763142347336, -0.04361017420887947, -0.009918258525431156, 0.00774793978780508, -0.026669718325138092, 0.025753041729331017, -0.021421967074275017, -0.004335868638008833, 0.012392478995025158, -0.0019982082303613424, -0.015216278843581676, 0.013504799455404282, -0.012538990005850792, 0.021672377362847328, -0.03063136525452137, 0.012901426292955875, -0.07487813383340836, -0.012093384750187397, 0.04477478191256523, 0.035018324851989746, -0.042831383645534515, 0.04034409299492836, 0.005433568265289068, 0.04371705278754234, -0.009120123460888863, -0.08133341372013092, -0.02306325174868107, 0.017449168488383293, -0.018210917711257935, 0.026192476972937584, -0.020193032920360565, -0.03407830744981766, 0.005927750375121832, -0.00228611147031188, 0.00855259783565998, 0.0124641889706254, -0.03023633174598217, 0.01430480182170868, 0.0035731096286326647, -0.0043923333287239075, 0.03853359818458557, 0.03631371632218361, 0.009666204452514648, -0.04098266735672951, 0.012061120942234993, 0.0073917219415307045, -0.02892225794494152, 0.009013786911964417, -0.025639686733484268, -0.020579680800437927, -0.04017074406147003, 0.03670092672109604, -0.022978607565164566, 0.04315463826060295, -0.02214355766773224, 0.001953951781615615, -0.02783099375665188, 0.043351612985134125, 0.0235435850918293, -0.020678982138633728, 0.008806218393146992, 0.005107641685754061, -0.03652998432517052, -0.011155907064676285, 0.015263100154697895, -0.03507411107420921, -0.005446888506412506, 0.02611582912504673, -0.02727702632546425, -0.01868765987455845, -0.019606072455644608, -0.028625568374991417, -0.02543889917433262, -0.013973791152238846, 0.03899994120001793, -0.019895311444997787, 0.007689573336392641, 0.019696014001965523, -0.016021115705370903, 0.00942901149392128, 0.028311358764767647, 0.01766597293317318, 0.0011912467889487743, -0.022735685110092163, 0.052315521985292435, -0.015089034102857113, 0.014792806468904018, -0.07996287941932678, -0.07568932324647903, 0.05458052456378937, 0.019906215369701385, -0.04037848487496376, -0.059166908264160156, 0.014293712563812733, -0.022225134074687958, -0.034383077174425125, -0.03798053413629532, 0.03592946007847786, 0.02301744557917118, -0.004493138287216425, 0.030728043988347054, 0.00760907307267189, 0.08192121237516403, 0.00815561879426241, -0.005638972390443087, 0.018088053911924362, -0.011248309165239334, -0.015731312334537506, -0.015670977532863617, 0.013938810676336288, -0.033032242208719254, 0.027669675648212433, -0.02785327471792698, 0.010247689671814442, 0.03736474737524986, -0.058910660445690155, -0.0020480570383369923, 0.020993510261178017, 0.011080536060035229, 0.006590249948203564, -0.04616565629839897, 0.01962946355342865, -0.003292058827355504, -0.004533218685537577, -0.008921685628592968, -0.015619841404259205, -0.016613664105534554, -0.02477685920894146, 0.028484519571065903, 0.001174899865873158, -0.004568440839648247, 0.02732911892235279, 0.03736245632171631, 0.0033186180517077446, -0.03717388957738876, -0.030286148190498352, 0.013396725058555603, 0.015544059686362743, -0.04064278304576874, 0.019550632685422897, 0.010988120920956135, -0.016040807589888573, -0.05373669043183327, -0.06396724283695221, -0.03114297427237034, 0.001062427181750536, 0.05436279624700546, -0.01879601739346981, 0.0549660362303257, 0.015248891897499561, 0.05023721233010292, -0.01545320637524128, 0.002144407480955124, 0.014288908801972866, -0.021438071504235268, 0.011497464962303638, 0.02079620398581028, 0.015155504457652569, 0.027053149417042732, 0.027144458144903183, 0.019020313397049904, 0.044308003038167953, 0.047755494713783264, 0.0263421218842268, 0.0018945072079077363, 0.033155299723148346, 0.012080328539013863, -0.02807367406785488, 0.019167589023709297, -0.04640074446797371, 0.06416172534227371, -0.0656287744641304, -0.009366105310618877, 0.06038429215550423, 0.031206121668219566, -0.02048421837389469, -0.020830370485782623, 0.005401162430644035, -0.03431856259703636, 0.009705477394163609, 0.030892934650182724, 0.004627858754247427, 0.029236484318971634, 0.03859010338783264, 0.05266348645091057, -0.03681562840938568, 0.009738946333527565, 0.0003335049550514668, -0.07151290029287338, -0.011323434300720692, -0.021303171291947365, -0.05906758829951286, 0.026002509519457817, 0.023351462557911873, 0.009882321581244469, -0.014597445726394653, -0.005776125472038984, -0.004115929361432791, -0.027085019275546074, 0.01934554986655712, -0.012774270959198475, 0.10612133890390396, 0.004496438894420862, 0.022035637870430946, -0.03322495147585869, -0.012592516839504242, 0.11557310074567795, 0.0716128721833229, 0.004122039303183556, -0.08391331881284714, 0.007504813373088837, -0.007004926446825266, 0.02865431271493435, -0.054314129054546356, 0.053255386650562286, 0.0447503998875618, 0.012382014654576778, 0.056322354823350906, 0.05168802663683891, -0.009573757648468018, -0.02325957641005516, 0.03903358057141304, -0.03387836739420891, -0.022880325093865395, 0.02437111735343933, 0.0008622372406534851, 0.024206696078181267, -0.012325391173362732, -0.0683513954281807, 0.06064652279019356, -0.036589574068784714, -0.028379177674651146, 0.00588661665096879, -0.012688683345913887, -0.005293739959597588, -0.013095197267830372, -0.01679742895066738, -0.011751468293368816, 0.00718672527000308, 0.005236129742115736, -0.008451220579445362, -0.029597805812954903, 0.00721150916069746, -0.03244958817958832, 0.010534542612731457, -0.004768094513565302, 0.023980000987648964, 0.0038106723222881556, 0.005340284202247858, 0.003675988642498851, -0.012471647001802921, -0.006836818065494299, -0.032903265208005905, 0.021452153101563454, -0.0009216518374159932, -0.010243049822747707, 0.0015768064185976982, -0.004175923299044371, -0.000047849753173068166, -0.018114034086465836, -0.032874878495931625, 0.012812822125852108, 0.03407871350646019, -0.044826406985521317, 0.007666656281799078, -0.04408004507422447, 0.025001218542456627, -0.00433226116001606, 0.041304778307676315, -0.011259174905717373, -0.029455363750457764, -0.03648195043206215, -0.04460960999131203, 0.06878045201301575, -0.004591452889144421, -0.0024542585015296936, 0.00235310778953135, -0.02800883911550045, -0.016997765749692917, 0.00762149877846241, 0.02034759894013405, -0.0054010977037250996, -0.004497107584029436, -0.0011158514535054564, -0.0259872917085886, 0.024321630597114563, -0.05220688879489899, 0.02487093210220337, -0.020040351897478104, 0.006154077127575874, -0.03327437490224838, 0.01585029438138008, 0.061572980135679245, 0.039317622780799866, 0.016755029559135437, 0.031723663210868835, -0.043303702026605606, 0.040179766714572906, 0.01246191468089819, -0.07270129024982452, -0.008587314747273922, -0.02147524058818817, -0.02460985630750656, -0.013942952267825603, -0.01709463633596897, 0.05376247689127922, 0.016579780727624893, -0.038118794560432434, -0.03666647896170616, 0.017107153311371803, -0.014848858118057251, 0.03108842484652996, 0.0009807461174204946, -0.051035571843385696, 0.002452075481414795, 0.012673106975853443, 0.0033911550417542458, -0.03080669417977333, -0.05273805931210518, 0.012284205295145512, 0.009764604270458221, -0.009754879400134087, 0.010287133976817131, -0.05553019419312477, 0.027084795758128166, 0.009304139763116837, 0.03198946639895439, -0.009437772445380688, 0.02409631758928299, -0.011400213465094566, 0.0008557101245969534, -0.02672436274588108, -0.021080024540424347, -0.006847556680440903, 0.0275641568005085, 0.023496270179748535, -0.009881085716187954, 0.02394036203622818, 0.014744102023541927, 0.024098750203847885, -0.003454803256317973, 0.01259081531316042, -0.017600519582629204, 0.015341666527092457, -0.020887859165668488, -0.042946189641952515, 0.02804558537900448, -0.04022860899567604, -0.03028222732245922, 0.01855209842324257, 0.02184027060866356, 0.029230831190943718, 0.03190942481160164, 0.0026626172475516796, 0.019977416843175888, 0.030635805800557137, -0.008481720462441444, -0.037285204976797104, 0.026615340262651443, 0.021446505561470985, 0.018777361139655113, -0.020622750744223595, 0.041769061237573624, 0.010057221166789532, -0.0011987373000010848, -0.01410729344934225, 0.030848398804664612, 0.002803608076646924, 0.004454606678336859, 0.020765181630849838, 0.0005660504684783518, 0.015588277950882912, -0.016903603449463844, -0.029921559616923332, 0.06948738545179367, 0.031111201271414757, -0.022408131510019302, 0.012156447395682335, -0.03230336308479309, 0.01152446772903204, -0.03711463138461113, 0.010777763091027737, 0.02492065168917179, -0.027970850467681885, 0.03528774902224541, -0.056069791316986084, -0.003830027999356389, 0.030920395627617836, -0.05244116112589836, 0.020984802395105362, 0.01729404926300049, -0.016600100323557854, -0.011552227661013603, -0.019697541370987892, -0.0020782025530934334, 0.04296594858169556, -0.006864428054541349, -0.006958520505577326, 0.018279196694493294, 0.004895377904176712, 0.020701246336102486, -0.013411820866167545, 0.028473319485783577, 0.008659372106194496, 0.009844361804425716, -0.005611990112811327, 0.012355145998299122, -0.04337075352668762, -0.026511969044804573, 0.03684623911976814, -0.010388652794063091, 0.018118487671017647, 0.00930826272815466, 0.027291743084788322, -0.01451218780130148, 0.035228025168180466, 0.02753124013543129, 0.01290548499673605, 0.032992951571941376, -0.02147592604160309, 0.022969314828515053, -0.004429806023836136, 0.0020515979267656803, 0.028666874393820763, 0.05331282690167427, -0.04165918007493019, 0.0007122497190721333, 0.0032503444235771894, -0.0419764518737793, 0.0026624700985848904, 0.020735234022140503, -0.010308603756129742, 0.001574664725922048, -0.025808608159422874, 0.006560944952070713, -0.02448614314198494, -0.016559964045882225, 0.027084799483418465, -0.0028676174115389585, 0.004096202552318573, -0.019571423530578613, -0.034449923783540726, -0.035258445888757706, 0.030539682134985924, -0.018746886402368546, -0.0084084402769804, -0.06997652351856232, 0.008197959512472153, 0.0061528743244707584, -0.014838118106126785, -0.06088338792324066, -0.044704679399728775, 0.03540786728262901, 0.05450078845024109, -0.003020799020305276, 0.042236827313899994, 0.03414340689778328, 0.007360413204878569, 0.013812897726893425, -0.06376516073942184, 0.062251314520835876, -0.009020911529660225, -0.03408600762486458, -0.01666102558374405, -0.02166902832686901, -0.043679896742105484, -0.04305041581392288, 0.03613101318478584, -0.024042246863245964, -0.005753048695623875, 0.013074871152639389, 0.03184857591986656, -0.011843844316899776, -0.04957682639360428, 0.00465873908251524, -0.04571474343538284, -0.0192868635058403, 0.008242893032729626, -0.03272193670272827, 0.013423837721347809, 0.009501883760094643, -0.005387051030993462, -0.0035166877787560225, -0.005957026034593582, 0.007862198166549206, -0.01917107217013836, 0.010675723664462566, -0.0073648542165756226, 0.019947359338402748, 0.052536580711603165, 0.0014597151894122362, -0.019685452803969383, 0.02451164647936821, -0.01780337654054165, -0.050516534596681595, 0.05984577164053917, -0.04922327399253845, -0.027057720348238945, 0.001410258817486465, 0.02285689488053322, 0.019213654100894928, -0.05584236606955528, -0.03875986486673355, 0.01735260896384716, -0.026963213458657265, 0.03174000605940819, 0.05174504220485687, 0.012068537063896656, 0.020678402855992317, -0.013451086357235909, 0.02499236911535263, 0.01909021846950054, 0.044901710003614426, -0.017427001148462296, 0.006707955151796341, 0.032224517315626144, -0.041949041187763214, 0.038519810885190964, 0.030803821980953217, 0.0016975689213722944, 0.06050942465662956, -0.023035528138279915, -0.004826926626265049, -0.017693471163511276, 0.0028637005016207695, 0.027737854048609734, -0.019576041027903557, 0.0000914060219656676, 0.005175486207008362, -0.01667809672653675, 0.031467415392398834, -0.05802007392048836, -0.012884819880127907, -0.001951885991729796, 0.019790126010775566, 0.015264397487044334, 0.010514333844184875, 0.03713968023657799, 0.014313671737909317, 0.002497886773198843, 0.011315345764160156, 0.01741275005042553, 0.03332505002617836, 0.029564829543232918, -0.02538248896598816, 0.01933988556265831, 0.006958573590964079, -0.009940515272319317, -0.037794869393110275, -0.062080059200525284, -0.07241412997245789, -0.038793109357357025, -0.01792687550187111, 0.028369423002004623, 0.021721066907048225, 0.020296931266784668, -0.006284622475504875, -0.015679212287068367, 0.04429014399647713, -0.08707749843597412, -0.016370832920074463, -0.03199191018939018, 0.0105917202308774, 0.008204133249819279, -0.009089360013604164 ]
<p>I am reading some books about hypothesis testing, but I am not sure if my following reasoning makes sense:</p> <p>Assume I have a gaussian random variable $X \sim N(\mu, \sigma)$ with $\sigma=1$. Now I obtain 5 iid samples, $x_1, \cdots, x_5$.</p> <p>I want to check if $\mu&lt;0$. So I set up the null hypothesis and alternative hypothesis to be $H_0: \mu=0$ and $H_1: \mu&lt;0$</p> <p>Therefore, for each sample $x_i$, I can compute the p-value = $P(X_i\le x_i)$, and denote it by $\alpha$. Therefore, I have $(1-\alpha)$ confidence to reject $H_0$. Also, by using the rule $(X\le x_i)$ to reject $H_0$, I have type-I error equal to $\alpha$.</p> <p>Now based on 5 samples, I have 5 p-values $\alpha_i$, ($i=1, \cdots, 5$). Therefore, I have $P(X_1\le x_1, \cdots, X_5\le x_5) = \alpha_1 \times \alpha_2 \times \cdots \times \alpha_5$. Therefore, using the decision rule that $(X_1\le x_1, \cdots, X_5\le x_5)$ to reject H0, I have a type-I error equal to $\times \alpha_1 \times \cdots \times \alpha_5$. And therefore, I have $(1-\times \alpha_1 \times \cdots \times \alpha_5)$ confidence to reject $H_0$.</p> <p>Basically, I want to use the 5 $x_i$'s for future testing. Next time I obtain 5 samples, I'll compare them to $x_i$. And I want to see how much confidence level this decision rule gives me. It seems to me that textbooks usually compute the p-value for one sample xi. I am basically trying to compute the "p-value" for 5 samples. </p> <p>Is the above reasoning correct?</p>
74,209
[ -0.024262530729174614, -0.06312096118927002, 0.0033910544589161873, -0.03674796223640442, 0.029440322890877724, 0.05375786870718002, -0.02312863990664482, -0.023794323205947876, -0.01672661490738392, 0.010567715391516685, 0.037905313074588776, 0.03262263536453247, 0.02179822325706482, 0.019495030865073204, 0.007652033120393753, 0.062152717262506485, -0.03081337735056877, 0.014013463631272316, -0.0209552813321352, -0.0225130096077919, 0.02071230486035347, 0.036284226924180984, 0.002180926501750946, -0.01697465218603611, -0.06422354280948639, 0.02022572234272957, 0.027586467564105988, -0.02458229847252369, 0.013656004332005978, 0.08796253800392151, -0.04401306062936783, 0.02751673199236393, 0.03690604865550995, 0.02024516463279724, -0.0026235824916511774, 0.01147075928747654, 0.040220268070697784, -0.016079165041446686, -0.011122895404696465, 0.010690278373658657, -0.024654505774378777, -0.033087048679590225, 0.04948753863573074, 0.02142420783638954, 0.00032225862378254533, 0.01860610768198967, 0.004847902338951826, -0.04493816941976547, -0.03050941787660122, -0.03294059634208679, 0.07395172864198685, 0.003903985721990466, 0.05569097772240639, 0.030839350074529648, 0.02848716638982296, -0.04973054677248001, 0.03530745208263397, 0.020173439756035805, -0.03260595351457596, -0.0659395158290863, -0.03419753536581993, -0.05756606534123421, 0.01752416230738163, -0.029381874948740005, -0.031746529042720795, 0.005955110304057598, -0.029509570449590683, 0.014818880707025528, 0.006678074132651091, -0.02208855003118515, 0.009460431523621082, 0.012811824679374695, 0.007537098601460457, -0.002828535158187151, -0.020951565355062485, -0.012055082246661186, 0.0376400463283062, 0.010427492670714855, 0.07049044966697693, 0.03879043087363243, 0.005647710524499416, 0.04991616681218147, 0.04416131228208542, 0.02490087039768696, 0.03169559687376022, -0.03709646686911583, 0.05111351236701012, -0.02369452454149723, 0.017742428928613663, 0.018737422302365303, -0.04201703518629074, 0.02008257806301117, 0.04311384633183479, -0.05677781254053116, -0.020773805677890778, 0.029601359739899635, -0.04089278355240822, 0.007351623848080635, -0.0334286205470562, 0.003813019720837474, -0.012225254438817501, -0.05945652723312378, 0.03033379651606083, 0.04080937057733536, -0.023698871955275536, -0.02533966302871704, 0.007093645632266998, -0.006941004190593958, 0.003047550329938531, -0.04202216491103172, -0.005948247853666544, 0.06182936206459999, 0.017876537516713142, 0.023582084104418755, 0.0006695786723867059, -0.036027684807777405, 0.00736834853887558, 0.006360628642141819, 0.0732744038105011, 0.03446115180850029, 0.04961246997117996, -0.004181914962828159, 0.02209615334868431, -0.002718778094276786, -0.042375825345516205, 0.013571420684456825, -0.019789855927228928, -0.00852266140282154, -0.02288191393017769, 0.07379519194364548, -0.01157174352556467, -0.003280108794569969, 0.018322322517633438, 0.05263775959610939, 0.02436820976436138, -0.007377369329333305, -0.06201156601309776, -0.011012854985892773, 0.07799581438302994, -0.043488647788763046, -0.01563331112265587, -0.043435949832201004, 0.044039905071258545, 0.04652736335992813, 0.024312952533364296, 0.0207406934350729, 0.04755764082074165, 0.027127038687467575, 0.04157055541872978, 0.035401877015829086, -0.009174652397632599, -0.016884295269846916, -0.0371934249997139, 0.01650686003267765, -0.031963467597961426, -0.042267847806215286, 0.046709638088941574, -0.013049143366515636, -0.027806563302874565, -0.017263146117329597, 0.024007074534893036, -0.01900388114154339, -0.029349414631724358, -0.016340646892786026, -0.02989831753075123, -0.02716328762471676, 0.05681119114160538, -0.010763552039861679, 0.059938929975032806, 0.015446045435965061, 0.005117335356771946, -0.004056609235703945, -0.016723209992051125, 0.05617080256342888, 0.047627925872802734, -0.0029123122803866863, 0.005467621143907309, -0.06372784078121185, -0.015786759555339813, 0.009394627995789051, -0.022225182503461838, 0.02718120627105236, -0.033831823617219925, 0.0002983046870213002, 0.01610906422138214, 0.03413420915603638, 0.030091136693954468, 0.009763393551111221, 0.004339898936450481, -0.05646210536360741, -0.057634033262729645, -0.07721918076276779, -0.012936139479279518, 0.029384056106209755, -0.03398571163415909, 0.021750329062342644, -0.01193528063595295, -0.00991753488779068, -0.008884868584573269, -0.005133932456374168, -0.0286693312227726, 0.008857243694365025, 0.02544233202934265, -0.07987706363201141, 0.01703910157084465, 0.009765375405550003, 0.04770714417099953, -0.0028565882239490747, 0.07290787994861603, -0.03568195179104805, -0.022636109963059425, 0.005433332175016403, -0.02504633367061615, 0.003663508454337716, 0.01233003195375204, -0.02680746279656887, 0.03000376932322979, -0.01682857796549797, 0.011727169156074524, 0.02928922139108181, -0.059323541820049286, 0.020332736894488335, 0.08459292352199554, -0.011963020078837872, 0.03320741653442383, -0.035940755158662796, -0.007436662446707487, -0.005047979298979044, -0.02915159799158573, -0.006248326972126961, -0.03194941207766533, -0.010839717462658882, 0.015496287494897842, 0.03569258749485016, -0.01779160276055336, -0.001565610058605671, 0.04181501269340515, 0.040433868765830994, 0.0059634726494550705, 0.05217284709215164, 0.004572830628603697, -0.009742600843310356, 0.010287465527653694, 0.029143735766410828, 0.005048674065619707, 0.05080274119973183, 0.019512373954057693, 0.006720144301652908, 0.05363599210977554, -0.003403854090720415, -0.004975692834705114, 0.04466554895043373, -0.020092293620109558, 0.014334529638290405, 0.009031265042722225, -0.022933758795261383, -0.019661739468574524, -0.008342145942151546, -0.010054515674710274, 0.028538161888718605, -0.0009321238030679524, 0.01668887585401535, -0.04668266698718071, 0.010650684125721455, 0.007965026423335075, 0.044136252254247665, -0.02080726996064186, 0.004467027727514505, 0.0028197295032441616, -0.048243001103401184, -0.021558083593845367, -0.04360305890440941, 0.0004930853028781712, -0.005755486432462931, -0.036261186003685, 0.006782705429941416, -0.025614513084292412, 0.014617495238780975, -0.03625235706567764, -0.021404901519417763, -0.016417518258094788, 0.010457618162035942, 0.06181139871478081, 0.0033664496149867773, -0.08829556405544281, -0.016164660453796387, -0.05814911797642708, -0.022664720192551613, 0.0450189933180809, -0.017970815300941467, -0.015464515425264835, 0.025649696588516235, 0.006754682399332523, -0.027032895013689995, -0.04632176458835602, -0.01911943219602108, -0.03510471060872078, -0.022822128608822823, -0.02159310318529606, 0.0572994090616703, 0.008363964967429638, -0.0631156861782074, 0.007300203666090965, -0.009771226905286312, -0.05786840617656708, -0.04028191789984703, -0.015176067128777504, -0.006744546350091696, -0.03180677816271782, 0.016354840248823166, 0.041200704872608185, 0.005889157764613628, 0.005734173581004143, -0.034941259771585464, -0.04865335300564766, 0.004382816143333912, -0.033351194113492966, 0.004113809205591679, -0.002372957533225417, -0.010490668006241322, 0.0893288180232048, 0.05043366923928261, 0.01689946837723255, -0.010397853329777718, 0.04805002734065056, -0.001273602363653481, -0.030930200591683388, 0.00033062236616387963, 0.030838480219244957, 0.005073721520602703, 0.012177514843642712, 0.0016162811079993844, 0.019176261499524117, 0.03074042871594429, -0.00960856955498457, 0.01637924835085869, -0.0010230819461867213, 0.001750426017679274, 0.003964175470173359, 0.05776624009013176, 0.013747014105319977, -0.003480088198557496, 0.01119677722454071, 0.017606977373361588, 0.0359562449157238, 0.03244460001587868, -0.004131923895329237, 0.030388997867703438, -0.008617376908659935, -0.014453672803938389, -0.008201035670936108, 0.04881282150745392, 0.02694009058177471, -0.06886414438486099, 0.01983778551220894, 0.0018343429546803236, 0.036164190620183945, -0.05858539417386055, -0.00340645550750196, 0.055005673319101334, 0.021006135269999504, -0.03989163413643837, -0.037711866199970245, -0.03144320473074913, -0.019243618473410606, 0.0032089068554341793, -0.02555140294134617, -0.0504479855298996, 0.03085099533200264, 0.05879912152886391, 0.02208947204053402, -0.007552970666438341, -0.048441801220178604, -0.010280425660312176, -0.012834289111196995, 0.00954505242407322, 0.0010045464150607586, 0.03881053999066353, -0.02455173060297966, 0.05525590479373932, 0.022701352834701538, -0.046328943222761154, 0.0022192473988980055, -0.01875796541571617, -0.021695539355278015, 0.043441515415906906, -0.025497348979115486, -0.02749653160572052, -0.0033441088162362576, 0.0021234173327684402, 0.05375656485557556, -0.007004647981375456, 0.020658543333411217, 0.0004231456550769508, 0.027240952476859093, -0.03393268957734108, 0.02315712161362171, -0.022510256618261337, -0.012837076559662819, -0.008770342916250229, 0.03886833041906357, 0.023338178172707558, -0.03286610171198845, 0.027015728875994682, -0.002171807223930955, -0.015128539875149727, 0.03348556533455849, -0.007642475422471762, 0.0030029385816305876, 0.05947011709213257, 0.022219985723495483, 0.048729896545410156, 0.024640075862407684, -0.004244531970471144, 0.03725023195147514, 0.008837287314236164, 0.08150239288806915, 0.03798092156648636, -0.03515869751572609, -0.001436171238310635, -0.00004255937164998613, 0.0012912226375192404, -0.008614613674581051, 0.013470259495079517, 0.007949632592499256, -0.015287602320313454, 0.046530723571777344, 0.0005380513612180948, -0.035024020820856094, 0.022783860564231873, 0.042005755007267, -0.004547020420432091, 0.04471977427601814, -0.02454511448740959, -0.05156376585364342, -0.041581667959690094, 0.006637022830545902, -0.005496332887560129, 0.016139868646860123, -0.015306255780160427, -0.042206063866615295, 0.04507015645503998, 0.012268059886991978, -0.06113377586007118, 0.008075620979070663, 0.013115582056343555, 0.03740823641419411, 0.06554774194955826, -0.03491630032658577, 0.051229625940322876, 0.03356955572962761, 0.044456224888563156, 0.01793869398534298, 0.024770038202404976, -0.0427677258849144, 0.005226851440966129, 0.009203723631799221, 0.045263927429914474, -0.03731316700577736, 0.031156141310930252, -0.03997746855020523, -0.0035058686044067144, 0.01879260502755642, -0.0342467799782753, 0.03369839861989021, -0.027847882360219955, 0.043407540768384933, -0.03363655135035515, -0.0018118981970474124, -0.03777674585580826, -0.01842087134718895, -0.004266445524990559, 0.03444673866033554, -0.041730985045433044, 0.008610472083091736, -0.05138644948601723, -0.01058982964605093, 0.01947280764579773, 0.07412366569042206, -0.06603189557790756, -0.034355733543634415, -0.002972253365442157, 0.03462183475494385, -0.025498205795884132, -0.03375280648469925, 0.024934861809015274, -0.00582564901560545, 0.006176169030368328, 0.045873064547777176, -0.035017091780900955, -0.03022599220275879, 0.03767652437090874, 0.0006418866105377674, -0.048442352563142776, -0.0020817264448851347, -0.04254741594195366, 0.00623204605653882, 0.009898360818624496, 0.020932653918862343, 0.04208981990814209, -0.007380141410976648, 0.002606702968478203, -0.01833416521549225, -0.03349705785512924, 0.00010909862612606958, -0.052748456597328186, -0.015492410399019718, -0.05229721590876579, -0.00992986373603344, -0.03409826010465622, 0.0014691795222461224, -0.010796821676194668, 0.048617955297231674, 0.020238924771547318, -0.031929388642311096, 0.006514626555144787, 0.013214309699833393, -0.02542513608932495, 0.021388523280620575, -0.014820332638919353, 0.01880028285086155, 0.0008041831315495074, 0.012078482657670975, 0.012393212877213955, -0.019918140023946762, 0.020520737394690514, 0.013654962182044983, -0.015350600704550743, -0.0015544366324320436, -0.01099854614585638, -0.010989763773977757, -0.009251789189875126, -0.02660624124109745, 0.014304082840681076, -0.0036881796550005674, -0.023543953895568848, -0.01701059751212597, -0.017697138711810112, -0.024652332067489624, 0.044664427638053894, -0.004798111971467733, 0.00997625757008791, -0.026383688673377037, -0.012994383461773396, 0.010423029772937298, -0.000298526807455346, -0.06826242059469223, 0.0010590545134618878, -0.005720233544707298, 0.0024283872917294502, -0.021259646862745285, -0.02952803671360016, -0.025734182447195053, 0.030728569254279137, -0.04996279254555702, 0.002020680345594883, 0.03288615867495537, 0.006533966865390539, -0.010131537914276123, -0.019741347059607506, -0.004397204145789146, 0.0755186602473259, -0.013964666984975338, -0.019853921607136726, -0.009925116784870625, -0.02331017144024372, 0.0036400414537638426, 0.019807711243629456, -0.03655583783984184, 0.00501067191362381, 0.00806505512446165, -0.00920755323022604, -0.0009069240768440068, -0.021448809653520584, 0.007629819214344025, -0.030209358781576157, -0.03344447910785675, 0.014593670144677162, -0.018175922334194183, 0.004091220907866955, -0.02349388785660267, -0.016243623569607735, 0.022005239501595497, 0.0039991578087210655, 0.000955831550527364, -0.010547486133873463, -0.01581539958715439, 0.043089792132377625, -0.005697470623999834, 0.014273764565587044, 0.056037306785583496, 0.07303464412689209, -0.03107638843357563, 0.030681462958455086, -0.016405828297138214, -0.018554288893938065, -0.0027054930105805397, 0.03779667615890503, 0.00328316749073565, 0.000981509336270392, -0.012683019042015076, -0.02802714705467224, 0.0006416222313418984, -0.0648777186870575, 0.03797141835093498, 0.056665170937776566, -0.003917595371603966, 0.023806912824511528, 0.005095574539154768, 0.03184141218662262, -0.007121644914150238, -0.026547275483608246, -0.012554674409329891, -0.025770656764507294, 0.0010375954443588853, 0.037378840148448944, -0.020764848217368126, -0.018901431933045387, 0.06205785647034645, -0.007027442567050457, 0.004906324669718742, 0.01855427585542202, 0.012551083229482174, 0.02614443376660347, -0.016327040269970894, -0.0322667732834816, -0.016531309112906456, 0.02688349410891533, -0.07459887862205505, -0.004647336900234222, -0.04626339301466942, -0.043733034282922745, -0.0026202232111245394, 0.023807227611541748, 0.02341662347316742, -0.04816325008869171, -0.010976714082062244, -0.054241303354501724, 0.031795669347047806, 0.029169287532567978, -0.006014236714690924, 0.03222593665122986, 0.023381227627396584, 0.022279884666204453, -0.005885133985430002, 0.06763888150453568, 0.004529832862317562, -0.06731154024600983, -0.021919213235378265, -0.037634171545505524, -0.04384491592645645, 0.027100516483187675, -0.019503451883792877, -0.036727119237184525, -0.007294243201613426, -0.02628312073647976, 0.044098321348428726, -0.005468866787850857, 0.03738561272621155, -0.008024373091757298, 0.0670083612203598, 0.00875907950103283, 0.056183282285928726, 0.03361606225371361, -0.0320921428501606, 0.12575066089630127, 0.06016258895397186, 0.006067406851798296, -0.024835295975208282, 0.014532813802361488, -0.047234609723091125, 0.005476250778883696, -0.0426483117043972, 0.047987475991249084, 0.014885345473885536, -0.005490131676197052, 0.007464016787707806, 0.060311149805784225, -0.006183968391269445, -0.03879772499203682, 0.07854299992322922, -0.05534636601805687, -0.02444004826247692, -0.04558528959751129, 0.032299790531396866, -0.0010988065041601658, -0.0035786002408713102, 0.027028081938624382, 0.01848209649324417, 0.009473220445215702, -0.025148434564471245, 0.006712338421493769, 0.020870037376880646, -0.017254523932933807, 0.0039643822237849236, -0.002879801904782653, 0.007626801263540983, 0.006407140288501978, -0.014485588297247887, -0.0048582651652395725, 0.0010785413905978203, -0.006831462029367685, -0.03596298024058342, 0.009783899411559105, 0.0303137619048357, -0.028089605271816254, 0.025502488017082214, 0.019903011620044708, 0.02482885681092739, -0.0315362885594368, -0.035095397382974625, -0.03590896725654602, 0.05087491124868393, -0.03637714311480522, 0.0030159135349094868, -0.00028363734600134194, -0.004492348991334438, 0.006090719718486071, -0.04544217512011528, -0.0023243529722094536, 0.03959663212299347, 0.0289568193256855, -0.013992870226502419, -0.027250129729509354, -0.03214605525135994, 0.0590970553457737, 0.007256591226905584, 0.0480705201625824, 0.03849662095308304, -0.05239802226424217, -0.03088216856122017, -0.014349878765642643, -0.008076070807874203, -0.006986530032008886, 0.012905810959637165, -0.006502198986709118, 0.026861757040023804, -0.042012251913547516, -0.007782731670886278, 0.017099035903811455, -0.008431648835539818, 0.02870619297027588, 0.02796432189643383, -0.027462365105748177, -0.0053343879990279675, -0.03325331583619118, -0.008420664817094803, -0.05292702466249466, 0.009279764257371426, -0.007687235716730356, -0.03506002947688103, -0.004444715101271868, 0.05156091973185539, 0.025783976539969444, 0.003530308371409774, 0.034134916961193085, 0.038871437311172485, 0.03138041868805885, -0.05131402984261513, -0.029466697946190834, -0.004967394284904003, -0.025722527876496315, -0.017509201541543007, 0.0192850474268198, 0.05312978848814964, 0.05523449555039406, 0.028352681547403336, 0.0191943496465683, 0.018921665847301483, 0.0028811744414269924, 0.00022426173381973058, -0.007108134683221579, -0.04590111970901489, 0.018956393003463745, 0.06263092905282974, 0.032846659421920776, -0.07010629773139954, -0.019430432468652725, -0.041685551404953, 0.0020971305202692747, 0.022565621882677078, -0.05548549070954323, -0.0012552617117762566, -0.029080448672175407, 0.015130497515201569, 0.02293408289551735, 0.003237673547118902, 0.0064145587384700775, -0.012595115229487419, 0.0011634010588750243, -0.02269180864095688, -0.03081527352333069, 0.004491670057177544, 0.003159844083711505, -0.005774741992354393, -0.00133549515157938, 0.061890341341495514, 0.005345693789422512, 0.019811328500509262, -0.043848916888237, 0.04275444522500038, 0.008432667702436447, 0.030604390427470207, -0.033728886395692825, 0.04884057864546776, 0.04272488132119179, -0.06156618148088455, -0.03887258097529411, 0.04230644553899765, 0.04984278231859207, 0.022253485396504402, -0.02326193079352379, -0.010499164462089539, -0.0492318794131279, 0.011558175086975098, -0.06571053713560104, -0.02686464600265026, -0.038405921310186386, -0.003477817866951227, -0.03917544335126877, -0.00698526855558157, -0.00794012751430273, 0.04091218113899231, 0.037860527634620667, 0.033980317413806915, 0.010967315174639225, 0.017546242102980614, 0.017037538811564445, 0.01684359833598137, -0.002262943657115102, 0.04234354570508003, 0.008004607632756233, -0.03828521445393562, -0.010886300355196, 0.07940425723791122, 0.001648387173190713, 0.03388062119483948, 0.02878950536251068, 0.012180909514427185, -0.08155858516693115, -0.0142481978982687, 0.04701857268810272, 0.07338974624872208, 0.05421824008226395, -0.022764408960938454, 0.0063215442933142185, 0.018997477367520332, -0.025393107905983925, 0.010939470492303371, -0.022135311737656593, -0.014430690556764603, -0.02706737443804741, 0.0031208598520606756, 0.003238799050450325, 0.003923255950212479, 0.027804866433143616, 0.0003295587666798383, 0.021622801199555397, 0.03475026413798332, 0.0004835894796997309, -0.05254395678639412, -0.007523618172854185, 0.028239399194717407, -0.04541216418147087, -0.06587199866771698, 0.03537917509675026, -0.036970775574445724, -0.024550585076212883, 0.029829595237970352, 0.014592872001230717, 0.017702702432870865, 0.02675815485417843, 0.07163101434707642, 0.007831125520169735, 0.01905369944870472, 0.01708916760981083, -0.022935742512345314, -0.025939466431736946, 0.027851251885294914, 0.020362939685583115, 0.0010885568335652351, 0.009489462710916996, -0.002373604802414775, 0.014851246029138565, -0.02588103711605072, -0.041445765644311905, 0.022038999944925308, 0.02470860257744789, -0.04805130511522293, -0.002728327875956893, 0.004634186625480652, -0.039502665400505066, -0.015559464693069458, 0.01250429917126894, -0.017459535971283913, -0.009570583701133728, 0.028605127707123756, 0.02012220025062561, -0.03854870796203613, -0.006771570537239313, -0.027040880173444748, -0.055449601262807846, 0.007502671331167221, 0.012660604901611805, 0.0021300995722413063, -0.06921269744634628, -0.011294775642454624, -0.023044882342219353, -0.02696859836578369, 0.0017497335793450475, -0.02044578827917576, -0.045365530997514725, 0.03189648315310478, 0.008798232302069664, 0.003002756042405963, 0.008313016034662724, -0.041559893637895584, -0.022024525329470634, -0.042039573192596436, 0.05752093717455864, -0.024952230975031853, -0.00411674939095974, -0.02232166938483715, -0.021000728011131287, -0.07032418996095657, -0.010516546666622162, 0.020934490486979485, 0.0380663126707077, 0.018688207492232323, 0.007512499112635851, 0.053364481776952744, -0.014883450232446194, -0.05998746305704117, 0.030255082994699478, 0.015120326541364193, -0.031240366399288177, -0.03863784298300743, 0.0015875967219471931, 0.052097395062446594, 0.032220806926488876, 0.022271838039159775, 0.009254120290279388, -0.0016454077558591962, -0.0008299989276565611, -0.006926459260284901, 0.026411378756165504, 0.04998527839779854, -0.008872232399880886, 0.04653969779610634, -0.016928013414144516, 0.014629507437348366, 0.03265431523323059, 0.014670852571725845, -0.07601998001337051, 0.008385984227061272, -0.03103102557361126, -0.032181162387132645, 0.0018830796470865607, 0.03241035342216492, -0.013454372994601727, -0.04866940528154373, 0.011270282790064812, 0.04105299338698387, -0.047097645699977875, -0.010062306188046932, 0.011294391937553883, 0.007242867257446051, 0.04517422243952751, -0.012538117356598377, 0.03710399568080902, 0.006859466899186373, -0.051342789083719254, 0.011989647522568703, -0.008390444330871105, 0.014363833703100681, -0.02573397569358349, 0.03195691853761673, 0.038684312254190445, 0.005629087332636118, 0.010118648409843445, -0.00045596089330501854, 0.0662633404135704, -0.029710857197642326, -0.022152520716190338, -0.009351993910968304, -0.006822429597377777, -0.00240344344638288, -0.020248597487807274, -0.0067596593871712685, 0.06360739469528198, -0.02540237456560135, -0.002037841361016035, -0.016753658652305603, -0.005354148801416159, -0.015609804540872574, 0.006716015283018351, 0.02172611840069294, 0.015178881585597992, -0.012977467849850655, 0.025612356141209602, -0.012605523690581322, -0.01671532541513443, 0.008336790837347507, -0.03208836913108826, 0.02712826617062092, 0.03458515182137489, -0.01826847717165947, -0.019536137580871582, -0.03854420781135559, -0.024203704670071602, -0.02003791555762291, -0.008131157606840134, 0.0010997154749929905, 0.011954277753829956, -0.003978440072387457, -0.03790987655520439, -0.02906738594174385, 0.01787973754107952, 0.02257210575044155, -0.0034503613132983446, -0.02230670489370823, -0.0035564738791435957, 0.033798947930336, 0.003818986937403679 ]
<p>Or more so "will it be"? <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_data">Big Data</a> makes statistics and relevant knowledge all the more important but seems to underplay Sampling Theory. </p> <p>I've seen this hype around 'Big Data' and can't help wonder that "why" would I want to analyze <strong>everything</strong>? Wasn't there a reason for "Sampling Theory" to be designed/implemented/invented/discovered? I don't get the point of analyzing the entire 'population' of the dataset. Just because you can do it doesn't mean you should (Stupidity is a privilege but you shouldn't abuse it :)</p> <p>So my question is this: Is it statistically relevant to analyze the entire data set? The best you could do would be to minimize error if you did sampling. But is the cost of minimizing that error really worth it? Is the "value of information" really worth the effort, time cost etc. that goes in analyzing big data over massively parallel computers?</p> <p>Even if one analyzes the entire population, the outcome would still be at best a guess with a higher probability of being right. Probably a bit higher than sampling (or would it be a lot more?) Would the insight gained from analyzing the population vs analyzing the sample differ widely? </p> <p>Or should we accept it as "times have changed"? Sampling as an activity could become less important given enough computational power :)</p> <p>Note: I'm not trying to start a debate but looking for an answer to understand the why big data does what it does (i.e. analyze everything) and disregard the theory of sampling (or it doesn't?)</p>
74,210
[ -0.02394811436533928, -0.02214774489402771, 0.021241912618279457, -0.049432992935180664, 0.05661388859152794, 0.0034571553114801645, 0.004859450273215771, -0.03724901005625725, -0.009325316175818443, -0.028343483805656433, 0.014918101951479912, 0.0423482283949852, 0.041193507611751556, 0.028337039053440094, 0.020734068006277084, 0.03251834958791733, -0.014913948252797127, 0.020215997472405434, -0.027049969881772995, 0.010794758796691895, -0.00015763737610541284, 0.024946032091975212, 0.029162762686610222, -0.023631827905774117, -0.07792723923921585, 0.03442365303635597, 0.030437299981713295, -0.029446035623550415, 0.028189977630972862, 0.06710804253816605, -0.04688059166073799, 0.01470869593322277, 0.014926020987331867, 0.05838664993643761, 0.03724270313978195, 0.017763355746865273, -0.07214529812335968, -0.01876753382384777, 0.026048928499221802, 0.02764134109020233, -0.04442243278026581, -0.008399762213230133, 0.002823024522513151, 0.015117133967578411, -0.022227102890610695, 0.0274050310254097, -0.01721448265016079, -0.013838546350598335, -0.007038896903395653, -0.045414604246616364, 0.04371912404894829, -0.011805325746536255, 0.0046376390382647514, 0.03508259356021881, -0.012118326500058174, -0.011798348277807236, 0.04551248997449875, 0.04761059954762459, -0.014797855168581009, -0.03483271226286888, -0.006751954555511475, 0.019975706934928894, 0.0034286202862858772, -0.004840135108679533, -0.035033900290727615, 0.044724732637405396, -0.018384860828518867, -0.030146585777401924, 0.03625231608748436, -0.013185525313019753, 0.030182447284460068, 0.03243809938430786, 0.019093608483672142, 0.02148515358567238, 0.008653565309941769, 0.002975720213726163, -0.01462298259139061, 0.005422359798103571, 0.05176011100411415, 0.04060694947838783, -0.007025278639048338, -0.006672356743365526, 0.04074147716164589, 0.05377262830734253, 0.03878733143210411, 0.004772110376507044, 0.0609637089073658, -0.031057188287377357, -0.00822789128869772, -0.028062038123607635, -0.0009730719029903412, -0.013161422684788704, 0.03348251059651375, -0.03507060185074806, -0.042655445635318756, 0.004892075899988413, -0.029558543115854263, 0.05176129937171936, -0.014304466545581818, -0.02888958342373371, -0.01360839232802391, -0.03010040521621704, 0.031331054866313934, 0.037110574543476105, -0.024935416877269745, -0.0271396916359663, -0.006626361049711704, 0.008856421336531639, -0.024563560262322426, -0.03878162428736687, 0.009621266275644302, 0.006072868127375841, 0.022576836869120598, -0.014128634706139565, 0.028761208057403564, 0.002246174728497863, 0.032111234962940216, 0.0015358454547822475, 0.08409664779901505, 0.07837124168872833, 0.02023659273982048, -0.026691284030675888, 0.004100666847079992, -0.04544193670153618, -0.04835313931107521, 0.02401828207075596, -0.0050957356579601765, -0.03920820727944374, -0.06042265146970749, 0.02792351506650448, -0.013701386749744415, -0.01632627099752426, 0.032500822097063065, -0.005152994766831398, 0.02430819906294346, -0.008062208071351051, -0.1088276356458664, -0.04017842561006546, 0.05877002701163292, 0.0016078989719972014, -0.026293594390153885, -0.0507265105843544, 0.01741253398358822, 0.009371784515678883, 0.027251824736595154, -0.010899672284722328, 0.03940984234213829, 0.009916982613503933, 0.03190293163061142, 0.01963547058403492, -0.05609589070081711, 0.005102197639644146, 0.010493452660739422, 0.011390795931220055, -0.03371356800198555, -0.09981941431760788, -0.008271939121186733, 0.02008141204714775, 0.003984817769378424, -0.024499913677573204, 0.030627142637968063, 0.009643830358982086, -0.026654355227947235, -0.025536760687828064, -0.013690998777747154, -0.024153586477041245, 0.06903515756130219, 0.007849807851016521, 0.0660255178809166, 0.01802239380776882, -0.004383452236652374, 0.04926434904336929, 0.01075278501957655, -0.00414998596534133, 0.046473730355501175, -0.025245822966098785, 0.039481792598962784, 0.002979008015245199, 0.020789965987205505, -0.017197882756590843, -0.019598625600337982, -0.04029534012079239, -0.0049213832244277, 0.005053425673395395, 0.05480353161692619, 0.05845694616436958, 0.009076440706849098, -0.03336263447999954, 0.03655274957418442, -0.04842866584658623, -0.056668516248464584, -0.07894587516784668, -0.022241923958063126, -0.01765136979520321, -0.007000996731221676, 0.014721720479428768, 0.014788745902478695, 0.015310980379581451, -0.008922782726585865, -0.020878607407212257, 0.004583378322422504, 0.012680301442742348, 0.05235679820179939, -0.034650735557079315, -0.020360946655273438, 0.039314914494752884, -0.003022060263901949, 0.004037835169583559, 0.029831957072019577, -0.020270099863409996, -0.06737389415502548, 0.026278777047991753, -0.01723361574113369, 0.010263626463711262, -0.015052140690386295, -0.027178997173905373, 0.0078212795779109, 0.00440273666754365, -0.016406038776040077, 0.03792496398091316, -0.045747242867946625, 0.10874554514884949, 0.05312853679060936, -0.013384677469730377, -0.02506149187684059, 0.031595680862665176, 0.021133026108145714, -0.017402494326233864, 0.004308569245040417, 0.021329501643776894, -0.08877862989902496, 0.03591733053326607, 0.021649200469255447, 0.027522865682840347, -0.009560247883200645, -0.006032972130924463, 0.05040309205651283, 0.0515582412481308, 0.016700202599167824, -0.009952634572982788, -0.029191844165325165, -0.04105604067444801, 0.010315364226698875, 0.015458997339010239, -0.007860024459660053, 0.03237536922097206, 0.017087172716856003, -0.0004293779784347862, 0.026418695226311684, 0.016224393621087074, 0.026116278022527695, 0.01832316629588604, 0.005886055529117584, -0.0015268807765096426, 0.0065691713243722916, -0.010373855009675026, 0.02198798768222332, -0.03495665639638901, -0.000456622481578961, 0.021786117926239967, 0.015059213154017925, 0.013085785321891308, -0.022283615544438362, -0.03617759793996811, -0.000552590296138078, 0.011662122793495655, -0.04381674900650978, 0.021458668634295464, 0.032263461500406265, -0.03246785327792168, 0.03225337341427803, -0.019428817555308342, -0.027004215866327286, -0.03711320087313652, 0.01669638603925705, 0.008357079699635506, -0.009757268242537975, 0.014377888292074203, -0.03385007753968239, -0.030519133433699608, -0.017920974642038345, -0.0009492252138443291, -0.016345512121915817, 0.02563224360346794, -0.0701843649148941, -0.02055884525179863, -0.008930246345698833, -0.030390191823244095, 0.03551318496465683, -0.0013603842817246914, 0.009755742736160755, 0.016980886459350586, 0.023201914504170418, -0.07353643327951431, 0.021528741344809532, -0.0033011147752404213, 0.019857723265886307, -0.023092858493328094, -0.013186590746045113, 0.029829256236553192, 0.036812469363212585, -0.026917381212115288, 0.0071620577946305275, -0.0037283815909177065, -0.07154464721679688, -0.02216271683573723, 0.008310730569064617, 0.009533558040857315, -0.007465610280632973, 0.028139887377619743, 0.03121199458837509, -0.042481280863285065, -0.05424702912569046, -0.03936448693275452, -0.07830020785331726, 0.034794408828020096, -0.02042807638645172, 0.05333821848034859, -0.0038928163703531027, -0.03351831063628197, 0.05608324706554413, 0.024843940511345863, -0.021721728146076202, 0.015217375941574574, -0.03256670758128166, -0.02407555840909481, -0.008121855556964874, 0.01889137364923954, -0.020446810871362686, -0.0056542083621025085, -0.00027576135471463203, 0.008944020606577396, 0.036962393671274185, 0.03299121558666229, 0.009134048596024513, -0.0017815011087805033, 0.0006695562042295933, -0.010106276720762253, 0.02227446436882019, -0.0015682773664593697, 0.010760672390460968, -0.03079504519701004, 0.04092143103480339, -0.01988973841071129, 0.015753433108329773, 0.04845554009079933, -0.014626770280301571, 0.03523266687989235, -0.005401985719799995, 0.003332644235342741, -0.04714079573750496, 0.03287213668227196, -0.015995685011148453, -0.022280462086200714, -0.0009547830559313297, 0.03725406527519226, 0.03025122918188572, -0.015081208199262619, -0.032371167093515396, 0.05377991870045662, 0.036294255405664444, -0.03919694200158119, 0.01887841336429119, -0.009405560791492462, 0.005793274845927954, 0.020321523770689964, -0.02623269148170948, 0.0092011122033, 0.018133260309696198, 0.08091843873262405, 0.01715363934636116, -0.04713758826255798, -0.029223358258605003, -0.004272707737982273, -0.04309156537055969, -0.0073017035610973835, -0.028804533183574677, 0.08028668165206909, -0.020603006705641747, 0.06743045896291733, 0.030247347429394722, 0.020898455753922462, -0.018409011885523796, 0.015962833538651466, -0.052689358592033386, -0.000344937841873616, -0.03123217448592186, 0.00526068452745676, -0.0052095260471105576, -0.05055650696158409, 0.062143612653017044, 0.010589691810309887, -0.022460922598838806, -0.0332583412528038, 0.029444878920912743, -0.04765157774090767, 0.0029438775964081287, -0.012775891460478306, 0.014434915967285633, -0.010672648437321186, 0.02175941877067089, 0.03091750480234623, -0.005757051985710859, 0.018337100744247437, 0.051126495003700256, 0.003517990233376622, -0.03376919776201248, -0.024148356169462204, 0.004293526988476515, 0.021291570737957954, 0.050770796835422516, 0.007911516353487968, 0.02097149007022381, -0.03713070973753929, 0.028452176600694656, 0.0010553936008363962, 0.059206195175647736, 0.011349780485033989, -0.027835693210363388, 0.023527204990386963, -0.03143225610256195, -0.042729318141937256, 0.01743423566222191, 0.021099302917718887, -0.007041615899652243, -0.00014328898396342993, 0.07158727943897247, -0.0007842918275855482, -0.05049263313412666, 0.04113243892788887, 0.06308145076036453, -0.03479624539613724, 0.022421691566705704, -0.03123542107641697, -0.0037652072496712208, -0.022592980414628983, -0.026233747601509094, 0.035369694232940674, 0.007168252021074295, -0.0012853037333115935, -0.009709140285849571, 0.017888952046632767, 0.005845625419169664, -0.05611414462327957, 0.01367765013128519, 0.0022632370237261057, 0.04393700137734413, 0.026250924915075302, -0.004101244732737541, 0.02777819149196148, 0.05380905419588089, 0.041443053632974625, 0.02091587334871292, 0.009534081444144249, -0.09561086446046829, -0.005199126433581114, 0.023969296365976334, 0.024124672636389732, -0.035559866577386856, 0.024640394374728203, -0.045181695371866226, -0.01238710805773735, 0.05073854699730873, -0.03712960332632065, 0.00728120980784297, -0.03575529158115387, 0.021332012489438057, -0.031135549768805504, -0.0010600248351693153, -0.0006873987731523812, -0.045065902173519135, -0.0392807275056839, 0.033817924559116364, -0.03150356188416481, -0.018282325938344002, -0.04489719122648239, 0.014060518704354763, -0.014929551631212234, 0.04772363603115082, -0.04027201235294342, -0.017006803303956985, -0.014424829743802547, 0.012187630869448185, -0.055929094552993774, -0.0695083737373352, 0.014978742226958275, -0.010743055492639542, -0.012210479006171227, 0.03075588122010231, -0.029896210879087448, -0.07514984905719757, 0.029754143208265305, 0.004483711905777454, -0.01795451156795025, -0.001263151178136468, -0.043638378381729126, 0.007100813556462526, 0.010432220995426178, 0.013470751233398914, 0.059965457767248154, 0.03237064555287361, -0.007040598429739475, 0.024311836808919907, -0.00964298751205206, -0.008807234466075897, -0.02376372739672661, -0.011932670138776302, -0.017542501911520958, -0.0058496007695794106, -0.035931073129177094, 0.026830829679965973, 0.03513040766119957, 0.007754147052764893, -0.0029892893508076668, -0.03153834864497185, 0.01692885346710682, 0.030666586011648178, 0.015414762310683727, 0.01396183855831623, -0.009436821565032005, 0.04091709479689598, -0.0028632301837205887, -0.024257143959403038, 0.02217532880604267, 0.00033571114181540906, -0.007599947974085808, 0.007699017878621817, -0.0035593968350440264, -0.006716959178447723, -0.05908529460430145, -0.021106326952576637, 0.04276719316840172, -0.006557787302881479, 0.058211151510477066, 0.004006424453109503, 0.04504336416721344, -0.0009668382117524743, -0.07683884352445602, -0.00595036381855607, 0.021830884739756584, 0.007111834362149239, 0.02928493730723858, -0.012242945842444897, 0.03677981719374657, -0.035966046154499054, 0.024069536477327347, -0.06328435242176056, -0.02411067672073841, 0.04056786745786667, -0.002951540984213352, -0.03670524060726166, -0.03835859149694443, 0.002069684909656644, -0.009946940466761589, -0.005356235895305872, -0.014416474848985672, 0.02925659343600273, -0.002344846958294511, -0.03684743493795395, 0.012248620390892029, -0.019221657887101173, 0.09304261952638626, -0.02560846507549286, 0.002624940825626254, 0.019376162439584732, -0.026255419477820396, 0.028477365151047707, -0.007647203281521797, 0.01550307311117649, -0.01882041245698929, -0.005006518680602312, -0.022162094712257385, -0.014436655677855015, 0.03396319970488548, -0.010887941345572472, -0.017442189157009125, 0.023651529103517532, -0.01587733067572117, 0.008673114702105522, -0.029434870928525925, -0.0012429936323314905, 0.0004189263272564858, 0.03328403830528259, -0.026503413915634155, 0.020721809938549995, 0.013022532686591148, 0.0006242419476620853, 0.046649545431137085, 0.016141369938850403, -0.044477857649326324, 0.04023343697190285, 0.01629989966750145, -0.042453255504369736, -0.011148836463689804, -0.007297915872186422, -0.047840993851423264, 0.033745959401130676, -0.011729259975254536, 0.010557027533650398, -0.00025313207879662514, 0.005725339520722628, -0.015227357856929302, -0.054452307522296906, -0.03167867287993431, -0.004550713114440441, 0.032755047082901, 0.03557616472244263, 0.030727701261639595, 0.03852091729640961, -0.019930988550186157, 0.023289531469345093, -0.004815816879272461, 0.024394597858190536, -0.01375765260308981, -0.014986544847488403, 0.01630156859755516, 0.0029846499674022198, -0.023844918236136436, 0.03505784273147583, -0.008223268203437328, 0.02368062734603882, 0.020228084176778793, 0.034669145941734314, 0.012058374471962452, 0.04797448590397835, -0.04120384156703949, -0.04580077528953552, 0.0004259370034560561, -0.0740671306848526, 0.008481185883283615, -0.005476608406752348, -0.007833296433091164, 0.05948555842041969, 0.0010260915150865912, 0.0025351536460220814, -0.035411056131124496, -0.011515336111187935, -0.07084120064973831, -0.028299754485487938, 0.004672371316701174, 0.016665078699588776, 0.022390492260456085, -0.013804981485009193, 0.007956522516906261, -0.03253960981965065, -0.015270412899553776, -0.0035220917779952288, -0.07230692356824875, -0.07947079092264175, -0.011881685815751553, -0.04701104015111923, 0.02548917755484581, 0.02076927199959755, -0.019399287179112434, 0.03147260472178459, -0.03535079210996628, 0.044294342398643494, 0.02017666958272457, 0.046313319355249405, -0.0655827447772026, 0.05094044655561447, -0.009200016036629677, 0.03968588262796402, -0.007545438129454851, -0.02521452307701111, 0.1252342313528061, 0.06946879625320435, 0.023226242512464523, -0.08899571001529694, 0.024339497089385986, -0.015384086407721043, -0.01092537958174944, -0.020781230181455612, 0.006854161154478788, 0.010321982204914093, 0.005937082227319479, 0.032907355576753616, 0.005913068074733019, 0.00718610780313611, 0.027210313826799393, 0.043954990804195404, -0.025411449372768402, -0.014667884446680546, 0.010569991543889046, 0.009030378423631191, -0.04153098911046982, -0.003511932445690036, -0.039872318506240845, -0.011789110489189625, -0.009694601409137249, -0.018365483731031418, -0.0058239661157131195, -0.001895011286251247, -0.0248256865888834, 0.0070937275886535645, -0.03761456161737442, 0.02281958796083927, 0.023834429681301117, -0.02603745646774769, -0.02922324277460575, -0.02819761261343956, -0.002486984245479107, -0.01647208258509636, -0.009616966359317303, 0.03052273765206337, -0.016565868631005287, -0.007138971704989672, -0.014625142328441143, 0.039706770330667496, -0.008435098454356194, -0.004698906559497118, -0.025190318003296852, 0.04956495389342308, -0.028767643496394157, 0.010984374210238457, -0.007894746959209442, -0.0017087840242311358, -0.014573984779417515, -0.02028338797390461, -0.005341396667063236, 0.01899794302880764, 0.03673727437853813, -0.020577505230903625, -0.061641186475753784, -0.005506804212927818, -0.002007370116189122, -0.021365070715546608, 0.01782512292265892, 0.022513868287205696, -0.02952590398490429, -0.035132504999637604, 0.019896112382411957, 0.006991633214056492, 0.0034286505542695522, -0.00475023640319705, -0.018523598089814186, 0.00499469880014658, -0.09062372893095016, 0.017565246671438217, 0.007542493753135204, -0.0046371882781386375, 0.028614487498998642, -0.01647699996829033, 0.02429276518523693, -0.024400051683187485, -0.007523521780967712, 0.026736540719866753, -0.018595676869153976, -0.011164693161845207, -0.03411722555756569, 0.009011583402752876, 0.02149631269276142, 0.045294567942619324, 0.03604462370276451, 0.006473073735833168, 0.012618722394108772, 0.01955311931669712, -0.006533847656100988, -0.041861094534397125, -0.00467443373054266, -0.014133540913462639, -0.04253587871789932, 0.028251199051737785, 0.003977630287408829, 0.04723624512553215, 0.0019860989414155483, 0.008680997416377068, 0.012962802313268185, 0.00707114115357399, 0.02212449721992016, 0.00019821521709673107, 0.014978794381022453, -0.05042428523302078, 0.014176346361637115, 0.040179282426834106, -0.016897423192858696, -0.0322587788105011, -0.044793784618377686, -0.05413592606782913, -0.01048423070460558, -0.008253656327724457, -0.014887023717164993, -0.02247048355638981, 0.013024304062128067, -0.0013477267930284142, 0.025919610634446144, -0.03405270352959633, -0.0071322126314044, -0.05315456539392471, -0.052040647715330124, -0.046851761639118195, -0.010579898953437805, 0.018097475171089172, -0.016023728996515274, 0.020405594259500504, 0.00198344886302948, 0.03929773345589638, -0.007120202761143446, -0.0068418425507843494, 0.004808589816093445, 0.03787815198302269, -0.015736626461148262, 0.02080904133617878, -0.013926428742706776, -0.0035788430832326412, 0.07679294049739838, -0.04980452358722687, -0.03337822109460831, 0.056801825761795044, -0.04161498695611954, 0.026693573221564293, 0.011216520331799984, 0.003993512596935034, 0.01098380796611309, 0.02451559156179428, -0.021945733577013016, 0.02521546743810177, 0.008272051811218262, 0.015117361210286617, 0.00371174537576735, 0.006488805636763573, 0.0497230626642704, 0.010817253962159157, 0.012149045243859291, 0.0496140792965889, 0.004788768012076616, -0.002005066489800811, -0.0071046906523406506, 0.022406110540032387, 0.013165583834052086, 0.03634018078446388, 0.00694917980581522, 0.0050997668877244, 0.059757765382528305, 0.0669088065624237, -0.025007739663124084, 0.02158927544951439, -0.024063631892204285, -0.009149017743766308, -0.09605158120393753, -0.009173044003546238, 0.014415151439607143, 0.0072892336174845695, 0.021325668320059776, -0.028920510783791542, -0.010716996155679226, 0.03956139087677002, -0.04567284882068634, 0.017152627930045128, -0.0010745221516117454, 0.019624914973974228, -0.024598240852355957, 0.03003436140716076, -0.03610502928495407, 0.023054419085383415, 0.024275945499539375, 0.031617213040590286, 0.035875871777534485, 0.012822321616113186, 0.037991829216480255, -0.005632562562823296, -0.037412576377391815, 0.021251488476991653, -0.02692793495953083, -0.02560233697295189, -0.0074709453620016575, -0.03544777259230614, -0.03561720624566078, 0.022061210125684738, -0.0063639371655881405, 0.035446006804704666, 0.02037999965250492, 0.00364437373355031, 0.01510702632367611, 0.034891027957201004, 0.040632106363773346, -0.04274106025695801, -0.022285204380750656, 0.023008188232779503, -0.0003537115117069334, 0.06734762340784073, 0.022214096039533615, 0.032060857862234116, 0.021930867806077003, -0.03177063167095184, 0.01433569099754095, 0.014891223981976509, -0.003968510311096907, -0.012202742509543896, -0.011073481291532516, 0.022984473034739494, -0.028496267274022102, -0.017633473500609398, 0.04042955860495567, -0.007159136701375246, 0.017733504995703697, 0.05446531996130943, 0.03926999494433403, -0.01664077490568161, 0.001298446673899889, -0.014896310865879059, -0.02661029063165188, 0.01042733434587717, 0.01897391304373741, 0.011183503083884716, -0.07804282009601593, -0.02253284864127636, 0.018597735092043877, 0.012062402442097664, -0.019633790478110313, 0.010014476254582405, -0.04494017735123634, 0.05137082189321518, 0.008813370019197464, 0.043431829661130905, 0.0019681372214108706, -0.0323207788169384, 0.0079200966283679, -0.07562094181776047, 0.10998398065567017, 0.002758095506578684, 0.009812787175178528, -0.039200905710458755, -0.017161265015602112, -0.021345239132642746, 0.0030269837006926537, 0.025147084146738052, -0.0030965087935328484, 0.017717717215418816, -0.016672305762767792, 0.016361812129616737, 0.013556363061070442, -0.004534432664513588, 0.015945540741086006, -0.04282906651496887, -0.013073496520519257, 0.0012587469536811113, -0.04819098114967346, -0.0027077074628323317, 0.009692094288766384, 0.013848545961081982, 0.0036539833527058363, 0.026350973173975945, 0.007629116531461477, 0.01008455641567707, 0.0719049721956253, 0.013223182410001755, 0.00437495531514287, 0.004363302141427994, -0.0070844246074557304, 0.02283596619963646, 0.014743945561349392, -0.013178355060517788, -0.02537921443581581, 0.022193416953086853, -0.05903175473213196, -0.05089592933654785, 0.02432883530855179, 0.02206474542617798, -0.011210103519260883, -0.02495826780796051, 0.01238294504582882, 0.03035874478518963, -0.0512169748544693, 0.027263090014457703, 0.033359114080667496, 0.008406254462897778, 0.02076258696615696, -0.006802471354603767, 0.013514276593923569, 0.018672538921236992, -0.04210438206791878, -0.026264188811182976, 0.02215610258281231, 0.01207171194255352, -0.005090539343655109, 0.025258544832468033, 0.040816038846969604, 0.031673405319452286, 0.02303776703774929, -0.002353488001972437, 0.026318717747926712, -0.06688866019248962, -0.03015884943306446, -0.0030996541026979685, -0.01043066568672657, 0.01731891930103302, 0.03077070787549019, 0.006785722449421883, 0.10336193442344666, 0.001708171097561717, -0.027371859177947044, 0.009149741381406784, -0.04903608560562134, -0.029904348775744438, 0.0049703107215464115, -0.03157515078783035, 0.06732996553182602, -0.020514827221632004, 0.008702900260686874, -0.033599335700273514, 0.02865547500550747, 0.055171772837638855, -0.025424370542168617, 0.03570609167218208, -0.006815755274146795, -0.024325214326381683, -0.03997897356748581, -0.015594788827002048, -0.013841778971254826, -0.017498241737484932, 0.012842344120144844, 0.02460518106818199, 0.02971041388809681, 0.04195781797170639, 0.0038279471918940544, -0.002246313961222768, 0.01987537182867527, -0.06607361137866974, 0.027108559384942055, -0.0602433905005455, 0.012376530095934868, -0.020000582560896873, -0.03142046183347702 ]
<p>If I have two different percentages and I wanted to know the change, I would simply use the percentage change formula...but what if I want to compare two percentages that have different amounts: Ex: August - there was 539 right answers out of 743 = 72.5 % September - there was 498 answers out of 820 = 60.7%</p> <p>How can I do a monthly comparison of change between those 2 percentages?</p> <p>It was suggested to me that I use LCD, but those numbers could be massive if I have a larger set of numbers like in the thousands.</p> <p>So, should I analyze the months separately or what should I do?</p> <p>**I want to do a comparative analysis on the students who took the exam in august vs the students in september. LCD = lowest common denominator. Can this be done?</p>
74,211
[ 0.012286175973713398, 0.014992142096161842, -0.0271829254925251, 0.014784038066864014, 0.014916731044650078, 0.04365088790655136, 0.00038955837953835726, -0.04062284901738167, 0.03128432109951973, 0.018894007429480553, 0.032311711460351944, 0.02568645589053631, 0.035984937101602554, 0.010664733126759529, 0.02387690544128418, 0.011986003257334232, -0.02356201410293579, 0.0009866401087492704, -0.020687120035290718, 0.0034450723323971033, -0.009297693148255348, -0.00661566061899066, 0.030005164444446564, -0.012252136133611202, -0.01755116507411003, 0.005046800710260868, 0.02168930694460869, -0.04987937584519386, 0.0035285106860101223, 0.04867304489016533, -0.05201217532157898, -0.03685063123703003, 0.033541616052389145, 0.02268337458372116, 0.007511804811656475, -0.007825855165719986, -0.03292219340801239, -0.037249915301799774, -0.039034925401210785, 0.01631852053105831, -0.026470502838492393, 0.019550561904907227, -0.024102909490466118, 0.07630842924118042, -0.016535798087716103, 0.02078375034034252, -0.021690186113119125, -0.009356321766972542, 0.03283272683620453, -0.05737649276852608, 0.058750804513692856, -0.030832184478640556, 0.0554705448448658, 0.07990731298923492, 0.022523270919919014, 0.004307169932872057, -0.004625200293958187, 0.04159880429506302, -0.004888076800853014, -0.01769832707941532, -0.00983256846666336, 0.026237737387418747, 0.03172988072037697, -0.002579796127974987, -0.01708940789103508, 0.018725717440247536, -0.01610732078552246, 0.001259999698959291, 0.012475076131522655, -0.020194480195641518, -0.005496525205671787, 0.046552449464797974, 0.07069679349660873, -0.028120292350649834, 0.034524235874414444, -0.09385724365711212, -0.01824968121945858, 0.03249767795205116, 0.030035581439733505, 0.06610604375600815, -0.04136083647608757, 0.04017098248004913, 0.027540385723114014, 0.021991850808262825, 0.05491941049695015, -0.04197593405842781, 0.05617963522672653, -0.006379042286425829, -0.014882293529808521, 0.00046140491031110287, 0.0186129342764616, -0.02511669509112835, 0.007640873547643423, 0.004287485498934984, -0.022848783060908318, 0.007259720005095005, -0.03376084193587303, 0.004595517180860043, 0.003647781442850828, 0.013222082518041134, -0.00012558196613099426, -0.024875447154045105, 0.05642271414399147, 0.03967352956533432, -0.003115326166152954, -0.010097237303853035, -0.013491902500391006, -0.01303205918520689, -0.0033359257504343987, 0.00752628967165947, -0.015589558519423008, 0.0014376024482771754, 0.020665589720010757, 0.02480403706431389, -0.0014071683399379253, -0.03315340355038643, -0.020102521404623985, -0.020652305334806442, 0.0688411295413971, 0.05473300442099571, 0.052212730050086975, -0.039965271949768066, 0.018053529784083366, -0.0374295748770237, -0.03163912519812584, 0.029762104153633118, -0.03240649774670601, -0.012747861444950104, -0.05983617529273033, 0.029443690553307533, -0.026416024193167686, -0.010441704653203487, 0.054815035313367844, -0.006606976967304945, 0.02560526877641678, 0.05647231638431549, -0.09651350229978561, -0.053378187119960785, 0.04192954674363136, -0.04248300939798355, 0.005336859729140997, -0.040104929357767105, 0.005418756511062384, 0.014852600172162056, 0.03192069008946419, 0.012829461134970188, 0.04169752448797226, 0.00832386314868927, 0.005865477491170168, 0.02494378574192524, -0.009610740467905998, -0.0072633326053619385, 0.011275317519903183, -0.010815618559718132, -0.00772450678050518, -0.07130992412567139, -0.012386837974190712, 0.040678080171346664, -0.026571670547127724, -0.0028144230600446463, 0.0442955419421196, 0.010426199063658714, -0.031650252640247345, -0.0015594996511936188, 0.023651402443647385, -0.025767046958208084, 0.11329906433820724, -0.00505913095548749, 0.014129411429166794, 0.018062837421894073, -0.0027313001919537783, 0.015052823349833488, 0.008441103622317314, -0.014028933830559254, 0.06882737576961517, 0.019177019596099854, 0.01321546919643879, -0.03374776989221573, 0.008831681683659554, -0.03576585650444031, -0.06097792088985443, -0.023380381986498833, -0.03289322555065155, 0.03049403801560402, 0.0031116718892008066, 0.06045886129140854, 0.029308848083019257, -0.023915382102131844, 0.039822857826948166, -0.04392683878540993, -0.0345151349902153, -0.06387234479188919, 0.021539023146033287, -0.005144163500517607, -0.021314403042197227, 0.02341996319591999, 0.020332153886556625, 0.019748924300074577, -0.005274888128042221, 0.008065938018262386, 0.011269178241491318, -0.007911556400358677, -0.015680288895964622, -0.04462554305791855, 0.018044069409370422, 0.037214651703834534, 0.04949912056326866, -0.02042274735867977, 0.012089839205145836, -0.07805869728326797, -0.014752114191651344, 0.011684336699545383, -0.0675240159034729, 0.025654064491391182, 0.03297146037220955, -0.061470888555049896, -0.009529857896268368, 0.012967891991138458, -0.03188219666481018, 0.04961298033595085, -0.061146412044763565, 0.07036331295967102, 0.062451813369989395, -0.00445358082652092, 0.05298071727156639, -0.014739062637090683, 0.013564513996243477, 0.04174938052892685, 0.014414980076253414, -0.016220539808273315, -0.04609861969947815, 0.041752755641937256, 0.023790394887328148, 0.004424136597663164, -0.027429679408669472, 0.038417521864175797, 0.04628894850611687, -0.010402437299489975, 0.0232346523553133, 0.003969263285398483, 0.009115801192820072, -0.028726767748594284, -0.007050899788737297, 0.026624372228980064, -0.017306989058852196, 0.014331880025565624, 0.021797863766551018, -0.00490327225998044, 0.04688996449112892, 0.027806639671325684, -0.003373874584212899, 0.04379972815513611, 0.03302832692861557, 0.0252805445343256, 0.01677560806274414, -0.00435378635302186, 0.02438987046480179, -0.017267446964979172, -0.04079505428671837, 0.018517514690756798, -0.020781993865966797, -0.018493440002202988, 0.02297252230346203, -0.03897212818264961, 0.02467375621199608, 0.04819093644618988, -0.030624063685536385, 0.015608234331011772, 0.03286167234182358, -0.0030530430376529694, 0.03856688365340233, -0.016545163467526436, -0.03218366578221321, -0.05030430108308792, -0.0032576376106590033, 0.036243267357349396, 0.02095109410583973, 0.037959493696689606, -0.011748004704713821, -0.027782097458839417, 0.024858808144927025, -0.011861724779009819, 0.018362971022725105, -0.05545377731323242, -0.023964714258909225, 0.005118301138281822, 0.02142297849059105, -0.01477242261171341, 0.03378458693623543, -0.000846592360176146, 0.008694522082805634, 0.034606993198394775, 0.02257687598466873, -0.05428418144583702, -0.024218032136559486, -0.010134764015674591, -0.0075821904465556145, -0.0004215246590320021, -0.025716129690408707, 0.04104477912187576, -0.0001355234271613881, -0.01074325293302536, 0.012374668382108212, -0.025216883048415184, 0.010370767675340176, -0.027607226744294167, 0.0026594139635562897, -0.004894480109214783, 0.004158033058047295, -0.0294505562633276, -0.006992776412516832, -0.0139665761962533, -0.00507349381223321, -0.077128104865551, -0.041308362036943436, 0.007004549726843834, -0.016253577545285225, 0.03840864449739456, -0.03152387589216232, 0.0012286754790693521, 0.0565643310546875, 0.032899994403123856, -0.050512999296188354, -0.008957620710134506, 0.0038839788176119328, -0.04212379455566406, -0.024220295250415802, 0.029846135526895523, 0.03144053742289543, -0.035236991941928864, -0.010533583350479603, 0.00703750504180789, 0.01969204843044281, 0.04575421288609505, 0.039791740477085114, -0.0023190323263406754, -0.00427316315472126, 0.011437658220529556, -0.007680612616240978, 0.012569725513458252, 0.0024061112198978662, -0.07321961224079132, 0.016575008630752563, 0.008006159216165543, 0.03761123865842819, 0.008391126990318298, -0.04770876467227936, 0.03101152554154396, -0.0031451734248548746, -0.014270760118961334, -0.029470989480614662, 0.019083186984062195, 0.058506079018116, -0.025204215198755264, 0.0025642255786806345, 0.01703066937625408, -0.007951733656227589, -0.02551041729748249, -0.04420958086848259, 0.05314851924777031, 0.055016595870256424, -0.05882561579346657, -0.002601784188300371, -0.016575923189520836, 0.005924546625465155, 0.04272110387682915, -0.0706392452120781, 0.008800161071121693, 0.03928853198885918, 0.034973595291376114, 0.019759992137551308, 0.0025225933641195297, -0.05927101522684097, -0.01853938214480877, -0.07601873576641083, -0.012472144328057766, 0.005914759822189808, 0.07695501297712326, -0.019002020359039307, 0.06280037015676498, 0.018980473279953003, 0.012928716838359833, 0.04612163081765175, -0.024149345234036446, -0.062072791159152985, 0.02656390517950058, -0.006911879871040583, -0.013588783331215382, 0.00044291329686529934, 0.009324178099632263, 0.008719307370483875, -0.017262468114495277, -0.037675775587558746, -0.031958337873220444, 0.0020847260020673275, -0.0016870297258719802, 0.04100487753748894, -0.03802746906876564, -0.010255453176796436, 0.020376404747366905, 0.03148532658815384, 0.010119033977389336, 0.005104823969304562, -0.00547859026119113, 0.03201080113649368, -0.019593503326177597, -0.037512701004743576, -0.02514914982020855, -0.021743929013609886, 0.0019903285428881645, 0.043681785464286804, 0.01750294491648674, 0.04833794757723808, -0.04218112304806709, 0.04765279218554497, 0.027461139485239983, 0.013047171756625175, 0.03657149896025658, -0.03434216231107712, -0.03797603398561478, -0.04166947677731514, -0.020498858764767647, -0.01694747805595398, 0.03302352875471115, 0.01044272817671299, 0.02506350539624691, 0.03674493730068207, 0.03526487201452255, -0.029153946787118912, 0.031243251636624336, 0.054351113736629486, -0.012077489867806435, -0.009713840670883656, -0.01764831505715847, 0.0056028529070317745, -0.04488255828619003, -0.04111723601818085, 0.037788260728120804, 0.028251975774765015, 0.013925179839134216, -0.009594108909368515, 0.05103382095694542, 0.004146524704992771, -0.04781996086239815, 0.015370181761682034, -0.0017863715765997767, 0.0199737548828125, 0.002294562291353941, -0.01437407173216343, 0.06759810447692871, 0.058166760951280594, 0.027731044217944145, -0.00615953141823411, 0.0526382252573967, -0.08369859308004379, -0.012140820734202862, 0.06188743934035301, 0.08296171575784683, -0.073746457695961, -0.03177957236766815, -0.022676240652799606, 0.0035837620962411165, 0.03171326592564583, -0.05412634462118149, 0.004383401479572058, -0.016589872539043427, 0.032787859439849854, -0.04355731979012489, -0.004580744542181492, 0.007786212954670191, 0.014416376128792763, -0.03585236147046089, 0.023592831566929817, 0.0007265895255841315, -0.015214146114885807, -0.04306331276893616, 0.02414417639374733, 0.010000082664191723, 0.07184305042028427, -0.030113110318779945, -0.01478475984185934, -0.013466199859976768, -0.01175221148878336, -0.02826428785920143, -0.045836757868528366, 0.006572290323674679, -0.009045591577887535, 0.006824768614023924, 0.007187353912740946, -0.004875102546066046, -0.04766014963388443, 0.026962129399180412, 0.02120169624686241, -0.03390275314450264, -0.01732782833278179, -0.018065592274069786, 0.022798405960202217, 0.07670610398054123, -0.008919157087802887, 0.05407270789146423, 0.017765989527106285, 0.01972765102982521, 0.010529237799346447, -0.002219250425696373, -0.0036620087921619415, 0.007292041555047035, -0.035089872777462006, -0.016811951994895935, -0.010611850768327713, -0.03488627448678017, 0.03390121832489967, -0.00785734597593546, 0.05237957462668419, -0.03168725222349167, -0.007651714142411947, -0.017550624907016754, -0.006934708915650845, 0.017211750149726868, 0.007811724673956633, 0.008870494551956654, -0.021359307691454887, 0.01091078482568264, -0.004517268855124712, 0.029106616973876953, -0.020387347787618637, -0.03114010952413082, -0.012801808305084705, -0.013535413891077042, 0.015938827767968178, -0.04509500414133072, -0.026274459436535835, 0.01895400881767273, 0.009327566251158714, -0.006656070705503225, -0.0075463661924004555, 0.04035883769392967, 0.019916612654924393, -0.028640668839216232, -0.013952604494988918, 0.04136931523680687, -0.021771203726530075, 0.01338671799749136, -0.05335092172026634, 0.04570972919464111, 0.010134945623576641, -0.020761126652359962, -0.036336492747068405, -0.06578700244426727, 0.0216472577303648, 0.025209195911884308, -0.04015018045902252, -0.021261144429445267, -0.04949890822172165, 0.03511307016015053, -0.009365800768136978, -0.033312320709228516, 0.045693300664424896, 0.00043288784218020737, -0.018096862360835075, -0.010684479027986526, -0.0010190147440880537, 0.0865042582154274, -0.011747305281460285, -0.008789312094449997, -0.02817952074110508, 0.0057543604634702206, -0.012451477348804474, 0.00005421118112280965, 0.014319008216261864, -0.0413186214864254, -0.022186843678355217, 0.001768706482835114, -0.017422664910554886, 0.0671909898519516, -0.05468997731804848, -0.020418820902705193, 0.04336700960993767, -0.008486957289278507, 0.003064352087676525, -0.032936226576566696, 0.0025386500637978315, -0.017872802913188934, 0.005274484399706125, -0.02555100806057453, 0.005273635499179363, 0.011325525119900703, -0.002345105865970254, -0.02240619622170925, 0.03162313252687454, -0.0344373881816864, 0.009127184748649597, 0.08582114428281784, -0.019727559760212898, -0.0016462053172290325, 0.024384232237935066, -0.023816021159291267, 0.018204087391495705, 0.017942069098353386, 0.01258199755102396, 0.0002264708891743794, 0.008864954113960266, -0.029188580811023712, -0.051875922828912735, -0.037352025508880615, 0.00217625149525702, 0.0541599802672863, 0.036419577896595, 0.045199621468782425, 0.0605747289955616, 0.022125069051980972, 0.053321607410907745, -0.014916880056262016, -0.021680906414985657, -0.01767023466527462, -0.029681839048862457, 0.07403787225484848, -0.02762232907116413, -0.029275018721818924, 0.029659001156687737, -0.005338495597243309, 0.01441776193678379, 0.030308673158288002, 0.017613353207707405, -0.011529380455613136, 0.03398949280381203, -0.01681964099407196, -0.027806667611002922, 0.00503038102760911, -0.042731788009405136, 0.031968776136636734, -0.06619678437709808, -0.018903154879808426, 0.059449203312397, 0.026437319815158844, -0.0005381103837862611, -0.042960263788700104, -0.014293632470071316, -0.08273600786924362, 0.027310121804475784, -0.006937135010957718, 0.025507261976599693, 0.047212421894073486, -0.00870739296078682, 0.05828806012868881, 0.0123470863327384, 0.006965648848563433, -0.03513375669717789, -0.04138694703578949, -0.029804343357682228, 0.00892436970025301, -0.02916501834988594, 0.004404203966259956, 0.0006577768363058567, 0.009927439503371716, 0.012626804411411285, 0.0166317131370306, 0.005142664071172476, -0.005858659744262695, 0.009261349216103554, 0.00017747795209288597, 0.06306654214859009, -0.017865145578980446, 0.032762255519628525, 0.0023330743424594402, -0.022363968193531036, 0.13190260529518127, 0.03443535044789314, -0.0047210222110152245, -0.045385077595710754, 0.024209002032876015, 0.030375247821211815, 0.029624607414007187, -0.016117101535201073, 0.011672080494463444, 0.010961676016449928, 0.0113091254606843, 0.06904254853725433, 0.035524725914001465, 0.0251313429325819, -0.011230838485062122, 0.02926180325448513, -0.009253503754734993, -0.02008644863963127, 0.00972748827189207, -0.010811224579811096, -0.007472566328942776, 0.02543063461780548, -0.011120160110294819, 0.022744838148355484, 0.026817165315151215, -0.0013447538949549198, -0.020425522699952126, -0.03980279713869095, 0.012108860537409782, -0.014302238821983337, -0.0743381679058075, 0.04633243381977081, 0.013276375830173492, 0.032924339175224304, -0.004815253429114819, 0.0066790273413062096, 0.012598603963851929, -0.03172488510608673, 0.005279643461108208, 0.03973231092095375, -0.005530065856873989, -0.04806896299123764, -0.041335999965667725, -0.010560084134340286, -0.012674285098910332, 0.000965126499067992, -0.09092950820922852, -0.005935263819992542, 0.005792251322418451, -0.010657813400030136, -0.03355417028069496, -0.017232971265912056, -0.04420141130685806, -0.04434823989868164, -0.04165083169937134, 0.05173230543732643, 0.016791552305221558, -0.019532278180122375, -0.000605351640842855, -0.004609457217156887, 0.02723066695034504, -0.015233490616083145, 0.013922869227826595, 0.040721382945775986, -0.018398890271782875, -0.008247209712862968, 0.013452819548547268, 0.03841507062315941, -0.03123103640973568, 0.014005394652485847, -0.005504335276782513, 0.03394853323698044, -0.008689033798873425, -0.0012030951911583543, -0.019150640815496445, 0.03899713605642319, -0.002128822263330221, -0.0016324634198099375, -0.013523198664188385, -0.0038212714716792107, -0.029554618522524834, 0.025828028097748756, 0.04444677382707596, 0.021173782646656036, -0.00794457457959652, -0.011669357307255268, 0.0427040196955204, 0.00824403204023838, 0.024017948657274246, 0.004125101491808891, 0.015681061893701553, 0.03821161389350891, 0.03814630210399628, -0.03910256177186966, -0.04278390109539032, -0.01263345219194889, -0.07478886842727661, 0.005958820693194866, -0.04254407063126564, 0.05254026874899864, 0.00412721699103713, -0.025380266830325127, -0.009778168052434921, 0.014887643046677113, -0.013322273269295692, 0.03598298132419586, -0.023216094821691513, -0.05278421565890312, -0.01689506508409977, 0.027427801862359047, -0.009939862415194511, -0.026717238128185272, 0.003816902404651046, -0.03499810770153999, 0.0210625808686018, 0.030235474929213524, -0.006221679970622063, -0.014965069480240345, 0.053706999868154526, -0.024615837261080742, -0.025384224951267242, -0.016101283952593803, 0.012985797598958015, -0.05038866400718689, -0.031485021114349365, 0.0008374201133847237, 0.009091819636523724, 0.030266188085079193, 0.025104111060500145, 0.0036924732849001884, 0.01587812229990959, 0.0702187642455101, -0.004658895544707775, 0.005649275612086058, -0.05120547115802765, 0.013181839138269424, -0.007209892850369215, -0.004994403570890427, -0.036233093589544296, -0.015217903070151806, 0.05985860899090767, -0.025332702323794365, -0.04267948120832443, 0.006205393001437187, -0.016725625842809677, 0.019212504848837852, 0.02310830168426037, 0.012647178024053574, 0.021547721698880196, 0.0625707358121872, -0.028568433597683907, -0.01061062328517437, -0.03124825470149517, 0.02349560521543026, 0.01988035812973976, -0.05186700448393822, -0.010887941345572472, 0.011798068881034851, 0.0128463851287961, 0.041012849658727646, 0.042310312390327454, -0.009204824455082417, 0.000749227125197649, -0.0062781511805951595, 0.0033709926065057516, 0.0013239324325695634, -0.00912028644233942, -0.0023526796139776707, 0.058205850422382355, 0.029732663184404373, -0.015253494493663311, 0.017062461003661156, -0.007852784357964993, 0.012881161645054817, -0.06831496953964233, -0.004157411865890026, 0.020813461393117905, 0.01655813679099083, 0.016810817644000053, -0.03845066949725151, 0.008793572895228863, 0.02462378889322281, -0.031969599425792694, 0.017787029966711998, -0.028751999139785767, 0.02193213254213333, -0.034476809203624725, 0.013495178893208504, 0.007545259781181812, 0.02395237609744072, 0.023848386481404305, 0.012958649545907974, 0.0265307929366827, 0.01524004340171814, 0.0370461642742157, -0.037389930337667465, -0.0020527036394923925, -0.030521532520651817, -0.0038652922958135605, -0.06370297819375992, 0.025471946224570274, -0.058666080236434937, -0.05622662603855133, 0.0038538682274520397, -0.05275880545377731, 0.05761123076081276, -0.01173678319901228, 0.0038782653864473104, -0.018157877027988434, 0.02325391210615635, 0.0247062798589468, 0.008284750394523144, -0.07566160708665848, -0.019730689004063606, 0.002225656993687153, 0.03554036095738411, 0.005414995364844799, 0.00620377529412508, 0.03452610224485397, 0.0005437350482679904, -0.015664735808968544, 0.024063745513558388, 0.00962839461863041, 0.003107586642727256, 0.005802358500659466, -0.016708197072148323, 0.020977851003408432, 0.003826088970527053, -0.010775941424071789, -0.027765560895204544, 0.013836206868290901, 0.045743752270936966, -0.007070348598062992, -0.006647383328527212, 0.006998130120337009, -0.019778329879045486, -0.02511676587164402, -0.00683580944314599, 0.03373061120510101, -0.012685157358646393, -0.01755150593817234, 0.008914033882319927, -0.012285798788070679, -0.032683346420526505, -0.013348549604415894, 0.00953842792659998, -0.058622028678655624, 0.02858913317322731, -0.024739285930991173, -0.024726521223783493, -0.0030253552831709385, -0.005735768936574459, 0.026427794247865677, -0.08195988833904266, 0.0360412523150444, 0.03987232595682144, -0.04850258305668831, -0.003130745841190219, -0.03775355964899063, -0.025637159124016762, 0.007208971306681633, 0.033195026218891144, 0.04417836666107178, -0.0027406858280301094, -0.02762751094996929, -0.0346180722117424, 0.021335724741220474, -0.05699256807565689, -0.015971489250659943, -0.045029595494270325, -0.01730414852499962, -0.012852645479142666, -0.0038895520847290754, 0.00149208412040025, -0.002448214218020439, -0.008629312738776207, -0.007404619362205267, 0.030950583517551422, 0.0013568595750257373, 0.007680154871195555, 0.04611065983772278, -0.01218663901090622, -0.04049370065331459, 0.025052795186638832, -0.008034264668822289, 0.017606282606720924, -0.007395070046186447, -0.009414044208824635, -0.0637989193201065, 0.040841102600097656, -0.05418749526143074, -0.015810158103704453, 0.03180108591914177, 0.004488656297326088, 0.0006488016806542873, -0.03237332031130791, -0.02628791704773903, 0.027363639324903488, -0.011719263158738613, 0.014577106572687626, 0.02545199915766716, -0.007061260286718607, -0.006594224367290735, 0.031850315630435944, 0.034563202410936356, 0.015867706388235092, -0.025122197344899178, -0.013699290342628956, -0.01233497355133295, 0.027364294975996017, 0.014889778569340706, 0.013504554517567158, 0.027675163000822067, 0.029226554557681084, -0.0012996160658076406, -0.0002310337295057252, 0.024185558781027794, 0.013889442197978497, -0.026654839515686035, -0.024324839934706688, -0.002805439755320549, 0.010409957729279995, 0.02870992198586464, 0.017173537984490395, 0.03927893936634064, -0.05507330596446991, 0.008205948397517204, -0.03311743587255478, 0.0012685314286500216, -0.04312373325228691, 0.018725410103797913, 0.021004648879170418, 0.0013764634495601058, -0.005747753661125898, -0.009584061801433563, 0.007229638285934925, -0.01738581620156765, 0.012839045375585556, 0.00008402047387789935, 0.02237851358950138, -0.03237990289926529, -0.03825760632753372, -0.0030859762337058783, -0.018187101930379868, -0.055937159806489944, -0.02149663306772709, 0.03865591436624527, 0.0383039228618145, 0.05796250328421593, 0.036539122462272644, -0.04830915108323097, 0.00874943658709526, 0.0047071571461856365, -0.024111531674861908, -0.05436423048377037, -0.05758640542626381, 0.005746307782828808, 0.009990021586418152, -0.05809517577290535 ]
<p>I am trying to mine product-usage sequences for multiple users of online gaming site. I have found the R package <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/arulesSequences/index.html" rel="nofollow">arulesSequences</a> but am not sure how to fit it to my problem. The data format would be tuples similar to those used in <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/arulesSequences/index.html" rel="nofollow">arulesSequences</a>, but instead of just mentioning products A and B in transactions, I would like to mention the quantities in which those products (games of different types) were bought (played, in my case). </p> <p>Example:</p> <p>sequence1 (for uid=1)</p> <pre><code>Date UID Game1 Game2 Game3 Game4 Jan1 1 125times 0times 0times 0times Jan2 1 0times 1time 0times 0times </code></pre> <p>Each user would have such a sequence. However, I see that arulesSequences function cspades would only allow to operate with bollean types, e.g. whether each game was actually played on that date:</p> <p>Example:</p> <p>sequence1 (for uid=1)</p> <pre><code>Date UID Jan1 1 Game1 Game2 Jan2 1 Game1 Jan3 1 Game2 Game3 </code></pre> <p>My goal is to determine rules like "if a user playes Game3 on that date, it causes them to play much more of Game2 one week later". </p>
74,212
[ 0.007941057905554771, -0.021272627636790276, -0.0007522550295107067, -0.002508786739781499, 0.0024614152498543262, 0.022996006533503532, 0.006111348047852516, -0.017767811194062233, 0.01811632513999939, 0.008892941288650036, 0.008507047779858112, 0.01640539988875389, 0.023567328229546547, 0.024635659530758858, 0.012592262588441372, -0.007949570193886757, -0.021801782771945, -0.002770863939076662, 0.01596618816256523, 0.016967762261629105, 0.016759146004915237, -0.030049296095967293, -0.03594852238893509, 0.015479899942874908, -0.00967238750308752, 0.024910876527428627, 0.002384511288255453, 0.006813331041485071, -0.019281255081295967, 0.054884832352399826, -0.0413370281457901, -0.07767639309167862, 0.03318090736865997, -0.011271328665316105, 0.014725674875080585, 0.025993304327130318, -0.05754939466714859, -0.016680294647812843, 0.0013588155852630734, -0.008331569842994213, -0.06986675411462784, 0.0038210100028663874, 0.009243709035217762, 0.06040092557668686, -0.02470383048057556, 0.01634233631193638, 0.005187760107219219, 0.019238581880927086, 0.01190840732306242, -0.03207477182149887, 0.07256809622049332, -0.04149801284074783, 0.0302885714918375, -0.004128976259380579, -0.03227410838007927, -0.0017708466621115804, 0.025631895288825035, 0.05364304408431053, 0.003164007794111967, -0.047680243849754333, -0.013941997662186623, -0.011021895334124565, 0.03485526889562607, -0.018425924703478813, -0.040194880217313766, 0.03241623565554619, 0.005189129617065191, -0.0038938415236771107, 0.013086104765534401, -0.06936702877283096, 0.029095692560076714, -0.026744477450847626, 0.026622658595442772, -0.007809832692146301, -0.0024652271531522274, -0.025196870788931847, 0.0017279083840548992, 0.007401567418128252, 0.0537198930978775, 0.040129151195287704, -0.023780185729265213, 0.019109074026346207, -0.011638067662715912, 0.006667721550911665, 0.07200238108634949, -0.013545080088078976, 0.04899841547012329, -0.04774322360754013, 0.027262313291430473, 0.011506346985697746, 0.014437122270464897, -0.027147024869918823, 0.06740336865186691, 0.03578803315758705, -0.0548861101269722, -0.002420256147161126, 0.007285094819962978, -0.008662623353302479, -0.02959549054503441, 0.038625918328762054, -0.01223425380885601, -0.0555490218102932, -0.00042499107075855136, 0.04040401428937912, -0.02730594575405121, -0.01887269876897335, -0.044646136462688446, -0.0480729304254055, -0.005747552495449781, 0.00730669591575861, -0.029860250651836395, 0.016224408522248268, -0.01904992014169693, -0.003040534211322665, 0.003947238903492689, -0.03368412330746651, -0.060929037630558014, 0.012323644943535328, 0.05901607871055603, 0.04033936560153961, 0.07914746552705765, -0.0015064002946019173, 0.04146526753902435, -0.017432156950235367, -0.09345902502536774, 0.03637348487973213, 0.012733438052237034, 0.00616878317669034, -0.028415082022547722, 0.04873558506369591, -0.00881185196340084, 0.0130562549456954, 0.028814150020480156, -0.02897888794541359, 0.01508062519133091, 0.014590222388505936, -0.052673012018203735, -0.04887606203556061, 0.024278633296489716, 0.02865486964583397, 0.03463681787252426, -0.037517350167036057, 0.028562845662236214, -0.002312633441761136, 0.03744744509458542, 0.00184054730925709, 0.035915497690439224, 0.04737367108464241, 0.014329468831419945, 0.019787948578596115, -0.04182284697890282, 0.020002873614430428, -0.02966146171092987, 0.018422318622469902, 0.0014526424929499626, -0.04798416793346405, 0.024533621966838837, 0.038053520023822784, 0.015098157338798046, -0.020892804488539696, 0.04008851945400238, 0.02533586323261261, -0.032041944563388824, -0.005312016699463129, 0.023551054298877716, -0.014562981203198433, 0.07211332023143768, -0.006799366325139999, 0.008151901885867119, 0.0044683064334094524, -0.019831206649541855, 0.03198270499706268, 0.016933074221014977, 0.018253354355692863, 0.07272320985794067, 0.002148101106286049, -0.02020004391670227, 0.014706029556691647, -0.02538951300084591, 0.03636282682418823, -0.02742815762758255, -0.008655416779220104, -0.030602015554904938, -0.02951175719499588, 0.00977310910820961, 0.02161119133234024, 0.01685887575149536, -0.022980844601988792, 0.03524019569158554, -0.05670766532421112, -0.0210831668227911, -0.08107013255357742, -0.00845788512378931, -0.005480714607983828, -0.031860366463661194, 0.032772429287433624, -0.02216811664402485, 0.008842261508107185, 0.02234708145260811, -0.014259939081966877, -0.04185362532734871, -0.008033080957829952, 0.015828212723135948, -0.01605747453868389, -0.04914432391524315, 0.036471281200647354, 0.003888313425704837, -0.04897115379571915, 0.019451342523097992, -0.014783776365220547, -0.007723633665591478, 0.032059501856565475, -0.064328633248806, 0.0034639001823961735, -0.04194788634777069, 0.024230653420090675, 0.04861315339803696, 0.020125534385442734, -0.006708938628435135, 0.06886041164398193, -0.04187597334384918, 0.026629069820046425, 0.10273414850234985, 0.02166229858994484, -0.011396393179893494, -0.02076113596558571, 0.009977745823562145, -0.006120014004409313, -0.050971079617738724, -0.01041070930659771, -0.04362174868583679, -0.05710725113749504, 0.024588989093899727, 0.04354598745703697, 0.0035474980250000954, -0.017275122925639153, 0.08095648884773254, -0.019129520282149315, 0.0076799155212938786, 0.033723603934049606, 0.00959126278758049, 0.021702801808714867, 0.012633034959435463, -0.0018028139602392912, 0.01920524425804615, 0.012319888919591904, -0.006769433617591858, 0.0018195243319496512, 0.017347857356071472, 0.037030939012765884, -0.015140165574848652, -0.01982337050139904, 0.029314812272787094, 0.015550418756902218, -0.01989166811108589, -0.0030182749032974243, 0.05409776419401169, -0.02792547456920147, -0.0015490473015233874, 0.015958888456225395, 0.028562195599079132, -0.03811031952500343, -0.004977546166628599, -0.04011250659823418, 0.03687429055571556, 0.021262889727950096, 0.0026062626857310534, -0.024648452177643776, 0.021252665668725967, -0.04767315462231636, 0.024402232840657234, 0.009270603768527508, -0.04414870962500572, -0.03397263586521149, 0.034349214285612106, -0.021007439121603966, -0.010595659725368023, 0.02417006716132164, -0.03797363117337227, -0.015104912221431732, 0.004276481457054615, -0.016637573018670082, -0.0030629229731857777, -0.012071295641362667, -0.04991883784532547, -0.00392218166962266, 0.037785276770591736, -0.028377695009112358, -0.007289358414709568, 0.0175424013286829, -0.06399553269147873, 0.06220380961894989, 0.014011210761964321, -0.02901073358952999, -0.002320528496056795, -0.004503180272877216, 0.029989097267389297, -0.020121362060308456, 0.002553746569901705, 0.01742890290915966, 0.019055169075727463, -0.060616813600063324, -0.029562195762991905, -0.061149682849645615, 0.004673323128372431, -0.04278324916958809, -0.05718601495027542, -0.007136764470487833, -0.0038050212897360325, -0.008108178153634071, 0.0025573705788701773, 0.02100815623998642, -0.018349433317780495, -0.03897201269865036, -0.07849457114934921, 0.039660558104515076, 0.008077355101704597, -0.0022398652508854866, -0.010743480175733566, 0.013277493417263031, 0.08377286791801453, 0.010539895854890347, -0.02506769448518753, -0.044498175382614136, -0.030532313510775566, 0.019008005037903786, -0.05160492658615112, 0.023013275116682053, 0.03303467109799385, 0.009145079180598259, -0.0011471905745565891, -0.0004608641902450472, 0.034416262060403824, 0.027718601748347282, -0.005701785441488028, 0.008000040426850319, -0.0001654182851780206, -0.0033261075150221586, 0.004268025979399681, 0.05162489414215088, 0.01087002269923687, -0.030416427180171013, 0.020609857514500618, -0.006382457911968231, 0.033441878855228424, -0.016910593956708908, -0.0378175750374794, -0.04289873689413071, 0.006952096242457628, -0.00872573908418417, 0.021078214049339294, -0.009737279266119003, 0.012917162850499153, -0.052635300904512405, -0.01191994734108448, 0.02307494916021824, 0.037157922983169556, -0.01640000380575657, 0.020543089136481285, 0.03979694843292236, 0.04521680250763893, -0.02399430237710476, 0.0028834817931056023, -0.01735091395676136, -0.004331388045102358, 0.00011350109707564116, -0.04923304170370102, -0.04031265899538994, 0.009510898031294346, 0.006799492985010147, 0.012985502369701862, 0.024731935933232307, -0.010694027878344059, -0.009045185521245003, -0.07859792560338974, -0.007883273996412754, -0.06111466884613037, 0.061329539865255356, 0.0125571945682168, 0.018407680094242096, 0.007417803630232811, -0.04063711687922478, -0.027455491945147514, -0.020518513396382332, -0.0592835433781147, 0.048033207654953, 0.019734332337975502, 0.031126050278544426, -0.00873295683413744, -0.006409775000065565, 0.01410767063498497, -0.034793511033058167, 0.01173292938619852, 0.04515451937913895, -0.0202033668756485, -0.07087142765522003, 0.00023174543457571417, -0.03641530126333237, -0.0349854975938797, 0.004777729045599699, -0.005196691956371069, 0.06874527782201767, 0.0021682940423488617, 0.024216443300247192, -0.021161163225769997, -0.004139334429055452, 0.033832840621471405, -0.01042693667113781, 0.018127525225281715, -0.013436717912554741, 0.028630392625927925, 0.004093543626368046, 0.034789279103279114, 0.010681616142392159, 0.016361786052584648, -0.0022323643788695335, 0.01968219503760338, 0.03641685098409653, 0.01077790092676878, -0.0038225697353482246, -0.025900300592184067, 0.008631117641925812, 0.03157771751284599, -0.01718372106552124, 0.015545305795967579, 0.019489524886012077, 0.03066716529428959, 0.02240206114947796, 0.012300381436944008, 0.004070672672241926, 0.09643153846263885, 0.019416959956288338, -0.005058010574430227, -0.0083382623270154, 0.010286625474691391, 0.008130171336233616, 0.015304104425013065, 0.025311361998319626, 0.073041632771492, 0.03525067865848541, 0.0142185864970088, 0.0048590898513793945, -0.017786812037229538, -0.06966978311538696, 0.02139049768447876, 0.01222515944391489, 0.04241776466369629, -0.02909868210554123, -0.05750760808587074, 0.021152731031179428, 0.0646679699420929, 0.0353534035384655, -0.007686706259846687, -0.023513179272413254, -0.09280289709568024, 0.00990635622292757, 0.04780180752277374, 0.06583760678768158, 0.017817942425608635, -0.03292432054877281, -0.02258257381618023, -0.0026313720736652613, 0.011094656772911549, -0.03839883580803871, 0.02645866386592388, -0.048240650445222855, -0.01384151354432106, -0.051652245223522186, 0.0004089770372956991, -0.015621896833181381, 0.019369276240468025, -0.06908737868070602, 0.03231623023748398, 0.023673586547374725, -0.038021720945835114, -0.042534295469522476, 0.04289630055427551, 0.024131029844284058, 0.009811565279960632, -0.052746787667274475, -0.011719874106347561, 0.030746150761842728, 0.0015252414159476757, -0.034256983548402786, -0.02216855250298977, 0.05385333299636841, -0.001765294000506401, 0.015189068391919136, 0.03702130168676376, 0.0015590253751724958, 0.030392572283744812, -0.01622157357633114, 0.023283999413251877, -0.003818906843662262, -0.009378173388540745, -0.0314616933465004, 0.021649740636348724, 0.031780753284692764, -0.004219271242618561, 0.011216623708605766, 0.013451817445456982, 0.015077706426382065, -0.01104019582271576, 0.004738354589790106, -0.01615055836737156, -0.010907141491770744, -0.004055792465806007, -0.06081114709377289, 0.004507911391556263, -0.002026751870289445, -0.008805421181023121, -0.006228295154869556, 0.013696042820811272, -0.04596473276615143, -0.016835009679198265, -0.019237695261836052, 0.02880541794002056, -0.014509257860481739, -0.0020911009050905704, -0.023444591090083122, 0.017379557713866234, -0.02226862497627735, 0.004608791787177324, 0.034350328147411346, -0.03736865147948265, 0.008535302244126797, -0.010052219033241272, -0.012331203557550907, 0.06932905316352844, -0.008529041893780231, -0.011042284779250622, 0.008259445428848267, -0.012141716666519642, 0.017446037381887436, 0.017591048032045364, 0.03294263407588005, -0.007078532129526138, -0.02604205161333084, 0.013081745244562626, 0.024585282430052757, -0.014992800541222095, 0.00651289988309145, -0.047223642468452454, 0.05205875262618065, -0.029196498915553093, -0.03533860296010971, -0.04908303543925285, -0.039091385900974274, -0.0009717516368255019, 0.014696910977363586, -0.04395867884159088, -0.023015178740024567, 0.018587283790111542, 0.023460282012820244, 0.017461806535720825, -0.008344472385942936, 0.04667352885007858, -0.047398392111063004, -0.005180220119655132, 0.009883148595690727, 0.029464205726981163, 0.08062390983104706, 0.031188225373625755, -0.00780385872349143, 0.037177473306655884, 0.06921113282442093, -0.003241530153900385, -0.024909503757953644, -0.025219706818461418, -0.01836760900914669, 0.03857412189245224, -0.01325334794819355, -0.019384099170565605, 0.06403186917304993, -0.04087003692984581, 0.006482688244432211, 0.0026541617698967457, 0.010935144498944283, -0.014771689660847187, -0.03982144966721535, -0.015053460374474525, 0.009033224545419216, 0.03688206896185875, -0.04245811700820923, -0.012495964765548706, -0.029269235208630562, 0.009692416526377201, 0.0033211640547960997, -0.022430360317230225, -0.004741032142192125, 0.023824239149689674, 0.012925718910992146, 0.006944055203348398, -0.024530308321118355, 0.03297834098339081, 0.014391202479600906, 0.06867754459381104, -0.0016150041483342648, -0.01091848500072956, -0.008418363519012928, 0.022839711979031563, -0.03135206922888756, -0.03316201642155647, -0.018975112587213516, -0.005926102865487337, 0.053094711154699326, 0.021840564906597137, 0.03644290566444397, 0.0628025010228157, -0.0005388796562328935, 0.011072184890508652, 0.025977322831749916, -0.014747836627066135, -0.024729039520025253, 0.019904805347323418, 0.0393042154610157, -0.03467776998877525, -0.0275802593678236, 0.03175259381532669, -0.013734282925724983, 0.021209092810750008, 0.05210090056061745, 0.0390581451356411, -0.006027694791555405, 0.031494349241256714, -0.020992515608668327, 0.0004685574385803193, 0.006064293906092644, -0.0269281305372715, -0.0034986715763807297, -0.04019654169678688, -0.030581174418330193, 0.025838559493422508, 0.037171900272369385, -0.023204654455184937, -0.007745764218270779, -0.054148927330970764, -0.08066775649785995, 0.029784390702843666, 0.023881960660219193, -0.0009318122174590826, 0.06404469907283783, 0.010328305885195732, 0.03732043877243996, -0.017060911282896996, 0.019657397642731667, -0.009502938017249107, -0.051505811512470245, 0.03180856630206108, -0.039978135377168655, -0.06898491084575653, 0.019196201115846634, 0.01822027377784252, 0.006986311636865139, 0.009362741373479366, 0.0035250624641776085, -0.010296282358467579, 0.014488309621810913, 0.03443777561187744, -0.010735901072621346, 0.09059351682662964, -0.008335525169968605, 0.0023149556946009398, -0.04425537958741188, -0.013484321534633636, 0.11502975225448608, 0.06817957758903503, 0.040311042219400406, -0.030855262652039528, 0.023677874356508255, 0.021083390340209007, 0.004472540691494942, -0.039883725345134735, -0.0029588399920612574, 0.022188132628798485, -0.02762848138809204, 0.039511870592832565, 0.03802521899342537, 0.007492686156183481, 0.014807207509875298, 0.05025584623217583, -0.05418137088418007, 0.0037700103130191565, 0.02143840864300728, 0.013802220113575459, 0.0027657554019242525, -0.03512825071811676, -0.08348946273326874, 0.01171556394547224, 0.019492173567414284, -0.04177023842930794, -0.012233632616698742, 0.000495504355058074, 0.009150577709078789, 0.03569917380809784, 0.03490377962589264, 0.03650715947151184, 0.04993278905749321, 0.020878735929727554, 0.006855524145066738, -0.02378551848232746, 0.05264550447463989, -0.019499758258461952, 0.020375214517116547, 0.023088892921805382, 0.018263233825564384, -0.012714785523712635, -0.027798645198345184, 0.021002234891057014, -0.04091915488243103, -0.02556956186890602, -0.024879198521375656, 0.005186066497117281, -0.02744670957326889, -0.00871262326836586, -0.003973880782723427, -0.021540621295571327, 0.010850715450942516, -0.04655994847416878, -0.05835605785250664, 0.039802927523851395, 0.02449178136885166, -0.034214217215776443, -0.01330158393830061, -0.03655560314655304, -0.0030125926714390516, -0.013468638062477112, 0.024256708100438118, 0.02939777635037899, -0.02037656120955944, 0.0030833168420940638, -0.047324877232313156, -0.004617038648575544, -0.026820287108421326, -0.0225549153983593, 0.017475195229053497, -0.0230190958827734, -0.03933293744921684, -0.005853875540196896, 0.020761800929903984, 0.010202120058238506, 0.009940030984580517, -0.01911335252225399, -0.016682272776961327, 0.0140420226380229, 0.004186192527413368, -0.002795419655740261, -0.024427790194749832, -0.011906071566045284, -0.018761953338980675, -0.00272498675622046, 0.06799639016389847, -0.0033136713318526745, 0.015004395507276058, -0.006533572915941477, -0.02827990986406803, 0.05527256056666374, 0.06863487511873245, -0.016596853733062744, -0.05657558515667915, -0.011842699721455574, -0.04351337254047394, -0.009921758435666561, 0.006335671059787273, 0.04454338178038597, 0.022351253777742386, -0.005604185163974762, 0.02920270524919033, -0.013893214985728264, -0.06267572939395905, 0.015339791774749756, 0.0523294061422348, -0.06277861446142197, -0.017883548513054848, 0.01597379520535469, -0.024804921820759773, -0.005334437824785709, -0.04945966228842735, -0.029961861670017242, -0.008824724704027176, 0.0023977349046617746, -0.04642428457736969, -0.03326333686709404, 0.03903656080365181, -0.03401240333914757, -0.004721188917756081, 0.046878766268491745, 0.04563761129975319, -0.04790332168340683, -0.023365207016468048, 0.020465075969696045, 0.008322962559759617, -0.011787150986492634, 0.04431239888072014, -0.021573813632130623, -0.028369512408971786, 0.025422535836696625, 0.01888977736234665, 0.025847094133496284, -0.015371467918157578, -0.024915819987654686, -0.025927841663360596, 0.01413495559245348, -0.010863804258406162, -0.0550089031457901, 0.022209981456398964, -0.03629104793071747, 0.035430893301963806, -0.0015749416779726744, -0.012342904694378376, 0.019672028720378876, -0.017725735902786255, -0.013254101388156414, -0.0030615348368883133, 0.047453373670578, -0.01971590518951416, 0.018282871693372726, 0.017051024362444878, 0.02089047245681286, 0.04900883883237839, 0.013142270967364311, -0.020867301151156425, 0.030216043815016747, -0.009521466679871082, 0.005159465596079826, 0.03883804753422737, 0.05958696827292442, 0.0120141776278615, -0.01952795684337616, -0.011877868324518204, -0.018404480069875717, 0.005838707089424133, -0.0037407486233860254, 0.06070361286401749, 0.049833573400974274, -0.032650768756866455, 0.0175748560577631, 0.006936513353139162, 0.022876519709825516, -0.034245844930410385, -0.028936097398400307, 0.021526385098695755, 0.020983440801501274, 0.017505478113889694, -0.017596706748008728, 0.0008925776346586645, -0.039177872240543365, -0.03722028061747551, 0.018744882196187973, -0.04252876341342926, -0.0394490547478199, -0.039362214505672455, 0.0395265556871891, -0.015962934121489525, -0.003208168549463153, 0.039509959518909454, 0.024080850183963776, 0.048665449023246765, -0.007650382351130247, -0.017535801976919174, -0.06332847476005554, -0.03788698464632034, 0.023191925138235092, 0.0292085912078619, -0.05479423701763153, 0.036314334720373154, -0.033554185181856155, -0.016068022698163986, 0.0351046584546566, -0.03931330889463425, 0.004689596127718687, 0.009573784656822681, 0.03939271345734596, 0.02487853355705738, 0.049968741834163666, 0.029141929000616074, -0.004213987849652767, -0.013220792636275291, -0.011176057159900665, -0.01213222835212946, 0.0012644921662285924, -0.026056280359625816, 0.028364554047584534, 0.015408583916723728, 0.00024786341236904263, 0.02283928170800209, 0.010830126702785492, -0.004936241079121828, -0.004403132013976574, -0.018096720799803734, 0.023869553580880165, 0.04984297603368759, -0.014901603572070599, 0.007352592423558235, 0.00607139989733696, 0.02547302469611168, 0.05229391157627106, 0.012843885459005833, -0.022899040952324867, -0.0013932909350842237, -0.028127159923315048, -0.06231320649385452, 0.031130867078900337, -0.007115010637789965, -0.025184310972690582, -0.04983136057853699, -0.003537016222253442, 0.0028592159505933523, 0.025302017107605934, -0.032425254583358765, -0.006709264125674963, -0.002594382967799902, 0.043085988610982895, 0.019714249297976494, -0.004526169970631599, 0.009007048793137074, 0.015724459663033485, 0.06301113963127136, -0.09556743502616882, 0.06882438063621521, 0.03588389977812767, 0.02931101806461811, -0.039169859141111374, -0.037638258188962936, -0.008553188294172287, 0.006150410044938326, 0.060358867049217224, -0.0597749762237072, -0.007078579161316156, -0.015248007141053677, 0.030371561646461487, 0.0037480283062905073, -0.02860022336244583, 0.04739975556731224, -0.0037799838464707136, -0.01609603501856327, 0.02653782069683075, 0.0015036737313494086, 0.022320495918393135, -0.014640768058598042, 0.010097716934978962, -0.007746296934783459, -0.06147849187254906, -0.008797230198979378, -0.027969419956207275, 0.01668931543827057, 0.022356031462550163, 0.01044673565775156, 0.05258221924304962, 0.023530879989266396, 0.010091297328472137, 0.04504065215587616, 0.013973364606499672, -0.02264106273651123, 0.05881029739975929, -0.06457199901342392, 0.007725294679403305, 0.015404907986521721, -0.020129907876253128, -0.0003069680533371866, -0.06706609576940536, -0.01114851888269186, 0.025951962918043137, 0.02545846998691559, 0.02229280211031437, 0.041640520095825195, -0.0020796149037778378, 0.03931054100394249, 0.001417154329828918, 0.024845771491527557, -0.00698174349963665, -0.019795270636677742, 0.008375710807740688, 0.004734535235911608, 0.007368536200374365, 0.009059612639248371, -0.03261404111981392, 0.023764872923493385, -0.013702087104320526, 0.009595347568392754, -0.04539274424314499, 0.059797678142786026, -0.026485778391361237, 0.020352277904748917, -0.01902240701019764, -0.021249156445264816, 0.00903243012726307, 0.03538670763373375, -0.023486141115427017, 0.016127487644553185, -0.048570748418569565, 0.01868867687880993, -0.045023832470178604, 0.01872093416750431, -0.04654989764094353, 0.014978212304413319, 0.01583542674779892, -0.030869314447045326, -0.030173921957612038, 0.03486767038702965, 0.01875951513648033, 0.011277587153017521, 0.0009773832280188799, -0.02133934758603573, -0.013374771922826767, -0.020130282267928123, 0.02331106923520565, 0.05058496445417404, -0.034843139350414276, -0.02032863162457943, -0.0231520663946867, -0.0034318494144827127, 0.04811600595712662, 0.006698162294924259, -0.050159286707639694, -0.00582698592916131, -0.0073031834326684475, -0.0030465491581708193, -0.06182205677032471, -0.010208306834101677, -0.04068291187286377, 0.0188407301902771, 0.03196112811565399, -0.023255756124854088 ]
<p>Has the idea of a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_entropy_probability_distribution" rel="nofollow">maximum entropy probability distribution</a> been explored for function spaces, and if so what are some key papers, books, or terms to look for?</p> <p>For $\mathbb{R}^n$ (and discrete spaces), the problem appears to be well studied - one maximizes the quantity, $$-\int f(x) ~ log f(x) ~ dx,$$ over the set of feasible candidate densities $f$, where the integral is taken with respect to the standard Lebesgue measure in $\mathbb{R}^n$ or counting measure in discrete spaces. There seems to be much literature about this problem which goes under names such as "non-informative priors", "maximum entropy distributions", "Jeffrey's priors", and the like.</p> <p>However, I've found little on this topic in the infinite dimensional (function space) setting. Can concept of maximum entropy priors be generalized to function spaces, or is the idea of entropy fundamentally incompatible with infinite dimensional space?</p> <p>Note: this thread wasn't getting answers here so I <a href="http://mathoverflow.net/questions/109671/maximum-entropy-priors-in-infinite-dimensional-spaces" rel="nofollow">reposted at mathoverflow</a>.</p>
74,213
[ -0.014157051220536232, 0.011810250580310822, 0.036814332008361816, -0.015445861034095287, 0.009175538085401058, 0.029658861458301544, -0.009109285660088062, -0.02591496892273426, 0.0035533823538571596, -0.04522879794239998, 0.029944760724902153, 0.035019680857658386, 0.06490542739629745, 0.016653407365083694, 0.013852035626769066, -0.019883811473846436, -0.0745568498969078, 0.02109912596642971, -0.02683023177087307, -0.016182836145162582, -0.016943033784627914, 0.07175332307815552, 0.030692536383867264, -0.039030034095048904, -0.046253614127635956, 0.009831288829445839, 0.006410854868590832, 0.028367584571242332, 0.009679561480879784, 0.08148254454135895, 0.0021424356382340193, -0.0016852450789883733, 0.021782850846648216, 0.08689109981060028, -0.0013360249577090144, -0.007969887927174568, -0.03511001542210579, -0.0032699843868613243, -0.023828405886888504, 0.01679486781358719, -0.0515536367893219, -0.044153470546007156, 0.009030451066792011, 0.01201082207262516, -0.022189950570464134, 0.025383690372109413, -0.00353434425778687, -0.047868289053440094, 0.013644191436469555, -0.06545030325651169, 0.05637247860431671, 0.004746000282466412, 0.018342116847634315, 0.043070629239082336, -0.0060691810213029385, -0.0071447161026299, 0.05206936225295067, 0.09524843841791153, 0.022246183827519417, -0.05224724858999252, -0.0402153842151165, -0.038692716509103775, 0.006383548490703106, -0.033097244799137115, -0.041748903691768646, 0.04807421937584877, -0.0033353911712765694, 0.0006941037718206644, 0.02287396788597107, 0.01536232978105545, -0.016970360651612282, 0.03083069436252117, 0.036404725164175034, -0.007967264391481876, 0.005165628623217344, 0.02198735810816288, 0.02814253233373165, -0.014090473763644695, 0.05418378859758377, 0.027159664779901505, 0.0008664967026561499, 0.004967674612998962, 0.01238603238016367, 0.03277544677257538, 0.008286023512482643, -0.00939891580492258, 0.07491466403007507, -0.007898860611021519, 0.0012258710339665413, 0.02860611490905285, -0.037752993404865265, -0.032721877098083496, 0.015217525884509087, -0.02393641695380211, -0.06345440447330475, 0.08147412538528442, -0.02335532195866108, 0.02708110772073269, -0.0067926072515547276, -0.05321912840008736, -0.007393506821244955, -0.021217504516243935, -0.016012724488973618, 0.062436290085315704, -0.03620654344558716, 0.006546023767441511, -0.04481383413076401, 0.024075638502836227, -0.009684200398623943, -0.008884568698704243, -0.050761934369802475, 0.029379641637206078, 0.021539174020290375, 0.011991412378847599, 0.014444258064031601, -0.00235857255756855, 0.011548209004104137, -0.04895671457052231, 0.06941498816013336, 0.09529980272054672, 0.03428728133440018, -0.008057489059865475, 0.03143880516290665, -0.03483754023909569, -0.059505023062229156, 0.007600417360663414, 0.024079427123069763, 0.004645020235329866, -0.02148669958114624, 0.05373801663517952, -0.019370632246136665, 0.014204197563230991, 0.053573090583086014, 0.010288791730999947, 0.022864125669002533, -0.035232096910476685, -0.057762596756219864, -0.017831189557909966, 0.04173174500465393, -0.01461891457438469, -0.01643965020775795, -0.05595920607447624, -0.010765640065073967, 0.027433328330516815, 0.04898476228117943, -0.007055444642901421, 0.046700458973646164, 0.0340932160615921, 0.039438728243112564, -0.0016189696034416556, -0.014605498872697353, -0.029586749151349068, 0.007622983306646347, 0.003526240587234497, -0.00353814335539937, -0.035936351865530014, 0.025029381737113, 0.02855137176811695, -0.010324259288609028, -0.023410508409142494, 0.03751547262072563, -0.0020113515201956034, -0.023752527311444283, -0.02574385330080986, 0.02488410286605358, -0.03092673048377037, 0.07627837359905243, 0.03349395468831062, 0.047191619873046875, 0.01575149968266487, 0.01255896408110857, 0.017491253092885017, 0.038586948066949844, 0.02152804285287857, 0.04406406357884407, -0.027849584817886353, -0.03319256752729416, -0.01196115743368864, 0.03120286762714386, 0.02167125791311264, 0.01522953249514103, 0.024502266198396683, -0.034750405699014664, -0.026515962556004524, -0.00739147188141942, 0.004209539853036404, 0.010122614912688732, -0.025447964668273926, 0.02646739035844803, -0.056740276515483856, -0.0011692545376718044, -0.05612095817923546, 0.007397129200398922, 0.0012096159625798464, -0.01122558768838644, 0.04723494127392769, -0.03612673282623291, 0.01720159500837326, -0.024792872369289398, -0.022368917241692543, -0.03502069413661957, -0.023271027952432632, 0.023186776787042618, -0.020790062844753265, 0.008875162340700626, 0.016606636345386505, 0.03174780309200287, -0.015370401553809643, 0.011967342346906662, -0.016589222475886345, -0.07176416367292404, -0.015286210924386978, -0.039996977895498276, 0.026519082486629486, -0.011995670385658741, -0.024827048182487488, 0.02433444932103157, 0.015171516686677933, -0.011887844651937485, -0.010605765506625175, -0.048008061945438385, 0.03776438161730766, 0.04093177616596222, 0.028158484026789665, -0.02645731344819069, 0.020204724743962288, 0.007273698225617409, 0.0037550232373178005, 0.006627102382481098, -0.031510982662439346, -0.053624700754880905, -0.010958242230117321, 0.04377378523349762, 0.07149557024240494, -0.043968457728624344, 0.014989684335887432, 0.017900904640555382, 0.010595545172691345, 0.02589702047407627, 0.021757597103714943, -0.027430498972535133, -0.04330042749643326, 0.0054630436934530735, -0.02175005152821541, 0.00863264687359333, -0.023833580315113068, 0.03936091065406799, -0.013717705383896828, 0.04853358492255211, 0.004257602617144585, -0.011688672006130219, 0.021555498242378235, -0.03723382577300072, 0.02065485529601574, -0.005743881221860647, -0.008061278611421585, 0.0033335608895868063, -0.012843878008425236, -0.018482021987438202, -0.009927233681082726, 0.02292490378022194, 0.020115889608860016, -0.028111489489674568, 0.0043672602623701096, 0.007959108799695969, 0.021435566246509552, -0.04802801460027695, -0.0026333334390074015, 0.007539717014878988, -0.026399921625852585, 0.0016121986554935575, -0.004014533944427967, -0.007140719797462225, -0.008539559319615364, -0.0004934397293254733, 0.03022993542253971, -0.0406402088701725, -0.01745256595313549, 0.006603357382118702, -0.020342344418168068, 0.0006894904654473066, -0.005334923043847084, 0.04094366729259491, 0.002171382773667574, -0.0501791313290596, -0.003492656396701932, -0.0360821895301342, -0.012964652851223946, 0.022262854501605034, -0.03488840535283089, 0.034412432461977005, -0.010896261781454086, -0.02597116492688656, -0.04694841429591179, -0.006153858732432127, -0.010161885060369968, 0.04859417676925659, -0.01238886546343565, 0.031531382352113724, 0.036952827125787735, -0.009074420668184757, -0.04626961052417755, 0.012879569083452225, -0.039174482226371765, -0.06890056282281876, -0.04788992926478386, 0.007988839410245419, 0.02513156272470951, 0.00007100408402038738, 0.024292295798659325, 0.009393483400344849, -0.04710765182971954, -0.005203973036259413, -0.06505928188562393, -0.07001487910747528, 0.02933495119214058, -0.0006701457896269858, 0.0494481585919857, -0.021209275349974632, -0.003069155151024461, 0.02598493918776512, 0.04371444508433342, -0.06725803017616272, -0.01871470920741558, 0.0011992790969088674, 0.0010600733803585172, 0.003437511157244444, -0.022036653012037277, 0.017019623890519142, -0.017942268401384354, 0.05362751707434654, 0.016675982624292374, -0.01072749774903059, 0.011101098731160164, -0.005225669126957655, -0.010374629870057106, 0.02897179126739502, 0.013157129287719727, 0.004484924953430891, 0.008658294565975666, 0.036193277686834335, -0.030865490436553955, 0.021468032151460648, 0.005497731734067202, -0.01914338394999504, 0.003303531091660261, -0.007753749843686819, 0.041613198816776276, 0.0032666195183992386, 0.001509093213826418, -0.06129897013306618, 0.01284070685505867, -0.016454435884952545, -0.005671887658536434, -0.008676707744598389, 0.026123518124222755, 0.015120423398911953, -0.01032522413879633, 0.033043622970581055, 0.017606893554329872, 0.03398693725466728, -0.04225106164813042, 0.017219020053744316, -0.04395979642868042, 0.017004767432808876, 0.02511266991496086, -0.007281142752617598, -0.01839904673397541, 0.009575072675943375, 0.040251225233078, 0.005246124230325222, -0.03050878643989563, -0.015175437554717064, 0.014334426261484623, -0.05202711373567581, -0.014384056441485882, -0.006650247611105442, 0.046190161257982254, 0.024597616866230965, 0.02937181293964386, 0.018021268770098686, 0.000947694992646575, -0.009068113751709461, 0.015091093257069588, -0.09595576673746109, -0.016628315672278404, -0.027973731979727745, 0.015567793510854244, -0.03052636981010437, -0.018595853820443153, 0.04380543902516365, -0.01326062623411417, -0.014846847392618656, -0.016903728246688843, 0.013787122443318367, -0.07203811407089233, 0.005166149698197842, -0.039830755442380905, -0.02265259250998497, -0.011645356193184853, 0.030603760853409767, 0.036927901208400726, -0.023234155029058456, 0.03663548082113266, 0.02389899641275406, -0.03704904764890671, -0.001318818423897028, 0.008632493205368519, 0.04119952768087387, -0.009120192378759384, 0.0343342199921608, -0.013931751251220703, 0.05881628394126892, -0.0051405904814600945, 0.05413828045129776, 0.007751199882477522, 0.07181141525506973, 0.018154283985495567, -0.050649527460336685, -0.02322697825729847, -0.02257237769663334, 0.0005399768706411123, -0.0021919209975749254, 0.030572133138775826, 0.019438598304986954, 0.005321959499269724, 0.03384365886449814, 0.010531521402299404, -0.03860243782401085, -0.01702721416950226, 0.045161765068769455, -0.014424744062125683, -0.019413921982049942, 0.008077398873865604, -0.01672104187309742, -0.016260940581560135, -0.011877353303134441, 0.01932281069457531, 0.009154253639280796, -0.012502194382250309, 0.01680547371506691, 0.004992721602320671, 0.01294712070375681, -0.033170975744724274, -0.03288951888680458, 0.035557013005018234, 0.01902609132230282, 0.01182652823626995, -0.02570752613246441, 0.024854840710759163, -0.010162407532334328, 0.04368389770388603, 0.021339967846870422, -0.0024153848644346, -0.05032706260681152, 0.00270484178327024, 0.03392232581973076, 0.030238229781389236, 0.0037720007821917534, 0.029942234978079796, -0.028849441558122635, -0.03208545222878456, 0.07183392345905304, 0.009663766250014305, 0.00698936078697443, -0.02725975774228573, -0.011962120421230793, -0.015598710626363754, -0.031820882111787796, -0.02302616648375988, -0.0046190121211111546, 0.03800700232386589, 0.0074446965008974075, -0.015784986317157745, 0.01473449170589447, -0.0200022105127573, 0.014254888519644737, -0.022605618461966515, 0.0600777268409729, -0.00033593527041375637, -0.0019207559525966644, 0.016938062384724617, 0.016229314729571342, -0.007412159349769354, -0.05698274448513985, 0.042540293186903, 0.011627851985394955, -0.024879347532987595, 0.019686179235577583, -0.009533224627375603, -0.04609958827495575, 0.05456360802054405, -0.005334828048944473, -0.024059351533651352, 0.04621558636426926, -0.0023810549173504114, 0.05102633312344551, 0.04882388561964035, 0.013592916540801525, 0.05933987349271774, 0.042333826422691345, 0.027826525270938873, 0.015904409810900688, -0.020851686596870422, 0.04499930515885353, -0.029028572142124176, -0.01584783010184765, -0.0387856587767601, 0.0011650556698441505, -0.019811732694506645, 0.04587940871715546, 0.013187986798584461, 0.027454087510704994, -0.03159645199775696, -0.01373382844030857, -0.00011659823940135539, 0.029593242332339287, 0.005304780788719654, -0.0022304102312773466, 0.006440302357077599, 0.03192036598920822, -0.0010503623634576797, 0.006975050084292889, -0.008351866155862808, 0.018621357157826424, 0.014179556630551815, 0.020845133811235428, -0.04276849702000618, 0.005388464313000441, -0.04742444306612015, -0.03710676729679108, 0.033475566655397415, 0.0012213930021971464, 0.03043573535978794, 0.006802952382713556, 0.010066932998597622, 0.00928636733442545, -0.0564412884414196, -0.0002493336796760559, 0.0004634748911485076, -0.015414275228977203, 0.03611352667212486, -0.04386060684919357, 0.026089489459991455, -0.009463593363761902, 0.027209127321839333, -0.05998282879590988, -0.015669792890548706, -0.01606570929288864, -0.0014557777903974056, -0.034734949469566345, -0.06262917816638947, 0.028553497046232224, -0.019338808953762054, -0.004385523032397032, 0.0044135283678770065, 0.012862587347626686, 0.002528302138671279, -0.017507564276456833, 0.0053633120842278, 0.050927627831697464, 0.02769835852086544, -0.010795996524393559, -0.006720783654600382, 0.027458326891064644, -0.008257809095084667, -0.009631245397031307, -0.0073178717866539955, 0.02884620800614357, -0.020255407318472862, 0.007837592624127865, -0.014451969414949417, 0.016600988805294037, 0.02355084754526615, -0.021259237080812454, -0.03287549316883087, 0.04348697513341904, 0.002523395698517561, 0.013452132232487202, 0.00484816450625658, -0.02479531243443489, -0.030003458261489868, -0.019854536280035973, -0.015776891261339188, -0.0024593458510935307, -0.02374158427119255, -0.040825922042131424, 0.05274422839283943, -0.012266787700355053, 0.019072312861680984, 0.0028734763618558645, 0.019551675766706467, -0.01722198724746704, 0.0030615150462836027, -0.0022398605942726135, -0.004150651395320892, 0.02269565872848034, -0.032448433339595795, 0.01158348098397255, 0.0032044120598584414, 0.010525324381887913, -0.03876517340540886, -0.046562034636735916, -0.03938869759440422, 0.017803004011511803, 0.0329245962202549, -0.015913713723421097, 0.0378696508705616, 0.015663402155041695, -0.0066504813730716705, -0.022361835464835167, -0.04200640320777893, -0.013565817847847939, 0.04420880600810051, 0.009841574355959892, 0.04299772530794144, -0.017665745690464973, -0.005331205204129219, 0.009229177609086037, -0.026945114135742188, -0.0012085351627320051, 0.018843375146389008, -0.007104719057679176, 0.04180067405104637, 0.05522959679365158, -0.05811648070812225, -0.03288941830396652, 0.04607922211289406, -0.06760937720537186, 0.019189421087503433, -0.018385475501418114, -0.040229812264442444, 0.012905634939670563, 0.003890357445925474, 0.01584511809051037, -0.05551062524318695, -0.03236839175224304, -0.02485594153404236, 0.013472736813127995, 0.01866651512682438, 0.019215939566493034, 0.04778280109167099, -0.04670887067914009, 0.010190015658736229, 0.0000031477318316319725, 0.012365502305328846, 0.009354701265692711, -0.09409554302692413, -0.0247817300260067, -0.023553788661956787, -0.0581061951816082, -0.008895670995116234, 0.03127969056367874, -0.02011110633611679, 0.01074567623436451, -0.021430132910609245, 0.03767132759094238, 0.02570524625480175, 0.03249047324061394, -0.03654381260275841, 0.103575199842453, -0.013610179536044598, 0.04171843081712723, -0.049459394067525864, 0.01619122549891472, 0.1095120906829834, 0.0771934911608696, 0.034148797392845154, -0.09610298275947571, -0.002055833116173744, -0.0014545356389135122, -0.015861742198467255, -0.036791153252124786, 0.03530308976769447, 0.029540663585066795, -0.024334266781806946, 0.005040925461798906, 0.05609424039721489, 0.01845630258321762, -0.02898203767836094, 0.049851249903440475, -0.05968888849020004, -0.03719488903880119, 0.04216498136520386, -0.007203505374491215, 0.0064949775114655495, 0.008474541828036308, -0.044939879328012466, 0.016952473670244217, 0.0285041481256485, -0.009115737862884998, -0.029848825186491013, -0.018470795825123787, 0.009114351123571396, 0.005933716427534819, 0.008290890604257584, -0.05675331875681877, 0.01800983026623726, -0.017320573329925537, 0.013795669190585613, -0.029999148100614548, 0.010028756223618984, 0.008166397921741009, 0.012408644892275333, 0.007596194744110107, 0.024070415645837784, 0.020850900560617447, 0.005216000601649284, 0.007044506259262562, -0.044638823717832565, -0.050551608204841614, -0.030358513817191124, 0.024607772007584572, -0.042712800204753876, 0.011984473094344139, -0.010900935158133507, 0.0000976490046014078, -0.0018199147889390588, -0.018034853041172028, -0.003332371124997735, -0.0006062426255084574, 0.08797003328800201, 0.03536784276366234, -0.02093557082116604, -0.004306231625378132, 0.023431165143847466, -0.01131624635308981, 0.04997720569372177, -0.02115650475025177, -0.04337000101804733, 0.0018262690864503384, -0.01487724483013153, 0.0337047204375267, -0.0033337348140776157, 0.019341982901096344, -0.024407921358942986, -0.00324687990359962, -0.0036776273045688868, -0.035441093146800995, -0.017154749482870102, -0.040842559188604355, 0.04178962484002113, 0.016016630455851555, 0.005575687158852816, -0.019836416468024254, -0.030798953026533127, 0.009526186622679234, -0.041610557585954666, 0.002049348084256053, -0.01871945522725582, 0.0062888250686228275, 0.04610256105661392, 0.02755693718791008, 0.04556483030319214, -0.021040039137005806, -0.022240417078137398, 0.007249033078551292, 0.0237030778080225, -0.02814614586532116, -0.002664849627763033, -0.017544696107506752, -0.03277154639363289, 0.007336658891290426, -0.02122926525771618, 0.027384191751480103, 0.019649717956781387, 0.05314014479517937, 0.033408261835575104, 0.015470755286514759, -0.010830700397491455, 0.006495376583188772, -0.03159606456756592, -0.05436321720480919, -0.02716817893087864, 0.00029980475665070117, 0.025739826261997223, -0.038805488497018814, -0.034914735704660416, -0.013633007183670998, 0.03255161643028259, 0.02811196818947792, 0.01056191697716713, -0.03397519886493683, -0.021670321002602577, 0.015000087209045887, 0.030878370627760887, 0.009730842895805836, -0.020378800109028816, 0.007793217897415161, 0.012184753082692623, -0.03579699620604515, 0.021616213023662567, -0.03321213647723198, 0.0032392479479312897, -0.026572581380605698, -0.05010748654603958, -0.007990524172782898, -0.004980012774467468, -0.01861671544611454, -0.001168153597973287, 0.004376723896712065, -0.004798969719558954, 0.05060037225484848, -0.03301679342985153, 0.016941428184509277, 0.030728928744792938, -0.06295864284038544, -0.05149727314710617, -0.0213673934340477, -0.007681252900511026, 0.026789702475070953, 0.028308838605880737, 0.03400636091828346, -0.05270613729953766, 0.03617186099290848, -0.009578274562954903, 0.01375249307602644, 0.023550868034362793, 0.004643092397600412, -0.000004919142156722955, -0.011841381900012493, 0.011079114861786366, -0.024519167840480804, -0.003815253032371402, 0.008689440786838531, 0.030614148825407028, 0.011856265366077423, -0.024241041392087936, 0.06008811667561531, -0.037572529166936874, 0.021708965301513672, 0.001043333439156413, -0.017568089067935944, 0.04217581823468208, 0.04223548248410225, -0.027668079361319542, 0.0598188191652298, 0.010979224927723408, 0.00107344810385257, -0.12005330622196198, -0.002998508745804429, 0.02611272782087326, 0.01709739677608013, 0.05320011079311371, -0.03445536270737648, 0.01347052026540041, 0.021647470071911812, -0.05792512372136116, 0.042225949466228485, -0.033369001001119614, -0.01816653646528721, -0.0568743534386158, 0.018176648765802383, -0.04199625179171562, 0.019003894180059433, 0.05017038434743881, 0.03807510808110237, 0.04715823754668236, 0.0190352164208889, -0.027353942394256592, 0.013716139830648899, -0.001791678019799292, 0.01816663332283497, 0.017525704577565193, -0.0280184093862772, 0.09636818617582321, -0.030415860936045647, -0.029187850654125214, 0.0261798445135355, 0.021544666960835457, 0.007492564152926207, -0.0061861309222877026, 0.033408280462026596, 0.023800740018486977, 0.04956929385662079, 0.0563809871673584, -0.007935509085655212, 0.012478743679821491, 0.02254166081547737, 0.024593288078904152, -0.0009308612789027393, -0.022476542741060257, -0.005210941657423973, 0.017051879316568375, -0.0013238288229331374, -0.037869229912757874, 0.007643683813512325, 0.005125770345330238, -0.03749513998627663, 0.022437015548348427, -0.015770593658089638, 0.008342825807631016, 0.0021801816765218973, 0.024992188438773155, -0.03340603783726692, -0.031135091558098793, 0.019045526161789894, -0.0011295658769086003, 0.00871977861970663, -0.00650758296251297, -0.025973418727517128, -0.06524594128131866, 0.018154608085751534, -0.0049309320747852325, 0.019098002463579178, -0.05983094871044159, -0.01049503218382597, 0.010115429759025574, -0.005562853999435902, 0.004612041171640158, -0.025854844599962234, -0.07043751329183578, 0.003565439721569419, -0.020172465592622757, 0.023603780195116997, 0.02111990936100483, -0.03252202644944191, -0.04995153099298477, -0.09356509149074554, 0.06464659422636032, -0.0006648540729656816, 0.01815682277083397, -0.004441901110112667, -0.0020064201671630144, 0.005630407948046923, -0.03480379283428192, 0.062402237206697464, 0.0025498531758785248, -0.011680778115987778, 0.000508428958710283, 0.039506349712610245, 0.05446697399020195, -0.0044698212295770645, 0.011591067537665367, -0.016635756939649582, -0.02453179657459259, -0.0244474895298481, 0.016913237050175667, 0.047811359167099, -0.008205422200262547, 0.02323097549378872, -0.025399181991815567, -0.026356087997555733, -0.005778472870588303, -0.018720705062150955, 0.04281480610370636, 0.013642205856740475, -0.018513251096010208, 0.004645256325602531, -0.026416447013616562, 0.0423763133585453, -0.017159193754196167, 0.023472148925065994, -0.02271150052547455, -0.00046930837561376393, -0.014179667457938194, -0.03132575377821922, 0.005834496114403009, 0.02247222140431404, 0.00955082569271326, -0.02315502054989338, -0.04008865728974342, 0.05024250969290733, -0.06296729296445847, -0.0039059787523001432, 0.057373493909835815, 0.02479393407702446, 0.07588829845190048, 0.024350302293896675, 0.011670478619635105, 0.022088030353188515, 0.006149917375296354, -0.03510696813464165, 0.023407673463225365, 0.04138366878032684, -0.017999878153204918, -0.013424483127892017, 0.024801772087812424, -0.03648004308342934, 0.034877534955739975, 0.007030815817415714, 0.07674461603164673, -0.08342038094997406, -0.030949197709560394, 0.0016816325951367617, -0.011945685371756554, 0.00654438603669405, -0.005588887259364128, -0.018571684136986732, 0.07805802673101425, 0.006026844028383493, 0.02682073973119259, -0.04298210144042969, -0.03553314879536629, -0.017799530178308487, 0.0036851647309958935, -0.013453401625156403, 0.047567907720804214, 0.023075900971889496, 0.03558015450835228, -0.010837802663445473, 0.023060616105794907, 0.02879844233393669, -0.01885594241321087, 0.019045323133468628, -0.013028709217905998, -0.011754651553928852, 0.02126319147646427, -0.02774796262383461, -0.03421776741743088, -0.020817333832383156, -0.016333308070898056, 0.08695615828037262, 0.04898805543780327, -0.024385938420891762, -0.03627330809831619, -0.027963737025856972, 0.06571134179830551, -0.0637209489941597, 0.02049853838980198, -0.04777979850769043, -0.006391291506588459, 0.01493001077324152, 0.0011806600959971547 ]
<p>Let $p$ be some probability distribution with a density $f$.</p> <p>$p$ is defined over $\Omega$.</p> <p>Is it true that for any $\omega \in \Omega$, $p(\omega) = 0$?</p> <p>If not, what are the "minimal conditions" under which $p(\omega) = 0$ for any $\omega$ (the space $\Omega$ is actually a subset of $\mathbb{R}^d$ for some $d$)?</p>
36,953
[ -0.010260388255119324, -0.0048453230410814285, 0.033363789319992065, -0.045790862292051315, 0.012508871033787727, 0.020760444924235344, -0.026410572230815887, -0.014251906424760818, 0.013891293667256832, -0.06852693855762482, 0.010770556516945362, 0.011572045274078846, 0.0578162856400013, 0.015854310244321823, 0.005772733129560947, -0.030243074521422386, -0.03773009404540062, 0.015563503839075565, -0.03488995507359505, -0.014319328591227531, -0.006014995742589235, 0.05759467929601669, 0.06847849488258362, -0.01665567420423031, -0.025089344009757042, 0.013334553688764572, -0.0013378335861489177, 0.023058807477355003, 0.02999502792954445, 0.057478539645671844, -0.05479324236512184, -0.011579575948417187, 0.002732045017182827, 0.06585073471069336, 0.04173334315419197, 0.009753542952239513, -0.06013723090291023, -0.0005537006654776633, -0.019893372431397438, -0.00911588966846466, -0.0188223235309124, -0.018910642713308334, 0.04130671173334122, 0.048066042363643646, -0.029686031863093376, 0.0003418569394852966, 0.034390635788440704, -0.03376272693276405, 0.048175960779190063, -0.018509406596422195, 0.03662262111902237, 0.01104141678661108, 0.031494878232479095, 0.05837132781744003, 0.0281274002045393, -0.03862423449754715, 0.05605473741889, 0.044565167278051376, -0.023206455633044243, -0.037202753126621246, -0.02823428437113762, -0.008227149955928326, 0.030721375718712807, -0.03670737147331238, -0.0448186993598938, 0.030710233375430107, 0.03187232464551926, -0.017665870487689972, 0.008882272988557816, 0.0031362813897430897, -0.012423115782439709, 0.026045070961117744, 0.027997050434350967, -0.012473683804273605, 0.03990250825881958, 0.007519615348428488, 0.027814215049147606, 0.008728458546102047, 0.039482492953538895, 0.014125547371804714, 0.02806052379310131, 0.006065627094358206, -0.0055196150206029415, 0.008794260211288929, 0.02574799954891205, -0.0028775506652891636, 0.042884182184934616, -0.0072293453849852085, 0.008274946361780167, 0.010524874553084373, -0.002016143174842, -0.03587793558835983, 0.011454285122454166, -0.04883243143558502, -0.029294829815626144, 0.04821421578526497, -0.03696896880865097, 0.03205770254135132, -0.01343186479061842, -0.030745042487978935, 0.00007104895485099405, -0.07063275575637817, 0.019363587722182274, 0.04692873731255531, -0.02190014161169529, 0.01703602820634842, -0.04224872216582298, -0.005255149211734533, -0.03680821880698204, 0.007579707074910402, -0.032191891223192215, 0.05028744786977768, 0.014270762912929058, 0.017450449988245964, 0.003761232364922762, -0.018327731639146805, -0.004616119433194399, -0.03846946731209755, 0.02407747507095337, 0.04736783728003502, 0.030348042026162148, -0.004972941242158413, 0.0029271156527101994, -0.038099076598882675, -0.08162813633680344, -0.010162906721234322, 0.015602854080498219, 0.0014084646245464683, -0.054844170808792114, 0.038585957139730453, -0.016935031861066818, -0.006294467952102423, 0.039714742451906204, 0.04809103161096573, 0.05210970714688301, -0.02390194684267044, -0.10982760787010193, -0.009279749356210232, 0.017222600057721138, -0.026306303218007088, -0.01759086176753044, -0.044257890433073044, 0.009025928564369678, 0.021821990609169006, 0.020166274160146713, -0.05631118267774582, 0.011902473866939545, -0.007470692507922649, 0.02693072333931923, 0.010626740753650665, -0.02424328215420246, -0.06212957948446274, -0.032741133123636246, -0.024226581677794456, -0.002862743102014065, -0.05855460837483406, 0.02824329026043415, 0.008521550334990025, -0.009963827207684517, -0.025436479598283768, 0.07684575021266937, -0.048239704221487045, -0.016224898397922516, -0.013759960420429707, -0.008737035095691681, -0.04136849194765091, 0.07695256918668747, 0.04292584955692291, 0.047689326107501984, 0.02237522043287754, 0.00044927294948138297, 0.04774760082364082, -0.01116564217954874, 0.03197585418820381, 0.039348676800727844, -0.0520046129822731, -0.029660673812031746, -0.016468282788991928, 0.06370978057384491, 0.03222595900297165, -0.029299836605787277, 0.05144454911351204, -0.01634576916694641, -0.024588139727711678, 0.02253677509725094, 0.034440912306308746, 0.010082138702273369, -0.004229079000651836, 0.038116637617349625, -0.02384893409907818, 0.006013549864292145, -0.05998346582055092, 0.03523111715912819, -0.00006584724178537726, -0.03850572556257248, 0.008424421772360802, 0.05695556476712227, -0.03152279183268547, -0.04020141810178757, -0.023476438596844673, -0.020521612837910652, -0.00771240284666419, 0.02122972346842289, -0.08745186775922775, 0.021728573366999626, 0.048436082899570465, 0.06109655648469925, 0.011509132571518421, 0.027433956041932106, -0.041502971202135086, -0.06301871687173843, 0.014469007961452007, -0.0014660744927823544, 0.026430368423461914, -0.01789059489965439, 0.016511138528585434, 0.02390512451529503, -0.014600556343793869, -0.005728812888264656, 0.02187802828848362, -0.05071190744638443, 0.02923033945262432, 0.08390231430530548, -0.004181453492492437, 0.017017986625432968, 0.012561894953250885, 0.01812404952943325, 0.004016199614852667, -0.011100081726908684, -0.012960392981767654, -0.05013391375541687, 0.002661382080987096, 0.06714057922363281, 0.018229074776172638, -0.046362075954675674, 0.03327672556042671, 0.04737294837832451, 0.03194057568907738, 0.00444641662761569, 0.009177572093904018, 0.011181456036865711, -0.04448290914297104, -0.005967556498944759, -0.01801181770861149, 0.03027418628334999, 0.029625127092003822, 0.03756176680326462, 0.003671809798106551, 0.03889698535203934, -0.005305794067680836, 0.0042863222770392895, 0.07481636852025986, -0.013025345280766487, -0.00988356675952673, -0.016147946938872337, -0.01596933603286743, 0.024345602840185165, -0.014460340142250061, 0.004359465558081865, 0.002056308090686798, -0.0048109907656908035, -0.006854967679828405, 0.007088689599186182, -0.05026685819029808, -0.006158112082630396, 0.010871825739741325, -0.04498608410358429, -0.028749439865350723, 0.023738373070955276, -0.025071697309613228, -0.03763820603489876, 0.010332782752811909, -0.02508951537311077, -0.01675822027027607, 0.008962064050137997, 0.06926637142896652, -0.03247740864753723, 0.02868337370455265, -0.03420781344175339, -0.013390968553721905, -0.015044200234115124, -0.02160961925983429, 0.012191938236355782, 0.021202148869633675, -0.04799577221274376, 0.0028206445276737213, -0.02025967836380005, -0.04087890684604645, 0.015489795245230198, -0.006165893282741308, 0.026525722816586494, 0.013698795810341835, -0.01491224579513073, -0.01243751123547554, 0.000027408255846239626, -0.03876340016722679, 0.009751424193382263, -0.0489438995718956, 0.014791677705943584, 0.04214182123541832, -0.008766147308051586, -0.035340771079063416, -0.020892295986413956, -0.058108557015657425, -0.04270152747631073, -0.052494220435619354, -0.033813051879405975, 0.06640138477087021, -0.034115612506866455, 0.0029818895272910595, 0.044268447905778885, -0.046201400458812714, -0.009024675004184246, -0.03881893679499626, -0.08409031480550766, -0.017235051840543747, -0.03281906247138977, 0.026256678625941277, 0.010600367560982704, -0.0693436935544014, 0.054605890065431595, 0.04778692498803139, -0.03922514244914055, 0.012000837363302708, 0.005789697635918856, -0.012192251160740852, -0.0440974123775959, -0.03127364441752434, -0.02492654137313366, -0.011568676680326462, 0.04223809391260147, 0.04195288568735123, 0.008330087177455425, 0.00309568434022367, 0.0023769461549818516, -0.011323610320687294, 0.028672518208622932, 0.0186553206294775, -0.004519997164607048, 0.027589352801442146, 0.030882427468895912, 0.011085818521678448, 0.006914650090038776, -0.011875550262629986, 0.017245858907699585, -0.015731623396277428, -0.002211343264207244, 0.025442807003855705, 0.010074357502162457, 0.01628805696964264, -0.04400523751974106, 0.061539217829704285, -0.01280426885932684, -0.03670220822095871, 0.007919827476143837, -0.005651263985782862, 0.034675464034080505, -0.02187010459601879, -0.02137451060116291, 0.0183938629925251, -0.003718483494594693, -0.037474460899829865, -0.0037156175822019577, -0.012362216599285603, 0.0160529725253582, 0.03190154954791069, -0.0017090266337618232, -0.008956581354141235, 0.04854872077703476, 0.014468029141426086, 0.03843345493078232, -0.012204867787659168, -0.0317644327878952, -0.009430118836462498, -0.05333196744322777, -0.002890633186325431, 0.014913351275026798, 0.049886882305145264, 0.020040789619088173, 0.04873444512486458, 0.0038984741549938917, 0.014638661406934261, -0.028279906138777733, 0.019023893401026726, -0.07125251740217209, -0.018412772566080093, -0.038213059306144714, 0.0057581025175750256, -0.021076278761029243, -0.006167796906083822, 0.04113157093524933, -0.031352076679468155, -0.026568714529275894, -0.034411944448947906, 0.0030860004480928183, -0.05910392478108406, -0.045341264456510544, -0.038231123238801956, -0.05059153586626053, -0.011598984710872173, 0.025060979649424553, 0.019111327826976776, -0.004781756084412336, 0.04208040237426758, 0.0541912317276001, -0.03218870609998703, 0.005991545505821705, -0.016143549233675003, -0.006357307080179453, 0.0047897109761834145, 0.034576140344142914, 0.028660310432314873, 0.038742851465940475, -0.0036204608622938395, 0.051847945898771286, 0.0030635714065283537, 0.07446666061878204, 0.012409042567014694, -0.04597551375627518, 0.010349057614803314, -0.04698754474520683, -0.024782676249742508, -0.039259761571884155, 0.02655613049864769, 0.006776916794478893, -0.016435446217656136, 0.027005065232515335, 0.00006258081702981144, -0.012127113528549671, 0.015776703134179115, 0.07199210673570633, 0.00986388698220253, 0.016516080126166344, -0.00355172180570662, -0.012182156555354595, -0.06303954869508743, 0.022138692438602448, -0.02053762972354889, 0.0029844793025404215, 0.014277392998337746, 0.006012657191604376, 0.008545746095478535, -0.01430842187255621, 0.007607544772326946, -0.029042698442935944, 0.0021689014974981546, 0.015101699158549309, -0.009464479982852936, -0.027409492060542107, 0.03467852622270584, 0.02563600242137909, 0.06851544231176376, 0.04755738750100136, -0.0007143811671994627, -0.027132423594594002, 0.02162003330886364, 0.020977679640054703, 0.019435571506619453, 0.04831184819340706, 0.009397362358868122, -0.05227530002593994, -0.0555388443171978, 0.031098874285817146, 0.00015457678819075227, 0.0121025824919343, -0.006527372635900974, -0.007675506640225649, -0.006856285035610199, -0.042636554688215256, -0.03880169242620468, 0.00027037825202569366, 0.0018620379269123077, 0.02597849629819393, -0.012426972389221191, 0.0024342630058526993, -0.04488985985517502, 0.012360002845525742, -0.0027055880054831505, 0.052187200635671616, -0.013578271493315697, 0.004901692736893892, -0.023298081010580063, 0.007165697403252125, 0.001949690980836749, -0.05396958813071251, 0.003108067438006401, 0.012124848552048206, 0.010676308535039425, 0.03287672623991966, -0.004436270333826542, -0.08743984997272491, 0.009159107692539692, -0.017001891508698463, -0.061857182532548904, 0.04171627387404442, -0.011763375252485275, 0.029200492426753044, 0.006707973312586546, 0.03731291741132736, 0.027224181219935417, 0.024832142516970634, 0.00359762622974813, -0.007278877776116133, -0.05074896290898323, 0.0336487703025341, -0.03761744126677513, 0.018027395009994507, -0.06021733954548836, -0.014966237358748913, -0.015280092135071754, 0.03011050447821617, -0.007916640490293503, 0.007821915671229362, 0.0033298374619334936, -0.03861909732222557, 0.005897633731365204, 0.023117849603295326, 0.018046265468001366, 0.04366442188620567, -0.009844817221164703, 0.014136240817606449, -0.002842051675543189, -0.012770818546414375, 0.0035358101595193148, 0.030863620340824127, 0.012227828614413738, 0.010174369439482689, -0.019398171454668045, 0.03850401192903519, -0.039235468953847885, -0.02064403146505356, -0.017052913084626198, -0.021500954404473305, 0.03220107778906822, 0.0037497375160455704, -0.0021731287706643343, 0.032860223203897476, -0.06396953761577606, -0.014126311987638474, -0.007139923050999641, -0.00493122823536396, 0.0053611514158546925, -0.03394537419080734, 0.022320488467812538, -0.009896359406411648, -0.012825115583837032, -0.08313076198101044, -0.06338775157928467, 0.023672141134738922, 0.012680974788963795, 0.0017796234460547566, -0.03790624067187309, 0.037767935544252396, -0.010879493318498135, -0.021849773824214935, -0.023690732195973396, 0.039503008127212524, 0.0028898194432258606, -0.03293007239699364, 0.02034965343773365, 0.007269114721566439, 0.07016348093748093, -0.007898765616118908, -0.014840685762465, 0.039615314453840256, -0.020958248525857925, -0.013114459812641144, -0.02545337751507759, 0.05975720286369324, -0.03654904663562775, -0.010763038881123066, -0.03107062727212906, -0.049217112362384796, 0.022672489285469055, -0.02047722041606903, -0.017017126083374023, 0.00657636858522892, -0.015386213548481464, -0.0017091266345232725, -0.007795986719429493, -0.016079014167189598, -0.01947924494743347, 0.010643146000802517, 0.009961342439055443, 0.012845570221543312, -0.002520283916965127, -0.04800061881542206, 0.020407646894454956, -0.020079798996448517, 0.012010671198368073, 0.028151482343673706, 0.06587264686822891, -0.004776590969413519, 0.02824280969798565, -0.010648463852703571, -0.017696648836135864, 0.019433092325925827, 0.010031342506408691, -0.04090046137571335, 0.004697766155004501, 0.004200466442853212, -0.05150853469967842, -0.017814379185438156, -0.05372318625450134, 0.03665776178240776, 0.03386978432536125, 0.005527449771761894, 0.05344269797205925, 0.026369016617536545, -0.015116802416741848, -0.011762697249650955, 0.0035397803876549006, -0.023480718955397606, -0.0014943238347768784, 0.008467704989016056, 0.052516333758831024, -0.019477088004350662, 0.034163858741521835, 0.04687577858567238, 0.028211740776896477, -0.020719002932310104, 0.03006744012236595, 0.012345373630523682, 0.035443179309368134, 0.050431616604328156, -0.04787140339612961, -0.03887882083654404, 0.02578728459775448, -0.03408588841557503, 0.026384392753243446, -0.015118522569537163, -0.07328560203313828, 0.01794498972594738, 0.019995510578155518, 0.029311247169971466, -0.0016315437387675047, -0.01747339963912964, -0.00814761221408844, 0.025851616635918617, 0.004989420063793659, 0.028917774558067322, -0.005749694537371397, -0.043805722147226334, 0.016811424866318703, -0.014784099534153938, 0.025742849335074425, 0.012390821240842342, -0.04436776414513588, -0.01963033527135849, -0.050122037529945374, -0.042442332953214645, 0.02176533453166485, 0.02940589375793934, -0.0019779307767748833, 0.006702232174575329, -0.023601597175002098, 0.030930519104003906, 0.04512440785765648, 0.036690037697553635, -0.00961034744977951, 0.06014364957809448, 0.014198548160493374, 0.03470205143094063, -0.021140890195965767, -0.00906629953533411, 0.12423034012317657, 0.058983758091926575, 0.032129283994436264, -0.05003275349736214, -0.00864715501666069, -0.014067405834794044, 0.024140486493706703, -0.010688300244510174, 0.039027515798807144, -0.009722212329506874, 0.01601022481918335, 0.023153411224484444, 0.05288197100162506, 0.002550744917243719, -0.014913125894963741, 0.05702657625079155, -0.05239392817020416, -0.014984525740146637, -0.018270689994096756, 0.001587322331033647, -0.027215661481022835, -0.01421437319368124, -0.04550202190876007, 0.011953658424317837, 0.01890569180250168, -0.0043574366718530655, -0.013951546512544155, -0.01074189692735672, 0.007005114573985338, -0.011927261017262936, -0.02426912635564804, -0.044497668743133545, 0.052289336919784546, -0.033730752766132355, -0.026934362947940826, -0.0006325816502794623, 0.016679830849170685, -0.015753967687487602, -0.005664778873324394, 0.044316165149211884, -0.005081512965261936, 0.003904202952980995, 0.008344963192939758, 0.01347313355654478, -0.018448902294039726, -0.012564904987812042, -0.011168763041496277, 0.04514070600271225, -0.03712243214249611, 0.0346820205450058, -0.005807832349091768, -0.0005059189861640334, -0.0030981923919171095, -0.06861944496631622, -0.05419132485985756, -0.004607043694704771, 0.02508530765771866, 0.0013557495549321175, -0.014764650724828243, -0.008366345427930355, 0.03868347406387329, -0.026894427835941315, 0.03029666095972061, -0.002504104282706976, -0.024740522727370262, -0.011665156111121178, -0.018495893105864525, 0.05261712148785591, -0.004610727075487375, 0.014801504090428352, -0.010062653571367264, -0.009707015007734299, -0.022131232544779778, -0.025285547599196434, 0.0026536639779806137, -0.016987347975373268, 0.05858777463436127, 0.009954537265002728, -0.01264233235269785, 0.02133353240787983, -0.05656702443957329, 0.019603010267019272, -0.06606373935937881, 0.0063155898824334145, -0.045247096568346024, -0.008624745532870293, 0.012752627022564411, 0.07701706141233444, 0.034262556582689285, -0.01289644930511713, -0.009349620901048183, 0.05841315537691116, 0.006337834056466818, -0.029190566390752792, -0.01602909527719021, 0.03115668334066868, 0.0035035412292927504, 0.033030714839696884, -0.01272169966250658, 0.030167754739522934, 0.022406000643968582, 0.034403130412101746, 0.012697921134531498, 0.02245236188173294, -0.024274736642837524, 0.019497429952025414, -0.02289688028395176, -0.03661256283521652, 0.019005250185728073, 0.016000783070921898, 0.014977504499256611, -0.0283099003136158, -0.03308110311627388, 0.01701669953763485, 0.039421528577804565, -0.0004898951156064868, -0.018351534381508827, -0.02252238057553768, -0.03911195695400238, -0.026913799345493317, 0.006501035764813423, -0.0075138951651751995, -0.011946171522140503, -0.02126193977892399, -0.019222818315029144, 0.04725877195596695, 0.022057674825191498, -0.023317931219935417, 0.004212846513837576, -0.0054125539027154446, -0.027281364426016808, 0.0031944045331329107, -0.0021565125789493322, -0.002289331052452326, 0.020451337099075317, 0.04773851856589317, 0.004830832593142986, 0.06592192500829697, -0.011212770827114582, 0.00003368765828781761, 0.04242776334285736, -0.050238024443387985, -0.04487012326717377, 0.02395048923790455, -0.004582688678056002, 0.04256078600883484, 0.0463351309299469, 0.008657333441078663, -0.04323679953813553, 0.031155014410614967, -0.0015459543792530894, 0.01282430998980999, -0.01415074709802866, 0.01225567888468504, -0.009165165014564991, 0.03293783590197563, 0.039882443845272064, -0.00738135538995266, -0.0028549139387905598, -0.01716885156929493, 0.017762281000614166, -0.0062184580601751804, -0.021307285875082016, 0.02997838892042637, 0.00681564724072814, -0.03211357817053795, 0.05029810965061188, 0.026093963533639908, 0.007757544983178377, 0.02745399996638298, -0.009164677932858467, 0.04870897904038429, -0.007178282830864191, 0.013800621964037418, -0.10997740924358368, -0.014094733633100986, 0.03280132636427879, 0.006110676564276218, 0.04534556716680527, -0.019186636433005333, -0.015403231605887413, 0.04987959936261177, -0.08111460506916046, 0.0179908350110054, 0.020693425089120865, 0.003122371155768633, -0.05570237338542938, 0.040731851011514664, -0.02047707326710224, 0.06850556284189224, 0.025338543578982353, 0.05329681560397148, 0.023630065843462944, 0.031474076211452484, 0.007726504001766443, 0.012204515747725964, -0.005258733406662941, 0.04010406509041786, -0.02659512870013714, -0.013869854621589184, 0.050749070942401886, -0.0071409279480576515, -0.0073444475419819355, 0.007229829207062721, 0.008146131411194801, -0.0347168929874897, -0.0008490968029946089, 0.016287852078676224, -0.0004976455820724368, 0.025247957557439804, 0.03885004669427872, 0.006502259057015181, -0.04021856561303139, 0.02565990388393402, -0.004562178160995245, 0.003974855411797762, -0.06842544674873352, -0.02539183758199215, 0.02302175760269165, -0.029782457277178764, -0.03334015980362892, 0.0003116506850346923, 0.007821946404874325, -0.02228708565235138, 0.013450175523757935, 0.024404365569353104, -0.028788086026906967, 0.006371269002556801, 0.04303458333015442, -0.051226455718278885, -0.003896129783242941, 0.02625037543475628, -0.024177880957722664, -0.023886224254965782, 0.01633155718445778, -0.010987074114382267, -0.03941512107849121, 0.03397960960865021, 0.01418687030673027, -0.0188039168715477, -0.06896746158599854, -0.0018855937523767352, -0.02789006382226944, 0.010329855605959892, 0.03433897718787193, -0.0312674418091774, -0.036916110664606094, -0.02223259210586548, 0.0014132794458419085, 0.0053009698167443275, -0.004062551073729992, -0.03225326910614967, -0.017901750281453133, -0.06463899463415146, 0.06641372293233871, 0.017083846032619476, 0.012187248095870018, -0.055754147469997406, 0.009019177407026291, -0.041197698563337326, 0.0036235544830560684, 0.018414370715618134, 0.017588943243026733, 0.025829549878835678, -0.017533091828227043, 0.019019505009055138, 0.05353434383869171, -0.03854500874876976, 0.03481975942850113, -0.029237180948257446, -0.051076002418994904, -0.017917869612574577, -0.006570496596395969, 0.03696117550134659, -0.007020934019237757, 0.02354494482278824, 0.004912912845611572, -0.0003453294630162418, -0.0027090793009847403, -0.030969487503170967, 0.08971915394067764, 0.030017713084816933, 0.02308073081076145, 0.05118585377931595, -0.037517379969358444, 0.04656098783016205, -0.02060532569885254, 0.01281307078897953, -0.01824583113193512, 0.024000519886612892, -0.035075705498456955, -0.03811227157711983, -0.024006079882383347, 0.03776513785123825, 0.0051866560243070126, -0.015308260917663574, -0.019521674141287804, 0.05765616148710251, -0.02499307692050934, -0.05886683240532875, 0.017020365223288536, 0.013122773729264736, 0.07335419207811356, 0.014382932335138321, -0.010079913772642612, 0.02325611189007759, -0.006520195864140987, 0.00911396648734808, 0.03038209304213524, 0.028027573600411415, -0.03716227784752846, 0.019468357786536217, 0.04416617378592491, -0.020511025562882423, 0.020838314667344093, 0.005099490750581026, 0.023718450218439102, -0.05415326729416847, -0.02556787058711052, 0.00762759568169713, -0.018466046079993248, 0.002623960142955184, 0.011798020452260971, 0.005721495021134615, 0.04785702005028725, 0.018055574968457222, 0.010370802134275436, -0.026762275025248528, 0.010027728974819183, -0.03365463763475418, 0.005224245600402355, 0.017085717990994453, 0.015322105959057808, -0.019246280193328857, 0.018748175352811813, 0.00021387942251749337, -0.007993126288056374, 0.05241018906235695, -0.017358623445034027, 0.04245912656188011, 0.04006056487560272, -0.014601935632526875, -0.015373730100691319, 0.0003745872527360916, 0.009685668163001537, -0.0005677785957232118, 0.016885574907064438, 0.028184685856103897, 0.04824623838067055, -0.0014800486387684941, -0.018686441704630852, -0.02587505802512169, 0.031183607876300812, -0.05384714901447296, 0.024556640535593033, -0.041762758046388626, -0.002861601300537586, 0.015577451325953007, 0.008469576016068459 ]
<p>I am currently completing my dissertation. My study is cross-cultural and looks at predictors and inhibitors to adoption of technology in two countries (Thailand and Australia). I have a hypothesised model with IV's (Ease of Use, Usefulness, Need for Interaction, Risk, and Social Influence) directly linked to a single DV (intention to use). Both models are the exact same, so are the IVs and DVs (and related items), and sample sizes are similiar. </p> <p>I have run regression analysis on both the Thai and Australian sample individually. I have the regression coefficient outputs with signifiance etc. What I am trying to find out now is how to best test the following question (or something similiar): "<em>Social influence (IV) will have a stronger relationship in Thailand with intention to use (DV) m-banking than in Australia</em>". </p> <p>Is this the best way to test whether individual constructs fit better in one country then another? I want to test each individual construct to find out which has a more significant relationship between that IV and DV. </p> <p>I apologise if this question has been answered already somewhere on the site or sounds very simplistic. I am using SPSS v19.0 btw. Thanks in advance!</p>
74,214
[ -0.06269605457782745, -0.019969215616583824, 0.023135945200920105, 0.042625900357961655, 0.028843961656093597, 0.024891816079616547, 0.011986401863396168, -0.014292677864432335, 0.044119372963905334, -0.0017253125552088022, 0.010153195820748806, 0.0615202896296978, 0.05468643084168434, -0.011181160807609558, -0.002779854228720069, 0.029848238453269005, -0.01258193887770176, 0.008648875169456005, 0.002266146242618561, 0.013286525383591652, -0.03533449023962021, 0.02094973996281624, 0.0281564611941576, 0.00010311116784578189, 0.01719304732978344, 0.04790952429175377, 0.03749672323465347, -0.06482292711734772, -0.0030472499784082174, 0.035978950560092926, -0.03328670561313629, -0.045125361531972885, -0.03183494508266449, 0.017211655154824257, 0.01345835067331791, 0.006307551171630621, -0.014452795498073101, 0.002863322151824832, -0.006531257648020983, 0.012307828292250633, -0.01711692474782467, 0.008837834931910038, 0.010279517620801926, 0.002227982971817255, 0.005806585308164358, 0.02702702023088932, -0.02305988036096096, 0.005907606333494186, 0.036155808717012405, -0.05643029138445854, 0.055097322911024094, -0.027091246098279953, 0.009163709357380867, 0.06114942952990532, -0.0025077350437641144, -0.008459743112325668, 0.014943343587219715, 0.028315279632806778, -0.03714901581406593, -0.04721381142735481, -0.009255480021238327, -0.014196893200278282, 0.008347726427018642, -0.02808288112282753, -0.041376855224370956, 0.04611547663807869, 0.0018394775688648224, -0.006353811360895634, 0.06722986698150635, 0.015259659849107265, 0.052675239741802216, 0.011551210656762123, 0.049268998205661774, -0.004277744330465794, -0.011791642755270004, -0.007188062183558941, -0.016533788293600082, 0.04349157586693764, 0.05992508307099342, 0.041125908493995667, 0.026890497654676437, 0.022509710863232613, -0.011845120228827, 0.03064846061170101, 0.03913275524973869, 0.01141029316931963, 0.023762675002217293, -0.03401348739862442, -0.003218224039301276, 0.031779129058122635, -0.044666267931461334, 0.0015958882868289948, 0.0290414746850729, 0.010447381064295769, -0.03490240499377251, 0.046629417687654495, -0.035207513719797134, 0.05820593237876892, 0.0019360267324373126, 0.00461282953619957, -0.024834563955664635, -0.01066868007183075, 0.005844969302415848, 0.07285166531801224, -0.01047519501298666, -0.012938657775521278, -0.011425967328250408, 0.012812881730496883, -0.0008876288193278015, -0.015636984258890152, -0.004910496529191732, 0.0012514486443251371, 0.005449613090604544, 0.007354884874075651, 0.03435852378606796, 0.0037922104820609093, -0.023986903950572014, -0.031195983290672302, 0.05005472153425217, 0.04152057319879532, 0.037701565772295, -0.06541403383016586, 0.02828352525830269, -0.046466391533613205, -0.04565874859690666, 0.01582382433116436, 0.0024823208805173635, -0.01828485168516636, 0.01285993680357933, 0.039068326354026794, 0.0050269984640181065, -0.04613244906067848, -0.001089520868845284, 0.01947621814906597, 0.024125680327415466, 0.011902572587132454, -0.07808069884777069, -0.057234011590480804, 0.008167293854057789, 0.023851213976740837, 0.03327636420726776, -0.03447885811328888, -0.02315438725054264, 0.02328938990831375, 0.0505470409989357, -0.0023192577064037323, 0.04702691361308098, 0.0035799057222902775, 0.033944759517908096, 0.02461082860827446, -0.03687393292784691, -0.03670820593833923, -0.043759021908044815, -0.025181973353028297, -0.010725203901529312, -0.06931060552597046, -0.006498987786471844, 0.034542180597782135, -0.034872137010097504, -0.01774420589208603, 0.05079088360071182, 0.027580641210079193, -0.007835726253688335, -0.03404601663351059, 0.03463080897927284, 0.00028759799897670746, 0.012559685856103897, -0.03358161076903343, 0.017034299671649933, 0.005248859990388155, 0.027053937315940857, -0.020784098654985428, 0.007450331002473831, 0.028354434296488762, 0.022861244156956673, -0.031571026891469955, -0.003751176642253995, -0.018843431025743484, 0.001553224865347147, 0.007474485319107771, -0.042670078575611115, -0.05771893262863159, -0.04932460933923721, -0.03548416495323181, 0.003515789518132806, 0.063725046813488, 0.012815400958061218, -0.017808042466640472, 0.006747571751475334, -0.06318693608045578, -0.07254042476415634, -0.027331719174981117, 0.009414776228368282, -0.005469596479088068, -0.05525285378098488, 0.02051491104066372, -0.035445667803287506, -0.00859465729445219, 0.005850813817232847, -0.014742114581167698, -0.04325493425130844, -0.02456641010940075, 0.034038811922073364, -0.02811739221215248, 0.002444285899400711, 0.02254898101091385, 0.003696911036968231, -0.054648395627737045, 0.022807473316788673, -0.04526699706912041, -0.02025795541703701, 0.054429952055215836, -0.04373936727643013, 0.02288026548922062, 0.017230963334441185, -0.041496094316244125, -0.00021263383678160608, 0.014348506927490234, -0.03537582606077194, 0.025449464097619057, -0.05130523815751076, 0.08320406824350357, 0.05581032484769821, 0.01103888638317585, 0.013617663644254208, 0.03084518574178219, 0.0008253878331743181, -0.01566946692764759, -0.04200402647256851, -0.02160213328897953, -0.04926863685250282, -0.04703008010983467, 0.022769618779420853, -0.005194082390516996, -0.06685630977153778, 0.01878380961716175, 0.03735816851258278, 0.025717204436659813, 0.00422339141368866, 0.007033924106508493, 0.005856401287019253, 0.002466413890942931, 0.002460922347381711, 0.051557864993810654, -0.014486405998468399, 0.024073565378785133, 0.022326555103063583, 0.024234509095549583, 0.03410416468977928, 0.0043366700410842896, 0.004275335930287838, 0.004757099784910679, 0.01249703299254179, 0.040244754403829575, -0.03978439047932625, 0.016039906069636345, 0.04037054628133774, -0.04218706116080284, 0.0007166166906245053, 0.05165742710232735, -0.004828281234949827, -0.010675998404622078, 0.03410167247056961, -0.030595606192946434, 0.0546836219727993, 0.04399300366640091, 0.025169525295495987, -0.005098399706184864, 0.02047588676214218, -0.033280786126852036, 0.0022879657335579395, -0.0026797056198120117, -0.009413708001375198, -0.039083655923604965, 0.020757775753736496, 0.02493462711572647, -0.0038768192753195763, 0.012810570187866688, -0.0008775476017035544, 0.03078124299645424, -0.030839303508400917, 0.011025974527001381, 0.004657625686377287, -0.029123377054929733, -0.05455958470702171, -0.010040400549769402, -0.003969130106270313, -0.011345171369612217, 0.02317008748650551, -0.03236444294452667, -0.01690879464149475, 0.04642089828848839, 0.02544212155044079, -0.037253059446811676, -0.028100037947297096, -0.00863394420593977, -0.000819397799205035, 0.005767198279500008, -0.025777244940400124, 0.0009407400502823293, 0.013096562586724758, -0.0674072727560997, 0.019877005368471146, -0.025606028735637665, -0.007513929158449173, -0.01769540272653103, -0.0379909947514534, 0.01831345073878765, -0.02961716055870056, 0.02417362667620182, 0.017005950212478638, 0.0015828339383006096, -0.029425587505102158, -0.0668477714061737, -0.07076995819807053, 0.059931736439466476, 0.029101360589265823, 0.06935372948646545, -0.0024306762497872114, 0.009111464954912663, 0.08829431980848312, 0.03757208585739136, -0.02533654496073723, -0.07195647805929184, -0.031055724248290062, -0.03005623072385788, -0.024372048676013947, 0.04419552534818649, 0.048570241779088974, 0.013253413140773773, 0.03446727618575096, -0.011422091163694859, 0.03137461096048355, 0.024323787540197372, -0.002752110129222274, 0.009275559335947037, 0.0058091674000024796, 0.006692171562463045, -0.053868554532527924, 0.03819072246551514, 0.047878894954919815, -0.043142564594745636, -0.019419914111495018, -0.005982160568237305, 0.015167225152254105, 0.018754949793219566, -0.000953120703343302, 0.027145227417349815, -0.04499845951795578, -0.02677350491285324, -0.04964831843972206, 0.006243514362722635, -0.011739961802959442, -0.04585624113678932, -0.03307675942778587, 0.028587492182850838, 0.01736304722726345, -0.0078292116522789, 0.011520573869347572, 0.08065494149923325, 0.01377769187092781, 0.024123452603816986, -0.007491258438676596, -0.0606067068874836, 0.008744127117097378, 0.011536761187016964, -0.003216411219909787, -0.016228141263127327, 0.03292755037546158, 0.04700760915875435, 0.014436600729823112, 0.015034260228276253, -0.055616941303014755, -0.013604966923594475, -0.09480653703212738, 0.0011277208104729652, -0.03498132526874542, 0.058824941515922546, 0.01226645428687334, 0.017971588298678398, 0.03275100886821747, -0.006110460497438908, -0.023578818887472153, 0.0010920169297605753, -0.054555948823690414, 0.05063436180353165, -0.010698760859668255, -0.02680928073823452, 0.0588509775698185, -0.003690378274768591, 0.022186094895005226, -0.024965541437268257, -0.00520502170547843, 0.014433523640036583, 0.004314260557293892, -0.027501016855239868, 0.02668948844075203, -0.023525312542915344, -0.025018902495503426, 0.04384336993098259, 0.05075191333889961, 0.025199484080076218, -0.004026534501463175, 0.011746793985366821, 0.019177859649062157, -0.03493266552686691, -0.011185732670128345, -0.03483417257666588, -0.009260843507945538, 0.03434886410832405, 0.04176222160458565, 0.06488671153783798, -0.009699750691652298, -0.04872104525566101, 0.008081174455583096, 0.004798243287950754, 0.012469957582652569, 0.03295571357011795, -0.03767579793930054, -0.023542027920484543, -0.03790541738271713, 0.0016522741643711925, 0.012932072393596172, 0.027675515040755272, 0.01408799085766077, -0.004950832575559616, 0.04684742912650108, 0.02405484765768051, -0.017330564558506012, 0.007376663386821747, 0.07849938422441483, 0.007795157376676798, -0.012172657996416092, -0.0374651774764061, 0.007638145238161087, -0.0008640476153232157, -0.025706173852086067, 0.05161508545279503, 0.04590173438191414, -0.01888364367187023, -0.0315016433596611, 0.05497473105788231, -0.0317610464990139, -0.0529593899846077, 0.04042210802435875, 0.0016936517786234617, 0.06425836682319641, 0.027624258771538734, -0.06385074555873871, 0.01160524133592844, 0.01756623387336731, -0.0036300686188042164, 0.04854261875152588, 0.0041392529383301735, -0.10644903779029846, 0.008055716753005981, 0.05298417806625366, 0.024983055889606476, -0.04629133641719818, -0.009898831136524677, 0.016843819990754128, -0.017379002645611763, 0.04627680778503418, -0.040898341685533524, 0.026699697598814964, 0.02401317097246647, 0.023590024560689926, -0.03954748809337616, -0.019871128723025322, -0.038356564939022064, 0.008781361393630505, 0.02007310837507248, 0.040716804563999176, 0.01115779485553503, -0.029174746945500374, -0.038860876113176346, 0.010566560551524162, 0.031215645372867584, 0.0315551795065403, 0.00030634368886239827, -0.018117086961865425, -0.008082227781414986, 0.020492039620876312, 0.002752199536189437, -0.020540768280625343, 0.01955978386104107, 0.01275118812918663, -0.012358393520116806, 0.05140649527311325, 0.010403856635093689, -0.024965791031718254, 0.006513507571071386, 0.00742748286575079, -0.014132821932435036, 0.010832310654222965, -0.018244564533233643, 0.04143054783344269, 0.01744515262544155, 0.008630754426121712, 0.01831824705004692, 0.03705573081970215, 0.007519157137721777, -0.004610360134392977, -0.004818412475287914, -0.028090422973036766, -0.012714425101876259, -0.04358995333313942, -0.028574755415320396, 0.008943213149905205, -0.023163069039583206, 0.018339145928621292, 0.01388793159276247, 0.01206211093813181, -0.05494363233447075, -0.004181742202490568, -0.014326152391731739, 0.03932872787117958, -0.009678006172180176, -0.0111654382199049, 0.00968342274427414, 0.002330504823476076, 0.010336754843592644, -0.02625364623963833, 0.01727164536714554, -0.010687697678804398, -0.011710177175700665, -0.011128907091915607, -0.035267554223537445, 0.02270491234958172, -0.011000615544617176, -0.05534008517861366, 0.010399139486253262, -0.05000404268503189, 0.040966518223285675, -0.023368829861283302, 0.007387996185570955, 0.004847658798098564, -0.00847836583852768, 0.010209049098193645, 0.044732846319675446, 0.032942239195108414, 0.05472404509782791, -0.03555694594979286, 0.020074520260095596, -0.04299178346991539, -0.032583173364400864, -0.06497238576412201, -0.056655947118997574, -0.015372267924249172, -0.016618195921182632, -0.019094128161668777, -0.010312942788004875, 0.02867557667195797, -0.011939330957829952, 0.012148216366767883, -0.030104855075478554, 0.05207927152514458, -0.005611758213490248, -0.002700745826587081, -0.018989551812410355, 0.027201738208532333, 0.08096525073051453, 0.010646850802004337, -0.0038906242698431015, 0.010025778785347939, -0.018806954845786095, 0.03581656143069267, -0.0038302545435726643, 0.009959126822650433, -0.017572397366166115, -0.0055711530148983, -0.04546777158975601, 0.02435782179236412, 0.027617404237389565, 0.008619976229965687, -0.00010040244524134323, 0.012694214470684528, -0.026400785893201828, 0.014728446491062641, -0.006049100309610367, 0.006495609879493713, 0.031584735959768295, 0.012754171155393124, 0.00472649559378624, 0.044151123613119125, -0.040309738367795944, 0.006597308907657862, 0.008512532338500023, 0.021517079323530197, -0.020402533933520317, -0.010492800734937191, 0.0496353842318058, 0.021855894476175308, 0.046905338764190674, 0.014307888224720955, 0.007169610820710659, 0.0447557270526886, -0.020777925848960876, -0.004030901473015547, -0.017873842269182205, 0.0595012903213501, -0.04918161779642105, -0.015170987695455551, -0.02113744616508484, 0.00017408064741175622, 0.059957996010780334, -0.0044397227466106415, 0.059020575135946274, 0.06738807260990143, -0.0054502934217453, 0.0033517975825816393, -0.047217536717653275, -0.021770190447568893, 0.0056951590813696384, -0.023638226091861725, 0.06044839695096016, -0.0032042195089161396, -0.008703602477908134, 0.010259843431413174, 0.035936981439590454, 0.048474982380867004, 0.059108056128025055, 0.040246617048978806, 0.03897878900170326, 0.06935674697160721, -0.05885157734155655, 0.0005568697233684361, 0.031014088541269302, -0.04133446887135506, 0.0006257097702473402, -0.0404781848192215, 0.00392468785867095, 0.02458460070192814, 0.026799799874424934, 0.012183289974927902, -0.03665703907608986, -0.014764446765184402, -0.05578722059726715, -0.016371870413422585, 0.026547323912382126, -0.03128327801823616, 0.013681557960808277, 0.01593026891350746, 0.03527374565601349, 0.023856254294514656, 0.019347287714481354, -0.0304025337100029, -0.10916084051132202, -0.020541781559586525, -0.005911911837756634, -0.018795020878314972, 0.051111482083797455, -0.012682381086051464, -0.030986156314611435, 0.010460186749696732, -0.06633235514163971, -0.007311452645808458, 0.007329544518142939, 0.015336208045482635, 0.04370151460170746, 0.06561075896024704, -0.03790125623345375, 0.03953881561756134, 0.017253926023840904, -0.01924886554479599, 0.10383152216672897, 0.05420592427253723, 0.042886026203632355, -0.07083474844694138, 0.022268997505307198, 0.009762498550117016, 0.004192886408418417, -0.024971356615424156, -0.0030942780431360006, 0.0034711386542767286, -0.02468838170170784, 0.07003742456436157, 0.045032355934381485, 0.019636277109384537, -0.016755137592554092, 0.06338144838809967, -0.017100747674703598, -0.03750013932585716, -0.01641552895307541, 0.010890335775911808, -0.00812862440943718, -0.041748497635126114, -0.0032263752073049545, -0.01621188223361969, -0.012691617012023926, -0.009537127800285816, 0.005431867204606533, -0.003960866946727037, 0.030011193826794624, -0.0038070620503276587, 0.008300134912133217, -0.006810770835727453, -0.007713237777352333, 0.03180255368351936, -0.05231437832117081, -0.01990503817796707, 0.059540748596191406, -0.039343371987342834, 0.011555184610188007, 0.04029783606529236, -0.028874877840280533, -0.03581732511520386, 0.042231470346450806, 0.009470012970268726, -0.07583890855312347, -0.03959685191512108, -0.018664130941033363, 0.04362291097640991, 0.011697971262037754, -0.05047386512160301, -0.006665712688118219, 0.006317909341305494, 0.007931503467261791, -0.018357479944825172, -0.04742951691150665, 0.0007458733161911368, 0.01925603114068508, -0.033682193607091904, 0.008093639276921749, -0.029861342161893845, 0.028286412358283997, 0.017002759501338005, 0.047412458807229996, 0.006764819845557213, -0.012600420042872429, -0.01136996690183878, -0.007011293899267912, 0.014541247859597206, -0.006319822743535042, -0.022715074941515923, 0.04295063018798828, -0.01128990389406681, -0.04100007936358452, 0.023677833378314972, 0.000554352649487555, -0.002361347433179617, 0.006420461926609278, -0.01718650944530964, 0.01553288847208023, -0.028696199879050255, -0.013745610602200031, -0.005650994833558798, -0.05186707526445389, -0.013757917098701, -0.05201653391122818, 0.024268126115202904, 0.017428789287805557, -0.007170495111495256, 0.004531672224402428, 0.01853892020881176, 0.01603487692773342, 0.053837042301893234, 0.018589254468679428, -0.036559443920850754, -0.036105673760175705, -0.042469751089811325, -0.06759174913167953, 0.007475484628230333, -0.04881827533245087, 0.03263270482420921, 0.0013957348419353366, 0.019113026559352875, -0.018574479967355728, 0.01680479571223259, -0.008194761350750923, 0.037040144205093384, 0.011096668429672718, -0.07684752345085144, -0.03423697501420975, 0.007821227423846722, 0.01004093885421753, -0.015807481482625008, 0.012639748863875866, -0.04250912368297577, -0.0005701978807337582, 0.016833830624818802, -0.033605799078941345, -0.027522902935743332, 0.04505806416273117, -0.019321931526064873, 0.03161029517650604, -0.03551974892616272, -0.006998514756560326, -0.06938084959983826, -0.03058217652142048, 0.03862413391470909, -0.009389200247824192, 0.0038404478691518307, -0.0007114702020771801, -0.0382540188729763, 0.015186458826065063, 0.01726376637816429, 0.025719832628965378, 0.014009618200361729, 0.007832922041416168, -0.017373835667967796, 0.015678770840168, 0.06264316290616989, -0.03448507934808731, -0.008199875243008137, -0.010135689750313759, -0.009901965968310833, -0.004183000884950161, 0.02025792934000492, -0.015567069873213768, 0.02248389460146427, 0.03989996761083603, 0.013212711550295353, -0.027199191972613335, 0.07175332307815552, -0.019626658409833908, -0.004837925545871258, -0.03156958892941475, 0.01011775340884924, 0.001369680743664503, 0.0019115618197247386, -0.04458518698811531, 0.0028454135172069073, -0.02044404298067093, 0.04098747298121452, 0.05196616053581238, 0.03193715214729309, 0.007022044621407986, -0.02715623937547207, -0.002978542121127248, 0.0000027230339583184104, 0.005048814695328474, -0.036806557327508926, 0.04629647731781006, 0.03396296873688698, -0.029961679130792618, 0.005609022453427315, -0.0036632250994443893, 0.0027698115445673466, -0.057964906096458435, -0.013599250465631485, -0.00030370542663149536, 0.02123843878507614, 0.004197027999907732, -0.029415393248200417, 0.023202890530228615, -0.012450339272618294, -0.04377489164471626, -0.0051302253268659115, 0.0163106732070446, 0.005029886029660702, -0.060482654720544815, -0.00347537430934608, 0.002864581998437643, 0.04403328895568848, -0.007823275402188301, 0.028027284890413284, 0.036667656153440475, 0.03029143251478672, -0.002677690936252475, -0.007208830211311579, -0.009877928532660007, 0.023287620395421982, 0.01942586712539196, -0.06775692850351334, 0.02508622780442238, -0.04977107048034668, -0.028922662138938904, 0.031288888305425644, -0.03426063433289528, 0.027032969519495964, 0.04381604120135307, 0.019019432365894318, 0.02433556132018566, 0.05820157751441002, 0.02351612038910389, -0.01971905678510666, -0.02375071868300438, 0.0023825252428650856, 0.013040089048445225, 0.025319302454590797, 0.00851104874163866, 0.007643070537596941, 0.023589206859469414, -0.015229526907205582, 0.023418160155415535, -0.03557968884706497, -0.004396858159452677, -0.03372874855995178, 0.013289839029312134, -0.014748797751963139, 0.04872291535139084, -0.0009228615090250969, -0.0004738866991829127, -0.07500460743904114, -0.011177883483469486, 0.031868934631347656, 0.016934527084231377, 0.003987002186477184, 0.00722779706120491, -0.018426930531859398, -0.024586984887719154, -0.0015995587455108762, 0.001887800870463252, 0.008201844990253448, -0.018693532794713974, -0.03644200414419174, -0.00671075563877821, 0.031145744025707245, -0.012166840024292469, 0.018920909613370895, -0.024776965379714966, 0.048792384564876556, -0.03839467093348503, 0.017850179225206375, 0.037076909095048904, -0.02782510034739971, 0.017887510359287262, -0.04569380730390549, 0.04435959830880165, -0.008294373750686646, -0.04289067164063454, -0.020255228504538536, -0.01717425510287285, -0.05331557244062424, -0.0011475698556751013, 0.03859052062034607, -0.04409022629261017, -0.00022775081743020564, -0.027362249791622162, 0.0329294316470623, -0.0038759892340749502, -0.034430284053087234, 0.04767852649092674, -0.0038656387478113174, -0.039070092141628265, 0.03412598371505737, -0.001978418556973338, 0.01415259763598442, 0.0020430367439985275, 0.010401193052530289, -0.02536606974899769, 0.016822557896375656, -0.009886860847473145, 0.0025544583331793547, -0.007460163440555334, -0.0018992323894053698, -0.007606122642755508, 0.05596538260579109, -0.014022658579051495, -0.00862458348274231, 0.03564908355474472, -0.01979706808924675, -0.03083162009716034, 0.04500780999660492, -0.008114529773592949, -0.011244957335293293, -0.045751407742500305, 0.01127197127789259, -0.029413754120469093, -0.04977056011557579, 0.00454163271933794, 0.012975439429283142, -0.013455613516271114, -0.01891990751028061, 0.04018787667155266, 0.03070026822388172, 0.0006780886906199157, 0.013620317913591862, 0.050217799842357635, -0.010042446665465832, -0.02376505173742771, 0.022347228601574898, 0.021762562915682793, 0.02302711270749569, 0.035458337515592575, 0.0018008464248850942, 0.03595626354217529, 0.004395757801830769, 0.038075219839811325, -0.037314143031835556, -0.011706437915563583, -0.01608976349234581, -0.03216671571135521, 0.03412821516394615, 0.01730729453265667, 0.008143397979438305, 0.005732686724513769, -0.006822619587182999, 0.05941000208258629, -0.05731372907757759, -0.017594030126929283, -0.03468244895339012, 0.00821713451296091, -0.0461096465587616, -0.0005565354367718101, 0.035114504396915436, -0.014024983160197735, -0.0176173634827137, 0.009029905311763287, 0.01397331990301609, -0.026774151250720024, 0.013898269273340702, -0.009129850193858147, -0.017543816938996315, -0.029106255620718002, -0.02357020601630211, -0.04589072987437248, 0.005437358748167753, -0.02899065613746643, 0.01546362042427063, 0.05490235239267349, 0.034716855734586716, 0.0034921399783343077, -0.023140905424952507, -0.03863545134663582, 0.035610925406217575, 0.05652240663766861, -0.07577326148748398, -0.017460625618696213, -0.043664127588272095, -0.007469332776963711, 0.02247922122478485, -0.008306421339511871 ]
<p>I've come accross a term called "statistical efficiency of the median" in a paper and couldn't find any definition in the paper. From my search online, I found that this might mean relative efficiency of the median compared to the mean.</p> <p>Can anyone shed some light to where I can look for clues?</p>
13
[ -0.05177319049835205, 0.0033907925244420767, -0.0028666220605373383, -0.03386019170284271, 0.02153162471950054, 0.06548786163330078, 0.007796083111315966, -0.0037474886048585176, 0.01646888442337513, -0.03275052458047867, 0.017615966498851776, 0.03135912865400314, 0.06392291188240051, 0.002271330449730158, 0.01753813587129116, -0.01911066472530365, -0.04766885191202164, 0.055632226169109344, 0.015035619959235191, -0.04363147169351578, 0.02904597669839859, 0.006631035823374987, 0.0412055179476738, 0.011523290537297726, -0.033848024904727936, 0.01961401104927063, 0.011354774236679077, -0.007974793203175068, -0.005271351896226406, 0.0583866722881794, -0.026500923559069633, -0.0030429682228714228, 0.01636420004069805, 0.031094089150428772, -0.003326732199639082, -0.010179206728935242, -0.022993054240942, -0.02396833524107933, 0.0164421908557415, 0.041774358600378036, -0.03959531709551811, -0.017576761543750763, -0.00691132852807641, 0.013316173106431961, -0.03022257424890995, 0.03819555789232254, 0.003134209895506501, -0.06807220727205276, 0.009179621003568172, -0.04614108428359032, 0.08393432199954987, 0.015735860913991928, 0.027520231902599335, 0.008083521388471127, 0.0017226454801857471, 0.027858836576342583, 0.03601914271712303, 0.0785541981458664, -0.011294781230390072, -0.042814403772354126, -0.019475096836686134, -0.020684007555246353, 0.009785282425582409, -0.013479545712471008, -0.048775721341371536, 0.029201479628682137, -0.014803724363446236, -0.021422050893306732, 0.04876421019434929, 0.02926434576511383, 0.0006197225884534419, 0.01576925814151764, 0.028796561062335968, 0.008688104338943958, 0.02148156426846981, -0.025598719716072083, 0.013667847029864788, -0.00597613537684083, 0.023754261434078217, 0.039388980716466904, 0.02918192744255066, 0.0019147410057485104, 0.018521293997764587, 0.030747748911380768, -0.022926747798919678, 0.005283966660499573, 0.0655495673418045, -0.045616552233695984, 0.021578365936875343, 0.0067726378329098225, -0.002833940787240863, -0.0055285245180130005, 0.041328828781843185, -0.0057540410198271275, -0.04628981649875641, 0.018488002941012383, -0.0008828064892441034, 0.037450555711984634, -0.002643090905621648, -0.013280988670885563, 0.015001351945102215, -0.038785334676504135, 0.011909441091120243, 0.05794677138328552, -0.003633683081716299, -0.02202938124537468, -0.04819566383957863, 0.02343255840241909, 0.010767991654574871, 0.029249384999275208, -0.021454930305480957, -0.00016778032295405865, 0.012381122447550297, 0.017110558226704597, 0.021151304244995117, -0.029177898541092873, 0.017116837203502655, 0.016307752579450607, 0.03248340263962746, 0.04341978579759598, 0.018633149564266205, -0.037767231464385986, 0.040202029049396515, -0.021981608122587204, -0.0017104201251640916, 0.030221763998270035, -0.0065962341614067554, -0.010206593200564384, -0.016372129321098328, 0.02864944003522396, 0.005059217568486929, -0.024380497634410858, 0.05738305300474167, 0.009426303207874298, 0.037782683968544006, -0.020582644268870354, -0.05975153669714928, -0.023921821266412735, 0.07903973013162613, 0.04456247389316559, 0.024564089253544807, -0.05376698449254036, -0.00451087299734354, 0.008244486525654793, -0.021092282608151436, 0.05515900254249573, 0.03646109625697136, 0.019020164385437965, 0.0033708224073052406, 0.017600620165467262, -0.030398797243833542, -0.03124186024069786, 0.05039278790354729, -0.033227499574422836, 0.01634228229522705, -0.08307762444019318, -0.0023133703507483006, -0.011563291773200035, -0.04481382668018341, -0.0354955680668354, 0.05741172283887863, 0.0125821428373456, -0.03008914552628994, 0.01009351946413517, 0.020963001996278763, 0.0223543681204319, 0.061279959976673126, -0.007741669192910194, 0.03380989655852318, 0.006724066101014614, 0.005633746273815632, 0.01504402793943882, 0.025797897949814796, 0.04383467510342598, 0.016632800921797752, -0.03652067109942436, -0.027699708938598633, -0.037213463336229324, -0.005524595268070698, 0.006158801261335611, -0.06965182721614838, -0.03649201616644859, -0.0021056835539638996, 0.011401916854083538, 0.029331430792808533, 0.0485835000872612, -0.03861301764845848, -0.03101172298192978, 0.0463578887283802, -0.01056697778403759, -0.018916241824626923, -0.06436152011156082, -0.015963131561875343, 0.019188059493899345, -0.03312792256474495, 0.022686077281832695, 0.021546373143792152, 0.0263983104377985, -0.026253845542669296, 0.014094254933297634, 0.0012059388682246208, -0.038779620081186295, 0.05626283213496208, -0.023245185613632202, 0.025156889110803604, 0.04838461056351662, 0.03803529590368271, -0.018599897623062134, 0.0049406965263187885, -0.037381481379270554, -0.05625303089618683, 0.013281122781336308, -0.010327285155653954, 0.024613333866000175, -0.0038109086453914642, -0.029041973873972893, 0.033909693360328674, -0.00042563691386021674, -0.020839320495724678, 0.020862121134996414, -0.030572306364774704, 0.03484398499131203, 0.031153840944170952, 0.04446236789226532, -0.00757099874317646, 0.016816886141896248, -0.012842769734561443, 0.021034352481365204, 0.018600542098283768, -0.02768886089324951, -0.02800130471587181, -0.015463381074368954, 0.05597620829939842, 0.0199530441313982, -0.04823586344718933, 0.02669549733400345, 0.05879579856991768, 0.011685371398925781, 0.044079381972551346, 0.03502364084124565, -0.018846994265913963, -0.006612464785575867, 0.009369379840791225, 0.033477216958999634, 0.013998573645949364, 0.017414120957255363, 0.022360289469361305, 0.02649359405040741, 0.00357058341614902, 0.03162422776222229, 0.008747901767492294, 0.07165967673063278, 0.014882885850965977, 0.02332446165382862, 0.003797744167968631, -0.01398497074842453, 0.04453473910689354, -0.062257714569568634, -0.014068526215851307, 0.05609966441988945, 0.020619649440050125, 0.04165913537144661, 0.01623249612748623, -0.017711345106363297, 0.0361543633043766, 0.025364086031913757, -0.013042476028203964, 0.008122134953737259, 0.03715531527996063, -0.00878087803721428, 0.023618336766958237, -0.024462886154651642, -0.00888536125421524, -0.022535450756549835, -0.01786758564412594, 0.03296002000570297, -0.03235208988189697, 0.025972936302423477, 0.00751585653051734, 0.009465684182941914, -0.00807545892894268, -0.013703416101634502, -0.008350891061127186, -0.0034175999462604523, -0.03988044336438179, -0.01576477847993374, -0.028572876006364822, -0.058171749114990234, 0.01776220090687275, -0.0582553930580616, -0.03345026075839996, 0.027452658861875534, 0.005881039425730705, -0.0593031644821167, 0.023954862728714943, -0.04161936044692993, 0.0065681287087500095, -0.023730121552944183, -0.03241317346692085, 0.03570522740483284, -0.018167641013860703, -0.023090198636054993, 0.058921243995428085, -0.013599203899502754, -0.04652731493115425, -0.042632095515728, 0.011343240737915039, 0.02863745205104351, 0.002389228902757168, 0.04817558452486992, 0.03347877785563469, -0.014582949690520763, -0.023935111239552498, -0.07033901661634445, -0.04134748503565788, 0.02125394344329834, -0.003766191890463233, 0.03425894305109978, -0.023132674396038055, -0.05159861221909523, 0.08699142187833786, 0.01642058603465557, -0.025431418791413307, -0.005045567639172077, -0.009766483679413795, -0.011868349276483059, -0.005437880754470825, 0.042607322335243225, 0.030384615063667297, 0.003563392674550414, 0.009534806944429874, -0.002770432038232684, 0.037191834300756454, 0.05072701722383499, -0.017641935497522354, -0.011359615251421928, 0.006873138714581728, 0.0010462373029440641, -0.021740440279245377, 0.01074137445539236, 0.028792405501008034, -0.04046636074781418, 0.016360996291041374, 0.017077738419175148, 0.034611452370882034, 0.013502208516001701, -0.046922799199819565, 0.04130576550960541, -0.015765560790896416, -0.017767930403351784, -0.017142198979854584, 0.016060516238212585, 0.020851783454418182, -0.001020256313495338, 0.020957782864570618, 0.00975494273006916, 0.0031068772077560425, -0.01885756105184555, 0.007443406153470278, 0.03820854797959328, 0.04157979041337967, -0.036828603595495224, 0.010054875165224075, -0.02614697813987732, -0.04052392765879631, 0.007783908396959305, -0.00010373220720794052, -0.02479400299489498, 0.0238625667989254, 0.03809674084186554, -0.03031001053750515, -0.001048459205776453, -0.03238892927765846, 0.030165888369083405, -0.05266650766134262, -0.0015928000211715698, -0.0047952537424862385, 0.018588604405522346, -0.01397701632231474, 0.006101048085838556, -0.007506244815886021, 0.012074006721377373, -0.009290439076721668, -0.01329547818750143, -0.007593140471726656, 0.0017788429977372289, -0.047189000993967056, -0.005343967117369175, 0.007370604667812586, -0.03607955947518349, 0.02802649326622486, -0.027179021388292313, -0.03374854102730751, -0.004526872653514147, 0.08345197141170502, -0.025926999747753143, 0.015956716611981392, 0.016144316643476486, -0.0007806159555912018, 0.007885558530688286, 0.018171390518546104, -0.003714034566655755, -0.019261077046394348, 0.028050532564520836, 0.013748539611697197, -0.02183075062930584, -0.05012466385960579, -0.032816365361213684, 0.002783762523904443, 0.01091676764190197, 0.020673256367444992, 0.010720793157815933, 0.017738258466124535, -0.03142666816711426, 0.026925673708319664, -0.02016308531165123, 0.06840851902961731, 0.015343118458986282, -0.04099090024828911, -0.02834024652838707, -0.023135239258408546, -0.031541187316179276, 0.010919029824435711, 0.023687493056058884, -0.005151357036083937, 0.014492341317236423, 0.023118814453482628, 0.028553789481520653, -0.047395844012498856, 0.03247090429067612, 0.03512965142726898, 0.011756419204175472, 0.022570807486772537, -0.07964083552360535, -0.03774508461356163, -0.003593812230974436, -0.03564918041229248, 0.044444456696510315, -0.014928043819963932, 0.009993491694331169, -0.016861997544765472, 0.0364140123128891, -0.020611952990293503, -0.03635108470916748, -0.02990543097257614, 0.005847998894751072, 0.018245743587613106, -0.010468357242643833, -0.04005066677927971, 0.02016965113580227, 0.038219209760427475, 0.015855956822633743, 0.05582783371210098, 0.04424557834863663, -0.07685647904872894, 0.008152611553668976, 0.04530506208539009, 0.02266438491642475, -0.03152567148208618, 0.012493926100432873, -0.04047813266515732, 0.040669169276952744, 0.022337472066283226, -0.011715644039213657, 0.01807236112654209, -0.04231024160981178, -0.03339853510260582, -0.01833142712712288, 0.002112956950441003, -0.009848339483141899, 0.003667693817988038, 0.01165599562227726, 0.002824686700478196, -0.0009319083765149117, -0.011885959655046463, -0.08720587939023972, -0.022838963195681572, 0.027707260102033615, 0.024893570691347122, -0.006685137748718262, -0.009798359125852585, -0.0004684496088884771, 0.05708631873130798, -0.025989852845668793, -0.06527984142303467, 0.019313907250761986, 0.00034713809145614505, 0.00867193192243576, 0.032708100974559784, -0.025719061493873596, -0.030732907354831696, 0.021650809794664383, -0.020518947392702103, -0.054411694407463074, -0.0029356409795582294, -0.011639785021543503, 0.03586795926094055, 0.08268848061561584, 0.021965065971016884, 0.047112591564655304, 0.01402584183961153, 0.004143139347434044, 0.0008275408181361854, -0.009725731797516346, 0.026939796283841133, -0.036710917949676514, -0.029032481834292412, -0.028905775398015976, -0.015994258224964142, -0.014631299301981926, 0.016259629279375076, -0.02389262244105339, 0.0483320914208889, -0.009669503197073936, -0.023045022040605545, -0.02337278239428997, -0.0031227755825966597, 0.018993906676769257, -0.022504549473524094, -0.011490486562252045, 0.0270588006824255, 0.006924424320459366, -0.02802029810845852, 0.026529958471655846, 0.012242864817380905, -0.010186802595853806, 0.03312522545456886, -0.033150192350149155, 0.0006918649887666106, -0.04357130825519562, -0.029304126277565956, 0.03379128500819206, -0.010851623490452766, 0.021882276982069016, -0.03347743675112724, -0.027183406054973602, 0.037298861891031265, -0.06839656084775925, -0.07047654688358307, 0.015505519695580006, -0.013348189182579517, 0.01805085875093937, -0.022564930841326714, 0.023850001394748688, -0.03568815067410469, -0.024776281788945198, -0.0796772837638855, -0.02808191254734993, 0.012129401788115501, -0.019140005111694336, -0.012870977632701397, -0.042550988495349884, 0.0060896254144608974, 0.013625923544168472, -0.022752275690436363, -0.012711434625089169, 0.04813283681869507, -0.010454199276864529, -0.011185155250132084, -0.024775801226496696, 0.005981889087706804, 0.08241766691207886, -0.023979034274816513, -0.02988310158252716, 0.04086887091398239, -0.009680482558906078, 0.012671487405896187, -0.018203679472208023, 0.03724677488207817, -0.03218594938516617, -0.001377747394144535, -0.03224056586623192, -0.0098780058324337, 0.01766381599009037, -0.004191514104604721, -0.019381579011678696, 0.016575446352362633, 0.025129351764917374, 0.03372630476951599, 0.0011801407672464848, 0.006845502648502588, -0.012182118371129036, 0.042121049016714096, -0.02250596508383751, 0.00888518150895834, -0.005215849727392197, -0.026203330606222153, 0.020996687933802605, -0.004151073284447193, -0.029021838679909706, -0.005419633351266384, 0.11289482563734055, -0.006157941184937954, 0.029259081929922104, 0.010013887658715248, -0.04977221414446831, 0.010047475807368755, 0.016274068504571915, 0.031070977449417114, -0.0216476172208786, -0.004386458080261946, -0.027509719133377075, -0.01111539639532566, -0.043434832245111465, 0.01276788953691721, 0.028482113033533096, -0.026089997962117195, 0.06268846243619919, 0.06064921244978905, -0.025132035836577415, 0.01755717769265175, -0.0558459497988224, -0.013814136385917664, -0.018188592046499252, 0.032100848853588104, 0.0632295310497284, -0.004293963313102722, 0.0014150801580399275, 0.06672751158475876, 0.03557460382580757, -0.022190317511558533, 0.05069262906908989, 0.03922249749302864, 0.034910257905721664, 0.011397792026400566, -0.025672880932688713, -0.03931109234690666, 0.043593086302280426, -0.036849863827228546, 0.009213009849190712, -0.04341094568371773, -0.02453756518661976, 0.049336083233356476, 0.0014954789076000452, 0.0071212295442819595, -0.05913718789815903, -0.019660653546452522, -0.006182737182825804, -0.0071546584367752075, 0.001470471266657114, -0.028212765231728554, 0.040382787585258484, 0.00329779414460063, 0.035872846841812134, -0.01196562685072422, 0.044304508715867996, 0.008477146737277508, -0.019340327009558678, -0.018498077988624573, -0.010116688907146454, -0.07671872526407242, -0.011881062760949135, -0.015972934663295746, -0.03149166703224182, 0.011629236862063408, -0.04034174606204033, -0.015926407650113106, -0.015608026646077633, 0.004525832831859589, 0.0022797491401433945, 0.09839482605457306, 0.05422176420688629, 0.03490300476551056, 0.029528819024562836, -0.027255984023213387, 0.10623743385076523, 0.06130596995353699, 0.03240117058157921, -0.06422430276870728, 0.030889956280589104, -0.022201834246516228, 0.009354309178888798, -0.029703043401241302, -0.006680447142571211, -0.002061476930975914, 0.004477584268897772, 0.05161892622709274, 0.061192359775304794, 0.02745855413377285, -0.017467033118009567, 0.03950973227620125, -0.029363585636019707, -0.028830353170633316, 0.03221719339489937, 0.007276640739291906, -0.019125016406178474, -0.028932791203260422, -0.04728156328201294, 0.024056576192378998, 0.017336077988147736, -0.017532827332615852, -0.020023861899971962, -0.020071951672434807, -0.0042841024696826935, -0.0033634842839092016, -0.02580886334180832, -0.021634360775351524, 0.02305564656853676, -0.003086590440943837, -0.01860561966896057, -0.03516996279358864, 0.01760641485452652, -0.02890356071293354, -0.01697375811636448, 0.04433605074882507, 0.01015494018793106, 0.015912577509880066, 0.034471191465854645, -0.006076929159462452, -0.048472948372364044, 0.002559398766607046, 0.0001573426998220384, 0.0012434568488970399, -0.009087543934583664, 0.029081396758556366, -0.05159704014658928, -0.01041420642286539, -0.0424920879304409, -0.026858510449528694, -0.0040443637408316135, 0.0036469290498644114, -0.002133648842573166, -0.009803670458495617, -0.016278570517897606, -0.005343940574675798, 0.014225000515580177, -0.02980772964656353, 0.02852645516395569, 0.0051512084901332855, -0.031807683408260345, -0.025393078103661537, -0.0252232663333416, 0.014277760870754719, 0.017194274812936783, -0.038085367530584335, -0.022883348166942596, -0.012669423595070839, -0.04214978590607643, 0.001955134328454733, 0.004332640673965216, -0.021704772487282753, 0.029584674164652824, 0.006512823980301619, -0.012915855273604393, -0.013275357894599438, -0.0499383769929409, 0.03252764418721199, -0.01908886805176735, -0.022048339247703552, -0.05016017332673073, 0.008891337551176548, 0.05366455763578415, 0.02996562048792839, 0.034190114587545395, 0.024878110736608505, -0.02471676841378212, 0.029028085991740227, 0.0026835345197468996, -0.04820484668016434, -0.0035247798077762127, -0.003926453646272421, -0.012249279767274857, -0.000015101107237569522, -0.0024164821952581406, 0.02170609124004841, 0.04103806987404823, 0.0020007553976029158, -0.016774633899331093, -0.004093542229384184, -0.0185215026140213, 0.033563293516635895, -0.005584843456745148, -0.07353085279464722, 0.018006809055805206, 0.024383530020713806, 0.0027856749948114157, -0.03461560234427452, 0.01112514827400446, -0.013572325929999352, -0.010067619383335114, 0.0025962351355701685, 0.000186878300155513, -0.022976525127887726, -0.005872312001883984, -0.01069727074354887, 0.039314091205596924, -0.020741837099194527, -0.023682432249188423, -0.029352331534028053, -0.008311277255415916, -0.02461598999798298, 0.010614410974085331, -0.023859668523073196, 0.00996421929448843, 0.024924540892243385, -0.010217889212071896, 0.045208852738142014, -0.00784775335341692, -0.001590471132658422, 0.010980800725519657, 0.010757388547062874, 0.008191430009901524, 0.06290865689516068, -0.032570578157901764, 0.01726599782705307, 0.06518398970365524, -0.037221234291791916, -0.045887067914009094, 0.012660983018577099, 0.01440473087131977, 0.014261516742408276, 0.0364798903465271, -0.0017202249728143215, -0.0550185889005661, 0.04621203988790512, -0.05358722060918808, -0.024068186059594154, -0.026815570890903473, -0.013900780119001865, 0.0243829432874918, -0.02233121171593666, -0.05419668182730675, -0.01620790921151638, -0.03966466337442398, -0.011468063108623028, 0.015780212357640266, -0.014341711066663265, 0.00025008677039295435, 0.02039535529911518, 0.005447712726891041, 0.007971838116645813, 0.0020892734173685312, -0.011435119435191154, 0.04397192597389221, 0.03261585906147957, -0.05994951352477074, 0.02766096219420433, -0.005570763256400824, 0.014829838648438454, -0.08586475253105164, 0.0008332572760991752, -0.0023268908262252808, 0.02032226324081421, 0.05735586956143379, -0.05358492210507393, -0.012252953834831715, 0.04256823658943176, -0.029102329164743423, 0.04020072892308235, 0.0020656900014728308, -0.028597569093108177, -0.07494177669286728, 0.002111229347065091, -0.019072633236646652, 0.05303739011287689, 0.0025138554628938437, 0.0035556394141167402, 0.030683310702443123, 0.03272784873843193, -0.01964370347559452, -0.018954843282699585, 0.006680151913315058, 0.05547766014933586, 0.0005442337715066969, -0.022615715861320496, 0.06098321080207825, -0.038414765149354935, -0.020565977320075035, 0.07101695239543915, 0.018964944407343864, 0.027809692546725273, 0.0030899399425834417, 0.017309335991740227, -0.0065514761954545975, 0.013099984265863895, 0.046979811042547226, 0.0008274965803138912, -0.028082188218832016, -0.008206568658351898, 0.009795842692255974, 0.04012100398540497, 0.010116681456565857, 0.0093096187338233, 0.032516542822122574, 0.003593587316572666, -0.05064103752374649, 0.022704921662807465, -0.01838845945894718, -0.043151311576366425, 0.02576906606554985, -0.02233954519033432, 0.04533645510673523, 0.0007195713697001338, 0.05212494730949402, -0.03582800179719925, -0.010664657689630985, 0.06838721036911011, -0.0044037895277142525, -0.030795868486166, 0.03682301566004753, 0.0010584997944533825, -0.016020985320210457, -0.01325108204036951, -0.0037408475764095783, -0.010418861173093319, -0.07130090892314911, -0.002250749384984374, -0.014283320866525173, 0.012238816358149052, -0.030836669728159904, -0.024672584608197212, -0.05969110503792763, 0.04873894155025482, 0.00426816288381815, -0.004984690807759762, 0.023801416158676147, -0.015942519530653954, -0.005474823992699385, -0.07856602966785431, 0.08372922241687775, 0.006101336795836687, -0.01636618562042713, -0.001771995797753334, -0.027895094826817513, -0.031655699014663696, -0.02366543374955654, 0.07506474107503891, 0.0346766859292984, 0.0021162466146051884, -0.0029600346460938454, 0.024714214727282524, 0.04697948694229126, -0.055682700127363205, 0.011831268668174744, 0.009163586422801018, -0.048866789788007736, -0.019707702100276947, -0.036298368126153946, 0.0002691168338060379, -0.014769741334021091, 0.021678730845451355, 0.01651715487241745, 0.006787991151213646, -0.00909874215722084, 0.0029803719371557236, 0.055035024881362915, 0.03438834846019745, -0.02322344109416008, 0.05711159482598305, -0.007984871976077557, 0.018390920013189316, -0.009968636557459831, 0.026816049590706825, -0.063002809882164, 0.010136689990758896, -0.01619480550289154, -0.012124912813305855, -0.013422033749520779, 0.01364369411021471, -0.033513497561216354, -0.02929784543812275, -0.015715062618255615, 0.00617576576769352, -0.05319300293922424, -0.002132524736225605, 0.03155007213354111, 0.02738003619015217, 0.042475052177906036, -0.023447543382644653, -0.003811083035543561, 0.01453751977533102, -0.021733615547418594, -0.008119788020849228, 0.02536640502512455, 0.009284249506890774, 0.007502701599150896, 0.023177580907940865, 0.011582457460463047, -0.01260504312813282, 0.06300809979438782, 0.01961069367825985, 0.03164484724402428, -0.029071466997265816, -0.05031053349375725, 0.008948796428740025, -0.0022278111428022385, 0.04091561958193779, 0.009423223324120045, -0.00466154282912612, 0.05695556476712227, -0.014737357385456562, 0.00843015406280756, -0.06041572242975235, -0.012775430455803871, -0.05013497546315193, -0.04015352204442024, 0.00922776572406292, -0.026701796799898148, -0.02915056236088276, 0.028759479522705078, 0.037412699311971664, 0.04505712911486626, 0.026720957830548286, -0.015310111455619335, 0.05420228838920593, -0.005515822675079107, -0.005824912805110216, -0.04067591205239296, -0.0064062573947012424, -0.032362502068281174, -0.01803203858435154, -0.014636548236012459, 0.046946994960308075, 0.0694127008318901, 0.051396045833826065, -0.03934423625469208, 0.014126604422926903, 0.052630871534347534, -0.09305141866207123, -0.022418437525629997, -0.06107521057128906, 0.0030877378303557634, -0.018796805292367935, -0.01826171763241291 ]
<p>We're working with some logistic regressions and we have realized that the average estimated probability always equals the proportion of ones in the sample; that is, the average of fitted values equals the average of the sample.</p> <p>Can anybody explain me the reason or give me a reference where I can find this demonstration?</p>
49,757
[ -0.02090277709066868, -0.021837981417775154, 0.01283884234726429, 0.014815096743404865, 0.013805045746266842, -0.006940062623471022, 0.010436179116368294, 0.003456912934780121, 0.004713688511401415, -0.04127723351120949, 0.05039966106414795, 0.04342799261212349, 0.047583796083927155, 0.009846911765635014, 0.010151730850338936, 0.005219123791903257, -0.0010518982307985425, 0.03973329812288284, 0.016114845871925354, -0.029996715486049652, -0.00267590070143342, 0.02989831194281578, 0.01917841285467148, -0.02418891154229641, 0.006480785086750984, 0.04936990141868591, 0.06023932248353958, -0.003441284643486142, 0.02117648348212242, 0.09594304859638214, -0.024394292384386063, -0.025838788598775864, 0.010679435916244984, 0.061920199543237686, 0.03801833838224411, -0.009976489469408989, -0.00869238656014204, 0.011827955953776836, 0.005832736846059561, 0.03257468715310097, -0.03339798003435135, -0.0357271283864975, 0.00933654885739088, -0.00230980827473104, -0.023419514298439026, 0.020219095051288605, -0.002116060582920909, -0.06079278141260147, 0.050929564982652664, -0.018596241250634193, 0.04845161363482475, -0.0020567935425788164, 0.04208211600780487, 0.042658042162656784, -0.0016936218598857522, 0.01933509111404419, 0.053743280470371246, 0.06662923842668533, -0.006164723541587591, -0.05124826729297638, -0.01832687295973301, -0.04393982142210007, 0.001806381274946034, 0.014166783541440964, -0.014277301728725433, 0.005949942860752344, -0.02391214482486248, -0.041682809591293335, 0.04003136232495308, 0.021370327100157738, -0.0004320161242503673, 0.02584274671971798, 0.03216325491666794, 0.005556180607527494, -0.008572482503950596, -0.015233887359499931, 0.012539299204945564, 0.015318223275244236, 0.04902468994259834, 0.02156468853354454, 0.012554964050650597, 0.006745506543666124, 0.05340326204895973, 0.01890501007437706, 0.021960105746984482, -0.027414895594120026, 0.0755065530538559, -0.005780912470072508, 0.02731374464929104, 0.017059748992323875, -0.04691557213664055, 0.008889460936188698, 0.038601797074079514, -0.012987121939659119, -0.028614351525902748, 0.0633682906627655, -0.035911060869693756, 0.043254267424345016, 0.0237304475158453, -0.00011075849761255085, 0.0066230082884430885, -0.04107370600104332, 0.008879726752638817, 0.03933853283524513, -0.025069916620850563, -0.020726772025227547, -0.052533213049173355, -0.004909907933324575, 0.015756454318761826, -0.03278033435344696, 0.006656469777226448, 0.03915458545088768, 0.04459302872419357, 0.025494160130620003, -0.003341779112815857, 0.00039241992635652423, -0.006884059868752956, -0.024723727256059647, 0.056878432631492615, 0.02483733743429184, 0.028062723577022552, -0.027046382427215576, 0.008192624896764755, -0.017496563494205475, -0.008230754174292088, 0.019764414057135582, -0.022699886932969093, -0.01671081781387329, -0.03889993205666542, 0.05926763266324997, -0.004326262511312962, -0.038274552673101425, 0.040936388075351715, 0.04790826886892319, 0.028171217069029808, 0.019914792850613594, -0.06165936589241028, -0.024824490770697594, 0.007989603094756603, -0.010147899389266968, 0.011288718320429325, -0.0382540337741375, 0.026208754628896713, 0.049823909997940063, 0.03850094974040985, 0.012725375592708588, 0.05856350436806679, -0.009899264201521873, 0.007195153273642063, -0.0008851750171743333, -0.0024504808243364096, -0.04274175688624382, 0.0010200231336057186, -0.02488616667687893, -0.024609677493572235, -0.095563605427742, 0.048041269183158875, -0.008494437672197819, 0.0029969108290970325, -0.03293738514184952, -0.008228392340242863, -0.019154202193021774, -0.007933108136057854, -0.008049695752561092, 0.029606027528643608, -0.007508925162255764, 0.08507335931062698, -0.011058706790208817, 0.03428788483142853, 0.013480942696332932, 0.008395683020353317, 0.001195848686620593, 0.035827480256557465, 0.0654132142663002, 0.010242000222206116, -0.03225187957286835, -0.041128695011138916, -0.012983203865587711, 0.03189665451645851, -0.00044692918891087174, -0.02097376435995102, -0.009223822504281998, -0.009682132862508297, 0.011282595805823803, 0.01034501288086176, 0.025790905579924583, 0.003467252943664789, -0.04900454729795456, -0.0012580216862261295, -0.037324197590351105, -0.041401006281375885, -0.07567305862903595, -0.007327082566916943, 0.004007985349744558, 0.004604675341397524, 0.01307771448045969, 0.01530318334698677, -0.004879863001406193, -0.0193338580429554, 0.012358617037534714, -0.0500202439725399, -0.04523428529500961, 0.03136447072029114, -0.07024829834699631, -0.0008380323997698724, 0.055499304085969925, 0.026711631566286087, -0.00699286675080657, 0.028562743216753006, -0.05911459028720856, -0.049056485295295715, 0.0070123798213899136, -0.03806624934077263, -0.020537616685032845, -0.044529370963573456, -0.015435820445418358, 0.01612750068306923, 0.01959884539246559, -0.010265485383570194, 0.03575577959418297, -0.07123495638370514, 0.04891015961766243, 0.05512595549225807, -0.01738176867365837, -0.019692743197083473, 0.010264093056321144, -0.010985163040459156, -0.022899150848388672, -0.01065561082214117, -0.03157595917582512, -0.07225415855646133, -0.010043946094810963, 0.012827185913920403, -0.0025242557749152184, -0.033251650631427765, -0.008781258948147297, 0.0731629952788353, 0.020695308223366737, 0.020018285140395164, 0.02885584533214569, 0.029703306034207344, 0.006091476883739233, 0.014775686897337437, 0.020011691376566887, 0.014388855546712875, -0.029034243896603584, 0.0043572536669671535, 0.021964842453598976, 0.014798123389482498, 0.06933556497097015, -0.01036828849464655, 0.00787827093154192, -0.018838223069906235, 0.011985552497208118, -0.019465133547782898, 0.0004782067844644189, 0.014889651909470558, -0.031702715903520584, -0.004798765294253826, 0.028511084616184235, 0.021025674417614937, -0.03488842025399208, 0.004274748731404543, -0.01910095475614071, 0.045450400561094284, 0.04790337011218071, -0.07685697078704834, -0.015732957050204277, 0.024810362607240677, -0.046136531978845596, 0.0021325829438865185, -0.03644539415836334, -0.047752201557159424, -0.02554604969918728, 0.027196459472179413, 0.02621498517692089, 0.00869645643979311, 0.013314779847860336, -0.016865616664290428, -0.02942570485174656, -0.008353884331882, -0.005037516821175814, 0.0077881659381091595, 0.023870287463068962, -0.06336234509944916, -0.0005917928647249937, -0.02898239530622959, -0.044113170355558395, 0.03730647638440132, -0.01397894136607647, -0.04187695309519768, 0.028788050636649132, -0.018403539434075356, -0.06319009512662888, 0.0038669307250529528, -0.021823041141033173, -0.02411346510052681, -0.0426030158996582, -0.0053397538140416145, 0.01673312298953533, 0.017643209546804428, -0.04053696617484093, 0.040301624685525894, -0.022560272365808487, -0.021430935710668564, -0.03778458386659622, -0.019581491127610207, 0.018583809956908226, 0.015222287736833096, 0.01823721081018448, 0.023044344037771225, 0.0036015992518514395, -0.03101644106209278, -0.07550269365310669, -0.07935155183076859, 0.002040113089606166, 0.03585626184940338, 0.03216063603758812, 0.0031864293850958347, 0.00990159809589386, 0.06403621286153793, 0.040615279227495193, -0.02688203565776348, -0.021255282685160637, 0.013083543628454208, 0.006275710184127092, 0.00295062898658216, 0.05075893551111221, 0.00821409560739994, -0.009416577406227589, 0.07064872980117798, -0.012922067195177078, 0.0367034412920475, 0.04880863055586815, 0.028809452429413795, 0.03793694078922272, 0.0010483446530997753, -0.025406168773770332, -0.03118349052965641, 0.02616351656615734, 0.04438680410385132, -0.04663414880633354, 0.024592649191617966, 0.03276324272155762, 0.04827835410833359, 0.021683048456907272, -0.055438607931137085, 0.021618040278553963, -0.004098243545740843, -0.0015827234601601958, -0.007894429378211498, 0.01927870139479637, 0.007363936863839626, -0.017972096800804138, 0.015742840245366096, 0.02619597315788269, 0.028854044154286385, -0.030908986926078796, -0.010058039799332619, 0.03910144418478012, 0.02194017916917801, -0.029968131333589554, -0.036635588854551315, 0.018067220225930214, -0.01963171921670437, 0.02936844900250435, 0.0049910652451217175, -0.03919943422079086, 0.03764420002698898, 0.04558219015598297, -0.004847468342632055, -0.05267170071601868, -0.009374204091727734, 0.016360720619559288, -0.05897454917430878, -0.02162141166627407, -0.006807632744312286, 0.024426663294434547, 0.02017739787697792, 0.031444523483514786, 0.004914505407214165, 0.007650340907275677, 0.006128191482275724, 0.046053167432546616, -0.058165453374385834, 0.013869171030819416, -0.011865987442433834, -0.015939882025122643, -0.027412917464971542, -0.05201186239719391, 0.05426650121808052, -0.05789638310670853, 0.00025621711392886937, -0.0025026083458215, 0.009566213004291058, -0.025616101920604706, 0.009420204907655716, 0.007547611370682716, -0.01547059416770935, -0.037831299006938934, 0.0072473445907235146, -0.022740233689546585, 0.001896265777759254, 0.006846872624009848, 0.057034194469451904, 0.014137248508632183, -0.03731858730316162, -0.022524384781718254, 0.0365230031311512, 0.04303944483399391, 0.044713933020830154, 0.05910669267177582, 0.002863431116566062, -0.0616946741938591, 0.028180046007037163, -0.010227403603494167, 0.06805382668972015, 0.027707882225513458, -0.0428699292242527, -0.008177241310477257, 0.006104231346398592, -0.027104569599032402, 0.011426004581153393, -0.003194555640220642, -0.014596467837691307, -0.003169543342664838, 0.04770933836698532, 0.04474740847945213, -0.05040910840034485, 0.019979823380708694, 0.05336514115333557, 0.0011520396219566464, -0.01012387778609991, -0.050443705171346664, 0.022785186767578125, -0.009643076919019222, 0.011503593064844608, 0.00713486410677433, 0.015007859095931053, 0.00016447692178189754, -0.00027219505864195526, 0.034555383026599884, -0.004495359491556883, -0.0326746366918087, -0.04967606067657471, 0.008145790547132492, 0.03396876901388168, -0.01453250739723444, -0.0679485872387886, 0.02519962377846241, 0.06922175735235214, 0.0044006058014929295, 0.03559025377035141, -0.013344630599021912, -0.04847181960940361, 0.03211889788508415, 0.017060568556189537, 0.01927093043923378, -0.06350154429674149, 0.013101223856210709, -0.01702875830233097, 0.020429594442248344, 0.05264196917414665, -0.0008356290636584163, -0.021486707031726837, 0.0378415584564209, 0.0024355838540941477, 0.007027707993984222, -0.019898859784007072, -0.055090293288230896, 0.009513307362794876, -0.02514137513935566, -0.02378544583916664, -0.013111771084368229, -0.014532526955008507, -0.07544092833995819, 0.036357805132865906, 0.042507678270339966, 0.03621792793273926, -0.02291661873459816, 0.005325057078152895, -0.0145087456330657, 0.03708922490477562, 0.008204000070691109, -0.06534767895936966, 0.008829494006931782, -0.015097588300704956, -0.02121879905462265, 0.0031336438842117786, -0.01909269206225872, -0.03398996219038963, 0.030740825459361076, 0.011914318427443504, -0.05271051079034805, -0.034449364989995956, -0.04629143327474594, 0.012513353489339352, 0.0031722476705908775, 0.004366149194538593, 0.0628616213798523, 0.02400117740035057, 0.007819063030183315, -0.02826167270541191, -0.050540246069431305, 0.0009001503931358457, -0.013330532237887383, -0.029852354899048805, -0.008243061602115631, 0.017818652093410492, 0.022689709439873695, -0.0071548703126609325, 0.028475726023316383, 0.015113177709281445, -0.0013945027021691203, -0.02905871905386448, -0.024159392341971397, 0.007965129800140858, 0.032819993793964386, 0.018800387158989906, 0.000061022066802252084, 0.017898567020893097, 0.0001464342203689739, -0.022261876612901688, 0.020136075094342232, -0.03491668775677681, 0.00005148040145286359, 0.007247840519994497, -0.0028774270322173834, 0.01876063644886017, -0.05624949559569359, -0.00990096665918827, 0.0476909801363945, -0.03506725654006004, 0.020796727389097214, -0.027666941285133362, 0.04459903761744499, -0.01895199716091156, -0.009879859164357185, -0.037775881588459015, -0.003825779538601637, -0.002453944878652692, 0.06000933796167374, -0.04679739102721214, 0.006072201766073704, -0.015970492735505104, 0.0054865567944943905, -0.07417315989732742, -0.04686755686998367, 0.01322735846042633, 0.02243071049451828, -0.025767160579562187, -0.013400912284851074, -0.0023458378855139017, -0.015220895409584045, -0.028231481090188026, -0.009925979189574718, 0.032531775534152985, 0.027365125715732574, -0.04596894234418869, -0.03458711504936218, 0.025053469464182854, 0.05257333815097809, -0.01236764620989561, -0.028512582182884216, 0.01336247380822897, -0.040690574795007706, -0.0005460124812088907, -0.005926568992435932, 0.024888360872864723, -0.04473452270030975, -0.0068344539031386375, 0.003694480285048485, -0.017811834812164307, 0.019541773945093155, -0.01206693984568119, -0.022167116403579712, 0.006327281706035137, 0.0023833485320210457, 0.017114218324422836, -0.0029044928960502148, -0.002396309282630682, 0.01128923799842596, 0.028622383251786232, 0.01143740862607956, -0.0021063375752419233, -0.010301753878593445, -0.004751383792608976, 0.03283790498971939, 0.006595973391085863, 0.004198221489787102, 0.015394994989037514, 0.08893825858831406, 0.01640979014337063, 0.009479409083724022, -0.022634420543909073, -0.06859190762042999, 0.02062157168984413, 0.0228059571236372, -0.016062047332525253, 0.016143277287483215, 0.03717387467622757, -0.02465745434165001, 0.011545924469828606, -0.03417222946882248, 0.009706905111670494, 0.030518045648932457, -0.027776679024100304, 0.04702502489089966, 0.023603787645697594, 0.025868339464068413, 0.0005936992820352316, -0.022015882655978203, -0.032429177314043045, -0.023071106523275375, 0.0056944601237773895, 0.058345727622509, -0.016345065087080002, -0.01943875290453434, 0.023389453068375587, 0.015728767961263657, 0.0030006880406290293, 0.03814902529120445, -0.005976196378469467, 0.035273171961307526, 0.032695118337869644, 0.016387857496738434, -0.02406870201230049, 0.04772269353270531, -0.03587840497493744, 0.0219352338463068, -0.01673666574060917, -0.021668069064617157, 0.04859523847699165, 0.0044401222839951515, -0.007979046553373337, -0.05412372574210167, -0.018020208925008774, 0.0013505967799574137, 0.018421657383441925, -0.010618670843541622, 0.02480950392782688, 0.05661729350686073, -0.0029976514633744955, -0.000011748586075555068, -0.006092826835811138, -0.008398471400141716, -0.015870695933699608, -0.04519907757639885, -0.015312614850699902, -0.01662912219762802, -0.03056589886546135, -0.008495062589645386, -0.007354862056672573, -0.017354942858219147, 0.0041104997508227825, -0.0390944741666317, 0.017469273880124092, 0.01885131001472473, 0.03424202650785446, 0.023028267547488213, 0.09544318169355392, 0.03576139360666275, 0.03954506292939186, -0.02236984111368656, -0.0194252897053957, 0.1152082309126854, 0.09221057593822479, 0.03958629071712494, -0.05222424864768982, 0.01362476497888565, 0.0018510076915845275, 0.008015871979296207, -0.024433040991425514, 0.006292304024100304, 0.005741914268583059, 0.022656677290797234, 0.04307471215724945, 0.04256962612271309, 0.023951971903443336, 0.013033443130552769, 0.03363419696688652, -0.027907896786928177, -0.013227570801973343, 0.0017874103505164385, 0.01986064948141575, 0.009092218242585659, -0.013432740233838558, -0.0402747318148613, 0.01792404055595398, 0.013629280030727386, -0.01612437143921852, 0.0007916439208202064, -0.04939744994044304, -0.02258686162531376, -0.0031245083082467318, -0.00980482716113329, -0.0062323641031980515, 0.05975116416811943, -0.02706034854054451, -0.03171538561582565, -0.0026704822666943073, 0.0016765370965003967, -0.02980835549533367, -0.008077654987573624, 0.02723877504467964, 0.015823999419808388, 0.028286481276154518, 0.02380518987774849, 0.03159609064459801, -0.008595220744609833, -0.020288342610001564, -0.05067097023129463, 0.02424682304263115, -0.013509808108210564, 0.01641811430454254, -0.01810808666050434, -0.011342087760567665, -0.020909735932946205, -0.029630273580551147, -0.008743359707295895, 0.03688520938158035, 0.008807011879980564, -0.02309262938797474, -0.024183612316846848, -0.012699714861810207, 0.0034150404389947653, -0.0024030711501836777, 0.026604924350976944, 0.0403011180460453, -0.029942592605948448, -0.02573954313993454, -0.03007877804338932, 0.02920675277709961, -0.0068222531117498875, -0.004840259440243244, 0.025019826367497444, -0.014873006381094456, -0.051273468881845474, -0.021713312715291977, -0.013722981326282024, -0.027449145913124084, 0.04876735433936119, 0.0017402948578819633, -0.006486989092081785, -0.0189446359872818, -0.05606095865368843, -0.004919371102005243, -0.003215949982404709, 0.007512546610087156, -0.027088230475783348, -0.006992655340582132, 0.002330071059986949, 0.03414382040500641, 0.0015118729788810015, -0.028746627271175385, 0.005034164059907198, 0.02947625145316124, -0.014432400465011597, -0.054832275956869125, -0.014690753072500229, 0.016664089635014534, -0.044750310480594635, 0.014991631731390953, 0.021671023219823837, 0.05651504173874855, 0.010786157101392746, 0.03228502720594406, -0.015194994397461414, 0.02185279130935669, -0.01929820515215397, 0.02800012193620205, -0.03166567161679268, -0.026176244020462036, -0.018363937735557556, 0.02533220872282982, 0.008468172512948513, -0.014315891079604626, -0.045482609421014786, -0.051659297198057175, -0.03870004042983055, 0.04374336078763008, -0.017048288136720657, -0.033112019300460815, -0.0004282902809791267, -0.006695926189422607, 0.04121279716491699, 0.004604106768965721, -0.017663873732089996, -0.045520152896642685, -0.02064061164855957, 0.004084030166268349, -0.03320276737213135, 0.004400444682687521, -0.0023687814828008413, 0.009014133363962173, -0.0029669960495084524, 0.0663784071803093, 0.014158498495817184, 0.01255796104669571, 0.000425088161136955, 0.03646573796868324, -0.008042452856898308, 0.038108427077531815, -0.041015930473804474, -0.020939484238624573, 0.043280553072690964, -0.008945362642407417, -0.020513372495770454, 0.024023329839110374, 0.010889066383242607, 0.03965162858366966, 0.02188475988805294, 0.006112880539149046, -0.04515234753489494, 0.031161045655608177, -0.04081948101520538, -0.044027574360370636, -0.029404502362012863, 0.021537115797400475, 0.016492480412125587, 0.019239358603954315, -0.020540867000818253, 0.025843029841780663, -0.006050606723874807, -0.006608659401535988, 0.03286014497280121, 0.00001604405952093657, -0.01770966313779354, 0.029497342184185982, 0.019065286964178085, 0.04277040436863899, 0.037837423384189606, 0.03035661391913891, -0.0042977845296263695, 0.05140026658773422, -0.01283371914178133, 0.03363613039255142, -0.03968329727649689, 0.023547470569610596, -0.05259507894515991, -0.03716016188263893, 0.004402404185384512, -0.01543133519589901, -0.001541047589853406, -0.03514422848820686, -0.021798986941576004, 0.0479980893433094, -0.05329753831028938, -0.011965821497142315, 0.0032141024712473154, -0.030165815725922585, -0.06301220506429672, 0.002418096410110593, -0.028273141011595726, 0.026881106197834015, 0.05758931115269661, -0.0005202151369303465, 0.0016439255559816957, 0.004746917635202408, 0.007969306781888008, -0.017063336446881294, -0.02661862038075924, 0.0462864451110363, -0.013250384479761124, -0.04314650595188141, 0.038418371230363846, -0.018445638939738274, -0.010486694984138012, 0.08952295035123825, 0.0044501242227852345, -0.021817626431584358, 0.041880179196596146, 0.014937430620193481, 0.002612947253510356, 0.03447280079126358, 0.02098955027759075, 0.011060884222388268, -0.012960691936314106, 0.016399240121245384, 0.046561021357774734, 0.03439558297395706, -0.046399783343076706, -0.00827000755816698, 0.04308011010289192, -0.01958196423947811, -0.08581693470478058, -0.006905793212354183, 0.025283602997660637, -0.008026390336453915, 0.00011504636495374143, -0.011777416802942753, -0.03756548836827278, -0.04492117837071419, 0.04669268801808357, -0.060755081474781036, 0.016358382999897003, 0.05752524361014366, 0.03293217346072197, -0.02242027409374714, 0.020320620387792587, 0.01820351369678974, -0.011188853532075882, 0.003993635531514883, 0.019021522253751755, -0.03704317286610603, -0.047567643225193024, 0.016705898568034172, 0.0033149593509733677, -0.0013862940249964595, 0.00806109793484211, -0.03654883801937103, -0.05860917270183563, 0.013044997118413448, -0.029291238635778427, 0.024360748007893562, 0.030176304280757904, -0.017885850742459297, -0.003939841408282518, -0.09600377082824707, 0.10993792861700058, 0.006793568376451731, -0.03207990899682045, -0.05275185778737068, 0.0008493778295814991, 0.007689278107136488, -0.02179798297584057, 0.05579378828406334, 0.014681805856525898, 0.01586066372692585, 0.007710927631705999, 0.04598911851644516, -0.004508513957262039, -0.02915419079363346, 0.027697952464222908, -0.04042835533618927, -0.04792701080441475, -0.019008196890354156, -0.006728996988385916, 0.017290979623794556, -0.0068097240291535854, 0.01648411527276039, -0.03626410663127899, 0.032651808112859726, -0.030675768852233887, 0.01029323972761631, 0.015130562707781792, 0.014809753745794296, -0.012752212584018707, 0.06789359450340271, -0.016822893172502518, -0.00016000894538592547, -0.005219058133661747, -0.010111353360116482, -0.07356873899698257, 0.0429079495370388, -0.014513219706714153, -0.015115748159587383, -0.020590821281075478, 0.03603892773389816, 0.007176791317760944, -0.04076743498444557, 0.0277126245200634, 0.01859433203935623, -0.053874459117650986, 0.0019291297066956758, 0.03748074918985367, -0.03252431005239487, 0.04185832664370537, -0.010852742940187454, 0.017403922975063324, -0.03459449112415314, -0.030986689031124115, 0.008942150510847569, 0.014688409864902496, 0.007385704666376114, 0.009411090984940529, 0.015637928619980812, 0.023995021358132362, 0.02330639958381653, 0.03602289780974388, 4.081596500782325e-7, 0.005516163073480129, -0.05321647599339485, -0.02440362051129341, -0.017093049362301826, -0.05447038263082504, 0.03143659234046936, -0.008293034508824348, 0.0063866726122796535, 0.05610799044370651, -0.04358288273215294, 0.009551621042191982, -0.04867643862962723, -0.010040334425866604, -0.014270736835896969, -0.040547411888837814, 0.05940856784582138, 0.03358167037367821, -0.008662700653076172, -0.010599249042570591, 0.0595562681555748, 0.004831179976463318, 0.02994176559150219, 0.016022996976971626, 0.0336657352745533, -0.003785826498642564, -0.01652837172150612, -0.0248976182192564, 0.014725714921951294, -0.0008250133250840008, -0.002357919467613101, 0.019624507054686546, 0.005606453400105238, 0.007349604740738869, 0.009289183653891087, -0.04221251979470253, -0.009723649360239506, 0.0820302665233612, -0.04906952381134033, -0.02368057332932949, -0.06100083887577057, 0.04149762541055679, -0.00806577317416668, -0.07617318630218506 ]
<p>Again this question may be simple for you, but it is an important aspect for my classification problem. Let`s say I have 5 attributes, which are:</p> <pre><code>- previous_value_1 - previous_value_2 - previous_value_3 - previous_value_4 - previous_value_5 </code></pre> <p>These attributes are generated with independent events, but I want to combine them for my classifiers therefore I need a way or statistical method to reach that goal. </p> <p>These, values are actually samples that if a process is improving or getting worse. Therefore, taking average of them is meaningless, I need them to generate a function and take its derivative. But, I do not know statistical counterpart for that operation or may be simpler way to do this. To sum up, I need a way to combine these attribute values as one, and that new attribute should indicate whether it is going up or down. </p> <p>I hope I managed to make some details clear to get an answer. </p> <p>Also, many thanks in advance.</p>
74,215
[ -0.006145641673356295, -0.02197258174419403, -0.041893042623996735, 0.024590356275439262, 0.00954651553183794, -0.0046414840035140514, 0.006081029772758484, -0.004287348128855228, 0.018411684781312943, -0.016814840957522392, 0.03359349071979523, 0.019317958503961563, 0.012445496395230293, 0.01175164245069027, 0.007734768092632294, 0.020651839673519135, 0.013725795783102512, -0.02483534626662731, -0.01001223735511303, -0.03783425688743591, -0.003619594033807516, -0.0024908275809139013, 0.027005374431610107, -0.015916595235466957, -0.04901503399014473, 0.022746345028281212, 0.02085968665778637, -0.01972128078341484, 0.004024012479931116, 0.07606351375579834, 0.002558737760409713, -0.030335325747728348, 0.011375601403415203, 0.0770215168595314, 0.033882658928632736, -0.0028408775106072426, -0.03460133075714111, -0.018567221239209175, -0.01675429940223694, 0.04420536383986473, -0.01028413139283657, -0.016400713473558426, -0.023967981338500977, 0.04660501703619957, -0.010546146892011166, -0.023911098018288612, -0.004317546263337135, -0.001691001234576106, 0.031081534922122955, -0.0550801046192646, 0.08827352523803711, -0.05470280721783638, 0.040895357728004456, 0.005301259458065033, -0.013514846563339233, 0.002315893769264221, 0.049350135028362274, 0.0684022456407547, -0.0042621963657438755, -0.060467567294836044, -0.004217733163386583, -0.002403304213657975, -0.009922183118760586, 0.012147887609899044, -0.01826689951121807, 0.014099433086812496, -0.035308804363012314, -0.010050434619188309, 0.03932270407676697, -0.012443171814084053, -0.01055191084742546, 0.02861795574426651, 0.056930311024188995, -0.004868028685450554, 0.0038005230017006397, -0.025186864659190178, 0.0036787211429327726, -0.019043678417801857, 0.030444011092185974, 0.02063608542084694, 0.012672309763729572, -0.01467390451580286, 0.013517475686967373, 0.01988072879612446, 0.025208761915564537, -0.04680981487035751, 0.06786085665225983, -0.030373917892575264, 0.023451466113328934, 0.021907107904553413, -0.014336444437503815, -0.019538309425115585, 0.03478939086198807, 0.009073356166481972, -0.06274911761283875, 0.013309062458574772, -0.0020423843525350094, 0.003986476454883814, 0.03817181661725044, 0.012873153202235699, 0.018474280834197998, -0.06733779609203339, -0.007763285655528307, 0.055019427090883255, -0.035621676594018936, -0.002396064344793558, -0.012096368707716465, -0.03856464475393295, -0.029990483075380325, -0.002033180557191372, -0.020737065002322197, -0.02418481558561325, 0.049012165516614914, -0.03056875616312027, -0.007909546606242657, -0.0031920894980430603, -0.043752025812864304, 0.006622432265430689, 0.0006229699938558042, 0.021286556497216225, 0.03825022280216217, -0.04360238090157509, 0.03819749131798744, -0.026134690269827843, -0.038451895117759705, 0.005515662953257561, 0.006183522287756205, -0.02911127172410488, -0.0017563619185239077, 0.027826424688100815, -0.023921331390738487, -0.009152611717581749, 0.0502055399119854, -0.013919870369136333, 0.025610191747546196, 0.04430650919675827, -0.031675148755311966, -0.01858510449528694, 0.019350994378328323, -0.02364254929125309, -0.0011756973108276725, -0.05817422270774841, 0.008712627924978733, 0.05369262769818306, 0.053531941026449203, 0.059048112481832504, 0.00852798018604517, 0.01889296993613243, 0.015429521910846233, 0.024462802335619926, -0.024065250530838966, -0.0423254631459713, -0.020687386393547058, 0.0023799489717930555, -0.04273006319999695, -0.07494477927684784, -0.012262740172445774, -0.0005173104000277817, -0.04863245412707329, 0.009147042408585548, 0.0019617192447185516, 0.004420632496476173, 0.0402822382748127, -0.022940726950764656, 0.019211221486330032, -0.02085215039551258, 0.05685945972800255, -0.007919030264019966, 0.037913497537374496, -0.005919178482145071, 0.011353926733136177, 0.003198193619027734, -0.002531946636736393, 0.016851747408509254, 0.06491526961326599, 0.0029255091212689877, -0.022449500858783722, -0.00441437354311347, 0.01058866921812296, 0.010967442765831947, -0.014638268388807774, -0.06044583022594452, -0.02204110100865364, 0.0351005457341671, -0.022171299904584885, 0.0004788332153111696, 0.010270539671182632, -0.029945524409413338, 0.03459380567073822, -0.054110828787088394, -0.01838330365717411, -0.07660050690174103, -0.011190377175807953, -0.047442927956581116, -0.01752374693751335, -0.003082810202613473, 0.02548394352197647, 0.047458019107580185, -0.027610480785369873, 0.007694401778280735, -0.012816647998988628, -0.028277140110731125, 0.04398822411894798, -0.03617468476295471, -0.03809897229075432, 0.015737466514110565, 0.0172223262488842, 0.012663212604820728, 0.029705366119742393, -0.022933725267648697, -0.02339053712785244, 0.0186995267868042, -0.040248945355415344, -0.004965204279869795, -0.04207884520292282, -0.007876911200582981, 0.04598207399249077, 0.004162298981100321, -0.00937323085963726, -0.01803465373814106, -0.06219057738780975, 0.07306697964668274, 0.07181872427463531, -0.005635392386466265, 0.022839047014713287, -0.026956040412187576, 0.010324069298803806, 0.0857791155576706, -0.004794843960553408, 0.013827591203153133, -0.025377526879310608, 0.003206726862117648, 0.001969663193449378, 0.03470109403133392, -0.058090876787900925, 0.004576382227241993, 0.08424429595470428, -0.0039913468062877655, 0.0017786495154723525, 0.04301753640174866, 0.010321663692593575, 0.0236755833029747, 0.04718737676739693, 0.02137846127152443, 0.038882382214069366, -0.00903864111751318, 0.030969249084591866, 0.00247069145552814, 0.042567022144794464, 0.005621536634862423, 0.017943082377314568, -0.03094162791967392, -0.021877476945519447, 0.014667872339487076, -0.018226342275738716, -0.0451965406537056, 0.02692759782075882, -0.008524461649358273, 0.005589177366346121, 0.018202457576990128, 0.0021114894188940525, -0.019795358180999756, 0.014337478205561638, -0.012689655646681786, 0.025811560451984406, 0.028884781524538994, -0.051154252141714096, -0.011270937509834766, 0.02355824038386345, -0.009672576561570168, 0.008758309297263622, -0.006454156711697578, -0.011797060258686543, -0.06333591043949127, 0.011923989281058311, 0.060003120452165604, 0.01362358033657074, 0.043897729367017746, -0.01193898543715477, -0.011720986105501652, -0.019348161295056343, 0.004702173639088869, 0.02497033402323723, 0.038546122610569, -0.05341585353016853, 0.03190912306308746, 0.022466126829385757, -0.043706756085157394, 0.06439130008220673, -0.009500608779489994, -0.05479259043931961, 0.009953289292752743, 0.010818714275956154, -0.0417853444814682, -0.02139096148312092, -0.018472502008080482, 0.03367764502763748, -0.012277240864932537, -0.016965504735708237, 0.03773869574069977, 0.006769462022930384, -0.053731344640254974, 0.03480259329080582, -0.044905878603458405, -0.040125250816345215, -0.009203745052218437, 0.005702963098883629, -0.005392621736973524, -0.016600146889686584, 0.007574827875941992, 0.03688996657729149, 0.002429461805149913, 0.0054096318781375885, -0.052842602133750916, -0.08431270718574524, 0.02583850733935833, -0.002877119928598404, 0.03705436736345291, 0.024199215695261955, -0.014466225169599056, 0.04338148236274719, 0.011173318140208721, -0.050922930240631104, -0.01452151034027338, 0.016023926436901093, -0.008110656403005123, -0.006834204308688641, -0.03961629047989845, 0.0229689609259367, 0.011401691474020481, -0.0008545339806005359, 0.03414905071258545, 0.03062230534851551, 0.05861099436879158, 0.012107275426387787, -0.022394176572561264, 0.033335130661726, 0.02503388561308384, -0.0020947405137121677, 0.01761152222752571, 0.040463320910930634, -0.014566745609045029, 0.02804611064493656, 0.01933443360030651, 0.014359701424837112, 0.029848674312233925, -0.04031277447938919, 0.029311271384358406, 0.0003919334558304399, -0.025411130860447884, -0.013009610585868359, -0.007821099832654, -0.004238479770720005, -0.017732378095388412, -0.0172733087092638, 0.04503345489501953, 0.03082410804927349, -0.031209856271743774, 0.028755508363246918, 0.04598027840256691, 0.04725756496191025, -0.02382301539182663, -0.02434004470705986, -0.0077937147580087185, -0.029684552922844887, 0.01861630566418171, -0.047565627843141556, 0.002406846499070525, 0.028550133109092712, 0.04176291450858116, 0.027642186731100082, 0.037071842700242996, -0.027366051450371742, 0.06596264243125916, -0.08035677671432495, 0.013391711749136448, -0.02751768007874489, 0.07139962166547775, 0.05299673229455948, 0.028816884383559227, 0.015717744827270508, -0.01798064447939396, 0.06436282396316528, 0.0024709294084459543, -0.07301340997219086, 0.028802966699004173, 0.044018592685461044, 0.0022510935086756945, -0.035033538937568665, 0.018664900213479996, 0.009492907673120499, -0.021296454593539238, 0.001115602208301425, -0.024669934064149857, 0.0315125398337841, -0.07433496415615082, 0.010305128991603851, -0.014352562837302685, 0.015128172934055328, -0.030077986419200897, -0.00002516736822144594, 0.04475497454404831, -0.01337510161101818, 0.05013423413038254, 0.0007458286127075553, 0.019390201196074486, -0.020526204258203506, -0.009412763640284538, 0.02334456518292427, 0.01793270744383335, 0.004607108887284994, 0.046401798725128174, 0.04907000809907913, -0.04555601254105568, 0.03133470192551613, 0.005460809916257858, 0.08744686841964722, 0.048521704971790314, -0.027104588225483894, 0.00004482955046114512, 0.005026872269809246, -0.02538183331489563, 0.027515985071659088, 0.04448195919394493, 0.02982322871685028, -0.006336679216474295, -0.036303531378507614, 0.017208917066454887, -0.07561622560024261, 0.012658384628593922, 0.10529378056526184, -0.01399235613644123, -0.028654243797063828, -0.050645340234041214, -0.006597153842449188, 0.03026699274778366, -0.02752366103231907, -0.006740123964846134, 0.04609236493706703, -0.021350795403122902, -0.009093469940125942, 0.003376209642738104, -0.004480008501559496, -0.020474882796406746, -0.00026798940962180495, -0.0049017127603292465, 0.043928153812885284, 0.017867252230644226, -0.04478546604514122, 0.01291302777826786, 0.04434715583920479, 0.039532486349344254, 0.025447847321629524, -0.019822221249341965, -0.11027276515960693, 0.02909725531935692, 0.03723759949207306, 0.0602843314409256, -0.05277283117175102, -0.004757771268486977, -0.025914372876286507, -0.021306149661540985, 0.050267111510038376, -0.03535400331020355, 0.03999747335910797, 0.017231587320566177, 0.008838318288326263, -0.012434232980012894, 0.0008641951135359704, -0.03679601475596428, 0.04455922544002533, -0.05166426673531532, 0.007300979923456907, -0.05020183324813843, -0.031040679663419724, -0.052099574357271194, 0.013350846245884895, -0.014783945865929127, 0.0757131353020668, -0.02852334827184677, -0.012058800086379051, -0.039158694446086884, 0.04357646405696869, -0.002150387968868017, -0.048924095928668976, 0.005017797462642193, 0.016190094873309135, -0.022482693195343018, 0.022836370393633842, -0.014638268388807774, 0.011754806153476238, 0.016499586403369904, 0.009328186511993408, -0.03520479425787926, -0.006567474454641342, -0.004823746625334024, 0.04335759952664375, 0.0321359746158123, 0.011689371429383755, 0.047934629023075104, 0.04189788177609444, -0.03076469525694847, -0.011797554790973663, 0.012955679558217525, 0.033211346715688705, -0.008016943000257015, -0.001295163412578404, -0.006888286210596561, -0.009580439887940884, -0.01194339245557785, 0.03474675118923187, -0.02507980726659298, 0.04241782799363136, -0.00988397654145956, -0.0015536636346951127, -0.005920219700783491, -0.00025945858214981854, -0.0253921989351511, -0.07301262766122818, -0.03338717669248581, 0.01057608611881733, -0.011921818368136883, -0.013013496994972229, 0.00604518037289381, -0.029744213446974754, -0.021701741963624954, -0.0044417125172913074, -0.03690330311655998, -0.005831684451550245, -0.05353519693017006, -0.0009240895160473883, 0.006541515234857798, 0.019715644419193268, 0.021981319412589073, 0.004479218740016222, 0.030811311677098274, 0.0459158755838871, 0.009740183129906654, 0.008106321096420288, 0.011961548589169979, 0.025258980691432953, 0.013976586051285267, -0.07420096546411514, 0.042912937700748444, -0.011278570629656315, 0.0187197457998991, -0.053987789899110794, -0.03926017880439758, 0.06796412914991379, -0.005760426167398691, -0.0331825390458107, -0.04119854420423508, -0.03135315328836441, -0.01705428957939148, -0.015115346759557724, 0.010009592399001122, 0.04040418565273285, -0.01686418615281582, -0.012402493506669998, 0.029912317171692848, -0.02507006749510765, 0.06744980812072754, 0.00546785956248641, 0.036188315600156784, 0.03652935475111008, 0.012236983515322208, -0.035663019865751266, -0.008726376108825207, 0.00871818047016859, -0.04930707439780235, 0.010181699879467487, 0.0008573501836508512, 0.01752074621617794, 0.049427855759859085, -0.001123135327361524, -0.03856514394283295, -0.05766959488391876, 0.021834107115864754, 0.005691490136086941, -0.04975663125514984, -0.025119254365563393, -0.041575007140636444, -0.010898143984377384, -0.00730333523824811, 0.0069035873748362064, -0.014628683216869831, -0.014115476049482822, -0.027285346761345863, 0.02024337463080883, -0.02628064900636673, 0.02472885139286518, 0.04813890531659126, -0.006193765439093113, -0.005210217088460922, 0.02590964362025261, -0.020766885951161385, 0.032063864171504974, 0.021935973316431046, -0.0060480148531496525, 0.014880584552884102, -0.009949920699000359, -0.033720411360263824, 0.020307423546910286, -0.03053690493106842, -0.04945572465658188, 0.06132437661290169, -0.002454977249726653, 0.06833183765411377, 0.04016560688614845, 0.028678257018327713, -0.029532834887504578, -0.0027265099342912436, -0.0225149467587471, 0.0057066455483436584, -0.005813530646264553, 0.0599212683737278, -0.005425908602774143, 0.005167980212718248, 0.005330052226781845, 0.013621341437101364, -0.02489779144525528, 0.049204021692276, -0.033404458314180374, 0.021771403029561043, 0.02670368365943432, -0.03679734095931053, -0.0387561060488224, 0.012503293342888355, -0.022969573736190796, 0.00644711684435606, -0.021860089153051376, -0.030175235122442245, 0.015266233123838902, 0.04278305172920227, -0.036540668457746506, -0.07030899822711945, -0.002735950518399477, -0.052202604711055756, 0.004589231219142675, 0.022887486964464188, -0.024248292669653893, 0.05404837802052498, 0.028893763199448586, 0.034849390387535095, 0.02944500371813774, 0.02491459995508194, -0.05262240767478943, -0.0642138198018074, 0.00523195369169116, -0.04062482714653015, -0.05357806384563446, 0.04026973620057106, 0.03141452372074127, -0.017814327031373978, 0.008017373271286488, -0.010064688511192799, 0.03763677179813385, -0.007382304407656193, 0.07228625565767288, 0.023042280226945877, 0.08100000023841858, -0.010813683271408081, 0.02531490847468376, 0.013550003059208393, -0.001936302985996008, 0.13925161957740784, 0.07234895974397659, 0.0022378177382051945, -0.03880375996232033, 0.009257053025066853, 0.05192498117685318, -0.000742985459510237, -0.008939891122281551, 0.01827465370297432, 0.028622467070817947, -0.013271989300847054, 0.011323243379592896, 0.010845184326171875, 0.008548504672944546, 0.027738582342863083, 0.04731226712465286, -0.04089752212166786, 0.015033015049993992, -0.0035713871475309134, 0.03735331445932388, -0.012424515560269356, 0.00837576761841774, -0.06868097931146622, 0.02791951596736908, 0.05355136841535568, -0.004946040455251932, -0.007651167456060648, -0.021726194769144058, -0.01428009383380413, 0.0025425951462239027, 0.007460313383489847, 0.014407068490982056, 0.017459522932767868, 0.039011839777231216, -0.011617155745625496, 0.00006896011473145336, -0.027937887236475945, -0.0004189581668470055, -0.014214174821972847, 0.015387632884085178, 0.08045708388090134, -0.0424579419195652, -0.009013689123094082, 0.034697119146585464, -0.022197358310222626, -0.019925517961382866, -0.05532287433743477, 0.00012998523015994579, -0.01168595440685749, -0.0007510057184845209, -0.022908488288521767, 0.006219940725713968, -0.000685173028614372, -0.04261307045817375, -0.026388756930828094, 0.01531194243580103, 0.02847743034362793, -0.009691323153674603, 0.010510152205824852, -0.01798246242105961, 0.0336398109793663, 0.019308293238282204, 0.0007288947235792875, -0.019787942990660667, -0.025584319606423378, -0.042218901216983795, -0.047892145812511444, 0.040609680116176605, 0.006212680134922266, -0.008213909342885017, 0.006503711454570293, -0.021388305351138115, -0.011260347440838814, 0.020733699202537537, -0.014885787852108479, -0.028174815699458122, 0.003136126324534416, 0.027504436671733856, -0.02504814974963665, 0.010796868242323399, 0.010816865600645542, 0.030272291973233223, -0.02350396104156971, 0.029301337897777557, -0.014244378544390202, 0.003403485519811511, 0.013085589744150639, 0.03531958907842636, 0.0014666399220004678, 0.0035327633377164602, -0.021656153723597527, 0.03660488873720169, 0.016416477039456367, -0.0408952459692955, -0.012443800456821918, 0.015996824949979782, -0.00047506997361779213, 0.013593895360827446, -0.010066497139632702, 0.09109703451395035, 0.0009565007640048862, -0.025536905974149704, -0.03283889591693878, 0.03251870349049568, -0.04222065210342407, 0.012240183539688587, -0.0038030296564102173, -0.02039225585758686, -0.022819876670837402, -0.031463053077459335, -0.00518881855532527, -0.01379731297492981, -0.0005315347225405276, 0.0033271261490881443, -0.05337861552834511, 0.004785439930856228, -0.015560442581772804, -0.011923778802156448, 0.012875103391706944, -0.027201194316148758, 0.018896060064435005, -0.020908094942569733, 0.01723467744886875, -0.04321395233273506, -0.025579601526260376, -0.019054988399147987, -0.02607344090938568, -0.005331503693014383, 0.004979406017810106, -0.021948926150798798, -0.020345773547887802, 0.018495459109544754, 0.033952463418245316, 0.02370254509150982, -0.03436654433608055, 0.030753593891859055, -0.016451453790068626, 0.013821322470903397, -0.03521337732672691, -0.02484779991209507, 0.00426841713488102, -0.04483984410762787, -0.016216862946748734, 0.041344303637742996, 0.013764504343271255, 0.03527893126010895, 0.005173897836357355, 0.00973119493573904, 0.027293305844068527, 0.022482693195343018, -0.023713449016213417, -0.019667701795697212, -0.01578863523900509, -0.005194114055484533, -0.02017671801149845, 0.027482496574521065, 0.009202410466969013, 0.01111106388270855, -0.0010044389637187123, -0.007768161594867706, 0.026324955746531487, -0.025521108880639076, -0.04255254194140434, 0.041744545102119446, -0.019574804231524467, -0.00008515190711477771, -0.004169417545199394, -0.008691094815731049, 0.05481589958071709, 0.018784046173095703, -0.0007221848936751485, -0.008526219986379147, -0.04674500226974487, -0.006896896753460169, -0.062155772000551224, 0.0017907700967043638, 0.008353113196790218, -0.020502939820289612, 0.011276239529252052, -0.07317624986171722, 0.03517485409975052, -0.006011604331433773, -0.033135879784822464, 0.011632350273430347, 0.017865628004074097, -0.018486827611923218, -0.01696809008717537, 0.03488389402627945, -0.034744180738925934, 0.005363864358514547, 0.013284005224704742, 0.03572889417409897, 0.05272764340043068, 0.025927377864718437, -0.006576265208423138, -0.02648717351257801, -0.04778827726840973, -0.002290921751409769, 0.02161054126918316, -0.024152887985110283, 0.02768201008439064, -0.06556384265422821, -0.006447406020015478, 0.02619427628815174, -0.03455229848623276, 0.003177772043272853, 0.02740487828850746, 0.03376109153032303, 0.020963452756404877, 0.06503436714410782, 0.01502642035484314, -0.026742860674858093, -0.02986285649240017, -0.011056147515773773, 0.017517322674393654, 0.024364223703742027, -0.02277064509689808, 0.015458645299077034, 0.02754470333456993, 0.006535216234624386, -0.038603685796260834, 0.0022351148072630167, -0.03837868571281433, -0.06281102448701859, -0.02458668313920498, -0.03207741677761078, 0.009066811762750149, -0.030057702213525772, -0.00631051417440176, -0.0031948271207511425, 0.007817725650966167, 0.003643553238362074, -0.024076996371150017, -0.01782754622399807, -0.003750900039449334, -0.007912163622677326, -0.03772591054439545, -0.011908088810741901, 0.046994898468256, 0.0058135115541517735, -0.03949679061770439, 0.02677789330482483, -0.015541375614702702, -0.0315077044069767, -0.04122186079621315, -0.04805152863264084, -0.03897646814584732, 0.05585203692317009, -0.017806250602006912, -0.0009705625125207007, 0.06475755572319031, -0.021953534334897995, 0.0378800667822361, -0.10025440901517868, 0.038765497505664825, 0.0240760687738657, -0.0180658008903265, -0.010845561511814594, -0.014798898249864578, -0.011983751319348812, 0.014237127266824245, 0.030551111325621605, -0.007613667286932468, 0.00043565663509070873, -0.012403862550854683, 0.031104713678359985, -0.0014227497158572078, -0.04420794919133186, 0.03153844550251961, -0.03166809305548668, -0.005254741292446852, -0.03789568692445755, -0.035452064126729965, 0.025853391736745834, 0.028476333245635033, 0.025544973090291023, -0.003948218654841185, 0.01541170384734869, -0.015056509524583817, -0.0018506714841350913, 0.008163847029209137, 0.002835724037140608, -0.015830250456929207, 0.03998880088329315, -0.009546799585223198, 0.01401666272431612, 0.004741774406284094, -0.0031458274461328983, -0.038677968084812164, 0.048514224588871, 0.005779212340712547, -0.0407697819173336, -0.04118596389889717, 0.003918476402759552, 0.004520168527960777, -0.05699654668569565, -0.03563053905963898, 0.014938924461603165, -0.05037510022521019, 0.02763168141245842, 0.05000494793057442, 0.014792806468904018, 0.036038629710674286, -0.001316518522799015, 0.0224870927631855, -0.028883738443255424, 0.006743708159774542, 0.006886529270559549, 0.0262575875967741, 0.033161308616399765, 0.012875279411673546, 0.012123999185860157, 0.009745058603584766, -0.0027763303369283676, 0.016557468101382256, -0.02835211344063282, 0.000667552521917969, 0.0011662368196994066, -0.0016068854602053761, 0.003255904885008931, -0.004638911224901676, 0.006324228830635548, 0.05447149649262428, 0.009376508183777332, 0.010525890626013279, -0.031574591994285583, -0.006026807706803083, -0.04779888316988945, -0.022914888337254524, -0.0345814973115921, -0.02742111310362816, 0.006662867031991482, 0.019340604543685913, 0.020101111382246017, 0.011854489333927631, 0.022222312167286873, 0.0015717773931100965, 0.019618500024080276, -0.018580060452222824, 0.0724727138876915, -0.0143453199416399, 0.01705116033554077, 0.07562142610549927, -0.015295399352908134, -0.06468607485294342, -0.023384563624858856, 0.019159546121954918, 0.023921340703964233, 0.07862382382154465, 0.021360157057642937, -0.02582533285021782, -0.007374052423983812, 0.016310853883624077, -0.0006713038310408592, 0.00541308056563139, -0.04668985679745674, -0.014617247506976128, -0.012514077126979828, -0.032421112060546875 ]
<p>Following my earlier question <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/16524/multidimensional-vs-unidimensional-measure">here</a>, is there a quick way (using Excel or SPSS) to ascertain/calculate the reliability of composite scores. </p> <p>Reliability in this case is for me to say confidently (i.e. the ordinary not statistical meaning of this word!) that the composite score is consistently measuring the concept. </p>
48,665
[ -0.017745792865753174, -0.030541736632585526, 0.01108978595584631, 0.0016787025379016995, 0.057157039642333984, 0.0018020619172602892, 0.00983368419110775, -0.04419058561325073, 0.04967183992266655, -0.020588159561157227, 0.030430011451244354, 0.010725194588303566, 0.05514872074127197, 0.07478988170623779, -0.022093409672379494, -0.0025651552714407444, 0.0017499633831903338, 0.014808877371251583, -0.006474484223872423, 0.010745243169367313, 0.00746514555066824, 0.006225385703146458, 0.0015275408513844013, -0.022813614457845688, 0.00782732106745243, 0.06552278995513916, 0.039306558668613434, -0.03950929641723633, 0.020245449617505074, 0.08364097774028778, -0.04540984705090523, -0.010477649047970772, 0.057454075664281845, 0.037997569888830185, 0.02213267795741558, -0.003965715412050486, -0.031088707968592644, -0.009235872887074947, -0.03481905534863472, 0.02657724730670452, -0.01083780825138092, -0.05433163791894913, -0.011089924722909927, 0.05469750985503197, -0.004427333828061819, -0.012692396529018879, -0.03684404864907265, -0.024751681834459305, 0.010617001913487911, -0.04010128974914551, 0.06169464439153671, 0.0397283099591732, 0.050139475613832474, 0.025647874921560287, -0.03779885545372963, -0.013890652917325497, 0.05652734637260437, 0.055991314351558685, -0.004713261500000954, -0.035559505224227905, -0.03462373465299606, -0.042231082916259766, 0.03040199540555477, -0.03692273050546646, -0.03645947948098183, 0.035584431141614914, -0.00113476172555238, -0.01472511887550354, 0.06670881807804108, -0.007991635240614414, -0.017216147854924202, 0.03419918939471245, 0.0378606915473938, -0.011678495444357395, 0.006559475790709257, -0.059892769902944565, 0.027260001748800278, -0.0005276824813336134, 0.02722886949777603, 0.04373127594590187, -0.01022301148623228, 0.018508881330490112, 0.022169681265950203, 0.024177828803658485, 0.03393165394663811, -0.01858309656381607, 0.06322392076253891, -0.030467646196484566, 0.016493989154696465, 0.013094078749418259, 0.009541506879031658, -0.024376248940825462, -0.013582874089479446, 0.03260832652449608, -0.028628675267100334, 0.03192039579153061, -0.03409262001514435, 0.03739943727850914, 0.012173398397862911, -0.002008643466979265, 0.01334795169532299, 0.008209782652556896, 0.03698999062180519, 0.04781143739819527, -0.03748160973191261, 0.011379587464034557, -0.03461664542555809, 0.001802978222258389, 0.03810329735279083, -0.04227299988269806, -0.025000333786010742, 0.02247879095375538, -0.019627809524536133, -0.0015082090394571424, 0.03574400022625923, -0.004772020038217306, -0.013428880833089352, 0.003521272912621498, 0.0568314753472805, 0.0632496252655983, 0.04750948026776314, -0.027446700260043144, 0.008411530405282974, -0.02382892556488514, -0.0785001814365387, 0.02118777297437191, 0.03999713435769081, 0.0009676023037172854, -0.016430633142590523, 0.0856451764702797, 0.00811522826552391, -0.01824265718460083, 0.030832311138510704, -0.0019670312758535147, -0.0001915786269819364, 0.028625722974538803, -0.05379238352179527, -0.04563348367810249, 0.009043765254318714, 0.028277838602662086, -0.019756916910409927, -0.05656033009290695, 0.012621384114027023, 0.021991968154907227, 0.044088684022426605, 0.004842274822294712, 0.05063685029745102, -0.004603573586791754, 0.008026838302612305, 0.02688756212592125, -0.04621770605444908, -0.017832115292549133, -0.015210638754069805, -0.07140746712684631, 0.00318259559571743, -0.09857328236103058, -0.013791069388389587, 0.01882515475153923, 0.011422545649111271, -0.028964580968022346, 0.02120189368724823, 0.005730698816478252, -0.00887493696063757, 0.009220169857144356, 0.020749440416693687, 0.008737949654459953, 0.03616248071193695, -0.007600731682032347, -0.010334469377994537, -0.005823175422847271, -0.012374860234558582, -0.03363977372646332, 0.0398578979074955, 0.03099147602915764, 0.029299233108758926, -0.0011604402679949999, -0.016560321673750877, -0.011313335038721561, 0.008044366724789143, -0.04292754828929901, -0.07168610394001007, -0.060394223779439926, -0.023340677842497826, -0.008999984711408615, 0.020990796387195587, 0.05582714453339577, -0.020297620445489883, -0.02359316684305668, 0.015616235323250294, -0.02514340914785862, -0.03738104924559593, -0.050964195281267166, 0.04230407252907753, -0.0004460872441995889, -0.04165659472346306, 0.032634928822517395, -0.03243180364370346, -0.005528455134481192, -0.01366919744759798, 0.00009529056842438877, -0.04357726499438286, -0.015288825146853924, 0.037627898156642914, -0.03989854454994202, -0.005767622031271458, 0.020144036039710045, 0.04681120812892914, -0.030640989542007446, 0.0209804680198431, -0.009075102396309376, -0.0441543310880661, 0.0030902456492185593, -0.051469769328832626, 0.0414639487862587, -0.03909221664071083, -0.04472976550459862, 0.012646734714508057, -0.0034579227212816477, -0.03922608494758606, 0.023631760850548744, -0.038841746747493744, 0.05521121248602867, 0.04061885178089142, 0.01951608620584011, 0.0058905137702822685, 0.013917538337409496, 0.0157148614525795, -0.002041078405454755, -0.01072891429066658, -0.005385579541325569, -0.0643852949142456, 0.0318455696105957, 0.015836194157600403, 0.00014403578825294971, -0.010875051841139793, 0.020487548783421516, 0.07367122918367386, 0.0174980778247118, 0.005432844161987305, 0.0067972829565405846, -0.013764330185949802, -0.039216842502355576, -0.0003067151119466871, 0.016262929886579514, 0.022333839908242226, 0.03163904324173927, -0.0025691369082778692, 0.030578525736927986, 0.038062985986471176, 0.030562428757548332, -0.0030851284973323345, 0.05564352497458458, 0.014053326100111008, 0.010609122924506664, -0.007736552506685257, -0.03289095312356949, 0.035671308636665344, -0.01239580288529396, 0.016236908733844757, 0.043382689356803894, 0.0029424468521028757, -0.010092646814882755, 0.028608687222003937, -0.009000136516988277, 0.052413709461688995, 0.04380801320075989, -0.04861549660563469, -0.017545906826853752, 0.01119600422680378, -0.024264607578516006, 0.006780735217034817, -0.04659039527177811, -0.022489115595817566, -0.02506645768880844, -0.019174424931406975, 0.03111726976931095, -0.0010871547274291515, 0.013191153295338154, -0.019220473244786263, -0.02756112441420555, 0.0035042292438447475, -0.037566933780908585, -0.005687517113983631, -0.030867185443639755, -0.03917207941412926, -0.01366005465388298, -0.0263352133333683, -0.019537653774023056, 0.02354399301111698, -0.015034466050565243, -0.04997674375772476, 0.034197572618722916, -0.006065043620765209, -0.04696840047836304, 0.019648481160402298, -0.0035284077748656273, 0.0034097922034561634, -0.053797680884599686, -0.02705313451588154, 0.03435906767845154, -0.019376007840037346, -0.049802180379629135, 0.02157333865761757, -0.020453909412026405, -0.011222940869629383, -0.008146940730512142, -0.020123980939388275, 0.03846794739365578, -0.02171807736158371, 0.009167278185486794, 0.005036354996263981, -0.012379361316561699, -0.01315053179860115, -0.039878446608781815, -0.04727394878864288, 0.03613114356994629, -0.006931840442121029, 0.026419732719659805, -0.015301357954740524, -0.05227917805314064, 0.04370935261249542, -0.008724319748580456, -0.0660751536488533, -0.032516010105609894, 0.002951210830360651, -0.0011511003831401467, -0.004140256438404322, 0.004620341584086418, 0.0028580583166331053, 0.001528390683233738, 0.008449330925941467, 0.006329611409455538, 0.00431138975545764, 0.0603499636054039, 0.013619779609143734, 0.004800210241228342, 0.01367749460041523, 0.019218986853957176, -0.02292313612997532, -0.016390550881624222, 0.021140066906809807, -0.05971737951040268, -0.002284637652337551, 0.02003590762615204, 0.0005002234247513115, 0.004190544132143259, -0.03339296951889992, 0.02342979423701763, -0.03564447537064552, -0.0008510517072863877, -0.01397273875772953, 0.03238866105675697, -0.002079790225252509, -0.004937927704304457, 0.010067575611174107, 0.042615488171577454, 0.01486595906317234, -0.018634717911481857, 0.009386581368744373, 0.06176463142037392, 0.02744431048631668, -0.007886486127972603, -0.008528600446879864, 0.013131252489984035, 0.016655396670103073, 0.0018572970293462276, -0.019753992557525635, -0.029577108100056648, 0.04517611861228943, 0.044558264315128326, 0.04998006671667099, -0.0008281574118882418, -0.03592401742935181, 0.02075960300862789, -0.08063323050737381, 0.015486050397157669, -0.031104834750294685, 0.04703005403280258, 0.03534707799553871, 0.06025996431708336, 0.023273037746548653, -0.026583606377243996, -0.007110170554369688, 0.01743628829717636, -0.056114621460437775, -0.003255999181419611, -0.03021465428173542, 0.008999104611575603, 0.022306591272354126, -0.011603820137679577, 0.008133510127663612, -0.011548605747520924, -0.018579183146357536, 0.00995789933949709, 0.05350639298558235, -0.028127707540988922, 0.012636068277060986, -0.0014500947436317801, 0.01404882688075304, 0.015329867601394653, 0.040802862495183945, -0.006259771529585123, -0.026563748717308044, 0.054568637162446976, 0.041158489882946014, -0.0006610969430767, -0.012746199034154415, -0.027247292920947075, -0.015039953403174877, 0.010561706498265266, 0.02546447515487671, -0.01726437546312809, 0.013486980460584164, -0.039799388498067856, 0.054808828979730606, -0.008301823399960995, 0.0457550585269928, 0.009592627175152302, -0.02786116674542427, -0.04283292591571808, -0.006215013563632965, -0.018186701461672783, 0.010638786479830742, 0.04317701607942581, -0.005502374842762947, -0.0038202085997909307, 0.049520544707775116, 0.023594262078404427, -0.044835079461336136, 0.05110311508178711, 0.0674930214881897, 0.0016111693112179637, -0.028226304799318314, -0.028515208512544632, -0.005922841373831034, -0.0031106683891266584, -0.029628312215209007, 0.055835988372564316, 0.035702429711818695, 0.0048087467439472675, -0.036564264446496964, 0.03244253993034363, -0.041753754019737244, -0.05089224502444267, 0.014669832773506641, -0.022464392706751823, 0.016339391469955444, -0.010957021266222, -0.05528268218040466, 0.04638253152370453, 0.02835105173289776, 0.035979975014925, 0.049774836748838425, -0.00609240448102355, -0.08597324788570404, 0.032858509570360184, 0.025264648720622063, 0.043167248368263245, -0.08625071495771408, -0.022190570831298828, -0.02095942385494709, -0.025506461039185524, 0.06817567348480225, -0.01878916099667549, 0.020619327202439308, -0.0024321130476891994, 0.025162795558571815, -0.04257557913661003, 0.023735683411359787, -0.0057435547932982445, 0.030588775873184204, 0.03513573855161667, 0.03792653605341911, -0.024638427421450615, 0.01458594761788845, -0.04666744917631149, -0.016081932932138443, 0.048912011086940765, 0.04550541564822197, -0.004144271835684776, -0.032672297209501266, 0.0010120008373633027, 0.009330306202173233, -0.017745155841112137, -0.058339715003967285, 0.02298169955611229, 0.03163612261414528, -0.030582351610064507, 0.05450047180056572, 0.000052705214329762384, -0.04895174130797386, -0.009984822943806648, -0.0051040309481322765, -0.03401864320039749, 0.008163138292729855, -0.014906574040651321, 0.06338747590780258, 0.027202479541301727, 0.007245518267154694, 0.044048793613910675, 0.01407183613628149, -0.00421549379825592, -0.004323167726397514, -0.008091304451227188, 0.01786111108958721, -0.04466346278786659, -0.015017755329608917, -0.01884411834180355, -0.007943017408251762, -0.03850938379764557, 0.02176637016236782, 0.006445105653256178, -0.0017366629326716065, -0.038849443197250366, -0.014543895609676838, -0.021700909361243248, 0.01425364799797535, -0.023608550429344177, 0.01721770316362381, -0.0005836956552229822, 0.0010658048558980227, -0.005580155644565821, -0.002849735552445054, 0.023560263216495514, 0.009389093145728111, 0.015680640935897827, 0.010370360687375069, -0.03671938553452492, 0.012299708090722561, -0.04865487664937973, -0.01963939517736435, -0.021206475794315338, -0.041064366698265076, 0.02669447846710682, -0.003162902547046542, 0.011554436758160591, -0.018298983573913574, -0.08579209446907043, -0.04034837707877159, 0.011158277280628681, 0.02063531056046486, 0.04359571263194084, -0.018047291785478592, 0.02603258192539215, -0.010149704292416573, -0.03413048014044762, -0.06814716756343842, -0.040094707161188126, 0.019189590588212013, 0.042268507182598114, -0.0043909610249102116, -0.017393935471773148, 0.018326085060834885, -0.02096634730696678, -0.025613468140363693, -0.0075262379832565784, 0.032881516963243484, 0.0010774703696370125, -0.021017583087086678, -0.004341894295066595, 0.012005948461592197, 0.07983806729316711, -0.0023429295979440212, 0.017689242959022522, 0.015398201532661915, -0.013772032223641872, -0.021396705880761147, -0.005941293202340603, 0.023499099537730217, -0.04220978170633316, -0.030336229130625725, -0.019517086446285248, -0.00590498698875308, 0.03784820809960365, -0.00025960212224163115, 0.0010801469907164574, -0.017294082790613174, -0.05423140525817871, -0.012809324078261852, -0.01953776367008686, 0.011862486600875854, -0.02125869132578373, -0.02550344169139862, -0.035273708403110504, 0.013597177341580391, -0.054712653160095215, 0.012891502119600773, 0.03141242638230324, 0.0045438832603394985, -0.0019193650223314762, -0.005437797866761684, 0.07864918559789658, 0.00027371413307264447, 0.023309601470828056, -0.014192290604114532, -0.03380730003118515, 0.03922935575246811, 0.05633598938584328, -0.004777138587087393, 0.040189169347286224, 0.011699937283992767, -0.0023690585512667894, -0.007770433556288481, -0.013953665271401405, 0.0047228168696165085, 0.06827576458454132, -0.031791798770427704, 0.04779692739248276, 0.03815736621618271, -0.00856095366179943, -0.011448192410171032, -0.023559316992759705, 0.007328355219215155, 0.016644814983010292, 0.04866090044379234, 0.044407498091459274, -0.0507383830845356, -0.029266782104969025, 0.051468536257743835, 0.009442409500479698, 0.0045382012613117695, 0.0383523553609848, 0.02961660921573639, 0.0388154573738575, 0.02575153298676014, -0.0009846137836575508, -0.016814006492495537, 0.032299697399139404, -0.03594342619180679, -0.011665272526443005, -0.017580904066562653, -0.03226804733276367, 0.02608887292444706, 0.058629751205444336, -0.022622788324952126, -0.028164438903331757, -0.016939064487814903, -0.03731178864836693, -0.00037462011096067727, 0.010383249260485172, -0.011522752232849598, -0.020099714398384094, -0.003069335361942649, 0.03654065728187561, -0.004377434495836496, 0.027921851724386215, -0.004486177582293749, -0.05161500722169876, -0.02083553560078144, 0.02506854571402073, -0.05753142014145851, 0.024654336273670197, -0.027950840070843697, -0.012228239327669144, 0.008418701589107513, -0.02415698766708374, -0.024291789159178734, -0.015512258745729923, 0.07084072381258011, -0.033622581511735916, 0.0574692003428936, -0.018087318167090416, 0.006518037989735603, 0.0014539571711793542, -0.01571938581764698, 0.07813826948404312, 0.06146713346242905, 0.03752247989177704, -0.05287303403019905, 0.03223206475377083, 0.010547553189098835, 0.014140675775706768, -0.03518655151128769, 0.003001854056492448, -0.01982453279197216, -0.022204698994755745, 0.048303477466106415, 0.09948132187128067, 0.03362322598695755, -0.012679305858910084, 0.028102803975343704, 0.010928163304924965, 0.004431089852005243, -0.018397698178887367, 0.018297575414180756, -0.01494168397039175, -0.03255613148212433, -0.007165604270994663, 0.021324321627616882, 0.029113290831446648, -0.017518388107419014, -0.018675178289413452, 0.006080505903810263, 0.001106368494220078, 0.0016038301400840282, 0.008905252441763878, 0.0001896592730190605, 0.05354651063680649, 0.02658919058740139, -0.0463932566344738, 0.000638106488622725, 0.04478049278259277, -0.04652703180909157, -0.006002059672027826, 0.04007774591445923, -0.025233382359147072, -0.004924739245325327, -0.00742204487323761, 0.03426468372344971, -0.054918818175792694, -0.036696434020996094, -0.037419144064188004, 0.0052123176865279675, 0.03651019185781479, 0.0019431309774518013, -0.033261124044656754, 0.011885019019246101, -0.008810499683022499, -0.042484868317842484, 0.003760028164833784, 0.030009547248482704, -0.005665749777108431, -0.028979076072573662, -0.005627375561743975, -0.001866176724433899, 0.011769970878958702, -0.04230103641748428, 0.036057960242033005, -0.0033423432614654303, -0.020152749493718147, -0.0206003338098526, -0.016950245946645737, 0.03607664629817009, 0.02621040865778923, 0.007900023832917213, -0.02272261120378971, -0.013863794505596161, -0.04206147417426109, 0.012370502576231956, 0.02226223610341549, -0.006115416064858437, 0.013450412079691887, 0.028729919344186783, 0.002656002528965473, -0.012583279982209206, -0.03989410027861595, 0.015643564984202385, -0.03737674653530121, -0.003490776289254427, -0.044634897261857986, -0.00432930514216423, 0.05696665123105049, 0.012783239595592022, 0.0029448503628373146, 0.014097577892243862, -0.04153580218553543, 0.03139037638902664, 0.021180082112550735, -0.05465220659971237, -0.002300716470927, -0.004364341497421265, -0.031478602439165115, -0.012289640493690968, -0.02532920613884926, 0.0025415162090212107, 0.018588028848171234, 0.04011622816324234, -0.03654457628726959, 0.051182836294174194, -0.0005116654792800546, 0.0444694347679615, 0.0016272157663479447, -0.07088062912225723, -0.02363644912838936, 0.007255821488797665, -0.009296281263232231, 0.02004912681877613, -0.024186527356505394, -0.04338538274168968, -0.011248554103076458, 0.01683688536286354, -0.006563188973814249, -0.02952282875776291, -0.017561709508299828, 0.016994593665003777, 0.010523008182644844, -0.03589853644371033, -0.012487703002989292, -0.02414512261748314, -0.012760724872350693, 0.001869699452072382, 0.002108497777953744, -0.01591378264129162, -0.009018858894705772, -0.034614235162734985, 0.003173753386363387, 0.051712516695261, 0.0012843949953094125, -0.0059056407772004604, -0.015253780409693718, 0.020514341071248055, 0.008023624308407307, 0.06648574024438858, -0.024637237191200256, -0.018417924642562866, 0.050616346299648285, -0.03907894715666771, -0.01553578581660986, 0.01811293512582779, -0.02133699133992195, 0.031340084969997406, 0.02711186744272709, 0.005301820579916239, -0.048773400485515594, 0.03762178122997284, -0.018159976229071617, -0.0098132798448205, 0.004361508414149284, -0.00530517753213644, -0.008553601801395416, 0.020880598574876785, -0.002610704628750682, -0.014001758769154549, -0.042674437165260315, 0.03892137110233307, 0.0525791235268116, 0.03145956993103027, 0.02925592102110386, 0.04367975890636444, -0.011456144042313099, 0.010066460818052292, 0.036386050283908844, -0.028037726879119873, 0.0007502067601308227, 0.03675070405006409, -0.024182843044400215, 0.01518662553280592, 0.0025058079045265913, 0.0027286000549793243, -0.0782233476638794, -0.006875360384583473, 0.001283637946471572, 0.013929154723882675, 0.009939905256032944, -0.05074862390756607, 0.0058325412683188915, 0.02999795414507389, -0.033677421510219574, 0.018266145139932632, 0.0002681687183212489, -0.02721712738275528, -0.0067581781186163425, -0.018742617219686508, -0.021786978468298912, 0.06092098355293274, -0.013135886751115322, 0.01105889305472374, -0.022557063028216362, 0.011807146482169628, -0.024952061474323273, -0.0037561370991170406, 0.024462688714265823, 0.02470282092690468, 0.011344131082296371, -0.0788353979587555, 0.0394476056098938, -0.0403122678399086, -0.034067895263433456, 0.06365328282117844, 0.003621606854721904, 0.04185957834124565, 0.019338024780154228, 0.03795401006937027, 0.013651537708938122, 0.0008290134137496352, 0.02013278938829899, -0.0044709485955536366, 0.0038688869681209326, 0.013595274649560452, 0.01310433354228735, 0.01737712137401104, -0.02178770862519741, 0.023961160331964493, 0.028112364932894707, 0.020685270428657532, -0.057278137654066086, 0.03990945592522621, -0.03341115266084671, -0.015244071371853352, -0.023511821404099464, -0.02543320134282112, 0.04783957824110985, -0.040074367076158524, 0.03603597357869148, -0.07060237973928452, -0.003366900375112891, 0.04616210237145424, 0.014325636439025402, 0.005380720365792513, 0.046867962926626205, 0.018444159999489784, -0.031987860798835754, 0.051836006343364716, -0.02500210888683796, -0.01423137541860342, -0.05492546781897545, -0.03144308179616928, 0.012599158100783825, 0.01132859755307436, -0.008027639240026474, 0.009044941514730453, -0.021073494106531143, 0.047522082924842834, -0.02310909703373909, 0.0348232202231884, 0.021528273820877075, -0.040520671755075455, 0.016759414225816727, -0.05790315568447113, 0.05322239175438881, 0.020348304882645607, -0.04997217282652855, -0.014003464952111244, -0.015833500772714615, -0.028797628358006477, -0.0081761060282588, 0.08999033272266388, -0.025119075551629066, 0.0339946411550045, -0.014066405594348907, 0.03656928986310959, 0.016105763614177704, -0.0584457591176033, 0.01526237279176712, 0.013566444627940655, -0.05424999073147774, -0.03592787683010101, -0.02034970372915268, 0.014141207560896873, -0.015673931688070297, 0.05085239186882973, -0.041973572224378586, 0.016439171507954597, -0.011228245683014393, -0.006074599921703339, 0.031016752123832703, -0.005902010947465897, -0.031215934082865715, 0.050373028963804245, -0.0024027652107179165, 0.01616887003183365, 0.03921835497021675, 0.0027856738306581974, -0.018247978761792183, 0.04382508620619774, -0.018232276663184166, 0.010421824641525745, 0.004531526938080788, 0.018521921709179878, -0.05197703838348389, -0.09340263903141022, -0.011287901550531387, 0.012944812886416912, -0.06605522334575653, -0.01363084465265274, 0.024912133812904358, 0.05543641000986099, 0.019399557262659073, 0.0006477969000115991, -0.007296303287148476, 0.0363883450627327, -0.043307237327098846, -0.009937899187207222, 0.05195105820894241, 0.07277971506118774, 0.009763074107468128, 0.01203551422804594, 0.003138147760182619, -0.015469580888748169, 0.05023747682571411, -0.008397531695663929, 0.0533117838203907, -0.02563047967851162, -0.02498033083975315, 0.017557471990585327, -0.0243099182844162, 0.039997804909944534, 0.0006553343264386058, -0.041723791509866714, 0.05453847721219063, -0.012937204912304878, -0.0022575773764401674, -0.037823159247636795, -0.007587753236293793, -0.04590224847197533, -0.013677539303898811, 0.07851196825504303, 0.054706331342458725, -0.008298486471176147, 0.005627591162919998, -0.018645819276571274, 0.013618817552924156, 0.026388246566057205, 0.0016025452641770244, 0.017723433673381805, -0.029272571206092834, 0.02103821001946926, -0.027340002357959747, -0.006449198815971613, -0.028334401547908783, -0.01084242295473814, 0.024421600624918938, -0.007430274970829487, 0.03218027949333191, -0.0038021765649318695, -0.01084911823272705, 0.012575792148709297, 0.055829908698797226, -0.07289202511310577, -0.02184692956507206, -0.059778306633234024, 0.015183825045824051, 0.013339398428797722, 0.02359805442392826 ]
<p>I am currently generating data by simulating a model of chemical system under different conditions (temperature) over time. In each simulation, the starting structure being modeled is exactly the same - only the temperature is different. The system is allowed to propagate over time and the length and number of observations in each simulation is identical. I would like to compare mean values e.g. distances between two atom under the different conditions. I have two questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>Should I regard the two simulations I have (high and low temperature) as paired data. How would an analogous human study be treated (e.g. comparing the behaviour of a single human participant under during a 1 hour period under condition 1 and another 1 hour period after an extensive washout period - under condition 2)? </p></li> <li><p>Since I effectively have two time series, what are the implications of the distance I want to measure being autocorrelated in some way? </p></li> </ol>
74,216
[ -0.043121688067913055, -0.00505219679325819, -0.02711409516632557, -0.00496642105281353, 0.011023856699466705, 0.009958080016076565, -0.0415429025888443, 0.006887099239975214, 0.010050243698060513, 0.009362981654703617, 0.05367741733789444, 0.05135514587163925, 0.023720525205135345, 0.008100880309939384, 0.0044794464483857155, -0.014089291915297508, -0.023009104654192924, 0.005776650737971067, 0.0066432342864573, -0.021657539531588554, 0.033366572111845016, -0.026303499937057495, 0.018701978027820587, -0.03862832859158516, -0.02761576697230339, 0.06157071143388748, -0.01642627641558647, -0.05718038231134415, 0.0022660652175545692, 0.029055016115307808, -0.02914183959364891, -0.03833919018507004, 0.011674167588353157, -0.007313145324587822, 0.022755024954676628, 0.013553638942539692, -0.03965580090880394, -0.025384042412042618, 0.015683891251683235, 0.047095585614442825, -0.03899669274687767, -0.012281428091228008, -0.02127641998231411, 0.028049437329173088, -0.028713824227452278, 0.0007612881599925458, -0.008571680635213852, -0.015360559336841106, 0.010300412774085999, -0.005559283774346113, 0.039020854979753494, -0.006970222108066082, 0.03888155519962311, 0.01878465712070465, -0.0046263872645795345, -0.00865633599460125, 0.04843498766422272, 0.007541709579527378, 0.013314370065927505, -0.06034373492002487, -0.00357881304807961, -0.0062565249390900135, 0.016577452421188354, 0.009326661005616188, -0.02227538451552391, 0.03656480833888054, -0.017301449552178383, -0.0584404394030571, 0.004533090628683567, 0.0070442394353449345, 0.029371662065386772, 0.009669382125139236, 0.02712726779282093, -0.0035737911239266396, 0.061111241579055786, 0.006976263597607613, 0.014095453545451164, 0.027485007420182228, 0.06445647776126862, 0.04944745823740959, -0.004401073325425386, -0.0022605699487030506, 0.006786304991692305, 0.028417019173502922, -0.0046350653283298016, -0.006975388620048761, 0.06299691647291183, -0.04035630077123642, -0.004014233592897654, 0.03887040168046951, 0.01721588894724846, 0.021719111129641533, 0.027313321828842163, 0.02974683791399002, -0.015036326833069324, 0.012607517652213573, 0.01861785165965557, 0.04858746379613876, -0.00935116782784462, 0.006059534847736359, -0.03533294051885605, -0.0663880780339241, 0.014732006005942822, 0.027897339314222336, -0.0013249033363536, -0.024465829133987427, 0.004735010210424662, -0.019828997552394867, -0.02748916670680046, -0.01813732460141182, -0.0435016043484211, -0.0029638030100613832, 0.008894883096218109, -0.009779876098036766, 0.039447933435440063, -0.007329715881496668, 0.007841733284294605, -0.025563552975654602, 0.05081239342689514, 0.07944542914628983, 0.04211472347378731, -0.022685877978801727, 0.00047642880235798657, 0.008172268979251385, -0.05386091396212578, 0.0031683461274951696, 0.0036829086020588875, -0.011168427765369415, -0.03940688446164131, 0.06228720024228096, -0.010524298995733261, -0.007690306752920151, 0.021104343235492706, -0.0351407527923584, 0.04388756677508354, 0.025545556098222733, -0.10552242398262024, -0.05527787655591965, 0.03580227494239807, 0.0013158655492588878, 0.0030256304889917374, -0.05481116473674774, 0.004683405626565218, -0.015868311747908592, 0.039290934801101685, 0.021513715386390686, 0.016026731580495834, -0.007667248602956533, 0.03175840899348259, 0.025505803525447845, -0.010568427853286266, -0.018360767513513565, -0.02125518023967743, -0.022037159651517868, -0.005860528443008661, -0.07576529681682587, 0.04065875709056854, 0.02780310809612274, -0.015473749488592148, 0.03766191750764847, 0.036676447838544846, -0.005119338631629944, -0.011310260742902756, 0.03351805731654167, 0.02511841244995594, -0.012930229306221008, 0.05207701772451401, -0.004368624184280634, 0.028710512444376945, -0.003397682448849082, 0.00316228112205863, 0.010918822139501572, 0.009903443977236748, 0.027492709457874298, 0.04056680575013161, 0.020281802862882614, -0.011271873489022255, 0.05143553018569946, -0.02497832477092743, 0.0310869999229908, -0.0425938218832016, -0.011281082406640053, -0.015002564527094364, -0.013789218850433826, 0.02057483233511448, 0.04573230817914009, 0.01882197894155979, 0.010632683522999287, 0.040542494505643845, -0.02510899491608143, -0.0359623022377491, -0.0843140110373497, -0.02122241072356701, -0.02051755040884018, -0.007635126821696758, 0.03641142323613167, 0.003512387629598379, 0.023535769432783127, -0.015608553774654865, -0.0512913279235363, -0.03962638974189758, 0.002466088393703103, 0.06436681747436523, -0.025681262835860252, 0.038282521069049835, 0.06859259307384491, 0.02892414852976799, 0.002441387390717864, 0.024294894188642502, -0.02181253768503666, -0.050516340881586075, -0.026006218045949936, -0.051562242209911346, 0.008405751548707485, -0.005091988015919924, -0.00621942849829793, 0.005861824844032526, -0.009645436890423298, -0.03991548344492912, 0.028235241770744324, -0.03451964631676674, 0.08335931599140167, 0.04648575186729431, -0.0235322006046772, -0.008378562517464161, 0.05421978607773781, 0.03772763907909393, -0.005341961979866028, -0.015383778139948845, -0.01919783465564251, -0.07314566522836685, -0.02164456807076931, 0.04915791004896164, 0.05301591753959656, -0.05031939968466759, 0.018500616773962975, 0.038095612078905106, 0.029282202944159508, 0.001524563878774643, 0.0059271641075611115, -0.0016068918630480766, -0.03782346844673157, 0.01953212171792984, 0.0007308616768568754, 0.023754801601171494, -0.00885465182363987, 0.003669538302347064, -0.022292517125606537, 0.016798540949821472, -0.03564702346920967, -0.024740315973758698, 0.026382604613900185, 0.03381754085421562, 0.005319705232977867, -0.045129865407943726, -0.0353926420211792, 0.005230491980910301, -0.01457693800330162, -0.009119801223278046, -0.0030769375152885914, 0.021481776610016823, -0.020123304799199104, -0.010749169625341892, -0.011107776314020157, 0.0009355397778563201, 0.0665430948138237, 0.011957170441746712, 0.010159623809158802, 0.017326589673757553, -0.032682307064533234, 0.0029162492137402296, -0.02976410649716854, -0.018923059105873108, -0.015019023790955544, -0.002199963666498661, 0.05834965407848358, 0.026618992909789085, 0.0369996540248394, -0.026999780908226967, -0.0022040465846657753, -0.008207755163311958, -0.009916276670992374, 0.03154875338077545, 0.021308787167072296, -0.010491102933883667, 0.013207757845520973, -0.012179652228951454, -0.024267248809337616, 0.0014381338842213154, -0.01717977412045002, 0.00793091394007206, 0.04006848484277725, -0.020905524492263794, -0.05391369014978409, -0.06887505948543549, -0.024182608351111412, 0.00812213309109211, -0.030537579208612442, 0.0020643952302634716, 0.03889567777514458, -0.02285609394311905, -0.05334516242146492, 0.017901156097650528, -0.045637283474206924, 0.024866348132491112, -0.01591111347079277, -0.018732409924268723, 0.016952380537986755, 0.004828264005482197, -0.02463175728917122, 0.04850511997938156, -0.03159806877374649, -0.032301340252161026, -0.07473774999380112, -0.034794460982084274, 0.04845065250992775, -0.007934151217341423, 0.022604908794164658, 0.0218396857380867, 0.007459727581590414, 0.06172284856438637, 0.028860783204436302, -0.014587752521038055, -0.0642772987484932, -0.004546868149191141, -0.056953977793455124, -0.03595219925045967, 0.04450548067688942, 0.009445508942008018, -0.018732825294137, 0.000372138136299327, 0.023592509329319, 0.052068080753088, 0.05563889071345329, -0.013002264313399792, -0.00418996624648571, 0.021176734939217567, 0.014409934170544147, 0.0027578123845160007, 0.04857674241065979, 0.01790197752416134, -0.033953238278627396, 0.0025749218184500933, -0.01595294661819935, 0.033445410430431366, 0.012956732884049416, -0.08051429688930511, 0.04665718227624893, -0.003393773455172777, 0.000012858588888775557, -0.055332738906145096, 0.03338996320962906, -0.008515342138707638, -0.027709973976016045, -0.02932136319577694, 0.060360852628946304, 0.02023349143564701, 0.001466704998165369, -0.0072075664065778255, 0.07907545566558838, 0.059595443308353424, -0.026773639023303986, -0.02134559117257595, -0.0017427313141524792, -0.0034078864846378565, 0.03815935179591179, -0.04206644371151924, -0.04513096436858177, 0.020457452163100243, 0.011162618175148964, 0.04547623172402382, 0.01562359370291233, -0.07250670343637466, -0.03079202212393284, -0.09854748845100403, -0.008047358132898808, -0.020055271685123444, 0.08293323963880539, 0.007334086112678051, 0.044723253697156906, 0.005465824156999588, 0.0015666274121031165, -0.01799595169723034, -0.02483760192990303, -0.043172165751457214, 0.002843117108568549, 0.0009122956544160843, -0.03929392620921135, 0.012081349268555641, -0.03478236496448517, 0.03034089505672455, -0.04824221879243851, 0.03772567957639694, 0.009027370251715183, 0.05023062601685524, -0.016990935429930687, -0.013199281878769398, -0.042780693620443344, -0.041017960757017136, -0.029380204156041145, 0.01840401068329811, 0.033501069992780685, -0.013130479492247105, 0.06131170317530632, 0.026721440255641937, -0.011080494150519371, -0.02170534059405327, -0.020175961777567863, 0.039147086441516876, 0.04246903583407402, 0.01038646511733532, 0.01931227184832096, 0.011830514296889305, -0.05232128128409386, 0.03196137398481369, 0.02095862664282322, 0.032252244651317596, 0.04090723767876625, 0.008543961681425571, -0.00845846813172102, -0.037645887583494186, -0.044052399694919586, 0.023260528221726418, 0.026499366387724876, 0.033326733857393265, -0.0005936955567449331, 0.01585051417350769, 0.03491152077913284, -0.049058668315410614, -0.003616271773353219, 0.04090004414319992, 0.00448234286159277, 0.01008173730224371, -0.025723136961460114, -0.04230676591396332, 0.02607751451432705, 0.012209913693368435, 0.04548937454819679, 0.006795841734856367, -0.0007330544758588076, 0.002503570169210434, 0.005622312892228365, 0.043164607137441635, -0.02779695950448513, 0.02290414646267891, 0.032258473336696625, 0.06103479862213135, 0.022008297964930534, -0.013462518341839314, -0.00021057830599602312, 0.0215800479054451, 0.029078451916575432, 0.031448930501937866, -0.0004004835500381887, -0.08869680762290955, -0.00938695389777422, 0.019338132813572884, 0.03429151698946953, -0.0029172368813306093, 0.033538445830345154, -0.02275165356695652, -0.01928708888590336, 0.022933999076485634, -0.005616050213575363, 0.04970484972000122, -0.00980580784380436, -0.01910299062728882, -0.00879649631679058, -0.05017415061593056, -0.01692046970129013, 0.03539527580142021, -0.007478826213628054, 0.0016112535959109664, -0.013098414056003094, -0.04694751277565956, 0.0008958213729783893, 0.00019746254838537425, -0.005673631094396114, 0.029327673837542534, -0.05859243497252464, -0.013642496429383755, 0.0056761144660413265, -0.0024552291724830866, 0.005204844754189253, -0.08019363135099411, 0.0009245396940968931, 0.02680291049182415, -0.007102128118276596, 0.0520903654396534, 0.004798060283064842, 0.0017606350593268871, 0.014014653861522675, -0.013297146186232567, -0.012462706305086613, -0.01614813320338726, -0.01513646636158228, 0.05723485350608826, 0.04544886201620102, -0.02979188784956932, 0.05350402742624283, 0.0334036685526371, 0.009259087033569813, 0.000023446134946425445, -0.024951966479420662, 0.024634143337607384, -0.017265239730477333, -0.00863883551210165, -0.06754230707883835, -0.01421100739389658, -0.02410213276743889, 0.045603662729263306, -0.0044264597818255424, 0.04543249309062958, -0.008157942444086075, -0.028382273390889168, 0.02890717424452305, 0.026450764387845993, -0.0025534923188388348, -0.022496869787573814, -0.02914859540760517, 0.013441117480397224, -0.02613220550119877, -0.037459198385477066, -0.007346923463046551, -0.036761268973350525, 0.01468570064753294, 0.00044901040382683277, -0.04600084200501442, 0.000634165306109935, -0.0214232224971056, -0.02273462899029255, -0.0034483952913433313, -0.06028839200735092, 0.022335801273584366, -0.004605056717991829, 0.015102498233318329, 0.02395423874258995, -0.031438201665878296, 0.01056650560349226, 0.04406069591641426, -0.007453281432390213, 0.017800331115722656, -0.01614796370267868, 0.026393361389636993, -0.034931622445583344, -0.007099575363099575, -0.04636366292834282, -0.03857623040676117, 0.024319704622030258, 0.0030543706379830837, -0.026058677583932877, -0.04671158269047737, -0.019314896315336227, 0.007949891500175, 0.0020002909004688263, -0.0004693679802585393, 0.08683409541845322, -0.023600896820425987, -0.03817491978406906, -0.02852260321378708, 0.021380050107836723, 0.05089852586388588, 0.028144516050815582, -0.01090509444475174, -0.00587494345381856, 0.020868834108114243, -0.02589118666946888, 0.00504694040864706, 0.03188303858041763, -0.04541369900107384, -0.012991301715373993, -0.038676392287015915, 0.003570748958736658, 0.04633577913045883, -0.04441434517502785, -0.040144264698028564, 0.009830239228904247, 0.01053454540669918, 0.01737220212817192, -0.041951362043619156, 0.0004436493036337197, -0.023832052946090698, 0.004503297153860331, -0.0225315410643816, 0.012440887279808521, 0.01537660788744688, -0.034591175615787506, -0.011519121937453747, 0.03128598630428314, -0.048026200383901596, 0.025322234258055687, 0.008502057753503323, -0.022210437804460526, -0.02483079954981804, 0.03510935604572296, -0.016138391569256783, 0.02812626026570797, -0.019332388415932655, -0.021893585100769997, 0.0359264612197876, 0.012133287265896797, -0.026855705305933952, -0.029676003381609917, -0.030581625178456306, -0.047078657895326614, 0.08759693801403046, -0.002917136298492551, 0.06478127092123032, 0.04576361924409866, -0.017749128863215446, 0.006172893103212118, -0.02849068120121956, 0.003250562120229006, -0.0060538542456924915, 0.004215608350932598, 0.03959479555487633, -0.019323335960507393, -0.03172139823436737, 0.04200271517038345, 0.03008303791284561, -0.011286149732768536, 0.04880042374134064, -0.004822668619453907, 0.017607590183615685, 0.00946580246090889, -0.018922921270132065, -0.03655928373336792, 0.036402326077222824, -0.06690234690904617, 0.03392229229211807, -0.046851612627506256, 0.0036498489789664745, 0.03559577465057373, 0.05880409851670265, 0.01564618945121765, -0.051199860870838165, -0.015802612528204918, -0.052278220653533936, 0.005211287178099155, 0.024127518758177757, 0.015429734252393246, 0.04958483204245567, 0.0032872729934751987, 0.08402621746063232, -0.011970468796789646, -0.012349084950983524, -0.0034549327101558447, -0.03416649252176285, -0.010549264028668404, 0.016293756663799286, 0.004075218923389912, 0.050417352467775345, -0.024576418101787567, -0.043433260172605515, -0.008786874823272228, -0.033798594027757645, 0.008426666259765625, -0.003611201886087656, 0.03155537694692612, -0.0338379442691803, 0.07420554757118225, 0.019101297482848167, 0.00923849269747734, -0.014210391789674759, 0.005287822335958481, 0.125904381275177, 0.05220630392432213, 0.04221724346280098, -0.03563487529754639, 0.016090331599116325, 0.01872008852660656, -0.0005373224266804755, -0.015281597152352333, 0.022719519212841988, 0.00042749670683406293, -0.00042598109575919807, 0.03720749542117119, 0.025489121675491333, 0.026112448424100876, -0.012375242076814175, 0.08244437724351883, -0.00987261813133955, 0.009145079180598259, 0.0013806319329887629, -0.027670245617628098, -0.015337925404310226, 0.009341544471681118, -0.022171081975102425, 0.0344715490937233, -0.006520948372781277, 0.01857931911945343, -0.002260061912238598, -0.019597060978412628, 0.01776721701025963, 0.013320595026016235, -0.02356192283332348, 0.017921216785907745, 0.012995072640478611, 0.011219354346394539, -0.0006352170603349805, 0.003318936564028263, 0.02116815187036991, -0.011708310805261135, -0.009094933047890663, 0.03356197103857994, -0.018492000177502632, 0.005412956699728966, 0.00606063986197114, -0.011120149865746498, -0.03172684460878372, -0.03291955590248108, -0.04550280049443245, 0.059615880250930786, -0.011396929621696472, -0.04424884170293808, 0.011991402134299278, 0.0036184757482260466, 0.025433117523789406, -0.02121591940522194, -0.014595439657568932, 0.022431040182709694, 0.04021165519952774, -0.03598684445023537, 0.017133157700300217, -0.024097036570310593, 0.02480936236679554, 0.008774226531386375, -0.006929890252649784, 0.039962902665138245, -0.019588638097047806, -0.023745134472846985, 0.0003812235372606665, 0.058794550597667694, -0.00446449825540185, 0.005386521108448505, -0.04166145250201225, 0.01758497580885887, -0.048331670463085175, -0.031747423112392426, 0.02590956911444664, 0.03606700897216797, 0.04224187135696411, 0.034507814794778824, -0.015087193809449673, -0.017889875918626785, -0.01865864172577858, -0.006508572958409786, -0.010426124557852745, -0.03371823579072952, 0.012523632496595383, -0.032852087169885635, 0.04747859761118889, 0.028097551316022873, 0.009003475308418274, -0.018542833626270294, 0.009829645976424217, 0.04674254730343819, 0.023379841819405556, -0.055550459772348404, -0.011638683266937733, 0.018382329493761063, -0.04930677264928818, 0.012789574451744556, -0.013564183376729488, 0.04401417449116707, 0.03190690651535988, -0.014691010117530823, 0.004574271384626627, 0.0031342352740466595, 0.004467291291803122, 0.029735220596194267, 0.015217142179608345, -0.033442094922065735, -0.020982228219509125, -0.004667988978326321, -0.024217166006565094, -0.019190721213817596, -0.03990842401981354, -0.025160429999232292, -0.032162874937057495, 0.01667768694460392, -0.0018309573642909527, -0.0010258968686684966, 0.009165197610855103, -0.029578303918242455, 0.015597433783113956, -0.04928376153111458, 0.012027109041810036, -0.0540480799973011, -0.061343420296907425, -0.019516143947839737, -0.008174638263881207, -0.012090199626982212, 0.02437025122344494, -0.01786656118929386, 0.004204452037811279, 0.03360581398010254, 0.016536692157387733, 0.014722838066518307, -0.01638508029282093, -0.018404893577098846, -0.028451833873987198, 0.041347332298755646, -0.0013426154619082808, -0.05396559089422226, 0.01709616556763649, -0.036652661859989166, -0.017444323748350143, 0.018410800024867058, -0.015156255103647709, 0.05076206102967262, 0.019201179966330528, 0.013809156604111195, -0.004676056560128927, 0.051271338015794754, -0.045811258256435394, -0.014303966425359249, -0.02459098771214485, -0.013482391834259033, -0.022171560674905777, 0.02087174914777279, 0.02847203239798546, 0.008436079137027264, 0.0005718714091926813, 0.04254685342311859, 0.04182274639606476, 0.012424398213624954, 0.022516245022416115, -0.0387503057718277, -0.004729999229311943, -0.018848538398742676, -0.018109265714883804, -0.005350676830857992, 0.03712214156985283, 0.0501345619559288, 0.012743092142045498, 0.03586580976843834, 0.01289430633187294, 0.007596554234623909, -0.10556972771883011, -0.00022562443336937577, 0.031305793672800064, 0.0310638640075922, 0.00897957943379879, -0.06125587597489357, -0.025910712778568268, -0.015451962128281593, -0.06591901928186417, 0.037337929010391235, 0.00608544796705246, -0.02565968595445156, -0.002514544641599059, -0.032860346138477325, -0.04786951467394829, 0.020357778295874596, 0.02325449138879776, 0.04742428660392761, 0.001733472105115652, 0.03305148333311081, 0.040733084082603455, -0.018265938386321068, -0.04454512894153595, 0.005712844431400299, 0.01844766177237034, -0.002736982423812151, 0.021148428320884705, -0.03144169598817825, -0.002684954321011901, 0.016672838479280472, -0.03387658670544624, 0.061379574239254, 0.011614805087447166, 0.0018470302456989884, -0.011918307282030582, 0.0394509956240654, 0.013136669993400574, -0.01795085147023201, 0.019370147958397865, -0.030181337147951126, -0.004626476671546698, 0.025675641372799873, -0.015037087723612785, 0.009898582473397255, 0.03774863854050636, -0.011122277937829494, -0.04520929232239723, 0.02167482301592827, 0.02131636068224907, -0.031241055577993393, -0.008391540497541428, 0.02268163301050663, 0.032228920608758926, -0.020842459052801132, -0.034816674888134, -0.007910827174782753, 0.016579516232013702, 0.05980490520596504, 0.034407682716846466, -0.022546110674738884, 0.008641534484922886, -0.04936303198337555, -0.018628250807523727, 0.027934441342949867, 0.004288659896701574, -0.020533183589577675, -0.04673248529434204, -0.03954391926527023, -0.03065762296319008, 0.002457203809171915, -0.05166550353169441, 0.012452633120119572, 0.0021620672196149826, 0.04024277627468109, 0.005754681304097176, 0.034245748072862625, -0.007674184162169695, -0.018950780853629112, -0.015339410863816738, -0.06803756952285767, 0.039747413247823715, -0.015522335655987263, 0.009012624621391296, -0.05624040588736534, -0.011068370193243027, -0.030288588255643845, 0.014655974693596363, 0.053491562604904175, 0.0688169002532959, 0.0025797258131206036, -0.02246127463877201, -0.002511165104806423, 0.00731532322242856, -0.03230605646967888, 0.06627257168292999, -0.021529095247387886, 0.0011728104436770082, 0.01918872632086277, -0.04907176271080971, -0.02284495159983635, 0.021603044122457504, 0.025803934782743454, -0.03669978305697441, 0.017422648146748543, 0.029909133911132812, -0.016608379781246185, 0.058230239897966385, -0.005280748009681702, -0.006802848074585199, 0.01452991645783186, 0.01840156503021717, 0.02216627635061741, 0.03201332688331604, -0.037895120680332184, -0.051719095557928085, 0.03514432907104492, -0.05163099989295006, -0.033396679908037186, 0.01105080172419548, -0.016115009784698486, 0.004382363520562649, -0.06641213595867157, 0.004464774392545223, 0.01457145530730486, -0.02007916569709778, 0.01563570648431778, 0.03011479042470455, 0.0373462438583374, 0.02294631488621235, -0.043907467275857925, 0.0697564110159874, -0.0004182537959422916, 0.01133132353425026, -0.011064770631492138, 0.010370226576924324, 0.0400192029774189, 0.0030562456231564283, 0.008280405774712563, 0.007690946571528912, -0.030471060425043106, 0.005693002603948116, 0.014585939235985279, 0.005286926869302988, -0.0064726220443844795, 0.019589262083172798, 0.03440862521529198, 0.005175680387765169, -0.0018918585265055299, 0.03746848925948143, 0.020625831559300423, 0.08171188831329346, -0.054375071078538895, 0.003157939063385129, -0.04725851118564606, -0.0014476525830104947, -0.03319156542420387, 0.012108382768929005, 0.026092328131198883, 0.018755309283733368, -0.0046696737408638, 0.01492221374064684, -0.011564914137125015, 0.0017365460516884923, -0.005801592953503132, -0.03311717510223389, 0.03528343886137009, -0.02404799871146679, -0.02535972371697426, 0.00415937090292573, -0.017675546929240227, -0.059318576008081436, -0.0441778339445591, 0.04645035043358803, 0.028195982798933983, -0.004242852795869112, -0.0002980838471557945, 0.007027991581708193, 0.017096472904086113, 0.042440906167030334, -0.08601682633161545, -0.04709867388010025, -0.04417590796947479, 0.045184385031461716, -0.016823500394821167, -0.02050381898880005 ]
<p>I used my training dataset to fit cluster using kmenas function</p> <pre><code>fit &lt;- kmeans(ca.data, 2); </code></pre> <p>How can I use fit object to predict cluster membership in a new dataset?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
74,217
[ -0.02430383861064911, -0.016814367845654488, -0.006884293165057898, 0.00552096962928772, 0.02977270632982254, 0.0006178010371513665, -0.009697476401925087, -0.04926977679133415, 0.0012076179264113307, -0.02098163589835167, 0.03790236636996269, 0.03619639202952385, 0.02549842558801174, 0.04319397732615471, 0.00406037038192153, 0.0021328297443687916, -0.05678458511829376, -0.024297986179590225, -0.010140362195670605, 0.0016349756624549627, -0.00930903572589159, 0.005156420636922121, 0.01461491547524929, -0.022744040936231613, -0.007451094686985016, 0.020531969144940376, 0.02566494047641754, -0.026285499334335327, 0.03709511458873749, 0.02477504499256611, -0.04041504114866257, -0.04209482669830322, 0.0685064047574997, 0.014210853725671768, 0.011093522422015667, -0.02076433226466179, -0.014013907872140408, -0.03885411471128464, -0.02596508339047432, 0.02444467693567276, -0.010418174788355827, -0.01349786575883627, 0.020129859447479248, 0.03368258476257324, 0.011436047032475471, 0.012365492060780525, -0.03910685330629349, -0.029088178649544716, 0.004103689920157194, -0.03267956152558327, 0.09123950451612473, 0.0020019528456032276, 0.010001624934375286, 0.02970963902771473, -0.03434848040342331, -0.007525315973907709, 0.057939812541007996, 0.042353007942438126, -0.027529772371053696, -0.035547059029340744, -0.03469604253768921, -0.06402085721492767, 0.02162359096109867, -0.025404509156942368, -0.03357746824622154, 0.05074751749634743, -0.01683540642261505, -0.031000936403870583, 0.053755711764097214, -0.0008888044394552708, 0.035992834717035294, -0.0020690748933702707, 0.07267514616250992, -0.050978660583496094, 0.026917122304439545, -0.04532135650515556, -0.020479917526245117, 0.03373299166560173, 0.04660142585635185, 0.012928863987326622, 0.018810700625181198, 0.013571174815297127, 0.00703844940289855, -0.01181309949606657, 0.045835476368665695, -0.01809013821184635, 0.06440272927284241, -0.0008202288299798965, 0.007192034740000963, 0.021081287413835526, -0.012697058729827404, 0.015261008404195309, 0.045555055141448975, -0.002214832464233041, -0.010556366294622421, 0.01026536151766777, -0.002430860185995698, 0.048286568373441696, 0.008052388206124306, -0.010883327573537827, -0.009942145086824894, -0.0294752586632967, 0.018686311319470406, 0.06036020442843437, -0.012511787936091423, 0.005175561644136906, -0.03969767317175865, -0.03463532030582428, -0.04012403264641762, -0.003242473816499114, 0.01653200387954712, -0.016536833718419075, 0.0001224832230946049, -0.011760585941374302, 0.04513310268521309, -0.009520582854747772, -0.015153761021792889, -0.00817631185054779, 0.021411215886473656, 0.0637325868010521, 0.02780294232070446, -0.03598744049668312, 0.0089694419875741, -0.0035768093075603247, -0.052877478301525116, 0.007220378611236811, 0.012989296577870846, -0.030506305396556854, 0.000022558308046427555, 0.03576115891337395, -0.0341251939535141, -0.015487145632505417, -0.003573817666620016, 0.016050061210989952, 0.02909468114376068, -0.026469290256500244, -0.08331238478422165, -0.04295221343636513, 0.018626099452376366, -0.015917321667075157, 0.018562866374850273, -0.038822341710329056, -0.00009806104935705662, 0.017843151465058327, 0.07540985196828842, 0.02435627020895481, -0.01246408000588417, 0.0023399314377456903, 0.02756889909505844, -0.013452012091875076, -0.03667405992746353, -0.011049983091652393, -0.04403053596615791, -0.014622376300394535, -0.027760162949562073, -0.05277327820658684, -0.006485649850219488, 0.01952672190964222, -0.018042437732219696, -0.02495478093624115, 0.03102339617908001, -0.02066815085709095, 0.00615275464951992, -0.03243832662701607, 0.008186955004930496, -0.011538861319422722, 0.0667012482881546, 0.012495984323322773, 0.02773268334567547, 0.022147895768284798, -0.01725040376186371, 0.008635307662189007, 0.047149065881967545, 0.04245168715715408, 0.03883753716945648, 0.024408722296357155, -0.013894721865653992, -0.03026087023317814, 0.03916805610060692, 0.0016023915959522128, -0.021866876631975174, -0.03415733575820923, 0.002943843835964799, -0.003469910006970167, 0.028473665937781334, 0.01677858643233776, 0.000005959160716884071, -0.020685330033302307, 0.03250424936413765, -0.0494573675096035, -0.03335242345929146, -0.05950794368982315, 0.024668872356414795, -0.01982598938047886, -0.026505814865231514, -0.011676167137920856, -0.008368699811398983, 0.03293047472834587, 0.011196538805961609, -0.01108806673437357, -0.06398728489875793, -0.01504467986524105, 0.015018749050796032, -0.006639254279434681, 0.005512923467904329, 0.0672944188117981, 0.038028232753276825, -0.017438162118196487, 0.06255212426185608, -0.025963550433516502, -0.028903616592288017, 0.007065102458000183, -0.02169964835047722, -0.035559676587581635, -0.025357631966471672, 0.03398142009973526, 0.013513613492250443, 0.011353596113622189, -0.02346787601709366, 0.022125691175460815, -0.04605800658464432, 0.08365598320960999, 0.047342073172330856, 0.016503944993019104, 0.0377371571958065, -0.012565873563289642, -0.01472046785056591, 0.029579108580946922, -0.054551009088754654, 0.002742381300777197, -0.06169004738330841, -0.010838526301085949, 0.04488992691040039, -0.0013723684241995215, -0.03634261339902878, 0.0029360163025557995, 0.042159609496593475, -0.017724279314279556, 0.007290815934538841, -0.022075651213526726, -0.012032943777740002, -0.008130322210490704, 0.032868850976228714, 0.00010439165635034442, 0.033593159168958664, -0.011536703445017338, 0.0217598769813776, 0.028415562584996223, 0.06258706003427505, -0.0020026329439133406, -0.003993249032646418, 0.05567888170480728, -0.020675837993621826, 0.011391600593924522, -0.019810812547802925, -0.010496105998754501, 0.03557078167796135, -0.012335116975009441, 0.005753717385232449, 0.015005410648882389, 0.03423198312520981, 0.009609515778720379, 0.0003575936716515571, -0.04189928248524666, -0.007487380877137184, 0.05671296641230583, -0.014691040851175785, -0.003564962651580572, 0.020016921684145927, -0.03127280995249748, 0.009683670476078987, 0.023458264768123627, -0.031300388276576996, -0.046788331121206284, 0.02139991894364357, 0.026831410825252533, 0.020318998023867607, 0.008245019242167473, -0.0228899996727705, -0.013136547058820724, -0.0012638902990147471, 0.020798051729798317, 0.008486079052090645, -0.009784526191651821, -0.024173900485038757, 0.007467449642717838, -0.017251519486308098, 0.0028701021801680326, -0.037525005638599396, 0.003904495621100068, -0.02962038293480873, 0.03255639970302582, -0.04281345009803772, -0.049876220524311066, -0.014503899030387402, 0.0032165651209652424, 0.011404884047806263, -0.00015620741760358214, -0.01018438395112753, 0.015147391706705093, 0.014860287308692932, -0.055856429040431976, -0.00037493646959774196, -0.03207147493958473, -0.003155350685119629, -0.04742255061864853, -0.04624704644083977, 0.032248642295598984, -0.032984912395477295, 0.030869394540786743, 0.01972014084458351, -0.021909791976213455, 0.005155004560947418, -0.05272991955280304, -0.061195097863674164, 0.006854207720607519, 0.008279578760266304, 0.025794563814997673, -0.00717956991866231, -0.0021593228448182344, 0.05652107298374176, 0.013459894806146622, -0.020479582250118256, -0.049802981317043304, -0.014954375103116035, -0.061445657163858414, -0.05810500308871269, 0.026211680844426155, -0.0015372141497209668, 0.03626236692070961, -0.035480156540870667, 0.021447060629725456, 0.03273073956370354, 0.0783146470785141, -0.033563271164894104, 0.006938569713383913, 0.0029895391780883074, 0.011216778308153152, -0.0049674008041620255, 0.03517259284853935, 0.013702785596251488, -0.009776383638381958, 0.03377876803278923, -0.018386967480182648, 0.006091158837080002, 0.0066121360287070274, -0.060125574469566345, -0.008501616306602955, 0.015267890878021717, 0.05150999873876572, -0.03989173099398613, 0.050772715359926224, -0.031087318435311317, -0.03727056086063385, 0.009560910984873772, 0.019094472751021385, 0.06278417259454727, 0.011394312605261803, -0.031216170638799667, 0.04401110112667084, -0.003378985682502389, -0.016307009384036064, 0.003683047369122505, -0.01081942580640316, -0.012903482653200626, 0.010538074187934399, -0.005953964311629534, -0.0032132824417203665, 0.015653733164072037, 0.024116825312376022, 0.030655303969979286, 0.01987440697848797, -0.023780127987265587, 0.017597230151295662, -0.04534830152988434, -0.0039724186062812805, -0.034868210554122925, 0.04869838431477547, 0.015473858453333378, 0.02717795968055725, 0.0421866737306118, -0.009863126091659069, 0.0378427654504776, 0.009555661119520664, -0.07605606317520142, 0.056329987943172455, 0.012364411726593971, -0.0015361894620582461, 0.0072709652595222, -0.06427048146724701, 0.028075741603970528, 0.007830054499208927, 0.04736705496907234, 0.013774503022432327, 0.0021903167944401503, -0.025090210139751434, 0.013009789399802685, -0.003368919249624014, 0.02693541906774044, 0.00008108187466859818, -0.0001934994215844199, 0.053484365344047546, 0.02960638329386711, 0.0364665761590004, 0.0441213957965374, -0.002324221655726433, -0.025534775108098984, -0.01206300314515829, -0.014606459066271782, 0.02102232165634632, 0.008960970677435398, 0.03699079900979996, 0.011511500924825668, -0.04858978092670441, -0.0004948198911733925, -0.024111244827508926, 0.04532288387417793, 0.04490511864423752, 0.021672692149877548, -0.006122163031250238, -0.03237399086356163, -0.017566455528140068, -0.021988926455378532, 0.018487518653273582, -0.024914966896176338, -0.006084411405026913, 0.02723764255642891, 0.02781437523663044, -0.05049798637628555, 0.02152436599135399, 0.05226713418960571, 0.048669829964637756, -0.029291197657585144, -0.0298447385430336, 0.011113614775240421, -0.006715880706906319, -0.020757434889674187, 0.011181927286088467, -0.036942776292562485, -0.00964315328747034, 0.04167001321911812, 0.032359469681978226, -0.002939570927992463, -0.03531178832054138, -0.009504725225269794, 0.006441144738346338, 0.053205374628305435, -0.035190969705581665, -0.024726703763008118, -0.004783622920513153, 0.05252799764275551, 0.04778231307864189, 0.000491096347104758, -0.013740957714617252, -0.09227970242500305, -0.012729335576295853, 0.05492190644145012, 0.032067183405160904, -0.03798269107937813, 0.004682021681219339, -0.06725668907165527, -0.01148256380110979, 0.04076080396771431, -0.03169059753417969, 0.05513010174036026, -0.01632499322295189, -0.00520706083625555, -0.01563536562025547, 0.0018557074945420027, -0.07353059202432632, 0.023463383316993713, -0.026107825338840485, 0.053974706679582596, -0.033616550266742706, -0.002546022180467844, -0.02433002181351185, 0.012294269166886806, 0.02926858700811863, 0.047853946685791016, -0.018966061994433403, -0.027417892590165138, 0.015898875892162323, 0.006372497882694006, 0.010368209332227707, -0.04415460675954819, 0.035256125032901764, 0.023563191294670105, 0.01748095639050007, 0.0052862344309687614, -0.019881729036569595, -0.016601115465164185, 0.01258808933198452, 0.01603248529136181, -0.020975830033421516, -0.05542614310979843, -0.06526365876197815, 0.02905076928436756, 0.016194641590118408, -0.007479596417397261, 0.052011288702487946, 0.007780933286994696, 0.009762723930180073, 0.012985987588763237, -0.041046977043151855, 0.014576093293726444, -0.024296537041664124, -0.02831977792084217, -0.032677169889211655, -0.02789083495736122, -0.04283389076590538, 0.002267891075462103, -0.020067667588591576, 0.027464361861348152, -0.04770683869719505, -0.012910847552120686, -0.0010472912108525634, 0.04644295945763588, -0.011409214697778225, 0.0028113964945077896, 0.01674092561006546, 0.037883210927248, -0.008421097882091999, -0.016976648941636086, 0.019667549058794975, -0.02839435078203678, 0.00953683815896511, 0.014943680725991726, -0.0176878459751606, 0.009234346449375153, -0.029961491003632545, -0.016724899411201477, 0.0484905019402504, -0.005365748889744282, 0.02866373211145401, -0.019365107640624046, 0.04823983460664749, 0.012800539843738079, -0.03821558505296707, 0.006756944581866264, 0.005147825926542282, -0.021234096959233284, 0.03359154239296913, -0.03811417892575264, 0.0432034507393837, 0.01813429407775402, -0.046039681881666183, -0.07670646905899048, -0.047556161880493164, -0.026747245341539383, 0.008320706896483898, -0.026850488036870956, -0.06257857382297516, -0.00037736428203061223, -0.020988916978240013, -0.011995723471045494, 0.014280631206929684, 0.04881596937775612, -0.007815462537109852, 0.00977955013513565, -0.027912145480513573, -0.014416069723665714, 0.08371902257204056, 0.054091326892375946, 0.0058427536860108376, 0.015110109932720661, -0.008779620751738548, -0.018742667511105537, -0.01279596146196127, 0.01960432529449463, -0.003228283254429698, 0.01317103672772646, -0.06265193223953247, 0.017231136560440063, 0.059017449617385864, -0.01360614225268364, -0.013568502850830555, -0.01970479264855385, 0.017655380070209503, 0.01614055037498474, -0.04900292679667473, 0.006796019617468119, -0.02606138400733471, -0.018381265923380852, -0.009441246278584003, 0.03204241022467613, -0.02195439673960209, -0.01870199479162693, 0.032418228685855865, -0.03150751441717148, 0.007484386209398508, 0.016689617186784744, 0.08649639040231705, 0.004078281112015247, -0.00042198257870040834, -0.016042055562138557, -0.04408559203147888, 0.033687639981508255, 0.03807393088936806, -0.010979779064655304, -0.0207758117467165, 0.050129517912864685, -0.04660404846072197, -0.01314172986894846, -0.03769123554229736, -0.05061088129878044, 0.09223097562789917, 0.010395354591310024, 0.04883846268057823, 0.045595888048410416, 0.010456785559654236, -0.0144657539203763, -0.03908906877040863, 0.01840003952383995, -0.01708933897316456, 0.03318984806537628, 0.04369482770562172, 0.020547199994325638, 0.012524789199233055, -0.0014604186872020364, 0.03285501152276993, 0.025013163685798645, 0.03897390514612198, 0.026985865086317062, 0.055690135806798935, -0.013614104129374027, -0.03575531393289566, -0.04759353771805763, 0.043240986764431, -0.008015742525458336, 0.020905762910842896, -0.03356331214308739, -0.021337062120437622, 0.03197309374809265, 0.05382425710558891, 0.01567928120493889, -0.0013970719883218408, -0.017132552340626717, -0.05299035832285881, 0.03737777844071388, 0.04507119208574295, -0.025922060012817383, 0.018391938880085945, 0.02914455719292164, 0.04012981802225113, 0.010186459869146347, 0.03068501688539982, -0.03655929118394852, -0.07867609709501266, -0.03985557332634926, -0.08038386702537537, -0.02691151760518551, 0.005903186276555061, 0.0264457818120718, -0.016861937940120697, 0.026545898988842964, -0.018967151641845703, 0.053189411759376526, 0.017333418130874634, 0.05509272590279579, 0.014085626229643822, 0.03818970173597336, -0.013033933006227016, 0.005706695839762688, -0.008462728001177311, -0.003996622283011675, 0.14705722033977509, 0.09059105813503265, 0.025089818984270096, -0.07802815735340118, 0.01552424393594265, 0.010869878344237804, -0.0275429654866457, -0.022050639614462852, 0.002070624614134431, 0.008036360144615173, 0.012362885288894176, 0.0338897779583931, 0.05869532749056816, 0.017534824088215828, 0.0375279076397419, 0.03808927536010742, -0.006544627249240875, -0.02712787315249443, 0.019090188667178154, 0.003768249647691846, -0.03682781010866165, -0.020498352125287056, -0.04861164838075638, 0.03483877703547478, 0.005835245363414288, -0.01434444822371006, -0.010091784410178661, -0.0011035171337425709, 0.02328704483807087, 0.00835542194545269, -0.0032456808257848024, -0.01599693112075329, -0.017350874841213226, 0.026429379358887672, 0.006758219562470913, -0.02073422074317932, 0.008714896626770496, -0.01349050085991621, 0.007642469834536314, 0.020122023299336433, 0.014768728986382484, -0.04716818034648895, -0.0503985732793808, 0.016678890213370323, -0.030574513599276543, -0.03568103536963463, -0.039662476629018784, 0.054358936846256256, -0.02254132367670536, 0.01842983439564705, 0.03518160805106163, 0.025752030313014984, 0.025114836171269417, -0.03589935973286629, 0.01611017808318138, 0.021449459716677666, 0.02810172364115715, -0.03118054009974003, 0.005881629418581724, -0.04867132380604744, -0.014073748141527176, -0.009509802795946598, 0.023079659789800644, 0.02718588151037693, -0.0023247594945132732, 0.017894752323627472, -0.03626317158341408, 0.016821041703224182, -0.023657038807868958, 0.014246750622987747, 0.015912599861621857, -0.03180377185344696, -0.041582975536584854, 0.008579505607485771, 0.004768379032611847, -0.01256494503468275, 0.022427044808864594, -0.015561368316411972, -0.025679493322968483, -0.019681936129927635, -0.057234421372413635, -0.0058288839645683765, -0.019459452480077744, 0.012145617976784706, -0.032956283539533615, 0.021166296675801277, 0.04773985594511032, 0.07384129613637924, 0.03011816181242466, 0.027220536023378372, -0.01559356227517128, 0.011564746499061584, -0.01310980785638094, -0.028320593759417534, -0.02629297599196434, -0.0034069702960550785, -0.0727192610502243, 0.01936132088303566, -0.02911546267569065, 0.07608632743358612, 0.009299859404563904, 0.015232670120894909, -0.01683821529150009, 0.03738406300544739, -0.010151773691177368, 0.033409807831048965, -0.016675779595971107, -0.030638165771961212, 0.007517999038100243, -0.03623203560709953, 0.008645729161798954, -0.028124641627073288, -0.015129750594496727, -0.03533410653471947, -0.04857674986124039, 0.030374467372894287, -0.02227635495364666, -0.04925129935145378, 0.04529163986444473, -0.005848241038620472, 0.012652563862502575, -0.05649625137448311, -0.01029348373413086, -0.03225359693169594, -0.03054891526699066, -0.03329239785671234, -0.05073830485343933, -0.0006280044908635318, -0.0019411914981901646, -0.03393099829554558, 0.02261880598962307, 0.04148457571864128, -0.006150849629193544, 0.028090033680200577, 0.008889165706932545, -0.002158764749765396, -0.04129595309495926, 0.047821179032325745, -0.02835259959101677, -0.02592749334871769, 0.04955768957734108, -0.06321750581264496, -0.03701351583003998, -0.01164930872619152, -0.02789127640426159, 0.06103147193789482, 0.017054738476872444, -0.004043264780193567, -0.001934959553182125, 0.05196429416537285, -0.03330995887517929, -0.0262443907558918, -0.013783304952085018, -0.015016267076134682, 0.0020170588977634907, 0.02441207878291607, 0.015858473256230354, 0.05587698519229889, -0.02037782222032547, 0.011632419191300869, 0.026870714500546455, 0.01378591451793909, -0.04731965437531471, 0.04201212897896767, -0.0017336875898763537, -0.006047702394425869, 0.015618645586073399, 0.003620945382863283, 0.01866980455815792, 0.03364557772874832, -0.015426501631736755, 0.015774697065353394, -0.04271451383829117, 0.021155402064323425, -0.0844750702381134, -0.044635891914367676, -0.014759469777345657, -0.0017529468750581145, 0.04707375168800354, -0.05070967972278595, 0.0040165334939956665, 0.020742103457450867, -0.0029049357399344444, 0.04385252669453621, 0.021192943677306175, 0.000841558794490993, -0.0384586900472641, 0.02655818685889244, -0.007803190965205431, -0.001210409915074706, 0.04005756974220276, 0.019762352108955383, 0.039783865213394165, -0.003883997444063425, 0.03342229127883911, -0.024333786219358444, -0.001119969179853797, 0.013954445719718933, 0.024616515263915062, -0.0500524677336216, 0.033530138432979584, -0.006981502752751112, 0.0005503207794390619, 0.018176335841417313, -0.02590160444378853, 0.014621229842305183, 0.06008709967136383, -0.0009162349160760641, -0.007159937173128128, 0.06310156732797623, 0.018857568502426147, -0.03558027371764183, -0.020283684134483337, -0.006713468581438065, 0.01302824355661869, 0.016058411449193954, 0.0075487010180950165, 0.020734967663884163, -0.0015464926837012172, -0.003695978783071041, -0.03253103047609329, 0.03286048769950867, -0.02703152783215046, 0.005241934210062027, 0.000599886232521385, 0.007967592217028141, -0.03763089329004288, -0.04182467237114906, -0.0014920554822310805, -0.010965143330395222, 0.016275733709335327, 0.05414204299449921, 0.04492626711726189, 0.004755384288728237, 0.022070812061429024, 0.011621709913015366, -0.05326559767127037, 0.021216116845607758, -0.0021076430566608906, -0.01890104077756405, -0.027697328478097916, -0.0272892527282238, -0.01492598932236433, 0.017951682209968567, -0.030154582113027573, -0.017230872064828873, 0.01590668596327305, 0.06873590499162674, -0.039805199950933456, 0.01586391218006611, 0.036959949880838394, -0.04053662344813347, -0.0012377090752124786, -0.06571771949529648, 0.05975265055894852, -0.022839006036520004, -0.017925353720784187, -0.04262528568506241, -0.01691599376499653, -0.029798611998558044, 0.003601143602281809, 0.047431956976652145, 0.04110207408666611, -0.0011722847120836377, -0.04832733795046806, 0.028530830517411232, -0.008104789070785046, -0.05712876841425896, 0.030230693519115448, -0.011526396498084068, -0.016269229352474213, 0.007469480391591787, 0.003642561612650752, 0.018878459930419922, 0.01592230424284935, 0.039938878268003464, -0.021205592900514603, 0.01290413923561573, -0.013127168640494347, -0.022841593250632286, 0.021745413541793823, -0.0024441129062324762, 0.004579039290547371, 0.04336375743150711, -0.00011480726243462414, -0.010626952163875103, 0.04391686990857124, -0.003202515421435237, -0.02096358872950077, 0.031856365501880646, -0.05129768326878548, -0.017990555614233017, 0.04067661985754967, -0.01929403655230999, -0.01620234176516533, -0.05071880668401718, -0.028681103140115738, 0.02119554951786995, -0.02248944155871868, 0.0041513643227517605, 0.029050078243017197, 0.023103393614292145, 0.040890082716941833, -0.005710673052817583, 0.023057902231812477, 0.021806761622428894, -0.003726531285792589, 0.03598858788609505, 0.014249672181904316, 0.0148926991969347, -0.0036300676874816418, -0.009453904815018177, 0.0021159646566957235, 0.005366323981434107, -0.018259188160300255, -0.040931422263383865, 0.04946571961045265, -0.0462300106883049, -0.0008953099022619426, -0.018087880685925484, -0.010980610735714436, 0.0470610186457634, -0.004000399727374315, 0.019583143293857574, 0.04611416533589363, -0.056331612169742584, 0.014303815551102161, -0.025224676355719566, -0.058912474662065506, -0.03675537928938866, 0.04164404049515724, 0.019748525694012642, 0.03703402355313301, 0.008745360188186169, 0.0256181787699461, 0.04502292722463608, -0.04110856354236603, 0.04531180113554001, 0.005359891802072525, 0.016441207379102707, -0.00875603687018156, 0.022252842783927917, -0.01092673372477293, 0.008916502818465233, 0.011741072870790958, -0.02935836836695671, -0.011799812316894531, 0.043087419122457504, 0.034612685441970825, -0.01653255708515644, -0.007330972235649824, -0.004999134223908186, 0.017670901492238045, -0.056025680154561996, -0.011736300773918629, -0.05042799562215805, 0.007057233713567257, -0.030805522575974464, -0.02620854042470455 ]
<p>I have 30 variables and am trying to select the best model. I have run the following methods on a 'large' data set (having removed a smaller test set): </p> <ul> <li>OLS, </li> <li>best subset selection, </li> <li>stepwise selection, </li> <li>ridge regression, </li> <li>LASSO, </li> <li>PCR and </li> <li>PLS. </li> </ul> <p>All outliers were removed from both data sets. None of the variables/response have been transformed in any way prior to running the above methods and there is little/no collinearity between variables. </p> <p>I ran each model (for OLS I ran the entire 30 variable model) and computed the MSE and variance for each. They differ only by 0.001 in MSE (best = PLS, worst = stepwise) and the variance (between the best – stepwise and the worst – ridge). </p> <p><strong>How do I now choose the best model?</strong> I'm pretty stuck! </p> <p>One idea I had is to cross validate the MSE and var on the test set, but I'm unsure about how to write this code in R. </p> <p>I'm using code similar to this <a href="http://cbio.ensmp.fr/~jvert/svn/tutorials/practical/linearregression/linearregression.R" rel="nofollow">website</a>'s. I'm not sure that will solve the problem though. I'm using <code>summary(model - y.test)^2</code> at the moment. </p>
34,587
[ -0.06356791406869888, 0.022171761840581894, -0.01175688486546278, 0.002987593412399292, 0.016446635127067566, 0.006476293783634901, -0.02558869868516922, -0.043488312512636185, 0.06171818822622299, 0.011611778289079666, 0.01991712674498558, 0.05810585990548134, 0.034067075699567795, -0.007832512259483337, -0.009458087384700775, -0.01964609883725643, -0.009542223066091537, -0.0027649798430502415, -0.005813537631183863, 0.021453343331813812, -0.007921405136585236, -0.014862976036965847, 0.0004781084426213056, -0.004562314599752426, -0.02006457932293415, 0.05094888433814049, 0.03846793249249458, 0.004924105480313301, -0.016290148720145226, 0.03252788633108139, -0.021968163549900055, -0.03301683068275452, 0.0017463082913309336, 0.06268814206123352, 0.013337475247681141, 0.01050550676882267, 0.027656013146042824, -0.001433638739399612, -0.009779319167137146, 0.040484219789505005, -0.017322737723588943, -0.03691063076257706, -0.00958267692476511, 0.046394892036914825, -0.016565479338169098, 0.022969340905547142, -0.009296628646552563, -0.007715797051787376, 0.03588217496871948, -0.038724955171346664, 0.06704297661781311, 0.0010461354395374656, 0.015603230334818363, 0.02865471877157688, -0.010911400429904461, 0.009456061758100986, 0.03755813091993332, 0.08332028239965439, 0.00019074232841376215, -0.015568197704851627, -0.033325761556625366, -0.02051754668354988, 0.011282562278211117, 0.000008892689947970212, -0.05042654648423195, 0.011427734978497028, 0.014563008211553097, 0.004717628005892038, 0.036261916160583496, -0.005173086188733578, 0.010111693292856216, 0.0016574645414948463, 0.030126968398690224, 0.027543991804122925, 0.023854512721300125, -0.00598429050296545, 0.004291201941668987, 0.02926677092909813, 0.03789643943309784, 0.018574146553874016, 0.028570132330060005, 0.00808738637715578, 0.006231846287846565, 0.05042067542672157, 0.015983358025550842, -0.016714448109269142, 0.09612954407930374, 0.009047316387295723, -0.00720685999840498, 0.01478818990290165, -0.012598367407917976, -0.023596415296196938, 0.04334362596273422, 0.04789149388670921, -0.03033839724957943, 0.01195794902741909, -0.0015552629483863711, 0.04112620651721954, 0.015179203823208809, 0.002610397059470415, 0.014806834049522877, -0.02810327149927616, -0.01811923086643219, 0.06927239149808884, -0.020776011049747467, 0.013778102584183216, -0.004255787003785372, -0.01393678318709135, -0.00847607385367155, -0.07932087033987045, -0.050917163491249084, 0.041172388941049576, -0.01173449121415615, 0.007287825457751751, 0.005551570560783148, -0.030081382021307945, -0.013222094625234604, -0.02119399979710579, 0.049477219581604004, 0.0787045881152153, 0.02800154872238636, -0.010560169816017151, 0.007477166596800089, -0.0405285619199276, -0.012494963593780994, 0.010891168378293514, 0.013079815544188023, 0.015568621456623077, -0.04028182476758957, 0.0707365944981575, 0.010100369341671467, -0.0207173191010952, 0.031015723943710327, -0.010176368057727814, 0.027736617252230644, -0.020541833713650703, -0.09018439054489136, -0.03328797221183777, 0.04523417353630066, -0.034996483474969864, 0.021654698997735977, -0.0304145235568285, -0.05016229674220085, 0.007498264778405428, 0.09183935075998306, -0.000695799826644361, 0.020483724772930145, 0.0394255667924881, 0.01554782409220934, -0.01899113692343235, -0.01156278233975172, -0.02449684590101242, -0.01837286166846752, -0.00473755830898881, -0.030475065112113953, -0.0647980272769928, -0.01787343993782997, 0.022451872006058693, -0.011663241311907768, 0.029844779521226883, 0.01902666501700878, -0.00022035704751033336, 0.0013963544042780995, -0.015933135524392128, 0.011998926289379597, -0.029189536347985268, 0.08870773762464523, 0.025660939514636993, 0.0032326902728527784, 0.027836967259645462, -0.013674626126885414, 0.01151726208627224, 0.027211137115955353, 0.06901004165410995, 0.018325861543416977, -0.01569954678416252, 0.0048954240046441555, -0.02988346666097641, -0.017302541062235832, 0.041800856590270996, -0.04717938229441643, -0.014226135797798634, -0.01606038585305214, -0.01407987717539072, 0.029399612918496132, 0.04995390400290489, -0.03456055000424385, -0.008639075793325901, 0.04346752539277077, -0.053420376032590866, -0.06115461513400078, -0.04568502679467201, 0.018520385026931763, 0.0445484034717083, -0.054570261389017105, 0.03490212932229042, 0.008359070867300034, -0.0056021190248429775, 0.009219741448760033, -0.028458772227168083, -0.011881946586072445, 0.009822755120694637, 0.02817719615995884, 0.019557351246476173, 0.006934937089681625, 0.030416343361139297, 0.024715328589081764, -0.046523336321115494, 0.012113779783248901, -0.03511904925107956, -0.047575291246175766, 0.005029011517763138, -0.023553404957056046, 0.014952785335481167, -0.014674274250864983, -0.033031899482011795, 0.0209342148154974, 0.019555900245904922, -0.010410742834210396, 0.040941622108221054, -0.04400455206632614, 0.03890576586127281, 0.04483902454376221, 0.018158063292503357, 0.012599579989910126, -0.009872914291918278, -0.024637145921587944, 0.07398388534784317, -0.029445258900523186, 0.041693054139614105, -0.045374494045972824, -0.006902804132550955, 0.011713752523064613, 0.02161158248782158, -0.046347539871931076, -0.0042388541623950005, 0.06781481951475143, 0.010306747630238533, 0.02846529707312584, 0.038590479642152786, 0.00463763065636158, -0.008349085226655006, -0.006939997896552086, 0.016859548166394234, -0.0013868913520127535, 0.01814183220267296, 0.009072726592421532, -0.007330276537686586, 0.027400804683566093, 0.023503942415118217, 0.024937808513641357, 0.06808330863714218, 0.029618004336953163, -0.0033514387905597687, -0.027734586969017982, -0.0317612923681736, 0.019629547372460365, -0.03761116787791252, -0.0077849566005170345, 0.052138201892375946, 0.02593114972114563, -0.02585296332836151, 0.03017744980752468, 0.027505967766046524, 0.04185978323221207, 0.030520986765623093, -0.02013835497200489, 0.016299644485116005, 0.02703339233994484, -0.06047981604933739, 0.003999572247266769, 0.0020569160114973783, -0.034630294889211655, -0.06506507098674774, 0.03484131395816803, 0.051232896745204926, 0.009116942062973976, 0.03867524489760399, -0.0036167108919471502, -0.02448248118162155, 0.0028798391576856375, -0.03342047706246376, 0.06891261786222458, 0.00024147726071532816, -0.04920549318194389, -0.012168917804956436, -0.07438410818576813, -0.014923679642379284, 0.04422151297330856, 0.007727157324552536, -0.009353096596896648, 0.008134037256240845, 0.017306871712207794, -0.049266181886196136, -0.050429947674274445, -0.04615839198231697, 0.062127064913511276, 0.00046903660404495895, -0.04643849655985832, 0.012334220111370087, 0.028725557029247284, -0.052729133516550064, -0.007850652560591698, -0.04032428190112114, 0.006798930931836367, 0.020634328946471214, -0.024212505668401718, -0.014879721216857433, 0.02858545072376728, 0.006422336213290691, 0.06723769009113312, -0.014829162508249283, -0.005952931009232998, -0.09279248863458633, -0.04304555803537369, -0.009900407865643501, 0.015664441511034966, 0.025797154754400253, -0.010595202445983887, -0.01572454534471035, 0.033131033182144165, 0.060374803841114044, -0.04885364696383476, -0.04826320335268974, 0.02131158672273159, -0.05268455296754837, -0.04095892608165741, 0.0438743457198143, 0.005964973941445351, 0.02009684592485428, 0.02722708135843277, -0.04533937945961952, 0.022931823506951332, 0.05157843977212906, -0.008798353374004364, 0.0018635389860719442, -0.0016498190816491842, -0.035142891108989716, -0.008589980192482471, 0.041236624121665955, 0.02749256230890751, -0.03603503108024597, 0.029582347720861435, -0.005131300538778305, 0.01595163717865944, -0.0019514844752848148, -0.058774493634700775, 0.006418157368898392, 0.0067744506523013115, 0.03396744281053543, -0.008917071856558323, 0.017980609089136124, 0.003761101281270385, -0.04567888006567955, -0.008210091851651669, 0.017218980938196182, 0.027139859274029732, -0.001643713447265327, 0.018732992932200432, 0.03763791173696518, 0.024336356669664383, 0.003897179150953889, 0.011737704277038574, -0.048943277448415756, -0.021597716957330704, -0.012643991969525814, 0.0004642866551876068, -0.014074331149458885, 0.024521293118596077, -0.004033398814499378, 0.024308595806360245, -0.004286530893296003, -0.05273553356528282, 0.051070962101221085, -0.07669878751039505, 0.010480431839823723, -0.0440644696354866, 0.037022508680820465, 0.02126646786928177, 0.04034075513482094, 0.007689131423830986, -0.011495471931993961, -0.0026562223210930824, -0.012035755440592766, -0.04889446124434471, 0.05475540831685066, 0.028956471011042595, -0.006743657402694225, 0.010559581220149994, -0.007369910832494497, 0.013321528211236, -0.014983917586505413, 0.041478268802165985, 0.003114865394309163, 0.010272406041622162, -0.032232679426670074, 0.012114860117435455, -0.02230118028819561, 0.008189215324819088, -0.01618249900639057, 0.025204312056303024, -0.006526133511215448, -0.04200964421033859, 0.027051670476794243, 0.04172634705901146, -0.021762270480394363, -0.009365853853523731, -0.00017044319247361273, 0.011778762564063072, 0.027293803170323372, 0.042638085782527924, -0.0015063747996464372, 0.01842244155704975, -0.03023228794336319, 0.0212235227227211, -0.015827462077140808, 0.027389192953705788, 0.059024520218372345, -0.0001444985973648727, -0.025462185963988304, -0.014287813566625118, -0.013642305508255959, 0.012923287227749825, -0.011794771067798138, 0.028599819168448448, -0.03305274620652199, 0.07201669365167618, 0.04035359248518944, -0.06427671015262604, -0.0021880625281482935, 0.05793121084570885, 0.03858955204486847, 0.014831418171525002, 0.008928983472287655, -0.03114822879433632, 0.0271412692964077, -0.0039376551285386086, 0.027941495180130005, 0.008612781763076782, 0.008462480269372463, -0.04031767696142197, 0.06216111406683922, -0.022088151425123215, -0.03616395220160484, 0.017154285684227943, 0.027023442089557648, 0.07438938319683075, -0.015582035295665264, -0.03550086170434952, -0.02591109462082386, 0.04355087876319885, 0.004055421333760023, 0.020049652084708214, -0.01858469285070896, -0.06775866448879242, -0.012821001000702381, 0.017976662144064903, 0.05999989062547684, -0.05859890952706337, -0.020113395527005196, -0.03397208824753761, -0.06755146384239197, 0.023743726313114166, -0.03960023820400238, 0.008505463600158691, -0.00993505958467722, -0.00807830411940813, -0.025426693260669708, -0.02950628288090229, -0.05268281698226929, -0.055350154638290405, -0.005676445551216602, 0.05113416910171509, -0.029519423842430115, -0.04020647704601288, -0.039531171321868896, 0.03373115509748459, -0.0034166777040809393, 0.04707862064242363, -0.04119260609149933, -0.010080615058541298, 0.01660129427909851, 0.029552821069955826, -0.0007127691060304642, -0.04032149538397789, 0.0020896741189062595, 0.011853065341711044, -0.02947860024869442, 0.0385093092918396, -0.0030179470777511597, -0.05917785316705704, -0.0017353466246277094, 0.005347514059394598, -0.016014352440834045, 0.025098441168665886, -0.02052292972803116, 0.029448626562952995, 0.01109525840729475, 0.003731444710865617, 0.06891533732414246, 0.020618679001927376, -0.010651481337845325, 0.007118066307157278, -0.04068571701645851, -0.0024856391828507185, -0.035264357924461365, -0.05017172172665596, -0.06415852904319763, -0.045162446796894073, 0.0012166170636191964, 0.010502721183001995, -0.020194847136735916, 0.032015927135944366, -0.030392494052648544, -0.013300755992531776, 0.02296278439462185, 0.03705710917711258, -0.03988351300358772, -0.004960003308951855, 0.021498238667845726, 0.009816314093768597, -0.014438334852457047, 0.0175737626850605, 0.03294898942112923, -0.025477640330791473, 0.01704069972038269, 0.04077710956335068, -0.07182307541370392, 0.015491225756704807, -0.008631650358438492, -0.019398117437958717, -0.01058311015367508, -0.0192889254540205, 0.01517188735306263, 0.012133460491895676, 0.03825157508254051, -0.01693459413945675, -0.013076061382889748, -0.009644957259297371, 0.019094498828053474, 0.01436543371528387, 0.01875578612089157, -0.03019482083618641, 0.03482877463102341, -0.05292079970240593, 0.006274139508605003, -0.054202623665332794, -0.05912427976727486, 0.0011227091308683157, 0.027182012796401978, -0.022572610527276993, -0.05144130811095238, -0.0048123737797141075, -0.027218591421842575, 0.005500327795743942, -0.030406184494495392, 0.040839873254299164, -0.03046474978327751, 0.019337816163897514, -0.0077689229510724545, 0.0464441180229187, 0.05611046403646469, -0.01667000725865364, 0.010103308595716953, 0.0093570277094841, -0.011853414587676525, -0.0061734882183372974, 0.008171929977834225, 0.022327352315187454, -0.02568144164979458, 0.009345381520688534, -0.03351110592484474, 0.01731342263519764, 0.047431573271751404, 0.0020491108298301697, -0.005530242342501879, 0.01499403826892376, -0.038809310644865036, 0.011962933465838432, -0.00026575138326734304, 0.022251276299357414, -0.02876618690788746, 0.0020654008258134127, -0.023267904296517372, 0.01076742447912693, -0.029639501124620438, -0.04527110606431961, 0.006158275995403528, 0.014411850832402706, -0.012248095124959946, 0.01718958467245102, 0.07457797974348068, -0.011743445880711079, 0.024499479681253433, -0.003220493672415614, -0.026322919875383377, 0.04337964579463005, 0.0037155253812670708, 0.04113093763589859, -0.026769835501909256, 0.035737745463848114, -0.0069657983258366585, -0.03878893703222275, -0.04193858802318573, 0.036680713295936584, 0.058599479496479034, -0.007633659522980452, 0.030070969834923744, 0.0771438404917717, -0.018922321498394012, 0.00011028347216779366, -0.07391154766082764, -0.012858454138040543, 0.0074161384254693985, 0.020758461207151413, 0.07159116119146347, 0.04270173981785774, -0.005586031824350357, 0.0340973362326622, -0.011311817914247513, 0.04272162541747093, 0.0391872376203537, 0.004329343792051077, 0.01618620567023754, 0.027812950313091278, -0.04983057454228401, -0.04457315430045128, -0.0007538720383308828, -0.05400961637496948, 0.012628856115043163, -0.022937694564461708, -0.020549219101667404, -0.011030466295778751, 0.05171233043074608, 0.016910094767808914, -0.0059801070019602776, -0.008884381502866745, -0.06976764649152756, 0.02088918536901474, 0.04214392602443695, -0.03480524942278862, 0.04197875037789345, 0.03876730054616928, 0.034734904766082764, 0.02894633077085018, 0.03613332286477089, -0.056716691702604294, -0.07902014255523682, 0.00035936859785579145, 0.008565795607864857, -0.032045695930719376, 0.03212956339120865, 0.0018658111803233624, -0.020564530044794083, 0.019388815388083458, -0.01741633377969265, -0.02889602817595005, -0.005940283183008432, 0.05497227609157562, 0.008011233992874622, 0.059768497943878174, -0.008401303552091122, 0.0017018982907757163, -0.01110867504030466, -0.03259657323360443, 0.12885022163391113, 0.0865236297249794, 0.015110628679394722, -0.0826757475733757, 0.009749997407197952, 0.02773115411400795, -0.027507435530424118, 0.006583356764167547, -0.026720525696873665, 0.007016110699623823, -0.006569355726242065, 0.06026187166571617, 0.03042818233370781, 0.007981893606483936, -0.032120756804943085, 0.02913954108953476, -0.014717435464262962, -0.009500536136329174, 0.00933903083205223, 0.006840951275080442, 0.0016278907423838973, -0.026448844000697136, -0.048345692455768585, 0.01244184747338295, 0.015703601762652397, -0.009856991469860077, -0.024311741814017296, -0.020309165120124817, -0.006582604721188545, -0.019298970699310303, 0.010451776906847954, 0.002374335890635848, -0.02155725657939911, 0.01130752358585596, -0.013257704675197601, 0.04947614297270775, 0.02243627980351448, -0.03483514115214348, 0.01879565790295601, 0.018034134060144424, -0.0039137001149356365, 0.016909854486584663, -0.01122127566486597, -0.010567239485681057, -0.027729371562600136, -0.049881886690855026, -0.04788091406226158, 0.039581283926963806, 0.0067016733810305595, -0.04011602699756622, 0.006192496977746487, 0.0028014385607093573, 0.012084277346730232, -0.03816494345664978, 0.0008885252173058689, 0.020908143371343613, 0.018284155055880547, -0.04001704230904579, -0.01773683913052082, -0.02782684937119484, 0.016018221154808998, 0.002899061655625701, 0.016799235716462135, 0.02858003042638302, -0.03149566799402237, -0.020930470898747444, -0.014603071846067905, 0.05447840690612793, 0.03753983601927757, 0.03313233330845833, -0.02857092209160328, -0.03165510669350624, 0.017188195139169693, -0.004464887548238039, 0.06883702427148819, 0.01735464110970497, 0.026613421738147736, -0.02775588072836399, -0.025780629366636276, -0.03180471062660217, -0.03166431561112404, 0.0024610403925180435, -0.02938474901020527, -0.005675009451806545, -0.007108004298061132, -0.013347110711038113, -0.013679812662303448, 0.034212447702884674, 0.0349789634346962, 0.005608559586107731, -0.016610929742455482, 0.044031042605638504, -0.020832791924476624, -0.07096687704324722, -0.018689600750803947, -0.016536246985197067, -0.019581930711865425, -0.006449107080698013, -0.011088638566434383, 0.10231852531433105, 0.024984803050756454, -0.004875468090176582, -0.05163436010479927, 0.05323402211070061, -0.031030865386128426, -0.020676860585808754, 0.028877384960651398, -0.030836189165711403, -0.000893804244697094, -0.003101056208834052, -0.003072942839935422, -0.019925137981772423, -0.002560789231210947, -0.040320683270692825, -0.04902965947985649, 0.04161020368337631, -0.04441830515861511, -0.03288290277123451, 0.032232459634542465, -0.005471686366945505, 0.041025273501873016, -0.028986919671297073, 0.014499206095933914, -0.034100912511348724, 0.0178120918571949, -0.022270116955041885, -0.018871694803237915, 0.012705410830676556, 0.007248251233249903, -0.006951852235943079, -0.013105944730341434, 0.03213867172598839, 0.021078137680888176, 0.03178653120994568, -0.02852056920528412, 0.006403510924428701, 0.0019931511487811804, 0.0777227059006691, -0.02284727245569229, 0.01498444378376007, 0.04561900347471237, -0.026766812428832054, -0.03475823253393173, 0.009392205625772476, -0.007695451844483614, 0.019932100549340248, -0.010738568380475044, 0.027294866740703583, -0.034290313720703125, 0.030324772000312805, 0.0008484318386763334, -0.027079345658421516, 0.004739644005894661, 0.016668908298015594, -0.008348915725946426, 0.0017452535685151815, -0.0011134130181744695, 0.019779814407229424, -0.024644998833537102, 0.003381475806236267, 0.014504840597510338, 0.004972527269273996, 0.0003642772790044546, -0.0034073221031576395, -0.039298828691244125, 0.0359814390540123, -0.006997810676693916, -0.01380250882357359, 0.021301893517374992, 0.04317908734083176, -0.0549723319709301, 0.02490868605673313, 0.013278724625706673, 0.0001746507186908275, -0.08089695125818253, -0.021565435454249382, -0.004113050643354654, -0.004523391369730234, 0.03210590034723282, -0.06218906491994858, 0.013629610650241375, 0.0793246403336525, -0.048299264162778854, 0.02405557967722416, 0.0007803724729456007, 0.06467218697071075, -0.00404303427785635, 0.0005889211315661669, -0.027191074565052986, 0.01899741217494011, -0.0005263877683319151, 0.03061915747821331, 0.071904256939888, 0.04770426079630852, 0.013918516226112843, -0.040483348071575165, -0.03906596079468727, 0.011013470590114594, -0.00679793069139123, -0.05372785031795502, 0.026594191789627075, -0.042819857597351074, -0.038099344819784164, 0.017061792314052582, -0.029271576553583145, 0.03863924741744995, 0.0025255961809307337, 0.03157376870512962, 0.006832053419202566, 0.044197555631399155, 0.024296296760439873, -0.007983196526765823, 0.010662033222615719, -0.015367688611149788, 0.014520479366183281, -0.005049337632954121, -0.013446066528558731, -0.004626259673386812, 0.035532671958208084, -0.015231755562126637, -0.00262811710126698, 0.01639709249138832, 0.007842068560421467, -0.010771166533231735, 0.018960313871502876, -0.009611722081899643, 0.024329746142029762, -0.03043397329747677, -0.019765662029385567, -0.03041812777519226, -0.012551096267998219, 0.0370483323931694, 0.04355546832084656, -0.027689557522535324, 0.025040315464138985, -0.04678541049361229, -0.03834236413240433, -0.02445235475897789, -0.003231976181268692, 0.018258847296237946, -0.0628679022192955, 0.007125204894691706, -0.014063236303627491, -0.039737872779369354, -0.02617044933140278, 0.006051022559404373, -0.04883555695414543, 0.03573576733469963, -0.013304873369634151, 0.012077228166162968, 0.016004422679543495, -0.02899622730910778, 0.012692896649241447, -0.06819625198841095, 0.03988499566912651, 0.00425661401823163, -0.0297537874430418, -0.010976823978126049, -0.02140238508582115, -0.039631202816963196, 0.0015759061789140105, 0.03175750747323036, 0.012645646929740906, 0.027923882007598877, -0.007139380555599928, 0.023035604506731033, 0.01064588874578476, -0.04659145325422287, 0.06973736733198166, 0.012556134723126888, -0.008123692125082016, 0.0012884874595329165, -0.012668972834944725, 0.026491468772292137, 0.006442096084356308, 0.02446005865931511, -0.013017073273658752, -0.0026845408137887716, 0.0048696440644562244, -0.014183545485138893, 0.019429873675107956, -0.04054507240653038, -0.01649070903658867, -0.0012198135955259204, -0.0019838272128254175, -0.02570432424545288, 0.01581520028412342, -0.019531313329935074, -0.03738956153392792, 0.0024519641883671284, -0.031248150393366814, -0.0008564398740418255, 0.008678547106683254, 0.03722752258181572, -0.0037925236392766237, -0.04570184275507927, 0.011159015819430351, 0.009805606678128242, -0.0215669646859169, 0.03453540429472923, 0.02046883851289749, -0.02566080167889595, 0.008991994895040989, 0.0014178154524415731, 0.018178829923272133, 0.022670568898320198, -0.017323141917586327, -0.010923362337052822, 0.00018912693485617638, 0.03412678465247154, 0.00004954083851771429, -0.0130073893815279, 0.05550641566514969, -0.0004727432387880981, 0.052471376955509186, 0.01269668061286211, 0.016583599150180817, -0.00427656713873148, -0.01134126540273428, 0.010462860576808453, -0.02607264369726181, -0.0100860008969903, -0.04096196964383125, -0.020070819184184074, 0.02614978887140751, -0.04441282898187637, -0.007294468116015196, -0.006351193878799677, -0.004533867817372084, 0.014502071775496006, 0.005388009361922741, -0.021168438717722893, 0.0020800691563636065, -0.007047346327453852, 0.02751598320901394, -0.022316213697195053, -0.002590747317299247, 0.030764320865273476, -0.016717862337827682, 0.04030442237854004, -0.01446995697915554, -0.03832182660698891, 0.00642715347930789, -0.036337144672870636, -0.020388208329677582, -0.003064496675506234, 0.027839716523885727, 0.05034251511096954, -0.016210248693823814, -0.07544063031673431, -0.03279677405953407, -0.007112808991223574, 0.004609331954270601, -0.039981406182050705, -0.0033871938940137625, -0.024601416662335396, 0.008720268495380878, -0.009493526071310043, -0.011817176826298237 ]
<p>I'm a first year statistics graduate student taking a course in regression. In the previous chapter we covered, we discussed partial F-tests for deciding whether to include a predictor variable. In the current chapter (which we just finished), we covered six model selection criteria. I was expecting these two concepts to be linked together at some point, but there's nothing in the book about it. Does anyone know what is the relationship between partial F-tests and model selection? To me, it looks like partial F tests should be considered a model selection criterion.</p>
74,218
[ -0.013503440655767918, -0.02966320514678955, -0.010505475103855133, -0.011250962503254414, 0.03518134728074074, 0.03322019428014755, 0.016352148726582527, -0.005644774530082941, 0.05117671564221382, -0.018231116235256195, 0.013432366773486137, 0.021505629643797874, 0.04346804693341255, -0.024858703836798668, 0.013041938655078411, 0.00466794241219759, -0.006328390445560217, 0.0062537542544305325, -0.01753508485853672, -0.012131566181778908, -0.018294481560587883, 0.054165907204151154, 0.03860862925648689, -0.002055700169876218, -0.004822978284209967, 0.03213765099644661, 0.0150290597230196, 0.0019802546594291925, 0.0372706837952137, 0.013803253881633282, -0.025176675990223885, -0.00995990913361311, -0.01993640884757042, 0.05792912840843201, 0.011705435812473297, -0.026693949475884438, 0.006943384185433388, -0.01291134674102068, 0.013734232634305954, 0.053463999181985855, -0.04272771626710892, -0.045226141810417175, 0.011278067715466022, -0.0018859654664993286, -0.021746492013335228, 0.02616730146110058, -0.017022909596562386, -0.03578510135412216, 0.03170840069651604, -0.04885919764637947, 0.05109256133437157, 0.018377017229795456, 0.01902240328490734, 0.039627887308597565, 0.034633755683898926, 0.017608050256967545, 0.05747766047716141, 0.09088071435689926, -0.057155728340148926, -0.06061000004410744, -0.04098188877105713, -0.07237798720598221, 0.031476784497499466, -0.018503326922655106, -0.07866813242435455, 0.03112691640853882, -0.007642805110663176, -0.031047392636537552, 0.05915650725364685, 0.0094895139336586, -0.013332655653357506, -0.008451650850474834, 0.032501619309186935, -0.006646083202213049, -0.004381749778985977, -0.0202188678085804, 0.01783945970237255, 0.03637354075908661, 0.05655409395694733, 0.03697681427001953, -0.005523024592548609, 0.010130612179636955, 0.007204096298664808, 0.05073413625359535, -0.00974278524518013, 0.008617259562015533, 0.04444120079278946, -0.00241635600104928, 0.004377944394946098, 0.003487225156277418, -0.03232967108488083, -0.030555108562111855, 0.026820866391062737, -0.000902376021258533, -0.05996643379330635, 0.06374448537826538, -0.02808164246380329, 0.025886448100209236, -0.0021603775676339865, 0.0013230962213128805, 0.010425643995404243, -0.043678753077983856, 0.008380146697163582, 0.043589599430561066, -0.0551508329808712, -0.017358457669615746, -0.03302837163209915, -0.012285575270652771, -0.009314094670116901, -0.02010214515030384, -0.03381015360355377, 0.049551259726285934, -0.02395773120224476, -0.019911903887987137, 0.019053103402256966, 0.005625957623124123, -0.019726505503058434, -0.025029899552464485, 0.08609288930892944, 0.051642272621393204, 0.07163181155920029, -0.020656514912843704, 0.006686166860163212, -0.025084616616368294, -0.0441766083240509, -0.006703169085085392, 0.029035532847046852, 0.00180707941763103, 0.0016834158450365067, 0.07145632058382034, 0.014313070103526115, 0.00466082151979208, -0.006979335565119982, 0.04381142929196358, 0.05715092644095421, 0.028833916410803795, -0.06360292434692383, -0.046852245926856995, 0.07502668350934982, -0.036447394639253616, 0.019933728501200676, -0.05605348199605942, 0.0022786830086261034, 0.02615278773009777, 0.08518777042627335, -0.005335398018360138, 0.017755575478076935, -0.023155437782406807, 0.010817504487931728, 0.009476709179580212, -0.04526805132627487, -0.05032765865325928, -0.013931973837316036, -0.021701810881495476, -0.009208661504089832, -0.09162230789661407, -0.015817875042557716, 0.00259476643987, -0.022030940279364586, -0.02269953303039074, 0.03997546806931496, 0.001746453926898539, -0.01882951520383358, -0.019113657996058464, -0.020867429673671722, 0.003262411803007126, 0.04042377695441246, -0.014894528314471245, 0.026489892974495888, 0.06692787259817123, 0.014634682796895504, 0.022895602509379387, 0.010752136819064617, 0.06099482625722885, 0.02443760633468628, -0.004122593905776739, -0.0414075031876564, -0.010006380267441273, 0.01547496858984232, -0.017564009875059128, -0.027414994314312935, -0.009031355381011963, -0.0066175456158816814, 0.024723723530769348, 0.017309747636318207, 0.03927532583475113, 0.011987091973423958, -0.036512792110443115, 0.03643767163157463, -0.047009650617837906, -0.0516749769449234, -0.06296011805534363, 0.022279471158981323, -0.009720053523778915, -0.04481206089258194, 0.04645899683237076, 0.019443238154053688, 0.016193846240639687, -0.024479245766997337, -0.03233500197529793, -0.04321780800819397, 0.009978112764656544, -0.0013459889451041818, -0.052107516676187515, 0.027630237862467766, 0.055807627737522125, 0.03348933160305023, -0.03340664133429527, 0.03164909407496452, -0.07810817658901215, -0.061105262488126755, 0.007491941098123789, -0.03051256760954857, -0.0033242939971387386, -0.04146832600235939, -0.016346817836165428, 0.016347957774996758, -0.026398183777928352, -0.020013535395264626, 0.024384157732129097, -0.04749087244272232, 0.07117506861686707, 0.019695086404681206, 0.03783222287893295, 0.031097156926989555, -0.03543204814195633, 0.04321427270770073, 0.011387860402464867, -0.02628171071410179, 0.019032983109354973, -0.04089672863483429, -0.02989300526678562, 0.03213446959853172, 0.006759321317076683, -0.046758875250816345, 0.01182818878442049, 0.05316367745399475, 0.028754645958542824, 0.015976112335920334, 0.041738539934158325, -0.0032621417194604874, -0.025978250429034233, -0.025146305561065674, 0.028816258534789085, 0.018142813816666603, 0.009263604879379272, 0.015635645017027855, 0.05059416964650154, 0.04790916666388512, -0.009394856169819832, -0.004342864267528057, 0.08708935230970383, 0.0029468834400177, -0.0003439848078414798, 0.012308260425925255, -0.007071075029671192, 0.007326193153858185, -0.04131929203867912, 0.011386430822312832, 0.028487544506788254, 0.01574849709868431, 0.006324019283056259, -0.014562759548425674, -0.04041004180908203, 0.03100687265396118, -0.0024703515227884054, -0.034484632313251495, 0.014538352377712727, 0.018842404708266258, -0.049909692257642746, 0.008854533545672894, -0.0479503758251667, -0.020857829600572586, -0.026561496779322624, 0.02895352989435196, 0.03545309230685234, 0.004041723906993866, 0.03925410658121109, 0.003175013465806842, -0.02186697907745838, -0.019068831577897072, -0.045054566115140915, 0.046632107347249985, -0.012261207215487957, -0.08133178949356079, 0.006159919314086437, -0.04087980091571808, -0.009462588466703892, 0.039104659110307693, -0.02719731628894806, 0.004425529856234789, 0.0009586765081621706, 0.0009228776907548308, -0.050567612051963806, -0.04241034388542175, -0.008396008051931858, 0.03951365873217583, -0.031990159302949905, -0.008061252534389496, 0.006977783981710672, -0.01719452440738678, -0.03580019995570183, 0.01545532327145338, -0.011589327827095985, -0.005201702006161213, -0.037476055324077606, -0.022680535912513733, 0.01909947581589222, -0.0032293731346726418, 0.025677597150206566, 0.03648923337459564, -0.04298628121614456, 0.012602932751178741, -0.04959557577967644, -0.05392898619174957, 0.017184389755129814, -0.015739955008029938, 0.03434985503554344, -0.018491128459572792, -0.024445077404379845, 0.07873819023370743, 0.024993982166051865, -0.019430672749876976, -0.029012037441134453, 0.02061748504638672, -0.03968492150306702, -0.04589732736349106, 0.004902037791907787, 0.012784639373421669, 0.021610045805573463, 0.040448710322380066, 0.003700483590364456, 0.016960393637418747, 0.05309052765369415, 0.013354489579796791, 0.021167373284697533, 0.012175885029137135, -0.009288163855671883, 0.004799291957169771, -0.001856427756138146, 0.01637951098382473, -0.012402289547026157, 0.007812014315277338, -0.03205525875091553, 0.0357399545609951, -0.0023325211368501186, -0.008377418853342533, 0.03277727961540222, -0.018432727083563805, -0.0009783785790205002, -0.006927539594471455, 0.013666168786585331, 0.013246187940239906, -0.03184089809656143, -0.018839286640286446, 0.0334554947912693, 0.037278883159160614, -0.02654147520661354, -0.026541832834482193, 0.022609828040003777, 0.021137814968824387, -0.021877434104681015, 0.01711820811033249, -0.03292959928512573, -0.02610192634165287, 0.018974896520376205, -0.008710759691894054, -0.009422209113836288, 0.07467921823263168, 0.0175566915422678, 0.04958707466721535, -0.01978030800819397, -0.02417845092713833, 0.008010941557586193, -0.034719083458185196, -0.00007543194078607485, 0.011575446464121342, 0.038194574415683746, -0.008842281997203827, 0.036314159631729126, -0.0021640555933117867, -0.010468962602317333, 0.0026011252775788307, 0.029896030202507973, -0.05983394384384155, 0.020994549617171288, -0.007579138036817312, -0.014300280250608921, -0.001983894035220146, 0.022134045138955116, 0.0336691178381443, -0.041073527187108994, -0.003592262975871563, -0.0494672916829586, -0.002452155575156212, -0.02968456782400608, 0.004981435835361481, -0.022325333207845688, -0.023155948147177696, -0.016063585877418518, 0.032319337129592896, 0.053179945796728134, -0.021828414872288704, 0.026042569428682327, 0.032580506056547165, -0.011387648060917854, -0.03478036820888519, -0.004780298098921776, 0.00844601634889841, 0.05072198435664177, 0.047227490693330765, 0.050938624888658524, 0.022288916632533073, -0.056725695729255676, 0.04398804157972336, -0.002764681586995721, 0.04084743931889534, 0.06739801168441772, -0.018883181735873222, -0.027521060779690742, -0.022419296205043793, -0.017298897728323936, 0.008940083906054497, 0.02364438772201538, 0.012096013873815536, -0.028851650655269623, 0.08475630730390549, 0.016855934634804726, -0.02116149477660656, 0.023712534457445145, 0.05777879059314728, 0.022493265569210052, -0.011597353965044022, -0.003911817446351051, -0.010017783381044865, -0.017797937616705894, 0.018363140523433685, 0.028357787057757378, 0.005613654851913452, -0.013977371156215668, 0.02172422595322132, 0.017611512914299965, -0.005249349866062403, -0.037970416247844696, -0.038155388087034225, 0.03093513660132885, 0.027958037331700325, 0.022201554849743843, -0.045729052275419235, 0.007464660331606865, 0.06996113806962967, 0.018610401079058647, 0.02708606980741024, 0.013079091906547546, -0.07685244083404541, 0.0025628332514315844, 0.04362994432449341, 0.03399845212697983, -0.03389028459787369, -0.0027011048514395952, -0.014995187520980835, -0.0157244261354208, 0.03736341372132301, -0.015226944349706173, 0.01828155480325222, -0.0015415367670357227, -0.011957668699324131, -0.036476194858551025, -0.031464286148548126, -0.046253181993961334, 0.010748110711574554, -0.01071851048618555, 0.004178457427769899, -0.02970273047685623, -0.026194775477051735, -0.04881984367966652, 0.008081207051873207, -0.010733176954090595, 0.06335979700088501, 0.004466408398002386, -0.021679436787962914, 0.003396810032427311, 0.04177467152476311, 0.0024776954669505358, -0.058252375572919846, -0.01213593129068613, -0.013652817346155643, -0.033863987773656845, 0.04889602214097977, -0.021900838240981102, -0.03110889531672001, 0.032728683203458786, 0.02559703402221203, -0.04879651591181755, -0.011434473097324371, -0.02248842641711235, 0.020104970782995224, 0.013386393897235394, -0.011979459784924984, 0.06409747153520584, 0.00904074963182211, 0.0006142714992165565, -0.02504679374396801, -0.0009358736569993198, 0.01594008319079876, -0.044505927711725235, -0.031247535720467567, -0.0426291823387146, -0.026487387716770172, -0.025908060371875763, 0.006792369298636913, 0.011749932542443275, -0.006662910804152489, -0.02414102293550968, -0.00590223353356123, -0.021267274394631386, 0.03361724689602852, 0.016997486352920532, 0.014282271265983582, 0.003823887323960662, 0.015575693920254707, -0.016670992597937584, 0.0067822192795574665, 0.03589152917265892, -0.021127255633473396, 0.011420494876801968, 0.02205502986907959, -0.00921141542494297, 0.011657455936074257, -0.0003560599870979786, -0.04061662033200264, 0.033778365701436996, 0.008425108157098293, 0.018926743417978287, -0.011379233561456203, -0.02124495431780815, -0.012894272804260254, -0.04980389028787613, 0.003155618207529187, 0.05315079912543297, 0.005498479586094618, 0.04117562249302864, -0.02137218415737152, 0.05753880739212036, -0.006403758190572262, 0.012428461574018002, -0.05061814561486244, 0.00017069961177185178, 0.020382490009069443, -0.01582411862909794, -0.05325357988476753, 0.0042213439010083675, -0.004611737094819546, -0.04912123084068298, -0.02087114192545414, -0.014412564225494862, 0.06214788183569908, -0.03131697326898575, -0.0428946316242218, 0.03640254959464073, 0.026069939136505127, 0.048773325979709625, 0.02568884752690792, -0.028998007997870445, 0.020032986998558044, -0.02180146984755993, -0.016302233561873436, 0.012272664345800877, 0.007494001183658838, -0.049009017646312714, 0.006405119318515062, -0.04814222827553749, -0.00771139794960618, 0.025665152817964554, -0.021793315187096596, 0.0012044800678268075, -0.0026756995357573032, -0.017043806612491608, 0.03188361972570419, -0.014853045344352722, 0.0013777614803984761, -0.034311383962631226, 0.007748396135866642, 0.008497354574501514, 0.032826825976371765, 0.03767231106758118, -0.010099474340677261, 0.05400771275162697, -0.016689522191882133, -0.015394135378301144, 0.005146258044987917, 0.060764964669942856, 0.011554780416190624, 0.03536134213209152, -0.0055397371761500835, -0.026596156880259514, 0.039006225764751434, 0.026035448536276817, 0.005793733522295952, -0.0037935259751975536, 0.05654001981019974, -0.04951288178563118, -0.019233178347349167, -0.010561405681073666, -0.014693657867610455, 0.05908292159438133, -0.056810349225997925, 0.00741128483787179, 0.0468759723007679, -0.027334412559866905, -0.0035415685269981623, -0.05279541015625, -0.003094325540587306, -0.018734430894255638, -0.016567762941122055, 0.061927229166030884, 0.008316404186189175, -0.0010843586642295122, 0.0579080656170845, -0.027273427695035934, -0.012169974856078625, 0.019891884177923203, 0.022996721789240837, 0.042974215000867844, -0.006869296543300152, -0.021849162876605988, -0.05079948902130127, 0.03670370206236839, -0.03940286859869957, 0.00967452023178339, 0.018835654482245445, 0.0026449537836015224, 0.039388034492731094, 0.05600617080926895, 0.014211566187441349, -0.04326124116778374, 0.005142312962561846, -0.03560782968997955, 0.02940966933965683, 0.002957121701911092, -0.01707959547638893, 0.027942948043346405, -0.007535835262387991, -0.01028447039425373, -0.0017766449600458145, 0.030480723828077316, 0.0017738185124471784, -0.063726045191288, -0.04782337322831154, -0.022506482899188995, 0.0005669780657626688, 0.0474335215985775, -0.01630723662674427, -0.02949407324194908, 0.004618321545422077, -0.043326202780008316, -0.01495328638702631, 0.003579888492822647, 0.03054954670369625, -0.010676231235265732, 0.07320452481508255, -0.009829169139266014, -0.022866306826472282, 0.016194308176636696, -0.041970156133174896, 0.11185067892074585, 0.08327750861644745, 0.012914231047034264, -0.07064436376094818, 0.022166993468999863, -0.019325939938426018, 0.008671714924275875, 0.006929234601557255, -0.02228000946342945, 0.00535243283957243, -0.00035322055919095874, 0.03470737487077713, 0.04601962864398956, -0.006539130583405495, -0.0020914331544190645, 0.054244980216026306, -0.06731706857681274, -0.030431613326072693, 0.0075600119307637215, 0.01829850859940052, 0.009335952810943127, -0.02631700597703457, -0.016302453354001045, -0.021969668567180634, 0.03835238143801689, -0.013053439557552338, 0.006688367575407028, 0.0026142101269215345, -0.004103495739400387, -0.007963581010699272, -0.023855086416006088, -0.016199979931116104, 0.006154631730169058, 0.031010305508971214, -0.030555484816432, 0.014696651138365269, -0.013488072901964188, -0.01790267787873745, -0.008534245193004608, 0.026114627718925476, -0.014130071736872196, -0.02458057925105095, 0.002622112398967147, 0.028053710237145424, -0.0483274944126606, -0.006336837541311979, -0.031347524374723434, 0.026432674378156662, 0.019671451300382614, -0.026286721229553223, -0.017187459394335747, 0.021407393738627434, 0.02750488370656967, -0.0016475585289299488, -0.047404203563928604, 0.02402828261256218, 0.06011032313108444, -0.03798949345946312, -0.02864634245634079, -0.039833009243011475, 0.00489834463223815, -0.0018861980643123388, 0.020212439820170403, 0.015237785875797272, -0.06360433250665665, 0.008844352327287197, -0.03359285369515419, 0.044362857937812805, 0.016933176666498184, 0.04029816761612892, 0.022339187562465668, 0.01787731610238552, -0.03879286348819733, 0.013050010427832603, 0.020021619275212288, -0.027007851749658585, 0.03137057647109032, -0.03488294035196304, -0.008992387913167477, -0.020874246954917908, -0.029146376997232437, 0.01807795651257038, -0.03177671134471893, -0.013249920681118965, -0.08381198346614838, 0.0022521652281284332, 0.04874125495553017, 0.027346394956111908, 0.013658516108989716, -0.017706720158457756, -0.029143299907445908, 0.02914915606379509, -0.0037261126562952995, -0.05284567549824715, 0.007483998779207468, 0.012835794128477573, 0.020174572244286537, 0.006395674776285887, -0.02343725971877575, 0.06372036039829254, 0.035210981965065, 0.035264287143945694, -0.004390834365040064, 0.020020509138703346, -0.004213187377899885, 0.01678471453487873, 0.011393265798687935, -0.0436418280005455, -0.018133802339434624, 0.014609427191317081, 0.011936836875975132, -0.07134534418582916, -0.03141618147492409, -0.04312789440155029, 0.004825654439628124, 0.023223331198096275, -0.028850138187408447, -0.04598928987979889, 0.043357234448194504, 0.01430047582834959, 0.03697805851697922, -0.047807104885578156, 0.001620848779566586, -0.04190080612897873, -0.0011912713525816798, 0.033589743077754974, -0.02385391667485237, 0.01285368762910366, -0.0021764924749732018, -0.0464179702103138, -0.007308280561119318, 0.03489290922880173, 0.03473733365535736, 0.012708036229014397, -0.010538052767515182, 0.013130554929375648, -0.00923679955303669, 0.0346476212143898, -0.034646112471818924, 0.015179664827883244, 0.04789820313453674, -0.04055829718708992, -0.04630477353930473, 0.028454195708036423, 0.0039856331422924995, 0.013244361616671085, 0.0020842759404331446, 0.010929281823337078, -0.02524271421134472, 0.01515771821141243, 0.0009213740122504532, -0.008598224259912968, -0.031300731003284454, 0.03109004907310009, -0.014277339912950993, -0.03583648055791855, -0.00697324238717556, -0.020774250850081444, 0.010397912003099918, 0.002962247235700488, 0.060152605175971985, 0.000017187958292197436, -0.01971760392189026, 0.015503163449466228, -0.0164076779037714, 0.03644570708274841, 0.005077866837382317, -0.012914113700389862, 0.011338813230395317, 0.014788147062063217, 0.0027657169848680496, 0.04043641686439514, 0.015419133007526398, 0.026513274759054184, -0.10842899233102798, -0.033302970230579376, 0.015292203985154629, 0.01986912451684475, 0.022673102095723152, -0.07909972965717316, -0.01900111697614193, 0.06762397289276123, -0.05560137704014778, -0.00999400857836008, 0.0024162393528968096, 0.0006053136894479394, -0.025133416056632996, -0.01671133190393448, -0.020145757123827934, 0.04830120876431465, 0.045855093747377396, -0.006337783299386501, 0.04982226341962814, 0.007033972069621086, -0.002691312227398157, -0.024242807179689407, -0.01683114282786846, 0.01072764117270708, -0.042933084070682526, -0.06911531090736389, 0.07128039002418518, 0.00970940850675106, -0.03990422189235687, -0.00801768433302641, 0.010299169458448887, 0.021942947059869766, 0.022762885317206383, -0.010657631792128086, 0.023476548492908478, 0.014858871698379517, 0.02822495438158512, -0.012141413986682892, -0.03192593902349472, 0.00041429608245380223, -0.009170839563012123, 0.061829034239053726, -0.004239349626004696, -0.0026071248576045036, -0.018962759524583817, -0.024692008271813393, -0.017960716038942337, -0.007248476147651672, -0.015424845740199089, -0.02851998619735241, 0.03313959762454033, 0.005324730183929205, -0.039459504187107086, -0.023457808420062065, 0.023161474615335464, -0.05273658409714699, -0.05695798248052597, 0.04161771386861801, 0.039869025349617004, 0.0016749337082728744, 0.01785808987915516, -0.021630173549056053, -0.04975762218236923, 0.03571108728647232, 0.010832429863512516, -0.012491739355027676, -0.04861072450876236, 0.011194146238267422, 0.034706179052591324, -0.019331976771354675, -0.046484578400850296, 0.0058767907321453094, -0.029301859438419342, 0.028283605352044106, -0.014570053666830063, -0.009695780463516712, 0.00048588417121209204, -0.0462307333946228, 0.013686873950064182, -0.08090516179800034, 0.06935154646635056, 0.0016395141137763858, -0.007527146954089403, -0.005691468250006437, -0.019365141168236732, -0.025118092074990273, -0.006153471767902374, 0.038785774260759354, -0.0026859818026423454, 0.018824990838766098, -0.018739238381385803, 0.0024133999831974506, 0.009022576734423637, -0.04415293410420418, 0.03138146549463272, -0.000589208269957453, -0.015645064413547516, -0.013951185159385204, -0.014044433832168579, 0.015246103517711163, 0.019220083951950073, 0.009157327935099602, 0.020701266825199127, 0.03129088133573532, 0.004373469855636358, 0.019245756790041924, 0.0722704827785492, 0.021602874621748924, 0.018179571256041527, 0.0334617905318737, -0.005429122131317854, 0.05096836015582085, 0.012318355031311512, -0.013804269023239613, -0.05385218560695648, 0.02180204540491104, -0.02773384191095829, -0.0389053039252758, 0.0122935576364398, 0.016727447509765625, -0.0152152543887496, -0.017749672755599022, -0.013835817575454712, 0.027519499883055687, -0.012074445374310017, 0.013311813585460186, -0.0026833144947886467, 0.03434081748127937, 0.02745451219379902, -0.02726704441010952, -0.0010296623222529888, 0.03063919208943844, -0.016255103051662445, -0.02643718011677265, 0.04059293493628502, 0.04702361673116684, 0.0019494155421853065, 0.01696746051311493, 0.04327522963285446, -0.011645196937024593, 0.024849852547049522, -0.009030357003211975, 0.0468987412750721, -0.05014292895793915, -0.011415643617510796, 0.004434230271726847, -0.01077770534902811, 0.021253637969493866, -0.0018289581639692187, 0.0156397707760334, 0.05142641067504883, -0.039407484233379364, 0.005796991754323244, -0.010232849977910519, -0.0015069196233525872, -0.014587564393877983, 0.0003610941639635712, 0.02554343454539776, 0.022662313655018806, -0.02383013628423214, 0.03858274593949318, 0.0013093986781314015, -0.015565468929708004, 0.03505013883113861, -0.0017599205020815134, 0.0165969580411911, 0.0075356485322117805, -0.03345274180173874, -0.041058752685785294, 0.019432904198765755, -0.02600988559424877, 0.01684519648551941, 0.047885697335004807, 0.05219961702823639, 0.003634858876466751, -0.030174849554896355, -0.023686902597546577, 0.004500375594943762, 0.06165391206741333, -0.06384074687957764, 0.0109980758279562, -0.027315156534314156, 0.025427868589758873, 0.011991765350103378, -0.017648661509156227 ]
<p>This may be a silly question, but I'm not seeing a clear answer in any of the usual sources. I'm preparing to build a Bayesian model to fit with BUGS/JAGS, currently working through the model logic in plate notation.</p> <p>I have a few kinds of observed variables, and several latent variables. I know that a Bayesian model has to be a DAG. What other conceptual constraints are there on the network? In particular, can an observed variable be the parent of a latent variable in a Bayesian model?</p> <p>Thanks, and happy fourth of July to all the Americans out there.</p>
36,960
[ -0.023815307766199112, 0.00129546201787889, 0.009495103731751442, -0.00842559989541769, 0.030114982277154922, -0.022869179025292397, -0.024217039346694946, 0.008016766048967838, 0.0285167433321476, -0.02510961890220642, 0.030476471409201622, 0.010747657157480717, 0.05458194762468338, 0.016548531129956245, -0.0030392471235245466, 0.039645615965127945, -0.00009264187974622473, 0.001437223982065916, -0.01021789200603962, -0.008373960852622986, -0.034030865877866745, 0.01945720799267292, 0.030062435194849968, -0.018089910969138145, 0.009265709668397903, 0.021796898916363716, 0.02021850273013115, 0.0024106944911181927, 0.020638154819607735, 0.037939392030239105, 0.008681448176503181, -0.01686951518058777, 0.028975710272789, 0.03142980858683586, 0.018084269016981125, 0.0008230589446611702, 0.011322244070470333, -0.0204081479460001, -0.030441224575042725, 0.05439944565296173, -0.04825553297996521, -0.018846267834305763, 0.010228745639324188, 0.021317869424819946, -0.031087759882211685, 0.01939297467470169, 0.0067475163377821445, 0.0056934719905257225, 0.07046110183000565, -0.016454394906759262, 0.08116433769464493, 0.016697319224476814, -0.0014325606171041727, 0.07336554676294327, -0.011605451814830303, -0.042545586824417114, 0.07272031158208847, 0.03515402600169182, 0.01991593837738037, -0.07433530688285828, -0.06542372703552246, -0.02334904856979847, 0.0007814014097675681, -0.05386524274945259, -0.04489864036440849, 0.014006082899868488, 0.01710275188088417, -0.03413347527384758, 0.027832968160510063, -0.0009849730413407087, -0.02962944097816944, -0.005100484937429428, 0.03062513656914234, 0.033604398369789124, 0.018572134897112846, -0.029958967119455338, 0.008909382857382298, 0.020047668367624283, 0.01479279063642025, -0.005628867540508509, 0.001279901247471571, 0.028312209993600845, -0.02481079287827015, 0.040153320878744125, -0.008912591263651848, -0.013584000058472157, 0.06757429987192154, -0.032826926559209824, 0.039088305085897446, 0.0001776386925484985, -0.09573691338300705, 0.022216953337192535, 0.049324650317430496, -0.00537090515717864, -0.051452185958623886, 0.02574162930250168, -0.002406541258096695, 0.01667678914964199, 0.015371115878224373, -0.01901227980852127, -0.04124998301267624, -0.037999801337718964, -0.00011099418043158948, 0.08118671923875809, 0.01614781655371189, -0.025736024603247643, -0.016276130452752113, 0.02744489535689354, -0.033093295991420746, -0.02317723073065281, -0.046755436807870865, 0.037660930305719376, -0.02078212983906269, 0.05335841327905655, 0.02356349676847458, -0.018422532826662064, -0.005880183074623346, -0.02023925818502903, 0.05569600686430931, 0.07112645357847214, 0.05494682863354683, -0.028722111135721207, 0.04860393702983856, -0.0031100274063646793, -0.06744177639484406, 0.028992125764489174, -0.004983942024409771, -0.02561175636947155, -0.00019376963609829545, 0.04794328659772873, -0.0027126544155180454, -0.03240726515650749, 0.023082850500941277, 0.012534990906715393, 0.015990814194083214, -0.006178074982017279, -0.07974259555339813, -0.07912316918373108, 0.00600211089476943, -0.0036205477081239223, 0.023365577682852745, -0.07707098126411438, 0.01752479374408722, 0.026464831084012985, 0.04450364038348198, -0.05219299718737602, 0.01961497589945793, 0.020319558680057526, 0.020165711641311646, -0.014739278703927994, -0.0031876300927251577, -0.03818842023611069, -0.014131664298474789, -0.04586225003004074, -0.026340395212173462, -0.06718377023935318, 0.0784011036157608, 0.012706651352345943, -0.013304885476827621, -0.01685340702533722, 0.05073738843202591, -0.03017556667327881, 0.009446977637708187, -0.027475479990243912, 0.014739579521119595, -0.038266316056251526, 0.0546586848795414, -0.01246216893196106, 0.013552763499319553, 0.036219388246536255, 0.021883955225348473, 0.0440785251557827, 0.007290883921086788, 0.08182778209447861, 0.04072655364871025, -0.028260789811611176, -0.05948038399219513, -0.01666441187262535, 0.020036939531564713, -0.006510433275252581, -0.01863347925245762, 0.010891100391745567, -0.023196280002593994, 0.006584789603948593, -0.03545108065009117, -0.002599980914965272, 0.019524743780493736, -0.010635226964950562, 0.05063989758491516, -0.02704964019358158, -0.03745982423424721, -0.025639010593295097, 0.018957259133458138, -0.0066864159889519215, -0.0014399240026250482, 0.0010829007951542735, -0.014647223055362701, 0.011492537334561348, -0.02625696174800396, -0.03497141972184181, -0.01106318086385727, -0.002313340548425913, 0.027201641350984573, -0.03619947284460068, -0.0009598486940376461, 0.03400985896587372, 0.059354446828365326, -0.0208419319242239, 0.026382476091384888, -0.045005567371845245, -0.015304173342883587, -0.018064072355628014, -0.015878545120358467, 0.006731313653290272, -0.030200311914086342, -0.004996735602617264, 0.012260576710104942, 0.004757121205329895, -0.01034300122410059, 0.04518217593431473, -0.05955147743225098, 0.06876864284276962, 0.05529751256108284, 0.009358186274766922, -0.006559798493981361, 0.04569224268198013, -0.0031669316813349724, 0.03311530500650406, -0.0217871256172657, 0.013780522160232067, -0.10161000490188599, -0.003160325577482581, 0.01524302363395691, -0.03530929237604141, -0.010707107372581959, 0.05017312988638878, 0.03353448957204819, 0.040964845567941666, -0.0024685112293809652, -0.001513487077318132, 0.0013428617967292666, -0.036132197827100754, -0.015712527558207512, 0.014282114803791046, 0.005768281873315573, 0.006626094225794077, 0.023984482511878014, 0.016887599602341652, 0.028758158907294273, -0.05020369589328766, -0.02376428432762623, 0.0239595714956522, 0.011978134512901306, 0.03246559575200081, -0.009838036261498928, -0.026107104495167732, 0.059961218386888504, -0.05332260578870773, 0.025972388684749603, 0.02186666429042816, -0.0015171525301411748, -0.05182703211903572, 0.0008767267572693527, -0.03055841661989689, -0.0003845388418994844, 0.03059028647840023, -0.03770126774907112, 0.010402202606201172, 0.034060798585414886, -0.010851982980966568, 0.02488907054066658, -0.02425863966345787, 0.0038084264378994703, -0.016136271879076958, 0.06204252317547798, 0.024536263197660446, -0.026573380455374718, 0.02612006850540638, -0.02340845577418804, -0.04360829293727875, 0.006809127051383257, -0.0033527894411236048, -0.003911215346306562, 0.0344170518219471, -0.029413307085633278, -0.01013709232211113, -0.022859785705804825, 0.010942277498543262, 0.0400862880051136, -0.03152564540505409, -0.025260867550969124, -0.007104456890374422, -0.013240248896181583, -0.022829372435808182, -0.0007989019504748285, -0.04356534779071808, -0.010920058004558086, -0.04216992110013962, -0.02144249901175499, 0.010965320281684399, 0.05934310704469681, -0.021436745300889015, 0.017075080424547195, -0.050216980278491974, -0.007099375128746033, -0.010340314358472824, -0.020040690898895264, -0.0000669022774673067, 0.02775523066520691, 0.026316111907362938, 0.06257861852645874, -0.03427455201745033, 0.03399890288710594, -0.008998613804578781, -0.08185230195522308, 0.04494556412100792, 0.01965591125190258, 0.014086456969380379, 0.01465541310608387, 0.01098776888102293, 0.045611120760440826, 0.022650543600320816, -0.04553975164890289, -0.0143040856346488, -0.017643991857767105, 0.00010456771269673482, -0.044771287590265274, 0.02426111325621605, 0.028300734236836433, 0.01854580268263817, 0.020850518718361855, -0.0042914762161672115, 0.028495457023382187, 0.003094913437962532, 0.00008863249968271703, 0.01904364302754402, 0.015818944200873375, -0.005757012404501438, -0.02111934684216976, 0.02275295928120613, 0.03989614546298981, -0.04170205816626549, -0.013007752597332, -0.0196582842618227, 0.01309958752244711, -0.010722504928708076, -0.018534451723098755, 0.007787791546434164, 0.008882139809429646, -0.019961917772889137, -0.024847984313964844, 0.003131162142381072, 0.04697265103459358, -0.018958164379000664, 0.00792678538709879, 0.01747116819024086, 0.04987659305334091, -0.010449458844959736, 0.014114784076809883, 0.07134995609521866, 0.01100120972841978, -0.023089472204446793, -0.03301655501127243, -0.012264369055628777, -0.030344638973474503, 0.0003353309875819832, -0.006485042627900839, 0.011700985953211784, 0.0144526157528162, -0.0138445645570755, 0.006535585969686508, 0.03430699184536934, -0.05880305916070938, 0.018329504877328873, -0.06196803227066994, 0.009323664009571075, -0.028702963143587112, 0.02045164629817009, -0.02705201506614685, 0.04387310519814491, -0.02192593924701214, 0.001920077484101057, -0.013427181169390678, 0.013460376299917698, -0.056069742888212204, -0.0152642372995615, -0.032022424042224884, -0.050642162561416626, -0.013207517564296722, -0.0421721413731575, 0.05759521573781967, -0.029169399291276932, 0.026254927739501, -0.01728164218366146, 0.003489105962216854, -0.02111043967306614, 0.028546631336212158, -0.05629466846585274, -0.04091762378811836, 0.02718352898955345, 0.009165281429886818, 0.027110792696475983, -0.01887533627450466, 0.0038940408267080784, 0.04633018374443054, 0.016098082065582275, -0.0472060963511467, -0.022668002173304558, -0.006086073815822601, -0.0022107369732111692, 0.0421266034245491, 0.041192829608917236, 0.024059249088168144, 0.0014387258561328053, -0.01114822831004858, 0.04078589379787445, 0.02800658531486988, 0.05024482309818268, -0.056031450629234314, 0.00020006234990432858, -0.030189666897058487, -0.031522780656814575, 0.028290461748838425, 0.049162209033966064, -0.00810998398810625, 0.022639896720647812, 0.04053362086415291, 0.015445075929164886, -0.03406200557947159, -0.002353332471102476, 0.045835528522729874, 0.02524505741894245, -0.03303951025009155, -0.011007939465343952, 0.016195744276046753, -0.022022049874067307, 0.016065606847405434, 0.0168819110840559, 0.0196398813277483, -0.004150346387177706, 0.008524889126420021, -0.013505063951015472, -0.03257560357451439, -0.002117095049470663, 0.006044691428542137, 0.009489641524851322, 0.024013133719563484, 0.005754250101745129, -0.03197016939520836, 0.01994585432112217, 0.03643931448459625, 0.048855993896722794, 0.05453451722860336, -0.02610846795141697, -0.07819166779518127, 0.014352161437273026, 0.03037506900727749, 0.015971630811691284, -0.012661561369895935, 0.004011655226349831, -0.03657158836722374, -0.05395316332578659, 0.027272986248135567, 0.005108386743813753, 0.030751818791031837, -0.006673823110759258, 0.05399085581302643, -0.0015493156388401985, -0.05708308145403862, -0.014338676817715168, 0.012001232244074345, -0.014534061774611473, 0.03215254098176956, -0.021183134987950325, -0.023548869416117668, -0.0019798860885202885, -0.021369732916355133, 0.0011110780760645866, 0.055665794759988785, -0.012772834859788418, -0.04062332212924957, -0.014219267293810844, 0.018845170736312866, -0.032939694821834564, -0.0709284096956253, 0.031526945531368256, 0.023586492985486984, -0.02691447176039219, 0.04617436230182648, -0.0029421274084597826, -0.02347324602305889, -0.008631631731987, 0.010242946445941925, -0.03243516385555267, 0.03655574470758438, -0.012148387730121613, 0.046315811574459076, 0.006106334738433361, 0.008922263979911804, 0.02310715802013874, -0.006651991046965122, 0.0136497113853693, 0.027442073449492455, -0.0313921794295311, 0.0314895398914814, -0.0607878603041172, 0.0382295623421669, -0.028784770518541336, -0.01962612196803093, -0.0031061323825269938, 0.043188802897930145, 0.005422074347734451, 0.028371170163154602, -0.032443463802337646, -0.05166632682085037, 0.017951251938939095, 0.008151501417160034, -0.014936448074877262, 0.0038430204149335623, -0.045196782797575, 0.05385657399892807, 0.010924266651272774, -0.004015992395579815, 0.04106356203556061, -0.03633099049329758, 0.0075415875762701035, 0.019958743825554848, -0.03412054851651192, 0.0031898198649287224, -0.02244351990520954, -0.052075427025556564, 0.020547816529870033, -0.028727352619171143, 0.033820994198322296, -0.009214730001986027, 0.017198191955685616, -0.02274542860686779, -0.06484128534793854, -0.03205180540680885, -0.011527854949235916, -0.011321229860186577, 0.03939838334918022, -0.01752377860248089, 0.01455971784889698, -0.03885605186223984, -0.003093698527663946, -0.057290758937597275, -0.036665741354227066, -0.021321261301636696, 0.0014062352711334825, -0.040887683629989624, 0.008747684769332409, 0.029698951169848442, -0.011270839720964432, -0.047251198440790176, -0.03278740495443344, 0.06895909458398819, -0.043117329478263855, 0.001725066569633782, 0.010567995719611645, 0.008668706752359867, 0.0696784257888794, 0.013933254405856133, 0.012795473448932171, 0.020474303513765335, -0.030878189951181412, 0.02503012865781784, -0.0005580363213084638, -0.008669164031744003, -0.0013017096789553761, 0.0170682892203331, -0.01586339995265007, 0.004154246766120195, 0.08051325380802155, -0.04002298787236214, 0.010675234720110893, 0.018788479268550873, -0.017295721918344498, -0.028130091726779938, -0.023097503930330276, 0.006482213735580444, -0.009824280627071857, -0.01328909583389759, -0.02926814928650856, 0.013405312784016132, 0.02813965082168579, -0.02309812605381012, 0.024212779477238655, -0.005502108484506607, 0.013465073890984058, 0.035772982984781265, 0.04586416482925415, 0.018648654222488403, 0.019285473972558975, 0.035909950733184814, 0.0031781448051333427, 0.059447482228279114, -0.014824985526502132, 0.03792954608798027, -0.037931330502033234, 0.007601040415465832, -0.03621935844421387, -0.018058601766824722, -0.06248057633638382, -0.029929235577583313, 0.07304152101278305, -0.011444373987615108, 0.056045979261398315, -0.0029483551625162363, 0.006601198110729456, -0.012641413137316704, -0.02629638835787773, 0.029885629191994667, -0.008414934389293194, -0.015182851813733578, 0.05266436189413071, -0.05826127529144287, -0.04383707791566849, 0.021378716453909874, 0.005093513987958431, 0.03111736848950386, 0.009601413272321224, 0.00756599148735404, 0.014985870569944382, 0.015999870374798775, -0.01562347263097763, -0.048124175518751144, 0.0013488748809322715, -0.05841619148850441, 0.00899440050125122, -0.041198402643203735, -0.0306688379496336, 0.039902713149785995, 0.015618517063558102, -0.017451025545597076, -0.04020218178629875, -0.05634944140911102, -0.04828598350286484, 0.023680632933974266, 0.019803320989012718, 0.02879531867802143, -0.0160544291138649, -0.022696061059832573, 0.011987196281552315, -0.044259920716285706, 0.004180638585239649, -0.03401980921626091, -0.07890128344297409, -0.06563842296600342, -0.001873781788162887, -0.033879004418849945, 0.03740215674042702, -0.0034216195344924927, -0.017490895465016365, -0.010287194512784481, -0.0276008490473032, -0.006556088570505381, -0.004978446289896965, 0.05147950351238251, -0.004702440928667784, 0.06838564574718475, 0.012705596163868904, 0.01217187661677599, -0.012387207709252834, 0.03413386642932892, 0.12650702893733978, 0.07110122591257095, 0.05167088657617569, -0.04367492347955704, 0.01228781882673502, -0.029526010155677795, -0.012757424265146255, -0.02087370865046978, 0.0214131660759449, 0.023713592439889908, -0.008442024700343609, 0.03824905678629875, 0.02391548454761505, -0.006580457556992769, 0.01571006327867508, 0.055572763085365295, -0.04775630682706833, -0.02211209014058113, 0.010109435766935349, 0.011057808995246887, -0.013813952915370464, -0.0009713372564874589, -0.026596587151288986, -0.00779492175206542, 0.02448946051299572, -0.007617197465151548, 0.017791233956813812, -0.025768060237169266, 0.02506161853671074, -0.0064262826927006245, 0.022680649533867836, -0.01682507060468197, 0.014570857398211956, -0.003361747832968831, 0.0019955241587013006, -0.01040719822049141, 0.013446059077978134, -0.037069715559482574, 0.011882207356393337, 0.017813706770539284, 0.000026692125175031833, 0.0031648343428969383, 0.004869767464697361, -0.008455104194581509, -0.01717096008360386, -0.056070614606142044, 0.007444459013640881, 0.03690963238477707, -0.02465219981968403, 0.023399092257022858, -0.010059086605906487, -0.011121703311800957, 0.03073435090482235, -0.03091464564204216, -0.003365105949342251, 0.05102984979748726, 0.009841754101216793, 0.005805095192044973, -0.03173595294356346, -0.0025330758653581142, 0.008228198625147343, -0.017480984330177307, 0.04233669862151146, 0.023007145151495934, -0.005193586461246014, -0.028174230828881264, -0.035469479858875275, 0.05466737225651741, 0.04546186700463295, -0.023279912769794464, 0.020265936851501465, -0.03876494988799095, -0.01188928633928299, 0.007455332670360804, 0.03599255904555321, 0.020240817219018936, -0.02617768384516239, -0.015128172002732754, 0.03370216116309166, -0.005821738392114639, 0.010868801735341549, -0.018048938363790512, -0.045517079532146454, -0.001809251494705677, -0.040199343115091324, 0.014122514054179192, 0.028537308797240257, 0.0711798444390297, -0.01879042014479637, 0.035872071981430054, -0.029870282858610153, 0.060643188655376434, 0.009996463544666767, -0.04314609616994858, -0.02620350569486618, 0.01442358922213316, -0.03979599103331566, 0.013159731402993202, 0.008174395188689232, 0.044893812388181686, 0.011809516698122025, 0.035858795046806335, -0.028406895697116852, 0.039064671844244, 0.027849044650793076, 0.04187111556529999, 0.008769797161221504, -0.0372299924492836, 0.0003545705112628639, -0.021810216829180717, 0.00597730465233326, -0.027560677379369736, -0.0441703274846077, -0.027892470359802246, 0.003381266724318266, -0.009656586684286594, -0.005005468148738146, -0.07718707621097565, -0.020052824169397354, 0.011125689372420311, 0.013740530237555504, -0.017201632261276245, 0.027899906039237976, -0.018571574240922928, -0.0025026509538292885, 0.0017545688897371292, 0.01402689516544342, -0.01614993065595627, 0.03698786720633507, -0.024209370836615562, -0.024005698040127754, 0.009598650969564915, 0.020417850464582443, 0.03826102241873741, -0.015679925680160522, -0.025352297350764275, 0.020355070009827614, 0.06413485109806061, -0.03458148241043091, -0.02363932877779007, 0.01646876335144043, -0.06186507269740105, -0.02667483501136303, 0.03856103494763374, 0.019423263147473335, 0.030122030526399612, 0.006596557796001434, 0.0017704180208966136, -0.030007680878043175, 0.008985630236566067, -0.011349582113325596, -0.0009873338276520371, 0.0027296964544802904, 0.015515628270804882, -0.02479853294789791, -0.0012729070149362087, -0.0087361391633749, 0.014198960736393929, -0.0037331676576286554, 0.017523735761642456, -0.003031477564945817, 0.030089695006608963, -0.01856863871216774, 0.0069551002234220505, 0.006259098183363676, 0.002907863585278392, -0.003953862003982067, 0.018808580935001373, 0.02461746148765087, 0.029891641810536385, -0.006943355314433575, 0.06414560228586197, 0.02972078137099743, 0.03966209292411804, -0.060993921011686325, 0.002922633895650506, 0.008107283152639866, 0.03731643781065941, 0.057945616543293, -0.036527689546346664, 0.025139471516013145, 0.006959309335798025, -0.06309499591588974, -0.009325942024588585, 0.010729442350566387, 0.016914406791329384, -0.003266748273745179, -0.030961237847805023, -0.023139799013733864, 0.0515604093670845, -0.02371705323457718, 0.03393728286027908, 0.023321034386754036, 0.021725937724113464, 0.02096458338201046, -0.05244220048189163, -0.0470646433532238, -0.020299622789025307, 0.019455503672361374, -0.028994431719183922, 0.061471521854400635, -0.0815851092338562, -0.0383937805891037, 0.03223279118537903, 0.034067634493112564, 0.0021281179506331682, -0.003614316927269101, 0.0011046165600419044, 0.05283807963132858, 0.018032651394605637, 0.053910478949546814, 0.002973813796415925, 0.005166726652532816, 0.039280638098716736, -0.02303575910627842, 0.016533443704247475, 0.0027343910187482834, -0.013838276267051697, 0.017588475719094276, -0.024684861302375793, 0.002970096655189991, -0.0300283282995224, -0.03677044063806534, -0.011471576988697052, 0.029546836391091347, -0.012127839028835297, 0.007919072173535824, -0.0024729229044169188, 0.02460118569433689, -0.07333552837371826, -0.004697146359831095, 0.055037736892700195, 0.044837672263383865, -0.039136242121458054, 0.013440013863146305, 0.001925271237269044, -0.046495672315359116, 0.00161723920609802, 0.008378458209335804, -0.006950401701033115, -0.04609058424830437, 0.01027111429721117, -0.01348102930933237, -0.03650176525115967, -0.02181212790310383, -0.030301852151751518, -0.051834139972925186, 0.05979222431778908, -0.043529655784368515, -0.005985503550618887, -0.0015697182388976216, -0.046073511242866516, 0.057637546211481094, -0.04209691658616066, 0.058875247836112976, 0.003904815763235092, 0.012884529307484627, -0.03754621371626854, -0.004851965699344873, -0.012232737615704536, 0.017422202974557877, 0.061084553599357605, -0.036711037158966064, 0.009142259135842323, -0.0003987515810877085, -0.009966757148504257, -0.005412675440311432, -0.021936912089586258, 0.05985496938228607, -0.013586613349616528, 0.00697670690715313, -0.03219810873270035, -0.019841117784380913, -0.01810147613286972, 0.022070758044719696, 0.010064677335321903, 0.013677871786057949, 0.026840606704354286, 0.009279487654566765, -0.02919875644147396, -0.014874587766826153, 0.004199102055281401, 0.029778849333524704, 0.06339167803525925, -0.0018790115136653185, -0.0017619117861613631, 0.07357078790664673, -0.005189265590161085, -0.06861308962106705, 0.06398837268352509, -0.00839652307331562, -0.011437763459980488, 0.008889762684702873, 0.02260771580040455, -0.005063805263489485, -0.03781570866703987, 0.0013444890500977635, 0.046606384217739105, -0.007492675445973873, -0.008891884237527847, 0.015281528234481812, 0.013154091313481331, 0.04306625947356224, -0.004900121130049229, 0.01522059179842472, 0.007239778060466051, -0.009836982935667038, 0.018051113933324814, 0.020940115675330162, 0.03738551214337349, 0.006669811904430389, 0.06060809642076492, 0.029110928997397423, -0.023065168410539627, 0.0408058762550354, -0.040377065539360046, 0.0063676550053060055, -0.003821012796834111, -0.005927377380430698, -0.009126258082687855, 0.01601342298090458, 0.0037989618722349405, -0.010053330101072788, 0.022905828431248665, 0.04043935239315033, -0.03916285187005997, 0.008530871011316776, -0.019268827512860298, 0.05893969535827637, -0.02676215022802353, 0.027898289263248444, -0.032478105276823044, 0.009615078568458557, 0.006316347047686577, -0.021507084369659424, -0.032069623470306396, -0.025272950530052185, 0.019400767982006073, -0.03877680376172066, 0.0055828336626291275, -0.033296842128038406, 0.0350332148373127, -0.013655298389494419, 0.001226289663463831, -0.06217936426401138, 0.016233351081609726, 0.032948482781648636, 0.040744613856077194, -0.008899455890059471, -0.032269760966300964, -0.04455910623073578, 0.014607580378651619, 0.012703251093626022, -0.06866741180419922, -0.028504110872745514, -0.027088958770036697, 0.04088721424341202, 0.023752707988023758, 0.01873626932501793 ]
<p>Is a p-value from a traditional significance test the same as the false alarm value in the Bayesian rule? And/or is it "close enough" to give correct results when used that way?</p> <p>The definitions of the two terms seem to be talking about the same things, but I know it's easy to be tripped up by subtleties. Wikipedia <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-value" rel="nofollow">says</a> that a p-value is "the probability of obtaining a test statistic at least as extreme as the one that was actually observed, assuming that the null hypothesis is true."</p> <p><a href="http://psych.fullerton.edu/mbirnbaum/bayes/BayesCalc.htm" rel="nofollow">This page</a> says the false error rate P(D|H') in the Bayesian rule is the probability of observing D if H' is true.</p> <p>In both cases, you are talking about the probability of seeing data that says H when the reality is H'.</p> <p>However, I see two possible problems with assuming that the two are equivalent: D in the definition of P(D|H') seems to refer to a single datum, while the definition of a p-value seems to refer to a range of values ("at least as extreme as"); and I'm not quite smart enough to figure out whether H' is equivalent to the null hypothesis. In all the simple Bayesian examples I've worked through it certainly seems to be, but I haven't yet found a definitive statement.</p> <p>I also haven't found a definitive statement of how p-value and the false alarm value are related if they aren't the same, given that they're both saying at least loosely analogous things about data and hypotheses.</p>
74,219
[ -0.030300132930278778, -0.03179045021533966, 0.0036246327217668295, -0.029114268720149994, 0.0528748594224453, 0.04720228537917137, 0.023510625585913658, -0.01905049942433834, 0.037055060267448425, -0.03485146164894104, 0.023289289325475693, 0.009225629270076752, 0.037393562495708466, 0.02440885826945305, 0.03382130712270737, 0.026165509596467018, -0.026951469480991364, 0.006997228600084782, -0.018094513565301895, -0.0367131344974041, 0.03219608962535858, 0.022878073155879974, 0.02127990499138832, -0.02341471053659916, -0.03177502751350403, 0.04415871948003769, 0.0422418974339962, 0.027085110545158386, 0.01499030739068985, 0.08276250213384628, -0.02963544800877571, -0.0076521956361830235, 0.009011704474687576, 0.04867557808756828, 0.018471192568540573, -0.014004978351294994, 0.0017446763813495636, 0.008546227589249611, -0.016790904104709625, 0.04307158663868904, -0.005482652690261602, -0.02954697422683239, 0.008314945735037327, 0.06728418916463852, -0.02603716030716896, -0.014337152242660522, -0.016305644065141678, -0.04680756852030754, 0.01286050584167242, -0.044645123183727264, 0.05189244821667671, -0.019850583747029305, 0.029860444366931915, 0.021705523133277893, 0.004273519851267338, -0.023301374167203903, 0.06175019592046738, 0.03882196545600891, -0.030756792053580284, -0.07496634870767593, -0.02438885159790516, -0.043867554515600204, -0.0035102053079754114, -0.03516480326652527, -0.022775594145059586, 0.05127667263150215, -0.01093440130352974, -0.05458518862724304, 0.04419523477554321, 0.028776366263628006, -0.01727692410349846, 0.02286391891539097, 0.033918287605047226, -0.0062110512517392635, 0.05900820344686508, -0.04971935972571373, 0.008593165315687656, 0.0297292061150074, 0.038064196705818176, 0.0719618946313858, 0.038041308522224426, -0.00437892833724618, 0.0464252270758152, 0.05794115737080574, 0.02208769880235195, -0.013681666925549507, 0.06901772320270538, -0.021711623296141624, 0.008394296281039715, 0.006265939213335514, -0.03914298489689827, 0.024884646758437157, 0.02803022414445877, -0.023252667859196663, -0.04221775010228157, 0.017183056101202965, -0.027592647820711136, 0.058814674615859985, 0.006186640355736017, 0.0012934651458635926, -0.00826917216181755, -0.04893650487065315, 0.04032228887081146, 0.023809121921658516, -0.008310619741678238, -0.03737275302410126, -0.00977865606546402, 0.026409514248371124, -0.018655279651284218, -0.034303683787584305, -0.009720675647258759, 0.05331232771277428, 0.016014575958251953, 0.02371823415160179, -0.003487030742689967, -0.012840049341320992, 0.00680555822327733, -0.001529657281935215, 0.10096969455480576, 0.029104523360729218, 0.041376322507858276, -0.003685122588649392, 0.013093900866806507, -0.03561164811253548, -0.030780993402004242, -0.0016294546658173203, -0.01523543894290924, -0.007704733870923519, -0.0006128005334176123, 0.0670059472322464, -0.015198877081274986, -0.024668781086802483, 0.06220786273479462, 0.007547796703875065, 0.013633777387440205, -0.02618449181318283, -0.07029041647911072, -0.024912267923355103, 0.03571419045329094, 0.03423304483294487, -0.01950712315738201, -0.08814119547605515, 0.0055617899633944035, 0.035438839346170425, 0.005761608015745878, 0.00986447837203741, 0.015582650899887085, 0.0017324785003438592, 0.020582539960741997, 0.014962964691221714, -0.036859337240457535, -0.017757494002580643, 0.013128597289323807, -0.01701514609158039, -0.03022165596485138, -0.09417005628347397, 0.008654102683067322, -0.0108836330473423, -0.013174792751669884, 0.0027698201593011618, 0.07573270797729492, -0.04540024697780609, -0.032073695212602615, -0.0172425489872694, 0.024723012000322342, -0.01092500425875187, 0.10575415194034576, -0.0005962891154922545, 0.017606796696782112, 0.04811638593673706, 0.018399294465780258, 0.006295783445239067, 0.007402015384286642, 0.043078623712062836, 0.03535861521959305, -0.03046678751707077, -0.010472015477716923, -0.06167939677834511, 0.03267673775553703, 0.0006651107687503099, -0.026711788028478622, 0.01848961040377617, -0.01909624971449375, -0.001181459752842784, -0.006650332361459732, 0.026007261127233505, 0.004450320731848478, -0.0202494990080595, 0.0272528026252985, -0.0557832196354866, -0.06018510460853577, -0.07932382822036743, -0.03795134276151657, -0.013062907382845879, -0.007099826354533434, 0.04142505303025246, 0.041419949382543564, 0.020493825897574425, -0.04797618091106415, -0.010618291795253754, 0.021143190562725067, -0.004474954679608345, 0.032422903925180435, -0.06520804762840271, 0.002221076749265194, 0.07142002135515213, 0.03731239587068558, 0.0032994376961141825, 0.027006570249795914, -0.03505012392997742, -0.05412758141756058, -0.006620046216994524, -0.029506143182516098, 0.0010029516415670514, -0.0021549975499510765, 0.004530706442892551, 0.04544428363442421, -0.03588779270648956, 0.00779886357486248, 0.01647525280714035, -0.06666629016399384, 0.0601806715130806, 0.054807789623737335, 0.003026003949344158, 0.01946733519434929, 0.00317306537181139, 0.011832207441329956, -0.004493093583732843, -0.04326774179935455, 0.026316292583942413, -0.03754117712378502, 0.010827669873833656, 0.04905766621232033, -0.005541256163269281, -0.027104590088129044, 0.014003628864884377, 0.029824990779161453, 0.02098187990486622, 0.05162039399147034, 0.060339804738759995, -0.013428309932351112, -0.042726270854473114, -0.010433553718030453, 0.016959190368652344, -0.014867098070681095, 0.005476436577737331, 0.016403695568442345, -0.01145881600677967, 0.05118700489401817, -0.016678910702466965, -0.015712110325694084, 0.039585892111063004, -0.039071619510650635, 0.019021285697817802, -0.016665613278746605, -0.020689338445663452, 0.017654545605182648, -0.046049561351537704, -0.030787823721766472, -0.007727750111371279, -0.014123177155852318, -0.014697743579745293, -0.01684984378516674, -0.01290940772742033, 0.017994368448853493, 0.020773382857441902, -0.030790001153945923, 0.00935925543308258, 0.017018135637044907, -0.03590047359466553, -0.003243229817599058, -0.05526479706168175, -0.026248391717672348, -0.01822848618030548, 0.016647346317768097, 0.007962157018482685, -0.004069611895829439, 0.04245615378022194, -0.03694434463977814, -0.03008919209241867, -0.05486429110169411, -0.03482401743531227, 0.0035797348245978355, -0.005330938380211592, -0.032520316541194916, -0.0013834198471158743, -0.04034377634525299, -0.036629948765039444, 0.03781658411026001, -0.030208604410290718, 0.0005649210070259869, 0.0033775721676647663, 0.0027013306971639395, -0.023993317037820816, -0.014950815588235855, -0.04171326383948326, -0.007479045540094376, -0.03561524301767349, -0.02446414902806282, 0.029652195051312447, -0.0021489071659743786, -0.012143708765506744, 0.057628218084573746, -0.010044228285551071, -0.05968577787280083, -0.05776846781373024, -0.00908857211470604, -0.02069171704351902, 0.005963155534118414, 0.031690970063209534, 0.03819441422820091, -0.04640989378094673, -0.008918850682675838, -0.05190391093492508, -0.0645548403263092, 0.03578688204288483, 0.001241012243553996, 0.024994604289531708, -0.003934066742658615, -0.00016045270604081452, 0.06469710916280746, 0.02828669734299183, -0.012994431890547276, -0.023090284317731857, 0.011955846101045609, -0.006437238771468401, 0.0005474559147842228, 0.0011038895463570952, 0.028552880510687828, 0.0074214753694832325, 0.009050531312823296, -0.04752817004919052, -0.0016899146139621735, 0.014378512278199196, 0.0327640026807785, 0.011858842335641384, 0.01565426029264927, 0.017109349370002747, -0.006166324019432068, 0.04952821508049965, 0.03658091649413109, -0.002863860921934247, 0.020439021289348602, 0.010165262036025524, 0.03201302886009216, -0.005072952248156071, -0.03761301934719086, 0.027870582416653633, -0.007532473653554916, 0.008122696541249752, -0.005271766800433397, 0.033450886607170105, 0.00988698285073042, -0.010366765782237053, -0.015162727795541286, 0.01268323976546526, 0.0151631785556674, -0.01915283128619194, -0.007166269235312939, 0.0641508400440216, 0.043451759964227676, 0.010845547541975975, -0.03918348252773285, -0.010768180713057518, 0.011469605378806591, 0.04182479903101921, -0.020589472725987434, -0.01724299229681492, 0.07407830655574799, 0.017101237550377846, 0.03963341563940048, 0.010915528051555157, -0.04757474735379219, -0.005083648953586817, -0.0702490285038948, 0.00654835719615221, -0.01700836978852749, 0.031017577275633812, -0.013131205923855305, 0.039123062044382095, 0.06104375794529915, 0.0019919693004339933, 0.004600790794938803, 0.011560426093637943, -0.0789506733417511, 0.013202176429331303, -0.018989356234669685, -0.026101570576429367, -0.01405960414558649, -0.054591670632362366, 0.02171262726187706, -0.02594197914004326, 0.025995317846536636, -0.010762323625385761, -0.0008459375821985304, -0.028765566647052765, 0.01767064444720745, -0.028452403843402863, -0.0036291037686169147, -0.009621169418096542, 0.01363703515380621, 0.027418043464422226, 0.001041303388774395, -0.019098075106739998, 0.05081143602728844, -0.03193628042936325, 0.005104330834001303, 0.021243726834654808, 0.019257619976997375, 0.03867350146174431, 0.03683364763855934, 0.03146098181605339, 0.05332145094871521, -0.03498714789748192, 0.03895263746380806, 0.025898385792970657, 0.05523359775543213, 0.043458402156829834, -0.03610795736312866, -0.01248982734978199, -0.01452256552875042, -0.015636825934052467, -0.01880686730146408, 0.036011338233947754, -0.016050051897764206, 0.01616816781461239, 0.03473760560154915, 0.021711118519306183, -0.015386443585157394, 0.06676715612411499, 0.0608426034450531, 0.013854580000042915, 0.00184915482532233, -0.03431675583124161, 0.0023628631606698036, -0.043012529611587524, -0.01647207885980606, 0.02878023497760296, 0.009129354730248451, -0.034213535487651825, -0.03723660856485367, 0.017369717359542847, -0.026692133396863937, -0.04127990081906319, -0.0038094078190624714, 0.024761637672781944, 0.012075735256075859, 0.022981273010373116, -0.0011055279755964875, 0.02987678535282612, 0.015719762071967125, 0.022391188889741898, 0.050756052136421204, 0.010036339052021503, -0.04602750763297081, 0.005668582394719124, 0.036314018070697784, 0.04810342937707901, -0.014067940413951874, 0.01179938018321991, -0.05435255542397499, -0.0009536971338093281, 0.030942818149924278, -0.03699452430009842, 0.0035831325221806765, -0.008903342299163342, 0.026763267815113068, -0.02346048317849636, -0.00031528648105449975, -0.04450229927897453, -0.010404312051832676, -0.010461957193911076, 0.03983692452311516, -0.020975666120648384, -0.024204786866903305, -0.06334410607814789, 0.011952150613069534, -0.007506019435822964, 0.035331740975379944, -0.0336986742913723, -0.027345772832632065, -0.008147560991346836, 0.01240371074527502, -0.01709405519068241, -0.0804605633020401, 0.02427968569099903, 0.002423470839858055, 0.018333744257688522, 0.03932657837867737, -0.033529479056596756, -0.00825776718556881, 0.019337065517902374, -0.014008931815624237, -0.039072830229997635, 0.022059498354792595, -0.014732162468135357, 0.03542085736989975, 0.03044954687356949, 0.0035713454708456993, 0.06022656708955765, -0.02773819863796234, 0.007649019360542297, -0.02559063397347927, -0.03973318636417389, 0.020602194592356682, -0.05832158029079437, 0.008013972081243992, -0.05676401033997536, -0.009651536121964455, -0.021371476352214813, 0.03650661185383797, 0.02139279618859291, -0.0014617197448387742, -0.0024490864016115665, -0.0003416983236093074, 0.023382345214486122, 0.004344213288277388, -0.0031952860299497843, 0.009543387219309807, -0.017973050475120544, 0.027004379779100418, 0.02418590523302555, 0.012410355731844902, 0.028748422861099243, -0.019024455919861794, 0.011866342276334763, 0.002330133458599448, -0.043392155319452286, 0.046384964138269424, -0.012508146464824677, -0.038114141672849655, 0.05600253865122795, -0.02499036304652691, 0.0219121016561985, -0.038867246359586716, -0.005553714465349913, -0.0017589099006727338, -0.04462067410349846, -0.009829523973166943, 0.00490376353263855, 0.03045639581978321, 0.05495774373412132, -0.05189213901758194, 0.04564736410975456, -0.02493571862578392, -0.019842302426695824, -0.07668648660182953, -0.0082186758518219, 0.040298085659742355, 0.014212498441338539, -0.046384505927562714, -0.007540563587099314, -0.027966775000095367, -0.008611355908215046, -0.031281158328056335, -0.030853979289531708, 0.06479877233505249, -0.03576622158288956, -0.03300806134939194, 0.007512303069233894, -0.00021586647199001163, 0.06745801120996475, -0.01174568198621273, 0.01189145166426897, -0.016673237085342407, -0.0024882734287530184, 0.005783670581877232, 0.008921894244849682, 0.04213429614901543, -0.012227795086801052, -0.002413457725197077, -0.02055353857576847, -0.020638125017285347, 0.024667419493198395, -0.023163771256804466, -0.03468107432126999, 0.014563691802322865, -0.00011083942808909342, -0.002211175160482526, -0.014342306181788445, -0.01636255346238613, -0.004012668039649725, 0.003360720816999674, -0.014501235447824001, 0.005198782775551081, 0.029696112498641014, -0.0008638227009214461, -0.017519259825348854, 0.001466099638491869, -0.0051391106098890305, 0.011397922411561012, 0.03440699353814125, -0.044728606939315796, 0.015599891543388367, -0.017866501584649086, -0.02327794022858143, 0.03265262767672539, 0.01745063066482544, -0.010019350796937943, -0.007918840274214745, 0.0017287053633481264, -0.008763267658650875, -0.0147545849904418, -0.05449619144201279, -0.002941293641924858, 0.050598956644535065, 0.011924613267183304, 0.05222536623477936, 0.020509853959083557, 0.026213325560092926, -0.01077671255916357, -0.05436313897371292, 0.0015632061986252666, -0.003997545689344406, 0.022395210340619087, 0.018203893676400185, -0.029268190264701843, -0.02172994054853916, 0.0470307283103466, 0.0034014026168733835, -0.013779588043689728, 0.05202296003699303, 0.035179946571588516, 0.03340098261833191, 0.026844628155231476, -0.03955281525850296, -0.036979883909225464, 0.049627967178821564, -0.04044158384203911, 0.01789102330803871, -0.0242763739079237, -0.045104190707206726, 0.037786815315485, 0.019273070618510246, 0.00014782571815885603, -0.05746515095233917, -0.015207963064312935, -0.051977500319480896, 0.0162272397428751, 0.032002147287130356, -0.011234104633331299, 0.029063913971185684, -0.02957339771091938, 0.023544445633888245, -0.012363515794277191, 0.017731858417391777, 0.007189723197370768, -0.0478859543800354, -0.04339056834578514, -0.014283627271652222, -0.0317801833152771, 0.017634987831115723, -0.021615829318761826, -0.024319138377904892, 0.00372384674847126, -0.05209934338927269, -0.006911665666848421, 0.016768496483564377, 0.04400273784995079, -0.010624104179441929, 0.034427396953105927, 0.0011045774444937706, 0.025834158062934875, -0.022249124944210052, -0.04286368191242218, 0.1199294775724411, 0.08948618173599243, 0.04747280478477478, -0.04476349800825119, 0.02568451501429081, -0.035036150366067886, 0.03398943692445755, -0.02365465834736824, -0.013373845256865025, 0.05001213774085045, -0.004239801317453384, 0.036492396146059036, 0.05031932517886162, 0.02369266003370285, -0.029995189979672432, 0.06654395163059235, -0.026470553129911423, -0.02308296039700508, -0.015365182422101498, 0.06038788706064224, -0.0121846254914999, -0.021400267258286476, 0.01505528949201107, 0.004988869186490774, 0.0017562624998390675, -0.014913514256477356, -0.011331383138895035, -0.016401225700974464, -0.0453442819416523, 0.010089455172419548, -0.03981849178671837, -0.050595082342624664, 0.0010821744799613953, -0.0402333103120327, -0.012258677743375301, -0.000903888198081404, -0.014528179541230202, -0.025844542309641838, -0.03984155133366585, 0.06682904809713364, 0.017839675769209862, -0.018241796642541885, 0.021010909229516983, 0.027629198506474495, -0.04774677753448486, -0.029356960207223892, -0.0006692425231449306, 0.04638481140136719, -0.008639813400804996, -0.017068440094590187, 0.01726294308900833, -0.014944142661988735, -0.0032997073139995337, -0.05721299722790718, 0.009046360850334167, 0.027134358882904053, 0.017734142020344734, -0.03342911973595619, -0.018519682809710503, -0.013790796510875225, 0.03009258769452572, -0.011891888454556465, 0.022674832493066788, 0.03073701076209545, -0.019053099676966667, -0.013750419020652771, -0.03840019553899765, 0.0466003492474556, 0.019270140677690506, 0.015706559643149376, 0.005282744765281677, -0.00139282934833318, -0.05048314109444618, 0.003787494031712413, 0.012756734155118465, -0.012122394517064095, 0.003646983066573739, 0.02924390695989132, -0.017366329208016396, -0.01125843171030283, -0.024341538548469543, 0.021469522267580032, -0.04213327541947365, -0.0195393655449152, -0.03775513544678688, -0.007259937468916178, 0.06693565845489502, 0.03854092210531235, 0.0020960383117198944, 0.048155974596738815, 0.01808171533048153, 0.04117448255419731, 0.018731148913502693, -0.051146287471055984, -0.018204163759946823, 0.03587641194462776, -0.02870030514895916, -0.001913128886371851, 0.020709456875920296, 0.04245005548000336, 0.04160677269101143, 0.04174556955695152, -0.011676554568111897, 0.01921182870864868, 0.012126500718295574, -0.012301583774387836, -0.04213528335094452, -0.04476197436451912, -0.0007845024229027331, 0.022717228159308434, 0.004138307645916939, -0.018285969272255898, -0.020533237606287003, -0.06908818334341049, -0.0018658410990610719, -0.00727578392252326, -0.032864995300769806, -0.030146801844239235, 0.0015091252280399203, 0.01715293899178505, 0.02877827174961567, -0.0030180923640727997, -0.0019558905623853207, -0.024535134434700012, -0.039371419697999954, 0.013117940165102482, -0.006784022320061922, -0.02206791751086712, 0.02618836611509323, -0.014455275610089302, -0.024785691872239113, 0.03735819086432457, 0.031737297773361206, 0.0060467408038675785, -0.016523471102118492, 0.013147369027137756, 0.02132495306432247, 0.03573479503393173, 0.003550130408257246, 0.004451625049114227, 0.06405910104513168, -0.05422678962349892, -0.039045143872499466, 0.06243766471743584, 0.04428260028362274, -0.006383523344993591, 0.013899854384362698, 0.02044445089995861, -0.015772607177495956, 0.038350172340869904, -0.02366350032389164, -0.02436143346130848, 0.01514136791229248, -0.0190530177205801, -0.030018066987395287, 0.01459836307913065, 0.009279861114919186, 0.04229220375418663, 0.023624936118721962, 0.014586081728339195, 0.026172174140810966, 0.013102572411298752, 0.04311317205429077, -0.016911529004573822, -0.013517538085579872, 0.01299135759472847, -0.012422608211636543, -0.024808796122670174, 0.010162985883653164, 0.05488423630595207, -0.01085806917399168, 0.026963133364915848, -0.017021968960762024, 0.04020277038216591, -0.10678477585315704, 0.0037052370607852936, 0.021744709461927414, 0.012817277573049068, 0.020000766962766647, -0.04043405130505562, 0.01366515178233385, -0.006007302552461624, -0.039704579859972, -0.00967616867274046, -0.013205545023083687, 0.0013722317526116967, -0.033546093851327896, -0.0209030918776989, -0.00576866464689374, 0.054746150970458984, -0.006617628503590822, 0.03192447870969772, 0.035372715443372726, 0.0014889428857713938, -0.019737491384148598, -0.03347116336226463, -0.02238357998430729, 0.06661158800125122, -0.00105211790651083, -0.06701400876045227, 0.03674924746155739, -0.04941849410533905, -0.021945446729660034, 0.03456158936023712, 0.028901172801852226, 0.03662452846765518, 0.015568891540169716, 0.025170892477035522, 0.043781112879514694, 0.03166995570063591, 0.04123035818338394, -0.014080410823225975, -0.05699475109577179, 0.02575402893126011, -0.005400402937084436, 0.042520854622125626, -0.018559744581580162, -0.031872764229774475, -0.0020272519905120134, -0.04311222583055496, -0.03136592358350754, 0.009170030243694782, -0.011108949780464172, -0.02085205912590027, -0.0019166027195751667, -0.011755620129406452, 0.023301636800169945, -0.016934959217905998, 0.033529702574014664, -0.0591663159430027, -0.006129883695393801, 0.060913026332855225, 0.010170752182602882, -0.029404625296592712, 0.02905610203742981, -0.027791155502200127, -0.037462443113327026, 0.012066413648426533, 0.016355615109205246, -0.002221998991444707, -0.04449789598584175, 0.01835261844098568, -0.027973581105470657, 0.01875396817922592, -0.012443432584404945, 0.00850680097937584, -0.05945354327559471, 0.03509601950645447, -0.011394619941711426, 0.008495279587805271, 0.01713826134800911, -0.01592501997947693, -0.003892905078828335, -0.061879370361566544, 0.08230418711900711, -0.0033303378149867058, -0.027333425357937813, -0.06543648988008499, -0.0000537256637471728, -0.010251091793179512, 0.006154818460345268, 0.02705029584467411, -0.0010601467220112681, -0.012726908549666405, -0.016596294939517975, 0.015475522726774216, 0.013183758594095707, -0.06790217757225037, 0.015634071081876755, -0.005460332613438368, -0.013764670118689537, -0.033959534019231796, -0.014593304134905338, 0.027750525623559952, 0.006546846590936184, 0.03128902614116669, -0.00024730441509746015, 0.04732320457696915, 0.027695391327142715, 0.014281978830695152, 0.0444035679101944, 0.016277335584163666, -0.023624515160918236, 0.053251419216394424, -0.01571516878902912, 0.010911816731095314, 0.03670091554522514, 0.00342723005451262, -0.043166834861040115, 0.0376347117125988, 0.006342175416648388, -0.02527233026921749, 0.04076249152421951, 0.03952950984239578, -0.014025363139808178, -0.036029499024152756, -0.01810997910797596, 0.02712690457701683, -0.03732365369796753, 0.010253352113068104, 0.006890289019793272, 0.007494943682104349, 0.0361209399998188, -0.03385029733181, 0.0458102747797966, 0.006483414676040411, -0.03313098102807999, 0.013111254200339317, 0.0267033614218235, 0.027652142569422722, -0.00576357776299119, 0.05706199258565903, 0.03656153753399849, -0.01472944300621748, -0.014815544709563255, 0.01816045120358467, 0.02771896682679653, -0.012050719931721687, -0.02294309437274933, 0.0007756960694678128, -0.012943830341100693, 0.004777449648827314, 0.010386639274656773, 0.008551734499633312, 0.06119541823863983, -0.006956929806619883, -0.0045549217611551285, -0.0011579577112570405, -0.02697897143661976, -0.031366489827632904, -0.014824199490249157, -0.012045318260788918, -0.00714870635420084, -0.03509869799017906, 0.00635813781991601, 0.00943792425096035, 0.009500350803136826, 0.03299318999052048, -0.0371321476995945, -0.014440144412219524, -0.034571435302495956, 0.007250675465911627, -0.03305692598223686, 0.005676149856299162, -0.014990159310400486, 0.009514229372143745, -0.008319760672748089, 0.009539064019918442, 0.00910594779998064, 0.0020755003206431866, -0.02657318487763405, 0.008252700790762901, 0.010118626058101654, -0.08345887064933777, 0.013634365983307362, -0.039141904562711716, 0.02031342312693596, -0.00462180282920599, -0.03809376433491707 ]
<p>Assume that I have a variable whose distribution is skewed positively to a very high degree, such that taking the log will not be sufficient in order to bring it within the range of skewness for a normal distribution. What are my options at this point? What can I do to transform the variable to a normal distribution?</p>
74,220
[ -0.02987855300307274, -0.0025851414538919926, 0.006078662350773811, -0.02166145294904709, 0.03993988409638405, 0.009588352404534817, -0.013796620070934296, 0.004585230257362127, 0.016664039343595505, -0.04736899584531784, 0.017513791099190712, 0.013107049278914928, 0.02860613539814949, 0.00932068657130003, 0.07255169004201889, -0.00043724311399273574, -0.024985823780298233, 0.006464717909693718, -0.006827472243458033, 0.003139485139399767, 0.002481479663401842, 0.024678729474544525, 0.02123330719769001, 0.003421991830691695, -0.03371104225516319, 0.04534874111413956, 0.03092929907143116, -0.02159484475851059, 0.0031787874177098274, 0.07169546186923981, -0.03844567760825157, 0.010122903622686863, 0.009963246993720531, 0.06719273328781128, 0.010171381756663322, 0.015448375605046749, -0.024695366621017456, 0.0032601093407720327, -0.034158483147621155, 0.009816776029765606, -0.03818714991211891, 0.004083378706127405, 0.009018565528094769, 0.03617456555366516, 0.0071807424537837505, 0.04323795437812805, -0.036142364144325256, -0.06541534513235092, 0.03813598304986954, -0.0529053770005703, 0.07272548973560333, -0.016508186236023903, 0.05298764258623123, 0.058622583746910095, 0.018195629119873047, -0.021004315465688705, 0.10732276737689972, 0.07344435900449753, -0.030872134491801262, -0.04951169341802597, -0.008057849481701851, -0.023537594825029373, -0.02790111117064953, -0.02544967271387577, -0.00919416919350624, -0.010383299551904202, -0.013690116815268993, -0.01999194733798504, 0.061869580298662186, -0.015982268378138542, 0.005714184604585171, 0.055220067501068115, 0.025387227535247803, -0.026686599478125572, 0.017041584476828575, -0.05061815306544304, 0.01137611549347639, 0.01126630138605833, 0.006605253554880619, 0.016705432906746864, 0.015791838988661766, -0.011699029244482517, 0.011001422069966793, 0.0408579483628273, 0.024221593514084816, -0.020255379378795624, 0.08259064704179764, -0.014488323591649532, 0.03539702668786049, 0.04380984231829643, -0.008947942405939102, -0.029843615368008614, 0.05988676846027374, -0.011004212312400341, -0.027590937912464142, 0.047474026679992676, -0.03548441082239151, 0.05148352310061455, 0.012949253432452679, -0.006094773765653372, -0.007713932078331709, -0.045759156346321106, 0.009492302313446999, 0.037902381271123886, 0.005669902078807354, 0.01637660153210163, -0.00186029018368572, 0.004549253731966019, 0.02004682831466198, -0.0203006099909544, -0.013672555796802044, 0.014121321961283684, 0.014735395088791847, -0.005385864991694689, 0.03122434951364994, -0.008172609843313694, -0.028582898899912834, -0.04251581057906151, 0.04848475754261017, 0.028859054669737816, 0.012517284601926804, -0.012241578660905361, 0.04356057941913605, -0.01312694326043129, -0.045971110463142395, 0.026536688208580017, 0.031667664647102356, 0.007710154168307781, -0.05395499989390373, 0.04738501086831093, 0.013841579668223858, -0.03789672255516052, 0.04231412708759308, 0.004300306551158428, 0.040692199021577835, -0.024541616439819336, -0.07410106062889099, -0.0542447604238987, 0.030641967430710793, -0.03078395687043667, 0.005546712316572666, -0.0713031142950058, -0.022039955481886864, 0.05233021453022957, 0.04627218842506409, -0.011579358950257301, 0.035677578300237656, 0.012842369265854359, 0.01507745310664177, -0.0017019188962876797, 0.005805631633847952, -0.030466582626104355, -0.022082017734646797, -0.014302615076303482, 0.022137274965643883, -0.07756654918193817, -0.005975351668894291, 0.006720153149217367, -0.020790841430425644, -0.017430802807211876, 0.030746696516871452, -0.017942436039447784, -0.006522827781736851, -0.012942266650497913, 0.015333759598433971, -0.03013933263719082, 0.11018254607915878, 0.0067918854765594006, 0.0199198666960001, 0.013849398121237755, 0.000855377409607172, -0.007363036274909973, -0.0025455434806644917, 0.05742523819208145, 0.06358913332223892, -0.043224141001701355, -0.00791449099779129, -0.042190201580524445, 0.06530678272247314, 0.018229519948363304, 0.008681771345436573, 0.02199656330049038, -0.008864208124577999, 0.027181362733244896, -0.011880762875080109, 0.02064366638660431, -0.009288366883993149, 0.004786974284797907, 0.026517145335674286, -0.04694114997982979, -0.021731527522206306, -0.03127438202500343, -0.006345664616674185, 0.022696619853377342, -0.00710715726017952, 0.06720300763845444, 0.02915114164352417, 0.037075817584991455, -0.01971426047384739, -0.01890830136835575, 0.0019852551631629467, 0.005652343854308128, 0.05661024898290634, -0.03689967840909958, 0.004035781137645245, 0.052341677248477936, 0.05792471021413803, -0.021035265177488327, 0.034818392246961594, -0.026571903377771378, -0.022190993651747704, 0.0010435074800625443, -0.021832801401615143, 0.043797194957733154, -0.0035593321081250906, -0.026285672560334206, -0.0006566104129888117, -0.004126711282879114, 0.010635318234562874, -0.002330145565792918, -0.046143438667058945, 0.06656540185213089, 0.06535506993532181, 0.019129900261759758, -0.003670095931738615, 0.002817845204845071, 0.009031164459884167, 0.0011245512869209051, -0.025475604459643364, -0.03007613681256771, -0.04279196634888649, 0.01961282454431057, 0.019537217915058136, 0.022952478379011154, -0.04508692026138306, 0.003009198233485222, 0.035190682858228683, 0.03401575982570648, 0.03738591447472572, 0.03654699772596359, -0.019898155704140663, -0.02361452579498291, -0.0008768373518250883, -0.014075043611228466, 0.027412772178649902, -0.0023712916299700737, 0.007871505804359913, 0.022672085091471672, 0.01494686771184206, -0.007422224618494511, -0.023695366457104683, 0.026632586494088173, 0.0039565167389810085, 0.04066036641597748, -0.0004131678433623165, -0.01844896748661995, 0.03244787082076073, -0.0413135327398777, 0.001647682162001729, 0.07346431165933609, 0.0019671730697155, 0.018890881910920143, 0.0004916245816275477, -0.003854169277474284, 0.02858174964785576, 0.047723449766635895, -0.015385826118290424, -0.009288357570767403, 0.024933405220508575, -0.020494049414992332, -0.018512174487113953, -0.008105503395199776, -0.03585612028837204, -0.005129767116159201, 0.020147157832980156, 0.03679012879729271, 0.020505506545305252, 0.024471376091241837, 0.008701033890247345, -0.034250617027282715, -0.004845592193305492, -0.0031048920936882496, -0.01879257895052433, -0.0026223957538604736, -0.05511578917503357, -0.03782441094517708, 0.01291880663484335, -0.01593867503106594, 0.015015428885817528, 0.0002783405361697078, 0.030873514711856842, -0.0067903511226177216, -0.006974723190069199, -0.04749084264039993, -0.005251993425190449, -0.008984440937638283, -0.013246122747659683, -0.01777791790664196, -0.028591522946953773, 0.05008124187588692, 0.006985682062804699, -0.02454219199717045, 0.0215555839240551, -0.04416168853640556, -0.05996527150273323, -0.043435029685497284, 0.00020104706345591694, 0.012220482341945171, 0.0006045917398296297, 0.0505751371383667, 0.004520381800830364, -0.05347679927945137, -0.002510366030037403, -0.06381098181009293, -0.062015846371650696, 0.026689721271395683, 0.04379289969801903, 0.03397155553102493, -0.010221973061561584, -0.029675763100385666, 0.05617525801062584, 0.040079135447740555, -0.02918698452413082, -0.034453123807907104, -0.004080876242369413, -0.013583739288151264, -0.020574254915118217, 0.007376119960099459, 0.000691594323143363, 0.013811890035867691, 0.07127004861831665, 0.011315901763737202, 0.01834935136139393, 0.02953319624066353, 0.013092642650008202, -0.04523778334259987, 0.030374208465218544, -0.018913595005869865, 0.0176766999065876, -0.0013047566171735525, 0.026967041194438934, -0.008108275942504406, 0.0064492556266486645, 0.02070765569806099, 0.006487053819000721, 0.023350518196821213, -0.04011920094490051, 0.013626973144710064, 0.01057378388941288, 0.009399248287081718, -0.030267272144556046, 0.015169949270784855, -0.00013726401084568352, -0.04081114009022713, 0.009389988146722317, 0.03927036374807358, 0.034677691757678986, -0.008575293235480785, 0.03293886408209801, 0.026062212884426117, 0.0509764589369297, -0.00899143610149622, -0.025479089468717575, -0.0035684003960341215, -0.018476631492376328, 0.02758673019707203, -0.032138895243406296, 0.029292088001966476, 0.02601562812924385, 0.027084853500127792, 0.00860405620187521, -0.009382198564708233, -0.016296759247779846, 0.006248841527849436, -0.05605226755142212, 0.001745161833241582, -0.004545886069536209, 0.009440363384783268, 0.02575104497373104, 0.011300343088805676, 0.04309314861893654, -0.012918451800942421, 0.03971897065639496, 0.01137870829552412, -0.09578072279691696, 0.04627910628914833, -0.030551519244909286, 0.026620332151651382, 0.006159603130072355, -0.0004198374808765948, 0.03738968446850777, -0.04003788158297539, 0.0018097789725288749, -0.0029490056913346052, 0.026235703378915787, -0.015750885009765625, -0.005634106695652008, -0.020239541307091713, -0.040306031703948975, -0.026096099987626076, 0.018440624698996544, -0.01179803628474474, -0.04449319466948509, -0.0044887191615998745, 0.03142975643277168, 0.010707340203225613, -0.007046350743621588, -0.007293047849088907, 0.04041287302970886, 0.003709919285029173, 0.07949129492044449, -0.016202285885810852, 0.014006085693836212, 0.000775946828071028, 0.020333055406808853, -0.010419042780995369, 0.05632443726062775, 0.04518566280603409, -0.0013807180803269148, -0.03453293442726135, -0.0718931332230568, -0.042877860367298126, -0.00908398162573576, 0.014804676175117493, 0.014986861497163773, 0.045943211764097214, 0.06480228900909424, 0.023483050987124443, -0.08855193108320236, 0.01913483440876007, 0.0992620587348938, 0.021090267226099968, -0.03021666593849659, 0.04630938917398453, -0.007458658888936043, -0.018256284296512604, 0.012086243368685246, 0.024154381826519966, -0.01991998590528965, -0.03972061350941658, -0.026854382827878, 0.0461164228618145, 0.012430554255843163, -0.02184467762708664, 0.00006717100040987134, 0.0006867329939268529, 0.046845413744449615, -0.0009235664620064199, -0.02231340855360031, 0.027537336573004723, 0.023435672745108604, 0.020033279433846474, 0.018400030210614204, -0.007375868037343025, -0.06473119556903839, 0.022424615919589996, 0.019950661808252335, 0.02812059596180916, -0.026911284774541855, 0.008090093731880188, -0.051630325615406036, 0.024799112230539322, 0.030666671693325043, -0.0569034144282341, 0.027175061404705048, -0.024912213906645775, 0.01930399425327778, 0.018244538456201553, -0.04607101157307625, -0.06851296126842499, 0.008402425795793533, 0.037843167781829834, -0.003809470683336258, -0.02001284621655941, -0.0019405477214604616, -0.08038493990898132, 0.014764560386538506, 0.019688954576849937, 0.05908665806055069, 0.010716729797422886, -0.03940942510962486, 0.01181605365127325, 0.03541446104645729, -0.0003991764970123768, -0.06310783326625824, 0.0024114458356052637, 0.0067379591055214405, -0.014093533158302307, 0.025039058178663254, 0.022508563473820686, -0.05095716193318367, 0.016515985131263733, -0.013144093565642834, -0.02391146868467331, 0.016009660437703133, 0.003916997462511063, 0.02947959490120411, 0.023116538301110268, 0.01887727528810501, 0.03900827839970589, 0.0369110070168972, -0.005406807642430067, -0.021150605753064156, -0.04914351925253868, -0.005888278596103191, -0.04602822661399841, -0.0102262943983078, -0.04867897555232048, -0.000335887772962451, 0.004598546307533979, 0.03202522546052933, -0.007692724000662565, 0.027590161189436913, 0.015327341854572296, 0.0027784397825598717, 0.0051955305971205235, 0.02296200767159462, 0.006396990269422531, -0.025426242500543594, 0.01523569691926241, 0.011872203089296818, -0.029021382331848145, -0.022191140800714493, 0.023005351424217224, -0.015333917923271656, 0.028059059754014015, 0.01074246782809496, -0.05000893399119377, -0.02615908719599247, -0.0233590267598629, -0.027554232627153397, 0.0016576427733525634, -0.03437668830156326, 0.04279204457998276, 0.0053778295405209064, 0.023948507383465767, 0.04264253377914429, -0.04942716285586357, 0.023984814062714577, 0.02331213653087616, 0.0030970938969403505, 0.030715452507138252, -0.03974287211894989, 0.029967574402689934, -0.018407078459858894, 0.005930548068135977, -0.045381080359220505, -0.03771674260497093, 0.02358371578156948, -0.0069466279819607735, -0.0011285978835076094, -0.05550232157111168, -0.03700266405940056, 0.0005643407930620015, -0.0159522145986557, -0.029383191838860512, 0.03387746214866638, 0.005685292184352875, -0.030041877180337906, -0.027972977608442307, 0.02179632894694805, 0.11257300525903702, -0.03554185852408409, 0.007519219536334276, 0.04025304317474365, 0.0030326538253575563, -0.01952497661113739, 0.0006788688478991389, 0.04600642994046211, -0.016830971464514732, -0.01424122042953968, -0.0013285755412653089, -0.012292582541704178, 0.010228713974356651, -0.03113376535475254, -0.001904633711092174, 0.005768067203462124, 0.017504408955574036, 0.004470304120332003, 0.011250536888837814, 0.006098319310694933, 0.002635256154462695, 0.022586029022932053, -0.010066919028759003, -0.021623753011226654, -0.04753631725907326, 0.007983183488249779, 0.05477462336421013, 0.03434256464242935, 0.03868386521935463, 0.03478962182998657, 0.0709015280008316, 0.013430300168693066, 0.004114056937396526, -0.006101228296756744, -0.015373957343399525, 0.014993083663284779, 0.010417883284389973, -0.010711993090808392, 0.01069581601768732, -0.0009265754488296807, -0.03777995705604553, -0.04761848598718643, -0.0411783903837204, -0.029467178508639336, 0.05662716180086136, -0.02199808694422245, 0.05903073027729988, 0.027119813486933708, 0.026271864771842957, -0.0474867969751358, -0.009874984622001648, -0.019695056602358818, -0.015429191291332245, 0.017795570194721222, 0.048292241990566254, 0.019186418503522873, 0.04876847565174103, -0.030455095693469048, 0.001728084054775536, 0.0005638196598738432, 0.05709903687238693, -0.015646617859601974, 0.02720598317682743, 0.05232136696577072, -0.031405508518218994, -0.029423462226986885, 0.030832301825284958, -0.05551336333155632, 0.05248972028493881, -0.016584401950240135, -0.013566489331424236, 0.04291760176420212, -0.005135766696184874, -0.004247673321515322, -0.03418796509504318, -0.03821471333503723, -0.05009135976433754, -0.016521669924259186, 0.013276170007884502, -0.025649847462773323, 0.036887433379888535, 0.016836663708090782, 0.029705515131354332, 0.0017944033024832606, 0.021781329065561295, -0.05586250126361847, -0.06801673769950867, -0.009615765884518623, -0.033714659512043, -0.043581489473581314, 0.033269401639699936, 0.00009590352419763803, 0.01506003737449646, 0.020013125613331795, -0.024519523605704308, -0.010105389170348644, 0.014132427982985973, 0.01672259159386158, -0.009174712002277374, 0.07377716153860092, 0.009355280548334122, -0.02963107079267502, -0.015245220623910427, -0.00546819856390357, 0.09625078737735748, 0.11359547823667526, 0.018578918650746346, -0.09228408336639404, 0.001519479206763208, -0.06253974139690399, 0.010885516181588173, -0.031000465154647827, 0.01780669018626213, -0.028617842122912407, -0.009487473405897617, 0.03303796425461769, 0.038761936128139496, -0.010829252190887928, 0.01983284018933773, 0.06926287710666656, -0.045597877353429794, -0.013734052889049053, -0.010404477827250957, 0.0066356840543448925, -0.023640839383006096, -0.007723710499703884, -0.05117381736636162, 0.021492980420589447, -0.029903490096330643, -0.026285763829946518, -0.018777914345264435, -0.0023575767409056425, -0.015583377331495285, -0.033239614218473434, -0.04258912056684494, 0.009062345139682293, 0.04293035715818405, -0.006816196255385876, 0.004095846321433783, -0.0006427451153285801, 0.030285276472568512, -0.03511723130941391, 0.01646973378956318, 0.003097583306953311, -0.008765045553445816, 0.03121102601289749, 0.037055324763059616, -0.003745622467249632, -0.015725940465927124, -0.045934613794088364, -0.013681587763130665, 0.034468770027160645, -0.010042008943855762, -0.0026350701227784157, -0.019713521003723145, -0.01658293418586254, -0.020670322701334953, -0.022948002442717552, -0.006647326517850161, 0.015397703275084496, 0.01673683524131775, -0.02286258339881897, -0.035437408834695816, 0.015706300735473633, 0.020047137513756752, 0.025559261441230774, 0.06585021317005157, 0.02843310311436653, -0.006587166804820299, 0.009777362458407879, -0.031732942909002304, 0.06909356266260147, -0.01628652773797512, -0.02743186056613922, -0.03081336058676243, 0.004652160219848156, -0.00019417163275647908, -0.006550081539899111, 0.0199233777821064, -0.020717479288578033, 0.012497001327574253, 0.0048040542751550674, 0.013700907118618488, -0.04738873615860939, -0.04080439731478691, 0.02707776427268982, -0.039805974811315536, 0.006380781065672636, -0.05381465703248978, -0.03459533676505089, 0.010356681421399117, 0.07343695312738419, 0.038918863981962204, -0.004584358073771, -0.01769273541867733, 0.051633380353450775, 0.02529403567314148, -0.0398172028362751, -0.018962278962135315, 0.02463892288506031, -0.042662374675273895, 0.0005018332158215344, 0.0023731065448373556, 0.07247260957956314, 0.03025364689528942, 0.0071836779825389385, -0.059885408729314804, 0.01362342108041048, -0.02188829518854618, -0.0038963081315159798, 0.016975412145256996, -0.0404328778386116, 0.015838703140616417, 0.0049329777248203754, 0.01231260783970356, -0.0388503298163414, -0.005635494831949472, -0.013742906041443348, -0.016095463186502457, 0.018881333991885185, 0.006669340655207634, -0.02059405855834484, 0.004167115781456232, -0.030615415424108505, 0.030335087329149246, -0.022293735295534134, 0.027252620086073875, 0.0027693076990544796, 0.019011884927749634, 0.0014731396222487092, -0.01404095720499754, -0.003907170612365007, 0.010840658098459244, 0.023813897743821144, -0.015094011090695858, 0.033963996917009354, 0.013247215189039707, 0.02361324429512024, -0.02350728213787079, -0.010388379916548729, -0.025993820279836655, 0.044559553265571594, -0.04878240451216698, -0.004692497197538614, 0.05602298676967621, -0.04216567799448967, -0.008842102251946926, 0.03219263628125191, -0.0014686170034110546, 0.0191310103982687, 0.005594376940280199, 0.0020960604306310415, -0.027797719463706017, 0.042162150144577026, 0.006735607516020536, -0.002965382067486644, 0.005326210521161556, -0.0038073535542935133, -0.01948114112019539, 0.017509473487734795, 0.004902313929051161, -0.0006315840291790664, -0.019622240215539932, 0.038447629660367966, 0.03225379064679146, -0.0017608258640393615, 0.012979866936802864, 0.03801549971103668, 0.027216712012887, 0.031116724014282227, 0.00495794927701354, -0.005325029604136944, 0.025087840855121613, 0.03139685094356537, -0.04375381022691727, 0.009084290824830532, -0.016290396451950073, -0.003906451631337404, -0.07513122260570526, 0.00042599652078934014, 0.06079031899571419, -0.02936241403222084, 0.0413176454603672, -0.08291164040565491, -0.03523589298129082, 0.01579524576663971, -0.041468486189842224, -0.011363109573721886, -0.019338030368089676, -0.031002024188637733, -0.03496425971388817, -0.015395797789096832, -0.022013111039996147, 0.02935764566063881, 0.012630261480808258, 0.040288571268320084, 0.02547270618379116, 0.007912987843155861, 0.0014980832347646356, -0.006862620823085308, 0.007661645766347647, 0.010782699100673199, 0.012274985201656818, -0.05924229696393013, 0.05134766176342964, -0.07611411064863205, -0.00911922287195921, 0.03865125775337219, -0.03781898692250252, 0.018297920003533363, -0.0009960694005712867, 0.001965186558663845, -0.006456025876104832, 0.06458008289337158, 0.033366505056619644, 0.009104588069021702, -0.010712605901062489, -0.0017009263392537832, 0.04005766659975052, 0.028908271342515945, -0.02659207209944725, -0.021035118028521538, 0.013923929072916508, -0.053150810301303864, -0.033827271312475204, 0.01009929645806551, -0.0021560401655733585, -0.0036755588371306658, -0.00508888578042388, 0.016765108332037926, 0.002509575802832842, -0.02198055386543274, 0.022903895005583763, -0.06432374566793442, -0.01788894087076187, 0.06324180215597153, 0.009757071733474731, -0.019719412550330162, 0.00690621929243207, -0.043660376220941544, -0.07336210459470749, 0.01035463809967041, -0.005535621661692858, -0.024818003177642822, -0.06199110299348831, -0.00019940627680625767, -0.019539328292012215, -0.033177223056554794, -0.00424782931804657, -0.008215325884521008, -0.033531103283166885, 0.06025436893105507, -0.034197404980659485, 0.05397152900695801, 0.009349164552986622, -0.02365080639719963, -0.00954659003764391, -0.059050511568784714, 0.05066681280732155, -0.005303363315761089, -0.008899549022316933, -0.032926030457019806, -0.0038016480393707752, -0.04291924461722374, -0.01766459085047245, 0.032559290528297424, -0.0020950722973793745, -0.01912623457610607, -0.03017551265656948, 0.02372426725924015, -0.01985313557088375, -0.051956526935100555, -0.009798607788980007, -0.02017347142100334, -0.029338940978050232, -0.033480316400527954, -0.017636023461818695, -0.004693762864917517, 0.0012204826343804598, -0.013682511635124683, -0.0303015299141407, -0.011199058033525944, 0.008594983257353306, -0.010318494401872158, 0.03157896548509598, -0.023608773946762085, -0.03868965432047844, 0.03398128226399422, -0.02536877989768982, -0.01794801652431488, 0.014203179627656937, 0.04221498221158981, -0.06517455726861954, 0.00941471103578806, -0.0248004961758852, -0.033458925783634186, -0.03010770119726658, 0.04029875248670578, 0.02135869860649109, -0.040901463478803635, 0.04203888028860092, 0.04267754405736923, -0.0485028512775898, -0.003201510291546583, 0.010200634598731995, -0.014698786661028862, 0.015250452794134617, 0.004480078816413879, -0.01881442219018936, 0.021940695121884346, -0.007969643920660019, -0.005010831169784069, 0.00700106518343091, 0.0022411339450627565, -0.0381525382399559, -0.0005472712800838053, 0.0022507517132908106, -0.009866409003734589, 0.05887899175286293, 0.013405336067080498, 0.051372602581977844, -0.04365880787372589, -0.0015568309463560581, -0.0020382599905133247, -0.010076630860567093, 0.046480052173137665, -0.01639287918806076, -0.014913944527506828, 0.008510436862707138, 0.009834128431975842, 0.00377934193238616, -0.03364593908190727, -0.042305540293455124, -0.02241729199886322, 0.0006072435644455254, -0.00578140327706933, 0.014078703708946705, -0.010069183073937893, 0.023019300773739815, 0.0064511350356042385, -0.004236135166138411, 0.008963147178292274, -0.03659888356924057, 0.02210928313434124, -0.004339494742453098, 0.017660902813076973, 0.006302366033196449, -0.02893398515880108, -0.019979843869805336, -0.0053629446774721146, -0.01561038475483656, 0.048128701746463776, 0.017147956416010857, -0.0041905660182237625, -0.001512219780124724, -0.05437687411904335, 0.05139349028468132, -0.056441083550453186, 0.022768599912524223, -0.039747778326272964, -0.014746095985174179, -0.0031800756696611643, -0.04046490415930748 ]
<p>I observe draws of some random variable $Y$ over time where $Y_{t} = aY_{t-1} + \epsilon_{t}$.</p> <p>$\epsilon \sim N(0, 1/\rho_\epsilon)$ and $a$ is an unknown parameter with prior distribution $a \sim N(\mu_0, \Sigma_0)$.</p> <p>Since both the noise and the prior are normal, after we observe $Y_t$, the posterior of $a$ is also normal and follows an updating process: $$ \mu_t = (\mu_{t-1}+\Sigma_{t-1}\rho_{\epsilon} Y_{t-1}Y_t)/(1+\Sigma_{t-1}\rho_{\epsilon}Y_{t-1}^2)\\ \Sigma_t = \Sigma_{t-1}/(1+\Sigma_{t-1}\rho_{\epsilon}Y_{t-1}^2) $$</p> <p>Moving two periods into the future, it's easy to see that: $$ Y_{t+2}= a(\underbrace{a Y_t + \epsilon_{t+1}}_{Y_{t+1}}) + \epsilon_{t+2} $$</p> <p>Given that I'm at time $t$, I'm looking to evaluate the variance of $Y_{t+2}$.</p> <p>Since $\epsilon_{t+1}$ and $\epsilon_{t+2}$ affect future draws of $Y$, they're independent of our current beliefs on the distribution of $a$. The variance is then: $$ var(Y_{t+2}) = var(b Y_{t+1}) + 1/\rho_{\epsilon} $$</p> <p>Is there a way to calculate the first variance term conditional on being at time $t$? I suppose I could take the covariance of $b$ and $T_{t+1}$ to obtain the joint distribution and then, if I wanted to solve this numerically, do the integration for the variance.</p>
74,221
[ 0.00722840428352356, -0.033604878932237625, 0.02737462893128395, -0.031200150027871132, 0.04985751956701279, -0.009611230343580246, 0.024218223989009857, -0.014174383133649826, 0.016547685489058495, -0.04168067127466202, 0.02571832947432995, 0.03022979386150837, 0.061643537133932114, 0.021959468722343445, 0.0188711229711771, 0.035303931683301926, -0.03682535141706467, -0.007175649981945753, -0.029928185045719147, -0.013456376269459724, -0.022749653086066246, 0.024580342695116997, 0.040988463908433914, -0.011921069584786892, -0.048793017864227295, 0.03692462667822838, 0.0378565676510334, -0.010803693905472755, -0.029522154480218887, 0.06716319173574448, -0.0345352478325367, -0.04524476081132889, 0.0013076049508526921, 0.036065589636564255, 0.020820466801524162, 0.005058444105088711, -0.004634658340364695, -0.04492497444152832, 0.004263436421751976, 0.025261107832193375, -0.06607116013765335, 0.020889591425657272, -0.03224562481045723, 0.04536200314760208, -0.02418217621743679, -0.015662899240851402, -0.017484741285443306, -0.007453120779246092, 0.026929307729005814, -0.025708703324198723, 0.08006162941455841, -0.048293329775333405, 0.020793110132217407, 0.03832419961690903, -0.021758675575256348, -0.02689495123922825, 0.02997991256415844, 0.0669054463505745, -0.012283368036150932, -0.047471560537815094, -0.017117472365498543, 0.0007538596400991082, 0.0016512031434103847, -0.016511082649230957, -0.01436108909547329, -0.034784577786922455, -0.010549032129347324, -0.009258241392672062, 0.019013885408639908, -0.06869874894618988, 0.03877952694892883, -0.01960175298154354, 0.01042665634304285, 0.00020028861763421446, 0.01731087639927864, 0.003929628990590572, -0.009998764842748642, 0.020460015162825584, 0.023762188851833344, 0.044648297131061554, -0.007903520949184895, 0.005112046375870705, 0.0507533997297287, 0.0332830548286438, 0.04800363630056381, 0.013374817557632923, 0.05553857609629631, -0.02321164682507515, 0.0315861813724041, 0.0033030197955667973, -0.004901845473796129, 0.0014742888743057847, 0.04155445098876953, -0.04643555358052254, -0.060777951031923294, 0.061696551740169525, -0.024809429422020912, -0.011851613409817219, 0.0069609698839485645, -0.013080392964184284, -0.030497394502162933, -0.07884956151247025, 0.014573642052710056, 0.09097035974264145, -0.0034689074382185936, -0.03992750495672226, 0.03773551061749458, -0.034159641712903976, -0.011640229262411594, -0.03316951170563698, -0.04578220471739769, 0.015230382792651653, -0.010538733564317226, -0.004404616076499224, 0.018390893936157227, 0.010527145117521286, 0.005698876921087503, 0.004571589641273022, 0.014117403887212276, 0.061692509800195694, 0.03954097628593445, 0.0022015010472387075, -0.019242949783802032, 0.0005069171311333776, -0.04077568277716637, -0.0015762794064357877, 0.03618084266781807, -0.04293772950768471, -0.05146064981818199, 0.06613036245107651, 0.007052436005324125, -0.016263818368315697, 0.04341904819011688, -0.004056017380207777, 0.029392657801508904, 0.027116261422634125, -0.08712327480316162, -0.03832506388425827, 0.04508696123957634, -0.030005021020770073, 0.027931436896324158, -0.06684011965990067, 0.0052940137684345245, 0.04508395865559578, 0.0411706380546093, -0.00487032113596797, 0.039139870554208755, 0.005667787045240402, 0.024288587272167206, 0.0176126379519701, -0.04744737595319748, 0.0016813615802675486, 0.010697712190449238, -0.01405415590852499, -0.026130549609661102, -0.06088251248002052, 0.006843183189630508, 0.003260561730712652, -0.0027017141692340374, -0.011107491329312325, 0.0638980120420456, 0.02788870967924595, -0.006237339694052935, -0.01094355620443821, -0.013777758926153183, -0.06074996665120125, 0.08436225354671478, 0.04238290339708328, 0.005249990615993738, -0.004072966985404491, 0.04240505024790764, 0.012135932222008705, 0.00871998444199562, 0.03554254770278931, 0.05233896151185036, -0.04943764582276344, -0.018620766699314117, 0.02482522465288639, -0.03926150128245354, 0.033577173948287964, -0.04381215572357178, -0.0013858291786164045, -0.07229983061552048, -0.009039415046572685, 0.024567462503910065, 0.00995732843875885, 0.0013542394153773785, 0.02682347595691681, -0.011077214032411575, -0.07914984971284866, 0.00027237043832428753, -0.09435966610908508, -0.03045949898660183, -0.011355075985193253, -0.008372457697987556, 0.006681246217340231, -0.018913786858320236, 0.02780541405081749, 0.0036554252728819847, -0.03188159689307213, -0.019094789400696754, 0.016173003241419792, 0.03726467490196228, -0.03931033983826637, 0.016485873609781265, 0.024902814999222755, 0.058619916439056396, 0.027638716623187065, 0.0388471856713295, -0.02192351035773754, -0.023513199761509895, -0.017268331721425056, -0.06048044562339783, 0.0437169186770916, 0.02314102090895176, -0.029091734439134598, 0.02229156531393528, -0.03468045964837074, -0.010866138152778149, 0.006544151809066534, -0.06663042306900024, 0.01640549674630165, 0.08197695761919022, -0.005581953097134829, -0.03038516826927662, 0.018385179340839386, 0.011303605511784554, 0.02350189909338951, -0.020540790632367134, -0.02178981713950634, 0.0005218320293352008, -0.018002348020672798, 0.01778586208820343, 0.05746157467365265, 0.011455405503511429, 0.015072491019964218, 0.032886479049921036, -0.028080755844712257, 0.0005581953446380794, 0.06251007318496704, 0.003315721172839403, -0.014414195902645588, 0.024072524160146713, -0.029031071811914444, 0.008853339590132236, 0.006254248321056366, 0.026151031255722046, -0.0035030993167310953, 0.02469935640692711, 0.004439421929419041, -0.015857305377721786, 0.025725996121764183, 0.0008168364875018597, 0.007296806667000055, -0.001937121502123773, -0.04016885906457901, 0.03734045848250389, 0.00618996424600482, 0.02215779386460781, 0.018654506653547287, 0.008944697678089142, -0.02086244337260723, -0.008573869243264198, -0.020254498347640038, 0.019080255180597305, 0.04374287277460098, -0.013599744997918606, -0.00645042909309268, 0.02456745132803917, 0.00028183977701701224, 0.015784986317157745, -0.01556206215173006, -0.011459204368293285, 0.0020949754398316145, -0.03618621081113815, 0.026081232354044914, 0.017328612506389618, -0.01264625322073698, -0.03964148834347725, -0.0031772865913808346, -0.009022902697324753, 0.0464983806014061, 0.05876753479242325, 0.001981785986572504, -0.05835673213005066, -0.017218701541423798, 0.030019273981451988, -0.0013567140558734536, 0.04837442561984062, 0.021687258034944534, -0.012272557243704796, 0.05105544999241829, -0.0019902428612113, -0.04751355201005936, -0.04848221689462662, 0.006858102511614561, -0.015212099067866802, -0.023534581065177917, -0.02256331965327263, 0.052436280995607376, 0.03323322907090187, -0.03336266428232193, 0.03403424471616745, -0.036702241748571396, -0.02558279223740101, -0.024377325549721718, -0.018912626430392265, -0.0038040701765567064, 0.00571992713958025, 0.04857705906033516, 0.01034091878682375, -0.007862704806029797, -0.012158420868217945, -0.06145507097244263, -0.09164593368768692, 0.03354761004447937, 0.010387945920228958, 0.04458342865109444, -0.00038701604353263974, -0.03642159700393677, 0.07688409835100174, 0.03373138606548309, 0.0009962070034816861, 0.005602076184004545, 0.01056616846472025, 0.001998263644054532, -0.038942523300647736, 0.015827760100364685, -0.0016393385594710708, -0.027108702808618546, 0.006364679429680109, -0.0008007509168237448, 0.0471828356385231, 0.055264201015233994, 0.00044896715553477407, 0.0027706141117960215, -0.012895661406219006, -0.003719982923939824, 0.02808002568781376, 0.020669953897595406, -0.013078290037810802, 0.004489799030125141, -0.014884275384247303, -0.011355698108673096, 0.03227991983294487, 0.029372159391641617, -0.040643248707056046, 0.0459536649286747, -0.02450409159064293, -0.016609683632850647, -0.06843290477991104, 0.07733796536922455, -0.00022316226386465132, -0.0194877739995718, -0.05819540470838547, -0.011474965140223503, 0.02865252085030079, 0.025064505636692047, 0.025345955044031143, 0.05820360407233238, 0.0449189767241478, 0.008432001806795597, -0.035709504038095474, -0.003976482432335615, -0.010708639398217201, 0.027453243732452393, -0.06079910695552826, 0.006250238046050072, -0.00032285202178172767, 0.01795204170048237, -0.008041399531066418, -0.012584209442138672, 0.01570119708776474, -0.0369919091463089, -0.04106609523296356, 0.005179830826818943, -0.014645409770309925, 0.041452616453170776, -0.014797461219131947, 0.014722863212227821, -0.022305795922875404, -0.004484610166400671, 0.02986452914774418, -0.02058720961213112, -0.06359152495861053, 0.014880827628076077, -0.005258636549115181, -0.024256844073534012, -0.02946871519088745, 0.028107894584536552, 0.0590926893055439, -0.025964057072997093, 0.022503796964883804, -0.0005936420639045537, 0.022412000223994255, -0.03458411619067192, -0.015371594578027725, -0.06547768414020538, -0.0239122174680233, -0.011727647855877876, 0.014280394650995731, 0.023740660399198532, -0.02983027510344982, 0.054242078214883804, 0.018407603725790977, 0.021964361891150475, -0.0168444886803627, -0.022586233913898468, 0.006158013828098774, 0.0020852815359830856, 0.019959352910518646, 0.03366662934422493, 0.02343328297138214, -0.0022377329878509045, 0.032116156071424484, 0.02441481128334999, 0.03499971330165863, 0.021564919501543045, 0.02448088675737381, -0.02712499164044857, -0.026359807699918747, -0.01728799380362034, 0.035063035786151886, -0.0037558397743850946, 0.021844984963536263, -0.0034304424189031124, 0.04864877834916115, -0.027936816215515137, -0.03748895227909088, 0.01795939728617668, 0.025250181555747986, -0.021408241242170334, 0.02206542156636715, -0.029297299683094025, 0.022898009046912193, 0.016956523060798645, 0.016449011862277985, -0.01389989722520113, 0.002826233161613345, -0.037670981138944626, 0.0002977027324959636, 0.03681398928165436, 0.011204318143427372, 0.013401011005043983, 0.018649300560355186, 0.04258868098258972, 0.04119470715522766, 0.08378211408853531, -0.007662044372409582, 0.02067902311682701, 0.0321904793381691, 0.009107171557843685, 0.017845580354332924, 0.015917688608169556, -0.07616697251796722, -0.021344605833292007, 0.022292152047157288, 0.023367203772068024, -0.028485925868153572, -0.013974401168525219, -0.037772294133901596, -0.013547406531870365, 0.04940608888864517, 0.016239263117313385, 0.050913795828819275, 0.00010326535993954167, -0.00003209849091945216, 0.015332059934735298, -0.062350593507289886, -0.07514458894729614, 0.0156097412109375, 0.0018244788516312838, 0.008962140418589115, -0.026412084698677063, 0.00009791890624910593, -0.017554746940732002, -0.026112087070941925, 0.008709506131708622, 0.07441450655460358, -0.039568718522787094, -0.012453085742890835, -0.02121461182832718, 0.01794007048010826, -0.00031018859590403736, -0.05697253718972206, 0.023851873353123665, 0.02404864691197872, -0.03180241212248802, 0.04940924048423767, -0.02260192483663559, -0.029983356595039368, 0.041926708072423935, 0.011075266636908054, -0.02364257164299488, -0.015894103795289993, -0.006673361174762249, 0.06802289187908173, 0.02880418673157692, 0.025394847616553307, 0.06617836654186249, 0.04220815747976303, 0.03985675796866417, 0.040025949478149414, 0.0004047701368108392, 0.004176928661763668, -0.0032904110848903656, 0.023055626079440117, -0.04665672406554222, -0.027893027290701866, -0.01446591503918171, 0.05009979382157326, 0.0008430122979916632, 0.019998524338006973, 0.008882165886461735, -0.01870609074831009, 0.016110187396407127, 0.058719001710414886, 0.00679287314414978, -0.01529644150286913, 0.023906894028186798, 0.00705689424648881, -0.006410599686205387, 0.026642868295311928, 0.01009258721023798, -0.03204134479165077, 0.008185231126844883, 0.03933278098702431, -0.04355286434292793, -0.004109364002943039, -0.021268781274557114, -0.0009565176442265511, 0.004071458708494902, 0.01386230904608965, 0.03593946993350983, -0.001242136931978166, 0.03239820897579193, 0.01844383217394352, -0.04004599153995514, -0.008577428758144379, 0.01529918983578682, -0.016275174915790558, -0.013782897964119911, -0.02293475531041622, 0.0030048342887312174, 0.04068128764629364, 0.0034317062236368656, -0.08808784931898117, 0.02147335559129715, 0.016705946996808052, -0.024290019646286964, -0.011214286088943481, -0.03557907044887543, 0.009943869896233082, -0.015445026569068432, -0.05681206285953522, 0.0004551866149995476, 0.011874227784574032, 0.010821804404258728, -0.014101454988121986, 0.001046885154210031, 0.03404850885272026, 0.09578350186347961, 0.005548580549657345, 0.02334095723927021, 0.02807663567364216, -0.03574042022228241, -0.026962043717503548, 0.020710092037916183, 0.03319486975669861, -0.022015651687979698, 0.03958377242088318, 0.028552675619721413, -0.02119133621454239, 0.03933645412325859, -0.05485115200281143, -0.05111564323306084, 0.03750159591436386, 0.004056168720126152, 0.012618456035852432, -0.03405150771141052, -0.03646839037537575, -0.022502858191728592, 0.03319596126675606, -0.03075523115694523, 0.0022934002336114645, 0.0018894379027187824, 0.013789976947009563, 0.0016579495277255774, 0.024961810559034348, -0.029913797974586487, -0.0036086896434426308, 0.02088676206767559, -0.017534920945763588, -0.04424190893769264, 0.001543384394608438, 0.006609336938709021, 0.04991348832845688, 0.014697018079459667, 0.013921543024480343, 0.00907739344984293, -0.01808876171708107, -0.0637311041355133, -0.018751079216599464, -0.023247130215168, -0.010280527174472809, 0.06441373378038406, -0.02770273946225643, 0.0659879744052887, 0.01840033195912838, 0.016935139894485474, -0.025310900062322617, -0.048467524349689484, 0.010459457524120808, -0.0206625834107399, -0.032726772129535675, -0.00627244682982564, -0.05061173811554909, -0.017115319147706032, 0.018701406195759773, 0.00668226508423686, 0.02053295262157917, 0.03348131477832794, -0.007111921440809965, 0.01310764066874981, 0.07263253629207611, -0.054754406213760376, -0.02394026145339012, 0.024492310360074043, -0.03956121206283569, 0.022456873208284378, -0.06895013153553009, -0.04352733865380287, 0.05080246925354004, 0.038871537894010544, -0.021498670801520348, -0.022681504487991333, -0.028820276260375977, -0.06554127484560013, -0.0237235389649868, 0.026698017492890358, -0.021316012367606163, 0.051731839776039124, -0.016371292993426323, 0.04604912921786308, -0.0522724948823452, 0.05052570626139641, -0.04186372458934784, -0.055802710354328156, -0.006417258642613888, 0.004968350287526846, -0.011938940733671188, 0.028263196349143982, -0.010550153441727161, -0.0204189233481884, -0.005678120069205761, -0.013821660540997982, 0.0022626963909715414, 0.03766384348273277, 0.024855703115463257, -0.05376352369785309, 0.11235947161912918, -0.026208659633994102, 0.030340801924467087, -0.0485743023455143, 0.026956064626574516, 0.11619672179222107, 0.05488867312669754, 0.011034292168915272, -0.04630265012383461, 0.005841628648340702, 0.012273111380636692, 0.026270797476172447, -0.04763730242848396, 0.03987913951277733, 0.03931247442960739, -0.013197732158005238, 0.026594800874590874, 0.020998269319534302, -0.0030650885310024023, -0.03684678301215172, 0.016112037003040314, -0.016469519585371017, -0.005879771430045366, 0.0021263679955154657, -0.011033978313207626, -0.0013769930228590965, 0.031163755804300308, -0.02981126308441162, 0.006428696680814028, -0.0015873514348641038, -0.020613383501768112, 0.004747023805975914, -0.0005647473153658211, -0.054791342467069626, -0.022705011069774628, -0.05496846139431, 0.016911789774894714, 0.022716794162988663, 0.012605578638613224, 0.017851121723651886, 0.003896521870046854, 0.027088651433587074, -0.03984954580664635, 0.03190040960907936, 0.024556206539273262, -0.0011590627254918218, 0.009429034776985645, 0.01088788639754057, 0.024712365120649338, -0.002623269334435463, -0.02464251220226288, -0.029921304434537888, 0.03360378369688988, -0.020357763394713402, -0.006955208256840706, -0.019975969567894936, -0.01843961514532566, 0.0064091756939888, -0.02228662744164467, -0.004658982623368502, 0.029907435178756714, 0.004799267277121544, -0.03277996554970741, 0.015527766197919846, -0.012162265367805958, -0.006350052077323198, 0.012930416502058506, 0.02643602341413498, 0.02548358216881752, -0.05363481119275093, -0.03018176555633545, -0.03136987239122391, 0.046717118471860886, 0.022452926263213158, 0.0011095802765339613, 0.013479353860020638, 0.007729669567197561, -0.02075580507516861, -0.007335336413234472, -0.02607337012887001, -0.02835129201412201, 0.017530009150505066, -0.013673646375536919, 0.011231907643377781, 0.007116773631423712, -0.0441642664372921, 0.007641776464879513, -0.03884872421622276, 0.00847200769931078, -0.027077939361333847, -0.01152887661010027, 0.02798135206103325, 0.019664186984300613, 0.0040975576266646385, -0.0256769098341465, -0.009400513954460621, 0.08915037661790848, 0.036317989230155945, -0.06092411279678345, -0.04900991544127464, 0.01415411476045847, -0.018206963315606117, -0.005287157371640205, -0.009949719533324242, 0.05054999515414238, 0.02487253211438656, 0.039316028356552124, -0.01193375326693058, 0.008358525112271309, -0.02238495834171772, 0.016322409734129906, 0.025148335844278336, -0.04651418328285217, 0.017879623919725418, 0.015557260252535343, 0.018973980098962784, -0.008371970616281033, 0.007313405629247427, 0.010038184002041817, -0.019158529117703438, -0.011137086898088455, -0.03173451870679855, -0.018528824672102928, 0.008106009103357792, 0.006259797606617212, -0.007154389284551144, -0.01568075828254223, 0.05913519486784935, 0.004937522113323212, -0.01924024149775505, -0.021901534870266914, 0.028258198872208595, 0.004027271643280983, 0.037698615342378616, -0.018510527908802032, -0.025429224595427513, 0.032879967242479324, 0.011068897321820259, 0.03502003848552704, -0.019504843279719353, 0.03262496739625931, 0.0020146395545452833, 0.015753943473100662, -0.017800448462367058, -0.05153323709964752, 0.02709585428237915, -0.02401094138622284, -0.0003456336271483451, 0.01727343536913395, 0.0433952659368515, 0.045031752437353134, 0.014433865435421467, -0.010253721848130226, -0.015619897283613682, 0.01951703242957592, -0.03181493654847145, -0.0004900845815427601, -0.020840657874941826, 0.0016228191088885069, 0.014850174076855183, -0.04255500063300133, 0.04209544137120247, 0.021669385954737663, 0.029930636286735535, 0.0127364257350564, 0.0065038176253438, -0.023414017632603645, -0.03523571789264679, 0.013887149281799793, -0.03424890339374542, -0.037563152611255646, -0.03510412573814392, -0.02794589288532734, 0.02594941109418869, 0.02480378746986389, -0.03535188362002373, 0.007938629016280174, -0.02384236641228199, -0.021642351523041725, -0.07235199213027954, -0.007495925761759281, 0.033559564501047134, 0.028698094189167023, 0.05778954550623894, -0.028188105672597885, 0.022519579157233238, 0.03121514804661274, -0.026432786136865616, 0.014670828357338905, 0.01955726556479931, 0.0025418123695999384, -0.014881214126944542, 0.006702997721731663, -0.047792430967092514, 0.012101085856556892, 0.023956740275025368, 0.01386939361691475, 0.007232336327433586, 0.02653113380074501, -0.00881113950163126, -0.07044144719839096, 0.01410739216953516, 0.006214146502315998, 0.028219936415553093, -0.035430628806352615, 0.03324473276734352, -0.048275843262672424, 0.012901854701340199, 0.03618933632969856, -0.0010445527732372284, 0.011553002521395683, -0.022899264469742775, 0.04803959280252457, 0.011753193102777004, 0.008687805384397507, -0.003295681905001402, 0.01728513278067112, 0.027993321418762207, 0.004160752519965172, 0.03924146667122841, 0.0016238350654020905, 0.006188031751662493, -0.009993517771363258, -0.014960397966206074, -0.009473518468439579, -0.019525106996297836, -0.01627783291041851, -0.038716964423656464, -0.017114726826548576, 0.02855626493692398, -0.013904890045523643, -0.012928273528814316, -0.009731871075928211, 0.007610911503434181, -0.002904406748712063, -0.0046239569783210754, 0.08041372895240784, 0.01687972992658615, -0.051162246614694595, -0.013890400528907776, -0.0038172879721969366, -0.038747601211071014, 0.07756010442972183, 0.02377965860068798, -0.004496785346418619, -0.07055771350860596, -0.019189929589629173, -0.00530662527307868, -0.0010256076930090785, -0.02522057108581066, -0.015004277229309082, -0.00909567903727293, 0.010483049787580967, -0.006406555883586407, 0.0001328817306784913, -0.028114374727010727, 0.028552258387207985, -0.015112917870283127, -0.051250163465738297, 0.05384175106883049, 0.01849048025906086, -0.06368444859981537, -0.05338151380419731, -0.011111713945865631, -0.05376380309462547, 0.010519307106733322, 0.030068807303905487, 0.010185339488089085, 0.016363482922315598, 0.02426980994641781, 0.022550510242581367, 0.0038496660999953747, -0.07078466564416885, 0.05378994718194008, -0.02827671356499195, -0.007132862228900194, -0.02369370311498642, -0.001034472486935556, 0.007909723557531834, 0.023488758131861687, -0.0018996772123500705, -0.005085696466267109, 0.012037943117320538, 0.03764238953590393, 0.010506737045943737, 0.01239851862192154, 0.006802456919103861, -0.028753230348229408, 0.02549555152654648, 0.004219341557472944, 0.014155782759189606, 0.004259110894054174, 0.003374272957444191, -0.04799317196011543, -0.017785988748073578, -0.0004942596424371004, 0.009799365885555744, -0.022063497453927994, 0.0048751989379525185, -0.0012950787786394358, -0.04633018746972084, -0.020153803750872612, 0.023461839184165, -0.03648736700415611, -0.004293350502848625, 0.06673092395067215, -0.0015255711041390896, 0.020717600360512733, 0.014339026995003223, 0.011893494054675102, 0.022107163444161415, 0.007017392665147781, -0.012766901403665543, 0.0032643720041960478, 0.032284971326589584, -0.047990962862968445, 0.023366378620266914, 0.05122363567352295, 0.002597572049126029, -0.005369747057557106, -0.0279411431401968, 0.004982921294867992, -0.0353308729827404, -0.005092631094157696, 0.014000584371387959, -0.038562625646591187, 0.009775524027645588, -0.011732411570847034, -0.017093311995267868, 0.01623399555683136, -0.03263844549655914, 0.008767770603299141, 0.018961545079946518, 0.01688118651509285, -0.00542623782530427, 0.022353431209921837, 0.00016281144053209573, 0.012369980104267597, 0.02787162736058235, 0.022327369078993797, -0.0013453789288178086, -0.004557369276881218, -0.012151922099292278, -0.08061487972736359, 0.02274615876376629, 0.029008371755480766, 0.0011966514866799116, -0.021768907085061073, -0.01845761574804783, -0.05945994332432747, -0.07379777729511261, 0.0034927886445075274, 0.015869345515966415, 0.0088840052485466, -0.019124161452054977, -0.02847415953874588, -0.01770835369825363, 0.05892593041062355, -0.05963525548577309, 0.007805014029145241, -0.03131202608346939, 0.021021055057644844, -0.06616105884313583, -0.027653547003865242 ]
<p>I have a problem that I don't think I've met before. I have N observations of the variables v1 and v2 and I assume that there is a function f such as v2 = f(v1).</p> <p>I want to know if f has a particular 'statistical' monotony (increasing or decreasing) and if it is 'statistically' convex or concave. By 'statistical' I mean that my observations may include error terms so you may encounter pairs of variable that show a monotony that is the opposite of the global monotony, if that's English.</p> <p>Should I simply compute a f' and a f'' ? (derivatives of f).</p> <p>If you have some thoughts on this I'd be glad to read it. Thanks,</p> <p>Arthur</p> <p>(btw I use Stata)</p>
36,962
[ -0.0446566604077816, 0.0238958653062582, -0.009185504168272018, 0.0238838791847229, 0.011517353355884552, 0.04933308809995651, 0.012838374823331833, -0.009648727253079414, 0.04448983818292618, -0.022404512390494347, -0.023210424929857254, 0.043778255581855774, 0.0420810766518116, 0.0020308662205934525, 0.010772120207548141, -0.018849877640604973, -0.041504234075546265, 0.0019847077783197165, -0.01771371439099312, 0.019325194880366325, -0.01747804507613182, 0.03054719604551792, 0.009788796305656433, -0.001863845274783671, -0.030023735016584396, 0.038972996175289154, 0.006899642292410135, -0.05594596266746521, -0.0030961609445512295, 0.07594779878854752, -0.0432625412940979, -0.05992894619703293, -0.045886196196079254, 0.05945224314928055, 0.06495895981788635, 0.045891523361206055, -0.03495347127318382, -0.0001750881056068465, -0.007803094573318958, 0.07020804286003113, -0.021924220025539398, -0.01288245152682066, -0.01037976797670126, -0.007352103013545275, -0.03322228044271469, 0.01216549426317215, 0.028526684269309044, -0.017965739592909813, 0.041989218443632126, -0.03913191705942154, 0.09165477007627487, -0.006919931620359421, 0.024216309189796448, 0.04862724989652634, -0.0037618877831846476, 0.032090023159980774, 0.027211634442210197, 0.05398167297244072, 0.008102278225123882, -0.03894147649407387, -0.032733675092458725, -0.003984827548265457, -0.02847457490861416, -0.01633431762456894, -0.026172436773777008, 0.028453782200813293, -0.005631846841424704, -0.03549618646502495, 0.05360417068004608, -0.021875804290175438, -0.02141725830733776, 0.0019450002582743764, 0.011470266617834568, -0.0085148299112916, 0.004443533252924681, 0.0030113141983747482, 0.03311150521039963, -0.009312078356742859, 0.03411995619535446, -0.006496998947113752, -0.029094001278281212, 0.005286519415676594, 0.018549323081970215, 0.04015320539474487, 0.03472613915801048, 0.0007855093572288752, 0.06219033896923065, -0.021126214414834976, 0.008991198614239693, 0.04772082343697548, -0.011430864222347736, -0.03917154669761658, 0.03869377076625824, -0.020795060321688652, -0.04124003276228905, 0.0008530901977792382, -0.025546059012413025, 0.003996651619672775, 0.005911014508455992, -0.010904565453529358, 0.012249739840626717, -0.03384653106331825, -0.03751041367650032, 0.029033398255705833, -0.019230850040912628, -0.00878407247364521, -0.004653742536902428, 0.007005662657320499, 0.003776710480451584, 0.01795598305761814, -0.027135170996189117, 0.03187653422355652, 0.035103052854537964, 0.02173243835568428, 0.03550758212804794, -0.0023014622274786234, -0.008776900358498096, 0.012711036019027233, 0.00842846930027008, 0.08033566176891327, 0.052291836589574814, -0.05552441626787186, 0.05519929528236389, -0.01642092876136303, -0.033268436789512634, 0.023421967402100563, 0.045462239533662796, -0.005068337079137564, -0.04744098708033562, 0.02704816311597824, 0.02455909177660942, -0.04642801359295845, 0.03080548346042633, -0.016945412382483482, 0.010050994344055653, 0.014609943144023418, -0.03312071040272713, -0.08666036278009415, -0.0032572865020483732, 0.009924218989908695, 0.011046839877963066, -0.03902232646942139, -0.01255923043936491, 0.03286132216453552, 0.030817750841379166, 0.02419128641486168, 0.023540448397397995, 0.04256649315357208, 0.03757645562291145, -0.004883002024143934, -0.013665778562426567, -0.02032683789730072, 0.00043248559813946486, 0.0017302040942013264, -0.026571908965706825, -0.058659475296735764, 0.025417111814022064, 0.02334931679069996, 0.01193805318325758, -0.013803139328956604, 0.06837699562311172, 0.0026723446790128946, -0.040363457053899765, -0.03355513885617256, 0.008242598734796047, 0.0039830333553254604, 0.10054492950439453, 0.02608531527221203, 0.04535507410764694, -0.016274690628051758, -0.024907780811190605, 0.01253199577331543, -0.008220047689974308, 0.03699587285518646, 0.06943202018737793, -0.016531407833099365, -0.04048185423016548, -0.04079169034957886, 0.011533587239682674, 0.02844371274113655, -0.018980223685503006, -0.012195179238915443, -0.02753511257469654, -0.004995101597160101, -0.03123084455728531, 0.05412985011935234, 0.010245433077216148, 0.021645892411470413, 0.012307603843510151, -0.04916274920105934, -0.025049762800335884, -0.06291931122541428, -0.012355348095297813, -0.025176359340548515, -0.013476615771651268, 0.019729329273104668, -0.006786488927900791, -0.026942722499370575, -0.004942361731082201, 0.032666582614183426, -0.0006210218416526914, 0.009190451353788376, 0.050602853298187256, -0.03895554319024086, -0.007562404032796621, 0.019160985946655273, 0.04766221344470978, 0.004582636058330536, 0.028594493865966797, -0.06652215868234634, -0.05721776932477951, 0.04784850776195526, -0.04740339145064354, -0.015802348032593727, -0.01271178387105465, 0.011745690368115902, 0.006663018837571144, -0.006770054344087839, -0.030450113117694855, -0.0013753208331763744, -0.0848594456911087, 0.061199210584163666, 0.06464647501707077, 0.018663352355360985, 0.013818593695759773, 0.013724570162594318, 0.010114233009517193, 0.00006274422776186839, -0.0010230500483885407, -0.0021044639870524406, -0.005599886178970337, 0.01932157762348652, 0.012387365102767944, 0.02052474208176136, -0.01211571041494608, -0.013807314448058605, 0.0634332224726677, -0.026654552668333054, 0.03056325763463974, 0.0007658976828679442, -0.005411315243691206, -0.007752198725938797, 0.014679600484669209, 0.006656541954725981, 0.04983064904808998, 0.04429734870791435, 0.03487472981214523, 0.01607028767466545, 0.03537729009985924, -0.010404295288026333, -0.0002749185950960964, 0.045318830758333206, 0.033912111073732376, 0.019254961982369423, -0.021157771348953247, 0.004007404670119286, 0.026549605652689934, -0.01563718542456627, 0.0034258058294653893, 0.017537059262394905, -0.012230180203914642, -0.020698828622698784, -0.0008649099036119878, -0.003607525723055005, 0.014953910373151302, -0.015661349520087242, -0.01665640063583851, -0.004278420936316252, 0.04895985126495361, -0.02841782197356224, 0.008804612793028355, -0.007275047246366739, -0.0194910429418087, -0.031956747174263, -0.03530467301607132, 0.0380636528134346, -0.036884456872940063, 0.006451258435845375, 0.001756787532940507, 0.028871266171336174, 0.001031385618261993, -0.05074385553598404, 0.006867003161460161, 0.01233992911875248, -0.028979558497667313, 0.004655890632420778, 0.0012173028662800789, -0.03750161826610565, 0.07780352979898453, -0.008694098331034184, 0.00901199970394373, 0.0635354071855545, -0.03061487525701523, -0.10852497071027756, -0.026636799797415733, -0.05344713479280472, 0.000037822446756763384, -0.013143753632903099, -0.031673863530159, 0.011964831501245499, -0.009416816756129265, -0.03003394789993763, 0.028212154284119606, -0.01920943520963192, -0.03251457214355469, -0.06599032133817673, -0.014847369864583015, -0.0017381621291860938, 0.03004060685634613, 0.026155002415180206, 0.021749259904026985, -0.006294677034020424, 0.00021063211897853762, -0.08573057502508163, -0.03313080221414566, 0.03287028521299362, -0.008332614786922932, 0.01199192926287651, -0.026270771399140358, -0.031777627766132355, 0.09047361463308334, 0.04736775904893875, -0.03188708797097206, -0.014628198929131031, -0.010155429132282734, 0.00600192416459322, 0.018056491389870644, 0.03404629975557327, -0.007965807802975178, 0.002674564253538847, -0.0017238663276657462, -0.0018777179066091776, 0.01296317484229803, 0.04378433898091316, 0.01166964415460825, -0.015675093978643417, 0.04523197188973427, 0.0025825549382716417, -0.009247631765902042, 0.051916200667619705, 0.057345740497112274, -0.02553657628595829, 0.047657325863838196, 0.0038883837405592203, 0.02391332946717739, 0.03666069358587265, -0.037678737193346024, 0.0491572804749012, 0.008238269947469234, -0.013130228035151958, -0.03296126425266266, 0.018391910940408707, 0.03556939214468002, -0.015308672562241554, -0.016419485211372375, 0.002523111877962947, 0.039052318781614304, -0.037606414407491684, 0.005176498554646969, 0.04449991136789322, 0.04873138293623924, -0.007157888729125261, -0.009355307556688786, -0.00789864081889391, -0.0037307804450392723, 0.02345057763159275, -0.039790838956832886, -0.0396181084215641, 0.0403582863509655, -0.0054480573162436485, 0.03463761880993843, 0.005003142636269331, -0.03372552990913391, 0.010858018882572651, -0.041297826915979385, -0.010243809781968594, -0.029572611674666405, 0.041534148156642914, -0.00015815580263733864, 0.011782022193074226, 0.00351452874019742, 0.02715097926557064, 0.002388756489381194, 0.000004673246166930767, -0.10237105935811996, 0.06658338010311127, 0.0037548618856817484, -0.01595255918800831, -0.03402894362807274, 0.004774677567183971, -0.004168308340013027, -0.018789799883961678, -0.008583525195717812, -0.018539533019065857, 0.033224381506443024, -0.07986669987440109, -0.0355299673974514, -0.07249989360570908, -0.04787236824631691, -0.03401586785912514, 0.011928880587220192, 0.019704805687069893, -0.0065869856625795364, 0.05977049097418785, -0.012913866899907589, -0.012033258564770222, -0.016343822702765465, -0.021773140877485275, 0.019845260307192802, 0.016652708873152733, 0.019097644835710526, -0.0035711261443793774, 0.048821233212947845, 0.004913643002510071, 0.06716161966323853, 0.0013773165410384536, 0.036595337092876434, 0.04750485345721245, 0.024318289011716843, -0.021907202899456024, -0.011141948401927948, -0.035468533635139465, -0.01653483137488365, 0.0423608236014843, 0.03768959641456604, 0.011699794791638851, 0.05661770701408386, 0.02310565859079361, -0.028599994257092476, 0.012751637026667595, 0.0596805103123188, 0.01921844482421875, -0.005814447533339262, -0.047378383576869965, -0.028946347534656525, 0.012380446307361126, -0.0038589832838624716, 0.013838410377502441, -0.014596905559301376, -0.029458820819854736, -0.017814412713050842, 0.0201057530939579, 0.00501466216519475, -0.025339379906654358, -0.02379867061972618, -0.014338582754135132, 0.03275603801012039, -0.050075631588697433, -0.03551186993718147, 0.0540790893137455, 0.0553227998316288, 0.017831994220614433, 0.029463564977049828, -0.004334444645792246, -0.11514557152986526, -0.003781894687563181, 0.045132942497730255, -0.00845157727599144, -0.037003349512815475, -0.011798064224421978, -0.023192759603261948, -0.002678631106391549, 0.06272006034851074, -0.01123280730098486, 0.032644279301166534, 0.02361379936337471, 0.015284646302461624, -0.014118501916527748, -0.009962314739823341, -0.022478660568594933, -0.0015567454975098372, -0.017835693433880806, 0.027735508978366852, -0.022162070497870445, -0.014893862418830395, -0.06592437624931335, -0.0030374506022781134, -0.015264282003045082, 0.06590083241462708, -0.029018811881542206, -0.020958181470632553, -0.0002709334949031472, -0.009976545348763466, -0.009656512178480625, -0.0461016520857811, 0.050194285809993744, -0.016727671027183533, -0.008185120299458504, 0.03193973749876022, 0.02324267476797104, -0.014413667842745781, 0.010425131767988205, -0.029879072681069374, -0.029424797743558884, 0.0351431667804718, -0.002672099508345127, 0.04671896994113922, 0.033989112824201584, 0.012142506428062916, 0.03787507489323616, 0.0005648615187965333, 0.023179659619927406, -0.025816332548856735, 0.028381722047924995, 0.012509038671851158, -0.0458715595304966, -0.04369105026125908, -0.025744643062353134, -0.03316110372543335, -0.01579536311328411, -0.017726875841617584, 0.005420162342488766, 0.024981684982776642, -0.013235107064247131, -0.014131823554635048, 0.02448691427707672, 0.031154783442616463, 0.011029637418687344, -0.01645662449300289, 0.005070256534963846, 0.008993610739707947, -0.03299933671951294, -0.054524920880794525, 0.014603257179260254, -0.012192422524094582, 0.009455665946006775, 0.016850806772708893, -0.04791588336229324, -0.0068081337958574295, -0.02158045768737793, -0.032024744898080826, 0.009478033520281315, -0.049549322575330734, 0.04647218808531761, -0.003861378412693739, 0.02792198583483696, 0.005582519806921482, -0.02586505189538002, -0.030489377677440643, 0.03391138091683388, -0.011429712176322937, 0.021421052515506744, -0.07528331130743027, 0.0544506274163723, -0.004255347419530153, -0.026400847360491753, -0.06662183254957199, -0.03217688202857971, 0.0416833870112896, 0.00983375869691372, -0.04671521857380867, 0.0029439337085932493, 0.022427935153245926, -0.01197883766144514, -0.005746355280280113, 0.005034366622567177, 0.05159521847963333, -0.0002488527097739279, -0.0045410748571157455, 0.006800047121942043, 0.031232181936502457, 0.04792244732379913, 0.0111520541831851, 0.022746017202734947, 0.015598097816109657, -0.009035343304276466, 0.009493956342339516, -0.024115175008773804, 0.03408671170473099, -0.043671321123838425, 0.03758116438984871, -0.006149780470877886, 0.011383230797946453, 0.031251512467861176, 0.00461864098906517, -0.015248310752213001, 0.04334303364157677, -0.0029597682878375053, 0.02955392748117447, -0.008043099194765091, 0.008177164942026138, -0.06123888120055199, -0.007044652942568064, 0.013848031871020794, -0.007358101662248373, 0.006568080745637417, -0.013419430702924728, -0.023368312045931816, 0.020887229591608047, -0.02805047482252121, 0.01672050543129444, 0.047156959772109985, 0.004900741390883923, -0.03454866632819176, 0.0226371418684721, 0.034089650958776474, 0.019479291513562202, -0.012621563859283924, -0.008461070246994495, -0.026357140392065048, 0.012558192014694214, -0.01844533160328865, -0.010366936214268208, -0.032128844410181046, 0.018393702805042267, 0.0976860374212265, 0.0033724806271493435, 0.04268637299537659, 0.02749081701040268, 0.013391291722655296, -0.013058710843324661, -0.03831518813967705, -0.03650718182325363, -0.017020728439092636, 0.02510775439441204, 0.02802537940442562, -0.016390837728977203, -0.000457514455774799, 0.0306855496019125, 0.011307231150567532, -0.02300458773970604, 0.03352408483624458, -0.026002949103713036, 0.01387619599699974, 0.06925078481435776, -0.03501952812075615, -0.05875806137919426, 0.02562331221997738, -0.03146057948470116, 0.05304226651787758, -0.03869721665978432, -0.045641858130693436, 0.0357564352452755, 0.038355641067028046, 0.044326361268758774, -0.06190565228462219, -0.03453509509563446, -0.029597653076052666, 0.00942232832312584, 0.007683570496737957, -0.027955692261457443, 0.027923831716179848, -0.005385281052440405, 0.02691388688981533, 0.024728666990995407, 0.05892862007021904, -0.06480033695697784, -0.056477248668670654, 0.010144381783902645, -0.004579200875014067, -0.028414003551006317, 0.05167926475405693, 0.019989771768450737, -0.043066684156656265, 0.052121829241514206, -0.014968160539865494, -0.01430511474609375, 0.06673785299062729, 0.023747285827994347, 0.0035146973095834255, 0.08435705304145813, -0.009945439174771309, 0.008434977382421494, -0.033002518117427826, -0.0006178417825140059, 0.11080606281757355, 0.05308755859732628, 0.01250971294939518, -0.021501705050468445, 0.011440676636993885, -0.009838147088885307, -0.008112735114991665, -0.01443072035908699, 0.020718850195407867, 0.03309497609734535, -0.039393484592437744, 0.01484439056366682, 0.013559346087276936, 0.011035126633942127, -0.013360932469367981, 0.024304205551743507, -0.020787514746189117, -0.0019863026682287455, -0.015067479573190212, 0.012693692930042744, 0.005633522290736437, -0.002855428494513035, -0.03552565351128578, 0.036698900163173676, -0.0007106957491487265, -0.005698725115507841, 0.0025595214683562517, -0.005962413270026445, -0.007572652772068977, 0.008091920055449009, -0.03406473994255066, 0.015370615758001804, 0.07217670232057571, 0.005966153461486101, -0.01770561933517456, 0.010526429861783981, 0.020991895347833633, -0.02676808275282383, 0.00105116399936378, 0.04724128171801567, 0.011212365701794624, 0.0014069534372538328, 0.022275086492300034, -0.006951092276722193, -0.05720040574669838, 0.0034172995947301388, -0.024440947920084, 0.0035671726800501347, 0.03336424008011818, -0.0025703608989715576, -0.01018543355166912, -0.003239270066842437, -0.011576304212212563, -0.042597588151693344, -0.02132609859108925, -0.005106189753860235, 0.005667981691658497, -0.024755720049142838, -0.015129346400499344, -0.011038849130272865, -0.012184449471533298, -0.006266469601541758, -0.015314781107008457, -0.00902484729886055, -0.04665528982877731, -0.04283721745014191, 0.008752726018428802, 0.06808988749980927, -0.022549422457814217, -0.025338007137179375, 0.02548193372786045, -0.025471804663538933, -0.04126134142279625, -0.0024184018839150667, -0.02763126976788044, -0.008197576738893986, 0.03181232884526253, 0.027307581156492233, -0.0249063428491354, -0.018706467002630234, -0.05096288397908211, 0.014679994434118271, -0.02249680459499359, 0.03474496677517891, -0.05487368255853653, -0.003899318166077137, 0.021466504782438278, -0.016224144026637077, 0.021082744002342224, 0.006369862239807844, 0.01565239578485489, 0.036329545080661774, 0.021956538781523705, -0.03789143264293671, -0.024668926373124123, 0.028271395713090897, -0.011383417062461376, -0.029034556820988655, -0.020880280062556267, 0.0853288322687149, 0.024276213720440865, 0.0425352081656456, -0.009207299910485744, -0.013762133195996284, -0.018823351711034775, 0.028077736496925354, 0.04519151151180267, -0.05558188259601593, -0.012412849813699722, -0.01094600185751915, -0.009154137223958969, -0.04818765074014664, 0.002847732976078987, -0.02587040141224861, 0.005833549425005913, 0.003515535267069936, -0.011484339833259583, -0.0021479646675288677, 0.020034436136484146, 0.015560767613351345, 0.034760814160108566, -0.020431987941265106, 0.010735418647527695, -0.020668666809797287, -0.01867971196770668, 0.014067322947084904, 0.03736436739563942, -0.015222886577248573, 0.05296146869659424, -0.06226671487092972, -0.027085362002253532, 0.0032351326663047075, 0.048775915056467056, 0.044360898435115814, -0.018455171957612038, 0.036792244762182236, -0.005109076853841543, 0.03602692484855652, -0.0014138768892735243, -0.025365879759192467, 0.006739343516528606, -0.03882913663983345, -0.038472335785627365, 0.0022161470260471106, 0.009973794221878052, 0.017073828727006912, -0.013794764876365662, -0.03570278361439705, -0.006206880789250135, 0.05588819831609726, -0.021663719788193703, 0.014792799018323421, 0.0022800627630203962, -0.0371718630194664, -0.016287866979837418, -0.03140007704496384, 0.01298082247376442, 0.024860750883817673, 0.023211633786559105, -0.007755807135254145, 0.024835780262947083, -0.020555609837174416, 0.003291144035756588, 0.0174055527895689, -0.007419508416205645, -0.007954294793307781, -0.02481466345489025, 0.016737740486860275, 0.01700679026544094, 0.022375497967004776, -0.0328374058008194, 0.024425560608506203, 0.0052628908306360245, 0.024489568546414375, -0.08223903179168701, -0.007556235417723656, 0.0073694088496267796, 0.0024173581041395664, 0.040334101766347885, -0.0713219866156578, -0.020997729152441025, 0.0075418963097035885, -0.06345658749341965, 0.025428060442209244, -0.020376306027173996, -0.015167000703513622, -0.02722984552383423, -0.008482009172439575, -0.013034865260124207, 0.03328871354460716, -0.013816583901643753, 0.008520437404513359, 0.003479279577732086, 0.03657238557934761, -0.018751738592982292, -0.028858227655291557, -0.007484209258109331, 0.0004089025023858994, 0.02383952960371971, -0.05438592657446861, 0.034370895475149155, -0.02027050219476223, -0.023518165573477745, 0.058316368609666824, -0.05680883675813675, 0.024106020107865334, -0.014975367113947868, 0.028151489794254303, 0.016480013728141785, 0.027529215440154076, -0.012804731726646423, 0.00515604205429554, -0.02705315873026848, -0.03382965922355652, -0.013099441304802895, 0.04053620621562004, -0.04260803386569023, 0.012742573395371437, 0.02710833214223385, 0.007843302562832832, 0.009935403242707253, 0.009392919950187206, 0.0027611495461314917, 0.022252650931477547, -0.016295889392495155, -0.016281526535749435, 0.00907412264496088, -0.002345013665035367, 0.044045936316251755, -0.0052294302731752396, -0.00019785258336924016, 0.006004993338137865, 0.033605895936489105, -0.03508520498871803, 0.02249917946755886, 0.0072980038821697235, -0.058144308626651764, -0.012308281846344471, -0.005306378938257694, -0.008617413230240345, -0.03913175314664841, -0.00012206108658574522, 0.020425453782081604, -0.0081856120377779, -0.03744199499487877, -0.05313782021403313, -0.026480618864297867, 0.024606607854366302, 0.02223929576575756, -0.03673065826296806, -0.007286290172487497, -0.01851453259587288, 0.028793852776288986, -0.09306211769580841, 0.038768161088228226, 0.019380347803235054, -0.01049468107521534, -0.0010096412152051926, -0.006940457038581371, -0.03254585340619087, -0.015599635429680347, 0.05391065776348114, -0.012619499117136002, 0.0052561163902282715, -0.003561242250725627, 0.03384723141789436, 0.001202983083203435, -0.046045172959566116, 0.008449843153357506, 0.0037028715014457703, 0.026103094220161438, -0.0014151897048577666, 0.007717086002230644, 0.03755658119916916, -0.028578346595168114, 0.041210152208805084, -0.029449578374624252, 0.012098475359380245, 0.036545999348163605, -0.007045485079288483, 0.024563657119870186, -0.0314289890229702, 0.020198440179228783, 0.021335510537028313, -0.026071852073073387, 0.042191799730062485, 0.02734309807419777, 0.03418899327516556, -0.05132336542010307, -0.006012726109474897, 0.00478197680786252, -0.04430190846323967, -0.021984528750181198, 0.0051492429338395596, 0.0248948335647583, -0.025349140167236328, -0.02452964149415493, 0.03365913778543472, -0.03412024676799774, 0.0038917309138923883, 0.0379929356276989, 0.014466515742242336, 0.034773845225572586, -0.03534584864974022, 0.00754140131175518, -0.0023759203031659126, 0.007319840136915445, -0.023590300232172012, 0.03062964603304863, 0.04338531196117401, 0.001876365626230836, 0.030302897095680237, 0.03757598251104355, -0.05349580571055412, 0.04020274057984352, -0.004406608175486326, 0.029226338490843773, -0.03181687369942665, -0.020542966201901436, -0.009807167574763298, 0.039726946502923965, -0.045682478696107864, 0.0002085004234686494, -0.004312891513109207, 0.03970657289028168, -0.02387620136141777, 0.007305819075554609, -0.05218590795993805, -0.008414310403168201, -0.06347063928842545, -0.03273451700806618, 0.025172926485538483, -0.021863186731934547, 0.021773315966129303, 0.05318576842546463, 0.006663565058261156, 0.02167455665767193, 0.03936944901943207, -0.04527335986495018, 0.022318432107567787, -0.01129515003412962, 0.006827383767813444, -0.0005062819691374898, -0.0045708538964390755, -0.036610331386327744, -0.0291071068495512, 0.0771414265036583, 0.03413752093911171, 0.04033011943101883, -0.03680793195962906, 0.012921459972858429, -0.045301809906959534, 0.04177944362163544, -0.05286756902933121, -0.047904662787914276, -0.031465083360672, 0.019268779084086418, 0.01660413295030594, -0.047326184809207916 ]
<p>Let $(X,Y)$ have the mixed discrete-continuous pdf given by:</p> <p>$$f(x,y)= \begin{cases} \frac{y^{a+x-1}e^{-2y}}{\Gamma(a) x!}\ y&gt;0;x=0,1,2,\ldots \\ 0 \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \text{elsewhere} \end{cases}$$</p> <p>Could you please help me show that this nasty pdf integrates/sums to 1 over the support of $(X,Y)$?</p> <p>I initially tried to integrate out $Y$, by completing the gamma distribution with parameters, <strong>shape**$=a+x$ and **scale</strong>=$1/2$ and then sum over $X$ but that lead to a mess. </p> <p>Is there another way to go here? Thank you.</p>
74,222
[ 0.025225261226296425, -0.005802487954497337, 0.04039844498038292, -0.007729104720056057, 0.040041521191596985, 0.011765684932470322, -0.013634744100272655, -0.040185462683439255, 0.02784203551709652, -0.051963597536087036, 0.0543205626308918, 0.031149238348007202, 0.06411894410848618, 0.01563088782131672, 0.008157487958669662, 0.026591187343001366, -0.03551993519067764, 0.001198875135742128, 0.007938440889120102, -0.025225892663002014, -0.032124344259500504, 0.013492368161678314, 0.01579255796968937, -0.003654127474874258, -0.021546706557273865, 0.037225645035505295, 0.021953707560896873, -0.02144494839012623, -0.0002288795221829787, 0.09607129544019699, -0.03393438830971718, -0.04669322445988655, 0.00003808011024375446, 0.04353766143321991, 0.003156190039590001, 0.029584895819425583, -0.03484734147787094, 0.004099793266505003, 0.005228726658970118, 0.013232466764748096, -0.019448911771178246, -0.0526885986328125, 0.02531260997056961, 0.007731809746474028, -0.013617442920804024, 0.017474640160799026, 0.027817172929644585, -0.02541416324675083, 0.06728252023458481, -0.05125950649380684, 0.07784023135900497, -0.03103429451584816, 0.02439667470753193, 0.05002317577600479, 0.02111692912876606, -0.007616619113832712, 0.031013963744044304, 0.03710508719086647, 0.017845608294010162, -0.04908064752817154, -0.01996513456106186, -0.043605104088783264, -0.0010374891571700573, -0.0028981748037040234, -0.015298636630177498, 0.007517717778682709, 0.012771331705152988, -0.06699855625629425, -0.02542102336883545, -0.020651351660490036, 0.012325203977525234, 0.013615788891911507, 0.03387339040637016, -0.026018396019935608, 0.018950175493955612, 0.019394269213080406, 0.011418387293815613, 0.05167875066399574, 0.03733905032277107, 0.020984090864658356, -0.030958501622080803, 0.026112085208296776, 0.03469514474272728, -0.0015674337046220899, 0.002266848925501108, 0.002211053390055895, 0.09343242645263672, 0.030308425426483154, -0.015686113387346268, 0.020248284563422203, 0.0040918686427176, 0.0016918425681069493, 0.04960258677601814, -0.01461196318268776, 0.014885460026562214, 0.04913938045501709, 0.018302325159311295, 0.031695932149887085, 0.019241681322455406, -0.026098767295479774, -0.025284161791205406, -0.05158839747309685, 0.03899671137332916, 0.08687854558229446, 0.005737763363867998, 0.011852753348648548, -0.02794579043984413, -0.0016343339812010527, -0.0011208101641386747, -0.018890414386987686, -0.03163008764386177, 0.002331089461222291, 0.02919391728937626, -0.026667147874832153, 0.016030199825763702, 0.054306190460920334, -0.006325661204755306, -0.004212670028209686, 0.029429730027914047, 0.04016938805580139, 0.07411549240350723, -0.02960008569061756, 0.026621103286743164, -0.024201104417443275, -0.0378434918820858, 0.011496836319565773, 0.005028229672461748, 0.012172775343060493, -0.07324197143316269, 0.0403984934091568, -0.022325841709971428, -0.02652786672115326, 0.04044070839881897, 0.025063026696443558, 0.024469951167702675, -0.03647367283701897, -0.0457279272377491, -0.038140688091516495, 0.01682942360639572, -0.041822656989097595, 0.019089508801698685, -0.05703473463654518, -0.02928542159497738, 0.045545462518930435, 0.04534025490283966, -0.031065979972481728, 0.03893740102648735, -0.01136926468461752, 0.027480298653244972, -0.007649905048310757, -0.020826153457164764, -0.04016200080513954, -0.03232869878411293, -0.06086308881640434, -0.03435571864247322, -0.015172280371189117, 0.053442973643541336, 0.011225721798837185, -0.014312708750367165, -0.03265715017914772, 0.048059891909360886, -0.0056054419837892056, -0.02374863624572754, -0.021857453510165215, 0.01136166974902153, -0.04292731732130051, 0.06138507276773453, 0.03813764080405235, 0.0029116878286004066, 0.020572714507579803, -0.02106383629143238, 0.014974595978856087, 0.012583574280142784, 0.02421189658343792, 0.05152247101068497, -0.05913376435637474, -0.0231026541441679, -0.01836870238184929, -0.003168630413711071, 0.0439331978559494, -0.007262039463967085, -0.017886800691485405, -0.048020172864198685, 0.0041402424685657024, 0.009047805331647396, 0.04145379737019539, 0.02754608914256096, -0.00961594469845295, 0.010492644272744656, -0.041062645614147186, -0.061240337789058685, -0.05112248659133911, -0.017410891130566597, -0.017328105866909027, -0.01554260402917862, 0.024088213220238686, 0.0018706910777837038, 0.027311794459819794, -0.0004672261420637369, 0.0010569024598225951, 0.013599985279142857, -0.013102794997394085, 0.05950228497385979, -0.025398289784789085, 0.023289617151021957, 0.0000393118716601748, 0.05942635238170624, -0.027930179610848427, 0.06530056893825531, -0.02315458096563816, -0.009778878651559353, -0.0424957275390625, -0.01286125835031271, 0.03540714830160141, -0.030845914036035538, 0.018732726573944092, -0.02101667784154415, 0.010777213610708714, 0.006264278199523687, 0.005611926782876253, -0.06619582325220108, 0.052407704293727875, 0.06839564442634583, 0.004759920760989189, -0.01569562777876854, 0.022399701178073883, 0.04258175939321518, 0.021565457805991173, -0.01702449470758438, -0.05645297095179558, 0.016768641769886017, 0.001506450236774981, 0.020399905741214752, 0.040228161960840225, -0.02733439765870571, -0.010629282332956791, 0.06172121688723564, 0.008246936835348606, 0.02404538169503212, 0.019588662311434746, 0.01926294155418873, -0.025898166000843048, -0.005503140389919281, 0.038081083446741104, -0.0012824763543903828, -0.028887690976262093, -0.00046985255903564394, -0.009870082139968872, 0.01994135230779648, 0.05531144514679909, -0.015786312520503998, 0.016427239403128624, -0.012776855379343033, 0.04744796082377434, -0.030876200646162033, -0.006474708206951618, 0.06833429634571075, -0.024684876203536987, 0.016703320667147636, 0.025885477662086487, -0.0127848070114851, -0.03675394505262375, -0.011981681920588017, 0.002416638657450676, 0.03049587830901146, 0.015615788288414478, 0.01293924730271101, -0.026193901896476746, 0.021630264818668365, 0.022502833977341652, 0.004567552357912064, -0.009593471884727478, -0.02307160757482052, -0.01601480506360531, 0.0013026846572756767, 0.024588488042354584, 0.02910599112510681, 0.011407362297177315, -0.026024606078863144, -0.05834634229540825, 0.006693018134683371, 0.019004108384251595, 0.010539302602410316, 0.0009846132015809417, -0.051185544580221176, -0.0183888990432024, -0.04092647135257721, 0.05109529197216034, 0.027198847383260727, -0.0001617677917238325, 0.007035404443740845, -0.007437705993652344, -0.026702767238020897, -0.03997276350855827, -0.0004647249006666243, 0.010372825898230076, 0.02277260273694992, -0.05419165641069412, -0.0450294055044651, 0.02769111655652523, 0.019240742549300194, -0.022696910426020622, 0.0042750719003379345, -0.002839213702827692, -0.03442326560616493, -0.012011165730655193, -0.014566615223884583, 0.03764975816011429, -0.00942842848598957, 0.015412930399179459, -0.018872404471039772, -0.016597788780927658, -0.008233453147113323, -0.08455269783735275, -0.023132609203457832, -0.005689569283276796, -0.01146887056529522, 0.018328189849853516, 0.03363480418920517, -0.032553743571043015, 0.0320151150226593, 0.030154995620250702, -0.017491010949015617, -0.007309264503419399, -0.005507692229002714, -0.011395756155252457, -0.03511686250567436, 0.027447719126939774, -0.0024818633683025837, 0.001051521161571145, 0.048730019479990005, 0.019635062664747238, -0.006147943902760744, 0.04404694214463234, -0.0012988257221877575, -0.03702634200453758, 0.02637597545981407, 0.02856913022696972, 0.025327512994408607, 0.02765771932899952, 0.034671369940042496, -0.018100297078490257, 0.0377882644534111, -0.005589212290942669, 0.03199649229645729, 0.01686090975999832, -0.006478109396994114, 0.01110193133354187, 0.0047127483412623405, -0.0021497614216059446, -0.052494823932647705, 0.051556143909692764, 0.02463320828974247, -0.048231858760118484, -0.03164111450314522, -0.0017247851938009262, 0.0398462638258934, -0.002687813714146614, 0.03313860669732094, 0.011079267598688602, 0.05175871402025223, -0.010494203306734562, -0.0488920696079731, -0.0029182627331465483, -0.002273540711030364, 0.05441579967737198, 0.027646426111459732, 0.007540032267570496, 0.016708509996533394, 0.028843924403190613, -0.011780643835663795, -0.050480395555496216, -0.020689411088824272, -0.00020800091442652047, -0.06947526335716248, -0.012361048720777035, -0.03174087777733803, 0.03332378715276718, 0.015815410763025284, 0.013846185058355331, 0.028933636844158173, 0.004494410008192062, -0.004690108355134726, -0.008923494257032871, -0.055767521262168884, -0.003017896320670843, -0.009350740350782871, 0.004161343444138765, -0.019000504165887833, 0.026335829868912697, 0.03513943403959274, -0.01488453708589077, -0.02021755278110504, -0.024219630286097527, -0.015741722658276558, -0.028996219858527184, -0.0420617014169693, -0.04949413612484932, -0.023906543850898743, -0.054782934486866, 0.02784552052617073, 0.01880362071096897, -0.029993193224072456, 0.013152961619198322, 0.021838320419192314, -0.025230558589100838, -0.015093538910150528, -0.018749181181192398, 0.03397837281227112, 0.024673722684383392, 0.024680303409695625, 0.011314834468066692, 0.02838379703462124, 0.012854557484388351, 0.005050260573625565, -0.011084478348493576, 0.05497729778289795, 0.0007843039347790182, -0.02516530267894268, 0.0033075539395213127, -0.0177353136241436, -0.04027307406067848, 0.00594799080863595, -0.0033380533568561077, -0.02180788479745388, 0.03442063927650452, 0.023539163172245026, 0.046385496854782104, -0.044300977140665054, 0.03586097061634064, 0.08030202984809875, 0.004341025371104479, -0.0027686324901878834, -0.03520800173282623, 0.007089685183018446, -0.03401825577020645, 0.0026446811389178038, -0.02010429836809635, -0.02183668129146099, -0.03105216473340988, 0.01661229319870472, 0.053444214165210724, -0.01528560183942318, -0.0214083194732666, -0.0179139357060194, 0.014528912492096424, 0.009869017638266087, 0.015873797237873077, -0.04200403019785881, 0.038218311965465546, 0.033211592584848404, -0.007944513112306595, 0.03124275431036949, -0.02220880053937435, -0.021882036700844765, -0.008724674582481384, 0.07911531627178192, 0.0481218621134758, 0.02122489921748638, -0.004901561886072159, -0.04602866247296333, -0.021955784410238266, 0.0405719056725502, -0.0005564046441577375, 0.010503318160772324, -0.011216498911380768, -0.01010438147932291, 0.05212423950433731, -0.04982370883226395, -0.07552986592054367, 0.024451516568660736, 0.006200411356985569, 0.004968713968992233, -0.02771640010178089, -0.04049883782863617, -0.03450140729546547, 0.022066298872232437, 0.010141231119632721, 0.055638041347265244, -0.01758187636733055, -0.013493708334863186, -0.01569250039756298, 0.021861692890524864, 0.0012089466908946633, -0.08505117893218994, 0.028348978608846664, 0.014010767452418804, -0.004724983125925064, 0.024060817435383797, -0.01242097932845354, -0.03741481900215149, 0.039311569184064865, 0.01665918342769146, 0.019636401906609535, 0.032897841185331345, -0.035201411694288254, 0.03187544271349907, 0.05697767436504364, 0.04408438503742218, 0.025203276425600052, 0.06536398828029633, 0.003204964566975832, 0.019840527325868607, -0.03899805247783661, 0.016410522162914276, -0.017038334161043167, -0.005676988512277603, -0.036652933806180954, -0.007317639887332916, -0.034473493695259094, 0.0029932803008705378, 0.011983702890574932, 0.008217520080506802, 0.044069647789001465, -0.0439402237534523, -0.004780401475727558, 0.02105731889605522, -0.03731118142604828, 0.007037016563117504, 0.023475248366594315, 0.02160930074751377, 0.03704719617962837, 0.007130878511816263, 0.0336637981235981, -0.03414051979780197, -0.01132517121732235, 0.03088201768696308, -0.014384608715772629, -0.0312906838953495, -0.01816200092434883, -0.01285014022141695, 0.005530672613531351, -0.020202521234750748, 0.018873320892453194, -0.045106496661901474, -0.0005258481251075864, -0.037351686507463455, -0.013865469954907894, 0.004689642693847418, 0.00848906859755516, 0.030150486156344414, 0.03675367310643196, -0.021695788949728012, -0.0046267262659966946, 0.016752196475863457, -0.04596726596355438, -0.09487011283636093, -0.007093777880072594, -0.002358880825340748, -0.013949641957879066, 0.0174502432346344, -0.0837835818529129, 0.009410252794623375, -0.015575626865029335, 0.0054114870727062225, -0.013574070297181606, 0.018139909952878952, 0.016724593937397003, 0.0003233842726331204, 0.034265175461769104, -0.006901585962623358, 0.06777661293745041, -0.04457662254571915, 0.00516602722927928, 0.02917983941733837, -0.028622200712561607, -0.06125578284263611, -0.0003883762110490352, 0.01811290718615055, -0.06075926125049591, 0.01517259981483221, 0.015146932564675808, -0.03517097979784012, -0.00036466337041929364, -0.04183254763484001, -0.034688010811805725, 0.03325207158923149, 0.007983283139765263, 0.03765619918704033, -0.03476373851299286, -0.019797202199697495, 0.01573444902896881, 0.00218875240534544, -0.028195131570100784, -0.0028110540006309748, -0.030491948127746582, -0.014658874832093716, 0.018327420577406883, 0.0009657219052314758, -0.0315014123916626, 0.04393516108393669, 0.062028270214796066, -0.0031207017600536346, -0.023302966728806496, 0.007408139295876026, 0.013751426711678505, 0.04505761340260506, 0.00196078117005527, -0.0071441419422626495, 0.038668833673000336, 0.021995818242430687, -0.06697960942983627, 0.023182930424809456, -0.06314432621002197, 0.024168875068426132, 0.034713130444288254, 0.01660827361047268, 0.04042184352874756, 0.025109704583883286, 0.012883691117167473, -0.026342051103711128, 0.006808718666434288, -0.04681362211704254, -0.00677152955904603, -0.037034276872873306, 0.014036950655281544, -0.001312284846790135, 0.012891547754406929, -0.011737159453332424, 0.04194686934351921, 0.025167742744088173, 0.05147013068199158, 0.00137286726385355, -0.014031335711479187, 0.027643943205475807, 0.006294299382716417, -0.021905848756432533, 0.02357952855527401, -0.030890900641679764, -0.012468789704144001, 0.007352122105658054, -0.052951257675886154, 0.04408864304423332, 0.042720310389995575, -0.0063042365945875645, -0.032918673008680344, -0.024729615077376366, -0.03314489498734474, 0.005352385807782412, 0.03201618045568466, 0.013056528754532337, 0.09573517739772797, -0.03211672604084015, 0.015527114272117615, -0.014186744578182697, 0.03947533667087555, -0.042583681643009186, -0.03301817551255226, 0.01441049575805664, -0.030421022325754166, -0.04563673958182335, 0.017745252698659897, -0.006913078483194113, -0.009792659431695938, 0.007799461483955383, -0.0364118255674839, 0.016811348497867584, 0.03260478749871254, 0.021366748958826065, -0.005348180420696735, 0.058972302824258804, 0.0027480139397084713, 0.01727801375091076, -0.010581079870462418, -0.017727041617035866, 0.13510969281196594, 0.0454803891479969, 0.021887242794036865, -0.07396356761455536, 0.006723096128553152, 0.013961180113255978, 0.004748497623950243, -0.03189318627119064, 0.01893913559615612, 0.0197282824665308, 0.00504088681191206, 0.02407871000468731, 0.11107682436704636, 0.03974755480885506, 0.013529629446566105, 0.017964523285627365, -0.012432163581252098, -0.03236999362707138, 0.018782809376716614, -0.010198566131293774, -0.010107203386723995, 0.0029986402951180935, -0.0752716213464737, -0.02047118917107582, -0.026147888973355293, -0.012258783914148808, -0.03168351948261261, -0.0169881209731102, -0.0189815666526556, 0.029181944206357002, -0.03039632923901081, -0.007218280807137489, 0.012199683114886284, -0.02908930368721485, 0.05874824523925781, -0.01441754400730133, 0.0439520999789238, -0.011034882627427578, 0.015707621350884438, 0.03540771082043648, 0.04099605232477188, 0.0035755890421569347, 0.02105564996600151, 0.02384272590279579, -0.02389807067811489, -0.049799252301454544, -0.02652045153081417, 0.026813868433237076, -0.01528511568903923, 0.02234208770096302, -0.00665280083194375, -0.03392824903130531, -0.020800303667783737, -0.027448832988739014, -0.010147538036108017, 0.028604423627257347, 0.01116062793880701, -0.005079986061900854, -0.028951678425073624, -0.020409371703863144, 0.036356840282678604, -0.003555119037628174, 0.009944790042936802, 0.05737774819135666, -0.04535442218184471, -0.00901957880705595, -0.03354806452989578, 0.04414157196879387, 0.014729374088346958, -0.038706183433532715, -0.017351236194372177, -0.024415958672761917, -0.03557012602686882, 0.0065422821789979935, -0.021292584016919136, -0.029569091275334358, 0.018325146287679672, 0.004219390917569399, 0.00872134231030941, -0.025711746886372566, -0.07026615738868713, -0.015410978347063065, -0.012273356318473816, -0.01392290648072958, -0.019447721540927887, -0.038811344653367996, -0.01350855827331543, -0.00044778810115531087, 0.013899832963943481, -0.0804404467344284, -0.0191703662276268, 0.07603511959314346, 0.016349222511053085, -0.01582401618361473, 0.01502090785652399, -0.025896156206727028, -0.05292605608701706, -0.020782485604286194, 0.0019113165326416492, 0.022751908749341965, 0.015795527026057243, 0.016857119277119637, 0.0173825453966856, -0.01373419538140297, -0.05893177166581154, -0.006226428784430027, 0.00045696922461502254, -0.05435604974627495, 0.002303601708263159, 0.010899192653596401, -0.01648414134979248, -0.03510561212897301, -0.008953685872256756, -0.01818695105612278, -0.008081710897386074, -0.0020367514807730913, 0.017234310507774353, -0.038590751588344574, -0.020661192014813423, 0.0014662229223176837, 0.012736884877085686, -0.031292080879211426, 0.00588614447042346, -0.008040515705943108, -0.009697861038148403, -0.03160679340362549, -0.0064264084212481976, -0.001660480978898704, 0.03595547005534172, 0.007019334938377142, 0.020020896568894386, 0.029884668067097664, 0.03222130984067917, 0.016198651865124702, -0.010539300739765167, 0.05904170498251915, -0.023300107568502426, 0.03541348874568939, -0.005135569255799055, 0.002543013310059905, 0.05018851161003113, -0.005451863631606102, 0.011887744069099426, 0.015108908526599407, -0.012096636928617954, 0.02677242085337639, 0.00629202276468277, -0.028975749388337135, -0.060229167342185974, 0.04939213767647743, -0.007226226851344109, -0.0384819433093071, -0.0001731736265355721, 0.024176668375730515, 0.016477059572935104, 0.0032368539832532406, 0.002372849965468049, 0.024343788623809814, 0.018082881346344948, -0.001975982915610075, -0.006395825184881687, -0.025487368926405907, -0.04165003448724747, 0.0024746768176555634, -0.025770967826247215, 0.04818063974380493, 0.021617431193590164, -0.01184365339577198, 0.036479104310274124, 0.0452394112944603, -0.003216856624931097, -0.006493282038718462, -0.05845725163817406, -0.03475945442914963, -0.06221821904182434, -0.016624074429273605, 0.03744892030954361, 0.03214146941900253, 0.020393021404743195, -0.04939991235733032, -0.012948691844940186, 0.07962559908628464, -0.02724388800561428, -0.041605256497859955, -0.00700678676366806, -0.015246502123773098, -0.04798385128378868, 0.019400695338845253, -0.03397456184029579, 0.02604026533663273, 0.028155889362096786, 0.06065494194626808, 0.031228112056851387, -0.006879569496959448, -0.03878181055188179, -0.03357774764299393, -0.008008945733308792, -0.0006846471223980188, -0.01073069591075182, -0.015515985898673534, 0.09916384518146515, 0.0031202994287014008, -0.013851785100996494, 0.04844943434000015, -0.015472265891730785, 0.018047025427222252, -0.013435591012239456, 0.04710281267762184, 0.032130613923072815, 0.015003738924860954, 0.03357471898198128, 0.04798439145088196, 0.03095162846148014, -0.005898184608668089, 0.038623321801424026, 0.012563108466565609, -0.03407367691397667, 0.010710262693464756, 0.04876817390322685, 0.011472265236079693, -0.03569452837109566, 0.025348326191306114, -0.028962980955839157, -0.014845035038888454, -0.0009661182994022965, -0.017582135275006294, 0.0015467063058167696, -0.042389944195747375, 0.049198150634765625, -0.00608149403706193, 0.019861025735735893, 0.021528564393520355, 0.026538589969277382, -0.005589519627392292, -0.019385218620300293, -0.0009237573249265552, -0.0642649233341217, 0.0037180143408477306, 0.03497202321887016, -0.009239745326340199, -0.033687375485897064, -0.00568448007106781, -0.002101336373016238, 0.007388038095086813, -0.001436907798051834, -0.015309707261621952, -0.042265817523002625, 0.00513147609308362, -0.029348891228437424, 0.035423725843429565, 0.010952652432024479, -0.035847343504428864, -0.0036061264108866453, -0.09942997992038727, 0.03570309653878212, 0.03080401010811329, -0.018596841022372246, -0.0016128553543239832, 0.03297847509384155, 0.006989191751927137, -0.029127461835741997, 0.053192880004644394, 0.0050260149873793125, 0.017067361623048782, 0.05045601725578308, 0.027815325185656548, 0.03238694742321968, -0.0285815317183733, -0.018173152580857277, -0.07109276950359344, 0.0045908004976809025, -0.01470277365297079, 0.029616551473736763, 0.00890913512557745, 0.030153237283229828, 0.005847985856235027, -0.014389119111001492, -0.02084627002477646, -0.0026437866035848856, -0.05815716087818146, 0.015596047043800354, 0.007723595015704632, -0.027177829295396805, 0.0629173070192337, -0.012485509738326073, -0.010901636444032192, -0.02643987350165844, -0.009075005538761616, -0.046464454382658005, 0.015120791271328926, 0.0009554098942317069, 0.0011671920074149966, -0.021582430228590965, 0.01870686374604702, -0.013275486417114735, -0.03399597853422165, 0.04075324162840843, 0.04179362207651138, -0.05140893533825874, -0.0004679234989453107, 0.03107486478984356, 0.046858493238687515, 0.04062100499868393, 0.03475870564579964, -0.011838971637189388, 0.045373689383268356, -0.003330257721245289, 0.007298663258552551, 0.014419976621866226, -0.010850153863430023, -0.049981847405433655, -0.019982634112238884, -0.008110079914331436, 0.006230881437659264, 0.0382709763944149, -0.01587219350039959, 0.01224523689597845, -0.007406660355627537, -0.008172630332410336, 0.026072600856423378, -0.0037231375463306904, 0.005802642088383436, 0.010317924432456493, -0.024463823065161705, 0.06061767414212227, -0.04681076109409332, 0.05561668798327446, -0.019380368292331696, -0.04030466079711914, -0.010741565376520157, 0.015964075922966003, 0.042831409722566605, 0.010333324782550335, 0.01030346006155014, 0.0030546525958925486, -0.023009223863482475, -0.04799667373299599, -0.0029436354525387287, -0.022767867892980576, 0.014163020998239517, -0.020450549200177193, -0.0026702589821070433, 0.0003487309149932116, -0.04305330291390419, -0.030978452414274216, -0.028193173930048943, -0.024484630674123764, 0.027979550883173943, 0.009603253565728664, -0.0036129571963101625, -0.02336018532514572, -0.014871221967041492, 0.07559085637331009, -0.07687234878540039, -0.019383272156119347, -0.05450750142335892, 0.02768087014555931, 0.0031665086280554533, -0.035280726850032806 ]
<p>I used the following R code to fit a probit model:</p> <pre><code>p1 &lt;- glm(natijeh ~ ., family=binomial(probit), data=data1) stepwise(p1, direction='backward/forward', criterion='BIC') </code></pre> <p>I want to know what does <code>stepwise</code> and <code>backward/forward</code> do exactly and how select the variables?</p>
74,223
[ -0.008849963545799255, -0.01705176942050457, 0.015310741029679775, 0.01275272574275732, 0.037902094423770905, 0.017823083326220512, 0.021873001009225845, -0.023953253403306007, 0.0435420460999012, 0.005262283608317375, 0.02059091627597809, 0.03146139159798622, 0.043309103697538376, 0.01073426567018032, 0.06899914145469666, 0.03431076183915138, 0.004403085447847843, -0.004665790591388941, -0.008430865593254566, 0.020573366433382034, 0.0030967050697654486, -0.002397316275164485, 0.001953211147338152, 0.025088462978601456, 0.011004826053977013, 0.031576212495565414, -0.002309836447238922, -0.02334824576973915, -0.020368514582514763, 0.036144379526376724, -0.023621585220098495, -0.031535256654024124, -0.012379751540720463, 0.022944098338484764, 0.025634434074163437, 0.018025394529104233, -0.010940121486783028, -0.059085045009851456, 0.015050330199301243, 0.015898074954748154, -0.019633855670690536, -0.0042175124399363995, 0.009971565566956997, 0.026916388422250748, 0.008331021293997765, 0.027470258995890617, -0.016513535752892494, -0.011738418601453304, 0.050953179597854614, -0.043648649007081985, 0.05067761242389679, -0.05027453601360321, 0.022238602861762047, 0.04207252338528633, 0.01219819113612175, 0.024073587730526924, 0.0735723227262497, 0.07591363787651062, -0.002574346726760268, -0.06967183947563171, 0.0014286517398431897, -0.03604621812701225, 0.00038938134093768895, -0.02605653926730156, -0.03062869980931282, 0.010420571081340313, 0.029279904440045357, -0.03293105587363243, 0.0509769432246685, -0.00239044101908803, -0.011068870313465595, -0.0033600390888750553, -0.005368003621697426, -0.007429609540849924, 0.028057072311639786, -0.04372909665107727, -0.018133770674467087, 0.004586817696690559, 0.05643974244594574, 0.02134029008448124, 0.008064660243690014, -0.027477417141199112, 0.02347438968718052, 0.04455137625336647, 0.0010948709677904844, -0.013628056272864342, 0.04333750158548355, -0.05267859622836113, 0.0062087299302220345, -0.015585462562739849, -0.03594965487718582, 0.04682089760899544, 0.03144550323486328, 0.01732739806175232, -0.00701948581263423, 0.06687993556261063, -0.011382249183952808, 0.02780296467244625, -0.009062343277037144, -0.03343409672379494, -0.0488472506403923, -0.042813610285520554, -0.003174584126099944, 0.039805833250284195, -0.03643709048628807, 0.028503527864813805, -0.018572550266981125, 0.034090183675289154, 0.003285803832113743, -0.04005518928170204, -0.03740980476140976, 0.023228343576192856, 0.0013133983593434095, 0.011114852502942085, 0.019653135910630226, -0.030784238129854202, -0.01590542495250702, 0.0049111745320260525, 0.07153645157814026, 0.04481346160173416, 0.04490906745195389, -0.009614774957299232, -0.0037503584753721952, -0.01242495235055685, -0.048913754522800446, -0.03445339947938919, 0.0318300686776638, 0.020935984328389168, 0.015729574486613274, 0.027735218405723572, 0.001532888738438487, -0.022373484447598457, 0.03851970657706261, 0.01343491766601801, 0.0014992821961641312, 0.0357067808508873, -0.04927200451493263, -0.033527620136737823, 0.053940609097480774, -0.007873299531638622, 0.037283238023519516, -0.060364823788404465, 0.02935240976512432, 0.04696914181113243, 0.0662410631775856, -0.004361005499958992, 0.014708995819091797, 0.02638881281018257, -0.0036925440654158592, 0.015890397131443024, -0.019676661118865013, -0.01663053222000599, -0.03131202235817909, 0.004364872816950083, -0.028094179928302765, -0.10013189166784286, 0.042702216655015945, 0.008603309281170368, 0.002810002537444234, -0.015385257080197334, 0.049509819597005844, 0.020117290318012238, -0.03211313858628273, -0.010587119497358799, -0.04931507259607315, 0.003571672597900033, 0.05141628906130791, 0.001918066875077784, -0.021581929177045822, 0.033307693898677826, -0.028155749663710594, 0.015470756217837334, -0.017835509032011032, 0.07221405953168869, 0.026476668193936348, 0.014526773244142532, -0.008833274245262146, 0.003173987613990903, -0.001275097718462348, 0.02274608239531517, -0.020383378490805626, -0.02105768583714962, 0.0021247875411063433, -0.004636362660676241, 0.02483685314655304, 0.014866149984300137, 0.012465734966099262, 0.002873135032132268, 0.071536585688591, -0.04839101433753967, -0.03430269658565521, -0.06925562024116516, 0.017335519194602966, 0.010886232368648052, -0.03533673286437988, 0.005083931609988213, 0.020099828019738197, 0.02911020629107952, 0.006605349015444517, -0.013600225560367107, -0.04248751327395439, -0.01798783615231514, 0.04540051147341728, -0.021357299759984016, -0.020086374133825302, 0.048267364501953125, 0.05210442841053009, -0.02234681323170662, 0.05834311991930008, -0.034524548798799515, -0.0032034236937761307, 0.014006322249770164, -0.01740908995270729, 0.0034327320754528046, -0.04852570593357086, -0.06384576857089996, 0.001555965980514884, 0.05345822125673294, -0.018132759258151054, 0.051773134618997574, -0.058954086154699326, 0.04957139119505882, 0.0646556094288826, -0.0003197024925611913, 0.012287546880543232, -0.020441189408302307, 0.006785761099308729, 0.04660565033555031, -0.032498691231012344, 0.02074863389134407, -0.021058885380625725, -0.02569538541138172, 0.02590971626341343, -0.020857110619544983, -0.048883188515901566, -0.023779941722750664, 0.039025433361530304, -0.022945137694478035, 0.019849006086587906, 0.026088925078511238, -0.003245802829042077, -0.02606174349784851, 0.020102467387914658, 0.009737719781696796, 0.0425860732793808, -0.004364971537142992, 0.04616498574614525, -0.011753669008612633, 0.04139213263988495, -0.010201110504567623, -0.017002152279019356, 0.08794096857309341, -0.009990714490413666, 0.017332669347524643, 0.024536682292819023, -0.04364513233304024, 0.05599236115813255, -0.018251284956932068, 0.010873958468437195, 0.052491966634988785, 0.034709103405475616, -0.029828930273652077, 0.017310384660959244, 0.0265218336135149, 0.022938502952456474, 0.0724891722202301, -0.02742905169725418, -0.024772070348262787, 0.011543392203748226, -0.035303883254528046, 0.03796204552054405, -0.010332996025681496, -0.039704177528619766, -0.0678635984659195, -0.0021915610413998365, 0.02355513907968998, 0.013564889319241047, 0.018915198743343353, -0.012990436516702175, -0.025896165519952774, -0.01614372245967388, -0.024989819154143333, 0.06449124217033386, 0.0007081444491632283, -0.054072052240371704, 0.012173803523182869, -0.062290504574775696, 0.01706738956272602, 0.025213617831468582, -0.00220649316906929, -0.050298139452934265, 0.023761628195643425, -0.016871295869350433, -0.010006816126406193, -0.04118892922997475, -0.016576973721385002, 0.02310272306203842, 0.003980530891567469, -0.019880197942256927, 0.0158880352973938, -0.00007762332097627223, -0.026782765984535217, -0.00009646743274061009, -0.0710303857922554, -0.04120822995901108, -0.034853145480155945, -0.028569098562002182, 0.006077435798943043, 0.016694964841008186, 0.007681800983846188, 0.002239484339952469, -0.03417164087295532, 0.010827568359673023, -0.04054596647620201, -0.02594495750963688, 0.020358016714453697, 0.029769860208034515, 0.02531164139509201, -0.006247851997613907, 0.0021001328714191914, 0.062387026846408844, 0.03297455608844757, -0.05272527411580086, -0.04981454089283943, 0.007128650788217783, -0.04607224091887474, -0.03493021801114082, 0.023710928857326508, 0.026564106345176697, 0.023576080799102783, 0.029871469363570213, -0.023036329075694084, 0.03935685381293297, 0.049135252833366394, -0.004883354529738426, -0.008017409592866898, 0.017711499705910683, -0.018169892951846123, -0.007132539059966803, -0.002110658446326852, -0.0009993197163566947, -0.01649319939315319, 0.0367419458925724, -0.04727397859096527, 0.02473420836031437, 0.00813343096524477, -0.04262746497988701, 0.011975178495049477, -0.003456731792539358, -0.022905685007572174, -0.051082346588373184, 0.046853408217430115, -0.011188403703272343, -0.06384249776601791, -0.011685732752084732, -0.009520121850073338, 0.044022440910339355, -0.036983419209718704, 0.020114503800868988, 0.00982936006039381, 0.00032310147071257234, -0.02325611375272274, 0.03863471746444702, 0.009758752770721912, -0.006607898976653814, 0.007939236238598824, -0.04416879266500473, -0.013398860581219196, 0.05596262961626053, 0.05222233012318611, 0.005591418128460646, 0.01500456128269434, -0.03253108635544777, 0.0022556325420737267, -0.04431124031543732, 0.004545634146779776, -0.04357612878084183, 0.06040390580892563, 0.015040851198136806, 0.08191783726215363, -0.0009283292456530035, 0.029305268079042435, 0.018504448235034943, -0.021084191277623177, -0.040892452001571655, 0.028712749481201172, 0.004105369560420513, 0.011553317308425903, 0.000372002279618755, -0.022977188229560852, 0.052784282714128494, -0.03697500005364418, -0.021741198375821114, -0.010228072293102741, 0.01678706519305706, -0.006129951681941748, 0.024534745141863823, 0.003929582890123129, -0.01990971900522709, -0.034236107021570206, 0.021297568455338478, 0.004635150078684092, -0.022111497819423676, 0.071100153028965, 0.0666724368929863, 0.01981876790523529, 0.0009146308293566108, -0.03165746480226517, -0.0024991289246827364, 0.045218609273433685, 0.028870919719338417, 0.04275374487042427, 0.032376307994127274, -0.03426434472203255, 0.020860513672232628, 0.023874301463365555, 0.03917079046368599, 0.09126221388578415, 0.00306377443484962, -0.007790693547576666, -0.0023796032182872295, -0.02274157851934433, -0.010457131080329418, 0.005903120152652264, -0.012109784409403801, 0.007047371938824654, 0.06424619257450104, 0.014522389508783817, -0.01530359871685505, -0.004937718156725168, 0.027043001726269722, 0.017600730061531067, -0.0026112254709005356, -0.03071923926472664, -0.03948143497109413, -0.029777459800243378, 0.019733071327209473, -0.00040193586028181016, 0.012855435721576214, -0.01159945223480463, 0.028206437826156616, 0.04850926622748375, -0.004017417784780264, -0.04177548736333847, 0.007768531795591116, 0.01896088384091854, 0.02760898321866989, 0.02181159146130085, -0.057244859635829926, -0.013959536328911781, 0.032331954687833786, -0.0019016902660951018, -0.025318246334791183, -0.003044877666980028, -0.09160789847373962, -0.02115543559193611, 0.030453363433480263, 0.03637087717652321, -0.06968967616558075, -0.011280432343482971, -0.05002497136592865, -0.005880406592041254, 0.014740983955562115, -0.027050787582993507, 0.05858717858791351, -0.03380342200398445, 0.01814058981835842, -0.026165341958403587, -0.02750873565673828, -0.0774746760725975, 0.018032323569059372, -0.026493167504668236, -0.014462577179074287, -0.04361686855554581, -0.0051288362592458725, -0.05257917195558548, 0.015964962542057037, -0.012923977337777615, 0.061257511377334595, -0.0743418037891388, 0.01814611814916134, 0.037957191467285156, -0.0007074565510265529, 0.017462236806750298, -0.01772124320268631, -0.013482949696481228, 0.029523368924856186, -0.01660003885626793, 0.03630295768380165, -0.01432133186608553, -0.060849178582429886, -0.004659106954932213, 0.038420420140028, 0.0008347271359525621, 0.013734427280724049, 0.008348744362592697, 0.021934768185019493, 0.022122269496321678, -0.03923006355762482, 0.04916509613394737, 0.015263902023434639, -0.01758723147213459, -0.011245055124163628, -0.04271123558282852, -0.007666171062737703, 0.007637323345988989, -0.03931724652647972, -0.07316904515028, -0.027707107365131378, -0.033246662467718124, 0.01090474333614111, -0.0015915967524051666, 0.006481503136456013, -0.016932161524891853, -0.04049263522028923, 0.007537209894508123, 0.04483471438288689, -0.021331127732992172, -0.025940191000699997, 0.02305152453482151, 0.0025474312715232372, -0.013375203125178814, -0.029600556939840317, 0.008927817456424236, -0.012385960668325424, 0.020881809294223785, -0.0176144540309906, -0.033595822751522064, 0.03486252948641777, -0.0014692744007334113, -0.03744867816567421, 0.016262108460068703, -0.005395863205194473, -0.016070397570729256, 0.013513836078345776, -0.0030169340316206217, 0.002214729320257902, -0.056414563208818436, -0.015884393826127052, 0.015725936740636826, -0.014303074218332767, -0.017825644463300705, -0.02822273038327694, 0.05590653792023659, -0.00008076130325207487, -0.005517001263797283, -0.022751107811927795, -0.021250342950224876, 0.004379801917821169, 0.0009659273782745004, -0.02635384537279606, -0.019541775807738304, -0.014809493906795979, -0.011485456489026546, -0.031706199049949646, 0.005993600469082594, 0.060353368520736694, -0.017486853525042534, 0.007112177554517984, -0.014578974805772305, 0.012365397065877914, 0.03783204033970833, 0.023117847740650177, -0.004704244900494814, 0.025440160185098648, -0.020332947373390198, 0.009881813079118729, 0.044263727962970734, -0.014549756422638893, -0.01670648343861103, -0.008654989302158356, -0.023564135655760765, 0.03591187670826912, 0.03640978783369064, 0.013503494672477245, -0.009256299585103989, -0.011083305813372135, -0.02331184782087803, -0.012391835451126099, -0.05270100384950638, 0.00029141042614355683, -0.011981692165136337, 0.04093649238348007, -0.04120008647441864, 0.01724819280207157, -0.03850899636745453, 0.0029458743520081043, 0.04097561165690422, -0.011760245077311993, -0.0023389270063489676, 0.01990797184407711, 0.0838904157280922, -0.010924456641077995, 0.02596164494752884, 0.013500342145562172, 0.0007100382354110479, 0.027157919481396675, 0.011161214672029018, -0.003422926180064678, 0.022634554654359818, 0.042101435363292694, -0.0036465360317379236, 0.023120542988181114, -0.05190272629261017, -0.010214186273515224, 0.05310104414820671, -0.03929080069065094, 0.03207472339272499, 0.04481273889541626, -0.01991743966937065, -0.011605367064476013, -0.04472963139414787, 0.01816043257713318, 0.03347066044807434, 0.02645903266966343, 0.072354756295681, -0.01741991937160492, -0.01727381721138954, 0.07123391330242157, -0.002404507016763091, 0.008159199729561806, -0.0026829128619283438, 0.009448539465665817, -0.015607397072017193, -0.02677174285054207, -0.04230554401874542, -0.0006909276708029211, 0.02138887718319893, -0.0287643875926733, 0.016788635402917862, -0.03718651086091995, -0.036960192024707794, 0.06299920380115509, 0.033110376447439194, -0.016698801890015602, -0.07413577288389206, 0.013415227644145489, -0.05862995609641075, -0.032256413251161575, 0.029552599415183067, -0.0364803746342659, 0.02495693974196911, 0.0064654103480279446, 0.01936592347919941, -0.01934812217950821, 0.03581657633185387, -0.013135136105120182, -0.057196758687496185, -0.011837980709969997, -0.01754583977162838, -0.058651894330978394, 0.05043637007474899, 0.0086443480104208, -0.0017446784768253565, -0.021096033975481987, -0.04666897654533386, 0.0015003911685198545, -0.004194061737507582, 0.014574378728866577, 0.0015603099018335342, 0.07253466546535492, -0.01615200936794281, 0.017181357368826866, 0.013679656200110912, -0.05143557861447334, 0.11644046753644943, 0.06639285385608673, 0.009518078528344631, -0.07505753636360168, -0.025497108697891235, 0.0017796680331230164, 0.017141273245215416, 0.002117397729307413, -0.04292325675487518, 0.030656838789582253, 0.006486112251877785, 0.07923854142427444, 0.01809433475136757, 0.020383991301059723, 0.010799960233271122, 0.024006064981222153, -0.04932662099599838, -0.029531164094805717, 0.027361402288079262, 0.0077812559902668, -0.022361116483807564, -0.00538549805060029, -0.03263194113969803, 0.0012082979083061218, 0.050549428910017014, -0.025699568912386894, -0.05370508134365082, -0.020363789051771164, -0.010601802729070187, 0.026719829067587852, 0.022050462663173676, 0.010209864005446434, 0.005979393143206835, 0.03742994740605354, -0.009149876423180103, -0.029489072039723396, 0.01580912619829178, -0.069648377597332, -0.014029254205524921, 0.03526345267891884, -0.01976516842842102, -0.014608640223741531, -0.012535267509520054, 0.013634493574500084, -0.0498691201210022, -0.017090044915676117, -0.01573917083442211, 0.02440524846315384, 0.0033243163488805294, -0.04103197902441025, -0.0027283194940537214, 0.011843486689031124, 0.03331752493977547, -0.03486790880560875, -0.020132049918174744, 0.0925418883562088, 0.026311103254556656, -0.02075512893497944, 0.0006382776191458106, -0.03918598219752312, 0.009713733568787575, 0.0034465568605810404, 0.045127011835575104, 0.0002714140573516488, -0.055511776357889175, -0.020693764090538025, -0.03865711763501167, 0.05001445859670639, -0.002822521608322859, 0.025463992729783058, 0.04532530903816223, -0.004786405246704817, -0.020474106073379517, 0.02329721301794052, 0.029686711728572845, 0.003934329375624657, -0.03014194965362549, -0.024654554203152657, -0.020632682368159294, -0.023045657202601433, -0.01569291763007641, 0.005704040639102459, -0.049238841980695724, -0.0024360103998333216, -0.03408046066761017, -0.01399211771786213, -0.0036938670091331005, 0.03487903252243996, 0.02617775648832321, 0.025705412030220032, -0.007876357063651085, 0.06745779514312744, 0.004642913118004799, -0.058722637593746185, -0.009246161207556725, 0.04814464598894119, -0.041196685284376144, -0.02256823517382145, -0.011011643335223198, 0.08191702514886856, 0.03467616066336632, 0.007369778119027615, -0.04482550546526909, -0.01090189814567566, -0.027006540447473526, -0.015071995556354523, 0.02902923710644245, -0.04358048364520073, 0.009843151085078716, -0.022255700081586838, -0.007933398708701134, -0.048955805599689484, 0.021804435178637505, -0.008204817771911621, -0.05057534575462341, 0.02959195338189602, -0.007851260714232922, -0.021042469888925552, 0.033685971051454544, -0.021529408171772957, 0.005685474257916212, -0.027881799265742302, -0.00430300971493125, -0.009180344641208649, 0.005226424429565668, 0.0004978263168595731, -0.025697585195302963, 0.04041178524494171, 0.010035556741058826, -0.03944452479481697, 0.010948318988084793, 0.03272046148777008, 0.012316346168518066, 0.00782831571996212, 0.002546625444665551, 0.036964304745197296, -0.01579214259982109, 0.008203592151403427, -0.019835399463772774, -0.027944589033722878, -0.0020576748065650463, -0.023769229650497437, -0.02868940681219101, 0.023603785783052444, 0.030017981305718422, 0.05494235083460808, -0.02437470853328705, 0.008134506642818451, -0.029437780380249023, 0.027868274599313736, -0.0016941024223342538, -0.011240663938224316, -0.007950227707624435, -0.006704217754304409, -0.002305783564224839, -0.02288668416440487, -0.028516478836536407, 0.016427498310804367, -0.004835604224354029, 0.01638520322740078, 0.05037853121757507, 0.0037375797983258963, -0.04449111968278885, 0.010144459083676338, -0.03377208113670349, -0.005799261387437582, 0.016930177807807922, -0.042344897985458374, 0.008066782727837563, 0.05405881255865097, -0.011340727098286152, 0.055719900876283646, -0.0005461828550323844, 0.0019168737344443798, -0.06477520614862442, -0.011959279887378216, 0.03468354791402817, 0.00025614706100896, 0.004926355089992285, -0.07183772325515747, 0.030283436179161072, 0.028933322057127953, -0.005327126942574978, 0.017386069521307945, 0.047086525708436966, 0.014328266493976116, -0.03411775082349777, 0.06407098472118378, -0.008287685923278332, 0.05251266807317734, -0.005857775919139385, -0.010934482328593731, 0.03741848096251488, -0.006960718426853418, 0.01118730753660202, -0.05222001671791077, -0.03467915952205658, 0.02196543850004673, -0.03640681505203247, -0.05454811081290245, 0.018623290583491325, -0.021636679768562317, -0.018012935295701027, 0.003047760808840394, 0.01723499223589897, 0.02271258272230625, 0.041012417525053024, 0.04111625999212265, 0.029315752908587456, 0.042879123240709305, -0.0011104904115200043, 0.03127167373895645, 0.005343075841665268, 0.04566757753491402, 0.012788752093911171, 0.0022205845452845097, 0.005584669765084982, 0.014095094054937363, 0.013250026851892471, -0.005542612634599209, 0.024753132835030556, 0.032952453941106796, -0.012186343781650066, -0.008188425563275814, 0.006416036747395992, -0.014905610121786594, -0.027537580579519272, -0.04091740772128105, 0.0045143961906433105, -0.05011078715324402, -0.04157235100865364, 0.009698988869786263, 0.02826865017414093, -0.02107180282473564, 0.030111994594335556, -0.054602377116680145, -0.0398186556994915, 0.014294341206550598, 0.008135040290653706, -0.019681740552186966, -0.03788754343986511, -0.015306244604289532, 0.023655705153942108, -0.022990046069025993, -0.022137999534606934, 0.01465831883251667, -0.024712184444069862, 0.022002117708325386, -0.02185131423175335, -0.002044853987172246, 0.024047834798693657, -0.02609293907880783, 0.007321878336369991, -0.10144814848899841, 0.07566501945257187, -0.005523869302123785, -0.03127806633710861, -0.05551014095544815, -0.017911002039909363, -0.06607888638973236, 0.02747250162065029, 0.030779145658016205, -0.002798994304612279, 0.0244451891630888, -0.028111746534705162, 0.011090807616710663, 0.018259624019265175, -0.04848514497280121, 0.04343167319893837, 0.0005328652332536876, -0.0030568151269108057, -0.0025158203206956387, -0.00018528573855292052, -0.024103259667754173, 0.05066198110580444, -0.0031467447988688946, -0.015484056435525417, 0.009768286719918251, 0.006489182356745005, -0.04426366835832596, 0.016119422391057014, -0.0068638683296740055, -0.00024380888498853892, 0.01993483118712902, -0.014119584113359451, 0.008797167800366879, 0.05502559244632721, 0.005551450420171022, -0.07279016822576523, 0.03300758823752403, -0.0058133890852332115, -0.025694871321320534, 0.012356606312096119, -0.01901494339108467, 0.018971074372529984, -0.028378449380397797, 0.022281592711806297, 0.017967214807868004, -0.04587450250983238, 0.019346561282873154, -0.00013853947166353464, 0.015786197036504745, 0.007613463327288628, -0.05655612796545029, 0.026380907744169235, 0.012010961771011353, -0.010706637986004353, 0.017349710687994957, 0.03695330768823624, 0.051668185740709305, -0.02466013841331005, 0.001063401810824871, 0.02792155183851719, 0.022678766399621964, 0.03774771839380264, -0.008017047308385372, 0.05030987039208412, -0.0009625424281693995, 0.02215486578643322, -0.008453932590782642, -0.018115052953362465, 0.009893207810819149, -0.013665768317878246, -0.024299118667840958, 0.03726864978671074, -0.050767671316862106, 0.00280680600553751, 0.007173837628215551, 0.0024458016268908978, -0.008932381868362427, -0.038875263184309006, -0.005937370005995035, 0.007714055012911558, 0.01910809427499771, 0.009745513089001179, 0.0217304565012455, -0.007664399221539497, 0.029611023142933846, -0.006075836718082428, 0.037355128675699234, 0.012533611617982388, 0.020978841930627823, -0.01655576191842556, -0.00514233997091651, -0.01601276732981205, -0.02439964935183525, 0.038615308701992035, 0.01870712824165821, 0.01900186948478222, -0.05020179599523544, -0.018249068409204483, 0.026865582913160324, 0.037161197513341904, -0.022103218361735344, 0.013116599060595036, -0.01918133907020092, 0.009857534430921078, -0.0026115761138498783, -0.020806072279810905 ]
<p>This is a homework questions. Can you guys give me some hints?</p> <p>Let $U_{(1)}&lt;\cdots&lt;U_{(n)}$ be the order statistics of a sample of size $n$ from a Uniform$(0,1)$ population. Show that $F^{-1}(U_{(1)})&lt;\cdots&lt;F^{-1}(U_{(n)})$ are distributed as the order statistics of a sample of size $n$ from a population with density $f$. </p> <p>Attempt:</p> <p>Let $U=(U_{(1)},\ldots,U_{(n)})$, and $V=(F^{-1}(U_{(1)}),\ldots,F^{-1}(U_{(n)}))=F^{-1}(U)$. I know that the joint pdf of the order statistics is: $f_{X_{(1)},\ldots,X_{(n)}}(x_1,\ldots,x_n)=n!\prod_{i=1}^n f_X(x_i)$. So I thought I could use the jacobian method or something:</p> <p>$\begin{align*}f_V(\mathbf{v})&amp;=f_U(F(\mathbf{v}))|J_{F^{-1}}(F(\mathbf{v}))|\\ &amp;= n!\prod_{i=1}^n F(v_i)|J_{F^{-1}}(F(\mathbf{v}))|\end{align*}$</p> <p>But I have no idea what the jacobian could be, and the $F(v_i)$ doesn't seem right either. Any ideas?</p>
74,224
[ -0.028649616986513138, -0.02243974804878235, -0.0073618111200630665, -0.00045141225564293563, 0.03866094723343849, -0.013483420945703983, 0.015377487055957317, 0.0037777586840093136, 0.021126585081219673, -0.03234798088669777, 0.03555259108543396, 0.037226345390081406, 0.08424961566925049, 0.022589625790715218, 0.03896088898181915, -0.004390955902636051, -0.046663008630275726, 0.011120283044874668, -0.024632347747683525, -0.011838732287287712, 0.0092041976749897, 0.030989190563559532, 0.0403299443423748, -0.0010219989344477654, -0.02511081099510193, 0.035417381674051285, 0.0035650215577334166, -0.008787148632109165, 0.014355950988829136, 0.05077996104955673, -0.024408021941781044, -0.00043145622476004064, -0.02003519795835018, 0.0265191700309515, 0.007573687471449375, 0.054045602679252625, -0.0335509218275547, -0.04168250784277916, 0.017816079780459404, 0.015154052525758743, -0.04925145208835602, -0.03332193195819855, -0.025480303913354874, 0.0015656300820410252, 0.010766679421067238, 0.03283624351024628, 0.02502961829304695, -0.021066712215542793, 0.055567607283592224, -0.035195790231227875, 0.11269313097000122, 0.017894240096211433, 0.02625955082476139, 0.02421870082616806, -0.013865050859749317, -0.0027849453035742044, 0.03588376194238663, 0.06662718951702118, -0.00026600671117193997, -0.043755318969488144, -0.029086502268910408, -0.04719027504324913, -0.02919858694076538, -0.04231875762343407, 0.00006350288458634168, 0.03250832483172417, -0.03282571956515312, -0.030106307938694954, 0.009470582939684391, -0.010764705017209053, 0.017596030607819557, 0.01454645860940218, 0.04412023723125458, -0.02566225454211235, 0.009743358939886093, -0.024760227650403976, 0.058836836367845535, -0.0019427293445914984, 0.015463920310139656, 0.019535180181264877, -0.03275524452328682, 0.03852570429444313, 0.01632128655910492, 0.04580643028020859, 0.0031910580582916737, -0.01661301776766777, 0.09308978915214539, -0.0025192764587700367, 0.03983910009264946, -0.0037749072071164846, -0.016189469024538994, -0.014710788615047932, 0.06577219069004059, -0.01227975357323885, -0.07061683386564255, 0.010932465083897114, -0.015543188899755478, 0.02042965218424797, -0.029116200283169746, -0.025517070665955544, -0.02965070679783821, -0.05767408013343811, 0.0016530818538740277, 0.0417514331638813, -0.027309559285640717, -0.030671386048197746, -0.035014063119888306, -0.008367041125893593, -0.010797612369060516, 0.008216086775064468, -0.012984032742679119, 0.01906568929553032, -0.009882260113954544, -0.019492095336318016, 0.006911716889590025, 0.01548099983483553, 0.040369827300310135, -0.003934270236641169, 0.04775208234786987, 0.059441354125738144, 0.08047958463430405, 0.020203204825520515, 0.07208847999572754, -0.0504358746111393, -0.04380723461508751, 0.01656922698020935, 0.03178843483328819, 0.026596110314130783, -0.03872763738036156, 0.05728743225336075, 0.00012057769345119596, -0.03801700845360756, -0.0017597974510863423, 0.03114408440887928, -0.0029793165158480406, -0.009185914881527424, -0.08636176586151123, -0.02119549922645092, 0.03367982804775238, -0.014571878127753735, 0.035606078803539276, -0.06809807568788528, 0.03389624133706093, 0.030867531895637512, -0.00542430579662323, -0.0076978509314358234, 0.015270526520907879, -0.0427590012550354, 0.03949183225631714, 0.008684458211064339, -0.014600344002246857, 0.00746126240119338, -0.03139539435505867, -0.04758225008845329, -0.024971993640065193, -0.05033940076828003, 0.02595646120607853, -0.0037753554061055183, 0.01328956801444292, -0.0567094124853611, 0.09185296297073364, 0.013801206834614277, -0.00066856958437711, -0.03038541041314602, 0.005003656260669231, -0.0319286473095417, 0.07401309907436371, 0.014175379648804665, 0.022458255290985107, 0.02291049435734749, -0.0007881422061473131, 0.03000802919268608, 0.024193836376070976, 0.06045910343527794, 0.02091260440647602, -0.06830525398254395, -0.02706160768866539, -0.0446738600730896, 0.015686193481087685, 0.03314686566591263, -0.013590686954557896, -0.01808861456811428, -0.034050434827804565, -0.01880931667983532, 0.0041075232438743114, 0.02215447463095188, 0.02121707610785961, 0.02772066928446293, 0.003938615322113037, -0.04553580656647682, -0.013151846826076508, -0.02874566987156868, -0.007015014998614788, 0.014978136867284775, -0.0407811738550663, 0.037224166095256805, 0.019977493211627007, 0.04728173837065697, 0.006712642032653093, -0.03518111631274223, -0.023448778316378593, -0.023776762187480927, 0.004683020059019327, -0.011608648113906384, 0.021344972774386406, 0.03368154540657997, 0.03822346776723862, -0.01634526439011097, 0.07469478249549866, -0.032618798315525055, -0.010671978816390038, 0.005476823076605797, -0.024831118062138557, 0.013333356939256191, -0.002762122778221965, -0.003868265077471733, 0.03210688754916191, -0.006753865629434586, 0.021789899095892906, -0.01401964295655489, -0.03277884051203728, 0.03553547337651253, 0.08015184849500656, 0.00803495291620493, 0.0168780405074358, 0.008681193925440311, 0.020256301388144493, 0.01814848929643631, 0.011108903214335442, -0.0016817704308778048, -0.029403533786535263, 0.015366562642157078, 0.039092760533094406, 0.01569061540067196, -0.022270986810326576, 0.01189597137272358, 0.06189347431063652, 0.007083652075380087, 0.013344253413379192, -0.007732790894806385, -0.010113833472132683, -0.011555814184248447, 0.03738170862197876, 0.026345890015363693, 0.03429409861564636, -0.011515943333506584, 0.011457829736173153, 0.0015916508855298162, 0.04189722239971161, -0.01736186258494854, -0.03097808174788952, 0.047718655318021774, -0.00874944869428873, 0.02543582394719124, -0.01337368693202734, 0.004333616234362125, 0.012561830691993237, -0.0023724278435111046, -0.03748881444334984, 0.018011199310421944, -0.017896918579936028, 0.004636327736079693, 0.012792348861694336, -0.024298153817653656, 0.03548840433359146, 0.02489519491791725, -0.04201004281640053, -0.02141299471259117, 0.03128848969936371, -0.03879959136247635, -0.004848909098654985, -0.021825727075338364, -0.01979098655283451, -0.007770268712192774, -0.0011970230843871832, 0.0409298911690712, 0.0008951948839239776, -0.002090438036248088, 0.0054518370889127254, 0.006707307882606983, 0.00506875803694129, -0.023179100826382637, 0.04680264741182327, -0.023988813161849976, -0.07238047569990158, 0.012333305552601814, -0.00890724640339613, -0.02759273536503315, 0.030917318537831306, 0.017109708860516548, -0.04666411504149437, 0.003200869308784604, -0.03754806891083717, -0.049397893249988556, -0.0353597067296505, -0.0348019115626812, 0.01786116510629654, -0.01820862479507923, -0.021674787625670433, 0.03918763995170593, -0.02297401800751686, -0.016807425767183304, 0.010713704861700535, -0.009631990455091, -0.009621959179639816, -0.05076320841908455, 0.007812939584255219, 0.046722348779439926, 0.009621056728065014, 0.058459557592868805, 0.010562451556324959, 0.01265698205679655, -0.01047941017895937, -0.06611127406358719, -0.053970322012901306, -0.025270093232393265, 0.02506386674940586, 0.05203501135110855, 0.03206983953714371, -0.02394629269838333, 0.02835455909371376, 0.0344785638153553, -0.026212941855192184, -0.025987721979618073, -0.008947004564106464, -0.012055509723722935, 0.0022440729662775993, 0.03654296696186066, 0.02555541694164276, 0.0017203320749104023, 0.06220481917262077, 0.026486236602067947, -0.006543140392750502, 0.04932074248790741, -0.026822736486792564, 0.0003823382721748203, 0.0051701683551073074, -0.010491878725588322, -0.013989057391881943, 0.026263359934091568, -0.007042046170681715, -0.003527503926306963, 0.030204864218831062, 0.029202356934547424, 0.0042078434489667416, 0.005452362354844809, -0.03739771246910095, -0.0016772166127339005, 0.006413326133042574, -0.0063921441324055195, -0.040639687329530716, 0.046805933117866516, 0.010566037148237228, -0.037872884422540665, 0.02828729711472988, 0.031015871092677116, 0.04056759923696518, -0.02980598248541355, 0.0388919934630394, 0.02092154137790203, 0.050039686262607574, -0.03783123940229416, -0.019453370943665504, -0.034171804785728455, -0.015246241353452206, 0.00009967641381081194, -0.022721534594893456, -0.0002830439480021596, 0.02440699189901352, -0.0005484824650920928, 0.02197309583425522, -0.04160492867231369, 0.0020374967716634274, 0.027802716940641403, -0.010586041957139969, -0.0009544037166051567, -0.015002778731286526, 0.06148878484964371, 0.027424102649092674, 0.05053991824388504, 0.007371868472546339, -0.0028618702199310064, -0.021789969876408577, 0.014058551751077175, -0.042729172855615616, 0.038340240716934204, 0.011610315181314945, 0.007901288568973541, -0.03008117340505123, -0.0047996798530220985, 0.036456119269132614, 0.01098671741783619, 0.017884783446788788, 0.030758913606405258, -0.0009416761458851397, -0.022707832977175713, -0.03505455330014229, -0.030640820041298866, -0.033610206097364426, 0.028091104701161385, 0.03998497128486633, 0.022795649245381355, -0.03419404476881027, 0.018511272966861725, 0.00442883325740695, -0.00666650477796793, -0.008806589990854263, 0.0026807861868292093, 0.02149026095867157, 0.043261781334877014, 0.03706314042210579, -0.022317197173833847, 0.04336632043123245, 0.002669051056727767, 0.030020227655768394, -0.008835635147988796, 0.061438389122486115, 0.04695170745253563, -0.03205496445298195, -0.0019033579155802727, -0.023927411064505577, -0.015159042552113533, 0.026662738993763924, 0.04113147407770157, -0.014427565038204193, 0.02831135131418705, 0.05457441508769989, 0.02270231395959854, -0.03513024002313614, 0.031246822327375412, 0.05105351284146309, -0.0028098884504288435, 0.029081305488944054, -0.009091607294976711, 0.030340490862727165, 0.013916664756834507, 0.005985851865261793, 0.020488029345870018, -0.01005933340638876, -0.025369154289364815, -0.014361106790602207, 0.030618317425251007, -0.015273645520210266, -0.04920307546854019, -0.018298078328371048, -0.006595944985747337, 0.024077361449599266, 0.002776729641482234, -0.040325064212083817, 0.015467734076082706, 0.013902781531214714, 0.045305293053388596, 0.025312036275863647, 0.0345967672765255, -0.06964284926652908, 0.009414673782885075, 0.01790725812315941, 0.010808036662638187, -0.029738858342170715, 0.04244676232337952, -0.03452179580926895, -0.0030280768405646086, 0.05247914418578148, -0.04349773749709129, 0.029692137613892555, 0.010337583720684052, 0.0011778590269386768, 0.011525286361575127, -0.031233791261911392, -0.08756699413061142, -0.009803610853850842, -0.03879072517156601, 0.003023655153810978, -0.007772507146000862, 0.03278495743870735, -0.04466988518834114, -0.002706705592572689, 0.015794869512319565, 0.05937330052256584, -0.011902924627065659, -0.042574651539325714, -0.008043631911277771, 0.025559190660715103, -0.010959179140627384, -0.09503557533025742, 0.04817604273557663, -0.01212485134601593, -0.014440950006246567, 0.06479568779468536, -0.030781712383031845, -0.057548537850379944, 0.04021170362830162, 0.0017287544906139374, 0.0028774437960237265, 0.03181108832359314, -0.019570931792259216, 0.04510927200317383, 0.009117139503359795, -0.004041517619043589, 0.04786337912082672, 0.02008083462715149, 0.020649811252951622, 0.0113925626501441, -0.014632422477006912, 0.031108953058719635, -0.04312821850180626, 0.0006363297579810023, -0.041079118847846985, 0.029387135058641434, 0.000014645572264271323, 0.026420310139656067, -0.023563073948025703, -0.007923967204988003, -0.02059418149292469, 0.0015521730529144406, 0.026045000180602074, 0.010828412137925625, 0.008636665530502796, -0.0068065207451581955, -0.00759643130004406, 0.028772424906492233, 0.029806772246956825, -0.010386969894170761, 0.029769031330943108, -0.020649731159210205, 0.045927464962005615, -0.009402446448802948, -0.011215145699679852, 0.010622262954711914, -0.022068126127123833, -0.022722171619534492, -0.016563642770051956, -0.05688677355647087, 0.02079971507191658, -0.014594832435250282, 0.04121173545718193, 0.015287511050701141, -0.014419079758226871, 0.00393891055136919, -0.022785231471061707, 0.02223932556807995, 0.06543201953172684, -0.016514234244823456, -0.01256032008677721, 0.011846817098557949, -0.01511965598911047, -0.0943240150809288, -0.024323871359229088, 0.017758844420313835, -0.00036247388925403357, -0.02759140357375145, -0.06548872590065002, 0.005568681284785271, -0.007723510731011629, 0.009336551651358604, -0.0010859587928280234, 0.033087510615587234, -0.019208654761314392, -0.01558736339211464, 0.0062777092680335045, -0.010821575298905373, 0.07755497097969055, -0.009491067379713058, -0.006260822992771864, 0.006344648078083992, 0.0035502214450389147, -0.03257450461387634, -0.006055033765733242, 0.013775556348264217, -0.019390428438782692, 0.029127493500709534, -0.014753335155546665, 0.01875641942024231, 0.025133144110441208, -0.013730610720813274, -0.028806790709495544, 0.029015829786658287, 0.01238900888711214, 0.00717384647578001, -0.000308261311147362, -0.05090748518705368, 0.0008454566705040634, -0.028864383697509766, -0.017366841435432434, 0.003396266372874379, 0.0006395909585990012, -0.016084760427474976, -0.010877731256186962, -0.047809798270463943, 0.03388810157775879, -0.0010279359994456172, 0.07268594205379486, -0.028874177485704422, 0.008952999487519264, 0.03391510248184204, -0.009648187085986137, 0.02951969765126705, 0.015864020213484764, -0.02218615449965, -0.006241807248443365, -0.009171109646558762, -0.03454070910811424, -0.003987440839409828, -0.056293778121471405, 0.014192593283951283, 0.07782841473817825, 0.0009015488903969526, 0.015879729762673378, 0.031824056059122086, -0.006172058638185263, -0.002482243115082383, 0.011187423951923847, -0.03991078585386276, -0.007401317358016968, -0.0011134962551295757, 0.011089465580880642, 0.00078469148138538, -0.04327847808599472, 0.04923515021800995, 0.004054450895637274, 0.02240270934998989, 0.037418805062770844, 0.01166920829564333, 0.04773876443505287, 0.03924927860498428, -0.0033471581991761923, -0.04028431326150894, 0.014896010980010033, -0.03968774527311325, -0.000025369088689330965, 0.006465991027653217, -0.021860426291823387, 0.06148586422204971, 0.035909462720155716, 0.011585328727960587, -0.042081352323293686, -0.054770443588495255, -0.034960824996232986, 0.012597983703017235, 0.007829035632312298, 0.01823403872549534, 0.030026720836758614, -0.0065049524419009686, 0.033486928790807724, -0.0062120999209582806, 0.05211932584643364, -0.007789017632603645, -0.02606762759387493, -0.015103688463568687, -0.019679009914398193, -0.05125316604971886, 0.01181056909263134, -0.034116365015506744, -0.032206278294324875, -0.0035539008677005768, 0.003742078086361289, -0.02059275470674038, 0.0021636956371366978, 0.02565685473382473, 0.018201295286417007, 0.09909314662218094, 0.03935356065630913, 0.04660268872976303, -0.0266641266644001, 0.0013059118064120412, 0.11107394099235535, 0.025520123541355133, 0.04114778712391853, -0.03398793935775757, -0.004293464124202728, -0.03506932780146599, -0.020426088944077492, -0.05027034506201744, 0.015081655234098434, -0.003857319476082921, 0.0035370008554309607, 0.04044683650135994, 0.048334889113903046, 0.006333146709948778, 0.0006595911690965295, 0.02452022209763527, -0.03138631582260132, -0.024976050481200218, 0.009325820952653885, -0.003846901934593916, -0.020226921886205673, -0.03716094419360161, -0.06230730935931206, 0.017010072246193886, 0.016719823703169823, -0.020154470577836037, -0.04671230539679527, -0.021617187187075615, -0.006086769513785839, -0.009332963265478611, 0.018269145861268044, -0.026041006669402122, 0.01741008460521698, -0.02372734062373638, -0.021785277873277664, -0.013865690678358078, -0.018823692575097084, -0.022496787831187248, 0.03626778721809387, 0.08629343658685684, -0.0073160575702786446, 0.026424413546919823, 0.03561896085739136, -0.007387156598269939, -0.019024822860956192, -0.014080698601901531, -0.0652761310338974, 0.033721525222063065, 0.009001519531011581, 0.0365692563354969, -0.0241194237023592, -0.0014533924404531717, -0.015817791223526, -0.04473405331373215, -0.01784656196832657, 0.03865904361009598, 0.04600159823894501, -0.01115310937166214, -0.044034991413354874, -0.03326645493507385, 0.019854938611388206, 0.014834593050181866, -0.007927590981125832, 0.057720452547073364, -0.07417362183332443, -0.00483049638569355, -0.029558418318629265, 0.04849083721637726, -0.009656073525547981, -0.017708268016576767, -0.013870390132069588, -0.04086571931838989, -0.009589603170752525, -0.010113682597875595, -0.01696493662893772, -0.02088131383061409, 0.0317920446395874, -0.007604203652590513, -0.00916024949401617, -0.006344053894281387, -0.06201833114027977, 0.019145332276821136, -0.016006359830498695, -0.004672555718570948, -0.01204520184546709, -0.008642459288239479, 0.04704488068819046, 0.0025556255131959915, 0.0029250108636915684, 0.01437324658036232, -0.00542851397767663, 0.07118599116802216, 0.010624679736793041, -0.04064510390162468, -0.041285499930381775, 0.026063458994030952, -0.019316712394356728, -0.0120792081579566, -0.008439663797616959, 0.05546814948320389, 0.044376078993082047, -0.00957717839628458, 0.0018149064853787422, 0.015005876310169697, -0.00827696267515421, 0.022464891895651817, -0.024346288293600082, -0.055207572877407074, 0.008420960046350956, 0.02300763502717018, -0.023444518446922302, -0.052119627594947815, -0.05525974556803703, -0.0008243141346611083, -0.018817901611328125, -0.011500705033540726, -0.01600998267531395, 0.005619451869279146, -0.06785254925489426, -0.012487933970987797, 0.029821595177054405, -0.01103778462857008, 0.0037782317958772182, 0.0021803565323352814, 0.009417853318154812, -0.007047772873193026, 0.019178833812475204, -0.05131499469280243, 0.02627229504287243, -0.007472397293895483, -0.022906189784407616, 0.009731455706059933, 0.014444543980062008, 0.04162735864520073, -0.013227111659944057, -0.007964345626533031, 0.0059179626405239105, 0.040930282324552536, 0.02521114982664585, -0.020869925618171692, 0.045272961258888245, -0.038521114736795425, -0.07282374054193497, 0.01453188993036747, 0.042265620082616806, 0.03341925889253616, -0.017659800127148628, 0.017713915556669235, -0.021717889234423637, 0.057820212095975876, -0.02262848988175392, -0.0008168265339918435, -0.03112257458269596, -0.003690221579745412, 0.005689683835953474, -0.0211414135992527, -0.035196609795093536, -0.005474449135363102, 0.029056090861558914, 0.02231696806848049, 0.021461958065629005, -0.01603374071419239, -0.03130237013101578, 0.05135456472635269, 0.013575393706560135, -0.003839212702587247, -0.001543451682664454, -0.005219683982431889, 0.027823396027088165, 0.06181098148226738, 0.00579480966553092, 0.024944202974438667, -0.07226235419511795, 0.01636817492544651, -0.10618507862091064, -0.029281629249453545, -0.02045421674847603, -0.003909453749656677, 0.03199511766433716, -0.05983654037117958, -0.050884392112493515, -0.010859468020498753, -0.01605362258851528, 0.010291178710758686, -0.0019278550753369927, -0.010228793136775494, -0.019230743870139122, 0.0091213034465909, -0.04192567616701126, 0.04736505448818207, -0.004709018860012293, 0.059140902012586594, 0.04258669167757034, 0.002750585088506341, -0.009625374339520931, -0.015598674304783344, -0.015017221681773663, 0.03778071701526642, 0.001096188323572278, -0.062485892325639725, 0.059028469026088715, -0.014151751063764095, -0.01946202851831913, 0.040716249495744705, -0.004455764312297106, -0.006332580931484699, -0.0004007757524959743, 0.024873383343219757, -0.006383715663105249, 0.04400887340307236, 0.00994160957634449, -0.0012674600584432483, 0.011989038437604904, -0.010776380077004433, -0.005076427478343248, 0.009327889420092106, -0.02419792115688324, 0.010490678250789642, 0.07445777952671051, 0.024216458201408386, -0.021851802244782448, 0.01238246913999319, -0.01864445209503174, -0.023983819410204887, -0.0005520705599337816, -0.033667001873254776, 0.0016336919507011771, -0.01794363372027874, 0.07341450452804565, -0.04504264518618584, -0.029903024435043335, -0.012341433204710484, -0.000034005923225777224, -0.0047885961830616, -0.011444955132901669, -0.02634587697684765, -0.05470623821020126, -0.012943552806973457, -0.0024711531586945057, -0.009891029447317123, -0.037916503846645355, -0.0011946435552090406, -0.0017294040881097317, -0.008782451041042805, -0.016335630789399147, -0.04566367343068123, -0.04760109633207321, 0.03752604126930237, 0.014379811473190784, -0.025041652843356133, 0.0011373194865882397, 0.005104009993374348, 0.009839767590165138, -0.04942869767546654, 0.060870856046676636, 0.05551299825310707, -0.06164442002773285, -0.0027914009988307953, -0.0024827381130307913, 0.026141595095396042, 0.022371524944901466, 0.024588098749518394, 0.02968575805425644, -0.011276839300990105, -0.012378199025988579, -0.007057527080178261, 0.03377198427915573, -0.07371515780687332, 0.02967589721083641, -0.020809687674045563, -0.004571845289319754, 0.0025291892234236, 0.01135579776018858, 0.005085865501314402, -0.020818743854761124, -0.009860167279839516, -0.03652752563357353, -0.037395816296339035, -0.017089711502194405, -0.028668809682130814, -0.01904953643679619, -0.02352292463183403, -0.0031719820108264685, 0.044193085283041, -0.010035031475126743, 0.02918274514377117, -0.021795019507408142, 0.015696832910180092, -0.06371213495731354, -0.0061749680899083614, -0.06463082134723663, -0.04472013935446739, -0.015033110976219177, -0.018374674022197723, 0.02703716605901718, -0.03244801238179207, -0.012815614230930805, 0.01927383430302143, -0.09386606514453888, 0.030914433300495148, 0.024952145293354988, 0.05193494260311127, 0.014960624277591705, -0.004434122238308191, -0.003504647873342037, 0.0014225103659555316, -0.012468836270272732, -0.009724457748234272, 0.02658526599407196, 0.025790764018893242, -0.005929875653237104, 0.012225132435560226, 0.016597749665379524, -0.052497442811727524, 0.041600633412599564, 0.009709130972623825, 0.03376144915819168, -0.0188632532954216, -0.004077857825905085, 0.008389494381844997, 0.005852797068655491, -0.025787539780139923, -0.004601775202900171, -0.0068350001238286495, 0.03357868641614914, 0.01664435863494873, 0.0035333451814949512, -0.04113122075796127, -0.014635489322245121, -0.047488100826740265, -0.03790951520204544, 0.0601646713912487, 0.02768830768764019, -0.04622971639037132, 0.022095458582043648, 0.01689770258963108, -0.023883366957306862, 0.03234419971704483, -0.027356019243597984, -0.005354045890271664, 0.009171834215521812, -0.012121033854782581, 0.017217718064785004, -0.02829970233142376, -0.003963859751820564, -0.03150941804051399, 0.03784783184528351, -0.006092455703765154, 0.004857640713453293, 0.01132975798100233, -0.002976266900077462, 0.025387799367308617, 0.11631830036640167, -0.06032666563987732, -0.032901614904403687, -0.07807686179876328, 0.00653918506577611, 0.02046888694167137, 0.0115283178165555 ]
<p>I have difficulty understanding how self organizing maps (SOM) are doing dimensionality reduction. Can anybody provide a useful explanation to me?</p> <p>Suppose we have 20 training data points in 50 dimensions. Let's say, I have specified 3 by 3 SOM (lattice with 9 points), I embed my manifold (3 by 3 lattice) to 50-D space and after the training process, each data point is mapped to one of the 9 points (nodes) in my manifold. Now, my embedded manifold (3 by 3 SOM) are 50-D. So how come I'm back to 2-D dimensions? I mean, where is this non-linear projection?</p>
36,966
[ -0.0013420337345451117, 0.017121803015470505, 0.0022060172632336617, -0.04147414118051529, 0.022855062037706375, -0.007996470667421818, -0.02802444063127041, -0.017802169546484947, 0.03855874016880989, -0.06399771571159363, -0.004613484721630812, 0.01809743605554104, 0.05340208113193512, 0.02727881446480751, -0.0046563297510147095, -0.013668346218764782, -0.04237858206033707, -0.001841148128733039, 0.004209874663501978, 0.0005469381576403975, 0.011930880136787891, 0.0366346649825573, 0.0021099247969686985, 0.0018595881992951035, -0.04371444880962372, 0.043989766389131546, 0.03164461627602577, 0.018794670701026917, 0.047626275569200516, 0.030893927440047264, -0.01319750864058733, -0.008350271731615067, 0.00292012607678771, 0.06204621121287346, -0.0029521228279918432, -0.018603051081299782, -0.018115680664777756, -0.028352998197078705, -0.01985613815486431, -0.0012386610032990575, -0.012996670790016651, -0.02118801139295101, -0.002150919521227479, 0.04755573347210884, -0.02916724979877472, 0.028777865692973137, 0.004988811910152435, -0.005996373947709799, 0.021281743422150612, -0.022534746676683426, 0.11154092848300934, 0.03209196776151657, -0.0033173381816595793, 0.02579287253320217, -0.002883248496800661, 0.02551165409386158, 0.06408943235874176, 0.03179815784096718, 0.0012497607385739684, -0.009035312570631504, -0.04955746605992317, -0.029579365625977516, -0.014012417756021023, -0.04434412345290184, -0.010073622688651085, 0.03732772916555405, -0.0023473866749554873, -0.010463930666446686, 0.04817073792219162, 0.00008067957969615236, -0.016480732709169388, -0.013026545755565166, 0.015432395040988922, -0.029640262946486473, 0.016230368986725807, 0.010223335586488247, -0.0031012047547847033, -0.007576069328933954, 0.024011075496673584, -0.010189782828092575, 0.0057830833829939365, 0.013131010346114635, 0.008733759634196758, 0.027808777987957, 0.014017250388860703, -0.026528919115662575, 0.045213792473077774, -0.018461620435118675, 0.01932510733604431, 0.03851703181862831, 0.0008906005532480776, 0.018180593848228455, 0.033302344381809235, -0.025904273614287376, -0.014156494289636612, 0.03876941278576851, 0.0049614328891038895, 0.040482766926288605, 0.004354739096015692, -0.013862084597349167, -0.021426761522889137, -0.04428800195455551, -0.004090013913810253, 0.01482030563056469, -0.03011016733944416, 0.025186138227581978, -0.017058325931429863, 0.025515753775835037, -0.036776408553123474, -0.0003119638131465763, -0.04606160521507263, -0.02443067356944084, 0.012858235277235508, 0.034861743450164795, 0.038343220949172974, -0.009724472649395466, -0.0006747409352101386, -0.03774957358837128, 0.0016305798199027777, 0.08904077857732773, -0.012265254743397236, -0.006316919811069965, -0.00020207909983582795, -0.020913943648338318, -0.06689565628767014, 0.023542489856481552, 0.00331282545812428, -0.019923456013202667, -0.03454035148024559, 0.023398324847221375, 0.016186194494366646, -0.03426550328731537, 0.020838720723986626, -0.006172840483486652, 0.05266615375876427, 0.00387750961817801, -0.10729687660932541, -0.02616335079073906, 0.0476713702082634, -0.010630112141370773, 0.03144517168402672, -0.07044164836406708, 0.032886162400245667, 0.041539810597896576, 0.045018792152404785, 0.028870854526758194, 0.018688656389713287, 0.055252861231565475, 0.0335884690284729, 0.020155716687440872, -0.020130382850766182, -0.014731188304722309, -0.04333971440792084, -0.01721826381981373, -0.018191488459706306, -0.05609465017914772, 0.03284557908773422, 0.007915329188108444, 0.014371774159371853, -0.039145201444625854, 0.022632015869021416, 0.001881732838228345, -0.0319191999733448, 0.007590045686811209, -0.010858043096959591, -0.05114477127790451, 0.06094999983906746, -0.024980705231428146, 0.0177743099629879, 0.017765581607818604, -0.04448232799768448, 0.024130750447511673, 0.02205013856291771, 0.08681701868772507, 0.028632061555981636, 0.030423928052186966, -0.013729172758758068, -0.007023227401077747, 0.016130996868014336, 0.030116945505142212, -0.04531978443264961, -0.06702075898647308, 0.025251664221286774, 0.022319475188851357, 0.03257809206843376, 0.03051288239657879, -0.008056150749325752, -0.048611417412757874, 0.011726845987141132, -0.039744291454553604, -0.049509644508361816, -0.0837724357843399, 0.033336490392684937, -0.03951013833284378, 0.011964930221438408, 0.019190626218914986, 0.04924224689602852, 0.01704218238592148, -0.0317850224673748, -0.05646231397986412, -0.057748302817344666, -0.004862990230321884, 0.02983933314681053, -0.05293995141983032, 0.0005794930038973689, 0.016254974529147148, 0.02393430843949318, -0.005847030319273472, 0.03876077011227608, -0.02950018271803856, -0.02130884677171707, 0.01320895366370678, 0.00364464009180665, -0.016695642843842506, -0.039178427308797836, -0.041722752153873444, -0.0028831404633820057, 0.013667440973222256, -0.017007166519761086, 0.03075261414051056, -0.035172220319509506, 0.11442301422357559, 0.06890814006328583, -0.025437379255890846, -0.0045575485564768314, 0.01563035137951374, -0.010558250360190868, 0.0299580916762352, -0.0012180599151179194, 0.005379450507462025, -0.02295750379562378, -0.03486091271042824, 0.03090217523276806, 0.05197737738490105, -0.020457817241549492, -0.017793145030736923, 0.0204168614000082, 0.03432576730847359, 0.018387118354439735, 0.036665383726358414, -0.0036285831592977047, -0.001696146558970213, 0.00014300558541435748, -0.0028972323052585125, 0.015826327726244926, 0.005681681912392378, 0.02673150599002838, 0.01145284716039896, 0.018720941618084908, -0.003000074764713645, -0.013090589083731174, 0.0657138004899025, -0.0388825349509716, 0.016708599403500557, -0.0059088412672281265, 0.0016792099922895432, 0.020905176177620888, -0.010500184260308743, -0.012505900114774704, 0.04942663013935089, 0.004186836536973715, 0.018172338604927063, -0.025815440341830254, 0.005062831565737724, 0.008652119897305965, 0.05106963589787483, -0.016382167115807533, 0.007688143290579319, 0.019094396382570267, -0.06013641133904457, -0.010073562152683735, -0.0061820619739592075, -0.008074923418462276, -0.0435657724738121, 0.03514443337917328, 0.046144261956214905, -0.02254006266593933, 0.02495410293340683, -0.02421369031071663, -0.052545446902513504, 0.012988915666937828, -0.00597719568759203, 0.04532609507441521, 0.04545166715979576, -0.04735453054308891, 0.04177148640155792, -0.030837902799248695, -0.0033878085669130087, 0.012784527614712715, -0.007824605330824852, 0.03796948492527008, -0.01871541142463684, -0.02929564379155636, -0.03555460646748543, -0.053013913333415985, -0.02389363944530487, 0.06025053560733795, 0.006203684490174055, -0.0067921909503638744, 0.07570648938417435, 0.016402777284383774, -0.021620063111186028, -0.00507172429934144, -0.021690668538212776, -0.037122681736946106, -0.025563551113009453, -0.010014966130256653, 0.002962412079796195, -0.04243722930550575, -0.032406121492385864, 0.03714176267385483, -0.04419252648949623, -0.003292066976428032, -0.04600858688354492, -0.05370601266622543, -0.008929817005991936, 0.010604150593280792, 0.021206563338637352, 0.014689742587506771, -0.04130520671606064, 0.07635191082954407, 0.014470755122601986, -0.058370232582092285, -0.03447188436985016, 0.02699691243469715, -0.03737828508019447, -0.03462107479572296, 0.02525305189192295, 0.002865828573703766, 0.02092183381319046, 0.03352901712059975, 0.014764307998120785, 0.047795917838811874, 0.09137878566980362, -0.024793555960059166, -0.0256730355322361, 0.006919811014086008, -0.010214597918093204, -0.02158333547413349, 0.010840724222362041, 0.02291771210730076, -0.050686996430158615, 0.015797104686498642, 0.020125512033700943, 0.016088027507066727, 0.015315329656004906, -0.011650776490569115, 0.012818078510463238, -0.042188216000795364, 0.030060619115829468, -0.032048579305410385, 0.015287636779248714, 0.01034532394260168, -0.020969385281205177, 0.0012022701557725668, -0.0012654413003474474, 0.05801565945148468, -0.02373969368636608, -0.01724178157746792, 0.022350825369358063, 0.02228930965065956, -0.019612189382314682, 0.0018967441283166409, 0.00011393232853151858, -0.005963318049907684, 0.001311316154897213, -0.0020998374093323946, -0.011793911457061768, 0.048772457987070084, 0.016918443143367767, 0.020079508423805237, 0.016454538330435753, -0.027838483452796936, 0.02773464098572731, -0.06376967579126358, -0.0043654972687363625, 0.014912647195160389, 0.0688185915350914, -0.01412997581064701, 0.02955087646842003, -0.018601136282086372, 0.02436835505068302, -0.0024316231720149517, 0.006072529591619968, -0.06049766764044762, 0.0006505308556370437, -0.04306073859333992, 0.01477266475558281, -0.003934731241315603, -0.028096511960029602, 0.02941206656396389, -0.021066462621092796, -0.011133803986012936, 0.012870161794126034, 0.01446989644318819, -0.06819717586040497, 0.012500690296292305, -0.011087975464761257, 0.029441986232995987, -0.058657094836235046, 0.02218121849000454, 0.045457322150468826, -0.04361314699053764, 0.009694881737232208, 0.033987440168857574, -0.020463239401578903, -0.00521571421995759, -0.02160399779677391, 0.0030794264748692513, 0.012004053220152855, 0.031706009060144424, 0.008592326194047928, 0.0385824479162693, -0.0166246946901083, 0.026399191468954086, 0.024806518107652664, 0.04029284417629242, 0.014232550747692585, -0.0076592895202338696, 0.0051651932299137115, -0.03766590729355812, -0.0242399200797081, -0.00047443012590520084, 0.05141367018222809, 0.021456046029925346, -0.0109854806214571, 0.030061598867177963, 0.027584629133343697, -0.06190738081932068, 0.03285328671336174, 0.0423165000975132, 0.006459488067775965, -0.03370194882154465, -0.04924878478050232, -0.05692055821418762, -0.02004503645002842, 0.012916834093630314, 0.028782982379198074, -0.04482366517186165, -0.025168931111693382, -0.009792874567210674, 0.021148858591914177, -0.03243569657206535, -0.027954064309597015, -0.010996231809258461, 0.023905672132968903, 0.02897382341325283, -0.008611633442342281, 0.010349051095545292, -0.025583598762750626, 0.05434485897421837, 0.05499689653515816, 0.030262237414717674, -0.0263440553098917, -0.10481920093297958, -0.004834172315895557, 0.03433411568403244, 0.015509878285229206, -0.005007618106901646, -0.009212949313223362, -0.05816766992211342, -0.024924952536821365, 0.03840192034840584, -0.014955708757042885, 0.020702488720417023, 0.033946529030799866, -0.015624717809259892, -0.03934123367071152, -0.005135177168995142, -0.015721092000603676, -0.015132110565900803, -0.011366321705281734, 0.03773308917880058, 0.009697076864540577, -0.019514702260494232, -0.05898255109786987, 0.028536682948470116, 0.0028513700235635042, 0.049265384674072266, -0.001947002368979156, 0.024266419932246208, -0.030518053099513054, 0.036037854850292206, 0.013891621492803097, -0.0624222531914711, 0.039639513939619064, 0.029306387528777122, -0.031034354120492935, 0.051884107291698456, 0.003380115842446685, -0.03604518249630928, 0.022414766252040863, 0.028057878836989403, -0.0021356744691729546, -0.029094180092215538, -0.024357451125979424, 0.05141999572515488, 0.043643806129693985, -0.03299913927912712, 0.04014098271727562, -0.027895700186491013, -0.027761243283748627, 0.004641390405595303, -0.05649220198392868, 0.051652804017066956, -0.019159510731697083, 0.013956677168607712, -0.021941136568784714, 0.016783583909273148, -0.008351746015250683, 0.07031317055225372, 0.01302977092564106, 0.05877458676695824, -0.0010540238581597805, -0.010715055279433727, 0.0015003338921815157, 0.04758801311254501, 0.0016702736029401422, -0.009376689791679382, 0.034409984946250916, 0.035783540457487106, 0.010210474953055382, -0.04573778435587883, -0.012456592172384262, 0.00012453626550268382, 0.00533760990947485, 0.027972368523478508, -0.031054280698299408, -0.011800154112279415, -0.03180716186761856, -0.010233537293970585, 0.028368521481752396, -0.02841627039015293, 0.04786142334342003, -0.03373737260699272, -0.03067670948803425, 0.027475528419017792, -0.07130860537290573, -0.009282917715609074, -0.022123586386442184, -0.014152740128338337, 0.007663443684577942, -0.029981739819049835, 0.027527794241905212, 0.028643211349844933, 0.021492525935173035, -0.07180675864219666, -0.06028036028146744, -0.003521305276080966, -0.011592992581427097, -0.03032359853386879, -0.02234679087996483, -0.002189387334510684, -0.01929021254181862, -0.05817478895187378, 0.020640505477786064, 0.049928151071071625, -0.017818497493863106, -0.001244698534719646, 0.05555269867181778, 0.007284878753125668, 0.029782705008983612, -0.017875542864203453, -0.026948925107717514, -0.009038172662258148, -0.013065425679087639, 0.010662137530744076, -0.01754913106560707, 0.0341574102640152, -0.018858877941966057, -0.0026302074547857046, -0.04309476166963577, -0.008849901147186756, 0.027695726603269577, -0.019015256315469742, -0.00909168180078268, 0.004954701289534569, 0.023084355518221855, 0.02842167764902115, -0.0375659242272377, -0.009925490245223045, 0.022304672747850418, 0.01656784489750862, -0.0011571538634598255, 0.004397841636091471, -0.0033607191871851683, -0.03130004182457924, 0.03817857429385185, 0.018817290663719177, 0.00918232649564743, 0.03649592399597168, 0.02278275601565838, -0.02512756735086441, 0.03925434499979019, -0.013932706788182259, -0.03392849490046501, 0.020660817623138428, 0.015662994235754013, 0.03864651173353195, 0.018206514418125153, 0.013041650876402855, -0.02810736559331417, -0.012593988329172134, -0.011718160472810268, 0.04535064101219177, 0.07845910638570786, -0.009029161185026169, 0.02692456543445587, 0.031576499342918396, -0.012635132297873497, 0.015578935854136944, -0.024890055879950523, -0.007863858714699745, 0.010518034920096397, -0.02807779796421528, 0.051363471895456314, 0.004444022662937641, -0.025857282802462578, 0.006514966953545809, 0.02266637608408928, -0.020885515958070755, 0.04578070342540741, 0.004333809018135071, 0.03239622339606285, 0.03107110597193241, -0.01837119460105896, -0.027968062087893486, 0.03935855254530907, -0.011097089387476444, 0.011854839511215687, 0.007570239715278149, -0.023444166406989098, 0.04866310581564903, 0.019342660903930664, 0.030385812744498253, -0.04637473449110985, -0.0069307866506278515, -0.05330297723412514, 0.00035208265762776136, 0.03027740865945816, 0.005628086160868406, 0.00798132736235857, 0.002639670390635729, 0.014682776294648647, 0.0022068871185183525, -0.0005243215127848089, 0.009445828385651112, -0.03714524209499359, -0.08018779009580612, -0.06521765887737274, -0.011588388122618198, 0.03704468905925751, 0.0030882207211107016, -0.049930933862924576, 0.006026933901011944, -0.0387938916683197, 0.02838478609919548, 0.03288561850786209, 0.03440532460808754, -0.009010961279273033, 0.06249223276972771, 0.02332906238734722, 0.03221049904823303, -0.02360009029507637, -0.0011460032546892762, 0.08840028196573257, 0.07533508539199829, 0.006310879252851009, -0.10198339819908142, 0.019597798585891724, 0.014772968366742134, -0.021949348971247673, -0.03190227970480919, 0.03535478189587593, 0.010306481271982193, 0.015239588916301727, 0.007561310660094023, 0.0710781067609787, -0.013142104260623455, -0.00003059225491597317, 0.031456224620342255, -0.024436363950371742, -0.024311574175953865, 0.00013508339179679751, -0.013278649188578129, -0.006232175976037979, -0.013266092166304588, -0.04743870720267296, 0.02025012858211994, 0.00519075570628047, -0.011317556723952293, 0.00836244784295559, -0.008689628913998604, 0.024015463888645172, -0.02086358144879341, -0.03114878386259079, 0.006625802721828222, -0.007619580719619989, 0.002481309464201331, -0.03360442444682121, 0.05545004457235336, -0.0054910373874008656, -0.02587597630918026, -0.004171600565314293, 0.025318525731563568, 0.009811809286475182, -0.0008005074923858047, -0.02041756920516491, -0.02553405985236168, -0.030695877969264984, -0.07695621997117996, -0.02706114389002323, 0.0636206790804863, -0.028665339574217796, -0.012442562729120255, 0.012064404785633087, 0.01962011680006981, -0.0019092165166512132, -0.03847609460353851, -0.019933179020881653, -0.009759899228811264, 0.027343984693288803, 0.008612943813204765, -0.033652789890766144, -0.03802862390875816, 0.00834054034203291, -0.03566291183233261, 0.04001690447330475, -0.0025851386599242687, 0.006627213209867477, 0.0019314218079671264, -0.007938496768474579, 0.00966951996088028, 0.031084150075912476, 0.0015144753269851208, -0.020062392577528954, 0.024608222767710686, -0.015908559784293175, -0.029971668496727943, -0.0026643923483788967, 0.0033042870927602053, 0.018909893929958344, -0.010886305011808872, -0.04113609716296196, 0.009030274115502834, -0.039390746504068375, -0.011246698908507824, 0.006884297821670771, -0.0009063552133738995, -0.014810800552368164, 0.03038542903959751, 0.021191950887441635, 0.03268728032708168, 0.015741409733891487, 0.012220299802720547, -0.02267790213227272, -0.001430954085662961, 0.004156867507845163, -0.03975267335772514, -0.01544314343482256, 0.03140488266944885, -0.040874820202589035, -0.006925233174115419, 0.013695859350264072, 0.052485592663288116, 0.024880148470401764, 0.0017815224127843976, 0.017598843201994896, 0.07237783819437027, 0.0024496461264789104, -0.010925685055553913, 0.01768989861011505, -0.035790227353572845, 0.04682223126292229, 0.03180217370390892, -0.02604098804295063, -0.056834276765584946, -0.04045899584889412, -0.0047288499772548676, -0.005002481862902641, -0.0018764467677101493, 0.036928847432136536, -0.003262466285377741, -0.022740038111805916, -0.007251442410051823, 0.03115011192858219, -0.011163933202624321, -0.025999458506703377, -0.0425957627594471, 0.017834512516856194, 0.010580937378108501, -0.012663894332945347, -0.0078132851049304, -0.0026799715124070644, -0.011552678421139717, -0.002068758010864258, 0.025987543165683746, 0.020306633785367012, 0.01382652297616005, -0.00986555777490139, 0.008710073307156563, 0.008662296459078789, 0.059896163642406464, -0.025978263467550278, -0.015160365961492062, 0.03439614176750183, -0.040175069123506546, -0.04201940447092056, 0.022017017006874084, -0.041857026517391205, 0.028250135481357574, 0.029628625139594078, -0.004884353838860989, -0.0326167531311512, 0.04867058992385864, -0.02572256699204445, -0.020488247275352478, -0.010334838181734085, -0.025392096489667892, -0.03125911206007004, 0.014607883989810944, 0.02512703463435173, -0.01576639525592327, -0.016208816319704056, 0.014426818117499352, 0.01389169879257679, 0.014069747179746628, -0.024190209805965424, 0.027717921882867813, -0.02325672097504139, 0.005882689729332924, -0.006720985285937786, 0.017069391906261444, 0.002405186416581273, 0.06472828984260559, -0.029095599427819252, 0.03770945593714714, 0.029374081641435623, 0.005146529991179705, -0.09657950699329376, 0.02498128078877926, 0.010305638425052166, 0.0009146556840278208, 0.05775182694196701, -0.080073282122612, 0.005347095895558596, 0.036152876913547516, -0.08061598241329193, 0.008075910620391369, -0.019687127321958542, -0.005775016266852617, -0.02545657381415367, -0.014207943342626095, 0.010535781271755695, 0.02889270707964897, 0.07413125038146973, 0.05160941183567047, 0.007150971330702305, -0.009904220700263977, -0.03050891123712063, 0.003461283165961504, -0.05689254775643349, 0.04714029282331467, -0.048051491379737854, -0.014011659659445286, 0.02764229103922844, -0.04051525518298149, -0.03179943934082985, 0.035874415189027786, -0.02290157787501812, -0.05207405239343643, 0.054237958043813705, -0.0005076455418020487, -0.011477994732558727, -0.0028178622014820576, 0.041117794811725616, -0.025889087468385696, 0.014158189296722412, 0.008492476306855679, 0.038219526410102844, -0.019669100642204285, -0.011871288530528545, 0.011690330691635609, 0.010568725876510143, -0.011099693365395069, 0.0029088351875543594, 0.02401089482009411, -0.003240229096263647, -0.029093757271766663, 0.009575452655553818, -0.0054060532711446285, -0.0001706282637314871, -0.029142973944544792, -0.0038358415476977825, -0.03593941777944565, -0.017915088683366776, -0.0039701820351183414, 0.01917426660656929, -0.025386232882738113, 0.037246886640787125, -0.018511468544602394, -0.06758426874876022, 0.0035858063492923975, 0.02132069692015648, -0.021315643563866615, -0.07096917182207108, 0.011248436756432056, 0.029645051807165146, -0.016663391143083572, 0.010450719855725765, -0.010538585484027863, -0.012000306509435177, 0.07549112290143967, 0.011428063735365868, 0.0771135538816452, 0.024719109758734703, -0.06414896249771118, -0.014053569175302982, -0.0901714339852333, 0.06347063183784485, 0.005555097479373217, -0.03361690416932106, -0.04065178707242012, 0.0162039902061224, -0.01623358577489853, 0.015720244497060776, 0.046911515295505524, 0.005307173356413841, 0.03042379394173622, -0.03164791315793991, 0.03749580681324005, 0.04743359982967377, -0.008196796290576458, 0.005422260146588087, 0.005247538909316063, -0.011896923184394836, 0.003575798822566867, -0.042582638561725616, -0.003968886565417051, 0.024379286915063858, -0.015366693958640099, 0.0033764757681638002, 0.01597451977431774, 0.008239888586103916, -0.008714052848517895, -0.0026301597245037556, 0.028362108394503593, 0.012639161199331284, 0.048557475209236145, -0.00004698485281551257, -0.010447191074490547, 0.02302991971373558, 0.0018954201368615031, -0.04165615886449814, 0.011395227164030075, -0.010570434853434563, 0.0038244822062551975, 0.005304980557411909, 0.008985375985503197, 0.047826316207647324, -0.06130870431661606, -0.01727445051074028, 0.04169327765703201, -0.0001917771005537361, -0.012113657779991627, 0.04053565859794617, 0.00032506618299521506, 0.0003691163728944957, 0.012651961296796799, 0.012064515613019466, 0.02468743361532688, 0.023232363164424896, 0.034416843205690384, 0.0617932453751564, 0.02666434645652771, 0.010243857279419899, 0.024901799857616425, 0.0008009196608327329, -0.03563696891069412, 0.008418799377977848, -0.02748366817831993, 0.06905435025691986, -0.04927113652229309, -0.02154417522251606, 0.015300269238650799, -0.0429953970015049, 0.022983308881521225, 0.007529543712735176, -0.029910694807767868, 0.053191766142845154, -0.035168010741472244, 0.0038688858039677143, -0.04252095893025398, -0.007423055823892355, -0.04086816683411598, -0.0099815484136343, 0.012904041446745396, 0.0568249486386776, -0.004168350715190172, 0.027277318760752678, -0.015347556211054325, -0.0018196841701865196, 0.04125263914465904, -0.0002739985357038677, 0.04210839793086052, 0.0060600582510232925, -0.03382977470755577, 0.004712125286459923, -0.015169493854045868, -0.03227352723479271, -0.02327495813369751, 0.024149274453520775, 0.013426207937300205, 0.01490163616836071, 0.03808159381151199, -0.023741260170936584, -0.005162034649401903, 0.024772683158516884, -0.08703048527240753, -0.024157118052244186, -0.052619148045778275, -0.0038336364086717367, -0.03616210073232651, -0.012773646041750908 ]
<p>Been reading through C.R.Rao's (1975) Simultaneous Estimation of Parameters in Different Linear Models and Applications to Biometric Problems, Biometrics, Vol. 31, No. 2 (Jun., 1975), pp. 545-554.</p> <p>On P550 he notes "that if V (the correlation matrix for the current observations) is unknown then it cannot be completely determined by the "y" observations alone. However if V has suitable structure it may be possible to estimate it. Such problems will be considered in a later paper." Does anyone know what this later paper he is referring to is? The author is pretty prolific so its going to virtually impossible to go through every paper he wrote subsequently (I've tried a few in the years afterwards (that I can get hold of) and so far found nothing.)</p> <p>On p551 he notes "that the computation of the prediction error of (2.39) is complicated", again is he simply noting that the calculation required care because there are more parameters or that additional derivations/calculations are required. It seems like it should be option 1, but it just seems odd for him to mention it.</p> <p>What confuses me is that the Bayesian formulation and Mixed Estimator (Thiel and Goldberger 1961) are equivalent. Under the mixed estimator you take your prior data and estimate the parameters Beta (mean_prior) and variance (sigma_prior) (these are effectively your priors) and estimate your new observations using OLS with the priors as a stochastic restriction. There is no mention of problems estimating the correlation matrix V (of the current observations). Indeed I had hoped to estimate V, by calculating the correlation matrix generated by regressing the current observations on the parameters. However Rao's comment seems to make sense: in the model the current parameters depend on their prior's and so estimation of the current correlation matrix must take this into account!) </p> <p>Happy to post the paper up (So long as it doesn't contravene any rules), really hope to get an answer to this as I am trying to apply precisely these techniques currently.</p>
36,967
[ -0.05797738954424858, -0.030361099168658257, 0.05592532828450203, -0.02496591955423355, 0.052584849298000336, -0.0005141975125297904, -0.028098974376916885, -0.010850124061107635, 0.015895729884505272, -0.057459332048892975, 0.013046042993664742, 0.02848079800605774, 0.10181260854005814, 0.0642094761133194, 0.011362198740243912, -0.017261074855923653, -0.01012058462947607, 0.011687603779137135, -0.015821371227502823, -0.005113639403134584, 0.01455098669975996, 0.0459459163248539, 0.022848285734653473, -0.03215116262435913, -0.00994179118424654, 0.019189074635505676, 0.0039897942915558815, -0.035662904381752014, 0.004600956104695797, 0.05316759645938873, -0.04950002580881119, -0.03414292633533478, 0.042568206787109375, 0.009458954446017742, -0.015142174437642097, -0.025371074676513672, -0.01152721419930458, -0.04901604726910591, -0.008527715690433979, 0.0609784871339798, -0.02756008505821228, 0.00342231965623796, -0.007659207563847303, 0.0364786833524704, 0.001948862336575985, 0.02360810711979866, 0.030447514727711678, -0.02352932281792164, 0.016727179288864136, -0.047250401228666306, 0.12976513803005219, -0.0015892565716058016, 0.011659917421638966, 0.038163233548402786, -0.025183245539665222, 0.03221387788653374, 0.05769144371151924, 0.03471923992037773, -0.0031228838488459587, -0.043554969131946564, -0.0014712197007611394, -0.007258356548845768, 0.020501263439655304, 0.007912685163319111, 0.019008517265319824, -0.003051182022318244, -0.0025186522398144007, -0.03303597867488861, 0.023645438253879547, -0.015820173546671867, 0.03275171294808388, 0.022882698103785515, 0.05008203536272049, 0.008421010337769985, 0.030329998582601547, -0.025599295273423195, -0.020764963701367378, 0.007429847493767738, 0.023616019636392593, 0.000593081524129957, 0.012412328273057938, 0.008751418441534042, 0.029802488163113594, 0.01579206809401512, -0.006380718667060137, -0.05645782873034477, 0.060946084558963776, -0.02749326452612877, 0.02796577475965023, 0.018389761447906494, -0.023823998868465424, 0.0340120866894722, 0.05329233780503273, -0.011178323067724705, -0.092463418841362, 0.0624345988035202, 0.0021171490661799908, 0.06893913447856903, -0.015668705105781555, -0.010526908561587334, 0.01326926052570343, -0.014384173788130283, -0.011990298517048359, 0.06034040078520775, -0.021237347275018692, -0.028418704867362976, 0.014427990652620792, 0.0243520624935627, -0.0035880685318261385, -0.06056227162480354, -0.05274471640586853, 0.040502991527318954, -0.0172794871032238, -0.005372003186494112, -0.026461610570549965, -0.017567630857229233, 0.023044757544994354, -0.010462954640388489, 0.05412599444389343, 0.0678340494632721, 0.0018188883550465107, -0.021203134208917618, 0.007672012783586979, 0.009875289164483547, -0.04114363342523575, 0.013773450627923012, 0.019853971898555756, -0.04474811628460884, -0.06467805057764053, 0.042165614664554596, 0.012580900453031063, -0.026890497654676437, 0.032961051911115646, -0.0010337858693674207, -0.02746574394404888, 0.038761526346206665, -0.07240287959575653, -0.024845639243721962, 0.01449898723512888, -0.006644985172897577, 0.0013683597790077329, -0.09034211933612823, 0.03668438643217087, 0.010375484824180603, 0.06520593166351318, -0.02410626970231533, 0.02467210218310356, 0.026400595903396606, 0.05366215854883194, -0.0009263022220693529, -0.05076605826616287, -0.041559115052223206, -0.016143618151545525, -0.011784365400671959, -0.04092928394675255, -0.05568159371614456, 0.01214629877358675, -0.007664577569812536, -0.023721083998680115, -0.0011113410582765937, 0.03567869961261749, 0.037150368094444275, -0.021404486149549484, -0.01214897632598877, 0.02654643915593624, -0.04053959995508194, 0.057316772639751434, -0.04991656914353371, 0.04238612577319145, 0.010305975563824177, -0.01494572777301073, 0.003930898383259773, 0.0038016370963305235, 0.015489914454519749, 0.06428393721580505, -0.03848222270607948, -0.005494832061231136, -0.007930641062557697, -0.014639288187026978, 0.011845797300338745, -0.02617526613175869, -0.0024816652294248343, -0.0017213046085089445, -0.008778365328907967, -0.0008594976388849318, 0.05907590314745903, -0.0025602616369724274, -0.004730604588985443, 0.0085698077455163, -0.023078685626387596, -0.015927787870168686, -0.09573018550872803, 0.0034602321684360504, 0.002826293697580695, -0.02023162692785263, 0.043323617428541183, -0.0406644381582737, 0.004815067630261183, 0.04652591422200203, -0.0381445437669754, -0.030265647917985916, 0.0036740354262292385, 0.07360832393169403, -0.0014497708762064576, 0.030805477872490883, 0.040733885020017624, 0.04230548068881035, -0.0038678778801113367, 0.030045662075281143, -0.0050358944572508335, -0.05821128562092781, 0.015530220232903957, -0.022869426757097244, 0.03469535708427429, -0.006570316385477781, -0.007637441158294678, 0.009093966335058212, -0.008967400528490543, -0.009662141092121601, 0.006706680171191692, -0.045691464096307755, 0.014538928866386414, 0.031126800924539566, 0.020653709769248962, -0.006866922602057457, 0.054271552711725235, 0.021348409354686737, 0.010499234311282635, -0.024969464167952538, -0.01041653472930193, -0.012147887609899044, -0.002250031800940633, 0.012716496363282204, 0.022450590506196022, -0.027491917833685875, 0.03130001202225685, 0.04235967621207237, 0.011965857818722725, 0.0032762261107563972, 0.02438458614051342, 0.008570894598960876, -0.03700965270400047, 0.005566614679992199, -0.016800932586193085, -0.010183568112552166, 0.009372691623866558, -0.009668991900980473, -0.02684110589325428, 0.036813169717788696, -0.005018535070121288, -0.013803823851048946, 0.03430485352873802, -0.010254214517772198, 0.012115181423723698, -0.03288237005472183, -0.032349612563848495, 0.0686686709523201, -0.027772484347224236, 0.0008472653571516275, 0.03387051448225975, 0.015208066441118717, -0.021882755681872368, 0.0059210448525846004, 0.0050067356787621975, 0.04080331698060036, 0.060305844992399216, -0.059229347854852676, 0.0023673593532294035, -0.004522175528109074, -0.04192475229501724, 0.017230739817023277, -0.01511965598911047, -0.003926147241145372, -0.007009084802120924, 0.04299350827932358, -0.0003635481116361916, 0.0015818625688552856, 0.028837259858846664, -0.0385180339217186, -0.041929855942726135, -0.006967201828956604, 0.0006480275187641382, 0.01753809303045273, -0.004938499070703983, -0.06892486661672592, -0.03349588066339493, -0.005955501459538937, -0.010662354528903961, -0.01178736798465252, -0.035873256623744965, -0.02625780552625656, 0.014293397776782513, -0.030976861715316772, -0.04664906486868858, -0.06815565377473831, -0.0036576532293111086, -0.0059065865352749825, 0.008952423930168152, -0.01862533949315548, 0.030321024358272552, 0.025946635752916336, -0.0030860283877700567, 0.0145075973123312, -0.032233577221632004, -0.04772810637950897, -0.004405537620186806, -0.017383689060807228, -0.01139810960739851, -0.016227299347519875, 0.019896309822797775, 0.023362793028354645, -0.004676382057368755, -0.01239303033798933, -0.08271033316850662, -0.05820102244615555, 0.04036596789956093, 0.005283873062580824, 0.025596827268600464, 0.009529348462820053, 0.0057935877703130245, 0.05815311148762703, -0.009672743268311024, -0.04764071851968765, -0.04372939094901085, 0.0077879647724330425, -0.028937723487615585, -0.030662482604384422, 0.009813458658754826, 0.02922862581908703, 0.0035988111048936844, 0.050465166568756104, 0.0017914163181558251, -0.0055883522145450115, 0.06483161449432373, 0.009242621250450611, -0.0011919260723516345, 0.027898918837308884, -0.019598286598920822, -0.00871103722602129, 0.031939707696437836, -0.012077510356903076, 0.012513850815594196, 0.004343008156865835, 0.004323751199990511, 0.02221893146634102, 0.023514946922659874, -0.0406668446958065, -0.0077261896803975105, -0.009159920737147331, 0.007928225211799145, -0.03196931257843971, 0.038763608783483505, 0.034393422305583954, -0.034734372049570084, -0.025418102741241455, 0.020751794800162315, 0.045735329389572144, -0.015586414374411106, 0.035793013870716095, 0.042996808886528015, 0.02247871272265911, 0.020941004157066345, 0.008620049804449081, 0.030853115022182465, -0.004536342807114124, 0.011037292890250683, -0.02676467038691044, -0.02381623536348343, 0.029093680903315544, 0.002038954058662057, 0.0033090440556406975, 0.007484365254640579, -0.038317255675792694, -0.022813212126493454, -0.06286188960075378, 0.017518170177936554, -0.04542102292180061, 0.031176231801509857, 0.0031662762630730867, 0.011882362887263298, 0.008377735503017902, -0.01188563834875822, 0.015498862601816654, 0.02061459794640541, -0.07519102096557617, -0.02630903385579586, 0.008534504100680351, -0.022931871935725212, 0.035241641104221344, -0.03128315135836601, 0.03994766250252724, -0.030086176469922066, -0.027618177235126495, -0.03992357850074768, 0.007590832654386759, -0.04288902506232262, 0.018635595217347145, -0.04309511184692383, -0.007229262497276068, 0.010523343458771706, 0.012994491495192051, 0.007840466685593128, -0.028467923402786255, 0.012323681265115738, 0.04219115898013115, -0.012661409564316273, -0.022346874698996544, -0.004604435060173273, 0.016471676528453827, 0.0008078659302555025, 0.04462174326181412, 0.015884054824709892, 0.014612781815230846, -0.02586548775434494, 0.00996585562825203, 0.015918198972940445, 0.058038417249917984, 0.0812830924987793, -0.013649523258209229, -0.01539035327732563, 0.006939329672604799, -0.02640656754374504, 0.009614242240786552, 0.012336688116192818, 0.0011351489229127765, 0.004550167825073004, 0.0567365400493145, 0.02453620359301567, -0.03205369412899017, 0.021383725106716156, 0.06974739581346512, 0.03958076983690262, 0.01141035184264183, -0.006724067963659763, -0.019390596076846123, -0.006410082336515188, 0.010870722122490406, 0.026672717183828354, 0.031990304589271545, -0.003320005489513278, -0.008470493368804455, 0.035723574459552765, -0.0433347150683403, -0.0013363143661990762, 0.03787410259246826, 0.04723450541496277, 0.044918786734342575, -0.010896806605160236, -0.0362442322075367, 0.02683517150580883, 0.05162249132990837, 0.02513899840414524, 0.0125268017873168, 0.013942072167992592, -0.06151862069964409, -0.020527396351099014, 0.030455559492111206, 0.04181208461523056, -0.044155605137348175, 0.003921635914593935, -0.05039030686020851, -0.04198601841926575, 0.01583719626069069, 0.021509582176804543, 0.03495870530605316, -0.012798269279301167, -0.04651978239417076, 0.017761247232556343, -0.04030672088265419, -0.04932194948196411, -0.01630566455423832, -0.008132917806506157, 0.035854510962963104, -0.009845418855547905, -0.04437196999788284, 0.010509876534342766, 0.025615498423576355, 0.01093562226742506, 0.031576670706272125, 0.012788519263267517, -0.0048431395553052425, 0.013689309358596802, 0.032188959419727325, -0.0167615357786417, -0.05014697462320328, 0.019290870055556297, 0.02842610515654087, -0.04450851306319237, 0.04715801030397415, -0.03145255893468857, -0.0300640556961298, 0.0394115224480629, -0.0008028714219108224, -0.025186628103256226, 0.015443312004208565, -0.014606259763240814, 0.07028744369745255, 0.03157717362046242, -0.0007101515657268465, 0.04777025431394577, -0.01540376991033554, -0.010113174095749855, -0.013235417194664478, -0.030041521415114403, -0.005890145432204008, -0.03091941587626934, -0.01284635066986084, -0.03883408010005951, 0.027900202199816704, 0.003670469857752323, 0.04947793111205101, -0.015596534125506878, 0.04991656914353371, -0.022016597911715508, -0.021926118060946465, 0.01348868664354086, 0.0022353697568178177, -0.04997395724058151, 0.007494674064218998, -0.005806022323668003, 0.049065206199884415, -0.01638224720954895, 0.01567653752863407, 0.01692163571715355, -0.020766671746969223, 0.0042029558680951595, 0.012059993110597134, -0.023148834705352783, 0.006352762226015329, -0.0012527236249297857, -0.028754228726029396, 0.03045709989964962, 0.015391289256513119, 0.05578187480568886, -0.003355054883286357, 0.04441153258085251, 0.032614901661872864, -0.030387209728360176, -0.008653351105749607, 0.00803217664361, -0.028291990980505943, 0.03500610962510109, -0.024081949144601822, 0.033330902457237244, -0.02212877944111824, -0.014754350297152996, -0.03231627494096756, -0.010502264834940434, 0.0245245099067688, -0.010802295058965683, -0.014707328751683235, -0.043567363172769547, 0.025218416005373, -0.018262600526213646, -0.03980664908885956, -0.006321810185909271, 0.017142046242952347, 0.010173858143389225, 0.010371767915785313, -0.0056423889473080635, 0.07299013435840607, 0.06875783950090408, -0.011358397081494331, 0.00791565328836441, 0.012839669361710548, -0.01132699754089117, -0.016753775998950005, 0.0015794861828908324, 0.026308711618185043, -0.04089541360735893, 0.025460034608840942, -0.0017874962650239468, 0.013816028833389282, 0.07214920967817307, 0.00527887511998415, -0.0032639517448842525, 0.027209894731640816, 0.00752786360681057, 0.01678244024515152, 0.00466112419962883, 0.011147389188408852, -0.017410883679986, 0.013583017513155937, -0.01339149009436369, -0.007838305085897446, -0.010950426571071148, -0.017383361235260963, 0.03332206606864929, 0.0005683662602677941, -0.0401989221572876, -0.018653983250260353, 0.054852165281772614, 0.017265627160668373, -0.0003333026834297925, 0.03952877223491669, 0.0008827337878756225, 0.05092260614037514, 0.0005863473634235561, 0.025238124653697014, 0.03882381319999695, 0.008274589665234089, -0.025511223822832108, -0.05540452525019646, -0.048427022993564606, 0.03389846533536911, 0.08459354192018509, -0.0008893561316654086, 0.04487205296754837, 0.019773589447140694, -0.0054593272507190704, -0.02024357207119465, -0.029449300840497017, -0.02002696879208088, -0.015848485752940178, -0.03315017372369766, 0.025213968008756638, -0.03188587352633476, -0.006397834978997707, 0.023956427350640297, 0.015473403036594391, 0.032743100076913834, 0.04968292638659477, 0.015734145417809486, 0.011498898267745972, 0.02588362991809845, -0.04177011922001839, -0.008441322483122349, 0.020517481490969658, -0.03303854539990425, -0.011152263730764389, -0.021308135241270065, -0.02306564338505268, 0.02748594805598259, 0.05914270505309105, 0.028980592265725136, -0.04923015460371971, -0.02788221649825573, -0.030722061172127724, 0.028849104419350624, 0.006706831511110067, -0.005659791640937328, 0.04471591114997864, -0.03308071568608284, 0.04462827369570732, 0.008767995983362198, 0.034539610147476196, -0.06238546594977379, -0.07950189709663391, -0.03105311468243599, -0.0392116904258728, -0.008289940655231476, 0.05874679982662201, 0.02013642154633999, -0.017184581607580185, -0.005449050106108189, -0.03248341754078865, 0.013129974715411663, 0.008644144050776958, 0.05750653147697449, -0.020213788375258446, 0.092980295419693, 0.004382019396871328, 0.01450909860432148, -0.021491125226020813, 0.03347613289952278, 0.10195519775152206, 0.08684659749269485, 0.036592915654182434, -0.05435230955481529, 0.052937861531972885, -0.017764942720532417, 0.0036263507790863514, -0.04841485992074013, 0.033212810754776, -0.006958807818591595, -0.016888214275240898, -0.003475836245343089, 0.04388788715004921, 0.020951038226485252, -0.038505252450704575, 0.013059686869382858, -0.01955326832830906, -0.03548576310276985, 0.02184431254863739, -0.012301990762352943, -0.006385431624948978, -0.0011309627443552017, -0.007862948812544346, -0.0013818959705531597, 0.007324371486902237, -0.04965508356690407, -0.034996408969163895, -0.004421501886099577, 0.02887662500143051, 0.01049965899437666, 0.01022869348526001, -0.007383419666439295, 0.025442494079470634, 0.022957010194659233, -0.019821932539343834, -0.020750170573592186, 0.001543717342428863, -0.004862148314714432, 0.041860181838274, 0.07251932471990585, -0.009722601622343063, 0.00850983988493681, 0.018932117149233818, -0.02492273971438408, -0.028758715838193893, -0.04300249367952347, -0.03655071556568146, 0.05728704482316971, -0.0011889435118064284, -0.01791572943329811, 0.0012210945133119822, -0.035839058458805084, -0.016029205173254013, -0.05997253209352493, -0.015060961246490479, 0.026140563189983368, 0.010927527211606503, -0.02947872318327427, -0.024791838601231575, -0.044943228363990784, -0.005697737913578749, 0.023613085970282555, 0.026490211486816406, 0.01805783249437809, -0.03314743936061859, -0.03139088302850723, -0.04561733454465866, 0.061316315084695816, 0.01831185817718506, 0.0029100291430950165, -0.015741167590022087, -0.011665615253150463, -0.04374917596578598, -0.044013213366270065, 0.025445185601711273, 0.0029373636934906244, 0.01831691712141037, -0.03224769979715347, 0.0012230697320774198, -0.0060227359645068645, -0.05467468872666359, -0.007543995976448059, 0.005524962674826384, -0.027840113267302513, -0.013104627840220928, 0.028038550168275833, 0.03223016858100891, 0.02141043357551098, 0.0008700538892298937, -0.027629641816020012, -0.021770140156149864, 0.052279114723205566, 0.023202095180749893, -0.05567163601517677, -0.015710540115833282, -0.018565654754638672, -0.011174960993230343, 0.005120878107845783, 0.016745148226618767, 0.010346799157559872, 0.03151514753699303, 0.06370091438293457, -0.0005394141771830618, 0.0334809385240078, 0.003439764492213726, -0.0037378943525254726, 0.017477624118328094, -0.03873826190829277, 0.005194511264562607, -0.01687389239668846, 0.012494072318077087, 0.011643028818070889, -0.01682295650243759, -0.031238604336977005, -0.028476709499955177, -0.007841045036911964, -0.016656270250678062, -0.06816092878580093, 0.007111184764653444, -0.025920238345861435, -0.031765300780534744, -0.005656213499605656, 0.009988071396946907, 0.01889583095908165, 0.04833739250898361, -0.030288876965641975, 0.02507774904370308, 0.004944123327732086, 0.03897680714726448, -0.022688835859298706, -0.020917735993862152, 0.053093865513801575, -0.003247014945372939, 0.008778763934969902, -0.021863915026187897, -0.030834699049592018, 0.04066196456551552, 0.052548088133335114, -0.016126615926623344, -0.00964135117828846, 0.01103312335908413, -0.0340372696518898, -0.034227535128593445, 0.015023873187601566, -0.005020733457058668, 0.021716700866818428, -0.0012045528274029493, 0.013879583217203617, -0.04268619790673256, 0.05156170576810837, -0.05583098903298378, 0.015851642936468124, -0.013476470485329628, 0.034552693367004395, -0.015732089057564735, 0.0013298291014507413, -0.0032829141709953547, 0.04313427209854126, 0.0021220070775598288, 0.02964165061712265, -0.006669487338513136, -0.03308076038956642, 0.0070211514830589294, 0.008424426428973675, -0.014373458921909332, -0.027892913669347763, -0.015429074876010418, -0.01395092997699976, 0.013714171946048737, 0.06258513033390045, -0.014896044507622719, 0.039858974516391754, -0.0033830301836133003, 0.01251064520329237, -0.085160031914711, 0.0026205619797110558, 0.020968740805983543, 0.04992549493908882, 0.030003966763615608, -0.0415671244263649, 0.013673863373696804, 0.04174531251192093, -0.04982855170965195, -0.03340541198849678, 0.02110542170703411, -0.0016196774085983634, -0.04561108350753784, 0.04252467676997185, -0.048370610922575, 0.015389988198876381, 0.0026333823334425688, -0.00203160522505641, 0.03401681408286095, 0.031708478927612305, 0.028631793335080147, -0.040651947259902954, -0.021071571856737137, 0.0052963136695325375, 0.002554916776716709, -0.05335157737135887, 0.05174632370471954, -0.035353414714336395, -0.024892957881093025, 0.03965321555733681, 0.007038616109639406, 0.03840150311589241, -0.008288375101983547, 0.052310049533843994, 0.030325189232826233, 0.016910932958126068, 0.052328921854496, 0.016706865280866623, 0.02169320173561573, -0.0168840941041708, -0.025363469496369362, -0.00009349398169433698, -0.009733127430081367, 0.009399596601724625, -0.011740258894860744, -0.0054570953361690044, -0.03692642226815224, -0.030734742060303688, -0.04749061167240143, 0.006145224440842867, 0.013959298841655254, -0.009304064325988293, -0.009369933977723122, -0.01838560774922371, 0.03424880653619766, -0.04498244449496269, -0.0027634333819150925, 0.029563168063759804, 0.027608519420027733, -0.005501388106495142, 0.024119948968291283, -0.027596544474363327, -0.03179571405053139, 0.011304325424134731, -0.04246228188276291, -0.016896435990929604, -0.06582491844892502, -0.014417178928852081, 0.029958628118038177, -0.018376270309090614, -0.027495892718434334, -0.008701147511601448, -0.043420515954494476, 0.037117063999176025, -0.017634747549891472, 0.0067091952078044415, 0.01847306825220585, -0.006003187038004398, -0.011320634745061398, -0.0642002522945404, 0.06582078337669373, -0.016366997733712196, -0.024335339665412903, -0.016843833029270172, -0.017911328002810478, -0.042461737990379333, 0.007279741112142801, 0.044855862855911255, -0.018276628106832504, 0.007509751711040735, -0.011319473385810852, 0.03678553178906441, -0.007519118022173643, -0.043259236961603165, 0.04420871287584305, 0.017827175557613373, 0.0025666134897619486, -0.04214448854327202, -0.042121391743421555, 0.004578429274260998, -0.004782233387231827, 0.014053710736334324, -0.052525270730257034, 0.012724015861749649, 0.026028525084257126, -0.011438600718975067, -0.009298437274992466, 0.03281880170106888, 0.009459659457206726, 0.038986094295978546, -0.010780375450849533, 0.02351413667201996, 0.03362520411610603, 0.010515054687857628, -0.08604150265455246, 0.02225819043815136, -0.01564706861972809, -0.02434956096112728, -0.004456174094229937, 0.015475182794034481, -0.008033203892409801, -0.04471807926893234, 0.024121079593896866, 0.02836822345852852, -0.028414327651262283, -0.0037923576310276985, 0.03646063059568405, 0.015558854676783085, 0.03657526895403862, 0.022477639839053154, 0.014295585453510284, 0.017407672479748726, -0.04237198829650879, -0.025834260508418083, 0.03241043910384178, 0.08696262538433075, -0.012063263915479183, -0.01265660673379898, 0.062098775058984756, -0.00947682186961174, 0.04646258056163788, -0.023900985717773438, 0.0009566778317093849, -0.08451400697231293, 0.007568874396383762, -0.018005963414907455, -0.006028114818036556, 0.006118294317275286, -0.02184545062482357, 0.0027649591211229563, 0.061449892818927765, -0.04361901432275772, -0.01199417281895876, -0.01888238824903965, -0.03639458492398262, -0.05237821862101555, 0.01727035455405712, 0.024486323818564415, 0.006591674871742725, 0.0034246582072228193, 0.0285484679043293, -0.04917703941464424, -0.01244086492806673, 0.022091757506132126, -0.03774530440568924, -0.03004596382379532, -0.0013972943415865302, -0.0035278492141515017, 0.005243759136646986, -0.020835191011428833, -0.021185489371418953, -0.0009548553498461843, 0.03361523896455765, 0.020581912249326706, 0.020665600895881653, -0.04877297580242157, -0.0352633036673069, 0.02100612036883831, 0.03155859187245369, -0.04844638705253601, -0.012113260105252266, -0.04171905294060707, 0.024222811684012413, -0.025999994948506355, -0.00990536529570818 ]
<p>I have a dataset containing $p$ variables (or columns) denoted by $X_i$ for $i=1,...,p$. I am trying to cluster this dataset using <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-organizing_map" rel="nofollow">Self-Organizing Map</a>. There are 3 main variables within these $p$ variables say $X_1$, $X_2$ and $X_3$. The rest of the variables (i.e $p-3$ of them) can be obtained by applying some functions on $X_1$, $X_2$ and $X_3$. In other words, by observing $X_1$, $X_2$ and $X_3$, I can actually recover $X_i$ for $i=3,5,...,p.$ Now my question: </p> <p>Q: Shall I apply the Self-Organizing Map on the whole dataset containing all the $p$ variables ( i.e. $X_i$ for $i=1,...,p$) or would it be better to just consider $X_1$, $X_2$ and $X_3$ when using the Self-Organizing Map? Is there any reference that can answer this question?</p>
36,968
[ -0.04165768250823021, 0.011646856553852558, -0.01606759801506996, -0.014204252511262894, 0.0279620960354805, -0.014246078208088875, -0.024878699332475662, -0.018483510240912437, 0.009378301911056042, -0.048994943499565125, 0.00424141576513648, 0.033561911433935165, 0.04777850955724716, 0.011491750366985798, 0.02794538624584675, -0.004212298430502415, -0.03175175189971924, 0.007721598260104656, 0.0007817748701199889, 0.0027657197788357735, 0.00024360264069400728, 0.014895344153046608, -0.03050437569618225, -0.023837845772504807, -0.01658802479505539, 0.0476655587553978, -0.019408438354730606, -0.0005540695274248719, 0.027888910844922066, 0.02579631842672825, 0.0001503400708315894, -0.009742951951920986, 0.009084830991923809, 0.05518614500761032, 0.006765242200344801, 0.011977494694292545, -0.006556553300470114, -0.020322125405073166, -0.022006500512361526, -0.013052388094365597, -0.04181506484746933, -0.006711328402161598, 0.007052931934595108, -0.001846526050940156, -0.017195237800478935, 0.02403300628066063, -0.009077268652617931, -0.031265757977962494, -0.02834705077111721, -0.05108673870563507, 0.11540485918521881, 0.014630034565925598, 0.0024903451558202505, 0.027702977880835533, -0.002640823135152459, -0.005174689460545778, 0.06596359610557556, 0.04827447980642319, -0.006031174678355455, -0.031505074352025986, -0.030543016269803047, 0.012841242365539074, -0.0073316143825650215, -0.07662370800971985, -0.06342356652021408, 0.030732888728380203, 0.02348007634282112, -0.010040387511253357, 0.06465914100408554, -0.006990921217948198, -0.010560190305113792, 0.011256742291152477, 0.04329539090394974, -0.006857349071651697, 0.01948709785938263, -0.006878192536532879, 0.010776523500680923, -0.007591373287141323, 0.021326953545212746, -0.0003466725174803287, 0.030428072437644005, 0.007811079267412424, 0.013962865807116032, 0.011120439507067204, 0.015344384126365185, -0.011778125539422035, 0.03862398490309715, -0.034075405448675156, 0.025231657549738884, 0.009389946237206459, -0.040059495717287064, 0.014757940545678139, 0.026143068447709084, 0.002490351675078273, -0.04248857870697975, 0.03976133093237877, -0.0012764717685058713, 0.037072278559207916, -0.005623724777251482, -0.0021846352610737085, -0.013231515884399414, -0.07332736253738403, -0.028362957760691643, 0.041649676859378815, -0.03430555760860443, 0.006383492145687342, -0.03017537295818329, 0.018056420609354973, -0.04822452366352081, -0.036695197224617004, 0.01235490757972002, 0.007875462993979454, -0.0002495963126420975, -0.0034484893549233675, 0.045737676322460175, -0.029014071449637413, 0.0149457436054945, -0.02078949101269245, -0.012563603930175304, 0.08250582963228226, 0.018230129033327103, -0.027753837406635284, 0.00166997779160738, -0.024970589205622673, -0.0573197640478611, 0.01569269225001335, -0.0036741357762366533, -0.018705198541283607, -0.05279700085520744, 0.0243584755808115, 0.015147109515964985, -0.036436326801776886, 0.05693960189819336, -0.005549856927245855, 0.029479969292879105, -0.015248134732246399, -0.0991189256310463, 0.007377495989203453, 0.0050328983925282955, -0.060248371213674545, 0.0519183985888958, -0.047349896281957626, 0.022177772596478462, 0.029899558052420616, 0.039083823561668396, 0.005176162347197533, 0.007400002796202898, 0.01522582583129406, 0.0490855798125267, 0.015456280671060085, -0.032137349247932434, -0.010472266934812069, -0.01611466519534588, -0.06155766546726227, -0.025751087814569473, -0.060231663286685944, 0.04887866601347923, 0.02716970257461071, 0.01916119083762169, -0.0019022064516320825, 0.053196705877780914, 0.03385980799794197, 0.023108908906579018, -0.007170862052589655, 0.00827022548764944, -0.018689677119255066, 0.03761936351656914, -0.0026554730720818043, 0.04602159559726715, -0.0071043032221496105, -0.012769274413585663, 0.044046759605407715, 0.015737472102046013, 0.05246299132704735, 0.0784974992275238, 0.008973751217126846, -0.010987911373376846, 0.0037704184651374817, 0.04745721071958542, 0.034922026097774506, -0.028582073748111725, -0.010755036026239395, 0.007555194199085236, 0.018726160749793053, 0.0016429128590971231, 0.0357692576944828, 0.006492946296930313, -0.037480369210243225, 0.045554954558610916, -0.0341891311109066, -0.011095980182290077, -0.03199997544288635, 0.013065651059150696, -0.0279189832508564, -0.005757041275501251, 0.051988545805215836, 0.0013057455653324723, 0.003948385827243328, 0.04227418825030327, -0.03731729835271835, -0.03819024935364723, 0.014221705496311188, 0.05711113661527634, -0.06996419280767441, -0.025152530521154404, 0.0164203979074955, 0.01416272297501564, 0.0007188135641627014, 0.05178238824009895, -0.05366048589348793, -0.028624258935451508, 0.012464146129786968, -0.00003604506127885543, 0.004647733177989721, -0.009382260031998158, 0.008117091841995716, 0.014391791075468063, 0.019680600613355637, -0.009531654417514801, 0.031343068927526474, -0.05972311645746231, 0.0905056893825531, 0.05931137502193451, 0.02429569885134697, 0.013565294444561005, -0.02004406787455082, 0.01408965140581131, 0.03802347928285599, 0.02019292488694191, 0.009335938841104507, -0.056178849190473557, 0.0037441689055413008, 0.023939097300171852, 0.03692316263914108, -0.04344487935304642, 0.01747884415090084, 0.026170579716563225, 0.03282938152551651, -0.0021939256694167852, 0.02835565246641636, -0.017691273242235184, -0.0069472710601985455, -0.010202684439718723, 0.027637366205453873, -0.002399659249931574, 0.006817244458943605, 0.01783006638288498, 0.014372041448950768, 0.03719848394393921, 0.023557256907224655, 0.0009062644094228745, 0.04614916071295738, -0.03307750076055527, -0.0026599084958434105, 0.005084003787487745, -0.009228900074958801, 0.02766849845647812, -0.01898004673421383, -0.00758022116497159, 0.03914799913764, 0.012604649178683758, -0.008053814060986042, 0.016230624169111252, -0.022194398567080498, 0.0001949468714883551, 0.05780349299311638, -0.067597396671772, 0.010939335450530052, -0.0004157688526902348, -0.04456435516476631, 0.003856122028082609, -0.017506495118141174, -0.0234331414103508, -0.044192880392074585, 0.02504957839846611, 0.03936934843659401, -0.01863141916692257, 0.0374143086373806, -0.013553713448345661, -0.0003494643606245518, 0.01525195874273777, 0.016342218965291977, 0.043504346162080765, 0.036237508058547974, -0.0815395712852478, -0.007587762083858252, -0.023922478780150414, -0.021686917170882225, 0.01138050016015768, -0.008910726755857468, -0.004130907356739044, -0.0027063998859375715, -0.03130288049578667, -0.025909852236509323, -0.005900740623474121, -0.04655502736568451, 0.03689140826463699, -0.01915457658469677, -0.039163947105407715, 0.040222812443971634, 0.0462379977107048, -0.0266791470348835, -0.028901956975460052, -0.04819754138588905, -0.06237819418311119, -0.02317032776772976, 0.028369929641485214, 0.009064598008990288, -0.015215469524264336, 0.0033240560442209244, 0.038902293890714645, -0.02795613370835781, 0.004461267031729221, -0.06487946212291718, -0.0879923477768898, 0.018713708966970444, -0.005666283890604973, 0.0018388465978205204, 0.0029103930573910475, -0.044048890471458435, 0.10790644586086273, 0.03259454667568207, -0.06080164760351181, -0.02427126094698906, -0.005821376573294401, -0.04153497517108917, -0.03604985028505325, 0.004748478066176176, 0.01554233580827713, 0.021040696650743484, 0.0073292977176606655, 0.004104559309780598, 0.04793138429522514, 0.07391119003295898, -0.018884126096963882, -0.02807747572660446, 0.04378560185432434, -0.002452814020216465, -0.006308837793767452, 0.030411701649427414, 0.004879450891166925, -0.014895476400852203, 0.02391722798347473, -0.008695276454091072, 0.003919532056897879, -0.0008952165953814983, -0.01104716770350933, 0.016106514260172844, -0.015438484959304333, 0.02547936700284481, -0.00566425547003746, 0.01770513504743576, 0.021286895498633385, -0.022288111969828606, 0.01128208264708519, 0.03424668684601784, 0.027604984119534492, -0.03209548443555832, -0.00421532616019249, 0.06939318776130676, 0.028028933331370354, -0.022880394011735916, -0.02256033942103386, 0.017199017107486725, -0.037640538066625595, 0.01855468936264515, -0.0062630390748381615, -0.014008775353431702, 0.0033040903508663177, 0.02974548563361168, 0.030630428344011307, 0.007703746668994427, -0.010805982165038586, 0.05642782151699066, -0.10203370451927185, -0.0007797954021953046, -0.01657211035490036, 0.05975058674812317, -0.005397936794906855, 0.03996235132217407, 0.017550736665725708, -0.013329025357961655, -0.011032836511731148, 0.027306728065013885, -0.06266287714242935, -0.003967212978750467, -0.00850450899451971, 0.014603456482291222, -0.025651847943663597, -0.032619643956422806, 0.05632526054978371, -0.0034628056455403566, 0.018176516517996788, -0.0005718978936783969, 0.013627552427351475, -0.05719432234764099, -0.014886259101331234, -0.032088927924633026, 0.025881867855787277, -0.0155715337023139, 0.03782539442181587, 0.040139488875865936, -0.03791016712784767, 0.034131817519664764, 0.04240429028868675, -0.013162150979042053, 0.015852071344852448, -0.007776270154863596, 0.005639107897877693, 0.01202684361487627, 0.03007698617875576, 0.0036293636076152325, 0.03010067343711853, -0.01280050165951252, 0.037866417318582535, 0.012453732080757618, 0.03860025480389595, 0.019970525056123734, -0.005018202122300863, -0.014054793864488602, -0.026138946413993835, -0.013180839829146862, 0.03265565633773804, 0.04494817554950714, 0.0092922393232584, -0.0031329214107245207, 0.04939073324203491, 0.009484315291047096, -0.06459008902311325, -0.0005631839158013463, 0.07404466718435287, -0.0007929856074042618, -0.028554711490869522, -0.0682334303855896, 0.011943827383220196, -0.02159315161406994, 0.016414284706115723, 0.02635880373418331, 0.015923989936709404, -0.016337834298610687, -0.01367028709501028, -0.00037994130980223417, -0.002203570445999503, -0.024134516716003418, 0.0036043997388333082, 0.05119328200817108, 0.030469637364149094, -0.030680542811751366, -0.04418892785906792, 0.012336619198322296, 0.058848362416028976, 0.04216646030545235, 0.03772818669676781, -0.015030973590910435, -0.08738704025745392, 0.00878174602985382, 0.03755640238523483, 0.024060089141130447, -0.02468598634004593, 0.03865599259734154, -0.058772191405296326, -0.010259955190122128, 0.024337096139788628, -0.031045543029904366, 0.03859999403357506, 0.010428025387227535, 0.005507593043148518, -0.032548174262046814, 0.013581709004938602, -0.05034318566322327, 0.023006867617368698, -0.022093821316957474, 0.04573500528931618, -0.03172186762094498, -0.0012728228466585279, -0.052406053990125656, 0.015188558027148247, 0.0023954773787409067, 0.0369911827147007, 0.006567968986928463, -0.0037597089540213346, 0.004196809139102697, 0.0413450188934803, -0.0063103740103542805, -0.055685386061668396, 0.031681206077337265, -0.0067519391886889935, -0.036141470074653625, 0.045801009982824326, -0.013072969391942024, -0.05790897086262703, 0.03635009750723839, 0.004568369593471289, 0.030351802706718445, -0.016875557601451874, -0.009702347218990326, 0.06337897479534149, 0.022215889766812325, -0.0547618605196476, 0.029217349365353584, 0.007524360902607441, 0.007260009180754423, 0.02389131858944893, -0.03510725125670433, -0.01112537831068039, -0.04696309193968773, -0.014859462156891823, -0.02623462677001953, -0.004875804763287306, -0.012214381247758865, 0.07509548962116241, -0.00021379008830990642, 0.05493519827723503, -0.04228132218122482, -0.012063791044056416, 0.00028743830625899136, 0.03900149092078209, 0.0009561480837874115, -0.002920181257650256, 0.006335319485515356, 0.0292607881128788, 0.017543897032737732, -0.020329058170318604, 0.012919904664158821, -0.028934461995959282, 0.007992532104253769, 0.00845093373209238, -0.05175282061100006, 0.03025859408080578, -0.04135793447494507, -0.014275169931352139, -0.0026042014360427856, -0.0015978984301909804, 0.03752216324210167, -0.020851071923971176, 0.029719814658164978, 0.013525818474590778, -0.04391270503401756, -0.021503282710909843, 0.0036746617406606674, 0.016938215121626854, 0.044498417526483536, -0.06797751039266586, 0.025325363501906395, 0.005656105931848288, 0.004872579127550125, -0.07091714441776276, -0.0712045282125473, 0.0425945445895195, 0.007395104970782995, -0.023717310279607773, -0.026351572945713997, 0.016462868079543114, -0.001834413968026638, -0.037581611424684525, -0.012075282633304596, 0.04462789371609688, -0.05170208588242531, -0.019932443276047707, 0.00640652934089303, 0.006297081243246794, 0.07310029864311218, 0.010612023063004017, 0.0025769807398319244, 0.03256009519100189, -0.021504662930965424, 0.014774605631828308, -0.005314949434250593, -0.018094364553689957, -0.018201710656285286, 0.010254480876028538, -0.05466937646269798, -0.006818057503551245, 0.03681741654872894, -0.040186747908592224, -0.019968006759881973, -0.015451107174158096, 0.020911555737257004, 0.02420683763921261, -0.02459813468158245, -0.006780682131648064, 0.005729837343096733, -0.033944811671972275, -0.007940543815493584, 0.00010663700959412381, -0.009300244972109795, -0.0009299871744588017, 0.01761414296925068, 0.02014702558517456, -0.01891951821744442, 0.028574232012033463, 0.06602602452039719, 0.015739640220999718, -0.0043376171961426735, -0.0025977184996008873, -0.000031962848879629746, 0.06308504939079285, 0.020158499479293823, 0.009049534797668457, -0.02522803470492363, 0.0570412315428257, -0.013016985729336739, -0.01661851815879345, -0.019518394023180008, -0.003088673809543252, 0.08037333190441132, -0.008129400201141834, 0.02577577345073223, 0.05696028470993042, 0.03706258907914162, 0.02353171817958355, -0.011563570238649845, 0.01461851131170988, -0.027863692492246628, -0.00746731786057353, 0.060905084013938904, -0.013932432048022747, 0.023450231179594994, 0.002085405867546797, 0.006546881515532732, -0.011794318445026875, 0.04737817868590355, 0.0066233109682798386, 0.03193613886833191, 0.01846940815448761, -0.044076599180698395, -0.06680537015199661, 0.0183419082313776, -0.024986261501908302, 0.013935219496488571, -0.016778448596596718, -0.06894005835056305, -0.00048200134187936783, 0.043096885085105896, 0.01959523744881153, -0.045145999640226364, -0.024101359769701958, -0.043087974190711975, -0.010323096066713333, 0.03852583467960358, -0.015665261074900627, 0.0074034580029547215, 0.005939548835158348, 0.03031241148710251, -0.007750772405415773, -0.005028645973652601, -0.004248994402587414, -0.05710936710238457, -0.05492910370230675, -0.014192251488566399, -0.0592210628092289, 0.01960429549217224, 0.0023761766497045755, -0.0385972298681736, 0.03419792652130127, -0.006037361919879913, 0.06095423176884651, 0.00036562036257237196, 0.03788572549819946, 0.023265333846211433, 0.05642206221818924, -0.010884964838624, 0.016133159399032593, 0.009481648914515972, 0.004761263728141785, 0.08934960514307022, 0.07117680460214615, 0.038179848343133926, -0.06886724382638931, 0.003545196959748864, 0.00732111930847168, -0.02371673658490181, -0.02418345771729946, 0.02150876820087433, 0.02663816697895527, 0.005813994910567999, 0.015442127361893654, 0.06909900158643723, -0.017034543678164482, -0.0017018794314935803, 0.04045713320374489, -0.05535237863659859, -0.0420149490237236, 0.01576203666627407, 0.0028408095240592957, -0.02433943562209606, -0.03321467712521553, -0.04428558796644211, 0.030739640817046165, 0.034913964569568634, -0.012199451215565205, 0.012443948537111282, 0.005504583939909935, 0.008888673037290573, -0.020205112174153328, 0.009403924457728863, 0.01526788529008627, -0.003741671098396182, 0.016310662031173706, -0.058838434517383575, 0.025803498923778534, -0.0169688668102026, -0.04668918997049332, 0.005795690231025219, 0.026775244623422623, 0.012029058299958706, 0.0019098728662356734, -0.010760036297142506, -0.01813923567533493, -0.039147838950157166, -0.030629534274339676, -0.03250783681869507, 0.062290310859680176, 0.011829624883830547, 0.007911286316812038, -0.01578427664935589, 0.02598467282950878, 0.011142135597765446, -0.036187488585710526, -0.026501189917325974, 0.024206705391407013, 0.03118058107793331, 0.0020691831596195698, -0.006528179161250591, -0.04531043767929077, -0.004982655867934227, -0.007411878556013107, 0.014796133153140545, 0.01495908759534359, -0.02673691138625145, 0.002315759425982833, -0.0050840978510677814, 0.005588167812675238, 0.003901945659890771, -0.013017832301557064, -0.000370920606656, -0.017195673659443855, -0.010988811030983925, -0.00619053840637207, 0.008253470063209534, 0.0094064399600029, 0.028511986136436462, -0.014154595322906971, -0.0038652471266686916, 0.0012810101034119725, -0.017586374655365944, 0.005213507451117039, -0.037108685821294785, -0.007464740891009569, -0.007007112726569176, 0.011221809312701225, 0.02903972566127777, 0.04753557965159416, 0.01901416853070259, 0.018658103421330452, 0.015058131888508797, 0.05161334574222565, 0.015679670497775078, -0.03468667343258858, -0.02136050909757614, -0.011891767382621765, -0.05167389661073685, 0.009216148406267166, 0.0028520175255835056, 0.04768507555127144, 0.0063180699944496155, -0.016332130879163742, 0.008215628564357758, 0.05731647089123726, 0.027123603969812393, 0.02233022265136242, 0.021769817918539047, -0.02627570927143097, 0.05886032432317734, 0.002238201443105936, -0.0014970776392146945, -0.04708526283502579, -0.05408730357885361, -0.0014816141920164227, 0.02654748223721981, 0.009692024439573288, -0.011499064043164253, -0.02642669342458248, -0.007411608938127756, -0.012007143348455429, 0.003907669801265001, -0.02268006093800068, -0.01377419475466013, -0.0521637462079525, 0.006276392377912998, -0.03523464873433113, -0.046762872487306595, -0.008521877229213715, 0.010551845654845238, 0.011584783904254436, 0.004652658477425575, 0.04737516865134239, -0.008487829007208347, -0.0010558412177488208, -0.04263033717870712, 0.0068761929869651794, -0.0380583181977272, 0.09870564937591553, -0.029024405404925346, 0.01718108355998993, 0.05067755654454231, -0.07787134498357773, -0.03465626761317253, 0.026234958320856094, -0.023283889517188072, 0.05517171323299408, 0.025169676169753075, -0.0008553990628570318, -0.016997309401631355, 0.03192402049899101, -0.03300699591636658, -0.012837633490562439, 0.01719786413013935, 0.008944731205701828, 0.00045360217336565256, 0.015066304244101048, 0.0012431395007297397, 0.018445566296577454, -0.035441089421510696, 0.017360182479023933, 0.06183239072561264, 0.01739269308745861, -0.02882133238017559, 0.049594730138778687, -0.002673196140676737, 0.010351001285016537, -0.03271353244781494, -0.02667938731610775, 0.03866465017199516, 0.0364646390080452, -0.05495331808924675, 0.008724305778741837, 0.008182873018085957, 0.0052774338982999325, -0.08339878916740417, -0.013394310139119625, 0.009952782653272152, 0.032151930034160614, 0.03622278571128845, -0.05891305208206177, 0.025870898738503456, 0.014598210342228413, -0.036041509360075, 0.01739695854485035, -0.012873886153101921, 0.003061824245378375, -0.006838195491582155, 0.016736896708607674, -0.008849617093801498, 0.01738288439810276, 0.026089563965797424, 0.0501764677464962, 0.011258838698267937, 0.009952829219400883, 0.011926794424653053, -0.02462051622569561, -0.04491933807730675, 0.033614709973335266, 0.001086584059521556, -0.06192159280180931, 0.0496135912835598, -0.06437981873750687, -0.03568873181939125, 0.001996323699131608, -0.03531564027070999, -0.0029186916071921587, 0.05180498957633972, 0.010613630525767803, -0.06354113668203354, 0.029654240235686302, 0.03974829986691475, -0.042811665683984756, -0.007702636066824198, 0.002941287588328123, 0.031344443559646606, -0.01182880625128746, -0.02840372361242771, 0.007070334628224373, 0.02758634462952614, -0.029042933136224747, -0.03218062222003937, -0.03354765102267265, -0.021933740004897118, -0.05480692535638809, -0.029048841446638107, -0.017048805952072144, -0.018421746790409088, -0.022837940603494644, 0.006638535298407078, -0.01988885924220085, 0.01717809960246086, -0.001095012528821826, 0.04057065397500992, -0.03273569419980049, 0.007674782536923885, -0.02079836092889309, -0.07350527495145798, 0.006292529869824648, -0.004687348380684853, -0.0018623078940436244, -0.07294967025518417, -0.023464571684598923, 0.05949415639042854, 0.004985731560736895, -0.020143302157521248, -0.008467466570436954, -0.003287032013759017, 0.05678228661417961, -0.044103916734457016, 0.01747567020356655, 0.06878487765789032, -0.04487721621990204, 0.012083413079380989, -0.06743161380290985, 0.05897517502307892, 0.02221187762916088, 0.017276668921113014, -0.025339830666780472, -0.004263006150722504, -0.05504206568002701, -0.005626967176795006, 0.015409601852297783, -0.026139922440052032, 0.010421239770948887, -0.01572236604988575, 0.04256876930594444, 0.03716106340289116, -0.016512226313352585, 0.01605224423110485, -0.015192500315606594, -0.010217887349426746, -0.016673089936375618, -0.036354321986436844, 0.024510294198989868, 0.0017999584088101983, -0.011292879469692707, 0.014815335161983967, -0.012079253792762756, 0.008503028191626072, -0.03844310715794563, -0.015836592763662338, -0.00764082744717598, 0.0071826474741101265, 0.018602561205625534, 0.00254641892388463, -0.025865675881505013, 0.05832945182919502, -0.0075527518056333065, -0.050905633717775345, 0.019681597128510475, -0.04006146639585495, -0.032647307962179184, 0.02623976580798626, 0.02256074547767639, 0.030466455966234207, -0.05494218319654465, -0.006319815758615732, 0.012144861742854118, -0.009661214426159859, -0.024342384189367294, 0.021812180057168007, -0.005976491142064333, -0.009484137408435345, 0.008335240185260773, 0.034942563623189926, 0.008891100995242596, -0.016521938145160675, 0.008889321237802505, 0.051255665719509125, -0.0024298648349940777, 0.02286669611930847, 0.020533345639705658, -0.00200269534252584, -0.014772569760680199, -0.0017777312314137816, -0.0012363293208181858, 0.041492022573947906, -0.004177951253950596, -0.011539153754711151, 0.028488146141171455, 0.004372851457446814, 0.014987152069807053, 0.012576748616993427, -0.005674063228070736, 0.03771883249282837, -0.02138153649866581, -0.0032228613272309303, -0.0441385842859745, 0.013067447580397129, -0.0246213898062706, -0.005198316182941198, -0.033597614616155624, 0.04417358711361885, -0.017188377678394318, -0.00038189926999621093, -0.01151118054986, 0.007740536238998175, 0.005941460374742746, -0.0179000161588192, 0.0384892039000988, -0.0233539380133152, 0.03127460181713104, -0.012992162257432938, -0.03294233977794647, -0.04689239710569382, -0.014439152553677559, 0.0423005037009716, 0.058270905166864395, 0.04576318338513374, -0.01421486958861351, -0.012666177935898304, -0.016227753832936287, 0.04045954346656799, -0.03364822268486023, -0.03731546550989151, -0.028010882437229156, 0.008509906940162182, 0.002222303068265319, -0.005071739200502634 ]
<p>I would like to ask the difference between the normal distribution and the multinomial distribution because I don't know when to use each of them. I know the normal distribution is used for continuous probability, and the multinomial distribution is used for probabilities of <em>K</em> kinds of categories.</p> <p>Can anyone give me some examples of each to make me understand them more clearly? Thanks.</p>
36,969
[ -0.02059585228562355, -0.059947531670331955, 0.006764147896319628, -0.0018682250520214438, 0.01725006476044655, 0.003941812552511692, 0.029895702376961708, -0.010193550027906895, 0.017407149076461792, -0.007544416468590498, 0.0257539302110672, 0.03327023983001709, 0.024114886298775673, 0.015361418947577477, 0.025231868028640747, 0.028724290430545807, -0.04273891821503639, 0.005790846422314644, 0.00991162657737732, 0.02667165733873844, 0.0012814004439860582, 0.024379663169384003, 0.02244320511817932, -0.019544964656233788, -0.024565355852246284, 0.043921880424022675, 0.018200699239969254, -0.013852516189217567, 0.05234752222895622, 0.04479034245014191, -0.033409133553504944, -0.019711222499608994, -0.005151464603841305, 0.04445550963282585, -0.019888030365109444, -0.0161602720618248, -0.0475243404507637, -0.012594813480973244, -0.03706742078065872, 0.0001449323899578303, -0.04809335246682167, -0.023939989507198334, -0.0011433834442868829, 0.01008752454072237, -0.03751819580793381, 0.004909605253487825, -0.01430889219045639, -0.04735983908176422, 0.005800684913992882, -0.04180300980806351, 0.06858043372631073, -0.016774937510490417, 0.03718361631035805, 0.0407571941614151, -0.01097205001860857, 0.0027887688484042883, 0.05076640471816063, 0.07263923436403275, -0.004058776888996363, -0.07260320335626602, -0.01649574562907219, -0.02111072838306427, -0.004696160089224577, -0.032673731446266174, -0.0010766368359327316, 0.016101650893688202, -0.021766338497400284, -0.0361228808760643, 0.05607422813773155, 0.005428588483482599, 0.02809799835085869, 0.059647273272275925, 0.045415248721838, -0.037610720843076706, 0.020530940964818, -0.0010942182270810008, 0.036854974925518036, 0.01015445590019226, 0.05052749812602997, 0.02542564459145069, 0.011451661586761475, -0.0014285389333963394, 0.015514599159359932, 0.012292982079088688, 0.01847437210381031, -0.03411490470170975, 0.06576185673475266, -0.006161664612591267, 0.00914573110640049, 0.0003922489704564214, -0.04630517214536667, -0.01198322419077158, 0.033612702041864395, -0.0016213100170716643, -0.06387782841920853, 0.044662248343229294, -0.03340231999754906, 0.0325358547270298, 0.04334435239434242, -0.01990862376987934, 0.00606764480471611, -0.04137997329235077, 0.03113940916955471, 0.053550299257040024, -0.03761798143386841, 0.019423246383666992, -0.024301378056406975, 0.01060400065034628, 0.01119681540876627, 0.0003451089432928711, -0.017821762710809708, 0.037355631589889526, 0.023689856752753258, 0.0030742152594029903, 0.02605481632053852, 0.0025064698420464993, 0.0192709993571043, 0.014236854389309883, 0.03887287154793739, 0.059256866574287415, 0.050718627870082855, -0.04071059450507164, 0.024190234020352364, -0.022980548441410065, -0.04807015508413315, -0.004705206025391817, 0.021781211718916893, 0.012134149670600891, -0.028671709820628166, 0.04922221601009369, -0.03899289295077324, -0.000266347749857232, 0.042159974575042725, -0.027970895171165466, 0.021001305431127548, -0.016483798623085022, -0.07056833058595657, -0.017305370420217514, 0.012998430989682674, -0.0037855408154428005, -0.018076183274388313, -0.03657917305827141, 0.011762747541069984, 0.01739235781133175, 0.032174013555049896, 0.00668676383793354, 0.03981471061706543, -0.028170648962259293, 0.012618083506822586, 0.01665789633989334, -0.030679913237690926, -0.0004380950704216957, -0.0046447389759123325, 0.0063019716180861, 0.0069181849248707294, -0.10600190609693527, 0.020135339349508286, 0.022764308378100395, 0.027625642716884613, -0.042494285851716995, 0.02543560042977333, -0.002427171217277646, -0.027951421216130257, -0.010377737693488598, 0.03465908393263817, -0.024432774633169174, 0.06528913229703903, 0.0011027712607756257, 0.0629686713218689, 0.039367884397506714, 0.036053117364645004, 0.025551822036504745, 0.009179273620247841, 0.060441482812166214, 0.04555464908480644, 0.010135731659829617, -0.009887183085083961, 0.0010993758914992213, 0.06616555899381638, 0.010379251092672348, -0.040774114429950714, 0.02007073350250721, 0.0035576489754021168, -0.005771471653133631, -0.007012049201875925, 0.012235144153237343, 0.01945069059729576, -0.015225116163492203, 0.009841670282185078, -0.0260873194783926, -0.043654803186655045, -0.07784951478242874, 0.01417990680783987, -0.0646233782172203, -0.0281947273761034, 0.0858103334903717, 0.05049850046634674, 0.02346780337393284, -0.05514638125896454, 0.002201615134254098, -0.039543766528367996, -0.018062381073832512, -0.007700626738369465, -0.07081222534179688, -0.00045157011481933296, 0.06290647387504578, 0.026265759021043777, 0.01769269071519375, 0.002971173729747534, -0.022186949849128723, -0.02263963781297207, 0.013107488863170147, -0.05550447851419449, 0.027170812711119652, 0.016018765047192574, -0.014108107425272465, -0.008309793658554554, -0.004053889308124781, -0.027217920869588852, 0.035490818321704865, -0.04518555477261543, 0.04441998898983002, 0.05167881399393082, 0.003744774963706732, -0.007747073192149401, 0.017704246565699577, -0.01799600198864937, -0.04831736907362938, 0.011243702843785286, -0.016207072883844376, -0.06187320500612259, -0.0002992104855366051, 0.02098851464688778, 0.007661345414817333, -0.06602922081947327, 0.04898236691951752, 0.023074155673384666, 0.051492996513843536, 0.057618655264377594, 0.03977132588624954, -0.01991850510239601, -0.02139570377767086, 0.0070815784856677055, 0.02394304983317852, 0.018957490101456642, 0.027066975831985474, 0.018555501475930214, -0.009973077103495598, 0.019663479179143906, -0.035344719886779785, -0.025528881698846817, 0.0808248370885849, -0.024601828306913376, 0.017809897661209106, -0.0021085357293486595, -0.04116470739245415, 0.009900888428092003, -0.043170686811208725, -0.008362303487956524, 0.038503073155879974, -0.009623988531529903, -0.02813132479786873, 0.012980912812054157, -0.029197070747613907, 0.03027442656457424, 0.029093850404024124, -0.032692402601242065, 0.012535460293293, 0.020510680973529816, -0.02588779479265213, 0.012130740098655224, -0.010821936652064323, -0.036991387605667114, -0.03926616907119751, -0.0034576815087348223, 0.00751122459769249, -0.00928013026714325, 0.03547387197613716, 0.004548861179500818, -0.01896476000547409, 0.005655228625983, -0.03233537822961807, 0.019570372998714447, -0.028271881863474846, -0.06230298429727554, -0.0007174935890361667, -0.008221844211220741, -0.04113423079252243, 0.03630368411540985, -0.02035932056605816, -0.00925967376679182, 0.019348418340086937, -0.0186894740909338, -0.03576982021331787, 0.007337208371609449, -0.0034994010347872972, 0.04628153517842293, -0.02654026448726654, -0.03883497416973114, 0.035654157400131226, -0.021312197670340538, -0.03168731555342674, 0.021438322961330414, -0.04452536255121231, -0.0537189245223999, -0.053589653223752975, 0.004059918690472841, 0.011646158993244171, -0.019290244206786156, -0.018434885889291763, 0.03155747056007385, -0.048051707446575165, 0.01533665880560875, -0.05189589411020279, -0.0413195937871933, 0.03631213307380676, -0.03331763297319412, 0.03714950755238533, 0.019839048385620117, -0.014270192943513393, 0.05112642049789429, 0.03628257289528847, -0.007845859974622726, -0.0006829972844570875, -0.0015842759748920798, -0.03857165202498436, -0.009690414182841778, 0.014820815064013004, 0.023278219625353813, 0.003772668307647109, 0.01847568154335022, 0.024476749822497368, 0.022510357201099396, 0.0579523928463459, -0.014957998879253864, -0.013894383795559406, 0.004476542584598064, 0.01130541879683733, -0.04574712738394737, 0.059184443205595016, 0.011557705700397491, -0.023896222934126854, 0.01950835809111595, -0.008380590938031673, 0.0069202156737446785, -0.00914616696536541, 0.019196540117263794, 0.04945627227425575, -0.011739397421479225, -0.019307807087898254, -0.05608751252293587, 0.03075503744184971, -0.007510052528232336, -0.02221953310072422, 0.020537950098514557, 0.018196461722254753, 0.03110327385365963, -0.05870518833398819, 0.014780963771045208, 0.05001513287425041, 0.06382229179143906, -0.05321083962917328, -0.01122346706688404, -0.04600924253463745, -0.006647748872637749, 0.051330264657735825, -0.01924028992652893, -0.0013732978841289878, 0.05279558524489403, 0.03650491312146187, 0.02771163173019886, 0.0014994970988482237, -0.015345009043812752, -0.014804689213633537, -0.062018804252147675, 0.026989130303263664, -0.007687367033213377, 0.013617338612675667, 0.01159493625164032, 0.07967394590377808, -0.0023176672402769327, -0.028743060305714607, 0.00859550479799509, 0.008823176845908165, -0.06959763914346695, 0.03071543760597706, -0.028615787625312805, 0.0015741008101031184, 0.013393702916800976, -0.044532544910907745, 0.04727230221033096, -0.012267333455383778, -0.0006575199076905847, 0.030457792803645134, -0.003261418780311942, -0.03879095986485481, 0.003613725770264864, -0.016851108521223068, -0.02690853178501129, -0.011967580765485764, -0.0053026434034109116, -0.003604078432545066, -0.009643971920013428, -0.009113316424190998, 0.042428914457559586, 0.0026152010541409254, 0.0012992809060961008, -0.01955624483525753, -0.003871658816933632, 0.027293752878904343, 0.023139655590057373, 0.022271711379289627, 0.021054845303297043, -0.014685510657727718, 0.035376448184251785, 0.020198509097099304, 0.07229478657245636, 0.005919802933931351, -0.02971581369638443, -0.029340656474232674, -0.08506907522678375, -0.03178127855062485, -0.03986342251300812, 0.03106853738427162, 0.010651174001395702, -0.00555172935128212, 0.041394054889678955, 0.021587185561656952, -0.03724656626582146, 0.0315786637365818, 0.06432783603668213, -0.022181039676070213, -0.0342971608042717, -0.014213021844625473, 0.017385199666023254, -0.03222360834479332, -0.0006986013031564653, 0.02722034975886345, 0.008717902936041355, -0.015767628327012062, 0.017061417922377586, 0.039430614560842514, -0.05002271756529808, -0.03932575508952141, -0.00598498759791255, 0.020455377176404, 0.02247427962720394, 0.0028700432740151882, -0.022977320477366447, 0.01030783448368311, 0.04275094345211983, 0.02445152774453163, 0.01975889503955841, 0.002680725185200572, -0.061933938413858414, 0.014550021849572659, 0.058343395590782166, 0.021173279732465744, -0.0502038337290287, -0.013771465979516506, -0.03453332930803299, 0.003951352089643478, 0.02112584188580513, -0.016856016591191292, 0.005667266435921192, -0.009865714237093925, 0.028230009600520134, -0.002258825348690152, 0.01980443298816681, -0.025339674204587936, 0.029498277232050896, 0.018558455631136894, 0.030905550345778465, 0.007939033210277557, 0.03013872541487217, -0.07500667870044708, 0.012787853367626667, 0.02947775088250637, 0.07950259000062943, -0.0022586032282561064, -0.038024481385946274, 0.029996085911989212, -0.011307456530630589, -0.0030272884760051966, -0.06899179518222809, -0.011057944037020206, 0.00028656565700657666, -0.003054306609556079, 0.04134051129221916, -0.003519912948831916, -0.019012000411748886, 0.0005046061123721302, -0.010675712488591671, -0.0516987182199955, 0.02802530862390995, -0.0015407444443553686, 0.009917451068758965, 0.0124971279874444, 0.0018101074965670705, 0.0497240386903286, 0.007899266667664051, -0.016206922009587288, -0.015077932737767696, -0.05564982444047928, 0.06592658162117004, -0.019687382504343987, -0.016373151913285255, -0.029355624690651894, -0.03311098739504814, -0.014333823695778847, 0.04909605532884598, -0.009774851612746716, 0.0007664830191060901, -0.035757001489400864, -0.03365464136004448, -0.020544668659567833, 0.04340149462223053, 0.022595226764678955, 0.00545839499682188, 0.02687891758978367, -0.0008695884607732296, 0.031056424602866173, 0.006658134516328573, 0.021368898451328278, -0.022172091528773308, 0.021380813792347908, 0.02459963969886303, -0.020667042583227158, 0.022195786237716675, -0.05102592706680298, -0.07254641503095627, 0.02782418206334114, -0.003501782426610589, 0.04373814910650253, -0.0032582071144133806, 0.042791835963726044, 0.009696561843156815, -0.09064670652151108, -0.021963588893413544, 0.025955362245440483, -0.01720857061445713, 0.06273748725652695, -0.04144083708524704, 0.05556757003068924, -0.0014390820870175958, -0.003300414653494954, -0.08038005232810974, -0.05925557762384415, -0.0009543178020976484, 0.017666161060333252, -0.017403097823262215, -0.012907261960208416, 0.024904247373342514, -0.0009421881986781955, -0.0355788879096508, -0.009411944076418877, 0.04192452132701874, -0.007035903166979551, -0.023976806551218033, -0.024470331147313118, -0.0026225040201097727, 0.07646122574806213, 0.029248500242829323, 0.0021419855765998363, -0.010528246872127056, -0.01065812073647976, -0.010064623318612576, -0.005941426381468773, 0.031864847987890244, -0.027145007625222206, -0.011637282557785511, -0.008726413361728191, 0.0017018369399011135, 0.060864586383104324, -0.054525699466466904, -0.005687792785465717, 0.030780989676713943, 0.0008817921043373644, 0.005797326099127531, -0.008040810003876686, -0.010491356253623962, -0.0124003104865551, 0.00973670557141304, -0.01981336995959282, -0.0004579639935400337, -0.02519746869802475, 0.012818582355976105, 0.05478174611926079, -0.00989527814090252, 0.026914572343230247, 0.05849862098693848, 0.06881307810544968, -0.01686198078095913, 0.039745040237903595, -0.023731039837002754, -0.015962112694978714, 0.035211604088544846, -0.0076025184243917465, -0.028335534036159515, 0.03327573835849762, 0.015993405133485794, -0.013766405172646046, 0.02732095494866371, -0.02970670908689499, 0.0020689901430159807, 0.03291342407464981, 0.01312919333577156, 0.042139120399951935, 0.0453505739569664, 0.004792794585227966, 0.005003148689866066, -0.02666044421494007, -0.014188334345817566, 0.005956424865871668, 0.00231932639144361, 0.0321253202855587, -0.01200649794191122, 0.017403479665517807, 0.0159772802144289, -0.007551019079983234, 0.005932485219091177, 0.015698736533522606, 0.01600930467247963, 0.05109718441963196, 0.016843410208821297, -0.031380314379930496, -0.031129345297813416, 0.05317924544215202, -0.04405008256435394, 0.008915937505662441, 0.00040635361801832914, -0.024133974686264992, 0.05418156459927559, 0.030255984514951706, -0.035420771688222885, -0.06822434812784195, -0.01111055351793766, -0.0003900876617990434, 0.011570899747312069, 0.0035025039687752724, 0.0013176992069929838, 0.011658563278615475, -0.005099080968648195, 0.051884956657886505, -0.016725394874811172, 0.011339890770614147, 0.029405998066067696, -0.06922562420368195, -0.046378932893276215, -0.019552206620573997, -0.04331353306770325, -0.00858164019882679, -0.02332046814262867, -0.05085336044430733, -0.00775406276807189, -0.03571290895342827, 0.032843153923749924, 0.025410598143935204, 0.0275256410241127, -0.023792410269379616, 0.04302072897553444, -0.005147593095898628, -0.008161522448062897, 0.012159612029790878, -0.03968900814652443, 0.10093296319246292, 0.07035791128873825, 0.017843473702669144, -0.07589170336723328, -0.009451031684875488, -0.02620661072432995, 0.0061427513137459755, -0.01886771246790886, 0.00431040907278657, 0.02836448699235916, 0.018246514722704887, 0.0620332770049572, 0.029782438650727272, 0.034218862652778625, -0.0004735918191727251, 0.06354238092899323, 0.003356932895258069, -0.04210326448082924, -0.009952540509402752, 0.0299703199416399, 0.002021664520725608, 0.019121678546071053, -0.04456532746553421, 0.034017592668533325, 0.008577904663980007, -0.00787026435136795, -0.028369219973683357, -0.008367540314793587, 0.032479435205459595, 0.003997293300926685, -0.010890473611652851, -0.019412290304899216, 0.04386020079255104, 0.006046510301530361, -0.008749266155064106, -0.001612206338904798, 0.01418108120560646, -0.04522096365690231, -0.005091103725135326, 0.02893550880253315, 0.01397390104830265, -0.01675531454384327, 0.034607961773872375, 0.006241794675588608, -0.07052353769540787, -0.02338310144841671, -0.03528689593076706, -0.007802003528922796, -0.0013547592097893357, 0.00707525247707963, -0.003566234838217497, 0.014698135666549206, -0.01268808078020811, -0.029208356514573097, -0.01280557457357645, 0.015599637292325497, 0.02147541008889675, -0.02466590516269207, -0.037707507610321045, -0.03447185084223747, 0.0467323362827301, -0.016731249168515205, 0.051295969635248184, 0.00025025862851180136, -0.0021903931628912687, 0.009276886470615864, -0.027997879311442375, -0.0046693398617208, -0.018617277964949608, 0.009564724750816822, -0.02357480674982071, -0.018996674567461014, -0.025993959978222847, 0.010156786069273949, -0.011192732490599155, -0.009355662390589714, 0.013839428313076496, 0.019988439977169037, -0.006893163081258535, 0.030506011098623276, -0.013936533592641354, 0.01310814917087555, -0.0005019988166168332, -0.006274381186813116, -0.051916226744651794, 0.005495653487741947, 0.03787004202604294, 0.0025612488389015198, 0.017224442213773727, 0.05099817365407944, 0.0027252098079770803, 0.029516221955418587, 0.022720593959093094, -0.045221418142318726, 0.007534188684076071, 0.026881065219640732, -0.03945748880505562, -0.010164808481931686, -0.04865245893597603, 0.03343251347541809, 0.009517387486994267, 0.028437864035367966, -0.03662341833114624, 0.022846892476081848, 0.006459060590714216, 0.020405437797307968, 0.013221646659076214, -0.07996942102909088, 0.029596008360385895, 0.032826729118824005, 0.016315152868628502, -0.025404054671525955, -0.04040495306253433, -0.010944387875497341, 0.0032487649004906416, 0.020199470221996307, -0.030889200046658516, -0.006407710257917643, -0.024578286334872246, 0.0015000607818365097, 0.05426180735230446, 0.0090938750654459, -0.03492937609553337, -0.017026083543896675, 0.022174663841724396, 0.027316538617014885, -0.008570575155317783, -0.010516480542719364, -0.004638636019080877, 0.01495268102735281, -0.0024896173272281885, 0.03850913047790527, 0.017019620165228844, -0.01249660737812519, 0.01247852947562933, 0.017300952225923538, 0.009570789523422718, 0.05830494314432144, -0.006087176501750946, 0.004783801734447479, 0.0285219457000494, -0.02719791792333126, -0.0027667288668453693, 0.008985914289951324, 0.018231099471449852, 0.05627064406871796, 0.01738349348306656, -0.004107248038053513, -0.024592308327555656, 0.0355331152677536, -0.04695389047265053, -0.02777867019176483, -0.0428786464035511, -0.018205147236585617, -0.018669312819838524, 0.008843678049743176, -0.02693472057580948, -0.0009191938443109393, -0.026177145540714264, 0.03767835721373558, 0.03277956694364548, 0.014302721247076988, -0.046869389712810516, 0.009763224050402641, 0.006311210338026285, -0.002571255434304476, 0.00666797673329711, 0.023686254397034645, 0.03017965890467167, 0.03735174983739853, -0.03193031996488571, 0.05020184814929962, -0.008183698169887066, -0.0013072616420686245, -0.06808596104383469, -0.04666278138756752, 0.030700387433171272, -0.031787630170583725, 0.07167252898216248, -0.057476408779621124, -0.023289045318961143, 0.03557663410902023, -0.027462918311357498, -0.024036351591348648, -0.002521877409890294, -0.034311164170503616, -0.027935339137911797, 0.0017457257490605116, 0.036914609372615814, 0.054653286933898926, 0.011728400364518166, 0.028373125940561295, -0.0020469892770051956, -0.008013890124857426, -0.016558174043893814, 0.005369260907173157, -0.028040356934070587, 0.024997977539896965, 0.03578505292534828, -0.0578528493642807, 0.04075583443045616, -0.03273862600326538, -0.03738802298903465, 0.04500974342226982, -0.012967846356332302, 0.0063203079625964165, 0.05680960789322853, 0.01264452375471592, 0.004426071885973215, 0.032193589955568314, -0.004985697567462921, -0.013879126869142056, -0.03246309608221054, 0.03058089315891266, 0.04968460276722908, 0.02952508069574833, -0.034892626106739044, -0.01779930666089058, 0.04229250177741051, -0.04190947860479355, -0.05543798208236694, 0.027066517621278763, 0.011690531857311726, -0.04072066769003868, -0.012700939550995827, -0.013426296412944794, 0.039308514446020126, -0.002611860865727067, 0.033149197697639465, -0.04749302566051483, -0.003214915283024311, 0.029257137328386307, 0.03925849124789238, 0.03450239822268486, 0.029569894075393677, -0.004935636185109615, -0.022845927625894547, 0.008777582086622715, 0.01000343356281519, -0.024801691994071007, -0.044603131711483, 0.0032830280251801014, -0.0174751915037632, 0.009456712752580643, 0.00101322156842798, -0.026676494628190994, -0.049216076731681824, 0.006265627220273018, -0.012407191097736359, 0.011166181415319443, 0.02364838495850563, -0.016339056193828583, -0.04051275551319122, -0.049692824482917786, 0.037344157695770264, 0.02420567348599434, -0.01767984963953495, -0.07665941119194031, 0.019285021349787712, -0.06390273571014404, 0.0018615934532135725, 0.02389342151582241, -0.00807015597820282, -0.01741962693631649, -0.04479718208312988, 0.02206570655107498, 0.034456800669431686, -0.05951086804270744, -0.013687820173799992, -0.021245304495096207, -0.07024402171373367, -0.024389738216996193, -0.015526273287832737, 0.017378652468323708, 0.0032637317199259996, 0.007453359197825193, -0.012007988058030605, 0.03260539844632149, -0.007298251613974571, 0.020715074613690376, 0.0303986594080925, 0.013453470543026924, -0.019969722256064415, 0.02798299305140972, -0.058121927082538605, -0.001572523731738329, 0.01861708238720894, 0.00523941358551383, -0.024082254618406296, 0.048598840832710266, -0.012895860709249973, -0.026316912844777107, -0.004196003545075655, -0.003493067342787981, 0.01084740087389946, -0.07692443579435349, -0.03054211474955082, 0.00961190927773714, -0.042258284986019135, 0.01037386991083622, 0.04483221843838692, 0.04369695484638214, 0.06639628857374191, -0.012217010371387005, -0.016017453745007515, -0.02081136777997017, -0.04209219664335251, 0.029604071751236916, 0.025076882913708687, 0.007991313003003597, -0.020246783271431923, 0.026791896671056747, -0.004342516418546438, -0.035044264048337936, 0.025600410997867584, 0.009237799793481827, 0.06036478653550148, -0.021340543404221535, -0.04323619231581688, 0.02034062147140503, -0.002150331623852253, 0.029862087219953537, -0.006559413857758045, -0.015725037083029747, 0.04529063403606415, -0.026380756869912148, -0.016831444576382637, -0.033047422766685486, -0.04291699081659317, -0.040349800139665604, -0.03575718030333519, 0.008213837631046772, 0.039265114814043045, -0.002148534171283245, 0.0009998905006796122, -0.011096259579062462, -0.008502387441694736, 0.06468473374843597, 0.007728626951575279, 0.0294383205473423, -0.02125410921871662, -0.016283812001347542, -0.03181711211800575, -0.0035245385952293873, -0.027073845267295837, -0.027345219627022743, 0.021062729880213737, 0.049693454056978226, 0.025934644043445587, 0.02752571925520897, -0.027682732790708542, 0.000785857904702425, 0.04183349758386612, -0.05860240384936333, 0.004827791824936867, -0.0641259104013443, 0.023927662521600723, 0.01578066684305668, -0.004270796664059162 ]
<p>At first I thought the order didn’t matter, but then I read about the gram-schmidt orthogonalization process for calculating multiple regression coefficients, and now I’m having second thoughts.</p> <p>According to the gram-schmidt process, the later an explanatory variable is indexed among the other variables, the smaller its residual vector is because preceding variables' residual vectors are subtracted from it. As a result, the explanatory variable's regression coefficient is also smaller. </p> <p>If that's true, then the residual vector of the variable in question would be larger if it were indexed earlier, since fewer residual vectors would be subtracted from it. This means that the regression coefficient would be larger too. </p> <p>Ok, so I've been asked to clarify my question. So I've posted screenshots from the text that got me confused in the first place. Ok, here goes.</p> <p>My understanding is that there are <em>at least</em> two options to calculate the regression coefficients. The first option is denoted (3.6) in the screenshot below. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/vVlAl.png" alt="The first way"></p> <p>Here is the second option (I had to use multiple screenshots).</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/PC6vp.png" alt="The second way"></p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/GO2cv.png" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/sSkCF.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Unless I am misreading something (which is definitely possible), it seems that order matters in the second option. Does it matter in the first option? Why or why not? Or is my frame of reference so messed up that this isn't even a valid question? Also, is this all somehow related to Type I Sum of Squares vs Type II Sum of Squares? </p> <p>Thanks so much in advance, I am so confused!</p>
74,225
[ -0.03469691053032875, -0.019862189888954163, -0.019853897392749786, 0.01993951015174389, 0.019322367385029793, 0.03230360895395279, -0.053606066852808, -0.013394465669989586, 0.02578873187303543, -0.058708306401968, 0.032103314995765686, -0.0012582318158820271, 0.06313273310661316, 0.007144205737859011, 0.017678450793027878, 0.04079648479819298, 0.0012326339492574334, 0.05049566552042961, 0.02402302250266075, -0.007762123364955187, 0.000464257609564811, 0.029208382591605186, -0.022055206820368767, -0.02504643052816391, -0.02352236770093441, 0.07656879723072052, 0.05477982014417648, -0.016980919986963272, -0.008110935799777508, 0.049533940851688385, -0.003193253418430686, -0.024096613749861717, -0.0028624222613871098, 0.009889592416584492, 0.019535984843969345, 0.01459222100675106, -0.0015212673461064696, -0.00814990233629942, 0.022547878324985504, 0.048500459641218185, 0.01874452270567417, -0.009862215258181095, -0.034169752150774, 0.031736958771944046, -0.008217868395149708, 0.015156594105064869, 0.0038150972686707973, -0.0011974276276305318, 0.036369357258081436, -0.006449774838984013, 0.06860318779945374, -0.003227942856028676, 0.020309526473283768, 0.0659579485654831, -0.04518140107393265, -0.003343243384733796, 0.022617977112531662, 0.06435585021972656, -0.015040721744298935, -0.03939933702349663, 0.015836939215660095, -0.00028519760235212743, -0.016784904524683952, 0.01887274906039238, -0.004716068040579557, 0.019214091822504997, 0.029785364866256714, 0.014151710085570812, 0.025127854198217392, -0.014430170878767967, 0.019481517374515533, 0.001587797305546701, 0.04869944602251053, -0.04771342873573303, 0.029468558728694916, -0.012653164565563202, 0.029887085780501366, 0.03274916112422943, 0.03145908936858177, -0.004742218181490898, -0.014985288493335247, 0.028350530192255974, 0.01080411672592163, 0.02271317131817341, 0.020549103617668152, 0.022533902898430824, 0.06261167675256729, -0.02349100634455681, 0.028797602280974388, 0.05488213151693344, -0.03020373359322548, 0.027726424857974052, 0.03908403590321541, 0.0007894978043623269, -0.01955636590719223, 0.033325448632240295, -0.007802649866789579, 0.017248427495360374, 0.03794325143098831, 0.0080515556037426, -0.034733280539512634, -0.03401024639606476, -0.004403403028845787, 0.05671996250748634, -0.010597207583487034, 0.018809232860803604, -0.03877832368016243, 0.06323885917663574, -0.021506456658244133, -0.05352594703435898, -0.004523053765296936, 0.04363498464226723, -0.024609792977571487, -0.030710142105817795, -0.0036428330931812525, -0.017223352566361427, 0.02291245013475418, -0.0011785574024543166, 0.05298767611384392, 0.07278017699718475, 0.026939427480101585, -0.03784146532416344, 0.0071449726819992065, -0.02542157843708992, -0.060795124620199203, 0.003969832789152861, 0.03316688910126686, -0.007762005086988211, -0.03500384837388992, 0.03717677667737007, 0.014338362030684948, -0.02261941321194172, 0.02256515622138977, -0.02014595828950405, -0.022611573338508606, 0.044365882873535156, -0.09478515386581421, -0.03630597144365311, 0.06743514537811279, -0.0073300255462527275, 0.027737153694033623, -0.031691551208496094, -0.013139910995960236, 0.014057960361242294, 0.06107204779982567, -0.012819213792681694, 0.03917863965034485, 0.0021301473025232553, 0.03409907594323158, -0.014172750525176525, -0.0029905643314123154, 0.015092059969902039, -0.041779547929763794, -0.03491198271512985, -0.046398505568504333, -0.06997250765562057, 0.004931124858558178, 0.05184345692396164, -0.010823460295796394, 0.009814794175326824, 0.07138247042894363, 0.016852645203471184, 0.015706578269600868, 0.0020075447391718626, -0.014001725241541862, -0.027580974623560905, 0.029599247500300407, -0.00002687217238417361, 0.027866628021001816, 0.013024789281189442, -0.011760921217501163, -0.009386586025357246, -0.04049810394644737, 0.028582094237208366, 0.05761605128645897, 0.0005875693168491125, 0.020664051175117493, -0.01945986971259117, 0.017008544877171516, 0.020799390971660614, -0.06424257904291153, -0.04760187491774559, -0.01094767078757286, -0.007113002240657806, 0.04302658513188362, 0.03617925941944122, -0.008035272359848022, -0.02182561345398426, 0.013270512223243713, -0.03542939946055412, -0.05013295263051987, -0.057475145906209946, -0.010821432806551456, 0.013062495738267899, -0.04608635604381561, 0.013452510349452496, -0.038287315517663956, 0.0026978212408721447, 0.03494039550423622, -0.013382721692323685, -0.014193336479365826, 0.01700633391737938, 0.032761022448539734, -0.0210482869297266, -0.028367526829242706, 0.053655147552490234, 0.05549466237425804, -0.0016001490876078606, 0.03998231515288353, -0.025934910401701927, -0.012407850474119186, 0.05277276039123535, -0.012463556602597237, 0.022768577560782433, -0.03757756948471069, -0.023124488070607185, 0.03829898685216904, 0.029970379546284676, -0.017052466049790382, -0.00282909139059484, -0.04145760461688042, 0.05477523431181908, 0.06062415614724159, -0.012209507636725903, -0.00422435998916626, 0.009557781741023064, 0.0315396785736084, 0.003786447923630476, -0.022795571014285088, -0.014831691049039364, -0.040200524032115936, -0.06588240712881088, 0.04741532355546951, 0.0383707731962204, -0.043923623859882355, 0.00943501852452755, 0.04170221835374832, 0.054611049592494965, 0.01101219467818737, -0.00633240444585681, 0.025285137817263603, -0.01621846854686737, -0.01399562880396843, -0.0005074921064078808, 0.010995261371135712, 0.024704862385988235, 0.020970575511455536, -0.016328811645507812, 0.034916047006845474, 0.03209806606173515, -0.004324416629970074, 0.04825309291481972, 0.02703913487493992, 0.010493875481188297, -0.022363897413015366, -0.003892580745741725, 0.04807275906205177, -0.024205636233091354, 0.025594329461455345, 0.028172247111797333, -0.006506145000457764, -0.022228827700018883, -0.009173065423965454, 0.010505566373467445, 0.02967396378517151, 0.05440746620297432, -0.05744676664471626, 0.007437031250447035, 0.014148693531751633, -0.013863072730600834, 0.019777793437242508, -0.06557824462652206, -0.019205641001462936, -0.031860556453466415, -0.01565140299499035, 0.04329441487789154, 0.021489128470420837, 0.013901745900511742, -0.037456758320331573, 0.011177926324307919, -0.03267723694443703, -0.011289965361356735, 0.0661495178937912, 0.007923070341348648, -0.07527226209640503, -0.010006221942603588, -0.03954651206731796, -0.03423835337162018, 0.025000358000397682, -0.0011803138768300414, -0.03113456256687641, 0.025825727730989456, -0.006161976605653763, -0.07287468016147614, -0.06085025891661644, -0.0034706464502960443, 0.00093856017338112, -0.030872026458382607, -0.05675114691257477, 0.07096552848815918, 0.005548236425966024, -0.054346270859241486, 0.01943526230752468, -0.04930529370903969, -0.025332633405923843, 0.00042232905980199575, -0.006215051747858524, -0.013556279242038727, 0.009120497852563858, 0.01175838615745306, 0.015589933842420578, -0.009437819942831993, -0.04243181645870209, -0.07467890530824661, -0.08211196959018707, 0.02400931343436241, -0.006004433147609234, 0.01874241977930069, -0.028690652921795845, -0.02644660882651806, 0.08015415072441101, 0.055695466697216034, 0.0035774128045886755, -0.05316855385899544, 0.003472596872597933, 0.001415574224665761, -0.019434496760368347, 0.02748757228255272, 0.016143115237355232, 0.040594689548015594, 0.039774391800165176, -0.03778250515460968, 0.07885298132896423, 0.0638154074549675, -0.016766518354415894, 0.030974620953202248, 0.015592318028211594, 0.012095917016267776, -0.03043394349515438, 0.021429309621453285, 0.022124430164694786, 0.023703182116150856, 0.02565320022404194, 0.011022997088730335, 0.028667228296399117, -0.00372417364269495, -0.04103958234190941, 0.011474472470581532, -0.02739606238901615, 0.0030158753506839275, -0.049668483436107635, 0.026114199310541153, 0.04047501087188721, 0.009508614428341389, -0.010641859844326973, -0.01350597757846117, 0.03902323916554451, -0.03671754151582718, 0.007219790946692228, -0.004422806669026613, 0.03686637431383133, -0.013545013032853603, 0.014229600317776203, -0.015929533168673515, -0.0135488361120224, 0.018190935254096985, -0.03840302303433418, -0.02045300602912903, 0.04032561928033829, 0.021061770617961884, 0.01629958115518093, -0.026657089591026306, -0.04584726691246033, 0.0124996118247509, -0.04179542511701584, 0.015073813498020172, -0.024383747950196266, 0.05202682316303253, 0.0046438961289823055, 0.023360013961791992, -0.020163370296359062, 0.0014662028988823295, -0.009008080698549747, 0.01352259237319231, -0.0761476382613182, 0.01823302172124386, 0.020839281380176544, -0.012631240300834179, 0.024839861318469048, -0.031274255365133286, 0.048042722046375275, -0.02576766163110733, 0.014741281978785992, 0.013607180677354336, 0.01721525937318802, -0.025238635018467903, 0.014655082486569881, -0.010972339659929276, 0.018525969237089157, 0.01251494325697422, 0.0014748285757377744, 0.017618563026189804, -0.02449866384267807, 0.021527932956814766, 0.06277255713939667, -0.02053682878613472, 0.021305328235030174, -0.0471673384308815, 0.01692393235862255, 0.05337720736861229, 0.021370723843574524, 0.005235390271991491, 0.006696922704577446, -0.026975031942129135, 0.0015260534128174186, -0.016196217387914658, 0.025130774825811386, 0.04691430181264877, -0.019284259527921677, -0.02896225079894066, -0.01665622554719448, -0.021199559792876244, -0.022886930033564568, 0.03152786195278168, -0.030208680778741837, 0.0082571841776371, 0.048313699662685394, -0.00833436194807291, -0.02802790328860283, 0.057635657489299774, 0.05288848653435707, 0.007257786113768816, -0.009420844726264477, -0.052504148334264755, -0.003240791382268071, 0.008458046242594719, -0.011576942168176174, 0.04112713411450386, 0.015232941135764122, -0.0204755961894989, -0.04218577593564987, 0.033410269767045975, -0.03556375950574875, 0.006394163239747286, 0.026804260909557343, 0.006780113093554974, 0.018593452870845795, 0.0320635661482811, -0.053405676037073135, -0.026746448129415512, 0.02427704818546772, 0.05086873471736908, 0.015880204737186432, -0.0012153607094660401, -0.07933208346366882, -0.010989994741976261, 0.026653779670596123, 0.032712213695049286, -0.07779988646507263, 0.018318967893719673, -0.028096485882997513, -0.04201188683509827, 0.027293920516967773, -0.03246140480041504, 0.01427112054079771, -0.022740783169865608, 0.005861541256308556, -0.02422105334699154, -0.04282853379845619, -0.03865895792841911, 0.014336555264890194, -0.01500619761645794, 0.03307453915476799, -0.03053138218820095, 0.0058507164940238, -0.033292967826128006, 0.018193937838077545, 0.004688825458288193, 0.0039716982282698154, -0.0064742048271000385, -0.0015850876225158572, 0.014850551262497902, 0.024083321914076805, -0.04329375550150871, -0.024092135950922966, 0.020263517275452614, 0.008630487136542797, -0.008609123528003693, 0.06049138680100441, -0.008230500854551792, -0.047822896391153336, 0.020674386993050575, 0.03689735755324364, -0.003437710925936699, -0.009783564135432243, -0.032237716019153595, 0.05216621607542038, 0.0282121691852808, -0.017853708937764168, 0.042767737060785294, 0.0593440867960453, 0.030567290261387825, 0.007614118047058582, -0.06196614354848862, -0.0059870281256735325, -0.0492437407374382, -0.05524754896759987, -0.01843724399805069, 0.006922172848135233, 0.009387347847223282, 0.03189335763454437, 0.004892896860837936, 0.02557208575308323, -0.03318600356578827, -0.03547404706478119, -0.01943310722708702, 0.022929826751351357, -0.01867162436246872, -0.017087889835238457, 0.012762259691953659, 0.03386704996228218, -0.0045821787789464, -0.030004365369677544, 0.02096298523247242, -0.013315664604306221, 0.00014155186363495886, 0.04517679288983345, -0.007139865774661303, -0.025361662730574608, 0.0059870025143027306, 0.007289854343980551, -0.015568011440336704, -0.033910803496837616, 0.03446533530950546, -0.013923280872404575, 0.003808330511674285, 0.004489061888307333, -0.02695714496076107, -0.04887326434254646, 0.016715599223971367, -0.026289109140634537, 0.006936633959412575, -0.023162612691521645, 0.013508561998605728, 0.008163494057953358, -0.0022186427377164364, -0.044153038412332535, -0.028554100543260574, -0.023555267602205276, -0.022151950746774673, -0.01879817433655262, -0.014589628204703331, 0.0019177771173417568, -0.01862100139260292, -0.02187025547027588, -0.009416020475327969, 0.03535858169198036, -0.052430324256420135, -0.021334202960133553, -0.011681223288178444, -0.00846206396818161, 0.0516849011182785, -0.03760886564850807, -0.006120896898210049, 0.007962159812450409, -0.04128509387373924, -0.034935954958200455, 0.020396418869495392, 0.011947029270231724, -0.022020990028977394, -0.013661488890647888, -0.049346260726451874, 0.028907813131809235, 0.026515135541558266, 0.029101507738232613, -0.021987590938806534, 0.012902840040624142, -0.03422720357775688, 0.030120698735117912, -0.04037639498710632, -0.0009603642392903566, 0.01686226576566696, 0.017008425667881966, 0.0009694695472717285, 0.00349827972240746, 0.005717836786061525, -0.022990316152572632, -0.0033262819051742554, 0.010224529542028904, -0.009444748051464558, 0.005262420978397131, 0.09342688322067261, -0.042807966470718384, 0.028480947017669678, 0.00326314615085721, -0.0070775458589196205, 0.0460776649415493, 0.009153851307928562, 0.013570807874202728, 0.0066873603500425816, 0.020981691777706146, -0.04457665607333183, -0.00022057941532693803, -0.08422383666038513, 0.0008640922023914754, 0.08293312788009644, -0.02868003584444523, 0.024061810225248337, 0.05285021662712097, -0.04060198366641998, 0.027352776378393173, -0.062103986740112305, 0.0042901672422885895, 0.016596611589193344, 0.02466011606156826, 0.0575111024081707, -0.03178877755999565, -0.014640052802860737, 0.037801072001457214, 0.023174850270152092, 0.012288711965084076, 0.0162575114518404, -0.006388940382748842, -0.01724180579185486, -0.003016581991687417, -0.03171627223491669, -0.059142254292964935, 0.03541634976863861, -0.04653611406683922, 0.02563534677028656, -0.012343749403953552, -0.025913063436746597, 0.07023854553699493, 0.054628338664770126, -0.024647388607263565, -0.05965476483106613, -0.023582614958286285, -0.07568203657865524, -0.0002080267295241356, -0.005420641507953405, -0.023004736751317978, -0.0003357292735017836, -0.03855812922120094, 0.03771137073636055, 0.013543251901865005, 0.04786961153149605, -0.05193096771836281, -0.07358765602111816, -0.002531882608309388, -0.00706634484231472, -0.0195987056940794, 0.029323983937501907, -0.015491834841668606, -0.016827434301376343, 0.023983020335435867, -0.07329078763723373, 0.005335897672921419, 0.01575464941561222, 0.04271316155791283, 0.027288958430290222, 0.059062808752059937, -0.017609352245926857, -0.019668826833367348, 0.010756103321909904, -0.04322892054915428, 0.12934204936027527, 0.08581244945526123, -0.0009888383792713284, -0.037774160504341125, 0.031022755429148674, 0.038810186088085175, 0.005828467663377523, -0.0075631472282111645, 0.008640921674668789, -0.026180298998951912, -0.0026560169644653797, 0.04160713404417038, 0.047069888561964035, -0.010167737491428852, -0.008253374136984348, 0.005936414934694767, -0.052647314965724945, 0.010166388005018234, -0.011733048595488071, 0.029691215604543686, 0.03420640155673027, 0.008609665557742119, -0.045931365340948105, -0.015261977910995483, -0.004846789874136448, -0.006967789959162474, -0.02424394153058529, -0.023604823276400566, -0.008257049135863781, -0.0050491150468587875, -0.034878358244895935, 0.030009303241968155, 0.01473261695355177, 0.01340998150408268, -0.04114334285259247, 0.02131607197225094, 0.025042133405804634, -0.02017240598797798, 0.012472405098378658, 0.016262609511613846, -0.030610620975494385, 0.03855057805776596, 0.022517604753375053, -0.00603776378557086, -0.03345436602830887, 0.0026731586549431086, -0.029389604926109314, 0.062363021075725555, 0.036405060440301895, -0.027318676933646202, -0.04140220209956169, 0.024762580171227455, 0.009540761820971966, -0.04780362546443939, 0.0037140410859137774, 0.04609563574194908, -0.010307925753295422, 0.005232765804976225, -0.04784334823489189, -0.02008221670985222, 0.02963847853243351, 0.0035020867362618446, 0.039518967270851135, 0.0033236125018447638, -0.017072167247533798, -0.02404782548546791, -0.04637709632515907, 0.06490382552146912, -0.01770731806755066, 0.03214632347226143, 0.04113546013832092, -0.016422122716903687, -0.0004275705141481012, -0.023507002741098404, 0.022019701078534126, 0.008909706957638264, 0.02870921976864338, -0.011372935958206654, -0.005404395051300526, -0.05033040791749954, -0.02710503526031971, -0.013439904898405075, -0.013877886347472668, 0.02187655307352543, -0.04881134256720543, -0.01972767896950245, 0.01181214302778244, 0.03277972340583801, 0.02377297356724739, 0.005148342344909906, 0.023069679737091064, 0.05769125372171402, -0.005253009498119354, -0.03701341524720192, -0.028465617448091507, 0.006876013707369566, -0.016211995854973793, -0.027492903172969818, -0.012694926001131535, 0.04059050977230072, -0.009939595125615597, 0.016141703352332115, 0.013352029956877232, 0.053482506424188614, -0.01597892865538597, -0.027332287281751633, 0.018963763490319252, -0.0289484690874815, 0.02933691255748272, 0.04516012594103813, -0.038045164197683334, -0.008112438954412937, 0.02022549882531166, -0.007750570308417082, -0.024147259071469307, -0.005646983627229929, -0.014217853546142578, -0.020146645605564117, 0.04015490785241127, -0.05465548858046532, 0.06362075358629227, -0.005228839349001646, -0.04928608983755112, -0.059451691806316376, 0.029075080528855324, -0.0036426063161343336, -0.05290249362587929, -0.0380547009408474, 0.01393342949450016, -0.013996051624417305, 0.0051970407366752625, 0.03720923885703087, 0.015867242589592934, 0.036828186362981796, -0.05939512699842453, 0.053814105689525604, -0.02497829683125019, 0.046916015446186066, 0.029675357043743134, -0.023191412910819054, -0.021825488656759262, -0.004457693547010422, -0.017557309940457344, 0.007868940941989422, 0.030995698645710945, 0.02198733761906624, 0.02923327125608921, 0.018841644749045372, -0.0250532329082489, 0.06185862794518471, -0.01828276365995407, 0.002319152234122157, 0.0014536106027662754, 0.009999018162488937, 0.016551610082387924, -0.04289659857749939, 0.004183531738817692, -0.00264356704428792, 0.002136070979759097, 0.02569516748189926, 0.01651019975543022, -0.03562474995851517, -0.03140147402882576, -0.0009065949125215411, -0.024191541597247124, 0.0011350706918165088, -0.01788475550711155, -0.01930326409637928, 0.00865682028234005, 0.03894821181893349, -0.018957586959004402, 0.06168247014284134, 0.009823469445109367, 0.041820138692855835, -0.08833355456590652, -0.021050771698355675, 0.011369015090167522, 0.018602320924401283, 0.022548403590917587, -0.026985181495547295, 0.006859034765511751, 0.05526193231344223, -0.06914596259593964, 0.014321570284664631, 0.020049333572387695, 0.007855720818042755, -0.04624633118510246, -0.006166643463075161, 0.012848037295043468, 0.011412916705012321, 0.021512918174266815, 0.009960856288671494, 0.05360392481088638, 0.006656005047261715, -0.027284588664770126, -0.06013491749763489, -0.024149999022483826, 0.02790536917746067, -0.017775380983948708, -0.06090538948774338, 0.03241854906082153, -0.009475446306169033, 0.00302294478751719, 0.0034443943295627832, -0.018321385607123375, 0.006880012806504965, 0.0027588428929448128, 0.043000947684049606, -0.0015987236984074116, 0.02770189568400383, -0.00035942974500358105, -0.01802241988480091, 0.012900260277092457, 0.00210833502933383, 0.014152124524116516, 0.020185979083180428, 0.02409989759325981, 0.018452946096658707, -0.000807223201263696, 0.022838514298200607, -0.044289104640483856, 0.007792068645358086, -0.009592674672603607, -0.011332204565405846, -0.017878388985991478, -0.015745630487799644, -0.009567382745444775, -0.033978864550590515, -0.0000695800845278427, -0.059103310108184814, 0.00008820146467769518, 0.0189328882843256, -0.014992225915193558, -0.04603966698050499, 0.016569672152400017, -0.004123803693801165, -0.020349683240056038, -0.02863328345119953, -0.012415200471878052, 0.004436810966581106, -0.04401522874832153, -0.0011150396894663572, 0.025372624397277832, -0.026987669989466667, -0.020952263846993446, -0.011630167253315449, -0.03628089278936386, 0.02394036017358303, 0.01944858580827713, -0.015603996813297272, 0.009608130902051926, -0.015744727104902267, 0.001875865156762302, -0.08842054754495621, 0.028771115466952324, 0.021081818267703056, -0.03743165731430054, -0.02325543947517872, -0.015691600739955902, 0.001538124750368297, 0.0385148786008358, 0.03937649726867676, 0.020545076578855515, -0.011855070479214191, -0.016348572447896004, 0.025095269083976746, 0.010541786439716816, -0.03379637002944946, 0.029836148023605347, 0.04305554926395416, 0.02024937979876995, 0.011869221925735474, 0.011308664456009865, -0.001188734662719071, 0.007692655082792044, -0.00021490687504410744, 0.00809929147362709, 0.023166358470916748, -0.0015468909405171871, 0.018335435539484024, 0.00940070953220129, 0.008014965802431107, -0.013690313324332237, 0.03701774403452873, 0.007607799954712391, -0.015134226530790329, 0.050266459584236145, 0.004627031274139881, -0.06470400840044022, -0.012777740135788918, 0.004218658898025751, -0.006984542589634657, 0.0049343956634402275, 0.0031597448978573084, 0.015192204155027866, -0.05917824059724808, 0.018558291718363762, 0.00856038834899664, -0.039106547832489014, 0.014463448897004128, 0.012161783874034882, 0.030293971300125122, 0.016013652086257935, -0.0010068445699289441, 0.053500063717365265, 0.056894637644290924, -0.05656922236084938, 0.06033572554588318, 0.019533779472112656, 0.009841112419962883, 0.02159140817821026, -0.010094007477164268, 0.0448942556977272, 0.025398660451173782, 0.007708227261900902, -0.0038756863214075565, 0.014842077158391476, -0.03735844045877457, -0.019969459623098373, -0.002057128818705678, -0.010822116397321224, -0.015050084330141544, -0.001986172515898943, 0.02962331846356392, 0.026872599497437477, -0.009276836179196835, -0.03674749284982681, -0.007832104340195656, 0.040129683911800385, -0.06093871593475342, -0.006968196015805006, 0.016223376616835594, 0.021556641906499863, 0.010668479837477207, -0.046814240515232086, -0.023188641294836998, -0.02750837430357933, 0.0025986097753047943, -0.013798965141177177, 0.010065823793411255, 0.03072703815996647, -0.0000070510168370674364, 0.007939736358821392, -0.027321893721818924, -0.019845465198159218, -0.01822495087981224, 0.03836428374052048, 0.015788089483976364, 0.012265154160559177, -0.028588108718395233, -0.02960919216275215, -0.014924107119441032, 0.042851392179727554, -0.07080002874135971, -0.05219311639666557, -0.024486735463142395, 0.011317062191665173, 0.00321243517100811, -0.005096806678920984 ]
<p>Both bootstrap and jackknife methods can be used to estimate bias and standard error of an estimate and mechanisms of both resampling methods are not huge different: sampling with replacement vs. leave out one observation at a time. However, jackknife is not as popular as bootstrap in research and practice. My question is that is there any obvious advantage to use bootstrap instead of using jackknife? Many thanks in advance</p>
74,226
[ -0.011287536472082138, -0.013734572567045689, -0.009900213219225407, -0.004886166658252478, 0.00273616099730134, 0.03164921700954437, 0.007683741394430399, -0.02801649644970894, 0.009854939766228199, -0.016825465485453606, 0.033585693687200546, 0.02590608224272728, 0.030833028256893158, 0.007973948493599892, 0.0208065714687109, -0.002568301511928439, -0.003197351936250925, -0.0050387256778776646, -0.0011774800950661302, -0.024571111425757408, 0.0015600542537868023, 0.03220614045858383, 0.004717844072729349, 0.019102977588772774, -0.007761100772768259, 0.026562992483377457, 0.014021715149283409, -0.013572273775935173, 0.014325756579637527, 0.07593425363302231, -0.0005087363533675671, -0.010126926004886627, 0.010319515131413937, 0.063853919506073, -0.005835134536027908, -0.029665539041161537, -0.02172181010246277, -0.06377729028463364, -0.008615140803158283, 0.043857526034116745, -0.07322406768798828, 0.016293352469801903, -0.014528729021549225, -0.013146480545401573, 0.005301567260175943, 0.03196658939123154, -0.012058193795382977, -0.05898921564221382, 0.0023789359256625175, -0.048143595457077026, 0.027906974777579308, -0.02744951657950878, 0.024880480021238327, 0.046414073556661606, -0.007524881511926651, 0.023863520473241806, 0.02807397022843361, 0.02880641259253025, -0.014541358686983585, -0.04901755601167679, -0.016371600329875946, -0.024662643671035767, -0.004579875618219376, 0.016484592109918594, -0.03446317836642265, 0.034498557448387146, -0.024406079202890396, -0.038985054939985275, 0.018568266183137894, -0.01580745168030262, 0.0019679598044604063, 0.004016518127173185, 0.05560670047998428, 0.0019641760736703873, 0.016787167638540268, -0.032087959349155426, -0.010900594294071198, 0.01493861060589552, 0.06043190881609917, 0.06861065328121185, 0.0030397905502468348, -0.013941475190222263, 0.04730312526226044, 0.03397221118211746, 0.03737148270010948, -0.018968001008033752, 0.07887440919876099, -0.0713472068309784, 0.03162628784775734, 0.02385723404586315, -0.06487550586462021, -0.011970811523497105, 0.05968913063406944, -0.0076017375104129314, -0.018880629912018776, 0.007100855931639671, 0.014313564635813236, 0.052189163863658905, -0.0027457429096102715, -0.017255187034606934, 0.010190458968281746, -0.015266806818544865, 0.026680845767259598, 0.040019240230321884, 0.015291969291865826, -0.0069863684475421906, -0.046143632382154465, 0.02720968797802925, -0.0044048321433365345, -0.03642915189266205, -0.018757835030555725, -0.0025994544848799706, -0.0077625783160328865, 0.01552602183073759, 0.05882139876484871, 0.012884796597063541, -0.006564464420080185, -0.010181397199630737, 0.039636239409446716, 0.06393846124410629, 0.04833363741636276, -0.014433207921683788, -0.004301370587199926, -0.01909974217414856, -0.03761276602745056, 0.039482999593019485, 0.019548583775758743, -0.04186674952507019, -0.03788246214389801, 0.051780059933662415, 0.02932247705757618, -0.031776268035173416, 0.06883546710014343, 0.014039640314877033, 0.03634776920080185, -0.008275668136775494, -0.08827917277812958, -0.07538830488920212, 0.06548010557889938, -0.003886957187205553, 0.04461279138922691, -0.04195929691195488, 0.015933265909552574, 0.003023493569344282, 0.02673356980085373, 0.0333641916513443, 0.05036076530814171, 0.007198911625891924, 0.011160985566675663, 0.028799111023545265, -0.035173747688531876, 0.007946373894810677, -0.009132802486419678, -0.01543388795107603, -0.0009138467139564455, -0.09436152130365372, -0.0015608788235113025, -0.028068846091628075, -0.011560474522411823, -0.044485967606306076, 0.03417229279875755, -0.011067138984799385, -0.008791297674179077, 0.013566340319812298, 0.019361820071935654, -0.012216700240969658, 0.07296599447727203, -0.050951726734638214, 0.037498876452445984, -0.012551432475447655, 0.0023219501599669456, 0.025861520320177078, 0.029583703726530075, 0.0013116042828187346, 0.02508622407913208, -0.056311752647161484, -0.00366014800965786, -0.024227697402238846, 0.00015010790957603604, 0.0069735050201416016, -0.04584575816988945, 0.01576702855527401, 0.010943679139018059, -0.010229560546576977, -0.00900083314627409, 0.056903667747974396, 0.027401885017752647, -0.02806747332215309, 0.06487024575471878, -0.053106408566236496, -0.010764596983790398, -0.08009709417819977, -0.009473856538534164, -0.01049466896802187, 0.007097410969436169, 0.05310087651014328, 0.015565047040581703, 0.005232568364590406, -0.021437300369143486, -0.026638967916369438, 0.012671731412410736, -0.00296425330452621, 0.0191312525421381, -0.05223263055086136, 0.01515243574976921, 0.026441629976034164, 0.026172621175646782, -0.03973683342337608, 0.03807363659143448, -0.03246342018246651, -0.04242700710892677, -0.005919029004871845, -0.057804130017757416, -0.0007365082856267691, -0.0067587425000965595, -0.02294682338833809, 0.019761929288506508, 0.0014104709262028337, -0.01836543157696724, 0.06893333047628403, -0.029483797028660774, 0.062384914606809616, 0.04849563166499138, 0.00487565528601408, -0.01183074340224266, 0.02316856198012829, 0.022899415343999863, 0.014569027349352837, -0.01261902879923582, -0.006804810371249914, -0.06503184884786606, -0.009310598485171795, 0.03240564838051796, 0.003756643971428275, -0.04799678921699524, 0.02658710442483425, 0.06691936403512955, -0.015373355709016323, 0.03121432289481163, 0.030034398660063744, 0.00893351063132286, -0.02590913139283657, -0.011679891496896744, 0.04767255485057831, 0.028188742697238922, 0.00950074102729559, 0.014642639085650444, -0.009325257502496243, 0.05397763103246689, 0.03638265281915665, -0.009483401663601398, 0.008226954378187656, 0.0014937943778932095, -0.0015615731244906783, 0.003711784491315484, -0.04484618827700615, 0.012523372657597065, -0.04992995783686638, 0.019876377657055855, 0.05812458693981171, -0.02206757292151451, 0.013550203293561935, 0.00888847652822733, 0.001434992766007781, 0.04512783885002136, 0.013794156722724438, -0.021350158378481865, 0.02540334314107895, 0.015134822577238083, -0.0006682887324132025, -0.00359915429726243, -0.019044511020183563, -0.017077293246984482, -0.03045041859149933, 0.009420722723007202, -0.014025995507836342, -0.026106765493750572, 0.0678132176399231, 0.021489012986421585, -0.0010473643196746707, 0.007999630644917488, -0.0271976999938488, 0.005103497300297022, 0.017553016543388367, -0.03545789793133736, -0.023028654977679253, -0.018267031759023666, -0.019187146797776222, 0.015210873447358608, 0.010451780632138252, 0.012099071405827999, -0.016938313841819763, -0.000564119138289243, -0.0009152261191047728, -0.007793991826474667, 0.0032349543180316687, 0.0245472714304924, 0.0215464998036623, -0.025426480919122696, 0.03190512955188751, 0.04198746010661125, -0.005355122499167919, 0.03061205893754959, -0.05188605561852455, -0.04118001461029053, -0.04969135671854019, 0.006704764440655708, 0.0016776075353845954, -0.0032413452863693237, -0.003753239056095481, 0.024894313886761665, -0.037038564682006836, 0.015671441331505775, -0.03954261541366577, -0.042662061750888824, 0.02980954945087433, 0.01250449102371931, -0.009382392279803753, -0.0017471052706241608, -0.010687390342354774, 0.07456254959106445, 0.04670710116624832, 0.008638654835522175, -0.0010150490561500192, -0.0287855826318264, -0.03775043040513992, 0.03710385039448738, -0.026675671339035034, 0.007305994164198637, 0.018066171556711197, 0.012823869474232197, -0.032075684517621994, 0.017261667177081108, 0.05527660995721817, 0.021158872172236443, 0.007265894208103418, -0.014977761544287205, 0.0023428667336702347, -0.02284172736108303, 0.05545983463525772, 0.0065750982612371445, -0.03814363479614258, -0.01557586994022131, 0.004997271113097668, 0.043328456580638885, 0.0054549346677958965, -0.037992335855960846, 0.0009508791845291853, -0.018908485770225525, 0.0032782857306301594, -0.041160520166158676, 0.023233653977513313, 0.015194381587207317, 0.00682765943929553, 0.003266223706305027, 0.014142830856144428, 0.007411671336740255, -0.0020797362085431814, -0.0033634959254413843, -0.006429100409150124, 0.044547852128744125, -0.0016839237650856376, 0.01880747638642788, -0.04135137423872948, -0.013319538906216621, 0.0376301035284996, -0.012371144257485867, -0.017893347889184952, -0.0051190475933253765, 0.06361151486635208, 0.03689844533801079, -0.01724732294678688, -0.02349824830889702, -0.01587548851966858, -0.06118256598711014, 0.022936634719371796, -0.026363283395767212, 0.050552546977996826, -0.023792432621121407, 0.048293162137269974, -0.00003363661380717531, -0.004580879583954811, -0.011905834078788757, -0.026104969903826714, -0.050277259200811386, 0.03507581353187561, -0.04847860708832741, -0.011269869282841682, 0.017104176804423332, -0.02459702454507351, 0.04142218083143234, -0.018890291452407837, 0.020771564915776253, -0.016611916944384575, 0.025689782574772835, -0.006366258952766657, 0.009290175512433052, -0.004532338120043278, 0.007858723402023315, -0.010866472497582436, 0.007371972780674696, 0.029660668224096298, -0.03867994248867035, 0.04138306900858879, 0.011304103769361973, -0.005726037546992302, -0.04341081902384758, -0.019398659467697144, 0.0496523380279541, 0.02700904756784439, 0.02632550336420536, 0.04946756362915039, 0.023290637880563736, -0.04550857096910477, 0.014344299212098122, 0.012142621912062168, 0.057056985795497894, 0.015340344049036503, -0.03158532455563545, -0.014754094183444977, -0.05659184232354164, -0.03289428725838661, -0.019973132759332657, 0.0057404739782214165, 0.017408328130841255, -0.011206786148250103, 0.07560853660106659, -0.02111201174557209, -0.02849326655268669, -0.0019225196447223425, 0.0707070529460907, -0.0012504361802712083, 0.009440012276172638, -0.021816132590174675, 0.021876171231269836, -0.012288939207792282, -0.02275620400905609, 0.05043186619877815, 0.01182573288679123, -0.017574522644281387, -0.008042117580771446, 0.03252377361059189, 0.009521501138806343, -0.028400402516126633, 0.009953787550330162, 0.0557500384747982, 0.045434944331645966, 0.020340386778116226, -0.028350776061415672, 0.015102941542863846, 0.02347153052687645, 0.009295519441366196, 0.002159487921744585, -0.02335161156952381, -0.0639897882938385, 0.019869085401296616, 0.027867434546351433, 0.004582097753882408, -0.08284533768892288, 0.0027037945110350847, -0.03529171645641327, -0.013415190391242504, 0.02965477481484413, -0.03306612744927406, 0.006249124184250832, -0.01870870403945446, -0.0052684941329061985, -0.02503070794045925, -0.021613193675875664, -0.02819743938744068, 0.01901586912572384, -0.03854389116168022, 0.0011155862594023347, -0.029159722849726677, -0.03091142699122429, -0.04647735133767128, 0.005047305021435022, 0.014188154600560665, 0.06269606202840805, -0.019439948722720146, -0.010018606670200825, 0.011374673806130886, 0.0265043955296278, -0.02695489674806595, -0.0647922083735466, 0.008984720334410667, -0.0013170712627470493, 0.0009812959469854832, 0.026133453473448753, 0.016510773450136185, -0.07257356494665146, 0.018332699313759804, -0.019043058156967163, -0.023592298850417137, -0.043394897133111954, -0.0029610400088131428, -0.020367350429296494, 0.03157222270965576, -0.008979648351669312, 0.07642798125743866, 0.027283156290650368, -0.015907593071460724, -0.016743186861276627, -0.011223471723496914, 0.02049502544105053, -0.04775131866335869, -0.006392649840563536, -0.015926232561469078, -0.0346832200884819, -0.06614115834236145, 0.0630711168050766, 0.007753117475658655, 0.05949277803301811, 0.0007180158863775432, -0.00904139131307602, 0.019735660403966904, 0.03447772189974785, 0.0030475500971078873, 0.021906232461333275, -0.003636234439909458, 0.028518199920654297, -0.006923492066562176, -0.03461373224854469, -0.0013949136482551694, -0.015593278221786022, -0.02604822814464569, 0.010888269171118736, -0.06745316088199615, -0.00021534196275752038, -0.05205979570746422, -0.05460400506854057, 0.03310321271419525, -0.022441715002059937, 0.03521836921572685, -0.0116188395768404, 0.023121442645788193, -0.03476276621222496, -0.08408122509717941, 0.007859849371016026, 0.02995268628001213, -0.004997246898710728, 0.02807624079287052, -0.05567271634936333, 0.05715573579072952, 0.0021075529512017965, -0.007318273186683655, -0.101495660841465, -0.05500362813472748, 0.013973668217658997, 0.010885709896683693, -0.012902607209980488, 0.0031122821383178234, 0.03270593285560608, -0.021417001262307167, -0.022878533229231834, -0.025463156402111053, 0.06314592063426971, 0.0001219895711983554, -0.020285822451114655, -0.013325516134500504, 0.02068399451673031, 0.06925952434539795, -0.004146890249103308, -0.018722640350461006, -0.005739443004131317, -0.03447899594902992, -0.00968831218779087, -0.011819317005574703, 0.04222406819462776, -0.03809728845953941, 0.003312826156616211, -0.03035285882651806, -0.030314184725284576, 0.006789755541831255, -0.025342244654893875, -0.005191985983401537, 0.041267573833465576, 0.01630251482129097, 0.008642729371786118, -0.03795165941119194, -0.04059838876128197, -0.029947003349661827, 0.004301000386476517, -0.004214686807245016, 0.021397409960627556, 0.01724151149392128, -0.001971242716535926, 0.03509403020143509, 0.0087504917755723, -0.025638408958911896, 0.0011546042514964938, 0.04558386653661728, -0.016667746007442474, 0.014447597786784172, -0.008009265176951885, -0.050795089453458786, 0.03307139500975609, 0.001491231843829155, 0.01205406803637743, 0.03593527525663376, -0.0017334831645712256, -0.004816683940589428, -0.031931545585393906, -0.011187324300408363, 0.023220516741275787, 0.04999588802456856, 0.016901539638638496, 0.0407499298453331, 0.05107761174440384, -0.002027692971751094, 0.021988658234477043, -0.022828388959169388, 0.036347754299640656, -0.00867089070379734, -0.03645067289471626, 0.05049528926610947, 0.011943493969738483, 0.019400978460907936, 0.054689716547727585, -0.0005235859425738454, 0.028029974550008774, 0.04874834790825844, 0.036673031747341156, 0.04278877004981041, 0.013070984743535519, 0.008476322516798973, -0.005465187132358551, 0.05288369581103325, -0.03907414898276329, 0.0087444968521595, -0.035239700227975845, -0.024762369692325592, 0.0664166808128357, 0.03957880288362503, 0.006540926173329353, -0.02925584279000759, -0.03097430057823658, -0.0513659231364727, -0.01295152585953474, -0.0316702276468277, -0.011805622838437557, 0.01569555699825287, 0.023263124749064445, 0.005210030823945999, -0.033967964351177216, 0.03164052963256836, -0.013948909938335419, -0.11305307596921921, -0.02511400356888771, -0.014210623688995838, -0.06163671612739563, 0.025793690234422684, -0.015224190428853035, -0.04120407998561859, 0.04189467057585716, -0.022169779986143112, 0.025412600487470627, -0.017304429784417152, 0.025505876168608665, -0.008892536163330078, 0.07230106741189957, 0.01543976366519928, 0.019919520244002342, -0.005739275831729174, 0.009863292798399925, 0.09393879026174545, 0.10068748891353607, 0.04733281955122948, -0.07238137722015381, 0.047327689826488495, -0.028549009934067726, 0.02179168537259102, -0.024350224062800407, 0.028755636885762215, 0.026515303179621696, 0.006876668427139521, 0.012336460873484612, 0.030090879648923874, -0.01340815145522356, -0.032819122076034546, 0.02764485776424408, -0.04512278735637665, 0.0053673735819756985, 0.010622034780681133, -0.0026136385276913643, 0.007456204388290644, 0.006513549480587244, -0.0394856333732605, 0.011551734060049057, -0.027801934629678726, -0.03297574073076248, -0.010427698493003845, -0.028323058038949966, -0.007440146058797836, 0.0032301575411111116, -0.037021566182374954, 0.006258134264498949, -0.0035478384234011173, 0.01754842884838581, -0.015661578625440598, 0.02502400055527687, -0.0020281693432480097, -0.022426938638091087, -0.002393901813775301, 0.043330274522304535, 0.022770773619413376, -0.00827227532863617, -0.027264675125479698, 0.01797306351363659, -0.026098554953932762, 0.005368586163967848, -0.03155909478664398, 0.04504736140370369, -0.011281031183898449, 0.014951043762266636, -0.03206142038106918, 0.0023280803579837084, -0.005404779687523842, -0.05463242903351784, -0.0038236542604863644, 0.017073538154363632, 0.008508886210620403, -0.04497931897640228, -0.0285651832818985, -0.03339599445462227, 0.02300962805747986, -0.021228287369012833, 0.01809493452310562, 0.03288611024618149, -0.039099156856536865, -0.042908914387226105, 0.019175950437784195, 0.0038752055261284113, -0.00801845546811819, -0.037027910351753235, 0.011802978813648224, 0.022053448483347893, -0.050565168261528015, 0.0011374733876436949, 0.01541654672473669, 0.009445114061236382, 0.062326040118932724, -0.05722102150321007, 0.0029986491426825523, -0.04061968997120857, -0.04920683428645134, 0.022638699039816856, -0.015651065856218338, 0.00752341328188777, -0.02411169931292534, -0.0021718258503824472, 0.0442281998693943, 0.004151845350861549, 0.0073709567077457905, -0.02315952442586422, -0.012252557091414928, 0.02713274583220482, 0.013702667318284512, -0.06445590406656265, -0.013723896816372871, -0.024656087160110474, -0.031605370342731476, -0.01780669204890728, -0.02270861715078354, 0.06345270574092865, 0.011095031164586544, 0.026199163869023323, -0.007530386094003916, 0.04862599074840546, 0.03551916405558586, 0.020020077005028725, 0.0446770153939724, -0.04756125435233116, -0.004139681346714497, 0.04229997470974922, 0.006599096115678549, -0.006990069989115, -0.01146559976041317, -0.027627620846033096, -0.0053961556404829025, -0.01136005949229002, -0.030432233586907387, -0.038081031292676926, -0.016366468742489815, -0.03501058742403984, 0.025156838819384575, -0.04263099655508995, -0.03277041018009186, -0.038049958646297455, -0.00018729711882770061, -0.008681376464664936, -0.027699816972017288, 0.012451079674065113, -0.02113948203623295, 0.01994672417640686, 0.012404439970850945, 0.04881758615374565, 0.007868857122957706, 0.00613918574526906, 0.004683270584791899, 0.01902306266129017, 0.011749285273253918, 0.03284705802798271, -0.04595695436000824, 0.041483260691165924, 0.04871164634823799, -0.05867461860179901, -0.027858706191182137, 0.024264020845294, 0.01221928559243679, 0.012718799524009228, 0.003399819601327181, -0.009196169674396515, -0.01460812147706747, 0.018083512783050537, -0.0345972403883934, -0.02639620751142502, -0.029297910630702972, -0.013990766368806362, 0.015840236097574234, -0.009052270092070103, -0.01278930064290762, -0.028471436351537704, -0.022599583491683006, 0.07127825170755386, 0.0433218814432621, 0.023078858852386475, -0.013171151280403137, 0.007788045797497034, 0.02639971487224102, 0.02854829467833042, -0.0181239265948534, -0.00489194318652153, 0.038821689784526825, 0.05918651819229126, -0.057291481643915176, 0.018962716683745384, -0.008534299209713936, -0.0013988867867738008, -0.06266321241855621, -0.016939647495746613, -0.0052854809910058975, 0.009974646382033825, -0.0028400919400155544, -0.018578417599201202, 0.019264204427599907, 0.034239187836647034, -0.012497871182858944, 0.005645596422255039, -0.00123804179020226, -0.012079538777470589, -0.036162227392196655, -0.014020624570548534, 0.010370069183409214, 0.008509556762874126, 0.0346367210149765, -0.01145938690751791, -0.006161385681480169, 0.026636512950062752, 0.0015827046008780599, -0.011084984987974167, -0.029070096090435982, 0.011546820402145386, -0.0009015995892696083, -0.08219651132822037, 0.010295139625668526, -0.03561529889702797, -0.045445963740348816, 0.07183980941772461, 0.04388691857457161, 0.029742633923888206, -0.01400575041770935, 0.02855088748037815, 0.008138487115502357, 0.03908336162567139, 0.030219385400414467, 0.0009208371629938483, -0.025684073567390442, 0.008260279893875122, 0.022336551919579506, 0.015797115862369537, 0.008660617284476757, 0.031498394906520844, 0.005009602289646864, -0.018013402819633484, -0.013253489509224892, 0.02609611116349697, 0.021280590444803238, -0.050609439611434937, 0.0010801656171679497, 0.007375057321041822, 0.037839166820049286, 0.02999735251069069, 0.017900587990880013, -0.06356547027826309, 0.042188145220279694, 0.055113159120082855, 0.02416224591434002, -0.024291671812534332, 0.01455614808946848, -0.0053191701881587505, -0.019305933266878128, 0.007100970949977636, -0.014764244668185711, -0.02124670520424843, -0.026309607550501823, 0.0027101831510663033, 0.0158708393573761, 0.02681995928287506, 0.0025463865604251623, -0.01831149496138096, 0.0019892414566129446, 0.04305874928832054, -0.05433391407132149, 0.006334132049232721, 0.040484849363565445, 0.03926017880439758, 0.00123625248670578, -0.09465400874614716, 0.11155801266431808, -0.008082603104412556, -0.021539514884352684, -0.03727462515234947, -0.002815898973494768, -0.023259423673152924, -0.01904413104057312, 0.07537639141082764, 0.008287402801215649, 0.0070409285835921764, -0.016979357227683067, 0.035032059997320175, -0.008555836975574493, -0.026690540835261345, 0.04836449772119522, -0.0008946469170041382, 0.006012349389493465, -0.010567729361355305, -0.02506212703883648, 0.022557290270924568, 0.02760918065905571, 0.02211937867105007, -0.03422119840979576, 0.05159109830856323, 0.007680912036448717, 0.04026827588677406, 0.03688475489616394, 0.006548694800585508, -0.029613668099045753, 0.051053330302238464, -0.0059302859008312225, 0.029951302334666252, 0.020091835409402847, -0.0181503314524889, -0.06299398094415665, 0.02111961506307125, -0.02075032889842987, -0.048889558762311935, -0.01375587284564972, -0.02136419340968132, -0.043867357075214386, -0.04669756442308426, -0.028523148968815804, 0.024871591478586197, -0.057432565838098526, 0.021194057539105415, 0.03282025456428528, 0.029836710542440414, 0.015581628307700157, -0.03452076390385628, 0.024129051715135574, 0.010126450099050999, -0.007084255572408438, -0.015008953399956226, 0.013568525202572346, -0.004050776362419128, 0.0195863526314497, -0.00015596456069033593, 0.02144774980843067, 0.0007890581618994474, 0.04065433889627457, -0.012818176299333572, 0.07369297742843628, -0.0018230477580800653, -0.041697245091199875, 0.011217408813536167, -0.008803908713161945, 0.01742057129740715, -0.0024800437968224287, -0.018488183617591858, 0.03826141357421875, -0.032542839646339417, 0.011044490151107311, -0.011409703642129898, -0.03822682052850723, -0.03843070939183235, -0.004597465042024851, -0.018216049298644066, 0.005984792485833168, 0.021988121792674065, 0.0075456732884049416, 0.0211590975522995, 0.0017385885585099459, 0.059962786734104156, -0.018542267382144928, 0.014817537739872932, -0.03475364297628403, -0.005036328453570604, 0.0026178844273090363, -0.013212250545620918, -0.012914987280964851, -0.00959368608891964, 0.018365025520324707, 0.023351578041911125, 0.042790498584508896, -0.006161523517221212, -0.07870583981275558, 0.004567430820316076, 0.046597324311733246, -0.04127630218863487, -0.04188937693834305, -0.03109086863696575, 0.01834743097424507, 0.008725522086024284, -0.013643670827150345 ]
<p>I have 2 daily time-series, each 6 years long. While noisy, they are both clearly periodic (with a frequency of ~1 year), but appear to be out of phase. I would like to estimate the phase difference between these time-series.</p> <p>I've considered fitting curves of the form $a\sin(\frac{2\pi}{365}t - b)$ to each time-series and just comparing the two different values for b, but I suspect there are more elegant (and rigourous!) methods for doing this (perhaps using Fourier transforms?). I would also prefer to have some kind of idea of the uncertainty in my phase difference estimate, if possible.</p> <p>Any help would be much appreciated!</p> <p><strong>Update</strong>: </p> <p><img src="http://imgur.com/v2gWn.jpg" alt="Plot of the two time-series"></p> <p>The shaded regions are 95% CIs.</p> <p>Sample crosscorrelation between the two time-series: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/b249A.jpg" alt="Sample crosscorrelation between the two time-series"></p>
36,970
[ 0.005386051721870899, -0.020447764545679092, -0.005142432637512684, 0.025741025805473328, 0.037471264600753784, -0.011831123381853104, -0.018857693299651146, -0.0017940649995580316, 0.024067441001534462, -0.011143088340759277, 0.04156455770134926, 0.0643894225358963, 0.015168275684118271, 0.026566749438643456, -0.0015072071691974998, -0.005570943001657724, -0.004636050201952457, -0.010536309331655502, -0.026276784017682076, -0.024095624685287476, 0.02583197131752968, 0.007570530287921429, 0.01823132112622261, -0.008085355162620544, -0.0280339065939188, 0.04795338213443756, 0.04078793153166771, -0.01576787792146206, -0.0469534732401371, 0.0748000368475914, -0.045823752880096436, -0.055979128926992416, -0.01319168321788311, 0.05222439020872116, 0.023761412128806114, 0.006863682996481657, -0.016890086233615875, -0.04422562196850777, -0.009816051460802555, 0.06357645243406296, -0.08292905986309052, 0.001728942384943366, -0.020780669525265694, 0.062233682721853256, -0.009990216232836246, -0.012057243846356869, 0.0010289057390764356, -0.007718792650848627, 0.015459727495908737, -0.016289331018924713, 0.06559105217456818, -0.034214768558740616, 0.018038863316178322, -0.005530131980776787, -0.01462810393422842, -0.042371876537799835, 0.06848102807998657, 0.06370135396718979, -0.003960045054554939, -0.06506187468767166, -0.012583953328430653, -0.01709824427962303, -0.007507087662816048, 0.012998128309845924, -0.043642520904541016, -0.005665642209351063, -0.05490848049521446, -0.02655121125280857, -0.004747009836137295, -0.01653589867055416, 0.023422114551067352, 0.023358508944511414, 0.027646830305457115, -0.0332060381770134, -0.004428722430020571, -0.05587577074766159, 0.0022288435138761997, 0.07097417861223221, 0.033516403287649155, 0.047672729939222336, -0.022433016449213028, 0.014121358282864094, 0.004892900586128235, -0.0051096160896122456, 0.027148839086294174, 0.010774054564535618, 0.07621896266937256, -0.010778437368571758, 0.00489872507750988, 0.027326103299856186, 0.007993783801794052, 0.0036750799044966698, 0.04749014601111412, 0.0008002255926840007, -0.0189120601862669, 0.02036234363913536, -0.012935435399413109, 0.016808798536658287, 0.0016661816043779254, -0.02700640819966793, 0.006045682821422815, -0.06612873077392578, 0.035498157143592834, 0.09382268786430359, 0.008994429372251034, -0.0059211766347289085, 0.027895908802747726, -0.0009985469514504075, -0.01517560239881277, -0.04293809458613396, -0.012874000705778599, 0.009663050062954426, 0.011593412607908249, -0.01973797380924225, -0.0018238946795463562, 0.011880568228662014, -0.0075341747142374516, -0.019524453207850456, 0.04445802792906761, 0.05033574998378754, 0.07924346625804901, -0.013302847743034363, 0.015633873641490936, -0.028086407110095024, -0.04689327999949455, -0.013167374767363071, 0.004145414102822542, 0.016637960448861122, -0.05578877776861191, 0.07770045846700668, -0.007141636218875647, -0.00970705971121788, 0.02056651934981346, -0.03437041491270065, 0.004129759967327118, 0.02970227040350437, -0.0979548990726471, -0.03256184235215187, 0.05420127511024475, -0.018017839640378952, -0.00371418334543705, -0.06417915970087051, 0.036170441657304764, 0.007879646494984627, 0.07941392809152603, 0.014441841281950474, 0.023082152009010315, 0.014251269400119781, 0.05152356997132301, 0.012267407961189747, -0.021407442167401314, 0.013282331638038158, 0.005371671169996262, -0.030021464452147484, -0.01451482530683279, -0.058953117579221725, -0.008646833710372448, 0.03360206261277199, 0.0025955194141715765, -0.0034773945808410645, 0.018288586288690567, 0.035596877336502075, -0.04122771695256233, 0.00893638376146555, 0.0463251955807209, -0.05536644160747528, 0.0451534129679203, 0.0022161060478538275, -0.01268973108381033, 0.022622786462306976, 0.005019248928874731, 0.024765990674495697, 0.029624825343489647, 0.020053010433912277, 0.07151785492897034, -0.006378745194524527, 0.030166756361722946, 0.01217630971223116, -0.013505333103239536, -0.00466701528057456, -0.02042115293443203, -0.028175512328743935, -0.03744614124298096, -0.026743050664663315, 0.008014208637177944, 0.056420039385557175, -0.010050567798316479, -0.004906002897769213, 0.02123819850385189, -0.03230633586645126, -0.038357142359018326, -0.0415496900677681, -0.01437410805374384, -0.0099398298189044, -0.022671036422252655, 0.03659485653042793, 0.007048348430544138, 0.002239616820588708, -0.010634848847985268, -0.05649133399128914, 0.008254582062363625, 0.01772480644285679, 0.022427169606089592, -0.0498884879052639, 0.030789103358983994, 0.0411885604262352, 0.0387282595038414, 0.007013456430286169, 0.03460148349404335, -0.043957050889730453, -0.012363044545054436, -0.005274592898786068, -0.05614926293492317, 0.003700723173096776, -0.019457384943962097, -0.01856948621571064, 0.03408335521817207, 0.0003540254256222397, -0.005664086434990168, 0.014788289554417133, -0.031534500420093536, 0.04168553650379181, 0.0496799573302269, 0.011034962721168995, 0.015433592721819878, 0.0313088484108448, 0.06451763212680817, 0.05540371686220169, -0.009061365388333797, -0.04170253127813339, -0.05120698735117912, 0.015790831297636032, 0.0506867878139019, 0.013513894751667976, -0.028299132362008095, 0.010957563295960426, 0.05106478929519653, 0.009375120513141155, -0.0049003432504832745, 0.04111598804593086, 0.006853113416582346, -0.044821079820394516, -0.0001773544354364276, 0.018582265824079514, -0.005458093713968992, 0.0018460849532857537, 0.029318775981664658, -0.015436502173542976, 0.026930071413517, -0.024953847751021385, -0.013762707822024822, 0.014289080165326595, -0.02026502601802349, 0.01806812919676304, -0.003193040145561099, -0.01547021884471178, 0.04980166628956795, 0.010479298420250416, -0.026776380836963654, -0.0024398115929216146, -0.03029290772974491, -0.021600669249892235, 0.01890360377728939, 0.004335920792073011, 0.0460902564227581, 0.032737355679273605, -0.05425229296088219, 0.01711944118142128, -0.0007412018603645265, -0.04345250502228737, 0.019014805555343628, -0.003596327733248472, -0.02023695781826973, -0.017974121496081352, -0.012750889174640179, 0.026396634057164192, 0.053620822727680206, 0.03981076180934906, -0.036139607429504395, -0.03966044262051582, 0.04336762800812721, -0.0014437446370720863, 0.004191137384623289, 0.005536896176636219, -0.026140853762626648, 0.03127417340874672, 0.03366007283329964, 0.001053200219757855, 0.012856327928602695, 0.018480896949768066, 0.03233126923441887, 0.00958684366196394, 0.02420722134411335, -0.06506230682134628, -0.020698916167020798, -0.00297735258936882, -0.007920672185719013, -0.022756215184926987, 0.010155290365219116, 0.024743109941482544, -0.00853334367275238, -0.036140795797109604, 0.04868197813630104, -0.01953817903995514, 0.012592424638569355, -0.0037028694059699774, 0.012326790951192379, 0.002865385729819536, -0.034553032368421555, -0.0035022867377847433, 0.030713440850377083, 0.025082148611545563, -0.007037711329758167, -0.04929183050990105, -0.06173430010676384, 0.018414316698908806, -0.016321690753102303, 0.01973862014710903, 0.008004465140402317, -0.01169546227902174, 0.07436274737119675, 0.03205995261669159, -0.04911576956510544, -0.020683493465185165, -0.002549427794292569, -0.057789456099271774, 0.0175569336861372, -0.0007782911416143179, 0.019034335389733315, -0.005173498764634132, 0.023052992299199104, 0.0165406484156847, -0.005106083583086729, 0.045005712658166885, 0.047309525310993195, 0.011535047553479671, 0.0040769376792013645, 0.01184048131108284, 0.02302384190261364, 0.04037558287382126, -0.02928861975669861, -0.02961166761815548, -0.015431092120707035, 0.010426424443721771, -0.03409479930996895, 0.028028542175889015, -0.050052836537361145, -0.006759884301573038, -0.03327509015798569, -0.01743234135210514, -0.028398318216204643, 0.032342009246349335, -0.014390967786312103, 0.008753855712711811, -0.049857258796691895, 0.010103478096425533, 0.04242647439241409, 0.028024228289723396, -0.013279138132929802, 0.06947247684001923, 0.02280081808567047, 0.01918237842619419, 0.00398483918979764, -0.038202621042728424, 0.014143588952720165, 0.007787858601659536, -0.026884544640779495, -0.07635494321584702, 0.05932581424713135, 0.016971463337540627, 0.04576515778899193, 0.004515133332461119, -0.01295442320406437, -0.020544974133372307, -0.07138676196336746, -0.027172308415174484, -0.03995293378829956, 0.04537080228328705, 0.017783425748348236, 0.06533457338809967, 0.022980688139796257, 0.00027304518152959645, 0.01715695858001709, 0.0187656432390213, -0.062092024832963943, 0.0674404725432396, 0.003287999425083399, -0.019428690895438194, -0.011560635641217232, 0.007885204628109932, 0.013864734210073948, -0.01880761981010437, 0.0033309604041278362, -0.02426820434629917, 0.01076954510062933, -0.04325505346059799, -0.006943234708160162, -0.006133337039500475, -0.020526906475424767, 0.0006364266737364233, -0.0011120480485260487, 0.0032298315782099962, -0.03098704293370247, 0.03749508410692215, 0.043326761573553085, 0.016122138127684593, -0.010036401450634003, -0.040333524346351624, 0.01754867099225521, -0.020975574851036072, 0.029298273846507072, 0.016288219019770622, 0.05059931054711342, -0.03727863356471062, -0.0012927590869367123, 0.011986978352069855, 0.039961446076631546, 0.05136750638484955, -0.007297475356608629, -0.017726875841617584, -0.05989714339375496, 0.003947919234633446, 0.0397113636136055, 0.020237784832715988, -0.018543729558587074, 0.00861905887722969, 0.027638109400868416, -0.004665336571633816, -0.0072767529636621475, 0.02674233540892601, 0.04084882512688637, 0.004524317104369402, 0.01861918345093727, -0.05222199112176895, -0.041033416986465454, 0.0065903253853321075, -0.020669540390372276, 0.05715488642454147, 0.007642677053809166, 0.010666746646165848, -0.02724708989262581, 0.03891166299581528, 0.03403586521744728, -0.014470960944890976, 0.0071855103597044945, 0.007513805758208036, 0.017878033220767975, 0.024151155725121498, -0.017307424917817116, 0.02000870741903782, 0.017968637868762016, 0.06248397007584572, 0.03264084830880165, 0.034153394401073456, -0.11630600690841675, -0.043214134871959686, 0.025322703644633293, 0.03162556141614914, -0.033849939703941345, -0.062279727309942245, -0.054046642035245895, -0.02908919006586075, 0.051568299531936646, -0.012920309789478779, 0.01284728106111288, 0.006906003225594759, 0.043141499161720276, -0.03458619490265846, -0.01739276759326458, -0.02860039472579956, 0.0015818868996575475, -0.009124169126152992, -0.0017772497376427054, -0.02427886612713337, -0.063775435090065, 0.00043607785482890904, -0.003954582381993532, 0.02736606076359749, 0.038072556257247925, -0.02011423371732235, -0.03413597494363785, 0.007980836555361748, 0.01481558009982109, 0.0029464082326740026, -0.05757341906428337, 0.013108680956065655, -0.01676139235496521, -0.008649549447000027, 0.07148045301437378, -0.056581586599349976, -0.036081019788980484, 0.015208842232823372, -0.009407487697899342, 0.009895866736769676, -0.01797664538025856, -0.03145261108875275, 0.049194201827049255, 0.012268158607184887, 0.038646526634693146, 0.0704723373055458, 0.03495187312364578, 0.02900151163339615, -0.019004013389348984, 0.02368360199034214, 0.04266709089279175, -0.008526784367859364, 0.00022770259238313884, -0.011385070160031319, -0.005116347689181566, -0.032165493816137314, 0.05269153416156769, -0.007075094617903233, 0.037815939635038376, -0.0025954502634704113, -0.03907430171966553, 0.0024326166603714228, 0.01770058274269104, -0.028791235759854317, 0.02402474358677864, 0.03545498102903366, -0.00033015027293004096, -0.03980393707752228, -0.019531933590769768, 0.006684521213173866, -0.030997294932603836, -0.010380116291344166, 0.016691945493221283, -0.030496638268232346, 0.03558594360947609, -0.05624891817569733, 0.005440035369247198, -0.012744399718940258, -0.0013962769880890846, 0.023816844448447227, -0.014770878478884697, 0.06359567493200302, 0.02218785509467125, -0.04386378452181816, 0.022511158138513565, -0.0031836845446377993, 0.004471317399293184, 0.046097755432128906, -0.033084042370319366, 0.007390269543975592, 0.03163272887468338, -0.0108469994738698, -0.061264488846063614, -0.07203438878059387, 0.04516568407416344, 0.05111909657716751, -0.030362443998456, -0.05461512878537178, 0.01514715701341629, 0.015581972897052765, 0.007461536675691605, -0.027805961668491364, 0.006204728502780199, 0.008185959421098232, -0.01700742170214653, 0.010941699147224426, 0.006829746998846531, 0.08182165026664734, -0.01955411024391651, 0.04579035937786102, 0.005640072748064995, -0.006353785749524832, -0.024980666115880013, 0.00776878884062171, 0.0443226657807827, -0.04364589974284172, -0.017131702974438667, 0.010846174322068691, -0.017988694831728935, 0.05871971324086189, -0.04403945058584213, -0.04018203169107437, 0.01681462675333023, 0.019979290664196014, 0.015118680894374847, -0.022559242323040962, 0.0025345569010823965, -0.0178998950868845, -0.004156303592026234, -0.04936976730823517, 0.005030025728046894, -0.005264522507786751, -0.041773371398448944, -0.027748964726924896, -0.005223771091550589, -0.07887806743383408, 0.0024622627533972263, 0.04162468761205673, -0.025362692773342133, -0.026789391413331032, 0.005790622904896736, -0.015318437479436398, 0.0067816185764968395, -0.012368157505989075, 0.03602932393550873, 0.05139493569731712, -0.018846889957785606, -0.028920214623212814, -0.05757676810026169, -0.038085974752902985, -0.03152237832546234, 0.07214537262916565, -0.004743658471852541, 0.0644807294011116, 0.042668942362070084, 0.01683884859085083, 0.016462331637740135, 0.005177775397896767, -0.005524739157408476, 0.02121388353407383, -0.01683652400970459, 0.009330757893621922, -0.05646215006709099, -0.016073642298579216, 0.0271702129393816, 0.008383089676499367, -0.006819990463554859, 0.05630035325884819, 0.021558262407779694, 0.039745982736349106, 0.026628531515598297, -0.01365302037447691, -0.048905909061431885, 0.03260524570941925, -0.016173385083675385, 0.04025319963693619, -0.022090835496783257, 0.026504604145884514, 0.03759988769888878, 0.06220267340540886, -0.014576416462659836, -0.02261362038552761, -0.026374680921435356, -0.05043435096740723, 0.0066883922554552555, 0.0318584218621254, -0.005578328389674425, 0.026874542236328125, 0.009643788449466228, 0.017535245046019554, 0.01894393563270569, 0.03457063436508179, -0.04383127763867378, -0.05324132367968559, 0.003850474487990141, -0.0123315853998065, -0.0668669044971466, 0.07145625352859497, -0.020649462938308716, -0.02521289512515068, 0.030804680660367012, -0.02809620462357998, 0.015846844762563705, 0.02667963318526745, 0.0302658062428236, -0.010903040878474712, 0.08195459842681885, -0.022943714633584023, -0.013414859771728516, -0.005975557025521994, 0.0046115959994494915, 0.11724966019392014, 0.04431774094700813, 0.043828334659338, -0.06307089328765869, 0.03962567821145058, 0.010755392722785473, -0.004957020748406649, -0.037435632199048996, 0.021660881116986275, 0.04480789974331856, -0.021476618945598602, 0.02783517725765705, 0.02369043603539467, 0.01423928514122963, -0.01974218338727951, 0.07264548540115356, 0.02825811691582203, 0.018503695726394653, -0.006101321894675493, 0.009800114668905735, 0.028811976313591003, 0.003171575488522649, -0.010724641382694244, 0.0028500177431851625, -0.038844142109155655, -0.035225871950387955, -0.05012534558773041, -0.021624671295285225, 0.007521799299865961, 0.0010218615643680096, -0.027894973754882812, 0.04114046320319176, 0.03951822221279144, 0.007092018146067858, -0.009008023887872696, 0.022301947697997093, 0.014406059868633747, -0.035807520151138306, 0.04119214788079262, 0.008234316483139992, 0.00888015516102314, -0.0191645547747612, 0.016007516533136368, -0.005837013944983482, -0.05084916576743126, -0.026732785627245903, -0.07274747639894485, 0.025164011865854263, 0.002387008164077997, -0.04884763062000275, -0.022960785776376724, -0.017400816082954407, 0.021017806604504585, -0.04338891804218292, -0.009536349214613438, -0.0016135774785652757, -0.011802855879068375, -0.02840731106698513, -0.0016948787961155176, -0.06213821470737457, 0.029039176180958748, 0.02201009728014469, 0.0319410115480423, 0.04616731032729149, -0.03323551267385483, -0.03247201070189476, 0.02084854245185852, 0.06372793018817902, -0.04264866188168526, -0.006397769786417484, 0.04059349372982979, 0.012839695438742638, -0.041018541902303696, 0.004720356315374374, -0.023827748373150826, 0.020362870767712593, 0.040069159120321274, 0.014171459712088108, -0.04559384658932686, 0.007166589144617319, -0.06641236692667007, -0.01888987608253956, 0.015734011307358742, -0.004964435938745737, 0.0009996658191084862, -0.012412895448505878, 0.06219666823744774, 0.0066565559245646, -0.010737237520515919, 0.031953152269124985, 0.0010455215815454721, 0.027104219421744347, 0.04379518702626228, -0.03935110569000244, -0.008023073896765709, 0.00622474355623126, -0.017196962609887123, -0.0035100479144603014, -0.02728484384715557, 0.051363252103328705, 0.027834121137857437, 0.029102230444550514, 0.029910264536738396, 0.012437215074896812, -0.04721478372812271, -0.012014968320727348, -0.02746317908167839, -0.04978083446621895, -0.03300043195486069, -0.015033639967441559, 0.013930484652519226, 0.0025474645663052797, -0.009072046726942062, -0.02889901027083397, -0.01683361455798149, 0.028410833328962326, -0.006704932078719139, -0.0259541068226099, -0.02062169462442398, 0.011793844401836395, -0.017702871933579445, -0.05951765552163124, 0.035835083574056625, -0.03470268473029137, -0.023139478638768196, -0.006706860847771168, 0.010296626016497612, -0.014834221452474594, 0.025989782065153122, -0.015445300377905369, -0.04325927421450615, 0.04360528662800789, 0.004328754730522633, 0.009604772552847862, 0.004497538320720196, 0.03062250092625618, -0.006181409116834402, 0.006668906658887863, -0.04454721510410309, -0.048094894737005234, 0.027185842394828796, -0.02638205885887146, -0.01440614927560091, 0.04157542437314987, -0.02351910062134266, 0.015247836709022522, 0.005892705637961626, -0.04156194627285004, 0.026399340480566025, 0.038359589874744415, -0.014954697340726852, -0.004082311410456896, -0.020659945905208588, 0.029802052304148674, 0.00921848975121975, 0.022660568356513977, 0.01395083125680685, 0.0028395529370754957, 0.01531247142702341, 0.008770388551056385, 0.033374570310115814, -0.0035794395953416824, 0.0038726492784917355, -0.005580915603786707, -0.0039422353729605675, 0.02010917291045189, -0.0017563198925927281, -0.017210107296705246, 0.039040420204401016, 0.029080986976623535, -0.003172699362039566, -0.012367655523121357, 0.007776157930493355, 0.006558476947247982, -0.05750993266701698, 0.036238569766283035, 0.003587747225537896, 0.026764418929815292, 0.03805289790034294, -0.03319595381617546, -0.004203869495540857, 0.01961877942085266, -0.04396030306816101, 0.00773046026006341, -0.013589105568826199, -0.01391697395592928, -0.02927747741341591, -0.010562854818999767, -0.04216878488659859, 0.004140867386013269, 0.05180085822939873, 0.004010286182165146, 0.050499603152275085, 0.044449273496866226, -0.020262431353330612, -0.028050391003489494, 0.008335941471159458, -0.014573968946933746, 0.043324947357177734, -0.05119315907359123, 0.004253385588526726, -0.040497515350580215, -0.04298996180295944, 0.03608023002743721, -0.050004445016384125, 0.01439265813678503, -0.025450771674513817, 0.04223063215613365, -0.0030500837601721287, 0.0045385523699223995, -0.004877062048763037, 0.006231737323105335, -0.010394256561994553, -0.016042208299040794, 0.013074541464447975, 0.010729612782597542, -0.032617390155792236, 0.010828022845089436, 0.02421155944466591, -0.010012476705014706, -0.023251915350556374, 0.005800013430416584, -0.035399436950683594, 0.003832645248621702, -0.022260282188653946, -0.010893112979829311, 0.02629575878381729, -0.014524397440254688, 0.0019617360085248947, -0.028607595711946487, 0.011357324197888374, 0.03470662981271744, 0.019461695104837418, -0.04243531823158264, -0.004219840746372938, -0.02007126994431019, -0.05592598393559456, 0.04671195521950722, -0.002936459146440029, -0.026417547836899757, -0.031156616285443306, -0.02808433398604393, -0.006188524886965752, -0.016403470188379288, -0.041412387043237686, 0.0019278082763776183, -0.026891669258475304, 0.04973132908344269, 0.012060083448886871, -0.014087635092437267, -0.012314031831920147, -0.002710603643208742, -0.010128249414265156, -0.03414903208613396, 0.018171899020671844, -0.011813655495643616, -0.03655824065208435, -0.042398713529109955, -0.03507331386208534, -0.04601985588669777, 0.009518771432340145, 0.026038790121674538, 0.021325482055544853, 0.009592673741281033, 0.01951456442475319, 0.015343333594501019, 0.0018005328020080924, -0.05907582491636276, 0.04324125871062279, -0.05235273763537407, -0.03969842568039894, 0.04075736925005913, -0.012399113737046719, -0.01423321571201086, 0.03365877643227577, 0.018081173300743103, -0.018137630075216293, 0.03150026872754097, 0.053711701184511185, 0.0035583183635026217, 0.008728750050067902, -0.020205039530992508, -0.007368155289441347, 0.05699281021952629, 0.011468223296105862, 0.00358522473834455, 0.004329480230808258, -0.019389430060982704, -0.061364203691482544, 0.07841165363788605, -0.025870881974697113, -0.040048081427812576, 0.00275151408277452, 0.010895845480263233, -0.023036599159240723, -0.062095046043395996, -0.0070487381890416145, 0.0018468480557203293, -0.006405056454241276, 0.02136320061981678, 0.06559096276760101, -0.0011506230803206563, 0.03340688347816467, -0.022626567631959915, 0.038304660469293594, 0.01184146385639906, 0.019178278744220734, 0.001969138626009226, -0.018335003405809402, 0.012423223815858364, -0.01360949594527483, -0.0018444032175466418, -0.008453626185655594, -0.01540680043399334, 0.006989430170506239, -0.013701255433261395, 0.03167935088276863, 0.002940469654276967, -0.03781387209892273, 0.006954246666282415, -0.013716628775000572, -0.00624105567112565, 0.019690901041030884, -0.00485838670283556, 0.071549192070961, -0.017157727852463722, -0.010131885297596455, -0.017286432906985283, -0.01011599600315094, -0.002414251444861293, 0.009188231080770493, 0.010038512758910656, -0.025751078501343727, 0.011183105409145355, -0.00764126842841506, -0.02212001197040081, -0.004067170433700085, -0.005582509096711874, -0.025489283725619316, 0.009899807162582874, -0.013034644536674023, 0.0007589131128042936, -0.00956080760806799, -0.03443199023604393, -0.048745047301054, -0.06768358498811722, 0.021495822817087173, 0.029729517176747322, -0.002969050081446767, -0.007679549045860767, 0.004609502851963043, -0.0021710193250328302, 0.04075360670685768, -0.0612255223095417, 0.01787601038813591, -0.0034310754854232073, 0.02965496852993965, 0.002357940189540386, -0.024243414402008057 ]
<p>Disclaimer: I know absolutely nothing about statistics. I've had trouble searching for answers to my question, as I don't have much knowledge about the terminology of statistics.</p> <p>I'm currently trying to plot a graph with two sets of values that are widely different. This doesn't really matter, but I'm doing this in Python with the matplotlib library.</p> <p>One of my sets of values is a company's stock price over several days. My second set of data has much, much smaller values, but I'd like to be able to compare both lines side by side. I'm more interested in the magnitude of the changes than in the actual values.</p> <p>For the moment, the only idea I've had is the following:</p> <ul> <li><p>Average the first values.</p></li> <li><p>Average the second values.</p></li> <li><p>Divide the first average by the second one, as to find a coefficient.</p></li> <li><p>Divide every single value in the first set of data by this coefficient.</p></li> </ul> <p>Now, this <em>looks</em> fine, but I don't know anything about statistics, so is this correct? If it isn't, what's a better way to do it?</p>
37,452
[ -0.02730637788772583, 0.010887248441576958, -0.047235049307346344, 0.024325156584382057, 0.02416498400270939, 0.030288536101579666, -0.005671007093042135, -0.030074402689933777, 0.020922420546412468, -0.011355934664607048, 0.047852881252765656, 0.04589994624257088, 0.06619217246770859, 0.027932656928896904, 0.02239130437374115, -0.00774226663634181, -0.04222118481993675, 0.007899024523794651, 0.010667654685676098, -0.03861424699425697, 0.007815859280526638, -0.005750447046011686, 0.02300533838570118, -0.01774885691702366, -0.03810643032193184, 0.0498863160610199, 0.030795829370617867, -0.03001410700380802, 0.009738587774336338, 0.06172220781445503, -0.05008941888809204, -0.0768452063202858, 0.024928761646151543, 0.0350041389465332, 0.03870788961648941, 0.02012915536761284, -0.006379949860274792, -0.04348162189126015, -0.011718588881194592, 0.044421788305044174, -0.014812100678682327, -0.0075510176829993725, -0.03023197501897812, -0.00461976183578372, -0.017366010695695877, 0.018714983016252518, 0.007198990788310766, -0.060899123549461365, 0.023464441299438477, -0.06140896677970886, 0.07473629713058472, -0.006338628940284252, 0.060300201177597046, 0.020475143566727638, -0.04123270511627197, 0.03734785318374634, 0.0020237574353814125, 0.05736321955919266, -0.01324845477938652, -0.028209712356328964, -0.007178702391684055, 0.022676458582282066, -0.031278032809495926, 0.006733706686645746, -0.025967519730329514, 0.005278627388179302, -0.035450808703899384, -0.0034552894067019224, 0.025133784860372543, -0.00008721574704395607, -0.02161804959177971, 0.04900135099887848, 0.05623101070523262, -0.0013471381971612573, -0.004207648802548647, -0.005792858544737101, 0.03278736025094986, 0.018939046189188957, 0.04101325199007988, 0.04154922440648079, -0.005536614451557398, 0.017961585894227028, 0.020197350531816483, 0.031856950372457504, 0.01668577268719673, 0.002095284406095743, 0.08790812641382217, -0.01969057507812977, 0.004829919431358576, 0.002890323055908084, 0.012270307168364525, -0.014338420704007149, 0.055145639926195145, 0.024566862732172012, -0.0357888862490654, 0.01432354561984539, -0.016793420538306236, 0.029087459668517113, 0.024676736444234848, -0.014892966486513615, 0.005933768581598997, -0.040025848895311356, 0.029230188578367233, 0.03238600492477417, -0.01960398443043232, -0.021635865792632103, -0.03003562241792679, -0.0063217622227966785, 0.01270617451518774, -0.003454878693446517, -0.010545773431658745, 0.01473288144916296, 0.03529450669884682, -0.007955578155815601, 0.02708432450890541, -0.007357609458267689, -0.017770882695913315, 0.01832437701523304, 0.07403511554002762, 0.06659673154354095, 0.046178266406059265, -0.03512176126241684, 0.06565022468566895, 0.0075818817131221294, -0.0314483568072319, 0.0066946763545274734, -0.013706870377063751, -0.011392123065888882, -0.03227706998586655, 0.06991669535636902, -0.03599713742733002, -0.006058268249034882, 0.05717181786894798, -0.03655064105987549, 0.012703022919595242, 0.034702643752098083, -0.06350073218345642, -0.05484776943922043, 0.023837966844439507, -0.0040907179936766624, -0.0088052898645401, -0.03890885412693024, -0.009806043468415737, 0.02303563989698887, 0.0334894135594368, 0.051761772483587265, 0.0394342876970768, -0.004452827852219343, 0.029076971113681793, 0.016340045258402824, -0.028020095080137253, -0.03148311376571655, 0.007936720736324787, -0.012796865776181221, 0.00197695754468441, -0.04616767168045044, -0.03727397322654724, 0.02799105830490589, -0.016069982200860977, 0.014618354849517345, -0.005126808770000935, 0.00975041650235653, -0.02085893228650093, 0.04208534583449364, 0.01425927598029375, -0.013369150459766388, 0.08542903512716293, 0.013274280354380608, 0.040131792426109314, 0.005460971035063267, 0.02278020605444908, 0.00037710010656155646, 0.013043628074228764, 0.033306218683719635, 0.060338784009218216, -0.009721598587930202, 0.004445225466042757, 0.007008258253335953, 0.0198565274477005, 0.003049870254471898, -0.024081306532025337, -0.04008080065250397, -0.04273713752627373, -0.009099876508116722, 0.021247154101729393, 0.05606669560074806, -0.0021218324545770884, -0.0315113291144371, 0.013377092778682709, -0.04614826291799545, -0.06281570345163345, -0.06224634498357773, 0.01139803510159254, -0.019506283104419708, -0.02393953874707222, -0.01119005773216486, 0.030903272330760956, 0.03008333221077919, -0.0526738315820694, -0.03219686448574066, -0.007445750758051872, -0.014619062654674053, 0.037978317588567734, -0.03134273365139961, -0.016269981861114502, 0.05462292954325676, 0.03900894522666931, -0.03293326124548912, 0.027339741587638855, -0.0331229567527771, -0.04161185026168823, 0.017491020262241364, -0.07133547961711884, -0.01801839843392372, -0.008772216737270355, -0.037870556116104126, 0.02618139609694481, 0.020704638212919235, -0.020846448838710785, 0.0059051853604614735, -0.034476518630981445, 0.07969685643911362, 0.04685170575976372, -0.0022956146858632565, 0.0032334609422832727, -0.0019431442487984896, 0.03540877625346184, 0.033877111971378326, -0.002593931509181857, -0.03874753788113594, -0.05600263550877571, 0.037743281573057175, 0.01711677759885788, 0.0021672151051461697, -0.027988459914922714, -0.009497815743088722, 0.09512435644865036, 0.000513613922521472, 0.03002563863992691, 0.009619150310754776, 0.028208386152982712, 0.018790224567055702, 0.01685205288231373, 0.020565597340464592, 0.00795727875083685, -0.011953253298997879, 0.0299421027302742, 0.0009747010190039873, 0.02004845440387726, 0.02626677230000496, 0.009825387969613075, 0.03112799860537052, -0.014605975709855556, 0.0348607636988163, -0.02681407332420349, -0.003106511663645506, 0.03833356872200966, -0.016220755875110626, -0.020489178597927094, 0.01391439326107502, -0.0010361116146668792, -0.031100580468773842, 0.01880214363336563, -0.008167676627635956, 0.0079342657700181, 0.030130978673696518, -0.06120622903108597, -0.012584514915943146, 0.02795579843223095, -0.01156977191567421, 0.026864396408200264, 0.0048902602866292, -0.02739776112139225, -0.03632374852895737, 0.010884429328143597, 0.02133442461490631, -0.014195921830832958, 0.038717322051525116, -0.03640332445502281, -0.022577328607439995, -0.019069282338023186, -0.01844334416091442, 0.0018511076923459768, 0.020844880491495132, -0.057106878608465195, 0.004498466849327087, -0.030779659748077393, -0.04206406697630882, 0.03580239787697792, -0.008181263692677021, -0.041939761489629745, 0.04060680419206619, 0.025386229157447815, -0.05123963952064514, -0.02083175629377365, -0.0395515114068985, 0.01897173747420311, -0.03531324490904808, -0.01091464702039957, 0.04246639460325241, -0.04135932773351669, -0.026739785447716713, 0.05233463644981384, -0.031707510352134705, -0.01299087330698967, -0.04614640399813652, -0.011965765617787838, 0.0022024286445230246, 0.000213280160096474, -0.003754505654796958, 0.030895892530679703, -0.023017650470137596, -0.044063273817300797, -0.0711229145526886, -0.058719392865896225, 0.014946449548006058, 0.0010793311521410942, 0.011634140275418758, -0.0020897178910672665, -0.0312964990735054, 0.029787687584757805, 0.016375258564949036, -0.02550104819238186, -0.03282049670815468, 0.031599145382642746, -0.008866457268595695, -0.002242420567199588, 0.02579461969435215, 0.017930978909134865, -0.022524293512105942, -0.00670099351555109, 0.015546878799796104, 0.03433128818869591, 0.04394149035215378, -0.01162721961736679, 0.008728662505745888, -0.010913487523794174, 0.022679392248392105, -0.014031404629349709, 0.0148491645231843, 0.05024636164307594, -0.0358194001019001, 0.019710499793291092, 0.015774210914969444, 0.015372232533991337, 0.013984755612909794, -0.033659059554338455, 0.010752066969871521, -0.012945498339831829, 0.01600867509841919, -0.021051064133644104, 0.01772385649383068, 0.006468826439231634, -0.015097186900675297, 0.0015469721984118223, 0.016015680506825447, 0.024788277223706245, -0.00813889130949974, -0.005319920834153891, 0.05108988657593727, 0.04813910648226738, -0.025187432765960693, -0.033773597329854965, -0.025266747921705246, -0.010848247446119785, 0.007804147433489561, -0.023284614086151123, -0.027208708226680756, 0.07519276440143585, 0.03303120657801628, 0.03656546771526337, -0.025498850271105766, -0.04493257775902748, 0.03434235602617264, -0.06440111994743347, 0.003146597184240818, -0.040514763444662094, 0.04647810757160187, 0.02252179943025112, 0.03039265237748623, 0.03321586549282074, -0.004253625404089689, 0.022556114941835403, -0.01662757433950901, -0.06282138079404831, 0.04838751628994942, -0.00438065966591239, -0.01357183326035738, -0.0005173669778741896, -0.0005525509477593005, 0.0372471809387207, -0.00892595387995243, 0.025652721524238586, -0.014201301150023937, 0.03542797639966011, -0.028094055131077766, -0.00712935533374548, -0.03860900178551674, 0.0024381123948842287, -0.015505409799516201, 0.013989293947815895, 0.015693219378590584, 0.007513605058193207, 0.011655285954475403, 0.024309920147061348, -0.01587565802037716, -0.025834592059254646, -0.004442593548446894, 0.03141389787197113, 0.02203311398625374, 0.01716536097228527, 0.026228567585349083, 0.02266416884958744, -0.044723186641931534, 0.0346858873963356, 0.007983844727277756, 0.052532900124788284, 0.01955188810825348, -0.01622329279780388, 0.0231180377304554, 0.0017462004907429218, -0.017605293542146683, 0.00824237521737814, 0.029612934216856956, -0.016897251829504967, -0.004635391291230917, 0.016468506306409836, 0.05462438240647316, -0.060168538242578506, 0.03778556361794472, 0.09386800974607468, -0.014198399148881435, 0.006801342125982046, -0.021422818303108215, -0.008849374949932098, -0.0006194961024448276, -0.0522414967417717, 0.046230122447013855, 0.02707558311522007, 0.015578050166368484, 0.015496296808123589, 0.040400560945272446, -0.007412801031023264, -0.0411018468439579, 0.01261407881975174, 0.021793588995933533, 0.04172028601169586, -0.002825613133609295, -0.05313161388039589, 0.0026004943065345287, 0.035813964903354645, 0.015648748725652695, 0.007622768171131611, 0.01831112429499626, -0.09384080767631531, 0.027324246242642403, 0.04008292406797409, 0.029573358595371246, -0.0298601184040308, -0.01010607648640871, -0.017338814213871956, 0.0379006527364254, 0.03622366115450859, -0.027825793251395226, 0.012547299265861511, 0.004838129971176386, -0.010654805228114128, -0.014192250557243824, 0.012100339867174625, -0.030673515051603317, 0.05406558886170387, -0.03689933568239212, 0.038677725940942764, 0.007700417190790176, -0.04105665907263756, -0.04273796081542969, 0.04121653363108635, -0.012137490324676037, 0.08765113353729248, -0.03404673561453819, -0.03232785686850548, 0.01454955991357565, 0.05039658769965172, -0.017315510660409927, -0.05233686789870262, -0.015176848508417606, -0.011058828793466091, -0.01728862337768078, 0.03785935789346695, 0.013384672813117504, -0.03331408277153969, 0.022447705268859863, 0.009349138475954533, -0.016888760030269623, 0.02404944971203804, 0.008100674487650394, 0.035078566521406174, 0.06336164474487305, 0.0215084757655859, 0.08222401887178421, 0.015185141004621983, 0.005311014596372843, 0.012710198760032654, -0.004628278780728579, 0.019045036286115646, -0.021861650049686432, -0.032704535871744156, -0.06351881474256516, -0.007500366773456335, -0.010723346844315529, -0.006654717493802309, -0.03137526661157608, 0.014038043096661568, -0.045234836637973785, -0.006524126511067152, -0.021568717435002327, -0.00089517782907933, 0.006196277681738138, -0.026155496016144753, 0.01672881469130516, 0.023724617436528206, -0.02955944649875164, -0.04538622125983238, 0.018070610240101814, -0.00033856459776870906, -0.012977994978427887, -0.015916915610432625, -0.03175460174679756, -0.0033485235180705786, -0.04999051243066788, -0.030167775228619576, 0.016871923580765724, -0.014501775614917278, 0.03676161915063858, -0.000051951668865513057, 0.03085498698055744, 0.017439154908061028, -0.007388093043118715, -0.032890237867832184, 0.021894045174121857, 0.008216682821512222, 0.03366197273135185, -0.06368684023618698, 0.025999853387475014, -0.04471031576395035, -0.04121055826544762, -0.05899203196167946, -0.09591474384069443, 0.025296783074736595, 0.025355495512485504, -0.0074042221531271935, -0.03235055133700371, -0.01620566099882126, 0.00234482204541564, 0.011457270942628384, -0.01776595041155815, 0.02670932374894619, -0.00004066785186296329, -0.01754261553287506, -0.009315631352365017, 0.023514769971370697, 0.0704786404967308, -0.026077643036842346, -0.011637779884040356, 0.00003061173265450634, 0.008184321224689484, -0.027058284729719162, -0.026861155405640602, 0.023986661806702614, -0.040076348930597305, -0.015589947812259197, -0.027419017627835274, 0.019106386229395866, 0.04459034278988838, -0.044056326150894165, -0.009215982630848885, 0.00910265278071165, 0.014562683179974556, 0.013699487783014774, -0.030862363055348396, -0.0032838331535458565, -0.02335175685584545, -0.0045516351237893105, -0.02208300493657589, -0.006323730573058128, -0.016498396173119545, -0.010710437782108784, -0.005120864138007164, 0.016536710783839226, -0.04582710936665535, 0.01312521193176508, 0.07852664589881897, -0.005746485199779272, 0.007835349068045616, -0.022694436833262444, -0.026013676077127457, 0.023816576227545738, -0.007221624720841646, -0.017769642174243927, 0.010926002636551857, -0.02686154656112194, -0.03922802582383156, -0.00355236092582345, -0.02944159507751465, -0.014353048987686634, 0.06725150346755981, -0.005524733103811741, 0.06103499233722687, 0.08860252797603607, 0.026033926755189896, 0.019928768277168274, -0.03469768539071083, -0.05674784630537033, -0.010226349346339703, 0.02194494567811489, 0.03761114552617073, -0.00042700630729086697, -0.012093555182218552, 0.05969298258423805, 0.02699461206793785, 0.02310994267463684, 0.06278768181800842, 0.013674561865627766, 0.031450897455215454, 0.02737746201455593, -0.0026887732092291117, -0.019204096868634224, 0.0011766012758016586, -0.06248063966631889, 0.023866504430770874, -0.07760002464056015, 0.00689614238217473, 0.03628368303179741, 0.03431687131524086, -0.03481056168675423, -0.06699899584054947, -0.021206263452768326, -0.04036177694797516, -0.0018725706031545997, 0.011462298221886158, -0.0002899621322285384, 0.054161202162504196, -0.006831407081335783, 0.05454009771347046, -0.003848413238301873, 0.0433238260447979, -0.024733951315283775, -0.06274869292974472, 0.001133009442128241, -0.026370380073785782, -0.022353246808052063, 0.026078222319483757, 0.008859450928866863, -0.01336186844855547, 0.0575580857694149, -0.03512229025363922, -0.01527343038469553, 0.018043484538793564, 0.03027929924428463, -0.009516413323581219, 0.05807868391275406, 0.0038412343710660934, 0.013715835288167, 0.009749648161232471, -0.03842364624142647, 0.10651068389415741, 0.052214816212654114, 0.030563613399863243, -0.04017353802919388, 0.011533284559845924, 0.016454646363854408, 0.01252281665802002, -0.05434455722570419, 0.005036809016019106, -0.00981921423226595, 0.007559098303318024, 0.05542527511715889, 0.05916861817240715, 0.029416853561997414, 0.005761649459600449, 0.06431327015161514, -0.008701763115823269, 0.01842673122882843, 0.020214442163705826, 0.00862603634595871, 0.029124749824404716, -0.018082793802022934, -0.07176972925662994, 0.025595325976610184, -0.020487556234002113, 0.0008423294057138264, -0.023006349802017212, -0.018348287791013718, -0.00704705948010087, 0.02851727418601513, -0.04415753111243248, 0.03661469370126724, 0.05127492547035217, -0.012902738526463509, -0.0200271625071764, -0.022567765787243843, 0.027612265199422836, -0.03042905405163765, -0.009486653842031956, 0.014907690696418285, -0.0035275211557745934, -0.009503267705440521, 0.029308851808309555, 0.010596896521747112, -0.05601868778467178, -0.026236331090331078, -0.05540607124567032, 0.03262000158429146, 0.0067731402814388275, -0.025517821311950684, -0.005685269832611084, 0.0005644241464324296, -0.02071993052959442, -0.017866158857941628, -0.007768172770738602, 0.011882170103490353, 0.013735096901655197, -0.029673658311367035, 0.015103771351277828, -0.011827925220131874, 0.028698135167360306, -0.0061234403401613235, 0.01921895332634449, 0.032758843153715134, -0.0220794714987278, -0.04313955456018448, -0.018786976113915443, 0.04921694099903107, -0.005723625421524048, -0.02582978643476963, 0.014311123639345169, -0.01593022421002388, -0.016397038474678993, -0.017033319920301437, -0.013423734344542027, -0.0013272741343826056, -0.010783804580569267, 0.011545597575604916, -0.020021235570311546, -0.012514892965555191, -0.008515497669577599, 0.018385687842965126, 0.004946529399603605, -0.00113497965503484, -0.03583665192127228, -0.01315505150705576, 0.057943135499954224, 0.0049981591291725636, 0.02382570505142212, 0.0029591023921966553, -0.023009570315480232, 0.05883346498012543, 0.026095084846019745, -0.05267580226063728, -0.012972719967365265, -0.0032935370691120625, -0.005550719331949949, -0.009255105629563332, -0.00791644211858511, 0.0540810264647007, 0.028323713690042496, -0.002427072264254093, 0.006090270821005106, 0.007465775590389967, -0.026408188045024872, 0.0294880960136652, -0.0178640428930521, -0.10584230720996857, -0.019286900758743286, 0.006107338238507509, -0.011955422349274158, -0.026798048987984657, -0.021387722343206406, -0.04365277290344238, -0.0027240519411861897, 0.023283878341317177, 0.02258460596203804, -0.002931618597358465, 0.0032744852360337973, -0.027696218341588974, 0.05278124287724495, -0.02496502362191677, -0.012104098685085773, -0.0353781022131443, -0.022436348721385002, 0.002178589114919305, -0.010223711840808392, -0.029988497495651245, 0.034145765006542206, -0.006851369049400091, 0.03284555301070213, 0.0518677644431591, 0.023111939430236816, 0.009090944193303585, 0.004407026339322329, 0.026797041296958923, -0.007208782713860273, 0.023652803152799606, -0.029216615483164787, -0.03449784964323044, 0.04883674532175064, -0.025157537311315536, -0.051533255726099014, 0.029261430725455284, 0.001429967349395156, 0.0353785939514637, -0.004650634713470936, -0.013949399814009666, -0.026105090975761414, 0.041716068983078, -0.03890185430645943, -0.03388536348938942, -0.03271055594086647, -0.013607156462967396, -0.010452255606651306, 0.01696670986711979, 0.003977728541940451, 0.0017904951237142086, -0.00559354480355978, 0.03811125457286835, 0.05139137804508209, -0.013262379914522171, -0.002781551331281662, -0.0018573232227936387, 0.008762355893850327, 0.013426825404167175, 0.0002486852463334799, 0.0011228106450289488, 0.06284946203231812, 0.04481038451194763, -0.036206088960170746, 0.006808506324887276, -0.02607560344040394, 0.012718130834400654, -0.07173128426074982, -0.008615411818027496, -0.01481673400849104, -0.004113749600946903, 0.04522078484296799, -0.052733518183231354, 0.0044168331660330296, 0.035079583525657654, -0.01850554347038269, 0.04231691733002663, -0.01323085930198431, -0.0234258770942688, -0.004194061271846294, -0.030091194435954094, -0.015220505185425282, 0.04316502809524536, 0.03433779999613762, 0.027750466018915176, 0.051485609263181686, 0.031270675361156464, 0.013043384067714214, -0.02066533826291561, -0.007812295574694872, -0.005549256224185228, 0.033979419618844986, -0.04137596860527992, 0.025533240288496017, -0.03676972538232803, -0.022007400169968605, 0.04466109722852707, -0.06082758679986, 0.045034363865852356, 0.03206329047679901, 0.005260264966636896, 0.0008713087881915271, 0.038069866597652435, -0.007028877269476652, 0.007286505773663521, -0.006236014422029257, -0.027703069150447845, 0.021099720150232315, 0.035096872597932816, -0.00405828095972538, 0.015887070447206497, 0.05835748091340065, -0.019920537248253822, -0.03727130591869354, -0.007150362245738506, 0.01049063354730606, 0.00023300769680645317, -0.008758134208619595, 0.007836880162358284, 0.04112052917480469, -0.03799285367131233, 0.012881215661764145, -0.02501429244875908, 0.002462980104610324, 0.03789527341723442, 0.0035144162829965353, -0.01861308328807354, 0.011334395036101341, -0.02319459058344364, -0.03213956952095032, -0.01006597001105547, 0.013497059233486652, -0.015136160887777805, -0.057527560740709305, -0.04124492034316063, -0.01402209047228098, -0.0204987283796072, -0.012783440761268139, -0.026707258075475693, -0.03745575249195099, 0.03499864414334297, -0.014024576172232628, -0.0018661756766960025, 0.0211440809071064, -0.00009495099220657721, -0.006960948929190636, -0.09857973456382751, 0.05719849839806557, 0.04438784718513489, 0.004900268744677305, -0.03366880118846893, 0.0015747637953609228, -0.040988534688949585, -0.00021582144836429507, 0.04164846986532211, 0.011334562674164772, 0.02404250018298626, -0.007814664393663406, 0.0061759380623698235, -0.012890858575701714, -0.07795217633247375, 0.022582514211535454, -0.0381392203271389, -0.0479864627122879, -0.016095148399472237, 0.0028965394012629986, 0.03343921899795532, -0.000018610831830301322, 0.01859564520418644, -0.01851433701813221, 0.015835272148251534, 0.00836216565221548, -0.014325128868222237, 0.024977853521704674, -0.007539817597717047, -0.055790726095438004, -0.00210485327988863, 0.006428705528378487, 0.011404750868678093, 0.04028838127851486, -0.0009043271420523524, -0.06287554651498795, 0.0545368567109108, -0.04362082853913307, -0.03497157618403435, -0.034747011959552765, 0.005782857537269592, 0.004145502112805843, -0.07446663081645966, 0.0034313115756958723, 0.0020242352038621902, -0.06213143467903137, 0.015951361507177353, 0.049951937049627304, 0.0032033284660428762, 0.02354295179247856, -0.004878704901784658, 0.04601338505744934, -0.01294991746544838, -0.014183733612298965, 0.022118451073765755, -0.030166950076818466, 0.0391685925424099, 0.026250796392560005, 0.024092404171824455, 0.012258568778634071, -0.006981403101235628, 0.009909470565617085, -0.023654617369174957, 0.03406557813286781, 0.005376288201659918, -0.005346962716430426, 0.005550208501517773, -0.0110712181776762, 0.013175172731280327, 0.005396494176238775, 0.019693542271852493, 0.049014437943696976, -0.029166894033551216, 0.0057855406776070595, -0.05247267335653305, -0.023239566013216972, -0.04911433160305023, -0.002410999732092023, 0.03895172104239464, 0.0029585338197648525, -0.00677070114761591, -0.0037796555552631617, 0.0077025690115988255, 0.016451943665742874, 0.02495628222823143, -0.022494351491332054, 0.052898772060871124, -0.02879301831126213, -0.0334002822637558, -0.028776519000530243, -0.029117288067936897, -0.023193886503577232, -0.045567259192466736, 0.0156867653131485, 0.031883999705314636, 0.0037948221433907747, 0.016314644366502762, -0.03585615009069443, -0.008710259571671486, 0.02759917825460434, -0.07792388647794724, -0.019735338166356087, -0.06789585202932358, 0.04430101439356804, 0.022176938131451607, -0.02514762431383133 ]
<p>Plotting a <strong>glm</strong> binomial model is reasonably simple with the <strong>predict</strong> function. I'm having trouble creating a similar plot for a <strong>glmer</strong> model; predict doesn't work: </p> <pre><code>id &lt;- factor(rep(1:20, 3)) age &lt;- rep(sample(20:50, 20, replace=T), 3) age &lt;- age + c(rep(0, 20), rep(3, 20), rep(6, 20)) score &lt;- rbinom(60, 15, 1-age/max(age)) dfx &lt;- data.frame(id, age, score) library(lme4) glmerb &lt;- glmer(cbind(score, 15-score) ~ age + (1|id), dfx, family=binomial) ndf &lt;- expand.grid(age=10:60) #for extensibility, usually also have factors ndf$fit &lt;- predict(glmerb, ndf, type="response") *Error in UseMethod("predict") : no applicable method for 'predict' applied to an object of class "mer"* </code></pre> <ol> <li>How can I produce the desired plot?</li> <li>While I'm at it, what other plots would be useful for this kind of model for either diagnostic, presentation or glam purposes?</li> </ol>
36,972
[ -0.06768135726451874, -0.00482846237719059, 0.026228519156575203, -0.00007969472790136933, 0.023420054465532303, -0.0025741122663021088, -0.01458094734698534, -0.011567564681172371, 0.06859809160232544, -0.040103208273649216, 0.05086046829819679, 0.04272918775677681, 0.08492688089609146, 0.02496226504445076, 0.02499166503548622, 0.0026238674763590097, 0.011210520751774311, -0.024924160912632942, 0.001102544367313385, -0.005405967123806477, -0.00878472812473774, 0.0008154604001902044, -0.004009970463812351, -0.01154136098921299, 0.004416898358613253, 0.04785054922103882, 0.037529848515987396, -0.006914051715284586, -0.00635775551199913, 0.04175940155982971, -0.076754130423069, -0.031103624030947685, -0.001197194098494947, 0.03519619628787041, 0.020376000553369522, -0.010808194987475872, 0.0016228763852268457, -0.002109662164002657, -0.004595383536070585, -0.0037683933041989803, -0.0016344531904906034, -0.0008939924882724881, 0.019469909369945526, 0.04004949331283569, -0.014641081914305687, -0.008640257641673088, -0.00040908833034336567, -0.007623979821801186, 0.07283647358417511, -0.03996941074728966, 0.04019021987915039, -0.002112277550622821, 0.04726506024599075, 0.022543685510754585, -0.06570079177618027, -0.02380351535975933, 0.09108154475688934, 0.06130434200167656, 0.015032308176159859, -0.04763003811240196, -0.013135538436472416, -0.039751484990119934, 0.023245282471179962, 0.0015000705607235432, -0.03862448036670685, -0.004717121832072735, 0.025798672810196877, 0.012292812578380108, 0.03040640987455845, -0.0466785803437233, 0.015514981932938099, 0.051415059715509415, 0.03675273433327675, -0.02076094038784504, 0.04582914710044861, -0.028103161603212357, 0.02405979484319687, -0.036660172045230865, 0.044764697551727295, 0.009759760461747646, -0.03288229554891586, 0.037602100521326065, -0.003195167751982808, 0.029654333367943764, -0.007716189604252577, -0.015591262839734554, 0.020409949123859406, -0.0067166476510465145, 0.03947197645902634, 0.023271873593330383, -0.013721420429646969, 0.005481840576976538, 0.05689730867743492, 0.016197141259908676, -0.03703339025378227, 0.03888072073459625, -0.021095041185617447, 0.02828075736761093, 0.02246949076652527, -0.008907688781619072, -0.004068635404109955, -0.04202191159129143, 0.0026363821234554052, 0.03447304666042328, -0.020549850538372993, -0.04172544181346893, -0.04324924200773239, -0.05375320836901665, 0.017164230346679688, -0.03131161257624626, 0.028716545552015305, 0.03766388073563576, 0.022224269807338715, -0.015475578606128693, -0.01075935922563076, -0.07708356529474258, -0.0021669885609298944, 0.012155272997915745, 0.03609263524413109, 0.03317157179117203, 0.0334111712872982, -0.03209549933671951, 0.006385700311511755, -0.022598743438720703, -0.05124666541814804, 0.008014190942049026, 0.027207301929593086, -0.02994914911687374, -0.015155755914747715, 0.04469182714819908, -0.013418188318610191, -0.02000969648361206, 0.039840955287218094, 0.005581121426075697, 0.021897125989198685, -0.0424160398542881, -0.05244223773479462, -0.03722938895225525, 0.006445514969527721, -0.02885105460882187, 0.012211364693939686, -0.037613395601511, -0.006724733393639326, 0.024908654391765594, 0.030787687748670578, 0.011681733652949333, 0.03386858105659485, -0.01494709961116314, 0.06240310147404671, 0.0166579931974411, -0.050026241689920425, 0.024521777406334877, -0.0241869930177927, 0.0034060273319482803, -0.030967241153120995, -0.10021862387657166, 0.01688900962471962, -0.017413007095456123, -0.018995292484760284, -0.0030256041791290045, 0.035482827574014664, -0.02636185847222805, 0.022684341296553612, -0.02704845368862152, -0.009533216245472431, -0.015955906361341476, 0.05563691630959511, 0.020481279119849205, 0.045973315834999084, 0.04425734654068947, -0.01955443061888218, 0.0497032105922699, -0.0006845395546406507, 0.041573695838451385, 0.03381013870239258, -0.0005000585224479437, 0.004544892348349094, -0.011740525253117085, 0.009632041677832603, 0.031158294528722763, -0.032025355845689774, -0.052169088274240494, -0.02240249142050743, -0.03925193473696709, -0.021127281710505486, -0.01012558676302433, -0.021683501079678535, -0.0056901779025793076, 0.06300195306539536, -0.04678146168589592, -0.04779467731714249, -0.06558727473020554, 0.0063954610377550125, 0.011133219115436077, -0.01113899890333414, 0.004179506562650204, 0.004572075325995684, 0.0693085715174675, 0.011716453358530998, -0.0013165588025003672, -0.04359019547700882, 0.021127182990312576, 0.04085974395275116, -0.019304506480693817, -0.04566987231373787, 0.004311895929276943, 0.04919571056962013, -0.022938208654522896, 0.013817204162478447, -0.05583541840314865, -0.02540166862308979, 0.0029290069360285997, -0.02638196013867855, 0.008223066106438637, -0.02775888890028, -0.046208456158638, -0.011805245652794838, 0.005361455958336592, -0.01480791624635458, 0.04801035299897194, -0.0668170377612114, 0.036356326192617416, 0.0890803411602974, 0.0035470204893499613, 0.024833712726831436, 0.01773032359778881, -0.006067175883799791, 0.01740134321153164, -0.05234125256538391, -0.02550281211733818, -0.03858204931020737, -0.036066893488168716, 0.06256425380706787, 0.0007325836922973394, -0.02778525836765766, 0.03750135749578476, 0.042065370827913284, -0.03881774842739105, 0.012021766975522041, 0.04269878566265106, -0.0029896493069827557, 0.02266775257885456, 0.0042034657672047615, 0.038245219737291336, 0.004136832896620035, -0.025599215179681778, 0.034024741500616074, 0.022502483800053596, 0.04841257259249687, -0.012129656970500946, -0.009772015735507011, 0.060104917734861374, -0.03169693052768707, -0.0281361173838377, -0.043680526316165924, -0.025581728667020798, 0.0660281851887703, -0.025154801085591316, 0.004364758264273405, 0.04437883943319321, 0.01489840168505907, 0.002221203874796629, 0.011288203299045563, -0.04233866557478905, -0.010705046355724335, 0.054884545505046844, -0.004734169226139784, -0.025152646005153656, 0.01795109733939171, -0.058660466223955154, 0.028529280796647072, 0.0018983748741447926, -0.03679698705673218, -0.07265761494636536, 0.029321325942873955, -0.04919372871518135, 0.0067816018126904964, -0.009296495467424393, -0.022291922941803932, -0.04150192812085152, -0.004110902082175016, 0.0026457668282091618, 0.011483706533908844, -0.018082577735185623, -0.045060303062200546, -0.025219596922397614, -0.04177002236247063, -0.034293223172426224, 0.01885257102549076, 0.011154485866427422, -0.052137333899736404, -0.00171524693723768, -0.012927252799272537, -0.03469458967447281, -0.04287075623869896, -0.03299744054675102, 0.019182000309228897, -0.006824250798672438, -0.02091565914452076, 0.04674616828560829, 0.004375110380351543, -0.014556696638464928, -0.00896990206092596, -0.033975228667259216, 0.007410967256873846, 0.0031121945939958096, -0.012737346813082695, 0.036207884550094604, 0.01486322283744812, 0.026043996214866638, 0.025541000068187714, -0.037282951176166534, -0.044182032346725464, -0.07445865869522095, -0.0548170804977417, 0.020757073536515236, 0.05163583159446716, 0.015454057604074478, 0.019758664071559906, 0.014229301363229752, 0.04123581945896149, 0.016111604869365692, -0.009666730649769306, -0.10205584019422531, -0.025851264595985413, -0.02290433458983898, -0.03149444982409477, 0.0006904072361066937, -0.01940026320517063, 0.03383145108819008, 0.03571179881691933, -0.0186948049813509, -0.023129217326641083, -0.0004623162967618555, -0.010064927861094475, -0.03496208041906357, 0.02178581804037094, -0.02031356655061245, -0.04156047850847244, 0.014953669160604477, -0.00743847293779254, 0.013232295401394367, 0.04716668650507927, -0.006174884270876646, 0.0012751052854582667, -0.034365441650152206, -0.011632793582975864, 0.008023629896342754, -0.016909144818782806, 0.04005720093846321, -0.03186267986893654, 0.02101019024848938, -0.010052249766886234, -0.043833985924720764, -0.013473214581608772, 0.02526756003499031, 0.03578230366110802, -0.009985506534576416, 0.0022062850184738636, 0.0555490143597126, 0.013690466992557049, -0.020636556670069695, 0.01810002326965332, -0.00440114364027977, -0.025660468265414238, -0.0015208196127787232, -0.010951128788292408, 0.008265593089163303, 0.019846143200993538, 0.03561898693442345, 0.0005094117950648069, 0.002081668470054865, -0.004568858537822962, 0.02485462836921215, -0.05047805234789848, 0.021071413531899452, -0.03692544251680374, 0.03102288395166397, 0.02586803026497364, 0.05596999451518059, 0.03911576792597771, 0.008835997432470322, 0.02607113867998123, 0.010066451504826546, -0.06828773021697998, 0.03992815688252449, -0.0018123002955690026, 0.019712062552571297, 0.01688304729759693, -0.012795699760317802, 0.01923450641334057, 0.01401456631720066, 0.018046990036964417, 0.026855401694774628, 0.028231870383024216, -0.007659854833036661, -0.04136063531041145, 0.013121536932885647, 0.0036826131399720907, -0.011617221869528294, -0.005104550626128912, 0.034785300493240356, -0.02225644886493683, 0.018341006711125374, 0.06555593758821487, -0.006529698148369789, -0.007385171949863434, -0.04502858966588974, -0.005464977119117975, -0.021778682246804237, 0.04274432733654976, 0.043699413537979126, 0.007529131602495909, -0.04590987414121628, 0.03267717733979225, 0.018055249005556107, 0.06417962163686752, 0.06936243921518326, 0.014769557863473892, 0.0060596768744289875, -0.02030659094452858, 0.01508155558258295, 0.008277986198663712, -0.0033657699823379517, 0.01562177762389183, -0.002437245100736618, 0.06475826352834702, -0.0004762537719216198, -0.007265847641974688, 0.013377219438552856, 0.05493080988526344, 0.02677900157868862, 0.011749383062124252, -0.007881038822233677, 0.0005267281085252762, -0.01609371416270733, -0.0036517162807285786, 0.04917103797197342, 0.036214061081409454, 0.01864153891801834, -0.008750183507800102, 0.029411615803837776, -0.02329045534133911, -0.04152574762701988, 0.021581092849373817, 0.030108412727713585, 0.04184895381331444, -0.029432160779833794, -0.052363086491823196, -0.020537322387099266, 0.05903477966785431, 0.033601064234972, -0.013779916800558567, -0.020930150523781776, -0.09200188517570496, 0.00901705026626587, 0.045591454952955246, 0.028208086267113686, -0.037647511810064316, -0.028434496372938156, -0.03889154642820358, -0.0013997836504131556, 0.017304660752415657, -0.03299305588006973, 0.02001972123980522, -0.029323164373636246, 0.009477375075221062, -0.034452978521585464, -0.0025139134377241135, -0.08256621658802032, 0.026115957647562027, -0.041663505136966705, 0.0005546535248868167, -0.004589645657688379, 0.0013525207759812474, -0.0107825743034482, -0.003752433229237795, -0.03046148456633091, 0.04193703085184097, -0.003735434263944626, -0.032182734459638596, 0.03286086395382881, 0.007173609454184771, -0.03283774107694626, -0.03886396810412407, -0.01128066424280405, -0.02715906873345375, 0.0031420865561813116, 0.06207650154829025, -0.005525992717593908, 0.014793545007705688, 0.004965837113559246, 0.014376908540725708, -0.01736559346318245, -0.010493606328964233, -0.03737305477261543, 0.014158889651298523, 0.020658694207668304, 0.00026442439411766827, 0.045853547751903534, 0.04696831479668617, 0.01366150937974453, -0.004669603426009417, -0.037204839289188385, -0.0015548855299130082, 0.0008363569504581392, -0.027776241302490234, -0.037484310567379, -0.032983265817165375, -0.0225591491907835, 0.007082603871822357, -0.027217663824558258, 0.019818592816591263, -0.039250798523426056, 0.00548566784709692, 0.029964448884129524, 0.05078117176890373, 0.0158341396600008, -0.02423306368291378, 0.025377249345183372, -0.0070932116359472275, 0.008635332807898521, -0.00014741379709448665, 0.013800445944070816, -0.024283071979880333, 0.015689771622419357, 0.013311699964106083, -0.043466851115226746, 0.018154360353946686, -0.010453240014612675, 0.0003055000561289489, 0.008173447102308273, -0.017257049679756165, 0.021721618250012398, -0.008201989345252514, 0.055490538477897644, 0.009131735190749168, -0.08918491750955582, -0.0016868460224941373, 0.02491750568151474, -0.011404561810195446, -0.010997693985700607, -0.0071379151195287704, 0.03144032508134842, -0.003725509624928236, -0.039051614701747894, -0.05433416739106178, -0.03917521610856056, 0.010141815058887005, -0.011632710695266724, 0.006004953291267157, -0.016293048858642578, -0.037741608917713165, -0.01901419460773468, -0.0014047628501430154, 0.012925549410283566, 0.04691695794463158, -0.0029853819869458675, 0.007206836715340614, -0.01545693539083004, -0.011335688643157482, 0.07137997448444366, 0.022881772369146347, 0.009439331479370594, 0.008027163334190845, -0.005357613321393728, -0.024616261944174767, 0.030066903680562973, -0.0329274982213974, -0.02100433222949505, -0.0036795565392822027, -0.01817493885755539, 0.04071499779820442, 0.04936690255999565, 0.02113446779549122, -0.04901425540447235, -0.00906425341963768, -0.007186898961663246, -0.0017742409836500883, -0.04264896363019943, 0.007775598205626011, -0.03511081635951996, -0.00008766751125222072, -0.040786467492580414, -0.009374563582241535, -0.0201967041939497, -0.02213268354535103, 0.024242054671049118, -0.011545049957931042, 0.018468869850039482, 0.02484176494181156, 0.05386406183242798, 0.0030388343147933483, -0.003982208669185638, 0.003012445755302906, -0.012180180288851261, 0.057570431381464005, 0.02214880660176277, -0.00937340036034584, 0.013943142257630825, 0.05286964774131775, -0.033804215490818024, -0.016106529161334038, 0.0041716923005878925, 0.01593332551419735, 0.022727562114596367, -0.021198194473981857, 0.012312491424381733, 0.017272498458623886, -0.014390773139894009, 0.013829932548105717, -0.034480758011341095, -0.009362068958580494, 0.024571236222982407, 0.01239666435867548, 0.06845485419034958, -0.012596686370670795, 0.030337464064359665, 0.036954041570425034, 0.03926519677042961, 0.029528500512242317, 0.03970937803387642, 0.0234749186784029, 0.014627696946263313, 0.032849740236997604, -0.01030938234180212, -0.012812677770853043, 0.052064958959817886, -0.02140508033335209, 0.024926787242293358, -0.019470812752842903, -0.02667982690036297, 0.040270790457725525, 0.03243952989578247, -0.008367570117115974, -0.04370909184217453, -0.03098226897418499, -0.030400825664401054, 0.0011472500627860427, 0.043262042105197906, -0.03431897610425949, 0.021337145939469337, 0.0011488085146993399, 0.045696768909692764, -0.019406838342547417, 0.042577993124723434, -0.031778283417224884, -0.07266377657651901, -0.025254851207137108, -0.04432001709938049, -0.018004978075623512, 0.05528981611132622, 0.014622892253100872, 0.010488522239029408, 0.0419112890958786, -0.030574612319469452, -0.0028970432467758656, 0.007491698954254389, 0.025746876373887062, 0.0022232988849282265, 0.03621046245098114, -0.01380633283406496, -0.03115454874932766, -0.008895035833120346, -0.02058279700577259, 0.1438785344362259, 0.07341939210891724, 0.04236640781164169, -0.07983069866895676, 0.005754661746323109, 0.013060019351541996, -0.0232316255569458, 0.020115941762924194, -0.02695426158607006, 0.024374496191740036, -0.030130663886666298, 0.048037901520729065, 0.032316550612449646, 0.034152623265981674, 0.04554293304681778, 0.045127589255571365, -0.022999094799160957, 0.008685142733156681, -0.005301653407514095, 0.014794967137277126, -0.0059126452542841434, -0.0016117622144520283, -0.06082301214337349, 0.008966994471848011, 0.022085510194301605, -0.017482150346040726, -0.028648991137742996, -0.0008688992820680141, -0.02182461880147457, 0.013955940492451191, -0.009601972997188568, -0.008643927983939648, 0.021325483918190002, 0.018012389540672302, 0.03464745357632637, -0.01800643838942051, 0.0055097914300858974, 0.002985801314935088, 0.008475181646645069, 0.06005879119038582, -0.008401605300605297, -0.00027624639915302396, 0.00016651461191941053, 0.025822851806879044, -0.02188331075012684, -0.033470697700977325, -0.023369869217276573, 0.00921234767884016, 0.010847858153283596, -0.0406334362924099, -0.018118998035788536, -0.0030353793408721685, 0.0464191809296608, -0.028001941740512848, -0.031410135328769684, 0.0076910569332540035, 0.027469845488667488, -0.022522663697600365, -0.02711678296327591, -0.039516329765319824, 0.016196664422750473, -0.006821159273386002, 0.03887045010924339, 0.012631689198315144, -0.024805596098303795, -0.0034243876580148935, -0.1022585853934288, 0.014848422259092331, 0.0401921309530735, -0.0023046124260872602, 0.02539299614727497, 0.0031714499928057194, 0.003298988798633218, 0.013820863328874111, 0.01461011916399002, 0.012167461216449738, -0.0003569366817828268, 0.01870780438184738, 0.000989078194834292, -0.018615083768963814, -0.038483139127492905, 0.0351281464099884, -0.05580298602581024, -0.04717544466257095, -0.022931281477212906, 0.022966435179114342, 0.020563771948218346, 0.05131393298506737, 0.026885436847805977, -0.009268642403185368, -0.029303085058927536, 0.04778054356575012, 0.0048952726647257805, -0.06337825208902359, -0.045039013028144836, 0.0379042886197567, -0.011380345560610294, -0.04178476706147194, -0.005616195499897003, 0.08346359431743622, 0.02519097924232483, 0.016563642770051956, -0.030688531696796417, 0.012103809043765068, 0.008886038325726986, -0.006146890111267567, 0.044134270399808884, -0.010874005034565926, 0.033121708780527115, -0.0289826188236475, -0.015298676677048206, -0.016062987968325615, -0.008898625150322914, -0.05045882612466812, -0.06304622441530228, 0.01426837220788002, -0.01929504983127117, -0.023901570588350296, 0.01390042807906866, 0.013463644310832024, -0.010067402385175228, -0.029457038268446922, -0.025269603356719017, -0.042108193039894104, -0.0519629642367363, 0.015499836765229702, -0.04573831334710121, 0.0029106303118169308, 0.004457714967429638, -0.024494275450706482, -0.012895890511572361, 0.013779807835817337, 0.025135189294815063, -0.000012933294783579186, 0.010046453215181828, -0.0013412685366347432, 0.0257073026150465, -0.0013617384247481823, -0.0028086185920983553, 0.014609655365347862, 0.0238391924649477, -0.07535162568092346, -0.042817093431949615, 0.02284824103116989, -0.009011605754494667, 0.025530487298965454, 0.017764458432793617, 0.008225110359489918, -0.0147255789488554, 0.0446893572807312, -0.02933051437139511, 0.002072452800348401, -0.0049118525348603725, 0.011668950319290161, -0.015782468020915985, -0.005885452497750521, 0.003096441039815545, 0.015503615140914917, 0.007556336000561714, 0.02561090886592865, 0.044081322848796844, 0.025850020349025726, 0.0038963069673627615, 0.03960870951414108, -0.03252001106739044, 0.0003803839790634811, 0.017644669860601425, -0.017269594594836235, 0.056651294231414795, 0.048078153282403946, -0.026360008865594864, 0.045595500618219376, -0.04724830761551857, 0.01011296920478344, -0.10123320668935776, -0.020561957731842995, 0.005057929083704948, -0.00043870374793186784, 0.04251863434910774, -0.06343134492635727, -0.008628151379525661, -0.0016937574837356806, -0.008423157036304474, -0.009353411383926868, 0.030949871987104416, -0.004324131179600954, -0.03790197893977165, 0.004235136788338423, -0.020243605598807335, 0.032174911350011826, 0.037889957427978516, 0.023625759407877922, 0.029387516900897026, 0.023065660148859024, 0.020187944173812866, -0.04197016358375549, -0.014197029173374176, 0.016722682863473892, 0.04031543806195259, -0.07544703781604767, 0.05087175592780113, -0.020969662815332413, -0.020658263936638832, 0.022308673709630966, -0.023438841104507446, 0.040668245404958725, 0.04146343842148781, 0.013169831596314907, 0.02232130616903305, 0.039976391941308975, 0.03381083160638809, -0.009187223389744759, 0.007633269764482975, 0.006522622425109148, 0.031348954886198044, -0.0015044159954413772, -0.03992742672562599, 0.030264051631093025, 0.026190806180238724, 0.0013496079482138157, -0.0179127249866724, 0.00500631146132946, -0.001157434773631394, -0.03183627873659134, -0.037841614335775375, 0.0017559593543410301, -0.018583988770842552, -0.037108153104782104, -0.0018463226733729243, -0.020096488296985626, -0.007072981912642717, 0.030434172600507736, 0.015477635897696018, -0.005750188138335943, 0.027691064402461052, -0.020220037549734116, -0.04230661317706108, -0.016981104388833046, -0.027667611837387085, -0.02529633603990078, -0.03798096254467964, -0.03118092380464077, -0.008423338644206524, 0.011856148019433022, -0.02618599496781826, 0.04241854324936867, -0.05865336209535599, 0.03080863691866398, -0.026339661329984665, 0.025516975671052933, 0.027570441365242004, -0.008036733604967594, 0.03528531268239021, -0.05835936218500137, 0.04815342649817467, 0.021101009100675583, -0.011476486921310425, -0.03811407834291458, 0.03698131442070007, 0.0057121990248560905, 0.02022157423198223, 0.009939859621226788, -0.01454204972833395, 0.016117315739393234, 0.020646115764975548, 0.0496155247092247, -0.019040800631046295, -0.04839698225259781, 0.02559196576476097, 0.03565521165728569, -0.014036988839507103, -0.03464684262871742, 0.017714301124215126, 0.011056323535740376, 0.006223691161721945, 0.023413153365254402, -0.0027729591820389032, -0.0019144642865285277, 0.0015447568148374557, -0.036616310477256775, 0.017809677869081497, -0.02073376066982746, -0.017939070239663124, 0.016243144869804382, -0.00909085851162672, -0.0017735461005941033, 0.026071172207593918, 0.030191687867045403, -0.0577985905110836, 0.026514660567045212, -0.022510036826133728, -0.022394586354494095, 0.012158507481217384, -0.023229893296957016, -0.017600826919078827, -0.09647524356842041, 0.00892877671867609, -0.0024205499794334173, -0.025861086323857307, -0.005601163953542709, 0.04841116815805435, 0.007352190092206001, 0.059049539268016815, -0.02454165183007717, -0.026693664491176605, 0.0003467078204266727, 0.00490622129291296, -0.0013216463848948479, 0.019823454320430756, 0.028966635465621948, -0.0205030869692564, 0.02048691362142563, 0.02484498731791973, 0.0008081355481408536, -0.011112662963569164, 0.00737817632034421, 0.08164715021848679, 0.019040346145629883, -0.010927741415798664, 0.009344070218503475, 0.011320685036480427, 0.061139047145843506, 0.016034867614507675, -0.0029686144553124905, 0.027319591492414474, -0.05671423301100731, -0.013377170078456402, -0.02915065549314022, -0.0494721420109272, -0.05431322380900383, 0.000320185354212299, 0.017649171873927116, 0.06106458604335785, 0.02117764763534069, 0.046824872493743896, 0.007040764205157757, -0.03718389570713043, 0.03351043909788132, 0.03545583412051201, -0.022439444437623024, -0.003854975337162614, -0.0036668721586465836, -0.0003206440305802971, 0.008147979155182838, 0.014199033379554749, -0.03725824132561684, 0.02604169212281704, 0.03309139236807823, 0.014644046314060688, -0.061679352074861526, -0.010946623049676418, 0.0253312848508358, 0.042063724249601364, -0.056131403893232346, -0.0034816318657249212, -0.017322184517979622, -0.011856402270495892, 0.03244349732995033, -0.029405491426587105 ]
<p>I'm a part of a volunteer organization that organizes a bunch of events. For each event, members need to submit an application in order to attend the event. A lot of people want to go to these events and we only have a limited number of spots available, so the selection process is usually pretty competitive. The application selections (accept/reject) for each event are usually handled by a different group of people, so it can be somewhat challenging to ensure that the selection process is as "fair" as possible across the board. I happen to have access to all of the relevant data (who applied to which events, who was accepted/rejected, some stats on the applicant, etc.), and I'm trying to assess whether the current acceptance policy is "fair" or not.</p> <p>In a perfect world, each applicant would be accepted the same proportion of the time. Obviously in real life this may not necessarily be the case. For example, if 5 people apply to 10 events each, and are accepted to 5,7,6,6,5 of them, the system appears to be mostly fair, since the difference between the acceptance proportions isn't that big. On the other hand, if the acceptance numbers are 2,3,9,8,3, the system is obviously unfair since a few people are being selected repeatedly at the expense of the others. What's the most meaningful way to quantify this in terms of actual statistics?</p> <p>Also, I have access to some data which might influence the acceptance rate of a particular individual, for example the number of articles written by them in the past year. It makes sense that someone who has written more articles should be accepted to more events. Also, if someone has, for example, only applied to 1 or 2 events ever, it makes sense for them to have a higher acceptance rate than someone who has applied to dozens.</p> <p>So in short, I'm trying to come with a way to figure out if the current distribution of acceptance proportions is correlated in terms of some of the variables to which I would expect it to be correlated, as opposed to based solely on luck, and if it does turn out to be based solely on luck, whether the proportions are roughly uniform across the population or some people are repeatedly being favored at the expense of others.</p> <p>Can someone guide me in the right direction here?</p>
36,974
[ -0.06595001369714737, -0.04005229100584984, -0.018483014777302742, -0.05005694553256035, 0.07940679788589478, 0.0099419504404068, 0.0017899147933349013, -0.011188213713467121, -0.0008456305949948728, 0.009936036542057991, 0.0541987307369709, 0.038632020354270935, 0.0034981619101017714, 0.05933823436498642, 0.009659036993980408, 0.0021467783953994513, -0.004624891094863415, 0.05498522147536278, 0.0030428923200815916, 0.016707969829440117, 0.01568427123129368, 0.02696257270872593, 0.0058526392094790936, -0.009333851747214794, -0.07977402955293655, 0.019123908132314682, 0.0010368026560172439, -0.028139935806393623, 0.0021530459634959698, 0.028350234031677246, -0.056772492825984955, 0.013447764329612255, 0.04991382732987404, 0.03940483182668686, 0.04284097999334335, 0.025965718552470207, -0.03517938032746315, -0.008906266652047634, -0.01595049351453781, 0.02625950798392296, -0.045223869383335114, -0.040746964514255524, -0.0388781912624836, 0.006502253469079733, 0.02255181409418583, 0.012297115288674831, -0.0030654845759272575, -0.04328998178243637, 0.04243011772632599, -0.04237757995724678, 0.08902980387210846, 0.022566262632608414, 0.01335503626614809, 0.012178639881312847, 0.004066407680511475, -0.044592998921871185, 0.040545299649238586, 0.04142126441001892, 0.003371765371412039, -0.015649547800421715, 0.02975211851298809, -0.030351441353559494, -0.031097710132598877, -0.008555658161640167, 0.0033268718980252743, 0.018301524221897125, 0.01162658166140318, -0.01574908196926117, 0.06386902183294296, -0.007697362918406725, -0.002425933489575982, 0.02379682846367359, 0.06304362416267395, -0.016191445291042328, 0.029225077480077744, -0.035503752529621124, 0.027033550664782524, -0.014448029920458794, 0.028651723638176918, 0.018210401758551598, -0.012896819971501827, -0.014191952534019947, 0.03624371439218521, 0.05363352596759796, 0.029630497097969055, -0.04484427347779274, 0.018348339945077896, -0.06092949956655502, 0.018097570165991783, 0.017023414373397827, -0.025485113263130188, -0.01531063113361597, 0.03766670450568199, -0.004667901434004307, -0.06535673141479492, 0.024800773710012436, -0.012941841967403889, 0.04229671135544777, 0.007432985585182905, 0.019564323127269745, -0.02818126417696476, -0.04748916253447533, -0.0224747471511364, 0.08257973194122314, -0.015567412599921227, -0.032736074179410934, -0.045549292117357254, -0.0017995923990383744, -0.03503507003188133, -0.0010590454330667853, -0.0064161294139921665, -0.0038309127558022738, 0.03232273831963539, 0.03634418174624443, 0.012244698591530323, 0.026697712019085884, -0.01960219442844391, -0.008781707845628262, 0.09049706906080246, 0.06311292201280594, 0.03100450150668621, -0.041512954980134964, 0.00010057631880044937, 0.010697088204324245, -0.01876259036362171, 0.0068304273299872875, 0.032064687460660934, -0.02105908840894699, -0.01914074458181858, 0.04442411661148071, 0.011551391333341599, -0.012643752619624138, 0.027068207040429115, -0.003693666774779558, -0.0034295725636184216, 0.002779867500066757, -0.06354273855686188, -0.04832695797085762, 0.014248620718717575, 0.03832349181175232, -0.04049789533019066, -0.06893032044172287, 0.0020374769810587168, 0.0171793382614851, 0.06444098800420761, -0.0003109496319666505, 0.0637904554605484, -0.02708739973604679, 0.027035197243094444, 0.017415858805179596, -0.020144127309322357, 0.021703967824578285, -0.012507220730185509, -0.007206302136182785, -0.005119194742292166, -0.07744935154914856, 0.027699433267116547, 0.03389688581228256, 0.007671299856156111, -0.022553451359272003, 0.014027446508407593, -0.005267046391963959, -0.02040606364607811, -0.028052154928445816, 0.03688256815075874, -0.005231255199760199, 0.05666537210345268, -0.008193125016987324, 0.007281193044036627, 0.012066145427525043, -0.00952084269374609, 0.022405842319130898, 0.014020184986293316, 0.03592878580093384, 0.015159813687205315, -0.03953427076339722, 0.04450571537017822, -0.006504657678306103, -0.005653210449963808, -0.01524356845766306, -0.011140512302517891, 0.0008628983632661402, -0.01176234520971775, 0.0018316926434636116, 0.017119240015745163, 0.00912917498499155, 0.03281269967556, 0.000981024233624339, 0.02042650245130062, -0.032473620027303696, -0.03965627774596214, -0.08226199448108673, -0.022720780223608017, -0.015216009691357613, -0.030725689604878426, 0.061857059597969055, 0.01600870117545128, -0.019466744735836983, -0.01738116517663002, -0.014193116687238216, -0.015872875228524208, -0.030622895807027817, 0.010545908473432064, -0.044996391981840134, -0.005697991698980331, 0.06118194758892059, 0.02249528281390667, 0.0017230615485459566, 0.057399436831474304, -0.06190342828631401, -0.08931832760572433, -0.028432132676243782, -0.0433083213865757, 0.0623905248939991, -0.007282780017703772, 0.007497029844671488, 0.016979577019810677, -0.008104473352432251, -0.03141231834888458, 0.016643129289150238, -0.05792218819260597, 0.08812768012285233, 0.06016720458865166, -0.003107756841927767, 0.004206882324069738, 0.013056167401373386, 0.020447181537747383, -0.005817245226353407, -0.014042224735021591, -0.00790995080024004, -0.049785204231739044, -0.0069591752253472805, 0.030760491266846657, 0.0012545614736154675, -0.015096758492290974, 0.013795956037938595, 0.062456753104925156, 0.0224972702562809, 0.01633600890636444, 0.017961708828806877, -0.02043304592370987, 0.004865369759500027, 0.006840238347649574, 0.023510906845331192, 0.003698453539982438, 0.027786828577518463, 0.031746234744787216, -0.013914975337684155, -0.002070758957415819, 0.0169292613863945, 0.0009116246947087348, 0.019922543317079544, 0.005789106246083975, 0.010173466056585312, -0.00688084727153182, -0.013057593256235123, 0.06335464119911194, 0.005167220253497362, 0.004395600873976946, 0.04510283097624779, 0.020850570872426033, 0.03342737257480621, 0.022537384182214737, -0.017860665917396545, 0.025408323854207993, 0.005686839576810598, -0.03778238967061043, -0.04446769878268242, 0.02255602367222309, -0.004434626549482346, 0.009853299707174301, -0.026503227651119232, -0.005920796189457178, -0.024890342727303505, -0.026204468682408333, 0.01882815733551979, 0.029284775257110596, 0.008061710745096207, -0.009675118140876293, -0.014156454242765903, -0.0017492934130132198, 0.000798950728494674, 0.018073795363307, 0.021710185334086418, -0.0813392624258995, 0.009877894073724747, 0.02293287217617035, -0.02598562464118004, 0.03902772068977356, -0.043935127556324005, -0.03624698892235756, 0.03478311747312546, 0.004870118107646704, -0.025301001965999603, -0.02437400631606579, 0.013529193587601185, -0.020998885855078697, -0.04922689497470856, -0.006184680853039026, 0.05304405465722084, 0.022920871153473854, -0.08202296495437622, 0.029192497953772545, -0.02608608454465866, -0.03495212644338608, -0.03320298343896866, -0.00496188597753644, 0.02670113742351532, -0.025577418506145477, 0.018576860427856445, 0.017598530277609825, 0.013829813338816166, 0.004296376835554838, -0.06925800442695618, -0.058589912950992584, 0.012809931300580502, -0.046155013144016266, 0.053915269672870636, 0.008744836784899235, -0.001788694760762155, 0.053732991218566895, 0.04109267517924309, -0.008356096222996712, 0.0005544109735637903, 0.01828375644981861, -0.02279466949403286, 0.0340624675154686, 0.03338320180773735, 0.04693982005119324, -0.010059020482003689, 0.028295906260609627, 0.023021111264824867, 0.034349068999290466, 0.0532352440059185, -0.01734011247754097, -0.0122445710003376, 0.04171482101082802, 0.008034740574657917, 0.004389303270727396, 0.02314947545528412, 0.01639438048005104, -0.060898929834365845, 0.04110947623848915, -0.020236803218722343, 0.0033864520955830812, 0.010491889901459217, -0.060538046061992645, 0.0020635498221963644, -0.019629256799817085, 0.007918734103441238, -0.023935850709676743, 0.016440071165561676, 0.0040189484134316444, -0.03973929211497307, -0.0011332952417433262, 0.012333748862147331, 0.05034535005688667, -0.013099062256515026, 0.022661106660962105, 0.05721567943692207, 0.038244687020778656, 0.00427937600761652, -0.005489852279424667, -0.05952555313706398, 0.010749489068984985, -0.002744478639215231, -0.03970249369740486, -0.0029895633924752474, 0.04889069125056267, 0.04361916333436966, 0.008025565184652805, -0.04500124976038933, -0.04480345547199249, 0.00777027290314436, -0.07177373766899109, 0.002082884544506669, -0.029548507183790207, 0.052366990596055984, -0.011131626553833485, 0.020680371671915054, -0.0032646090257912874, -0.007392017636448145, 0.01565193571150303, 0.021623602136969566, -0.06032935902476311, -0.003858816111460328, -0.032425105571746826, 0.02759632281959057, -0.02391120418906212, -0.010147690773010254, 0.01847613789141178, -0.018728649243712425, 0.010068823583424091, -0.010376631282269955, 0.04615214094519615, -0.008937302976846695, 0.0240348931401968, -0.0451892614364624, -0.0280006043612957, 0.008267238736152649, 0.03370935097336769, -0.0045829350128769875, 0.018171560019254684, 0.064932681620121, 0.021133113652467728, 0.004291634541004896, -0.04310643672943115, -0.020675282925367355, 0.038012050092220306, 0.03991890326142311, 0.044979579746723175, 0.0022561296354979277, 0.0346129909157753, -0.06786859780550003, 0.015589313581585884, -0.023267870768904686, 0.04067908972501755, 0.04676953703165054, 0.005773997865617275, -0.025027016177773476, -0.053306035697460175, -0.012311669997870922, -0.0030071937944740057, 0.0011230198433622718, -0.005551528185606003, -0.037403322756290436, 0.05174827575683594, 0.010647308081388474, -0.08037204295396805, -0.012956998310983181, 0.02019469439983368, -0.01882479526102543, -0.0028514834120869637, -0.007454275619238615, -0.019320398569107056, 0.039864957332611084, 0.007295066490769386, -0.020826658234000206, 0.022030362859368324, 0.017728928476572037, 0.020470641553401947, 0.008557189255952835, -0.0018941008020192385, -0.0742814689874649, -0.009535626508295536, -0.030113626271486282, 0.06094225496053696, 0.020830262452363968, -0.03141181543469429, 0.03597089648246765, 0.04247564822435379, 0.01947297342121601, 0.0245321374386549, -0.004306456074118614, -0.016570718958973885, 0.004117901436984539, 0.0656396821141243, 0.005018836352974176, -0.04800940677523613, -0.026550009846687317, -0.03932970017194748, 0.0005877590738236904, 0.040170978754758835, -0.0012879041023552418, 0.014139419421553612, 0.05428270995616913, 0.00902397371828556, -0.0005267005763016641, -0.029403913766145706, -0.05682488530874252, 0.008274114690721035, -0.010452797636389732, 0.010964234359562397, -0.04949142038822174, -0.01913909986615181, -0.046956248581409454, 0.011765051633119583, 0.03890327364206314, 0.0646471306681633, -0.028829550370573997, -0.0340636745095253, -0.013975669629871845, -0.0049905781634151936, -0.007240192033350468, -0.08628372848033905, 0.010938276536762714, 0.024661146104335785, 0.0317843034863472, 0.034175314009189606, -0.027896931394934654, 0.007271305657923222, 0.037951234728097916, -0.021214047446846962, -0.031657371670007706, 0.0172419473528862, -0.048680614680051804, 0.06370536983013153, 0.047138821333646774, 0.03305579349398613, 0.06036180257797241, 0.005103630945086479, -0.027571555227041245, -0.002763167954981327, -0.04182078689336777, 0.0032685173209756613, -0.018432945013046265, 0.00757095729932189, -0.023784980177879333, -0.006022234912961721, -0.026026466861367226, -0.0023184509482234716, 0.013556038960814476, 0.036866165697574615, 0.014549687504768372, -0.04475656896829605, -0.03136849403381348, -0.007568486500531435, -0.0007757011917419732, -0.007127237040549517, 0.03605058789253235, 0.010214252397418022, -0.005202764179557562, -0.004429821390658617, 0.03809259086847305, -0.02533097192645073, 0.0006893760873936117, 0.0002904174034483731, -0.044014036655426025, -0.02000785805284977, -0.02530072070658207, -0.018588297069072723, -0.009908393025398254, -0.009265696629881859, 0.059226732701063156, -0.04232311621308327, 0.05738357454538345, -0.002764485776424408, -0.006632857955992222, -0.02319101057946682, 0.04258198291063309, -0.007257202640175819, 0.05474993586540222, 0.004196183755993843, 0.014660312794148922, -0.025113705545663834, 0.01632678136229515, -0.07339011132717133, 0.012701988220214844, 0.004692582879215479, 0.0035594997461885214, -0.04565791040658951, -0.03840147331357002, -0.027662115171551704, 0.0025003182236105204, -0.04523162916302681, -0.002898597391322255, 0.058729495853185654, -0.026199545711278915, -0.005500625818967819, -0.013761659152805805, 0.022990353405475616, 0.06992144882678986, -0.0351857915520668, -0.04585815966129303, 0.01676955819129944, -0.0018361349357292056, 0.012469246052205563, -0.017186947166919708, 0.027702748775482178, -0.04877535626292229, -0.014607743360102177, -0.020710548385977745, 0.0029864883981645107, 0.024226972833275795, -0.009616568684577942, -0.025045502930879593, -0.0009975559078156948, -0.026126353070139885, 0.0027986448258161545, 0.0015479011926800013, 0.01931711472570896, 0.01795675978064537, -0.03474275767803192, -0.005647663492709398, -0.00025501943309791386, -0.01242004707455635, 0.008640533313155174, 0.007639902178198099, 0.03048119507730007, -0.014189203269779682, 0.030789662152528763, 0.0578092597424984, -0.022766707465052605, -0.0011131609790027142, 0.012998527847230434, -0.011073675006628036, 0.035333119332790375, -0.0067888833582401276, -0.011678270995616913, -0.0037867401260882616, 0.017368871718645096, -0.020423101261258125, -0.027964722365140915, -0.043403830379247665, -0.010166293010115623, 0.03754027560353279, 0.004352075979113579, -0.0053581479005515575, 0.05893522873520851, 0.002541732043027878, -0.020849481225013733, 0.0027252198196947575, 0.007020166143774986, -0.032764192670583725, 0.018129803240299225, 0.05207054316997528, -0.034116629511117935, -0.03404511138796806, 0.025574536994099617, 0.014063007198274136, 0.019817179068922997, 0.02953578345477581, 0.016566695645451546, -0.009249518625438213, 0.04071513190865517, -0.01985255628824234, -0.03666984289884567, 0.02213106118142605, -0.03541891649365425, 0.03443191573023796, -0.006787296384572983, -0.03604194149374962, 0.059530794620513916, 0.040841080248355865, -0.023775622248649597, -0.024350125342607498, -0.0324203297495842, -0.03135082870721817, -0.005501719191670418, 0.0185181125998497, -0.0021655496675521135, 0.0432143434882164, -0.0017192598897963762, 0.026008162647485733, 0.01755150966346264, 0.01867990754544735, -0.04528024420142174, -0.03783658891916275, 0.01620161533355713, -0.028563452884554863, -0.07508254051208496, 0.0191336777061224, 0.02549634501338005, -0.0011542367283254862, 0.0015348492888733745, -0.020750852301716805, 0.007790659088641405, 0.011277459561824799, 0.05816611647605896, -0.020727066323161125, 0.06332377344369888, 0.03484960272908211, 0.0024407620076090097, -0.028544850647449493, -0.008927053771913052, 0.11716039478778839, 0.06379278004169464, 0.03681504353880882, -0.026482919231057167, 0.00316253793425858, 0.008689669892191887, -0.004419479053467512, -0.019473960623145103, -0.009732904843986034, 0.004255540668964386, -0.03337452933192253, 0.0699869692325592, 0.014781403355300426, 0.01757311448454857, -0.008439933881163597, 0.07001709192991257, -0.016129864379763603, -0.03826358541846275, -0.00825098343193531, -0.008224151097238064, 0.029731811955571175, -0.0019924454391002655, -0.025711150839924812, 0.01418557669967413, 0.05824224278330803, 0.025654733180999756, -0.03049832209944725, -0.007173907943069935, -0.011668190360069275, -0.04286986216902733, 0.008648091927170753, 0.010847778059542179, 0.005720670334994793, -0.008201058022677898, -0.051433853805065155, -0.016341842710971832, 0.014486615546047688, -0.05949359014630318, 0.04242955148220062, 0.060124922543764114, 0.0075583928264677525, -0.003277006559073925, -0.011467047035694122, 0.020118147134780884, -0.011079354211688042, -0.008500952273607254, -0.053106486797332764, 0.03294886276125908, -0.03824765980243683, 0.001353616127744317, -0.006766922771930695, -0.004362010397017002, 0.008965901099145412, -0.03456142917275429, -0.017892519012093544, -0.0012675138423219323, 0.012584172189235687, -0.023160012438893318, 0.0013329974608495831, 0.02400493621826172, 0.023258348926901817, 0.0023697898723185062, 0.015719644725322723, 0.023367155343294144, -0.02320357784628868, -0.03622429817914963, -0.04320055991411209, 0.04609350860118866, 0.0057271611876785755, -0.026868082582950592, -0.033538591116666794, 0.001371213118545711, -0.04665909707546234, 0.008739501237869263, -0.019674720242619514, -0.009901738725602627, 0.05347680673003197, -0.003019727999344468, 0.011404155753552914, -0.04360843077301979, 0.016827823594212532, 0.01903345063328743, -0.025098830461502075, -0.02548268996179104, -0.032386694103479385, -0.01129077561199665, 0.005871235858649015, 0.017020724713802338, 0.03209745138883591, 0.028149213641881943, 0.0019809436053037643, 0.027393268421292305, 0.008945283479988575, -0.03522001951932907, -0.016820281744003296, -0.0461646169424057, -0.03957071900367737, 0.018938487395644188, 0.021155277267098427, 0.07405105978250504, 0.022186098620295525, 0.005637517664581537, 0.015284940600395203, 0.00013674685033038259, -0.014073334634304047, 0.002164066070690751, -0.003912525251507759, -0.05074048414826393, -0.029570864513516426, 0.0030047742184251547, -0.027177885174751282, -0.038539402186870575, -0.02576669678092003, -0.05142678692936897, -0.021105587482452393, 0.02611711621284485, -0.025750180706381798, 0.005822811275720596, 0.0025230632163584232, -0.0011214978294447064, 0.022101489827036858, 0.027131929993629456, -0.020504949614405632, -0.031428731977939606, -0.04437772557139397, -0.008601079694926739, 0.021625779569149017, -0.00008515569061273709, 0.011434722691774368, 0.028053566813468933, 0.024027453735470772, 0.025408083572983742, -0.038506899029016495, 0.004424322862178087, -0.042736031115055084, 0.011217975057661533, -0.002083652652800083, 0.040574029088020325, -0.023657748475670815, -0.027983609586954117, 0.05181526765227318, -0.013818207196891308, -0.047828711569309235, 0.021176481619477272, -0.020946519449353218, 0.06862349808216095, -0.004959066864103079, -0.01988123543560505, -0.03796418756246567, 0.042695850133895874, -0.038057003170251846, -0.03281344845890999, -0.04079756140708923, 0.026106707751750946, 0.037340376526117325, -0.0073169018141925335, -0.0045455871149897575, 0.009845303371548653, 0.002168146660551429, 0.01106998324394226, 0.027677690610289574, -0.01737060397863388, -0.014619878493249416, -0.01042737253010273, -0.01402400340884924, -0.02569933980703354, -0.007925553247332573, -0.024270743131637573, -0.014557554386556149, 0.04496094956994057, -0.032346345484256744, 0.05018036440014839, 0.017450416460633278, -0.006229322869330645, -0.06188199296593666, -0.034535735845565796, 0.00762601662427187, -0.004637424368411303, 0.015652766451239586, -0.027874939143657684, 0.016206953674554825, 0.030538655817508698, -0.02217325195670128, 0.03269404172897339, 0.022415021434426308, -0.009863542392849922, -0.05086498707532883, 0.0313756950199604, -0.03222155570983887, 0.005175478756427765, 0.03503574803471565, 0.021992895752191544, 0.020375410094857216, 0.02400960959494114, -0.019918357953429222, -0.006080509163439274, -0.02166644297540188, 0.01550420094281435, -0.01477217860519886, -0.04523414745926857, 0.04505518078804016, -0.04612928628921509, -0.06312436610460281, 0.05202220380306244, 0.026190871372818947, 0.004400400444865227, 0.006762443110346794, 0.020174896344542503, 0.01239089760929346, 0.047266434878110886, 0.03947223350405693, -0.012728135101497173, 0.018594205379486084, 0.015049023553729057, 0.01741030253469944, 0.055184777826070786, -0.03048175945878029, 0.001997465267777443, 0.022730840370059013, -0.004565870855003595, -0.020339075475931168, -0.001388720702379942, 0.023074360564351082, -0.017594143748283386, 0.008745166473090649, -0.06275250762701035, 0.04426364228129387, 0.0009938131552189589, 0.032178379595279694, -0.04290672764182091, 0.017576586455106735, 0.01947903260588646, 0.011236208491027355, -0.04040552303195, 0.02930108830332756, -0.037110984325408936, -0.011271994560956955, 0.008601945824921131, 0.024083435535430908, 0.022333811968564987, -0.04490921273827553, -0.004062588792294264, -0.01586042530834675, -0.007492572534829378, 0.0026999327819794416, -0.017369916662573814, -0.028562365099787712, 0.015113357454538345, -0.005319179035723209, -0.0008820340735837817, 0.019722212105989456, -0.00521899713203311, 0.007889761589467525, -0.10855717957019806, 0.03208201751112938, -0.0075948359444737434, -0.001414684345945716, -0.04065200313925743, -0.014500507153570652, -0.028042461723089218, 0.013848111033439636, 0.03555283322930336, 0.004379540681838989, -0.02888931892812252, -0.014324118383228779, 0.017495397478342056, 0.004927312023937702, -0.0822836384177208, 0.04045224189758301, -0.030238326638936996, -0.007890754379332066, -0.03847683221101761, 0.008030458353459835, 0.013262012973427773, -0.03487442061305046, -0.00742409797385335, -0.018741006031632423, -0.00825272686779499, -0.004448005463927984, -0.01880922168493271, 0.03941258415579796, 0.033920351415872574, -0.007687845267355442, 0.002846648683771491, -0.016247030347585678, 0.038554783910512924, 0.003512088442221284, -0.0005578352138400078, -0.06937839090824127, 0.04052278399467468, -0.03672238439321518, -0.06348782777786255, -0.007317023817449808, 0.029271984472870827, -0.011132555082440376, -0.07358507812023163, 0.03308408707380295, 0.03702666237950325, -0.05163899064064026, -0.004387591499835253, 0.015271349810063839, 0.029697204008698463, 0.01720445044338703, -0.0065513369627296925, 0.03993825241923332, -0.021860241889953613, -0.06448668241500854, -0.030671562999486923, -0.005520982202142477, 0.035924941301345825, 0.019510425627231598, 0.019044771790504456, 0.0315365344285965, 0.02691408433020115, 0.049145687371492386, 0.017959976568818092, 0.01895419880747795, -0.03882051631808281, 0.026439065113663673, 0.0366341806948185, -0.008982050232589245, 0.006092729512602091, 0.027013689279556274, 0.019556377083063126, 0.07020986825227737, 0.00029784892103634775, 0.042278263717889786, -0.05417841672897339, 0.007176710292696953, 0.019777104258537292, 0.004769567400217056, -0.0005636792629957199, 0.018408501520752907, -0.038087595254182816, -0.0009779914980754256, -0.003247348591685295, 0.03344860300421715, 0.056316256523132324, -0.025928717106580734, 0.041014425456523895, 0.026525042951107025, -0.009610817767679691, 0.002989571075886488, -0.001307403203099966, -0.017730697989463806, -0.028219550848007202, 0.03893829137086868, 0.014795870520174503, 0.002225184813141823, 0.01620945706963539, -0.00023188747582025826, 0.023253081366419792, 0.05470365658402443, -0.02454119548201561, -0.04072951152920723, -0.07901865988969803, 0.04158739373087883, -0.011020778678357601, 0.016523050144314766 ]
<p>Generating n random variables whose summation will be 1. [<em>I got the answer.</em>]</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong></p> <p>On genetic algorithm, we have to maintain population. Say, I have two individuals <strong>a</strong> and <strong>b</strong>. Every individual consists of $n$ pairs of ($x_i, \theta_i$), where $ 0 \leq i &lt; n$. A fitness function evaluates fitness, $f$ of every individual. <strong>Constraint is for every individual is $\Sigma\theta_i \approx 1$ ($0.95 \leq \Sigma\theta_i &lt; 1.05$ would suffice).</strong> $\theta_i$ associated with individual <strong>a</strong> will be adapted by some function (which I haven't figured out yet) of $d(a, b)$ &amp; $\Delta f$. $\theta_i$ will be adaptive (by I guess something like covariance matrix). So if I increase value of $\theta_i$, values of some $\theta_j$ have to be decreased to maintain summation $\Sigma\theta_i \approx 1$. So I am seeking suggestion how can be $\theta_i$ adapted based on $d(a, b)$ &amp; $\Delta f$?</p>
74,227
[ -0.04346282035112381, -0.0047274199314415455, -0.008407795801758766, -0.0075520798563957214, 0.037236955016851425, -0.006489375606179237, -0.009587719105184078, -0.037905432283878326, 0.04457888752222061, -0.05579940229654312, 0.035866446793079376, 0.032043714076280594, 0.04028503969311714, 0.03384028375148773, 0.07395396381616592, -0.024712644517421722, -0.017085397616028786, -0.004740928765386343, -0.0173365268856287, -0.010740760713815689, 0.01700819469988346, 0.06012125685811043, 0.04849791154265404, -0.0015228112461045384, -0.023267043754458427, 0.046066638082265854, 0.005542149767279625, -0.024402111768722534, -0.03173373267054558, 0.0648563876748085, -0.03568026050925255, -0.031671006232500076, 0.02035067230463028, 0.0723138079047203, 0.017814461141824722, 0.006609056144952774, -0.05244026705622673, -0.006066170055419207, -0.015611475333571434, -0.013950495980679989, -0.045818205922842026, -0.058790478855371475, -0.017405208200216293, 0.0017627691850066185, -0.009640614502131939, 0.013934889808297157, -0.02365298569202423, -0.059951841831207275, 0.027736296877264977, -0.05546830967068672, 0.09345787018537521, 0.025796951726078987, 0.026994852349162102, 0.02136647328734398, 0.018717465922236443, -0.056391339749097824, 0.03306160867214203, 0.06655703485012054, 0.02469738759100437, -0.02136445790529251, -0.0022405926138162613, -0.039360273629426956, 0.041174884885549545, -0.0008524334407411516, -0.021975111216306686, 0.017538946121931076, -0.0072248950600624084, -0.02069941721856594, 0.0030858993995934725, -0.054917093366384506, 0.02948530577123165, 0.018520096316933632, 0.02932065539062023, -0.002452503191307187, -0.0003421954170335084, -0.0032942388206720352, -0.02104237675666809, 0.0006140024634078145, 0.04895460233092308, 0.024401210248470306, -0.005975229199975729, 0.004794544540345669, 0.029488753527402878, 0.030198466032743454, -0.006930302828550339, 0.019894735887646675, 0.0630902647972107, -0.023966293781995773, 0.017073968425393105, 0.02576199732720852, -0.01756262220442295, 0.014123344793915749, 0.060094721615314484, -0.047020502388477325, -0.08422588557004929, 0.028459958732128143, -0.017231764271855354, 0.015430908650159836, 0.018248209729790688, -0.04467189684510231, 0.0055443593300879, -0.06276830285787582, 0.02560529299080372, 0.05688946694135666, -0.012464657425880432, -0.008479791693389416, -0.06101610139012337, 0.005113272927701473, 0.01756262220442295, -0.039679236710071564, 0.006380253005772829, 0.03044324927031994, 0.0022792217787355185, -0.016539203003048897, 0.030010584741830826, 0.023649167269468307, -0.034749835729599, -0.019780263304710388, 0.03192242234945297, 0.07577380537986755, 0.03294971585273743, -0.006058383733034134, 0.026052601635456085, 0.007124318275600672, -0.0408349484205246, 0.023223036900162697, 0.009176241233944893, -0.031814634799957275, -0.049865152686834335, 0.030560018494725227, 0.006595341954380274, -0.05707547441124916, 0.012415919452905655, 0.0428549163043499, -0.001112234080210328, -0.005836748983711004, -0.10129299014806747, -0.04336912930011749, 0.03400864079594612, -0.05416398122906685, 0.005662492476403713, -0.08414805680513382, -0.011453009210526943, 0.05724911764264107, 0.046603791415691376, 0.04426489397883415, 0.053863950073719025, 0.003368213539943099, 0.04118680953979492, 0.04695414751768112, -0.019689228385686874, -0.01807834580540657, -0.048220809549093246, -0.017663292586803436, -0.025376437231898308, -0.06360438466072083, 0.02904597856104374, 0.020333506166934967, -0.01779104582965374, -0.007966642268002033, 0.0426720567047596, -0.0011577610857784748, -0.014256162568926811, -0.039971768856048584, 0.026447927579283714, -0.0023388187400996685, 0.06398233026266098, 0.006303184200078249, 0.027988309040665627, -0.010809868574142456, -0.031941916793584824, -0.021055443212389946, 0.01739320531487465, 0.04693692922592163, 0.04583482816815376, -0.04593893885612488, 0.011232206597924232, -0.01776353269815445, 0.008829005993902683, 0.01586863026022911, -0.013704409822821617, -0.03612690791487694, -0.03140505403280258, -0.003121208632364869, 0.014141418039798737, 0.03708186373114586, -0.0059159244410693645, -0.0011290787952020764, 0.014686060138046741, -0.02681269310414791, -0.0008069735486060381, -0.07380697131156921, -0.009900383651256561, 0.04047146439552307, -0.01926434598863125, 0.02897435799241066, 0.02199583500623703, 0.026602672412991524, 0.003828323446214199, -0.012224770151078701, -0.0168729480355978, 0.01976572535932064, 0.06135614216327667, -0.03913360834121704, 0.015852367505431175, 0.05464066565036774, 0.035101793706417084, -0.014909571968019009, 0.05944707244634628, -0.007118969224393368, -0.0432475320994854, -0.02252756431698799, -0.05465542525053024, 0.02458040975034237, -0.01198045164346695, 0.0075699519366025925, 0.022861847653985023, -0.01911999098956585, 0.018182994797825813, 0.003837074851617217, -0.05187167972326279, 0.04873304441571236, 0.041003428399562836, 0.014509106054902077, 0.010666041634976864, 0.062229521572589874, 0.014576145447790623, 0.0018506357446312904, -0.04746808484196663, -0.042493030428886414, -0.03571978583931923, 0.03578384965658188, 0.05554140359163284, 0.04332864657044411, -0.042942095547914505, -0.000040413397073280066, 0.02133173495531082, 0.0186637993901968, 0.029576260596513748, 0.03299586847424507, -0.018105875700712204, -0.00439845584332943, 0.004414790775626898, 0.033123929053545, 0.03348289430141449, 0.004405525978654623, 0.00688482541590929, -0.0101792486384511, -0.018555723130702972, -0.021651197224855423, 0.02753293514251709, -0.012902981601655483, 0.029224781319499016, -0.014934300445020199, -0.04660806059837341, 0.010299576446413994, 0.022838206961750984, -0.04026508703827858, 0.02304753288626671, 0.03969832882285118, -0.022561702877283096, -0.01843501254916191, -0.009292367845773697, -0.054550815373659134, 0.019433263689279556, 0.023429447785019875, -0.011736143380403519, -0.022295411676168442, 0.020928939804434776, -0.0003814786905422807, 0.007817928679287434, -0.0005261414917185903, -0.028846008703112602, 0.0005184606416150928, 0.00763401435688138, -0.01190722081810236, 0.010673942044377327, 0.0031508419197052717, -0.01843918487429619, -0.0005863522528670728, -0.0008852657047100365, 0.007459715474396944, 0.010434405878186226, 0.015563578344881535, -0.05709577724337578, -0.02726234681904316, 0.009074659086763859, -0.038170356303453445, 0.03540244325995445, 0.013133239932358265, 0.01428959984332323, -0.001263572252355516, -0.02922404557466507, -0.07758934795856476, -0.01091673132032156, -0.03440611809492111, -0.002932742005214095, -0.03643279895186424, -0.040232155472040176, 0.034161943942308426, 0.019378015771508217, -0.04059239476919174, 0.01452882681041956, -0.04047035425901413, -0.023755086585879326, -0.032255422323942184, 0.020934198051691055, -0.004088439978659153, 0.011734824627637863, 0.04053865373134613, 0.04589096084237099, -0.015888728201389313, -0.0026465600822120905, -0.060443855822086334, -0.05572181195020676, 0.012432744726538658, 0.004223623778671026, 0.04966932535171509, 0.031972482800483704, -0.03161516785621643, 0.05242382735013962, 0.03325849398970604, -0.027336901053786278, -0.027060188353061676, -0.011458789929747581, 0.05989912897348404, -0.0782676488161087, 0.03318825736641884, 0.04147292301058769, -0.015152867883443832, 0.050626419484615326, 0.007526601664721966, 0.0112993149086833, 0.064144566655159, -0.003155106445774436, -0.034094925969839096, 0.04436441883444786, -0.010185863822698593, 0.012785722501575947, 0.039932116866111755, 0.002265345538035035, -0.023099461570382118, 0.03582235798239708, 0.011960486881434917, 0.015226992778480053, 0.0006899524596519768, -0.024058155715465546, 0.016747282817959785, -0.00435124896466732, 0.012474523857235909, -0.02172330766916275, 0.021652033552527428, 0.002675530966371298, -0.04810819402337074, -0.0006895991391502321, 0.05908118560910225, 0.010790999978780746, -0.022052627056837082, 0.026922903954982758, 0.038663435727357864, 0.016525128856301308, -0.009320120327174664, -0.004520444665104151, 0.01848731003701687, 0.018772650510072708, 0.019643031060695648, -0.016137823462486267, 0.012392017059028149, 0.014294124208390713, 0.020980387926101685, 0.001955307088792324, -0.004977201111614704, -0.016976265236735344, -0.00982654094696045, -0.04877542331814766, 0.037023305892944336, -0.046932414174079895, 0.07370533794164658, -0.005953379441052675, 0.028690364211797714, 0.024441992864012718, 0.009010562673211098, 0.016071973368525505, 0.0016188077861443162, -0.09931616485118866, 0.030172428116202354, -0.007882298901677132, -0.020969435572624207, -0.004445746075361967, -0.020530546084046364, 0.033125001937150955, -0.032789986580610275, 0.042773015797138214, -0.01789095811545849, 0.014502635225653648, -0.013103487901389599, -0.006154234055429697, -0.008051264099776745, -0.0495210625231266, -0.015898386016488075, 0.048249293118715286, 0.010205813683569431, -0.04330476373434067, 0.012795095331966877, 0.017350761219859123, -0.02344057708978653, -0.013711575418710709, -0.019636690616607666, -0.004969246685504913, 0.0027511415537446737, 0.035735391080379486, 0.059672001749277115, 0.03400985151529312, -0.0007524185348302126, 0.002573013538494706, 0.02225962094962597, 0.042865779250860214, 0.02607867307960987, 0.01528355572372675, -0.0002935499360319227, -0.06522515416145325, -0.04344150424003601, -0.006510243751108646, 0.02238897979259491, 0.016586603596806526, -0.014293809421360493, 0.046507079154253006, 0.02889190800487995, -0.043855197727680206, -0.013793687336146832, 0.06292068958282471, -0.021045584231615067, -0.018214449286460876, 0.02385254204273224, 0.005194846075028181, -0.030418235808610916, -0.00546529795974493, 0.03155430406332016, 0.01983826607465744, -0.013676770962774754, 0.0011831611627712846, 0.032763686031103134, -0.014534245245158672, 0.011830336414277554, -0.016057709231972694, 0.03143761679530144, 0.057597752660512924, -0.000979989767074585, -0.02546430565416813, -0.0425504706799984, 0.025526784360408783, 0.015681307762861252, 0.038023676723241806, 0.03496502712368965, -0.058869369328022, -0.012990044429898262, 0.012562211602926254, 0.047105561941862106, -0.026237964630126953, 0.030116545036435127, -0.04687840864062309, -0.036862969398498535, 0.04545474052429199, -0.041562169790267944, 0.015798376873135567, 0.02172243595123291, -0.027797482907772064, -0.0094162467867136, -0.031029975041747093, -0.05786457285284996, 0.0513530932366848, -0.033663827925920486, 0.04659663513302803, -0.035169363021850586, -0.010160217061638832, -0.007451675366610289, 0.00616613170132041, 0.01787559874355793, 0.0651252269744873, -0.0004971908056177199, -0.02330097369849682, -0.01625153049826622, 0.033306021243333817, -0.003122808178886771, -0.05107923224568367, 0.030038703233003616, 0.0045567783527076244, -0.0043300907127559185, 0.007118913810700178, -0.04544174298644066, -0.05587402731180191, 0.04931509122252464, -0.021426966413855553, 0.005486769136041403, 0.009590587578713894, 0.017375046387314796, 0.05983291193842888, 0.04811332747340202, -0.022444622591137886, 0.03159894421696663, 0.034543026238679886, -0.024453429505228996, 0.03606836497783661, -0.035171106457710266, -0.014347216114401817, -0.021449977532029152, -0.02079196460545063, -0.03219351917505264, 0.002199742244556546, -0.014636430889368057, 0.025477485731244087, 0.013836374506354332, 0.04386328533291817, -0.020481117069721222, -0.048798393458127975, 0.001748601789586246, 0.026110641658306122, -0.02491028420627117, -0.005280373618006706, 0.07181026041507721, 0.03738807514309883, 0.03509638085961342, -0.02881089225411415, 0.0014170515350997448, -0.03053530491888523, -0.027578148990869522, 0.012993871234357357, -0.0628071129322052, -0.00849323719739914, -0.034925077110528946, -0.029459640383720398, -0.005340969190001488, -0.03361613303422928, 0.05529031157493591, -0.04123575985431671, 0.06218317151069641, 0.024371832609176636, -0.057358670979738235, -0.007460367400199175, 0.0021922099404037, 0.02425232343375683, 0.0445227175951004, -0.03098115138709545, -0.005795224569737911, -0.059675198048353195, -0.016437707468867302, -0.049271780997514725, 0.01702910289168358, 0.0019764085300266743, 0.01863865926861763, -0.029321826994419098, -0.04325348511338234, 0.024293603375554085, -0.046186648309230804, -0.013897454366087914, -0.014556712470948696, 0.061954256147146225, 0.002703546779230237, -0.01233941875398159, 0.002897037658840418, 0.04902269318699837, 0.06220168620347977, -0.02154751494526863, 0.035354215651750565, 0.01354212686419487, -0.04265981912612915, 0.017909802496433258, -0.009304484352469444, 0.023184936493635178, -0.04734895005822182, 0.007115321699529886, 0.00419105589389801, -0.0029945431742817163, 0.006517488043755293, 0.0027774039190262556, -0.0034422678872942924, 0.00035323237534612417, -0.005385999567806721, -0.024042850360274315, -0.014448191039264202, -0.01313784345984459, -0.00030920698191039264, 0.0420752689242363, -0.032355740666389465, -0.0017839439678937197, -0.002819696208462119, 0.011400135233998299, 0.0007217394304461777, 0.019215775653719902, 0.010998519137501717, 0.028621461242437363, 0.08631442487239838, -0.009738336317241192, -0.013429350219666958, 0.0266051534563303, 0.002657526172697544, 0.057009901851415634, 0.011915971525013447, 0.01024134736508131, 0.023143138736486435, 0.03507419303059578, -0.01170764397829771, -0.018431272357702255, -0.04183582589030266, 0.01002438459545374, 0.01960064470767975, -0.02030237950384617, 0.03378184512257576, 0.03521563485264778, 0.05011022835969925, -0.014492171816527843, -0.04249454289674759, -0.0038188444450497627, -0.0007825595093891025, -0.03335150331258774, 0.01781615987420082, -0.009576807729899883, -0.02488006465137005, 0.02938763238489628, 0.02201772667467594, 0.036201294511556625, 0.03631588816642761, -0.018848013132810593, 0.02556818164885044, -0.002348695183172822, -0.043042413890361786, -0.04839158430695534, 0.030266040936112404, -0.026800457388162613, -0.011284563690423965, -0.005682002287358046, -0.026284771040081978, 0.05173430219292641, 0.012807033024728298, -0.002253483282402158, -0.025663480162620544, -0.026506967842578888, -0.052993834018707275, 0.021564802154898643, 0.027381423860788345, -0.028363553807139397, 0.04863177239894867, -0.019417772069573402, -0.0065058209002017975, 0.00719181215390563, -0.011616477742791176, -0.015126761049032211, -0.08545534312725067, -0.0383785180747509, -0.02222185581922531, -0.038929376751184464, 0.044186320155858994, 0.04839940741658211, -0.05661362037062645, 0.016165895387530327, -0.007940966635942459, 0.04538334906101227, -0.02579324319958687, 0.008458305150270462, -0.010806730017066002, 0.061274170875549316, 0.011606387794017792, 0.02664676122367382, 0.0034628966823220253, -0.010045263916254044, 0.10161828994750977, 0.04184413328766823, 0.0551154799759388, -0.05408196896314621, 0.00654676603153348, -0.024867283180356026, -0.01752196066081524, -0.018920741975307465, 0.008377437479794025, 0.05442708358168602, -0.008607965894043446, -0.008781230077147484, 0.03214116394519806, 0.020243819802999496, -0.009589655324816704, 0.04900457710027695, -0.05711597949266434, -0.02838173322379589, 0.029422705993056297, -0.0014160203281790018, 0.02288074977695942, -0.0357184037566185, -0.03441960737109184, 0.007665303070098162, 0.008244737982749939, -0.0007208200404420495, -0.04613322764635086, -0.011202172376215458, -0.0020175992976874113, -0.048166580498218536, -0.012629806064069271, 0.006216457579284906, -0.0019624270498752594, 0.01494708750396967, -0.010496126487851143, 0.01325073279440403, 0.00041187406168319285, -0.022441288456320763, 0.0030735977925360203, 0.03145182132720947, 0.059975408017635345, 0.03392980620265007, 0.01789005659520626, -0.011463609524071217, 0.014807281084358692, -0.016650550067424774, -0.03854459524154663, 0.053431663662195206, -0.02091825380921364, 0.023874826729297638, 0.009042592719197273, 0.0056245471350848675, -0.017291009426116943, -0.05822952091693878, -0.001972452038899064, -0.003986278083175421, 0.015837091952562332, 0.008372636511921883, 0.010416599921882153, -0.01266439538449049, 0.055108122527599335, -0.010076497681438923, 0.03990531712770462, 0.0035845341626554728, -0.06962545216083527, -0.013537688180804253, -0.020358962938189507, 0.07728064805269241, 0.03401174768805504, -0.038745805621147156, -0.02065102383494377, -0.02652372606098652, -0.037755634635686874, -0.02290439046919346, -0.025997677817940712, -0.0038054052274674177, -0.004556240048259497, -0.01250288262963295, 0.030544906854629517, -0.01634395681321621, -0.04094768688082695, 0.0019527124240994453, -0.01988670602440834, 0.008074350655078888, -0.0316036120057106, -0.04168076440691948, 0.015656035393476486, 0.03897952660918236, -0.008614834398031235, -0.028946353122591972, -0.010362579487264156, 0.02687159553170204, 0.015412157401442528, -0.04465494304895401, -0.015510550700128078, -0.024060280993580818, -0.01801099255681038, 0.02491222880780697, -0.009974622167646885, 0.05166587233543396, 0.017299631610512733, 0.022763341665267944, 0.00283808633685112, 0.03238505870103836, -0.015367500483989716, 0.02277722768485546, 0.006788232363760471, -0.05206192657351494, 0.00822589173913002, 0.0227679293602705, -0.007628799416124821, -0.006762552075088024, -0.008058758452534676, -0.014114078134298325, -0.015279047191143036, -0.0031088488176465034, -0.002595453755930066, -0.028264714404940605, 0.007449714001268148, -0.0391058512032032, -0.009850626811385155, -0.017749156802892685, 0.0014248432125896215, 0.0034021902829408646, -0.009637870825827122, -0.03654475137591362, -0.008917415514588356, -0.006926337257027626, 0.01923258602619171, -0.024446722120046616, -0.005496616940945387, 0.04559184983372688, 0.05030877888202667, 0.05729694664478302, 0.013305212371051311, -0.029848335310816765, -0.014009017497301102, 0.04654509946703911, -0.03596102446317673, -0.053034745156764984, 0.055978115648031235, -0.03371956944465637, -0.025240987539291382, 0.01933850534260273, 0.011114966124296188, 0.03409352898597717, 0.016870081424713135, -0.03499903157353401, -0.036450695246458054, 0.031897738575935364, -0.023146091029047966, 0.010961562395095825, -0.024710815399885178, 0.02908727154135704, 0.0008907734882086515, -0.035510726273059845, 0.007602562662214041, -0.005627988371998072, 0.02192685753107071, -0.013759754598140717, 0.032356154173612595, -0.02070309780538082, 0.002767387544736266, 0.05311080813407898, 0.02376023307442665, -0.004081232473254204, 0.007547334302216768, 0.012857168912887573, 0.02128475159406662, 0.05333804339170456, -0.01991826854646206, -0.017162127420306206, -0.04889170452952385, 0.0125682158395648, -0.08858334273099899, 0.008976036682724953, 0.04392267391085625, -0.01047958992421627, 0.028158117085695267, -0.06273677945137024, -0.017449257895350456, 0.012027175165712833, -0.06866501271724701, 0.039598215371370316, -0.023852266371250153, 0.016976971179246902, -0.024956610053777695, 0.016452297568321228, -0.04927052929997444, -0.0027082536835223436, -0.007700770627707243, 0.0222550630569458, 0.047839343547821045, 0.011662752367556095, -0.00011793994781328365, -0.040875907987356186, -0.010856031440198421, 0.00973988976329565, 0.005402016919106245, -0.06877204775810242, 0.024109896272420883, -0.020981259644031525, -0.044401004910469055, 0.0014997967518866062, -0.0005435175262391567, -0.009991288185119629, 0.019670860841870308, 0.04354410618543625, 0.03878793492913246, 0.046733807772397995, 0.026425572112202644, -0.009108650498092175, 0.004151269793510437, -0.00231506978161633, 0.022226950153708458, 0.013012063689529896, -0.02693340741097927, 0.03684277832508087, 0.03600922226905823, 0.006094032898545265, -0.03808441758155823, -0.0008063535788096488, -0.011333453468978405, -0.0384630523622036, 0.005587145686149597, 0.011452323757112026, 0.019298788160085678, -0.05276138335466385, -0.0052911401726305485, -0.017462827265262604, -0.018704937770962715, 0.024670010432600975, 0.021491823717951775, 0.010952737182378769, 0.01031607948243618, -0.009491252712905407, -0.031120190396904945, 0.006108533125370741, 0.011529146693646908, -0.02810773067176342, -0.003155964659526944, -0.00895852129906416, -0.00014549710613209754, 0.018857235088944435, -0.02784746140241623, -0.04691343754529953, -0.039175212383270264, 0.02587191015481949, -0.011351299472153187, 0.01237313449382782, -0.0028873763512820005, -0.009538762271404266, -0.024139879271388054, -0.09096233546733856, 0.049031708389520645, -0.009819742292165756, -0.004623818211257458, -0.016984088346362114, -0.0064461724832654, -0.0292133167386055, 0.021246731281280518, 0.06659261137247086, -0.009313691407442093, -0.0013196318177506328, 0.02037087455391884, 0.034242067486047745, 0.04675766080617905, -0.008227315731346607, 0.05527821183204651, -0.050805989652872086, 0.0017927400767803192, -0.033947307616472244, 0.011967211961746216, 0.04518133029341698, -0.009838121943175793, -0.021232586354017258, -0.002905501052737236, 0.0149534922093153, -0.0001551738241687417, -0.03169546648859978, 0.002623186679556966, -0.011486119590699673, 0.000598203158006072, 0.028057387098670006, -0.025152303278446198, 0.0003437359700910747, 0.0026747295632958412, 0.005312868859618902, -0.05896194651722908, 0.03239450976252556, -0.03786085173487663, -0.028058836236596107, -0.019675346091389656, 0.0020786740351468325, -0.006700790487229824, -0.05116363614797592, 0.0018578664166852832, 0.05649409070611, -0.017263639718294144, -0.022899998351931572, 0.004327626898884773, 0.01747877150774002, 0.026128364726901054, 0.0013005597284063697, 0.03145232051610947, -0.019969718530774117, 0.015096883289515972, -0.024042313918471336, 0.04479711130261421, 0.030654069036245346, -0.026515386998653412, 0.02968130074441433, 0.03003176674246788, -0.007662699557840824, 0.0553496778011322, 0.0027208446990698576, 0.0048976982943713665, 0.009071731008589268, -0.005270594730973244, 0.023249849677085876, -0.015400989912450314, -0.010393545962870121, 0.0033127344213426113, 0.0016079756896942854, 0.06973852217197418, -0.026829905807971954, 0.006363461259752512, -0.004662198014557362, -0.029255002737045288, -0.023349696770310402, -0.024541135877370834, -0.027183707803487778, 0.03325619176030159, 0.0011890168534591794, -0.018451813608407974, 0.02738058567047119, 0.008431883528828621, 0.008927817456424236, -0.009177887812256813, 0.05993182584643364, 0.03334559500217438, -0.002948722569271922, -0.004463561810553074, 0.02124997042119503, -0.03891652822494507, -0.02455897629261017, 0.062284793704748154, 0.05237958952784538, 0.038019098341464996, -0.029710005968809128, -0.057125307619571686, 0.043069664388895035, 0.025561509653925896, -0.03541164845228195, -0.03289911895990372, -0.015025013126432896, 0.0022397865541279316, -0.01576683670282364, -0.011961370706558228 ]
<p>I have bivariate data from which I have generated thousands of bootstrapped estimates within each of two conditions (pink &amp; blue):</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/EnBqf.png" alt="bivariate data"></p> <p>I'd like to determine whether these conditions' bivariate distributions have different central tendencies. </p> <p>If I were dealing with univariate data, I'd compute, within each point, the .025 and .975 quantiles of the bootstrapped estimates for that point to construct a 95% confidence interval then compare the intervals of the conditions. Indeed, that's what the lines represent in the above graphic. However, I feel that comparing the conditions on each dimension separately ignores the fundamental bivariate nature of the data, yet I don't know what the appropriate procedure is for bivariate data.</p> <p>Note that any suggested solution should rely on just the bootstrapped estimates and not the raw data. This is because the estimates in this particular case actually come from rather complicated models that attempt to take into account and remove differences between the conditions that are present in the raw data.</p>
36,978
[ -0.01459397654980421, 0.014077979139983654, 0.01428170409053564, 0.049438588321208954, 0.0353841707110405, -0.01304693054407835, 0.026578610762953758, -0.006035239435732365, 0.04813847690820694, -0.04083285108208656, 0.043450966477394104, 0.03259097784757614, 0.0414499007165432, 0.04941629245877266, -0.002255711006000638, -0.017550144344568253, -0.009729813784360886, -0.0037075206637382507, 0.0008965378510765731, -0.010333487764000893, -0.007520886138081551, 0.018320251256227493, 0.0007147234282456338, -0.00048396174679510295, 0.007173189893364906, 0.05642389506101608, 0.03444966673851013, -0.02296105958521366, 0.00554305873811245, 0.050076380372047424, -0.04491302743554115, -0.05235673859715462, 0.013904387131333351, 0.06057778745889664, -0.027939068153500557, -0.00106708868406713, -0.02637304738163948, -0.015398731455206871, -0.04109270125627518, 0.01516138855367899, -0.051034245640039444, 0.008020957931876183, -0.015873387455940247, 0.020162707194685936, 0.02583230845630169, 0.007848319597542286, 0.019703328609466553, -0.0026599776465445757, 0.025419285520911217, -0.03866364061832428, 0.07917236536741257, 0.0258974339812994, 0.05060243234038353, 0.034714389592409134, -0.018478965386748314, -0.019859950989484787, 0.006489168852567673, 0.05561361461877823, 0.036288123577833176, -0.07299623638391495, -0.004565908573567867, -0.019475573673844337, 0.018875809386372566, -0.029008585959672928, -0.04171975702047348, 0.03771334886550903, 0.024221980944275856, -0.03798351436853409, -0.008775782771408558, -0.015281148254871368, -0.004795948043465614, 0.011266050860285759, 0.0599619522690773, -0.014124118722975254, -0.028183456510305405, -0.010920446366071701, 0.017714200541377068, 0.00534098083153367, 0.07816731184720993, -0.011698920279741287, -0.014870152808725834, 0.012460711412131786, -0.02204114757478237, 0.046606048941612244, 0.028695490211248398, -0.001135195721872151, 0.0704270675778389, -0.05560973286628723, -0.0176742784678936, 0.012130220420658588, -0.05636663734912872, -0.01665124110877514, 0.06315677613019943, 0.00561519293114543, -0.05213731527328491, 0.01983002759516239, 0.017764540389180183, -0.0018753416370600462, -0.04444769397377968, -0.006841280963271856, -0.020026883110404015, -0.02357630617916584, 0.02363745868206024, 0.048863474279642105, 0.049820736050605774, 0.015812208876013756, -0.029909364879131317, 0.003536755219101906, -0.017680661752820015, -0.03673221915960312, -0.03477722406387329, 0.00861343089491129, 0.004641680512577295, -0.0026820970233529806, 0.027581535279750824, 0.008697571232914925, -0.01460723951458931, -0.02681455947458744, 0.04098323732614517, 0.009635458700358868, 0.03917589411139488, -0.0033010609913617373, -0.00473471824079752, -0.02443988248705864, -0.052800584584474564, 0.007839982397854328, 0.028201773762702942, 0.0014243689365684986, -0.05623910203576088, 0.06063229963183403, 0.00043339337571524084, -0.018873797729611397, -0.016103867441415787, -0.002182777039706707, 0.03200746327638626, 0.0372992604970932, -0.07707082480192184, -0.08367238938808441, 0.015998946502804756, -0.00034263284760527313, 0.008271953091025352, -0.019942020997405052, -0.0012825578451156616, 0.060097187757492065, 0.05252554640173912, -0.026291850954294205, 0.059932343661785126, -0.01302594318985939, 0.002527979901060462, 0.04215884581208229, -0.019360452890396118, 0.013289283029735088, -0.049615681171417236, -0.004038397688418627, -0.016536597162485123, -0.08937951922416687, 0.0013945315731689334, 0.000016853580746101215, -0.021560553461313248, -0.006824738346040249, 0.0376058891415596, -0.007556871045380831, -0.03357671946287155, -0.027797766029834747, 0.011414389126002789, -0.012295139953494072, 0.037105757743120193, -0.05000891909003258, 0.020567243918776512, 0.018559839576482773, -0.01194735523313284, 0.0017329048132523894, 0.00905612576752901, 0.03325424715876579, 0.072452612221241, -0.0001815709110815078, 0.027633868157863617, -0.013390043750405312, 0.015041533857584, 0.014615326188504696, -0.06496287137269974, -0.018407516181468964, -0.0663520023226738, -0.011905454099178314, 0.0013964115642011166, 0.059569768607616425, -0.01139572449028492, -0.0669904425740242, 0.06698957830667496, -0.030343767255544662, -0.006910332944244146, -0.05590515956282616, -0.02501397207379341, 0.03256304934620857, -0.032917570322752, 0.04549555853009224, 0.006487070117145777, 0.0003822256694547832, -0.02052590250968933, -0.01637216843664646, -0.015668002888560295, 0.00038335894350893795, 0.05651722475886345, -0.05713270604610443, 0.03821318596601486, -0.004459562711417675, 0.04725725203752518, -0.015639644116163254, 0.04629672318696976, -0.013220017775893211, -0.04571179300546646, 0.033198967576026917, -0.049914587289094925, 0.017193298786878586, 0.002352309413254261, -0.010791443288326263, 0.014034015126526356, -0.01616652123630047, -0.0190825704485178, 0.021871130913496017, -0.03980443254113197, 0.04363207519054413, 0.055902764201164246, -0.0104523291811347, -0.010800362564623356, 0.019409097731113434, 0.025177009403705597, 0.02761785127222538, -0.01939760521054268, -0.011091167107224464, -0.017755592241883278, -0.004353814758360386, 0.04639030992984772, -0.005475210025906563, -0.010919737629592419, 0.02716921828687191, 0.024365298449993134, 0.013991056010127068, 0.001646371092647314, 0.04554957151412964, 0.01699775457382202, -0.018783586099743843, 0.0010715378448367119, 0.02306693233549595, 0.06914599984884262, -0.019455133005976677, 0.019024524837732315, 0.003778514452278614, 0.06903436779975891, -0.01781727932393551, 0.016786623746156693, 0.03270899876952171, 0.009760870598256588, -0.010416741482913494, -0.007414492778480053, -0.01538446918129921, 0.07107717543840408, -0.004095517564564943, 0.016767757013440132, 0.03468158468604088, -0.020924696698784828, -0.0037544730585068464, 0.03414127603173256, 0.007387761492282152, 0.059070080518722534, 0.050578393042087555, -0.05075262114405632, 0.015085842460393906, 0.018564891070127487, 0.0009183018701151013, 0.01974826492369175, -0.010678933933377266, -0.03857401758432388, -0.012663460336625576, 0.005745073314756155, 0.026872199028730392, 0.024030646309256554, 0.022663330659270287, -0.006324200890958309, -0.00732405437156558, 0.003321734955534339, 0.011826260015368462, 0.018950900062918663, -0.0000533061902387999, -0.012110334821045399, 0.014601496048271656, -0.031867265701293945, 0.010851962491869926, -0.01791135035455227, 0.015619967132806778, -0.014764565043151379, 0.003392616054043174, 0.0003191579016856849, -0.003037062706425786, 0.0038475929759442806, -0.002155085327103734, 0.027591265738010406, -0.03503670543432236, -0.016810884699225426, 0.05448967590928078, 0.005109907127916813, -0.04106606915593147, 0.020586583763360977, 0.013120436109602451, -0.04576568305492401, -0.015443718060851097, 0.024169759824872017, 0.015251202508807182, 0.03324965387582779, 0.060456641018390656, 0.015057952143251896, 0.014722749590873718, -0.006445135921239853, -0.06267433613538742, -0.0477982759475708, -0.0006114085554145277, -0.0006775639485567808, 0.039653610438108444, -0.01536639779806137, -0.014140077866613865, 0.04660605639219284, 0.05284595862030983, -0.01232188381254673, -0.051851022988557816, -0.03805122897028923, -0.0615728497505188, 0.026180919259786606, -0.022686246782541275, -0.015089279040694237, -0.025124821811914444, 0.014462198130786419, 0.01782347820699215, 0.009628061205148697, 0.03630051389336586, 0.021012160927057266, -0.005549762863665819, 0.019721494987607002, -0.0024766530841588974, 0.016816195100545883, 0.009133225306868553, 0.018687639385461807, 0.0007177318329922855, -0.0050588189624249935, 0.007735081948339939, 0.02097702957689762, 0.024488205090165138, -0.06232835724949837, 0.023920372128486633, -0.020637789741158485, 0.018299007788300514, -0.043237555772066116, 0.007441367954015732, 0.008340490981936455, -0.030258186161518097, -0.0037034451961517334, 0.03269490227103233, 0.02803448960185051, -0.039456915110349655, 0.026989873498678207, 0.044735658913850784, 0.04184294492006302, 0.008084459230303764, 0.02321697771549225, -0.021612368524074554, -0.005036924034357071, 0.045686833560466766, -0.06717594712972641, 0.004547635558992624, 0.033418383449316025, 0.036743178963661194, 0.044574521481990814, -0.005403023678809404, -0.05862121656537056, 0.01177204679697752, -0.06816708296537399, 0.02065785601735115, -0.017822036519646645, 0.046293165534734726, 0.002167360158637166, 0.04825805872678757, 0.00687797088176012, -0.008671635761857033, -0.0200947392731905, -0.030226517468690872, -0.06351742893457413, 0.031756091862916946, -0.015333818271756172, 0.022874172776937485, 0.018502252176404, -0.04300712049007416, 0.0012545562349259853, -0.03804368898272514, 0.0017139700939878821, -0.012451901100575924, 0.026161175221204758, -0.01081120129674673, 0.01928582787513733, -0.06623020768165588, -0.022784026339650154, -0.010408798232674599, -0.03060881793498993, -0.003703013062477112, -0.013818556442856789, 0.04537258669734001, -0.017889603972434998, -0.014686550945043564, 0.01735159009695053, -0.019083794206380844, 0.027547594159841537, 0.005850175861269236, 0.051098477095365524, -0.01861763373017311, 0.021399183198809624, 0.005632695741951466, 0.0008628148352727294, 0.024890227243304253, 0.06365089118480682, -0.01040119118988514, -0.05608843266963959, -0.009526725858449936, -0.03269355744123459, -0.020397847518324852, 0.0007046246901154518, 0.014380419626832008, 0.005709586199373007, -0.021529197692871094, 0.06730850040912628, 0.03383577615022659, -0.059422366321086884, 0.02215656451880932, 0.058500926941633224, 0.024167239665985107, -0.001738280989229679, -0.03630910441279411, -0.01406608335673809, -0.015358414500951767, -0.028804970905184746, 0.03218669816851616, 0.02076093666255474, -0.014638151973485947, -0.006728051230311394, 0.044245943427085876, -0.0077547975815832615, -0.03722621873021126, 0.008459307253360748, 0.018989291042089462, 0.05807724595069885, 0.0004575696075335145, -0.01500335056334734, 0.02068985439836979, -0.011427517049014568, 0.011836997233331203, 0.03523953631520271, 0.005735875107347965, -0.10961584746837616, 0.023657605051994324, 0.06501549482345581, 0.02365908771753311, 0.008716113865375519, -0.037362925708293915, -0.03930427506566048, -0.0030676417518407106, 0.006348700728267431, -0.011187419295310974, 0.038396697491407394, 0.04958045110106468, 0.04494646564126015, 0.011288304813206196, 0.004122643265873194, -0.02006099745631218, 0.002123863436281681, -0.034390270709991455, 0.04302698001265526, -0.006732574664056301, -0.04784725606441498, -0.04666339233517647, 0.02768114022910595, 0.026643136516213417, 0.06035633757710457, 0.013945733197033405, -0.010056672617793083, -0.025520605966448784, -0.006834970787167549, -0.009716925211250782, -0.06177261844277382, 0.0270604956895113, 0.012770411558449268, 0.026199793443083763, 0.09163428097963333, 0.0024265360552817583, -0.030426548793911934, 0.055318355560302734, -0.002803803887218237, 0.002775423461571336, 0.02974674291908741, 0.025828899815678596, 0.0442068874835968, 0.02127319574356079, 0.033158279955387115, 0.03771549463272095, -0.0012104070046916604, -0.029045652598142624, -0.03903322294354439, -0.026336276903748512, -0.013989768922328949, 0.004995965864509344, -0.01619562692940235, -0.041166726499795914, -0.0004462267679627985, -0.01274857111275196, 0.009927784092724323, -0.00877449382096529, 0.022415194660425186, 0.017036879435181618, -0.013616949319839478, -0.01278573740273714, -0.010567726567387581, -0.005335901398211718, -0.006911987904459238, -0.021737944334745407, 0.025700807571411133, -0.028873439878225327, -0.009268774650990963, 0.005448729265481234, -0.02716200053691864, -0.021793046966195107, -0.02405834197998047, -0.052079543471336365, 0.01372245792299509, -0.06203725188970566, -0.02891247719526291, -0.025424305349588394, -0.01234429981559515, 0.013650501146912575, -0.012715990655124187, 0.012893394567072392, -0.0035229043569415808, -0.03335898742079735, 0.013677360489964485, 0.022462110966444016, 0.029616842046380043, 0.07314389199018478, -0.02964189648628235, 0.030880147591233253, -0.00784339290112257, -0.007005671504884958, -0.09913724660873413, -0.027795972302556038, 0.027544301003217697, 0.043250199407339096, -0.03955938667058945, -0.03494320809841156, -0.01740775629878044, -0.037384264171123505, -0.011072552762925625, -0.025701578706502914, 0.04335528984665871, 0.007541742641478777, -0.02347983792424202, -0.006005384959280491, 0.01835738867521286, 0.055080484598875046, -0.05855998769402504, 0.03978683054447174, 0.004587539006024599, -0.01604941301047802, 0.015449068509042263, 0.03969484567642212, 0.023437894880771637, -0.017741212621331215, 0.006076933816075325, -0.031880516558885574, 0.0019227853044867516, 0.00933102797716856, -0.048292167484760284, 0.0009007661719806492, 0.013829519972205162, -0.034603144973516464, -0.019804174080491066, -0.04559389129281044, -0.03308248892426491, -0.014374623075127602, -0.011661920696496964, -0.03327303007245064, -0.015257257036864758, 0.03856835141777992, -0.019194450229406357, 0.0210683885961771, -0.007007125299423933, -0.052824005484580994, -0.013407141901552677, 0.07994504272937775, 0.009040876291692257, 0.005047747399657965, -0.005984686780720949, -0.00026492428150959313, 0.03639272227883339, -0.016470033675432205, -0.033093322068452835, 0.03625397011637688, 0.0012517585419118404, -0.02894180826842785, -0.004265548195689917, -0.03705812618136406, 0.033801738172769547, 0.04223402217030525, -0.007981807924807072, 0.054759006947278976, 0.07373952865600586, -0.00886817742139101, 0.004752109292894602, -0.011231430806219578, 0.016967030242085457, -0.01782657392323017, 0.02126648649573326, 0.047937314957380295, 0.024399258196353912, -0.03037125989794731, 0.025780869647860527, 0.0231485515832901, -0.012303563766181469, 0.06746752560138702, 0.0013184595154598355, 0.027372155338525772, 0.038866281509399414, -0.01601548306643963, -0.013146101497113705, 0.03899348899722099, -0.04466787725687027, -0.01845625415444374, -0.032142315059900284, -0.02303813025355339, 0.013682541437447071, 0.04137546941637993, -0.01765334978699684, -0.030770381912589073, -0.043926943093538284, -0.035003963857889175, -0.006492616143077612, -0.011617371812462807, 0.010545501485466957, 0.009320206940174103, 0.025611637160182, 0.03714054077863693, 0.009220408275723457, -0.030412880703806877, -0.03294786065816879, -0.03652380034327507, -0.007518824189901352, -0.0020363738294690847, -0.053091879934072495, 0.047820042818784714, 0.003313350724056363, -0.016883280128240585, 0.05117269232869148, -0.04427504166960716, -0.007119819521903992, -0.004374896641820669, 0.006271198391914368, 0.013867833651602268, 0.04909733310341835, 0.023247307166457176, -0.0128098139539361, -0.007714331615716219, 0.020848916843533516, 0.1080256924033165, 0.08342796564102173, 0.033817630261182785, -0.08359445631504059, 0.03744468465447426, 0.0078322384506464, -0.016364868730306625, -0.01830844022333622, -0.013542982749640942, 0.016332358121871948, -0.018706075847148895, 0.0615396685898304, 0.0694732740521431, -0.004425675142556429, -0.03347749635577202, 0.04386226087808609, -0.02754272148013115, 0.004422966856509447, 0.0016379097942262888, 0.007031128276139498, -0.015452014282345772, -0.007758208084851503, -0.06548094004392624, 0.014794996939599514, -0.029220087453722954, 0.009395080618560314, -0.014224324375391006, -0.037819601595401764, -0.000017340416889055632, -0.007413918152451515, -0.009118295274674892, 0.00846921931952238, 0.032789237797260284, 0.00785464234650135, -0.04038937762379646, 0.021272670477628708, 0.024250736460089684, -0.029651425778865814, 0.03146353363990784, 0.005880286451429129, 0.00380988628603518, -0.006368755362927914, -0.02537623420357704, 0.02824835479259491, -0.00029623694717884064, -0.026727527379989624, -0.05413402244448662, 0.030120544135570526, -0.017118046060204506, -0.015715422108769417, -0.023990511894226074, -0.00822384562343359, 0.01537014078348875, -0.02294226549565792, -0.008902913890779018, -0.018470628187060356, 0.004948016721755266, 0.01080899965018034, 0.0007890406996011734, -0.01771383173763752, 0.003950231242924929, 0.019863951951265335, 0.027790840715169907, -0.009615696035325527, -0.03820764273405075, -0.023426443338394165, -0.0028059082105755806, 0.08870063722133636, -0.008344895206391811, -0.0015124693745747209, -0.021985650062561035, -0.024437636137008667, -0.01583121344447136, -0.018737036734819412, 0.03336356580257416, -0.002055578166618943, 0.03261931240558624, 0.0048836409114301205, -0.018551290035247803, -0.029681812971830368, -0.03964750096201897, -0.028148889541625977, -0.02644343487918377, 0.0024240717757493258, -0.04869498685002327, -0.022721150889992714, 0.028714200481772423, 0.03550197184085846, 0.02521459572017193, 0.023166626691818237, -0.005378264002501965, 0.0443582683801651, 0.03296133503317833, -0.08021403849124908, -0.013582596555352211, -0.044097088277339935, -0.018663527444005013, -0.03560781851410866, -0.042379770427942276, 0.02985180914402008, -0.02671496756374836, 0.025362102314829826, 0.03852498158812523, 0.05459444224834442, 0.0024636900052428246, 0.029013747349381447, 0.015471301972866058, -0.06664164364337921, -0.02745167352259159, 0.04007389396429062, 0.004757831804454327, -0.03760562837123871, -0.023625969886779785, -0.05210065841674805, -0.05466586723923683, 0.017229372635483742, -0.027207711711525917, 0.004840094596147537, -0.016196904703974724, 0.017216986045241356, -0.03982077166438103, -0.03361263871192932, -0.021131442859768867, -0.054675184190273285, 0.0026108736637979746, 0.025263017043471336, 0.0016658591339364648, 0.02283894270658493, -0.025373075157403946, -0.01452898234128952, 0.034792210906744, 0.04429197311401367, 0.0020688301883637905, 0.01741054654121399, -0.004493349231779575, 0.013155777007341385, 0.015941908583045006, 0.03267895057797432, -0.021847298368811607, 0.016561776399612427, 0.030657917261123657, 0.0004245829186402261, -0.03742088004946709, 0.017132269218564034, -0.013025087304413319, 0.02422577701508999, 0.022411899641156197, -0.021206771954894066, -0.010431434027850628, 0.020499665290117264, -0.0012826145393773913, -0.015591828152537346, -0.00505634443834424, 0.00928272120654583, -0.012158962897956371, 0.004973521456122398, -0.009994011372327805, -0.006022140849381685, -0.003968058153986931, 0.03491849824786186, 0.05446401610970497, 0.03100680373609066, -0.006346503272652626, 0.00814610905945301, 0.00045283755753189325, 0.0253581739962101, 0.020243236795067787, -0.023122400045394897, 0.03264707699418068, 0.035125624388456345, -0.07434354722499847, 0.0018274092581123114, -0.010874833911657333, 0.04113166406750679, -0.08556289970874786, -0.025240492075681686, 0.016237063333392143, 0.014895460568368435, 0.019995974376797676, -0.0507403165102005, 0.018976757302880287, 0.01181238517165184, -0.021637894213199615, 0.022879527881741524, -0.014663673005998135, 0.04437517747282982, -0.0332605205476284, -0.011448066681623459, -0.029619906097650528, 0.04954877123236656, 0.022814366966485977, 0.019736478105187416, 0.02183295413851738, 0.04256685823202133, -0.041288234293460846, -0.023741574957966805, -0.010710015892982483, 0.00435162428766489, 0.034947652369737625, -0.08212333172559738, 0.03244570642709732, -0.030795086175203323, -0.040953245013952255, 0.04338444396853447, -0.012190760113298893, 0.006351364776492119, -0.0012458458077162504, 0.03338150307536125, 0.02917989157140255, 0.06445138156414032, 0.02226589433848858, 0.00005965663513052277, -0.0029786303639411926, 0.013689722865819931, 0.028103893622756004, 0.012304016388952732, -0.05283140391111374, 0.02279733493924141, 0.04540834203362465, -0.011285017244517803, -0.013781534507870674, 0.02289472334086895, -0.008868908509612083, -0.01885191909968853, -0.01830163411796093, 0.02111859992146492, 0.0013424180215224624, 0.0017128330655395985, 0.02535090036690235, -0.09143650531768799, 0.030815940350294113, 0.003776489058509469, 0.010449755005538464, -0.023220406845211983, 0.006627986673265696, 0.008937202394008636, -0.06899062544107437, 0.01278137881308794, -0.000980586395598948, -0.006632223725318909, -0.055697739124298096, -0.0069513460621237755, -0.020994683727622032, 0.016482481732964516, -0.008076836355030537, -0.00352122588083148, -0.034379348158836365, 0.031198758631944656, -0.0175931453704834, -0.00862160325050354, -0.008132352493703365, -0.006555754225701094, 0.0027961530722677708, -0.10386878997087479, 0.05387788638472557, 0.022857781499624252, -0.031662505120038986, -0.017648058012127876, 0.009441081434488297, -0.040050357580184937, -0.012882822193205357, 0.042068175971508026, 0.02619343064725399, -0.024985522031784058, 0.009857868775725365, 0.03796226531267166, -0.013543505221605301, -0.04663380607962608, 0.02330722287297249, -0.014985733665525913, -0.00006310539902187884, -0.028537878766655922, -0.02871568687260151, 0.014857380650937557, 0.03748892620205879, 0.023361044004559517, 0.0021055685356259346, 0.020332951098680496, 0.05498846620321274, 0.007655894383788109, 0.024278804659843445, -0.019743256270885468, -0.006565467454493046, 0.066609226167202, 0.013877229765057564, -0.029592040926218033, 0.011807674542069435, -0.02067330852150917, -0.043993618339300156, 0.056593503803014755, 0.002151538385078311, -0.04897983372211456, -0.007184491492807865, 0.010893036611378193, 0.004674145486205816, -0.06979630887508392, -0.006973277777433395, 0.008057931438088417, -0.0222867950797081, 0.017068883404135704, 0.008381905034184456, 0.032846495509147644, 0.03790701925754547, -0.012362436391413212, 0.002897887723520398, 0.003824461717158556, -0.020554235205054283, 0.017981523647904396, -0.009721629321575165, 0.05061735585331917, 0.021613117307424545, 0.012551766820251942, 0.023396046832203865, -0.06100291758775711, 0.03354554623365402, -0.055193111300468445, 0.025663776323199272, 0.00223902752622962, -0.035658348351716995, 0.055913157761096954, -0.02156451717019081, 0.03604894503951073, -0.01945236325263977, -0.0237553883343935, 0.05007065460085869, -0.019507993012666702, -0.012062720954418182, -0.017542455345392227, -0.001202216139063239, -0.016196291893720627, 0.027273589745163918, 0.022307951003313065, -0.004616497550159693, 0.010793725959956646, 0.008882085792720318, -0.017974983900785446, -0.021224524825811386, 0.021522000432014465, 0.01105088647454977, 0.015452404506504536, -0.017170436680316925, -0.0065043107606470585, 0.030747098848223686, -0.0419282466173172, -0.04199375584721565, -0.014819187112152576, -0.00039503187872469425, 0.012716780416667461, 0.016298117116093636, 0.004529972560703754, -0.056675076484680176, -0.025223419070243835, 0.031843509525060654, -0.06099016219377518, -0.03940751031041145, -0.02704237587749958, 0.018933068960905075, 0.0025027894880622625, -0.0197876188904047 ]
<p>If one wanted to use Kernel Regression in a Bayesian Framework, any ideas on how one would go about it? </p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kernel_regression" rel="nofollow">Kernel Regression</a></p>
74,228
[ -0.008117598481476307, -0.01950518786907196, 0.020564762875437737, -0.01211536955088377, 0.033125340938568115, -0.0037202928215265274, 0.011198718100786209, -0.042966172099113464, 0.04534197598695755, -0.011748661287128925, 0.01589423231780529, 0.023904958739876747, 0.06354118883609772, 0.002578954678028822, 0.001449809642508626, 0.020024994388222694, -0.017572320997714996, -0.00398348830640316, -0.014461147598922253, -0.028865428641438484, 0.015817614272236824, 0.02163141965866089, -0.001855120761319995, 0.0015017827972769737, -0.03241902217268944, 0.04573153331875801, 0.031474508345127106, -0.031121861189603806, 0.03253435716032982, 0.04871645197272301, -0.01331737544387579, -0.01563655026257038, 0.029775867238640785, 0.07666721194982529, -0.0035310396924614906, -0.017534164711833, -0.042166486382484436, -0.03331131115555763, -0.010999531485140324, 0.044044651091098785, -0.021549981087446213, -0.02340555563569069, 0.0031015402637422085, 0.026644408702850342, -0.011173889972269535, -0.01422816514968872, 0.0059569296427071095, -0.03778427094221115, 0.013931222259998322, -0.05427516624331474, 0.056910622864961624, -0.030685409903526306, 0.005206966307014227, 0.07609526813030243, -0.018439367413520813, -0.003949198871850967, 0.054669708013534546, 0.07815107703208923, -0.017105888575315475, -0.07017399370670319, -0.023266052827239037, -0.03620557114481926, -0.0008062925189733505, -0.037483956664800644, -0.028404859825968742, 0.044153425842523575, 0.003158171894028783, -0.021235361695289612, 0.009832844138145447, -0.025667795911431313, 0.011591342277824879, -0.0027955102268606424, 0.021281037479639053, -0.013315657153725624, 0.026824967935681343, -0.020920967683196068, -0.0012128200614824891, 0.05651957169175148, 0.03766557574272156, 0.030690765008330345, 0.0038793962448835373, -0.01900920830667019, 0.03673529997467995, 0.0413336381316185, 0.0016303176525980234, -0.0050115520134568214, 0.06077929958701134, -0.026068607345223427, 0.024934537708759308, 0.027814192697405815, -0.054000869393348694, 0.019636068493127823, 0.04406651481986046, -0.04300784319639206, -0.06305447965860367, 0.04713509604334831, -0.012837189249694347, 0.05163374915719032, -0.0008249052334576845, -0.0262333732098341, 0.021862700581550598, 0.0014249059604480863, -0.015221823938190937, 0.04940364137291908, -0.04131421819329262, -0.03137889876961708, -0.014860852621495724, 0.021262619644403458, -0.018056875094771385, -0.03280879184603691, -0.06301485002040863, 0.029776740819215775, 0.009372950531542301, 0.009390190243721008, 0.03729737922549248, -0.030742930248379707, -0.01218657847493887, -0.05994780734181404, 0.013611637987196445, 0.05729818344116211, 0.019758043810725212, -0.04615136981010437, 0.02028704807162285, -0.02215537615120411, -0.04428282380104065, 0.040768761187791824, 0.01906874030828476, -0.028864556923508644, -0.02572145313024521, 0.03587121516466141, -0.020808318629860878, -0.03569600731134415, 0.0542248897254467, -0.008096986450254917, 0.0011174665996804833, -0.0014177458360791206, -0.07335468381643295, -0.04077189788222313, 0.0389748252928257, -0.017924359068274498, 0.01634100265800953, -0.05275557562708855, 0.022774120792746544, 0.029629230499267578, 0.05767850577831268, -0.0013258244143798947, 0.014101782813668251, 0.024541031569242477, 0.035942308604717255, -0.031024474650621414, -0.040619514882564545, -0.026870448142290115, -0.009371665306389332, 0.021531231701374054, -0.02618689276278019, -0.0912618637084961, 0.017149053514003754, 0.009766804054379463, -0.002899609738960862, 0.020114025101065636, 0.05091569945216179, -0.01892140693962574, -0.013269290328025818, -0.022131100296974182, 0.0184103362262249, -0.042645152658224106, 0.0863197073340416, 0.026914497837424278, 0.02832043543457985, 0.017468620091676712, -0.01881103590130806, 0.010687224566936493, 0.0256795734167099, 0.04113736003637314, 0.05148841813206673, -0.03464966639876366, -0.013153781183063984, -0.010452449321746826, 0.03055221401154995, -0.005820554215461016, -0.053571268916130066, -0.008915829472243786, -0.015000328421592712, -0.011488785035908222, 0.025918008759617805, 0.03752756491303444, 0.0024690742138773203, -0.022169100120663643, 0.029511207714676857, -0.05981394276022911, -0.04386049881577492, -0.058924321085214615, -0.0032706281635910273, -0.020664187148213387, 0.001164969289675355, 0.02787681296467781, 0.01480203028768301, 0.00866569671779871, -0.034371715039014816, -0.04417363554239273, -0.03017602674663067, -0.015078797936439514, 0.003438954707235098, -0.04118889570236206, 0.004581899382174015, 0.03963330760598183, 0.049148522317409515, -0.02477055974304676, 0.02933640033006668, -0.037144359201192856, -0.04361908510327339, -0.021275324746966362, -0.027581481263041496, -0.013171638362109661, -0.0499093122780323, -0.006393856834620237, 0.03297584131360054, -0.0011058896780014038, -0.016715899109840393, -0.0014457677025347948, -0.07835104316473007, 0.06882781535387039, 0.056262027472257614, 0.01837071217596531, 0.015019237995147705, 0.0038512470200657845, -0.010163790546357632, 0.011234018951654434, 0.0029414098244160414, -0.005602031014859676, -0.051154688000679016, 0.0003162358480039984, 0.03803139552474022, 0.006224724464118481, -0.03463209420442581, 0.027723005041480064, 0.04352376610040665, 0.04276541247963905, 0.010669835843145847, 0.013545287773013115, -0.02664896473288536, -0.00448837224394083, 0.02040885016322136, 0.006902117282152176, -0.013730691745877266, 0.001412693178281188, 0.022744452580809593, 0.002774860244244337, 0.03293485939502716, -0.012877988629043102, -0.019116351380944252, 0.0325063094496727, -0.02674630470573902, 0.01918703317642212, -0.01322635542601347, -0.02503354847431183, 0.03379354998469353, -0.019881663843989372, -0.011954057030379772, 0.015260664746165276, 0.01516490988433361, 0.025463923811912537, -0.0012045468902215362, -0.008619560860097408, 0.019160401076078415, 0.05460314452648163, -0.0591324158012867, 0.018094416707754135, 0.022932033985853195, -0.0500570647418499, 0.025448698550462723, -0.01243494264781475, -0.021124323830008507, -0.06355707347393036, 0.021623458713293076, 0.03960282355546951, -0.0051766070537269115, 0.015352621674537659, 0.010273088701069355, -0.04738481715321541, 0.01559444610029459, -0.027194175869226456, 0.022388331592082977, -0.005758555140346289, -0.07484624534845352, 0.011691941879689693, 0.0035979982931166887, -0.0039264303632080555, 0.04316120594739914, -0.0171680711209774, 0.006646803114563227, -0.007779737468808889, -0.02653408609330654, -0.053977400064468384, -0.02401890978217125, -0.02957945689558983, 0.001563752768561244, -0.03011184185743332, -0.027352282777428627, 0.01822621375322342, 0.010826781392097473, -0.024279512465000153, 0.021986382082104683, -0.03957236930727959, -0.05364484712481499, -0.03941773250699043, 0.00056649703765288, -0.0028463792987167835, -0.0029032339807599783, 0.034664086997509, 0.01461718138307333, -0.051632095128297806, 0.022700997069478035, -0.06230700761079788, -0.043926604092121124, 0.07466324418783188, -0.0039476328529417515, 0.02448044903576374, 0.007330816704779863, -0.004383317660540342, 0.059880129992961884, 0.014987424947321415, -0.0269439909607172, -0.02430296689271927, -0.002596450736746192, -0.038314852863550186, -0.02997742034494877, 0.0006502707256004214, -0.000723663077224046, 0.01576201803982258, 0.018153944984078407, -0.013995862565934658, 0.0008440787787549198, 0.034775495529174805, 0.0033991478849202394, -0.006818586494773626, 0.030058203265070915, -0.0270188357681036, -0.02306145615875721, 0.015237178653478622, 0.008050244301557541, -0.027974629774689674, -0.003560655517503619, -0.009307880885899067, -0.018437964841723442, -0.001438798732124269, -0.048397112637758255, 0.0058534773997962475, 0.004677855409681797, -0.010596799664199352, -0.03278100863099098, 0.008116657845675945, 0.008680259808897972, -0.03678489476442337, 0.009387712925672531, 0.029797112569212914, 0.03859918564558029, -0.010382846929132938, 0.033321794122457504, 0.04239077866077423, 0.02807494066655636, -0.014494715258479118, -0.009301576763391495, -0.006117449142038822, -0.026753418147563934, 0.012166115455329418, 0.0029644095338881016, 0.0034028140362352133, 0.04476761072874069, 0.032662633806467056, 0.027384966611862183, -0.023065004497766495, -0.048579733818769455, 0.014460142701864243, -0.06209323927760124, -0.03147038072347641, -0.01880241185426712, 0.055975038558244705, -0.01092162448912859, 0.016902951523661613, 0.014022424817085266, -0.021346498280763626, 0.018579252064228058, 0.006504660006612539, -0.07124236971139908, -0.0015031718648970127, -0.03254343196749687, 0.0009957733564078808, 0.0006241747760213912, -0.03567134588956833, 0.04992593452334404, -0.028233490884304047, 0.023097321391105652, -0.02743520401418209, 0.016504332423210144, -0.03813454881310463, -0.00458570709452033, -0.024225523695349693, -0.02717880718410015, 0.010112818330526352, -0.03709820657968521, 0.028013551607728004, 0.010409414768218994, 0.00932248029857874, 0.05863162502646446, -0.015712153166532516, -0.0058050635270774364, -0.018322991207242012, 0.011322805657982826, -0.002263972768560052, 0.03096068650484085, 0.024939777329564095, 0.04413234069943428, -0.04110708087682724, 0.04298870638012886, -0.014881918206810951, 0.04175333306193352, 0.08220382034778595, -0.0208642166107893, -0.0093467952683568, -0.021191520616412163, -0.02303304150700569, 0.008949687704443932, 0.017692498862743378, -0.015247482806444168, -0.0010820251191034913, 0.061818335205316544, -0.0004713314410764724, -0.06487429141998291, -0.005509953014552593, 0.05946110561490059, 0.010091835632920265, -0.008458639495074749, -0.027162188664078712, 0.0016394680133089423, -0.005997516680508852, -0.003683822462335229, 0.031242048367857933, -0.0011825037654489279, -0.042554810643196106, -0.00004543557588476688, 0.029962988570332527, -0.023858249187469482, -0.01784331724047661, -0.01022440753877163, 0.04045731574296951, 0.03089100867509842, 0.031369760632514954, -0.050275977700948715, 0.019764920696616173, 0.04137716814875603, 0.03732796013355255, 0.04448039457201958, 0.00991970393806696, -0.09383425861597061, -0.01370168849825859, 0.05645398795604706, 0.007074787747114897, -0.040453311055898666, 0.030017096549272537, -0.06414463371038437, -0.02312343940138817, 0.04660290107131004, 0.012752769514918327, 0.02807394601404667, -0.007557533215731382, 0.003069865284487605, 0.001644075266085565, -0.028799204155802727, -0.04522651806473732, 0.023827536031603813, -0.021976672112941742, 0.01831088215112686, -0.03984835743904114, -0.01557287946343422, -0.038980163633823395, 0.022112000733613968, 0.0037003227043896914, 0.06907246261835098, -0.000926132604945451, -0.02642904222011566, 0.008143783546984196, 0.011367341503500938, 0.014911634847521782, -0.05182386562228203, 0.016376836225390434, 0.02272740937769413, -0.013097253628075123, 0.006625405978411436, 0.008154431357979774, -0.040046676993370056, 0.018459027633070946, 0.026066981256008148, -0.034108083695173264, 0.001731226104311645, -0.003445402020588517, 0.002377982484176755, 0.01628630794584751, 0.0036120847798883915, 0.05974787101149559, 0.03467564657330513, -0.012815166264772415, -0.0007877065218053758, -0.033266473561525345, 0.020195333287119865, -0.039018724113702774, -0.008958788588643074, -0.01212165504693985, -0.006736230570822954, -0.008112900890409946, 0.005814610049128532, 0.040439240634441376, 0.05168544128537178, -0.019838707521557808, -0.017407994717359543, 0.002637522527948022, 0.031742509454488754, -0.014916612766683102, -0.01915545016527176, -0.02411104552447796, 0.008510981686413288, 0.0030712266452610493, -0.02958596870303154, -0.016098681837320328, 0.03825743496417999, 0.030408788472414017, -0.004398188088089228, -0.061937008053064346, 0.019756117835640907, -0.029467405751347542, -0.018998971208930016, 0.047742825001478195, -0.053938575088977814, 0.06642381101846695, 0.008006655611097813, 0.03449181094765663, 0.005417575128376484, -0.05084283649921417, -0.020617332309484482, 0.0041566877625882626, -0.008775589987635612, 0.05267229676246643, -0.04068244248628616, 0.03142676129937172, -0.005260724574327469, 0.0005539031117223203, -0.06669195741415024, -0.02059171348810196, 0.04328460991382599, -0.03348948061466217, -0.01287421490997076, -0.056735239923000336, 0.03550256788730621, -0.02744113840162754, -0.04540494456887245, 0.004672706127166748, 0.05277090519666672, -0.045385800302028656, 0.01662544161081314, -0.015562699176371098, -0.028099380433559418, 0.07354721426963806, 0.019737483933568, -0.024179870262742043, 0.01794375665485859, -0.01340967882424593, -0.01588660292327404, 0.030175136402249336, 0.02126038260757923, -0.020017266273498535, 0.014264272525906563, -0.04957364499568939, -0.0024671549908816814, 0.04695933312177658, 0.0008804842946119606, 0.0002306894020875916, 0.009464763104915619, 0.02600070834159851, 0.011073361150920391, -0.04017490893602371, 0.01747102104127407, -0.01592552289366722, -0.028935041278600693, -0.021225789561867714, -0.020710283890366554, -0.00742256548255682, -0.007490057963877916, 0.05083484947681427, -0.008470243774354458, -0.016353577375411987, 0.0011261809850111604, 0.041173141449689865, 0.00589510053396225, 0.023900067433714867, 0.006336278282105923, -0.006007745862007141, 0.018909621983766556, 0.006118312943726778, 0.008803512901067734, 0.024785814806818962, 0.0029087236616760492, -0.019034065306186676, -0.02069939486682415, -0.06387484073638916, -0.04903563857078552, 0.06787042319774628, -0.04460318386554718, 0.07516607642173767, 0.045546695590019226, 0.010828055441379547, 0.004294935148209333, -0.023212037980556488, 0.009534679353237152, 0.011807448230683804, -0.007209675386548042, 0.036406032741069794, -0.01801111549139023, 0.03482499346137047, 0.04733280837535858, 0.009176820516586304, 0.008826455101370811, 0.038098037242889404, -0.025106295943260193, 0.04338841512799263, 0.04949841648340225, -0.018411029130220413, -0.06277500092983246, 0.04171533137559891, -0.030080698430538177, 0.026429444551467896, -0.02022092230618, -0.05633249133825302, 0.07328721135854721, 0.01209939830005169, 0.01489825639873743, -0.02955901250243187, -0.029241710901260376, -0.031559135764837265, 0.05527385696768761, 0.025194602087140083, -0.004793467465788126, 0.038070835173130035, 0.022653881460428238, 0.022801388055086136, -0.0014419351937249303, 0.009489928372204304, -0.01411519292742014, -0.09580513834953308, -0.027191514149308205, -0.021586662158370018, -0.014917182736098766, 0.010999150574207306, 0.02362154610455036, -0.05646234378218651, 0.009114136919379234, -0.010479460470378399, 0.022950880229473114, 0.029209211468696594, 0.04649946466088295, -0.0018926679622381926, 0.08352643996477127, -0.024532945826649666, -0.01065690629184246, -0.0186877753585577, -0.007604299113154411, 0.10371480137109756, 0.08102217316627502, 0.021632445976138115, -0.07609716057777405, 0.014051136560738087, -0.020247003063559532, -0.016006914898753166, -0.05561274290084839, 0.043253831565380096, 0.0031270431354641914, -0.015044317580759525, 0.008375934325158596, 0.04202164709568024, 0.013205212540924549, -0.00238604168407619, 0.07156500220298767, -0.021281970664858818, -0.004776547662913799, 0.0025124584790319204, 0.0021456016693264246, 0.0316375270485878, -0.005701781250536442, -0.05392918363213539, 0.034909576177597046, -0.017507797107100487, -0.05329785495996475, -0.03859211876988411, -0.01986551471054554, -0.002312007360160351, 0.019564442336559296, -0.011168285273015499, -0.017595648765563965, 0.012962517328560352, -0.020664773881435394, 0.01104260329157114, -0.003364349016919732, 0.011789393611252308, -0.03826990723609924, 0.007718777284026146, 0.0281780157238245, 0.00605595950037241, -0.023077091202139854, -0.020278939977288246, -0.023713568225502968, -0.008719145320355892, -0.002536277985200286, -0.028913235291838646, 0.08846588432788849, -0.0003065536147914827, 0.003959693014621735, -0.014820411801338196, -0.01607383042573929, 0.005070395302027464, -0.012200962752103806, -0.003324908670037985, 0.01995793916285038, 0.040907490998506546, -0.0154316620901227, -0.007498673629015684, -0.006237392779439688, 0.019250446930527687, -0.013431044295430183, 0.07581015676259995, 0.025387559086084366, -0.03881043940782547, -0.03594930097460747, -0.047759950160980225, 0.042564328759908676, 0.0005908414605073631, -0.004529659170657396, 0.02558261901140213, -0.04565451294183731, -0.03120730258524418, -0.018910810351371765, 0.0493905283510685, -0.012226138263940811, 0.009927979670464993, -0.03170133754611015, -0.01994025520980358, -0.01954246126115322, -0.0304893646389246, 0.01642780378460884, -0.0529632605612278, 0.01332785002887249, -0.036756664514541626, 0.02260941080749035, 0.06671160459518433, 0.04881603643298149, 0.02669965848326683, 0.006255933549255133, -0.00035996962105855346, 0.013986663892865181, 0.03564644977450371, -0.07135935127735138, 0.003306369064375758, -0.021593203768134117, -0.0050783283077180386, -0.006298864725977182, -0.011721453629434109, 0.06187348812818527, 0.03158225491642952, -0.006009872071444988, -0.002799302339553833, 0.012926873750984669, -0.004684171639382839, 0.02334606647491455, -0.031326744705438614, -0.03396042808890343, 0.016065118834376335, 0.0007888330146670341, 0.012266891077160835, -0.018904590979218483, -0.004555975086987019, -0.020145447924733162, -0.015871237963438034, -0.00693726958706975, -0.026062991470098495, -0.03858313336968422, 0.01667417585849762, 0.008117987774312496, 0.030410705134272575, -0.022507663816213608, 0.031483959406614304, 0.014193940907716751, -0.007464908994734287, -0.031241655349731445, 0.004781833849847317, -0.0026444424875080585, -0.011637631803750992, 0.010414442047476768, -0.005357955116778612, 0.06737224012613297, 0.011325378902256489, 0.05118560791015625, 0.016816144809126854, 0.01965700276196003, -0.01700582355260849, 0.024199839681386948, -0.020652448758482933, -0.007906525395810604, 0.03398013859987259, -0.05336248502135277, 0.004712443798780441, 0.02611619606614113, -0.010416250675916672, 0.03434959053993225, -0.00017247821961063892, 0.02209015004336834, -0.019429964944720268, 0.0455801822245121, -0.012991382740437984, 0.022330377250909805, 0.00026772430283017457, -0.005454394035041332, 0.009670755825936794, -0.01261967048048973, -0.00008451197209069505, 0.008103452622890472, -0.004056326113641262, 0.0015509782824665308, 0.018880611285567284, 0.005019724369049072, -0.02328088879585266, 0.03614778816699982, 0.004176038783043623, -0.019254980608820915, -0.005010485183447599, -0.011592160910367966, 0.05723220109939575, 0.04427114129066467, -0.034275684505701065, 0.035727359354496, 0.003615750465542078, 0.020892083644866943, -0.11912434548139572, -0.02823103964328766, -0.00022628075385000557, -0.005056503228843212, 0.04500172287225723, -0.029195468872785568, 0.015404506586492062, 0.031894296407699585, -0.027386382222175598, 0.02130972035229206, 0.04650476947426796, 0.009157424792647362, -0.02211427316069603, 0.00556359626352787, -0.028370661661028862, 0.04107338935136795, 0.013599996455013752, 0.03479241952300072, 0.04989207535982132, 0.014667217619717121, 0.015146872960031033, 0.004455475602298975, 0.010020706802606583, 0.013455582782626152, 0.012556435540318489, -0.05692475661635399, 0.05858798325061798, -0.041529759764671326, -0.03122846595942974, 0.01271933875977993, 0.05359889566898346, 0.03354312852025032, 0.03143642470240593, 0.01849907822906971, 0.0028562273364514112, 0.03721125051379204, 0.036646369844675064, 0.013119070790708065, -0.009896010160446167, 0.00497368024662137, 0.015642257407307625, 0.02442309632897377, -0.046901632100343704, 0.03191157057881355, 0.007111565209925175, -0.026818599551916122, -0.02731218934059143, 0.02420591562986374, -0.003822092665359378, -0.026049740612506866, 0.014014853164553642, 0.0021972833201289177, -0.02686420828104019, 0.00414931820705533, 0.015762750059366226, -0.07075061649084091, -0.006527511868625879, 0.01976950839161873, 0.00782476644963026, -0.02721327543258667, -0.005775646772235632, -0.02195853181183338, -0.05198457092046738, 0.0356023907661438, -0.029745005071163177, -0.010112482123076916, -0.0668085366487503, 0.0010824751807376742, 0.028815099969506264, -0.03544747456908226, -0.03672834485769272, 0.0017750017577782273, -0.046860769391059875, 0.024793609976768494, -0.01276056095957756, 0.011617000214755535, 0.059023819863796234, 0.01349765807390213, -0.006527108605951071, -0.05957650765776634, 0.08179932832717896, 0.01079819817095995, -0.049905192106962204, -0.016464384272694588, -0.006497581489384174, -0.00696733221411705, -0.020955950021743774, 0.05465327203273773, -0.016852669417858124, -0.005410623271018267, -0.021154947578907013, 0.02072303183376789, 0.033184900879859924, -0.04039643332362175, 0.03805781900882721, -0.016757356002926826, -0.047472428530454636, -0.02785646729171276, -0.018583687022328377, -0.01204462256282568, 0.031679607927799225, 0.028208404779434204, -0.0049749878235161304, 0.009066523052752018, 0.01741238869726658, -0.009073366411030293, 0.012515739537775517, 0.005881343502551317, 0.007693777792155743, 0.03626851364970207, -0.0034685893915593624, 0.01709105260670185, 0.02794909104704857, 0.04218081012368202, -0.07585307210683823, 0.01981532573699951, -0.008651139214634895, -0.03406220301985741, 0.005096889566630125, 0.016068339347839355, -0.023060781881213188, -0.03503609448671341, -0.030997542664408684, 0.027158167213201523, -0.05075448751449585, 0.031967643648386, 0.03658108785748482, -0.01898621767759323, 0.040101345628499985, -0.0008375493343919516, 0.018074098974466324, 0.036324966698884964, -0.010122334584593773, 0.015782415866851807, 0.02498330920934677, 0.043546054512262344, -0.014710750430822372, 0.0434202216565609, 0.04294952005147934, -0.014623288065195084, 0.02406555786728859, -0.002942311577498913, 0.03258032724261284, -0.08655320852994919, -0.0048562344163656235, -0.018095863983035088, -0.0054292879067361355, 0.0042583635076880455, 0.010913043282926083, -0.015328456647694111, 0.06823385506868362, -0.010059204883873463, -0.03005409799516201, -0.000639828504063189, 0.007750240154564381, -0.007072925101965666, 0.03195645660161972, -0.0003893453103955835, 0.04843892529606819, 0.009863589890301228, 0.03777694329619408, 0.012351583689451218, 0.006922133266925812, 0.03210349753499031, -0.0021933140233159065, 0.008393572643399239, 0.00013295315147843212, -0.008377676829695702, -0.004193607252091169, 0.00195433315820992, 0.010610345751047134, -0.040623053908348083, 0.0031908343080431223, 0.06242663413286209, 0.039441704750061035, -0.009518852457404137, -0.01698392443358898, -0.017837805673480034, 0.04323867708444595, -0.07823028415441513, 0.006104099564254284, -0.0034988573752343655, -0.003572273999452591, -0.015483664348721504, -0.03529680520296097 ]
<p>I'v been playing around with back propagation, trying to see if I can find a solution to the XOR problem using a 2-2-1 network. Based on my simulations and calculations, a solution is not possible without implementing a bias for every neuron. Is this correct?</p>
74,229
[ -0.031262315809726715, 0.007664965000003576, -0.0011462740367278457, 0.021356625482439995, 0.03375173732638359, -0.030568117275834084, -0.024243228137493134, -0.0019499445334076881, -0.004041294567286968, -0.04077049717307091, 0.02040884830057621, 0.02867680788040161, -0.0009739273227751255, 0.06174725294113159, 0.019326047971844673, 0.0020401389338076115, -0.0004844515351578593, 0.002276686020195484, 0.03667862340807915, -0.018733061850070953, 0.013863202184438705, 0.03214116021990776, -0.008011690340936184, -0.008272327482700348, -0.022905530408024788, 0.027979817241430283, -0.01728149689733982, -0.020922865718603134, 0.027183733880519867, 0.059858355671167374, -0.009052729234099388, -0.03345474973320961, 0.030377931892871857, 0.054142143577337265, 0.011885321699082851, 0.007469383534044027, 0.02157449908554554, -0.07136399298906326, -0.027973877266049385, 0.031219705939292908, 0.01167640183120966, -0.03316711261868477, 0.008937807753682137, 0.0015866117319092155, -0.028819775208830833, 0.021758560091257095, -0.003869122825562954, -0.04373791441321373, 0.006228865589946508, -0.044325511902570724, 0.0904148519039154, -0.01660088822245598, 0.019891370087862015, 0.027195308357477188, -0.013718237169086933, 0.0009116819710470736, 0.07583191990852356, 0.06916380673646927, 0.0006590491975657642, -0.016208883374929428, -0.006903714966028929, 0.0022873105481266975, -0.0006435539689846337, -0.019237278029322624, -0.026537420228123665, -0.005738043691962957, 0.033859968185424805, -0.019426703453063965, -0.013339133001863956, -0.060190655291080475, 0.03634900972247124, -0.009846423752605915, 0.029629480093717575, -0.010655306279659271, -0.024041950702667236, -0.01562565378844738, 0.0315500870347023, 0.033827923238277435, -0.003353395964950323, 0.013559365645051003, -0.008716299198567867, -0.0012672854354605079, 0.02997777797281742, 0.07176747173070908, -0.001695250510238111, 0.017256921157240868, 0.05564189329743385, -0.03750133514404297, 0.03393740579485893, 0.029557758942246437, -0.0009453800157643855, 0.005946848075836897, 0.08497796952724457, 0.011979787610471249, -0.041450295597314835, 0.035592466592788696, 0.03230142593383789, 0.03158850595355034, 0.02520766668021679, -0.012623713351786137, -0.0013321456499397755, 0.013547522015869617, -0.017600199207663536, 0.07614797353744507, -0.043758317828178406, 0.00857483595609665, -0.0055879466235637665, 0.02869279496371746, -0.010455461218953133, 0.016505710780620575, -0.03650616481900215, 0.03860337287187576, -0.009593495167791843, -0.00015887578774709255, 0.030722565948963165, -0.023703033104538918, -0.014729886315762997, -0.010160135105252266, -0.0099252974614501, 0.06209134683012962, 0.022662920877337456, -0.032788001000881195, 0.021501269191503525, -0.024173537269234657, -0.03612096235156059, 0.027949610725045204, 0.018011609092354774, -0.008266127668321133, -0.053706854581832886, 0.04918726906180382, 0.031111182644963264, -0.053453635424375534, 0.028843985870480537, 0.006815565750002861, 0.037416841834783554, -0.021302735432982445, -0.07790359854698181, -0.0699821189045906, 0.040307849645614624, -0.04939578101038933, 0.002280102577060461, -0.09173096716403961, 0.013342541642487049, 0.06418243795633316, 0.08286700397729874, 0.02459188550710678, 0.016957463696599007, 0.04538625106215477, 0.0023663542233407497, 0.02011801302433014, -0.010042321868240833, -0.019425252452492714, -0.002303334651514888, -0.031916383653879166, -0.01680733636021614, -0.050348322838544846, 0.04893288016319275, 0.026259420439600945, -0.03397361561655998, -0.014277325943112373, 0.0271027609705925, -0.007828527130186558, 0.009660495445132256, 0.0012853579828515649, 0.005308930296450853, -0.053882014006376266, 0.12245706468820572, -0.0065923030488193035, 0.06834953278303146, 0.022191237658262253, -0.046096812933683395, 0.03114653006196022, 0.0021463329903781414, 0.022556623443961143, 0.0374494306743145, -0.025018498301506042, -0.039031848311424255, -0.008683650754392147, 0.016437944024801254, -0.009674212895333767, -0.036879777908325195, -0.0191004890948534, -0.01693439669907093, 0.026012200862169266, -0.005692010745406151, 0.02625277079641819, -0.0026035846676677465, -0.021185563877224922, 0.013839167542755604, -0.00694349454715848, 0.028861790895462036, -0.07000263780355453, 0.009086855687201023, -0.01341844629496336, 0.003624468808993697, -0.0011499169049784541, -0.025786709040403366, 0.019667133688926697, -0.0282309390604496, -0.04542481154203415, -0.05124369263648987, 0.020516613498330116, 0.05688926950097084, 0.001375921186991036, 0.014076306484639645, 0.062103789299726486, 0.006609479896724224, -0.028927480801939964, 0.050457850098609924, -0.06836111098527908, -0.04012442007660866, 0.018420949578285217, 0.0012198984622955322, 0.02093302458524704, -0.014154925011098385, -0.006240564398467541, 0.026232289150357246, -0.0075358981266617775, 0.010674877092242241, 0.030475543811917305, -0.07874657958745956, 0.07280278950929642, 0.03701673075556755, 0.0391247421503067, -0.0039141252636909485, 0.039302848279476166, 0.048151612281799316, 0.007514927536249161, 0.003326255362480879, 0.000679743941873312, -0.05305758863687515, -0.03848204389214516, 0.04283686354756355, 0.045004814863204956, -0.046541906893253326, 0.030221622437238693, 0.04137946665287018, 0.035386670380830765, -0.006969568319618702, 0.002242540940642357, -0.01881071738898754, 0.01849399134516716, -0.021932287141680717, 0.010439223609864712, 0.02588454633951187, 0.03818163648247719, 0.040070611983537674, -0.002448517829179764, 0.010738098993897438, 0.014246102422475815, -0.044700127094984055, 0.043935514986515045, 0.01638723723590374, 0.016625117510557175, 0.0010160260135307908, -0.0727454274892807, 0.006372010800987482, 0.0005845286068506539, 0.015401061624288559, 0.028180444613099098, 0.0022276625968515873, -0.010069742798805237, -0.019112253561615944, -0.020672164857387543, -0.025401296094059944, 0.019730467349290848, -0.01919948309659958, -0.007163642439991236, 0.0407257080078125, -0.01730460487306118, 0.012594439089298248, 0.007173119578510523, -0.01596563681960106, -0.01502884179353714, 0.007723974529653788, 0.01786975748836994, -0.003520825644955039, -0.004585218150168657, -0.032735515385866165, -0.03005010448396206, -0.021091803908348083, 0.006579922046512365, 0.01599428988993168, -0.019429445266723633, -0.05516931414604187, 0.008047818206250668, -0.019545119255781174, -0.0017612192314118147, 0.021563401445746422, 0.025925656780600548, 0.03005550056695938, 0.006440024357289076, -0.030399667099118233, -0.04665398970246315, -0.027841253206133842, -0.07002776861190796, -0.005293038208037615, -0.016870474442839622, -0.029827991500496864, 0.04508350417017937, 0.03308308869600296, -0.046937715262174606, 0.013538885861635208, -0.007062478922307491, -0.038561467081308365, -0.021056804805994034, 0.00041788516682572663, -0.003636683337390423, 0.0021025005262345076, 0.0030505319591611624, 0.031921062618494034, -0.019146928563714027, 0.01103748008608818, -0.04776139557361603, -0.07403242588043213, 0.027184713631868362, 0.02909877710044384, 0.015644624829292297, 0.01785438321530819, 0.02177843451499939, 0.08483166992664337, 0.014076449908316135, -0.01870163530111313, -0.023562563583254814, -0.028127621859312057, 0.013809632509946823, -0.050953786820173264, 0.03168940916657448, 0.030905188992619514, 0.023329734802246094, 0.012440776452422142, -0.02517683431506157, 0.009595080278813839, 0.08682230114936829, 0.008215207606554031, -0.003181478939950466, 0.028811311349272728, 0.00949162244796753, -0.043015845119953156, 0.04527511075139046, 0.00541298370808363, -0.007544724270701408, 0.022027352824807167, 0.01060453336685896, 0.012308688834309578, 0.0034696089569479227, -0.0005209886003285646, 0.016077103093266487, -0.014350282028317451, 0.02712087891995907, -0.024052001535892487, 0.047553543001413345, -0.011900687590241432, 0.015225287526845932, -0.02053765580058098, 0.002458779374137521, 0.05853654071688652, -0.004790934268385172, 0.021794861182570457, 0.05105121061205864, 0.025378206744790077, 0.007694002706557512, -0.010476605966687202, 0.025556983426213264, -0.019035276025533676, 0.0028386481571942568, 0.0011124127777293324, 0.00013253054930828512, 0.017662059515714645, 0.003454426769167185, -0.0014838024508208036, 0.05711294338107109, 0.013349169865250587, -0.0058784447610378265, -0.07548249512910843, 0.014006193727254868, -0.04692130535840988, 0.04345274344086647, -0.01651540771126747, 0.01040398795157671, -0.03844575583934784, -0.013782232068479061, 0.008668389171361923, 0.020462417975068092, -0.08303297311067581, -0.001818068907596171, 0.008019337430596352, -0.02031059004366398, -0.00093397859018296, -0.0718904361128807, 0.01918596215546131, -0.018309468403458595, -0.013692169450223446, 0.017605094239115715, 0.013791012577712536, -0.04633934795856476, 0.019648469984531403, -0.031803276389837265, -0.012265713885426521, -0.00766406673938036, 0.04568886756896973, 0.025441806763410568, 0.0012144517386332154, 0.013641132041811943, 0.0030321767553687096, -0.01481765415519476, 0.013051735237240791, -0.016774235293269157, 0.01171754952520132, 0.03667566180229187, 0.03583783283829689, 0.014101034961640835, 0.037360046058893204, -0.06389740109443665, -0.0016135048354044557, 0.007068931125104427, 0.048532746732234955, 0.042940154671669006, -0.015095682814717293, -0.016419852152466774, -0.07870830595493317, -0.020681455731391907, 0.029549622908234596, 0.05670546367764473, -0.009974348358809948, 0.027042638510465622, 0.03724925220012665, 0.020458636805415154, -0.07081956416368484, -0.018847787752747536, 0.08012616634368896, 0.030800361186265945, -0.01987581141293049, -0.02607756480574608, -0.024555981159210205, -0.01899910159409046, 0.015059254132211208, 0.012101036496460438, -0.036927323788404465, -0.02000626176595688, -0.011922448873519897, 0.028625693172216415, 0.0233712587505579, 0.0020780947525054216, -0.010988020338118076, -0.011303955689072609, 0.01390296034514904, 0.0036422566045075655, 0.026378659531474113, -0.007889804430305958, 0.03285648673772812, 0.006783209275454283, 0.04065876081585884, 0.0038622221909463406, -0.07787083834409714, -0.0029581424314528704, 0.03467991575598717, 0.039695557206869125, -0.013884403742849827, -0.02589668147265911, -0.020397653803229332, -0.006831851322203875, 0.022812126204371452, -0.02885919250547886, 0.0604567676782608, -0.010667726397514343, -0.029152119532227516, -0.034308165311813354, -0.018144913017749786, -0.0174166951328516, 0.036963339895009995, -0.044728249311447144, 0.018188439309597015, -0.005040602292865515, 0.0035920143127441406, -0.02464361861348152, -0.036041464656591415, 0.039647508412599564, 0.07684004306793213, -0.028490211814641953, -0.0007702792063355446, 0.015405738726258278, 0.05175456777215004, -0.02752101607620716, -0.04706988483667374, 0.007386180106550455, -0.025107841938734055, -0.03335283324122429, 0.05768353119492531, -0.029263876378536224, -0.04387523978948593, 0.06374209374189377, 0.012969587929546833, -0.018863394856452942, -0.0356200747191906, -0.03736573085188866, 0.037019532173871994, 0.04256151244044304, -0.02111424319446087, 0.0909932553768158, 0.012110104784369469, -0.015306749381124973, -0.011345500126481056, -0.018131567165255547, -0.0007280331337824464, -0.02912864461541176, 0.024278922006487846, -0.003277247305959463, -0.01665646769106388, -0.02264510467648506, 0.034059833735227585, 0.024634774774312973, 0.06489482522010803, -0.009185991249978542, -0.018482204526662827, -0.03304829075932503, 0.037439197301864624, -0.03179454430937767, -0.012042315676808357, 0.022000430151820183, 0.040796857327222824, 0.008658415637910366, -0.008677089586853981, -0.0002543042355682701, -0.033637017011642456, 0.03100757859647274, 0.04665611311793327, 0.013486047275364399, -0.020531948655843735, -0.05265790596604347, -0.006571659818291664, -0.017567932605743408, -0.0317818708717823, 0.07558571547269821, 0.01057123951613903, 0.012099669314920902, 0.029547857120633125, -0.048920754343271255, -0.01466451957821846, 0.0315069854259491, 0.015441068448126316, 0.0006856832769699395, -0.02048325724899769, -0.016927285119891167, 0.022192731499671936, -0.003106111893430352, -0.03202144056558609, -0.07207164913415909, 0.005839866120368242, 0.009188743308186531, 0.032044753432273865, -0.03637845814228058, 0.013969369232654572, 0.015522443689405918, -0.04301464557647705, 0.0007864031358622015, 0.06527282297611237, 0.0017932755872607231, 0.025511393323540688, 0.03377481922507286, -0.013818599283695221, 0.0408400222659111, 0.021107468754053116, -0.043821316212415695, -0.008374465629458427, -0.042007237672805786, -0.02358640357851982, -0.0245394054800272, 0.0037728610914200544, -0.047761887311935425, -0.013080250471830368, -0.03716777265071869, 0.027784278616309166, 0.04624311253428459, 0.004587809555232525, -0.012526853941380978, 0.0034632582683116198, 0.008467594161629677, -0.012594031170010567, -0.0681636780500412, -0.01679992489516735, 0.010347454808652401, -0.020092684775590897, 0.023126762360334396, -0.020511938259005547, -0.028705419972538948, -0.028514884412288666, 0.02117837406694889, 0.016005689278244972, -0.019703207537531853, 0.004930705297738314, 0.07963957637548447, -0.01523219607770443, -0.013970118947327137, -0.02549017407000065, -0.008908912539482117, 0.056176140904426575, -0.00029436330078169703, 0.006304646376520395, -0.01455683819949627, 0.015196720138192177, -0.047490350902080536, -0.012553559616208076, 0.010367859154939651, 0.010829749517142773, 0.040468018501996994, -0.00935463048517704, 0.019358638674020767, 0.02634415030479431, 0.03485075384378433, -0.028172386810183525, 0.004157394170761108, -0.01701267994940281, -0.0009326098370365798, -0.04249747470021248, 0.017192810773849487, -0.012082945555448532, 0.011998200789093971, 0.020943813025951385, 0.025224661454558372, 0.04394189640879631, -0.008754217997193336, 0.011617457494139671, 0.01438454445451498, -0.004959938116371632, 0.002679984550923109, -0.05015047267079353, 0.039009492844343185, -0.047177884727716446, -0.0010714952368289232, -0.029804253950715065, -0.058111853897571564, 0.055368416011333466, -0.0022156774066388607, 0.0042714872397482395, -0.03196129947900772, -0.043715063482522964, -0.055037155747413635, -0.042208198457956314, -0.03246393799781799, 0.026645328849554062, -0.0010739783756434917, 0.016886750236153603, 0.030427411198616028, -0.002690942259505391, 0.011225668713450432, -0.02739688940346241, -0.07697500288486481, -0.029534446075558662, -0.038913141936063766, -0.0473591685295105, 0.028488269075751305, 0.02522093616425991, -0.0439433827996254, 0.02713174745440483, -0.03920227289199829, 0.06231053173542023, 0.0012448510387912393, 0.04136386886239052, 0.0045804111286997795, 0.04340897873044014, -0.017350027337670326, 0.040979016572237015, -0.029994506388902664, -0.020008565858006477, 0.0901867225766182, 0.08685968071222305, 0.05189303681254387, -0.07972059398889542, -0.019101794809103012, -0.05693114921450615, -0.012886532582342625, -0.03646674007177353, 0.009039072319865227, 0.021436935290694237, 0.0044940076768398285, -0.027221696451306343, 0.03052312135696411, 0.026859944686293602, -0.06052030995488167, 0.036260005086660385, -0.035485200583934784, -0.02123442478477955, 0.04417257755994797, 0.010853219777345657, 0.008161614648997784, -0.012136074714362621, -0.032817546278238297, 0.004710664041340351, -0.008149559609591961, -0.037830885499715805, -0.03182265907526016, 0.012605443596839905, 0.03284377232193947, -0.02340048737823963, -0.02362680435180664, 0.0009126350632868707, -0.0037070002872496843, -0.012649468146264553, -0.005298343021422625, 0.0007087031845003366, -0.010729755274951458, -0.03615458309650421, 0.02696910686790943, 0.02331710420548916, 0.02301129698753357, 0.004551147576421499, 0.02495180070400238, -0.04380970448255539, -0.040837012231349945, -0.009334437549114227, -0.04561649262905121, 0.05268655717372894, -0.028046520426869392, 0.01703496463596821, 0.05069821700453758, -0.010192408226430416, 0.014326645992696285, -0.030054595321416855, -0.01865224912762642, 0.045266151428222656, 0.0280440840870142, 0.0027813659980893135, -0.017868507653474808, 0.008058223873376846, 0.031770654022693634, -0.027864916250109673, -0.0017103782156482339, 0.00011301589984213933, -0.005139676388353109, -0.014188061468303204, -0.020162273198366165, 0.07483552396297455, 0.03140971437096596, -0.020748933777213097, -0.022519806399941444, -0.015137006528675556, -0.03103741444647312, -0.0013732991646975279, -0.012391440570354462, 0.004862661939114332, -0.009831208735704422, 0.016576506197452545, -0.048210687935352325, 0.007556724827736616, -0.03891677409410477, 0.01535759400576353, -0.006724535021930933, 0.01151206437498331, -0.008081229403614998, -0.01709158904850483, 0.010492948815226555, 0.008195125497877598, 0.0475657656788826, 0.04832090809941292, 0.028744477778673172, 0.009010957553982735, 0.03039734810590744, -0.030776159837841988, -0.030698461458086967, -0.011335971765220165, -0.04386052116751671, -0.0016553679015487432, 0.01345312874764204, 0.018560977652668953, -0.012981497682631016, 0.020907504484057426, 0.02862762287259102, 0.0085971774533391, 0.02441345900297165, -0.017879385501146317, 0.004036510828882456, -0.07208433002233505, 0.003755242796614766, -0.014879588969051838, 0.007898160256445408, -0.04610336571931839, -0.0431755892932415, -0.03673836961388588, -0.01613357476890087, -0.01704424060881138, 0.04305713623762131, -0.017518071457743645, -0.03572768345475197, -0.030198324471712112, 0.022696051746606827, -0.0031938732136040926, -0.0046870047226548195, -0.008257213979959488, 0.003459327621385455, -0.022325867787003517, -0.016804853454232216, -0.0032560769468545914, 0.038239456713199615, 0.01634610816836357, 0.004124326165765524, 0.04667840152978897, -0.0011995980748906732, -0.006966960616409779, 0.013828557915985584, 0.008101960644125938, -0.000019192071704310365, 0.041258927434682846, -0.03342701867222786, -0.04336737096309662, 0.011189449578523636, -0.023809542879462242, -0.006058600731194019, 0.014931805431842804, -0.0014253939734771848, -0.0011676591821014881, 0.05569054186344147, -0.009758563712239265, -0.013164587318897247, 0.04427989572286606, -0.035988349467515945, -0.012193899601697922, 0.026144126430153847, 0.009578724391758442, 0.020448623225092888, -0.0013032747665420175, 0.0200332161039114, 0.0029497856739908457, -0.027506357058882713, -0.00024879330885596573, 0.0016749351052567363, 0.029964309185743332, -0.00899876281619072, 0.009424712508916855, 0.016039924696087837, 0.0186181478202343, -0.025393038988113403, -0.013053110800683498, -0.005586567334830761, 0.011800022795796394, -0.025236010551452637, 0.03829384222626686, -0.00235052895732224, 0.0160544253885746, -0.053563281893730164, -0.00217898259870708, 0.04567428305745125, 0.024886824190616608, 0.06765913963317871, -0.043102994561195374, 0.01859593577682972, 0.005852558184415102, -0.0931750163435936, -0.006200225092470646, -0.0008389934082515538, -0.06082254648208618, -0.014814906753599644, 0.026594650000333786, -0.03856535255908966, 0.015117719769477844, -0.012793464586138725, 0.021349133923649788, -0.00964295119047165, -0.0039151920937001705, -0.016890360042452812, -0.028264926746487617, -0.02026098035275936, -0.017467385157942772, 0.0027481243014335632, -0.02740665338933468, -0.000558357045520097, -0.018498772755265236, -0.008138468489050865, 0.02924257144331932, -0.030700821429491043, -0.0070426887832582, 0.003688569413498044, 0.05515798181295395, -0.007699410896748304, 0.028207264840602875, -0.005036698654294014, -0.015010755509138107, 0.01792902685701847, 0.002635519253090024, 0.0227428637444973, 0.04431888833642006, -0.023991858586668968, 0.012015286833047867, 0.015537894330918789, 0.01517826784402132, -0.08069350570440292, 0.0004261053982190788, -0.03440380096435547, -0.014260310679674149, 0.01805088296532631, 0.017836419865489006, 0.003981928341090679, -0.0037772804498672485, -0.012274174019694328, -0.025412291288375854, 0.00017385240062139928, 0.006005122791975737, 0.038606274873018265, -0.023282021284103394, -0.009424581192433834, 0.01828126423060894, -0.04824987053871155, 0.0026914787013083696, 0.029035037383437157, -0.00802710559219122, -0.048741843551397324, 0.009083263576030731, 0.04844341427087784, -0.013249434530735016, 0.015277484431862831, -0.0556458979845047, -0.020561452955007553, 0.03699466586112976, 0.0035157124511897564, 0.04131687805056572, -0.010782876051962376, -0.034314099699258804, 0.002902803011238575, -0.05384441465139389, 0.07721425592899323, -0.0046292259357869625, 0.028724562376737595, -0.02691270411014557, -0.031487785279750824, -0.024744879454374313, -0.02116595022380352, 0.04348668083548546, -0.007368823979049921, -0.014374742284417152, -0.01077574584633112, 0.026731152087450027, 0.02301708050072193, 0.01237996481359005, 0.022679556161165237, -0.007509284652769566, -0.02223578840494156, -0.043610360473394394, -0.012425943277776241, -0.015864038839936256, 0.02796649932861328, -0.004395135212689638, 0.008478224277496338, -0.007379395421594381, -0.010368927381932735, -0.003800245700404048, 0.035430535674095154, -0.009827157482504845, 0.009550623595714569, 0.05981448292732239, 0.013960275799036026, 0.013302064500749111, 0.010675590485334396, 0.011698503978550434, -0.09249179810285568, 0.016611330211162567, -0.026545826345682144, -0.0155784348025918, -0.00867033377289772, -0.02186846360564232, 0.013320984318852425, -0.04802636802196503, -0.02776135317981243, 0.04551476612687111, -0.008354760706424713, 0.003981309477239847, 0.044539306312799454, -0.015761172398924828, 0.006361602805554867, -0.012906583026051521, 0.06570065766572952, -0.019314618781208992, 0.036480944603681564, 0.014458023011684418, 0.013064089231193066, -0.006270297337323427, -0.009705456905066967, 0.047842007130384445, 0.04072977602481842, -0.03170733526349068, 0.043009646236896515, -0.011137428693473339, 0.03318677097558975, -0.03702935203909874, 0.02727534994482994, 0.047057803720235825, 0.004786796867847443, 0.011291950941085815, -0.006657910533249378, -0.06537678092718124, 0.0697953999042511, -0.004006857518106699, 0.012362997978925705, -0.04071556031703949, -0.009600185789167881, 0.03423696011304855, -0.034814462065696716, 0.015235797502100468, 0.01643981784582138, -0.008994236588478088, -0.01822325401008129, 0.03892848640680313, 0.0402851328253746, 0.046203579753637314, -0.019974108785390854, 0.017004936933517456, -0.019607113674283028, -0.003452419536188245, 0.00984090007841587, -0.0069924951530992985, -0.050878074020147324, -0.06511238217353821, 0.0150328129529953, 0.04816802963614464, 0.008934889920055866, -0.0008530606864951551, -0.020336344838142395, -0.022335654124617577, 0.03030310943722725, -0.03458094224333763, -0.022794896736741066, -0.05227675288915634, 0.03894240781664848, 0.02067878097295761, -0.0201778132468462 ]
<p>I'm using rb-libsvm and the RBF kernel to make classifications. <code>svm.predict(measurements)</code> returns either -1.0 or 1.0. Is there a way to get a confidence for this classification? I am interested in throwing out low-confidence classifications and tweaking precision/recall.</p>
74,230
[ -0.014449851587414742, -0.021350383758544922, -0.027474116533994675, 0.017883485183119774, -0.02212480828166008, -0.012211370281875134, -0.03431033343076706, 0.012210311368107796, 0.05964389070868492, -0.004814498592168093, 0.04145807772874832, 0.05215979740023613, 0.02161499299108982, 0.01969449408352375, -0.0037822083104401827, 0.016572250053286552, 0.0038822961505502462, -0.042870864272117615, -0.0020876219496130943, -0.027963807806372643, 0.00047579879174008965, 0.02781885489821434, 0.03495299443602562, 0.0064850617200136185, -0.011280061677098274, 0.03832882642745972, 0.04625904560089111, -0.054776981472969055, -0.00044754150439985096, 0.013300702907145023, -0.05477658286690712, 0.00034614105243235826, 0.012246515601873398, 0.02132369764149189, 0.04565315693616867, 0.021269910037517548, -0.017457960173487663, -0.059924669563770294, -0.021451527252793312, 0.02397499978542328, 0.013078389689326286, 0.003808387788012624, -0.005542546510696411, 0.07494336366653442, 0.02339687943458557, 0.012720664031803608, 0.006030050106346607, -0.02192140929400921, 0.035198986530303955, -0.03568718582391739, 0.04228157922625542, -0.004809823352843523, 0.031853966414928436, 0.03697660565376282, -0.032068077474832535, -0.024861061945557594, 0.04571697115898132, 0.08003952354192734, 0.014089757576584816, -0.014462783932685852, -0.0036504860036075115, -0.04311254620552063, -0.0076566580682992935, -0.007094580680131912, -0.008791507221758366, 0.03373846411705017, -0.009042752906680107, -0.037191376090049744, 0.022681981325149536, -0.029887095093727112, 0.0065313950181007385, -0.0019085599342361093, 0.02291952446103096, 0.01164157036691904, 0.019892960786819458, -0.025672651827335358, 0.011219488456845284, 0.029875461012125015, 0.0399998314678669, 0.021369999274611473, -0.0014829525025561452, 0.04277631267905235, -0.0010781190358102322, 0.019276496022939682, 0.014844471588730812, -0.017534518614411354, 0.029398372396826744, 0.019760649651288986, -0.003132760524749756, 0.11336681246757507, -0.012406342662870884, 0.01676332950592041, 0.04879111424088478, 0.002730164909735322, -0.03509342670440674, 0.04217090457677841, -0.025056609883904457, 0.0233104657381773, 0.015073015354573727, -0.04186112433671951, -0.005045697093009949, 0.006612139288336039, 0.0101724062114954, 0.03279875963926315, -0.07237260788679123, -0.050229065120220184, -0.025638069957494736, -0.03398557007312775, -0.014698086306452751, -0.02376415580511093, 0.031668614596128464, -0.00004381769394967705, 0.013327399268746376, -0.009220745414495468, 0.02161104418337345, -0.052201077342033386, -0.018195364624261856, -0.032141316682100296, -0.009927616454660892, 0.027558278292417526, 0.03766980767250061, 0.008728773333132267, 0.008636247366666794, -0.015454241074621677, -0.0462561771273613, 0.011045493185520172, 0.04685946926474571, -0.018106112256646156, -0.023441126570105553, 0.041496213525533676, -0.006447516847401857, -0.04411332681775093, 0.02195923775434494, -0.039648257195949554, 0.006133359391242266, 0.0054433103650808334, -0.07190384715795517, -0.058232907205820084, 0.00907011516392231, -0.007844937965273857, 0.008387554436922073, -0.034317824989557266, 0.030625268816947937, 0.02960166335105896, 0.03172548860311508, 0.04542037844657898, 0.046083856374025345, 0.025265345349907875, 0.018958473578095436, -0.015297936275601387, -0.0019771745428442955, 0.0033294102177023888, -0.03534185513854027, 0.0038440795615315437, -0.09521806985139847, -0.005675890017300844, 0.023210374638438225, -0.0007706230389885604, -0.008020621724426746, -0.0023312214761972427, 0.002762844553217292, -0.0451129712164402, 0.0030364582780748606, 0.005937329959124327, -0.00973761547356844, -0.023125145584344864, 0.07792411744594574, 0.02015567198395729, 0.02510806731879711, -0.007849711924791336, -0.01816798932850361, 0.0056485021486878395, 0.043573327362537384, 0.016186365857720375, 0.07076884061098099, 0.01542389765381813, -0.01398397609591484, -0.0319177508354187, 0.050662606954574585, -0.015196689404547215, -0.054592058062553406, -0.029095398262143135, -0.0279631819576025, 0.021713050082325935, 0.004034633748233318, 0.045796241611242294, -0.003324526594951749, 0.0050075170584023, 0.04389030858874321, -0.03589780256152153, -0.0028569609858095646, -0.04375035688281059, -0.014240989461541176, 0.0064681777730584145, 0.003475464414805174, 0.0247404333204031, 0.01666177809238434, 0.0036837407387793064, -0.011633978225290775, 0.002761058509349823, -0.041841909289360046, 0.028000421822071075, 0.03087593801319599, -0.06391328573226929, -0.0026014349423348904, 0.03244763985276222, 0.05180348455905914, -0.05192483216524124, 0.05740995705127716, -0.020048800855875015, -0.06609775125980377, 0.015661226585507393, -0.028445614501833916, 0.002394166076555848, 0.0070031750947237015, -0.0258279200643301, 0.03778959810733795, 0.016270658001303673, 0.006590671371668577, -0.028817979618906975, -0.040889937430620193, 0.03885427117347717, 0.04334651678800583, -0.0018527624197304249, 0.002306019887328148, -0.0008207805803976953, -0.010430294089019299, -0.0033012917265295982, -0.04708361625671387, -0.0062986393459141254, -0.009414074011147022, -0.04905790090560913, 0.06039519980549812, 0.042900390923023224, -0.029503025114536285, 0.02249087393283844, 0.0704328790307045, 0.012586681172251701, 0.009079408831894398, 0.009531035088002682, 0.0013732730876654387, -0.005522980820387602, 0.05089987814426422, -0.0007233059732243419, 0.02431481145322323, -0.0019101815996691585, 0.004514455795288086, 0.03196442127227783, 0.009942641481757164, 0.002015369012951851, -0.02518909052014351, 0.0297645702958107, 0.013686208985745907, -0.011590695008635521, 0.007775754667818546, -0.04830396547913551, 0.004665502347052097, -0.0016616309294477105, -0.023467546328902245, 0.028451383113861084, -0.028563516214489937, 0.03941108286380768, 0.02420789562165737, -0.035369496792554855, 0.035985317081213, 0.07672513276338577, -0.023201288655400276, -0.01725233905017376, 0.036836039274930954, -0.04988829046487808, -0.018974963575601578, -0.008739790879189968, 0.001512965769506991, -0.05531802028417587, 0.026525326073169708, 0.04617947340011597, -0.03630475699901581, 0.011723884381353855, -0.011377491988241673, -0.014278626069426537, 0.028679925948381424, -0.015333562158048153, 0.05083745718002319, -0.008797011338174343, -0.08156520873308182, 0.0004768938524648547, -0.018242480233311653, -0.05349135026335716, 0.0238774623721838, 0.017961055040359497, -0.035362742841243744, 0.014697074890136719, -0.045565683394670486, -0.07166163623332977, -0.044790904968976974, -0.04810825735330582, -0.00809454545378685, 0.022195931524038315, -0.0026267936918884516, 0.04630908742547035, -0.00110345589928329, -0.05695389583706856, -0.011519523337483406, -0.012206226587295532, -0.02199544571340084, -0.012073257938027382, -0.04951297491788864, 0.014980463311076164, -0.03854401409626007, 0.03750956058502197, 0.035548578947782516, -0.01682077907025814, -0.0017196013359352946, -0.059213150292634964, -0.03245130181312561, 0.03407495468854904, 0.009544718079268932, 0.027469351887702942, 0.0317559689283371, 0.0015463418094441295, 0.10478869080543518, 0.020208414644002914, -0.023736396804451942, -0.03220305219292641, -0.018589017912745476, -0.04281485080718994, -0.014915761537849903, -0.013322313316166401, 0.01602051593363285, 0.04041609540581703, 0.044192224740982056, -0.014069191180169582, 0.012162504717707634, 0.037306517362594604, 0.0004766605270560831, -0.025105157867074013, 0.02611096017062664, -0.04163871333003044, -0.021233757957816124, 0.04912392795085907, 0.03017297200858593, -0.031002620235085487, -0.007786893751472235, -0.021687639877200127, -0.003388897283002734, 0.010154162533581257, -0.015713032335042953, 0.007697856053709984, -0.06796805560588837, 0.031288690865039825, -0.04545524716377258, 0.009808264672756195, 0.008273649029433727, -0.015644032508134842, -0.011759527027606964, 0.009879645891487598, 0.043516404926776886, -0.03803960978984833, 0.001823080936446786, 0.02443617396056652, 0.023273693397641182, 0.021291173994541168, -0.02128482051193714, -0.0003338098176755011, -0.008597752079367638, 0.004322370979934931, 0.006307687144726515, -0.012731482274830341, 0.06275853514671326, 0.012314504943788052, -0.006031322292983532, 0.004757467657327652, -0.015382958576083183, 0.01177190151065588, -0.0398583710193634, -0.015701526775956154, -0.003858063602820039, 0.04472482576966286, 0.020038548856973648, 0.014392927289009094, 0.021808817982673645, -0.03422369435429573, 0.00900642853230238, 0.029956381767988205, -0.04294281080365181, 0.02420400269329548, -0.007593619637191296, -0.015921179205179214, -0.006599665619432926, -0.010574460960924625, 0.03327999636530876, -0.04788074269890785, 0.01942693255841732, 0.0013391139218583703, 0.028797555714845657, -0.04971868917346001, -0.0056648338213562965, 0.013853532262146473, -0.023378968238830566, -0.02736278809607029, -0.0007437588064931333, 0.023572159931063652, -0.005720835644751787, 0.0615188404917717, 0.000747840793337673, -0.016297051683068275, -0.009768553078174591, -0.04236308112740517, 0.017316682264208794, 0.0039151995442807674, 0.03707073628902435, 0.046147171407938004, 0.02731158584356308, -0.042416106909513474, 0.03819548711180687, 0.030675675719976425, 0.05131902918219566, 0.04315748065710068, 0.0028672285843640566, -0.013805837370455265, -0.018754001706838608, -0.04328443482518196, 0.007538266479969025, 0.00869953166693449, -0.00038056180346757174, 0.015058990567922592, 0.030224956572055817, -0.0035789033863693476, -0.04195993021130562, -0.015069594606757164, 0.07622172683477402, -0.0034737936221063137, 0.0055037797428667545, -0.04428708553314209, 0.007627029903233051, 0.005045945756137371, 0.00020652322564274073, 0.00004450267078937031, 0.009443627670407295, -0.021711723878979683, -0.017528105527162552, 0.058708466589450836, -0.028542175889015198, -0.05833365023136139, -0.00848944578319788, 0.009353403002023697, 0.041672948747873306, 0.005712020676583052, 0.010096525773406029, 0.0035844675730913877, 0.027510255575180054, 0.01660265028476715, 0.021010298281908035, 0.016011269763112068, -0.11204179376363754, -0.009079868905246258, 0.07286303490400314, 0.022621314972639084, -0.01659214310348034, -0.02639137953519821, -0.062479909509420395, -0.008245362900197506, 0.07033953815698624, -0.03382084146142006, 0.018183330073952675, 0.00876985676586628, 0.004324287176132202, -0.011930826120078564, -0.0077833142131567, -0.05055413022637367, 0.012346185743808746, -0.02874290570616722, 0.03290737420320511, -0.023988524451851845, -0.008647915907204151, -0.016206709668040276, -0.015200295485556126, 0.02319313772022724, 0.08785292506217957, -0.022736627608537674, -0.01477977354079485, -0.011816088110208511, 0.018451984971761703, -0.00537835294380784, -0.0430414192378521, -0.023369239643216133, -0.004038575571030378, -0.0008919303072616458, 0.06055914983153343, -0.007134940940886736, -0.035376254469156265, 0.03264462575316429, -0.006891649682074785, -0.025096261873841286, -0.015555051155388355, -0.04012499749660492, 0.009595553390681744, 0.002812744118273258, -0.013412266038358212, 0.04479353129863739, 0.030890727415680885, 0.046200647950172424, -0.011263114400207996, -0.04454042389988899, 0.028451818972826004, -0.030409669503569603, -0.006520519498735666, -0.005844948347657919, -0.01891167275607586, 0.0019433501875028014, 0.00603489251807332, 0.03386712819337845, 0.0501498319208622, 0.011379252187907696, -0.008426850661635399, 0.013630569912493229, 0.001944484538398683, -0.015600396320223808, -0.02374476194381714, -0.008718346245586872, 0.01827978901565075, -0.0342387855052948, -0.012118987739086151, -0.03871532157063484, 0.02374822460114956, 0.03691764920949936, 0.03728479892015457, -0.0807270035147667, 0.04690193384885788, -0.0061979894526302814, -0.005907428916543722, 0.005688454955816269, -0.049218256026506424, 0.03928330913186073, -0.009536887519061565, 0.02111516334116459, -0.011152699589729309, -0.018855752423405647, -0.007201093249022961, -0.012215380556881428, -0.01936333067715168, 0.03890819475054741, -0.02323559671640396, -0.0018084499752148986, 0.028553590178489685, -0.042231690138578415, -0.06719890236854553, -0.05514846742153168, 0.0020524575375020504, 0.00112327397800982, -0.016958294436335564, -0.0228878203779459, -0.004053821321576834, 0.012802292592823505, -0.02156245708465576, 0.022026387974619865, 0.04580336809158325, -0.018597358837723732, -0.0004386877117212862, 0.004304228816181421, -0.02587018348276615, 0.04718805477023125, 0.00413028197363019, 0.029398897662758827, 0.025256002321839333, -0.002477629343047738, -0.07447870075702667, 0.06449814140796661, 0.006077333819121122, -0.03378092870116234, -0.007172171957790852, -0.038502730429172516, 0.02785196155309677, 0.05364174768328667, 0.013226065784692764, -0.004282706882804632, 0.0006458558491431177, -0.020408758893609047, 0.005020710173994303, -0.026449719443917274, 0.007468003313988447, 0.005192622542381287, -0.04425949603319168, -0.0035946837160736322, -0.024659913033246994, -0.036466244608163834, -0.0241041649132967, 0.03565780818462372, 0.0012431355426087976, -0.019974704831838608, -0.004484224133193493, 0.07613291591405869, 0.0015593288699164987, -0.006550587713718414, 0.028165243566036224, -0.026619018986821175, -0.018194302916526794, -0.0001565447892062366, 0.016141504049301147, 0.011119329370558262, 0.011399638839066029, -0.05844544991850853, -0.026305118575692177, -0.023094570264220238, -0.0340883769094944, 0.03213205188512802, 0.02439483441412449, 0.064641572535038, 0.006581038236618042, 0.019428372383117676, -0.0059664323925971985, -0.008853993378579617, -0.0616326704621315, 0.0020233856048434973, -0.0063918111845850945, 0.026674583554267883, -0.02620035596191883, 0.021087830886244774, 0.00552948797121644, 0.023546891286969185, 0.03451792150735855, 0.06441944092512131, 0.025905204936861992, 0.02324526570737362, 0.04697609320282936, 0.006783914752304554, -0.012418881058692932, 0.008874054998159409, -0.017588617280125618, -0.013901014812290668, 0.006152155343443155, 0.0067010121420025826, 0.03974026441574097, 0.00031260051764547825, 0.024361392483115196, -0.03758779540657997, -0.04010024294257164, -0.04951876774430275, 0.011934210546314716, 0.024701975286006927, -0.009800991974771023, 0.030816590413451195, 0.04534871131181717, 0.02687283419072628, -0.00765847647562623, 0.041611772030591965, -0.043402694165706635, -0.07405473291873932, -0.032662082463502884, -0.06315498054027557, -0.03209030628204346, 0.02869543991982937, 0.01802101917564869, -0.032308369874954224, 0.015596631914377213, -0.03206038475036621, 0.03044792450964451, 0.004312812350690365, 0.0385112464427948, 0.006778544280678034, 0.03357069939374924, 0.02740163542330265, 0.029868295416235924, 0.004468850325793028, -0.0010296378750354052, 0.13906794786453247, 0.08653805404901505, 0.026293424889445305, -0.026584552600979805, -0.03150581195950508, -0.013396624475717545, 0.0077394889667630196, -0.020562710240483284, 0.02014809474349022, -0.024930933490395546, -0.028021275997161865, 0.01845596171915531, -0.019227495416998863, 0.030591947957873344, 0.013173849321901798, 0.04414859041571617, -0.0033050437923520803, 0.01243174821138382, -0.00004481902942643501, 0.011016057804226875, 0.037110038101673126, -0.009767789393663406, -0.03541944548487663, 0.03268716111779213, -0.0025752659421414137, -0.0342492014169693, -0.029924385249614716, -0.021526144817471504, 0.02032705955207348, 0.006701623555272818, 0.018184121698141098, 0.014656727202236652, 0.024544652551412582, 0.024288112297654152, 0.02476196549832821, -0.017893582582473755, 0.028649121522903442, 0.014232860878109932, 0.010136340744793415, 0.017101671546697617, 0.017081495374441147, 0.004172132350504398, -0.011714337393641472, 0.0068008676171302795, -0.082124724984169, -0.00615069130435586, -0.02409263513982296, 0.022945549339056015, 0.020339852198958397, 0.011229737661778927, -0.00817678589373827, -0.04205874726176262, -0.03064538910984993, -0.06870265305042267, -0.04161284118890762, 0.006016332656145096, 0.004383543971925974, -0.004903862252831459, -0.06299146264791489, -0.03221029415726662, 0.03076547384262085, -0.03212764114141464, -0.006731924135237932, 0.024995937943458557, -0.03807932883501053, -0.009934969246387482, -0.0019071615533903241, 0.00614687567576766, -0.005879966076463461, -0.005726824048906565, 0.020795339718461037, -0.020739290863275528, -0.012610777281224728, -0.01618039608001709, 0.001332536805421114, 0.008581090718507767, 0.02752554416656494, -0.007779351901262999, -0.004771071951836348, -0.01491555292159319, -0.07323348522186279, -0.012530424632132053, -0.07418391108512878, -0.005562424659729004, -0.02164975181221962, 0.04674968868494034, 0.001530143665149808, 0.018686270341277122, -0.02953457459807396, 0.0023954538628458977, 0.027174251154065132, 0.029640045017004013, 0.031326260417699814, -0.048006605356931686, -0.020351789891719818, 0.009766400791704655, -0.05585774779319763, 0.02820715308189392, 0.027647241950035095, 0.059945087879896164, 0.03237103298306465, 0.004981847479939461, -0.0197211392223835, -0.01405236218124628, 0.03006189689040184, 0.011167151853442192, -0.05517664551734924, -0.02851244807243347, -0.016827575862407684, -0.016729263588786125, -0.010319739580154419, -0.0440991036593914, -0.032456640154123306, -0.03594249114394188, -0.029884343966841698, 0.0040345145389437675, 0.040309954434633255, -0.03232957050204277, -0.0015470798825845122, 0.025945991277694702, 0.014592116698622704, -0.029896965250372887, -0.011256328783929348, -0.0038172753993421793, -0.004297375679016113, -0.026914479210972786, -0.04452565684914589, 0.008094877935945988, -0.006693558301776648, -0.007430476602166891, 0.010484166443347931, 0.05484922230243683, -0.0015118906740099192, 0.025555459782481194, -0.004591922741383314, 0.015206052921712399, -0.02030245214700699, 0.05271589756011963, -0.05514366924762726, -0.01873200759291649, 0.022190313786268234, -0.04819503054022789, -0.049036066979169846, 0.043497804552316666, 0.03404207155108452, 0.046543706208467484, 0.012335103005170822, 0.0009401225834153593, 0.011287473142147064, 0.045063987374305725, -0.04309898614883423, 0.022839577868580818, -0.009270943701267242, -0.0007621930562891066, -0.005992361344397068, 0.034229472279548645, 0.03140391781926155, -0.0007615952054038644, -0.008090103045105934, 0.018595630303025246, 0.02072759158909321, -0.008086706511676311, -0.01254804152995348, 0.01179336104542017, -0.00039293812005780637, 0.01002540159970522, 0.011040844954550266, -0.004298138432204723, 0.037761393934488297, 0.0016576854977756739, -0.025831658393144608, 0.019725631922483444, 0.0014481265097856522, 0.009643875993788242, -0.06192551180720329, -0.02896570973098278, -0.017682839184999466, 0.01912558823823929, 0.03024161234498024, -0.043278828263282776, 0.029874557629227638, 0.04870426654815674, -0.017678281292319298, -0.009085999801754951, 0.014268429949879646, -0.0008424162515439093, -0.05069926753640175, 0.0021429385524243116, -0.0395052433013916, -0.001168020535260439, 0.01924353465437889, 0.02804284170269966, 0.029987841844558716, 0.038468264043331146, -0.052527956664562225, -0.02873857691884041, -0.04303358867764473, 0.031243599951267242, -0.016059208661317825, -0.03239792585372925, 0.022555379197001457, -0.04225564002990723, -0.008624730631709099, 0.04793825373053551, -0.039019566029310226, 0.01469799317419529, 0.07904122769832611, 0.05008042976260185, 0.0008863285765983164, 0.06061571463942528, 0.022045942023396492, -0.02578022889792919, -0.014308859594166279, 0.021347282454371452, 0.01952480711042881, 0.023671356961131096, -0.02203219011425972, -0.0034692075569182634, 0.010364994406700134, -0.02777934819459915, -0.0010758900316432118, 0.08484870940446854, -0.015137597918510437, 0.0013116002082824707, -0.03400015830993652, 0.012369407340884209, -0.018649913370609283, -0.028288455680012703, 0.02444371022284031, -0.04041241854429245, -0.014936881139874458, -0.005863674916327, -0.009113369509577751, -0.05056897923350334, -0.0018577446462586522, -0.0012042497983202338, -0.04387433081865311, 0.011332079768180847, -0.012675338424742222, -0.029207594692707062, -0.04442315921187401, -0.004496682435274124, 0.010817171074450016, 0.006445386912673712, 0.0008126930915750563, -0.03651374205946922, -0.0457959920167923, 0.07124532014131546, 0.0027602422051131725, 0.021781308576464653, 0.04784323647618294, 0.00998297892510891, -0.025575701147317886, -0.1018017902970314, 0.044608958065509796, 0.019270621240139008, -0.018402909860014915, -0.006125794257968664, 0.01132888998836279, -0.031020116060972214, -0.0033287552651017904, 0.05849025398492813, 0.000004127698502998101, 0.001870436710305512, -0.01712210476398468, 0.004213760606944561, 0.018196625635027885, -0.043227363377809525, 0.01166504342108965, -0.011149369180202484, 0.0026346538215875626, -0.000831018085591495, -0.025322819128632545, 0.011621523648500443, 0.016536779701709747, 0.007106534671038389, -0.013815934769809246, -0.018719002604484558, -0.014177346602082253, -0.028026867657899857, 0.022699065506458282, 0.03449637442827225, 0.024152955040335655, 0.06814303249120712, 0.030659623444080353, -0.014375641942024231, 0.015781622380018234, 0.033788617700338364, -0.03778499737381935, 0.016127320006489754, 0.01270817406475544, -0.04043649137020111, -0.008853198029100895, 0.02546069771051407, 0.02308666706085205, -0.0456889383494854, -0.046939872205257416, 0.03791305795311928, -0.020883994176983833, 0.027429882436990738, 0.06282469630241394, 0.005137773230671883, 0.048213742673397064, 0.013975348323583603, 0.006133546121418476, 0.011090507730841637, 0.0007129994337446988, 0.031234152615070343, 0.03893594071269035, 0.02189931832253933, -0.010241192765533924, 0.040536679327487946, 0.06086699292063713, -0.02596626803278923, 0.02371278405189514, 0.01357771921902895, 0.0510752908885479, -0.035535458475351334, 0.006892335135489702, 0.004987764172255993, 0.030978664755821228, 0.038694072514772415, -0.001646886463277042, -0.042079076170921326, 0.06148320436477661, -0.031356681138277054, -0.03355877101421356, -0.11434881389141083, -0.013563270680606365, -0.010488051921129227, 0.010369614697992802, 0.04288261756300926, 0.03430091589689255, 0.01612762361764908, 0.016912583261728287, -0.0037767961621284485, 0.009710191749036312, 0.03434621915221214, -0.05113754794001579, 0.006228653248399496, -0.046453963965177536, 0.02536877617239952, -0.0012035962427034974, 0.012911592610180378, -0.007873228751122952, -0.01889513060450554, -0.024670762941241264, 0.04886966943740845, 0.07310173660516739, 0.004245060496032238, -0.044218774884939194, -0.008726270869374275, 0.023193221539258957, -0.04380887746810913, -0.019661536440253258, -0.02727028913795948, 0.01988157071173191, 0.01646159216761589, -0.02713395096361637 ]
<p>(Ross [2009], p.162) The current in a semiconductor diode is often measured by the Shockley equation I = I0(e^aV-1) where V is the voltage across the diode; I0 is the reverse current; a is a constant; and I is the resulting diode current. Find E(I ) if a = 5, I0= 10^-6 , and V is uniformly distributed over [1; 3]. Answer <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IZYkC.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>my question is: how "1/2" is calculated ??? E[x]= (a+b)/2 thats mean (1+3)/2 =2 not 1/2 I need help please thanks in advance</p>
74,231
[ 0.017381910234689713, -0.01519833318889141, 0.012340085580945015, -0.0010546906851232052, 0.02216188795864582, -0.018717274069786072, -0.0009678396745584905, 0.00799059122800827, -0.0158898513764143, -0.008463941514492035, 0.056216899305582047, 0.029710078611969948, 0.045912135392427444, 0.0330185703933239, 0.0058273980394005775, 0.03867269307374954, -0.005292891524732113, 0.008768454194068909, -0.018252840265631676, -0.0038299106527119875, -0.011705881915986538, -0.010484603233635426, -0.015994245186448097, 0.006359336897730827, -0.0501943975687027, 0.040147196501493454, 0.032296933233737946, -0.007843226194381714, 0.013497158885002136, 0.05648644641041756, 0.006542467977851629, -0.07308488339185715, 0.040763504803180695, 0.013655431568622589, 0.03671381622552872, 0.02718779258430004, 0.007869625464081764, -0.046551186591386795, -0.011949878185987473, 0.05785408988595009, 0.008507935330271721, 0.027565382421016693, -0.019447006285190582, -0.008918195962905884, -0.0020666623022407293, 0.012074709869921207, -0.01726456545293331, -0.024442033842206, 0.01793747954070568, -0.06338512152433395, 0.0886644721031189, -0.010427298955619335, 0.04580477252602577, 0.014434386976063251, -0.007310032844543457, -0.003217092016711831, 0.05149458348751068, 0.04942427575588226, 0.024771440774202347, -0.031277112662792206, 0.004865953698754311, -0.018994469195604324, -0.03120812028646469, 0.008531219325959682, -0.018269140273332596, -0.014222441241145134, -0.0032349422108381987, -0.03785582631826401, 0.016744131222367287, -0.003638905007392168, 0.02973300591111183, 0.025414761155843735, 0.0050039454363286495, -0.04481754079461098, 0.024201663210988045, -0.029204748570919037, 0.003498260397464037, 0.009075561538338661, 0.04564698413014412, 0.02954513020813465, -0.021417366340756416, 0.002950385445728898, 0.04916975647211075, 0.06755627691745758, 0.03999568149447441, -0.03313375264406204, 0.09262207895517349, -0.008193395100533962, 0.015286620706319809, -0.007592180743813515, 0.005374025087803602, 0.053565774112939835, 0.01754899136722088, -0.012175203301012516, -0.02510509453713894, 0.051448628306388855, -0.013706118799746037, 0.05016106739640236, -0.020901905372738838, -0.001868321793153882, -0.01691322587430477, -0.02690265327692032, 0.02562233805656433, 0.03733063116669655, -0.05088000372052193, -0.010601570829749107, -0.03473663702607155, 0.006885759066790342, -0.0061567360535264015, 0.002714358037337661, -0.025044988840818405, 0.011243627406656742, 0.03457057103514671, 0.020846759900450706, 0.030807947739958763, -0.017846427857875824, 0.011447068303823471, -0.004767305683344603, 0.021420368924736977, 0.023109812289476395, 0.006330524105578661, -0.018007567152380943, 0.02319995127618313, -0.01153573114424944, -0.04400172084569931, 0.038157712668180466, 0.011814123019576073, 0.02236437425017357, -0.06213613599538803, 0.061322521418333054, 0.017272142693400383, -0.018244272097945213, 0.03652302920818329, 0.02870819717645645, 0.02144348807632923, -0.02419259212911129, -0.04682666435837746, -0.07907386869192123, 0.021489495411515236, -0.020498858764767647, -0.01916341297328472, -0.07791371643543243, 0.0029358994215726852, 0.033416472375392914, 0.04366913065314293, 0.012081886641681194, 0.0489322766661644, -0.01417406927794218, 0.008116820827126503, -0.015158814378082752, -0.01931534893810749, -0.0552971214056015, -0.019949480891227722, -0.02172098681330681, 0.030414633452892303, -0.024102168157696724, 0.02987908199429512, -0.010873549617826939, -0.04265465959906578, -0.02501721680164337, 0.054547280073165894, -0.000994080794043839, 0.010551013052463531, 0.011285258457064629, -0.01181468553841114, -0.010928746312856674, 0.07882252335548401, -0.0021017729304730892, -0.021741917356848717, 0.017113974317908287, -0.01404427457600832, 0.002787719015032053, -0.03971468284726143, 0.01113251131027937, 0.04884357005357742, -0.06160176545381546, -0.03473930433392525, -0.032257694751024246, 0.008545821532607079, 0.03577591851353645, -0.05864885076880455, -0.0499972440302372, 0.03434562310576439, -0.00786832720041275, 0.03295755758881569, 0.010106989182531834, -0.008661308325827122, -0.0024575642310082912, 0.013042042031884193, -0.01463694404810667, -0.025131288915872574, -0.047995857894420624, 0.01951957866549492, 0.0028800400905311108, -0.027197694405913353, 0.001578994677402079, -0.0416564866900444, 0.053391534835100174, 0.006298347841948271, 0.03268539160490036, 0.01445089466869831, -0.014456530101597309, 0.03384251892566681, -0.03843998908996582, 0.0002914093201979995, 0.0325380377471447, 0.041136812418699265, 0.003832785412669182, 0.04744213446974754, -0.012708248570561409, -0.02212931215763092, -0.007583795115351677, -0.04633133485913277, 0.036557652056217194, 0.03972335532307625, -0.030266093090176582, 0.025790205225348473, -0.014093034900724888, -0.0005676081054843962, 0.04224404692649841, -0.010075599886476994, 0.07615705579519272, 0.08672266453504562, 0.056075114756822586, 0.006968475878238678, 0.012154771015048027, -0.009613320231437683, 0.012600839138031006, -0.01803046278655529, -0.08131401985883713, -0.05133339390158653, 0.01774228923022747, 0.010897662490606308, 0.00488700158894062, -0.01626214012503624, -0.0030575385317206383, 0.07408755272626877, -0.042532648891210556, 0.006156695540994406, 0.05451350659132004, -0.00998359452933073, 0.002299781423062086, 0.03762127086520195, 0.009456281550228596, 0.023025745525956154, 0.0160974208265543, 0.014397614635527134, 0.00989048182964325, 0.04001294821500778, 0.017446288838982582, -0.027842799201607704, 0.0417548269033432, -0.002145808655768633, 0.06020112708210945, -0.01617981307208538, 0.01045695599168539, 0.022141151130199432, -0.02176022343337536, 0.015253642573952675, 0.01221397053450346, -0.0029706128407269716, -0.009947524406015873, 0.011204327456653118, -0.031532201915979385, 0.02098623663187027, 0.018777286633849144, -0.017950136214494705, -0.026885664090514183, 0.027514366433024406, 0.0033715306781232357, 0.014546613208949566, -0.021266989409923553, -0.0061350916512310505, -0.01375417411327362, -0.04072731360793114, 0.054979149252176285, -0.0022788597270846367, -0.010766367428004742, -0.03553738817572594, 0.022639796137809753, -0.01548417005687952, -0.05147373303771019, 0.04070957750082016, 0.005260099191218615, -0.017362678423523903, 0.02227506786584854, -0.005584808997809887, -0.012252886779606342, 0.010088788345456123, -0.007512890268117189, -0.00874718464910984, 0.026747100055217743, 0.023377561941742897, -0.06959184259176254, 0.00555016752332449, -0.020831763744354248, 0.022546308115124702, -0.04504338651895523, -0.010002581402659416, 0.04988786205649376, -0.00672483816742897, -0.028480006381869316, 0.04908248037099838, -0.057012442499399185, -0.03500252589583397, -0.010657214559614658, -0.05902784690260887, 0.03121419996023178, -0.01599976234138012, 0.05441902205348015, 0.007259952370077372, -0.0025976879987865686, -0.011767931282520294, -0.06477028131484985, -0.052090562880039215, 0.003360897535458207, -0.0011534986551851034, 0.013199461624026299, 0.033317241817712784, -0.03899023309350014, 0.06225285306572914, 0.010349086485803127, -0.02581925503909588, -0.009013895876705647, -0.0024205450899899006, 0.0021843230351805687, -0.02404472418129444, 0.03540787473320961, 0.06813079863786697, -0.024327341467142105, -0.008728290908038616, -0.0412122942507267, 0.06416863948106766, 0.053026553243398666, -0.032918866723775864, -0.03543848544359207, 0.03427263721823692, -0.021492933854460716, 0.01566712185740471, 0.06561408191919327, 0.0027857653331011534, -0.037075482308864594, -0.005763760767877102, -0.013361189514398575, 0.024955496191978455, 0.027537135407328606, -0.036770228296518326, 0.006120801903307438, -0.04080536216497421, 0.02239217609167099, -0.03887385129928589, 0.019067276269197464, 0.003475269302725792, -0.023734746500849724, 0.03321819007396698, -0.006073831580579281, 0.05649932473897934, -0.045202601701021194, -0.03507009893655777, 0.015939153730869293, 0.03430163115262985, -0.013090899214148521, -0.027133287861943245, -0.022100189700722694, 0.02836926281452179, -0.0046780467964708805, -0.0544314980506897, -0.021761758252978325, 0.03862274810671806, 0.05685373768210411, -0.01169109158217907, -0.011611156165599823, -0.0617561936378479, -0.03124730847775936, -0.03493822365999222, -0.052269868552684784, -0.012163319624960423, 0.07242768257856369, 0.01572495885193348, 0.030705945566296577, 0.007784407120198011, 0.022036124020814896, 0.029928866773843765, -0.007739182561635971, -0.07848820835351944, 0.0029259170405566692, 0.0020544009748846292, -0.03013673983514309, -0.04785182327032089, -0.007366096135228872, 0.02926509641110897, 0.004538604523986578, 0.01981481723487377, -0.003600251628085971, 0.014460651203989983, -0.04129539430141449, 0.020348165184259415, 0.01772479899227619, 0.007431681267917156, -0.03847581893205643, -0.00854889303445816, 0.020276635885238647, -0.0523238331079483, 0.025070201605558395, 0.020558558404445648, -0.009103660471737385, -0.014144983142614365, -0.019924376159906387, 0.0037418953143060207, 0.0353412926197052, 0.04975661635398865, 0.024042677134275436, 0.000874532270245254, -0.002224171767011285, 0.025878146290779114, 0.004332817625254393, 0.08860795199871063, 0.03623037040233612, -0.020064882934093475, -0.03549695387482643, -0.01842387020587921, -0.029702389612793922, -0.0041587320156395435, 0.036982212215662, -0.005963983945548534, 0.049788519740104675, 0.04011596366763115, 0.03141280636191368, -0.006058658007532358, 0.020297536626458168, 0.05584434047341347, -0.023328058421611786, -0.009611415676772594, -0.03853472322225571, 0.00394956162199378, -0.019428061321377754, -0.011860376223921776, 0.017055487260222435, -0.010844829492270947, -0.021785451099276543, 0.002498128218576312, 0.07552425563335419, 0.02974424511194229, -0.018294041976332664, -0.004601519554853439, -0.0032511011231690645, 0.017338747158646584, 0.008933515287935734, -0.050296682864427567, -0.0039641461335122585, -0.0034071425907313824, 0.02008974179625511, -0.018902458250522614, 0.007638297509402037, -0.06444542109966278, -0.009594389237463474, 0.01585949771106243, 0.049358051270246506, -0.031176501885056496, -0.005847921594977379, -0.07366394996643066, 0.020025204867124557, 0.007425779476761818, -0.025374196469783783, -0.014742957428097725, -0.028831642121076584, 0.009933441877365112, -0.004063690081238747, -0.022324221208691597, -0.03694073483347893, 0.021715497598052025, -0.0007815734716132283, 0.029979726299643517, -0.0034861431922763586, -0.031058592721819878, -0.027698220685124397, -0.020488763228058815, 0.03197287395596504, 0.07975712418556213, -0.05082262307405472, 0.02655951678752899, 0.023351017385721207, 0.03443507105112076, -0.03360782191157341, -0.05579502880573273, -0.010028190910816193, -0.016327321529388428, 0.04262566193938255, 0.048818595707416534, -0.03760629519820213, -0.06700878590345383, 0.02623673528432846, 0.04033121466636658, 0.03154144063591957, 0.0010029046097770333, -0.0032014206517487764, 0.05919117107987404, 0.02774921990931034, -0.022658970206975937, 0.06264834851026535, 0.0513082779943943, -0.008871166966855526, -0.012849630787968636, -0.015707412734627724, 0.012900092639029026, -0.031000033020973206, -0.010775730945169926, -0.005904535297304392, 0.009204144589602947, -0.01633543334901333, 0.019119814038276672, -0.017183955758810043, 0.04717664793133736, 0.0034009248483926058, -0.036560140550136566, 0.04746805876493454, 0.02111799083650112, 0.004617350175976753, 0.007495601195842028, -0.0392325259745121, 0.038638416677713394, -0.004212082829326391, -0.048823803663253784, 0.038956236094236374, 0.04124581068754196, 0.021366897970438004, -0.02149229124188423, -0.02738117054104805, 0.028153805062174797, -0.04178276285529137, -0.02263455092906952, 0.04561423137784004, -0.04452134296298027, 0.047938913106918335, -0.019263507798314095, 0.004462764598429203, 0.012952256947755814, 0.006658182479441166, -0.015958907082676888, 0.010994723066687584, -0.01219145581126213, 0.019115103408694267, -0.03222523629665375, 0.01821536011993885, 0.012423966079950333, -0.0007228277390822768, -0.09485585987567902, -0.04066774249076843, 0.04493264481425285, -0.0012094865087419748, -0.016272500157356262, -0.010082081891596317, -0.04555969312787056, 0.01757265441119671, -0.025287508964538574, 0.027614304795861244, 0.015198199078440666, 0.03472502529621124, -0.030748913064599037, 0.010822835378348827, 0.04384380578994751, 0.0475459061563015, 0.014674241654574871, -0.012759719043970108, 0.019836517050862312, -0.02270122617483139, -0.027203697711229324, 0.01761021837592125, 0.06345006078481674, -0.03655219078063965, 0.006757895462214947, 0.024082139134407043, 0.0008277493761852384, 0.0055065094493329525, -0.030260244384407997, -0.02397230826318264, 0.022435083985328674, 0.017359409481287003, 0.013149730861186981, -0.03981579467654228, -0.014677617698907852, -0.005764297675341368, 0.012920667417347431, 0.010827209800481796, -0.00949093047529459, -0.07766956090927124, 0.004087057430297136, 0.008316770195960999, 0.02774064429104328, 0.011531546711921692, 0.007414746098220348, 0.05089059844613075, 0.001472253119572997, 0.02339909039437771, 0.07201485335826874, -0.009845922701060772, 0.012190781533718109, -0.008546009659767151, 0.006882709916681051, 0.025645382702350616, -0.005115932784974575, -0.02753913775086403, -0.01183379627764225, -0.06919360160827637, 0.03080456517636776, 0.05674710497260094, -0.00006093786214478314, 0.060167886316776276, 0.02374023012816906, 0.016665510833263397, 0.003259485587477684, 0.00036184833152219653, -0.004376259166747332, -0.04363544285297394, -0.006217063404619694, 0.008252771571278572, -0.04514675959944725, -0.0008818267961032689, 0.020228279754519463, 0.027717851102352142, -0.0017425533151254058, 0.037782736122608185, 0.027894599363207817, 0.001270654727704823, 0.031616877764463425, -0.011605383828282356, -0.0006782783893868327, -0.0008444298291578889, 0.019263053312897682, 0.020482052117586136, -0.0020408397540450096, -0.03992999717593193, 0.06327000260353088, 0.014982289634644985, -0.022433023899793625, -0.060626957565546036, -0.04017557203769684, -0.03430381417274475, -0.0040432363748550415, 0.026225456967949867, -0.01449200976639986, 0.025297407060861588, 0.04238376021385193, -0.03799553960561752, -0.016064200550317764, 0.039214685559272766, -0.05438400059938431, -0.0518808588385582, 0.032126594334840775, -0.03692610561847687, -0.028989514335989952, 0.006348798517137766, 0.01823963224887848, -0.02114630863070488, -0.0026052407920360565, -0.03319171816110611, 0.01350705511868, 0.0413084514439106, 0.023163121193647385, 0.02033580280840397, 0.09401778131723404, -0.005157211795449257, 0.03390811011195183, -0.038697171956300735, 0.03210842236876488, 0.1242791935801506, 0.05151329189538956, 0.025519972667098045, -0.0563541017472744, -0.027021542191505432, -0.029613487422466278, 0.009663895703852177, -0.019185401499271393, 0.0053228819742798805, -0.023090897127985954, 0.005430043675005436, 0.030930574983358383, 0.028790390118956566, 0.022085577249526978, -0.016703564673662186, -0.0028162640519440174, -0.0061695571057498455, -0.05855823680758476, 0.028736134991049767, 0.016498858109116554, 0.007070854306221008, 0.013524218462407589, -0.058101460337638855, 0.028345908969640732, -0.018534190952777863, -0.010503051802515984, -0.04583146795630455, -0.0018904198659583926, 0.030686205253005028, 0.0322539396584034, -0.025112081319093704, 0.029515091329813004, 0.04224563017487526, -0.011699243448674679, 0.0017457040958106518, 0.02283416874706745, 0.049055445939302444, -0.008436823263764381, 0.006700634956359863, 0.012375404126942158, 0.030377401039004326, -0.002314819721505046, 0.010539249517023563, 0.02911967784166336, -0.015663811936974525, -0.03086833842098713, -0.03682805970311165, 0.06951186060905457, -0.007667960599064827, -0.033861804753541946, -0.013749832287430763, 0.016034772619605064, -0.015075123868882656, -0.06317202001810074, -0.004801360424607992, 0.007167238276451826, 0.004799353424459696, -0.036065153777599335, -0.04379042237997055, 0.005178671795874834, -0.010243755765259266, -0.011788835749030113, 0.010870436206459999, 0.005023590754717588, -0.038434501737356186, -0.025740815326571465, -0.023898867890238762, 0.025897027924656868, -0.037402912974357605, -0.03226176276803017, 0.003255356103181839, -0.01648029312491417, -0.039937686175107956, -0.03178214654326439, -0.009097738191485405, -0.0018079119035974145, 0.022564975544810295, 0.0072423964738845825, -0.03443523123860359, -0.012351102195680141, -0.05643637105822563, 0.051231637597084045, -0.004359474405646324, -0.014574367552995682, -0.04543657228350639, 0.007870243862271309, 0.021532759070396423, -0.008389533497393131, 0.02195265144109726, -0.02371724136173725, 0.017513344064354897, 0.037463534623384476, -0.006977725308388472, -0.020528193563222885, -0.010024745017290115, -0.009567569941282272, -0.020555831491947174, -0.009089045226573944, 0.03888005018234253, 0.0241551510989666, -0.0073644183576107025, 0.0046571060083806515, -0.05215413123369217, -0.0027194758877158165, -0.04553048685193062, 0.029434015974402428, -0.022810952737927437, -0.03903427720069885, 0.022728312760591507, 0.006084059365093708, -0.0011105570010840893, -0.032224301248788834, 0.0358130969107151, -0.014597823843359947, 0.014925654046237469, -0.010991319082677364, 0.018600065261125565, -0.012242910452187061, 0.010103071108460426, -0.03481915593147278, 0.005941992625594139, -0.0031457445584237576, -0.017956199124455452, 0.01788107119500637, -0.008199016563594341, -0.0024213972501456738, -0.007145218551158905, -0.01615029200911522, 0.021763140335679054, -0.014693492092192173, 0.00475838128477335, 0.05516098812222481, 0.06465364247560501, 0.0028191599994897842, 0.001685578259639442, 0.03868534415960312, -0.028748810291290283, 0.0439411960542202, -0.08226607739925385, -0.05917835235595703, 0.05140317231416702, -0.039823103696107864, 0.01983114704489708, 0.043532367795705795, 0.025263365358114243, 0.000042071493226103485, 0.029195310547947884, -0.02471025474369526, -0.04658561572432518, 0.047993339598178864, -0.03699438273906708, -0.031976912170648575, -0.013774230144917965, -0.058445293456315994, 0.02603624388575554, 0.007427327800542116, -0.044792093336582184, 0.005294651724398136, -0.010387709364295006, 0.030018461868166924, 0.013501015491783619, -0.011747275479137897, -0.02297821268439293, 0.03837837278842926, 0.01094102393835783, 0.02941746823489666, 0.04668530449271202, -0.028885409235954285, 0.02128666453063488, 0.0741199254989624, 0.005268035922199488, 0.039499085396528244, -0.04714756831526756, -0.019954191520810127, -0.048175640404224396, -0.038855500519275665, 0.013575288467109203, 0.035202424973249435, 0.024136250838637352, -0.02629331313073635, -0.028043894097208977, -0.011192884296178818, -0.017969954758882523, -0.009911607950925827, -0.00115451798774302, -0.05998757854104042, -0.053323231637477875, 0.020126130431890488, -0.01618482545018196, 0.031111614778637886, 0.01643184944987297, 0.015940845012664795, 0.042667824774980545, 0.022880079224705696, -0.017664197832345963, -0.05182758346199989, -0.0031506603118032217, 0.03635702282190323, -0.015092175453901291, -0.04193498194217682, 0.021676374599337578, -0.013864146545529366, 0.019019953906536102, 0.029447004199028015, -0.0012829108163714409, -0.026561234146356583, 0.007842231541872025, 0.00961885042488575, -0.019134454429149628, 0.054384101182222366, 0.03153982758522034, -0.024462267756462097, 0.010646148584783077, 0.011050542816519737, 0.012814330868422985, -0.015442942269146442, 0.045458320528268814, 0.017378738150000572, 0.0466826893389225, 0.0060064238496124744, -0.013476870954036713, 0.0330314002931118, 0.0031028427183628082, -0.048594556748867035, -0.0038380734622478485, -0.002222752897068858, 0.013064230792224407, -0.05985415354371071, 0.05025229603052139, -0.04722099378705025, -0.01703656278550625, 0.024484414607286453, 0.016749700531363487, -0.03177228197455406, -0.008965429849922657, 0.0137095982208848, -0.019326096400618553, 0.011110596358776093, 0.027841730043292046, -0.01732047274708748, -0.05702449753880501, -0.03185213729739189, 0.006638964172452688, -0.00728075485676527, 0.051539096981287, -0.053135257214307785, -0.022473804652690887, 0.024835998192429543, 0.014784569852054119, -0.017559228464961052, -0.010128882713615894, -0.03185201436281204, -0.015024812892079353, -0.047628771513700485, 0.06220576912164688, -0.026492709293961525, -0.03929293528199196, -0.04018757864832878, -0.01997499167919159, -0.03252691030502319, 0.018129786476492882, 0.05627107992768288, 0.01666818931698799, -0.033739011734724045, -0.00735651608556509, 0.008784311823546886, 0.018194636330008507, -0.060736995190382004, -0.02166927419602871, -0.014898925088346004, -0.04065142944455147, -0.030515355989336967, 0.003112104022875428, -0.01782316155731678, -0.020080914720892906, 0.013569130562245846, -0.01256678905338049, 0.020845619961619377, -0.03863048925995827, -0.03937371447682381, -0.006614746060222387, 0.01732650212943554, -0.003922659903764725, 0.09333203732967377, -0.03382109850645065, 0.026728233322501183, 0.014453005976974964, -0.01887192763388157, -0.0317860022187233, 0.004658871330320835, -0.044277820736169815, -0.02066851779818535, -0.008395951241254807, -0.023832427337765694, 0.08412005007266998, -0.040063437074422836, -0.03515215963125229, -0.012991765514016151, -0.02820008620619774, -0.015267951413989067, 0.04015053063631058, -0.011064951308071613, 0.015334909781813622, 0.0076148235239088535, 0.023252835497260094, 0.021263888105750084, 0.04763786122202873, -0.010522617027163506, 0.004007673356682062, 0.008676576428115368, -0.02177334949374199, -0.004141956102102995, 0.03782844543457031, -0.04396302253007889, 0.036532141268253326, -0.014401133172214031, -0.03355525806546211, 0.017551513388752937, -0.01808314211666584, 0.021406449377536774, -0.017397815361618996, 0.010237415321171284, 0.008889433927834034, -0.010277548804879189, 0.06409332156181335, -0.035383809357881546, 0.03904740512371063, -0.019765162840485573, -0.018723906949162483, -0.013901961967349052, 0.012270635925233364, 0.02015484683215618, -0.0030991530511528254, -0.0086466483771801, -0.006310579366981983, -0.016744622960686684, 0.00762495631352067, 0.02501302771270275, -0.04166949912905693, 0.016883330419659615, 0.010314898565411568, -0.024658091366291046, -0.00792562123388052, 0.015538554638624191, 0.005779441446065903, -0.02470717392861843, -0.001586027443408966, 0.0304994098842144, 0.0028699778486043215, 0.01523546688258648, -0.018791867420077324, 0.008593619801104069, 0.06731503456830978, -0.03006022796034813, -0.034428711980581284, -0.018835872411727905, 0.004089232999831438, -0.0007896997267380357, -0.02632146142423153 ]
<p>I was reading this <a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/1206.4762.pdf" rel="nofollow">article</a>, where the author says that Maximum Likelihood (ML) estimates are asymptotically normal if the log-likelihood is asymptotically quadratic.</p> <p>I have heard or read other times about the likelihood being asymptotically quadratic (under conditions), but I have never read any proof of this. Is anybody aware of such a proof?</p> <p>It would be great to see a proof that shows also the rate of convergence $(\sqrt{n}?)$ of the log-likelihood to a quadratic function.</p>
36,980
[ -0.046139299869537354, -0.02672095037996769, 0.019906966015696526, -0.025301117449998856, 0.015073108486831188, 0.01750415563583374, 0.010059451684355736, -0.005317811854183674, 0.02661811374127865, -0.06295676529407501, 0.05235625430941582, 0.03716978430747986, 0.07602772116661072, 0.04361387714743614, 0.023060550913214684, -0.022173108533024788, -0.029756959527730942, 0.019470257684588432, 0.0013219545362517238, -0.0016136254416778684, -0.008327590301632881, 0.06744813174009323, 0.033722635358572006, 0.0020613097585737705, -0.034206390380859375, 0.0015735817141830921, 0.023188358172774315, -0.018603883683681488, -0.006394438445568085, 0.09272503107786179, -0.044403139501810074, 0.026911651715636253, 0.02885613590478897, 0.0492633692920208, 0.028245504945516586, 0.01717335917055607, -0.014404875226318836, -0.020329264923930168, -0.002663610503077507, 0.030618654564023018, -0.018101360648870468, -0.02589484117925167, 0.0159926675260067, 0.04466117545962334, -0.0116614094004035, 0.03533477708697319, -0.018801581114530563, -0.03675242140889168, 0.028642911463975906, -0.039579156786203384, 0.09017270803451538, 0.022901561111211777, 0.018473196774721146, 0.04043066129088402, -0.018433578312397003, -0.004841811954975128, 0.06902339309453964, 0.08080300688743591, 0.01223861426115036, -0.05088915303349495, 0.010835668072104454, -0.057995837181806564, 0.02586354687809944, -0.01063155010342598, -0.01445569097995758, 0.03718176484107971, -0.02149628847837448, -0.02271958440542221, 0.036344535648822784, -0.047634758055210114, -0.028416715562343597, 0.02211291529238224, 0.05958212912082672, -0.0009969486854970455, -0.030036011710762978, -0.014935602433979511, 0.0019162975950166583, 0.017488645389676094, 0.016937756910920143, 0.0020045002456754446, 0.023118147626519203, 0.023161161690950394, 0.01680072210729122, 0.030205899849534035, 0.007456787396222353, 0.014142096042633057, 0.06654384732246399, -0.03599192574620247, 0.02606183849275112, 0.04133187606930733, -0.02151174657046795, 0.02137826383113861, 0.04165684059262276, -0.026936914771795273, -0.06838048249483109, 0.043073832988739014, -0.02340429276227951, 0.024964917451143265, 0.0409807451069355, -0.01298479549586773, -0.03105274774134159, -0.04318705573678017, -0.0245785191655159, 0.037060726433992386, -0.02792072668671608, 0.007428018841892481, -0.005418239627033472, 0.023568827658891678, 0.006939466577023268, -0.002363137435168028, -0.01964700035750866, 0.01460576057434082, 0.004536809865385294, -0.012629818171262741, -0.003212078707292676, -0.03253396973013878, -0.030775025486946106, -0.027520280331373215, 0.05915512517094612, 0.04516531527042389, 0.030020680278539658, -0.025264274328947067, 0.012377077713608742, -0.04044470191001892, -0.035661738365888596, 0.012817205861210823, -0.010624213144183159, -0.006778617389500141, -0.06686396151781082, 0.05552826076745987, -0.016619866713881493, -0.026041606441140175, 0.025833172723650932, 0.019236261025071144, 0.021845005452632904, -0.016963915899395943, -0.0679386630654335, -0.05485494062304497, 0.059695784002542496, -0.02843540720641613, 0.06015497073531151, -0.06435467302799225, 0.007740409579128027, 0.057251401245594025, 0.07609258592128754, 0.017897795885801315, 0.06385763734579086, 0.007422111462801695, 0.033323585987091064, 0.015346657484769821, -0.04766364395618439, -0.048527881503105164, 0.0038202281575649977, -0.00005468352173920721, 0.0220437441021204, -0.10751984268426895, 0.008024374954402447, -0.0037799242418259382, 0.009951240383088589, -0.03766957297921181, 0.04286998137831688, 0.003656400367617607, -0.05553457513451576, -0.03604968264698982, 0.03057718276977539, -0.027796195819973946, 0.0620015412569046, 0.009349027648568153, 0.00639637466520071, 0.045302897691726685, -0.004265141673386097, 0.054049208760261536, 0.016908073797822, 0.055102117359638214, 0.015381971374154091, -0.06157262995839119, -0.001222800463438034, -0.038373369723558426, 0.03753430023789406, 0.02315663918852806, -0.023616060614585876, 0.0033457970712333918, -0.008946657180786133, 0.011383573524653912, 0.017424773424863815, 0.03651674836874008, 0.00811845250427723, -0.016714656725525856, 0.03489002212882042, -0.029823865741491318, -0.015219486318528652, -0.06840266287326813, 0.020145032554864883, -0.029667872935533524, 0.018323199823498726, 0.030808130279183388, 0.006278492975980043, 0.03574362397193909, -0.02256798930466175, -0.0013707367470487952, -0.011460931971669197, -0.02170378901064396, -0.011921335943043232, -0.04563472792506218, 0.032078489661216736, 0.03891139477491379, 0.018278520554304123, 0.0028226561844348907, 0.0435262992978096, -0.01686943881213665, -0.04857418313622475, 0.03369978070259094, -0.03072451613843441, 0.0169554203748703, -0.00557189853861928, 0.0082097752019763, 0.0017572804354131222, -0.035987488925457, -0.012223438359797001, 0.030187351629137993, -0.04024863988161087, 0.05124139413237572, 0.028679078444838524, 0.017667299136519432, -0.01888868771493435, -0.007495477795600891, 0.007583572529256344, -0.008769465610384941, -0.0018638885812833905, -0.01460361573845148, -0.059428468346595764, -0.027326688170433044, 0.06218728795647621, 0.038493093103170395, -0.056656718254089355, 0.04288477078080177, 0.043283335864543915, 0.04490504786372185, 0.020338527858257294, 0.023983174934983253, -0.03770977258682251, -0.04627060517668724, -0.0056423223577439785, 0.023115597665309906, -0.03555555269122124, 0.029862849041819572, 0.003806971712037921, -0.004375778138637543, 0.020169198513031006, 0.0008123414590954781, -0.010942761786282063, 0.016269508749246597, -0.0015313720796257257, 0.019114958122372627, -0.016027165576815605, -0.012832104228436947, 0.025001926347613335, -0.03702032193541527, -0.009707794524729252, 0.013842274434864521, -0.010616151615977287, 0.03988686203956604, -0.025026269257068634, 0.004419596400111914, 0.040764160454273224, 0.009421427734196186, -0.034542012959718704, -0.016593240201473236, 0.008123768493533134, -0.02870195545256138, 0.003074676264077425, -0.04057883471250534, -0.04594740271568298, 0.008058397099375725, 0.0006600242923013866, -0.04428255930542946, -0.009029866196215153, 0.0034658119548112154, -0.024457871913909912, -0.03721390292048454, 0.03491058200597763, -0.03387650102376938, 0.03364263474941254, 0.009219869039952755, -0.008675486780703068, -0.0036263472866266966, -0.004207763820886612, -0.014294914901256561, 0.04467950761318207, -0.012637190520763397, 0.025623437017202377, 0.014163331128656864, -0.02132117934525013, -0.01929369568824768, 0.0012863001320511103, -0.0013941265642642975, -0.030131414532661438, -0.013919364660978317, -0.011714169755578041, 0.049236565828323364, -0.0071744066663086414, 0.0002263682836201042, 0.0006221399526111782, -0.05006874352693558, -0.03734645992517471, -0.05057515576481819, 0.0027480816934257746, 0.02992810308933258, -0.016107067465782166, 0.06339993327856064, 0.014658402651548386, -0.03384896740317345, 0.03758343309164047, -0.05774415656924248, -0.0506514236330986, 0.01764548197388649, -0.010497277602553368, 0.06049145758152008, -0.0041461531072855, -0.04571860656142235, 0.07433523237705231, 0.032416023313999176, -0.019309960305690765, -0.01780840754508972, 0.02664421871304512, -0.030375221744179726, -0.02180379629135132, 0.04622504860162735, 0.014188941568136215, -0.010769853368401527, 0.05385880544781685, -0.011741234920918941, 0.008010173216462135, 0.025707406923174858, 0.021601425483822823, -0.0006265140254981816, 0.011579756624996662, -0.010768158361315727, 0.004970875568687916, 0.016510404646396637, 0.02800608240067959, -0.022492393851280212, 0.027805959805846214, 0.0241958349943161, 0.01031339168548584, 0.015633566305041313, -0.03636014834046364, 0.04681794345378876, -0.023212173953652382, -0.003936703782528639, -0.048399243503808975, 0.036588262766599655, 0.024598754942417145, -0.030363518744707108, 0.013598115183413029, 0.018927769735455513, 0.015765881165862083, 0.0008460848475806415, -0.007798026781529188, 0.016415901482105255, 0.014551264233887196, -0.0010602612746879458, -0.002566884271800518, -0.036520816385746, -0.02353813871741295, 0.007300007622689009, -0.00856594368815422, -0.012583857402205467, 0.025865530595183372, 0.012362215667963028, -0.02786487713456154, -0.044906698167324066, 0.011076542548835278, -0.009516221471130848, -0.04353521764278412, 0.004284297116100788, 0.006064419634640217, 0.04993236064910889, 0.011371839791536331, 0.032860562205314636, -0.005962735041975975, -0.03309604525566101, 0.02988400310277939, 0.010004552081227303, -0.07621999084949493, 0.008459795266389847, -0.037409164011478424, 0.005392515100538731, 0.020977066829800606, -0.03505523130297661, 0.023358816280961037, 0.0004589680174831301, -0.011170033365488052, -0.0021414931397885084, 0.014509465545415878, -0.0305924192070961, 0.0045212628319859505, -0.0268716923892498, -0.030269861221313477, 0.003776943776756525, -0.004303628113120794, -0.010902656242251396, -0.016135970130562782, 0.02607245184481144, 0.0493214912712574, -0.016427529975771904, -0.03611071780323982, -0.032476767897605896, 0.026589490473270416, 0.009208261035382748, 0.02566821128129959, 0.012693879194557667, -0.0006037852144800127, -0.045550040900707245, 0.023903848603367805, -0.02466077171266079, 0.042925406247377396, 0.034580036997795105, -0.011517140083014965, -0.007173856254667044, -0.03851499408483505, -0.03758833929896355, 0.003951562102884054, 0.0023752828128635883, 0.01913212426006794, 0.0190205629914999, 0.05773770064115524, 0.00009390876948600635, -0.03364599123597145, -0.008702968247234821, 0.05559883266687393, -0.01349776703864336, -0.010418097488582134, -0.04324280843138695, -0.027012234553694725, 0.011975842528045177, 0.012131909839808941, 0.021933726966381073, -0.032746896147727966, -0.003582852426916361, -0.011729649268090725, 0.011918301694095135, -0.009954922832548618, -0.01907424069941044, -0.036839842796325684, 0.03300851210951805, 0.04487093910574913, -0.006831041537225246, -0.012361709028482437, 0.05012653395533562, 0.06155308708548546, 0.04463086277246475, 0.01092870719730854, -0.0026736401487141848, -0.05680178850889206, 0.03386229649186134, 0.026575222611427307, 0.036185991019010544, -0.030052265152335167, -0.005446849390864372, -0.056819114834070206, 0.01863790862262249, 0.009671499952673912, 0.007418842054903507, 0.016328534111380577, 0.013230147771537304, 0.009596526622772217, -0.005498502403497696, 0.0014252543915063143, -0.061630040407180786, -0.03984120860695839, 0.008975240401923656, 0.0006374692311510444, -0.008452479727566242, -0.02718060463666916, -0.08788131177425385, 0.004038715735077858, 0.02479501999914646, 0.08823966979980469, 0.003427805844694376, -0.006059105508029461, -0.014650286175310612, -0.00653728237375617, -0.01791190728545189, -0.04507571831345558, 0.05873305723071098, -0.033705197274684906, -0.03525068238377571, 0.009198478423058987, -0.02604103274643421, -0.06440215557813644, 0.03891303762793541, 0.017029087990522385, -0.043195802718400955, -0.008182085119187832, -0.014125615358352661, 0.013527996838092804, 0.02921096608042717, 0.027831748127937317, 0.039129309356212616, 0.02918914519250393, -0.007956722751259804, -0.014208437874913216, -0.03211500495672226, 0.019521988928318024, -0.068526491522789, -0.015780314803123474, -0.019181272014975548, 0.01801414228975773, -0.0024023486766964197, 0.018297815695405006, 0.0019977479241788387, 0.027916349470615387, -0.0008541084243915975, -0.010449126362800598, -0.010300090536475182, 0.03977196663618088, -0.0012729456648230553, 0.028901908546686172, 0.04594167694449425, 0.029333539307117462, 0.024265581741929054, -0.010576538741588593, 0.023808928206562996, -0.04263410344719887, 0.009386127814650536, 0.0238496121019125, -0.003895470639690757, -0.012884539552032948, -0.040787097066640854, -0.01475867535918951, -0.010092603974044323, -0.005340845324099064, 0.021502872928977013, -0.02615431509912014, 0.021015221253037453, 0.007622523233294487, -0.0776016041636467, 0.0185928326100111, 0.003935117740184069, -0.04707835242152214, 0.04599211364984512, -0.03200140222907066, -0.006622425280511379, 0.008932432159781456, 0.01061988715082407, -0.08326782286167145, -0.027237962931394577, 0.02464359812438488, -0.006095735356211662, -0.025170553475618362, -0.015221085399389267, -0.028460746631026268, -0.0018729595467448235, -0.05388341844081879, -0.0010463726939633489, 0.0677734985947609, 0.02077667787671089, -0.03497521951794624, -0.0206861924380064, 0.04887799918651581, 0.042440369725227356, 0.005414620507508516, -0.02970488928258419, 0.02669464610517025, -0.03349996358156204, -0.009709861129522324, 0.016302399337291718, 0.058459341526031494, -0.031478095799684525, 0.023633839562535286, -0.030568605288863182, -0.02219073846936226, 0.03286736086010933, -0.056733667850494385, -0.030571287497878075, 0.014520702883601189, 0.019597049802541733, -0.012194240465760231, -0.0140074472874403, -0.019257161766290665, 0.0079826470464468, 0.035687413066625595, 0.0024125187192112207, -0.016078758984804153, 0.02836892567574978, -0.020385976880788803, 0.06877042353153229, 0.0006899072322994471, 0.019861619919538498, -0.004506145138293505, 0.06073686480522156, -0.013874619267880917, -0.000931981485337019, -0.017745893448591232, -0.009937160648405552, 0.029711000621318817, 0.0050004636868834496, 0.03308434039354324, 0.0020621109288185835, 0.006730508990585804, -0.03591630235314369, -0.04187464714050293, -0.017633643001317978, 0.03378215804696083, 0.05436006560921669, 0.021226312965154648, 0.02514667809009552, 0.015430348925292492, 0.002764809411019087, -0.010482115671038628, -0.04510394483804703, 0.006217158865183592, -0.01113065704703331, 0.021510979160666466, 0.041025761514902115, -0.0370771698653698, 0.003180136438459158, 0.008222170174121857, 0.024401262402534485, 0.03059525601565838, 0.005847450345754623, 0.008230328559875488, 0.021320214495062828, 0.025588544085621834, 0.02820686437189579, -0.051564786583185196, 0.08199898898601532, -0.040567588061094284, 0.03512351214885712, -0.03080948069691658, -0.0025445125065743923, 0.04857763275504112, 0.03207096457481384, 0.03764622285962105, -0.027205126360058784, -0.042561255395412445, -0.05154018476605415, 0.027269864454865456, 0.028035355731844902, 0.01353383343666792, 0.044656019657850266, 0.020486753433942795, 0.015428013168275356, -0.0029308642260730267, 0.023367203772068024, -0.02270825207233429, -0.09672112762928009, -0.0371408648788929, 0.00583648681640625, -0.04009295627474785, -0.012050194665789604, 0.0042279306799173355, -0.03589904308319092, 0.0002855568891391158, -0.04615258425474167, 0.01948833279311657, -0.0006694819894619286, 0.008397039957344532, -0.01812238059937954, 0.08494219183921814, 0.01433984749019146, 0.04030891880393028, -0.04725775122642517, -0.02302737906575203, 0.10189434140920639, 0.07698633521795273, 0.053843025118112564, -0.04059138149023056, 0.03231193497776985, -0.045247770845890045, -0.006117976736277342, -0.035896241664886475, -0.03240734711289406, -0.015191785991191864, -0.013113720342516899, 0.03180524706840515, 0.05798656493425369, -0.0035976676736027002, -0.012508653104305267, 0.05807933211326599, -0.0326598696410656, -0.039856474846601486, 0.016458993777632713, -0.012189146131277084, -0.024696065112948418, 0.007366195321083069, -0.0018696467159315944, 0.044703077524900436, -0.013621118851006031, -0.04852114990353584, -0.023767223581671715, -0.02542147785425186, -0.02090514823794365, -0.03548870235681534, -0.025351209565997124, -0.014681348577141762, 0.03988518938422203, -0.013628513552248478, -0.009052082896232605, -0.007823502644896507, -0.002234983490779996, -0.017578577622771263, 0.029971111565828323, 0.05321154743432999, 0.02520333230495453, -0.006501579191535711, 0.016714634373784065, -0.014779938384890556, -0.043559055775403976, -0.007874674163758755, -0.033334989100694656, 0.0339248925447464, -0.052412159740924835, 0.012281430885195732, 0.004879925865679979, 0.025640591979026794, -0.002817887347191572, -0.01797132007777691, 0.01295439898967743, 0.011129774153232574, 0.03237733244895935, -0.004057507961988449, 0.00037791981594637036, -0.0019185574492439628, 0.03979337215423584, 0.008605467155575752, 0.0014953970676288009, 0.015563149936497211, -0.0063218651339411736, -0.018252432346343994, -0.002067837631329894, 0.014638524502515793, -0.011388590559363365, -0.007932830601930618, -0.0005096444510854781, -0.0014813659945502877, -0.0420696847140789, -0.023612217977643013, 0.032631948590278625, -0.03005385212600231, 0.05085111781954765, -0.0005082435673102736, 0.000403396668843925, 0.0015099826268851757, -0.08850812911987305, 0.013101215474307537, -0.01960415206849575, 0.002230324549600482, -0.05988854914903641, 0.017938530072569847, 0.05168129876255989, 0.029781945049762726, 0.004109000321477652, 0.022244548425078392, -0.014045150950551033, 0.012185532599687576, -0.009754013270139694, -0.021205764263868332, -0.005763523280620575, 0.009459581226110458, -0.03310270234942436, -0.017940891906619072, -0.02563541755080223, 0.015147133730351925, 0.05204155668616295, 0.056949835270643234, 0.005313513800501823, 0.005606870632618666, -0.004171401262283325, 0.01189839094877243, 0.019767286255955696, -0.02698107808828354, -0.002447381615638733, 0.02329644374549389, 0.03438085317611694, 0.0015748569276183844, -0.034959398210048676, -0.04453108459711075, 0.007495773956179619, 0.004221679642796516, -0.006519939750432968, -0.042696814984083176, 0.036368533968925476, -0.009861892089247704, 0.0026684219483286142, -0.01791510544717312, -0.027912631630897522, 0.021649427711963654, -0.0030486031901091337, 0.009287679567933083, -0.008893612772226334, -0.013161294162273407, -0.0011050248285755515, 0.007563451770693064, -0.02052145078778267, 0.03506310284137726, -0.01576954498887062, -0.02772141993045807, -0.0010163115803152323, 0.010061756707727909, -0.014937409199774265, 0.05041129142045975, -0.057666536420583725, -0.01539884228259325, 0.04709121584892273, -0.022962423041462898, -0.05484135076403618, 0.02767503261566162, -0.007916274480521679, 0.011949526146054268, 0.02747458405792713, -0.011115223169326782, -0.036715421825647354, 0.024098951369524002, -0.00794327910989523, -0.004960273392498493, -0.02703775092959404, -0.023756731301546097, 0.03444860130548477, -0.0018440642161294818, -0.019258838146924973, -0.01106776762753725, -0.006980803795158863, 0.02429894171655178, 0.07160936295986176, -0.0015165302902460098, -0.00007558761717518792, 0.021036183461546898, 0.014752453193068504, 0.017794998362660408, 0.0060536968521773815, 0.016712013632059097, 0.025000611320137978, 0.05701876059174538, -0.009248130023479462, 0.019490938633680344, -0.010355395264923573, 0.007262595929205418, -0.09587305784225464, -0.029613396152853966, 0.002829045057296753, 0.04279908537864685, 0.05410245805978775, -0.09984409809112549, -0.0010015113512054086, 0.05576751381158829, -0.07700014859437943, -0.023794008418917656, -0.0210946686565876, -0.014096463099122047, -0.032116763293743134, -0.01155775599181652, -0.0013433607527986169, 0.03315778449177742, 0.010609302669763565, 0.034111008048057556, 0.05191868171095848, 0.03248345106840134, -0.023373741656541824, 0.0017617123667150736, -0.015076923184096813, 0.015409723855555058, 0.043416935950517654, -0.031302668154239655, 0.024079646915197372, -0.029128916561603546, -0.027580805122852325, 0.059339817613363266, 0.006173169240355492, -0.012858566828072071, 0.02471882291138172, 0.04066917300224304, -0.00032279492006637156, 0.01655155047774315, 0.006799710914492607, 0.012845072895288467, 0.01729014329612255, 0.023488029837608337, 0.02905503287911415, 0.042004916816949844, -0.06206226721405983, -0.0070404899306595325, -0.0017567145405337214, -0.012452424503862858, -0.049302905797958374, 0.028170250356197357, 0.01237782184034586, -0.016792597249150276, -0.010012323036789894, -0.014512221328914165, -0.01953335478901863, -0.03716694563627243, 0.05538935586810112, 0.0009858545381575823, 0.01152835227549076, 0.0037847880739718676, 0.06897673010826111, -0.014264157973229885, -0.0007362024625763297, 0.005114964209496975, -0.0224574264138937, 0.007590301334857941, 0.004552840255200863, -0.013975095003843307, -0.05538937821984291, 0.0009080998715944588, 0.004452705383300781, -0.006444600876420736, -0.010849982500076294, 0.00014366461255121976, -0.04546486958861351, 0.03468986973166466, -0.004017963074147701, 0.02236330136656761, 0.021985145285725594, -0.02984480932354927, -0.02281290479004383, -0.08992551267147064, 0.06784871965646744, -0.002773337299004197, 0.013236717320978642, -0.01756320521235466, 0.006186651531606913, 0.03253638371825218, -0.036704644560813904, 0.06127674877643585, -0.010111347772181034, 0.010522831231355667, -0.007356354501098394, 0.019692737609148026, 0.012136314995586872, -0.032493963837623596, -0.002804392483085394, -0.03512177616357803, -0.04028869792819023, -0.01042979396879673, -0.02392154559493065, 0.037162113934755325, 0.0007398146553896368, 0.0062639773823320866, -0.016024934127926826, 0.002431536326184869, -0.0013637847732752562, 0.00249713403172791, 0.0334838405251503, 0.0160622987896204, -0.04023461788892746, 0.07168107479810715, -0.03103003278374672, 0.008969125337898731, 0.03690200299024582, -0.01198633387684822, -0.06463326513767242, 0.013540650717914104, -0.03713066130876541, -0.03229029104113579, -0.015111919492483139, 0.0018792640184983611, -0.0019557734485715628, -0.024892421439290047, -0.02113906294107437, 0.027265863493084908, -0.018751416355371475, 0.022354856133461, 0.015126818791031837, -0.002471531741321087, 0.06394269317388535, 0.02343817427754402, -0.015393007546663284, 0.017931899055838585, 0.02370143122971058, 0.0020959188695997, 0.010566470213234425, 0.009396202862262726, -0.016250332817435265, 0.0030385456047952175, -0.0006845906027592719, -0.021273629739880562, 0.056553035974502563, -0.0017062424449250102, 0.04326391965150833, -0.031579889357089996, -0.00811820663511753, 0.0326237678527832, -0.012809610925614834, 0.03215113282203674, -0.01965496875345707, -0.04216224327683449, 0.03843575716018677, -0.02321496792137623, -0.008178198710083961, -0.01188366487622261, -0.014077100902795792, -0.04536013677716255, -0.03364982455968857, -0.007650697138160467, -0.0032115699723362923, 0.00014644194743596017, 0.006014431361109018, 0.0317876972258091, -0.004640855360776186, 0.04917285218834877, -0.028144391253590584, 0.029451783746480942, -0.0029950616881251335, -0.021925373002886772, -0.03083222359418869, -0.02549135871231556, -0.016935257241129875, 0.011496870778501034, 0.016105875372886658, 0.0284248199313879, 0.02274390123784542, -0.030459430068731308, 0.00487945694476366, -0.014454292133450508, 0.0665174201130867, -0.08751793205738068, 0.00986895989626646, -0.06726650893688202, -0.010363510809838772, 0.004050011746585369, -0.051634665578603745 ]
<p><strong>Question:</strong> I want to test a medicine and I have two groups of people with baseline blood pressure, one I give medicine A and the other one medicine B. After 6 months, I measure their blood pressure.</p> <p>Now there are two options:</p> <ul> <li>I measure the difference of the mean change. </li> <li>I forget about the baseline and just measure the difference of the final values.</li> </ul> <p>When and why do you use method one or method two? </p> <p>And what would happen in case you work with the lowest p-value of each test to reject the null-hypothesis that both tests are equal?</p>
36,981
[ -0.026979586109519005, 0.035268787294626236, -0.03275411203503609, -0.02348104491829872, 0.0056644924916327, 0.022832537069916725, 0.004634124226868153, -0.038920752704143524, 0.014916246756911278, 0.015441951341927052, 0.06628507375717163, 0.03663234785199165, 0.005378107074648142, -0.020393071696162224, 0.02736709639430046, 0.016374818980693817, -0.006260398309677839, 0.002346285618841648, -0.03383418917655945, -0.001981056062504649, -0.013913359493017197, -0.025550635531544685, 0.019264446571469307, -0.010160640813410282, -0.03449593111872673, 0.043813902884721756, 0.027600020170211792, -0.04180782660841942, -0.03919298201799393, 0.07775185257196426, -0.059553857892751694, -0.027338983491063118, -0.018346590921282768, 0.002476343186572194, 0.040894702076911926, -0.005860024597495794, -0.02793792262673378, -0.025191375985741615, -0.008995816111564636, 0.05138697847723961, -0.005642588250339031, -0.0022376456763595343, -0.00335751473903656, 0.028187910094857216, -0.02914377488195896, 0.013014272786676884, -0.005857918411493301, -0.0032071846071630716, 0.009248897433280945, -0.048830240964889526, 0.011917535215616226, -0.01725139655172825, 0.040358856320381165, 0.02968423441052437, -0.04613276943564415, -0.04600250720977783, 0.033049069344997406, 0.0706683024764061, -0.01404102798551321, -0.050651926547288895, -0.00857408344745636, -0.03428436070680618, -0.0020780691411346197, 0.0026262085884809494, -0.04225054755806923, 0.00918584130704403, -0.024949001148343086, -0.016713088378310204, 0.05299801379442215, 0.0006274442421272397, 0.0074144816026091576, 0.03134245052933693, 0.025833919644355774, 0.0044985003769397736, 0.0377553254365921, -0.04688490927219391, 0.017718015238642693, 0.016230078414082527, 0.07029185444116592, 0.051211368292570114, -0.00321030686609447, -0.0032352260313928127, 0.0648089125752449, 0.04617786034941673, 0.0392097644507885, -0.04747655242681503, 0.07487865537405014, 0.006156746298074722, -0.004822999704629183, 0.061179473996162415, 0.009251981973648071, -0.01923186145722866, 0.00980334635823965, 0.00022624603298027068, -0.025922512635588646, 0.04772219434380531, -0.029034649953246117, 0.04088004678487778, 0.0036525612231343985, 0.02325049228966236, 0.00977294147014618, -0.053843434900045395, 0.04215554893016815, 0.036280691623687744, -0.011102741584181786, -0.015933390706777573, -0.020698998123407364, -0.005137898027896881, 0.002559265121817589, 0.01885758340358734, -0.0191532950848341, -0.004876142833381891, -0.005076854024082422, -0.001738052349537611, 0.015081379562616348, -0.006964065600186586, -0.019465962424874306, -0.03763259947299957, 0.0819593295454979, 0.009042910300195217, 0.07431972771883011, 0.016276035457849503, -0.016257300972938538, -0.018293123692274094, -0.041931334882974625, -0.013742849230766296, -0.022583968937397003, -0.007652913685888052, -0.022866006940603256, 0.057821858674287796, 0.0013419699389487505, -0.012484023347496986, 0.04410555586218834, 0.006009581033140421, 0.03733501583337784, 0.05099191516637802, -0.09842010587453842, -0.04200160130858421, 0.04582265391945839, -0.004870334640145302, -0.02945895493030548, -0.056941043585538864, -0.0059534646570682526, 0.027032645419239998, 0.029039740562438965, 0.03000478632748127, 0.014335640706121922, 0.010301719419658184, 0.030038606375455856, 0.0221523717045784, 0.015472836792469025, -0.006089923437684774, -0.02261856012046337, -0.011889800429344177, -0.026762889698147774, -0.08847551047801971, -0.01679454930126667, 0.00046492397086694837, -0.026932794600725174, 0.0009207067196257412, 0.03230675682425499, -0.015507725067436695, 0.0024630269035696983, -0.019613604992628098, 0.010433078743517399, 0.015403380617499352, 0.04225880652666092, 0.011383106000721455, 0.0025484440848231316, 0.011655200272798538, 0.002804387593641877, 0.04353521764278412, -0.00918936263769865, 0.026965780183672905, 0.020462727174162865, -0.02754659205675125, -0.0041543859988451, 0.020190466195344925, 0.010018973611295223, 0.006106640212237835, -0.030211959034204483, -0.022876642644405365, -0.020564677193760872, 0.0051412940956652164, 0.015706252306699753, 0.04610830545425415, 0.016963563859462738, 0.000642696802970022, 0.0235464908182621, -0.05489940941333771, -0.028183387592434883, -0.10270370543003082, -0.012060927227139473, 0.03130879998207092, -0.030667757615447044, 0.02792987786233425, 0.0011325990781188011, -0.004367060959339142, -0.02138846553862095, -0.014334487728774548, 0.004144162405282259, -0.0109655000269413, 0.03386670723557472, -0.05411239713430405, -0.013939314521849155, 0.0652560442686081, 0.07085512578487396, -0.01034878846257925, 0.01926947943866253, -0.06507883220911026, -0.011297455057501793, 0.0011274681892246008, -0.0334336943924427, -0.014516676776111126, 0.018130958080291748, -0.03314603120088577, 0.004170007538050413, -0.01766958460211754, -0.005742276087403297, 0.026882553473114967, -0.07851660996675491, 0.08395379781723022, 0.0626082643866539, -0.027902409434318542, 0.038769934326410294, -0.015814024955034256, 0.002265728311613202, 0.026292821392416954, 0.016202233731746674, -0.010396375320851803, -0.04711981490254402, -0.013497102074325085, 0.003950833342969418, -0.010874072089791298, -0.019922785460948944, 0.03352691978216171, 0.047062646597623825, -0.016012724488973618, -0.018883688375353813, 0.020201604813337326, 0.035072993487119675, -0.03642512485384941, 0.008498924784362316, 0.030436135828495026, 0.008898111991584301, 0.050833240151405334, 0.02648371458053589, -0.021197138354182243, 0.03405507281422615, 0.03126431256532669, 0.009392591193318367, 0.03272796794772148, 0.055913493037223816, 0.009426262229681015, 0.0022439290769398212, -0.03184358403086662, 0.0025446638464927673, 0.009483014233410358, 0.0019590575248003006, 0.015545178204774857, 0.010332314297556877, -0.010776445269584656, 0.013376748189330101, -0.017789974808692932, 0.029379094019532204, 0.0343451052904129, -0.005878761410713196, 0.017829839140176773, 0.01931028626859188, -0.04228498414158821, 0.003115191822871566, -0.04940161108970642, -0.03011474758386612, -0.04483639821410179, -0.01984415575861931, 0.004374312702566385, 0.001915580127388239, 0.041263215243816376, -0.04286602512001991, 0.0014186303596943617, -0.002243923721835017, -0.04746929183602333, 0.011060217395424843, -0.024257058277726173, -0.0289639700204134, 0.015052758157253265, -0.036000922322273254, -0.006674764212220907, 0.01979396864771843, 0.009488366544246674, -0.02076030522584915, 0.04059799015522003, 0.02766762487590313, -0.04848668351769447, -0.04696495085954666, -0.00836282316595316, 0.0023183575831353664, 0.008998451754450798, -0.023433668538928032, 0.07363235205411911, 0.007908282801508904, -0.014712803065776825, 0.031931426376104355, -0.02656478062272072, 0.009359989315271378, -0.027446163818240166, -0.01855848729610443, 0.0032904718536883593, 0.011861461214721203, -0.020283205434679985, 0.02859875187277794, -0.043020378798246384, -0.018150288611650467, -0.08171676099300385, -0.06156563758850098, 0.02920662611722946, 0.0018115335842594504, 0.045782335102558136, -0.010092376731336117, 0.003818644443526864, 0.10068216174840927, 0.040564969182014465, -0.018585776910185814, -0.02952522039413452, 0.012614235281944275, -0.018546365201473236, -0.004118465818464756, 0.01533893495798111, 0.04473056644201279, -0.010063841938972473, 0.008662771433591843, 0.017885245382785797, 0.030798301100730896, 0.03534850478172302, 0.027906108647584915, -0.002842966001480818, -0.010919146239757538, 0.046623069792985916, 0.006185214500874281, 0.043046776205301285, 0.013416953384876251, -0.010230363346636295, 0.004688761197030544, -0.000787428580224514, 0.032428041100502014, 0.004070933908224106, -0.02434764802455902, 0.03808470070362091, -0.0028552908916026354, -0.021010855212807655, -0.022223101928830147, 0.04367760568857193, 0.013747591525316238, 0.0008317935862578452, -0.014601727947592735, -0.013786598108708858, 0.007635097019374371, -0.03072933852672577, -0.025382112711668015, 0.03153989091515541, 0.052610691636800766, -0.042460713535547256, -0.023410232737660408, 0.006072262767702341, 0.020629694685339928, 0.03967560827732086, -0.029705805703997612, -0.031054245308041573, 0.04612784460186958, 0.03696798160672188, 0.015815582126379013, 0.019361257553100586, -0.05046837404370308, -0.018006592988967896, -0.06825295090675354, 0.004325137473642826, 0.000024941722585936077, 0.05901527777314186, -0.005326011683791876, 0.04908955842256546, 0.01937183365225792, 0.010906313546001911, -0.004537112079560757, -0.02151617221534252, -0.05085374042391777, 0.012912743724882603, -0.021131638437509537, -0.011658892966806889, 0.010563220828771591, 0.004620581399649382, 0.02316879667341709, -0.024345040321350098, 0.021842466667294502, -0.02889007329940796, 0.03151683881878853, -0.016647974029183388, 0.007815530523657799, -0.03127506747841835, -0.012559179216623306, -0.02990364469587803, 0.006195822264999151, 0.01588655821979046, 0.00026445506955496967, 0.015913376584649086, 0.022182730957865715, 0.01648947037756443, 0.002474881010130048, -0.02306763082742691, -0.028508754447102547, 0.01735190488398075, 0.06327686458826065, 0.011351398192346096, 0.04503846541047096, -0.03383474424481392, 0.028626898303627968, 0.013961659744381905, 0.03470243141055107, 0.03384118527173996, 0.004637671168893576, -0.006233924068510532, -0.013610487803816795, -0.01957220770418644, -0.0198011826723814, 0.026855647563934326, 0.01114604901522398, -0.02204548381268978, -0.00317489355802536, 0.016107292845845222, -0.02058253437280655, 0.015847064554691315, 0.06463692337274551, -0.0026873270981013775, 0.006473907735198736, -0.04178779199719429, -0.042575668543577194, -0.02699100226163864, -0.019729603081941605, 0.029399093240499496, 0.01682240702211857, -0.005490751471370459, -0.012235716916620731, 0.03860192745923996, 0.008116648532450199, -0.04950246587395668, -0.014927361160516739, 0.018279336392879486, 0.01564607210457325, 0.04920429363846779, 0.007223564200103283, 0.0446641743183136, 0.04855925589799881, 0.020241621881723404, 0.006264761555939913, -0.00967585202306509, -0.05778833478689194, -0.0038660040590912104, 0.038899801671504974, 0.021065007895231247, -0.04573245719075203, -0.015476489439606667, -0.019014859572052956, 0.00428016996011138, 0.03432071954011917, -0.060947172343730927, 0.0021779348608106375, -0.007361233234405518, 0.0021790924947708845, -0.0678546205163002, -0.016853870823979378, -0.062246862798929214, 0.011418060399591923, -0.0029951445758342743, 0.007419670931994915, 0.011958267539739609, -0.001429163385182619, -0.04708158224821091, -0.01119118183851242, 0.005753231700509787, 0.05438710376620293, -0.07115788757801056, 0.000808746786788106, 0.03922203555703163, -0.012073292396962643, -0.0011409100843593478, -0.05897248163819313, 0.005135948769748211, -0.00502061378210783, -0.00011542297579580918, 0.03628528490662575, -0.023951370269060135, -0.04206868261098862, 0.003963072318583727, -0.02417691797018051, -0.02767992578446865, 0.01464986614882946, -0.04206318035721779, 0.0448048934340477, 0.08504477143287659, -0.013179231435060501, 0.061541780829429626, -0.008114838041365147, 0.022546814754605293, 0.02025611139833927, -0.03870934620499611, -0.023896658793091774, -0.02921907976269722, -0.021563049405813217, -0.061688169836997986, -0.02735014259815216, -0.017344066873192787, 0.04681115224957466, 0.03217955306172371, 0.008781529031693935, -0.0018276562914252281, -0.006385390181094408, 0.033727969974279404, 0.022304994985461235, 0.03613286837935448, 0.009714549407362938, 0.03581003472208977, -0.03269347921013832, -0.014648734591901302, -0.02198886126279831, 0.020324943587183952, -0.02160947397351265, 0.006256658583879471, 0.008179344236850739, -0.07726931571960449, 0.026346076279878616, -0.02055363357067108, -0.0324416384100914, 0.022251754999160767, -0.0327313207089901, 0.01812027208507061, 0.0012831619242206216, 0.037351567298173904, 0.025381356477737427, -0.02950110286474228, -0.04333353415131569, 0.025925207883119583, -0.01181273628026247, -0.01949773170053959, -0.03423056751489639, 0.07662394642829895, 0.0181304682046175, 0.017888229340314865, -0.0656077116727829, 0.000016393414625781588, 0.03680187091231346, -0.009732144884765148, 0.024902619421482086, -0.013533656485378742, 0.02982979081571102, 0.005071856081485748, -0.013571435585618019, -0.030802810564637184, 0.04701885208487511, -0.010509969666600227, -0.05704409256577492, -0.020377235487103462, 0.02542811818420887, 0.08680940419435501, -0.014132941141724586, -0.01667703315615654, 0.030926711857318878, -0.038455523550510406, -0.01762651838362217, -0.008081748150289059, 0.02104059047996998, -0.027619531378149986, -0.009950276464223862, -0.02644302137196064, -0.014275896362960339, 0.04622824862599373, -0.005111358128488064, -0.03048010729253292, 0.020335795357823372, -0.032131269574165344, -0.00858757458627224, -0.05679768696427345, -0.026330316439270973, -0.04991907626390457, 0.010428138077259064, -0.021665258333086967, 0.036103859543800354, 0.01685922034084797, -0.04228748753666878, 0.02332366071641445, 0.045844875276088715, -0.0734112560749054, -0.006243424490094185, 0.04476939141750336, -0.007287310902029276, 0.019792182371020317, 0.008005314506590366, -0.044867366552352905, -0.001327547593973577, 0.03482125326991081, -0.01784861832857132, 0.027198592200875282, 0.023872826248407364, -0.05599813908338547, -0.018884705379605293, -0.025757931172847748, -0.0031570852734148502, 0.03594878315925598, 0.003968528937548399, 0.0737212523818016, 0.0653345063328743, 0.01834229752421379, 0.02356179617345333, -0.028142578899860382, 0.01669851318001747, -0.04170489311218262, -0.004211144987493753, 0.051633644849061966, -0.03729826211929321, 0.016307400539517403, 0.07479364424943924, 0.0346856415271759, 0.011966332793235779, 0.02539452351629734, 0.010173427872359753, -0.0008713630959391594, 0.02809291146695614, -0.0545097291469574, -0.03234698623418808, 0.04744943976402283, -0.06779781728982925, 0.036364272236824036, -0.021128248423337936, 0.00598099734634161, 0.02726925164461136, 0.020737633109092712, -0.02533946931362152, -0.07223605364561081, 0.019168796017766, -0.06197158992290497, -0.02633720077574253, 0.008424161933362484, 0.0014941291883587837, 0.04037332907319069, 0.0057871681638062, 0.025216229259967804, -0.006879155989736319, 0.02111446112394333, -0.04309596121311188, -0.047187574207782745, -0.037793371826410294, 0.009231820702552795, -0.037548720836639404, 0.038204118609428406, -0.008883033879101276, -0.007276017684489489, 0.024791929870843887, -0.04785702005028725, 0.008200054988265038, 0.017708776518702507, 0.001744366018101573, -0.01130700297653675, 0.061261944472789764, -0.012810173444449902, 0.028886806219816208, 0.027942867949604988, -0.0079988157376647, 0.11991163343191147, 0.05640614777803421, 0.04446698725223541, -0.05916012078523636, 0.03503977879881859, 0.04151074215769768, 0.04344668611884117, 0.0009557126904837787, 0.017976881936192513, 0.0024284201208502054, 0.027229001745581627, 0.046595532447099686, 0.06370939314365387, 0.019583046436309814, -0.0032492526806890965, 0.05392400920391083, -0.01661072112619877, 0.008231068961322308, 0.01181518379598856, -0.001649766694754362, -0.013907980173826218, -0.01136853452771902, 0.0017159173730760813, 0.029521651566028595, 0.01831340231001377, -0.019144726917147636, -0.008082792162895203, -0.005669537931680679, -0.003848892403766513, 0.012065812945365906, -0.003617166541516781, 0.03870704770088196, 0.012720038183033466, -0.0029761025216430426, -0.03045221045613289, 0.0002555616956669837, 0.032014161348342896, -0.03340880945324898, 0.0035614585503935814, 0.026897680014371872, 0.002590600401163101, -0.01656101830303669, -0.002163934288546443, 0.03583266958594322, -0.049942854791879654, -0.022586842998862267, -0.025419291108846664, 0.04482659325003624, -0.007209897506982088, -0.043968480080366135, -0.029364829882979393, -0.027195462957024574, -0.019793443381786346, -0.039539992809295654, -0.04112419858574867, 0.025575056672096252, 0.013222151435911655, -0.018917756155133247, 0.016388781368732452, -0.015432698652148247, 0.062343232333660126, -0.013800522312521935, 0.010937219485640526, 0.026638802140951157, -0.007115621585398912, -0.016258196905255318, -0.008255085907876492, -0.0016058952314779162, -0.01597687602043152, 0.011726327240467072, 0.017295610159635544, -0.012955747544765472, -0.0448356494307518, -0.000176811488927342, -0.004007800482213497, 0.01488000713288784, 0.024770718067884445, 0.002471616491675377, 0.011507663875818253, -0.03895525261759758, -0.040739431977272034, 0.011065293103456497, -0.007404818199574947, 0.03144465386867523, -0.030563997104763985, -0.03394791856408119, 0.017161952331662178, 0.020678292959928513, 0.021800244227051735, 0.00035840406781062484, 0.033066198229789734, 0.061304379254579544, 0.023268215358257294, -0.048313386738300323, -0.02013348415493965, 0.015409691259264946, -0.044475357979536057, 0.007206580135971308, -0.0538552887737751, 0.06718078255653381, 0.038097985088825226, 0.00016166579734999686, -0.003955344669520855, -0.004471778403967619, -0.03891779109835625, -0.012838001362979412, -0.013147574849426746, -0.04553508758544922, -0.014574430882930756, 0.012870317324995995, 0.005318650044500828, 0.015993069857358932, 0.0071621909737586975, -0.04377789795398712, -0.02907211147248745, 0.04355083033442497, -0.027374358847737312, 0.013502448797225952, 0.02540167048573494, -0.0022459744941443205, 0.030091164633631706, -0.022249016910791397, 0.017632827162742615, -0.05858293175697327, -0.05128771811723709, 0.014525588601827621, -0.029996247962117195, -0.021593885496258736, 0.0379941463470459, -0.03352063149213791, 0.0042059882543981075, 0.028315506875514984, 0.009248333051800728, 0.017874568700790405, 0.0352744497358799, 0.011622786521911621, 0.0018083142349496484, 0.0060927956365048885, 0.008079035207629204, -0.044725608080625534, 0.03601852059364319, -0.040430698543787, -0.009158342145383358, 0.03191617131233215, 0.03938351199030876, 0.025504393503069878, 0.018494922667741776, -0.0022911708801984787, 0.015984689816832542, 0.024831203743815422, -0.047253239899873734, -0.06591448932886124, -0.03528328612446785, -0.054379332810640335, -0.010484962724149227, 0.0027151217218488455, 0.03942475467920303, 0.0009272271418012679, -0.03478190302848816, 0.03639259561896324, 0.05066662281751633, 0.016744393855333328, -0.016447778791189194, -0.03547199070453644, 0.005539792124181986, 0.03230194002389908, 0.02013661339879036, -0.0174984410405159, 0.03447270020842552, 0.05001707002520561, -0.01579154096543789, 0.016312148422002792, -0.06445806473493576, -0.01912447065114975, -0.09118891507387161, -0.00978982262313366, 0.01280192844569683, -0.01634036935865879, 0.03151729702949524, -0.043450307101011276, 0.005769143346697092, 0.03896729275584221, -0.0449540838599205, -0.0006234713946469128, -0.017638541758060455, -0.0020329239778220654, -0.018905507400631905, 0.026699267327785492, -0.011182070709764957, 0.02461215853691101, 0.007497827522456646, 0.03346247225999832, 0.00845944695174694, 0.04849141836166382, 0.03700258582830429, -0.007787427399307489, -0.013109967112541199, 0.02517082914710045, 0.00923666451126337, -0.07942767441272736, -0.012492934241890907, -0.025712598115205765, -0.013106263242661953, 0.01578196883201599, -0.01760258711874485, 0.041450075805187225, 0.004503361880779266, 0.01002888847142458, 0.002169694984331727, 0.024442221969366074, -0.00888337567448616, 0.007192608434706926, -0.0430464968085289, -0.013751588761806488, -0.004889217671006918, 0.02654501050710678, 0.010438399389386177, 0.008880794048309326, 0.028442135080695152, 0.0051829637959599495, -0.010325762443244457, -0.006672844756394625, -0.02339709922671318, -0.03283410891890526, 0.007398888934403658, -0.014936495572328568, 0.0219498872756958, -0.020007306709885597, -0.0601440854370594, -0.010402427054941654, -0.000617126643192023, 0.06449346989393234, 0.021564384922385216, -0.07108649611473083, 0.03904431685805321, -0.020575283095240593, 0.00007669890328543261, 0.011884684674441814, 0.01764436438679695, -0.011833490803837776, -0.0464065819978714, -0.006052573211491108, -0.022747689858078957, 0.0061110565438866615, -0.03322532773017883, 0.008420725353062153, 0.008191822096705437, 0.006120670586824417, -0.021033598110079765, 0.01538388803601265, -0.030078064650297165, -0.01828019693493843, 0.022689513862133026, -0.08010002225637436, 0.06389527767896652, 0.0018439790001139045, -0.012499136850237846, -0.04417729750275612, -0.009103571996092796, -0.05860845744609833, 0.011638577096164227, 0.0775994062423706, 0.054892510175704956, -0.002961857942864299, -0.025714298710227013, 0.025280699133872986, 0.026987574994564056, -0.07039789110422134, 0.03266114369034767, 0.008609752170741558, -0.020527061074972153, -0.0019808162469416857, 0.016095442697405815, 0.007493677549064159, 0.030243806540966034, 0.033215414732694626, -0.03345063701272011, 0.014073211699724197, 0.013371649198234081, 0.02668602764606476, 0.01801208034157753, -0.005432183388620615, -0.02674284391105175, 0.025518624112010002, -0.007838740013539791, 0.025233136489987373, 0.028144454583525658, -0.0023616687394678593, -0.039063598960638046, 0.04325732961297035, -0.03257247433066368, -0.009645126760005951, 0.005045408848673105, 0.001890432322397828, -0.04020526260137558, -0.05824816972017288, -0.0073583913035690784, 0.013049918226897717, -0.0413515530526638, -0.0077348933555185795, 0.035513028502464294, 0.018180882558226585, 0.02166491001844406, -0.004171959590166807, 0.018854942172765732, -0.010280606336891651, 0.009357092902064323, 0.013652092777192593, -0.0021621258929371834, 0.025629591196775436, -0.0027124988846480846, 0.009044009260833263, 0.021661927923560143, -0.02330278791487217, 0.00546635827049613, -0.010895182378590107, 0.06610850244760513, -0.0003066544886678457, -0.019724728539586067, -0.0043154023587703705, -0.016796331852674484, 0.00675900699570775, 0.032930903136730194, 0.04343889281153679, 0.04238833114504814, -0.026873154565691948, -0.012344974093139172, -0.032707057893276215, 0.00005167436393094249, -0.027301698923110962, 0.00492832763120532, 0.020611431449651718, -0.010545976459980011, 0.020192677155137062, 0.006445932202041149, 0.005359164904803038, -0.018052447587251663, -0.016155485063791275, 0.0058841644786298275, 0.0731963962316513, -0.04011646658182144, -0.04409762844443321, -0.04754822328686714, -0.008780643343925476, -0.05353328585624695, 0.010084837675094604, 0.027146464213728905, 0.05056769773364067, 0.04282467067241669, 0.0006004723254591227, -0.0194085706025362, 0.011022639460861683, 0.023603426292538643, -0.062293607741594315, -0.012668200768530369, -0.058359164744615555, -0.029538586735725403, -0.00784324947744608, -0.031047286465764046 ]
<p>$\newcommand{\Var}{\mathrm{Var}}$ Consider $Z_i$ as a binary random variable with $\mathrm{Pr}[Z_i = 1] = \pi$. Also, consider $Y_i$ as:</p> <p>$Y_i|Z_i = 0 \sim \mathrm{Poisson} (\lambda_0) $</p> <p>$Y_i|Z_i = 1 \sim \mathrm{Poisson} (\lambda_1) $</p> <p>My question is how we can find $\Var(Y_i)$.</p> <p>Here is what I think I should do, but I've not had any success till now:</p> <p>$\Var(Y_i) = E(\Var(Y_i|Z_i)) + \Var(E(Y_i|Z_i)) = E(\pi\cdot\lambda_1 + (1 - \pi)\cdot\lambda_0) + \Var(\pi\cdot\lambda_1 + (1 - \pi)\cdot\lambda_0) = \pi\cdot\lambda_1 + (1 - \pi)\cdot\lambda_0 + 0 $</p> <p>What I've got above is different from what my instructor has in his lecture notes. He has: $\Var(Y_i) = \pi\cdot\lambda_1 + (1 - \pi)\cdot\lambda_0 + (\lambda_1 - \lambda_0)^2\cdot\pi\cdot(1 - \pi)$</p> <p>I appreciate your help.</p>
74,232
[ -0.013270186260342598, -0.04185778275132179, 0.016284512355923653, -0.02127614989876747, 0.020334897562861443, 0.004071403294801712, 0.032564692199230194, -0.00024747769930399954, 0.016132954508066177, -0.01251723151654005, 0.0012714125914499164, 0.07431616634130478, 0.06530439108610153, 0.024069728329777718, 0.0634513795375824, 0.009125773794949055, -0.015387624502182007, -0.026459552347660065, -0.0402555987238884, -0.02383371628820896, 0.0027364054694771767, 0.019692106172442436, 0.03453168645501137, -0.011485080234706402, -0.05250300094485283, 0.0379236675798893, 0.011190610937774181, -0.014490951783955097, 0.014369426295161247, 0.09208514541387558, -0.022058287635445595, -0.039145514369010925, 0.0008320541237480938, 0.04815492033958435, -0.00031982059590518475, -0.013916153460741043, -0.04770883917808533, -0.03975392132997513, -0.007965014316141605, 0.0207226425409317, -0.032502081245183945, -0.03272055834531784, 0.006738787051290274, 0.04118799418210983, -0.04129078611731529, 0.005829899571835995, -0.024467427283525467, -0.03850952163338661, 0.06708353757858276, -0.04812921956181526, 0.05679299682378769, -0.02180599234998226, 0.0502873957157135, 0.051661908626556396, 0.010806255973875523, -0.016241751611232758, 0.05424388870596886, 0.03366169333457947, -0.012876773253083229, -0.013797190971672535, -0.014898213557898998, -0.02454111911356449, 0.003959923982620239, -0.048254236578941345, -0.032822586596012115, -0.024895556271076202, -0.002224577823653817, -0.038494836539030075, 0.015057059936225414, -0.006995601113885641, 0.04793790727853775, 0.004637732170522213, 0.034924447536468506, -0.027288472279906273, 0.0006583370268344879, -0.01548740640282631, -0.007343272678554058, 0.0379856713116169, 0.019877398386597633, 0.0221866387873888, 0.011674159206449986, 0.014120794832706451, 0.021527117118239403, 0.03538135439157486, 0.0007984777330420911, -0.043510790914297104, 0.07529135048389435, 0.013946767896413803, 0.010235967114567757, 0.032171666622161865, -0.010216106660664082, -0.005246329586952925, 0.020603787153959274, -0.011494030244648457, -0.029604952782392502, 0.060597654432058334, -0.020953452214598656, 0.011786098591983318, 0.0031590727157890797, 0.005702893249690533, -0.0034348410554230213, -0.0461321696639061, 0.028973519802093506, 0.052984438836574554, -0.040013816207647324, -0.0026046140119433403, -0.0031926303636282682, 0.019360123202204704, -0.008102372288703918, -0.030695047229528427, -0.03847350925207138, 0.05319809913635254, 0.019503716379404068, -0.01714402064681053, -0.017023149877786636, -0.035876620560884476, 0.01647896133363247, 0.00002516404856578447, 0.020161792635917664, 0.06957796961069107, 0.01870894990861416, -0.007986875250935555, 0.05719221383333206, -0.04592149704694748, -0.05445365980267525, 0.026019517332315445, 0.024438317865133286, -0.018368232995271683, -0.05056867003440857, 0.07233867049217224, 0.011964922770857811, -0.006497612223029137, 0.01212418545037508, -0.009515407495200634, 0.025869468227028847, -0.015638260170817375, -0.0628110021352768, -0.02422049082815647, -0.008086943067610264, -0.020425768569111824, 0.0402630977332592, -0.03963536396622658, 0.015869295224547386, 0.033777814358472824, 0.0393163338303566, 0.02119748666882515, 0.026704486459493637, 0.020480746403336525, 0.003929826430976391, 0.026465417817234993, -0.04369163140654564, -0.03739510849118233, -0.01868963986635208, -0.01755082607269287, 0.004012115765362978, -0.08445227146148682, 0.018584132194519043, 0.010570037178695202, -0.01150275394320488, -0.011249864473938942, 0.047963209450244904, -0.004181231372058392, 0.029994046315550804, -0.01660526730120182, 0.022174101322889328, -0.052424490451812744, 0.07728368043899536, 0.01577940583229065, 0.00009951061656465754, 0.02805149368941784, 0.006684922147542238, -0.011982868425548077, -0.03064550645649433, 0.04578179493546486, 0.04407237470149994, -0.048812154680490494, -0.05658889561891556, -0.05207302048802376, -0.005106564145535231, 0.0349234975874424, -0.03292442113161087, -0.0269177183508873, -0.03557126224040985, 0.01640622690320015, 0.023860832676291466, 0.054012663662433624, 0.0030911678913980722, 0.012814736925065517, 0.014850716106593609, -0.01847430318593979, -0.01921756938099861, -0.035452984273433685, -0.0006800310220569372, 0.025494756177067757, -0.006515929009765387, 0.011707109399139881, 0.01223799865692854, -0.003952493891119957, 0.004347573965787888, -0.01789163239300251, -0.029068313539028168, -0.0019530069548636675, 0.05417213961482048, -0.008387284353375435, 0.005835614632815123, 0.04160788655281067, 0.021274350583553314, -0.013295075856149197, 0.02282479964196682, -0.028186360374093056, -0.023913854733109474, -0.016926145181059837, -0.01809660531580448, 0.025708679109811783, -0.010435515083372593, 0.014036936685442924, 0.05523330718278885, 0.008705256506800652, -0.0019401430618017912, 0.010044500231742859, -0.06314018368721008, 0.013936974108219147, 0.0776810273528099, 0.04117550700902939, 0.025149963796138763, 0.0334155298769474, 0.02708459459245205, 0.006688594352453947, 0.01066710613667965, -0.0075957090593874454, -0.04390634223818779, 0.02092141844332218, 0.048921849578619, -0.0031324324663728476, -0.02111121453344822, 0.00679121445864439, 0.07188723236322403, 0.035713080316782, 0.011766319163143635, 0.04046490788459778, -0.023170139640569687, 0.03025238588452339, 0.05856214091181755, 0.010952704586088657, 0.02277967520058155, 0.001687237760052085, 0.034004077315330505, -0.015423103235661983, 0.02319805882871151, -0.016375890001654625, -0.04203086346387863, 0.026519322767853737, 0.002869350602850318, 0.029849249869585037, -0.05210781469941139, -0.005835325922816992, 0.039510488510131836, -0.007446661125868559, 0.004324667621403933, 0.048750005662441254, 0.022151721641421318, -0.02974134497344494, -0.026465333998203278, -0.0009852575603872538, -0.006747552193701267, 0.0038965835701674223, -0.04726657271385193, -0.0048831552267074585, 0.012433436699211597, -0.06183517351746559, 0.024205252528190613, 0.017885897308588028, -0.05492548644542694, -0.05559954047203064, -0.00010524973913561553, 0.031859613955020905, 0.005169246345758438, -0.009595980867743492, -0.02540617436170578, -0.04160504788160324, -0.017012614756822586, 0.026404770091176033, 0.035960130393505096, 0.02018190547823906, -0.06545086205005646, -0.022843442857265472, -0.015638822689652443, -0.022424599155783653, 0.03400913253426552, -0.00439463322982192, 0.0028344737365841866, 0.009626361541450024, 0.015805313363671303, -0.027430199086666107, -0.0030595222488045692, -0.0523190014064312, 0.03038031980395317, -0.026709366589784622, -0.03319741040468216, 0.013604501262307167, 0.033422790467739105, -0.054208770394325256, 0.03396453335881233, -0.05018752068281174, -0.06210508570075035, -0.050228606909513474, -0.00034445803612470627, 0.051096703857183456, -0.025361090898513794, 0.03755661100149155, 0.016072601079940796, 0.008380132727324963, 0.02260580286383629, -0.07926440238952637, -0.08220602571964264, 0.01233045756816864, -0.005429733078926802, 0.017898932099342346, -0.009787221439182758, -0.024694155901670456, 0.10933392494916916, 0.022928250953555107, 0.019879629835486412, -0.009735089726746082, 0.050274915993213654, -0.03448982536792755, -0.04575694724917412, 0.00667303241789341, -0.014149325899779797, -0.02679908089339733, 0.06712125986814499, 0.035884544253349304, 0.030181605368852615, 0.0629606544971466, 0.026970863342285156, -0.012812832370400429, 0.004112024325877428, -0.006927184294909239, -0.014508949592709541, 0.06115074083209038, 0.004637978505343199, -0.016666095703840256, -0.02737092413008213, -0.00579821364954114, -0.002809536410495639, -0.013037401251494884, -0.05975009500980377, 0.018343385308980942, -0.003653158200904727, 0.02445303276181221, -0.015626613050699234, 0.07562728971242905, -0.009431105107069016, -0.03004767745733261, 0.029966235160827637, 0.010144202038645744, 0.07053789496421814, -0.051357679069042206, 0.02683834172785282, 0.06274592131376266, 0.052767764776945114, -0.01650085672736168, -0.031089596450328827, -0.015527166426181793, -0.004569937940686941, 0.03141259029507637, -0.0512717068195343, -0.009581207297742367, 0.0037985944654792547, 0.03121103346347809, 0.033776938915252686, -0.03886394202709198, -0.020617742091417313, -0.015454960986971855, -0.05871938169002533, 0.017965206876397133, -0.0014693262055516243, 0.06248054653406143, 0.012041258625686169, 0.070624440908432, 0.014771134592592716, -0.0028458533342927694, 0.04731260985136032, 0.013725251890718937, -0.059227097779512405, 0.017719870433211327, -0.012236345559358597, -0.022202078253030777, -0.015879357233643532, -0.003223576582968235, 0.031027428805828094, -0.02526746317744255, 0.013551543466746807, -0.010363577865064144, -0.022753139957785606, -0.02162475325167179, 0.01783355325460434, -0.041196346282958984, -0.01834005117416382, -0.019539643079042435, 0.013047441840171814, 0.007536857854574919, -0.011256353929638863, 0.029500186443328857, 0.033332839608192444, 0.011726959608495235, 0.011006554588675499, -0.04715871065855026, -0.01005319319665432, 0.005913433153182268, 0.033235497772693634, 0.022018391638994217, 0.031651608645915985, 0.01391261164098978, 0.02456003800034523, -0.005171041935682297, 0.02384653501212597, 0.06309783458709717, -0.009077491238713264, 0.010401999577879906, -0.06459388881921768, -0.028390944004058838, -0.009684999473392963, 0.011732788756489754, 0.022120444104075432, 0.010427609086036682, 0.04975531995296478, 0.026769861578941345, -0.038198038935661316, 0.035069938749074936, 0.03498949855566025, -0.020182983949780464, -0.01129052322357893, -0.033576849848032, 0.03432507812976837, -0.01695794053375721, 0.0015965020284056664, 0.024530859664082527, 0.0016133910976350307, -0.029120707884430885, 0.0006474617985077202, 0.06801794469356537, 0.009987039491534233, 0.008466851897537708, 0.01482602022588253, -0.03688895329833031, 0.03298472985625267, 0.00017428738647140563, -0.038579944521188736, -0.003042955882847309, 0.011370275169610977, -0.007049597334116697, 0.04354705661535263, -0.05393613502383232, -0.04886077716946602, -0.0594860203564167, -0.0025827863719314337, 0.040957916527986526, -0.02587706781923771, 0.02031923271715641, -0.057694002985954285, -0.04224291816353798, 0.041203923523426056, -0.00789737980812788, 0.044178593903779984, -0.016587356105446815, 0.0014934266218915582, 0.014786665327847004, -0.04097798839211464, -0.0582389160990715, 0.01296332385390997, -0.003752002725377679, 0.027750562876462936, -0.0344909206032753, -0.00568064721301198, -0.038479577749967575, 0.017255133017897606, 0.031329359859228134, 0.09296348690986633, -0.015760794281959534, -0.0024966117925941944, -0.01034903060644865, 0.00924624688923359, 0.012863289564847946, -0.09614654630422592, 0.01077290065586567, 0.0012068195501342416, -0.004460726864635944, 0.04132246971130371, -0.040553294122219086, -0.047142043709754944, 0.007395715452730656, 0.01754126325249672, -0.021644949913024902, 0.00651524355635047, -0.038318879902362823, 0.050905633717775345, 0.03623995929956436, 0.012875384651124477, 0.05917202681303024, 0.057902779430150986, 0.014098653569817543, 0.001069572870619595, -0.00899580493569374, -0.01534960325807333, -0.0024799390230327845, -0.01585531234741211, -0.04629569500684738, 0.029490899294614792, -0.013050757348537445, 0.024241719394922256, 0.0011472647311165929, 0.029080672189593315, -0.039537087082862854, -0.03357106074690819, -0.0039521013386547565, 0.0128240454941988, -0.004779883660376072, -0.023372074589133263, -0.011380692012608051, -0.016282454133033752, 0.012307848781347275, -0.02188178338110447, -0.0008475950453430414, -0.0401153564453125, -0.03661961853504181, 0.008434847928583622, -0.006686960346996784, 0.024702036753296852, -0.026945343241095543, -0.018313465639948845, 0.008198036812245846, -0.06903994083404541, 0.03291391208767891, 0.01958821341395378, 0.030210988596081734, 0.004977433010935783, -0.04429825767874718, -0.02914721891283989, -0.017394624650478363, -0.01324380747973919, -0.0015112278051674366, -0.05374794825911522, -0.0145527683198452, -0.010107140988111496, -0.021982688456773758, -0.0637945681810379, -0.066466324031353, 0.013888531364500523, 0.017607759684324265, -0.0008907563169486821, -0.01753605343401432, 0.012069136835634708, 0.007566422689706087, -0.03071928769350052, -0.011106511577963829, 0.013121436350047588, -0.03346457704901695, 0.008551744744181633, 0.0025723064318299294, 0.01663915067911148, 0.06670673191547394, 0.0211540088057518, -0.016505444422364235, 0.0019282926805317402, -0.032073311507701874, -0.03135096654295921, 0.03626517578959465, 0.016144610941410065, -0.0059986598789691925, -0.03265796974301338, 0.00853563379496336, 0.012005601078271866, 0.0011239077430218458, -0.011582816950976849, -0.003755174810066819, 0.027658401057124138, 0.01359721552580595, 0.0323248915374279, -0.02962479740381241, -0.02028217911720276, 0.019039198756217957, 0.00918589811772108, -0.026745285838842392, 0.010492424480617046, -0.020462365821003914, -0.005487673915922642, 0.020949602127075195, 0.003678532550111413, 0.03581898659467697, 0.013790919445455074, 0.07813464105129242, 0.008320491760969162, -0.03311724215745926, 0.031060870736837387, 0.01634240709245205, 0.03031000681221485, 0.016391295939683914, -0.02701581083238125, 0.032637424767017365, 0.019171427935361862, -0.005300481338053942, 0.02140708453953266, -0.03682626411318779, 0.00868029985576868, 0.08427412807941437, -0.013678320683538914, 0.04874575138092041, 0.024500694125890732, 0.027324561029672623, -0.014786061830818653, -0.007953113876283169, -0.005562343634665012, 0.006558384280651808, -0.029845934361219406, 0.0162647757679224, -0.0419992096722126, 0.023418264463543892, 0.02594427764415741, 0.019284415990114212, -0.007308813277631998, 0.020277315750718117, -0.014128039591014385, 0.012026481330394745, 0.011065077036619186, -0.026769984513521194, -0.034333858639001846, 0.01904647797346115, -0.04075592756271362, 0.03311045840382576, -0.03208356723189354, -0.08010491728782654, 0.07004842907190323, 0.010258637368679047, 0.03921721503138542, -0.04094986617565155, -0.03106897696852684, -0.03364715352654457, 0.00017157192633021623, 0.024892112240195274, 0.021952548995614052, 0.0018666295800358057, 0.022443316876888275, 0.03903466463088989, 0.018645277246832848, 0.03187738358974457, 0.007012885995209217, -0.08074537664651871, -0.017410894855856895, -0.01541405450552702, -0.035182006657123566, 0.020122703164815903, -0.0015157517045736313, 0.0032741038594394922, 0.04930109903216362, -0.03583592548966408, 0.011687695048749447, -0.005294161848723888, 0.035157233476638794, -0.01473316177725792, 0.08376094698905945, 0.011316398158669472, 0.03309163823723793, -0.007401584647595882, 0.027795154601335526, 0.09565884619951248, 0.07127976417541504, 0.004087735898792744, -0.056645121425390244, 0.025717010721564293, 0.006201293785125017, 0.004721845034509897, -0.03405839577317238, 0.03231055662035942, 0.008052948862314224, 0.0018293506000190973, 0.03610112518072128, 0.042886968702077866, -0.023017574101686478, -0.009398465044796467, 0.04407472535967827, -0.04833120107650757, -0.028247976675629616, -0.029367588460445404, 0.03127524256706238, 0.009428851306438446, 0.008274823427200317, -0.03819909319281578, 0.03191075846552849, -0.03761788457632065, -0.025483213365077972, -0.030253788456320763, 0.01091091986745596, -0.035857170820236206, -0.004359618294984102, -0.0052260588854551315, -0.00856164563447237, 0.04342895373702049, -0.03391332924365997, 0.01908732019364834, 0.033386293798685074, 0.01682998239994049, -0.02360152080655098, 0.027581054717302322, 0.03953984007239342, -0.0011354152811691165, 0.00572662428021431, 0.0176051277667284, -0.021886194124817848, -0.033324114978313446, -0.02158571220934391, -0.03075905703008175, 0.06389915198087692, -0.026141807436943054, 0.022310391068458557, 0.0036814617924392223, -0.0037440068554133177, 0.00028105464298278093, -0.041734080761671066, -0.010544361546635628, 0.019603636115789413, 0.027418162673711777, -0.02258758246898651, -0.007164767477661371, -0.038647137582302094, -0.009147288277745247, 0.013481990434229374, 0.04236512631177902, 0.03669488802552223, -0.06125521659851074, -0.05652874708175659, -0.04680081084370613, 0.06634432822465897, 0.015207339078187943, -0.008445648476481438, 0.0128396637737751, -0.06513024866580963, -0.012796478345990181, -0.012952568009495735, -0.02688039466738701, -0.030233200639486313, 0.03686129301786423, -0.01874665729701519, -0.016650864854454994, 0.014136817306280136, -0.016061117872595787, -0.00701890466734767, -0.02814161404967308, -0.007125426083803177, -0.01092999242246151, -0.042727552354335785, 0.03303838521242142, 0.06000681221485138, -0.023535043001174927, -0.027131391689181328, 0.018576763570308685, 0.05666444078087807, 0.014218976721167564, -0.038002487272024155, -0.016186675056815147, 0.0009273917530663311, 0.001268627936951816, 0.005933364853262901, -0.045502711087465286, 0.029687639325857162, 0.04724179208278656, 0.014558699913322926, 0.00014730097609572113, -0.003556702984496951, -0.022386953234672546, 0.04321759194135666, 0.01607411541044712, -0.02326457016170025, -0.015636209398508072, 0.016560837626457214, 0.010519797913730145, -0.03700845316052437, -0.011061364784836769, -0.007044004742056131, -0.016892926767468452, 0.02560945600271225, -0.02131917141377926, -0.054676368832588196, -0.027127983048558235, -0.022641155868768692, -0.03628815338015556, -0.0268908329308033, 0.002817033790051937, -0.01089275348931551, -0.002907485468313098, 0.009071004576981068, 0.03083687275648117, -0.01611694134771824, 0.014363675378262997, 0.002345518209040165, -0.016704099252820015, 0.05044212564826012, 0.015574325807392597, 0.015543296001851559, -0.014571696519851685, 0.018765980377793312, 0.0006696896743960679, 0.0451476089656353, -0.03792920708656311, -0.011554148979485035, 0.05070238560438156, -0.03317714110016823, 0.016568876802921295, 0.05118366703391075, 0.025263573974370956, 0.038158390671014786, 0.025797612965106964, -0.03293117508292198, -0.018346602097153664, 0.0001363123010378331, -0.009075953625142574, -0.031405527144670486, -0.010189770720899105, 0.004528629127889872, 0.0018621382769197226, 0.011636272072792053, -0.03728455305099487, 0.016016725450754166, 0.013807862065732479, 0.0183112770318985, -0.0030430706683546305, -0.02409159392118454, 0.006800638511776924, 0.0090058334171772, 0.0017362908693030477, 0.0018773553892970085, 0.032072484493255615, -0.03169455751776695, 0.02744225040078163, 0.029304195195436478, -0.033382534980773926, 0.013032462447881699, -0.0077891177497804165, -0.018305955454707146, -0.06004222109913826, 0.00612286664545536, 0.00989511888474226, -0.005120196379721165, 0.030189525336027145, -0.02943814918398857, 0.006884058937430382, -0.0018889174098148942, -0.013588669709861279, 0.008544637821614742, 0.026262953877449036, -0.0024277945049107075, -0.020751705393195152, 0.010091986507177353, -0.0011646067723631859, 0.03244810923933983, -0.010353307239711285, 0.020727982744574547, 0.068404421210289, 0.06785428524017334, 0.010785701684653759, -0.03692048415541649, -0.005498649552464485, -0.0015183360083028674, 0.02772613614797592, -0.04065493866801262, 0.05857418477535248, -0.061612818390131, -0.017735376954078674, 0.01746639981865883, 0.012528160586953163, -0.05094324052333832, -0.030344074591994286, 0.03494623675942421, 0.004795196000486612, 0.05424623563885689, 0.020909635350108147, 0.004683276638388634, 0.003503940999507904, 0.00031345110619440675, 0.031464654952287674, 0.004870097152888775, -0.0005140387220308185, -0.014534163288772106, 0.03665512800216675, -0.005455969832837582, -0.05171944573521614, 0.036775846034288406, 0.00962784793227911, -0.014708324335515499, 0.007081899791955948, -0.0018072481034323573, -0.0053350115194916725, -0.01997786946594715, 0.03200438246130943, -0.0770682767033577, -0.0238258708268404, 0.046389367431402206, 0.029963044449687004, -0.03026697225868702, -0.020060816779732704, 0.00980525091290474, -0.04425599053502083, 0.02011776901781559, 0.0030123128090053797, -0.027993859723210335, -0.04682047665119171, 0.007582542486488819, 0.011888289824128151, 0.010265210643410683, -0.016986269503831863, -0.015865551307797432, -0.07595107704401016, 0.0029446620028465986, -0.005361214280128479, -0.011913019232451916, 0.001839617732912302, 0.001472398405894637, 0.019623592495918274, -0.04430369287729263, 0.02230946347117424, 0.028151219710707664, 0.00443163700401783, -0.04650568962097168, -0.04467439278960228, -0.06402827054262161, 0.006928648799657822, 0.05608164519071579, 0.016278499737381935, -0.031668368726968765, -0.017577700316905975, 0.02387937344610691, 0.007191551849246025, -0.036045391112565994, 0.035892605781555176, -0.03264540806412697, -0.040986232459545135, -0.005399448797106743, -0.01745026558637619, 0.028459778055548668, 0.008668052032589912, 0.04099021852016449, -0.00468961987644434, -0.007608204614371061, -0.04811768978834152, -0.03085070662200451, -0.010251099243760109, -0.032913126051425934, -0.02378717064857483, 0.06541252881288528, -0.009409482590854168, -0.009616672992706299, 0.022116946056485176, -0.015307856723666191, -0.07856230437755585, 0.022388989105820656, -0.033427946269512177, -0.03549181669950485, 0.012601369991898537, 0.019290883094072342, 0.010098608210682869, -0.04548507183790207, 0.034271761775016785, 0.01619417779147625, -0.028345298022031784, -0.010102109983563423, 0.026922091841697693, 0.012058127671480179, 0.04260967671871185, -0.02102029323577881, -0.008355047553777695, 0.005375551991164684, -0.005630441941320896, 0.026822855696082115, 0.027480755001306534, 0.01951373741030693, -0.03740460053086281, 0.04597996547818184, 0.003364485688507557, 0.03577576205134392, 0.04229157790541649, 0.027276935055851936, 0.04619487747550011, -0.05166114121675491, 0.013075756840407848, 0.011177022010087967, -0.00263763964176178, 0.002328077796846628, 0.01504024863243103, -0.023266887292265892, 0.0639149397611618, -0.013946671970188618, 0.023776747286319733, -0.0006736867362633348, -0.01539253443479538, -0.011290298774838448, 0.0018757818033918738, 0.025228548794984818, 0.05260588601231575, 0.0006821039714850485, -0.010199952870607376, -0.02968970499932766, -0.056132249534130096, -0.014964237809181213, -0.04795759171247482, 0.0019035021541640162, 0.02029440365731716, -0.0016021585324779153, 0.010978956706821918, -0.025735339149832726, -0.0017337779281660914, -0.008791953325271606, 0.040539614856243134, 0.01241382583975792, 0.017827710136771202, -0.011568442918360233, -0.04149232059717178, -0.003592687426134944, 0.026938801631331444, -0.07075433433055878, -0.012460724450647831, -0.02765306457877159, 0.015750888735055923, 0.01711289770901203, -0.029239311814308167 ]
<p>In Rapid Miner, I created a predictive model (SVM) with Kernel type = polynomial, c= 10, and obtained 80.77% accuracy using cross validation. When compared to hold out set my accuracy on the test set was: 71.54472%. That is 9.23% difference. My questions are 1) Is my SVM model overfit? 2) I created other models like k-NN, decision trees, Naive bayes etc but they all gave accuracy of less than 70%. Will the difference against the hold out set be less than 9.23% ? </p>
36,986
[ -0.027345288544893265, -0.045694123953580856, -0.0243103988468647, -0.013924012891948223, 0.018577780574560165, -0.03382858261466026, -0.0035786812659353018, -0.026976153254508972, 0.053797729313373566, -0.01822611503303051, 0.0512138307094574, -0.005292247049510479, 0.051846034824848175, 0.041566602885723114, -0.0007955088512971997, 0.013674916699528694, 0.028652654960751534, -0.03931296244263649, 0.020552951842546463, 0.012462797574698925, -0.010955854319036007, 0.018204379826784134, 0.012919592671096325, 0.010172885842621326, -0.04495307430624962, 0.0533023402094841, 0.02158239111304283, -0.01263656746596098, 0.024398798123002052, -0.007358620874583721, -0.014072323217988014, -0.028996586799621582, 0.043840788304805756, 0.013100406154990196, 0.03555009886622429, 0.004496418870985508, 0.004766590893268585, -0.05959610268473625, -0.013877984136343002, 0.03427271172404289, 0.004515241365879774, -0.014130462892353535, -0.0016246994491666555, 0.03955581784248352, 0.03254951164126396, -0.01283316221088171, 0.0040389979258179665, -0.025842204689979553, 0.0443582721054554, -0.02305126003921032, 0.0335480235517025, 0.0018023926531895995, 0.02643725648522377, 0.0713462233543396, -0.00801598560065031, -0.024211784824728966, 0.04494859650731087, 0.13193975389003754, 0.0094258738681674, -0.05124996602535248, -0.008794066496193409, 0.0036005075089633465, -0.0049577150493860245, -0.01906977966427803, -0.02990683913230896, 0.059806644916534424, -0.042411305010318756, -0.03426188603043556, 0.004826204851269722, -0.026607774198055267, 0.026267435401678085, -0.014551020227372646, 0.004936540964990854, 0.020868247374892235, 0.05033685639500618, -0.026865279302001, -0.042329151183366776, 0.042274557054042816, 0.007669270969927311, 0.050375036895275116, 0.035128723829984665, 0.031721699982881546, 0.02416878752410412, 0.046532370150089264, 0.02243500016629696, -0.0083418358117342, 0.03587996959686279, 0.011623128317296505, 0.020386461168527603, 0.013555369339883327, -0.03490516170859337, 0.0532226637005806, 0.04383543133735657, -0.016638940200209618, -0.024892162531614304, 0.03770150616765022, -0.0023849583230912685, 0.010786502622067928, 0.013424696400761604, -0.013337800279259682, -0.011617269366979599, 0.005171685013920069, 0.037593599408864975, 0.08480478823184967, -0.022979428991675377, -0.0312870629131794, -0.007674831431359053, -0.011437762528657913, -0.031035015359520912, -0.04098996892571449, 0.01394126657396555, 0.016883818432688713, -0.0038337616715580225, 0.02268974296748638, 0.03260265663266182, -0.01400644239038229, 0.01943938247859478, -0.0392354354262352, 0.05572213977575302, 0.02785520628094673, 0.02962002344429493, 0.0005729419062845409, 0.006139329168945551, -0.028508851304650307, -0.00576998433098197, -0.005350412335246801, 0.019614435732364655, -0.001628054422326386, -0.04595199227333069, 0.04733873903751373, -0.0008487323648296297, -0.013681365177035332, 0.012877245433628559, -0.021079041063785553, 0.04483693093061447, 0.0025329587515443563, -0.11144889146089554, -0.04824381321668625, 0.03307977318763733, -0.0024973053950816393, 0.03471539169549942, -0.04298326373100281, 0.0009749096934683621, 0.030338872224092484, 0.04996955767273903, 0.01101166382431984, 0.04159677028656006, 0.008563891053199768, 0.02250833995640278, 0.000858104438520968, -0.059704896062612534, -0.024016717448830605, 0.005780753679573536, -0.006777753122150898, -0.031177116557955742, -0.08899880200624466, -0.011596152558922768, -0.008997292257845402, -0.022164588794112206, -0.0032308935187757015, -0.012358736246824265, -0.01457374170422554, -0.007431648671627045, -0.005579398944973946, 0.023328956216573715, -0.03194877505302429, 0.022267360240221024, 0.008556874468922615, 0.056639693677425385, 0.008183694444596767, -0.0060685863718390465, -0.02208271622657776, 0.040510207414627075, 0.01837090402841568, 0.035697780549526215, 0.022473514080047607, 0.0114824203774333, -0.04521340876817703, 0.036714136600494385, 0.007654896471649408, -0.06482680886983871, 0.0002612228272482753, -0.008752346970140934, 0.02105218544602394, -0.0038351204711943865, 0.03308438882231712, 0.0016587682766839862, -0.04281194135546684, 0.02841823920607567, -0.01438649371266365, -0.01565389521420002, -0.02155371569097042, 0.026807429268956184, -0.01579947955906391, 0.02532048337161541, 0.021023500710725784, 0.02214711159467697, 0.006417735479772091, -0.00717751681804657, -0.015992676839232445, -0.033930838108062744, 0.012153992429375648, 0.02443254180252552, -0.06733259558677673, -0.020701197907328606, 0.05453881993889809, -0.01395819429308176, -0.04021535441279411, 0.012929946184158325, -0.02127574011683464, -0.04989124462008476, 0.006439863238483667, -0.002580501837655902, -0.027891449630260468, -0.012188880704343319, -0.054317545145750046, 0.04663287103176117, 0.020244207233190536, -0.00038893611053936183, 0.03684818744659424, -0.03579623997211456, 0.05189462751150131, 0.053554046899080276, 0.010456177406013012, 0.011585233733057976, -0.011978060007095337, -0.025408199056982994, 0.034731216728687286, -0.02403835766017437, -0.01531044952571392, -0.04845369607210159, -0.023129573091864586, 0.03812394291162491, 0.042614176869392395, -0.032740142196416855, 0.040040548890829086, 0.07064414024353027, 0.0037704911082983017, 0.027176007628440857, -0.002759934403002262, -0.003111565485596657, -0.04179450124502182, 0.05109454318881035, 0.057081740349531174, -0.0023248670622706413, 0.008451365865767002, 0.006758776027709246, -0.002940777223557234, 0.010107859037816525, -0.012432539835572243, 0.02750210464000702, 0.02043374627828598, 0.0030270814895629883, -0.018082300201058388, -0.013822738081216812, -0.003279655473306775, 0.019351301714777946, -0.022225111722946167, -0.010167576372623444, 0.012155866250395775, 0.018186621367931366, 0.017273593693971634, -0.016242675483226776, -0.011175056919455528, 0.04305439442396164, 0.0499865896999836, -0.0012225121026858687, -0.014150933362543583, 0.020048901438713074, -0.06731794029474258, -0.026608170941472054, -0.03638550266623497, -0.030797621235251427, -0.07750135660171509, 0.04045373573899269, 0.05953187495470047, -0.009764453396201134, 0.029413634911179543, -0.011931926012039185, 0.004526216071099043, -0.018238481134176254, -0.036013323813676834, 0.043517012149095535, -0.00676210131496191, -0.08333981782197952, 0.011041341349482536, 0.006677798926830292, -0.014098905958235264, 0.0448092482984066, -0.04897846654057503, -0.003872525179758668, 0.013308295980095863, 0.0072731804102659225, -0.03778309002518654, 0.005092526786029339, -0.06327497959136963, 0.012994911521673203, -0.006867745891213417, -0.05103199556469917, 0.011627662926912308, -0.009441358968615532, -0.032174766063690186, 0.056266430765390396, -0.029230613261461258, 0.015660468488931656, -0.0014238471630960703, 0.00615311972796917, 0.013297737576067448, -0.012756632640957832, 0.032309744507074356, 0.02244463749229908, -0.0010516324546188116, 0.022989176213741302, -0.07006147503852844, -0.03408016636967659, -0.007582421880215406, -0.03589798882603645, -0.0029017797205597162, 0.030774764716625214, -0.010519362986087799, 0.06752606481313705, 0.03645344451069832, -0.02727128379046917, -0.047413285821676254, 0.01567848026752472, -0.06086396798491478, -0.018553324043750763, 0.014271397143602371, 0.0027688953559845686, 0.02850239910185337, -0.01685517467558384, -0.014802885241806507, 0.015846025198698044, 0.05471311882138252, -0.012099180370569229, -0.02658965438604355, 0.02637939155101776, 0.02086692862212658, -0.0022604616824537516, 0.05565684661269188, 0.01509190071374178, -0.011370470747351646, -0.006384990643709898, -0.015098363161087036, 0.014177937991917133, 0.03421156480908394, -0.04505251720547676, 0.05345204845070839, -0.027477433905005455, 0.040917184203863144, -0.004338501486927271, 0.024073228240013123, -0.021994153037667274, -0.05492734536528587, -0.008546500466763973, -0.010548482649028301, 0.026199109852313995, -0.021823860704898834, 0.021806593984365463, 0.048454649746418, 0.03899925947189331, -0.02589060366153717, -0.010223783552646637, -0.04308588057756424, -0.028939787298440933, 0.018685031682252884, 0.0034155158791691065, -0.01687196083366871, 0.03523700311779976, 0.042637038975954056, 0.007193897385150194, 0.004777059890329838, -0.006102157291024923, 0.009256275370717049, -0.08197498321533203, -0.01134076714515686, -0.042373936623334885, 0.0846073254942894, 0.017103424295783043, 0.024593137204647064, 0.013273424468934536, -0.0530526340007782, 0.007869858294725418, 0.005235334392637014, -0.055583614856004715, 0.008316410705447197, 0.018915776163339615, -0.0021794165950268507, -0.006004842929542065, -0.06579890847206116, 0.010631940327584743, -0.031434204429388046, 0.039531271904706955, 0.017720498144626617, 0.03274659812450409, -0.04701331630349159, 0.031566642224788666, -0.006888001225888729, 0.027997277677059174, -0.01566455140709877, 0.012490560300648212, -0.01851862296462059, -0.01959136314690113, 0.054692573845386505, 0.02041349746286869, -0.03811011463403702, -0.012857194058597088, -0.02234303206205368, -0.006316566374152899, 0.03257722407579422, 0.029317624866962433, 0.05753203481435776, 0.02687850221991539, -0.06722826510667801, 0.020365314558148384, 0.03679347410798073, 0.023348134011030197, 0.0689535140991211, 0.005486662965267897, -0.0028914182912558317, -0.0480959489941597, -0.039381567388772964, 0.017940761521458626, 0.013488070107996464, 0.01770344190299511, 0.004215045366436243, 0.026766570284962654, -0.01958940178155899, -0.06509662419557571, -0.010999071411788464, 0.03472079709172249, 0.010026671923696995, 0.005060168448835611, -0.056268949061632156, 0.017223769798874855, 0.006691173184663057, -0.008078496903181076, 0.009114513173699379, -0.009692835621535778, -0.05140219256281853, -0.015841789543628693, 0.04061928763985634, -0.018282312899827957, -0.05325920879840851, 0.03380536660552025, 0.011810779571533203, 0.02954396978020668, -0.019822698086500168, -0.01265712734311819, 0.011482622474431992, 0.03679317235946655, 0.04250801354646683, 0.016639025881886482, 0.035669080913066864, -0.0775752067565918, -0.007818840444087982, 0.048228029161691666, 0.043387386947870255, -0.05086860805749893, -0.013451928272843361, -0.0357666015625, -0.001457028090953827, -0.02727843075990677, -0.043592121452093124, 0.027323400601744652, -0.013743561692535877, 0.01906573958694935, -0.04027024656534195, -0.01634889841079712, -0.07363475859165192, -0.009303074330091476, -0.054976195096969604, 0.04595927521586418, -0.03200386092066765, -0.024495892226696014, 0.016820872202515602, 0.006754731759428978, 0.03615078330039978, 0.05745764076709747, -0.02776150591671467, -0.003984087612479925, -0.01560233160853386, 0.014195665717124939, -0.0007466728566214442, -0.06370518356561661, -0.01425192877650261, 0.0012266066623851657, -0.008678860031068325, 0.06634033471345901, -0.007023997604846954, -0.06529805064201355, 0.024370014667510986, 0.012983095832169056, -0.03124959021806717, -0.013625530526041985, -0.041234441101551056, 0.007361082825809717, 0.035236846655607224, -0.004108215216547251, 0.05608372390270233, 0.02796735055744648, 0.0003658286586869508, 0.013184170238673687, -0.03648102656006813, 0.012898525223135948, -0.040567416697740555, 0.0014147520996630192, -0.008816821500658989, -0.01622680202126503, -0.034648776054382324, 0.01442873664200306, 0.006841524504125118, 0.06605882942676544, -0.0399322435259819, 0.0292862169444561, 0.012143969535827637, 0.026843542233109474, -0.001884380471892655, 0.010353573597967625, -0.015913119539618492, 0.01364059466868639, -0.025413082912564278, -0.002233399311080575, -0.030479928478598595, -0.02102481573820114, 0.010626592673361301, 0.051018860191106796, -0.028356432914733887, 0.00753552233800292, -0.0232522115111351, -0.016848726198077202, 0.009674621745944023, -0.0035003328230232, 0.06596487760543823, 0.0287321750074625, 0.048100266605615616, 0.0066704354248940945, -0.037300076335668564, 0.03054957091808319, -0.0032966970466077328, 0.029863713309168816, 0.05083794146776199, -0.017940456047654152, 0.03555035591125488, 0.0056775473058223724, -0.026685817167162895, -0.07657637447118759, -0.044613637030124664, 0.029664654284715652, -0.013665175065398216, -0.05999085679650307, -0.03297273442149162, 0.00048117019468918443, -0.00212300568819046, -0.01812339387834072, -0.028865506872534752, 0.05828968062996864, -0.01706921122968197, 0.009067246690392494, 0.030041852965950966, -0.042319707572460175, 0.06018497794866562, 0.003457339247688651, -0.00027338374638929963, 0.012700680643320084, 0.01795453578233719, -0.03307097405195236, 0.03558406978845596, 0.00140706030651927, -0.005610126070678234, -0.01929548569023609, -0.02525199018418789, 0.03236811235547066, 0.06112908944487572, 0.01890258863568306, 0.0020659547299146652, 0.0010453220456838608, -0.006526818498969078, 0.02896520309150219, -0.000876903475727886, -0.053787101060152054, 0.008876213803887367, -0.0029691297095268965, 0.006901552900671959, -0.005431066732853651, -0.034889768809080124, -0.01756368950009346, 0.018409473821520805, -0.02330760657787323, 0.004963391460478306, 0.005960290785878897, 0.07831636071205139, -0.034977640956640244, 0.038045480847358704, 0.003031218657270074, -0.027999727055430412, 0.024859057739377022, -0.008903310634195805, 0.04828723892569542, 0.007501828484237194, 0.03332270681858063, -0.024646207690238953, -0.008917252533137798, 0.007042994257062674, 0.00014865442062728107, 0.046119075268507004, -0.010124702006578445, 0.05305862799286842, 0.0013706769095733762, -0.01041750330477953, -0.013879028148949146, -0.028123436495661736, -0.004493627697229385, -0.01699274778366089, 0.008454560302197933, 0.027063731104135513, 0.01304127462208271, 0.02616792730987072, 0.039643239229917526, 0.01707926020026207, 0.03138495236635208, 0.03163960576057434, 0.00514938635751605, 0.03138003870844841, 0.013348081149160862, 0.02001289278268814, -0.0518123023211956, 0.02507222257554531, -0.020544523373246193, -0.00013725848111789674, -0.0018560204189270735, 0.014149467460811138, 0.0232392568141222, 0.010916665196418762, 0.03653709590435028, -0.038775961846113205, -0.016861485317349434, -0.04799894243478775, -0.0029275885317474604, 0.03670336306095123, 0.00418896833434701, 0.03004753775894642, 0.01612026058137417, 0.009419037029147148, 0.019979268312454224, 0.0193795058876276, -0.03997334465384483, -0.09845498949289322, -0.013296094723045826, -0.03853348270058632, -0.03166862204670906, 0.015036111697554588, 0.002444898709654808, -0.04696696251630783, 0.0037593806628137827, -0.048869580030441284, 0.042096883058547974, -0.004263232462108135, -0.011872409842908382, -0.023101957514882088, 0.048697762191295624, -0.034263722598552704, 0.014693127945065498, 0.013571009039878845, -0.01245067361742258, 0.13103146851062775, 0.07222762703895569, 0.025833643972873688, -0.019987478852272034, -0.031277794390916824, -0.017171867191791534, -0.020719578489661217, -0.029259754344820976, 0.014534852467477322, -0.0017474174965173006, -0.02380838245153427, 0.03318772837519646, -0.005720201414078474, -0.030682342126965523, -0.020541071891784668, 0.05677188187837601, -0.001322092255577445, 0.005268046632409096, 0.01661457121372223, 0.012667546980082989, 0.01189469639211893, -0.020026355981826782, -0.03542336821556091, 0.014850571751594543, -0.008914303034543991, -0.0332341268658638, -0.01747230812907219, -0.001483321189880371, 0.03299694135785103, 0.016030341386795044, 0.0025864981580525637, 0.019009161740541458, -0.027641471475362778, 0.00011875959899043664, -0.04941822960972786, -0.02497510053217411, -0.005318216513842344, -0.01112002320587635, 0.009541992098093033, 0.013858160935342312, 0.031640805304050446, 0.005914544221013784, -0.019726723432540894, 0.024228962138295174, -0.0790637955069542, -0.006499181035906076, -0.07920897006988525, 0.04900253191590309, 0.028234213590621948, -0.012817966751754284, 0.0196557454764843, 0.012768164277076721, -0.011613903567194939, -0.014102375134825706, -0.04345420002937317, 0.024279450997710228, -0.011620196513831615, -0.02441701665520668, -0.07803193479776382, -0.01519543956965208, 0.028684541583061218, 0.019109390676021576, 0.01021639071404934, -0.014962048269808292, -0.0648789182305336, 0.003974397201091051, -0.01859302818775177, 0.04441983625292778, -0.019441571086645126, 0.024398861452937126, -0.014988829381763935, -0.0068146102130413055, 0.016727225854992867, -0.016316762194037437, 0.0328746996819973, -0.004849727731198072, 0.00501725310459733, -0.01672043651342392, -0.017804034054279327, -0.02431553043425083, -0.029924334958195686, 0.005042489152401686, -0.03337719291448593, 0.037986982613801956, -0.04108939692378044, 0.0011100559495389462, 0.010673966258764267, 0.01145536731928587, -0.008662999607622623, -0.011180431582033634, -0.008696484379470348, 0.04656665027141571, -0.00575817096978426, -0.045063093304634094, 0.0009828044567257166, -0.052983399480581284, -0.050025977194309235, 0.05863191932439804, -0.010911536403000355, 0.06336819380521774, 0.05277246609330177, -0.01138926763087511, -0.031814876943826675, 0.049287546426057816, 0.038459572941064835, 0.02072960138320923, -0.01605106331408024, -0.020049428567290306, 0.0007263830048032105, 0.012000583112239838, -0.014044519513845444, -0.036421824246644974, -0.04643421620130539, -0.043868742883205414, -0.03305589407682419, 0.04240890219807625, -0.018903357908129692, -0.04376186430454254, 0.01407234463840723, 0.008340590633451939, 0.03169289976358414, 0.010594742372632027, -0.005046631675213575, -0.025652019307017326, 0.007260983809828758, -0.03246675059199333, -0.04522933065891266, 0.0026368724647909403, -0.027173824608325958, -0.005416924599558115, -0.02152363583445549, 0.029786044731736183, -0.020834090188145638, -0.015834016725420952, -0.004270077683031559, 0.00031951474375091493, -0.02443602867424488, 0.052968770265579224, -0.02972128987312317, -0.003053193213418126, 0.04842592030763626, -0.04845147207379341, -0.029162859544157982, 0.06451465934515, 0.004343260545283556, 0.04512614756822586, 0.02332288771867752, 0.04755639657378197, 0.020924998447299004, 0.04119543731212616, 0.010233218781650066, -0.013033893890678883, 0.02550549991428852, 0.006314997561275959, 0.0028660129755735397, 0.03559480980038643, 0.01816069334745407, 0.01329471543431282, 0.01516739372164011, 0.00267120567150414, 0.011853989213705063, 0.015735628083348274, -0.022523749619722366, -0.003234539646655321, -0.02954288013279438, 0.0018293533939868212, 0.016358384862542152, -0.030021965503692627, 0.027483712881803513, -0.01832219585776329, -0.011716489680111408, 0.01685582660138607, -0.046606793999671936, 0.003548182314261794, -0.08599305897951126, -0.028431041166186333, -0.002389814704656601, 0.026909787207841873, 0.02097327448427677, -0.022438647225499153, -0.00902580562978983, 0.04733527824282646, -0.046969592571258545, 0.028217803686857224, -0.009437787346541882, 0.00008039040403673425, -0.043590247631073, 0.016195204108953476, -0.028214920312166214, -0.027590014040470123, 0.027001293376088142, -0.006626996211707592, 0.03771926835179329, 0.0217827707529068, -0.025002123787999153, -0.01994968019425869, -0.01705186627805233, 0.04261321946978569, -0.025407306849956512, -0.02762717194855213, 0.011173875071108341, -0.03238106518983841, -0.009677020832896233, 0.01425271388143301, -0.012676049023866653, -0.014860429801046848, 0.06722333282232285, 0.027202023193240166, -0.025001324713230133, 0.03881508857011795, 0.058712188154459, -0.02783043496310711, -0.0014854494947940111, -0.008675954304635525, -0.02174101397395134, -0.0013106581754982471, 0.0006774979992769659, 0.02416009083390236, 0.022813687101006508, -0.004957067314535379, 0.013395555317401886, 0.03295977786183357, -0.02498778887093067, -0.029613224789500237, 0.0022153633181005716, 0.017298879101872444, -0.011542605236172676, -0.03579092025756836, -0.04883580282330513, -0.0035689205396920443, -0.0004036438767798245, 0.003897168906405568, 0.02890738472342491, -0.015363994985818863, -0.007739560678601265, -0.031032748520374298, -0.04910515993833542, 0.003348352387547493, 0.016682082787156105, -0.012477890588343143, -0.04107578098773956, -0.032840315252542496, 0.0409872904419899, -0.021139906719326973, -0.03582785278558731, -0.007950435392558575, -0.02566021867096424, 0.08253072947263718, -0.03260679170489311, 0.022869106382131577, 0.05304281786084175, -0.018204065039753914, -0.0067517803981900215, -0.0720473900437355, 0.09024026989936829, -0.01597958616912365, -0.039597902446985245, -0.031551580876111984, 0.019343510270118713, -0.00810133758932352, -0.020566167309880257, 0.023586129769682884, 0.042636439204216, -0.007199237588793039, -0.012846817262470722, -0.016649600118398666, -0.0035062660463154316, -0.06372977793216705, 0.016380971297621727, -0.015484899282455444, -0.012735328637063503, -0.0036984323523938656, -0.020224163308739662, 0.003113850951194763, 0.041656579822301865, 0.026636917144060135, -0.006463094148784876, 0.0036654912400990725, 0.028229812160134315, -0.01948966644704342, -0.0014331592246890068, 0.020733390003442764, 0.02403029054403305, 0.03985598310828209, -0.012142215855419636, -0.002626231638714671, 0.015617674216628075, -0.033059436827898026, -0.04759015515446663, 0.048333220183849335, -0.024094481021165848, 0.0035169802140444517, -0.004283012356609106, 0.009924257174134254, 0.020559923723340034, -0.060980163514614105, -0.028912950307130814, 0.04695834219455719, -0.02045070379972458, 0.011373224668204784, 0.04059002548456192, 0.01354188472032547, 0.019184917211532593, -0.014306822791695595, 0.07375672459602356, -0.009867362678050995, -0.03781086206436157, 0.0070051392540335655, 0.017501840367913246, 0.014957661740481853, 0.03223932534456253, 0.037553705275058746, 0.008514043875038624, -0.008055617101490498, 0.002235190477222204, 0.021354878321290016, 0.061240654438734055, -0.02622685395181179, -0.012011227197945118, -0.001810727291740477, 0.005141331348568201, 0.002405507955700159, 0.011614525690674782, -0.02912740409374237, 0.054955460131168365, -0.05121820047497749, -0.03182896971702576, -0.050153620541095734, -0.022893304005265236, 0.016246642917394638, 0.024961119517683983, 0.03280782699584961, 0.023387346416711807, 0.014524917118251324, -0.0009913734393194318, 0.020030593499541283, 0.03287222608923912, 0.06673600524663925, 0.010156858712434769, -0.012676347978413105, -0.01697615534067154, 0.010171446017920971, -0.024729527533054352, -0.0003962006594520062, -0.024105388671159744, -0.01043158769607544, 0.050894372165203094, 0.041976649314165115, 0.002355372766032815, -0.001773820142261684, -0.02925722301006317, 0.012950103729963303, 0.024301249533891678, -0.04653151333332062, 0.011711137369275093, -0.01600569486618042, 0.011145636439323425, 0.0012739022495225072, -0.030749667435884476 ]
<p>Using wikipedia I found a way to calculate the probability mass function resulting from the sum of two Poisson random variables. However, I think that the approach I have is wrong.</p> <p>Let $X_1, X_2$ be two independent Poisson random variables with mean $\lambda_1, \lambda_2$, and $S_2 = a_1 X_1+a_2 X_2$, where the $a_1$ and $a_2$ are constants, then the probability-generating function of $S_2$ is given by $$ G_{S_2}(z) = \operatorname{E}(z^{S_2})= \operatorname{E}(z^{a_1 X_1+a_2 X_2}) G_{X_1}(z^{a_1})G_{X_2}(z^{a_2}). $$ Now, using the fact that the probability-generating function for a Poisson random variable is $G_{X_i}(z) = \textrm{e}^{\lambda_i(z - 1)}$, we can write the probability-generating function of the sum of the two independent Poisson random variables as $$ \begin{aligned} G_{S_2}(z) &amp;= \textrm{e}^{\lambda_1(z^{a_1} - 1)}\textrm{e}^{\lambda_2(z^{a_2} - 1)} \\ &amp;= \textrm{e}^{\lambda_1(z^{a_1} - 1)+\lambda_2(z^{a_2} - 1)}. \end{aligned} $$ It seems that the probability mass function of $S_2$ is recovered by taking derivatives of $G_{S_2}(z)$ $\operatorname{Pr}(S_2 = k) = \frac{G_{S_2}^{(k)}(0)}{k!}$, where $G_{S_2}^{(k)} = \frac{d^k G_{S_2}(z)}{ d z^k}$.</p> <p>Is this is correct? I have the feeling I cannot just take the derivative to obtain the probability mass function, because of the constants $a_1$ and $a_2$. Is this right? Is there an alternative approach?</p> <p>If this is correct can I now obtain an approximation of the cumulative distribution by truncating the infinite sum over all k?</p>
74,233
[ -0.02175385132431984, -0.009775515645742416, 0.01326502114534378, -0.01837342418730259, 0.01047227531671524, -0.03662637621164322, -0.011270135641098022, -0.03581342473626137, 0.024509970098733902, -0.045359063893556595, 0.01564209908246994, 0.023093776777386665, 0.06475137174129486, 0.009827635250985622, 0.02344641089439392, 0.014257005415856838, -0.010431832633912563, -0.0018669071141630411, -0.0027400387916713953, -0.010881858877837658, -0.008955413475632668, 0.006925536319613457, -0.008709201589226723, -0.04486605152487755, -0.026939015835523605, 0.04373329505324364, 0.012949280440807343, -0.029558058828115463, -0.029068751260638237, 0.08847810328006744, -0.03915322944521904, -0.02601657807826996, 0.012386473827064037, 0.06469351053237915, 0.006854755338281393, 0.013946725986897945, -0.048998214304447174, -0.045496705919504166, 0.0028174854815006256, 0.05188244208693504, -0.026444412767887115, -0.0007884118822403252, -0.020472092553973198, 0.031592655926942825, -0.04785577952861786, 0.027152154594659805, -0.012530272826552391, -0.062144987285137177, 0.028079312294721603, -0.04912298917770386, 0.025119731202721596, 0.011052634567022324, 0.024373460561037064, 0.009506134316325188, -0.021002022549510002, 0.00575274508446455, 0.01875828579068184, 0.03633090481162071, 0.02487192302942276, -0.06082858890295029, -0.026516079902648926, -0.002286867005750537, -0.004001121502369642, -0.04628348723053932, -0.011860659345984459, -0.017990993335843086, 0.0021271712612360716, -0.055058423429727554, 0.02813083864748478, -0.006103105843067169, 0.03388860821723938, -0.0032008071430027485, 0.021810270845890045, -0.030980970710515976, -0.01168622262775898, 0.007660001516342163, 0.010227914899587631, 0.003479471430182457, 0.0433446504175663, 0.0006331295589916408, 0.027265608310699463, 0.009917535819113255, 0.03810018301010132, 0.01441842969506979, 0.031378310173749924, -0.01207909919321537, 0.09310943633317947, 0.031180957332253456, 0.0047581433318555355, 0.008413932286202908, -0.009477459825575352, 0.014802965335547924, 0.005414249375462532, -0.05807674303650856, 0.009387969970703125, 0.034127332270145416, -0.03092879429459572, -0.002723481273278594, -0.027943026274442673, 0.0065046497620642185, -0.034041665494441986, -0.04515095800161362, 0.030428333207964897, 0.08403191715478897, -0.014089230448007584, -0.000648009474389255, 0.006995076313614845, 0.006708941422402859, -0.05143437534570694, -0.018129810690879822, 0.0027368743903934956, 0.03570777177810669, 0.00841605570167303, -0.018348241224884987, -0.03361576423048973, 0.02737811766564846, 0.013712065294384956, 0.03907471150159836, 0.016654573380947113, 0.061587050557136536, 0.006703075021505356, -0.04102243483066559, -0.00020878587383776903, -0.06360512971878052, -0.02242864854633808, -0.032305244356393814, 0.034712567925453186, 0.0031704206485301256, -0.06462135165929794, 0.05837142467498779, 0.05731789767742157, -0.02196429669857025, 0.033657900989055634, 0.030020270496606827, -0.00028128508711233735, -0.01727808266878128, -0.04371068626642227, -0.01913490891456604, 0.04309052228927612, -0.019942060112953186, 0.06224888563156128, -0.06395860761404037, -0.02470872923731804, 0.04274709150195122, 0.04538382217288017, 0.03519158437848091, 0.024149764329195023, -0.020891420543193817, 0.0690472424030304, 0.024714894592761993, -0.016841450706124306, -0.01693638041615486, -0.004222358111292124, -0.023007959127426147, -0.008464276790618896, -0.04863332584500313, 0.030757199972867966, -0.012026619166135788, -0.006024654489010572, 0.006943441927433014, 0.06549524515867233, 0.016469867900013924, 0.0014571761712431908, -0.0051101273857057095, 0.04893573001027107, -0.043170373886823654, 0.03452209010720253, 0.04147905856370926, -0.010897473432123661, 0.010786992497742176, -0.045335378497838974, -0.0009512827964499593, -0.011990315280854702, 0.04289945587515831, 0.018367767333984375, -0.0330977663397789, -0.025315064936876297, -0.05185332149267197, 0.02535214275121689, 0.004892285447567701, -0.030366715043783188, -0.0014087450690567493, -0.028072066605091095, 0.010335148312151432, 0.02256804332137108, 0.007762504275888205, 0.013058016076683998, 0.019735483452677727, -0.010615476407110691, -0.010858939029276371, -0.03798669949173927, -0.018729938194155693, 0.0051345727406442165, 0.02186995930969715, 0.00578800356015563, 0.02685621939599514, -0.0034619728103280067, 0.00827771332114935, 0.015046205371618271, -0.03579019010066986, 0.018530651926994324, -0.01563422568142414, 0.02179577574133873, -0.03837401419878006, 0.013899164274334908, 0.04894082248210907, 0.061613358557224274, 0.017653191462159157, 0.061272360384464264, -0.026583801954984665, -0.024143308401107788, 0.0005491101182997227, 0.01937500201165676, 0.021735474467277527, -0.012589996680617332, 0.012026547454297543, 0.04109891876578331, 0.027893783524632454, 0.0187456626445055, 0.00325606158003211, -0.05264505743980408, 0.007914913818240166, 0.07333491742610931, 0.05393417924642563, 0.01882992871105671, 0.03827008977532387, 0.013878747820854187, 0.02575184404850006, -0.009306383319199085, -0.004907385911792517, -0.02395724132657051, -0.022012673318386078, 0.05960030481219292, 0.021912921220064163, -0.02352503128349781, -0.012485610321164131, 0.05339958891272545, 0.002791810315102339, 0.030657632276415825, 0.038461834192276, -0.018313376232981682, -0.037319544702768326, 0.031153177842497826, 0.025030847638845444, 0.03529895469546318, 0.0010350738884881139, 0.017261609435081482, -0.030197273939847946, 0.01606331393122673, 0.012683521956205368, -0.022686993703246117, 0.03898695111274719, -0.01756320893764496, 0.01959531381726265, -0.03924092277884483, -0.006677196826785803, 0.04545774310827255, 0.006415537558495998, 0.0038910454604774714, 0.0419682152569294, 0.01531841978430748, 0.0010170333553105593, -0.04283755645155907, -0.0005803402746096253, 0.027631979435682297, -0.02087521180510521, -0.04548618942499161, 0.009714167565107346, 0.004632246680557728, -0.011325303465127945, 0.018236719071865082, -0.00034686614526435733, -0.044631678611040115, 0.003141522640362382, 0.008038302883505821, 0.015713682398200035, -0.00505291111767292, -0.016814112663269043, 0.010831690393388271, -0.03473079577088356, -0.006589858327060938, 0.002431080210953951, 0.06154060736298561, 0.029509278014302254, -0.08195789158344269, -0.025386186316609383, -0.02993215061724186, -0.024707039818167686, 0.056393228471279144, 0.014091507531702518, -0.005265275947749615, 0.007289338856935501, 0.025152085348963737, -0.043258652091026306, -0.014298145659267902, -0.0529174767434597, 0.007443104404956102, -0.07681707292795181, 0.0006022827583365142, 0.059778399765491486, 0.02314363233745098, -0.038382332772016525, 0.006668519228696823, 0.006863926537334919, -0.05734821781516075, -0.03119230456650257, -0.0077145216055214405, 0.03704816848039627, -0.020615695044398308, 0.040909573435783386, 0.01484596636146307, 0.0237075537443161, -0.014231051318347454, -0.07309865206480026, -0.05112583935260773, 0.0253460556268692, -0.008240357972681522, 0.05111688748002052, 0.006965357810258865, -0.03445598483085632, 0.08788307756185532, -0.016791384667158127, 0.03473393991589546, 0.052368324249982834, 0.0311777051538229, -0.010373888537287712, -0.029782673344016075, 0.011449879966676235, -0.013272079639136791, -0.028065063059329987, 0.045283883810043335, 0.011995716020464897, -0.024469686672091484, 0.07160598784685135, -0.03966177627444267, -0.014218947850167751, 0.040097445249557495, 0.028386052697896957, -0.00472091231495142, 0.03876031935214996, -0.036896176636219025, -0.013253260403871536, -0.007707840763032436, -0.008209832943975925, 0.03147977590560913, -0.028145264834165573, -0.07050282508134842, 0.01527022197842598, 0.008481254801154137, 0.001536763971671462, 0.002178854774683714, 0.03833654150366783, 0.012650660239160061, -0.046962060034275055, 0.023237666115164757, -0.0148629667237401, 0.06495938450098038, -0.05833766609430313, 0.028926480561494827, 0.04998777434229851, 0.048884376883506775, -0.011133650317788124, -0.03542104363441467, -0.03998943790793419, -0.03138125315308571, 0.021067772060632706, -0.02003597654402256, -0.015947964042425156, 0.006438145413994789, 0.018791647627949715, -0.009196728467941284, -0.04142378643155098, -0.01605287939310074, -0.022245891392230988, -0.06655146181583405, 0.018239090219140053, -0.019034206867218018, 0.05019661784172058, 0.0035455406177788973, 0.059130847454071045, 0.022482488304376602, 0.01835249550640583, -0.044580139219760895, -0.016523092985153198, -0.08267917484045029, -0.0014099855907261372, -0.01584131456911564, -0.014134380966424942, -0.016673456877470016, -0.02368324063718319, 0.04202662780880928, -0.0007517661433666945, -0.0007077710470184684, -0.022293826565146446, -0.012911958619952202, -0.034845370799303055, -0.004041493404656649, -0.04087125509977341, -0.0540594607591629, -0.019435817375779152, 0.016883663833141327, 0.021811898797750473, -0.0164779145270586, 0.026996001601219177, 0.031153129413723946, 0.014978224411606789, -0.015015658922493458, -0.05506901070475578, 0.016133306547999382, 0.002653831383213401, 0.009384454227983952, 0.0034991458524018526, 0.029295453801751137, 0.0033719122875481844, 0.003017963143065572, 0.006166559178382158, 0.04512592777609825, 0.03383863717317581, 0.01870816759765148, -0.003228052519261837, -0.030983613803982735, -0.04392482340335846, -0.015881849452853203, 0.03400368615984917, 0.0017378161428496242, -0.0005620972951874137, 0.024585342034697533, 0.023664982989430428, 0.019216274842619896, 0.04135425016283989, 0.039502352476119995, -0.020256832242012024, 0.008694995194673538, -0.048868175595998764, 0.02697904035449028, -0.020720399916172028, -0.011408217251300812, 0.009909247048199177, -0.0407031774520874, -0.01606983318924904, -0.004836483858525753, 0.02498614601790905, -0.004568182863295078, -0.0001835785951698199, -0.010996466502547264, -0.0030031485948711634, 0.03972655534744263, 0.0397467240691185, -0.0442393496632576, 0.006869517732411623, 0.004458628129214048, -0.00617288937792182, 0.0338115431368351, 0.00023987390159163624, -0.04647495225071907, -0.0366961695253849, 0.01046113483607769, 0.030413353815674782, -0.009459974244236946, 0.022922739386558533, -0.06389269977807999, -0.05174194276332855, 0.01788514293730259, 0.007604713551700115, 0.05408289283514023, -0.014861583709716797, 0.030242322012782097, 0.029133429750800133, -0.009750558994710445, -0.034223075956106186, 0.032456427812576294, -0.009739093482494354, -0.031172657385468483, -0.0551522821187973, 0.0275423564016819, -0.04795340076088905, -0.0031475508585572243, 0.012107138521969318, 0.06420537084341049, 0.019369233399629593, -0.018138037994503975, -0.02302231825888157, 0.02874327264726162, -0.008304949849843979, -0.09351096302270889, 0.011433894746005535, -0.030473792925477028, -0.006401365157216787, 0.042871687561273575, -0.04759131744503975, -0.04053052142262459, 0.023673173040151596, 0.0153829799965024, 0.019612574949860573, 0.012334732338786125, 0.022941509261727333, 0.05168658494949341, 0.04610432684421539, -0.02810405008494854, 0.10074841976165771, 0.05900334194302559, -0.028551051393151283, 0.003949495032429695, 0.006599679589271545, 0.00262495712377131, -0.026426857337355614, -0.020490091294050217, -0.07804607599973679, 0.02136891335248947, -0.04243830218911171, 0.016308721154928207, 0.008495746180415154, 0.014430630952119827, -0.009375635534524918, -0.018343713134527206, 0.028877612203359604, 0.006175041198730469, -0.0011759981280192733, 0.0054264552891254425, -0.01684613525867462, 0.008471574634313583, 0.0031093796715140343, -0.01944195106625557, 0.014605402015149593, -0.01963968016207218, 0.0008587925112806261, -0.024714965373277664, -0.05353988707065582, 0.032478392124176025, -0.042730867862701416, -0.001986998599022627, 0.05658057704567909, -0.01800546795129776, 0.04900957643985748, -0.005929021164774895, 0.0020115901716053486, 0.026902640238404274, -0.055989038199186325, -0.04248575121164322, 0.019822726026177406, 0.014297048561275005, 0.0044458056800067425, -0.026262372732162476, -0.019885385408997536, 0.02111940272152424, -0.044652219861745834, -0.07857290655374527, 0.020309830084443092, 0.04851209744811058, -0.004857048857957125, -0.0020820777863264084, -0.036073554307222366, 0.008823494426906109, -0.008121446706354618, -0.02310795895755291, 0.00019731419160962105, 0.02382548153400421, -0.007348593324422836, 0.004269138444215059, -0.0051628961227834225, 0.01145296823233366, 0.060433294624090195, 0.006094596814364195, 0.005951848812401295, 0.02181934006512165, -0.029190298169851303, -0.0102872708812356, 0.007478539366275072, 0.007790831848978996, 0.008187143132090569, 0.03063538856804371, 0.009818688035011292, -0.029287979006767273, -0.01629166305065155, -0.022200850769877434, -0.037006840109825134, 0.0038047018460929394, 0.028868772089481354, 0.04703813046216965, -0.038532041013240814, -0.05327196419239044, 0.004501607269048691, 0.025082262232899666, -0.020938223227858543, -0.02973654307425022, 0.004966189619153738, 0.020335854962468147, -0.028785254806280136, -0.004627243150025606, -0.00312597444280982, 0.01487249881029129, 0.03793971613049507, -0.012225182726979256, -0.039608247578144073, 0.009422596544027328, 0.0022317124530673027, 0.042082950472831726, -0.02965727634727955, 0.0013421758776530623, 0.07391596585512161, 0.006794995162636042, -0.018941044807434082, 0.0177178755402565, -0.05777094513177872, 0.042850397527217865, 0.06452126801013947, -0.023289036005735397, 0.042971186339855194, 0.030098646879196167, 0.017633110284805298, 0.00017986312741413713, -0.020144041627645493, -0.009710290469229221, 0.0012553537962958217, -0.025284359231591225, 0.007475524675101042, -0.061375878751277924, -0.01609243080019951, 0.05462132394313812, -0.0029496578499674797, -0.030044659972190857, 0.0182874146848917, -0.03456154838204384, 0.02746749296784401, 0.015763530507683754, -0.029886892065405846, -0.03931286931037903, 0.03825489059090614, -0.027875438332557678, 0.005460128653794527, -0.030153190717101097, -0.017401598393917084, 0.03641944006085396, 0.03252473473548889, -0.01858614943921566, -0.04480702430009842, -0.02434444986283779, -0.045196570456027985, 0.03362727537751198, 0.028156273066997528, 0.008536715060472488, 0.06311505287885666, -0.0061217667534947395, 0.02082926407456398, -0.004201667383313179, 0.03644883632659912, 0.00832744874060154, -0.038138676434755325, 0.027910256758332253, -0.0313759371638298, -0.0851665809750557, 0.026275143027305603, -0.0309681985527277, -0.017355700954794884, 0.017112750560045242, -0.01360876951366663, 0.012130474671721458, 0.023220624774694443, 0.015835527330636978, 0.0001566584105603397, 0.07638353854417801, 0.003981385380029678, 0.0330859050154686, -0.019437164068222046, 0.0013352921232581139, 0.1511189341545105, 0.019417382776737213, -0.004317054059356451, -0.051056090742349625, -0.006107698194682598, 0.01786169968545437, 0.010085123591125011, -0.04715048894286156, 0.02712264098227024, -0.008172057569026947, -0.030693188309669495, 0.017534663900732994, 0.05678778141736984, -0.026818323880434036, -0.03846706077456474, 0.037224654108285904, 0.00695807347074151, -0.0035080225206911564, -0.03804405406117439, 0.025842074304819107, -0.036175522953271866, 0.00501274224370718, -0.011724025011062622, 0.007161434274166822, -0.029099564999341965, 0.009266517125070095, -0.03694885969161987, 0.032905463129282, -0.0769186019897461, -0.007421680726110935, -0.03352675214409828, 0.013754576444625854, 0.05655631050467491, -0.0024483739398419857, 0.009773007594048977, 0.028067275881767273, -0.010545896366238594, -0.011203030124306679, 0.0017267895163968205, 0.04114283621311188, 0.01464735809713602, 0.019749252125620842, 0.033391073346138, -0.004252277314662933, -0.05789807066321373, -0.023172590881586075, -0.046789754182100296, 0.05650202929973602, -0.01903599500656128, 0.015215185470879078, -0.013356268405914307, -0.06946796178817749, 0.010433065705001354, 0.012306162156164646, 0.013618328608572483, 0.0020005458500236273, 0.005541498772799969, -0.047994598746299744, 0.01277513150125742, -0.038987480103969574, 0.04859060421586037, 0.02017010748386383, 0.02737177349627018, 0.015051561407744884, -0.06854022294282913, -0.03058578260242939, -0.005321701988577843, 0.030780980363488197, 0.007560683414340019, -0.007333538495004177, -0.022609462961554527, -0.0040007117204368114, -0.027724212035536766, -0.0344838947057724, -0.043562762439250946, -0.0299519132822752, 0.05073340982198715, 0.005350321065634489, 0.002219011075794697, -0.0067585911601781845, -0.034311506897211075, 0.037077680230140686, -0.04182311147451401, 0.004475584253668785, -0.009236305020749569, -0.027651838958263397, 0.017699692398309708, 0.034578580409288406, -0.033897798508405685, 0.015199878253042698, 0.0175157617777586, 0.06124483793973923, 0.0066696167923510075, -0.044601332396268845, 0.028241651132702827, 0.026441391557455063, -0.01100830640643835, -0.029104843735694885, -0.04112914577126503, 0.017227839678525925, 0.050019871443510056, 0.0615679956972599, -0.023345764726400375, -0.011716911569237709, -0.03563414141535759, 0.029293866828083992, 0.02519170381128788, -0.015303046442568302, 0.005437785759568214, 0.04370025917887688, 0.048165637999773026, 0.006963205989450216, 0.0005270980764180422, 0.028484126552939415, -0.020725982263684273, -0.003311330685392022, -0.016819247975945473, -0.023593049496412277, -0.03716752305626869, -0.031461991369724274, 0.018070325255393982, 0.006384005304425955, 0.002070599002763629, 0.0023653621319681406, 0.034340400248765945, -0.0014040846144780517, -0.009168408811092377, -0.012525820173323154, 0.01415215153247118, 0.01664256677031517, 0.01598690077662468, 0.05679914727807045, 0.021870335564017296, 0.004796440713107586, -0.019694751128554344, 0.05644146725535393, -0.04722988232970238, 0.03579822555184364, 0.04269546642899513, 0.0038141401018947363, 0.027980556711554527, -0.020739305764436722, -0.022736024111509323, 0.040893033146858215, 0.026713773608207703, 0.03977673128247261, 0.02634705789387226, -0.02417410910129547, -0.015347384847700596, 0.009177006781101227, -0.025137508288025856, -0.031620901077985764, -0.05437484011054039, -0.015341893769800663, 0.02075350657105446, -0.005834989249706268, -0.013908177614212036, 0.004713037516921759, 0.0027713568415492773, -0.015075906179845333, -0.010206305421888828, -0.039453428238630295, -0.03500935807824135, 0.018015766516327858, -0.044821955263614655, 0.008285615593194962, 0.01027827337384224, 0.008026761934161186, 0.055525556206703186, 0.0819503590464592, 0.017055252566933632, -0.018516283482313156, -0.0255887471139431, -0.0201035775244236, -0.07172811776399612, -0.004970958456397057, 0.012260152958333492, 0.009352615103125572, 0.039546262472867966, -0.0008926320588216186, 0.0003964205679949373, -0.002556971972808242, -0.018567468971014023, 0.02422400191426277, -0.007058321498334408, -0.007642917335033417, -0.03394054248929024, -0.00673263194039464, -0.021272582933306694, 0.019183780997991562, 0.01715620793402195, 0.038828350603580475, 0.04715008661150932, 0.07356492429971695, -0.010995140299201012, -0.017124826088547707, -0.03958403691649437, 0.027512479573488235, -0.015504701994359493, -0.05466318503022194, 0.0612466037273407, -0.026626454666256905, 0.013123877346515656, 0.00833880715072155, 0.01849021203815937, -0.018114261329174042, -0.04791616275906563, 0.03287048265337944, 0.021593742072582245, 0.027645260095596313, 0.005263307131826878, 0.02182300016283989, 0.020674875006079674, 0.00011012880713678896, 0.02230917662382126, -0.003554856637492776, -0.050713930279016495, 0.007313430774956942, 0.029539775103330612, 0.009499608539044857, -0.034873511642217636, 0.029740896075963974, -0.006076682358980179, -0.032407693564891815, 0.02214634232223034, -0.03545593470335007, -0.007174871861934662, -0.008828345686197281, 0.021433452144265175, -0.05441432073712349, -0.002779504517093301, 0.052666883915662766, 0.008100172504782677, -0.03163374960422516, 0.019584814086556435, -0.008474343456327915, -0.03246590867638588, 0.042234867811203, 0.009710286743938923, -0.02224598079919815, -0.025834230706095695, -0.017450690269470215, -0.015614429488778114, 0.0095094945281744, -0.005194775760173798, -0.02580227516591549, -0.03644777461886406, 0.014243300072848797, 0.006009453907608986, 0.009273877367377281, -0.04559410735964775, 0.012791209854185581, 0.05672142654657364, -0.07678148150444031, 0.005709844175726175, 0.011513964273035526, -0.04105004295706749, -0.030199747532606125, -0.04645194485783577, 0.02516602724790573, -0.00405633170157671, 0.0632132962346077, 0.01309912744909525, -0.008916495367884636, -0.01422205101698637, 0.032937437295913696, 0.0453592985868454, -0.041044335812330246, 0.018939724192023277, -0.030530879274010658, 0.002555240411311388, -0.03119770810008049, -0.011125173419713974, -0.01814979314804077, 0.042733047157526016, 0.023717151954770088, -0.00990043394267559, 0.01599140278995037, -0.026178283616900444, -0.011037698946893215, 0.04702804610133171, -0.020768625661730766, -0.04006969928741455, 0.06099366396665573, -0.005652614403516054, 0.01075648795813322, 0.0011993998195976019, 0.0015418552793562412, -0.028945820406079292, 0.02054346352815628, -0.025506693869829178, -0.009059606119990349, -0.007081294897943735, 0.017707131803035736, 0.019040483981370926, -0.043840374797582626, 0.02242751233279705, 0.0019467943347990513, -0.05067990720272064, -0.027851294726133347, 0.07661578804254532, 0.008555680513381958, 0.020201027393341064, -0.010845234617590904, 0.028854703530669212, 0.00921529158949852, -0.005606587510555983, 0.027361605316400528, 0.026713142171502113, 0.0035860256757587194, -0.010415507480502129, -0.0018550734966993332, 0.00639472808688879, 0.01091040950268507, 0.031267546117305756, -0.0009043278987519443, 0.006242907606065273, -0.020020654425024986, -0.003435140708461404, -0.0036229111719876528, -0.0368758924305439, 0.027690593153238297, 0.039253052324056625, -0.028828609734773636, 0.04911266639828682, 0.00774058373644948, 0.04265028238296509, -0.024749742820858955, 0.0028762391302734613, -0.026607569307088852, -0.01779044419527054, 0.019544851034879684, 0.009425523690879345, 0.005338072311133146, 0.01714317873120308, -0.024125665426254272, -0.026567798107862473, -0.019826630130410194, -0.016136784106492996, 0.04999571666121483, 0.04271256551146507, 0.0027163734193891287, -0.03286610171198845, -0.060718655586242676, -0.01243938971310854, -0.06008755415678024, 0.026960819959640503, 0.04452282935380936, 0.005851416848599911, -0.010884029790759087, 0.002428314881399274, -0.008545084856450558, 0.044924478977918625, -0.053240932524204254, -0.026968523859977722, -0.00521107716485858, -0.004080543760210276, 0.010046636685729027, -0.008092950098216534 ]
<p>I want to fit a Cox PH model with random effect (Gamma frailty). Here is an example with 'kidney catheter' data set:</p> <pre><code> &gt; library(survival) &gt; data(kidney) &gt; fit &lt;- coxph(Surv(time, status)~ age + sex + disease + frailty(id), kidney) &gt; fit Call: coxph(formula = Surv(time, status) ~ age + sex + disease + frailty(id), data = kidney) coef se(coef) se2 Chisq DF p age 0.00318 0.0111 0.0111 0.08 1 7.8e-01 sex -1.48314 0.3582 0.3582 17.14 1 3.5e-05 diseaseGN 0.08796 0.4064 0.4064 0.05 1 8.3e-01 diseaseAN 0.35079 0.3997 0.3997 0.77 1 3.8e-01 diseasePKD -1.43111 0.6311 0.6311 5.14 1 2.3e-02 frailty(id) 0.00 0 9.3e-01 Iterations: 6 outer, 28 Newton-Raphson Variance of random effect= 5e-07 I-likelihood = -179.1 Degrees of freedom for terms= 1 1 3 0 Likelihood ratio test=17.6 on 5 df, p=0.00342 n= 76 &gt; fit$history[[1]]$theta [1] 5e-09 </code></pre> <p>Does the <code>fit$history[[1]]$theta</code> returns the variance of random effect? Why is the value different?</p>
74,234
[ -0.022189347073435783, 0.02068302594125271, 0.030076386407017708, 0.008467668667435646, 0.031074421480298042, 0.03132198005914688, -0.009183610789477825, -0.015217483043670654, 0.03859176114201546, -0.04355337843298912, 0.037064675241708755, 0.06932774931192398, 0.04431542754173279, 0.001278927898965776, 0.05002344772219658, 0.03417900204658508, 0.015715954825282097, 0.02210056409239769, 0.016682399436831474, -0.01062921341508627, 0.012782732956111431, 0.009939282201230526, 0.01042366772890091, -0.005590399727225304, 0.00414383877068758, 0.04653842747211456, 0.04091092571616173, -0.03208542987704277, 0.0028348122723400593, 0.03919938951730728, -0.04389373958110809, -0.013169853948056698, -0.008757134899497032, 0.0007799610611982644, 0.019053218886256218, 0.039167456328868866, -0.007031829096376896, -0.03781847283244133, 0.011038321070373058, 0.040678028017282486, -0.020373934879899025, 0.0029935790225863457, -0.010609863325953484, 0.024779843166470528, -0.0027766083367168903, 0.014940241351723671, -0.0032336083240807056, 0.01399277988821268, 0.03630971908569336, -0.05227093771100044, 0.09783516824245453, -0.03042406402528286, 0.04925414174795151, 0.03478744253516197, -0.06255321949720383, -0.016627145931124687, 0.04431463032960892, 0.04343530163168907, -0.010923528112471104, -0.05788116529583931, -0.045315779745578766, -0.05108277499675751, 0.00781341828405857, -0.014427408576011658, -0.0008710769470781088, -0.026092784479260445, 0.02079884521663189, -0.04049375280737877, 0.03513946384191513, -0.010923842899501324, 0.010419690050184727, 0.009713551960885525, 0.036278095096349716, -0.003291022963821888, 0.02549402229487896, -0.02865011617541313, 0.03763291612267494, 0.0063265301287174225, 0.017566025257110596, 0.015934722498059273, -0.04057271406054497, -0.0024125459603965282, 0.03406897559762001, 0.03266308456659317, -0.03005172684788704, 0.01969841495156288, 0.058278873562812805, -0.02358854189515114, 0.012532967142760754, 0.02431199513375759, -0.020156538113951683, 0.04920455440878868, 0.040302108973264694, 0.001243573147803545, -0.03486274182796478, 0.040206097066402435, -0.0006280934321694076, 0.05713120847940445, 0.019842492416501045, 0.011574456468224525, -0.03761495649814606, -0.08580579608678818, 0.044386301189661026, 0.0352170504629612, -0.010873659513890743, -0.03447888046503067, -0.016172686591744423, -0.017406126484274864, 0.010235858149826527, -0.039141181856393814, -0.010082107968628407, -0.015591107308864594, -0.022952372208237648, -0.001975422725081444, 0.0032615410163998604, -0.03136122226715088, -0.06916584074497223, 0.012950626201927662, 0.0832589641213417, 0.08118283003568649, 0.05440950021147728, -0.01867561973631382, 0.0118588050827384, -0.06926926970481873, -0.051972512155771255, 0.006428693886846304, 0.00048062382848002017, -0.016127467155456543, -0.007487943861633539, 0.03481990471482277, -0.010356576181948185, -0.016996078193187714, 0.02223999798297882, 0.022244438529014587, 0.03887074068188667, -0.026213359087705612, -0.11175201833248138, -0.06502153724431992, 0.010537760332226753, 0.008687789551913738, 0.01947665400803089, -0.05534162372350693, 0.03482431173324585, 0.037051886320114136, 0.038234613835811615, -0.007309742271900177, 0.014309842139482498, -0.03501763567328453, -0.012010295875370502, 0.028024645522236824, -0.03909772261977196, 0.013917312026023865, -0.013814074918627739, -0.013659846968948841, -0.028601132333278656, -0.060928817838430405, 0.01058157067745924, 0.002246799413114786, 0.02020086906850338, -0.03361308202147484, 0.034723784774541855, -0.009378654882311821, -0.00721155758947134, -0.012788813561201096, -0.034184779971838, -0.04737330973148346, 0.07491717487573624, 0.029007438570261, -0.00285600614733994, 0.018417030572891235, -0.004245505668222904, -0.026110738515853882, -0.0026539417449384928, 0.051810722798109055, 0.030466632917523384, 0.0015592678682878613, 0.022318299859762192, 0.004550812765955925, 0.019912872463464737, 0.03504105284810066, -0.035292718559503555, 0.00003834547533188015, -0.021763574331998825, -0.03328513354063034, 0.014895504340529442, 0.0029359133914113045, 0.002128535183146596, 0.007224688772112131, 0.06765586137771606, -0.028232699260115623, -0.028454836457967758, -0.03835107386112213, -0.008637304417788982, 0.008541454561054707, -0.015693338587880135, -0.026336343958973885, -0.02234099805355072, 0.04371228814125061, 0.03544477000832558, 0.007930589839816093, -0.042867109179496765, -0.016694912686944008, 0.025472111999988556, -0.03403181582689285, -0.01191039104014635, 0.022470537573099136, 0.03916396200656891, -0.002125239698216319, 0.06133487820625305, -0.0030816097278147936, -0.002827310934662819, -0.013888660818338394, -0.032662104815244675, -0.005001682322472334, 0.016322294250130653, -0.011746235191822052, -0.028349686414003372, 0.00424211984500289, 0.011087021790444851, 0.018757332116365433, -0.04274642840027809, 0.061113618314266205, 0.07944514602422714, 0.042730435729026794, 0.003990821074694395, 0.000703117111697793, 0.020932026207447052, 0.027812404558062553, -0.011514894664287567, -0.024961931630969048, -0.008722798898816109, -0.011469953693449497, -0.009633350186049938, -0.014089297503232956, 0.0018325983546674252, 0.018927685916423798, 0.038627732545137405, -0.014416401274502277, 0.0037863703910261393, 0.051068928092718124, -0.0026539016980677843, 0.0021749127190560102, 0.027941038832068443, 0.027533002197742462, 0.002463738899677992, 0.01850423403084278, 0.04086156189441681, -0.010585461743175983, 0.057262178510427475, -0.021101173013448715, 0.0075910743325948715, 0.010939151979982853, -0.008657500147819519, -0.009904726408421993, -0.0007286272011697292, -0.028519989922642708, 0.06783415377140045, 0.020930234342813492, 0.03253946453332901, 0.0356636606156826, -0.024369362741708755, 0.0025516890455037355, -0.017079364508390427, -0.037091128528118134, 0.024716762825846672, 0.02162751369178295, -0.018933886662125587, 0.00007568286673631519, -0.005632438231259584, 0.0032604082953184843, -0.010502949357032776, -0.027638904750347137, -0.012003056704998016, -0.03340655192732811, -0.015118126757442951, 0.018035318702459335, 0.0017740114126354456, 0.024481777101755142, -0.023851096630096436, -0.02176770195364952, -0.004703811835497618, -0.03396887332201004, 0.02500217966735363, 0.016912035644054413, -0.048625558614730835, -0.019263049587607384, -0.01920653134584427, 0.017748886719346046, 0.0014969296753406525, 0.008456527255475521, -0.03196478635072708, 0.014962599612772465, -0.010101337917149067, -0.011738806031644344, 0.003448168048635125, 0.004006393253803253, -0.014828814193606377, -0.007653069216758013, -0.03141210973262787, 0.02750881016254425, 0.0372043214738369, -0.0008008409640751779, 0.02057197131216526, -0.04842963069677353, -0.014619299210608006, 0.009353862144052982, 0.018671231344342232, 0.025029901415109634, -0.0007751238299533725, 0.026387829333543777, 0.04954516887664795, -0.03555302694439888, -0.020550694316625595, -0.07454291731119156, -0.04213278368115425, 0.0008847141289152205, -0.011095105670392513, -0.04511804133653641, 0.012390851974487305, -0.033306244760751724, 0.05667669326066971, 0.04053322225809097, -0.05307111516594887, -0.0623142383992672, 0.011191456578671932, -0.0237424299120903, -0.03591732680797577, 0.009750544093549252, 0.012298311106860638, 0.040445540100336075, 0.01018351037055254, -0.011534460820257664, 0.0546022392809391, 0.020177649334073067, -0.01957818493247032, 0.008137586526572704, 0.026829931885004044, 0.030681027099490166, -0.05192282423377037, 0.052397944033145905, 0.023291729390621185, 0.0012767750304192305, 0.012050279416143894, -0.002866939175873995, 0.025520309805870056, -0.008346512913703918, -0.04681099206209183, 0.005068422760814428, 0.003085940610617399, -0.004587887786328793, -0.0655965730547905, 0.04971928149461746, -0.01035569328814745, -0.04561842232942581, -0.014492116868495941, -0.008586757816374302, 0.060573432594537735, -0.0164851825684309, 0.006250111386179924, 0.030002975836396217, 0.005239123944193125, -0.0021341207902878523, 0.005930800456553698, -0.007943528704345226, 0.0018107048235833645, 0.01735696941614151, -0.04531102627515793, -0.03549450635910034, 0.054742831736803055, 0.025193650275468826, 0.03108716383576393, -0.03178590163588524, -0.043246667832136154, 0.00898364745080471, -0.027501441538333893, 0.01608397252857685, -0.004948143381625414, 0.05888007581233978, 0.03740571066737175, 0.04786932095885277, 0.027120361104607582, -0.04521308094263077, -0.007240069564431906, -0.040424760431051254, -0.07903905212879181, 0.053448792546987534, -0.001976664876565337, -0.005638064816594124, 0.0049022105522453785, -0.038092195987701416, 0.04048052430152893, -0.03831234574317932, 0.018730534240603447, 0.009869895875453949, -0.024182124063372612, 0.01609809882938862, 0.009074343368411064, -0.0009823309956118464, 0.02115563675761223, -0.00040165751124732196, 0.02329491451382637, 0.015490292571485043, -0.032454993575811386, 0.021005162969231606, 0.03726307302713394, 0.04101892560720444, 0.013780035078525543, -0.02252880297601223, 0.028864605352282524, -0.018806003034114838, 0.010100162588059902, 0.059954091906547546, 0.02848018892109394, -0.023338502272963524, 0.032358862459659576, 0.00011331537825753912, 0.01826268434524536, 0.06414142996072769, -0.001305390615016222, -0.002878428902477026, 0.003840707242488861, 0.010821538046002388, 0.012893362902104855, -0.0065534780733287334, 0.01211283914744854, 0.014532807283103466, 0.08023964613676071, 0.017751002684235573, -0.06483307480812073, 0.026419365778565407, 0.051894403994083405, 0.01576162874698639, -0.0010979637736454606, -0.019699370488524437, 0.009268069639801979, 0.005452791228890419, -0.003938458859920502, 0.027034686878323555, 0.024767255410552025, -0.00016473532014060766, -0.00032287329668179154, 0.031226491555571556, -0.0488663911819458, -0.027540186420083046, -0.01860203593969345, 0.060487840324640274, 0.0344892218708992, 0.008667022921144962, 0.005376813001930714, 0.00030974947731010616, 0.012106446549296379, 0.00845967885106802, 0.011618266813457012, 0.01764756254851818, -0.09569863975048065, -0.014867017045617104, 0.03769851103425026, 0.03226620703935623, -0.03260749205946922, -0.05053701251745224, -0.04480573907494545, 0.013630707748234272, 0.03388919681310654, -0.05488390848040581, 0.00905059464275837, -0.02612871490418911, 0.007380919065326452, -0.003773544216528535, -0.01654738374054432, -0.05538618564605713, 0.028563080355525017, -0.01035277172923088, 0.012642593123018742, -0.03520083799958229, -0.05152043327689171, -0.030452711507678032, -0.019068745896220207, -0.0009855664102360606, 0.01917487382888794, -0.05138150230050087, -0.025402553379535675, 0.027915233746170998, 0.044568758457899094, -0.018146971240639687, -0.053497664630413055, 0.05209019035100937, -0.025157108902931213, 0.017193041741847992, 0.018419459462165833, 0.003619204508140683, 0.0036930101923644543, 0.0013297072146087885, 0.01660079136490822, -0.02165243960916996, 0.01415229495614767, -0.012412028387188911, 0.023000545799732208, 0.02690003253519535, -0.018226198852062225, 0.048047397285699844, 0.007551552727818489, 0.035753700882196426, -0.0005992056103423238, -0.06617873907089233, 0.017268789932131767, -0.01838350109755993, -0.009429390542209148, -0.08592279255390167, 0.003374359803274274, 0.018777593970298767, 0.004603286273777485, -0.0015938268043100834, 0.04881630092859268, -0.03308456018567085, 0.015282505191862583, -0.0012571890838444233, 0.04477701336145401, 0.006970990914851427, 0.003887332044541836, 0.025266515091061592, -0.01124122180044651, 0.02637460269033909, -0.028659343719482422, -0.0035388253163546324, -0.022013766691088676, -0.02847418189048767, -0.01345400232821703, -0.02041151188313961, -0.01730463095009327, 0.02048078179359436, -0.010586509481072426, -0.0017418470233678818, -0.0014067153679206967, -0.00463142478838563, -0.003040433395653963, 0.007867947220802307, -0.016721880063414574, -0.018952900543808937, 0.009301111102104187, 0.005450172815471888, 0.002427582396194339, -0.0017890238668769598, -0.029147235676646233, 0.05757429450750351, 0.015084889717400074, -0.0034842633176594973, -0.09408359974622726, -0.011709191836416721, 0.006987265311181545, -0.016569966450333595, -0.03662276268005371, -0.018908264115452766, -0.02449951134622097, -0.026009414345026016, -0.04578998684883118, -0.0113223847001791, 0.017571598291397095, -0.029934648424386978, 0.019103150814771652, -0.037084102630615234, 0.015724409371614456, 0.04656315594911575, -0.00820787250995636, 0.007636737544089556, 0.01685664989054203, -0.06994866579771042, 0.0002302905631950125, 0.031132906675338745, -0.0003850341308861971, -0.02943648025393486, 0.02701454982161522, 0.01401494536548853, 0.013724218122661114, 0.031331781297922134, 0.00647782115265727, -0.023563647642731667, -0.016662465408444405, -0.01408100314438343, 0.05308990180492401, -0.031556617468595505, 0.00626528263092041, -0.006769994739443064, 0.02782977744936943, -0.012386267073452473, 0.023791201412677765, -0.01586499996483326, 0.014919757843017578, 0.024476129561662674, -0.029424309730529785, -0.017489183694124222, 0.01758323609828949, 0.08645375818014145, -0.01639719493687153, -0.02300220914185047, -0.009644937701523304, -0.030041445046663284, 0.054374679923057556, 0.03789449855685234, -0.02680785208940506, 0.033593401312828064, 0.04072432219982147, -0.0569508820772171, -0.002070333808660507, -0.07904510200023651, 0.0076466635800898075, 0.0582447275519371, -0.03895014896988869, 0.019461266696453094, 0.03380541503429413, -0.00396528746932745, -0.007943852804601192, -0.042176030576229095, -0.036702848970890045, -0.02669491060078144, 0.017788147553801537, 0.06139473617076874, -0.027690406888723373, 0.00673461752012372, 0.03444819897413254, 0.05198389291763306, 0.017443949356675148, 0.0657719075679779, 0.03584345802664757, -0.004490379709750414, 0.015345913358032703, 0.013718904927372932, -0.01658712513744831, 0.029959145933389664, -0.013194539584219456, 0.015718383714556694, -0.05357852578163147, -0.025285737589001656, 0.055119626224040985, 0.0471167266368866, -0.001273282803595066, -0.03768761083483696, -0.0021928988862782717, -0.05168865993618965, -0.003400080604478717, 0.06513022631406784, -0.03236262872815132, 0.025160808116197586, 0.021484972909092903, 0.028268467634916306, 0.008687011897563934, 0.03550028055906296, -0.052446041256189346, -0.0628783106803894, -0.012103444896638393, -0.0003398727276362479, -0.003016594797372818, 0.01801329106092453, 0.0060445587150752544, -0.012475414201617241, 0.006567475851625204, -0.04555075243115425, 0.013803371228277683, 0.0030138634610921144, 0.02515757642686367, -0.025399621576070786, 0.07095788419246674, -0.02289607562124729, 0.024604782462120056, -0.028264213353395462, -0.020505612716078758, 0.11936337500810623, 0.04505975916981697, 0.027079233899712563, -0.031094541773200035, -0.027760105207562447, 0.003614865243434906, 0.0033030498307198286, 0.0017117587849497795, -0.02664046175777912, 0.02612285688519478, -0.013210797682404518, 0.06624403595924377, 0.051405929028987885, 0.05671106278896332, -0.0192999467253685, 0.05316738411784172, -0.037954896688461304, -0.044328056275844574, 0.010998728685081005, -0.006914007477462292, -0.023958560079336166, -0.01331234909594059, -0.03467504680156708, 0.007806821726262569, 0.007070542778819799, -0.04910608008503914, -0.021604442968964577, -0.0036747544072568417, -0.014865138567984104, 0.023137442767620087, -0.013433992862701416, 0.027735266834497452, -0.034536827355623245, 0.015030210837721825, -0.0009242529631592333, 0.011596170254051685, 0.014423529617488384, 0.0002158231072826311, 0.02392675168812275, 0.028014475479722023, 0.037598274648189545, -0.014819340780377388, 0.02970851957798004, 0.019964663311839104, -0.03430707007646561, -0.03442291542887688, -0.02287214808166027, 0.07252860814332962, 0.008805390447378159, -0.009467235766351223, -0.035221222788095474, -0.0109557518735528, -0.004431711044162512, -0.04350346326828003, -0.019614597782492638, 0.028827309608459473, 0.004010036587715149, -0.015149376355111599, 0.007941409014165401, -0.01432266179472208, 0.022227032110095024, -0.005261645652353764, 0.024068621918559074, 0.05803040415048599, -0.06621993333101273, 0.0019604815170168877, -0.05731751397252083, 0.017533252015709877, -0.042575057595968246, 0.0073255011811852455, 0.03558937460184097, -0.016816720366477966, -0.04931354895234108, -0.013965667225420475, 0.04323597252368927, 0.000895892211701721, 0.04153143987059593, -0.0491882860660553, -0.0012964612105861306, -0.027061082422733307, -0.03741953521966934, 0.01822526566684246, -0.022762099280953407, -0.03672988340258598, -0.054525118321180344, -0.006464238744229078, 0.015358454547822475, 0.04182767495512962, -0.002683149417862296, 0.019413333386182785, -0.03513018414378166, 0.0494062714278698, -0.03486555442214012, -0.05837085098028183, -0.04589266702532768, 0.02225588634610176, -0.03250797092914581, -0.028798339888453484, -0.02025868371129036, 0.029419630765914917, 0.02632634900510311, 0.0018352004699409008, -0.01844600960612297, 0.04031389579176903, 0.004021590109914541, 0.004308246076107025, 0.010180524550378323, -0.025259269401431084, 0.017900345847010612, -0.014798825606703758, -0.022271767258644104, -0.0006172393914312124, -0.015058877877891064, -0.0502779558300972, -0.07855211943387985, 0.019756291061639786, -0.02621394582092762, -0.03268706798553467, -0.003357598790898919, -0.029087312519550323, 0.001385392271913588, -0.0022864090278744698, 0.01890692487359047, -0.027390537783503532, 0.011901361867785454, -0.010555661283433437, -0.045052602887153625, 0.0056313397362828255, 0.023276058956980705, -0.02275616116821766, -0.01954970508813858, 0.00603831559419632, 0.01098982710391283, 0.02094963751733303, 0.015894563868641853, 0.02878408506512642, 0.006425455212593079, 0.03876273334026337, -0.03399328514933586, 0.0048870365135371685, 0.022514615207910538, -0.048926156014204025, -0.033965177834033966, 0.022783109918236732, 0.024357687681913376, 0.021750764921307564, -0.0012121550971642137, -0.01704365946352482, 0.019822940230369568, 0.06490756571292877, -0.030826572328805923, -0.008587846532464027, -0.011150703765451908, 0.005381772294640541, 0.018330803140997887, -0.015533342026174068, -0.011442912742495537, 0.02308417670428753, 0.005717424675822258, 0.04888780042529106, 0.05265272408723831, 0.029802992939949036, 0.0035387095995247364, 0.039536233991384506, 0.011711201630532742, 0.014260879717767239, 0.015964990481734276, -0.0126346992328763, 0.008769594132900238, 0.0527917705476284, -0.021674368530511856, 0.017129244282841682, -0.021725811064243317, 0.03649281710386276, -0.10541469603776932, -0.005156285595148802, -0.030321845784783363, 0.020087240263819695, 0.0085629066452384, -0.06345996260643005, 0.010532785207033157, -0.010284516029059887, -0.033428020775318146, -0.020127158612012863, 0.011729693040251732, -0.01998763158917427, -0.04802369698882103, 0.0564747080206871, -0.028030145913362503, 0.003126366063952446, 0.06144452467560768, 0.010842254385352135, 0.022178295999765396, -0.025101343169808388, -0.003589987987652421, -0.03650938719511032, -0.013706491328775883, 0.02482030540704727, 0.004323534667491913, -0.05646517500281334, 0.037527307868003845, -0.011405089870095253, -0.06166458502411842, 0.01202182937413454, 0.011473334394395351, 0.03242598474025726, -0.0015489256475120783, 0.03384525328874588, 0.0026937704533338547, 0.0510881170630455, 0.01979892887175083, -0.026926787570118904, 0.003456569742411375, -0.007969217374920845, -0.0023652329109609127, 0.022765643894672394, -0.017177345231175423, 0.03812163323163986, 0.017525475472211838, -0.017202487215399742, 0.0017457181820645928, 0.0427740104496479, -0.022801730781793594, -0.015793247148394585, -0.02245515212416649, -0.017303466796875, -0.007983938790857792, -0.02462928742170334, 0.03207649290561676, -0.025661999359726906, 0.00924704596400261, 0.0707629919052124, 0.05957085266709328, -0.002298482693731785, 0.023440102115273476, -0.009140802547335625, -0.03453771024942398, -0.001975633669644594, 0.019405316561460495, -0.016599321737885475, -0.03951190412044525, -0.04792957007884979, -0.022738683968782425, 0.01096989307552576, 0.019326092675328255, 0.004581506829708815, -0.04290960356593132, 0.00510540883988142, -0.008958140388131142, 0.0009828325128182769, 0.051350340247154236, 0.001355560845695436, 0.014707883819937706, -0.08105950802564621, 0.04722554236650467, -0.005715569015592337, -0.022851435467600822, -0.07462551444768906, 0.011850854381918907, -0.04788554459810257, 0.02478068694472313, 0.04759974405169487, 0.0004864109505433589, 0.004058804828673601, 0.003950336016714573, 0.03346918523311615, -0.0027709135320037603, -0.0634552612900734, 0.06328988075256348, -0.015602258034050465, 0.013893661089241505, -0.00005159373176866211, 0.03884278982877731, 0.027867380529642105, 0.02975345030426979, -0.0042365193367004395, -0.020716650411486626, 0.009918466210365295, -0.000668219814542681, -0.040078211575746536, -0.022113781422376633, 0.0021405781153589487, -0.00509522994980216, 0.05799442529678345, 0.010527106933295727, 0.03341015428304672, 0.025639470666646957, 0.01626245491206646, -0.0337582491338253, 0.05384489521384239, -0.04238003119826317, -0.03274491801857948, 0.04054942727088928, -0.01705760695040226, 0.000616627570707351, -0.04770830646157265, 0.00019528977281879634, 0.01898546889424324, -0.07457295805215836, -0.03132256120443344, 0.01559328194707632, 0.03487290069460869, 0.013461435213685036, -0.0037989492993801832, -0.004670314956456423, 0.01767803356051445, -0.019085172563791275, 0.02219940349459648, -0.01089215837419033, 0.01872001215815544, -0.006149462424218655, 0.011658817529678345, 0.023182271048426628, -0.029169972985982895, -0.007970021106302738, -0.04035324975848198, 0.0826178789138794, -0.007074556779116392, -0.007264065556228161, -0.0019764923490583897, -0.015785597264766693, 0.025918079540133476, -0.027946388348937035, -0.024549946188926697, 0.03052152320742607, -0.044448934495449066, 0.015171054750680923, -0.024991542100906372, -0.023606808856129646, 0.00018265807011630386, 0.002013350138440728, 0.04262092337012291, 0.043661996722221375, 0.011405684053897858, 0.017028428614139557, -0.0033859875984489918, -0.01918966695666313, 0.0008414761978201568, -0.0481003075838089, -0.011577199213206768, 0.019264359027147293, -0.008219828829169273, -0.02837258391082287, -0.0075826277025043964, -0.051135238260030746, -0.05093494802713394, 0.018068229779601097, 0.010122842155396938, 0.034006599336862564, -0.060690585523843765, -0.010974636301398277, 0.017646295949816704, 0.06477857381105423, -0.06519276648759842, -0.024700364097952843, -0.010050307027995586, 0.007678295485675335, 0.008969306945800781, 0.002544678980484605 ]
<p>I ran some experiments first. Afterwards, I looked for the parameter $p_{max}$ for which I can claim the chance a matrix has the ESP-property is $p_{max}$ or lower to a significance of exactly 99%. Is this correct on a more philosophical basis?</p> <p>I'm doing research in computer science, and have a test to determine whether a random matrix holds the ESP-property or not.</p> <p>If you run this Bernouilli experiment repeatedly, so I get a binomial distribution of matrices holding or not holding the ESP-property of which I estimate the $p$ parameter. This chance $p$ of not holding the ESP-property is really low (like 0.001%). So what I do is to find the chance $p_{max}$ a matrix holds the ESP-property, with a significance level of exactly 0.99.</p> <p>Finding this value is no problem. However, are there good reasons this is a bad approach to the problem? Because basically, it is a more advanced approach of this: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/24203/is-it-ever-good-to-increase-significance-level">Is it ever good to increase significance level?</a></p> <p>The difference in this case is I keep the significance level constant, while looking for a parameter $p$ which best explains my experimental results.</p>
74,235
[ -0.03985346853733063, -0.01640370674431324, -0.02841208688914776, -0.04804250970482826, 0.04149876907467842, 0.01583089306950569, -0.017586354166269302, -0.032404880970716476, -0.015613428317010403, -0.0338408537209034, 0.03929537907242775, 0.05479080602526665, 0.007003196515142918, 0.0040488759987056255, 0.0319882296025753, 0.015491937287151814, -0.017336392775177956, 0.002921265084296465, -0.016440914943814278, 0.018250172957777977, -0.019621700048446655, -0.0001472493604524061, 0.006429473869502544, -0.0066666388884186745, -0.019788619130849838, 0.015674663707613945, -0.0012104447232559323, -0.02465975098311901, -0.006920940242707729, 0.08098869025707245, -0.036046721041202545, -0.02635279856622219, 0.04071857035160065, 0.024653280153870583, 0.024539947509765625, -0.017127465456724167, -0.0026975679211318493, -0.019312473013997078, -0.007123235147446394, 0.022469673305749893, 0.004390748217701912, -0.01579396426677704, 0.03706437349319458, 0.016164397820830345, 0.007489040028303862, 0.027433564886450768, 0.009555699303746223, -0.06914673000574112, 0.04652641341090202, -0.0468694232404232, 0.049443602561950684, 0.027713503688573837, 0.02737494930624962, 0.0297195166349411, -0.017244547605514526, -0.05932456627488136, 0.05844101309776306, 0.038912855088710785, -0.016225295141339302, -0.04280901327729225, 0.0027034166269004345, -0.019767584279179573, 0.004857518710196018, -0.010909623466432095, -0.01808314025402069, 0.028747815638780594, -0.007047159131616354, -0.0039877151139080524, 0.05797179043292999, -0.01993769407272339, -0.0077655985951423645, 0.012887346558272839, 0.03249908983707428, -0.021806515753269196, 0.0352422259747982, -0.039007171988487244, 0.036712609231472015, 0.02832210436463356, 0.03396400809288025, 0.0748339593410492, 0.01126776821911335, 0.018086865544319153, 0.025869999080896378, 0.040604978799819946, 0.032751742750406265, -0.027847163379192352, 0.07350651919841766, -0.016515251249074936, 0.027672162279486656, 0.04255426675081253, -0.03620722517371178, -0.04580109566450119, 0.043570276349782944, -0.016382114961743355, -0.06761705875396729, 0.009951593354344368, -0.023776859045028687, 0.021272730082273483, -0.005196646321564913, -0.004511086270213127, -0.022807031869888306, -0.019052468240261078, 0.01933150179684162, 0.04179076850414276, -0.02269595116376877, -0.030797788873314857, -0.027453837916254997, 0.03188852220773697, -0.010773303918540478, -0.05021125450730324, 0.00032327574444934726, 0.047700513154268265, 0.009242421016097069, 0.03621498495340347, 0.01537614781409502, -0.03022684156894684, 0.014047631993889809, -0.04124363139271736, 0.07463301718235016, 0.040918733924627304, 0.049108121544122696, 0.006444570142775774, 0.016804292798042297, -0.04542442411184311, -0.043167345225811005, 0.016009578481316566, 0.01607370749115944, -0.003192230826243758, -0.042860377579927444, 0.02633855491876602, 0.03104277513921261, 0.0016667208401486278, 0.016634425148367882, -0.005314028821885586, 0.010290713049471378, 0.009503100998699665, -0.08634571731090546, -0.016334693878889084, 0.06660418957471848, 0.010714647360146046, 0.015276060439646244, -0.10180923342704773, -0.017021071165800095, 0.009145847521722317, 0.07298868149518967, -0.007642330601811409, 0.02842908911406994, -0.02762715145945549, 0.04623894393444061, 0.010765131562948227, -0.025866298004984856, -0.004467109218239784, -0.018802089616656303, -0.02401603013277054, -0.0012220086064189672, -0.07205100357532501, 0.023850930854678154, -0.01055759284645319, 0.007486359681934118, -0.0024580741301178932, 0.014663484878838062, -0.020168211311101913, -0.014583886601030827, -0.02640857733786106, 0.02075853943824768, 0.012163283303380013, 0.07498321682214737, 0.01027341466397047, 0.046043992042541504, 0.034326933324337006, -0.006390016060322523, 0.032137103378772736, 0.02182708866894245, 0.0343162827193737, 0.05436592176556587, -0.058941327035427094, 0.01974739506840706, -0.028959576040506363, 0.03849900886416435, -0.005165141075849533, -0.05223246291279793, -0.0047114817425608635, -0.007338720839470625, 0.00454758619889617, 0.017101619392633438, 0.03389027342200279, -0.014272443018853664, -0.0030442639254033566, 0.03603851795196533, -0.05144525319337845, -0.033785127103328705, -0.09889855980873108, 0.008186956867575645, -0.012011903338134289, -0.033694155514240265, 0.04752298444509506, -0.012360312044620514, 0.013888146728277206, -0.016375694423913956, 0.047133926302194595, -0.020266536623239517, 0.02255050465464592, 0.043303482234478, -0.05531187355518341, 0.004163532517850399, 0.040366172790527344, 0.017579246312379837, -0.011843547224998474, 0.038839373737573624, -0.04700079187750816, -0.05679771676659584, -0.02066998928785324, -0.03339236602187157, -0.0006727338186465204, 0.03722669184207916, -0.013811870478093624, 0.013325140811502934, -0.0262351855635643, -0.009489498101174831, 0.0201864130795002, -0.0392371341586113, 0.07683390378952026, 0.04005195200443268, 0.00482294661924243, 0.023751717060804367, 0.03057103231549263, 0.01263885572552681, -0.020806433632969856, 0.019731031730771065, -0.0017689426895231009, -0.08873093873262405, 0.006092420779168606, 0.01168493740260601, 0.03861236572265625, -0.03838764876127243, 0.02722860313951969, 0.007289830129593611, 0.0226554237306118, -0.019464313983917236, 0.059907909482717514, -0.03212464228272438, -0.03887039050459862, 0.012292260304093361, 0.027477430179715157, -0.019783038645982742, 0.04020863026380539, 0.026916082948446274, -0.008061205968260765, 0.0345018208026886, -0.011733605526387691, 0.000902741274330765, -0.012058689258992672, -0.02648550644516945, -0.016262928023934364, 0.004001387860625982, 0.033970948308706284, 0.01044802088290453, -0.015093694441020489, -0.0015678188065066934, 0.017131812870502472, 0.029835842549800873, 0.012827814556658268, -0.020779753103852272, -0.04713599383831024, 0.03717288002371788, 0.017187990248203278, -0.05145253613591194, -0.02539917454123497, 0.01076673623174429, -0.022062605246901512, 0.005356112029403448, -0.018671654164791107, -0.015206585638225079, -0.016138151288032532, 0.021669115871191025, -0.012780815362930298, -0.016650155186653137, 0.028775306418538094, -0.03850095719099045, -0.021721310913562775, -0.007327375002205372, -0.015209304168820381, -0.0028948774561285973, 0.002087244065478444, -0.07535078376531601, -0.02603529579937458, -0.04170127213001251, -0.015077726915478706, 0.020183056592941284, -0.012342873960733414, 0.02088109217584133, 0.0036957678385078907, 0.0059554497711360455, -0.009896127507090569, 0.009268708527088165, -0.046755604445934296, 0.005204618908464909, -0.014957636594772339, -0.050197627395391464, 0.04431730508804321, -0.003284432692453265, -0.025154292583465576, 0.056046731770038605, -0.033138591796159744, -0.01804347150027752, -0.020012076944112778, 0.007331555709242821, 0.0011886399006471038, 0.002389016794040799, -0.0013618082739412785, 0.014635260216891766, -0.006155393552035093, 0.0008963782456703484, -0.08751660585403442, -0.08099742978811264, -0.0018050699727609754, 0.003922088537365198, 0.04040944203734398, -0.0054842750541865826, -0.01606854610145092, 0.09251661598682404, 0.06745393574237823, 0.0011271017137914896, -0.00870672520250082, 0.014586004428565502, -0.014192280359566212, -0.01107713021337986, -0.006205705460160971, 0.022391950711607933, -0.018956147134304047, 0.027201686054468155, -0.0014456253265962005, 0.04268280789256096, 0.004913362208753824, 0.02365291304886341, -0.026158882305026054, 0.008015511557459831, 0.0034593481104820967, -0.004536569118499756, 0.05254535377025604, 0.004900708794593811, -0.012724319472908974, 0.01162672508507967, -0.004479249007999897, 0.043353013694286346, -0.008386801928281784, -0.016596166417002678, 0.03622644022107124, -0.020415376871824265, 0.028849182650446892, -0.004290782380849123, 0.04660383611917496, 0.02598138153553009, 0.001519214129075408, -0.006972483824938536, 0.010684072971343994, 0.010978871956467628, -0.018137285485863686, 0.038402050733566284, 0.0509246289730072, 0.043110109865665436, -0.038638096302747726, -0.036266494542360306, -0.009173949249088764, -0.015602344647049904, 0.03648195415735245, -0.03393467888236046, -0.03480903059244156, 0.024447545409202576, 0.03717740997672081, 0.04214925691485405, -0.03352261334657669, -0.06001385301351547, -0.005424486007541418, -0.029714642092585564, 0.03103584051132202, -0.02258787304162979, 0.006714037153869867, -0.03038300760090351, 0.04826486110687256, 0.031772125512361526, -0.008329167030751705, -0.012490114197134972, 0.01423521526157856, -0.10281364619731903, 0.017918676137924194, -0.052876826375722885, 0.009292657487094402, 0.011324530467391014, -0.00989716686308384, 0.03691321238875389, -0.047217972576618195, 0.03559436276555061, -0.013009166345000267, 0.03378273546695709, -0.04632658138871193, 0.008449038490653038, -0.09058349579572678, -0.03019251488149166, -0.036860279738903046, 0.003361659124493599, 0.026238055899739265, -0.0035062578972429037, 0.02658175490796566, 0.008119002915918827, -0.03603503480553627, -0.007024148944765329, -0.007988609373569489, 0.017336256802082062, 0.014733702875673771, 0.03677227720618248, 0.005723156966269016, 0.04661019891500473, -0.01854526996612549, 0.031352557241916656, 0.014677481725811958, 0.02193458192050457, 0.028606509789824486, -0.021828653290867805, -0.016590774059295654, -0.05625920742750168, -0.0303279310464859, 0.0019004566129297018, 0.01763276569545269, 0.007956239394843578, -0.042187515646219254, 0.054060403257608414, 0.00813432689756155, -0.039791289716959, 0.024604959413409233, 0.05939735472202301, 0.005915789399296045, 0.008779022842645645, -0.05036754906177521, 0.0001686311443336308, -0.03297341614961624, -0.014070002362132072, -0.010103677399456501, 0.033244844526052475, -0.008974847383797169, -0.00978970155119896, 0.00010648484749253839, -0.011556224897503853, -0.027275586500763893, -0.002651893999427557, 0.005968558136373758, 0.011430713348090649, -0.02031187154352665, -0.012743008323013783, 0.0077535598538815975, 0.004723238293081522, -0.017680838704109192, 0.009979214519262314, 0.009984751231968403, -0.045823387801647186, 0.007019028998911381, 0.0735875740647316, 0.0700698122382164, -0.0558570921421051, 0.012905526906251907, -0.009888271801173687, -0.011466730386018753, 0.020812999457120895, -0.02534734085202217, 0.0362631194293499, -0.03749537467956543, -0.0029539112001657486, -0.05159315839409828, -0.014655862003564835, -0.049871284514665604, -0.02626463584601879, -0.019056271761655807, 0.044824693351984024, -0.05101142078638077, -0.019473133608698845, -0.045082200318574905, 0.028385603800415993, 0.022382039576768875, 0.06201625615358353, -0.04560352489352226, 0.0024493965320289135, 0.005088655278086662, -0.027869852259755135, -0.005520150996744633, -0.06935777515172958, 0.022685302421450615, 0.01932976208627224, 0.0029673443641513586, 0.0054169027134776115, -0.03590450808405876, -0.052456941455602646, 0.0453752800822258, -0.022150322794914246, -0.06371273100376129, 0.027695881202816963, 0.016599789261817932, 0.035259366035461426, 0.038022056221961975, 0.004533232189714909, 0.0459994375705719, 0.026864254847168922, -0.006262896116822958, 0.02787746489048004, -0.019445719197392464, 0.02355819009244442, -0.02819087728857994, 0.015137989073991776, -0.0626874715089798, 0.013505538925528526, -0.03532857447862625, 0.03103102743625641, 0.026000848039984703, 0.02205708436667919, -0.01823411136865616, -0.014715616591274738, -0.004979938268661499, 0.036739420145750046, 0.002776481444016099, -0.0006854449748061597, 0.02320539392530918, -0.0030102620366960764, -0.006304791197180748, -0.0031009940430521965, 0.012710983864963055, -0.03363309055566788, 0.026577835902571678, 0.038813840597867966, -0.0395268052816391, 0.0360834002494812, -0.0480874665081501, -0.02543335035443306, 0.01887083239853382, -0.03202776983380318, 0.033888399600982666, 0.007003027014434338, 0.017815956845879555, 0.0005657050060108304, -0.0300062894821167, -0.005635394249111414, 0.028229014948010445, -0.010122944600880146, 0.03822573646903038, -0.04400980845093727, -0.004570981487631798, -0.04396171495318413, 0.029868876561522484, -0.03152059018611908, -0.017598355188965797, 0.005020204000174999, 0.03379695490002632, -0.007387997582554817, -0.033481717109680176, 0.005484460853040218, -0.025101805105805397, 0.009647054597735405, -0.008304640650749207, 0.05313849449157715, -0.0235759224742651, -0.02561192773282528, 0.014136099256575108, 0.02167171612381935, 0.0848451480269432, -0.03129999339580536, -0.01280487235635519, 0.007529317867010832, 0.007838999852538109, 0.00520673394203186, -0.0026724315248429775, 0.012582298368215561, -0.028166621923446655, -0.026256967335939407, -0.0036862357519567013, -0.006651264149695635, 0.05726715549826622, -0.03414984419941902, -0.014142134226858616, 0.03754272311925888, -0.006978155113756657, 0.031704336404800415, -0.028554309159517288, -0.015150202438235283, -0.0048979208804667, 0.01619015447795391, 0.023236511275172234, -0.0013786469353362918, 0.006076434627175331, -0.035253845155239105, 0.03595347702503204, 0.009122413583099842, -0.035576604306697845, 0.013596298173069954, 0.05309892073273659, -0.0013137999922037125, -0.015354068018496037, 0.0053624981082975864, -0.004943410865962505, 0.015725037083029747, 0.03406039997935295, -0.016799351200461388, 0.019443480297923088, -0.016187867149710655, -0.005910999141633511, -0.017996415495872498, -0.032403215765953064, -0.0039484151639044285, 0.03870821371674538, 0.01692906953394413, 0.01713382825255394, 0.027357637882232666, 0.0026972803752869368, -0.004319568630307913, -0.044582467526197433, 0.005771399475634098, -0.025192316621541977, -0.010755437426269054, 0.018035007640719414, -0.028681181371212006, 0.0010615207720547915, 0.05131031200289726, 0.012603173032402992, -0.001942344824783504, 0.025523953139781952, 0.046810880303382874, 0.01572696678340435, 0.05598779022693634, -0.0804530680179596, -0.03679921105504036, 0.09147762507200241, -0.06476972252130508, 0.03354350104928017, -0.03620383143424988, -0.030007191002368927, 0.0013933825539425015, 0.0366077721118927, -0.020550651475787163, -0.021025264635682106, -0.012671717442572117, -0.044346947222948074, -0.00772359361872077, 0.029919590801000595, -0.025060951709747314, 0.035768307745456696, -0.02990315668284893, 0.014349870383739471, -0.0019017518498003483, 0.04907698929309845, -0.011686049401760101, -0.05942479148507118, -0.04007256031036377, -0.013840685598552227, -0.034896280616521835, 0.032535988837480545, 0.017737865447998047, -0.008685593493282795, 0.01934048719704151, -0.0508110448718071, 0.02478679269552231, 0.02967253141105175, 0.03825288638472557, -0.021019043400883675, 0.05448808893561363, 0.013059682212769985, 0.01270546019077301, 0.01727486588060856, 0.005221833474934101, 0.10532635450363159, 0.06421735137701035, 0.026014799252152443, -0.01878877729177475, 0.061343491077423096, -0.02043266035616398, 0.001630663755349815, -0.04181154444813728, 0.016817038878798485, -0.005436988081783056, 0.015678446739912033, -0.011042495258152485, 0.04540102556347847, 0.011932916007936, 0.003341138595715165, 0.06673131883144379, -0.06290547549724579, -0.01980367675423622, 0.03401878476142883, 0.029548751190304756, -0.03322133421897888, -0.02033412829041481, -0.02187814936041832, -0.012493997812271118, -0.004650834947824478, -0.0061197588220238686, 0.005372029263526201, -0.0018345991848036647, -0.03236423805356026, -0.013446302153170109, 0.00970613956451416, -0.01873662695288658, 0.012074262835085392, -0.0004186162550467998, -0.02368459850549698, -0.0008931647753342986, -0.001656413427554071, 0.020797576755285263, 0.01555396243929863, 0.017330355942249298, -0.0013817548751831055, 0.019534748047590256, 0.010430065914988518, 0.03497244417667389, -0.058236800134181976, -0.028488943353295326, -0.004976971540600061, 0.06157230585813522, -0.007618817035108805, -0.018385615199804306, -0.007398752495646477, -0.051217224448919296, -0.02038569003343582, -0.030355291441082954, -0.007106333039700985, 0.022525765001773834, 0.02103220485150814, 0.007626209408044815, 0.0020160158164799213, -0.03416808322072029, 0.019912639632821083, 0.004106457810848951, 0.015919344499707222, 0.02805590070784092, -0.03420094773173332, -0.040056243538856506, 0.013653761707246304, 0.04847314581274986, 0.020969592034816742, -0.0024484763853251934, 0.009929586201906204, -0.024610772728919983, -0.05515105649828911, -0.06296398490667343, -0.0037687644362449646, -0.02164342626929283, 0.02110111713409424, -0.004517026711255312, 0.014132535085082054, -0.010581391863524914, -0.04287317395210266, -0.0036621748004108667, -0.011754833161830902, -0.0014474670169875026, -0.014564256183803082, -0.015066430903971195, -0.006447910331189632, 0.013427907600998878, -0.017399894073605537, -0.02571011520922184, 0.029669690877199173, 0.07582951337099075, 0.013586949557065964, -0.03785182163119316, -0.030100198462605476, -0.034752409905195236, -0.020455798134207726, 0.01632341369986534, -0.017813904210925102, 0.016727019101381302, -0.002652745461091399, -0.013879778794944286, 0.017554040998220444, 0.0159754641354084, -0.03583642095327377, 0.024419939145445824, 0.05050745606422424, -0.0395163856446743, -0.030018461868166924, 0.04584629833698273, 0.00010325190669391304, -0.002074190881103277, -0.023268625140190125, -0.03408748283982277, -0.02085944451391697, -0.0013544510584324598, -0.00954229012131691, -0.008887658827006817, -0.03434475138783455, -0.016869021579623222, 0.017826151102781296, -0.035114385187625885, -0.059711769223213196, -0.0631663054227829, 0.013310360722243786, -0.005404149182140827, -0.010181709192693233, -0.016770265996456146, 0.023260191082954407, -0.0059170350432395935, -0.015026496723294258, 0.02500966191291809, 0.019840819761157036, 0.0029410587158054113, -0.042210228741168976, 0.020803963765501976, -0.011372856795787811, 0.045866139233112335, -0.058508723974227905, -0.0014551806962117553, 0.07359802722930908, -0.04854504391551018, -0.035957515239715576, 0.038856249302625656, -0.020699406042695045, 0.0018651267746463418, 0.013921859674155712, -0.011367697268724442, 0.023768741637468338, 0.02715342678129673, -0.010431434027850628, -0.002044418128207326, -0.004864192102104425, 0.006937885656952858, -0.014496784657239914, 0.002880678977817297, 0.031035125255584717, -0.01093747466802597, 0.009838149882853031, 0.028934821486473083, 0.031108947470784187, -0.005400634836405516, 0.022167373448610306, 0.02910769358277321, 0.005127843003720045, 0.024174055084586143, 0.01682582125067711, -0.046769287437200546, 0.008808580227196217, 0.06440488249063492, -0.03662750869989395, -0.0034553164150565863, -0.019835390150547028, 0.02141900733113289, -0.09511326998472214, -0.029807472601532936, -0.014390930533409119, -0.002122627105563879, 0.05331665277481079, -0.020138369873166084, 0.06729210913181305, 0.024390554055571556, -0.039392948150634766, 0.03225763142108917, -0.02416374534368515, -0.004501019604504108, -0.03990749642252922, 0.021359030157327652, -0.031164785847067833, 0.03445466235280037, 0.013073036447167397, 0.030444851145148277, 0.052272457629442215, 0.048486802726984024, 0.011769113130867481, -0.028882121667265892, -0.0035815597511827946, 0.05819825455546379, -0.015476935543119907, -0.052489347755908966, 0.031025860458612442, -0.030022380873560905, -0.05347684770822525, 0.029890816658735275, 0.03210730850696564, 0.02127848193049431, 0.0057587395422160625, 0.04982028529047966, 0.012265047058463097, 0.061877112835645676, 0.04019218683242798, 0.010379638522863388, 0.0056768483482301235, -0.020709151402115822, 0.008746682666242123, 0.056310106068849564, -0.008198628202080727, -0.005526112858206034, 0.030333416536450386, 0.0007788532529957592, -0.027280686423182487, -0.02234845794737339, -0.021213900297880173, -0.01680464670062065, -0.018558137118816376, -0.012092139571905136, -0.011800836771726608, -0.02581721730530262, 0.03200292959809303, -0.058457352221012115, -0.020746957510709763, 0.019205506891012192, 0.0524517297744751, -0.01700766570866108, 0.010544858872890472, -0.0020092299673706293, -0.023933613672852516, 0.020227378234267235, -0.02026059292256832, -0.0005700151668861508, -0.07140438258647919, -0.02562018483877182, -0.0018558712908998132, 0.04671557620167732, 0.0012943039182573557, -0.013012722134590149, -0.050759200006723404, 0.028243159875273705, -0.008392129093408585, 0.016087891533970833, 0.013976475223898888, -0.014103658497333527, 0.029002830386161804, -0.09603802859783173, 0.0627831220626831, 0.009897984564304352, 0.010985626839101315, -0.023626983165740967, 0.001613608212210238, -0.011846300214529037, 0.046384766697883606, 0.04560816287994385, 0.01319148950278759, 0.0010511125437915325, -0.0028650793246924877, 0.029639367014169693, 0.022053590044379234, -0.009416405111551285, 0.04166267067193985, -0.033384427428245544, -0.009543717838823795, -0.04920695349574089, -0.022748028859496117, 0.054856330156326294, 0.007698948960751295, 0.020318951457738876, 0.013266975060105324, 0.02299259416759014, 0.005412672180682421, -0.01255387905985117, 0.07490082085132599, 0.036710213869810104, -0.03347146883606911, 0.05909901112318039, 0.005955402739346027, 0.03315822407603264, -0.011613745242357254, -0.005579967517405748, -0.052707720547914505, 0.04823179543018341, -0.020092424005270004, -0.02490776963531971, 0.010731583461165428, 0.01270995382219553, 0.005413472186774015, -0.054307978600263596, 0.024098122492432594, 0.03300794959068298, -0.04301580786705017, -0.00559191545471549, 0.010577148757874966, 0.017010260373353958, 0.025196027010679245, 0.006151852197945118, 0.03104225918650627, 0.02450411766767502, -0.03727518767118454, -0.02021360956132412, 0.03803858160972595, -0.004692213609814644, -0.0379595048725605, 0.04473971575498581, 0.05288468673825264, -0.0012779769022017717, 0.009549503214657307, 0.03740626201033592, 0.03554754704236984, 0.009321997873485088, -0.015717072412371635, 0.018074244260787964, -0.028256239369511604, -0.01316886581480503, 0.006159900687634945, 0.023721259087324142, 0.05473092198371887, -0.011256223544478416, -0.00036039421684108675, -0.009466087445616722, -0.01519207563251257, -0.022459596395492554, -0.024784844368696213, 0.016417887061834335, 0.013768302276730537, 0.009271127171814442, 0.01441187597811222, -0.022839615121483803, 0.006041926797479391, -0.015753593295812607, -0.0284409262239933, 0.037342369556427, -0.02089078351855278, 0.019321464002132416, -0.024808689951896667, -0.014473269693553448, -0.05840202048420906, -0.008254775777459145, 0.03703819960355759, 0.05558314919471741, 0.017226770520210266, 0.0012635054299607873, -0.05927827209234238, 0.029924524948000908, 0.04385840892791748, -0.020501304417848587, -0.01865444891154766, -0.04081515595316887, 0.027009880170226097, -0.011444978415966034, -0.009657308459281921 ]
<p>I wrote a script to do some analysis and it was working fine until I tried to impliment a while loop to find the number clusters appropriate for k-means. For some reason it keeps saying that an argument is of length zero, but there shouldn't be any. I'm running this remotely, and it works fine locally.</p> <pre><code>freq_1 &lt;- NULL freq_alignment &lt;- NULL for (res in point_reference) { point &lt;- paste(as.character(res), "_output.txt", sep = "") point_file &lt;- file(point, "r") point2 &lt;- read.table(point_file) point2 &lt;- as.data.frame(point2) k &lt;- 2 check &lt;- 0.5 while (check &lt; 0.75) { k &lt;- k + 1 kcluster &lt;- kmeans(point2, k) check &lt;- kcluster$betweenss/(kcluster$tot.withins+kcluster$betweenss) } config &lt;- kcluster$cluster frames &lt;- length(config) freq &lt;- as.data.frame(table(conformations)) freq_1 &lt;- cbind(freq_1, freq))) freq_alignment &lt;- cbind(freq_alignment, kcluster$cluster) close(residue_file) } </code></pre> <p>point_reference is a list of numbers (2, 3, 4, etc.) corresponding to which file to load and the files themselves load fine. My goal is to find the k that corresponds to 75% of the total SS coming from between clusters. Only the loops is wrong...if I replace it with just clustering with k = 5, it works fine. The exact error is:</p> <p>Error in while (check &lt; 0.75) { : argument is of length zero</p> <p>Again, I'm doing this remotely on a cluster, and it works on my desktop R64. All files were produced on the cluster. I hope you guys can help! Thank in advance.</p>
36,989
[ -0.011036144569516182, 0.017155226320028305, -0.03637882322072983, 0.005175365135073662, 0.024676544591784477, -0.013690095394849777, -0.0018731357995420694, -0.02380153350532055, -0.005654700566083193, -0.00767883425578475, 0.04588768258690834, 0.04362250119447708, 0.031613536179065704, 0.046904306858778, -0.05236130952835083, -0.005178213585168123, -0.014192161150276661, -0.01601029559969902, -0.027997002005577087, 0.0017192865489050746, 0.008567165583372116, 0.0031944357324391603, 0.015375268645584583, -0.04840303957462311, 0.00907856784760952, 0.020501432940363884, -0.009386672638356686, -0.017247281968593597, 0.018242428079247475, 0.04521205648779869, -0.07611839473247528, -0.04160793870687485, 0.02271641418337822, 0.025385819375514984, 0.0024185667280107737, 0.009409181773662567, 0.004633328411728144, -0.029226845130324364, -0.06333456933498383, 0.01622462458908558, -0.0041788797825574875, 0.01924324966967106, -0.0013320399448275566, 0.043143074959516525, 0.020200766623020172, 0.008211115375161171, 0.0358438603579998, 0.03367859497666359, 0.05316489189863205, -0.0386640690267086, 0.09937600046396255, 0.001368235913105309, 0.00218672351911664, 0.05204923823475838, -0.029471734538674355, 0.0028542180079966784, 0.057115908712148666, 0.038502100855112076, -0.014091743156313896, -0.049999069422483444, -0.022266240790486336, -0.04404626414179802, -0.00008615943079348654, -0.010519240982830524, -0.03103988990187645, -0.016049429774284363, -0.003193858079612255, 0.014628924429416656, 0.06867798417806625, -0.027425263077020645, 0.030263224616646767, 0.015707198530435562, 0.05202699080109596, -0.037461910396814346, 0.01651841402053833, -0.01780201867222786, -0.029436957091093063, -0.05705854296684265, 0.02304569073021412, 0.05029108002781868, -0.017199300229549408, 0.0009797669481486082, -0.0012371743796393275, -0.0322042815387249, 0.04735700413584709, -0.01436256431043148, 0.04561685770750046, 0.010339513421058655, -0.020848210901021957, 0.039026256650686264, 0.01541090477257967, 0.017502281814813614, 0.06898156553506851, 0.03932385519146919, 0.014947224408388138, 0.061739251017570496, -0.005089317914098501, 0.048950765281915665, -0.032586708664894104, 0.027305273339152336, -0.0064467377960681915, -0.05026960000395775, 0.026316069066524506, 0.04931054264307022, -0.01974540203809738, -0.00905479583889246, -0.03908258676528931, -0.02417437732219696, -0.03233805298805237, -0.005153174977749586, 0.001853219815529883, 0.021509800106287003, 0.0045365095138549805, -0.015523667447268963, 0.003626488847658038, -0.03751905634999275, -0.029266655445098877, 0.005929756909608841, 0.03196690231561661, 0.057364024221897125, 0.07794991880655289, -0.0071603525429964066, -0.011307277716696262, -0.042056646198034286, -0.03055768646299839, 0.01147463172674179, 0.029022958129644394, -0.030209163203835487, -0.015478333458304405, 0.03485593944787979, 0.0005610798252746463, -0.00754647608846426, 0.03594193607568741, -0.0009803172433748841, 0.030039120465517044, -0.03146369755268097, -0.08595744520425797, -0.050700943917036057, 0.04125694930553436, 0.005411427468061447, 0.03223757818341255, -0.05991058051586151, 0.01613256148993969, -0.004463603254407644, 0.052581749856472015, 0.00685479212552309, 0.006746171973645687, 0.0034354454837739468, -0.014178670011460781, -0.012956961989402771, -0.019680937752127647, -0.00959766749292612, -0.07271143794059753, -0.009935225360095501, -0.012852818705141544, -0.016432659700512886, 0.024453813210129738, 0.014715534634888172, -0.0009248044225387275, 0.005638032220304012, 0.003937973640859127, -0.01642475463449955, 0.04904719814658165, -0.015623257495462894, 0.013362258672714233, -0.03911447897553444, 0.06147050857543945, 0.018457742407917976, -0.009086808189749718, 0.004485107492655516, -0.0729786828160286, 0.008973932825028896, 0.00967276282608509, 0.01651933789253235, 0.0355614610016346, 0.008006513118743896, 0.02064400725066662, -0.024583930149674416, 0.045678701251745224, 0.0001497227349318564, -0.005235814489424229, -0.026279162615537643, 0.04090000316500664, -0.02952013723552227, 0.03185383975505829, 0.027527930215001106, -0.03589080274105072, -0.02917383424937725, 0.007529941853135824, -0.050128839910030365, -0.01901416853070259, -0.04100215807557106, -0.006558367982506752, -0.047137849032878876, -0.06666657328605652, 0.023308034986257553, 0.005849961191415787, 0.015748770907521248, -0.018022794276475906, -0.04273494705557823, -0.0223242174834013, -0.016199998557567596, 0.026950152590870857, -0.017014089971780777, -0.009015978313982487, 0.05703604221343994, 0.030708901584148407, 0.023627687245607376, 0.031061166897416115, -0.0031406956259161234, -0.051401473581790924, -0.027423430234193802, -0.023013098165392876, -0.00019007446826435626, -0.004692448303103447, 0.010167133063077927, -0.015942219644784927, 0.04209798946976662, -0.010987085290253162, 0.015582469291985035, -0.08051849156618118, 0.03595956414937973, 0.04978201538324356, 0.008497234433889389, 0.007751607336103916, -0.009538319893181324, -0.033572062849998474, 0.08632159233093262, -0.032952092587947845, -0.008026059716939926, -0.0697503313422203, 0.00024473475059494376, 0.043110255151987076, 0.042497023940086365, -0.028202923014760017, -0.0005506059969775379, 0.04699834808707237, -0.02786356210708618, 0.018107663840055466, 0.010371311567723751, 0.02513439767062664, -0.002438466064631939, 0.02381550334393978, -0.027791624888777733, -0.008484755642712116, 0.001445831498131156, 0.05311835557222366, -0.018302666023373604, 0.0628756657242775, 0.013012793846428394, 0.0001803713821573183, 0.01365006621927023, 0.019033631309866905, 0.020723845809698105, 0.00954340398311615, 0.029457757249474525, 0.023072801530361176, 0.027166539803147316, -0.007654221728444099, 0.05229388177394867, 0.02776375599205494, 0.019737662747502327, 0.023346545174717903, -0.007034182548522949, -0.024227982386946678, 0.02260134369134903, -0.0276167169213295, -0.040892649441957474, 0.0027537711430341005, -0.012861042283475399, -0.0082888538017869, -0.023001210764050484, -0.04801518842577934, -0.026366082951426506, 0.02869744785130024, 0.0338200218975544, 0.03707524761557579, 0.012934576719999313, -0.03818334639072418, 0.009305686689913273, 0.0008018164080567658, -0.016226211562752724, 0.03208738937973976, 0.00029291713144630194, -0.009936344809830189, -0.014456541277468204, -0.0039124456234276295, 0.020202364772558212, 0.010850191116333008, -0.021666884422302246, -0.05222273990511894, 0.025440234690904617, -0.0009784322464838624, -0.058622099459171295, -0.0069062672555446625, -0.009027318097651005, -0.014379912056028843, -0.03147336095571518, -0.0015780135290697217, 0.013494626618921757, 0.02837579883635044, -0.040310729295015335, 0.023901451379060745, -0.04698428511619568, 0.006590718403458595, 0.0008642850443720818, -0.018414458259940147, 0.008069267496466637, -0.001346693141385913, 0.020561324432492256, 0.01749056950211525, -0.04094117134809494, 0.01159659493714571, -0.04114237800240517, -0.042974259704351425, -0.023508772253990173, -0.008431815542280674, 0.04589657858014107, -0.016587043181061745, -0.007224877364933491, 0.07496671378612518, 0.016054699197411537, -0.04463241994380951, -0.027370691299438477, -0.007492446340620518, -0.062306854873895645, -0.007713991682976484, 0.004643700085580349, -0.00721292058005929, 0.055255625396966934, -0.0158395953476429, 0.007379013579338789, 0.04896175116300583, 0.08528102934360504, -0.07298267632722855, -0.016362236812710762, 0.016632849350571632, -0.027893144637346268, 0.0005945961456745863, 0.030163023620843887, 0.03764474019408226, -0.008798089809715748, 0.011532986536622047, -0.0037883175536990166, -0.01143360324203968, -0.014450754970312119, -0.037340618669986725, -0.01435569953173399, 0.024799738079309464, 0.07491225004196167, -0.05226818844676018, 0.02941075898706913, 0.033643558621406555, -0.027355611324310303, -0.006110603921115398, 0.03554603457450867, 0.05906987190246582, -0.03201643377542496, 0.011235775426030159, 0.03190254420042038, 0.04138130694627762, -0.03889252245426178, 0.004957240074872971, -0.0009182627545669675, -0.02125604636967182, -0.02577793598175049, -0.015271427109837532, -0.03640918433666229, 0.0180364903062582, 0.03134722262620926, 0.04664139449596405, -0.007849270477890968, -0.0240445826202631, 0.014583670534193516, -0.036961037665605545, 0.007466339040547609, -0.06153387948870659, 0.02573966048657894, 0.014188749715685844, 0.04701557755470276, 0.022029897198081017, -0.020128637552261353, -0.03126244992017746, -0.013568510301411152, -0.04772615060210228, 0.013559257611632347, -0.005188728217035532, -0.014790533110499382, -0.008041010238230228, -0.022911163046956062, -0.0032235169783234596, -0.0021267514675855637, 0.020735053345561028, 0.021562479436397552, 0.012025097385048866, -0.041820261627435684, 0.015932077541947365, -0.02108830027282238, 0.0053876666352152824, -0.02700708992779255, 0.0036372023168951273, 0.04765525460243225, -0.0034577955957502127, 0.04857158288359642, 0.02334965206682682, -0.041360531002283096, 0.020960640162229538, 0.003690676996484399, -0.015930205583572388, 0.00036530036595650017, 0.030713465064764023, 0.02551102079451084, 0.02768808975815773, -0.018242929130792618, -0.009334027767181396, -0.024778246879577637, 0.052675168961286545, 0.06222973018884659, -0.009360196068882942, 0.002337855286896229, -0.023992346599698067, -0.02668742649257183, -0.02592058666050434, 0.02278820239007473, -0.009278327226638794, -0.011500961147248745, 0.02926909364759922, 0.015871312469244003, 0.0005646628560498357, 0.01964768022298813, 0.05854591727256775, 0.06277133524417877, -0.05206505209207535, -0.023626694455742836, -0.02974090725183487, 0.008999449200928211, 0.029975345358252525, 0.029727114364504814, 0.0008056112565100193, 0.0025000493042171, 0.007615182548761368, -0.004340894520282745, -0.04266556724905968, -0.016473624855279922, 0.045928407460451126, -0.027430113404989243, 0.02664141170680523, -0.018893565982580185, -0.019090523943305016, 0.008513109758496284, -0.0025599102955311537, 0.040788326412439346, 0.012716150842607021, -0.02305944822728634, -0.06727061420679092, 0.0036751534789800644, 0.06478437036275864, 0.037051063030958176, -0.010249301791191101, 0.007936622947454453, -0.04795234650373459, -0.0720600113272667, 0.02010360360145569, -0.026878179982304573, 0.03113078884780407, -0.03581566736102104, 0.00755226518958807, -0.012759550474584103, -0.0207721795886755, -0.0390082485973835, -0.029139265418052673, -0.04259863868355751, 0.030362678691744804, 0.0016399410087615252, -0.00877358764410019, -0.04186660051345825, -0.004642353858798742, 0.0036330162547528744, 0.012322897091507912, -0.03845188021659851, -0.01758434996008873, 0.04302500560879707, -0.02729968912899494, -0.0036592085380107164, -0.013585190288722515, 0.03676119074225426, -0.005159260705113411, 0.05081319436430931, 0.021887293085455894, 0.004472138825803995, 0.006592610850930214, 0.02922021970152855, 0.022069359198212624, -0.0356883630156517, -0.01649325154721737, -0.019448289647698402, 0.018403921276330948, 0.026986654847860336, 0.009168900549411774, 0.07116301357746124, 0.01551220566034317, -0.03628310188651085, 0.04912003502249718, -0.09452038258314133, 0.004849613644182682, -0.02486918307840824, 0.017528111115098, -0.027273058891296387, -0.040811214596033096, -0.015059322118759155, 0.00205587618984282, -0.026821136474609375, 0.042234379798173904, -0.02305951900780201, 0.006608651019632816, 0.0382004976272583, 0.04955330118536949, -0.017990561202168465, 0.016027117148041725, 0.016144979745149612, 0.035572350025177, -0.04345550015568733, -0.035474807024002075, 0.03340812399983406, -0.043744757771492004, -0.004806931130588055, 0.03244026377797127, -0.03661699965596199, -0.01983686164021492, 0.007216165773570538, 0.01654645800590515, 0.018331846222281456, -0.021084370091557503, -0.005597922019660473, -0.021838564425706863, 0.045744266360998154, -0.004677583929151297, 0.010783656500279903, -0.012102742679417133, -0.008044254034757614, -0.05903313308954239, -0.008148706518113613, 0.024887295439839363, 0.06673126667737961, 0.014786174520850182, 0.03361586481332779, -0.06744605302810669, -0.03607531264424324, -0.018973207101225853, -0.011792453937232494, -0.05941949412226677, -0.09044758230447769, -0.06045303866267204, 0.03709571436047554, 0.014230108819901943, -0.028280990198254585, 0.025156524032354355, -0.026738297194242477, -0.015952864661812782, -0.0032483430113643408, 0.017123879864811897, 0.08917178213596344, 0.009388831444084644, 0.020355386659502983, 0.03346141055226326, 0.01291592512279749, -0.042449042201042175, 0.018793217837810516, -0.010649250820279121, -0.018765868619084358, 0.00338757480494678, -0.009838352911174297, 0.006653753109276295, 0.03417867422103882, 0.00822505448013544, -0.002879328792914748, -0.014590715989470482, -0.010622890666127205, 0.02438819780945778, -0.05435039848089218, 0.022463979199528694, -0.018275486305356026, -0.004319510888308287, -0.07252853363752365, 0.00317489355802536, -0.02338491752743721, -0.004626958630979061, -0.02680082619190216, -0.022406674921512604, -0.015616669319570065, 0.04947420954704285, 0.09148597717285156, 0.017394177615642548, -0.011599560268223286, -0.004872351419180632, -0.03740893676877022, 0.02990793250501156, 0.020052626729011536, 0.0016655318904668093, -0.01848830282688141, 0.016430024057626724, -0.0014724776847288013, 0.0004024326626677066, -0.013150873593986034, -0.007402919232845306, 0.07142181694507599, 0.015902310609817505, -0.0044092112220823765, 0.017023924738168716, -0.00715389009565115, 0.005264410749077797, -0.05730624496936798, 0.006435859017074108, -0.014614391140639782, 0.05340046435594559, 0.06240644305944443, 0.015330762602388859, -0.017662467435002327, 0.012035497464239597, 0.024357998743653297, 0.003452519653365016, 0.03876177966594696, 0.021532757207751274, 0.018216321244835854, -0.009113713167607784, -0.0245345626026392, -0.06431782990694046, 0.022024869918823242, -0.0009711734019219875, 0.0506635382771492, -0.008255207911133766, -0.05740124732255936, -0.01678430289030075, 0.0388311930000782, -0.0013545480323955417, -0.028955232352018356, -0.015507285483181477, -0.028821319341659546, 0.032743554562330246, 0.015935061499476433, -0.048622965812683105, 0.041551899164915085, 0.0007422755006700754, 0.044696975499391556, 0.05072934553027153, 0.0029537351801991463, -0.054099228233098984, -0.02233246900141239, -0.03590402007102966, -0.02986527420580387, -0.06697261333465576, 0.0611582025885582, 0.006225972902029753, -0.03539327532052994, 0.023652512580156326, 0.014623841270804405, 0.060427844524383545, 0.014841113239526749, 0.017693962901830673, 0.014505685307085514, 0.0393964983522892, 0.008275811560451984, 0.017116941511631012, -0.05287168174982071, -0.0007126437849365175, 0.1623113602399826, 0.059395842254161835, 0.0043905675411224365, -0.05267694219946861, 0.00019715413509402424, 0.008892093785107136, 0.01904258504509926, -0.020826304331421852, 0.0175430066883564, -0.020659970119595528, -0.0019437490263953805, 0.05971032753586769, 0.05310188606381416, 0.03398696333169937, 0.049617547541856766, 0.028470193967223167, -0.031195392832159996, -0.03195149451494217, 0.0012113216798752546, -0.011325457133352757, -0.017560169100761414, -0.012688979506492615, -0.04482736438512802, 0.015847917646169662, 0.0009818810503929853, -0.015783246606588364, -0.033888597041368484, 0.01731126569211483, 0.022134779021143913, 0.005808494985103607, -0.017879927530884743, 0.01365498173981905, -0.00999959371984005, 0.007123721297830343, 0.011636176146566868, -0.021146586164832115, 0.0245550237596035, -0.04722851514816284, 0.018088722601532936, 0.031633149832487106, -0.006698270794004202, 0.011952051892876625, -0.007912088185548782, -0.022180164232850075, -0.016707317903637886, -0.009423124603927135, -0.03756999224424362, 0.044305164366960526, -0.02862575650215149, -0.004649334587156773, 0.011804284527897835, 0.01847059838473797, 0.006857798434793949, -0.04399460554122925, 0.019814593717455864, -0.0219108983874321, -0.015623318962752819, 0.00022486636589746922, -0.0022216886281967163, -0.05259867012500763, 0.05151483044028282, 0.012982265092432499, 0.026361433789134026, 0.03815509006381035, 0.00645162258297205, -0.013291224837303162, -0.044384222477674484, 0.062132466584444046, -0.04740070179104805, 0.035078223794698715, 0.01875252276659012, 0.001524220802821219, 0.004833659157156944, -0.00565792340785265, 0.007366583216935396, 0.007406848482787609, 0.029311761260032654, -0.031433604657649994, -0.012465632520616055, -0.02515021525323391, -0.025153813883662224, -0.019900323823094368, -0.027302725240588188, -0.06613734364509583, 0.0500512421131134, -0.013699192553758621, 0.03821545094251633, 0.04042920470237732, 0.0022273745853453875, 0.05324835330247879, -0.04736301675438881, 0.002442937344312668, 0.009833194315433502, -0.04469907283782959, -0.04028303548693657, -0.007081836927682161, -0.047983407974243164, 0.004008149262517691, -0.05242260545492172, 0.04779227077960968, 0.007733562029898167, 0.007339473348110914, 0.0027452476788312197, 0.042458418756723404, -0.01956993341445923, 0.02713237889111042, 0.019462458789348602, -0.013251922093331814, 0.03794806823134422, 0.0009644629317335784, 0.0022586812265217304, -0.05186716839671135, -0.036390163004398346, -0.04405088350176811, -0.055995069444179535, 0.02338084764778614, -0.04193907231092453, -0.06387727707624435, 0.03990562632679939, 0.00974134262651205, -0.015578923746943474, 0.008150365203619003, 0.026988500729203224, -0.0374344103038311, -0.015765272080898285, -0.023803506046533585, 0.018663492053747177, 0.008766461163759232, -0.0028564168605953455, -0.04172713682055473, 0.015624523162841797, 0.023076098412275314, -0.0024777038488537073, 0.03180577978491783, 0.007406402379274368, 0.024297624826431274, -0.003957932814955711, 0.03999835625290871, 0.0006223060190677643, -0.012138107791543007, 0.0025218084920197725, -0.05900803580880165, -0.07911685109138489, -0.009072113782167435, -0.0034869113005697727, -0.0005014967173337936, 0.00019453147251624614, -0.002848240314051509, -0.009676115587353706, 0.06390051543712616, -0.027333585545420647, -0.0002190127270296216, -0.017329741269350052, 0.03377888351678848, -0.0035667105112224817, 0.006244444288313389, -0.006150608882308006, 0.0051928129978477955, -0.0029876346234232187, -0.0017362263752147555, 0.019941547885537148, -0.021589571610093117, 0.003475781297311187, -0.004942234605550766, -0.003050540341064334, -0.02030516043305397, -0.007383267395198345, -0.01423970889300108, 0.01756317913532257, 0.013193539343774319, -0.034613363444805145, 0.027232719585299492, -0.009219929575920105, 0.052658483386039734, -0.09112904220819473, -0.019350748509168625, -0.010747574269771576, 0.01607932709157467, 0.026077814400196075, -0.02710074558854103, -0.013799132779240608, 0.027819065377116203, -0.05599171295762062, 0.006745693739503622, -0.011557326652109623, -0.000525791896507144, -0.04931216686964035, 0.0726403295993805, -0.024658067151904106, -0.030849596485495567, 0.03423813730478287, 0.006716956850141287, 0.03196169063448906, 0.040604833513498306, 0.023107264190912247, 0.012825015932321548, -0.0028144773095846176, -0.0031738507095724344, 0.019302960485219955, -0.019476372748613358, 0.046079810708761215, -0.028664443641901016, 0.023438414558768272, -0.0015216978499665856, -0.0237495768815279, 0.0019699125550687313, 0.017739346250891685, 0.04429347440600395, 0.019990120083093643, 0.08176638185977936, 0.00021036936959717423, 0.0012257647467777133, 0.021193040534853935, -0.03232746943831444, -0.012355927377939224, 0.020260421559214592, -0.034182701259851456, -0.024948734790086746, -0.00481420336291194, -0.025767356157302856, -0.014702297747135162, 0.029345856979489326, -0.03765692189335823, -0.016847072169184685, -0.01587323471903801, 0.02527545765042305, 0.005194326397031546, -0.05628158897161484, 0.025941476225852966, -0.024700529873371124, 0.02998400293290615, 0.05086179077625275, 0.03050132840871811, 0.000009479909749643411, 0.0047388141974806786, 0.010584065690636635, -0.042224857956171036, 0.014766248874366283, -0.007476673927158117, -0.03526449576020241, -0.019886106252670288, 0.006431670859456062, -0.03746093437075615, 0.018964312970638275, -0.021210284903645515, 0.003270787186920643, -0.004112523049116135, 0.044736478477716446, -0.014188040979206562, 0.03794373571872711, 0.0190744549036026, 0.010996748693287373, 0.0015402951976284385, -0.08297444880008698, 0.016947394236922264, -0.0024480046704411507, -0.008647628128528595, -0.0062940469942986965, -0.0033606498036533594, -0.022249119356274605, 0.056864216923713684, 0.006639481987804174, 0.040606994181871414, 0.01477524358779192, -0.0024405561853200197, -0.011565917171537876, 0.020168598741292953, -0.046651337295770645, 0.041377849876880646, 0.010080435313284397, -0.040822822600603104, 0.021975087001919746, -0.025211868807673454, 0.008646657690405846, 0.01520537119358778, -0.013801992870867252, 0.008689341135323048, -0.026922617107629776, 0.010530942119657993, -0.02629740908741951, 0.03324316069483757, 0.007634239736944437, 0.005845488980412483, 0.0351937934756279, 0.025362439453601837, -0.02271602861583233, 0.06008019670844078, -0.010563157498836517, -0.02418694645166397, 0.02764195203781128, -0.05557699874043465, -0.02243771031498909, 0.044968776404857635, 0.00013468343240674585, 0.016807716339826584, -0.05053551122546196, 0.03667842969298363, 0.017980432137846947, -0.031022245064377785, 0.005831100046634674, 0.017647847533226013, 0.00018474753596819937, 0.05840218812227249, 0.03821058198809624, 0.03364561125636101, -0.006634086836129427, -0.03727620467543602, 0.05866356939077377, 0.009452825412154198, 0.012797637842595577, -0.018615571781992912, -0.013374298810958862, 0.011971346102654934, -0.008016631938517094, 0.00266108731739223, -0.049637001007795334, 0.05461505427956581, -0.004877147730439901, -0.03427882120013237, -0.009822843596339226, -0.031792398542165756, -0.0015059716533869505, 0.04111688211560249, -0.00040142121724784374, 0.027449605986475945, -0.010401490144431591, 0.04023533686995506, -0.013609495013952255, -0.04439288377761841, 0.024283314123749733, 0.024538705125451088, -0.020271221175789833, 0.01567244902253151, 0.0007719782879576087, 0.032934319227933884, -0.006408473942428827, -0.010877339169383049, 0.021760636940598488, -0.025559330359101295, 0.02223229594528675, -0.019233275204896927, 0.03125857189297676, 0.02349177747964859, 0.005782146006822586, 0.02020283229649067, -0.01189532782882452, 0.019034801051020622, 0.026716509833931923, -0.027545293793082237, -0.05236555263400078, -0.009354028850793839, 0.034502774477005005, 0.05438285693526268, -0.0353272445499897, -0.021924544125795364, -0.00617788964882493, 0.02060200646519661, -0.024456961080431938, -0.014751987531781197 ]
<p>Let's say I have a set of scalar values $V$ that I sampled from a set $S$. I want to test whether a given value $X$ could be a member of $S$ or not.</p> <p>I understand that if the values in $V$ are distributed normally, then we can find the mean and standard deviation, after which you can determine the probability of occurrence for any particular value based on how many standard deviations your value differs from the mean.</p> <p>However, what happens if the values are not distributed normally? For example, what if you have 2 peaks in your data?</p> <p>Example: If you sample the ratio of pelvis width to femur length over a large number of adults, you will have 2 peaks, one for men and one for women. Now, my question is, given a particular ratio, how can we determine the probability that the subject was human? (i.e. probability that the ratio is part of our set $S$.)</p>
74,236
[ 0.00813413318246603, -0.04661765322089195, 0.015153761021792889, -0.02785029448568821, -0.007104388903826475, 0.030240610241889954, -0.027241235598921776, -0.032264795154333115, 0.016530117020010948, -0.03150981292128563, 0.031045658513903618, 0.007145648822188377, 0.03339787945151329, 0.0656125545501709, 0.005498768296092749, -0.009286307729780674, -0.03126705437898636, 0.016769539564847946, -0.025820666924118996, -0.04278602451086044, 0.01907828077673912, 0.018469134345650673, -0.0003607891558203846, -0.04455862194299698, -0.03427974879741669, 0.03273133188486099, 0.004486778751015663, -0.046437423676252365, 0.020477429032325745, 0.05353568494319916, -0.05277730152010918, -0.050893984735012054, 0.0015792149351909757, 0.024899709969758987, 0.0464034266769886, 0.009673726744949818, -0.029526347294449806, -0.01395068597048521, 0.015353236347436905, 0.04815087467432022, -0.06387373805046082, -0.022538118064403534, 0.02833930030465126, 0.022924920544028282, -0.02374723181128502, -0.008272562175989151, 0.012565373443067074, -0.0753902867436409, 0.020844968035817146, -0.061558760702610016, 0.06866016983985901, 0.010430233553051949, 0.0329756960272789, 0.005844543222337961, 0.007165787275880575, 0.014093633741140366, 0.02984093502163887, 0.0474197119474411, 0.009262703359127045, -0.05602072551846504, -0.01736011542379856, -0.035817909985780716, -0.022614996880292892, -0.012795395217835903, -0.02020011655986309, -0.00013026251690462232, -0.03360791504383087, -0.03844774141907692, 0.033548299223184586, -0.017974328249692917, 0.03148447722196579, 0.03967568650841713, 0.0076910448260605335, -0.010913511738181114, 0.005362850613892078, -0.015441047959029675, 0.02068505436182022, -0.007171794772148132, 0.04426446184515953, 0.011660805903375149, 0.024680450558662415, 0.0015335507923737168, 0.02954530157148838, 0.012104452587664127, 0.049145810306072235, -0.050419654697179794, 0.03421054035425186, -0.02369694784283638, 0.010762867517769337, 0.012689479626715183, -0.0008415716583840549, -0.0010558232897892594, 0.04329220578074455, -0.026081586256623268, -0.06721870601177216, 0.032083895057439804, -0.021507056429982185, 0.037415530532598495, -0.02194358967244625, -0.021491702646017075, -0.012905485928058624, -0.06440921127796173, 0.021003415808081627, 0.054382555186748505, -0.020151400938630104, 0.0014211813686415553, -0.013649538159370422, -0.018328571692109108, -0.019995350390672684, 0.0024133562110364437, -0.013723599724471569, 0.018436457961797714, 0.03303126245737076, 0.030147859826683998, 0.044441211968660355, 0.03814936429262161, -0.034344933927059174, -0.06677646189928055, 0.062175482511520386, 0.04402541369199753, 0.029415754601359367, 0.01645916886627674, 0.019789893180131912, -0.001130661810748279, -0.044391557574272156, 0.04162897542119026, 0.020515572279691696, 0.008479112759232521, -0.03773358464241028, 0.01453359890729189, -0.029218006879091263, 0.013545609079301357, 0.03647908195853233, 0.00007685532182222232, 0.034525856375694275, 0.012194974347949028, -0.08979832381010056, -0.05453271418809891, 0.0023705128114670515, 0.007550539914518595, -0.021875377744436264, -0.061682529747486115, 0.027127716690301895, 0.05382779985666275, 0.010586582124233246, 0.00652673002332449, 0.049493953585624695, -0.02269747108221054, 0.016422288492321968, 0.023593900725245476, -0.018250899389386177, -0.008061032742261887, -0.038207296282052994, -0.023210803046822548, -0.014556413516402245, -0.06464504450559616, 0.056974146515131, -0.018803512677550316, 0.0011713913409039378, -0.035205405205488205, -0.003964689560234547, 0.004270651843398809, -0.01722852699458599, 0.03560240566730499, 0.0030209829565137625, -0.003099593333899975, 0.05212603136897087, -0.0003347723395563662, 0.01524635124951601, 0.013522506691515446, 0.03310815989971161, 0.02401355281472206, 0.022483302280306816, 0.05896151810884476, 0.035489510744810104, -0.01984380930662155, -0.02572323940694332, 0.003899742616340518, 0.0005848786095157266, 0.01471724547445774, -0.0178106389939785, -0.009291422553360462, -0.0029543156269937754, 0.0294716265052557, 0.05983755365014076, -0.0013692483771592379, 0.0298452228307724, -0.05584839731454849, 0.056336410343647, -0.07039828598499298, -0.028994014486670494, -0.08196567744016647, -0.02042233943939209, -0.007930043153464794, -0.06675534695386887, 0.03785904496908188, 0.032136209309101105, 0.015035931020975113, -0.03777956962585449, -0.03918743133544922, -0.029514655470848083, 0.0036136573180556297, 0.056745514273643494, -0.07308392971754074, -0.007363583892583847, 0.04964505881071091, 0.02282392978668213, 0.0022071057464927435, 0.0461098738014698, -0.002812436781823635, -0.06239521875977516, 0.0002781753137242049, -0.039023660123348236, -0.010722432285547256, -0.0009669190039858222, 0.03412499651312828, 0.0037926086224615574, -0.0052688331343233585, -0.0071744960732758045, 0.05567434802651405, -0.049432240426540375, 0.05388303101062775, 0.061434127390384674, -0.02115093171596527, 0.013075331225991249, -0.03579331189393997, 0.01617816463112831, -0.023109516128897667, -0.03905918449163437, -0.03640339896082878, -0.0826222151517868, 0.0038106057327240705, -0.009165682829916477, 0.029712023213505745, -0.027104845270514488, 0.017350805923342705, 0.052820220589637756, 0.009094464592635632, 0.019623132422566414, 0.006670735776424408, 0.025046484544873238, -0.028838250786066055, 0.014260404743254185, -0.00197103014215827, 0.05226791277527809, 0.00426816800609231, -0.01568095199763775, 0.03056548349559307, 0.038895826786756516, -0.027180233970284462, 0.038351431488990784, 0.04285009577870369, -0.023076744750142097, -0.002539248438552022, 0.0021760661620646715, -0.020322242751717567, 0.033725984394550323, -0.015451828949153423, 0.009084086865186691, 0.06933417916297913, -0.001332277781330049, -0.051920220255851746, -0.015182344242930412, -0.0069882431998848915, 0.02443152666091919, 0.06044742837548256, -0.04586852714419365, -0.004082618281245232, 0.025820845738053322, -0.05917172133922577, -0.008908716030418873, -0.007480610627681017, -0.044465046375989914, -0.004326400812715292, -0.018986796960234642, 0.042851950973272324, -0.016418414190411568, 0.000932691153138876, -0.01201089657843113, -0.015223742462694645, 0.021463919430971146, -0.025592107325792313, -0.014391995035111904, 0.016423076391220093, -0.07585595548152924, -0.0059732901863753796, -0.02537795528769493, -0.021656369790434837, -0.02475891262292862, -0.0052963546477258205, 0.002803832059726119, 0.03210889920592308, 0.0008652620599605143, -0.03571038320660591, -0.0064873117953538895, -0.006748354062438011, 0.005688004661351442, -0.012388920411467552, 0.0006406269385479391, 0.05016982555389404, 0.008916595950722694, -0.03363022208213806, 0.026987355202436447, -0.037286944687366486, -0.015551133081316948, -0.04460430145263672, -0.00007130426092771813, 0.045469921082258224, -0.02272576466202736, -0.012491214089095592, 0.03172539174556732, 0.007447400595992804, 0.00968224462121725, -0.055107615888118744, -0.07223081588745117, -0.014551619067788124, 0.008422904647886753, 0.028944147750735283, 0.03010372258722782, -0.01678711548447609, 0.06421660631895065, 0.047392088919878006, -0.007066093850880861, -0.0009527169750072062, 0.04604731500148773, -0.015378167852759361, -0.023823397234082222, 0.03694702684879303, 0.016475388780236244, 0.01870708167552948, 0.02336736209690571, 0.005589575972408056, 0.04844646155834198, 0.055072154849767685, 0.01836995594203472, -0.019102808088064194, 0.020457809790968895, 0.0039797257632017136, 0.0035013933666050434, 0.048744652420282364, 0.012555242516100407, -0.01718873716890812, 0.021046476438641548, -0.027086274698376656, 0.02150074578821659, 0.03017354942858219, -0.039182595908641815, 0.02493603155016899, 0.008480454795062542, 0.013667766004800797, -0.022896384820342064, 0.042460959404706955, 0.026784082874655724, -0.026127707213163376, -0.004169971216470003, 0.03472883999347687, 0.01640894077718258, -0.028598381206393242, -0.009803212247788906, 0.057906121015548706, 0.04436614736914635, -0.026279635727405548, -0.031142283231019974, -0.02479630708694458, -0.004597625695168972, -0.009224673733115196, -0.016432195901870728, -0.05725239962339401, 0.05097140371799469, 0.06199603155255318, 0.022041024640202522, -0.021161746233701706, -0.01934410072863102, -0.029270287603139877, -0.020723287016153336, -0.05550862476229668, -0.006027329713106155, 0.012699037790298462, -0.005019604694098234, 0.05398555099964142, 0.047889091074466705, -0.0028699729591608047, -0.019279245287179947, -0.009128456935286522, -0.059401705861091614, 0.01566634699702263, -0.008191864937543869, -0.015019851736724377, 0.0009165254887193441, -0.055418118834495544, 0.024532170966267586, -0.03680558502674103, 0.0031293327920138836, 0.006239243783056736, 0.03903013467788696, -0.057901330292224884, 0.00939416978508234, 0.01844116859138012, -0.029183540493249893, -0.0018483875319361687, 0.05388215184211731, 0.00018607320089358836, -0.021847307682037354, -0.005172403063625097, 0.033077605068683624, 0.02561994083225727, 0.001823106431402266, 0.005709312856197357, 0.01623755507171154, -0.0016588270664215088, 0.0801725685596466, 0.027611196041107178, 0.012942379340529442, -0.07148087024688721, 0.014125814661383629, 0.004882211331278086, 0.10054412484169006, 0.04332129284739494, -0.008422303013503551, -0.018627852201461792, -0.020157651975750923, -0.02932984195649624, -0.00633895443752408, 0.012954188510775566, -0.02175767906010151, -0.024065304547548294, 0.05056831240653992, 0.03777110204100609, -0.055613670498132706, 0.02831191010773182, 0.05466008931398392, 0.017717156559228897, 0.0020194523967802525, -0.03523789346218109, -0.018813269212841988, -0.03538784012198448, -0.007130716927349567, 0.004283304326236248, 0.005693977698683739, -0.03374553099274635, 0.0310378335416317, 0.042233046144247055, 0.015931852161884308, -0.041426315903663635, -0.030309803783893585, -0.030270205810666084, 0.0408635176718235, -0.01272765826433897, -0.013220387510955334, 0.0034326945897191763, 0.0035567525774240494, 0.05717096105217934, -0.0014580998104065657, -0.002622162224724889, -0.07929651439189911, 0.01775192655622959, 0.05314251780509949, 0.027246298268437386, -0.050810959190130234, -0.009492387063801289, 0.012189868837594986, 0.015091395005583763, 0.06430389732122421, -0.03125173971056938, -0.015209781005978584, -0.011816363781690598, -0.011318947188556194, 0.006756325252354145, -0.03648427873849869, -0.04031608626246452, -0.0046525513753294945, 0.0021587840747088194, 0.00864037498831749, -0.026935767382383347, -0.03491766378283501, -0.033161718398332596, -0.009985239244997501, 0.01086401380598545, 0.06485872715711594, -0.010967206209897995, -0.0016667605377733707, -0.014319359324872494, 0.02830648049712181, 0.0017925177235156298, -0.07863649725914001, 0.015332992188632488, 0.007545491214841604, -0.00901663489639759, 0.013946904800832272, -0.009231878444552422, -0.05372188612818718, 0.023320619016885757, 0.023876413702964783, -0.018291741609573364, 0.039849549531936646, -0.006721013691276312, 0.04530806839466095, 0.035339273512363434, 0.0567721351981163, 0.0543014332652092, 0.022939670830965042, 0.0010365407215431333, -0.010787274688482285, -0.028616109862923622, 0.011761436238884926, -0.02652955800294876, -0.020836815237998962, -0.03657602518796921, -0.0010714482050389051, -0.0091489776968956, 0.027405153959989548, 0.00036624574568122625, 0.026080746203660965, -0.004459033254534006, -0.0008558125700801611, 0.00017779847257770598, 0.024406587705016136, 0.02472863718867302, 0.034926969558000565, -0.02577444724738598, 0.0379946231842041, 0.0028723767027258873, 0.0018908277852460742, 0.023020397871732712, -0.032991714775562286, -0.00996485073119402, 0.019374491646885872, -0.016617970541119576, -0.003921276889741421, -0.05587832257151604, -0.005604033824056387, 0.037389062345027924, -0.049189209938049316, 0.029230277985334396, 0.003731104079633951, 0.024078790098428726, -0.01354003045707941, -0.005480475258082151, -0.005094506777822971, 0.007601015269756317, 0.010569036938250065, 0.04295135289430618, -0.03235918655991554, 0.04531872645020485, -0.02890537865459919, 0.044415295124053955, -0.08137606084346771, -0.013559596613049507, -0.016444122418761253, 0.033649079501628876, -0.04541812464594841, -0.025027070194482803, 0.006251361686736345, -0.00012572920240927488, -0.019524840638041496, -0.011392135173082352, 0.07646910101175308, -0.01921331137418747, -0.013592551462352276, -0.025233549997210503, 0.04818907380104065, 0.09318602085113525, -0.013946748338639736, 0.0079495282843709, 0.02032889612019062, -0.0006321275723166764, 0.005843694321811199, -0.029003288596868515, 0.006997892167419195, -0.04146837070584297, -0.03177250176668167, -0.011409783735871315, -0.017283324152231216, 0.03733958303928375, 0.0076591274701058865, -0.05321367084980011, 0.011651490814983845, -0.018163442611694336, 0.01348885614424944, -0.0008723123464733362, 0.001162537606433034, -0.00331030017696321, 0.005152043886482716, -0.009962121024727821, 0.00477553578093648, -0.009226705878973007, 0.011410116218030453, 0.050740648061037064, 0.02663355879485607, -0.015124916099011898, 0.03748098760843277, 0.04164280369877815, -0.053688399493694305, 0.031427882611751556, -0.0012448591878637671, -0.014216911047697067, 0.03767881169915199, 0.021714968606829643, 0.01695309393107891, 0.0009910191874951124, 0.03862961754202843, -0.014085154049098492, 0.013483095914125443, -0.047268982976675034, -0.003781927516683936, 0.05228465422987938, 0.00830252468585968, 0.04793517664074898, 0.054573945701122284, 0.002483241492882371, 0.035763759166002274, -0.02750871516764164, -0.009369910694658756, -0.023788198828697205, -0.01749342493712902, 0.04019612818956375, -0.019621415063738823, 0.00933790858834982, 0.03200581669807434, 0.01472175121307373, 0.006001582834869623, 0.044135935604572296, 0.020982375368475914, 0.025313561782240868, 0.039087217301130295, 0.0050936429761350155, -0.018932867795228958, 0.036210622638463974, -0.036657288670539856, -0.015845386311411858, -0.01079824473708868, 0.005202933680266142, 0.03080231323838234, 0.04151402413845062, -0.012583923526108265, -0.06099613383412361, -0.025830259546637535, -0.04330888390541077, 0.025547493249177933, 0.0030607441440224648, -0.012771696783602238, 0.04025048390030861, 0.015973566100001335, 0.04413890466094017, -0.06185316666960716, 0.00044317712308838964, -0.016151942312717438, -0.0766710489988327, 0.01023279782384634, -0.0356556661427021, -0.03586513176560402, 0.040474701672792435, 0.006562743801623583, 0.005552867893129587, 0.01293381117284298, -0.04510572552680969, 0.03233793005347252, 0.014063606970012188, 0.04353182017803192, -0.0710081085562706, 0.058213360607624054, -0.007164299488067627, 0.008167620748281479, 0.00760076055303216, 0.007692774757742882, 0.09514635801315308, 0.0714869350194931, 0.007386145181953907, -0.028987742960453033, 0.010254554450511932, -0.00606897147372365, -0.014468653127551079, 0.00030849757604300976, -0.0010971918236464262, 0.033469151705503464, 0.016212673857808113, 0.03590461611747742, 0.02138333022594452, 0.014904655516147614, -0.015135527588427067, 0.0830477699637413, -0.012039944529533386, -0.00885072909295559, 0.009968928061425686, 0.0007235776865854859, -0.02954530529677868, 0.0032824163790792227, -0.017378846183419228, 0.022388281300663948, 0.011465763673186302, 0.02209334634244442, -0.03549737483263016, 0.002153749344870448, 0.01915845088660717, -0.009112875908613205, -0.05868881940841675, -0.010093571618199348, 0.03928611800074577, 0.008857335895299911, -0.004959591198712587, -0.030859287828207016, -0.009480619803071022, -0.032729316502809525, 0.015530183911323547, 0.012232198379933834, 0.0025220117531716824, -0.003922382369637489, -0.0006356357480399311, 0.02939610928297043, -0.043193962424993515, -0.0376708097755909, -0.07172979414463043, 0.044954992830753326, -0.004913842771202326, -0.04002945497632027, 0.01124675665050745, 0.018715545535087585, -0.007519048172980547, -0.03593410179018974, -0.008498874492943287, -0.027472443878650665, 0.02621440216898918, 0.0022477535530924797, -0.002849636832252145, -0.011572311632335186, 0.03459461033344269, -0.021493934094905853, 0.017360515892505646, 0.043610185384750366, -0.0361802913248539, -0.019299818202853203, 0.009456845931708813, 0.005871443077921867, 0.02063070423901081, 0.006017962470650673, -0.035966794937849045, -0.03221302106976509, -0.017028426751494408, -0.007781658787280321, 0.0027082436718046665, 0.0006042582099325955, 0.017807774245738983, 0.020681411027908325, -0.02619251050055027, -0.02572018839418888, -0.001001491560600698, 0.019982073456048965, -0.019188176840543747, 0.027001312002539635, -0.032938528805971146, 0.005051859654486179, 0.025244824588298798, 0.03418289124965668, 0.022322868928313255, -0.0218665674328804, -0.0007989273290149868, 0.057777535170316696, 0.0016383760375902057, -0.060641732066869736, -0.029001887887716293, -0.00827014073729515, -0.01919293962419033, 0.031196000054478645, -0.01112190168350935, 0.01369566936045885, 0.0022304898593574762, 0.06400763243436813, 0.017412949353456497, 0.024550549685955048, -0.004238436929881573, 0.0038852612487971783, 0.02817673049867153, -0.05162230134010315, 0.004703636281192303, 0.022806191816926003, 0.019803281873464584, -0.02195492386817932, -0.04698140174150467, 0.0035147902090102434, -0.049181606620550156, 0.04148228466510773, -0.02542233094573021, -0.024653099477291107, -0.03221183270215988, 0.013298935256898403, 0.00808737799525261, 0.02430497482419014, 0.005812713410705328, -0.009153064340353012, -0.010180111974477768, 0.018726089969277382, -0.005558568052947521, -0.004721512086689472, -0.01854250207543373, 0.005361224990338087, 0.004307297524064779, 0.008397991769015789, 0.014520554803311825, 0.03586367890238762, 0.02524344064295292, 0.014187526889145374, 0.01894056610763073, 0.012895810417830944, 0.012517891824245453, 0.013859043829143047, 0.04468056187033653, -0.051207613199949265, -0.014257523231208324, 0.04121405631303787, -0.022503891959786415, 0.02771040052175522, -0.015410921536386013, -0.012314220890402794, 0.018580492585897446, 0.04776127636432648, -0.035663947463035583, -0.002994994167238474, -0.04472241923213005, 0.04726281762123108, -0.01807968132197857, 0.027574462816119194, 0.009459066204726696, 0.04519592598080635, -0.013985328376293182, 0.0381757877767086, 0.02672080136835575, -0.04991922155022621, -0.004826975986361504, 0.007782271131873131, 0.012444717809557915, -0.0036075131502002478, -0.001262456877157092, 0.016580121591687202, 0.04679759964346886, 0.045989833772182465, -0.0010056492174044251, 0.029990151524543762, -0.04202801734209061, -0.008712748996913433, -0.08749814331531525, -0.03748174011707306, 0.01207459531724453, -0.028136512264609337, 0.002934429096058011, -0.0561857670545578, -0.04343308135867119, 0.010673053562641144, -0.045137107372283936, -0.009065638296306133, 0.0001917760819196701, -0.04484251141548157, -0.02845994383096695, 0.030384400859475136, -0.03529919683933258, 0.022468743845820427, 0.028021637350320816, -0.005529018118977547, 0.03866393864154816, 0.011381917633116245, -0.007126575335860252, -0.024707570672035217, 0.005829137749969959, -0.0010158284567296505, 0.01024013664573431, -0.08566244691610336, 0.023001637309789658, -0.019252941012382507, -0.027550585567951202, 0.002923328196629882, 0.019074076786637306, 0.009943461045622826, 0.04314948245882988, 0.0066357324831187725, -0.006538398563861847, 0.04252304881811142, 0.018709776923060417, 0.010821639560163021, -0.005457802210003138, 0.015984248369932175, -0.0034300205297768116, 0.03519444167613983, -0.03435923904180527, -0.03226066380739212, 0.04987642541527748, -0.03671532869338989, 0.003500145161524415, 0.018279096111655235, -0.010697796009480953, -0.03297474980354309, 0.00822640210390091, -0.011661946773529053, -0.0035488558933138847, -0.03627657890319824, 0.06273758411407471, -0.04430375248193741, 0.027855241671204567, 0.05668386444449425, 0.04979831352829933, 0.013105591759085655, 0.007494539488106966, -0.03766867518424988, -0.04877886176109314, 0.019920742139220238, 0.019475750625133514, -0.04237779974937439, -0.05724749714136124, -0.00036892518983222544, -0.046951357275247574, -0.0008894060738384724, -0.00275146565400064, 0.021465813741087914, -0.006649106275290251, 0.03992881253361702, 0.0008562951115891337, 0.05070372670888901, 0.015697486698627472, -0.014043760485947132, -0.030193477869033813, -0.08867517113685608, 0.0556834377348423, 0.02663041278719902, -0.032475121319293976, -0.058417897671461105, 0.015034424141049385, -0.04525521770119667, 0.002793866442516446, 0.023903576657176018, 0.034132834523916245, 0.04526578634977341, -0.0009636569302529097, 0.02704228274524212, -0.010635481216013432, -0.05263887718319893, 0.0211270023137331, -0.022361526265740395, -0.04706563055515289, -0.018528373911976814, 0.014414445497095585, 0.018727727234363556, -0.009034777991473675, -0.0013080056523904204, -0.0038824512157589197, -0.008918756619095802, 0.029606172814965248, 0.0203887689858675, 0.04238342493772507, 0.018385635688900948, -0.0025464545469731092, 0.030003683641552925, -0.013915715739130974, -0.006695468444377184, -0.013205460272729397, -0.014220200479030609, -0.03869142383337021, 0.04655449837446213, -0.035583894699811935, -0.040996942669153214, 0.009835487231612206, 0.03121805377304554, -0.029847167432308197, -0.02599668875336647, -0.005475686863064766, 0.02777424268424511, -0.029145024716854095, -0.007338104769587517, 0.016919929534196854, -0.003220384242013097, 0.012798198498785496, -0.022831466048955917, 0.00876007229089737, 0.00540392380207777, -0.04338331148028374, 0.02054486982524395, -0.009500051848590374, -0.0005272331763990223, -0.014906736090779305, -0.021314889192581177, 0.048728980123996735, -0.007891434244811535, 0.03126508742570877, 0.013848279602825642, 0.022993609309196472, -0.016628175973892212, -0.0016563674435019493, 0.011116662994027138, -0.011597097851336002, 0.03638086095452309, 0.002706033643335104, -0.02386530488729477, 0.08612682670354843, -0.008734134025871754, -0.026425592601299286, -0.05097387731075287, -0.03180256485939026, -0.009097792208194733, 0.0019900475163012743, 0.033540330827236176, 0.011593163013458252, -0.007042680401355028, 0.00712633179500699, 0.007519457023590803, -0.0018408173928037286, 0.07493103295564651, -0.02318716235458851, 0.051975466310977936, -0.00714222714304924, -0.011943371035158634, 0.004441188648343086, 0.00020999884873162955, -0.025139372795820236, -0.01744500920176506, 0.034378841519355774, 0.012035319581627846, 0.025682466104626656, -0.005511532537639141, -0.02736937440931797, -0.012775455601513386, 0.0043999264016747475, -0.051000937819480896, -0.07527391612529755, -0.045867763459682465, 0.03124232031404972, -0.004509985912591219, -0.07202335447072983 ]